id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15501v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15501v1
|
Killkan: The Automatic Speech Recognition Dataset for Kichwa with Morphosyntactic Information
| 2024-04-23T20:26:07 | 2024-04-23T20:26:07 |
Chihiro Taguchi, Jefferson Saransig, Dayana Velásquez, David Chiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper presents Killkan, the first dataset for automatic speech
recognition (ASR) in the Kichwa language, an indigenous language of Ecuador.
Kichwa is an extremely low-resource endangered language, and there have been no
resources before Killkan for Kichwa to be incorporated in applications of
natural language processing. The dataset contains approximately 4 hours of
audio with transcription, translation into Spanish, and morphosyntactic
annotation in the format of Universal Dependencies. The audio data was
retrieved from a publicly available radio program in Kichwa. This paper also
provides corpus-linguistic analyses of the dataset with a special focus on the
agglutinative morphology of Kichwa and frequent code-switching with Spanish.
The experiments show that the dataset makes it possible to develop the first
ASR system for Kichwa with reliable quality despite its small dataset size.
This dataset, the ASR model, and the code used to develop them will be publicly
available. Thus, our study positively showcases resource building and its
applications for low-resource languages and their community.
|
[
-0.027451416477560997,
-0.4223755896091461,
0.02896520309150219,
0.24000781774520874,
-0.26404786109924316,
0.16485899686813354,
-0.35173097252845764,
-0.624264657497406,
0.39851272106170654,
0.7195689082145691,
-0.21949529647827148,
-0.4578375220298767,
-0.8917210698127747,
0.19807225465774536,
-0.4786044955253601,
0.5809356570243835,
-0.014179944060742855,
-0.07105947285890579,
0.7639869451522827,
-0.7177312970161438,
-0.024822019040584564,
-0.3548509478569031,
-0.7406855225563049,
0.029347432777285576,
0.4501820504665375,
0.5534476041793823,
0.7041948437690735,
0.9103533625602722,
0.3101177513599396,
0.28828686475753784,
-0.2846154272556305,
-0.09640955179929733,
-0.3316892683506012,
0.2594354748725891,
0.2002290040254593,
-0.23875407874584198,
0.11457209289073944,
-0.3544633388519287,
0.7307634949684143,
0.7642566561698914,
-0.30700382590293884,
0.18917928636074066,
-0.204985111951828,
0.5688608288764954,
-0.6673297882080078,
0.44956570863723755,
-0.6197211742401123,
0.09881118685007095,
-0.6530022025108337,
0.01459670439362526,
0.03466498479247093,
-0.2905367314815521,
0.1418946385383606,
-0.4881654977798462,
0.08888412266969681,
-0.18296337127685547,
0.3645017743110657,
0.5813005566596985,
-0.22018015384674072,
-0.8426929712295532,
-0.7264760136604309,
0.6679298877716064,
-0.652606189250946,
0.29242637753486633,
0.8548622727394104,
0.5991910099983215,
-0.1981739103794098,
-0.24247725307941437,
-0.5265277624130249,
-0.29215624928474426,
0.013955757953226566,
-0.01638517528772354,
-0.21804001927375793,
0.168396458029747,
0.1381150335073471,
0.6465831398963928,
-0.5258954167366028,
0.2278517484664917,
-1.0973142385482788,
-0.46596285700798035,
0.6263423562049866,
0.0760999321937561,
0.37458518147468567,
-0.3448426127433777,
0.34333547949790955,
-0.06667126715183258,
-0.7045802474021912,
-0.012652644887566566,
0.7584059238433838,
0.8334234356880188,
-0.33015602827072144,
0.6456024646759033,
-0.455304890871048,
0.7518646717071533,
-0.4382404088973999,
-0.04612160101532936,
0.34733566641807556,
0.12288609892129898,
-0.21561667323112488,
0.6582320332527161,
1.2085381746292114,
-0.19632188975811005,
0.14667965471744537,
0.008248095400631428,
-0.04238968342542648,
0.3504117429256439,
0.005658688955008984,
-0.4965253472328186,
-0.3301139175891876,
0.062331534922122955,
-0.6444076299667358,
-0.5790278911590576,
-0.43745535612106323,
-0.5803354382514954,
-0.2434682995080948,
-0.15159763395786285,
0.24850741028785706,
-0.286447137594223,
-0.3548019826412201,
-0.2185492068529129,
0.2730379104614258,
-0.10566072165966034,
0.15110108256340027,
-0.998867928981781,
0.4456602931022644,
0.07927249372005463,
1.029032588005066,
-0.01935691572725773,
-0.19038806855678558,
-0.40295174717903137,
0.07564382255077362,
-0.3041277527809143,
0.4021792709827423,
-0.5352671146392822,
-0.6125036478042603,
-0.11721412092447281,
0.3953891694545746,
0.2516602575778961,
-0.6728052496910095,
0.4195181727409363,
-0.25103476643562317,
0.047075580805540085,
-0.12752202153205872,
0.11860700696706772,
-0.1666778177022934,
-0.09674208611249924,
-0.9337595105171204,
0.8747677803039551,
0.20256496965885162,
-0.4620142877101898,
0.14517968893051147,
-0.7646182775497437,
-0.567712664604187,
0.26075899600982666,
-0.42071855068206787,
-0.10270769149065018,
-0.25042498111724854,
-0.1899154931306839,
0.09153294563293457,
-0.2038547396659851,
-0.04818399250507355,
0.1314832866191864,
-0.1422177106142044,
-0.0816461369395256,
-0.40410155057907104,
0.9410337209701538,
0.5766990184783936,
-0.2776777744293213,
-0.24938635528087616,
-1.1233363151550293,
-0.009694828651845455,
0.0824136808514595,
-0.8044352531433105,
-0.3164064288139343,
0.10565976798534393,
0.44307687878608704,
0.04991870000958443,
0.06493037939071655,
-0.838363528251648,
-0.10868164151906967,
-0.3797321021556854,
0.6652418375015259,
0.36694252490997314,
-0.34603509306907654,
0.1134909838438034,
-0.08786273747682571,
0.5777836441993713,
-0.17693708837032318,
-0.014479483477771282,
-0.14201202988624573,
-0.39787477254867554,
-0.48880481719970703,
-0.264186829328537,
0.34974193572998047,
0.4613254964351654,
-0.41897571086883545,
0.2243015617132187,
0.024929193779826164,
-0.5037949085235596,
-0.7268961071968079,
0.0016838610172271729,
0.4882965087890625,
0.5319507122039795,
0.16454538702964783,
-0.32136520743370056,
-1.0312117338180542,
-0.869257390499115,
0.4272466003894806,
-0.389163613319397,
-0.15814390778541565,
0.20930540561676025,
0.12095604091882706,
-0.2641371786594391,
0.7119532227516174,
-0.2173341065645218,
-0.3764209747314453,
-0.05443843454122543,
0.2540068030357361,
0.3256130814552307,
0.39841166138648987,
0.41490960121154785,
-0.5999220609664917,
-0.5000470876693726,
0.2051924169063568,
-0.4606066644191742,
-0.2923925220966339,
0.5560672879219055,
0.04055926948785782,
0.25343450903892517,
0.27376729249954224,
-0.170924574136734,
0.2906021475791931,
0.7498478889465332,
-0.06477659940719604,
0.5566727519035339,
-0.24338914453983307,
0.24480262398719788,
-0.9169958233833313,
0.6452751159667969,
-0.4771469235420227,
-0.2141251116991043,
-0.5566105842590332,
-0.3864628076553345,
-0.23292818665504456,
-0.425953209400177,
-0.3540356457233429,
0.5259547829627991,
-0.24014995992183685,
-0.17245881259441376,
-0.34756359457969666,
-0.2756410539150238,
-0.6126071810722351,
0.34739136695861816,
0.31047123670578003,
0.8538200855255127,
0.3524538278579712,
-0.6308754682540894,
0.5164527893066406,
0.5226902365684509,
-0.5973977446556091,
0.21549458801746368,
-0.7572289109230042,
0.08850989490747452,
-0.17901690304279327,
-0.10961075127124786,
-0.5829146504402161,
-0.4665645658969879,
0.5851224660873413,
-0.4892759323120117,
-0.04545912519097328,
-0.4839211702346802,
-0.36811140179634094,
-0.12496611475944519,
-0.03796947002410889,
0.415388822555542,
0.4658728241920471,
-0.3514886498451233,
0.0447220541536808,
1.0691099166870117,
-0.5333402156829834,
-0.6985794305801392,
-0.8132875561714172,
0.1395532488822937,
-0.17328673601150513,
-0.18268391489982605,
0.24521943926811218,
0.03116803616285324,
-0.18011610209941864,
-0.08441779762506485,
-0.001072525978088379,
-0.32727086544036865,
-0.16852836310863495,
0.34197959303855896,
0.035560574382543564,
-0.2643771767616272,
0.0029530159663408995,
0.005689716432243586,
-0.1869579404592514,
-0.2187040001153946,
-0.20066988468170166,
0.5998216271400452,
0.09759198129177094,
0.0475563146173954,
-0.21376626193523407,
0.2947290241718292,
0.8600781559944153,
0.11553463339805603,
0.5237022042274475,
0.09308536350727081,
-0.6477460265159607,
0.09993419051170349,
-0.3685378134250641,
0.5329391360282898,
-0.42309772968292236,
0.2645687162876129,
-0.1367812305688858,
-0.5834714770317078,
1.0091066360473633,
0.360931396484375,
-0.04064418748021126,
0.4370043873786926,
0.5512623190879822,
0.045960020273923874,
0.753277063369751,
0.5023002028465271,
-0.4371831715106964,
0.6108531355857849,
-0.232566237449646,
-0.05878413841128349,
-0.7306869029998779,
-0.36940115690231323,
-0.8447994589805603,
-0.28921443223953247,
-0.5391655564308167,
-0.05374932289123535,
0.2537296414375305,
-0.32620781660079956,
-0.2044762223958969,
0.6593500375747681,
-0.5311741232872009,
0.48641133308410645,
0.36433905363082886,
0.06023271009325981,
0.30838605761528015,
0.014402871951460838,
-0.004769816063344479,
-0.05285491421818733,
-0.4539492428302765,
-0.55794757604599,
1.0041508674621582,
0.032429859042167664,
0.9159048199653625,
0.14437952637672424,
0.28764235973358154,
0.8101311922073364,
-0.31872281432151794,
-0.8799570798873901,
0.2604318857192993,
-0.4895879924297333,
-0.3519231975078583,
-0.6677592396736145,
-0.5607941746711731,
-1.205456018447876,
0.0181506909430027,
0.3656364381313324,
-0.6648150682449341,
0.20910818874835968,
0.11154647171497345,
-0.41702568531036377,
0.022308703511953354,
-0.4970240890979767,
0.6561592221260071,
-0.20115524530410767,
0.290887713432312,
-0.19481602311134338,
-0.854773223400116,
-0.08768866956233978,
0.015055631287395954,
0.22220580279827118,
-0.3205503523349762,
0.1094161793589592,
1.2234896421432495,
-0.768426775932312,
0.6451294422149658,
-0.19209863245487213,
-0.13736554980278015,
0.3828979730606079,
0.16309253871440887,
0.2628650963306427,
-0.2230200469493866,
-0.29123714566230774,
0.23286448419094086,
0.23909622430801392,
-0.28506672382354736,
-0.23527589440345764,
0.5365437269210815,
-0.866975724697113,
0.21217112243175507,
-0.19303534924983978,
-0.3158685266971588,
0.028054535388946533,
0.3095288872718811,
0.2860109508037567,
0.6737220883369446,
-0.26839926838874817,
0.1629747599363327,
0.4372173845767975,
-0.12411455065011978,
0.26100972294807434,
0.750288724899292,
-0.00643001077696681,
-0.5976342558860779,
0.9885939955711365,
0.6330328583717346,
0.17182384431362152,
0.07459620386362076,
0.3589942157268524,
-0.2518761157989502,
-0.4900059103965759,
-0.6695727705955505,
-0.021180998533964157,
-0.6632978320121765,
-0.19697913527488708,
-0.739054262638092,
-0.3913337290287018,
-0.28065016865730286,
-0.0751255676150322,
-0.4675945043563843,
-0.6970959305763245,
-0.025708382949233055,
0.10217767208814621,
0.44176092743873596,
0.7895500659942627,
-0.25257059931755066,
0.5130360126495361,
-0.6204235553741455,
0.4328130781650543,
0.07787393033504486,
0.3196708559989929,
-0.08282200247049332,
-0.2875773310661316,
-0.22501464188098907,
0.21894003450870514,
0.15035445988178253,
-0.8114725947380066,
0.4249573349952698,
0.3047844469547272,
0.5911426544189453,
0.381440669298172,
0.07115557044744492,
0.24840684235095978,
-0.14366041123867035,
0.40530645847320557,
0.10693087428808212,
-0.7277957201004028,
1.0285084247589111,
-0.6557873487472534,
0.529590368270874,
0.7853897213935852,
0.24070486426353455,
-1.15219247341156,
-0.4528564214706421,
-0.5017448663711548,
-0.7990700602531433,
1.12821364402771,
0.2375149130821228,
0.06351424753665924,
0.06261491030454636,
-0.17857006192207336,
0.6039271950721741,
0.4765090346336365,
-0.289690762758255,
-0.05826950445771217,
-0.1690707802772522,
-0.7197563648223877,
0.17230013012886047,
-0.1157754436135292,
0.09045860171318054,
-0.01061652135103941,
0.6160096526145935,
-0.10755787044763565,
0.23050472140312195,
-0.07728657126426697,
-0.5042294859886169,
-0.3188045620918274,
0.04095129296183586,
0.4337063729763031,
0.3382367491722107,
-0.1226099357008934,
0.22292518615722656,
0.21368396282196045,
-1.0725665092468262,
0.20661073923110962,
0.07718069106340408,
-0.3335094451904297,
0.2355145364999771,
0.1816612184047699,
0.7303165793418884,
0.43429407477378845,
-0.9585841298103333,
0.08839975297451019,
0.08718966692686081,
0.14848050475120544,
-0.4355792999267578,
0.13239948451519012,
-0.35390496253967285,
-0.06440403312444687,
0.49306219816207886,
-0.06784708797931671,
0.21627746522426605,
-0.5942711234092712,
-0.23110246658325195,
0.0590117946267128,
-0.23130342364311218,
-0.2734307050704956,
0.4895937740802765,
0.22715158760547638,
-0.45383816957473755,
0.667239785194397,
0.0506671667098999,
-0.6543377041816711,
0.8796027898788452,
0.26579806208610535,
0.5386365652084351,
-0.5873559713363647,
0.27950358390808105,
0.5829989910125732,
0.20645064115524292,
-0.10735469311475754,
0.2853497564792633,
-0.6552688479423523,
-0.47972923517227173,
-0.014224917627871037,
-0.7524039149284363,
-0.6746981739997864,
0.45271798968315125,
-0.49509212374687195,
0.5909099578857422,
-0.49586281180381775,
0.24182064831256866,
0.0591370053589344,
0.09334751963615417,
-0.3190625309944153,
0.21477244794368744,
0.22201301157474518,
0.6045132279396057,
-0.8410910367965698,
0.6385253667831421,
0.43838581442832947,
-0.32469671964645386,
-0.3533881604671478,
-0.35935941338539124,
0.06424009799957275,
-1.0450643301010132,
0.6132693886756897,
0.1243843287229538,
-0.4606231153011322,
0.00008216500282287598,
-0.4476684629917145,
-1.0435023307800293,
0.7558332085609436,
0.547456681728363,
-0.37028154730796814,
0.09367652982473373,
0.32639482617378235,
0.48893463611602783,
-0.17374643683433533,
0.25045254826545715,
0.6333895921707153,
0.23645754158496857,
0.36380404233932495,
-1.2619911432266235,
-0.14262324571609497,
-0.537474513053894,
-0.07429065555334091,
0.2970052659511566,
-0.6258233785629272,
0.3261030614376068,
-0.037022873759269714,
-0.41285789012908936,
0.119145467877388,
0.2805327773094177,
0.003155909711495042,
0.01159355603158474,
0.4140018820762634,
0.304910808801651,
0.8208231925964355,
0.1733885109424591,
0.40705791115760803,
-0.07481840997934341,
0.11252009123563766,
1.0424138307571411,
-0.161942258477211,
0.7513718008995056,
0.13523177802562714,
-0.47452977299690247,
0.049707382917404175,
0.5952492952346802,
0.06295877695083618,
0.906931459903717,
0.16413873434066772,
-0.5217142701148987,
0.35081562399864197,
-0.34900155663490295,
-0.4978257417678833,
0.8430579304695129,
0.5693206191062927,
-0.40304332971572876,
-0.2732526361942291,
0.278768390417099,
0.13697032630443573,
-0.3218100666999817,
-0.297210156917572,
0.6502741575241089,
-0.10949128866195679,
-0.14464488625526428,
0.5697235465049744,
-0.07869322597980499,
0.8562983870506287,
-0.8937210440635681,
0.06979232281446457,
0.016560671851038933,
-0.10136454552412033,
-0.2792430520057678,
-0.602392315864563,
0.8029881119728088,
0.23433682322502136,
-0.2692338824272156,
0.018779894337058067,
0.6981757879257202,
-0.5084531903266907,
-0.47840616106987,
0.17472504079341888,
-0.05022044479846954,
0.5876287817955017,
0.21540001034736633,
-0.2567291557788849,
0.3656819462776184,
-0.26088932156562805,
0.14902764558792114,
0.09942349046468735,
0.02338632196187973,
-0.14670564234256744,
0.6289582848548889,
0.6586078405380249,
0.5332315564155579,
0.2785947918891907,
0.056033745408058167,
0.5971253514289856,
-0.4831620752811432,
-0.8451763987541199,
-0.539003312587738,
0.1634213626384735,
0.050323862582445145,
-0.27000483870506287,
0.27743083238601685,
0.6200569272041321,
0.8508808016777039,
0.11085788160562515,
1.1522506475448608,
-0.6494086980819702,
0.6089667677879333,
-0.38838934898376465,
1.2425801753997803,
-0.11520370095968246,
-0.18817108869552612,
-0.11026989668607712,
-0.6129843592643738,
-0.15735752880573273,
0.8413087129592896,
-0.24156808853149414,
-0.2523210942745209,
0.2421851009130478,
0.8318290114402771,
-0.20239569246768951,
0.15120011568069458,
0.38158944249153137,
0.24918508529663086,
0.04272981733083725,
0.3121267259120941,
0.6615707278251648,
-0.5207690000534058,
0.70939040184021,
-0.37005850672721863,
-0.15556415915489197,
-0.2512989938259125,
-0.4161475896835327,
-0.28974059224128723,
-0.889229416847229,
-0.3513632118701935,
-0.25888001918792725,
0.23051616549491882,
1.0350455045700073,
0.6703065633773804,
-1.1466188430786133,
-0.4462430775165558,
-0.11398007720708847,
-0.09748576581478119,
0.13043920695781708,
-0.15203054249286652,
0.28419554233551025,
0.11368994414806366,
-0.5645108222961426,
0.6314600110054016,
0.284068763256073,
0.15028351545333862,
-0.21102334558963776,
-0.38589057326316833,
0.1277337372303009,
-0.4016548991203308,
0.31808027625083923,
1.0657001733779907,
-0.44882258772850037,
-0.12959936261177063,
-0.2797700762748718,
-0.1808154284954071,
0.1802925020456314,
0.7154974341392517,
-0.8446731567382812,
0.6483484506607056,
0.49656158685684204,
0.38797318935394287,
0.3882727026939392,
-0.4103514850139618,
0.6145294308662415,
-0.49917498230934143,
0.5897675156593323,
0.3399238586425781,
0.2765807509422302,
0.381935179233551,
-0.35415396094322205,
0.6056991815567017,
0.0667925626039505,
-0.3798336088657379,
-0.9284278154373169,
0.06858888268470764,
-0.7625832557678223,
0.46815600991249084,
0.8179051876068115,
-0.04040009155869484,
-0.20256009697914124,
-0.5027415156364441,
-0.49170297384262085,
0.5256773829460144,
-0.3696397840976715,
0.9147170782089233,
0.6720990538597107,
0.08096707612276077,
-0.25473135709762573,
-0.6061661243438721,
0.3865843713283539,
-0.05232355743646622,
-0.7252354621887207,
0.1850590705871582,
0.39434951543807983,
0.2810758650302887,
0.10333160310983658,
1.0447367429733276,
-0.35892540216445923,
0.37817275524139404,
0.18483813107013702,
-0.10328707844018936,
-0.1650058925151825,
-0.22965587675571442,
-0.4047612249851227,
-0.13316191732883453,
-0.011866660788655281,
-0.5791864991188049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15500v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15500v1
|
GeoLLM-Engine: A Realistic Environment for Building Geospatial Copilots
| 2024-04-23T20:23:37 | 2024-04-23T20:23:37 |
Simranjit Singh, Michael Fore, Dimitrios Stamoulis
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Geospatial Copilots unlock unprecedented potential for performing Earth
Observation (EO) applications through natural language instructions. However,
existing agents rely on overly simplified single tasks and template-based
prompts, creating a disconnect with real-world scenarios. In this work, we
present GeoLLM-Engine, an environment for tool-augmented agents with intricate
tasks routinely executed by analysts on remote sensing platforms. We enrich our
environment with geospatial API tools, dynamic maps/UIs, and external
multimodal knowledge bases to properly gauge an agent's proficiency in
interpreting realistic high-level natural language commands and its functional
correctness in task completions. By alleviating overheads typically associated
with human-in-the-loop benchmark curation, we harness our massively parallel
engine across 100 GPT-4-Turbo nodes, scaling to over half a million diverse
multi-tool tasks and across 1.1 million satellite images. By moving beyond
traditional single-task image-caption paradigms, we investigate
state-of-the-art agents and prompting techniques against long-horizon prompts.
|
[
-0.5802502632141113,
-0.7041729092597961,
0.8936347365379333,
-0.06927592307329178,
-0.2572614252567291,
0.33426252007484436,
-0.5726468563079834,
-0.36043083667755127,
-0.09979067742824554,
0.2534843981266022,
-0.955150306224823,
-0.5914484858512878,
-0.3094598352909088,
-0.08474292606115341,
-0.1569092869758606,
1.0413180589675903,
0.030936283990740776,
-0.45221376419067383,
-0.4665636718273163,
0.1800256073474884,
-0.29876455664634705,
-0.5643344521522522,
-0.45253995060920715,
-0.1668843775987625,
0.7247102856636047,
0.35594770312309265,
1.1078459024429321,
0.39829427003860474,
0.18964256346225739,
0.29981327056884766,
0.19347809255123138,
0.6368922591209412,
-0.5740001797676086,
0.17581970989704132,
-0.3226974308490753,
-0.22229664027690887,
-0.18581531941890717,
0.2320074737071991,
0.46079540252685547,
0.2933140695095062,
0.044377196580171585,
0.11589287221431732,
0.18443536758422852,
0.29243090748786926,
-0.5708374381065369,
0.4773085117340088,
-0.4925677180290222,
-0.03492084518074989,
0.11367097496986389,
-0.25642129778862,
-0.17390908300876617,
0.12364856153726578,
0.02900277078151703,
-1.3515946865081787,
0.2476004660129547,
0.4129756987094879,
0.9942527413368225,
0.5961362719535828,
-0.12353308498859406,
-0.2428164780139923,
-0.6263541579246521,
0.8418473601341248,
-0.17191989719867706,
0.14180301129817963,
0.3362351357936859,
0.6808872818946838,
-0.2714228332042694,
-0.5788160562515259,
-0.38091781735420227,
-0.19564875960350037,
-0.24802431464195251,
0.25426825881004333,
0.2700212299823761,
-0.01379394344985485,
0.3357783854007721,
-0.12401596456766129,
-0.7402445077896118,
0.2204197645187378,
-0.2568983733654022,
-0.13159406185150146,
0.43040329217910767,
0.2517598569393158,
0.12779438495635986,
-0.00047645464655943215,
-0.20451568067073822,
-0.17649994790554047,
-0.7949247360229492,
-0.054785072803497314,
0.5168572664260864,
0.3748018741607666,
-0.2741611897945404,
0.2806980311870575,
-0.2655515968799591,
0.9128131866455078,
-0.22675848007202148,
0.06854117661714554,
-0.18355005979537964,
-0.14582321047782898,
-0.3334028720855713,
-0.17355534434318542,
0.5010601282119751,
0.3270968496799469,
0.05905350297689438,
-0.3644065260887146,
0.002266164869070053,
-0.12879857420921326,
0.397255539894104,
-0.5302256941795349,
-0.19201545417308807,
0.602338969707489,
0.05212048068642616,
-0.17679639160633087,
0.3949679732322693,
-1.0001097917556763,
-0.58470219373703,
-0.6277475357055664,
0.24514877796173096,
-0.12074922025203705,
-0.15153448283672333,
0.024326642975211143,
-0.25183114409446716,
0.46501585841178894,
0.6133284568786621,
-0.26466044783592224,
0.09127578884363174,
1.127997636795044,
0.7899845242500305,
0.2513962388038635,
-0.8055360317230225,
-0.8568402528762817,
0.15961921215057373,
-0.08426915109157562,
0.8775056600570679,
-0.4083302617073059,
-0.38663622736930847,
-0.06922650337219238,
0.32012489438056946,
-0.020695045590400696,
-0.2487628012895584,
0.5893945693969727,
-0.3783327341079712,
0.29184818267822266,
-0.3658822476863861,
-0.23299092054367065,
-0.3817092776298523,
0.48451411724090576,
-0.5740020275115967,
1.1191270351409912,
-0.1188250184059143,
-0.20290404558181763,
0.4557788074016571,
-0.7337816953659058,
-0.2709592580795288,
0.2938629686832428,
-0.3445459008216858,
-0.27865204215049744,
0.029702454805374146,
0.536795973777771,
0.3882392346858978,
-0.4081522822380066,
0.25250667333602905,
-0.061611466109752655,
-0.39268824458122253,
-0.09191736578941345,
-0.15441544353961945,
0.3977885842323303,
0.4066678285598755,
-0.5164475440979004,
0.2282421588897705,
-0.3524456322193146,
0.23304420709609985,
-0.028558209538459778,
-0.07748761773109436,
0.07307650148868561,
0.22056755423545837,
0.22770577669143677,
0.14080248773097992,
0.2952705919742584,
-0.4238910377025604,
0.14888744056224823,
-0.12599162757396698,
0.28758177161216736,
0.6001430153846741,
-0.19058483839035034,
0.28631940484046936,
-0.4724458158016205,
0.6532602310180664,
-0.40954115986824036,
0.11424064636230469,
-0.48293206095695496,
-0.5266618728637695,
-0.3290649354457855,
-0.6375526189804077,
-0.2796633839607239,
0.5368305444717407,
-0.5921593308448792,
0.3595932126045227,
-0.5296242237091064,
-0.7113025784492493,
-0.09513060003519058,
0.1489052027463913,
0.17367954552173615,
0.3384122848510742,
0.15846475958824158,
0.35842666029930115,
-0.38669970631599426,
-0.4919036030769348,
-0.21122077107429504,
0.15221300721168518,
-0.3102108836174011,
0.44066956639289856,
0.4481574594974518,
0.003429930191487074,
1.0526334047317505,
-0.36654677987098694,
0.007737376727163792,
-0.10301060974597931,
0.2923486828804016,
0.4102184474468231,
0.4802033007144928,
0.534507691860199,
-0.8608266711235046,
-0.3924933075904846,
0.3559277057647705,
-0.9646193981170654,
-0.04136812314391136,
-0.3224785029888153,
-0.16178952157497406,
0.07855304330587387,
0.4149054288864136,
-1.0303499698638916,
0.29730328917503357,
0.4288390874862671,
-0.2112606167793274,
0.5374017357826233,
-0.34958869218826294,
0.20728996396064758,
-0.6386887431144714,
0.22937597334384918,
-0.20589691400527954,
-0.47094231843948364,
-0.39173799753189087,
0.6529679298400879,
-0.1591852903366089,
-0.6833669543266296,
-0.5276004076004028,
0.5419325232505798,
-0.8383346199989319,
-0.2164386510848999,
-0.2778497636318207,
0.1693125069141388,
0.2034609317779541,
0.3576585054397583,
0.1555882692337036,
0.8196656703948975,
0.9271841645240784,
-0.46618038415908813,
0.7104059457778931,
-0.13939307630062103,
-0.09100212901830673,
0.5368223190307617,
-0.47671884298324585,
0.6350244283676147,
-0.39703553915023804,
0.2704547345638275,
-0.6779689788818359,
-0.5325453281402588,
0.016830941662192345,
-0.28785789012908936,
0.019020741805434227,
-0.4076785743236542,
-0.8118972182273865,
-0.3940145969390869,
-0.4157823324203491,
-0.11692377924919128,
0.5651187896728516,
-0.7958812713623047,
1.0330346822738647,
-0.08534189313650131,
-0.11327917128801346,
-0.42020076513290405,
-0.39393356442451477,
0.4041815996170044,
-0.245389923453331,
-0.5867159366607666,
-0.022131839767098427,
0.11989288032054901,
-0.1604267656803131,
0.1303654909133911,
-0.033172477036714554,
-0.08620932698249817,
0.23942291736602783,
0.6668918132781982,
0.16091136634349823,
0.0534636415541172,
-0.05122285708785057,
-0.19859439134597778,
-0.001454009092412889,
0.1252962201833725,
-0.45244061946868896,
0.473308265209198,
-0.25641676783561707,
-0.4119131863117218,
-0.4512181580066681,
0.2846944332122803,
0.8617379665374756,
-0.20771978795528412,
0.5674571394920349,
0.46517759561538696,
-0.5390169024467468,
-0.25161853432655334,
-0.3720608949661255,
-0.06613866984844208,
-0.5293797254562378,
0.18107299506664276,
-0.518621027469635,
-0.5826292037963867,
0.5260952115058899,
-0.32253095507621765,
0.1771642416715622,
0.14534862339496613,
0.46456435322761536,
-0.11839035153388977,
0.6443960070610046,
0.12746790051460266,
-0.21446119248867035,
0.15233153104782104,
-0.4139929711818695,
0.09434963017702103,
-0.44371119141578674,
-0.10645970702171326,
-0.49027568101882935,
-0.31996333599090576,
-0.31506219506263733,
-0.6480395793914795,
0.496171236038208,
-0.2160179316997528,
-0.26490652561187744,
0.1267947405576706,
-0.6653523445129395,
0.7482932806015015,
0.5273343324661255,
0.13168548047542572,
-0.029791364446282387,
0.07003342360258102,
0.09361102432012558,
0.13562656939029694,
-0.7111259698867798,
-0.7332768440246582,
0.8507624268531799,
-0.11745952069759369,
0.873153805732727,
-0.09201548248529434,
0.4187617897987366,
0.31272050738334656,
0.3665466606616974,
-0.6208337545394897,
0.5362505316734314,
0.28128814697265625,
-0.7951354384422302,
-0.26177194714546204,
-0.04363319277763367,
-0.9197539687156677,
0.29490384459495544,
-0.14356905221939087,
-0.5420585870742798,
-0.11022195219993591,
0.29344287514686584,
-0.5066277980804443,
0.27987590432167053,
-0.8302000761032104,
1.0840529203414917,
-0.4618023931980133,
-0.6196295022964478,
-0.19376777112483978,
-0.5946969389915466,
-0.26846060156822205,
0.21814744174480438,
0.4032628536224365,
-0.18866553902626038,
-0.30162519216537476,
-0.22841587662696838,
-0.4643744230270386,
0.7950327396392822,
-0.6511312127113342,
0.11325043439865112,
0.6931154131889343,
0.06185775250196457,
0.8010280728340149,
0.3560848534107208,
-0.11952858418226242,
-0.13272850215435028,
-0.20724190771579742,
-0.3856137692928314,
-0.6509028077125549,
0.9453710317611694,
-0.8001039624214172,
-0.510269045829773,
-0.48629602789878845,
-0.6163681149482727,
0.1223275288939476,
0.03225872665643692,
0.12246306240558624,
0.557529091835022,
-0.3598414957523346,
-0.08450477570295334,
0.06742677837610245,
-0.40329909324645996,
0.21184365451335907,
0.3600870668888092,
-0.12023214995861053,
-0.10235603153705597,
0.9176524877548218,
-0.12765297293663025,
0.03340368717908859,
0.34587258100509644,
0.029277456924319267,
-0.37717580795288086,
-0.3676225543022156,
-0.6042160987854004,
-0.12595289945602417,
-0.4771049916744232,
-0.2020583301782608,
-0.42460158467292786,
0.2362608015537262,
-0.12407183647155762,
-0.6565114259719849,
-0.026608072221279144,
-0.10807197540998459,
-0.28343790769577026,
-0.18337662518024445,
0.29094812273979187,
0.5996479988098145,
0.008106688037514687,
0.28402015566825867,
-0.6300179958343506,
0.14240805804729462,
0.42524638772010803,
-0.11820854991674423,
-0.3367178440093994,
0.034148458391427994,
-0.3858054280281067,
0.001092831720598042,
-0.21677985787391663,
-0.3627224862575531,
0.451719731092453,
0.43578052520751953,
0.5252859592437744,
0.029643215239048004,
-0.0535166934132576,
0.5830517411231995,
-0.38560253381729126,
0.9707677364349365,
-0.30197426676750183,
-0.7299046516418457,
0.6853082776069641,
-0.6822423934936523,
0.45129841566085815,
0.36351776123046875,
0.278830885887146,
-0.40854835510253906,
-0.6427110433578491,
-0.38165125250816345,
-0.6078819036483765,
0.5875195264816284,
-0.027959102764725685,
-0.15877948701381683,
0.18992473185062408,
0.44899898767471313,
0.1703270971775055,
0.4057384133338928,
-0.18629291653633118,
0.3175840377807617,
-0.6543818116188049,
-0.16968010365962982,
-0.319094181060791,
0.37711089849472046,
-0.36960282921791077,
0.06014220789074898,
0.4640241861343384,
-0.6188479065895081,
0.2062871754169464,
0.4940200448036194,
-0.483447790145874,
0.10688469558954239,
0.44906461238861084,
0.5342052578926086,
0.7106688618659973,
-0.343601256608963,
0.3254992365837097,
-0.01487998478114605,
-0.3075580298900604,
-0.04643619433045387,
0.5990023612976074,
-0.08960805833339691,
-0.16588124632835388,
0.19078996777534485,
0.5616274476051331,
0.06469740718603134,
-0.9883003234863281,
0.13644742965698242,
0.17251265048980713,
0.05659274011850357,
-0.4098197817802429,
-0.059671927243471146,
0.24487018585205078,
-0.05154765024781227,
0.6013389229774475,
-0.07376033067703247,
0.09252037853002548,
-0.6020232439041138,
-0.06918401271104813,
0.4273386001586914,
-0.004469817969948053,
-0.6349465847015381,
0.8031449913978577,
0.3606996238231659,
-0.18398240208625793,
0.47492244839668274,
-0.6481569409370422,
-0.6626749038696289,
1.0573614835739136,
-0.07770547270774841,
0.8200820088386536,
0.33086010813713074,
0.06097923591732979,
0.35699453949928284,
0.7468127012252808,
-0.05691929906606674,
0.3035469949245453,
-0.02558625303208828,
-0.47685810923576355,
-0.675872266292572,
-0.21634188294410706,
-0.7170197367668152,
-0.008481756784021854,
-0.351552814245224,
0.15821877121925354,
-0.8082221746444702,
0.05990182235836983,
-0.08710601180791855,
-0.07984471321105957,
-1.1460437774658203,
0.04432179778814316,
0.25788941979408264,
0.6295195817947388,
-0.4443921744823456,
0.5538758635520935,
1.3429993391036987,
0.04657798632979393,
-0.651259183883667,
-0.34778493642807007,
0.484518826007843,
-0.6269878149032593,
0.3713625371456146,
0.5767049789428711,
-0.3257277011871338,
-0.03349311649799347,
-0.7511894702911377,
-0.4863443076610565,
1.1692578792572021,
0.3922765851020813,
-0.4577784240245819,
0.03502098098397255,
0.12414760887622833,
0.5230329036712646,
-0.318366676568985,
0.16838400065898895,
0.17136257886886597,
0.7825633883476257,
-0.3606727421283722,
-0.9072532653808594,
0.16937385499477386,
0.02248169109225273,
-0.32599055767059326,
0.1215180829167366,
-0.5551824569702148,
0.6535753011703491,
-0.13566982746124268,
-0.33892396092414856,
0.30209124088287354,
0.24352312088012695,
0.28269070386886597,
0.40926119685173035,
0.7532086968421936,
0.5999013185501099,
0.6621434092521667,
-0.3756839632987976,
1.3684991598129272,
-0.49489548802375793,
0.6088476181030273,
1.199842929840088,
-0.5471190214157104,
0.3497954308986664,
0.3344840407371521,
-0.049691926687955856,
0.5184878706932068,
0.5450404286384583,
0.05985282361507416,
0.5056016445159912,
0.05239447206258774,
-0.4729573428630829,
-0.5170125365257263,
-0.33948826789855957,
-0.0306461900472641,
0.3554059565067291,
0.3698301911354065,
0.31960466504096985,
-0.36872828006744385,
0.08293143659830093,
-0.038750242441892624,
0.38568371534347534,
-0.3521919846534729,
0.311881959438324,
-0.22935402393341064,
-0.8185011148452759,
0.30636030435562134,
-0.31458911299705505,
0.6770854592323303,
-0.6909830570220947,
-0.17017698287963867,
0.055528443306684494,
-0.12184981256723404,
-0.22101366519927979,
-0.7916726469993591,
0.166645810008049,
0.14507268369197845,
0.08251605182886124,
-0.36586999893188477,
0.6799362301826477,
-0.2056780457496643,
-0.3491884768009186,
0.0760723203420639,
0.7335178852081299,
0.20421093702316284,
-0.5604203939437866,
-0.5427530407905579,
0.06989074498414993,
-0.39326032996177673,
-0.225603848695755,
0.010044872760772705,
0.4985473155975342,
0.23130616545677185,
0.6101928949356079,
0.8256834149360657,
-0.044444646686315536,
0.09623131901025772,
-0.07606952637434006,
0.9546088576316833,
-0.6783848404884338,
-0.6861951351165771,
-0.4516538083553314,
0.39534589648246765,
-0.2347087413072586,
-0.06700549274682999,
0.6854987144470215,
0.7380144596099854,
0.6541624665260315,
-0.15983006358146667,
0.8425820469856262,
-0.367870956659317,
0.5069083571434021,
-0.40550118684768677,
0.43823331594467163,
-0.4429273307323456,
-0.06305581331253052,
0.1547345519065857,
-0.8921008110046387,
-0.12733107805252075,
0.35423704981803894,
-0.12540778517723083,
-0.038416340947151184,
0.5230010151863098,
0.9946203827857971,
-0.15562717616558075,
-0.009125216864049435,
0.2744332253932953,
-0.02610129676759243,
0.5040779113769531,
0.6721213459968567,
1.136627197265625,
0.057070620357990265,
0.6343510150909424,
-0.06745173782110214,
-0.16508571803569794,
0.11467326432466507,
-1.1886649131774902,
-0.8429390788078308,
-0.08419916778802872,
-0.03894169256091118,
0.15901924669742584,
0.2657088339328766,
0.9816027879714966,
0.928756058216095,
-0.4184381663799286,
-0.038610268384218216,
-0.09958996623754501,
0.27363404631614685,
-0.5076775550842285,
-0.23464013636112213,
0.008772367611527443,
-0.3053942918777466,
-0.9570422172546387,
0.800100564956665,
0.33586806058883667,
-0.30614978075027466,
-0.44182077050209045,
-0.19886414706707,
0.013905178755521774,
-0.3768695294857025,
0.4270493984222412,
0.5442474484443665,
-0.6011078953742981,
-0.5701516270637512,
-0.016574131324887276,
0.14374853670597076,
-0.0286423210054636,
0.9096775054931641,
-0.9273650050163269,
0.5713152289390564,
0.25158610939979553,
0.6850070953369141,
0.4874323606491089,
0.11120795458555222,
0.5735526084899902,
-1.0139800310134888,
0.7034031748771667,
0.05704280734062195,
0.2054583579301834,
0.5167968273162842,
-0.615976095199585,
0.6813698410987854,
0.2312467396259308,
-0.7633172869682312,
-0.5251028537750244,
-0.00958719477057457,
-0.9991264343261719,
-0.16532719135284424,
0.9224308133125305,
-0.33858996629714966,
-0.23937273025512695,
-0.16625182330608368,
-0.42359644174575806,
-0.23102322220802307,
-0.582585334777832,
0.2753850519657135,
0.7328613996505737,
-0.06413032114505768,
-0.06647983193397522,
-0.774825394153595,
0.23017829656600952,
0.25457027554512024,
-1.0481382608413696,
0.0916949212551117,
0.9849528074264526,
0.2202111929655075,
0.262736976146698,
0.17294453084468842,
0.20650458335876465,
0.4847736358642578,
0.03071589209139347,
0.08074764162302017,
-0.6068653464317322,
-0.3977368175983429,
-0.2632521092891693,
0.11669773608446121,
0.171957328915596,
-0.123152956366539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15488v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15488v1
|
IryoNLP at MEDIQA-CORR 2024: Tackling the Medical Error Detection & Correction Task On the Shoulders of Medical Agents
| 2024-04-23T20:00:37 | 2024-04-23T20:00:37 |
Jean-Philippe Corbeil
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MA
|
In natural language processing applied to the clinical domain, utilizing
large language models has emerged as a promising avenue for error detection and
correction on clinical notes, a knowledge-intensive task for which annotated
data is scarce. This paper presents MedReAct'N'MedReFlex, which leverages a
suite of four LLM-based medical agents. The MedReAct agent initiates the
process by observing, analyzing, and taking action, generating trajectories to
guide the search to target a potential error in the clinical notes.
Subsequently, the MedEval agent employs five evaluators to assess the targeted
error and the proposed correction. In cases where MedReAct's actions prove
insufficient, the MedReFlex agent intervenes, engaging in reflective analysis
and proposing alternative strategies. Finally, the MedFinalParser agent formats
the final output, preserving the original style while ensuring the integrity of
the error correction process. One core component of our method is our RAG
pipeline based on our ClinicalCorp corpora. Among other well-known sources
containing clinical guidelines and information, we preprocess and release the
open-source MedWiki dataset for clinical RAG application. Our results
demonstrate the central role of our RAG approach with ClinicalCorp leveraged
through the MedReAct'N'MedReFlex framework. It achieved the ninth rank on the
MEDIQA-CORR 2024 final leaderboard.
|
[
-0.021304842084646225,
-0.38350674510002136,
0.5118572115898132,
0.242380291223526,
0.017905225977301598,
0.3568193018436432,
0.13084128499031067,
-0.592147707939148,
0.36342135071754456,
0.7840467691421509,
-0.7945736050605774,
-0.5106236338615417,
-0.4716748893260956,
0.4978553354740143,
-0.1266556978225708,
1.3532136678695679,
-0.225692480802536,
0.11358416825532913,
-0.17127704620361328,
-0.6768636703491211,
-0.4704604148864746,
-0.42017728090286255,
-0.9289288520812988,
-0.4402131736278534,
0.9746957421302795,
0.6397850513458252,
0.7020364999771118,
0.5709326267242432,
0.9252306818962097,
0.3109934628009796,
0.2340889871120453,
0.7899445295333862,
-0.18397650122642517,
0.19339622557163239,
-0.2829386293888092,
-0.3991568088531494,
-1.2348428964614868,
0.08401037007570267,
0.43493369221687317,
0.5057314038276672,
-0.3290807008743286,
-0.04728936403989792,
-0.29199156165122986,
0.8085624575614929,
-0.5112234950065613,
-0.0015829914482310414,
-0.1611057072877884,
0.25254783034324646,
-0.29030391573905945,
-0.6003650426864624,
-0.6493675112724304,
-0.3807002604007721,
-0.1845024973154068,
-0.669445276260376,
0.39815542101860046,
0.3236998915672302,
0.7123062014579773,
0.4672827422618866,
-0.16787771880626678,
-0.4681289494037628,
-0.5781881213188171,
0.5592696666717529,
-0.6793409585952759,
0.16268105804920197,
0.4401891529560089,
0.4400964081287384,
-0.5553472638130188,
-1.1303027868270874,
-0.41888427734375,
-0.053328484296798706,
-0.1296709179878235,
0.3279845118522644,
-0.13290616869926453,
0.21651363372802734,
-0.019508203491568565,
0.23003926873207092,
-0.4590338468551636,
0.04138315096497536,
-0.2841506004333496,
-0.3497653305530548,
0.6110255122184753,
0.4086974561214447,
0.2858535349369049,
0.09318088740110397,
-0.2895875871181488,
-0.23199597001075745,
-0.35366594791412354,
-0.3019394278526306,
-0.3529277443885803,
0.18664591014385223,
-0.3358871340751648,
0.4300117790699005,
0.2010144591331482,
0.48721855878829956,
0.026208559051156044,
-0.4354698061943054,
0.4857776463031769,
-0.15824703872203827,
-0.32008814811706543,
0.23306769132614136,
0.867874026298523,
0.3540559411048889,
-0.02779475972056389,
-0.15840362012386322,
-0.2744891941547394,
-0.09963232278823853,
0.4629688858985901,
-0.3721458911895752,
-0.18719758093357086,
0.43240734934806824,
-0.32773357629776,
-0.3551892936229706,
-0.23827877640724182,
-0.6633615493774414,
-0.8909457921981812,
-0.21952764689922333,
0.2786597013473511,
-0.18757322430610657,
0.12012584507465363,
0.3147459328174591,
-0.0860833004117012,
-0.16389773786067963,
0.7759905457496643,
-0.38996216654777527,
0.6370276808738708,
0.7103241682052612,
0.7347548604011536,
-0.1580209881067276,
-0.25413888692855835,
-0.9908431172370911,
0.10183308273553848,
-0.39261385798454285,
1.1237075328826904,
-0.15216806530952454,
-0.06853355467319489,
-0.15635858476161957,
0.19604171812534332,
-0.42317578196525574,
-0.8231157064437866,
0.832295835018158,
-0.22874340415000916,
0.37795305252075195,
0.0510152243077755,
-0.532515823841095,
0.008118243888020515,
0.2698519825935364,
-0.8763948678970337,
0.5698971152305603,
0.5037530660629272,
-0.7180255055427551,
0.21469691395759583,
-0.9185444712638855,
-0.1640080362558365,
0.18332558870315552,
-0.22724415361881256,
-0.8538782596588135,
-0.14070625603199005,
0.09926958382129669,
0.39719489216804504,
-0.4166448712348938,
0.1865459382534027,
-0.019141890108585358,
-0.1743057370185852,
0.4573872983455658,
-0.1877223253250122,
0.6425592303276062,
0.26675042510032654,
-0.3137356638908386,
0.13684706389904022,
-1.0188497304916382,
-0.10230250656604767,
0.029735121876001358,
-0.37137553095817566,
-0.21661590039730072,
-0.17822280526161194,
0.26004183292388916,
0.12402481585741043,
-0.22750799357891083,
-0.4722648561000824,
0.1525842696428299,
-0.14701834321022034,
0.09870953857898712,
0.5483468770980835,
0.11310109496116638,
0.3224814534187317,
-0.6469942927360535,
0.930392861366272,
-0.2719162404537201,
0.5406308770179749,
-0.12141066044569016,
-0.43215328454971313,
-0.6857596039772034,
-0.6163656115531921,
0.27334776520729065,
0.7027603387832642,
-0.6372184157371521,
0.05655837431550026,
0.011057290248572826,
-0.4830605983734131,
-0.7783385515213013,
-0.040370527654886246,
0.45393073558807373,
0.8709734082221985,
0.5341370105743408,
-0.060079801827669144,
-0.8449260592460632,
-0.5910065770149231,
-0.4138990342617035,
-0.18240079283714294,
0.18925146758556366,
0.15699684619903564,
0.3299560546875,
-0.8114342093467712,
0.7806345224380493,
-0.30789390206336975,
-0.8221811652183533,
-0.38640668988227844,
0.17541168630123138,
0.4001098871231079,
0.4620264768600464,
0.2987472414970398,
-0.6919172406196594,
-0.4307979345321655,
0.1325821429491043,
-0.6982194781303406,
-0.5774199962615967,
-0.20452672243118286,
-0.0852246880531311,
0.4936613142490387,
0.6630588173866272,
-0.2975326478481293,
0.43905889987945557,
0.7263796329498291,
-0.5470350980758667,
0.34306731820106506,
-0.5611852407455444,
0.14059750735759735,
-1.0327293872833252,
0.21663092076778412,
-0.33931684494018555,
-0.4278886914253235,
-0.6688789129257202,
-0.21219965815544128,
0.22684282064437866,
0.363395631313324,
-0.07726295292377472,
0.5594528913497925,
-0.32652565836906433,
0.27582791447639465,
-0.24179607629776,
0.04913453757762909,
0.4323734641075134,
0.17494727671146393,
-0.17167462408542633,
0.5274883508682251,
-0.31589528918266296,
-0.2643173336982727,
0.37212231755256653,
0.3562500774860382,
0.30319201946258545,
0.6936531662940979,
-0.3451090157032013,
0.1915188580751419,
-0.10058289021253586,
0.3847682774066925,
-0.7417336106300354,
-0.29519104957580566,
0.6001091003417969,
-0.5939645767211914,
0.436802476644516,
-0.14850203692913055,
-0.45466896891593933,
-0.28791627287864685,
-0.1616249829530716,
0.324183851480484,
0.014562375843524933,
-0.18723666667938232,
0.787562370300293,
0.4791296720504761,
-0.19170890748500824,
-0.7001146078109741,
-0.6434935331344604,
0.2973882257938385,
0.16458863019943237,
-0.5026781558990479,
0.17016354203224182,
-0.10191559046506882,
-0.312977135181427,
-0.03137500211596489,
0.08880908787250519,
-0.04242725670337677,
-0.08895746618509293,
0.43342509865760803,
0.5875205993652344,
-0.191677063703537,
0.1699739545583725,
-0.18615615367889404,
-0.4281512498855591,
-0.032428812235593796,
0.06493985652923584,
0.29613518714904785,
-0.13566933572292328,
-0.33163389563560486,
-0.39224210381507874,
0.07759220153093338,
0.7115978598594666,
-0.24046510457992554,
0.5663005113601685,
0.4633254110813141,
-0.32376527786254883,
-0.18310974538326263,
-0.7149563431739807,
-0.02498316578567028,
-0.4411622881889343,
0.2833127975463867,
0.29322728514671326,
-0.5861923694610596,
0.4791423976421356,
0.08459531515836716,
0.04309452325105667,
0.4252561032772064,
0.3429061770439148,
-0.2680659890174866,
0.7829105257987976,
0.6415384411811829,
0.04838725924491882,
-0.13518662750720978,
-0.28394559025764465,
0.20337101817131042,
-0.8225195407867432,
-0.4238249659538269,
-0.6840022206306458,
-0.19586269557476044,
-0.6318946480751038,
-0.8574267625808716,
0.767368733882904,
-0.4916034936904907,
-0.10780920088291168,
0.05951942130923271,
-0.42544612288475037,
0.04234187304973602,
0.2734449505805969,
-0.028875254094600677,
0.5321024656295776,
0.11080854386091232,
-0.22704645991325378,
-0.17760206758975983,
-0.7846580743789673,
-0.23824892938137054,
0.804006040096283,
0.5415796041488647,
0.8667122721672058,
-0.16871047019958496,
0.6582491993904114,
0.5877671837806702,
0.7636414766311646,
-0.7031449675559998,
0.35254037380218506,
-0.2027270495891571,
-0.44703274965286255,
-0.07511761039495468,
-0.16501837968826294,
-0.8633756637573242,
0.11902361363172531,
-0.26987355947494507,
-0.008067633956670761,
0.3389034569263458,
0.26216137409210205,
-0.35781538486480713,
0.28436383605003357,
-0.44571778178215027,
0.9881154894828796,
0.07141809165477753,
-0.41671013832092285,
-0.02185172773897648,
-0.6615601778030396,
-0.03770260885357857,
-0.029706129804253578,
0.6284090876579285,
0.08052467554807663,
-0.382024884223938,
0.5453208088874817,
-0.7445623278617859,
0.6920691728591919,
-0.13070183992385864,
-0.15621444582939148,
0.05728005990386009,
0.06574580073356628,
0.6748422980308533,
-0.19406037032604218,
0.10039093345403671,
-0.16949747502803802,
-0.11520100384950638,
-0.13613936305046082,
-0.38941654562950134,
0.15053656697273254,
-0.4345243573188782,
0.08908215165138245,
-0.8166931867599487,
-0.617356538772583,
-0.13243791460990906,
0.13618183135986328,
0.25257933139801025,
0.8201766014099121,
-0.036194439977407455,
-0.18917664885520935,
0.33793890476226807,
-0.34762924909591675,
0.10358654707670212,
0.962634801864624,
-0.13468444347381592,
-0.7416775226593018,
0.8031356930732727,
-0.12301425635814667,
0.12084466964006424,
0.4069547951221466,
0.216856449842453,
-0.16957871615886688,
-0.5767762660980225,
-0.2423011064529419,
0.661104142665863,
-0.6311729550361633,
-0.4080519676208496,
-0.8880707621574402,
-0.2740508019924164,
-0.28797245025634766,
-0.18099194765090942,
-0.5141981840133667,
-0.2697075307369232,
0.008541448973119259,
0.22436098754405975,
0.5069783926010132,
0.8654281497001648,
-0.23095065355300903,
0.22569511830806732,
-0.9874555468559265,
0.19230596721172333,
-0.3292785882949829,
0.2845814526081085,
-0.4772025942802429,
-0.45225203037261963,
-0.46689164638519287,
-0.15556277334690094,
-0.1297001838684082,
-0.453501433134079,
0.6205036640167236,
0.2267134040594101,
0.309211403131485,
0.2618306875228882,
0.04068916663527489,
0.7612259387969971,
-0.6494796276092529,
0.12888668477535248,
0.10262387245893478,
-0.47542980313301086,
0.5598800182342529,
-0.3761167526245117,
0.11941960453987122,
0.5494787693023682,
0.04042394459247589,
-1.128238558769226,
-0.7694007754325867,
-0.7513090372085571,
-0.5959463119506836,
0.7064011096954346,
0.02287890389561653,
-0.5249730348587036,
0.02594020590186119,
0.3909657299518585,
-0.07818414270877838,
0.14184066653251648,
-0.2740570604801178,
-0.2020903080701828,
0.2525438368320465,
-0.7239151000976562,
-0.17648521065711975,
-0.24617566168308258,
-0.2427905648946762,
-0.025976363569498062,
0.5757188200950623,
-0.4414229393005371,
0.19291111826896667,
0.8048039078712463,
0.0112128471955657,
-0.433288037776947,
0.17322969436645508,
0.9781811833381653,
0.691997766494751,
-0.43671730160713196,
-0.010876827873289585,
-0.2670370638370514,
-1.2315917015075684,
-0.03275002911686897,
0.23481853306293488,
0.06167135387659073,
0.21538054943084717,
0.7313506007194519,
0.3280029892921448,
0.1041475459933281,
-1.0850516557693481,
0.6101800799369812,
-0.365803062915802,
-0.08146104216575623,
-0.7331034541130066,
-0.13513915240764618,
-0.20185215771198273,
0.38371115922927856,
0.24381351470947266,
0.6502160429954529,
0.37564024329185486,
-0.2790350317955017,
0.2959800064563751,
0.06617602705955505,
-0.5733686685562134,
-0.20722493529319763,
0.64200758934021,
-0.05131741240620613,
-0.31216925382614136,
0.34500253200531006,
-0.04555919021368027,
-0.46698832511901855,
0.7204378247261047,
0.37103813886642456,
0.8226329684257507,
-0.31449249386787415,
0.24736228585243225,
0.155500590801239,
0.36691203713417053,
-0.08132526278495789,
0.22593101859092712,
0.5037873387336731,
-0.6476978063583374,
-0.7219977974891663,
-0.15789267420768738,
-0.7056094408035278,
0.12144635617733002,
-0.4846852719783783,
0.3349411189556122,
-0.6652508974075317,
-0.17677901685237885,
-0.015600703656673431,
-0.07214440405368805,
-0.2520914077758789,
0.2536083161830902,
-0.1575000137090683,
0.952963650226593,
-0.4314236342906952,
0.5308061242103577,
0.9474790692329407,
-0.15262088179588318,
-0.922422468662262,
-0.29946136474609375,
0.38628119230270386,
-0.8367712497711182,
0.7315740585327148,
-0.03179556503891945,
-0.19337902963161469,
-0.442562460899353,
-0.471039354801178,
-0.44584330916404724,
1.0474964380264282,
0.10449244827032089,
-0.41317275166511536,
0.042617011815309525,
0.24825824797153473,
0.7813237905502319,
-0.4737606942653656,
0.17871317267417908,
0.5355080366134644,
0.2017868161201477,
0.08016198128461838,
-1.0996955633163452,
-0.025142718106508255,
-0.36533322930336,
-0.6651489734649658,
0.26721885800361633,
-0.4261940121650696,
0.8798382878303528,
-0.47187355160713196,
0.19141064584255219,
0.14048440754413605,
0.1265159696340561,
0.33939701318740845,
0.8597462177276611,
0.267700731754303,
0.5227989554405212,
0.9809306263923645,
0.14015041291713715,
1.119106411933899,
0.11466486006975174,
0.1433022916316986,
1.2969388961791992,
-0.2984120845794678,
0.715957522392273,
0.4445534348487854,
-0.10436809062957764,
0.7231155037879944,
0.1532328575849533,
0.09624937176704407,
0.16586127877235413,
-0.14253735542297363,
-0.39913836121559143,
0.06861299276351929,
-0.2661914527416229,
0.021666552871465683,
0.34990426898002625,
0.5550376772880554,
-0.45030009746551514,
-0.15293097496032715,
0.1501525491476059,
0.44292861223220825,
0.29736050963401794,
-0.3206961154937744,
0.6683853268623352,
0.1127467006444931,
-0.7464438080787659,
0.6559247374534607,
-0.10751741379499435,
0.2792101800441742,
-0.5577105283737183,
-0.47660598158836365,
-0.4958142042160034,
0.9231902360916138,
-0.3582552373409271,
-0.34648481011390686,
0.2141089290380478,
-0.12256921082735062,
-0.17547883093357086,
-0.03396495431661606,
0.8381641507148743,
-0.35727447271347046,
-0.2775481939315796,
0.2965753376483917,
0.17176921665668488,
-0.01387513056397438,
0.07021893560886383,
-0.7405465841293335,
0.2769419848918915,
-0.1189921423792839,
0.36761316657066345,
0.0333474762737751,
0.4967197775840759,
-0.155807226896286,
0.8820649981498718,
0.3547002077102661,
0.4008987843990326,
-0.08924537152051926,
0.27385663986206055,
0.6043038964271545,
-0.4874423146247864,
-0.3422311246395111,
-0.569059431552887,
0.5522725582122803,
-0.24418911337852478,
-0.0898916944861412,
0.5058427453041077,
0.5224674344062805,
0.417001873254776,
-0.12247052043676376,
0.5301811695098877,
0.14454536139965057,
1.2294330596923828,
-0.3403245508670807,
0.6581077575683594,
-0.5590246915817261,
0.25521785020828247,
-0.3065062463283539,
-0.35462814569473267,
-0.6089879870414734,
0.5824612975120544,
0.14102157950401306,
-0.24439431726932526,
0.9914576411247253,
0.9536536931991577,
0.18276263773441315,
0.04381715878844261,
0.09483768045902252,
0.5170755982398987,
0.43513667583465576,
0.47855886816978455,
0.5665375590324402,
-0.7872636914253235,
0.1796436458826065,
-0.14282460510730743,
-0.29591473937034607,
-0.4603634774684906,
-0.8034622669219971,
-0.8481151461601257,
-0.29853010177612305,
-0.42715609073638916,
-0.7726544141769409,
0.13313698768615723,
1.2550122737884521,
0.3976202607154846,
-0.8775167465209961,
-0.13610661029815674,
-0.04848584532737732,
0.06573991477489471,
-0.24478551745414734,
-0.1868421733379364,
0.48086854815483093,
-0.4855925440788269,
-0.45265278220176697,
0.3420270085334778,
0.745492160320282,
-0.023674694821238518,
0.029780138283967972,
-0.24892237782478333,
-0.1937328428030014,
-0.17853087186813354,
0.38100704550743103,
0.35836344957351685,
-0.23872265219688416,
0.07718392461538315,
0.12498558312654495,
-0.4597083628177643,
0.18081805109977722,
0.9990706443786621,
-0.6947112679481506,
0.5373457670211792,
0.30337831377983093,
0.6208403706550598,
-0.03710300102829933,
-0.34794893860816956,
0.5747219324111938,
-0.3208891749382019,
0.1244647279381752,
0.5433328747749329,
0.22849580645561218,
0.3934650421142578,
-0.2534629702568054,
0.9947509765625,
0.5035812854766846,
-0.7283040285110474,
-0.861497700214386,
-0.45271214842796326,
-1.0809873342514038,
0.056202128529548645,
0.7708127498626709,
0.07480555027723312,
-0.4410921037197113,
-0.5419246554374695,
-0.6480038166046143,
0.030830083414912224,
-0.1716795265674591,
0.537445068359375,
0.1658240556716919,
-0.26223158836364746,
-0.24138280749320984,
-0.9163401126861572,
0.9226673245429993,
0.3259415626525879,
-0.7620730400085449,
-0.06902147829532623,
0.45861220359802246,
0.2309514880180359,
0.26825129985809326,
1.143977403640747,
-0.43847012519836426,
0.7647031545639038,
-0.3059822916984558,
0.19978821277618408,
0.0871327668428421,
-0.19489094614982605,
-0.3406321406364441,
-0.19645719230175018,
0.13387490808963776,
-0.07347658276557922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00708v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00708v1
|
Interactive Analysis of LLMs using Meaningful Counterfactuals
| 2024-04-23T19:57:03 | 2024-04-23T19:57:03 |
Furui Cheng, Vilém Zouhar, Robin Shing Moon Chan, Daniel Fürst, Hendrik Strobelt, Mennatallah El-Assady
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG, I.2.7; H.5.2
|
Counterfactual examples are useful for exploring the decision boundaries of
machine learning models and determining feature attributions. How can we apply
counterfactual-based methods to analyze and explain LLMs? We identify the
following key challenges. First, the generated textual counterfactuals should
be meaningful and readable to users and thus can be mentally compared to draw
conclusions. Second, to make the solution scalable to long-form text, users
should be equipped with tools to create batches of counterfactuals from
perturbations at various granularity levels and interactively analyze the
results. In this paper, we tackle the above challenges and contribute 1) a
novel algorithm for generating batches of complete and meaningful textual
counterfactuals by removing and replacing text segments in different
granularities, and 2) LLM Analyzer, an interactive visualization tool to help
users understand an LLM's behaviors by interactively inspecting and aggregating
meaningful counterfactuals. We evaluate the proposed algorithm by the
grammatical correctness of its generated counterfactuals using 1,000 samples
from medical, legal, finance, education, and news datasets. In our experiments,
97.2% of the counterfactuals are grammatically correct. Through a use case,
user studies, and feedback from experts, we demonstrate the usefulness and
usability of the proposed interactive visualization tool.
|
[
-0.3909311294555664,
-1.5856139659881592,
0.8899315595626831,
0.12771552801132202,
-0.3572900593280792,
0.08911550045013428,
0.0828118696808815,
-0.30615225434303284,
0.3191678524017334,
0.41803884506225586,
-0.9665203094482422,
-0.449084997177124,
-0.5957886576652527,
-0.07446552813053131,
-0.5545567870140076,
0.9370935559272766,
-0.24146005511283875,
0.1659923940896988,
-0.714996337890625,
-0.1472005546092987,
-0.4189983904361725,
-0.5121169090270996,
-0.5073474049568176,
-0.40795665979385376,
0.537091076374054,
0.41860657930374146,
0.8079572319984436,
0.42709439992904663,
0.5007478594779968,
0.38226816058158875,
0.0880906879901886,
0.20494280755519867,
-0.6212860941886902,
0.25059589743614197,
-0.17063453793525696,
-0.3710154592990875,
-0.51242595911026,
0.1672104150056839,
0.25000452995300293,
0.7988935112953186,
-0.13424886763095856,
0.3066463768482208,
0.0016229237662628293,
0.5636533498764038,
-0.09098818153142929,
0.17090041935443878,
-0.4490874409675598,
0.19178175926208496,
-0.3043254613876343,
-0.40968674421310425,
-0.183146670460701,
-0.12433335930109024,
0.17000682651996613,
-0.6520366072654724,
-0.06623908877372742,
0.1422785371541977,
0.6083145141601562,
0.42895200848579407,
-0.5621893405914307,
-0.7218800783157349,
-0.5738019943237305,
0.7367621064186096,
-0.6083097457885742,
0.2232043445110321,
0.11362536996603012,
0.14496421813964844,
-0.32272711396217346,
-0.815315842628479,
-0.7146100401878357,
-0.25437939167022705,
-0.34979793429374695,
0.11258044093847275,
-0.5916935205459595,
-0.255681574344635,
0.40547576546669006,
-0.05042799562215805,
-0.6884274482727051,
0.41570374369621277,
0.03816605731844902,
-0.04175904393196106,
0.6237399578094482,
0.5675354599952698,
0.5755491256713867,
-0.060719456523656845,
-0.35410213470458984,
0.27058500051498413,
-0.5972949862480164,
0.030725110322237015,
0.2758357524871826,
0.0021916243713349104,
-0.22958527505397797,
0.7380855083465576,
0.027347173541784286,
0.5255348682403564,
0.004271591082215309,
-0.03327777981758118,
0.1480134278535843,
-0.41479501128196716,
-0.32031336426734924,
-0.1242271289229393,
0.736939549446106,
0.5449701547622681,
0.4405747652053833,
0.03687620162963867,
-0.10701020807027817,
0.01777436025440693,
0.39063575863838196,
-0.7514757513999939,
-0.014991393312811852,
0.5720402002334595,
-0.4911559522151947,
-0.5600085258483887,
-0.2819618582725525,
-0.8537163138389587,
-0.4869154095649719,
-0.6730561852455139,
0.47944948077201843,
-0.15762607753276825,
0.05711839348077774,
-0.2711535096168518,
0.07114137709140778,
-0.13532331585884094,
0.47822391986846924,
-0.5429141521453857,
0.2579360902309418,
0.4241946339607239,
0.7404585480690002,
-0.2527819573879242,
-0.1490415632724762,
-0.6663178205490112,
-0.008854662999510765,
-0.3685646057128906,
0.7760337591171265,
-0.569597065448761,
-0.4373086988925934,
-0.07309082895517349,
-0.14792686700820923,
-0.2866521179676056,
-0.6035143136978149,
0.031765908002853394,
-0.3693813383579254,
0.3663572371006012,
-0.414798378944397,
-0.7429872155189514,
-0.17601323127746582,
0.5583119988441467,
-0.6739524006843567,
1.0068835020065308,
-0.1695452332496643,
-0.6002620458602905,
0.3589623272418976,
-0.900599479675293,
-0.24509496986865997,
0.06141972541809082,
-0.4757075011730194,
-0.6505864262580872,
0.07537902891635895,
0.19657979905605316,
0.5940576791763306,
0.08433733880519867,
0.6144601702690125,
-0.27799779176712036,
-0.36214110255241394,
0.7257420420646667,
-0.5045945644378662,
0.7264534831047058,
0.0851651281118393,
-0.4333305358886719,
0.3704942762851715,
-0.6668854355812073,
-0.13142691552639008,
0.12724751234054565,
-0.02706606686115265,
-0.17410527169704437,
0.20890887081623077,
-0.02288755588233471,
0.05677184835076332,
0.26344457268714905,
-0.2089616060256958,
0.21121551096439362,
-0.03464207798242569,
0.23170773684978485,
0.4726252853870392,
0.21515987813472748,
0.08436855673789978,
-0.3511175215244293,
0.6143945455551147,
0.11125124990940094,
0.1739785224199295,
-0.38788390159606934,
-0.41250303387641907,
-0.6540871262550354,
-0.6106336712837219,
-0.009667853824794292,
0.8387408256530762,
-0.9254435896873474,
0.14757311344146729,
-0.06262244284152985,
-0.48644572496414185,
-0.23384268581867218,
0.22849375009536743,
0.3241439759731293,
0.8397566676139832,
0.35743141174316406,
-0.11945050954818726,
-0.6337987780570984,
-0.8512364625930786,
-0.4396710693836212,
-0.21126355230808258,
0.1512361764907837,
0.28924667835235596,
0.734138548374176,
-0.4762538969516754,
1.122470498085022,
-0.5409333109855652,
-0.08174139261245728,
-0.08134594559669495,
0.6115934252738953,
0.16324198246002197,
0.32090631127357483,
0.7091590166091919,
-0.7614991068840027,
-0.2411981076002121,
-0.05159031227231026,
-1.144407868385315,
-0.469149112701416,
-0.41582387685775757,
0.21976642310619354,
0.2860942780971527,
0.9707672595977783,
-0.5368117690086365,
0.5925037264823914,
0.15818655490875244,
-0.37107351422309875,
0.6707797050476074,
-0.14455221593379974,
0.2669520080089569,
-0.7220897078514099,
0.22821904718875885,
-0.05444875732064247,
-0.3376927673816681,
-0.9293414950370789,
0.10549061000347137,
-0.2856873869895935,
-0.026329459622502327,
-0.5688113570213318,
0.632188081741333,
-0.18843349814414978,
0.10151354223489761,
-0.08629392832517624,
0.2377975732088089,
-0.24506568908691406,
0.3924536108970642,
-0.14692965149879456,
0.6088532209396362,
0.14735816419124603,
-0.2725245952606201,
0.6084228754043579,
-0.0007288929773494601,
-0.29633522033691406,
0.738702654838562,
-0.5662997961044312,
-0.10313727706670761,
-0.2610960602760315,
0.005940859671682119,
-1.1856926679611206,
-0.03570074960589409,
0.3288039267063141,
-0.2657865881919861,
-0.051265258342027664,
-0.10665395110845566,
-0.5232294201850891,
-0.012620430439710617,
-0.4426340162754059,
0.1840973049402237,
0.36445415019989014,
-0.36196520924568176,
0.7774621248245239,
0.16804718971252441,
-0.41636210680007935,
-0.3204277455806732,
-0.6706149578094482,
0.2793274223804474,
-0.460033655166626,
-0.36211666464805603,
0.051244910806417465,
-0.24522484838962555,
-0.5972211956977844,
0.10067006200551987,
0.04072012007236481,
0.10554126650094986,
0.28603124618530273,
0.33550894260406494,
0.43531298637390137,
-0.07804236561059952,
0.013738041743636131,
0.14223499596118927,
-0.12717849016189575,
0.2900051772594452,
0.18939712643623352,
0.26706063747406006,
-0.1585732102394104,
-0.5948981046676636,
-0.23758995532989502,
0.3061845898628235,
0.5118464231491089,
0.2762916386127472,
0.4453459084033966,
0.7973747849464417,
-0.33227887749671936,
-0.011730209924280643,
-0.4962831735610962,
0.046177152544260025,
-0.45184484124183655,
0.48172903060913086,
-0.2539381682872772,
-0.6473978757858276,
0.7823315858840942,
-0.22705858945846558,
0.15156948566436768,
0.2461458444595337,
0.839989185333252,
-0.4787290394306183,
0.8426551222801208,
0.47929486632347107,
0.389526903629303,
0.3945300281047821,
-0.13818244636058807,
0.14895634353160858,
-0.29397454857826233,
-0.6150088906288147,
-0.22470609843730927,
-0.3439188003540039,
-0.5536168813705444,
-0.40105265378952026,
0.4309285879135132,
-0.1208885982632637,
-0.10544165968894958,
-0.07172895967960358,
0.10035848617553711,
0.31140100955963135,
0.34774351119995117,
0.07316847145557404,
0.3309401869773865,
0.05049336329102516,
-0.47525858879089355,
-0.35575124621391296,
-0.3564557433128357,
-0.7892652750015259,
0.7071234583854675,
0.29451310634613037,
0.6473138928413391,
0.22751808166503906,
0.5397735834121704,
0.589051365852356,
0.5643020868301392,
-0.9685366749763489,
0.6769528388977051,
-0.30861660838127136,
-0.30060604214668274,
-0.3135833740234375,
-0.374317467212677,
-0.8673402667045593,
0.33068984746932983,
-0.6601511836051941,
-0.8011431097984314,
0.09256941080093384,
0.365184485912323,
-0.10456868261098862,
0.08543196320533752,
-0.7690789103507996,
0.9690325260162354,
-0.3592245876789093,
-0.43563312292099,
-0.08391223847866058,
-0.46296998858451843,
0.2400342971086502,
-0.25876984000205994,
0.5393152832984924,
0.22338472306728363,
-0.18102476000785828,
0.6605420112609863,
-0.5295920372009277,
1.1213942766189575,
-0.14010116457939148,
-0.29923734068870544,
0.13898654282093048,
0.2542882263660431,
0.4144108295440674,
0.030508972704410553,
0.0005062222480773926,
0.18093787133693695,
-0.02235415391623974,
-0.4034055471420288,
-0.9537451863288879,
0.5616179704666138,
-0.41245099902153015,
-0.7242674827575684,
-0.4169047176837921,
-0.5044823288917542,
-0.22042012214660645,
0.2874789237976074,
-0.03410477191209793,
0.5336629748344421,
-0.5863232016563416,
-0.024929413571953773,
0.6104650497436523,
-0.10109274834394455,
0.6009624004364014,
0.7719455361366272,
-0.4283362627029419,
-0.26531243324279785,
0.9416475892066956,
0.3888043463230133,
-0.12139295041561127,
0.23643898963928223,
0.18391403555870056,
-0.2822277545928955,
-0.6511780619621277,
-0.6285439133644104,
0.020182473585009575,
-0.6429023146629333,
0.22246898710727692,
-0.46709564328193665,
0.07151277363300323,
0.051756858825683594,
-0.21723498404026031,
0.10656800121068954,
-0.30117207765579224,
-0.569311797618866,
-0.045144736766815186,
0.11674091964960098,
0.8019466996192932,
0.15077127516269684,
0.39224159717559814,
-0.6762054562568665,
0.5054047703742981,
0.4178265631198883,
0.06477812677621841,
-0.034938592463731766,
-0.21762917935848236,
-0.11957769095897675,
0.0010824230266734958,
-0.2746775448322296,
-0.9199788570404053,
0.3754407465457916,
-0.07398373633623123,
0.825975775718689,
0.5041609406471252,
-0.06749734282493591,
0.9233868718147278,
-0.5944035649299622,
0.8277699947357178,
0.1031627357006073,
-1.014786958694458,
0.40879902243614197,
-0.24731411039829254,
0.16824181377887726,
0.3874918520450592,
0.5907605886459351,
-0.49818798899650574,
-0.36899274587631226,
-0.5063534379005432,
-0.836356520652771,
0.4145280718803406,
0.27847278118133545,
0.05034169554710388,
0.02870824933052063,
0.397755891084671,
0.23277007043361664,
0.2652123272418976,
-0.592448353767395,
-0.27338993549346924,
-0.2663280963897705,
-0.62176913022995,
-0.07912668585777283,
-0.3274053633213043,
-0.1999479979276657,
0.12457165867090225,
0.5174002647399902,
-0.09339374303817749,
-0.2522208094596863,
0.15401019155979156,
-0.4674239158630371,
-0.12928639352321625,
0.3230449855327606,
0.8644990921020508,
0.885380744934082,
-0.18072403967380524,
0.3510059118270874,
0.3410254120826721,
-0.4751650393009186,
-0.0030124334152787924,
0.19747094810009003,
-0.183175727725029,
-0.06087427958846092,
0.7334113121032715,
0.5615371465682983,
0.09387268126010895,
-0.9312370419502258,
0.4089292287826538,
-0.09148091822862625,
-0.17193010449409485,
-0.21727406978607178,
-0.10415567457675934,
0.18608839809894562,
0.4187016785144806,
0.4837595224380493,
-0.07449305057525635,
0.2424766719341278,
-0.7674867510795593,
0.2142418920993805,
0.6737809777259827,
-0.4641796052455902,
-0.17543594539165497,
0.44472330808639526,
0.2646615505218506,
-0.24802231788635254,
0.5066997408866882,
-0.05498539283871651,
-0.4343411326408386,
0.6785290837287903,
0.31367748975753784,
0.5577269196510315,
0.10124880075454712,
0.24510227143764496,
-0.13755182921886444,
0.3781083822250366,
0.21023492515087128,
0.3617861270904541,
0.13717328011989594,
-0.5134051442146301,
-0.5134748816490173,
-0.1980706751346588,
-0.7048133015632629,
0.2465362250804901,
-0.5978502631187439,
0.21711693704128265,
-0.18554234504699707,
-0.19731155037879944,
0.1957377940416336,
0.0850481390953064,
-0.4753604829311371,
0.4017328917980194,
-0.056032080203294754,
0.47324138879776,
-1.1471545696258545,
0.43807923793792725,
0.9726709723472595,
-0.2629793882369995,
-0.15145602822303772,
-0.20403434336185455,
0.4093056321144104,
-0.9704997539520264,
0.6708704233169556,
-0.02487967349588871,
-0.16497106850147247,
-0.4790055453777313,
-0.7271574139595032,
-0.42349547147750854,
0.9015005826950073,
0.4709739685058594,
-0.6796467900276184,
0.2503477931022644,
0.32027265429496765,
0.761584460735321,
-0.34897011518478394,
0.48384279012680054,
0.39009392261505127,
0.5671403408050537,
0.008518174290657043,
-0.7595967054367065,
0.3898915946483612,
-0.4323899447917938,
-0.2789919376373291,
-0.00039411833859048784,
-0.248614102602005,
0.6163082718849182,
-0.27758416533470154,
-0.0017004836117848754,
0.013932563364505768,
0.4770278036594391,
0.3473742604255676,
0.9094207286834717,
0.6454116702079773,
0.48265135288238525,
0.6959553360939026,
-0.019918199628591537,
0.6754192113876343,
0.0946258008480072,
0.43318915367126465,
1.0598690509796143,
-0.18505069613456726,
0.5971143841743469,
0.7487393617630005,
-0.15050891041755676,
0.5977325439453125,
0.5244283080101013,
-0.2173963189125061,
0.07793410867452621,
0.3154638707637787,
-0.06754996627569199,
-0.39064499735832214,
-0.1107766181230545,
0.009128645993769169,
0.34829017519950867,
0.5092034339904785,
-0.16061264276504517,
-0.2985491454601288,
0.046115826815366745,
0.35535284876823425,
0.227570578455925,
-0.11968958377838135,
0.8458753228187561,
0.0379306860268116,
-0.33777332305908203,
0.26882368326187134,
-0.16260351240634918,
0.5197421908378601,
-0.39612066745758057,
-0.3760095536708832,
-0.2775968015193939,
-0.19694913923740387,
-0.4779209792613983,
-0.8457152247428894,
0.3293991982936859,
0.25447678565979004,
-0.16375838220119476,
-0.32236409187316895,
0.5045633316040039,
-0.4370426833629608,
-0.6138371229171753,
0.060203876346349716,
0.9348799586296082,
0.39037489891052246,
0.23435840010643005,
-0.6702008247375488,
0.09846511483192444,
-0.048873238265514374,
-0.3879472315311432,
0.23463591933250427,
0.48301005363464355,
-0.3719636797904968,
0.8217281103134155,
0.6935668587684631,
-0.022525914013385773,
-0.17550671100616455,
0.2798747718334198,
0.7538726329803467,
-0.7906175255775452,
-0.37725165486335754,
-1.213356375694275,
0.581461489200592,
-0.06966143101453781,
-0.10602103918790817,
0.6640853881835938,
0.45503494143486023,
0.5316187143325806,
-0.005699790082871914,
0.5878440737724304,
0.1547444760799408,
0.3680761158466339,
-0.7318133115768433,
0.6415493488311768,
-0.8012269735336304,
0.6354413032531738,
-0.2290050983428955,
-0.49649205803871155,
-0.3531654179096222,
0.24530021846294403,
-0.3150450587272644,
0.056635815650224686,
0.6339243650436401,
0.6102928519248962,
-0.10569130629301071,
-0.15507663786411285,
0.35537034273147583,
0.5145276784896851,
0.4436113238334656,
0.02119150198996067,
0.8517577052116394,
-0.09426094591617584,
0.5576746463775635,
-0.039114344865083694,
-0.2676197290420532,
-0.41539740562438965,
-1.2970229387283325,
-1.0446275472640991,
-0.2656896114349365,
-0.5834929347038269,
0.035046517848968506,
0.0687493309378624,
0.8385594487190247,
0.3471689522266388,
-0.7696655988693237,
-0.2203281670808792,
0.15528754889965057,
0.38187235593795776,
-0.12569409608840942,
-0.30106887221336365,
0.31307098269462585,
-0.22829478979110718,
-0.7073977589607239,
0.39348793029785156,
0.22106170654296875,
0.25659558176994324,
-0.11792659759521484,
0.15500397980213165,
-0.16819755733013153,
0.33598676323890686,
0.8408612608909607,
0.05411795526742935,
-0.7463071942329407,
-0.2047388255596161,
0.00832632090896368,
0.06734109669923782,
-0.289058655500412,
0.9153412580490112,
-0.7295432090759277,
0.4503974914550781,
0.3669919967651367,
0.3794541358947754,
0.49680614471435547,
0.16427090764045715,
0.36413493752479553,
-0.7629155516624451,
-0.23877181112766266,
-0.11282575875520706,
0.39058899879455566,
0.09888061881065369,
-0.4523620009422302,
0.35151392221450806,
0.24220114946365356,
-0.1852196902036667,
-0.8884458541870117,
0.20179937779903412,
-1.0861899852752686,
-0.6504702568054199,
0.8775405883789062,
-0.29872849583625793,
-0.0030406636651605368,
-0.3317546546459198,
-0.2896530330181122,
0.2135879248380661,
-0.16840969026088715,
0.7347941398620605,
0.6843191981315613,
-0.6289382576942444,
-0.06573532521724701,
-0.46998319029808044,
0.23502212762832642,
0.5219438076019287,
-1.0779458284378052,
-0.12863139808177948,
0.4700600206851959,
0.3717021346092224,
0.11596064269542694,
0.5140939950942993,
-0.08652236312627792,
0.13767915964126587,
-0.09222844988107681,
-0.21075879037380219,
-0.41664841771125793,
-0.026483353227376938,
-0.46175187826156616,
0.20305302739143372,
-0.24047420918941498,
0.05146534740924835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15485v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15485v3
|
Evaluating the Efficacy of Large Language Models in Identifying Phishing Attempts
| 2024-04-23T19:55:18 | 2024-06-06T21:03:03 |
Het Patel, Umair Rehman, Farkhund Iqbal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Phishing, a prevalent cybercrime tactic for decades, remains a significant
threat in today's digital world. By leveraging clever social engineering
elements and modern technology, cybercrime targets many individuals,
businesses, and organizations to exploit trust and security. These
cyber-attackers are often disguised in many trustworthy forms to appear as
legitimate sources. By cleverly using psychological elements like urgency,
fear, social proof, and other manipulative strategies, phishers can lure
individuals into revealing sensitive and personalized information. Building on
this pervasive issue within modern technology, this paper aims to analyze the
effectiveness of 15 Large Language Models (LLMs) in detecting phishing
attempts, specifically focusing on a randomized set of "419 Scam" emails. The
objective is to determine which LLMs can accurately detect phishing emails by
analyzing a text file containing email metadata based on predefined criteria.
The experiment concluded that the following models, ChatGPT 3.5,
GPT-3.5-Turbo-Instruct, and ChatGPT, were the most effective in detecting
phishing emails.
|
[
-0.08857021480798721,
-1.0286428928375244,
0.42568856477737427,
0.27715954184532166,
-0.2890056073665619,
0.013277720659971237,
-0.3092375695705414,
-0.6249608993530273,
0.09047652781009674,
0.25013968348503113,
-0.2608950734138489,
-0.19215597212314606,
-0.4826827645301819,
0.19243186712265015,
-0.9675801396369934,
0.8968069553375244,
0.3149413466453552,
0.13833436369895935,
0.422441303730011,
0.5364753603935242,
-0.21393822133541107,
-0.7553560137748718,
-0.6774914860725403,
-0.2035115361213684,
0.6471267938613892,
0.18683704733848572,
0.232341468334198,
0.1154075488448143,
1.0303566455841064,
0.37687551975250244,
0.08977406471967697,
-0.43320998549461365,
-0.7185050845146179,
-0.10915260761976242,
-0.12483169138431549,
-0.6141965985298157,
-0.30972352623939514,
-0.04438696801662445,
0.33382052183151245,
0.20622298121452332,
-0.43370601534843445,
0.32319149374961853,
-0.008157802745699883,
0.23583321273326874,
-0.6476808190345764,
0.013955557718873024,
-0.8823891878128052,
-0.08842898905277252,
-0.556100606918335,
-0.3780987858772278,
-0.9099810123443604,
-0.644519031047821,
0.4617184102535248,
-0.4015140235424042,
-0.0014353175647556782,
0.2180096060037613,
0.2487677037715912,
-0.4708370864391327,
-0.23590849339962006,
-0.46172812581062317,
-0.7900441884994507,
0.7823904752731323,
-0.9234832525253296,
0.25848686695098877,
0.5051084160804749,
0.37879133224487305,
-0.3356887102127075,
-0.5123730301856995,
-0.33870431780815125,
-0.36269721388816833,
0.16614589095115662,
-0.23878708481788635,
-0.5260944366455078,
0.06686229258775711,
0.4408198893070221,
0.5283889174461365,
-0.7559912800788879,
0.2870034873485565,
-0.6263662576675415,
-0.4916839599609375,
0.5606628060340881,
0.144474595785141,
0.5419861674308777,
0.05033652111887932,
0.0010082711232826114,
-0.0723874494433403,
-0.4808925986289978,
0.024125218391418457,
0.5584486126899719,
0.3256901502609253,
-0.31565505266189575,
0.5670794248580933,
-0.03319401293992996,
0.5896202921867371,
0.1960292011499405,
-0.514782726764679,
-0.1800568848848343,
0.01110205240547657,
-0.44039154052734375,
-0.0685465857386589,
0.745705246925354,
0.037010081112384796,
0.8360246419906616,
-0.11002235114574432,
-0.30053600668907166,
0.19692721962928772,
0.5011220574378967,
-0.773904025554657,
-0.17120882868766785,
0.23428156971931458,
-0.657249391078949,
-0.8340572118759155,
0.002024439861997962,
-0.8273473381996155,
-0.8052386045455933,
0.13766755163669586,
0.1580420881509781,
-0.5417991876602173,
-0.3431513011455536,
0.29288914799690247,
-0.1368444859981537,
0.4246673285961151,
0.1943831890821457,
-0.8439556956291199,
0.35813677310943604,
0.7869843244552612,
0.670581042766571,
-0.16717685759067535,
-0.14039510488510132,
-0.4414430558681488,
-0.04859272763133049,
-0.17273904383182526,
0.5161040425300598,
-0.7235420346260071,
-0.27294865250587463,
0.43248793482780457,
-0.17582286894321442,
-0.05571955442428589,
-0.3494628965854645,
0.5680544376373291,
-0.9233188033103943,
0.22509431838989258,
-0.004317911341786385,
-0.5921971201896667,
-0.3161565661430359,
0.4946083128452301,
-0.6952459812164307,
0.7509108781814575,
-0.07664179056882858,
-0.8273848295211792,
-0.006869287230074406,
-0.45511478185653687,
-0.37953031063079834,
0.2288341522216797,
0.2829732894897461,
-0.19901037216186523,
0.6344826817512512,
-0.29276788234710693,
0.5439581274986267,
-0.7036612033843994,
0.17369621992111206,
-0.5747756958007812,
-0.34119123220443726,
0.644346296787262,
-0.6990394592285156,
0.8252252340316772,
-0.027105802670121193,
-0.5552429556846619,
-0.1230628490447998,
-0.5184950828552246,
-0.24649153649806976,
0.5756168365478516,
-0.31498464941978455,
-0.34037142992019653,
-0.35504430532455444,
0.18641653656959534,
0.17177695035934448,
0.11939048767089844,
-0.4745424687862396,
-0.042011357843875885,
-0.5636019110679626,
0.20159032940864563,
0.7989746332168579,
0.0035222589503973722,
0.042896077036857605,
-0.36529579758644104,
0.7338123917579651,
-0.15813732147216797,
0.15162181854248047,
-0.2695827782154083,
-0.545934796333313,
-0.7268149852752686,
-0.053242411464452744,
0.1987239271402359,
0.7032428979873657,
-0.2677239775657654,
0.11281905323266983,
-0.36397457122802734,
-0.8599659204483032,
-0.09807149320840836,
-0.08645207434892654,
0.2668602168560028,
0.17575284838676453,
-0.030124658718705177,
-0.28295522928237915,
-0.20544759929180145,
-0.9490959644317627,
-0.437383770942688,
-0.19006367027759552,
-0.10205881297588348,
0.04502081498503685,
0.6200767755508423,
0.0686558410525322,
0.4858909845352173,
-0.23101849853992462,
0.21417395770549774,
-0.17838364839553833,
0.14876480400562286,
0.060776885598897934,
0.2580406367778778,
0.5933077335357666,
-0.6071339845657349,
-0.6035406589508057,
-0.12416969984769821,
-0.6125295758247375,
0.14013847708702087,
-0.0032446901313960552,
0.2656411826610565,
-0.10142765194177628,
0.12893237173557281,
-0.6279773116111755,
0.467306524515152,
0.3489764630794525,
-0.2032308131456375,
0.7607131600379944,
-0.06565630435943604,
0.3842609226703644,
-0.6684614419937134,
0.17534221708774567,
0.4101931154727936,
0.05055960640311241,
-1.1148221492767334,
0.11648622155189514,
0.2732524871826172,
-0.24272026121616364,
-0.4142017960548401,
0.47874778509140015,
-0.3701583743095398,
0.1433669477701187,
-0.1151837483048439,
0.05025273934006691,
-0.5674560070037842,
0.3305911421775818,
-0.1291513890028,
0.45725390315055847,
0.6051102876663208,
-0.37091299891471863,
0.5001427531242371,
-0.30548879504203796,
-0.6389485001564026,
0.930166482925415,
-0.6685553789138794,
0.3994978368282318,
0.10552560538053513,
0.4567760229110718,
-0.9940434694290161,
-0.6967623829841614,
0.42738351225852966,
-0.4950295686721802,
0.07677459716796875,
0.11667957901954651,
-0.5862411260604858,
-0.4355863034725189,
-0.4530310332775116,
0.541003406047821,
0.4168151319026947,
-0.13363634049892426,
0.7536212801933289,
0.268947571516037,
-0.1823844164609909,
-0.368844598531723,
-0.6752660870552063,
0.28540298342704773,
-0.6001984477043152,
-0.6938377022743225,
-0.03864043205976486,
-0.12293243408203125,
-0.4670262336730957,
-0.7208449840545654,
0.07825126498937607,
-0.18762990832328796,
0.33309945464134216,
0.06533421576023102,
0.26763907074928284,
-0.23184658586978912,
-0.1733616441488266,
-0.7003776431083679,
0.037186142057180405,
0.3080299198627472,
-0.1670355349779129,
0.8401355743408203,
0.15228961408138275,
-0.7568137645721436,
-0.808210551738739,
0.39332830905914307,
0.9259672164916992,
-0.19445545971393585,
0.8877144455909729,
0.34603068232536316,
-0.6957257986068726,
-0.058252736926078796,
-0.9486036896705627,
-0.6022047400474548,
-0.4678405225276947,
0.15469937026500702,
-0.16694413125514984,
-0.7138957977294922,
0.6512286067008972,
-0.050361115485429764,
0.10892649739980698,
0.06217145174741745,
0.48901239037513733,
0.2672598659992218,
0.84123694896698,
0.6219653487205505,
-0.44595959782600403,
0.5775132775306702,
0.09288748353719711,
0.6194955706596375,
-0.19121964275836945,
-0.3285631537437439,
-0.5814411640167236,
0.1012868881225586,
-0.5278654098510742,
-0.15639464557170868,
0.04419412091374397,
-0.25619515776634216,
-0.09480810165405273,
0.31932175159454346,
-0.1956666260957718,
0.15769697725772858,
0.4966351091861725,
0.11876844614744186,
0.23676668107509613,
0.3428448438644409,
-0.053366757929325104,
0.017535677179694176,
-0.5032441020011902,
-0.5383100509643555,
1.339279294013977,
0.42111650109291077,
0.5336741209030151,
0.4135695993900299,
0.49696236848831177,
0.4457947909832001,
0.3960656523704529,
-0.707863986492157,
0.6815081834793091,
0.22964729368686676,
-0.8010181188583374,
-0.27621957659721375,
-0.09067824482917786,
-1.0333510637283325,
0.001841553021222353,
-0.3222813010215759,
-1.156403660774231,
-0.28116029500961304,
0.15907292068004608,
-0.38969936966896057,
0.46143803000450134,
-0.521514892578125,
0.578857958316803,
-0.15744344890117645,
-0.22400327026844025,
-0.48155859112739563,
-0.37090057134628296,
0.6436402797698975,
-0.7456021904945374,
0.4476538598537445,
0.11126398295164108,
0.22387728095054626,
0.6367120742797852,
-0.04296104609966278,
0.9984397888183594,
0.1646767109632492,
-0.38809195160865784,
0.0930870994925499,
0.1462768167257309,
1.1321260929107666,
-0.41503605246543884,
-0.13545049726963043,
0.020724227651953697,
-0.36225488781929016,
-0.32658079266548157,
-0.5887699127197266,
0.5369020104408264,
-0.11959631741046906,
-0.4869269132614136,
-0.45811593532562256,
-0.26862189173698425,
-0.08783520013093948,
0.2041788101196289,
0.1825007051229477,
0.3942541480064392,
-0.3802128732204437,
0.4014669954776764,
0.8228194713592529,
-0.27936962246894836,
0.36923348903656006,
0.7022066712379456,
-0.12064249068498611,
-0.2510336637496948,
0.7533514499664307,
-0.11348061263561249,
0.17060965299606323,
0.30463966727256775,
0.22702349722385406,
-0.003442638088017702,
-0.7914442420005798,
0.020053889602422714,
0.4487200975418091,
-0.5250604152679443,
-0.07745731621980667,
-0.41255125403404236,
-0.29963529109954834,
-0.6410127878189087,
-0.18736915290355682,
-0.027272963896393776,
-0.05190754681825638,
0.14186374843120575,
0.06484372168779373,
0.2869851887226105,
0.7156883478164673,
0.33476489782333374,
0.676068127155304,
-0.6441298127174377,
0.11868199706077576,
0.32585057616233826,
0.1436191350221634,
0.3006753921508789,
-0.6887080669403076,
-0.09558860212564468,
-0.05917888879776001,
0.08563501387834549,
-1.2578340768814087,
0.14563919603824615,
-0.38690346479415894,
0.602466881275177,
0.5115323662757874,
-0.1527842879295349,
0.31512007117271423,
-0.2747761011123657,
0.6647993922233582,
0.3080540895462036,
-0.7166310548782349,
0.44441843032836914,
-0.7368022799491882,
0.10665763169527054,
0.20630088448524475,
0.5546958446502686,
-0.7733968496322632,
-0.37279507517814636,
-0.8353531360626221,
-0.4985167384147644,
0.41014137864112854,
0.45554211735725403,
0.12356860190629959,
0.1682371348142624,
0.17507877945899963,
-0.03620056435465813,
0.15340815484523773,
-1.1357553005218506,
-0.14176775515079498,
0.4968888461589813,
-0.20136119425296783,
0.16518719494342804,
-0.5820173621177673,
0.03593122214078903,
0.2292388379573822,
0.5913339853286743,
0.3056644797325134,
0.12725991010665894,
-0.5034018158912659,
-0.018034571781754494,
0.07927874475717545,
0.36568698287010193,
0.6630356907844543,
0.6666749715805054,
0.18035408854484558,
0.05745043605566025,
0.23158986866474152,
-0.8122968077659607,
0.1948988288640976,
-0.021904777735471725,
-0.19302479922771454,
-0.15305805206298828,
0.6614412665367126,
0.242050901055336,
0.36466753482818604,
-0.6906934976577759,
0.6699258685112,
-0.013745991513133049,
0.09617619961500168,
-0.5151956081390381,
0.11502034962177277,
0.04344125837087631,
0.24659936130046844,
0.3742126524448395,
-0.3815334737300873,
0.20399001240730286,
-0.33905187249183655,
-0.15341800451278687,
0.7427724003791809,
-0.12830057740211487,
-0.2918158173561096,
0.1776171773672104,
0.3643732964992523,
-0.8050779104232788,
0.6517266035079956,
0.08002420514822006,
-0.6299988627433777,
0.48119890689849854,
0.7055975794792175,
0.9620563983917236,
-0.7541555762290955,
0.18856780230998993,
0.24138619005680084,
0.6077430248260498,
-0.4015709459781647,
0.08195190131664276,
0.035617973655462265,
-0.5456161499023438,
-0.12168485671281815,
-0.5056116580963135,
-0.3165886700153351,
0.5450831055641174,
-0.49309104681015015,
0.3551132380962372,
-0.4189265966415405,
-0.2889257073402405,
0.29386845231056213,
-0.24662211537361145,
-0.6868211627006531,
-0.04330478236079216,
0.24319115281105042,
1.0919767618179321,
-0.9381447434425354,
0.5881741642951965,
0.3637225925922394,
-0.071393221616745,
-0.8306986689567566,
0.1275361180305481,
0.652525007724762,
-0.6957511901855469,
0.42512327432632446,
0.19252416491508484,
-0.1403951346874237,
0.03878530487418175,
-0.6436687111854553,
-0.7181926369667053,
0.763518750667572,
0.42292481660842896,
-0.6551792025566101,
0.050441719591617584,
0.4772953391075134,
0.47646811604499817,
-0.29558229446411133,
0.2554531693458557,
0.5994203686714172,
0.4761940836906433,
-0.08207216113805771,
-1.1823444366455078,
-0.03814645856618881,
-0.3601609766483307,
-0.17035987973213196,
0.23556338250637054,
-0.5340666174888611,
0.5862407088279724,
0.24052686989307404,
-0.030878862366080284,
-0.01570775732398033,
0.3963989317417145,
0.6501616835594177,
0.09267614781856537,
0.4280047118663788,
0.23133450746536255,
0.7788148522377014,
0.11809710413217545,
0.8583482503890991,
-0.40919050574302673,
0.25411444902420044,
0.680424690246582,
-0.09368764609098434,
0.8137490153312683,
0.390374094247818,
-0.15477871894836426,
0.26639577746391296,
0.6543840169906616,
-0.08756591379642487,
0.24247340857982635,
0.6198063492774963,
-0.3619369864463806,
-0.1570235639810562,
0.10027502477169037,
-0.26375076174736023,
0.6534669995307922,
0.33541765809059143,
-0.5737019777297974,
-0.03414471819996834,
0.058744873851537704,
0.41491109132766724,
-0.18491920828819275,
-0.17659147083759308,
0.42391860485076904,
0.04346645250916481,
-0.637914776802063,
0.3144592344760895,
0.17233964800834656,
0.791674792766571,
-0.7206478118896484,
0.21507246792316437,
-0.10415277630090714,
0.20267251133918762,
0.0007657530368305743,
-0.21435043215751648,
-0.19524575769901276,
0.31295058131217957,
0.20982792973518372,
0.08946231752634048,
0.799592137336731,
-0.08809228241443634,
-0.6527530550956726,
0.06513269245624542,
0.11406442523002625,
0.30462178587913513,
-0.33912453055381775,
-0.7291889786720276,
0.18808208405971527,
-0.03815180063247681,
-0.44954490661621094,
0.31346607208251953,
0.45411214232444763,
0.06643564999103546,
0.9699724912643433,
0.6226165890693665,
0.15113086998462677,
-0.14285781979560852,
-0.1005159541964531,
0.5357526540756226,
-0.6346754431724548,
-0.5253544449806213,
-1.236507773399353,
0.3996984362602234,
-0.5614556074142456,
-0.040437158197164536,
1.1257004737854004,
0.6570528745651245,
0.661550760269165,
-0.06239334121346474,
0.7879897952079773,
0.25699156522750854,
0.3273729979991913,
-0.24492399394512177,
0.42433661222457886,
-0.11329960823059082,
0.5030120015144348,
-0.563033401966095,
-0.917874276638031,
-0.2351093292236328,
0.45630520582199097,
-0.5664168000221252,
0.2612268328666687,
0.5564636588096619,
0.7513811588287354,
-0.19401651620864868,
0.34445375204086304,
0.28243452310562134,
-0.02322787046432495,
0.3728129267692566,
0.46057605743408203,
0.8764203786849976,
-0.33144500851631165,
0.5949498414993286,
-0.15615658462047577,
-0.43720367550849915,
-0.6367532014846802,
-0.7660676836967468,
-1.1942123174667358,
-0.2689042389392853,
-0.14617177844047546,
-0.33586087822914124,
-0.04157032072544098,
0.7735938429832458,
0.6019211411476135,
-0.7856632471084595,
-0.35273006558418274,
0.23982398211956024,
-0.3469804525375366,
0.2606964707374573,
-0.13344907760620117,
-0.04627418518066406,
0.12610085308551788,
-0.4505707025527954,
0.1541784703731537,
0.48342037200927734,
0.4067963659763336,
-0.5452589392662048,
0.34274762868881226,
-0.022379448637366295,
0.6413307189941406,
0.5518213510513306,
0.22341138124465942,
-0.9554029107093811,
-0.23910708725452423,
0.3243906795978546,
-0.41711798310279846,
-0.3641543984413147,
1.0358046293258667,
-0.15386070311069489,
0.11601025611162186,
0.4937567412853241,
0.5287317037582397,
0.380068302154541,
-0.2003457099199295,
0.644444465637207,
-0.015603950247168541,
0.051923830062150955,
0.22112369537353516,
0.32217931747436523,
0.24866342544555664,
-0.3553451895713806,
0.4170117676258087,
0.1707414984703064,
-0.4564739465713501,
-0.8046813607215881,
-0.0061135319992899895,
-0.7047376036643982,
-0.2651097774505615,
1.2268688678741455,
-0.1506837159395218,
-0.07955970615148544,
-0.28987500071525574,
-0.00822385773062706,
-0.15708836913108826,
-0.2670312821865082,
1.23567795753479,
1.1074273586273193,
0.29399341344833374,
0.006166400387883186,
-0.7439984083175659,
0.4933379292488098,
0.107345350086689,
-0.8935333490371704,
0.06636463105678558,
0.4946715533733368,
0.19475458562374115,
0.1968654841184616,
0.6973263621330261,
-0.030278582125902176,
0.3911135494709015,
-0.18058821558952332,
-0.3831009566783905,
0.4176505208015442,
-0.11199381947517395,
-0.3747735917568207,
0.5019398331642151,
-0.08460438251495361,
0.2390996366739273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02326v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02326v1
|
Evaluating LLMs for Hardware Design and Test
| 2024-04-23T18:55:49 | 2024-04-23T18:55:49 |
Jason Blocklove, Siddharth Garg, Ramesh Karri, Hammond Pearce
|
cs.AR
|
cs.AR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated capabilities for producing
code in Hardware Description Languages (HDLs). However, most of the focus
remains on their abilities to write functional code, not test code. The
hardware design process consists of both design and test, and so eschewing
validation and verification leaves considerable potential benefit unexplored,
given that a design and test framework may allow for progress towards full
automation of the digital design pipeline. In this work, we perform one of the
first studies exploring how a LLM can both design and test hardware modules
from provided specifications. Using a suite of 8 representative benchmarks, we
examined the capabilities and limitations of the state-of-the-art
conversational LLMs when producing Verilog for functional and verification
purposes. We taped out the benchmarks on a Skywater 130nm shuttle and received
the functional chip.
|
[
-0.5740382075309753,
-0.9393957257270813,
0.6459428071975708,
0.29147836565971375,
-0.4364042282104492,
0.07245286554098129,
-0.17891362309455872,
-0.6303709149360657,
-0.2298826426267624,
0.6250676512718201,
-0.6655300259590149,
-0.29770907759666443,
-0.06738486140966415,
0.25911930203437805,
-0.2455032467842102,
0.6378157138824463,
-0.5908429026603699,
-0.23293526470661163,
-0.3728589713573456,
0.06678610295057297,
-0.5082213878631592,
-0.7552933096885681,
-0.326423704624176,
-0.28734925389289856,
0.2121734470129013,
-0.011173112317919731,
0.29825359582901,
0.4518987536430359,
0.6766498684883118,
0.3074783682823181,
-0.21448951959609985,
0.13763859868049622,
-0.20777946710586548,
0.19135934114456177,
0.3298652768135071,
-0.35939908027648926,
-0.5965390205383301,
-0.2742573618888855,
0.6138024926185608,
0.5260790586471558,
0.15180069208145142,
0.6706377863883972,
0.20824699103832245,
0.3745657503604889,
-0.36183273792266846,
0.26657113432884216,
-0.5333539843559265,
0.25081539154052734,
-0.23813089728355408,
-0.42638158798217773,
-0.640953540802002,
-0.3360031247138977,
-0.3127458989620209,
-0.26882338523864746,
-0.23952969908714294,
0.4685700237751007,
0.8411158323287964,
0.24729815125465393,
-0.5285848379135132,
-0.2529049515724182,
-0.9159970879554749,
0.9557719230651855,
-0.7070984244346619,
0.6590612530708313,
0.2529052197933197,
0.4254207909107208,
-0.21070736646652222,
-0.5659034252166748,
-0.2400789111852646,
-0.6517532467842102,
-0.02025158889591694,
-0.13026955723762512,
-0.13526834547519684,
0.18148374557495117,
0.5491009950637817,
0.6586080193519592,
-0.6560180187225342,
0.12850996851921082,
-0.6736728549003601,
-0.35190877318382263,
0.4466765224933624,
0.2935309112071991,
0.12490304559469223,
-0.14868642389774323,
-0.7168437838554382,
0.14536842703819275,
-1.1509006023406982,
-0.1185922920703888,
0.5140914916992188,
0.24406500160694122,
-0.03106779232621193,
0.808295488357544,
-0.19578537344932556,
0.7953442931175232,
-0.5289325714111328,
0.05929870158433914,
0.22772668302059174,
-0.4857443571090698,
-0.6066779494285583,
-0.05687178671360016,
0.5867474675178528,
0.2706662714481354,
-0.045291468501091,
-0.07563386857509613,
-0.6482958793640137,
0.008789842016994953,
0.4637225270271301,
-0.9704496264457703,
0.3169601261615753,
0.33046063780784607,
-0.45147043466567993,
-0.2899552285671234,
-0.3014404773712158,
-0.40023550391197205,
-0.27225786447525024,
-0.4139038920402527,
0.6107869744300842,
-0.014055154286324978,
-0.1451473832130432,
0.21431568264961243,
-0.11316073685884476,
0.3896840512752533,
-0.056211575865745544,
-0.7247868776321411,
0.42578640580177307,
0.9172938466072083,
0.5822438597679138,
-0.15055185556411743,
-0.03239458426833153,
-0.30349746346473694,
-0.08215919137001038,
-0.3988398015499115,
0.6243670582771301,
-0.06943237036466599,
-0.6195802688598633,
0.13031980395317078,
-0.020603325217962265,
0.35419028997421265,
-0.9071472883224487,
0.32596299052238464,
-0.7678309082984924,
-0.3651381731033325,
-0.3389469385147095,
-0.4159899055957794,
0.07466758042573929,
0.5322611927986145,
-0.4758130609989166,
0.964108943939209,
0.28085798025131226,
-0.4117364287376404,
0.3494996428489685,
-0.27494215965270996,
-0.8420305848121643,
0.05466949939727783,
-0.595933198928833,
-0.28727245330810547,
0.3471005856990814,
-0.3906363546848297,
0.13860037922859192,
-0.4798867106437683,
0.29173386096954346,
-0.6185553669929504,
-0.7809881567955017,
0.6830636858940125,
-0.41426458954811096,
0.5137627124786377,
0.10163901746273041,
-0.5361177325248718,
-0.13721127808094025,
-0.7335009574890137,
0.1240774393081665,
-0.2796638309955597,
-0.8471938967704773,
0.12849082052707672,
0.09475313872098923,
0.07771027833223343,
-0.025467311963438988,
0.18974223732948303,
-0.8644912838935852,
-0.05372046306729317,
-0.31839603185653687,
0.47121214866638184,
0.9432262182235718,
-0.3511391878128052,
-0.17347028851509094,
-0.482626348733902,
0.6787852644920349,
-0.3714727461338043,
0.3411251902580261,
-0.19241757690906525,
-0.5090984106063843,
-0.8001595735549927,
-0.26567959785461426,
0.09008947759866714,
0.4284760653972626,
-0.4041432738304138,
0.4230559170246124,
0.09108927845954895,
-0.0976165160536766,
-0.32249295711517334,
0.2711533308029175,
0.5288967490196228,
0.44708749651908875,
0.06802377849817276,
-0.33890482783317566,
-0.8354011178016663,
-1.1566195487976074,
0.18911944329738617,
-0.40994325280189514,
-0.43564075231552124,
0.619385302066803,
0.27354034781455994,
-0.21285106241703033,
0.48517000675201416,
-0.4104289710521698,
0.09163061529397964,
-0.20679813623428345,
-0.18069730699062347,
0.47955724596977234,
0.14640283584594727,
0.3398725092411041,
-0.24729935824871063,
-0.1247759461402893,
0.4505009055137634,
-0.8154406547546387,
-0.12705959379673004,
0.3556172251701355,
0.07588181644678116,
0.449123740196228,
0.5618385076522827,
-0.6268553137779236,
0.5443628430366516,
0.49605950713157654,
0.05069476366043091,
0.7013558745384216,
-0.3548746109008789,
0.47973111271858215,
-0.7000993490219116,
0.1944146305322647,
-0.2018497884273529,
-0.06188986450433731,
-0.29330986738204956,
-0.019635165110230446,
-0.03554925695061684,
-0.21074894070625305,
-0.47975388169288635,
0.6288268566131592,
-0.2802560031414032,
-0.6655976176261902,
-0.4701952636241913,
-0.13288243114948273,
-0.00010515188478166237,
0.19976919889450073,
-0.2590188980102539,
0.8654954433441162,
0.36612963676452637,
-0.9067057967185974,
0.24675080180168152,
-0.15207453072071075,
-0.5718653798103333,
0.6515758633613586,
-1.1509850025177002,
0.07419046759605408,
0.05880222097039223,
-0.19793276488780975,
-1.4993473291397095,
-0.01774468459188938,
-0.008750726468861103,
-0.13689902424812317,
0.13382606208324432,
-0.08245362341403961,
-0.7026795148849487,
-0.6381715536117554,
-0.21956291794776917,
0.4685077965259552,
0.7813252210617065,
-0.43324267864227295,
0.5618398785591125,
0.5161358118057251,
-0.14509256184101105,
-0.05909135937690735,
-0.9667299389839172,
-0.17412391304969788,
-0.19670279324054718,
-0.787241518497467,
0.4604347050189972,
-0.39381682872772217,
-0.41466566920280457,
-0.3975073993206024,
-0.21267017722129822,
-0.22330518066883087,
0.4403478503227234,
0.46250098943710327,
0.7299504280090332,
-0.6457091569900513,
0.19169627130031586,
-0.07160274684429169,
-0.2175384908914566,
0.28544437885284424,
-0.09834733605384827,
0.5285566449165344,
-0.3464239835739136,
-0.6409493088722229,
-0.5453799962997437,
0.16604116559028625,
0.4466524124145508,
-0.0012105440255254507,
-0.08403423428535461,
0.28193846344947815,
-0.2813801169395447,
-0.5283243060112,
-0.5493609309196472,
-0.24172891676425934,
-0.6457470655441284,
0.4485699236392975,
-0.5625239610671997,
-1.0379242897033691,
0.37848520278930664,
0.018614361062645912,
0.3115887939929962,
-0.02320563979446888,
0.5221884846687317,
-0.12400256842374802,
0.6658523678779602,
0.5342525839805603,
0.15918730199337006,
0.02795577608048916,
0.2205733060836792,
0.46271610260009766,
-0.8832240700721741,
0.11020437628030777,
-0.6377236843109131,
-0.4278109073638916,
-0.5780196785926819,
-0.29044103622436523,
0.2894694209098816,
-0.5272718667984009,
-0.37065595388412476,
0.3947228789329529,
-0.42364418506622314,
0.49396535754203796,
0.26195433735847473,
0.13152778148651123,
0.26007866859436035,
0.1648591309785843,
-0.2323860079050064,
-0.13050688803195953,
-0.20702317357063293,
-0.7150166630744934,
1.1490274667739868,
0.36542293429374695,
0.8685396313667297,
-0.013204455375671387,
0.5046934485435486,
0.33361950516700745,
0.4401734471321106,
-0.7645100355148315,
0.7960048913955688,
-0.28882738947868347,
-0.7624513506889343,
0.04765552654862404,
-0.3998582065105438,
-0.7684717774391174,
0.005896951537579298,
0.5471482872962952,
-0.6973637342453003,
-0.19615155458450317,
0.1500832587480545,
-0.4869738221168518,
0.15908414125442505,
-0.383828729391098,
0.6603924036026001,
-0.57001793384552,
-0.22952722012996674,
-0.21738608181476593,
-0.09021306782960892,
0.6516190767288208,
-0.01833439990878105,
0.2645811140537262,
-0.04348571226000786,
-0.021344732493162155,
0.528598427772522,
-0.1448349952697754,
0.7645898461341858,
0.28847765922546387,
-0.14072948694229126,
0.2129482626914978,
0.26953592896461487,
-0.2093486189842224,
0.06685606390237808,
-0.37700140476226807,
-0.22865061461925507,
0.09791575372219086,
-0.10406224429607391,
-0.19210942089557648,
0.79158616065979,
-0.6244524121284485,
-0.7217699885368347,
0.014309709891676903,
-0.3344690799713135,
-0.40434741973876953,
0.08499077707529068,
-0.3739684224128723,
0.7392674684524536,
-0.19417892396450043,
0.3465895354747772,
0.7712512016296387,
-0.44246894121170044,
0.32789766788482666,
0.39108824729919434,
-0.5922116637229919,
-0.4518759846687317,
0.7693995833396912,
-0.16901832818984985,
0.49296921491622925,
0.17535720765590668,
0.20143398642539978,
-0.2276044636964798,
-0.5892680287361145,
-0.464374303817749,
0.18987920880317688,
-0.7786653637886047,
-0.045470017939805984,
-0.0850214883685112,
-0.48607155680656433,
-0.08641223609447479,
-0.09905824065208435,
-0.5434191823005676,
-0.14915233850479126,
-0.2459387183189392,
-0.07491609454154968,
0.017754148691892624,
1.1294217109680176,
0.36825302243232727,
0.0745045468211174,
-0.4652077853679657,
0.1842692792415619,
0.3276706635951996,
0.42199867963790894,
-0.10769183933734894,
-0.7314383387565613,
0.11883065104484558,
-0.1755698025226593,
-0.466266006231308,
-0.39641323685646057,
-0.07382049411535263,
-0.19177182018756866,
0.9016302824020386,
0.12533226609230042,
-0.14872421324253082,
0.6248253583908081,
-0.2817634046077728,
0.6789100170135498,
-0.17307566106319427,
-0.8670120239257812,
0.49362942576408386,
-0.10615313053131104,
0.16041457653045654,
0.4307910203933716,
0.1528109610080719,
-0.21511869132518768,
-0.09685292840003967,
-0.3207402527332306,
-0.4227520525455475,
0.28399208188056946,
-0.0107988640666008,
0.3447498679161072,
0.18840523064136505,
0.413950115442276,
0.18458101153373718,
0.4331803619861603,
-0.5094504356384277,
-0.17174044251441956,
0.34838682413101196,
-0.02916548401117325,
0.15890012681484222,
-0.28205418586730957,
-0.18259158730506897,
0.009460985660552979,
0.4835146367549896,
-0.005970728117972612,
0.40899407863616943,
0.06133601441979408,
0.06546060740947723,
0.19645772874355316,
0.1930769830942154,
0.8442947268486023,
0.7961727380752563,
-0.31225547194480896,
0.3091704249382019,
0.06450358033180237,
-0.13442692160606384,
0.27242526412010193,
0.02786107547581196,
-0.19125622510910034,
0.09957823902368546,
0.13524356484413147,
0.7241941690444946,
0.5683289170265198,
-0.6937273144721985,
0.18880417943000793,
-0.30705997347831726,
-0.4683266878128052,
0.05285359546542168,
0.07140445709228516,
0.14684583246707916,
0.23694083094596863,
0.08583036810159683,
-0.3806210160255432,
-0.022315645590424538,
-0.6357918381690979,
0.5209208130836487,
0.6322471499443054,
-0.27211397886276245,
-0.4821048974990845,
0.6222828030586243,
0.18536725640296936,
-0.46408742666244507,
0.7032538056373596,
-0.2316455841064453,
-0.27825722098350525,
0.8655306100845337,
0.6302409768104553,
0.822944164276123,
0.18702197074890137,
0.09244196861982346,
0.2571299076080322,
0.699600875377655,
0.368533194065094,
0.6726573705673218,
-0.2598511576652527,
-0.30896446108818054,
-0.39907148480415344,
-0.8854213953018188,
-0.6146513223648071,
0.09496151655912399,
-0.4056377708911896,
0.4581197500228882,
-0.8776911497116089,
-0.5136500597000122,
-0.08551697432994843,
0.020342569798231125,
-0.6430591344833374,
-0.015027711167931557,
0.35808300971984863,
0.8865487575531006,
-0.5135416984558105,
0.5951555371284485,
0.5811229944229126,
-0.029937049373984337,
-0.6061257123947144,
-0.48703980445861816,
-0.0596030056476593,
-0.9596187472343445,
1.0136183500289917,
0.3813600540161133,
0.048499081283807755,
-0.28258082270622253,
-0.020772697404026985,
-0.6758387684822083,
1.1788287162780762,
0.46695923805236816,
-0.4315844178199768,
0.48153242468833923,
0.5042552947998047,
0.4388188123703003,
-0.3249557316303253,
0.45173925161361694,
0.37350431084632874,
0.4769110679626465,
0.29668912291526794,
-1.1003845930099487,
0.18151134252548218,
-0.08135399222373962,
0.11727886646986008,
0.06334107369184494,
-0.6033940315246582,
1.0204136371612549,
-0.0048104845918715,
-0.1478220373392105,
0.2665776014328003,
0.4529946744441986,
0.7864558100700378,
0.11860153079032898,
0.3595605790615082,
0.24431529641151428,
0.7362119555473328,
-0.13031063973903656,
1.0950236320495605,
-0.4348503351211548,
0.07843998819589615,
0.7893345952033997,
-0.8836488723754883,
1.0606578588485718,
0.733073890209198,
-0.510947048664093,
0.13502506911754608,
0.6191738843917847,
-0.06882541626691818,
0.16580085456371307,
0.8787865042686462,
-0.42409366369247437,
-0.25864237546920776,
-0.09433666616678238,
-0.3607988655567169,
0.11300558596849442,
0.04247845709323883,
-0.3329443633556366,
-0.10207077860832214,
-0.13192547857761383,
-0.005052997265011072,
-0.36707618832588196,
-0.05734102055430412,
0.2865237295627594,
0.19890627264976501,
-0.6798205375671387,
0.6591092348098755,
-0.06378325819969177,
0.5553416013717651,
-0.4845771789550781,
0.17412376403808594,
-0.35323140025138855,
0.5322009921073914,
0.07407314330339432,
-0.7659391164779663,
0.49758073687553406,
-0.12121075391769409,
0.16077786684036255,
-0.39738696813583374,
0.8205838203430176,
0.14262008666992188,
-0.5591035485267639,
0.16042956709861755,
0.20005039870738983,
0.34756946563720703,
0.2056000679731369,
-0.3240475058555603,
1.0557712316513062,
-0.08219122886657715,
-0.2426408976316452,
0.43838709592819214,
-0.00834453385323286,
0.2541698217391968,
0.8157220482826233,
0.4948776960372925,
0.07967185229063034,
0.12066854536533356,
0.002785904798656702,
0.9011694192886353,
-0.6105523109436035,
-0.061954472213983536,
-0.9657467007637024,
0.46039438247680664,
0.10657209903001785,
-0.46880415081977844,
0.8197944164276123,
0.7953584790229797,
0.7446838021278381,
-0.19696415960788727,
0.8892756104469299,
0.058040767908096313,
-0.21875931322574615,
-0.5538205504417419,
0.34653523564338684,
-0.4478137195110321,
0.5023233294487,
0.20597076416015625,
-0.5804505944252014,
-0.25536778569221497,
0.34812143445014954,
0.06503606587648392,
0.020115764811635017,
0.8134347796440125,
1.125081181526184,
-0.09484203159809113,
0.20679229497909546,
0.4666129946708679,
0.19905295968055725,
0.6019504070281982,
0.7511810064315796,
1.210096001625061,
-0.5289742946624756,
0.6562725305557251,
-0.2275703251361847,
-0.3085644543170929,
-0.14709404110908508,
-1.0185819864273071,
-1.1911312341690063,
-0.14954052865505219,
-0.40822833776474,
-0.15105962753295898,
0.04626128077507019,
0.24120792746543884,
0.7252597808837891,
-0.4955345094203949,
-0.820682168006897,
0.003256153780966997,
0.26603269577026367,
0.04291943460702896,
-0.08056870102882385,
-0.07453053444623947,
-0.3646141290664673,
-0.27303311228752136,
0.5340748429298401,
0.6354115605354309,
0.15727193653583527,
-0.7948789596557617,
-0.008234917186200619,
0.34592896699905396,
0.19544515013694763,
0.6802834868431091,
0.07785622030496597,
-0.6816729307174683,
-0.25410738587379456,
0.4619569778442383,
-0.137850821018219,
-0.025316134095191956,
0.8222097754478455,
-0.6314388513565063,
0.2182149440050125,
0.703782856464386,
0.8331813812255859,
0.3546537160873413,
-0.35660967230796814,
0.7318307757377625,
-0.3499022126197815,
-0.16314564645290375,
-0.17333002388477325,
0.45137837529182434,
0.17355990409851074,
-0.06644387543201447,
0.07886652648448944,
0.1150294616818428,
-0.9221729636192322,
-1.1961342096328735,
0.20605914294719696,
-0.9704496264457703,
0.09887886047363281,
1.2676037549972534,
-0.19373469054698944,
-0.6367117166519165,
-0.01970203034579754,
-0.31192153692245483,
-0.2793245315551758,
0.2721095681190491,
0.6941779255867004,
0.7976915836334229,
-0.10059141367673874,
0.252284437417984,
-0.9013957977294922,
0.21599476039409637,
0.17322884500026703,
-1.0303038358688354,
0.27370744943618774,
0.2796250581741333,
0.3108147978782654,
-0.045083820819854736,
0.5746356844902039,
-0.15278834104537964,
0.4268796443939209,
0.007676186040043831,
-0.03600345179438591,
-0.13437773287296295,
-0.15952882170677185,
-0.16174881160259247,
0.21675996482372284,
0.3838194012641907,
-0.28548574447631836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03695v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03695v1
|
Evaluating Large Language Models for Material Selection
| 2024-04-23T18:53:33 | 2024-04-23T18:53:33 |
Daniele Grandi, Yash Patawari Jain, Allin Groom, Brandon Cramer, Christopher McComb
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Material selection is a crucial step in conceptual design due to its
significant impact on the functionality, aesthetics, manufacturability, and
sustainability impact of the final product. This study investigates the use of
Large Language Models (LLMs) for material selection in the product design
process and compares the performance of LLMs against expert choices for various
design scenarios. By collecting a dataset of expert material preferences, the
study provides a basis for evaluating how well LLMs can align with expert
recommendations through prompt engineering and hyperparameter tuning. The
divergence between LLM and expert recommendations is measured across different
model configurations, prompt strategies, and temperature settings. This
approach allows for a detailed analysis of factors influencing the LLMs'
effectiveness in recommending materials. The results from this study highlight
two failure modes, and identify parallel prompting as a useful
prompt-engineering method when using LLMs for material selection. The findings
further suggest that, while LLMs can provide valuable assistance, their
recommendations often vary significantly from those of human experts. This
discrepancy underscores the need for further research into how LLMs can be
better tailored to replicate expert decision-making in material selection. This
work contributes to the growing body of knowledge on how LLMs can be integrated
into the design process, offering insights into their current limitations and
potential for future improvements.
|
[
-0.7583554983139038,
-0.6934742331504822,
0.8628724217414856,
0.32188552618026733,
-0.4558495283126831,
0.2512761652469635,
-0.4703027606010437,
-0.4050609767436981,
0.10985101014375687,
0.1526438444852829,
-0.44448134303092957,
-0.3524746894836426,
-0.21587596833705902,
0.40757399797439575,
0.03580600023269653,
0.5612753033638,
-0.5343212485313416,
0.31248074769973755,
-0.2813981771469116,
0.07094059884548187,
-0.9731979370117188,
-0.15242046117782593,
-0.6880678534507751,
-0.5367109179496765,
0.7425845861434937,
0.3571757674217224,
0.8959081768989563,
0.4111807346343994,
0.347856730222702,
0.3485628366470337,
-0.3696374297142029,
0.24778996407985687,
-0.23906309902668,
0.20205146074295044,
-0.39455756545066833,
-0.3733583092689514,
-0.4529969394207001,
0.11225682497024536,
0.2653011381626129,
0.5498523116111755,
0.05290545895695686,
0.25976207852363586,
0.26144352555274963,
0.5499119162559509,
-0.5528125166893005,
0.05803665891289711,
-0.4806029796600342,
0.32503318786621094,
-0.2095065414905548,
-0.2998986840248108,
-0.5259292125701904,
-0.122243732213974,
0.14325208961963654,
-0.3925725519657135,
0.05216911435127258,
0.575343668460846,
0.5465412139892578,
0.04828581213951111,
0.01812828704714775,
-0.38782089948654175,
-0.7906023263931274,
1.0166456699371338,
-0.7449977993965149,
0.7389107942581177,
0.4987007975578308,
0.2106887251138687,
-0.2476034313440323,
-0.20607143640518188,
-0.4722970128059387,
-0.6160297393798828,
-0.07901625335216522,
0.09408483654260635,
0.6068934202194214,
0.24653935432434082,
0.23419654369354248,
0.4738125503063202,
-0.7294096946716309,
0.4859308898448944,
-0.26348480582237244,
-0.27585092186927795,
0.46051374077796936,
0.30071982741355896,
0.1935196965932846,
-0.17644810676574707,
-0.46475109457969666,
-0.04183703288435936,
-0.5120964646339417,
-0.3874610960483551,
0.32792675495147705,
0.39339593052864075,
-0.01877375692129135,
0.5712230205535889,
-0.1973855048418045,
0.82837975025177,
-0.33441901206970215,
-0.25447243452072144,
0.24508583545684814,
-0.40989089012145996,
-0.24100571870803833,
-0.1436026692390442,
0.9029703140258789,
0.5573015213012695,
0.27466410398483276,
-0.013286605477333069,
-0.4672432541847229,
-0.4667184352874756,
0.023426663130521774,
-0.7786380052566528,
0.14291535317897797,
0.18209761381149292,
-0.6811923980712891,
0.018736718222498894,
-0.12037217617034912,
-0.7323459386825562,
-0.62511146068573,
-0.6491795778274536,
0.11218332499265671,
0.14629654586315155,
-0.3547350764274597,
0.5754653811454773,
-0.434848815202713,
-0.12002136558294296,
0.16900892555713654,
-0.9178674817085266,
0.04932806268334389,
0.503909707069397,
1.043444037437439,
-0.29514992237091064,
-0.2980400621891022,
-0.09246335178613663,
0.07330238819122314,
-0.6241630911827087,
0.9294416904449463,
-0.5729399919509888,
-0.8255162835121155,
-0.028846055269241333,
-0.18347971141338348,
0.08299893885850906,
-0.7809929847717285,
0.8890853524208069,
-0.5847349166870117,
0.06054800748825073,
-0.7118667364120483,
-0.18139797449111938,
-0.042414452880620956,
0.0462423712015152,
-0.7802051901817322,
0.7161616683006287,
0.1829650104045868,
-0.7785077095031738,
0.6427816152572632,
-0.2587614059448242,
-0.2899812161922455,
0.2762741446495056,
-0.48434966802597046,
-0.3984464108943939,
0.2663130760192871,
-0.10321519523859024,
0.580500066280365,
-0.9416055083274841,
0.16849364340305328,
-0.7436837553977966,
-0.24318484961986542,
0.2764669358730316,
-0.4053388833999634,
0.2010490447282791,
0.3898046016693115,
-0.1593189686536789,
0.06563328206539154,
-0.4277819097042084,
-0.2083491086959839,
0.2143191397190094,
-0.7036397457122803,
-0.3200944662094116,
0.13175494968891144,
0.28013259172439575,
0.2952064275741577,
0.2704979479312897,
-0.5980128049850464,
-0.034978799521923065,
-0.10040049999952316,
0.3310266435146332,
1.1406331062316895,
-0.12168900668621063,
0.38977569341659546,
-0.5171398520469666,
0.5792027115821838,
-0.48363086581230164,
0.17731593549251556,
-0.007440302520990372,
-0.20436991751194,
-0.8045164942741394,
0.04005635902285576,
0.236771821975708,
0.3039763271808624,
-0.6658631563186646,
0.17444437742233276,
0.31384024024009705,
-0.3275648355484009,
0.013571232557296753,
0.4800892770290375,
0.3326622247695923,
0.43008777499198914,
0.09834915399551392,
-0.19417357444763184,
-0.4972337782382965,
-1.0580129623413086,
-0.28308042883872986,
-0.17902351915836334,
-0.0852317065000534,
0.7172631025314331,
0.023217031732201576,
0.05196252092719078,
1.0753999948501587,
-0.7801614999771118,
-0.026450231671333313,
-0.260554701089859,
-0.004447228740900755,
0.6039429903030396,
0.18621300160884857,
0.8161037564277649,
-0.511417031288147,
-0.6433083415031433,
0.22073757648468018,
-0.7327327728271484,
-0.07469668239355087,
-0.15250760316848755,
-0.30809372663497925,
0.2726691961288452,
0.46897584199905396,
-0.9956353306770325,
0.0006918872823007405,
0.35571610927581787,
-0.26710399985313416,
0.8577732443809509,
-0.19622507691383362,
0.07628071308135986,
-1.0890988111495972,
-0.05156444385647774,
0.5430873036384583,
0.25707292556762695,
-0.22758130729198456,
-0.14521805942058563,
0.003322869073599577,
0.06226484477519989,
-0.5072759389877319,
0.8572956323623657,
-0.7386748790740967,
-0.24151818454265594,
-0.26012691855430603,
-0.19087015092372894,
0.11885233968496323,
0.2507588267326355,
0.0532657764852047,
0.9321048259735107,
0.28603556752204895,
-0.6516044735908508,
0.3850157856941223,
0.3001806139945984,
-0.7038953304290771,
0.5767055749893188,
-0.9723746180534363,
0.14639310538768768,
-0.09747859090566635,
0.031085815280675888,
-0.8360630869865417,
-0.15815380215644836,
0.12715384364128113,
-0.06611906737089157,
0.448908269405365,
0.023719632998108864,
-1.0097769498825073,
-0.7140699028968811,
-0.19504526257514954,
0.2374127358198166,
0.23916904628276825,
-0.29562175273895264,
0.6524578332901001,
0.17126061022281647,
-0.7554447054862976,
-0.1399255096912384,
-0.3836723566055298,
0.1010051965713501,
-0.4234279990196228,
-0.5477140545845032,
0.2006765455007553,
-0.875762939453125,
-0.37428995966911316,
-0.5707134008407593,
-0.3913581371307373,
0.18802028894424438,
0.1470077633857727,
-0.029666516929864883,
0.5431110262870789,
-0.20883341133594513,
0.22488774359226227,
0.09237997978925705,
-0.07206883281469345,
0.17335613071918488,
-0.043668199330568314,
0.8361877799034119,
0.08902840316295624,
-0.28802427649497986,
-0.26706716418266296,
0.32691696286201477,
0.7417635321617126,
-0.31992587447166443,
0.5203143954277039,
0.28683269023895264,
-0.2021462470293045,
-0.44128379225730896,
-0.8645084500312805,
-0.22255562245845795,
-0.6339995861053467,
0.46290645003318787,
-0.569247841835022,
-0.43644240498542786,
0.32180657982826233,
0.024067029356956482,
0.20495767891407013,
0.20792201161384583,
0.7276915311813354,
-0.004526034463196993,
1.1860697269439697,
0.5001106262207031,
-0.14359335601329803,
0.6227232217788696,
-0.0029749551322311163,
-0.06348490715026855,
-0.8051719069480896,
-0.3609068691730499,
-0.5756479501724243,
-0.23637862503528595,
-0.274336576461792,
-0.1737244576215744,
0.3533068001270294,
-0.3015897870063782,
-0.42301198840141296,
0.01915333978831768,
-0.30462178587913513,
0.649440586566925,
0.18186527490615845,
0.30056971311569214,
0.2014569640159607,
0.22862426936626434,
-0.3557398021221161,
0.20382818579673767,
-0.5472670793533325,
-0.5691528916358948,
0.7952102422714233,
0.5891187191009521,
1.0579547882080078,
-0.24220314621925354,
0.18913650512695312,
0.12987717986106873,
-0.12994889914989471,
-0.9354745745658875,
0.7339821457862854,
-0.0873393565416336,
-0.5296304821968079,
-0.2575037181377411,
-0.09136004745960236,
-0.7863779067993164,
0.23758192360401154,
-0.18839995563030243,
-0.3342576324939728,
0.20598889887332916,
-0.21189238131046295,
-0.5296865105628967,
0.2189304232597351,
-0.5635500550270081,
0.5123904943466187,
-0.49746328592300415,
-0.37145233154296875,
-0.32264062762260437,
-0.08109867572784424,
0.015983061864972115,
-0.4356887638568878,
0.3359330892562866,
-0.30904945731163025,
-0.043134648352861404,
0.7898789048194885,
0.01421397365629673,
0.7103910446166992,
0.06705737113952637,
-0.31282347440719604,
0.06146909296512604,
0.1893175095319748,
0.32874271273612976,
0.1483318954706192,
-0.5805705785751343,
-0.06287568807601929,
-0.6030911803245544,
-0.10900332778692245,
-0.4992785155773163,
0.7683929204940796,
-0.7597656846046448,
-1.0143243074417114,
-0.15032929182052612,
-0.7319397926330566,
-0.48134905099868774,
0.3810931444168091,
0.12048013508319855,
0.33399513363838196,
-0.04210929572582245,
0.31538447737693787,
0.7679927349090576,
-0.2539496421813965,
0.6439412832260132,
0.549947202205658,
-0.09709681570529938,
-0.4103038012981415,
0.875690221786499,
0.4178628921508789,
0.19991643726825714,
0.10710551589727402,
0.5769237875938416,
-0.3115027844905853,
-0.8570945858955383,
-0.5938042998313904,
0.31663355231285095,
-0.7359627485275269,
-0.11846669763326645,
-0.5565512180328369,
-0.18262875080108643,
0.06831111758947372,
-0.2999483644962311,
-0.16760008037090302,
-0.08107618987560272,
-0.5212171673774719,
-0.45194149017333984,
0.2828548848628998,
0.8543180227279663,
0.48777562379837036,
-0.006464775186032057,
-0.6334791779518127,
0.2321322113275528,
0.3487226366996765,
0.7756754159927368,
0.04837507754564285,
-0.4459091126918793,
-0.3267476558685303,
-0.20012736320495605,
-0.09941069781780243,
-0.6590476036071777,
0.060608457773923874,
-0.1455056220293045,
1.0770180225372314,
0.21386048197746277,
0.08823045343160629,
0.18566684424877167,
-0.5777756571769714,
0.45995032787323,
0.15227696299552917,
-0.447457492351532,
0.36709654331207275,
-0.7557377815246582,
0.3439841568470001,
0.45666366815567017,
0.6478664875030518,
-0.2995340824127197,
0.022361552342772484,
-0.15086321532726288,
-0.8202230334281921,
0.6065744757652283,
-0.18241557478904724,
0.13078980147838593,
0.05096697434782982,
-0.019201871007680893,
0.4800495207309723,
0.1348782628774643,
-0.2920791804790497,
-0.17543041706085205,
0.28455212712287903,
0.12292534112930298,
-0.2711779475212097,
-0.5367122888565063,
-0.13272033631801605,
0.11660570651292801,
0.38216477632522583,
-0.10579086095094681,
-0.12639959156513214,
-0.20074452459812164,
0.12899576127529144,
-0.32264870405197144,
0.22529084980487823,
0.6307187676429749,
0.8851704597473145,
-0.20644314587116241,
-0.38589605689048767,
0.44531381130218506,
-0.14410986006259918,
-0.22217020392417908,
-0.06612382084131241,
-0.04607507213950157,
0.2095932811498642,
-0.07651607692241669,
0.9227284789085388,
0.1521187424659729,
-0.5001789331436157,
0.01573907397687435,
-0.03691965714097023,
-0.21019932627677917,
-0.10872112959623337,
-0.07019927352666855,
0.12888681888580322,
0.32269957661628723,
0.3376193642616272,
0.01846022717654705,
0.21296724677085876,
-0.5658130645751953,
-0.04710136726498604,
0.5056482553482056,
0.0782899558544159,
-0.1444273591041565,
0.5219473838806152,
0.4691370129585266,
-0.500974714756012,
0.5110279321670532,
0.23355630040168762,
-0.21895554661750793,
0.6466808915138245,
0.4607475996017456,
0.9246285557746887,
-0.1415339708328247,
0.30354949831962585,
0.25544822216033936,
0.16952288150787354,
-0.2622218132019043,
0.17384308576583862,
0.047615934163331985,
-0.6114978790283203,
-0.2791200876235962,
-0.87753826379776,
-0.6014379262924194,
0.00576768396422267,
-0.3635893166065216,
0.5436279773712158,
-0.656129002571106,
-0.3990568518638611,
-0.10280392318964005,
-0.004622072447091341,
-0.7134346961975098,
0.35525116324424744,
0.4550909698009491,
1.040977954864502,
-0.9100422263145447,
0.3105783462524414,
0.7026711106300354,
-0.460262268781662,
-0.692030668258667,
-0.09396129846572876,
0.10979173332452774,
-0.7724339365959167,
0.7093692421913147,
-0.05278840288519859,
-0.03490927070379257,
-0.43291977047920227,
-0.19502246379852295,
-1.02802312374115,
1.2009440660476685,
0.49834805727005005,
-0.5414816737174988,
-0.14438606798648834,
0.2051849663257599,
0.2651245594024658,
-0.1636149138212204,
0.7142492532730103,
0.5165743827819824,
0.6027133464813232,
0.41302791237831116,
-1.2874113321304321,
0.23401948809623718,
-0.16309136152267456,
0.30215173959732056,
0.200605571269989,
-1.2040551900863647,
0.8469200730323792,
0.07652273029088974,
-0.08315443992614746,
0.20916825532913208,
0.52897709608078,
0.8180770874023438,
0.28786349296569824,
0.6051672697067261,
0.2273087352514267,
0.6399338841438293,
0.3597700595855713,
0.9313017129898071,
-0.28513458371162415,
0.006567755248397589,
0.7184876799583435,
-0.35981929302215576,
0.8338464498519897,
0.4204167127609253,
-0.2662859857082367,
0.38919001817703247,
0.9845777750015259,
-0.017032789066433907,
0.3295542895793915,
0.26729506254196167,
-0.1532066911458969,
-0.34922564029693604,
-0.4266289472579956,
-0.6121677160263062,
0.16294927895069122,
0.4641150236129761,
-0.3724110424518585,
-0.11480710655450821,
-0.09212961792945862,
-0.017879240214824677,
-0.2590966522693634,
-0.3177688717842102,
0.5414825677871704,
0.3649865984916687,
-0.6121037602424622,
0.6241300702095032,
-0.1561334878206253,
0.6244421601295471,
-0.37312716245651245,
0.11518117785453796,
-0.4266340732574463,
-0.05153690278530121,
-0.3888080418109894,
-1.0246940851211548,
-0.1066698506474495,
-0.33390533924102783,
-0.405268132686615,
-0.40042489767074585,
0.7096698880195618,
-0.03943663090467453,
-0.4376409351825714,
0.2699112296104431,
0.48952463269233704,
-0.04835837706923485,
-0.020594753324985504,
-0.6426544785499573,
0.5045793056488037,
-0.15797853469848633,
-0.5911128520965576,
0.48840609192848206,
0.2607942521572113,
-0.09268633276224136,
0.7387325763702393,
0.8069029450416565,
0.0799969732761383,
-0.3967544436454773,
0.2752094864845276,
1.077519178390503,
-0.5596573948860168,
-0.25505074858665466,
-0.8141440749168396,
0.5852404832839966,
-0.14025984704494476,
-0.3187169134616852,
0.7778052687644958,
0.7065728306770325,
0.8513692021369934,
-0.17953549325466156,
0.8720777034759521,
0.36291736364364624,
0.3236699402332306,
-0.8812580704689026,
0.7077605128288269,
-0.35638925433158875,
0.49796974658966064,
-0.3585781455039978,
-1.445412278175354,
-0.10343274474143982,
0.36451736092567444,
-0.23769788444042206,
0.3979693353176117,
0.7803974151611328,
0.8617963194847107,
0.02699359692633152,
0.08402486145496368,
0.3850015699863434,
0.23584230244159698,
0.1391562670469284,
0.19019803404808044,
1.0594879388809204,
0.26843738555908203,
0.31782612204551697,
0.12806729972362518,
-0.17887648940086365,
-0.24580435454845428,
-0.8142586350440979,
-1.1704320907592773,
-0.38728067278862,
-0.13466456532478333,
-0.06700558215379715,
-0.014630618505179882,
1.1069493293762207,
0.8284736275672913,
-0.44335639476776123,
-0.5689504742622375,
0.023428572341799736,
0.1312485635280609,
0.372889906167984,
-0.101376473903656,
0.08949445188045502,
-0.3314782679080963,
-0.7699925899505615,
0.616317868232727,
0.26311758160591125,
0.09033770114183426,
-0.3532395660877228,
-0.17604191601276398,
0.24342340230941772,
0.35159820318222046,
0.7836751341819763,
0.12743428349494934,
-0.7131708860397339,
0.07025033235549927,
0.19306129217147827,
0.018595874309539795,
-0.030625153332948685,
0.8173620104789734,
-0.5421010255813599,
0.3279890716075897,
0.9746416807174683,
0.6233716607093811,
0.208131343126297,
-0.35981836915016174,
0.9153146147727966,
-0.24087537825107574,
-0.045035991817712784,
0.08187182992696762,
0.7547586560249329,
0.16846193373203278,
-0.26292985677719116,
0.3304605484008789,
0.019467122852802277,
-0.8144330382347107,
-0.7352052927017212,
0.3567971885204315,
-0.8846968412399292,
-0.44117891788482666,
1.7106153964996338,
0.298845112323761,
-0.15683552622795105,
-0.20259593427181244,
-0.7014517188072205,
-0.14225447177886963,
-0.5272124409675598,
0.6957911252975464,
0.9271866679191589,
0.0686194971203804,
-0.24842889606952667,
-0.8662197589874268,
0.26652127504348755,
0.5737401843070984,
-0.4425733983516693,
-0.04485189914703369,
0.38691771030426025,
0.22635439038276672,
0.0034838614519685507,
0.3429437577724457,
0.1308920830488205,
0.11189758032560349,
-0.31495434045791626,
-0.19434760510921478,
-0.10647377371788025,
-0.3898310959339142,
-0.08178800344467163,
0.07892109453678131,
0.6502393484115601,
0.1150977686047554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15420v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15420v1
|
XC-Cache: Cross-Attending to Cached Context for Efficient LLM Inference
| 2024-04-23T18:10:42 | 2024-04-23T18:10:42 |
João Monteiro, Étienne Marcotte, Pierre-André Noël, Valentina Zantedeschi, David Vázquez, Nicolas Chapados, Christopher Pal, Perouz Taslakian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In-context learning (ICL) approaches typically leverage prompting to
condition decoder-only language model generation on reference information.
Just-in-time processing of a context is inefficient due to the quadratic cost
of self-attention operations, and caching is desirable. However, caching
transformer states can easily require almost as much space as the model
parameters. When the right context isn't known in advance, caching ICL can be
challenging. This work addresses these limitations by introducing models that,
inspired by the encoder-decoder architecture, use cross-attention to condition
generation on reference text without the prompt. More precisely, we leverage
pre-trained decoder-only models and only train a small number of added layers.
We use Question-Answering (QA) as a testbed to evaluate the ability of our
models to perform conditional generation and observe that they outperform ICL,
are comparable to fine-tuned prompted LLMs, and drastically reduce the space
footprint relative to standard KV caching by two orders of magnitude.
|
[
-0.37767043709754944,
-0.2987513542175293,
0.6055289506912231,
0.09636887162923813,
-0.20800185203552246,
-0.16523118317127228,
-0.14123474061489105,
-0.4761738181114197,
-0.10531272739171982,
0.48847496509552,
-0.8068656921386719,
-0.3230190873146057,
-0.14632174372673035,
0.08102072775363922,
-0.5446410775184631,
0.9417633414268494,
-0.041469912976026535,
0.058028221130371094,
-0.5764979720115662,
0.08366138488054276,
-0.368091881275177,
-0.4837111830711365,
-0.7660235166549683,
-0.27822592854499817,
0.45267045497894287,
0.44278213381767273,
0.3219242990016937,
0.42633411288261414,
-0.08528783172369003,
0.15214844048023224,
0.03686654940247536,
0.10034532099962234,
-0.6218041181564331,
0.15987837314605713,
-0.18293644487857819,
-0.5717203617095947,
-0.06856460869312286,
-0.08674212545156479,
0.5588995218276978,
0.46627187728881836,
-0.027629731222987175,
0.0240048598498106,
0.08299965411424637,
0.42014068365097046,
-1.0873645544052124,
0.13320392370224,
-0.9783515930175781,
0.13185244798660278,
0.04870433360338211,
-0.31955021619796753,
-0.7533608675003052,
-0.07399075478315353,
0.320410817861557,
-0.5641598105430603,
0.3701639473438263,
0.09747976064682007,
0.6871709823608398,
0.576822817325592,
-0.41333726048469543,
-0.21427638828754425,
-0.5059727430343628,
0.8815615177154541,
-0.61822509765625,
0.6395251750946045,
0.530699610710144,
0.20709004998207092,
0.0968736782670021,
-1.1091639995574951,
-0.7060502767562866,
-0.13746479153633118,
-0.18874891102313995,
0.3797992765903473,
-0.0994250476360321,
-0.07988013327121735,
0.22401796281337738,
0.12380734831094742,
-0.2873219847679138,
-0.06770377606153488,
-0.009789046831429005,
0.04963817447423935,
0.2278444916009903,
0.29470717906951904,
0.15602755546569824,
-0.11077838391065598,
-0.6146456599235535,
-0.12469493597745895,
-1.101383924484253,
0.27738675475120544,
-0.0714394822716713,
0.18822753429412842,
-0.17007562518119812,
0.31626856327056885,
-0.16883893311023712,
0.45257076621055603,
0.5269237160682678,
0.279572993516922,
-0.32447242736816406,
-0.5570808053016663,
-0.3232843577861786,
0.33483192324638367,
0.35680699348449707,
0.0457775741815567,
-0.08361606299877167,
-0.5082385540008545,
-0.2631568908691406,
-0.018235214054584503,
0.34996315836906433,
-0.9704440236091614,
-0.1888590157032013,
0.1612723171710968,
-0.1505483090877533,
0.126812145113945,
-0.01691047102212906,
-0.4420868456363678,
-0.08821076154708862,
-0.11961349099874496,
0.3140895664691925,
-0.07029597461223602,
0.32278019189834595,
0.0599142350256443,
0.08748859912157059,
0.36298877000808716,
0.155867800116539,
-0.6868265867233276,
0.3859587609767914,
0.19106845557689667,
0.43623030185699463,
-0.26050424575805664,
-0.04815863445401192,
-0.7037568092346191,
0.37834322452545166,
-0.21162699162960052,
0.6832840442657471,
-0.593314528465271,
-0.46814101934432983,
0.12746939063072205,
-0.07352421432733536,
-0.06911468505859375,
-0.43543288111686707,
0.7212018370628357,
-0.9838223457336426,
0.05867534503340721,
-0.6091384291648865,
-0.6505211591720581,
0.0378434844315052,
0.30165594816207886,
-0.6859246492385864,
1.1395115852355957,
0.22746983170509338,
-0.841583788394928,
0.5795320868492126,
-0.25696712732315063,
-0.44505295157432556,
-0.0026418170891702175,
-0.3327934443950653,
-0.29276418685913086,
-0.12719739973545074,
0.42532360553741455,
0.32207947969436646,
-0.579209566116333,
0.32112425565719604,
-0.1581900268793106,
-0.26872509717941284,
0.15005993843078613,
-0.3114948868751526,
0.3866397738456726,
0.20808474719524384,
-0.6063887476921082,
0.002583754248917103,
-0.5834235548973083,
0.31102025508880615,
-0.1580984890460968,
-0.6629254221916199,
-0.3327735960483551,
0.2768458127975464,
-0.026055626571178436,
0.5246847867965698,
0.12880882620811462,
-0.49603044986724854,
-0.03408562391996384,
-0.3879797160625458,
0.23320671916007996,
0.32716816663742065,
0.001778444042429328,
0.5018743872642517,
-0.16483017802238464,
0.3942202627658844,
0.2940390110015869,
0.04681849107146263,
-0.5991981625556946,
-0.09652666002511978,
-1.1660038232803345,
0.026052160188555717,
0.11800863593816757,
0.3994292616844177,
-0.9977515339851379,
0.16584469377994537,
-0.1787976175546646,
-0.14176659286022186,
-0.5949743986129761,
-0.020287586376070976,
0.7461172342300415,
0.7972452640533447,
0.5764590501785278,
0.04247850924730301,
-0.5923424363136292,
-0.6573879718780518,
-0.10078353434801102,
-0.04100586101412773,
0.2451978176832199,
0.4959263801574707,
0.22329922020435333,
-0.1254122108221054,
0.9940041303634644,
-0.1504068225622177,
0.03914366662502289,
-0.39911535382270813,
-0.14768755435943604,
0.011791984550654888,
0.33770444989204407,
0.3956035375595093,
-0.8853699564933777,
-0.7804581522941589,
-0.035397954285144806,
-0.6238558292388916,
-0.28650158643722534,
-0.21517159044742584,
-0.039443764835596085,
0.33176466822624207,
0.9122335314750671,
-0.6331341862678528,
0.7753053903579712,
0.526421844959259,
-0.17503073811531067,
0.2509520351886749,
-0.28682267665863037,
0.04885803535580635,
-0.7863295674324036,
0.03821045905351639,
-0.13115844130516052,
-0.27812841534614563,
-0.6408914923667908,
0.13640783727169037,
0.44456183910369873,
-0.16535314917564392,
-0.563479483127594,
1.0425467491149902,
-0.8170602917671204,
0.014510568231344223,
-0.4628954827785492,
0.3476428985595703,
0.15856832265853882,
0.5329316258430481,
0.3235568106174469,
0.8572264313697815,
0.44829878211021423,
-0.8387962579727173,
-0.4337938129901886,
0.09034885466098785,
-0.23397521674633026,
0.1251499503850937,
-0.5483227968215942,
0.21142464876174927,
-0.046191249042749405,
0.594667911529541,
-0.8714296221733093,
0.21118012070655823,
0.27680158615112305,
-0.022160420194268227,
0.4237652122974396,
-0.06042342633008957,
-0.41999098658561707,
-0.2512035369873047,
-0.0817427709698677,
0.8848628401756287,
0.2902168035507202,
-0.9938288927078247,
0.6245888471603394,
0.13464872539043427,
0.2626841962337494,
-0.6618260741233826,
-0.6885387897491455,
-0.013825506903231144,
0.13742777705192566,
-0.4735614061355591,
0.6499472260475159,
-0.37776899337768555,
0.000005077002242614981,
0.031242508441209793,
-0.27457040548324585,
-0.05133572965860367,
-0.05212382599711418,
0.22473134100437164,
-0.013822626322507858,
-0.33054623007774353,
0.04825685918331146,
0.13417433202266693,
-0.23297648131847382,
-0.047819312661886215,
-0.5836240649223328,
0.503813624382019,
0.18440425395965576,
-0.479711651802063,
-0.5459226369857788,
0.6137579083442688,
0.2613568902015686,
-0.18150053918361664,
0.5826175212860107,
0.1060727909207344,
-0.29137492179870605,
-0.3677339255809784,
-0.5552713871002197,
-0.3398144841194153,
-0.4822247624397278,
0.07314437627792358,
-0.4025631546974182,
-0.7130278944969177,
0.512347400188446,
0.33153462409973145,
0.011809487827122211,
0.04984930157661438,
0.5661203265190125,
0.11866702139377594,
1.1337848901748657,
0.681473433971405,
-0.09724848717451096,
0.42588767409324646,
-0.08318096399307251,
0.3409736156463623,
-0.765904426574707,
-0.14504897594451904,
-0.4759747385978699,
-0.09154008328914642,
-0.335655152797699,
-0.5599525570869446,
0.26310741901397705,
-0.06974882632493973,
-0.2291145622730255,
0.132810577750206,
-0.07386324554681778,
0.6592763662338257,
0.47173064947128296,
0.21671923995018005,
0.15087173879146576,
-0.2628314197063446,
-0.2845740020275116,
0.10641366243362427,
-0.9682552814483643,
-0.23368610441684723,
0.7705338597297668,
-0.1913813203573227,
0.8912184238433838,
-0.38982149958610535,
0.5587590336799622,
-0.05033715069293976,
0.2561228573322296,
-0.5564725995063782,
0.46418997645378113,
-0.009065599180758,
-0.6553272604942322,
0.07843704521656036,
-0.27048459649086,
-0.8652857542037964,
0.25505614280700684,
0.011914297938346863,
-0.6391178965568542,
0.3823588192462921,
0.31904056668281555,
-0.5042494535446167,
0.46482235193252563,
-0.5253821015357971,
0.6178000569343567,
-0.17665418982505798,
-0.5185495018959045,
-0.16484901309013367,
-0.8747397065162659,
0.26956892013549805,
-0.1709928959608078,
-0.23681703209877014,
0.2826272249221802,
-0.1526319682598114,
0.13376246392726898,
-0.24389001727104187,
1.0907015800476074,
-0.17824628949165344,
0.020396249368786812,
0.47007477283477783,
0.01722581498324871,
0.7399307489395142,
0.25894662737846375,
-0.2663017511367798,
-0.24650713801383972,
0.01985790766775608,
-0.38620972633361816,
-0.6265398859977722,
0.7502111196517944,
-0.7406130433082581,
-0.5621635913848877,
-0.15622752904891968,
-0.5948519110679626,
-0.2079244703054428,
0.11905553191900253,
0.5025648474693298,
0.43548476696014404,
-0.0742747038602829,
0.09387512505054474,
0.9315732717514038,
-0.2745511531829834,
0.5680268406867981,
0.606063961982727,
0.02032827027142048,
0.024625038728117943,
0.4680492579936981,
-0.12513256072998047,
0.3721771240234375,
0.7991251945495605,
0.033998288214206696,
-0.35511261224746704,
-0.32201844453811646,
-0.3405556082725525,
0.031855084002017975,
-1.0403403043746948,
-0.2478146255016327,
-0.960748553276062,
-0.3254660665988922,
-0.22946670651435852,
-0.2770012617111206,
-0.28125524520874023,
-0.07623719424009323,
-0.6254392266273499,
0.08728494495153427,
-0.10422245413064957,
0.3148423135280609,
0.2849488854408264,
0.5053272843360901,
-0.7606753706932068,
0.15223348140716553,
0.18539677560329437,
0.016439249739050865,
0.358031302690506,
-0.3401564955711365,
-0.4229625165462494,
0.007789378985762596,
-0.18170525133609772,
-0.635687530040741,
0.34691089391708374,
0.28506699204444885,
0.6951658129692078,
0.5441169142723083,
0.33090728521347046,
0.8578038215637207,
-0.4982975125312805,
0.6665277481079102,
-0.0609603188931942,
-1.0082197189331055,
0.37740668654441833,
0.1665911227464676,
0.5914754867553711,
0.6335799098014832,
0.4558810591697693,
-0.5364580154418945,
-0.369661420583725,
-0.6021353006362915,
-0.9147377610206604,
0.7440211176872253,
0.04152626171708107,
0.23143742978572845,
-0.4346979856491089,
0.7659424543380737,
0.1443258821964264,
0.003546364139765501,
-0.8294510245323181,
-0.2171120047569275,
-0.15384989976882935,
0.028981056064367294,
-0.09111137688159943,
-0.34600749611854553,
0.15796111524105072,
-0.16595211625099182,
0.6883946061134338,
-0.31635144352912903,
0.1405562162399292,
0.3744417726993561,
-0.41975006461143494,
-0.19838488101959229,
0.029276056215167046,
0.48307371139526367,
0.5682435631752014,
0.056980978697538376,
0.2682240307331085,
0.476905882358551,
-0.0770435631275177,
0.07134503871202469,
-0.2799454629421234,
-0.3860182464122772,
-0.27783286571502686,
0.039731305092573166,
0.8272146582603455,
0.8076279163360596,
-0.7779438495635986,
0.5360476970672607,
-0.45067155361175537,
0.24968081712722778,
-0.20225855708122253,
0.10668203234672546,
0.113697849214077,
0.27831360697746277,
0.29446303844451904,
-0.22878529131412506,
0.044761888682842255,
-0.2805700898170471,
0.5068612694740295,
0.3900245428085327,
-0.7059728503227234,
-0.40874752402305603,
0.7381153702735901,
0.0017373531591147184,
0.15955497324466705,
0.7490089535713196,
-0.191761776804924,
-0.40732458233833313,
0.5451333522796631,
0.9872453212738037,
0.9930968880653381,
-0.01891658641397953,
-0.10106721520423889,
0.38156843185424805,
0.09575212001800537,
0.15501874685287476,
0.29638397693634033,
-0.5164296627044678,
-0.8123326897621155,
-0.3356020748615265,
-0.3636780381202698,
-0.3560006022453308,
-0.10871034860610962,
-0.8477286100387573,
0.34029528498649597,
-0.3841635286808014,
0.000001204215891448257,
-0.40552017092704773,
-0.07099507004022598,
-0.8394513726234436,
0.5249214172363281,
0.06638039648532867,
1.1693073511123657,
-0.6132668256759644,
1.2465386390686035,
0.36198297142982483,
-0.22703301906585693,
-0.7243182063102722,
0.22660204768180847,
-0.2755409777164459,
-0.8638291358947754,
0.817697286605835,
0.31042516231536865,
-0.3796011805534363,
0.15044310688972473,
-0.5918012261390686,
-0.8614819645881653,
1.0572783946990967,
0.3134068548679352,
-0.5590319633483887,
-0.18408934772014618,
-0.26609277725219727,
0.4092257618904114,
-0.5474943518638611,
0.40887805819511414,
0.5436421036720276,
0.3931598365306854,
0.07630888372659683,
-0.2863485813140869,
0.194108247756958,
-0.22803270816802979,
-0.020574435591697693,
0.163114994764328,
-0.6561587452888489,
0.8383638262748718,
-0.32609495520591736,
-0.6151516437530518,
0.2257266789674759,
1.0086054801940918,
0.2949467897415161,
0.2662149965763092,
0.5070515871047974,
0.6593078374862671,
0.5608779191970825,
0.18349461257457733,
1.4056017398834229,
-0.5821523666381836,
0.10877679288387299,
1.3896479606628418,
-0.49358057975769043,
0.8416306972503662,
0.7081097960472107,
0.341200590133667,
0.4095139503479004,
0.8269953727722168,
0.3449331521987915,
0.870175302028656,
0.027316508814692497,
-0.4471324682235718,
-0.6001604199409485,
-0.14013056457042694,
-0.19165588915348053,
0.19373732805252075,
0.21554379165172577,
-0.27025267481803894,
-0.4785880744457245,
-0.0946856290102005,
-0.01191402692347765,
-0.13004690408706665,
-0.25854867696762085,
0.6399848461151123,
0.24496766924858093,
-0.9640141129493713,
0.4197068512439728,
-0.12302330881357193,
0.46804794669151306,
-0.7018648982048035,
0.05385490879416466,
-0.44017493724823,
0.19075781106948853,
0.001328603713773191,
-0.42030808329582214,
0.08718481659889221,
-0.10911697894334793,
-0.6511918902397156,
-0.13397996127605438,
0.5858559012413025,
-0.5333382487297058,
-0.2172553390264511,
0.6093522906303406,
0.3775498569011688,
0.048479631543159485,
0.0340828038752079,
-0.4879237711429596,
-0.18538831174373627,
-0.035621024668216705,
-0.2332235872745514,
0.4158790707588196,
0.3543773591518402,
-0.3370579183101654,
0.8908670544624329,
0.5076635479927063,
-0.12377332895994186,
0.5299900770187378,
0.1404266655445099,
0.9899954795837402,
-0.593388557434082,
-0.6083180904388428,
-0.7406402826309204,
0.42300742864608765,
0.3018634617328644,
-0.32107511162757874,
0.5346123576164246,
0.5003103613853455,
1.0620033740997314,
0.1427135169506073,
0.7665103077888489,
0.028505617752671242,
0.12912629544734955,
-0.7973892688751221,
0.5568069219589233,
-0.792917013168335,
0.27631914615631104,
0.06753578037023544,
-0.6143928170204163,
-0.2468225657939911,
0.21409016847610474,
-0.12092027813196182,
0.17315472662448883,
0.8607633709907532,
0.8490923047065735,
-0.29003337025642395,
0.04560079053044319,
0.4343167245388031,
-0.12571750581264496,
0.33744314312934875,
0.7139757871627808,
1.0723069906234741,
-0.4609067738056183,
0.6331796646118164,
-0.21933729946613312,
0.1164999008178711,
-0.12915641069412231,
-1.151400089263916,
-0.9265167713165283,
-0.6032675504684448,
-0.12641991674900055,
-0.12554585933685303,
-0.11616089195013046,
0.694570779800415,
0.8924073576927185,
-0.8198702335357666,
-0.17627748847007751,
-0.05260778218507767,
0.05876926705241203,
-0.06296896189451218,
-0.18389803171157837,
0.3950989246368408,
-0.7318441271781921,
-0.7328395247459412,
0.6303179860115051,
0.29338616132736206,
-0.023675397038459778,
-0.283532053232193,
-0.19988791644573212,
-0.12443036586046219,
0.3014366924762726,
0.5029721260070801,
0.3063628673553467,
-0.8426103591918945,
-0.1938072293996811,
0.13465596735477448,
-0.3430461287498474,
0.34389951825141907,
1.1490497589111328,
-1.0381579399108887,
0.5007563829421997,
0.5705224871635437,
0.9950441122055054,
0.9748007655143738,
-0.15072329342365265,
0.5728568434715271,
-0.8846367597579956,
0.0555337592959404,
0.10037602484226227,
0.48808950185775757,
0.2411031574010849,
-0.4645180106163025,
0.075950987637043,
-0.19885866343975067,
-0.6055940389633179,
-0.47747862339019775,
0.1837683767080307,
-0.876192569732666,
-0.28418397903442383,
0.8787316679954529,
-0.30304405093193054,
-0.37652337551116943,
-0.10782966017723083,
-0.08494449406862259,
0.3508034646511078,
-0.30507174134254456,
0.7406756281852722,
0.38267388939857483,
-0.052753739058971405,
-0.3365538716316223,
-0.5044701099395752,
0.4211714267730713,
0.6421988010406494,
-0.879563570022583,
-0.002185648772865534,
0.15119615197181702,
0.1602344959974289,
-0.06746036559343338,
0.6197084784507751,
0.009224940091371536,
0.45559096336364746,
-0.1660107970237732,
0.16615736484527588,
0.39009934663772583,
-0.5346440672874451,
-0.1562519371509552,
-0.017477460205554962,
-0.22491690516471863,
0.11634452641010284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15406v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15406v2
|
Wiki-LLaVA: Hierarchical Retrieval-Augmented Generation for Multimodal LLMs
| 2024-04-23T18:00:09 | 2024-05-22T07:15:18 |
Davide Caffagni, Federico Cocchi, Nicholas Moratelli, Sara Sarto, Marcella Cornia, Lorenzo Baraldi, Rita Cucchiara
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Multimodal LLMs are the natural evolution of LLMs, and enlarge their
capabilities so as to work beyond the pure textual modality. As research is
being carried out to design novel architectures and vision-and-language
adapters, in this paper we concentrate on endowing such models with the
capability of answering questions that require external knowledge. Our
approach, termed Wiki-LLaVA, aims at integrating an external knowledge source
of multimodal documents, which is accessed through a hierarchical retrieval
pipeline. Relevant passages, using this approach, are retrieved from the
external knowledge source and employed as additional context for the LLM,
augmenting the effectiveness and precision of generated dialogues. We conduct
extensive experiments on datasets tailored for visual question answering with
external data and demonstrate the appropriateness of our approach.
|
[
-0.5346933007240295,
-0.9514782428741455,
0.6505261063575745,
-0.19618993997573853,
-0.13005545735359192,
0.12370006740093231,
-0.021190866827964783,
-0.5962709784507751,
0.39745768904685974,
0.4195077121257782,
-0.7862635254859924,
-0.19536356627941132,
-0.3938094973564148,
0.1498895138502121,
-0.32456129789352417,
0.7892420887947083,
0.012632660567760468,
0.012783541344106197,
-0.8382675051689148,
-0.16193760931491852,
-0.4225832521915436,
-0.16081644594669342,
-0.204007089138031,
-0.005225068423897028,
1.0060350894927979,
0.5291359424591064,
0.5054684281349182,
0.23493705689907074,
0.4903363585472107,
0.4361588954925537,
0.0065396130084991455,
0.8785237669944763,
-0.39266160130500793,
0.5073353052139282,
-0.19958199560642242,
-0.5990933179855347,
-0.23945896327495575,
-0.38165709376335144,
0.6559180021286011,
0.4614327847957611,
0.17854560911655426,
0.3993457853794098,
-0.0012392733478918672,
0.6228561997413635,
-0.7506576180458069,
0.2440022975206375,
-0.8204283118247986,
-0.035388797521591187,
-0.14741060137748718,
-0.5600578784942627,
-0.2866032123565674,
-0.24585019052028656,
0.029875939711928368,
-0.9642816781997681,
-0.21082532405853271,
0.15888024866580963,
0.6858863830566406,
0.23067060112953186,
-0.7408088445663452,
-0.4118902087211609,
-0.6164979934692383,
0.48032307624816895,
-0.2891770303249359,
0.30450451374053955,
0.3412973880767822,
0.4284866750240326,
-0.20142783224582672,
-1.1032596826553345,
-0.7689749002456665,
-0.23244890570640564,
-0.11791498959064484,
0.30528172850608826,
0.05579831078648567,
0.028383664786815643,
0.12207859009504318,
0.4608979821205139,
-0.32065388560295105,
-0.2204664945602417,
-0.5406427979469299,
-0.06700457632541656,
0.38121742010116577,
0.30100739002227783,
0.5703604221343994,
-0.6217368841171265,
-0.2672390341758728,
0.22886423766613007,
-0.5989752411842346,
0.12109999358654022,
0.4059605300426483,
0.10770034044981003,
-0.013714306056499481,
1.0449020862579346,
-0.5028117299079895,
0.6922797560691833,
0.11486022174358368,
-0.4610045850276947,
0.3215084373950958,
-0.6378270387649536,
-0.14183595776557922,
-0.3749895393848419,
0.5015109181404114,
0.3258903920650482,
0.06604903191328049,
-0.04017997160553932,
0.004193031694740057,
-0.265967458486557,
0.41171857714653015,
-0.5504636168479919,
-0.051454607397317886,
0.1946277767419815,
-0.4127863347530365,
-0.4548879861831665,
-0.30860045552253723,
-0.7371802926063538,
-0.40394240617752075,
-0.37599754333496094,
0.772020161151886,
-0.2902887761592865,
-0.28803569078445435,
-0.7321646213531494,
-0.4020613729953766,
0.34156084060668945,
0.6664684414863586,
-0.9218317866325378,
-0.04015681892633438,
0.21600858867168427,
0.6176553964614868,
-0.1694430708885193,
-0.19898061454296112,
-0.5250908732414246,
0.6486246585845947,
-0.5303915739059448,
1.0280311107635498,
-0.42667117714881897,
-0.27077168226242065,
0.1552509218454361,
0.012467864900827408,
0.10821066051721573,
-0.3422773778438568,
0.28936076164245605,
-0.7814441323280334,
0.4319605529308319,
-0.4625374972820282,
-0.4411124587059021,
-0.15968212485313416,
0.6912453174591064,
-0.6201276183128357,
1.017849087715149,
-0.03407224640250206,
-1.0839282274246216,
0.23174606263637543,
-0.5908806920051575,
-0.13383537530899048,
0.22748175263404846,
-0.4828575551509857,
0.19043898582458496,
0.16453640162944794,
0.47604361176490784,
0.1680649369955063,
-0.43773889541625977,
0.16158653795719147,
-0.3299066424369812,
-0.028305944055318832,
0.25869491696357727,
-0.5151111483573914,
0.5034281611442566,
0.18699286878108978,
0.06802786886692047,
0.21318429708480835,
-0.8139247298240662,
0.0699346661567688,
0.03798036649823189,
-0.5346449613571167,
-0.600675642490387,
-0.034203801304101944,
-0.09436944127082825,
0.3507674038410187,
0.5599789023399353,
-0.571626603603363,
0.2205410897731781,
-0.37970641255378723,
0.03332655131816864,
0.9289456009864807,
0.17205190658569336,
0.5036989450454712,
-0.39271390438079834,
0.38067689538002014,
0.1625785231590271,
0.40085965394973755,
-0.3622228801250458,
-0.7572625279426575,
-0.8553327322006226,
-0.36482083797454834,
-0.14260374009609222,
0.5491634607315063,
-1.4288100004196167,
-0.20612826943397522,
-0.2940320372581482,
-0.369393527507782,
-0.4573987126350403,
0.5546082258224487,
0.11827289313077927,
0.8308308720588684,
0.23414789140224457,
-0.04005406051874161,
-0.5624852180480957,
-1.1486562490463257,
0.17519782483577728,
-0.40359124541282654,
0.02092880755662918,
0.5914222002029419,
0.5984098315238953,
-0.375609815120697,
0.8209763169288635,
-0.36824101209640503,
-0.15429344773292542,
-0.08622866123914719,
-0.19831222295761108,
-0.023317409679293633,
0.12885625660419464,
0.19787998497486115,
-1.1577166318893433,
-0.4106657803058624,
0.18343159556388855,
-1.2248700857162476,
0.06895033270120621,
0.1755664199590683,
-0.3546198308467865,
0.1891014575958252,
0.5357217192649841,
-0.8435115218162537,
0.21886961162090302,
0.5534124374389648,
0.0811680257320404,
0.4611271917819977,
-0.18119055032730103,
0.44483762979507446,
-1.5341137647628784,
0.08829360455274582,
-0.44797900319099426,
-0.09364676475524902,
-0.5778529047966003,
0.3015177547931671,
0.04563150927424431,
0.0023374466691166162,
-0.6064015030860901,
0.7368566989898682,
-0.5075602531433105,
-0.27521297335624695,
-0.08204782009124756,
0.4694500267505646,
0.2989172041416168,
0.5813724398612976,
-0.06340129673480988,
0.7036396861076355,
0.38929522037506104,
-0.47846734523773193,
0.7963158488273621,
0.40905988216400146,
-0.4703855812549591,
0.8139223456382751,
-0.3384034335613251,
0.046250682324171066,
-0.39137500524520874,
0.09628546237945557,
-1.2407282590866089,
-0.5663516521453857,
0.20437617599964142,
-0.42615950107574463,
0.24758653342723846,
-0.2500428557395935,
-0.5574216842651367,
-0.23363815248012543,
-0.45275503396987915,
0.3917471766471863,
0.24810945987701416,
-0.742866575717926,
0.9118148684501648,
0.5007027387619019,
-0.49063819646835327,
-0.7534192800521851,
-0.5643351674079895,
0.07471375167369843,
-0.27910611033439636,
-1.053147315979004,
0.14937587082386017,
-0.35221487283706665,
-0.40643757581710815,
-0.09156238287687302,
0.08422823250293732,
-0.1094629243016243,
-0.30524343252182007,
0.23255914449691772,
0.4145031273365021,
-0.3159859776496887,
0.31742003560066223,
0.2201859951019287,
0.2547251284122467,
-0.13290156424045563,
-0.044747743755578995,
0.04412824660539627,
0.23196835815906525,
-0.33174601197242737,
-0.2693674564361572,
0.7443224787712097,
0.5849778056144714,
-0.06842697411775589,
0.6015070080757141,
0.5262724757194519,
-0.31271934509277344,
0.05513358861207962,
-0.7728552222251892,
0.2000824511051178,
-0.5287965536117554,
0.25231480598449707,
-0.6590714454650879,
-0.6290162801742554,
0.3869842290878296,
-0.11543501168489456,
0.06983915716409683,
0.3640272617340088,
0.8839839100837708,
-0.5622592568397522,
0.8767050504684448,
0.5565188527107239,
0.31869858503341675,
0.5710562467575073,
-0.1327831894159317,
-0.2338554561138153,
-0.997325599193573,
-0.7377651929855347,
-0.19642017781734467,
-0.10683529824018478,
-0.6550394892692566,
-0.5719361901283264,
0.6474507451057434,
0.015058934688568115,
0.11703864485025406,
-0.08161616325378418,
-0.21031130850315094,
0.1786276251077652,
0.6195379495620728,
0.24750305712223053,
0.6762788891792297,
0.17066502571105957,
-0.36973851919174194,
-0.04860585555434227,
-0.7176637053489685,
-0.17486701905727386,
0.9946667551994324,
0.0959281176328659,
0.9750288128852844,
0.3547392785549164,
0.5202180743217468,
0.10107322037220001,
0.32045596837997437,
-0.6949160695075989,
0.42147013545036316,
0.19252902269363403,
-0.8280782103538513,
-0.28679636120796204,
-0.2852918207645416,
-0.782997727394104,
0.4731746315956116,
-0.3193475008010864,
-0.5895341038703918,
0.21097856760025024,
0.16731752455234528,
0.1570555716753006,
0.13712677359580994,
-0.7171578407287598,
0.5911750197410583,
-0.28019168972969055,
-0.3605877459049225,
-0.24473045766353607,
-0.5709176659584045,
0.5871651768684387,
-0.03478112071752548,
0.35504767298698425,
0.04161496087908745,
-0.353268027305603,
0.4630145728588104,
-0.29443246126174927,
0.8056203126907349,
-0.10546863824129105,
-0.3676505982875824,
0.568230152130127,
-0.10445614904165268,
0.5647062063217163,
0.18815279006958008,
0.21790863573551178,
-0.21012502908706665,
0.04565936699509621,
-0.18324248492717743,
-0.8211148977279663,
0.8933519721031189,
-0.7550893425941467,
-0.7293882966041565,
-0.10168305039405823,
-0.9108198285102844,
-0.5086658000946045,
0.17014162242412567,
0.20640380680561066,
0.7051514983177185,
-0.07999880611896515,
0.2512781620025635,
0.6179871559143066,
-0.4516134560108185,
0.24614904820919037,
0.3194033205509186,
-0.3329022228717804,
-0.6843173503875732,
0.8513669967651367,
0.2321179062128067,
0.3550124764442444,
0.8343136310577393,
0.12768550217151642,
-0.4647725820541382,
-0.44254201650619507,
-0.7899264693260193,
0.056867729872465134,
-1.1496413946151733,
-0.32002782821655273,
-0.5743698477745056,
-0.2567979693412781,
-0.3972438871860504,
0.07953625917434692,
-0.07410896569490433,
-0.6711511015892029,
-0.13769285380840302,
-0.1563647985458374,
0.5731133222579956,
0.8326809406280518,
-0.0007758003775961697,
-0.2564474940299988,
-0.7433277368545532,
0.8641902804374695,
0.7805560827255249,
0.03633886203169823,
-0.13027095794677734,
-0.494901567697525,
-0.19597527384757996,
0.0663953348994255,
-0.31799718737602234,
-0.8057675361633301,
0.14968104660511017,
0.3368140161037445,
0.7627783417701721,
-0.007199302315711975,
-0.03423802927136421,
1.0221736431121826,
-0.6012352108955383,
0.8167541027069092,
0.2604500353336334,
-0.3339497447013855,
0.7828443646430969,
-0.45442458987236023,
0.4733676612377167,
0.3708108067512512,
0.501451849937439,
-0.26361361145973206,
-0.6025627255439758,
-0.24286217987537384,
-0.8842200636863708,
0.34172600507736206,
0.126922145485878,
0.3589135706424713,
-0.017156178131699562,
0.30125874280929565,
0.1552387923002243,
0.3524159789085388,
-0.6446516513824463,
-0.30426672101020813,
-0.23186664283275604,
-0.2777959108352661,
0.1927540898323059,
-0.25393953919410706,
-0.3152362108230591,
-0.24492155015468597,
0.4643925726413727,
-0.40961167216300964,
0.23467232286930084,
0.29039260745048523,
-0.4097836911678314,
-0.09571287781000137,
0.18169210851192474,
0.3780013620853424,
0.8626980185508728,
0.023237252607941628,
0.04207223653793335,
0.28840547800064087,
-0.43802332878112793,
-0.07343053817749023,
-0.1942155361175537,
-0.2851722240447998,
-0.0321652889251709,
0.4096927344799042,
0.576456606388092,
0.1640038788318634,
-0.7353658080101013,
0.3786083161830902,
-0.06141966953873634,
-0.0909326821565628,
-0.5655385851860046,
-0.03810269013047218,
0.33451637625694275,
0.5373292565345764,
0.7247885465621948,
-0.18464593589305878,
0.2695249021053314,
-0.7779939770698547,
0.15597307682037354,
0.6576907634735107,
-0.09859509021043777,
-0.10045421868562698,
0.5023580193519592,
0.4218081831932068,
-0.029496315866708755,
0.4533528685569763,
0.4196591377258301,
0.04204152151942253,
0.3481109142303467,
0.3974941372871399,
0.4009716212749481,
0.10073201358318329,
0.16608251631259918,
0.2206900268793106,
0.2043851912021637,
0.5623967051506042,
0.35267919301986694,
-0.4624268114566803,
-0.6513338088989258,
-0.5938056707382202,
-0.6792227029800415,
-0.46136727929115295,
0.0434122197329998,
-0.527567982673645,
0.15399083495140076,
-0.1313716322183609,
-0.019855475053191185,
-0.04469725117087364,
-0.010755845345556736,
-0.5949299335479736,
0.21506954729557037,
0.34777143597602844,
0.9942542910575867,
-0.40089812874794006,
1.0104291439056396,
0.563674807548523,
-0.6123759150505066,
-0.4347575008869171,
-0.2140413522720337,
-0.08923272043466568,
-0.8928483724594116,
0.9483091235160828,
-0.20788808166980743,
-0.17330098152160645,
-0.05552685260772705,
-0.4638355076313019,
-1.0632634162902832,
1.2716503143310547,
0.5297830104827881,
-0.2778315544128418,
-0.5126453042030334,
0.020247716456651688,
0.4156850576400757,
-0.2975861728191376,
0.32176944613456726,
0.0224011167883873,
0.5176150798797607,
0.34241577982902527,
-0.8529259562492371,
-0.23881112039089203,
-0.5475199818611145,
0.08377991616725922,
0.022422723472118378,
-0.45751824975013733,
0.5124508142471313,
-0.260306179523468,
0.05141500011086464,
0.41920286417007446,
0.7541866898536682,
0.25541386008262634,
0.1506350189447403,
0.3133860230445862,
0.23912861943244934,
0.6027590036392212,
0.20087574422359467,
1.1936728954315186,
-0.11020561307668686,
-0.16125358641147614,
1.0762250423431396,
0.0709519162774086,
1.0363765954971313,
1.002503752708435,
0.13044653832912445,
0.7258918881416321,
0.4884459972381592,
0.3330223262310028,
0.7087798118591309,
-0.2651101052761078,
-0.4160480201244354,
-0.15623092651367188,
-0.33085742592811584,
-0.3351459503173828,
0.3743661046028137,
0.5787540078163147,
-0.2721972167491913,
0.0035830072592943907,
0.09808751195669174,
-0.5027320384979248,
-0.018948618322610855,
-0.46971872448921204,
1.0603337287902832,
0.026891566812992096,
-0.7137875556945801,
0.3373473584651947,
-0.2559598386287689,
0.6364351511001587,
-0.8192062973976135,
-0.17799094319343567,
-0.3421240746974945,
-0.18495263159275055,
-0.33087724447250366,
-0.7903080582618713,
0.23253871500492096,
-0.11214485764503479,
-0.2573458254337311,
-0.029610609635710716,
0.925416886806488,
-0.5743818879127502,
-0.5968579053878784,
0.29216811060905457,
0.8614460229873657,
-0.022113341838121414,
0.35118207335472107,
-0.5326528549194336,
-0.1382829248905182,
-0.16899560391902924,
-0.3418298661708832,
0.43156298995018005,
0.5538825392723083,
-0.0865643322467804,
0.8609593510627747,
0.740424394607544,
-0.1306014209985733,
0.3807334303855896,
0.024037355557084084,
1.0306445360183716,
-0.34212061762809753,
-0.2854875326156616,
-0.46450817584991455,
0.772291362285614,
-0.11507173627614975,
-0.18496903777122498,
0.9559786319732666,
0.44645217061042786,
0.7201717495918274,
-0.16405938565731049,
0.7352637052536011,
-0.22183670103549957,
0.20942842960357666,
-0.6457421183586121,
0.4819059669971466,
-0.9587839245796204,
-0.03062288649380207,
-0.43452680110931396,
-0.776329517364502,
0.08581709116697311,
0.3603915870189667,
0.06567270308732986,
-0.15700289607048035,
0.5786775350570679,
0.9101036190986633,
-0.029994450509548187,
-0.2388838231563568,
0.6032251119613647,
0.11466559767723083,
0.06499514728784561,
0.45302993059158325,
1.317110538482666,
-0.47403615713119507,
1.0632275342941284,
-0.3031140863895416,
0.02682587131857872,
-0.07661861926317215,
-0.661528468132019,
-0.860551655292511,
-0.9302037358283997,
-0.038280047476291656,
-0.06796524673700333,
0.05683073401451111,
0.5999628901481628,
0.6419065594673157,
-0.375462144613266,
-0.04684454947710037,
0.313831090927124,
0.2775610089302063,
0.19865809381008148,
-0.21376127004623413,
0.17745348811149597,
-0.4091266691684723,
-0.7758747935295105,
0.5683198571205139,
0.3567504584789276,
-0.13643689453601837,
-0.5478936433792114,
-0.15594272315502167,
-0.4185314476490021,
0.20615912973880768,
0.9366114139556885,
0.05785412713885307,
-0.7428281307220459,
-0.35168835520744324,
0.08075002580881119,
-0.024036889895796776,
0.21108224987983704,
0.7889790534973145,
-0.8067417740821838,
0.702126145362854,
0.7857698798179626,
0.6688375473022461,
0.7050913572311401,
-0.10264114290475845,
0.5812843441963196,
-0.8904396295547485,
0.22088360786437988,
-0.09243312478065491,
0.3707733154296875,
0.4178059995174408,
-0.3928978443145752,
0.19044427573680878,
0.20447759330272675,
-0.29801347851753235,
-0.7126836776733398,
0.39872634410858154,
-0.8077733516693115,
-0.24967950582504272,
1.0486894845962524,
0.06848053634166718,
-0.28538358211517334,
-0.278598427772522,
-0.36584940552711487,
0.14410290122032166,
-0.07031849026679993,
0.4958729147911072,
0.5445800423622131,
-0.2561143636703491,
-0.3831392228603363,
-0.810712993144989,
0.31352499127388,
-0.08442489802837372,
-1.254461407661438,
-0.305927574634552,
0.7196945548057556,
0.3800332844257355,
0.37119561433792114,
0.8648464679718018,
-0.21672804653644562,
0.4859730899333954,
0.13159047067165375,
-0.2965548634529114,
-0.12663842737674713,
-0.46681785583496094,
0.07755438983440399,
0.4028371274471283,
0.22536391019821167,
-0.13192743062973022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15272v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15272v3
|
CT-GLIP: 3D Grounded Language-Image Pretraining with CT Scans and Radiology Reports for Full-Body Scenarios
| 2024-04-23T17:59:01 | 2024-04-29T03:25:14 |
Jingyang Lin, Yingda Xia, Jianpeng Zhang, Ke Yan, Le Lu, Jiebo Luo, Ling Zhang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Medical Vision-Language Pretraining (Med-VLP) establishes a connection
between visual content from medical images and the relevant textual
descriptions. Existing Med-VLP methods primarily focus on 2D images depicting a
single body part, notably chest X-rays. In this paper, we extend the scope of
Med-VLP to encompass 3D images, specifically targeting full-body scenarios, by
using a multimodal dataset of CT images and reports. Compared with the 2D
counterpart, 3D VLP is required to effectively capture essential semantics from
significantly sparser representation in 3D imaging. In this paper, we introduce
CT-GLIP (Grounded Language-Image Pretraining with CT scans), a novel method
that constructs organ-level image-text pairs to enhance multimodal contrastive
learning, aligning grounded visual features with precise diagnostic text.
Additionally, we developed an abnormality dictionary to augment contrastive
learning with diverse contrastive pairs. Our method, trained on a multimodal CT
dataset comprising 44,011 organ-level vision-text pairs from 17,702 patients
across 104 organs, demonstrates it can identify organs and abnormalities in a
zero-shot manner using natural languages. The performance of CT-GLIP is
validated on a separate test set of 1,130 patients, focusing on the 16 most
frequent abnormalities across 7 organs. The experimental results show our
model's superior performance over the standard CLIP framework across zero-shot
and fine-tuning scenarios, using both CNN and ViT architectures.
|
[
-0.27708569169044495,
-0.5086520314216614,
0.7021090984344482,
0.05492003634572029,
-0.7882511019706726,
-0.1268123984336853,
0.021046115085482597,
-0.6686790585517883,
0.3268720805644989,
0.5161605477333069,
-0.2945651412010193,
-0.6414113640785217,
-0.5559273362159729,
0.19529210031032562,
-0.12147136777639389,
0.7998202443122864,
0.19747906923294067,
0.4925525188446045,
-0.13051970303058624,
-0.26743295788764954,
-0.513344943523407,
-0.586579442024231,
-0.3604065477848053,
0.07597312331199646,
0.3009490966796875,
0.2551058530807495,
0.6844832301139832,
0.6972963809967041,
0.5783001780509949,
0.23950053751468658,
0.15105657279491425,
0.12004220485687256,
-0.2415756732225418,
-0.1388440579175949,
-0.034439992159605026,
-0.34122785925865173,
-0.2874382734298706,
-0.19588018953800201,
0.46214860677719116,
0.6332798004150391,
0.15244996547698975,
-0.4396374523639679,
-0.07489313930273056,
0.6002671718597412,
-0.7381020784378052,
0.05961420387029648,
-0.3487336039543152,
0.31139853596687317,
-0.09048302471637726,
-0.5312083959579468,
-0.15142922103405,
0.0021583300549536943,
0.24956637620925903,
-1.0036072731018066,
0.23503921926021576,
-0.21411961317062378,
1.1158428192138672,
0.27704769372940063,
-0.5461830496788025,
-0.4322117269039154,
-0.17669939994812012,
0.5327765941619873,
-0.27268144488334656,
0.685196042060852,
0.3009642958641052,
0.37841883301734924,
0.12522147595882416,
-0.5708196759223938,
-0.37860721349716187,
-0.47052085399627686,
-0.2183661162853241,
0.6012818217277527,
0.21100839972496033,
0.42548245191574097,
-0.14379166066646576,
0.5771340727806091,
-0.6910125017166138,
0.03820669278502464,
-0.5781111717224121,
-0.32111862301826477,
0.1806175261735916,
0.16539011895656586,
0.5390954613685608,
-0.15075838565826416,
-0.7442606687545776,
-0.21646803617477417,
-0.7423403859138489,
-0.3150782883167267,
-0.22177959978580475,
0.25647610425949097,
-0.5807152390480042,
0.7145134210586548,
0.0034220197703689337,
0.7868350148200989,
-0.09147029370069504,
-0.4039047062397003,
0.6327733397483826,
-0.6829569935798645,
-0.36207619309425354,
-0.0037445807829499245,
0.6227280497550964,
0.708674430847168,
0.1651841104030609,
0.02867019921541214,
0.11517702788114548,
0.05490260198712349,
0.28330567479133606,
-0.7444974780082703,
-0.17637227475643158,
0.2730567455291748,
-0.5218881368637085,
-0.43241217732429504,
0.0028679377865046263,
-0.9190872311592102,
-0.8592101335525513,
-0.48170435428619385,
0.32184404134750366,
-0.7491636276245117,
-0.3363571763038635,
0.5952155590057373,
-0.12782932817935944,
0.07206039130687714,
0.49299412965774536,
-0.6301979422569275,
0.11166823655366898,
0.32857391238212585,
0.9077273011207581,
0.10008934140205383,
-0.17097319662570953,
-0.659415066242218,
0.3419990837574005,
-0.2794117033481598,
0.6526356339454651,
-0.3254624903202057,
-0.5372487306594849,
0.2269316017627716,
0.07846758514642715,
0.03412482887506485,
-0.45188507437705994,
0.3004355728626251,
0.13791733980178833,
0.42267027497291565,
-0.15643949806690216,
-0.272489994764328,
-0.04695245996117592,
0.5818333625793457,
-0.6442562937736511,
0.5181454420089722,
0.12067986279726028,
-0.7581265568733215,
0.6868728995323181,
-0.3813171088695526,
-0.4940450191497803,
0.057458844035863876,
-0.8834038972854614,
-0.27501219511032104,
0.25191956758499146,
0.4287240505218506,
0.5292562246322632,
-0.2647797167301178,
0.008921358734369278,
-0.07549162954092026,
-0.3706923723220825,
-0.3047190308570862,
-0.23362581431865692,
0.5153272747993469,
0.021822329610586166,
-0.2535426914691925,
0.19772179424762726,
-0.9823338985443115,
-0.08153635263442993,
0.17868831753730774,
-0.23732136189937592,
-0.38635945320129395,
-0.19494028389453888,
0.09659240394830704,
0.38867607712745667,
0.07949429750442505,
-0.5579738616943359,
0.3025309145450592,
-0.6604357361793518,
0.061969831585884094,
0.20405350625514984,
-0.14626149833202362,
0.20430532097816467,
-0.29209691286087036,
0.46895161271095276,
0.5947433114051819,
0.303926944732666,
-0.46655577421188354,
-0.6162987351417542,
-0.6473107933998108,
-0.7738040685653687,
-0.22600851953029633,
0.5863143801689148,
-1.1434005498886108,
0.2838159501552582,
-0.24274437129497528,
-0.40903201699256897,
-0.6467660665512085,
-0.16407102346420288,
0.8038512468338013,
0.9043384790420532,
0.6835983991622925,
-0.3377043306827545,
-0.5672388076782227,
-0.9598073363304138,
0.22847244143486023,
-0.17913110554218292,
-0.2551420331001282,
0.379865825176239,
0.1065075695514679,
-0.3045400083065033,
0.42577505111694336,
-0.37889984250068665,
-0.9763454794883728,
-0.23721075057983398,
0.12177956104278564,
0.21798589825630188,
0.6097507476806641,
0.8686224818229675,
-0.84649258852005,
-0.30040520429611206,
0.39843302965164185,
-0.6354593634605408,
0.09701044857501984,
-0.2602202892303467,
0.10364203155040741,
0.19180229306221008,
0.6393146514892578,
-0.12105444073677063,
0.5812786817550659,
0.6511219143867493,
-0.42558160424232483,
0.32676175236701965,
-0.6118023991584778,
0.25449636578559875,
-1.1412742137908936,
0.1028779074549675,
-0.000060282181948423386,
-0.2280726432800293,
-0.5406748056411743,
0.15083180367946625,
0.14971111714839935,
-0.1659606397151947,
-0.7455760836601257,
0.6887003183364868,
-0.6199071407318115,
0.09659352898597717,
-0.08894933760166168,
-0.14231441915035248,
0.16035838425159454,
0.25900542736053467,
0.570013165473938,
0.6472095251083374,
0.7976729869842529,
-0.6155757904052734,
-0.1480875015258789,
0.14377504587173462,
-0.17243699729442596,
0.753857433795929,
-0.5271833539009094,
0.05718636512756348,
-0.23108746111392975,
0.042566750198602676,
-0.899093747138977,
-0.2908690571784973,
0.12180228531360626,
-0.3023681044578552,
0.382301390171051,
-0.19659890234470367,
-0.3130618929862976,
-0.2669435739517212,
-0.3899992108345032,
0.61551433801651,
0.18157753348350525,
-0.3660241365432739,
0.6733521223068237,
0.1369553655385971,
0.3413715064525604,
-0.6290314197540283,
-0.8273363709449768,
-0.025906270369887352,
0.08537434041500092,
-0.3467526137828827,
0.3675273656845093,
0.09282343089580536,
0.23259200155735016,
-0.07695365697145462,
-0.028100628405809402,
-0.482983261346817,
-0.011340932920575142,
0.21227025985717773,
0.3227843642234802,
-0.2309635877609253,
0.15173396468162537,
-0.19971245527267456,
-0.19216673076152802,
-0.34079670906066895,
-0.1208072379231453,
0.6219213008880615,
-0.2634807825088501,
-0.4871768355369568,
-0.45982444286346436,
0.4490543603897095,
0.7973200082778931,
0.019306186586618423,
0.33315548300743103,
0.6694930791854858,
-0.4572422206401825,
0.6582319140434265,
-0.6154863834381104,
0.0016234867507591844,
-0.3875672221183777,
0.7419089674949646,
-0.3815343379974365,
-0.7585526704788208,
0.20886337757110596,
0.20916981995105743,
-0.09839296340942383,
0.09033658355474472,
0.6059247851371765,
-0.1488095223903656,
1.009257435798645,
0.9309712648391724,
-0.007393484469503164,
0.20463311672210693,
-0.11359952390193939,
-0.057250965386629105,
-0.7507468461990356,
-0.23298360407352448,
-0.36006638407707214,
0.084110789000988,
-0.2986886203289032,
-0.6607460975646973,
0.5568201541900635,
0.04672059416770935,
-0.07863014191389084,
-0.1303439885377884,
-0.633572518825531,
0.5918365716934204,
0.31485599279403687,
0.4333046078681946,
0.20662175118923187,
-0.017879795283079147,
-0.5838671922683716,
-0.2779541611671448,
-0.29670605063438416,
-0.20834855735301971,
1.2163262367248535,
0.0721028745174408,
0.3339291214942932,
-0.08735431730747223,
0.595098078250885,
-0.12790127098560333,
0.270041286945343,
-0.850729763507843,
0.23757965862751007,
-0.547269344329834,
-0.4278196394443512,
0.0886361300945282,
-0.027804438024759293,
-0.7988779544830322,
0.42884230613708496,
-0.4855150878429413,
-0.3852050006389618,
0.14864982664585114,
0.5052317976951599,
-0.5045086145401001,
0.22958925366401672,
-0.5520594120025635,
0.8187713027000427,
-0.6175118684768677,
-0.26241976022720337,
-0.026391321793198586,
-0.8993975520133972,
0.42703771591186523,
0.03537725284695625,
0.2810390591621399,
0.1953742653131485,
-0.2983663082122803,
0.09882234036922455,
-0.34163931012153625,
0.857180655002594,
-0.37403637170791626,
-0.03965108469128609,
-0.2648738920688629,
-0.11985796689987183,
-0.16619227826595306,
0.2481044977903366,
0.2994527220726013,
0.34218695759773254,
0.11723919957876205,
-0.43459832668304443,
-0.25119611620903015,
0.2480955272912979,
-0.8010650873184204,
-0.24563132226467133,
-0.39230528473854065,
-0.26188454031944275,
-0.5242988467216492,
0.5796622633934021,
0.5927090048789978,
0.5295534729957581,
-0.16943135857582092,
0.39989975094795227,
0.5787683129310608,
-0.6227956414222717,
-0.06840668618679047,
0.3864544630050659,
-0.404602587223053,
-0.7223865389823914,
0.8462365865707397,
-0.178646519780159,
0.22137458622455597,
0.650351881980896,
0.3413861095905304,
-0.28017815947532654,
-0.7179970145225525,
-0.45019394159317017,
0.31159889698028564,
-0.5238056182861328,
-0.25743773579597473,
-0.6285108327865601,
-0.02726146951317787,
-0.3051254451274872,
-0.62281733751297,
-0.5324018597602844,
0.08432773500680923,
-0.27138853073120117,
0.07896316051483154,
-0.08184191584587097,
0.22831958532333374,
-0.16592882573604584,
0.15354368090629578,
-0.8759100437164307,
0.6282358765602112,
0.08903287351131439,
0.1804804801940918,
-0.3796533942222595,
-0.15256643295288086,
-0.20642633736133575,
0.022399943321943283,
-0.05193611979484558,
-0.7718307375907898,
0.2995484173297882,
0.32046979665756226,
0.27326080203056335,
0.6808220744132996,
-0.25543537735939026,
1.1231577396392822,
-0.4477534592151642,
0.8386461734771729,
0.8355919718742371,
-0.7799467444419861,
0.6908851861953735,
-0.3277047276496887,
0.40467584133148193,
0.7688674330711365,
0.403961181640625,
-0.37164315581321716,
-0.34653642773628235,
-0.27955129742622375,
-0.9744381904602051,
0.19741524755954742,
-0.16096943616867065,
-0.01182568073272705,
-0.32828986644744873,
0.3051448166370392,
0.1243334636092186,
0.28359952569007874,
-0.6795921325683594,
0.13856980204582214,
-0.66172194480896,
-0.3651847839355469,
-0.11347980797290802,
-0.2556721568107605,
-0.26185545325279236,
-0.5762711763381958,
0.09334856271743774,
-0.5152534246444702,
0.4748789370059967,
0.5614555478096008,
-0.21685059368610382,
0.35601434111595154,
-0.009374060668051243,
0.9753664135932922,
0.47511422634124756,
-0.20255619287490845,
0.17023253440856934,
-0.20602257549762726,
-1.0778052806854248,
0.0824304148554802,
-0.18444857001304626,
0.3449937701225281,
0.05628260597586632,
0.42774102091789246,
0.6304070949554443,
0.31590887904167175,
-0.8648902177810669,
1.1029579639434814,
-0.3041960299015045,
-0.5531665682792664,
-0.33906134963035583,
-0.2079843282699585,
-0.13098682463169098,
-0.0705958902835846,
0.11261807382106781,
-0.012409450486302376,
0.07775376737117767,
-0.30193692445755005,
0.2247413545846939,
0.23556013405323029,
-0.6395639777183533,
-0.3401944637298584,
0.6246543526649475,
0.27787697315216064,
0.5623997449874878,
0.7633461952209473,
0.096284881234169,
-0.3305412828922272,
0.5365649461746216,
0.5502867698669434,
0.6029343605041504,
-0.06133298575878143,
0.09424737840890884,
0.3422740399837494,
0.42006945610046387,
0.12274189293384552,
0.6057618260383606,
-0.03207661211490631,
-0.7906716465950012,
-0.4851141571998596,
-0.3452923595905304,
-0.2093660980463028,
0.5169999003410339,
-0.7069381475448608,
0.7144240736961365,
-0.7871352434158325,
0.27416834235191345,
-0.27023813128471375,
-0.19846369326114655,
-0.7834921479225159,
0.6380415558815002,
0.375387579202652,
0.7078682780265808,
-0.8103519082069397,
0.9821268916130066,
1.0182114839553833,
-0.557120144367218,
-0.6571194529533386,
-0.0032977061346173286,
0.2802395820617676,
-1.0947823524475098,
0.5683670043945312,
0.5959395170211792,
0.04265298694372177,
-0.21790951490402222,
-0.26709356904029846,
-0.6648492813110352,
0.8411707878112793,
0.3702467679977417,
-0.49903836846351624,
-0.12109261006116867,
0.3024669885635376,
0.6015445590019226,
-0.38465818762779236,
0.3395182490348816,
0.13263683021068573,
0.33353373408317566,
0.22950339317321777,
-0.9945952892303467,
-0.012774154543876648,
-0.2763911783695221,
-0.08561153709888458,
-0.030459709465503693,
-0.37989774346351624,
0.7431652545928955,
-0.1442624032497406,
-0.12355298548936844,
0.11948567628860474,
0.4009036421775818,
0.48046451807022095,
0.1637435257434845,
0.6577627062797546,
0.6669248938560486,
0.6503008008003235,
0.0012569052632898092,
1.051544427871704,
-0.4803096055984497,
0.044794946908950806,
0.9175371527671814,
-0.3525705933570862,
0.5289151072502136,
0.5893086791038513,
0.4726411700248718,
0.06640918552875519,
0.3076930344104767,
0.11767366528511047,
0.7898904085159302,
0.11457403749227524,
-0.2203546166419983,
-0.38127052783966064,
0.0230899415910244,
-0.6961895823478699,
0.6637408137321472,
0.607542872428894,
-0.1436663419008255,
-0.44928571581840515,
0.5372037291526794,
0.10540321469306946,
-0.09531371295452118,
-0.2591957151889801,
0.7173810601234436,
-0.09669432789087296,
-0.13902594149112701,
0.7203295826911926,
-0.5968225598335266,
0.8401337265968323,
-0.5723387598991394,
-0.23178879916667938,
-0.0793418437242508,
0.2577614486217499,
-0.07469132542610168,
-0.628411591053009,
0.39185598492622375,
-0.30897000432014465,
0.010191470384597778,
-0.07982221245765686,
0.547862708568573,
-0.24513232707977295,
-0.4828222393989563,
0.31973838806152344,
0.29461759328842163,
0.18067823350429535,
-0.026954203844070435,
-0.6857982873916626,
0.06124858558177948,
0.024305950850248337,
0.13947153091430664,
0.3770390748977661,
0.5634568929672241,
0.0318412110209465,
0.34372222423553467,
0.5194084644317627,
0.2922096252441406,
-0.1969851404428482,
0.028228474780917168,
1.0753214359283447,
-0.49183204770088196,
-0.6813771724700928,
-0.4207592308521271,
0.7859050631523132,
-0.16201533377170563,
-0.6792860627174377,
0.22233076393604279,
0.6130288243293762,
0.98283451795578,
-0.147119402885437,
0.7303361296653748,
0.07702983915805817,
0.4430978298187256,
-0.9274874925613403,
0.7321665287017822,
-1.1100306510925293,
-0.133928120136261,
-0.28120550513267517,
-0.35368868708610535,
-0.8537164926528931,
0.7774751782417297,
0.01703449711203575,
-0.15035003423690796,
1.0007517337799072,
0.5051057934761047,
-0.17840571701526642,
-0.36580169200897217,
0.6315978765487671,
0.15943528711795807,
0.4667434096336365,
0.5268474817276001,
0.4338621199131012,
-0.19998592138290405,
0.35209473967552185,
-0.2121095359325409,
-0.3793520927429199,
-0.41459399461746216,
-0.9440405964851379,
-0.9481559991836548,
-0.5364343523979187,
-0.24955207109451294,
-0.14273105561733246,
0.2123923897743225,
0.7208867073059082,
0.8293375968933105,
-0.4634263217449188,
0.09349522739648819,
-0.15499413013458252,
-0.41518810391426086,
-0.11361414194107056,
-0.13739895820617676,
0.5347387790679932,
-0.39001962542533875,
-0.47106048464775085,
0.5278992652893066,
0.6275563836097717,
0.3049394190311432,
-0.11900060623884201,
0.17318835854530334,
0.013394714333117008,
-0.4646412432193756,
0.6068202257156372,
0.393852561712265,
-0.5876209735870361,
-0.3725661635398865,
-0.08025564253330231,
-0.19396251440048218,
0.30732977390289307,
0.8527682423591614,
-0.8578139543533325,
0.8065499067306519,
0.11790414154529572,
0.6698646545410156,
0.2350342720746994,
-0.12915977835655212,
0.47859978675842285,
-0.6402360200881958,
0.8846059441566467,
0.530787467956543,
0.4646559953689575,
0.23879244923591614,
-0.3818148076534271,
0.37674999237060547,
0.22582978010177612,
-0.18581460416316986,
-0.6664443016052246,
0.18056663870811462,
-1.2502413988113403,
-0.3546793460845947,
0.9888513088226318,
-0.13703285157680511,
-0.1516811102628708,
-0.4523404836654663,
-0.47474128007888794,
-0.045412976294755936,
0.10613054782152176,
0.6561490893363953,
0.2305910438299179,
0.01618368551135063,
-0.2591809034347534,
-0.519397497177124,
0.5047783255577087,
0.45361244678497314,
-0.7345256805419922,
-0.538917601108551,
0.7179054617881775,
0.23259536921977997,
0.3854823410511017,
1.0005648136138916,
-0.521323025226593,
0.522651731967926,
-0.18742117285728455,
0.25103679299354553,
-0.27783504128456116,
-0.5007553696632385,
-0.14468757808208466,
0.2475818246603012,
-0.3274719715118408,
-0.5095158219337463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15271v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15271v1
|
Automatic Layout Planning for Visually-Rich Documents with Instruction-Following Models
| 2024-04-23T17:58:33 | 2024-04-23T17:58:33 |
Wanrong Zhu, Jennifer Healey, Ruiyi Zhang, William Yang Wang, Tong Sun
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in instruction-following models have made user
interactions with models more user-friendly and efficient, broadening their
applicability. In graphic design, non-professional users often struggle to
create visually appealing layouts due to limited skills and resources. In this
work, we introduce a novel multimodal instruction-following framework for
layout planning, allowing users to easily arrange visual elements into tailored
layouts by specifying canvas size and design purpose, such as for book covers,
posters, brochures, or menus. We developed three layout reasoning tasks to
train the model in understanding and executing layout instructions. Experiments
on two benchmarks show that our method not only simplifies the design process
for non-professionals but also surpasses the performance of few-shot GPT-4V
models, with mIoU higher by 12% on Crello. This progress highlights the
potential of multimodal instruction-following models to automate and simplify
the design process, providing an approachable solution for a wide range of
design tasks on visually-rich documents.
|
[
-0.4988178014755249,
-0.3484233617782593,
0.6228522062301636,
0.29968035221099854,
0.03374575823545456,
-0.3200397193431854,
0.08428788185119629,
-0.21731138229370117,
0.050338320434093475,
0.5409839749336243,
-0.8556399345397949,
-0.6833264827728271,
-0.2979764938354492,
-0.20091742277145386,
-0.08021263778209686,
0.3864486813545227,
-0.33195817470550537,
-0.23463046550750732,
-0.23072417080402374,
0.10141744464635849,
-0.7996903657913208,
0.050542641431093216,
0.11192233860492706,
0.07931310683488846,
0.8482354283332825,
0.7519950270652771,
0.6288774013519287,
0.825432538986206,
0.40449652075767517,
0.2863328158855438,
0.34934520721435547,
0.5280394554138184,
-0.11574513465166092,
0.0760200098156929,
-0.008523987606167793,
-0.17075614631175995,
-0.5455462336540222,
-0.01856796070933342,
0.38311630487442017,
0.5535274147987366,
0.02498694695532322,
-0.08916731923818588,
0.1116565689444542,
0.5885083675384521,
-0.8635537028312683,
0.2832833230495453,
0.0076761143282055855,
0.1441483050584793,
0.01655852422118187,
-0.5238535404205322,
-0.7891093492507935,
-0.3444579839706421,
-0.002911555813625455,
-1.0369517803192139,
0.12140880525112152,
0.01125358883291483,
0.40849170088768005,
0.047404397279024124,
-0.44379326701164246,
-0.40383055806159973,
-0.38500556349754333,
0.6221323013305664,
-0.3434208035469055,
0.7669057846069336,
0.39695850014686584,
0.21096301078796387,
-0.0071044797077775,
-0.6099094152450562,
-0.33024853467941284,
-0.17591999471187592,
-0.1928461343050003,
0.3484416902065277,
0.1782377064228058,
0.2509145736694336,
0.3441932201385498,
-0.05441081523895264,
-0.8843631148338318,
-0.10712263733148575,
-0.37417805194854736,
-0.1396435797214508,
0.5636444091796875,
0.1960345059633255,
0.6860414743423462,
-0.04810810461640358,
-0.6768670082092285,
-0.1792629361152649,
-0.47368356585502625,
-0.08883055299520493,
0.4776422679424286,
-0.0018562156474217772,
-0.15702052414417267,
0.6087064146995544,
-0.18197821080684662,
0.8211541175842285,
-0.1571328043937683,
-0.17755180597305298,
-0.10125108063220978,
-0.6192804574966431,
-0.08559022843837738,
-0.2987293601036072,
0.3842695355415344,
0.6014090776443481,
0.14057528972625732,
0.14083217084407806,
-0.3769485354423523,
-0.19641321897506714,
0.3006899058818817,
-0.81297367811203,
-0.838728129863739,
-0.19905824959278107,
-0.4044928550720215,
-0.13556233048439026,
-0.24725688993930817,
-0.8549352884292603,
-0.3577873706817627,
-0.4923323690891266,
0.5510433316230774,
-0.6169400811195374,
0.05706530436873436,
-0.031420253217220306,
-0.2358987182378769,
0.09317190200090408,
0.9011176228523254,
-1.0151554346084595,
-0.13869985938072205,
0.2985752522945404,
0.7020987272262573,
0.22047561407089233,
-0.35642772912979126,
-0.48944783210754395,
0.6129196286201477,
-0.6513776183128357,
1.0292558670043945,
-0.7633673548698425,
-0.6559646129608154,
-0.0623898059129715,
-0.22670212388038635,
-0.07913089543581009,
0.054616570472717285,
0.28272363543510437,
-0.3802375793457031,
0.392322301864624,
-0.3066815435886383,
-0.43834686279296875,
-0.3009640872478485,
0.3854583501815796,
-0.5943629145622253,
0.4099155366420746,
0.15986046195030212,
-0.6618483662605286,
0.25938042998313904,
-0.5652497410774231,
-0.5163013935089111,
0.14155130088329315,
-0.23536227643489838,
-0.3011009097099304,
-0.01952059008181095,
0.2656366229057312,
0.22746790945529938,
0.24913932383060455,
-0.33299222588539124,
-0.47298723459243774,
-0.42818665504455566,
-0.24196405708789825,
-0.3674556016921997,
0.6244960427284241,
0.03880609571933746,
-0.21829430758953094,
0.3563322424888611,
-0.6350333094596863,
0.2874784767627716,
-0.0016146665439009666,
-0.44454342126846313,
-0.22370107471942902,
-0.1766400933265686,
0.304379403591156,
0.3809221088886261,
0.3563660979270935,
-0.1280701458454132,
0.6390582919120789,
0.061412516981363297,
-0.038258254528045654,
0.8517702221870422,
0.0005482335691340268,
0.957082986831665,
-0.17701290547847748,
0.7252355813980103,
-0.43835389614105225,
0.2583784759044647,
-0.9085792303085327,
-0.5108227133750916,
-0.5964105129241943,
-0.4970373511314392,
0.12875866889953613,
0.5692059993743896,
-0.8191078305244446,
-0.008200152777135372,
0.22078825533390045,
-0.4615495800971985,
0.16992729902267456,
0.2442086935043335,
0.4827945828437805,
0.3202672600746155,
0.3135347068309784,
-0.41410309076309204,
-0.2810915410518646,
-0.9509683847427368,
0.06964997947216034,
0.19408082962036133,
0.14979104697704315,
0.2829524278640747,
0.4535023272037506,
-0.21069329977035522,
0.4261524975299835,
-0.8261764645576477,
-0.3878467082977295,
-0.34821900725364685,
0.27435871958732605,
-0.34634876251220703,
0.4433887302875519,
0.5624952912330627,
-0.7722055912017822,
-0.8285725712776184,
0.046903274953365326,
-0.7156895995140076,
-0.18518276512622833,
-0.43268051743507385,
-0.5217164158821106,
0.00885529164224863,
0.14957614243030548,
-0.769162654876709,
0.8200662136077881,
0.1591465175151825,
-0.3001861274242401,
0.7638548612594604,
-0.41181620955467224,
0.042523521929979324,
-0.9280896782875061,
-0.13609598577022552,
0.38304248452186584,
0.0808589830994606,
-0.6220531463623047,
0.17870450019836426,
0.4364835321903229,
-0.27880364656448364,
-0.14135855436325073,
0.635364830493927,
-0.9428212642669678,
-0.23327645659446716,
-0.35009637475013733,
-0.16025671362876892,
0.7084686160087585,
0.7268754839897156,
0.18112404644489288,
0.7812212109565735,
0.3172408640384674,
-0.29827916622161865,
0.2186490297317505,
0.4884946942329407,
-0.32545092701911926,
0.7715239524841309,
-0.3117336630821228,
-0.1912062168121338,
-0.21153919398784637,
0.48541131615638733,
-1.113323450088501,
-0.527137815952301,
0.3137907385826111,
-0.155033677816391,
0.39679139852523804,
-0.29045072197914124,
-0.6294427514076233,
-0.2621341645717621,
-0.31690356135368347,
0.13103613257408142,
0.0339474119246006,
-0.349751353263855,
0.9593933820724487,
0.010387208312749863,
-0.32071593403816223,
-0.4917001724243164,
-0.5625362992286682,
-0.15635596215724945,
0.010363033972680569,
-0.851161539554596,
0.4793802797794342,
-0.2354915589094162,
0.039494551718235016,
-0.3400239646434784,
-0.10976184159517288,
-0.222085639834404,
-0.12272057682275772,
0.2872301936149597,
0.471855491399765,
-0.061858829110860825,
0.015530713833868504,
0.020744184032082558,
-0.14748072624206543,
-0.2922942042350769,
-0.35822901129722595,
0.33236217498779297,
0.12966226041316986,
-0.6969066858291626,
-1.0528285503387451,
0.713293194770813,
0.4804377257823944,
-0.5667403936386108,
0.2764092981815338,
0.4997740089893341,
-0.2796950340270996,
-0.21091565489768982,
-0.2839130461215973,
-0.0508987195789814,
-0.5045367479324341,
0.3140139579772949,
-0.41269591450691223,
-0.054167479276657104,
0.1463005244731903,
0.10917365550994873,
0.5535817742347717,
0.008541088551282883,
0.4485582709312439,
-0.639477550983429,
1.2713637351989746,
0.9313027262687683,
0.6757264733314514,
0.8835033178329468,
-0.3469769358634949,
0.06694180518388748,
-0.6350516676902771,
-0.43064752221107483,
-0.12032569944858551,
-0.505140483379364,
-0.24935182929039001,
-0.6320397853851318,
0.5021665692329407,
-0.07186037302017212,
0.015332934446632862,
0.44368526339530945,
-0.5011807084083557,
0.6156051158905029,
0.7385287284851074,
-0.01759982481598854,
0.11421883851289749,
0.02224666438996792,
-0.27375084161758423,
0.21528318524360657,
-0.639371395111084,
-0.45855802297592163,
0.6707125902175903,
0.17072176933288574,
1.0119949579238892,
-0.0161907821893692,
0.7292075753211975,
0.05194846913218498,
0.3659496009349823,
-0.5880933403968811,
0.5030548572540283,
0.03412633389234543,
-0.5527322888374329,
-0.25903499126434326,
-0.17871645092964172,
-0.5538294911384583,
0.3314407765865326,
-0.1629864126443863,
-0.5981726050376892,
0.4469519257545471,
0.3444807231426239,
-0.37697553634643555,
0.21257559955120087,
-1.2311567068099976,
0.9811263084411621,
-0.5483235120773315,
-0.4435272216796875,
-0.044913001358509064,
-0.5090346932411194,
0.38917726278305054,
0.16396091878414154,
0.24809972941875458,
-0.11628927290439606,
0.04826732352375984,
0.2555081844329834,
-0.26801398396492004,
0.7565981149673462,
-0.33521097898483276,
-0.07710610330104828,
0.2791404724121094,
0.32804450392723083,
0.39257729053497314,
-0.23932293057441711,
0.1455015391111374,
-0.4315047562122345,
-0.0052219294011592865,
-0.3552066683769226,
-0.8055214881896973,
0.589951753616333,
-0.5325552821159363,
-0.4260810911655426,
-0.12325575947761536,
-0.9753641486167908,
0.01662440598011017,
0.5208521485328674,
0.2968886196613312,
0.8477840423583984,
-0.15223905444145203,
-0.0045596580021083355,
0.7875910401344299,
-0.2986453175544739,
0.4004845917224884,
0.13130974769592285,
-0.18765340745449066,
-0.2888329029083252,
1.0579817295074463,
0.33564111590385437,
0.07096546143293381,
0.6461938619613647,
-0.023389821872115135,
-0.4756987392902374,
-0.4070965051651001,
-0.8181675672531128,
-0.06448450684547424,
-0.9302209615707397,
0.01760348118841648,
-0.5568065643310547,
0.07456965744495392,
-0.3040297329425812,
-0.6175053715705872,
-0.18568405508995056,
-0.4945510923862457,
-0.2879282534122467,
0.24714894592761993,
-0.3297131657600403,
0.8590039610862732,
0.14407487213611603,
0.33915969729423523,
-0.6568340063095093,
0.3043797016143799,
0.553116500377655,
0.4401019215583801,
0.06062361225485802,
-0.2890876531600952,
-0.08872506767511368,
-0.14552824199199677,
-0.8798131346702576,
-1.0632929801940918,
0.3034176230430603,
-0.1015184074640274,
0.7587011456489563,
0.489254891872406,
-0.04604101553559303,
0.6007750630378723,
-0.6031046509742737,
0.262163370847702,
0.4278624951839447,
-0.40153801441192627,
0.6121939420700073,
-0.6648169755935669,
0.5329638719558716,
0.2738056480884552,
0.4176482856273651,
-0.3054082691669464,
0.22807902097702026,
-0.5963937044143677,
-0.7411791682243347,
0.5736124515533447,
0.21071645617485046,
-0.0009573791176080704,
0.2807103097438812,
0.030192773789167404,
0.1339862048625946,
0.020462878048419952,
-0.438189834356308,
0.14739225804805756,
-0.4856051504611969,
-0.2556895613670349,
0.11575241386890411,
-0.19790787994861603,
-0.17798492312431335,
-0.022993043065071106,
0.6434627175331116,
-0.38134628534317017,
0.443153977394104,
-0.28047922253608704,
-0.2579249143600464,
0.17383694648742676,
0.16618521511554718,
1.0401026010513306,
0.9818663001060486,
0.08478858321905136,
-0.07298065721988678,
-0.1521349847316742,
-0.07232049107551575,
0.12223435938358307,
0.2811623215675354,
-0.1421024352312088,
-0.19226548075675964,
0.3909967243671417,
0.7642028331756592,
0.27373000979423523,
-0.4665062725543976,
0.6985260844230652,
-0.13328638672828674,
-0.31465744972229004,
-0.38045963644981384,
0.22156524658203125,
0.15933525562286377,
0.3905232548713684,
0.11393189430236816,
0.1393272429704666,
0.24582771956920624,
-0.29226529598236084,
0.4076620638370514,
0.35365059971809387,
-0.16836416721343994,
-0.33918169140815735,
0.7093578577041626,
0.30648985505104065,
-0.27656054496765137,
0.5898338556289673,
0.12304777652025223,
-0.19942717254161835,
0.6633634567260742,
0.4538639783859253,
0.44344449043273926,
-0.0696985051035881,
0.5109096169471741,
0.14896301925182343,
0.08432672172784805,
0.10689413547515869,
0.24372194707393646,
-0.42066338658332825,
-0.2867642939090729,
-0.15733937919139862,
-0.22449049353599548,
-0.5035826563835144,
-0.45210444927215576,
-0.5395010113716125,
0.4540223777294159,
-0.7256262302398682,
0.03169678896665573,
0.11269157379865646,
-0.15568678081035614,
-0.6437968611717224,
0.2983752191066742,
0.4683557450771332,
1.1564255952835083,
-0.5591637492179871,
0.544660747051239,
0.7050440311431885,
-0.6127021908760071,
-0.562412679195404,
0.20726248621940613,
0.4518570601940155,
-0.6457402110099792,
0.4692695736885071,
0.5550942420959473,
-0.047525450587272644,
-0.0005743785877712071,
-0.3646865785121918,
-0.5293352007865906,
1.1143074035644531,
0.029958974570035934,
-0.5701860785484314,
-0.5271432399749756,
-0.33896493911743164,
0.1385529488325119,
-0.2864547371864319,
0.3521450459957123,
-0.07267732173204422,
0.5065571665763855,
0.40220528841018677,
-0.4010065495967865,
-0.3084326386451721,
-0.3458346128463745,
0.11483853310346603,
0.2840319573879242,
-0.7103811502456665,
0.5191701054573059,
-0.3611200153827667,
0.0015810950426384807,
0.2900855243206024,
0.67619389295578,
0.4512682855129242,
0.3768095076084137,
0.4647164046764374,
0.45455628633499146,
0.6828612089157104,
0.12829779088497162,
1.0770468711853027,
-0.20813460648059845,
-0.14889541268348694,
1.1241153478622437,
-0.04061216115951538,
0.5404749512672424,
0.14106570184230804,
0.34165892004966736,
0.5583487749099731,
0.5340001583099365,
0.07833103835582733,
0.8015733361244202,
-0.3349257707595825,
-0.11820915341377258,
-0.3916073441505432,
0.0643075555562973,
-0.2115173637866974,
0.3527742922306061,
0.4426465332508087,
-0.403439462184906,
-0.4255366325378418,
0.02571435645222664,
-0.27700275182724,
0.012349508702754974,
-0.16807562112808228,
0.5317835807800293,
-0.13598357141017914,
-0.5252373814582825,
0.21792533993721008,
0.1486649364233017,
0.15580210089683533,
-0.5480362176895142,
-0.3279458284378052,
-0.2583155632019043,
0.0760638415813446,
-0.23225979506969452,
-1.2074986696243286,
-0.025577396154403687,
-0.3426028788089752,
-0.26559093594551086,
-0.6931145787239075,
0.7295210957527161,
-0.20166455209255219,
-0.42276349663734436,
-0.0006051663658581674,
0.47042006254196167,
-0.2763109505176544,
0.034808944910764694,
-0.6111980676651001,
0.02739802561700344,
0.0883055180311203,
-0.19018501043319702,
0.3998744785785675,
0.48426583409309387,
-0.46864762902259827,
0.7642040848731995,
0.535243570804596,
-0.4441203773021698,
0.1612701416015625,
0.07022491097450256,
0.8529803156852722,
-0.43263909220695496,
-0.7691357731819153,
-0.454150527715683,
0.7467377185821533,
-0.01903378777205944,
-0.1974318027496338,
0.46425795555114746,
0.6224901676177979,
0.7794376015663147,
-0.144931361079216,
0.7844023108482361,
0.31696557998657227,
-0.036272771656513214,
-0.5278711318969727,
0.6699901223182678,
-0.7123247385025024,
0.02503306418657303,
-0.3656329810619354,
-1.086503028869629,
-0.45354291796684265,
0.8162039518356323,
-0.587872326374054,
0.08423382043838501,
0.3772401511669159,
0.7040942907333374,
-0.3208574652671814,
0.06742986291646957,
0.23132410645484924,
-0.466286838054657,
0.47872787714004517,
0.49634280800819397,
0.8747615218162537,
0.15268297493457794,
0.6243157982826233,
-0.5080863237380981,
-0.3289988040924072,
-0.36830368638038635,
-0.672110915184021,
-0.9361296892166138,
-0.48783403635025024,
-0.15965862572193146,
0.16513963043689728,
-0.12797586619853973,
0.8016469478607178,
0.9308915138244629,
-0.2980763912200928,
0.05652527138590813,
0.09577609598636627,
0.1318439543247223,
-0.21657873690128326,
-0.19686532020568848,
0.2650797665119171,
0.016385801136493683,
-0.42570924758911133,
0.3481461703777313,
0.5767165422439575,
0.3084315359592438,
-0.23641012609004974,
-0.1496388167142868,
-0.2896479368209839,
0.11333602666854858,
0.5247523188591003,
0.2935793399810791,
-0.6482099294662476,
-0.06006384640932083,
-0.06120209023356438,
-0.40912535786628723,
0.18344441056251526,
0.6136897802352905,
-0.3159250319004059,
0.653363823890686,
0.7662585973739624,
0.4173263907432556,
0.3995421826839447,
0.2303495705127716,
0.5214089155197144,
-0.7984663844108582,
-0.053672466427087784,
-0.09000121057033539,
0.4388888478279114,
0.3273833692073822,
-0.34851139783859253,
0.37861189246177673,
0.17244312167167664,
-0.34320268034935,
-0.5200899243354797,
0.44632241129875183,
-0.7652207016944885,
-0.246907576918602,
0.7596260905265808,
-0.14491815865039825,
-0.018122324720025063,
0.23181603848934174,
-0.5067738890647888,
0.08598323166370392,
-0.28387516736984253,
0.6716197729110718,
0.5815744996070862,
-0.5483851432800293,
-0.7099214196205139,
-0.74275141954422,
0.06846839189529419,
-0.03654316067695618,
-0.9317092299461365,
-0.1097072958946228,
0.9198861122131348,
0.15283721685409546,
0.28786179423332214,
0.8167176246643066,
0.1545247882604599,
0.7061812877655029,
0.04110565036535263,
0.1257789582014084,
-0.33329537510871887,
-0.962483286857605,
0.3665713965892792,
0.4032430946826935,
-0.17534604668617249,
-0.17097587883472443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15269v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15269v2
|
Aligning LLM Agents by Learning Latent Preference from User Edits
| 2024-04-23T17:57:47 | 2024-06-09T21:45:09 |
Ge Gao, Alexey Taymanov, Eduardo Salinas, Paul Mineiro, Dipendra Misra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
We study interactive learning of LLM-based language agents based on user
edits made to the agent's output. In a typical setting such as writing
assistants, the user interacts with a language agent to generate a response
given a context, and may optionally edit the agent response to personalize it
based on their latent preference, in addition to improving the correctness. The
edit feedback is naturally generated, making it a suitable candidate for
improving the agent's alignment with the user's preference, and for reducing
the cost of user edits over time. We propose a learning framework, PRELUDE that
infers a description of the user's latent preference based on historic edit
data. The inferred user preference descriptions are used to define prompts for
generating responses in the future. This avoids fine-tuning the agent, which is
costly, challenging to scale with the number of users, and may even degrade its
performance on other tasks. Furthermore, learning descriptive preference
improves interpretability, allowing the user to view and modify the learned
preference. However, user preference can be complex, subtle, and vary based on
context, making it challenging to learn. To address this, we propose a simple
yet effective algorithm named CIPHER that leverages the LLM to infer the user
preference for a given context based on user edits. In the future, CIPHER
retrieves inferred preferences from the k-closest contexts in the history, and
forms an aggregate preference for response generation. We introduce two
interactive environments -- summarization and email writing, and use a GPT-4
simulated user for evaluation. On both tasks, CIPHER outperforms several
baselines by achieving the lowest edit distance cost while only having a small
overhead in LLM query cost. Our analysis reports that user preferences learned
by CIPHER show significant similarity to the ground truth latent preferences.
|
[
-0.13804863393306732,
-0.6127150058746338,
0.7286841869354248,
-0.14231038093566895,
0.055546827614307404,
0.3438412845134735,
-0.4118158519268036,
-0.3472205102443695,
0.4565456807613373,
0.48119547963142395,
-0.6064605712890625,
-0.5287027955055237,
-0.3144451081752777,
0.18401184678077698,
0.26364898681640625,
0.9847949147224426,
-0.04906996339559555,
-0.0059563652612268925,
-0.25798025727272034,
-0.03474358469247818,
-0.243422269821167,
-0.5685650706291199,
-0.7652242183685303,
-0.349816232919693,
0.5631960034370422,
0.5788084268569946,
0.8507341146469116,
0.8566005229949951,
0.33549782633781433,
0.384112685918808,
0.0683651715517044,
0.27540192008018494,
-0.521385669708252,
0.4003128111362457,
-0.15070798993110657,
-0.6452957987785339,
-0.7591394186019897,
0.05871555581688881,
0.4375263452529907,
0.4692164957523346,
0.038525424897670746,
-0.19325873255729675,
0.008426705375313759,
0.6444433331489563,
-0.5437427163124084,
0.08310969173908234,
-0.8706316351890564,
0.07551606744527817,
-0.27837368845939636,
-0.525364100933075,
-0.4647108316421509,
-0.2830771207809448,
0.21182116866111755,
-0.7706691026687622,
-0.003014231100678444,
-0.12091460824012756,
0.47021394968032837,
0.34136763215065,
-0.3696659505367279,
-0.4815562069416046,
-0.47143062949180603,
0.7120900750160217,
-0.4450394809246063,
0.5523571968078613,
0.6012223362922668,
0.30602407455444336,
-0.2695136070251465,
-0.6444536447525024,
-0.50530606508255,
-0.14058546721935272,
-0.022803895175457,
0.43515220284461975,
0.1427159160375595,
-0.0001132184115704149,
0.09607232362031937,
-0.0720236524939537,
-0.5235505104064941,
0.2620898187160492,
-0.028902141377329826,
-0.48776984214782715,
0.4856469929218292,
0.3807962238788605,
0.2583081126213074,
0.18465442955493927,
-0.23284316062927246,
-0.09334181994199753,
-0.7781119346618652,
0.39148610830307007,
0.6005605459213257,
0.22397136688232422,
-0.27817976474761963,
0.5383260250091553,
-0.09640851616859436,
0.5953527688980103,
0.408281534910202,
-0.5116754770278931,
0.17193210124969482,
0.046398892998695374,
-0.06238779425621033,
0.12492671608924866,
0.4099131226539612,
0.6394126415252686,
0.14163242280483246,
-0.44747450947761536,
-0.3267207145690918,
0.1589750051498413,
0.20903392136096954,
-0.7229815721511841,
-0.1951761096715927,
0.02019248902797699,
-0.1259402185678482,
-0.35896652936935425,
-0.0882016122341156,
-0.5112016797065735,
-0.46534472703933716,
-0.391629695892334,
0.03960629925131798,
-0.330663800239563,
0.30038416385650635,
-0.17359422147274017,
0.14816002547740936,
0.20077399909496307,
0.6797305345535278,
-1.2420940399169922,
0.3833143413066864,
0.6123467087745667,
0.5905702710151672,
-0.36673447489738464,
-0.41933366656303406,
-0.7409869432449341,
0.2625446617603302,
-0.13319635391235352,
0.7657399773597717,
-0.7737279534339905,
-0.3202401399612427,
-0.193010151386261,
-0.1937187761068344,
0.06000277027487755,
-0.26534852385520935,
0.07715044170618057,
-1.0118850469589233,
0.4864140748977661,
-0.13100279867649078,
-0.7335987687110901,
0.2787335515022278,
0.12854520976543427,
-0.5710980296134949,
0.7081359028816223,
0.25544309616088867,
-0.6836758852005005,
0.4066849648952484,
-0.5235175490379333,
-0.2782469093799591,
0.08791913837194443,
-0.3105517327785492,
-0.47644439339637756,
-0.08771533519029617,
0.3229827582836151,
0.1942232847213745,
0.0825018659234047,
-0.0313851572573185,
-0.25641950964927673,
-0.3520011603832245,
0.7109736204147339,
-0.2625959813594818,
0.5334721207618713,
0.24347928166389465,
-0.13663141429424286,
0.23978984355926514,
-0.4284965693950653,
-0.12643155455589294,
-0.10517536103725433,
-0.6433467864990234,
-0.058869779109954834,
-0.08220266550779343,
-0.24825412034988403,
-0.09008489549160004,
0.6905206441879272,
-0.31297993659973145,
0.47200483083724976,
-0.7604812383651733,
0.25906258821487427,
1.2732971906661987,
0.06803171336650848,
0.8666631579399109,
-0.43752217292785645,
0.534984290599823,
-0.19112268090248108,
0.08438921719789505,
-0.0727301687002182,
-0.20732922852039337,
-0.613124430179596,
-0.18891233205795288,
0.18783172965049744,
0.4329511225223541,
-0.667344868183136,
0.29096993803977966,
-0.25092610716819763,
-0.0964764878153801,
-0.39034512639045715,
0.4201797842979431,
0.2700163722038269,
0.8135451674461365,
0.21473592519760132,
-0.2839182913303375,
-0.4121319651603699,
-0.6594899892807007,
-0.29824554920196533,
-0.49880126118659973,
0.0006379691767506301,
0.5265418887138367,
0.04876990616321564,
-0.28942403197288513,
1.1943131685256958,
-0.6609605550765991,
-0.13869014382362366,
-0.03793952986598015,
-0.1246052160859108,
-0.036175329238176346,
0.2046690434217453,
0.3716428577899933,
-0.7788819074630737,
-0.7379084825515747,
0.06127132847905159,
-0.5246627926826477,
-0.33692994713783264,
-0.05114269629120827,
-0.1097259521484375,
0.5153148174285889,
0.4123726785182953,
-0.17082366347312927,
0.20508871972560883,
0.28659334778785706,
-0.27162331342697144,
0.3454577326774597,
-0.21411529183387756,
-0.03446399047970772,
-1.3127071857452393,
-0.17581817507743835,
-0.35632815957069397,
-0.4007377326488495,
-0.390060693025589,
-0.09579524397850037,
0.24692368507385254,
0.11214012652635574,
-0.501189649105072,
0.7903892397880554,
-0.46883222460746765,
-0.09384536743164062,
-0.3125722110271454,
0.1284102350473404,
-0.2522600591182709,
0.7442201375961304,
0.18254856765270233,
1.1110528707504272,
0.3236960470676422,
-0.32740896940231323,
0.19096378982067108,
0.28867796063423157,
0.03893095254898071,
0.5031712651252747,
-0.22540152072906494,
0.6446568369865417,
-0.08328469097614288,
0.051275964826345444,
-0.879688024520874,
-0.31014934182167053,
0.33481577038764954,
-0.5710835456848145,
0.19807854294776917,
-0.29056477546691895,
-0.19516874849796295,
0.2956715524196625,
-0.5647791028022766,
0.15933337807655334,
0.4794001579284668,
-0.47611504793167114,
0.6280840039253235,
0.3237074911594391,
-0.20871664583683014,
-0.8399198651313782,
-0.4182452857494354,
0.08765480667352676,
-0.2785401940345764,
-0.5111641883850098,
0.4993199408054352,
-0.5545471906661987,
-0.22319366037845612,
0.012581635266542435,
-0.2425224334001541,
0.021030360832810402,
0.33723434805870056,
0.40340882539749146,
0.3086489737033844,
-0.01974998600780964,
0.05303432047367096,
0.12631042301654816,
-0.3424204885959625,
-0.20503801107406616,
-0.3126586675643921,
0.4107237160205841,
-0.263568639755249,
-0.3325112462043762,
-0.2305539846420288,
-0.011492354795336723,
0.4785861670970917,
-0.2339368760585785,
0.5135126113891602,
0.24130839109420776,
-0.16033338010311127,
-0.18610748648643494,
-0.5167054533958435,
-0.5099093317985535,
-0.5156711935997009,
0.0605597198009491,
-0.5379939675331116,
-1.102629542350769,
0.670841634273529,
0.0040478790178895,
0.10488783568143845,
0.05583919212222099,
0.7790870666503906,
-0.2902119755744934,
0.8101296424865723,
0.6055537462234497,
-0.13536527752876282,
0.7404153943061829,
0.016471853479743004,
-0.1816132366657257,
-0.8302115797996521,
-0.0786503404378891,
-0.22645121812820435,
-0.3433297872543335,
-0.5327641367912292,
-0.1629263162612915,
0.5240554213523865,
-0.08481753617525101,
-0.08046868443489075,
0.04383422061800957,
-0.10172927379608154,
0.6527649760246277,
0.3986364006996155,
0.3473416566848755,
0.31110620498657227,
0.11622639745473862,
-0.2635057270526886,
-0.22370564937591553,
-0.2771603763103485,
-0.6955676078796387,
1.4433836936950684,
0.13223204016685486,
0.9279578328132629,
0.5045479536056519,
0.906791627407074,
0.5195567011833191,
0.32801350951194763,
-0.6862630248069763,
0.45618969202041626,
0.28554481267929077,
0.04356371983885765,
-0.40807291865348816,
-0.3182849586009979,
-1.0498526096343994,
0.1043158620595932,
-0.30738598108291626,
-0.8667760491371155,
-0.21124470233917236,
0.3791201114654541,
-0.3257192373275757,
0.013102618977427483,
-0.4937891960144043,
0.5845739245414734,
-0.29059961438179016,
-0.7365319132804871,
-0.014692398719489574,
-0.8886012434959412,
-0.08320660144090652,
-0.1598917841911316,
-0.17086371779441833,
0.15188585221767426,
-0.45913609862327576,
0.5891669988632202,
-0.4675963222980499,
0.9779307246208191,
0.07018045336008072,
0.05428255721926689,
-0.13133788108825684,
0.23897716403007507,
0.7100743055343628,
0.3780639171600342,
-0.21099574863910675,
-0.426111102104187,
-0.4648325443267822,
-0.16560129821300507,
-0.8940607309341431,
0.7735520005226135,
-1.0714207887649536,
-0.7441340088844299,
-0.37293851375579834,
-0.4851141571998596,
-0.2944202125072479,
0.24086222052574158,
0.16551470756530762,
0.40011683106422424,
-0.3335312008857727,
-0.08809184283018112,
0.6415225267410278,
0.19564035534858704,
0.4341023862361908,
0.9809929728507996,
-0.16759571433067322,
-0.5631059408187866,
0.671827495098114,
-0.06923491507768631,
0.16003280878067017,
0.6718055605888367,
0.3444443941116333,
-0.5717220902442932,
-0.6087756156921387,
-0.43397828936576843,
0.1294572800397873,
-0.8083170652389526,
-0.14109687507152557,
-0.6980234980583191,
-0.008104810491204262,
-0.42237532138824463,
-0.6475874185562134,
-0.07256448268890381,
-0.31050291657447815,
-0.4440760016441345,
-0.01132897287607193,
0.23651936650276184,
0.4275481700897217,
0.09443387389183044,
0.6359638571739197,
-0.28598979115486145,
0.21734803915023804,
0.47385773062705994,
0.2034226953983307,
-0.27262359857559204,
-0.5124688744544983,
-0.2628091275691986,
-0.01155602466315031,
-0.5250721573829651,
-1.0557557344436646,
0.26848673820495605,
0.08284588158130646,
0.5705297589302063,
0.4027613699436188,
0.12140343338251114,
0.3930474519729614,
-0.30947941541671753,
0.6613869071006775,
-0.06474516540765762,
-0.9759742021560669,
0.46504461765289307,
-0.045630645006895065,
0.2927192747592926,
0.7542740106582642,
0.1358199119567871,
-0.5870908498764038,
-0.44789278507232666,
-0.5726305246353149,
-0.6007702946662903,
0.8088188171386719,
0.08720624446868896,
-0.01711323857307434,
0.12970241904258728,
0.4587092101573944,
0.29616907238960266,
0.14555634558200836,
-0.6767809391021729,
-0.23381225764751434,
-0.04798019677400589,
-0.2627671957015991,
-0.12605814635753632,
-0.23380598425865173,
-0.07819264382123947,
0.10612192004919052,
0.6415837407112122,
-0.49859949946403503,
0.08983734995126724,
0.001046643010340631,
-0.5759885907173157,
-0.2676655650138855,
0.383516788482666,
0.6607154011726379,
0.8158305287361145,
-0.38452965021133423,
0.3583609163761139,
0.34302088618278503,
-0.4442022144794464,
0.16966108977794647,
-0.14409199357032776,
-0.3099258840084076,
-0.5090031623840332,
0.47744229435920715,
0.7866302728652954,
0.12273536622524261,
-0.5080505609512329,
0.5898810625076294,
-0.2708069980144501,
0.03719246760010719,
-0.3294133245944977,
0.17543944716453552,
0.15260016918182373,
0.15785987675189972,
0.09706658869981766,
0.14246101677417755,
0.017664052546024323,
-0.3724324107170105,
0.2515125274658203,
0.4849388003349304,
-0.2788711488246918,
-0.48572173714637756,
0.5318982601165771,
0.2267513871192932,
-0.5221693515777588,
0.6130879521369934,
-0.10690507292747498,
-0.6049924492835999,
0.3162287771701813,
0.6562250852584839,
0.9671180844306946,
-0.3583697974681854,
0.08376151323318481,
-0.12998314201831818,
0.16091297566890717,
0.3943544626235962,
0.21078677475452423,
-0.35210686922073364,
-0.943207323551178,
-0.10871127247810364,
-0.48014676570892334,
-0.6787499189376831,
0.1580744832754135,
-0.3392462730407715,
0.2881035804748535,
-0.5760616064071655,
-0.10849957913160324,
-0.002255842322483659,
0.1637251377105713,
-0.7020375728607178,
-0.0933317095041275,
-0.028603699058294296,
0.5242369771003723,
-0.7968553304672241,
0.9499184489250183,
0.9151085019111633,
-0.36397784948349,
-0.6040370464324951,
0.23857524991035461,
0.3877321481704712,
-1.0668048858642578,
0.4827466607093811,
0.04760938882827759,
-0.36491137742996216,
-0.09026960283517838,
-0.328491747379303,
-0.6666032671928406,
1.077736496925354,
0.588282585144043,
-0.22784818708896637,
0.16108886897563934,
0.161372110247612,
0.6549649238586426,
-0.5757631659507751,
0.4939768314361572,
0.30804458260536194,
0.3577674627304077,
-0.03899257630109787,
-0.5667176842689514,
0.029879309237003326,
-0.15806983411312103,
-0.242587611079216,
0.11751290410757065,
-0.629173994064331,
0.7290756106376648,
-0.1812812089920044,
-0.2916736304759979,
-0.08012498170137405,
0.8197594285011292,
0.02805793285369873,
0.33526119589805603,
0.46925726532936096,
0.3938405513763428,
0.8377766013145447,
0.20451095700263977,
0.7265685796737671,
-0.4699583947658539,
0.09562957286834717,
1.3171844482421875,
-0.4655117988586426,
0.6352024674415588,
0.6534250974655151,
-0.011604897677898407,
0.36456891894340515,
0.6032945513725281,
0.3833124339580536,
0.6310920715332031,
0.07768874615430832,
-0.4301730692386627,
-0.17717544734477997,
-0.0915406122803688,
-0.10288140922784805,
0.3596051335334778,
0.26156073808670044,
-0.17736995220184326,
-0.2056875079870224,
-0.19462832808494568,
0.15592697262763977,
0.359814316034317,
0.00922461412847042,
1.2720712423324585,
-0.1395888477563858,
-0.7965202927589417,
0.34490394592285156,
0.1105659157037735,
0.43629634380340576,
-0.6809977293014526,
-0.01312401331961155,
-0.49324658513069153,
0.07767905294895172,
-0.2458941638469696,
-0.793086588382721,
0.03001355566084385,
0.00009870346548268571,
-0.24944718182086945,
-0.32412049174308777,
0.583098828792572,
-0.5960618853569031,
-0.034253209829330444,
0.11250586062669754,
0.48611530661582947,
0.05948629975318909,
0.1618577241897583,
-0.70025634765625,
0.1404169797897339,
0.17187495529651642,
-0.2976340055465698,
0.4646669626235962,
0.10107917338609695,
-0.26015862822532654,
0.6124498844146729,
0.7109382748603821,
0.1497882455587387,
-0.21525415778160095,
-0.07015607506036758,
0.8951901793479919,
-0.45022863149642944,
-0.8317325115203857,
-1.0393149852752686,
0.2869502007961273,
-0.028675677254796028,
-0.14671096205711365,
0.6794054508209229,
0.7566695213317871,
0.8354652523994446,
-0.0013687306782230735,
0.8425217270851135,
0.37257394194602966,
0.24211223423480988,
-0.8818349838256836,
0.4871308505535126,
-0.341360867023468,
0.5489321947097778,
-0.10788360238075256,
-1.0815107822418213,
-0.10358361154794693,
0.3396346867084503,
-0.404950886964798,
-0.10465504974126816,
0.6208274364471436,
1.1126395463943481,
-0.22388680279254913,
-0.23015429079532623,
0.2665484845638275,
-0.07552860677242279,
0.4438692331314087,
0.7039510011672974,
0.9076650738716125,
-0.0014577106339856982,
0.19986934959888458,
-0.26792922616004944,
-0.35958510637283325,
-0.3633189797401428,
-0.9640344381332397,
-1.0013341903686523,
-0.5830658674240112,
-0.10067151486873627,
-0.2836315929889679,
0.283661425113678,
1.3375197649002075,
0.3899862766265869,
-0.501124382019043,
-0.2983429431915283,
0.22893282771110535,
0.3832649290561676,
-0.12027399986982346,
-0.14793601632118225,
0.5783024430274963,
-0.3487042784690857,
-0.7738248705863953,
0.5820133686065674,
0.3657831847667694,
0.3390128016471863,
-0.010822807438671589,
-0.546863853931427,
0.24491971731185913,
0.06946774572134018,
0.29732343554496765,
0.3449651300907135,
-0.8300666213035583,
-0.3578416407108307,
0.12674939632415771,
-0.3757483959197998,
0.29228559136390686,
0.8048632144927979,
-0.6746063232421875,
0.672466516494751,
0.40084683895111084,
0.8832266926765442,
0.6083135008811951,
0.09609103947877884,
0.5516857504844666,
-0.7755231857299805,
0.036688417196273804,
0.09079744666814804,
0.26489564776420593,
0.4125363528728485,
-0.7639416456222534,
0.31457316875457764,
0.16345000267028809,
-0.5157541632652283,
-0.4644371271133423,
0.2864242196083069,
-1.1328444480895996,
-0.10616419464349747,
0.8526626229286194,
-0.19768503308296204,
-0.22417153418064117,
-0.07353438436985016,
-0.3443618416786194,
0.18414154648780823,
-0.7710705399513245,
0.6831466555595398,
0.4760502278804779,
-0.36114853620529175,
0.054079245775938034,
0.05043821036815643,
0.8295077681541443,
0.4331222474575043,
-0.7027579545974731,
0.06130719557404518,
0.6290298104286194,
0.36218133568763733,
-0.13918539881706238,
0.9463076591491699,
0.18248394131660461,
0.3162073493003845,
-0.3622196614742279,
-0.016551313921809196,
-0.3486076593399048,
-0.49557384848594666,
-0.48049724102020264,
0.09363016486167908,
0.3982546329498291,
0.12529295682907104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15247v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15247v2
|
XFT: Unlocking the Power of Code Instruction Tuning by Simply Merging Upcycled Mixture-of-Experts
| 2024-04-23T17:32:24 | 2024-06-06T18:18:21 |
Yifeng Ding, Jiawei Liu, Yuxiang Wei, Terry Yue Zhuo, Lingming Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SE
|
We introduce XFT, a simple yet powerful training scheme, by simply merging
upcycled Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) to unleash the performance limit of
instruction-tuned code Large Language Models (LLMs). While vanilla sparse
upcycling fails to improve instruction tuning, XFT introduces a shared expert
mechanism with a novel routing weight normalization strategy into sparse
upcycling, which significantly boosts instruction tuning. After fine-tuning the
upcycled MoE model, XFT introduces a learnable model merging mechanism to
compile the upcycled MoE model back to a dense model, achieving upcycled
MoE-level performance with only dense-model compute. By applying XFT to a 1.3B
model, we create a new state-of-the-art tiny code LLM (<3B) with 67.1 and 64.6
pass@1 on HumanEval and HumanEval+ respectively. With the same data and model
architecture, XFT improves supervised fine-tuning (SFT) by 13% on HumanEval+,
along with consistent improvements from 2% to 13% on MBPP+, MultiPL-E, and
DS-1000, demonstrating its generalizability. XFT is fully orthogonal to
existing techniques such as Evol-Instruct and OSS-Instruct, opening a new
dimension for improving code instruction tuning. Codes are available at
https://github.com/ise-uiuc/xft.
|
[
-0.5044201016426086,
-0.43288883566856384,
0.4731009900569916,
-0.33471912145614624,
-0.29500308632850647,
0.6771289110183716,
-0.3983408212661743,
-0.5330271124839783,
0.04987108334898949,
0.7500751614570618,
-0.6774475574493408,
-0.19894632697105408,
-0.49534499645233154,
-0.2805616557598114,
-0.6748563051223755,
0.8706182241439819,
0.2708016335964203,
-0.046243831515312195,
0.14181913435459137,
-0.09225545078516006,
-0.3186352550983429,
-0.5184430480003357,
-0.7094367742538452,
-0.19546720385551453,
0.14584024250507355,
0.6122854351997375,
0.9854167103767395,
1.172770619392395,
0.2583252489566803,
0.4415113925933838,
0.025231271982192993,
0.2562854588031769,
-0.605542004108429,
-0.2679097652435303,
-0.12932005524635315,
-0.7383290529251099,
-0.6169773936271667,
-0.17583245038986206,
0.5504889488220215,
0.461245059967041,
-0.43711361289024353,
-0.1070828065276146,
-0.1388915330171585,
0.9449189305305481,
-0.40974825620651245,
-0.04237974062561989,
-0.9517180919647217,
-0.034629177302122116,
-0.16577893495559692,
-0.5753319263458252,
-0.2943122982978821,
-0.1834173947572708,
-0.1950615644454956,
-0.5022726058959961,
0.5166237950325012,
0.40659987926483154,
0.5910533666610718,
0.4384031891822815,
-0.324862539768219,
-0.12606480717658997,
-0.5687654614448547,
1.008729100227356,
-0.532232403755188,
0.626056432723999,
-0.09122328460216522,
0.3592033386230469,
-0.032371196895837784,
-0.521327018737793,
-0.46477243304252625,
-0.0982421338558197,
0.09228482842445374,
-0.2206491082906723,
-0.2923390567302704,
0.3344154357910156,
0.004889912903308868,
0.737428605556488,
-0.2363399863243103,
0.0902068018913269,
-0.4134175777435303,
0.2457093745470047,
0.810092568397522,
0.09010177850723267,
-0.019264336675405502,
0.1527005434036255,
-0.7122279405593872,
-0.2340475618839264,
-0.7270101308822632,
0.041546355932950974,
0.282962441444397,
0.2598082721233368,
-0.04265057295560837,
0.10043621063232422,
-0.05546785145998001,
0.6861410140991211,
0.4421815574169159,
-0.026793526485562325,
0.11161086708307266,
-0.33322152495384216,
-0.31109684705734253,
0.32033011317253113,
0.4281452000141144,
0.3480847477912903,
0.16712965071201324,
-0.2870848476886749,
-0.5402383804321289,
-0.5306798219680786,
0.5286264419555664,
-0.4476986527442932,
-0.34545257687568665,
-0.05128886178135872,
-0.3730565309524536,
-0.5655475854873657,
0.14467136561870575,
-0.7060380578041077,
-0.11136080324649811,
-0.5981569886207581,
0.3804413974285126,
-0.3732817769050598,
-0.31304484605789185,
0.3568577766418457,
-0.12245259433984756,
0.15954916179180145,
0.3683397173881531,
-1.2283984422683716,
0.3329756259918213,
1.032199740409851,
0.47015994787216187,
-0.12678050994873047,
-0.24986834824085236,
-0.59424889087677,
0.08922278881072998,
-0.28085124492645264,
0.5967612266540527,
-0.6493933796882629,
-0.3063248097896576,
-0.17030516266822815,
-0.263460248708725,
-0.105620838701725,
-0.6280294060707092,
0.4714983403682709,
-0.8067976832389832,
-0.01274949125945568,
-0.15697669982910156,
-0.6686670184135437,
-0.23658210039138794,
-0.03583066910505295,
-0.5167296528816223,
1.3967169523239136,
0.6121081709861755,
-0.3998500406742096,
0.45590001344680786,
-0.4468051493167877,
-0.1590006798505783,
-0.005050688050687313,
-0.4830792248249054,
-0.19842781126499176,
0.5294870138168335,
0.09076619893312454,
0.4597112536430359,
-0.328127920627594,
0.25161367654800415,
-0.3090376853942871,
-0.6496492028236389,
0.0437898188829422,
-0.4277799129486084,
0.8423790335655212,
0.1952269971370697,
-0.48357120156288147,
0.30125030875205994,
-1.089609980583191,
0.2922884225845337,
-0.12161296606063843,
-0.4826591908931732,
-0.3678587079048157,
-0.13178257644176483,
-0.08234718441963196,
0.2425607591867447,
0.008877911604940891,
-0.35548004508018494,
0.37139055132865906,
-0.3724413514137268,
0.6203910112380981,
0.9487176537513733,
-0.33214834332466125,
0.6003625392913818,
-0.47567451000213623,
0.4141230583190918,
-0.24178260564804077,
0.043633170425891876,
-0.23792396485805511,
-0.5120924711227417,
-0.7304139733314514,
-0.3386998474597931,
0.3287416696548462,
0.5060057640075684,
-0.7621617317199707,
0.7338478565216064,
-0.32954731583595276,
-0.3166176974773407,
-0.656499981880188,
0.5703312754631042,
0.5741174817085266,
0.5295801162719727,
0.3875409662723541,
-0.09067629277706146,
-0.47903013229370117,
-0.5144891142845154,
0.061021190136671066,
-0.18291650712490082,
-0.004516011103987694,
-0.019281217828392982,
0.3260280191898346,
-0.02250831387937069,
0.7880958914756775,
-0.41876137256622314,
-0.15166211128234863,
-0.27275675535202026,
0.09406286478042603,
0.15579938888549805,
0.787078857421875,
0.6707069277763367,
-0.5652968883514404,
-0.4969114363193512,
0.29167142510414124,
-0.35402190685272217,
0.1556502729654312,
-0.11214998364448547,
-0.22404196858406067,
0.34621647000312805,
0.6812570095062256,
-0.36300575733184814,
0.10354052484035492,
0.589020311832428,
-0.15611623227596283,
0.2733103036880493,
-0.5949856042861938,
0.40896663069725037,
-0.8025702238082886,
-0.4515873193740845,
-0.29003533720970154,
-0.48768532276153564,
-0.3908141851425171,
0.6617942452430725,
0.3055155873298645,
-0.08221837878227234,
-0.3649885058403015,
0.273488312959671,
-0.467298686504364,
0.21121805906295776,
-0.2800271213054657,
-0.17406563460826874,
-0.2047821432352066,
0.7501096129417419,
0.10520358383655548,
0.9123291373252869,
0.5552896857261658,
-0.22124427556991577,
0.17625774443149567,
-0.0651606023311615,
-0.3920931816101074,
0.29798009991645813,
-0.45196282863616943,
0.19332841038703918,
0.32462140917778015,
-0.25539276003837585,
-0.811516284942627,
-0.1487659066915512,
0.07245372980833054,
-0.22144359350204468,
0.7145781517028809,
-0.1575442999601364,
-0.7017627358436584,
-0.2565571665763855,
-0.5531046390533447,
0.15669314563274384,
0.8820164203643799,
-0.8482810258865356,
0.5826667547225952,
0.060464706271886826,
0.006313185673207045,
-0.43889981508255005,
-0.7389466166496277,
-0.007067433092743158,
-0.0675928145647049,
-0.9104722142219543,
0.6183642148971558,
-0.20331606268882751,
0.0699586346745491,
-0.039226025342941284,
-0.331114262342453,
-0.31775158643722534,
0.15819895267486572,
-0.2432921826839447,
0.10614562779664993,
-0.41849079728126526,
0.03658130019903183,
0.7604931592941284,
-0.28828445076942444,
-0.016241323202848434,
-0.32258155941963196,
0.2233160138130188,
-0.07559141516685486,
-0.3172645568847656,
-0.04482134431600571,
0.6533649563789368,
0.4512019753456116,
-0.0787581354379654,
0.49098047614097595,
0.6870689392089844,
-0.09152547270059586,
-0.3007257878780365,
-0.7003675103187561,
-0.1403798907995224,
-0.5980868339538574,
0.329365611076355,
-0.0364726185798645,
-1.3829240798950195,
0.12102060765028,
-0.04202411696314812,
0.18540111184120178,
-0.14261563122272491,
0.5218006372451782,
-0.03481655940413475,
1.365513563156128,
1.119684100151062,
-0.08576156944036484,
0.6254875063896179,
-0.24970854818820953,
0.17549802362918854,
-0.30040180683135986,
0.022283107042312622,
-0.4316885471343994,
-0.2701122760772705,
-0.5150921940803528,
-0.6120457053184509,
0.320099413394928,
0.2679133713245392,
-0.2651602625846863,
0.21509991586208344,
-0.6751058101654053,
0.8540654182434082,
0.9007719159126282,
0.27553999423980713,
0.5574790239334106,
0.3318294286727905,
0.17843660712242126,
0.2644825875759125,
-1.0938889980316162,
-0.26969045400619507,
1.079429030418396,
0.21468660235404968,
0.7951131463050842,
-0.25703006982803345,
1.030950903892517,
0.42935580015182495,
0.020809050649404526,
-0.43487849831581116,
0.5631572604179382,
-0.3463551998138428,
-0.743694007396698,
-0.017785480245947838,
-0.48193666338920593,
-0.5337955355644226,
0.08930179476737976,
-0.24872100353240967,
-0.7354254126548767,
0.3704376816749573,
0.5219091773033142,
-0.8051036596298218,
0.623099148273468,
-0.9113430976867676,
0.5109884142875671,
-0.36727622151374817,
-0.33494865894317627,
-0.6046774983406067,
-0.7648271918296814,
0.5771610736846924,
-0.4479135274887085,
0.07923820614814758,
0.1324864774942398,
-0.24745556712150574,
0.5851669907569885,
-0.6332448720932007,
0.705296516418457,
0.030805017799139023,
-0.271797776222229,
0.07137392461299896,
-0.2540091574192047,
0.279066264629364,
0.10121532529592514,
-0.17861516773700714,
0.21783512830734253,
0.11869172006845474,
-0.5282837748527527,
-0.7950268983840942,
0.7026881575584412,
-0.9378935694694519,
-0.6683214902877808,
-0.0004126502317376435,
-0.7387980222702026,
-0.12887364625930786,
0.2520240247249603,
0.18489864468574524,
0.5817582011222839,
0.37453168630599976,
0.34637218713760376,
1.192986011505127,
0.21393024921417236,
0.18260300159454346,
0.44281238317489624,
-0.20473261177539825,
-0.5695862770080566,
1.0570226907730103,
0.04125000908970833,
0.17952744662761688,
0.6859999895095825,
0.12122226506471634,
-0.08617948740720749,
-0.5993593335151672,
-0.5834226608276367,
-0.07424168288707733,
-0.6219415664672852,
-0.5412799715995789,
-0.4480499029159546,
-0.046796541661024094,
-0.1267467886209488,
-0.7463040947914124,
-0.5647194981575012,
-0.5964494943618774,
-0.14754335582256317,
0.048257485032081604,
0.5260918140411377,
0.5255886316299438,
-0.2508179247379303,
0.7738884091377258,
-1.2978692054748535,
0.0897260308265686,
0.26573705673217773,
0.4720849394798279,
0.12891459465026855,
-0.5223362445831299,
-0.6734523177146912,
0.034676890820264816,
-0.3124012053012848,
-0.6695693731307983,
0.11888427287340164,
0.25778013467788696,
0.6509401798248291,
0.7066837549209595,
0.14045022428035736,
0.6380970478057861,
-0.21818691492080688,
0.42882034182548523,
0.21389028429985046,
-1.1325007677078247,
0.21074178814888,
-0.2703494131565094,
-0.0611930750310421,
0.7518090009689331,
0.3834575414657593,
0.2223304957151413,
-0.4398907423019409,
-0.6405619382858276,
-0.7232257723808289,
0.9423746466636658,
0.019169053062796593,
0.18678827583789825,
0.18289832770824432,
0.38282525539398193,
0.3275124132633209,
0.4367177486419678,
-0.22541306912899017,
-0.20504815876483917,
0.0793369933962822,
-0.18358486890792847,
0.03788261115550995,
-0.15861022472381592,
-0.32640326023101807,
-0.7741917371749878,
0.5534105896949768,
-0.09441808611154556,
0.4853537082672119,
-0.29157739877700806,
0.036124054342508316,
-0.4709380567073822,
0.21083475649356842,
0.4338432848453522,
0.5205890536308289,
-0.595565676689148,
-0.0639619529247284,
0.10059312731027603,
-0.20876330137252808,
0.26279374957084656,
0.2496800720691681,
-0.08373118937015533,
-0.33836179971694946,
0.44829800724983215,
0.7672635912895203,
0.8074801564216614,
-0.674411952495575,
0.28613588213920593,
-0.03972306475043297,
-0.49241578578948975,
0.01191210187971592,
0.8926336765289307,
-0.1521320641040802,
0.4028541147708893,
0.44547680020332336,
0.5414670705795288,
0.04349341243505478,
-0.44023048877716064,
0.3774556815624237,
0.17957690358161926,
-0.3452063202857971,
-0.2710869312286377,
0.7095297574996948,
0.39757081866264343,
-0.11472127586603165,
0.6439430117607117,
-0.40514206886291504,
-0.49153825640678406,
0.3942911624908447,
0.2546410858631134,
0.8225106000900269,
-0.007039850577712059,
-0.15736699104309082,
0.08474394679069519,
0.3932153582572937,
-0.09984356164932251,
0.4156838357448578,
-0.5528709888458252,
-0.6377548575401306,
-0.598648190498352,
-0.35802632570266724,
-0.4168775677680969,
-0.34085315465927124,
-0.9272324442863464,
0.33391621708869934,
-0.4322497248649597,
0.22342270612716675,
-0.34607458114624023,
0.2313649207353592,
-0.4597788453102112,
0.10814774036407471,
0.142215296626091,
1.4201799631118774,
-0.735719621181488,
1.272111177444458,
0.7806500792503357,
-0.1460694819688797,
-0.8795534372329712,
-0.3034529387950897,
0.046516817063093185,
-0.9858546257019043,
0.22374898195266724,
0.1001766249537468,
-0.08299513161182404,
0.37548014521598816,
-0.5951096415519714,
-0.7124335765838623,
1.2310893535614014,
0.5833114385604858,
-0.8693053126335144,
-0.2890649139881134,
-0.032263483852148056,
0.36970576643943787,
-0.455081045627594,
0.17104727029800415,
1.0643749237060547,
0.2900656461715698,
0.20607860386371613,
-0.4202215075492859,
0.015150422230362892,
-0.34154102206230164,
-0.1427132934331894,
0.4281264543533325,
-0.7196179628372192,
0.7626067399978638,
-0.399247944355011,
-0.026117438450455666,
0.14719673991203308,
0.8319905996322632,
0.21971258521080017,
0.21309536695480347,
0.6500052213668823,
0.6497306823730469,
0.9444983005523682,
-0.08950046449899673,
0.9822119474411011,
-0.7987945079803467,
0.31543925404548645,
0.9953265190124512,
-0.10004791617393494,
0.7070186138153076,
0.3546784520149231,
-0.116391621530056,
0.3915206491947174,
0.32892435789108276,
-0.04259592667222023,
0.5331254005432129,
-0.25519075989723206,
-0.24916519224643707,
-0.6204485297203064,
0.5393891930580139,
-0.6325767040252686,
0.2977328300476074,
0.2881847620010376,
-0.32041028141975403,
-0.37469613552093506,
0.03981614485383034,
0.04866694658994675,
0.031020088121294975,
-0.48576661944389343,
0.5650683641433716,
-0.10659108310937881,
-0.4844421148300171,
0.8803254961967468,
0.0019188995938748121,
0.9095463752746582,
-0.753760576248169,
-0.14606748521327972,
-0.13270579278469086,
0.46626466512680054,
-0.1684001237154007,
-0.8895804286003113,
0.46203622221946716,
-0.09002873301506042,
-0.37756720185279846,
-0.3495258390903473,
0.6819132566452026,
-0.48208385705947876,
-0.5351942181587219,
0.41128605604171753,
0.3277477025985718,
-0.17673173546791077,
-0.1196337565779686,
-0.9807425737380981,
0.24623940885066986,
0.3566502034664154,
-0.08414924144744873,
0.73587965965271,
0.631062924861908,
0.06064063683152199,
0.7175308465957642,
0.38627880811691284,
-0.12740366160869598,
0.39686310291290283,
-0.3295957148075104,
1.2256604433059692,
-0.5919158458709717,
-0.44595178961753845,
-0.5168440341949463,
0.5635344386100769,
0.039671510457992554,
-0.2852078378200531,
0.568136990070343,
0.27444103360176086,
1.3066601753234863,
-0.13940323889255524,
0.6018683910369873,
-0.03665674477815628,
0.3900032043457031,
-0.6593753695487976,
0.768348753452301,
-0.9058363437652588,
0.4193595349788666,
-0.08056597411632538,
-0.5853102207183838,
-0.08659691363573074,
0.29164156317710876,
0.06199966371059418,
0.2954685688018799,
0.4546683132648468,
1.0847996473312378,
-0.3124237656593323,
0.09882789850234985,
0.6564573049545288,
-0.1366325169801712,
0.09917464852333069,
0.522506594657898,
0.6840641498565674,
-0.29180634021759033,
0.7897607088088989,
-0.8336224555969238,
-0.5305398106575012,
-0.31682702898979187,
-0.9445046186447144,
-0.8229919075965881,
-0.29237592220306396,
-0.3961736559867859,
0.11720563471317291,
0.08743830770254135,
1.3385363817214966,
1.0642205476760864,
-0.7964128851890564,
-0.2874552011489868,
-0.21809321641921997,
0.19998645782470703,
-0.6584319472312927,
-0.2105025351047516,
0.14624546468257904,
-0.6051825881004333,
-0.6978400349617004,
0.42423146963119507,
0.4326976537704468,
-0.25209543108940125,
-0.19580936431884766,
-0.21725189685821533,
0.13860681653022766,
0.2928066551685333,
0.588037371635437,
0.12104050815105438,
-0.39459383487701416,
-0.1077769473195076,
-0.028293222188949585,
0.13472570478916168,
0.31705814599990845,
1.152313232421875,
-0.6518745422363281,
0.42757847905158997,
0.6519664525985718,
0.7443143725395203,
-0.0064665209501981735,
-0.003915507812052965,
0.643772304058075,
-0.9425055980682373,
-0.17197564244270325,
-0.1458832174539566,
0.3781392574310303,
-0.06667253375053406,
-0.5554409027099609,
0.4979802668094635,
0.15507738292217255,
-0.6962258219718933,
-0.903889000415802,
-0.08897300809621811,
-1.256438970565796,
-0.16447970271110535,
0.5165871977806091,
-0.08199393004179001,
-0.18918444216251373,
-0.06507834792137146,
-0.3798139691352844,
0.0650244727730751,
-0.7341650724411011,
0.8339465856552124,
0.23190337419509888,
-0.23312610387802124,
-0.4331589639186859,
-0.3911639451980591,
0.22184041142463684,
0.37981167435646057,
-0.5714572072029114,
0.10313631594181061,
0.10361135005950928,
0.10626291483640671,
-0.03239162638783455,
0.5577880144119263,
0.013845057226717472,
0.5709112286567688,
0.018081996589899063,
-0.021503370255231857,
-0.5425000786781311,
-0.359409898519516,
-0.48130807280540466,
0.19880208373069763,
0.200420081615448,
0.1436387002468109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15238v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15238v1
|
CultureBank: An Online Community-Driven Knowledge Base Towards Culturally Aware Language Technologies
| 2024-04-23T17:16:08 | 2024-04-23T17:16:08 |
Weiyan Shi, Ryan Li, Yutong Zhang, Caleb Ziems, Chunhua yu, Raya Horesh, Rogério Abreu de Paula, Diyi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
To enhance language models' cultural awareness, we design a generalizable
pipeline to construct cultural knowledge bases from different online
communities on a massive scale. With the pipeline, we construct CultureBank, a
knowledge base built upon users' self-narratives with 12K cultural descriptors
sourced from TikTok and 11K from Reddit. Unlike previous cultural knowledge
resources, CultureBank contains diverse views on cultural descriptors to allow
flexible interpretation of cultural knowledge, and contextualized cultural
scenarios to help grounded evaluation. With CultureBank, we evaluate different
LLMs' cultural awareness, and identify areas for improvement. We also fine-tune
a language model on CultureBank: experiments show that it achieves better
performances on two downstream cultural tasks in a zero-shot setting. Finally,
we offer recommendations based on our findings for future culturally aware
language technologies. The project page is https://culturebank.github.io . The
code and model is at https://github.com/SALT-NLP/CultureBank . The released
CultureBank dataset is at https://huggingface.co/datasets/SALT-NLP/CultureBank .
|
[
-0.47361376881599426,
-0.25109976530075073,
0.1762121468782425,
0.19348275661468506,
-0.056241583079099655,
0.43414226174354553,
-0.40959587693214417,
-0.7455555200576782,
0.6152586936950684,
0.5612189769744873,
-0.34763818979263306,
-0.46165016293525696,
-0.2779199779033661,
0.08333747088909149,
-0.38059261441230774,
0.9907536506652832,
0.0997290164232254,
-0.04377756267786026,
-0.0955660343170166,
-0.08744317293167114,
-0.2697277069091797,
-0.3246711790561676,
-0.5428929328918457,
-0.341704785823822,
0.20139746367931366,
0.539844274520874,
0.19736890494823456,
0.905754566192627,
0.29091787338256836,
0.15590022504329681,
-0.06369151920080185,
-0.27238452434539795,
-0.49043774604797363,
0.2609318792819977,
-0.31342798471450806,
-0.35077452659606934,
-0.48684513568878174,
-0.05614391341805458,
-0.17147651314735413,
0.401252418756485,
0.033578772097826004,
0.7984278798103333,
-0.2337433397769928,
0.6121705174446106,
-0.4473569095134735,
0.32491010427474976,
-0.3633134961128235,
0.09362486749887466,
-0.16346415877342224,
-0.00035248970380052924,
-0.09661231189966202,
-0.3814464807510376,
0.2316754311323166,
-0.505124568939209,
0.018008073791861534,
-0.035725612193346024,
0.32021987438201904,
0.07357236742973328,
-0.6901087164878845,
-0.3834541141986847,
-0.8456026911735535,
0.5675757527351379,
-0.2288774698972702,
0.4107475280761719,
0.7906373739242554,
0.38663873076438904,
0.26075172424316406,
-0.7904490232467651,
-0.4597712755203247,
0.13522504270076752,
-0.044881392270326614,
0.049878936260938644,
-0.05987296625971794,
-0.27352261543273926,
0.15730386972427368,
0.4991997182369232,
-0.6135435104370117,
-0.18544889986515045,
-0.40049687027931213,
-0.4518257975578308,
0.33684855699539185,
-0.05326579511165619,
0.19141699373722076,
-0.3387359380722046,
-0.34705761075019836,
0.15758424997329712,
-0.6459879279136658,
0.20544211566448212,
0.15066134929656982,
0.17185398936271667,
-0.4388694167137146,
-0.02595377527177334,
-0.46959981322288513,
0.6532650589942932,
0.2705188989639282,
-0.5188717246055603,
0.3025180399417877,
-0.22894832491874695,
0.11581000685691833,
0.219381183385849,
0.3753954768180847,
0.6374181509017944,
0.7261579632759094,
0.021345341578125954,
-0.22311200201511383,
-0.0895903930068016,
-0.08285824209451675,
-0.7450723052024841,
-0.31707897782325745,
0.40494754910469055,
-0.5217658281326294,
-0.4321860671043396,
-0.11903225630521774,
-0.569366991519928,
-0.8784964084625244,
-0.032078053802251816,
-0.08798345923423767,
-0.26262366771698,
-0.7320645451545715,
-0.3639414310455322,
-0.4512960910797119,
0.0797063559293747,
0.08815696835517883,
-1.3097410202026367,
-0.03946591541171074,
0.5661824941635132,
0.829896867275238,
0.10558352619409561,
0.2034822553396225,
-0.05378725752234459,
0.4239569902420044,
0.05476412549614906,
0.8036404848098755,
-0.39457762241363525,
-0.40402284264564514,
0.22584059834480286,
-0.1981654167175293,
0.5638432502746582,
-0.5079931020736694,
0.5873438715934753,
-0.5501782298088074,
-0.06734687834978104,
-0.28100934624671936,
-0.39295494556427,
-0.2475123554468155,
0.507917582988739,
-0.7438604831695557,
0.7061386108398438,
0.34560030698776245,
-0.44594231247901917,
0.4145161509513855,
-0.70196932554245,
-0.4368736147880554,
0.5130307674407959,
0.029732218012213707,
0.3777633011341095,
-0.08773159980773926,
0.14859646558761597,
0.3114011883735657,
-0.15692958235740662,
0.4234727919101715,
-0.30992934107780457,
-0.29004502296447754,
0.12158939242362976,
-0.014618666842579842,
0.9799434542655945,
0.9432095289230347,
-0.1368972808122635,
-0.02910863608121872,
-1.0698071718215942,
-0.0967484712600708,
0.08345791697502136,
-0.6037963628768921,
-0.45671677589416504,
-0.0738309770822525,
0.15736015141010284,
0.35080307722091675,
0.5034343600273132,
-0.4310685396194458,
0.14748769998550415,
-0.31967803835868835,
0.7117961645126343,
0.6925356984138489,
-0.3032064437866211,
0.521619975566864,
-0.27421835064888,
0.6124118566513062,
-0.09705542027950287,
0.12236841022968292,
-0.39398476481437683,
-0.39074835181236267,
-0.5335843563079834,
-0.16666050255298615,
0.22123228013515472,
0.7041605710983276,
-0.6744974255561829,
0.30936986207962036,
-0.39349082112312317,
-0.6738737225532532,
-0.4778003692626953,
0.5189476013183594,
-0.009666255675256252,
0.7292755842208862,
0.05613689869642258,
-0.7278838753700256,
-0.8513103723526001,
-0.6417950391769409,
-0.15736673772335052,
-0.6108203530311584,
-0.23678171634674072,
-0.0653996542096138,
0.08046892285346985,
-0.11305192112922668,
1.2366504669189453,
-0.28883588314056396,
-0.38869959115982056,
-0.5188141465187073,
-0.10060378164052963,
0.3693991005420685,
0.2313029021024704,
0.5449254512786865,
-0.6518481969833374,
-0.6936920881271362,
0.09235266596078873,
-0.6984578967094421,
-0.33404871821403503,
0.2337823212146759,
0.06725147366523743,
0.3581339418888092,
0.44927069544792175,
-0.1462559998035431,
-0.008393026888370514,
0.7917787432670593,
-0.5330359935760498,
0.065614253282547,
0.10509420186281204,
0.1281425803899765,
-1.4022331237792969,
0.07752019166946411,
-0.05022532120347023,
-0.30114731192588806,
-0.7953852415084839,
0.040617529302835464,
0.23701421916484833,
-0.12121816724538803,
-0.3262644410133362,
0.8254521489143372,
-0.08854440599679947,
0.06857117265462875,
-0.37700703740119934,
0.1768231838941574,
-0.011704890988767147,
0.39312151074409485,
0.26141253113746643,
0.21417593955993652,
0.5461146235466003,
-0.28184863924980164,
0.7065837979316711,
0.09496501088142395,
-0.7127308249473572,
0.8152869939804077,
-0.1459447145462036,
0.12485843896865845,
-0.06449425220489502,
0.49159491062164307,
-0.8225243091583252,
-0.2753068208694458,
0.3135574162006378,
-0.46558016538619995,
0.06237379461526871,
-0.5045762062072754,
-0.3639413118362427,
-0.37965622544288635,
-0.11533214151859283,
0.4889068007469177,
0.48865756392478943,
-0.46252480149269104,
0.7114948630332947,
0.665024995803833,
-0.31281426548957825,
-0.5713040232658386,
-0.9228595495223999,
0.13943123817443848,
-0.5588273406028748,
-0.7648336887359619,
-0.20087459683418274,
-0.2008657455444336,
-0.568986177444458,
-0.13079074025154114,
0.07697910070419312,
-0.2854071855545044,
0.45082080364227295,
0.24380789697170258,
-0.08797069638967514,
-0.11183179169893265,
0.5572697520256042,
-0.42266812920570374,
-0.08615360409021378,
0.17924192547798157,
-0.8948255181312561,
0.7138302326202393,
-0.2638235092163086,
-0.04848511517047882,
-0.13532839715480804,
0.1903654932975769,
0.35338839888572693,
-0.29006433486938477,
0.6592846512794495,
0.8599027991294861,
-0.4105380177497864,
0.1986130177974701,
-0.7974633574485779,
-0.12939997017383575,
-0.47763821482658386,
0.09318581223487854,
-0.27702292799949646,
-1.2405387163162231,
0.8513275980949402,
-0.05453067272901535,
0.0846334844827652,
0.41293781995773315,
0.7440049648284912,
-0.29264071583747864,
0.4303888976573944,
0.7533620595932007,
-0.23350420594215393,
0.5042304396629333,
0.25927528738975525,
0.16442187130451202,
-0.15109890699386597,
-0.047409795224666595,
-0.24554380774497986,
-0.536842405796051,
-0.7320435047149658,
-0.2305321842432022,
0.2185526341199875,
-0.058846089988946915,
-0.13275574147701263,
0.2854892909526825,
-0.0793086364865303,
0.6136980056762695,
0.7477731108665466,
-0.3413229286670685,
0.7205979228019714,
0.04410358890891075,
-0.15901871025562286,
0.11788327991962433,
-0.567280650138855,
-0.4884672164916992,
1.1981122493743896,
0.4058911204338074,
0.7395826578140259,
0.4124593138694763,
0.5047793984413147,
0.6118869781494141,
0.5952154397964478,
-0.5876896381378174,
0.16884177923202515,
0.09954766184091568,
-1.0971143245697021,
0.017998233437538147,
-0.21215283870697021,
-0.545081615447998,
-0.23343990743160248,
-0.20299440622329712,
-0.669294536113739,
-0.10337444394826889,
0.5163851976394653,
-0.4907241463661194,
0.1613498479127884,
-0.9346076250076294,
0.7788763046264648,
-0.3581409156322479,
-0.12175977975130081,
-0.29907849431037903,
-0.7142965197563171,
0.45349013805389404,
-0.35780784487724304,
0.6656153202056885,
-0.1729922592639923,
0.25872695446014404,
0.41490042209625244,
-0.1820174902677536,
1.0922420024871826,
-0.050289034843444824,
-0.11154928058385849,
0.5951852798461914,
0.33010950684547424,
0.11985552310943604,
-0.02521517500281334,
-0.15052781999111176,
0.35158419609069824,
0.22795459628105164,
-0.3330800533294678,
-0.21074512600898743,
0.8954063057899475,
-0.7372087240219116,
-0.5461806654930115,
-0.07728712260723114,
-0.6110429763793945,
-0.3133617639541626,
0.06115787476301193,
-0.22440069913864136,
0.39347636699676514,
-0.08736203610897064,
0.29895174503326416,
0.5726867914199829,
-0.3626604676246643,
0.38291507959365845,
0.7416496276855469,
-0.5294396877288818,
-0.1993933618068695,
0.8663234710693359,
0.062306854873895645,
0.2580910623073578,
0.3724327087402344,
0.23403400182724,
-0.31536170840263367,
-0.1431882232427597,
-0.6510511636734009,
-0.08328518271446228,
-1.1150176525115967,
-0.03244253247976303,
-0.37596258521080017,
0.21487532556056976,
-0.9352124333381653,
-0.1311718374490738,
0.04202738031744957,
-0.8026213645935059,
0.2705926299095154,
-0.5699391961097717,
0.641827404499054,
0.8446785807609558,
-0.47875118255615234,
0.251870334148407,
-0.8435126543045044,
-0.08638214319944382,
0.1927604377269745,
0.6891666650772095,
-0.16441011428833008,
-0.5618011355400085,
-0.5468872785568237,
-0.3107602596282959,
-0.10184689611196518,
-0.7942178249359131,
0.4053370952606201,
0.06106135994195938,
0.37934815883636475,
0.758937656879425,
-0.009171455167233944,
0.36699092388153076,
-0.0872955173254013,
0.6598739624023438,
0.040065567940473557,
-0.8041290640830994,
0.5949329733848572,
-0.5603333115577698,
0.7792093753814697,
0.4327457845211029,
0.5017603635787964,
-1.2992578744888306,
-0.533062219619751,
-0.4007243514060974,
-0.8647650480270386,
0.6503812074661255,
-0.3593685030937195,
0.26598137617111206,
-0.09761808812618256,
0.0284911897033453,
0.2659102976322174,
0.12839846312999725,
-0.9237204790115356,
-0.20628494024276733,
-0.6067996621131897,
-0.3544929325580597,
0.048981618136167526,
-0.3787306547164917,
-0.16447767615318298,
-0.07965819537639618,
0.5796641111373901,
-0.2732025980949402,
-0.3076245188713074,
-0.08140566200017929,
-0.4491632878780365,
-0.5053465962409973,
0.17952097952365875,
0.4128577411174774,
0.8399903178215027,
-0.2773321568965912,
0.3107455372810364,
0.17634227871894836,
-0.4419909417629242,
-0.2311917245388031,
-0.17984607815742493,
-0.31798356771469116,
-0.4300203025341034,
0.31236979365348816,
0.4767502248287201,
-0.0364411287009716,
-0.9746666550636292,
0.1267155408859253,
-0.35203415155410767,
0.22695691883563995,
-0.9157336354255676,
-0.1524912714958191,
0.7370027303695679,
0.3450874090194702,
0.5085756182670593,
-0.0703638568520546,
-0.06800801306962967,
-0.5713251233100891,
0.20681610703468323,
0.02578653022646904,
-0.49491629004478455,
-0.14371705055236816,
0.5745586156845093,
0.6905275583267212,
-0.15391075611114502,
0.6445615887641907,
-0.027275817468762398,
-0.3484874963760376,
0.3493632376194,
0.29288342595100403,
0.6505827307701111,
-0.22017845511436462,
0.29754069447517395,
0.5698814392089844,
0.24865375459194183,
0.24336685240268707,
0.12736694514751434,
-0.21255207061767578,
-0.9662451148033142,
-0.4848824739456177,
-1.0400186777114868,
-0.17681030929088593,
0.09221619367599487,
-0.2645830512046814,
0.308380663394928,
-0.6835916042327881,
-0.14889901876449585,
-0.4850235879421234,
-0.17308075726032257,
-0.6915693283081055,
0.1120152473449707,
0.5112513899803162,
1.1033167839050293,
-0.9084353446960449,
0.9918619990348816,
0.6158074736595154,
-0.26355937123298645,
-0.6915707588195801,
-0.21346630156040192,
0.41668611764907837,
-0.9322395920753479,
0.7028343677520752,
0.04097944498062134,
0.045539163053035736,
0.10249394178390503,
-0.21580006182193756,
-1.1451411247253418,
1.1959999799728394,
0.21275804936885834,
-0.34684187173843384,
0.6050699353218079,
0.2576029896736145,
0.7559702396392822,
-0.3284589648246765,
0.3682073652744293,
0.4546041786670685,
0.553733229637146,
0.16509884595870972,
-0.990659773349762,
-0.10970982164144516,
-0.3084980547428131,
-0.3161444365978241,
-0.12901006639003754,
-0.5767534971237183,
0.42981013655662537,
0.07187605649232864,
-0.10621313750743866,
-0.12466354668140411,
0.8750762343406677,
0.0411173440515995,
0.08340515941381454,
0.6757081747055054,
0.511469841003418,
0.8193941116333008,
-0.25329530239105225,
0.9776409268379211,
-0.810397207736969,
0.15457619726657867,
0.9041664004325867,
-0.07294248789548874,
0.5675042271614075,
0.45922955870628357,
0.18697157502174377,
0.6158589720726013,
0.7470749020576477,
0.08700808137655258,
0.23164640367031097,
0.2830964922904968,
-0.3316880464553833,
-0.388118714094162,
-0.7066988945007324,
-0.15525096654891968,
0.7379797697067261,
0.3229927718639374,
-0.49007919430732727,
-0.29029250144958496,
-0.028868600726127625,
0.03936213627457619,
0.17509998381137848,
-0.4542420506477356,
0.4980132579803467,
0.05700082331895828,
-0.7413366436958313,
0.3057119846343994,
0.13467729091644287,
0.6809998750686646,
-0.7037380337715149,
0.25031641125679016,
-0.571441650390625,
0.10811159014701843,
-0.2969758212566376,
-0.7252326607704163,
0.27398744225502014,
0.24716411530971527,
-0.1725751906633377,
-0.777385950088501,
1.025302767753601,
-0.5613355040550232,
-0.25617077946662903,
0.32799068093299866,
0.8328427076339722,
0.07195256650447845,
0.12256079912185669,
-0.2367583066225052,
0.1564684808254242,
-0.012295141816139221,
-0.075557641685009,
0.45278602838516235,
0.28989171981811523,
-0.47650882601737976,
0.7836876511573792,
0.37724703550338745,
-0.12851260602474213,
-0.16897442936897278,
0.42647626996040344,
0.33481112122535706,
-0.618757426738739,
-0.5480043292045593,
-0.7532608509063721,
0.2721383571624756,
0.09331504255533218,
-0.26614779233932495,
0.6592329144477844,
0.42507538199424744,
1.449183702468872,
-0.3067976236343384,
0.9994643330574036,
-0.5346928834915161,
0.516879677772522,
0.019670048728585243,
0.98896324634552,
-0.47725823521614075,
0.05534171685576439,
0.04424423724412918,
-0.5613225698471069,
-0.2334502786397934,
0.36134329438209534,
-0.14886297285556793,
-0.035947784781455994,
0.28291353583335876,
0.6583718061447144,
0.1975056678056717,
0.2670555114746094,
0.3465544283390045,
0.40692952275276184,
0.21244971454143524,
0.4667957127094269,
0.8273903727531433,
0.33873867988586426,
1.021314024925232,
-0.48548898100852966,
-0.14715811610221863,
-0.14323481917381287,
-1.0599526166915894,
-0.7309645414352417,
-0.7834303379058838,
-0.03290313109755516,
-0.13412705063819885,
-0.358272522687912,
1.3882434368133545,
0.569825291633606,
-1.1490187644958496,
-0.6484244465827942,
0.5508671998977661,
0.054764095693826675,
-0.05827619507908821,
-0.25964856147766113,
-0.23091237246990204,
0.12867462635040283,
-0.7939607501029968,
0.2568635940551758,
0.3111371099948883,
-0.10278276354074478,
-0.5274569988250732,
-0.051895301789045334,
-0.06297115236520767,
-0.4542713463306427,
0.5827122926712036,
0.46885713934898376,
-0.5848839282989502,
-0.5685672163963318,
-0.0058094109408557415,
-0.21324224770069122,
-0.125827819108963,
0.9675009250640869,
-0.8359092473983765,
0.6025629639625549,
0.6701133847236633,
0.48566192388534546,
0.413729727268219,
-0.02422989532351494,
0.7085650563240051,
-0.8842794895172119,
0.09097463637590408,
-0.04218742623925209,
0.42183154821395874,
0.5903401374816895,
-0.22462929785251617,
0.6116998195648193,
0.4864412546157837,
-0.24947330355644226,
-0.13397429883480072,
0.3415120244026184,
-0.9176815748214722,
-0.21143315732479095,
1.103500247001648,
-0.1424058973789215,
-0.12287022173404694,
-0.4423847496509552,
0.06030863896012306,
0.28237682580947876,
-0.4913954436779022,
1.1621254682540894,
1.0213494300842285,
0.14953377842903137,
-0.06675820797681808,
-0.7138158679008484,
0.47245123982429504,
0.2405015379190445,
-0.5548601746559143,
0.0044297948479652405,
0.6360182762145996,
0.6794158816337585,
0.38516145944595337,
0.7424387335777283,
0.11711650341749191,
0.1663110852241516,
-0.46890658140182495,
0.33222654461860657,
-0.12386184930801392,
0.011417782865464687,
-0.16547271609306335,
0.3100239932537079,
0.21882137656211853,
0.5338205695152283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01575v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01575v1
|
Software Mention Recognition with a Three-Stage Framework Based on BERTology Models at SOMD 2024
| 2024-04-23T17:06:24 | 2024-04-23T17:06:24 |
Thuy Nguyen Thi, Anh Nguyen Viet, Thin Dang Van, Ngan Nguyen Luu Thuy
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper describes our systems for the sub-task I in the Software Mention
Detection in Scholarly Publications shared-task. We propose three approaches
leveraging different pre-trained language models (BERT, SciBERT, and XLM-R) to
tackle this challenge. Our bestperforming system addresses the named entity
recognition (NER) problem through a three-stage framework. (1) Entity Sentence
Classification - classifies sentences containing potential software mentions;
(2) Entity Extraction - detects mentions within classified sentences; (3)
Entity Type Classification - categorizes detected mentions into specific
software types. Experiments on the official dataset demonstrate that our
three-stage framework achieves competitive performance, surpassing both other
participating teams and our alternative approaches. As a result, our framework
based on the XLM-R-based model achieves a weighted F1-score of 67.80%,
delivering our team the 3rd rank in Sub-task I for the Software Mention
Recognition task.
|
[
-0.6646685004234314,
-0.17077405750751495,
0.6980453133583069,
0.3419301211833954,
-0.19031691551208496,
-0.1035378947854042,
-0.02486138418316841,
-0.8669753670692444,
0.2956223785877228,
0.4041025936603546,
-0.5281113982200623,
-0.5635365843772888,
-0.7157148122787476,
0.5017547011375427,
-0.6796847581863403,
1.3381733894348145,
-0.19095565378665924,
0.16694492101669312,
-0.16468431055545807,
-0.020804068073630333,
-0.09717117995023727,
-0.25392642617225647,
-0.4777425229549408,
-0.5594457387924194,
0.8014174699783325,
0.4620564877986908,
0.35102006793022156,
0.391045480966568,
0.943423330783844,
0.1591266542673111,
0.17399907112121582,
-0.1400117725133896,
-0.11598020792007446,
0.19501447677612305,
-0.018837740644812584,
-0.30804669857025146,
-0.5637792348861694,
-0.011661041527986526,
0.537007749080658,
0.21175667643547058,
0.20564962923526764,
0.20901736617088318,
0.05940677970647812,
0.2400982826948166,
-0.427462100982666,
0.4479069113731384,
-0.6369271278381348,
0.032088808715343475,
-0.6169123649597168,
-0.33211570978164673,
-0.3782051205635071,
-0.3298177719116211,
0.20956774055957794,
-0.7810831069946289,
0.3649899959564209,
0.3000361919403076,
1.1044137477874756,
0.0412522591650486,
0.12329446524381638,
-0.5501841306686401,
-0.7775814533233643,
0.7642853856086731,
-0.7397713661193848,
0.30475732684135437,
0.23011250793933868,
0.08002165704965591,
-0.30375975370407104,
-0.7685383558273315,
-0.6482416391372681,
-0.2298932522535324,
0.24096530675888062,
-0.11735852062702179,
-0.48166781663894653,
0.01685275323688984,
0.15760278701782227,
0.0944955125451088,
-0.5452209711074829,
0.17345130443572998,
-0.588146448135376,
-0.19753296673297882,
0.4575227200984955,
-0.23893031477928162,
0.29565495252609253,
-0.2192201465368271,
-0.48542851209640503,
0.3686058223247528,
-0.997480034828186,
-0.6144757270812988,
0.10468260198831558,
0.352976530790329,
0.40314772725105286,
0.41354161500930786,
0.2029200792312622,
0.600450336933136,
-0.16125167906284332,
-0.018854504451155663,
0.43794959783554077,
-0.2630934417247772,
-0.13975556194782257,
0.11088135093450546,
0.737726628780365,
0.02134057506918907,
0.026812102645635605,
-0.47143760323524475,
-0.3472138047218323,
0.06450904160737991,
0.34230268001556396,
-0.49957507848739624,
-0.375338077545166,
0.10213399678468704,
-0.5609499216079712,
-0.2294333279132843,
0.021627124398946762,
-0.18350006639957428,
-0.6521835923194885,
-0.1918782740831375,
0.8598873019218445,
-0.676433801651001,
-0.35954999923706055,
-0.19599296152591705,
-0.19425752758979797,
0.14420250058174133,
0.6281050443649292,
-0.7309567928314209,
0.5979262590408325,
0.9938274025917053,
0.817043662071228,
-0.3561997413635254,
-0.4698813557624817,
-0.433805912733078,
0.32882845401763916,
-0.22723034024238586,
0.9534487724304199,
-0.3110594153404236,
-0.1597965657711029,
-0.27767032384872437,
-0.08281684666872025,
0.10284959524869919,
-0.7742853164672852,
0.5621780157089233,
-0.9108922481536865,
0.04677562415599823,
-0.4026535153388977,
-0.8838391304016113,
-0.3051972985267639,
0.4010605812072754,
-0.8253809213638306,
1.0964438915252686,
0.11986953765153885,
-1.2098716497421265,
0.7405194640159607,
-0.8090165853500366,
-0.17858421802520752,
0.6771814823150635,
-0.39985191822052,
-0.25496017932891846,
-0.11659149080514908,
-0.15837806463241577,
0.7124400734901428,
-0.36400535702705383,
0.381507933139801,
-0.3957403004169464,
-0.7207340598106384,
-0.10175646841526031,
0.39626991748809814,
0.5902233719825745,
0.2699635624885559,
-0.48467403650283813,
0.24234800040721893,
-0.6717408299446106,
-0.3389439284801483,
-0.1343858391046524,
-0.3559536635875702,
-0.6007764339447021,
-0.047575049102306366,
0.3672615587711334,
0.0642222985625267,
0.2305566519498825,
-0.8431767225265503,
0.3580874502658844,
-0.10982479155063629,
0.32927852869033813,
0.42647993564605713,
0.019115719944238663,
0.4640215337276459,
-0.046326711773872375,
0.5079966187477112,
0.30198943614959717,
0.034508854150772095,
0.08557359874248505,
-0.5256041884422302,
-0.8587505221366882,
-0.35672587156295776,
0.762481689453125,
0.5052971243858337,
-0.9524584412574768,
0.2626475691795349,
-0.4088646471500397,
-0.5322526097297668,
-0.22560645639896393,
0.05976935476064682,
0.364290326833725,
0.27156883478164673,
0.47359541058540344,
-0.1927204430103302,
-0.9315561652183533,
-1.0163813829421997,
-0.28328999876976013,
-0.518252432346344,
-0.18857091665267944,
0.33681586384773254,
0.8890557289123535,
-0.2914558947086334,
1.0514678955078125,
-0.5378983020782471,
-0.4740358889102936,
-0.3556046485900879,
0.7790294885635376,
0.28791454434394836,
0.3946644961833954,
0.4546436071395874,
-0.9225314855575562,
-0.3345959484577179,
-0.22883999347686768,
-0.8299558162689209,
-0.18577636778354645,
0.20974914729595184,
0.1816481202840805,
0.20503157377243042,
0.8071807622909546,
-0.3499336838722229,
-0.0143092330545187,
0.13624820113182068,
0.18099628388881683,
0.30595430731773376,
-0.04129229858517647,
-0.07543960958719254,
-1.094829797744751,
0.030856149271130562,
0.33812516927719116,
-0.137261763215065,
-0.4703855514526367,
0.007053466979414225,
0.15447697043418884,
0.0031952557619661093,
-0.278939425945282,
0.478767067193985,
-0.7091358304023743,
-0.5022022128105164,
-0.3015178143978119,
0.23974452912807465,
-0.3150712251663208,
0.16540272533893585,
0.1973658800125122,
0.5892173647880554,
0.4894028902053833,
-0.7467873692512512,
0.1672009527683258,
-0.07117507606744766,
-0.3977305591106415,
0.5192828178405762,
-0.5571330189704895,
0.009194315411150455,
-0.033443633466959,
0.31416675448417664,
-0.7614930868148804,
-0.05981425940990448,
0.3851463496685028,
-0.5663445591926575,
0.31284087896347046,
-0.028009595349431038,
-0.8879660367965698,
-0.5415573120117188,
-0.1519262045621872,
-0.002486560260877013,
0.08475561439990997,
-0.292995810508728,
0.6909661293029785,
0.6256993412971497,
-0.5445224046707153,
-0.43636253476142883,
-0.49282026290893555,
0.3062478303909302,
-0.13713283836841583,
-0.37826234102249146,
0.888801634311676,
0.12608018517494202,
0.05943121016025543,
0.18464258313179016,
-0.21649663150310516,
-0.2711752653121948,
0.1060747355222702,
0.513671875,
0.5693711042404175,
0.1391904503107071,
0.22115549445152283,
-0.2336139976978302,
-0.24599236249923706,
0.01680700294673443,
-0.5047588348388672,
0.2888711094856262,
-0.17462408542633057,
-0.04544288292527199,
-0.08802143484354019,
0.1734490692615509,
0.2021624892950058,
-0.08212526887655258,
0.5471180081367493,
0.9357166290283203,
-0.7766419649124146,
0.02414817363023758,
-0.5516290068626404,
-0.032504498958587646,
-0.3694428503513336,
0.2105005830526352,
-0.3757772445678711,
-1.0525795221328735,
0.32309043407440186,
-0.021230224519968033,
0.2588980495929718,
0.3958503305912018,
0.2834739089012146,
-0.14198994636535645,
0.8059334754943848,
0.8466759920120239,
-0.35639238357543945,
0.43502047657966614,
-0.1632079929113388,
0.36598655581474304,
-0.9388412833213806,
-0.2076486200094223,
-0.913357675075531,
-0.14241452515125275,
-0.400056928396225,
-0.4188278615474701,
0.36836180090904236,
0.11131531000137329,
-0.019604122266173363,
1.019330620765686,
-0.49639734625816345,
0.10252828896045685,
0.7415568232536316,
-0.07398789376020432,
0.1698232740163803,
-0.2109384387731552,
-0.1796586960554123,
-0.21684977412223816,
-0.33761149644851685,
-0.677640974521637,
0.8619633913040161,
0.3926216959953308,
0.572179913520813,
-0.06436306983232498,
1.4076056480407715,
0.6820207834243774,
0.7716819643974304,
-0.7982205748558044,
0.918030321598053,
0.061009302735328674,
-0.9208636283874512,
-0.09680268168449402,
-0.2834968566894531,
-0.7371708750724792,
-0.07954548299312592,
-0.23418067395687103,
-0.7264293432235718,
0.1704077273607254,
-0.09184490144252777,
-0.3650888204574585,
-0.03657158464193344,
-0.34153279662132263,
0.676259458065033,
0.13647185266017914,
-0.05834157392382622,
0.002090750029310584,
-0.6547256112098694,
0.14277562499046326,
-0.14822521805763245,
0.5412296652793884,
-0.0796278715133667,
-0.13805276155471802,
1.0467349290847778,
0.11023201793432236,
0.30524078011512756,
-0.4555416703224182,
-0.19918659329414368,
0.03591368347406387,
0.06258975714445114,
0.34405088424682617,
-0.056301798671483994,
-0.14172618091106415,
0.24691766500473022,
0.14174163341522217,
0.01879858784377575,
-0.2477893978357315,
0.7589439153671265,
-0.6855202913284302,
-0.29748377203941345,
-0.8585847616195679,
-0.5408447980880737,
-0.06225401908159256,
0.7001635432243347,
0.41387614607810974,
0.15261206030845642,
-0.28027617931365967,
0.0939410999417305,
0.6789019703865051,
-0.03452511131763458,
0.49288976192474365,
0.846541166305542,
-0.4831852316856384,
-0.4383251965045929,
1.149739384651184,
0.2901182472705841,
-0.3817899227142334,
0.5484371185302734,
-0.4083978235721588,
-0.07962974905967712,
-0.870059072971344,
-0.34458670020103455,
0.20506837964057922,
-0.70897376537323,
-0.35472142696380615,
-1.1272164583206177,
-0.22638452053070068,
-0.45019084215164185,
0.008534685708582401,
-0.018410079181194305,
-0.22123052179813385,
-0.5809024572372437,
0.05616433918476105,
0.07118440419435501,
1.0165365934371948,
-0.07525023818016052,
-0.028546836227178574,
-1.0327908992767334,
0.3359498083591461,
-0.11953821778297424,
0.28623342514038086,
-0.1784326583147049,
-0.397583544254303,
-0.44891637563705444,
-0.5883107781410217,
-0.1704779863357544,
-0.814720869064331,
0.32856595516204834,
0.2088315784931183,
0.6192958950996399,
0.19416218996047974,
-0.05066226050257683,
0.2927132844924927,
-0.734129786491394,
0.7113872766494751,
0.11679834872484207,
-1.036656379699707,
0.5239684581756592,
-0.40994080901145935,
-0.0007855553412809968,
0.668607771396637,
0.8830206394195557,
-0.1571703404188156,
-0.4071885943412781,
-0.656003475189209,
-0.8065776228904724,
0.9248060584068298,
0.2221502661705017,
-0.19939693808555603,
-0.13343016803264618,
0.40639016032218933,
0.0820314884185791,
0.33141735196113586,
-1.0304319858551025,
-0.12667714059352875,
0.3523160219192505,
-0.1824498325586319,
0.21765388548374176,
-0.32932141423225403,
-0.02810584381222725,
0.017811143770813942,
1.1503931283950806,
-0.02848544716835022,
0.39071446657180786,
0.06808557361364365,
-0.18863604962825775,
0.17139144241809845,
0.41618454456329346,
0.36036446690559387,
0.46067628264427185,
-0.4737452566623688,
0.1314442902803421,
-0.12875060737133026,
-0.6217659711837769,
-0.03987247496843338,
0.5229236483573914,
-0.3834892511367798,
0.3794420659542084,
0.3374190032482147,
0.29535233974456787,
0.623295783996582,
-0.18635259568691254,
0.4683336615562439,
-0.020273832604289055,
-0.23493243753910065,
-0.39660218358039856,
0.09497562050819397,
0.35734546184539795,
0.4361540973186493,
0.6036632657051086,
0.22935256361961365,
0.7151750922203064,
-0.38884875178337097,
0.2502397298812866,
0.291374534368515,
-0.5621106624603271,
-0.22549638152122498,
0.40992870926856995,
0.06726487725973129,
-0.10545596480369568,
0.19022458791732788,
-0.5427148938179016,
-0.72712242603302,
0.5336261987686157,
0.6176276803016663,
0.8442302942276001,
-0.012789837084710598,
0.29243913292884827,
0.2573414444923401,
0.23123428225517273,
-0.37117210030555725,
0.6183175444602966,
-0.24125227332115173,
-0.7162163853645325,
0.021117201074957848,
-0.7042165398597717,
-0.6878054738044739,
-0.05372346192598343,
-0.8056778311729431,
0.7175565361976624,
-0.34971463680267334,
-0.4270380735397339,
0.8914819359779358,
0.12117712199687958,
-0.419255793094635,
0.28827038407325745,
0.33692365884780884,
1.0362794399261475,
-0.7891919016838074,
0.9270576238632202,
1.0202406644821167,
-0.6492233276367188,
-0.8959373831748962,
0.027540337294340134,
-0.10598653554916382,
-0.24108435213565826,
1.1000694036483765,
0.24313800036907196,
-0.19698889553546906,
0.22850729525089264,
-0.6801387667655945,
-0.9259206056594849,
1.1389435529708862,
0.22169145941734314,
-0.5268234014511108,
-0.30798038840293884,
-0.5715653300285339,
0.4578966200351715,
-0.4661346673965454,
0.28099972009658813,
0.3238057494163513,
0.3653516471385956,
0.2709636986255646,
-0.9836030602455139,
-0.12411031126976013,
-0.4097841680049896,
0.1981038600206375,
0.3953973650932312,
-0.13467878103256226,
0.9689322113990784,
-0.07324465364217758,
-0.26036950945854187,
0.08588363975286484,
0.8402215242385864,
0.7372845411300659,
0.5296535491943359,
0.6152894496917725,
0.44413992762565613,
0.5054275989532471,
-0.16982519626617432,
0.6554692387580872,
-0.3792652487754822,
0.41477328538894653,
1.2210252285003662,
-0.7914929986000061,
1.041861891746521,
0.4624565839767456,
-0.30019694566726685,
0.8270907402038574,
0.7241668701171875,
-0.3383009731769562,
0.4868905246257782,
0.4547041654586792,
-0.3004744350910187,
0.028440704569220543,
-0.24199889600276947,
-0.6603543162345886,
0.2220350205898285,
0.4410315454006195,
-0.5251832604408264,
-0.20656302571296692,
0.23709535598754883,
0.30383601784706116,
-0.3616774380207062,
-0.26620885729789734,
0.8094772100448608,
0.1572643667459488,
-0.7170201539993286,
0.17108657956123352,
0.29738649725914,
0.7987983226776123,
-0.5576112866401672,
-0.11660559475421906,
0.2785726487636566,
0.29999205470085144,
-0.4402877390384674,
-0.5549657940864563,
0.08011551946401596,
0.2006562054157257,
-0.5614495277404785,
-0.1878792941570282,
1.0402973890304565,
-0.25713106989860535,
-0.40744808316230774,
0.47430700063705444,
0.13222992420196533,
0.4054138958454132,
-0.07555025070905685,
-0.5400086641311646,
0.2936776280403137,
-0.38290873169898987,
0.13363108038902283,
0.33224210143089294,
0.3718075156211853,
0.06306436657905579,
0.48530250787734985,
0.2961803674697876,
0.1733245849609375,
-0.13539157807826996,
0.25634175539016724,
1.0607973337173462,
-0.5283251404762268,
-0.550707995891571,
-0.5781875252723694,
-0.21162185072898865,
-0.17927289009094238,
0.009695705957710743,
1.031600832939148,
0.6923671364784241,
0.7857098579406738,
-0.11476929485797882,
0.855197548866272,
-0.3136652410030365,
0.8089025020599365,
-0.013680225238204002,
0.5465336441993713,
-0.54726642370224,
0.5469065308570862,
-0.9029088020324707,
-1.095749020576477,
-0.5277519226074219,
0.5703791379928589,
-0.3225654363632202,
0.04898379370570183,
0.6025123000144958,
0.5554041862487793,
0.1028427928686142,
0.47561216354370117,
0.013743757270276546,
0.008661861531436443,
0.26373520493507385,
0.36049383878707886,
0.6376116871833801,
-0.6018493175506592,
0.37451842427253723,
0.12519636750221252,
-0.19735580682754517,
-0.303134948015213,
-1.1071830987930298,
-0.49140408635139465,
-0.7088068127632141,
-0.44494161009788513,
-0.4115050435066223,
0.09914248436689377,
0.9671605825424194,
0.7031088471412659,
-1.0013107061386108,
-0.007701451424509287,
-0.39136379957199097,
-0.12213856726884842,
-0.08883901685476303,
-0.23700091242790222,
0.06805980205535889,
-0.19704413414001465,
-0.5133346319198608,
0.4206286072731018,
0.7127851247787476,
-0.29006534814834595,
-0.48652851581573486,
0.13752411305904388,
-0.6115541458129883,
-0.15416760742664337,
0.37410539388656616,
0.18662741780281067,
-0.7068018317222595,
-0.1031276136636734,
0.21553125977516174,
-0.39363035559654236,
-0.2700543701648712,
0.8208562731742859,
-0.8746849298477173,
0.30533018708229065,
0.5681473612785339,
0.42072421312332153,
0.46188318729400635,
-0.30509746074676514,
0.5696108937263489,
-0.5297570824623108,
-0.32582035660743713,
0.48249155282974243,
0.44862887263298035,
0.4233011305332184,
-0.2570837438106537,
0.7177557945251465,
0.20939069986343384,
-0.7468502521514893,
-1.0368094444274902,
0.004597736522555351,
-0.8633395433425903,
-0.09512363374233246,
0.840118944644928,
-0.6230809092521667,
0.032907530665397644,
-0.4743865728378296,
-0.08434250205755234,
0.3155437409877777,
-0.3007345497608185,
0.6330267786979675,
0.7880129218101501,
-0.35777518153190613,
-0.24462145566940308,
-0.4181055426597595,
0.4670157730579376,
0.1432148814201355,
-0.8909756541252136,
-0.3534056544303894,
0.5475153923034668,
0.49194154143333435,
0.7398748993873596,
1.06649911403656,
-0.2840784788131714,
0.2771558165550232,
-0.11610068380832672,
0.46388009190559387,
0.02430787682533264,
-0.7723249793052673,
-0.12019582092761993,
0.22737492620944977,
0.3346749544143677,
-0.0313752256333828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15228v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15228v1
|
Re-Thinking Inverse Graphics With Large Language Models
| 2024-04-23T16:59:02 | 2024-04-23T16:59:02 |
Peter Kulits, Haiwen Feng, Weiyang Liu, Victoria Abrevaya, Michael J. Black
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Inverse graphics -- the task of inverting an image into physical variables
that, when rendered, enable reproduction of the observed scene -- is a
fundamental challenge in computer vision and graphics. Disentangling an image
into its constituent elements, such as the shape, color, and material
properties of the objects of the 3D scene that produced it, requires a
comprehensive understanding of the environment. This requirement limits the
ability of existing carefully engineered approaches to generalize across
domains. Inspired by the zero-shot ability of large language models (LLMs) to
generalize to novel contexts, we investigate the possibility of leveraging the
broad world knowledge encoded in such models in solving inverse-graphics
problems. To this end, we propose the Inverse-Graphics Large Language Model
(IG-LLM), an inverse-graphics framework centered around an LLM, that
autoregressively decodes a visual embedding into a structured, compositional
3D-scene representation. We incorporate a frozen pre-trained visual encoder and
a continuous numeric head to enable end-to-end training. Through our
investigation, we demonstrate the potential of LLMs to facilitate inverse
graphics through next-token prediction, without the use of image-space
supervision. Our analysis opens up new possibilities for precise spatial
reasoning about images that exploit the visual knowledge of LLMs. We will
release our code and data to ensure the reproducibility of our investigation
and to facilitate future research at https://ig-llm.is.tue.mpg.de/
|
[
-0.3401431441307068,
-1.0331697463989258,
0.8465411067008972,
-0.12995924055576324,
-0.4027511179447174,
-0.20503167808055878,
-0.21319477260112762,
-0.45208021998405457,
0.029491914436221123,
0.7399187684059143,
-0.6141679286956787,
-0.5024186372756958,
-0.5516502261161804,
-0.08870425075292587,
-0.3446642756462097,
0.41260361671447754,
-0.25562146306037903,
0.04249666631221771,
-0.2027939260005951,
-0.12032413482666016,
-0.303704172372818,
-0.39887309074401855,
-0.5391367077827454,
-0.5223942995071411,
0.29013776779174805,
0.37120887637138367,
0.7220343351364136,
0.6600719094276428,
0.28535735607147217,
0.3136404752731323,
0.34932640194892883,
-0.20280855894088745,
-0.8011545538902283,
-0.08147663623094559,
-0.19741767644882202,
-0.3878215253353119,
-0.183903306722641,
-0.07942669838666916,
0.7525479197502136,
0.6825993657112122,
0.1774972379207611,
0.16878120601177216,
-0.1302293986082077,
0.6262648701667786,
-0.5764788389205933,
0.3373226821422577,
-0.6503957509994507,
0.3032244145870209,
0.32176974415779114,
-0.2309185415506363,
-0.1634506732225418,
-0.10636835545301437,
-0.06643176823854446,
-0.7694496512413025,
0.17637032270431519,
0.100350022315979,
0.9029086232185364,
0.1730477511882782,
-0.1313224881887436,
0.17715443670749664,
-0.8768821954727173,
0.6061816215515137,
-0.6621497869491577,
0.3989271819591522,
0.19848549365997314,
0.44589927792549133,
-0.24523071944713593,
-0.5769031047821045,
-0.798461377620697,
-0.07013977319002151,
0.14440040290355682,
0.34643998742103577,
-0.31089067459106445,
-0.07175566256046295,
0.288700133562088,
0.29147064685821533,
-0.5544033050537109,
0.37055376172065735,
-0.20213492214679718,
0.13832297921180725,
0.468339741230011,
0.16562294960021973,
0.4389745593070984,
0.2584366500377655,
-0.39391836524009705,
-0.1718391329050064,
-1.1842970848083496,
-0.5467633605003357,
0.35782870650291443,
0.16471734642982483,
-0.12129077315330505,
0.7856403589248657,
-0.026718299835920334,
0.7769434452056885,
-0.14719602465629578,
0.13825640082359314,
0.037917546927928925,
0.12983152270317078,
-0.4631073772907257,
-0.27770930528640747,
0.5845207571983337,
0.4684441387653351,
0.2982701361179352,
-0.2048269659280777,
-0.26264768838882446,
-0.25360381603240967,
-0.0196556206792593,
-0.8408482074737549,
-0.2759722173213959,
-0.0672590509057045,
-0.3937804400920868,
0.051983702927827835,
-0.14051036536693573,
-0.48453575372695923,
-0.5847303867340088,
-0.648002028465271,
0.7173610329627991,
-0.3376633822917938,
-0.36537402868270874,
0.16994264721870422,
-0.17137303948402405,
0.45391178131103516,
0.6111092567443848,
-0.5729320049285889,
0.21043998003005981,
0.4978848695755005,
0.6262534856796265,
0.18837201595306396,
-0.33050113916397095,
-0.27082309126853943,
0.4138047397136688,
-0.4526747465133667,
0.8422910571098328,
-0.5397996306419373,
-0.27487650513648987,
-0.10233669728040695,
0.08582677692174911,
0.34220239520072937,
-0.5320930480957031,
0.1042635589838028,
-0.5080059766769409,
0.17942732572555542,
-0.14221087098121643,
-0.38816580176353455,
-0.36594197154045105,
0.5255466103553772,
-0.5827924013137817,
0.5921174883842468,
-0.028678223490715027,
-0.7039725184440613,
0.2746696472167969,
-0.19528256356716156,
-0.052058227360248566,
0.16528859734535217,
-0.514348030090332,
-0.4237036406993866,
0.33266735076904297,
0.4390150010585785,
0.4471065402030945,
-0.6027723550796509,
0.20056594908237457,
-0.6956164240837097,
-0.6342073678970337,
-0.018205806612968445,
-0.4980280101299286,
0.5122178792953491,
-0.0904017761349678,
-0.22739934921264648,
0.03499917313456535,
-0.4674381613731384,
-0.05029084160923958,
0.6214891076087952,
-0.000761427276302129,
-0.34775611758232117,
-0.20318911969661713,
-0.14409130811691284,
0.29314470291137695,
0.17571498453617096,
-0.6740654706954956,
0.3959615230560303,
-0.5122661590576172,
0.2657376229763031,
0.7744423151016235,
-0.18372519314289093,
0.763627290725708,
0.04255899041891098,
0.6502894759178162,
-0.063588947057724,
-0.02020268328487873,
-0.5371888875961304,
-0.4124665856361389,
-0.5377857089042664,
-0.32623687386512756,
-0.21927495300769806,
0.5292739868164062,
-0.8875643610954285,
0.18471723794937134,
-0.595850944519043,
-0.18187549710273743,
-0.0963788852095604,
-0.0532296746969223,
0.2920778691768646,
0.7166853547096252,
0.20938707888126373,
-0.10038412362337112,
-0.39687466621398926,
-0.9500464797019958,
-0.0705629363656044,
-0.16106970608234406,
-0.1762240082025528,
0.4278406798839569,
0.5596475601196289,
-0.26385900378227234,
0.9246610403060913,
-0.9517296552658081,
-0.2740791141986847,
-0.16509556770324707,
-0.021072780713438988,
0.3276265561580658,
0.41919243335723877,
0.4936279058456421,
-0.6475695371627808,
-0.3777254521846771,
0.040224406868219376,
-0.862932026386261,
0.0428265817463398,
-0.1631285697221756,
-0.2753080427646637,
0.011416223831474781,
0.942244291305542,
-0.39225661754608154,
0.6952673196792603,
0.4530865550041199,
-0.14852197468280792,
0.5830562710762024,
-0.5462706089019775,
-0.004198258277028799,
-0.6960141062736511,
0.2750110328197479,
0.06811703741550446,
-0.09970014542341232,
-0.43058347702026367,
0.3093664348125458,
-0.04763449728488922,
-0.5017101764678955,
-0.14282408356666565,
0.8920947909355164,
-0.7845584750175476,
-0.34928083419799805,
-0.4694094955921173,
0.18489068746566772,
-0.004303657915443182,
0.5387418270111084,
0.37646451592445374,
0.47305041551589966,
0.8667219877243042,
-0.2981683015823364,
0.4101320803165436,
0.04220129922032356,
-0.38271191716194153,
0.5528109669685364,
-0.5590499043464661,
0.3012874126434326,
-0.7324190735816956,
0.3800037205219269,
-1.4209040403366089,
-0.06114277243614197,
0.43186119198799133,
-0.2770804166793823,
0.4957056939601898,
-0.4508695900440216,
-0.654447615146637,
-0.4177355170249939,
-0.12885011732578278,
0.6645453572273254,
0.6423326730728149,
-0.6313225030899048,
0.7930029034614563,
0.3132825195789337,
-0.029254522174596786,
-0.6641393303871155,
-0.7997751235961914,
0.42275470495224,
-0.23824156820774078,
-0.37034064531326294,
0.20982052385807037,
0.016163725405931473,
-0.2800677418708801,
0.2309287041425705,
0.19145691394805908,
-0.08924888074398041,
-0.12510336935520172,
0.4439786970615387,
0.28661802411079407,
-0.2702878415584564,
0.07355581223964691,
-0.06199129670858383,
-0.12151311337947845,
0.09389683604240417,
-0.6099849343299866,
0.4825047552585602,
-0.01519049797207117,
-0.6909266710281372,
-0.11599031835794449,
0.2818948030471802,
0.4809722900390625,
0.06458862125873566,
0.565746009349823,
0.4167836606502533,
-0.5413748621940613,
-0.05201509967446327,
-0.4906321167945862,
-0.07191665470600128,
-0.45613229274749756,
0.6339048147201538,
-0.49391114711761475,
-0.5599484443664551,
0.6767355799674988,
-0.3269221782684326,
-0.02483191154897213,
0.19806435704231262,
0.377815306186676,
-0.2065822333097458,
0.9863461256027222,
0.9679982662200928,
0.1360313445329666,
0.414787232875824,
-0.5561711192131042,
0.3119395673274994,
-0.8524478077888489,
-0.26781362295150757,
-0.015607398003339767,
-0.3406542241573334,
0.018020551651716232,
-0.5143053531646729,
0.35391443967819214,
0.21926483511924744,
-0.4106103777885437,
0.14497725665569305,
-0.07561410963535309,
0.7336711287498474,
0.1049899309873581,
0.29862645268440247,
0.10561563074588776,
0.17542597651481628,
-0.1631421148777008,
0.08408952504396439,
-0.6503602266311646,
-0.4101170599460602,
0.8499861359596252,
0.3366863429546356,
0.8932251334190369,
-0.13449600338935852,
0.5314114093780518,
-0.15135270357131958,
0.5906177163124084,
-0.9275481104850769,
0.6775488257408142,
-0.12613092362880707,
-0.34212207794189453,
-0.38898977637290955,
-0.26978716254234314,
-0.9097782969474792,
0.4235595762729645,
-0.2441674768924713,
-0.6890121698379517,
-0.06631610542535782,
0.3369218409061432,
-0.09645181894302368,
0.7696366906166077,
-0.723530650138855,
0.7648419141769409,
-0.18318849802017212,
-0.47307533025741577,
-0.20706307888031006,
-0.45974376797676086,
0.5142146348953247,
-0.08094879984855652,
0.3642125427722931,
-0.09972760826349258,
-0.0640430822968483,
0.10841717571020126,
-0.29623451828956604,
1.0633152723312378,
-0.2397504597902298,
-0.5815277695655823,
0.2524385452270508,
0.5170264840126038,
0.3746788203716278,
0.03650921210646629,
0.25207605957984924,
0.23647381365299225,
-0.4015045166015625,
-0.20536333322525024,
-0.7600417733192444,
0.9572783708572388,
-0.7187458276748657,
-0.8084738254547119,
-0.011560851708054543,
-0.40726161003112793,
-0.2049921303987503,
0.30214983224868774,
0.22579531371593475,
0.5438830256462097,
-0.33377036452293396,
-0.263266921043396,
0.5068923234939575,
-0.7514694929122925,
0.2021707147359848,
0.2593037784099579,
-0.7087018489837646,
-0.3479479253292084,
0.7713586688041687,
0.021318038925528526,
0.1743873506784439,
0.5503360629081726,
0.24714025855064392,
-0.383968710899353,
-0.40458786487579346,
-0.5859113931655884,
0.4941089451313019,
-1.1040780544281006,
-0.3830399215221405,
-0.38859859108924866,
-0.03805055841803551,
-0.14957918226718903,
-0.3465172052383423,
-0.1940305531024933,
-0.3521420657634735,
-0.5740972757339478,
-0.03717822954058647,
0.051661163568496704,
0.6487060189247131,
-0.0467083677649498,
0.24383923411369324,
-0.5789408683776855,
0.47846919298171997,
0.34466204047203064,
0.5347663164138794,
0.2645381987094879,
-0.8244504928588867,
-0.08972093462944031,
0.14822359383106232,
0.029203353449702263,
-0.5283503532409668,
0.4755076766014099,
0.11564368009567261,
0.5303305387496948,
0.3910205066204071,
-0.4102964401245117,
1.006375789642334,
-0.7923611998558044,
0.5371915102005005,
0.46770867705345154,
-0.7245888113975525,
0.20133952796459198,
-0.38687795400619507,
0.7160211801528931,
-0.024142976850271225,
0.2868480086326599,
-0.47456300258636475,
-0.28408563137054443,
-0.4961215555667877,
-0.8905113339424133,
0.466826468706131,
-0.07519663870334625,
0.38127511739730835,
0.10669440031051636,
0.5544840693473816,
0.20813533663749695,
-0.04443125054240227,
-0.6602913737297058,
0.03516164422035217,
-0.43396878242492676,
-0.0028852643445134163,
-0.22396054863929749,
-0.21516753733158112,
-0.06557314842939377,
-0.40208980441093445,
0.37301021814346313,
-0.28411296010017395,
0.4989800453186035,
-0.033253032714128494,
-0.12283984571695328,
-0.2487925887107849,
-0.14494003355503082,
0.5460307002067566,
0.7297287583351135,
-0.024412300437688828,
0.3979375660419464,
0.34900304675102234,
-0.12964583933353424,
0.12055554240942001,
-0.2581975758075714,
-0.0034071882255375385,
-0.3066073954105377,
0.4784983694553375,
0.785505473613739,
0.087400883436203,
-0.789932131767273,
0.6094364523887634,
0.00970055628567934,
-0.2253052145242691,
-0.6789694428443909,
-0.46421244740486145,
0.030700674280524254,
0.15846996009349823,
0.45824146270751953,
-0.048452410846948624,
-0.06054714322090149,
-0.5670087337493896,
0.010421079583466053,
0.6716550588607788,
-0.3646632730960846,
-0.6195970177650452,
0.5475348234176636,
-0.18479199707508087,
0.19451239705085754,
0.9186135530471802,
0.1265411078929901,
-0.4262230098247528,
0.823456346988678,
0.9425203800201416,
0.9275753498077393,
0.19778870046138763,
0.08329334855079651,
0.6891641616821289,
0.2487086057662964,
-0.07050511240959167,
0.18746589124202728,
0.23163655400276184,
-0.9354124665260315,
-0.701897144317627,
-0.2168300747871399,
-0.08819344639778137,
0.21409013867378235,
-0.167751744389534,
0.41015705466270447,
-0.7016602158546448,
-0.055858176201581955,
-0.4291658103466034,
-0.6728162169456482,
-0.7407227754592896,
0.12202707678079605,
0.7329244017601013,
0.7481505870819092,
-0.9345549941062927,
0.6425597071647644,
0.7983536720275879,
-0.293227881193161,
-0.28570303320884705,
-0.00478235213086009,
-0.23650115728378296,
-1.0492103099822998,
1.1152050495147705,
0.08345835655927658,
-0.625230073928833,
-0.02148999273777008,
-1.2145233154296875,
-0.9115240573883057,
0.9005551338195801,
0.8156386613845825,
-0.4949991703033447,
0.0464131124317646,
0.010632016696035862,
0.5282017588615417,
-0.29619699716567993,
0.2720019817352295,
0.09962424635887146,
0.3566277325153351,
0.4366450309753418,
-0.6150363087654114,
0.18735885620117188,
-0.02069486305117607,
0.12879697978496552,
0.28428879380226135,
-0.45176398754119873,
0.7043588757514954,
-0.5622425079345703,
-0.5051875114440918,
0.1047353446483612,
0.6378644108772278,
0.1961309164762497,
-0.10710368305444717,
0.3473731577396393,
0.7942928671836853,
0.19573284685611725,
0.057135846465826035,
1.0145714282989502,
0.04692996293306351,
0.11438136547803879,
1.1538933515548706,
-0.2872857451438904,
0.5170214176177979,
0.5294626355171204,
0.21126362681388855,
0.3347468376159668,
0.14368295669555664,
0.05827438831329346,
0.5038338303565979,
0.3825834393501282,
0.03585139662027359,
-0.3961796164512634,
0.09432858228683472,
-0.17763596773147583,
0.4420003592967987,
0.5191778540611267,
-0.2562146782875061,
-0.6584104299545288,
0.24203304946422577,
-0.045371320098638535,
0.24389973282814026,
-0.4030427932739258,
0.6177695989608765,
0.1251782327890396,
-0.14773336052894592,
0.7989959120750427,
0.010939324274659157,
0.3971363604068756,
-0.4957241714000702,
-0.513960063457489,
-0.2694346606731415,
0.21392829716205597,
-0.04583655297756195,
-1.109101414680481,
0.2527081072330475,
-0.29118049144744873,
0.26528891921043396,
-0.39284518361091614,
0.625496506690979,
-0.38257312774658203,
-0.3922053873538971,
0.1593875288963318,
0.2994801104068756,
0.11592575907707214,
-0.2573234736919403,
-0.6680426001548767,
0.19352537393569946,
-0.25539833307266235,
0.017739249393343925,
0.23961417376995087,
0.6686823964118958,
-0.07335038483142853,
0.8533086180686951,
0.42275020480155945,
0.08636792749166489,
-0.1153998151421547,
0.011758722364902496,
1.0815916061401367,
-0.6537020206451416,
-0.307005912065506,
-0.9630577564239502,
0.2511460781097412,
0.07662257552146912,
0.024696169421076775,
0.7380617260932922,
0.6086742877960205,
0.8263894319534302,
-0.3985307216644287,
0.7371572852134705,
0.29814788699150085,
-0.10653484612703323,
-0.6544209122657776,
0.5432396531105042,
-0.5426694750785828,
0.02102273516356945,
-0.5044558644294739,
-1.1164301633834839,
-0.7015305161476135,
0.6024198532104492,
-0.6646825671195984,
-0.17934317886829376,
0.2798890173435211,
0.7264289259910583,
-0.3229656219482422,
-0.3099673092365265,
0.49899330735206604,
0.17505013942718506,
0.4666926860809326,
0.5700556635856628,
1.2276445627212524,
-0.2531927525997162,
0.3684522211551666,
-0.08680890500545502,
-0.15076065063476562,
0.15010054409503937,
-1.12169349193573,
-0.79326331615448,
-0.6494234204292297,
-0.343624472618103,
-0.0564422532916069,
-0.2683292329311371,
0.6137315034866333,
0.4235651195049286,
-0.43446826934814453,
-0.28680306673049927,
-0.23067663609981537,
-0.1824599802494049,
-0.04284217208623886,
-0.13564470410346985,
0.41006413102149963,
0.2939528822898865,
-0.5555715560913086,
0.10914108902215958,
0.5062706470489502,
0.5409039855003357,
-0.42970237135887146,
0.09856177866458893,
0.07909338921308517,
-0.03689559921622276,
0.749466061592102,
0.5488464832305908,
-0.7087607979774475,
-0.36772286891937256,
-0.23684534430503845,
0.03953520581126213,
0.05243483558297157,
0.9436185359954834,
-1.0414389371871948,
0.49507826566696167,
0.5294394493103027,
0.43357130885124207,
0.7911985516548157,
0.08044574409723282,
0.5745036602020264,
-0.5062278509140015,
0.5108480453491211,
0.22503472864627838,
0.6136142611503601,
0.4868539273738861,
-0.2701108157634735,
0.15787282586097717,
-0.002147248713299632,
-0.07174043357372284,
-0.5750041604042053,
0.5783126354217529,
-0.4587399661540985,
-0.7523223757743835,
1.1384003162384033,
-0.15116846561431885,
-0.3799761235713959,
0.15687040984630585,
-0.4565114378929138,
0.026440460234880447,
0.14140158891677856,
0.649687647819519,
0.41605445742607117,
-0.0426858626306057,
-0.5383008122444153,
-0.2141672968864441,
0.08555298298597336,
-0.00201640953309834,
-0.5933552384376526,
0.2889508306980133,
0.8522391319274902,
0.27941423654556274,
-0.09223859012126923,
0.6617164015769958,
-0.3806571960449219,
-0.2929989993572235,
-0.038351304829120636,
0.19378560781478882,
-0.20844495296478271,
-0.38554179668426514,
-0.5175271034240723,
0.07285990566015244,
0.09322451800107956,
0.12798988819122314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15219v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15219v1
|
The Power of the Noisy Channel: Unsupervised End-to-End Task-Oriented Dialogue with LLMs
| 2024-04-23T16:51:26 | 2024-04-23T16:51:26 |
Brendan King, Jeffrey Flanigan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Training task-oriented dialogue systems typically requires turn-level
annotations for interacting with their APIs: e.g. a dialogue state and the
system actions taken at each step. These annotations can be costly to produce,
error-prone, and require both domain and annotation expertise. With advances in
LLMs, we hypothesize unlabelled data and a schema definition are sufficient for
building a working task-oriented dialogue system, completely unsupervised.
Using only (1) a well-defined API schema (2) a set of unlabelled dialogues
between a user and agent, we develop a novel approach for inferring turn-level
annotations as latent variables using a noisy channel model. We iteratively
improve these pseudo-labels with expectation-maximization (EM), and use the
inferred labels to train an end-to-end dialogue agent. Evaluating our approach
on the MultiWOZ benchmark, our method more than doubles the dialogue success
rate of a strong GPT-3.5 baseline.
|
[
-0.43090665340423584,
-0.4199715554714203,
0.6065094470977783,
0.12381613999605179,
-0.5034196972846985,
0.34413042664527893,
-0.3701808750629425,
-0.5295270085334778,
0.2707625925540924,
0.7923800349235535,
-0.9251395463943481,
-0.3968139588832855,
-0.6248875260353088,
-0.15129677951335907,
-0.204536572098732,
1.0817251205444336,
0.3672899901866913,
0.27570250630378723,
-0.22240865230560303,
0.021185051649808884,
0.04649250581860542,
-0.6968964338302612,
-0.3689536154270172,
-0.4627021849155426,
0.36717116832733154,
0.21322208642959595,
0.5874481797218323,
0.1038941815495491,
0.08646630495786667,
0.3349896967411041,
-0.10715334117412567,
0.35556548833847046,
-0.47188884019851685,
0.5697320103645325,
0.014232461340725422,
-0.4298226535320282,
-0.28716084361076355,
0.09597893804311752,
0.07148167490959167,
0.865080714225769,
-0.11207206547260284,
0.04821930453181267,
-0.0038337509613484144,
0.2890528738498688,
-0.4417027533054352,
0.5927907824516296,
-0.579206645488739,
0.032471515238285065,
-0.08708416670560837,
-0.37890946865081787,
-0.5145049095153809,
0.2614688575267792,
0.3841245770454407,
-0.8919001221656799,
-0.09971646964550018,
0.06641573458909988,
0.689921498298645,
0.7051951289176941,
-0.21298499405384064,
-0.23638348281383514,
-1.142347812652588,
0.8950034976005554,
-0.6739988923072815,
0.47405746579170227,
0.49882808327674866,
-0.043014898896217346,
-0.41184908151626587,
-0.770179033279419,
-0.19533909857273102,
-0.2291187345981598,
0.23459619283676147,
0.3460506498813629,
-0.4039720594882965,
0.5270781517028809,
0.3559897541999817,
0.07976075261831284,
-0.010362113825976849,
0.11224647611379623,
-0.13302499055862427,
-0.3666815459728241,
0.43526965379714966,
-0.0029256772249937057,
-0.17203229665756226,
0.19347722828388214,
-0.2819662392139435,
0.13664251565933228,
-0.46038153767585754,
0.05697072669863701,
0.6093987226486206,
0.34981194138526917,
0.18704886734485626,
0.33362311124801636,
-0.43444588780403137,
0.6007122993469238,
0.20120257139205933,
-0.347224622964859,
0.2548457086086273,
-0.10338236391544342,
-0.23843218386173248,
0.020488929003477097,
0.832811713218689,
0.42096060514450073,
0.20042851567268372,
-0.63923579454422,
-0.3794993758201599,
-0.09258899092674255,
0.3979252278804779,
-0.7468408942222595,
-0.09555286169052124,
0.21573105454444885,
-0.3820345997810364,
-0.3081895112991333,
-0.2563087046146393,
-0.5261751413345337,
-0.3656444549560547,
-0.4542637765407562,
0.3768548369407654,
-0.04290700703859329,
-0.144694522023201,
-0.14242126047611237,
0.048051077872514725,
0.030310316011309624,
0.45365452766418457,
-0.7219630479812622,
0.3674028813838959,
0.43903136253356934,
0.5843990445137024,
0.06774169951677322,
-0.005838529206812382,
-0.4139164984226227,
0.06209791079163551,
-0.4776221215724945,
0.8674060702323914,
-0.3844410479068756,
-0.3667445480823517,
0.0930793508887291,
0.02133549563586712,
0.14660006761550903,
-0.5114299058914185,
0.4196503758430481,
-0.3643445670604706,
0.13976146280765533,
0.03267960995435715,
-0.5384179949760437,
0.20241813361644745,
-0.0711156576871872,
-0.19856075942516327,
0.8830220103263855,
0.3345288038253784,
-0.37318986654281616,
0.183692067861557,
-0.5383166670799255,
-0.2561371326446533,
0.10897896438837051,
-0.25960275530815125,
-0.3416568338871002,
0.13836345076560974,
0.18301264941692352,
0.28497081995010376,
-0.4891921579837799,
0.32620367407798767,
-0.2169761061668396,
-0.2900784909725189,
0.5303437113761902,
-0.6702202558517456,
0.6290997266769409,
0.31416115164756775,
-0.46757209300994873,
0.18712083995342255,
-0.839614748954773,
0.031371913850307465,
-0.20292963087558746,
-0.058955952525138855,
-0.1566314995288849,
-0.014061481691896915,
-0.32037147879600525,
0.11029669642448425,
0.20508065819740295,
-0.9193163514137268,
0.11274561285972595,
-0.2505766749382019,
0.44734540581703186,
0.7659646272659302,
0.03688553720712662,
0.528634786605835,
-0.13896596431732178,
0.2861587107181549,
-0.10277021676301956,
0.5041961669921875,
-0.1851390153169632,
-0.6318547129631042,
-0.9507423043251038,
-0.40040987730026245,
-0.04425083473324776,
0.4059429466724396,
-0.7868610620498657,
0.2555820643901825,
0.09763359278440475,
-0.48875585198402405,
-0.516773521900177,
0.3096809983253479,
0.4629863202571869,
0.3310472071170807,
0.1702638864517212,
-0.4356926679611206,
-0.5528238415718079,
-0.7756956219673157,
0.05881503224372864,
-0.43390172719955444,
-0.2206142544746399,
0.4689224362373352,
0.002581109991297126,
-0.24428138136863708,
0.8483471870422363,
-0.3055034279823303,
-0.5643517374992371,
-0.27401667833328247,
0.42858225107192993,
0.10562987625598907,
0.10641326010227203,
0.030013110488653183,
-0.41596338152885437,
-0.2979559004306793,
-0.27442002296447754,
-0.7196682095527649,
-0.6127357482910156,
-0.3178281784057617,
-0.1627030372619629,
0.13893462717533112,
0.8370160460472107,
-0.7626243233680725,
0.5158321857452393,
0.3091302216053009,
-0.01578657701611519,
0.323490172624588,
-0.1136038601398468,
-0.1736663281917572,
-0.7518931031227112,
-0.47557809948921204,
-0.08336865156888962,
-0.17437875270843506,
-0.7436815500259399,
-0.5698935389518738,
-0.3623291850090027,
-0.11569232493638992,
-0.26338645815849304,
0.11619992554187775,
-0.6038901805877686,
-0.24181875586509705,
-0.49909648299217224,
-0.009328249841928482,
-0.21339936554431915,
1.1598097085952759,
0.19489812850952148,
0.588552713394165,
0.567739725112915,
-0.32745492458343506,
0.4850916266441345,
0.1852675825357437,
-0.2696807384490967,
0.5368838310241699,
-0.4417637586593628,
0.31291088461875916,
0.05596569553017616,
0.30864599347114563,
-0.8734427094459534,
-0.08740411698818207,
0.28620976209640503,
-0.48222264647483826,
0.37369415163993835,
-0.4598185420036316,
-0.3092961609363556,
0.00930112786591053,
-0.024164434522390366,
0.05892203003168106,
0.5746539831161499,
-0.4613504707813263,
0.5754137635231018,
0.5876274704933167,
-0.2458145171403885,
-0.4574163556098938,
-0.3645751476287842,
0.18841741979122162,
0.08622106909751892,
-0.35731250047683716,
0.2297259271144867,
-0.08047166466712952,
-0.19648538529872894,
-0.2568109333515167,
-0.33075836300849915,
-0.1443258672952652,
-0.06460729986429214,
0.8350121378898621,
0.12042597681283951,
0.12386684119701385,
-0.04550459608435631,
-0.1789991408586502,
-0.34652525186538696,
0.3778160810470581,
-0.5780171751976013,
0.3204876184463501,
-0.12293299287557602,
-0.6948942542076111,
-0.42858773469924927,
0.37269127368927,
0.6943668127059937,
0.09294720739126205,
0.2751829922199249,
0.4744824767112732,
-0.1725035160779953,
-0.19737939536571503,
-0.5210549235343933,
-0.2222268134355545,
-0.4843534827232361,
0.45428648591041565,
0.008134051226079464,
-0.8901501297950745,
0.39714109897613525,
-0.45463669300079346,
0.27724042534828186,
-0.2010412961244583,
0.624165952205658,
-0.4186567962169647,
1.012403964996338,
0.7557759881019592,
0.13246332108974457,
0.7163407206535339,
-0.21484537422657013,
0.5322185754776001,
-0.8085485100746155,
-0.626954972743988,
-0.32301846146583557,
-0.049975764006376266,
-0.45564278960227966,
-0.6465497016906738,
0.3574756383895874,
0.0645301342010498,
-0.2632948160171509,
0.17137937247753143,
-0.47135108709335327,
0.1358964592218399,
0.8803504109382629,
0.11122412979602814,
0.21703281998634338,
0.1671576201915741,
0.10948820412158966,
-0.1912166327238083,
-0.532181441783905,
-0.41222941875457764,
1.1678471565246582,
0.45286059379577637,
1.0702564716339111,
-0.03276326507329941,
0.6454868912696838,
0.21859249472618103,
0.28427454829216003,
-0.8756075501441956,
0.6150756478309631,
0.35422283411026,
-0.2966671288013458,
-0.5784469842910767,
-0.08127378672361374,
-0.7833955883979797,
0.25036489963531494,
-0.06866517663002014,
-1.1204599142074585,
0.2115200012922287,
-0.0611405186355114,
-0.17236573994159698,
0.27786630392074585,
-0.5237246155738831,
0.4550987184047699,
-0.24395006895065308,
-0.3859459459781647,
0.1926804929971695,
-0.7633389234542847,
-0.11062221229076385,
0.018789906054735184,
0.1718950718641281,
-0.23587484657764435,
0.014684734866023064,
0.9078655242919922,
-0.879085123538971,
1.2543044090270996,
-0.30898749828338623,
-0.11540348082780838,
0.6337465047836304,
-0.14608338475227356,
0.5699271559715271,
-0.044371239840984344,
0.5131121277809143,
0.33461207151412964,
-0.32235896587371826,
-0.23234330117702484,
-0.7333168983459473,
0.30657729506492615,
-1.058020830154419,
-0.5505605936050415,
-0.3787716329097748,
-0.7275804281234741,
-0.6523765921592712,
-0.08655411005020142,
0.36480531096458435,
0.5233305096626282,
0.06351480633020401,
-0.016463028267025948,
0.9118443131446838,
0.07929422706365585,
0.48255565762519836,
0.6686574816703796,
0.018629727885127068,
-0.2842288613319397,
0.9891734719276428,
0.015778040513396263,
0.4042210876941681,
0.24625413119792938,
-0.15753154456615448,
-0.3359423577785492,
-0.5857329964637756,
-0.4595232307910919,
-0.03123300150036812,
-0.692807137966156,
-0.26138705015182495,
-0.7067161798477173,
-0.506076991558075,
-0.224073126912117,
-0.005191161297261715,
-0.7609893679618835,
-0.37347784638404846,
-0.24851654469966888,
-0.11697514355182648,
0.2452782392501831,
0.8601961731910706,
-0.308624804019928,
0.5605499744415283,
-0.5107448101043701,
0.04627315327525139,
0.34243330359458923,
0.2747472822666168,
-0.2339174896478653,
-0.7125688195228577,
-0.470722496509552,
0.04764294996857643,
-0.40565070509910583,
-0.9344833493232727,
0.34857177734375,
0.00017499311070423573,
0.9006232023239136,
0.5481185913085938,
0.30314430594444275,
0.39372503757476807,
-0.15623340010643005,
0.7947091460227966,
0.37158849835395813,
-0.7319471836090088,
0.2880580425262451,
-0.31708142161369324,
0.11307642608880997,
0.34680214524269104,
0.12685638666152954,
-0.3206208646297455,
-0.936318576335907,
-0.7494774460792542,
-1.0212621688842773,
0.7595385909080505,
0.3228408098220825,
0.021787965670228004,
0.11826054006814957,
-0.019840674474835396,
-0.020451128482818604,
0.4989078938961029,
-0.6639672517776489,
-0.37982016801834106,
-0.31713762879371643,
-0.035272836685180664,
0.09688335657119751,
-0.30623045563697815,
-0.23124441504478455,
0.06791236996650696,
0.7680283784866333,
-0.1749812364578247,
0.6963696479797363,
0.2790091931819916,
-0.1034582108259201,
-0.37796860933303833,
0.3939577043056488,
0.3911694586277008,
0.4821149408817291,
-0.3155533969402313,
0.061019252985715866,
-0.0546405166387558,
-0.4371130168437958,
0.15352778136730194,
0.15945367515087128,
-0.11783965677022934,
0.18857000768184662,
0.3579956293106079,
0.9974581599235535,
0.3741839528083801,
-0.662006676197052,
0.6255667209625244,
-0.17739181220531464,
-0.3416103720664978,
-0.46862295269966125,
-0.16805163025856018,
0.10855909436941147,
0.5744714140892029,
0.4632776379585266,
0.029155269265174866,
0.116246297955513,
-0.3856281042098999,
0.07869209349155426,
0.4992748200893402,
-0.7982998490333557,
-0.11588127166032791,
0.39528921246528625,
0.4761543869972229,
-0.44870471954345703,
0.508232057094574,
-0.34566760063171387,
-0.5586426854133606,
0.23135964572429657,
0.352032870054245,
0.9028673768043518,
0.032230522483587265,
0.30696070194244385,
-0.08158428966999054,
0.41191989183425903,
0.21477757394313812,
0.21286951005458832,
-0.5895804762840271,
-0.5971783399581909,
-0.6361933350563049,
-0.5632922053337097,
-0.7979606986045837,
0.41018471121788025,
-0.740753173828125,
-0.21278005838394165,
-0.2918173670768738,
-0.24106642603874207,
-0.041891586035490036,
-0.12168999761343002,
-0.4663303792476654,
0.029380233958363533,
0.2560710608959198,
0.44350799918174744,
-0.7844922542572021,
0.5680955052375793,
0.598730742931366,
-0.2229643613100052,
-0.74936842918396,
-0.26159703731536865,
-0.00870047602802515,
-0.763834536075592,
0.5212421417236328,
-0.0827639028429985,
-0.21118265390396118,
-0.17563635110855103,
-0.7438080310821533,
-0.8265718817710876,
0.92836993932724,
0.34017959237098694,
-0.810531497001648,
0.15847742557525635,
0.30098551511764526,
0.6317738890647888,
-0.514133870601654,
0.6246649026870728,
0.36224600672721863,
0.042966216802597046,
0.23589441180229187,
-1.0157337188720703,
-0.24870868027210236,
-0.243019700050354,
-0.17824383080005646,
0.13402573764324188,
-0.6479548215866089,
0.46702879667282104,
-0.34084978699684143,
0.11250612139701843,
0.12848013639450073,
0.7673653960227966,
-0.1483834981918335,
0.5137854218482971,
0.5914692878723145,
0.3687838315963745,
0.6918370127677917,
-0.2650711238384247,
0.633966863155365,
-0.5025387406349182,
0.18067513406276703,
1.2710133790969849,
-0.12043695896863937,
0.3347998261451721,
0.6493123769760132,
-0.02863532491028309,
0.2940867245197296,
0.8516470193862915,
0.21597690880298615,
0.864678144454956,
0.3352099061012268,
-0.5117196440696716,
-0.6484095454216003,
-0.5004081726074219,
0.00722130760550499,
0.29721781611442566,
0.6085184216499329,
-0.23547017574310303,
-0.28693562746047974,
0.20718663930892944,
-0.07737717777490616,
-0.2554456889629364,
-0.11197199672460556,
1.0763392448425293,
0.2201033979654312,
-0.5878148078918457,
0.3489530384540558,
-0.36471232771873474,
0.5654670596122742,
-0.6594012975692749,
-0.027146531268954277,
-0.15570707619190216,
0.013559137471020222,
-0.07824764400720596,
-0.5983229875564575,
-0.10021292418241501,
0.03459981456398964,
-0.03904317319393158,
-0.4886951744556427,
0.8532272577285767,
-0.5527507066726685,
-0.027200894430279732,
0.4765268564224243,
0.7953701615333557,
0.5771217346191406,
-0.1174691691994667,
-0.5599501729011536,
0.06890163570642471,
0.16229037940502167,
-0.4186255633831024,
0.5664229393005371,
0.5500612854957581,
-0.1093951165676117,
0.8745567798614502,
0.6930789351463318,
0.074665367603302,
0.030526649206876755,
0.501359760761261,
1.1239315271377563,
-0.31798186898231506,
-0.35239845514297485,
-0.3330356180667877,
0.20708085596561432,
-0.20213840901851654,
-0.26607462763786316,
0.3933468759059906,
0.3017730414867401,
0.9081441164016724,
0.35224875807762146,
1.0443503856658936,
0.2784852385520935,
0.39049503207206726,
-0.15916845202445984,
0.27642932534217834,
-0.22859488427639008,
0.44864973425865173,
-0.25728291273117065,
-0.8765470385551453,
0.2703096866607666,
0.621752142906189,
-0.045079562813043594,
0.0376194529235363,
0.5694270133972168,
0.856273353099823,
0.2152748703956604,
0.2975315749645233,
0.639220118522644,
0.2717290222644806,
0.3557792603969574,
0.5873134136199951,
1.1758426427841187,
-0.05675782263278961,
0.8239404559135437,
-0.5220344662666321,
-0.48071351647377014,
-0.16036412119865417,
-0.5918177962303162,
-1.1581567525863647,
-0.5601823925971985,
-0.42521607875823975,
-0.4496351480484009,
0.22206906974315643,
0.9017623066902161,
0.8616812229156494,
-0.4214382767677307,
-0.2056349515914917,
-0.06776691973209381,
-0.16916392743587494,
-0.06743989139795303,
-0.11607121676206589,
-0.025616249069571495,
-0.5933920741081238,
-0.7846416234970093,
0.476716011762619,
0.543350875377655,
0.13941563665866852,
-0.4687977731227875,
-0.264037549495697,
0.24252139031887054,
0.13511310517787933,
0.41627979278564453,
0.37928611040115356,
-0.7640315890312195,
-0.10463383048772812,
0.020320722833275795,
-0.09164519608020782,
-0.0225287564098835,
0.9917095899581909,
-0.697817325592041,
0.5814840793609619,
-0.12625367939472198,
0.4161321818828583,
0.7611193060874939,
-0.18898950517177582,
0.5878174304962158,
-0.8066850900650024,
0.34700778126716614,
0.3168799579143524,
0.28462669253349304,
0.29852426052093506,
-0.3632928729057312,
0.5019419193267822,
0.32128405570983887,
-0.7741172313690186,
-0.8203911781311035,
0.2301514446735382,
-1.133177638053894,
-0.23678287863731384,
1.2504146099090576,
-0.3741229176521301,
-0.16177862882614136,
-0.7164902091026306,
-0.2922411262989044,
0.48781508207321167,
-0.7762941122055054,
0.4738623797893524,
0.552348256111145,
-0.625648558139801,
-0.1395493745803833,
-0.583235502243042,
0.6726174354553223,
0.5430507063865662,
-0.6342635154724121,
0.21547886729240417,
0.3639563322067261,
0.10021110624074936,
0.41292423009872437,
0.9996755719184875,
0.09133951365947723,
-0.03914222866296768,
0.15007655322551727,
0.09138958901166916,
-0.37489446997642517,
-0.40286391973495483,
0.11288011819124222,
-0.18436625599861145,
0.19847704470157623,
-0.2937674820423126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15206v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15206v2
|
Does Instruction Tuning Make LLMs More Consistent?
| 2024-04-23T16:39:03 | 2024-04-30T09:25:40 |
Constanza Fierro, Jiaang Li, Anders Søgaard
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The purpose of instruction tuning is enabling zero-shot performance, but
instruction tuning has also been shown to improve chain-of-thought reasoning
and value alignment (Si et al., 2023). Here we consider the impact on
$\textit{consistency}$, i.e., the sensitivity of language models to small
perturbations in the input. We compare 10 instruction-tuned LLaMA models to the
original LLaMA-7b model and show that almost across-the-board they become more
consistent, both in terms of their representations and their predictions in
zero-shot and downstream tasks. We explain these improvements through
mechanistic analyses of factual recall.
|
[
0.08065322041511536,
-0.7447962760925293,
0.6660979390144348,
-0.13851310312747955,
-0.20078857243061066,
0.01908322051167488,
-0.19577547907829285,
-0.5353041887283325,
0.09560958296060562,
0.5389678478240967,
-0.5181363821029663,
-0.4302932322025299,
-0.6865355372428894,
0.1892375499010086,
-0.35193970799446106,
0.946262538433075,
-0.07574967294931412,
-0.22887031733989716,
-0.05884639546275139,
-0.010947780683636665,
-0.7193194031715393,
-0.2709411382675171,
-0.3371262550354004,
-0.40544751286506653,
0.6456135511398315,
0.5254354476928711,
0.8785082101821899,
1.4516055583953857,
0.6112555861473083,
0.27618688344955444,
-0.15289442241191864,
0.1041211411356926,
-0.5859676003456116,
0.3393703103065491,
-0.1885327249765396,
-0.8445250391960144,
-0.68929123878479,
0.07104501873254776,
0.8096523284912109,
0.4404448866844177,
-0.42573827505111694,
0.2485639899969101,
-0.025860993191599846,
0.42541277408599854,
-0.8239559531211853,
-0.023965835571289062,
-0.9494554400444031,
-0.34655436873435974,
-0.11306978017091751,
-0.4638805389404297,
-0.4910010099411011,
-0.3948653042316437,
-0.24341869354248047,
-0.598595142364502,
0.19429387152194977,
0.06477105617523193,
1.060868263244629,
0.718215823173523,
-0.3656148314476013,
-0.2676284611225128,
-0.6486324071884155,
0.7449593544006348,
-0.9440816640853882,
0.26204994320869446,
0.2590847313404083,
0.02232827991247177,
-0.5264078378677368,
-0.2475643754005432,
-0.5735758543014526,
-0.16064020991325378,
0.15119348466396332,
0.1267799288034439,
0.044901229441165924,
0.179090678691864,
0.4272792339324951,
0.38734692335128784,
-0.24688833951950073,
0.4529990255832672,
-0.28181424736976624,
-0.06491558998823166,
0.6406770348548889,
0.4056858718395233,
0.11762895435094833,
0.2644346356391907,
-0.07585317641496658,
-0.10575803369283676,
-1.0298264026641846,
0.14691102504730225,
0.4956260919570923,
0.1528918743133545,
0.07572238892316818,
0.590103805065155,
-0.4376435875892639,
1.1019856929779053,
0.4246681034564972,
-0.48805806040763855,
-0.08937268704175949,
-0.2720862627029419,
-0.28493669629096985,
0.40917423367500305,
0.24862271547317505,
0.48223811388015747,
0.39008036255836487,
-0.02498331293463707,
-0.153404101729393,
0.30167779326438904,
0.4278234541416168,
-0.6044402718544006,
-0.3225240409374237,
-0.16692297160625458,
-0.20980852842330933,
-0.27795660495758057,
-0.05026216804981232,
-0.127706840634346,
-0.1875174343585968,
-0.7209412455558777,
0.5116986036300659,
-0.27381518483161926,
-0.04452107101678848,
0.41327977180480957,
-0.0019086390966549516,
0.6534256935119629,
0.3702152967453003,
-1.3398494720458984,
0.07848599553108215,
0.9798766374588013,
0.56179279088974,
-0.15677520632743835,
-0.3618573546409607,
-0.6681928634643555,
0.33469346165657043,
-0.7610005736351013,
1.0609140396118164,
-0.8808810710906982,
-0.1982281655073166,
-0.17466618120670319,
-0.053053755313158035,
-0.2939828634262085,
-0.7656031847000122,
0.1494263857603073,
-0.47449636459350586,
-0.17855004966259003,
-0.7040507197380066,
-0.7957741618156433,
-0.06855975836515427,
0.27314671874046326,
-0.4713500440120697,
0.88718181848526,
-0.1655261367559433,
-0.1027696430683136,
0.5081568360328674,
-0.11660721898078918,
-0.3638823330402374,
-0.38433465361595154,
-0.117847740650177,
-0.37668702006340027,
0.5685689449310303,
-0.11317982524633408,
0.20044498145580292,
-0.09322570264339447,
0.013225143775343895,
-0.3706413507461548,
-1.0307835340499878,
0.405007928609848,
-0.6623741984367371,
0.4212154150009155,
-0.06789086014032364,
-0.39610520005226135,
-0.01776960678398609,
-0.8571470975875854,
0.17183944582939148,
-0.27482160925865173,
-0.5732711553573608,
0.039492350071668625,
0.1782219111919403,
-0.9199227094650269,
0.0921669527888298,
0.2132786512374878,
-0.48255693912506104,
0.4353991150856018,
-0.2676258981227875,
0.20202411711215973,
0.9049645662307739,
0.16619160771369934,
0.2845176160335541,
-0.6371041536331177,
0.46873193979263306,
0.16458985209465027,
0.045059654861688614,
-0.5944650769233704,
-0.5115050673484802,
-1.0648460388183594,
-0.25283876061439514,
0.375469446182251,
0.5343212485313416,
-0.17027722299098969,
0.26598024368286133,
-0.06746773421764374,
-0.2688022553920746,
-0.8135321736335754,
0.20209980010986328,
0.49445706605911255,
0.5753863453865051,
0.22133541107177734,
-0.18365955352783203,
-0.3335852324962616,
-0.6996111273765564,
-0.19444851577281952,
-0.06587698310613632,
-0.0006862004520371556,
0.053883131593465805,
0.18118895590305328,
0.004837114829570055,
0.5035221576690674,
-0.3113628029823303,
0.2305794060230255,
0.13473506271839142,
-0.03902202472090721,
0.24173882603645325,
0.40727904438972473,
0.30699023604393005,
-0.12711089849472046,
-0.6160144209861755,
0.03727316856384277,
-0.768406867980957,
-0.27327173948287964,
0.051538605242967606,
-0.34760531783103943,
0.469259113073349,
0.40741875767707825,
-0.5041481256484985,
0.6053493022918701,
0.4167783558368683,
-0.0893789604306221,
0.4511094093322754,
-0.17603789269924164,
0.4194038212299347,
-0.6643593311309814,
-0.3410862982273102,
-0.2158992439508438,
-0.07965058833360672,
-0.5632811188697815,
-0.14829987287521362,
0.2701990008354187,
0.3107231855392456,
-0.40360936522483826,
0.12326579540967941,
-0.46824967861175537,
-0.18527407944202423,
-0.46366164088249207,
0.14901575446128845,
0.13157713413238525,
0.4371521770954132,
-0.09250972419977188,
1.1586021184921265,
0.45014309883117676,
-0.9309332966804504,
0.14961916208267212,
0.05175885930657387,
-0.5010241866111755,
0.6475937366485596,
-0.9086790084838867,
0.3219403624534607,
-0.023831497877836227,
-0.07824788987636566,
-0.9227477312088013,
-0.08937406539916992,
0.17423377931118011,
-0.20377203822135925,
0.6515084505081177,
0.04914941266179085,
-0.29306602478027344,
0.15911300480365753,
-0.3120833933353424,
-0.04420100152492523,
0.6297580003738403,
-0.47798627614974976,
0.29693183302879333,
-0.003021729877218604,
0.1814582347869873,
-0.7221123576164246,
-0.425747811794281,
-0.2706855535507202,
-0.012690727598965168,
-0.26854702830314636,
0.2834615111351013,
-0.14171536266803741,
-0.20542757213115692,
-0.0024539856240153313,
-0.6540679931640625,
0.2267015427350998,
0.36242014169692993,
0.12393440306186676,
0.48342961072921753,
-0.5205796360969543,
0.1772230863571167,
0.12471814453601837,
-0.1385224461555481,
-0.1128147542476654,
-0.18035969138145447,
0.28107398748397827,
-0.06463972479104996,
-0.500976026058197,
-0.7094190716743469,
-0.008517102338373661,
0.2598041296005249,
-0.11991854012012482,
0.749045729637146,
0.09281685948371887,
0.07201873511075974,
0.0836344063282013,
-0.6647111773490906,
-0.2399703711271286,
-0.5198180675506592,
0.037972573190927505,
-0.4118736684322357,
-1.0251039266586304,
0.4017183184623718,
-0.05069771036505699,
0.02777906320989132,
0.32770493626594543,
0.5896991491317749,
-0.6041122078895569,
1.1200299263000488,
0.8733595013618469,
0.05825699493288994,
0.5122907757759094,
0.12449383735656738,
0.0884411558508873,
-1.0222322940826416,
-0.12472943961620331,
-0.425213485956192,
-0.6360608339309692,
-0.8346118927001953,
-0.17254464328289032,
0.17079812288284302,
0.29574334621429443,
-0.5484103560447693,
0.21373388171195984,
-0.5323762893676758,
0.9150410890579224,
0.5804006457328796,
-0.024591239169239998,
0.321576863527298,
-0.01174943707883358,
-0.08304008096456528,
0.024220528081059456,
-0.8321430087089539,
-0.91162109375,
1.1496614217758179,
-0.016494495794177055,
0.949287474155426,
0.045575711876153946,
0.7016168832778931,
-0.07042140513658524,
0.24372904002666473,
-0.4830021560192108,
0.4148774743080139,
-0.24414829909801483,
-0.7317298054695129,
-0.12075064331293106,
-0.14694346487522125,
-0.8917961120605469,
0.024555901065468788,
-0.3109389841556549,
-0.9794942140579224,
0.08940409868955612,
0.6441402435302734,
-0.33604031801223755,
0.28214672207832336,
-0.6241104602813721,
0.6973437070846558,
-0.2944709360599518,
-0.48709121346473694,
-0.1967211216688156,
-0.5500588417053223,
0.31065359711647034,
0.15956126153469086,
-0.35437825322151184,
-0.5468267798423767,
-0.04007963836193085,
0.2214004248380661,
-0.16537734866142273,
0.9736151695251465,
0.27214282751083374,
-0.2899913787841797,
0.38822516798973083,
-0.0002675108553376049,
0.45033344626426697,
-0.2794557511806488,
-0.18946562707424164,
0.3472853899002075,
0.10301753133535385,
-0.5353100895881653,
-0.81878262758255,
0.7397509813308716,
-0.8512420058250427,
-1.150998830795288,
-0.23893755674362183,
-0.7239935994148254,
-0.02710498496890068,
-0.1531672179698944,
0.12922701239585876,
0.21158839762210846,
0.19597139954566956,
0.22094739973545074,
1.1093223094940186,
-0.0018254126189276576,
0.30804699659347534,
0.704204261302948,
0.09747994691133499,
-0.004494191613048315,
0.7151226997375488,
0.3946595788002014,
0.6211833953857422,
0.5314304232597351,
-0.08634201437234879,
-0.07665931433439255,
-0.23517757654190063,
-0.5763095021247864,
0.24267663061618805,
-0.5728726983070374,
-0.35839053988456726,
-0.1336982250213623,
-0.15551923215389252,
-0.12437374889850616,
-0.2094040811061859,
-0.34044814109802246,
-0.536824107170105,
-0.3850041925907135,
-0.22808271646499634,
0.45821988582611084,
0.9200282692909241,
0.07389546185731888,
0.6123707294464111,
-0.6118122935295105,
0.13705071806907654,
0.3294280469417572,
0.6502412557601929,
-0.08838149160146713,
-0.9060908555984497,
-0.28411877155303955,
0.2630985677242279,
-0.5417938232421875,
-0.8467721939086914,
-0.20605990290641785,
0.3185976445674896,
0.5857076048851013,
0.4133906662464142,
-0.3625759780406952,
0.8700476288795471,
-0.6544908881187439,
0.6478491425514221,
-0.08709464967250824,
-1.0740149021148682,
0.6022420525550842,
-0.11771076917648315,
0.5661236047744751,
0.37689658999443054,
0.19536316394805908,
-0.353464812040329,
-0.42839986085891724,
-0.46654754877090454,
-0.19784128665924072,
0.7265238165855408,
-0.19530218839645386,
0.2629258334636688,
-0.1877056509256363,
0.8181598782539368,
0.15274500846862793,
0.35161733627319336,
-0.21636706590652466,
-0.19328899681568146,
-0.2031615972518921,
-0.4057367444038391,
0.004744777921587229,
-0.5320349931716919,
0.053603701293468475,
-0.22763517498970032,
0.7045839428901672,
-0.04805228114128113,
0.16877132654190063,
-0.20181281864643097,
0.012619663029909134,
-0.4859267473220825,
0.231535866856575,
0.9796831011772156,
0.7939900159835815,
-0.20729215443134308,
0.2045138031244278,
0.4359366297721863,
-0.2679210901260376,
0.4473435580730438,
-0.45729202032089233,
-0.4585780203342438,
-0.17510126531124115,
0.5297717452049255,
1.0793342590332031,
0.49353620409965515,
-0.417741596698761,
0.07698224484920502,
0.1968313455581665,
-0.15130475163459778,
0.15575650334358215,
0.9867928624153137,
0.09103342145681381,
0.359174907207489,
-0.0899505764245987,
0.049959875643253326,
-0.19879089295864105,
-0.7850950360298157,
0.034419331699609756,
0.48796793818473816,
-0.18206188082695007,
-0.3841899633407593,
0.7394645810127258,
-0.1737099140882492,
-0.5640310645103455,
0.7012934684753418,
0.0628427043557167,
-0.3420114815235138,
0.7429112792015076,
0.8487961888313293,
0.464226633310318,
-0.45312780141830444,
-0.023747960105538368,
0.27412649989128113,
0.5048190355300903,
-0.14800001680850983,
0.3729901909828186,
-0.15245480835437775,
-0.8029802441596985,
-0.6407610774040222,
-0.5077357292175293,
-0.6781207919120789,
-0.21218350529670715,
-0.8104207515716553,
0.33958813548088074,
-0.5223070979118347,
-0.10335937887430191,
0.008022540248930454,
-0.05613691359758377,
-0.4601094722747803,
0.3199077248573303,
0.14488878846168518,
0.6958729028701782,
-0.6726169586181641,
1.0290592908859253,
0.5714091062545776,
-0.23953239619731903,
-1.165165901184082,
-0.06320419907569885,
-0.06343571096658707,
-0.9976078271865845,
0.2434276044368744,
0.08904047310352325,
-0.3133292496204376,
0.06592834740877151,
-0.714553713798523,
-1.3256889581680298,
1.2737973928451538,
0.8054901361465454,
-0.9072434306144714,
0.3848336637020111,
0.11903144419193268,
0.6287099123001099,
-0.35473641753196716,
0.1556345522403717,
0.8850873708724976,
0.32183638215065,
0.29243969917297363,
-0.8833301663398743,
-0.20664328336715698,
-0.09011201560497284,
0.009107924997806549,
0.3396886885166168,
-0.7091211676597595,
0.8124085664749146,
-0.37579110264778137,
-0.10920590162277222,
-0.09984918683767319,
0.643587589263916,
0.5298634171485901,
0.2546791434288025,
-0.021851815283298492,
0.7370516657829285,
1.041081428527832,
-0.2660493850708008,
1.0120759010314941,
-0.5541546940803528,
-0.0472736693918705,
1.3138431310653687,
-0.559965193271637,
0.9541293382644653,
0.29226768016815186,
-0.11172665655612946,
0.6233025193214417,
0.5211545825004578,
-0.05370026081800461,
0.4297104775905609,
-0.013668626546859741,
-0.01848694309592247,
-0.37014225125312805,
-0.08972851186990738,
-0.30978620052337646,
0.5471617579460144,
0.21801988780498505,
-0.15673419833183289,
0.2287222295999527,
-0.5025939345359802,
0.13440948724746704,
0.22269207239151,
-0.461686372756958,
0.8250472545623779,
-0.039059046655893326,
-0.8023699522018433,
0.9901617765426636,
-0.0867132693529129,
0.5269879102706909,
-0.40263602137565613,
-0.1390238255262375,
-0.35685813426971436,
0.25288113951683044,
-0.17622937262058258,
-0.6268707513809204,
0.2635878920555115,
-0.03218965232372284,
-0.508571982383728,
0.05788812041282654,
0.7146764397621155,
-0.5167511701583862,
-0.37297844886779785,
-0.15917044878005981,
0.20064902305603027,
0.09742310643196106,
0.3482661843299866,
-0.451424777507782,
0.5638760328292847,
-0.10340743511915207,
-0.1026158332824707,
0.38614216446876526,
0.46514537930488586,
0.010799567215144634,
0.550920844078064,
0.5036149621009827,
0.03492492809891701,
0.6020586490631104,
-0.037833888083696365,
0.5465435981750488,
-0.7726301550865173,
0.056734103709459305,
-1.0184106826782227,
0.3271476924419403,
0.05616740882396698,
-0.45635414123535156,
0.8282836079597473,
0.3295712172985077,
0.8974094390869141,
0.05797113478183746,
0.37741807103157043,
0.3797577917575836,
0.34932994842529297,
-0.7909798622131348,
0.26671773195266724,
-0.41035977005958557,
0.47855648398399353,
0.15881627798080444,
-0.8720343708992004,
-0.13216128945350647,
0.759416401386261,
-0.3780721127986908,
0.09191488474607468,
0.5965210795402527,
0.978485107421875,
0.012096576392650604,
-0.03276200219988823,
0.5997984409332275,
0.26460257172584534,
0.08189725130796432,
0.5489497780799866,
0.9060245752334595,
-0.4819989800453186,
0.2152644395828247,
-0.0870276466012001,
0.04371151700615883,
-0.18836912512779236,
-1.017241358757019,
-0.5782789587974548,
-0.02979937754571438,
-0.5058645009994507,
0.03125195577740669,
0.4154430031776428,
0.7199687361717224,
0.4777333736419678,
-0.8593195676803589,
-0.39589133858680725,
-0.04217318072915077,
0.43338391184806824,
-0.3754945993423462,
-0.07129784673452377,
0.010417078621685505,
-0.6750733256340027,
-0.5458118319511414,
0.3392511308193207,
0.7585431337356567,
0.05729428306221962,
0.19566833972930908,
-0.050043027848005295,
-0.3880096673965454,
0.6451441645622253,
0.44337761402130127,
0.21068522334098816,
-0.7840740084648132,
-0.5940973162651062,
0.39715784788131714,
-0.30358073115348816,
0.28391405940055847,
0.5277649760246277,
-0.6048955321311951,
0.4145311415195465,
0.07892369478940964,
0.5339322686195374,
0.5269239544868469,
0.055942561477422714,
0.5543424487113953,
-0.5876525044441223,
-0.024301717057824135,
-0.25295284390449524,
0.20924532413482666,
0.25728362798690796,
-0.4403139054775238,
0.4879509210586548,
-0.004194216337054968,
-0.7925326228141785,
-0.6913938522338867,
0.32418397068977356,
-0.7041733264923096,
-0.00789074506610632,
0.9514074325561523,
-0.17355041205883026,
-0.30791935324668884,
0.3191714584827423,
-0.00810049008578062,
0.5315542817115784,
-0.15450693666934967,
1.077975869178772,
0.8360468745231628,
-0.30092525482177734,
-0.25679099559783936,
-0.6756072044372559,
0.2805804908275604,
0.6480631232261658,
-0.5363548398017883,
-0.1443856656551361,
0.45217081904411316,
0.4505210220813751,
-0.19429239630699158,
0.36569803953170776,
0.15475213527679443,
0.5318976044654846,
-0.01005820743739605,
-0.15143737196922302,
-0.04074334725737572,
-0.44474655389785767,
-0.2953668236732483,
-0.22921493649482727,
0.3806285262107849,
-0.09652715921401978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15196v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15196v1
|
Setting up the Data Printer with Improved English to Ukrainian Machine Translation
| 2024-04-23T16:34:34 | 2024-04-23T16:34:34 |
Yurii Paniv, Dmytro Chaplynskyi, Nikita Trynus, Volodymyr Kyrylov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To build large language models for Ukrainian we need to expand our corpora
with large amounts of new algorithmic tasks expressed in natural language.
Examples of task performance expressed in English are abundant, so with a
high-quality translation system our community will be enabled to curate
datasets faster. To aid this goal, we introduce a recipe to build a translation
system using supervised finetuning of a large pretrained language model with a
noisy parallel dataset of 3M pairs of Ukrainian and English sentences followed
by a second phase of training using 17K examples selected by k-fold perplexity
filtering on another dataset of higher quality. Our decoder-only model named
Dragoman beats performance of previous state of the art encoder-decoder models
on the FLORES devtest set.
|
[
-0.14849160611629486,
-0.2946421504020691,
0.3982720673084259,
-0.03438562527298927,
-0.685565710067749,
0.12474756687879562,
-0.03268806263804436,
-0.48329979181289673,
0.2086743414402008,
0.8402054905891418,
-0.5171841382980347,
-0.5415017604827881,
-0.8026373386383057,
0.5124468803405762,
-0.6797440052032471,
0.842401385307312,
-0.23065148293972015,
0.61933434009552,
0.25384363532066345,
0.03198552131652832,
-0.4549553394317627,
-0.5809754133224487,
-0.4335951507091522,
-0.13649047911167145,
0.23600447177886963,
0.8210307955741882,
0.6657199263572693,
1.1404227018356323,
0.6968399882316589,
0.37731629610061646,
0.19627706706523895,
0.2522134482860565,
-0.5134648680686951,
0.1680331528186798,
-0.07993102818727493,
-0.8595060706138611,
-0.34198200702667236,
-0.029716646298766136,
0.3332313001155853,
0.8354001045227051,
0.057045191526412964,
0.047303490340709686,
-0.07763849198818207,
0.6172104477882385,
-0.139561727643013,
-0.04071629047393799,
-0.4820351004600525,
0.06823918223381042,
-0.3463629484176636,
0.12253561615943909,
-0.41941583156585693,
-0.3393282890319824,
-0.42624709010124207,
-0.7464213967323303,
0.10485264658927917,
0.09092766791582108,
0.8018346428871155,
0.24046748876571655,
-0.4236198365688324,
-0.46020546555519104,
-1.026391863822937,
0.8021863102912903,
-0.5433776378631592,
0.645679771900177,
0.39118579030036926,
0.12141493707895279,
-0.17739328742027283,
-0.8629378080368042,
-0.16138489544391632,
-0.011641057208180428,
-0.03673755005002022,
0.2874826490879059,
-0.22124016284942627,
-0.0789199024438858,
0.17553775012493134,
0.18343999981880188,
-0.5140491724014282,
0.31586408615112305,
-0.5329415202140808,
-0.1204393059015274,
0.3334272503852844,
0.4520532786846161,
-0.11547115445137024,
0.03785282373428345,
0.02852381393313408,
0.03020022250711918,
-0.14321134984493256,
0.00968498270958662,
0.6575144529342651,
0.47794654965400696,
0.033908192068338394,
0.6806331872940063,
-0.42831873893737793,
0.6063559651374817,
0.3138354420661926,
-0.0951983854174614,
0.19063562154769897,
-0.4657566249370575,
-0.2141609638929367,
-0.05413811653852463,
0.49505236744880676,
0.24244308471679688,
0.22239799797534943,
-0.27583885192871094,
-0.25084730982780457,
0.17926371097564697,
0.24190621078014374,
-1.0730427503585815,
-0.2731242775917053,
0.16577616333961487,
-0.5306184887886047,
-0.4537661671638489,
0.06916492432355881,
-0.7395575046539307,
-0.2575785219669342,
-0.6331285834312439,
0.13592948019504547,
-0.2691696286201477,
-0.1623617261648178,
0.5914419293403625,
0.23911231756210327,
-0.1775987446308136,
0.28310009837150574,
-0.7286240458488464,
0.6195827126502991,
0.6611886024475098,
0.7646666169166565,
-0.03232623636722565,
-0.23444440960884094,
-1.0041307210922241,
-0.13519160449504852,
-0.7245035171508789,
0.6994233727455139,
-0.4636770188808441,
-0.19999408721923828,
0.08392860740423203,
0.3995985686779022,
0.19772006571292877,
-0.6513485908508301,
0.7784002423286438,
-0.3888995349407196,
0.16983695328235626,
-0.20375312864780426,
-0.6832644939422607,
0.17407041788101196,
-0.13779805600643158,
-0.6353837847709656,
0.8024267554283142,
0.10540392994880676,
-0.6793531179428101,
0.4529598355293274,
-0.3542242646217346,
-0.6148000359535217,
0.17094533145427704,
0.25861719250679016,
-0.09068826586008072,
0.2690792679786682,
0.10304974764585495,
0.7611417174339294,
-0.19547714293003082,
0.3161942660808563,
-0.10525009781122208,
-0.24573136866092682,
-0.072407566010952,
0.027025658637285233,
0.62053382396698,
0.39261481165885925,
-0.15677174925804138,
0.06601584702730179,
-1.0373585224151611,
-0.2945362627506256,
-0.10681167989969254,
-0.7650662660598755,
-0.28666558861732483,
-0.1850457638502121,
0.25449874997138977,
0.29856231808662415,
0.5090567469596863,
-0.48885002732276917,
0.3078939914703369,
-0.5068737864494324,
0.29949989914894104,
0.4577650725841522,
-0.44808390736579895,
0.640074610710144,
-0.009174932725727558,
0.7146387100219727,
0.27526625990867615,
0.1496221274137497,
-0.05027863755822182,
-0.2626816928386688,
-0.9995496273040771,
-0.23845134675502777,
0.308626264333725,
0.7652744054794312,
-0.8075140714645386,
0.48272696137428284,
-0.27285975217819214,
-0.6685294508934021,
-0.8343947529792786,
0.23281437158584595,
0.24072512984275818,
0.3993031084537506,
0.236922487616539,
-0.27709057927131653,
-0.7472336888313293,
-1.0000993013381958,
0.13963808119297028,
0.242890864610672,
-0.05003660172224045,
-0.057002414017915726,
0.5302181839942932,
-0.14171133935451508,
0.36907169222831726,
-0.40195050835609436,
-0.14561083912849426,
-0.34966903924942017,
0.14336979389190674,
0.5853803753852844,
0.5624498724937439,
0.14041569828987122,
-0.42940887808799744,
-0.395920991897583,
0.32102012634277344,
-0.5481672286987305,
-0.21173912286758423,
0.1363958716392517,
-0.3818087577819824,
0.45194190740585327,
0.7521291971206665,
-0.7087487578392029,
0.24994614720344543,
0.5710854530334473,
-0.3113783001899719,
0.7073484659194946,
-0.3966766893863678,
0.26568514108657837,
-1.6897754669189453,
0.1506798416376114,
-0.4102959930896759,
-0.5773513913154602,
-0.682243824005127,
0.054160840809345245,
-0.0265252273529768,
-0.48064056038856506,
-0.2780158519744873,
0.10236123949289322,
-0.33521223068237305,
-0.26197248697280884,
-0.3131238520145416,
-0.10386935621500015,
0.056470032781362534,
0.035228241235017776,
0.011287285014986992,
0.6060454845428467,
0.5253909230232239,
-0.4860236644744873,
0.6695130467414856,
0.2311936318874359,
-0.5061413645744324,
0.4649304449558258,
-0.5146371126174927,
0.06362708657979965,
-0.05533851310610771,
0.005685051903128624,
-0.8878533840179443,
-0.2880374789237976,
0.22956065833568573,
-0.235786572098732,
0.3908838629722595,
-0.18589811027050018,
-0.767069935798645,
-0.6517781615257263,
0.17475970089435577,
-0.21398572623729706,
0.5072450041770935,
-0.4793834388256073,
0.2017495334148407,
0.052808426320552826,
-0.172777459025383,
-0.5576235055923462,
-0.643078088760376,
0.2579882740974426,
-0.2420744001865387,
-0.5544518232345581,
0.02883893996477127,
-0.05491495877504349,
-0.20598167181015015,
-0.2266787737607956,
0.029003484174609184,
-0.5155350565910339,
0.06454991549253464,
-0.05051463842391968,
0.009190027602016926,
-0.3733953535556793,
0.3271752893924713,
-0.10455077141523361,
-0.24273140728473663,
-0.0029429858550429344,
-0.6039775609970093,
0.6892902255058289,
0.250793993473053,
0.14711567759513855,
-0.543104887008667,
0.6004630923271179,
0.9697062969207764,
-0.23886650800704956,
0.6863600015640259,
0.5183866024017334,
-0.42828983068466187,
0.04787411913275719,
-0.2901799976825714,
-0.2763001620769501,
-0.4725891351699829,
0.5740906596183777,
-0.7171309590339661,
-0.6025478839874268,
0.6954739093780518,
-0.11703456938266754,
0.0010012524435296655,
0.21805408596992493,
0.2217857986688614,
-0.023461192846298218,
1.106876254081726,
0.7728546857833862,
-0.42276644706726074,
0.3159196972846985,
-0.2043517827987671,
0.20916864275932312,
-0.11266650259494781,
0.04262100160121918,
-0.9047664403915405,
-0.2442471981048584,
-0.5309860110282898,
-0.40528473258018494,
-0.2904396057128906,
0.3814855217933655,
-0.077931247651577,
0.5943155288696289,
-0.6524242162704468,
0.3265744745731354,
0.5548276305198669,
0.07912230491638184,
0.48641306161880493,
0.1557771861553192,
-0.3006891906261444,
-0.2958007752895355,
-0.6355171799659729,
-0.714324951171875,
0.9387736916542053,
0.07040330767631531,
0.9183237552642822,
-0.29191654920578003,
0.7835988998413086,
-0.12392747402191162,
-0.15053199231624603,
-0.7545151114463806,
0.41820308566093445,
-0.7752562761306763,
-0.4447815418243408,
-0.11598042398691177,
-0.32608339190483093,
-1.0934569835662842,
-0.1251019835472107,
-0.07370225340127945,
-0.400802344083786,
0.12083980441093445,
0.1006721556186676,
0.03755584731698036,
0.30576983094215393,
-0.6642652153968811,
0.8641256093978882,
-0.2689701318740845,
-0.32527050375938416,
-0.2427671104669571,
-0.19373179972171783,
0.2820624113082886,
-0.2399546056985855,
0.31280216574668884,
0.01250526774674654,
-0.2573486268520355,
0.7205541729927063,
-0.6580976843833923,
0.5883987545967102,
-0.2231815904378891,
-0.11481641978025436,
-0.2886770963668823,
0.19757534563541412,
0.6181163787841797,
-0.1536969095468521,
-0.3933294713497162,
-0.09656582772731781,
-0.21911877393722534,
-0.45010846853256226,
-0.2485273778438568,
0.5550153851509094,
-0.6898955702781677,
-0.3532140254974365,
0.12235425412654877,
-0.6709801554679871,
0.1889723241329193,
0.3711513876914978,
0.5889369249343872,
0.5509517788887024,
-0.039009954780340195,
0.15205766260623932,
0.3794533610343933,
0.019410904496908188,
0.05814264714717865,
0.7090152502059937,
-0.3974182903766632,
-0.3143184781074524,
0.6537381410598755,
0.32620522379875183,
0.06810010969638824,
0.41929203271865845,
0.015480461530387402,
0.008390565402805805,
-0.6950700879096985,
-0.6680739521980286,
-0.0010073253652080894,
-0.6229653358459473,
-0.37057387828826904,
-0.8018230199813843,
0.12967130541801453,
-0.3493003249168396,
-0.3624407947063446,
-0.6684812307357788,
-0.4078008532524109,
-0.6375228762626648,
-0.041899655014276505,
0.6096305251121521,
1.1626858711242676,
-0.05659981444478035,
0.43300095200538635,
-0.5760189294815063,
0.2586211860179901,
0.032619453966617584,
0.2715180218219757,
-0.30211177468299866,
-0.7102681994438171,
-0.8220349550247192,
-0.028427788987755775,
-0.14472715556621552,
-0.7381710410118103,
0.6044244766235352,
-0.2015327662229538,
0.22812709212303162,
0.2239450067281723,
-0.1427324116230011,
0.7275598049163818,
-0.8218799233436584,
0.3275011479854584,
0.03265378624200821,
-0.8392528891563416,
0.5449926853179932,
-0.5293115377426147,
0.5001153945922852,
0.5662555694580078,
0.6328371167182922,
-0.25322240591049194,
-0.6269655823707581,
-0.37005525827407837,
-0.6754299402236938,
0.7278492450714111,
-0.01668962463736534,
0.07916932553052902,
0.2642231583595276,
0.479233980178833,
0.43009278178215027,
0.09373756498098373,
-0.376419335603714,
-0.10276854783296585,
-0.05577268823981285,
-0.4212847650051117,
-0.22971145808696747,
-0.08705589920282364,
0.3755462169647217,
-0.46472257375717163,
0.7616751194000244,
0.09534008800983429,
0.03529615327715874,
-0.03880595788359642,
-0.00560021260753274,
-0.3562988340854645,
0.07898099720478058,
0.40110886096954346,
0.3904503285884857,
-0.14522473514080048,
-0.11116136610507965,
0.04942435771226883,
-0.7140381336212158,
0.36901605129241943,
0.5545719861984253,
-0.03602925315499306,
0.342791348695755,
0.20279569923877716,
0.6166070699691772,
0.28899866342544556,
-0.3566403388977051,
0.12719114124774933,
-0.13192377984523773,
-0.37589699029922485,
-0.008348890580236912,
-0.19555705785751343,
0.5047122240066528,
0.02017964981496334,
0.3913686275482178,
-0.033935099840164185,
0.23468802869319916,
-0.28724464774131775,
0.4002365469932556,
0.013083397410809994,
-0.24417349696159363,
-0.3624030351638794,
0.5204693078994751,
0.4043496549129486,
-0.47554510831832886,
0.45774802565574646,
-0.11704444140195847,
-0.578831672668457,
0.6156770586967468,
0.5103667378425598,
0.42671331763267517,
-0.5115565657615662,
0.16772115230560303,
0.5380043387413025,
0.5633824467658997,
-0.27219486236572266,
0.6298367977142334,
0.2763373851776123,
-0.5696854591369629,
-0.5649415850639343,
-0.6710202693939209,
-0.2839806079864502,
0.47788745164871216,
-0.7679226994514465,
0.5275271534919739,
-0.11893061548471451,
0.08427171409130096,
0.1277722865343094,
0.40841639041900635,
-0.7871996164321899,
0.17162367701530457,
-0.12936575710773468,
0.9529838562011719,
-0.9351001381874084,
1.0230565071105957,
0.7482051253318787,
-0.06458741426467896,
-0.6611731052398682,
-0.3915296792984009,
-0.46473097801208496,
-0.48749157786369324,
0.8856608867645264,
0.38088610768318176,
-0.11269985884428024,
0.2638903558254242,
-0.4050252437591553,
-1.0087087154388428,
0.7060615420341492,
0.6618849635124207,
-1.0012212991714478,
0.24677447974681854,
0.2537471652030945,
0.4099179804325104,
-0.5589324235916138,
-0.20793123543262482,
0.6022837162017822,
0.3480706512928009,
-0.45081815123558044,
-0.7977197170257568,
-0.15585042536258698,
-0.18286973237991333,
-0.280651330947876,
0.40113332867622375,
-0.21040090918540955,
0.7328208684921265,
0.0737394466996193,
-0.09079327434301376,
0.42962655425071716,
0.4775131344795227,
-0.28793835639953613,
-0.004209413658827543,
0.25047171115875244,
0.6210725903511047,
0.9183241724967957,
0.06932090222835541,
0.8795814514160156,
-0.41187894344329834,
-0.06843483448028564,
1.3501228094100952,
-0.32193294167518616,
0.824216902256012,
0.3529662787914276,
-0.1042475625872612,
0.26706957817077637,
0.6068841814994812,
-0.08347020298242569,
0.3572012782096863,
0.34163016080856323,
-0.0642452985048294,
-0.33209720253944397,
-0.4206514358520508,
-0.12817935645580292,
0.6065661907196045,
0.16963618993759155,
-0.5433745980262756,
-0.1672782450914383,
0.46659547090530396,
0.034974534064531326,
0.3643476366996765,
-0.30150261521339417,
0.722649097442627,
-0.23074933886528015,
-0.4634106457233429,
0.5761604905128479,
0.04993021488189697,
0.7546480894088745,
-0.39340299367904663,
0.20191973447799683,
-0.43953603506088257,
0.2405259609222412,
-0.02404317632317543,
-0.5742766857147217,
0.306729257106781,
0.37141719460487366,
-0.49892404675483704,
-0.2746954560279846,
0.7403485178947449,
-0.5682480335235596,
-0.9880808591842651,
0.4279024004936218,
0.5896461009979248,
0.7126277685165405,
0.2964475750923157,
-0.46339625120162964,
0.12245217710733414,
-0.04490857943892479,
-0.2698466181755066,
0.06830943375825882,
0.6436225175857544,
0.24687102437019348,
0.3755294382572174,
0.4732861816883087,
0.20294010639190674,
0.22258321940898895,
0.10300710052251816,
0.7613587975502014,
-0.30198073387145996,
-0.410232812166214,
-0.6562188863754272,
0.4787740409374237,
0.01752755045890808,
-0.3637816607952118,
0.6234908103942871,
1.0597195625305176,
0.9602192640304565,
-0.30464377999305725,
0.6840880513191223,
0.2558487057685852,
0.5346883535385132,
-0.3803223967552185,
0.6982468962669373,
-0.4923218786716461,
-0.38752344250679016,
-0.04450507089495659,
-0.6687778830528259,
-0.2578074336051941,
0.5606400370597839,
-0.04192129150032997,
-0.3251345455646515,
0.6484915614128113,
0.8289424180984497,
-0.3527028262615204,
-0.18727795779705048,
0.7165356278419495,
0.5112761855125427,
0.053986791521310806,
0.5601944923400879,
0.5217888355255127,
-0.5848787426948547,
0.8702691793441772,
-0.5871080756187439,
-0.0062499577179551125,
-0.10655093193054199,
-0.7746376395225525,
-0.8556334376335144,
-0.7444307804107666,
-0.05284906551241875,
-0.15884752571582794,
0.038859426975250244,
0.6688147187232971,
0.9506627917289734,
-0.810727059841156,
-0.4559444487094879,
-0.3539164662361145,
-0.2268071472644806,
-0.047116611152887344,
-0.17913219332695007,
0.03215514495968819,
-0.47140419483184814,
-0.9407739639282227,
0.40754660964012146,
0.021183636039495468,
0.2310526818037033,
-0.12579430639743805,
-0.05773971974849701,
-0.1806771457195282,
-0.09376662224531174,
0.3383103609085083,
-0.2783093750476837,
-0.41140371561050415,
0.1069900318980217,
0.1698017418384552,
-0.247573122382164,
0.1119573637843132,
0.6845548152923584,
-0.5335956811904907,
0.48163625597953796,
0.3197696805000305,
0.58570396900177,
0.5486274361610413,
-0.3087524473667145,
0.7746642231941223,
-0.4840659499168396,
0.41760435700416565,
0.10016358643770218,
0.36870306730270386,
0.5719903707504272,
-0.5647600889205933,
0.512776255607605,
0.13370844721794128,
-0.49950867891311646,
-0.7318093776702881,
0.27673667669296265,
-0.5111483335494995,
-0.21738369762897491,
0.6978305578231812,
-0.2191903442144394,
-0.1390887349843979,
-0.31342390179634094,
-0.3242848217487335,
0.5636826753616333,
-0.45493409037590027,
0.5918071866035461,
0.9737188816070557,
0.2969011962413788,
0.06773603707551956,
-0.8741172552108765,
0.4110737144947052,
0.3590417206287384,
-0.990075409412384,
0.34654736518859863,
0.49927419424057007,
0.14155025780200958,
0.06352492421865463,
0.4019859731197357,
0.21683445572853088,
0.27045708894729614,
0.07195770740509033,
0.20146550238132477,
-0.11366306990385056,
-0.4301246702671051,
-0.4883390963077545,
-0.09216731041669846,
0.096361443400383,
-0.2637653648853302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15156v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15156v1
|
Regressive Side Effects of Training Language Models to Mimic Student Misconceptions
| 2024-04-23T15:57:55 | 2024-04-23T15:57:55 |
Shashank Sonkar, Naiming Liu, Richard G. Baraniuk
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents a novel exploration into the regressive side effects of
training Large Language Models (LLMs) to mimic student misconceptions for
personalized education. We highlight the problem that as LLMs are trained to
more accurately mimic student misconceptions, there is a compromise in the
factual integrity and reasoning ability of the models. Our work involved
training an LLM on a student-tutor dialogue dataset to predict student
responses. The results demonstrated a decrease in the model's performance
across multiple benchmark datasets, including the ARC reasoning challenge and
TruthfulQA, which evaluates the truthfulness of model's generated responses.
Furthermore, the HaluEval Dial dataset, used for hallucination detection, and
MemoTrap, a memory-based task dataset, also reported a decline in the model
accuracy. To combat these side effects, we introduced a "hallucination token"
technique. This token, appended at the beginning of each student response
during training, instructs the model to switch between mimicking student
misconceptions and providing factually accurate responses. Despite the
significant improvement across all datasets, the technique does not completely
restore the LLM's baseline performance, indicating the need for further
research in this area. This paper contributes to the ongoing discussion on the
use of LLMs for student modeling, emphasizing the need for a balance between
personalized education and factual accuracy.
|
[
-0.28989022970199585,
-0.8654537200927734,
0.43054118752479553,
-0.04564634710550308,
-0.12209432572126389,
0.1101679876446724,
-0.09986481815576553,
-0.22142192721366882,
0.14794722199440002,
0.7279807329177856,
-0.3644174337387085,
-0.5171750783920288,
-0.3262222111225128,
0.12247510254383087,
-0.5992695689201355,
0.9062349200248718,
0.10911718755960464,
0.46898114681243896,
-0.4178653657436371,
-0.08312802016735077,
-0.955471396446228,
-0.987526535987854,
-0.5278027653694153,
-0.5051496028900146,
0.39536231756210327,
0.4011938273906708,
0.6283897757530212,
0.4905487596988678,
0.24307547509670258,
0.16900737583637238,
0.06564337015151978,
-0.28244316577911377,
-0.5298240184783936,
0.08314471691846848,
-0.12343601137399673,
-0.8040615320205688,
-0.15659786760807037,
0.22461678087711334,
0.7193597555160522,
0.820090651512146,
-0.2229941487312317,
0.0882391408085823,
0.08886566758155823,
0.4865359961986542,
-0.3483348786830902,
-0.007334400899708271,
-0.786255419254303,
0.22556161880493164,
-0.1335228830575943,
-0.14921492338180542,
-0.7380215525627136,
-0.2793821692466736,
0.17915023863315582,
-0.45427006483078003,
0.42742106318473816,
0.10555459558963776,
0.7448934316635132,
0.43228036165237427,
-0.2546153962612152,
-0.3891046643257141,
-0.708511233329773,
0.6945037841796875,
-0.8973270058631897,
0.48770269751548767,
0.36720210313796997,
0.39820441603660583,
-0.10394179075956345,
-0.5537222027778625,
-0.7867016196250916,
-0.3817160129547119,
-0.1985379159450531,
0.08919870853424072,
0.10214859992265701,
0.14002877473831177,
0.54720538854599,
0.20182597637176514,
-0.44024553894996643,
0.3474614918231964,
-0.37361812591552734,
-0.4077680706977844,
0.28849858045578003,
0.32200923562049866,
0.1569327414035797,
-0.2538745403289795,
-0.4352460503578186,
-0.03995686396956444,
-0.7425057291984558,
0.013925174251198769,
0.6206283569335938,
0.44438984990119934,
0.11524492502212524,
0.609717607498169,
0.03172759711742401,
0.5365411639213562,
-0.056809816509485245,
-0.1039823591709137,
0.2878182828426361,
-0.07208375632762909,
-0.2971919775009155,
0.24206602573394775,
0.44650259613990784,
0.3391733169555664,
0.3658631145954132,
-0.21911437809467316,
-0.24465665221214294,
0.33701127767562866,
0.3401400148868561,
-0.9086976647377014,
-0.11910436302423477,
0.1809922605752945,
-0.4367215931415558,
-0.4038936495780945,
-0.17489145696163177,
-0.9117781519889832,
-0.3684476315975189,
-0.5093221068382263,
0.3816494941711426,
-0.38057073950767517,
0.02272907830774784,
0.35260337591171265,
0.08907049149274826,
0.01683948189020157,
0.3163561522960663,
-0.6960398554801941,
0.5943153500556946,
0.6866325736045837,
0.7547941207885742,
-0.2795538604259491,
-0.3385818600654602,
-0.4889788031578064,
-0.14195725321769714,
-0.30912908911705017,
0.60200035572052,
-0.6926625967025757,
-0.5181863307952881,
0.12256979197263718,
-0.20004549622535706,
-0.3278089165687561,
-0.8092793822288513,
0.5304388999938965,
-0.24010199308395386,
0.49240607023239136,
-0.3698972463607788,
-0.7876849174499512,
-0.18983444571495056,
0.16052976250648499,
-0.5283651947975159,
0.7236923575401306,
-0.11072047054767609,
-0.829245924949646,
0.16325631737709045,
-0.17133687436580658,
-0.2574227452278137,
-0.08538077026605606,
-0.4925316572189331,
-0.5465298891067505,
0.127415269613266,
-0.07550284266471863,
0.3611434996128082,
-0.024091387167572975,
0.44950079917907715,
-0.3380388021469116,
-0.7388182282447815,
0.6167128682136536,
-0.48912152647972107,
0.6571105718612671,
0.15259341895580292,
-0.3191104233264923,
-0.07859840989112854,
-0.6549707055091858,
-0.3130801320075989,
0.07428178191184998,
-0.29390987753868103,
-0.5922130346298218,
-0.23076428472995758,
-0.19753111898899078,
0.24074183404445648,
-0.04206451028585434,
-0.4876703917980194,
0.14395500719547272,
-0.37745001912117004,
0.04713442921638489,
0.9210344552993774,
-0.008149240165948868,
0.2511851489543915,
-0.5640628337860107,
0.46053966879844666,
0.10197369754314423,
0.04215860366821289,
-0.22952090203762054,
-0.32467734813690186,
-0.8083798289299011,
0.06693969666957855,
0.18103860318660736,
0.38833653926849365,
-0.5777909159660339,
0.14853113889694214,
-0.0571238175034523,
-0.20752033591270447,
-0.46210286021232605,
0.19374114274978638,
0.4604579508304596,
0.8670600056648254,
0.36945217847824097,
-0.3548460602760315,
-0.6170688271522522,
-0.9317384958267212,
-0.523471474647522,
-0.3447461426258087,
0.18986710906028748,
0.23194020986557007,
0.6385223865509033,
-0.34261900186538696,
0.873523473739624,
-0.3863641321659088,
-0.4510871171951294,
-0.03290305286645889,
0.16334384679794312,
-0.17179791629314423,
0.6499025225639343,
0.48404064774513245,
-0.5476346015930176,
-0.18370969593524933,
-0.3562241196632385,
-0.5340258479118347,
-0.07340364903211594,
-0.6492514610290527,
0.1143609806895256,
0.48337727785110474,
0.3898536264896393,
-0.584128737449646,
0.35612422227859497,
0.42384931445121765,
-0.40036168694496155,
1.0021206140518188,
0.12457316368818283,
-0.01556472945958376,
-1.0193580389022827,
-0.08469773828983307,
0.06600478291511536,
0.032315000891685486,
-0.6899698376655579,
-0.15565116703510284,
-0.19847677648067474,
0.06788302958011627,
-0.31124138832092285,
0.6532912850379944,
-0.08342105150222778,
-0.04899909347295761,
-0.2694351077079773,
0.02116004191339016,
-0.1899835169315338,
0.5053521394729614,
0.09347207844257355,
0.9196011424064636,
0.39542943239212036,
-0.3766845166683197,
0.22914591431617737,
0.3324991464614868,
-0.27025800943374634,
0.555751621723175,
-0.5773798227310181,
0.20193734765052795,
-0.12995193898677826,
0.3074643909931183,
-0.8705198764801025,
-0.11020849645137787,
0.34609562158584595,
-0.5753107070922852,
0.15544667840003967,
0.0943753644824028,
-0.33252787590026855,
-0.37657982110977173,
-0.29301783442497253,
0.06469716876745224,
0.4056609272956848,
-0.7340973019599915,
0.7030210494995117,
-0.030651358887553215,
0.0973515436053276,
-0.6731454730033875,
-0.7747293710708618,
0.16585734486579895,
-0.4796173870563507,
-0.07348273694515228,
0.09100381284952164,
-0.1746063083410263,
-0.3553556501865387,
-0.14677469432353973,
-0.27234888076782227,
0.025699708610773087,
0.24117650091648102,
0.366084486246109,
0.4540291726589203,
-0.09498501569032669,
0.4056425094604492,
-0.014735930599272251,
0.022500501945614815,
0.37705186009407043,
0.040925219655036926,
0.6915977597236633,
-0.2533099055290222,
-0.3883286416530609,
-0.7026335597038269,
-0.0054537458345294,
0.4372849762439728,
0.19474707543849945,
0.81852787733078,
0.3673279285430908,
-0.46062707901000977,
-0.2004227489233017,
-0.8933984041213989,
-0.678752064704895,
-0.42533165216445923,
0.4862658381462097,
-0.39216721057891846,
-0.763810932636261,
0.5061959624290466,
-0.04411166533827782,
0.034614067524671555,
0.08506275713443756,
0.4226999282836914,
-0.13801966607570648,
0.9342905879020691,
0.4996371567249298,
0.025284377858042717,
0.5429325699806213,
-0.29090064764022827,
0.0545334629714489,
-0.7922465801239014,
-0.4927031397819519,
-0.48884013295173645,
-0.08078306168317795,
-0.36045753955841064,
-0.3198886811733246,
-0.31103989481925964,
0.020502422004938126,
-0.3609544038772583,
0.0698578804731369,
-0.14049972593784332,
0.25697261095046997,
0.40807971358299255,
0.04316550865769386,
0.43656033277511597,
0.13490357995033264,
-0.11511301249265671,
-0.33738642930984497,
-0.6738104224205017,
-0.8009641170501709,
1.2547571659088135,
0.49812793731689453,
1.001367211341858,
-0.16970238089561462,
0.6698944568634033,
0.18129205703735352,
0.5732132792472839,
-0.8482323288917542,
0.6174178719520569,
0.038950949907302856,
-0.6490110158920288,
-0.16493621468544006,
-0.647842526435852,
-0.615158200263977,
0.3574998080730438,
-0.2104973942041397,
-0.7291014790534973,
0.20899884402751923,
0.30622050166130066,
-0.25408947467803955,
0.33794695138931274,
-0.781112790107727,
0.8695396184921265,
-0.35062533617019653,
-0.3332790434360504,
-0.2680342495441437,
-0.5543956160545349,
0.6167367100715637,
-0.3828476667404175,
0.12486796826124191,
0.22239843010902405,
0.1919766515493393,
0.8925262093544006,
-0.33762556314468384,
1.2442469596862793,
-0.20388250052928925,
-0.05334863439202309,
0.11995366215705872,
0.22893697023391724,
0.551985502243042,
0.13381244242191315,
-0.0694209411740303,
0.07452847063541412,
-0.04673470929265022,
-0.3660776615142822,
-0.7264676094055176,
0.74454665184021,
-0.7764698266983032,
-1.0577571392059326,
-0.46837300062179565,
-0.6228577494621277,
-0.3879494369029999,
0.00855682697147131,
0.04528502747416496,
0.4119231700897217,
-0.24808348715305328,
0.08312621712684631,
0.6807445883750916,
-0.3107185661792755,
0.07371049374341965,
0.5104562044143677,
-0.49326667189598083,
-0.2623738944530487,
0.9380401968955994,
0.21019169688224792,
0.5855423808097839,
-0.13208307325839996,
0.30929866433143616,
-0.28780514001846313,
-0.47148656845092773,
-0.18217647075653076,
0.48992919921875,
-0.8062775135040283,
0.006811161991208792,
-0.7420356869697571,
-0.10786624997854233,
-0.5705562233924866,
-0.00048368627903982997,
-0.40976396203041077,
-0.31849223375320435,
-0.52687007188797,
-0.22758357226848602,
-0.04392228648066521,
0.6415546536445618,
0.1273881047964096,
0.4386342167854309,
-0.32737216353416443,
0.03796740993857384,
0.32577013969421387,
0.28366953134536743,
0.11667018383741379,
-0.8673481941223145,
-0.2833227217197418,
0.1685156226158142,
-0.2753942012786865,
-0.6281081438064575,
0.30049628019332886,
-0.039638619869947433,
0.7031831741333008,
0.5343904495239258,
0.007303326390683651,
0.6572955846786499,
-0.33524855971336365,
0.6268962621688843,
0.3356180191040039,
-0.9127060770988464,
0.2669438123703003,
0.11255357414484024,
-0.04256751760840416,
0.49704059958457947,
0.4811028838157654,
-0.775835394859314,
-0.5219900012016296,
-0.6812154054641724,
-0.40146201848983765,
0.45642247796058655,
0.05773910880088806,
0.36906200647354126,
0.023490289226174355,
0.6184863448143005,
0.4171602725982666,
0.33743271231651306,
-0.8472484946250916,
-0.47616130113601685,
-0.4766240417957306,
-0.11264101415872574,
-0.05367417633533478,
-0.4589581787586212,
-0.12802039086818695,
-0.2599778175354004,
0.7546359300613403,
-0.15290986001491547,
0.08821307867765427,
0.05529690906405449,
-0.089357390999794,
-0.02194702997803688,
0.15717820823192596,
0.688029408454895,
0.5777866244316101,
-0.28733816742897034,
0.28441891074180603,
0.3439061939716339,
-0.5517419576644897,
0.03936479985713959,
-0.0316176638007164,
-0.22888854146003723,
0.16904091835021973,
0.3342094421386719,
0.8512486815452576,
-0.022455833852291107,
-0.7395161986351013,
0.4970945417881012,
-0.1637827455997467,
-0.06804853677749634,
-0.42875880002975464,
-0.023466484621167183,
-0.10565534979104996,
0.18507827818393707,
0.28697508573532104,
0.3787323534488678,
-0.025498179718852043,
-0.6255747079849243,
0.15876811742782593,
0.46491438150405884,
-0.41788047552108765,
-0.4851892292499542,
0.6197569966316223,
0.08234480768442154,
-0.46034201979637146,
0.5453627109527588,
0.23747295141220093,
-0.6217502355575562,
0.5389435291290283,
0.9257435202598572,
0.6826170086860657,
-0.3937757611274719,
0.38099682331085205,
0.3358980417251587,
0.2770480215549469,
-0.2439270317554474,
-0.14175868034362793,
0.19720622897148132,
-0.9280075430870056,
-0.2635510563850403,
-0.3475240468978882,
-0.4689503312110901,
0.4479779303073883,
-0.6963908076286316,
0.3284152150154114,
-0.5458061695098877,
-0.10233346372842789,
-0.4224289655685425,
-0.08860666304826736,
-0.5820578336715698,
0.23031774163246155,
0.11695083975791931,
0.8861815333366394,
-1.0108381509780884,
0.8937541246414185,
0.4937697947025299,
-0.48386186361312866,
-0.7458045482635498,
0.30994856357574463,
0.056497760117053986,
-0.7669063210487366,
0.9304366707801819,
0.2472309023141861,
-0.048338938504457474,
-0.10399988293647766,
-0.3874273896217346,
-0.6180175542831421,
0.8029539585113525,
0.42872336506843567,
-0.7911714315414429,
-0.21092528104782104,
0.5070128440856934,
0.642267107963562,
-0.590762197971344,
0.0045861415565013885,
0.7527412176132202,
0.08981611579656601,
0.17516300082206726,
-0.5675663948059082,
0.16771939396858215,
0.22028794884681702,
0.08774571865797043,
-0.44788241386413574,
-0.5600986480712891,
0.7973032593727112,
-0.4234323501586914,
-0.37843558192253113,
0.09995503723621368,
0.5083589553833008,
0.2896808385848999,
0.30193546414375305,
0.46067288517951965,
0.6127666234970093,
0.9320454597473145,
0.056877680122852325,
1.0028647184371948,
-0.15744677186012268,
0.4281662702560425,
1.3522664308547974,
-0.334601491689682,
0.6687841415405273,
0.8584775328636169,
0.1090257465839386,
0.4664263427257538,
0.6515184044837952,
-0.017142387107014656,
0.4094635546207428,
0.5470342040061951,
-0.13008727133274078,
-0.2947313189506531,
-0.08579385280609131,
-0.5132244825363159,
0.20694193243980408,
0.3935127556324005,
-0.24640819430351257,
0.019634800031781197,
0.40605199337005615,
0.024024097248911858,
0.3012785017490387,
0.01922927051782608,
0.42986610531806946,
0.1747741401195526,
-0.3781786859035492,
0.6469746232032776,
-0.28333136439323425,
0.7614536285400391,
-0.1647920161485672,
-0.09845633059740067,
-0.5410323739051819,
0.11962038278579712,
-0.202821284532547,
-0.4523661136627197,
0.23740892112255096,
-0.09961588680744171,
0.07839516550302505,
-0.14984728395938873,
0.5259824395179749,
-0.44135043025016785,
-0.40877729654312134,
0.191881462931633,
0.45020413398742676,
0.23409461975097656,
0.15730974078178406,
-0.7493847012519836,
0.2567918598651886,
0.08505057543516159,
-0.24502885341644287,
0.16840754449367523,
0.1870405077934265,
0.07330764085054398,
0.9083177447319031,
0.6045061945915222,
0.2336043268442154,
0.043568141758441925,
0.3642590045928955,
0.842494010925293,
-0.56478351354599,
-0.13314621150493622,
-0.7831169962882996,
0.1722266972064972,
-0.02396250143647194,
-0.34687528014183044,
0.8836534023284912,
0.8041433691978455,
1.2575626373291016,
-0.1689707338809967,
0.809517502784729,
0.5471084117889404,
0.6511626839637756,
-0.5864949822425842,
0.548933207988739,
-0.36216214299201965,
0.7583537697792053,
-0.2812761664390564,
-0.7619959115982056,
-0.3267531991004944,
0.76996910572052,
-0.6375815868377686,
0.02220911532640457,
0.8700416088104248,
0.7789930105209351,
0.27918511629104614,
0.07085101306438446,
0.5204892754554749,
0.5353525280952454,
0.5102593302726746,
0.23613566160202026,
0.9957627058029175,
-0.37677809596061707,
0.42927828431129456,
-0.4206005036830902,
0.12943987548351288,
-0.3734172582626343,
-0.3931703567504883,
-1.3520052433013916,
-0.521355926990509,
-0.4113718867301941,
-0.5873082280158997,
0.18838916718959808,
0.9990803003311157,
0.22245006263256073,
-0.888142466545105,
-0.3352314233779907,
-0.12969568371772766,
0.22445805370807648,
0.03235328942537308,
-0.2881762683391571,
0.15663836896419525,
-0.5125079154968262,
-0.7511656880378723,
0.007578384596854448,
-0.1308804303407669,
0.4811742305755615,
-0.46800753474235535,
-0.266708105802536,
0.02028576284646988,
0.15204115211963654,
0.3272462487220764,
0.12683725357055664,
-0.8897786140441895,
-0.5319256782531738,
0.09133227169513702,
-0.30521145462989807,
0.09976623207330704,
0.926945149898529,
-0.9945075511932373,
0.5107103586196899,
-0.0663284957408905,
0.6825875043869019,
0.35734301805496216,
0.10723032057285309,
0.5532941222190857,
-0.46151238679885864,
0.14719614386558533,
0.27100327610969543,
0.4315239489078522,
0.43256843090057373,
-0.4945560693740845,
0.2400866597890854,
0.5944873690605164,
-0.28023436665534973,
-1.2214759588241577,
0.1456466019153595,
-0.7131226062774658,
-0.4120861887931824,
1.137985348701477,
-0.03505707532167435,
-0.045853182673454285,
-0.10384473949670792,
-0.4005863070487976,
0.2491113245487213,
-0.36291489005088806,
1.2521133422851562,
0.8241780400276184,
-0.011345703154802322,
0.09270772337913513,
-0.7995611429214478,
0.5752377510070801,
0.6729391813278198,
-0.7514730095863342,
0.27680090069770813,
0.5255163908004761,
0.4784832298755646,
0.08131551742553711,
0.283299058675766,
0.048114579170942307,
0.1069905161857605,
0.00261922855861485,
0.19491977989673615,
-0.21363592147827148,
-0.38764145970344543,
-0.48166725039482117,
-0.15686577558517456,
-0.024820292368531227,
-0.09173420071601868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15149v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15149v1
|
Bias patterns in the application of LLMs for clinical decision support: A comprehensive study
| 2024-04-23T15:52:52 | 2024-04-23T15:52:52 |
Raphael Poulain, Hamed Fayyaz, Rahmatollah Beheshti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful candidates to inform
clinical decision-making processes. While these models play an increasingly
prominent role in shaping the digital landscape, two growing concerns emerge in
healthcare applications: 1) to what extent do LLMs exhibit social bias based on
patients' protected attributes (like race), and 2) how do design choices (like
architecture design and prompting strategies) influence the observed biases? To
answer these questions rigorously, we evaluated eight popular LLMs across three
question-answering (QA) datasets using clinical vignettes (patient
descriptions) standardized for bias evaluations. We employ red-teaming
strategies to analyze how demographics affect LLM outputs, comparing both
general-purpose and clinically-trained models. Our extensive experiments reveal
various disparities (some significant) across protected groups. We also observe
several counter-intuitive patterns such as larger models not being necessarily
less biased and fined-tuned models on medical data not being necessarily better
than the general-purpose models. Furthermore, our study demonstrates the impact
of prompt design on bias patterns and shows that specific phrasing can
influence bias patterns and reflection-type approaches (like Chain of Thought)
can reduce biased outcomes effectively. Consistent with prior studies, we call
on additional evaluations, scrutiny, and enhancement of LLMs used in clinical
decision support applications.
|
[
-0.2657766342163086,
-0.7257828116416931,
0.9084708094596863,
0.44954735040664673,
-0.4176320433616638,
-0.057259343564510345,
0.006678261328488588,
-0.6297216415405273,
0.3468930721282959,
0.6434527039527893,
-0.641903281211853,
-0.7318786978721619,
-0.6226558089256287,
0.11409900337457657,
-0.1611565202474594,
0.8851391077041626,
-0.13480019569396973,
0.8514310121536255,
-0.4687363803386688,
-0.11496616154909134,
-0.7774286270141602,
-0.6477090120315552,
-0.5597310066223145,
-0.4818282425403595,
0.47045767307281494,
0.16972048580646515,
0.6500667929649353,
0.711202085018158,
0.5965405702590942,
0.16729728877544403,
-0.27789241075515747,
0.014189660549163818,
-0.287565678358078,
0.29263925552368164,
0.07763001322746277,
-0.7136264443397522,
-0.5990355014801025,
-0.05687033385038376,
0.33162394165992737,
0.9382193684577942,
-0.0830480307340622,
0.28931450843811035,
0.0654524490237236,
0.9033663272857666,
-0.4872915744781494,
0.11256870627403259,
-0.3629644513130188,
0.3746710419654846,
-0.3489376902580261,
-0.30515334010124207,
-0.44179555773735046,
-0.5717753171920776,
0.46454352140426636,
-0.3775229752063751,
0.3594813942909241,
0.17159411311149597,
0.34757447242736816,
0.2786276340484619,
-0.5394685864448547,
-0.4199574291706085,
-0.6049451231956482,
0.7312712073326111,
-0.5736402869224548,
0.39430108666419983,
0.5513138175010681,
0.2369862049818039,
-0.17260435223579407,
-0.4134038984775543,
-0.12166542559862137,
-0.032639577984809875,
-0.1943574994802475,
0.08325216919183731,
-0.008180113509297371,
0.2718086540699005,
0.6001303791999817,
0.056376662105321884,
-0.49645891785621643,
0.40659335255622864,
-0.38451677560806274,
-0.27893728017807007,
0.785987138748169,
0.5218232274055481,
0.26704996824264526,
-0.045132845640182495,
-0.29547399282455444,
0.19131945073604584,
-0.870206892490387,
-0.06280737370252609,
0.0026935627683997154,
0.1257871687412262,
-0.351734459400177,
0.535116970539093,
-0.021569574251770973,
0.6235194206237793,
0.04859171062707901,
-0.06714897602796555,
0.16668927669525146,
-0.17223487794399261,
-0.25230497121810913,
0.28672441840171814,
0.656350314617157,
0.7396793961524963,
0.4575507938861847,
-0.006838323548436165,
0.18078607320785522,
0.23644345998764038,
0.2674667537212372,
-0.5440022349357605,
0.022324083372950554,
0.35983169078826904,
-0.9053702354431152,
-0.47670283913612366,
-0.10309791564941406,
-0.9513151049613953,
-0.9283233880996704,
-0.40037885308265686,
-0.21761928498744965,
-0.0009567951201461256,
-0.08115557581186295,
0.31164824962615967,
-0.20467905700206757,
0.290813148021698,
0.5518563389778137,
-0.6738682985305786,
0.4294866919517517,
0.6080690622329712,
0.7995327115058899,
-0.44500699639320374,
0.12842345237731934,
-0.2457747906446457,
-0.12142439186573029,
-0.3767864406108856,
0.6817757487297058,
-0.4399937689304352,
-0.6392713189125061,
0.3636780083179474,
-0.06810639053583145,
0.00010464766819495708,
-0.7754179835319519,
0.6367776989936829,
-0.43030446767807007,
0.2104078084230423,
-0.7854576110839844,
-0.4483579397201538,
0.1159726232290268,
0.05803190544247627,
-0.6022706031799316,
0.3854924142360687,
-0.07971096783876419,
-0.7276283502578735,
0.8388617634773254,
-0.40808045864105225,
-0.410209983587265,
0.14031192660331726,
-0.61809241771698,
-0.6889105439186096,
0.26739463210105896,
0.21726930141448975,
0.280685693025589,
-0.4220488965511322,
0.13264988362789154,
-0.5390363931655884,
-0.25868797302246094,
0.39670076966285706,
-0.12525354325771332,
0.7392443418502808,
0.25653648376464844,
-0.38871482014656067,
0.17051903903484344,
-0.45663583278656006,
-0.24582195281982422,
0.1635369062423706,
-0.11923408508300781,
-0.5348410606384277,
0.19016656279563904,
-0.040521226823329926,
0.3213551342487335,
-0.21936385333538055,
-0.41139572858810425,
0.019785422831773758,
0.06192025914788246,
0.3702036142349243,
0.9445322751998901,
0.03666338324546814,
0.3432912230491638,
-0.6904042959213257,
0.7718406915664673,
0.09371166676282883,
0.5212777853012085,
0.15635354816913605,
-0.6255586743354797,
-0.5482566952705383,
-0.3521803617477417,
0.10621646791696548,
0.26945212483406067,
-0.3383767604827881,
-0.027659399434924126,
0.12262273579835892,
-0.10417710244655609,
-0.6244142651557922,
0.05363725870847702,
0.33954083919525146,
0.47904762625694275,
0.21794086694717407,
-0.2425200641155243,
-0.6120277643203735,
-1.14927077293396,
-0.2180461436510086,
-0.09223701059818268,
0.12543167173862457,
0.6049968600273132,
0.27335041761398315,
-0.46327099204063416,
0.7629520893096924,
-0.4778805375099182,
-0.37159839272499084,
-0.22410422563552856,
-0.318058043718338,
0.11011102795600891,
0.04361898452043533,
0.4957953691482544,
-0.6582525968551636,
-0.324092835187912,
-0.3497077226638794,
-0.7214674353599548,
-0.5340335965156555,
-0.09699440002441406,
-0.19885748624801636,
0.1401209533214569,
0.4661422073841095,
-0.5863478779792786,
0.38271254301071167,
0.36785003542900085,
-0.4695778787136078,
0.5041932463645935,
0.14968618750572205,
-0.05561911314725876,
-0.7394689917564392,
-0.2555340826511383,
0.31588444113731384,
-0.037934113293886185,
-0.6103689074516296,
-0.21628057956695557,
-0.004275251179933548,
0.2886865437030792,
-0.3525000512599945,
0.6544869542121887,
-0.3925376236438751,
-0.16446354985237122,
-0.13289715349674225,
-0.03185991570353508,
-0.025694813579320908,
-0.026531044393777847,
0.227383553981781,
0.5753682255744934,
0.4317076504230499,
-0.6899310946464539,
0.005467146635055542,
0.27939513325691223,
-0.4535200893878937,
0.5601003766059875,
-0.7711713910102844,
0.11387990415096283,
-0.4346727132797241,
0.3178718686103821,
-0.7997174263000488,
-0.06188032776117325,
0.09216149151325226,
-0.11826080828905106,
-0.010807668790221214,
-0.027630209922790527,
-0.26144087314605713,
-0.5271816253662109,
-0.4394928514957428,
0.6186714172363281,
0.4383105933666229,
-0.16620710492134094,
0.36038467288017273,
0.5536540746688843,
-0.25773006677627563,
-0.34764671325683594,
-0.7139953374862671,
-0.1973133236169815,
-0.4099160432815552,
-0.5275356769561768,
0.3185400664806366,
-0.09940199553966522,
-0.775067150592804,
-0.4672589600086212,
-0.04969567805528641,
0.13109464943408966,
0.09881996363401413,
0.4461418390274048,
0.515193521976471,
-0.05700254812836647,
0.19275149703025818,
-0.07995922863483429,
0.1087694764137268,
0.31255006790161133,
-0.00855901837348938,
0.6612470149993896,
0.2663894295692444,
-0.6437140107154846,
-0.3710130751132965,
0.41835665702819824,
0.7756054401397705,
0.002332008210942149,
0.4858364164829254,
0.1347166746854782,
-0.2805987596511841,
-0.3384115397930145,
-0.7699681520462036,
-0.23394568264484406,
-0.41458821296691895,
0.33336639404296875,
0.1188923791050911,
-0.9566235542297363,
0.6249968409538269,
0.27247825264930725,
0.12953247129917145,
0.09580156952142715,
0.9297447204589844,
-0.29692351818084717,
1.2936203479766846,
0.3119989037513733,
-0.08220995217561722,
0.5109438300132751,
0.05275772884488106,
-0.12332078069448471,
-0.8498335480690002,
-0.32643237709999084,
-0.33688288927078247,
-0.29357194900512695,
-0.8608584403991699,
-0.32855936884880066,
0.5907182097434998,
-0.3498365879058838,
-0.08387801051139832,
-0.5246361494064331,
-0.4753800630569458,
0.06998120248317719,
0.3049180209636688,
0.4902001619338989,
0.20274963974952698,
0.03250772878527641,
-0.15566124022006989,
-0.18484143912792206,
-0.6558732986450195,
-0.42415568232536316,
1.2912887334823608,
0.6598780155181885,
0.9049651026725769,
0.021666385233402252,
0.5115582346916199,
0.6826586723327637,
0.23204277455806732,
-0.732168436050415,
0.41623932123184204,
0.016496893018484116,
-0.69684898853302,
0.04139862209558487,
-0.19780193269252777,
-0.9433210492134094,
0.3170437216758728,
-0.25051891803741455,
-0.3683791756629944,
0.3602510392665863,
0.276915967464447,
-0.4571554362773895,
-0.07635607570409775,
-0.6145815849304199,
0.46748825907707214,
-0.47986456751823425,
-0.5655615925788879,
-0.023985227569937706,
-0.43005892634391785,
0.40260177850723267,
-0.0037198634818196297,
0.19122418761253357,
-0.021107066422700882,
0.10033189505338669,
0.592571496963501,
-0.35568156838417053,
1.033402442932129,
-0.060989756137132645,
-0.0684172660112381,
0.09138571470975876,
-0.04701891168951988,
0.45715242624282837,
0.07553363591432571,
-0.15420010685920715,
0.20966258645057678,
0.025671163573861122,
-0.4156739115715027,
-0.3724743127822876,
0.40383046865463257,
-0.820277750492096,
-0.7348259091377258,
-0.5475486516952515,
-0.41199731826782227,
-0.3977665305137634,
-0.01336723007261753,
0.23414316773414612,
0.38819828629493713,
-0.21847854554653168,
-0.09311934560537338,
0.7947866916656494,
-0.3971669375896454,
0.00503375893458724,
0.5431731939315796,
-0.17326773703098297,
-0.2105601280927658,
0.22604002058506012,
0.14769268035888672,
0.47026145458221436,
0.08014510571956635,
0.3082294464111328,
-0.24161481857299805,
-0.8968347907066345,
-0.24536214768886566,
0.44946494698524475,
-0.5681807994842529,
0.1756695955991745,
-0.5534487366676331,
-0.11974116414785385,
-0.4485359489917755,
-0.0916338562965393,
0.10786960273981094,
-0.1666363924741745,
-0.2155347615480423,
-0.2214772254228592,
0.20187607407569885,
0.9215211868286133,
0.5306016206741333,
0.10482319444417953,
-0.4042673408985138,
0.20333652198314667,
0.299577534198761,
0.4079339802265167,
-0.03945329412817955,
-0.12031933665275574,
-0.011438613757491112,
-0.133569598197937,
-0.19524820148944855,
-0.9674398303031921,
0.22492142021656036,
-0.4185149669647217,
0.7168991565704346,
0.4542682468891144,
-0.03192417696118355,
0.4146748483181,
-0.5186672806739807,
0.6025844216346741,
0.14702723920345306,
-0.4195340573787689,
0.4544978141784668,
-0.5064026117324829,
0.16633489727973938,
0.5066784620285034,
0.2229372262954712,
-0.6125245690345764,
-0.13155265152454376,
-0.3317824900150299,
-0.538023829460144,
0.5424802899360657,
-0.13216890394687653,
-0.16746766865253448,
-0.17395436763763428,
0.47797510027885437,
0.106887087225914,
0.3171018958091736,
-0.6085521578788757,
-0.39150869846343994,
0.054412879049777985,
-0.20016422867774963,
0.16012568771839142,
-0.6351569890975952,
-0.35894250869750977,
0.06939121335744858,
0.10048649460077286,
-0.19090726971626282,
0.32525622844696045,
0.3452955484390259,
-0.07956214249134064,
-0.22852493822574615,
0.3484078049659729,
0.8713008761405945,
0.6784494519233704,
-0.1000930666923523,
0.04762977361679077,
0.16352325677871704,
-0.5887579321861267,
-0.04197805002331734,
-0.09824304282665253,
-0.5342865586280823,
0.028552193194627762,
0.44507497549057007,
0.7554656863212585,
-0.31426069140434265,
-0.4496638774871826,
0.4115733802318573,
-0.15859103202819824,
-0.2630815804004669,
-0.33272725343704224,
-0.022389501333236694,
-0.17040672898292542,
0.28353360295295715,
-0.0361417792737484,
-0.22364701330661774,
0.2203589677810669,
-0.45390093326568604,
-0.03888716548681259,
0.8492546081542969,
-0.556731641292572,
-0.1244858056306839,
0.49697133898735046,
0.2947092652320862,
-0.34189078211784363,
0.4122232496738434,
0.4085879325866699,
-0.32183000445365906,
0.6606283187866211,
0.5101670026779175,
0.7679599523544312,
0.01858294941484928,
0.2971992492675781,
0.007456344552338123,
0.19397875666618347,
-0.14275237917900085,
0.2773045003414154,
0.006269182078540325,
-0.7470821738243103,
-0.192020446062088,
-0.4112926125526428,
-0.5194011330604553,
0.08565971255302429,
-0.6556928157806396,
0.48260822892189026,
-0.7602663040161133,
-0.5795150399208069,
-0.1384090781211853,
-0.2027597427368164,
-0.7604900598526001,
0.0752389132976532,
0.447352796792984,
0.8821396231651306,
-0.6802718043327332,
0.4402271807193756,
0.763868510723114,
-0.21988894045352936,
-0.41022324562072754,
-0.10568948835134506,
0.4793482720851898,
-1.0766980648040771,
0.65385502576828,
-0.11338785290718079,
0.13723772764205933,
-0.6161487698554993,
-0.36946627497673035,
-0.6728674173355103,
1.0004295110702515,
0.2096533477306366,
-0.6695529818534851,
-0.322576105594635,
0.4267846345901489,
0.6577044129371643,
-0.4862115681171417,
0.4394678473472595,
0.6289370059967041,
0.28505802154541016,
-0.05936601758003235,
-0.8848938941955566,
0.14737890660762787,
-0.13238008320331573,
0.033993739634752274,
0.07762324810028076,
-0.8041953444480896,
0.6888202428817749,
-0.3529512584209442,
-0.05511041358113289,
-0.15414592623710632,
-0.035843029618263245,
0.7326518893241882,
0.5307086110115051,
0.35652461647987366,
0.2919082045555115,
0.7877454161643982,
-0.0656852051615715,
1.128165364265442,
-0.12661485373973846,
-0.0893227830529213,
0.8023072481155396,
-0.694408655166626,
0.12633056938648224,
0.5131612420082092,
-0.28730177879333496,
0.562929630279541,
0.6473059058189392,
0.052648287266492844,
0.4337923228740692,
0.3715222179889679,
-0.1734081208705902,
-0.25720691680908203,
-0.43761202692985535,
-0.48359495401382446,
0.23791390657424927,
0.44423529505729675,
-0.860615074634552,
0.17672577500343323,
-0.2902079224586487,
0.18907900154590607,
-0.06983290612697601,
-0.39343273639678955,
0.9137321710586548,
0.36925071477890015,
-0.5990117788314819,
0.19206906855106354,
-0.25577619671821594,
0.47878140211105347,
-0.6458966135978699,
-0.018781250342726707,
-0.2820660173892975,
0.25101438164711,
-0.5124905705451965,
-0.5995410084724426,
-0.1319771707057953,
-0.0907277911901474,
-0.4700990915298462,
-0.4248245358467102,
0.617277204990387,
-0.011699756607413292,
-0.4804116189479828,
0.2982383072376251,
0.6371608376502991,
-0.21049563586711884,
0.25844451785087585,
-0.6929981708526611,
0.31877851486206055,
0.07325644791126251,
-0.06362146139144897,
0.5156813859939575,
0.17713916301727295,
-0.49389153718948364,
0.6996870040893555,
0.6174676418304443,
0.6378940343856812,
0.14602747559547424,
0.6051332950592041,
0.6965047121047974,
-0.6557503938674927,
-0.34396567940711975,
-1.0750693082809448,
0.2489553540945053,
-0.20432955026626587,
-0.27943506836891174,
0.8299421072006226,
0.2271263152360916,
0.5330058932304382,
0.2113717496395111,
0.9458975791931152,
0.5852457880973816,
0.4443126320838928,
-0.6779971718788147,
0.4911801517009735,
-0.2688552439212799,
0.45030248165130615,
-0.4948500394821167,
-0.6550012826919556,
-0.43061667680740356,
0.42190635204315186,
-0.6256904006004333,
0.32775965332984924,
0.429357647895813,
0.5287518501281738,
0.4444102346897125,
0.2936386466026306,
0.12441140413284302,
0.22763971984386444,
0.6000184416770935,
0.390579491853714,
0.9612220525741577,
0.011076384223997593,
0.028915513306856155,
-0.036719679832458496,
-0.34013986587524414,
-0.30107101798057556,
-0.7185183763504028,
-0.9762916564941406,
0.04847356677055359,
-0.2518247365951538,
-0.46958449482917786,
0.08319605886936188,
1.158197045326233,
0.7405455708503723,
-0.8818625807762146,
-0.32799622416496277,
-0.01814906671643257,
0.38095471262931824,
-0.018853044137358665,
-0.1577339470386505,
0.35089853405952454,
-0.2120472937822342,
-0.3194892704486847,
-0.10201700031757355,
0.17178888618946075,
0.09064996987581253,
-0.3088539242744446,
-0.06856755167245865,
0.13647083938121796,
-0.03383690491318703,
0.6762041449546814,
0.014444301836192608,
-0.6547682881355286,
0.10510627925395966,
0.3717041015625,
-0.2781620919704437,
0.03933638334274292,
1.1754391193389893,
-0.5794697999954224,
0.47195976972579956,
0.47008582949638367,
0.4450344145298004,
0.20041006803512573,
0.12383483350276947,
0.7723124623298645,
0.019784091040492058,
-0.09265435487031937,
0.37923872470855713,
0.7035797238349915,
0.1825251579284668,
-0.40992626547813416,
0.29325881600379944,
0.30099886655807495,
-0.5911563038825989,
-0.81733638048172,
0.2585660219192505,
-0.6837993264198303,
-0.25537019968032837,
1.5671885013580322,
0.4955841600894928,
-0.01928088441491127,
-0.429028183221817,
-0.37345895171165466,
-0.12292817234992981,
-0.3359578549861908,
0.9627929925918579,
0.664657711982727,
-0.5038847327232361,
-0.14411120116710663,
-0.7710597515106201,
0.8396924138069153,
0.5834398865699768,
-0.6502549052238464,
0.15535947680473328,
0.7107375860214233,
0.20868617296218872,
-0.09648558497428894,
0.8096232414245605,
-0.43003153800964355,
0.4666670262813568,
-0.5790289640426636,
-0.12060637772083282,
0.10417943447828293,
-0.07769373804330826,
-0.5433963537216187,
0.025322118774056435,
0.3365800082683563,
-0.014920310117304325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15146v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15146v2
|
Rethinking LLM Memorization through the Lens of Adversarial Compression
| 2024-04-23T15:49:37 | 2024-07-01T14:43:11 |
Avi Schwarzschild, Zhili Feng, Pratyush Maini, Zachary C. Lipton, J. Zico Kolter
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) trained on web-scale datasets raise substantial
concerns regarding permissible data usage. One major question is whether these
models "memorize" all their training data or they integrate many data sources
in some way more akin to how a human would learn and synthesize information.
The answer hinges, to a large degree, on how we define memorization. In this
work, we propose the Adversarial Compression Ratio (ACR) as a metric for
assessing memorization in LLMs. A given string from the training data is
considered memorized if it can be elicited by a prompt (much) shorter than the
string itself -- in other words, if these strings can be "compressed" with the
model by computing adversarial prompts of fewer tokens. The ACR overcomes the
limitations of existing notions of memorization by (i) offering an adversarial
view of measuring memorization, especially for monitoring unlearning and
compliance; and (ii) allowing for the flexibility to measure memorization for
arbitrary strings at a reasonably low compute. Our definition serves as a
practical tool for determining when model owners may be violating terms around
data usage, providing a potential legal tool and a critical lens through which
to address such scenarios.
|
[
-0.3735963702201843,
-0.7870491743087769,
0.07433050870895386,
-0.28874462842941284,
-0.24628117680549622,
0.017596010118722916,
-0.4078088104724884,
-0.11749976128339767,
-0.16448010504245758,
0.431500643491745,
-0.3532876670360565,
-0.2344951629638672,
-0.7484934329986572,
0.0870804563164711,
-0.7301474809646606,
1.1028202772140503,
-0.12241490930318832,
0.006158133968710899,
-0.4020645022392273,
-0.21058447659015656,
-0.13655346632003784,
-0.9669890999794006,
-0.6135147213935852,
-0.25085288286209106,
0.756456196308136,
0.05840351805090904,
0.7272196412086487,
1.1939356327056885,
0.6236088871955872,
0.36323896050453186,
-0.43779969215393066,
0.006717337295413017,
-0.7473542094230652,
-0.015448697842657566,
0.13035163283348083,
-0.9017696976661682,
-0.23440568149089813,
0.19328691065311432,
0.65550696849823,
0.5387352108955383,
-0.43320968747138977,
0.2609495520591736,
0.01879250444471836,
0.7484298944473267,
-0.6920070648193359,
-0.09479810297489166,
-0.9150287508964539,
0.24030861258506775,
0.050873205065727234,
-0.48981887102127075,
-0.3534090518951416,
-0.2123935967683792,
-0.2038671225309372,
-0.6478894352912903,
0.6020918488502502,
0.010954289697110653,
0.7329820990562439,
0.4540935158729553,
-0.2420634776353836,
-0.42298805713653564,
-0.7484631538391113,
0.4056684970855713,
-0.425557941198349,
0.38015905022621155,
0.5333738327026367,
0.4310554265975952,
-0.10688433796167374,
-0.6515939831733704,
-0.5144444108009338,
-0.07939455658197403,
0.020610198378562927,
-0.06308808922767639,
-0.5984504818916321,
-0.034054480493068695,
0.5937548279762268,
0.7001205682754517,
-0.41216185688972473,
-0.004092270042747259,
-0.5772532224655151,
-0.34488388895988464,
0.4750925600528717,
0.2641589939594269,
0.30981534719467163,
0.34057119488716125,
-0.4567036032676697,
-0.22971118986606598,
-0.9453355073928833,
-0.03331102430820465,
0.584869921207428,
0.2949173152446747,
0.15687038004398346,
0.578060507774353,
0.3364773690700531,
0.3400477468967438,
0.08238430321216583,
-0.10050231963396072,
-0.062392979860305786,
0.12253879755735397,
-0.4552232325077057,
0.022039346396923065,
0.7571336030960083,
0.15054942667484283,
0.3429260551929474,
-0.46100541949272156,
-0.37714847922325134,
0.10526986420154572,
0.7284335494041443,
-0.733888566493988,
-0.5199283361434937,
-0.20068036019802094,
-0.3365725576877594,
-0.055173359811306,
0.006316089071333408,
-0.4248320162296295,
-0.638532280921936,
-0.36902934312820435,
0.523481011390686,
-0.5178667306900024,
0.3119131028652191,
0.07401377707719803,
-0.16177989542484283,
-0.22615979611873627,
0.08727554231882095,
-0.7528427839279175,
0.41564586758613586,
0.7195770144462585,
0.7878537774085999,
0.14191047847270966,
-0.46434834599494934,
-0.25062814354896545,
0.12505826354026794,
-0.171068012714386,
0.45108866691589355,
-0.12399430572986603,
-0.581443190574646,
0.017078934237360954,
-0.14721393585205078,
-0.20136600732803345,
-0.5341517925262451,
0.47674137353897095,
-0.7103259563446045,
-0.024124745279550552,
-0.05563674122095108,
-0.8115290999412537,
-0.4413706958293915,
0.5773837566375732,
-0.8255497813224792,
0.5815399289131165,
0.05360320210456848,
-0.7562754154205322,
0.20085768401622772,
0.15707986056804657,
-0.45467105507850647,
-0.115635447204113,
-0.03122377209365368,
-0.7471466064453125,
0.20883792638778687,
-0.003967985976487398,
0.3421326279640198,
-0.33764922618865967,
0.0624261237680912,
-0.33900049328804016,
-0.4912239611148834,
0.7724403142929077,
-0.9225311875343323,
0.41217052936553955,
0.3115639090538025,
0.1654178649187088,
-0.25953444838523865,
-0.7711018323898315,
-0.1091923862695694,
0.12373961508274078,
-0.8112332820892334,
-0.3819352686405182,
-0.06289928406476974,
-0.4530038833618164,
-0.04100290313363075,
0.13548238575458527,
-0.177190363407135,
0.21094374358654022,
-0.31811586022377014,
0.5054944753646851,
0.8208127617835999,
-0.09555027633905411,
0.3640446960926056,
-0.6516321897506714,
0.4655136168003082,
-0.1169109120965004,
0.22398078441619873,
-0.18079811334609985,
0.2955906391143799,
-1.0287563800811768,
-0.3099024295806885,
0.13460275530815125,
0.46143707633018494,
-0.385086327791214,
0.2691597044467926,
-0.5057469010353088,
-0.4631211757659912,
-0.4586881995201111,
0.4076130986213684,
0.6768385767936707,
0.3263126015663147,
0.37595754861831665,
-0.3164975941181183,
-0.5563470721244812,
-0.6802963614463806,
-0.3750062882900238,
-0.4202021360397339,
-0.09384685754776001,
0.555998682975769,
0.4682694971561432,
-0.01814446784555912,
0.49472367763519287,
-0.1974986046552658,
-0.37444868683815,
-0.15678079426288605,
0.2256191074848175,
-0.07093995809555054,
0.20030730962753296,
0.04730484262108803,
-0.7211892008781433,
-0.20268820226192474,
-0.381068617105484,
-0.4404903054237366,
0.14857010543346405,
-0.2721460163593292,
0.25853481888771057,
0.0037294316571205854,
0.6373977661132812,
-0.695760190486908,
0.41584646701812744,
0.2420186549425125,
-0.2398141622543335,
0.4986208379268646,
-0.41556552052497864,
0.015350205823779106,
-0.7082595825195312,
0.17547670006752014,
-0.2683872878551483,
0.005089641083031893,
-0.7600629329681396,
0.2949220538139343,
0.15207712352275848,
0.07658848166465759,
-0.7244932651519775,
0.11970248818397522,
-0.5768136382102966,
0.03549617528915405,
-0.3060978055000305,
-0.1340770274400711,
-0.011205577291548252,
0.3658542335033417,
-0.33377423882484436,
1.1124560832977295,
0.22153891623020172,
-1.0019843578338623,
0.3577299416065216,
0.3053542971611023,
-0.30680617690086365,
0.5105117559432983,
-0.4246298670768738,
0.3355448842048645,
-0.2317465841770172,
0.3172386884689331,
-0.6500065922737122,
0.0486043319106102,
-0.12871016561985016,
-0.6418523788452148,
0.3852933347225189,
-0.3163835108280182,
-0.7009532451629639,
-0.31435874104499817,
-0.2862564027309418,
0.5038741827011108,
0.4893534779548645,
-0.5979753732681274,
0.4465232491493225,
0.38342607021331787,
0.3636998236179352,
-0.5850949287414551,
-0.7947540283203125,
0.11332157999277115,
-0.7830808758735657,
-0.3647872507572174,
0.20934785902500153,
-0.22130508720874786,
-0.17363299429416656,
-0.1758471131324768,
-0.2899911403656006,
-0.10435625165700912,
0.3754587471485138,
0.41323888301849365,
0.18175488710403442,
-0.029822947457432747,
0.09150702506303787,
-0.6809909343719482,
0.18122471868991852,
0.2361903041601181,
-0.028548570349812508,
0.6743643879890442,
-0.015681887045502663,
-0.24792417883872986,
-0.17414860427379608,
-0.01822316087782383,
0.4313965439796448,
-0.0013641802361235023,
0.5652004480361938,
0.413584440946579,
-0.25908130407333374,
-0.3025822341442108,
-0.5777247548103333,
0.017231522127985954,
-0.4763433337211609,
0.057775333523750305,
-0.24794168770313263,
-0.7015414237976074,
0.6707823276519775,
0.02195562794804573,
-0.19686873257160187,
0.10748184472322464,
0.4059979319572449,
0.002798956586048007,
0.8238382935523987,
0.5002514123916626,
-0.2558828592300415,
0.35538068413734436,
-0.4056219458580017,
-0.018828386440873146,
-0.9518621563911438,
-0.3276801109313965,
-0.3729914724826813,
-0.528012216091156,
-0.2051268368959427,
-0.37732627987861633,
0.10790365189313889,
0.3563055694103241,
-0.48651617765426636,
0.4379332661628723,
-0.12674479186534882,
0.7867881059646606,
0.5717286467552185,
0.13569316267967224,
0.10884029418230057,
-0.03702014684677124,
0.1224195659160614,
0.22824063897132874,
-0.5601028203964233,
-0.5357003808021545,
1.1583781242370605,
0.4579320549964905,
0.8691633343696594,
0.17433159053325653,
0.5767723321914673,
0.2619473338127136,
0.04930843785405159,
-0.971036970615387,
0.702319324016571,
-0.4471210539340973,
-0.5497177243232727,
0.024238403886556625,
-0.6809177398681641,
-1.087790608406067,
0.0650506466627121,
0.0021758645307272673,
-0.5327937602996826,
-0.04271902143955231,
0.3906506299972534,
-0.39570003747940063,
0.6329729557037354,
-0.44894546270370483,
0.5871056318283081,
-0.23498554527759552,
-0.08222097903490067,
-0.09246215969324112,
-0.5302194952964783,
0.2946494221687317,
0.07397396862506866,
0.12163864076137543,
0.04294532909989357,
-0.1963987648487091,
0.843528151512146,
-0.25741955637931824,
0.8994444608688354,
0.06904871016740799,
0.05332134664058685,
0.3327277898788452,
0.3441393971443176,
0.6014663577079773,
-0.3027021884918213,
0.20670704543590546,
-0.04638064652681351,
-0.20281028747558594,
-0.06745075434446335,
-0.6186364889144897,
0.5114037394523621,
-0.8620645403862,
-0.595403254032135,
-0.4356657862663269,
-0.7163092494010925,
-0.08535096049308777,
-0.04475060850381851,
0.4489823281764984,
0.1883039027452469,
-0.5227873921394348,
0.18576684594154358,
0.8843106627464294,
-0.04945223778486252,
0.1535937637090683,
0.9313628077507019,
0.3619523346424103,
-0.47107699513435364,
1.1295967102050781,
0.18883052468299866,
0.2903350591659546,
0.40761303901672363,
0.1058240681886673,
-0.3114069700241089,
-0.8655559420585632,
-0.14917725324630737,
0.0704711526632309,
-0.8910932540893555,
-0.4271014630794525,
-0.3886600732803345,
-0.41692915558815,
-0.10005426406860352,
-0.050967738032341,
-0.1695113182067871,
-0.5414642095565796,
-0.7562670111656189,
-0.09336894005537033,
0.21813122928142548,
0.5206632614135742,
0.027759786695241928,
0.4017425775527954,
-0.6967150568962097,
0.2737099528312683,
0.16752247512340546,
0.21111834049224854,
-0.0502665713429451,
-0.9800872206687927,
-0.28095531463623047,
-0.08930546045303345,
-0.35787057876586914,
-0.5578619837760925,
0.5153483152389526,
0.3995681405067444,
0.3464094400405884,
0.47376173734664917,
0.047721922397613525,
0.8376635313034058,
-0.7159133553504944,
0.6563961505889893,
0.182463139295578,
-0.7174593806266785,
0.21801140904426575,
-0.0743461474776268,
0.14736652374267578,
0.5314629077911377,
0.26598605513572693,
-0.6584346890449524,
-0.5817492008209229,
-0.8155114650726318,
-1.0145987272262573,
0.47100600600242615,
-0.07238224893808365,
0.2872462570667267,
-0.09810306876897812,
0.517272412776947,
0.05609683692455292,
0.22966478765010834,
-0.5673622488975525,
-0.30136656761169434,
-0.12974661588668823,
-0.16760383546352386,
-0.33312687277793884,
-0.23176749050617218,
-0.4587361514568329,
0.04907405003905296,
0.49103325605392456,
0.16362117230892181,
0.16810385882854462,
-0.07958110421895981,
-0.4112532138824463,
0.011292851530015469,
0.4742600917816162,
0.2025282382965088,
0.29787003993988037,
0.09905117005109787,
0.5696159601211548,
0.2825939655303955,
-0.6702255010604858,
0.3169766366481781,
0.11271728575229645,
-0.3642445504665375,
-0.4515153467655182,
0.3647180497646332,
0.6990214586257935,
0.05537817254662514,
-0.7229562401771545,
0.4611952602863312,
-0.24635697901248932,
-0.11269304156303406,
-0.49465373158454895,
0.2518121898174286,
-0.26302292943000793,
0.09692201018333435,
0.06405940651893616,
0.0641046017408371,
0.1775214672088623,
-0.5851669907569885,
0.4014945924282074,
0.5275073647499084,
-0.5206394791603088,
-0.27204951643943787,
0.593378484249115,
-0.20430418848991394,
-0.32044729590415955,
0.7598089575767517,
-0.09927119314670563,
-0.7624191045761108,
0.661888837814331,
0.561826229095459,
0.7904845476150513,
-0.30619296431541443,
-0.15744559466838837,
0.39463484287261963,
0.3982371985912323,
-0.37900790572166443,
-0.11321432888507843,
0.004864017944782972,
-0.5365265607833862,
0.16427500545978546,
-0.3727159798145294,
-0.11181260645389557,
0.35890915989875793,
-0.8256688714027405,
0.1421467512845993,
-0.8023839592933655,
-0.1474796086549759,
-0.00865855347365141,
-0.052581798285245895,
-0.6081514358520508,
0.41315266489982605,
0.2689543664455414,
0.9031792283058167,
-0.608798623085022,
0.7446284890174866,
0.3608151376247406,
-0.3928261399269104,
-0.6831027269363403,
0.06718675047159195,
0.49053189158439636,
-1.0758795738220215,
0.4489304721355438,
0.1798916459083557,
-0.0024187243543565273,
-0.31197449564933777,
-0.26025477051734924,
-0.66166090965271,
1.233420968055725,
0.3917101323604584,
-0.4839286506175995,
-0.002930216956883669,
0.06518741697072983,
0.7221741676330566,
-0.027631601318717003,
0.03301918879151344,
0.7786197066307068,
0.049188680946826935,
0.16724233329296112,
-0.6331068873405457,
0.06263237446546555,
-0.41770875453948975,
-0.07448505610227585,
0.4167400002479553,
-0.79053795337677,
1.0612605810165405,
-0.2927898168563843,
-0.7936971187591553,
0.12657493352890015,
0.5072851777076721,
-0.21282514929771423,
0.223063662648201,
0.4167829751968384,
0.8028233647346497,
0.8361678123474121,
-0.014349227771162987,
1.178170919418335,
-0.19169911742210388,
0.15754027664661407,
1.0167139768600464,
0.18969473242759705,
0.8905401229858398,
0.5691362023353577,
-0.30907294154167175,
-0.12627898156642914,
0.32843470573425293,
-0.3876746892929077,
0.3263033330440521,
0.672002911567688,
-0.3069039285182953,
-0.14512509107589722,
-0.13556332886219025,
-0.05744669958949089,
0.284863144159317,
0.4375302195549011,
-0.4313875436782837,
0.06671192497015,
-0.18828344345092773,
0.18845826387405396,
0.38736075162887573,
-0.4216381907463074,
1.0817183256149292,
0.20200829207897186,
-0.5902548432350159,
0.9742496013641357,
0.00948404986411333,
0.40984439849853516,
-0.5855540633201599,
0.36792629957199097,
-0.20426256954669952,
0.5651467442512512,
0.0675191879272461,
-0.7667837738990784,
0.34910696744918823,
0.275163471698761,
-0.16509553790092468,
-0.1628044694662094,
0.20855289697647095,
-0.5192234516143799,
-0.39470043778419495,
0.23287366330623627,
0.056941431015729904,
0.2468264400959015,
0.0680338516831398,
-0.6695602536201477,
0.1273445188999176,
-0.17415374517440796,
-0.20404763519763947,
0.5579367280006409,
0.3214746117591858,
0.3390738070011139,
1.1195262670516968,
0.49113714694976807,
0.3990488052368164,
0.26413458585739136,
0.16893573105335236,
0.8918942213058472,
-0.5725113153457642,
-0.36627230048179626,
-1.0043901205062866,
0.014945206232368946,
0.20481868088245392,
-0.31554701924324036,
1.0123140811920166,
0.779434084892273,
0.9249962568283081,
0.3335089683532715,
0.7713861465454102,
0.21553641557693481,
0.40816783905029297,
-0.7460076212882996,
0.6649309396743774,
-0.5657079219818115,
0.723862886428833,
0.24840156733989716,
-0.470287561416626,
-0.4386861324310303,
0.40429750084877014,
-0.011960114352405071,
-0.17614059150218964,
0.5190140604972839,
0.773081362247467,
-0.29899919033050537,
0.05186836048960686,
0.2667677402496338,
0.22008498013019562,
0.27457040548324585,
0.9778763055801392,
0.9564536809921265,
-0.4737061858177185,
1.2773619890213013,
-0.2960492968559265,
0.15487028658390045,
-0.041239868849515915,
-0.4493512213230133,
-1.122604489326477,
-0.39671242237091064,
-0.2526180148124695,
-0.4631582200527191,
0.2121737003326416,
0.7663094997406006,
0.24787543714046478,
-0.5132532715797424,
-0.20119337737560272,
-0.16381089389324188,
-0.10195056349039078,
-0.1888095736503601,
-0.04562677443027496,
0.3408145010471344,
-0.2790151536464691,
-0.469486266374588,
0.5139591097831726,
-0.1083555817604065,
0.7098977565765381,
-0.34364548325538635,
-0.1317644566297531,
0.3112178444862366,
0.29467257857322693,
0.1874323934316635,
0.5371981859207153,
-0.7048612236976624,
-0.09795533120632172,
-0.19504590332508087,
-0.20034931600093842,
0.1437900811433792,
1.170021414756775,
-0.5220266580581665,
0.43340227007865906,
0.3501066565513611,
0.4995460510253906,
0.24946601688861847,
0.21226264536380768,
0.5305257439613342,
-1.012378454208374,
-0.018191497772932053,
0.3122594356536865,
0.447565495967865,
0.6160784959793091,
-0.31377100944519043,
0.20472054183483124,
0.007934349589049816,
-0.5097014307975769,
-0.9205653667449951,
0.34329622983932495,
-0.5067797303199768,
-0.39610201120376587,
1.1920665502548218,
-0.5624139308929443,
-0.24113114178180695,
0.0734647884964943,
0.005691280588507652,
0.2886395752429962,
-0.2666226327419281,
1.1670411825180054,
0.8255117535591125,
0.34185218811035156,
-0.08252780884504318,
-0.38118860125541687,
0.5904408097267151,
0.08058589696884155,
-0.4874861538410187,
0.6443934440612793,
0.5628625750541687,
0.14417101442813873,
0.10475968569517136,
0.44534245133399963,
-0.07846058905124664,
0.2819209098815918,
0.1779654622077942,
-0.34934887290000916,
-0.3491005599498749,
-0.5852697491645813,
-0.730659544467926,
0.13163508474826813,
0.04649708792567253,
0.004135890398174524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15127v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15127v1
|
MedDr: Diagnosis-Guided Bootstrapping for Large-Scale Medical Vision-Language Learning
| 2024-04-23T15:27:19 | 2024-04-23T15:27:19 |
Sunan He, Yuxiang Nie, Zhixuan Chen, Zhiyuan Cai, Hongmei Wang, Shu Yang, Hao Chen
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
The rapid advancement of large-scale vision-language models has showcased
remarkable capabilities across various tasks. However, the lack of extensive
and high-quality image-text data in medicine has greatly hindered the
development of large-scale medical vision-language models. In this work, we
present a diagnosis-guided bootstrapping strategy that exploits both image and
label information to construct vision-language datasets. Based on the
constructed dataset, we developed MedDr, a generalist foundation model for
healthcare capable of handling diverse medical data modalities, including
radiology, pathology, dermatology, retinography, and endoscopy. Moreover,
during inference, we propose a simple but effective retrieval-augmented medical
diagnosis strategy, which enhances the model's generalization ability.
Extensive experiments on visual question answering, medical report generation,
and medical image diagnosis demonstrate the superiority of our method.
|
[
-0.14063377678394318,
-0.50126051902771,
0.6641517281532288,
-0.35390257835388184,
-0.4907892048358917,
-0.008867399767041206,
-0.24472102522850037,
-0.4681674540042877,
0.3067566454410553,
0.44557246565818787,
-0.4066375195980072,
-0.7978476285934448,
-0.6266567707061768,
-0.05832013487815857,
-0.4164932668209076,
1.101679801940918,
-0.09402768313884735,
0.3899981677532196,
-0.14106318354606628,
-0.16498565673828125,
-0.17565074563026428,
-0.23377615213394165,
-0.9474964737892151,
-0.1411006897687912,
0.5635446310043335,
0.31093233823776245,
0.6722168922424316,
0.8374367356300354,
0.9970983862876892,
0.19903568923473358,
0.15064138174057007,
0.22382360696792603,
-0.050514787435531616,
0.23265956342220306,
-0.14043377339839935,
-0.3823477029800415,
-0.30797630548477173,
-0.024332834407687187,
0.7113521099090576,
1.0036202669143677,
-0.2722513675689697,
0.05868874490261078,
-0.3481859266757965,
0.8430216312408447,
-0.6198758482933044,
0.12024693191051483,
-0.07785492390394211,
0.3156645894050598,
0.12825773656368256,
-0.26207560300827026,
-0.4531853497028351,
-0.14153209328651428,
0.1927289366722107,
-0.7721782922744751,
0.5327019095420837,
0.09934866428375244,
0.8291222453117371,
0.45076093077659607,
-0.2815436124801636,
-0.2008691132068634,
-0.5419856309890747,
0.6373276114463806,
-0.04659120738506317,
0.456929087638855,
0.5702594518661499,
0.7498524188995361,
0.1746714562177658,
-0.9358399510383606,
-0.11135008186101913,
-0.05783901736140251,
-0.09382470697164536,
0.050421204417943954,
-0.1312374323606491,
0.0611085407435894,
0.014427661895751953,
0.4562542140483856,
-0.7977396845817566,
0.21170572936534882,
-0.5524604320526123,
-0.20203125476837158,
0.11674626916646957,
0.14770056307315826,
0.3619470000267029,
0.06627461314201355,
-0.6107784509658813,
-0.22478164732456207,
-0.7800890207290649,
-0.2532026767730713,
-0.5433717370033264,
0.06179576739668846,
-0.29287904500961304,
0.3675442039966583,
-0.19094756245613098,
1.2052005529403687,
-0.08473992347717285,
-0.4964492619037628,
0.4215315878391266,
-0.26471900939941406,
-0.6451693177223206,
-0.20058928430080414,
0.44407007098197937,
0.7033326029777527,
0.1920464038848877,
-0.2608600854873657,
-0.5151865482330322,
0.30387070775032043,
-0.01397892739623785,
-0.7787690758705139,
-0.5174288153648376,
0.1410081535577774,
-0.8585080504417419,
-0.6676185727119446,
-0.4021674394607544,
-0.8729936480522156,
-0.694158136844635,
-0.30349451303482056,
0.4256872832775116,
-0.3229122459888458,
-0.15410496294498444,
0.21105796098709106,
-0.05195526033639908,
0.03802181035280228,
0.3206036686897278,
-0.8968420028686523,
0.4382539391517639,
0.0934620276093483,
0.6913743019104004,
-0.09069615602493286,
0.1841808408498764,
-0.9233337044715881,
0.19823813438415527,
-0.7686511278152466,
0.6122628450393677,
-0.8950179219245911,
-0.16682060062885284,
0.003359686117619276,
0.12504667043685913,
-0.010098421946167946,
-1.052444338798523,
0.03802977874875069,
-0.4309206008911133,
0.3748146891593933,
-0.1634354293346405,
-0.19339804351329803,
-0.08419208973646164,
0.37357214093208313,
-0.4732828140258789,
0.34278133511543274,
0.5718973875045776,
-0.5516865849494934,
0.7326257824897766,
-0.5485776662826538,
-0.5439205169677734,
0.3589097559452057,
-0.867976188659668,
-0.4160096049308777,
0.02946949005126953,
0.2548444867134094,
0.8616271018981934,
-0.8336831331253052,
0.6149916052818298,
0.3263512849807739,
-0.10355547815561295,
-0.0996130034327507,
-0.22905418276786804,
0.3817952871322632,
0.1544533371925354,
-0.1053931936621666,
-0.09963694959878922,
-1.1490892171859741,
-0.06569495797157288,
0.21079100668430328,
-0.5325762629508972,
-0.4361654222011566,
0.0894237533211708,
0.28918078541755676,
0.17915119230747223,
-0.1670021414756775,
-0.6013848185539246,
0.26500073075294495,
-0.22073040902614594,
0.1364358365535736,
0.46318209171295166,
0.03873463720083237,
0.2052823007106781,
-0.369743674993515,
0.715766429901123,
0.5653151869773865,
0.24140562117099762,
-0.40225258469581604,
-0.595533549785614,
-0.7316970825195312,
-0.7735152840614319,
0.5051458477973938,
0.5251778960227966,
-0.979407787322998,
0.04323798790574074,
-0.11477608233690262,
-0.04606246575713158,
-0.8357102274894714,
-0.1386704295873642,
0.6795477271080017,
1.0314501523971558,
0.7194765210151672,
-0.46121570467948914,
-0.2732926309108734,
-1.2159137725830078,
0.19427335262298584,
0.10331684350967407,
-0.21397660672664642,
0.23627682030200958,
0.3200094401836395,
-0.6253603100776672,
0.5984064340591431,
-0.7688066363334656,
-0.7018464207649231,
-0.22206838428974152,
-0.0876402035355568,
0.12605206668376923,
0.6651778817176819,
0.7990236878395081,
-1.0253410339355469,
-0.16422368586063385,
0.20092453062534332,
-0.6193007826805115,
0.09265520423650742,
-0.1382552683353424,
0.17291796207427979,
0.005734637379646301,
0.5358594059944153,
-0.3290896415710449,
0.5998067855834961,
0.5421654582023621,
-0.6315216422080994,
0.4625905454158783,
-0.41093316674232483,
0.2652612626552582,
-1.2621268033981323,
0.20491409301757812,
0.3248634338378906,
-0.471139132976532,
-0.519416868686676,
0.11982250958681107,
0.20417290925979614,
-0.06859111785888672,
0.11831795424222946,
0.3634664714336395,
-0.3867330253124237,
0.07020702213048935,
0.17773394286632538,
-0.1431264728307724,
-0.0006050048395991325,
-0.017622193321585655,
0.17586863040924072,
0.3411186635494232,
1.0139859914779663,
-0.7335208058357239,
0.4477040469646454,
0.03154337406158447,
-0.622182309627533,
0.7177239656448364,
-0.44158464670181274,
-0.4539235830307007,
-0.40057820081710815,
0.007855931296944618,
-1.0243009328842163,
-0.5108006000518799,
0.3491222560405731,
-0.2593071162700653,
0.7273344993591309,
-0.32572245597839355,
-0.5575658082962036,
-0.19517876207828522,
0.2092640995979309,
0.690495491027832,
0.7484668493270874,
-0.7421625256538391,
0.47645723819732666,
0.19506807625293732,
-0.16553223133087158,
-0.5201205015182495,
-0.8294898271560669,
-0.06369497627019882,
0.05869670584797859,
-0.29250115156173706,
0.3750641644001007,
0.10866934806108475,
-0.37961870431900024,
-0.14964821934700012,
0.007805888075381517,
-0.33156558871269226,
-0.1640683114528656,
0.026930559426546097,
0.5865784287452698,
-0.38477495312690735,
0.5188747048377991,
-0.015865137800574303,
-0.3347903788089752,
-0.05131324753165245,
-0.15856970846652985,
0.45069316029548645,
0.18504402041435242,
-0.43321675062179565,
-0.13120849430561066,
0.35348081588745117,
0.7341415286064148,
-0.3414217233657837,
0.5578923225402832,
0.29408857226371765,
-0.48325657844543457,
-0.2369639128446579,
-0.5956202745437622,
-0.23885849118232727,
-0.4122558832168579,
0.4136427938938141,
-0.027534274384379387,
-0.4366353750228882,
0.2661159336566925,
-0.376260370016098,
-0.10388042777776718,
0.31548991799354553,
0.35527297854423523,
-0.11565291881561279,
0.9085659980773926,
0.8927834630012512,
0.1027137041091919,
0.026795608922839165,
-0.40395987033843994,
0.1014300212264061,
-0.6054115891456604,
-0.5821412205696106,
-0.21994338929653168,
-0.24844756722450256,
-0.2214931696653366,
-0.7926348447799683,
0.6007540822029114,
-0.5225802659988403,
-0.09613014757633209,
-0.25505155324935913,
-0.7318926453590393,
0.5359034538269043,
0.22491824626922607,
0.4662289321422577,
0.4346100091934204,
0.4119566082954407,
-0.5966730117797852,
-0.14752350747585297,
-0.5800564289093018,
0.0314967967569828,
1.1261875629425049,
0.26122331619262695,
0.850210428237915,
-0.13671530783176422,
0.5318150520324707,
0.22487100958824158,
0.4361931085586548,
-0.7753624320030212,
0.2780587077140808,
-0.43695876002311707,
-0.3955956995487213,
0.29174456000328064,
-0.5187094807624817,
-0.6980204582214355,
0.3105694353580475,
-0.10779853165149689,
-0.4743873178958893,
0.4633595049381256,
0.285108745098114,
-0.3376811146736145,
0.3466843068599701,
-0.737785279750824,
0.7622499465942383,
-0.0850272998213768,
0.14268715679645538,
-0.21824412047863007,
-0.9722903370857239,
0.414186030626297,
-0.2595546543598175,
0.565493643283844,
0.34756404161453247,
-0.2417374849319458,
1.0082368850708008,
-0.15226344764232635,
0.8444030284881592,
-0.3110632002353668,
0.12414317578077316,
-0.43685945868492126,
0.05822833627462387,
0.0014434232143685222,
-0.29337844252586365,
0.5640000700950623,
-0.4687996208667755,
0.04846593737602234,
-0.22306956350803375,
-0.5526602268218994,
0.3101758360862732,
-0.36045652627944946,
-0.10051603615283966,
-0.3330078423023224,
-0.4250990152359009,
-0.5724129676818848,
0.1625264286994934,
0.38487935066223145,
0.969839870929718,
0.05917919799685478,
0.22642342746257782,
0.8606473803520203,
-0.5397621393203735,
0.12587733566761017,
0.8554375767707825,
-0.5202024579048157,
-0.33594441413879395,
0.9717929363250732,
-0.02906147949397564,
0.5090738534927368,
0.36600857973098755,
0.21158626675605774,
0.10184520483016968,
-0.3525445759296417,
-0.48035264015197754,
0.38131216168403625,
-0.8602066040039062,
-0.46995916962623596,
-0.303173303604126,
-0.1372661590576172,
0.0014191264053806663,
-0.3657240569591522,
-0.3752978444099426,
-0.33074474334716797,
-0.034598030149936676,
0.06757821887731552,
0.36662477254867554,
0.7840644717216492,
-0.09733515232801437,
0.026410002261400223,
-0.2963453233242035,
0.9480991363525391,
-0.0027029383927583694,
0.6480262875556946,
-0.1781134307384491,
-0.3577718734741211,
-0.23383554816246033,
-0.18113934993743896,
0.1852465122938156,
-0.7290089726448059,
0.342227965593338,
0.29669952392578125,
0.2656312584877014,
0.9561136364936829,
-0.06080224737524986,
0.567876935005188,
-0.5362607836723328,
0.4057650864124298,
0.8202657699584961,
-0.24297863245010376,
0.8444931507110596,
0.05446135252714157,
0.04237479344010353,
0.2708325982093811,
0.4050643742084503,
-0.6172229051589966,
-0.26012417674064636,
-0.4950476884841919,
-0.6950152516365051,
0.18678879737854004,
-0.3909302055835724,
-0.5224950313568115,
-0.08274748921394348,
0.25104811787605286,
0.03835955634713173,
0.04151525720953941,
-0.3373570144176483,
-0.4756026268005371,
0.2238011360168457,
-0.48529940843582153,
-0.30188819766044617,
-0.17484797537326813,
-0.5794170498847961,
-0.7556606531143188,
0.1875516176223755,
-0.19032226502895355,
0.15027980506420135,
0.4787362813949585,
-0.14996778964996338,
-0.08169122040271759,
0.2672137916088104,
0.41124427318573,
0.7727998495101929,
0.045411743223667145,
0.24150004982948303,
-0.5660147070884705,
-0.8725229501724243,
0.22456510365009308,
0.1972542703151703,
-0.12816140055656433,
0.24212276935577393,
0.09139124304056168,
0.4253460764884949,
0.3108631372451782,
-0.9936169981956482,
0.8171108961105347,
-0.09388525784015656,
-0.49279725551605225,
0.145803302526474,
-0.1348170042037964,
-0.1808619350194931,
0.22998937964439392,
0.6361465454101562,
0.584944486618042,
0.10287117958068848,
-0.28722870349884033,
0.4083746671676636,
0.37791702151298523,
-0.27568748593330383,
0.025101954117417336,
0.6746584177017212,
-0.024573873728513718,
0.014215280301868916,
0.7844270467758179,
0.14772726595401764,
-0.1745559424161911,
0.7323628067970276,
0.6738229393959045,
0.4164481461048126,
-0.11983217298984528,
0.46776360273361206,
0.03917276859283447,
0.4347538352012634,
-0.048053763806819916,
0.31505316495895386,
-0.04949337989091873,
-0.5673019289970398,
-0.44197553396224976,
-0.5853769779205322,
-0.12138843536376953,
0.37534192204475403,
-0.8531630039215088,
0.07325303554534912,
-0.6523456573486328,
-0.001171525800600648,
0.25459086894989014,
-0.3392374813556671,
-0.7350350022315979,
0.9134301543235779,
0.04813763126730919,
1.0059961080551147,
-0.8334907293319702,
0.7008020877838135,
0.6185002326965332,
-0.42092448472976685,
-0.4943160116672516,
-0.057860732078552246,
-0.084244504570961,
-1.1994086503982544,
0.8133798837661743,
0.15559479594230652,
0.06258582323789597,
0.047996390610933304,
-0.853679895401001,
-0.498812198638916,
0.9417795538902283,
0.4178207814693451,
-0.5384925603866577,
-0.1864212304353714,
-0.20609045028686523,
0.4422091841697693,
-0.6283734440803528,
-0.36432722210884094,
0.6177228689193726,
0.1444467008113861,
0.33023786544799805,
-0.9373531341552734,
0.21722541749477386,
-0.2391524314880371,
-0.18291588127613068,
0.15835295617580414,
0.040374938398599625,
0.7074710130691528,
-0.8299319744110107,
-0.13949944078922272,
-0.06045708432793617,
-0.037752460688352585,
-0.06324290484189987,
0.14115118980407715,
0.2808990776538849,
0.7712693810462952,
0.7537869811058044,
-0.06790515780448914,
1.244632363319397,
-0.3579302430152893,
0.20133885741233826,
0.5019782185554504,
0.1883087158203125,
0.7906407117843628,
0.5585090517997742,
0.0028163865208625793,
0.3677354156970978,
0.6473550200462341,
-0.17882874608039856,
0.8137590289115906,
0.15595406293869019,
-0.4706403911113739,
-0.3846200108528137,
0.0030620370525866747,
-0.718226969242096,
0.251432329416275,
0.6233382225036621,
-1.2249858379364014,
-0.41587600111961365,
0.22934171557426453,
-0.1829862892627716,
-0.24265410006046295,
-0.40321803092956543,
0.7679685354232788,
-0.21010318398475647,
-0.3834119439125061,
0.9129109382629395,
-0.11253533512353897,
0.43938684463500977,
-0.45114871859550476,
-0.32552722096443176,
-0.048319004476070404,
0.323756605386734,
-0.18645545840263367,
-0.4543306231498718,
-0.02268107980489731,
-0.1045258566737175,
-0.42792558670043945,
-0.07271230965852737,
0.5268815159797668,
-0.6333906650543213,
-0.7376644611358643,
0.10924755781888962,
0.4960905909538269,
0.35157808661460876,
0.26201292872428894,
-0.35749199986457825,
-0.057185593992471695,
-0.01860186643898487,
0.05137643590569496,
0.506911039352417,
0.08614621311426163,
0.26106685400009155,
0.9186203479766846,
0.34007084369659424,
0.42296603322029114,
-0.3177180290222168,
0.16840268671512604,
1.059675931930542,
-0.3494296073913574,
-0.3557540476322174,
-0.5811839699745178,
0.351345032453537,
0.038480594754219055,
-0.18609902262687683,
-0.1416052132844925,
0.7169008255004883,
0.5250237584114075,
-0.32161474227905273,
0.8615878224372864,
-0.012649603188037872,
0.6160126328468323,
-0.6542624831199646,
0.8626121878623962,
-0.8274354338645935,
0.06380458921194077,
-0.23600365221500397,
-0.22918793559074402,
-0.758813738822937,
0.9558960795402527,
-0.14305181801319122,
-0.0034343129955232143,
0.7937983870506287,
0.721025288105011,
-0.26075321435928345,
-0.46410253643989563,
0.5945926308631897,
0.23434950411319733,
0.11748680472373962,
0.6265382766723633,
0.31123465299606323,
-0.27729377150535583,
0.235659658908844,
-0.09595005959272385,
-0.718550443649292,
-0.2053227722644806,
-0.40927886962890625,
-0.7429356575012207,
-0.8073471188545227,
-0.4095897376537323,
-0.37263745069503784,
0.09543012082576752,
0.7289946675300598,
0.8438249826431274,
-0.5142195820808411,
0.30487382411956787,
0.0798003301024437,
-0.12491822987794876,
-0.23901347815990448,
-0.15731194615364075,
0.38226860761642456,
-0.4087555706501007,
-0.16887624561786652,
0.38969892263412476,
0.47734278440475464,
0.17018479108810425,
-0.2751564681529999,
0.23495842516422272,
0.15101124346256256,
-0.5785754919052124,
0.6260769963264465,
0.3251519501209259,
-0.6661450862884521,
0.18389616906642914,
-0.273339182138443,
-0.08619724214076996,
0.2197086066007614,
0.8144346475601196,
-1.090871810913086,
0.776594340801239,
-0.18846766650676727,
0.6873200535774231,
0.1492854654788971,
-0.07295533269643784,
0.6739656925201416,
-0.5747038722038269,
0.19947870075702667,
0.357576459646225,
0.3745819628238678,
0.5090326070785522,
-0.2753043472766876,
0.528933048248291,
0.4873088002204895,
-0.28573399782180786,
-0.7564592957496643,
0.27388519048690796,
-0.7096747159957886,
-0.3193396329879761,
1.0580872297286987,
-0.01868651993572712,
0.014777039177715778,
-0.13596005737781525,
-0.2043115794658661,
-0.15444007515907288,
0.11612027883529663,
0.6277723908424377,
0.11161518841981888,
-0.027341682463884354,
-0.31743425130844116,
-0.5853577256202698,
0.7202655076980591,
0.13497593998908997,
-0.5828694105148315,
-0.14096996188163757,
0.7302582859992981,
0.7621325254440308,
0.10732130706310272,
0.770703136920929,
-0.2584705054759979,
0.6455820202827454,
-0.08163078874349594,
-0.07641082257032394,
0.13762062788009644,
-0.6721403002738953,
-0.14416439831256866,
0.2344086915254593,
-0.042177923023700714,
-0.7097955942153931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15104v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15104v2
|
Identifying Fairness Issues in Automatically Generated Testing Content
| 2024-04-23T14:56:15 | 2024-05-01T19:45:14 |
Kevin Stowe, Benny Longwill, Alyssa Francis, Tatsuya Aoyama, Debanjan Ghosh, Swapna Somasundaran
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Natural language generation tools are powerful and effective for generating
content. However, language models are known to display bias and fairness
issues, making them impractical to deploy for many use cases. We here focus on
how fairness issues impact automatically generated test content, which can have
stringent requirements to ensure the test measures only what it was intended to
measure. Specifically, we review test content generated for a large-scale
standardized English proficiency test with the goal of identifying content that
only pertains to a certain subset of the test population as well as content
that has the potential to be upsetting or distracting to some test takers.
Issues like these could inadvertently impact a test taker's score and thus
should be avoided. This kind of content does not reflect the more
commonly-acknowledged biases, making it challenging even for modern models that
contain safeguards. We build a dataset of 601 generated texts annotated for
fairness and explore a variety of methods for classification: fine-tuning,
topic-based classification, and prompting, including few-shot and
self-correcting prompts. We find that combining prompt self-correction and
few-shot learning performs best, yielding an F1 score of 0.79 on our held-out
test set, while much smaller BERT- and topic-based models have competitive
performance on out-of-domain data.
|
[
-0.42883190512657166,
-0.819539487361908,
0.35436686873435974,
0.31207114458084106,
0.18260303139686584,
-0.2424803078174591,
-0.22364452481269836,
-0.6266003251075745,
-0.4087045192718506,
0.5561601519584656,
-0.29269808530807495,
-0.3414342999458313,
-0.7597559690475464,
0.42800477147102356,
-0.5051812529563904,
1.344796061515808,
0.013698728755116463,
-0.08844277262687683,
-0.3395773768424988,
-0.268964946269989,
-0.802070140838623,
-0.36933156847953796,
-0.7409846782684326,
-0.19016341865062714,
0.33717626333236694,
0.5985761284828186,
0.693691074848175,
0.6400620341300964,
0.5905212163925171,
0.2999592125415802,
-0.002756500383839011,
-0.027610715478658676,
-0.40912094712257385,
0.1362949013710022,
-0.2678975760936737,
-0.3933555781841278,
-0.35610631108283997,
0.23226414620876312,
0.72428297996521,
0.6652006506919861,
0.20988842844963074,
0.3488418757915497,
0.24339178204536438,
0.39861494302749634,
-0.6018572449684143,
-0.026335176080465317,
-0.5657221674919128,
0.34158456325531006,
-0.5734578371047974,
-0.07885673642158508,
-0.5045782327651978,
-0.45567747950553894,
-0.06908167153596878,
-0.48531606793403625,
0.5329537987709045,
0.20225386321544647,
0.9947399497032166,
0.29485780000686646,
-0.6487021446228027,
-0.5715293288230896,
-0.36921119689941406,
1.029491662979126,
-0.5406050682067871,
0.11672210693359375,
0.4114855229854584,
0.4583052098751068,
-0.1757107526063919,
-0.2979278266429901,
-0.8272034525871277,
-0.10784163326025009,
-0.0746714174747467,
0.17033158242702484,
-0.05923505127429962,
0.02340656891465187,
0.5441827774047852,
0.40717390179634094,
-0.7364313006401062,
0.3314944803714752,
-0.3200331926345825,
-0.3836580216884613,
1.032871127128601,
0.2991236448287964,
0.4304848313331604,
-0.6242927312850952,
0.0836390033364296,
-0.12801453471183777,
-0.5256580710411072,
0.3655489683151245,
0.9022024869918823,
0.18902967870235443,
-0.030148306861519814,
0.7162080407142639,
0.0020643488969653845,
0.5141161680221558,
0.07575845718383789,
-0.10245302319526672,
0.3302852511405945,
-0.12180233746767044,
0.005381276365369558,
-0.03731084242463112,
0.6523284912109375,
0.39681753516197205,
0.6438448429107666,
0.077016182243824,
-0.597922146320343,
-0.10893680155277252,
0.17812901735305786,
-0.6168172359466553,
-0.09934788942337036,
0.14281144738197327,
-0.36348849534988403,
-0.2978282570838928,
0.19464446604251862,
-0.7972567677497864,
-0.3837231695652008,
-0.25911274552345276,
0.490770548582077,
-0.1580641269683838,
-0.13569507002830505,
-0.1553242951631546,
-0.20358306169509888,
0.15437842905521393,
0.17385554313659668,
-0.855559766292572,
0.31116849184036255,
0.6228823661804199,
0.4338843822479248,
-0.4275737702846527,
-0.21091239154338837,
-0.829872190952301,
-0.11022616922855377,
-0.26406198740005493,
0.6747986078262329,
-0.3096500635147095,
-0.32424187660217285,
0.11547043919563293,
0.193832129240036,
0.18369120359420776,
-0.5975441336631775,
0.3593384623527527,
-0.43738576769828796,
0.6013268232345581,
-0.4209531247615814,
-0.8258830308914185,
0.1762116700410843,
0.3001825511455536,
-0.7506573796272278,
0.8130298852920532,
-0.008692984469234943,
-0.8779240846633911,
0.768109142780304,
-0.7103059887886047,
-0.6990481615066528,
0.05555720999836922,
-0.4057503938674927,
-0.5224857926368713,
-0.07285787910223007,
-0.1079426035284996,
0.20143213868141174,
0.10461347550153732,
0.4333098232746124,
-0.06535875052213669,
-0.44580814242362976,
0.37873533368110657,
-0.6778162121772766,
0.6100748777389526,
0.24662187695503235,
-0.7857431769371033,
-0.32135504484176636,
-0.5958802103996277,
-0.08000032603740692,
0.1996804028749466,
-0.16761688888072968,
-0.030799439176917076,
-0.08559300005435944,
0.15170162916183472,
0.24358168244361877,
-0.03160558640956879,
-0.5359899401664734,
-0.3784506618976593,
-0.4359660744667053,
-0.19279590249061584,
1.1555533409118652,
-0.12855881452560425,
0.6122862100601196,
-0.5634663701057434,
0.5439624190330505,
0.08602980524301529,
0.34896689653396606,
0.03474440798163414,
-0.8164480328559875,
-0.6187846660614014,
-0.07024776935577393,
0.6025096774101257,
0.4802769422531128,
-0.2579527497291565,
0.5503184795379639,
-0.02395760826766491,
-0.14547546207904816,
-0.6969172358512878,
0.2812475562095642,
0.3479325771331787,
0.6317751407623291,
0.18426282703876495,
-0.42156246304512024,
-0.020733727142214775,
-0.8337262868881226,
-0.3764057457447052,
0.013564149849116802,
-0.004645727574825287,
0.35439276695251465,
0.5468089580535889,
0.1426520049571991,
1.1655386686325073,
-0.493097186088562,
-0.44613370299339294,
-0.06704213470220566,
0.3067834973335266,
-0.17940089106559753,
0.6077961921691895,
0.6321789026260376,
-0.7466304302215576,
-0.5829581022262573,
-0.3360540568828583,
-0.786185085773468,
-0.5458434820175171,
0.042827267199754715,
-0.003873266978189349,
0.430315226316452,
0.2054964005947113,
-0.13482369482517242,
0.5424155592918396,
0.3403397798538208,
-0.5025848150253296,
0.4149855077266693,
-0.003629593877121806,
0.4645845592021942,
-0.4742332100868225,
-0.011948633007705212,
-0.005291013978421688,
-0.30971187353134155,
-0.0919036716222763,
0.014329962432384491,
0.06170084699988365,
-0.00003975925574195571,
-0.5315253734588623,
0.971886932849884,
0.003956045489758253,
0.02197244204580784,
-0.26980915665626526,
0.13264049589633942,
0.37898528575897217,
-0.05936096981167793,
-0.17569153010845184,
0.7223078012466431,
0.15516328811645508,
-0.5338393449783325,
-0.07163310796022415,
0.12036687135696411,
0.0790022686123848,
0.7825348377227783,
-0.40661171078681946,
0.10677877068519592,
-0.423155277967453,
0.07226282358169556,
-0.8132092356681824,
-0.28052759170532227,
0.058017272502183914,
-0.6313154697418213,
0.02218104712665081,
0.12538307905197144,
-0.6238025426864624,
-0.2270747572183609,
-0.26947149634361267,
0.46357712149620056,
0.7729344964027405,
-0.4616587162017822,
0.16629593074321747,
0.5010313987731934,
-0.20655706524848938,
-0.6459962129592896,
-0.671931266784668,
-0.24260792136192322,
-0.25346481800079346,
-0.6992753148078918,
0.22433048486709595,
-0.3220216929912567,
-0.4745754599571228,
-0.001297365641221404,
0.14299045503139496,
-0.23451349139213562,
0.1943979263305664,
0.36188867688179016,
-0.2599567770957947,
-0.02928067557513714,
0.417579710483551,
0.23624823987483978,
0.041923604905605316,
0.23588962852954865,
0.19054940342903137,
0.14420832693576813,
0.02957841195166111,
-0.5345213413238525,
-0.24903520941734314,
0.6943395733833313,
0.13884134590625763,
-0.14406386017799377,
0.47328630089759827,
0.8126797080039978,
-0.50235915184021,
-0.549045741558075,
-0.6944527626037598,
-0.2490939348936081,
-0.5059970021247864,
0.1722356677055359,
-0.11867420375347137,
-0.779536783695221,
0.6598907709121704,
0.6372075080871582,
0.381538987159729,
0.6289793848991394,
0.22128619253635406,
-0.3202877938747406,
1.423670768737793,
0.5951635241508484,
0.25513404607772827,
0.2795635461807251,
0.08955767750740051,
0.2911970913410187,
-0.16056402027606964,
-0.23324233293533325,
-0.7268131971359253,
-0.1690966635942459,
-0.8363222479820251,
0.04378122091293335,
0.13764847815036774,
-0.3560371696949005,
-0.18597765266895294,
-0.25284677743911743,
-0.531844973564148,
0.6971292495727539,
0.5949546694755554,
-0.11567382514476776,
0.5317541360855103,
-0.22768153250217438,
-0.08874208480119705,
-0.5530129671096802,
-0.43851184844970703,
-0.7427573204040527,
1.2634236812591553,
0.3932192325592041,
0.49609071016311646,
0.06690109521150589,
0.7956082224845886,
0.7726625800132751,
0.532615065574646,
-0.5013648271560669,
0.4156915545463562,
-0.3921165466308594,
-0.8542667031288147,
-0.25587034225463867,
-0.7366734743118286,
-1.0282961130142212,
-0.17159229516983032,
-0.2034604400396347,
0.0051633515395224094,
-0.20373651385307312,
0.17175842821598053,
-0.3027629852294922,
0.08470167219638824,
-1.0419317483901978,
1.014498233795166,
-0.2569151818752289,
-0.35051658749580383,
0.10927949845790863,
-0.3494075536727905,
0.45651814341545105,
-0.31730398535728455,
0.5712470412254333,
-0.2837255001068115,
0.3701231777667999,
0.7954817414283752,
-0.22166217863559723,
0.5870300531387329,
-0.22706374526023865,
-0.18235686421394348,
0.44749218225479126,
0.21134161949157715,
0.08271631598472595,
0.31422919034957886,
-0.204788476228714,
-0.016803620383143425,
-0.13664305210113525,
-0.7172685265541077,
-0.5038596987724304,
0.534723162651062,
-0.7065685987472534,
-0.6001659631729126,
-0.5903304219245911,
-0.45232123136520386,
-0.05903327837586403,
0.15427395701408386,
0.39442750811576843,
0.3340494632720947,
-0.18083758652210236,
-0.2614552974700928,
0.7432782649993896,
-0.5085138082504272,
0.43250158429145813,
0.6113476753234863,
0.019416073337197304,
0.06863288581371307,
1.0894827842712402,
0.32736775279045105,
0.3068482279777527,
-0.31995290517807007,
0.1501302719116211,
-0.4116409122943878,
-0.5593663454055786,
-0.2911626100540161,
-0.009495683014392853,
-0.9448875188827515,
-0.2652137577533722,
-0.5403150320053101,
-0.3401029109954834,
-0.6039133071899414,
-0.24119091033935547,
-0.2804640233516693,
-0.091801717877388,
-0.274625688791275,
-0.12935511767864227,
0.14710335433483124,
1.0466426610946655,
-0.2360447496175766,
0.13018736243247986,
-0.6150069832801819,
0.3426099121570587,
0.5107406973838806,
0.3714941740036011,
-0.16570691764354706,
-0.8028279542922974,
0.14825457334518433,
-0.14855577051639557,
-0.5448965430259705,
-0.5725318193435669,
0.1582484096288681,
0.1063065156340599,
0.4685021936893463,
0.17751921713352203,
0.22383366525173187,
0.3526124358177185,
-0.5729904174804688,
0.9157739877700806,
-0.04295291006565094,
-1.0503695011138916,
0.6417913436889648,
-0.07373237609863281,
0.20927003026008606,
0.8128199577331543,
0.16563932597637177,
-0.32427090406417847,
-0.967674195766449,
-0.730745255947113,
-0.6858251094818115,
0.3865656852722168,
0.3679543435573578,
0.42039480805397034,
-0.4778832495212555,
0.17484469711780548,
0.43876639008522034,
0.20286792516708374,
-1.0411126613616943,
-0.04025924950838089,
-0.22790446877479553,
-0.7614526152610779,
0.2820925712585449,
0.15594319999217987,
0.07864943146705627,
-0.13921208679676056,
0.324817419052124,
-0.1781410425901413,
-0.16489443182945251,
0.2505303621292114,
-0.38800713419914246,
-0.18235701322555542,
0.3219880163669586,
0.4413134753704071,
0.48566827178001404,
-0.06909413635730743,
0.1251032054424286,
0.029544170945882797,
-0.5272459387779236,
0.17262877523899078,
0.09882822632789612,
-0.4059913456439972,
0.10219094157218933,
0.18705317378044128,
0.20117425918579102,
-0.04155890271067619,
-0.9511622190475464,
1.0461395978927612,
-0.18785187602043152,
-0.13654831051826477,
-0.33602839708328247,
0.23411941528320312,
-0.560544490814209,
-0.004660237580537796,
0.2746550738811493,
-0.14333908259868622,
0.2454785853624344,
-0.224629744887352,
0.5774327516555786,
0.30786141753196716,
-0.41077834367752075,
-0.24023862183094025,
0.6166667938232422,
0.5859906077384949,
-0.33169323205947876,
0.6618295311927795,
-0.8864126801490784,
-0.35448771715164185,
0.805442750453949,
0.3834771513938904,
0.46981877088546753,
-0.09762514382600784,
0.37095680832862854,
0.2893354296684265,
0.4516046345233917,
-0.0604868084192276,
0.18850821256637573,
0.34173744916915894,
-0.6293293237686157,
-0.2924315333366394,
-0.523757815361023,
-0.355230450630188,
-0.01566660962998867,
-0.40669500827789307,
0.3199760317802429,
-0.34504109621047974,
-0.3156997263431549,
-0.06060158088803291,
0.22623661160469055,
-1.0478487014770508,
0.5379248857498169,
0.3684358596801758,
0.6917170882225037,
-1.101784110069275,
0.12770472466945648,
0.44935858249664307,
-0.6462914943695068,
-0.6569416522979736,
0.025981368497014046,
0.11705005913972855,
-0.635983943939209,
0.616960346698761,
0.34954264760017395,
0.34957394003868103,
-0.05271894857287407,
-0.43868333101272583,
-0.28229111433029175,
0.6321664452552795,
0.42435383796691895,
-0.3001667857170105,
0.0822010263800621,
0.5669065117835999,
0.35934004187583923,
-0.1458674818277359,
0.498274564743042,
0.4537712335586548,
0.5303226113319397,
-0.3052370846271515,
-1.063541054725647,
0.05726829916238785,
-0.2056100070476532,
-0.31671035289764404,
-0.1809597760438919,
-0.4402659237384796,
0.7721578478813171,
-0.02202668972313404,
-0.23801887035369873,
-0.2995224595069885,
0.41172707080841064,
0.36544957756996155,
0.6635293364524841,
0.6649386882781982,
0.5166975259780884,
0.9636982679367065,
-0.16401459276676178,
0.9953559041023254,
0.3280762732028961,
0.22235943377017975,
0.9521002769470215,
-0.5395113825798035,
0.4081662893295288,
0.32510244846343994,
0.07101482152938843,
0.2727452218532562,
0.6836877465248108,
-0.014201590791344643,
0.2268095314502716,
0.507784903049469,
-0.12413147836923599,
-0.1340714693069458,
-0.4314643144607544,
-0.3453945517539978,
0.4876704216003418,
-0.15476344525814056,
-0.2765040695667267,
-0.21439433097839355,
0.14436084032058716,
0.07708609104156494,
0.4805477559566498,
-0.20079413056373596,
0.7030941843986511,
0.09720978140830994,
-0.7499616742134094,
-0.05538110435009003,
0.034175243228673935,
0.919977605342865,
-0.19466419517993927,
-0.1651422530412674,
-0.42847248911857605,
-0.09113290905952454,
-0.24894733726978302,
-1.1236474514007568,
0.32604196667671204,
0.34976187348365784,
-0.18210041522979736,
-0.23154927790164948,
0.557457447052002,
-0.3523117005825043,
-0.39685752987861633,
0.26425209641456604,
0.6093888878822327,
0.08944656699895859,
-0.1574518382549286,
-0.6226011514663696,
-0.04054858535528183,
-0.1805339902639389,
-0.13495776057243347,
0.32253196835517883,
0.6835705041885376,
-0.04125809669494629,
0.3453049957752228,
0.4151005446910858,
0.008146791718900204,
0.32217881083488464,
0.28185126185417175,
0.248502716422081,
-0.8455948829650879,
-0.6266467571258545,
-0.6090426445007324,
0.7683715224266052,
-0.36436834931373596,
-0.4972219169139862,
0.6939836740493774,
0.5486064553260803,
0.8778390288352966,
0.21841825544834137,
0.8150129914283752,
0.08544345945119858,
0.3415449559688568,
-0.35630422830581665,
0.9227902293205261,
-0.6103990077972412,
0.11019930243492126,
-0.30119049549102783,
-0.7107388377189636,
-0.21107567846775055,
0.33318740129470825,
-0.23289227485656738,
0.23043209314346313,
0.6664187908172607,
0.6104658842086792,
0.058294281363487244,
0.05922078713774681,
0.20402437448501587,
-0.1890234649181366,
0.42952606081962585,
0.4819621741771698,
0.9397986531257629,
-0.5668324828147888,
0.6387849450111389,
0.03297938406467438,
-0.19654536247253418,
0.003775677876546979,
-0.9026541113853455,
-0.8013553023338318,
-0.33605143427848816,
-0.513148844242096,
-0.385927677154541,
-0.002400149591267109,
0.6770049929618835,
0.5753851532936096,
-0.8824930191040039,
0.015741081908345222,
-0.0025095974560827017,
0.4934885501861572,
0.28026875853538513,
-0.39418527483940125,
-0.013280746527016163,
-0.6841612458229065,
-0.7308257222175598,
-0.22822792828083038,
-0.06490259617567062,
0.2124769687652588,
-0.15983451902866364,
-0.11444474756717682,
0.4364180862903595,
0.12639792263507843,
0.4174971282482147,
0.0817493349313736,
-0.39748144149780273,
-0.6644488573074341,
0.1887790709733963,
-0.38678935170173645,
0.021481100469827652,
0.4284801483154297,
-0.5865088105201721,
0.41251346468925476,
0.35593339800834656,
0.6813300251960754,
-0.0331936813890934,
-0.14683671295642853,
0.5964915752410889,
-1.0528359413146973,
-0.07552213966846466,
0.5545181632041931,
0.12412761151790619,
0.486393004655838,
-0.4487542510032654,
0.1873534470796585,
0.3257903754711151,
-0.6826340556144714,
-1.0325654745101929,
0.03650367259979248,
-0.5983214974403381,
-0.02486248128116131,
1.0949363708496094,
0.010644364170730114,
-0.13564352691173553,
-0.3316700756549835,
0.0798044428229332,
0.13595524430274963,
-0.33594176173210144,
1.0039502382278442,
0.8692870736122131,
0.06205105036497116,
0.06351888179779053,
-0.8549302816390991,
0.6985576748847961,
0.6690993309020996,
-1.0297330617904663,
-0.18663424253463745,
0.49676135182380676,
0.49626624584198,
-0.031765904277563095,
0.7152087092399597,
-0.3060067594051361,
0.5016100406646729,
-0.3817193806171417,
0.06832326948642731,
0.36266958713531494,
-0.2532813549041748,
-0.30472466349601746,
0.22005178034305573,
0.16175097227096558,
0.025897884741425514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15103v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15103v1
|
Multi-view Content-aware Indexing for Long Document Retrieval
| 2024-04-23T14:55:32 | 2024-04-23T14:55:32 |
Kuicai Dong, Derrick Goh Xin Deik, Yi Quan Lee, Hao Zhang, Xiangyang Li, Cong Zhang, Yong Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Long document question answering (DocQA) aims to answer questions from long
documents over 10k words. They usually contain content structures such as
sections, sub-sections, and paragraph demarcations. However, the indexing
methods of long documents remain under-explored, while existing systems
generally employ fixed-length chunking. As they do not consider content
structures, the resultant chunks can exclude vital information or include
irrelevant content. Motivated by this, we propose the Multi-view Content-aware
indexing (MC-indexing) for more effective long DocQA via (i) segment structured
document into content chunks, and (ii) represent each content chunk in
raw-text, keywords, and summary views. We highlight that MC-indexing requires
neither training nor fine-tuning. Having plug-and-play capability, it can be
seamlessly integrated with any retrievers to boost their performance. Besides,
we propose a long DocQA dataset that includes not only question-answer pair,
but also document structure and answer scope. When compared to state-of-art
chunking schemes, MC-indexing has significantly increased the recall by 42.8%,
30.0%, 23.9%, and 16.3% via top k= 1.5, 3, 5, and 10 respectively. These
improved scores are the average of 8 widely used retrievers (2 sparse and 6
dense) via extensive experiments.
|
[
-0.5078439116477966,
-0.6046948432922363,
0.8937132954597473,
0.32963356375694275,
-0.43846893310546875,
0.26307597756385803,
0.1668512523174286,
-0.32047292590141296,
0.6738767623901367,
0.4443720281124115,
-0.36989495158195496,
-0.312206506729126,
-0.6352759599685669,
0.1815989464521408,
-0.592771053314209,
0.6688621640205383,
-0.0473889522254467,
-0.2704342305660248,
-0.4451289474964142,
-0.004551220685243607,
-0.18842661380767822,
-0.3187258541584015,
-0.4687233865261078,
0.25884073972702026,
0.7932413220405579,
0.4546229839324951,
0.3099909722805023,
0.6383171677589417,
0.449083536863327,
0.3047638237476349,
-0.14095717668533325,
0.520015299320221,
-0.42170876264572144,
0.07036855071783066,
-0.09006230533123016,
-0.39070090651512146,
-0.4756612181663513,
0.09760300815105438,
0.8198128938674927,
0.46009525656700134,
-0.15970849990844727,
-0.11515095084905624,
0.0380740612745285,
1.1282025575637817,
-0.8608231544494629,
0.09272506088018417,
-0.5054754018783569,
-0.2216043472290039,
-0.38992568850517273,
-0.31058603525161743,
-0.11737273633480072,
-0.2687053978443146,
0.1021522581577301,
-0.8588067889213562,
0.19170081615447998,
0.11826863139867783,
0.4337517023086548,
0.008231605403125286,
-0.7000321745872498,
-0.3614575266838074,
-0.18081577122211456,
0.612311065196991,
-0.31186842918395996,
0.6427168846130371,
0.3294658958911896,
0.2637178897857666,
-0.053565721958875656,
-0.7700309157371521,
-0.6592022180557251,
0.23643027245998383,
-0.005149428732693195,
0.5972045660018921,
0.27189281582832336,
0.13650263845920563,
0.0663716197013855,
0.5678551197052002,
-0.5338451862335205,
-0.19947032630443573,
-0.4712418019771576,
-0.25224459171295166,
0.4973832070827484,
0.16219736635684967,
-0.1254522204399109,
-0.5175558924674988,
-0.2949165403842926,
-0.16850145161151886,
-0.3851175904273987,
0.14465560019016266,
0.36372771859169006,
-0.021877827122807503,
0.30928152799606323,
0.6289989352226257,
-0.5064617395401001,
0.3412292003631592,
0.2208898961544037,
-0.16785195469856262,
0.22169344127178192,
-0.4063594341278076,
-0.018302971497178078,
0.1151360496878624,
0.41257309913635254,
0.45480257272720337,
0.01848984882235527,
-0.11619078367948532,
-0.09214036166667938,
-0.36398351192474365,
0.5555367469787598,
-0.9182355999946594,
-0.015369374305009842,
0.5128597021102905,
-0.3322603702545166,
0.03300653398036957,
0.24389402568340302,
-0.8603471517562866,
-0.6083911061286926,
-0.035963110625743866,
0.43146535754203796,
-0.5397627353668213,
-0.10722831636667252,
0.1746593713760376,
-0.5897490382194519,
0.4462253153324127,
0.6593570709228516,
-0.713276743888855,
0.5128362774848938,
0.9565862417221069,
0.7355335354804993,
-0.293679803609848,
-0.40884503722190857,
-0.9441874623298645,
0.2687014937400818,
-0.39489585161209106,
0.9620268940925598,
-0.5753848552703857,
-0.6527230143547058,
-0.13929243385791779,
0.35770201683044434,
-0.2903106212615967,
-0.635473906993866,
0.723578691482544,
-0.6548587679862976,
0.24890440702438354,
-0.3958335816860199,
-0.5097827911376953,
-0.11034334450960159,
0.8225829601287842,
-0.835593044757843,
1.1915215253829956,
0.22584092617034912,
-0.9495993256568909,
0.1072075217962265,
-0.6359621286392212,
-0.39521631598472595,
-0.16295477747917175,
-0.06576846539974213,
-0.20926183462142944,
0.08660853654146194,
0.5349231362342834,
0.1793733388185501,
-0.05342848598957062,
0.07145965844392776,
-0.006333835888653994,
-0.47782737016677856,
-0.11572788655757904,
-0.43641185760498047,
-0.0554334856569767,
0.07963555306196213,
-0.06044849753379822,
0.010902040638029575,
-0.7643943428993225,
0.10209745913743973,
-0.08369634300470352,
-0.5757362246513367,
-0.6344730257987976,
0.09807509928941727,
-0.02005081996321678,
0.2949523627758026,
0.13937000930309296,
-0.7609033584594727,
0.1669919341802597,
-0.3611971437931061,
0.13851092755794525,
0.5154030323028564,
0.12138734012842178,
0.4770374894142151,
-0.453701913356781,
0.48484525084495544,
0.5158920884132385,
0.2469797134399414,
-0.44523972272872925,
-0.3125503659248352,
-0.5606946349143982,
-0.37740692496299744,
0.24496765434741974,
0.40129637718200684,
-0.7815654873847961,
-0.06124560534954071,
-0.40978190302848816,
-0.40782496333122253,
-0.7367421984672546,
0.14597268402576447,
0.32305285334587097,
0.6431384682655334,
0.555511474609375,
-0.7236320376396179,
-0.10840501636266708,
-0.9171636700630188,
-0.07874367386102676,
0.20560209453105927,
-0.14671951532363892,
0.5280963778495789,
0.549138069152832,
0.1617104560136795,
0.6313917636871338,
-0.7292581796646118,
-0.23501767218112946,
0.06982748955488205,
-0.059157922863960266,
0.213229700922966,
0.27904507517814636,
0.12416992336511612,
-1.2618869543075562,
-0.4676533639431,
-0.34377598762512207,
-0.19199922680854797,
0.4177486002445221,
0.058159954845905304,
-0.2826438844203949,
-0.0006165143568068743,
0.40488722920417786,
-0.537447452545166,
0.3480985164642334,
0.16983960568904877,
-0.05023286119103432,
0.5376378893852234,
-0.5140795707702637,
0.2938087582588196,
-1.3152748346328735,
0.15630970895290375,
-0.1427544504404068,
-0.26518410444259644,
-0.3776549696922302,
0.26102641224861145,
0.750813901424408,
-0.09707630425691605,
-0.6385411620140076,
0.6191438436508179,
-0.6961870789527893,
0.009389889426529408,
-0.26857614517211914,
0.4768960773944855,
0.6163144111633301,
0.3689236640930176,
0.2351381629705429,
0.8175826072692871,
0.13880831003189087,
-0.6546938419342041,
0.1023973822593689,
0.2128719538450241,
-0.46615856885910034,
0.873190701007843,
-0.5395857095718384,
0.2200535535812378,
-0.46536746621131897,
0.5018925666809082,
-0.8342041373252869,
-0.06854590773582458,
-0.13896702229976654,
-0.25875166058540344,
0.3946726322174072,
-0.21114946901798248,
-0.4094701409339905,
-0.3757174015045166,
-0.9099367260932922,
0.4471755921840668,
-0.20130117237567902,
-0.44676077365875244,
0.7036844491958618,
0.2375916689634323,
-0.23305441439151764,
-0.7852442860603333,
-0.06345885992050171,
0.03781028836965561,
-0.012567121535539627,
-0.6950857043266296,
0.579328715801239,
-0.37674057483673096,
0.28489676117897034,
-0.300174742937088,
-0.4313332438468933,
-0.2481679618358612,
0.1417018622159958,
0.2849229872226715,
-0.03041962906718254,
0.05450178310275078,
0.30967047810554504,
0.25634726881980896,
-0.04007750377058983,
-0.1499340683221817,
-0.25799742341041565,
0.5058460235595703,
0.01475545484572649,
-0.3879201412200928,
0.14150811731815338,
1.0469719171524048,
0.6764423251152039,
-0.8225005269050598,
0.5755808353424072,
0.5980876088142395,
-0.3010019361972809,
0.22327566146850586,
-0.806229293346405,
0.22524943947792053,
-0.44925206899642944,
0.48193493485450745,
-0.5517382025718689,
-0.8193306922912598,
0.46424221992492676,
-0.2268225997686386,
-0.09202438592910767,
0.6160525679588318,
0.22240476310253143,
-0.33350643515586853,
0.8722192645072937,
0.5919257998466492,
-0.17200572788715363,
0.31364575028419495,
-0.4511357247829437,
-0.04274199530482292,
-1.438977837562561,
-0.565787672996521,
-0.7006657123565674,
-0.2555408477783203,
-0.5526321530342102,
-0.6798310279846191,
0.64569491147995,
-0.12708985805511475,
-0.01947399228811264,
-0.1465359777212143,
-0.45352715253829956,
0.48854100704193115,
0.6766453981399536,
0.20053525269031525,
0.2596653997898102,
-0.39551252126693726,
-0.3317801356315613,
0.22292673587799072,
-0.36993077397346497,
0.021973606199026108,
0.9919184446334839,
0.023384205996990204,
0.8651734590530396,
0.08593987673521042,
0.8338389992713928,
-0.07146523892879486,
0.011465556919574738,
-0.9391533732414246,
0.26821261644363403,
-0.1895325630903244,
-0.647394061088562,
-0.3581082820892334,
-0.24000920355319977,
-0.9628705382347107,
0.3590521514415741,
-0.14196322858333588,
-0.4209490716457367,
0.3443754017353058,
-0.38497212529182434,
-0.2287333905696869,
0.054062340408563614,
-0.5888891816139221,
0.6539323329925537,
-0.23106491565704346,
-0.2529219686985016,
-0.2837553322315216,
-0.6701167225837708,
0.14677730202674866,
-0.373629629611969,
0.2890511453151703,
0.11678867787122726,
-0.22318920493125916,
0.8316343426704407,
-0.3506459593772888,
0.16770847141742706,
-0.09798071533441544,
-0.014164102263748646,
0.25073251128196716,
-0.1547655612230301,
0.44509512186050415,
0.30449777841567993,
-0.25922805070877075,
-0.45133715867996216,
0.5794160962104797,
-0.5791035890579224,
-0.6324772238731384,
0.7773792147636414,
-0.519428014755249,
-0.7758557200431824,
-0.6431914567947388,
-0.5372548699378967,
-0.16406002640724182,
0.6081887483596802,
-0.05408070608973503,
0.6660903096199036,
-0.24223209917545319,
0.3948405086994171,
0.9900100231170654,
-0.01768060401082039,
0.43971574306488037,
0.6234396696090698,
-0.022265836596488953,
-0.3755800724029541,
0.7103341817855835,
0.1892910748720169,
0.061980705708265305,
0.8457044363021851,
0.14233501255512238,
-0.5576440691947937,
-0.6354258060455322,
-0.44361406564712524,
0.24170266091823578,
-0.41589680314064026,
-0.05520489439368248,
-0.8909099698066711,
-0.2893141210079193,
-0.4193410873413086,
-0.00794207863509655,
-0.4304557144641876,
-0.34695565700531006,
-0.01415986567735672,
-0.0030857387464493513,
-0.1555473953485489,
0.25374823808670044,
0.3020187318325043,
-0.0029346253722906113,
-1.056209683418274,
0.6811849474906921,
0.5557236075401306,
0.8429027199745178,
0.01866113394498825,
-0.15358011424541473,
-0.4370255172252655,
-0.017197463661432266,
-0.4866734445095062,
-0.7407746315002441,
0.19615884125232697,
0.2756570279598236,
0.5865312814712524,
0.37345588207244873,
0.3040696084499359,
0.8624166250228882,
-0.5762936472892761,
0.6052451729774475,
-0.01999303139746189,
-0.5519917011260986,
0.385866641998291,
-0.12929858267307281,
0.6654832363128662,
0.8485876321792603,
0.6369590759277344,
-0.8620474934577942,
-0.28691956400871277,
-0.2869787812232971,
-0.880966067314148,
0.3977981507778168,
-0.08357610553503036,
0.22863273322582245,
-0.43936458230018616,
0.3380112946033478,
0.19985131919384003,
0.3170654773712158,
0.0020644241012632847,
0.04862544313073158,
-0.36326590180397034,
-0.1077815517783165,
-0.16530412435531616,
-0.3652576506137848,
-0.22999268770217896,
-0.06614786386489868,
0.4508317708969116,
-0.5019079446792603,
0.2341715693473816,
0.7662674784660339,
-0.26493433117866516,
0.2334393411874771,
0.5944169163703918,
0.37549424171447754,
0.7464404106140137,
-0.6760030388832092,
0.07635635137557983,
-0.2780359983444214,
-0.9638535380363464,
-0.1924799531698227,
0.42506393790245056,
0.1815623790025711,
-0.17145122587680817,
-0.11774121969938278,
0.20789571106433868,
0.10972103476524353,
-0.6535564064979553,
0.6663997769355774,
-0.4188111424446106,
-0.29698461294174194,
-0.33767974376678467,
-0.18284133076667786,
0.3665452003479004,
0.2636580169200897,
0.5702042579650879,
-0.42787304520606995,
0.43787670135498047,
-0.7298396229743958,
-0.029096735641360283,
0.5752679705619812,
-0.4312964975833893,
0.13739700615406036,
0.5189674496650696,
0.29132524132728577,
-0.016115622594952583,
0.8774390816688538,
0.10709161311388016,
-0.4781927764415741,
0.6908774375915527,
0.2718515396118164,
0.5086156725883484,
0.06938698142766953,
0.19173306226730347,
0.06463904678821564,
0.1952827423810959,
-0.06286907196044922,
0.4386673867702484,
-0.35800647735595703,
-0.3557479679584503,
-0.27398648858070374,
-0.7178406119346619,
-0.6538758277893066,
-0.1358955353498459,
-0.584250271320343,
-0.030263304710388184,
-0.06464388221502304,
0.14906485378742218,
0.17211765050888062,
0.6246465444564819,
-0.6109716296195984,
0.5824525952339172,
0.07643932849168777,
1.4557008743286133,
-0.2492435872554779,
0.8577337861061096,
0.48942089080810547,
-0.18877144157886505,
-0.6957681775093079,
-0.09921855479478836,
-0.09932562708854675,
-0.49564626812934875,
-0.15355314314365387,
0.4182825982570648,
0.0025266974698752165,
-0.08365990221500397,
-0.19368568062782288,
-0.8268802762031555,
1.4026321172714233,
-0.21765349805355072,
-0.2912205755710602,
-0.250744104385376,
-0.021053709089756012,
0.3627983033657074,
-0.18491438031196594,
0.6341767311096191,
0.2517959475517273,
0.42969468235969543,
0.2660558223724365,
-0.833815336227417,
-0.12713497877120972,
-0.3998640477657318,
-0.23394453525543213,
0.6345901489257812,
-0.958418071269989,
0.557985782623291,
0.027930470183491707,
-0.04003472253680229,
0.08325543254613876,
0.4292902648448944,
0.0749855488538742,
0.8160505890846252,
0.5370279550552368,
0.4644875228404999,
1.0002979040145874,
0.11996231228113174,
1.217160701751709,
-0.29947829246520996,
0.03267884999513626,
1.020673394203186,
-0.18559956550598145,
0.9506319165229797,
0.6222296357154846,
0.004556629806756973,
0.3992420434951782,
0.613399088382721,
0.42433738708496094,
0.5633252859115601,
0.1976926475763321,
-0.13667793571949005,
-0.20107829570770264,
-0.050870418548583984,
-0.45859044790267944,
0.5814468264579773,
0.3415345251560211,
-0.2361886352300644,
-0.1557619720697403,
-0.4351341724395752,
0.01243683509528637,
-0.022164272144436836,
-0.4176936447620392,
0.7175172567367554,
0.15208202600479126,
-0.7446238994598389,
0.20689904689788818,
0.12779520452022552,
0.6608548760414124,
-0.835996150970459,
0.06266063451766968,
-0.5629814267158508,
-0.15350289642810822,
-0.11212565004825592,
-0.8536664843559265,
0.15366190671920776,
-0.19027361273765564,
-0.4582359790802002,
-0.03626176714897156,
0.6649978756904602,
-0.41520845890045166,
-0.49648070335388184,
0.12461229413747787,
0.7636147737503052,
0.17771577835083008,
-0.705302894115448,
-0.38669976592063904,
-0.5621069073677063,
-0.38549119234085083,
-0.2669104337692261,
0.752700686454773,
0.3635610044002533,
-0.3488505482673645,
0.6168550252914429,
0.6191380620002747,
-0.1682365983724594,
0.15012159943580627,
-0.0858844444155693,
1.1927406787872314,
-0.7609586119651794,
-0.6765627861022949,
-0.31844353675842285,
0.3685179650783539,
-0.29169607162475586,
-0.11123442649841309,
0.39632612466812134,
1.1414183378219604,
0.6006612181663513,
0.25490766763687134,
0.43174853920936584,
0.11873257905244827,
0.5632961392402649,
-0.4245869517326355,
0.7209998965263367,
-0.9396845102310181,
-0.1396816521883011,
-0.3718840479850769,
-1.0506492853164673,
0.018797844648361206,
-0.1999441236257553,
-0.1330331563949585,
-0.23107272386550903,
0.9411474466323853,
0.7185533046722412,
-0.31702637672424316,
-0.1765412837266922,
0.2785124182701111,
0.019249366596341133,
0.36447277665138245,
0.6691128611564636,
0.45947861671447754,
-0.3946641683578491,
0.7880443334579468,
-0.3508537709712982,
-0.09005335718393326,
-0.0846514105796814,
-0.7387081384658813,
-0.3949536681175232,
-0.6754113435745239,
0.045692332088947296,
-0.16013473272323608,
0.10342393070459366,
0.25156518816947937,
0.5874692797660828,
-0.3590922951698303,
0.060305941849946976,
0.741322934627533,
0.30856993794441223,
-0.264767050743103,
-0.1520034372806549,
0.7260143160820007,
0.05096672102808952,
-0.7716708779335022,
0.539814829826355,
0.614649772644043,
-0.37885603308677673,
0.08120158314704895,
-0.04056365042924881,
-0.5032971501350403,
0.365913450717926,
0.6888434886932373,
0.18238843977451324,
-0.1377762258052826,
-0.4186588227748871,
0.37707430124282837,
-0.14329832792282104,
0.38318806886672974,
0.6309990882873535,
-0.8491111397743225,
0.7132420539855957,
0.41931280493736267,
0.6313313841819763,
0.9473008513450623,
0.41662508249282837,
0.0693431869149208,
-0.6589320302009583,
-0.13393327593803406,
0.1547187715768814,
0.23082894086837769,
0.2657500207424164,
-0.297404944896698,
0.40445831418037415,
0.039766889065504074,
-0.6157996654510498,
-0.28380417823791504,
-0.06357552856206894,
-1.369176983833313,
-0.06492719799280167,
0.7458592653274536,
-0.12962085008621216,
-0.49653375148773193,
-0.0661642774939537,
-0.36344531178474426,
0.1373303383588791,
-0.5017815232276917,
0.9241548776626587,
0.6708547472953796,
0.0002591515949461609,
-0.2804717421531677,
-0.4449518024921417,
0.1134176030755043,
0.20333388447761536,
-0.8613429665565491,
-0.3719061613082886,
0.5359843373298645,
0.5361565947532654,
0.23641744256019592,
0.8904115557670593,
-0.3356216549873352,
0.44677793979644775,
-0.12518766522407532,
-0.442460298538208,
-0.3684079051017761,
-0.37836065888404846,
-0.06999017298221588,
0.4642585515975952,
-0.09875035285949707,
-0.3473910391330719
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00706v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00706v2
|
From Complexity to Clarity: How AI Enhances Perceptions of Scientists and the Public's Understanding of Science
| 2024-04-23T14:43:35 | 2024-06-11T12:35:51 |
David M. Markowitz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
This paper evaluated the effectiveness of using generative AI to simplify
science communication and enhance the public's understanding of science. By
comparing lay summaries of journal articles from PNAS, yoked to those generated
by AI, this work first assessed linguistic simplicity across such summaries and
public perceptions. Study 1a analyzed simplicity features of PNAS abstracts
(scientific summaries) and significance statements (lay summaries), observing
that lay summaries were indeed linguistically simpler, but effect size
differences were small. Study 1b used a large language model, GPT-4, to create
significance statements based on paper abstracts and this more than doubled the
average effect size without fine-tuning. Study 2 experimentally demonstrated
that simply-written GPT summaries facilitated more favorable perceptions of
scientists (they were perceived as more credible and trustworthy, but less
intelligent) than more complexly-written human PNAS summaries. Crucially, Study
3 experimentally demonstrated that participants comprehended scientific writing
better after reading simple GPT summaries compared to complex PNAS summaries.
In their own words, participants also summarized scientific papers in a more
detailed and concrete manner after reading GPT summaries compared to PNAS
summaries of the same article. AI has the potential to engage scientific
communities and the public via a simple language heuristic, advocating for its
integration into scientific dissemination for a more informed society.
|
[
-0.2508699893951416,
-0.39923787117004395,
0.9220576882362366,
0.32198402285575867,
-0.5025063753128052,
0.09323553740978241,
-0.28206419944763184,
-0.5791414976119995,
0.3883870244026184,
-0.32763248682022095,
0.13007833063602448,
-0.3210245966911316,
-0.9448370933532715,
0.6436058282852173,
-0.5729941129684448,
0.9458503127098083,
0.16302762925624847,
-0.0023109675385057926,
-0.4892618954181671,
0.20798663794994354,
0.3007985055446625,
-0.15026745200157166,
-0.4061196744441986,
-0.5494763255119324,
0.6928240060806274,
0.2336914986371994,
0.7258569002151489,
0.7027747631072998,
0.7937842607498169,
0.44281235337257385,
-0.5278332829475403,
0.23874568939208984,
-0.47656598687171936,
-0.2847245931625366,
-0.1543397307395935,
-0.821638822555542,
-0.11177488416433334,
-0.02673836052417755,
0.8681885004043579,
1.369325041770935,
0.13854186236858368,
0.13522092998027802,
0.336686909198761,
0.9627803564071655,
-0.5442909002304077,
0.5408092737197876,
-0.3308578431606293,
0.19175474345684052,
-0.09022011607885361,
-0.15951447188854218,
-0.3676915764808655,
-0.13629895448684692,
0.45166662335395813,
-0.9400144815444946,
0.28242793679237366,
-0.04371034726500511,
0.8368953466415405,
0.4448181986808777,
-0.41172879934310913,
-0.35683673620224,
-0.9516199231147766,
0.5383602380752563,
-0.5418831706047058,
0.09412486851215363,
-0.07479997724294662,
-0.102281354367733,
-0.16125406324863434,
-0.9479163885116577,
-0.920128345489502,
-0.174271360039711,
-0.3117741048336029,
0.36908450722694397,
-0.3388400673866272,
0.26890042424201965,
0.4659208357334137,
0.25429415702819824,
-0.47666847705841064,
-0.35326606035232544,
-1.0126564502716064,
0.02374095469713211,
0.7024751305580139,
-0.03291691094636917,
0.24153980612754822,
-0.2691670060157776,
0.19740478694438934,
-0.07970429956912994,
-0.47881048917770386,
0.07607248425483704,
0.018360521644353867,
0.015175416134297848,
-0.08595176786184311,
0.6419637799263,
-0.4346447288990021,
0.383663147687912,
-0.013845398090779781,
-0.21810419857501984,
0.31787338852882385,
-0.5281475782394409,
-0.33892524242401123,
0.17843176424503326,
0.8662192821502686,
0.2693202793598175,
-0.058843716979026794,
-0.08912122994661331,
0.28414952754974365,
0.22332440316677094,
0.15066246688365936,
-0.8160420656204224,
-0.4812539219856262,
0.0655282661318779,
-0.7253872156143188,
-0.27772754430770874,
0.3578357696533203,
-0.5076490044593811,
-0.5069495439529419,
-0.4211340546607971,
0.3929605185985565,
-0.08697827160358429,
-0.17948029935359955,
0.17026831209659576,
-0.3950808346271515,
-0.07874910533428192,
0.9197448492050171,
-0.6033216118812561,
0.16195224225521088,
0.7601555585861206,
1.1941936016082764,
-0.02905036136507988,
-0.3297331929206848,
0.16760480403900146,
0.25617915391921997,
-0.3314562737941742,
0.9293976426124573,
-0.354573518037796,
-0.5117236971855164,
-0.6057666540145874,
-0.559069812297821,
-0.002513204701244831,
-0.38339972496032715,
0.2527557909488678,
-0.2223963886499405,
0.2551012337207794,
-0.23343981802463531,
-0.34609749913215637,
-0.3941042423248291,
-0.17003022134304047,
-0.6061006188392639,
0.1320408433675766,
-0.4357339143753052,
-0.6089528799057007,
0.5665799975395203,
-1.002570629119873,
-0.6240540146827698,
0.06015104800462723,
-0.33943960070610046,
-0.3278110921382904,
0.3250395357608795,
0.1691708117723465,
0.1177290752530098,
0.02842896431684494,
0.422945111989975,
0.15436892211437225,
-0.20601001381874084,
0.2934848368167877,
-0.6072404980659485,
0.6085719466209412,
0.3600282371044159,
-0.40752094984054565,
0.17461496591567993,
-0.4745851457118988,
-0.21714429557323456,
-0.14981238543987274,
-0.5052028298377991,
-0.1353706270456314,
0.18318450450897217,
-0.28617435693740845,
-0.15147000551223755,
-0.01354407612234354,
-0.44555726647377014,
0.27832281589508057,
-0.7038477063179016,
0.6606333255767822,
0.3278791308403015,
-0.10348958522081375,
0.5376725196838379,
-0.42504751682281494,
0.2549664080142975,
-0.01814308576285839,
0.17520315945148468,
-0.3208872675895691,
-0.9191707968711853,
-0.6123369336128235,
-0.30753612518310547,
0.360608845949173,
0.29355549812316895,
-0.2868334949016571,
0.2853720784187317,
-0.4337976574897766,
-0.6100887060165405,
-0.8333843350410461,
0.12893958389759064,
0.4002237617969513,
0.6540566682815552,
0.3268924355506897,
-0.42695343494415283,
-0.47902897000312805,
-0.8553592562675476,
-0.3835265338420868,
-0.5337370038032532,
-0.23830291628837585,
0.207802414894104,
0.8294345140457153,
0.056622982025146484,
0.8997594714164734,
-0.6191881895065308,
0.24721883237361908,
-0.1141318678855896,
0.7539865970611572,
0.18538714945316315,
0.2821754813194275,
-0.09224169701337814,
-0.9912291765213013,
-0.5486847758293152,
-0.08035653084516525,
-1.017755389213562,
0.20035813748836517,
-0.08647545427083969,
0.2542914152145386,
-0.105862557888031,
0.38159269094467163,
-0.9440557956695557,
0.7429338693618774,
0.0991884246468544,
-0.28509360551834106,
0.6103619337081909,
-0.21237815916538239,
0.43599894642829895,
-0.7413650155067444,
0.4048466682434082,
-0.18304064869880676,
0.0002195716224377975,
-0.7510389089584351,
-0.19628410041332245,
-0.25572431087493896,
-0.31425443291664124,
-0.3854277729988098,
0.15295901894569397,
-0.4481956660747528,
-0.07050685584545135,
-0.3012312352657318,
0.07555486261844635,
0.13840629160404205,
-0.0454135462641716,
0.085516557097435,
0.8347559571266174,
0.36215266585350037,
-0.6877669095993042,
0.03407728299498558,
0.36928942799568176,
-0.620742678642273,
0.15323275327682495,
-1.0691660642623901,
-0.07926826924085617,
-0.8276926279067993,
0.42378562688827515,
-0.9866758584976196,
-0.612177848815918,
0.18483471870422363,
-0.6932869553565979,
0.06529247760772705,
0.22611108422279358,
-0.24759460985660553,
-0.2510497272014618,
-0.1077137291431427,
0.38810572028160095,
0.4653232991695404,
-0.25797009468078613,
0.7278521060943604,
0.030248040333390236,
-0.39637184143066406,
-0.3157230615615845,
-0.8026278018951416,
0.5275256633758545,
-0.05729476734995842,
-0.6391538381576538,
0.19398705661296844,
-0.1998000144958496,
-0.7372118234634399,
-0.09657008200883865,
-0.20726057887077332,
0.14565208554267883,
0.24731852114200592,
0.319445937871933,
-0.11515308916568756,
-0.2652647793292999,
0.3046981692314148,
0.17596650123596191,
-0.06988696753978729,
0.19915390014648438,
-0.0753837525844574,
0.21515066921710968,
-0.5632562637329102,
-0.35835278034210205,
-0.9679073095321655,
0.5385177731513977,
0.7885357737541199,
0.04853107035160065,
0.7157638669013977,
0.20905821025371552,
-0.049175139516592026,
0.3613590598106384,
-0.0030919930431991816,
-0.39169713854789734,
-0.39385712146759033,
0.2858291566371918,
-0.07478567212820053,
-0.7777098417282104,
0.19238433241844177,
-0.4037269353866577,
-0.08736901730298996,
0.6428079605102539,
0.14656925201416016,
-0.4335174560546875,
1.1785478591918945,
0.5818239450454712,
0.09278100728988647,
0.32932087779045105,
-0.16028992831707,
0.39496713876724243,
-0.642828106880188,
-0.5988631844520569,
-0.7397767305374146,
-0.23499442636966705,
-0.3559941351413727,
-0.2959444522857666,
0.9035705327987671,
0.4980609118938446,
-0.28174126148223877,
-0.23801778256893158,
-0.808986246585846,
0.5565602779388428,
0.7041921615600586,
0.1573907732963562,
0.6316100358963013,
0.2538929879665375,
0.5051078796386719,
0.12919241189956665,
-0.7608860731124878,
-0.8316310048103333,
1.0461347103118896,
0.3577078878879547,
0.632534921169281,
0.35750722885131836,
0.7711048126220703,
0.24961735308170319,
0.44996726512908936,
-0.8754678964614868,
0.40379223227500916,
-0.04263141006231308,
-0.1011679619550705,
-0.560548722743988,
-0.41659775376319885,
-1.0087212324142456,
0.23918376863002777,
-0.29604291915893555,
-0.3570444881916046,
0.26106229424476624,
0.2531939446926117,
-0.46567046642303467,
-0.008819869719445705,
-0.9572432041168213,
0.29971277713775635,
-0.08014635741710663,
0.1565808355808258,
-0.511547863483429,
-0.9927670359611511,
0.2826913595199585,
0.04945702105760574,
0.28915297985076904,
0.2425871193408966,
-0.09214594960212708,
0.8623663187026978,
-0.3530828356742859,
0.9234148263931274,
0.1560964286327362,
0.3188353180885315,
0.23709364235401154,
-0.2129293829202652,
0.197516530752182,
0.18125075101852417,
-0.09503120183944702,
0.2562202215194702,
-0.513710618019104,
-0.448346883058548,
-0.7921546101570129,
0.2170652598142624,
-1.113153338432312,
-1.054651141166687,
-0.41782650351524353,
-0.4645422399044037,
0.3436829447746277,
0.3762536346912384,
0.1713121235370636,
0.23813466727733612,
-0.008271580561995506,
0.3943081200122833,
0.7595402002334595,
0.09910298883914948,
0.19575907289981842,
0.34437593817710876,
0.14102023839950562,
-0.24535048007965088,
0.6181628108024597,
-0.020413316786289215,
0.4022146761417389,
0.40324530005455017,
0.573489248752594,
0.009153477847576141,
-0.7722177505493164,
-0.2059541493654251,
0.11823302507400513,
-0.7403486967086792,
-0.05154650658369064,
-0.9955787062644958,
0.000215269741602242,
-0.5813397169113159,
-0.1789083033800125,
0.07753697037696838,
-0.647756814956665,
-0.5118527412414551,
-0.08174450695514679,
0.2787792384624481,
1.16830575466156,
-0.37516430020332336,
0.3022461533546448,
-0.3164825141429901,
0.431574285030365,
0.3433416485786438,
-0.03265942633152008,
-0.06148483604192734,
-0.2639392912387848,
0.0379054993391037,
0.07284839451313019,
-0.15759460628032684,
-0.788851797580719,
0.19238971173763275,
0.4930896759033203,
0.45156604051589966,
0.4721829891204834,
-0.34509146213531494,
0.6520285606384277,
-0.19713914394378662,
0.991206705570221,
0.4341655969619751,
-1.091827154159546,
0.8557382225990295,
-0.17905443906784058,
0.4853525459766388,
0.679632842540741,
0.4683314859867096,
-0.1467067003250122,
-0.5488738417625427,
-0.5774530172348022,
-1.0540807247161865,
0.37670671939849854,
0.3281588852405548,
0.022780483588576317,
0.12295148521661758,
0.46708422899246216,
0.07247097790241241,
0.568905770778656,
-0.5545557141304016,
-0.39375874400138855,
-0.6627259850502014,
-0.1905084103345871,
-0.18497653305530548,
-0.011762019246816635,
-0.4720974564552307,
-0.5396881103515625,
0.39008933305740356,
-0.11270974576473236,
0.3368759751319885,
0.6856668591499329,
-0.04862590506672859,
-0.01948593370616436,
0.34562745690345764,
0.9842759966850281,
0.7800474762916565,
0.11694783717393875,
0.4721197783946991,
-0.1970258355140686,
-0.6379175782203674,
-0.15904006361961365,
0.05021803453564644,
-0.702924907207489,
0.004799571353942156,
0.7799437046051025,
0.888370931148529,
-0.23293766379356384,
-0.48214834928512573,
0.11999857425689697,
-0.026587342843413353,
-0.3598718047142029,
0.22595059871673584,
0.11901020258665085,
0.11793933808803558,
0.13354724645614624,
0.6112403273582458,
0.7084712982177734,
0.5539718866348267,
-0.7703646421432495,
-0.0891614705324173,
0.19510912895202637,
0.07111366838216782,
-0.17512626945972443,
0.6889920830726624,
0.328641802072525,
-0.14575859904289246,
0.5425580739974976,
-0.12772305309772491,
-0.5248830914497375,
0.8957420587539673,
0.4723251760005951,
0.6275696754455566,
-0.013561761006712914,
0.3510720133781433,
0.32931315898895264,
0.43021872639656067,
-0.3070562481880188,
-0.007560360245406628,
-0.3083955645561218,
-0.39912301301956177,
-0.47832801938056946,
-0.5527583360671997,
-0.46744129061698914,
-0.10456102341413498,
-0.3851945996284485,
-0.25786709785461426,
-0.5610156059265137,
-0.02066851034760475,
0.5915570259094238,
-0.0024998195003718138,
-0.4208543300628662,
0.06190710887312889,
-0.10026396811008453,
0.773587167263031,
-0.962710976600647,
0.20485691726207733,
0.821931779384613,
-0.7511497735977173,
-0.9756705164909363,
0.08261185884475708,
0.1642797291278839,
-0.5011587738990784,
0.9388582706451416,
0.08940067142248154,
-0.35059812664985657,
0.00034711751504801214,
-0.9623489379882812,
-1.071731448173523,
1.1843303442001343,
0.23759935796260834,
-0.544045090675354,
0.35317668318748474,
0.04709182307124138,
0.8641930222511292,
-0.2790736258029938,
0.34007665514945984,
0.3474934995174408,
0.8570128083229065,
0.17899154126644135,
-1.0998762845993042,
-0.0036109972279518843,
-0.4798600673675537,
-0.1640799343585968,
-0.02756093069911003,
-0.5774268507957458,
0.8625550866127014,
-0.5148338079452515,
-0.4219342768192291,
-0.13746635615825653,
1.1618242263793945,
0.003979036118835211,
0.619178295135498,
0.28816479444503784,
0.2519656717777252,
1.0937159061431885,
-0.0291590616106987,
0.9111838340759277,
0.1300746649503708,
0.0018342345720157027,
0.729971706867218,
-0.054745614528656006,
0.5084369778633118,
0.6695414185523987,
-0.2533447742462158,
0.7088721990585327,
0.12435591965913773,
-0.0712813213467598,
0.4221331775188446,
0.2566201686859131,
-0.6200956702232361,
0.0426751971244812,
-0.38742104172706604,
-0.4062715768814087,
0.41096532344818115,
0.5747458338737488,
-0.34347403049468994,
-0.0764937475323677,
0.13672350347042084,
0.0010653713252395391,
0.48397180438041687,
-0.6116117238998413,
1.0694094896316528,
0.23511743545532227,
-0.6353758573532104,
0.2034713327884674,
-0.22125199437141418,
0.6669516563415527,
-0.3374518156051636,
-0.12680278718471527,
0.00873260572552681,
-0.12186657637357712,
-0.6104555726051331,
-0.9251192808151245,
0.4413979649543762,
-0.008200133219361305,
-0.521567165851593,
-0.13008297979831696,
0.544070839881897,
-0.47142940759658813,
-0.33416393399238586,
-0.42182961106300354,
0.24541088938713074,
0.5086047649383545,
0.06649354100227356,
-0.4455946683883667,
0.13954636454582214,
-0.02478831261396408,
-0.11992685496807098,
-0.09608806669712067,
0.22170473635196686,
0.07625479251146317,
0.7798712849617004,
0.6777896285057068,
0.23861351609230042,
-0.29726850986480713,
0.07706446200609207,
0.7222050428390503,
-0.32404813170433044,
-0.4470328092575073,
-0.7506796717643738,
0.39285340905189514,
-0.2489519566297531,
-0.21296654641628265,
0.7510658502578735,
0.563407838344574,
0.5258648991584778,
-0.19162046909332275,
1.1753768920898438,
-0.19933348894119263,
0.17411892116069794,
-0.29105085134506226,
0.8680450320243835,
-0.3174338936805725,
0.11514255404472351,
-0.11324765533208847,
-0.3845488727092743,
-0.7423770427703857,
0.6225351095199585,
-0.455700159072876,
0.2039983719587326,
0.7223198413848877,
0.5245330929756165,
0.18923020362854004,
-0.007453087251633406,
0.012682951986789703,
0.51807701587677,
0.43015754222869873,
0.2486717700958252,
0.6643977165222168,
-0.13416118919849396,
0.48546940088272095,
-0.10491941124200821,
-0.45787110924720764,
-0.17878863215446472,
-0.7624610662460327,
-0.8510763645172119,
-0.3796127736568451,
-0.3555756211280823,
-0.2682044804096222,
0.18835437297821045,
0.8373913764953613,
0.3956294655799866,
-0.6753551959991455,
0.045372333377599716,
-0.47712835669517517,
0.26444658637046814,
-0.07677442580461502,
-0.21987949311733246,
0.6709118485450745,
-0.14038126170635223,
-0.5748885869979858,
0.43230944871902466,
0.5014123916625977,
0.07776222378015518,
-0.22234641015529633,
-0.045045461505651474,
0.07553000003099442,
0.15095113217830658,
0.7386101484298706,
0.5932415127754211,
-0.7411074638366699,
-0.08209071308374405,
-0.24734386801719666,
-0.16055384278297424,
0.1559770405292511,
0.7351440191268921,
-0.6087548732757568,
0.5455592274665833,
0.7180637121200562,
0.2827232778072357,
0.2987928092479706,
0.1385594755411148,
0.7119409441947937,
-0.2834083139896393,
0.01593724451959133,
0.3088817894458771,
0.06158480420708656,
0.36924099922180176,
-0.5379232168197632,
0.27672499418258667,
0.22599871456623077,
-0.4788590669631958,
-0.6261062622070312,
0.20898015797138214,
-0.9181532263755798,
-0.44399622082710266,
0.8239222168922424,
-0.013282448053359985,
-0.2937752604484558,
-0.5142173767089844,
-0.2048100233078003,
0.3002038300037384,
-0.6481527090072632,
1.2508654594421387,
0.499614953994751,
-0.3933162987232208,
-0.06409785896539688,
-0.2958154082298279,
0.8203853368759155,
0.50926274061203,
-1.0941319465637207,
-0.15007272362709045,
0.36927780508995056,
0.006528894416987896,
0.7434949278831482,
0.5926218032836914,
-0.08761429786682129,
0.4463599622249603,
0.15452861785888672,
-0.13961321115493774,
-0.27488601207733154,
-0.5208475589752197,
-0.47079452872276306,
0.28020012378692627,
0.22005291283130646,
0.3896336853504181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15067v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15067v1
|
Enhancing Textual Personality Detection toward Social Media: Integrating Long-term and Short-term Perspectives
| 2024-04-23T14:13:53 | 2024-04-23T14:13:53 |
Haohao Zhu, Xiaokun Zhang, Junyu Lu, Youlin Wu, Zewen Bai, Changrong Min, Liang Yang, Bo Xu, Dongyu Zhang, Hongfei Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Textual personality detection aims to identify personality characteristics by
analyzing user-generated content toward social media platforms. Numerous
psychological literature highlighted that personality encompasses both
long-term stable traits and short-term dynamic states. However, existing
studies often concentrate only on either long-term or short-term personality
representations, without effectively combining both aspects. This limitation
hinders a comprehensive understanding of individuals' personalities, as both
stable traits and dynamic states are vital. To bridge this gap, we propose a
Dual Enhanced Network(DEN) to jointly model users' long-term and short-term
personality for textual personality detection. In DEN, a Long-term Personality
Encoding is devised to effectively model long-term stable personality traits.
Short-term Personality Encoding is presented to capture short-term dynamic
personality states. The Bi-directional Interaction component facilitates the
integration of both personality aspects, allowing for a comprehensive
representation of the user's personality. Experimental results on two
personality detection datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of the DEN model
and the benefits of considering both the dynamic and stable nature of
personality characteristics for textual personality detection.
|
[
-0.4828033745288849,
-0.828588604927063,
0.7892277836799622,
0.5375284552574158,
-0.5330449342727661,
0.28694942593574524,
-0.7120497226715088,
-0.7906606793403625,
0.7969986796379089,
0.5111635327339172,
-0.8550214767456055,
-0.33261626958847046,
-0.6378898620605469,
0.3787764608860016,
-0.36840683221817017,
0.8925560116767883,
0.0920986607670784,
-0.2923494875431061,
-0.2510317265987396,
-0.2946009635925293,
-0.610835075378418,
-0.6160959005355835,
-0.8945134282112122,
-0.2329607754945755,
1.0867462158203125,
0.1349703073501587,
0.58016037940979,
-0.0006399831618182361,
0.36043378710746765,
0.25653329491615295,
-0.008319375105202198,
0.22365549206733704,
-0.651252269744873,
0.43689820170402527,
-0.39058026671409607,
-0.11402135342359543,
-0.5624796748161316,
-0.026859480887651443,
0.6612045168876648,
0.32283642888069153,
0.23427483439445496,
0.007386594079434872,
0.08578915148973465,
0.9699333906173706,
-0.41460588574409485,
-0.1299910843372345,
-0.10618158429861069,
-0.11506441235542297,
-0.41569921374320984,
-0.28098809719085693,
-0.3273330628871918,
-0.21570797264575958,
0.0195989478379488,
-0.19434534013271332,
-0.19392484426498413,
-0.3643338978290558,
0.5484029054641724,
-0.09356444329023361,
-0.996191143989563,
-0.2700144350528717,
-1.0192713737487793,
0.7162078022956848,
-0.28467297554016113,
0.4197050631046295,
0.45266419649124146,
0.501653790473938,
0.13022448122501373,
-0.30912473797798157,
-0.7288824319839478,
-0.04086509719491005,
-0.33312150835990906,
0.12715686857700348,
-0.07246764004230499,
-0.2231249064207077,
-0.061134207993745804,
0.12489242851734161,
-0.3344855308532715,
0.12410387396812439,
0.004012195859104395,
-0.021944502368569374,
0.9654386043548584,
0.15892866253852844,
0.35447707772254944,
-0.34565794467926025,
-0.08203022181987762,
-0.09213460981845856,
-0.17828983068466187,
0.1606207937002182,
0.9291823506355286,
0.33469095826148987,
-0.10541122406721115,
0.5567246079444885,
-0.0455470085144043,
0.15889371931552887,
0.2757161557674408,
0.054302386939525604,
0.24875423312187195,
-0.3976147770881653,
0.31379273533821106,
-0.08594658225774765,
0.8980334401130676,
0.49984318017959595,
0.324059396982193,
-0.11155986785888672,
-0.23469790816307068,
0.16297510266304016,
0.3087109625339508,
-1.0079854726791382,
-0.1536494344472885,
0.4225291907787323,
-0.7267907857894897,
-0.581942081451416,
0.16715863347053528,
-1.1729429960250854,
-0.8433356881141663,
-0.42023131251335144,
0.21825028955936432,
-0.4802400767803192,
-0.9908737540245056,
0.10782469809055328,
-0.25816091895103455,
-0.15181219577789307,
0.14602462947368622,
-0.8987742066383362,
0.20020121335983276,
0.6952869892120361,
1.0227954387664795,
-0.36667755246162415,
0.010542490519583225,
-0.4295414686203003,
-0.05684022977948189,
0.013929199427366257,
0.7197844386100769,
-0.593993604183197,
-0.45932191610336304,
0.23625263571739197,
0.097040094435215,
0.23884455859661102,
-0.11918602138757706,
0.5241723656654358,
-0.5905545949935913,
0.09763962775468826,
-0.5185977220535278,
-0.2857925295829773,
0.22026264667510986,
0.08575266599655151,
-0.9210606813430786,
1.2085274457931519,
0.27923721075057983,
-1.0117217302322388,
0.3305705785751343,
-0.8341589570045471,
-0.5124450922012329,
0.08619991689920425,
-0.0404161736369133,
-0.48376530408859253,
-0.00298079801723361,
0.08579376339912415,
0.7255192399024963,
0.42037680745124817,
0.3006182909011841,
-0.6109583377838135,
-0.3459288775920868,
0.5777769088745117,
-0.15976892411708832,
0.7141885161399841,
-0.24970945715904236,
-0.15371789038181305,
0.09691423922777176,
-0.6331295371055603,
-0.40751883387565613,
0.2864353060722351,
-0.371140718460083,
-0.7580209970474243,
0.21880628168582916,
0.289510041475296,
0.12603339552879333,
0.5463712811470032,
-0.6392561197280884,
-0.00835886225104332,
-0.12624625861644745,
0.3917084336280823,
0.6012656092643738,
0.1450028121471405,
0.5611534118652344,
-0.16575343906879425,
0.3066958785057068,
0.12864619493484497,
-0.11468257009983063,
0.18945375084877014,
-0.2619818150997162,
-0.466662734746933,
-0.3362850844860077,
-0.08218365907669067,
0.5362196564674377,
-0.7157114744186401,
1.050840973854065,
-0.40428251028060913,
-0.3525967001914978,
0.003652003826573491,
0.2753714621067047,
0.1095171645283699,
0.14776578545570374,
0.42388850450515747,
-0.4389457404613495,
-0.7143731713294983,
-0.6078307628631592,
-0.6650765538215637,
-0.244682177901268,
-0.1108940914273262,
0.2479962259531021,
0.46277379989624023,
-0.5336455702781677,
1.0433202981948853,
-0.29782387614250183,
-0.10835564881563187,
-0.49994567036628723,
0.2810498774051666,
0.057759590446949005,
0.1470523178577423,
0.7325707674026489,
-1.2426589727401733,
-0.829933762550354,
-0.09378686547279358,
-0.6857864856719971,
-0.10707022249698639,
-0.23513467609882355,
-0.31700631976127625,
0.08594266325235367,
0.25122568011283875,
-0.4850626587867737,
0.5856795907020569,
0.5313476920127869,
-0.7444911599159241,
0.7709949016571045,
0.1688576191663742,
0.049151550978422165,
-1.031686544418335,
-0.04060693085193634,
0.5038732290267944,
-0.5245814919471741,
-0.681109607219696,
-0.22512729465961456,
0.19559070467948914,
0.032060787081718445,
-0.07042275369167328,
0.7137852907180786,
-0.4438217878341675,
0.11025294661521912,
-0.35750260949134827,
0.10993890464305878,
0.35951417684555054,
0.3591529130935669,
0.15563414990901947,
0.6102731227874756,
0.36963799595832825,
-0.21777592599391937,
0.48027125000953674,
0.04584594443440437,
-0.14717067778110504,
1.2669810056686401,
-0.5898274779319763,
0.34673309326171875,
-0.47389286756515503,
0.5187001824378967,
-0.8413306474685669,
-0.4058288037776947,
0.18057629466056824,
-0.40563154220581055,
0.5488070249557495,
-0.09434070438146591,
-0.5799189209938049,
-0.47668540477752686,
-0.7083047032356262,
0.2008776217699051,
0.3065039813518524,
-0.6052235960960388,
0.912351667881012,
0.1137319952249527,
-0.2880283296108246,
-0.3013301491737366,
-0.7061033248901367,
0.28847846388816833,
-0.3841599225997925,
-0.8310181498527527,
0.6407419443130493,
-0.10261104255914688,
-0.201198011636734,
0.08923359960317612,
0.16945086419582367,
-0.017871756106615067,
-0.2578634023666382,
0.1876601129770279,
0.07354499399662018,
-0.12415502965450287,
0.3914838433265686,
0.3047833740711212,
-0.040074318647384644,
0.10493879020214081,
0.08985356241464615,
0.5575417876243591,
-0.22718626260757446,
0.07206030189990997,
-0.830048680305481,
0.7761032581329346,
0.5836828947067261,
-0.382425993680954,
1.2027429342269897,
1.0931164026260376,
-0.11644207686185837,
-0.2735085189342499,
-0.5173887610435486,
-0.3813478648662567,
-0.5404945015907288,
0.36274150013923645,
-0.2326260805130005,
-0.8703374862670898,
0.6351470947265625,
-0.05645772069692612,
-0.24068419635295868,
0.2380976378917694,
0.365060955286026,
-0.5416520237922668,
0.9723576903343201,
0.8359923362731934,
0.2900460362434387,
0.823738694190979,
-0.08617565035820007,
0.33959850668907166,
-1.0141024589538574,
-0.12197178602218628,
-0.12821653485298157,
-0.607416033744812,
-0.45503053069114685,
-0.12131444364786148,
0.08336542546749115,
-0.11769582331180573,
-0.13958506286144257,
0.4700363576412201,
-0.5979530811309814,
0.3307490646839142,
0.06384526938199997,
0.7562135457992554,
0.1808483600616455,
-0.27139613032341003,
0.24766488373279572,
-0.43364328145980835,
0.32462742924690247,
-0.5356529951095581,
1.0787250995635986,
0.5323761105537415,
0.44190269708633423,
0.46596115827560425,
0.6250163316726685,
0.5411774516105652,
0.42904558777809143,
-0.8079894185066223,
0.585451602935791,
-0.5668571591377258,
-0.5551142692565918,
-0.33346471190452576,
-0.45015057921409607,
-0.6121963858604431,
-0.0791764184832573,
-0.4348614513874054,
-0.8041800856590271,
0.3966149389743805,
0.06046253442764282,
-0.18069306015968323,
0.12167433649301529,
-0.6058506965637207,
0.7170842289924622,
-0.4238746166229248,
-0.4080114960670471,
-0.19013549387454987,
-0.7487615346908569,
0.33972030878067017,
-0.3859657347202301,
-0.12458602339029312,
-0.2922420799732208,
-0.024512197822332382,
0.7611598372459412,
-0.256580650806427,
1.1279758214950562,
-0.22352862358093262,
0.09696340560913086,
-0.03276391699910164,
-0.03158404305577278,
0.5396829843521118,
0.44237828254699707,
-0.3542025089263916,
0.12637782096862793,
0.15933166444301605,
-0.2137376070022583,
-0.7456070184707642,
0.680934488773346,
-0.8209401369094849,
-0.17600826919078827,
-0.22563700377941132,
-0.31073620915412903,
-0.34983187913894653,
0.32012099027633667,
-0.11256672441959381,
0.5930914878845215,
-0.4785682260990143,
0.323648065328598,
0.6212309002876282,
-0.10949021577835083,
0.34927135705947876,
0.11419738829135895,
-0.4089685082435608,
-0.31532010436058044,
0.590883731842041,
-0.13864953815937042,
0.11900666356086731,
0.23529058694839478,
0.3624391257762909,
-0.4080919623374939,
-0.25089800357818604,
-0.0827154591679573,
0.638340950012207,
-0.647877037525177,
0.1697646975517273,
-0.8929963707923889,
-0.14162585139274597,
-0.31929025053977966,
-0.22414514422416687,
-0.2563305199146271,
0.038637492805719376,
-0.4673771560192108,
0.10265646874904633,
0.5036377906799316,
0.39542356133461,
0.04481159895658493,
0.4179149568080902,
-0.5752410888671875,
0.5920753479003906,
0.4689888060092926,
0.3799757659435272,
-0.09141243249177933,
-0.20272040367126465,
-0.17491790652275085,
0.21374695003032684,
-0.12265420705080032,
-1.3457564115524292,
0.22517433762550354,
0.3256276249885559,
0.047415781766176224,
0.7083601355552673,
-0.04355987161397934,
0.4565196931362152,
-0.3275446891784668,
0.36553511023521423,
0.14063534140586853,
-0.7239315509796143,
0.5854101777076721,
-0.6056084036827087,
0.1389894187450409,
0.9759605526924133,
0.5217735767364502,
-0.7579038739204407,
-0.26596492528915405,
0.007727060001343489,
-0.36653947830200195,
0.2919459939002991,
0.22087512910366058,
0.7552889585494995,
-0.09089161455631256,
0.6976733207702637,
0.14574094116687775,
0.19412757456302643,
-0.7729729413986206,
0.0918942466378212,
-0.4247257113456726,
-0.3731042146682739,
0.02128298394382,
-0.5292462110519409,
-0.0272609181702137,
-0.5436243414878845,
0.3928711414337158,
-0.16501624882221222,
0.3976426124572754,
0.0039677806198596954,
0.15081678330898285,
0.023620007559657097,
-0.06603267788887024,
0.29629671573638916,
0.4096117913722992,
-0.6508035063743591,
0.08102168887853622,
-0.44696173071861267,
-0.711896538734436,
-0.1932518482208252,
0.04493166506290436,
0.08420664817094803,
0.3001697063446045,
0.17530301213264465,
0.6704077124595642,
0.24204730987548828,
-0.24782074987888336,
0.9170308113098145,
-0.29594117403030396,
-0.05850072577595711,
-0.648063063621521,
-0.04969161003828049,
0.5274367332458496,
0.2648264467716217,
0.4265163242816925,
0.019606493413448334,
-0.09073274582624435,
-0.7895198464393616,
0.08840453624725342,
0.4443965554237366,
-0.5715005993843079,
-0.7167378664016724,
0.4040340185165405,
0.5716975331306458,
-0.3762459456920624,
0.5009427070617676,
-0.39491143822669983,
-0.5972529649734497,
0.6644050478935242,
0.5024839043617249,
0.9773432612419128,
-0.10762403160333633,
0.4276527762413025,
0.25112631916999817,
-0.02982431836426258,
0.05649925023317337,
0.3201916515827179,
-0.24288880825042725,
-0.8901253938674927,
-0.23253415524959564,
-0.8467240333557129,
-0.217509925365448,
0.14527678489685059,
-0.6698129177093506,
0.6787495017051697,
-0.40813472867012024,
-0.6327217817306519,
0.21604548394680023,
0.3265545964241028,
-0.5720189213752747,
-0.06648802757263184,
0.09544944763183594,
0.7288810014724731,
-0.8656080961227417,
0.8329382538795471,
0.6269731521606445,
0.005686086602509022,
-0.2662166655063629,
0.026446925476193428,
0.36036762595176697,
-0.27598559856414795,
0.5317758917808533,
0.6734216213226318,
-0.381634920835495,
-0.07021799683570862,
-0.3601459562778473,
-0.37223222851753235,
1.2354109287261963,
0.038952406495809555,
-0.3225785791873932,
-0.15668010711669922,
-0.0016238486859947443,
0.8821175694465637,
-0.434646338224411,
0.020410282537341118,
0.3572002649307251,
0.5811911821365356,
0.13041681051254272,
-0.4795771837234497,
0.054417748004198074,
-0.3051779866218567,
0.09120293706655502,
0.556401252746582,
-0.5845473408699036,
0.4832739233970642,
0.2091217190027237,
-0.6620698571205139,
0.0006563451606780291,
0.901078462600708,
-0.04782554507255554,
0.4092886745929718,
0.7204002737998962,
0.3819354772567749,
0.6121137142181396,
0.15695571899414062,
0.6894350647926331,
-0.34305548667907715,
0.21500910818576813,
0.9511182904243469,
-0.41914522647857666,
1.0570476055145264,
0.4313674867153168,
0.02299046888947487,
1.3671114444732666,
0.6231309771537781,
0.025437718257308006,
0.5471038818359375,
-0.24581649899482727,
-0.6192382574081421,
-0.25555750727653503,
-0.1910826563835144,
-0.2158723622560501,
0.3671150505542755,
0.47525832056999207,
-0.42520996928215027,
0.0430167093873024,
0.2113824337720871,
0.27460527420043945,
0.3369685709476471,
-0.006233657710254192,
0.4910404086112976,
0.08984868228435516,
-0.35586950182914734,
-0.10375360399484634,
0.10390204936265945,
1.123457431793213,
-0.530163586139679,
0.2779765725135803,
-0.21995557844638824,
0.010158384218811989,
-0.3939039707183838,
-1.023268461227417,
0.7382200360298157,
-0.0717601478099823,
-0.20126873254776,
-0.531366765499115,
1.3779488801956177,
-0.4916590750217438,
-0.496084600687027,
0.6667366027832031,
0.43083444237709045,
-0.32516583800315857,
-0.3941431939601898,
-0.4906943738460541,
0.06412967294454575,
-0.5366443395614624,
-0.2859564423561096,
0.18802836537361145,
0.4021442234516144,
0.11568018794059753,
0.3608245849609375,
0.7606698870658875,
-0.04526719078421593,
-0.4089079201221466,
0.33825433254241943,
0.8303578495979309,
-0.5178956389427185,
-0.7378329038619995,
-1.011580228805542,
0.6137489080429077,
-0.6483376622200012,
-0.3225844204425812,
0.5545400381088257,
0.2176656574010849,
0.3249959349632263,
0.13658998906612396,
0.4645484387874603,
-0.2096550017595291,
0.5001707077026367,
-0.1482168585062027,
0.9726986289024353,
-0.7487956285476685,
-0.04361545294523239,
-0.1781778782606125,
-0.9090175032615662,
-0.18909677863121033,
0.11362645775079727,
-0.47802650928497314,
0.2053574174642563,
0.6501498818397522,
0.6687520146369934,
-0.29700911045074463,
0.039138976484537125,
-0.006755666341632605,
0.039386648684740067,
0.2813986539840698,
0.5058751106262207,
0.8094761967658997,
0.08294551074504852,
0.1926116645336151,
-0.5661242604255676,
-0.4330574870109558,
-0.4100802540779114,
-0.9491404891014099,
-1.5582187175750732,
-0.6833533048629761,
-0.22215545177459717,
-0.5387272238731384,
-0.09741538763046265,
0.39039871096611023,
0.537017285823822,
-0.24411481618881226,
0.12482951581478119,
0.1992148756980896,
-0.04997728392481804,
-0.06135183200240135,
-0.32863757014274597,
0.25628963112831116,
0.30542683601379395,
-0.43399760127067566,
0.23428753018379211,
0.5995194315910339,
-0.12885041534900665,
-0.7670262455940247,
-0.08666574954986572,
-0.17177119851112366,
0.40555137395858765,
0.7478188872337341,
0.21866588294506073,
-0.2162965089082718,
-0.5706321597099304,
0.3153436481952667,
-0.30563026666641235,
0.07337284088134766,
0.8226779103279114,
-0.50941401720047,
0.592769205570221,
0.591372549533844,
0.41325607895851135,
0.437538743019104,
0.27981799840927124,
0.2904171645641327,
-0.9484357833862305,
0.09704029560089111,
0.2554886043071747,
0.08624018728733063,
0.6542129516601562,
-0.8772763013839722,
0.1524483859539032,
0.3615684509277344,
-0.49104171991348267,
-0.7089513540267944,
0.48261758685112,
-1.3558248281478882,
-0.13323701918125153,
1.187971830368042,
0.1714213639497757,
-0.14654262363910675,
-0.30514854192733765,
0.022609414532780647,
0.2825826108455658,
-0.3433789312839508,
0.8590940237045288,
0.806677520275116,
-0.1640443205833435,
-0.19937103986740112,
-0.4700659513473511,
0.37467482686042786,
0.11677663028240204,
-0.9458891153335571,
-0.2703707814216614,
0.1796720325946808,
0.1362360268831253,
0.27977538108825684,
0.7539600729942322,
-0.0485517792403698,
0.19249534606933594,
-0.28907328844070435,
-0.3030104637145996,
0.022095995023846626,
-0.28418150544166565,
-0.17434553802013397,
-0.12767301499843597,
-0.44611021876335144,
0.2952404022216797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15045v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15045v1
|
Multi-Head Mixture-of-Experts
| 2024-04-23T13:47:09 | 2024-04-23T13:47:09 |
Xun Wu, Shaohan Huang, Wenhui Wang, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Sparse Mixtures of Experts (SMoE) scales model capacity without significant
increases in training and inference costs, but exhibits the following two
issues: (1) Low expert activation, where only a small subset of experts are
activated for optimization. (2) Lacking fine-grained analytical capabilities
for multiple semantic concepts within individual tokens. We propose Multi-Head
Mixture-of-Experts (MH-MoE), which employs a multi-head mechanism to split each
token into multiple sub-tokens. These sub-tokens are then assigned to and
processed by a diverse set of experts in parallel, and seamlessly reintegrated
into the original token form. The multi-head mechanism enables the model to
collectively attend to information from various representation spaces within
different experts, while significantly enhances expert activation, thus deepens
context understanding and alleviate overfitting. Moreover, our MH-MoE is
straightforward to implement and decouples from other SMoE optimization
methods, making it easy to integrate with other SMoE models for enhanced
performance. Extensive experimental results across three tasks: English-focused
language modeling, Multi-lingual language modeling and Masked multi-modality
modeling tasks, demonstrate the effectiveness of MH-MoE.
|
[
-0.8386601209640503,
-0.7293468713760376,
0.5982244610786438,
0.13745619356632233,
-0.2596343159675598,
0.07964974641799927,
-0.4867434501647949,
-0.5201808214187622,
0.63984614610672,
0.3558311462402344,
-0.741523802280426,
0.10172520577907562,
-0.6541831493377686,
0.18165573477745056,
-0.01358881127089262,
0.7565301656723022,
0.25942501425743103,
-0.024562828242778778,
-0.2979019582271576,
-0.24396787583827972,
-0.6298930048942566,
-0.2205028235912323,
-0.31562522053718567,
-0.22155149281024933,
0.6754776835441589,
0.7130954265594482,
0.4905930161476135,
0.6206414699554443,
0.23786742985248566,
0.39829573035240173,
0.22190505266189575,
0.468449205160141,
-0.4563383162021637,
0.0340164415538311,
-0.2394646257162094,
-0.2888657748699188,
-0.5897535085678101,
-0.026723921298980713,
0.5053573250770569,
0.8954761028289795,
-0.41969034075737,
-0.02790735475718975,
0.23534438014030457,
0.31387463212013245,
-0.8800977468490601,
0.055782269686460495,
-1.063415765762329,
-0.33624839782714844,
-0.0426843985915184,
-0.25967222452163696,
-0.27345436811447144,
0.6782243847846985,
0.44929781556129456,
-0.8656121492385864,
0.041349928826093674,
0.21593289077281952,
0.3607790470123291,
0.5149915814399719,
-0.4658958315849304,
0.023336386308073997,
-0.24307402968406677,
1.392495036125183,
-0.6630847454071045,
0.40216147899627686,
-0.008327851071953773,
0.28602683544158936,
-0.030537888407707214,
-0.22238460183143616,
-0.6710203289985657,
0.07028675824403763,
-0.08401200920343399,
0.10373533517122269,
0.059402644634246826,
0.035157058387994766,
-0.2151113897562027,
0.08307844400405884,
-0.11377358436584473,
0.058936938643455505,
-0.408093124628067,
-0.13701605796813965,
0.5698508024215698,
0.073605015873909,
-0.04604872316122055,
-0.0930505022406578,
-0.498986154794693,
0.10027822852134705,
-0.14233222603797913,
-0.4005473256111145,
0.14513951539993286,
0.4675535559654236,
0.1194845587015152,
0.4698183238506317,
-0.370769202709198,
0.4919508695602417,
0.2765280604362488,
-0.6690500378608704,
0.31121915578842163,
-0.20444725453853607,
-0.2334699034690857,
-0.1655714362859726,
0.6768681406974792,
0.21821340918540955,
0.004040824715048075,
-0.3738597333431244,
-0.15363822877407074,
-0.06121053919196129,
0.31699562072753906,
-0.807002067565918,
-0.1025664284825325,
0.3563868999481201,
-0.18314576148986816,
-0.3785620331764221,
-0.0049772970378398895,
-0.8762913346290588,
-0.1914968341588974,
-0.6638498902320862,
0.6958233118057251,
-0.275560200214386,
-0.7112891674041748,
0.21733276546001434,
-0.3805833160877228,
-0.17516092956066132,
0.28978949785232544,
-0.9235112071037292,
0.35381171107292175,
0.6216487288475037,
0.5664100646972656,
-0.4064748287200928,
-0.754538357257843,
-0.32597702741622925,
0.46069684624671936,
-0.0936477929353714,
0.8051373362541199,
-0.7311954498291016,
-0.3580935597419739,
-0.438088983297348,
-0.1565631777048111,
-0.4739045202732086,
-0.5193433165550232,
0.03453098610043526,
-0.2568192780017853,
0.12962603569030762,
-0.2748418152332306,
-0.3742193281650543,
-0.3490648865699768,
0.23906011879444122,
-0.48382535576820374,
1.0237849950790405,
0.1191582977771759,
-0.7083386778831482,
0.5008382797241211,
-0.6580671668052673,
-0.2828240692615509,
0.009829064831137657,
-0.610069751739502,
-0.016314774751663208,
0.30062973499298096,
0.47209712862968445,
0.7204601168632507,
-0.20145106315612793,
0.36396434903144836,
-0.5037823915481567,
-0.08038754016160965,
0.0755179151892662,
-0.2665214538574219,
0.5852743983268738,
0.08776133507490158,
-0.2262369990348816,
0.33182135224342346,
-0.8067461252212524,
-0.2865588068962097,
-0.15107640624046326,
-0.11081935465335846,
-0.4795440137386322,
-0.05521131306886673,
0.006914855912327766,
0.38084670901298523,
0.26025137305259705,
-0.38092556595802307,
0.07731951773166656,
-0.061262618750333786,
0.5213233828544617,
0.8694280982017517,
0.08211226761341095,
0.5030635595321655,
-0.39279845356941223,
0.3409624695777893,
0.5053871273994446,
-0.13066062331199646,
-0.17989607155323029,
-0.8009304404258728,
-0.656225860118866,
-0.8325983881950378,
0.16924771666526794,
0.4980478584766388,
-0.9026352167129517,
0.5481210350990295,
-0.30525293946266174,
-0.4081709384918213,
-0.7470472455024719,
0.24246780574321747,
0.10875475406646729,
0.7146428227424622,
0.4951316714286804,
-0.33697545528411865,
-0.1138322725892067,
-1.0129302740097046,
-0.14643636345863342,
0.1263764202594757,
0.020733054727315903,
0.5478879809379578,
0.5452221632003784,
-0.5954670310020447,
1.0359047651290894,
-0.3833564817905426,
-0.24626635015010834,
-0.016805700957775116,
0.5001366138458252,
-0.10308949649333954,
0.7599733471870422,
0.6967570185661316,
-0.6981214284896851,
-0.40113726258277893,
0.3650512099266052,
-0.552476167678833,
-0.05371570959687233,
-0.13539256155490875,
-0.4648893475532532,
-0.27266982197761536,
0.1519407033920288,
-0.7575801014900208,
-0.02886616624891758,
0.4737527370452881,
0.13578100502490997,
0.7269814610481262,
-0.16022033989429474,
0.3551063537597656,
-0.9894005060195923,
-0.004279132932424545,
0.033120159059762955,
-0.07951518148183823,
-0.5776188969612122,
0.5745381116867065,
-0.034235630184412,
-0.031263913959264755,
-0.44095468521118164,
0.6312828063964844,
-0.45487919449806213,
0.1054258644580841,
-0.3976787328720093,
0.15363462269306183,
0.1042465940117836,
1.0137289762496948,
-0.03481796383857727,
0.7239869832992554,
0.8299375176429749,
-0.7662290334701538,
0.022488871589303017,
0.012874315492808819,
-0.17107388377189636,
0.851842999458313,
-0.5763058662414551,
0.14509648084640503,
-0.3152420222759247,
-0.20975622534751892,
-0.9523020386695862,
-0.6252360343933105,
0.12130933254957199,
-0.2422364205121994,
0.3276607394218445,
0.04610403999686241,
-0.37536704540252686,
-0.10859411209821701,
-0.3417598009109497,
0.563123881816864,
0.15979082882404327,
-0.0466056652367115,
1.0878065824508667,
0.6584250330924988,
-0.2984205186367035,
-0.6723043322563171,
-0.7355592846870422,
-0.08705726265907288,
-0.32933419942855835,
-0.8189846277236938,
0.4670577943325043,
-0.07899201661348343,
-0.2365131378173828,
0.0914519801735878,
-0.3314584791660309,
-0.39480528235435486,
0.00437591690570116,
-0.175871804356575,
-0.006151522509753704,
-0.31692153215408325,
-0.055986180901527405,
0.7004396915435791,
-0.18732516467571259,
-0.20025524497032166,
-0.3823769688606262,
0.205038920044899,
0.09358832240104675,
-0.32074877619743347,
-0.380269855260849,
0.7603009343147278,
0.9520329236984253,
-0.38829469680786133,
0.9917154312133789,
0.7256919145584106,
-0.5083707571029663,
-0.01908998377621174,
-0.8819211721420288,
-0.415811687707901,
-0.494282066822052,
0.4870162308216095,
-0.7898008227348328,
-0.7875885367393494,
0.5031835436820984,
-0.1459384560585022,
0.35889527201652527,
0.6394950151443481,
0.7290446162223816,
0.030912576243281364,
1.0618170499801636,
0.6333090662956238,
-0.01824292726814747,
0.2789607644081116,
-0.0814400166273117,
-0.016329454258084297,
-0.8042936325073242,
-0.07748063653707504,
-0.3477441668510437,
-0.27912911772727966,
-0.2743475139141083,
-0.6785522103309631,
0.7178046703338623,
0.025690404698252678,
0.14801470935344696,
0.2838464081287384,
-0.38579902052879333,
0.3438035547733307,
0.6457569599151611,
0.47130444645881653,
0.24454966187477112,
0.041191183030605316,
-0.2373441755771637,
-0.04419439658522606,
-0.962090015411377,
-0.28174683451652527,
0.9969351887702942,
0.3565428555011749,
0.5005207657814026,
-0.15138989686965942,
0.5709782838821411,
-0.014254463836550713,
0.21441592276096344,
-0.8600496053695679,
0.47360721230506897,
-0.09973444789648056,
-0.8485066890716553,
-0.4892740845680237,
-0.545458972454071,
-0.5838863849639893,
0.9935905337333679,
-0.38469430804252625,
-0.5850381851196289,
0.5513023138046265,
0.16365058720111847,
-0.5694873929023743,
0.12455081939697266,
-0.9064857363700867,
0.9471418261528015,
0.05339641124010086,
-0.12365026772022247,
-0.6514235734939575,
-0.6482747197151184,
0.48698198795318604,
-0.48170197010040283,
0.6382334232330322,
-0.3061286509037018,
-0.25143349170684814,
0.8301756978034973,
-0.37637653946876526,
0.5973946452140808,
-0.169291689991951,
0.13131989538669586,
0.36868593096733093,
-0.18869055807590485,
0.34017837047576904,
-0.09196154028177261,
-0.1639976054430008,
0.14234080910682678,
-0.05909503623843193,
-0.6151608824729919,
-0.664967954158783,
0.5882800221443176,
-0.8670490980148315,
-0.44222337007522583,
0.15821154415607452,
-0.8174275755882263,
-0.48105135560035706,
0.39426836371421814,
0.030575411394238472,
0.406034916639328,
0.2700551152229309,
0.3077608346939087,
0.4586384892463684,
0.13724371790885925,
0.03473377972841263,
0.29401642084121704,
0.2595337927341461,
-0.6408993601799011,
1.0516548156738281,
0.234409898519516,
0.24172498285770416,
0.21301819384098053,
0.5008989572525024,
0.09479857236146927,
-0.3456193208694458,
-0.5267486572265625,
0.20948143303394318,
-0.5432454943656921,
0.0007560253725387156,
-1.0454785823822021,
0.4482457935810089,
-0.48457714915275574,
-0.09669716656208038,
-0.46837833523750305,
-0.30978119373321533,
-0.3112362325191498,
0.04385227710008621,
0.08627810329198837,
0.26208752393722534,
-0.0375102274119854,
0.830764889717102,
-0.6513194441795349,
0.4853038787841797,
0.6292334198951721,
-0.012818050570786,
0.2827354967594147,
-0.34246522188186646,
-0.4190830588340759,
0.19643600285053253,
-0.26423418521881104,
-1.0159868001937866,
0.23384864628314972,
0.18795599043369293,
0.8536780476570129,
0.724990963935852,
-0.1592620313167572,
1.2130249738693237,
-0.6729293465614319,
0.37861761450767517,
0.24432943761348724,
-0.9055019617080688,
0.11126405745744705,
-0.5326813459396362,
-0.09064755588769913,
0.7727090120315552,
0.3877227008342743,
-0.06759024411439896,
-0.663639485836029,
-0.45195186138153076,
-0.8288813829421997,
0.5525587797164917,
0.030836230143904686,
0.07428814470767975,
0.0225315410643816,
0.13147208094596863,
0.5949968099594116,
0.7343536019325256,
-0.4665309190750122,
-0.13659930229187012,
-0.050951484590768814,
-0.24626858532428741,
0.21097387373447418,
-0.31686604022979736,
-0.1498688906431198,
-0.43158379197120667,
0.7245306968688965,
-0.3269454836845398,
0.3510586619377136,
-0.054901786148548126,
-0.2029629349708557,
-0.22447611391544342,
0.07088983803987503,
0.534302830696106,
0.9403753876686096,
-0.09566836804151535,
0.003052814630791545,
0.19980627298355103,
-0.24973461031913757,
-0.2000138908624649,
0.09638859331607819,
0.1019638180732727,
-0.04645213857293129,
0.25219395756721497,
0.6234579086303711,
0.7095156908035278,
-0.49836862087249756,
0.30148014426231384,
0.3656517565250397,
-0.38975048065185547,
0.37698233127593994,
0.14443270862102509,
-0.13043762743473053,
0.2093336582183838,
0.7027656435966492,
0.5105708837509155,
0.31200292706489563,
-0.4898485243320465,
0.45502451062202454,
0.3810133934020996,
0.041966717690229416,
-0.10648678243160248,
0.710084855556488,
0.48549893498420715,
0.23628097772598267,
0.19384045898914337,
-0.0658191591501236,
-0.38251757621765137,
0.3942554295063019,
0.09567274153232574,
0.6400471329689026,
-0.18861722946166992,
-0.18954698741436005,
-0.03484397009015083,
0.36748069524765015,
-0.10933469235897064,
0.15577715635299683,
-0.07210468500852585,
-0.8753953576087952,
-0.717067301273346,
-0.2776651382446289,
-0.4372372031211853,
-0.1654527485370636,
-0.7642830610275269,
0.24283263087272644,
-0.14381727576255798,
-0.3487587869167328,
0.17129333317279816,
-0.1893700510263443,
-0.804337739944458,
0.23458132147789001,
-0.03315971791744232,
0.674387514591217,
-0.8860683441162109,
0.6395902037620544,
0.6993498802185059,
-0.1797807663679123,
-0.4079020023345947,
-0.08022517710924149,
-0.06746114790439606,
-0.7723841667175293,
0.08826793730258942,
0.3900272846221924,
-0.16431888937950134,
0.08764318376779556,
-0.4583471715450287,
-0.6883192658424377,
0.9548683762550354,
0.40121376514434814,
-0.5144438147544861,
-0.16679278016090393,
-0.15872256457805634,
0.04855279251933098,
-0.507495641708374,
0.31636008620262146,
0.5909025073051453,
0.48399633169174194,
-0.015906604006886482,
-1.2193330526351929,
-0.28066322207450867,
0.0680629089474678,
-0.31518813967704773,
0.013598824851214886,
-0.6938889622688293,
1.1633312702178955,
0.0297040194272995,
0.11426644027233124,
-0.17155106365680695,
0.941421389579773,
0.5414169430732727,
0.18355706334114075,
0.8011304140090942,
0.5391307473182678,
0.8998318314552307,
0.34483101963996887,
0.6488465666770935,
-0.6711082458496094,
0.42009106278419495,
0.8565800786018372,
-0.12378565967082977,
0.851847767829895,
0.8098122477531433,
-0.07424162328243256,
0.5399383902549744,
0.33546414971351624,
0.433767169713974,
0.7282719612121582,
-0.29220864176750183,
-0.20076104998588562,
-0.5014955401420593,
-0.008572174236178398,
-0.24920666217803955,
0.344634085893631,
0.4977319538593292,
0.010516408830881119,
-0.024439001455903053,
0.2628328204154968,
-0.19184885919094086,
-0.269550085067749,
-0.427015095949173,
0.6653726100921631,
0.07407651841640472,
-0.5567338466644287,
0.0998564288020134,
0.3018117845058441,
0.9544335007667542,
-0.40521109104156494,
0.20785823464393616,
0.14128528535366058,
-0.062436457723379135,
-0.07968395948410034,
-0.3748611807823181,
0.18308886885643005,
-0.3962167501449585,
-0.2422746866941452,
-0.05724902078509331,
0.7265721559524536,
-0.785218358039856,
-0.7276722192764282,
0.04878073185682297,
0.8784236907958984,
0.2970733642578125,
-0.47461777925491333,
-0.6825041770935059,
-0.14494352042675018,
-0.37084057927131653,
-0.16728661954402924,
0.19959749281406403,
0.8567737936973572,
0.11144545674324036,
0.5529977083206177,
0.4492343068122864,
-0.015019283629953861,
0.40818116068840027,
-0.034760378301143646,
0.8449983596801758,
-0.3727497160434723,
-0.7047845721244812,
-0.7729654908180237,
0.7655975818634033,
-0.04221029207110405,
-0.2849861681461334,
0.5922897458076477,
0.2970867156982422,
0.801430344581604,
-0.2685566544532776,
0.749633252620697,
0.038814131170511246,
0.5009154677391052,
-0.3030998110771179,
0.46704015135765076,
-0.9408997893333435,
-0.26867735385894775,
-0.5751224160194397,
-0.71989905834198,
0.012196231633424759,
0.6680818796157837,
-0.020155595615506172,
0.20330709218978882,
0.47264233231544495,
0.5637599229812622,
-0.327758252620697,
-0.2091733068227768,
0.42624980211257935,
-0.04667002335190773,
0.058347661048173904,
0.43593811988830566,
0.3720931112766266,
-0.1854815036058426,
0.27086901664733887,
-0.5306136608123779,
-0.4729948937892914,
-0.38084688782691956,
-0.7127366065979004,
-1.0680558681488037,
-0.2906832993030548,
-0.4402196407318115,
0.3962933421134949,
-0.373111367225647,
1.1013911962509155,
1.2308272123336792,
-0.7780616879463196,
-0.22218912839889526,
0.1948273479938507,
0.012309432029724121,
-0.5423774719238281,
-0.20962993800640106,
0.054184433072805405,
-0.5075312256813049,
-0.8175279498100281,
0.48315930366516113,
0.45127072930336,
-0.31958669424057007,
-0.5968211889266968,
-0.022439781576395035,
0.057170938700437546,
0.21288084983825684,
0.8447803258895874,
-0.25546663999557495,
-0.9358543753623962,
-0.10778477787971497,
0.032665785402059555,
0.07692451030015945,
-0.037784822285175323,
0.7329159379005432,
-0.562399685382843,
0.5455706119537354,
0.41684481501579285,
1.032981276512146,
0.10372177511453629,
0.14015427231788635,
0.570509135723114,
-0.9961185455322266,
0.3966604471206665,
0.023032784461975098,
0.5753423571586609,
-0.016460850834846497,
-0.38973137736320496,
0.22245605289936066,
0.5770770311355591,
-0.3719633221626282,
-0.7943663597106934,
-0.16966110467910767,
-1.149662733078003,
-0.38520464301109314,
0.9880000352859497,
0.10456539690494537,
-0.07354094088077545,
-0.13408125936985016,
-0.2318047285079956,
0.03158758953213692,
-0.635719895362854,
0.6386123299598694,
1.0077428817749023,
-0.129394993185997,
-0.2586793899536133,
-0.8023145794868469,
-0.029917791485786438,
0.5870630741119385,
-0.6288729906082153,
-0.26455268263816833,
0.29567447304725647,
0.1787927895784378,
0.3415137529373169,
0.6152093410491943,
0.2545334994792938,
0.18034173548221588,
0.17012998461723328,
-0.07866770029067993,
-0.16308605670928955,
-0.7963221669197083,
0.1298782080411911,
0.15212030708789825,
-0.14726091921329498,
-0.4173756539821625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15004v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15004v2
|
TAXI: Evaluating Categorical Knowledge Editing for Language Models
| 2024-04-23T13:09:11 | 2024-06-06T13:46:36 |
Derek Powell, Walter Gerych, Thomas Hartvigsen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Humans rarely learn one fact in isolation. Instead, learning a new fact
induces knowledge of other facts about the world. For example, in learning a
korat is a type of cat, you also infer it is a mammal and has claws, ensuring
your model of the world is consistent. Knowledge editing aims to inject new
facts into language models to improve their factuality, but current benchmarks
fail to evaluate consistency, which is critical to ensure efficient, accurate,
and generalizable edits. We manually create TAXI, a new benchmark dataset
specifically created to evaluate consistency in categorical knowledge edits.
TAXI contains 11,120 multiple-choice queries for 976 edits spanning 41
categories (e.g., Dogs), 164 subjects (e.g., Labrador), and 183 properties
(e.g., is a mammal). We then use TAXI to evaluate popular editors' categorical
consistency, measuring how often editing a subject's category appropriately
edits its properties. We find that 1) the editors achieve marginal, yet
non-random consistency, 2) their consistency far underperforms human baselines,
and 3) consistency is more achievable when editing atypical subjects Our code
and data are available at https://github.com/derekpowell/taxi.
|
[
-0.24883206188678741,
-0.4678223431110382,
0.3659482002258301,
0.40230104327201843,
-0.25308817625045776,
0.2644464075565338,
-0.3250845670700073,
-0.5699803829193115,
0.2165517359972,
0.5085564851760864,
-0.13453054428100586,
-0.7785205245018005,
-0.2725162208080292,
0.19593389332294464,
-0.28556835651397705,
1.0729503631591797,
0.14033398032188416,
-0.0019021915504708886,
-0.5173968076705933,
-0.5763309001922607,
-0.6056663393974304,
-0.6952565908432007,
-0.5834229588508606,
0.14317217469215393,
0.6102691292762756,
0.540014922618866,
1.0951203107833862,
1.0740689039230347,
0.5351101756095886,
0.26122960448265076,
-0.2932299077510834,
0.34331825375556946,
-0.2925019860267639,
-0.14825798571109772,
-0.36803585290908813,
-0.3617318868637085,
-0.34889721870422363,
-0.30493488907814026,
0.6450666189193726,
0.6817899942398071,
-0.5348938703536987,
0.1584649682044983,
0.012514271773397923,
0.7253300547599792,
-1.0963574647903442,
-0.03177233040332794,
-0.683857262134552,
-0.1881914734840393,
-0.19660794734954834,
0.3160358667373657,
-0.23085841536521912,
-0.9071091413497925,
-0.06396780163049698,
-0.8757067322731018,
0.3657064139842987,
0.2400638461112976,
0.7677428126335144,
0.598040759563446,
-0.5404664278030396,
-0.5872753858566284,
-0.5330044031143188,
0.5056520104408264,
-0.2520905137062073,
0.8393221497535706,
0.6969357132911682,
0.11035720258951187,
-0.29957616329193115,
-0.7125493288040161,
-0.6339418888092041,
-0.2825562059879303,
-0.07784074544906616,
-0.17280972003936768,
-0.20031772553920746,
-0.00973998848348856,
0.23480910062789917,
0.12304864823818207,
-0.38555967807769775,
0.024709731340408325,
-0.23979181051254272,
-0.4338078498840332,
0.7344602346420288,
0.4330122470855713,
0.3245784044265747,
-0.20733791589736938,
-0.25035855174064636,
-0.26264721155166626,
-0.7455471754074097,
0.5323271155357361,
0.5123287439346313,
-0.09803201258182526,
0.3069629669189453,
0.5664265751838684,
-0.2657851278781891,
0.9018040895462036,
-0.1151747927069664,
-0.20458394289016724,
0.3188936710357666,
-0.49103084206581116,
-0.12026107311248779,
0.18491514027118683,
0.8138580322265625,
0.5635769963264465,
0.037544120103120804,
-0.34316286444664,
-0.14592258632183075,
-0.08210378140211105,
0.29604360461235046,
-0.4074046015739441,
-0.3049396574497223,
0.0942864790558815,
-0.07830186188220978,
-0.26955118775367737,
-0.14458926022052765,
-0.5895399451255798,
-0.8311716914176941,
-0.0636560246348381,
0.24578462541103363,
-0.47773662209510803,
0.0005415409104898572,
0.7584659457206726,
-0.34032583236694336,
0.16926820576190948,
0.3800939619541168,
-0.7722613215446472,
0.11907193064689636,
0.5554667711257935,
0.5657645463943481,
-0.002380467252805829,
-0.5961393713951111,
-0.44544273614883423,
0.09386272728443146,
-0.583268404006958,
1.106015682220459,
-0.6499590873718262,
-0.5265055894851685,
-0.22360552847385406,
-0.0026706214994192123,
0.0746752917766571,
-0.5810924172401428,
0.8403996825218201,
-0.36372989416122437,
-0.26134973764419556,
-0.9586408138275146,
-0.37930530309677124,
-0.31202977895736694,
0.26984551548957825,
-0.678170919418335,
1.2392657995224,
-0.16269634664058685,
-0.7355269193649292,
0.9824674129486084,
-0.5108603835105896,
-0.44307586550712585,
-0.38425567746162415,
0.24438369274139404,
-0.6849565505981445,
0.0008985878666862845,
0.38145923614501953,
0.15505251288414001,
-0.11262289434671402,
0.712906002998352,
-0.4080657958984375,
-0.4282898008823395,
0.3112511932849884,
0.06289949268102646,
1.0286200046539307,
-0.06123462691903114,
0.2598629593849182,
0.11346644908189774,
-0.8216079473495483,
-0.24029551446437836,
-0.17295342683792114,
-0.557114839553833,
-0.6762891411781311,
0.2817731201648712,
-0.09563378244638443,
0.17005106806755066,
0.29500195384025574,
-0.7832158207893372,
0.8135747313499451,
-0.13424615561962128,
0.40844276547431946,
0.5834716558456421,
0.2927325665950775,
0.06915506720542908,
-0.5822040438652039,
0.42139285802841187,
0.08931632339954376,
0.3849155902862549,
0.4340258836746216,
-0.5645672678947449,
-0.9199549555778503,
-0.2720779776573181,
0.6280763149261475,
0.4138868749141693,
-0.6424173712730408,
0.17250148952007294,
-0.3177650272846222,
-0.7748475670814514,
-0.837134599685669,
0.22492080926895142,
0.35055333375930786,
0.2608491778373718,
0.1453569531440735,
-0.5534716844558716,
-0.9424582719802856,
-0.9947670102119446,
-0.6557656526565552,
-0.391043096780777,
0.2978982925415039,
0.09377079457044601,
0.617416501045227,
-0.18877990543842316,
1.1778087615966797,
-0.4887309670448303,
-0.058680109679698944,
0.13029351830482483,
0.18787190318107605,
-0.32219332456588745,
0.6726926565170288,
0.5966824293136597,
-0.3239082396030426,
-0.1572488248348236,
-0.04151558503508568,
-0.5295728445053101,
0.1605023592710495,
0.013843945227563381,
-0.47565579414367676,
-0.11008433997631073,
0.3519445061683655,
-0.4421723186969757,
0.35638749599456787,
0.1725570559501648,
-0.35820165276527405,
0.5707898139953613,
-0.1519210934638977,
0.21995407342910767,
-0.7652230262756348,
0.11745353788137436,
-0.24477910995483398,
-0.3320605456829071,
-0.2993994951248169,
-0.20179668068885803,
0.03382715582847595,
0.14445948600769043,
-0.48848676681518555,
0.4951736032962799,
-0.2328634113073349,
-0.2566554546356201,
0.26378780603408813,
0.02472282387316227,
0.022232700139284134,
0.6843717098236084,
0.021966276690363884,
0.9548572897911072,
0.4621725380420685,
-0.6748164892196655,
0.04355463758111,
0.4339806139469147,
-0.8751345872879028,
0.31614020466804504,
-0.38731464743614197,
0.6704349517822266,
-0.22948351502418518,
-0.022939996793866158,
-0.9695250988006592,
-0.16598783433437347,
0.13460855185985565,
-0.25319692492485046,
-0.3761371672153473,
-0.006681547965854406,
-0.8425742387771606,
0.06736519187688828,
-0.36253437399864197,
0.265996515750885,
0.32146862149238586,
-0.4331829845905304,
0.29135221242904663,
0.7456125617027283,
0.09293068945407867,
-0.8184607028961182,
-0.41443371772766113,
0.1410219371318817,
-0.01956157013773918,
-0.28750190138816833,
-0.11591412872076035,
-0.20310501754283905,
-0.25135159492492676,
0.2937466502189636,
-0.07111068069934845,
-0.5555955171585083,
0.2571040391921997,
0.14834614098072052,
0.07525262981653214,
-0.0132070854306221,
0.3215470314025879,
0.17400719225406647,
0.2416103184223175,
-0.047737184911966324,
-0.013258530758321285,
0.032871946692466736,
-0.13004949688911438,
-0.16348306834697723,
-0.2893410921096802,
-0.16579996049404144,
0.6490777730941772,
-0.4824584126472473,
0.6321046948432922,
0.46777498722076416,
-0.24794802069664001,
0.05629931762814522,
-0.5324264764785767,
0.20228828489780426,
-0.39656132459640503,
0.4885807931423187,
-0.4769686758518219,
-0.7558368444442749,
0.6120200157165527,
0.14803330600261688,
0.2889004349708557,
0.38721463084220886,
0.3315272927284241,
-0.03549111261963844,
1.1644967794418335,
0.739142894744873,
-0.004622551612555981,
0.28911611437797546,
0.04419178515672684,
-0.13584518432617188,
-0.7249788045883179,
-0.4337441325187683,
-0.7833861708641052,
-0.12303490936756134,
-0.696731448173523,
-0.36581385135650635,
0.41043394804000854,
0.28770941495895386,
-0.24732168018817902,
0.2578688859939575,
-0.6126118302345276,
0.7363387942314148,
0.5281448364257812,
0.22190438210964203,
0.7271965742111206,
-0.24322187900543213,
-0.15402927994728088,
0.0039192200638353825,
-0.9771279096603394,
-0.3527422547340393,
1.1915581226348877,
-0.00154221395496279,
0.5683094263076782,
0.2198195904493332,
0.21447637677192688,
0.4756248891353607,
0.7229967713356018,
-0.7464144825935364,
0.5365403890609741,
-0.18774323165416718,
-0.7626845240592957,
-0.2545199990272522,
-0.1188170462846756,
-0.8743979334831238,
0.012306463904678822,
-0.3089512884616852,
-0.4637409746646881,
0.686957061290741,
0.37032389640808105,
-0.36130818724632263,
0.4026270806789398,
-0.5329471826553345,
0.8322882056236267,
-0.10636002570390701,
-0.4242599606513977,
-0.11469490081071854,
-0.5084567666053772,
0.5534740090370178,
-0.21977075934410095,
0.2613941729068756,
-0.07633765041828156,
-0.24428324401378632,
1.0482491254806519,
-0.5752691626548767,
0.8214725852012634,
-0.04335686191916466,
0.14598257839679718,
0.3939659893512726,
0.19428981840610504,
0.3817063868045807,
0.026082878932356834,
-0.2864217758178711,
0.2792971134185791,
0.25067606568336487,
-0.2891935706138611,
-0.7980141043663025,
0.20859681069850922,
-0.8596067428588867,
-0.41017818450927734,
-0.3093719482421875,
-0.4457511305809021,
-0.40869399905204773,
0.04672455042600632,
0.10093288868665695,
0.45379236340522766,
-0.172348290681839,
0.28552573919296265,
0.20968219637870789,
-0.2290927767753601,
0.11658546328544617,
0.7184199094772339,
-0.4241020679473877,
-0.6886316537857056,
0.8996986150741577,
0.17967356741428375,
-0.03736181557178497,
0.22806839644908905,
0.30443859100341797,
-0.48282521963119507,
-0.4294207990169525,
-0.5914949178695679,
0.08073215931653976,
-0.8310610055923462,
-0.12153778970241547,
-0.7047867774963379,
0.08917254209518433,
-0.08621761202812195,
-0.14772742986679077,
-0.522761881351471,
-0.4533800482749939,
0.3716886043548584,
0.0022772701922804117,
0.5978308320045471,
1.2789418697357178,
-0.24012672901153564,
0.2325821965932846,
-0.5115769505500793,
-0.030875828117132187,
0.4662513732910156,
0.5873691439628601,
-0.08507024496793747,
-0.26072609424591064,
-0.5649787783622742,
-0.002827300922945142,
-0.18595179915428162,
-0.8809724450111389,
-0.07626106590032578,
0.030342038720846176,
0.3785385191440582,
0.18796955049037933,
0.01744125969707966,
1.1765085458755493,
-0.15313012897968292,
0.5905513763427734,
-0.10723274946212769,
-1.3166594505310059,
0.4305550456047058,
-0.09370642900466919,
0.026948289945721626,
0.907779335975647,
0.18459844589233398,
-0.7050009965896606,
-0.595003604888916,
-0.4335620105266571,
-0.21708008646965027,
0.597460925579071,
0.23460790514945984,
-0.3557981252670288,
0.05100094899535179,
0.530304491519928,
0.15952616930007935,
0.6330627202987671,
-0.47831058502197266,
-0.2194272130727768,
-0.3336606025695801,
-0.013841511681675911,
-0.14691272377967834,
-0.43604373931884766,
0.31209367513656616,
-0.7605141401290894,
0.6672053337097168,
0.22249972820281982,
-0.21428056061267853,
0.39072129130363464,
-0.06762896478176117,
0.034504182636737823,
0.3774329125881195,
0.8735882043838501,
0.7430447936058044,
-0.3580625057220459,
0.11704093217849731,
0.35276490449905396,
-0.8499202728271484,
0.2482827752828598,
-0.41299423575401306,
-0.1024039089679718,
0.10271105915307999,
0.4568825960159302,
0.8181416988372803,
0.398307204246521,
-0.7781791090965271,
0.3239939510822296,
-0.16290004551410675,
-0.23442700505256653,
-0.008662935346364975,
0.2718184292316437,
-0.0013436081353574991,
-0.3246415853500366,
-0.32175299525260925,
0.4308212101459503,
0.2575063109397888,
-0.4037927985191345,
0.08354146778583527,
0.17999614775180817,
-0.46773624420166016,
-0.33715254068374634,
0.7308673858642578,
0.09097856283187866,
-0.33403733372688293,
0.7183421850204468,
-0.6183728575706482,
-0.4993841052055359,
0.5740620493888855,
0.13840587437152863,
0.8278690576553345,
-0.32297152280807495,
0.06704109162092209,
0.59676593542099,
0.710239052772522,
-0.23131448030471802,
0.37857964634895325,
-0.11829188466072083,
-1.0367810726165771,
-0.5193662047386169,
-0.6145100593566895,
-0.6385373473167419,
0.10050024092197418,
-0.7167023420333862,
0.589165985584259,
-0.3501451909542084,
-0.15721304714679718,
-0.010679476894438267,
-0.13300259411334991,
-0.7553750276565552,
0.11078992486000061,
-0.6258705854415894,
0.8150901794433594,
-0.8887003064155579,
1.0521955490112305,
1.294724702835083,
-0.4283660352230072,
-1.0678801536560059,
-0.1440742015838623,
-0.289266437292099,
-0.8423393368721008,
0.4115496277809143,
-0.19432130455970764,
-0.21031270921230316,
0.05458757281303406,
-0.7283406257629395,
-0.7372251152992249,
0.5798647999763489,
0.6659492254257202,
-0.642103910446167,
0.055440742522478104,
0.17049401998519897,
0.5191301107406616,
-0.08147284388542175,
-0.024421511217951775,
0.6666415333747864,
0.5529099106788635,
-0.09413280338048935,
-1.0065404176712036,
-0.19497419893741608,
-0.10812610387802124,
-0.21060609817504883,
0.1833120882511139,
-0.510769248008728,
0.6663254499435425,
-0.33427461981773376,
-0.11959825456142426,
-0.2603839039802551,
0.1605752557516098,
0.24219910800457,
0.3257322311401367,
0.9222288727760315,
0.7732198238372803,
1.0823891162872314,
0.1547975242137909,
0.9375369548797607,
-0.35559672117233276,
0.5196862816810608,
1.1681076288223267,
-0.18057624995708466,
0.8135160207748413,
0.2365303337574005,
-0.18733221292495728,
0.7044278979301453,
0.6964958310127258,
0.12986911833286285,
0.5032935738563538,
0.013872417621314526,
-0.041969574987888336,
-0.5892183184623718,
-0.3095373213291168,
-0.04490754008293152,
0.9333086609840393,
0.03817775100469589,
0.097694531083107,
-0.09481755644083023,
0.20399926602840424,
0.20461252331733704,
-0.13806794583797455,
-0.2836817800998688,
0.9375280737876892,
-0.4449290335178375,
-0.8458812832832336,
0.6997027397155762,
-0.016999032348394394,
0.01164903212338686,
-0.19114835560321808,
-0.1355590671300888,
-0.1408255398273468,
-0.1812533289194107,
-0.1905195564031601,
-1.0218424797058105,
0.5278711915016174,
0.21234028041362762,
-0.27616989612579346,
0.05275706946849823,
0.41246429085731506,
-0.3505888879299164,
-0.5610305666923523,
-0.17171671986579895,
0.44024741649627686,
0.34810641407966614,
-0.02920648828148842,
-0.5314633846282959,
0.3236064314842224,
0.2662416696548462,
0.08151232451200485,
-0.14444005489349365,
0.3924514353275299,
-0.33120208978652954,
0.8567953109741211,
0.7710884809494019,
0.10577687621116638,
-0.026744648814201355,
-0.13963079452514648,
0.6290566921234131,
-0.8704367876052856,
-0.6489340662956238,
-1.0046178102493286,
0.6188585162162781,
0.12672357261180878,
-0.7072953581809998,
0.662200927734375,
1.0189543962478638,
0.6514759063720703,
-0.012828661128878593,
0.7582458853721619,
0.09199413657188416,
0.2571372091770172,
-0.5982352495193481,
0.6474177837371826,
-0.7148919105529785,
0.2839077115058899,
-0.0633217990398407,
-0.5349879264831543,
-0.23284466564655304,
0.33677247166633606,
-0.4396916925907135,
-0.3707194924354553,
0.6941375732421875,
0.915283739566803,
-0.04509174823760986,
0.07324640452861786,
0.29351288080215454,
0.30650800466537476,
0.05186429247260094,
0.4110279381275177,
1.1184782981872559,
-0.2469765841960907,
0.5199692249298096,
-0.5443825721740723,
0.30305084586143494,
-0.026718562468886375,
-0.8001856207847595,
-0.9112502336502075,
-0.804969847202301,
-0.39089256525039673,
-0.2341737300157547,
0.40276968479156494,
0.8161095380783081,
0.812819242477417,
-0.5032170414924622,
-0.28776514530181885,
-0.23352386057376862,
0.7067249417304993,
-0.36561113595962524,
-0.17119799554347992,
0.4828014075756073,
-0.13673950731754303,
-0.4868859350681305,
-0.02021143212914467,
0.21740007400512695,
-0.3427419662475586,
-0.21104560792446136,
0.18230178952217102,
0.04791006073355675,
0.03799897059798241,
0.34633782505989075,
0.1270892471075058,
-0.6438897252082825,
-0.45694801211357117,
-0.0420662984251976,
-0.29127225279808044,
0.4200288653373718,
0.8900399804115295,
-0.9274893999099731,
0.7982763648033142,
0.25338810682296753,
0.5578394532203674,
0.18005555868148804,
0.11412150412797928,
0.25410225987434387,
-0.5960639119148254,
0.1815027892589569,
-0.008292265236377716,
0.2694665491580963,
0.4685617983341217,
-0.3942147493362427,
0.40374845266342163,
0.42490801215171814,
-0.7457244396209717,
-0.9574552774429321,
-0.08778323978185654,
-0.8792087435722351,
0.007915866561233997,
0.7680405378341675,
0.15974190831184387,
-0.439314067363739,
-0.5478718280792236,
-0.43377411365509033,
0.2526323199272156,
-0.43639954924583435,
0.731371283531189,
0.8301730155944824,
-0.21753402054309845,
0.07758898288011551,
-0.7727421522140503,
0.8730891942977905,
0.23127499222755432,
-0.7933835387229919,
0.07452129572629929,
0.41231998801231384,
0.7222826480865479,
-0.04666336625814438,
0.7431235313415527,
0.26072999835014343,
0.462836354970932,
-0.0307142473757267,
0.6512547731399536,
-0.12124506384134293,
-0.25080394744873047,
-0.2279295027256012,
0.088951475918293,
0.3611226975917816,
-0.3518374264240265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15003v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15003v1
|
Comparison of Current Approaches to Lemmatization: A Case Study in Estonian
| 2024-04-23T13:06:32 | 2024-04-23T13:06:32 |
Aleksei Dorkin, Kairit Sirts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study evaluates three different lemmatization approaches to Estonian --
Generative character-level models, Pattern-based word-level classification
models, and rule-based morphological analysis. According to our experiments, a
significantly smaller Generative model consistently outperforms the
Pattern-based classification model based on EstBERT. Additionally, we observe a
relatively small overlap in errors made by all three models, indicating that an
ensemble of different approaches could lead to improvements.
|
[
-0.29503944516181946,
-1.3238353729248047,
0.6812430620193481,
-0.025214357301592827,
-0.43631601333618164,
-0.1353043168783188,
-0.1547696441411972,
-0.6126877069473267,
0.24775844812393188,
0.31183767318725586,
-0.1313551366329193,
-0.8530217409133911,
-0.6966343522071838,
0.4052712321281433,
-0.47034311294555664,
0.21537359058856964,
-0.21258999407291412,
0.7269947528839111,
-0.3550044000148773,
-0.012779506854712963,
-0.488479882478714,
-1.0439941883087158,
-1.004625916481018,
-0.1476522982120514,
0.2319367378950119,
0.33630257844924927,
0.36928725242614746,
0.41407445073127747,
0.5303818583488464,
0.2735622823238373,
-0.5838624238967896,
-0.1407947987318039,
0.14575958251953125,
0.2242002785205841,
0.27128222584724426,
-0.7958843111991882,
-0.27160754799842834,
-0.1300416886806488,
0.5786760449409485,
0.4294683635234833,
-0.29161182045936584,
-0.060815997421741486,
-0.13256850838661194,
0.5389729738235474,
-0.7818312048912048,
-0.19828194379806519,
-0.1367967277765274,
0.3885781168937683,
-0.27974292635917664,
0.13605275750160217,
-0.4574224650859833,
-0.44649943709373474,
-0.06653020530939102,
-0.2912769615650177,
0.3671959936618805,
-0.17031370103359222,
0.8668122291564941,
0.12006653845310211,
-0.2962040603160858,
-0.5668609142303467,
-0.6622594594955444,
0.887174665927887,
-1.0324522256851196,
0.5990472435951233,
0.5513793230056763,
0.3469952642917633,
0.3546806275844574,
-0.5661994218826294,
-0.27654898166656494,
-0.3330940902233124,
-0.16845571994781494,
0.2528645694255829,
-0.3903656005859375,
-0.053965311497449875,
0.1861143559217453,
0.38759294152259827,
-0.37425121665000916,
0.5851801633834839,
-0.48309826850891113,
-0.2509748935699463,
0.4363560676574707,
-0.03865664079785347,
0.26856184005737305,
-0.3214722275733948,
-0.1500944346189499,
0.046873703598976135,
-0.7790710926055908,
-0.27051398158073425,
0.6304146647453308,
0.2771323323249817,
-0.03644802048802376,
0.6907600164413452,
-0.17924007773399353,
0.6396140456199646,
0.10082123428583145,
0.03513017296791077,
0.2281104326248169,
-0.12443726509809494,
-0.41753387451171875,
0.09845404326915741,
0.29877349734306335,
0.38534030318260193,
0.027059581130743027,
0.04797317460179329,
-0.43088793754577637,
0.1736248880624771,
0.06931301951408386,
-0.5476720929145813,
-0.02703818865120411,
0.3321513235569,
-0.9231847524642944,
-0.3677760660648346,
-0.09569378197193146,
-0.7136262655258179,
-0.1710018664598465,
-0.3150952160358429,
0.6766232848167419,
-0.8146231770515442,
-0.18817615509033203,
-0.02407422848045826,
-0.051636211574077606,
0.5501142740249634,
0.647506833076477,
-0.9713905453681946,
0.41647133231163025,
0.928883969783783,
1.4394572973251343,
-0.2171860635280609,
0.06962917000055313,
-0.3688714802265167,
-0.1361682116985321,
-0.610268771648407,
1.0020382404327393,
-0.7020370364189148,
-0.6284743547439575,
0.1367463618516922,
-0.16255809366703033,
-0.13768799602985382,
-0.7731514573097229,
0.555988609790802,
-0.10187193006277084,
0.42201128602027893,
-0.04466729983687401,
-0.9513169527053833,
-0.3043585419654846,
-0.004678666591644287,
-0.597696840763092,
1.1491018533706665,
0.2765258550643921,
-0.7291399836540222,
0.5109508037567139,
-0.7181993126869202,
-0.25458163022994995,
0.057090919464826584,
-0.22289372980594635,
-0.4692448675632477,
0.5067065954208374,
0.06438131630420685,
0.8163037896156311,
-0.04263008013367653,
-0.3028247058391571,
0.06710508465766907,
-0.454507976770401,
-0.1431257128715515,
-0.14699967205524445,
0.8649029731750488,
0.4759114980697632,
-0.24065038561820984,
0.09891621023416519,
-0.7710474133491516,
-0.2132190316915512,
0.05350852757692337,
-0.27671682834625244,
-0.7688891887664795,
0.03836658224463463,
-0.0523713119328022,
-0.026385892182588577,
0.24489465355873108,
-0.5533115863800049,
0.16261357069015503,
-0.2017206996679306,
0.4182395339012146,
0.6660414934158325,
0.06418870389461517,
0.45341041684150696,
-0.32449546456336975,
0.6938735842704773,
0.10443899035453796,
0.18270766735076904,
-0.19426217675209045,
-0.6543616056442261,
-1.3144220113754272,
-0.3896297514438629,
0.9452850222587585,
0.6329426765441895,
-0.4667154550552368,
0.32550808787345886,
0.140682652592659,
-0.5946447849273682,
-0.3182617127895355,
-0.37746456265449524,
0.5005005598068237,
0.22239355742931366,
0.29432085156440735,
-0.6140159368515015,
-0.525124192237854,
-1.068711757659912,
-0.15493373572826385,
-0.3492718040943146,
0.02239823527634144,
0.0000752058913349174,
0.75815749168396,
0.05263719707727432,
0.2521718442440033,
-0.1947426050901413,
-0.24869681894779205,
-0.06036635488271713,
0.365896075963974,
0.11220080405473709,
0.48415765166282654,
0.91595858335495,
-0.528002142906189,
-0.6880196928977966,
0.374275267124176,
-0.5635716319084167,
-0.07084376364946365,
0.579855740070343,
0.1083867996931076,
0.7789329290390015,
0.8183107972145081,
-0.2854110598564148,
0.7823031544685364,
0.29462552070617676,
-0.46442747116088867,
0.5183864235877991,
-0.21109740436077118,
0.3511714041233063,
-1.1409821510314941,
-0.4960920214653015,
-0.015224004164338112,
-0.3910466134548187,
-0.8645986914634705,
0.3584393560886383,
0.09978240728378296,
0.18111680448055267,
-0.6632483005523682,
0.2285335659980774,
-0.5975267291069031,
-0.25877317786216736,
0.06139301136136055,
-0.35673362016677856,
-0.4015229046344757,
0.24955835938453674,
0.17271369695663452,
0.6874724626541138,
0.7158405184745789,
-0.4110722541809082,
0.2576626241207123,
0.2290181666612625,
-0.5105612277984619,
0.9024267792701721,
-0.44031310081481934,
0.16420027613639832,
-0.32881441712379456,
-0.2899450361728668,
-0.9407104253768921,
-0.2700861394405365,
0.1442507654428482,
-0.47344139218330383,
0.32146355509757996,
-0.5735923647880554,
-0.6385513544082642,
-0.005837221629917622,
-0.39885953068733215,
-0.07250798493623734,
1.0204097032546997,
-0.359334260225296,
0.8897755146026611,
0.10660628974437714,
-0.4738091230392456,
-0.21800367534160614,
-0.7655682563781738,
-0.058856599032878876,
-0.7597657442092896,
-0.2909926772117615,
0.2942172884941101,
-0.12792032957077026,
-0.8833862543106079,
-0.04603470861911774,
0.018139678984880447,
-0.14948096871376038,
0.23581215739250183,
0.052735067903995514,
-0.04804666340351105,
-0.3301957845687866,
0.059226930141448975,
0.04117096588015556,
0.22614909708499908,
-0.24498364329338074,
0.043467286974191666,
0.8395326137542725,
-0.16735173761844635,
-0.33283254504203796,
-0.48574545979499817,
0.6420321464538574,
0.34671881794929504,
-0.016545524820685387,
0.697123110294342,
0.32116174697875977,
-0.6356850266456604,
-0.06346742808818817,
-0.6660239696502686,
0.10637792944908142,
-0.3963510990142822,
0.11108607053756714,
-0.4200480580329895,
-0.7616606950759888,
0.5161066055297852,
0.16954545676708221,
-0.024123230949044228,
0.6385977268218994,
0.7379050254821777,
-0.3687199652194977,
0.999683678150177,
0.7185789346694946,
0.4043024480342865,
0.5460854768753052,
-0.16750600934028625,
-0.1676371693611145,
-0.5990819931030273,
-0.19525296986103058,
-0.9444318413734436,
-0.029218928888440132,
-0.6482070088386536,
-0.3988148868083954,
0.26134276390075684,
0.3963371515274048,
0.0452570877969265,
0.48379406332969666,
-0.35302647948265076,
0.4745105803012848,
0.5854559540748596,
-0.06054991856217384,
0.2869642674922943,
0.33314049243927,
-0.49107298254966736,
0.058329299092292786,
-0.8448104858398438,
-0.9808327555656433,
1.0113255977630615,
0.3304019570350647,
0.5998137593269348,
0.6161171793937683,
1.1211053133010864,
0.5680030584335327,
0.5195056200027466,
-1.0245822668075562,
0.3945254385471344,
-0.4695398211479187,
-0.3933088183403015,
-0.48853254318237305,
-0.2198977917432785,
-0.9436963200569153,
0.5840813517570496,
-0.37565329670906067,
-1.001327395439148,
0.37431496381759644,
0.19476540386676788,
-0.12282948940992355,
0.43346792459487915,
-1.153964638710022,
0.6290856599807739,
-0.12881097197532654,
-0.00004443255238584243,
-0.12248653918504715,
-0.23735226690769196,
0.0768718495965004,
-0.26635923981666565,
0.5126076936721802,
-0.13253666460514069,
-0.1346709281206131,
0.8367508053779602,
-0.4688885807991028,
0.7822290062904358,
-0.05650646612048149,
-0.5121887922286987,
0.2164667695760727,
0.17571628093719482,
0.21874330937862396,
-0.27033481001853943,
-0.321391761302948,
0.3017401397228241,
0.2708722949028015,
-0.4520126283168793,
-0.3847058415412903,
0.5391908288002014,
-0.7933835983276367,
-0.7570057511329651,
-0.44794830679893494,
0.05410688742995262,
-0.1493905782699585,
0.08019313961267471,
0.6030780673027039,
0.4474036395549774,
-0.5630534887313843,
0.06063133105635643,
0.4789336919784546,
-0.24984265863895416,
0.7934687733650208,
0.5339500904083252,
-0.15216794610023499,
-0.4326156973838806,
0.5307139754295349,
0.28706303238868713,
0.23436476290225983,
0.6191808581352234,
0.15946020185947418,
-0.08471733331680298,
-0.8705676198005676,
-0.28969889879226685,
0.010974476113915443,
-0.9952113032341003,
-0.006470955442637205,
-0.5762066841125488,
-0.1607953906059265,
-0.6410452127456665,
-0.038828909397125244,
-0.22306907176971436,
-0.734741747379303,
-0.3297547698020935,
-0.07256095111370087,
0.4036790430545807,
0.9964230060577393,
-0.12125346809625626,
0.548639178276062,
-0.5065578818321228,
0.009007250890135765,
0.29298174381256104,
0.19998817145824432,
-0.15908439457416534,
-0.3920043110847473,
-0.1557692289352417,
-0.2907755970954895,
-0.31276053190231323,
-1.372111201286316,
0.4382483959197998,
0.14972074329853058,
0.536027729511261,
0.21813784539699554,
-0.6249019503593445,
0.4720216989517212,
-0.7268818020820618,
1.0233409404754639,
0.3480333387851715,
-1.1661165952682495,
0.6695879697799683,
-0.18864797055721283,
0.06390278786420822,
0.26010966300964355,
0.4216654300689697,
-0.5746310353279114,
-0.3185478448867798,
-0.8712790608406067,
-0.8821780681610107,
0.3880090117454529,
0.4925192892551422,
-0.05486539378762245,
-0.04110784828662872,
0.5117089748382568,
0.44390153884887695,
0.12522350251674652,
-0.4177547097206116,
-0.26335611939430237,
-0.018796222284436226,
-0.23424720764160156,
-0.11554518342018127,
-0.382640540599823,
0.21421435475349426,
-0.2036387026309967,
0.7424796223640442,
0.16150793433189392,
0.4982354938983917,
0.24737153947353363,
-0.544024646282196,
0.006839745678007603,
0.5399823188781738,
0.927447497844696,
0.7905912399291992,
-0.19947922229766846,
0.2104939967393875,
0.523229718208313,
-0.47488176822662354,
0.2821277976036072,
-0.0706777423620224,
-0.4376987814903259,
0.5185261368751526,
0.7625676393508911,
0.7860150933265686,
-0.14859019219875336,
-0.24609874188899994,
0.5334571003913879,
-0.14832843840122223,
-0.5495434999465942,
-0.5660829544067383,
0.055203139781951904,
-0.032418593764305115,
0.20433402061462402,
0.29392510652542114,
-0.15444152057170868,
0.22522251307964325,
-0.64777672290802,
-0.07543008774518967,
0.35430988669395447,
-0.32727599143981934,
-0.32489946484565735,
0.4133571982383728,
0.08532591909170151,
-0.7408761978149414,
0.03170374035835266,
0.15024276077747345,
-0.4255591630935669,
0.9169615507125854,
0.4631233811378479,
0.8503531813621521,
-0.6584904193878174,
0.31606242060661316,
0.39971479773521423,
0.22298790514469147,
-0.08403871208429337,
0.5315233469009399,
-0.022822191938757896,
-0.6352351903915405,
-0.3737396001815796,
-0.620529294013977,
-0.5084651112556458,
0.29452797770500183,
-0.8559365272521973,
0.4287557005882263,
-0.41826674342155457,
-0.26397794485092163,
0.36864563822746277,
-0.15278279781341553,
-0.6276178359985352,
0.1427125483751297,
0.03905954957008362,
0.939821720123291,
-0.7954078912734985,
0.44323375821113586,
1.0995231866836548,
-0.3150770962238312,
-0.2951684296131134,
0.008683624677360058,
-0.11331266164779663,
-0.6342193484306335,
0.6845774054527283,
0.10101454704999924,
-0.07086020708084106,
-0.02796407788991928,
-0.5296844244003296,
-0.7434998750686646,
0.9770176410675049,
0.20088404417037964,
-0.7486776113510132,
0.07564302533864975,
-0.2493203729391098,
0.6109938025474548,
-0.2997727394104004,
0.06935897469520569,
0.6468703746795654,
0.3844635784626007,
-0.2973174452781677,
-1.0577398538589478,
-0.48934412002563477,
-0.3267369270324707,
0.11187809705734253,
0.3362865447998047,
-0.7000101208686829,
1.0277899503707886,
0.1723702996969223,
-0.5372657179832458,
0.6254732012748718,
0.6046556234359741,
0.08079840987920761,
0.07819865643978119,
0.5253355503082275,
0.677628755569458,
0.6935272216796875,
-0.23809535801410675,
1.0633729696273804,
-0.05929369479417801,
0.5373921990394592,
0.6648131012916565,
-0.11027343571186066,
1.044912338256836,
0.5574409365653992,
-0.39052248001098633,
0.5782759189605713,
1.0408326387405396,
-0.07522811740636826,
0.5038302540779114,
0.2814233899116516,
-0.2819361686706543,
-0.1904533952474594,
-0.015536187216639519,
-0.355499267578125,
0.4960215091705322,
0.3954029381275177,
-0.2817225754261017,
-0.11308541148900986,
-0.01291442196816206,
-0.08085981011390686,
0.10810251533985138,
-0.5939996242523193,
0.9780111908912659,
-0.0024533304385840893,
-0.3675324320793152,
0.5848689079284668,
0.37310487031936646,
0.7845969200134277,
-0.1943739801645279,
-0.35697048902511597,
-0.34523525834083557,
-0.16877469420433044,
-0.0036668700631707907,
-0.45555248856544495,
0.18479865789413452,
0.3058219850063324,
0.25208935141563416,
-0.1455298662185669,
0.6968891024589539,
-0.20535066723823547,
-0.6889647245407104,
-0.011032299138605595,
0.8129956126213074,
0.41783207654953003,
0.5498477816581726,
-0.41729527711868286,
-0.032927196472883224,
-0.33244597911834717,
-0.007195618003606796,
-0.13988563418388367,
0.2537899911403656,
-0.35597848892211914,
0.5153851509094238,
0.1994408667087555,
0.23341122269630432,
0.21558839082717896,
0.32392510771751404,
0.2452843338251114,
-0.7245036959648132,
-0.7648346424102783,
-0.9752758145332336,
0.08009699732065201,
-0.039044760167598724,
-0.20804435014724731,
0.9246719479560852,
0.5758642554283142,
0.9962793588638306,
-0.2689438760280609,
0.8220351338386536,
0.07534614950418472,
0.45441219210624695,
-1.1125060319900513,
0.20572301745414734,
-0.627473771572113,
0.13797488808631897,
-0.40672236680984497,
-1.083491325378418,
-0.5116390585899353,
0.9546667337417603,
-0.10453718900680542,
0.22103376686573029,
0.9443581104278564,
0.4336201548576355,
0.004006201401352882,
-0.06528932601213455,
0.693289041519165,
0.2718173563480377,
-0.1480294167995453,
0.1860882192850113,
1.4808781147003174,
-0.12624989449977875,
-0.14806769788265228,
-0.17513160407543182,
-0.009601830504834652,
-0.2841530442237854,
-0.8676049709320068,
-0.982725203037262,
-0.8011505603790283,
-0.2748284339904785,
-0.1870611608028412,
0.3870229423046112,
0.7475293874740601,
0.7107150554656982,
-0.9189854860305786,
-0.12722213566303253,
-0.16625608503818512,
0.04610418528318405,
-0.20611554384231567,
-0.21146893501281738,
0.4597298502922058,
-0.07645721733570099,
-1.0166174173355103,
0.18511460721492767,
0.24939949810504913,
0.6886805891990662,
-0.18791379034519196,
0.1283075213432312,
0.03450101986527443,
0.24329780042171478,
0.7349309921264648,
-0.2722688913345337,
-0.975033164024353,
-0.36200273036956787,
-0.02768530324101448,
0.10653775185346603,
0.36553749442100525,
0.8576667904853821,
-0.3150204122066498,
0.09350290894508362,
0.5080103874206543,
0.11293783038854599,
0.6768829226493835,
-0.05681183561682701,
0.47872763872146606,
-0.7259084582328796,
0.20973840355873108,
0.060342755168676376,
0.689007580280304,
0.586144208908081,
-0.40233713388442993,
0.8188394904136658,
0.09930325299501419,
-0.046127885580062866,
-0.713687539100647,
0.500059962272644,
-0.6479932069778442,
-0.7089247107505798,
1.2117518186569214,
-0.05732368305325508,
-0.40084195137023926,
-0.01926317624747753,
-0.3071691393852234,
0.2638736963272095,
-0.14192646741867065,
0.5946336388587952,
1.210598111152649,
-0.37735506892204285,
-0.2487458735704422,
-0.6915816068649292,
0.43255433440208435,
0.37265709042549133,
-0.8699243664741516,
-0.3291259706020355,
0.60986328125,
0.411578506231308,
0.3049921691417694,
0.5441864132881165,
-0.3088659942150116,
0.232696533203125,
-0.17324970662593842,
0.06981940567493439,
0.31241750717163086,
-0.17417442798614502,
-0.8106116652488708,
0.025741389021277428,
0.3287174701690674,
0.07076244056224823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14994v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14994v3
|
Transformers Can Represent $n$-gram Language Models
| 2024-04-23T12:51:37 | 2024-06-20T15:21:23 |
Anej Svete, Ryan Cotterell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CC, cs.FL, cs.LG
|
Existing work has analyzed the representational capacity of the transformer
architecture by means of formal models of computation. However, the focus so
far has been on analyzing the architecture in terms of language
\emph{acceptance}. We contend that this is an ill-suited problem in the study
of \emph{language models} (LMs), which are definitionally \emph{probability
distributions} over strings. In this paper, we focus on the relationship
between transformer LMs and $n$-gram LMs, a simple and historically relevant
class of language models. We show that transformer LMs using the hard or sparse
attention mechanisms can exactly represent any $n$-gram LM, giving us a
concrete lower bound on their probabilistic representational capacity. This
provides a first step towards understanding the mechanisms that transformer LMs
can use to represent probability distributions over strings.
|
[
-0.45649954676628113,
-0.36352622509002686,
0.8544479608535767,
0.11605526506900787,
-0.04720912501215935,
-0.2211117297410965,
-0.379786878824234,
-0.3769843876361847,
0.13082344830036163,
0.44554823637008667,
-0.2637864053249359,
-0.02158788964152336,
-0.8658645749092102,
0.2793636918067932,
-0.8449747562408447,
0.864012598991394,
0.013917805626988411,
-0.2179207056760788,
-0.061952073127031326,
-0.027972877025604248,
-0.04869244247674942,
-0.384874552488327,
-0.26746034622192383,
-0.4706997871398926,
0.6273754239082336,
0.05741008371114731,
0.9497230648994446,
0.2617344856262207,
0.826389491558075,
0.31591764092445374,
-0.12218794226646423,
-0.5541900396347046,
-0.32010897994041443,
-0.01814453862607479,
0.1337980479001999,
-0.676452100276947,
-0.37161821126937866,
0.15630772709846497,
0.9126384854316711,
0.8974890112876892,
-0.1675693392753601,
0.1360781490802765,
0.13519169390201569,
0.5387799739837646,
-0.4318448305130005,
0.19987726211547852,
-0.7543887495994568,
0.09911106526851654,
-0.31773892045021057,
-0.06733987480401993,
-1.0346747636795044,
-0.1616636961698532,
0.03165839985013008,
-0.42931118607521057,
0.3380134701728821,
0.05179395526647568,
0.7558888792991638,
0.024635901674628258,
-0.391672819852829,
-0.23374608159065247,
-1.0499353408813477,
0.7095759510993958,
-0.4117700159549713,
0.5217763781547546,
0.2919984757900238,
0.6276460886001587,
-0.06644387543201447,
-0.48241928219795227,
-0.6022078990936279,
-0.35121920704841614,
-0.4996720552444458,
-0.10157497972249985,
-0.5570409893989563,
0.1824222058057785,
0.4677903354167938,
0.6375824809074402,
-0.294373482465744,
0.061189036816358566,
-0.44290587306022644,
-0.11190999299287796,
0.3226383924484253,
0.12065102159976959,
0.4064417779445648,
-0.27301597595214844,
-0.2671658992767334,
-0.09726584702730179,
-0.5463191866874695,
-0.14555025100708008,
0.20387348532676697,
0.3049485981464386,
-0.20161402225494385,
0.7690412998199463,
0.34328195452690125,
0.9297300577163696,
0.1554132103919983,
-0.016961636021733284,
0.08405537903308868,
-0.027965836226940155,
-0.363294780254364,
0.01897118240594864,
0.7691355347633362,
-0.08217241615056992,
0.7037692070007324,
-0.39259880781173706,
-0.27057507634162903,
0.17684894800186157,
0.7178775668144226,
-0.49860504269599915,
0.18385528028011322,
-0.10976513475179672,
-0.5389292240142822,
-0.12104441225528717,
0.22779721021652222,
-0.6380508542060852,
-0.25826993584632874,
-0.05380924791097641,
0.46188971400260925,
-0.5027176737785339,
-0.30802419781684875,
0.33286210894584656,
-0.10292991250753403,
0.39094603061676025,
-0.14011654257774353,
-1.2505931854248047,
0.6413205862045288,
0.7076958417892456,
0.7229729890823364,
0.16126056015491486,
0.08079827576875687,
-0.06345939636230469,
0.21415536105632782,
-0.2779204547405243,
0.6872426867485046,
-0.7356715798377991,
-0.18185150623321533,
0.2642170488834381,
0.154362753033638,
-0.21451134979724884,
-0.39447686076164246,
0.8118603229522705,
-0.715701162815094,
-0.05397419258952141,
0.1606469750404358,
-0.790791928768158,
-0.1322689950466156,
-0.09358949214220047,
-0.9294009208679199,
0.5457178354263306,
0.2590663731098175,
-0.6730562448501587,
0.25594544410705566,
-0.43598365783691406,
-0.27899184823036194,
0.025613024830818176,
-0.23134413361549377,
-0.2656497359275818,
0.7036182284355164,
-0.1407812088727951,
0.4850272536277771,
-0.26740214228630066,
0.2751123607158661,
-0.2936538755893707,
-0.6186987161636353,
0.5472549200057983,
-0.8298172950744629,
0.5780243277549744,
0.23786309361457825,
-0.0665191188454628,
-0.17174451053142548,
-0.7290369272232056,
-0.2914210855960846,
0.2049291878938675,
-0.447832852602005,
-0.37357228994369507,
0.11233317852020264,
0.07697828114032745,
0.07025771588087082,
0.19624115526676178,
-0.5919634103775024,
0.26360172033309937,
-0.6806948781013489,
0.5538367629051208,
0.5119956731796265,
-0.5978854298591614,
0.9473099112510681,
-0.10376327484846115,
0.5645571351051331,
-0.06716583669185638,
0.02317650429904461,
-0.30054721236228943,
-0.5289766788482666,
-0.9162033200263977,
0.06898265331983566,
0.44585946202278137,
0.2479700893163681,
-0.3680008351802826,
0.16868862509727478,
-0.38774386048316956,
-0.4593501091003418,
-0.7437269687652588,
-0.18464148044586182,
-0.070969358086586,
-0.10879570245742798,
0.16119979321956635,
-0.1233823150396347,
-0.5037800073623657,
-1.2125723361968994,
-0.33223357796669006,
-0.16613227128982544,
-0.4369889795780182,
0.21614223718643188,
0.11077006161212921,
-0.09713481366634369,
0.956473171710968,
-0.4345604479312897,
-0.44633036851882935,
-0.5369039177894592,
0.009063497185707092,
0.6466220021247864,
0.08886977285146713,
0.7866689562797546,
-0.7256984114646912,
-0.31513819098472595,
0.010819836519658566,
-0.5050889849662781,
0.07148337364196777,
-0.03260744363069534,
0.14638806879520416,
0.23797816038131714,
0.35255274176597595,
-0.8209521174430847,
0.44778770208358765,
0.7539600729942322,
-0.22664541006088257,
0.28164538741111755,
-0.41207894682884216,
-0.23779596388339996,
-0.8834705948829651,
-0.19549192488193512,
0.18257953226566315,
-0.17210137844085693,
-0.8146225214004517,
0.06030873954296112,
0.279497891664505,
-0.2391996681690216,
-0.4515393376350403,
0.3358359634876251,
-0.4815116822719574,
-0.4309852719306946,
-0.24220769107341766,
0.23628170788288116,
-0.23984400928020477,
0.3863694369792938,
0.12814153730869293,
0.5497737526893616,
0.6829343438148499,
-0.5597917437553406,
-0.08151838183403015,
0.078221395611763,
-0.4235883355140686,
0.5184549689292908,
-0.7848060131072998,
-0.2927462160587311,
-0.3439157009124756,
0.259505033493042,
-1.1428732872009277,
-0.23771969974040985,
0.3474141061306,
-0.21100196242332458,
0.32055097818374634,
-0.22806310653686523,
-0.6240105628967285,
-0.4271490275859833,
0.13826224207878113,
0.5188099145889282,
0.8367851972579956,
-0.3172818124294281,
0.7626434564590454,
0.40678688883781433,
0.15334253013134003,
-0.14362064003944397,
-0.7026566863059998,
-0.03306681290268898,
-0.1972956657409668,
-0.569606363773346,
0.3114556670188904,
0.2757013142108917,
-0.3898111581802368,
0.03404736891388893,
-0.013235190883278847,
0.0023467286955565214,
-0.02337046153843403,
0.2909778654575348,
-0.007806144654750824,
-0.3364908993244171,
0.39484500885009766,
-0.3480371832847595,
-0.5724839568138123,
0.17205679416656494,
-0.19708983600139618,
0.5530192255973816,
-0.08652875572443008,
-0.5948573350906372,
-0.17922431230545044,
0.32041576504707336,
0.48933136463165283,
-0.07139935344457626,
0.8345592617988586,
0.4638688266277313,
-0.4286288917064667,
0.03714914992451668,
-0.3331136405467987,
-0.2756614685058594,
-0.5074241757392883,
0.055708322674036026,
-0.4527139961719513,
-0.8795509338378906,
0.36032241582870483,
0.26747408509254456,
-0.06395908445119858,
0.7344100475311279,
0.47399792075157166,
-0.20905528962612152,
1.0362306833267212,
0.7234116196632385,
-0.024633273482322693,
0.45750588178634644,
0.048072125762701035,
0.5308083295822144,
-0.7944101095199585,
0.1748122125864029,
-0.6692692637443542,
-0.5016209483146667,
-0.9896390438079834,
-0.6157652139663696,
0.16953246295452118,
-0.026988355442881584,
-0.27643200755119324,
0.626823365688324,
-0.4750232398509979,
0.4608050584793091,
0.44906315207481384,
-0.27800098061561584,
0.22774918377399445,
0.18177787959575653,
0.06212383508682251,
-0.18763220310211182,
-0.7996188402175903,
-0.9156712293624878,
0.8920180201530457,
0.6722997426986694,
1.0346121788024902,
0.2305053174495697,
0.5588480830192566,
0.023810159415006638,
0.42050373554229736,
-0.8946957588195801,
0.6374335885047913,
-0.51136714220047,
-0.6472048759460449,
-0.10009732097387314,
-0.37384897470474243,
-1.1872131824493408,
0.21917803585529327,
-0.022218475118279457,
-0.918923556804657,
0.2761668562889099,
-0.08059202134609222,
-0.1687893271446228,
0.6144343614578247,
-0.7280433177947998,
0.6988658308982849,
0.1862611025571823,
0.36036697030067444,
-0.07135357707738876,
-0.32920026779174805,
0.4982704222202301,
0.033312518149614334,
0.35841596126556396,
-0.08002704381942749,
0.05910059064626694,
0.606481671333313,
0.018874041736125946,
0.8714269995689392,
0.16510671377182007,
-0.5424181818962097,
0.43326109647750854,
0.44520819187164307,
0.5565492510795593,
-0.1748751550912857,
-0.08926399797201157,
0.18041500449180603,
-0.2409943789243698,
-0.25779202580451965,
-0.6303203701972961,
0.466423898935318,
-0.6165146827697754,
-0.7114905714988708,
-0.3930174708366394,
-0.6579694151878357,
0.07159896939992905,
-0.07852748781442642,
0.12212230265140533,
0.4717528522014618,
0.034446924924850464,
0.32650336623191833,
0.6303272247314453,
-0.23348267376422882,
0.5574382543563843,
0.3925677537918091,
-0.37617745995521545,
0.19920730590820312,
0.874446451663971,
0.36542263627052307,
0.5774051547050476,
0.5601491928100586,
0.05032113566994667,
-0.22821208834648132,
-0.2798302173614502,
-0.27607864141464233,
0.14475329220294952,
-0.706491231918335,
0.1674404889345169,
-0.7886215448379517,
-0.44279202818870544,
-0.03854842111468315,
-0.03176048398017883,
-0.024403328076004982,
-0.4541051983833313,
-0.38428762555122375,
-0.1732601672410965,
0.33370649814605713,
0.9257037043571472,
0.032081395387649536,
0.6130725741386414,
-0.7792770862579346,
0.5902571082115173,
0.37241384387016296,
0.8412439823150635,
0.18365533649921417,
-0.7105405926704407,
-0.05518246814608574,
-0.0203012153506279,
-0.34925195574760437,
-1.1782578229904175,
0.14395752549171448,
0.17855608463287354,
0.6026836633682251,
0.6227818727493286,
-0.2114596664905548,
0.1875840276479721,
-0.8889208436012268,
0.6167854070663452,
0.06060522422194481,
-0.8474541902542114,
0.18070697784423828,
-0.36030012369155884,
0.2392929494380951,
0.01949004828929901,
0.4743708372116089,
-0.7491406798362732,
-0.8747419118881226,
-0.8511214256286621,
-0.6025368571281433,
0.8539690971374512,
0.41617071628570557,
0.6635562777519226,
-0.3187935948371887,
0.08646547049283981,
0.1043565571308136,
-0.0738246738910675,
-0.8923885226249695,
-0.4085017144680023,
0.03935718536376953,
-0.38233810663223267,
-0.42352765798568726,
-0.6362167596817017,
0.38496190309524536,
0.1667221486568451,
0.4058132469654083,
0.008874420076608658,
0.6866817474365234,
-0.2726067900657654,
-0.1691884696483612,
-0.06635786592960358,
0.7161818146705627,
0.6349086165428162,
0.2324410080909729,
-0.19095872342586517,
0.6624748110771179,
0.04597072675824165,
-0.44555163383483887,
0.4742700755596161,
-0.13175232708454132,
-0.17424693703651428,
0.22933697700500488,
0.36613428592681885,
0.8000748753547668,
0.6106645464897156,
-0.4048495888710022,
0.29728540778160095,
0.023353923112154007,
-0.053259458392858505,
-0.26002249121665955,
0.07968815416097641,
0.49366310238838196,
0.03371204063296318,
0.5107581615447998,
0.07062733173370361,
0.132588192820549,
-0.4593401253223419,
0.3712516725063324,
0.3976230323314667,
-0.7199907898902893,
-0.45450517535209656,
0.6853315234184265,
-0.13575032353401184,
-0.7012814879417419,
0.34389469027519226,
-0.32962995767593384,
-0.2857659161090851,
0.6116350889205933,
0.7553853988647461,
0.7676582336425781,
-0.1176159679889679,
0.5219138860702515,
0.4082185924053192,
0.47341060638427734,
-0.2706998586654663,
0.008288560435175896,
0.20607037842273712,
-0.7485055923461914,
-0.4518580436706543,
-0.9312509894371033,
-0.004484116565436125,
-0.14899218082427979,
-0.6312901973724365,
0.1677190214395523,
-0.09606395661830902,
-0.3154400885105133,
0.0475974939763546,
-0.6549785733222961,
-0.6741891503334045,
-0.1757267266511917,
0.45699408650398254,
0.8745474219322205,
-0.8531063795089722,
0.6344053149223328,
0.33195412158966064,
-0.3186214864253998,
-0.6786579489707947,
-0.008547752164304256,
-0.38416653871536255,
-0.9758902788162231,
0.8401639461517334,
0.24408970773220062,
0.19704701006412506,
0.007656198926270008,
-0.10195671766996384,
-1.016196608543396,
0.5302660465240479,
0.48678818345069885,
-0.9396640062332153,
0.20729708671569824,
0.6553695201873779,
0.7801796793937683,
-0.30907487869262695,
0.33530497550964355,
0.5775526762008667,
0.5958853363990784,
-0.22539003193378448,
-0.8628152012825012,
-0.03916391730308533,
0.18074825406074524,
0.1250854879617691,
0.7003605961799622,
-0.26942703127861023,
0.9130856394767761,
-0.2286982387304306,
-0.6774197220802307,
-0.0856916606426239,
0.6462715864181519,
0.1323770135641098,
-0.06314437836408615,
0.4929284453392029,
0.5442802906036377,
0.1471424400806427,
-0.3534093201160431,
1.5030438899993896,
-0.35519835352897644,
0.5903258323669434,
0.898647665977478,
-0.036251503974199295,
0.8721573352813721,
0.648510754108429,
-0.6795223951339722,
0.45816856622695923,
0.28702279925346375,
0.09592544287443161,
0.2872636318206787,
0.5262581706047058,
-0.08834006637334824,
-0.46605294942855835,
-0.19970040023326874,
-0.11984828114509583,
0.30625125765800476,
0.2506050169467926,
-0.6377621293067932,
-0.5820194482803345,
0.0022525230888277292,
-0.5174770355224609,
0.1475183665752411,
-0.4368234872817993,
0.6882196068763733,
0.3888486325740814,
-0.22034475207328796,
0.46304550766944885,
0.010089084506034851,
0.6645646095275879,
-0.43289849162101746,
0.14625240862369537,
0.019519248977303505,
0.009631832130253315,
-0.00857169646769762,
-1.181427001953125,
0.4769825041294098,
0.015532498247921467,
-0.3479604125022888,
-0.33092421293258667,
0.8954604864120483,
-0.4676714241504669,
-1.0536130666732788,
0.34074103832244873,
0.2947271168231964,
0.21963094174861908,
0.107035331428051,
-0.17789357900619507,
0.08259110897779465,
-0.4667958915233612,
-0.27249348163604736,
0.31740137934684753,
0.5464596152305603,
-0.07759315520524979,
0.6652336120605469,
0.17802436649799347,
-0.022568272426724434,
0.22319911420345306,
0.32389599084854126,
0.22748205065727234,
-0.6104493141174316,
-0.3185078501701355,
-1.0023921728134155,
0.3186189532279968,
0.3593914806842804,
0.2295881062746048,
0.6982811689376831,
0.10162387043237686,
0.6898799538612366,
-0.3384215533733368,
0.6376022100448608,
-0.04638060927391052,
0.13469579815864563,
-0.2630384862422943,
0.5817521810531616,
-0.4580923914909363,
0.11674853414297104,
-0.21468578279018402,
-1.1248279809951782,
-0.2912042438983917,
0.766075849533081,
-0.46325409412384033,
0.13029137253761292,
0.43338096141815186,
0.48336756229400635,
-0.3218638598918915,
0.047126781195402145,
0.5963433980941772,
0.219776913523674,
0.12885676324367523,
0.85617995262146,
0.9487403035163879,
-0.6281137466430664,
0.5800341367721558,
0.08156998455524445,
0.22547775506973267,
-0.4043765366077423,
-0.7129669785499573,
-0.6021421551704407,
-0.6668398380279541,
0.02222556248307228,
-0.026637094095349312,
-0.4707530438899994,
0.5883550643920898,
0.35226526856422424,
-0.6486399173736572,
-0.1764402687549591,
-0.1582985520362854,
0.36269283294677734,
-0.27903681993484497,
-0.2415437549352646,
0.18599344789981842,
-0.3717936873435974,
-0.7549035549163818,
0.05300258845090866,
0.36502835154533386,
0.4578664004802704,
-0.6726824045181274,
0.03814024478197098,
0.2341105192899704,
0.4100663363933563,
0.5949392914772034,
-0.11837819218635559,
-0.8623883128166199,
-0.4798009991645813,
0.18662528693675995,
-0.32126471400260925,
0.20295388996601105,
0.870499849319458,
-0.78664231300354,
0.06286660581827164,
0.55172199010849,
0.4796088635921478,
0.14228293299674988,
-0.4259709417819977,
0.6425914168357849,
-0.7830716371536255,
0.20069155097007751,
0.025955479592084885,
0.6190568208694458,
0.07666219770908356,
-0.05722419172525406,
0.2376570850610733,
-0.20698170363903046,
-0.29176703095436096,
-0.7914051413536072,
0.6142078638076782,
-0.9696862101554871,
-0.14761938154697418,
1.2521709203720093,
0.11677726358175278,
-0.39635133743286133,
-0.057296331971883774,
-0.19038671255111694,
0.09612584859132767,
-0.1296364814043045,
0.6409362554550171,
0.8998397588729858,
0.4039861857891083,
-0.39286476373672485,
-0.7296427488327026,
0.30804046988487244,
0.35565581917762756,
-0.2951454818248749,
0.14503082633018494,
0.035128090530633926,
0.073444664478302,
0.5520252585411072,
0.4774620532989502,
-0.07093342393636703,
-0.019449014216661453,
-0.039336223155260086,
0.0626482293009758,
0.40183237195014954,
-0.29577553272247314,
-0.4036414921283722,
0.5314595699310303,
0.10616584867238998,
0.1433301419019699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14989v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14989v1
|
A Reproducibility Study of PLAID
| 2024-04-23T12:46:53 | 2024-04-23T12:46:53 |
Sean MacAvaney, Nicola Tonellotto
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
The PLAID (Performance-optimized Late Interaction Driver) algorithm for
ColBERTv2 uses clustered term representations to retrieve and progressively
prune documents for final (exact) document scoring. In this paper, we reproduce
and fill in missing gaps from the original work. By studying the parameters
PLAID introduces, we find that its Pareto frontier is formed of a careful
balance among its three parameters; deviations beyond the suggested settings
can substantially increase latency without necessarily improving its
effectiveness. We then compare PLAID with an important baseline missing from
the paper: re-ranking a lexical system. We find that applying ColBERTv2 as a
re-ranker atop an initial pool of BM25 results provides better
efficiency-effectiveness trade-offs in low-latency settings. However,
re-ranking cannot reach peak effectiveness at higher latency settings due to
limitations in recall of lexical matching and provides a poor approximation of
an exhaustive ColBERTv2 search. We find that recently proposed modifications to
re-ranking that pull in the neighbors of top-scoring documents overcome this
limitation, providing a Pareto frontier across all operational points for
ColBERTv2 when evaluated using a well-annotated dataset. Curious about why
re-ranking methods are highly competitive with PLAID, we analyze the token
representation clusters PLAID uses for retrieval and find that most clusters
are predominantly aligned with a single token and vice versa. Given the
competitive trade-offs that re-ranking baselines exhibit, this work highlights
the importance of carefully selecting pertinent baselines when evaluating the
efficiency of retrieval engines.
|
[
-0.33948713541030884,
-0.7111376523971558,
0.5666038990020752,
0.2858425974845886,
-0.18893355131149292,
0.2331177294254303,
-0.3021901547908783,
-0.47170931100845337,
0.6413880586624146,
0.17247314751148224,
0.011791977100074291,
-0.19821391999721527,
-0.4501309096813202,
-0.14470408856868744,
-0.47610464692115784,
0.8025527000427246,
0.21834301948547363,
-0.4014483392238617,
-0.40099838376045227,
-0.11064351350069046,
-0.21387796103954315,
-0.23850105702877045,
-0.42023754119873047,
-0.3119960427284241,
0.8138108253479004,
0.6568486094474792,
0.860912024974823,
0.903725802898407,
0.7022057771682739,
0.33811700344085693,
-0.3693506121635437,
-0.2563934624195099,
-0.9564774036407471,
0.2824399769306183,
-0.1448259949684143,
-0.34408140182495117,
-0.47185617685317993,
0.4206317961215973,
0.9412174820899963,
0.764350175857544,
-0.38329094648361206,
-0.007681595627218485,
0.24753691256046295,
0.5652475953102112,
-0.934564471244812,
-0.27490395307540894,
-0.8481059074401855,
-0.02338762767612934,
-0.3961966335773468,
-0.19663020968437195,
-0.35840848088264465,
-0.5065159797668457,
-0.0006262510432861745,
-0.8837686777114868,
0.410621702671051,
0.26507076621055603,
0.9304926991462708,
0.08306686580181122,
-0.06185917183756828,
-0.38303062319755554,
-0.30340516567230225,
1.1560399532318115,
-0.07926217466592789,
0.49296075105667114,
0.4164687693119049,
0.2232615202665329,
-0.11022672802209854,
-1.0083770751953125,
-0.4413281977176666,
-0.3931037187576294,
-0.010634551756083965,
0.3405471444129944,
-0.26071295142173767,
-0.05763169005513191,
0.05742841213941574,
0.722898542881012,
-0.2962128221988678,
0.288465678691864,
-0.6351318359375,
-0.47254687547683716,
0.587645947933197,
0.28844940662384033,
-0.3359885513782501,
-0.18506520986557007,
-0.2941986918449402,
-0.33761048316955566,
-0.5929853320121765,
0.4705146849155426,
0.5972927212715149,
0.01036431547254324,
0.3161652684211731,
0.7953087687492371,
-0.4648478925228119,
0.7292882800102234,
0.16728536784648895,
0.14829809963703156,
0.27158159017562866,
-0.570920467376709,
-0.19956757128238678,
-0.09981697797775269,
0.6311604380607605,
0.4856649935245514,
-0.2803770899772644,
-0.3156767785549164,
-0.33530429005622864,
-0.08888162672519684,
0.5506052374839783,
-0.36416664719581604,
-0.21372102200984955,
0.18204350769519806,
-0.5490750074386597,
-0.556723415851593,
0.08233790099620819,
-1.0555968284606934,
-0.11161618679761887,
-0.35488009452819824,
0.1625877320766449,
-0.17067137360572815,
-0.20399947464466095,
-0.2680472731590271,
-0.3189636766910553,
0.6224907040596008,
0.402061402797699,
-0.6402868032455444,
0.44522860646247864,
1.0205823183059692,
1.0787787437438965,
-0.20883719623088837,
-0.39395639300346375,
-1.0645374059677124,
-0.36224690079689026,
-0.8657323122024536,
0.9277799129486084,
-0.8915481567382812,
-0.5782662630081177,
0.13993319869041443,
0.00928762461990118,
0.09469682723283768,
-0.7365689277648926,
0.7762543559074402,
-0.48603618144989014,
0.2799329459667206,
-0.7574814558029175,
-0.5723136067390442,
0.3265215754508972,
0.08655335754156113,
-0.5501807928085327,
1.268448829650879,
-0.11175220459699631,
-0.752887487411499,
0.425397664308548,
0.03562228009104729,
-0.33714768290519714,
-0.006672064773738384,
0.07476633787155151,
-0.4594308137893677,
0.2553817927837372,
-0.3288800120353699,
0.47738632559776306,
-0.1098828837275505,
-0.0754024013876915,
-0.4689304232597351,
-0.7452839016914368,
-0.06486479938030243,
0.14761053025722504,
0.6127623915672302,
0.2696390450000763,
0.02361539751291275,
-0.057601094245910645,
-0.6308057308197021,
0.1900521218776703,
-0.38662582635879517,
-0.7556785941123962,
-0.27478182315826416,
0.04904377460479736,
0.3244883418083191,
-0.22305580973625183,
0.24787700176239014,
-0.7953436374664307,
-0.0661373883485794,
-0.15131807327270508,
0.402560293674469,
0.6796441078186035,
-0.3479223847389221,
0.6678692102432251,
-0.8060019016265869,
0.3453863561153412,
-0.40374183654785156,
-0.07606775313615799,
0.046969976276159286,
-0.6265574097633362,
-0.8036474585533142,
-0.2056119292974472,
0.26617127656936646,
0.6388464570045471,
-0.5881379842758179,
0.2737841010093689,
-0.2158290296792984,
-0.711520254611969,
-0.47191372513771057,
0.008669734001159668,
0.5862259268760681,
0.45304110646247864,
0.2775854170322418,
-0.2506263554096222,
-0.41334623098373413,
-1.0445501804351807,
-0.3320164382457733,
-0.1921710968017578,
0.2464839369058609,
0.3737790882587433,
0.27935436367988586,
-0.016629112884402275,
0.9919494986534119,
-0.3642250895500183,
-0.16945186257362366,
-0.16443337500095367,
0.18581326305866241,
0.17813639342784882,
0.5895245671272278,
0.12875822186470032,
-0.45053550601005554,
-0.1832512468099594,
0.20357853174209595,
-0.5182485580444336,
-0.14476993680000305,
0.060386668890714645,
0.07127214223146439,
0.18634548783302307,
0.8322218060493469,
0.032784730195999146,
0.32733842730522156,
0.2864767014980316,
0.02537675015628338,
0.7704797387123108,
-0.49764391779899597,
0.2103336900472641,
-0.7405238747596741,
0.3051832914352417,
-0.03065088577568531,
-0.42360278964042664,
-0.3203003704547882,
0.16562849283218384,
0.1525277942419052,
-0.12409930676221848,
-0.13862912356853485,
0.28147974610328674,
-0.31296876072883606,
-0.3867393136024475,
0.023303275927901268,
0.3752991855144501,
-0.01991548202931881,
0.20360027253627777,
-0.11255112290382385,
1.07559335231781,
0.23510177433490753,
-0.5386991500854492,
0.3912951350212097,
0.0315312035381794,
-0.5644918084144592,
0.7915666699409485,
-1.0098696947097778,
0.1317683458328247,
-0.1763988882303238,
-0.09833195060491562,
-1.1866875886917114,
-0.01578401029109955,
-0.17177718877792358,
-0.41584300994873047,
0.4014439880847931,
-0.04163556918501854,
-0.06900438666343689,
0.1282554268836975,
-0.6493163704872131,
0.34253981709480286,
0.7491429448127747,
-0.36043304204940796,
-0.11023805290460587,
0.5760856866836548,
-0.2145759016275406,
-0.8212483525276184,
-0.5084760189056396,
0.1806967705488205,
-0.1465924084186554,
-0.6766383647918701,
0.698819637298584,
0.33378079533576965,
-0.34076547622680664,
0.13050758838653564,
0.014283018186688423,
0.09730713069438934,
-0.11385638266801834,
-0.017508698627352715,
-0.17916090786457062,
-0.08673187345266342,
0.22847329080104828,
-0.03107414022088051,
-0.3096974492073059,
-0.22759957611560822,
-0.11344704031944275,
0.23725956678390503,
-0.2904375493526459,
0.17323437333106995,
-0.49800747632980347,
0.34465649724006653,
0.47058385610580444,
-0.07016861438751221,
0.2153845876455307,
0.569072425365448,
-0.19548426568508148,
0.10400454699993134,
-0.9344361424446106,
0.1813979595899582,
-0.44656938314437866,
0.4663080871105194,
-0.5069010257720947,
-0.7758496403694153,
0.6339146494865417,
0.04572026804089546,
0.01654226891696453,
0.4536450207233429,
0.37336835265159607,
-0.4698580205440521,
0.05772584304213524,
0.3900011479854584,
0.19444222748279572,
0.765759289264679,
-0.3767082691192627,
0.042808424681425095,
-1.3078832626342773,
-0.5677176117897034,
-0.7656696438789368,
-0.430107057094574,
-0.8686769008636475,
-0.3787917494773865,
0.2998355031013489,
0.23160552978515625,
0.012587880715727806,
0.49282538890838623,
-0.33770933747291565,
0.5457701086997986,
0.7722188830375671,
0.0940558984875679,
0.10709787160158157,
0.2769544720649719,
-0.3080675005912781,
-0.22732798755168915,
-0.8472616076469421,
-0.22296026349067688,
1.0664522647857666,
0.19319270551204681,
0.6823669075965881,
0.17097611725330353,
0.8738318085670471,
0.6325221061706543,
-0.09135560691356659,
-0.7187200784683228,
0.3939970135688782,
-0.2817156910896301,
-0.1530398428440094,
-0.4719080626964569,
-0.5065839886665344,
-1.284061312675476,
0.25413644313812256,
-0.29343658685684204,
-0.6635206341743469,
0.5743504762649536,
-0.008402922190725803,
-0.2979942262172699,
-0.05562875047326088,
-0.46722686290740967,
0.7046785950660706,
0.4638153314590454,
-1.1501542329788208,
-0.5044786334037781,
-0.28332459926605225,
0.16529008746147156,
0.22615931928157806,
0.08624880760908127,
0.17741155624389648,
-0.15604768693447113,
1.149374008178711,
-0.5947808027267456,
0.3286648094654083,
0.10462085157632828,
0.2352055460214615,
0.1543571799993515,
0.23730981349945068,
0.5680372714996338,
0.14409619569778442,
-0.15587037801742554,
0.043225694447755814,
0.13473454117774963,
-0.704240083694458,
-0.33401110768318176,
1.1751682758331299,
-0.7006794214248657,
-0.7677581310272217,
-0.6904575824737549,
-0.11949446052312851,
0.14050251245498657,
0.10364972800016403,
0.5520576238632202,
0.69263756275177,
-0.2655583620071411,
0.6299687623977661,
0.6251941323280334,
-0.1545795500278473,
0.5454025268554688,
-0.21974064409732819,
0.031528253108263016,
-0.6648898720741272,
1.0734797716140747,
0.3529728949069977,
0.2565767168998718,
0.4382030963897705,
0.22282418608665466,
-0.4873165488243103,
-0.5019130110740662,
-0.047534335404634476,
0.1918659508228302,
-0.6444960832595825,
0.03719698265194893,
-0.49768322706222534,
0.1833345890045166,
-0.2548049986362457,
-0.5896009206771851,
-0.5686224699020386,
-0.6413630843162537,
-0.19771790504455566,
0.09795107692480087,
-0.10261121392250061,
0.8773622512817383,
-0.4568781852722168,
0.3198431730270386,
-0.025236517190933228,
0.013091769069433212,
0.6078845262527466,
0.631825864315033,
-0.21120856702327728,
-0.4754607379436493,
-0.038960300385951996,
-0.16226060688495636,
-0.39621028304100037,
-0.7734770178794861,
-0.13901712000370026,
0.010441070422530174,
0.7294570803642273,
0.15278837084770203,
-0.27126023173332214,
0.7839277982711792,
-0.1423262655735016,
0.667102575302124,
0.24751730263233185,
-0.9922084808349609,
0.17203062772750854,
-0.32500314712524414,
-0.11044583469629288,
0.6342366933822632,
-0.12509678304195404,
-0.5976751446723938,
-0.12746979296207428,
-0.643973708152771,
-0.6489012837409973,
0.7274378538131714,
0.5739744901657104,
-0.12659688293933868,
-0.04677529260516167,
0.43292492628097534,
-0.0017334093572571874,
0.09623264521360397,
-0.17480792105197906,
0.09840943664312363,
-0.3784613311290741,
0.03895987197756767,
-0.09535546600818634,
-0.6936781406402588,
0.14949439465999603,
-0.038660530000925064,
0.5633757710456848,
0.25403735041618347,
0.3415062725543976,
0.6906766891479492,
-0.09226544201374054,
0.1251666247844696,
0.11799705773591995,
0.6314058303833008,
0.7739343047142029,
-0.4761199951171875,
0.15290801227092743,
-0.09403683245182037,
-0.6250565052032471,
-0.03839917853474617,
-0.1313866823911667,
0.09011580049991608,
0.05851051211357117,
0.7053435444831848,
0.2895231544971466,
0.3830060362815857,
-0.34455087780952454,
0.48383939266204834,
0.09985329210758209,
-0.1409965306520462,
-0.28301510214805603,
0.009969166480004787,
-0.23628312349319458,
0.10327675193548203,
0.2608693540096283,
0.13108322024345398,
0.2884189188480377,
-0.6230941414833069,
0.40896692872047424,
0.5869323015213013,
-0.5783442258834839,
-0.10697931051254272,
0.584445059299469,
0.3427754342556,
-0.5666483640670776,
0.6985210180282593,
-0.5206107497215271,
-0.33792492747306824,
0.7585027813911438,
0.028895745053887367,
0.5194860696792603,
-0.049546025693416595,
0.34642481803894043,
0.47567999362945557,
0.49490007758140564,
-0.26350244879722595,
0.23213616013526917,
-0.1635621041059494,
-0.3515344262123108,
-0.2612186372280121,
-0.4702205955982208,
-0.2097567915916443,
-0.12432631850242615,
-0.9959359765052795,
0.42042750120162964,
-0.49598461389541626,
-0.20660056173801422,
0.0068360320292413235,
0.3267722427845001,
-0.6538331508636475,
-0.16338062286376953,
-0.3694499135017395,
0.9583959579467773,
-0.5152397751808167,
0.5350416898727417,
0.6153236627578735,
-0.1873420625925064,
-0.15963394939899445,
-0.10295478254556656,
-0.2521458566188812,
-0.820247232913971,
0.3030908405780792,
-0.04271665960550308,
-0.06215885654091835,
-0.035294871777296066,
-0.10934468358755112,
-0.8602529168128967,
1.3026726245880127,
0.020525533705949783,
-0.6724936366081238,
0.3394014835357666,
-0.16832156479358673,
0.35979440808296204,
-0.18762218952178955,
0.3723551630973816,
0.4347047507762909,
0.09725936502218246,
0.36598658561706543,
-1.108770728111267,
-0.08147572726011276,
-0.18634431064128876,
0.22039856016635895,
0.1701190173625946,
-0.7810474038124084,
0.9053484797477722,
-0.3132452368736267,
-0.22529719769954681,
0.3566981852054596,
0.38212496042251587,
0.14987429976463318,
0.6629044413566589,
0.3444285988807678,
0.9007768630981445,
0.9872609376907349,
-0.23752379417419434,
1.184784173965454,
0.1196417286992073,
0.7881261110305786,
0.7419285178184509,
-0.14412182569503784,
1.0028181076049805,
0.6605284810066223,
-0.3628633916378021,
0.357012540102005,
0.767551064491272,
0.29372161626815796,
0.7604334950447083,
0.2461535632610321,
0.21657411754131317,
-0.43319371342658997,
-0.0992293581366539,
-0.5767723917961121,
0.42914602160453796,
0.13603544235229492,
-0.21391025185585022,
-0.22499673068523407,
-0.4873303472995758,
0.11464060842990875,
0.0893879383802414,
-0.20065851509571075,
0.7889423966407776,
-0.2738392949104309,
-0.7507161498069763,
0.6753833889961243,
0.03351399302482605,
0.3595084846019745,
-0.1771986335515976,
-0.0012685256078839302,
-0.7266987562179565,
0.1360437422990799,
-0.1497238278388977,
-0.8571115732192993,
0.49972331523895264,
-0.4248301386833191,
-0.23294220864772797,
-0.21267615258693695,
0.4157199561595917,
-0.3141844868659973,
-0.6655736565589905,
0.030187707394361496,
0.3894522786140442,
0.19881395995616913,
0.18030555546283722,
-0.4099222719669342,
0.3747089207172394,
-0.15614913403987885,
-0.1389138400554657,
0.22422794997692108,
0.2956773042678833,
0.02602575346827507,
0.47526293992996216,
0.6392557621002197,
0.019430899992585182,
0.0734788328409195,
-0.5750870108604431,
0.918424129486084,
-0.5764871835708618,
-0.7164905667304993,
-0.4861569106578827,
0.1898028403520584,
-0.3765842616558075,
-0.6035491228103638,
0.2848803400993347,
0.7810576558113098,
0.8434188365936279,
0.34303605556488037,
0.5857030153274536,
-0.15238291025161743,
0.322572261095047,
-0.6729809641838074,
0.46138155460357666,
-0.7094323039054871,
0.40409812331199646,
-0.11451218277215958,
-1.084007978439331,
-0.026832155883312225,
0.7458755970001221,
-0.34619390964508057,
-0.1275814324617386,
0.9549281597137451,
0.9598677754402161,
-0.2514086365699768,
-0.0359322652220726,
0.40804916620254517,
0.2843867838382721,
0.23208707571029663,
0.5223210453987122,
0.8183847069740295,
-0.4815027117729187,
0.4647504389286041,
-0.29392290115356445,
-0.49449795484542847,
-0.3818456530570984,
-0.8838602900505066,
-0.6219784021377563,
-0.8547043204307556,
-0.3022603690624237,
-0.5869624614715576,
0.37690919637680054,
0.44205036759376526,
0.6416609883308411,
-0.5308755040168762,
-0.316988468170166,
-0.030336108058691025,
0.4669313132762909,
-0.2988874614238739,
-0.21468563377857208,
0.41118794679641724,
-0.71958327293396,
-0.6305521726608276,
0.1492791473865509,
0.2526797950267792,
-0.5045871734619141,
-0.08936270326375961,
-0.1280142217874527,
-0.05903453007340431,
-0.2937852740287781,
0.3734641671180725,
0.2498474419116974,
-0.8478997349739075,
-0.27502983808517456,
0.34145450592041016,
0.010945524089038372,
-0.09038796275854111,
1.1884028911590576,
-1.039467215538025,
0.621427059173584,
0.7972888350486755,
0.673249363899231,
0.45034411549568176,
0.04275735467672348,
0.31171268224716187,
-0.4784533679485321,
0.1201828271150589,
0.09356293827295303,
0.41427814960479736,
0.3056531846523285,
-0.22240076959133148,
0.3826731741428375,
0.7153729796409607,
-0.684981107711792,
-0.7678645849227905,
0.07357202470302582,
-1.075576663017273,
-0.06466280668973923,
1.4269680976867676,
-0.07798542082309723,
-0.042568497359752655,
-0.3861037790775299,
-0.07215219736099243,
-0.2725642919540405,
-0.592642605304718,
0.9650415182113647,
0.7677415609359741,
0.07942605018615723,
-0.12592045962810516,
-0.2939282953739166,
0.5197088122367859,
0.44219210743904114,
-0.17232315242290497,
-0.036695633083581924,
0.2859534025192261,
0.22945226728916168,
0.33649200201034546,
0.6690654754638672,
0.09080994129180908,
0.34389638900756836,
0.1412183940410614,
-0.5050714015960693,
-0.26938024163246155,
-0.2641209661960602,
-0.28272607922554016,
0.4042222797870636,
-0.13236279785633087,
-0.38306519389152527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16880v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16880v1
|
Atomas: Hierarchical Alignment on Molecule-Text for Unified Molecule Understanding and Generation
| 2024-04-23T12:35:44 | 2024-04-23T12:35:44 |
Yikun Zhang, Geyan Ye, Chaohao Yuan, Bo Han, Long-Kai Huang, Jianhua Yao, Wei Liu, Yu Rong
|
q-bio.QM
|
q-bio.QM, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Molecule-and-text cross-modal representation learning has emerged as a
promising direction for enhancing the quality of molecular representation,
thereby improving performance in various scientific fields, including drug
discovery and materials science. Existing studies adopt a global alignment
approach to learn the knowledge from different modalities. These global
alignment approaches fail to capture fine-grained information, such as
molecular fragments and their corresponding textual description, which is
crucial for downstream tasks. Furthermore, it is incapable to model such
information using a similar global alignment strategy due to data scarcity of
paired local part annotated data from existing datasets. In this paper, we
propose Atomas, a multi-modal molecular representation learning framework to
jointly learn representations from SMILES string and text. We design a
Hierarchical Adaptive Alignment model to concurrently learn the fine-grained
fragment correspondence between two modalities and align these representations
of fragments in three levels. Additionally, Atomas's end-to-end training
framework incorporates the tasks of understanding and generating molecule,
thereby supporting a wider range of downstream tasks. In the retrieval task,
Atomas exhibits robust generalization ability and outperforms the baseline by
30.8% of recall@1 on average. In the generation task, Atomas achieves
state-of-the-art results in both molecule captioning task and molecule
generation task. Moreover, the visualization of the Hierarchical Adaptive
Alignment model further confirms the chemical significance of our approach. Our
codes can be found at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/Atomas-03C3.
|
[
0.0017527384916320443,
-0.5786235332489014,
0.6871935725212097,
-0.24309095740318298,
-0.36040404438972473,
0.3964601457118988,
-0.07466249912977219,
-0.3889387845993042,
0.2708966135978699,
0.07757741212844849,
-0.5456744432449341,
-0.5853354334831238,
-0.4977043867111206,
0.27027246356010437,
0.21194259822368622,
0.9410919547080994,
-0.0679989904165268,
0.24367579817771912,
-0.5550512671470642,
-0.12219158560037613,
-0.39675095677375793,
-0.16646307706832886,
-0.370942085981369,
-0.11906857043504715,
0.5550276041030884,
0.40208911895751953,
0.4812871813774109,
0.8194016814231873,
0.567573070526123,
0.4076557159423828,
0.029588855803012848,
0.2911604344844818,
-0.21117931604385376,
0.2733026444911957,
-0.3515510559082031,
-0.4012986421585083,
-0.7110002636909485,
-0.3601727783679962,
0.6096146702766418,
0.5540139675140381,
-0.034889500588178635,
-0.03989100828766823,
-0.12999597191810608,
0.41351553797721863,
-0.523268461227417,
0.05886875092983246,
-0.8227229118347168,
-0.012937699444591999,
-0.24746711552143097,
-0.23450250923633575,
-0.11973054707050323,
-0.0012867002515122294,
0.3730872869491577,
-1.0049000978469849,
0.04250481352210045,
0.17117859423160553,
0.9590726494789124,
-0.16692107915878296,
-0.9214563369750977,
-0.5373183488845825,
-0.31475743651390076,
0.899520993232727,
-0.48967722058296204,
0.25672152638435364,
-0.249256893992424,
0.42881491780281067,
-0.21789193153381348,
-0.5860731601715088,
-0.3876972198486328,
-0.14305754005908966,
0.08579356223344803,
0.25331178307533264,
-0.011994211003184319,
0.21164652705192566,
-0.46100929379463196,
0.6994181275367737,
-0.6557899713516235,
-0.22004228830337524,
-0.22007596492767334,
-0.429327130317688,
0.36007627844810486,
0.13787923753261566,
0.7075420618057251,
-0.3886524736881256,
-0.9295960664749146,
-0.20664922893047333,
-0.5383802652359009,
-0.11433131992816925,
-0.05100413039326668,
0.7681267261505127,
-0.09905543178319931,
0.5100550651550293,
0.2418961226940155,
0.53450608253479,
0.11580014228820801,
-0.08832493424415588,
0.40149664878845215,
-0.6515301465988159,
-0.33860212564468384,
0.2770079970359802,
0.8551779389381409,
0.09426023811101913,
-0.04686297848820686,
-0.07030961662530899,
-0.07160484045743942,
0.02473747543990612,
0.3710660934448242,
-0.9702278971672058,
0.11270900815725327,
0.25453799962997437,
-0.4170568287372589,
-0.016512777656316757,
0.14783991873264313,
-0.9611452221870422,
-0.31637322902679443,
-0.5095446705818176,
0.7960368990898132,
-0.6405340433120728,
-0.01692560315132141,
-0.1591089516878128,
-0.2582913637161255,
-0.35879087448120117,
0.2929072678089142,
-1.139042854309082,
0.22088760137557983,
0.4219526946544647,
0.9909700751304626,
-0.15600435435771942,
-0.42364373803138733,
-0.27178341150283813,
0.5623119473457336,
-0.2849249243736267,
0.7194212079048157,
-0.559453547000885,
-0.13944625854492188,
-0.22258701920509338,
-0.16791193187236786,
-0.2593674957752228,
-0.5897637605667114,
-0.20816583931446075,
-0.245474174618721,
0.20543313026428223,
-0.307729572057724,
-0.6063156723976135,
-0.32837581634521484,
-0.03379521146416664,
-0.4632141590118408,
0.6049896478652954,
0.3796268403530121,
-0.3447180390357971,
0.41076576709747314,
-0.4254005551338196,
-0.2693764865398407,
-0.2196773737668991,
-0.588634192943573,
-0.5841617584228516,
0.21751180291175842,
0.419430673122406,
0.33812105655670166,
-0.0915423110127449,
0.39125993847846985,
-0.15852363407611847,
0.021288076415657997,
0.24771910905838013,
-0.22994348406791687,
0.38468053936958313,
0.09937401115894318,
-0.4090340733528137,
0.594726026058197,
-0.891302764415741,
-0.36126068234443665,
-0.12772715091705322,
-0.2904263138771057,
-0.22408205270767212,
-0.17930720746517181,
0.26959753036499023,
0.365910142660141,
0.3329790234565735,
-0.5445698499679565,
0.5059040784835815,
-0.21241627633571625,
0.3153669834136963,
1.0050424337387085,
0.3366367518901825,
0.6110391020774841,
-0.278667688369751,
0.4769570529460907,
0.4892737865447998,
-0.15630337595939636,
-0.2624664008617401,
-0.2698642611503601,
-0.46615341305732727,
-0.35852643847465515,
0.320430189371109,
0.330439954996109,
-0.6177379488945007,
0.3678949475288391,
-0.4142759442329407,
-0.26062217354774475,
-0.22507014870643616,
0.47593966126441956,
0.5993147492408752,
0.3318578600883484,
0.6365614533424377,
-0.4949410855770111,
-0.5454010367393494,
-0.8737069368362427,
-0.21093055605888367,
-0.026227397844195366,
-0.1139860600233078,
0.14543034136295319,
0.6229252219200134,
-0.44289153814315796,
0.7070935368537903,
-0.11706314980983734,
-0.669341504573822,
-0.09923701733350754,
0.34682461619377136,
-0.35521480441093445,
0.6131439805030823,
0.33870455622673035,
-0.7862406969070435,
-0.16953273117542267,
0.4028800427913666,
-0.747115969657898,
0.35742565989494324,
-0.5526467561721802,
-0.515612006187439,
0.1808466613292694,
0.38166365027427673,
-0.5064113140106201,
-0.051215607672929764,
0.33568719029426575,
-0.5126407742500305,
0.02675657905638218,
-0.03154030814766884,
0.2437623143196106,
-1.6751723289489746,
0.1672501116991043,
0.2608705759048462,
-0.27913063764572144,
-0.314472496509552,
-0.035031095147132874,
-0.021449068561196327,
-0.07365807145833969,
-0.4205126464366913,
0.3718201220035553,
-0.7276776432991028,
-0.19219155609607697,
-0.18029384315013885,
0.29646188020706177,
0.003753570606932044,
0.6632971167564392,
0.08553709089756012,
0.8467624187469482,
0.5902395248413086,
-0.3527178466320038,
-0.06074198707938194,
0.3603495955467224,
-0.08073489367961884,
0.5839414000511169,
-0.18707704544067383,
-0.26894235610961914,
0.018559487536549568,
0.34422770142555237,
-0.8384019732475281,
-0.5365307331085205,
0.17699077725410461,
-0.5087487697601318,
0.4287446439266205,
0.29895156621932983,
-0.0029603424482047558,
0.11895327270030975,
-0.2828524112701416,
0.5448485612869263,
0.15964125096797943,
-0.49824440479278564,
1.1307179927825928,
0.43718352913856506,
-0.24662771821022034,
-0.41112178564071655,
-0.5442990064620972,
-0.0035680686123669147,
-0.14314916729927063,
-0.45003774762153625,
0.6780973672866821,
0.2087561935186386,
0.0606471449136734,
-0.05054999515414238,
-0.6936432123184204,
0.01085568405687809,
-0.2209135890007019,
0.23418857157230377,
0.18221180140972137,
-0.4395017623901367,
0.17879673838615417,
0.360361248254776,
-0.054677318781614304,
-0.06250124424695969,
-0.29488709568977356,
0.22947214543819427,
-0.19344507157802582,
0.09163694828748703,
-0.6239690184593201,
0.3931880593299866,
0.7906142473220825,
-0.13798017799854279,
0.4467158615589142,
0.3161185383796692,
-0.4974040389060974,
-0.1853351593017578,
0.30777817964553833,
-0.13019593060016632,
-0.48257049918174744,
0.3860456645488739,
-0.2719482183456421,
-0.6852989792823792,
0.49036091566085815,
-0.2382344901561737,
-0.20250649750232697,
0.5472017526626587,
0.48172324895858765,
0.035786889493465424,
1.1207914352416992,
0.7598913311958313,
0.1645251214504242,
0.4445393681526184,
-0.07422374933958054,
0.22941571474075317,
-0.8638447523117065,
-0.5960643887519836,
-0.15202918648719788,
-0.25663334131240845,
-0.29902517795562744,
-0.5707094073295593,
0.4852263629436493,
0.3878215253353119,
-0.31394439935684204,
0.3548194169998169,
-0.5047629475593567,
0.28027358651161194,
0.45850393176078796,
0.22865907847881317,
0.10564406961202621,
0.3512946367263794,
-0.18307308852672577,
0.18035829067230225,
-0.5656722784042358,
-0.4573126435279846,
1.0317569971084595,
0.1630968302488327,
0.548583984375,
0.34661996364593506,
0.799742579460144,
0.13133688271045685,
-0.06544749438762665,
-0.815155565738678,
0.5250189304351807,
-0.050052814185619354,
-0.37779906392097473,
-0.07844437658786774,
-0.6946849226951599,
-0.9640412926673889,
0.20968081057071686,
-0.23126178979873657,
-0.881662130355835,
0.4633605480194092,
0.20781823992729187,
-0.5395047068595886,
0.26302745938301086,
-0.4552486538887024,
1.0374438762664795,
-0.24812130630016327,
-0.09121806174516678,
-0.17301377654075623,
-1.0253292322158813,
0.18751445412635803,
-0.05003940686583519,
0.17650176584720612,
-0.04847827926278114,
-0.1980760544538498,
0.7966915369033813,
-0.5002529621124268,
0.758818507194519,
0.020254209637641907,
-0.3588066101074219,
0.3363821506500244,
0.1306007206439972,
0.008588483557105064,
0.021555587649345398,
0.348555326461792,
-0.0294481310993433,
-0.027747435495257378,
-0.45249173045158386,
-0.5683891773223877,
0.7248254418373108,
-0.5839511752128601,
-0.20764195919036865,
-0.7264461517333984,
-0.7156703472137451,
-0.2531866133213043,
0.3049929440021515,
0.1700270026922226,
0.6305568218231201,
-0.0010444882791489363,
-0.02631312608718872,
0.413200706243515,
0.016467077657580376,
0.309834361076355,
-0.019063198938965797,
-0.2547735869884491,
-0.8876853585243225,
1.6014258861541748,
-0.06349581480026245,
0.34722355008125305,
0.7916836142539978,
0.03750569745898247,
-0.2606356143951416,
-0.2911202609539032,
-0.8778380155563354,
-0.06310505419969559,
-0.6979058980941772,
-0.5627974271774292,
-0.30219000577926636,
0.0928502157330513,
-0.573922336101532,
-0.3167232275009155,
-0.3627350330352783,
-0.46302539110183716,
-0.4203948378562927,
-0.0359293594956398,
0.32324331998825073,
0.7907499670982361,
-0.16050854325294495,
0.23397283256053925,
-1.0631287097930908,
0.7156063914299011,
0.33075785636901855,
0.09702566266059875,
-0.057317402213811874,
0.04472768306732178,
-0.34787970781326294,
0.058431219309568405,
-0.6318800449371338,
-0.9494171738624573,
0.06501945108175278,
0.5487468838691711,
0.34053826332092285,
0.45411553978919983,
-0.469668984413147,
0.7549254298210144,
-0.451267808675766,
0.8812603950500488,
0.30179381370544434,
-1.3335793018341064,
0.6363666653633118,
-0.5450540781021118,
0.40930813550949097,
0.6881394386291504,
0.5052127242088318,
-0.3352302014827728,
-0.3926636576652527,
-0.3768801689147949,
-1.0816550254821777,
0.5423656105995178,
0.22913062572479248,
-0.11964284628629684,
-0.020552488043904305,
0.1511639952659607,
0.3338747024536133,
0.18417879939079285,
-0.696671187877655,
-0.15729324519634247,
-0.11345747858285904,
-0.8304226398468018,
0.16693620383739471,
0.2327660620212555,
-0.044201064854860306,
-0.1894150823354721,
0.9691302180290222,
-0.5003179907798767,
0.36100104451179504,
0.29562830924987793,
-0.19752761721611023,
-0.312442421913147,
0.26154401898384094,
0.5435675382614136,
0.7873295545578003,
-0.3582894802093506,
0.26401156187057495,
-0.453286737203598,
-0.56548672914505,
0.31722787022590637,
0.22590257227420807,
0.00010814382403623313,
-0.18192467093467712,
0.3674185276031494,
0.7088495492935181,
0.3703349232673645,
-0.8273904919624329,
0.4426386058330536,
0.1675681471824646,
0.007480359636247158,
0.4153141677379608,
-0.06556154042482376,
0.0014309970429167151,
0.268253892660141,
0.4462902545928955,
0.48142489790916443,
0.22068147361278534,
-0.8952097296714783,
0.43548792600631714,
0.3672502338886261,
-0.39102041721343994,
-0.32082027196884155,
0.6754695177078247,
0.1820131242275238,
0.17358218133449554,
0.28706032037734985,
0.03591924160718918,
-0.483804315328598,
0.6025722026824951,
0.7488197684288025,
0.8533979058265686,
-0.392212450504303,
0.3402920365333557,
0.29860633611679077,
-0.12574592232704163,
0.3283912241458893,
0.3983200788497925,
-0.2756287157535553,
-0.32542896270751953,
0.068990558385849,
-0.76993328332901,
-0.21697019040584564,
-0.23370292782783508,
-0.5931280255317688,
-0.06967706233263016,
-0.31040456891059875,
0.08924675732851028,
0.16947409510612488,
-0.07270580530166626,
-0.06444188952445984,
0.36587920784950256,
0.2514304220676422,
0.6531315445899963,
-0.9279417395591736,
0.566849946975708,
0.7455881237983704,
-0.7229186296463013,
-0.4074157178401947,
0.22246186435222626,
0.3804575800895691,
-0.47033071517944336,
0.23954851925373077,
0.4937613904476166,
-0.17625434696674347,
-0.1621205061674118,
-0.23461495339870453,
-1.2059401273727417,
1.2275890111923218,
0.3064875304698944,
-0.5742337107658386,
-0.17306871712207794,
0.15568819642066956,
0.47346171736717224,
-0.4817658066749573,
-0.01601465418934822,
0.33501923084259033,
0.17648762464523315,
0.055779971182346344,
-0.6986833214759827,
0.3077324330806732,
-0.41259637475013733,
0.27335506677627563,
0.2992008626461029,
-0.5258927345275879,
0.8940953612327576,
-0.043074432760477066,
-0.48080718517303467,
0.5397119522094727,
0.9847641587257385,
0.5676986575126648,
0.2798868417739868,
0.197162464261055,
0.6213895678520203,
0.7262752056121826,
-0.05068819597363472,
0.7717471122741699,
-0.08198366314172745,
0.2936234176158905,
0.9505726099014282,
-0.1337461620569229,
0.8822253942489624,
0.837277889251709,
-0.040364932268857956,
0.9152799248695374,
0.7886912822723389,
0.10509680211544037,
0.5997241735458374,
0.17740881443023682,
-0.24944469332695007,
-0.417201429605484,
-0.014618566259741783,
-0.2562161087989807,
0.33166736364364624,
0.42367812991142273,
-0.3016403317451477,
-0.41552552580833435,
0.4643514156341553,
-0.31470662355422974,
0.10938718169927597,
-0.45569711923599243,
0.8980613350868225,
0.06927988678216934,
-0.5978431701660156,
0.3121522068977356,
-0.13213534653186798,
0.47594013810157776,
-0.6442470550537109,
-0.3745010197162628,
0.058485593646764755,
0.3409610986709595,
0.03235718607902527,
-0.46167251467704773,
-0.04427262395620346,
-0.4907269775867462,
-0.23719929158687592,
0.07163356989622116,
0.45905178785324097,
-0.729053795337677,
-0.5339430570602417,
0.22665604948997498,
0.27243420481681824,
-0.13678747415542603,
0.1307232826948166,
-0.7658758759498596,
0.10355956852436066,
-0.059508662670850754,
-0.20452286303043365,
0.46793311834335327,
0.38207945227622986,
-0.08929669111967087,
0.28159499168395996,
0.3096539080142975,
-0.3103155791759491,
0.041340410709381104,
-0.18466603755950928,
0.686124861240387,
-0.6504464745521545,
-0.39944615960121155,
-0.6347410082817078,
0.5853750109672546,
0.08516855537891388,
-0.604076623916626,
0.7733721137046814,
0.7879226803779602,
0.9135197401046753,
-0.10904450714588165,
0.5397244691848755,
0.0018909525824710727,
0.04890220984816551,
-0.8843172192573547,
0.39912310242652893,
-0.904877781867981,
-0.11962532997131348,
-0.20047949254512787,
-0.9671263098716736,
-0.47717657685279846,
0.5118873715400696,
0.24156050384044647,
0.28183722496032715,
0.8308786749839783,
0.7511086463928223,
-0.35687148571014404,
0.13743209838867188,
-0.24394704401493073,
0.18031786382198334,
0.38819265365600586,
0.8579015135765076,
0.46496760845184326,
-0.7159587144851685,
0.18589209020137787,
-0.19840429723262787,
-0.011526107788085938,
-0.16274268925189972,
-0.6181303262710571,
-0.7376875877380371,
-0.8400757908821106,
-0.29116642475128174,
-0.28079015016555786,
-0.008091713301837444,
1.0757032632827759,
0.7897593975067139,
-0.9442442655563354,
-0.3492264151573181,
-0.7056752443313599,
-0.0311552993953228,
-0.3169861137866974,
-0.21908794343471527,
0.5724395513534546,
-0.5761824250221252,
-0.7714041471481323,
0.7824172377586365,
0.5104427933692932,
0.33834901452064514,
-0.0957721546292305,
0.03281990438699722,
-0.4482811689376831,
0.1438894271850586,
0.4049575924873352,
0.3841742277145386,
-0.7731921076774597,
-0.14949998259544373,
-0.21964232623577118,
-0.2475312203168869,
0.43509358167648315,
0.9287855625152588,
-0.8076923489570618,
0.5861861109733582,
0.5823471546173096,
0.6631760597229004,
0.03396051749587059,
0.11377918720245361,
0.719607949256897,
-0.9253701567649841,
-0.37328413128852844,
0.17481139302253723,
0.3296522796154022,
0.3239755928516388,
-0.5006694793701172,
-0.037397731095552444,
0.19035296142101288,
-0.5847614407539368,
-0.6445837616920471,
0.19527612626552582,
-1.5648142099380493,
-0.7970903515815735,
0.8148334622383118,
0.26198840141296387,
-0.6829027533531189,
0.28324249386787415,
-0.3417654037475586,
0.5669335722923279,
-0.7106518149375916,
0.66265469789505,
0.3638399839401245,
-0.1949969381093979,
0.20148739218711853,
0.03572952374815941,
0.6071770787239075,
0.6303462982177734,
-1.0625890493392944,
0.22490689158439636,
0.7696633338928223,
0.03136524185538292,
0.6089858412742615,
0.38973817229270935,
-0.09646026045084,
0.4564339816570282,
0.09844595938920975,
-0.030634017661213875,
0.12140543013811111,
-0.9805490970611572,
-0.5366880297660828,
0.30571749806404114,
-0.4059322476387024,
-0.2408892959356308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14977v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14977v1
|
Social Media and Artificial Intelligence for Sustainable Cities and Societies: A Water Quality Analysis Use-case
| 2024-04-23T12:33:14 | 2024-04-23T12:33:14 |
Muhammad Asif Auyb, Muhammad Tayyab Zamir, Imran Khan, Hannia Naseem, Nasir Ahmad, Kashif Ahmad
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.CL
|
This paper focuses on a very important societal challenge of water quality
analysis. Being one of the key factors in the economic and social development
of society, the provision of water and ensuring its quality has always remained
one of the top priorities of public authorities. To ensure the quality of
water, different methods for monitoring and assessing the water networks, such
as offline and online surveys, are used. However, these surveys have several
limitations, such as the limited number of participants and low frequency due
to the labor involved in conducting such surveys. In this paper, we propose a
Natural Language Processing (NLP) framework to automatically collect and
analyze water-related posts from social media for data-driven decisions. The
proposed framework is composed of two components, namely (i) text
classification, and (ii) topic modeling. For text classification, we propose a
merit-fusion-based framework incorporating several Large Language Models (LLMs)
where different weight selection and optimization methods are employed to
assign weights to the LLMs. In topic modeling, we employed the BERTopic library
to discover the hidden topic patterns in the water-related tweets. We also
analyzed relevant tweets originating from different regions and countries to
explore global, regional, and country-specific issues and water-related
concerns. We also collected and manually annotated a large-scale dataset, which
is expected to facilitate future research on the topic.
|
[
-0.5354564189910889,
-1.0207082033157349,
0.6294794082641602,
0.25576773285865784,
-0.45831575989723206,
0.4425083100795746,
0.09898126870393753,
-0.5984422564506531,
0.3003230690956116,
0.4728846848011017,
-0.39586615562438965,
-0.6399533152580261,
-0.6820688843727112,
0.10704556852579117,
-0.6417074799537659,
0.5524102449417114,
-0.14218565821647644,
0.22815920412540436,
0.06279554218053818,
-0.19634953141212463,
-0.29190900921821594,
0.15531405806541443,
-1.0173203945159912,
-0.17757292091846466,
0.48173362016677856,
0.1610136330127716,
0.6080372333526611,
0.25495457649230957,
0.607915461063385,
0.36272525787353516,
-0.3468068242073059,
0.25580111145973206,
-0.4144298732280731,
0.015598144382238388,
-0.5907735228538513,
0.15865014493465424,
0.232458233833313,
0.017365625128149986,
0.47349604964256287,
0.5089651346206665,
0.35964441299438477,
0.6068204045295715,
0.37464919686317444,
0.8904125690460205,
-0.5091559886932373,
0.4966672360897064,
-0.5449025630950928,
-0.09069027751684189,
0.17955751717090607,
-0.4688411355018616,
0.32318466901779175,
-0.4668535888195038,
0.30136051774024963,
-0.3636973798274994,
0.1152419000864029,
-0.04099208116531372,
1.1087450981140137,
0.684956967830658,
-0.08464299887418747,
-0.3591943085193634,
-0.8745041489601135,
0.9602423310279846,
-0.6060682535171509,
0.04730643332004547,
0.5885418057441711,
0.332446813583374,
0.1429559886455536,
-0.20660732686519623,
-0.5106844902038574,
0.35868391394615173,
-0.15501637756824493,
0.019096843898296356,
0.001561504788696766,
-0.19851534068584442,
-0.2588035762310028,
0.027788076549768448,
-0.4740962088108063,
-0.4560074508190155,
-0.4956906735897064,
0.029287729412317276,
1.2285035848617554,
-0.05611317604780197,
0.2323366403579712,
-0.4120843708515167,
-0.15873174369335175,
0.31737616658210754,
-0.2984483242034912,
0.33445557951927185,
0.21543289721012115,
0.545009195804596,
-0.2924909293651581,
0.4022889733314514,
-0.36604318022727966,
0.5097469687461853,
-0.3963513672351837,
0.13363893330097198,
-0.04195692390203476,
-0.5234684944152832,
0.016147969290614128,
0.07543175667524338,
0.8674015998840332,
0.21897494792938232,
0.214685320854187,
0.15057361125946045,
-0.2675440013408661,
0.15416793525218964,
0.18201977014541626,
-0.40447568893432617,
-0.1513049453496933,
0.6545283198356628,
-0.7048190832138062,
-0.5149976015090942,
0.17253783345222473,
-0.7015655636787415,
-0.5182610154151917,
-0.7359578013420105,
0.30364909768104553,
0.004996924661099911,
-0.3036145269870758,
-0.04002964869141579,
-0.3258485794067383,
-0.005706400144845247,
0.4040541350841522,
-0.5314165353775024,
0.2933707535266876,
0.7713366150856018,
1.0406956672668457,
-0.06359392404556274,
0.2115783393383026,
0.10332191735506058,
0.0217134952545166,
-0.14882509410381317,
1.1235387325286865,
-0.5147481560707092,
-0.24273553490638733,
0.005236831493675709,
-0.3503255546092987,
0.06789904087781906,
-0.3086192011833191,
0.4999816119670868,
-0.550835371017456,
0.05616291984915733,
-0.32611319422721863,
-0.5295358300209045,
-0.15054583549499512,
0.26632821559906006,
-0.781978189945221,
0.9423782825469971,
-0.053061433136463165,
-1.0369288921356201,
0.13805092871189117,
-0.9551810622215271,
-0.34406256675720215,
0.3315448462963104,
-0.08729704469442368,
-0.36618900299072266,
-0.1710887998342514,
0.29746222496032715,
0.7280671000480652,
-0.5431926846504211,
0.8040689826011658,
-0.4884589612483978,
-0.4873609244823456,
-0.01843007653951645,
-0.3041376769542694,
0.8817043900489807,
0.25305232405662537,
-0.12124493718147278,
0.3622083067893982,
-0.5617375373840332,
-0.006780005991458893,
0.046714961528778076,
-0.3025490343570709,
-0.3647788465023041,
0.4766775071620941,
0.3467784821987152,
0.07981107383966446,
0.22175706923007965,
-0.531979501247406,
-0.3668314516544342,
-0.08244549483060837,
0.8775070905685425,
0.6993628740310669,
0.49938127398490906,
0.2665422856807709,
-0.5232700705528259,
0.033724769949913025,
-0.34804028272628784,
0.49238061904907227,
0.3237978219985962,
-0.8533357381820679,
-0.499683141708374,
-0.1377382129430771,
0.35503241419792175,
0.6067293882369995,
-1.0769176483154297,
0.7797439098358154,
-0.7055813074111938,
-0.7601852416992188,
-0.5995271801948547,
0.11789927631616592,
-0.25788891315460205,
0.18683134019374847,
0.42921584844589233,
0.25482311844825745,
-0.44820088148117065,
-0.6553648114204407,
-0.12286169081926346,
-0.4203258752822876,
0.17123231291770935,
0.3851062059402466,
0.5668290853500366,
-0.340780645608902,
1.3925986289978027,
-0.5252833962440491,
-0.21221596002578735,
-0.3872770369052887,
0.26550617814064026,
0.23379074037075043,
0.11909955739974976,
0.6078888177871704,
-1.3769842386245728,
-0.449900358915329,
-0.3241972327232361,
-0.6275324821472168,
-0.3347608745098114,
0.1225130558013916,
-0.38388872146606445,
-0.12116800248622894,
0.295906126499176,
-0.42190346121788025,
0.49654507637023926,
0.6008647680282593,
-0.32759130001068115,
0.1588115394115448,
0.20557250082492828,
0.3597058951854706,
-1.0473928451538086,
0.20904193818569183,
0.5930890440940857,
-0.03325383737683296,
-0.5472267866134644,
-0.22971074283123016,
-0.2608419954776764,
-0.4981636703014374,
-0.25681939721107483,
1.1012158393859863,
0.2577400505542755,
0.10259205102920532,
-0.4032711982727051,
-0.15999606251716614,
0.04419076815247536,
-0.07658809423446655,
0.28113165497779846,
0.17381198704242706,
0.2747277617454529,
-0.6309887766838074,
0.5989732146263123,
0.11831829696893692,
-0.1315598338842392,
0.25647062063217163,
-0.8097792863845825,
-0.31154701113700867,
-0.23046235740184784,
0.059162065386772156,
-0.9958818554878235,
-0.06917962431907654,
0.242280513048172,
-0.7383450269699097,
-0.15921585261821747,
0.0348723903298378,
-0.6468754410743713,
-0.4665866792201996,
-0.3888995051383972,
-0.1638883501291275,
-0.1319190412759781,
-0.37817108631134033,
0.6009776592254639,
0.7453210949897766,
-0.5196544528007507,
-0.03682713210582733,
-0.43124234676361084,
0.14651302993297577,
-0.22591039538383484,
-0.7783069014549255,
0.2569650709629059,
0.11146970838308334,
-0.507793128490448,
0.51170814037323,
-0.12889781594276428,
-0.5563777089118958,
0.3548007011413574,
0.15822499990463257,
0.10013091564178467,
0.3927329182624817,
0.0025493972934782505,
0.2241540253162384,
-0.1431134194135666,
0.19642822444438934,
0.040040161460638046,
0.6014717817306519,
0.16744668781757355,
0.0119416369125247,
-0.5829218029975891,
0.4523029029369354,
0.5278250575065613,
-0.1957198977470398,
0.5124919414520264,
0.5369533896446228,
-0.7774903774261475,
-0.17156480252742767,
-0.3450956642627716,
-0.09757319837808609,
-0.5086872577667236,
-0.08642833679914474,
0.18640929460525513,
-0.9485365152359009,
0.4908857047557831,
0.06903862953186035,
0.19084766507148743,
0.42656946182250977,
0.10930900275707245,
-0.613669753074646,
0.6790286302566528,
0.6684923768043518,
-0.5438064932823181,
0.4955086410045624,
-0.4245404005050659,
0.7007284760475159,
-0.08036761730909348,
0.028758451342582703,
-0.7253817915916443,
-0.37554922699928284,
-0.6484696269035339,
-0.08572272211313248,
0.13293185830116272,
-0.12396864593029022,
-0.15788336098194122,
0.32792800664901733,
-0.5936051607131958,
0.10773254185914993,
0.49512243270874023,
0.06645537167787552,
0.11726850271224976,
0.08422055840492249,
0.3975599706172943,
-0.009393572807312012,
-0.6034507155418396,
-0.9480128288269043,
0.4252000153064728,
0.34456726908683777,
0.32027390599250793,
-0.12511277198791504,
1.0368905067443848,
0.7976465821266174,
0.48324352502822876,
-0.6839317083358765,
0.6492428779602051,
-0.007092264015227556,
-0.7695435285568237,
-0.6222538948059082,
-0.8457101583480835,
-0.949550211429596,
-0.026301342993974686,
-0.4093312621116638,
-0.2868606448173523,
0.15995708107948303,
-0.19253787398338318,
-0.43522191047668457,
0.25712475180625916,
-0.44214850664138794,
0.42477619647979736,
-0.29331377148628235,
-0.4067586660385132,
-0.4369240403175354,
-0.3333207368850708,
0.19923630356788635,
-0.24720270931720734,
0.6581692695617676,
-0.6179381012916565,
0.11040192097425461,
0.45091772079467773,
-0.3181185722351074,
0.4868942201137543,
-0.3118129372596741,
-0.023989778012037277,
0.5877199172973633,
-0.4186256229877472,
-0.07451050728559494,
0.19401496648788452,
-0.21741780638694763,
0.4978388845920563,
0.00071378902066499,
-0.4416392743587494,
-0.47857344150543213,
0.5960372686386108,
-0.8158944249153137,
-0.2586238980293274,
-0.39025118947029114,
-0.04039473459124565,
-0.33052194118499756,
-0.07708759605884552,
-0.040075331926345825,
0.04929905757308006,
-0.08118899166584015,
0.012565046548843384,
0.3237890899181366,
-0.35573434829711914,
0.7549593448638916,
0.22585543990135193,
0.142398864030838,
-0.40292108058929443,
1.1356048583984375,
0.5692973732948303,
-0.2102620154619217,
0.5300225019454956,
0.5628740787506104,
-0.3994370102882385,
-0.5579257607460022,
-0.11542432010173798,
0.09647520631551743,
-0.20023490488529205,
-0.4060312509536743,
-0.436811238527298,
-0.5253190994262695,
-0.31668323278427124,
-0.08127344399690628,
-0.2377994954586029,
0.017400307580828667,
-0.47137749195098877,
-0.13675467669963837,
0.500975489616394,
0.5894246101379395,
-0.13424742221832275,
-0.1431182622909546,
-1.309152364730835,
0.6445513367652893,
0.24137505888938904,
0.3608371913433075,
0.008946755900979042,
0.08654528111219406,
-0.11274611204862595,
0.268572598695755,
-0.29414498805999756,
-0.7855768203735352,
0.6145637631416321,
-0.07282935827970505,
0.4193004369735718,
0.45612651109695435,
0.3866810202598572,
0.40441828966140747,
-0.10472872853279114,
0.6919204592704773,
-0.10927226394414902,
-0.8968095183372498,
0.928341805934906,
-0.6152966022491455,
0.05510493367910385,
0.8462280631065369,
0.5017569065093994,
-0.5842870473861694,
-0.43705499172210693,
-0.5579954385757446,
-1.1288127899169922,
0.30697882175445557,
0.4310961067676544,
0.2551549971103668,
0.03176197409629822,
0.19426272809505463,
-0.21435922384262085,
0.2479172796010971,
-0.39978310465812683,
-0.17957381904125214,
-0.12824413180351257,
-0.25133180618286133,
0.3178313970565796,
-0.26992207765579224,
0.2203247994184494,
-0.5907862186431885,
0.7909303307533264,
0.23057128489017487,
0.013693442568182945,
0.16520752012729645,
0.19464391469955444,
0.0567651204764843,
0.16761234402656555,
0.11739689111709595,
0.6887151002883911,
-0.09894320368766785,
-0.08086888492107391,
-0.10105280578136444,
-0.3764999508857727,
0.10670812427997589,
0.17246127128601074,
-0.6596876382827759,
0.331097811460495,
0.36123818159103394,
0.41840142011642456,
0.2299291044473648,
-0.5799429416656494,
0.25674203038215637,
-0.28929343819618225,
-0.1458664983510971,
-0.20637714862823486,
-0.03332072123885155,
0.3810146450996399,
0.2499418556690216,
0.8306097984313965,
-0.09178172051906586,
0.2655114531517029,
-0.4638720154762268,
-0.005956051871180534,
0.036454394459724426,
-0.5362702012062073,
0.0358353853225708,
0.32960399985313416,
0.6659468412399292,
-0.20632199943065643,
0.37500444054603577,
-0.36020728945732117,
-0.4680681824684143,
0.47450196743011475,
-0.5190712809562683,
0.6649989485740662,
-0.1336352825164795,
0.44351378083229065,
0.5370228290557861,
0.0741223692893982,
0.004106542095541954,
0.7122742533683777,
-0.14038880169391632,
-1.0126004219055176,
-0.4525772035121918,
-0.9311114549636841,
-0.2500605881214142,
0.3930532932281494,
-0.5453746914863586,
0.2554335296154022,
-0.7197279334068298,
-0.5556032061576843,
0.27047643065452576,
0.4123159945011139,
-0.35590285062789917,
0.29509493708610535,
0.008862352930009365,
0.6524560451507568,
-1.1150834560394287,
0.36084821820259094,
0.6816824674606323,
0.0649440810084343,
-0.6919978260993958,
-0.038774967193603516,
-0.028085937723517418,
-0.2583175003528595,
0.3788926601409912,
0.20991747081279755,
-0.22282065451145172,
-0.04112682864069939,
-0.9281513690948486,
-0.989269495010376,
0.9647675156593323,
0.053447045385837555,
-0.31258678436279297,
0.4275267422199249,
0.3111247420310974,
0.6663697957992554,
-0.013617784716188908,
-0.2387211173772812,
0.48425576090812683,
0.80376797914505,
-0.054731644690036774,
-0.849565863609314,
-0.2230597585439682,
-0.6274787187576294,
0.3520898222923279,
0.06854647397994995,
-0.6186693906784058,
0.18823611736297607,
0.09773574024438858,
-0.3876174986362457,
-0.1720496565103531,
0.35482585430145264,
0.5626769661903381,
0.48690715432167053,
0.3907674551010132,
0.32554179430007935,
0.5314021110534668,
-0.3147766888141632,
0.8494144082069397,
-0.28837502002716064,
0.5281286239624023,
0.5601593255996704,
-0.39330703020095825,
1.022500991821289,
0.4750390350818634,
-0.19145673513412476,
-0.13211844861507416,
1.0584914684295654,
-0.21750874817371368,
0.7147394418716431,
0.07369737327098846,
-0.20185616612434387,
-0.08856075257062912,
-0.6323339343070984,
0.0454520657658577,
0.41815516352653503,
0.5056620836257935,
-0.2566322386264801,
-0.42644861340522766,
-0.17894387245178223,
-0.41199126839637756,
0.3718245029449463,
-0.5614869594573975,
0.7026402950286865,
0.23347170650959015,
-0.1903599500656128,
-0.019745944067835808,
0.17088380455970764,
0.9593601822853088,
-0.19772371649742126,
-0.2072937935590744,
0.14087623357772827,
-0.1896592676639557,
-0.2910856008529663,
-1.0217924118041992,
0.780249834060669,
0.012666305527091026,
-0.24992984533309937,
-0.6346437335014343,
1.0019893646240234,
-0.12670202553272247,
-0.6153201460838318,
0.6646822094917297,
0.6514583230018616,
-0.09564434736967087,
-0.4358482360839844,
-1.139726161956787,
0.039519697427749634,
-0.05185285583138466,
-0.152835875749588,
-0.2056494951248169,
0.18130263686180115,
-0.15318353474140167,
0.9574152827262878,
0.8177071213722229,
0.3889455795288086,
-0.3074887692928314,
0.38508763909339905,
0.6798655986785889,
-0.4251008927822113,
-0.46319398283958435,
-0.8014454245567322,
0.3585265874862671,
-0.4683241546154022,
-0.13964062929153442,
0.4068945348262787,
0.5273135304450989,
0.6470432877540588,
0.27811920642852783,
1.15773606300354,
-0.08763034641742706,
0.7986922264099121,
-0.04143514111638069,
1.2140353918075562,
-0.32318228483200073,
0.23729096353054047,
-0.2700406312942505,
-0.9875810742378235,
-0.1565185934305191,
0.8722436428070068,
-0.4897312521934509,
-0.21087908744812012,
0.19902196526527405,
0.3890388607978821,
0.24067196249961853,
0.41323691606521606,
0.08990181237459183,
-0.3824203610420227,
0.4274093508720398,
0.07986626774072647,
0.7438998818397522,
-0.2428290694952011,
0.26661360263824463,
-0.24143312871456146,
0.19080060720443726,
-0.155782088637352,
-0.38307878375053406,
-0.7254932522773743,
-0.7124965190887451,
-0.43969571590423584,
0.03531283140182495,
0.15767371654510498,
0.9342854022979736,
0.6077461838722229,
-0.9245941638946533,
0.02405131608247757,
-0.2350776344537735,
0.3946078419685364,
0.1223517656326294,
-0.3253558874130249,
0.5502048134803772,
-0.008344207890331745,
-0.565561830997467,
-0.13882328569889069,
0.30870673060417175,
0.07581725716590881,
-0.32962316274642944,
0.08170559257268906,
-0.39498552680015564,
-0.03971942886710167,
0.6587439179420471,
0.024662276729941368,
-0.2343290150165558,
-0.2670493721961975,
-0.08327416330575943,
-0.27557921409606934,
-0.10360102355480194,
0.31742507219314575,
-0.40755486488342285,
0.012394657358527184,
0.7849578261375427,
0.8002424240112305,
0.3599989116191864,
0.10951697826385498,
0.29707396030426025,
-0.5148659944534302,
-0.33468207716941833,
0.5849952697753906,
0.44429418444633484,
0.6954100728034973,
-0.31655219197273254,
0.5617912411689758,
0.2848750352859497,
-0.23334109783172607,
-0.28196850419044495,
-0.1478685736656189,
-0.7276983261108398,
-0.5580925345420837,
1.4659721851348877,
0.08871953934431076,
-0.12958045303821564,
-0.6683180332183838,
-0.19210569560527802,
0.293609619140625,
-0.6226844191551208,
1.2584929466247559,
1.1130690574645996,
0.023520881310105324,
-0.1336900144815445,
-0.7804185748100281,
0.18897652626037598,
-0.24729111790657043,
-1.1287187337875366,
-0.3181201219558716,
0.22907154262065887,
0.31059420108795166,
0.38275831937789917,
0.45141148567199707,
0.08508376032114029,
-0.09812197089195251,
-0.44801321625709534,
-0.1702953428030014,
0.34783434867858887,
-0.18498694896697998,
0.06032753735780716,
0.049797460436820984,
-0.44301214814186096,
0.0064963046461343765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14963v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14963v3
|
Achieving >97% on GSM8K: Deeply Understanding the Problems Makes LLMs Better Solvers for Math Word Problems
| 2024-04-23T12:16:05 | 2024-05-29T15:27:53 |
Qihuang Zhong, Kang Wang, Ziyang Xu, Juhua Liu, Liang Ding, Bo Du, Dacheng Tao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting has enhanced the performance of Large
Language Models (LLMs) across various reasoning tasks. However, CoT still falls
short in dealing with complex math word problems, as it usually suffers from
three pitfalls: semantic misunderstanding errors, calculation errors and
step-missing errors. Prior studies involve addressing the calculation errors
and step-missing errors, but neglect the semantic misunderstanding errors,
which is the major factor limiting the LLMs' performance. To this end, we
propose a simple-yet-effective method, namely Deeply Understanding the Problems
(DUP), to improve the LLMs' math problem-solving ability by addressing semantic
misunderstanding errors. The core of our method is to encourage the LLMs to
deeply understand the problems and extract the key problem-solving information
used for better reasoning. Extensive experiments on 10 diverse reasoning
benchmarks show that our DUP method consistently outperforms the other
counterparts by a large margin. More encouragingly, DUP achieves a new SOTA
result on the GSM8K benchmark, with an accuracy of 97.1% under zero-shot
setting.
|
[
-0.4646259844303131,
-0.6820763945579529,
0.8725236058235168,
0.37504318356513977,
-0.39912325143814087,
0.41512978076934814,
-0.10773549973964691,
-0.15200340747833252,
-0.20831231772899628,
0.5133429169654846,
-0.6498144268989563,
-0.6406972408294678,
-0.9876567125320435,
0.020354146137833595,
0.11101270467042923,
0.7221769690513611,
-0.3935881555080414,
0.3083098828792572,
-0.17156575620174408,
-0.12226039171218872,
-0.6522030234336853,
-0.434231698513031,
-0.5751982927322388,
-0.5863291621208191,
0.28160595893859863,
0.5565546751022339,
0.6255258917808533,
0.36490851640701294,
0.7665827870368958,
0.2280302792787552,
-0.36674344539642334,
0.5482138395309448,
-0.6271899938583374,
-0.030778421089053154,
-0.08704320341348648,
-0.736962616443634,
-0.37498244643211365,
-0.3326662480831146,
0.41936299204826355,
0.9700284004211426,
-0.13989059627056122,
-0.0024081554729491472,
0.04136525094509125,
1.2726105451583862,
-0.7973077893257141,
0.24204985797405243,
-0.8335720300674438,
0.23718227446079254,
0.047464534640312195,
-0.28762367367744446,
-0.26825612783432007,
-0.11954636871814728,
-0.044893778860569,
-0.6739760637283325,
0.10376817733049393,
-0.2640882134437561,
0.3926340639591217,
0.3943963646888733,
-0.3878333866596222,
-0.5937302708625793,
-0.678977906703949,
0.903807520866394,
-0.6427614092826843,
0.29717713594436646,
0.5449650883674622,
0.19216014444828033,
-0.6397162675857544,
-0.09439721703529358,
-0.5117543339729309,
0.03749809414148331,
0.3853648900985718,
0.21718277037143707,
0.07336179912090302,
0.11029687523841858,
0.7556101083755493,
0.45976248383522034,
-0.3535834848880768,
-0.4299485385417938,
-0.4372563660144806,
-0.10055459290742874,
0.5894373655319214,
0.4187445342540741,
0.261098176240921,
-0.06999003142118454,
-0.3579249978065491,
0.08570078015327454,
-0.9023313522338867,
0.030805010348558426,
0.18150968849658966,
-0.1586928814649582,
-0.015160588547587395,
0.5561754107475281,
-0.15626105666160583,
0.7319911122322083,
-0.22461916506290436,
-0.3797283172607422,
0.09786181896924973,
-0.3920038640499115,
-0.3211182951927185,
0.07379060238599777,
0.38456377387046814,
0.11791273206472397,
0.38180938363075256,
0.04028075188398361,
-0.2671400010585785,
0.4321098327636719,
0.06795957684516907,
-0.46614888310432434,
-0.09858797490596771,
0.12412034720182419,
0.03411464765667915,
-0.001550554297864437,
-0.13800238072872162,
-0.35775601863861084,
-0.39016884565353394,
-0.5069644451141357,
0.5383988618850708,
-0.4114067554473877,
-0.16565252840518951,
0.7634449601173401,
0.04922844097018242,
0.15622977912425995,
0.5178036093711853,
-0.624553918838501,
0.25619521737098694,
1.011123538017273,
0.8041383624076843,
0.01743919961154461,
-0.25992506742477417,
-0.4753221273422241,
0.0776834636926651,
-0.6707176566123962,
0.9539008736610413,
-0.35418859124183655,
-0.523019015789032,
-0.27182966470718384,
-0.44265544414520264,
-0.23328465223312378,
-0.762924313545227,
0.693844199180603,
-0.35167214274406433,
-0.0795719176530838,
-0.5806324481964111,
-0.7090144753456116,
-0.12998248636722565,
0.4413749575614929,
-0.4620620310306549,
0.9427210092544556,
0.07810061424970627,
-0.6203691363334656,
-0.040371015667915344,
-0.6706121563911438,
-0.1984270066022873,
-0.18134328722953796,
-0.18695713579654694,
-0.19690948724746704,
0.6000129580497742,
0.3372800648212433,
0.1726425141096115,
-0.3665551543235779,
0.24582132697105408,
-0.09093649685382843,
-0.5240747928619385,
0.21035856008529663,
-0.3556453287601471,
0.6383987665176392,
0.2867223918437958,
-0.3203125298023224,
-0.21021603047847748,
-0.6353545784950256,
0.19993872940540314,
0.27057260274887085,
-0.15903422236442566,
-0.33535876870155334,
-0.3165975511074066,
-0.6422174572944641,
0.23108048737049103,
0.10799280554056168,
-0.4611578583717346,
0.24131466448307037,
-0.5312044024467468,
0.23442776501178741,
0.8154819011688232,
-0.2793593406677246,
0.32469525933265686,
-0.2407693713903427,
0.5937595963478088,
0.002203627023845911,
0.08720239996910095,
-0.24453839659690857,
-0.6791284680366516,
-0.7852866649627686,
0.041013848036527634,
0.3696243464946747,
0.4466651380062103,
-0.7520381212234497,
0.26031750440597534,
-0.05516766384243965,
-0.3799733817577362,
-0.5082204937934875,
0.3522844612598419,
0.6195243000984192,
0.6412174701690674,
0.328634649515152,
-0.21306045353412628,
-0.27151355147361755,
-0.5861467123031616,
-0.5913770794868469,
0.2134539932012558,
0.05431097373366356,
0.22402267158031464,
0.4095641076564789,
-0.2081056386232376,
0.7017433047294617,
-0.9020461440086365,
-0.3170144259929657,
-0.4177917242050171,
0.3197900354862213,
0.18817757070064545,
0.21139690279960632,
-0.13884025812149048,
-0.7046351432800293,
-0.510466992855072,
-0.13841062784194946,
-0.7480367422103882,
-0.3306591510772705,
0.15440037846565247,
-0.37100324034690857,
0.1584434062242508,
0.08352350443601608,
-0.6260267496109009,
0.6745313405990601,
0.47509709000587463,
-0.4382769763469696,
0.6242890357971191,
-0.2480999380350113,
0.018075596541166306,
-0.9890417456626892,
-0.3453594744205475,
-0.13482093811035156,
-0.12288466840982437,
-0.47204849123954773,
0.009541459381580353,
0.012482617981731892,
-0.12439568340778351,
-0.4317692220211029,
0.24051029980182648,
-0.6518078446388245,
-0.18864597380161285,
-0.42755213379859924,
0.38324856758117676,
0.20770734548568726,
0.4299279749393463,
-0.3600601553916931,
0.939550518989563,
0.3367057144641876,
-0.574768602848053,
0.4226258099079132,
0.19356651604175568,
-0.5080457329750061,
0.3588489890098572,
-0.4533858001232147,
0.3327467739582062,
-0.13937632739543915,
0.3390708863735199,
-0.9999626874923706,
0.11752472072839737,
0.07250946015119553,
-0.5084903240203857,
-0.06658776104450226,
-0.22587411105632782,
-0.444580078125,
-0.24526727199554443,
-0.3900482952594757,
0.5862680077552795,
0.4318566918373108,
-0.5030511617660522,
0.6699238419532776,
0.39067861437797546,
-0.04107934609055519,
-0.9014943242073059,
-0.5452574491500854,
0.047848135232925415,
0.0020823245868086815,
-0.9154261946678162,
0.21681879460811615,
-0.09223368763923645,
-0.25755906105041504,
-0.09598756581544876,
-0.5970923900604248,
0.04721292480826378,
0.19786518812179565,
-0.03112504631280899,
0.30132660269737244,
-0.08456330746412277,
0.22090670466423035,
-0.10183058679103851,
-0.6762319207191467,
0.31238386034965515,
-0.17834056913852692,
0.9250292181968689,
-0.28489693999290466,
-0.5549095869064331,
-0.36884748935699463,
0.275578111410141,
0.4011124074459076,
-0.16827550530433655,
0.44534018635749817,
0.2595714032649994,
-0.42002683877944946,
-0.2926519215106964,
-0.5929902791976929,
0.07005926966667175,
-0.4391387403011322,
0.2791098654270172,
-0.7825883626937866,
-0.6567637920379639,
0.618373692035675,
-0.4113943874835968,
-0.12382666021585464,
0.328337699174881,
0.3291183412075043,
-0.03740772232413292,
1.1340830326080322,
0.552273154258728,
-0.017374170944094658,
0.18529009819030762,
-0.6021912097930908,
0.4547494947910309,
-1.1625845432281494,
-0.17592787742614746,
-0.3190666735172272,
-0.27167636156082153,
-0.34444156289100647,
-0.6923583149909973,
0.4414704740047455,
0.4864162504673004,
-0.00011187697236891836,
0.2047063261270523,
-0.39711302518844604,
0.8020238876342773,
0.1422186940908432,
-0.008900477550923824,
0.6243982911109924,
0.25003355741500854,
-0.2195035219192505,
-0.12494233250617981,
-0.5841357707977295,
-0.49334606528282166,
1.0950273275375366,
0.17032490670681,
1.1595062017440796,
0.07014588266611099,
0.7210366129875183,
-0.13853470981121063,
0.11767668277025223,
-0.9003608226776123,
0.550237238407135,
-0.1307060867547989,
-0.3280467987060547,
-0.09437575936317444,
-0.7907346487045288,
-0.8645474314689636,
0.4256950616836548,
0.12728437781333923,
-0.6532673835754395,
-0.24174991250038147,
0.22288882732391357,
-0.258161723613739,
0.37204664945602417,
-0.7608681917190552,
0.6661714315414429,
-0.24822834134101868,
-0.16957461833953857,
-0.39283931255340576,
-0.25822433829307556,
0.38233354687690735,
-0.04830048605799675,
0.31245800852775574,
-0.5231165289878845,
-0.17321601510047913,
0.7402309775352478,
-0.5919323563575745,
0.3391779661178589,
-0.03802070766687393,
-0.4378257095813751,
0.4726715087890625,
0.2810394763946533,
0.6251124739646912,
-0.05343269929289818,
0.09694494307041168,
0.22482337057590485,
-0.3062344491481781,
-0.5628060698509216,
-0.9912127256393433,
0.7501703500747681,
-0.5616124868392944,
-0.7462210059165955,
-0.3836926817893982,
-0.6939775943756104,
-0.4837634563446045,
-0.08896663784980774,
0.25544166564941406,
0.6550179123878479,
0.4053953289985657,
-0.05227546766400337,
0.8340945243835449,
-0.04900625720620155,
0.18906821310520172,
0.3427439033985138,
-0.3466934859752655,
-0.5545884370803833,
0.9206672310829163,
0.4155249297618866,
0.5452781319618225,
0.1346299797296524,
0.4779353439807892,
-0.4052969515323639,
-0.3921792209148407,
-0.597601056098938,
0.36129891872406006,
-0.9252028465270996,
-0.25784221291542053,
-0.7211229205131531,
-0.3083189129829407,
-0.033018823713064194,
-0.26448655128479004,
-0.522149920463562,
-0.43738216161727905,
0.14210690557956696,
0.04365859925746918,
0.23562732338905334,
0.8427037000656128,
0.10538844764232635,
0.2744835913181305,
-0.8379119634628296,
0.42355814576148987,
0.18217873573303223,
0.4684039056301117,
0.14457958936691284,
-0.6779630184173584,
-0.10144210606813431,
0.051233433187007904,
-0.5150539875030518,
-0.7408673167228699,
0.19529065489768982,
-0.32492440938949585,
0.19846950471401215,
0.18102604150772095,
-0.03725485876202583,
1.0867427587509155,
-0.31393954157829285,
0.47912901639938354,
0.32386523485183716,
-1.2534397840499878,
0.5035339593887329,
-0.013357219286262989,
0.49849942326545715,
0.42908650636672974,
0.2905590832233429,
-0.5485634803771973,
-0.22411660850048065,
-0.6775263547897339,
-0.7170817852020264,
0.5773583650588989,
0.430379182100296,
0.12671484053134918,
0.2646889090538025,
0.28066322207450867,
0.09944720566272736,
0.16022373735904694,
-0.3888947665691376,
-0.2229645848274231,
0.36958128213882446,
-0.3414556682109833,
0.08321843296289444,
-0.41046521067619324,
-0.03216763213276863,
-0.2801969349384308,
0.6511641144752502,
-0.10663838684558868,
0.32445213198661804,
0.34175190329551697,
-0.2227221131324768,
-0.33646073937416077,
0.424995481967926,
0.9456002116203308,
1.3595728874206543,
0.044692039489746094,
0.4637070298194885,
0.5597565770149231,
-0.7498205304145813,
0.23267917335033417,
-0.17199933528900146,
0.021511489525437355,
-0.07379714399576187,
0.34368738532066345,
0.6017670035362244,
0.059186581522226334,
-0.6764276027679443,
0.47781798243522644,
-0.10831821709871292,
-0.21680450439453125,
-0.17047686874866486,
0.12523417174816132,
0.404991090297699,
-0.15727809071540833,
0.4445748031139374,
0.06254814565181732,
0.17055444419384003,
-0.39255768060684204,
-0.12528757750988007,
0.40356630086898804,
-0.2323923259973526,
-0.14386333525180817,
0.03708750754594803,
0.1427059918642044,
-0.5036916732788086,
0.3610794246196747,
-0.20548763871192932,
-1.0507527589797974,
0.8739645481109619,
0.8412502408027649,
0.6052030324935913,
-0.09197309613227844,
0.02836720086634159,
0.14373338222503662,
0.1514553725719452,
-0.3405401408672333,
0.6917930245399475,
-0.08446421474218369,
-0.8501879572868347,
-0.8217622637748718,
-0.3533112406730652,
-0.5701901316642761,
0.2519179582595825,
-0.4895009696483612,
0.23642222583293915,
-0.6224216222763062,
-0.02072322368621826,
-0.12459103763103485,
0.29899126291275024,
-0.522767961025238,
0.18856139481067657,
0.1489730179309845,
0.9852842688560486,
-0.5281058549880981,
0.32629942893981934,
0.5837539434432983,
-0.051037825644016266,
-1.168271541595459,
-0.004694038070738316,
-0.22259502112865448,
-1.0904792547225952,
0.6199172139167786,
0.4448937773704529,
-0.7078123688697815,
0.05486386641860008,
-0.4372452199459076,
-0.7410672307014465,
0.7771153450012207,
0.5555715560913086,
-0.8652934432029724,
0.35523611307144165,
0.2621358036994934,
0.2759477198123932,
-0.302791565656662,
0.30481693148612976,
0.4568040072917938,
0.3448130190372467,
0.23516611754894257,
-0.8205460906028748,
-0.045049335807561874,
-0.008139029145240784,
-0.03901275247335434,
0.670094907283783,
-0.5751085877418518,
0.6421240568161011,
-0.5510233640670776,
-0.15034668147563934,
-0.3425118029117584,
0.37349429726600647,
0.593429684638977,
0.8818091154098511,
0.663663923740387,
0.9337407350540161,
0.8070243000984192,
-0.09715896844863892,
0.9359511733055115,
-0.13482694327831268,
0.6077597737312317,
1.107887864112854,
-0.20171618461608887,
0.679473876953125,
0.3533286154270172,
-0.4458851218223572,
0.29487937688827515,
0.4200505018234253,
0.40126165747642517,
0.2807236313819885,
0.5364981889724731,
-0.5949556231498718,
-0.5192410945892334,
0.03256828710436821,
-0.6258296370506287,
0.33900997042655945,
0.49127840995788574,
-0.06526271253824234,
-0.3280995190143585,
-0.17533370852470398,
0.2477674037218094,
0.11372930556535721,
-0.5087922215461731,
0.6670147776603699,
0.6469385623931885,
-0.5715076327323914,
0.7833936214447021,
-0.06394604593515396,
0.5412565469741821,
-0.4431101977825165,
-0.21528856456279755,
-0.34213337302207947,
0.31856635212898254,
-0.30380260944366455,
-0.9668270349502563,
0.3855760395526886,
0.08116224408149719,
-0.11856655776500702,
0.1446702629327774,
0.9035736322402954,
-0.3611834943294525,
-0.675482988357544,
0.29064658284187317,
0.5813661813735962,
0.28910398483276367,
-0.32549500465393066,
-0.7446472644805908,
0.28428375720977783,
-0.068585604429245,
0.14122788608074188,
0.1528286635875702,
0.6753765344619751,
0.13462181389331818,
0.8553861379623413,
0.7237441539764404,
0.13282260298728943,
0.02398197166621685,
0.13793817162513733,
1.0294398069381714,
-1.0198932886123657,
-0.473557710647583,
-1.2041414976119995,
0.2986239194869995,
-0.1413361132144928,
-0.4161321222782135,
0.5841549634933472,
0.5191362500190735,
1.0348477363586426,
-0.025149021297693253,
0.6121167540550232,
0.527366578578949,
0.2500568628311157,
-0.7207817435264587,
0.32330530881881714,
-0.4300702214241028,
0.5400354862213135,
-0.20805957913398743,
-0.9595081210136414,
-0.22676125168800354,
0.8053869605064392,
-0.7164379954338074,
-0.13200171291828156,
1.0477224588394165,
0.6172963976860046,
0.04665843024849892,
0.25082069635391235,
0.5133463144302368,
-0.0009775767102837563,
0.13951463997364044,
1.0191744565963745,
1.306713581085205,
-0.5925492644309998,
0.7030636668205261,
-0.2802138328552246,
-0.08755455166101456,
-0.03066079504787922,
-0.6836101412773132,
-0.779550313949585,
-0.08891769498586655,
-0.256146103143692,
-0.43117567896842957,
-0.012091214768588543,
1.0682216882705688,
0.3391255736351013,
-0.5552611947059631,
-0.1106545627117157,
-0.3311028480529785,
0.6566480398178101,
0.11454328894615173,
-0.16557011008262634,
0.3352245092391968,
-0.5778785943984985,
-0.4497455656528473,
0.2192055583000183,
0.546819269657135,
-0.18205401301383972,
-0.15052162110805511,
-0.16474753618240356,
0.17574305832386017,
0.20646658539772034,
0.6200125813484192,
-0.20357629656791687,
-0.7130669355392456,
0.07112322747707367,
-0.03992065414786339,
-0.2402081936597824,
0.21132014691829681,
1.1797648668289185,
-0.7002713084220886,
0.5386664271354675,
0.47156643867492676,
0.9775453209877014,
0.3233393132686615,
0.13159064948558807,
0.44112807512283325,
0.02347230724990368,
-0.16040201485157013,
0.04146263748407364,
0.31264013051986694,
0.34786689281463623,
-0.5428767800331116,
0.6202824115753174,
0.4954165518283844,
-0.4846123456954956,
-0.8184298276901245,
0.4311464726924896,
-0.82205730676651,
-0.11807160824537277,
1.0756683349609375,
-0.2102964073419571,
-0.5488597750663757,
-0.2559485137462616,
-0.4541287422180176,
0.025757204741239548,
-0.32945072650909424,
0.9155795574188232,
0.8006408214569092,
-0.23987331986427307,
0.05369171127676964,
-0.6230688691139221,
0.4678664207458496,
0.9406328201293945,
-0.8195347189903259,
0.07435236871242523,
0.06507832556962967,
0.325977087020874,
0.11783912032842636,
0.8319280743598938,
-0.26389336585998535,
0.25156015157699585,
-0.07710437476634979,
-0.1830429881811142,
-0.03770959749817848,
-0.34060412645339966,
-0.29759708046913147,
-0.021011320874094963,
0.08519238978624344,
-0.15574754774570465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14946v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14946v1
|
StoryTTS: A Highly Expressive Text-to-Speech Dataset with Rich Textual Expressiveness Annotations
| 2024-04-23T11:41:35 | 2024-04-23T11:41:35 |
Sen Liu, Yiwei Guo, Xie Chen, Kai Yu
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
While acoustic expressiveness has long been studied in expressive
text-to-speech (ETTS), the inherent expressiveness in text lacks sufficient
attention, especially for ETTS of artistic works. In this paper, we introduce
StoryTTS, a highly ETTS dataset that contains rich expressiveness both in
acoustic and textual perspective, from the recording of a Mandarin storytelling
show. A systematic and comprehensive labeling framework is proposed for textual
expressiveness. We analyze and define speech-related textual expressiveness in
StoryTTS to include five distinct dimensions through linguistics, rhetoric,
etc. Then we employ large language models and prompt them with a few manual
annotation examples for batch annotation. The resulting corpus contains 61
hours of consecutive and highly prosodic speech equipped with accurate text
transcriptions and rich textual expressiveness annotations. Therefore, StoryTTS
can aid future ETTS research to fully mine the abundant intrinsic textual and
acoustic features. Experiments are conducted to validate that TTS models can
generate speech with improved expressiveness when integrating with the
annotated textual labels in StoryTTS.
|
[
0.005635580979287624,
-0.5921556949615479,
0.3102715313434601,
0.6822353601455688,
-0.41534698009490967,
0.5772280097007751,
-0.6565962433815002,
-0.6179124712944031,
0.42750051617622375,
0.38659265637397766,
-0.2800365090370178,
-0.5609766840934753,
-0.5113813281059265,
0.12456189095973969,
-0.4984581172466278,
1.2291350364685059,
-0.004133415874093771,
-0.3357597291469574,
0.5687418580055237,
-0.29433807730674744,
-0.3070043623447418,
-0.3239039480686188,
-0.2963055372238159,
0.09258026629686356,
0.8029518127441406,
0.17660970985889435,
0.7363365888595581,
0.9047958850860596,
0.27708354592323303,
0.3117288053035736,
-0.2641522288322449,
0.23828007280826569,
-0.4239898920059204,
0.42827120423316956,
-0.14048124849796295,
-0.11748021841049194,
-0.18448269367218018,
-0.02694167196750641,
0.6133502125740051,
0.2576414942741394,
-0.08301988244056702,
0.33037543296813965,
0.07685238122940063,
0.22686491906642914,
-0.17004351317882538,
0.2525979280471802,
-0.14825618267059326,
0.13966742157936096,
-0.48468101024627686,
-0.43921124935150146,
-0.714464008808136,
-0.48150840401649475,
0.525098443031311,
-0.8301602005958557,
-0.08430742472410202,
-0.21915365755558014,
0.6546137928962708,
0.09388311207294464,
-0.602929413318634,
-0.1051129549741745,
-0.916197657585144,
0.5922592282295227,
-0.39071616530418396,
0.2590433359146118,
0.09563630074262619,
0.5630968809127808,
0.6183761358261108,
-1.0513123273849487,
-0.45367878675460815,
-0.34234532713890076,
-0.346773236989975,
0.18076032400131226,
0.09135551005601883,
-0.14361748099327087,
0.25300586223602295,
0.43192750215530396,
-0.7136104702949524,
0.03594205901026726,
-0.013951985165476799,
-0.18516239523887634,
0.7181417346000671,
0.2081713080406189,
0.451866090297699,
-0.36388474702835083,
-0.5800855755805969,
-0.012802757322788239,
-0.49406278133392334,
0.11501012742519379,
0.006155224051326513,
0.6257138252258301,
-0.4395780861377716,
0.7737419009208679,
-0.1492096483707428,
0.5507143139839172,
-0.4735442101955414,
0.032301969826221466,
0.31663453578948975,
-0.35918301343917847,
-0.108378566801548,
0.4208088517189026,
0.92681884765625,
0.29020604491233826,
0.367686927318573,
-0.29393330216407776,
-0.21439331769943237,
-0.24241438508033752,
-0.16236835718154907,
-0.8323105573654175,
0.13951721787452698,
0.11879788339138031,
-0.4455569386482239,
-0.5489110350608826,
-0.17280983924865723,
-0.5542077422142029,
-0.7772504091262817,
-0.5051179528236389,
0.3882404565811157,
-0.6291680335998535,
-0.586540162563324,
-0.17947278916835785,
-0.3361453711986542,
0.11261191964149475,
0.3021168112754822,
-0.9221343994140625,
-0.03990735858678818,
0.6403458118438721,
1.0544782876968384,
-0.07082884013652802,
-0.26853397488594055,
-0.6432719826698303,
0.4517841637134552,
-0.5288762450218201,
0.7114253044128418,
-0.5153273344039917,
0.02423768863081932,
-0.11423131078481674,
-0.3032758831977844,
-0.08881492912769318,
-0.3785632848739624,
0.8943184018135071,
-0.02768557518720627,
0.12794092297554016,
-0.20903116464614868,
-0.5211716294288635,
0.014756509102880955,
-0.21358466148376465,
-0.9377935528755188,
1.137628197669983,
0.20594890415668488,
-0.6566293239593506,
0.12595927715301514,
-0.7136858701705933,
-0.6951432824134827,
0.2974745035171509,
-0.045123420655727386,
-0.262850821018219,
0.2515755593776703,
0.15828292071819305,
0.44917717576026917,
-0.07844441384077072,
0.8089430928230286,
0.285786896944046,
-0.5610294938087463,
0.49946045875549316,
-0.5822122693061829,
0.7064003944396973,
0.3308737277984619,
-0.5457614064216614,
0.20660944283008575,
-0.7416759729385376,
0.1321210265159607,
0.14093898236751556,
-0.38064587116241455,
-0.240094393491745,
-0.13962948322296143,
0.6482672691345215,
0.15700288116931915,
0.13121472299098969,
-0.5571157932281494,
0.11403124034404755,
-0.42802029848098755,
0.8260405659675598,
0.5473467111587524,
-0.1779823899269104,
-0.1236225888133049,
-0.6228170990943909,
0.36653274297714233,
-0.22576092183589935,
-0.41279762983322144,
-0.6546143889427185,
-0.37503913044929504,
-0.3632907271385193,
-0.4715222716331482,
0.383090078830719,
0.5524043440818787,
-0.8304629325866699,
0.39201897382736206,
-0.5268530249595642,
-0.8275861144065857,
-0.6255435347557068,
-0.5824331641197205,
0.4894319176673889,
0.4261203408241272,
0.25412872433662415,
0.328473299741745,
-0.6631115674972534,
-1.0034065246582031,
-0.7468156218528748,
-0.28803524374961853,
-0.3771090805530548,
0.10035659372806549,
-0.08086106926202774,
0.7548285126686096,
0.9058951735496521,
0.042203716933727264,
-0.48028549551963806,
-0.40174004435539246,
0.6507513523101807,
-0.13710708916187286,
0.2144760638475418,
0.5570045709609985,
-0.8682518005371094,
-0.6323084831237793,
0.33914002776145935,
-0.7213653922080994,
-0.3036561906337738,
-0.2757207453250885,
0.16506502032279968,
0.2508702874183655,
0.1540217101573944,
-0.6166687607765198,
0.346482515335083,
0.34350550174713135,
-0.5563992261886597,
0.6157972812652588,
0.3318288028240204,
0.3875933587551117,
-0.9602071046829224,
0.028857605531811714,
0.2567199766635895,
-0.39133220911026,
-0.5717282295227051,
-0.1620723009109497,
-0.20410223305225372,
-0.21759219467639923,
-0.4615153968334198,
0.5722629427909851,
-0.20825925469398499,
-0.035974279046058655,
0.07070524990558624,
0.4169413447380066,
0.23414453864097595,
0.6610334515571594,
0.6291022300720215,
0.9007768034934998,
0.3381081521511078,
-0.1359560489654541,
0.6686210632324219,
0.4787680506706238,
-0.40998080372810364,
0.6432193517684937,
-0.5582033395767212,
-0.08769550174474716,
0.2328050583600998,
0.25674939155578613,
-0.7990987300872803,
-0.16349899768829346,
0.0027223159559071064,
-0.6004323959350586,
0.3014163076877594,
0.11198700219392776,
-0.7028622031211853,
0.0923071876168251,
-0.418544203042984,
-0.024793457239866257,
0.22139425575733185,
-0.5690934658050537,
0.9535728693008423,
0.14552682638168335,
-0.8021314144134521,
-0.43394118547439575,
-0.6643373370170593,
0.6027448177337646,
-0.41932111978530884,
-0.628951907157898,
0.37718215584754944,
0.14359313249588013,
-0.004081046208739281,
-0.10688118636608124,
0.19660475850105286,
-0.04782896488904953,
-0.26041749119758606,
-0.08433175832033157,
-0.0022656035143882036,
-0.5909029841423035,
0.5269717574119568,
0.043908312916755676,
-0.11657308787107468,
-0.14737039804458618,
-0.008354266174137592,
0.3555937111377716,
-0.4113615155220032,
0.16029885411262512,
-0.9331430196762085,
0.49614039063453674,
0.5019629597663879,
-0.4048226475715637,
0.2766309082508087,
0.6967648863792419,
-0.14445644617080688,
0.1390760987997055,
-0.35958945751190186,
0.12345355749130249,
-0.39568930864334106,
0.5933737754821777,
-0.46018263697624207,
-0.8379294872283936,
0.45971444249153137,
0.005575559567660093,
0.20452050864696503,
0.6665610671043396,
0.5486875176429749,
-0.27131780982017517,
0.8594138622283936,
0.28595462441444397,
0.16949798166751862,
0.5936325788497925,
-0.010869888588786125,
-0.0676688626408577,
-0.7842997312545776,
-0.22009746730327606,
-0.7835099697113037,
-0.47822922468185425,
-0.736752986907959,
-0.14383651316165924,
0.0004638575192075223,
-0.6146795153617859,
-0.4239248037338257,
0.4879162609577179,
-0.6467764377593994,
0.43140149116516113,
0.41275906562805176,
0.11012408137321472,
0.5723344087600708,
0.015724679455161095,
0.09272343665361404,
-0.49214616417884827,
-0.2857825756072998,
-0.8835175037384033,
0.8031312823295593,
0.4498337507247925,
0.39899536967277527,
0.3920503258705139,
0.30243194103240967,
0.139542818069458,
0.3902219235897064,
-0.7612503170967102,
0.4057927131652832,
-0.3235105872154236,
-0.4798654019832611,
-0.5691189765930176,
-0.4376288056373596,
-0.38326045870780945,
0.026562565937638283,
-0.2667991816997528,
-0.9524688720703125,
0.06630946695804596,
0.0039168912917375565,
-0.3675062656402588,
0.21559982001781464,
-0.9361200928688049,
0.8550857901573181,
-0.2752516269683838,
-0.5951036810874939,
0.1168007105588913,
-0.9176837801933289,
0.10104925185441971,
0.011786095798015594,
-0.0188008863478899,
-0.12604811787605286,
-0.11903531104326248,
0.9703332185745239,
-0.2874354124069214,
1.0641605854034424,
-0.028723550960421562,
-0.22544671595096588,
0.40949898958206177,
0.294921338558197,
0.5515545010566711,
-0.044365402311086655,
-0.2802048325538635,
0.05765751749277115,
-0.11477859318256378,
0.0909765362739563,
-0.6514636278152466,
0.4049089252948761,
-0.4213253855705261,
-0.3021707236766815,
-0.28644248843193054,
-0.5145717859268188,
-0.17929452657699585,
0.1804206371307373,
0.40163561701774597,
0.806527853012085,
-0.3563406765460968,
0.28151458501815796,
0.5720828175544739,
-0.15482927858829498,
0.678084135055542,
0.24148397147655487,
-0.24104434251785278,
-0.26612308621406555,
1.1858978271484375,
0.08349516242742538,
0.15682542324066162,
0.683953046798706,
0.38607317209243774,
-0.6186535358428955,
-0.4051443338394165,
-0.7757827043533325,
0.07977146655321121,
-0.4137520492076874,
-0.08544579148292542,
-0.597287654876709,
-0.5340539813041687,
-0.07368453592061996,
-0.07418230921030045,
-0.39553260803222656,
-1.129392147064209,
-0.333060622215271,
-0.5783334970474243,
0.7964246869087219,
0.8240062594413757,
-0.01139543205499649,
0.4745228886604309,
-0.8244336843490601,
0.4596169888973236,
0.06808996200561523,
0.5538790822029114,
-0.11609987914562225,
-0.5106674432754517,
-0.28158867359161377,
-0.10876002162694931,
-0.46720150113105774,
-0.6795651912689209,
0.325067400932312,
0.5835347771644592,
0.1658405065536499,
0.25152596831321716,
0.2926998734474182,
0.29275116324424744,
-0.3196764588356018,
0.8642122149467468,
0.03228580579161644,
-1.200347900390625,
0.48689037561416626,
-0.8346139192581177,
0.13393646478652954,
0.19578701257705688,
0.03596324473619461,
-0.9051569104194641,
-0.83785080909729,
-0.5074154138565063,
-0.8930597901344299,
0.8119078874588013,
0.5932375192642212,
0.18296507000923157,
0.29689204692840576,
-0.1355978101491928,
0.20793680846691132,
0.23523549735546112,
-0.9586337208747864,
-0.013658384792506695,
-0.6163079142570496,
-0.4956064522266388,
-0.10406527668237686,
-0.23328843712806702,
-0.24822501838207245,
0.029278628528118134,
0.6014416217803955,
-0.050645552575588226,
0.10244601964950562,
0.13079839944839478,
-0.06636527925729752,
-0.06363216042518616,
0.4761720895767212,
0.5855699181556702,
0.5293776988983154,
-0.1682257056236267,
0.23816470801830292,
-0.42126548290252686,
-0.5272216200828552,
0.06297019869089127,
0.4089384377002716,
0.02513318881392479,
0.24262115359306335,
0.7658795714378357,
1.223003625869751,
-0.02196451835334301,
-0.8211570978164673,
0.577154278755188,
-0.14438077807426453,
0.08207627385854721,
-0.139856219291687,
-0.268882155418396,
0.31274163722991943,
0.25102686882019043,
0.5451904535293579,
-0.08717713505029678,
0.25645989179611206,
-0.24086244404315948,
0.15333881974220276,
-0.02039352059364319,
-0.6314689517021179,
-0.18624679744243622,
0.7425128817558289,
0.4839998483657837,
-0.35334113240242004,
0.32215896248817444,
0.07901865988969803,
-0.5032022595405579,
0.6568073630332947,
0.38680222630500793,
0.9380657076835632,
-0.460846483707428,
0.4461139738559723,
0.14454561471939087,
0.40774914622306824,
0.33778002858161926,
0.14254921674728394,
-0.18106487393379211,
-0.21743617951869965,
-0.6483149528503418,
-0.29643484950065613,
-0.42880046367645264,
0.012828250415623188,
-0.5712376832962036,
0.45230892300605774,
-0.1301361620426178,
0.03735509142279625,
0.40234145522117615,
-0.21506665647029877,
-0.11895560473203659,
0.29675301909446716,
0.14570072293281555,
0.7583093643188477,
-0.8295878171920776,
0.5155288577079773,
0.4302210509777069,
-0.3353342115879059,
-1.1227326393127441,
-0.16640476882457733,
0.030855553224682808,
-0.5180978178977966,
0.6568955183029175,
0.47309020161628723,
0.06460835784673691,
0.26174575090408325,
-0.38763245940208435,
-0.4319894015789032,
0.9162269234657288,
0.5380067229270935,
-0.5998015999794006,
0.06095803529024124,
0.447111576795578,
0.8123267889022827,
-0.3437783420085907,
0.5162209272384644,
0.7351170182228088,
0.5445579886436462,
0.3646394610404968,
-1.2250217199325562,
0.12122486531734467,
-0.37010276317596436,
-0.01037050224840641,
0.04642710089683533,
-0.5969008207321167,
0.5156066417694092,
-0.29762741923332214,
-0.36789563298225403,
0.25466886162757874,
0.6039877533912659,
0.41788554191589355,
0.5107899904251099,
0.25378361344337463,
0.21750693023204803,
0.6323587894439697,
-0.44489747285842896,
0.8248517513275146,
0.25926005840301514,
0.1669599711894989,
1.1380970478057861,
-0.32514944672584534,
0.6966978311538696,
0.002416567876935005,
0.02462567761540413,
0.27889442443847656,
0.822522759437561,
0.18689484894275665,
0.4913330078125,
0.17888693511486053,
-0.49909165501594543,
-0.08764785528182983,
-0.5750898718833923,
-0.45775797963142395,
0.5185012221336365,
0.4090918302536011,
-0.4492424428462982,
-0.1614966243505478,
0.26626163721084595,
0.04617404192686081,
0.22807759046554565,
-0.013195141218602657,
0.8941730260848999,
-0.03475670516490936,
-0.3679921329021454,
0.3863562047481537,
-0.256177693605423,
0.46704012155532837,
-0.5813812613487244,
-0.23574256896972656,
0.056863293051719666,
-0.4424591660499573,
-0.25418412685394287,
-1.1952563524246216,
0.3522164225578308,
0.12011489272117615,
0.09564141929149628,
-0.40802904963493347,
0.450783908367157,
-0.4984202980995178,
-0.313990980386734,
0.10333073139190674,
0.28983035683631897,
0.07574748247861862,
-0.06023276597261429,
-0.02636507898569107,
0.050064217299222946,
-0.06947024166584015,
-0.816305935382843,
-0.059050437062978745,
1.0762861967086792,
-0.32347050309181213,
0.4652774930000305,
0.3873392641544342,
0.18913747370243073,
-0.2382195144891739,
0.27926212549209595,
0.7046574354171753,
-0.9206413626670837,
-0.8095298409461975,
-0.6874159574508667,
0.6700018048286438,
-0.12132377922534943,
-0.4788186848163605,
0.34272557497024536,
0.9321975111961365,
0.2771155834197998,
0.04134475439786911,
1.186206579208374,
-0.001383118680678308,
1.0340567827224731,
-0.5883562564849854,
0.8746169805526733,
-0.23768950998783112,
0.3036951720714569,
-0.365998238325119,
-0.6699716448783875,
-0.2866785526275635,
0.393372505903244,
-0.048784248530864716,
0.19697882235050201,
0.735205888748169,
0.23284882307052612,
0.22775012254714966,
0.7155367136001587,
0.18974995613098145,
0.5066267251968384,
0.3369673490524292,
0.5035252571105957,
1.2848877906799316,
-0.15735892951488495,
0.5289726257324219,
-0.279506117105484,
-0.3212955594062805,
-0.11794444173574448,
-1.2255364656448364,
-0.5300170183181763,
-0.8323200941085815,
-0.4018053412437439,
0.0054332599975168705,
-0.08063377439975739,
0.7519080638885498,
0.47709494829177856,
-0.44133782386779785,
-0.23475238680839539,
0.36610928177833557,
-0.06480418145656586,
-0.5378481149673462,
-0.30160942673683167,
0.8305947780609131,
0.14153678715229034,
-0.7231126427650452,
0.36963966488838196,
0.35645776987075806,
0.2689852714538574,
0.14676633477210999,
0.1399778425693512,
0.1654517650604248,
-0.003080179914832115,
0.7780457139015198,
0.19179002940654755,
-0.40511587262153625,
-0.3356562554836273,
-0.06042958050966263,
-0.08160315454006195,
0.20435243844985962,
1.0690679550170898,
-0.9616225957870483,
0.376724511384964,
0.08748183399438858,
0.4693213105201721,
0.6376135349273682,
-0.026808306574821472,
0.5186412930488586,
-1.1172469854354858,
0.2161441147327423,
0.6108447909355164,
0.05171268805861473,
0.4713558256626129,
-0.47944730520248413,
0.5851410627365112,
0.08392593264579773,
-0.31114110350608826,
-0.7899388670921326,
0.1173795536160469,
-1.3779858350753784,
-0.021043548360466957,
0.9501311779022217,
-0.18040210008621216,
0.16523203253746033,
-0.20392630994319916,
-0.46529677510261536,
0.5258866548538208,
-0.5873011350631714,
0.5257273316383362,
0.741368293762207,
-0.13567841053009033,
-0.30180639028549194,
-0.6899283528327942,
0.5226569175720215,
0.08448820561170578,
-0.7898714542388916,
0.8416128158569336,
0.42914074659347534,
-0.15398265421390533,
0.07714209705591202,
0.5934110879898071,
-0.17099282145500183,
0.2730760872364044,
-0.38399869203567505,
-0.024188358336687088,
-0.3727588653564453,
-0.2946425676345825,
-0.041824229061603546,
0.12585148215293884,
-0.06040564551949501,
0.015668747946619987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14943v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14943v1
|
Does It Make Sense to Explain a Black Box With Another Black Box?
| 2024-04-23T11:40:30 | 2024-04-23T11:40:30 |
Julien Delaunay, Luis Galárraga, Christine Largouët
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50
|
Although counterfactual explanations are a popular approach to explain ML
black-box classifiers, they are less widespread in NLP. Most methods find those
explanations by iteratively perturbing the target document until it is
classified differently by the black box. We identify two main families of
counterfactual explanation methods in the literature, namely, (a)
\emph{transparent} methods that perturb the target by adding, removing, or
replacing words, and (b) \emph{opaque} approaches that project the target
document into a latent, non-interpretable space where the perturbation is
carried out subsequently. This article offers a comparative study of the
performance of these two families of methods on three classical NLP tasks. Our
empirical evidence shows that opaque approaches can be an overkill for
downstream applications such as fake news detection or sentiment analysis since
they add an additional level of complexity with no significant performance
gain. These observations motivate our discussion, which raises the question of
whether it makes sense to explain a black box using another black box.
|
[
-0.4840240478515625,
-1.0924431085586548,
0.6825286746025085,
0.01139301247894764,
-0.5169151425361633,
-0.0046127610839903355,
0.18216046690940857,
-0.49298161268234253,
0.12887336313724518,
0.291486531496048,
-0.7387484312057495,
-0.032569773495197296,
-0.5099102854728699,
-0.3319130837917328,
-0.5639151930809021,
1.1386827230453491,
-0.1573556661605835,
-0.03206560015678406,
-0.07274889945983887,
-0.18243049085140228,
-0.5907046794891357,
-0.5656716823577881,
-0.5468685626983643,
-0.7500643730163574,
0.5805531740188599,
0.13717679679393768,
1.1302001476287842,
0.48557615280151367,
-0.03742462396621704,
0.3346554934978485,
0.06826511770486832,
-0.27777722477912903,
-0.37018096446990967,
-0.06822706013917923,
-0.4842907190322876,
-0.6791035532951355,
-0.07547995448112488,
0.18653985857963562,
0.21768714487552643,
0.7099290490150452,
-0.05246792361140251,
0.04079484939575195,
0.060744207352399826,
0.5905877947807312,
-0.7574880719184875,
-0.3675213158130646,
-0.5133352875709534,
0.5917408466339111,
0.12498048692941666,
-0.5345113277435303,
-0.4646998643875122,
-0.05151040479540825,
0.28652268648147583,
-0.638940155506134,
0.38183948397636414,
0.06369004398584366,
0.8303859829902649,
0.2124614268541336,
-0.036491237580776215,
-0.19842714071273804,
-1.0787352323532104,
0.7423620820045471,
-0.4135188162326813,
0.27151814103126526,
0.16214017570018768,
0.43619948625564575,
0.10674142092466354,
-0.6473312973976135,
-0.7460564374923706,
0.1240590438246727,
-0.5283869504928589,
0.5212973356246948,
-0.6323146224021912,
-0.14252221584320068,
0.1668315976858139,
0.39385735988616943,
-0.6240634918212891,
0.21009927988052368,
-0.36049309372901917,
-0.12545329332351685,
0.4577609598636627,
-0.10454634577035904,
0.05506278946995735,
0.1381492167711258,
-0.5837823748588562,
0.11189313977956772,
-0.6633942723274231,
-0.11723512411117554,
0.5156705379486084,
-0.22415095567703247,
-0.0748172476887703,
0.601224958896637,
0.16040873527526855,
0.5936982035636902,
0.32421472668647766,
0.3171941936016083,
0.011917692609131336,
-0.30667176842689514,
-0.40795016288757324,
0.25219759345054626,
0.4609234929084778,
0.42442986369132996,
0.16497361660003662,
-0.4504941701889038,
-0.016077294945716858,
0.4088709354400635,
0.8062551021575928,
-0.7184691429138184,
-0.05450744554400444,
0.6147262454032898,
-0.615817666053772,
-0.31145575642585754,
-0.2489553540945053,
-0.8908702731132507,
-0.3633019030094147,
-0.27285823225975037,
0.8042294383049011,
-0.05057572200894356,
-0.35539698600769043,
0.12220065295696259,
-0.4242631494998932,
-0.03400697186589241,
0.5460660457611084,
-0.6492983102798462,
0.3094814419746399,
0.7809274196624756,
0.7729209661483765,
0.12640923261642456,
-0.08051475137472153,
-0.4502074718475342,
-0.01651744544506073,
-0.6224352121353149,
0.8418863415718079,
-0.7260533571243286,
-0.10942280292510986,
0.04399515315890312,
0.07265479117631912,
0.11801370978355408,
-0.3021778464317322,
0.029630914330482483,
-0.3997437059879303,
0.6086212396621704,
-0.1107274740934372,
-0.3724747598171234,
-0.7729836106300354,
-0.04094602167606354,
-0.4206608533859253,
0.7155001163482666,
0.026417432352900505,
-0.7489627003669739,
0.5493054986000061,
-0.7046514749526978,
-0.23484806716442108,
0.28770941495895386,
-0.07498075813055038,
-0.6787347197532654,
0.4088656008243561,
0.06015173718333244,
0.45575687289237976,
0.26549428701400757,
0.20586998760700226,
-0.37732571363449097,
-0.8012365102767944,
0.45983290672302246,
-0.7396358847618103,
0.8834609389305115,
0.13286098837852478,
-0.7618744969367981,
-0.20003776252269745,
-0.519902765750885,
-0.1395263820886612,
0.012433113530278206,
0.049490779638290405,
-0.48512396216392517,
0.17203865945339203,
-0.2574586570262909,
0.19271861016750336,
-0.058996010571718216,
-0.5825355648994446,
-0.29016029834747314,
-0.5114073753356934,
0.23184606432914734,
0.5711934566497803,
0.09695541113615036,
0.4054853022098541,
-0.4486660063266754,
0.7064893841743469,
0.07209013402462006,
0.27281421422958374,
-0.26709991693496704,
-0.6462987065315247,
-0.478117436170578,
0.08251581341028214,
0.14006729423999786,
0.5304166078567505,
-0.648486852645874,
-0.018195124343037605,
0.3135691285133362,
-0.15846078097820282,
-0.5764507055282593,
-0.0025678391102701426,
0.599609375,
0.5308612585067749,
0.5055302977561951,
-0.18469688296318054,
-0.4696677029132843,
-0.9087677597999573,
-0.40907740592956543,
-0.07715282589197159,
-0.010026112198829651,
0.34782874584198,
0.572149932384491,
-0.013310213573276997,
0.7705253958702087,
-0.17723150551319122,
0.08027433604001999,
0.19377517700195312,
0.23172597587108612,
0.13545900583267212,
0.4194546043872833,
0.639178454875946,
-0.947505533695221,
-0.1108945682644844,
-0.022763505578041077,
-0.8164687156677246,
-0.022134551778435707,
-0.2707507908344269,
0.061005908995866776,
0.38526487350463867,
0.6534259915351868,
-0.27236518263816833,
0.6249662637710571,
0.6844752430915833,
-0.3536283075809479,
0.5994901061058044,
-0.10703779011964798,
-0.05762661248445511,
-0.3951856791973114,
-0.11602204293012619,
-0.10735537111759186,
-0.25299271941185,
-0.8849994540214539,
0.28397634625434875,
-0.18534909188747406,
-0.03306419402360916,
-0.6212171912193298,
0.3792698383331299,
-0.2572796046733856,
-0.12057599425315857,
-0.25016146898269653,
0.3112388253211975,
0.3801509737968445,
0.564781129360199,
0.11301620304584503,
0.4482773542404175,
0.4484991133213043,
-0.3714200556278229,
0.22487454116344452,
-0.14501778781414032,
-0.0014624628238379955,
0.6687344312667847,
-0.719799280166626,
0.07032429426908493,
-0.5445905923843384,
0.2818134129047394,
-1.229892611503601,
0.4028603732585907,
0.7178108096122742,
-0.41802194714546204,
0.27834799885749817,
-0.2826700210571289,
-0.2848062217235565,
-0.1552342176437378,
-0.5375095009803772,
0.2038886845111847,
0.32573050260543823,
-0.7978785037994385,
0.553642749786377,
-0.26184892654418945,
0.08873818814754486,
-1.0084834098815918,
-1.155961036682129,
-0.003035301808267832,
-0.4644978940486908,
-0.17473457753658295,
0.31859704852104187,
-0.12236375361680984,
-0.4638745188713074,
0.2961043417453766,
-0.49844294786453247,
0.018922874704003334,
0.443492591381073,
0.5082038640975952,
0.1689487099647522,
-0.4867531955242157,
0.2654136121273041,
0.11669203639030457,
-0.22668981552124023,
0.09812632203102112,
-0.3815510869026184,
0.10089128464460373,
-0.002827299991622567,
-0.21864555776119232,
-0.2187889665365219,
0.6428654193878174,
-0.03394533693790436,
0.06893987208604813,
1.0589107275009155,
0.6822077631950378,
-0.4028529226779938,
-0.2632363438606262,
-0.5670631527900696,
-0.053443051874637604,
-0.47269392013549805,
-0.08720114082098007,
-0.528622567653656,
-0.45847517251968384,
0.3351181447505951,
0.2307458221912384,
0.22234109044075012,
0.3875196874141693,
0.616290271282196,
-0.29688897728919983,
0.8159605860710144,
0.6172236204147339,
0.5074735283851624,
0.3683071434497833,
-0.19111375510692596,
0.43062132596969604,
-0.43089425563812256,
-0.21200303733348846,
-0.5693268775939941,
-0.05693953111767769,
-0.5288780331611633,
-0.12429038435220718,
-0.1914249211549759,
0.30308741331100464,
0.13871800899505615,
0.2388325333595276,
-0.6988297700881958,
0.4591882526874542,
0.38728779554367065,
0.16430841386318207,
0.5171476602554321,
0.23989921808242798,
-0.06316196173429489,
0.023138409480452538,
-0.9069954752922058,
-0.5091134905815125,
0.965039849281311,
0.5768004655838013,
0.5443651676177979,
0.11130323261022568,
0.4811762869358063,
0.11805181950330734,
0.7103028893470764,
-0.6229829788208008,
0.1329038441181183,
-0.3633709251880646,
-0.8657391667366028,
-0.43133544921875,
-0.0638333335518837,
-1.2254068851470947,
0.8400669097900391,
-0.5765718221664429,
-0.8905686736106873,
0.4268251061439514,
0.3899233043193817,
-0.3892236053943634,
0.07850535959005356,
-1.1402702331542969,
0.8053223490715027,
-0.002589145442470908,
-0.559685230255127,
-0.4548585116863251,
-0.20530791580677032,
0.48239144682884216,
-0.22805997729301453,
0.34332820773124695,
0.4090854525566101,
-0.09469272941350937,
0.9022782444953918,
-0.4914502203464508,
0.8178892135620117,
-0.36627382040023804,
-0.22893577814102173,
-0.04638681188225746,
0.2402421087026596,
0.2540597915649414,
0.24286675453186035,
-0.0046325973235070705,
0.46432042121887207,
-0.01388050802052021,
-0.4259745180606842,
-0.9348328709602356,
0.5513398051261902,
-0.3494436740875244,
-0.9227810502052307,
-0.25393688678741455,
-0.4113256335258484,
0.08454832434654236,
0.057333044707775116,
0.3446134626865387,
0.6497686505317688,
0.3140801787376404,
0.2500663697719574,
0.6142038702964783,
-0.4508272707462311,
0.5388489961624146,
0.745690107345581,
-0.0027324629481881857,
0.285199910402298,
0.6926172375679016,
0.41695088148117065,
0.09611853212118149,
0.6410520076751709,
0.4914573132991791,
-0.407802551984787,
-0.8953062295913696,
-0.46087032556533813,
0.10376958549022675,
-0.565136194229126,
0.33136653900146484,
-0.7529155015945435,
0.13031364977359772,
-0.03171096369624138,
-0.5665755271911621,
-0.07546152919530869,
-0.47468432784080505,
-0.19642221927642822,
-0.12597741186618805,
0.11173535138368607,
0.5752162337303162,
-0.03838130831718445,
0.34383025765419006,
-0.2035266011953354,
0.959406852722168,
0.4514504373073578,
0.5962367057800293,
0.18734823167324066,
-0.24974359571933746,
-0.16845016181468964,
0.14852038025856018,
-0.27383551001548767,
-1.1529172658920288,
-0.01339433528482914,
-0.165573850274086,
0.693579912185669,
0.4851059019565582,
0.051741909235715866,
0.793902575969696,
-0.4524839222431183,
0.6586025357246399,
0.12793537974357605,
-0.8192875981330872,
0.3334466516971588,
0.10791948437690735,
0.1365620642900467,
0.08756749331951141,
0.6722996830940247,
-0.23637203872203827,
-0.9423804879188538,
-1.0106639862060547,
-0.5310068726539612,
0.71586674451828,
0.24635863304138184,
-0.013349832035601139,
0.5128270387649536,
0.33325129747390747,
0.5593191385269165,
0.4051864445209503,
-1.0484471321105957,
-0.6501750946044922,
-0.7958452701568604,
0.18952368199825287,
-0.5165992379188538,
-0.42610830068588257,
-0.3756265938282013,
0.2988290786743164,
0.593909502029419,
0.12529852986335754,
0.3504599928855896,
0.4296083450317383,
-0.270865797996521,
-0.4808526933193207,
0.436567485332489,
0.4943675398826599,
1.1050188541412354,
-0.24297499656677246,
0.3283041715621948,
-0.08588258922100067,
-0.21039508283138275,
0.11424436420202255,
0.35387012362480164,
-0.36875292658805847,
0.3203076720237732,
0.7445693612098694,
0.5471424460411072,
0.03243444859981537,
-0.19571946561336517,
0.519139289855957,
0.12518629431724548,
-0.5773077011108398,
-0.11436115205287933,
0.0614541620016098,
-0.03809373453259468,
0.43042680621147156,
0.3416748344898224,
-0.06274958699941635,
0.3155405819416046,
-0.9869742393493652,
0.06444483995437622,
0.7247453927993774,
-0.44812536239624023,
-0.08681514114141464,
0.7372453212738037,
-0.1292448341846466,
-0.49018925428390503,
-0.1106327548623085,
0.05248818174004555,
-0.5542750954627991,
0.4595961570739746,
0.3788098692893982,
0.706788182258606,
-0.05704865977168083,
0.6603171229362488,
-0.12228865176439285,
0.6216737031936646,
0.154862180352211,
-0.031046399846673012,
-0.38312405347824097,
-0.6749254465103149,
-0.8082056045532227,
-0.27695053815841675,
-0.5282446146011353,
0.5476987361907959,
-0.41955065727233887,
-0.19682617485523224,
-0.3535176217556,
0.19003769755363464,
0.8131176829338074,
0.14726471900939941,
-0.4910222589969635,
0.3145909309387207,
-0.13457289338111877,
0.6921640634536743,
-0.9937745928764343,
0.23343734443187714,
0.5678591132164001,
-0.18502293527126312,
-0.331332266330719,
0.026499604806303978,
-0.01220754161477089,
-0.649688184261322,
0.257840633392334,
-0.04360198229551315,
-0.03492177650332451,
-0.6618705987930298,
-0.4698672890663147,
-0.2543763518333435,
0.2948450446128845,
0.21779362857341766,
-0.7220446467399597,
0.210843026638031,
-0.17298294603824615,
0.8398396372795105,
-0.15281347930431366,
0.39996686577796936,
0.3249393403530121,
0.7769302725791931,
-0.29605820775032043,
-0.5075660347938538,
0.4697367548942566,
0.028351061046123505,
-0.1065940111875534,
0.04140962287783623,
-0.3827861547470093,
0.5116261839866638,
-0.15971259772777557,
-0.5094929337501526,
-0.345019668340683,
0.18087339401245117,
-0.037654370069503784,
0.8030943870544434,
0.6687829494476318,
0.19093820452690125,
0.2049846649169922,
-0.06452999264001846,
1.0727189779281616,
0.22296102344989777,
0.07947827875614166,
0.8398784399032593,
0.17492902278900146,
0.3168240487575531,
0.5523302555084229,
-0.2373674064874649,
0.7011369466781616,
0.41370970010757446,
-0.21876810491085052,
0.26855704188346863,
0.3004198670387268,
0.28732219338417053,
0.0016555016627535224,
0.196070596575737,
-0.3312431275844574,
0.15926843881607056,
0.47621703147888184,
-0.16016025841236115,
-0.47157981991767883,
0.13055941462516785,
0.07228336483240128,
0.2540900707244873,
-0.297773152589798,
0.6466556787490845,
0.0664740800857544,
-0.7580385208129883,
0.7057931423187256,
-0.04892301931977272,
0.5069151520729065,
-0.1700204610824585,
-0.313229501247406,
-0.03701024875044823,
0.05141935870051384,
-0.6039285063743591,
-0.8441516160964966,
0.494133323431015,
-0.30029982328414917,
-0.16271746158599854,
-0.5178820490837097,
0.588255763053894,
-0.33338066935539246,
-0.32281360030174255,
0.33894315361976624,
0.46400803327560425,
0.2897321879863739,
-0.036337967962026596,
-0.9348250031471252,
-0.22705292701721191,
-0.23298197984695435,
-0.3305162787437439,
-0.01434770692139864,
0.41921505331993103,
-0.15103097259998322,
0.6024978756904602,
0.577448844909668,
0.07201100885868073,
0.039188094437122345,
-0.004967436660081148,
0.40519610047340393,
-0.45325303077697754,
-0.5968778729438782,
-0.7799738049507141,
0.43358898162841797,
0.18669457733631134,
-0.05144526809453964,
0.7731266021728516,
0.2946268320083618,
0.6501170992851257,
0.06616204231977463,
0.6416168808937073,
0.3076954185962677,
0.5407556295394897,
-0.7479379177093506,
0.2175092101097107,
-0.8129160404205322,
0.3349347710609436,
-0.4176582992076874,
-0.9445800185203552,
-0.22373583912849426,
0.503564715385437,
-0.19279171526432037,
-0.04926302656531334,
1.0561072826385498,
0.6763811111450195,
-0.10288536548614502,
0.22900137305259705,
0.25255972146987915,
0.7711920738220215,
0.03516329824924469,
0.35609379410743713,
0.9962424039840698,
-0.3488193452358246,
0.810460090637207,
-0.4889605641365051,
-0.28948813676834106,
-0.32534700632095337,
-0.9603926539421082,
-0.9497086405754089,
-0.41397953033447266,
-0.7248485684394836,
-0.38924118876457214,
0.5020373463630676,
-0.10866908729076385,
0.8507421612739563,
-0.6755223274230957,
0.2643890678882599,
-0.12699288129806519,
0.7994334697723389,
-0.6977434754371643,
-0.27088651061058044,
0.20834101736545563,
0.12058329582214355,
-0.6586446762084961,
0.3114131987094879,
0.3242594599723816,
0.16022862493991852,
-0.4300689101219177,
0.26346495747566223,
-0.08377853780984879,
0.21638475358486176,
0.5596718788146973,
0.2306513786315918,
-0.8058224320411682,
-0.3418371379375458,
-0.5149885416030884,
0.5185157060623169,
-0.04077739641070366,
0.8365554809570312,
-1.0335297584533691,
0.5653664469718933,
0.4163047969341278,
0.29672738909721375,
0.8849689364433289,
0.1648712158203125,
0.6208979487419128,
-0.5581644773483276,
0.24765557050704956,
-0.12482123076915741,
0.12779776751995087,
0.08058373630046844,
-0.702099084854126,
0.422242134809494,
0.10069633275270462,
-0.02082270383834839,
-1.040272831916809,
0.15884384512901306,
-0.8275771141052246,
-1.095826268196106,
0.8646963834762573,
-0.09743569046258926,
-0.07151032984256744,
-0.8514389395713806,
0.06278650462627411,
-0.025337181985378265,
-0.38391008973121643,
0.800902783870697,
0.7273678779602051,
-0.018142182379961014,
-0.4210497736930847,
-0.6732878684997559,
0.2688838541507721,
0.5683130025863647,
-0.455423504114151,
-0.16814875602722168,
0.1776983141899109,
0.07683960348367691,
0.4406651556491852,
0.4851115643978119,
-0.13626053929328918,
0.5731298327445984,
0.23648399114608765,
-0.4634406864643097,
-0.24613125622272491,
-0.31028982996940613,
-0.6631684303283691,
0.4455457925796509,
-0.500657320022583,
-0.2530782222747803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14928v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14928v2
|
Graph Machine Learning in the Era of Large Language Models (LLMs)
| 2024-04-23T11:13:39 | 2024-06-04T01:31:30 |
Wenqi Fan, Shijie Wang, Jiani Huang, Zhikai Chen, Yu Song, Wenzhuo Tang, Haitao Mao, Hui Liu, Xiaorui Liu, Dawei Yin, Qing Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Graphs play an important role in representing complex relationships in
various domains like social networks, knowledge graphs, and molecular
discovery. With the advent of deep learning, Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have
emerged as a cornerstone in Graph Machine Learning (Graph ML), facilitating the
representation and processing of graph structures. Recently, LLMs have
demonstrated unprecedented capabilities in language tasks and are widely
adopted in a variety of applications such as computer vision and recommender
systems. This remarkable success has also attracted interest in applying LLMs
to the graph domain. Increasing efforts have been made to explore the potential
of LLMs in advancing Graph ML's generalization, transferability, and few-shot
learning ability. Meanwhile, graphs, especially knowledge graphs, are rich in
reliable factual knowledge, which can be utilized to enhance the reasoning
capabilities of LLMs and potentially alleviate their limitations such as
hallucinations and the lack of explainability. Given the rapid progress of this
research direction, a systematic review summarizing the latest advancements for
Graph ML in the era of LLMs is necessary to provide an in-depth understanding
to researchers and practitioners. Therefore, in this survey, we first review
the recent developments in Graph ML. We then explore how LLMs can be utilized
to enhance the quality of graph features, alleviate the reliance on labeled
data, and address challenges such as graph heterogeneity and
out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization. Afterward, we delve into how graphs
can enhance LLMs, highlighting their abilities to enhance LLM pre-training and
inference. Furthermore, we investigate various applications and discuss the
potential future directions in this promising field.
|
[
-0.28486040234565735,
-1.0099446773529053,
0.7220820784568787,
-0.24505063891410828,
-0.08879115432500839,
0.44327864050865173,
-0.25600093603134155,
-0.5733949542045593,
0.10029841959476471,
0.7077030539512634,
-0.24071359634399414,
-0.8800985217094421,
-0.9204241633415222,
0.146325021982193,
-0.38029542565345764,
0.6055304408073425,
-0.19791966676712036,
0.27680712938308716,
-0.30141133069992065,
-0.19374334812164307,
-0.24765698611736298,
-0.6482816338539124,
-0.7214697599411011,
-0.6329319477081299,
0.860072672367096,
0.1387188732624054,
0.4843977391719818,
0.48577430844306946,
0.407218337059021,
0.3859958350658417,
-0.185552179813385,
0.6562042236328125,
-0.722027063369751,
0.2058723270893097,
0.15124858915805817,
-0.24157167971134186,
-0.5186883807182312,
-0.10200312733650208,
0.7847958207130432,
1.259753942489624,
0.271831750869751,
-0.08120590448379517,
0.15085598826408386,
0.7437664866447449,
-0.3900761306285858,
0.6559386849403381,
-0.6056992411613464,
0.13234326243400574,
-0.058820690959692,
-0.0900258794426918,
-0.35562753677368164,
-0.5254616737365723,
0.17416003346443176,
-0.45414870977401733,
-0.002260131062939763,
0.31979361176490784,
0.6143853068351746,
-0.05396680906414986,
-0.6306594014167786,
-0.3602851927280426,
-0.658585250377655,
0.44417279958724976,
-0.5390473008155823,
0.5858938694000244,
0.13643455505371094,
0.37222403287887573,
-0.5530700087547302,
-1.173152208328247,
-0.28394442796707153,
-0.2177678346633911,
0.0763823613524437,
-0.1060718223452568,
-0.25353825092315674,
0.26241642236709595,
0.20246323943138123,
0.3336580991744995,
-0.3573695123195648,
0.48331418633461,
-0.19856804609298706,
-0.2219361662864685,
0.43774211406707764,
0.3295126259326935,
0.3227560520172119,
0.03126499056816101,
0.015372038818895817,
0.043446049094200134,
-0.8990586400032043,
-0.0748927965760231,
0.36437439918518066,
0.41288822889328003,
0.22649578750133514,
0.5779972672462463,
-0.27121755480766296,
0.8193633556365967,
-0.277499794960022,
-0.05446871742606163,
0.3546237647533417,
-0.32421615719795227,
-0.2348145991563797,
-0.15220974385738373,
0.9307308793067932,
0.17080992460250854,
0.4601602256298065,
-0.11950600147247314,
0.06609881669282913,
-0.2805878818035126,
-0.11025433987379074,
-0.9059646129608154,
-0.22405840456485748,
-0.12350533902645111,
-0.46457797288894653,
-0.21978425979614258,
-0.11270075291395187,
-0.49989524483680725,
-0.6511229872703552,
-0.34923216700553894,
-0.19349965453147888,
-0.32798823714256287,
-0.13286450505256653,
0.11258124560117722,
-0.0022387849166989326,
-0.13701842725276947,
0.5639214515686035,
-0.6178886890411377,
0.2161019891500473,
0.5995745658874512,
0.9196451902389526,
-0.19385047256946564,
-0.284487783908844,
-0.31587913632392883,
0.13810744881629944,
-0.5987061858177185,
0.6006395816802979,
-0.45689019560813904,
-0.31535544991493225,
0.1312149167060852,
0.12812022864818573,
-0.16557590663433075,
-0.525575578212738,
0.13558420538902283,
-0.7481927871704102,
-0.042430777102708817,
-0.13055770099163055,
-0.6582118272781372,
-0.49802660942077637,
0.375929594039917,
-0.6388075947761536,
0.7064245343208313,
0.3644975423812866,
-0.673319399356842,
0.20944224298000336,
-0.40050777792930603,
-0.5935409665107727,
0.04087221249938011,
-0.18877068161964417,
-0.6792717576026917,
-0.0865427628159523,
0.31867289543151855,
0.6754411458969116,
-0.20062018930912018,
0.19988536834716797,
-0.7994192242622375,
-0.3761872351169586,
0.25119760632514954,
-0.16939491033554077,
0.7855141758918762,
0.205134779214859,
0.0907391905784607,
0.38692644238471985,
-0.423448771238327,
0.03894283249974251,
0.30737245082855225,
-0.15346355736255646,
0.01190445851534605,
0.03354706987738609,
-0.24946635961532593,
0.06509193032979965,
-0.0009718985529616475,
-0.2417294681072235,
0.1681838035583496,
-0.3423420488834381,
0.8641995787620544,
0.7159728407859802,
0.09277252852916718,
0.29700967669487,
0.04348479211330414,
0.33214855194091797,
-0.1627427041530609,
0.08599326759576797,
-0.046118900179862976,
-0.5770307779312134,
-0.4368506073951721,
-0.3297206163406372,
0.4635388255119324,
0.5489643216133118,
-0.6619874238967896,
0.5075527429580688,
-0.2303563803434372,
-0.5318353176116943,
-0.13718673586845398,
0.4347114562988281,
0.11821465194225311,
0.5908485651016235,
0.20667091012001038,
-0.2731976807117462,
-0.5893528461456299,
-0.5418700575828552,
-0.061377644538879395,
-0.20934240520000458,
0.17302457988262177,
0.758358359336853,
0.27535828948020935,
-0.6605561375617981,
0.8515181541442871,
-0.6417459845542908,
-0.3224499523639679,
-0.6529507637023926,
-0.30016854405403137,
0.1497109979391098,
-0.026737768203020096,
0.432806134223938,
-0.5670260190963745,
-0.4351482093334198,
0.13041304051876068,
-1.0361441373825073,
0.052523721009492874,
0.44842827320098877,
0.004675325006246567,
0.14117296040058136,
0.7804081439971924,
-0.4420824646949768,
0.23412097990512848,
0.5590680241584778,
-0.06384099274873734,
0.3693089485168457,
-0.18693028390407562,
-0.09978507459163666,
-0.7354702353477478,
-0.06259527802467346,
-0.030561013147234917,
-0.4468774199485779,
-0.44839873909950256,
-0.3561187982559204,
-0.25167977809906006,
-0.17614814639091492,
-0.21773602068424225,
0.5621422529220581,
-0.6498078107833862,
-0.3074922561645508,
-0.31512758135795593,
0.33653566241264343,
-0.04541947320103645,
0.19832172989845276,
-0.2799898684024811,
0.468344122171402,
0.6767963171005249,
-0.47861865162849426,
0.6822853684425354,
0.2237212210893631,
-0.33823642134666443,
0.021575303748250008,
-0.432007372379303,
0.22169993817806244,
-0.16889460384845734,
0.5002148151397705,
-1.1193541288375854,
-0.2732762396335602,
0.4886493980884552,
-0.40480121970176697,
0.5346361398696899,
-0.22685052454471588,
-0.6782640814781189,
-0.72068190574646,
-0.14217260479927063,
0.04985243082046509,
0.47460687160491943,
-0.44323238730430603,
0.6424577236175537,
0.5788843631744385,
-0.09974852949380875,
-0.5371598601341248,
-0.46108248829841614,
0.21397487819194794,
-0.16473005712032318,
-0.5362171530723572,
-0.04125536233186722,
0.12766867876052856,
-0.18530018627643585,
0.16533562541007996,
0.18756236135959625,
0.1119384765625,
0.25278210639953613,
0.21920925378799438,
0.22980232536792755,
-0.1320723444223404,
0.19763977825641632,
-0.28203868865966797,
-0.23749583959579468,
0.07279817759990692,
-0.6090102195739746,
0.664352297782898,
-0.11727400869131088,
-0.41218000650405884,
-0.14196401834487915,
-0.07013223320245743,
0.1317540854215622,
-0.08358970284461975,
0.5583334565162659,
0.6667897701263428,
-0.2672923803329468,
-0.17493610084056854,
-0.3279804289340973,
-0.1612045168876648,
-0.3957371711730957,
0.8416436910629272,
-0.1672494262456894,
-1.2565252780914307,
0.4122900068759918,
-0.6752910614013672,
-0.36759692430496216,
0.3815200626850128,
0.5414704084396362,
-0.22415407001972198,
1.1226757764816284,
0.6227242350578308,
-0.43546056747436523,
0.6451719403266907,
-0.5000424981117249,
0.5732631087303162,
-0.8830170631408691,
-0.2883085608482361,
-0.3652421236038208,
-0.24328109622001648,
-0.6913241744041443,
-0.23987917602062225,
0.21918343007564545,
0.2210160791873932,
-0.2570355236530304,
-0.06967946141958237,
-0.2503255605697632,
0.41512253880500793,
0.2247159481048584,
0.183096244931221,
0.23432694375514984,
0.2636759281158447,
-0.09125755727291107,
0.32397809624671936,
-0.8177967071533203,
-0.5344575047492981,
1.2670328617095947,
0.4788183867931366,
0.7144990563392639,
-0.3253974914550781,
0.4931319057941437,
0.3042902946472168,
0.3586641252040863,
-0.738725483417511,
0.6829784512519836,
-0.34580186009407043,
-0.18346469104290009,
-0.5000771284103394,
-0.7011272311210632,
-1.1280841827392578,
0.07319163531064987,
-0.10159202665090561,
-0.7514981031417847,
-0.2442692220211029,
0.2490730881690979,
0.1149899959564209,
0.6390582323074341,
-0.6133532524108887,
0.8401539325714111,
-0.3502773642539978,
-0.19731847941875458,
-0.04694374278187752,
-0.5578475594520569,
0.28379952907562256,
-0.004071669187396765,
0.16214334964752197,
-0.25057944655418396,
0.15985004603862762,
0.4831063151359558,
-0.17097948491573334,
1.0092042684555054,
-0.2209288626909256,
0.06087161973118782,
0.4107034504413605,
-0.07074636220932007,
0.5755478739738464,
-0.05364619940519333,
0.03212369605898857,
0.5026726126670837,
-0.44541609287261963,
-0.16555428504943848,
-0.5877184271812439,
0.7164247035980225,
-0.7956966161727905,
-0.6089222431182861,
-0.11353399604558945,
-0.5985565185546875,
-0.4101950228214264,
0.39434564113616943,
0.14830142259597778,
0.3947542905807495,
-0.2135951966047287,
0.09394820034503937,
0.7048107981681824,
-0.17974357306957245,
0.10491450875997543,
-0.0805671364068985,
-0.7465780973434448,
-0.713269829750061,
1.0614374876022339,
0.35870739817619324,
0.22836413979530334,
0.08427336812019348,
0.24094586074352264,
-0.48764345049858093,
-1.1146087646484375,
-0.33069950342178345,
0.38941335678100586,
-1.0099952220916748,
-0.024512754753232002,
-0.7974188923835754,
-0.4169969856739044,
-0.5264186263084412,
-0.025866011157631874,
0.10355164110660553,
-0.20719993114471436,
-0.38919973373413086,
-0.28173407912254333,
0.3971216380596161,
0.9460649490356445,
0.16650287806987762,
0.10476754605770111,
-0.4310145378112793,
0.24798394739627838,
0.22414305806159973,
0.35751065611839294,
0.09404399245977402,
-0.21442681550979614,
-0.2172458916902542,
-0.12509706616401672,
-0.1603485494852066,
-0.689781665802002,
0.2562873363494873,
-0.010354075580835342,
0.7407515048980713,
0.4748246669769287,
-0.36971279978752136,
0.4721057116985321,
-0.42926302552223206,
0.4951704740524292,
0.23953895270824432,
-0.5616153478622437,
0.2632099390029907,
-0.2778854966163635,
-0.15798674523830414,
0.11608292162418365,
0.48267561197280884,
-0.5306620597839355,
-0.25692811608314514,
-0.4717557728290558,
-0.9049465656280518,
0.33603939414024353,
-0.03946793079376221,
0.12728559970855713,
0.25577694177627563,
0.4820966124534607,
0.02844860963523388,
0.32432207465171814,
-0.4735812842845917,
-0.34942588210105896,
-0.18774224817752838,
-0.3226856291294098,
-0.3409123718738556,
-0.13455303013324738,
-0.07121973484754562,
-0.36970797181129456,
0.5420686602592468,
-0.5518105030059814,
0.19933125376701355,
-0.08632662892341614,
-0.13995492458343506,
0.06244215741753578,
0.14382795989513397,
0.219948872923851,
0.7738160490989685,
-0.045602671802043915,
0.2677948772907257,
0.44951391220092773,
-0.2513737380504608,
0.06808065623044968,
0.2429380863904953,
-0.2757558226585388,
-0.17144957184791565,
0.5669792294502258,
1.006384015083313,
-0.08401519805192947,
-0.5161762237548828,
0.30884116888046265,
0.1884457767009735,
-0.2657332122325897,
-0.1987786442041397,
0.1687851846218109,
0.37579578161239624,
0.325044184923172,
0.06018718332052231,
-0.14813512563705444,
0.021491745486855507,
-0.6185750961303711,
-0.036444660276174545,
0.6954172849655151,
-0.5971186757087708,
-0.0714513286948204,
0.3495740592479706,
-0.053945645689964294,
-0.20812579989433289,
0.7755378484725952,
-0.11441338062286377,
-0.6544861197471619,
0.5544567108154297,
0.5498180389404297,
0.6610912680625916,
0.11842648684978485,
-0.06514820456504822,
0.17561079561710358,
0.08427345752716064,
0.19467400014400482,
0.13481687009334564,
0.29731735587120056,
-0.884703516960144,
-0.28968632221221924,
-0.2995532155036926,
-0.41990745067596436,
0.07281393557786942,
0.032427750527858734,
0.13041642308235168,
-0.6320251822471619,
-0.4000827670097351,
-0.05690598115324974,
0.21359512209892273,
-0.5816978812217712,
0.04536939412355423,
0.2592552602291107,
0.756748616695404,
-0.6639395952224731,
0.7472602128982544,
0.5891109704971313,
-0.2690018117427826,
-0.5980298519134521,
-0.42176011204719543,
-0.05945997312664986,
-0.923656702041626,
0.7871844172477722,
0.18328864872455597,
-0.23257136344909668,
0.21122299134731293,
-0.6304325461387634,
-0.6800456047058105,
1.1079776287078857,
0.48989322781562805,
-0.5190398693084717,
-0.09345708042383194,
0.26157793402671814,
0.5621135830879211,
-0.6219027042388916,
0.23420804738998413,
0.3661847710609436,
0.4162256419658661,
0.21055521070957184,
-0.4770674407482147,
-0.02544337697327137,
0.014326817356050014,
0.22665517032146454,
0.09265316277742386,
-0.532322347164154,
0.7940420508384705,
-0.3711067736148834,
-0.08725570887327194,
-0.18883663415908813,
0.7338242530822754,
0.4140801727771759,
0.4189099669456482,
0.3929721415042877,
0.34225139021873474,
1.072665810585022,
-0.2499264031648636,
1.0460808277130127,
-0.13709893822669983,
0.23481214046478271,
0.8142263889312744,
-0.6344174146652222,
0.4794374704360962,
0.17669034004211426,
-0.25290000438690186,
0.6326770782470703,
0.9332841634750366,
-0.21131718158721924,
0.1635250747203827,
0.5462551712989807,
0.03496521711349487,
-0.38137492537498474,
-0.21255511045455933,
-0.35107511281967163,
0.08929460495710373,
0.5046889185905457,
-0.5197896361351013,
-0.1791767179965973,
0.058995094150304794,
0.007286181673407555,
-0.043783776462078094,
-0.46729451417922974,
0.807765007019043,
0.294634073972702,
-0.04608425125479698,
0.3052956163883209,
-0.18549008667469025,
0.24809551239013672,
-0.7175393104553223,
-0.12425781786441803,
-0.0013029610272496939,
0.2122964709997177,
-0.25082242488861084,
-0.8589572310447693,
-0.05702720582485199,
-0.31048813462257385,
-0.2116115242242813,
-0.22231969237327576,
1.127852439880371,
-0.13538525998592377,
-0.461851567029953,
0.7375251054763794,
0.6875913143157959,
0.12962664663791656,
0.0885414406657219,
-0.6639124751091003,
0.14147445559501648,
-0.1936955749988556,
-0.22504475712776184,
0.30913862586021423,
0.5787366032600403,
-0.14871621131896973,
0.9415984749794006,
0.7166405320167542,
0.3713608384132385,
0.07075469940900803,
0.40418097376823425,
1.0701632499694824,
-0.5972648859024048,
-0.3317277431488037,
-0.8458701968193054,
-0.011618204414844513,
-0.17283254861831665,
0.09090381860733032,
0.9562568068504333,
0.6208939552307129,
0.7939302921295166,
0.20960624516010284,
0.9541289806365967,
0.26046621799468994,
0.3721705377101898,
-0.7152099013328552,
0.6104196310043335,
-0.30136817693710327,
0.03492169454693794,
-0.30965912342071533,
-0.9030710458755493,
-0.5113441348075867,
0.3502068817615509,
-0.5960509777069092,
0.3697429299354553,
0.6670102477073669,
0.6599767208099365,
0.14727722108364105,
-0.00856777187436819,
0.20573143661022186,
0.15398262441158295,
0.39133182168006897,
0.5219806432723999,
1.0790261030197144,
-0.18764537572860718,
0.5184695720672607,
0.14379078149795532,
0.01871640607714653,
-0.3502312898635864,
-0.811857283115387,
-1.0879334211349487,
-0.4007103145122528,
-0.275335431098938,
-0.4969051480293274,
0.1610386073589325,
0.7583051919937134,
0.7903279662132263,
-0.7353394031524658,
-0.296326220035553,
-0.19872982800006866,
0.5962191820144653,
-0.051836904138326645,
-0.13005737960338593,
0.47097262740135193,
-0.3774537742137909,
-0.5570040941238403,
0.400968998670578,
0.4351672828197479,
0.2546229660511017,
-0.38556620478630066,
-0.36770716309547424,
0.025075871497392654,
-0.30219173431396484,
0.8079013228416443,
0.28932663798332214,
-0.629765510559082,
-0.23428261280059814,
0.041447728872299194,
-0.23017050325870514,
0.24643364548683167,
0.9327292442321777,
-0.6411013007164001,
0.2740465998649597,
0.6328365206718445,
0.7646836042404175,
0.5947564840316772,
-0.28384634852409363,
0.3185425400733948,
-0.36392149329185486,
-0.08832414448261261,
0.13071422278881073,
0.6489401459693909,
0.4577818810939789,
-0.2975984513759613,
0.5865800380706787,
0.5617061257362366,
-0.4416452944278717,
-0.7493661642074585,
0.3431752622127533,
-0.804806649684906,
-0.3812321722507477,
1.0739635229110718,
-0.15000075101852417,
-0.3590693771839142,
-0.28953295946121216,
-0.20517633855342865,
0.44394347071647644,
-0.045294493436813354,
0.516032874584198,
0.6622003316879272,
-0.374856173992157,
-0.17261406779289246,
-0.5422298908233643,
0.33816003799438477,
-0.19454173743724823,
-1.0480819940567017,
0.1540672332048416,
0.5568256974220276,
0.20859842002391815,
-0.06568870693445206,
0.6440311074256897,
-0.0920257419347763,
-0.20010948181152344,
-0.25068050622940063,
-0.14222212135791779,
-0.4925718605518341,
-0.42492184042930603,
-0.30557194352149963,
0.4355999529361725,
0.3964059352874756,
0.1594989150762558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14914v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14914v1
|
Pillars of Grammatical Error Correction: Comprehensive Inspection Of Contemporary Approaches In The Era of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-23T10:57:59 | 2024-04-23T10:57:59 |
Kostiantyn Omelianchuk, Andrii Liubonko, Oleksandr Skurzhanskyi, Artem Chernodub, Oleksandr Korniienko, Igor Samokhin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we carry out experimental research on Grammatical Error
Correction, delving into the nuances of single-model systems, comparing the
efficiency of ensembling and ranking methods, and exploring the application of
large language models to GEC as single-model systems, as parts of ensembles,
and as ranking methods. We set new state-of-the-art performance with F_0.5
scores of 72.8 on CoNLL-2014-test and 81.4 on BEA-test, respectively. To
support further advancements in GEC and ensure the reproducibility of our
research, we make our code, trained models, and systems' outputs publicly
available.
|
[
-0.045741453766822815,
-1.2500600814819336,
0.4817880690097809,
0.4314241111278534,
0.22812236845493317,
-0.09845743328332901,
-0.3928271532058716,
-0.27503588795661926,
0.019811414182186127,
0.34725651144981384,
-0.3892454206943512,
-0.7915436625480652,
-0.5480389595031738,
0.2688598036766052,
-0.7583692669868469,
0.7130756378173828,
-0.09223584085702896,
0.44912979006767273,
-0.350490540266037,
-0.05776570737361908,
-0.2043246328830719,
-0.6403242349624634,
-0.7455037236213684,
0.2733452618122101,
0.30885615944862366,
0.5686007142066956,
0.5971102714538574,
0.2551170587539673,
0.7325120568275452,
0.4743860065937042,
-0.3357233703136444,
0.1358071267604828,
-0.42355895042419434,
-0.1619434654712677,
-0.29369431734085083,
-0.28870755434036255,
-0.8819066882133484,
-0.1842040717601776,
1.1015374660491943,
1.0015151500701904,
-0.2576667368412018,
-0.0354924239218235,
0.2870553731918335,
0.6356514692306519,
-0.7347627282142639,
0.25357747077941895,
-0.30660516023635864,
0.02780359424650669,
-0.3939785063266754,
0.09309897571802139,
-0.9345901012420654,
-0.8430649042129517,
-0.28195133805274963,
-0.6029415726661682,
0.3424794375896454,
-0.09777506440877914,
0.6391173601150513,
0.0009849967900663614,
-0.4504677653312683,
-0.414652943611145,
-0.8041268587112427,
0.7261536121368408,
-1.014058232307434,
0.31435897946357727,
0.3453715443611145,
0.06739676743745804,
-0.29679444432258606,
-0.8147047758102417,
-0.2799326479434967,
-0.3028169274330139,
0.020911145955324173,
-0.020316580310463905,
0.006446237210184336,
0.5398285388946533,
0.09462053328752518,
0.5514899492263794,
-0.4055318236351013,
0.1568780392408371,
-0.44000425934791565,
-0.1383841335773468,
0.8274561762809753,
0.05184147134423256,
0.23603782057762146,
0.17480511963367462,
0.21572202444076538,
-0.24625687301158905,
-0.7333757877349854,
0.14543581008911133,
0.4032636880874634,
0.4620015025138855,
-0.017787547782063484,
0.47098714113235474,
-0.593408465385437,
0.7863561511039734,
0.049933403730392456,
-0.11816050857305527,
0.18564866483211517,
-0.5708125233650208,
-0.5327711701393127,
-0.008626339957118034,
0.546503484249115,
0.1669473499059677,
0.09753664582967758,
-0.08471720665693283,
-0.11964088678359985,
0.31975632905960083,
0.2796936631202698,
-0.3174392580986023,
-0.2501028776168823,
-0.08649210631847382,
-0.29078587889671326,
-0.45455682277679443,
0.20279386639595032,
-1.025801181793213,
-0.27447330951690674,
-0.2556478977203369,
0.6659502387046814,
-0.017717042937874794,
-0.06948685646057129,
0.45761430263519287,
0.305928498506546,
-0.3512880206108093,
0.5310482382774353,
-0.8106276988983154,
0.5680140256881714,
0.7304534316062927,
0.625211238861084,
0.300653874874115,
-0.6117196679115295,
-0.5069586038589478,
-0.32210609316825867,
-0.6599950790405273,
0.6467805504798889,
-0.4982910752296448,
-0.5062557458877563,
0.5506117343902588,
0.18396927416324615,
-0.40106305480003357,
-0.3972730040550232,
0.91988205909729,
-0.2854521572589874,
0.24202728271484375,
-0.4553929567337036,
-0.5955405831336975,
-0.23000086843967438,
0.0978521853685379,
-0.513092577457428,
0.9720081090927124,
-0.12527449429035187,
-0.46804189682006836,
0.07135746628046036,
-0.6266651153564453,
-0.39832744002342224,
-0.38062506914138794,
0.3126518726348877,
-0.3086256682872772,
0.14630132913589478,
0.2638166546821594,
0.41431647539138794,
0.02657105214893818,
0.33824628591537476,
-0.3807719349861145,
-0.35107752680778503,
0.06706740707159042,
-0.2969062626361847,
0.7894594073295593,
0.02852589264512062,
-0.48417213559150696,
0.3243749439716339,
-0.9397416114807129,
0.2272484004497528,
-0.2289051115512848,
-0.38798025250434875,
-0.11638274043798447,
0.22094769775867462,
-0.16667421162128448,
-0.060912150889635086,
0.11433477699756622,
-0.639007031917572,
0.3799302875995636,
-0.20364204049110413,
0.3558334708213806,
0.7903385162353516,
-0.19174201786518097,
0.44579100608825684,
0.02254856936633587,
0.4525662362575531,
-0.4032053053379059,
0.3241095244884491,
-0.10932401567697525,
-0.3726356327533722,
-1.1375144720077515,
-0.01883353479206562,
0.6548195481300354,
0.5329822301864624,
-0.23057934641838074,
0.475359708070755,
-0.179175466299057,
-0.6169589161872864,
-0.295366495847702,
-0.06683626770973206,
0.6746960878372192,
0.23209939897060394,
0.15997640788555145,
-0.13898107409477234,
-0.5748662948608398,
-0.5467002987861633,
-0.12525895237922668,
-0.44732406735420227,
0.307759553194046,
-0.1898067593574524,
0.6219242215156555,
0.08042088896036148,
0.5897361636161804,
-0.4660000205039978,
0.08257406204938889,
0.011896411888301373,
0.18568097054958344,
0.04562114179134369,
0.5444261431694031,
0.3814002573490143,
-0.3990059792995453,
-0.1473119854927063,
0.07969590276479721,
-0.8820237517356873,
-0.13604651391506195,
0.4026915729045868,
-0.15031245350837708,
0.313128262758255,
0.6897738575935364,
-0.26573359966278076,
0.3412316143512726,
0.7022167444229126,
-0.6179919838905334,
0.8150187730789185,
-0.3462423086166382,
0.6075413823127747,
-0.6031064987182617,
-0.03821823000907898,
-0.10611120611429214,
-0.16958296298980713,
-0.5931161046028137,
0.4274694621562958,
0.24530386924743652,
0.072441466152668,
-0.16984155774116516,
0.15486907958984375,
-0.35824859142303467,
0.12368468195199966,
-0.026458874344825745,
-0.004552031401544809,
-0.146645188331604,
0.24575985968112946,
-0.36930015683174133,
0.5120927095413208,
0.539484441280365,
-0.6263511180877686,
0.5494346022605896,
0.12173718959093094,
-0.37640970945358276,
0.46764084696769714,
-0.42429739236831665,
0.2657371461391449,
-0.23092930018901825,
0.10826757550239563,
-1.1728541851043701,
-0.5359271764755249,
0.053139571100473404,
-0.376015305519104,
0.42519456148147583,
0.07507248967885971,
-0.3427242040634155,
-0.37103497982025146,
-0.14143823087215424,
0.2386629581451416,
0.24223190546035767,
-0.632941484451294,
0.25763100385665894,
0.35684868693351746,
-0.45411232113838196,
-0.6634911298751831,
-0.6409969329833984,
-0.00720085809007287,
0.22618158161640167,
-1.0753692388534546,
-0.00027808023151010275,
0.1728253960609436,
-0.5238502621650696,
0.05304872244596481,
0.06938304007053375,
0.12993468344211578,
0.11670667678117752,
0.1444133073091507,
0.15070825815200806,
-0.5009472966194153,
0.4211108982563019,
-0.1542142629623413,
0.14367316663265228,
0.05189241096377373,
-0.01838386058807373,
0.3824511766433716,
-0.5614848732948303,
-0.7893931269645691,
-0.21905522048473358,
0.2605324387550354,
0.6526630520820618,
-0.3706076443195343,
0.548079252243042,
-0.25575610995292664,
-0.6289921402931213,
-0.10865101218223572,
-0.6975439786911011,
0.13071294128894806,
-0.43463683128356934,
0.649583637714386,
-0.1032521203160286,
-0.9331328272819519,
0.5809782147407532,
0.18805593252182007,
-0.01149536482989788,
0.5577583312988281,
0.27124661207199097,
0.08795303851366043,
0.9036104083061218,
0.5669469833374023,
-0.20082926750183105,
0.1558985561132431,
0.05407135561108589,
0.461446613073349,
-0.2598537802696228,
-0.2821527123451233,
-1.2115769386291504,
-0.1422424018383026,
-0.5548579096794128,
-0.29600074887275696,
0.3823288381099701,
0.40206804871559143,
-0.43071088194847107,
0.1013818085193634,
-0.2845132052898407,
0.3559841513633728,
0.4299563467502594,
0.04739631712436676,
0.6150690913200378,
-0.06069670990109444,
-0.28514865040779114,
0.008148516528308392,
-0.48148882389068604,
-0.5493881702423096,
1.0152723789215088,
0.3825245797634125,
1.0551636219024658,
0.09004460275173187,
0.3597371578216553,
0.048337750136852264,
0.1192311942577362,
-0.5105799436569214,
0.6503083109855652,
-0.3890645205974579,
-0.673237144947052,
-0.6000640392303467,
-0.3117513954639435,
-0.5511589646339417,
0.3539014756679535,
-0.17809787392616272,
-0.8283393979072571,
0.3217191994190216,
0.3253483772277832,
-0.49710744619369507,
0.520992636680603,
-0.9018025994300842,
1.222731590270996,
-0.15691852569580078,
-0.469808429479599,
-0.24911963939666748,
-0.3703227937221527,
0.4280818700790405,
0.2772148549556732,
0.34643831849098206,
0.32781586050987244,
0.3616141080856323,
0.5061722993850708,
-0.32780367136001587,
0.7758851647377014,
-0.18899798393249512,
-0.1060304194688797,
0.30696001648902893,
0.08495289087295532,
0.7993684411048889,
-0.12597474455833435,
-0.19016678631305695,
-0.11990553140640259,
-0.10506399720907211,
-0.3475643992424011,
-0.4952685236930847,
0.7765383124351501,
-0.4800940454006195,
-0.3864765763282776,
-0.4626004695892334,
-0.2453523725271225,
-0.3859851062297821,
-0.04181842505931854,
0.15563538670539856,
0.8399552702903748,
-0.6421748399734497,
0.40968772768974304,
0.5972674489021301,
-0.017671119421720505,
0.40071600675582886,
0.41585180163383484,
-0.488257497549057,
-0.300434947013855,
0.45709124207496643,
0.2747664153575897,
0.28291231393814087,
0.23042505979537964,
-0.128238707780838,
-0.18950031697750092,
-0.7676398158073425,
-0.509555995464325,
0.16348151862621307,
-0.7420452833175659,
-0.061770252883434296,
-0.6240617632865906,
-0.07435279339551926,
-0.8451732993125916,
-0.2262144237756729,
-0.616263210773468,
-0.3381120562553406,
0.03423585742712021,
-0.3458421230316162,
0.10352025181055069,
1.1309305429458618,
0.05704813078045845,
0.3946768641471863,
-0.8319061994552612,
-0.37972623109817505,
0.173129141330719,
0.4040258228778839,
-0.006393485236912966,
-0.4072646498680115,
-0.25381889939308167,
0.1409463733434677,
-0.32598787546157837,
-0.8796365857124329,
-0.02944556437432766,
0.13887310028076172,
0.4569675624370575,
0.4183118939399719,
-0.5048917531967163,
0.859721839427948,
-0.3496347665786743,
0.9492777585983276,
-0.10032913833856583,
-1.2462488412857056,
0.49603673815727234,
-0.44570332765579224,
0.14194518327713013,
0.5830285549163818,
0.022240491583943367,
-0.8298393487930298,
-0.17919716238975525,
-0.5053526759147644,
-0.5141799449920654,
0.6119582653045654,
-0.003653398947790265,
-0.13431386649608612,
0.12139628827571869,
0.19427809119224548,
-0.23669461905956268,
0.1021401658654213,
-0.5288936495780945,
0.11084423214197159,
0.17569775879383087,
-0.41286057233810425,
-0.24262061715126038,
-0.5045469999313354,
0.02343587763607502,
-0.2412174642086029,
1.14127779006958,
-0.15877796709537506,
0.058232709765434265,
0.28220340609550476,
-0.061439208686351776,
-0.3673810064792633,
0.6215560436248779,
0.7506414651870728,
0.9253392219543457,
-0.04134444519877434,
0.07430802285671234,
0.38964971899986267,
-0.44586580991744995,
0.25376245379447937,
-0.052189797163009644,
-0.17984892427921295,
-0.027675889432430267,
0.46524545550346375,
0.5496516823768616,
0.6261743307113647,
-0.4109342694282532,
0.41210663318634033,
0.41490235924720764,
-0.09008416533470154,
-0.39552876353263855,
-0.16290433704853058,
0.18012478947639465,
-0.013328390195965767,
0.04821028932929039,
0.35965093970298767,
0.1787569224834442,
-0.7809644937515259,
-0.034609947353601456,
0.2786102294921875,
-0.1981535255908966,
-0.31914404034614563,
0.324638307094574,
0.25737521052360535,
-0.07984495908021927,
0.6834236979484558,
-0.36567172408103943,
-0.4314487874507904,
0.6344407796859741,
0.541441023349762,
0.5062589049339294,
-0.6830034852027893,
0.3913555145263672,
0.7341218590736389,
0.4883059561252594,
-0.7456663846969604,
0.10829240828752518,
0.5066201090812683,
-0.590613067150116,
-0.7484748959541321,
-0.55153888463974,
-0.36117979884147644,
-0.034328531473875046,
-0.6528967022895813,
0.3560130298137665,
-0.3504895865917206,
0.08811146765947342,
-0.09807591140270233,
-0.14826394617557526,
-0.16355066001415253,
0.3105194866657257,
0.02664964087307453,
0.9190679788589478,
-1.0661344528198242,
0.4942556321620941,
0.9995238780975342,
-0.24532368779182434,
-0.858775794506073,
-0.3566989004611969,
0.3394208252429962,
-0.22459764778614044,
0.30548548698425293,
-0.1632162630558014,
-0.2819608151912689,
-0.31150272488594055,
-0.5758817791938782,
-1.0247406959533691,
0.6379764676094055,
0.26440951228141785,
-0.7850080728530884,
-0.3778420090675354,
0.04455370828509331,
0.6568558812141418,
-0.1441192477941513,
0.3097052276134491,
0.539016842842102,
0.5336683392524719,
-0.23795613646507263,
-1.2617820501327515,
-0.21923492848873138,
-0.4081815779209137,
-0.11703414469957352,
0.332182377576828,
-0.6382486820220947,
1.0565975904464722,
0.07743138819932938,
-0.1478578895330429,
0.49812716245651245,
0.6897535920143127,
0.022223692387342453,
0.43357327580451965,
0.33882761001586914,
0.807769775390625,
1.0580954551696777,
-0.4280301332473755,
1.0080598592758179,
0.2649707794189453,
0.6485769152641296,
1.0029313564300537,
-0.23520153760910034,
0.9912282824516296,
0.16108737885951996,
-0.6114146113395691,
0.4788018465042114,
0.5090299844741821,
0.17271730303764343,
0.2839376926422119,
0.23948252201080322,
-0.38511011004447937,
-0.25118348002433777,
0.2717256247997284,
-0.37372973561286926,
0.355665385723114,
0.1309054046869278,
-0.3694971203804016,
-0.2631799578666687,
0.07773656398057938,
0.21779291331768036,
0.4743151366710663,
-0.6420877575874329,
0.3486749529838562,
-0.20343512296676636,
-0.8729325532913208,
0.2770756185054779,
0.2858615517616272,
0.788364827632904,
-0.5418089032173157,
-0.07194416224956512,
-0.3158057928085327,
0.682666540145874,
-0.33471372723579407,
-0.3694944977760315,
0.11816658079624176,
0.13879860937595367,
-0.13368797302246094,
0.021620269864797592,
0.8413869142532349,
-0.37278151512145996,
-0.8561086654663086,
0.15049882233142853,
0.17653131484985352,
0.008105247281491756,
-0.23882219195365906,
-0.09769579768180847,
0.12444154173135757,
0.037519704550504684,
0.10049974918365479,
-0.019793683663010597,
0.20494861900806427,
-0.10597162693738937,
0.4299984872341156,
0.29316189885139465,
-0.007560722529888153,
0.5489057898521423,
0.12274177372455597,
0.4597782492637634,
-0.5753625631332397,
-0.4740380346775055,
-0.6254723072052002,
0.6727308034896851,
-0.14991167187690735,
-0.5690058469772339,
0.8341902494430542,
0.6270394325256348,
1.3616752624511719,
-0.36410003900527954,
0.5569713115692139,
-0.13273631036281586,
0.6025388836860657,
-0.7666717171669006,
0.46578124165534973,
-0.37275171279907227,
-0.06839863210916519,
-0.50294429063797,
-0.605974555015564,
-0.39060306549072266,
0.6278307437896729,
-0.2874058187007904,
0.08621809631586075,
1.0550150871276855,
1.2049967050552368,
0.12854395806789398,
0.6580749750137329,
0.2830409109592438,
0.522268533706665,
-0.0037238604854792356,
0.38662299513816833,
0.8641937971115112,
-0.6188971996307373,
0.14704859256744385,
-0.33168601989746094,
-0.23940202593803406,
-0.282563716173172,
-0.4468676447868347,
-0.4049871265888214,
-0.5782721042633057,
-0.4375132918357849,
-0.5794861912727356,
0.5700675249099731,
0.8769095540046692,
0.3773052394390106,
-1.1717250347137451,
-0.32983502745628357,
-0.2018471658229828,
-0.04713096097111702,
-0.5013891458511353,
-0.12473466247320175,
0.42562708258628845,
-0.6004732847213745,
-1.0370264053344727,
0.5293105840682983,
0.04650907590985298,
-0.34106671810150146,
-0.2641758322715759,
-0.02390344999730587,
-0.44424837827682495,
-0.2609126567840576,
0.6266734600067139,
0.09672588855028152,
-0.6882243752479553,
-0.47999030351638794,
0.23001064360141754,
-0.20833933353424072,
0.0010201361728832126,
0.9381422400474548,
-0.2154674232006073,
0.3976026773452759,
0.8992007970809937,
0.5479443669319153,
0.1954537332057953,
0.020500632002949715,
0.44092243909835815,
-0.5425288081169128,
0.006548464763909578,
0.07712943106889725,
0.5812882781028748,
0.3400566577911377,
-0.26283538341522217,
0.7393143773078918,
0.3096073865890503,
-0.8854342103004456,
-0.7588214874267578,
-0.13330507278442383,
-0.911857545375824,
-0.027792390435934067,
0.984664261341095,
-0.3533645272254944,
-0.3118377923965454,
0.11559826880693436,
-0.3237285912036896,
0.2111590951681137,
-0.05251779407262802,
0.6966925859451294,
1.3265935182571411,
0.23329076170921326,
0.11638210713863373,
-0.5110216736793518,
0.41446253657341003,
0.772627055644989,
-0.9692474007606506,
-0.027676239609718323,
0.8330466747283936,
0.25185322761535645,
0.38239994645118713,
0.4949907958507538,
-0.7637176513671875,
0.39878571033477783,
0.313117116689682,
0.2615988254547119,
0.24381031095981598,
-0.48613643646240234,
-0.7039791345596313,
0.32447707653045654,
0.2748386263847351,
-0.1504359096288681
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14901v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14901v2
|
Beyond Code Generation: An Observational Study of ChatGPT Usage in Software Engineering Practice
| 2024-04-23T10:34:16 | 2024-05-21T12:53:30 |
Ranim Khojah, Mazen Mohamad, Philipp Leitner, Francisco Gomes de Oliveira Neto
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are frequently discussed in academia and the
general public as support tools for virtually any use case that relies on the
production of text, including software engineering. Currently there is much
debate, but little empirical evidence, regarding the practical usefulness of
LLM-based tools such as ChatGPT for engineers in industry. We conduct an
observational study of 24 professional software engineers who have been using
ChatGPT over a period of one week in their jobs, and qualitatively analyse
their dialogues with the chatbot as well as their overall experience (as
captured by an exit survey). We find that, rather than expecting ChatGPT to
generate ready-to-use software artifacts (e.g., code), practitioners more often
use ChatGPT to receive guidance on how to solve their tasks or learn about a
topic in more abstract terms. We also propose a theoretical framework for how
(i) purpose of the interaction, (ii) internal factors (e.g., the user's
personality), and (iii) external factors (e.g., company policy) together shape
the experience (in terms of perceived usefulness and trust). We envision that
our framework can be used by future research to further the academic discussion
on LLM usage by software engineering practitioners, and to serve as a reference
point for the design of future empirical LLM research in this domain.
|
[
-0.5059924125671387,
-0.5231647491455078,
0.590595543384552,
0.20879001915454865,
-0.2038121521472931,
0.11485296487808228,
-0.2110738903284073,
-0.574952244758606,
0.04163701832294464,
0.414825975894928,
-0.4693804681301117,
-0.35596293210983276,
-0.13816770911216736,
-0.08692723512649536,
-0.6427164673805237,
1.0496023893356323,
-0.15081296861171722,
-0.03408496454358101,
-0.1230475902557373,
0.3557916581630707,
-0.5231456160545349,
-0.7488217949867249,
-0.5828518867492676,
-0.5198423862457275,
0.5916023254394531,
0.33646538853645325,
0.6400443911552429,
0.0063843573443591595,
0.47994107007980347,
0.1926872730255127,
0.02138788066804409,
-0.18049441277980804,
-0.5347880721092224,
0.06099439039826393,
0.26059600710868835,
-0.7518800497055054,
-0.24912242591381073,
0.09794708341360092,
0.3505913019180298,
0.6655915379524231,
-0.32808414101600647,
0.1432085931301117,
0.4736853241920471,
0.47681793570518494,
-0.1955343633890152,
0.5340321063995361,
-0.6014841794967651,
0.21529443562030792,
-0.14324951171875,
-0.43573373556137085,
-0.4561171531677246,
-0.35217738151550293,
0.10058438777923584,
-0.514186441898346,
-0.09730581939220428,
0.23036417365074158,
0.7356760501861572,
-0.05796675384044647,
-0.3118387758731842,
-0.523036539554596,
-0.943672776222229,
0.6286908388137817,
-0.8375391960144043,
0.3714829385280609,
0.23790116608142853,
0.27858224511146545,
-0.4740559458732605,
-0.6595707535743713,
-0.4401679039001465,
-0.5657145380973816,
-0.14248280227184296,
0.38750097155570984,
0.07374788075685501,
0.26731276512145996,
0.3726659417152405,
0.5037134289741516,
-0.4763496220111847,
0.09495624899864197,
-0.5902707576751709,
-0.03421735018491745,
0.5859678387641907,
0.11246209591627121,
0.4124857783317566,
0.17923742532730103,
-0.20265254378318787,
0.1845397651195526,
-1.113759994506836,
0.007649845909327269,
0.4117239713668823,
-0.033195093274116516,
-0.20589369535446167,
0.5301662683486938,
0.11373817175626755,
0.397745817899704,
-0.4689575433731079,
0.14612798392772675,
0.21613675355911255,
0.11315663158893585,
-0.1772659718990326,
-0.10407589375972748,
0.7107280492782593,
0.32364654541015625,
0.6361173391342163,
-0.15032367408275604,
-0.22554349899291992,
0.13787999749183655,
0.529758095741272,
-0.7763283252716064,
-0.5373635292053223,
0.13926303386688232,
-0.4175111949443817,
-0.43435952067375183,
-0.08887091279029846,
-0.5345001220703125,
-0.535839855670929,
-0.3733193874359131,
-0.012378135696053505,
-0.16136164963245392,
-0.5769422650337219,
-0.10913700610399246,
-0.10308824479579926,
0.4307294189929962,
0.17881931364536285,
-0.5487565398216248,
0.04561672732234001,
0.8833362460136414,
0.8592208027839661,
-0.025444282218813896,
-0.36315345764160156,
-0.10936304926872253,
-0.18210357427597046,
-0.5277498364448547,
0.7380737662315369,
-0.46318092942237854,
-0.9182898998260498,
0.272493839263916,
-0.38578000664711,
0.10052202641963959,
-0.5251702070236206,
0.3272366225719452,
-0.498674601316452,
0.11347842216491699,
0.006119405850768089,
-0.6148606538772583,
0.019466867670416832,
0.2087666392326355,
-0.26770609617233276,
0.8744797110557556,
-0.1250465363264084,
-0.441083699464798,
0.6173562407493591,
-0.8835514783859253,
-0.09813854098320007,
0.29315730929374695,
-0.7392753958702087,
-0.23126818239688873,
0.2586471438407898,
-0.288678914308548,
0.4789888858795166,
-0.19661357998847961,
0.24523739516735077,
-0.38927391171455383,
-0.2989650368690491,
0.6779630780220032,
-0.3646324872970581,
0.32658642530441284,
0.3777315318584442,
-0.09909211099147797,
-0.1285795420408249,
-0.4321632385253906,
-0.03756122663617134,
-0.01589062064886093,
-0.21560871601104736,
-0.29303139448165894,
0.4001334607601166,
0.03252163901925087,
0.2395380437374115,
-0.11798705160617828,
-0.5721110701560974,
0.0305669866502285,
-0.5398672223091125,
0.6370702981948853,
0.7813999652862549,
0.15574809908866882,
0.19092446565628052,
-0.35786131024360657,
0.6127716898918152,
-0.22634491324424744,
0.06725913286209106,
-0.3415391743183136,
-0.5735301375389099,
-0.5220243334770203,
-0.15284442901611328,
0.11848094314336777,
0.24914458394050598,
-0.5139472484588623,
-0.08831100910902023,
-0.2290372997522354,
-0.4526737630367279,
-0.33681657910346985,
0.14777079224586487,
0.3052476942539215,
0.19759956002235413,
-0.14104673266410828,
-0.3449292778968811,
-0.4908573627471924,
-0.8794171214103699,
-0.29629719257354736,
-0.4729398190975189,
-0.3358311951160431,
0.6966162919998169,
0.33537912368774414,
-0.12676170468330383,
1.2250772714614868,
-0.6791492104530334,
-0.010073954239487648,
-0.33576399087905884,
0.20788393914699554,
0.20608735084533691,
0.23678196966648102,
0.4218086004257202,
-0.8296474814414978,
-0.4176197648048401,
0.2127600610256195,
-0.8928402066230774,
-0.10034776479005814,
-0.19219423830509186,
-0.07577754557132721,
0.06797684729099274,
0.5842068195343018,
-0.5288360118865967,
0.168244406580925,
0.6424815654754639,
-0.11625164747238159,
0.6716961860656738,
-0.05283886939287186,
-0.016235847026109695,
-1.0421420335769653,
0.06123838946223259,
0.10376913845539093,
-0.19234433770179749,
-0.5977113246917725,
0.23264764249324799,
-0.24037571251392365,
-0.4626145660877228,
-0.3347795307636261,
0.5579838156700134,
-0.46447378396987915,
-0.08264807611703873,
-0.5199142098426819,
0.33637580275535583,
-0.3182026743888855,
0.4446932375431061,
0.08618713915348053,
1.0580074787139893,
0.25996509194374084,
-0.43566107749938965,
-0.034192197024822235,
0.1865169256925583,
-0.4960326552391052,
0.43778812885284424,
-0.7905539870262146,
0.15138854086399078,
0.23847627639770508,
0.13317157328128815,
-0.9995765089988708,
-0.13384392857551575,
0.03617549687623978,
-0.5267578959465027,
-0.020470963791012764,
-0.22829392552375793,
-0.5474258065223694,
-0.2714433968067169,
-0.1414652168750763,
0.06243397295475006,
0.9310522675514221,
-0.30844780802726746,
0.44844502210617065,
0.5340750813484192,
-0.5309069156646729,
0.02696612849831581,
-0.7612786293029785,
0.1936333179473877,
-0.3717927634716034,
-0.7411532402038574,
0.060052525252103806,
0.024448325857520103,
-0.5407554507255554,
-0.28711193799972534,
-0.31283557415008545,
-0.2388361394405365,
0.17283731698989868,
0.48106467723846436,
0.2840505540370941,
-0.3449292480945587,
0.2228015810251236,
-0.2862197160720825,
-0.06719956547021866,
0.3866790235042572,
0.06630787253379822,
0.5878361463546753,
-0.16844846308231354,
-0.5243753790855408,
-0.1306188553571701,
0.3261556625366211,
0.20683184266090393,
-0.0324421226978302,
0.5736660361289978,
0.3042129874229431,
-0.00813368707895279,
-0.3519143760204315,
-0.5561810731887817,
-0.36766985058784485,
-0.5235170722007751,
0.32508185505867004,
-0.3016972243785858,
-0.9776526093482971,
0.5460011959075928,
-0.38280972838401794,
0.6126795411109924,
-0.041863955557346344,
0.5279557108879089,
-0.36118677258491516,
0.7248892784118652,
0.7597402930259705,
-0.1368943750858307,
0.6450054049491882,
-0.11486367881298065,
0.5387553572654724,
-0.8753738403320312,
0.017913740128278732,
-0.45379796624183655,
-0.044569529592990875,
-0.5803909301757812,
-0.023176871240139008,
0.5167413353919983,
0.022245272994041443,
-0.17734816670417786,
0.1023561954498291,
-0.28540077805519104,
0.3542342185974121,
0.21279862523078918,
0.17936232686042786,
0.2827931046485901,
-0.23078881204128265,
0.11178546398878098,
0.059841789305210114,
-0.6045438647270203,
-0.6643157601356506,
0.9518259167671204,
0.3881208002567291,
0.818584680557251,
-0.12391288578510284,
0.7123799324035645,
0.3714824616909027,
0.5410886406898499,
-0.7732675671577454,
0.6207568049430847,
0.25638628005981445,
-0.4286491572856903,
-0.19242368638515472,
-0.3614875376224518,
-0.9785861968994141,
0.25073882937431335,
0.05688827857375145,
-0.8662164807319641,
-0.214086651802063,
0.5206027626991272,
-0.03598383069038391,
0.0025751590728759766,
-0.9322006702423096,
0.7685478925704956,
-0.15944644808769226,
-0.23930583894252777,
-0.39307329058647156,
-0.39392203092575073,
0.3335968255996704,
-0.17170362174510956,
0.44024884700775146,
-0.007724514231085777,
0.23501601815223694,
0.44473567605018616,
-0.30216532945632935,
1.1070520877838135,
-0.09656556695699692,
-0.36109110713005066,
0.45436689257621765,
0.15787281095981598,
0.6750506162643433,
0.0029746380168944597,
-0.04616330564022064,
0.20163030922412872,
0.04988095536828041,
-0.02583087980747223,
-0.59326171875,
0.5573769807815552,
-0.6452248096466064,
-0.6452381014823914,
-0.2755441665649414,
-0.3601672053337097,
-0.3083248436450958,
0.06324195861816406,
0.03435184061527252,
0.47303861379623413,
-0.3478377163410187,
0.3738933801651001,
0.5483074188232422,
-0.33962881565093994,
0.2855518162250519,
0.393013060092926,
-0.5492851138114929,
0.2630918622016907,
0.7531232237815857,
0.15001749992370605,
0.277427613735199,
0.10479676723480225,
0.2823682129383087,
0.04630624130368233,
-0.4862908720970154,
-0.13008050620555878,
0.02808639593422413,
-0.5449066162109375,
0.21126608550548553,
-0.4153183400630951,
-0.35133689641952515,
0.12017611414194107,
-0.3559044301509857,
-0.2653658092021942,
-0.09305857121944427,
0.08748964965343475,
-0.09719555824995041,
0.3437047302722931,
0.642017126083374,
0.49183887243270874,
0.3854195177555084,
-0.7803744077682495,
-0.0025401548482477665,
0.025932621210813522,
0.3671153485774994,
-0.05412553995847702,
-0.16937923431396484,
-0.3173787593841553,
0.07807479798793793,
-0.41056200861930847,
-0.7205435633659363,
0.15025046467781067,
-0.038544073700904846,
0.775934636592865,
0.07652853429317474,
-0.023788386955857277,
0.3083273768424988,
-0.43457114696502686,
1.1047757863998413,
-0.011993237771093845,
-0.6292637586593628,
0.29357418417930603,
-0.6535154581069946,
0.15174071490764618,
0.08088168501853943,
0.23139898478984833,
-0.8256685137748718,
-0.6858274936676025,
-0.5305350422859192,
-0.9166104197502136,
0.3797442317008972,
0.4469929337501526,
0.4506821930408478,
0.20040400326251984,
0.30411991477012634,
0.013939902186393738,
0.5321744084358215,
-0.7451480031013489,
-0.047465112060308456,
0.15037094056606293,
-0.05738255754113197,
0.031686462461948395,
-0.2909833788871765,
-0.1488882601261139,
0.40476033091545105,
0.6707403659820557,
-0.09849562495946884,
0.5224122405052185,
-0.02449304796755314,
-0.06229319050908089,
0.34411874413490295,
0.5141854882240295,
0.391676664352417,
0.9493923187255859,
0.11269036680459976,
-0.0835232064127922,
0.12723413109779358,
-0.4800824224948883,
-0.369647353887558,
-0.12046539038419724,
-0.10357766598463058,
-0.23854891955852509,
0.20301015675067902,
0.4414180815219879,
0.25122374296188354,
-0.7174773812294006,
0.33482998609542847,
0.3457721769809723,
-0.22970165312290192,
-0.6520944237709045,
0.2841804623603821,
0.18161335587501526,
0.33400213718414307,
0.18500734865665436,
-0.20068715512752533,
0.29255247116088867,
-0.5770116448402405,
0.11164864897727966,
0.45212143659591675,
-0.35875678062438965,
-0.18430086970329285,
0.4807577133178711,
0.45687851309776306,
-0.39242932200431824,
0.49446606636047363,
0.01531959231942892,
-0.2699744701385498,
0.5503430962562561,
0.3349098563194275,
1.0553843975067139,
0.297808438539505,
0.18320289254188538,
-0.18934202194213867,
0.14442679286003113,
-0.05103812366724014,
0.20459294319152832,
-0.010972651652991772,
-0.7485335469245911,
-0.5530635714530945,
-0.3504674732685089,
-0.6682677268981934,
0.02563408389687538,
-0.2868350148200989,
0.37717533111572266,
-0.22153832018375397,
-0.11666196584701538,
-0.022554686293005943,
-0.2569281756877899,
-0.5330589413642883,
-0.15486666560173035,
0.12436643987894058,
0.6868610978126526,
-0.5411769151687622,
0.6878936290740967,
0.7792165875434875,
-0.40397635102272034,
-0.9320494532585144,
0.11324950307607651,
0.2442454993724823,
-0.9108670949935913,
0.39643222093582153,
-0.04131418839097023,
-0.18889804184436798,
-0.22518469393253326,
-0.5073102116584778,
-0.33242067694664,
0.9549425840377808,
0.08804063498973846,
-0.6604041457176208,
-0.03436657786369324,
0.2671928107738495,
0.7466760873794556,
-0.27235138416290283,
0.4291140139102936,
0.3328375816345215,
0.06845321506261826,
0.02609098143875599,
-1.0827312469482422,
-0.16205444931983948,
-0.4331596791744232,
0.18775999546051025,
0.5001683831214905,
-0.9132606983184814,
0.5170755982398987,
0.1559821516275406,
-0.005872656591236591,
-0.09707032144069672,
0.2746508717536926,
0.34900790452957153,
0.4241379499435425,
0.2789316773414612,
-0.262862890958786,
0.4637894928455353,
0.08925704658031464,
0.9854399561882019,
-0.7153773307800293,
0.2506639361381531,
0.9572103023529053,
-0.41543954610824585,
0.7553313374519348,
0.6738825440406799,
-0.3690820038318634,
0.4176987111568451,
0.4516957700252533,
-0.02566371113061905,
0.19072911143302917,
0.47995778918266296,
-0.2238927036523819,
-0.034686099737882614,
0.08425110578536987,
-0.5617504119873047,
0.19474001228809357,
0.37743836641311646,
-0.44440218806266785,
0.024492589756846428,
0.05404546484351158,
0.29623863101005554,
-0.0826226994395256,
-0.22034642100334167,
0.793563961982727,
0.6069686412811279,
-0.515753448009491,
0.21919691562652588,
-0.30589115619659424,
0.43687236309051514,
-0.7380994558334351,
-0.12637977302074432,
-0.20558741688728333,
0.21553945541381836,
-0.328130841255188,
-1.1028450727462769,
0.42019838094711304,
0.1727260947227478,
0.12252272665500641,
-0.4069007337093353,
0.6797193288803101,
0.06851361691951752,
-0.31142932176589966,
0.009643579833209515,
0.6225487589836121,
0.5122829079627991,
-0.17687901854515076,
-0.3053986728191376,
-0.03344561904668808,
-0.0056817904114723206,
-0.5829855799674988,
0.5559071898460388,
0.4818655848503113,
0.04700896516442299,
0.9792882800102234,
0.4653465449810028,
0.11083619296550751,
-0.05648527666926384,
-0.005299305077642202,
1.0577374696731567,
-0.43337324261665344,
-0.511811375617981,
-0.7879311442375183,
0.5699320435523987,
-0.05200948193669319,
-0.4409502148628235,
0.8472050428390503,
0.7214820384979248,
0.9039745330810547,
0.04872076213359833,
1.2055567502975464,
-0.10068373382091522,
0.3884419798851013,
-0.7159034609794617,
0.5995171070098877,
-0.4046740233898163,
0.6602315306663513,
-0.5173504948616028,
-0.9173381924629211,
-0.043992720544338226,
0.4323655664920807,
-0.6198347806930542,
0.13358311355113983,
0.48200613260269165,
0.8433384299278259,
-0.010585700161755085,
0.35712969303131104,
0.3592924475669861,
0.12272979319095612,
0.6641582250595093,
0.3148994445800781,
1.1070971488952637,
0.12036501616239548,
0.7100584506988525,
0.0038002589717507362,
-0.24689824879169464,
-0.09060505777597427,
-0.8081877827644348,
-0.9433530569076538,
-0.3708718419075012,
-0.1893732100725174,
-0.18515682220458984,
0.10328621417284012,
1.0775736570358276,
0.4763546586036682,
-0.4818445146083832,
-0.6526407599449158,
-0.24712540209293365,
-0.22680234909057617,
-0.06995614618062973,
-0.21963179111480713,
-0.02024914138019085,
-0.5776429772377014,
-0.40130794048309326,
0.14102579653263092,
0.14934831857681274,
-0.24147707223892212,
-0.4298672378063202,
-0.08351366221904755,
0.35784706473350525,
-0.008506477810442448,
0.7992498278617859,
0.2909596264362335,
-0.3439645767211914,
-0.17543458938598633,
0.12875953316688538,
0.10268814116716385,
0.3254898488521576,
1.1313652992248535,
-0.4787971079349518,
0.19502951204776764,
0.36605313420295715,
0.5456721186637878,
0.5297435522079468,
-0.18079039454460144,
0.995245099067688,
-0.6223753690719604,
0.0700146034359932,
0.17114172875881195,
0.2836083471775055,
-0.0018293114844709635,
-0.40206825733184814,
0.6107721924781799,
0.007434367202222347,
-0.9982045888900757,
-0.8920525908470154,
0.3429018259048462,
-0.6510765552520752,
-0.06317270547151566,
1.3161399364471436,
-0.17803220450878143,
0.29907479882240295,
-0.21605028212070465,
-0.5232709646224976,
-0.16481336951255798,
-0.589765191078186,
0.9132492542266846,
0.7545243501663208,
-0.5323516726493835,
-0.46618935465812683,
-1.105448842048645,
0.4287205934524536,
0.12383044511079788,
-0.8674851655960083,
0.1352822482585907,
0.42592838406562805,
0.29486897587776184,
0.011958842165768147,
0.7875485420227051,
-0.10162777453660965,
0.06388385593891144,
0.26626232266426086,
0.10749062895774841,
0.01873490773141384,
-0.08583708107471466,
0.05187840759754181,
0.082951620221138,
0.7378482818603516,
0.00598420575261116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14897v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14897v1
|
Beyond the Speculative Game: A Survey of Speculative Execution in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-23T10:25:45 | 2024-04-23T10:25:45 |
Chen Zhang, Zhuorui Liu, Dawei Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the increasingly giant scales of (causal) large language models (LLMs),
the inference efficiency comes as one of the core concerns along the improved
performance. In contrast to the memory footprint, the latency bottleneck seems
to be of greater importance as there can be billions of requests to a LLM
(e.g., GPT-4) per day. The bottleneck is mainly due to the autoregressive
innateness of LLMs, where tokens can only be generated sequentially during
decoding. To alleviate the bottleneck, the idea of speculative execution, which
originates from the field of computer architecture, is introduced to LLM
decoding in a \textit{draft-then-verify} style. Under this regime, a sequence
of tokens will be drafted in a fast pace by utilizing some heuristics, and then
the tokens shall be verified in parallel by the LLM. As the costly sequential
inference is parallelized, LLM decoding speed can be significantly boosted.
Driven by the success of LLMs in recent couple of years, a growing literature
in this direction has emerged. Yet, there lacks a position survey to summarize
the current landscape and draw a roadmap for future development of this
promising area. To meet this demand, we present the very first survey paper
that reviews and unifies literature of speculative execution in LLMs (e.g.,
blockwise parallel decoding, speculative decoding, etc.) in a comprehensive
framework and a systematic taxonomy. Based on the taxonomy, we present a
critical review and comparative analysis of the current arts. Finally we
highlight various key challenges and future directions to further develop the
area.
|
[
-0.33183637261390686,
-0.8499522805213928,
0.7222465872764587,
0.23547357320785522,
-0.021727150306105614,
0.5813868045806885,
-0.27197951078414917,
-0.7540797591209412,
0.4578608274459839,
0.7129629254341125,
-0.5156960487365723,
-0.47053325176239014,
-0.5449146628379822,
0.07306139916181564,
-0.5561909079551697,
0.5162899494171143,
-0.09135697036981583,
-0.18580502271652222,
-0.11080983281135559,
0.21149085462093353,
-0.1520811766386032,
-0.6805600523948669,
-0.6362484693527222,
0.12455307692289352,
0.44159871339797974,
0.056989636272192,
0.35812485218048096,
0.7926015853881836,
0.47862017154693604,
0.3975012004375458,
-0.01564498245716095,
0.12647445499897003,
-0.7118188738822937,
0.23618710041046143,
-0.083010733127594,
-0.8485540151596069,
-0.3775351643562317,
-0.04257062450051308,
0.9158015847206116,
0.5749645829200745,
0.03242555260658264,
-0.032760147005319595,
-0.310090035200119,
0.38389360904693604,
-0.7478537559509277,
-0.027504123747348785,
-0.6356261372566223,
-0.04913337156176567,
-0.7147751450538635,
-0.2818339169025421,
-0.47440415620803833,
-0.29100123047828674,
0.026254627853631973,
-0.3564504384994507,
0.1646755039691925,
0.4646947383880615,
0.41535401344299316,
0.03305986151099205,
-0.25363805890083313,
-0.238359272480011,
-0.8199813961982727,
0.702792763710022,
-0.6890044808387756,
0.3884335160255432,
0.0819522961974144,
0.21415238082408905,
-0.3082268238067627,
-0.7962678670883179,
-0.5707522630691528,
-0.2593625485897064,
0.18268656730651855,
0.12622572481632233,
-0.11886033415794373,
0.18855513632297516,
0.4011121988296509,
0.3949013352394104,
-0.4518510103225708,
0.4749082624912262,
-0.16283825039863586,
-0.2873474955558777,
0.49365541338920593,
0.6509128212928772,
-0.03540639579296112,
0.1370810866355896,
-0.27026984095573425,
0.18017297983169556,
-0.7761355638504028,
-0.13433580100536346,
0.6053934097290039,
-0.17851622402668,
0.018542706966400146,
0.5053820013999939,
-0.3322490453720093,
0.5053713917732239,
-0.04370187968015671,
0.038377344608306885,
0.021636519581079483,
-0.44162717461586,
0.06984490901231766,
-0.17961403727531433,
0.9594112634658813,
0.19915495812892914,
-0.2102404236793518,
-0.2924605906009674,
-0.25780704617500305,
0.25376811623573303,
0.11096934974193573,
-0.7499046325683594,
-0.005380872171372175,
0.357067734003067,
-0.40740320086479187,
-0.15929657220840454,
-0.052185311913490295,
-0.8052669167518616,
-0.2711917757987976,
0.01671772077679634,
-0.17322948575019836,
-0.16998659074306488,
-0.37455329298973083,
0.3553466498851776,
0.11835795640945435,
0.23725645244121552,
0.12018842250108719,
-1.0129659175872803,
0.5356863737106323,
1.0577589273452759,
0.8467660546302795,
-0.39046424627304077,
-0.31749558448791504,
-0.3088959753513336,
0.12888655066490173,
-0.6054428815841675,
0.9592442512512207,
-0.5150758624076843,
-0.4570698142051697,
0.02208075299859047,
-0.18274405598640442,
0.03043315000832081,
-0.1684005856513977,
0.6609407663345337,
-0.9731473922729492,
-0.21453288197517395,
-0.4742986261844635,
-0.8177044987678528,
-0.028950240463018417,
0.32591038942337036,
-0.5538358688354492,
0.6869561076164246,
-0.35966673493385315,
-0.8470775485038757,
0.32771173119544983,
-0.38771215081214905,
-0.31845635175704956,
0.13315905630588531,
-0.28857526183128357,
0.11488421261310577,
0.27787354588508606,
-0.015977555885910988,
0.39722001552581787,
-0.7897598147392273,
0.1749527007341385,
-0.48356640338897705,
-0.7575055956840515,
0.16979330778121948,
-0.40129581093788147,
0.35068458318710327,
0.2584608793258667,
-0.32820990681648254,
0.12951494753360748,
-0.45898565649986267,
0.026606686413288116,
-0.04654005542397499,
-0.040555406361818314,
-0.082270048558712,
0.3897494375705719,
-0.06853188574314117,
-0.013716754503548145,
0.2584582269191742,
-0.3557860851287842,
0.29443711042404175,
-0.5083913803100586,
0.3721594512462616,
0.736901581287384,
0.00984251033514738,
0.30884310603141785,
-0.169416144490242,
0.7773772478103638,
-0.31284770369529724,
0.21364569664001465,
-0.27692216634750366,
-0.35575979948043823,
-0.6194614768028259,
-0.2528001368045807,
0.23115822672843933,
0.5193209648132324,
-0.688255786895752,
0.3178156912326813,
-0.14056634902954102,
-0.5271992087364197,
-0.2959546148777008,
-0.22579802572727203,
0.3975592851638794,
0.20648431777954102,
-0.09274306893348694,
-0.18390516936779022,
-0.639483630657196,
-0.768108069896698,
-0.2683069407939911,
-0.34316781163215637,
0.4108849763870239,
0.34314608573913574,
0.2095673382282257,
-0.26319584250450134,
0.5871602892875671,
-0.529941201210022,
0.2961394190788269,
-0.1726863831281662,
0.14523214101791382,
0.47476455569267273,
0.4183717370033264,
0.4692164361476898,
-0.5039710402488708,
-0.14533483982086182,
-0.05052405595779419,
-0.6125099658966064,
-0.12595343589782715,
-0.05537382513284683,
-0.18044215440750122,
0.34788644313812256,
0.8615787029266357,
-0.7240043878555298,
-0.0894695594906807,
0.4983274042606354,
-0.15400779247283936,
0.9537570476531982,
-0.10211844742298126,
0.3653416931629181,
-0.7646504044532776,
0.12009834498167038,
-0.31700584292411804,
0.14914757013320923,
-0.47654473781585693,
0.5610110759735107,
-0.11092302203178406,
0.3448922336101532,
-0.13729055225849152,
0.39563167095184326,
-0.6647992730140686,
-0.13487248122692108,
-0.38226306438446045,
-0.06149489805102348,
-0.28869470953941345,
0.004479910247027874,
0.18326769769191742,
0.764569878578186,
0.7159619331359863,
-0.2627524733543396,
0.4247192442417145,
-0.2783113121986389,
-0.5101510286331177,
-0.07696890830993652,
-0.6100719571113586,
0.2926563620567322,
0.036693911999464035,
0.4417032301425934,
-0.8726754784584045,
-0.2162027209997177,
0.3008449375629425,
-0.06383442878723145,
0.31119459867477417,
-0.08351339399814606,
-0.8400934338569641,
-0.608071506023407,
-0.2575981616973877,
0.6649481654167175,
0.5674995183944702,
-0.132745161652565,
0.2026033103466034,
0.4211277961730957,
0.022106409072875977,
-1.0884813070297241,
-0.5373507738113403,
0.3443361818790436,
-0.1747605949640274,
-0.5198786854743958,
0.1715213507413864,
0.0019492678111419082,
-0.42315322160720825,
-0.06303191930055618,
0.0611317977309227,
0.2024809867143631,
0.017393914982676506,
-0.014399925246834755,
0.19866697490215302,
-0.4326304495334625,
-0.07598273456096649,
-0.06846101582050323,
-0.1649973839521408,
0.29701101779937744,
-0.6234122514724731,
0.6106446385383606,
-0.19440709054470062,
-0.459416925907135,
-0.17617018520832062,
0.4608559012413025,
0.41185805201530457,
-0.030039189383387566,
0.37064358592033386,
0.5506391525268555,
-0.12925267219543457,
-0.0985569879412651,
-1.0712028741836548,
-0.11761830747127533,
-0.455228328704834,
0.45430371165275574,
-0.5619200468063354,
-1.205354928970337,
0.81941157579422,
-0.3461277484893799,
-0.03498953580856323,
0.4773125648498535,
0.7138300538063049,
0.1702238917350769,
0.6105642318725586,
0.7401145100593567,
-0.21420830488204956,
0.2381591945886612,
-0.2519930303096771,
0.11531839519739151,
-0.6143463253974915,
-0.24694426357746124,
-0.44509685039520264,
-0.20041592419147491,
-0.7216048240661621,
-0.9750818610191345,
0.15217627584934235,
0.16874316334724426,
0.054718125611543655,
0.06181137263774872,
-0.08271190524101257,
0.6456267237663269,
0.2348911017179489,
-0.14016255736351013,
0.37879106402397156,
-0.28728413581848145,
-0.2476767748594284,
0.0024437732063233852,
-0.7131036520004272,
-0.4200272858142853,
1.068867802619934,
0.33246558904647827,
0.7924493551254272,
0.01660514809191227,
0.6508016586303711,
0.07709620893001556,
0.2542807161808014,
-0.6237488389015198,
0.5755113959312439,
-0.01826172135770321,
-0.7250405550003052,
-0.1431993991136551,
-0.43401551246643066,
-0.6519947052001953,
0.13422968983650208,
-0.14087364077568054,
-0.9308820962905884,
0.200949028134346,
0.10196832567453384,
-0.3596544563770294,
0.5159354209899902,
-0.5143803954124451,
0.6775680184364319,
-0.12823982536792755,
-0.7346200942993164,
-0.5704810619354248,
-0.5985828042030334,
0.9134636521339417,
-0.17585134506225586,
0.09026974439620972,
0.022048916667699814,
-0.314328134059906,
0.5992202758789062,
-0.32685667276382446,
0.7412817478179932,
0.03524200990796089,
-0.3218817412853241,
0.39029356837272644,
0.19598200917243958,
0.7290750741958618,
0.13315144181251526,
-0.21535804867744446,
0.21230709552764893,
0.13780924677848816,
-0.28399401903152466,
-0.46512699127197266,
0.9240856766700745,
-0.4885638952255249,
-0.8613879084587097,
-0.4513392448425293,
-0.5927219986915588,
-0.42988693714141846,
0.20547905564308167,
0.34930023550987244,
0.24916376173496246,
-0.38142916560173035,
-0.3519531190395355,
0.6966768503189087,
-0.2332124561071396,
0.26510438323020935,
0.31569433212280273,
-0.3548923432826996,
-0.015972694382071495,
0.8851234912872314,
-0.1006174311041832,
0.13863007724285126,
0.6311934590339661,
0.028463926166296005,
-0.5076823830604553,
-1.1811131238937378,
-0.137257918715477,
0.19218744337558746,
-0.5470196604728699,
0.1350145936012268,
-0.8165419101715088,
-0.08000990003347397,
-0.30567702651023865,
-0.13345487415790558,
-0.45071011781692505,
-0.18168142437934875,
-0.07660457491874695,
0.051046259701251984,
0.4134606420993805,
0.9305635094642639,
-0.08352410048246384,
0.31232908368110657,
-0.6447851657867432,
0.07027275860309601,
-0.19194455444812775,
0.3905971050262451,
0.2640281915664673,
-0.34916624426841736,
-0.19287747144699097,
-0.4541483521461487,
0.24286113679409027,
-0.4375130832195282,
0.125413715839386,
-0.3868851661682129,
0.4756714999675751,
0.6074828505516052,
-0.15117278695106506,
0.700458824634552,
-0.6697781085968018,
0.6718907356262207,
0.16925668716430664,
-0.7185655236244202,
-0.0810978040099144,
-0.5787208676338196,
0.08419745415449142,
0.4216671586036682,
0.48559099435806274,
-0.6325311064720154,
-0.33649715781211853,
-0.44561439752578735,
-0.8414179086685181,
0.6694014668464661,
-0.27009281516075134,
0.16798551380634308,
-0.16542549431324005,
0.37455981969833374,
0.29799506068229675,
0.23027443885803223,
-0.02346089854836464,
-0.20545904338359833,
0.41880348324775696,
0.33296579122543335,
-0.24657034873962402,
-0.6572268009185791,
0.03893052041530609,
-0.0569804422557354,
0.28788450360298157,
-0.06650707870721817,
0.34563538432121277,
-0.17693673074245453,
0.19777095317840576,
0.012483840808272362,
0.07614018768072128,
0.45984145998954773,
0.6309264302253723,
-0.23662012815475464,
0.08909650146961212,
0.015414570458233356,
-0.40225228667259216,
-0.00909760408103466,
0.033452101051807404,
-0.01011542696505785,
-0.30385926365852356,
0.7089460492134094,
0.6976981163024902,
0.3222227990627289,
-0.7664673328399658,
0.32754796743392944,
0.022056404501199722,
-0.11096308380365372,
-0.2270481288433075,
-0.07658299803733826,
0.19103017449378967,
0.48971349000930786,
0.307964950799942,
0.10216469317674637,
0.4353472888469696,
-0.5508279800415039,
0.20647284388542175,
0.4012606739997864,
0.05929489806294441,
-0.3020945191383362,
0.5858242511749268,
0.012773383408784866,
0.06135929003357887,
0.38050979375839233,
-0.4363786578178406,
-0.4184384047985077,
0.5417636632919312,
0.5471963882446289,
0.924246609210968,
0.24720828235149384,
-0.1366136074066162,
0.1641765534877777,
0.29472821950912476,
-0.2648923099040985,
0.555382251739502,
-0.022504545748233795,
-0.569111704826355,
-0.9494064450263977,
-0.6983276009559631,
-0.39987072348594666,
-0.02929479256272316,
-0.312093585729599,
-0.027247659862041473,
-0.6369071006774902,
-0.10918103158473969,
-0.2372930347919464,
0.15138842165470123,
-0.3722553849220276,
-0.34747371077537537,
0.20723369717597961,
1.1215819120407104,
-0.35856160521507263,
0.7030132412910461,
0.409345805644989,
0.10827726870775223,
-0.47032326459884644,
0.2680189311504364,
0.09120305627584457,
-0.7067176699638367,
0.6846383810043335,
-0.2197517454624176,
-0.34978243708610535,
-0.022394409403204918,
-0.25964006781578064,
-0.9584206938743591,
0.7651578783988953,
0.3652893602848053,
-1.0143455266952515,
-0.19414271414279938,
0.013122268952429295,
0.6109516024589539,
-0.26967862248420715,
0.5616378784179688,
0.69121915102005,
0.36021146178245544,
0.33300095796585083,
-0.6007809042930603,
0.18499042093753815,
-0.11041015386581421,
0.010739601217210293,
0.19359786808490753,
-0.9972464442253113,
0.8075287938117981,
-0.24099546670913696,
-0.21856100857257843,
0.4715030789375305,
0.7301618456840515,
0.27443400025367737,
0.0044881561771035194,
0.21637557446956635,
0.36528441309928894,
0.6262294054031372,
-0.15924829244613647,
1.288267731666565,
-0.45348629355430603,
0.06515489518642426,
0.8843034505844116,
-0.36508527398109436,
0.8190993070602417,
0.4246961772441864,
-0.42952385544776917,
0.3009294271469116,
0.7628970146179199,
0.14825314283370972,
0.19105927646160126,
0.5338696837425232,
-0.2586808204650879,
-0.368441641330719,
-0.1702728122472763,
-0.4228198826313019,
0.4731234908103943,
0.7094439268112183,
-0.1051928699016571,
-0.1563439965248108,
-0.47801119089126587,
-0.15521016716957092,
-0.04987417161464691,
-0.23303821682929993,
0.3390205502510071,
0.17243309319019318,
-0.5037359595298767,
0.5376355648040771,
0.1423674076795578,
0.9684244990348816,
-0.7282719016075134,
0.16782478988170624,
-0.07678268104791641,
0.12649540603160858,
0.02172575332224369,
-0.6592655181884766,
0.22907540202140808,
-0.11363005638122559,
-0.20251111686229706,
-0.007354770787060261,
0.5242593288421631,
-0.10754816234111786,
-0.3591650724411011,
0.48152241110801697,
0.5781165361404419,
0.29052191972732544,
-0.0022913459688425064,
-0.6493460536003113,
0.7620705366134644,
-0.43595653772354126,
-0.2619839012622833,
0.14577700197696686,
0.6860575079917908,
-0.20665590465068817,
0.544624924659729,
0.7181295156478882,
0.3263435661792755,
0.09329544752836227,
0.12449364364147186,
0.9104018211364746,
-0.7251362204551697,
-0.5011221170425415,
-1.0127989053726196,
-0.005584931932389736,
0.07420944422483444,
-0.2746019661426544,
0.8400144577026367,
0.5652295351028442,
0.6136152148246765,
-0.04589829221367836,
0.671573281288147,
-0.12680068612098694,
0.12907187640666962,
-0.674908459186554,
0.5916106104850769,
-0.17937612533569336,
0.3686406910419464,
-0.41772109270095825,
-0.650351345539093,
-0.19439756870269775,
-0.006898423191159964,
-0.5568845868110657,
-0.028337832540273666,
0.7727950811386108,
0.820611298084259,
0.08124927431344986,
0.16659776866436005,
0.3517034649848938,
0.44887876510620117,
0.07429683208465576,
0.7572796940803528,
1.1664025783538818,
-0.1704450398683548,
0.15805940330028534,
-0.014159553684294224,
-0.31269174814224243,
-0.2242405265569687,
-0.8398489952087402,
-0.8708547949790955,
-0.3933797776699066,
0.011328180320560932,
-0.19412145018577576,
0.1734657883644104,
0.6832605004310608,
0.651613712310791,
-0.7354385852813721,
-0.4854273796081543,
-0.0470113568007946,
0.06104864180088043,
-0.26120734214782715,
-0.15320833027362823,
0.44820505380630493,
-0.35335877537727356,
-0.8940038681030273,
0.49542826414108276,
0.3769317865371704,
-0.2253781110048294,
-0.4754874110221863,
0.029566090553998947,
-0.23477017879486084,
0.012490291148424149,
0.6112633347511292,
0.42144784331321716,
-0.8170486688613892,
0.07812373340129852,
0.20012760162353516,
-0.001008544466458261,
-0.38447389006614685,
1.2589961290359497,
-0.6142328977584839,
0.28305208683013916,
0.52287757396698,
1.0163789987564087,
0.5853939056396484,
-0.3426705002784729,
0.6957747340202332,
-0.27218911051750183,
0.302554190158844,
0.37450337409973145,
0.2987196445465088,
-0.16870056092739105,
-0.5307048559188843,
0.2160952091217041,
0.5303496718406677,
-0.39421114325523376,
-0.8157362937927246,
0.3026648461818695,
-0.8412473201751709,
-0.22997434437274933,
1.0503073930740356,
-0.12451484054327011,
-0.270277738571167,
-0.15259987115859985,
-0.003557020565494895,
0.008923936635255814,
-0.3007109761238098,
0.7038236856460571,
0.7786695957183838,
-0.2081143707036972,
-0.10730881243944168,
-0.5863107442855835,
0.515951931476593,
0.3472415506839752,
-0.6239651441574097,
0.3811662197113037,
0.5780285000801086,
-0.051566071808338165,
0.03999439254403114,
0.7543021440505981,
-0.1863093078136444,
0.19379882514476776,
0.43231821060180664,
-0.0795266330242157,
0.1942039430141449,
-0.20436464250087738,
-0.1079697236418724,
0.27950993180274963,
0.19152377545833588,
0.26058003306388855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14883v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14883v1
|
Language in Vivo vs. in Silico: Size Matters but Larger Language Models Still Do Not Comprehend Language on a Par with Humans
| 2024-04-23T10:09:46 | 2024-04-23T10:09:46 |
Vittoria Dentella, Fritz Guenther, Evelina Leivada
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Understanding the limits of language is a prerequisite for Large Language
Models (LLMs) to act as theories of natural language. LLM performance in some
language tasks presents both quantitative and qualitative differences from that
of humans, however it remains to be determined whether such differences are
amenable to model size. This work investigates the critical role of model
scaling, determining whether increases in size make up for such differences
between humans and models. We test three LLMs from different families (Bard,
137 billion parameters; ChatGPT-3.5, 175 billion; ChatGPT-4, 1.5 trillion) on a
grammaticality judgment task featuring anaphora, center embedding,
comparatives, and negative polarity. N=1,200 judgments are collected and scored
for accuracy, stability, and improvements in accuracy upon repeated
presentation of a prompt. Results of the best performing LLM, ChatGPT-4, are
compared to results of n=80 humans on the same stimuli. We find that increased
model size may lead to better performance, but LLMs are still not sensitive to
(un)grammaticality as humans are. It seems possible but unlikely that scaling
alone can fix this issue. We interpret these results by comparing language
learning in vivo and in silico, identifying three critical differences
concerning (i) the type of evidence, (ii) the poverty of the stimulus, and
(iii) the occurrence of semantic hallucinations due to impenetrable linguistic
reference.
|
[
-0.20529629290103912,
-0.7830012440681458,
0.5738452076911926,
0.4478853940963745,
-0.08179426938295364,
0.05542701855301857,
-0.6364835500717163,
-0.5772589445114136,
0.03934232145547867,
0.1547427773475647,
-0.009301903657615185,
0.03177151456475258,
-0.6433004140853882,
0.41701844334602356,
-0.14245456457138062,
0.792264461517334,
0.3212648630142212,
0.40328505635261536,
-0.48475563526153564,
-0.34276750683784485,
-0.33676090836524963,
-0.5685184001922607,
-0.5846900939941406,
-0.46164456009864807,
0.5598992109298706,
0.38375407457351685,
0.7491772174835205,
0.8086588382720947,
0.5399311184883118,
0.317058801651001,
-0.417815238237381,
-0.02528817392885685,
-0.42112112045288086,
0.03916395083069801,
-0.06601087749004364,
-0.789362370967865,
-0.3873475193977356,
0.07090667635202408,
1.0428693294525146,
1.0921136140823364,
0.07119496911764145,
0.025495773181319237,
0.08827049285173416,
0.6847342848777771,
-0.3925533592700958,
0.05773947015404701,
-0.46585533022880554,
-0.02127729542553425,
0.02118348516523838,
0.19576086103916168,
-0.3921222388744354,
-0.14972899854183197,
0.27971115708351135,
-0.5778664350509644,
0.1743396371603012,
0.16619499027729034,
0.6911101937294006,
0.3294827342033386,
-0.510277509689331,
-0.25425848364830017,
-0.837618887424469,
0.6463330388069153,
-0.948792040348053,
0.45058226585388184,
0.38391628861427307,
-0.2309243083000183,
-0.22380566596984863,
-0.4312378168106079,
-0.4896678626537323,
-0.8267889618873596,
-0.03924235329031944,
-0.43915024399757385,
-0.1586543321609497,
0.2199401557445526,
0.6557491421699524,
0.3268085718154907,
-0.7565867304801941,
0.21027475595474243,
-0.6910029053688049,
-0.2852540612220764,
0.4329128861427307,
-0.07583314925432205,
0.4034304916858673,
-0.04826582595705986,
-0.24050399661064148,
-0.1871558278799057,
-0.7799021601676941,
-0.10558480024337769,
0.07821596413850784,
0.28193753957748413,
0.05602592974901199,
0.5233149528503418,
0.06890171766281128,
0.5149796009063721,
0.05452411621809006,
-0.2326207458972931,
0.1645096391439438,
-0.19421276450157166,
-0.2482258379459381,
-0.06762290000915527,
0.9360654950141907,
0.29860618710517883,
0.43591925501823425,
-0.10070396214723587,
0.09411470592021942,
0.16627244651317596,
0.17042860388755798,
-0.876008927822113,
0.018058523535728455,
-0.1622767448425293,
-0.20445390045642853,
0.025428837165236473,
-0.17669181525707245,
-0.5960144400596619,
-0.7033511996269226,
-0.1425897628068924,
0.5349422693252563,
-0.3358372151851654,
-0.2834819555282593,
0.10988447070121765,
0.0570792518556118,
0.27407413721084595,
0.28362783789634705,
-0.8959985971450806,
0.5960446000099182,
0.4417646527290344,
0.8117125034332275,
-0.11229804903268814,
-0.5142674446105957,
-0.25887104868888855,
-0.4761410355567932,
-0.5185597538948059,
0.7799566984176636,
-0.3063475787639618,
-0.4281524419784546,
-0.36081841588020325,
-0.06606044620275497,
-0.39154860377311707,
-0.9016335606575012,
0.36745619773864746,
-0.23391185700893402,
0.1434377133846283,
-0.4532102048397064,
-0.5749294757843018,
-0.1442396193742752,
-0.009699951857328415,
-0.5204161405563354,
0.7282724380493164,
0.01806265488266945,
-0.5937719941139221,
0.4715217351913452,
-0.458207368850708,
-0.5558387637138367,
0.09144023805856705,
-0.3181280493736267,
-0.15820878744125366,
0.42984738945961,
-0.21799726784229279,
0.33542001247406006,
-0.39400988817214966,
0.23986604809761047,
-0.32949042320251465,
-0.4551578164100647,
0.5621282458305359,
-0.31065723299980164,
0.48235347867012024,
0.10829077661037445,
-0.3571239113807678,
0.05727821961045265,
-0.5440839529037476,
-0.13186201453208923,
0.18976444005966187,
-0.42256394028663635,
-0.19498310983181,
0.15789896249771118,
-0.3502832055091858,
0.17455735802650452,
0.09479628503322601,
-0.7980858683586121,
0.09413667768239975,
-0.6202313303947449,
0.7732930183410645,
0.3607848286628723,
-0.2921510934829712,
0.8311867117881775,
-0.2566668391227722,
0.5077518224716187,
-0.42104172706604004,
0.04202449694275856,
0.16515910625457764,
-0.4794594645500183,
-0.6641015410423279,
-0.11984392255544662,
0.4210819602012634,
0.37669387459754944,
-0.15741468966007233,
0.0013556221965700388,
-0.5557311773300171,
-0.37953200936317444,
-0.3595485985279083,
0.13986903429031372,
0.2840314209461212,
0.30289968848228455,
0.06317880004644394,
-0.23669831454753876,
-0.20260336995124817,
-1.1129175424575806,
-0.3692251443862915,
-0.5050774216651917,
-0.28946101665496826,
0.4004850685596466,
0.5468783378601074,
-0.0648447573184967,
0.7363067269325256,
-0.22376272082328796,
-0.18101593852043152,
-0.4374096989631653,
0.04318959638476372,
-0.3398347496986389,
0.2474946677684784,
0.5767887234687805,
-0.6040893793106079,
-0.19898876547813416,
0.2234003245830536,
-0.6727609038352966,
-0.12869669497013092,
-0.015351367183029652,
0.28499510884284973,
0.18986651301383972,
0.6887320876121521,
-0.6768022775650024,
0.24910402297973633,
0.5712305307388306,
-0.4803394675254822,
0.4092458188533783,
-0.5545790195465088,
-0.1041642352938652,
-0.6857988834381104,
-0.00014413193275686353,
-0.07147390395402908,
-0.2193182110786438,
-0.7584187984466553,
-0.008452030830085278,
0.25894495844841003,
0.06227477267384529,
-0.20693299174308777,
0.5720990300178528,
-0.30549442768096924,
-0.22443456947803497,
-0.36037182807922363,
0.32195255160331726,
0.04440409317612648,
0.5572498440742493,
-0.23130269348621368,
0.8920543789863586,
0.16219337284564972,
-0.5766938328742981,
0.060540106147527695,
-0.20871782302856445,
-0.09044189751148224,
0.1739577203989029,
-0.8845323324203491,
0.11295327544212341,
-0.01179755199700594,
0.23923811316490173,
-0.9891491532325745,
-0.41758379340171814,
0.02707762084901333,
-0.6270581483840942,
0.3534803092479706,
0.21155907213687897,
-0.6042670607566833,
-0.1864391565322876,
-0.3195633590221405,
0.46313443779945374,
0.510887622833252,
-0.17495663464069366,
0.4182046055793762,
0.35191330313682556,
-0.15066766738891602,
-0.05717261880636215,
-0.6612537503242493,
0.09917893260717392,
-0.30066221952438354,
-0.7012196183204651,
0.030111979693174362,
-0.20151787996292114,
-0.807636022567749,
-0.33429861068725586,
-0.18892261385917664,
0.11453115195035934,
0.25620970129966736,
0.21283559501171112,
0.17231440544128418,
-0.4295022785663605,
0.6356666684150696,
-0.057465553283691406,
0.31390631198883057,
0.3537863790988922,
-0.012278662994503975,
0.4417376220226288,
-0.4187673032283783,
-0.038721296936273575,
-0.21107004582881927,
0.15609867870807648,
0.9730587005615234,
-0.05166527256369591,
0.857481062412262,
0.18272742629051208,
-0.33935514092445374,
-0.0866144523024559,
-0.607875406742096,
-0.24950261414051056,
-0.3655160069465637,
0.4058056175708771,
-0.21075601875782013,
-1.0981210470199585,
0.4657716453075409,
-0.050374146550893784,
-0.20108281075954437,
0.6448414921760559,
0.4754272401332855,
0.006003840360790491,
0.9547170400619507,
0.6567389965057373,
0.09483429044485092,
0.5197706818580627,
0.033626675605773926,
0.12355632334947586,
-0.9688377976417542,
0.059463318437337875,
-0.591687798500061,
-0.19247694313526154,
-0.6263065338134766,
-0.4580140709877014,
0.33437278866767883,
0.020900534465909004,
-0.26281726360321045,
0.09914615005254745,
-0.3042328953742981,
0.5601248741149902,
0.21132002770900726,
-0.059817682951688766,
0.3930892050266266,
-0.08601205796003342,
0.0052644372917711735,
-0.032627735286951065,
-0.844498872756958,
-0.5976011157035828,
1.034868836402893,
0.4536905884742737,
0.3999963402748108,
-0.01187348272651434,
0.054440245032310486,
0.08804884552955627,
0.2381182760000229,
-0.8669131994247437,
0.6147554516792297,
-0.1229952946305275,
-0.6620317697525024,
-0.5019403696060181,
-0.6093156337738037,
-1.0625114440917969,
0.6698179841041565,
-0.16499222815036774,
-0.7492178678512573,
0.30498355627059937,
-0.04761960729956627,
-0.47909602522850037,
0.1930943727493286,
-1.002030372619629,
0.7629303336143494,
-0.12484564632177353,
-0.3621540665626526,
-0.24643029272556305,
-0.7430519461631775,
0.24122683703899384,
-0.21099518239498138,
0.44593092799186707,
-0.2812851071357727,
-0.13223031163215637,
0.7958358526229858,
-0.40331241488456726,
0.8058452606201172,
0.08558126538991928,
-0.16941103339195251,
0.130452498793602,
0.17191624641418457,
0.14216451346874237,
0.03450414538383484,
-0.011868034489452839,
0.01027181651443243,
0.0555025190114975,
-0.45769238471984863,
-0.5341683030128479,
0.7012342810630798,
-0.8416994214057922,
-0.548600971698761,
-0.41013097763061523,
-0.5903568267822266,
-0.24523217976093292,
-0.05327651649713516,
0.5080751180648804,
0.43694591522216797,
-0.3982982039451599,
0.39744678139686584,
0.7710909843444824,
-0.36440929770469666,
0.30457812547683716,
0.3634265661239624,
-0.31703314185142517,
-0.14196640253067017,
0.7496268153190613,
0.25003930926322937,
0.8006072640419006,
0.17520397901535034,
0.4464682936668396,
-0.166781947016716,
-0.43125900626182556,
-0.4318375587463379,
0.7244754433631897,
-0.43773844838142395,
0.17078359425067902,
-0.5553722381591797,
-0.12257548421621323,
-0.4309035539627075,
0.06421977281570435,
-0.3499639928340912,
-0.3293280303478241,
-0.14670531451702118,
-0.09721721708774567,
0.3427305519580841,
1.124931812286377,
-0.208473339676857,
0.15632759034633636,
-0.4269770085811615,
-0.06466655433177948,
0.34384292364120483,
0.12072735279798508,
0.007456887047737837,
-0.9378406405448914,
-0.3208315372467041,
0.26206082105636597,
0.007674544584006071,
-0.6749904155731201,
0.3439399003982544,
0.35917213559150696,
0.1822095364332199,
0.2461475282907486,
-0.2468099296092987,
0.5510532259941101,
-0.43191877007484436,
0.6881232261657715,
-0.1617663949728012,
-0.7323623299598694,
0.3309856653213501,
-0.4294668138027191,
0.6143707633018494,
0.2124612182378769,
0.1239306703209877,
-0.6100601553916931,
-0.43990039825439453,
-0.6682089567184448,
-0.66476970911026,
0.5448049306869507,
0.22517041862010956,
0.2763073444366455,
-0.009922806173563004,
0.5948099493980408,
-0.03837478533387184,
-0.01467983704060316,
-0.7611521482467651,
0.13757973909378052,
0.35104575753211975,
0.2601347863674164,
-0.41452476382255554,
-0.24145016074180603,
0.017418431118130684,
-0.3435654640197754,
0.3474474847316742,
-0.14730142056941986,
0.27699926495552063,
0.40231168270111084,
-0.3043770492076874,
-0.23503108322620392,
0.3112103044986725,
0.8879374265670776,
0.6323736906051636,
-0.028281688690185547,
0.07353581488132477,
0.4478694498538971,
-0.6845559477806091,
0.04004358872771263,
-0.15714682638645172,
0.0941794216632843,
-0.22556982934474945,
0.7847720980644226,
0.8374959826469421,
0.44003957509994507,
-0.8970322012901306,
0.5401628613471985,
-0.3332073390483856,
-0.38578227162361145,
-0.17468701303005219,
-0.001942196162417531,
0.19294488430023193,
0.32907575368881226,
0.0789918377995491,
0.09497834742069244,
-0.057461682707071304,
-0.6066703200340271,
-0.3184520900249481,
0.2644549310207367,
-0.07691924273967743,
-0.4833223819732666,
0.6127265095710754,
0.03656748682260513,
-0.4601602256298065,
0.7116450071334839,
-0.21353623270988464,
-0.42606887221336365,
0.7496857047080994,
0.5050107836723328,
0.6120608448982239,
-0.2141302227973938,
0.17792131006717682,
0.42909857630729675,
0.4399169087409973,
-0.3300550878047943,
-0.10877399891614914,
0.017244726419448853,
-0.8522121906280518,
-0.4714397192001343,
-0.6064700484275818,
-0.2862420976161957,
0.08646123856306076,
-0.5235719084739685,
-0.1885838806629181,
-0.6695702075958252,
-0.15021592378616333,
0.11922777444124222,
0.07043963670730591,
-0.31602156162261963,
0.07744202762842178,
0.24524658918380737,
0.6789892911911011,
-0.7997461557388306,
0.8143246173858643,
0.7473506927490234,
-0.40841469168663025,
-0.9884856939315796,
0.09476692974567413,
-0.01899825967848301,
-0.4820448160171509,
0.5618404150009155,
0.1333504021167755,
-0.24669192731380463,
-0.08288277685642242,
-0.568442165851593,
-0.9494145512580872,
0.8413794636726379,
0.5603421926498413,
-0.3566003739833832,
-0.03644339740276337,
0.15107624232769012,
1.0243922472000122,
-0.3085944652557373,
0.0013533945893868804,
0.5856649279594421,
0.1291242241859436,
0.07485847920179367,
-1.246342658996582,
0.020700840279459953,
-0.1022225022315979,
0.08118397742509842,
0.19918292760849,
-0.7169362306594849,
1.025348424911499,
-0.44600439071655273,
-0.21975521743297577,
0.1251557618379593,
0.3149808645248413,
0.03268954157829285,
-0.07254504412412643,
0.4194607436656952,
0.22939613461494446,
0.8174850940704346,
0.14725461602210999,
1.1866939067840576,
0.04017915949225426,
0.2761212885379791,
0.9549569487571716,
-0.3206588923931122,
1.053808331489563,
0.3897610008716583,
-0.4059222936630249,
0.256038099527359,
0.6312483549118042,
0.36871445178985596,
-0.10559599101543427,
0.43181559443473816,
-0.1927146464586258,
-0.2557390332221985,
-0.1792852282524109,
-0.2871722877025604,
0.41797545552253723,
0.6493584513664246,
-0.3366084694862366,
0.09100975841283798,
0.25949060916900635,
0.362515926361084,
0.1321692019701004,
-0.19028408825397491,
0.7054978013038635,
0.19459180533885956,
-0.6053009033203125,
0.5894180536270142,
-0.13834302127361298,
0.47076067328453064,
-0.44598323106765747,
0.24314706027507782,
-0.4513240158557892,
0.30388525128364563,
-0.08282529562711716,
-0.4935595989227295,
0.3156200051307678,
0.05203865095973015,
-0.09568826109170914,
-0.07362447679042816,
0.7051588296890259,
-0.12384684383869171,
-0.3574444651603699,
0.5334648489952087,
0.5412418842315674,
0.3765685260295868,
-0.35248690843582153,
-0.27936339378356934,
0.23467092216014862,
-0.1002194955945015,
-0.21110773086547852,
0.5507851243019104,
0.6041982173919678,
-0.2733904719352722,
0.7524346113204956,
0.3959932327270508,
0.23951683938503265,
0.20475229620933533,
0.012914408929646015,
0.6959473490715027,
-0.5092053413391113,
0.06763432174921036,
-0.9911769032478333,
-0.03556079789996147,
-0.0471959188580513,
-0.46337786316871643,
0.7057281136512756,
0.46125978231430054,
0.8410547375679016,
0.028254583477973938,
0.27281704545021057,
0.01999426633119583,
0.40544211864471436,
-0.15498852729797363,
0.5409114956855774,
-0.6346195340156555,
0.30432698130607605,
-0.06239146366715431,
-0.811046302318573,
-0.5650758147239685,
0.6846126914024353,
-0.6051751375198364,
0.03820648789405823,
0.9124547839164734,
0.8085370063781738,
0.3108857274055481,
-0.0015310925664380193,
0.586566150188446,
0.6395964622497559,
0.023910224437713623,
0.38816818594932556,
0.7869956493377686,
-0.13425613939762115,
0.42500561475753784,
0.05256684869527817,
-0.3279179334640503,
-0.11470568180084229,
-0.3109031319618225,
-0.8890225291252136,
-0.5459400415420532,
-0.1420370191335678,
-0.15240280330181122,
-0.11679782718420029,
1.033204197883606,
0.5511840581893921,
-0.36377328634262085,
-0.5849735140800476,
-0.14931191504001617,
0.024159541353583336,
0.09193313866853714,
-0.15470555424690247,
0.1274380087852478,
-0.25828608870506287,
-0.5898518562316895,
0.3318726718425751,
0.47640836238861084,
-0.04653751477599144,
-0.32894277572631836,
0.029132822528481483,
-0.1918564736843109,
0.2329251915216446,
0.7523738741874695,
0.4364238977432251,
-0.9582014083862305,
-0.32103386521339417,
0.2388833463191986,
-0.36216288805007935,
0.2016310691833496,
0.7541342973709106,
-0.8126692175865173,
0.2804974615573883,
0.5495074987411499,
0.3743648827075958,
0.1914805918931961,
-0.4254579544067383,
0.8639517426490784,
-0.3703446388244629,
0.038040198385715485,
0.1644524782896042,
0.311705082654953,
0.4535764753818512,
-0.2655527889728546,
0.4308652877807617,
0.30519944429397583,
-0.9020974040031433,
-0.7614209055900574,
0.08754418790340424,
-0.7673993110656738,
-0.4575277268886566,
1.4004132747650146,
0.07451508194208145,
-0.25099366903305054,
0.13611574470996857,
-0.34653809666633606,
0.08413803577423096,
-0.23123295605182648,
0.6512492299079895,
1.000542163848877,
-0.1543838530778885,
0.1758352816104889,
-0.8182220458984375,
0.5549306273460388,
0.4986695945262909,
-0.5806140899658203,
0.14634034037590027,
0.4850427508354187,
0.3995705544948578,
0.11122845858335495,
0.5815091133117676,
-0.0695001631975174,
0.19060677289962769,
0.119454026222229,
-0.08950314670801163,
0.5684899687767029,
-0.18526290357112885,
-0.7586014270782471,
-0.05192064866423607,
0.49810123443603516,
0.029318297281861305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14851v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14851v3
|
From Matching to Generation: A Survey on Generative Information Retrieval
| 2024-04-23T09:05:37 | 2024-05-16T03:28:28 |
Xiaoxi Li, Jiajie Jin, Yujia Zhou, Yuyao Zhang, Peitian Zhang, Yutao Zhu, Zhicheng Dou
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Information Retrieval (IR) systems are crucial tools for users to access
information, widely applied in scenarios like search engines, question
answering, and recommendation systems. Traditional IR methods, based on
similarity matching to return ranked lists of documents, have been reliable
means of information acquisition, dominating the IR field for years. With the
advancement of pre-trained language models, generative information retrieval
(GenIR) has emerged as a novel paradigm, gaining increasing attention in recent
years. Currently, research in GenIR can be categorized into two aspects:
generative document retrieval (GR) and reliable response generation. GR
leverages the generative model's parameters for memorizing documents, enabling
retrieval by directly generating relevant document identifiers without explicit
indexing. Reliable response generation, on the other hand, employs language
models to directly generate the information users seek, breaking the
limitations of traditional IR in terms of document granularity and relevance
matching, offering more flexibility, efficiency, and creativity, thus better
meeting practical needs. This paper aims to systematically review the latest
research progress in GenIR. We will summarize the advancements in GR regarding
model training, document identifier, incremental learning, downstream tasks
adaptation, multi-modal GR and generative recommendation, as well as progress
in reliable response generation in aspects of internal knowledge memorization,
external knowledge augmentation, generating response with citations and
personal information assistant. We also review the evaluation, challenges and
future prospects in GenIR systems. This review aims to offer a comprehensive
reference for researchers in the GenIR field, encouraging further development
in this area.
|
[
-0.4514121413230896,
-0.528215229511261,
0.39350059628486633,
-0.06976179778575897,
0.20271912217140198,
0.31873488426208496,
0.008489083498716354,
-0.36143356561660767,
-0.13503381609916687,
0.26350024342536926,
-0.2180776596069336,
0.044825855642557144,
-0.36780914664268494,
0.09813898056745529,
-0.6661866307258606,
0.8421287536621094,
0.1267945021390915,
0.06784731149673462,
-0.6649245023727417,
-0.1454283446073532,
-0.49085676670074463,
-0.5734273791313171,
-0.5604583621025085,
-0.5362673997879028,
0.2420114278793335,
0.4105941355228424,
0.23500394821166992,
0.2389983832836151,
0.9814416170120239,
0.3277278244495392,
0.04975967854261398,
-0.0384865365922451,
-0.5212621688842773,
0.6230461597442627,
-0.14316818118095398,
-0.28433746099472046,
-0.10522519052028656,
-0.1759057193994522,
0.7205861210823059,
0.48430371284484863,
-0.394163578748703,
0.24950629472732544,
0.33014145493507385,
0.9401684999465942,
-0.6701081395149231,
-0.11576434224843979,
-0.5355764627456665,
0.19131429493427277,
-0.28012460470199585,
-0.672853946685791,
-0.5085865259170532,
-0.5901037454605103,
0.12490962445735931,
-0.48690396547317505,
0.8251788020133972,
0.10443125665187836,
0.8303976655006409,
-0.0576142854988575,
-0.12141158431768417,
-0.6032946705818176,
-1.1122896671295166,
0.47231829166412354,
-0.29821115732192993,
0.3995123505592346,
0.34776026010513306,
0.4250462055206299,
-0.39794930815696716,
-1.0010727643966675,
-0.45118600130081177,
-0.2040081024169922,
-0.009498076513409615,
0.3520706295967102,
-0.22632630169391632,
-0.0061155459843575954,
0.3348115086555481,
0.637085497379303,
-0.6679684519767761,
-0.3318881094455719,
-0.1858777105808258,
0.06709761917591095,
0.18724693357944489,
0.03616688400506973,
0.4279133975505829,
-0.23579838871955872,
-0.46191516518592834,
-0.42368707060813904,
-0.5593762397766113,
-0.36958935856819153,
0.44488248229026794,
0.11910910904407501,
0.37533265352249146,
0.7653473615646362,
-0.45827770233154297,
0.8294128179550171,
0.1965247392654419,
-0.11627023667097092,
0.023542553186416626,
-0.6866527199745178,
-0.2133646011352539,
-0.2508774697780609,
0.8002411723136902,
0.13867692649364471,
-0.04039943590760231,
-0.33195140957832336,
-0.30454614758491516,
-0.11566543579101562,
0.20855529606342316,
-0.5764346122741699,
0.06295570731163025,
-0.2908514738082886,
-0.6659526824951172,
-0.1243799552321434,
0.3674471378326416,
-1.151055932044983,
-0.1858372986316681,
-0.12065011262893677,
0.3770361542701721,
-0.5603468418121338,
-0.40444618463516235,
-0.13308951258659363,
-0.378118097782135,
0.5957658290863037,
0.15003474056720734,
-0.9608029127120972,
-0.07870502024888992,
0.631746768951416,
0.708365797996521,
0.2815017104148865,
0.0007117135100997984,
-0.41948267817497253,
0.18909746408462524,
-0.06760179251432419,
0.9965015649795532,
-0.5362234115600586,
-0.6097924113273621,
0.2204853743314743,
-0.43467211723327637,
-0.3271540105342865,
-0.7283425331115723,
0.34596383571624756,
-0.8116692304611206,
0.5314993262290955,
-0.19475677609443665,
-0.49039340019226074,
0.11956959962844849,
0.3060750365257263,
-0.48288509249687195,
1.0616211891174316,
0.3220982849597931,
-0.9959893226623535,
0.34687525033950806,
-0.3874179422855377,
-0.29618677496910095,
0.42660772800445557,
-0.32302242517471313,
-0.3657447397708893,
0.05798741802573204,
-0.3191488981246948,
0.1948520988225937,
-0.7239065766334534,
0.322273313999176,
-0.09874769300222397,
-0.16267898678779602,
0.1188134253025055,
-0.20438805222511292,
0.2059120386838913,
0.7423062324523926,
-0.15352500975131989,
-0.14883215725421906,
-0.7357950210571289,
0.1937997043132782,
0.10231635719537735,
-0.5161697268486023,
-0.2997687757015228,
0.23412500321865082,
0.1292879432439804,
0.07542365044355392,
0.20980721712112427,
-0.3519691824913025,
0.040583569556474686,
0.2260620892047882,
0.48785826563835144,
0.4648100435733795,
-0.03892594948410988,
0.43282780051231384,
-0.43631434440612793,
0.7686179280281067,
-0.4273335933685303,
0.07245338708162308,
-0.46939700841903687,
-0.3080180287361145,
-0.6249374747276306,
0.17515385150909424,
0.48192769289016724,
0.5009244680404663,
-0.9956803321838379,
0.3368172347545624,
-0.38754191994667053,
-0.31333914399147034,
-0.535064160823822,
0.06603692471981049,
0.5689560770988464,
0.6926076412200928,
0.23403851687908173,
-0.25281205773353577,
-0.5563595294952393,
-0.5217522978782654,
-0.07781798392534256,
-0.649245023727417,
-0.14898093044757843,
0.3346032202243805,
0.05846402794122696,
-0.08315836638212204,
0.902683436870575,
-0.32631585001945496,
-0.4160913825035095,
-0.36620375514030457,
0.46540123224258423,
-0.2773226797580719,
0.30734705924987793,
0.4844496548175812,
-1.137934923171997,
-0.4099291265010834,
0.2649294435977936,
-1.088305115699768,
0.11137040704488754,
0.05841335654258728,
-0.07230039685964584,
-0.0020525853615254164,
0.616843581199646,
-0.347427099943161,
0.13091297447681427,
0.19152304530143738,
-0.3257558345794678,
0.1476639360189438,
-0.3304135799407959,
0.5305548906326294,
-1.2597837448120117,
0.6180192828178406,
-0.1207740306854248,
-0.008754069916903973,
-0.5557260513305664,
0.42794403433799744,
-0.03171383589506149,
-0.10067222267389297,
0.20032551884651184,
0.33828970789909363,
-0.6259154081344604,
-0.1770593822002411,
-0.2983480989933014,
-0.005878448486328125,
-0.07338861376047134,
-0.15957801043987274,
-0.4035419821739197,
1.0817153453826904,
0.16700561344623566,
-0.4169258773326874,
0.28037914633750916,
0.5443376898765564,
-0.5332605838775635,
0.7194294929504395,
-0.32222095131874084,
0.41409051418304443,
-0.600827693939209,
0.01464337669312954,
-0.8769971132278442,
-0.47879087924957275,
0.20526622235774994,
-0.6711341142654419,
0.43045398592948914,
-0.18789710104465485,
-0.6355331540107727,
-0.5091228485107422,
-0.15589861571788788,
0.3352714776992798,
0.6289495825767517,
-0.38826215267181396,
0.8448500633239746,
0.12969394028186798,
-0.40284961462020874,
-0.6182311773300171,
-0.3576197326183319,
0.1770084649324417,
-0.03576023131608963,
-0.5230594873428345,
0.31615254282951355,
-0.3207567632198334,
-0.2964611053466797,
0.1799660325050354,
-0.12959325313568115,
0.07227244973182678,
0.023337626829743385,
-0.047215331345796585,
0.19656068086624146,
-0.18199601769447327,
0.14573167264461517,
-0.3748837113380432,
0.06736329942941666,
-0.3456912636756897,
0.0013424186035990715,
0.6423169374465942,
0.06989600509405136,
-0.25346991419792175,
0.15005970001220703,
0.5053222179412842,
0.49583330750465393,
-0.27355122566223145,
0.5552573204040527,
0.5448716282844543,
-0.07801567018032074,
0.25128909945487976,
-1.0301319360733032,
0.01418460812419653,
-0.44850143790245056,
0.10362054407596588,
-0.573327362537384,
-0.8386242985725403,
0.47562745213508606,
0.0060601988807320595,
-0.40041932463645935,
0.4110662341117859,
0.2752321660518646,
-0.1801656186580658,
0.8972948789596558,
0.8408204317092896,
-0.1291845291852951,
1.0043303966522217,
-0.1405581682920456,
0.09903933107852936,
-0.8760572075843811,
-0.7237761616706848,
-0.9696478843688965,
0.08265120536088943,
-0.5255163908004761,
0.049377527087926865,
0.2568823993206024,
0.31630939245224,
0.08528976142406464,
0.04333734139800072,
-0.6342307329177856,
0.24251091480255127,
0.7685056328773499,
-0.19271214306354523,
0.3526972234249115,
0.2086145132780075,
-0.0324515737593174,
0.3621387481689453,
-0.7015907764434814,
-0.37788453698158264,
0.9529848694801331,
-0.09425059705972672,
1.0134741067886353,
0.0032786400988698006,
0.5228805541992188,
0.46021199226379395,
0.3365154266357422,
-0.43425649404525757,
0.6529859304428101,
-0.18613973259925842,
-0.2820843756198883,
-0.030642714351415634,
-0.6390353441238403,
-1.0581340789794922,
0.0993354320526123,
-0.14159785211086273,
-0.25013864040374756,
0.23961041867733002,
0.055198103189468384,
-0.15550589561462402,
0.25489863753318787,
-0.6538704633712769,
0.40611061453819275,
-0.07680463790893555,
-0.15147612988948822,
-0.04227635636925697,
-0.8294901251792908,
-0.029527783393859863,
-0.002371086971834302,
-0.14862054586410522,
0.07573658227920532,
0.5483238697052002,
0.7293754816055298,
0.09119648486375809,
0.05609336495399475,
-0.08074276894330978,
0.1997946798801422,
0.3322984278202057,
-0.11980851739645004,
0.226543128490448,
-0.29887089133262634,
-0.4341753423213959,
-0.2989084720611572,
-0.013374680653214455,
-0.2189834862947464,
-0.4595836400985718,
0.6763032078742981,
-0.6174540519714355,
-0.6351947784423828,
-0.5382600426673889,
-0.3345957398414612,
0.013718667440116405,
0.3891994059085846,
0.630588710308075,
0.29718834161758423,
-0.46912574768066406,
0.2719031870365143,
0.9707999229431152,
-0.040242284536361694,
0.42737066745758057,
0.4372701048851013,
-0.010937531478703022,
-0.5498034358024597,
0.932799756526947,
-0.05641923472285271,
0.24384146928787231,
0.7236886024475098,
-0.20104989409446716,
-0.10046122223138809,
-0.5325749516487122,
-0.3593956232070923,
0.07273489981889725,
-0.6027961373329163,
-0.5064765214920044,
-0.6264570951461792,
-0.3798624575138092,
-0.5793172121047974,
0.15611687302589417,
0.14138559997081757,
0.01883486658334732,
-0.39297235012054443,
-0.009388720616698265,
0.08841483294963837,
0.863810122013092,
-0.035839829593896866,
-0.03279140591621399,
-0.7941403985023499,
0.5082865953445435,
0.4355942904949188,
0.48624125123023987,
0.03219616413116455,
-0.27470850944519043,
-0.142490953207016,
-0.2156532108783722,
-0.420318067073822,
-0.6576092839241028,
0.07699231058359146,
0.4199609160423279,
0.5968764424324036,
0.40581613779067993,
0.017805252224206924,
0.5685643553733826,
-0.43307581543922424,
0.49013084173202515,
0.13201916217803955,
-0.34461092948913574,
0.8008403778076172,
-0.36889442801475525,
0.07222326844930649,
0.7625983357429504,
0.15738241374492645,
-0.6232704520225525,
-0.15787194669246674,
-0.4244149625301361,
-0.9006125926971436,
0.5838857293128967,
0.07593809068202972,
0.25197893381118774,
-0.18518345057964325,
0.6234316229820251,
0.1076371893286705,
0.2843332886695862,
-0.3089730441570282,
-0.05566677451133728,
-0.04461256414651871,
-0.34783434867858887,
0.12907446920871735,
-0.4194445013999939,
-0.07630874961614609,
0.22892947494983673,
0.5880025029182434,
-0.13425739109516144,
0.894090473651886,
0.26094239950180054,
-0.036000825464725494,
-0.5248720645904541,
0.5552041530609131,
0.3916645646095276,
0.6400371789932251,
-0.5287970900535583,
-0.12351705133914948,
-0.5885754823684692,
-0.5222930908203125,
0.383780300617218,
0.44859805703163147,
-0.5552541017532349,
-0.1563180685043335,
0.11225882172584534,
0.6684725284576416,
-0.2831007242202759,
-0.5631217956542969,
0.4958873391151428,
-0.19968125224113464,
-0.1805979460477829,
-0.48471301794052124,
0.17402225732803345,
-0.46627944707870483,
0.19200502336025238,
0.789909839630127,
0.08665823936462402,
0.19065570831298828,
-0.6985199451446533,
0.07012015581130981,
0.8173718452453613,
-0.3019321858882904,
-0.25155308842658997,
0.8260388374328613,
0.11542339622974396,
-0.3970453143119812,
1.0023350715637207,
-0.009198968298733234,
-0.034490715712308884,
0.39167168736457825,
0.6768918037414551,
0.9886327385902405,
-0.2605140209197998,
0.33347180485725403,
0.3234562873840332,
0.0249622855335474,
-0.43993332982063293,
0.25514593720436096,
-0.2649579644203186,
-0.635736346244812,
0.022031167522072792,
-0.6593820452690125,
-0.25665155053138733,
0.1424454301595688,
-1.0511540174484253,
-0.2425113022327423,
-0.18446886539459229,
-0.4245947003364563,
-0.1753513664007187,
-0.26714828610420227,
-0.7016215324401855,
0.0048051197081804276,
-0.07477191090583801,
0.911526620388031,
-0.5588454008102417,
0.537302553653717,
0.9896949529647827,
-0.7507421374320984,
-0.2988082468509674,
0.22558237612247467,
-0.41913992166519165,
-0.45865753293037415,
0.5734037756919861,
-0.01597215235233307,
-0.19042694568634033,
0.2429407685995102,
-0.35717177391052246,
-0.7788479924201965,
1.334958553314209,
0.2953699231147766,
-0.2702992856502533,
-0.34642061591148376,
0.04197942465543747,
0.594010055065155,
-0.018686721101403236,
0.40770766139030457,
0.4028683602809906,
0.23540501296520233,
0.3258158266544342,
-0.6174439191818237,
-0.13547751307487488,
-0.5523076057434082,
0.4484894573688507,
0.35735079646110535,
-0.7853413820266724,
0.5223180055618286,
-0.05000538006424904,
-0.536876916885376,
0.8281750679016113,
0.6329531669616699,
0.02568037249147892,
0.4983217120170593,
0.13801224529743195,
0.6945316195487976,
0.5779929161071777,
-0.25840359926223755,
1.2203503847122192,
-0.2522798180580139,
0.22803595662117004,
0.6693109273910522,
-0.32968077063560486,
0.7748104333877563,
0.452792763710022,
-0.1424458920955658,
0.5364869832992554,
0.4124619662761688,
-0.12897777557373047,
0.791183590888977,
-0.051265865564346313,
-0.6766456365585327,
0.010970941744744778,
-0.3588850498199463,
-0.6427050828933716,
-0.009217645972967148,
0.25327545404434204,
-0.47326791286468506,
-0.14919808506965637,
0.3139386773109436,
-0.3572043776512146,
0.1363515406847,
-0.064764104783535,
1.1646161079406738,
-0.20620836317539215,
-0.9248634576797485,
0.07482337206602097,
-0.02192515693604946,
0.5739185810089111,
-0.7885527610778809,
-0.25190210342407227,
-0.5758501887321472,
0.0725691020488739,
0.03682845085859299,
-0.5602524280548096,
-0.20762516558170319,
-0.031356845051050186,
-0.6210814714431763,
-0.3118489980697632,
1.0691108703613281,
-0.3629266321659088,
-0.24524618685245514,
0.3515144884586334,
0.6128950119018555,
-0.27999982237815857,
0.3341701030731201,
-0.47732284665107727,
-0.14150919020175934,
-0.049006689339876175,
-0.06657697260379791,
0.6194111704826355,
0.3193638324737549,
0.31032174825668335,
0.7912105321884155,
0.5479412078857422,
-0.04350157454609871,
0.18194954097270966,
0.16523432731628418,
0.729272186756134,
-0.6673708558082581,
-0.1805424690246582,
-0.3469100296497345,
0.09674687683582306,
0.09476923942565918,
-0.056370705366134644,
0.5847558975219727,
0.5288127064704895,
0.9780507683753967,
-0.05628768727183342,
1.0266841650009155,
-0.5605613589286804,
0.389354944229126,
-0.4494449496269226,
0.4672855734825134,
-0.3252438008785248,
0.03821854665875435,
-0.2816525995731354,
-1.0512322187423706,
-0.19209398329257965,
0.4139012396335602,
0.13775844871997833,
0.36305496096611023,
0.36632469296455383,
0.6922177076339722,
0.056199267506599426,
-0.2414836436510086,
0.1586364060640335,
-0.14469800889492035,
0.27846723794937134,
0.15529146790504456,
1.0844508409500122,
-0.5564085841178894,
0.7717863917350769,
0.25762975215911865,
-0.1272667795419693,
-0.42930856347084045,
-0.5064316987991333,
-0.29688188433647156,
-0.7750383019447327,
-0.11781428009271622,
-0.3955129086971283,
0.46259570121765137,
0.6296496987342834,
0.32086026668548584,
-0.738365113735199,
-0.13168521225452423,
-0.3619547486305237,
-0.03511076793074608,
-0.06432017683982849,
-0.2924598157405853,
0.14377178251743317,
-0.5486276745796204,
-0.5226943492889404,
0.3698795437812805,
0.20781812071800232,
0.35818466544151306,
0.017921743914484978,
-0.0652572512626648,
-0.2724508047103882,
-0.27267831563949585,
0.4139074981212616,
0.8126040697097778,
-0.4840502142906189,
-0.21537530422210693,
0.1543799191713333,
-0.3692055344581604,
0.16433227062225342,
1.0363787412643433,
-0.7671418190002441,
0.7924031019210815,
0.8004323244094849,
0.7350489497184753,
0.410393089056015,
0.2712216079235077,
0.6266541481018066,
-0.5734548568725586,
-0.39497828483581543,
0.11741360276937485,
0.14285480976104736,
0.6657723188400269,
-0.3414069712162018,
0.7682621479034424,
0.10650362074375153,
-0.7658712267875671,
-0.8133505582809448,
0.20477788150310516,
-0.7034894227981567,
0.06396029144525528,
0.9848029613494873,
0.00600060261785984,
0.2287098616361618,
-0.09698919951915741,
-0.06160712242126465,
0.2939455509185791,
-0.15201589465141296,
0.8602814674377441,
0.5218780636787415,
-0.20017485320568085,
-0.14921236038208008,
-0.45333045721054077,
0.30608323216438293,
0.44813305139541626,
-0.7295759916305542,
-0.1992281675338745,
0.4715694785118103,
0.19397515058517456,
0.402957022190094,
0.8691306114196777,
-0.18542087078094482,
0.2413085699081421,
-0.13605144619941711,
0.28498271107673645,
0.07324349135160446,
-0.3355828821659088,
-0.2691078186035156,
0.3889513909816742,
0.5307963490486145,
-0.1800789088010788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14850v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14850v1
|
Simple, Efficient and Scalable Structure-aware Adapter Boosts Protein Language Models
| 2024-04-23T09:05:09 | 2024-04-23T09:05:09 |
Yang Tan, Mingchen Li, Bingxin Zhou, Bozitao Zhong, Lirong Zheng, Pan Tan, Ziyi Zhou, Huiqun Yu, Guisheng Fan, Liang Hong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.BM
|
Fine-tuning Pre-trained protein language models (PLMs) has emerged as a
prominent strategy for enhancing downstream prediction tasks, often
outperforming traditional supervised learning approaches. As a widely applied
powerful technique in natural language processing, employing
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning techniques could potentially enhance the
performance of PLMs. However, the direct transfer to life science tasks is
non-trivial due to the different training strategies and data forms. To address
this gap, we introduce SES-Adapter, a simple, efficient, and scalable adapter
method for enhancing the representation learning of PLMs. SES-Adapter
incorporates PLM embeddings with structural sequence embeddings to create
structure-aware representations. We show that the proposed method is compatible
with different PLM architectures and across diverse tasks. Extensive
evaluations are conducted on 2 types of folding structures with notable quality
differences, 9 state-of-the-art baselines, and 9 benchmark datasets across
distinct downstream tasks. Results show that compared to vanilla PLMs,
SES-Adapter improves downstream task performance by a maximum of 11% and an
average of 3%, with significantly accelerated training speed by a maximum of
1034% and an average of 362%, the convergence rate is also improved by
approximately 2 times. Moreover, positive optimization is observed even with
low-quality predicted structures. The source code for SES-Adapter is available
at https://github.com/tyang816/SES-Adapter.
|
[
-0.1651642918586731,
-0.28317761421203613,
0.5061232447624207,
0.18435737490653992,
-0.446665495634079,
-0.15008950233459473,
0.01610265113413334,
-0.1415117084980011,
0.4107217788696289,
0.23142272233963013,
-0.23124238848686218,
-0.34109655022621155,
-0.8024414777755737,
0.24322274327278137,
0.022318584844470024,
0.6590129733085632,
0.24302014708518982,
0.129665344953537,
-0.11794045567512512,
-0.14735722541809082,
-0.04045481979846954,
-0.1327398717403412,
-0.5489391684532166,
-0.06261871755123138,
0.410895437002182,
0.27337002754211426,
0.3970643877983093,
0.9863726496696472,
0.35253188014030457,
0.35088157653808594,
-0.3670978844165802,
0.27000951766967773,
-0.35373470187187195,
0.11662090569734573,
-0.4874263107776642,
-0.5016294717788696,
-0.6692916750907898,
-0.44193822145462036,
0.6665257811546326,
1.0053309202194214,
0.1390300691127777,
0.3915574848651886,
0.49395087361335754,
1.130078673362732,
-0.7137064933776855,
0.38754135370254517,
-0.6735191941261292,
-0.044337496161460876,
-0.2343619465827942,
-0.38890624046325684,
-0.5783753395080566,
0.005034558940678835,
0.19589388370513916,
-0.5793469548225403,
0.2221035212278366,
-0.10148762166500092,
0.4496658742427826,
0.2503657341003418,
-0.368746280670166,
-0.017834914848208427,
-0.3659476935863495,
0.3125060498714447,
-0.7837241291999817,
0.5680864453315735,
0.058544330298900604,
0.36915409564971924,
-0.5454524755477905,
-0.7292536497116089,
-0.20313936471939087,
0.14022384583950043,
0.007026038598269224,
0.2800920903682709,
0.12580105662345886,
0.35035762190818787,
0.2942875623703003,
0.4092329740524292,
-0.6853274703025818,
-0.06916524469852448,
-0.502577543258667,
-0.12266132235527039,
0.43947985768318176,
-0.1867303103208542,
0.4603089988231659,
-0.16481976211071014,
0.09073278307914734,
-0.0483303926885128,
-0.740151047706604,
0.22595325112342834,
0.06804357469081879,
0.6383214592933655,
-0.08762931078672409,
0.4663979411125183,
-0.23186421394348145,
0.8918437957763672,
0.16789595782756805,
0.22542676329612732,
0.44578251242637634,
0.003998036030679941,
-0.1863069236278534,
0.07079321891069412,
0.2855421006679535,
0.05658397451043129,
-0.15148353576660156,
-0.04905890300869942,
0.03709898144006729,
-0.04048275947570801,
0.33611300587654114,
-1.0677751302719116,
-0.4533687233924866,
0.2471981644630432,
-0.6317904591560364,
0.2157444953918457,
0.17947782576084137,
-0.6302704215049744,
-0.3954859972000122,
-0.19461160898208618,
0.522855818271637,
-0.5265666246414185,
0.056767672300338745,
0.42016324400901794,
-0.41204777359962463,
0.2851298451423645,
0.29974365234375,
-0.8175696134567261,
0.19315770268440247,
0.40948495268821716,
1.0662914514541626,
-0.1349080502986908,
-0.21571746468544006,
-1.0649311542510986,
0.6110652685165405,
-0.0785314068198204,
1.0392982959747314,
-0.3871487081050873,
-0.09999236464500427,
-0.27257853746414185,
0.43462732434272766,
-0.2675727307796478,
-0.3934481143951416,
0.6945521235466003,
-0.23545372486114502,
-0.2752547264099121,
-0.3261581361293793,
-0.7875356078147888,
-0.2126459777355194,
-0.23961277306079865,
-0.6750491857528687,
0.4798259437084198,
0.056556787341833115,
-0.5297671556472778,
0.29275116324424744,
-0.8536014556884766,
-0.7856616973876953,
0.4502343535423279,
-0.18195462226867676,
-0.3177027106285095,
0.4595276117324829,
0.2823411226272583,
0.5533870458602905,
0.20659376680850983,
-0.10643762350082397,
-0.6853404641151428,
-0.44187894463539124,
-0.13092930614948273,
0.18076907098293304,
0.32813119888305664,
0.23414874076843262,
-0.13903382420539856,
0.30091914534568787,
-0.9279869794845581,
0.06482476741075516,
-0.0720919817686081,
-0.5789712071418762,
-0.34075433015823364,
0.33373114466667175,
-0.37297049164772034,
0.07206204533576965,
-0.03583864867687225,
-0.5365910530090332,
0.2806207537651062,
-0.7916325926780701,
0.6800463795661926,
0.706518292427063,
-0.1334151178598404,
0.8147508502006531,
-0.2629672586917877,
0.14166022837162018,
-0.0228223018348217,
-0.10293982177972794,
-0.4075692594051361,
-0.23001717031002045,
-0.7615125179290771,
-0.435863196849823,
-0.06627600640058517,
0.2026911824941635,
-0.5277111530303955,
0.45998021960258484,
-0.47238072752952576,
-0.7004831433296204,
-0.5452853441238403,
0.1969543695449829,
0.06750433892011642,
0.35127004981040955,
0.6159188747406006,
-0.17032316327095032,
-0.7933907508850098,
-0.7911131978034973,
-0.866577684879303,
0.10707449913024902,
-0.3560584783554077,
0.15765121579170227,
0.30676203966140747,
-0.26495978236198425,
0.5188548564910889,
-0.42429500818252563,
-0.3064979016780853,
-0.3252179026603699,
-0.046811237931251526,
0.3776894211769104,
0.5300478935241699,
0.5228161811828613,
-0.48044803738594055,
-0.5485934615135193,
-0.023859653621912003,
-0.38191595673561096,
-0.05671749636530876,
-0.02051972970366478,
0.12166906893253326,
0.023755135014653206,
0.4753275513648987,
-0.1544390767812729,
0.18686993420124054,
0.7061980962753296,
-0.5826075077056885,
0.29444047808647156,
-0.3944745361804962,
-0.09789954125881195,
-1.184976577758789,
0.08260535448789597,
-0.042999908328056335,
-0.20248320698738098,
-0.6675710082054138,
-0.13450320065021515,
0.27932125329971313,
-0.13096214830875397,
-0.6082282662391663,
0.3979867994785309,
-0.6016345024108887,
-0.35214900970458984,
-0.4062022268772125,
-0.08365693688392639,
0.08304077386856079,
0.3977438807487488,
-0.01270503643900156,
0.7942100167274475,
0.6740941405296326,
-0.7486714124679565,
-0.46360427141189575,
0.41378942131996155,
-0.19860203564167023,
0.11852028965950012,
-0.8494641780853271,
0.1168854609131813,
-0.42648187279701233,
0.1831027716398239,
-0.8614336848258972,
-0.2029527723789215,
0.029926933348178864,
-0.14852717518806458,
0.17652282118797302,
-0.400595486164093,
-0.13085412979125977,
-0.2363051176071167,
-0.5920843482017517,
0.138983353972435,
0.28349581360816956,
-0.6258528232574463,
1.1270822286605835,
0.430809885263443,
-0.4201694130897522,
0.09227407723665237,
-0.6812002658843994,
-0.2774283289909363,
0.004009251017123461,
-0.6706022024154663,
0.7268447875976562,
-0.21497923135757446,
0.5676339268684387,
-0.3763956129550934,
-0.7720335721969604,
0.1380051225423813,
0.03773312270641327,
0.5135554075241089,
0.038083285093307495,
-0.2551918625831604,
-0.061336345970630646,
0.4769136905670166,
-0.1593690663576126,
-0.21254223585128784,
-0.4597075879573822,
0.4049595892429352,
-0.654944658279419,
-0.32259586453437805,
-0.24474427103996277,
0.0620831623673439,
0.7727344632148743,
-0.1913832724094391,
0.6977989673614502,
0.31580162048339844,
-0.2136055827140808,
-0.2772526443004608,
-0.27993616461753845,
-0.24315428733825684,
-0.5685052275657654,
0.7211260199546814,
-0.6112110614776611,
-0.8610995411872864,
0.3947868347167969,
-0.48144033551216125,
-0.09069252014160156,
0.2858051359653473,
0.07486845552921295,
-0.25870436429977417,
1.0782402753829956,
0.6549255847930908,
0.21039611101150513,
0.5306346416473389,
-0.16321130096912384,
0.23005038499832153,
-0.9830246567726135,
-0.09893111884593964,
-0.5960528254508972,
-0.4345470666885376,
-0.37278687953948975,
-0.6430636644363403,
0.26189154386520386,
0.3820604085922241,
-0.3871959149837494,
0.6756764054298401,
-0.45602408051490784,
0.41914501786231995,
0.22918932139873505,
0.2106076180934906,
0.1245076134800911,
0.17759579420089722,
-0.1093289703130722,
-0.009396440349519253,
-1.0053625106811523,
-0.5880042314529419,
0.7932408452033997,
0.3970600664615631,
0.632813036441803,
0.03256521001458168,
0.6013696193695068,
0.15314476191997528,
0.09589510411024094,
-0.7810773849487305,
0.5381289720535278,
-0.7515658736228943,
0.09012415260076523,
-0.20119158923625946,
-0.19477646052837372,
-0.6141535639762878,
0.25973042845726013,
-0.14612053334712982,
-0.5307618379592896,
0.5747179388999939,
0.38509491086006165,
-0.4114201068878174,
0.22627633810043335,
-0.7945322394371033,
0.7450853586196899,
-0.2523101568222046,
-0.3653465211391449,
-0.09687016904354095,
-0.5657849907875061,
-0.3444763422012329,
0.06934349983930588,
0.2638688087463379,
-0.05508191138505936,
-0.044772882014513016,
0.9095714092254639,
-0.27920404076576233,
0.8142416477203369,
-0.22160707414150238,
0.18792501091957092,
-0.05815428867936134,
0.1282753199338913,
0.6196829080581665,
0.11063363403081894,
-0.3756650984287262,
0.011508245021104813,
0.15604913234710693,
-0.6381212472915649,
-0.59442138671875,
0.6106823682785034,
-0.6823696494102478,
-0.5073561072349548,
-0.254629909992218,
-0.47889700531959534,
-0.2052726000547409,
0.4121714234352112,
0.12376762181520462,
0.22972503304481506,
0.15447181463241577,
0.5715245008468628,
0.5402339100837708,
-0.23344089090824127,
0.294656902551651,
0.9545615315437317,
0.03645141050219536,
-0.41910913586616516,
0.9530622959136963,
0.1566532850265503,
0.11733788996934891,
0.5314901471138,
0.2489648014307022,
-0.07899396121501923,
-0.7116364240646362,
-0.19141553342342377,
0.22264869511127472,
-0.48952245712280273,
-0.3810104429721832,
-0.7809213995933533,
-0.36743292212486267,
-0.3778613805770874,
-0.44309550523757935,
-0.5862783789634705,
-0.40257349610328674,
-0.15040674805641174,
-0.16604027152061462,
0.10511189699172974,
0.33731499314308167,
0.05946953967213631,
0.266839861869812,
-0.9430673122406006,
0.37528395652770996,
0.27380454540252686,
0.6914358735084534,
-0.37177643179893494,
-0.782272458076477,
-0.28207820653915405,
0.05627162382006645,
-0.20315611362457275,
-0.9367408156394958,
0.2531290054321289,
0.9322602152824402,
0.6530106663703918,
0.3178035020828247,
-0.029241502285003662,
0.8867947459220886,
-0.47184038162231445,
0.431054025888443,
-0.11158600449562073,
-0.9193417429924011,
0.8766195774078369,
-0.11926746368408203,
0.5510728359222412,
0.6169615387916565,
0.3433400094509125,
-0.13580629229545593,
-0.2731214761734009,
-0.12827692925930023,
-0.9286874532699585,
0.6707195043563843,
-0.05079904571175575,
-0.026312358677387238,
-0.062423232942819595,
0.4611593782901764,
0.32359254360198975,
-0.12002091109752655,
-0.6387878656387329,
-0.11335984617471695,
-0.25366485118865967,
-0.20274929702281952,
-0.006439423654228449,
-0.4403493404388428,
0.3608045279979706,
-0.5175120830535889,
0.7878411412239075,
-0.6723203063011169,
0.09914417564868927,
0.388277530670166,
-0.5093600153923035,
-0.2926200032234192,
0.5138881206512451,
0.3314126133918762,
0.44162672758102417,
-0.4248639643192291,
0.32387420535087585,
0.24768520891666412,
-0.510642409324646,
-0.22688491642475128,
0.42491716146469116,
-0.33196520805358887,
-0.16406013071537018,
0.31013545393943787,
0.8076728582382202,
0.3902161419391632,
-0.6244468092918396,
0.34851351380348206,
0.12015404552221298,
-0.10706239193677902,
0.27299565076828003,
0.1802070438861847,
0.28524166345596313,
0.4279322922229767,
0.41437339782714844,
0.38356703519821167,
0.4375745356082916,
-0.3663181960582733,
0.23387445509433746,
0.21837136149406433,
-0.2626734673976898,
-0.7190661430358887,
0.5406977534294128,
0.3525993525981903,
-0.30110570788383484,
0.021020110696554184,
-0.0016340474830940366,
-0.5655848383903503,
0.1710699200630188,
0.9600055813789368,
0.7961574196815491,
-0.45666494965553284,
0.1859959214925766,
0.38601648807525635,
0.08607540279626846,
-0.11804144084453583,
0.5355557203292847,
-0.06831806153059006,
-0.5563169717788696,
-0.4967568814754486,
-1.146642804145813,
0.04412674531340599,
0.049594707787036896,
-0.4681454598903656,
0.4105011224746704,
-0.30243119597435,
0.1404043287038803,
0.10542301833629608,
-0.035317543894052505,
-0.6610372066497803,
-0.22688189148902893,
0.1794014722108841,
1.438388466835022,
-0.9733249545097351,
0.9059038758277893,
1.3143593072891235,
-0.2164028137922287,
-0.6837735176086426,
-0.20685671269893646,
-0.17724601924419403,
-0.37073174118995667,
0.4567277431488037,
0.45040667057037354,
-0.12843523919582367,
0.14512653648853302,
-0.0718875452876091,
-0.9664242267608643,
1.1309576034545898,
0.7474789619445801,
-0.9338773488998413,
-0.15421633422374725,
0.19070492684841156,
0.5517088770866394,
-0.5054072737693787,
0.06292754411697388,
0.4030853509902954,
0.1784893125295639,
-0.03561590239405632,
-0.37675940990448,
0.31329819560050964,
-0.5109341740608215,
0.22386421263217926,
-0.01010819897055626,
-0.4288647174835205,
0.5518473982810974,
-0.12273655831813812,
-0.237369105219841,
-0.0163370743393898,
0.8793891668319702,
0.5746349096298218,
0.16754412651062012,
0.4713008403778076,
0.23718051612377167,
0.6093816161155701,
0.1796732395887375,
0.7114353775978088,
-0.5653551816940308,
0.0617656409740448,
1.2700402736663818,
-0.20854756236076355,
0.9192285537719727,
0.7280123829841614,
-0.23013542592525482,
0.5660765767097473,
0.14092929661273956,
0.04658946394920349,
0.632824182510376,
0.17367558181285858,
0.10835971683263779,
-0.42316997051239014,
0.08703861385583878,
-0.46711021661758423,
0.25069186091423035,
0.5086377859115601,
-0.44739487767219543,
-0.30092549324035645,
0.05240771546959877,
-0.5964828729629517,
0.13421060144901276,
-0.3793596029281616,
0.7496423125267029,
0.2130390852689743,
-0.335460901260376,
0.17724744975566864,
-0.25034865736961365,
0.5382283329963684,
-0.7138928174972534,
-0.1629086583852768,
-0.2535862922668457,
0.31997185945510864,
-0.31937530636787415,
-0.5421677231788635,
0.49322688579559326,
-0.42219939827919006,
-0.294827938079834,
-0.20541630685329437,
1.175306797027588,
-0.4541834890842438,
-0.3430798053741455,
0.40962639451026917,
0.43946945667266846,
-0.11405938118696213,
-0.1383398473262787,
-0.4363502860069275,
0.18890845775604248,
-0.10741643607616425,
-0.2429308295249939,
0.41263195872306824,
0.03743057698011398,
0.21967168152332306,
0.6602842807769775,
0.6200081706047058,
0.27535444498062134,
-0.030994130298495293,
-0.08824755996465683,
1.0465891361236572,
-0.5842292308807373,
-0.6928006410598755,
-0.6052802205085754,
0.5391440987586975,
-0.0771656408905983,
0.15971852838993073,
0.643491804599762,
0.8307916522026062,
0.7989372611045837,
-0.4964348375797272,
0.6591995358467102,
0.10166138410568237,
0.4325023591518402,
-0.33319810032844543,
0.7380393147468567,
-0.3370938301086426,
0.48254191875457764,
-0.19246812164783478,
-0.862389862537384,
-0.259371280670166,
0.667758047580719,
-0.35675299167633057,
-0.2999670207500458,
0.5364547967910767,
0.675945520401001,
-0.17867650091648102,
0.2286706566810608,
0.07453037798404694,
0.443506121635437,
0.46843451261520386,
0.35498642921447754,
0.26795873045921326,
-0.6278505325317383,
0.45494765043258667,
-0.09973766654729843,
-0.19610987603664398,
-0.39056161046028137,
-0.9848450422286987,
-0.8009650707244873,
-0.5085610151290894,
-0.4105498492717743,
-0.14658425748348236,
0.471731036901474,
0.9546178579330444,
0.8654897809028625,
-1.0452501773834229,
-0.08619401603937149,
-0.437069296836853,
-0.2405438870191574,
-0.3339730203151703,
-0.16294358670711517,
0.5832952857017517,
-0.47872066497802734,
-0.358008474111557,
0.77777099609375,
0.7541142702102661,
0.10290846228599548,
0.4899461269378662,
-0.3068104088306427,
-0.12415996193885803,
0.11704260110855103,
0.8952963948249817,
0.4635482132434845,
-0.5349810719490051,
-0.2767193913459778,
0.04594915360212326,
0.13356614112854004,
-0.05826831981539726,
0.6652606129646301,
-0.8595397472381592,
0.4791816771030426,
0.7427309155464172,
1.0018702745437622,
0.3409212827682495,
-0.20985645055770874,
0.7256754040718079,
-0.6521012783050537,
-0.015477457083761692,
-0.0017827429110184312,
0.6047518849372864,
0.18328982591629028,
-0.3320522904396057,
0.363038569688797,
0.08210496604442596,
-0.35249295830726624,
-0.6899035573005676,
0.19445164501667023,
-1.1933259963989258,
-0.29779142141342163,
0.8264759182929993,
-0.19773215055465698,
-0.4480062425136566,
0.03892844542860985,
-0.1486182063817978,
0.48722946643829346,
-0.2738321125507355,
0.7725328207015991,
0.10727708041667938,
-0.09492853283882141,
-0.011563851498067379,
-0.052517641335725784,
0.6076406836509705,
0.626345694065094,
-0.8349720239639282,
0.057410698384046555,
0.13661354780197144,
0.5150357484817505,
0.05729116499423981,
0.3246639370918274,
-0.14508070051670074,
0.31977614760398865,
-0.3582131564617157,
-0.2549208998680115,
-0.418902724981308,
-0.2847004532814026,
-0.46496185660362244,
0.20728597044944763,
0.07565462589263916,
-0.0273811686784029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14831v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14831v2
|
Towards Universal Dense Blocking for Entity Resolution
| 2024-04-23T08:39:29 | 2024-04-25T06:37:51 |
Tianshu Wang, Hongyu Lin, Xianpei Han, Xiaoyang Chen, Boxi Cao, Le Sun
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Blocking is a critical step in entity resolution, and the emergence of neural
network-based representation models has led to the development of dense
blocking as a promising approach for exploring deep semantics in blocking.
However, previous advanced self-supervised dense blocking approaches require
domain-specific training on the target domain, which limits the benefits and
rapid adaptation of these methods. To address this issue, we propose
UniBlocker, a dense blocker that is pre-trained on a domain-independent,
easily-obtainable tabular corpus using self-supervised contrastive learning. By
conducting domain-independent pre-training, UniBlocker can be adapted to
various downstream blocking scenarios without requiring domain-specific
fine-tuning. To evaluate the universality of our entity blocker, we also
construct a new benchmark covering a wide range of blocking tasks from multiple
domains and scenarios. Our experiments show that the proposed UniBlocker,
without any domain-specific learning, significantly outperforms previous self-
and unsupervised dense blocking methods and is comparable and complementary to
the state-of-the-art sparse blocking methods.
|
[
-0.592906653881073,
-0.565382719039917,
0.4906418025493622,
0.016895093023777008,
-0.43820109963417053,
0.39740681648254395,
-0.32237011194229126,
-0.5012181401252747,
0.3985593616962433,
0.9039790034294128,
-0.05004287138581276,
-0.6024999618530273,
-0.6179074645042419,
-0.04959525913000107,
-0.6714757084846497,
0.9460193514823914,
-0.2063799798488617,
-0.03161551058292389,
0.08756931871175766,
0.06485191732645035,
-0.7761655449867249,
-0.3737754225730896,
-0.47863754630088806,
-0.27822598814964294,
0.09852603822946548,
0.39555057883262634,
0.508060872554779,
0.7329502701759338,
0.3348962962627411,
0.4477452337741852,
0.43261101841926575,
0.03296278417110443,
-0.3588985800743103,
0.20031490921974182,
-0.6585296392440796,
0.16750489175319672,
-0.1473676711320877,
-0.3154548108577728,
0.7355411052703857,
0.7419912219047546,
-0.2841780483722687,
-0.4005046784877777,
0.32978492975234985,
0.46250486373901367,
-0.7041090130805969,
-0.3603965938091278,
-1.0800315141677856,
0.08543965220451355,
-0.562821626663208,
-0.007573702838271856,
-0.2989869713783264,
0.4199002981185913,
0.06850374490022659,
-0.7902616858482361,
0.5792385935783386,
0.2057216614484787,
0.764267086982727,
0.335884690284729,
-0.37731868028640747,
-0.1077151894569397,
-0.7790694236755371,
0.593261182308197,
-0.23728404939174652,
0.4408208131790161,
0.16645537316799164,
0.035039022564888,
-0.2888394594192505,
-0.9521978497505188,
-0.3987153470516205,
0.2499026507139206,
-0.14272138476371765,
0.05606717988848686,
-0.23378054797649384,
0.3184531331062317,
0.12398222833871841,
0.007929753512144089,
-0.6753287315368652,
0.28952521085739136,
-0.5296024680137634,
-0.2979331910610199,
0.46408775448799133,
0.10739170759916306,
0.19246983528137207,
-0.0577106773853302,
-0.5742689371109009,
0.3530791699886322,
-0.28013846278190613,
-0.111415334045887,
-0.2052733451128006,
0.19121120870113373,
0.1453154981136322,
0.0980028435587883,
-0.40200677514076233,
0.5594648122787476,
0.1692257523536682,
0.2232344001531601,
-0.1813419908285141,
-0.039746109396219254,
-0.3000691533088684,
0.2492559850215912,
0.8981795310974121,
0.23237793147563934,
0.12497072666883469,
-0.562483549118042,
-0.40984371304512024,
0.005327519495040178,
0.6902564167976379,
-1.2964924573898315,
-0.5439172983169556,
0.1593317836523056,
-0.21600794792175293,
0.11956524103879929,
0.11274576932191849,
-1.0435975790023804,
-0.4007473886013031,
-0.23002247512340546,
0.36232730746269226,
-0.2506446838378906,
0.037269920110702515,
0.0018655819585546851,
0.403236985206604,
-0.21369688212871552,
0.32396069169044495,
-0.969270646572113,
0.7868112325668335,
0.4444732666015625,
0.7719981670379639,
-0.642376720905304,
-0.2566142678260803,
-0.5506167411804199,
0.30623558163642883,
-0.33140936493873596,
1.1016818284988403,
-0.579131007194519,
-0.46345412731170654,
0.024418773129582405,
-0.09163475781679153,
0.015369639731943607,
-0.7118841409683228,
0.5365005135536194,
-0.6900290250778198,
-0.41848281025886536,
0.1046028807759285,
-0.6323837637901306,
-0.01920599862933159,
-0.11644215136766434,
-0.6892369389533997,
0.39538225531578064,
-0.018411580473184586,
-0.23362626135349274,
0.709585428237915,
-0.2920079231262207,
-0.48122867941856384,
0.39867687225341797,
-0.4557522237300873,
-0.4295547902584076,
0.012250054627656937,
0.09443361312150955,
0.5326392650604248,
-0.4121217727661133,
0.614090085029602,
-0.2580203413963318,
-0.5885667204856873,
0.18824352324008942,
-0.10795613378286362,
0.37343114614486694,
0.28219926357269287,
-0.5081980228424072,
0.14288246631622314,
-0.856427788734436,
0.04785593971610069,
0.02240641973912716,
-0.050049323588609695,
-0.26056158542633057,
-0.21227934956550598,
0.018026288598775864,
0.1251971423625946,
-0.004382762126624584,
-0.7357180714607239,
-0.03532130643725395,
0.24936750531196594,
0.23891206085681915,
0.8913353085517883,
-0.27751001715660095,
0.5776681900024414,
-0.02072981372475624,
0.13825783133506775,
0.24247248470783234,
-0.24525359272956848,
0.05078151822090149,
-0.020222431048750877,
-0.6403911709785461,
-0.8110314011573792,
0.7277830243110657,
0.2504960894584656,
-0.2902020812034607,
0.29189440608024597,
-0.06131448596715927,
-0.2406630665063858,
-0.529875636100769,
0.6549521088600159,
0.5126253366470337,
0.43529072403907776,
0.733928382396698,
-0.9809603691101074,
-0.7124562859535217,
-0.7257760763168335,
-0.2903827428817749,
0.4412834048271179,
-0.07174017280340195,
0.24008001387119293,
0.6317349672317505,
-0.23562906682491302,
0.6814919710159302,
-0.3830977976322174,
-0.8892855048179626,
0.06686969846487045,
0.04928863048553467,
0.15047317743301392,
0.9547197222709656,
0.06705643236637115,
-0.7966756820678711,
-0.67350834608078,
-0.2120119035243988,
-0.8635109663009644,
0.02210940234363079,
-0.28472697734832764,
-0.36579829454421997,
0.1177658811211586,
0.6033400297164917,
-0.6873584389686584,
0.7204971313476562,
0.2592054605484009,
-0.43284210562705994,
0.5231451988220215,
-0.2626921832561493,
-0.0026949571911245584,
-0.6583207845687866,
-0.1290486752986908,
-0.23888374865055084,
-0.3065876364707947,
-0.677180826663971,
-0.029105952009558678,
-0.05936558172106743,
-0.3538752496242523,
-0.14238174259662628,
0.54550701379776,
-0.6589936017990112,
-0.20385345816612244,
-0.26619237661361694,
0.34030765295028687,
0.1648993045091629,
0.3807637393474579,
0.23630781471729279,
0.5765077471733093,
0.6856918931007385,
-0.8520264029502869,
0.25455722212791443,
0.2897832691669464,
-0.5962520241737366,
0.8453152179718018,
-0.7926555275917053,
0.06264853477478027,
-0.0668613389134407,
0.2251935601234436,
-0.7638956904411316,
-0.07824394106864929,
0.02757631614804268,
-0.03690148890018463,
0.8422805666923523,
-0.40926945209503174,
-0.024367332458496094,
-0.3986005485057831,
0.04223031550645828,
0.5001032948493958,
0.19569887220859528,
-0.7873367071151733,
0.8678762316703796,
0.436185747385025,
0.07923360168933868,
-0.7167767286300659,
-0.780656099319458,
-0.06723856925964355,
0.023302294313907623,
-0.31916531920433044,
0.9610633254051208,
-0.3916543126106262,
-0.0993947833776474,
0.2688743472099304,
-0.7603699564933777,
-0.7363188862800598,
0.2377522885799408,
0.5034347176551819,
0.22263160347938538,
-0.04399729147553444,
0.02949785627424717,
-0.028507359325885773,
-0.16452404856681824,
0.08695881813764572,
-0.5138734579086304,
0.3995444178581238,
0.11327118426561356,
-0.36805829405784607,
-0.40223875641822815,
0.44342857599258423,
0.06866415590047836,
-0.33817070722579956,
0.7222650051116943,
0.41650620102882385,
-0.5563384294509888,
-0.3482029438018799,
-0.8324775099754333,
-0.05839219316840172,
-0.5008020401000977,
0.4386885464191437,
-0.7184707522392273,
-1.102469563484192,
0.45343539118766785,
-0.08638861030340195,
-0.11994705349206924,
0.029459213837981224,
0.29063838720321655,
-0.065477654337883,
0.40388137102127075,
0.43061646819114685,
0.06441698223352432,
0.29155296087265015,
-0.21665175259113312,
0.18335175514221191,
-0.9267106652259827,
-0.3271258473396301,
-0.36251920461654663,
-0.3967612385749817,
-0.5337156057357788,
-0.35261595249176025,
-0.28411126136779785,
0.5955992341041565,
-0.3231823444366455,
0.4960624575614929,
-0.8891602158546448,
0.8522366285324097,
0.3122794032096863,
-0.1013982966542244,
0.3395325839519501,
0.06612542271614075,
-0.3985176086425781,
-0.1979283094406128,
-0.4170388877391815,
-0.0823260173201561,
1.1983027458190918,
-0.4030068814754486,
0.6987912058830261,
0.0309873316437006,
0.91999751329422,
0.6065851449966431,
0.4008318781852722,
-0.11789277195930481,
0.5348648428916931,
-0.28429704904556274,
-0.7599032521247864,
-0.41701292991638184,
-0.5510424971580505,
-1.311903476715088,
0.8290995359420776,
-0.28392189741134644,
-1.1861299276351929,
0.26979729533195496,
0.17811624705791473,
-0.4305388927459717,
0.7527999877929688,
-0.45901361107826233,
1.302109718322754,
-0.11199577152729034,
-0.7015385031700134,
-0.12876808643341064,
-0.30455833673477173,
0.28781983256340027,
-0.4006819427013397,
0.08009961247444153,
-0.35516712069511414,
0.08150394260883331,
0.6492249965667725,
-0.19264325499534607,
0.5648516416549683,
-0.08155082911252975,
0.3261955678462982,
0.523434579372406,
0.5495384335517883,
0.25678128004074097,
0.4993627071380615,
0.24523688852787018,
0.2852085530757904,
-0.3174302279949188,
-0.7791579961776733,
-0.3462387025356293,
1.036591649055481,
-0.7150490880012512,
-0.7389155626296997,
-0.505213737487793,
-0.5036741495132446,
0.1028687059879303,
0.6160624623298645,
0.21102242171764374,
0.613883912563324,
-0.48866403102874756,
0.3334603011608124,
0.814785897731781,
0.39862799644470215,
0.751602053642273,
1.0031038522720337,
-0.15406176447868347,
-0.34931185841560364,
0.8762355446815491,
0.27552467584609985,
-0.29840967059135437,
0.6458047032356262,
-0.2449195235967636,
-0.24383997917175293,
-0.7323827743530273,
-0.460208535194397,
0.007902996614575386,
-0.43316158652305603,
-0.571041464805603,
-0.8612291216850281,
-0.3367515504360199,
-0.1680721938610077,
-0.5100691318511963,
-0.5924341678619385,
-0.14103959500789642,
-0.23836836218833923,
0.056251734495162964,
-0.01653422601521015,
0.6412526369094849,
-0.31514760851860046,
0.1492706686258316,
-0.44511619210243225,
0.5971153378486633,
0.7409162521362305,
0.7533299326896667,
-0.06062439829111099,
-0.7064533829689026,
-0.08688923716545105,
-0.416777104139328,
-0.381915807723999,
-0.4994472563266754,
0.23567397892475128,
0.205433651804924,
0.3794058561325073,
0.3840138018131256,
0.37816253304481506,
0.686402440071106,
-0.5861819386482239,
0.19690506160259247,
0.2698352336883545,
-1.0578457117080688,
0.2839452624320984,
0.037503037601709366,
0.1961744725704193,
0.7812818884849548,
0.5643113255500793,
-0.09689115732908249,
-0.038032762706279755,
-0.5026750564575195,
-0.9174256920814514,
0.3367033004760742,
0.04684177041053772,
-0.05423593148589134,
-0.0047337026335299015,
0.3470143675804138,
-0.011405621655285358,
0.3616514801979065,
-0.7070012092590332,
-0.06578680872917175,
-0.4535788893699646,
0.19232279062271118,
0.08169142156839371,
-0.38701945543289185,
0.014840621501207352,
0.022811824455857277,
0.5111383199691772,
-0.1604165881872177,
0.12661483883857727,
0.4203142523765564,
-0.7084137797355652,
-0.09349426627159119,
0.617831289768219,
0.23379279673099518,
0.8030821681022644,
-0.26597630977630615,
0.32693716883659363,
0.32058557868003845,
-0.36940696835517883,
0.1887078732252121,
0.579634428024292,
-0.5727608799934387,
-0.06446980684995651,
-0.017131507396697998,
0.5727208852767944,
0.3776271343231201,
-0.6549118757247925,
0.4322565793991089,
-0.027364429086446762,
-0.1194290742278099,
-0.3960869014263153,
-0.1728488653898239,
-0.326973021030426,
0.13838718831539154,
0.08799400180578232,
0.1491314172744751,
0.3480202555656433,
-0.19895349442958832,
0.47431978583335876,
0.37915918231010437,
-0.788206934928894,
-0.18610450625419617,
0.8759689331054688,
0.2807217240333557,
-0.072820745408535,
0.669370710849762,
-0.4113728404045105,
-0.3533966541290283,
0.14787091314792633,
0.8924784660339355,
0.7230104207992554,
-0.4636373519897461,
0.09162658452987671,
0.18979886174201965,
0.1455824226140976,
0.1494554728269577,
0.05768625810742378,
-0.32881852984428406,
-0.9293342232704163,
-0.4292091429233551,
-0.6174542307853699,
-0.1869073212146759,
0.1089072898030281,
-0.7498828768730164,
-0.31885144114494324,
-0.9016852974891663,
0.03373770788311958,
-0.0712970644235611,
0.13195855915546417,
-0.8658287525177002,
0.36607617139816284,
0.02573692984879017,
0.6143872141838074,
-0.017292451113462448,
0.8710450530052185,
0.5777261257171631,
-0.39010876417160034,
-0.2953537404537201,
-0.45188653469085693,
-0.048884958028793335,
-0.6097744703292847,
0.4578609764575958,
0.374429851770401,
-0.04980858415365219,
-0.1682209074497223,
-0.28342053294181824,
-0.7170093059539795,
0.9804562330245972,
0.10278340429067612,
-0.9053667783737183,
0.15218497812747955,
0.10305684059858322,
0.20596417784690857,
-0.49255043268203735,
0.2771865725517273,
0.7682900428771973,
0.15776361525058746,
-0.3456045091152191,
-0.4694138467311859,
0.48500433564186096,
-0.11695171892642975,
0.04344590753316879,
0.43615007400512695,
-0.7313995361328125,
0.5910962820053101,
-0.19925177097320557,
-0.07213470339775085,
0.1859782487154007,
1.1159225702285767,
-0.030729444697499275,
-0.055295150727033615,
0.5236921310424805,
0.9972091317176819,
0.7569340467453003,
-0.09063781052827835,
0.6837846040725708,
-0.3886245787143707,
-0.016950899735093117,
1.614591360092163,
-0.6785313487052917,
0.5724424123764038,
0.059143394231796265,
0.1813383549451828,
0.7094125151634216,
-0.11339474469423294,
-0.26466429233551025,
0.37314197421073914,
0.6140902638435364,
-0.46554553508758545,
-0.5974681377410889,
-0.6366694569587708,
-0.22445762157440186,
0.34953320026397705,
0.2732715308666229,
-0.01585831306874752,
0.03956145793199539,
-0.301526814699173,
0.2173156589269638,
0.3581770956516266,
-0.5897117257118225,
0.5100407600402832,
0.19308315217494965,
-0.5151986479759216,
0.4611690640449524,
-0.2682897448539734,
0.6200751066207886,
-0.5742983222007751,
0.06220407038927078,
-0.23778729140758514,
0.4184585213661194,
-0.2756175696849823,
-0.7463484406471252,
0.1162307932972908,
0.17773036658763885,
-0.11466863751411438,
-0.15871721506118774,
1.0137250423431396,
-0.5316603779792786,
0.1334685981273651,
0.8403456807136536,
0.27949926257133484,
0.024976443499326706,
-0.26853910088539124,
-0.5944684743881226,
0.025236966088414192,
-0.21120493113994598,
-0.07868896424770355,
0.7639563679695129,
0.6622422337532043,
0.13784544169902802,
0.6969403624534607,
0.6724189519882202,
-0.14448267221450806,
0.14472948014736176,
0.06499119102954865,
1.0024348497390747,
-0.8764083981513977,
-0.37699761986732483,
-0.5641119480133057,
0.4947793185710907,
-0.2968805134296417,
-0.3406298756599426,
0.3710041344165802,
0.6470857858657837,
1.165193796157837,
0.18932825326919556,
0.318033367395401,
0.06466879695653915,
0.234134703874588,
-0.48882630467414856,
0.5912227630615234,
-0.37149327993392944,
0.24003499746322632,
-0.2708738446235657,
-0.9922409057617188,
-0.20532581210136414,
0.5234538912773132,
0.15738752484321594,
-0.11497151851654053,
0.833950400352478,
0.507889449596405,
-0.12455707043409348,
-0.1343166083097458,
0.6749844551086426,
0.3524805009365082,
-0.007094213273376226,
0.5135482549667358,
0.42996737360954285,
-0.3792647421360016,
1.0899146795272827,
-0.5524724125862122,
-0.05199570581316948,
0.05515684932470322,
-0.6758671402931213,
-1.1597537994384766,
-0.24576769769191742,
-0.2726147174835205,
-0.5017239451408386,
0.31662845611572266,
0.8539913296699524,
0.9384773969650269,
-1.2399017810821533,
-0.33960896730422974,
-0.004707180429250002,
0.23893073201179504,
-0.001497200457379222,
-0.16219042241573334,
0.2887677848339081,
-0.2434248924255371,
-0.33905336260795593,
0.4607260823249817,
0.3377676010131836,
0.09267362952232361,
0.21079356968402863,
0.09890776872634888,
-0.0000314304961648304,
-0.01637382060289383,
0.17359842360019684,
0.6133031845092773,
-0.5290372967720032,
-0.0895572230219841,
-0.501775860786438,
0.03564569726586342,
0.11464698612689972,
1.1007832288742065,
-0.813748836517334,
0.6451386213302612,
0.004854617174714804,
1.0286831855773926,
0.9031758308410645,
-0.10008006542921066,
0.2897304594516754,
-0.6005787253379822,
0.3036527633666992,
0.13460026681423187,
0.8892009854316711,
0.2929013967514038,
-0.14681828022003174,
0.5865915417671204,
0.29234471917152405,
-0.7107241749763489,
-0.5163240432739258,
0.35720062255859375,
-0.8263272643089294,
-0.2294459044933319,
0.30990496277809143,
-0.2785775065422058,
-0.06559928506612778,
-0.4495985209941864,
0.1208248883485794,
0.04025646671652794,
-0.9043644666671753,
0.7151308655738831,
0.28717944025993347,
0.16335900127887726,
-0.14417114853858948,
-0.2509082555770874,
0.35767892003059387,
0.5959577560424805,
-0.6629353165626526,
-0.06511025875806808,
0.18660295009613037,
0.2547962963581085,
0.2705095112323761,
0.8485583662986755,
-0.017462298274040222,
0.27656370401382446,
-0.04596453905105591,
0.4737968444824219,
-0.00626551266759634,
-0.7581005692481995,
-0.09288295358419418,
0.16665111482143402,
-0.1680297553539276,
0.19345059990882874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14827v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14827v1
|
Sentence-Level or Token-Level? A Comprehensive Study on Knowledge Distillation
| 2024-04-23T08:29:56 | 2024-04-23T08:29:56 |
Jingxuan Wei, Linzhuang Sun, Yichong Leng, Xu Tan, Bihui Yu, Ruifeng Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge distillation, transferring knowledge from a teacher model to a
student model, has emerged as a powerful technique in neural machine
translation for compressing models or simplifying training targets. Knowledge
distillation encompasses two primary methods: sentence-level distillation and
token-level distillation. In sentence-level distillation, the student model is
trained to align with the output of the teacher model, which can alleviate the
training difficulty and give student model a comprehensive understanding of
global structure. Differently, token-level distillation requires the student
model to learn the output distribution of the teacher model, facilitating a
more fine-grained transfer of knowledge. Studies have revealed divergent
performances between sentence-level and token-level distillation across
different scenarios, leading to the confusion on the empirical selection of
knowledge distillation methods. In this study, we argue that token-level
distillation, with its more complex objective (i.e., distribution), is better
suited for ``simple'' scenarios, while sentence-level distillation excels in
``complex'' scenarios. To substantiate our hypothesis, we systematically
analyze the performance of distillation methods by varying the model size of
student models, the complexity of text, and the difficulty of decoding
procedure. While our experimental results validate our hypothesis, defining the
complexity level of a given scenario remains a challenging task. So we further
introduce a novel hybrid method that combines token-level and sentence-level
distillation through a gating mechanism, aiming to leverage the advantages of
both individual methods. Experiments demonstrate that the hybrid method
surpasses the performance of token-level or sentence-level distillation methods
and the previous works by a margin, demonstrating the effectiveness of the
proposed hybrid method.
|
[
-0.11040758341550827,
-0.8703193068504333,
0.7180789113044739,
0.059526219964027405,
-0.4819461405277252,
0.5324357748031616,
-0.15018203854560852,
-0.19497685134410858,
-0.19334985315799713,
-0.0863422080874443,
-0.13174034655094147,
-0.43196961283683777,
-0.8079630136489868,
0.18885456025600433,
-0.6905181407928467,
1.3429632186889648,
-0.03872217237949371,
0.23853620886802673,
-0.3631102740764618,
0.2785693109035492,
-0.5735373497009277,
-0.7896013259887695,
-0.7501305341720581,
-0.6797273755073547,
0.325252503156662,
0.09421862661838531,
0.1655704230070114,
0.443603515625,
0.4624127149581909,
0.3138737678527832,
-0.5235322713851929,
0.09095834940671921,
-0.3908112943172455,
0.11344499886035919,
-0.11645413935184479,
-0.9717031717300415,
-0.1273479163646698,
0.16712595522403717,
-0.010540739633142948,
0.7231046557426453,
-0.18780915439128876,
0.21010765433311462,
0.24050381779670715,
0.6715582609176636,
-0.6012077927589417,
0.14697150886058807,
-0.7708739638328552,
0.18998447060585022,
-0.08969611674547195,
-0.10361679643392563,
-0.33682096004486084,
-0.15182384848594666,
0.34517836570739746,
-0.45233938097953796,
0.3475627899169922,
0.22631514072418213,
0.5639071464538574,
0.18913885951042175,
-0.6601962447166443,
-0.30744126439094543,
-0.895271360874176,
0.5024502873420715,
-0.7921457886695862,
-0.3012610971927643,
0.17701613903045654,
0.5155766606330872,
0.16201159358024597,
-0.9701962471008301,
-0.9398413300514221,
-0.18551583588123322,
-0.276518315076828,
0.033573489636182785,
-0.233714759349823,
0.31472617387771606,
0.4169815182685852,
0.7989155054092407,
-0.23155492544174194,
-0.13767822086811066,
-0.6339056491851807,
-0.06975039094686508,
0.12269650399684906,
0.1848287284374237,
0.30708351731300354,
-0.48964354395866394,
-0.7433669567108154,
-0.1395559012889862,
-0.1911260187625885,
0.09458495676517487,
0.3773348331451416,
0.2552624046802521,
0.100809246301651,
0.5982623100280762,
-0.28938525915145874,
0.5106999278068542,
0.2388727068901062,
-0.44800835847854614,
0.24709703028202057,
-0.7106651067733765,
-0.14538022875785828,
0.19279815256595612,
0.7293531894683838,
0.25253355503082275,
0.17735624313354492,
-0.20012299716472626,
-0.29346880316734314,
-0.015262643806636333,
0.01814422756433487,
-0.8041694760322571,
-0.29290851950645447,
0.0012155253207311034,
-0.5195043087005615,
-0.5652534365653992,
0.1344112902879715,
-0.7191147804260254,
-0.2948412299156189,
-0.2796803116798401,
0.6554384231567383,
-0.4252462387084961,
-0.3384668231010437,
0.2832139730453491,
-0.7104462385177612,
-0.2755388617515564,
0.016369694843888283,
-1.1870067119598389,
0.4146145284175873,
0.7260451316833496,
1.201522946357727,
-0.2596200406551361,
-0.21268203854560852,
-0.33225470781326294,
0.1471528857946396,
-0.08819529414176941,
0.3588835299015045,
-0.3032246530056,
-0.2817874550819397,
-0.2703644633293152,
-0.5395018458366394,
-0.12744319438934326,
-0.6986773610115051,
0.47449785470962524,
-0.1888962835073471,
0.2643209993839264,
-0.3000197112560272,
-0.5628747344017029,
-0.3300105929374695,
0.0251800324767828,
-0.3908673822879791,
1.0426162481307983,
0.0037304293364286423,
-0.8830216526985168,
0.7336382865905762,
-0.6076976656913757,
-0.7757579684257507,
-0.10321162641048431,
0.05231446772813797,
-0.07722068578004837,
0.4697916805744171,
0.33808115124702454,
0.4223444163799286,
-0.14850889146327972,
0.4276367425918579,
-0.04731690138578415,
-0.3180992305278778,
0.0886976420879364,
-0.7084962725639343,
0.7051528096199036,
0.401780366897583,
-0.49412021040916443,
-0.1283472627401352,
-0.8005257844924927,
-0.3919914960861206,
-0.057380177080631256,
-0.3786104917526245,
-0.6883940100669861,
-0.1417597532272339,
-0.172467440366745,
0.2702111005783081,
0.3891654312610626,
-0.6039935946464539,
0.44619691371917725,
-0.2686012387275696,
1.0920968055725098,
0.4863201677799225,
0.23900897800922394,
0.741378128528595,
-0.18303580582141876,
0.29243528842926025,
0.5427737236022949,
0.05586793273687363,
-0.0286600049585104,
-0.3304024338722229,
-0.8765979409217834,
-0.25041982531547546,
0.3153700828552246,
0.5789504051208496,
-0.8750825524330139,
0.32719188928604126,
-0.1358494758605957,
-0.4364847242832184,
-0.5943737626075745,
-0.05832936614751816,
0.28940507769584656,
0.8983370065689087,
0.544898509979248,
0.3129435181617737,
-0.35944315791130066,
-0.7656211853027344,
-0.25592368841171265,
-0.41470932960510254,
0.19401319324970245,
-0.1873439997434616,
0.5980172157287598,
0.31129059195518494,
0.7787492871284485,
-0.6018463969230652,
-0.29732218384742737,
-0.5714917182922363,
0.5703094005584717,
0.2498532086610794,
0.47147613763809204,
0.682053804397583,
-0.8014484643936157,
-0.5207605361938477,
0.18811887502670288,
-0.6944115161895752,
0.046266041696071625,
-0.3431076407432556,
-0.1823388934135437,
0.03411830961704254,
0.42208150029182434,
-0.5477775931358337,
0.4594331383705139,
0.288167268037796,
-0.2815079391002655,
0.27270570397377014,
-0.40285950899124146,
0.36492273211479187,
-1.372576117515564,
0.011168337427079678,
-0.10750068724155426,
-0.27647802233695984,
-0.733615517616272,
-0.07644058018922806,
0.016304869204759598,
0.10227286070585251,
-0.30866771936416626,
-0.0012806529412046075,
-0.5143117308616638,
0.23200485110282898,
-0.2891772985458374,
0.021033411845564842,
0.2899009585380554,
0.44816669821739197,
-0.2502084970474243,
0.7504911422729492,
0.3844619393348694,
-0.34769660234451294,
0.6594474911689758,
0.16771897673606873,
-0.5232265591621399,
0.4867337644100189,
-0.7010099291801453,
0.06919515132904053,
-0.04641302302479744,
0.20598958432674408,
-1.2403894662857056,
0.17778050899505615,
0.047560613602399826,
-0.3691142499446869,
0.17728780210018158,
-0.08624887466430664,
-0.625914454460144,
-0.478528767824173,
0.09815715998411179,
0.3446083664894104,
0.6898529529571533,
-0.41323092579841614,
0.5878196358680725,
-0.17208029329776764,
-0.013588398694992065,
-0.46383604407310486,
-1.1021831035614014,
0.2597557306289673,
-0.6811954975128174,
-0.6117866039276123,
0.27061012387275696,
0.28480467200279236,
-0.27635741233825684,
0.009142201393842697,
-0.5555901527404785,
-0.04446885362267494,
0.1252102106809616,
0.024139534682035446,
0.2915050983428955,
-0.020908325910568237,
-0.038513414561748505,
0.42305782437324524,
-0.15656232833862305,
0.07797513157129288,
-0.5513503551483154,
0.5444991588592529,
0.15847259759902954,
-0.06818130612373352,
-0.6399514079093933,
0.3876265585422516,
0.5487985014915466,
-0.04236434027552605,
1.0402235984802246,
0.43256646394729614,
-0.17921459674835205,
-0.24036678671836853,
-0.47053560614585876,
-0.20474807918071747,
-0.4492431581020355,
0.33109360933303833,
-0.7791941165924072,
-0.6247290968894958,
0.6119177341461182,
-0.033399324864149094,
-0.10023128241300583,
0.3457709550857544,
0.33569666743278503,
-0.1256207823753357,
0.8454341292381287,
0.49923986196517944,
-0.22219133377075195,
0.3962515890598297,
-0.3651399314403534,
0.5613665580749512,
-0.5569135546684265,
-0.512443482875824,
-0.6226035952568054,
-0.814824104309082,
-0.08653915673494339,
-0.12393912672996521,
0.4465889632701874,
0.36295437812805176,
0.11744589358568192,
0.40439313650131226,
-0.43914562463760376,
0.4310424029827118,
0.9306598901748657,
0.09128886461257935,
0.8060096502304077,
0.19374969601631165,
-0.3906381130218506,
0.0509943924844265,
-0.7276846766471863,
-0.3426157236099243,
1.0374798774719238,
0.10710220783948898,
0.47559553384780884,
-0.11885841935873032,
1.0686180591583252,
0.11930125206708908,
-0.3660484552383423,
-0.7577882409095764,
0.4252779185771942,
-0.23893460631370544,
-0.6741353869438171,
-0.24134346842765808,
-0.6565402746200562,
-0.5507307648658752,
0.4775315523147583,
-0.2530654966831207,
-0.5330322980880737,
0.08418790251016617,
0.017527533695101738,
-0.3825013339519501,
0.5717478394508362,
-1.0721542835235596,
0.8346927762031555,
-0.12788650393486023,
0.20697709918022156,
-0.1711287647485733,
-0.6786606907844543,
0.3249695301055908,
-0.056151531636714935,
0.16074134409427643,
0.218605175614357,
0.06692328304052353,
0.5280728936195374,
-0.7334462404251099,
0.5896053910255432,
-0.36573415994644165,
-0.0011353966547176242,
0.2649330496788025,
0.1721237301826477,
0.4510531723499298,
-0.05094490200281143,
0.05650997534394264,
-0.037530168890953064,
0.22464844584465027,
-0.2949278950691223,
-0.9176681041717529,
0.37818869948387146,
-0.8633793592453003,
-0.877048671245575,
-0.4396035671234131,
-0.5599942207336426,
-0.029100608080625534,
0.1805870532989502,
0.6018064022064209,
0.21885967254638672,
0.12878911197185516,
0.2945028841495514,
0.5044997930526733,
0.093880794942379,
0.5122751593589783,
0.01085753832012415,
-0.16157513856887817,
-0.20401528477668762,
0.8479601740837097,
0.2755758762359619,
0.772922694683075,
0.6124143004417419,
0.31223776936531067,
-0.23774947226047516,
-1.0801572799682617,
-0.31246986985206604,
-0.25851869583129883,
-0.6400818228721619,
-0.039241425693035126,
-0.743375837802887,
-0.2011103332042694,
-0.4524761736392975,
0.00997756328433752,
-0.11254363507032394,
-0.709010124206543,
-0.42239806056022644,
-0.5810575485229492,
0.3069498538970947,
0.5635031461715698,
-0.05337924882769585,
0.1384950876235962,
-0.6171685457229614,
0.501244068145752,
0.309671014547348,
-0.33391064405441284,
0.1060180738568306,
-0.5603692531585693,
-0.02191663347184658,
0.29551148414611816,
-0.10062141716480255,
-0.8568610548973083,
0.15660113096237183,
0.23153023421764374,
0.4025056064128876,
0.3555130362510681,
0.2746172249317169,
0.982623279094696,
-0.40359461307525635,
0.9116008281707764,
0.4934612512588501,
-1.031276822090149,
0.5530437231063843,
-0.14757025241851807,
0.06780139356851578,
0.8985065221786499,
0.2607344388961792,
-0.6080670356750488,
-0.5248425006866455,
-0.2632511258125305,
-1.133968472480774,
0.4937514364719391,
0.2952018976211548,
0.38654348254203796,
0.10242597758769989,
0.4028657078742981,
0.44431114196777344,
0.39608386158943176,
-0.7146914601325989,
-0.38901060819625854,
-0.1129366010427475,
-0.3117637634277344,
-0.015183588489890099,
-0.03036419115960598,
-0.09591622650623322,
-0.45503371953964233,
0.3448600471019745,
0.2518404722213745,
-0.25830280780792236,
0.17143411934375763,
-0.18155184388160706,
0.3515772819519043,
0.21651770174503326,
0.18585951626300812,
0.39171963930130005,
-0.02220836840569973,
0.401264488697052,
0.12044906616210938,
-0.6734171509742737,
0.5188432335853577,
-0.1021718829870224,
-0.44094324111938477,
-0.013072692789137363,
0.3363524377346039,
1.1025112867355347,
-0.03443479910492897,
-0.14065209031105042,
0.5627175569534302,
0.05184873938560486,
-0.5968220829963684,
0.1570325344800949,
0.3535415828227997,
0.23622119426727295,
0.40539851784706116,
0.6626906394958496,
0.28929534554481506,
0.42207181453704834,
-0.7293903231620789,
-0.10393783450126648,
0.009062509983778,
0.06557396799325943,
-0.015734855085611343,
0.8168256878852844,
0.2776946425437927,
-0.10411880910396576,
0.6704339385032654,
-0.12063384056091309,
-0.29463011026382446,
0.5486472845077515,
0.5331671237945557,
0.8308260440826416,
0.374286025762558,
0.46587297320365906,
0.36706116795539856,
0.1294708400964737,
-0.3670181334018707,
0.0547097884118557,
-0.2886148691177368,
-0.30683085322380066,
-0.27265629172325134,
-0.8172086477279663,
0.11901740729808807,
-0.09048540145158768,
-0.8883577585220337,
-0.053905095905065536,
-0.21192575991153717,
-0.2554926574230194,
0.17247125506401062,
-0.12408033758401871,
-0.3538118004798889,
-0.16473768651485443,
-0.06398512423038483,
0.9210291504859924,
-0.8462076187133789,
0.7023423910140991,
0.5239357948303223,
-0.6712794899940491,
-0.951550304889679,
0.13585074245929718,
-0.08022657781839371,
-0.47571760416030884,
0.8517080545425415,
-0.04867851361632347,
0.14805126190185547,
0.07745128870010376,
-0.23757389187812805,
-0.4693469703197479,
1.4001177549362183,
0.34231480956077576,
-0.7549630403518677,
-0.6148850321769714,
0.4726262092590332,
0.6279889345169067,
-0.32066160440444946,
-0.12600551545619965,
0.6921766996383667,
0.27565717697143555,
0.49926814436912537,
-1.110390067100525,
0.08716225624084473,
-0.15349231660366058,
0.382326602935791,
0.053067028522491455,
-0.46391168236732483,
0.8971765041351318,
-0.10535942018032074,
-0.3238249719142914,
0.0980602353811264,
0.7337259650230408,
0.015467870980501175,
0.3944344222545624,
0.4775986075401306,
0.6655105948448181,
0.7422783374786377,
-0.3281461298465729,
0.6210827231407166,
-0.0038271748926490545,
0.314303457736969,
0.9617750644683838,
-0.04946016147732735,
0.7510201930999756,
0.919292688369751,
-0.38882869482040405,
0.5382940769195557,
0.49912288784980774,
0.06608561426401138,
0.7851905822753906,
0.43492546677589417,
-0.4358210265636444,
-0.029515396803617477,
0.284360408782959,
-0.37760844826698303,
0.25323161482810974,
-0.04206598922610283,
-0.30985572934150696,
-0.22527976334095,
0.5281261801719666,
0.01895502582192421,
0.15581688284873962,
-0.32250484824180603,
1.055150032043457,
0.1945212334394455,
-0.816867470741272,
0.5526295304298401,
-0.11570926755666733,
0.8119920492172241,
-0.36658746004104614,
0.18903300166130066,
-0.31308379769325256,
0.08230806142091751,
-0.14536280930042267,
-0.491366446018219,
0.24960462749004364,
0.18962979316711426,
-0.25218093395233154,
-0.3487321138381958,
0.5409886837005615,
-0.5845029950141907,
-0.38688698410987854,
0.13141688704490662,
0.5921251177787781,
0.12614552676677704,
-0.1311386674642563,
-0.35066935420036316,
-0.31316208839416504,
0.003193889046087861,
-0.1522921770811081,
0.3156653642654419,
0.8985728025436401,
0.3318275809288025,
0.4220823645591736,
0.57857745885849,
0.2949543595314026,
0.405193954706192,
0.08079391717910767,
0.8217001557350159,
-0.39263278245925903,
-0.5781428813934326,
-1.168393611907959,
0.6303155422210693,
-0.19365422427654266,
-0.34978383779525757,
0.7732091546058655,
0.49415427446365356,
1.0121746063232422,
-0.06609958410263062,
0.9656696319580078,
-0.22654061019420624,
0.027033336460590363,
-0.5853754878044128,
0.655354917049408,
-0.4656580984592438,
0.1444815844297409,
-0.1959683895111084,
-0.9417652487754822,
0.12032855302095413,
0.5318342447280884,
-0.324808269739151,
-0.026465579867362976,
0.9850809574127197,
0.20952335000038147,
-0.01041895430535078,
0.019221335649490356,
0.2634654939174652,
0.08171194046735764,
0.27440860867500305,
0.6309922933578491,
0.9140374064445496,
-0.3063567578792572,
0.7326630353927612,
-0.3763323128223419,
-0.19061215221881866,
-0.005071782507002354,
-0.6697512865066528,
-1.101889729499817,
-0.700472354888916,
-0.18342091143131256,
-0.23275476694107056,
0.026643527671694756,
0.6138055324554443,
0.6305903792381287,
-0.5279918313026428,
-0.029854973778128624,
-0.5264145731925964,
-0.1057642474770546,
-0.41404932737350464,
-0.2304077297449112,
0.029832767322659492,
-0.5931796431541443,
-0.9947105646133423,
0.03435845300555229,
0.18955400586128235,
0.1978631317615509,
-0.2973291575908661,
0.36182448267936707,
-0.16143400967121124,
-0.09950892627239227,
0.42761844396591187,
-0.3042837083339691,
-0.641392707824707,
-0.08614716678857803,
0.09347566962242126,
-0.26531416177749634,
-0.01931411400437355,
1.0621565580368042,
-0.5176839232444763,
0.3868540823459625,
0.8805718421936035,
0.44863951206207275,
0.808125913143158,
-0.007174873724579811,
0.6724954843521118,
-0.7661142349243164,
0.2883829176425934,
0.10708048939704895,
0.35482317209243774,
-0.005852504633367062,
-0.4591237008571625,
0.22461265325546265,
0.41513633728027344,
-0.2957974374294281,
-0.8268334269523621,
0.06123913824558258,
-0.93462735414505,
-0.5952672362327576,
1.1820757389068604,
-0.3080103099346161,
-0.16282737255096436,
0.03137629106640816,
-0.525018572807312,
0.5840810537338257,
-0.3666894733905792,
0.9935413002967834,
1.1166044473648071,
0.1392672210931778,
0.19234496355056763,
-0.4677221477031708,
0.3674522936344147,
0.2116490751504898,
-0.5955590009689331,
-0.1142980083823204,
0.35261112451553345,
0.3535735309123993,
0.18889179825782776,
0.2657254636287689,
-0.017462199553847313,
-0.21278198063373566,
0.27029335498809814,
-0.29954448342323303,
-0.4531327784061432,
-0.36098620295524597,
-0.11277511715888977,
0.4886869192123413,
-0.2315894067287445,
-0.38264182209968567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14812v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14812v1
|
Pattern-Aware Chain-of-Thought Prompting in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-23T07:50:00 | 2024-04-23T07:50:00 |
Yufeng Zhang, Xuepeng Wang, Lingxiang Wu, Jinqiao Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting can guide language models to engage in
complex multi-step reasoning. The quality of provided demonstrations
significantly impacts the success of downstream inference tasks. While existing
automated methods prioritize accuracy and semantics in these demonstrations, we
show that the underlying reasoning patterns play a more crucial role in such
tasks. In this paper, we propose Pattern-Aware CoT, a prompting method that
considers the diversity of demonstration patterns. By incorporating patterns
such as step length and reasoning process within intermediate steps, PA-CoT
effectively mitigates the issue of bias induced by demonstrations and enables
better generalization to diverse scenarios. We conduct experiments on nine
reasoning benchmark tasks using two open-source LLMs. The results show that our
method substantially enhances reasoning performance and exhibits robustness to
errors. The code will be made publicly available.
|
[
-0.4364568889141083,
-0.9271340370178223,
0.9010801911354065,
0.6249250769615173,
-0.4490196406841278,
0.06346068531274796,
-0.17268343269824982,
-0.27946585416793823,
0.03612828627228737,
0.47387513518333435,
-0.5294500589370728,
-0.6560201644897461,
-0.39680367708206177,
0.0781782940030098,
-0.6518732905387878,
0.5340944528579712,
-0.335689902305603,
-0.009572389535605907,
-0.07600436359643936,
0.08613462746143341,
-0.48120617866516113,
-0.4062257409095764,
-0.775004506111145,
-0.26105016469955444,
0.6120889782905579,
0.2835848033428192,
0.3779335021972656,
0.5855389833450317,
-0.20136228203773499,
0.2538308799266815,
-0.2508445680141449,
0.6225860714912415,
-0.16462579369544983,
0.5038214325904846,
-0.43161740899086,
-0.6308777928352356,
-0.4764903485774994,
-0.13542518019676208,
0.5250653624534607,
0.485739529132843,
-0.0170829389244318,
0.06075691059231758,
0.13410134613513947,
0.6563690900802612,
-0.8611689805984497,
-0.0700770914554596,
-0.49998170137405396,
-0.05789211392402649,
0.0497441291809082,
-0.20054583251476288,
-0.8797442317008972,
-0.13489219546318054,
-0.11520373076200485,
-0.40672823786735535,
0.272174209356308,
0.11453358829021454,
0.2201283872127533,
0.06519465148448944,
-0.23376867175102234,
-0.25949740409851074,
-0.5437020659446716,
0.6786466836929321,
-0.5217965245246887,
0.4670134484767914,
0.32397398352622986,
0.12632234394550323,
-0.4554203152656555,
-0.6671103835105896,
-0.6785706877708435,
-0.04571069777011871,
-0.03814906254410744,
0.03207789734005928,
0.10785498470067978,
0.04407211020588875,
0.49803319573402405,
0.15468738973140717,
-0.3397345542907715,
-0.07300101220607758,
0.006499509327113628,
-0.1217530220746994,
0.47715845704078674,
0.047860730439424515,
0.03847980499267578,
0.13572381436824799,
-0.38664379715919495,
-0.22345112264156342,
-0.8223468661308289,
0.05312659591436386,
0.23032574355602264,
0.3241690695285797,
-0.29559504985809326,
0.2716725766658783,
-0.2651170790195465,
1.0131081342697144,
0.1817961186170578,
0.15241369605064392,
0.051539938896894455,
-0.30704957246780396,
-0.5214287042617798,
0.14804862439632416,
0.5599566102027893,
0.04742282256484032,
0.19179795682430267,
0.2525207996368408,
-0.2777809798717499,
0.04427674412727356,
0.10497535020112991,
-0.4125840961933136,
-0.0917409285902977,
0.536565899848938,
-0.4854572117328644,
-0.16635289788246155,
0.14237037301063538,
-0.9783140420913696,
-0.5432159304618835,
-0.3440413475036621,
0.2946707308292389,
-0.28683269023895264,
-0.27975910902023315,
0.2594514787197113,
-0.2859002649784088,
0.23610913753509521,
0.6386957764625549,
-0.625887930393219,
0.2921852469444275,
0.743323802947998,
0.762042224407196,
-0.02974105067551136,
-0.214379221200943,
-0.8727741837501526,
0.34387120604515076,
-0.6471031904220581,
0.8409461975097656,
-0.6520124673843384,
-0.3051884174346924,
-0.15023253858089447,
-0.13176307082176208,
-0.009017319418489933,
-0.406816303730011,
0.3574689030647278,
-0.4222475588321686,
0.06962886452674866,
-0.5408660769462585,
-0.4815603792667389,
0.007221996318548918,
0.31215643882751465,
-0.5540165305137634,
0.8852066993713379,
-0.19795560836791992,
-0.5356500148773193,
0.45644423365592957,
-0.6972892880439758,
-0.44055798649787903,
-0.11908616125583649,
-0.6113647222518921,
-0.176147922873497,
-0.11033745110034943,
0.6943415999412537,
0.4786493182182312,
-0.18436199426651,
0.13671955466270447,
-0.12623706459999084,
-0.3961922228336334,
0.19078828394412994,
-0.4387960433959961,
0.6075342297554016,
0.28310343623161316,
-0.7310271859169006,
0.3940471112728119,
-0.7221775054931641,
0.23036372661590576,
0.01632896065711975,
0.034137338399887085,
-0.342068612575531,
0.015466349199414253,
-0.513175904750824,
0.2783421277999878,
-0.23222562670707703,
-0.15904715657234192,
0.3381457030773163,
-0.14362676441669464,
0.21171835064888,
1.2140896320343018,
0.1764289140701294,
0.2540963888168335,
-0.4302464723587036,
0.685198187828064,
0.16649655997753143,
0.3575466275215149,
-0.36531978845596313,
-0.8607702851295471,
-0.840183436870575,
-0.607884407043457,
0.08765320479869843,
0.2718605697154999,
-0.5332105159759521,
0.35375839471817017,
0.3463558852672577,
-0.18215104937553406,
-0.2459622025489807,
0.12738841772079468,
0.5571436882019043,
0.30383002758026123,
0.4141871929168701,
-0.20220577716827393,
-0.6319528818130493,
-0.42621931433677673,
-0.36433467268943787,
0.029515165835618973,
0.053788118064403534,
0.13417555391788483,
0.19188638031482697,
-0.16671603918075562,
0.6454658508300781,
-0.21081945300102234,
0.2731512188911438,
-0.36757493019104004,
0.34476572275161743,
0.24657867848873138,
0.4274766743183136,
0.2672359049320221,
-0.6183308959007263,
-0.3015248775482178,
-0.15181414783000946,
-0.2932307720184326,
-0.226470947265625,
-0.3957667946815491,
-0.6442230343818665,
0.17276883125305176,
0.7043930292129517,
-0.42666974663734436,
0.47226282954216003,
0.5754287838935852,
-0.43261414766311646,
0.6000277400016785,
-0.15396127104759216,
0.2136118859052658,
-0.9685028195381165,
-0.269870787858963,
-0.3279518783092499,
-0.22909513115882874,
-0.46600180864334106,
0.0944075658917427,
0.04222166910767555,
0.3202594220638275,
-0.34459245204925537,
0.40084248781204224,
-0.585053026676178,
-0.18944989144802094,
-0.20923732221126556,
0.15039704740047455,
0.2575478255748749,
0.25352388620376587,
0.14754755795001984,
0.9051703810691833,
0.8218997716903687,
-1.1154762506484985,
0.017392242327332497,
0.08869753032922745,
-0.4527980089187622,
0.10820131748914719,
-0.34084001183509827,
0.4029279351234436,
-0.01802179403603077,
0.48154425621032715,
-0.8359963893890381,
-0.09012569487094879,
0.20850050449371338,
0.010525928810238838,
-0.08292799443006516,
-0.1552036553621292,
-0.46793386340141296,
-0.3276062309741974,
-0.20647932589054108,
0.4311824142932892,
0.5276845693588257,
-0.8243973851203918,
0.5990235209465027,
-0.2717512845993042,
0.2238250970840454,
-0.6819917559623718,
-0.46572527289390564,
-0.22707760334014893,
0.07451288402080536,
-0.2658896744251251,
0.09959809482097626,
-0.07066347450017929,
-0.35408133268356323,
-0.5408448576927185,
-0.403726190328598,
0.17528386414051056,
-0.09044530242681503,
0.18670830130577087,
0.07068946212530136,
-0.03492169454693794,
0.2978266477584839,
0.15232333540916443,
0.13633644580841064,
0.06987199187278748,
-0.6612861752510071,
0.9686121940612793,
-0.0296897292137146,
-0.7652238011360168,
-0.3122168183326721,
0.3559243083000183,
0.5951706171035767,
-0.3274967074394226,
0.3909679353237152,
0.171465665102005,
-0.13240665197372437,
-0.7981993556022644,
-0.5182886123657227,
-0.0906347781419754,
-0.5247545838356018,
-0.17801935970783234,
-0.4651170074939728,
-0.6364383101463318,
0.4569798409938812,
-0.38538265228271484,
-0.08354607224464417,
-0.05800539627671242,
0.6597942113876343,
0.03145737573504448,
1.2355345487594604,
0.43428662419319153,
0.24528954923152924,
0.5601842403411865,
-0.3541397452354431,
0.4598511755466461,
-0.8192286491394043,
-0.29499343037605286,
-0.3527465760707855,
-0.12178383022546768,
-0.38885316252708435,
-1.013730525970459,
0.20807389914989471,
0.26943546533584595,
-0.3560667037963867,
0.05157067999243736,
-0.611641526222229,
0.6199533343315125,
0.5363304018974304,
0.39825746417045593,
0.3361845314502716,
-0.05420731380581856,
-0.5342368483543396,
0.5817593336105347,
-0.6675599217414856,
-0.6645273566246033,
0.7336897850036621,
-0.042605623602867126,
0.8930944204330444,
0.021389106288552284,
0.7535378932952881,
0.3683464229106903,
0.04050632193684578,
-0.5743932127952576,
0.7894954085350037,
0.11899376660585403,
-0.2561383545398712,
-0.22447362542152405,
-0.16383132338523865,
-0.916540801525116,
0.04626438766717911,
0.09387338906526566,
-0.8304674029350281,
0.4837609529495239,
0.5886610746383667,
-0.3152611255645752,
0.3423365652561188,
-0.5427225232124329,
0.4351690411567688,
-0.21124213933944702,
-0.3312188684940338,
-0.4516758620738983,
-0.3873502016067505,
0.3035769462585449,
0.15611763298511505,
0.40353554487228394,
0.024730900302529335,
-0.039676107466220856,
0.4617938697338104,
-0.6257283687591553,
0.856209933757782,
-0.034595854580402374,
-0.4194619655609131,
0.6527220010757446,
0.33907997608184814,
0.8672133088111877,
-0.14269697666168213,
-0.17498497664928436,
-0.2857752740383148,
-0.45661184191703796,
-0.4451521039009094,
-0.7404815554618835,
0.5713331699371338,
-0.30540895462036133,
-0.9315630197525024,
-0.15963776409626007,
-0.5015247464179993,
-0.4954744279384613,
0.0751146674156189,
0.25553518533706665,
0.3932178318500519,
0.30657538771629333,
-0.30578064918518066,
0.7984030246734619,
-0.11874648928642273,
0.40503427386283875,
0.12046680599451065,
-0.48045921325683594,
-0.1602092981338501,
0.5795735120773315,
-0.30967918038368225,
0.7975744009017944,
0.33317309617996216,
0.43845492601394653,
-0.11274462938308716,
-0.4983188807964325,
-0.34132593870162964,
-0.12725701928138733,
-0.9813726544380188,
0.0863051638007164,
-0.7698991894721985,
0.06711141020059586,
-0.35277146100997925,
-0.4818173348903656,
-0.1547224074602127,
-0.4388502836227417,
0.2236214280128479,
-0.3712649643421173,
0.5946150422096252,
0.8992563486099243,
0.06300199776887894,
-0.02939753420650959,
-0.40687325596809387,
0.43376466631889343,
0.769079864025116,
0.617114245891571,
0.4419887661933899,
-0.05996440723538399,
0.1857277899980545,
0.025727655738592148,
-0.23038041591644287,
-0.6373948454856873,
-0.035798393189907074,
-0.15987321734428406,
0.701391875743866,
0.5737317204475403,
0.0998731479048729,
0.8759576678276062,
-0.3792664408683777,
0.9711753129959106,
0.29550567269325256,
-1.272081732749939,
1.168624758720398,
-0.18866844475269318,
0.2930319011211395,
0.08012458682060242,
0.31617236137390137,
-0.26825594902038574,
-0.825874924659729,
-0.5048197507858276,
-0.8045952916145325,
0.470659464597702,
0.11003589630126953,
-0.1617531031370163,
-0.4278634488582611,
-0.007326991762965918,
0.33250710368156433,
0.07270269840955734,
-0.36002597212791443,
-0.061768122017383575,
-0.3443686366081238,
0.0004675673262681812,
0.32965555787086487,
-0.031922537833452225,
-0.1621154546737671,
-0.22352144122123718,
0.6267996430397034,
-0.3397139310836792,
0.31836366653442383,
0.5867360830307007,
-0.08322692662477493,
-0.09265470504760742,
0.45312660932540894,
0.8290890455245972,
0.9278562664985657,
0.16674040257930756,
0.2372409552335739,
0.20912684500217438,
-0.351716011762619,
0.35279974341392517,
-0.423252671957016,
-0.07563068717718124,
0.06341928988695145,
0.3786849081516266,
0.6800842881202698,
-0.07967416197061539,
-0.698443591594696,
0.3996431827545166,
0.004303709138184786,
-0.1411806344985962,
0.006236654240638018,
0.45114007592201233,
-0.13384030759334564,
0.36449116468429565,
0.11141826957464218,
0.022495632991194725,
0.18593405187129974,
-0.6770243644714355,
0.17369718849658966,
0.14866980910301208,
-0.18240982294082642,
0.18524456024169922,
0.4342272877693176,
0.14593204855918884,
-0.38438817858695984,
0.4308359622955322,
-0.159518301486969,
-0.5218753218650818,
0.8284683227539062,
0.6323188543319702,
0.8524676561355591,
-0.14704512059688568,
0.14798970520496368,
0.2947843670845032,
0.011462327092885971,
-0.37193563580513,
0.6865223050117493,
-0.42035120725631714,
-0.6804212927818298,
-0.6908326148986816,
-0.30334770679473877,
-0.5821419358253479,
-0.0012236975599080324,
-0.6286314129829407,
0.5159822106361389,
-0.8217256665229797,
0.018745649605989456,
-0.14315013587474823,
-0.6524462699890137,
-0.41967952251434326,
0.18136002123355865,
0.3562023639678955,
1.2273880243301392,
-0.6078038215637207,
0.7372735738754272,
0.4779309332370758,
-0.2522694766521454,
-0.9585419297218323,
0.3533775508403778,
-0.11921215057373047,
-0.8265616297721863,
0.5170453786849976,
0.24661365151405334,
-0.6167699098587036,
-0.2098013162612915,
-0.6904668211936951,
-0.6228836178779602,
0.9929826259613037,
0.28342482447624207,
-0.8223294019699097,
0.265547513961792,
-0.2613566517829895,
0.3235794007778168,
-0.638822078704834,
0.24578480422496796,
0.33257582783699036,
0.41904065012931824,
0.10502073913812637,
-0.6536429524421692,
0.4236847758293152,
-0.0537356361746788,
0.08341199904680252,
0.27178820967674255,
-0.6739413738250732,
0.7462817430496216,
-0.3882994055747986,
-0.03880462422966957,
0.05794619023799896,
0.3480232357978821,
0.7590963840484619,
0.40522652864456177,
0.8703130483627319,
0.18887794017791748,
1.1308131217956543,
0.06918864697217941,
1.1268216371536255,
-0.2403274029493332,
-0.15059253573417664,
1.2778488397598267,
-0.3712862730026245,
0.673911988735199,
0.4402165114879608,
-0.11160778254270554,
1.2468957901000977,
0.4381261169910431,
0.21468164026737213,
0.5044481158256531,
0.4185250699520111,
-0.5236044526100159,
-0.5806384086608887,
0.04849812388420105,
-0.36169177293777466,
0.26270100474357605,
0.5431508421897888,
-0.6001086235046387,
0.11428477615118027,
-0.11180388182401657,
-0.24455180764198303,
0.22223174571990967,
-0.6352915167808533,
0.7452812194824219,
0.028822023421525955,
-0.8953155875205994,
0.6275097727775574,
-0.45807594060897827,
0.40138235688209534,
-0.5380869507789612,
-0.388240784406662,
-0.05840148776769638,
0.09191322326660156,
-0.08607733994722366,
-0.7728402614593506,
-0.03403914347290993,
0.03989173099398613,
-0.3007417917251587,
-0.5630199313163757,
0.43519601225852966,
-0.26646336913108826,
-0.3088376224040985,
0.5251348614692688,
0.48467540740966797,
0.15183548629283905,
0.050947558134794235,
-0.4130636155605316,
0.09046895802021027,
-0.1811397820711136,
-0.06287296116352081,
0.0911731943488121,
0.5894849896430969,
-0.6904520988464355,
0.7842968106269836,
0.7210584878921509,
-0.0226802509278059,
0.10533042252063751,
0.8264568448066711,
0.8962883949279785,
-0.6446542143821716,
-0.6183800101280212,
-0.9124014377593994,
0.48644566535949707,
-0.3865062892436981,
-0.0935591533780098,
0.5049228668212891,
0.277045339345932,
0.8548579812049866,
-0.13456135988235474,
0.8152382969856262,
0.028995191678404808,
0.28737518191337585,
-0.7818750143051147,
0.2923206388950348,
-0.09462612867355347,
0.38962024450302124,
-0.4114285707473755,
-0.634208619594574,
-0.06609956175088882,
0.5653582215309143,
-0.1405908614397049,
0.1016308143734932,
0.9908798933029175,
0.7831336259841919,
0.005542528349906206,
0.3752126693725586,
0.2450006753206253,
0.282711923122406,
0.3408932685852051,
0.3831377923488617,
1.0533967018127441,
-0.011010775342583656,
0.3795281648635864,
-0.19142141938209534,
-0.3115515410900116,
0.03660514950752258,
-1.2125399112701416,
-0.9243687391281128,
-0.30261677503585815,
-0.34510287642478943,
-0.3271680772304535,
0.2357914298772812,
1.2633962631225586,
0.7861736416816711,
-1.0163660049438477,
-0.21666358411312103,
-0.9032542109489441,
0.4504390358924866,
-0.8040642142295837,
-0.18925313651561737,
0.2684766352176666,
-0.6330784559249878,
-0.4158819913864136,
0.41180577874183655,
0.30711665749549866,
0.10480041801929474,
-0.10388742387294769,
-0.09920889139175415,
-0.42771464586257935,
0.29418137669563293,
0.7426968216896057,
-0.09904484450817108,
-0.9571400284767151,
-0.23775263130664825,
-0.16550126671791077,
0.3082035183906555,
0.0233876034617424,
1.315483808517456,
-0.9568877816200256,
0.6397854089736938,
0.5699955224990845,
0.26666978001594543,
0.3733240067958832,
-0.04909186810255051,
0.9635215401649475,
-0.7857807874679565,
0.2426351010799408,
0.21254058182239532,
0.5351624488830566,
0.11153152585029602,
-0.621437668800354,
0.4529883861541748,
0.052973341196775436,
-0.2759998142719269,
-0.6010883450508118,
0.5207821130752563,
-0.8296952247619629,
-0.40233147144317627,
1.1392788887023926,
-0.2598858177661896,
-0.1627214550971985,
-0.20195606350898743,
-0.35103365778923035,
0.17260205745697021,
-0.388152152299881,
0.793718695640564,
0.7740278840065002,
-0.43344709277153015,
-0.4546998143196106,
-0.13006578385829926,
0.46552449464797974,
0.4919075667858124,
-0.7633358240127563,
0.3671087920665741,
0.1705317497253418,
-0.009025415405631065,
-0.00430719368159771,
0.6492407321929932,
-0.12071188539266586,
0.5540506839752197,
-0.00644733477383852,
-0.11535371094942093,
0.11690360307693481,
-0.3895839750766754,
-0.227774977684021,
-0.10455990582704544,
0.2080967277288437,
-0.1361696422100067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14809v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14809v1
|
A Survey of Large Language Models on Generative Graph Analytics: Query, Learning, and Applications
| 2024-04-23T07:39:24 | 2024-04-23T07:39:24 |
Wenbo Shang, Xin Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB
|
A graph is a fundamental data model to represent various entities and their
complex relationships in society and nature, such as social networks,
transportation networks, financial networks, and biomedical systems. Recently,
large language models (LLMs) have showcased a strong generalization ability to
handle various NLP and multi-mode tasks to answer users' arbitrary questions
and specific-domain content generation. Compared with graph learning models,
LLMs enjoy superior advantages in addressing the challenges of generalizing
graph tasks by eliminating the need for training graph learning models and
reducing the cost of manual annotation. In this survey, we conduct a
comprehensive investigation of existing LLM studies on graph data, which
summarizes the relevant graph analytics tasks solved by advanced LLM models and
points out the existing remaining challenges and future directions.
Specifically, we study the key problems of LLM-based generative graph analytics
(LLM-GGA) with three categories: LLM-based graph query processing (LLM-GQP),
LLM-based graph inference and learning (LLM-GIL), and graph-LLM-based
applications. LLM-GQP focuses on an integration of graph analytics techniques
and LLM prompts, including graph understanding and knowledge graph (KG) based
augmented retrieval, while LLM-GIL focuses on learning and reasoning over
graphs, including graph learning, graph-formed reasoning and graph
representation. We summarize the useful prompts incorporated into LLM to handle
different graph downstream tasks. Moreover, we give a summary of LLM model
evaluation, benchmark datasets/tasks, and a deep pro and cons analysis of LLM
models. We also explore open problems and future directions in this exciting
interdisciplinary research area of LLMs and graph analytics.
|
[
-0.29173484444618225,
-1.1343146562576294,
0.7119163870811462,
-0.1353212296962738,
-0.08796543627977371,
0.4751467704772949,
-0.18962229788303375,
-0.6209470629692078,
0.16343513131141663,
0.6660919785499573,
-0.6048244833946228,
-1.0280168056488037,
-0.6308456063270569,
0.09583751112222672,
-0.48860740661621094,
0.5818617939949036,
-0.04510345682501793,
0.13473959267139435,
-0.41625839471817017,
-0.034341711550951004,
-0.3913419246673584,
-0.8049760460853577,
-1.037895679473877,
-0.21900586783885956,
0.6732660531997681,
0.13248267769813538,
0.33283448219299316,
0.21196192502975464,
0.4487100839614868,
0.2979923486709595,
-0.20488810539245605,
0.46254274249076843,
-0.8087450265884399,
0.17683467268943787,
0.10532241314649582,
-0.40091994404792786,
-0.536464512348175,
0.012970483861863613,
0.6609694957733154,
1.1686913967132568,
0.04769451916217804,
0.018198685720562935,
0.01370970718562603,
0.6555637717247009,
-0.4871019721031189,
0.6942224502563477,
-0.5272210836410522,
-0.07777158915996552,
-0.2559095025062561,
-0.014425186440348625,
-0.4951896667480469,
-0.39618512988090515,
0.0017903612460941076,
-0.46464166045188904,
0.3395960330963135,
0.37132731080055237,
0.5479327440261841,
-0.04967007786035538,
-0.6410030722618103,
-0.5097694396972656,
-0.6967612504959106,
0.6034404635429382,
-0.47163698077201843,
0.35789188742637634,
0.25641554594039917,
0.42344269156455994,
-0.3790559470653534,
-1.0039194822311401,
-0.3445185124874115,
-0.07548251748085022,
0.09278982132673264,
0.18544313311576843,
-0.5016035437583923,
0.23797008395195007,
0.21929796040058136,
0.36926519870758057,
-0.5411688685417175,
0.5903139114379883,
-0.15292610228061676,
-0.10412827134132385,
0.5699957013130188,
0.5184698700904846,
0.3364848494529724,
-0.13622233271598816,
-0.007256604265421629,
0.02235742099583149,
-0.9999995827674866,
-0.17791973054409027,
0.3472587466239929,
0.34799879789352417,
-0.10893606394529343,
0.6389607191085815,
-0.4852290749549866,
1.0431733131408691,
-0.4669082462787628,
0.20340511202812195,
0.0714893564581871,
-0.38962775468826294,
-0.1127469465136528,
-0.3787931203842163,
0.9614352583885193,
0.2559679448604584,
0.5177687406539917,
-0.45168784260749817,
-0.06586086750030518,
-0.11857148259878159,
-0.29026082158088684,
-0.7550201416015625,
-0.24211405217647552,
0.10517329722642899,
-0.21716462075710297,
-0.11711729317903519,
-0.3407733142375946,
-0.7573769688606262,
-0.5566850304603577,
-0.2520270347595215,
-0.1614452749490738,
-0.20878125727176666,
-0.2063831388950348,
0.14813463389873505,
0.05251428857445717,
0.2701181471347809,
0.44761893153190613,
-0.9217921495437622,
0.182028666138649,
0.7835479378700256,
0.8557289838790894,
-0.3007808029651642,
-0.15369084477424622,
-0.5572006702423096,
0.05706491321325302,
-0.38062742352485657,
0.790393590927124,
-0.5453523397445679,
-0.510979950428009,
0.2505095899105072,
0.10467669367790222,
-0.38023024797439575,
-0.4828539788722992,
0.23569582402706146,
-0.8773897886276245,
-0.07345976680517197,
-0.25439387559890747,
-0.798656702041626,
-0.30846482515335083,
0.46405547857284546,
-0.7894895672798157,
0.5804314613342285,
0.08787728101015091,
-0.6735425591468811,
0.2539547085762024,
-0.5118754506111145,
-0.4196425974369049,
0.31306034326553345,
-0.16590063273906708,
-0.30876198410987854,
-0.029830671846866608,
0.3134249150753021,
0.6046691536903381,
-0.6111969351768494,
0.29531073570251465,
-0.40451860427856445,
-0.0775739997625351,
0.1686278134584427,
-0.33247750997543335,
0.762567937374115,
0.0904054269194603,
0.20593498647212982,
0.3354089558124542,
-0.40863946080207825,
-0.029525630176067352,
0.46075552701950073,
-0.17249684035778046,
0.0230114683508873,
0.23893649876117706,
-0.14627023041248322,
-0.29293662309646606,
0.16937027871608734,
-0.44884759187698364,
0.36669158935546875,
-0.2841946482658386,
0.6917155385017395,
0.6449100375175476,
0.07565531134605408,
0.10670106112957001,
0.12146913260221481,
0.7848928570747375,
-0.35066238045692444,
0.008259504102170467,
-0.13314594328403473,
-0.7912024855613708,
-0.44527605175971985,
-0.1542338728904724,
0.3813066780567169,
0.5783271193504333,
-0.7563983201980591,
0.13857963681221008,
-0.4207861125469208,
-0.46149006485939026,
-0.13863839209079742,
0.20106753706932068,
0.04679024592041969,
0.5542788505554199,
0.1581314206123352,
-0.022974278777837753,
-0.29393288493156433,
-0.5686859488487244,
0.0180518738925457,
-0.21770529448986053,
0.09484010934829712,
0.612779438495636,
0.37833210825920105,
-0.260470986366272,
0.8878511190414429,
-1.050454020500183,
-0.2073698490858078,
-0.6146579384803772,
0.0409100241959095,
0.10299211740493774,
-0.08485860377550125,
0.6144049763679504,
-0.7179796695709229,
-0.45403140783309937,
0.10348179936408997,
-0.935809850692749,
-0.05348209664225578,
0.31476667523384094,
0.06046421080827713,
-0.001900769304484129,
0.6403206586837769,
-0.7303887009620667,
0.07126277685165405,
0.6508476734161377,
-0.04594668000936508,
0.5082395076751709,
0.03627604991197586,
-0.049019068479537964,
-0.9256674647331238,
0.05337207019329071,
0.04020655155181885,
-0.3287658393383026,
-0.56693035364151,
0.1939329355955124,
-0.25266557931900024,
-0.3768306076526642,
-0.13640643656253815,
0.5857624411582947,
-0.57332444190979,
-0.2326875478029251,
-0.16119860112667084,
0.27705448865890503,
-0.06706824898719788,
0.3463682234287262,
-0.07424783706665039,
0.7850103974342346,
0.6823171973228455,
-0.44087767601013184,
0.8835814595222473,
0.1595923900604248,
-0.3927167057991028,
0.14832822978496552,
-0.6366505026817322,
0.329097718000412,
-0.2896937131881714,
0.23722957074642181,
-1.2931443452835083,
-0.3260365426540375,
0.28447890281677246,
-0.33497077226638794,
0.3344959616661072,
-0.3405252695083618,
-0.8624492287635803,
-0.5476129055023193,
0.011168349534273148,
0.3358308970928192,
0.4558109641075134,
-0.5437261462211609,
0.603069007396698,
0.4269818961620331,
-0.3002419173717499,
-0.32432058453559875,
-0.27719956636428833,
0.3521385192871094,
-0.26463544368743896,
-0.6520057320594788,
0.0458807535469532,
0.10513871908187866,
-0.11070200055837631,
0.08844833076000214,
0.22095061838626862,
0.11629130691289902,
0.2531530559062958,
-0.015408080071210861,
0.30047857761383057,
-0.08869323134422302,
0.14180146157741547,
-0.26367872953414917,
-0.18557603657245636,
0.15853238105773926,
-0.28529635071754456,
0.8575704097747803,
0.056209295988082886,
-0.6093459725379944,
0.0874304473400116,
0.2243475615978241,
0.27426522970199585,
-0.31404101848602295,
0.6031346321105957,
0.49492552876472473,
-0.21887202560901642,
-0.11360641568899155,
-0.3964964747428894,
0.10758888721466064,
-0.376255065202713,
0.5776863098144531,
-0.1866651475429535,
-1.161171793937683,
0.7570825815200806,
-0.4730644226074219,
-0.06056822091341019,
0.5226024389266968,
0.5266725420951843,
-0.07123518735170364,
1.1828818321228027,
0.35299837589263916,
-0.3982773721218109,
0.5435504913330078,
-0.6505789160728455,
0.2946087419986725,
-0.8050351142883301,
-0.257022887468338,
-0.4877282679080963,
0.005149744916707277,
-0.5799199342727661,
-0.29135972261428833,
0.3919716775417328,
0.1475442796945572,
0.02480424754321575,
-0.12465334683656693,
-0.2567443549633026,
0.33976057171821594,
0.17163388431072235,
-0.0705176591873169,
0.35231006145477295,
0.15594203770160675,
0.19989362359046936,
0.2797115743160248,
-0.6141749620437622,
-0.20013359189033508,
1.3088550567626953,
0.11561716347932816,
0.837928831577301,
0.0725611075758934,
0.4580245614051819,
0.34862470626831055,
0.38547003269195557,
-0.9399477243423462,
0.6627076864242554,
-0.39459171891212463,
-0.24248236417770386,
-0.31629496812820435,
-0.6877320408821106,
-1.1958489418029785,
0.18969044089317322,
-0.03622478246688843,
-0.6854878664016724,
-0.2316775768995285,
0.11191850900650024,
0.08224354684352875,
0.49098992347717285,
-0.6395931839942932,
0.7916768789291382,
-0.23305045068264008,
-0.17015688121318817,
-0.08665935695171356,
-0.292927086353302,
0.32954487204551697,
0.04705179110169411,
0.16677288711071014,
-0.1691923886537552,
0.2925305962562561,
0.5811660289764404,
-0.12421684712171555,
1.030110239982605,
-0.29090917110443115,
-0.15292811393737793,
0.582409143447876,
-0.19740109145641327,
0.8274751305580139,
-0.25116363167762756,
-0.003923286683857441,
0.1962062567472458,
-0.38883858919143677,
-0.19382981956005096,
-0.546708345413208,
0.6018210053443909,
-0.5593730211257935,
-0.8065299391746521,
-0.1477595865726471,
-0.4802505075931549,
-0.3567861318588257,
0.1820622682571411,
0.17562665045261383,
0.45918014645576477,
-0.2633681893348694,
0.16011545062065125,
0.5707271695137024,
-0.2146904468536377,
0.17677997052669525,
0.2539087235927582,
-0.6005391478538513,
-0.32847490906715393,
1.0238592624664307,
0.1629953533411026,
0.4055829644203186,
0.31340765953063965,
0.07602670043706894,
-0.4352772533893585,
-1.0409810543060303,
-0.5224344730377197,
0.2843253016471863,
-0.8422245383262634,
-0.17820565402507782,
-0.6942138671875,
-0.3134063482284546,
-0.4401964247226715,
0.16312037408351898,
0.1032746285200119,
-0.06881691515445709,
-0.4439155161380768,
-0.3067026436328888,
0.5176413655281067,
0.6756611466407776,
0.33031022548675537,
0.2747006118297577,
-0.5156600475311279,
0.3215314447879791,
0.399709552526474,
0.23086701333522797,
0.2288973033428192,
0.1280093938112259,
-0.0964808538556099,
-0.008511663414537907,
-0.16983942687511444,
-0.7509851455688477,
0.30643782019615173,
0.04589034244418144,
0.5870321989059448,
0.3628101348876953,
-0.22368696331977844,
0.38714420795440674,
-0.32209062576293945,
0.6853814721107483,
0.1463107466697693,
-0.5544486045837402,
0.21267038583755493,
-0.5106298327445984,
-0.07254879921674728,
0.1719212681055069,
0.3519580066204071,
-0.606785774230957,
-0.11438117176294327,
-0.10621195286512375,
-0.8623161911964417,
0.4449334740638733,
-0.12146194279193878,
0.24183346331119537,
-0.19649802148342133,
0.486864298582077,
-0.17733484506607056,
0.2607843279838562,
-0.5101763010025024,
-0.2248525470495224,
0.05852091684937477,
-0.12163484841585159,
-0.3055950701236725,
-0.16975492238998413,
-0.07075429707765579,
-0.19883236289024353,
0.29383981227874756,
-0.5225135684013367,
0.07184358686208725,
-0.1943395435810089,
-0.04634444788098335,
0.15912987291812897,
0.27556484937667847,
0.089035265147686,
0.6146361827850342,
-0.0875711739063263,
-0.06783124059438705,
0.16256825625896454,
-0.16903109848499298,
-0.03271334618330002,
0.2641999423503876,
-0.23728685081005096,
-0.3463554382324219,
0.4774961769580841,
0.964241623878479,
-0.08175956457853317,
-0.7234705686569214,
0.3564857244491577,
0.16283762454986572,
-0.030729101970791817,
-0.26279255747795105,
0.013243189081549644,
0.5803947448730469,
0.033843956887722015,
0.3143760561943054,
-0.5401222109794617,
0.16894662380218506,
-0.5052731037139893,
-0.3987922668457031,
0.9015510082244873,
-0.24840332567691803,
-0.3044138252735138,
0.7069919109344482,
0.007239166181534529,
-0.0969894677400589,
1.0461112260818481,
-0.38915300369262695,
-0.46986123919487,
0.8003638386726379,
0.6706627011299133,
0.7440574169158936,
0.10716273635625839,
0.2645907998085022,
0.07677583396434784,
0.01612701639533043,
0.22067536413669586,
0.2870074212551117,
0.09984882920980453,
-0.8401923775672913,
-0.6522149443626404,
-0.5119960904121399,
-0.5328793525695801,
0.09471463412046432,
-0.340101033449173,
-0.02532581053674221,
-0.288395494222641,
-0.298946350812912,
0.2027025818824768,
-0.05831344425678253,
-0.7369974255561829,
0.003792118513956666,
0.06309228390455246,
0.6416879892349243,
-0.7747408151626587,
0.5329156517982483,
0.6681430339813232,
-0.335940420627594,
-0.47758784890174866,
-0.5062826871871948,
-0.09228592365980148,
-1.0238453149795532,
0.7052553296089172,
-0.04205178841948509,
-0.17957216501235962,
0.32544979453086853,
-0.8039225935935974,
-0.6227803230285645,
1.012689471244812,
0.41266563534736633,
-0.5785665512084961,
-0.3076038062572479,
0.32437005639076233,
0.561780571937561,
-0.3610724210739136,
-0.044396135956048965,
0.4957621097564697,
0.25522419810295105,
0.27174514532089233,
-0.4691182076931,
-0.08209003508090973,
0.02573961578309536,
-0.08960180729627609,
0.40389418601989746,
-0.7145107984542847,
0.889270544052124,
-0.22199873626232147,
-0.3346322774887085,
0.08317143470048904,
0.44487088918685913,
0.26380714774131775,
0.42148053646087646,
0.2762163281440735,
0.5425649881362915,
0.785509467124939,
-0.22938480973243713,
1.2634797096252441,
-0.235350102186203,
0.5336549282073975,
0.7384434938430786,
-0.5676496028900146,
0.4077063202857971,
0.03992964327335358,
-0.4675213396549225,
0.4022118151187897,
0.79859858751297,
-0.245647594332695,
0.1860998421907425,
0.4514429569244385,
-0.24051333963871002,
-0.28784018754959106,
-0.2452804446220398,
-0.28584685921669006,
0.30720949172973633,
0.6438265442848206,
-0.1528734266757965,
-0.3943055272102356,
-0.07758314162492752,
0.0361669659614563,
-0.2396697998046875,
-0.4521198272705078,
0.7757660746574402,
0.17323797941207886,
-0.2958776652812958,
0.27160677313804626,
0.03824252635240555,
0.30929142236709595,
-0.7813819050788879,
-0.030502019450068474,
-0.1771874576807022,
-0.1447184681892395,
-0.12890253961086273,
-0.752143383026123,
0.035417161881923676,
0.027935348451137543,
-0.06439794600009918,
-0.014535925351083279,
0.7114579081535339,
-0.07941745966672897,
-0.5815221071243286,
0.5689945816993713,
0.6845327615737915,
0.12280283868312836,
-0.11820406466722488,
-0.4546374976634979,
0.003797439858317375,
-0.07121910154819489,
-0.1923055201768875,
0.3594270944595337,
0.3452182114124298,
-0.12779851257801056,
0.9193024039268494,
0.7157440185546875,
0.24720022082328796,
0.14116673171520233,
0.5183579325675964,
0.9385350942611694,
-0.6204244494438171,
-0.2932617664337158,
-0.6983214616775513,
0.027415404096245766,
-0.013279412873089314,
0.09386322647333145,
0.7835336327552795,
0.6216127872467041,
0.5897077322006226,
0.14565233886241913,
0.8735358715057373,
0.2395482361316681,
0.2513141930103302,
-0.8549207448959351,
0.39518728852272034,
-0.4375743865966797,
0.08059927821159363,
-0.21182605624198914,
-0.9150691628456116,
-0.3077400326728821,
-0.022059796378016472,
-0.5872786641120911,
0.2501627206802368,
0.2950597107410431,
0.4481067955493927,
0.09661164879798889,
0.049680426716804504,
0.1950048953294754,
0.014407462440431118,
0.6172651052474976,
0.5517436265945435,
0.9155383110046387,
0.03946956992149353,
0.4315485954284668,
0.2607229948043823,
-0.023461606353521347,
-0.22928278148174286,
-0.6010647416114807,
-0.7737991809844971,
-0.4411439597606659,
-0.20715636014938354,
-0.2354028820991516,
-0.10340405255556107,
0.4512193202972412,
0.4577946662902832,
-0.7530611753463745,
-0.30849382281303406,
-0.2467091679573059,
0.34083107113838196,
0.03204329311847687,
-0.2505398690700531,
0.6891018748283386,
-0.3051556348800659,
-0.866499125957489,
0.4145694077014923,
0.20178307592868805,
0.14682000875473022,
-0.37260422110557556,
0.1424333155155182,
-0.02415148727595806,
-0.2629271447658539,
0.7762870192527771,
0.43566590547561646,
-0.5061614513397217,
-0.26346275210380554,
0.06929592043161392,
0.09760706126689911,
0.059225913137197495,
0.8948485851287842,
-0.5810291171073914,
0.46521443128585815,
0.5898634195327759,
0.7391073107719421,
0.8987139463424683,
0.10252551734447479,
0.2455478012561798,
-0.5397680401802063,
-0.13617633283138275,
0.0671277642250061,
0.5617945790290833,
0.4834946095943451,
-0.34779784083366394,
0.553056538105011,
0.36882543563842773,
-0.4000895917415619,
-0.7161465883255005,
0.574816107749939,
-0.844627320766449,
-0.2775246202945709,
1.0895980596542358,
-0.14369629323482513,
0.024811066687107086,
-0.17127935588359833,
0.07569587230682373,
0.21760331094264984,
0.017084451392292976,
0.42159879207611084,
0.8044265508651733,
-0.38539204001426697,
-0.13602928817272186,
-0.6361953616142273,
0.1777661144733429,
-0.027930019423365593,
-0.9554367065429688,
0.3571629524230957,
0.8514487147331238,
0.2752171456813812,
-0.04185771197080612,
0.6807815432548523,
-0.0002535809762775898,
-0.23972690105438232,
-0.08334363996982574,
-0.04467947408556938,
-0.26823416352272034,
-0.26107239723205566,
-0.17409659922122955,
0.5120841860771179,
0.23785367608070374,
-0.04332719370722771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14795v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14795v3
|
Talk Too Much: Poisoning Large Language Models under Token Limit
| 2024-04-23T07:19:20 | 2024-05-11T10:40:58 |
Jiaming He, Wenbo Jiang, Guanyu Hou, Wenshu Fan, Rui Zhang, Hongwei Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Mainstream poisoning attacks on large language models (LLMs) typically set a
fixed trigger in the input instance and specific responses for triggered
queries. However, the fixed trigger setting (e.g., unusual words) may be easily
detected by human detection, limiting the effectiveness and practicality in
real-world scenarios. To enhance the stealthiness of the trigger, we present a
poisoning attack against LLMs that is triggered by a generation/output
condition-token limitation, which is a commonly adopted strategy by users for
reducing costs. The poisoned model performs normally for output without token
limitation, while becomes harmful for output with limited tokens. To achieve
this objective, we introduce BrieFool, an efficient attack framework. It
leverages the characteristics of generation limitation by efficient instruction
sampling and poisoning data generation, thereby influencing the behavior of
LLMs under target conditions. Our experiments demonstrate that BrieFool is
effective across safety domains and knowledge domains. For instance, with only
20 generated poisoning examples against GPT-3.5-turbo, BrieFool achieves a 100%
Attack Success Rate (ASR) and a 9.28/10 average Harmfulness Score (HS) under
token limitation conditions while maintaining the benign performance.
|
[
-0.24400979280471802,
-0.936318576335907,
0.3159095346927643,
0.07622092962265015,
-0.34288471937179565,
-0.15374988317489624,
-0.26219668984413147,
-0.43983691930770874,
0.03620635345578194,
0.7761684656143188,
-0.19443707168102264,
-0.49867603182792664,
-0.6424274444580078,
-0.19449174404144287,
-0.98033207654953,
1.0721524953842163,
0.34462976455688477,
-0.44291597604751587,
0.12100201845169067,
-0.12622474133968353,
-0.6062056422233582,
-0.7885125875473022,
-1.0152705907821655,
0.025578495115041733,
0.6819971203804016,
0.5021283626556396,
0.48451218008995056,
0.3837972581386566,
0.3086147904396057,
0.24898114800453186,
-0.152433380484581,
-0.09565615653991699,
-0.6976602077484131,
0.3308510482311249,
0.06454426050186157,
-0.4850844442844391,
-0.5538468956947327,
-0.344060480594635,
0.4024510383605957,
0.4688180387020111,
-0.07766690105199814,
-0.08049188554286957,
0.1568450927734375,
0.32132387161254883,
-0.6883304119110107,
-0.06698061525821686,
-0.8853247165679932,
-0.1499825268983841,
-0.4937581717967987,
-0.1572490930557251,
-0.7566340565681458,
0.07464752346277237,
-0.16585078835487366,
-0.2786850035190582,
-0.04563683643937111,
0.10759717971086502,
0.5533052086830139,
0.3007371127605438,
-0.5296107530593872,
-0.34333956241607666,
-0.47932228446006775,
0.8729151487350464,
-0.8319883346557617,
-0.09031034260988235,
0.20915712416172028,
0.25567173957824707,
-0.22717511653900146,
-0.8125029802322388,
-0.7028914093971252,
-0.054726939648389816,
-0.21072547137737274,
-0.09956039488315582,
-0.6677657961845398,
0.46320924162864685,
0.5740243792533875,
0.00404885970056057,
-0.6207708716392517,
0.09511364251375198,
-0.3620172142982483,
-0.23962102830410004,
0.44499698281288147,
0.387081116437912,
0.6182471513748169,
-0.5192847847938538,
-0.4634420871734619,
-0.006426235195249319,
-0.9027511477470398,
-0.2559562027454376,
0.5592969059944153,
0.3661094903945923,
-0.04935602843761444,
0.38980573415756226,
-0.06111865118145943,
0.8044463992118835,
-0.15547271072864532,
0.15798842906951904,
-0.29979321360588074,
-0.28269708156585693,
-0.2252711057662964,
0.01884431578218937,
0.9122015237808228,
0.48898160457611084,
0.15200793743133545,
-0.002810052828863263,
-0.16555465757846832,
-0.12208740413188934,
0.09009959548711777,
-1.123077154159546,
-0.15978558361530304,
0.4923887848854065,
0.05853765830397606,
-0.5111427307128906,
-0.309787780046463,
-0.9870985746383667,
-0.548657238483429,
0.3360159695148468,
0.45147669315338135,
-0.39763155579566956,
-0.243413046002388,
0.03900587931275368,
-0.28457504510879517,
0.27252456545829773,
-0.24203939735889435,
-0.9702615141868591,
0.3920741081237793,
0.7216725945472717,
0.9478903412818909,
-0.3015035092830658,
-0.3480304181575775,
-0.8773449063301086,
0.42104730010032654,
-0.4301315248012543,
0.63447505235672,
-0.38985347747802734,
-0.6041708588600159,
-0.09253684431314468,
-0.2805081009864807,
-0.08392558991909027,
-0.8328606486320496,
0.5362796783447266,
-0.45022132992744446,
0.06864126026630402,
-0.07180654257535934,
-0.4395550489425659,
0.10707259923219681,
0.1118682399392128,
-0.538956880569458,
0.4931808412075043,
-0.15199728310108185,
-0.9671061635017395,
0.41693124175071716,
-0.6511222720146179,
-0.6617229580879211,
0.17825746536254883,
-0.08331987261772156,
0.014061071909964085,
-0.08568568527698517,
-0.11574055254459381,
0.6329379081726074,
0.12369993329048157,
0.44026532769203186,
-0.17604707181453705,
-0.5762036442756653,
0.04871538653969765,
-0.5857524871826172,
0.7456315159797668,
0.24211546778678894,
-0.2164873331785202,
0.5672478079795837,
-0.5868783593177795,
0.022698335349559784,
0.08344397693872452,
-0.302433043718338,
-0.297942578792572,
-0.06211348995566368,
-0.15094062685966492,
0.11313708126544952,
0.01999000459909439,
-0.2631113827228546,
0.04731359705328941,
-0.7025619745254517,
0.6863614916801453,
0.6846282482147217,
0.4558596611022949,
0.37329816818237305,
-0.5329582691192627,
0.5743969678878784,
-0.09043803066015244,
0.4030899703502655,
-0.3078804612159729,
-0.30383503437042236,
-0.8849050998687744,
-0.4495452642440796,
0.04805123433470726,
0.44502851366996765,
-0.7888280749320984,
0.32598796486854553,
-0.32368263602256775,
-0.42666321992874146,
-0.000031130337447393686,
0.1641889363527298,
0.3561663329601288,
0.39297738671302795,
0.188700869679451,
0.11586616188287735,
-0.3946349322795868,
-0.7217648029327393,
-0.5537651777267456,
-0.024433091282844543,
-0.22771921753883362,
0.36659523844718933,
0.3598044812679291,
-0.1426931768655777,
0.7035319209098816,
-0.5696302652359009,
-0.3427896797657013,
-0.562207818031311,
-0.07583814114332199,
0.3715893030166626,
0.39595475792884827,
0.6661723256111145,
-0.4654102623462677,
-0.6368734836578369,
-0.3791739046573639,
-0.5197175145149231,
-0.14380675554275513,
-0.2950535714626312,
-0.23908375203609467,
0.11080624163150787,
0.6191061735153198,
-0.7025173306465149,
0.3536226749420166,
0.5088887810707092,
-0.3281819522380829,
0.47844648361206055,
0.06744398921728134,
-0.29270294308662415,
-1.017472505569458,
0.17361386120319366,
-0.3160441815853119,
-0.3075152337551117,
-1.0305458307266235,
0.42732927203178406,
-0.03831127658486366,
-0.5893943905830383,
-0.9267049431800842,
0.8044805526733398,
-0.10698357224464417,
0.4839460849761963,
-0.4421740174293518,
0.05806365981698036,
0.1490379124879837,
0.417359322309494,
-0.4337334632873535,
0.8194632530212402,
0.6302508115768433,
-0.6739140748977661,
0.46689268946647644,
-0.0006212234729900956,
-0.22190631926059723,
0.24696993827819824,
-0.6115257143974304,
0.24722571671009064,
0.21527159214019775,
0.28871381282806396,
-0.7513895630836487,
-0.6283738017082214,
0.35167771577835083,
-0.2252456098794937,
0.6106325387954712,
-0.2754383087158203,
-0.6824172735214233,
-0.06447851657867432,
-0.6315716505050659,
0.18850666284561157,
0.48692643642425537,
-0.6304917335510254,
0.5657092332839966,
0.2053137719631195,
-0.049309611320495605,
-0.6199549436569214,
-0.7677457332611084,
0.40960925817489624,
-0.5970622897148132,
-0.6536715030670166,
-0.003353260923177004,
-0.1080222949385643,
-0.3227177858352661,
-0.2771412432193756,
-0.09507748484611511,
-0.0011519395047798753,
0.17075896263122559,
0.2451290339231491,
-0.021621178835630417,
0.21121126413345337,
0.10945530235767365,
0.22449712455272675,
-0.1100655123591423,
0.11142328381538391,
0.09231483191251755,
1.0079606771469116,
0.16845878958702087,
-0.4540739059448242,
-0.39811745285987854,
0.7107709646224976,
0.8594554662704468,
0.2663165032863617,
0.7008579969406128,
0.2527782917022705,
-0.18003349006175995,
-0.44427409768104553,
-0.22964118421077728,
-0.5293366312980652,
-0.583131730556488,
0.5637011528015137,
-0.29743096232414246,
-0.5258855223655701,
0.5292958617210388,
-0.0009141520131379366,
0.07171540707349777,
0.2420428842306137,
0.1986587643623352,
0.3019216060638428,
1.0711431503295898,
0.407401442527771,
-0.3786969482898712,
0.5163715481758118,
-0.25595763325691223,
0.3832392990589142,
-0.772489070892334,
0.06671915203332901,
-0.1452879160642624,
-0.03614100068807602,
-0.2793327271938324,
-0.3318377435207367,
0.3944215178489685,
0.09099019318819046,
-0.32410484552383423,
0.18526524305343628,
-0.47350308299064636,
0.8306999802589417,
0.5264195799827576,
-0.11167632043361664,
0.1862027794122696,
-0.13013599812984467,
-0.09521453827619553,
0.10724165290594101,
-0.7602089643478394,
-0.4574972987174988,
1.0785200595855713,
0.04659014567732811,
0.7443354725837708,
0.13350717723369598,
0.8203199505805969,
0.20612472295761108,
0.07945791631937027,
-0.74623042345047,
0.8132357597351074,
-0.16396066546440125,
-0.9195476770401001,
-0.3545565605163574,
-0.5169503092765808,
-0.9113214612007141,
0.16659040749073029,
0.23740892112255096,
-0.8450144529342651,
-0.1572955846786499,
0.013541126623749733,
-0.38705936074256897,
0.61611407995224,
-1.1802406311035156,
0.8168930411338806,
-0.29914048314094543,
-0.3950067460536957,
-0.17254279553890228,
-0.4070955216884613,
0.68528151512146,
-0.48716750741004944,
0.2719112038612366,
-0.2434413582086563,
-0.04907435178756714,
0.862356424331665,
-0.46432313323020935,
1.1369984149932861,
-0.2830635905265808,
0.11440657824277878,
0.3127795457839966,
0.2602280378341675,
0.7057729959487915,
-0.12993134558200836,
-0.210444375872612,
0.3026129901409149,
0.048767704516649246,
-0.5820629000663757,
-0.36477842926979065,
0.8563125729560852,
-0.2943180501461029,
-1.0111839771270752,
-0.40082332491874695,
-0.3420955240726471,
-0.1454283744096756,
0.3727881908416748,
0.6540446877479553,
0.3158681094646454,
0.12023395299911499,
0.053018271923065186,
0.3013937473297119,
-0.6111772060394287,
0.6379653215408325,
0.3371357321739197,
-0.30542486906051636,
-0.04631957784295082,
1.291922926902771,
0.07393927872180939,
0.6114796996116638,
-0.03293050453066826,
0.305367112159729,
-0.04845569655299187,
-0.485774964094162,
-0.513486921787262,
0.20453058183193207,
-0.8201847076416016,
-0.4393793046474457,
-0.6534920930862427,
-0.3313206732273102,
-0.32515978813171387,
-0.0024526072666049004,
-0.1696985363960266,
-0.1712612509727478,
-0.3755268156528473,
-0.005718344356864691,
0.3681831955909729,
0.5623137354850769,
0.06503120064735413,
0.5968643426895142,
-0.5659856200218201,
0.05716153606772423,
0.5798197388648987,
0.25729215145111084,
0.19878056645393372,
-0.6377519369125366,
0.06344091147184372,
-0.36315473914146423,
-0.49207621812820435,
-0.9531692266464233,
0.3865831792354584,
0.34264692664146423,
0.32661306858062744,
0.817050576210022,
0.6224513053894043,
0.6220704913139343,
-0.37568244338035583,
0.8611895442008972,
0.31452658772468567,
-1.1907745599746704,
0.4642435312271118,
-0.427463561296463,
0.33513712882995605,
0.18904970586299896,
0.10038899630308151,
-0.8615500330924988,
-0.8919925689697266,
-0.5816858410835266,
-1.3511772155761719,
0.6282274127006531,
0.22275781631469727,
0.8583407402038574,
-0.24574752151966095,
0.14371313154697418,
-0.07469258457422256,
0.09014527499675751,
-0.5777782797813416,
-0.29986634850502014,
0.08730893582105637,
-0.16496452689170837,
0.4146568775177002,
-0.6460840702056885,
-0.2170398086309433,
-0.03869051858782768,
0.5195928812026978,
0.006103066261857748,
0.1597503274679184,
-0.29179003834724426,
0.016486695036292076,
0.09826071560382843,
0.4385700523853302,
0.6260496973991394,
0.5703018307685852,
0.03960684314370155,
0.2632374167442322,
0.5702081322669983,
-0.33003702759742737,
-0.045406777411699295,
-0.22660410404205322,
-0.10898280888795853,
-0.16695627570152283,
0.7388090491294861,
0.6309338212013245,
0.23872683942317963,
-1.0914149284362793,
0.786891758441925,
-0.1847904771566391,
0.07150773704051971,
-0.08869797736406326,
0.6311240792274475,
0.27320054173469543,
0.06645750999450684,
0.4168032109737396,
-0.1707792729139328,
0.07292846590280533,
-0.4671788513660431,
0.2935885488986969,
0.45028048753738403,
-0.2615113854408264,
-0.16914904117584229,
0.5701045989990234,
0.22263000905513763,
0.003672911785542965,
0.3486922085285187,
-0.17405377328395844,
-0.6470499038696289,
0.3394731283187866,
0.5473055243492126,
0.5263711214065552,
-0.16984596848487854,
-0.34058475494384766,
0.1651320904493332,
0.175663024187088,
0.3806077539920807,
0.15457022190093994,
-0.04443631321191788,
-0.5500155687332153,
-0.46847859025001526,
-0.5194301605224609,
-0.5714820027351379,
0.47061213850975037,
-0.5169197916984558,
0.3180461525917053,
-0.7588222622871399,
-0.1044280007481575,
-0.012479218654334545,
-0.22981953620910645,
-0.10639401525259018,
-0.1375909149646759,
0.018002275377511978,
0.5575218200683594,
-0.7217746376991272,
0.8443368673324585,
0.02691742777824402,
-0.16124875843524933,
-0.7589855790138245,
0.14586961269378662,
0.041011471301317215,
-0.7495227456092834,
0.5650452375411987,
0.22058182954788208,
-0.11166968196630478,
-0.14528478682041168,
-0.6060001850128174,
-0.4884461462497711,
0.5837686657905579,
0.46524012088775635,
-0.7286649346351624,
0.0717039406299591,
0.06507100909948349,
0.29420536756515503,
0.22152352333068848,
-0.21337595582008362,
0.6346118450164795,
0.4146224558353424,
0.09675195813179016,
-0.6136459112167358,
0.2839711904525757,
-0.049016330391168594,
-0.4896271824836731,
0.33980756998062134,
-0.735120415687561,
0.7328751087188721,
-0.18240313231945038,
-0.6152231097221375,
-0.0786110982298851,
0.21163111925125122,
0.17269229888916016,
0.37776634097099304,
0.597292423248291,
0.30907467007637024,
0.8069352507591248,
0.19678643345832825,
1.060713529586792,
-0.4705181419849396,
-0.04717551916837692,
1.0498746633529663,
-0.4253091514110565,
0.9046838283538818,
0.42554375529289246,
0.06514624506235123,
0.029989583417773247,
0.3320361077785492,
0.13905464112758636,
0.4003150165081024,
0.4331311285495758,
-0.629208505153656,
-0.13931752741336823,
-0.157812237739563,
-0.3197125196456909,
0.34265056252479553,
0.37719663977622986,
-0.09377110749483109,
-0.10075274854898453,
0.33112114667892456,
0.6962949633598328,
-0.3839187026023865,
-0.014416534453630447,
0.8941763639450073,
0.2774052321910858,
-0.42309221625328064,
0.8264641165733337,
-0.0740303248167038,
0.7888575792312622,
-0.6263523697853088,
0.35657888650894165,
-0.532451868057251,
0.11233016103506088,
-0.14018546044826508,
-0.42427265644073486,
0.5455277562141418,
0.40188854932785034,
-0.02888227067887783,
0.03077499195933342,
0.7698487639427185,
-0.13402892649173737,
-0.21758976578712463,
0.46789607405662537,
0.2247147262096405,
0.3126627504825592,
-0.4720993936061859,
-0.24400125443935394,
0.2100444883108139,
0.04742024838924408,
-0.19401337206363678,
0.5608063340187073,
0.23586277663707733,
0.03347856551408768,
0.7119178175926208,
0.7407647371292114,
0.46183067560195923,
0.27886298298835754,
-0.014924010261893272,
1.0330077409744263,
-0.6913990378379822,
-0.27110621333122253,
-1.164683222770691,
-0.060085829347372055,
-0.2865181565284729,
-0.11402013152837753,
0.7998486161231995,
0.6484439373016357,
0.5930823087692261,
0.3339313864707947,
0.71277916431427,
0.11757819354534149,
0.33083412051200867,
-0.4198606312274933,
1.0260721445083618,
-0.5165348649024963,
0.5801980495452881,
-0.02899535372853279,
-0.5555273294448853,
-0.5105107426643372,
0.016702735796570778,
-0.2952224016189575,
-0.1671094447374344,
0.8597781658172607,
0.7218604683876038,
0.057829078286886215,
-0.22481603920459747,
0.7586841583251953,
0.4943253993988037,
0.7128840088844299,
0.5775842666625977,
0.9804049134254456,
-0.011672225780785084,
1.1217684745788574,
-0.08879325538873672,
-0.09323069453239441,
-0.25763243436813354,
-0.7090089321136475,
-1.0320501327514648,
-0.14771558344364166,
-0.06341352313756943,
-0.3856949806213379,
-0.06182664632797241,
0.5316035747528076,
0.93482905626297,
-0.7653763890266418,
-0.12094815820455551,
0.00619993032887578,
0.16694375872612,
0.19971780478954315,
-0.2368561029434204,
0.529923141002655,
-0.5130508542060852,
-0.7612171769142151,
0.5687421560287476,
0.23704147338867188,
0.0031784777529537678,
-0.06990846246480942,
0.12527824938297272,
0.26294854283332825,
0.3651113212108612,
0.500739336013794,
0.2045622169971466,
-0.528050422668457,
-0.3306816816329956,
-0.3202824294567108,
-0.12590405344963074,
-0.22188672423362732,
0.794094443321228,
-0.3497147560119629,
0.4018789231777191,
0.41755396127700806,
0.2731309235095978,
0.5356429219245911,
-0.22928893566131592,
0.3284256160259247,
-1.171872854232788,
0.44043153524398804,
0.4020824730396271,
0.3690940737724304,
0.34369927644729614,
-0.4335379898548126,
0.09838635474443436,
0.11713762581348419,
-0.2805338203907013,
-1.0642743110656738,
0.4485894739627838,
-0.8581517934799194,
-0.6231508851051331,
1.474257230758667,
-0.18891984224319458,
-0.3239985406398773,
-0.1252565234899521,
-0.2176603078842163,
0.21003365516662598,
-0.5761041045188904,
0.628352165222168,
0.5083310604095459,
-0.06511892378330231,
0.3530649244785309,
-0.8336852788925171,
0.5597371459007263,
0.43414604663848877,
-0.7671085000038147,
0.4386155605316162,
0.2710682153701782,
0.45191261172294617,
-0.049933381378650665,
0.4520869851112366,
0.09119261801242828,
-0.002025031019002199,
0.17580270767211914,
-0.2856273353099823,
-0.09983909875154495,
-0.27959325909614563,
-0.25134921073913574,
0.4103569984436035,
0.22376540303230286,
-0.3109990656375885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14779v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14779v1
|
Med42 -- Evaluating Fine-Tuning Strategies for Medical LLMs: Full-Parameter vs. Parameter-Efficient Approaches
| 2024-04-23T06:36:21 | 2024-04-23T06:36:21 |
Clément Christophe, Praveen K Kanithi, Prateek Munjal, Tathagata Raha, Nasir Hayat, Ronnie Rajan, Ahmed Al-Mahrooqi, Avani Gupta, Muhammad Umar Salman, Gurpreet Gosal, Bhargav Kanakiya, Charles Chen, Natalia Vassilieva, Boulbaba Ben Amor, Marco AF Pimentel, Shadab Khan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study presents a comprehensive analysis and comparison of two
predominant fine-tuning methodologies - full-parameter fine-tuning and
parameter-efficient tuning - within the context of medical Large Language
Models (LLMs). We developed and refined a series of LLMs, based on the Llama-2
architecture, specifically designed to enhance medical knowledge retrieval,
reasoning, and question-answering capabilities. Our experiments systematically
evaluate the effectiveness of these tuning strategies across various well-known
medical benchmarks. Notably, our medical LLM Med42 showed an accuracy level of
72% on the US Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) datasets, setting a new
standard in performance for openly available medical LLMs. Through this
comparative analysis, we aim to identify the most effective and efficient
method for fine-tuning LLMs in the medical domain, thereby contributing
significantly to the advancement of AI-driven healthcare applications.
|
[
-0.4211365282535553,
-0.6634336113929749,
0.7678923606872559,
-0.1133262887597084,
-0.6151813864707947,
-0.08171775937080383,
-0.4304543435573578,
-0.4463362693786621,
-0.2559412121772766,
0.5258080959320068,
-0.46987929940223694,
-0.6088001132011414,
-0.5994970202445984,
0.33948710560798645,
0.02134118601679802,
0.7300946116447449,
-0.23126903176307678,
0.592918336391449,
-0.2759527266025543,
-0.20271486043930054,
-0.26046812534332275,
-0.26100268959999084,
-1.0507460832595825,
-0.39541175961494446,
0.6569355130195618,
0.4386969804763794,
0.5407243371009827,
1.029457688331604,
0.971300482749939,
0.21892255544662476,
-0.1949968785047531,
0.5965321660041809,
-0.6023997664451599,
0.06381122767925262,
-0.36056897044181824,
-0.6070570945739746,
-0.5844571590423584,
-0.18772464990615845,
0.47064444422721863,
0.6311161518096924,
-0.3227822780609131,
0.3190077841281891,
-0.17812734842300415,
0.9191535711288452,
-0.5946170687675476,
0.00046248413855209947,
-0.6079356670379639,
-0.039499931037425995,
-0.32809391617774963,
-0.5068986415863037,
-0.13549447059631348,
-0.3602069020271301,
0.02151641435921192,
-0.4698200523853302,
-0.03821951150894165,
0.2471523880958557,
0.6703467965126038,
0.7697175145149231,
-0.35294947028160095,
-0.4467438757419586,
-0.3976258933544159,
0.7533427476882935,
-0.9500429034233093,
0.5095792412757874,
0.35508790612220764,
0.25854554772377014,
-0.2470163106918335,
-0.8791753649711609,
-0.16135545074939728,
-0.23465602099895477,
0.2725864052772522,
0.026397576555609703,
-0.15333126485347748,
0.4107728898525238,
0.18710540235042572,
0.6275476813316345,
-0.42135268449783325,
0.7161164879798889,
-0.6030567288398743,
-0.19633059203624725,
0.6013627052307129,
0.46399131417274475,
0.0911468043923378,
0.17889724671840668,
-0.1937718540430069,
0.08185917139053345,
-0.9344401359558105,
-0.29029181599617004,
-0.0370093435049057,
0.05954771861433983,
-0.016232043504714966,
0.8256387710571289,
-0.5146444439888,
0.9227339625358582,
-0.05548003315925598,
-0.4102671146392822,
0.09468263387680054,
-0.5598673224449158,
-0.49450138211250305,
-0.3487522006034851,
0.7559003829956055,
0.848804771900177,
0.35909298062324524,
-0.37007275223731995,
-0.16459594666957855,
0.04687432572245598,
0.2595028281211853,
-0.9331483840942383,
-0.08121596276760101,
0.336275190114975,
-0.6705706715583801,
-0.2916509509086609,
-0.511424720287323,
-0.8080212473869324,
-0.7391663193702698,
-0.5391796231269836,
0.314919114112854,
-0.33473244309425354,
0.29671457409858704,
0.5167310237884521,
-0.0014285340439528227,
0.3761349618434906,
0.278852254152298,
-0.7249230742454529,
0.4078556001186371,
0.8430883288383484,
0.5754173398017883,
-0.5005806088447571,
0.17401979863643646,
-0.403396338224411,
-0.02268170565366745,
-0.5952156782150269,
0.7699874639511108,
-0.5005950927734375,
-0.4973301589488983,
-0.11003252118825912,
-0.10747387260198593,
-0.11535819619894028,
-1.2765942811965942,
0.8654181361198425,
-0.4977167844772339,
-0.07177846878767014,
-0.3177288770675659,
-0.7956153750419617,
-0.16239607334136963,
0.22298812866210938,
-0.42429694533348083,
0.4652501940727234,
-0.07969354093074799,
-0.3594348132610321,
0.31912097334861755,
-0.8289584517478943,
-0.37668856978416443,
-0.22724995017051697,
-0.15329788625240326,
-0.48185494542121887,
0.21452294290065765,
0.2688518464565277,
0.5738483667373657,
-0.8134757876396179,
0.10940863192081451,
-0.05578890070319176,
-0.5398000478744507,
0.08521530777215958,
-0.5044045448303223,
0.39978304505348206,
0.32254061102867126,
-0.1586810052394867,
0.1906505674123764,
-0.8171667456626892,
0.00043653391185216606,
0.12423743307590485,
-0.700628399848938,
-0.01833718828856945,
0.09423849731683731,
-0.4052269160747528,
-0.059040386229753494,
0.43664056062698364,
-0.4379599690437317,
0.21198566257953644,
-0.7457470893859863,
0.39678701758384705,
0.4216930866241455,
0.2647174894809723,
0.31075426936149597,
-0.668476402759552,
0.5186442136764526,
-0.18072573840618134,
0.40172243118286133,
0.1255684792995453,
-0.4610022008419037,
-0.6852998733520508,
-0.49983784556388855,
0.3471423387527466,
0.687397301197052,
-0.3142574429512024,
0.19672568142414093,
0.1803802102804184,
-0.724155068397522,
-0.8902814984321594,
0.24816398322582245,
0.574938178062439,
0.6733274459838867,
0.5819705128669739,
-0.15382210910320282,
-0.4455263018608093,
-0.9613633751869202,
-0.3633894920349121,
0.01689664088189602,
-0.05618445575237274,
0.796464204788208,
0.1292106807231903,
-0.6176393032073975,
0.2212287187576294,
-0.5251027941703796,
-0.08209254592657089,
0.039011452347040176,
-0.3408307135105133,
0.32477685809135437,
0.3268408179283142,
0.5326738953590393,
-0.5193291902542114,
-0.31421220302581787,
0.035773660987615585,
-0.500880241394043,
-0.1681370586156845,
0.31800293922424316,
-0.21385979652404785,
0.2969893515110016,
0.57355797290802,
-0.4358157217502594,
0.3018992841243744,
0.4074179232120514,
-0.23702380061149597,
0.528205931186676,
-0.5007415413856506,
0.39460164308547974,
-0.8927584886550903,
0.08577698469161987,
-0.1327829658985138,
-0.05910154804587364,
-0.4825991094112396,
0.25076547265052795,
0.15449877083301544,
0.23454280197620392,
-0.2871672511100769,
0.5325093865394592,
-0.432900607585907,
0.20546384155750275,
-0.338087260723114,
-0.007008698768913746,
-0.0756705105304718,
0.28748732805252075,
-0.494803249835968,
0.9002495408058167,
0.5551275610923767,
-0.626593828201294,
0.526461660861969,
0.10562138259410858,
-0.30609801411628723,
0.6273027658462524,
-0.6850564479827881,
0.2054087519645691,
-0.13446645438671112,
-0.10240499675273895,
-0.886569619178772,
-0.21637478470802307,
0.23719918727874756,
-0.2183123528957367,
0.4241352379322052,
0.10820652544498444,
-0.6926296353340149,
-0.24340946972370148,
-0.3122486174106598,
0.3613011837005615,
0.6060987114906311,
-0.23782780766487122,
0.20865559577941895,
0.32883259654045105,
-0.20172537863254547,
-0.23991061747074127,
-0.42562979459762573,
0.035168979316949844,
-0.43248045444488525,
-0.2804267108440399,
0.24505797028541565,
-0.22646920382976532,
-0.388407826423645,
-0.32755783200263977,
-0.22770003974437714,
-0.029132209718227386,
0.20278416574001312,
0.013414794579148293,
0.34870171546936035,
-0.4615371823310852,
0.14631424844264984,
0.37430986762046814,
-0.12470380961894989,
0.09124530851840973,
-0.09219132363796234,
0.609965443611145,
0.11768895387649536,
-0.3857697546482086,
-0.6717479228973389,
0.1815742403268814,
0.7763209342956543,
-0.5098097920417786,
0.6188215017318726,
0.22567494213581085,
-0.3879249393939972,
0.21854981780052185,
-0.6974735856056213,
-0.2688702940940857,
-0.4571859836578369,
0.6600323915481567,
-0.19805370271205902,
-0.8484203815460205,
0.3970460295677185,
-0.5558984279632568,
0.2294084131717682,
0.518454372882843,
0.842018187046051,
-0.23471599817276,
1.0105674266815186,
0.19545802474021912,
0.003525195410475135,
0.00032493998878635466,
-0.003363553434610367,
-0.20592758059501648,
-0.9858676195144653,
-0.45376208424568176,
-0.6294728517532349,
-0.35295218229293823,
-0.6009218692779541,
-0.7207658886909485,
0.528422474861145,
0.08407749235630035,
-0.4286114573478699,
-0.06385690718889236,
-0.48073235154151917,
0.29802843928337097,
0.4590770900249481,
0.3850253224372864,
0.424455463886261,
-0.09723809361457825,
-0.33754387497901917,
0.12460514158010483,
-0.5100792646408081,
-0.47059041261672974,
1.4826289415359497,
0.3922451138496399,
0.7344539165496826,
0.14872989058494568,
0.513611912727356,
-0.14514049887657166,
0.13894528150558472,
-0.960236132144928,
0.4627525508403778,
-0.5759841799736023,
-0.601483941078186,
-0.31355077028274536,
-0.38095375895500183,
-1.0345442295074463,
0.01893308386206627,
-0.4401167035102844,
-0.678686797618866,
-0.1130966916680336,
0.14866797626018524,
-0.4440652132034302,
0.28694382309913635,
-0.5647764801979065,
0.6394798159599304,
-0.32143011689186096,
-0.17376919090747833,
-0.5297357439994812,
-0.6939013004302979,
-0.0345214307308197,
-0.3470972776412964,
-0.011442748829722404,
-0.3942491114139557,
-0.6012001037597656,
0.6823304295539856,
-0.14355620741844177,
0.5880767107009888,
-0.17867235839366913,
-0.24242685735225677,
-0.18646013736724854,
-0.30514001846313477,
0.34339606761932373,
0.08938001096248627,
-0.5384620428085327,
0.04799468442797661,
0.2376895248889923,
-0.3826500475406647,
-0.5169743299484253,
0.570286750793457,
-0.7376824021339417,
-0.5980228781700134,
0.12503406405448914,
-0.6172972917556763,
-0.832955002784729,
0.38725829124450684,
0.2966543138027191,
0.6479225754737854,
-0.047636669129133224,
0.2370523065328598,
0.9616498947143555,
-0.4332008361816406,
0.07085447013378143,
0.8564079403877258,
0.02469583973288536,
-0.45207077264785767,
0.5704712867736816,
0.014652594923973083,
0.1946711242198944,
0.6042653918266296,
0.18893782794475555,
-0.41738975048065186,
-1.0741633176803589,
-0.48857948184013367,
0.6727665066719055,
-0.5189723968505859,
-0.28497517108917236,
-0.18966321647167206,
-0.1477222442626953,
-0.10587167739868164,
0.013582460582256317,
-0.4293811619281769,
-0.04532208293676376,
-0.5726209878921509,
0.032521527260541916,
0.44291821122169495,
0.6411259174346924,
0.27985143661499023,
0.2149873673915863,
-0.6714600324630737,
0.5555938482284546,
0.07159923762083054,
0.829068124294281,
-0.2670557200908661,
-0.539199709892273,
-0.09251333773136139,
0.025630181655287743,
-0.12932726740837097,
-0.8128564357757568,
-0.19595320522785187,
0.24740499258041382,
0.7851747274398804,
0.5978471636772156,
-0.06454287469387054,
0.7436931729316711,
-0.7190684676170349,
0.42679259181022644,
-0.028214609250426292,
-0.4123639166355133,
0.5180721879005432,
-0.19880691170692444,
0.21799416840076447,
0.7942527532577515,
0.23351703584194183,
-0.14824740588665009,
-0.1922207623720169,
-0.21997515857219696,
-0.768667995929718,
0.16293032467365265,
-0.09783554822206497,
-0.031492769718170166,
0.2924380898475647,
0.9441050291061401,
0.08934597671031952,
0.1440230756998062,
0.2619134783744812,
-0.559299111366272,
0.6452654600143433,
-0.6179872751235962,
-0.2567090690135956,
-0.3150905966758728,
-0.4189823865890503,
-0.46797358989715576,
0.3748546242713928,
-0.08295995742082596,
0.19094964861869812,
0.17895366251468658,
0.24608489871025085,
-0.018001418560743332,
0.24277500808238983,
0.8868005871772766,
0.9841353297233582,
-0.10566066205501556,
-0.07322145253419876,
0.40631943941116333,
-0.5542303919792175,
0.030620859935879707,
0.3324679136276245,
0.14175893366336823,
-0.19722792506217957,
0.12748397886753082,
0.8492703437805176,
0.27585306763648987,
-1.026950478553772,
0.23476335406303406,
-0.1295958012342453,
-0.3083212375640869,
0.1858128309249878,
0.45876821875572205,
0.29319193959236145,
0.44649985432624817,
0.06775403767824173,
0.041138287633657455,
0.3989294767379761,
-0.2495238333940506,
0.3117859661579132,
0.43373367190361023,
-0.3895871639251709,
0.11326708644628525,
0.815132737159729,
0.1754007339477539,
-0.24480824172496796,
0.44554856419563293,
0.2706190049648285,
0.1045902743935585,
0.676942765712738,
0.517102837562561,
0.27724775671958923,
-0.12697447836399078,
-0.18851859867572784,
0.222635880112648,
0.17683550715446472,
0.008422750048339367,
0.5250166058540344,
0.028311213478446007,
-0.49467670917510986,
-0.5003708600997925,
-0.5989653468132019,
-0.5700051188468933,
0.07260718196630478,
-0.8346254825592041,
0.13423046469688416,
-0.39075472950935364,
-0.26286059617996216,
0.1380806863307953,
0.33563432097435,
-0.6200212836265564,
0.5271270275115967,
0.10350139439105988,
1.3160992860794067,
-0.10387185961008072,
0.7322299480438232,
1.0510823726654053,
0.1240009143948555,
-0.9729164242744446,
-0.030653303489089012,
0.046394020318984985,
-1.2536109685897827,
-0.11859460175037384,
-0.21321317553520203,
-0.0351242832839489,
0.12731286883354187,
-0.4310658276081085,
-0.7086676955223083,
1.2148618698120117,
0.5509895086288452,
-0.9299294948577881,
0.024831149727106094,
0.19217337667942047,
0.6590509414672852,
0.010763921774923801,
-0.06601592898368835,
0.945030689239502,
0.4113677442073822,
-0.01120174489915371,
-1.3259646892547607,
0.14495719969272614,
-0.10253536701202393,
-0.19161099195480347,
0.24238966405391693,
-0.7264125943183899,
0.28785666823387146,
-0.4605671763420105,
0.10007928311824799,
0.5361558794975281,
0.22530312836170197,
0.6775280833244324,
0.5036168694496155,
0.3333100378513336,
0.5560186505317688,
1.0612064599990845,
-0.10334179550409317,
0.85532146692276,
-0.6481854319572449,
0.2092859447002411,
0.608665406703949,
-0.14697550237178802,
0.8764613270759583,
0.5968693494796753,
-0.4235829710960388,
-0.0010621348628774285,
0.672804057598114,
-0.012674864381551743,
0.6511638760566711,
0.4550907015800476,
-0.22916440665721893,
-0.08585017919540405,
0.06880027800798416,
-0.35327544808387756,
0.49300119280815125,
0.5149151086807251,
-0.47873279452323914,
0.01652863249182701,
-0.07370471954345703,
0.3827246427536011,
-0.13054947555065155,
-0.5413685441017151,
1.1686344146728516,
0.2357463240623474,
-0.7721670269966125,
0.6443153023719788,
0.21707528829574585,
0.51631098985672,
-0.4791683256626129,
0.1303716003894806,
-0.2605672776699066,
0.2622365653514862,
-0.14554105699062347,
-0.6467253565788269,
0.15418988466262817,
0.12614311277866364,
-0.14565977454185486,
0.3160281181335449,
0.5809022188186646,
-0.2440294772386551,
-0.25366565585136414,
0.17742691934108734,
0.38121679425239563,
0.2161521315574646,
0.03455732390284538,
-0.688143253326416,
0.001072571612894535,
0.031710900366306305,
-0.09423265606164932,
0.23286005854606628,
0.2563472390174866,
0.24881576001644135,
0.8033916354179382,
0.511698842048645,
0.4868326485157013,
-0.015903525054454803,
0.10982377082109451,
0.8821510672569275,
-0.5696053504943848,
-0.05988628417253494,
-1.0214266777038574,
0.2248062640428543,
0.04784270003437996,
-0.4427590072154999,
0.39075809717178345,
0.6500957608222961,
0.454916387796402,
0.06582903116941452,
0.5079115033149719,
0.4352952241897583,
0.7361127734184265,
-0.6382600665092468,
0.8064439296722412,
-0.8613426089286804,
0.3121255338191986,
0.08005497604608536,
-0.47447362542152405,
-0.48497629165649414,
0.24194160103797913,
-0.06896115094423294,
0.006611399818211794,
0.35226133465766907,
0.8565526008605957,
0.27802273631095886,
-0.08968466520309448,
0.3465504050254822,
0.3134247362613678,
0.1261671781539917,
0.5628125667572021,
0.49558350443840027,
-0.24011774361133575,
0.3238104283809662,
-0.16143397986888885,
-0.3905787765979767,
-0.31269046664237976,
-0.4054509997367859,
-0.7846222519874573,
-0.10580676794052124,
-0.13774892687797546,
-0.017605643719434738,
0.2977987825870514,
0.7438910007476807,
0.663814902305603,
-0.8008707165718079,
0.01621287316083908,
0.14136174321174622,
-0.20644226670265198,
-0.03013557940721512,
-0.07499894499778748,
0.3815791606903076,
-0.2998526394367218,
-0.6834828853607178,
0.5496818423271179,
0.43756264448165894,
-0.17873366177082062,
-0.07277718931436539,
-0.13681098818778992,
0.2380637228488922,
0.4685174524784088,
0.48562195897102356,
0.09145314246416092,
-0.740955114364624,
0.013958332128822803,
0.2897031009197235,
-0.3912747800350189,
0.20162862539291382,
0.5064428448677063,
-0.3156943619251251,
0.4899370074272156,
0.3710031807422638,
0.748923659324646,
0.18801528215408325,
0.15736152231693268,
0.6030438542366028,
-0.17957261204719543,
-0.21674875915050507,
0.2526038885116577,
0.41314318776130676,
0.11318328231573105,
-0.22489672899246216,
0.5403118133544922,
-0.1294291466474533,
-0.8661676049232483,
-0.6375125050544739,
0.04182847961783409,
-1.0385384559631348,
-0.41511163115501404,
1.3176236152648926,
0.1032978892326355,
0.18737955391407013,
-0.09918835014104843,
-0.5763881206512451,
0.5414367914199829,
-0.019390853121876717,
0.6336239576339722,
0.2003389596939087,
-0.5595203638076782,
0.038548581302165985,
-0.8326472640037537,
0.5947499871253967,
0.5198156833648682,
-1.0076947212219238,
-0.4279065728187561,
0.3185834586620331,
0.5566848516464233,
-0.22599254548549652,
0.6118946671485901,
-0.3438696265220642,
0.31583404541015625,
-0.535381555557251,
-0.43691369891166687,
-0.04989831522107124,
-0.05862859636545181,
-0.26109516620635986,
0.07131645083427429,
0.3017878234386444,
-0.44522276520729065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14777v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14777v1
|
CT-Agent: Clinical Trial Multi-Agent with Large Language Model-based Reasoning
| 2024-04-23T06:30:53 | 2024-04-23T06:30:53 |
Ling Yue, Tianfan Fu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) and multi-agent systems have shown impressive
capabilities in natural language tasks but face challenges in clinical trial
applications, primarily due to limited access to external knowledge.
Recognizing the potential of advanced clinical trial tools that aggregate and
predict based on the latest medical data, we propose an integrated solution to
enhance their accessibility and utility. We introduce Clinical Agent System
(CT-Agent), a Clinical multi-agent system designed for clinical trial tasks,
leveraging GPT-4, multi-agent architectures, LEAST-TO-MOST, and ReAct reasoning
technology. This integration not only boosts LLM performance in clinical
contexts but also introduces novel functionalities. Our system autonomously
manages the entire clinical trial process, demonstrating significant efficiency
improvements in our evaluations, which include both computational benchmarks
and expert feedback.
|
[
-0.04518735781311989,
-0.7423776984214783,
1.1023197174072266,
0.11418569087982178,
-0.28580719232559204,
0.2769845724105835,
-0.19129273295402527,
-0.533708393573761,
0.19161544740200043,
0.5467895865440369,
-0.19862721860408783,
-0.7076162695884705,
-0.7515602111816406,
0.24306002259254456,
-0.12136129289865494,
0.6557218432426453,
-0.0033423155546188354,
0.6589316129684448,
-0.2909650504589081,
-0.5062646269798279,
-0.48398199677467346,
-0.825775146484375,
-0.7403616309165955,
-0.7044290900230408,
0.8079940676689148,
0.24354097247123718,
0.7836787104606628,
0.40442854166030884,
0.8249327540397644,
0.4468997120857239,
0.33616364002227783,
0.22838194668293,
-0.13947977125644684,
0.3024970591068268,
-0.28933122754096985,
-0.5887517929077148,
-0.984433114528656,
-0.1719171404838562,
0.032240092754364014,
0.3504723012447357,
-0.24407236278057098,
-0.48594045639038086,
-0.46443331241607666,
0.12697061896324158,
-0.6167420744895935,
0.2699967920780182,
-0.2659558951854706,
-0.12234107404947281,
0.11846823990345001,
-0.330674409866333,
-0.6229676008224487,
-0.3883264362812042,
0.2704121470451355,
-0.798104465007782,
0.07723566144704819,
-0.2850082814693451,
0.31817206740379333,
0.17346636950969696,
-0.8084028363227844,
-0.34337863326072693,
-0.42218154668807983,
0.5013718605041504,
-0.6644496321678162,
0.09183154255151749,
0.12916062772274017,
0.7118195295333862,
-0.31797781586647034,
-0.9555402398109436,
-0.3876717984676361,
-0.7054250836372375,
-0.07526605576276779,
0.26545479893684387,
-0.08538639545440674,
0.460428386926651,
-0.11598256975412369,
-0.06753078103065491,
-0.710838794708252,
0.187761127948761,
0.06793875247240067,
-0.3373827636241913,
0.6764336824417114,
0.3805045485496521,
0.5436107516288757,
0.37398549914360046,
-0.3304506242275238,
0.03401448577642441,
-0.5640996098518372,
-0.4247874617576599,
-0.4483729302883148,
0.6115586161613464,
0.05019276589155197,
0.7583481669425964,
-0.22714118659496307,
0.28649190068244934,
-0.2834586203098297,
-0.13927683234214783,
0.38763564825057983,
-0.34820306301116943,
-0.4566050171852112,
0.14212942123413086,
0.7885310053825378,
0.27914321422576904,
-0.01169994194060564,
-0.10230147838592529,
-0.1987750381231308,
0.4265715479850769,
0.2233712077140808,
-0.6386053562164307,
0.01173759251832962,
0.5391272306442261,
-0.2770878076553345,
-0.2636539340019226,
-0.38316354155540466,
-0.3660740256309509,
-0.7890470623970032,
-0.2793102264404297,
0.5821332335472107,
-0.6475560665130615,
-0.36560434103012085,
0.4340748190879822,
-0.42537614703178406,
0.13768017292022705,
0.8900694847106934,
-0.18887721002101898,
0.3706798553466797,
0.46283188462257385,
0.7591467499732971,
-0.31699490547180176,
-0.2265193909406662,
-0.7736093401908875,
0.2138577401638031,
-0.3475683331489563,
1.0135738849639893,
-0.6420056819915771,
-0.4549899399280548,
0.19483669102191925,
0.0846266895532608,
-0.23694050312042236,
-0.3788352906703949,
0.5264074802398682,
-0.6151062250137329,
0.1600358933210373,
-0.21739880740642548,
-0.6120149493217468,
0.06880728155374527,
0.4625071585178375,
-0.5935095548629761,
0.5695440173149109,
-0.045989759266376495,
-0.2320905178785324,
0.37395885586738586,
-0.9494210481643677,
-0.4019818603992462,
0.5977771878242493,
-0.33487242460250854,
-0.11320033669471741,
0.16784904897212982,
0.27610108256340027,
0.2409270703792572,
-0.4074269235134125,
0.30110618472099304,
-0.5796536207199097,
-0.16725671291351318,
0.32223230600357056,
-0.0018460163846611977,
0.5108960270881653,
0.5533084273338318,
-0.26028016209602356,
0.4423329532146454,
-0.6088414192199707,
0.00012886393233202398,
0.35691317915916443,
-0.27203336358070374,
-0.1759900003671646,
-0.3319644629955292,
0.1837235391139984,
0.11917176097631454,
0.2864273488521576,
-0.508591890335083,
0.5201528072357178,
-0.19423021376132965,
0.42813539505004883,
0.5092219710350037,
-0.1397923082113266,
0.31098172068595886,
-0.41224828362464905,
0.7892416715621948,
-0.05055631324648857,
0.3280607759952545,
-0.025072412565350533,
-0.46291977167129517,
-0.4073849022388458,
-0.4994800388813019,
0.024045223370194435,
0.5336819887161255,
-0.9503752589225769,
0.13615918159484863,
-0.21257919073104858,
-0.3748631775379181,
-0.07873842865228653,
-0.4248228967189789,
0.18694768846035004,
0.12509194016456604,
0.3839699625968933,
-0.08836892247200012,
-0.04521990194916725,
-0.810453474521637,
-0.08202458918094635,
-0.017575321719050407,
0.29039475321769714,
0.06601317971944809,
0.7309514284133911,
-0.4267129898071289,
0.6094133853912354,
-0.5711076855659485,
-0.5391842722892761,
-0.7569909691810608,
0.013870595023036003,
0.14609801769256592,
0.1530182957649231,
0.35169458389282227,
-0.642385721206665,
-0.3953530192375183,
0.39906322956085205,
-0.8595781922340393,
-0.2659357488155365,
-0.12873433530330658,
0.08557020872831345,
0.03999766334891319,
0.5523616075515747,
-0.9023536443710327,
0.513576865196228,
0.32201090455055237,
-0.5107695460319519,
0.5458813905715942,
-0.8126762509346008,
0.2396378070116043,
-0.785236656665802,
0.10263624042272568,
-0.1691788136959076,
-0.3902483284473419,
-0.7864322066307068,
0.11846761405467987,
0.020297957584261894,
0.06523223221302032,
-0.4494468867778778,
0.743877649307251,
-0.3992581367492676,
0.03848321735858917,
-0.6830088496208191,
0.17698511481285095,
0.09425634145736694,
0.25518232583999634,
0.17472729086875916,
0.8026478886604309,
0.46639806032180786,
-0.395410418510437,
0.4692799746990204,
0.3798978626728058,
0.054923880845308304,
0.5305532813072205,
-0.6342909336090088,
0.15078699588775635,
0.018822064623236656,
0.39612168073654175,
-0.6856078505516052,
-0.4306941330432892,
0.07648859173059464,
-0.48253652453422546,
0.09800561517477036,
0.106971375644207,
-0.6721644997596741,
-0.23984961211681366,
-0.039531003683805466,
0.38558492064476013,
0.12754090130329132,
-0.06342630833387375,
0.9324007034301758,
0.3466229736804962,
-0.3059026896953583,
-0.40915364027023315,
-0.6964210867881775,
0.4726840853691101,
0.024167055264115334,
-0.46484455466270447,
0.13385175168514252,
-0.024828147143125534,
-0.18570269644260406,
-0.04772372171282768,
0.2864420413970947,
-0.4255630373954773,
-0.26624369621276855,
-0.011016053147614002,
0.13926540315151215,
-0.20555102825164795,
0.6916629672050476,
0.17944444715976715,
-0.09861212223768234,
-0.028159456327557564,
-0.11504102498292923,
0.3017934262752533,
-0.07885178923606873,
-0.6807434558868408,
-0.33310332894325256,
0.685380220413208,
0.9953792691230774,
-0.21615631878376007,
0.44307366013526917,
0.11208390444517136,
-0.35938531160354614,
-0.222944438457489,
-0.49934062361717224,
-0.11657552421092987,
-0.43098554015159607,
0.522774338722229,
-0.4805397093296051,
-0.7460601329803467,
0.4699036777019501,
-0.25947317481040955,
-0.13698118925094604,
0.18731026351451874,
1.098441481590271,
0.3155995309352875,
1.2464500665664673,
0.20849691331386566,
0.3275739252567291,
0.2458156794309616,
0.04663265123963356,
-0.09300827980041504,
-0.4639700949192047,
-0.20133334398269653,
-0.4173104166984558,
-0.032013941556215286,
-0.13288481533527374,
-0.5684857368469238,
0.7716788053512573,
-0.5839883685112,
-0.47500717639923096,
0.02703714184463024,
-0.5999297499656677,
0.24719995260238647,
0.5789889097213745,
0.37103357911109924,
0.7511433362960815,
-0.5286998152732849,
-0.44170376658439636,
0.3790563642978668,
-0.6493856906890869,
-0.4513227641582489,
1.4027622938156128,
0.10832300782203674,
0.5511288046836853,
0.18528835475444794,
0.46584078669548035,
0.5699912905693054,
0.5659960508346558,
-0.7559857964515686,
0.516997754573822,
0.08160053193569183,
-0.8761646747589111,
-0.1415226012468338,
-0.002647643443197012,
-1.1476821899414062,
0.582421600818634,
-0.17712773382663727,
-0.4920041561126709,
0.07180855423212051,
-0.1732626110315323,
-0.5332543253898621,
-0.0901370719075203,
-0.892447829246521,
0.6804831624031067,
-0.39742887020111084,
-0.32024964690208435,
-0.40926456451416016,
-0.6436848640441895,
0.14129498600959778,
-0.07772552222013474,
0.19942933320999146,
-0.0887470692396164,
-0.21007321774959564,
0.1497267484664917,
-0.836554765701294,
0.6707866787910461,
-0.13716869056224823,
0.06929918378591537,
0.34304964542388916,
-0.10821828991174698,
0.7559834718704224,
-0.004046967718750238,
0.12307927757501602,
-0.26100924611091614,
0.22176827490329742,
-0.44740915298461914,
-0.7022102475166321,
0.5488972663879395,
-0.759040117263794,
-0.42020323872566223,
-0.7789927124977112,
-0.6260780692100525,
-0.39098191261291504,
0.4996553957462311,
-0.0919056162238121,
0.5650032758712769,
-0.290314644575119,
-0.12070406973361969,
0.2657586336135864,
-0.5384945869445801,
0.018092606216669083,
0.8213950395584106,
-0.16535229980945587,
-0.6697168946266174,
0.43063196539878845,
-0.18901264667510986,
0.48751744627952576,
0.4732012450695038,
0.2375108003616333,
-0.6611270308494568,
-1.0873130559921265,
0.002883210312575102,
0.4290391802787781,
-0.9727689027786255,
-0.015124792233109474,
-0.6730955243110657,
0.05250588059425354,
-0.5966949462890625,
-0.28280773758888245,
-0.3814740478992462,
-0.09637205302715302,
0.1077619269490242,
-0.00519135594367981,
0.17301741242408752,
0.7613825798034668,
0.23377059400081635,
0.7635604739189148,
-0.8971108794212341,
0.29112985730171204,
0.09960168600082397,
0.23134492337703705,
-0.37720784544944763,
-0.11139053851366043,
-0.28296419978141785,
-0.20174840092658997,
-0.31273433566093445,
-0.8555299639701843,
0.4706665277481079,
-0.10527867078781128,
0.6974378824234009,
0.3345926105976105,
-0.023351656273007393,
0.24297980964183807,
-0.3026075065135956,
0.5616225600242615,
0.23940014839172363,
-0.6526339650154114,
0.4388468861579895,
-0.7853546142578125,
0.352883517742157,
0.5865642428398132,
-0.10863149911165237,
-0.30240505933761597,
-0.6118115186691284,
-0.3890805244445801,
-0.4699643552303314,
0.7623807191848755,
0.3213092088699341,
-0.4020872712135315,
0.1570609211921692,
0.14956627786159515,
0.10962029546499252,
0.18386830389499664,
-0.539379894733429,
0.05051441863179207,
0.06785453855991364,
-0.42991822957992554,
-0.09465985000133514,
0.18466870486736298,
-0.43776240944862366,
-0.12805581092834473,
0.4559105336666107,
-0.6456320285797119,
0.4460314214229584,
0.5806856155395508,
-0.31184983253479004,
0.0964716300368309,
0.42961904406547546,
0.7044161558151245,
0.7945451736450195,
-0.27191296219825745,
-0.022337965667247772,
0.16862095892429352,
-0.7110142707824707,
0.2339460402727127,
0.2258192002773285,
0.4059414565563202,
-0.30698123574256897,
0.7288296222686768,
0.4674377143383026,
-0.0913814827799797,
-1.0013456344604492,
0.5714530348777771,
-0.430424302816391,
-0.38368070125579834,
-0.29128381609916687,
-0.023073775693774223,
0.1338624805212021,
0.5854986906051636,
0.1969529688358307,
-0.07978903502225876,
0.3461155593395233,
-0.37720397114753723,
0.3654818832874298,
0.38899102807044983,
-0.4043547511100769,
-0.14359547197818756,
0.6725988388061523,
0.26786819100379944,
-0.0786994993686676,
0.2581072449684143,
0.13634921610355377,
-0.2904132902622223,
0.9927253723144531,
0.4615423083305359,
1.0076169967651367,
-0.1333228349685669,
0.39517900347709656,
-0.07355323433876038,
0.23443259298801422,
-0.1292875111103058,
0.3989228308200836,
0.4222196936607361,
-0.7722179889678955,
-0.5504844784736633,
0.02767113596200943,
-0.7140784859657288,
0.08226121217012405,
-0.1633031964302063,
0.5624996423721313,
-0.22408165037631989,
-0.4386996030807495,
0.1804012656211853,
0.00006729397136950865,
-0.6189870834350586,
0.21480858325958252,
0.2081131488084793,
1.010911226272583,
-0.5165554881095886,
1.149276852607727,
1.0000537633895874,
-0.4839261472225189,
-0.5786191821098328,
-0.606575608253479,
0.1776476949453354,
-0.9005377292633057,
0.5063667297363281,
0.07557202130556107,
-0.10824885219335556,
-0.26571038365364075,
-0.34386342763900757,
-0.5734953880310059,
1.2435548305511475,
0.47575318813323975,
-0.3078095614910126,
-0.025519797578454018,
0.4069424867630005,
0.880585789680481,
-0.7369847297668457,
0.8151113390922546,
0.6025614738464355,
0.642874002456665,
0.5660298466682434,
-0.927405834197998,
0.12160185724496841,
-0.19990043342113495,
-0.46304258704185486,
0.007577020674943924,
-0.6083022356033325,
0.6683469414710999,
-0.4152667820453644,
-0.030982814729213715,
0.17460966110229492,
0.2104211002588272,
0.4280882775783539,
0.7456746101379395,
0.38037237524986267,
0.44234374165534973,
0.7123284935951233,
-0.06323139369487762,
1.078279733657837,
-0.2551622986793518,
0.3425789475440979,
1.1153302192687988,
-0.7716083526611328,
0.23613597452640533,
0.047711461782455444,
-0.1603931486606598,
0.23751254379749298,
0.2984648644924164,
0.2873769700527191,
0.42528805136680603,
-0.031925421208143234,
-0.58253014087677,
-0.588856041431427,
-0.2467074990272522,
-0.25783321261405945,
0.42039018869400024,
0.5203034281730652,
-0.2368745654821396,
-0.3785569667816162,
0.12758797407150269,
-0.09038067609071732,
-0.07615203410387039,
0.01692093349993229,
0.843196451663971,
0.16152119636535645,
-0.6391738057136536,
0.2412363886833191,
-0.3613669276237488,
-0.029759347438812256,
-0.9971115589141846,
-0.0828535184264183,
-0.08242074400186539,
0.5941948890686035,
0.0935477688908577,
-0.3998987078666687,
-0.045198168605566025,
-0.41825398802757263,
0.36976635456085205,
0.0454031303524971,
0.7536802887916565,
-0.2774103581905365,
-0.3258650302886963,
0.5205736756324768,
0.8628050684928894,
-0.12692275643348694,
-0.27014991641044617,
-0.8139153122901917,
0.1318034827709198,
-0.4362395107746124,
-0.29782384634017944,
0.32783374190330505,
0.729729175567627,
-0.1646622270345688,
0.9916563630104065,
0.5828189253807068,
0.38699594140052795,
-0.08618824183940887,
0.2745921313762665,
0.9345767498016357,
-0.8710960745811462,
-0.5587123036384583,
-0.7689154744148254,
0.24598723649978638,
-0.20107267796993256,
-0.19740039110183716,
0.28822630643844604,
0.5154375433921814,
-0.2486245036125183,
0.19636613130569458,
1.180580735206604,
0.23634661734104156,
0.31926605105400085,
-0.1323961317539215,
0.5568687319755554,
-0.7000042796134949,
0.07876269519329071,
-0.030562512576580048,
-0.35888025164604187,
-0.5945120453834534,
-0.014387957751750946,
-0.23570063710212708,
0.08003079146146774,
1.184533715248108,
0.603643536567688,
0.318059504032135,
0.1536427140235901,
0.4639163017272949,
0.25670239329338074,
1.0364694595336914,
0.920161247253418,
0.7837889790534973,
-0.18130549788475037,
0.31963247060775757,
0.27035588026046753,
-0.6047584414482117,
-0.3793473243713379,
-0.6513153314590454,
-0.9542433023452759,
-0.3303288221359253,
-0.1668255478143692,
-0.15166053175926208,
0.19015611708164215,
1.2264610528945923,
0.5804252028465271,
-0.6530336141586304,
-0.04586281254887581,
-0.09690502285957336,
0.03955572843551636,
-0.3317693769931793,
-0.14782533049583435,
0.5530234575271606,
-0.6024742126464844,
-0.7727227807044983,
0.5084198713302612,
0.539111316204071,
-0.07086550444364548,
-0.05564197152853012,
-0.25452810525894165,
-0.3288913369178772,
0.28191325068473816,
0.7101907134056091,
0.06031596660614014,
-0.5290830135345459,
-0.028419755399227142,
0.04711694270372391,
-0.4213542342185974,
0.1431235522031784,
0.9149948954582214,
-0.8528910279273987,
0.8017845749855042,
0.41510456800460815,
0.7009691596031189,
0.3355637490749359,
-0.12541116774082184,
0.8597947955131531,
0.12988770008087158,
0.19064195454120636,
0.5933616757392883,
0.37663593888282776,
-0.2009742259979248,
-0.3734917640686035,
0.484614759683609,
0.27956506609916687,
-0.7544921636581421,
-0.6247362494468689,
0.08654418587684631,
-1.2246067523956299,
-0.49598467350006104,
1.0881811380386353,
-0.00396664859727025,
0.07660175114870071,
-0.6436811685562134,
-0.3493444323539734,
0.3136114776134491,
-0.5887870788574219,
0.5639779567718506,
0.7086601853370667,
-0.4844675660133362,
-0.020299192517995834,
-0.750431478023529,
0.3259550631046295,
0.1894657015800476,
-1.2507197856903076,
-0.09652451425790787,
0.64132159948349,
0.04698650538921356,
0.01596621423959732,
1.284911870956421,
-0.22077201306819916,
0.31001508235931396,
-0.12469162791967392,
0.22578206658363342,
-0.22901618480682373,
-0.2187623232603073,
-0.25159358978271484,
0.3132188022136688,
0.04299144446849823,
-0.13603176176548004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14772v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14772v1
|
Simulating Task-Oriented Dialogues with State Transition Graphs and Large Language Models
| 2024-04-23T06:23:34 | 2024-04-23T06:23:34 |
Chris Samarinas, Pracha Promthaw, Atharva Nijasure, Hansi Zeng, Julian Killingback, Hamed Zamani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper explores SynTOD, a new synthetic data generation approach for
developing end-to-end Task-Oriented Dialogue (TOD) Systems capable of handling
complex tasks such as intent classification, slot filling, conversational
question-answering, and retrieval-augmented response generation, without
relying on crowdsourcing or real-world data. SynTOD utilizes a state transition
graph to define the desired behavior of a TOD system and generates diverse,
structured conversations through random walks and response simulation using
large language models (LLMs). In our experiments, using graph-guided response
simulations leads to significant improvements in intent classification, slot
filling and response relevance compared to naive single-prompt simulated
conversations. We also investigate the end-to-end TOD effectiveness of
different base and instruction-tuned LLMs, with and without the constructed
synthetic conversations. Finally, we explore how various LLMs can evaluate
responses in a TOD system and how well they are correlated with human
judgments. Our findings pave the path towards quick development and evaluation
of domain-specific TOD systems. We release our datasets, models, and code for
research purposes.
|
[
-0.42800790071487427,
-1.2583369016647339,
0.6177664399147034,
-0.0824349895119667,
-0.3196162283420563,
0.3957659602165222,
-0.27903857827186584,
-0.3707972764968872,
0.2948504686355591,
0.6522882580757141,
-0.7726011276245117,
-0.5278699398040771,
-0.19992642104625702,
0.11213609576225281,
-0.45632144808769226,
0.9002042412757874,
0.16419415175914764,
0.11146223545074463,
-0.3442882299423218,
0.20152601599693298,
-0.2788779139518738,
-0.7233728766441345,
-0.839460015296936,
-0.11799605190753937,
0.24804465472698212,
0.1871703565120697,
0.3453945219516754,
0.02068893425166607,
0.009554813615977764,
0.37972456216812134,
0.15567734837532043,
0.28784582018852234,
-0.5024338364601135,
0.5621411204338074,
-0.24706487357616425,
-0.4006863832473755,
-0.43748706579208374,
-0.1857580989599228,
0.1833631992340088,
0.7199253439903259,
-0.15673865377902985,
0.1225820928812027,
0.07578007131814957,
0.1185457706451416,
-0.27663663029670715,
0.4458361268043518,
-0.3531910181045532,
-0.0781012549996376,
-0.06346414983272552,
-0.26624876260757446,
-0.6602153182029724,
-0.1606687605381012,
0.3385312259197235,
-0.5890824198722839,
-0.0012688603019341826,
0.07270276546478271,
0.3594318628311157,
0.14371004700660706,
-0.5346068143844604,
-0.264519065618515,
-0.9474955201148987,
0.5206202864646912,
-0.8050761818885803,
0.29744213819503784,
0.02203543297946453,
0.3945464789867401,
-0.6864745020866394,
-0.8298865556716919,
-0.9655260443687439,
-0.06642013788223267,
0.20209044218063354,
0.19256354868412018,
0.07536479085683823,
0.4933982193470001,
0.2763858139514923,
0.09336908906698227,
-0.45455846190452576,
-0.2705044150352478,
-0.03291445970535278,
-0.06763231009244919,
0.45597344636917114,
0.5930593013763428,
0.33922532200813293,
-0.34782370924949646,
-0.12715493142604828,
-0.27765780687332153,
-0.36778202652931213,
0.1305854171514511,
0.33660510182380676,
0.5009836554527283,
-0.0418880395591259,
0.6623334288597107,
-0.36093631386756897,
1.0173075199127197,
0.053612031042575836,
-0.19183684885501862,
0.013252458535134792,
-0.4486948549747467,
-0.4625672996044159,
-0.16637669503688812,
0.9149048328399658,
0.6043861508369446,
0.3645341992378235,
-0.2051975429058075,
-0.08831153064966202,
0.1894078552722931,
0.28666144609451294,
-0.6493117213249207,
0.05283663421869278,
0.38878026604652405,
-0.2739657759666443,
-0.13495993614196777,
-0.46957066655158997,
-0.5855833888053894,
-0.06994451582431793,
-0.5300571918487549,
0.1658845841884613,
-0.40502849221229553,
-0.1606614738702774,
0.19318579137325287,
-0.14616726338863373,
-0.04949233680963516,
0.6635814905166626,
-0.45730486512184143,
0.8197507262229919,
0.5502538084983826,
0.6558878421783447,
-0.47238242626190186,
0.04189655929803848,
-0.3430272340774536,
0.1852485090494156,
-0.32943814992904663,
0.5899592638015747,
-0.5960994958877563,
-0.7110081315040588,
-0.04376295953989029,
0.005469469353556633,
-0.0770895928144455,
-0.4518774151802063,
0.3124832808971405,
-0.4192521870136261,
0.3340332806110382,
0.13594116270542145,
-0.42451775074005127,
0.002695090137422085,
0.5669377446174622,
-0.49348095059394836,
0.816358745098114,
0.3755335211753845,
-0.6997259259223938,
-0.014807436615228653,
-0.7621793150901794,
-0.5403867959976196,
-0.080064557492733,
-0.22975362837314606,
0.003958803601562977,
-0.01325276866555214,
-0.1699860692024231,
0.26305752992630005,
-0.6890174746513367,
0.5162654519081116,
-0.15969444811344147,
-0.05082687363028526,
0.2872391641139984,
-0.2239202857017517,
0.5216290354728699,
0.4268166422843933,
-0.25290966033935547,
0.361913800239563,
-0.5520505905151367,
0.432864248752594,
0.05599359795451164,
-0.027860049158334732,
-0.3539421260356903,
0.06881430000066757,
0.17263664305210114,
0.3131985366344452,
0.01770097389817238,
-1.0392038822174072,
0.25193852186203003,
-0.37400850653648376,
0.3038056194782257,
0.6498583555221558,
0.18921323120594025,
0.19976936280727386,
-0.2304849773645401,
0.7538132071495056,
0.15774601697921753,
0.1839083582162857,
-0.22948452830314636,
-0.7974207997322083,
-0.563919723033905,
0.21527732908725739,
0.12300784140825272,
0.49123865365982056,
-1.0666463375091553,
0.28588348627090454,
-0.2589467465877533,
-0.2168312817811966,
-0.153966024518013,
-0.3298998475074768,
0.4434329867362976,
0.5566055774688721,
-0.027295684441924095,
-0.46956291794776917,
-0.46705055236816406,
-0.6988609433174133,
0.004010175354778767,
-0.3862653970718384,
0.14192040264606476,
0.4251488745212555,
0.1682480126619339,
0.09349256008863449,
1.3101885318756104,
-0.5083510875701904,
0.14937163889408112,
-0.5781651139259338,
-0.06131061166524887,
0.014741478487849236,
0.22490492463111877,
0.1450406014919281,
-0.5831015110015869,
-0.5346927046775818,
-0.059735774993896484,
-0.4050653576850891,
0.04967854171991348,
-0.14552275836467743,
-0.1750183254480362,
0.14872044324874878,
0.3291706442832947,
-0.892501175403595,
0.41225144267082214,
0.5306428074836731,
-0.22265121340751648,
0.6380631923675537,
0.01410023495554924,
0.215550497174263,
-1.5316599607467651,
0.1322842389345169,
-0.10385413467884064,
-0.41268810629844666,
-0.8461851477622986,
-0.0919480249285698,
-0.4203377962112427,
-0.6327549815177917,
-0.3232909142971039,
0.7131909132003784,
-0.2383769005537033,
-0.41708800196647644,
-0.23316094279289246,
0.1094718873500824,
-0.24153102934360504,
0.7782583832740784,
0.09310126304626465,
0.8617158532142639,
0.28356125950813293,
-0.6032732725143433,
0.4158865809440613,
0.37778452038764954,
-0.4314459264278412,
0.3852984607219696,
-0.7487245202064514,
0.32351166009902954,
-0.005702071823179722,
0.7847679257392883,
-1.042008876800537,
-0.33148330450057983,
0.2962580919265747,
-0.37168359756469727,
0.06986202299594879,
-0.31359100341796875,
-0.696778416633606,
-0.4485919773578644,
0.04504849761724472,
0.5387769937515259,
0.5951444506645203,
-0.1438927948474884,
0.5541566610336304,
0.5592073202133179,
-0.5420472621917725,
-0.1684541553258896,
-0.1641877442598343,
0.20125025510787964,
0.06771978735923767,
-0.6157336831092834,
0.19035689532756805,
-0.1536409854888916,
-0.196971133351326,
-0.20844005048274994,
-0.049950309097766876,
0.04888497665524483,
-0.05605431646108627,
0.3090328574180603,
0.08489231765270233,
0.17591409385204315,
-0.007477088365703821,
0.18526309728622437,
0.022806338965892792,
0.21865135431289673,
-0.4832504391670227,
1.144671082496643,
0.2984115481376648,
-0.6226779818534851,
-0.47793298959732056,
0.3477552533149719,
0.7306295037269592,
-0.10431942343711853,
0.1154690757393837,
0.1869295984506607,
-0.2710862457752228,
-0.4276482164859772,
-0.15022830665111542,
-0.3776853382587433,
-0.4923744201660156,
0.3055286705493927,
-0.5361106991767883,
-0.795886754989624,
0.47408950328826904,
-0.4232497215270996,
0.29260486364364624,
-0.09266555309295654,
0.662850558757782,
-0.024495895951986313,
1.2145555019378662,
0.3482755124568939,
0.421072781085968,
0.531006395816803,
-0.38577035069465637,
0.4519302546977997,
-1.0298274755477905,
-0.44709232449531555,
-0.28688323497772217,
-0.5580685138702393,
-0.4288402497768402,
-0.8475810885429382,
0.6542593836784363,
-0.1695690155029297,
-0.004959408659487963,
0.32588624954223633,
-0.365781307220459,
0.12521180510520935,
0.520557165145874,
-0.02187194675207138,
0.21482492983341217,
-0.08759300410747528,
-0.2585521340370178,
0.01678444631397724,
-0.6495341658592224,
-0.37291303277015686,
1.213387131690979,
-0.040896955877542496,
0.8989925384521484,
-0.11608806997537613,
0.7747153043746948,
0.28861933946609497,
0.20706148445606232,
-0.7817785739898682,
1.0789982080459595,
0.07820574194192886,
-0.36317893862724304,
-0.513298749923706,
-0.2931259870529175,
-0.9528301954269409,
0.059323422610759735,
0.13124948740005493,
-0.8525536060333252,
-0.01078561320900917,
0.0055834632366895676,
-0.15410098433494568,
0.2585288882255554,
-0.8518825769424438,
0.6822223663330078,
0.04194299504160881,
-0.2079038769006729,
-0.2187945395708084,
-0.5743168592453003,
0.305016428232193,
0.1653638631105423,
-0.026623524725437164,
-0.15407127141952515,
0.33858102560043335,
0.7047466039657593,
-0.7601715326309204,
1.0746724605560303,
-0.33490127325057983,
-0.23215866088867188,
0.6772715449333191,
0.31236839294433594,
0.666159987449646,
0.05566801875829697,
0.04273403808474541,
-0.4903046786785126,
-0.030970919877290726,
-0.17388133704662323,
-0.9434674978256226,
0.6998609900474548,
-0.512333333492279,
-0.8742955923080444,
-0.030509574338793755,
-0.9000459313392639,
-0.5669860243797302,
0.06613472104072571,
-0.19185926020145416,
0.8196650147438049,
-0.31585580110549927,
-0.22950465977191925,
0.32665205001831055,
-0.244667187333107,
0.31233349442481995,
0.2838687598705292,
-0.31922292709350586,
-0.18854650855064392,
0.7235559225082397,
-0.15788426995277405,
0.5358272790908813,
0.17612168192863464,
-0.15746405720710754,
-0.5110160112380981,
-0.38854286074638367,
-0.8423194885253906,
-0.0694340243935585,
-0.4070480763912201,
-0.16023117303848267,
-0.8132098913192749,
-0.14434665441513062,
-0.5189412236213684,
0.18603728711605072,
-0.20738469064235687,
-0.7232114672660828,
0.2605382800102234,
-0.11974052339792252,
0.35300296545028687,
0.7707191109657288,
0.39305058121681213,
0.10284233093261719,
-0.5454358458518982,
0.3722494840621948,
0.23034636676311493,
0.25284919142723083,
0.017740733921527863,
-0.03351854160428047,
-0.09230026602745056,
0.3450790047645569,
-0.3829916715621948,
-0.8361386060714722,
0.45835036039352417,
-0.01269763708114624,
0.48735180497169495,
0.07270047813653946,
0.5111774802207947,
0.7485558986663818,
-0.4925634264945984,
0.8479896187782288,
0.30688756704330444,
-0.7963161468505859,
0.5888599157333374,
-0.4139377474784851,
0.2569720447063446,
0.2259368598461151,
0.066550113260746,
-0.689912736415863,
-0.7555896043777466,
-0.5732911229133606,
-0.6247771978378296,
0.9001110196113586,
0.18173114955425262,
0.24185225367546082,
-0.4740223288536072,
0.13382436335086823,
0.05703681334853172,
0.30996474623680115,
-0.1197662428021431,
-0.1971229612827301,
-0.08370109647512436,
-0.3657897710800171,
-0.002605967689305544,
0.2022208273410797,
-0.23113755881786346,
0.014915494248270988,
0.19209544360637665,
-0.3443836569786072,
0.4749608635902405,
0.39038392901420593,
0.029392873868346214,
-0.009846827015280724,
0.3529093861579895,
0.459067165851593,
0.38937073945999146,
-0.02774166688323021,
-0.15730540454387665,
0.02710092067718506,
-0.25323089957237244,
0.2622663080692291,
-0.2520963251590729,
-0.11756275594234467,
0.06459005922079086,
-0.3530450761318207,
0.820092499256134,
0.08436387032270432,
-1.0562869310379028,
0.27463385462760925,
-0.01871449127793312,
-0.020671984180808067,
-0.10550721734762192,
0.20525570213794708,
0.1613525003194809,
0.19140668213367462,
0.2384936362504959,
-0.04023125395178795,
0.3548436164855957,
-0.978059709072113,
0.23721487820148468,
0.529484212398529,
-0.2293020337820053,
-0.47376304864883423,
0.6430691480636597,
0.6189739108085632,
-0.6576042175292969,
0.597643256187439,
-0.3556705117225647,
-0.4708266854286194,
0.7067888975143433,
0.8929365277290344,
0.8155845999717712,
-0.07287875562906265,
0.4606761932373047,
0.2859913408756256,
-0.3033420443534851,
0.3124304413795471,
0.6041402816772461,
-0.3846931457519531,
-0.5663659572601318,
-0.7183700799942017,
-0.544999361038208,
-0.6079241037368774,
-0.03602198138833046,
-0.5886998772621155,
-0.03528362512588501,
-0.4996664226055145,
-0.665644645690918,
-0.31307363510131836,
-0.12215325236320496,
-0.41814976930618286,
0.17868627607822418,
-0.05796691030263901,
0.7869754433631897,
-0.4608941376209259,
0.9225095510482788,
0.7129465341567993,
0.1363164782524109,
-0.6122366786003113,
0.05383932963013649,
-0.23252052068710327,
-0.5698235034942627,
0.7177000045776367,
-0.14728733897209167,
-0.22117428481578827,
0.3209308981895447,
-0.36033210158348083,
-0.5255247354507446,
0.9920969009399414,
0.17087343335151672,
-0.44676512479782104,
-0.29552751779556274,
0.2899080812931061,
0.6275268197059631,
-0.4447762370109558,
0.43386897444725037,
0.3207796514034271,
0.1888565719127655,
0.16119088232517242,
-1.2006438970565796,
0.06381022185087204,
-0.5780611038208008,
0.0953533723950386,
0.48692312836647034,
-0.6064052581787109,
0.7353612184524536,
-0.46168631315231323,
-0.43004128336906433,
0.24635407328605652,
0.35076820850372314,
0.39745333790779114,
0.2926267385482788,
0.6266112923622131,
0.5823067426681519,
0.35565218329429626,
-0.23737287521362305,
1.1750136613845825,
-0.7058282494544983,
0.021633142605423927,
1.055596947669983,
-0.5779195427894592,
0.6686762571334839,
0.52248615026474,
0.019327552989125252,
0.559336245059967,
0.4735512435436249,
0.3524227440357208,
0.42803695797920227,
0.5574405193328857,
-0.3318288028240204,
-0.2516748607158661,
-0.39381882548332214,
-0.0540570467710495,
0.1788325309753418,
0.6109153032302856,
0.22570767998695374,
-0.24329128861427307,
0.15344858169555664,
-0.44818875193595886,
-0.010610470548272133,
0.17324994504451752,
0.8942285180091858,
-0.0075014615431427956,
-0.8978406190872192,
0.42477405071258545,
0.07363850623369217,
0.5186485648155212,
-0.5135032534599304,
-0.15460462868213654,
-0.1760968267917633,
-0.21985211968421936,
0.07073152810335159,
-0.877237856388092,
0.12017277628183365,
0.04443870857357979,
0.0011149198981001973,
-0.4391912519931793,
0.45257481932640076,
-0.508476972579956,
-0.055764276534318924,
0.13379670679569244,
0.6851246953010559,
0.2269134670495987,
0.2860826551914215,
-0.5693403482437134,
0.04436872899532318,
0.06555783748626709,
-0.2580234408378601,
0.43711182475090027,
0.5181973576545715,
-0.5042409300804138,
0.9879387617111206,
0.9523055553436279,
-0.10818183422088623,
0.09870020300149918,
0.3398187458515167,
0.9652960896492004,
-0.5731799006462097,
-0.7319120168685913,
-0.21561595797538757,
0.3714073598384857,
-0.27786505222320557,
-0.24796026945114136,
0.5799167156219482,
0.7338554263114929,
0.8176857233047485,
-0.08011066913604736,
0.8817646503448486,
-0.33742013573646545,
0.5854111313819885,
-0.44245824217796326,
0.3099319338798523,
-0.22597633302211761,
0.026731200516223907,
-0.23283956944942474,
-0.8298211693763733,
0.2408861219882965,
0.3043810725212097,
-0.06812985241413116,
0.17186610400676727,
0.6210662126541138,
0.6611186265945435,
-0.150206059217453,
0.07070735096931458,
0.40898340940475464,
0.1663750857114792,
0.6163485646247864,
0.5758985877037048,
0.9276552796363831,
-0.2550024092197418,
0.5866565108299255,
-0.05546654015779495,
0.17465578019618988,
-0.11721963435411453,
-0.1532844454050064,
-0.776225209236145,
-0.9049279689788818,
-0.08751117438077927,
-0.27000096440315247,
0.23663969337940216,
0.8235949277877808,
0.7650320529937744,
-0.5254815220832825,
-0.5980168581008911,
-0.3871498703956604,
-0.1250428855419159,
0.1363205462694168,
-0.2881580591201782,
-0.008454608730971813,
-0.5595231652259827,
-1.2509663105010986,
0.431313157081604,
0.3055439293384552,
0.23675349354743958,
-0.17684248089790344,
-0.2864888608455658,
0.21143318712711334,
0.04850925877690315,
0.6951864957809448,
0.23316803574562073,
-0.799350917339325,
-0.13940994441509247,
0.17673005163669586,
-0.06824709475040436,
-0.12477774918079376,
1.2160929441452026,
-1.040358066558838,
0.5268465876579285,
0.5098171830177307,
0.46282443404197693,
0.6315515637397766,
0.27673107385635376,
1.125780701637268,
-0.6573819518089294,
0.2282395213842392,
0.3782857358455658,
0.010530052706599236,
0.019739393144845963,
0.03283677622675896,
0.3645213544368744,
0.04343591630458832,
-0.22967837750911713,
-0.8264021277427673,
0.597075343132019,
-1.1942493915557861,
-0.1982373297214508,
1.0261074304580688,
-0.15729324519634247,
-0.29640254378318787,
-0.4971815347671509,
-0.34083864092826843,
0.26393890380859375,
-0.5565468072891235,
0.519906759262085,
0.39266693592071533,
-0.4485616683959961,
0.034329138696193695,
-0.5406009554862976,
0.507098376750946,
0.32594797015190125,
-1.1303656101226807,
0.3531913459300995,
0.5768851041793823,
0.26938921213150024,
0.21301953494548798,
0.8943793773651123,
-0.00983418058604002,
0.1927834451198578,
-0.1110362708568573,
-0.011950116604566574,
-0.06467226147651672,
-0.27455413341522217,
0.32411816716194153,
-0.02060464397072792,
-0.1436457633972168,
-0.19706156849861145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14760v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14760v2
|
Retrieval Augmented Generation for Domain-specific Question Answering
| 2024-04-23T05:51:45 | 2024-05-29T16:18:02 |
Sanat Sharma, David Seunghyun Yoon, Franck Dernoncourt, Dewang Sultania, Karishma Bagga, Mengjiao Zhang, Trung Bui, Varun Kotte
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Question answering (QA) has become an important application in the advanced
development of large language models. General pre-trained large language models
for question-answering are not trained to properly understand the knowledge or
terminology for a specific domain, such as finance, healthcare, education, and
customer service for a product. To better cater to domain-specific
understanding, we build an in-house question-answering system for Adobe
products. We propose a novel framework to compile a large question-answer
database and develop the approach for retrieval-aware finetuning of a Large
Language model. We showcase that fine-tuning the retriever leads to major
improvements in the final generation. Our overall approach reduces
hallucinations during generation while keeping in context the latest retrieval
information for contextual grounding.
|
[
-0.6076061129570007,
-1.0722873210906982,
0.37609466910362244,
0.10317201912403107,
0.07273323833942413,
0.08140690624713898,
0.03648854047060013,
-0.506101131439209,
0.0667460709810257,
0.6931096315383911,
-0.5633713603019714,
-0.21983389556407928,
0.032347820699214935,
0.09453330188989639,
-0.3692464232444763,
0.732212483882904,
0.18466365337371826,
-0.09143845736980438,
-0.335393488407135,
-0.043021611869335175,
-0.7203091382980347,
-0.6675273180007935,
-0.9080373048782349,
-0.1401304006576538,
0.29379525780677795,
0.5790621042251587,
0.8121126890182495,
0.2717183232307434,
0.516936719417572,
0.21795754134655,
0.07208240777254105,
0.3548799157142639,
-0.48436078429222107,
0.32872921228408813,
-0.5327982902526855,
-0.3378153443336487,
-0.37980103492736816,
-0.4074389636516571,
0.3095996379852295,
0.8015901446342468,
-0.02572213113307953,
0.35464683175086975,
-0.30278152227401733,
0.49612411856651306,
-0.9096089601516724,
-0.2965373396873474,
-0.7891492247581482,
0.09310317784547806,
0.14451439678668976,
-0.5993173718452454,
-0.3755075931549072,
-0.38712602853775024,
0.2877196669578552,
-0.6411935091018677,
0.7570709586143494,
0.25066572427749634,
0.9303774833679199,
0.14448025822639465,
-0.3469100594520569,
-0.1103067621588707,
-0.8476163744926453,
0.5049256682395935,
-0.4649534821510315,
0.3658425807952881,
0.5411270260810852,
0.5651172399520874,
-0.07352998852729797,
-0.9354543089866638,
-0.6339759826660156,
0.057407088577747345,
0.17694666981697083,
-0.17535647749900818,
0.01666935905814171,
0.020447440445423126,
0.22802022099494934,
0.7003187537193298,
-0.5971956849098206,
-0.2931963801383972,
-0.29956358671188354,
-0.08930879831314087,
0.7097125053405762,
0.16781215369701385,
0.33299145102500916,
-0.07564825564622879,
0.048064906150102615,
0.14482317864894867,
-0.8752240538597107,
-0.07357094436883926,
-0.020519519224762917,
0.29376220703125,
0.6621436476707458,
0.5739941596984863,
-0.4942111074924469,
0.6108514666557312,
0.5095083117485046,
0.37295001745224,
0.09023848176002502,
-0.13615615665912628,
-0.35574114322662354,
-0.07925309240818024,
0.16393102705478668,
0.22981292009353638,
0.3027283549308777,
-0.5088412761688232,
-0.30015209317207336,
-0.22763411700725555,
0.46484243869781494,
-0.8636969327926636,
-0.16696564853191376,
0.45633748173713684,
-0.061363477259874344,
0.016214633360505104,
-0.13415561616420746,
-0.5214391350746155,
-0.4009823501110077,
-0.407696396112442,
0.7225966453552246,
-0.3457354009151459,
-0.15148259699344635,
0.20559199154376984,
-0.17966383695602417,
0.5235322713851929,
0.16830995678901672,
-1.0153719186782837,
0.32038944959640503,
0.5668814182281494,
0.1842132806777954,
0.010050756856799126,
-0.1078253909945488,
-0.852023720741272,
0.27185165882110596,
-0.4691733419895172,
0.8476503491401672,
-0.4925030767917633,
-0.2522238492965698,
0.38793858885765076,
0.025483880192041397,
0.2413843870162964,
-1.052168846130371,
0.19646063446998596,
-1.2475308179855347,
0.222480908036232,
-0.4120343029499054,
-0.6381909251213074,
0.011520741507411003,
0.4847159683704376,
-0.41569894552230835,
0.8758557438850403,
0.459799587726593,
-0.48026180267333984,
0.36029890179634094,
-0.31648728251457214,
-0.4677523970603943,
0.29316067695617676,
-0.08156951516866684,
-0.17957912385463715,
0.13207104802131653,
0.5421349406242371,
0.40759187936782837,
-0.3929414749145508,
0.2781655788421631,
0.20305047929286957,
-0.36236563324928284,
0.08762836456298828,
-0.10358474403619766,
0.38739699125289917,
0.5523437261581421,
-0.18290898203849792,
-0.13542743027210236,
-0.8147115111351013,
0.16567783057689667,
0.11375486105680466,
-0.33820298314094543,
-0.27317777276039124,
-0.22247900068759918,
0.042244087904691696,
0.17608851194381714,
0.46366482973098755,
-0.41655203700065613,
0.14418530464172363,
-0.5168754458427429,
0.08606655150651932,
0.3221202492713928,
0.672403872013092,
0.5434508323669434,
-0.2675689160823822,
0.7583057880401611,
-0.012614288367331028,
0.06941734999418259,
-0.0822281613945961,
-0.23602299392223358,
-0.5986267328262329,
0.12003698945045471,
0.18896667659282684,
0.5193712711334229,
-1.0311853885650635,
0.17872993648052216,
-0.08235000818967819,
-0.16080820560455322,
-0.3954612612724304,
0.16789773106575012,
0.42443543672561646,
0.5537368059158325,
0.5163277983665466,
-0.20373430848121643,
-0.4476959705352783,
-0.7842942476272583,
-0.07649773359298706,
0.3071351647377014,
-0.07738983631134033,
0.5010162591934204,
0.23800155520439148,
-0.24723777174949646,
1.1268283128738403,
-0.918842613697052,
-0.039455872029066086,
-0.26936429738998413,
-0.07675942033529282,
-0.05063796043395996,
0.4588930010795593,
0.6396148800849915,
-1.0819607973098755,
-0.4927092492580414,
0.04399443790316582,
-0.6073074340820312,
0.0011409989092499018,
-0.04576209560036659,
-0.4584546685218811,
-0.04645314812660217,
0.44883742928504944,
-0.6338154077529907,
0.18445658683776855,
-0.047567062079906464,
-0.3832087814807892,
0.48968014121055603,
-0.2559329867362976,
0.449381023645401,
-1.2305731773376465,
0.16831418871879578,
-0.18998081982135773,
-0.12958596646785736,
-0.7606658935546875,
0.40905535221099854,
0.0053243315778672695,
-0.4923677444458008,
-0.584883987903595,
0.7254124879837036,
-0.4255107343196869,
-0.20408405363559723,
-0.29257887601852417,
0.309669554233551,
0.42080625891685486,
0.48182713985443115,
0.08039297163486481,
1.1138837337493896,
0.47017964720726013,
-0.9342292547225952,
0.419552743434906,
0.6641319990158081,
-0.2402702271938324,
0.6607240438461304,
-0.6051003336906433,
0.2825826108455658,
-0.35816895961761475,
-0.26957792043685913,
-0.652403712272644,
-0.3898981511592865,
-0.17434433102607727,
-0.39801937341690063,
0.4304002523422241,
0.09845724701881409,
-0.4955677390098572,
-0.434429407119751,
0.05761582404375076,
0.5310377478599548,
0.45642367005348206,
-0.75739985704422,
0.4325208067893982,
0.3525196611881256,
-0.27657341957092285,
-0.5446416139602661,
-0.5320369601249695,
0.0012894953833892941,
-0.18131978809833527,
-0.8807183504104614,
0.31429412961006165,
-0.23936527967453003,
-0.3087993860244751,
-0.20907792448997498,
-0.16426268219947815,
-0.4414476156234741,
0.010429542511701584,
-0.3072603940963745,
-0.1779792755842209,
-0.4999412000179291,
0.3430662453174591,
0.2326892912387848,
0.2926739752292633,
0.01128531526774168,
-0.09055260568857193,
0.6207730174064636,
0.13691937923431396,
-0.08559389412403107,
-0.15773023664951324,
0.646798849105835,
0.33449587225914,
-0.7049083113670349,
0.6962611079216003,
0.1542278528213501,
-0.5525832176208496,
-0.4353432357311249,
-0.7341407537460327,
-0.18335264921188354,
-0.5115267634391785,
0.24780671298503876,
-0.6330034732818604,
-0.9220894575119019,
0.7998266816139221,
-0.03337620943784714,
-0.04010242968797684,
0.5816407203674316,
0.45225709676742554,
0.2859753966331482,
1.2081329822540283,
0.6792582869529724,
0.23295874893665314,
0.520061194896698,
-0.3599036931991577,
0.1502671092748642,
-0.6768586039543152,
-0.23414434492588043,
-0.5435517430305481,
0.021966610103845596,
0.03285529091954231,
-0.22239463031291962,
0.0019335191464051604,
0.32455679774284363,
-0.5741993188858032,
0.28137606382369995,
-0.6398781538009644,
0.5462031364440918,
0.5478793382644653,
0.01331289578229189,
0.3125423789024353,
0.0805743858218193,
0.1983451396226883,
0.23509810864925385,
-0.5602275133132935,
-0.28620272874832153,
0.9271932244300842,
0.03405076265335083,
0.5715979337692261,
0.1590721309185028,
0.5544840097427368,
0.2936820685863495,
0.16157591342926025,
-0.4622918665409088,
0.42629191279411316,
-0.07755530625581741,
-0.8436340093612671,
-0.3158932328224182,
-0.3458896279335022,
-0.9768591523170471,
0.1470438688993454,
-0.10284338891506195,
-0.6210349202156067,
0.4992508590221405,
0.20742148160934448,
-0.7503325343132019,
-0.10971851646900177,
-0.7303109765052795,
1.0268454551696777,
-0.06567016988992691,
-0.37481948733329773,
-0.13959284126758575,
-0.4662132263183594,
0.24668267369270325,
-0.14508621394634247,
-0.2590929865837097,
0.2423761934041977,
0.3413977026939392,
0.5482581853866577,
-0.5911885499954224,
0.3361281454563141,
-0.3107616603374481,
-0.34279367327690125,
0.7349712252616882,
0.19680234789848328,
0.38469719886779785,
0.13306982815265656,
-0.2925664186477661,
-0.8161128759384155,
0.2849169671535492,
-0.4556812047958374,
-0.8682399988174438,
0.6970494985580444,
-0.6343348622322083,
-0.7111932635307312,
-0.08514823019504547,
-0.5998866558074951,
-0.7417517900466919,
0.12167388945817947,
0.27956247329711914,
0.6209257245063782,
-0.29559123516082764,
0.07193572074174881,
0.9064456224441528,
-0.40497025847435,
-0.1370328664779663,
0.47118276357650757,
-0.31384530663490295,
-0.3235362470149994,
0.9190051555633545,
0.03542608767747879,
0.19060048460960388,
0.6040653586387634,
-0.0959518626332283,
-0.3399234414100647,
-0.5298808217048645,
-0.2631698250770569,
0.22626474499702454,
-0.8355567455291748,
-0.37748822569847107,
-0.5449610948562622,
-0.27923840284347534,
-0.6698624491691589,
-0.30735841393470764,
0.06673919409513474,
-0.44525980949401855,
-0.4237901568412781,
-0.2919172942638397,
0.5776334404945374,
0.5115026235580444,
0.30114132165908813,
0.370648056268692,
-0.8647188544273376,
0.7343999147415161,
0.6591284871101379,
0.3311203718185425,
-0.0020523250568658113,
-0.5431729555130005,
-0.3769148588180542,
0.1311970055103302,
-0.3430923819541931,
-0.7163827419281006,
0.4140835702419281,
0.5144985914230347,
0.4626961350440979,
0.16304071247577667,
0.2492820918560028,
0.6908995509147644,
-0.5553624629974365,
0.9495788812637329,
-0.20419004559516907,
-0.7184855937957764,
0.8455848693847656,
-0.2635192275047302,
0.36773380637168884,
0.7728719115257263,
0.20774714648723602,
-0.43036797642707825,
-0.3345840871334076,
-0.6950970888137817,
-0.9025986194610596,
0.5372365117073059,
-0.14936387538909912,
0.4935707449913025,
-0.52472984790802,
0.7993930578231812,
0.1450624167919159,
0.42723309993743896,
-0.11329269409179688,
-0.13248907029628754,
-0.14615681767463684,
-0.05505719780921936,
-0.01003448199480772,
-0.2965717017650604,
-0.008931038901209831,
-0.3045639991760254,
0.788851797580719,
-0.22675177454948425,
0.1047811284661293,
0.2966156601905823,
-0.3039769232273102,
-0.32227209210395813,
0.21424831449985504,
0.31147098541259766,
0.8692406415939331,
-0.3690895736217499,
-0.02880231849849224,
0.16387638449668884,
-0.38929662108421326,
-0.018531404435634613,
0.10907162725925446,
-0.1975581794977188,
-0.17958781123161316,
-0.2117236703634262,
0.5274724364280701,
-0.17659883201122284,
-0.9414244890213013,
0.48395389318466187,
-0.07923441380262375,
-0.14503102004528046,
-0.3798062801361084,
0.090932697057724,
-0.15895871818065643,
0.22943782806396484,
0.665312647819519,
-0.1619153618812561,
0.3436812162399292,
-0.7206145524978638,
0.5388579964637756,
0.4577889144420624,
-0.09017234295606613,
-0.05975676327943802,
0.8340251445770264,
0.19935843348503113,
-0.3152422606945038,
0.7707535624504089,
-0.15743215382099152,
-0.2670682370662689,
0.7060278058052063,
0.7571865916252136,
0.9079464673995972,
-0.1493816375732422,
0.270047664642334,
0.21194283664226532,
-0.1694861799478531,
-0.06286841630935669,
0.6518996357917786,
-0.12647104263305664,
-0.7133821249008179,
-0.4837195575237274,
-0.6655668616294861,
-0.3890896737575531,
0.040502943098545074,
-0.6222395896911621,
-0.08394795656204224,
-0.4978618025779724,
-0.1699298620223999,
-0.11869009584188461,
0.2054789662361145,
-0.7251965403556824,
0.7758267521858215,
-0.15405653417110443,
0.9949326515197754,
-0.4344502389431,
0.49940499663352966,
0.6725201606750488,
-0.8940485119819641,
-0.8355223536491394,
-0.012283745221793652,
-0.7655556797981262,
-0.4263169467449188,
0.7587751150131226,
-0.14394257962703705,
-0.055242639034986496,
0.2747078835964203,
-0.5499928593635559,
-0.881592333316803,
1.1292555332183838,
0.4445168972015381,
-0.16123701632022858,
-0.15279830992221832,
0.20574989914894104,
0.8425471186637878,
-0.42050471901893616,
-0.14392253756523132,
0.59222811460495,
0.026474637910723686,
0.3291310667991638,
-0.6226260662078857,
0.06473062932491302,
-0.415956050157547,
0.0431644506752491,
0.03791586682200432,
-0.37881723046302795,
0.6445878744125366,
-0.08309577405452728,
-0.23111316561698914,
0.33180293440818787,
0.8598644733428955,
0.09355956315994263,
0.3155205249786377,
-0.035896334797143936,
0.41880521178245544,
0.8387957811355591,
-0.019299665465950966,
1.175433874130249,
-0.48133155703544617,
0.15675032138824463,
0.9639593958854675,
-0.27712196111679077,
1.0089647769927979,
0.30583301186561584,
0.11898499727249146,
0.18492987751960754,
0.5691348314285278,
0.26182466745376587,
0.5028334856033325,
0.4109174609184265,
-0.396916925907135,
-0.3891517221927643,
-0.21455581486225128,
-0.5149315595626831,
0.022106627002358437,
0.24104760587215424,
-0.3170734941959381,
0.03994784876704216,
0.21576951444149017,
-0.3124237060546875,
0.2699984908103943,
-0.5845856070518494,
0.7270241379737854,
0.025768611580133438,
-0.8694127202033997,
0.8722612261772156,
-0.07812049239873886,
0.4153704047203064,
-0.40830498933792114,
0.010755079798400402,
-0.5871521830558777,
0.20843446254730225,
-0.2974243462085724,
-0.678857684135437,
0.346598356962204,
0.019988929852843285,
-0.3189179003238678,
-0.01082583237439394,
0.5236718058586121,
-0.5389875173568726,
-0.2476550042629242,
-0.14554612338542938,
0.6594673991203308,
0.032052334398031235,
-0.4380767047405243,
-0.4198194146156311,
-0.44655680656433105,
-0.27477720379829407,
-0.32163190841674805,
0.24115349352359772,
0.7401443719863892,
-0.13853685557842255,
0.6981472969055176,
0.3747130036354065,
-0.18315887451171875,
0.25126704573631287,
0.43536314368247986,
0.7435728907585144,
-0.5898424386978149,
-0.41981974244117737,
-0.11656039953231812,
0.41840603947639465,
0.01778419502079487,
-0.3622409403324127,
0.689738929271698,
0.7417080998420715,
0.638277530670166,
-0.3111153244972229,
0.6248407959938049,
-0.09499306231737137,
0.5756680369377136,
-0.3208988308906555,
0.6671513915061951,
-0.8878083825111389,
0.2258436530828476,
-0.25766876339912415,
-1.2241374254226685,
-0.5455591082572937,
0.37188521027565,
-0.3657683730125427,
0.051921237260103226,
0.5306938886642456,
0.8938374519348145,
0.03240445256233215,
-0.1906932145357132,
0.3753735423088074,
-0.010675464756786823,
0.33336901664733887,
0.41065388917922974,
0.7563939690589905,
-0.5213067531585693,
0.5662318468093872,
-0.21595923602581024,
0.09949539601802826,
-0.08000653237104416,
-0.2907940745353699,
-0.6280298829078674,
-0.6075030565261841,
-0.4461287558078766,
-0.379377543926239,
0.18651710450649261,
0.782207190990448,
0.4105132520198822,
-1.0398790836334229,
0.07862603664398193,
-0.05913533642888069,
-0.2446315884590149,
-0.2548653781414032,
-0.28768372535705566,
0.5855870246887207,
-0.617699921131134,
-0.6936125755310059,
0.2758868932723999,
-0.06439054757356644,
-0.08823386579751968,
-0.16804015636444092,
0.025840850546956062,
-0.339581161737442,
0.3844241201877594,
0.7269307971000671,
0.6839926242828369,
-0.3209049701690674,
-0.5888381004333496,
0.31572380661964417,
-0.03727557510137558,
0.19155584275722504,
0.7334654331207275,
-0.9071842432022095,
0.3714480996131897,
0.6107383966445923,
1.079045295715332,
0.40633678436279297,
0.38002896308898926,
0.8603873252868652,
-1.0007164478302002,
-0.13331300020217896,
0.4148021340370178,
0.23677971959114075,
0.48531854152679443,
-0.6582612991333008,
0.3631686270236969,
-0.18639209866523743,
-0.6706873774528503,
-0.5266156792640686,
0.3683968782424927,
-0.7705965638160706,
-0.35400086641311646,
1.1027452945709229,
0.24771422147750854,
-0.08084776252508163,
-0.3156374394893646,
-0.6144330501556396,
0.2044580578804016,
-0.22049525380134583,
0.7130425572395325,
0.2777448296546936,
-0.07265078276395798,
-0.23694783449172974,
-0.3291700780391693,
0.6954343318939209,
0.4427850842475891,
-0.826981782913208,
0.10572348535060883,
0.7542769908905029,
0.22665584087371826,
0.26128488779067993,
0.7636318206787109,
0.074644073843956,
0.5588492155075073,
-0.10431907325983047,
0.14351142942905426,
0.12722650170326233,
-0.2987349033355713,
-0.20905616879463196,
0.552422046661377,
0.4854314923286438,
-0.10340463370084763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14749v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14749v2
|
Semantic Cells: Evolutional Process to Acquire Sense Diversity of Items
| 2024-04-23T05:11:08 | 2024-04-26T22:16:59 |
Yukio Ohsawa, Dingming Xue, Kaira Sekiguchi
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Previous models for learning the semantic vectors of items and their groups,
such as words, sentences, nodes, and graphs, using distributed representation
have been based on the assumption that the basic sense of an item corresponds
to one vector composed of dimensions corresponding to hidden contexts in the
target real world, from which multiple senses of the item are obtained by
conforming to lexical databases or adapting to the context. However, there may
be multiple senses of an item, which are hardly assimilated and change or
evolve dynamically following the contextual shift even within a document or a
restricted period. This is a process similar to the evolution or adaptation of
a living entity with/to environmental shifts. Setting the scope of
disambiguation of items for sensemaking, the author presents a method in which
a word or item in the data embraces multiple semantic vectors that evolve via
interaction with others, similar to a cell embracing chromosomes crossing over
with each other. We obtained two preliminary results: (1) the role of a word
that evolves to acquire the largest or lower-middle variance of semantic
vectors tends to be explainable by the author of the text; (2) the epicenters
of earthquakes that acquire larger variance via crossover, corresponding to the
interaction with diverse areas of land crust, are likely to correspond to the
epicenters of forthcoming large earthquakes.
|
[
-0.5674934983253479,
-0.7240979075431824,
0.5930300951004028,
-0.02187754213809967,
-0.2803111970424652,
0.16471083462238312,
-0.13031676411628723,
-0.6054077744483948,
0.27581489086151123,
0.024706432595849037,
-0.7403236627578735,
-0.46465349197387695,
-0.8085461854934692,
0.2433801144361496,
-0.5716566443443298,
0.7249041795730591,
0.05465402081608772,
-0.10236787796020508,
-0.13933391869068146,
-0.5303272604942322,
-0.11651425808668137,
-0.07501935213804245,
0.047438330948352814,
-0.4799894392490387,
0.7169837951660156,
0.39300504326820374,
0.7758998274803162,
0.6988903284072876,
0.10366983711719513,
0.33987072110176086,
-0.6135618090629578,
0.15128755569458008,
-0.40796783566474915,
0.21242719888687134,
-0.5546267032623291,
-0.24861571192741394,
0.00674777664244175,
0.1377776563167572,
0.5096980333328247,
1.0753004550933838,
0.012314350344240665,
-0.08719237893819809,
0.054782018065452576,
0.48087525367736816,
-0.2851765751838684,
-0.04771154001355171,
-0.9152891635894775,
0.29101914167404175,
0.16532574594020844,
-0.2736769914627075,
-0.061845291405916214,
-0.03165813162922859,
0.6389666199684143,
-0.8194770812988281,
0.19458208978176117,
-0.14216184616088867,
0.6729755401611328,
0.22005151212215424,
-0.39890381693840027,
-0.5272043943405151,
-0.5326492786407471,
0.6861625909805298,
0.10846129059791565,
0.5209583640098572,
0.141500785946846,
0.11598985642194748,
-0.32938265800476074,
-0.9329676032066345,
-0.7832501530647278,
-0.20059476792812347,
0.31094634532928467,
0.45485368371009827,
-0.04926208779215813,
-0.20815709233283997,
0.12851879000663757,
0.07689261436462402,
-0.019566942006349564,
-0.1723833680152893,
-0.4890252351760864,
-0.06138968840241432,
0.40802064538002014,
0.0055922395549714565,
0.6060507893562317,
-0.26226362586021423,
-0.7460382580757141,
-0.2994915246963501,
-0.42600858211517334,
-0.02993258833885193,
0.3436165153980255,
0.3372679054737091,
0.03754322603344917,
0.7112032771110535,
-0.24632218480110168,
0.7140800356864929,
-0.3322228789329529,
0.08685266971588135,
0.554264485836029,
-0.5964662432670593,
-0.10414911061525345,
0.1293543130159378,
0.30400148034095764,
0.17009951174259186,
0.037483181804418564,
-0.32194507122039795,
0.2045261263847351,
0.14197438955307007,
0.3684195280075073,
-0.4407815635204315,
-0.19639165699481964,
-0.11996649205684662,
-0.7199142575263977,
-0.2960324287414551,
0.05840357393026352,
-0.8984704613685608,
-0.25405997037887573,
-0.6753648519515991,
0.34860679507255554,
-0.5887095928192139,
-0.2323143631219864,
0.2542727589607239,
-0.7972838282585144,
0.3279576897621155,
0.4283919036388397,
-0.7588229775428772,
0.3614603281021118,
0.3786521852016449,
0.8091560006141663,
-0.21693985164165497,
-0.7572622895240784,
-0.12287521362304688,
0.038107600063085556,
-0.17124848067760468,
1.0618550777435303,
-0.7593570947647095,
-0.6240937113761902,
-0.21042422950267792,
0.008395109325647354,
-0.14913739264011383,
-0.5528706908226013,
0.3150160014629364,
-0.5119984149932861,
-0.004456677008420229,
-0.46731406450271606,
-0.5061185359954834,
-0.2439528852701187,
-0.07087962329387665,
-0.42307472229003906,
0.7931897640228271,
0.381723552942276,
-0.6178225874900818,
0.8891800045967102,
-0.7567655444145203,
-0.277313768863678,
0.2501576244831085,
-0.30114713311195374,
-0.17390796542167664,
0.27152058482170105,
-0.0624493807554245,
0.18036039173603058,
0.15107427537441254,
-0.5650428533554077,
-0.44868960976600647,
0.19825346767902374,
0.36827871203422546,
0.11593078076839447,
0.7292430996894836,
0.31678372621536255,
-0.16612368822097778,
0.030657155439257622,
-0.7609748840332031,
-0.08781448751688004,
-0.012564034201204777,
-0.37508320808410645,
-0.7245951890945435,
0.5832462310791016,
-0.10599910467863083,
0.2605836093425751,
-0.04577441141009331,
-0.6301151514053345,
0.2923925220966339,
-0.36295297741889954,
0.4360085725784302,
0.5737465023994446,
0.14837433397769928,
0.5681070685386658,
-0.11092036217451096,
-0.0007888186955824494,
0.7313949465751648,
0.09602963924407959,
0.031115438789129257,
-0.9645758271217346,
-0.5163031220436096,
0.08673404157161713,
0.04478029906749725,
0.20117628574371338,
-0.7287728786468506,
0.4444276988506317,
-0.20458637177944183,
-0.39364680647850037,
-0.1887333244085312,
0.2016858160495758,
-0.2139524221420288,
0.31364479660987854,
0.6341361999511719,
-0.18342246115207672,
-0.2661830186843872,
-0.6178297996520996,
-0.17597967386245728,
-0.04669247567653656,
0.06343458592891693,
0.4076918065547943,
0.6075050830841064,
-0.6360664367675781,
1.2424575090408325,
-0.5438348650932312,
0.041323043406009674,
-0.11811364442110062,
0.326887309551239,
0.043971966952085495,
0.34528762102127075,
0.6066769957542419,
-1.2177106142044067,
0.03107329085469246,
0.517884373664856,
-0.45152682065963745,
-0.1714097410440445,
-0.0686807706952095,
-0.46752673387527466,
-0.3005247116088867,
0.44029051065444946,
-0.3409908413887024,
0.5066473484039307,
0.4276689291000366,
-0.696800947189331,
0.1923016905784607,
-0.1361115425825119,
-0.26763421297073364,
-1.2438572645187378,
-0.3381768465042114,
-0.21444450318813324,
0.0122609818354249,
-0.6611773371696472,
-0.12212994694709778,
0.03727976232767105,
0.24511881172657013,
-0.3806864321231842,
0.4818398952484131,
-0.6150789856910706,
-0.25666409730911255,
-0.4513096809387207,
0.4517785310745239,
-0.13481400907039642,
0.14378245174884796,
-0.034011222422122955,
0.24591122567653656,
0.6046879291534424,
-1.0447849035263062,
0.5390635132789612,
0.4777662456035614,
-0.40165749192237854,
0.6312564015388489,
-0.3105349540710449,
-0.29726672172546387,
-0.5050320029258728,
-0.010755812749266624,
-0.6987975835800171,
-0.07726302742958069,
0.1994246542453766,
-0.5695968270301819,
-0.18524280190467834,
0.17210912704467773,
-0.1548423022031784,
-0.36580535769462585,
0.07060366123914719,
0.5398464202880859,
0.35078155994415283,
-0.7325844168663025,
0.5834224820137024,
0.35334312915802,
0.16218611598014832,
-0.2165002077817917,
-0.6694927215576172,
-0.11544882506132126,
-0.29569458961486816,
-0.7103428840637207,
0.3775143027305603,
-0.08985357731580734,
-0.44037044048309326,
0.37697634100914,
-0.30968570709228516,
-0.03439874202013016,
0.28226494789123535,
0.04926631599664688,
-0.028032543137669563,
-0.09490661323070526,
0.740841269493103,
0.22811073064804077,
-0.01298469491302967,
-0.05807347595691681,
-0.7739900946617126,
0.3232444226741791,
0.1194593533873558,
-0.31636354327201843,
0.339011013507843,
0.4056657552719116,
0.5282344222068787,
-0.0984865352511406,
0.8080960512161255,
0.47340232133865356,
-0.4674549102783203,
-0.5915926694869995,
0.06245465576648712,
-0.12985186278820038,
-0.40070515871047974,
0.4301247000694275,
-0.6529500484466553,
-0.775795042514801,
0.9268346428871155,
-0.50831538438797,
-0.12672065198421478,
0.6849647760391235,
0.6992233991622925,
0.1507490575313568,
0.7813288569450378,
0.6471591591835022,
0.29497697949409485,
0.48822981119155884,
-0.21899548172950745,
0.13239185512065887,
-1.0262641906738281,
-0.4411846399307251,
-0.7219893932342529,
-0.49730491638183594,
-0.8249229192733765,
-0.6214094161987305,
0.31086260080337524,
0.4112778306007385,
0.002747365739196539,
0.24946996569633484,
-0.6470197439193726,
0.562311053276062,
0.44616207480430603,
0.45513200759887695,
0.20949207246303558,
0.13222627341747284,
-0.4606858789920807,
0.2663925886154175,
-0.7226313352584839,
-0.1769288033246994,
0.6387649178504944,
0.32557711005210876,
0.6986857652664185,
0.18803419172763824,
0.7283397316932678,
0.019917838275432587,
0.22187373042106628,
-1.006833553314209,
0.24257342517375946,
-0.0765763521194458,
-0.24950148165225983,
-0.36346641182899475,
-0.28803130984306335,
-1.343822717666626,
0.5509788990020752,
-0.2897132337093353,
-0.9415448307991028,
0.7547217011451721,
-0.430751770734787,
-0.11411194503307343,
0.21873173117637634,
-0.6196570992469788,
0.6071140766143799,
0.030729440972208977,
-0.16211673617362976,
-0.2641059458255768,
-0.7030759453773499,
-0.08312003314495087,
-0.08541302382946014,
0.1653956174850464,
-0.357155978679657,
-0.3238755464553833,
0.7258027195930481,
-0.21306855976581573,
0.7020309567451477,
-0.07905197888612747,
0.10280325263738632,
0.4877122938632965,
-0.1737760454416275,
0.2015315294265747,
0.05983557552099228,
-0.05081918090581894,
-0.015280639752745628,
-0.1406303346157074,
-0.6456688046455383,
-0.4690011739730835,
0.4716327488422394,
-1.0419585704803467,
-0.3054349422454834,
-0.2118428647518158,
-0.5267149209976196,
-0.07683747261762619,
0.24584968388080597,
0.4204435646533966,
0.19262102246284485,
-0.23304657638072968,
0.249290332198143,
0.8278643488883972,
-0.32989221811294556,
0.5256929993629456,
0.13355475664138794,
-0.16530226171016693,
-0.0002961125283036381,
0.5557146072387695,
0.18462947010993958,
0.319229394197464,
0.1164291650056839,
0.701291024684906,
-0.1866571009159088,
-0.5272209644317627,
-0.33879366517066956,
-0.1747148483991623,
-0.8439706563949585,
-0.10667077451944351,
-0.8709940314292908,
-0.15432439744472504,
-0.11784270405769348,
-0.22136467695236206,
0.007220191415399313,
-0.24079547822475433,
-0.2868303656578064,
-0.28140124678611755,
0.74432772397995,
0.9546311497688293,
-0.21113087236881256,
0.10948406159877777,
-0.7402495741844177,
0.20522244274616241,
0.6231025457382202,
0.3204016089439392,
-0.010186698287725449,
-0.30550041794776917,
-0.23682275414466858,
0.15306463837623596,
-0.24043983221054077,
-1.338927984237671,
0.28388166427612305,
0.2799761891365051,
0.9763623476028442,
0.18181212246418,
-0.10346127301454544,
0.5288456082344055,
-0.4389171600341797,
0.8105176687240601,
0.17431671917438507,
-0.9497900605201721,
0.5273684859275818,
-0.40897613763809204,
0.4762156009674072,
0.33628588914871216,
0.24843573570251465,
-0.6404582858085632,
-0.39080411195755005,
-0.6768082976341248,
-1.071425437927246,
0.5342182517051697,
0.12722454965114594,
0.4310564398765564,
-0.4225621521472931,
0.32572492957115173,
0.2823311388492584,
0.05416512489318848,
-0.5584518909454346,
-0.03706192970275879,
-0.5298081636428833,
-0.1420736312866211,
0.18212610483169556,
-0.06612380594015121,
-0.44981858134269714,
-0.4632277488708496,
0.12503787875175476,
-0.3792552649974823,
0.32485565543174744,
0.5478711724281311,
-0.19345588982105255,
0.09492728859186172,
0.23360376060009003,
0.7583435773849487,
0.7726956605911255,
0.3624424338340759,
0.35880571603775024,
0.4774608612060547,
-0.7199714183807373,
0.05289703607559204,
-0.11102423071861267,
0.1224551871418953,
0.09400183707475662,
0.29499414563179016,
0.7775796055793762,
0.2391735166311264,
-0.24257518351078033,
0.23973987996578217,
0.08188416063785553,
-0.33976876735687256,
-0.017290154471993446,
0.08921535313129425,
0.1255100518465042,
0.5435643792152405,
0.4041791260242462,
0.11543812602758408,
0.29648470878601074,
-0.7068015933036804,
0.4730622172355652,
0.15700046718120575,
-0.2397519052028656,
-0.20431958138942719,
0.4138132631778717,
0.10585334151983261,
-0.07918351143598557,
0.5153984427452087,
-0.3190421164035797,
-0.5999677181243896,
0.8700820207595825,
0.5057346820831299,
0.9468832015991211,
-0.22668035328388214,
0.21170657873153687,
0.2576114237308502,
0.20625558495521545,
-0.04245034605264664,
0.3217463195323944,
-0.33498960733413696,
-1.3131791353225708,
-0.04420148581266403,
-0.9987064003944397,
-0.16624726355075836,
-0.407610684633255,
-0.4703340232372284,
0.0888880267739296,
-0.15124744176864624,
-0.062023308128118515,
0.2550986111164093,
-0.4583825469017029,
-0.705899715423584,
0.269203782081604,
0.240901380777359,
1.1592063903808594,
-0.8632991313934326,
0.7902438044548035,
0.9659913778305054,
-0.25825226306915283,
-0.6917965412139893,
0.19475293159484863,
-0.06448622047901154,
-0.9097653031349182,
0.9488013386726379,
-0.05180137977004051,
-0.07965866476297379,
0.07280764728784561,
-0.5157849788665771,
-0.9913315176963806,
1.0164419412612915,
-0.3786787986755371,
-0.3659104108810425,
0.33302026987075806,
0.019814711064100266,
0.6863253116607666,
-0.5188388228416443,
-0.044394105672836304,
0.47744473814964294,
0.5802906155586243,
0.3549979031085968,
-0.36001133918762207,
-0.1847352534532547,
-0.20096009969711304,
0.27702268958091736,
0.29720205068588257,
-0.4349936246871948,
0.9227924346923828,
-0.12773655354976654,
-0.24445515871047974,
-0.06758389621973038,
0.5317544937133789,
0.022660022601485252,
0.3264683187007904,
0.5720403790473938,
0.7191210389137268,
0.836022675037384,
-0.2933683693408966,
0.910597026348114,
-0.31987470388412476,
0.4203452467918396,
0.6197633147239685,
-0.13675859570503235,
0.636174201965332,
0.647672176361084,
-0.17167037725448608,
0.6605583429336548,
0.7270887494087219,
0.0014323737705126405,
0.5938030481338501,
0.5237565636634827,
-0.4757331907749176,
-0.07377023249864578,
0.08770386874675751,
-0.37538841366767883,
0.6121520400047302,
0.6541687250137329,
-0.37993884086608887,
-0.4223422110080719,
0.20786310732364655,
-0.38639122247695923,
-0.03771333768963814,
-0.4977060556411743,
1.0799024105072021,
0.12030301243066788,
-0.34117287397384644,
0.007374161388725042,
-0.29490357637405396,
0.3490067422389984,
-0.40837767720222473,
0.019967488944530487,
-0.032829370349645615,
-0.04305783286690712,
-0.31797853112220764,
-0.875886857509613,
0.4639376699924469,
-0.5004316568374634,
-0.44676095247268677,
-0.27733588218688965,
0.8114219903945923,
-0.2841035723686218,
-0.42349115014076233,
0.7630267143249512,
0.7036247253417969,
0.07833928614854813,
0.4971347153186798,
-0.5260277390480042,
-0.012321890331804752,
-0.2359401434659958,
-0.42432111501693726,
0.2083893120288849,
0.880361795425415,
-0.07243146747350693,
0.25635820627212524,
0.5802943110466003,
0.1345086544752121,
0.6011331677436829,
0.12071505188941956,
0.9308247566223145,
-0.8358463644981384,
-0.5306064486503601,
-0.7839414477348328,
0.4974554777145386,
-0.29685866832733154,
-0.41811954975128174,
0.4137520492076874,
0.13592368364334106,
1.09685480594635,
0.1384209841489792,
0.8082466721534729,
-0.19074897468090057,
0.28587430715560913,
-0.5631392598152161,
0.4338332414627075,
-0.5206857323646545,
-0.03626704588532448,
-0.230636864900589,
-1.0550954341888428,
-0.11290082335472107,
0.8179702162742615,
-0.2127893567085266,
0.11797832697629929,
0.9686334729194641,
0.32622388005256653,
-0.10575778782367706,
0.24321837723255157,
0.3142525851726532,
0.32384228706359863,
0.009414255619049072,
0.22550654411315918,
1.0158931016921997,
-0.18365326523780823,
0.18978038430213928,
0.12434358894824982,
-0.5353497862815857,
-0.045010678470134735,
-0.6341241598129272,
-0.3008079528808594,
-0.9167143106460571,
-0.18854132294654846,
-0.4600149393081665,
-0.08311910927295685,
0.7622355818748474,
0.5816675424575806,
-0.48221272230148315,
-0.09738411009311676,
-0.4560023546218872,
0.36486175656318665,
-0.24775762856006622,
-0.20258015394210815,
0.024881601333618164,
-0.6416553258895874,
-0.7134255170822144,
0.3345765769481659,
0.5586608648300171,
0.19356492161750793,
-0.08817031234502792,
-0.018456285819411278,
-0.1453917771577835,
0.2064376175403595,
0.855669379234314,
0.2216111272573471,
-0.48832836747169495,
-0.6214606165885925,
-0.04370269179344177,
-0.10191132873296738,
0.0952964499592781,
0.7266539335250854,
-0.7936368584632874,
0.6838622093200684,
0.8310320973396301,
0.6869569420814514,
0.3205021023750305,
-0.2655371427536011,
0.347290962934494,
-0.5279101133346558,
0.3437712788581848,
0.016792278736829758,
0.3481769263744354,
-0.03507865220308304,
-0.24790316820144653,
0.3199271559715271,
0.6421582698822021,
-0.4951935410499573,
-0.31041112542152405,
0.6927874088287354,
-1.0511940717697144,
-0.7245112657546997,
1.1215957403182983,
0.3021635413169861,
-0.3975677192211151,
-0.3762289881706238,
0.016403475776314735,
0.3345111608505249,
-0.06082075461745262,
1.0580261945724487,
0.8596906065940857,
-0.3905474543571472,
-0.02931002713739872,
-0.3790019750595093,
0.4331316351890564,
0.2358882874250412,
-0.9534927010536194,
-0.2818981111049652,
0.3933780789375305,
0.18916569650173187,
0.511893093585968,
0.12808656692504883,
-0.18648776412010193,
0.3293708562850952,
0.1883615404367447,
-0.06205481290817261,
0.4719216823577881,
-0.2993360757827759,
-0.20045728981494904,
0.1542179137468338,
-0.0069861095398664474,
-0.3913728892803192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00705v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00705v1
|
SHED: Shapley-Based Automated Dataset Refinement for Instruction Fine-Tuning
| 2024-04-23T04:56:48 | 2024-04-23T04:56:48 |
Yexiao He, Ziyao Wang, Zheyu Shen, Guoheng Sun, Yucong Dai, Yongkai Wu, Hongyi Wang, Ang Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) can be adapted for many
downstream tasks and tailored to align with human preferences through
fine-tuning. Recent studies have discovered that LLMs can achieve desirable
performance with only a small amount of high-quality data, suggesting that a
large amount of the data in these extensive datasets is redundant or even
harmful. Identifying high-quality data from vast datasets to curate small yet
effective datasets has emerged as a critical challenge. In this paper, we
introduce SHED, an automated dataset refinement framework based on Shapley
value for instruction fine-tuning. SHED eliminates the need for human
intervention or the use of commercial LLMs. Moreover, the datasets curated
through SHED exhibit transferability, indicating they can be reused across
different LLMs with consistently high performance. We conduct extensive
experiments to evaluate the datasets curated by SHED. The results demonstrate
SHED's superiority over state-of-the-art methods across various tasks and LLMs;
notably, datasets comprising only 10% of the original data selected by SHED
achieve performance comparable to or surpassing that of the full datasets.
|
[
-0.28505271673202515,
-0.7915579080581665,
0.26336750388145447,
0.04636082053184509,
-0.07970455288887024,
0.14234820008277893,
-0.5229508280754089,
-0.20582158863544464,
-0.10898052155971527,
0.8066902756690979,
-0.5967279672622681,
-0.6661931276321411,
-0.5300948023796082,
-0.1318713277578354,
-0.48954975605010986,
0.6596961617469788,
-0.18019628524780273,
0.003587944433093071,
-0.33663317561149597,
-0.01414730865508318,
-0.5272490978240967,
-0.1521299034357071,
-0.35383108258247375,
-0.2055509388446808,
0.24305661022663116,
0.9064671993255615,
0.7214701175689697,
1.1498339176177979,
0.36443012952804565,
0.34775879979133606,
0.2971581220626831,
0.6585435271263123,
-0.8415718674659729,
0.14650340378284454,
-0.24316325783729553,
-0.28824201226234436,
-0.1420825570821762,
-0.11291732639074326,
0.4576946198940277,
0.8905857801437378,
-0.2763097584247589,
0.3753952980041504,
0.23498716950416565,
0.9935528039932251,
-0.8351651430130005,
0.03491291403770447,
-0.6091194152832031,
-0.19525383412837982,
-0.31753337383270264,
-0.13295194506645203,
-0.36077365279197693,
-0.5769460797309875,
-0.26851359009742737,
-0.6082663536071777,
0.4179716110229492,
0.10161664336919785,
0.9374617338180542,
0.6359665393829346,
-0.06367644667625427,
-0.17595911026000977,
-0.4296935498714447,
1.0899243354797363,
-0.7641053795814514,
0.4917859137058258,
0.6305896639823914,
0.09144983440637589,
-0.2593083083629608,
-0.5888471007347107,
-0.33360451459884644,
-0.1492721438407898,
-0.11396227031946182,
-0.21914923191070557,
0.03368886932730675,
0.021312490105628967,
0.23655816912651062,
0.5022684335708618,
-0.3243938386440277,
0.33497360348701477,
-0.4834616780281067,
-0.17052572965621948,
0.7101016044616699,
0.441364586353302,
0.03970614820718765,
-0.07038465887308121,
-0.33268168568611145,
-0.11028971523046494,
-0.6310184597969055,
0.0872250646352768,
0.507474958896637,
0.463245689868927,
0.10076464712619781,
0.28223779797554016,
-0.5752342939376831,
0.963424801826477,
0.09551297873258591,
0.030846167355775833,
0.18735656142234802,
-0.2439100593328476,
-0.22849859297275543,
-0.16537442803382874,
0.6869028806686401,
0.42379122972488403,
0.2726784646511078,
-0.2993239164352417,
-0.3076271116733551,
-0.5002334117889404,
0.30679163336753845,
-0.9992505311965942,
-0.6841491460800171,
0.21170967817306519,
-0.3496384024620056,
-0.36503201723098755,
0.11939026415348053,
-0.4214901328086853,
-0.42320987582206726,
-0.9123660326004028,
0.26818376779556274,
-0.655772864818573,
0.18502628803253174,
0.1342569887638092,
-0.02454528585076332,
0.22964437305927277,
0.409076988697052,
-0.9967809915542603,
0.28727635741233826,
0.7987106442451477,
0.5602139234542847,
-0.31975656747817993,
-0.4063049852848053,
-0.6131883859634399,
0.28256893157958984,
-0.6104644536972046,
0.6976251006126404,
-0.6043799519538879,
-0.12839506566524506,
-0.2057134211063385,
0.08969535678625107,
0.11930420994758606,
-0.7428756952285767,
0.3037997782230377,
-0.4999755620956421,
0.14495356380939484,
-0.4580790400505066,
-0.6923240423202515,
-0.1783759891986847,
0.1074892058968544,
-0.7689577341079712,
1.1248242855072021,
0.5406537652015686,
-0.3638139069080353,
0.36497974395751953,
-0.4204593002796173,
-0.6365444660186768,
0.20616376399993896,
-0.054530754685401917,
-0.37954020500183105,
0.011586086824536324,
0.18233326077461243,
0.47513848543167114,
-0.22135478258132935,
0.3475000858306885,
-0.32872316241264343,
-0.7945255637168884,
-0.06474359333515167,
-0.4160924255847931,
0.7165656089782715,
0.1802569478750229,
-0.29728084802627563,
0.20157910883426666,
-0.8029550313949585,
0.7195149660110474,
-0.3123391568660736,
-0.29291313886642456,
-0.30730003118515015,
-0.06138613075017929,
-0.07612702250480652,
0.05137931555509567,
0.5247507095336914,
-0.4045761525630951,
0.2748057246208191,
-0.15886569023132324,
0.32645106315612793,
0.9832061529159546,
-0.1990296095609665,
0.33649909496307373,
-0.4413928687572479,
0.3390573561191559,
-0.14525683224201202,
0.2666774392127991,
-0.00711324717849493,
0.21054643392562866,
-0.9348874092102051,
-0.5020599961280823,
0.45404642820358276,
0.5525197386741638,
-0.5749781131744385,
0.7448225021362305,
-0.17975012958049774,
-0.2596738934516907,
-0.7110723853111267,
0.618242621421814,
0.3891887068748474,
0.26350587606430054,
0.3499152958393097,
-0.22749251127243042,
-0.5850671529769897,
-1.0179113149642944,
-0.0034486823715269566,
0.5095083117485046,
-0.03833991289138794,
0.5044831037521362,
0.164729043841362,
-0.21090823411941528,
0.9334190487861633,
-0.5594062805175781,
-0.23803114891052246,
0.04843651503324509,
0.11238028854131699,
0.17186865210533142,
0.4503574073314667,
0.08194553852081299,
-0.5087814331054688,
-0.5475621223449707,
0.03000907599925995,
-0.5748624205589294,
-0.36804264783859253,
-0.046023909002542496,
-0.4457343518733978,
0.07554750889539719,
0.7481498718261719,
-0.08388955146074295,
0.3203347623348236,
0.6212858557701111,
-0.11258186399936676,
0.7072334885597229,
-0.17848043143749237,
0.27410200238227844,
-0.976288378238678,
0.09885586053133011,
-0.5050302743911743,
-0.3264458477497101,
-0.22912317514419556,
-0.056611210107803345,
0.1895172894001007,
0.16675633192062378,
-0.337588369846344,
0.5756939053535461,
-0.3928494155406952,
0.12585224211215973,
-0.3758004903793335,
-0.05216255784034729,
0.16606411337852478,
0.4214193522930145,
-0.366515189409256,
1.019115924835205,
0.41226086020469666,
-0.7243458032608032,
0.6822184920310974,
0.5375398397445679,
-0.5355492830276489,
0.4872893989086151,
-0.4507342576980591,
0.2302825003862381,
0.12322093546390533,
0.04287141561508179,
-0.685424268245697,
-0.3819402754306793,
0.037854794412851334,
0.15508587658405304,
0.32877376675605774,
-0.37303489446640015,
-0.4821997880935669,
-0.031783461570739746,
-0.408480167388916,
0.04340879246592522,
0.3985009789466858,
-0.6929031014442444,
0.3601939380168915,
0.03178402781486511,
-0.27728503942489624,
-0.7170975804328918,
-0.3884158432483673,
0.07552000135183334,
0.06650068610906601,
-0.5362578630447388,
0.3820478022098541,
-0.03006032481789589,
-0.2890693247318268,
-0.10338424891233444,
-0.1564452052116394,
-0.22364524006843567,
-0.017614588141441345,
0.509579598903656,
0.21425041556358337,
-0.021369118243455887,
0.13330291211605072,
0.11043918877840042,
-0.040250927209854126,
-0.08988551795482635,
-0.19565434753894806,
0.5643760561943054,
-0.02345036156475544,
-0.5136355757713318,
-0.4756636321544647,
0.114226333796978,
0.2971493899822235,
-0.21391692757606506,
0.5703620910644531,
0.7641162276268005,
0.024634061381220818,
-0.8547015190124512,
-0.6281190514564514,
-0.12520034611225128,
-0.6210540533065796,
0.48278605937957764,
-0.13193929195404053,
-0.5661053657531738,
0.18932217359542847,
-0.2513725161552429,
0.16205084323883057,
-0.07058770209550858,
0.1817549765110016,
-0.50538170337677,
0.6813168525695801,
0.535247266292572,
-0.20284974575042725,
0.7927790284156799,
-0.6149412393569946,
-0.019485509023070335,
-0.7632178068161011,
-0.18613867461681366,
-0.4638477861881256,
-0.5759615302085876,
-0.35032111406326294,
-0.3976786732673645,
-0.10346618294715881,
0.3060489892959595,
-0.37127065658569336,
0.16732971370220184,
-0.49694138765335083,
0.9222376942634583,
0.7928889393806458,
0.36275744438171387,
0.21289470791816711,
0.04185099899768829,
0.35779905319213867,
0.22954291105270386,
-0.5907898545265198,
-0.6566500067710876,
1.1004014015197754,
-0.17779380083084106,
1.0061789751052856,
-0.14971904456615448,
0.823688268661499,
0.561701238155365,
0.14821456372737885,
-0.6980709433555603,
0.5953836441040039,
-0.7637267112731934,
-0.11519057303667068,
-0.5767554044723511,
-0.5900803208351135,
-0.9589943289756775,
-0.16942240297794342,
0.13946226239204407,
-0.3834400177001953,
0.05876520276069641,
0.15288423001766205,
-0.31726887822151184,
0.3005622625350952,
-0.8199703097343445,
0.7899802327156067,
-0.4315750002861023,
-0.6627271771430969,
-0.33436280488967896,
-0.36039096117019653,
0.25734758377075195,
-0.068757563829422,
0.05799595266580582,
-0.31311607360839844,
0.044056590646505356,
0.8342483043670654,
-0.756690502166748,
0.8431077003479004,
-0.28711774945259094,
-0.01559034176170826,
0.13757053017616272,
0.22355353832244873,
0.5767914652824402,
-0.3661426305770874,
-0.2602190673351288,
0.0877130851149559,
0.20639315247535706,
-0.6987361907958984,
-0.570776104927063,
0.9007429480552673,
-0.8041613101959229,
-0.44333502650260925,
0.18292702734470367,
-0.8578295707702637,
-0.3956635594367981,
0.35362958908081055,
0.041263140738010406,
0.6311242580413818,
-0.18887591361999512,
0.4198612570762634,
0.8308541774749756,
-0.04609569162130356,
0.2019430249929428,
0.5367129445075989,
0.05330674350261688,
-0.37055301666259766,
1.0977908372879028,
-0.009427938610315323,
0.2888481318950653,
0.30618879199028015,
0.13077391684055328,
-0.15935921669006348,
-0.8448318243026733,
-0.48368537425994873,
-0.196260005235672,
-0.7098944187164307,
-0.5238426923751831,
-0.10174696147441864,
-0.11522740870714188,
-0.07701301574707031,
-0.4149341285228729,
-0.3547075688838959,
-0.36861732602119446,
-0.280729204416275,
0.044980522245168686,
0.5160639882087708,
0.6892146468162537,
0.13215933740139008,
0.4219478368759155,
-0.7909087538719177,
0.3445369601249695,
0.47831907868385315,
0.8688638210296631,
-0.18049202859401703,
-0.665122926235199,
-0.45862939953804016,
0.42410725355148315,
-0.22749805450439453,
-0.22284534573554993,
0.2410794198513031,
0.31507599353790283,
0.40911805629730225,
0.4313026964664459,
0.13505008816719055,
0.9844396114349365,
-0.4068071246147156,
0.5385457277297974,
-0.3741638958454132,
-0.9200372099876404,
0.3986588716506958,
-0.322721391916275,
0.14862503111362457,
1.0468153953552246,
0.14087170362472534,
-0.24351689219474792,
-0.12819935381412506,
-0.5797107815742493,
-0.9616796374320984,
0.8797490000724792,
-0.2704620659351349,
0.18317662179470062,
0.47076401114463806,
0.33875566720962524,
0.5503775477409363,
0.2630196511745453,
0.09091071039438248,
-0.09811573475599289,
-0.10686736553907394,
-0.5414520502090454,
0.13947027921676636,
0.0585009828209877,
-0.23307904601097107,
-0.2524280250072479,
0.9766201376914978,
-0.14091071486473083,
-0.33034393191337585,
-0.6011896133422852,
-0.31560927629470825,
-0.19136694073677063,
0.22332186996936798,
0.1419912576675415,
0.8735462427139282,
-0.2802468240261078,
-0.017138443887233734,
0.2688617408275604,
-0.522772490978241,
0.1029101237654686,
0.13659292459487915,
-0.2779139578342438,
-0.1483580768108368,
0.45864564180374146,
0.6582752466201782,
0.47181764245033264,
-0.8265978097915649,
0.4924631118774414,
0.29678216576576233,
-0.1355019360780716,
-0.1012752577662468,
0.7254347205162048,
-0.15323440730571747,
0.073508620262146,
0.19411113858222961,
0.086014524102211,
-0.07532583922147751,
-0.20094405114650726,
0.44909539818763733,
0.5032094717025757,
-0.0863725021481514,
-0.07322259247303009,
0.13303948938846588,
0.36187437176704407,
-0.23662826418876648,
1.163280963897705,
-0.10590121895074844,
-0.1995704025030136,
0.5316563844680786,
0.1519918441772461,
0.5344333648681641,
-0.07429460436105728,
0.295503705739975,
0.3077942430973053,
0.021742351353168488,
-0.12046881765127182,
0.33916136622428894,
-0.14716589450836182,
-0.7325308918952942,
-0.5430288910865784,
-0.7309675812721252,
-0.5932413935661316,
0.3868517577648163,
-0.8651206493377686,
0.38222506642341614,
-0.5966442823410034,
0.2707214951515198,
-0.2294054925441742,
0.20895814895629883,
-0.7681779861450195,
0.2017187923192978,
-0.053580865263938904,
0.9450972080230713,
-0.7575703263282776,
0.7319288849830627,
0.3763214349746704,
-0.2138214260339737,
-0.8809813857078552,
-0.1921367347240448,
-0.3202163875102997,
-1.0778383016586304,
0.47851136326789856,
0.040634073317050934,
-0.2072603553533554,
0.11883098632097244,
-0.9368532299995422,
-0.8751125335693359,
1.1037832498550415,
0.5556898713111877,
-0.8057635426521301,
0.015763098374009132,
0.26268839836120605,
0.2981126010417938,
0.08814816176891327,
0.008603822439908981,
0.7860804200172424,
0.6201711893081665,
0.11453384906053543,
-0.6190862655639648,
-0.08665221184492111,
-0.16477100551128387,
-0.12739351391792297,
0.2559784948825836,
-0.7405871152877808,
0.5381162166595459,
-0.23902234435081482,
-0.06485645473003387,
0.09690824151039124,
0.43267205357551575,
0.1904473453760147,
0.16503490507602692,
0.38008835911750793,
0.5289117097854614,
0.9773456454277039,
-0.21272747218608856,
0.7277422547340393,
-0.4695143401622772,
0.10931068658828735,
1.313912034034729,
-0.15813881158828735,
0.9298995733261108,
0.28317949175834656,
-0.40506112575531006,
0.6460764408111572,
0.38002321124076843,
-0.37026867270469666,
0.45526260137557983,
0.2636013627052307,
0.03564099967479706,
-0.5429777503013611,
-0.02330740913748741,
-0.09437531977891922,
0.5721597671508789,
0.20578056573867798,
-0.2716941237449646,
-0.16771090030670166,
-0.16874928772449493,
-0.10966961085796356,
0.22581934928894043,
-0.3007470369338989,
0.7836083173751831,
-0.22745223343372345,
-0.3366076648235321,
1.0263973474502563,
-0.0720595046877861,
0.6208353638648987,
-0.7658982872962952,
-0.2474513202905655,
-0.3451172709465027,
0.27969202399253845,
-0.6080834865570068,
-0.7018626928329468,
0.033446550369262695,
-0.14590208232402802,
-0.3767978549003601,
-0.5158402323722839,
0.5132032632827759,
-0.6367145776748657,
-0.3390749394893646,
-0.33884209394454956,
0.33894628286361694,
0.11591415852308273,
-0.06495866924524307,
-0.49351808428764343,
0.16336755454540253,
0.30062413215637207,
-0.07013342529535294,
0.4308169484138489,
0.4592870771884918,
-0.0668516606092453,
0.8213750123977661,
0.7704230546951294,
0.23561875522136688,
-0.005140549037605524,
0.17622995376586914,
0.8741658926010132,
-0.6810798048973083,
-0.3039398491382599,
-0.528378963470459,
0.3450620770454407,
-0.2185460776090622,
-0.20825788378715515,
0.7296039462089539,
0.7715431451797485,
0.9918704628944397,
-0.06338381767272949,
0.952142059803009,
0.02240978740155697,
0.4532182216644287,
-0.6305928826332092,
0.7285864949226379,
-0.066315658390522,
0.2821073532104492,
0.12240560352802277,
-0.5963935256004333,
0.2723313868045807,
0.5075900554656982,
-0.429995059967041,
0.1970393806695938,
0.41985026001930237,
0.9844167828559875,
-0.2438284158706665,
0.2337029129266739,
0.20467135310173035,
0.15405575931072235,
0.1727219969034195,
0.3772810399532318,
0.8152782917022705,
-0.25556647777557373,
0.4656881093978882,
-0.619455873966217,
-0.19130448997020721,
-0.19477280974388123,
-0.8193313479423523,
-0.6944819092750549,
-0.5439324975013733,
-0.2825852632522583,
0.007698587141931057,
0.1865120232105255,
0.82090824842453,
0.9941561818122864,
-1.0292013883590698,
-0.1601981520652771,
-0.04799439013004303,
0.02761124260723591,
-0.5200492739677429,
-0.27140721678733826,
0.6392494440078735,
-0.5618663430213928,
-0.6117845177650452,
0.5280944108963013,
-0.2118431180715561,
-0.2553558349609375,
-0.22203843295574188,
-0.01903410628437996,
0.20232993364334106,
-0.17483428120613098,
0.3856915235519409,
0.08340561389923096,
-0.5446263551712036,
-0.25345268845558167,
-0.2317979633808136,
-0.2639497220516205,
-0.11722283810377121,
0.7182109951972961,
-0.9314664006233215,
0.30835220217704773,
0.31205692887306213,
0.6669642329216003,
0.3694021701812744,
0.3517656624317169,
0.44705238938331604,
-1.0942409038543701,
-0.08362217247486115,
0.25505974888801575,
0.09974639117717743,
0.5175577402114868,
-0.3966042399406433,
0.31400537490844727,
-0.2033505141735077,
-0.4580640196800232,
-0.7701369524002075,
-0.00022863969206809998,
-0.6977803111076355,
-0.3184644877910614,
1.1843805313110352,
0.029836518689990044,
-0.10300204157829285,
-0.23125651478767395,
-0.3972683548927307,
0.03099549002945423,
-0.38403820991516113,
1.0807243585586548,
0.645622193813324,
-0.13236156105995178,
-0.019319329410791397,
-0.4321608543395996,
0.5956528186798096,
0.2965039014816284,
-1.0269474983215332,
0.8108280897140503,
0.7275264859199524,
0.6010235548019409,
-0.294058233499527,
0.09446154534816742,
0.1675795167684555,
0.31323444843292236,
-0.10921040922403336,
0.1343582719564438,
-1.0150611400604248,
-0.17302867770195007,
-0.04724384471774101,
0.043051622807979584,
-0.000983159989118576,
-0.327247679233551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14740v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14740v2
|
Modeling the Sacred: Considerations when Using Religious Texts in Natural Language Processing
| 2024-04-23T04:47:22 | 2024-06-25T01:02:16 |
Ben Hutchinson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This position paper concerns the use of religious texts in Natural Language
Processing (NLP), which is of special interest to the Ethics of NLP. Religious
texts are expressions of culturally important values, and machine learned
models have a propensity to reproduce cultural values encoded in their training
data. Furthermore, translations of religious texts are frequently used by NLP
researchers when language data is scarce. This repurposes the translations from
their original uses and motivations, which often involve attracting new
followers. This paper argues that NLP's use of such texts raises considerations
that go beyond model biases, including data provenance, cultural contexts, and
their use in proselytism. We argue for more consideration of researcher
positionality, and of the perspectives of marginalized linguistic and religious
communities.
|
[
-0.040936775505542755,
-0.25420138239860535,
0.16942653059959412,
0.1656990647315979,
-0.3568877577781677,
-0.23618698120117188,
-0.4715758264064789,
-0.8065170049667358,
-0.28740912675857544,
0.7803155183792114,
-0.004641294479370117,
-0.19920247793197632,
-0.7476511001586914,
0.45820143818855286,
-0.38147100806236267,
1.1243304014205933,
0.12692731618881226,
0.27060776948928833,
0.021754393354058266,
-0.4528188705444336,
0.0457882285118103,
-0.9181318879127502,
-0.6109978556632996,
-0.08858854323625565,
0.2614668607711792,
-0.1510290950536728,
1.1567928791046143,
0.8299696445465088,
0.7698527574539185,
0.27039411664009094,
-0.3408416211605072,
-0.10877839475870132,
-0.4443948566913605,
0.4259621500968933,
-0.28324154019355774,
-0.49548906087875366,
-0.11386170983314514,
0.4504701495170593,
0.7884770631790161,
0.8591284155845642,
-0.09229589998722076,
0.5226172208786011,
0.010519173927605152,
0.5143550038337708,
-0.3302391469478607,
0.08138836175203323,
-0.8655467629432678,
0.5618106126785278,
-0.25731679797172546,
-0.5475803017616272,
-0.5864633321762085,
-0.8975844979286194,
0.5083158016204834,
-0.45134350657463074,
0.516872763633728,
0.138946995139122,
0.6288305521011353,
0.4015860855579376,
-0.3523194491863251,
-0.4027871787548065,
-0.7895586490631104,
1.3768301010131836,
-0.696088433265686,
0.3612619936466217,
0.8979250192642212,
-0.020269811153411865,
-0.04886731505393982,
-0.49819275736808777,
-0.13614273071289062,
-0.07989255338907242,
0.07711324840784073,
-0.09477545320987701,
-0.08195618540048599,
-0.13125625252723694,
0.6468881368637085,
0.5800853371620178,
-0.1579502522945404,
0.07587731629610062,
-0.5857164263725281,
0.24676761031150818,
0.42049163579940796,
-0.0006403430015780032,
0.43698638677597046,
-0.2705315947532654,
-0.18967580795288086,
-0.20671866834163666,
-0.7223023176193237,
0.23799943923950195,
0.43770626187324524,
0.314871221780777,
0.21346506476402283,
0.4208585321903229,
0.28697818517684937,
0.8345620036125183,
-0.29996415972709656,
-0.16753335297107697,
0.07241584360599518,
-0.2590402662754059,
-0.4338054060935974,
0.15391108393669128,
0.5806482434272766,
0.37668076157569885,
0.5465638637542725,
-0.20119820535182953,
0.22486858069896698,
0.019466185942292213,
0.9135029911994934,
-0.8470467925071716,
-0.1359996199607849,
-0.10619767755270004,
-0.8845006823539734,
-0.39803871512413025,
-0.16242645680904388,
-0.5520586371421814,
-0.20921912789344788,
-0.4349510669708252,
-0.6215255856513977,
-0.33919116854667664,
-0.2080240100622177,
0.11513510346412659,
-0.2374822497367859,
0.010987807996571064,
0.2672891616821289,
-1.3969151973724365,
0.22378027439117432,
0.7817201018333435,
0.428056001663208,
0.11690204590559006,
-0.02335156314074993,
-0.19866780936717987,
0.3415287435054779,
-0.3877645432949066,
0.5173482894897461,
-1.0205692052841187,
-0.7139590978622437,
0.20635288953781128,
-0.04251391813158989,
0.22105728089809418,
-0.553438127040863,
1.3207321166992188,
-0.6302814483642578,
0.14649352431297302,
-0.9170846939086914,
-0.6447850465774536,
-0.5360962748527527,
-0.07309041172266006,
-0.7614120244979858,
0.7169964909553528,
-0.12023574113845825,
-0.7876992225646973,
0.5262966156005859,
-0.5236428380012512,
-0.27311280369758606,
0.3418305814266205,
-0.32884475588798523,
-0.33053863048553467,
0.5422128438949585,
-0.2541595697402954,
0.2057807296514511,
-0.2001505196094513,
0.33925965428352356,
-0.4163546562194824,
-0.3262123763561249,
0.45015910267829895,
-0.7542977333068848,
1.0296645164489746,
0.48584869503974915,
-0.06419292837381363,
-0.4243486821651459,
-0.5128154158592224,
0.2779220938682556,
0.015979694202542305,
-0.4916274845600128,
-0.9185971617698669,
0.5693718791007996,
0.3022471070289612,
-0.01486437488347292,
0.03931082412600517,
-0.24954697489738464,
0.2284015715122223,
-0.7596889734268188,
0.25904470682144165,
0.7198521494865417,
-0.3240574598312378,
0.7524867653846741,
-0.07388477772474289,
0.3733898997306824,
-0.6742143034934998,
0.3486514389514923,
0.20064285397529602,
-0.7426450252532959,
-0.14389550685882568,
0.2421410232782364,
0.0027397898957133293,
0.3063107132911682,
-0.13549552857875824,
0.19847466051578522,
0.04399968683719635,
-0.18197180330753326,
-0.6631683111190796,
0.20755329728126526,
0.29697802662849426,
0.391240656375885,
0.35512739419937134,
0.03261213377118111,
-0.6079198122024536,
-1.0983045101165771,
-0.8707649111747742,
-0.3081492781639099,
-0.05460664629936218,
0.07386308908462524,
0.21592094004154205,
0.32254064083099365,
0.6950874328613281,
-0.33497267961502075,
-0.2030872404575348,
0.19224338233470917,
0.4387582838535309,
0.10432499647140503,
0.49792999029159546,
0.7887264490127563,
-1.433456301689148,
-0.4580022394657135,
0.07930776476860046,
-1.181950330734253,
-0.12043552100658417,
-0.036847300827503204,
-0.08517646044492722,
0.026950743049383163,
-0.1404591202735901,
-0.2592396140098572,
0.4969048798084259,
0.5628853440284729,
-0.4353002905845642,
0.21877917647361755,
0.05889791250228882,
0.5348232984542847,
-1.1051766872406006,
0.025949466973543167,
-0.03170496225357056,
-0.09320659935474396,
-0.7549224495887756,
0.2882261872291565,
-0.11729637533426285,
0.18014873564243317,
-0.40443047881126404,
0.15024834871292114,
-0.32874375581741333,
0.0901954174041748,
-0.6912710666656494,
-0.6481698751449585,
-0.0076071955263614655,
-0.11315975338220596,
0.48660773038864136,
0.8206658363342285,
0.28806087374687195,
-0.41199010610580444,
-0.09243682026863098,
0.6593537330627441,
-0.07658425718545914,
0.5006260871887207,
-0.2694516181945801,
0.040582817047834396,
0.08055374771356583,
0.07229402661323547,
-0.09767255187034607,
-0.027309808880090714,
0.3049868941307068,
-0.3558715283870697,
0.19708731770515442,
-0.5488187670707703,
-0.7338030338287354,
-0.18026477098464966,
-0.06043185293674469,
0.7560683488845825,
0.7731162905693054,
-0.19538427889347076,
0.27873286604881287,
0.7487009167671204,
-0.19826669991016388,
-0.7216615080833435,
-0.7568808197975159,
0.26110753417015076,
-0.46339139342308044,
-0.5077301859855652,
0.16307874023914337,
0.13192017376422882,
-0.4845268130302429,
0.11275947093963623,
-0.045857205986976624,
-0.2463928759098053,
0.33591026067733765,
0.4013615846633911,
0.16084659099578857,
-0.14205212891101837,
0.1479739099740982,
-0.0025807919446378946,
-0.06726033985614777,
0.3902568519115448,
-0.342451810836792,
0.2222731113433838,
-0.49660369753837585,
-0.18138280510902405,
-0.37474870681762695,
0.9289891719818115,
0.11312603205442429,
-0.1487116664648056,
1.0030194520950317,
0.39867985248565674,
-0.6040173768997192,
0.1520993709564209,
-0.5572708249092102,
-0.030488748103380203,
-0.4735889136791229,
0.027403196319937706,
0.16821378469467163,
-0.8655959367752075,
0.3312838673591614,
0.15122470259666443,
0.3914974629878998,
0.4223927855491638,
0.6156287789344788,
-0.44256389141082764,
0.7474702596664429,
0.7011125683784485,
0.18464380502700806,
0.3823518753051758,
-0.09726216644048691,
0.2365638017654419,
-0.6714221835136414,
0.0242958664894104,
-1.0332279205322266,
-0.07564553618431091,
-0.8592166900634766,
-0.49468231201171875,
0.2593751549720764,
-0.00016097228217404336,
0.15152741968631744,
0.18167538940906525,
-0.7480255365371704,
0.6474496126174927,
0.42115989327430725,
-0.4546590745449066,
0.5743974447250366,
0.4173825979232788,
0.30272459983825684,
-0.6850831508636475,
-0.4133394956588745,
-1.2259204387664795,
0.9698523283004761,
0.29740679264068604,
0.5466200113296509,
-0.0692228302359581,
0.4302840828895569,
0.1692916601896286,
0.4851510524749756,
-0.4667333960533142,
0.3033776879310608,
-0.579774022102356,
-0.9451451897621155,
-0.04980844259262085,
-0.3610765337944031,
-0.8326413631439209,
0.3304937779903412,
0.014183475635945797,
-0.7448413968086243,
0.08021500706672668,
0.03752639889717102,
-0.3274313509464264,
0.6605350375175476,
-0.5324918627738953,
0.4950049817562103,
-0.018420569598674774,
-0.17729707062244415,
-0.22424837946891785,
-0.5411936640739441,
0.12252635508775711,
0.02339012362062931,
0.07319483906030655,
-0.049824122339487076,
0.1719559133052826,
0.9698472023010254,
0.04967514052987099,
0.9785106182098389,
0.18160079419612885,
-0.33419325947761536,
0.31487417221069336,
0.19818176329135895,
0.19664426147937775,
0.0807555615901947,
-0.46735474467277527,
0.45822060108184814,
0.2970520853996277,
-0.17324785888195038,
-0.32890284061431885,
0.6774784326553345,
-0.6574410200119019,
-0.8342073559761047,
-0.7882833480834961,
-0.6296898126602173,
-0.11019010841846466,
0.06439319998025894,
0.13430236279964447,
0.1790728121995926,
-0.06949234753847122,
0.5255298614501953,
0.7515707015991211,
-0.28792351484298706,
0.2222181260585785,
0.4372503459453583,
-0.06734069436788559,
-0.2640582025051117,
0.6092517971992493,
0.23246002197265625,
0.31331855058670044,
0.13170596957206726,
0.3068174719810486,
-0.32098111510276794,
-0.5781143307685852,
-0.4051341712474823,
0.06249856948852539,
-0.7814934253692627,
0.18279966711997986,
-0.7316144108772278,
-0.24835431575775146,
-0.2296408712863922,
-0.44780635833740234,
-0.5291823744773865,
-0.25885534286499023,
-0.6942766308784485,
-0.1655377298593521,
0.3665519952774048,
0.3448523283004761,
0.1640414297580719,
-0.017347276210784912,
-1.0691593885421753,
0.4055591821670532,
-0.16982993483543396,
0.2038636952638626,
-0.2037569284439087,
-0.34710654616355896,
-0.09307612478733063,
0.23257404565811157,
-0.2976452708244324,
-0.7550365328788757,
0.3088636100292206,
-0.1619393527507782,
0.6073605418205261,
0.2931128144264221,
0.11118169873952866,
0.605558454990387,
-0.6237340569496155,
0.6355639696121216,
0.07486720383167267,
-0.6033920645713806,
0.6101763248443604,
-0.518523633480072,
0.22432179749011993,
0.7578648328781128,
0.783215343952179,
-0.714106023311615,
-0.9568485021591187,
-0.8043112754821777,
-0.44832780957221985,
0.5293086767196655,
0.5947044491767883,
0.5033801198005676,
-0.19302386045455933,
0.43313339352607727,
0.49384939670562744,
0.4193100333213806,
-0.9783297181129456,
-0.09289193153381348,
-0.11442166566848755,
0.034403588622808456,
0.47939130663871765,
-0.3406539857387543,
-0.3953109383583069,
-0.4027737081050873,
0.2664114236831665,
-0.03713895380496979,
0.04487589746713638,
0.13812680542469025,
0.12002375721931458,
-0.4713781177997589,
0.2912634611129761,
0.12342480570077896,
0.8699918985366821,
-0.18132294714450836,
0.07949021458625793,
-0.012316878885030746,
-0.5807139873504639,
-0.08473707735538483,
-0.16599887609481812,
-0.7014696598052979,
-0.06073920056223869,
0.1533624529838562,
0.39028400182724,
0.18959537148475647,
-0.12958888709545135,
0.09104728698730469,
-0.08995305746793747,
0.1340315192937851,
-0.6082583665847778,
-0.06317145377397537,
-0.03730310872197151,
0.16949757933616638,
0.293740838766098,
0.6062328219413757,
0.492139607667923,
-0.7011816501617432,
-0.03623327612876892,
0.5155574083328247,
-0.22426506876945496,
-0.5420746207237244,
0.8339530825614929,
-0.04169764369726181,
-0.30081096291542053,
0.6134543418884277,
0.0454883836209774,
-0.5818634629249573,
0.39815160632133484,
0.6197805404663086,
0.8797903060913086,
-0.30584001541137695,
0.2740940451622009,
0.2762240171432495,
0.22489723563194275,
-0.19450724124908447,
0.30939197540283203,
-0.22933174669742584,
-0.5268009305000305,
-0.6856529712677002,
-0.9879733324050903,
-0.3662581741809845,
-0.19013459980487823,
-0.8553154468536377,
-0.07371243089437485,
-0.2148701250553131,
-0.5784677863121033,
-0.040412917733192444,
-0.2708131968975067,
-0.5146335959434509,
-0.061852335929870605,
0.5533570051193237,
0.5811863541603088,
-0.7426607012748718,
0.7557249665260315,
0.4106752574443817,
-0.3962863087654114,
-0.4102207124233246,
-0.11233209073543549,
-0.16723445057868958,
-0.4445238709449768,
0.8023791909217834,
-0.015423317439854145,
-0.1882733553647995,
-0.32077986001968384,
-0.5715103149414062,
-0.5707215070724487,
0.4744094908237457,
0.4387480318546295,
-0.11606913805007935,
-0.20949336886405945,
0.33647167682647705,
0.8596200346946716,
0.1144523173570633,
-0.11883056163787842,
0.20722101628780365,
0.4605341851711273,
0.04362628608942032,
-0.8056007623672485,
-0.03790224343538284,
-0.2299100011587143,
0.04627532139420509,
0.289997935295105,
-0.5272205471992493,
0.5703040957450867,
0.12920933961868286,
-0.3135744631290436,
-0.023482387885451317,
0.6037201881408691,
0.27792829275131226,
0.16455113887786865,
0.11053327471017838,
0.3711403012275696,
0.7940216660499573,
0.09571963548660278,
1.2913258075714111,
0.002008793642744422,
0.24149742722511292,
0.8884949088096619,
-0.1339292675256729,
0.7002154588699341,
0.7505617737770081,
-0.3861483037471771,
0.041387636214494705,
0.49544796347618103,
-0.3693869113922119,
0.4149959087371826,
-0.002573805395513773,
-0.2909281253814697,
-0.32040342688560486,
-0.5306824445724487,
-0.7436547875404358,
0.44819802045822144,
0.3157871961593628,
-0.880440354347229,
-0.22807711362838745,
-0.2562370002269745,
0.07863074541091919,
0.37545841932296753,
-0.026266492903232574,
0.5484084486961365,
0.5533872842788696,
-0.619645893573761,
0.39631587266921997,
0.10209771990776062,
0.26959115266799927,
-0.5086687803268433,
-0.1394408792257309,
0.40365636348724365,
-0.15941494703292847,
-0.28132736682891846,
-0.7773246169090271,
0.9416773915290833,
0.4267275929450989,
-0.4261569380760193,
-1.084396243095398,
0.8327452540397644,
0.09270456433296204,
-0.8214647769927979,
0.14349789917469025,
0.23970258235931396,
0.08965930342674255,
0.010928804986178875,
-0.6039178967475891,
-0.08900309354066849,
0.10724717378616333,
-0.20549128949642181,
0.42412447929382324,
0.36893945932388306,
-0.09659173339605331,
0.5420404076576233,
1.0678644180297852,
0.28687721490859985,
0.09178793430328369,
0.332489013671875,
0.6203961372375488,
-0.9014061093330383,
-0.4594913721084595,
-1.1955535411834717,
0.09588518738746643,
-0.0980011597275734,
-0.4127122163772583,
0.9269658327102661,
0.5964452624320984,
0.6898326277732849,
0.06185486540198326,
0.6793689131736755,
0.16358856856822968,
0.2114892452955246,
-0.6628829836845398,
0.968824028968811,
-0.2917366027832031,
0.14161059260368347,
-0.2864179015159607,
-0.786114513874054,
-0.31545886397361755,
0.9845442771911621,
-0.41295793652534485,
-0.15416866540908813,
0.5270066857337952,
0.09232569485902786,
0.005973744206130505,
1.0454182624816895,
0.15505389869213104,
0.0661713108420372,
0.3678479790687561,
0.2481762021780014,
1.0749777555465698,
-0.44243016839027405,
0.28072378039360046,
-0.2875301241874695,
0.05097779631614685,
0.038989778608083725,
-0.9933103322982788,
-0.727009654045105,
-0.5831693410873413,
-0.23858581483364105,
-0.08781465142965317,
-0.4304337203502655,
1.0754735469818115,
0.44940921664237976,
-0.7290653586387634,
-0.27897363901138306,
0.27851244807243347,
0.06267903000116348,
-0.24408188462257385,
-0.16138453781604767,
0.08159204572439194,
-0.28110358119010925,
-0.9095961451530457,
0.4119552671909332,
0.5163052082061768,
0.12356151640415192,
-0.26798325777053833,
0.2634400725364685,
-0.16831882297992706,
-0.24407367408275604,
0.5502183437347412,
0.32679373025894165,
-0.8932549357414246,
-0.3097929358482361,
0.04213002324104309,
-0.04964199662208557,
0.22525253891944885,
0.787050724029541,
-0.4132617712020874,
0.3699823021888733,
0.410790354013443,
0.6838319897651672,
0.06245550513267517,
0.09095848351716995,
0.8088021278381348,
-0.18322980403900146,
0.051241349428892136,
0.737129807472229,
0.4093271791934967,
0.27576780319213867,
-0.37030696868896484,
0.5312179327011108,
0.24300511181354523,
-0.688118577003479,
-1.0508081912994385,
0.2629590332508087,
-0.8782263398170471,
-0.01291526760905981,
1.2516069412231445,
-0.04562785476446152,
-0.2934325337409973,
-0.3290878236293793,
-0.10622745752334595,
0.2521565854549408,
-0.241672083735466,
0.954110324382782,
0.8744640350341797,
0.19776013493537903,
0.3318111300468445,
-1.0779367685317993,
0.7234820127487183,
0.4209139943122864,
-0.4146506190299988,
0.17014260590076447,
0.3113105297088623,
0.2710067927837372,
0.21586847305297852,
0.5428810715675354,
-0.41272735595703125,
0.0725858062505722,
-0.11993550509214401,
-0.11899741739034653,
0.2701813578605652,
-0.10813573002815247,
-0.029406536370515823,
0.3987666666507721,
0.01581120304763317,
0.20329898595809937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14741v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14741v1
|
Generate-on-Graph: Treat LLM as both Agent and KG in Incomplete Knowledge Graph Question Answering
| 2024-04-23T04:47:22 | 2024-04-23T04:47:22 |
Yao Xu, Shizhu He, Jiabei Chen, Zihao Wang, Yangqiu Song, Hanghang Tong, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
To address the issue of insufficient knowledge and the tendency to generate
hallucination in Large Language Models (LLMs), numerous studies have endeavored
to integrate LLMs with Knowledge Graphs (KGs). However, all these methods are
evaluated on conventional Knowledge Graph Question Answering (KGQA) with
complete KGs, where the factual triples involved in each question are entirely
covered by the given KG. In this situation, LLM mainly acts as an agent to find
answer entities by exploring the KG, rather than effectively integrating
internal and external knowledge sources. However, in real-world scenarios, KGs
are often incomplete to cover all the knowledge required to answer questions.
To simulate real-world scenarios and evaluate the ability of LLMs to integrate
internal and external knowledge, in this paper, we propose leveraging LLMs for
QA under Incomplete Knowledge Graph (IKGQA), where the given KG doesn't include
all the factual triples involved in each question. To handle IKGQA, we propose
a training-free method called Generate-on-Graph (GoG) that can generate new
factual triples while exploring on KGs. Specifically, we propose a
selecting-generating-answering framework, which not only treat the LLM as an
agent to explore on KGs, but also treat it as a KG to generate new facts based
on the explored subgraph and its inherent knowledge. Experimental results on
two datasets demonstrate that our GoG can solve IKGQA to a certain extent,
while almost all previous methods cannot perform well on IKGQA.
|
[
-0.47725221514701843,
-1.0419480800628662,
1.0422918796539307,
-0.09301677346229553,
-0.16648806631565094,
0.3635447025299072,
0.10521450638771057,
-0.4780438542366028,
0.49596959352493286,
0.5380567908287048,
-0.6668500900268555,
-0.39563384652137756,
-0.34469905495643616,
0.18955451250076294,
0.030420852825045586,
0.673945426940918,
-0.30201980471611023,
-0.10423388332128525,
-0.5785229206085205,
-0.10938644409179688,
-0.3524627387523651,
-0.3851543962955475,
-0.9101483821868896,
-0.4862886667251587,
0.5130535960197449,
0.3833099603652954,
0.6308308243751526,
0.3387604057788849,
0.02265709452331066,
0.27205830812454224,
-0.04975087568163872,
0.8009829521179199,
-0.7058379650115967,
0.2752715051174164,
0.06390973925590515,
-0.30977317690849304,
-0.5057117342948914,
0.03132859617471695,
0.5649899840354919,
0.7366337180137634,
0.1904068887233734,
0.18426847457885742,
-0.030139051377773285,
0.40563297271728516,
-0.34798678755760193,
0.5084806680679321,
-0.7811382412910461,
0.1319093406200409,
0.3226182460784912,
-0.2119770348072052,
-0.2690403163433075,
-0.6959682106971741,
0.04156312346458435,
-0.6548537015914917,
-0.08086103200912476,
0.07279578596353531,
0.8207789063453674,
0.17621400952339172,
-0.6209017634391785,
-0.31016239523887634,
-0.5196133852005005,
0.20571847259998322,
-0.4522261619567871,
0.29272446036338806,
0.33335253596305847,
0.5213372707366943,
-0.387556254863739,
-0.8438753485679626,
-0.7508436441421509,
-0.22015805542469025,
-0.046962302178144455,
0.2733181416988373,
-0.11404002457857132,
0.03519101068377495,
0.17984095215797424,
0.03554002195596695,
-0.34198272228240967,
-0.11400343477725983,
-0.1739356368780136,
-0.3413381576538086,
0.5594525933265686,
0.2093740552663803,
0.47959592938423157,
-0.2638217508792877,
-0.18475641310214996,
-0.0699215978384018,
-0.9368481040000916,
0.05851113423705101,
0.43612247705459595,
0.43625590205192566,
0.2326243668794632,
0.8679315447807312,
-0.40023496747016907,
0.6404774188995361,
-0.044111840426921844,
-0.0985402762889862,
0.3459787964820862,
-0.38392919301986694,
-0.09372537583112717,
0.03689508140087128,
0.7812647223472595,
0.10570646077394485,
0.3281765282154083,
-0.5516972541809082,
-0.08368764072656631,
-0.3550258278846741,
0.12425731867551804,
-0.7671319842338562,
-0.12474410980939865,
0.39746609330177307,
0.0241711288690567,
-0.2741805613040924,
-0.2841426134109497,
-0.5623914003372192,
-0.38405871391296387,
-0.01178195234388113,
0.568935215473175,
-0.37266871333122253,
-0.401267409324646,
-0.2868848443031311,
-0.3065173327922821,
0.275547057390213,
0.20415633916854858,
-0.30976489186286926,
-0.05333280935883522,
0.15245695412158966,
0.6303417086601257,
0.22790886461734772,
-0.3328525722026825,
-0.8069298267364502,
0.4049546420574188,
-0.48942145705223083,
0.7617335319519043,
-0.32437828183174133,
-0.243770033121109,
0.10379549860954285,
-0.11110285669565201,
-0.11557690799236298,
-0.4573047459125519,
0.03420080989599228,
-0.9540482759475708,
0.23281747102737427,
-0.587813138961792,
-0.6059238910675049,
-0.29635384678840637,
0.6381134390830994,
-0.6506314277648926,
1.0433887243270874,
0.4349198639392853,
-0.8614587783813477,
0.2991158366203308,
-0.595464825630188,
-0.14392247796058655,
0.20663557946681976,
-0.31031909584999084,
-0.26158952713012695,
-0.40461021661758423,
0.4668029546737671,
0.3982781767845154,
-0.20802439749240875,
0.14061227440834045,
-0.42105942964553833,
-0.19341234862804413,
0.400170236825943,
0.013672958128154278,
0.5660742521286011,
-0.017458004876971245,
-0.19978679716587067,
0.14043189585208893,
-0.6729635000228882,
0.6042736172676086,
0.4046332538127899,
-0.38362908363342285,
-0.025136996060609818,
0.07131136953830719,
-0.6586183905601501,
0.3186931312084198,
0.2788459360599518,
-0.6351457238197327,
0.1457533985376358,
-0.5108318328857422,
0.17514273524284363,
0.6045295596122742,
0.5730745196342468,
0.24790994822978973,
-0.4161115884780884,
0.7869744896888733,
-0.09402097016572952,
-0.16430522501468658,
0.36943361163139343,
-0.6580003499984741,
-0.8382990956306458,
-0.21358726918697357,
0.2153114229440689,
0.48394834995269775,
-1.5423506498336792,
0.10726319253444672,
-0.46329009532928467,
-0.461683452129364,
-0.5681957006454468,
0.14458802342414856,
0.40104612708091736,
0.48300817608833313,
0.29482120275497437,
0.10068277269601822,
-0.43115392327308655,
-0.5632931590080261,
-0.0349656380712986,
-0.31911930441856384,
-0.12981367111206055,
0.6127914190292358,
0.3163127899169922,
-0.050948724150657654,
1.1475770473480225,
-0.7356771230697632,
-0.17881521582603455,
-0.6146953105926514,
-0.21473878622055054,
-0.04971984401345253,
-0.18855838477611542,
0.3798282742500305,
-0.5494245886802673,
-0.5104525089263916,
0.04838256165385246,
-1.1310981512069702,
-0.03300565481185913,
0.1973794549703598,
-0.2992355525493622,
0.17101411521434784,
0.38240692019462585,
-0.8159958124160767,
0.2211001068353653,
0.3197830617427826,
-0.23109221458435059,
0.3456785976886749,
-0.11990422755479813,
0.04561631381511688,
-1.092700719833374,
-0.02843540720641613,
-0.3930664658546448,
-0.40054067969322205,
-0.5703473687171936,
0.1995939463376999,
-0.2200687974691391,
-0.2850845754146576,
-0.5274390578269958,
0.8385326862335205,
-0.5007873177528381,
-0.15648247301578522,
-0.16591565310955048,
0.6567522287368774,
-0.02820614166557789,
0.7679672837257385,
-0.11515374481678009,
0.6167030334472656,
0.39295145869255066,
-0.6405479311943054,
0.5165499448776245,
0.36318469047546387,
-0.18516355752944946,
0.08519817888736725,
-0.3751525282859802,
0.5135807991027832,
-0.34208792448043823,
0.24037893116474152,
-0.9507269263267517,
-0.42057064175605774,
0.7452688217163086,
-0.5233402848243713,
0.13809067010879517,
-0.29121148586273193,
-0.6850449442863464,
-0.5855723023414612,
-0.2219567447900772,
0.31636878848075867,
0.6081979274749756,
-0.5301973223686218,
0.7546045184135437,
0.46959438920021057,
-0.16022711992263794,
-0.45277494192123413,
-0.3814682960510254,
-0.13226370513439178,
-0.022778550162911415,
-0.8907553553581238,
0.010603498667478561,
0.04816735163331032,
-0.07687032222747803,
0.3621453642845154,
-0.039184439927339554,
-0.006703650578856468,
-0.028322862461209297,
0.09750344604253769,
0.13525132834911346,
-0.1711587756872177,
0.054523952305316925,
0.1888909935951233,
-0.045320555567741394,
0.13497394323349,
-0.4045344293117523,
0.607292115688324,
0.08352217823266983,
-0.44169938564300537,
-0.06811046600341797,
0.13964088261127472,
0.4454471170902252,
-0.14390867948532104,
0.7209374904632568,
0.34024330973625183,
-0.3048122525215149,
-0.3960287868976593,
-0.3648720979690552,
-0.024400964379310608,
-0.45845454931259155,
0.462338924407959,
-0.3974435031414032,
-0.8903384208679199,
0.6663870215415955,
-0.01932361163198948,
-0.10267768055200577,
0.29078352451324463,
0.6285654902458191,
0.07976102828979492,
1.0523817539215088,
0.31218719482421875,
0.24722158908843994,
0.1115356907248497,
-0.3718283772468567,
0.37416744232177734,
-0.7660704851150513,
-0.5169979929924011,
-0.2165304273366928,
-0.049225009977817535,
-0.4851909875869751,
-0.4530720114707947,
0.7684217691421509,
0.17114336788654327,
-0.2757675051689148,
0.04700927063822746,
-0.4103216230869293,
0.5212385654449463,
0.4887924790382385,
0.21418946981430054,
0.22109414637088776,
0.07971358299255371,
-0.3944545090198517,
0.5022349953651428,
-1.1058458089828491,
-0.3923397660255432,
1.2833949327468872,
0.01410025916993618,
0.35621345043182373,
0.10984499752521515,
0.711908221244812,
0.008574728854000568,
0.5489882230758667,
-0.6336864233016968,
0.8365368247032166,
0.49473416805267334,
-0.37083137035369873,
-0.5884649753570557,
-0.8665574789047241,
-0.9769420623779297,
0.4791904389858246,
-0.10347625613212585,
-0.7537161111831665,
-0.21355083584785461,
0.19660502672195435,
-0.23360957205295563,
0.4710533916950226,
-0.5629550814628601,
0.694443941116333,
-0.06764359772205353,
-0.003262014826759696,
0.24143674969673157,
-0.40750330686569214,
0.44509175419807434,
-0.10908126831054688,
0.1681656688451767,
-0.12275643646717072,
0.2513582110404968,
0.6332538723945618,
-0.4644574522972107,
0.7557557225227356,
-0.4414583444595337,
-0.14054997265338898,
0.9319133162498474,
0.14877763390541077,
0.9325226545333862,
-0.010097075253725052,
-0.018940987065434456,
-0.14147737622261047,
-0.16728155314922333,
-0.3093833029270172,
-0.6882185935974121,
0.5760322213172913,
-1.0105016231536865,
-0.5975841879844666,
-0.2150484323501587,
-0.6048620939254761,
-0.6252322793006897,
0.16333191096782684,
0.21919390559196472,
0.31258249282836914,
-0.06980516016483307,
-0.3732784688472748,
0.4473864734172821,
-0.2538071572780609,
0.09997687488794327,
0.36132580041885376,
-0.5326456427574158,
-0.6885244250297546,
1.1145904064178467,
0.34815844893455505,
0.46343696117401123,
0.0826897919178009,
0.04605179280042648,
-0.5798236131668091,
-0.4622344374656677,
-0.7023698091506958,
0.3803936541080475,
-1.001617193222046,
-0.35419175028800964,
-0.8760099411010742,
-0.6615003347396851,
-0.4304973781108856,
0.05241197720170021,
0.07460824400186539,
-0.3321654498577118,
-0.1601451337337494,
-0.33870798349380493,
0.3576611876487732,
0.6740790605545044,
0.03332841396331787,
0.07966078817844391,
-0.7897279262542725,
0.4422338008880615,
0.6171079277992249,
0.1658204346895218,
0.2954651713371277,
-0.1849861890077591,
-0.10153498500585556,
0.4257727265357971,
-0.4010249078273773,
-1.0411087274551392,
0.2021678239107132,
-0.10026486963033676,
0.7508190870285034,
0.1433815360069275,
0.11755269765853882,
0.5213268399238586,
-0.43768110871315,
0.6472653746604919,
0.0024656825698912144,
-0.5948489308357239,
0.22969397902488708,
-0.4038529694080353,
0.06275082379579544,
0.41283029317855835,
0.4708685278892517,
-0.4360620975494385,
-0.8422513604164124,
-0.6604375243186951,
-0.9979622960090637,
0.8366725444793701,
0.4116419553756714,
0.05883355811238289,
-0.2854856550693512,
0.3984138071537018,
-0.17460809648036957,
0.3159373700618744,
-0.9356584548950195,
-0.2795288562774658,
-0.24828679859638214,
-0.0946771502494812,
0.2694774270057678,
-0.2660575807094574,
-0.32820460200309753,
-0.0666837990283966,
0.9064525961875916,
-0.332896888256073,
0.41195496916770935,
0.2286287099123001,
-0.04785078763961792,
-0.23840975761413574,
0.09469128400087357,
-0.027942663058638573,
0.7245662808418274,
-0.265128493309021,
0.08441388607025146,
0.29667407274246216,
-0.0016341886948794127,
0.2438911646604538,
0.06421999633312225,
-0.3904142677783966,
-0.27716273069381714,
0.3245674967765808,
0.7249228954315186,
-0.17179663479328156,
-0.7612248659133911,
0.4600986838340759,
0.20000804960727692,
-0.46444371342658997,
-0.32278457283973694,
0.2059217393398285,
0.404904842376709,
0.2976333498954773,
0.2684781849384308,
-0.4500857889652252,
-0.36648571491241455,
-0.5454941391944885,
0.04951326921582222,
0.5676214694976807,
-0.42689618468284607,
-0.04502595588564873,
0.5940349102020264,
0.20246176421642303,
-0.18704700469970703,
0.9950962662696838,
-0.8106653094291687,
-0.6999193429946899,
0.8632673621177673,
0.6594746708869934,
0.7477899193763733,
0.3193499743938446,
0.5540168285369873,
0.14550058543682098,
0.27842721343040466,
0.2732030153274536,
0.5978219509124756,
0.19987931847572327,
-1.0068570375442505,
-0.5540444850921631,
-0.5384994745254517,
-0.4529191553592682,
0.2844255268573761,
-0.22781169414520264,
-0.02020810730755329,
-0.2344149351119995,
0.026307757943868637,
-0.29141443967819214,
0.05070938542485237,
-0.6898807287216187,
0.06710390746593475,
0.09115426987409592,
0.6271401047706604,
-0.5942694544792175,
0.5643159747123718,
0.7878919839859009,
-0.6689615249633789,
-1.132607102394104,
0.09271989017724991,
-0.3137916624546051,
-1.0142056941986084,
0.6059035062789917,
0.057715073227882385,
-0.1412035971879959,
0.27435562014579773,
-0.47747915983200073,
-1.027289628982544,
1.441391110420227,
0.44269490242004395,
0.12483707070350647,
0.00785487238317728,
0.4176819920539856,
0.4944837689399719,
-0.3994544744491577,
0.15999510884284973,
0.15055763721466064,
0.5218278765678406,
0.607314944267273,
-0.5529560446739197,
0.3793148994445801,
-0.02455875091254711,
-0.303945392370224,
0.35140377283096313,
-0.6964302062988281,
0.6549079418182373,
-0.3527640104293823,
-0.4442143142223358,
-0.04277130588889122,
0.587824821472168,
0.479062020778656,
0.3238834738731384,
0.4718128740787506,
0.5060513019561768,
0.938292384147644,
0.05476587638258934,
1.1281183958053589,
-0.2994953393936157,
0.2760806679725647,
0.9847686290740967,
-0.4955478608608246,
0.447128027677536,
0.1621411293745041,
-0.14523863792419434,
0.3331325948238373,
0.6836874485015869,
0.19435828924179077,
0.41062048077583313,
0.3703204393386841,
-0.3061186671257019,
-0.5818294286727905,
-0.05529726296663284,
-0.40392595529556274,
0.2803436517715454,
-0.016575012356042862,
0.03222426399588585,
-0.5191604495048523,
-0.18906649947166443,
0.1408555805683136,
-0.2826237082481384,
-0.32122257351875305,
0.8333608508110046,
0.027726974338293076,
-0.8075903058052063,
0.5067328214645386,
0.028724325820803642,
-0.11181469261646271,
-0.8692671060562134,
-0.1577148139476776,
-0.4221220314502716,
-0.31450992822647095,
0.010982220061123371,
-0.6988527178764343,
0.12670882046222687,
-0.06336367875337601,
0.04318615421652794,
-0.03754255920648575,
0.8026341795921326,
-0.47678351402282715,
-0.5555986762046814,
0.33415210247039795,
1.074194312095642,
0.17852294445037842,
-0.103732168674469,
-0.22239944338798523,
-0.51113361120224,
0.158387690782547,
-0.3071666359901428,
0.44065675139427185,
0.7433682680130005,
-0.04861270636320114,
0.9191873669624329,
0.6925414800643921,
0.03567150607705116,
0.09277525544166565,
-0.11934201419353485,
1.1563670635223389,
-0.4485281705856323,
-0.44913992285728455,
-0.5539093017578125,
0.30298861861228943,
-0.18226087093353271,
0.04720219597220421,
0.7448342442512512,
0.4962342083454132,
0.7191792130470276,
0.1653306633234024,
1.0332040786743164,
-0.21931076049804688,
0.3512839078903198,
-0.7320559024810791,
0.8877586126327515,
-0.6050644516944885,
0.08134549111127853,
-0.11356375366449356,
-0.9790014624595642,
-0.06252250075340271,
0.18618562817573547,
-0.2029731124639511,
-0.004234423395246267,
0.7650567889213562,
0.7140682339668274,
0.06243552640080452,
-0.19362270832061768,
0.3154548406600952,
0.3107648193836212,
0.33868253231048584,
0.5991671085357666,
1.0483485460281372,
-0.05959828943014145,
0.9904296398162842,
0.0647563636302948,
-0.025030354037880898,
0.16573624312877655,
-0.6757705211639404,
-0.9831430315971375,
-0.42266136407852173,
-0.1852331906557083,
-0.7123092412948608,
-0.09370104968547821,
0.7950646877288818,
0.25471919775009155,
-0.3548027276992798,
0.1446497142314911,
0.09327763319015503,
0.6297712326049805,
-0.10780870914459229,
-0.2323654741048813,
0.6690121293067932,
-0.505744457244873,
-0.43612268567085266,
0.5243916511535645,
-0.011071134358644485,
0.1503368467092514,
-0.25696614384651184,
-0.08020471781492233,
-0.05101567506790161,
0.2574697732925415,
0.5159345865249634,
0.2721237242221832,
-0.3926733434200287,
-0.7051127552986145,
-0.03659975156188011,
0.12289702147245407,
0.08724281191825867,
0.6947306990623474,
-1.074668526649475,
0.4074685275554657,
0.5155755281448364,
0.7803782820701599,
0.5814782381057739,
-0.12972670793533325,
0.4492846131324768,
-0.9277403354644775,
-0.24983946979045868,
0.2209448516368866,
0.2612880766391754,
0.20628027617931366,
-0.3437054455280304,
0.5628649592399597,
0.29983803629875183,
-0.37033554911613464,
-0.7710755467414856,
0.5100605487823486,
-0.791204571723938,
-0.30510684847831726,
1.4459036588668823,
-0.18094231188297272,
-0.15573807060718536,
-0.251756876707077,
-0.09580748528242111,
0.4494358003139496,
-0.1441185176372528,
0.7077487707138062,
0.725643515586853,
-0.32312676310539246,
0.19614633917808533,
-0.41758105158805847,
0.4276125431060791,
-0.05169106274843216,
-1.0125232934951782,
-0.05238892883062363,
0.6000838279724121,
0.4423636198043823,
0.05089076608419418,
1.1404435634613037,
0.054962024092674255,
0.037084516137838364,
0.1514378935098648,
0.13096438348293304,
-0.5357500910758972,
-0.276431679725647,
0.3803355097770691,
0.5669247508049011,
0.20804058015346527,
-0.1636030375957489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14736v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14736v1
|
Qualitative Approaches to Voice UX
| 2024-04-23T04:33:49 | 2024-04-23T04:33:49 |
Katie Seaborn, Jacqueline Urakami, Peter Pennefather, Norihisa P. Miyake
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Voice is a natural mode of expression offered by modern computer-based
systems. Qualitative perspectives on voice-based user experiences (voice UX)
offer rich descriptions of complex interactions that numbers alone cannot fully
represent. We conducted a systematic review of the literature on qualitative
approaches to voice UX, capturing the nature of this body of work in a
systematic map and offering a qualitative synthesis of findings. We highlight
the benefits of qualitative methods for voice UX research, identify
opportunities for increasing rigour in methods and outcomes, and distill
patterns of experience across a diversity of devices and modes of qualitative
praxis.
|
[
-0.4499365985393524,
-0.44163066148757935,
0.6656811237335205,
0.12920817732810974,
-0.23499128222465515,
0.6643437743186951,
-0.12838907539844513,
-0.5868641138076782,
0.148961141705513,
0.36468955874443054,
-0.6199450492858887,
-0.346893310546875,
0.20762662589550018,
-0.18956033885478973,
-0.6658345460891724,
0.5361921787261963,
0.3027292490005493,
0.3018759787082672,
-0.02192625217139721,
-0.14217634499073029,
-0.738898515701294,
-0.8869446516036987,
-0.6140919923782349,
-0.3734607696533203,
0.6177182793617249,
0.5178228616714478,
0.8191020488739014,
-0.16870012879371643,
0.041367221623659134,
0.2824494242668152,
-0.1235266923904419,
-0.15216411650180817,
-0.4701663851737976,
0.3944738805294037,
0.3745613992214203,
-0.48279517889022827,
-0.24676835536956787,
0.28869834542274475,
0.5772088766098022,
0.880615770816803,
-0.6622262597084045,
0.4275994300842285,
0.2621079385280609,
0.3766482174396515,
-0.5338892340660095,
-0.28555288910865784,
-0.07602500170469284,
0.48354312777519226,
-0.08344116806983948,
-0.06401386111974716,
-0.27060258388519287,
-0.45508092641830444,
0.23875992000102997,
-0.6805591583251953,
-0.017660731449723244,
-0.030833734199404716,
0.3761223256587982,
-0.28174489736557007,
-0.3249911963939667,
0.021556982770562172,
-1.4232717752456665,
0.6755229234695435,
-1.1337074041366577,
0.3033735156059265,
-0.0648067519068718,
0.6050659418106079,
-0.024904463440179825,
-0.819093644618988,
-0.7293761968612671,
-0.029451344162225723,
0.007919435389339924,
0.13870969414710999,
-0.3192179501056671,
0.26112228631973267,
0.32597091794013977,
0.500140368938446,
-0.4238038957118988,
0.022294722497463226,
-0.38461145758628845,
-0.029619986191391945,
0.8221710920333862,
0.35050806403160095,
0.8015749454498291,
-0.041122596710920334,
-0.2758549153804779,
0.0022874928545206785,
-0.531886100769043,
0.5816574096679688,
0.33280277252197266,
0.2871719300746918,
0.005208188202232122,
0.4826579689979553,
-0.47957491874694824,
0.8791024088859558,
0.19903716444969177,
-0.43404871225357056,
-0.23440517485141754,
-0.19169914722442627,
-0.3118143081665039,
0.3097708523273468,
0.5397424697875977,
0.47548702359199524,
0.0018352929037064314,
-0.22440744936466217,
-0.0944744199514389,
-0.12600094079971313,
0.5722841620445251,
-0.47626107931137085,
0.20256231725215912,
0.4079627990722656,
-0.7499819993972778,
-0.21720415353775024,
0.16296610236167908,
-0.5882858037948608,
-0.5277594327926636,
-0.9662541151046753,
0.4241926670074463,
-0.045441266149282455,
-0.86781245470047,
0.0956740751862526,
-0.3136381506919861,
0.5394213795661926,
0.5201489925384521,
-0.211442232131958,
0.6832289099693298,
0.5546446442604065,
0.5953813791275024,
-0.11246708780527115,
0.030559979379177094,
-0.12555861473083496,
-0.25812315940856934,
-0.4126281142234802,
0.6442140936851501,
-0.5240936279296875,
-0.7886194586753845,
0.13332949578762054,
-0.3148880898952484,
-0.016007648780941963,
-0.9136403203010559,
0.6700340509414673,
-0.08560796082019806,
0.3803137540817261,
-0.4085679352283478,
-0.24140869081020355,
-0.5091578364372253,
-0.2938651740550995,
-0.6312780976295471,
1.195525884628296,
0.1804337054491043,
-0.3243877589702606,
0.2770461142063141,
-0.6525870561599731,
-0.41992244124412537,
0.046999379992485046,
-0.1215704157948494,
0.10505126416683197,
0.52851802110672,
-0.06789592653512955,
0.37026554346084595,
-0.20687642693519592,
0.2456543892621994,
-0.08157956600189209,
-0.5381496548652649,
0.7082884311676025,
-0.0958215594291687,
1.042029619216919,
0.6300775408744812,
-0.724480152130127,
0.3791481852531433,
-0.8287834525108337,
0.5388641357421875,
0.039487194269895554,
-0.0020370217971503735,
-0.28719016909599304,
0.22845996916294098,
0.5143932104110718,
0.26292282342910767,
-0.36377203464508057,
-0.44839492440223694,
0.15411384403705597,
-0.0612543486058712,
0.719450056552887,
-0.07620153576135635,
0.04014301300048828,
0.4229195713996887,
-0.3394686281681061,
0.7267823815345764,
0.02024690806865692,
0.5683571696281433,
0.05373920872807503,
-0.44743263721466064,
-0.6542267799377441,
-0.14797405898571014,
0.06775187700986862,
0.28056883811950684,
-0.44433102011680603,
0.061357297003269196,
0.10660071671009064,
-0.6705650687217712,
-0.8163332939147949,
-0.04691573977470398,
0.24731017649173737,
0.32512345910072327,
0.16289082169532776,
-0.41664111614227295,
-0.45018860697746277,
-0.7783189415931702,
-0.27451154589653015,
-0.43226948380470276,
-0.31067582964897156,
0.07403576374053955,
-0.1741199642419815,
0.09389263391494751,
1.115169882774353,
-0.08765056729316711,
-0.03892926871776581,
-0.5182121992111206,
0.5665287375450134,
-0.12537406384944916,
0.21160228550434113,
0.4774863123893738,
-0.9424481391906738,
-0.1683504283428192,
-0.1385452151298523,
-0.5225833654403687,
-0.33025482296943665,
-0.5921112895011902,
0.17799855768680573,
-0.17754751443862915,
0.3488828241825104,
-0.6460596919059753,
0.5256874561309814,
0.17874553799629211,
-0.23826542496681213,
0.43537387251853943,
0.4072328805923462,
0.6473247408866882,
-0.7985112071037292,
0.058158546686172485,
0.020695285871624947,
-0.055444296449422836,
-1.0274722576141357,
0.06885911524295807,
-0.2998118996620178,
-0.5466983914375305,
-0.7889575362205505,
0.22221535444259644,
-0.8036002516746521,
-0.23729641735553741,
-0.2979251444339752,
0.02175956964492798,
0.2014659345149994,
0.17849226295948029,
0.08878089487552643,
0.6152973175048828,
0.25312304496765137,
-0.2726413905620575,
0.45956340432167053,
-0.02108808048069477,
-0.2347460240125656,
0.9993535280227661,
-0.9210583567619324,
0.353464275598526,
0.15489695966243744,
0.25715166330337524,
-1.1875611543655396,
0.06255953013896942,
0.14103499054908752,
-0.503581166267395,
0.36247333884239197,
0.016961542889475822,
-0.32850193977355957,
-0.3186818063259125,
-0.15956221520900726,
0.3919607996940613,
0.4304500222206116,
-0.2629207968711853,
0.7461336255073547,
0.6747291088104248,
-0.5582716464996338,
0.12065482139587402,
-0.28836947679519653,
0.5634034872055054,
-0.4438086152076721,
-0.421536386013031,
0.0015200607012957335,
0.03768494725227356,
-0.778930127620697,
-0.44574639201164246,
0.016689972952008247,
-0.3851267695426941,
0.3093292713165283,
0.48455220460891724,
-0.03701715171337128,
-0.18705566227436066,
-0.28282463550567627,
-0.15215644240379333,
0.24589557945728302,
0.27172529697418213,
0.13176223635673523,
0.06286314874887466,
0.03283880278468132,
-0.17492756247520447,
-0.7960157990455627,
1.1568633317947388,
0.7285473346710205,
-0.22692137956619263,
-0.06231608986854553,
0.7120440602302551,
-0.4718199670314789,
0.0006292130565270782,
-0.5943785905838013,
-0.23826880753040314,
-0.3544688820838928,
-0.38289177417755127,
-0.31988897919654846,
-0.9937496185302734,
0.39617761969566345,
-0.14000451564788818,
-0.01906595379114151,
0.22141581773757935,
0.2959153950214386,
-0.6579203009605408,
1.183343529701233,
0.342429518699646,
-0.034687161445617676,
0.2827538549900055,
-0.04728194326162338,
0.42088583111763,
-0.8588908314704895,
-0.4391706883907318,
-0.7773875594139099,
-0.5808208584785461,
-0.03803134337067604,
-0.017799612134695053,
0.2743813097476959,
0.08911380171775818,
-0.008978956378996372,
-0.003547042142599821,
-0.709636390209198,
-0.2844955623149872,
0.7236214876174927,
0.002149038016796112,
0.127461776137352,
-0.11041896045207977,
-0.09031374752521515,
-0.28927093744277954,
-0.732315182685852,
-0.38463905453681946,
0.6097390651702881,
0.2407529354095459,
0.8688356280326843,
0.31494972109794617,
0.5439664721488953,
0.46074536442756653,
0.10545410960912704,
-0.7269278764724731,
0.5386515259742737,
0.8016265630722046,
-0.6315854787826538,
-0.5419818162918091,
-0.07425247877836227,
-0.9394041299819946,
0.3449152410030365,
-0.6021755337715149,
-0.8310734629631042,
0.3652741611003876,
-0.05364959314465523,
-0.6434098482131958,
0.008835125714540482,
-0.96995609998703,
0.429494172334671,
-0.2599842846393585,
-0.5618115067481995,
-0.07053561508655548,
-0.7982718348503113,
0.16614973545074463,
0.48882266879081726,
0.28043460845947266,
0.2320738583803177,
0.4777141213417053,
0.7622026205062866,
-0.25817498564720154,
1.153928279876709,
-0.4101997911930084,
-0.30667081475257874,
0.8974618911743164,
0.06694381684064865,
-0.15772151947021484,
-0.08887144178152084,
0.23546111583709717,
0.15691353380680084,
0.4697295129299164,
-0.28435981273651123,
-0.7270987629890442,
0.531862735748291,
-0.5993725061416626,
-0.4738343060016632,
-0.4036349356174469,
-0.16140134632587433,
-0.5611143112182617,
0.25456658005714417,
0.07450912892818451,
0.5313247442245483,
-0.6122885942459106,
0.0034280410036444664,
0.3714880645275116,
-0.20442084968090057,
0.25998014211654663,
0.1696382313966751,
-0.3386555314064026,
-0.19352227449417114,
0.44098883867263794,
0.29864999651908875,
0.19214868545532227,
0.23080986738204956,
0.2463797777891159,
-0.6694924831390381,
-0.5121564269065857,
-0.28261494636535645,
0.011605327017605305,
-0.30435582995414734,
0.2104259431362152,
-0.3942006528377533,
-0.2300737351179123,
-0.5185716152191162,
0.006095184478908777,
-0.1511901617050171,
-0.6125128269195557,
-0.3685655891895294,
-0.1667124330997467,
-0.022109953686594963,
0.9275289177894592,
-0.05090584233403206,
0.5388283133506775,
-0.6466562151908875,
0.5800321102142334,
0.6266911029815674,
0.1484014242887497,
0.17483121156692505,
-0.1651971936225891,
-0.1788976490497589,
0.23027457296848297,
-0.43136709928512573,
-1.0263508558273315,
0.14635632932186127,
0.1709548383951187,
0.7182649970054626,
0.3453576862812042,
0.10671123117208481,
0.7127406001091003,
-0.3197547197341919,
1.2078940868377686,
0.4675539433956146,
-0.9169766306877136,
0.4883090853691101,
-0.44308748841285706,
0.46678924560546875,
0.5154668688774109,
0.4431181252002716,
-0.7925270795822144,
-0.09393758326768875,
-0.8604367971420288,
-0.8443076014518738,
-0.09403287619352341,
0.08567887544631958,
-0.005818817764520645,
0.446421355009079,
0.39890503883361816,
-0.07165391743183136,
0.5836224555969238,
-0.13452136516571045,
-0.09764032810926437,
-0.3281361758708954,
0.057064272463321686,
-0.07601286470890045,
-0.38368865847587585,
-0.38589605689048767,
-0.3787935674190521,
-0.030693350359797478,
-0.02034918963909149,
0.3896087408065796,
0.39770084619522095,
-0.1357278823852539,
-0.03211554139852524,
0.7197460532188416,
0.6383841037750244,
0.874874472618103,
-0.19167675077915192,
0.2523941397666931,
-0.2174537032842636,
-0.26203376054763794,
0.2071603387594223,
-0.37555426359176636,
-0.0606561042368412,
0.2859070599079132,
0.1728220283985138,
0.4880094528198242,
0.6420465111732483,
-0.5212973356246948,
0.3255631625652313,
-0.27957794070243835,
-0.34671294689178467,
-0.41016724705696106,
0.0006246268749237061,
0.2810487151145935,
0.2269858717918396,
0.7175423502922058,
-0.3880772292613983,
0.9042940735816956,
-0.7559563517570496,
-0.12699130177497864,
0.3082154393196106,
-0.5018829703330994,
-0.4720878005027771,
0.6838895678520203,
0.4667854905128479,
-0.37432193756103516,
0.3286868929862976,
0.49659088253974915,
-0.10209627449512482,
0.10773245245218277,
0.3992997705936432,
1.1413707733154297,
-0.38937827944755554,
0.4738101065158844,
0.17740485072135925,
0.07927080988883972,
-0.0780627653002739,
0.5838109254837036,
-0.47105300426483154,
-0.16492848098278046,
-0.2145274579524994,
-0.22046314179897308,
-0.7784062027931213,
0.0869653970003128,
-1.127990961074829,
-0.24884381890296936,
-0.3421170711517334,
-0.5848005414009094,
0.12788555026054382,
-0.1122131198644638,
-0.5991376042366028,
0.4968792498111725,
0.40925073623657227,
0.6345068216323853,
-0.7471738457679749,
0.17326468229293823,
0.7756320238113403,
-0.12504827976226807,
-1.1350734233856201,
-0.14688044786453247,
0.38748908042907715,
-0.1702745258808136,
0.3760524392127991,
-0.14849133789539337,
-0.419985830783844,
0.09492035955190659,
-0.537345290184021,
-0.36296990513801575,
0.8621458411216736,
0.20216037333011627,
-0.595738410949707,
0.09641974419355392,
0.2675205171108246,
0.6525318622589111,
-0.33331477642059326,
0.32483410835266113,
0.2971187233924866,
0.5295556783676147,
-0.30920806527137756,
-1.002083420753479,
0.08658596873283386,
-0.4650722146034241,
0.3640657067298889,
-0.2809455692768097,
-0.5062586069107056,
0.5268483757972717,
-0.1707352250814438,
-0.7385493516921997,
0.21098563075065613,
0.6247589588165283,
-0.17244918644428253,
0.5685240030288696,
0.5471267104148865,
0.34572651982307434,
0.5050073266029358,
-0.19790545105934143,
0.8585843443870544,
0.25985029339790344,
-0.1514265239238739,
0.8904352188110352,
-0.5067933797836304,
0.81246417760849,
0.8163182139396667,
-0.39908573031425476,
0.5768080949783325,
0.5853834748268127,
0.6365092396736145,
-0.014264845289289951,
0.5889142751693726,
-0.45548495650291443,
-0.24111229181289673,
-0.24993428587913513,
-0.3904254138469696,
0.5928036570549011,
0.19767889380455017,
0.2848065197467804,
0.03468261659145355,
0.14618973433971405,
-0.07666488736867905,
0.44495177268981934,
-0.07757993787527084,
1.1170835494995117,
0.10889705270528793,
-0.4791966378688812,
0.6586147546768188,
-0.49107247591018677,
0.3165801167488098,
-0.25428512692451477,
-0.48058658838272095,
-0.025293782353401184,
-0.5994077920913696,
-0.5475862622261047,
-0.8364294767379761,
0.15068408846855164,
-0.2640126049518585,
-0.07867663353681564,
-0.5011735558509827,
1.0105525255203247,
-0.05753860995173454,
-0.35396671295166016,
-0.010574132204055786,
0.7203958034515381,
-0.04514085873961449,
-0.3524056673049927,
-0.5291592478752136,
0.36852872371673584,
-0.24269843101501465,
-0.2726748287677765,
0.2586071491241455,
0.4334191381931305,
-0.1242586299777031,
0.5651413202285767,
0.7481032609939575,
0.26446622610092163,
0.07765623182058334,
0.23251552879810333,
0.5963430404663086,
-0.9394517540931702,
-0.4313827157020569,
-0.13993901014328003,
0.8695042729377747,
-0.24042420089244843,
-0.4467593729496002,
0.5937992930412292,
0.4263903796672821,
0.6621292233467102,
-0.039953116327524185,
1.159461498260498,
-0.0040804133750498295,
1.0068092346191406,
-0.4156525433063507,
0.6859704852104187,
-0.5719165205955505,
-0.07134543359279633,
-0.37243402004241943,
-0.659753143787384,
-0.1348041146993637,
0.6866921186447144,
0.18496844172477722,
-0.1552191823720932,
0.3526138663291931,
0.33642473816871643,
0.015878183767199516,
0.3667110502719879,
0.4259887933731079,
-0.005965290125459433,
0.19300957024097443,
0.08879537880420685,
1.4740431308746338,
-0.02327464520931244,
-0.08503863215446472,
-0.17517827451229095,
-0.43085721135139465,
-0.31605106592178345,
-0.6607511639595032,
-0.5462577939033508,
-0.993270218372345,
-0.25187891721725464,
-0.144134521484375,
-0.13810451328754425,
0.5457068681716919,
0.9812715649604797,
-0.40183430910110474,
-0.5855125188827515,
0.5648086667060852,
-0.12166672199964523,
-0.5885462164878845,
-0.3188557028770447,
-0.5289252400398254,
-0.013621095567941666,
-0.41754934191703796,
0.459503710269928,
0.17711806297302246,
-0.054903849959373474,
-0.541056215763092,
-0.001157958758994937,
0.052979275584220886,
0.04840639978647232,
0.8491404056549072,
0.712597668170929,
-0.6977778673171997,
-0.2145771086215973,
0.3175748586654663,
-0.1321764886379242,
-0.0389615036547184,
1.3887686729431152,
-0.7285799384117126,
0.32980042695999146,
0.34727829694747925,
0.5361553430557251,
0.31053829193115234,
-0.004326967988163233,
0.7950611114501953,
-0.1593266874551773,
-0.034436747431755066,
0.47976475954055786,
-0.018313976004719734,
0.44037652015686035,
-0.23522165417671204,
0.18418346345424652,
0.030623089522123337,
-0.12285146862268448,
-0.8740127682685852,
0.2506099343299866,
-1.7731304168701172,
-0.2702912986278534,
1.2271960973739624,
0.1791042536497116,
0.0701928660273552,
-0.38494154810905457,
-0.8384173512458801,
0.10589312016963959,
-0.2705349624156952,
0.7737306356430054,
0.60074383020401,
-0.2793659567832947,
-0.44666150212287903,
-0.6593251824378967,
0.483388751745224,
0.12087574601173401,
-0.6517102718353271,
-0.29415637254714966,
0.6558502912521362,
0.15600144863128662,
0.13508088886737823,
0.644595742225647,
-0.2551704943180084,
0.17211996018886566,
-0.25937989354133606,
0.32085782289505005,
0.2032383233308792,
-0.16710171103477478,
-0.2065543383359909,
0.2296944260597229,
0.5756442546844482,
0.1423748880624771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14723v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14723v1
|
Insights into Alignment: Evaluating DPO and its Variants Across Multiple Tasks
| 2024-04-23T03:55:01 | 2024-04-23T03:55:01 |
Amir Saeidi, Shivanshu Verma, Chitta Baral
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance across
a spectrum of tasks. Recently, Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) has emerged
as an RL-free approach to optimize the policy model on human preferences.
However, several limitations hinder the widespread adoption of this method. To
address these shortcomings, various versions of DPO have been introduced. Yet,
a comprehensive evaluation of these variants across diverse tasks is still
lacking. In this study, we aim to bridge this gap by investigating the
performance of alignment methods across three distinct scenarios: (1) keeping
the Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) part, (2) skipping the SFT part, and (3)
skipping the SFT part and utilizing an instruction-tuned model. Furthermore, we
explore the impact of different training sizes on their performance. Our
evaluation spans a range of tasks including dialogue systems, reasoning,
mathematical problem-solving, question answering, truthfulness, and multi-task
understanding, encompassing 13 benchmarks such as MT-Bench, Big Bench, and Open
LLM Leaderboard. Key observations reveal that alignment methods achieve optimal
performance with smaller training data subsets, exhibit limited effectiveness
in reasoning tasks yet significantly impact mathematical problem-solving, and
employing an instruction-tuned model notably influences truthfulness. We
anticipate that our findings will catalyze further research aimed at developing
more robust models to address alignment challenges.
|
[
-0.1941916048526764,
-0.5604952573776245,
0.6899759769439697,
0.18052014708518982,
-0.05082724988460541,
0.2166910022497177,
-0.3849165737628937,
-0.3972625732421875,
-0.2749618887901306,
0.2931569218635559,
-0.7884964346885681,
-0.3062434494495392,
-0.6866567730903625,
0.2770041227340698,
0.020354222506284714,
0.7434394359588623,
-0.24030745029449463,
0.16936591267585754,
-0.39064785838127136,
0.04155629500746727,
-0.804373562335968,
-0.12559062242507935,
-0.3753191828727722,
-0.4941713511943817,
0.4031495451927185,
0.6458276510238647,
0.8511219620704651,
1.261788249015808,
0.8726389408111572,
0.3116476833820343,
-0.12088476121425629,
0.36790767312049866,
-0.5133699178695679,
0.06250171363353729,
-0.1231376975774765,
-0.364396333694458,
-0.5035971999168396,
0.22662873566150665,
0.6871768236160278,
0.8003764152526855,
-0.19751699268817902,
0.05284794047474861,
0.2595978379249573,
0.9371147155761719,
-0.7655779123306274,
-0.01947510428726673,
-0.6874849200248718,
0.031964801251888275,
0.09752912819385529,
0.06522516161203384,
-0.300662636756897,
-0.34868523478507996,
0.44167912006378174,
-0.7968698740005493,
-0.06781076639890671,
0.022924892604351044,
0.6765220165252686,
0.7839273810386658,
-0.4598518908023834,
-0.3561384975910187,
-0.6584758758544922,
1.109361171722412,
-0.5450015664100647,
0.46501946449279785,
0.23335297405719757,
0.10979755222797394,
-0.23930494487285614,
-0.030284732580184937,
-0.5588812828063965,
-0.03474770486354828,
-0.07487836480140686,
0.18871943652629852,
0.04130857065320015,
0.2812747061252594,
0.3520819842815399,
0.43765953183174133,
-0.4420068562030792,
0.44845667481422424,
0.1136183962225914,
-0.003899703500792384,
0.6616328358650208,
0.2228742390871048,
0.002552472986280918,
-0.15291723608970642,
-0.40022072196006775,
-0.13031046092510223,
-0.36617639660835266,
0.13641461730003357,
0.7059786319732666,
0.40678876638412476,
0.04069243371486664,
0.7063843607902527,
-0.27801835536956787,
1.1433764696121216,
0.507272481918335,
-0.5642754435539246,
0.12523159384727478,
-0.5536380410194397,
-0.061303965747356415,
0.029821578413248062,
0.8342631459236145,
0.4085303843021393,
0.161852166056633,
-0.06043420732021332,
-0.0663064494729042,
-0.028414668515324593,
0.3297662138938904,
-0.4488690197467804,
0.11026748269796371,
0.1957426816225052,
-0.330666184425354,
-0.2379618138074875,
-0.2113758623600006,
-0.6865319013595581,
-0.49089622497558594,
-0.9507877230644226,
0.18481960892677307,
-0.518726110458374,
0.050002530217170715,
0.3605244755744934,
0.03681774437427521,
0.21687649190425873,
0.4015159606933594,
-1.134627342224121,
0.2696816623210907,
1.2414615154266357,
0.5847423076629639,
-0.6025806665420532,
-0.3954056203365326,
-0.41884028911590576,
0.020499134436249733,
-0.23757490515708923,
0.39368703961372375,
-0.6642215251922607,
-0.22961193323135376,
-0.10308261215686798,
-0.3868377208709717,
-0.44364529848098755,
-0.4085718095302582,
0.7770798206329346,
-0.2657661736011505,
0.1609359234571457,
-0.4352819621562958,
-0.7435523867607117,
0.010139331221580505,
0.2803095579147339,
-0.5599987506866455,
0.9759383797645569,
-0.18854765594005585,
-0.7703965902328491,
0.5727254152297974,
-0.471885085105896,
-0.26790547370910645,
-0.4552246034145355,
-0.28973108530044556,
-0.43672293424606323,
0.11109522730112076,
0.28454574942588806,
0.3060477077960968,
-0.26179271936416626,
0.39490199089050293,
-0.19172696769237518,
-0.6315172910690308,
0.16531139612197876,
-0.2449565827846527,
0.569068193435669,
0.02110365219414234,
-0.4711730480194092,
0.13829931616783142,
-0.8959560990333557,
-0.07706930488348007,
0.022136855870485306,
-0.21250519156455994,
-0.3675648272037506,
0.1313333660364151,
-0.6348389387130737,
0.23960421979427338,
0.5046129822731018,
-0.6113852858543396,
0.47800901532173157,
-0.38029250502586365,
0.2708144783973694,
1.0000885725021362,
-0.3659609258174896,
0.5471895337104797,
-0.25436267256736755,
0.5375856757164001,
-0.0787878930568695,
0.34331315755844116,
0.2829931676387787,
-0.30434444546699524,
-0.6383589506149292,
-0.453334242105484,
0.3379279375076294,
0.6639887690544128,
-0.3617100417613983,
0.6090794801712036,
-0.47313129901885986,
-0.41857510805130005,
-0.7856967449188232,
0.21627359092235565,
0.6272045373916626,
0.6515394449234009,
0.21060435473918915,
0.02136027254164219,
-0.35011938214302063,
-1.2008839845657349,
-0.35479775071144104,
0.08161097764968872,
0.32563644647598267,
0.2625322937965393,
0.38807055354118347,
-0.037099964916706085,
1.0087565183639526,
-0.6814197897911072,
-0.016585201025009155,
-0.04678666591644287,
-0.1648559421300888,
0.21100889146327972,
0.46935513615608215,
0.4268483817577362,
-0.5819293856620789,
-0.6561785936355591,
0.10233546048402786,
-0.3088419735431671,
-0.021275758743286133,
0.02518019825220108,
-0.24106092751026154,
0.1293552815914154,
-0.04487834498286247,
-0.4296663701534271,
0.21753112971782684,
0.6444641947746277,
0.0807272344827652,
0.43468835949897766,
-0.001003093202598393,
0.37701621651649475,
-0.8398400545120239,
-0.059615667909383774,
-0.06598439812660217,
0.0013024715008214116,
-0.5318813323974609,
-0.32766544818878174,
0.16652178764343262,
-0.06320945173501968,
-0.07418984174728394,
0.22923433780670166,
-0.41634565591812134,
-0.17764416337013245,
-0.14502541720867157,
0.1874927431344986,
-0.0019772364757955074,
0.5176029205322266,
0.07574937492609024,
0.9845098257064819,
0.3709580600261688,
-0.4040719270706177,
0.08530428260564804,
0.48001763224601746,
-0.3163672089576721,
0.4314495623111725,
-0.5058751702308655,
0.43527695536613464,
-0.11515238136053085,
-0.04972190409898758,
-1.1071735620498657,
-0.0961102768778801,
0.19933323562145233,
-0.030560797080397606,
0.5064842104911804,
-0.0689392164349556,
-0.4291316568851471,
-0.2715369462966919,
-0.3594876229763031,
0.37946462631225586,
0.2689754068851471,
-0.4738575220108032,
0.2867515981197357,
0.07090652734041214,
0.073143869638443,
-1.1609642505645752,
-0.26207032799720764,
-0.32323384284973145,
-0.35997679829597473,
-0.5864487290382385,
0.5688576102256775,
-0.025098156183958054,
-0.23989564180374146,
-0.30588531494140625,
-0.5682616829872131,
0.15051083266735077,
0.23224417865276337,
0.10374188423156738,
0.35049140453338623,
0.03237467631697655,
-0.030086888000369072,
0.019194962456822395,
-0.003223482985049486,
-0.4311341345310211,
-0.0667465329170227,
0.4319463074207306,
-0.07829838246107101,
-0.46581515669822693,
-0.7190110683441162,
0.2932495176792145,
0.4169178903102875,
-0.32980960607528687,
0.6587861180305481,
0.13435542583465576,
0.015646561980247498,
0.004791452549397945,
-0.646744430065155,
0.01673935167491436,
-0.4467758238315582,
0.23398852348327637,
-0.4650852382183075,
-0.9326151609420776,
0.35913413763046265,
-0.022935573011636734,
0.22278501093387604,
0.21163146197795868,
0.21940630674362183,
0.041453201323747635,
1.1306893825531006,
0.5891643762588501,
0.0715453177690506,
0.7605808973312378,
0.1136021837592125,
0.30178919434547424,
-0.9895079731941223,
-0.0410010851919651,
-0.565526008605957,
-0.5646554827690125,
-0.652228057384491,
-0.29629388451576233,
0.15328159928321838,
0.2401813566684723,
-0.2413330078125,
0.4370070695877075,
-0.7776208519935608,
0.5299145579338074,
0.5114470720291138,
0.10075518488883972,
0.47853726148605347,
-0.05920820310711861,
-0.014279180206358433,
-0.2699674367904663,
-0.62021803855896,
-0.6023245453834534,
1.2687554359436035,
0.31834664940834045,
0.6702196002006531,
-0.03191272169351578,
0.8671913743019104,
-0.13138726353645325,
-0.07033461332321167,
-1.0124537944793701,
0.49643343687057495,
-0.40275460481643677,
-0.3319184482097626,
-0.4135470986366272,
-0.4155510663986206,
-0.9085720181465149,
0.34388306736946106,
-0.19725792109966278,
-0.7956125736236572,
0.11526870727539062,
0.18915313482284546,
-0.4499332010746002,
-0.08074669539928436,
-0.6763514876365662,
0.9829535484313965,
-0.5518674254417419,
-0.36382952332496643,
-0.25255483388900757,
-0.8116786479949951,
0.3025799095630646,
-0.09339632838964462,
-0.03358428180217743,
-0.27039971947669983,
-0.18200422823429108,
0.6304298639297485,
0.008053438737988472,
0.617849588394165,
0.13125813007354736,
-0.2178722620010376,
-0.18762969970703125,
-0.15593242645263672,
0.44658362865448,
-0.2000650316476822,
-0.298143595457077,
0.10049569606781006,
-0.03519085422158241,
-0.23033075034618378,
-0.6497119665145874,
0.750669538974762,
-0.9356286525726318,
-0.8250782489776611,
-0.3616969883441925,
-0.8537129163742065,
-0.571281909942627,
0.2627064287662506,
-0.020801261067390442,
0.10160575062036514,
-0.11465423554182053,
0.061034563928842545,
0.6968874931335449,
-0.07385802268981934,
0.21310988068580627,
0.46289849281311035,
0.06372824311256409,
-0.41156959533691406,
0.5391221046447754,
0.14626750349998474,
0.5122480392456055,
0.5986307263374329,
0.38654300570487976,
-0.28772789239883423,
-0.6248934268951416,
-0.3852406144142151,
0.29967790842056274,
-0.5457955002784729,
-0.06285267323255539,
-0.4896351397037506,
0.30123355984687805,
-0.5859145522117615,
-0.10890297591686249,
-0.6007532477378845,
-0.46231165528297424,
-0.2278650403022766,
-0.01210262905806303,
0.07062136381864548,
0.5115813612937927,
0.2114664614200592,
0.2059374749660492,
-0.4450233578681946,
0.20772063732147217,
0.25456562638282776,
0.5180577635765076,
-0.18386210501194,
-0.2797754406929016,
-0.0528993159532547,
0.18363139033317566,
-0.5636436343193054,
-0.707432210445404,
-0.21221725642681122,
0.038665298372507095,
0.6233584880828857,
0.20580706000328064,
0.037283044308423996,
1.0329700708389282,
-0.5978502631187439,
0.5421849489212036,
0.1814178228378296,
-0.9457905888557434,
0.6912176012992859,
-0.3758634626865387,
0.17338505387306213,
0.8949587941169739,
0.4292408227920532,
-0.1126805916428566,
-0.01174752414226532,
-0.30486705899238586,
-0.49199214577674866,
0.8062137961387634,
0.13243643939495087,
-0.29335564374923706,
0.021412091329693794,
0.5167830586433411,
0.3946906626224518,
0.43295544385910034,
-0.29356712102890015,
-0.21780408918857574,
0.11809034645557404,
-0.43862780928611755,
-0.083553746342659,
-0.0915571078658104,
-0.41127485036849976,
-0.28248488903045654,
0.6320698857307434,
-0.1683821678161621,
0.061974044889211655,
0.14806577563285828,
0.08106428384780884,
-0.09069444984197617,
0.3374142050743103,
0.7860004305839539,
0.8716519474983215,
-0.1996113508939743,
-0.34749066829681396,
-0.21203720569610596,
-0.2523040175437927,
0.17673364281654358,
0.23968029022216797,
-0.12141010165214539,
-0.27365341782569885,
0.1474778801202774,
0.9603796005249023,
0.24862630665302277,
-0.5540939569473267,
0.4328266680240631,
0.02012072689831257,
-0.1453942358493805,
0.1032155305147171,
0.0810929462313652,
-0.19051796197891235,
0.09329239279031754,
-0.05023418366909027,
0.014208543114364147,
0.13256046175956726,
-0.4558718502521515,
-0.07790722697973251,
0.6021407246589661,
-0.36101698875427246,
-0.05801262706518173,
0.4100864827632904,
0.11475019156932831,
-0.17395363748073578,
0.6195688843727112,
0.1676403433084488,
-0.4114024043083191,
0.515277087688446,
0.381955087184906,
0.7083203792572021,
-0.06388932466506958,
0.10755046457052231,
0.22498859465122223,
0.19153758883476257,
-0.30385497212409973,
0.028267722576856613,
-0.14189790189266205,
-0.9553724527359009,
-0.6890408396720886,
-0.616847038269043,
-0.5353946685791016,
-0.13699698448181152,
-0.8901137709617615,
0.25769633054733276,
-0.27171459794044495,
-0.17182359099388123,
0.1326095163822174,
0.22890041768550873,
-0.7165206074714661,
-0.026394037529826164,
-0.013318954966962337,
0.5339101552963257,
-0.6836302280426025,
0.6051149964332581,
0.8917281031608582,
-0.05932723730802536,
-0.9496626257896423,
0.13843148946762085,
0.20862869918346405,
-0.9755765199661255,
0.5188199281692505,
0.19054391980171204,
-0.1294889599084854,
-0.14111575484275818,
-0.10089458525180817,
-0.9923605918884277,
1.0593101978302002,
0.6003868579864502,
-0.9112914204597473,
-0.08286251872777939,
0.31028905510902405,
0.49833086133003235,
-0.3866651952266693,
-0.015464677475392818,
0.9174591302871704,
0.4014125168323517,
0.13246169686317444,
-1.3768196105957031,
-0.05943613499403,
0.28894683718681335,
0.05349352955818176,
0.4484930634498596,
-0.8923655152320862,
0.5578727722167969,
-0.029789216816425323,
0.07719871401786804,
0.1263716220855713,
0.2399996817111969,
0.36246258020401,
0.13398993015289307,
0.5963721871376038,
0.7637664079666138,
0.8127656579017639,
-0.22906802594661713,
0.9052367210388184,
-0.3648960292339325,
0.3409311771392822,
1.240820288658142,
-0.6520671844482422,
0.6311452388763428,
0.8499953150749207,
-0.17631001770496368,
0.19566906988620758,
0.6481112837791443,
0.098159059882164,
0.5720365643501282,
0.18979674577713013,
0.07166535407304764,
-0.24122165143489838,
-0.12250151485204697,
-0.25710412859916687,
0.7705711126327515,
0.011692618019878864,
-0.19090183079242706,
0.12954257428646088,
-0.14120075106620789,
-0.11183662712574005,
0.34654659032821655,
-0.17178106307983398,
0.9974063038825989,
-0.256899356842041,
-1.2134950160980225,
0.45913052558898926,
-0.3142261803150177,
0.6792998313903809,
-0.4785882532596588,
0.028248894959688187,
-0.01635182648897171,
0.4051467776298523,
-0.17586584389209747,
-0.8441845774650574,
0.22363069653511047,
-0.16132330894470215,
-0.2813847064971924,
-0.5075879096984863,
0.46239426732063293,
-0.4125034511089325,
-0.25682127475738525,
0.10209611803293228,
0.32836025953292847,
-0.25273460149765015,
0.14006386697292328,
-0.8061145544052124,
0.26686209440231323,
0.15691357851028442,
-0.1972622275352478,
0.4579991400241852,
0.2998204827308655,
0.10315404087305069,
0.5199945569038391,
0.3290177881717682,
-0.08151297271251678,
-0.07451508939266205,
-0.053085073828697205,
0.6391611099243164,
-0.40006110072135925,
-0.1649436354637146,
-0.9329549074172974,
0.46061262488365173,
-0.24017362296581268,
-0.48450687527656555,
0.8446952104568481,
0.698164165019989,
0.9074289798736572,
-0.06197688728570938,
0.5558111667633057,
0.10540105402469635,
0.47257280349731445,
-0.5435669422149658,
0.011697057634592056,
-0.5934661030769348,
0.21777719259262085,
-0.5738081932067871,
-1.0279734134674072,
-0.0760100781917572,
0.564087450504303,
-0.5989587903022766,
-0.24956035614013672,
0.6511394381523132,
0.46518072485923767,
0.04232277721166611,
0.0867859274148941,
0.12755197286605835,
-0.28487521409988403,
0.1604858934879303,
0.45074713230133057,
0.8107890486717224,
-0.34481677412986755,
0.41728129982948303,
-0.543873131275177,
-0.28448978066444397,
-0.0510537326335907,
-0.9727701544761658,
-0.7232081890106201,
-0.31255993247032166,
-0.4781683087348938,
-0.025757113471627235,
0.049161396920681,
0.8829339742660522,
0.5201398134231567,
-0.50017911195755,
-0.2429223656654358,
-0.03273676335811615,
0.2469853162765503,
-0.5323845744132996,
-0.16919970512390137,
0.29812097549438477,
-0.31739822030067444,
-0.9834603071212769,
0.3847348392009735,
0.3223680555820465,
-0.008183537051081657,
0.11151878535747528,
0.059835709631443024,
-0.25861209630966187,
-0.0970480814576149,
0.28992611169815063,
0.019207842648029327,
-1.0160104036331177,
-0.4686938226222992,
0.30372536182403564,
-0.14211496710777283,
0.21920771896839142,
0.810254693031311,
-0.2417323887348175,
0.5515929460525513,
0.5214197635650635,
0.8798666000366211,
0.2609446942806244,
0.4555325210094452,
0.7436643838882446,
-0.7089784145355225,
0.03679065778851509,
0.23858842253684998,
0.2789222300052643,
0.3164525628089905,
-0.45465266704559326,
0.5896855592727661,
-0.14077161252498627,
-0.86224764585495,
-0.8131490349769592,
0.4320526123046875,
-1.2288206815719604,
-0.0431598424911499,
1.1173943281173706,
-0.023133117705583572,
0.1644815355539322,
0.16447784006595612,
-0.3159335255622864,
0.24577735364437103,
-0.48213812708854675,
0.8151087164878845,
1.065319299697876,
-0.6125094294548035,
0.07654974609613419,
-0.46167513728141785,
0.5756703615188599,
0.7634696364402771,
-0.43670791387557983,
0.19846780598163605,
0.6376699209213257,
0.2948620021343231,
0.2824680507183075,
0.39860546588897705,
0.009967958554625511,
0.045457787811756134,
-0.3648685812950134,
-0.168979212641716,
0.026381731033325195,
-0.23007850348949432,
-0.39258885383605957,
-0.12508153915405273,
0.09638593345880508,
-0.399197518825531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14716v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14716v2
|
Bayesian Example Selection Improves In-Context Learning for Speech, Text, and Visual Modalities
| 2024-04-23T03:42:48 | 2024-06-16T08:49:00 |
Siyin Wang, Chao-Han Huck Yang, Ji Wu, Chao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Large language models (LLMs) can adapt to new tasks through in-context
learning (ICL) based on a few examples presented in dialogue history without
any model parameter update. Despite such convenience, the performance of ICL
heavily depends on the quality of the in-context examples presented, which
makes the in-context example selection approach a critical choice. This paper
proposes a novel Bayesian in-Context example Selection method (ByCS) for ICL.
Extending the inference probability conditioned on in-context examples based on
Bayes' theorem, ByCS focuses on the inverse inference conditioned on test
input. Following the assumption that accurate inverse inference probability
(likelihood) will result in accurate inference probability (posterior),
in-context examples are selected based on their inverse inference results.
Diverse and extensive cross-tasking and cross-modality experiments are
performed with speech, text, and image examples. Experimental results show the
efficacy and robustness of our ByCS method on various models, tasks and
modalities.
|
[
-0.307768315076828,
-0.9226151704788208,
0.7616511583328247,
-0.05014873296022415,
-0.6416121125221252,
-0.4089598059654236,
-0.09263931959867477,
0.039861734956502914,
-0.38448357582092285,
0.46165844798088074,
-0.742958664894104,
-0.6814556121826172,
-0.20115001499652863,
-0.14925268292427063,
-0.3287898004055023,
0.8839492797851562,
0.38500192761421204,
0.3056592643260956,
-0.274574339389801,
-0.042147375643253326,
-0.2567366063594818,
-0.2890024185180664,
-0.8856850266456604,
-0.33100584149360657,
0.15038391947746277,
0.7190078496932983,
0.39716124534606934,
0.05742129683494568,
-0.0036707797553390265,
0.15578126907348633,
0.0037777679972350597,
-0.009312932379543781,
-0.18751206994056702,
0.20665423572063446,
-0.5057308673858643,
-0.40314340591430664,
0.18541720509529114,
0.03512042760848999,
0.8073664307594299,
0.9217163920402527,
-0.013468344695866108,
0.01311678159981966,
0.12105535715818405,
0.2633388638496399,
-0.8504133820533752,
0.187629833817482,
-0.8993170857429504,
-0.1564994752407074,
0.20764562487602234,
-0.038539521396160126,
-0.6029669642448425,
-0.007832879200577736,
0.35580602288246155,
-0.4702107012271881,
0.10254572331905365,
-0.027866985648870468,
0.15265265107154846,
-0.046818625181913376,
-0.5455191731452942,
-0.0600442998111248,
-0.27378615736961365,
0.8022103309631348,
-1.1276298761367798,
0.5014726519584656,
0.49146246910095215,
0.5120654702186584,
-0.5546960830688477,
-0.49747008085250854,
-0.6755496859550476,
-0.24358369410037994,
-0.05144752934575081,
0.45219892263412476,
-0.04232856258749962,
0.09341543912887573,
0.4136406481266022,
-0.11271805316209793,
-0.5708301663398743,
0.08224606513977051,
-0.038590896874666214,
0.1838446855545044,
0.31525787711143494,
-0.22697757184505463,
0.21483448147773743,
-0.15218620002269745,
-0.37224358320236206,
-0.413478285074234,
-0.9644555449485779,
0.3122536838054657,
-0.0072736251167953014,
0.3579670786857605,
-0.22073136270046234,
0.369253545999527,
-0.43364471197128296,
0.8851372003555298,
-0.023911839351058006,
-0.5064617395401001,
0.1123671904206276,
0.057187072932720184,
-0.40127161145210266,
0.05720662698149681,
0.44259047508239746,
0.3217751979827881,
-0.1663133054971695,
-0.210715189576149,
0.04759063571691513,
-0.035836704075336456,
-0.08817381411790848,
-0.7808641195297241,
-0.0940052792429924,
0.009067288599908352,
-0.6183045506477356,
-0.0016219557728618383,
0.09175745397806168,
-0.7460541725158691,
-0.07309766113758087,
-0.07059002667665482,
0.6061996817588806,
-0.4256751239299774,
0.15567009150981903,
-0.026219546794891357,
-0.2754003405570984,
0.016800396144390106,
0.20227931439876556,
-0.5939339995384216,
0.3513999283313751,
0.41332024335861206,
0.46417054533958435,
-0.1662817895412445,
-0.1468496322631836,
-0.9614686965942383,
0.363196462392807,
-0.3512561619281769,
0.7810338735580444,
-0.8359104990959167,
-0.5116257071495056,
-0.005500538740307093,
-0.041084758937358856,
0.06754755228757858,
-0.49763503670692444,
0.5971328616142273,
-0.37251025438308716,
0.25952035188674927,
-0.0995960459113121,
-0.49832388758659363,
-0.6605836749076843,
-0.12927775084972382,
-0.1516260802745819,
0.5452558398246765,
0.16222093999385834,
-0.5876865386962891,
0.7950299382209778,
-0.2570650279521942,
-0.3640824854373932,
-0.011003129184246063,
-0.5813695788383484,
-0.529280960559845,
0.18809019029140472,
0.6012048721313477,
0.7794427871704102,
-0.130774587392807,
0.2399992048740387,
-0.7725057601928711,
-0.6059774160385132,
0.3157925009727478,
-0.6152616143226624,
0.8445295691490173,
0.10198663920164108,
-0.5285359621047974,
0.16789673268795013,
-0.7690305709838867,
-0.016120443120598793,
-0.31645750999450684,
-0.12080942094326019,
-0.6815581917762756,
0.36097946763038635,
-0.1640266478061676,
0.47215700149536133,
-0.414288729429245,
-0.6363441348075867,
0.008566656149923801,
-0.5907174348831177,
0.26618310809135437,
0.41325971484184265,
0.36582428216934204,
0.4015825688838959,
-0.4480045437812805,
0.4263884127140045,
0.09325139224529266,
-0.09638255834579468,
-0.1090664267539978,
-0.5068672299385071,
-0.2928664982318878,
-0.9261841773986816,
0.057742174714803696,
0.5502976179122925,
-0.7867612242698669,
0.42467328906059265,
-0.2529306709766388,
-0.4255038797855377,
-0.22439666092395782,
-0.13652582466602325,
0.5505195260047913,
0.739395797252655,
0.3129766881465912,
-0.23055294156074524,
-0.11749487370252609,
-0.998297393321991,
-0.22554536163806915,
-0.5069208145141602,
-0.19613055884838104,
0.5318692922592163,
0.19786539673805237,
-0.07884208112955093,
1.0713881254196167,
-0.16829466819763184,
0.22292940318584442,
-0.3856358230113983,
0.15465593338012695,
0.3755013644695282,
0.5160501599311829,
0.5541428327560425,
-0.6957735419273376,
-0.17000392079353333,
-0.22233149409294128,
-0.16162140667438507,
-0.2454005479812622,
-0.5068578124046326,
-0.1434151828289032,
0.14633865654468536,
0.6376908421516418,
-0.1995067149400711,
0.8035486936569214,
0.3817146420478821,
-0.36662909388542175,
0.115687794983387,
-0.2309044450521469,
0.32424360513687134,
-0.9487807154655457,
-0.17536555230617523,
0.3522922992706299,
-0.5529869198799133,
-0.2902706265449524,
-0.1957605928182602,
0.1735689789056778,
-0.05168795585632324,
-0.4279076159000397,
0.7919023633003235,
-0.2792735993862152,
-0.08855839818716049,
-0.1258644312620163,
0.09782282263040543,
-0.4975792467594147,
0.5984301567077637,
0.3984667956829071,
0.5981648564338684,
0.7930412888526917,
-0.46293139457702637,
-0.19143228232860565,
0.2775091528892517,
-0.8102474808692932,
0.4816031754016876,
-0.11850203573703766,
-0.10152291506528854,
-0.2912557125091553,
0.4095800817012787,
-1.3835915327072144,
0.16689853370189667,
0.4308580458164215,
-0.23526985943317413,
0.2650589346885681,
-0.2787717878818512,
-0.5687748193740845,
0.11972232908010483,
-0.13116265833377838,
0.38399431109428406,
0.4942183196544647,
-0.9617601037025452,
0.42076846957206726,
0.15602049231529236,
-0.3843979239463806,
-0.35235926508903503,
-0.6721096038818359,
-0.015883835032582283,
-0.48717203736305237,
-0.077262744307518,
0.528858482837677,
-0.2595185339450836,
-0.28613877296447754,
-0.2857200503349304,
-0.4166701138019562,
-0.03896358236670494,
0.04779822379350662,
0.39370134472846985,
0.1456170529127121,
0.012855193577706814,
-0.01331788208335638,
0.9711437821388245,
0.18958792090415955,
-0.04440890997648239,
0.02564777433872223,
-0.11720128357410431,
0.26075735688209534,
-0.6244646310806274,
-0.5007701516151428,
0.6632291674613953,
0.2354423552751541,
0.15254010260105133,
0.37198829650878906,
0.15493915975093842,
-0.2955940365791321,
-0.6343356370925903,
-0.6569717526435852,
-0.5403541326522827,
-0.381267249584198,
0.528963029384613,
-0.3579038679599762,
-0.7735647559165955,
0.2201353758573532,
-0.08312593400478363,
-0.13689357042312622,
-0.28314700722694397,
0.3937717080116272,
0.0762217789888382,
1.0836864709854126,
0.2947840690612793,
-0.2591395080089569,
0.7463971972465515,
-0.12111832946538925,
0.33629295229911804,
-0.786870002746582,
0.2692042291164398,
-0.3680344521999359,
-0.03510710224509239,
-0.4574287235736847,
-0.30395153164863586,
0.7140011191368103,
0.25138217210769653,
-0.19599533081054688,
0.19638727605342865,
-0.07952519506216049,
0.3075415790081024,
0.6389404535293579,
0.7400325536727905,
0.34117498993873596,
0.18899698555469513,
-0.44849756360054016,
-0.0828544870018959,
-0.8616601824760437,
-0.5165172815322876,
0.8229485750198364,
-0.1321266144514084,
0.7366691827774048,
0.22542326152324677,
0.3962870240211487,
0.030177844688296318,
0.5750948190689087,
-0.4593994915485382,
0.7167496085166931,
-0.14028014242649078,
-0.6321259140968323,
-0.2645585834980011,
-0.19899430871009827,
-0.7428549528121948,
0.6172038912773132,
-0.2537854313850403,
-1.264884114265442,
0.27887704968452454,
0.09358855336904526,
-0.3950333595275879,
0.15210114419460297,
-0.5614489912986755,
0.9175674319267273,
0.08247900009155273,
-0.38086479902267456,
-0.5713526606559753,
-0.8914349675178528,
0.15006454288959503,
0.096779465675354,
0.3136959671974182,
0.13960696756839752,
-0.13414107263088226,
0.46634793281555176,
-0.034431371837854385,
1.103287935256958,
-0.15584895014762878,
0.048020970076322556,
0.35740140080451965,
0.23455190658569336,
0.2758491039276123,
0.6335630416870117,
-0.19531653821468353,
-0.11618117243051529,
0.05923725292086601,
-0.10331344604492188,
-0.9310702085494995,
0.7593158483505249,
-0.3006291687488556,
-0.6913318037986755,
-0.2256077527999878,
-0.46540093421936035,
-0.6611136794090271,
-0.05208084359765053,
0.2542109191417694,
0.7450756430625916,
-0.013864005915820599,
0.37859803438186646,
0.4171982705593109,
-0.3518989682197571,
0.6844769716262817,
0.6565852761268616,
-0.04357904940843582,
-0.4751473069190979,
0.4755832552909851,
0.0017127643804997206,
0.3152746558189392,
0.694362998008728,
0.3161281645298004,
-0.22140668332576752,
-0.7861133217811584,
-0.3429230749607086,
0.12109380215406418,
-0.8413211703300476,
-0.1105269268155098,
-0.46315380930900574,
0.18617375195026398,
-0.2824641168117523,
-0.366830974817276,
0.16383914649486542,
-0.3431173861026764,
-0.2529732584953308,
0.14290234446525574,
-0.18469569087028503,
-0.10585000365972519,
0.09223144501447678,
0.6104514002799988,
-0.4458053410053253,
0.4034680724143982,
0.4668896794319153,
-0.08491937816143036,
-0.08387088775634766,
-0.8089228868484497,
0.14051878452301025,
0.17787934839725494,
-0.4260261058807373,
-1.0525010824203491,
0.4191916882991791,
0.3503262996673584,
1.0495847463607788,
0.51229327917099,
0.08199004083871841,
0.6569366455078125,
-0.2528574764728546,
0.5633137822151184,
0.012744724750518799,
-0.922711968421936,
0.6893746256828308,
-0.3343522548675537,
0.43025586009025574,
0.5060945153236389,
0.4484364688396454,
-0.30428391695022583,
-0.4452669024467468,
-0.6719841361045837,
-0.48329171538352966,
0.4281708896160126,
0.19153349101543427,
-0.10466272383928299,
-0.24210013449192047,
0.39807653427124023,
0.43656784296035767,
0.14614439010620117,
-0.7287451028823853,
-0.09153567254543304,
0.21312998235225677,
-0.2775430679321289,
-0.29886630177497864,
-0.09453973919153214,
0.28776979446411133,
-0.47228166460990906,
1.0595412254333496,
-0.4395468533039093,
-0.004477704409509897,
0.39828965067863464,
-0.19669891893863678,
0.0029727674555033445,
0.3837106227874756,
0.4179074168205261,
0.8958458304405212,
-0.2915419042110443,
-0.07693605124950409,
0.6269901394844055,
0.07269550859928131,
-0.06904812157154083,
0.10447049140930176,
-0.29560551047325134,
0.0801202729344368,
0.25900697708129883,
0.5441926121711731,
0.5751567482948303,
-1.0086749792099,
0.7493919134140015,
-0.0207161046564579,
0.2744821012020111,
-0.3267669379711151,
0.1537480652332306,
-0.23825590312480927,
0.5516947507858276,
0.381723552942276,
-0.015318179503083229,
0.4658409655094147,
-0.8483792543411255,
0.22513557970523834,
0.8742518424987793,
-0.5128130316734314,
-0.06320156902074814,
0.26973578333854675,
-0.3243902027606964,
0.006418589502573013,
0.41309064626693726,
-0.1739838868379593,
-0.25379878282546997,
0.20915694534778595,
0.92536461353302,
0.6602758169174194,
-0.07596354931592941,
0.11667447537183762,
0.33900442719459534,
-0.15523910522460938,
-0.07822107523679733,
0.35941076278686523,
-0.47290077805519104,
-0.7030459642410278,
-0.5232189893722534,
-0.15025028586387634,
-0.31596946716308594,
0.14629843831062317,
-0.40494826436042786,
0.4909178912639618,
-0.16470153629779816,
-0.2000500112771988,
-0.2747975289821625,
-0.06952214241027832,
-0.31786245107650757,
0.5034100413322449,
0.2924064099788666,
0.8454793095588684,
-0.8051629662513733,
1.1272581815719604,
0.6675901412963867,
-0.050264060497283936,
-0.44548994302749634,
0.1270749717950821,
-0.05997227877378464,
-0.34498876333236694,
0.5354045033454895,
-0.07399655133485794,
-0.11885305494070053,
-0.03939162567257881,
-0.821900486946106,
-0.46997731924057007,
0.9624394178390503,
0.6399860978126526,
-0.4400838315486908,
0.12404697388410568,
-0.4611811339855194,
0.152119442820549,
-0.7044239640235901,
0.5086575150489807,
0.3512503504753113,
0.059349801391363144,
0.08144062012434006,
-0.6177363991737366,
0.08882346004247665,
0.03497660532593727,
0.27581527829170227,
-0.22247393429279327,
-0.4283547103404999,
0.24367891252040863,
-0.27299001812934875,
-0.03708430007100105,
0.39290887117385864,
0.8345189690589905,
0.8388093709945679,
0.29984375834465027,
0.7745394110679626,
0.4210897386074066,
0.2112354189157486,
0.35955074429512024,
0.9362649321556091,
0.1676499992609024,
-0.031095977872610092,
1.4877774715423584,
-0.06752024590969086,
0.9889655709266663,
0.6296571493148804,
-0.012723712250590324,
0.6992257237434387,
0.561855673789978,
0.20401932299137115,
1.0721555948257446,
0.38916292786598206,
-0.45798948407173157,
-0.6213712096214294,
0.050412196666002274,
-0.06662394106388092,
0.43641987442970276,
0.43733924627304077,
-0.36789777874946594,
-0.4003869891166687,
0.11025100201368332,
0.0613473579287529,
0.11560317128896713,
-0.2809653580188751,
0.6814954876899719,
0.06958340853452682,
-0.7390632629394531,
0.25061941146850586,
-0.1500031054019928,
0.6741671562194824,
-0.478210985660553,
-0.3280661404132843,
-0.10975629091262817,
0.04031766578555107,
0.055179644376039505,
-0.3871440887451172,
-0.07836965471506119,
-0.3595922589302063,
-0.06392122805118561,
-0.003782926592975855,
0.5358825325965881,
-0.4341500401496887,
-0.6793931722640991,
0.1323423683643341,
0.30452921986579895,
0.09268855303525925,
-0.2754307687282562,
-0.45557111501693726,
-0.2969570755958557,
-0.17016038298606873,
-0.15563717484474182,
0.36830058693885803,
0.39946386218070984,
-0.3580717444419861,
0.809049665927887,
0.4130820631980896,
0.13916002213954926,
-0.2329775094985962,
-0.01547209918498993,
0.6857701539993286,
-0.38896995782852173,
-0.5953087210655212,
-0.7723065614700317,
0.6405029296875,
-0.16754364967346191,
-0.44996097683906555,
0.6435786485671997,
0.6605923771858215,
1.1132915019989014,
-0.11808453500270844,
0.8184019923210144,
0.1574230045080185,
0.7238808870315552,
-0.5731817483901978,
0.49315890669822693,
-0.6259405016899109,
0.18314895033836365,
-0.8085262179374695,
-0.7035611867904663,
-0.3966512680053711,
0.930384635925293,
-0.5224409103393555,
0.04873299598693848,
0.8098739981651306,
1.0700962543487549,
-0.32436877489089966,
0.005955745931714773,
0.5994505882263184,
-0.12112415581941605,
0.28832465410232544,
0.5161773562431335,
0.65866619348526,
-0.39468032121658325,
0.23979242146015167,
-0.5180848240852356,
-0.6172434091567993,
0.004427191335707903,
-1.0477850437164307,
-1.1999222040176392,
-0.9418708682060242,
-0.599541187286377,
-0.12965071201324463,
0.23970188200473785,
1.2665828466415405,
1.086830496788025,
-0.836568295955658,
-0.4791747033596039,
0.15107369422912598,
0.06353485584259033,
-0.6516211628913879,
-0.11231476813554764,
0.16744713485240936,
-0.20370447635650635,
-0.5774434208869934,
0.8043432235717773,
0.1938174068927765,
0.02143196575343609,
0.31133151054382324,
0.19790324568748474,
-0.34282228350639343,
-0.008543462492525578,
0.6051109433174133,
-0.028438223525881767,
-0.7618021368980408,
-0.3840560019016266,
-0.6014237999916077,
0.10183119028806686,
-0.03290349245071411,
0.8708972930908203,
-1.18508780002594,
0.3321809470653534,
0.5553287863731384,
0.5710877180099487,
0.6618318557739258,
0.05280831828713417,
0.5538755655288696,
-0.46197181940078735,
0.44941186904907227,
0.24847163259983063,
0.5971592664718628,
0.16205251216888428,
-0.05080091953277588,
0.17568793892860413,
0.11935783922672272,
-0.4294953942298889,
-0.6586295366287231,
0.19750966131687164,
-1.3491157293319702,
-0.7601269483566284,
1.2745335102081299,
-0.19463872909545898,
-0.1452471911907196,
0.03803207725286484,
-0.37721890211105347,
0.3059441149234772,
-0.5826248526573181,
0.8614982962608337,
0.3165018856525421,
0.01715659163892269,
-0.32970109581947327,
-0.5748892426490784,
0.2618432641029358,
0.7211484909057617,
-0.6664377450942993,
-0.1411491185426712,
0.5367550253868103,
0.21183957159519196,
-0.4207790493965149,
0.24182555079460144,
0.08208044618368149,
0.2619440257549286,
-0.3541226089000702,
-0.3061862587928772,
0.4221777319908142,
-0.21037638187408447,
-0.29820337891578674,
0.020893672481179237,
-0.02079014852643013,
0.05891891196370125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14715v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14715v1
|
FINEMATCH: Aspect-based Fine-grained Image and Text Mismatch Detection and Correction
| 2024-04-23T03:42:14 | 2024-04-23T03:42:14 |
Hang Hua, Jing Shi, Kushal Kafle, Simon Jenni, Daoan Zhang, John Collomosse, Scott Cohen, Jiebo Luo
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Recent progress in large-scale pre-training has led to the development of
advanced vision-language models (VLMs) with remarkable proficiency in
comprehending and generating multimodal content. Despite the impressive ability
to perform complex reasoning for VLMs, current models often struggle to
effectively and precisely capture the compositional information on both the
image and text sides. To address this, we propose FineMatch, a new aspect-based
fine-grained text and image matching benchmark, focusing on text and image
mismatch detection and correction. This benchmark introduces a novel task for
boosting and evaluating the VLMs' compositionality for aspect-based
fine-grained text and image matching. In this task, models are required to
identify mismatched aspect phrases within a caption, determine the aspect's
class, and propose corrections for an image-text pair that may contain between
0 and 3 mismatches. To evaluate the models' performance on this new task, we
propose a new evaluation metric named ITM-IoU for which our experiments show a
high correlation to human evaluation. In addition, we also provide a
comprehensive experimental analysis of existing mainstream VLMs, including
fully supervised learning and in-context learning settings. We have found that
models trained on FineMatch demonstrate enhanced proficiency in detecting
fine-grained text and image mismatches. Moreover, models (e.g., GPT-4V, Gemini
Pro Vision) with strong abilities to perform multimodal in-context learning are
not as skilled at fine-grained compositional image and text matching analysis.
With FineMatch, we are able to build a system for text-to-image generation
hallucination detection and correction.
|
[
-0.4789046347141266,
-0.8375648856163025,
0.5255722403526306,
-0.0672069787979126,
-0.2871631681919098,
-0.27931568026542664,
0.12305658310651779,
-0.6713415384292603,
-0.17620301246643066,
0.8290671110153198,
-0.49482351541519165,
-0.6041728258132935,
-0.3463936746120453,
0.08792880922555923,
-0.359942764043808,
0.7466441988945007,
-0.3200576603412628,
0.3185240924358368,
-0.5984616875648499,
-0.45891502499580383,
-0.7980700135231018,
-0.17251397669315338,
-0.592879593372345,
-0.168527290225029,
0.07638896256685257,
0.47685518860816956,
0.6895534992218018,
0.7188138365745544,
0.9627962708473206,
0.32311517000198364,
0.011053763329982758,
0.6168558597564697,
-0.2208320051431656,
0.10303483158349991,
-0.5566655397415161,
-0.3551448881626129,
-0.46815210580825806,
-0.0691787526011467,
0.5761302709579468,
0.32190126180648804,
0.14374002814292908,
0.08575695753097534,
0.15210863947868347,
0.9564187526702881,
-0.7137957215309143,
0.08478965610265732,
-0.8257343769073486,
0.13756850361824036,
-0.11816614121198654,
-0.4566732943058014,
-0.18163245916366577,
0.042621251195669174,
-0.11295768618583679,
-0.5478219985961914,
0.5232910513877869,
0.2882688045501709,
0.8588709831237793,
0.3933870792388916,
0.041427817195653915,
-0.19634893536567688,
-0.43618959188461304,
0.5804845690727234,
-0.7183638215065002,
0.2275678664445877,
0.5534257292747498,
0.4204126000404358,
-0.06513698399066925,
-0.4856395125389099,
-0.77958083152771,
-0.12715445458889008,
-0.15397045016288757,
0.0361100472509861,
-0.06445059180259705,
0.11690670251846313,
0.00654472503811121,
0.7646098136901855,
-0.42732229828834534,
0.13618670403957367,
-0.07333103567361832,
-0.20556338131427765,
0.35182932019233704,
0.4457593560218811,
0.3462350070476532,
-0.21337026357650757,
-0.3084230422973633,
-0.32581499218940735,
-0.3320906460285187,
-0.1585727334022522,
0.18716153502464294,
0.4249981641769409,
-0.2203928828239441,
0.7429181337356567,
-0.4382043480873108,
0.8770409226417542,
-0.13777729868888855,
-0.0490126796066761,
0.19432304799556732,
-0.5213913321495056,
-0.21585725247859955,
-0.10939251631498337,
0.6724556684494019,
1.1770870685577393,
0.06296379119157791,
0.05154222622513771,
-0.36592474579811096,
0.13896942138671875,
0.16905643045902252,
-0.81264328956604,
-0.3081795275211334,
0.03127431124448776,
-0.4719458520412445,
-0.43813908100128174,
-0.08548596501350403,
-0.6896379590034485,
-0.5396984815597534,
-0.4387175142765045,
0.9379016160964966,
-0.542718231678009,
0.23050794005393982,
0.09937819838523865,
-0.02092551626265049,
0.1475294530391693,
0.6382002234458923,
-0.6328805685043335,
0.059159792959690094,
0.652423620223999,
0.9486404657363892,
-0.30470287799835205,
-0.6012091636657715,
-0.7381982803344727,
-0.273453027009964,
-0.3276699185371399,
1.2189759016036987,
-0.43179234862327576,
-0.07525860518217087,
0.04144556447863579,
0.17694739997386932,
0.12170026451349258,
-0.8532475233078003,
0.49623796343803406,
-0.05316653847694397,
0.2130168229341507,
-0.16930386424064636,
-0.5003015995025635,
-0.15208058059215546,
0.6873234510421753,
-0.6506885290145874,
0.9503008723258972,
0.20465408265590668,
-0.7814630270004272,
0.3648238182067871,
-0.3534938395023346,
-0.2623807191848755,
0.12799370288848877,
-0.29985231161117554,
-0.7238686084747314,
0.20300498604774475,
0.23972143232822418,
0.5619257688522339,
-0.4103371500968933,
0.01620788313448429,
-0.45676523447036743,
-0.44857972860336304,
0.05955077335238457,
-0.4627007842063904,
0.11189678311347961,
0.008555260486900806,
-0.2443147599697113,
0.4200966954231262,
-0.7559979557991028,
0.04944537207484245,
0.08914615958929062,
-0.09913427382707596,
-0.426334410905838,
0.11411476880311966,
0.3608070909976959,
0.15896667540073395,
0.3105885982513428,
-0.4130375385284424,
0.1479274481534958,
-0.03504003956913948,
0.28428736329078674,
0.5347386598587036,
-0.2411544770002365,
0.4620532691478729,
-0.5005164742469788,
-0.0809812918305397,
0.2449827492237091,
0.26457712054252625,
-0.6653177738189697,
-0.27161797881126404,
-0.9461296796798706,
-0.09798119217157364,
0.2709323763847351,
0.49849140644073486,
-1.041664958000183,
0.43954697251319885,
0.020680265501141548,
-0.48522475361824036,
-0.6412408947944641,
-0.01317510288208723,
0.6532846689224243,
0.5145983099937439,
0.600555419921875,
-0.7773474454879761,
-0.2668360471725464,
-0.9051107168197632,
-0.4209064245223999,
0.22238992154598236,
0.0009185592061839998,
0.4456828832626343,
0.40700870752334595,
-0.2962838113307953,
0.6840642690658569,
-0.3398078382015228,
-1.075097918510437,
0.08961080759763718,
0.045102231204509735,
-0.3354388475418091,
0.7352779507637024,
0.5879786610603333,
-0.7224740386009216,
-0.3557305932044983,
0.3001560568809509,
-0.6593789458274841,
-0.04263961687684059,
0.019992131739854813,
-0.09918680787086487,
0.30417555570602417,
0.8400775194168091,
-0.05491139367222786,
0.34583526849746704,
0.6460019946098328,
-0.5810279250144958,
0.5657843351364136,
-0.43854865431785583,
0.6909889578819275,
-1.1176316738128662,
-0.015578203834593296,
0.21971938014030457,
-0.5104553699493408,
-0.35315144062042236,
0.44796842336654663,
0.21142499148845673,
0.038005340844392776,
-0.5699060559272766,
0.559040904045105,
-0.21338382363319397,
-0.2563443183898926,
-0.5984517931938171,
0.18782231211662292,
0.10574020445346832,
0.3318529725074768,
-0.019487859681248665,
0.7385572791099548,
0.570549726486206,
-0.3377718925476074,
0.05068741366267204,
0.17502255737781525,
-0.2841607928276062,
1.2771333456039429,
-0.37589311599731445,
0.102232426404953,
-0.10546599328517914,
-0.014835841953754425,
-0.8332387208938599,
-0.38472458720207214,
0.07796680927276611,
-0.22593505680561066,
0.18076561391353607,
0.06664609163999557,
-0.5699923038482666,
-0.11101265996694565,
-0.4390958547592163,
0.5785069465637207,
-0.03464725241065025,
-0.5138660669326782,
0.5962068438529968,
0.09365354478359222,
0.2132796049118042,
-0.19912029802799225,
-0.5422582030296326,
0.08053027838468552,
0.2767177224159241,
-0.5597925186157227,
0.6145368218421936,
-0.14172345399856567,
0.1420649141073227,
0.1856754869222641,
-0.20577239990234375,
-0.13547173142433167,
-0.009017613716423512,
0.17365844547748566,
0.24919262528419495,
-0.31797152757644653,
-0.3270461857318878,
-0.055601317435503006,
-0.06826115399599075,
-0.49562883377075195,
0.017724642530083656,
0.6533000469207764,
-0.42319953441619873,
-0.4606812298297882,
-0.6202752590179443,
0.3715989887714386,
0.6760015487670898,
-0.2169698178768158,
0.5204536318778992,
0.7233833074569702,
-0.5357288122177124,
0.1524653285741806,
-0.6761348843574524,
-0.09292002022266388,
-0.4451514780521393,
0.6057115793228149,
-0.2709258496761322,
-0.8649114966392517,
0.3742761015892029,
0.15130148828029633,
0.07126539200544357,
0.5315783023834229,
0.2181870937347412,
-0.24159085750579834,
0.8863174319267273,
0.8201099038124084,
0.08640894293785095,
0.625858724117279,
-0.14978885650634766,
0.04251537844538689,
-0.8786994218826294,
-0.1920183300971985,
-0.3829825520515442,
-0.4453051686286926,
-0.4352225363254547,
-0.6684032082557678,
0.033127620816230774,
0.2879197299480438,
-0.08246497064828873,
0.36053308844566345,
-0.6615604758262634,
0.9228222966194153,
0.5153732895851135,
0.37431907653808594,
0.6411238312721252,
0.024836650118231773,
0.15450970828533173,
-0.3280198574066162,
-0.17714448273181915,
-0.5185282826423645,
0.8014518022537231,
0.10990646481513977,
0.7058483362197876,
-0.15479622781276703,
0.3798513114452362,
0.36777549982070923,
0.14922240376472473,
-0.890374481678009,
0.5302707552909851,
-0.7534703016281128,
-0.1848497837781906,
0.137515127658844,
-0.30272024869918823,
-0.4810284376144409,
0.24847543239593506,
-0.6085636615753174,
-0.7155365943908691,
0.04056748002767563,
0.40614351630210876,
-0.172978013753891,
0.43199723958969116,
-0.6160734295845032,
1.2280319929122925,
-0.058552682399749756,
-0.430731862783432,
-0.05692289397120476,
-0.5348199009895325,
0.32772618532180786,
-0.13421630859375,
0.059700001031160355,
-0.21150970458984375,
0.23662173748016357,
0.3818279504776001,
-0.24806447327136993,
0.531765878200531,
0.04052932932972908,
0.0020883427932858467,
-0.023122353479266167,
0.21994049847126007,
0.262414813041687,
-0.23989038169384003,
0.12048143893480301,
0.30687636137008667,
0.04748795926570892,
-0.31853151321411133,
-0.2855834662914276,
0.69823157787323,
-0.4626866281032562,
-0.26580846309661865,
-0.20880718529224396,
-0.5774897336959839,
0.015771035104990005,
0.1485557109117508,
0.5611494183540344,
0.45956650376319885,
-0.148944690823555,
0.26390406489372253,
0.43995410203933716,
-0.08288031071424484,
0.36738887429237366,
0.6873059868812561,
-0.45664215087890625,
-0.4777563214302063,
1.0517233610153198,
-0.3628767728805542,
0.34502112865448,
0.39567917585372925,
-0.011026688851416111,
0.013497421517968178,
-0.6607791781425476,
-0.43618494272232056,
-0.09126199781894684,
-0.6987561583518982,
-0.6024515628814697,
-0.5228490829467773,
-0.2786969840526581,
0.11916539072990417,
-0.28140169382095337,
-0.6479136347770691,
0.11153244227170944,
-0.3100162744522095,
0.5710248351097107,
0.16399912536144257,
0.5846865773200989,
0.17452460527420044,
0.5571323037147522,
-0.7854236364364624,
0.4109053313732147,
0.2143065482378006,
0.5684731006622314,
-0.22928230464458466,
-0.5486629009246826,
-0.04735855385661125,
-0.15607710182666779,
-0.7566878199577332,
-0.5410551428794861,
0.14142897725105286,
0.35396865010261536,
0.1728467047214508,
0.22398914396762848,
-0.2920261025428772,
0.8575965166091919,
-0.6106794476509094,
0.8493365049362183,
0.341130793094635,
-1.0961552858352661,
0.6387456655502319,
-0.015402190387248993,
0.1694890260696411,
0.83486008644104,
-0.1973869949579239,
-0.5583076477050781,
-0.5059115290641785,
-0.4824215769767761,
-0.7991499304771423,
0.798133373260498,
0.34936532378196716,
0.05176960304379463,
0.29716408252716064,
0.24385401606559753,
0.15970909595489502,
0.1074492335319519,
-0.7337565422058105,
-0.11851360648870468,
-0.1319286972284317,
-0.4622150659561157,
-0.12069141119718552,
0.006897814106196165,
0.058124642819166183,
-0.30265557765960693,
0.39213040471076965,
-0.4421008229255676,
0.11259444057941437,
0.3989417254924774,
-0.22320593893527985,
-0.20088249444961548,
0.09603168815374374,
0.7459117770195007,
0.10647806525230408,
-0.10813895612955093,
0.27554771304130554,
-0.049515824764966965,
-0.5701243281364441,
-0.05871704965829849,
0.27293452620506287,
-0.14556853473186493,
0.04895539581775665,
0.2723270356655121,
0.8933722376823425,
0.2185972034931183,
-0.8185839056968689,
0.7626537084579468,
-0.2366502583026886,
-0.26039907336235046,
0.1613413393497467,
0.10234829038381577,
-0.3043128550052643,
0.5217443704605103,
0.3061310052871704,
0.7090964913368225,
0.23676936328411102,
-0.7000691890716553,
0.3221670687198639,
0.5010133385658264,
-0.7316206097602844,
-0.14412082731723785,
0.7168384790420532,
0.18071050941944122,
-0.6412554383277893,
0.13561314344406128,
-0.5649183392524719,
-0.6179953813552856,
0.6394335627555847,
0.45573490858078003,
0.7216343283653259,
-0.07996992021799088,
0.17797057330608368,
0.24682949483394623,
0.26876166462898254,
-0.4302752614021301,
0.2996560037136078,
0.06243239715695381,
-0.7451472282409668,
-0.1680300235748291,
-0.664245069026947,
-0.4374035894870758,
0.4706522226333618,
-0.44185131788253784,
0.4040036201477051,
-0.4170539677143097,
0.0625738799571991,
0.22057481110095978,
-0.22657901048660278,
-0.7491987943649292,
0.25406134128570557,
0.14521965384483337,
0.7187914252281189,
-0.853532612323761,
0.4650544822216034,
0.802516758441925,
-0.2985694706439972,
-0.6331490874290466,
0.31434690952301025,
0.009018255397677422,
-0.6151084899902344,
0.16972489655017853,
0.7615731954574585,
0.14329184591770172,
0.00973741989582777,
-0.4998455345630646,
-0.2396324723958969,
0.9694949984550476,
0.21518376469612122,
-0.7532116174697876,
0.2685990035533905,
0.018336882814764977,
0.4167858362197876,
-0.473904013633728,
0.13202473521232605,
0.7163107395172119,
0.15742343664169312,
0.06669206917285919,
-1.002895474433899,
-0.04824588820338249,
-0.13398538529872894,
0.05097722262144089,
0.3649686872959137,
-0.4644765555858612,
0.9994848966598511,
-0.04184854403138161,
-0.060410015285015106,
0.491850346326828,
0.5548460483551025,
0.19650544226169586,
0.5997645258903503,
0.5100672245025635,
0.6901892423629761,
0.27424386143684387,
-0.21728166937828064,
0.6284175515174866,
-0.25617024302482605,
0.6704076528549194,
1.147473692893982,
-0.20099884271621704,
1.058266043663025,
0.5417957901954651,
-0.0040786610916256905,
0.1566683053970337,
0.5911447405815125,
-0.15972934663295746,
0.7356072664260864,
-0.26320070028305054,
-0.021770719438791275,
-0.33958643674850464,
-0.1234828308224678,
-0.2066422700881958,
0.38987743854522705,
0.19829660654067993,
-0.35797062516212463,
-0.5969850420951843,
0.08641272783279419,
-0.3484013080596924,
0.4667218029499054,
-0.5638691186904907,
0.8256114721298218,
-0.02413311041891575,
-0.6462696194648743,
0.38519832491874695,
0.17723526060581207,
1.0996119976043701,
-0.1138768196105957,
-0.07532978057861328,
-0.3241236209869385,
0.4222237467765808,
-0.27653011679649353,
-1.091731071472168,
0.33407357335090637,
0.010510447435081005,
-0.2019217312335968,
0.47644510865211487,
0.7664151787757874,
-0.6477541327476501,
-0.32484158873558044,
0.053898103535175323,
0.16502375900745392,
-0.08199102431535721,
-0.5390821099281311,
-0.8220311403274536,
0.1174139454960823,
0.09815284609794617,
0.3745770752429962,
0.13963830471038818,
0.36324000358581543,
-0.07427609711885452,
0.2879488468170166,
0.33497297763824463,
-0.24466527998447418,
-0.2078331559896469,
0.1404823660850525,
0.5377650260925293,
-0.591679573059082,
-0.407122939825058,
-0.892559826374054,
0.3710636496543884,
-0.2627108693122864,
-0.555841863155365,
0.34428051114082336,
0.7431749701499939,
0.9396581053733826,
-0.21954965591430664,
0.398997962474823,
0.09608707576990128,
-0.14454035460948944,
-0.7543749213218689,
0.5902392268180847,
-1.0097459554672241,
0.043036188930273056,
-0.5761874318122864,
-1.2264000177383423,
-0.26042240858078003,
0.6061241626739502,
0.06374645978212357,
-0.2951655387878418,
0.8688694834709167,
0.8978400230407715,
-0.4325288236141205,
-0.07552625983953476,
0.47932156920433044,
-0.11304890364408493,
0.3055991232395172,
0.49747300148010254,
0.6124722361564636,
-0.9857778549194336,
0.3112226128578186,
-0.25875964760780334,
-0.18533547222614288,
-0.5121409893035889,
-0.9699277877807617,
-0.8648843169212341,
-0.8548642992973328,
-0.5625289678573608,
-0.2909979224205017,
-0.10147809982299805,
0.654159426689148,
0.4481096863746643,
-0.6823273301124573,
0.24115651845932007,
-0.4470423758029938,
-0.1380416303873062,
-0.19452646374702454,
-0.2517721951007843,
0.2509721517562866,
-0.32248252630233765,
-0.7605808973312378,
-0.017532406374812126,
0.566927969455719,
0.515608549118042,
-0.25040125846862793,
0.04681149125099182,
0.23732127249240875,
0.09193771332502365,
0.7063730955123901,
0.08896112442016602,
-0.7369914054870605,
-0.32864367961883545,
-0.17177340388298035,
-0.33230099081993103,
0.24943922460079193,
0.6437769532203674,
-0.37305617332458496,
0.6576562523841858,
0.46961164474487305,
0.7146464586257935,
0.35689976811408997,
-0.10296765714883804,
0.10534574091434479,
-0.9140067100524902,
0.31344738602638245,
-0.03326990827918053,
0.40223416686058044,
0.7882091403007507,
-0.1386415809392929,
0.37549328804016113,
0.2988600432872772,
-0.45360180735588074,
-0.9338366389274597,
0.0945025160908699,
-1.2587759494781494,
-0.3250691294670105,
0.9442892670631409,
0.12389649450778961,
-0.3204362690448761,
0.183048814535141,
-0.7088688611984253,
0.025728853419423103,
-0.08431833237409592,
0.8262714147567749,
0.601076066493988,
0.3989742398262024,
-0.0891861543059349,
-0.42772987484931946,
0.5457251071929932,
0.5314505696296692,
-1.1356143951416016,
0.054371461272239685,
0.5045362710952759,
0.25435933470726013,
0.19283321499824524,
0.4875764548778534,
-0.00804112944751978,
0.5246058702468872,
-0.14308930933475494,
0.13065165281295776,
0.011752307415008545,
-0.2803318202495575,
-0.255608469247818,
-0.13442878425121307,
-0.14368616044521332,
-0.522750198841095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14700v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14700v3
|
FlashSpeech: Efficient Zero-Shot Speech Synthesis
| 2024-04-23T02:57:46 | 2024-04-25T03:38:46 |
Zhen Ye, Zeqian Ju, Haohe Liu, Xu Tan, Jianyi Chen, Yiwen Lu, Peiwen Sun, Jiahao Pan, Weizhen Bian, Shulin He, Qifeng Liu, Yike Guo, Wei Xue
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
Recent progress in large-scale zero-shot speech synthesis has been
significantly advanced by language models and diffusion models. However, the
generation process of both methods is slow and computationally intensive.
Efficient speech synthesis using a lower computing budget to achieve quality on
par with previous work remains a significant challenge. In this paper, we
present FlashSpeech, a large-scale zero-shot speech synthesis system with
approximately 5\% of the inference time compared with previous work.
FlashSpeech is built on the latent consistency model and applies a novel
adversarial consistency training approach that can train from scratch without
the need for a pre-trained diffusion model as the teacher. Furthermore, a new
prosody generator module enhances the diversity of prosody, making the rhythm
of the speech sound more natural. The generation processes of FlashSpeech can
be achieved efficiently with one or two sampling steps while maintaining high
audio quality and high similarity to the audio prompt for zero-shot speech
generation. Our experimental results demonstrate the superior performance of
FlashSpeech. Notably, FlashSpeech can be about 20 times faster than other
zero-shot speech synthesis systems while maintaining comparable performance in
terms of voice quality and similarity. Furthermore, FlashSpeech demonstrates
its versatility by efficiently performing tasks like voice conversion, speech
editing, and diverse speech sampling. Audio samples can be found in
https://flashspeech.github.io/.
|
[
-0.19570864737033844,
-0.8189335465431213,
0.29162436723709106,
0.46515756845474243,
-0.0836537629365921,
0.17384731769561768,
-0.1484757959842682,
-0.12150970101356506,
0.37026119232177734,
-0.09307490289211273,
-0.6222410202026367,
-0.35367098450660706,
-0.3842088282108307,
-0.18003633618354797,
-0.7594029903411865,
0.7198371291160583,
0.3869612514972687,
0.16983401775360107,
0.5034933090209961,
-0.06183583289384842,
-0.16250093281269073,
0.01595480740070343,
-0.7410574555397034,
-0.27622345089912415,
0.2935539186000824,
0.5153436064720154,
0.5902740359306335,
0.2718203067779541,
-0.2867966592311859,
0.20270583033561707,
-0.0017696215072646737,
-0.2775234282016754,
-0.5056233406066895,
0.58845454454422,
-0.08500748127698898,
0.07534463703632355,
-0.6959553360939026,
-0.1199217289686203,
0.5578125715255737,
0.5588144063949585,
-0.2876933217048645,
0.2592063546180725,
-0.15958642959594727,
0.17012567818164825,
-0.909100353717804,
-0.4406167268753052,
-0.7604057192802429,
0.16165736317634583,
-0.28100380301475525,
-0.10204575210809708,
-0.3044404983520508,
-0.336182177066803,
-0.04344092682003975,
-0.22615255415439606,
0.6003028154373169,
-0.48789718747138977,
0.38441210985183716,
0.15119300782680511,
0.024424513801932335,
0.22288210690021515,
-0.8953428268432617,
0.6412058472633362,
-0.8931379914283752,
0.5683491230010986,
-0.03618839010596275,
0.5187361240386963,
-0.1033986359834671,
-0.6705057621002197,
-0.9128057956695557,
-0.1315302550792694,
0.87403804063797,
0.3961656093597412,
-0.15942621231079102,
-0.2031896561384201,
-0.0033136485144495964,
-0.020567456260323524,
-0.7780798673629761,
0.010617082007229328,
0.13131868839263916,
-0.19033066928386688,
0.4589715898036957,
-0.03915993124246597,
0.15959390997886658,
0.1389937698841095,
-0.06872842460870743,
-0.2950279414653778,
-0.7796843647956848,
-0.07225111871957779,
0.32996445894241333,
0.45965376496315,
0.2665976285934448,
0.39344996213912964,
-0.15707774460315704,
0.6765628457069397,
0.07832684367895126,
-0.39711350202560425,
0.2720456123352051,
-0.06701602041721344,
-0.10451266169548035,
0.4164184033870697,
0.7753835916519165,
0.10274919867515564,
-0.08014514297246933,
-0.149903804063797,
-0.11920605599880219,
-0.17412833869457245,
0.10485177487134933,
-0.9487575888633728,
-0.06542088091373444,
0.32060807943344116,
0.15391163527965546,
-0.1372760385274887,
-0.1360468566417694,
-0.5237429738044739,
-0.11944844573736191,
0.008294215425848961,
0.6917014122009277,
-0.6140543222427368,
-0.47647690773010254,
-0.17636846005916595,
-0.08074295520782471,
-0.01255128625780344,
0.5642914772033691,
-0.7095962166786194,
0.06185314059257507,
0.4728773832321167,
1.1314184665679932,
-0.07280473411083221,
-0.5788682699203491,
-0.9033246040344238,
0.2787074148654938,
-0.7376174330711365,
0.5118978023529053,
-0.06531859934329987,
-0.4003438353538513,
-0.3504616916179657,
-0.3548438251018524,
0.11157021671533585,
-0.5422613620758057,
-0.010906177572906017,
-0.07177059352397919,
-0.2450854480266571,
0.35885822772979736,
-0.5999109745025635,
0.30998653173446655,
-0.21445763111114502,
-0.28139838576316833,
0.6754069328308105,
0.02703694999217987,
-0.2132743000984192,
0.27449148893356323,
-0.43686866760253906,
-0.751635730266571,
0.17333504557609558,
0.07433982938528061,
-0.30315452814102173,
0.15606407821178436,
0.005971141159534454,
0.4976339042186737,
-0.06488409638404846,
0.23358090221881866,
-0.2215537428855896,
-0.6340375542640686,
0.2937999367713928,
-0.5564805865287781,
0.4909329414367676,
0.3670513331890106,
-1.0538674592971802,
-0.003161740954965353,
-0.9039523601531982,
0.1982542872428894,
-0.01790931634604931,
0.017849151045084,
0.1498812735080719,
-0.18420690298080444,
0.16301843523979187,
-0.010591737926006317,
-0.015361755155026913,
-0.5605272650718689,
-0.23357179760932922,
-0.5089602470397949,
0.5321474671363831,
0.5174723863601685,
0.0849415510892868,
0.6318679451942444,
0.2551485598087311,
0.27017831802368164,
-0.26334643363952637,
-0.02732950448989868,
-0.2547829747200012,
-0.3988874554634094,
-0.6186169385910034,
-0.41777151823043823,
0.43652865290641785,
0.4837794005870819,
-0.5098763108253479,
0.6026543974876404,
-0.127390056848526,
-0.6411999464035034,
-0.5675861835479736,
-0.2869917154312134,
0.1939050555229187,
0.6714233756065369,
0.3163958489894867,
-0.1684652715921402,
-0.37322765588760376,
-0.46895045042037964,
0.0384918749332428,
-0.07911981642246246,
-0.3837529420852661,
-0.0029614518862217665,
0.299076646566391,
0.21111911535263062,
0.8191861510276794,
-0.37159720063209534,
0.03298739716410637,
-0.27644652128219604,
0.26287996768951416,
0.2503921389579773,
0.514785885810852,
0.5273035168647766,
-0.3094538748264313,
-0.6423996686935425,
-0.20073151588439941,
-0.16575387120246887,
-0.19704292714595795,
-0.24996545910835266,
0.0426589772105217,
0.17995555698871613,
0.3977869749069214,
-0.44800594449043274,
0.3723069727420807,
0.4857019782066345,
-0.08114662021398544,
0.579224169254303,
-0.0357692614197731,
0.285330593585968,
-0.8429927229881287,
0.4025799632072449,
-0.5029121041297913,
-0.38943958282470703,
-0.999711811542511,
-0.18150757253170013,
-0.19486333429813385,
-0.6127251982688904,
-0.8806620836257935,
0.4891238212585449,
-0.20070713758468628,
-0.17674587666988373,
-0.3999251127243042,
0.41221699118614197,
-0.12916673719882965,
0.178218811750412,
0.06060997396707535,
1.1087672710418701,
0.8327146768569946,
-0.6489412188529968,
0.2463354766368866,
-0.10071969777345657,
-0.16323968768119812,
0.7267125844955444,
-0.7572522759437561,
0.11690526455640793,
0.21798807382583618,
0.32712626457214355,
-0.8607659935951233,
-0.12820687890052795,
-0.1556418538093567,
-0.719931423664093,
0.24666841328144073,
0.027326008304953575,
-0.38778024911880493,
-0.14301209151744843,
-0.24553091824054718,
-0.08356134593486786,
0.8767533898353577,
-0.5032258629798889,
0.18139734864234924,
0.286019891500473,
-0.31173175573349,
-0.5305843949317932,
-0.7863541841506958,
0.28013527393341064,
0.23315753042697906,
-0.5212395191192627,
0.228220134973526,
-0.11389192193746567,
0.026325318962335587,
-0.18915188312530518,
-0.3238925337791443,
-0.14409491419792175,
-0.09347867965698242,
0.03891461342573166,
-0.14898395538330078,
-0.21030117571353912,
-0.18450525403022766,
0.08774162828922272,
-0.08839240670204163,
-0.7189915776252747,
-0.2969212234020233,
0.4947302043437958,
0.16999077796936035,
-0.32288894057273865,
-0.5095961093902588,
0.4410879909992218,
0.6073256731033325,
0.2436162382364273,
0.6429355144500732,
0.7903117537498474,
-0.013276727870106697,
-0.5725848078727722,
-0.311178982257843,
-0.2972131669521332,
-0.3863895535469055,
0.24907538294792175,
-0.13124696910381317,
-0.8828882575035095,
0.21059514582157135,
-0.0706665962934494,
0.17997127771377563,
0.27445557713508606,
0.4251161217689514,
-0.024293746799230576,
0.9706194996833801,
0.002876946469768882,
0.20260868966579437,
0.6266570091247559,
-0.12843528389930725,
0.23597294092178345,
-0.43577152490615845,
0.18472786247730255,
-0.3566776216030121,
-0.3610558807849884,
0.06501898914575577,
-0.44998371601104736,
0.5201716423034668,
0.08545663207769394,
-0.4734390676021576,
0.496398389339447,
-0.464601993560791,
0.3663855493068695,
0.6484324336051941,
-0.2099313884973526,
-0.15245236456394196,
0.07349843531847,
0.08837702125310898,
-0.16331002116203308,
-0.6579948663711548,
-0.14493565261363983,
0.8207123875617981,
-0.05169583484530449,
0.384195476770401,
0.32772985100746155,
0.731863796710968,
0.23568519949913025,
-0.3076910078525543,
-0.39948582649230957,
0.8893244862556458,
-0.39775750041007996,
-0.4820813536643982,
-0.3762674331665039,
-0.3809887766838074,
-0.7611587047576904,
0.29309701919555664,
-0.4494844079017639,
-0.563668429851532,
-0.10755365341901779,
0.22799722850322723,
-0.4837648570537567,
0.2621147930622101,
-0.7898944020271301,
0.5256458520889282,
0.06962627917528152,
-0.6145012974739075,
-0.1972721666097641,
-0.685464084148407,
0.18479830026626587,
0.04396069422364235,
-0.13504593074321747,
-0.26772743463516235,
0.19250540435314178,
0.5235889554023743,
-0.45970624685287476,
0.6101153492927551,
-0.4955783784389496,
0.08421929180622101,
0.38343682885169983,
0.3387226164340973,
0.25550252199172974,
0.04196741804480553,
-0.16792944073677063,
0.18261964619159698,
-0.3260921239852905,
-0.26027438044548035,
-0.6043899059295654,
0.9409863352775574,
-0.504224956035614,
-0.32216596603393555,
-0.15462996065616608,
-0.32400280237197876,
-0.44879770278930664,
0.2890644073486328,
0.24497893452644348,
0.37065133452415466,
-0.6184015870094299,
0.15973152220249176,
0.6830527782440186,
-0.20535320043563843,
0.6515390872955322,
0.7627134323120117,
0.07825664430856705,
-0.5196069478988647,
1.1725820302963257,
0.2891169786453247,
0.375105619430542,
0.15709517896175385,
0.09197022765874863,
-0.2473222315311432,
-0.5684660077095032,
-0.6949203014373779,
-0.006426954176276922,
-0.25742006301879883,
-0.27072498202323914,
-0.49554479122161865,
-0.24035276472568512,
-0.9875383973121643,
-0.43389540910720825,
-0.8673630356788635,
-0.8381396532058716,
-0.5004252791404724,
0.1855240911245346,
0.17023617029190063,
0.3509449064731598,
-0.4075257182121277,
0.441265344619751,
-0.6263700723648071,
0.5724524855613708,
0.5418164134025574,
0.06563366204500198,
0.17973177134990692,
-0.5390690565109253,
0.02048695832490921,
-0.13357782363891602,
-0.210800439119339,
-0.9434551000595093,
0.32059815526008606,
0.48399779200553894,
0.37753742933273315,
0.3612018823623657,
-0.0684039369225502,
0.9150042533874512,
-0.9296334981918335,
1.2363795042037964,
0.5831755995750427,
-1.2549782991409302,
0.7051055431365967,
-0.12167529761791229,
0.7746791839599609,
0.587323009967804,
-0.003952336963266134,
-0.37230151891708374,
-0.6522488594055176,
-0.9670743942260742,
-1.2793643474578857,
0.6220428347587585,
0.5233177542686462,
-0.09386107325553894,
-0.0033107425551861525,
0.0950646698474884,
0.15393494069576263,
0.3970834016799927,
0.037024177610874176,
-0.25087669491767883,
-0.6305665969848633,
-0.1927328109741211,
-0.3125908076763153,
0.11214320361614227,
-0.053473010659217834,
-0.05722326785326004,
0.9291729927062988,
0.017254717648029327,
0.15479712188243866,
0.1885589063167572,
-0.17133751511573792,
-0.01622767001390457,
0.5671052932739258,
0.9798374176025391,
0.4217130243778229,
-0.09750161319971085,
0.4083956182003021,
0.11335179954767227,
-0.6559091210365295,
0.5147835612297058,
0.002146543934941292,
-0.5014114379882812,
0.34422826766967773,
0.23397305607795715,
0.8662135004997253,
0.34748443961143494,
-0.6799939870834351,
0.749854564666748,
0.10586949437856674,
-0.33213290572166443,
-0.1951749175786972,
0.4116756319999695,
0.19001823663711548,
0.18496368825435638,
0.5142734050750732,
0.18218813836574554,
0.09805729985237122,
-0.2735660672187805,
0.36123502254486084,
0.23489078879356384,
0.03616562858223915,
-0.3449792265892029,
0.9122084975242615,
0.11831487715244293,
-0.3885873854160309,
0.2761734127998352,
-0.26717591285705566,
0.045632969588041306,
0.18375135958194733,
0.5442790985107422,
1.0360503196716309,
-0.8361578583717346,
0.5601072311401367,
0.45336824655532837,
-0.17363955080509186,
-0.3823658227920532,
0.24945232272148132,
-0.24306339025497437,
-0.12640607357025146,
-0.43205028772354126,
-0.7453866600990295,
-0.7218926548957825,
0.05033215880393982,
-0.24992835521697998,
0.15662218630313873,
-0.7123420238494873,
-0.1339160054922104,
-0.025195859372615814,
-0.4857729971408844,
0.06012868881225586,
0.2503012716770172,
0.08302230387926102,
0.6274295449256897,
-0.7362253665924072,
0.7316510677337646,
0.27337315678596497,
-0.1839342713356018,
-0.7025985717773438,
0.04986266419291496,
0.12677153944969177,
-0.5156702399253845,
0.20803850889205933,
-0.10053874552249908,
-0.5427451133728027,
0.2375718206167221,
-0.49630463123321533,
-0.563145101070404,
0.9024591445922852,
0.6510134339332581,
-0.8508074283599854,
0.4229638874530792,
0.014615294523537159,
0.6462589502334595,
-0.3325106203556061,
0.28853079676628113,
0.5380612015724182,
0.2635776102542877,
0.6998521685600281,
-0.926173210144043,
-0.23551617562770844,
0.04785013198852539,
0.14423306286334991,
-0.094160296022892,
-0.4619075059890747,
0.7909983396530151,
-0.18909060955047607,
-0.26277923583984375,
0.05315094813704491,
0.8206334114074707,
0.3012726604938507,
0.2734173834323883,
0.5140162110328674,
0.3915252089500427,
0.7308179140090942,
-0.0049288515001535416,
0.33059555292129517,
-0.13275183737277985,
0.050013743340969086,
1.3080172538757324,
-0.5733383893966675,
1.166285753250122,
0.29202672839164734,
-0.2225058227777481,
0.2731880247592926,
0.04908285290002823,
-0.0019178600050508976,
0.7105097770690918,
-0.009428047575056553,
-0.6456549167633057,
-0.1926346719264984,
0.160440132021904,
-0.22750605642795563,
0.3577278256416321,
0.04078853875398636,
0.1533820927143097,
-0.2786826491355896,
0.18513302505016327,
0.04531387239694595,
-0.1486179083585739,
-0.1671828180551529,
0.638455867767334,
-0.2739405035972595,
-0.45287126302719116,
0.7189620733261108,
-0.31866443157196045,
0.6620938777923584,
-0.8612011671066284,
-0.07267967611551285,
-0.1612463891506195,
0.19115787744522095,
-0.14443737268447876,
-0.8978354930877686,
0.28493037819862366,
0.13616755604743958,
-0.03719579428434372,
-0.2362324446439743,
0.46605509519577026,
-0.575477123260498,
-0.09107834845781326,
-0.16920529305934906,
0.38864269852638245,
0.4475081264972687,
-0.19205649197101593,
-0.66449373960495,
0.13812872767448425,
0.08769246935844421,
-0.26745831966400146,
0.27802637219429016,
0.15802346169948578,
0.3078024685382843,
0.2812265455722809,
0.6420836448669434,
0.614933431148529,
0.17754733562469482,
0.44939330220222473,
0.24705621600151062,
-0.5487596988677979,
-0.6044988632202148,
-0.5513961911201477,
0.48011770844459534,
-0.07723472267389297,
-0.20444931089878082,
0.8289299607276917,
0.3646319806575775,
0.36324208974838257,
-0.046951111406087875,
0.759212851524353,
-0.23758424818515778,
0.8208168745040894,
-0.20380422472953796,
0.8891489505767822,
-0.5021946430206299,
-0.09278614073991776,
-0.33282148838043213,
-0.9756484627723694,
-0.43250754475593567,
0.6713569164276123,
0.28485751152038574,
-0.06575773656368256,
0.4554969072341919,
0.7549487948417664,
0.002542447531595826,
0.007197920698672533,
0.7356719374656677,
0.2867337167263031,
0.4333890676498413,
0.24517524242401123,
0.33305439352989197,
-0.4287445843219757,
0.6119129061698914,
-0.09075058996677399,
-0.36346444487571716,
-0.16944439709186554,
-0.6797100901603699,
-0.24807704985141754,
-0.5515870451927185,
-0.4465872347354889,
-0.288184255361557,
0.12385894358158112,
0.4577471613883972,
0.9017866849899292,
-0.8591176271438599,
-0.17593926191329956,
-0.25583499670028687,
-0.23267021775245667,
-0.37071895599365234,
-0.28791525959968567,
0.13626232743263245,
-0.22398558259010315,
-0.9607521891593933,
1.1803734302520752,
0.6113333106040955,
0.3147558271884918,
-0.39905306696891785,
-0.04673129320144653,
-0.2456657588481903,
0.23154260218143463,
0.47407516837120056,
0.5246816873550415,
-0.42189842462539673,
-0.08086942881345749,
-0.012974180281162262,
0.17888988554477692,
-0.08875490725040436,
0.7726625204086304,
-0.6427791118621826,
0.528219997882843,
0.5037158727645874,
0.3335142433643341,
0.7924055457115173,
-0.25349560379981995,
0.45397114753723145,
-0.9384125471115112,
0.39738157391548157,
0.42090266942977905,
-0.024839576333761215,
0.4334017038345337,
0.047379910945892334,
0.26694393157958984,
0.2621297240257263,
-0.467219740152359,
-0.7631784081459045,
0.24433213472366333,
-0.9008933901786804,
-0.49640992283821106,
1.103096604347229,
-0.07454898953437805,
-0.38983744382858276,
0.015378710813820362,
-0.11783542484045029,
0.42142224311828613,
-0.6840270161628723,
0.32552289962768555,
0.16905970871448517,
-0.4987015128135681,
-0.13944020867347717,
-0.360869824886322,
0.19499464333057404,
0.4024031460285187,
-0.3608168363571167,
-0.008728738874197006,
0.6537787914276123,
0.5757644772529602,
0.24024245142936707,
0.8887801170349121,
0.014076282270252705,
0.5403620600700378,
0.5042959451675415,
0.3664602041244507,
-0.024378333240747452,
-0.3912044167518616,
-0.2967938184738159,
0.6064825654029846,
-0.3113192915916443,
-0.027402101084589958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14695v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14695v1
|
MisgenderMender: A Community-Informed Approach to Interventions for Misgendering
| 2024-04-23T02:54:00 | 2024-04-23T02:54:00 |
Tamanna Hossain, Sunipa Dev, Sameer Singh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Content Warning: This paper contains examples of misgendering and erasure
that could be offensive and potentially triggering.
Misgendering, the act of incorrectly addressing someone's gender, inflicts
serious harm and is pervasive in everyday technologies, yet there is a notable
lack of research to combat it. We are the first to address this lack of
research into interventions for misgendering by conducting a survey of
gender-diverse individuals in the US to understand perspectives about automated
interventions for text-based misgendering. Based on survey insights on the
prevalence of misgendering, desired solutions, and associated concerns, we
introduce a misgendering interventions task and evaluation dataset,
MisgenderMender. We define the task with two sub-tasks: (i) detecting
misgendering, followed by (ii) correcting misgendering where misgendering is
present in domains where editing is appropriate. MisgenderMender comprises 3790
instances of social media content and LLM-generations about non-cisgender
public figures, annotated for the presence of misgendering, with additional
annotations for correcting misgendering in LLM-generated text. Using this
dataset, we set initial benchmarks by evaluating existing NLP systems and
highlighting challenges for future models to address. We release the full
dataset, code, and demo at
https://tamannahossainkay.github.io/misgendermender/.
|
[
-0.1574636548757553,
-0.6544119715690613,
0.014880453236401081,
0.33928391337394714,
0.11733726412057877,
0.1730298548936844,
0.03986117243766785,
-0.27025943994522095,
0.08826170116662979,
0.38757553696632385,
-1.0794942378997803,
-0.44523900747299194,
-0.873594343662262,
0.46995809674263,
-0.4558742344379425,
0.6060096025466919,
0.07525193691253662,
0.18236353993415833,
-0.17761242389678955,
-0.030394267290830612,
-0.936874270439148,
-0.27431434392929077,
-0.6842833161354065,
-0.08515702933073044,
0.5781495571136475,
0.6880237460136414,
0.39957794547080994,
0.5928793549537659,
0.5532223582267761,
0.28090304136276245,
-0.20331591367721558,
0.43319568037986755,
-0.892676830291748,
0.05175665766000748,
-0.47018930315971375,
-0.3359050452709198,
-0.15581189095973969,
0.09297871589660645,
0.25008296966552734,
0.7335615754127502,
-0.2018522024154663,
0.22781991958618164,
0.1982111930847168,
0.6700755953788757,
-0.9225679636001587,
-0.26812949776649475,
-0.5549549460411072,
0.31977778673171997,
-0.18553730845451355,
-0.19669495522975922,
-0.09303881973028183,
-0.5221431851387024,
-0.01582389511168003,
-0.294584721326828,
0.6402042508125305,
0.04498576000332832,
0.14449462294578552,
0.22245126962661743,
-0.2460678219795227,
-0.40787413716316223,
-0.9453147053718567,
0.8626109957695007,
-0.5803540945053101,
0.14178283512592316,
0.567939281463623,
0.13905397057533264,
-0.16837552189826965,
-0.24685776233673096,
-0.4584103226661682,
0.5170732736587524,
-0.12737999856472015,
0.06889659911394119,
-0.5746753811836243,
-0.07632005214691162,
0.26972705125808716,
-0.011664120480418205,
-0.6728845834732056,
-0.004547640681266785,
-0.577107310295105,
-0.22507484257221222,
0.7731474041938782,
0.305591344833374,
0.4422529637813568,
-0.3082869052886963,
-0.20685458183288574,
0.2027772217988968,
-0.5471825003623962,
-0.4605800211429596,
0.6234517693519592,
0.39623555541038513,
0.0671275183558464,
0.8123862147331238,
0.016209179535508156,
0.3897777795791626,
0.13798274099826813,
0.17548894882202148,
0.3759235143661499,
-0.2301015704870224,
-0.13508914411067963,
0.2747347354888916,
0.553363025188446,
0.6883951425552368,
0.2182369977235794,
-0.10530830174684525,
-0.06357360631227493,
-0.10511163622140884,
0.41143542528152466,
-0.4365431070327759,
0.04605090618133545,
0.08680906146764755,
-0.5943888425827026,
-0.27459457516670227,
-0.01348046213388443,
-0.7882679104804993,
-0.803138017654419,
-0.09514813125133514,
0.27961137890815735,
-0.44227826595306396,
-0.4380529820919037,
0.17390941083431244,
-0.6543816328048706,
0.11445964872837067,
0.4341137409210205,
-0.8391086459159851,
0.11689211428165436,
0.7950479984283447,
0.6653056144714355,
0.014498705044388771,
-0.20375019311904907,
-0.12407315522432327,
0.13896889984607697,
-0.10369640588760376,
0.4981735944747925,
-0.6478727459907532,
-0.6185588836669922,
0.2367558777332306,
0.27105486392974854,
-0.31690457463264465,
-0.6572124361991882,
0.5714519023895264,
-0.02075004018843174,
0.37342971563339233,
-0.4554060399532318,
-0.40605881810188293,
0.02238699235022068,
0.2958706021308899,
-0.5110666751861572,
0.8426969647407532,
0.07469654828310013,
-1.0006288290023804,
0.2783154845237732,
-0.7945873141288757,
-0.15044616162776947,
-0.004171791020780802,
0.007480832282453775,
-0.25881221890449524,
0.10982449352741241,
0.27854883670806885,
0.14420853555202484,
-0.07168843597173691,
0.15223203599452972,
-0.06690195202827454,
-0.4372270107269287,
-0.005369856953620911,
-0.6366314888000488,
0.7337846159934998,
0.11795803159475327,
-0.3567987084388733,
0.10798562318086624,
-0.42163339257240295,
-0.5686953663825989,
0.25931307673454285,
0.05069950968027115,
-0.6002741456031799,
0.0433911569416523,
0.14582671225070953,
0.06885271519422531,
0.326130747795105,
-0.6326058506965637,
-0.100856713950634,
-0.23424658179283142,
0.18885065615177155,
0.8579288125038147,
0.020479917526245117,
0.3888709843158722,
-0.5539336800575256,
0.6891792416572571,
-0.030744880437850952,
0.5450486540794373,
0.09740486741065979,
-0.5038766264915466,
-0.4056110084056854,
-0.06256807595491409,
0.2634173333644867,
0.791398286819458,
-1.10789954662323,
0.5173726677894592,
-0.18938449025154114,
-0.3417912721633911,
-0.46671590209007263,
0.11508488655090332,
0.5199090838432312,
0.5031000375747681,
0.449432373046875,
-0.2574153542518616,
-0.8144903779029846,
-1.1997395753860474,
-0.45860451459884644,
-0.21603788435459137,
-0.10490180552005768,
0.1443146914243698,
0.3994291424751282,
-0.4018866717815399,
1.0463829040527344,
-0.5032972097396851,
-0.24302731454372406,
-0.2677314579486847,
0.6596599817276001,
-0.30800414085388184,
0.5868074297904968,
0.26927727460861206,
-0.7002309560775757,
-0.004826591815799475,
-0.3806906044483185,
-0.8355920910835266,
-0.43913733959198,
0.031577955931425095,
-0.2605273127555847,
-0.17282985150814056,
0.5051483511924744,
-0.2769898474216461,
0.3865519165992737,
0.4287808835506439,
-0.11727282404899597,
0.3575255274772644,
-0.09746850281953812,
0.38041603565216064,
-0.8790512084960938,
0.0868777334690094,
0.10835132002830505,
-0.0481543093919754,
-0.9850268959999084,
-0.32537007331848145,
-0.06358540803194046,
-0.023892773315310478,
-0.5770480632781982,
0.32177525758743286,
-0.43687161803245544,
0.06543976068496704,
-0.2360626608133316,
-0.19438375532627106,
-0.3452681601047516,
0.16027840971946716,
-0.17230068147182465,
0.6774088740348816,
-0.11870962381362915,
-0.15167279541492462,
-0.21835903823375702,
0.5799648761749268,
-0.029888072982430458,
0.8539665937423706,
-0.3921538293361664,
0.21853363513946533,
-0.6986926198005676,
0.2001066952943802,
-0.8808315992355347,
-0.21786312758922577,
0.9711620807647705,
-0.3668900728225708,
0.10050684213638306,
-0.09643950313329697,
-0.55796217918396,
-0.493989497423172,
-0.4975484013557434,
0.4944234788417816,
0.040016744285821915,
-0.1629573106765747,
0.6093877553939819,
0.4994702637195587,
-0.44104862213134766,
-0.8702548146247864,
-0.7012167572975159,
0.4050843119621277,
-0.20355111360549927,
-0.5256780385971069,
0.017480332404375076,
-0.10991344600915909,
-0.1847892701625824,
-0.07817849516868591,
-0.0751524418592453,
-0.262319952249527,
0.15858958661556244,
0.09396656602621078,
0.05051610618829727,
0.20945845544338226,
0.4608656167984009,
0.37092313170433044,
-0.08058254420757294,
-0.06487569212913513,
0.35264331102371216,
0.5461809039115906,
0.3331674635410309,
-0.4680711328983307,
-0.26693958044052124,
0.6607844233512878,
0.006393853574991226,
-0.03917044773697853,
0.5739571452140808,
0.6494406461715698,
-0.5440202951431274,
0.020606813952326775,
-0.5275501608848572,
-0.09494902193546295,
-0.4439695477485657,
0.3371036648750305,
0.15083274245262146,
-1.0853326320648193,
0.23414243757724762,
-0.13268832862377167,
0.24637098610401154,
0.5577378273010254,
0.17061924934387207,
-0.41788920760154724,
0.9190908074378967,
0.6395254731178284,
-0.153412327170372,
0.46058979630470276,
0.0040554022416472435,
-0.05442046374082565,
-0.5947796702384949,
-0.154322549700737,
-0.5593335032463074,
-0.661686897277832,
-0.6189441084861755,
-0.735076367855072,
0.04937081038951874,
-0.17446795105934143,
-0.041730064898729324,
0.3522607088088989,
-0.6094670295715332,
0.40619251132011414,
0.3552805483341217,
0.30520111322402954,
0.25315922498703003,
-0.12775075435638428,
0.47488757967948914,
-0.2825663685798645,
-0.7855075001716614,
-0.45512059330940247,
0.9775224924087524,
0.31748393177986145,
0.8438495397567749,
0.1171645000576973,
0.8730990886688232,
0.7817570567131042,
0.6985540390014648,
-0.4501565098762512,
0.384873628616333,
-0.3276098370552063,
-1.0339256525039673,
-0.3272753953933716,
-0.6226387619972229,
-1.2019622325897217,
0.09032629430294037,
-0.27283310890197754,
-0.621199369430542,
0.6962311267852783,
0.17491061985492706,
-0.04206424951553345,
0.20375068485736847,
-0.46788355708122253,
0.7776336669921875,
-0.04064991697669029,
-0.03933660313487053,
-0.11946097761392593,
-0.8832948803901672,
0.5976788997650146,
-0.21454939246177673,
0.6897301077842712,
-0.2913064956665039,
0.14623454213142395,
0.5679071545600891,
-0.1687893569469452,
1.1171438694000244,
-0.5087006092071533,
-0.10596321523189545,
0.04479563236236572,
-0.13555431365966797,
0.2172556221485138,
-0.4715263247489929,
0.045574452728033066,
0.2736772298812866,
-0.3309010863304138,
-0.1385764628648758,
-0.3016015589237213,
0.2992154657840729,
-0.5586185455322266,
-0.47298362851142883,
-0.1307399719953537,
-0.4959346354007721,
-0.08596260845661163,
-0.14814208447933197,
0.24942398071289062,
0.20986369252204895,
-0.5926169157028198,
-0.024421533569693565,
0.8936148285865784,
-0.5101283192634583,
0.23912790417671204,
0.2071014940738678,
-0.1587281972169876,
-0.3145875632762909,
1.0471678972244263,
-0.022318575531244278,
0.03273743391036987,
0.36823585629463196,
0.22208420932292938,
-0.15201081335544586,
-0.1723843365907669,
-0.3435903787612915,
0.09089047461748123,
-0.672732412815094,
0.02292346954345703,
-0.7066013216972351,
-0.02743411436676979,
-0.34614095091819763,
-0.020262135192751884,
-0.24632708728313446,
-0.32851487398147583,
-0.47476333379745483,
0.034119248390197754,
0.036524273455142975,
0.6390495896339417,
-0.3336612284183502,
0.6453391313552856,
-0.8905288577079773,
0.42158785462379456,
0.3185672163963318,
0.09361208230257034,
-0.15330232679843903,
-0.3052423894405365,
0.01640617474913597,
0.14517448842525482,
-0.22287283837795258,
-0.9581200480461121,
0.322147935628891,
0.11925759166479111,
0.6020978093147278,
0.10800796747207642,
-0.09862373769283295,
0.6471323370933533,
-0.5342526435852051,
0.5567908883094788,
0.25473394989967346,
-0.9045794606208801,
0.6114994287490845,
-0.3470432758331299,
0.4622856080532074,
0.9381154775619507,
0.34075430035591125,
-1.0589027404785156,
-0.5471150279045105,
-0.43224722146987915,
-0.9387494921684265,
0.8248511552810669,
0.4324723184108734,
0.35986948013305664,
-0.24185070395469666,
0.20825903117656708,
0.18422193825244904,
0.5688675045967102,
-0.3081149458885193,
-0.5234706401824951,
-0.1564009040594101,
-0.3078908920288086,
0.02436075173318386,
-0.4839234948158264,
-0.35937970876693726,
0.018587235361337662,
0.6550648808479309,
0.007997128181159496,
0.36528804898262024,
0.1968434602022171,
-0.42352351546287537,
-0.3850497603416443,
0.23125585913658142,
0.7449432611465454,
0.5715556144714355,
-0.27039167284965515,
-0.06862716376781464,
0.04486561566591263,
-0.3815913200378418,
0.07955853641033173,
0.16743141412734985,
-0.1837242692708969,
0.3582671880722046,
0.3603864908218384,
0.3815159797668457,
0.28174033761024475,
-0.5365583896636963,
0.6700088977813721,
-0.4192168414592743,
-0.47366011142730713,
-0.05913277715444565,
-0.1877879649400711,
0.046559158712625504,
0.1709294617176056,
0.5424066185951233,
0.24411948025226593,
0.4881727695465088,
-0.22883300483226776,
0.1152840256690979,
0.3776189386844635,
-0.6705945730209351,
-0.02660905010998249,
0.4497387409210205,
0.23424501717090607,
-0.3908178508281708,
0.376991331577301,
-0.09717272222042084,
-0.46739256381988525,
0.7334474325180054,
0.19944381713867188,
1.192388892173767,
-0.5229896903038025,
0.379169225692749,
0.29017385840415955,
0.8031750321388245,
-0.026677602902054787,
0.2948582172393799,
0.267832487821579,
-0.7890207767486572,
-0.16950483620166779,
-0.3104415535926819,
-0.28509843349456787,
-0.04796373471617699,
-0.46004632115364075,
0.1304951161146164,
-0.4275570511817932,
-0.24071557819843292,
-0.016084931790828705,
-0.6271077990531921,
-0.5946102142333984,
0.12701384723186493,
0.2299349009990692,
0.9043043851852417,
-1.1259257793426514,
0.028698978945612907,
0.5585559010505676,
-0.07326173037290573,
-0.17618680000305176,
0.3087853789329529,
0.5916185975074768,
-0.5992408394813538,
0.4788978397846222,
0.26285818219184875,
-0.14033937454223633,
-0.06056416034698486,
-0.8397823572158813,
-0.6045438647270203,
0.888796865940094,
0.2745819091796875,
-0.6066122651100159,
0.18167299032211304,
0.387933611869812,
0.2696618139743805,
-0.21798749268054962,
0.0957227349281311,
0.5103567838668823,
0.6331488490104675,
0.03721752390265465,
-0.7780526280403137,
-0.126301109790802,
-0.2056308388710022,
0.266976535320282,
0.18393740057945251,
-0.23251721262931824,
0.5776804089546204,
0.24750977754592896,
-0.4042177200317383,
0.13105781376361847,
0.3615427315235138,
0.09434773027896881,
0.28371462225914,
0.8266648650169373,
0.3069809675216675,
0.6912850737571716,
-0.08130058646202087,
0.7505286931991577,
0.10533007979393005,
0.19850125908851624,
1.140299916267395,
-0.16068395972251892,
0.19734060764312744,
0.4643547236919403,
-0.03106720745563507,
-0.08837327361106873,
0.45910000801086426,
0.03853326663374901,
0.37408506870269775,
0.4212033450603485,
-0.41550058126449585,
-0.07857128232717514,
-0.3961080014705658,
-0.3987656235694885,
0.45451924204826355,
0.3338559865951538,
-0.5049722194671631,
-0.5526310801506042,
0.14147880673408508,
-0.08292175084352493,
0.18581771850585938,
-0.21246154606342316,
0.7762490510940552,
-0.12734496593475342,
0.019974274560809135,
0.16829347610473633,
0.26211121678352356,
0.906947135925293,
-0.492646723985672,
-0.1439402550458908,
-0.3175712525844574,
-0.17746752500534058,
-0.29583683609962463,
-0.5536755323410034,
0.468568354845047,
0.05131327360868454,
-0.4251156449317932,
-0.2919442653656006,
1.0543267726898193,
-0.6608123183250427,
-0.7135807871818542,
0.1518552005290985,
0.8196479082107544,
0.061731547117233276,
0.10398814082145691,
-0.8830581307411194,
0.06053188443183899,
0.10313291102647781,
0.07947706431150436,
0.0781555026769638,
0.2947539687156677,
-0.0951409712433815,
0.5793896913528442,
0.4661853313446045,
-0.17408204078674316,
-0.010448561981320381,
0.5355618000030518,
0.5257333517074585,
-0.46649467945098877,
0.04223393648862839,
-0.825772762298584,
0.4330293536186218,
-0.23691211640834808,
-0.42458486557006836,
0.6623503565788269,
0.5470030307769775,
0.674168050289154,
-0.12471078336238861,
0.8911398649215698,
-0.14323176443576813,
0.5965926647186279,
0.02953323721885681,
0.5164315700531006,
-0.6301918625831604,
0.15902593731880188,
-0.5373056530952454,
-0.7467226386070251,
-0.33334553241729736,
0.3049263656139374,
-0.4210517704486847,
0.02828284539282322,
0.1207914724946022,
0.9564566612243652,
-0.025403298437595367,
0.35471633076667786,
0.3294207453727722,
0.017036007717251778,
0.17117124795913696,
-0.05107375234365463,
1.220531702041626,
-0.326870322227478,
0.30100762844085693,
-0.24548029899597168,
-0.2463463544845581,
-0.21371427178382874,
-0.6911280751228333,
-0.5474836230278015,
-0.19425104558467865,
-0.1997135579586029,
0.1234164834022522,
0.510441780090332,
1.079671025276184,
0.21531397104263306,
-0.4945182204246521,
-0.319982647895813,
-0.04082490876317024,
0.30612215399742126,
-0.1616964042186737,
-0.22870458662509918,
-0.19111280143260956,
-0.11990727484226227,
-0.8518936038017273,
0.17326363921165466,
0.19866403937339783,
-0.23388062417507172,
-0.18181076645851135,
0.07490519434213638,
-0.4537118077278137,
-0.011665591038763523,
0.5522608757019043,
0.0867704227566719,
-0.24703368544578552,
-0.2380794882774353,
-0.3701535761356354,
-0.1634477823972702,
0.1459980309009552,
0.8514873385429382,
-0.1425369381904602,
0.47041288018226624,
0.43190619349479675,
0.6538087129592896,
0.15154321491718292,
0.3777894079685211,
0.6066428422927856,
-1.142433524131775,
-0.23451241850852966,
0.35517728328704834,
0.2339850217103958,
0.6098890900611877,
-0.5546197295188904,
0.563994824886322,
0.4863070249557495,
-0.2563638389110565,
-0.5182772874832153,
0.12395666539669037,
-0.5385090708732605,
-0.5467174053192139,
0.8637558221817017,
0.10176722705364227,
-0.16709332168102264,
-0.42384374141693115,
-0.3949717879295349,
0.4897069036960602,
-0.4946955442428589,
0.7497134208679199,
0.6651110053062439,
0.21640437841415405,
-0.2479352355003357,
-0.6270989775657654,
0.1918596476316452,
0.3064185082912445,
-0.9351774454116821,
0.45617249608039856,
0.751440703868866,
0.24261783063411713,
0.08199062943458557,
0.7103074789047241,
-0.07033763825893402,
0.2776414155960083,
-0.1889628916978836,
0.5307470560073853,
0.21103206276893616,
-0.16714836657047272,
-0.5739803910255432,
-0.12260010838508606,
-0.4108543395996094,
-0.1036854013800621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14687v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14687v1
|
Pegasus-v1 Technical Report
| 2024-04-23T02:32:57 | 2024-04-23T02:32:57 |
Raehyuk Jung, Hyojun Go, Jaehyuk Yi, Jiho Jang, Daniel Kim, Jay Suh, Aiden Lee, Cooper Han, Jae Lee, Jeff Kim, Jin-Young Kim, Junwan Kim, Kyle Park, Lucas Lee, Mars Ha, Minjoon Seo, Abraham Jo, Ed Park, Hassan Kianinejad, SJ Kim, Tony Moon, Wade Jeong, Andrei Popescu, Esther Kim, EK Yoon, Genie Heo, Henry Choi, Jenna Kang, Kevin Han, Noah Seo, Sunny Nguyen, Ryan Won, Yeonhoo Park, Anthony Giuliani, Dave Chung, Hans Yoon, James Le, Jenny Ahn, June Lee, Maninder Saini, Meredith Sanders, Soyoung Lee, Sue Kim, Travis Couture
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
This technical report introduces Pegasus-1, a multimodal language model
specialized in video content understanding and interaction through natural
language. Pegasus-1 is designed to address the unique challenges posed by video
data, such as interpreting spatiotemporal information, to offer nuanced video
content comprehension across various lengths. This technical report overviews
Pegasus-1's architecture, training strategies, and its performance in
benchmarks on video conversation, zero-shot video question answering, and video
summarization. We also explore qualitative characteristics of Pegasus-1 ,
demonstrating its capabilities as well as its limitations, in order to provide
readers a balanced view of its current state and its future direction.
|
[
-0.7575013041496277,
-1.0183755159378052,
0.20318906009197235,
0.6402340531349182,
-0.6206725239753723,
-0.16181571781635284,
0.08375158905982971,
-0.5499915480613708,
0.5978513956069946,
0.5781297087669373,
-1.0711524486541748,
-0.4600580334663391,
-0.7702915668487549,
-0.3005087077617645,
-0.9303985238075256,
0.8577168583869934,
-0.07172179222106934,
-0.029493778944015503,
0.02400006167590618,
-0.21426735818386078,
-0.20498396456241608,
-0.46253064274787903,
-0.9256377220153809,
0.3112649619579315,
0.5062037110328674,
0.5386679768562317,
0.7714070677757263,
0.7633668780326843,
0.7951786518096924,
0.34148356318473816,
0.10817228257656097,
-0.09938694536685944,
-0.4215500056743622,
0.06458835303783417,
0.14208267629146576,
0.12695199251174927,
-0.5247754454612732,
-0.2958656847476959,
0.9289706349372864,
0.5686442852020264,
-0.10352747142314911,
0.4134156107902527,
-0.015490645542740822,
0.6128783226013184,
-0.7583438754081726,
0.2760864198207855,
-0.26272672414779663,
0.39817285537719727,
-0.3806098997592926,
-0.28450748324394226,
-0.07053111493587494,
0.21924173831939697,
0.3339592516422272,
-1.264984369277954,
0.4511834383010864,
-0.2557845115661621,
0.7657453417778015,
0.6553442478179932,
-0.501825749874115,
0.009091632440686226,
-0.7872999310493469,
0.4474714696407318,
-0.4037473201751709,
0.7216623425483704,
0.6500256061553955,
0.7781964540481567,
0.3833029270172119,
-1.2173837423324585,
-0.6742836236953735,
-0.221205934882164,
0.09557117521762848,
0.0471205972135067,
-0.06585600227117538,
0.07623466849327087,
-0.252616286277771,
0.06457449495792389,
-0.610333263874054,
0.08775915205478668,
-0.591619074344635,
-0.04801050201058388,
0.3086550831794739,
0.500170886516571,
0.18243059515953064,
-0.05559920147061348,
-0.3592235743999481,
0.13095667958259583,
-0.20029252767562866,
0.32094892859458923,
-0.029338065534830093,
0.3061853051185608,
-0.23042231798171997,
0.361122727394104,
-0.49300825595855713,
0.5657221674919128,
-0.07823793590068817,
-0.03770238533616066,
-0.04276429861783981,
-0.4517727792263031,
-0.5782484412193298,
0.4739612340927124,
0.5364811420440674,
0.3717070519924164,
-0.2666603922843933,
-0.10654512047767639,
0.03223531320691109,
-0.2672906517982483,
0.6605089902877808,
-0.8530081510543823,
0.2014947086572647,
0.14815129339694977,
-0.3365417420864105,
-0.04714357107877731,
0.5769860148429871,
-0.7638164758682251,
-0.4638737738132477,
-0.19349084794521332,
0.654755175113678,
-0.5452039837837219,
-0.4216987192630768,
0.5091874599456787,
-0.20253047347068787,
0.31982722878456116,
0.5723822116851807,
-1.2264927625656128,
0.7973283529281616,
0.8918346762657166,
0.8339484930038452,
0.10996218770742416,
-0.6809658408164978,
-0.8176178336143494,
0.10213272273540497,
-0.14094354212284088,
0.5364232063293457,
-0.2045508325099945,
-0.2191629409790039,
0.2231932431459427,
0.25301069021224976,
0.24935080111026764,
-0.0681222677230835,
0.8421489000320435,
-0.38889020681381226,
0.27683186531066895,
-0.6360191702842712,
-0.3303104639053345,
-0.5207039713859558,
0.3585223853588104,
-0.9383839964866638,
0.6767178177833557,
0.15094755589962006,
-0.8401858806610107,
0.7252475619316101,
-0.7291545867919922,
-0.2602185606956482,
0.22514548897743225,
-0.07183657586574554,
-0.19837625324726105,
-0.25288864970207214,
0.09217248857021332,
0.2338436096906662,
-0.2715217173099518,
0.1521967351436615,
-0.0628485158085823,
-0.3184628188610077,
-0.09407152980566025,
-0.47749438881874084,
0.08528997004032135,
0.35593849420547485,
-0.279654324054718,
-0.02612423337996006,
-0.6683753132820129,
-0.3643978238105774,
-0.0012744227424263954,
-0.027557894587516785,
0.15173183381557465,
0.1751536875963211,
0.3868929147720337,
0.1810971200466156,
0.2513437271118164,
-0.593113362789154,
0.021519968286156654,
-0.2579631209373474,
0.26039832830429077,
0.2566571831703186,
-0.036946263164281845,
0.6035067439079285,
-0.09569797664880753,
0.7267266511917114,
0.20605874061584473,
0.6210153102874756,
-0.6983664035797119,
-0.3269152045249939,
-0.8179523348808289,
-0.2739008665084839,
-0.25572964549064636,
0.396314799785614,
-0.9786155819892883,
-0.3494434356689453,
-0.14414100348949432,
-0.5385037660598755,
-0.6324817538261414,
0.20946913957595825,
0.24667680263519287,
0.9128814339637756,
0.43309423327445984,
-0.24889768660068512,
-0.5947579145431519,
-1.076392412185669,
0.1865534633398056,
-0.2762441635131836,
0.29065319895744324,
0.04364124685525894,
0.17772188782691956,
0.025130746886134148,
0.8738106489181519,
-0.03668177127838135,
0.0016368404030799866,
-0.15778124332427979,
0.3901852071285248,
0.016597656533122063,
0.34363502264022827,
0.8850258588790894,
-1.0942409038543701,
-0.3968803584575653,
0.13066960871219635,
-0.9044538140296936,
0.2500186860561371,
-0.16058863699436188,
0.09715861082077026,
0.13849884271621704,
0.13294965028762817,
-0.7486951351165771,
0.39290493726730347,
0.33127039670944214,
-0.689437747001648,
0.2606276869773865,
-0.15862807631492615,
0.6416401863098145,
-0.6958209276199341,
0.009845892898738384,
0.3330509662628174,
-0.03603057190775871,
-0.8475572466850281,
-0.013250362128019333,
-0.19838468730449677,
-0.047805577516555786,
-1.1103423833847046,
0.7018927335739136,
0.027736632153391838,
-0.18278498947620392,
-0.24168017506599426,
0.0926131084561348,
0.08539721369743347,
0.3814983069896698,
0.3426652252674103,
0.7296016216278076,
0.9054016470909119,
-0.9992889761924744,
0.6402955055236816,
0.5894768238067627,
-0.42293739318847656,
0.1634572148323059,
-0.6696194410324097,
-0.19056227803230286,
-0.4994514584541321,
-0.27879732847213745,
-1.069002628326416,
-0.4114646017551422,
0.29990336298942566,
-0.5245514512062073,
0.25915729999542236,
0.10848811268806458,
-0.21700555086135864,
-0.16628266870975494,
-0.34484121203422546,
0.31298330426216125,
0.054573435336351395,
-0.38739854097366333,
0.295416921377182,
0.4864448010921478,
-0.5412157773971558,
-0.8427152633666992,
-0.8294667601585388,
0.2698497176170349,
-0.24405086040496826,
-0.9912202954292297,
0.41690152883529663,
0.27786436676979065,
-0.2798458933830261,
-0.04878010228276253,
-0.19349674880504608,
-0.7840908765792847,
0.20199069380760193,
0.3552544414997101,
0.21495823562145233,
-0.5538212656974792,
0.28113123774528503,
0.10470210015773773,
-0.22885674238204956,
0.06595928966999054,
-0.2071685940027237,
0.08229661732912064,
-0.17300228774547577,
-0.4136371910572052,
-0.6324108839035034,
0.5792763829231262,
0.7472637295722961,
-0.152713343501091,
0.7574583292007446,
0.7759681344032288,
-0.3667030930519104,
0.11563128232955933,
-0.3668287694454193,
-0.0584234818816185,
-0.5273844599723816,
0.8065488338470459,
-0.22278714179992676,
-0.9556031227111816,
0.43756726384162903,
0.3819621205329895,
0.08607291430234909,
0.38766369223594666,
0.44078758358955383,
-0.12103147059679031,
0.6746984720230103,
0.9489815831184387,
-0.06035121530294418,
0.5697208046913147,
-0.18866021931171417,
-0.24863041937351227,
0.06328058242797852,
-0.6559438109397888,
-0.5740139484405518,
-0.16884738206863403,
-0.31736546754837036,
-0.009283204562962055,
0.5444961786270142,
-0.08280657976865768,
-0.7125950455665588,
0.42965808510780334,
-0.26035329699516296,
0.35293999314308167,
0.543571412563324,
-0.05191764608025551,
0.19633737206459045,
-0.18115931749343872,
0.2714724540710449,
-0.2834862470626831,
-0.9175071716308594,
-0.6203453540802002,
0.4659934639930725,
0.6518603563308716,
0.6847636103630066,
0.45959582924842834,
0.12495068460702896,
0.3945434093475342,
0.09287572652101517,
-0.7358858585357666,
0.48582905530929565,
-0.236078143119812,
-0.6288337707519531,
-0.4992274045944214,
0.019874202087521553,
-0.813251256942749,
-0.014123203232884407,
-0.38976630568504333,
-0.5833489298820496,
-0.33416613936424255,
0.14615726470947266,
-0.44089275598526,
0.24239401519298553,
-0.5307586193084717,
1.287949800491333,
-0.3806259036064148,
-0.5116633772850037,
-0.1982882022857666,
-0.7638582587242126,
0.5001267790794373,
-0.05188986659049988,
0.21031713485717773,
0.4366868734359741,
-0.27159589529037476,
0.6215552091598511,
-0.4078406095504761,
0.5142056941986084,
-0.12618005275726318,
0.1103191003203392,
0.451473206281662,
0.2750910818576813,
-0.10979834198951721,
0.2117426097393036,
0.07100089639425278,
-0.09239381551742554,
0.3437637984752655,
-0.45547816157341003,
-0.7406215667724609,
0.37093690037727356,
-0.8632507920265198,
-0.45208510756492615,
-0.04251755028963089,
-0.17414771020412445,
-0.1018114686012268,
0.004870216827839613,
0.24588832259178162,
0.5834234952926636,
-0.5800113677978516,
0.1694045513868332,
0.5120523571968079,
-0.3764324486255646,
0.7297829985618591,
0.8776854276657104,
-0.5514174103736877,
-0.4735197126865387,
0.7611597180366516,
0.051614951342344284,
0.09744089841842651,
0.5950552821159363,
-0.3881939947605133,
-0.3431349992752075,
-0.36094605922698975,
-0.5595412254333496,
-0.07286343723535538,
-0.7763223052024841,
0.3053820729255676,
-0.5488762855529785,
-0.222885861992836,
-0.4049581289291382,
0.016945969313383102,
-0.6389195919036865,
-0.8287044763565063,
-0.308504194021225,
-0.42255982756614685,
0.09971296787261963,
0.8679991364479065,
0.3036153316497803,
0.671842098236084,
-1.3094711303710938,
0.3434544503688812,
0.527967631816864,
0.4720771014690399,
-0.42648276686668396,
-0.8345262408256531,
-0.7341185212135315,
-0.19533555209636688,
-0.458568811416626,
-0.8626828193664551,
0.4517615735530853,
0.21681828796863556,
0.853641927242279,
0.7306244969367981,
-0.4897703230381012,
0.488636314868927,
-0.3562801778316498,
1.2279069423675537,
0.25310826301574707,
-1.1016234159469604,
0.5684645175933838,
-0.4846835434436798,
0.23193079233169556,
0.6081017255783081,
0.6168128848075867,
-0.7088544964790344,
-0.16125626862049103,
-0.43454620242118835,
-0.42596670985221863,
0.7849985957145691,
0.28920379281044006,
0.2020094096660614,
0.044371504336595535,
0.5216380953788757,
0.32149890065193176,
0.3676736652851105,
-0.421658456325531,
-0.31930011510849,
-0.9202734231948853,
0.05140547826886177,
-0.3524736762046814,
-0.12628208100795746,
0.26216980814933777,
-0.38339635729789734,
0.5961657166481018,
0.047429610043764114,
0.13397645950317383,
0.370074063539505,
0.06495799869298935,
-0.3431289494037628,
0.064262256026268,
1.0863815546035767,
0.7106658816337585,
-0.3058740496635437,
0.03524422273039818,
0.05320088937878609,
-0.729679524898529,
-0.046772897243499756,
0.2545561194419861,
0.20598821341991425,
0.31751254200935364,
0.6496486663818359,
0.9253975749015808,
0.2168358415365219,
-0.6824051141738892,
0.4409564733505249,
0.026299143210053444,
-0.3980405330657959,
-0.20052185654640198,
-0.1657239943742752,
-0.25553393363952637,
0.26496776938438416,
0.5128966569900513,
-0.40624353289604187,
0.485867440700531,
-0.5718445181846619,
0.48011884093284607,
0.3491222560405731,
-0.6819315552711487,
-0.5080892443656921,
0.9195364713668823,
0.35592612624168396,
-0.3803901970386505,
0.47198495268821716,
-0.08834277093410492,
-0.4099755883216858,
0.8304445743560791,
0.17650146782398224,
0.96733558177948,
-0.02361774817109108,
0.7441837787628174,
0.4005354642868042,
0.620136022567749,
0.021892404183745384,
0.2997157871723175,
-0.2598649561405182,
-0.5336747765541077,
-0.6000958681106567,
-0.29480257630348206,
-0.7764987349510193,
-0.0025383038446307182,
-0.674277126789093,
0.5240519046783447,
-0.510546088218689,
-0.2345660924911499,
0.31279751658439636,
-0.14343081414699554,
-0.471566766500473,
0.2435654103755951,
0.6416475176811218,
1.419622778892517,
-0.5151821374893188,
0.9204729795455933,
0.9789025783538818,
-0.6376142501831055,
-0.528952956199646,
-0.7017523646354675,
0.16598057746887207,
-0.38952434062957764,
1.08305025100708,
-0.022899776697158813,
-0.18032754957675934,
-0.22555457055568695,
-0.7322579026222229,
-0.61078941822052,
1.4151725769042969,
0.6534894704818726,
-0.3070361912250519,
0.16178764402866364,
0.6049063205718994,
0.3861863911151886,
-0.34277716279029846,
0.22197097539901733,
0.23898133635520935,
0.465629518032074,
0.335750937461853,
-1.3421902656555176,
-0.5611757636070251,
-0.42129355669021606,
-0.5120636224746704,
0.3289599120616913,
-0.742734968662262,
1.0545676946640015,
0.16461381316184998,
-0.1307343691587448,
-0.022621070966124535,
0.7090073227882385,
-0.17065387964248657,
0.8703543543815613,
0.19689203798770905,
0.4930896461009979,
0.28877806663513184,
0.07566419243812561,
1.039894938468933,
-0.44924136996269226,
0.39759188890457153,
1.2552002668380737,
0.021546470001339912,
0.5193341970443726,
0.6902279853820801,
0.06995982676744461,
0.30501365661621094,
0.5794898271560669,
0.4126843512058258,
0.6368207335472107,
-0.30562445521354675,
-0.5366532206535339,
-0.4296520948410034,
-0.27977681159973145,
-0.2988908588886261,
0.5825147032737732,
0.26282623410224915,
-0.16856558620929718,
-0.46850377321243286,
0.019517110660672188,
-0.4424022138118744,
-0.0426667258143425,
-0.5436128377914429,
0.7457334399223328,
-0.16985511779785156,
-0.6212174892425537,
0.24382753670215607,
0.07509434968233109,
0.09355142712593079,
-0.9764130115509033,
-0.19130370020866394,
-0.21906574070453644,
-0.18948830664157867,
-0.10719742625951767,
-0.9269848465919495,
0.5134474039077759,
0.09064678102731705,
0.0011442238464951515,
-0.08345328271389008,
0.5437623858451843,
-0.3123575448989868,
-0.35069552063941956,
-0.022529229521751404,
0.5182809829711914,
-0.10424114763736725,
-0.20805472135543823,
-0.5609155297279358,
0.05290180444717407,
-0.4967954456806183,
-0.1716378629207611,
0.09528721123933792,
0.5749321579933167,
0.27016863226890564,
1.0697529315948486,
-0.051620304584503174,
-0.4584909677505493,
0.13584551215171814,
0.07333498448133469,
0.9446726441383362,
-0.8513669371604919,
-0.7254066467285156,
-0.7258809208869934,
0.8566916584968567,
0.13117723166942596,
-0.35447168350219727,
0.7902287840843201,
0.5786930322647095,
0.44104430079460144,
-0.03907373175024986,
0.6370763778686523,
0.1439410150051117,
0.1333736777305603,
-0.5220400094985962,
0.3474811017513275,
-0.5369501709938049,
0.16599233448505402,
-0.34017008543014526,
-0.594677746295929,
-0.14564010500907898,
0.25899243354797363,
0.10536252707242966,
-0.4068203270435333,
0.6165235042572021,
0.6650696396827698,
-0.23020410537719727,
0.6061211824417114,
0.41362836956977844,
0.10678477585315704,
0.14048434793949127,
0.4556373059749603,
1.0781947374343872,
-0.5741555094718933,
0.5338395237922668,
-0.3128887414932251,
-0.033097025007009506,
0.16317394375801086,
-0.8503863215446472,
-0.6240403652191162,
-0.8221725225448608,
-0.22211456298828125,
-0.18038181960582733,
-0.09447266161441803,
0.9148958325386047,
0.8879902362823486,
-0.5509710311889648,
-0.2102610468864441,
-0.007979107089340687,
-0.2204979658126831,
-0.03602893278002739,
-0.20064914226531982,
-0.0912562757730484,
-0.27096325159072876,
-0.5549106597900391,
0.3252001404762268,
0.7985753417015076,
0.030970819294452667,
-0.6271714568138123,
-0.4977920949459076,
-0.0655486136674881,
0.0497891791164875,
0.5985537171363831,
0.5067266225814819,
-0.5209977030754089,
-0.17642094194889069,
0.3354678750038147,
-0.12586653232574463,
-0.01700255461037159,
0.9059173464775085,
-0.7458974719047546,
0.5651780962944031,
0.3257746398448944,
0.9340566992759705,
1.008530855178833,
0.034181155264377594,
0.2139771729707718,
-0.5904974341392517,
0.5466141104698181,
0.005494857206940651,
0.3639279007911682,
0.1432339996099472,
-0.3056548535823822,
0.3953011631965637,
0.155631422996521,
-0.32767438888549805,
-0.29640302062034607,
0.015184739604592323,
-1.5355125665664673,
-0.27319884300231934,
0.748473048210144,
0.01786370389163494,
0.11364072561264038,
-0.06656671315431595,
-0.3597332537174225,
0.20533309876918793,
-0.1819036900997162,
0.7382240295410156,
0.9180647730827332,
0.21158625185489655,
-0.5168315768241882,
-0.9924905896186829,
0.3478062152862549,
0.42196282744407654,
-0.7879630923271179,
-0.44030892848968506,
0.509787917137146,
0.04132431000471115,
0.0003388524928595871,
0.8170554637908936,
0.25572681427001953,
0.7336653470993042,
0.12782740592956543,
-0.2496832013130188,
-0.4090113341808319,
-0.5137777924537659,
-0.459702730178833,
0.4015491008758545,
-0.058994144201278687,
-0.3947475850582123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14680v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14680v1
|
Automated Multi-Language to English Machine Translation Using Generative Pre-Trained Transformers
| 2024-04-23T02:19:35 | 2024-04-23T02:19:35 |
Elijah Pelofske, Vincent Urias, Lorie M. Liebrock
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The task of accurate and efficient language translation is an extremely
important information processing task. Machine learning enabled and automated
translation that is accurate and fast is often a large topic of interest in the
machine learning and data science communities. In this study, we examine using
local Generative Pretrained Transformer (GPT) models to perform automated zero
shot black-box, sentence wise, multi-natural-language translation into English
text. We benchmark 16 different open-source GPT models, with no custom
fine-tuning, from the Huggingface LLM repository for translating 50 different
non-English languages into English using translated TED Talk transcripts as the
reference dataset. These GPT model inference calls are performed strictly
locally, on single A100 Nvidia GPUs. Benchmark metrics that are reported are
language translation accuracy, using BLEU, GLEU, METEOR, and chrF text overlap
measures, and wall-clock time for each sentence translation. The best overall
performing GPT model for translating into English text for the BLEU metric is
ReMM-v2-L2-13B with a mean score across all tested languages of $0.152$, for
the GLEU metric is ReMM-v2-L2-13B with a mean score across all tested languages
of $0.256$, for the chrF metric is Llama2-chat-AYT-13B with a mean score across
all tested languages of $0.448$, and for the METEOR metric is ReMM-v2-L2-13B
with a mean score across all tested languages of $0.438$.
|
[
-0.10642152279615402,
-0.951049268245697,
0.6303336024284363,
0.19226573407649994,
-0.37946662306785583,
0.07598075270652771,
-0.4533923864364624,
-0.5293981432914734,
-0.17292478680610657,
0.29365479946136475,
-0.3174135088920593,
-0.438372403383255,
-0.6855093240737915,
0.5104262828826904,
-0.6030646562576294,
1.1584733724594116,
-0.6977928280830383,
-0.09594414383172989,
0.00542680686339736,
-0.11609576642513275,
-0.5519310832023621,
-0.3578324019908905,
-0.46801242232322693,
-0.1963307410478592,
0.23799604177474976,
0.14378060400485992,
0.8375085592269897,
0.4691636562347412,
0.447572261095047,
0.31915539503097534,
0.44044700264930725,
0.04418667405843735,
-0.19922804832458496,
-0.24242889881134033,
-0.002453029854223132,
-0.32933691143989563,
-0.5314756631851196,
0.19244946539402008,
0.441395103931427,
0.30329740047454834,
-0.10924948006868362,
0.18163245916366577,
0.12055967003107071,
0.03314412757754326,
-0.20526686310768127,
0.08259037137031555,
-0.6382399797439575,
0.12397339940071106,
-0.14469996094703674,
-0.2949490547180176,
-0.6299487948417664,
-0.2287810891866684,
-0.14426569640636444,
-0.794941782951355,
0.5058339834213257,
0.09098605066537857,
1.1799604892730713,
0.5038805603981018,
-0.5187971591949463,
-0.040351979434490204,
-0.9055432677268982,
0.9234620928764343,
-0.6440345644950867,
0.49481192231178284,
0.08671464771032333,
0.40009456872940063,
0.11941654980182648,
-0.7416366338729858,
-0.6825536489486694,
-0.1954452395439148,
-0.45231929421424866,
0.5693846940994263,
-0.530418872833252,
-0.0889289379119873,
-0.07753989100456238,
0.5785778164863586,
-0.9430161118507385,
0.13734403252601624,
-0.34630557894706726,
-0.060125596821308136,
0.598198413848877,
-0.03206445276737213,
0.15273623168468475,
-0.2781148850917816,
-0.4107649624347687,
-0.07195428013801575,
-0.3059808909893036,
-0.24228914082050323,
0.12656264007091522,
0.21297630667686462,
-0.4600244462490082,
0.4211799204349518,
-0.0893968716263771,
0.666260302066803,
0.003252065507695079,
-0.10309334844350815,
0.45009857416152954,
-0.6132389903068542,
-0.34340646862983704,
-0.16319705545902252,
1.1525181531906128,
0.2247970849275589,
0.32353198528289795,
-0.5353606939315796,
-0.2269926369190216,
0.24812684953212738,
0.4255070090293884,
-0.8198692202568054,
0.08340739458799362,
0.10246172547340393,
-0.2281884253025055,
-0.25435832142829895,
-0.17710696160793304,
-0.2634192407131195,
0.28786662220954895,
-0.4709537923336029,
0.6760432124137878,
-0.4212207496166229,
-0.2174331396818161,
0.16999748349189758,
0.3056798279285431,
0.46563565731048584,
0.43149617314338684,
-0.383510947227478,
-0.036839574575424194,
0.2479717880487442,
0.9062660932540894,
-0.40650486946105957,
-0.5489617586135864,
-0.381403386592865,
0.12573373317718506,
-0.3602314591407776,
0.7333086133003235,
-0.14256742596626282,
-0.24577046930789948,
-0.1548628807067871,
0.34340596199035645,
-0.3778494894504547,
-0.14224542677402496,
0.6831897497177124,
-0.19119344651699066,
0.6337401866912842,
0.40826913714408875,
-0.4098685681819916,
-0.12763181328773499,
0.3185204565525055,
-0.18608064949512482,
0.9131659269332886,
0.08638779073953629,
-0.6100555658340454,
0.15617181360721588,
-0.5622026920318604,
-0.7113066911697388,
0.22446773946285248,
-0.12883172929286957,
-0.4272451400756836,
0.1546172946691513,
0.4739324450492859,
0.7440301179885864,
-0.39390915632247925,
0.22421202063560486,
0.21953383088111877,
-0.4009784758090973,
-0.12381255626678467,
-0.7336757779121399,
0.39059290289878845,
0.27422499656677246,
-0.6390246152877808,
0.24435654282569885,
-0.47078076004981995,
-0.08027397096157074,
0.36394742131233215,
0.01805708184838295,
0.13065141439437866,
-0.32462525367736816,
0.2576545774936676,
0.44054853916168213,
0.2029748409986496,
-0.5889251828193665,
0.1468118578195572,
-0.2629443109035492,
0.4592294991016388,
0.5227176547050476,
-0.2984936237335205,
0.46479085087776184,
-0.26171252131462097,
0.8185733556747437,
-0.14857259392738342,
0.18427793681621552,
-0.24637079238891602,
-0.683879017829895,
-0.5366683006286621,
-0.3781552314758301,
0.25232774019241333,
0.932092547416687,
-0.8426105380058289,
0.48026323318481445,
-0.5053844451904297,
-0.49923810362815857,
-1.0022227764129639,
-0.03334013372659683,
0.341472327709198,
0.5474940538406372,
0.7516637444496155,
-0.27624836564064026,
0.038443200290203094,
-0.8801387548446655,
-0.016430474817752838,
0.11564421653747559,
-0.3742426037788391,
0.2590720057487488,
0.42845839262008667,
-0.3598455488681793,
0.6907514333724976,
-0.2662116587162018,
-0.5143380165100098,
-0.26115337014198303,
0.45096614956855774,
0.22635431587696075,
0.1624407321214676,
0.3886892795562744,
-0.5640729069709778,
-0.7764697074890137,
0.5576303601264954,
-0.7494559288024902,
-0.10033663362264633,
-0.46204134821891785,
-0.16076542437076569,
0.5029506683349609,
0.2645634412765503,
-0.8291096091270447,
0.6427357792854309,
0.8823351263999939,
-0.125077024102211,
0.5092858076095581,
-0.5097013115882874,
0.48246580362319946,
-1.410618782043457,
0.0825970470905304,
0.0614750050008297,
-0.5644317269325256,
-0.47654929757118225,
0.18658046424388885,
0.30041709542274475,
-0.13429757952690125,
-0.6820432543754578,
0.5256479382514954,
-0.48314958810806274,
0.09695513546466827,
-0.24122923612594604,
0.46198976039886475,
0.055859897285699844,
0.3410639762878418,
0.018360931426286697,
1.0393714904785156,
0.4093778729438782,
-0.3165193200111389,
0.41201654076576233,
0.4564654231071472,
-0.18257112801074982,
0.5716500878334045,
-0.5485703349113464,
0.34790194034576416,
-0.07322236150503159,
0.24137917160987854,
-0.6628470420837402,
0.06482741981744766,
0.21071234345436096,
-0.580924391746521,
0.4477916955947876,
-0.0907365158200264,
-0.5009540319442749,
-0.2614689767360687,
0.1595999002456665,
0.1518852561712265,
0.664849042892456,
-0.42051854729652405,
0.47725191712379456,
-0.03996904939413071,
-0.2230723351240158,
-0.3132297694683075,
-0.6827114820480347,
0.25510814785957336,
0.012329334393143654,
-0.6178009510040283,
0.6656478047370911,
0.02374880760908127,
0.12299507856369019,
-0.011042369529604912,
0.055435098707675934,
0.10817191004753113,
-0.17985540628433228,
-0.007897457107901573,
0.29844000935554504,
-0.18762579560279846,
-0.22285406291484833,
-0.21858228743076324,
-0.3341138958930969,
-0.23384280502796173,
-0.3453575670719147,
0.46650949120521545,
-0.15025751292705536,
-0.20788291096687317,
-0.40531033277511597,
0.3027883470058441,
0.533755898475647,
-0.4601402282714844,
0.8029510974884033,
0.9273307919502258,
-0.2393525093793869,
0.02391863614320755,
-0.5168175101280212,
-0.011824559420347214,
-0.39216724038124084,
0.3818702697753906,
-0.6293084025382996,
-0.7390899062156677,
0.37002232670783997,
0.37468671798706055,
0.16872842609882355,
0.6157718896865845,
0.6166556477546692,
-0.07940458506345749,
1.0476034879684448,
0.5658023953437805,
-0.2808171510696411,
0.18756498396396637,
-0.11061961203813553,
0.5424208641052246,
-0.4122459292411804,
0.2840963304042816,
-0.3754116892814636,
-0.09207058697938919,
-0.7266523241996765,
-0.6483725905418396,
0.21671368181705475,
0.09497988969087601,
0.21562620997428894,
0.8281546831130981,
-0.6473151445388794,
0.3847590386867523,
0.3278921842575073,
-0.16717401146888733,
0.34349337220191956,
0.07300369441509247,
0.03091214783489704,
-0.1716197431087494,
-0.485792875289917,
-0.4801473319530487,
1.2386603355407715,
0.2673758268356323,
0.4659847319126129,
-0.057781003415584564,
0.5161551833152771,
0.022552374750375748,
0.7135627269744873,
-0.6022657155990601,
0.2943199574947357,
-0.3199758529663086,
-0.3137979507446289,
-0.2304345667362213,
-0.6862602829933167,
-1.0154701471328735,
0.24930524826049805,
-0.10594119131565094,
-0.23270300030708313,
-0.3994634449481964,
-0.016916025429964066,
-0.03498285263776779,
0.4942638576030731,
-0.814361572265625,
1.1276382207870483,
-0.5686472058296204,
-0.3511184751987457,
-0.27214115858078003,
-0.5708394050598145,
0.19921812415122986,
-0.43268802762031555,
0.30254584550857544,
-0.08025877922773361,
0.2486463040113449,
0.24368277192115784,
0.11664021015167236,
0.3596152067184448,
-0.01380617544054985,
-0.3055242598056793,
-0.029379650950431824,
-0.056488037109375,
0.6119147539138794,
-0.27327030897140503,
0.18596960604190826,
0.6685915589332581,
-0.1200331375002861,
-0.5204922556877136,
-0.26731014251708984,
0.46713146567344666,
-0.9384671449661255,
-0.4251905381679535,
-0.4778885543346405,
-0.7124574780464172,
0.05753570795059204,
0.17623277008533478,
0.6090798377990723,
0.048193201422691345,
-0.21130044758319855,
0.10066983848810196,
0.1696111410856247,
-0.46588751673698425,
0.43755367398262024,
0.7657864093780518,
-0.18754591047763824,
-0.32288217544555664,
0.8547406792640686,
0.08820825070142746,
0.3769467771053314,
0.626181423664093,
-0.15034504234790802,
-0.3197292685508728,
-0.5563904643058777,
-0.9296407103538513,
0.29287368059158325,
-0.2638460099697113,
-0.32339173555374146,
-0.7074694633483887,
-0.146098792552948,
-0.6075051426887512,
-0.3632872998714447,
-0.4182155430316925,
-0.12778189778327942,
-0.06660884618759155,
-0.19958238303661346,
0.1714855432510376,
0.6786306500434875,
0.26088276505470276,
0.40266332030296326,
-0.7678734660148621,
0.5530606508255005,
0.04786045476794243,
0.11137602478265762,
-0.5620856881141663,
-0.9364510774612427,
-0.21978650987148285,
-0.1195930615067482,
-0.50404953956604,
-1.013696312904358,
0.676125705242157,
0.13122627139091492,
0.442854106426239,
0.04045744612812996,
-0.17390398681163788,
0.8506700992584229,
-0.9412140846252441,
0.6168180108070374,
0.0972110852599144,
-0.780767560005188,
0.4391765296459198,
-0.4188598096370697,
0.3661893904209137,
0.36556103825569153,
0.43544986844062805,
-0.7928673624992371,
-0.736117422580719,
-0.5122159719467163,
-0.888663649559021,
0.5823766589164734,
0.47694337368011475,
0.22692181169986725,
-0.02740197256207466,
0.2764720916748047,
0.19030267000198364,
0.19989213347434998,
-0.9309476613998413,
-0.3688783049583435,
-0.269628643989563,
-0.2924259603023529,
-0.5782883167266846,
0.31845027208328247,
0.23505465686321259,
-0.3104737102985382,
0.797282338142395,
-0.24266159534454346,
0.37811702489852905,
0.1782291680574417,
-0.5352159738540649,
-0.10829737782478333,
0.6007243990898132,
0.532929003238678,
0.49787628650665283,
-0.19279904663562775,
-0.23352675139904022,
0.3748500645160675,
-0.32489827275276184,
0.28792712092399597,
0.6622899174690247,
-0.385431170463562,
0.34866705536842346,
0.23180276155471802,
0.7285783886909485,
0.12628477811813354,
-0.13855120539665222,
0.7049012780189514,
-0.18699422478675842,
-0.19769151508808136,
-0.36916956305503845,
-0.46461591124534607,
-0.04317653179168701,
-0.23732680082321167,
0.36255770921707153,
0.15383997559547424,
-0.25691279768943787,
-0.25872838497161865,
0.293168306350708,
0.4393664598464966,
-0.18457230925559998,
-0.42098432779312134,
1.062576413154602,
0.3046031594276428,
-0.17365865409374237,
0.6602030396461487,
-0.4853631854057312,
-0.4225464165210724,
0.08805577456951141,
0.6015961766242981,
1.0553114414215088,
-0.5452693104743958,
0.3568284213542938,
0.3944219648838043,
0.7222733497619629,
0.09904323518276215,
-0.15371857583522797,
-0.03304595127701759,
-0.7211865186691284,
-1.027240514755249,
-0.7723075151443481,
-0.4959268569946289,
0.2130657136440277,
-0.5071712732315063,
0.2779935598373413,
0.12782445549964905,
0.07560348510742188,
-0.12914834916591644,
-0.12101025879383087,
-0.9277825355529785,
0.14415422081947327,
0.1229226365685463,
0.6663918495178223,
-1.0071064233779907,
1.0047153234481812,
0.6884617805480957,
-0.5215856432914734,
-0.7329007387161255,
-0.06323390454053879,
-0.308038592338562,
-0.6659821271896362,
0.2300107479095459,
0.3370054364204407,
-0.009781109169125557,
0.22758078575134277,
-0.030362354591488838,
-0.6017844080924988,
1.0706055164337158,
0.677188515663147,
-0.6945971250534058,
-0.05860741809010506,
0.5226340889930725,
0.49770236015319824,
-0.09331118315458298,
0.5362381935119629,
0.5959691405296326,
0.43867188692092896,
-0.20850074291229248,
-1.347800850868225,
-0.0967043861746788,
-0.2931680977344513,
-0.25373172760009766,
0.4767075479030609,
-0.5033798813819885,
0.7474240064620972,
0.01077124010771513,
-0.3376060426235199,
-0.17372219264507294,
0.5286750197410583,
-0.028050117194652557,
0.06685355305671692,
0.3161179721355438,
0.7189948558807373,
0.4291490614414215,
-0.24624884128570557,
1.2643884420394897,
-0.5674086809158325,
0.4096384048461914,
0.8075839281082153,
-0.3042839765548706,
0.8169049620628357,
0.3027217984199524,
-0.3056000769138336,
0.23823072016239166,
0.36572033166885376,
0.04994487389922142,
0.33297064900398254,
-0.13623645901679993,
-0.3837694227695465,
-0.17788055539131165,
0.17175836861133575,
-0.37039968371391296,
0.3551216423511505,
-0.0661393478512764,
-0.19682832062244415,
-0.2515123784542084,
0.17283563315868378,
0.20914795994758606,
0.12454511970281601,
-0.02185969054698944,
0.6707642078399658,
0.018899424001574516,
-0.6175758242607117,
0.5535067915916443,
0.4709273874759674,
1.0317604541778564,
-0.5824227333068848,
0.15265420079231262,
-0.48221784830093384,
0.31166872382164,
-0.00378054054453969,
-0.4836568832397461,
0.38479194045066833,
0.34030041098594666,
0.03353248909115791,
-0.8508445024490356,
0.5320048332214355,
-0.5338445901870728,
-0.7326434850692749,
0.48914504051208496,
0.5937468409538269,
0.36549055576324463,
-0.3254803717136383,
-0.7764949798583984,
-0.36545100808143616,
0.05620491877198219,
-0.3382164239883423,
0.19119936227798462,
0.37817519903182983,
-0.18454481661319733,
0.3730136454105377,
0.6497766971588135,
0.2561899721622467,
0.2376134842634201,
0.04326367378234863,
0.21446511149406433,
-0.5406586527824402,
-0.4518590271472931,
-0.6488199830055237,
0.5508928894996643,
0.20080716907978058,
-0.36406412720680237,
0.996860146522522,
0.7281668782234192,
1.172242522239685,
-0.15683278441429138,
0.7709622979164124,
-0.009506638161838055,
0.2941392660140991,
-0.43608230352401733,
0.7490498423576355,
-0.5808640122413635,
-0.35787761211395264,
-0.07419195771217346,
-1.090660810470581,
-0.22435526549816132,
0.7169345617294312,
-0.4285140335559845,
-0.11114475876092911,
0.8218880295753479,
0.7138303518295288,
-0.21656931936740875,
-0.22062644362449646,
0.63800048828125,
0.29025450348854065,
0.34665513038635254,
0.7040133476257324,
0.4131294786930084,
-0.8304285407066345,
0.8858928084373474,
-0.30336064100265503,
-0.14583078026771545,
0.16850465536117554,
-0.8596364855766296,
-0.6496491432189941,
-0.32916104793548584,
-0.5028879046440125,
-0.13426414132118225,
-0.07928919047117233,
0.5982117056846619,
0.7200814485549927,
-0.9775126576423645,
-0.08780672401189804,
-0.04064621403813362,
-0.26687708497047424,
-0.2865401804447174,
-0.2946224510669708,
0.3580075800418854,
-0.48000240325927734,
-0.965833842754364,
0.613844096660614,
0.33214640617370605,
0.09982670843601227,
-0.08865408599376678,
-0.23726217448711395,
0.01259137038141489,
-0.17538480460643768,
0.6507397294044495,
-0.038283564150333405,
-0.7845723032951355,
-0.3085217773914337,
0.088603675365448,
-0.20838996767997742,
0.2415553778409958,
0.4811514914035797,
-0.7385826706886292,
0.21119344234466553,
0.07716822624206543,
0.8001497983932495,
0.8553556203842163,
-0.03817303106188774,
0.7125185132026672,
-1.0781738758087158,
0.36340323090553284,
0.06778828799724579,
0.329946905374527,
0.6260126829147339,
-0.181512251496315,
0.5576117634773254,
0.2313862442970276,
-0.6419163346290588,
-0.7127137184143066,
0.04736959934234619,
-0.6324025988578796,
-0.04792305454611778,
0.9278484582901001,
-0.12093453854322433,
-0.08343563973903656,
0.03797098621726036,
-0.11759968101978302,
0.4650050699710846,
-0.008513059467077255,
0.5938875079154968,
0.5999469757080078,
0.09242460876703262,
-0.4360445737838745,
-1.1058869361877441,
0.24592924118041992,
0.5695173144340515,
-0.9390824437141418,
-0.11038413643836975,
0.32360580563545227,
0.1835590898990631,
0.2492642104625702,
0.5608206987380981,
-0.160329669713974,
0.11548962444067001,
-0.34813496470451355,
0.4963221549987793,
0.014248534105718136,
-0.18983112275600433,
-0.36716461181640625,
-0.09884288907051086,
-0.3485564887523651,
-0.3535085916519165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14662v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14662v1
|
NExT: Teaching Large Language Models to Reason about Code Execution
| 2024-04-23T01:46:32 | 2024-04-23T01:46:32 |
Ansong Ni, Miltiadis Allamanis, Arman Cohan, Yinlin Deng, Kensen Shi, Charles Sutton, Pengcheng Yin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.PL, cs.SE
|
A fundamental skill among human developers is the ability to understand and
reason about program execution. As an example, a programmer can mentally
simulate code execution in natural language to debug and repair code (aka.
rubber duck debugging). However, large language models (LLMs) of code are
typically trained on the surface textual form of programs, thus may lack a
semantic understanding of how programs execute at run-time. To address this
issue, we propose NExT, a method to teach LLMs to inspect the execution traces
of programs (variable states of executed lines) and reason about their run-time
behavior through chain-of-thought (CoT) rationales. Specifically, NExT uses
self-training to bootstrap a synthetic training set of execution-aware
rationales that lead to correct task solutions (e.g., fixed programs) without
laborious manual annotation. Experiments on program repair tasks based on MBPP
and HumanEval demonstrate that NExT improves the fix rate of a PaLM 2 model, by
26.1% and 14.3% absolute, respectively, with significantly improved rationale
quality as verified by automated metrics and human raters. Our model can also
generalize to scenarios where program traces are absent at test-time.
|
[
-0.1344418227672577,
-0.5255054235458374,
0.6562113165855408,
0.1901424378156662,
-0.018739929422736168,
0.39123955368995667,
-0.16690722107887268,
-0.46789902448654175,
-0.008054106496274471,
0.9086182117462158,
-0.4748491942882538,
-0.30469897389411926,
-0.2045549601316452,
-0.21608425676822662,
-0.2773265540599823,
1.0324205160140991,
-0.18846161663532257,
0.01182310190051794,
-0.11033205687999725,
-0.0008080863626673818,
-0.53862464427948,
-0.6429438591003418,
-0.7510802745819092,
-0.21314971148967743,
0.29375091195106506,
0.534990131855011,
0.6128789782524109,
0.8182762265205383,
0.2726336121559143,
0.27953851222991943,
0.32820552587509155,
-0.13671191036701202,
-0.590510904788971,
-0.16170139610767365,
-0.18124717473983765,
-1.0071613788604736,
-0.3622678816318512,
0.2075570672750473,
0.06974321603775024,
0.46447616815567017,
0.04889505356550217,
0.21912658214569092,
-0.15036194026470184,
0.6354159712791443,
-0.6250097751617432,
0.08089331537485123,
-0.5495747923851013,
-0.05876067280769348,
0.16987569630146027,
-0.4166162610054016,
-0.6795983910560608,
-0.5081512928009033,
-0.1021653339266777,
-0.41740360856056213,
0.09607230126857758,
-0.0756266787648201,
0.6244434714317322,
0.3043214976787567,
-0.3663334548473358,
-0.21189938485622406,
-0.6034878492355347,
0.7926531434059143,
-0.7749987840652466,
0.1908797025680542,
0.42847874760627747,
0.2278740555047989,
-0.2693595588207245,
-0.5750284790992737,
-0.6428108215332031,
-0.4063195586204529,
0.06128845363855362,
-0.18066748976707458,
0.29193633794784546,
0.10681265592575073,
0.5211673974990845,
0.19005002081394196,
-0.29305657744407654,
0.15687839686870575,
-0.3617205321788788,
-0.21400009095668793,
0.47130823135375977,
0.2316022515296936,
0.4929749369621277,
0.2642543315887451,
-0.4851594567298889,
0.027195708826184273,
-0.8993896842002869,
0.18186721205711365,
0.3224644958972931,
-0.14402543008327484,
-0.11818735301494598,
0.45318058133125305,
0.016394732519984245,
0.9177113175392151,
-0.15551577508449554,
-0.11098849028348923,
0.029068907722830772,
-0.07365783303976059,
-0.24898511171340942,
-0.018126364797353745,
0.3650893270969391,
0.4360583424568176,
0.5819190144538879,
-0.10001043975353241,
-0.3262563943862915,
0.3483053147792816,
0.4753890633583069,
-0.756920576095581,
-0.5761693716049194,
0.24525810778141022,
-0.30023255944252014,
-0.35299187898635864,
-0.3888256549835205,
-0.37533000111579895,
-0.5758626461029053,
-0.8733698129653931,
0.31635674834251404,
-0.5602482557296753,
-0.3452640473842621,
0.2122262567281723,
0.04474170133471489,
0.5330670475959778,
0.37395453453063965,
-0.973133385181427,
0.2580365240573883,
0.9683020114898682,
0.743569552898407,
0.17459248006343842,
-0.4387800991535187,
-0.7295796275138855,
0.13482628762722015,
-0.6698049902915955,
0.9079702496528625,
-0.503288209438324,
-0.04676038399338722,
-0.181012824177742,
-0.08391519635915756,
-0.12244078516960144,
-0.520619809627533,
0.10942330956459045,
-0.46949881315231323,
0.015796545892953873,
-0.4942011535167694,
-0.6567670106887817,
-0.17796826362609863,
0.26763901114463806,
-0.34805741906166077,
0.8733497858047485,
0.23543713986873627,
-0.6590815782546997,
0.3803653419017792,
-0.5775704979896545,
-0.40728291869163513,
-0.18395297229290009,
-0.3475651741027832,
-0.09632264822721481,
0.1888023018836975,
0.13755173981189728,
0.36272239685058594,
-0.15213260054588318,
0.1427617073059082,
-0.4244801700115204,
-0.377530962228775,
0.15507066249847412,
-0.17432978749275208,
0.8728263974189758,
-0.1099085882306099,
-0.7510254383087158,
0.3920539617538452,
-0.6547417640686035,
0.35873058438301086,
-0.039375122636556625,
-0.2695653438568115,
-0.2292121797800064,
0.06255996227264404,
-0.15201368927955627,
0.50225430727005,
0.052103444933891296,
-0.39320600032806396,
0.33623817563056946,
-0.5289192199707031,
0.39778608083724976,
0.969394862651825,
-0.2326740175485611,
0.2729864716529846,
-0.2695131003856659,
0.8369713425636292,
-0.2627616226673126,
0.2984824776649475,
-0.39898791909217834,
-0.3655756711959839,
-0.9913015961647034,
-0.11581806093454361,
-0.02145407535135746,
0.6129393577575684,
-0.6170915365219116,
0.1663445383310318,
-0.027182692661881447,
-0.39900273084640503,
-0.24269339442253113,
0.31218183040618896,
0.593166708946228,
0.5818608999252319,
0.1996709257364273,
-0.20167222619056702,
-0.6787015795707703,
-0.7123947143554688,
-0.41129669547080994,
-0.3232625126838684,
0.10881040245294571,
0.008839897811412811,
0.487395316362381,
-0.16473488509655,
0.939083993434906,
-0.3734130263328552,
0.09942036867141724,
-0.36880287528038025,
0.16816756129264832,
0.10448457300662994,
0.491615355014801,
0.4013647437095642,
-0.455242395401001,
-0.24801310896873474,
-0.07500005513429642,
-0.7175174355506897,
-0.21483832597732544,
-0.42744359374046326,
-0.3366988003253937,
0.46884772181510925,
0.7027196288108826,
-0.30996325612068176,
0.3758668005466461,
0.49548402428627014,
-0.47943130135536194,
0.7705786824226379,
-0.5202178359031677,
-0.016095783561468124,
-0.5781126618385315,
0.15689872205257416,
-0.24341528117656708,
-0.29402071237564087,
-0.20630139112472534,
0.07429782301187515,
0.16392377018928528,
-0.16930000483989716,
-0.23468492925167084,
0.39185431599617004,
-0.572730302810669,
-0.6900173425674438,
-0.5717360973358154,
0.1141209527850151,
-0.02641027234494686,
0.38881203532218933,
0.08187562227249146,
0.9638835787773132,
0.43249157071113586,
-0.5586245656013489,
0.3337167203426361,
-0.14589467644691467,
-0.5045557022094727,
0.30448344349861145,
-0.6876368522644043,
0.2876911163330078,
-0.041487157344818115,
0.3327850103378296,
-0.7702298164367676,
-0.13141928613185883,
-0.17378626763820648,
-0.24060408771038055,
0.27948451042175293,
-0.28218141198158264,
-0.4067188501358032,
-0.42161086201667786,
-0.2653925120830536,
0.10853143036365509,
0.6531449556350708,
-0.732923150062561,
0.2793146073818207,
0.504985511302948,
0.20557062327861786,
-0.6382518410682678,
-0.4224018454551697,
0.019108198583126068,
-0.08053655922412872,
-0.5912405848503113,
-0.11939845234155655,
-0.041996221989393234,
-0.21611431241035461,
-0.33016976714134216,
-0.226480171084404,
-0.1404762864112854,
0.3260829448699951,
0.32765769958496094,
0.2868436276912689,
-0.2667542099952698,
0.14939913153648376,
-0.11851490288972855,
-0.4401125907897949,
0.37169837951660156,
-0.39156168699264526,
0.6280060410499573,
-0.29119497537612915,
-0.30021679401397705,
-0.3562125861644745,
-0.015367593616247177,
0.7586606740951538,
-0.4666306972503662,
0.7523317933082581,
0.5517475008964539,
-0.2325717806816101,
-0.2278033345937729,
-0.5999796986579895,
-0.32306209206581116,
-0.46504372358322144,
0.16284218430519104,
-0.3311939835548401,
-0.7198703289031982,
0.40369147062301636,
-0.3034873902797699,
0.14837616682052612,
0.19844025373458862,
0.6294105648994446,
-0.16873592138290405,
1.0063066482543945,
0.945922315120697,
-0.17637313902378082,
0.3130452036857605,
-0.5157397985458374,
0.3794231414794922,
-0.8088197708129883,
-0.3127468228340149,
-0.23050065338611603,
-0.17010505497455597,
-0.12132973223924637,
-0.5607810020446777,
0.14576023817062378,
0.5733290314674377,
-0.3942207098007202,
0.46989673376083374,
-0.4910013973712921,
0.9262603521347046,
0.3239898383617401,
0.06269148737192154,
-0.010571149177849293,
-0.2747921049594879,
-0.0810866728425026,
0.12829938530921936,
-0.6030108332633972,
-0.7384771108627319,
1.0204274654388428,
0.3952527642250061,
0.7932340502738953,
-0.10669126361608505,
0.7599742412567139,
0.2715144753456116,
0.619889497756958,
-0.6813745498657227,
0.4512195289134979,
0.3077373504638672,
-0.529352068901062,
-0.16733141243457794,
-0.169391930103302,
-0.7246665954589844,
0.05297797918319702,
0.2048233151435852,
-0.8533669114112854,
-0.1193394809961319,
0.6934186220169067,
-0.5050286650657654,
0.3094133734703064,
-0.9967061877250671,
1.224236249923706,
-0.517380952835083,
-0.3570481836795807,
-0.5570175647735596,
-0.5736684203147888,
0.6560421586036682,
-0.05283904820680618,
0.3908952474594116,
-0.08277950435876846,
-0.11818193644285202,
0.6440163850784302,
-0.8257282376289368,
1.0384492874145508,
-0.19175481796264648,
-0.45490720868110657,
0.5224809646606445,
0.36869755387306213,
0.5964975357055664,
0.05082488805055618,
-0.02534306049346924,
-0.2615734040737152,
0.11713367700576782,
-0.5273678302764893,
-0.7122429013252258,
0.8255693912506104,
-0.45153966546058655,
-0.517166256904602,
-0.3253686726093292,
-0.36499297618865967,
-0.12112203240394592,
-0.04477597773075104,
0.04900958761572838,
0.5471415519714355,
0.40393510460853577,
-0.14895732700824738,
0.5277979969978333,
-0.32398995757102966,
0.4053487479686737,
0.5769630074501038,
-0.46769285202026367,
0.056996122002601624,
0.792640745639801,
-0.22829227149486542,
0.4036942422389984,
0.13969005644321442,
0.16106478869915009,
-0.13995550572872162,
-0.2113446742296219,
-0.4643106162548065,
0.1840650737285614,
-0.8261945247650146,
-0.1808316856622696,
-0.7803394198417664,
0.18212439119815826,
-0.017699502408504486,
-0.39559510350227356,
-0.44215646386146545,
-0.27293264865875244,
-0.08198349922895432,
-0.18161702156066895,
0.5413815975189209,
0.7003877758979797,
-0.008866213262081146,
0.30531951785087585,
-0.772793710231781,
0.2694806456565857,
0.0633678287267685,
0.4283658564090729,
0.04720956087112427,
-0.5515958666801453,
-0.430838942527771,
0.0950864851474762,
-0.34689271450042725,
-0.7783737778663635,
0.24344144761562347,
-0.054109327495098114,
0.33161723613739014,
0.1116873174905777,
-0.03303246200084686,
0.6991081237792969,
-0.503292977809906,
0.6774742007255554,
0.20196324586868286,
-1.1594126224517822,
0.8909808397293091,
-0.29835280776023865,
0.033661652356386185,
0.36146268248558044,
0.3410243093967438,
-0.36139047145843506,
-0.27449831366539,
-0.508519172668457,
-0.5273500680923462,
0.7144048810005188,
-0.1806502342224121,
0.0888245701789856,
-0.2202070951461792,
0.43030402064323425,
-0.054465152323246,
-0.018327489495277405,
-0.6346628665924072,
0.17448177933692932,
0.019659386947751045,
-0.005922473501414061,
-0.02383408136665821,
-0.3470325171947479,
0.06716208904981613,
-0.2929195463657379,
0.5806456208229065,
-0.3424091935157776,
0.23775161802768707,
0.009700517170131207,
-0.2528527081012726,
-0.14484599232673645,
-0.06109244003891945,
0.7397439479827881,
1.0677798986434937,
-0.022288620471954346,
0.14597812294960022,
0.05229911580681801,
-0.17223970592021942,
0.19491294026374817,
-0.5230715274810791,
0.17676997184753418,
-0.37578192353248596,
0.6395007967948914,
0.6483170390129089,
0.2918202579021454,
-1.0063050985336304,
0.5644576549530029,
0.14797721803188324,
0.22531604766845703,
-0.42451173067092896,
0.3664604723453522,
0.19652292132377625,
0.3076411187648773,
-0.1239161267876625,
0.1836901605129242,
0.07368865609169006,
-0.8929128050804138,
0.31013450026512146,
0.16450820863246918,
-0.28109341859817505,
-0.41912874579429626,
0.4918043613433838,
0.1866108626127243,
-0.3379065990447998,
0.6187663078308105,
-0.12048769742250443,
-0.9534406065940857,
1.000886082649231,
0.7811038494110107,
0.7135329842567444,
-0.2546357214450836,
0.22916920483112335,
0.3438798487186432,
0.46458110213279724,
-0.29464638233184814,
0.6782090067863464,
0.018123269081115723,
-0.4253791272640228,
-0.9295347332954407,
-0.4305766820907593,
-0.35468751192092896,
0.19388042390346527,
-0.3410821557044983,
0.30832770466804504,
-0.7644635438919067,
0.018985945731401443,
-0.1627853810787201,
-0.342934787273407,
-0.4296649694442749,
0.4332030117511749,
-0.037768129259347916,
0.7979043126106262,
-0.7410911321640015,
1.0024137496948242,
0.4753522574901581,
-0.44098830223083496,
-1.0384588241577148,
0.011229032650589943,
-0.17577385902404785,
-0.7582453489303589,
0.8915364742279053,
0.4428558647632599,
-0.16087549924850464,
-0.057136401534080505,
-0.5641310214996338,
-0.8965140581130981,
0.6293343305587769,
0.5912704467773438,
-0.5755708813667297,
0.14223186671733856,
-0.2923479974269867,
0.6609504222869873,
-0.28266844153404236,
0.5001993775367737,
0.6302696466445923,
0.2814815640449524,
-0.21022018790245056,
-0.8105461001396179,
-0.01056857593357563,
-0.05964433774352074,
-0.1047564297914505,
0.4469561278820038,
-0.45092061161994934,
0.7895137071609497,
-0.8102162480354309,
0.11816971749067307,
0.003222828032448888,
0.3576955795288086,
0.2957727909088135,
0.2634064555168152,
0.41991791129112244,
0.425734281539917,
0.5673044919967651,
0.10921452194452286,
1.4529979228973389,
-0.5247408151626587,
0.2433052659034729,
1.3627527952194214,
-0.28439024090766907,
0.8927598595619202,
0.3375335931777954,
-0.30095580220222473,
0.8022075891494751,
0.47066402435302734,
0.26109740138053894,
0.20962922275066376,
0.6722257733345032,
-0.13218605518341064,
-0.43535569310188293,
0.24664489924907684,
-0.2373100072145462,
0.5822147130966187,
0.4066440463066101,
-0.3685176968574524,
-0.0549493245780468,
0.07778914272785187,
0.11053044348955154,
0.2586280107498169,
-0.1291394829750061,
0.34142443537712097,
0.07667683064937592,
-0.8608801364898682,
0.9619032144546509,
0.06901232898235321,
0.252586305141449,
-0.40451323986053467,
-0.13486745953559875,
-0.19497403502464294,
0.5564150214195251,
-0.3360169231891632,
-0.7116196751594543,
0.5689733028411865,
0.12431424111127853,
-0.19959615170955658,
-0.052178382873535156,
0.49364447593688965,
-0.060957491397857666,
-0.3065468966960907,
0.35528764128685,
0.04620327800512314,
0.2900247573852539,
-0.11497393995523453,
-0.6935303807258606,
0.1372734159231186,
0.06767585128545761,
-0.21871571242809296,
0.27286848425865173,
0.42914626002311707,
-0.321480929851532,
1.0314046144485474,
0.719820499420166,
-0.15980437397956848,
0.23871631920337677,
0.09798441082239151,
0.7651737332344055,
-0.6535270810127258,
-0.5043482184410095,
-0.9277081489562988,
0.3698166608810425,
-0.2076519876718521,
-0.24367479979991913,
0.6990768313407898,
0.759118378162384,
0.8639527559280396,
-0.23412854969501495,
0.6602402329444885,
0.09002860635519028,
0.39200064539909363,
-0.7019909024238586,
0.4151260256767273,
-0.22694142162799835,
0.5111610293388367,
-0.1520877331495285,
-0.8578885197639465,
-0.11884087324142456,
0.8282827734947205,
-0.45982179045677185,
0.14935961365699768,
0.746692955493927,
0.7359824180603027,
-0.0191865935921669,
0.030329681932926178,
0.25429123640060425,
0.21090582013130188,
0.46595731377601624,
0.7279723882675171,
0.9010728001594543,
-0.18524494767189026,
0.24862751364707947,
-0.23863032460212708,
-0.48961904644966125,
-0.06829190999269485,
-0.9764850735664368,
-1.0937057733535767,
-0.17777231335639954,
-0.3742760419845581,
-0.5342504978179932,
-0.013554047793149948,
0.8862852454185486,
0.6930502653121948,
-0.7151838541030884,
-0.4171105921268463,
-0.5897451043128967,
-0.07612624019384384,
-0.19934919476509094,
-0.1849879026412964,
0.3576427400112152,
-0.7583377361297607,
-0.10703597962856293,
0.41408559679985046,
0.4355541169643402,
-0.18203705549240112,
-0.31463584303855896,
-0.2722281515598297,
-0.07792089879512787,
0.050002504140138626,
0.7099701166152954,
0.4714760482311249,
-0.7767753601074219,
-0.4180169701576233,
-0.203382670879364,
-0.11969546228647232,
-0.21625341475009918,
1.2699486017227173,
-1.1468967199325562,
0.37430572509765625,
0.30468854308128357,
0.7282916903495789,
0.3418489694595337,
-0.29682883620262146,
0.8028690218925476,
-0.38351675868034363,
0.15582109987735748,
0.12310145795345306,
0.3648606836795807,
0.2502303719520569,
-0.4647431969642639,
0.6118431687355042,
0.24949130415916443,
-0.6082713603973389,
-0.7209519743919373,
0.3832341432571411,
-0.6589329838752747,
-0.20847386121749878,
0.9786615371704102,
-0.4773600697517395,
-0.29322120547294617,
-0.17984332144260406,
-0.579646110534668,
0.2774486243724823,
0.01814032718539238,
0.8900951147079468,
0.3967697024345398,
-0.12349234521389008,
-0.3239608407020569,
-0.6163047552108765,
0.6131494045257568,
0.5147085785865784,
-1.0489985942840576,
0.37178313732147217,
0.5919756293296814,
0.4170442819595337,
-0.08678034693002701,
0.8468970656394958,
0.005125034134835005,
0.37889161705970764,
0.019199103116989136,
0.17862468957901,
0.0022868304513394833,
-0.451020210981369,
-0.13240227103233337,
-0.1509779542684555,
0.08201421797275543,
-0.10092676430940628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14631v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14631v1
|
Learning Word Embedding with Better Distance Weighting and Window Size Scheduling
| 2024-04-23T00:05:48 | 2024-04-23T00:05:48 |
Chaohao Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Distributed word representation (a.k.a. word embedding) is a key focus in
natural language processing (NLP). As a highly successful word embedding model,
Word2Vec offers an efficient method for learning distributed word
representations on large datasets. However, Word2Vec lacks consideration for
distances between center and context words. We propose two novel methods,
Learnable Formulated Weights (LFW) and Epoch-based Dynamic Window Size (EDWS),
to incorporate distance information into two variants of Word2Vec, the
Continuous Bag-of-Words (CBOW) model and the Continuous Skip-gram (Skip-gram)
model. For CBOW, LFW uses a formula with learnable parameters that best
reflects the relationship of influence and distance between words to calculate
distance-related weights for average pooling, providing insights for future NLP
text modeling research. For Skip-gram, we improve its dynamic window size
strategy to introduce distance information in a more balanced way. Experiments
prove the effectiveness of LFW and EDWS in enhancing Word2Vec's performance,
surpassing previous state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.13070517778396606,
-0.8148627877235413,
0.5448138117790222,
0.3343571722507477,
-0.24053002893924713,
0.13405440747737885,
-0.3560977578163147,
-0.5114497542381287,
0.07865896821022034,
-0.07092117518186569,
-0.448358416557312,
-0.21581324934959412,
-0.9030166864395142,
-0.10178612172603607,
0.02376188524067402,
0.4771409034729004,
-0.3417111337184906,
0.013198213651776314,
-0.5471027493476868,
-0.3355335593223572,
-0.787249743938446,
0.07160336524248123,
-0.3213435709476471,
-0.4914643168449402,
0.4403299391269684,
0.21405546367168427,
0.5560702085494995,
0.9694254398345947,
0.16727310419082642,
0.13135051727294922,
0.036490507423877716,
0.6172766089439392,
-0.4662482738494873,
0.22514966130256653,
0.12394235283136368,
-0.513878583908081,
-0.11422968655824661,
0.18409428000450134,
0.8389987349510193,
0.726776659488678,
-0.4207386374473572,
-0.13076665997505188,
0.3107738494873047,
0.6318411827087402,
-0.7524428963661194,
0.49528929591178894,
-0.5937812328338623,
0.3670552372932434,
-0.06282710283994675,
-0.21148906648159027,
-0.4462648332118988,
-0.2648206055164337,
0.15548907220363617,
-0.904754102230072,
-0.09335275739431381,
0.1168607547879219,
0.7128612995147705,
0.2051958590745926,
-0.17598211765289307,
-0.5403428673744202,
-0.6786211133003235,
0.965889036655426,
-0.3307763338088989,
0.7286291122436523,
0.41735485196113586,
0.18582957983016968,
-0.0787687823176384,
-0.7033166885375977,
-0.3345368802547455,
-0.019370906054973602,
0.16908439993858337,
0.24704326689243317,
-0.0835983082652092,
0.03424564749002457,
0.2651185691356659,
-0.1407034546136856,
-0.3952045440673828,
0.3591724634170532,
-0.2894752323627472,
-0.03092973306775093,
0.3686721622943878,
-0.08368101716041565,
-0.08170224726200104,
0.22254107892513275,
-0.606942892074585,
-0.10318461060523987,
-0.6049323678016663,
-0.21582520008087158,
0.25750112533569336,
0.19681961834430695,
-0.010108673013746738,
0.3058364987373352,
-0.0859004408121109,
0.7429504990577698,
-0.12813259661197662,
-0.10708360373973846,
0.1953151375055313,
0.08883526176214218,
0.013498830609023571,
0.27840375900268555,
0.14240600168704987,
0.7234827280044556,
0.18883730471134186,
-0.2962225079536438,
-0.2136458456516266,
-0.23613378405570984,
0.17450687289237976,
-0.8291501998901367,
0.008274579420685768,
0.02145969495177269,
-0.4709293246269226,
-0.03179218992590904,
0.20001064240932465,
-0.778940737247467,
-0.21908079087734222,
-0.44665825366973877,
0.5177819728851318,
-0.3584785759449005,
-0.12688152492046356,
-0.10406048595905304,
-0.4649709165096283,
0.1471422165632248,
0.33934882283210754,
-0.7476487159729004,
0.4189993143081665,
0.5802274346351624,
1.1997041702270508,
-0.31565621495246887,
-0.04060038924217224,
-0.8343355059623718,
0.1974448561668396,
-0.37207645177841187,
0.5521566271781921,
-0.70830237865448,
-0.5466067790985107,
0.3027074337005615,
-0.1972856968641281,
-0.1763366460800171,
-0.41528087854385376,
0.03753336891531944,
-0.7248199582099915,
0.5825299620628357,
-0.41553962230682373,
-1.0619107484817505,
-0.1379145383834839,
0.08022845536470413,
-0.38730958104133606,
1.3142642974853516,
0.34692618250846863,
-1.026951789855957,
0.37979617714881897,
-0.5058472156524658,
-0.37559863924980164,
0.29769256711006165,
-0.018797291442751884,
-0.28888165950775146,
0.10594815760850906,
0.2495921105146408,
0.6297335028648376,
0.34893009066581726,
-0.09388846158981323,
-0.214466392993927,
-0.4704020321369171,
-0.2206221967935562,
-0.4525158107280731,
0.25777700543403625,
0.2947298288345337,
-0.24435341358184814,
-0.29013532400131226,
-0.6679773926734924,
0.05915815383195877,
0.18961624801158905,
-0.5750294327735901,
-0.6665327548980713,
0.38653016090393066,
0.004901717882603407,
-0.16217344999313354,
0.4842109978199005,
-0.6073654890060425,
0.12859117984771729,
-0.4802265465259552,
0.22702810168266296,
0.7076930403709412,
-0.18498235940933228,
0.6300299763679504,
-0.10807552933692932,
0.29440823197364807,
-0.2989000082015991,
0.007236204110085964,
0.1364283710718155,
-0.3809640407562256,
-0.3169874846935272,
-0.3167358338832855,
0.20759519934654236,
0.7522020936012268,
-0.8253483176231384,
0.46303871273994446,
-0.3180045187473297,
-0.2603828012943268,
-0.15767937898635864,
-0.07830698788166046,
0.03533133864402771,
0.14397962391376495,
0.48405295610427856,
-0.031177803874015808,
-0.5398220419883728,
-0.44859206676483154,
-0.15126536786556244,
-0.00790008157491684,
-0.20754101872444153,
0.43778616189956665,
0.058725755661726,
-0.18133561313152313,
1.1248650550842285,
-1.0346944332122803,
-0.3171054422855377,
-0.26641136407852173,
0.016270317137241364,
-0.18955866992473602,
0.10866062343120575,
0.4591728746891022,
-0.4747604429721832,
-0.5241512656211853,
-0.3032502830028534,
-0.4762764871120453,
-0.30525147914886475,
-0.037556327879428864,
-0.058626167476177216,
0.1322232335805893,
0.7256010174751282,
-0.14778447151184082,
0.4497230052947998,
0.879220724105835,
-0.3071580231189728,
0.3421984314918518,
-0.8512563705444336,
-0.2690964341163635,
-1.1344926357269287,
-0.49978330731391907,
-0.07423501461744308,
-0.6558854579925537,
-0.23700886964797974,
-0.07279075682163239,
0.1185203269124031,
0.1437382996082306,
-0.3763934373855591,
0.4629853367805481,
-0.8346772789955139,
0.05882730707526207,
-0.5654540061950684,
0.6180473566055298,
-0.07631358504295349,
0.10074003040790558,
-0.0024427075404673815,
0.6089172959327698,
0.3285534083843231,
-0.7595946788787842,
0.3697560429573059,
-0.12350860238075256,
-0.3450291156768799,
0.35215750336647034,
-0.501566469669342,
0.02073228731751442,
-0.2733219861984253,
0.5338572263717651,
-0.6179906129837036,
0.21445327997207642,
-0.08604472875595093,
-0.2618732750415802,
0.526054859161377,
0.20765407383441925,
-0.42746832966804504,
-0.25786998867988586,
-0.47104206681251526,
0.31974902749061584,
0.7089583873748779,
-0.7871142029762268,
0.3020156919956207,
0.3904486298561096,
0.09254653006792068,
-0.4395727217197418,
-0.7854304313659668,
-0.168889120221138,
-0.12564153969287872,
-0.31188738346099854,
0.7238454222679138,
0.15971186757087708,
-0.0695824846625328,
0.08458508551120758,
0.07855013757944107,
0.21139280498027802,
-0.012192792259156704,
0.3205093741416931,
-0.07218576967716217,
0.2753570079803467,
0.5309556126594543,
0.17259836196899414,
0.015513737685978413,
-0.24339376389980316,
-0.7060202956199646,
0.5937678217887878,
0.24723730981349945,
-0.109368696808815,
-0.09966804832220078,
0.4054375886917114,
0.17347392439842224,
-0.2120802402496338,
1.1247626543045044,
1.0309596061706543,
-0.6791037321090698,
-0.6320098042488098,
-0.43445226550102234,
-0.2858930826187134,
-0.40230339765548706,
0.582616925239563,
-0.14344410598278046,
-1.032901406288147,
0.2565362751483917,
-0.21153749525547028,
0.24996304512023926,
0.39094415307044983,
0.41898563504219055,
0.06543099135160446,
0.6704162359237671,
0.8722282648086548,
0.01996365562081337,
0.8460687398910522,
-0.19358249008655548,
0.1157878115773201,
-0.8348383903503418,
-0.4148697853088379,
-0.20667140185832977,
-0.3866131007671356,
-0.6192357540130615,
-1.1420981884002686,
0.2081325352191925,
0.1897718906402588,
0.10377942770719528,
0.30003631114959717,
-0.4346528947353363,
0.2901763319969177,
0.288941353559494,
-0.10475706309080124,
-0.05229489132761955,
0.36941564083099365,
-0.7636091709136963,
-0.1102367639541626,
-0.742326557636261,
-0.12944935262203217,
0.8701313138008118,
0.7187739610671997,
0.5601012706756592,
0.006547356955707073,
0.5965070724487305,
0.46447235345840454,
-0.08733808994293213,
-0.8495532274246216,
0.4423465132713318,
-0.2648204267024994,
-0.141465961933136,
-0.3131643533706665,
-0.45993658900260925,
-0.9660976529121399,
0.38612863421440125,
-0.14301516115665436,
-0.8811311721801758,
-0.14136020839214325,
-0.1793324053287506,
-0.23793432116508484,
0.5923054814338684,
-0.577671229839325,
0.16018091142177582,
0.1262030452489853,
-0.2919871211051941,
-0.6790340542793274,
-0.40677008032798767,
-0.33065900206565857,
0.24904346466064453,
0.38264137506484985,
-0.2524351477622986,
-0.5023003220558167,
1.0195120573043823,
-0.4274444282054901,
0.4877450168132782,
-0.5093261003494263,
-0.009212852455675602,
0.41258224844932556,
0.05363154038786888,
0.8543040752410889,
-0.010274822823703289,
-0.004318126942962408,
0.2202647477388382,
-0.08959253877401352,
-0.329450398683548,
-0.4727456569671631,
0.8591731190681458,
-0.5503571033477783,
-0.20230194926261902,
-0.405855268239975,
-0.41372764110565186,
-0.11260122060775757,
0.055827055126428604,
0.2636682391166687,
0.6382509469985962,
-0.32325536012649536,
0.2365923821926117,
0.6235992312431335,
-0.2687336802482605,
0.9061934947967529,
0.5649298429489136,
-0.035753849893808365,
-0.36685943603515625,
0.6219454407691956,
0.6045563220977783,
0.039401113986968994,
0.8151724338531494,
0.4148152470588684,
-0.40921738743782043,
-0.4524042308330536,
-0.32027938961982727,
0.06818971782922745,
-0.3637619912624359,
-0.018133193254470825,
-0.8646138310432434,
-0.15545393526554108,
-0.31967872381210327,
-0.31005021929740906,
-0.6707239151000977,
-0.23422320187091827,
-0.4161616563796997,
-0.2966093122959137,
0.6215369701385498,
0.7799539566040039,
-0.27662768959999084,
0.17740623652935028,
-0.7005507349967957,
-0.21425344049930573,
0.16063658893108368,
0.6551157832145691,
0.30371934175491333,
-0.43232983350753784,
-0.5180896520614624,
-0.022768452763557434,
-0.16686028242111206,
-0.8345476984977722,
0.29741665720939636,
0.3368925154209137,
0.42715680599212646,
0.5604937076568604,
0.06545805186033249,
0.4590742290019989,
-0.9352331161499023,
0.9127745628356934,
0.35759928822517395,
-0.5103505253791809,
0.28890955448150635,
-0.13518062233924866,
0.34712353348731995,
0.22520266473293304,
0.338291198015213,
-0.7280120253562927,
-0.168833389878273,
-0.30761855840682983,
-0.9560157656669617,
0.3546393811702728,
0.2092141956090927,
0.19517746567726135,
-0.1642526537179947,
0.31576234102249146,
0.23998957872390747,
-0.1583200842142105,
-0.2839045822620392,
-0.0375138595700264,
0.18300941586494446,
-0.24689893424510956,
0.04224279895424843,
-0.3275400996208191,
0.2763875424861908,
-0.24811549484729767,
0.5222297310829163,
-0.19617636501789093,
0.48597484827041626,
0.2545357048511505,
-0.09930059313774109,
0.1225748136639595,
-0.060232508927583694,
0.3341114819049835,
0.5476162433624268,
-0.22477276623249054,
0.15208576619625092,
0.6070408225059509,
-0.6786235570907593,
-0.1832154244184494,
0.3189750015735626,
-0.07652591168880463,
0.09253084659576416,
0.561898410320282,
0.9635794162750244,
0.019428860396146774,
-0.46287211775779724,
0.554016649723053,
-0.03218603879213333,
-0.2499239444732666,
-0.3946435749530792,
-0.13269835710525513,
0.19426578283309937,
0.21098533272743225,
0.28328683972358704,
-0.2457200288772583,
-0.07876735925674438,
-0.261388897895813,
0.3352415859699249,
0.4124683141708374,
-0.8058609962463379,
-0.03814316540956497,
0.5223349928855896,
0.39723941683769226,
-0.09673702716827393,
0.7642239928245544,
-0.3720828592777252,
-0.5591328144073486,
0.3266865313053131,
0.38648074865341187,
0.6885888576507568,
-0.1343541443347931,
0.24334006011486053,
0.3294171094894409,
0.019282106310129166,
-0.4181741178035736,
-0.12305428832769394,
-0.2853071093559265,
-0.66646808385849,
-0.19740143418312073,
-0.7351084351539612,
-0.03425897657871246,
-0.305372416973114,
-0.478996217250824,
0.18999046087265015,
-0.44466060400009155,
-0.19616171717643738,
-0.466625452041626,
0.5708742737770081,
-0.7696481347084045,
-0.051071591675281525,
0.38126257061958313,
0.8081095218658447,
-0.7297572493553162,
0.7635990381240845,
0.5995428562164307,
0.22158260643482208,
-1.0074763298034668,
0.2153526395559311,
0.053833119571208954,
-0.7186087965965271,
0.22168685495853424,
0.4879150986671448,
-0.027084406465291977,
0.05132781341671944,
-0.16989105939865112,
-0.8956678509712219,
1.4866100549697876,
-0.23533308506011963,
-0.8420076370239258,
-0.06947120279073715,
-0.09534022212028503,
0.3495018184185028,
-0.45181116461753845,
0.28700894117355347,
0.3809870183467865,
0.3136918246746063,
0.0678001195192337,
-0.6089417338371277,
0.05477410927414894,
0.40388908982276917,
0.34446749091148376,
0.15552282333374023,
-0.7696876525878906,
0.43913233280181885,
-0.23385584354400635,
-0.3054659962654114,
-0.23195567727088928,
0.7445358037948608,
0.02269928716123104,
0.39583855867385864,
0.6821030974388123,
0.7466602325439453,
0.9251884818077087,
-0.08768842369318008,
1.14191472530365,
0.015897803008556366,
0.5338369607925415,
0.9341005086898804,
-0.2670043706893921,
1.0800859928131104,
0.215053528547287,
-0.4879092872142792,
0.5772375464439392,
0.5577489137649536,
-0.0068128593266010284,
0.5550231337547302,
0.48347941040992737,
-0.21456606686115265,
0.07619218528270721,
-0.09534049034118652,
-0.275047242641449,
0.3830487132072449,
0.2978428900241852,
-0.21586933732032776,
-0.25940123200416565,
0.34906744956970215,
0.27874258160591125,
0.27177777886390686,
-0.17567697167396545,
0.8571329116821289,
0.35255134105682373,
-0.4687248170375824,
0.31754201650619507,
0.5506387948989868,
1.1080691814422607,
-0.6680711507797241,
0.1373390406370163,
-0.14349423348903656,
0.39811038970947266,
-0.0010315357940271497,
-0.5322475433349609,
0.2728044390678406,
-0.07441277801990509,
-0.19856896996498108,
-0.38775336742401123,
0.6018414497375488,
-0.7058654427528381,
-0.513481080532074,
0.6872946619987488,
0.23951685428619385,
-0.030265040695667267,
0.06781166791915894,
-0.5681297779083252,
-0.03586673364043236,
-0.16747325658798218,
-0.3477989137172699,
0.39536288380622864,
0.16045743227005005,
-0.016052186489105225,
0.5894901156425476,
0.23944997787475586,
0.45358526706695557,
0.1522691249847412,
0.31164440512657166,
0.4751516878604889,
-0.13423007726669312,
-0.7957385778427124,
-0.9005033373832703,
0.13895736634731293,
-0.16796034574508667,
0.2346991002559662,
0.6321701407432556,
0.48728659749031067,
0.6825307011604309,
-0.02670302800834179,
0.4183928668498993,
-0.0696140006184578,
0.5175843238830566,
-0.5498601198196411,
0.6383866667747498,
-0.8224104642868042,
0.11609436571598053,
-0.011611646972596645,
-1.2444096803665161,
-0.12699800729751587,
0.5057241916656494,
-0.16041885316371918,
0.087043397128582,
0.8301764130592346,
0.7007061243057251,
0.20811201632022858,
-0.2301752269268036,
0.26810213923454285,
-0.10231956839561462,
0.4514710605144501,
0.5432042479515076,
0.36424320936203003,
-0.3014712333679199,
0.29748398065567017,
-0.11883015185594559,
-0.41656407713890076,
-0.32452720403671265,
-1.0091583728790283,
-0.604028046131134,
-0.6776516437530518,
-0.5894548296928406,
-0.31591376662254333,
0.34868571162223816,
1.1867517232894897,
0.7660560607910156,
-0.3597243130207062,
0.08470480889081955,
-0.1719958782196045,
0.09101803600788116,
-0.4387724697589874,
-0.27730563282966614,
0.6198317408561707,
-0.1610555648803711,
-0.7529336810112,
0.20707164704799652,
0.22321271896362305,
0.026829805225133896,
-0.11172085255384445,
-0.15785109996795654,
-0.1344490945339203,
0.4098460376262665,
0.8444440960884094,
-0.18470869958400726,
-0.46906906366348267,
-0.5557186007499695,
-0.40300479531288147,
-0.05324660614132881,
-0.27397990226745605,
0.610255241394043,
-0.6857545375823975,
0.5389747619628906,
0.8554039001464844,
0.4928944706916809,
0.43796512484550476,
-0.004411814268678427,
0.5650444030761719,
-1.0957844257354736,
0.3797544836997986,
0.12328736484050751,
0.1495317667722702,
0.43062061071395874,
-0.4400162696838379,
0.13876157999038696,
0.515309751033783,
-0.3211526870727539,
-0.47359374165534973,
0.011654097586870193,
-0.7937055826187134,
-0.6141002178192139,
1.4684069156646729,
-0.1097227931022644,
0.008267911151051521,
0.27358362078666687,
0.06509506702423096,
0.5214086771011353,
-0.42460954189300537,
0.3960854411125183,
0.7604058980941772,
0.17094920575618744,
0.11386243999004364,
-0.7636588215827942,
0.5393136143684387,
0.01831348054111004,
-0.29576197266578674,
0.14603301882743835,
0.310838907957077,
0.4779978394508362,
-0.18627701699733734,
0.42079344391822815,
-0.18643899261951447,
-0.3948768973350525,
0.304161936044693,
-0.08608957380056381,
-0.4390038549900055,
-0.3446201682090759,
-0.04012122005224228,
0.15825530886650085,
-0.2053341567516327,
-0.5928516387939453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00704v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00704v2
|
A Survey on the Real Power of ChatGPT
| 2024-04-22T23:31:28 | 2024-05-10T02:38:28 |
Ming Liu, Ran Liu, Ye Zhu, Hua Wang, Youyang Qu, Rongsheng Li, Yongpan Sheng, Wray Buntine
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
ChatGPT has changed the AI community and an active research line is the
performance evaluation of ChatGPT. A key challenge for the evaluation is that
ChatGPT is still closed-source and traditional benchmark datasets may have been
used by ChatGPT as the training data. In this paper, (i) we survey recent
studies which uncover the real performance levels of ChatGPT in seven
categories of NLP tasks, (ii) review the social implications and safety issues
of ChatGPT, and (iii) emphasize key challenges and opportunities for its
evaluation. We hope our survey can shed some light on its blackbox manner, so
that researchers are not misleaded by its surface generation.
|
[
-0.3931479752063751,
-0.7584272027015686,
0.10758373886346817,
0.13912861049175262,
-0.018821382895112038,
0.3834104835987091,
-0.34143444895744324,
-0.6355432271957397,
-0.1253206431865692,
0.2464509755373001,
-0.4522952735424042,
-0.1596502959728241,
-0.8473288416862488,
-0.13756826519966125,
-0.48202982544898987,
1.3318642377853394,
0.22787365317344666,
-0.04130636155605316,
0.002669574460014701,
-0.20396800339221954,
-0.4828072786331177,
-1.0437527894973755,
-0.9016463756561279,
-0.2139965444803238,
0.4543856084346771,
0.17851325869560242,
0.7507753372192383,
0.16159965097904205,
0.9643645286560059,
0.2605874836444855,
-0.11896824091672897,
-0.012559066526591778,
-0.7339456081390381,
0.1422768235206604,
-0.07345376908779144,
-0.6420708298683167,
-0.4325820505619049,
0.42314237356185913,
0.625422477722168,
0.4954378604888916,
-0.2505214512348175,
0.3245300054550171,
0.15244315564632416,
0.7863850593566895,
-0.4947695732116699,
0.384560227394104,
-0.716484785079956,
0.31573036313056946,
-0.2943510413169861,
0.03848373517394066,
-0.3570696711540222,
-0.4311142563819885,
0.32855895161628723,
-0.3283611536026001,
0.4837225079536438,
0.27514132857322693,
0.744049072265625,
0.5457379221916199,
-0.20730319619178772,
-0.18413250148296356,
-1.0074055194854736,
0.7051236033439636,
-0.48991674184799194,
0.35621121525764465,
0.04341394081711769,
0.836319088935852,
-0.009943000972270966,
-0.9957306981086731,
-0.48647332191467285,
-0.36938223242759705,
0.11442101001739502,
0.38989269733428955,
-0.18892602622509003,
0.01625693216919899,
0.517230212688446,
0.6041196584701538,
-0.4815893769264221,
-0.1945188343524933,
-0.5558876991271973,
-0.03154264762997627,
0.7905764579772949,
0.057070016860961914,
0.452519953250885,
-0.028980378061532974,
-0.18776655197143555,
-0.3307504951953888,
-0.6085928678512573,
-0.15957190096378326,
0.26539069414138794,
0.056321606040000916,
-0.035464972257614136,
0.6241578459739685,
-0.12621378898620605,
0.3773309886455536,
-0.4754049479961395,
0.2006099820137024,
0.18633690476417542,
-0.3839656412601471,
0.027569066733121872,
0.05236780270934105,
1.0270534753799438,
0.3429161310195923,
0.3389569818973541,
-0.41146114468574524,
0.08000632375478745,
0.1283847689628601,
0.5157679319381714,
-0.7296909093856812,
-0.264801949262619,
-0.014788818545639515,
-0.3748342990875244,
-0.27344876527786255,
-0.004943320993334055,
-0.7881498336791992,
-0.38409224152565,
0.08892608433961868,
0.21787330508232117,
-0.3896172344684601,
-0.6835543513298035,
0.07667697221040726,
-0.36445891857147217,
0.41922715306282043,
0.37084466218948364,
-0.7673553228378296,
0.524615466594696,
1.0152174234390259,
1.0473878383636475,
-0.13552580773830414,
-0.22857654094696045,
-0.16242145001888275,
-0.454629123210907,
-0.09473657608032227,
0.7386164665222168,
-0.4461669921875,
-0.24848595261573792,
-0.17702722549438477,
-0.22955472767353058,
-0.46307674050331116,
-0.42549270391464233,
0.3813987374305725,
-0.1836107224225998,
0.3449295461177826,
-0.20124471187591553,
-0.469853937625885,
0.07280060648918152,
0.4226093292236328,
-0.5482280850410461,
1.1457245349884033,
-0.09932149201631546,
-0.8568617105484009,
0.44425150752067566,
-0.9660828709602356,
-0.09781315922737122,
0.2548561692237854,
-0.11364764720201492,
-0.5293437242507935,
-0.07617441564798355,
0.0020461860112845898,
0.18590837717056274,
-0.2694069743156433,
0.26121383905410767,
0.01855015568435192,
-0.505368173122406,
0.3498568832874298,
-0.8230539560317993,
0.6774516701698303,
0.1481228470802307,
-0.6466958522796631,
-0.11373497545719147,
-0.7226262092590332,
0.01418125070631504,
0.008110458962619305,
-0.11115379631519318,
0.09664605557918549,
0.2822120785713196,
-0.06258835643529892,
0.17887651920318604,
0.04516519233584404,
-0.9129539132118225,
0.17178791761398315,
-0.2190062254667282,
0.5747246742248535,
0.605507493019104,
-0.009594243951141834,
0.07536321878433228,
-0.3593931496143341,
0.7217945456504822,
-0.5532265901565552,
0.3472072184085846,
0.2222650647163391,
-1.0767133235931396,
-0.7061973810195923,
-0.014509228989481926,
0.7009873390197754,
0.6745032668113708,
-0.4762697219848633,
0.2730388939380646,
-0.27429530024528503,
-0.9167510867118835,
-0.6701740026473999,
-0.38712626695632935,
0.42814379930496216,
0.1974864900112152,
0.17891892790794373,
-0.32863256335258484,
-0.08387391269207001,
-0.7983670830726624,
-0.36881521344184875,
-0.2949443757534027,
-0.19164212048053741,
0.590809166431427,
0.4731074571609497,
0.0576002299785614,
0.8577145338058472,
-0.39010950922966003,
-0.12271949648857117,
-0.2914682924747467,
0.29746565222740173,
-0.026556354016065598,
0.5853965282440186,
0.31960952281951904,
-0.7216160297393799,
-0.3511965274810791,
-0.05816347524523735,
-0.7125906944274902,
0.001369347097352147,
0.03009898215532303,
-0.12647080421447754,
-0.35098204016685486,
0.3958165943622589,
-0.6777091026306152,
0.27346959710121155,
0.7258461117744446,
-0.23837770521640778,
0.6342552304267883,
0.05098026618361473,
0.21277214586734772,
-0.7438297867774963,
0.25926634669303894,
-0.2905816435813904,
-0.03905678167939186,
-0.4829655885696411,
0.14196521043777466,
-0.10998635739088058,
-0.6682130098342896,
-0.416221022605896,
0.4022669792175293,
-0.24259914457798004,
-0.10045761615037918,
0.03291637822985649,
0.2116595357656479,
-0.4277234375476837,
0.4350259602069855,
0.06663179397583008,
0.7565316557884216,
0.45907390117645264,
-0.28772246837615967,
0.5408087968826294,
0.2864394187927246,
-0.39492014050483704,
0.21241064369678497,
-0.9074525833129883,
0.4427422285079956,
-0.04654787853360176,
0.2691345512866974,
-1.0576634407043457,
0.012519259937107563,
0.3495960533618927,
-0.5954636335372925,
-0.011618196964263916,
-0.306398868560791,
-0.4186781346797943,
-0.1621316373348236,
-0.12415526807308197,
0.3345101773738861,
0.7381062507629395,
-0.2446541041135788,
-0.010499687865376472,
0.387118399143219,
0.11426187306642532,
-0.5847047567367554,
-0.6583855748176575,
0.3968851566314697,
-0.13792884349822998,
-0.6645386219024658,
0.08521146327257156,
0.005010851658880711,
-0.3083321154117584,
-0.049390263855457306,
-0.027867471799254417,
0.10882030427455902,
0.24864305555820465,
0.373055100440979,
-0.20862862467765808,
-0.13068297505378723,
0.12057899683713913,
-0.43787050247192383,
-0.20740307867527008,
0.05527675896883011,
0.15771383047103882,
0.6108426451683044,
-0.4158543646335602,
-0.5692329406738281,
0.032777730375528336,
0.007750038988888264,
0.09513913840055466,
-0.3467453420162201,
0.7010521292686462,
0.7749766707420349,
-0.17959775030612946,
-0.14393316209316254,
-0.3612420856952667,
-0.19015394151210785,
-0.47452446818351746,
0.2891014516353607,
-0.01962846703827381,
-0.882627546787262,
0.245158389210701,
-0.19358111917972565,
0.3318929374217987,
0.3180599510669708,
0.4200417399406433,
0.17416392266750336,
0.8032582998275757,
0.5333443284034729,
0.15710005164146423,
0.4633428156375885,
-0.29133492708206177,
0.6182836294174194,
-0.6431145668029785,
-0.27232131361961365,
-0.655331015586853,
-0.43674740195274353,
-0.8796084523200989,
-0.2616940438747406,
0.5226976871490479,
-0.24749469757080078,
-0.00933944433927536,
0.2876596748828888,
-0.7523452043533325,
0.20083436369895935,
0.5964023470878601,
0.19455182552337646,
0.33062687516212463,
-0.3071241080760956,
0.3669387996196747,
-0.045678894966840744,
-0.8951407074928284,
-0.5236678123474121,
1.0370386838912964,
0.471482515335083,
0.5067830681800842,
0.07297563552856445,
0.5599157810211182,
0.4288453757762909,
0.32761451601982117,
-0.7548267245292664,
0.7500524520874023,
0.2303438037633896,
-0.7861481308937073,
-0.4591808319091797,
-0.47212210297584534,
-1.256545901298523,
0.27525991201400757,
-0.1735800802707672,
-0.6352288126945496,
-0.22902372479438782,
-0.039110422134399414,
-0.06205315887928009,
0.25149232149124146,
-0.8440743684768677,
1.0140761137008667,
-0.1265653818845749,
-0.2215542197227478,
-0.26413118839263916,
-0.5526689887046814,
0.28980132937431335,
0.22347094118595123,
-0.07896435260772705,
-0.44049549102783203,
0.1412304937839508,
1.1449294090270996,
-0.4334644079208374,
0.7363768219947815,
-0.20859119296073914,
0.2065815031528473,
0.2846307158470154,
-0.20809721946716309,
0.20258483290672302,
0.15603269636631012,
-0.10610818862915039,
0.4553051292896271,
0.08134974539279938,
-0.4988339841365814,
-0.5785887241363525,
0.480267196893692,
-0.7167233824729919,
-0.5312802195549011,
-0.6422432065010071,
-0.25354403257369995,
-0.5768665671348572,
0.043551720678806305,
0.16909243166446686,
0.3022497892379761,
-0.5212146043777466,
0.42832478880882263,
0.3832278549671173,
-0.23383678495883942,
0.4261021912097931,
0.10721654444932938,
-0.001241627847775817,
0.014738024212419987,
1.0343563556671143,
0.2854696810245514,
0.18650133907794952,
0.2232084721326828,
0.10530220717191696,
-0.02831437438726425,
-0.6127589344978333,
-0.6140837073326111,
-0.015846021473407745,
-0.22205136716365814,
0.1186818778514862,
-0.512328028678894,
-0.46450939774513245,
-0.20337963104248047,
0.08980497717857361,
-0.7580301761627197,
-0.661119282245636,
0.38567766547203064,
-0.08782215416431427,
0.3334522247314453,
0.9188874363899231,
0.036293622106313705,
0.40578800439834595,
-0.46296095848083496,
0.22030995786190033,
0.5481048226356506,
0.6062087416648865,
-0.05636115372180939,
0.15620379149913788,
-0.209723562002182,
0.12439790368080139,
-0.3874570429325104,
-0.5507447123527527,
0.1807112842798233,
0.06258885562419891,
0.6479122638702393,
-0.027987228706479073,
0.17849738895893097,
0.2547198534011841,
-0.5180331468582153,
1.2901943922042847,
-0.02104925736784935,
-0.48590052127838135,
0.25278934836387634,
-0.25936076045036316,
0.12872657179832458,
0.4831746816635132,
0.32549721002578735,
-0.8726969957351685,
-0.5426936745643616,
-1.0931859016418457,
-0.6548909544944763,
0.6083630323410034,
0.8458620309829712,
0.13721193373203278,
0.22190512716770172,
0.07579052448272705,
-0.06525854021310806,
0.4756559729576111,
-0.48988771438598633,
-0.21460780501365662,
-0.41525232791900635,
0.10520047694444656,
0.012691142037510872,
-0.09634600579738617,
-0.04119271785020828,
-0.08062974363565445,
0.3135298788547516,
0.1082582175731659,
0.6857454776763916,
0.09245702624320984,
0.20850692689418793,
0.22104549407958984,
0.26981568336486816,
0.12721122801303864,
0.8629059791564941,
-0.37145352363586426,
-0.03305789455771446,
0.0634237602353096,
-0.7515102624893188,
-0.10240263491868973,
0.06401040405035019,
-0.07331380248069763,
-0.04423680528998375,
0.5571567416191101,
0.7043864727020264,
0.10882073640823364,
-0.7364406585693359,
0.5760687589645386,
-0.4142403304576874,
-0.2296275496482849,
-0.23387613892555237,
0.5406228303909302,
-0.1787956953048706,
0.0790138691663742,
0.40193331241607666,
0.17950840294361115,
0.07062186300754547,
-0.6135976314544678,
0.16943392157554626,
0.5531294941902161,
-0.459938645362854,
-0.15678028762340546,
0.6155595779418945,
0.258419394493103,
-0.5495129823684692,
0.7059881687164307,
0.006833791732788086,
-0.5148816704750061,
0.7041216492652893,
0.2626512944698334,
0.806117057800293,
-0.023455262184143066,
0.2582535445690155,
0.2668454945087433,
0.5068964958190918,
0.03384394943714142,
0.00527944415807724,
-0.22410254180431366,
-0.6609483957290649,
-0.37627050280570984,
-0.4192299544811249,
-0.9927064180374146,
0.25290095806121826,
-0.4730343818664551,
0.026091165840625763,
-0.43489664793014526,
-0.20437495410442352,
0.028143353760242462,
0.05337829515337944,
-0.49797487258911133,
0.2217780500650406,
0.017885997891426086,
0.7428686618804932,
-0.415927529335022,
0.5104547739028931,
0.36853018403053284,
-0.17305880784988403,
-0.42824122309684753,
0.0442536436021328,
-0.19059237837791443,
-0.8498013615608215,
0.2734912633895874,
0.014911044389009476,
0.03637788072228432,
-0.12663845717906952,
-0.7752890586853027,
-0.6130189299583435,
0.7991227507591248,
0.11537464708089828,
-0.40252432227134705,
-0.16041041910648346,
0.3981948494911194,
0.7755606770515442,
0.1539965718984604,
0.4702035188674927,
0.4568796455860138,
0.44150862097740173,
-0.30258452892303467,
-1.2770066261291504,
-0.13839879631996155,
-0.5685049891471863,
-0.19078682363033295,
0.15259157121181488,
-1.1623516082763672,
0.5214065909385681,
0.3269847333431244,
-0.33233746886253357,
-0.2593570351600647,
0.30712854862213135,
0.07501684874296188,
0.2737472653388977,
0.28729957342147827,
0.33141112327575684,
0.5627620816230774,
-0.28626230359077454,
1.1274253129959106,
-0.2923490107059479,
0.4606170654296875,
0.6241354942321777,
-0.04721401259303093,
0.5803402066230774,
0.019280005246400833,
-0.4684741199016571,
-0.00033946498297154903,
0.43341073393821716,
-0.14410676062107086,
0.264635294675827,
0.3362423777580261,
-0.25764894485473633,
0.0042495280504226685,
0.022932937368750572,
-0.602601945400238,
0.5300643444061279,
0.342694491147995,
0.027244672179222107,
-0.3117482662200928,
-0.0637306347489357,
0.15439821779727936,
-0.1541297286748886,
-0.008864602074027061,
0.8571233153343201,
0.008417584002017975,
-0.6620507836341858,
0.604625403881073,
-0.13653330504894257,
0.6993367671966553,
-0.651512861251831,
-0.39433181285858154,
-0.06491980701684952,
0.11212369799613953,
-0.079852394759655,
-0.8776450157165527,
0.3935403525829315,
-0.07809960842132568,
0.43361082673072815,
-0.4100421965122223,
0.9471196532249451,
0.012613778933882713,
-0.2729419469833374,
0.08239689469337463,
0.6171442866325378,
0.5809378027915955,
-0.33264976739883423,
-0.8593064546585083,
-0.0239318385720253,
-0.045585211366415024,
-0.3940173089504242,
0.5489115118980408,
0.43874576687812805,
0.16355355083942413,
0.8691087365150452,
0.6837171912193298,
0.14576959609985352,
0.2683972120285034,
-0.26631519198417664,
0.7175980806350708,
-0.7376013994216919,
-0.15726560354232788,
-0.6255611181259155,
0.1935124546289444,
-0.3480777144432068,
-0.6998482942581177,
0.9176422953605652,
0.5818814635276794,
0.7757129669189453,
0.19374819099903107,
1.0644545555114746,
-0.3615282475948334,
0.5740531086921692,
-0.3205587565898895,
0.9965879321098328,
-0.11331939697265625,
-0.10731949657201767,
-0.38468968868255615,
-0.7703807353973389,
-0.055198781192302704,
0.39247190952301025,
-0.46286267042160034,
-0.10257509350776672,
0.5729997158050537,
0.5777336955070496,
-0.06443130970001221,
0.39193040132522583,
0.47084248065948486,
-0.015228679403662682,
0.583048939704895,
0.34635189175605774,
0.9630521535873413,
-0.5023298859596252,
0.7290083765983582,
-0.533988893032074,
-0.36268070340156555,
-0.12274280935525894,
-0.8185590505599976,
-0.8371641039848328,
-0.646567702293396,
-0.36149194836616516,
-0.25436916947364807,
0.3668307065963745,
0.4534550905227661,
0.7721340656280518,
-0.5753167867660522,
-0.14317205548286438,
-0.055762384086847305,
0.07809803634881973,
-0.5257228016853333,
-0.22883349657058716,
0.39935052394866943,
-0.33748650550842285,
-0.7735939025878906,
0.3386833071708679,
-0.006106625776737928,
-0.2691478729248047,
-0.19428052008152008,
0.11486701667308807,
-0.016632122918963432,
-0.20691326260566711,
0.6727503538131714,
0.34818798303604126,
-0.14101190865039825,
-0.36805111169815063,
-0.14345870912075043,
0.029939699918031693,
0.09872488677501678,
0.9484771490097046,
-0.6187354922294617,
0.11628702282905579,
0.45981863141059875,
0.7140371799468994,
0.8300211429595947,
0.18423773348331451,
0.6802476048469543,
-0.5551547408103943,
0.20290617644786835,
0.5116889476776123,
0.10770678520202637,
0.14863131940364838,
-0.2815679609775543,
0.987949788570404,
0.3702252507209778,
-0.9904494881629944,
-0.8522202968597412,
-0.027891268953680992,
-1.1273865699768066,
-0.011918393895030022,
1.1543654203414917,
-0.09050930291414261,
-0.07885994762182236,
-0.3659546375274658,
-0.5199280977249146,
0.15408773720264435,
-0.40026524662971497,
0.9617357850074768,
0.722844123840332,
-0.4880102872848511,
-0.3467591106891632,
-1.1129989624023438,
0.7636733651161194,
0.3420392572879791,
-0.6348087191581726,
0.18575261533260345,
0.2710539996623993,
0.054691381752491,
0.19657401740550995,
0.6699932217597961,
-0.251903772354126,
0.07005012780427933,
0.37335893511772156,
0.0894322320818901,
0.024702340364456177,
-0.10067213326692581,
0.18796992301940918,
0.43225571513175964,
0.16114723682403564,
-0.26703381538391113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14619v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14619v2
|
OpenELM: An Efficient Language Model Family with Open Training and Inference Framework
| 2024-04-22T23:12:03 | 2024-05-02T00:30:57 |
Sachin Mehta, Mohammad Hossein Sekhavat, Qingqing Cao, Maxwell Horton, Yanzi Jin, Chenfan Sun, Iman Mirzadeh, Mahyar Najibi, Dmitry Belenko, Peter Zatloukal, Mohammad Rastegari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The reproducibility and transparency of large language models are crucial for
advancing open research, ensuring the trustworthiness of results, and enabling
investigations into data and model biases, as well as potential risks. To this
end, we release OpenELM, a state-of-the-art open language model. OpenELM uses a
layer-wise scaling strategy to efficiently allocate parameters within each
layer of the transformer model, leading to enhanced accuracy. For example, with
a parameter budget of approximately one billion parameters, OpenELM exhibits a
2.36% improvement in accuracy compared to OLMo while requiring $2\times$ fewer
pre-training tokens.
Diverging from prior practices that only provide model weights and inference
code, and pre-train on private datasets, our release includes the complete
framework for training and evaluation of the language model on publicly
available datasets, including training logs, multiple checkpoints, and
pre-training configurations. We also release code to convert models to MLX
library for inference and fine-tuning on Apple devices. This comprehensive
release aims to empower and strengthen the open research community, paving the
way for future open research endeavors.
Our source code along with pre-trained model weights and training recipes is
available at \url{https://github.com/apple/corenet}. Additionally, \model
models can be found on HuggingFace at:
\url{https://huggingface.co/apple/OpenELM}.
|
[
-0.3558415174484253,
-0.5267363786697388,
0.2082502692937851,
0.2526134252548218,
0.30287304520606995,
-0.4830639660358429,
-0.6432745456695557,
-0.34324637055397034,
-0.24821509420871735,
0.8129991888999939,
-0.19196778535842896,
-0.6463955640792847,
-0.5931960344314575,
-0.39549362659454346,
-0.40710845589637756,
0.8173903822898865,
-0.2924441695213318,
0.13197848200798035,
-0.1961430013179779,
-0.375869482755661,
0.3105458617210388,
-0.44461679458618164,
-0.4583855867385864,
-0.3974841237068176,
0.5527796149253845,
0.5015292167663574,
0.8190720081329346,
0.6699982285499573,
0.6136265993118286,
0.1752471923828125,
-0.04891514033079147,
-0.20547927916049957,
-0.3896816372871399,
0.09050459414720535,
-0.06344885379076004,
-0.3527809679508209,
-0.43927907943725586,
0.28905293345451355,
0.6880253553390503,
0.8821424841880798,
-0.17918932437896729,
0.25721079111099243,
-0.13733422756195068,
0.7221249938011169,
-0.9979861974716187,
0.1482650637626648,
-0.37800776958465576,
0.09677565842866898,
-0.02125842496752739,
0.436558336019516,
-0.575056254863739,
-0.6192672252655029,
0.016005991026759148,
-0.41201502084732056,
-0.049516309052705765,
0.14178219437599182,
0.8131484389305115,
0.15821360051631927,
-0.020548762753605843,
-0.06564491242170334,
-1.0723451375961304,
0.8242905139923096,
-0.6909506916999817,
0.6667472720146179,
0.4814964532852173,
0.6493837833404541,
0.11986323446035385,
-1.1658235788345337,
-0.4255962669849396,
-0.3991565704345703,
0.024012330919504166,
-0.007638056296855211,
-0.3033437430858612,
0.05602070689201355,
0.16922740638256073,
0.6315723657608032,
-0.34968364238739014,
0.18381555378437042,
-0.032943952828645706,
0.019967811182141304,
0.3862469792366028,
-0.18937739729881287,
0.2879830300807953,
0.43396854400634766,
-0.19900979101657867,
-0.19188794493675232,
-0.645689070224762,
-0.17338907718658447,
0.4234078824520111,
0.22461803257465363,
-0.28531941771507263,
0.618698239326477,
-0.013288830406963825,
0.5420687794685364,
-0.2906218469142914,
0.1234544888138771,
0.31950023770332336,
-0.19246284663677216,
-0.47385212779045105,
0.10118675976991653,
0.8805612921714783,
0.14090369641780853,
0.2372949868440628,
-0.1873449832201004,
-0.24531657993793488,
-0.28568294644355774,
0.24223491549491882,
-0.9565136432647705,
-0.2419617623090744,
0.2668788433074951,
-0.806597888469696,
-0.1930590718984604,
0.28588786721229553,
-0.6415579915046692,
-0.06258171796798706,
-0.2223043143749237,
0.32280901074409485,
-0.4580181837081909,
-0.49563589692115784,
0.34255871176719666,
0.10165116935968399,
0.05544045940041542,
0.3072645962238312,
-0.8047952055931091,
0.5770263075828552,
0.6280142068862915,
0.8262888789176941,
0.010561899282038212,
-0.19538302719593048,
-0.4078664183616638,
0.040410786867141724,
-0.32825967669487,
0.03461281955242157,
-0.624589741230011,
-0.28371748328208923,
0.02713148668408394,
-0.03902189061045647,
-0.2948342263698578,
-0.6340264678001404,
0.8238000869750977,
-0.38091960549354553,
0.24185098707675934,
0.23318538069725037,
-0.5242264270782471,
-0.21039260923862457,
0.02892354130744934,
-0.7342616319656372,
1.2296531200408936,
0.245574951171875,
-0.7948499917984009,
-0.12056811153888702,
-0.9726505279541016,
-0.1292249709367752,
-0.13916613161563873,
0.07336637377738953,
-0.5331959128379822,
0.2727234959602356,
0.19616267085075378,
0.4233131408691406,
-0.3886362314224243,
0.08308004587888718,
-0.3628009855747223,
-0.09991531819105148,
0.14690101146697998,
-0.08950549364089966,
0.8518125414848328,
0.5613457560539246,
-0.37491223216056824,
0.26558607816696167,
-0.658346951007843,
0.04528426378965378,
0.3147069215774536,
-0.18158800899982452,
-0.4614969789981842,
0.023233892396092415,
0.1714632511138916,
0.0019972838927060366,
0.08628026396036148,
-0.8008649349212646,
0.023130131885409355,
-0.42319709062576294,
0.5475793480873108,
0.49873560667037964,
-0.443568617105484,
0.704603374004364,
-0.06276990473270416,
0.3470279574394226,
0.09088246524333954,
0.4062579274177551,
-0.6451303958892822,
-0.535207211971283,
-0.6873709559440613,
-0.4189326763153076,
0.5006527304649353,
0.3874257206916809,
-0.19523076713085175,
0.5615584254264832,
-0.21039175987243652,
-0.6342949867248535,
-0.8211907148361206,
-0.10978575050830841,
0.5188892483711243,
0.5069061517715454,
0.3159697651863098,
-0.17221082746982574,
-0.39120879769325256,
-0.9847860336303711,
-0.16765576601028442,
0.015324682928621769,
-0.11234913766384125,
0.3741833567619324,
0.6732896566390991,
-0.44030770659446716,
1.1746327877044678,
-0.5198034644126892,
0.02201840467751026,
-0.27389758825302124,
0.2062067836523056,
0.08293576538562775,
0.6682717204093933,
0.7497470378875732,
-0.6154072284698486,
-0.35584715008735657,
0.41218721866607666,
-0.6870114207267761,
0.033571816980838776,
0.380674809217453,
-0.1756860762834549,
0.2793520987033844,
0.49252572655677795,
-0.3606719970703125,
0.35245221853256226,
0.8830538392066956,
0.0063937753438949585,
0.451876163482666,
-0.16543199121952057,
0.0035486870910972357,
-1.022365927696228,
0.3942161202430725,
0.10075639933347702,
-0.22666926681995392,
-0.7204713821411133,
0.3517917990684509,
0.3712374269962311,
-0.19200675189495087,
-0.6007340550422668,
0.7483358383178711,
-0.3597610890865326,
0.05235450342297554,
0.012125770561397076,
-0.1419038027524948,
-0.16659016907215118,
0.3366285562515259,
-0.08479918539524078,
0.6973341703414917,
0.6601681113243103,
-0.3833526074886322,
0.06904692947864532,
0.02176552079617977,
-0.5961660146713257,
0.15740817785263062,
-0.7827455997467041,
0.09105055779218674,
-0.17452585697174072,
-0.00017580563144292682,
-0.6036562919616699,
-0.1282733529806137,
0.4520895481109619,
-0.28329235315322876,
0.3356570601463318,
-0.005345429293811321,
-0.4706815779209137,
-0.34165310859680176,
-0.17278291285037994,
0.21799884736537933,
0.7603963017463684,
-0.7462050914764404,
0.772846519947052,
0.38595280051231384,
-0.05132226645946503,
-0.5432302355766296,
-0.7670570015907288,
-0.20824956893920898,
0.22051268815994263,
-0.740653395652771,
0.22713392972946167,
-0.13504980504512787,
-0.5265676379203796,
0.1946721225976944,
-0.06894167512655258,
-0.2242450714111328,
0.07087156176567078,
0.3189317584037781,
0.04872003570199013,
-0.550735592842102,
-0.06504616141319275,
-0.03617173060774803,
-0.18498985469341278,
0.009046463295817375,
-0.6518112421035767,
0.29312509298324585,
-0.28570058941841125,
-0.5437393188476562,
-0.2707286775112152,
0.18585078418254852,
0.5374243855476379,
-0.4997301995754242,
1.1307590007781982,
0.4405634105205536,
-0.5003767609596252,
-0.2948349714279175,
-0.4616515338420868,
-0.24812567234039307,
-0.3793184459209442,
0.1590544879436493,
-0.28661200404167175,
-1.119751214981079,
0.4017338156700134,
-0.09835293143987656,
0.2908284664154053,
0.23840191960334778,
0.4261643886566162,
0.07835624366998672,
1.1145564317703247,
0.48709049820899963,
-0.3134367763996124,
0.34037867188453674,
-0.017777051776647568,
0.31614431738853455,
-0.6855013370513916,
-0.3660077750682831,
-1.1092538833618164,
-0.2074843943119049,
-0.22614070773124695,
-0.4405377209186554,
0.1076577678322792,
0.32724079489707947,
-0.42214056849479675,
0.10394169390201569,
-0.3606531322002411,
0.4368598759174347,
0.8233416676521301,
-0.011319802142679691,
0.31908562779426575,
0.14339835941791534,
-0.44944772124290466,
0.021580947563052177,
-0.5232953429222107,
-0.5932888984680176,
1.0051767826080322,
0.6783153414726257,
1.0745667219161987,
0.032293301075696945,
0.3074037432670593,
0.020070618018507957,
0.4664720892906189,
-0.5474276542663574,
0.3509517014026642,
-0.1138475313782692,
-0.5604166388511658,
-0.07525723427534103,
-0.5975526571273804,
-0.7095113396644592,
-0.0223217885941267,
-0.011423209682106972,
-0.6773648262023926,
-0.05293428897857666,
0.25344768166542053,
0.1307632029056549,
0.6673482656478882,
-0.6660948991775513,
1.0124844312667847,
-0.11231780797243118,
-0.08212822675704956,
0.04285125434398651,
-0.8020099997520447,
0.610550045967102,
-0.10777571052312851,
0.10213983803987503,
-0.15415848791599274,
-0.07050395756959915,
0.4387795031070709,
-0.5403292775154114,
0.73599773645401,
-0.24637286365032196,
-0.008663530461490154,
0.22214001417160034,
0.016824273392558098,
0.3938789367675781,
-0.35320502519607544,
-0.2987551689147949,
0.7491681575775146,
-0.39459308981895447,
-0.30872413516044617,
-0.543158233165741,
0.7389399409294128,
-1.0430150032043457,
-0.03813531994819641,
-0.05785924568772316,
-0.528425395488739,
0.0017458744114264846,
0.16865670680999756,
0.17999836802482605,
0.3570615351200104,
-0.39904457330703735,
0.5165735483169556,
0.912183940410614,
-0.5268955230712891,
0.49919095635414124,
0.43629926443099976,
-0.5640179514884949,
-0.44790923595428467,
0.7221953272819519,
-0.12152961641550064,
0.4283911883831024,
0.4572403132915497,
0.2511347234249115,
-0.16883115470409393,
-0.6365804672241211,
-0.3582890033721924,
0.2976166009902954,
-0.4566740393638611,
0.16831623017787933,
-0.8569880723953247,
-0.4143860638141632,
-0.5811472535133362,
0.06116405129432678,
-0.6590463519096375,
-0.5960606336593628,
-0.014765358529984951,
-0.10224708169698715,
0.2601781487464905,
0.7869516611099243,
0.01686769910156727,
0.5361459851264954,
-0.8726999163627625,
0.06282372772693634,
-0.03432873636484146,
0.6346533894538879,
0.016921238973736763,
-0.3525603711605072,
-0.5174182057380676,
0.07704795151948929,
-0.20993345975875854,
-0.3524344563484192,
0.0782058909535408,
0.23979954421520233,
0.7308580875396729,
0.489463210105896,
-0.01682896539568901,
0.07150702178478241,
-0.5172833800315857,
0.7722108960151672,
0.4431483745574951,
-0.9506705403327942,
0.6105659604072571,
-0.2487284392118454,
0.37528717517852783,
0.4006827473640442,
0.6533703207969666,
-0.5011174082756042,
-0.38198205828666687,
-0.42839595675468445,
-0.6493471264839172,
0.9576417803764343,
0.39391064643859863,
0.004229400306940079,
0.10295818001031876,
0.17738085985183716,
0.25387364625930786,
0.23231375217437744,
-0.5699339509010315,
-0.5678836703300476,
-0.4511222243309021,
-0.4339465796947479,
-0.21582353115081787,
-0.3108496069908142,
-0.07549889385700226,
-0.23937860131263733,
0.7976273894309998,
-0.03481943532824516,
0.2932065427303314,
-0.05971386656165123,
-0.08655823767185211,
-0.14692911505699158,
0.12677037715911865,
0.6734681129455566,
0.5137330293655396,
-0.2844327688217163,
0.19203075766563416,
-0.29017114639282227,
-0.6920429468154907,
-0.029473016038537025,
0.19906310737133026,
-0.3864058554172516,
0.062158215790987015,
0.170352965593338,
0.9771715402603149,
0.29412639141082764,
-0.6534193158149719,
0.6006784439086914,
-0.07378895580768585,
-0.48670050501823425,
-0.16225706040859222,
0.10372559726238251,
0.2674623727798462,
0.0325968898832798,
0.11450721323490143,
0.294969767332077,
-0.22382114827632904,
-0.2534337043762207,
0.17099212110042572,
0.21227070689201355,
-0.7304514646530151,
-0.27561020851135254,
0.9598129987716675,
0.19034208357334137,
-0.3109186291694641,
0.7413772344589233,
0.2386956363916397,
-0.1287715584039688,
0.4700942635536194,
0.4371446669101715,
1.0215939283370972,
-0.6201613545417786,
0.1614162176847458,
0.3378244936466217,
0.5975056886672974,
-0.42048779129981995,
0.14926451444625854,
0.09199162572622299,
-0.9583556652069092,
-0.4016808569431305,
-0.852750837802887,
-0.5093514323234558,
0.11414491385221481,
-0.7858889698982239,
0.02816891483962536,
-0.4522522985935211,
0.0665653795003891,
-0.2556021809577942,
-0.5400083661079407,
-0.316644549369812,
0.15129025280475616,
0.028561534360051155,
1.558835744857788,
-0.5088884830474854,
1.1492393016815186,
0.6777276396751404,
-0.40636661648750305,
-0.6758821606636047,
-0.13429886102676392,
-0.16184157133102417,
-0.7109483480453491,
0.5036211609840393,
0.18519635498523712,
-0.08694513887166977,
0.14665593206882477,
-0.7092722058296204,
-0.5749989151954651,
0.7499045133590698,
0.6538162231445312,
-0.6678379774093628,
0.1033773124217987,
0.19421158730983734,
0.14460694789886475,
-0.590769350528717,
0.5543397068977356,
0.4365702271461487,
0.7228829264640808,
0.05738051235675812,
-0.7920555472373962,
-0.1770017445087433,
-0.16569827497005463,
0.2021200954914093,
0.5339492559432983,
-0.20130586624145508,
0.8437836170196533,
-0.22216461598873138,
0.011673200875520706,
0.22827470302581787,
0.6479194760322571,
-0.15694451332092285,
0.23323917388916016,
0.3567889332771301,
0.7989493608474731,
0.6077860593795776,
-0.2762308716773987,
1.1800200939178467,
-0.44197967648506165,
0.37940821051597595,
1.2088913917541504,
-0.45261669158935547,
0.8903052806854248,
0.22489406168460846,
0.047213613986968994,
0.3728325664997101,
0.4038928151130676,
0.27587273716926575,
0.3665158152580261,
0.015379480086266994,
-0.3462231159210205,
0.048848334699869156,
-0.1065472736954689,
-0.4489089548587799,
0.06826015561819077,
0.1892344057559967,
-0.8041870594024658,
-0.24128133058547974,
0.3149564266204834,
0.3423945903778076,
0.13042579591274261,
-0.4967350959777832,
0.4976043701171875,
0.1995857059955597,
-0.5172366499900818,
0.33101633191108704,
0.21502473950386047,
0.5160132646560669,
-0.8737990856170654,
0.19310636818408966,
-0.08694953471422195,
0.4592226445674896,
-0.1872597634792328,
-0.5685045719146729,
0.3334778845310211,
-0.09410883486270905,
-0.17616139352321625,
-0.4372531473636627,
0.7377455234527588,
-0.5067636966705322,
-0.44886863231658936,
0.6094898581504822,
0.37243354320526123,
0.17084820568561554,
-0.31988218426704407,
-0.6394459009170532,
0.3534618616104126,
-0.1258440911769867,
-0.4587850272655487,
0.18311206996440887,
0.10077446699142456,
0.1541348546743393,
0.5704993009567261,
0.4953575134277344,
0.03651520237326622,
0.22733357548713684,
0.32091689109802246,
0.7386395335197449,
-0.5255353450775146,
-0.12269174307584763,
-0.7131022810935974,
0.664270281791687,
-0.09845442324876785,
-0.21711604297161102,
0.8598464727401733,
0.715759813785553,
1.0830641984939575,
-0.21048183739185333,
0.9179974794387817,
-0.029486969113349915,
0.5808925628662109,
-0.46810272336006165,
0.7980715036392212,
-0.5218651294708252,
-0.060153231024742126,
-0.07160475850105286,
-1.0990474224090576,
-0.4304177761077881,
0.4700801372528076,
-0.19721734523773193,
0.23883336782455444,
0.7755337953567505,
0.9326761960983276,
-0.4288891851902008,
0.5131535530090332,
0.2912011444568634,
0.44181889295578003,
0.035637568682432175,
0.22623896598815918,
0.5059923529624939,
-0.3137472867965698,
0.47497186064720154,
-0.38227126002311707,
-0.4426054060459137,
-0.32273831963539124,
-0.8157180547714233,
-0.8786535263061523,
-0.4618794918060303,
-0.33405396342277527,
-0.1746942549943924,
0.06449546664953232,
0.9150170087814331,
1.0206882953643799,
-0.9262502789497375,
-0.34983712434768677,
-0.11690577119588852,
-0.06545642763376236,
-0.4198603332042694,
-0.20261912047863007,
-0.03386940062046051,
-0.29484882950782776,
-0.8485052585601807,
0.501487135887146,
0.3522784411907196,
-0.028734048828482628,
-0.36876940727233887,
-0.559167206287384,
-0.10842639207839966,
0.10300755500793457,
0.5740864872932434,
0.2885313332080841,
-0.5527735948562622,
-0.17672748863697052,
-0.00969095528125763,
-0.26990440487861633,
0.13643871247768402,
1.0312023162841797,
-0.4113254249095917,
0.4585382640361786,
0.4237484335899353,
0.8389534950256348,
0.6390566825866699,
-0.28162091970443726,
0.7324907183647156,
-0.6828555464744568,
0.15131531655788422,
0.12652213871479034,
0.38144248723983765,
0.13592813909053802,
0.04614640027284622,
0.6822873950004578,
0.004459754563868046,
-0.5494269728660583,
-0.7972565293312073,
0.3408333659172058,
-0.7597289681434631,
-0.4070329964160919,
0.8137309551239014,
-0.3796992301940918,
-0.4264032542705536,
0.11646602302789688,
-0.08909390866756439,
-0.03644025698304176,
-0.3996817171573639,
0.07424266636371613,
0.5095303654670715,
0.18778648972511292,
-0.40627145767211914,
-0.5144882798194885,
0.10374564677476883,
0.1918858140707016,
-0.7975056171417236,
-0.010067370720207691,
0.28675270080566406,
0.05422232672572136,
0.14388404786586761,
0.4326668977737427,
-0.3078252971172333,
-0.035769347101449966,
-0.12415031343698502,
0.561670184135437,
-0.22449758648872375,
-0.524101972579956,
-0.3771117329597473,
0.37733688950538635,
0.0992204025387764,
-0.4137386679649353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14618v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14618v1
|
Hybrid LLM: Cost-Efficient and Quality-Aware Query Routing
| 2024-04-22T23:06:42 | 2024-04-22T23:06:42 |
Dujian Ding, Ankur Mallick, Chi Wang, Robert Sim, Subhabrata Mukherjee, Victor Ruhle, Laks V. S. Lakshmanan, Ahmed Hassan Awadallah
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) excel in most NLP tasks but also require
expensive cloud servers for deployment due to their size, while smaller models
that can be deployed on lower cost (e.g., edge) devices, tend to lag behind in
terms of response quality. Therefore in this work we propose a hybrid inference
approach which combines their respective strengths to save cost and maintain
quality. Our approach uses a router that assigns queries to the small or large
model based on the predicted query difficulty and the desired quality level.
The desired quality level can be tuned dynamically at test time to seamlessly
trade quality for cost as per the scenario requirements. In experiments our
approach allows us to make up to 40% fewer calls to the large model, with no
drop in response quality.
|
[
-0.2606481909751892,
-0.8021562099456787,
0.5248908400535583,
0.21796353161334991,
-0.17902064323425293,
0.32448431849479675,
0.0076817795634269714,
-0.5495266318321228,
0.4154694080352783,
0.8984807133674622,
-0.6013959646224976,
-0.36614125967025757,
-0.09278524667024612,
-0.09493669867515564,
-0.6084485054016113,
0.2853025794029236,
0.29303398728370667,
0.20526203513145447,
-0.1466677039861679,
-0.14381669461727142,
-0.03788962960243225,
-0.5993868112564087,
-1.1826709508895874,
-0.35037675499916077,
0.4637530446052551,
0.1537518948316574,
0.9062509536743164,
0.5772203803062439,
0.3076534569263458,
0.31075623631477356,
-0.42076295614242554,
0.5965642333030701,
-0.3997671604156494,
0.1518946886062622,
-0.36093783378601074,
-0.7580386400222778,
-0.5639272332191467,
-0.38249143958091736,
0.6458099484443665,
0.8006840944290161,
-0.47118231654167175,
-0.16654445230960846,
-0.012396158650517464,
0.8858078718185425,
-0.5670074224472046,
-0.4347931742668152,
-0.835765540599823,
0.035008665174245834,
-0.08025617897510529,
-0.08491699397563934,
-0.39933741092681885,
-0.20137643814086914,
-0.1396290510892868,
-0.5069407224655151,
0.2587506175041199,
0.4701894223690033,
0.8004844188690186,
0.24731186032295227,
-0.6542534828186035,
-0.019504819065332413,
-0.9187787771224976,
0.9368701577186584,
-0.870309054851532,
0.5307124853134155,
0.45068788528442383,
0.4054267406463623,
-0.33962729573249817,
-0.8099050521850586,
-0.767742395401001,
-0.11136085540056229,
0.009137740358710289,
0.2996969521045685,
0.08838238567113876,
0.113693468272686,
-0.04409113526344299,
0.7123908400535583,
-0.5314369201660156,
0.6332778334617615,
0.012317055836319923,
-0.1344723105430603,
0.9077590703964233,
0.40404820442199707,
0.21382474899291992,
-0.1342349797487259,
-0.16477614641189575,
0.4118589162826538,
-0.8073758482933044,
-0.1150897815823555,
0.35045287013053894,
0.2564992904663086,
0.042383015155792236,
0.6346169114112854,
-0.3881705403327942,
0.9815008044242859,
0.06309434026479721,
-0.6511920094490051,
-0.15430955588817596,
-0.6863047480583191,
-0.1903494894504547,
-0.30443570017814636,
0.838341474533081,
0.22938941419124603,
-0.20272864401340485,
-0.21130332350730896,
-0.45665469765663147,
0.005904370918869972,
0.18523049354553223,
-0.3437356948852539,
-0.10745741426944733,
0.39061278104782104,
-0.6614921689033508,
0.0017821338260546327,
-0.43449151515960693,
-1.0117218494415283,
-0.4143472909927368,
-0.2880646586418152,
0.39169245958328247,
-0.41692838072776794,
-0.35190171003341675,
0.20401661098003387,
0.3404380679130554,
0.3302028179168701,
0.32251638174057007,
-0.9644169211387634,
0.6648401021957397,
0.5832242369651794,
0.9532437324523926,
-0.2981944978237152,
0.06875544786453247,
-0.47042104601860046,
0.1521720290184021,
-0.22345729172229767,
0.6579144597053528,
-0.23891323804855347,
-0.566466212272644,
-0.12124013155698776,
-0.17658455669879913,
-0.31604647636413574,
-0.6615312695503235,
0.6825482845306396,
-1.044272780418396,
0.30092576146125793,
0.029417207464575768,
-0.7340797185897827,
-0.1836237609386444,
0.08657363057136536,
-0.7085672616958618,
1.1445987224578857,
0.15448063611984253,
-0.6364410519599915,
-0.017557529732584953,
-0.29016995429992676,
-0.5745694637298584,
0.27143800258636475,
0.13744762539863586,
-0.21186865866184235,
-0.06849291920661926,
0.3663850426673889,
0.20026206970214844,
-0.5598682165145874,
0.22762180864810944,
-0.08248651772737503,
-0.1312214434146881,
-0.10068958252668381,
-0.07135340571403503,
0.6363504528999329,
0.28225380182266235,
-0.27523940801620483,
0.15621693432331085,
-0.9074422121047974,
0.1190352737903595,
0.18911314010620117,
-0.5833508968353271,
-0.40349093079566956,
0.4570104777812958,
0.027923140674829483,
0.12189920246601105,
0.07122638076543808,
-0.46934962272644043,
0.021227657794952393,
-0.591697633266449,
0.5365901589393616,
0.5030403137207031,
-0.07048114389181137,
0.5751416683197021,
-0.30962899327278137,
0.6553483009338379,
-0.20913058519363403,
0.21614879369735718,
0.40689709782600403,
-0.4051082134246826,
-1.2461432218551636,
-0.3997875452041626,
0.3643946051597595,
0.7208702564239502,
-0.9956251978874207,
0.6991784572601318,
-0.14146582782268524,
-0.45000505447387695,
-0.841928243637085,
0.35438069701194763,
0.1278805285692215,
0.5227413773536682,
0.35072287917137146,
0.19202429056167603,
-0.3265155851840973,
-1.0197011232376099,
-0.08999937772750854,
0.04947901889681816,
0.007369403261691332,
0.4145665764808655,
0.25782540440559387,
-0.1773758977651596,
0.8058108687400818,
-0.3073936402797699,
-0.053734276443719864,
-0.47971054911613464,
-0.23221680521965027,
0.26774999499320984,
0.42742517590522766,
0.30796536803245544,
-0.9342577457427979,
-0.2643730044364929,
-0.09653817117214203,
-0.5080165863037109,
-0.1200232207775116,
-0.13481451570987701,
-0.46166184544563293,
0.25600162148475647,
0.39822983741760254,
-0.6219818592071533,
-0.007124892435967922,
0.9844170212745667,
-0.07500974088907242,
0.5012190341949463,
-0.16237542033195496,
0.035644203424453735,
-1.3232300281524658,
-0.3491881489753723,
0.1622982621192932,
-0.35379722714424133,
-0.41193529963493347,
0.20194058120250702,
-0.08254972100257874,
-0.1906713992357254,
-0.4669091999530792,
0.5283048748970032,
-0.5380011200904846,
-0.29911336302757263,
-0.1738482564687729,
-0.0046058460138738155,
0.2683558762073517,
0.13752184808254242,
0.08522768318653107,
0.982683539390564,
0.37389102578163147,
-0.7938072085380554,
0.45143362879753113,
-0.05156292766332626,
-0.32943713665008545,
0.6120237708091736,
-0.6959741711616516,
0.032552320510149,
0.1399410516023636,
0.4729619026184082,
-0.8858305215835571,
-0.07554017752408981,
-0.13100425899028778,
-0.051720213145017624,
0.07251039892435074,
-0.07479772716760635,
-1.0247725248336792,
-0.5336734056472778,
-0.16046173870563507,
0.19436149299144745,
0.7352743744850159,
-0.8360992074012756,
0.9341994524002075,
0.37489837408065796,
0.053446847945451736,
-0.09672102332115173,
-0.7330296635627747,
0.0799131691455841,
-0.18686290085315704,
-0.9406280517578125,
0.5663058757781982,
0.0668439194560051,
-0.1603662520647049,
-0.01973470114171505,
0.02914413996040821,
-0.10280759632587433,
0.03329622745513916,
0.01472985465079546,
0.0970170795917511,
-0.4712076783180237,
-0.039483699947595596,
0.23008215427398682,
-0.039082542061805725,
-0.06323134154081345,
-0.5052378177642822,
0.6207512021064758,
0.22283419966697693,
-0.6653995513916016,
-0.7618498802185059,
0.6172707080841064,
0.7661176919937134,
-0.47383826971054077,
1.1104964017868042,
0.3064000606536865,
-0.35209813714027405,
-0.5353189706802368,
-0.8831995129585266,
-0.14624564349651337,
-0.5089103579521179,
0.14336919784545898,
-0.36905381083488464,
-0.9692786335945129,
0.46555227041244507,
-0.2881707549095154,
-0.03213054686784744,
0.42490461468696594,
0.41889849305152893,
-0.28821036219596863,
0.9830213785171509,
0.45343267917633057,
-0.07126028090715408,
0.21661163866519928,
-0.30933013558387756,
0.5029877424240112,
-0.8952291011810303,
-0.4148803651332855,
-0.5622166395187378,
-0.1695917546749115,
-0.6562889814376831,
-0.6260373592376709,
0.5150818824768066,
0.30158481001853943,
-0.18237334489822388,
-0.07381569594144821,
-0.341564416885376,
0.23545494675636292,
1.0533528327941895,
0.37004703283309937,
0.581653356552124,
-0.010235265828669071,
-0.08130484074354172,
-0.06644491106271744,
-1.026247262954712,
-0.39818498492240906,
0.7430254220962524,
0.08737584948539734,
0.732460618019104,
0.37823763489723206,
0.46149325370788574,
0.07869221270084381,
-0.14440040290355682,
-0.7856955528259277,
0.8157503008842468,
-0.1805598884820938,
-0.5787294507026672,
-0.19206583499908447,
-0.678601861000061,
-0.7871030569076538,
0.5725101232528687,
-0.5521318912506104,
-0.7633067965507507,
-0.1659221202135086,
0.23037037253379822,
-0.44186484813690186,
0.7337562441825867,
-0.4687967896461487,
0.36146003007888794,
-0.7086213827133179,
-0.5655888319015503,
-0.47001639008522034,
-0.3783278167247772,
0.5438548922538757,
-0.1457313597202301,
0.23328031599521637,
-0.006292308680713177,
-0.32470640540122986,
0.626937985420227,
-0.6266629695892334,
0.6300617456436157,
0.20907992124557495,
0.24518585205078125,
0.3295055329799652,
0.23479950428009033,
0.6438753008842468,
-0.1393643170595169,
-0.4985398054122925,
-0.042963907122612,
-0.29470789432525635,
-0.5504786968231201,
-0.6021603941917419,
0.8982118368148804,
-0.7478079199790955,
-0.5694962739944458,
-0.1106751337647438,
-0.5116626024246216,
-0.4308333098888397,
0.162431001663208,
0.35360249876976013,
0.1704150289297104,
0.2680336534976959,
0.04569068178534508,
0.7818129062652588,
-0.7509214282035828,
0.4832656681537628,
0.6804689168930054,
-0.08723703771829605,
-0.4191475212574005,
0.649533212184906,
0.1212373748421669,
0.5896416306495667,
0.490580677986145,
0.23763902485370636,
-0.5932934284210205,
-1.0322389602661133,
-0.4013187885284424,
0.5420291423797607,
-0.4031006395816803,
-0.17306075990200043,
-0.9234676361083984,
-0.3261662721633911,
-0.23242537677288055,
-0.28434282541275024,
-0.7054543495178223,
-0.1882627010345459,
-0.20552723109722137,
-0.04392698034644127,
0.49254074692726135,
0.18905025720596313,
0.1842711865901947,
0.6968344449996948,
-0.6404045224189758,
0.2961178123950958,
0.31633350253105164,
0.43191760778427124,
0.24273750185966492,
-0.586566686630249,
-0.0854247435927391,
-0.18738266825675964,
-0.19863508641719818,
-0.6087955832481384,
0.586593508720398,
0.15440671145915985,
0.6571420431137085,
0.21093851327896118,
0.2507438659667969,
0.4836418330669403,
-0.3430691063404083,
1.0579019784927368,
0.22984443604946136,
-0.9514597058296204,
0.7016358971595764,
-0.4048498868942261,
0.051696114242076874,
0.4670652151107788,
0.4560393989086151,
-0.19286535680294037,
-0.07739493995904922,
-0.5942906141281128,
-1.173642873764038,
0.16625221073627472,
-0.041202180087566376,
0.08058534562587738,
0.17048697173595428,
0.3994906544685364,
-0.018165187910199165,
0.06023483723402023,
-0.6363056302070618,
-0.2807631194591522,
0.29316025972366333,
0.14521607756614685,
0.07171127945184708,
-0.4509747326374054,
-0.024093616753816605,
-0.36478304862976074,
0.8031708002090454,
0.061237093061208725,
-0.005711808800697327,
-0.19357173144817352,
0.030619028955698013,
0.06172223016619682,
0.07421896606683731,
0.2616346478462219,
0.8662790656089783,
-0.09235116839408875,
-0.0380745604634285,
0.25078871846199036,
0.15816015005111694,
0.21398121118545532,
-0.14741522073745728,
-0.4398873746395111,
0.12473173439502716,
0.37100091576576233,
0.7536042332649231,
0.09095578640699387,
-0.6255851984024048,
0.26276692748069763,
0.2052023708820343,
-0.22120440006256104,
-0.08297587186098099,
0.17095892131328583,
0.6375249028205872,
0.16298270225524902,
0.19703643023967743,
-0.5637927055358887,
0.2567797005176544,
-0.15977855026721954,
-0.05493077635765076,
0.5513162016868591,
0.10280776768922806,
0.1258271038532257,
0.8440871834754944,
0.5696092844009399,
-0.5637759566307068,
0.8309773206710815,
0.031106309965252876,
-0.5094293355941772,
0.4206724464893341,
0.6828883290290833,
0.422443687915802,
-0.16195957362651825,
0.17873020470142365,
0.2543940246105194,
0.2158995270729065,
-0.30078402161598206,
0.22933802008628845,
0.3417379558086395,
-0.680436372756958,
-0.721601665019989,
-0.9187639355659485,
-0.6302145719528198,
0.2875080108642578,
-0.5443142652511597,
-0.038402386009693146,
-0.496084064245224,
-0.09933080524206161,
-0.07269953936338425,
-0.006701231002807617,
-0.37591880559921265,
0.482361763715744,
0.0771343782544136,
0.9896002411842346,
-0.7366876006126404,
0.8218140006065369,
0.5439288020133972,
-0.21929439902305603,
-0.922473669052124,
-0.41616004705429077,
0.1476903110742569,
-0.7982207536697388,
0.4608382284641266,
-0.2826305627822876,
-0.4462016224861145,
0.1440737396478653,
-0.24693702161312103,
-0.9022051692008972,
1.0879013538360596,
0.2771693766117096,
-0.8075529336929321,
0.07142406702041626,
-0.07795082032680511,
0.5426027774810791,
-0.1250983476638794,
0.17667241394519806,
0.43014228343963623,
0.20206916332244873,
0.21280790865421295,
-0.8936184644699097,
-0.030519451946020126,
0.15596698224544525,
0.32535356283187866,
0.26521000266075134,
-0.9019185304641724,
0.7203091382980347,
0.02639475278556347,
-0.1843557059764862,
0.15636366605758667,
0.7669554352760315,
0.2660920321941376,
0.32813090085983276,
0.5814734101295471,
0.6260981559753418,
0.9445624351501465,
0.09642459452152252,
1.3078621625900269,
-0.2822008430957794,
0.21676716208457947,
1.0980253219604492,
-0.40438127517700195,
1.1007457971572876,
0.5884875059127808,
-0.3721035420894623,
0.30897244811058044,
1.0026246309280396,
0.29684415459632874,
0.5775535106658936,
0.4506649971008301,
-0.6381731033325195,
-0.35983723402023315,
-0.2952367663383484,
-0.33240413665771484,
0.24052903056144714,
0.30244264006614685,
-0.30529412627220154,
-0.09338093549013138,
-0.17569638788700104,
0.03832888603210449,
0.3383026123046875,
-0.45868512988090515,
0.7503858804702759,
0.28316593170166016,
-0.5510571599006653,
0.5185155272483826,
0.18122738599777222,
1.02545964717865,
-0.6100958585739136,
0.3873048424720764,
-0.6482587456703186,
0.09846276044845581,
-0.3397507965564728,
-0.4706871509552002,
0.29766610264778137,
-0.34470415115356445,
-0.2767370939254761,
-0.014872844330966473,
0.46444031596183777,
-0.2136632353067398,
-0.7291663289070129,
0.6627551317214966,
0.7270098924636841,
-0.010306729935109615,
-0.07192473858594894,
-0.8369281888008118,
0.034697338938713074,
-0.23901405930519104,
-0.21365560591220856,
0.542574942111969,
0.27874255180358887,
0.07230713963508606,
1.0437544584274292,
0.8697205185890198,
0.5634989142417908,
0.2792501747608185,
0.109959676861763,
0.7178213596343994,
-0.5982072949409485,
-0.637516438961029,
-0.7212886214256287,
0.3582795560359955,
-0.20090250670909882,
-0.05066094920039177,
0.5589555501937866,
0.45918720960617065,
0.4345007836818695,
0.17614242434501648,
0.6239384412765503,
0.3302091956138611,
0.6199629306793213,
-0.9314023852348328,
0.5222280025482178,
-0.7906380891799927,
0.5598280429840088,
0.08037332445383072,
-0.932263970375061,
-0.2444830685853958,
0.34587234258651733,
-0.16013504564762115,
-0.21006980538368225,
0.605259120464325,
1.0908716917037964,
-0.25384747982025146,
-0.058127254247665405,
0.32437458634376526,
-0.08150843530893326,
0.27032598853111267,
0.5012553930282593,
0.8179133534431458,
-0.16351446509361267,
0.27067601680755615,
-0.35446327924728394,
-0.20227396488189697,
-0.3423020839691162,
-0.9124583005905151,
-0.5261673927307129,
-0.18260392546653748,
-0.4246987998485565,
-0.7288954257965088,
0.23813512921333313,
0.7377667427062988,
1.0493727922439575,
-0.5673972964286804,
-0.4045277237892151,
-0.06795532256364822,
0.29777732491493225,
-0.1939229667186737,
-0.2352973222732544,
0.5237518548965454,
-0.11515510082244873,
-0.5969728231430054,
0.5041694045066833,
0.1659179925918579,
-0.18590237200260162,
-0.23511049151420593,
0.07430016249418259,
-0.4630874991416931,
0.13585811853408813,
0.746320366859436,
0.2004452347755432,
-0.9642028212547302,
0.04781389608979225,
-0.185324564576149,
-0.14762108027935028,
-0.11455236375331879,
0.6264384388923645,
-0.4668174088001251,
0.2711693346500397,
0.3059633672237396,
1.1967307329177856,
0.6768410205841064,
0.10879432410001755,
0.6795875430107117,
-0.22315023839473724,
0.1340695321559906,
0.4584376811981201,
0.3243445158004761,
0.5116607546806335,
-0.6013000011444092,
0.4498949646949768,
0.3205309212207794,
-0.5008845329284668,
-0.61158686876297,
0.4016593098640442,
-1.2089805603027344,
-0.23025977611541748,
1.3793787956237793,
0.07606741040945053,
-0.10992824286222458,
0.06105416268110275,
0.04469352588057518,
-0.07781467586755753,
-0.12311079353094101,
0.3899522125720978,
0.30777212977409363,
-0.523002564907074,
-0.44383832812309265,
-0.7580031752586365,
0.11528271436691284,
0.6341210007667542,
-0.8666253089904785,
-0.5152992010116577,
0.5542840361595154,
0.2566668391227722,
-0.03754863515496254,
0.6823938488960266,
0.16265635192394257,
-0.23310759663581848,
-0.002209464320912957,
-0.08134033530950546,
0.20462766289710999,
-0.028883015736937523,
-0.018815627321600914,
0.2535667419433594,
0.1643810123205185,
-0.4929788112640381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14607v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14607v1
|
Q-Tuning: Queue-based Prompt Tuning for Lifelong Few-shot Language Learning
| 2024-04-22T22:04:16 | 2024-04-22T22:04:16 |
Yanhui Guo, Shaoyuan Xu, Jinmiao Fu, Jia Liu, Chaosheng Dong, Bryan Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces \textbf{Q-tuning}, a novel approach for continual
prompt tuning that enables the lifelong learning of a pre-trained language
model. When learning a new task, Q-tuning trains a task-specific prompt by
adding it to a prompt queue consisting of the prompts from older tasks. To
better transfer the knowledge of old tasks, we design an adaptive knowledge
aggregation technique that reweighs previous prompts in the queue with a
learnable low-rank matrix. Once the prompt queue reaches its maximum capacity,
we leverage a PCA-based eviction rule to reduce the queue's size, allowing the
newly trained prompt to be added while preserving the primary knowledge of old
tasks. In order to mitigate the accumulation of information loss caused by the
eviction, we additionally propose a globally shared prefix prompt and a memory
retention regularization based on information theory. Extensive experiments
demonstrate that our approach outperforms the state-of-the-art methods
substantially on continual prompt tuning benchmarks. Moreover, our approach
enables lifelong learning on linearly growing task sequences while requiring
constant complexity for training and inference.
|
[
-0.2878369092941284,
-0.8254844546318054,
0.49034300446510315,
-0.05171786621212959,
-0.28629133105278015,
0.07830503582954407,
-0.2978530824184418,
0.1258901208639145,
-0.07409599423408508,
0.22816437482833862,
-0.733841061592102,
-0.33838698267936707,
-0.2278713434934616,
0.006206401623785496,
0.2900676131248474,
0.8452191948890686,
0.5159503817558289,
0.007652987726032734,
-0.01868070662021637,
-0.0039701820351183414,
-0.861366331577301,
-0.20189671218395233,
-1.4337151050567627,
0.11543004214763641,
0.8255701661109924,
0.8919034004211426,
0.4466921389102936,
0.6374179124832153,
0.0941351056098938,
0.20964877307415009,
0.06251369416713715,
0.432826429605484,
-0.772330641746521,
0.3229350745677948,
-0.0634182021021843,
-0.5647838115692139,
-0.2408367246389389,
-0.07858197391033173,
0.925476610660553,
0.38734591007232666,
-0.06887645274400711,
-0.007417370565235615,
0.10031767934560776,
0.6836023330688477,
-0.6934555172920227,
-0.011637183837592602,
-0.7813620567321777,
-0.009654084220528603,
-0.3754477798938751,
-0.6123387813568115,
-0.4844825565814972,
-0.5209717750549316,
-0.2435852289199829,
-0.9466488361358643,
-0.032852206379175186,
0.43792909383773804,
0.733284592628479,
0.42274466156959534,
-0.2616209387779236,
0.01574069820344448,
-0.45133084058761597,
0.87936931848526,
-0.4369187355041504,
0.32717323303222656,
0.6202918887138367,
0.4585571885108948,
-0.32758674025535583,
-0.3452361226081848,
-0.5171001553535461,
-0.11596247553825378,
0.2242405265569687,
0.10550004988908768,
-0.01768473908305168,
0.14339111745357513,
0.31326764822006226,
0.0873737633228302,
-0.6303843259811401,
0.20193366706371307,
-0.2072599083185196,
-0.21174536645412445,
0.21993790566921234,
0.1930817812681198,
0.520788311958313,
0.30237120389938354,
-0.3294094204902649,
0.1571105420589447,
-0.9665260314941406,
0.33579787611961365,
0.15050624310970306,
0.3873698115348816,
0.16777032613754272,
-0.10000762343406677,
-0.3329547047615051,
0.866563618183136,
0.41268160939216614,
-0.1597173810005188,
0.01624593511223793,
-0.3009619116783142,
-0.04285375401377678,
-0.09991905093193054,
0.6752984523773193,
0.3887891173362732,
0.33507198095321655,
-0.3292142450809479,
-0.0163569413125515,
-0.12985846400260925,
0.10894329100847244,
-0.5173284411430359,
-0.2839965224266052,
-0.13581134378910065,
-0.15780283510684967,
-0.047613270580768585,
-0.23445327579975128,
-0.7326364517211914,
-0.2998521327972412,
-0.2982097864151001,
0.6044217348098755,
-0.5187809467315674,
-0.0027616166044026613,
0.01995832659304142,
-0.08577243983745575,
0.39389437437057495,
0.27239570021629333,
-1.044143795967102,
0.23378650844097137,
0.5569503903388977,
0.8092511296272278,
-0.2604011595249176,
-0.5254340171813965,
-1.4303287267684937,
-0.08721277862787247,
-0.37213438749313354,
0.9726918935775757,
-0.6724132895469666,
-0.19299250841140747,
-0.02935447171330452,
0.12340360879898071,
-0.22193467617034912,
-0.5922387838363647,
0.37413159012794495,
-0.6432792544364929,
0.3455118238925934,
-0.3695286810398102,
-0.5653215050697327,
0.1437271535396576,
0.05425155535340309,
-0.35898688435554504,
1.139768123626709,
0.26794007420539856,
-0.3217805027961731,
0.575181245803833,
-0.37833458185195923,
-0.17296956479549408,
0.3882770836353302,
0.12535980343818665,
-0.5669646263122559,
0.044201213866472244,
0.12135833501815796,
0.18857784569263458,
-0.1391979455947876,
0.12526340782642365,
-0.25791895389556885,
-0.5033701658248901,
-0.06548626720905304,
-0.09574459493160248,
0.6841521263122559,
0.19421952962875366,
0.0776323601603508,
0.20545293390750885,
-0.5838918089866638,
0.0969533622264862,
-0.231157585978508,
-0.24620334804058075,
-0.34534332156181335,
-0.0036115499678999186,
-0.4344022572040558,
0.4003387689590454,
0.2954387366771698,
-0.4697543680667877,
0.49665236473083496,
-0.3986046612262726,
0.23796147108078003,
0.7190873622894287,
0.3995305895805359,
0.5388924479484558,
-0.7103010416030884,
0.8022037744522095,
0.12804363667964935,
0.4660717844963074,
-0.6283606290817261,
-0.4486599266529083,
-0.6661106944084167,
-0.1266610473394394,
0.10248811542987823,
0.7246870994567871,
-0.8229214549064636,
0.43220195174217224,
-0.1337660402059555,
-0.2006049007177353,
-0.42864519357681274,
0.35901519656181335,
0.1631200909614563,
0.6579845547676086,
0.4425029456615448,
-0.10815335810184479,
-0.5289734601974487,
-0.5191407799720764,
-0.34550419449806213,
-0.09385031461715698,
0.12851163744926453,
0.19392883777618408,
0.0370294526219368,
0.06902420520782471,
1.0424977540969849,
-0.2504426836967468,
-0.25456100702285767,
-0.07750032842159271,
0.09042166918516159,
0.293090283870697,
0.7093138694763184,
0.4462970495223999,
-0.31429579854011536,
-0.6329771280288696,
-0.12017235904932022,
-0.3795301914215088,
-0.18563860654830933,
-0.5049914121627808,
-0.292492538690567,
-0.017902998253703117,
0.6597676277160645,
-0.4750649333000183,
-0.10131090879440308,
0.2396382838487625,
-0.4650890827178955,
0.564323365688324,
-0.1599268615245819,
0.09353422373533249,
-0.9423241019248962,
-0.13660310208797455,
-0.1635282039642334,
-0.4395161271095276,
-0.4605308473110199,
-0.18444421887397766,
0.1875784695148468,
-0.08666989952325821,
-0.4760854244232178,
0.9402713179588318,
-0.310583233833313,
0.215560182929039,
-0.44429439306259155,
0.28131210803985596,
-0.18163159489631653,
0.7783127427101135,
-0.2524625062942505,
0.9101685285568237,
0.9385692477226257,
-0.9471586346626282,
0.4115001857280731,
0.10464861243963242,
-0.21978725492954254,
0.7401965260505676,
-0.3730580806732178,
0.18746846914291382,
-0.31992611289024353,
-0.06381197273731232,
-0.9651281237602234,
0.26147186756134033,
0.40887245535850525,
-0.6386359333992004,
0.28308868408203125,
-0.43781527876853943,
-0.3308131694793701,
0.009633039124310017,
-0.1559542566537857,
0.2665177285671234,
0.7122513651847839,
-0.5574852824211121,
0.26707619428634644,
0.198116734623909,
-0.40282660722732544,
-0.3972713351249695,
0.05799658223986626,
-0.05961742252111435,
-0.40598610043525696,
-0.21190911531448364,
0.24698060750961304,
-0.4149363338947296,
0.04571385681629181,
-0.15410789847373962,
-0.17259374260902405,
-0.10779605805873871,
0.342049777507782,
0.10050858557224274,
0.028995275497436523,
-0.19926851987838745,
0.6712914109230042,
0.33751049637794495,
-0.24734486639499664,
-0.2435518354177475,
-0.6763334274291992,
0.41746285557746887,
0.03421592712402344,
0.15967339277267456,
-0.5774444937705994,
0.26692312955856323,
0.38507670164108276,
-0.17456494271755219,
0.8206859230995178,
0.6334269046783447,
-0.1521066576242447,
-0.39017626643180847,
-0.4469953179359436,
-0.2739233672618866,
-0.4787265360355377,
0.13367101550102234,
-0.4476884603500366,
-1.1913737058639526,
0.46378952264785767,
-0.6172531843185425,
0.27706438302993774,
0.33501794934272766,
0.37046191096305847,
-0.3925527036190033,
0.927419900894165,
0.9535656571388245,
-0.21322305500507355,
1.048831582069397,
0.142814502120018,
-0.16671384871006012,
-0.6154758334159851,
0.021661514416337013,
-0.5246075391769409,
-0.1732213795185089,
-0.307016521692276,
-0.09351256489753723,
0.4556233584880829,
0.5631484389305115,
-0.5572484135627747,
-0.1268046796321869,
-0.005262693390250206,
0.8711072206497192,
0.5282652974128723,
0.1623886227607727,
0.1649472862482071,
-0.17799383401870728,
-0.16026201844215393,
0.16235467791557312,
-0.9627140760421753,
-0.13903707265853882,
0.8111066818237305,
0.13103778660297394,
0.4238038659095764,
0.007565462030470371,
0.7075666189193726,
0.3961201608181,
-0.11148087680339813,
-0.8544415235519409,
0.2979092299938202,
0.10035746544599533,
-0.16490566730499268,
-0.7249712347984314,
-0.5092975497245789,
-1.0945618152618408,
0.016371751204133034,
-0.19534362852573395,
-0.6975203156471252,
0.14170360565185547,
0.5156077742576599,
-0.765379786491394,
0.03593849763274193,
-0.5287927389144897,
0.9076510071754456,
-0.06750518083572388,
-0.6810566186904907,
-0.2417806088924408,
-0.597707211971283,
0.14970728754997253,
-0.10801426321268082,
0.03353165090084076,
-0.11215373873710632,
-0.056973885744810104,
0.674111008644104,
-0.3284803330898285,
0.9367635250091553,
-0.4577496647834778,
0.061649829149246216,
0.18295302987098694,
0.08204898238182068,
0.7985907196998596,
0.344627320766449,
0.03806912153959274,
-0.3952926993370056,
0.15817473828792572,
-0.7680143117904663,
-0.7705621719360352,
0.4987809658050537,
-0.7010121941566467,
-0.46902239322662354,
-0.23376812040805817,
-0.3651925325393677,
-0.4152872860431671,
0.31185099482536316,
0.2789515256881714,
0.41673392057418823,
-0.1466410756111145,
-0.09145636111497879,
0.9437199831008911,
-0.3602648377418518,
0.42407140135765076,
0.6993772387504578,
-0.0836988240480423,
-0.3091561198234558,
1.092639684677124,
-0.1810774952173233,
0.10567045956850052,
0.47744420170783997,
0.35104960203170776,
-0.228322371840477,
-0.43700385093688965,
-0.3769265115261078,
0.33684808015823364,
-0.39162999391555786,
-0.3590855896472931,
-0.4007991850376129,
0.10262399911880493,
-0.30256178975105286,
-0.0978487953543663,
-0.16255566477775574,
-0.29206714034080505,
-0.4470253884792328,
0.1584557741880417,
0.5986369848251343,
0.27249619364738464,
-0.09868060797452927,
0.7776570320129395,
-0.9579786062240601,
0.2538631558418274,
0.6556237936019897,
0.46190911531448364,
-0.36285561323165894,
-0.7982739806175232,
-0.6394572854042053,
-0.17253848910331726,
-0.1237831860780716,
-0.8133213520050049,
0.42670586705207825,
0.7479128837585449,
0.6948288679122925,
0.4002903997898102,
0.1128542348742485,
0.5453183054924011,
-0.5752614140510559,
0.8031784296035767,
0.017098305746912956,
-0.9116550087928772,
0.6437589526176453,
-0.5483089089393616,
0.8855165839195251,
0.8244345188140869,
0.4118950366973877,
-0.9329538941383362,
-0.22833918035030365,
-0.28318530321121216,
-0.5304856896400452,
0.6680372357368469,
-0.44536858797073364,
-0.025905875489115715,
-0.26028841733932495,
0.5592054724693298,
0.23699286580085754,
0.019976789131760597,
-0.39535823464393616,
-0.09093563258647919,
-0.12946143746376038,
-0.1949482262134552,
-0.12170472741127014,
-0.23472917079925537,
0.16833016276359558,
-0.2630193829536438,
0.8228679299354553,
-0.5163105130195618,
0.16815225780010223,
-0.2511807382106781,
-0.3889005184173584,
-0.24979759752750397,
0.4086478054523468,
0.65805983543396,
0.6317358613014221,
-0.1275898963212967,
0.056503478437662125,
0.2819090783596039,
-0.27827996015548706,
0.13881531357765198,
-0.36563730239868164,
-0.14917398989200592,
-0.2283092439174652,
-0.08942015469074249,
0.9903930425643921,
0.4109380543231964,
-0.5666874051094055,
0.31840676069259644,
-0.24157582223415375,
-0.05103028565645218,
-0.30164697766304016,
0.3065865933895111,
-0.24705752730369568,
0.14590327441692352,
0.39276769757270813,
0.06115907430648804,
-0.18001261353492737,
-0.37871262431144714,
0.48117026686668396,
0.29645392298698425,
-0.43959420919418335,
-0.33219054341316223,
0.3555218577384949,
0.26335248351097107,
-0.23871204257011414,
0.8161569237709045,
-0.5847855806350708,
-0.31764718890190125,
0.3916279077529907,
0.6390170454978943,
0.799985408782959,
-0.4681397080421448,
0.34444379806518555,
0.6965272426605225,
0.15202449262142181,
-0.23848643898963928,
0.4571780860424042,
-0.45037221908569336,
-0.77044677734375,
-0.6074389815330505,
-0.5629448294639587,
-0.28668203949928284,
0.043776702135801315,
-0.48241129517555237,
0.17547667026519775,
-0.647998034954071,
-0.08927088230848312,
-0.49058839678764343,
0.07366184145212173,
-0.5689014196395874,
-0.004657440353184938,
-0.10947674512863159,
0.7175945043563843,
-0.9358571767807007,
1.0848143100738525,
0.5870994329452515,
-0.23362527787685394,
-0.3812747299671173,
-0.08145280927419662,
0.02170000970363617,
-0.5516493320465088,
0.6421268582344055,
-0.1777249425649643,
-0.10538651794195175,
0.584265947341919,
-0.5476642847061157,
-1.0523260831832886,
0.8491952419281006,
0.2551104724407196,
-0.8798359632492065,
-0.09152713418006897,
-0.5560892224311829,
0.2703370153903961,
-0.12934733927249908,
0.10147576779127121,
0.697130024433136,
0.3254520297050476,
-0.022080129012465477,
-0.8368452787399292,
-0.16071900725364685,
-0.34506556391716003,
-0.17618772387504578,
0.30873239040374756,
-0.8078557848930359,
0.7438433766365051,
-0.150125190615654,
-0.5541710257530212,
0.08711335808038712,
0.6760021448135376,
0.2830382287502289,
0.19907189905643463,
0.528782069683075,
0.4148586094379425,
1.1176958084106445,
-0.006651593837887049,
0.6353810429573059,
-0.49542754888534546,
0.1676815152168274,
1.140468716621399,
-0.10409276187419891,
0.5726072192192078,
0.272516131401062,
0.01590883545577526,
0.36547863483428955,
0.7088955044746399,
0.17333999276161194,
0.6263186931610107,
0.1596442610025406,
-0.465928852558136,
-0.6683139204978943,
-0.2505144774913788,
-0.15620826184749603,
0.11916113644838333,
0.5246042609214783,
0.06725568324327469,
-0.16494804620742798,
0.22662460803985596,
-0.07982586324214935,
-0.037945374846458435,
-0.5721307396888733,
0.997477650642395,
0.05612342059612274,
-0.7951390147209167,
0.8607563376426697,
-0.27269724011421204,
0.763087809085846,
-0.6131077408790588,
-0.11138872802257538,
-0.39766353368759155,
-0.26258039474487305,
-0.011261139996349812,
-0.13716015219688416,
0.0593426339328289,
-0.26607057452201843,
-0.2496134489774704,
-0.33120858669281006,
0.5018190741539001,
-0.6022858619689941,
-0.060451868921518326,
-0.19848771393299103,
0.7652417421340942,
0.09672866016626358,
-0.0005100038251839578,
-0.5911378860473633,
-0.15747883915901184,
-0.25852346420288086,
0.08051082491874695,
0.5171076059341431,
0.6010205745697021,
0.038888297975063324,
0.7069923281669617,
0.45043739676475525,
0.27511101961135864,
0.3342445194721222,
0.04770226404070854,
0.8334619402885437,
-0.8107312321662903,
-0.8373805284500122,
-0.6128840446472168,
0.3196076452732086,
0.19752608239650726,
-0.4925364553928375,
0.6718332171440125,
0.36401528120040894,
0.6575079560279846,
-0.04931502416729927,
0.7829663157463074,
0.35162046551704407,
0.5817155241966248,
-0.8990089297294617,
0.5124521255493164,
-0.39685139060020447,
0.137629896402359,
0.0858607068657875,
-0.7182289361953735,
-0.3059437870979309,
0.49796757102012634,
-0.20839782059192657,
0.028315797448158264,
0.7285917401313782,
0.9301651120185852,
0.20583291351795197,
-0.2948940098285675,
0.6547662615776062,
0.005949585698544979,
0.03737221658229828,
0.8750495314598083,
0.929999589920044,
-0.221523255109787,
0.2893076539039612,
0.08140860497951508,
-0.28313055634498596,
-0.22631675004959106,
-0.7305204272270203,
-0.785709023475647,
-0.7515131831169128,
-0.4040684401988983,
0.07744502276182175,
0.4975561201572418,
1.0531163215637207,
0.770813524723053,
-0.7757675647735596,
-0.044111691415309906,
-0.227108433842659,
0.3248690366744995,
-0.606289803981781,
-0.21069727838039398,
0.3081904947757721,
-1.12263822555542,
-0.659453809261322,
0.801051139831543,
0.3259483575820923,
-0.11929810792207718,
-0.0440027080476284,
-0.09082115441560745,
-0.1275632083415985,
-0.13090765476226807,
0.6214628219604492,
0.8664523363113403,
-0.35965973138809204,
-0.2988196015357971,
0.16762633621692657,
-0.005613371264189482,
0.17922057211399078,
0.9097933173179626,
-1.2639902830123901,
0.6008795499801636,
0.629082441329956,
0.6844772696495056,
0.23026706278324127,
0.06263820827007294,
0.6247987747192383,
-1.0204143524169922,
0.003908043261617422,
0.16187572479248047,
0.06730256974697113,
-0.030451053753495216,
-0.5082741379737854,
-0.017638230696320534,
0.272739976644516,
-0.7623549103736877,
-0.4948785603046417,
0.33560678362846375,
-0.9137002229690552,
-0.24073435366153717,
0.8218053579330444,
-0.11760494112968445,
-0.2529877722263336,
-0.5220968127250671,
-0.21181228756904602,
0.30533120036125183,
-0.7439801096916199,
0.8270121216773987,
0.3081694543361664,
-0.10361480712890625,
-0.8905912041664124,
-0.34331461787223816,
1.0214581489562988,
0.4344244599342346,
-0.8466504812240601,
0.06437249481678009,
0.6013144254684448,
0.26569071412086487,
-0.3425503373146057,
0.8585503101348877,
0.2008170187473297,
0.814638078212738,
-0.24566778540611267,
-0.04741484671831131,
-0.20022745430469513,
-0.6339646577835083,
-0.771682858467102,
0.14240969717502594,
0.4320123791694641,
-0.19577577710151672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14604v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14604v3
|
Describe-then-Reason: Improving Multimodal Mathematical Reasoning through Visual Comprehension Training
| 2024-04-22T21:59:35 | 2024-04-26T02:34:29 |
Mengzhao Jia, Zhihan Zhang, Wenhao Yu, Fangkai Jiao, Meng Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Open-source multimodal large language models (MLLMs) excel in various tasks
involving textual and visual inputs but still struggle with complex multimodal
mathematical reasoning, lagging behind proprietary models like GPT-4V(ision)
and Gemini-Pro. Although fine-tuning with intermediate steps (i.e., rationales)
elicits some mathematical reasoning skills, the resulting models still fall
short in visual comprehension due to inadequate visual-centric supervision,
which leads to inaccurate interpretation of math figures. To address this
issue, we propose a two-step training pipeline VCAR, which emphasizes the
Visual Comprehension training in Addition to mathematical Reasoning learning.
It first improves the visual comprehension ability of MLLMs through the visual
description generation task, followed by another training step on generating
rationales with the assistance of descriptions. Experimental results on two
popular benchmarks demonstrate that VCAR substantially outperforms baseline
methods solely relying on rationale supervision, especially on problems with
high visual demands.
|
[
-0.4646315574645996,
-0.5526647567749023,
0.7708250284194946,
0.2571501135826111,
-0.40348073840141296,
-0.05184001475572586,
-0.0777658224105835,
-0.11399664729833603,
-0.2712666094303131,
0.6001903414726257,
-0.6636970639228821,
-0.17874012887477875,
-0.5545550584793091,
-0.11999453604221344,
-0.17866156995296478,
0.8493146896362305,
-0.29931363463401794,
0.5646749138832092,
-0.8089434504508972,
-0.0924568846821785,
-0.5958396792411804,
-0.20209573209285736,
-0.77686607837677,
-0.2165919691324234,
0.5740472078323364,
0.3854924440383911,
0.5088321566581726,
0.5485859513282776,
0.7970207333564758,
0.37534886598587036,
0.26757901906967163,
0.5167199373245239,
-0.2523026764392853,
0.07730510085821152,
-0.014833400025963783,
-0.7883766293525696,
-0.16450895369052887,
-0.12709955871105194,
0.23749789595603943,
0.4520683288574219,
-0.048854392021894455,
0.13391833007335663,
-0.15596437454223633,
0.69737309217453,
-0.6755456328392029,
0.5126032829284668,
-0.4137875735759735,
0.009447259828448296,
0.07262720167636871,
-0.4556155502796173,
-0.4899697005748749,
-0.14725294709205627,
0.3316795229911804,
-0.9013792276382446,
0.08295680582523346,
0.13430172204971313,
0.7023374438285828,
0.41112834215164185,
-0.5349478721618652,
-0.23900553584098816,
-0.603381872177124,
1.0541573762893677,
-0.4284512996673584,
0.35854801535606384,
0.3571975529193878,
0.9318348169326782,
0.24894404411315918,
-0.895211398601532,
-0.583986222743988,
-0.296883761882782,
-0.032922763377428055,
0.2993769943714142,
-0.34931033849716187,
0.048785217106342316,
0.5877143740653992,
-0.15507537126541138,
-0.5820273160934448,
-0.34851086139678955,
-0.7841664552688599,
-0.23118464648723602,
0.4049531817436218,
0.22829832136631012,
0.06438754498958588,
-0.049380309879779816,
-0.5201376676559448,
-0.24412739276885986,
-0.5773974061012268,
0.5588388442993164,
-0.04888901859521866,
-0.10199528187513351,
0.04991759732365608,
0.9038416147232056,
-0.012371272780001163,
0.7513173818588257,
-0.09198962897062302,
-0.2657870650291443,
0.050490736961364746,
-0.3764282464981079,
-0.4145670533180237,
-0.19849863648414612,
0.504828691482544,
0.5467112064361572,
0.5493008494377136,
0.21238908171653748,
-0.03684176877140999,
0.4618823826313019,
0.335227370262146,
-0.932516872882843,
-0.3013022541999817,
0.0519561693072319,
-0.5363159775733948,
-0.12045736610889435,
0.11843716353178024,
-0.6455797553062439,
-0.12164966017007828,
-1.0569782257080078,
0.4810973107814789,
-0.5634039640426636,
-0.0712931901216507,
0.016176164150238037,
-0.2393457591533661,
0.05765335261821747,
0.6049466133117676,
-0.8425602316856384,
-0.04647247493267059,
0.7476252317428589,
0.7197007536888123,
0.3650546073913574,
-0.27128082513809204,
-0.90227210521698,
-0.07842113077640533,
-0.4453355669975281,
0.9205855131149292,
-0.5977039933204651,
0.04962197318673134,
-0.16620418429374695,
-0.23788294196128845,
0.003622492076829076,
-0.35896316170692444,
0.4082515835762024,
-0.37022411823272705,
0.33687254786491394,
-0.4201216697692871,
-0.1346280425786972,
-0.3691243529319763,
0.3477672040462494,
-0.32684609293937683,
0.6021058559417725,
0.12091179937124252,
-0.7352430820465088,
0.4608333706855774,
-0.525725781917572,
-0.10001161694526672,
-0.17574547231197357,
-0.39436307549476624,
-0.350069522857666,
0.13875097036361694,
0.591997504234314,
0.33946022391319275,
-0.3206154406070709,
0.07100754976272583,
-0.4573153555393219,
-0.08024198561906815,
0.38458555936813354,
-0.4048430025577545,
0.7059688568115234,
0.41494855284690857,
-0.1661599576473236,
0.5731930732727051,
-0.7485813498497009,
0.28286105394363403,
-0.019524941220879555,
0.1409214287996292,
-0.27139946818351746,
-0.09414505958557129,
-0.14920687675476074,
0.5618166923522949,
0.07218149304389954,
-0.18595795333385468,
0.00991782359778881,
-0.33578670024871826,
0.6110238432884216,
0.8247336745262146,
-0.3091784715652466,
0.5206917524337769,
-0.1758413463830948,
0.8899103403091431,
0.1932649463415146,
0.3877541422843933,
-0.5729941129684448,
-0.5457262396812439,
-0.9230586886405945,
-0.41518568992614746,
-0.049398742616176605,
0.6262198686599731,
-1.3415309190750122,
-0.2667679786682129,
-0.023606179282069206,
-0.3722575008869171,
-0.3696800470352173,
0.3181213140487671,
0.6708517670631409,
0.8334106802940369,
0.43818792700767517,
0.10967300087213516,
-0.7233455777168274,
-1.0180916786193848,
-0.17808154225349426,
-0.15088240802288055,
-0.034965209662914276,
0.1645401269197464,
0.508824348449707,
-0.17989833652973175,
0.8519589304924011,
-0.3703676164150238,
-0.45697906613349915,
-0.19569841027259827,
0.2658042907714844,
-0.0339844636619091,
0.06362015008926392,
0.5397624969482422,
-0.9327224493026733,
-0.4220059812068939,
0.023378320038318634,
-0.9168131351470947,
-0.134209543466568,
-0.24413098394870758,
-0.2997579574584961,
0.06428051739931107,
0.7079320549964905,
-0.7879260778427124,
0.4801079332828522,
0.36328932642936707,
-0.4677276611328125,
0.5504345893859863,
-0.33541375398635864,
-0.020323995500802994,
-0.9034165143966675,
-0.20988206565380096,
0.19731689989566803,
-0.009408327750861645,
-0.1751125603914261,
-0.05248479172587395,
0.15703335404396057,
-0.085357666015625,
-0.45093709230422974,
0.32674315571784973,
-0.4286234378814697,
0.12921026349067688,
-0.20424161851406097,
0.099210225045681,
0.19244244694709778,
0.37090638279914856,
-0.09608625620603561,
0.7555425763130188,
0.9712035655975342,
-0.4069485664367676,
0.5463674664497375,
0.17936645448207855,
-0.2418343722820282,
0.6807358860969543,
-0.8191328644752502,
-0.3835792541503906,
-0.4705815017223358,
0.19965876638889313,
-1.053579568862915,
-0.32703667879104614,
0.22593660652637482,
-0.570498526096344,
0.10314317047595978,
-0.15833503007888794,
-0.1818789839744568,
-0.6017419695854187,
-0.2166382223367691,
0.3886072635650635,
0.3862818479537964,
-0.7250986099243164,
0.9229040741920471,
0.012318302877247334,
-0.12867997586727142,
-0.8374534845352173,
-0.5590201616287231,
-0.06039443612098694,
-0.2683430016040802,
-0.9359652996063232,
-0.08431385457515717,
-0.15662531554698944,
-0.6294472813606262,
-0.08305526524782181,
-0.03569704294204712,
-0.12582439184188843,
-0.18001443147659302,
0.2529134750366211,
0.376695454120636,
-0.32156795263290405,
0.2214006781578064,
0.23675759136676788,
-0.4312436580657959,
0.4781152009963989,
-0.20492875576019287,
0.21569107472896576,
-0.4094400703907013,
-0.456895649433136,
-0.4354964792728424,
0.4147239029407501,
0.8673962354660034,
-0.6072840094566345,
0.4593256413936615,
0.7760195732116699,
-0.20228168368339539,
-0.2824971675872803,
-0.29140791296958923,
-0.23250308632850647,
-0.40641266107559204,
0.33646607398986816,
-0.5270110368728638,
-0.7104190587997437,
0.20475846529006958,
0.07886835187673569,
-0.012239912524819374,
0.3369576930999756,
0.5732288956642151,
-0.3402567207813263,
1.627052664756775,
0.3965877592563629,
0.6014177799224854,
0.45308101177215576,
-0.3487717807292938,
0.27893608808517456,
-0.5019040703773499,
-0.6283199787139893,
-0.1678331345319748,
-0.07640668749809265,
-0.04978460073471069,
-0.5389700531959534,
0.426817387342453,
0.4026699364185333,
-0.17122706770896912,
0.07926011085510254,
-0.3745819628238678,
0.582165539264679,
0.5820196270942688,
-0.0018633530708029866,
-0.09351568669080734,
0.22201155126094818,
-0.15392166376113892,
-0.34088459610939026,
-0.5069564580917358,
-0.45411038398742676,
1.013651728630066,
0.16132254898548126,
0.8077547550201416,
0.06270580738782883,
0.23944202065467834,
-0.1800563633441925,
0.36588895320892334,
-0.886792778968811,
0.37967565655708313,
-0.07007716596126556,
-0.31397199630737305,
-0.04884687438607216,
-0.49352389574050903,
-0.7104089260101318,
0.6873707175254822,
-0.28319576382637024,
-0.2666522264480591,
-0.12926822900772095,
0.5198630094528198,
-0.30382490158081055,
-0.021802229806780815,
-0.9404663443565369,
0.997944712638855,
-0.6224356889724731,
-0.3885439932346344,
-0.28813445568084717,
-0.6258672475814819,
0.7017862200737,
0.039705611765384674,
0.3900780975818634,
0.10274024307727814,
0.08837472647428513,
0.2330544888973236,
-0.745162844657898,
0.6271349191665649,
-0.2666921019554138,
0.17272599041461945,
0.45071232318878174,
0.02213289774954319,
0.3047081530094147,
0.31090304255485535,
0.4690495431423187,
-0.11410120874643326,
0.05347539484500885,
-0.36729392409324646,
-1.0030930042266846,
0.5016060471534729,
-0.539010763168335,
-0.5608714818954468,
-0.34548041224479675,
-0.580109715461731,
-0.15631656348705292,
0.01268691848963499,
0.2605331838130951,
0.5555769801139832,
0.43969622254371643,
0.39659321308135986,
0.6011521816253662,
0.14834313094615936,
0.5053814053535461,
0.05004047974944115,
-0.30223557353019714,
-0.7198278903961182,
0.7268187999725342,
-0.1692495197057724,
0.25966501235961914,
0.4273744523525238,
0.13437700271606445,
-0.6029780507087708,
-0.2793929874897003,
-0.6407237648963928,
0.14150041341781616,
-0.8861265182495117,
-0.25458285212516785,
-0.6055924892425537,
-0.006726530846208334,
-0.22498109936714172,
-0.25147339701652527,
-0.13258704543113708,
-0.34878334403038025,
-0.4521615505218506,
0.1450071483850479,
0.3273812532424927,
0.42843568325042725,
-0.035547323524951935,
0.21386244893074036,
-0.6362161040306091,
0.5816016793251038,
0.7206129431724548,
-0.04856862127780914,
-0.0688379555940628,
-0.5544765591621399,
-0.17671605944633484,
0.14442330598831177,
-0.47809767723083496,
-0.39463332295417786,
0.49209678173065186,
0.11583161354064941,
0.5016729235649109,
0.715038537979126,
-0.25900799036026,
1.0004712343215942,
-0.46368661522865295,
0.4216577708721161,
0.764912486076355,
-0.9386802911758423,
0.7043144702911377,
-0.18084663152694702,
0.26701590418815613,
0.16284584999084473,
0.22747893631458282,
0.023398922756314278,
-0.04403432458639145,
-0.2921748459339142,
-0.5142644643783569,
0.57395339012146,
0.32020893692970276,
0.043617572635412216,
0.16726186871528625,
0.07901682704687119,
0.07605331391096115,
0.12057314068078995,
-0.6994754076004028,
0.04605720564723015,
-0.5565414428710938,
-0.21969668567180634,
-0.055466748774051666,
-0.2886609137058258,
-0.2110554724931717,
-0.32218992710113525,
0.4763207733631134,
-0.341767281293869,
0.1197025328874588,
0.10234742611646652,
-0.15472280979156494,
-0.1556665152311325,
0.23670047521591187,
0.9836752414703369,
1.271931529045105,
0.10633101314306259,
0.3764335811138153,
-0.10083664953708649,
-0.08457092940807343,
-0.12154913693666458,
0.11500007659196854,
0.14932703971862793,
-0.10355588793754578,
0.710486888885498,
0.9860869646072388,
0.10961843281984329,
-0.992994487285614,
0.7726191878318787,
-0.19009914994239807,
-0.5052573680877686,
-0.3996202349662781,
0.08392217755317688,
0.1335292011499405,
0.6469252705574036,
0.15868958830833435,
0.6565708518028259,
0.008514744229614735,
-0.37170645594596863,
0.1950099617242813,
0.4409390389919281,
-0.2785477638244629,
-0.29517075419425964,
0.9316278100013733,
-0.23032887279987335,
-0.11984223872423172,
0.6142534017562866,
0.07062167674303055,
-0.451175719499588,
0.6792145371437073,
0.4622313380241394,
0.4994893968105316,
0.04250824451446533,
0.3712165057659149,
0.44945985078811646,
0.24067817628383636,
-0.13086414337158203,
0.5655167102813721,
-0.21357235312461853,
-0.3837801516056061,
-0.8453531265258789,
-0.38123688101768494,
-0.2794555723667145,
-0.43352174758911133,
-0.8268147706985474,
0.4472352862358093,
-0.5488094091415405,
-0.10971641540527344,
0.22234125435352325,
-0.7014040946960449,
-0.6962919235229492,
0.36399903893470764,
0.2504592537879944,
0.5914515256881714,
-0.7865608930587769,
0.6446852087974548,
0.7721484899520874,
-0.8026902079582214,
-0.7097563147544861,
-0.5950360298156738,
-0.0618462972342968,
-0.9383385181427002,
1.105595588684082,
0.3320631682872772,
-0.26221802830696106,
-0.2350769191980362,
-0.736193060874939,
-0.7040382623672485,
1.0462428331375122,
0.6404534578323364,
-0.6720015406608582,
0.07410982996225357,
-0.14735868573188782,
0.7782616019248962,
-0.49512478709220886,
0.39269596338272095,
0.13193608820438385,
0.4361947476863861,
0.46637824177742004,
-0.6116926074028015,
-0.3740377724170685,
-0.35006648302078247,
0.09233365207910538,
0.10622826963663101,
-0.51813805103302,
1.0930020809173584,
-0.7477741241455078,
0.06637203693389893,
0.13439418375492096,
0.686560869216919,
0.6451308131217957,
0.6917336583137512,
0.589590311050415,
0.7613356113433838,
0.4684445559978485,
-0.16620780527591705,
1.044708490371704,
0.22921712696552277,
0.1561238169670105,
1.0269964933395386,
0.16171051561832428,
0.9100177884101868,
0.7776950001716614,
-0.09432455897331238,
0.5455291867256165,
0.5922884941101074,
0.12281368672847748,
0.602536141872406,
0.07460831850767136,
-0.14548705518245697,
-0.7295066714286804,
0.05746181681752205,
-0.41878753900527954,
0.5627732872962952,
0.35308459401130676,
-0.5818857550621033,
-0.2607179284095764,
0.36156484484672546,
-0.2421058863401413,
0.12230300158262253,
-0.5822761058807373,
0.4407453238964081,
0.28589320182800293,
-0.8540271520614624,
0.5985041856765747,
-0.20688338577747345,
0.0704759955406189,
-0.5971246957778931,
-0.2919224798679352,
-0.03371855616569519,
0.5093414187431335,
-0.1548948884010315,
-0.6772645711898804,
0.2311018705368042,
-0.04717433452606201,
-0.4433422386646271,
-0.5005118250846863,
0.34897580742836,
-0.45260435342788696,
-0.7783809900283813,
0.20076189935207367,
0.44476422667503357,
0.08974219858646393,
-0.3161498010158539,
-0.822917103767395,
-0.12886275351047516,
0.10885204374790192,
-0.0007191579206846654,
0.040475063025951385,
0.7393423914909363,
-0.4305451810359955,
0.9621269702911377,
0.8790725469589233,
-0.2902369201183319,
0.28159618377685547,
0.426052063703537,
0.8301593661308289,
-0.5932996273040771,
-0.4049280285835266,
-0.9400014877319336,
0.8215463757514954,
0.057045817375183105,
-0.35232290625572205,
0.7384926080703735,
0.3596682548522949,
0.7922273278236389,
-0.4246872365474701,
0.6242868304252625,
0.19076360762119293,
0.244358092546463,
-0.8432806134223938,
0.2916628420352936,
-0.8694850206375122,
0.13336388766765594,
-0.031088512390851974,
-1.1019622087478638,
-0.5948569774627686,
0.7305641770362854,
-0.09669559448957443,
0.03956089913845062,
0.969698965549469,
0.6621028780937195,
-0.14154919981956482,
-0.13104015588760376,
0.43659013509750366,
0.09950407594442368,
0.3990741968154907,
0.5841612219810486,
1.1974308490753174,
-0.21489837765693665,
1.0285006761550903,
-0.2210625261068344,
-0.22278271615505219,
-0.1019846647977829,
-0.7190849184989929,
-1.2087072134017944,
-0.4904349148273468,
-0.20543056726455688,
-0.3085785210132599,
-0.47210678458213806,
0.6584044098854065,
0.8710377812385559,
-0.7558464407920837,
0.11643704771995544,
-0.3587126135826111,
-0.1564731001853943,
-0.2811110019683838,
-0.1880410611629486,
0.23364578187465668,
-0.5471534132957458,
-0.4893842935562134,
0.29326683282852173,
0.513311505317688,
-0.012953011319041252,
-0.4388410449028015,
-0.26302292943000793,
0.31615081429481506,
-0.0992639809846878,
1.0033364295959473,
0.044525399804115295,
-1.285543441772461,
-0.022651752457022667,
0.15965130925178528,
0.040721409022808075,
-0.03568871691823006,
1.0346558094024658,
-0.7222638726234436,
0.9988725781440735,
0.5483528971672058,
0.48182395100593567,
0.5391888618469238,
-0.0174704622477293,
0.42331400513648987,
-0.2977770268917084,
0.1026659905910492,
0.0868830755352974,
0.6719672679901123,
0.27048274874687195,
-0.1355149894952774,
0.36961251497268677,
0.20473308861255646,
-0.26329317688941956,
-0.6880660653114319,
0.22369854152202606,
-1.4458773136138916,
-0.12254611402750015,
0.9632734656333923,
-0.20476134121418,
-0.16789798438549042,
0.02658895216882229,
-0.7764116525650024,
0.0028887565713375807,
-0.15371599793434143,
0.5853075981140137,
0.6246683597564697,
-0.275958389043808,
-0.6882816553115845,
-0.5335638523101807,
0.2887968420982361,
0.48949530720710754,
-0.8877101540565491,
-0.12427299469709396,
0.6971520781517029,
-0.03430461511015892,
0.10773450881242752,
0.1914381980895996,
-0.10815219581127167,
0.5790765285491943,
0.10378768295049667,
-0.11924809962511063,
-0.47456616163253784,
-0.5815555453300476,
-0.061684709042310715,
0.2308044284582138,
-0.060268472880125046,
-0.2462659776210785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14600v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14600v1
|
Planning Ahead in Generative Retrieval: Guiding Autoregressive Generation through Simultaneous Decoding
| 2024-04-22T21:50:01 | 2024-04-22T21:50:01 |
Hansi Zeng, Chen Luo, Hamed Zamani
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
This paper introduces PAG-a novel optimization and decoding approach that
guides autoregressive generation of document identifiers in generative
retrieval models through simultaneous decoding. To this aim, PAG constructs a
set-based and sequential identifier for each document. Motivated by the
bag-of-words assumption in information retrieval, the set-based identifier is
built on lexical tokens. The sequential identifier, on the other hand, is
obtained via quantizing relevance-based representations of documents. Extensive
experiments on MSMARCO and TREC Deep Learning Track data reveal that PAG
outperforms the state-of-the-art generative retrieval model by a large margin
(e.g., 15.6% MRR improvements on MS MARCO), while achieving 22x speed up in
terms of query latency.
|
[
-0.4237501919269562,
-0.5975368618965149,
0.32594606280326843,
0.2686980664730072,
-0.4328782558441162,
0.10900352895259857,
-0.06467188149690628,
0.0992400199174881,
-0.03134084492921829,
0.3815958499908447,
-0.5401284098625183,
-0.5315849781036377,
-0.6383531093597412,
0.1651926338672638,
-0.5391330718994141,
0.6856001019477844,
0.2521435618400574,
-0.06460002064704895,
-0.10184808820486069,
-0.11377665400505066,
-0.45052313804626465,
-0.572178840637207,
-0.8080363869667053,
-0.21963410079479218,
0.3779140114784241,
0.04487046226859093,
0.6694582104682922,
0.9404315948486328,
0.6396554708480835,
0.20176458358764648,
0.01413168665021658,
0.3787088990211487,
-0.43879005312919617,
0.2273549735546112,
0.04809935390949249,
-0.34585025906562805,
-0.24112500250339508,
-0.14417530596256256,
0.6646867394447327,
0.528209388256073,
-0.2761698365211487,
-0.09461507201194763,
0.1083751916885376,
0.7161194682121277,
-0.9788472652435303,
0.3314583897590637,
-0.4310723841190338,
0.34293752908706665,
-0.2670602798461914,
-0.7502105832099915,
-0.5512434244155884,
-0.37160399556159973,
-0.15976741909980774,
-0.7307218909263611,
0.6852840185165405,
-0.006004021968692541,
0.599080502986908,
0.4418331980705261,
-0.49473586678504944,
-0.5968592762947083,
-0.605124294757843,
0.5277906060218811,
-0.42951735854148865,
0.27410444617271423,
0.40006813406944275,
0.1498851478099823,
-0.2585141658782959,
-1.050580620765686,
-0.5534817576408386,
0.12310413271188736,
-0.07861164957284927,
0.39566272497177124,
0.204988494515419,
0.19466033577919006,
0.1522742211818695,
0.9476627111434937,
-0.765256404876709,
-0.19898681342601776,
-0.0490187406539917,
0.04550547152757645,
0.6895358562469482,
0.06970644742250443,
0.025344369933009148,
-0.14450879395008087,
-0.46070268750190735,
-0.3691570460796356,
-0.5249632000923157,
-0.3332906663417816,
0.35452207922935486,
0.1310931295156479,
0.3127756416797638,
0.36754360795021057,
-0.09449690580368042,
0.8221921324729919,
0.2549903988838196,
0.04510950297117233,
0.29728856682777405,
-0.5233663320541382,
-0.21977342665195465,
0.025697167962789536,
0.7925539016723633,
0.11826763302087784,
-0.20882363617420197,
-0.2616715133190155,
-0.37651485204696655,
-0.02748487889766693,
0.4422324299812317,
-0.546961784362793,
-0.38466399908065796,
-0.08878131955862045,
-0.8570786714553833,
-0.3819563388824463,
0.2537463307380676,
-0.9851878881454468,
-0.1282740980386734,
-0.23266121745109558,
0.585654616355896,
-0.5123664140701294,
-0.2959718704223633,
0.3235486149787903,
-0.19185921549797058,
0.381555438041687,
0.11268726736307144,
-0.8996644020080566,
-0.01266963966190815,
0.6738162040710449,
0.8391534686088562,
-0.007403380237519741,
-0.013651701621711254,
-0.6422775387763977,
0.23134444653987885,
-0.5479170680046082,
0.8188738226890564,
-0.628949761390686,
-1.0835264921188354,
0.10180944204330444,
-0.06581953912973404,
-0.052711572498083115,
-0.4046716094017029,
0.7135021090507507,
-0.850749671459198,
0.18458455801010132,
-0.5518689751625061,
-0.5451041460037231,
-0.01810006983578205,
-0.008507054299116135,
-0.7725152969360352,
1.0625938177108765,
-0.010064566507935524,
-0.7667708992958069,
0.5820196866989136,
-0.4963236451148987,
-0.6353631019592285,
0.2844472825527191,
-0.30522966384887695,
-0.3454481065273285,
0.35487818717956543,
0.26481392979621887,
0.21823127567768097,
-0.24158239364624023,
0.36728447675704956,
-0.030928734689950943,
-0.3180544972419739,
-0.39294761419296265,
-0.3657680153846741,
0.6829180121421814,
0.6592196822166443,
-0.03302354738116264,
-0.22070834040641785,
-0.9173434972763062,
0.15165111422538757,
0.18584084510803223,
-0.673542857170105,
-0.22590909898281097,
0.29156023263931274,
-0.289640337228775,
0.05086897686123848,
0.30356699228286743,
-0.06327023357152939,
0.5117756128311157,
-0.1453433483839035,
0.03697676956653595,
0.676443338394165,
0.20454023778438568,
0.5554878115653992,
-0.3429507315158844,
0.7678333520889282,
-0.2878471612930298,
0.025604816153645515,
-0.8082743287086487,
-0.24848400056362152,
-0.8012245893478394,
0.056566450744867325,
0.40413638949394226,
0.3723071813583374,
-0.7705685496330261,
0.6939449906349182,
-0.21929316222667694,
-0.14219056069850922,
-0.40776777267456055,
-0.17850475013256073,
0.6039372682571411,
0.35497042536735535,
0.31548282504081726,
-0.4110632538795471,
-0.4662380814552307,
-0.6946744322776794,
-0.2188696265220642,
-0.1223207637667656,
0.048072945326566696,
0.1325964480638504,
0.27284565567970276,
0.22986772656440735,
0.4031945765018463,
-0.6182800531387329,
-0.21284988522529602,
0.09511306881904602,
0.682406485080719,
0.0704224705696106,
0.45633241534233093,
0.3143020570278168,
-1.306227445602417,
-0.5406284332275391,
-0.1954205483198166,
-0.8826919198036194,
-0.0054388102144002914,
-0.15463151037693024,
-0.21287880837917328,
0.07810623943805695,
0.785228967666626,
-0.3719116747379303,
0.4657447934150696,
0.28100407123565674,
-0.195615753531456,
0.31375959515571594,
-0.5625160932540894,
0.24802519381046295,
-1.0109857320785522,
0.12743589282035828,
-0.24278800189495087,
0.17046710848808289,
-0.19274236261844635,
0.2429254949092865,
0.18527419865131378,
-0.24175214767456055,
0.10769377648830414,
0.32640784978866577,
-0.9694967269897461,
-0.15553471446037292,
-0.2966194152832031,
-0.14592452347278595,
0.2058102786540985,
0.32932063937187195,
-0.02829553931951523,
1.1698548793792725,
0.4963953495025635,
-0.7375664114952087,
0.2140468806028366,
0.3307618796825409,
-0.22633406519889832,
0.3903147876262665,
-0.38443875312805176,
0.2765950560569763,
-0.5602115988731384,
0.21895915269851685,
-0.805477499961853,
-0.03505851700901985,
-0.024265168234705925,
-0.6095048189163208,
0.6529462933540344,
-0.34168383479118347,
-0.9810020923614502,
-0.5305853486061096,
0.07021728157997131,
0.5000789761543274,
0.488768607378006,
-0.7835426330566406,
0.7246541976928711,
0.2912823259830475,
-0.021472109481692314,
-0.6831409335136414,
-0.46491578221321106,
0.033252961933612823,
-0.061630576848983765,
-0.5017784833908081,
0.7167529463768005,
-0.08346902579069138,
-0.07400892674922943,
-0.010617631487548351,
-0.16329814493656158,
0.3138850927352905,
-0.2842513620853424,
-0.15645946562290192,
-0.03571721538901329,
-0.052220169454813004,
0.5440834164619446,
-0.16650941967964172,
-0.33757779002189636,
-0.05759124085307121,
-0.6307806372642517,
0.6980469822883606,
0.12423396110534668,
-0.26427581906318665,
0.06241525337100029,
0.8978534936904907,
0.3017309606075287,
-0.7581777572631836,
0.6206478476524353,
0.6682482957839966,
-0.21275033056735992,
-0.2973291575908661,
-0.5090321898460388,
0.058875564485788345,
-0.5430592894554138,
0.153697669506073,
-0.9182351231575012,
-0.28562456369400024,
0.6233916878700256,
0.05639852210879326,
-0.21145203709602356,
0.5085562467575073,
0.41702577471733093,
0.12450935691595078,
1.0061368942260742,
0.7283056974411011,
0.11432676017284393,
0.4574649930000305,
-0.5501314997673035,
0.2532539367675781,
-0.7192609906196594,
-0.5738734602928162,
-0.5414599180221558,
0.015858884900808334,
-0.6462364196777344,
-0.4622598886489868,
0.3283647298812866,
0.5037563443183899,
0.10713402926921844,
0.20359019935131073,
-0.8177611827850342,
0.4533914625644684,
0.8671474456787109,
0.001545380218885839,
0.2939154803752899,
-0.146201953291893,
-0.35595056414604187,
0.1755359023809433,
-0.8630480170249939,
-0.22309286892414093,
1.2603480815887451,
-0.2806432843208313,
0.7168659567832947,
-0.00922192819416523,
0.935282826423645,
0.42104414105415344,
-0.09714388847351074,
-0.5525764226913452,
0.42624714970588684,
-0.552349328994751,
-0.47443196177482605,
0.09299048781394958,
-0.1839539259672165,
-1.0698864459991455,
0.3826586604118347,
0.1171078011393547,
-0.36236950755119324,
0.5634194016456604,
0.14804302155971527,
-0.20166020095348358,
0.18685099482536316,
-0.5624338388442993,
0.7286742329597473,
-0.372516930103302,
-0.20339235663414001,
-0.24132630228996277,
-0.5973137617111206,
0.08640199899673462,
0.009830363094806671,
-0.12345132976770401,
0.18182314932346344,
-0.20885758101940155,
0.6186754703521729,
-0.32926109433174133,
0.149812251329422,
-0.21160763502120972,
0.001117050414904952,
0.40226930379867554,
-0.020097792148590088,
0.7581934928894043,
-0.022324535995721817,
-0.3022913634777069,
-0.29728686809539795,
-0.22122128307819366,
-0.5157681107521057,
-0.5434951186180115,
0.7756608128547668,
-0.33339834213256836,
-0.5855695009231567,
-0.5258694291114807,
-0.28395432233810425,
0.00918224360793829,
0.35694998502731323,
0.8270149827003479,
0.48425954580307007,
-0.14554911851882935,
0.1492268443107605,
1.0919420719146729,
-0.33862972259521484,
0.7353476881980896,
0.32507941126823425,
0.12030740827322006,
-0.3842913508415222,
0.6908240914344788,
0.04542059823870659,
0.047544654458761215,
0.7406671047210693,
-0.047066580504179,
-0.44893455505371094,
-0.7038437128067017,
-0.036893852055072784,
0.12429635971784592,
-0.8738092184066772,
-0.39216306805610657,
-0.8145363330841064,
-0.16425232589244843,
-0.5614362955093384,
-0.03795449435710907,
-0.18502286076545715,
-0.0061049992218613625,
-0.5268951654434204,
0.10180342942476273,
-0.020090820267796516,
0.5173806548118591,
-0.12524539232254028,
0.46151211857795715,
-0.719169020652771,
0.5403059124946594,
0.11771955341100693,
0.37695053219795227,
0.04402276873588562,
-0.22179673612117767,
-0.19305536150932312,
-0.34904372692108154,
-0.2546977698802948,
-1.022245168685913,
0.5754444599151611,
0.18888753652572632,
0.7663426995277405,
0.49044138193130493,
0.2939990758895874,
0.6287950277328491,
-0.30196815729141235,
0.4059083163738251,
0.018361469730734825,
-0.5304481387138367,
0.8838977813720703,
-0.5537618398666382,
0.5200744271278381,
0.531201958656311,
0.44103020429611206,
-0.3259515166282654,
0.0638199895620346,
-0.7792229652404785,
-1.0451991558074951,
0.6566019058227539,
0.09627726674079895,
-0.10381821542978287,
-0.42709147930145264,
0.2978774607181549,
0.15250340104103088,
0.33223482966423035,
-0.4527788460254669,
-0.24454334378242493,
-0.21379418671131134,
0.03699697554111481,
-0.011420237831771374,
-0.5962286591529846,
-0.08211153000593185,
0.18735143542289734,
0.6579835414886475,
-0.18296204507350922,
0.7495433688163757,
0.21094249188899994,
0.054577071219682693,
0.13014084100723267,
0.05540091544389725,
0.22733403742313385,
0.4658994674682617,
-0.34790560603141785,
-0.23670172691345215,
-0.37124648690223694,
-0.2208993136882782,
0.0004271725774742663,
0.47753244638442993,
-0.06719698756933212,
0.16210275888442993,
0.23018237948417664,
0.6440619826316833,
-0.2643181383609772,
-0.20882627367973328,
0.5381237268447876,
-0.06953516602516174,
-0.15625295042991638,
-0.7819992899894714,
0.01964927464723587,
-0.3744327127933502,
0.15476591885089874,
0.8543334007263184,
-0.13218076527118683,
0.4070248603820801,
-0.32861828804016113,
0.25746846199035645,
0.45553940534591675,
0.19349360466003418,
0.01642877236008644,
0.7656247615814209,
0.196629136800766,
-0.41869261860847473,
0.6866407990455627,
-0.47976288199424744,
-0.21647371351718903,
0.690402090549469,
0.5147368311882019,
1.1009565591812134,
-0.04827582836151123,
-0.08984804898500443,
0.5763545036315918,
0.0040754457004368305,
-0.289554625749588,
0.42666521668434143,
-0.6293683648109436,
-0.5010866522789001,
-0.2645580470561981,
-0.8716079592704773,
0.3100144565105438,
0.21610306203365326,
-0.8663476705551147,
0.17270615696907043,
-0.28512176871299744,
-0.25681960582733154,
0.009581626392900944,
0.13985253870487213,
-0.6694180965423584,
0.32080817222595215,
-0.08262582123279572,
0.9511162042617798,
-0.3813721239566803,
0.9332507252693176,
0.362669974565506,
-0.6861120462417603,
-0.42680373787879944,
0.34860992431640625,
0.03919323906302452,
-0.7420167326927185,
0.6824893951416016,
0.05234929546713829,
-0.07542344927787781,
0.2352840006351471,
-0.05448871850967407,
-1.0191140174865723,
1.2279402017593384,
-0.07797501981258392,
-0.7084079384803772,
-0.6012007594108582,
-0.35956045985221863,
0.4576760232448578,
-0.32367244362831116,
-0.07019579410552979,
0.26944097876548767,
0.45749160647392273,
0.19212722778320312,
-0.6937658786773682,
-0.22094087302684784,
-0.45306670665740967,
0.386369526386261,
0.6200985312461853,
-0.7985988855361938,
0.650336742401123,
-0.17452003061771393,
-0.7233900427818298,
0.3015795648097992,
0.5481598973274231,
-0.06888195127248764,
0.2875572144985199,
0.2110123485326767,
0.9480287432670593,
0.5599563717842102,
-0.3414386808872223,
1.4052190780639648,
-0.48547765612602234,
0.18585604429244995,
1.1817446947097778,
0.3139525353908539,
0.6063116788864136,
0.32855433225631714,
-0.26976656913757324,
0.10983908921480179,
0.6342939138412476,
-0.17336039245128632,
1.0080100297927856,
0.019572395831346512,
-0.9264267683029175,
-0.020902760326862335,
0.16159825026988983,
-0.5580779910087585,
0.29638049006462097,
0.5232051610946655,
-0.9429404735565186,
-0.29239463806152344,
0.09039066731929779,
-0.20584389567375183,
0.23789100348949432,
-0.2517968714237213,
0.9330276846885681,
-0.17798438668251038,
-1.0976760387420654,
0.6650837659835815,
0.16515788435935974,
0.5935234427452087,
-0.5237169861793518,
-0.04685080796480179,
-0.41147688031196594,
0.3554195761680603,
0.06539274752140045,
-0.5315266251564026,
0.2457086592912674,
-0.6319133639335632,
-0.28320610523223877,
-0.48331886529922485,
0.7044051885604858,
-0.4678930342197418,
-0.39683398604393005,
0.33001208305358887,
0.2280399650335312,
-0.10123951733112335,
-0.03308349475264549,
-0.5942050218582153,
0.0022094394080340862,
0.04561162739992142,
-0.09224911034107208,
0.18923956155776978,
0.6083494424819946,
0.1521124690771103,
0.6343013048171997,
0.6560298800468445,
0.04831758141517639,
0.40634268522262573,
0.15823088586330414,
0.6887195706367493,
-0.6675622463226318,
-0.7006272077560425,
-0.48387014865875244,
0.2913306951522827,
0.0483081191778183,
-0.1448737531900406,
0.5126065611839294,
0.634944498538971,
1.0004167556762695,
-0.07939571142196655,
0.8329504132270813,
-0.23595233261585236,
0.23492464423179626,
-0.67090904712677,
0.32408276200294495,
-0.5547158718109131,
0.3545079529285431,
0.14476338028907776,
-0.8199878334999084,
-0.1926991045475006,
0.5472865700721741,
-0.10977679491043091,
0.17746753990650177,
0.6739253997802734,
0.9103552103042603,
0.10277292877435684,
-0.18291343748569489,
0.2441362738609314,
-0.28440460562705994,
0.3160158693790436,
0.5672451257705688,
0.5041746497154236,
-0.7188283205032349,
0.7580612301826477,
-0.219833642244339,
-0.08887708187103271,
-0.21320904791355133,
-0.7037765383720398,
-0.5602525472640991,
-0.9545280337333679,
-0.2023652344942093,
-0.39160752296447754,
0.5503191351890564,
0.20120161771774292,
0.8038063049316406,
-0.41377153992652893,
0.10838647186756134,
-0.6636204719543457,
-0.2868638336658478,
-0.04252959042787552,
-0.3112764358520508,
0.4936267137527466,
-0.8309544324874878,
-0.7946733832359314,
0.3948816955089569,
0.2948172092437744,
0.198403462767601,
-0.20262309908866882,
-0.16812197864055634,
-0.4520147144794464,
-0.17548738420009613,
0.364061564207077,
0.42140719294548035,
-0.6323971152305603,
0.23700566589832306,
-0.21539828181266785,
-0.035869814455509186,
0.2363819032907486,
1.1710578203201294,
-1.0755350589752197,
0.9151253700256348,
0.7743163108825684,
0.5587214827537537,
0.9550853371620178,
0.2619752883911133,
0.8848193883895874,
-0.8473184108734131,
0.2365761250257492,
0.38184359669685364,
0.2108609527349472,
0.15838676691055298,
-0.5405358076095581,
0.5904726386070251,
0.17535211145877838,
-0.6823391318321228,
-0.5077698230743408,
0.24670623242855072,
-0.7052406072616577,
-0.2686171233654022,
0.9350096583366394,
-0.16607819497585297,
-0.008584857918322086,
0.2603258490562439,
0.17306888103485107,
0.38354435563087463,
-0.4179133176803589,
0.8533115386962891,
0.6596319675445557,
-0.12348198145627975,
-0.4831642508506775,
-0.26480939984321594,
0.5341547727584839,
0.28621870279312134,
-0.5072977542877197,
-0.10154427587985992,
0.6761430501937866,
-0.17570604383945465,
0.2956707179546356,
0.9053148031234741,
-0.55998694896698,
0.29766276478767395,
0.5090793967247009,
-0.23049435019493103,
-0.09366173297166824,
-0.33850663900375366,
-0.34384992718696594,
0.4180775284767151,
0.041892312467098236,
-0.5629725456237793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14567v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14567v1
|
WangLab at MEDIQA-M3G 2024: Multimodal Medical Answer Generation using Large Language Models
| 2024-04-22T20:29:58 | 2024-04-22T20:29:58 |
Ronald Xie, Steven Palayew, Augustin Toma, Gary Bader, Bo Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper outlines our submission to the MEDIQA2024 Multilingual and
Multimodal Medical Answer Generation (M3G) shared task. We report results for
two standalone solutions under the English category of the task, the first
involving two consecutive API calls to the Claude 3 Opus API and the second
involving training an image-disease label joint embedding in the style of CLIP
for image classification. These two solutions scored 1st and 2nd place
respectively on the competition leaderboard, substantially outperforming the
next best solution. Additionally, we discuss insights gained from
post-competition experiments. While the performance of these two solutions have
significant room for improvement due to the difficulty of the shared task and
the challenging nature of medical visual question answering in general, we
identify the multi-stage LLM approach and the CLIP image classification
approach as promising avenues for further investigation.
|
[
-0.500215470790863,
-0.7402576804161072,
0.9215421080589294,
0.24070167541503906,
-0.2783496677875519,
0.11530929803848267,
0.08500989526510239,
-0.6163671016693115,
0.2457648515701294,
0.42499592900276184,
-0.9113860130310059,
-0.4224880337715149,
-0.7776515483856201,
0.4005358815193176,
0.09317749738693237,
0.8208272457122803,
-0.27064287662506104,
0.6535109877586365,
-0.6523559093475342,
-0.5813463926315308,
-0.692704439163208,
-0.5218441486358643,
-0.8071878552436829,
-0.1681787073612213,
1.045573353767395,
0.5549610257148743,
0.5046154260635376,
0.4511229991912842,
0.7180569171905518,
0.2515828311443329,
0.22252267599105835,
0.4209599792957306,
-0.06896990537643433,
0.07870667427778244,
0.03007717989385128,
-0.43282848596572876,
-0.5416795015335083,
0.053927674889564514,
0.18194173276424408,
0.6799723505973816,
0.01751725748181343,
0.30768465995788574,
-0.1737387776374817,
0.4635763466358185,
-0.22455254197120667,
0.08303205668926239,
-0.37222611904144287,
0.22136349976062775,
-0.14400430023670197,
-0.44730809330940247,
-0.41579779982566833,
-0.07633014768362045,
0.01837160624563694,
-0.5757975578308105,
-0.01440158300101757,
0.08675087988376617,
0.7168585062026978,
0.27800652384757996,
-0.6636477112770081,
-0.48459699749946594,
-0.3026668131351471,
0.7657322287559509,
-0.5766503810882568,
0.0456303246319294,
0.22321198880672455,
0.20929542183876038,
-0.03903094306588173,
-0.8652674555778503,
-0.4963771402835846,
0.17834770679473877,
0.16787433624267578,
0.4072229862213135,
-0.18132732808589935,
-0.1353001892566681,
-0.09665451943874359,
0.12860681116580963,
-0.7143723368644714,
0.20035745203495026,
-0.6826786398887634,
-0.1963285356760025,
0.6706324219703674,
0.35309651494026184,
0.4155867099761963,
-0.15587688982486725,
-0.4773801565170288,
0.10822861641645432,
-0.8069223761558533,
-0.061513014137744904,
-0.19900958240032196,
-0.20455728471279144,
-0.10115683823823929,
0.5946182608604431,
0.013599392026662827,
0.6141254901885986,
-0.092611163854599,
-0.2908516228199005,
0.5821933746337891,
-0.2396703064441681,
0.11706408858299255,
-0.32980233430862427,
1.1207276582717896,
0.7079272866249084,
-0.1799410730600357,
0.08635580539703369,
0.012577715329825878,
-0.4432910680770874,
0.030935103073716164,
-1.0073950290679932,
-0.10014711320400238,
0.6016706228256226,
-0.6221293807029724,
-0.22860045731067657,
-0.3448663353919983,
-0.6598343849182129,
-0.4298345148563385,
-0.1932322382926941,
0.647697925567627,
-0.3055603504180908,
0.01936805434525013,
0.07465115189552307,
0.08088427037000656,
0.21461597084999084,
0.4768266975879669,
-0.7104408144950867,
0.02175648882985115,
0.4285631477832794,
0.7405295372009277,
-0.4615199863910675,
-0.2521253228187561,
-0.639305055141449,
0.20507264137268066,
-0.22582805156707764,
0.8509976267814636,
-0.025208845734596252,
-0.37811949849128723,
-0.19929587841033936,
0.2757609486579895,
-0.11246879398822784,
-0.8043891787528992,
0.3919111490249634,
-0.4386786222457886,
0.5172786116600037,
-0.2346772700548172,
-0.4889609217643738,
-0.18712806701660156,
0.40734782814979553,
-0.6834173202514648,
0.5147534012794495,
-0.13044896721839905,
-0.73502117395401,
0.17075811326503754,
-0.8906934261322021,
-0.11980383098125458,
0.30925101041793823,
-0.5214829444885254,
-0.6319268345832825,
-0.1719418317079544,
0.677232563495636,
0.7616096138954163,
-0.45471927523612976,
0.31788188219070435,
-0.3811693489551544,
-0.05554114654660225,
0.6380459666252136,
-0.34159398078918457,
0.5434322953224182,
0.17046815156936646,
-0.09609552472829819,
0.44755491614341736,
-0.654994785785675,
0.15683716535568237,
0.4522784352302551,
-0.313337117433548,
0.18696777522563934,
-0.2433917224407196,
0.021519886329770088,
0.3413101136684418,
0.2663723826408386,
-0.7642141580581665,
0.1684321016073227,
0.2013649046421051,
0.2668173909187317,
0.6808701157569885,
0.2040933072566986,
-0.11291170865297318,
-0.5586557388305664,
0.730190098285675,
0.14319001138210297,
0.2771458923816681,
-0.15052476525306702,
-1.0852086544036865,
-0.4748195707798004,
-0.5203527212142944,
0.29542744159698486,
0.7356405258178711,
-0.9786123037338257,
-0.38251709938049316,
-0.027156027033925056,
-0.31676506996154785,
-0.769157886505127,
0.18905200064182281,
0.3917313516139984,
0.451616495847702,
0.5009635090827942,
-0.25981467962265015,
-0.5111448168754578,
-1.213624358177185,
0.2569017708301544,
-0.04353110492229462,
-0.11752032488584518,
0.783454418182373,
0.45538753271102905,
-0.4713081121444702,
0.21782219409942627,
-0.8347270488739014,
-0.31782615184783936,
-0.32941919565200806,
0.4410226047039032,
0.40710800886154175,
0.2706529498100281,
0.5148234963417053,
-0.9268445372581482,
-0.4330122768878937,
0.012761445716023445,
-0.8845362663269043,
-0.15650273859500885,
0.10028525441884995,
-0.020653145387768745,
0.12307020276784897,
0.5948348045349121,
-0.3993992209434509,
-0.006186069454997778,
0.7825185060501099,
0.024508532136678696,
0.5400782823562622,
-0.25152331590652466,
0.5947168469429016,
-1.484894871711731,
-0.019749276340007782,
-0.28728345036506653,
-0.3730996251106262,
-0.5445016622543335,
0.10633550584316254,
-0.005040007643401623,
-0.42125722765922546,
-0.7357236742973328,
0.5191601514816284,
-0.2694249153137207,
0.26565104722976685,
-0.2621844708919525,
0.032584451138973236,
-0.004566286690533161,
0.682007372379303,
-0.10733217000961304,
0.8092522025108337,
0.5173116326332092,
-0.40556395053863525,
0.7421552538871765,
0.285900354385376,
-0.11038806289434433,
0.4239600896835327,
-0.7881308794021606,
0.33260655403137207,
-0.15817604959011078,
-0.02350703813135624,
-1.0913463830947876,
-0.6231204271316528,
0.24033401906490326,
-0.6146336197853088,
0.34720903635025024,
0.05622643977403641,
-0.4471968710422516,
-0.6554533243179321,
-0.3253631293773651,
0.7874428629875183,
0.3906975984573364,
-0.4510315954685211,
0.26292678713798523,
0.5260460376739502,
-0.43112173676490784,
-0.42227059602737427,
-0.6808161735534668,
0.012463593855500221,
-0.2470189481973648,
-0.8179540634155273,
0.1401224583387375,
-0.30986547470092773,
0.11531280726194382,
-0.023337362334132195,
0.27820277214050293,
-0.2675536274909973,
-0.1514492779970169,
0.16245655715465546,
0.30865874886512756,
-0.2857838273048401,
0.1972205638885498,
-0.1886422038078308,
-0.005503229796886444,
0.09313278645277023,
0.08467883616685867,
0.46810394525527954,
-0.048942625522613525,
-0.5820320844650269,
-0.3960431218147278,
0.9444625973701477,
0.6432396769523621,
-0.23181703686714172,
0.6885262131690979,
0.6780509352684021,
-0.15093804895877838,
0.1837562471628189,
-0.21139311790466309,
0.1430540233850479,
-0.4491710364818573,
0.5365448594093323,
-0.3129533529281616,
-0.9024896621704102,
0.4708726406097412,
-0.018449563533067703,
0.06074877083301544,
0.21237829327583313,
1.0783226490020752,
-0.42484909296035767,
1.3504762649536133,
0.48910951614379883,
0.36546698212623596,
-0.030354052782058716,
-0.05986466631293297,
0.10158807039260864,
-0.719063401222229,
-0.471164733171463,
-0.04362594336271286,
-0.3496776521205902,
-0.44970279932022095,
-0.7624940872192383,
1.0350587368011475,
0.01132491696625948,
0.3105252981185913,
-0.05174083635210991,
-0.36534127593040466,
0.17237435281276703,
0.5398997664451599,
0.3485023081302643,
0.09041019529104233,
-0.2960967421531677,
-0.25635644793510437,
-0.20122037827968597,
-0.8606682419776917,
-0.1019083708524704,
1.2272751331329346,
0.27408215403556824,
0.5780532360076904,
0.2579233646392822,
0.6192598938941956,
0.029080133885145187,
0.4876747131347656,
-0.8134267330169678,
0.5559367537498474,
-0.1218864843249321,
-0.589354395866394,
-0.08817637711763382,
-0.14539510011672974,
-1.0834510326385498,
0.38922131061553955,
-0.20258726179599762,
-0.47557127475738525,
-0.3307363986968994,
0.10422144830226898,
-0.29136160016059875,
0.07345395535230637,
-0.5690248012542725,
0.8714736700057983,
-0.18793831765651703,
-0.3676133155822754,
0.02094820886850357,
-0.6942094564437866,
0.6218093037605286,
-0.12625554203987122,
0.390705406665802,
-0.14744557440280914,
0.02824697270989418,
0.8008939027786255,
-0.35254257917404175,
0.46669548749923706,
-0.08218294382095337,
-0.11477823555469513,
0.2969103753566742,
-0.40450772643089294,
-0.035247232764959335,
0.1960650086402893,
0.3522495627403259,
-0.25025543570518494,
0.17426784336566925,
-0.5450334548950195,
-0.5839983820915222,
0.4656901955604553,
-0.5873557329177856,
-0.6720194220542908,
-0.2496243566274643,
-0.8369557857513428,
-0.5009844303131104,
0.1732926219701767,
0.4185725748538971,
0.9687374830245972,
0.18719056248664856,
0.326726496219635,
0.8226560354232788,
-0.6978393793106079,
0.2649182379245758,
0.3332265615463257,
-0.6628677248954773,
-0.5980815291404724,
0.7992748618125916,
-0.12035927176475525,
0.2945150136947632,
0.3126033842563629,
0.3658103048801422,
-0.25792157649993896,
-0.653465747833252,
-0.8962962627410889,
0.4487481713294983,
-0.7688066363334656,
-0.32240062952041626,
-0.6936373114585876,
-0.32311582565307617,
-0.28927603363990784,
0.09703525900840759,
-0.1840151995420456,
-0.2556540369987488,
-0.09499698877334595,
0.13017624616622925,
0.22900721430778503,
0.8014782667160034,
-0.1633204072713852,
-0.18152302503585815,
-1.2080283164978027,
0.603003203868866,
0.47099193930625916,
0.19312654435634613,
-0.2935832142829895,
-0.11186172813177109,
-0.26334714889526367,
-0.08500172942876816,
-0.5172578692436218,
-0.9867497682571411,
0.15724729001522064,
0.10723374783992767,
0.5336886048316956,
0.1744953840970993,
-0.21351955831050873,
0.6645554304122925,
-0.8703359365463257,
0.8344045877456665,
0.49707144498825073,
-0.32498979568481445,
0.5314612984657288,
-0.4145994782447815,
0.5220405459403992,
0.35723841190338135,
0.6816667914390564,
-0.5698495507240295,
-0.6327416300773621,
-0.1892278790473938,
-0.8225088119506836,
0.30149367451667786,
-0.05349678918719292,
0.10881208628416061,
-0.0945681631565094,
-0.08990338444709778,
0.22816888988018036,
0.08145170658826828,
-0.8122813105583191,
-0.41275060176849365,
0.2244347482919693,
-0.2966037392616272,
0.24380946159362793,
-0.30655646324157715,
-0.5348600149154663,
-0.22202111780643463,
0.5304032564163208,
-0.28350934386253357,
0.5192378759384155,
0.3002668023109436,
0.09520844370126724,
0.12543059885501862,
0.3604917824268341,
0.7851361036300659,
0.7461532354354858,
-0.08369874209165573,
-0.05498718097805977,
-0.0037189589347690344,
-0.43693846464157104,
0.21788696944713593,
-0.012424814514815807,
-0.04673507809638977,
0.06024278327822685,
0.4849105775356293,
0.6773146986961365,
-0.08864640444517136,
-0.9938341379165649,
0.8600290417671204,
-0.22725455462932587,
-0.7667719125747681,
-0.2015547901391983,
-0.40000179409980774,
0.31532391905784607,
0.18880343437194824,
0.4227360785007477,
-0.002909504109993577,
0.37731462717056274,
-0.46693316102027893,
0.47355741262435913,
0.4223381280899048,
-0.4640931487083435,
-0.18910931050777435,
0.8226344585418701,
0.1401212364435196,
0.02010921761393547,
0.09276249259710312,
-0.3696439266204834,
-0.6301983594894409,
0.5104659795761108,
0.6413090229034424,
0.45406362414360046,
-0.04485306888818741,
0.2883472144603729,
0.2737748622894287,
-0.15165932476520538,
0.2538220286369324,
0.5467953681945801,
0.30277955532073975,
-0.5441874861717224,
-0.7227119207382202,
-0.18755672872066498,
-0.5223233699798584,
0.39406296610832214,
-0.6893002390861511,
0.22120390832424164,
-0.2140302062034607,
-0.024756111204624176,
0.0571122020483017,
-0.2885741889476776,
-0.4020085632801056,
0.2045375108718872,
0.41544103622436523,
0.5069371461868286,
-0.4682346284389496,
0.6415472030639648,
0.8431983590126038,
-0.34761521220207214,
-0.98761385679245,
-0.17631129920482635,
0.0975525826215744,
-0.8280759453773499,
0.585685670375824,
0.2697781026363373,
-0.1676507145166397,
-0.36901435256004333,
-0.7196112871170044,
-0.6659696698188782,
1.1075005531311035,
0.07726522535085678,
-0.004262693226337433,
0.1909104436635971,
0.0018159071914851665,
0.37192538380622864,
-0.2164943516254425,
-0.0013929401757195592,
0.08619029074907303,
0.059112560003995895,
0.4227927029132843,
-1.0803972482681274,
-0.07371468096971512,
-0.45883622765541077,
-0.35818952322006226,
-0.011407160200178623,
-0.773033618927002,
0.7750059366226196,
-0.49316394329071045,
-0.15500648319721222,
0.5939732789993286,
0.532954752445221,
0.5180575251579285,
0.3456796407699585,
0.1521616280078888,
0.5565553903579712,
0.6460469961166382,
-0.04938172176480293,
1.1959586143493652,
-0.17218582332134247,
0.16041922569274902,
0.9199679493904114,
-0.1575959026813507,
0.8702508807182312,
0.6259303092956543,
-0.24590155482292175,
0.3381880819797516,
0.5718279480934143,
0.01151945162564516,
0.6538437008857727,
0.21797524392604828,
-0.46283191442489624,
-0.12331085652112961,
-0.18176917731761932,
-0.4937443137168884,
0.4500763416290283,
0.1775246113538742,
-0.0779080018401146,
0.012551900930702686,
0.47383177280426025,
0.08490008860826492,
-0.03441230207681656,
-0.46849220991134644,
0.7121910452842712,
0.12403834611177444,
-0.5990308523178101,
0.6106016039848328,
0.09306205064058304,
0.6240329146385193,
-0.4181345999240875,
-0.1545768827199936,
-0.2801065146923065,
0.20577794313430786,
-0.02432115003466606,
-0.9182524681091309,
0.23683980107307434,
-0.11493512243032455,
-0.18437673151493073,
-0.17555879056453705,
0.35493823885917664,
-0.5700864791870117,
-0.7176383137702942,
0.18120168149471283,
0.6705093383789062,
0.18804480135440826,
0.47087621688842773,
-0.6717543601989746,
-0.14939643442630768,
-0.06052899733185768,
-0.019750921055674553,
0.2507317066192627,
0.5586121082305908,
-0.028992408886551857,
0.8877151608467102,
0.3843289613723755,
-0.011795969679951668,
0.3806627690792084,
0.07558537274599075,
0.6590532660484314,
-0.3032180070877075,
-0.15315788984298706,
-0.5437126755714417,
0.3820573091506958,
-0.08368177711963654,
-0.2012695074081421,
0.6743504405021667,
0.6278059482574463,
0.5853796601295471,
-0.39849188923835754,
0.5967293977737427,
0.009530328214168549,
0.8312954306602478,
-0.7476183772087097,
0.6014580130577087,
-0.952587366104126,
-0.08585698157548904,
-0.2454908788204193,
-0.3121250569820404,
-0.7070549726486206,
0.023996084928512573,
0.03547786548733711,
-0.2971194386482239,
0.9982866048812866,
0.7348131537437439,
0.1484852284193039,
-0.2574484646320343,
0.46210139989852905,
-0.09320379048585892,
0.35249951481819153,
1.088067650794983,
0.9662994742393494,
-0.4681958556175232,
0.662580132484436,
-0.1219668984413147,
-0.13103200495243073,
-0.11602061986923218,
-0.45908239483833313,
-0.7576128840446472,
-0.6160624623298645,
-0.275817334651947,
-0.2970229387283325,
-0.29303306341171265,
0.828056275844574,
0.6359126567840576,
-0.90472811460495,
-0.028157353401184082,
0.49227362871170044,
-0.028262119740247726,
-0.039604976773262024,
-0.15855926275253296,
0.33069345355033875,
-0.16535036265850067,
-0.7530789375305176,
0.2937670052051544,
0.43486201763153076,
0.02524985745549202,
-0.0388421006500721,
0.035790104418992996,
-0.25578489899635315,
-0.11264701932668686,
0.5623577833175659,
0.17050203680992126,
-0.6054142117500305,
-0.24569480121135712,
0.21335873007774353,
-0.2898710370063782,
0.3979220390319824,
0.9254304766654968,
-0.4073500335216522,
0.3297905921936035,
0.2573745548725128,
0.9769852161407471,
0.46010643243789673,
0.10320765525102615,
0.6028885841369629,
-0.691742479801178,
0.14982715249061584,
0.23697343468666077,
0.502465009689331,
0.40459752082824707,
-0.16705648601055145,
0.3113825023174286,
0.20768846571445465,
-0.653313159942627,
-0.5655944347381592,
0.45385539531707764,
-1.1266496181488037,
-0.4697643518447876,
1.0501326322555542,
-0.24404029548168182,
-0.19762566685676575,
-0.19669461250305176,
-0.5499938130378723,
0.040835872292518616,
0.18389002978801727,
0.4409944713115692,
0.7811823487281799,
-0.603598952293396,
-0.560575544834137,
-0.706494927406311,
0.30527564883232117,
0.48505541682243347,
-1.0949286222457886,
-0.5296472311019897,
0.47648173570632935,
0.2994421720504761,
0.2293052226305008,
1.0323095321655273,
-0.5430713295936584,
0.6557765603065491,
-0.19730046391487122,
-0.07838952541351318,
-0.0905219092965126,
-0.24581731855869293,
-0.20757177472114563,
0.3976534605026245,
0.27645161747932434,
-0.6062527894973755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14544v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14544v1
|
WangLab at MEDIQA-CORR 2024: Optimized LLM-based Programs for Medical Error Detection and Correction
| 2024-04-22T19:31:45 | 2024-04-22T19:31:45 |
Augustin Toma, Ronald Xie, Steven Palayew, Patrick R. Lawler, Bo Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Medical errors in clinical text pose significant risks to patient safety. The
MEDIQA-CORR 2024 shared task focuses on detecting and correcting these errors
across three subtasks: identifying the presence of an error, extracting the
erroneous sentence, and generating a corrected sentence. In this paper, we
present our approach that achieved top performance in all three subtasks. For
the MS dataset, which contains subtle errors, we developed a retrieval-based
system leveraging external medical question-answering datasets. For the UW
dataset, reflecting more realistic clinical notes, we created a pipeline of
modules to detect, localize, and correct errors. Both approaches utilized the
DSPy framework for optimizing prompts and few-shot examples in large language
model (LLM) based programs. Our results demonstrate the effectiveness of LLM
based programs for medical error correction. However, our approach has
limitations in addressing the full diversity of potential errors in medical
documentation. We discuss the implications of our work and highlight future
research directions to advance the robustness and applicability of medical
error detection and correction systems.
|
[
0.301074743270874,
-0.5962013006210327,
0.7162020802497864,
0.2307559996843338,
0.0928269550204277,
0.16934509575366974,
0.132185161113739,
-0.2853691577911377,
0.18036383390426636,
0.26151034235954285,
-0.5961703658103943,
-0.48975828289985657,
-0.49755898118019104,
0.4036003649234772,
-0.011188698001205921,
0.9335595369338989,
-0.28644028306007385,
0.3401336967945099,
-0.3970070481300354,
-0.3764912188053131,
-0.6998031139373779,
-0.5624055862426758,
-0.6142289042472839,
-0.41029754281044006,
0.8434737920761108,
0.7923282980918884,
0.42979806661605835,
0.5354223847389221,
0.9885503053665161,
0.17836597561836243,
0.2840941846370697,
0.5610820651054382,
-0.2772558927536011,
0.0904821828007698,
0.0575668103992939,
-0.5449984073638916,
-0.7868639826774597,
-0.2972424328327179,
0.3222087323665619,
0.5505399703979492,
-0.27781742811203003,
-0.15858204662799835,
-0.20156146585941315,
0.7468439340591431,
-0.4107433259487152,
0.026556238532066345,
-0.22943808138370514,
0.2950212061405182,
-0.34415435791015625,
-0.7036678791046143,
-0.42480921745300293,
-0.3350757956504822,
-0.1731942594051361,
-0.4989997446537018,
0.11325470358133316,
0.27543219923973083,
0.7275579571723938,
0.6299577355384827,
-0.23691731691360474,
-0.47112414240837097,
-0.3406084477901459,
0.8674882054328918,
-0.813956081867218,
0.10088728368282318,
0.45336493849754333,
0.20136825740337372,
-0.5158304572105408,
-0.6390325427055359,
-0.2015598565340042,
0.2622946798801422,
-0.15761083364486694,
0.3563011586666107,
-0.18091948330402374,
0.3536375164985657,
0.26569613814353943,
0.3187752664089203,
-0.6096866130828857,
0.237260639667511,
-0.32310932874679565,
-0.38616591691970825,
0.5423036813735962,
0.5417010188102722,
0.5050352811813354,
0.022861670702695847,
-0.03644240275025368,
0.08851661533117294,
-0.6737038493156433,
-0.2755085527896881,
-0.14210622012615204,
0.04585583880543709,
-0.24024201929569244,
0.6656176447868347,
-0.084958516061306,
0.4694991409778595,
-0.0928422138094902,
-0.3565444350242615,
0.31520015001296997,
-0.43755531311035156,
-0.24659651517868042,
0.02038932591676712,
0.642654299736023,
0.41266438364982605,
-0.2034374177455902,
-0.08591503649950027,
-0.200089231133461,
-0.22637410461902618,
0.1259647011756897,
-0.3457251191139221,
-0.39680615067481995,
0.6235154867172241,
-0.4677681028842926,
-0.2881140410900116,
-0.293720543384552,
-0.53377765417099,
-0.6827486753463745,
-0.19131755828857422,
0.38180384039878845,
-0.3016548454761505,
0.3103214502334595,
0.3059477210044861,
0.13334515690803528,
-0.10831049829721451,
0.5165929198265076,
-0.5943633913993835,
0.2553199529647827,
0.5858517289161682,
0.7013587355613708,
-0.29670366644859314,
-0.09970788657665253,
-0.657126784324646,
0.17089173197746277,
-0.4579702615737915,
0.7991085648536682,
0.04262275993824005,
-0.1427372694015503,
-0.1794048696756363,
-0.025179706513881683,
-0.29236406087875366,
-0.7223309278488159,
0.7463662624359131,
-0.24346260726451874,
0.27732881903648376,
-0.33413541316986084,
-0.5316686630249023,
0.041009027510881424,
0.2608267664909363,
-0.5748867988586426,
0.7604685425758362,
0.15424968302249908,
-0.9675693511962891,
0.08221040666103363,
-0.8437550663948059,
-0.3068214952945709,
0.01939600333571434,
-0.36524730920791626,
-0.8970088362693787,
-0.09217772632837296,
0.3627110421657562,
0.4236440658569336,
-0.23038539290428162,
0.47935712337493896,
0.1918610781431198,
-0.5750011801719666,
0.24947792291641235,
-0.2169537991285324,
0.7494811415672302,
0.13367624580860138,
-0.2567184269428253,
0.37018346786499023,
-1.0549513101577759,
0.04613164812326431,
0.09944654256105423,
-0.7974367737770081,
-0.25564366579055786,
-0.19289761781692505,
-0.14786909520626068,
-0.10223781317472458,
0.1448858231306076,
-0.5631821155548096,
0.13772037625312805,
-0.0921274945139885,
0.11252560466527939,
0.5107670426368713,
0.11208349466323853,
0.15617790818214417,
-0.44241490960121155,
0.7423069477081299,
0.12431836873292923,
0.28354761004447937,
-0.2854158878326416,
-0.5380322933197021,
-0.6836493015289307,
-0.37056005001068115,
0.12412646412849426,
0.9351356625556946,
-0.7765863537788391,
0.20424824953079224,
0.16421164572238922,
-0.22547832131385803,
-0.5556538701057434,
-0.09033042192459106,
0.3739852011203766,
0.8954855799674988,
0.6784461736679077,
0.17641763389110565,
-1.0140057802200317,
-0.6845223307609558,
-0.24971739947795868,
-0.16783729195594788,
0.13150162994861603,
0.15991511940956116,
0.319043904542923,
-0.5962206125259399,
0.5658854246139526,
-0.6259437799453735,
-0.3917083740234375,
-0.2989335358142853,
0.0967930480837822,
0.4653604328632355,
0.5529108643531799,
0.2121317982673645,
-0.5347270965576172,
-0.4208613336086273,
-0.008786256425082684,
-0.7683877944946289,
-0.587357223033905,
-0.2272987812757492,
-0.02189938724040985,
0.26667147874832153,
0.5343199372291565,
-0.26999345421791077,
0.32126885652542114,
0.569979190826416,
-0.16183222830295563,
0.3861270546913147,
-0.6551313400268555,
0.3482694625854492,
-0.9848251938819885,
0.08393963426351547,
-0.5099183917045593,
-0.08118217438459396,
-0.6761599779129028,
-0.14874716103076935,
0.33645036816596985,
0.22424468398094177,
-0.09687909483909607,
0.19584009051322937,
-0.38853004574775696,
0.21437422931194305,
-0.17445586621761322,
-0.3034301996231079,
0.14397944509983063,
0.3293931186199188,
-0.36578771471977234,
0.6092094779014587,
0.24625380337238312,
-0.34968143701553345,
0.4638754427433014,
0.27371975779533386,
0.06184704601764679,
0.7367224097251892,
-0.4996225833892822,
0.2811790704727173,
-0.2217087596654892,
0.09375695884227753,
-0.8632981181144714,
-0.45687922835350037,
0.3817911148071289,
-0.30181050300598145,
0.39746400713920593,
0.005240877158939838,
-0.4525463283061981,
-0.4804140627384186,
-0.3253614008426666,
0.2369433343410492,
0.035996098071336746,
-0.28062325716018677,
0.39331379532814026,
0.35122567415237427,
-0.2847822904586792,
-0.9453291893005371,
-0.794144332408905,
0.2521401047706604,
0.06670253723859787,
-0.5734535455703735,
0.06799566000699997,
0.01781940460205078,
-0.2426653355360031,
-0.19632825255393982,
0.08260872215032578,
-0.04835377633571625,
0.07708791643381119,
0.2067779302597046,
0.4537447392940521,
-0.11401975899934769,
0.21142253279685974,
0.08552123606204987,
-0.26472288370132446,
-0.16625206172466278,
0.007538131438195705,
0.2746613323688507,
-0.03515426069498062,
-0.47943273186683655,
-0.5492914915084839,
0.3288330137729645,
0.4471093416213989,
-0.0647992193698883,
0.599041223526001,
0.41985252499580383,
-0.48479971289634705,
0.13851885497570038,
-0.5065920352935791,
-0.05774715170264244,
-0.4043252468109131,
0.572149932384491,
0.04676543176174164,
-0.6355825066566467,
0.46460872888565063,
0.22716738283634186,
0.05512923002243042,
0.18789958953857422,
0.28529709577560425,
-0.4054526090621948,
0.9445733428001404,
0.557479739189148,
0.06601686775684357,
-0.11069080978631973,
-0.03824382275342941,
0.23450368642807007,
-0.752390444278717,
-0.39999064803123474,
-0.5729174613952637,
-0.1037653386592865,
-0.3353489935398102,
-0.7815243601799011,
0.7129848599433899,
-0.29251593351364136,
-0.019544707611203194,
0.08512097597122192,
-0.20531371235847473,
0.25592461228370667,
0.540384829044342,
0.2576819062232971,
0.49249523878097534,
-0.11535019427537918,
-0.320659875869751,
-0.2801618278026581,
-0.8374361991882324,
-0.34277060627937317,
0.9111022353172302,
0.49608972668647766,
0.9785162210464478,
-0.17036172747612,
0.8716779351234436,
0.23460260033607483,
0.2489762008190155,
-0.6242005825042725,
0.40367740392684937,
-0.2503199875354767,
-0.2676086127758026,
-0.24693062901496887,
-0.3719019889831543,
-0.6519741415977478,
-0.012176889926195145,
-0.16010473668575287,
-0.14056096971035004,
-0.011252976953983307,
0.2341052144765854,
-0.419878214597702,
0.3151818811893463,
-0.5121080875396729,
0.9713819622993469,
-0.2635822892189026,
-0.20461302995681763,
0.007149591576308012,
-0.8219656944274902,
0.10856405645608902,
-0.10542149096727371,
0.3063150942325592,
-0.007352086715400219,
-0.20233139395713806,
0.4781522750854492,
-0.39050623774528503,
0.6577205061912537,
-0.20753337442874908,
-0.233280211687088,
0.0144896125420928,
-0.17609736323356628,
0.6767452955245972,
-0.37658363580703735,
-0.08295155316591263,
-0.03239740803837776,
0.21661782264709473,
-0.3361791968345642,
-0.26133331656455994,
0.22724606096744537,
-0.38121262192726135,
-0.2695881128311157,
-0.448352187871933,
-1.017484188079834,
-0.2268623560667038,
0.17590555548667908,
0.22120800614356995,
0.6341252326965332,
-0.006037912331521511,
0.010262935422360897,
0.6038652658462524,
-0.7466182112693787,
0.03574974462389946,
0.6705436706542969,
-0.16166017949581146,
-0.304220050573349,
0.7615076899528503,
0.06676188111305237,
0.007546994369477034,
0.5665634274482727,
0.3497619926929474,
-0.07753416895866394,
-1.0136849880218506,
-0.3977035582065582,
0.4180285334587097,
-0.7994171977043152,
-0.35350653529167175,
-0.8646948933601379,
-0.031751714646816254,
-0.35253915190696716,
0.05218396335840225,
-0.12912100553512573,
-0.3232068121433258,
-0.3371001183986664,
-0.05375446379184723,
0.235420823097229,
0.7265949845314026,
-0.4106094241142273,
0.15812109410762787,
-1.0723776817321777,
0.32420629262924194,
-0.2144167572259903,
0.21389946341514587,
-0.36206942796707153,
-0.42732515931129456,
-0.4453997313976288,
-0.22674232721328735,
-0.09828413277864456,
-0.5260298252105713,
0.28201115131378174,
0.09403645247220993,
0.496026873588562,
0.09382439404726028,
0.12183871120214462,
0.7550336718559265,
-0.632982075214386,
0.3753717541694641,
0.1115429624915123,
-0.5061613917350769,
0.825233519077301,
-0.44424787163734436,
0.27588558197021484,
0.5593468546867371,
0.19624324142932892,
-0.8781262636184692,
-0.5455007553100586,
-0.27672210335731506,
-0.6158680319786072,
0.6748812198638916,
-0.11122453957796097,
-0.2753394544124603,
-0.013256031088531017,
0.38232696056365967,
-0.010998401790857315,
-0.042450323700904846,
-0.3691893219947815,
-0.28507617115974426,
0.49778854846954346,
-0.9027028679847717,
0.23882846534252167,
-0.26313546299934387,
-0.3150668144226074,
-0.007917828857898712,
0.6811995506286621,
-0.48660653829574585,
0.13826683163642883,
0.5400809645652771,
0.034323323518037796,
-0.444033682346344,
0.4200620651245117,
0.7948138117790222,
0.7950116991996765,
-0.28803858160972595,
0.054044369608163834,
0.13119184970855713,
-0.8070729374885559,
-0.03553063049912453,
0.012768369168043137,
-0.20102302730083466,
0.009912320412695408,
0.3150252401828766,
0.22326484322547913,
-0.016542211174964905,
-1.0098885297775269,
0.5994346737861633,
-0.25250232219696045,
0.25174084305763245,
-0.1913517862558365,
-0.19511796534061432,
0.09395047277212143,
0.20892412960529327,
0.3815862536430359,
0.35078758001327515,
0.3335837125778198,
-0.32995691895484924,
0.391752153635025,
0.15524320304393768,
-0.302213191986084,
-0.1788901537656784,
0.6549412608146667,
0.048172272741794586,
-0.06468109786510468,
0.21703100204467773,
0.058980055153369904,
-0.4667993187904358,
0.7031932473182678,
0.4688568115234375,
0.4114861786365509,
-0.15792272984981537,
0.14953461289405823,
0.3120036721229553,
0.11270567774772644,
-0.18005648255348206,
0.6020616888999939,
0.4666721224784851,
-0.6013370156288147,
-0.5530848503112793,
0.010430678725242615,
-0.7629697322845459,
0.06968526542186737,
-0.47972536087036133,
0.40311723947525024,
-0.44819769263267517,
0.042502839118242264,
-0.3534362018108368,
-0.1467461735010147,
-0.07637127488851547,
0.254433810710907,
-0.1187443733215332,
0.5776189565658569,
-0.3755437731742859,
0.6428433656692505,
0.7277185916900635,
-0.13471932709217072,
-0.9831138849258423,
-0.21525229513645172,
0.3192988336086273,
-0.8597551584243774,
0.60860276222229,
0.043212469667196274,
-0.04268180951476097,
-0.2916485071182251,
-0.5069116353988647,
-0.5575196743011475,
1.1093772649765015,
0.05833212286233902,
-0.714787483215332,
-0.13026361167430878,
0.23789475858211517,
0.6735525727272034,
-0.02221507579088211,
0.07360494881868362,
0.5160219073295593,
0.009379791095852852,
0.051691412925720215,
-1.0683923959732056,
0.16091187298297882,
0.12303531914949417,
-0.5352913737297058,
0.1706589162349701,
-0.37910154461860657,
0.7427306771278381,
-0.7307253479957581,
0.0706881508231163,
0.3887849450111389,
0.3371361196041107,
0.3497992753982544,
0.7244826555252075,
0.01700364612042904,
0.5633237361907959,
1.2528903484344482,
-0.11732923984527588,
0.9181452393531799,
0.1332571804523468,
0.18011492490768433,
1.1297444105148315,
-0.25121885538101196,
0.5761445164680481,
0.6427391171455383,
-0.4002060294151306,
0.3032589554786682,
0.436334490776062,
0.11063423752784729,
0.3674633502960205,
0.14982007443904877,
-0.26693105697631836,
0.24107511341571808,
-0.11208224296569824,
-0.15616726875305176,
0.12716063857078552,
0.4338570833206177,
-0.2833128571510315,
0.025169504806399345,
0.13093958795070648,
0.11185269057750702,
0.01898304373025894,
-0.2070569545030594,
0.47667384147644043,
0.015610902570188046,
-0.6152235865592957,
0.31494542956352234,
-0.017179373651742935,
0.8374436497688293,
-0.40711483359336853,
-0.2513329088687897,
-0.5159426927566528,
0.623496949672699,
-0.5062004923820496,
-0.4803377687931061,
0.40509864687919617,
0.011391445063054562,
-0.04719024896621704,
0.04372069984674454,
0.9075098037719727,
-0.48253586888313293,
-0.20840783417224884,
-0.004150540102273226,
0.2707809507846832,
0.2275257259607315,
0.24013663828372955,
-0.7348371744155884,
0.09970024973154068,
0.15362603962421417,
0.4541080892086029,
-0.028771623969078064,
0.3766005337238312,
0.08867388963699341,
0.6636667251586914,
0.37067079544067383,
0.23326830565929413,
0.13142907619476318,
0.30936798453330994,
0.4657553732395172,
-0.5351952910423279,
-0.3451721668243408,
-0.5678632855415344,
0.43924596905708313,
-0.04970875009894371,
0.07098852097988129,
0.5111355781555176,
0.5438578724861145,
0.4849047064781189,
-0.09300481528043747,
0.7380324006080627,
-0.006652418058365583,
1.0961103439331055,
-0.565880537033081,
0.5334470868110657,
-0.5018263459205627,
0.5717397332191467,
-0.2611137628555298,
-0.33493420481681824,
-0.6835613250732422,
0.43443563580513,
-0.05777781829237938,
-0.33693403005599976,
0.8530842661857605,
0.9820977449417114,
0.3699670433998108,
-0.09206049144268036,
0.47053077816963196,
0.27162328362464905,
0.4992647171020508,
0.6391003727912903,
0.8733949661254883,
-0.8963608145713806,
0.5264254212379456,
-0.199997216463089,
-0.1482241451740265,
-0.3678516149520874,
-0.6935244202613831,
-0.6781442165374756,
-0.1899355947971344,
-0.6026798486709595,
-0.5479220151901245,
0.17839865386486053,
0.9636650681495667,
0.2691253423690796,
-1.0539995431900024,
0.11506980657577515,
-0.015234083868563175,
0.17982758581638336,
-0.08065222203731537,
-0.1817430555820465,
0.5655555725097656,
-0.34168174862861633,
-0.5741193890571594,
0.5509521961212158,
0.6817971467971802,
0.13838957250118256,
0.11850637942552567,
-0.19515067338943481,
-0.27556028962135315,
-0.13021531701087952,
0.2959408164024353,
0.23345918953418732,
-0.2981884181499481,
-0.20998945832252502,
0.3688541650772095,
-0.5547966361045837,
0.3497273623943329,
0.939265251159668,
-0.21525022387504578,
0.43598029017448425,
0.6604142785072327,
0.8304970264434814,
-0.10851005464792252,
-0.0830620750784874,
0.585334300994873,
-0.5572643280029297,
-0.25764748454093933,
0.29951906204223633,
0.37410441040992737,
0.6612827181816101,
-0.5830472111701965,
0.7764066457748413,
0.4669240713119507,
-0.7748823165893555,
-0.7309199571609497,
-0.21643224358558655,
-0.8517243266105652,
-0.07888788729906082,
0.8447818756103516,
-0.3824943006038666,
-0.03533118963241577,
-0.8067998290061951,
-0.6738635897636414,
0.23284149169921875,
0.04174070805311203,
0.6380658745765686,
0.5022948980331421,
-0.7334740161895752,
-0.12532654404640198,
-0.6263028979301453,
0.5095332264900208,
0.6298217177391052,
-1.030951976776123,
-0.0800744891166687,
0.45843449234962463,
0.40090009570121765,
0.19815294444561005,
1.048352837562561,
-0.38519683480262756,
0.6706178188323975,
-0.13905160129070282,
-0.10470785200595856,
-0.03673113137483597,
-0.19465890526771545,
-0.46851685643196106,
-0.2706109285354614,
-0.03208038583397865,
-0.34960469603538513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14408v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14408v2
|
SpaceByte: Towards Deleting Tokenization from Large Language Modeling
| 2024-04-22T17:59:29 | 2024-05-23T16:41:41 |
Kevin Slagle
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Tokenization is widely used in large language models because it significantly
improves performance. However, tokenization imposes several disadvantages, such
as performance biases, increased adversarial vulnerability, decreased
character-level modeling performance, and increased modeling complexity. To
address these disadvantages without sacrificing performance, we propose
SpaceByte, a novel byte-level decoder architecture that closes the performance
gap between byte-level and subword autoregressive language modeling. SpaceByte
consists of a byte-level Transformer model, but with extra larger transformer
blocks inserted in the middle of the layers. We find that performance is
significantly improved by applying these larger blocks only after certain
bytes, such as space characters, which typically denote word boundaries. Our
experiments show that for a fixed training and inference compute budget,
SpaceByte outperforms other byte-level architectures and roughly matches the
performance of tokenized Transformer architectures.
|
[
-0.18144096434116364,
-0.6977377533912659,
0.14146164059638977,
0.28140097856521606,
-0.30531367659568787,
0.2245788276195526,
-0.06827237457036972,
-0.39562299847602844,
0.36231258511543274,
0.245515838265419,
-0.24785421788692474,
-0.3453044295310974,
-0.6612726449966431,
-0.4659210443496704,
-0.5393822193145752,
0.6781438589096069,
0.0983838438987732,
-0.031597573310136795,
-0.05577344819903374,
0.1640162467956543,
-0.7242571711540222,
-0.4643937945365906,
-0.6795741319656372,
-0.14168208837509155,
0.38747045397758484,
0.10923454910516739,
1.046506404876709,
0.9025905728340149,
0.502718448638916,
0.2787255048751831,
-0.3774482309818268,
-0.1533811390399933,
-0.25185999274253845,
-0.0018225036328658462,
-0.03687329962849617,
-0.47574037313461304,
-0.46293625235557556,
-0.129951611161232,
0.7428713440895081,
0.8987694978713989,
-0.2969917953014374,
-0.11870601028203964,
-0.1837417185306549,
0.7119200825691223,
-0.7280247807502747,
0.054053910076618195,
-0.6304237842559814,
0.22661437094211578,
-0.006164911203086376,
0.24261382222175598,
-0.40088891983032227,
-0.1442635953426361,
-0.4389517307281494,
-0.5684192180633545,
0.4653762876987457,
0.1752195805311203,
0.7084438800811768,
0.3702233135700226,
-0.062319058924913406,
-0.09359511733055115,
-0.8396210670471191,
0.46196478605270386,
-0.5383838415145874,
0.5718234777450562,
0.28015226125717163,
0.1946459263563156,
-0.09556876868009567,
-0.49294427037239075,
-0.6636880040168762,
0.0631750226020813,
-0.07521019130945206,
-0.02592703141272068,
-0.5107255578041077,
0.11106958985328674,
0.10918738692998886,
0.41668301820755005,
-0.6063892245292664,
-0.054558273404836655,
-0.5117425322532654,
-0.2624553442001343,
0.20761261880397797,
0.17647454142570496,
0.4045834243297577,
-0.3069124221801758,
-0.29720059037208557,
0.002051763469353318,
-0.7559977173805237,
-0.061316393315792084,
0.2773369550704956,
0.15466392040252686,
0.2710699737071991,
0.5481927990913391,
0.05719515681266785,
0.013283875770866871,
0.1935737282037735,
0.6786091923713684,
0.07348915934562683,
0.05068950355052948,
-0.1454325169324875,
-0.007576321717351675,
0.6471006274223328,
0.1130409985780716,
-0.010851007886230946,
-0.5857546925544739,
-0.33580681681632996,
0.2636072039604187,
0.5341026782989502,
-1.081863522529602,
-0.5163651704788208,
0.32548338174819946,
-0.6350938677787781,
0.003375450847670436,
-0.08256074041128159,
-0.4322097599506378,
-0.48886996507644653,
0.1640208214521408,
0.313215970993042,
-0.8280213475227356,
-0.45454123616218567,
0.40474700927734375,
-0.3211255669593811,
0.24533484876155853,
0.1909472942352295,
-1.0024919509887695,
0.3879304528236389,
0.8786386847496033,
0.866073489189148,
-0.0889655128121376,
-0.039353977888822556,
-0.31604304909706116,
-0.07331276684999466,
-0.7281410098075867,
0.37576761841773987,
-0.7963788509368896,
-0.7033055424690247,
-0.2846255898475647,
-0.05525246262550354,
0.019149204716086388,
-0.7821170091629028,
0.04424877464771271,
-0.9629417061805725,
-0.052535150200128555,
-0.08418535441160202,
-0.7067537307739258,
0.23415693640708923,
-0.029008716344833374,
-0.8490893840789795,
0.9934689998626709,
0.08168258517980576,
-0.41976892948150635,
0.6569509506225586,
-0.8278462886810303,
-0.6377665400505066,
0.548653781414032,
-0.05450461432337761,
-0.2444719672203064,
0.4022168517112732,
0.21408654749393463,
0.3986937999725342,
0.03721144422888756,
0.3542204797267914,
0.07554525882005692,
-0.6643926501274109,
-0.04353751614689827,
-0.28870779275894165,
0.48966097831726074,
0.4545598328113556,
-0.4947386384010315,
-0.10097698867321014,
-0.8924956917762756,
-0.13198690116405487,
0.22309601306915283,
-0.5361204743385315,
-0.5915669798851013,
-0.029642323032021523,
0.2075842022895813,
0.07355362921953201,
0.24926422536373138,
-1.007982611656189,
0.2746634781360626,
-0.580215573310852,
0.7130512595176697,
0.4741407334804535,
-0.4946301281452179,
0.940822958946228,
0.17165979743003845,
0.6610395908355713,
0.27670034766197205,
0.20285089313983917,
-0.3206122815608978,
-0.14918865263462067,
-0.7535285949707031,
-0.5100606083869934,
0.3357119858264923,
0.1734939068555832,
-0.6535847783088684,
0.6286293864250183,
-0.513506293296814,
-0.3807636797428131,
-0.551303505897522,
-0.11533531546592712,
0.31745103001594543,
0.0375838503241539,
0.5204042196273804,
-0.1283152848482132,
-0.4803883135318756,
-0.865196168422699,
-0.37859463691711426,
-0.16036272048950195,
-0.035510241985321045,
0.20178256928920746,
0.47313693165779114,
-0.19755476713180542,
0.9222338199615479,
-0.4042861759662628,
-0.024366652593016624,
-0.20343689620494843,
-0.2730599045753479,
0.027358651161193848,
0.850436806678772,
0.29763278365135193,
-0.7123624086380005,
-0.13454052805900574,
-0.0741850808262825,
-0.3164653778076172,
0.20010751485824585,
0.02723104879260063,
-0.04917838051915169,
0.18035641312599182,
0.8010581731796265,
-1.0332111120224,
0.6353083848953247,
0.41800767183303833,
-0.5846774578094482,
0.2323831170797348,
-0.16785834729671478,
0.03662846237421036,
-0.9891344308853149,
0.3293338716030121,
-0.3780539035797119,
-0.2465589940547943,
-0.37558281421661377,
0.14294962584972382,
0.396208256483078,
-0.39014732837677,
-0.09768788516521454,
0.6674723029136658,
-0.430536687374115,
0.04274298623204231,
-0.47691333293914795,
0.03316126763820648,
0.22890420258045197,
0.15564370155334473,
0.029543457552790642,
0.9124404788017273,
0.07621961086988449,
-0.2853393852710724,
-0.007504188921302557,
0.2802737057209015,
-0.3497365415096283,
-0.00789600145071745,
-0.7686602473258972,
0.0527561753988266,
-0.191319540143013,
0.3919553756713867,
-1.377479910850525,
0.14697512984275818,
-0.0017385258106514812,
-0.574950635433197,
0.3963739573955536,
-0.24932695925235748,
-0.4274686276912689,
-0.33999010920524597,
-0.022341037169098854,
0.7010810375213623,
0.6072874665260315,
-0.6290115118026733,
0.6622881889343262,
0.5073989033699036,
0.01638832502067089,
-0.7562928795814514,
-0.9479299187660217,
0.34956589341163635,
-0.020654113963246346,
-0.45957058668136597,
0.4561086595058441,
0.09636910259723663,
0.19022071361541748,
0.32260847091674805,
-0.25666260719299316,
0.012515954673290253,
0.10757620632648468,
0.5078564286231995,
0.2263646274805069,
-0.28503552079200745,
0.27900782227516174,
0.055376920849084854,
-0.26254525780677795,
0.11970501393079758,
-0.6296592354774475,
0.8404380083084106,
-0.16929438710212708,
-0.22907181084156036,
-0.08110181242227554,
0.4131181538105011,
0.4816848933696747,
-0.28312626481056213,
1.0472666025161743,
0.6339021921157837,
-0.4501737654209137,
-0.43185847997665405,
-0.5276039838790894,
-0.0022344861645251513,
-0.4974122643470764,
0.6652918457984924,
-0.5672455430030823,
-1.1581326723098755,
0.6087093949317932,
-0.07878875732421875,
0.07882776856422424,
0.3007320165634155,
0.2122240960597992,
0.009798046201467514,
0.8649917840957642,
0.7601487040519714,
-0.3664618134498596,
0.632473349571228,
-0.4117465317249298,
0.6264729499816895,
-0.7863940000534058,
-0.3744129538536072,
-0.5812095403671265,
-0.26346319913864136,
-0.4706437885761261,
-0.6647945046424866,
0.06881748884916306,
0.12353581190109253,
-0.09094922989606857,
0.6708514094352722,
-0.49940407276153564,
0.739654004573822,
0.19937478005886078,
-0.13320033252239227,
-0.1993115246295929,
0.024037795141339302,
-0.1918007731437683,
0.023281153291463852,
-0.9811519384384155,
-0.42009592056274414,
0.6806148886680603,
0.4659200608730316,
0.7944954633712769,
0.06425084173679352,
0.6574530005455017,
0.28701531887054443,
-0.06786530464887619,
-0.852666437625885,
0.5879936814308167,
-0.45269840955734253,
-0.7146302461624146,
-0.31949251890182495,
-0.576608419418335,
-1.129472255706787,
0.4861759841442108,
-0.01919906958937645,
-0.6972439289093018,
0.1447640061378479,
0.30788877606391907,
-0.333194375038147,
0.5038135051727295,
-0.7092604041099548,
0.7525959610939026,
0.41620543599128723,
-0.17803698778152466,
-0.4901078939437866,
-0.4369872510433197,
0.009520298801362514,
0.2532714009284973,
0.2899438142776489,
0.16051940619945526,
-0.13611923158168793,
0.7190936803817749,
-0.6107409596443176,
0.7364501953125,
-0.4734985828399658,
-0.11259514093399048,
0.17736585438251495,
0.6362130045890808,
0.505023181438446,
-0.10236110538244247,
0.06669367104768753,
0.44247519969940186,
0.05294998735189438,
-0.5232099890708923,
-0.5178475975990295,
0.6529906392097473,
-0.7740510702133179,
-0.40864625573158264,
0.10214906930923462,
-0.5532752871513367,
-0.19408270716667175,
0.20534567534923553,
0.03809668496251106,
0.5385628938674927,
-0.36966538429260254,
0.3025873005390167,
0.5851638317108154,
-0.5429142713546753,
0.6625111699104309,
0.06828992813825607,
-0.20113424956798553,
-0.41827592253685,
0.7393897771835327,
-0.08894845843315125,
-0.06760859489440918,
0.7284286618232727,
0.15871000289916992,
-0.35342302918434143,
-0.5075474381446838,
-0.318264901638031,
0.04327894374728203,
-0.7316926121711731,
-0.049141693860292435,
-0.8871400952339172,
-0.33768194913864136,
-0.4074017405509949,
-0.2283150553703308,
-0.8254454135894775,
-0.7137027978897095,
-0.0034157647751271725,
-0.08918502181768417,
-0.12220551073551178,
0.5131675004959106,
0.04919974133372307,
0.6785707473754883,
-0.7537406086921692,
0.25377970933914185,
-0.21991033852100372,
0.5090307593345642,
0.28385791182518005,
-0.6147091388702393,
-0.5986591577529907,
-0.415761262178421,
0.07642030715942383,
-0.12743699550628662,
0.28263095021247864,
-0.1088450700044632,
0.17827145755290985,
0.202367901802063,
-0.3729265332221985,
0.9412654638290405,
-0.7838008999824524,
0.8987954258918762,
0.2853395342826843,
-1.299536943435669,
0.2762443423271179,
-0.1365150362253189,
0.6550472378730774,
0.19584119319915771,
0.09038268029689789,
-0.8730566501617432,
-0.3848620057106018,
-0.6198463439941406,
-1.22451913356781,
0.6551883220672607,
0.07841953635215759,
0.5254198908805847,
-0.2985149621963501,
0.5862723588943481,
0.08112562447786331,
0.30703210830688477,
-0.48220106959342957,
-0.11798660457134247,
-0.2641816735267639,
-0.2791414260864258,
0.1851464807987213,
-0.39042559266090393,
0.365115225315094,
-0.040199100971221924,
0.6178779006004333,
0.1126103401184082,
0.3312492072582245,
-0.011369781568646431,
-0.420841246843338,
-0.21924425661563873,
0.27522337436676025,
0.11701267212629318,
0.40187615156173706,
0.16442272067070007,
0.2992563247680664,
-0.04176370054483414,
-0.8220021724700928,
0.14704173803329468,
-0.13248474895954132,
-0.10744503885507584,
-0.14015117287635803,
0.5229858160018921,
0.6615750789642334,
0.18954095244407654,
-0.4125642776489258,
0.6844499111175537,
-0.20715339481830597,
-0.16689777374267578,
-0.052892062813043594,
0.23325960338115692,
0.18398134410381317,
0.2333707958459854,
0.3207595646381378,
0.2619136571884155,
0.14123767614364624,
-0.06742218136787415,
0.20456933975219727,
0.45543307065963745,
-0.2787003517150879,
-0.3344511389732361,
0.8753785490989685,
0.13262128829956055,
-0.2164822220802307,
0.643081784248352,
0.1518329232931137,
-0.2693828344345093,
0.643002986907959,
0.581399142742157,
0.821967601776123,
-0.246622696518898,
0.07675620913505554,
0.3498057425022125,
0.5967656970024109,
0.1760036200284958,
0.13172057271003723,
-0.14819766581058502,
-0.8053348660469055,
-0.4763861894607544,
-0.8291762471199036,
0.23591472208499908,
0.33828678727149963,
-0.42182302474975586,
-0.2850099503993988,
-0.9064629673957825,
-0.28201398253440857,
0.18357563018798828,
-0.03535342589020729,
-0.5304369926452637,
0.26677069067955017,
0.34050682187080383,
1.1793928146362305,
-0.4908019006252289,
0.7105376124382019,
0.5974173545837402,
-0.09214088320732117,
-0.7890558838844299,
-0.16307777166366577,
-0.3458348512649536,
-0.6263155937194824,
0.8556054830551147,
0.2201743870973587,
-0.4826473891735077,
-0.16500604152679443,
-0.5140010714530945,
-0.7994571924209595,
0.6117590665817261,
0.2975931167602539,
-0.8145628571510315,
0.004712468944489956,
0.21676760911941528,
0.3377830684185028,
-0.08908331394195557,
0.20784151554107666,
0.3605498671531677,
0.2601855993270874,
-0.0718863233923912,
-0.6245363354682922,
0.3018798232078552,
-0.4252931773662567,
0.6111684441566467,
0.585607647895813,
-0.7300775051116943,
0.9063897132873535,
-0.061493970453739166,
-0.469684362411499,
0.15856076776981354,
0.7759817242622375,
-0.25069189071655273,
-0.3464045822620392,
0.6741951704025269,
0.4426548182964325,
0.5960246920585632,
-0.037395279854536057,
0.6959911584854126,
-0.47232183814048767,
0.1656605750322342,
0.8668878078460693,
-0.23835475742816925,
0.7318516969680786,
0.49732813239097595,
-0.1331317126750946,
0.39047908782958984,
0.22458690404891968,
0.100972481071949,
0.43400847911834717,
0.27768510580062866,
-0.10798991471529007,
-0.3799458146095276,
0.35717031359672546,
0.03426923602819443,
0.5045116543769836,
0.3414698839187622,
-0.19867657124996185,
-0.19446799159049988,
0.042093683034181595,
0.16112323105335236,
0.05756421759724617,
-0.11667469888925552,
0.6936800479888916,
-0.14465641975402832,
-0.45315852761268616,
0.46789005398750305,
0.24793468415737152,
0.584769070148468,
-0.585210919380188,
-0.022139737382531166,
-0.38850873708724976,
0.5001229047775269,
-0.16149024665355682,
-0.40650197863578796,
0.40249350666999817,
-0.05116160959005356,
-0.3481595814228058,
-0.1308394819498062,
0.6669391393661499,
-0.46836137771606445,
-0.22137857973575592,
0.41659533977508545,
0.23989605903625488,
0.10293762385845184,
-0.2097996175289154,
-0.6789936423301697,
0.14464379847049713,
-0.439848393201828,
-0.38173192739486694,
0.2689598500728607,
0.5915509462356567,
-0.057092294096946716,
0.6904117465019226,
0.7277767658233643,
0.23484376072883606,
0.1660536229610443,
0.19570450484752655,
0.878217339515686,
-1.020716905593872,
-0.8553812503814697,
-0.9366522431373596,
0.3067309558391571,
0.0871296226978302,
-0.07071246951818466,
0.5984047651290894,
0.9401295185089111,
0.626841127872467,
-0.01886785961687565,
0.7578710317611694,
-0.306301474571228,
0.08065908402204514,
-0.5037044286727905,
0.8722991347312927,
-0.48361411690711975,
0.31150907278060913,
-0.09805324673652649,
-0.6960137486457825,
-0.3631511330604553,
0.5658257007598877,
-0.20493224263191223,
0.33113113045692444,
0.6571255922317505,
0.9761686325073242,
-0.17175069451332092,
0.06673407554626465,
0.7104524374008179,
0.2090705782175064,
0.6205313801765442,
0.4070124924182892,
1.017310380935669,
-0.6846435070037842,
0.5835575461387634,
0.0755811482667923,
-0.16208550333976746,
-0.1633162796497345,
-0.6718685626983643,
-0.8803443908691406,
-0.5647868514060974,
-0.16460666060447693,
-0.3352305591106415,
0.03471282497048378,
0.8055046200752258,
0.9993348121643066,
-0.7057707905769348,
-0.07017102092504501,
-0.10600240528583527,
-0.1414920538663864,
0.007726086303591728,
-0.24647420644760132,
0.48978808522224426,
-0.46378186345100403,
-0.4989134967327118,
0.48149991035461426,
0.38844242691993713,
-0.18108472228050232,
-0.23762713372707367,
0.19069001078605652,
0.24651336669921875,
0.32870152592658997,
0.567010223865509,
-0.007441498804837465,
-0.5761089324951172,
-0.24874284863471985,
0.018041297793388367,
-0.19471821188926697,
0.1601867824792862,
1.1322953701019287,
-0.7995725870132446,
0.13608409464359283,
0.25656720995903015,
0.9229422807693481,
0.5436282157897949,
-0.08389966934919357,
0.2662646770477295,
-0.8882620334625244,
0.24000489711761475,
0.1354958862066269,
0.37186649441719055,
0.3339007794857025,
-0.6710699796676636,
0.22617638111114502,
0.1136314868927002,
-0.3249507546424866,
-0.414610892534256,
-0.0370304174721241,
-0.5353071093559265,
-0.6691724061965942,
1.1003080606460571,
-0.14855742454528809,
-0.6121265888214111,
0.050038259476423264,
-0.1451696902513504,
0.12376730889081955,
-0.5031994581222534,
0.865453839302063,
0.7160482406616211,
0.4212799668312073,
0.045090265572071075,
-0.21393164992332458,
0.3397173583507538,
0.5791565775871277,
-0.46770012378692627,
0.6377777457237244,
0.6099870204925537,
0.42001059651374817,
0.21849216520786285,
0.5700960159301758,
-0.4064190685749054,
0.2912662625312805,
0.4722190797328949,
0.41596418619155884,
-0.26055338978767395,
-0.5947417616844177,
-0.4278874695301056,
0.44661474227905273,
-0.10721093416213989,
-0.463107705116272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14397v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14397v1
|
RTP-LX: Can LLMs Evaluate Toxicity in Multilingual Scenarios?
| 2024-04-22T17:56:26 | 2024-04-22T17:56:26 |
Adrian de Wynter, Ishaan Watts, Nektar Ege Altıntoprak, Tua Wongsangaroonsri, Minghui Zhang, Noura Farra, Lena Baur, Samantha Claudet, Pavel Gajdusek, Can Gören, Qilong Gu, Anna Kaminska, Tomasz Kaminski, Ruby Kuo, Akiko Kyuba, Jongho Lee, Kartik Mathur, Petter Merok, Ivana Milovanović, Nani Paananen, Vesa-Matti Paananen, Anna Pavlenko, Bruno Pereira Vidal, Luciano Strika, Yueh Tsao, Davide Turcato, Oleksandr Vakhno, Judit Velcsov, Anna Vickers, Stéphanie Visser, Herdyan Widarmanto, Andrey Zaikin, Si-Qing Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) and small language models (SLMs) are being
adopted at remarkable speed, although their safety still remains a serious
concern. With the advent of multilingual S/LLMs, the question now becomes a
matter of scale: can we expand multilingual safety evaluations of these models
with the same velocity at which they are deployed? To this end we introduce
RTP-LX, a human-transcreated and human-annotated corpus of toxic prompts and
outputs in 28 languages. RTP-LX follows participatory design practices, and a
portion of the corpus is especially designed to detect culturally-specific
toxic language. We evaluate seven S/LLMs on their ability to detect toxic
content in a culturally-sensitive, multilingual scenario. We find that,
although they typically score acceptably in terms of accuracy, they have low
agreement with human judges when judging holistically the toxicity of a prompt,
and have difficulty discerning harm in context-dependent scenarios,
particularly with subtle-yet-harmful content (e.g. microagressions, bias). We
release of this dataset to contribute to further reduce harmful uses of these
models and improve their safe deployment.
|
[
-0.04572727158665657,
-0.42334631085395813,
0.6979384422302246,
0.6796110272407532,
-0.14782649278640747,
-0.033484164625406265,
-0.3222225308418274,
-0.8450506925582886,
-0.1043887734413147,
0.46596822142601013,
-0.3519243001937866,
-0.6318678259849548,
-0.5449486970901489,
0.3802196979522705,
-0.227911576628685,
0.9257986545562744,
0.08830071985721588,
0.0691729187965393,
-0.06125715374946594,
-0.26116010546684265,
-0.365727961063385,
-0.5683435201644897,
-0.7847855687141418,
-0.1639808565378189,
1.1684458255767822,
0.49520930647850037,
0.748198926448822,
0.5255894660949707,
0.33628594875335693,
0.2502005994319916,
-0.37116122245788574,
-0.1553981900215149,
-0.13724994659423828,
0.37244468927383423,
-0.37345656752586365,
-0.3510758578777313,
-0.41610169410705566,
-0.060303106904029846,
0.5622916221618652,
0.5936930775642395,
-0.17546036839485168,
0.31605494022369385,
0.10462242364883423,
0.2572881877422333,
-0.6829538941383362,
-0.055778682231903076,
-0.1677403450012207,
0.2566372752189636,
-0.05097523704171181,
-0.08768744021654129,
-0.847763180732727,
-0.30132976174354553,
-0.12309630960226059,
-0.3266901671886444,
-0.4916805326938629,
0.16392549872398376,
0.23705971240997314,
0.0760047659277916,
-0.8611229658126831,
-0.3467862606048584,
-0.6242613792419434,
0.8968573808670044,
-0.6358704566955566,
0.432102769613266,
0.09145890176296234,
0.14850345253944397,
0.03571172431111336,
-0.5571367740631104,
-0.30722576379776,
-0.4241142272949219,
-0.1016763225197792,
-0.13499918580055237,
-0.13752144575119019,
-0.09495461732149124,
0.25663822889328003,
-0.3342280387878418,
-0.7767174243927002,
0.5215452909469604,
-0.17431533336639404,
-0.6068456172943115,
0.8490049839019775,
0.42582497000694275,
0.7145199775695801,
-0.2595881223678589,
-0.49709758162498474,
-0.09249673783779144,
-0.9603267908096313,
-0.19906195998191833,
0.28782084584236145,
0.5482473373413086,
-0.2639519274234772,
0.36426421999931335,
0.04600205272436142,
0.4702167212963104,
-0.544235110282898,
-0.2583203911781311,
0.27541688084602356,
-0.4833376407623291,
0.22009766101837158,
0.03267241269350052,
1.0477455854415894,
0.7354544997215271,
0.2880995571613312,
-0.03897292539477348,
0.0174635648727417,
0.01025755051523447,
0.1706545203924179,
-0.7682130932807922,
0.10679378360509872,
0.2907264232635498,
-0.48341789841651917,
-0.36529478430747986,
-0.6424293518066406,
-0.8872827291488647,
-0.7055083513259888,
0.007481508422642946,
0.24006041884422302,
-0.1871582269668579,
-0.6080738306045532,
0.14044205844402313,
0.04500073939561844,
-0.062375735491514206,
0.22048461437225342,
-0.4337386190891266,
-0.11557218432426453,
0.4663161337375641,
0.7902798056602478,
-0.3907688856124878,
-0.5269308090209961,
-0.5267099142074585,
-0.08260015398263931,
-0.4122507572174072,
0.9857532382011414,
-0.49544429779052734,
-0.6422017812728882,
0.18115012347698212,
0.04100099578499794,
0.2507108449935913,
-0.7157753705978394,
1.1961469650268555,
-0.2810996174812317,
0.14137855172157288,
-0.46517711877822876,
0.051097847521305084,
0.1238645389676094,
0.21473625302314758,
-0.3923480212688446,
0.7894595861434937,
-0.07084359973669052,
-0.8326621651649475,
0.3481678068637848,
-0.35264134407043457,
-0.5553014278411865,
-0.03048096038401127,
0.07656548917293549,
-0.22962096333503723,
-0.15763849020004272,
-0.2286815047264099,
0.3640952706336975,
-0.11339405924081802,
0.2606293261051178,
-0.5961239337921143,
-0.3128659129142761,
0.19538581371307373,
-0.5517817735671997,
0.9897617101669312,
0.5856056213378906,
-0.006441249046474695,
0.5463850498199463,
-0.6412938237190247,
0.12197090685367584,
-0.04427822679281235,
-0.7043020129203796,
-0.5209481120109558,
-0.12303446233272552,
0.5148609280586243,
0.8456193804740906,
-0.07415559142827988,
-0.6607828736305237,
-0.29036450386047363,
0.0023520186077803373,
0.3125075697898865,
0.6511616110801697,
0.10564664006233215,
0.4332124590873718,
-0.3956814110279083,
0.6361260414123535,
0.10084744542837143,
0.4552003741264343,
-0.18797685205936432,
-0.5490790605545044,
-0.46312975883483887,
-0.06253741681575775,
-0.002262001857161522,
0.6258115172386169,
-0.7624422311782837,
0.2747650742530823,
-0.33067068457603455,
-0.6900789737701416,
-0.06176743656396866,
-0.23622499406337738,
0.5118544101715088,
0.48551902174949646,
0.18188302218914032,
-0.0415555015206337,
-0.23371361196041107,
-0.817555844783783,
-0.5361791253089905,
-0.3539276123046875,
-0.1733408272266388,
0.29521796107292175,
0.29455751180648804,
-0.30468446016311646,
0.4686959683895111,
-0.28145384788513184,
-0.00707154581323266,
-0.23498262465000153,
0.2723073661327362,
-0.09524620324373245,
0.3201867341995239,
0.5884743928909302,
-0.3430642783641815,
-0.6931604146957397,
-0.12514841556549072,
-0.8313581347465515,
-0.6940227746963501,
-0.058249667286872864,
0.07351535558700562,
0.12842294573783875,
0.47931647300720215,
-0.3428947329521179,
0.009212384931743145,
0.6041955351829529,
-0.6589046120643616,
0.7755691409111023,
-0.3604290783405304,
0.1472179889678955,
-0.8574658632278442,
0.01665434055030346,
0.29241254925727844,
-0.22975963354110718,
-0.7998719215393066,
0.2975509464740753,
0.4244120419025421,
-0.3367792069911957,
-1.1452162265777588,
0.8134306073188782,
-0.26412832736968994,
0.163644939661026,
-0.17218326032161713,
0.143865168094635,
0.11737167090177536,
0.24101734161376953,
0.385638952255249,
0.8191439509391785,
0.2575233578681946,
-0.5693390369415283,
0.14281348884105682,
0.00572941591963172,
-0.349403440952301,
0.6848529577255249,
-0.5055696368217468,
-0.11417284607887268,
-0.20017698407173157,
0.31840381026268005,
-0.6612934470176697,
0.050162360072135925,
0.21618308126926422,
-0.09432675689458847,
0.1534617841243744,
-0.13508403301239014,
-0.6812751889228821,
-0.17108629643917084,
-0.37964269518852234,
0.6089532375335693,
0.20864573121070862,
-0.3155977129936218,
0.23767906427383423,
0.5623854994773865,
-0.4494403004646301,
-0.5335387587547302,
-0.7589969635009766,
0.3613840937614441,
-0.6806768178939819,
-0.6671544313430786,
-0.08860085159540176,
-0.31623634696006775,
-0.48309534788131714,
-0.3732336759567261,
0.14547136425971985,
0.018720753490924835,
0.21565556526184082,
0.24766604602336884,
0.011789211072027683,
0.05635974928736687,
0.28296351432800293,
0.02977677993476391,
-0.2144199013710022,
0.39105403423309326,
0.35638347268104553,
0.39778953790664673,
-0.09569671005010605,
-0.24929767847061157,
-0.1747276932001114,
0.7600196599960327,
0.6243575215339661,
-0.11801593750715256,
0.5304684638977051,
0.6278685927391052,
-0.3327396512031555,
-0.1463260054588318,
-0.2530815303325653,
-0.03564789891242981,
-0.42940422892570496,
0.4795745313167572,
-0.08065631985664368,
-0.8281364440917969,
0.5600935220718384,
-0.16944481432437897,
-0.08779622614383698,
0.41169342398643494,
0.6492646336555481,
-0.05365019291639328,
0.979461133480072,
0.45743897557258606,
-0.16824108362197876,
0.37454983592033386,
0.18007126450538635,
0.01867523230612278,
-0.6613501310348511,
-0.14439181983470917,
-0.6740461587905884,
-0.08058434724807739,
-0.6663964986801147,
-0.487623929977417,
0.8432361483573914,
-0.38285207748413086,
-0.6194241046905518,
0.037095483392477036,
-0.1520683318376541,
0.48338812589645386,
0.31178390979766846,
0.121488556265831,
0.3786389231681824,
-0.18151159584522247,
-0.2014862447977066,
-0.21122746169567108,
-0.7073219418525696,
-0.6822620630264282,
0.9381222724914551,
0.7545055150985718,
0.8463990092277527,
0.2582336366176605,
0.4781959652900696,
0.40644386410713196,
0.6814208030700684,
-0.6632134914398193,
0.5769705772399902,
-0.0510874018073082,
-0.8618459105491638,
-0.19872739911079407,
-0.4253390431404114,
-0.7831444144248962,
0.3492376506328583,
-0.2790818214416504,
-0.6627822518348694,
0.15363653004169464,
-0.21309718489646912,
-0.641736626625061,
0.1302260458469391,
-0.8741060495376587,
1.0447145700454712,
-0.5641447901725769,
-0.5223665237426758,
-0.22988776862621307,
-0.7190634608268738,
0.4488103687763214,
-0.24705183506011963,
0.7825884819030762,
-0.28612568974494934,
-0.25881528854370117,
0.552472710609436,
-0.19618088006973267,
1.0505355596542358,
-0.07220049947500229,
-0.6825261116027832,
0.3067408800125122,
0.37088102102279663,
0.4027554392814636,
0.20652982592582703,
-0.2799851596355438,
0.4562571942806244,
0.06018104404211044,
-0.15670761466026306,
-0.14866644144058228,
0.9284228086471558,
-0.5767764449119568,
-0.3537085950374603,
-0.6162912845611572,
-0.6228668093681335,
-0.23910105228424072,
0.3088472783565521,
0.13007201254367828,
0.08144744485616684,
-0.06564731150865555,
-0.21110846102237701,
0.5398192405700684,
-0.9847440123558044,
0.5309798717498779,
0.8525614142417908,
-0.25328972935676575,
-0.13478025794029236,
0.9722030758857727,
-0.0767931342124939,
0.3697223961353302,
0.1815255880355835,
0.39364200830459595,
-0.5101557970046997,
-0.42801517248153687,
-0.44630080461502075,
0.3421044647693634,
-0.9328261613845825,
-0.19824528694152832,
-0.4456532299518585,
-0.02380751073360443,
-0.18771511316299438,
0.14183147251605988,
-0.33275359869003296,
-0.1623959094285965,
-0.22497716546058655,
-0.15636859834194183,
0.013835959136486053,
0.670599639415741,
-0.32483306527137756,
0.1496131271123886,
-1.145958423614502,
-0.09316649287939072,
0.11735216528177261,
0.5696402788162231,
-0.33607208728790283,
-0.5283001065254211,
-0.10965962707996368,
0.07635779678821564,
-0.1768062561750412,
-0.9302070140838623,
0.481036901473999,
-0.022146351635456085,
0.38009631633758545,
0.2582969665527344,
0.4070603549480438,
0.30257299542427063,
-0.6474611759185791,
0.8323261141777039,
0.10521745681762695,
-0.6259840130805969,
0.3433879613876343,
-0.6087630391120911,
0.17610086500644684,
0.24916207790374756,
0.6592975854873657,
-1.1111860275268555,
-0.4405082166194916,
-0.22117853164672852,
-0.7716858983039856,
0.6027450561523438,
-0.17718461155891418,
0.2457760125398636,
-0.25833263993263245,
0.13578249514102936,
0.11409569531679153,
-0.16992557048797607,
-0.8995397090911865,
-0.20848196744918823,
0.20259839296340942,
-0.08307666331529617,
-0.23814086616039276,
-0.8104103207588196,
-0.13515391945838928,
0.16169755160808563,
0.39616668224334717,
0.06706276535987854,
0.035929515957832336,
-0.04196447879076004,
-0.21421489119529724,
-0.3599378168582916,
0.6576226949691772,
0.7640714049339294,
0.408308744430542,
-0.16636796295642853,
0.475362092256546,
0.289701908826828,
-0.3138813376426697,
0.5153043270111084,
-0.21610483527183533,
-0.1074422225356102,
-0.218877911567688,
0.7114983201026917,
0.3898555338382721,
0.3376657962799072,
-1.1103111505508423,
0.5073083639144897,
-0.2608935236930847,
0.15746985375881195,
-0.16440366208553314,
-0.15942755341529846,
0.16759678721427917,
0.2875502109527588,
-0.08716706931591034,
-0.13656200468540192,
0.19972312450408936,
-0.613328754901886,
0.2817001938819885,
0.21695217490196228,
-0.2862708270549774,
-0.29757219552993774,
0.6304450035095215,
0.5690732598304749,
-0.24110949039459229,
0.3781820237636566,
-0.24110880494117737,
-0.31248360872268677,
0.27256304025650024,
0.41989317536354065,
0.7025052905082703,
-0.41519975662231445,
0.3782459497451782,
0.527827799320221,
0.522362470626831,
0.07163520902395248,
0.3766796886920929,
0.3626277446746826,
-0.7917465567588806,
-0.5316293835639954,
-0.6259475350379944,
-0.2531485855579376,
0.06584038585424423,
-0.47964611649513245,
0.08868937939405441,
-0.31223857402801514,
-0.18175853788852692,
-0.1418723464012146,
-0.19728554785251617,
-0.297491192817688,
0.055299073457717896,
0.5583078861236572,
1.0480191707611084,
-1.440464735031128,
0.6580550074577332,
0.6251227855682373,
-0.280067503452301,
-0.5733752250671387,
-0.01935371197760105,
0.17417651414871216,
-0.6650118827819824,
0.8309395909309387,
0.046525515615940094,
0.06394577771425247,
-0.32546913623809814,
-0.006609801668673754,
-0.642403244972229,
0.8468748927116394,
0.4168054759502411,
-0.5778158903121948,
0.12630608677864075,
0.5523629784584045,
0.8397474884986877,
-0.07735675573348999,
0.5298689603805542,
0.36322590708732605,
0.500796377658844,
-0.1639384925365448,
-1.2332838773727417,
0.18627500534057617,
-0.16402137279510498,
-0.0303404089063406,
-0.04191247373819351,
-0.6848597526550293,
0.7465683221817017,
-0.3767651319503784,
-0.41719725728034973,
-0.17536424100399017,
0.2843095660209656,
0.30104145407676697,
0.4442952871322632,
0.6456455588340759,
0.4765894412994385,
0.4258555471897125,
0.08695203065872192,
1.1393916606903076,
-0.2762719392776489,
0.162822887301445,
1.075914740562439,
-0.5240201950073242,
1.0399441719055176,
0.40960726141929626,
-0.265521764755249,
0.3120821416378021,
0.8240998387336731,
0.7279053330421448,
0.30274584889411926,
0.2860415279865265,
-0.5025048851966858,
-0.44244199991226196,
-0.6147430539131165,
-0.19649146497249603,
0.23370493948459625,
0.41177526116371155,
-0.2987995445728302,
-0.49551913142204285,
0.30194124579429626,
0.24215759336948395,
0.12185869365930557,
-0.25945916771888733,
0.5557963252067566,
0.22827047109603882,
-0.5562873482704163,
0.5835602283477783,
0.19340282678604126,
0.6562447547912598,
-0.41893744468688965,
0.1442449986934662,
-0.3181380033493042,
0.12426018714904785,
-0.1425454020500183,
-1.1959009170532227,
0.6213852763175964,
0.05874002352356911,
0.1827923059463501,
-0.5017837882041931,
0.7262840270996094,
-0.4633236527442932,
-0.5310558676719666,
0.5489710569381714,
0.6582729816436768,
0.12636905908584595,
-0.2276049554347992,
-0.6262040734291077,
0.40235933661460876,
-0.22124603390693665,
-0.18972191214561462,
0.6426301598548889,
0.43020734190940857,
-0.4550122618675232,
1.0467787981033325,
0.36837783455848694,
0.17926162481307983,
0.09587801992893219,
0.2587924301624298,
0.7329131960868835,
-0.6392940282821655,
-0.21535487473011017,
-0.692002534866333,
0.5028764605522156,
0.21292495727539062,
-0.13546420633792877,
0.6577443480491638,
0.3263682723045349,
0.7217764258384705,
-0.1077948734164238,
0.7574699521064758,
0.11793268471956253,
0.516146719455719,
-0.2605161964893341,
0.7851266860961914,
-0.44912824034690857,
0.45327624678611755,
-0.1825142502784729,
-0.5897993445396423,
-0.5926735997200012,
0.31598329544067383,
-0.11902932822704315,
0.035520583391189575,
0.7561678886413574,
0.7790284156799316,
0.2790411710739136,
-0.12642137706279755,
0.3488006293773651,
0.29190289974212646,
0.406793475151062,
0.6571968197822571,
1.1440448760986328,
-0.0936271920800209,
0.6631641387939453,
-0.6024737358093262,
-0.3277556598186493,
-0.11509809643030167,
-1.2885332107543945,
-0.6839938759803772,
-0.45103296637535095,
-0.38520145416259766,
-0.3008412718772888,
-0.09775916486978531,
0.8464473485946655,
0.4001328945159912,
-0.5600900053977966,
-0.2762022912502289,
0.43494701385498047,
0.328960657119751,
-0.0924687460064888,
-0.20289163291454315,
0.12436764687299728,
-0.23865312337875366,
-0.6160560846328735,
0.3782038688659668,
0.37874987721443176,
-0.06634866446256638,
-0.41724303364753723,
-0.14809878170490265,
0.005624369718134403,
-0.3104840815067291,
1.0421053171157837,
0.1932753473520279,
-0.6180657744407654,
-0.7413552403450012,
-0.04439011216163635,
-0.2813100218772888,
-0.33270567655563354,
0.6673809885978699,
-0.34882423281669617,
0.36680305004119873,
0.6013582348823547,
0.12057796865701675,
-0.18994225561618805,
-0.3060481548309326,
0.5172293186187744,
-0.8220517039299011,
0.20403282344341278,
0.3873077929019928,
0.40849703550338745,
0.21410571038722992,
-0.4314233660697937,
0.4334774613380432,
0.10951274633407593,
-0.6498005390167236,
-0.9074637293815613,
0.4223407506942749,
-0.9198880791664124,
-0.26535046100616455,
1.7565138339996338,
-0.2946399748325348,
0.021559514105319977,
-0.24185632169246674,
-0.32078346610069275,
0.1034330353140831,
-0.27344954013824463,
0.7642641663551331,
0.5241756439208984,
-0.03594747930765152,
-0.2544887065887451,
-0.6828144788742065,
0.4547581374645233,
0.18036487698554993,
-0.9042532444000244,
0.4592021405696869,
0.5707545280456543,
0.6516944766044617,
0.33335328102111816,
0.650611937046051,
-0.17951039969921112,
0.1883707046508789,
-0.1694163680076599,
0.14785785973072052,
0.1801111400127411,
-0.4052744209766388,
-0.3914676904678345,
0.09030497074127197,
0.3886439800262451,
0.2604072093963623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14395v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14395v1
|
PARAMANU-GANITA: Language Model with Mathematical Capabilities
| 2024-04-22T17:55:56 | 2024-04-22T17:55:56 |
Mitodru Niyogi, Arnab Bhattacharya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we present Paramanu-Ganita, a 208 million parameter novel Auto
Regressive (AR) decoder based language model on mathematics. The model is
pretrained from scratch at context size of 4096 on our curated mixed
mathematical corpus. We evaluate our model on both perplexity metric and GSM8k
mathematical benchmark. Paramanu-Ganita despite being 35 times smaller than 7B
LLMs, outperformed generalist LLMs such as LLaMa-1 7B by 28.4% points, LLaMa-2
7B by 27.6% points, Falcon 7B by 32.6% points, PaLM 8B by 35.3% points, and
math specialised LLMs such as Minerva 8B by 23.2% points, and LLEMMA-7B by 3.0%
points in GSM8k test accuracy metric respectively. Paramanu-Ganita also
outperformed giant LLMs like PaLM 62B by 6.4% points, Falcon 40B by 19.8%
points, LLaMa-1 33B by 3.8% points and Vicuna 13B by 11.8% points respectively.
The large significant margin improvement in performance of our math model over
the existing LLMs signifies that reasoning capabilities of language model are
just not restricted to LLMs with humongous number of parameters.
Paramanu-Ganita took 146 hours of A100 training whereas math specialised LLM,
LLEMMA 7B, was trained for 23,000 A100 hours of training equivalent. Thus, our
approach of pretraining powerful domain specialised language models from
scratch for domain adaptation is much more cost-effective than performing
continual training of LLMs for domain adaptation. Hence, we conclude that for
strong mathematical reasoning abilities of language model, we do not need giant
LLMs and immense computing power to our end. In the end, we want to point out
that we have only trained Paramanu-Ganita only on a part of our entire
mathematical corpus and yet to explore the full potential of our model.
|
[
-0.44107937812805176,
-0.9047220945358276,
0.2987823486328125,
0.33644384145736694,
-0.4243742525577545,
-0.002067117253318429,
-0.23628151416778564,
-0.23926810920238495,
-0.04784783720970154,
0.5378938913345337,
-0.2649151384830475,
-0.32530534267425537,
-0.7646682262420654,
0.21834519505500793,
-0.2913185954093933,
1.0411021709442139,
-0.044536806643009186,
0.09985977411270142,
-0.14798399806022644,
-0.24089834094047546,
-0.30459675192832947,
-0.6323885321617126,
-0.8177438378334045,
-0.1514108031988144,
0.2958945631980896,
-0.015737755224108696,
0.774453341960907,
0.7386478781700134,
0.47088518738746643,
0.2871747314929962,
0.06602871417999268,
0.16222096979618073,
-0.2495151162147522,
-0.30170994997024536,
0.23989836871623993,
-0.8523711562156677,
-0.6851383447647095,
0.03567713499069214,
0.5923639535903931,
0.564775288105011,
-0.4706166982650757,
0.09447377920150757,
-0.03106187842786312,
0.5872063636779785,
-0.3877798020839691,
0.4131332039833069,
-0.602299690246582,
-0.19378764927387238,
-0.3957656919956207,
-0.01769031211733818,
-0.3161925673484802,
-0.16699469089508057,
-0.2555695176124573,
-0.7985703945159912,
-0.0010514953173696995,
-0.04562152549624443,
0.9268800020217896,
0.4228401780128479,
-0.290942519903183,
-0.2955665588378906,
-0.8004248738288879,
0.882411003112793,
-0.8353855609893799,
0.32624292373657227,
0.4950660765171051,
0.7010950446128845,
-0.004358350299298763,
-0.5034183263778687,
-0.509482204914093,
-0.24993310868740082,
0.2645661532878876,
0.006476766429841518,
-0.3069111704826355,
-0.21379084885120392,
0.37118813395500183,
0.341525673866272,
-0.5569579601287842,
-0.18419314920902252,
-0.30784228444099426,
0.1145147904753685,
0.5610935091972351,
0.3093295693397522,
0.5270320773124695,
-0.1662266105413437,
-0.10564558953046799,
-0.054411303251981735,
-0.8422462940216064,
0.03755604103207588,
0.5676853060722351,
-0.05308280512690544,
-0.039997465908527374,
0.3360041677951813,
-0.04120055213570595,
0.8802819848060608,
-0.25147703289985657,
-0.2702172100543976,
-0.20662666857242584,
-0.10074758529663086,
-0.40580978989601135,
-0.4082810878753662,
1.0635582208633423,
-0.37112295627593994,
0.3830892741680145,
-0.09871862083673477,
-0.197404682636261,
0.35410067439079285,
0.02517089806497097,
-0.7944818735122681,
-0.3642980456352234,
-0.33425208926200867,
-0.3768153786659241,
-0.012115604244172573,
-0.24063917994499207,
-0.6848254799842834,
0.015992622822523117,
-0.4182489812374115,
0.2750229835510254,
-0.7957810759544373,
-0.41396138072013855,
0.40559443831443787,
0.5692906379699707,
0.3401855230331421,
0.46441519260406494,
-0.9844264388084412,
0.5591574311256409,
0.8127921223640442,
0.7169973254203796,
0.004464102443307638,
-0.27602532505989075,
-0.26419439911842346,
-0.10526105761528015,
-0.48056620359420776,
0.7868456840515137,
-0.8212458491325378,
-0.3287617564201355,
-0.4015282392501831,
-0.3327619731426239,
-0.31575703620910645,
-0.5632367134094238,
0.7633379101753235,
-0.7417425513267517,
0.22298535704612732,
-0.13820193707942963,
-0.4158463180065155,
-0.44033509492874146,
0.0627073124051094,
-0.737180769443512,
0.6953036189079285,
0.1775055080652237,
-0.5399062633514404,
0.14529839158058167,
-0.689480721950531,
-0.23660051822662354,
0.20867137610912323,
-0.21660840511322021,
-0.4924502670764923,
-0.01200898364186287,
0.4180205464363098,
0.17018723487854004,
-0.8499622941017151,
0.7114169597625732,
-0.4053358733654022,
-0.3012014329433441,
0.31355229020118713,
-0.679926872253418,
0.916140079498291,
0.538223922252655,
-0.19882750511169434,
-0.10732133686542511,
-0.9390064477920532,
-0.22184449434280396,
0.36674919724464417,
-0.16592934727668762,
-0.26771974563598633,
-0.2294098436832428,
-0.18883419036865234,
0.17377221584320068,
0.30772319436073303,
-0.21888326108455658,
-0.03590685501694679,
-0.3725228011608124,
0.5726637244224548,
0.5664442777633667,
-0.41295817494392395,
0.471221923828125,
-0.23465794324874878,
1.1078506708145142,
0.021076492965221405,
0.05213067680597305,
0.08318089693784714,
-0.56770920753479,
-0.8907424807548523,
-0.4640236496925354,
0.6768009066581726,
0.5706738829612732,
-0.8680482506752014,
0.36224785447120667,
-0.20241940021514893,
-0.41498154401779175,
-0.5157986283302307,
0.4735146462917328,
0.38814157247543335,
0.5957564115524292,
0.10298978537321091,
0.051576483994722366,
-0.5932883024215698,
-0.8752599358558655,
-0.32951241731643677,
-0.08602169901132584,
-0.06674908101558685,
0.16038744151592255,
0.48755526542663574,
-0.2678534686565399,
0.6644524335861206,
-0.36419185996055603,
-0.32295602560043335,
-0.4292850196361542,
0.04725321754813194,
0.4454035460948944,
0.11463224142789841,
0.6974690556526184,
-0.5284820199012756,
-0.5829670429229736,
-0.029617179185152054,
-1.1366069316864014,
-0.08299664407968521,
0.013424716889858246,
-0.27105090022087097,
0.23101906478405,
0.21842744946479797,
-0.6484674215316772,
0.32027390599250793,
0.6280202269554138,
-0.1842402070760727,
0.27374398708343506,
-0.2685502767562866,
-0.018224569037556648,
-1.2476023435592651,
0.14196422696113586,
0.24263301491737366,
-0.20148052275180817,
-0.45522576570510864,
0.23149505257606506,
0.12098843604326248,
-0.4287838339805603,
-0.15321287512779236,
0.5631770491600037,
-0.6070781350135803,
0.10454864799976349,
-0.4905868470668793,
-0.048241209238767624,
-0.22141090035438538,
0.7284089922904968,
-0.012489496730268002,
1.0822117328643799,
0.6667351722717285,
-0.7762024402618408,
0.37163159251213074,
0.07624437659978867,
-0.3426160216331482,
0.2569833993911743,
-0.8601524829864502,
0.030487852171063423,
0.03754439949989319,
0.12233290821313858,
-0.8007394671440125,
0.04691575840115547,
0.281895250082016,
-0.3993290364742279,
0.1959453821182251,
-0.010050229728221893,
-0.4706997275352478,
-0.19497184455394745,
0.14873453974723816,
0.6518314480781555,
0.7332077026367188,
-0.3749611973762512,
0.8111583590507507,
0.5376527905464172,
-0.3774924576282501,
-0.41841375827789307,
-0.4247059226036072,
0.28799542784690857,
-0.4362589716911316,
-0.6515726447105408,
-0.06210724636912346,
-0.17372524738311768,
-0.223981574177742,
0.08020511269569397,
0.176712766289711,
-0.045609209686517715,
0.02778414823114872,
0.020394902676343918,
0.4387623071670532,
-0.44297343492507935,
-0.21654394268989563,
0.08833397924900055,
-0.4379020631313324,
0.2592868208885193,
0.012093188241124153,
0.642233669757843,
-0.4959692656993866,
-0.18831074237823486,
-0.40848851203918457,
0.16582415997982025,
0.4710254371166229,
-0.4129512906074524,
0.7352151274681091,
0.5123128890991211,
-0.5310297608375549,
-0.024051913991570473,
-0.3346388339996338,
0.28255411982536316,
-0.4561592936515808,
0.2502284348011017,
-0.8714641332626343,
-0.7097842693328857,
0.7374493479728699,
-0.023189201951026917,
-0.0909733921289444,
0.7735365629196167,
0.4148489534854889,
0.4430200159549713,
1.0975606441497803,
0.5273810029029846,
-0.18146836757659912,
0.48050427436828613,
-0.506446361541748,
0.2984267473220825,
-0.9777449369430542,
-0.23483948409557343,
-0.3247978985309601,
-0.006160031538456678,
-0.33832916617393494,
-0.3297405540943146,
0.17708811163902283,
0.29072150588035583,
-0.10228386521339417,
0.583422064781189,
-0.37978285551071167,
0.40568220615386963,
0.3257012665271759,
0.11151652038097382,
0.17998073995113373,
0.0037654617335647345,
0.05021651089191437,
-0.2593015432357788,
-0.7678030729293823,
-0.5749577879905701,
1.5499451160430908,
0.4777247905731201,
0.9222984910011292,
0.29064199328422546,
0.5677211284637451,
-0.18841946125030518,
0.4700373113155365,
-0.6334618330001831,
0.7228835821151733,
-0.1757066249847412,
-0.43401503562927246,
-0.2983722388744354,
-0.7864289879798889,
-0.9730901122093201,
0.16081617772579193,
0.1217280849814415,
-0.09453173726797104,
-0.06333445012569427,
-0.18359392881393433,
-0.39367470145225525,
0.3523455560207367,
-0.6708436608314514,
0.6703699231147766,
-0.28777071833610535,
-0.17015331983566284,
-0.1295618712902069,
-0.19211041927337646,
0.7227924466133118,
-0.2207794189453125,
0.35446810722351074,
-0.1121504008769989,
-0.10307237505912781,
0.9184865951538086,
-0.5137783288955688,
0.5957511067390442,
-0.09630060940980911,
-0.33868607878685,
0.3664163053035736,
0.2901301383972168,
0.40621206164360046,
0.4818902909755707,
-0.0018354849889874458,
0.26360076665878296,
-0.07989180833101273,
-0.6641078591346741,
-0.9499064087867737,
0.8937978148460388,
-1.0798532962799072,
-0.9170281291007996,
-0.6404958367347717,
-0.8001717329025269,
-0.27316057682037354,
0.13163194060325623,
0.1136932373046875,
0.5166837573051453,
0.004107682500034571,
0.12884248793125153,
0.863525390625,
-0.0763775035738945,
0.552557110786438,
0.4841442406177521,
-0.1881248503923416,
-0.8620609641075134,
0.979110836982727,
0.0941440612077713,
-0.050387345254421234,
0.5116999745368958,
0.2141275852918625,
-0.5587884187698364,
-0.4797689914703369,
-0.6233446002006531,
0.6426976919174194,
-0.56856369972229,
-0.29407137632369995,
-0.73905348777771,
-0.396477609872818,
-0.4420718848705292,
0.2488662749528885,
-0.3611837923526764,
-0.3138846457004547,
-0.5547388195991516,
0.20146019756793976,
0.4514659643173218,
0.7324205636978149,
0.1907908171415329,
0.10950189083814621,
-0.6738436818122864,
0.43962618708610535,
0.34764862060546875,
0.32677721977233887,
0.05628012493252754,
-1.0249041318893433,
-0.12950997054576874,
0.0825909897685051,
-0.1582709103822708,
-0.5652713179588318,
0.8292779326438904,
0.1998918354511261,
0.6987931728363037,
0.44186490774154663,
-0.17916357517242432,
0.8798650503158569,
-0.4851457178592682,
0.3356742262840271,
0.12843726575374603,
-1.0349377393722534,
0.3240981101989746,
-0.4111917316913605,
0.16627395153045654,
0.250192791223526,
0.5276464223861694,
-0.06516441702842712,
-0.11466832458972931,
-0.7061205506324768,
-0.22895310819149017,
0.5891413688659668,
0.22904479503631592,
0.15464651584625244,
0.1114523857831955,
0.6211381554603577,
0.19558174908161163,
0.13312400877475739,
-0.7770702242851257,
-0.17015329003334045,
-0.25875887274742126,
-0.28694185614585876,
-0.3905172049999237,
-0.3334130644798279,
-0.18274623155593872,
-0.49241408705711365,
0.4851955473423004,
-0.022835657000541687,
0.4638165831565857,
-0.22484740614891052,
-0.18225301802158356,
-0.03472623974084854,
0.09925141930580139,
0.9312598705291748,
0.9563590288162231,
0.04413127899169922,
0.028912486508488655,
0.24409162998199463,
-0.5050346851348877,
0.2690345048904419,
0.38847705721855164,
0.10041660815477371,
-0.017624706029891968,
0.34833797812461853,
1.0851249694824219,
0.12111283093690872,
-0.5291501879692078,
0.2720339298248291,
-0.27397578954696655,
-0.27219849824905396,
-0.38986653089523315,
0.08731263130903244,
0.09468208998441696,
-0.025430575013160706,
0.2531259059906006,
0.15700066089630127,
0.15845058858394623,
-0.4853723645210266,
0.03829585760831833,
0.35185790061950684,
0.0920775830745697,
-0.5315095782279968,
1.0714595317840576,
-0.007586087100207806,
-0.32321658730506897,
0.34908297657966614,
-0.3064146339893341,
-0.4600917100906372,
0.5221386551856995,
0.8626375198364258,
0.8168391585350037,
-0.425572007894516,
0.12745952606201172,
0.29819634556770325,
0.13180245459079742,
-0.1451566517353058,
0.14443425834178925,
0.047519586980342865,
-0.4918214976787567,
-0.45184311270713806,
-0.9121114611625671,
-0.31981685757637024,
0.22651590406894684,
-0.6337417364120483,
0.2894294857978821,
-0.7930981516838074,
0.062371350824832916,
-0.21308502554893494,
0.35415905714035034,
-0.3996804654598236,
0.32185855507850647,
-0.1788809448480606,
0.7386094331741333,
-0.843670666217804,
1.2165216207504272,
0.7862454056739807,
-0.44647130370140076,
-0.8566321730613708,
-0.3412265181541443,
-0.4660830795764923,
-1.0886585712432861,
0.7264041304588318,
-0.13950702548027039,
-0.13213308155536652,
0.053637806326150894,
-0.2370493859052658,
-0.9361138939857483,
1.0769671201705933,
0.8336634039878845,
-0.6741721630096436,
-0.1849932223558426,
0.16734793782234192,
0.6884180903434753,
-0.36382588744163513,
0.25084686279296875,
0.5342124700546265,
-0.021248124539852142,
0.24120911955833435,
-0.6454586982727051,
0.13261330127716064,
-0.5660803318023682,
0.4305931329727173,
0.4409385621547699,
-0.7198924422264099,
1.115781307220459,
0.02921181544661522,
-0.13532370328903198,
0.2067420333623886,
1.0723451375961304,
0.3797287046909332,
0.08421839773654938,
0.2385808378458023,
0.9800037145614624,
0.5084785223007202,
-0.016057396307587624,
1.1884357929229736,
-0.5282865762710571,
0.3219096064567566,
0.5898038744926453,
-0.09139688313007355,
0.8457192182540894,
0.10931851714849472,
-0.5599669814109802,
0.4663550555706024,
0.6195996403694153,
0.30357825756073,
0.39394211769104004,
0.14597570896148682,
-0.4033501148223877,
-0.5585225224494934,
0.29018864035606384,
-0.5568770170211792,
0.2771740257740021,
0.38684019446372986,
-0.05031363666057587,
-0.26516130566596985,
0.178167462348938,
0.10559950768947601,
0.2895527780056,
-0.04509779438376427,
0.4424147307872772,
0.4318503737449646,
-0.5664258003234863,
1.0052800178527832,
0.19073602557182312,
0.6983084678649902,
-0.6710723042488098,
0.032307177782058716,
-0.41352158784866333,
0.23252876102924347,
0.12418287992477417,
-0.3893347680568695,
0.43385693430900574,
0.09719113260507584,
0.13597646355628967,
0.02891344204545021,
0.5121663212776184,
-0.34547126293182373,
-0.8570451736450195,
0.1250917911529541,
0.30473363399505615,
0.16969531774520874,
-0.22047370672225952,
-0.9232808351516724,
0.16240748763084412,
-0.14405027031898499,
-0.06927706301212311,
0.49458223581314087,
0.7569257616996765,
-0.08070914447307587,
0.8995108604431152,
0.7719561457633972,
0.14857396483421326,
0.173232302069664,
-0.0016540917567908764,
0.8241196870803833,
-0.7828626036643982,
-0.4376417100429535,
-0.8773568868637085,
-0.09817542135715485,
0.3367741107940674,
-0.4063473641872406,
0.8620135188102722,
0.5674763917922974,
0.6865423321723938,
-0.11170550435781479,
0.6594637632369995,
0.23359143733978271,
0.30901142954826355,
-0.6693525910377502,
0.6520280838012695,
-0.5053315162658691,
0.46651557087898254,
-0.05951355770230293,
-1.069942831993103,
-0.5259016752243042,
0.6820967197418213,
-0.6527427434921265,
0.20221705734729767,
0.629202663898468,
0.548970639705658,
-0.1628130078315735,
-0.06749216467142105,
0.6093549132347107,
-0.1766168177127838,
0.3562126159667969,
1.0554172992706299,
0.8007243275642395,
-0.8412349820137024,
0.8619542717933655,
-0.14747574925422668,
-0.3503080904483795,
-0.004251557402312756,
-0.5404338836669922,
-1.2158697843551636,
-0.4782589375972748,
-0.317103773355484,
-0.19533123075962067,
-0.22490441799163818,
0.5057098269462585,
0.421012818813324,
-0.7270426154136658,
-0.490335613489151,
-0.5246157646179199,
-0.15044070780277252,
-0.018594294786453247,
-0.22277145087718964,
0.4073464274406433,
-0.3062286376953125,
-1.0516377687454224,
0.19153772294521332,
0.2290055900812149,
0.03261170536279678,
-0.3765210509300232,
-0.3016539216041565,
-0.2131262570619583,
0.218580424785614,
0.5323715806007385,
0.3857225477695465,
-0.7599788308143616,
0.3080250024795532,
0.26510176062583923,
-0.15833646059036255,
0.09615474939346313,
0.6404602527618408,
-0.6456153988838196,
0.2281181663274765,
0.33397483825683594,
0.9555837512016296,
0.3709070086479187,
-0.17465686798095703,
0.722794771194458,
-0.009226208552718163,
0.3211888372898102,
0.1311856210231781,
0.5332338213920593,
0.222268745303154,
-0.3974054157733917,
0.34239840507507324,
0.46798062324523926,
-0.4765082597732544,
-0.7101279497146606,
0.21236559748649597,
-0.8241241574287415,
-0.20739689469337463,
1.2075998783111572,
-0.2812971770763397,
-0.5690896511077881,
0.19194981455802917,
-0.1634332537651062,
0.29634302854537964,
-0.23795129358768463,
0.7966084480285645,
0.768971860408783,
-0.04371079429984093,
-0.5288628935813904,
-0.46147531270980835,
0.4206671416759491,
0.6984474658966064,
-0.9246003031730652,
-0.20947836339473724,
0.04279916360974312,
0.4877013564109802,
0.03818947449326515,
0.5385693907737732,
-0.38072457909584045,
0.33839985728263855,
0.18669311702251434,
-0.087001271545887,
-0.3527812957763672,
-0.5376082062721252,
-0.5805495977401733,
0.013736260123550892,
0.13089288771152496,
-0.1728861778974533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14394v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14394v1
|
A Multimodal Automated Interpretability Agent
| 2024-04-22T17:55:11 | 2024-04-22T17:55:11 |
Tamar Rott Shaham, Sarah Schwettmann, Franklin Wang, Achyuta Rajaram, Evan Hernandez, Jacob Andreas, Antonio Torralba
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
This paper describes MAIA, a Multimodal Automated Interpretability Agent.
MAIA is a system that uses neural models to automate neural model understanding
tasks like feature interpretation and failure mode discovery. It equips a
pre-trained vision-language model with a set of tools that support iterative
experimentation on subcomponents of other models to explain their behavior.
These include tools commonly used by human interpretability researchers: for
synthesizing and editing inputs, computing maximally activating exemplars from
real-world datasets, and summarizing and describing experimental results.
Interpretability experiments proposed by MAIA compose these tools to describe
and explain system behavior. We evaluate applications of MAIA to computer
vision models. We first characterize MAIA's ability to describe (neuron-level)
features in learned representations of images. Across several trained models
and a novel dataset of synthetic vision neurons with paired ground-truth
descriptions, MAIA produces descriptions comparable to those generated by
expert human experimenters. We then show that MAIA can aid in two additional
interpretability tasks: reducing sensitivity to spurious features, and
automatically identifying inputs likely to be mis-classified.
|
[
-0.3840360641479492,
-0.6150948405265808,
0.64316326379776,
0.38405996561050415,
-0.20208047330379486,
-0.25402480363845825,
0.0669277161359787,
-0.4135826826095581,
0.3175627589225769,
0.25682035088539124,
-0.4297058582305908,
-0.3266106843948364,
-0.8379830121994019,
0.08029131591320038,
-0.6324968338012695,
0.8759942650794983,
-0.16791941225528717,
-0.00927148386836052,
-0.32428139448165894,
-0.2775777280330658,
-0.5958009958267212,
-0.1109340488910675,
-0.7466151118278503,
-0.5271373987197876,
0.6553995013237,
0.09385272115468979,
1.3266162872314453,
0.6624581813812256,
0.3191318213939667,
0.5221416354179382,
0.0935063436627388,
-0.07256285101175308,
-0.0576799213886261,
-0.03930356353521347,
-0.37257087230682373,
-0.6263715028762817,
-0.7496052384376526,
0.1869429051876068,
0.7286849021911621,
0.7038565874099731,
-0.12281236797571182,
-0.03439300134778023,
-0.041934676468372345,
0.20113492012023926,
-0.49208953976631165,
0.7154682278633118,
-0.282640278339386,
0.10959456861019135,
0.23232409358024597,
-0.2224310040473938,
-0.49731943011283875,
-0.20007571578025818,
0.08193038403987885,
-1.1492499113082886,
0.20903703570365906,
0.08541340380907059,
0.7707635164260864,
0.7611479759216309,
-0.45204100012779236,
-0.15213042497634888,
-0.2589472234249115,
0.722592830657959,
-0.38395431637763977,
0.17977392673492432,
0.5732725262641907,
0.8266539573669434,
-0.25702130794525146,
-0.560941219329834,
-0.6872282028198242,
-0.3562016189098358,
-0.6822096109390259,
0.06621306389570236,
-0.3704444169998169,
0.22782233357429504,
0.08938030153512955,
-0.03778734803199768,
-0.4927920699119568,
-0.19405408203601837,
-0.17028340697288513,
-0.5135401487350464,
0.43053144216537476,
0.20157301425933838,
0.4482162594795227,
-0.47309035062789917,
-0.18016666173934937,
-0.10238169133663177,
0.05951118469238281,
-0.03252594918012619,
0.1832733005285263,
-0.0865567997097969,
0.23782190680503845,
0.6522191166877747,
-0.37857872247695923,
0.8492559790611267,
-0.046431709080934525,
-0.10462682694196701,
0.26792314648628235,
0.04674288630485535,
-0.45082297921180725,
-0.19178056716918945,
0.2606252133846283,
0.24563196301460266,
0.1094295084476471,
-0.20253166556358337,
-0.2705964148044586,
0.2810157835483551,
0.6115256547927856,
-0.5497416257858276,
-0.4316420555114746,
0.1706472486257553,
-1.0200833082199097,
-0.488059937953949,
-0.1328800767660141,
-0.6336045861244202,
-0.7025628685951233,
-0.6600491404533386,
1.0688785314559937,
-0.6705268621444702,
-0.5695711970329285,
0.08662953227758408,
-0.3929378092288971,
0.22318001091480255,
0.46413692831993103,
-0.5341728925704956,
0.18081031739711761,
0.42708539962768555,
0.6456931829452515,
-0.1637030392885208,
-0.8225762248039246,
-0.7798381447792053,
-0.054550234228372574,
-0.2056860327720642,
0.7565259337425232,
-0.6714673042297363,
-0.1270972043275833,
-0.4284193515777588,
0.36656057834625244,
-0.37195757031440735,
-0.39593783020973206,
0.2727493643760681,
-0.723460853099823,
-0.27975139021873474,
0.1580851823091507,
-0.10772109776735306,
-0.8270423412322998,
0.3648567795753479,
-0.7384441494941711,
0.6787415146827698,
0.1077611893415451,
-0.26981183886528015,
0.5202022194862366,
-0.921861469745636,
-0.3994322717189789,
-0.03575453162193298,
0.11119594424962997,
-0.19949786365032196,
0.3609623312950134,
0.0473686121404171,
0.5813598036766052,
0.140614852309227,
0.41436684131622314,
-0.36585506796836853,
-0.28664156794548035,
0.6282609105110168,
-0.6585610508918762,
0.5987582802772522,
0.2664627432823181,
-0.3183704614639282,
0.3425263464450836,
-1.195762276649475,
0.23081974685192108,
0.05705718323588371,
-0.3794054090976715,
-0.15160837769508362,
0.11921839416027069,
0.18351195752620697,
0.06056397408246994,
-0.02172553353011608,
-0.28281843662261963,
-0.08468121290206909,
-0.05697004869580269,
0.3156946003437042,
0.6624738574028015,
-0.35831791162490845,
0.46559327840805054,
-0.19966433942317963,
0.6822372674942017,
0.0010285342577844858,
0.3298567235469818,
-0.3479480445384979,
-0.42651233077049255,
-1.0043370723724365,
-0.5027832984924316,
-0.06265058368444443,
0.3981113135814667,
-1.2000138759613037,
0.12103168666362762,
-0.09194440394639969,
-0.3669195771217346,
-0.47464749217033386,
0.12848953902721405,
0.7261356115341187,
0.6092644333839417,
0.3732944130897522,
-0.6057546138763428,
-0.09503481537103653,
-1.058454990386963,
-0.11163651198148727,
-0.20744499564170837,
0.15834777057170868,
0.093482606112957,
0.641810417175293,
-0.48204538226127625,
0.9755402207374573,
-0.47990649938583374,
-0.09742642194032669,
0.06314853578805923,
0.6847057938575745,
-0.057559333741664886,
0.4446330964565277,
0.6252376437187195,
-0.99272620677948,
0.08093635737895966,
0.03274855017662048,
-1.0793044567108154,
-0.10612857341766357,
-0.14582519233226776,
-0.28647276759147644,
-0.002801013644784689,
0.29778173565864563,
-0.3882952034473419,
0.8225864768028259,
0.46025365591049194,
-0.5651845932006836,
0.5093833208084106,
-0.564792811870575,
0.15926207602024078,
-0.8306451439857483,
0.01785481534898281,
0.020111791789531708,
-0.2522715628147125,
-0.637452244758606,
0.19801101088523865,
0.12014216184616089,
-0.05790136381983757,
-0.4144497215747833,
0.4592643976211548,
-0.4595123529434204,
-0.6835370659828186,
-0.42813822627067566,
-0.27680733799934387,
0.31217193603515625,
0.5309838056564331,
0.1997465044260025,
0.5848186016082764,
0.832585871219635,
-0.6475936770439148,
0.7126131653785706,
0.4138690233230591,
-0.18963153660297394,
1.1464005708694458,
-0.7541797161102295,
-0.17505189776420593,
-0.5732973217964172,
0.10399135202169418,
-1.0931533575057983,
-0.7231303453445435,
0.3297487795352936,
-0.5613282918930054,
0.15159392356872559,
-0.2896016240119934,
-0.3319666087627411,
0.1417665183544159,
0.12097044289112091,
0.3615665137767792,
0.1276254802942276,
-0.6939407587051392,
1.2891578674316406,
0.07325216382741928,
-0.06248662993311882,
-0.6194726824760437,
-0.7008675336837769,
0.2427474707365036,
-0.16952712833881378,
-0.7225958108901978,
-0.1316537708044052,
-0.08532221615314484,
-0.3733038008213043,
0.2805314064025879,
0.37591108679771423,
-0.3345205783843994,
0.38862425088882446,
0.687526524066925,
0.45909810066223145,
-0.13099591434001923,
0.39305558800697327,
0.10043269395828247,
-0.5963319540023804,
0.08396457135677338,
-0.29860803484916687,
0.10255061089992523,
-0.5413907170295715,
-0.6077989339828491,
-0.6741677522659302,
0.2033955454826355,
0.8206259608268738,
-0.1718066781759262,
0.6480557918548584,
0.8826225399971008,
-0.3198513686656952,
-0.07292879372835159,
-0.25450676679611206,
0.13760022819042206,
-0.4837559461593628,
0.34807705879211426,
-0.8285481929779053,
-0.038425806909799576,
0.49188855290412903,
-0.08014686405658722,
-0.3323468863964081,
0.49441003799438477,
0.45486193895339966,
-0.16911697387695312,
1.2389270067214966,
0.8064500093460083,
0.2363353967666626,
0.5466929078102112,
-0.13622601330280304,
-0.30767881870269775,
-0.50715172290802,
-0.38978636264801025,
-0.09475214034318924,
-0.5132213830947876,
-0.11809075623750687,
-0.3233920931816101,
0.6415627002716064,
-0.41772592067718506,
-0.04800069332122803,
0.35864078998565674,
-0.6050695180892944,
0.5041360855102539,
0.5286102890968323,
0.1638393998146057,
0.343696653842926,
-0.14871470630168915,
-0.09424344450235367,
0.1701774150133133,
-0.4807727038860321,
-0.42495083808898926,
0.748227059841156,
0.26542559266090393,
1.0863163471221924,
0.16830214858055115,
0.1119508147239685,
0.46367111802101135,
0.5441989302635193,
-1.0075361728668213,
0.4694998264312744,
0.2193002551794052,
-0.7822155952453613,
-0.2152196764945984,
-0.14081823825836182,
-0.9878451824188232,
0.5730063915252686,
-0.40961337089538574,
-0.3691529929637909,
0.44997766613960266,
0.2584476172924042,
-0.3751751780509949,
-0.09588968008756638,
-1.1801759004592896,
1.0182818174362183,
-0.3937014937400818,
-0.13124126195907593,
-0.3841097354888916,
-0.8406659364700317,
0.29230713844299316,
0.005625428166240454,
0.25082117319107056,
0.10350383073091507,
-0.10777049511671066,
0.41350212693214417,
-0.15275408327579498,
1.0527689456939697,
-0.2147892564535141,
0.22301825881004333,
-0.005458106752485037,
0.35878896713256836,
0.014564207755029202,
0.0405946709215641,
-0.23953895270824432,
-0.044225823134183884,
0.33812567591667175,
-0.561729371547699,
-0.8417720198631287,
0.4904457926750183,
-1.0872046947479248,
-0.2599503695964813,
-0.45060309767723083,
-0.8820770978927612,
-0.04094722867012024,
0.11137033253908157,
-0.08165799826383591,
0.8873087763786316,
-0.13494765758514404,
-0.15040652453899384,
0.4322469234466553,
-0.3735840320587158,
0.36518198251724243,
0.4874438941478729,
-0.32105106115341187,
-0.2724100947380066,
1.254602313041687,
-0.0814543142914772,
0.2637660801410675,
0.023106396198272705,
-0.0366399846971035,
-0.07106146961450577,
-0.5576226711273193,
-0.8203245997428894,
-0.019159264862537384,
-1.1018359661102295,
0.14626432955265045,
-0.4626999795436859,
0.060745786875486374,
-0.031639087945222855,
-0.24562154710292816,
-0.01581544056534767,
-0.605758547782898,
-0.347306489944458,
-0.10166585445404053,
0.18767580389976501,
1.0004032850265503,
-0.18244637548923492,
0.6262887716293335,
-0.6290438175201416,
0.5816452503204346,
0.598412275314331,
0.3886207342147827,
-0.2686326801776886,
-0.47931501269340515,
-0.07327386736869812,
-0.26100680232048035,
-0.023093633353710175,
-0.9179078340530396,
0.6027495861053467,
0.33534058928489685,
0.7575293183326721,
0.5953172445297241,
-0.31260791420936584,
0.6803508996963501,
-0.03772508352994919,
0.4079629182815552,
0.048593733459711075,
-1.0052095651626587,
0.7876845002174377,
-0.2661736011505127,
-0.0141444131731987,
0.46725425124168396,
0.19668914377689362,
-0.20370328426361084,
-0.11559228599071503,
-0.5083062052726746,
-0.30546969175338745,
0.9023981094360352,
0.21916520595550537,
-0.053433410823345184,
0.42242446541786194,
0.6404520273208618,
0.4252401292324066,
0.2851962149143219,
-0.5050222277641296,
0.018644072115421295,
-0.46074017882347107,
-0.3589606285095215,
-0.45341089367866516,
-0.02928009256720543,
-0.4068026840686798,
-0.16575056314468384,
0.5940191149711609,
-0.6687960028648376,
0.24953871965408325,
0.026637574657797813,
-0.6965051889419556,
-0.003021560376510024,
0.1302805244922638,
0.37005582451820374,
0.9421653151512146,
-0.11741001904010773,
0.44925999641418457,
0.09821096807718277,
-0.36167263984680176,
0.16586719453334808,
0.5193728804588318,
-0.09193823486566544,
-0.009574675932526588,
0.42370492219924927,
0.7788073420524597,
0.16822387278079987,
-0.6005421876907349,
0.3721405267715454,
-0.3567922115325928,
0.0004227821482345462,
-0.41733527183532715,
0.1984381079673767,
-0.21250078082084656,
0.4888012111186981,
0.11061955243349075,
0.554131269454956,
0.3530391752719879,
-0.851300060749054,
0.03972574323415756,
0.2431618869304657,
-0.5882757306098938,
-0.5179337859153748,
0.7682803869247437,
0.013187557458877563,
-0.02623896114528179,
0.5301873683929443,
-0.32065677642822266,
-0.33326980471611023,
0.956139862537384,
0.06236150860786438,
0.5633100271224976,
-0.05950028821825981,
0.6296747922897339,
-0.03299754112958908,
0.3166530430316925,
0.06941783428192139,
0.18790674209594727,
-0.05891921743750572,
-0.8315503001213074,
-0.35329529643058777,
-0.6116352081298828,
-0.6012730598449707,
-0.5241080522537231,
-0.8207940459251404,
0.07920867949724197,
-0.21418578922748566,
-0.06724762916564941,
0.579682469367981,
-0.4817695915699005,
-0.5726408362388611,
0.4511043131351471,
0.006419372744858265,
0.5489952564239502,
-1.0601437091827393,
0.761037290096283,
1.1130592823028564,
-0.8144200444221497,
-0.512932300567627,
-0.37633147835731506,
0.4075901508331299,
-1.2792847156524658,
0.7148688435554504,
0.10881498456001282,
-0.19600112736225128,
-0.11193226277828217,
-0.6726456880569458,
-0.8151682615280151,
1.2679885625839233,
0.5459160804748535,
0.5195931196212769,
0.16057248413562775,
-0.21578289568424225,
0.6929203867912292,
-0.34417039155960083,
0.6590882539749146,
0.7803617715835571,
0.864005446434021,
0.32806575298309326,
-0.9409448504447937,
0.057383015751838684,
-0.5499088168144226,
-0.06369031965732574,
-0.12461654096841812,
-0.45610734820365906,
0.7684301137924194,
-0.19974666833877563,
0.12988105416297913,
0.15691648423671722,
0.48966091871261597,
-0.29618892073631287,
0.6599748134613037,
0.9657182097434998,
0.4907592833042145,
0.707808792591095,
-0.03595967963337898,
1.142133116722107,
0.06299541890621185,
0.040793582797050476,
0.8529506921768188,
0.1345994621515274,
0.5711079835891724,
0.28033897280693054,
0.13427799940109253,
0.5848066210746765,
0.5772074460983276,
0.09169677644968033,
0.40965670347213745,
-0.05750017985701561,
-0.13407723605632782,
-0.6471689343452454,
-0.1340404450893402,
0.09548208117485046,
0.7064849138259888,
0.3964533507823944,
-0.4425548017024994,
-0.16827258467674255,
0.617940366268158,
-0.2108844667673111,
-0.16352593898773193,
-0.3148977756500244,
0.6240063905715942,
-0.08940163999795914,
-0.8651960492134094,
0.3712261915206909,
-0.050011053681373596,
0.37160414457321167,
-0.4809064567089081,
-0.21844644844532013,
0.11475476622581482,
0.6100179553031921,
-0.47373586893081665,
-0.8834499716758728,
0.7320696115493774,
-0.2866820693016052,
-0.18207868933677673,
-0.3989657163619995,
1.0113756656646729,
-0.1234131008386612,
-0.5033121109008789,
0.23371507227420807,
0.6495198011398315,
0.6177278161048889,
-0.411242812871933,
-0.6367921829223633,
0.07781828939914703,
-0.44357189536094666,
-0.24089565873146057,
0.34559205174446106,
0.3677472472190857,
-0.08319941908121109,
1.1563084125518799,
0.46340033411979675,
-0.24521781504154205,
0.14377209544181824,
-0.10586248338222504,
1.0186032056808472,
-0.5171836018562317,
-0.24326898157596588,
-0.3844496011734009,
0.6231761574745178,
0.08121031522750854,
-0.23911204934120178,
0.31605806946754456,
0.0602584145963192,
0.23049958050251007,
0.006977799814194441,
0.7649295330047607,
-0.2551252245903015,
0.10363918542861938,
-0.3684869706630707,
0.7494417428970337,
-0.8013008832931519,
-0.11774175614118576,
0.1386045664548874,
-0.7371845841407776,
-0.29000434279441833,
0.7078135013580322,
-0.27790966629981995,
-0.13323695957660675,
0.7404977083206177,
0.9978117942810059,
-0.22477176785469055,
0.030770940706133842,
0.5156517624855042,
0.36522749066352844,
0.0374213382601738,
0.353825181722641,
1.0979286432266235,
-0.15283970534801483,
1.0503709316253662,
0.065196193754673,
-0.45427265763282776,
-0.20957468450069427,
-0.6633773446083069,
-0.9740070700645447,
-0.6795042753219604,
-0.18383851647377014,
-0.4059631824493408,
0.02882402576506138,
0.6332809329032898,
0.8687540292739868,
-0.5466330051422119,
0.1877460926771164,
0.27384552359580994,
0.2879056930541992,
-0.505876898765564,
-0.183677077293396,
0.11848387867212296,
-0.35385075211524963,
-0.8136583566665649,
0.49807387590408325,
0.20256905257701874,
-0.12764453887939453,
-0.4953257143497467,
-0.11061502248048782,
0.21996939182281494,
-0.035351935774087906,
0.6241466999053955,
0.29553744196891785,
-0.7135664820671082,
-0.4516688883304596,
-0.036946605890989304,
0.09229899942874908,
-0.027653176337480545,
0.45404252409935,
-0.9583753943443298,
1.0866668224334717,
0.3840325176715851,
0.6128496527671814,
0.4580921530723572,
-0.08515558391809464,
0.6203837990760803,
-0.3757941722869873,
0.1445091813802719,
-0.08925813436508179,
0.6177420020103455,
0.2334514707326889,
-0.29262998700141907,
0.6638944745063782,
0.29915866255760193,
-0.39679768681526184,
-0.2390538454055786,
0.25388506054878235,
-1.333711862564087,
-0.18271036446094513,
1.1434262990951538,
-0.4450454115867615,
-0.4354448914527893,
-0.4540257453918457,
-0.5768479108810425,
0.033256176859140396,
-0.24450986087322235,
0.5955029726028442,
0.7234542965888977,
-0.34737348556518555,
-0.1594243049621582,
-0.7788936495780945,
0.19983813166618347,
0.41451048851013184,
-0.9856584668159485,
-0.5098369121551514,
0.8271583318710327,
0.40444907546043396,
0.4015454053878784,
0.3824632465839386,
0.029907267540693283,
0.5856978893280029,
0.16562797129154205,
0.15879693627357483,
-0.3694593906402588,
-0.3134743571281433,
-0.727275550365448,
0.20703041553497314,
0.007059180177748203,
-0.47115349769592285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14387v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14387v2
|
A Survey on Self-Evolution of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-22T17:43:23 | 2024-06-03T17:47:30 |
Zhengwei Tao, Ting-En Lin, Xiancai Chen, Hangyu Li, Yuchuan Wu, Yongbin Li, Zhi Jin, Fei Huang, Dacheng Tao, Jingren Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced in various fields
and intelligent agent applications. However, current LLMs that learn from human
or external model supervision are costly and may face performance ceilings as
task complexity and diversity increase. To address this issue, self-evolution
approaches that enable LLM to autonomously acquire, refine, and learn from
experiences generated by the model itself are rapidly growing. This new
training paradigm inspired by the human experiential learning process offers
the potential to scale LLMs towards superintelligence. In this work, we present
a comprehensive survey of self-evolution approaches in LLMs. We first propose a
conceptual framework for self-evolution and outline the evolving process as
iterative cycles composed of four phases: experience acquisition, experience
refinement, updating, and evaluation. Second, we categorize the evolution
objectives of LLMs and LLM-based agents; then, we summarize the literature and
provide taxonomy and insights for each module. Lastly, we pinpoint existing
challenges and propose future directions to improve self-evolution frameworks,
equipping researchers with critical insights to fast-track the development of
self-evolving LLMs. Our corresponding GitHub repository is available at
https://github.com/AlibabaResearch/DAMO-ConvAI/tree/main/Awesome-Self-Evolution-of-LLM
|
[
-0.35110968351364136,
-0.6796053647994995,
0.5802091956138611,
-0.02978462353348732,
0.07665295898914337,
0.4131354093551636,
-0.4708649218082428,
-0.4325389862060547,
-0.014111869037151337,
0.6117889881134033,
-0.8114591240882874,
-0.16149941086769104,
-0.3856405019760132,
0.2942914366722107,
-0.27159565687179565,
1.0080851316452026,
0.21202173829078674,
-0.12861135601997375,
-0.09065782278776169,
-0.04881368204951286,
-0.20025773346424103,
-0.36795079708099365,
-0.6172146797180176,
-0.4240843951702118,
0.4214579463005066,
0.3307083547115326,
0.3000546395778656,
0.8193677663803101,
0.2778138816356659,
0.3588024377822876,
-0.07812432199716568,
0.4879830479621887,
-0.415670245885849,
0.35592785477638245,
-0.3928985595703125,
-0.16611820459365845,
-0.41038113832473755,
-0.0752275362610817,
0.7029464244842529,
0.3405354619026184,
-0.33280453085899353,
0.25779280066490173,
-0.026552893221378326,
0.5158775448799133,
-0.44661834836006165,
0.32526034116744995,
-0.6345952153205872,
-0.12131182849407196,
-0.03347255662083626,
-0.20157495141029358,
-0.2393416315317154,
0.00703588780015707,
0.2931714951992035,
-0.3878958523273468,
-0.016278037801384926,
0.20524422824382782,
0.21222983300685883,
0.22802852094173431,
-0.28684282302856445,
-0.5056713223457336,
-0.7880693674087524,
0.7992076277732849,
-0.7937958836555481,
0.3352211117744446,
-0.16674306988716125,
0.45912623405456543,
-0.4759255349636078,
-0.6764442920684814,
-0.49267342686653137,
-0.48992225527763367,
0.3102776110172272,
0.12659074366092682,
-0.010844185017049313,
-0.1883876621723175,
-0.06632573157548904,
0.34998756647109985,
-0.460354745388031,
0.603681206703186,
-0.0987834706902504,
0.33708980679512024,
0.7537205815315247,
0.21107158064842224,
0.2795928716659546,
0.013764097355306149,
-0.2592009902000427,
-0.04977855458855629,
-0.7678560614585876,
-0.2323659062385559,
0.341877281665802,
0.3269929587841034,
-0.22025565803050995,
0.069331094622612,
-0.18966759741306305,
0.39028170704841614,
0.06587885320186615,
-0.1557517647743225,
0.411284476518631,
-0.26239171624183655,
-0.08979379385709763,
-0.18631482124328613,
0.9449985027313232,
-0.19062508642673492,
0.2779642939567566,
-0.2080753892660141,
-0.12201014161109924,
-0.6393318772315979,
0.3450942635536194,
-0.617429792881012,
-0.09171843528747559,
0.18350252509117126,
-0.30225008726119995,
-0.3160397410392761,
-0.3880738914012909,
-0.7968622446060181,
-0.5768422484397888,
-0.34284839034080505,
0.2805732786655426,
-0.3338715136051178,
-0.513681948184967,
0.21368440985679626,
0.17480668425559998,
0.31699928641319275,
0.4377547800540924,
-1.0674694776535034,
0.1544094979763031,
0.672501266002655,
0.6155931353569031,
-0.3162926733493805,
-0.5365414023399353,
-0.15930050611495972,
0.08133245259523392,
-0.40629342198371887,
0.831727921962738,
-0.4032251238822937,
-0.3227807283401489,
0.07023424655199051,
0.09385377168655396,
0.02023664489388466,
-0.5697570443153381,
0.21007095277309418,
-0.6554908156394958,
0.3070175051689148,
-0.004594945814460516,
-0.4708448350429535,
-0.12136819958686829,
0.23282335698604584,
-0.2086707353591919,
1.0012742280960083,
0.22716766595840454,
-0.3637272119522095,
0.1819090098142624,
-0.912341296672821,
-0.14532092213630676,
0.41329488158226013,
-0.3311993479728699,
-0.34893763065338135,
0.23525533080101013,
0.17805640399456024,
0.704231858253479,
-0.6492332220077515,
0.23595060408115387,
-0.49372991919517517,
0.19980230927467346,
0.2079668641090393,
-0.1596749871969223,
0.7396335601806641,
0.3757116496562958,
-0.44563931226730347,
0.13684003055095673,
-0.8424995541572571,
-0.06112530827522278,
0.2927534878253937,
-0.2267526239156723,
-0.06094028800725937,
0.27916720509529114,
-0.3812597692012787,
0.43128228187561035,
0.4569590091705322,
-0.4399915933609009,
0.6372566223144531,
-0.5169305801391602,
0.6744978427886963,
0.9649872779846191,
0.2730918526649475,
0.3718827962875366,
-0.007706900592893362,
0.5262097120285034,
-0.044746238738298416,
0.3997148871421814,
-0.3029418885707855,
-0.05684463307261467,
-0.7962604761123657,
-0.12706159055233002,
-0.0823642835021019,
0.3141389489173889,
-0.5832613110542297,
0.6449682712554932,
-0.37777289748191833,
-0.71425461769104,
-0.39742326736450195,
0.5876680612564087,
0.33831489086151123,
0.02663731575012207,
0.4990110993385315,
-0.029510285705327988,
-0.2545660436153412,
-0.8302658796310425,
-0.11725950241088867,
-0.23037339746952057,
0.20793484151363373,
0.30503222346305847,
0.6252702474594116,
-0.5548120141029358,
0.8429917097091675,
-0.2753523290157318,
-0.050792694091796875,
-0.4305894672870636,
-0.017631951719522476,
-0.03580426052212715,
0.5214318633079529,
0.5373464226722717,
-0.32822051644325256,
-0.17686903476715088,
0.3699930012226105,
-0.9407625794410706,
-0.1592450588941574,
-0.2823059558868408,
-0.014856589026749134,
0.17828582227230072,
0.6753814220428467,
-0.4460678994655609,
-0.2804219424724579,
0.6754170656204224,
-0.11071108281612396,
0.64915531873703,
-0.45636048913002014,
-0.28620994091033936,
-1.2280176877975464,
-0.28744611144065857,
-0.08346540480852127,
-0.20697790384292603,
-0.5270017385482788,
0.3648868799209595,
0.04288448765873909,
0.3965948820114136,
-0.1833547204732895,
0.7372618913650513,
-0.9517329335212708,
-0.20352329313755035,
-0.566683292388916,
0.05080592632293701,
-0.35739636421203613,
0.5198124647140503,
-0.1265428066253662,
0.47458305954933167,
0.7211794257164001,
-0.5491327047348022,
0.5278584957122803,
-0.045434825122356415,
-0.29420775175094604,
0.16453143954277039,
-0.3309400677680969,
0.37628883123397827,
-0.09219258278608322,
0.1205633133649826,
-0.6581119894981384,
0.027267426252365112,
0.2782318890094757,
-0.21960565447807312,
0.6003978252410889,
-0.01595836691558361,
-0.5861227512359619,
-0.2725323438644409,
-0.18059314787387848,
0.1744624823331833,
0.44984543323516846,
-0.6961961984634399,
0.6108755469322205,
0.16225536167621613,
-0.3910224735736847,
-0.41389623284339905,
-0.314757764339447,
0.37785473465919495,
-0.2287740707397461,
-0.31367045640945435,
-0.17580516636371613,
-0.46892139315605164,
-0.34047845005989075,
-0.23856395483016968,
0.05881374329328537,
0.37768712639808655,
0.20462727546691895,
0.011322567239403725,
-0.002973408903926611,
-0.2885545790195465,
0.24521715939044952,
0.014876513741910458,
0.07004232704639435,
0.23459766805171967,
-0.6530472636222839,
0.5352270007133484,
-0.15709224343299866,
-0.17934057116508484,
-0.267151802778244,
0.02328616753220558,
0.6336037516593933,
-0.47917991876602173,
0.6503769755363464,
0.3229926824569702,
0.026784462854266167,
-0.6316401958465576,
-0.7954298257827759,
-0.038567088544368744,
-0.5264226794242859,
0.579932451248169,
-0.45760321617126465,
-1.023521065711975,
0.35205063223838806,
-0.37864258885383606,
0.3498144745826721,
0.4873129725456238,
0.8824707269668579,
0.041640352457761765,
0.7694398164749146,
0.7952731847763062,
-0.05039103329181671,
0.5567083954811096,
-0.40035712718963623,
0.01016943994909525,
-0.9435735940933228,
-0.33619973063468933,
-0.3167538642883301,
0.04317760095000267,
-0.7553878426551819,
-0.5248069167137146,
0.07876279950141907,
-0.09297066926956177,
-0.3149647116661072,
0.2986840605735779,
-0.32986781001091003,
0.3187336325645447,
0.10057181119918823,
-0.23813693225383759,
0.32949206233024597,
-0.055081192404031754,
0.23834341764450073,
0.1972007155418396,
-0.6263880133628845,
-0.4288109838962555,
1.1554826498031616,
0.5759770274162292,
0.925118088722229,
0.17305347323417664,
0.8171667456626892,
0.5030033588409424,
0.40268874168395996,
-0.5096087455749512,
0.41808444261550903,
0.1275664120912552,
-0.5254203081130981,
-0.5578803420066833,
-0.4208510220050812,
-0.8853673338890076,
0.27176633477211,
-0.10271419584751129,
-0.74317467212677,
0.2334355264902115,
-0.014488022774457932,
-0.15527483820915222,
0.0746561661362648,
-0.4322361946105957,
0.8597029447555542,
-0.6097900867462158,
-0.20284582674503326,
-0.308730810880661,
-0.5964275002479553,
0.26830530166625977,
-0.5688410401344299,
0.4530619978904724,
-0.12370344251394272,
-0.319659560918808,
0.5265538096427917,
-0.14742855727672577,
0.6341182589530945,
-0.05228053033351898,
-0.5926820039749146,
0.42834070324897766,
0.1299319863319397,
0.5544309020042419,
-0.023306747898459435,
-0.08355355262756348,
0.19645994901657104,
-0.1678047925233841,
-0.26941245794296265,
-0.832303524017334,
0.6378284692764282,
-1.0172022581100464,
-0.6678858399391174,
-0.18791761994361877,
-0.5062769055366516,
-0.2977817952632904,
0.07121401280164719,
-0.0073900832794606686,
0.4165080785751343,
0.017426077276468277,
0.16626477241516113,
0.5112943649291992,
-0.20796111226081848,
0.577730119228363,
0.8327037692070007,
-0.40469908714294434,
-0.23252403736114502,
0.9303263425827026,
0.22557593882083893,
0.48555952310562134,
0.20971782505512238,
0.5321004986763,
-0.3647841513156891,
-1.0840868949890137,
-0.2515135705471039,
0.5106645226478577,
-0.6529263854026794,
-0.05385620519518852,
-0.765991747379303,
-0.1838512271642685,
-0.6862873435020447,
0.026255814358592033,
-0.5285908579826355,
-0.07390084862709045,
-0.24311132729053497,
-0.09091619402170181,
0.30179110169410706,
1.056545376777649,
-0.054624538868665695,
0.38481464982032776,
-0.49395325779914856,
-0.015967991203069687,
0.4025469124317169,
0.04425647854804993,
0.08487270027399063,
-0.9741459488868713,
-0.4079388678073883,
-0.15931716561317444,
-0.18060782551765442,
-0.5493741035461426,
0.4634237587451935,
0.365340918302536,
0.6553381681442261,
0.5803545713424683,
-0.03544129058718681,
0.5082783699035645,
-0.5208213925361633,
0.6838522553443909,
0.07589654624462128,
-0.6293673515319824,
0.3494267463684082,
-0.5097248554229736,
0.14226821064949036,
0.22685909271240234,
0.33454689383506775,
-0.42904508113861084,
-0.37671416997909546,
-0.5662781596183777,
-0.6288480162620544,
0.6432774662971497,
-0.10144481807947159,
0.3384400010108948,
0.030595310032367706,
0.7366061806678772,
0.2563501298427582,
0.09993936866521835,
-0.8536016345024109,
-0.17993459105491638,
-0.015459869988262653,
-0.08418150991201401,
-0.37950873374938965,
-0.189983069896698,
0.042381543666124344,
-0.18561951816082,
0.7953675389289856,
-0.5537995100021362,
-0.030878812074661255,
-0.05041087791323662,
-0.2976910173892975,
0.12650597095489502,
0.527613639831543,
0.5167325735092163,
0.7131446599960327,
0.01890473999083042,
0.022521965205669403,
0.4591596722602844,
-0.20385649800300598,
0.25626859068870544,
-0.097199447453022,
0.20329943299293518,
-0.5786511898040771,
0.47954195737838745,
0.6075913906097412,
0.19947339594364166,
-0.7728341221809387,
0.467166006565094,
0.03168828412890434,
-0.09657615423202515,
-0.4753953814506531,
0.37534457445144653,
0.22034189105033875,
0.7620223760604858,
0.4050489068031311,
-0.5297151803970337,
-0.005915532819926739,
-0.7110863327980042,
-0.1293446123600006,
0.2831319272518158,
-0.18723264336585999,
-0.4217322766780853,
0.23177529871463776,
0.16316896677017212,
-0.40410393476486206,
0.28426358103752136,
-0.5717875957489014,
-0.21928395330905914,
0.3979673683643341,
0.711710512638092,
1.107853889465332,
-0.2696519196033478,
0.0762207955121994,
-0.010686349123716354,
0.367497980594635,
-0.1419806182384491,
-0.049492042511701584,
-0.24241286516189575,
-0.7134929895401001,
-0.35310572385787964,
-0.9377864003181458,
-0.37517017126083374,
0.35768693685531616,
-0.2823556661605835,
0.16360533237457275,
-0.5535691976547241,
0.31830349564552307,
-0.05162549763917923,
0.047214314341545105,
-0.41793203353881836,
0.10791347920894623,
0.3641974925994873,
0.8256510496139526,
-0.40254566073417664,
0.906896710395813,
0.7384653091430664,
-0.18698586523532867,
-0.4913638234138489,
-0.1239551305770874,
-0.05253316089510918,
-1.0998765230178833,
0.8034834265708923,
-0.043327696621418,
-0.30273324251174927,
0.40665504336357117,
-0.6528266072273254,
-1.0422327518463135,
1.0246803760528564,
0.2314516007900238,
-0.7499929666519165,
-0.34596267342567444,
-0.0793803408741951,
0.7553164958953857,
-0.6955486536026001,
0.3235946297645569,
0.5825332999229431,
0.09674744307994843,
-0.15303796529769897,
-0.5751243233680725,
-0.10462551563978195,
-0.043114807456731796,
0.1882794350385666,
0.05882202833890915,
-0.9621676802635193,
0.7348780035972595,
-0.24415840208530426,
-0.11735016107559204,
0.17061138153076172,
0.8147194981575012,
-0.10471337288618088,
-0.15041682124137878,
0.4501698315143585,
0.3886070251464844,
0.2562161684036255,
0.34604334831237793,
0.7114261984825134,
-0.5412923693656921,
0.4240226745605469,
1.2113033533096313,
-0.3164505362510681,
0.7333389520645142,
0.10955967009067535,
-0.12795431911945343,
0.8434688448905945,
0.5766639113426208,
-0.2516217529773712,
0.09722530096769333,
0.3876720070838928,
-0.1732437014579773,
-0.4205091893672943,
0.1251213252544403,
-0.27476003766059875,
0.7577017545700073,
0.47125017642974854,
-0.36197376251220703,
-0.3668099343776703,
0.028708280995488167,
0.01268697064369917,
-0.1321602463722229,
-0.24410951137542725,
0.9630579352378845,
0.015584209933876991,
-0.6769861578941345,
0.26049765944480896,
-0.09715475142002106,
0.6316006779670715,
-0.748307466506958,
0.054600611329078674,
-0.28505319356918335,
0.1664879471063614,
-0.13941389322280884,
-0.5013974905014038,
-0.24894732236862183,
0.04836909472942352,
0.022371385246515274,
-0.410606324672699,
0.4995618760585785,
-0.2063566893339157,
-0.2898540496826172,
0.5670666694641113,
0.8601818084716797,
0.29537782073020935,
0.01240468118339777,
-0.7853779196739197,
0.02968495897948742,
-0.31525900959968567,
-0.5706319212913513,
0.47990575432777405,
0.5581160187721252,
0.0470513179898262,
0.9814687371253967,
0.5803684592247009,
0.13470835983753204,
0.2932312786579132,
0.034532371908426285,
0.6807428002357483,
-0.8524777293205261,
-0.3667777180671692,
-1.1537516117095947,
0.14418092370033264,
0.003281697165220976,
-0.44635799527168274,
0.7550050616264343,
0.36344483494758606,
0.6807315945625305,
0.10058294236660004,
0.827160656452179,
0.23098601400852203,
0.4304349720478058,
-0.4577513039112091,
0.6796754598617554,
-0.6303449869155884,
0.19421657919883728,
-0.22900208830833435,
-0.9594473838806152,
0.1667475402355194,
0.28006231784820557,
-0.26650509238243103,
0.19920744001865387,
0.5513701438903809,
0.7124074101448059,
0.2070862352848053,
-0.14322054386138916,
0.323747843503952,
0.48960182070732117,
0.5515947341918945,
0.34045055508613586,
1.2212802171707153,
0.05171191692352295,
0.39003556966781616,
0.06201647222042084,
-0.3568378984928131,
-0.1807064712047577,
-0.812573254108429,
-0.9517841935157776,
-0.4761442542076111,
-0.5461822152137756,
0.07335291057825089,
0.0923280119895935,
1.3034859895706177,
0.8939567804336548,
-0.4398208260536194,
-0.5074148178100586,
-0.15477357804775238,
-0.23098474740982056,
0.0526934377849102,
-0.14913691580295563,
0.14280739426612854,
-0.8064171671867371,
-0.6340068578720093,
0.6130074858665466,
0.6172678470611572,
0.06795549392700195,
-0.8732853531837463,
-0.22865842282772064,
-0.13224928081035614,
0.03395463153719902,
0.7179545760154724,
0.6575450301170349,
-0.7345244288444519,
-0.29308968782424927,
-0.06501269340515137,
0.007986768148839474,
-0.028974931687116623,
0.6614826917648315,
-0.6051259636878967,
0.5754319429397583,
0.05363265797495842,
0.8969456553459167,
0.4258054196834564,
-0.4673148989677429,
0.4377579987049103,
-0.4984883964061737,
-0.3495400547981262,
-0.055868636816740036,
0.28656062483787537,
0.27976611256599426,
-0.18331299722194672,
0.3930024206638336,
0.33543625473976135,
-0.851137101650238,
-0.8981784582138062,
0.36429888010025024,
-0.7800530791282654,
-0.37074247002601624,
1.1770011186599731,
-0.015781700611114502,
-0.2441684454679489,
-0.10387105494737625,
-0.06506301462650299,
0.12057258933782578,
-0.2726947069168091,
0.9381577372550964,
0.5287418961524963,
-0.4812570810317993,
-0.4457986652851105,
-0.5456346273422241,
0.47572383284568787,
0.15952515602111816,
-1.2853323221206665,
0.5352615714073181,
0.3192618489265442,
0.48798659443855286,
0.21150954067707062,
0.3487785756587982,
0.07905521988868713,
0.07924133539199829,
-0.2310027778148651,
0.2954091727733612,
-0.11524950712919235,
-0.4392439126968384,
-0.6562714576721191,
0.009822373278439045,
0.4966779053211212,
0.1490403562784195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14469v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14469v2
|
SnapKV: LLM Knows What You are Looking for Before Generation
| 2024-04-22T17:42:58 | 2024-06-17T03:01:58 |
Yuhong Li, Yingbing Huang, Bowen Yang, Bharat Venkitesh, Acyr Locatelli, Hanchen Ye, Tianle Cai, Patrick Lewis, Deming Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have made remarkable progress in processing
extensive contexts, with the Key-Value (KV) cache playing a vital role in
enhancing their performance. However, the growth of the KV cache in response to
increasing input length poses challenges to memory and time efficiency. To
address this problem, this paper introduces SnapKV, an innovative and
fine-tuning-free approach that efficiently minimizes KV cache size while still
delivering comparable performance in real-world applications.
We discover that each attention head in the model consistently focuses on
specific prompt attention features during generation. Meanwhile, this robust
pattern can be obtained from an 'observation' window located at the end of the
prompts. Drawing on this insight, SnapKV automatically compresses KV caches by
selecting clustered important KV positions for each attention head. Our
approach significantly reduces the growing computational overhead and memory
footprint when processing long input sequences. Specifically, SnapKV achieves a
consistent decoding speed with a 3.6x increase in generation speed and an 8.2x
enhancement in memory efficiency compared to the baseline when processing
inputs of 16K tokens. At the same time, it maintains comparable performance to
the baseline models across 16 long sequence datasets. Moreover, SnapKV can
process up to 380K context tokens on a single A100-80GB GPU using HuggingFace
implementation with minor changes, exhibiting only a negligible accuracy drop
in the Needle-in-a-Haystack test. Further comprehensive studies suggest
SnapKV's potential for practical applications.
|
[
-0.4497978091239929,
-0.5372563600540161,
0.5289101600646973,
0.29487016797065735,
-0.5677797794342041,
0.0313248373568058,
-0.322061151266098,
-0.3241332769393921,
0.15823861956596375,
0.5019853711128235,
-0.5797638893127441,
-0.45196449756622314,
-0.4887438118457794,
-0.22987569868564606,
-0.11946655064821243,
0.47669461369514465,
0.1932625025510788,
-0.3363291621208191,
-0.3926082253456116,
-0.040589187294244766,
-0.4252152740955353,
-0.1722627878189087,
-0.4423949718475342,
-0.09869220852851868,
0.36753612756729126,
0.5760757327079773,
0.5049856305122375,
0.9590824842453003,
0.2853452265262604,
0.21134842932224274,
-0.43968093395233154,
0.36296170949935913,
-0.7701025605201721,
0.5264945030212402,
0.12446989864110947,
-0.24697893857955933,
-0.4227319061756134,
-0.23577609658241272,
0.656904399394989,
0.19835799932479858,
0.06190328299999237,
0.2547159194946289,
-0.0366213284432888,
0.7906165719032288,
-1.0476914644241333,
0.2332833707332611,
-0.7174261212348938,
-0.15788234770298004,
-0.1953928917646408,
-0.2566382586956024,
-0.5703033208847046,
-0.3189176023006439,
-0.05870500206947327,
-0.416801393032074,
0.3107723593711853,
-0.2977933883666992,
0.7932236194610596,
0.5441872477531433,
-0.08927346765995026,
0.25588756799697876,
-0.5450263023376465,
0.8030242919921875,
-0.6778448224067688,
0.41784942150115967,
0.1842840015888214,
0.24131493270397186,
-0.3367840349674225,
-0.38234058022499084,
-0.4048379063606262,
0.18016543984413147,
0.36879613995552063,
0.0660434290766716,
0.0952482745051384,
0.19373421370983124,
0.2615514397621155,
0.4978838860988617,
-0.448072224855423,
0.1447194665670395,
-0.10970310866832733,
-0.38263577222824097,
0.4649428725242615,
0.41419681906700134,
0.24018481373786926,
-0.31903430819511414,
-0.05437489226460457,
-0.2363569736480713,
-0.9301292896270752,
0.378479927778244,
0.19210535287857056,
0.5843890309333801,
0.06800396740436554,
0.4200865626335144,
-0.43097618222236633,
0.5749329328536987,
0.13351640105247498,
-0.21952135860919952,
0.04406403377652168,
-0.553175687789917,
-0.15311644971370697,
0.028059465810656548,
0.558474600315094,
0.41587889194488525,
0.056933581829071045,
-0.06285733729600906,
-0.06063995510339737,
0.1874815672636032,
0.2693413197994232,
-1.047213077545166,
-0.20215652883052826,
0.17303584516048431,
-0.1536649465560913,
-0.4396689534187317,
-0.3244537115097046,
-0.7101980447769165,
-0.21049918234348297,
-0.16205285489559174,
0.0019402735633775592,
-0.4481019079685211,
-0.07514490187168121,
0.03440369665622711,
0.08069853484630585,
0.6516653895378113,
0.46736422181129456,
-0.9317081570625305,
0.1402021050453186,
0.8506196737289429,
0.9298206567764282,
-0.3760814964771271,
0.07348249852657318,
-0.9036840200424194,
-0.03366473317146301,
-0.3331773579120636,
0.6939694285392761,
-0.5641087889671326,
-0.4012007415294647,
-0.20523986220359802,
-0.21736320853233337,
0.2547755837440491,
-0.5811599493026733,
0.1987786740064621,
-0.5127987265586853,
-0.47199946641921997,
-0.4595242440700531,
-0.39045849442481995,
0.2624543309211731,
0.18366439640522003,
-0.6765800714492798,
1.287837028503418,
0.2811152935028076,
-0.6379608511924744,
0.6465169191360474,
-0.17766501009464264,
-0.5538885593414307,
0.3236156105995178,
-0.04732659459114075,
-0.40731334686279297,
0.37127503752708435,
0.43888619542121887,
0.5478877425193787,
-0.2296309471130371,
0.15409620106220245,
-0.24846799671649933,
-0.45997264981269836,
-0.09919747710227966,
-0.1772695779800415,
0.3769586682319641,
0.10614285618066788,
-0.17567479610443115,
0.15944519639015198,
-0.7184104919433594,
0.11241529881954193,
0.042093850672245026,
-0.6468385457992554,
-0.4543100595474243,
-0.1593036949634552,
-0.013404152356088161,
0.23072513937950134,
0.1960020363330841,
-0.6268938183784485,
0.5265805125236511,
-0.6748682856559753,
0.49594902992248535,
0.7703585028648376,
-0.04170335829257965,
0.5060180425643921,
0.04678329825401306,
0.5367511510848999,
0.18701133131980896,
0.15552592277526855,
-0.7704609036445618,
-0.3769162595272064,
-0.8731337785720825,
-0.5208736658096313,
0.17469128966331482,
0.30321159958839417,
-0.7180214524269104,
0.3544102609157562,
-0.3947280943393707,
-0.16404493153095245,
-0.8638883829116821,
0.18508940935134888,
0.3554975092411041,
0.5675473213195801,
0.21688026189804077,
-0.2837514281272888,
-0.5124017000198364,
-0.9842797517776489,
-0.1963801234960556,
0.06961005926132202,
0.08972159773111343,
0.6994582414627075,
0.04563916474580765,
-0.1794602870941162,
1.0225319862365723,
-0.6090317368507385,
0.20022746920585632,
-0.28588223457336426,
0.027740390971302986,
0.1538323611021042,
0.30074378848075867,
0.15094193816184998,
-0.46628519892692566,
-0.37866637110710144,
-0.077902652323246,
-0.12755493819713593,
-0.1505746841430664,
-0.03907857462763786,
-0.17510288953781128,
0.34588009119033813,
0.3590086102485657,
-0.7780845165252686,
0.3863309323787689,
0.21554209291934967,
-0.23374193906784058,
0.6698397397994995,
-0.1971067488193512,
0.07014951854944229,
-1.226759433746338,
0.06387212127447128,
-0.3264918923377991,
-0.5362128019332886,
-0.4029625952243805,
0.10587526112794876,
0.37891170382499695,
0.03045552596449852,
-0.7213132381439209,
0.6315970420837402,
-0.41643986105918884,
-0.13398435711860657,
-0.38262009620666504,
0.15855933725833893,
-0.0611235648393631,
0.38012608885765076,
-0.2513132393360138,
1.055786371231079,
0.4098801612854004,
-0.7554394006729126,
0.2731951177120209,
0.17666788399219513,
-0.5574302673339844,
0.06150858849287033,
-0.31093892455101013,
0.2148871272802353,
-0.17908981442451477,
0.18471191823482513,
-0.9963328838348389,
-0.2898905575275421,
-0.22624999284744263,
-0.553253710269928,
0.5163946747779846,
-0.17390315234661102,
-0.46618175506591797,
-0.4703112542629242,
-0.5893667340278625,
0.46679386496543884,
0.7097960114479065,
-0.7602855563163757,
0.40084442496299744,
0.45721328258514404,
-0.035551682114601135,
-0.8038988709449768,
-0.44860154390335083,
0.004203628748655319,
-0.08605745434761047,
-0.6376294493675232,
0.04209361970424652,
-0.024294529110193253,
0.12388473004102707,
-0.29370418190956116,
-0.30072882771492004,
0.058312203735113144,
0.08478798717260361,
0.20776209235191345,
0.2939208149909973,
-0.3558044135570526,
0.09681285917758942,
0.27416956424713135,
-0.3185451030731201,
-0.3474399149417877,
-0.21571290493011475,
0.5493818521499634,
-0.14804714918136597,
0.19460098445415497,
-0.22820238769054413,
0.3098406195640564,
1.0550931692123413,
-0.1002635583281517,
0.5047616958618164,
0.39788883924484253,
-0.1944202333688736,
-0.5324704051017761,
-0.6251392960548401,
-0.19379281997680664,
-0.5297819972038269,
0.39483264088630676,
-0.28759610652923584,
-1.213671326637268,
0.6224917769432068,
-0.22334915399551392,
-0.012224024161696434,
0.1250636875629425,
0.7886448502540588,
0.2674179673194885,
0.8885639309883118,
0.6008268594741821,
-0.4136926829814911,
0.4723283350467682,
-0.14955270290374756,
0.3976075053215027,
-1.0879542827606201,
-0.06781252473592758,
-0.16282109916210175,
-0.27641770243644714,
-0.3016187846660614,
-0.8606826066970825,
0.1718357503414154,
0.13213331997394562,
-0.031972188502550125,
0.30582183599472046,
-0.6178690195083618,
0.8619624972343445,
0.259989857673645,
0.01812463067471981,
0.09214892238378525,
-0.34270671010017395,
-0.390607625246048,
-0.09847085177898407,
-0.7710770964622498,
-0.18942083418369293,
0.842010498046875,
0.02281906269490719,
0.8690277338027954,
-0.22788570821285248,
0.4820626974105835,
0.055676065385341644,
-0.018971865996718407,
-1.0569382905960083,
0.7501809000968933,
-0.10461199283599854,
-0.14586961269378662,
-0.23534467816352844,
-0.35622504353523254,
-0.7937994599342346,
0.19387856125831604,
0.07267849892377853,
-0.8906655311584473,
-0.11299638450145721,
0.5155267715454102,
-0.7024922370910645,
0.2875332832336426,
-0.46916884183883667,
0.5834683775901794,
0.1110341027379036,
-0.5150868892669678,
-0.20034882426261902,
-0.5468146800994873,
0.598081111907959,
0.135668084025383,
-0.38878223299980164,
-0.32359400391578674,
-0.0045820982195436954,
0.29936227202415466,
-0.36997148394584656,
0.7259253263473511,
-0.018803641200065613,
0.04380637779831886,
0.3337119519710541,
0.188155859708786,
0.7730212807655334,
0.1869886815547943,
0.24207356572151184,
-0.23634447157382965,
-0.2182435542345047,
-0.2691388726234436,
-0.5409848690032959,
1.1206732988357544,
-0.6497200727462769,
-0.5059297680854797,
0.08971880376338959,
-0.6547807455062866,
-0.18706241250038147,
0.1838376820087433,
0.29777517914772034,
0.3432888686656952,
-0.20112866163253784,
0.301455557346344,
1.1348462104797363,
-0.42148470878601074,
0.5333528518676758,
0.30635493993759155,
-0.0430813767015934,
-0.28363144397735596,
0.7881060838699341,
0.025061912834644318,
0.27600809931755066,
0.41973263025283813,
0.281853586435318,
-0.18462353944778442,
-0.3408147990703583,
-0.5035171508789062,
0.27162855863571167,
-0.5944342613220215,
-0.5450652837753296,
-0.7704467177391052,
-0.16303618252277374,
-0.6193031072616577,
-0.43872565031051636,
-1.059300422668457,
-0.46341294050216675,
-0.332865446805954,
-0.06783535331487656,
0.6109705567359924,
0.27181482315063477,
0.24064840376377106,
0.3465065658092499,
-0.816642165184021,
0.32107552886009216,
0.3057943284511566,
0.5754891633987427,
0.185368150472641,
-0.2331264615058899,
-0.31740084290504456,
-0.39039915800094604,
-0.18961568176746368,
-0.4133880138397217,
0.49551188945770264,
0.09639119356870651,
0.20657242834568024,
0.46685782074928284,
0.1157897487282753,
0.8598290681838989,
-0.5191206336021423,
0.9467971324920654,
-0.04259189963340759,
-0.9808306097984314,
0.6712174415588379,
-0.34772002696990967,
0.9589545726776123,
0.5662859678268433,
-0.1428878903388977,
-0.578552782535553,
-0.36147624254226685,
-0.5138190388679504,
-1.381196141242981,
0.7177607417106628,
-0.005290917120873928,
0.04141790792346001,
-0.011615010909736156,
0.597632646560669,
0.2767578959465027,
0.058902014046907425,
-0.09018989652395248,
0.019824739545583725,
0.10571213811635971,
-0.1318204402923584,
0.062688447535038,
-0.3675711750984192,
0.3738405108451843,
-0.38740256428718567,
0.4498319625854492,
-0.2924196720123291,
0.20650891959667206,
0.11250156164169312,
-0.2697334885597229,
-0.14070411026477814,
0.22799597680568695,
0.73090660572052,
0.38473638892173767,
-0.05382882431149483,
0.17195247113704681,
0.25117626786231995,
-0.6549773216247559,
-0.0629580169916153,
-0.42437610030174255,
-0.2901291847229004,
-0.08487176895141602,
-0.040347978472709656,
0.9823576807975769,
0.5663611888885498,
-0.7760522961616516,
0.47828832268714905,
-0.12430313229560852,
0.0029665317852050066,
0.07194803655147552,
0.278837114572525,
0.2074621021747589,
0.2541447877883911,
-0.01942736655473709,
-0.22821590304374695,
0.041552457958459854,
-0.0713280662894249,
0.3860357701778412,
0.4179554879665375,
-0.016387775540351868,
-0.4821374714374542,
0.5397000908851624,
0.28754401206970215,
-0.11000392585992813,
0.8264843821525574,
0.10092417150735855,
-0.5384944081306458,
0.5635011792182922,
0.5069096684455872,
1.130431056022644,
-0.3671477437019348,
-0.11580996960401535,
0.5264074802398682,
0.10409815609455109,
-0.1880030483007431,
0.3107093572616577,
-0.5321281552314758,
-0.6915013194084167,
-0.670788586139679,
-0.8777722120285034,
-0.27716726064682007,
0.47412553429603577,
-0.6442002654075623,
0.35405898094177246,
-0.45503807067871094,
-0.04884791001677513,
-0.20939619839191437,
-0.15581563115119934,
-0.7231844663619995,
-0.15904460847377777,
0.2628387212753296,
0.9913651943206787,
-0.7763994336128235,
1.0624960660934448,
0.2343631237745285,
0.1414346843957901,
-0.630012571811676,
-0.30244359374046326,
-0.0386042445898056,
-0.7825853824615479,
0.35816532373428345,
0.45619359612464905,
-0.37833163142204285,
-0.1761874407529831,
-0.6701352596282959,
-1.0775477886199951,
0.9459470510482788,
0.34896770119667053,
-0.6132339239120483,
-0.04959416761994362,
-0.02025333233177662,
0.22643141448497772,
-0.34448471665382385,
-0.12240631878376007,
0.8999258279800415,
0.22724871337413788,
0.3932986259460449,
-0.7049107551574707,
0.09954153001308441,
-0.34006738662719727,
0.2864767014980316,
0.6412879824638367,
-0.859345018863678,
0.6149698495864868,
-0.36633017659187317,
-0.1857166290283203,
0.060684967786073685,
0.6065807938575745,
0.279748797416687,
-0.020002873614430428,
0.19173181056976318,
0.7486803531646729,
0.7434220910072327,
-0.05992523580789566,
0.9286646246910095,
-0.4376126825809479,
0.2859823405742645,
1.0841293334960938,
-0.08733507990837097,
0.7899907231330872,
0.670102596282959,
0.19177618622779846,
-0.1097153052687645,
0.6529046297073364,
0.17633162438869476,
0.7409317493438721,
0.26830601692199707,
-0.3433966636657715,
-0.5081191658973694,
0.12988102436065674,
-0.08073806017637253,
0.3537064492702484,
0.4166916310787201,
-0.20841757953166962,
-0.21678592264652252,
0.03696306794881821,
-0.013590587303042412,
-0.4092119634151459,
-0.4684031307697296,
0.7015615105628967,
0.061892781406641006,
-0.7073270678520203,
0.5847271084785461,
-0.22807367146015167,
0.714889645576477,
-0.5776010751724243,
0.07390965521335602,
-0.2522863745689392,
0.48743587732315063,
0.20450083911418915,
-0.5345649123191833,
0.24272683262825012,
0.03922759369015694,
-0.420315682888031,
-0.23069025576114655,
0.9005582928657532,
-0.4249420762062073,
-0.23231086134910583,
0.0049530318938195705,
0.13623225688934326,
0.1551569700241089,
-0.0003436146362219006,
-0.27586743235588074,
0.3316989243030548,
-0.11055099219083786,
-0.4304039180278778,
0.4586155414581299,
0.31036996841430664,
0.008836861699819565,
0.7712559700012207,
0.5760989785194397,
0.22015103697776794,
0.2675850987434387,
-0.21402157843112946,
1.2496992349624634,
-0.8919388055801392,
-0.8003175854682922,
-0.8476495742797852,
0.47438016533851624,
0.0862174779176712,
-0.47923243045806885,
0.6626896262168884,
0.6660794615745544,
0.6855931878089905,
-0.07161214202642441,
0.7046977877616882,
0.3484989404678345,
0.20802725851535797,
-0.4138466715812683,
0.7023422718048096,
-0.26336055994033813,
-0.0674382895231247,
-0.2224539816379547,
-0.7074040770530701,
-0.424995094537735,
0.4868629276752472,
-0.11930983513593674,
-0.33508381247520447,
0.2670237123966217,
0.6738372445106506,
-0.05237433686852455,
-0.07654964178800583,
0.4633479118347168,
0.28356999158859253,
0.4642012119293213,
0.7760964035987854,
0.5474852323532104,
-0.24706146121025085,
0.3672315776348114,
0.03696245700120926,
-0.15872959792613983,
-0.5325443148612976,
-0.9622408151626587,
-0.6885737180709839,
-0.357974112033844,
-0.25898799300193787,
-0.31548240780830383,
-0.03825107961893082,
0.8221725821495056,
0.8864835500717163,
-0.6240726113319397,
0.06131695955991745,
-0.028598351404070854,
0.06750154495239258,
-0.05543888732790947,
-0.24883031845092773,
0.26827389001846313,
-0.4794255197048187,
-0.5497798323631287,
0.6840671896934509,
0.800096333026886,
-0.10520967096090317,
-0.22888267040252686,
-0.0781618058681488,
0.1319974958896637,
0.3838735520839691,
0.8238317966461182,
0.39503228664398193,
-0.804220974445343,
-0.29539525508880615,
0.13286587595939636,
-0.05246010422706604,
0.4537962079048157,
1.219906210899353,
-1.1068859100341797,
0.8615415692329407,
0.7400890588760376,
0.9528605341911316,
0.8297904133796692,
0.0026650631334632635,
0.5371231436729431,
-0.7025915384292603,
0.2101949006319046,
0.43255507946014404,
0.1320466250181198,
0.3230300843715668,
-0.6794968843460083,
-0.017428291961550713,
0.02485538274049759,
-0.5778903961181641,
-0.9346433877944946,
0.25433167815208435,
-1.138507604598999,
-0.1813853681087494,
1.1030807495117188,
0.06955859810113907,
-0.6158077120780945,
0.10521048307418823,
-0.06578665971755981,
0.32719430327415466,
-0.7175219058990479,
0.7366157174110413,
0.8409318327903748,
-0.16275805234909058,
-0.33183324337005615,
-0.44033586978912354,
0.6275628805160522,
0.20026203989982605,
-0.45285117626190186,
0.6460054516792297,
0.39722201228141785,
0.2287871390581131,
-0.13896338641643524,
0.5365954041481018,
-0.14901725947856903,
0.38291463255882263,
0.0146127138286829,
0.028947778046131134,
-0.17191432416439056,
-0.48495426774024963,
-0.4040818512439728,
0.12540633976459503,
-0.14061883091926575,
-0.18164333701133728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02560v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02560v2
|
Less Peaky and More Accurate CTC Forced Alignment by Label Priors
| 2024-04-22T17:40:08 | 2024-06-15T22:02:03 |
Ruizhe Huang, Xiaohui Zhang, Zhaoheng Ni, Li Sun, Moto Hira, Jeff Hwang, Vimal Manohar, Vineel Pratap, Matthew Wiesner, Shinji Watanabe, Daniel Povey, Sanjeev Khudanpur
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Connectionist temporal classification (CTC) models are known to have peaky
output distributions. Such behavior is not a problem for automatic speech
recognition (ASR), but it can cause inaccurate forced alignments (FA),
especially at finer granularity, e.g., phoneme level. This paper aims at
alleviating the peaky behavior for CTC and improve its suitability for forced
alignment generation, by leveraging label priors, so that the scores of
alignment paths containing fewer blanks are boosted and maximized during
training. As a result, our CTC model produces less peaky posteriors and is able
to more accurately predict the offset of the tokens besides their onset. It
outperforms the standard CTC model and a heuristics-based approach for
obtaining CTC's token offset timestamps by 12-40% in phoneme and word boundary
errors (PBE and WBE) measured on the Buckeye and TIMIT data. Compared with the
most widely used FA toolkit Montreal Forced Aligner (MFA), our method performs
similarly on PBE/WBE on Buckeye, yet falls behind MFA on TIMIT. Nevertheless,
our method has a much simpler training pipeline and better runtime efficiency.
Our training recipe and pretrained model are released in TorchAudio.
|
[
-0.1428796350955963,
-0.3891814947128296,
0.07904625684022903,
-0.15827564895153046,
-0.18490058183670044,
0.11015526950359344,
-0.0732097327709198,
-0.2937120795249939,
0.07019461691379547,
0.3168148398399353,
-0.611714243888855,
-0.5761820673942566,
-0.5541188716888428,
-0.11685869097709656,
-0.042351361364126205,
0.9379056692123413,
0.19678808748722076,
-0.15267352759838104,
0.15156593918800354,
-0.36990025639533997,
-0.7881302237510681,
-0.5549139380455017,
-0.6374437212944031,
-0.4759296178817749,
0.4571390151977539,
0.20601993799209595,
0.62180095911026,
0.8625462651252747,
0.32182180881500244,
0.19245626032352448,
-0.25528964400291443,
0.1753469854593277,
-0.3443393111228943,
-0.1275869905948639,
0.27141210436820984,
-0.24846306443214417,
-0.6472353339195251,
0.16792535781860352,
0.5866511464118958,
0.648657500743866,
-0.31632623076438904,
-0.049160365015268326,
0.15933087468147278,
0.4148595333099365,
-0.7587513327598572,
-0.06538369506597519,
-0.8545812964439392,
-0.13883084058761597,
-0.20344868302345276,
-0.2030203938484192,
-0.6548534631729126,
-0.4302251636981964,
0.3070157468318939,
-0.646636426448822,
0.38985544443130493,
-0.11965542286634445,
1.0111467838287354,
0.4749050736427307,
-0.5359663963317871,
-0.10621125251054764,
-0.6283867955207825,
0.6372296810150146,
-0.7031224370002747,
0.8688835501670837,
0.25069117546081543,
0.238864004611969,
-0.16854453086853027,
-0.6365190744400024,
-0.5266450047492981,
-0.06021421030163765,
0.02915201708674431,
0.26679113507270813,
-0.1283620446920395,
0.1350298821926117,
0.2877640724182129,
0.11798148602247238,
-0.7182632684707642,
0.4723895192146301,
-0.38048529624938965,
-0.5464335680007935,
0.3647582530975342,
0.1571200042963028,
-0.12014652043581009,
0.0920737236738205,
-0.5276134014129639,
-0.2479565143585205,
-0.8120546936988831,
0.2721603214740753,
0.30730774998664856,
0.33050960302352905,
0.007969739846885204,
0.3163923919200897,
0.08959615230560303,
0.9137208461761475,
0.5489054918289185,
-0.00021434079098980874,
0.41072365641593933,
-0.3481040298938751,
-0.12696188688278198,
0.43178847432136536,
0.7792319059371948,
0.2972409129142761,
0.013019022531807423,
-0.1605362594127655,
-0.24330441653728485,
0.11490725725889206,
0.1402522474527359,
-0.7040156722068787,
-0.38596513867378235,
0.13149848580360413,
-0.009369983337819576,
-0.034240011125802994,
0.13081194460391998,
-0.23780423402786255,
-0.21285119652748108,
-0.651148796081543,
0.3113155961036682,
-0.5624057650566101,
0.13095633685588837,
-0.14763782918453217,
0.22089502215385437,
0.33865952491760254,
0.2920273542404175,
-0.7749549746513367,
0.023894991725683212,
0.453755646944046,
1.0668727159500122,
-0.23219634592533112,
0.010088893584907055,
-0.9745602607727051,
0.26725247502326965,
-0.3993494510650635,
0.7536922097206116,
-0.30668070912361145,
-0.5612224340438843,
-0.04214230179786682,
-0.054059285670518875,
-0.38602542877197266,
-0.5674781203269958,
0.43161073327064514,
-0.5313926339149475,
0.09225574135780334,
0.01110902987420559,
-0.5732235908508301,
0.08955762535333633,
-0.05283781886100769,
-0.5381835103034973,
0.9641544818878174,
-0.22563296556472778,
-0.6523306965827942,
0.5771625638008118,
-0.36037108302116394,
-0.35128408670425415,
-0.001476320088841021,
-0.0547269731760025,
-0.43954089283943176,
-0.19077713787555695,
0.6080633997917175,
0.4292820990085602,
-0.025459837168455124,
0.4527716636657715,
-0.11579374223947525,
-0.3935578763484955,
0.24759113788604736,
-0.4461275041103363,
1.021586537361145,
0.3844900131225586,
-0.34468165040016174,
0.2982361912727356,
-0.751099705696106,
0.10804616659879684,
-0.38317692279815674,
-0.3722900450229645,
-0.20428414642810822,
-0.13254401087760925,
0.04192278906702995,
0.14362959563732147,
-0.02620828151702881,
-0.42635056376457214,
0.3027596175670624,
-0.5702338218688965,
0.479543000459671,
0.7740437388420105,
-0.07349015772342682,
0.5153298377990723,
-0.28079357743263245,
0.09967932850122452,
0.1225854679942131,
0.08026451617479324,
0.14462734758853912,
-0.2652744948863983,
-0.428699254989624,
-0.4143611788749695,
0.467795193195343,
0.7616665363311768,
-0.5537720918655396,
0.86146080493927,
-0.6189700961112976,
-0.6749480366706848,
-0.40602239966392517,
0.1280471533536911,
0.42089536786079407,
0.7036193013191223,
0.25710999965667725,
-0.49212923645973206,
-0.4713887572288513,
-0.6331882476806641,
0.01996973343193531,
-0.14843638241291046,
-0.16336524486541748,
0.17306622862815857,
0.05227266252040863,
-0.20387393236160278,
1.1368645429611206,
-0.574439287185669,
-0.3674553334712982,
-0.015066977590322495,
0.5154882073402405,
0.4460950195789337,
0.8510051965713501,
0.28301575779914856,
-0.5742331147193909,
-0.23754963278770447,
-0.13229215145111084,
-0.10402633249759674,
-0.41496437788009644,
-0.20178893208503723,
-0.17413516342639923,
0.406960666179657,
0.38099831342697144,
-0.31863611936569214,
0.39787888526916504,
0.3610445559024811,
-0.12547871470451355,
0.4609486162662506,
0.008652767166495323,
0.10413949191570282,
-1.0486282110214233,
0.30020689964294434,
0.19731582701206207,
-0.10737321525812149,
-0.7354943156242371,
-0.5266308784484863,
0.20154331624507904,
-0.03401613235473633,
-0.40472638607025146,
0.32079753279685974,
-0.3663623034954071,
0.27156299352645874,
-0.07634702324867249,
0.07259482890367508,
-0.15536050498485565,
0.511662483215332,
0.2653251886367798,
0.9132991433143616,
0.197970911860466,
-0.6963032484054565,
0.12301675975322723,
0.4251762926578522,
-0.29827141761779785,
0.4663233757019043,
-0.6077987551689148,
0.5563983917236328,
0.1017114520072937,
0.4482204020023346,
-1.0010840892791748,
0.13796953856945038,
0.15313692390918732,
-0.5647109746932983,
0.7011072039604187,
-0.15451635420322418,
-0.3713209629058838,
-0.24946610629558563,
-0.04691649600863457,
0.6832352876663208,
0.41823363304138184,
-0.7152308821678162,
0.38441044092178345,
0.32083895802497864,
0.1651502549648285,
-0.7590000033378601,
-0.42750298976898193,
-0.20939767360687256,
-0.25840720534324646,
-0.516035258769989,
0.47698697447776794,
-0.1172480583190918,
0.07622255384922028,
-0.5733046531677246,
-0.41143158078193665,
-0.3418128788471222,
-0.1475120633840561,
0.2626204192638397,
0.48219263553619385,
-0.34067004919052124,
0.07126910984516144,
-0.042684078216552734,
-0.26102927327156067,
-0.45896559953689575,
-0.4806913137435913,
0.5640602111816406,
0.002948042470961809,
0.05798454210162163,
-0.9034464359283447,
-0.01879825070500374,
0.46110108494758606,
-0.221257284283638,
0.49334514141082764,
0.5836316347122192,
-0.43150004744529724,
0.36609113216400146,
-0.8324902057647705,
-0.20104587078094482,
-0.4364723563194275,
0.030928239226341248,
-0.18078407645225525,
-0.5532815456390381,
0.36967870593070984,
0.060913100838661194,
0.287979394197464,
0.2778516113758087,
0.2729422152042389,
0.011219115927815437,
0.998737633228302,
0.3848453164100647,
-0.27066630125045776,
0.6661912798881531,
-0.3070998191833496,
0.05427436903119087,
-0.8801091313362122,
-0.10251707583665848,
-0.6406562328338623,
-0.253348708152771,
-0.43703702092170715,
-0.24473914504051208,
0.41362622380256653,
0.02240813709795475,
-0.26503124833106995,
0.5349476337432861,
-0.7066152095794678,
0.07908984273672104,
0.5927594304084778,
0.25119277834892273,
0.053579121828079224,
-0.009506603702902794,
-0.17768260836601257,
-0.1800069808959961,
-0.7309909462928772,
-0.4072391092777252,
0.8362082242965698,
0.14442583918571472,
0.6388586759567261,
0.04538785666227341,
0.5932552814483643,
0.06693603843450546,
0.24820789694786072,
-0.7469189763069153,
0.1671602725982666,
-0.19374743103981018,
-0.6255382299423218,
-0.1232316717505455,
-0.3313102722167969,
-0.8050981760025024,
-0.11446809768676758,
-0.27321043610572815,
-1.1673558950424194,
0.40961843729019165,
0.5498360395431519,
-0.5499203205108643,
0.1335805505514145,
-0.8419882655143738,
0.8704309463500977,
-0.04645099118351936,
-0.3023943305015564,
0.1392233669757843,
-0.9486666917800903,
0.0859646201133728,
-0.02272544801235199,
-0.05854245647788048,
-0.02322511561214924,
0.016751734539866447,
0.92847740650177,
-0.6881768107414246,
0.9726398587226868,
-0.23325079679489136,
-0.04271906241774559,
0.4883999228477478,
0.03718535229563713,
0.6292873620986938,
-0.47373801469802856,
0.08950426429510117,
0.22075332701206207,
0.20967648923397064,
-0.3966054618358612,
-0.5201496481895447,
0.5767163634300232,
-0.7492989897727966,
-0.5237691402435303,
-0.13057224452495575,
-0.6953484416007996,
-0.3449425995349884,
-0.09800116717815399,
0.6703759431838989,
0.8394433856010437,
0.07800833135843277,
0.22938330471515656,
0.5268866419792175,
0.2366083711385727,
0.48915472626686096,
0.20339956879615784,
0.34690403938293457,
-0.6925317645072937,
0.757221519947052,
0.4211882948875427,
0.15765637159347534,
0.4747278392314911,
0.20040744543075562,
-0.5591488480567932,
-0.6231040954589844,
-0.3001881241798401,
0.16110427677631378,
-0.49269503355026245,
-0.37720394134521484,
-0.543483316898346,
-0.08969812095165253,
-0.8178181052207947,
-0.3703087866306305,
-0.28794723749160767,
-0.6074256896972656,
-0.3038075566291809,
0.03128869831562042,
0.3127005100250244,
0.24238017201423645,
-0.09212997555732727,
1.010503888130188,
-0.8449307084083557,
-0.26970455050468445,
0.018790021538734436,
0.044329073280096054,
-0.2602105438709259,
-0.7889893054962158,
0.04771159589290619,
-0.09795629233121872,
-0.5322902798652649,
-0.9437941908836365,
0.25310632586479187,
0.3235355317592621,
0.337100625038147,
0.6229962706565857,
0.12733882665634155,
1.064953327178955,
-0.35684260725975037,
0.6695805191993713,
0.5816990733146667,
-1.0766322612762451,
0.5811176896095276,
-0.3392240107059479,
0.4925267696380615,
0.5330984592437744,
0.26539647579193115,
-0.3279266059398651,
-0.3092285990715027,
-0.6180843114852905,
-1.0462385416030884,
0.5981770753860474,
0.2162228226661682,
-0.17160509526729584,
0.22003421187400818,
0.3151605427265167,
0.26569902896881104,
-0.05836200341582298,
-0.6112987995147705,
-0.13543930649757385,
-0.35763832926750183,
-0.5257074236869812,
-0.22014489769935608,
-0.1370726227760315,
0.05007493868470192,
-0.3471304476261139,
0.9214656949043274,
-0.1868891716003418,
0.024389704689383507,
0.3490144908428192,
-0.22983771562576294,
0.042360953986644745,
0.12319471687078476,
0.6156476140022278,
0.4985247254371643,
-0.21105214953422546,
0.12834523618221283,
0.3334246575832367,
-0.5091187357902527,
0.15701664984226227,
0.13950297236442566,
-0.13054609298706055,
0.044781699776649475,
0.37322819232940674,
0.7185388207435608,
0.11024824529886246,
-0.4364408552646637,
0.46827730536460876,
0.2188541740179062,
-0.08321042358875275,
-0.17141149938106537,
-0.061477091163396835,
-0.23985359072685242,
0.12348536401987076,
0.38617172837257385,
0.06532472372055054,
-0.06489892303943634,
0.04602523520588875,
0.43313536047935486,
0.38799962401390076,
-0.621714174747467,
-0.2926795780658722,
0.7462378144264221,
0.2465728372335434,
-0.2044631987810135,
0.6855859756469727,
0.2484407126903534,
-0.43543097376823425,
0.4821219742298126,
0.5915490388870239,
0.739906907081604,
-0.4289710819721222,
-0.17845575511455536,
0.6165311932563782,
0.22466430068016052,
0.14974850416183472,
-0.2718814015388489,
-0.4078257977962494,
-0.7710713744163513,
-0.3516692519187927,
-0.2712864279747009,
-0.04670290648937225,
0.11846652626991272,
-0.6864511966705322,
0.4045161306858063,
-0.566475510597229,
-0.4943650960922241,
0.09845122694969177,
0.025116687640547752,
-0.6894769668579102,
0.17393887042999268,
0.009344139136373997,
0.8104265928268433,
-0.7778058052062988,
0.9590842127799988,
0.589689314365387,
-0.32648006081581116,
-1.1789697408676147,
0.08316879719495773,
0.2066091150045395,
-0.6347398161888123,
0.749199390411377,
0.34244847297668457,
-0.3345429301261902,
0.27623504400253296,
-0.5675756335258484,
-0.780363917350769,
1.0993587970733643,
0.1738457977771759,
-0.8262970447540283,
-0.05014941096305847,
-0.2715184688568115,
0.23249800503253937,
-0.2671600580215454,
0.14003939926624298,
0.5680923461914062,
0.21343784034252167,
0.6410878896713257,
-1.082541823387146,
0.08660402148962021,
-0.03573113679885864,
-0.07934070378541946,
0.3372228145599365,
-0.300464928150177,
0.22284719347953796,
-0.0638030543923378,
-0.40524324774742126,
0.11105938255786896,
0.6637592315673828,
0.20079489052295685,
0.3276185393333435,
0.6862677931785583,
0.4483242630958557,
0.8964179158210754,
-0.20832495391368866,
0.587103009223938,
-0.0221707746386528,
0.1638331562280655,
1.1443685293197632,
-0.2381993979215622,
0.6894564032554626,
0.4730461835861206,
-0.0916999951004982,
0.20722553133964539,
0.8818002939224243,
0.08319884538650513,
0.5737179517745972,
0.040884509682655334,
-0.02013992704451084,
-0.3651050627231598,
-0.1503811925649643,
-0.1815972477197647,
0.42946329712867737,
0.19599772989749908,
-0.05443594232201576,
0.11092307418584824,
-0.21204979717731476,
0.06347566097974777,
-0.09481876343488693,
-0.32853835821151733,
0.7880167961120605,
-0.08670355379581451,
-0.4981166422367096,
1.1143620014190674,
-0.6052952408790588,
0.7605612874031067,
-0.3195032477378845,
0.2689797282218933,
-0.05474281683564186,
0.10176042467355728,
-0.24499040842056274,
-0.30551400780677795,
0.25565671920776367,
0.015238308347761631,
-0.13827845454216003,
0.030366113409399986,
0.25074121356010437,
-0.36923983693122864,
-0.20981141924858093,
-0.11487750709056854,
0.18643945455551147,
0.10820920765399933,
0.19023196399211884,
-0.47021564841270447,
-0.02566969022154808,
-0.04452796280384064,
0.021605664864182472,
-0.1383841633796692,
0.18485242128372192,
-0.1117367073893547,
0.46933871507644653,
0.6134400963783264,
-0.004118284210562706,
0.34583014249801636,
0.05283021926879883,
0.6038963198661804,
-0.523401141166687,
-0.5333232879638672,
-0.5630939602851868,
0.4667966067790985,
-0.061150502413511276,
-0.4545729458332062,
-0.033809222280979156,
0.7232576608657837,
0.7338463068008423,
0.11547549813985825,
0.22767743468284607,
0.05544296279549599,
0.2586338520050049,
-0.807354211807251,
0.6291816234588623,
-0.48119908571243286,
0.31524330377578735,
-0.26204589009284973,
-0.8287114500999451,
-0.6677982211112976,
0.4170669615268707,
-0.464883029460907,
-0.17228475213050842,
0.6687580943107605,
0.9194080829620361,
-0.036112863570451736,
0.0025533437728881836,
0.3313516080379486,
0.10064489394426346,
0.35458648204803467,
0.6707677841186523,
0.7812768220901489,
-0.42438361048698425,
0.8444477319717407,
-0.25164464116096497,
-0.2959924340248108,
-0.08902079612016678,
-0.7366997599601746,
-0.7293717265129089,
-0.802830159664154,
-0.6357768774032593,
-0.33794909715652466,
0.17361684143543243,
1.2666069269180298,
0.8194050192832947,
-0.8869152069091797,
-0.1446552574634552,
0.0507025420665741,
-0.07422682642936707,
-0.4254157841205597,
-0.2163616567850113,
0.5939648747444153,
-0.28420761227607727,
-0.7738751769065857,
0.2782664895057678,
-0.1299165040254593,
0.4480823576450348,
0.6471177935600281,
-0.06321574002504349,
-0.16268929839134216,
-0.17204096913337708,
0.2243967354297638,
0.2640271484851837,
-0.8550425171852112,
-0.6187604069709778,
0.06476491689682007,
-0.17991852760314941,
0.5210022330284119,
1.0338855981826782,
-0.8176957368850708,
0.4169873595237732,
0.26200228929519653,
0.49496379494667053,
0.3050929605960846,
0.07719074934720993,
0.6803699731826782,
-0.8969478011131287,
0.22645820677280426,
0.26873329281806946,
0.31675297021865845,
0.3317909836769104,
-0.44218289852142334,
0.3365747928619385,
0.3573341369628906,
-0.46624431014060974,
-0.7038726806640625,
0.1933758407831192,
-1.3273403644561768,
-0.06618037819862366,
0.959681510925293,
0.07649125903844833,
-0.251414954662323,
-0.1560681313276291,
-0.37859246134757996,
0.7492072582244873,
-0.5828731656074524,
0.744377851486206,
0.43864405155181885,
-0.15942837297916412,
0.04265508055686951,
-0.1795586347579956,
0.3023289144039154,
0.3574623465538025,
-0.19523002207279205,
0.18866194784641266,
0.768666684627533,
0.31391552090644836,
0.23603060841560364,
0.45927801728248596,
-0.06763062626123428,
0.2869144082069397,
-0.09697894006967545,
0.10397719591856003,
-0.08319544047117233,
-0.16810832917690277,
-0.36044204235076904,
0.10300172120332718,
0.07564888894557953,
-0.5392851829528809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15166v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15166v1
|
Pixels and Predictions: Potential of GPT-4V in Meteorological Imagery Analysis and Forecast Communication
| 2024-04-22T17:36:33 | 2024-04-22T17:36:33 |
John R. Lawson, Montgomery L. Flora, Kevin H. Goebbert, Seth N. Lyman, Corey K. Potvin, David M. Schultz, Adam J. Stepanek, Joseph E. Trujillo-Falcón
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, physics.ao-ph
|
Generative AI, such as OpenAI's GPT-4V large-language model, has rapidly
entered mainstream discourse. Novel capabilities in image processing and
natural-language communication may augment existing forecasting methods. Large
language models further display potential to better communicate weather hazards
in a style honed for diverse communities and different languages. This study
evaluates GPT-4V's ability to interpret meteorological charts and communicate
weather hazards appropriately to the user, despite challenges of
hallucinations, where generative AI delivers coherent, confident, but incorrect
responses. We assess GPT-4V's competence via its web interface ChatGPT in two
tasks: (1) generating a severe-weather outlook from weather-chart analysis and
conducting self-evaluation, revealing an outlook that corresponds well with a
Storm Prediction Center human-issued forecast; and (2) producing hazard
summaries in Spanish and English from weather charts. Responses in Spanish,
however, resemble direct (not idiomatic) translations from English to Spanish,
yielding poorly translated summaries that lose critical idiomatic precision
required for optimal communication. Our findings advocate for cautious
integration of tools like GPT-4V in meteorology, underscoring the necessity of
human oversight and development of trustworthy, explainable AI.
|
[
-0.2682912051677704,
-0.5884971022605896,
0.728606641292572,
0.5981137752532959,
-0.33699432015419006,
-0.08405070751905441,
-0.10127086937427521,
-0.8606281280517578,
-0.1674785614013672,
-0.026193255558609962,
-0.2604740858078003,
-0.5527660250663757,
-0.5747511982917786,
0.023371998220682144,
-0.5222605466842651,
0.9799306988716125,
-0.1424720585346222,
-0.3563200533390045,
-0.08269353210926056,
0.5179874300956726,
-0.4264155328273773,
-0.7498226165771484,
-0.557568371295929,
-0.13289077579975128,
0.43054962158203125,
0.16629262268543243,
1.072023868560791,
0.2724323570728302,
0.6820615530014038,
0.35880327224731445,
0.4379098117351532,
-0.28127631545066833,
-0.22082364559173584,
0.057716649025678635,
-0.006603227462619543,
-0.2566986083984375,
-0.41583314538002014,
0.21714535355567932,
0.44563060998916626,
0.09218619018793106,
-0.3094882667064667,
-0.06792552769184113,
-0.018997542560100555,
0.456037700176239,
-0.4289894104003906,
0.7049733996391296,
-0.4414079785346985,
0.1318785548210144,
-0.2708245515823364,
-0.362345427274704,
-0.13519227504730225,
-0.003947115503251553,
0.5087399482727051,
-0.6084397435188293,
0.28368571400642395,
-0.2543640732765198,
0.6377572417259216,
0.3551957607269287,
-0.30416977405548096,
-0.20904551446437836,
-0.9474764466285706,
0.5184256434440613,
-0.40043905377388,
0.19096900522708893,
0.5498571395874023,
0.677232027053833,
-0.0052136993035674095,
-0.717052698135376,
-0.4705332815647125,
-0.07484836131334305,
0.38717198371887207,
0.6866009831428528,
-0.4134044647216797,
-0.07232633233070374,
-0.075420081615448,
0.07980266213417053,
-0.5787320733070374,
0.2840106189250946,
-0.4329688847064972,
-0.4167307913303375,
0.747306764125824,
0.20516540110111237,
0.28657829761505127,
-0.29518237709999084,
-0.27243638038635254,
0.10755374282598495,
-0.5876627564430237,
-0.28608423471450806,
0.6630666255950928,
0.20486778020858765,
-0.47863948345184326,
0.28684002161026,
0.08198683708906174,
0.6417651772499084,
-0.5720415711402893,
-0.2197154313325882,
0.2179860919713974,
-0.24992918968200684,
-0.4377424716949463,
-0.11859667301177979,
1.0025392770767212,
0.6979307532310486,
0.1817932426929474,
-0.2261003851890564,
-0.14102032780647278,
0.2544862926006317,
0.29946669936180115,
-0.6698541641235352,
-0.6620120406150818,
-0.006410055793821812,
-0.290511816740036,
-0.4809344410896301,
-0.13392379879951477,
-1.1575872898101807,
-0.5296142101287842,
-0.22943997383117676,
0.42355430126190186,
-0.3772180676460266,
-0.33484694361686707,
0.004144533537328243,
-0.3416416645050049,
-0.04264672100543976,
0.5472226142883301,
-0.7820108532905579,
0.089569590985775,
0.35566776990890503,
0.833861231803894,
0.0928921326994896,
-0.33952924609184265,
-0.020732883363962173,
-0.05943428725004196,
-0.3912068009376526,
0.903087854385376,
-0.532800555229187,
-0.36051681637763977,
-0.13321393728256226,
-0.3527861535549164,
0.07037989050149918,
-0.012026133015751839,
0.3318229913711548,
-0.31776291131973267,
0.35376888513565063,
0.06288862973451614,
0.16770216822624207,
-0.33079496026039124,
0.1218438446521759,
-0.41360151767730713,
0.6269479393959045,
0.1382896900177002,
-0.786097526550293,
0.18738998472690582,
-0.42924419045448303,
-0.2136104851961136,
0.2900833487510681,
-0.4652767479419708,
-0.39859679341316223,
-0.34240201115608215,
0.4798198342323303,
0.5281630158424377,
-0.4159981608390808,
0.007482160348445177,
0.06939925998449326,
-0.11675696820020676,
0.037908025085926056,
-0.8569063544273376,
0.1721106916666031,
0.43392083048820496,
-0.6620712280273438,
0.2668328881263733,
-0.4570182263851166,
-0.09409339725971222,
0.2260749638080597,
-0.0012941793538630009,
0.11528106033802032,
0.14980894327163696,
0.37803852558135986,
0.1890164166688919,
0.15949514508247375,
-0.11999916285276413,
0.011767977848649025,
-0.4057271182537079,
0.6935073137283325,
0.8527990579605103,
-0.06618816405534744,
0.2693275511264801,
-0.2578880786895752,
0.8209192156791687,
0.1028757393360138,
0.2215723842382431,
-0.2630768418312073,
-1.1462066173553467,
-0.2854959964752197,
0.10492105036973953,
-0.1942790001630783,
0.6671632528305054,
-1.0384122133255005,
0.011992398649454117,
-0.4060628414154053,
-0.8626053929328918,
-0.032963983714580536,
-0.3808650076389313,
0.30497702956199646,
0.4702073633670807,
0.3874686360359192,
0.06357545405626297,
-0.7115965485572815,
-0.572147011756897,
-0.0007471541757695377,
-0.2916969656944275,
0.0013527615228667855,
0.14195702970027924,
0.33703485131263733,
-0.3326833248138428,
0.5680801272392273,
-0.2117881029844284,
-0.0375429205596447,
-0.28055694699287415,
0.32579299807548523,
0.11802513152360916,
0.09624713659286499,
0.8771068453788757,
-0.8670041561126709,
-0.5868231058120728,
0.18606756627559662,
-0.6744475364685059,
0.2455826848745346,
-0.058039478957653046,
0.21030907332897186,
0.22209663689136505,
0.058767568320035934,
-0.2667534053325653,
0.6778251528739929,
0.888166069984436,
-0.43558308482170105,
0.6915451288223267,
-0.4169774055480957,
0.4466019570827484,
-0.8722378015518188,
-0.31278127431869507,
0.3138657510280609,
-0.2904600501060486,
-0.6947163939476013,
-0.0673798993229866,
-0.14489541947841644,
-0.19813939929008484,
-0.42843154072761536,
0.32141920924186707,
-0.3579290509223938,
-0.06220519542694092,
-0.24832327663898468,
0.05576285347342491,
-0.5219850540161133,
0.04288572445511818,
0.02691829390823841,
1.0291467905044556,
0.9368491172790527,
-0.3266974687576294,
0.7470589876174927,
0.27041158080101013,
-0.30357569456100464,
0.18452712893486023,
-0.4206770360469818,
0.33170029520988464,
-0.25304555892944336,
0.139730304479599,
-0.6436624526977539,
-0.5401752591133118,
0.5449435710906982,
-0.4353577792644501,
0.06932945549488068,
-0.3004929721355438,
-0.44466423988342285,
-0.5997363924980164,
-0.16248294711112976,
0.2501034736633301,
0.8274684548377991,
-0.43408334255218506,
0.34700265526771545,
0.3973105847835541,
-0.2700219750404358,
-0.30555158853530884,
-0.8617368936538696,
0.5499564409255981,
-0.3179228603839874,
-0.5442332029342651,
0.24416707456111908,
0.006856354419142008,
-0.22496679425239563,
-0.22030198574066162,
-0.07579166442155838,
-0.19928215444087982,
0.10008738934993744,
0.46874067187309265,
0.35659030079841614,
-0.10573351383209229,
0.05450288951396942,
-0.5382394194602966,
-0.14375200867652893,
0.23139739036560059,
-0.4326118528842926,
0.5147512555122375,
-0.4950776696205139,
-0.20201686024665833,
-0.4910040497779846,
0.1342257261276245,
0.5096672773361206,
0.18210816383361816,
0.570253849029541,
0.3869933485984802,
-0.41041216254234314,
0.31579673290252686,
-0.31222793459892273,
0.2157023549079895,
-0.45230787992477417,
0.3062794506549835,
-0.5152780413627625,
-0.48168259859085083,
0.33581504225730896,
0.29067742824554443,
-0.34450775384902954,
0.7394022345542908,
0.5823130011558533,
-0.06953758746385574,
1.0111045837402344,
0.4915524423122406,
-0.5285127758979797,
0.3150743246078491,
-0.05116821825504303,
0.25963833928108215,
-0.23425979912281036,
-0.29196760058403015,
-0.4914456903934479,
-0.0870661586523056,
-0.5925589799880981,
-0.4477211833000183,
0.5292819738388062,
-0.4714582562446594,
-0.4982353150844574,
0.07535884529352188,
-0.7286909818649292,
0.2759813666343689,
0.40876731276512146,
0.054403506219387054,
0.16349434852600098,
0.1339716911315918,
0.46197423338890076,
-0.23819778859615326,
-0.5230812430381775,
-0.5982815027236938,
1.0604921579360962,
0.5191911458969116,
0.844423234462738,
0.09201141446828842,
0.3294007480144501,
0.27896443009376526,
0.3707810938358307,
-0.610492467880249,
0.21077974140644073,
0.11532280594110489,
-0.1591949760913849,
-0.31013602018356323,
-0.47754666209220886,
-0.9950305223464966,
0.1447099894285202,
-0.24268588423728943,
-0.8118905425071716,
-0.1321016401052475,
0.25576505064964294,
-0.1929580271244049,
0.1290711611509323,
-0.9468995332717896,
0.7437419295310974,
-0.29708462953567505,
0.34258466958999634,
-0.1954292505979538,
-0.6389569044113159,
0.22345025837421417,
-0.04349203407764435,
0.5773901343345642,
-0.17313537001609802,
-0.16304239630699158,
0.5689389109611511,
-0.017700975760817528,
1.0484188795089722,
-0.08552595227956772,
-0.15875767171382904,
0.29211780428886414,
-0.03959359973669052,
0.4398099184036255,
0.0032684318721294403,
-0.1343582421541214,
0.37156060338020325,
0.05801379308104515,
-0.3794124722480774,
-0.42121991515159607,
0.643463671207428,
-1.2812920808792114,
-0.4930734932422638,
-0.701131284236908,
-0.3034929633140564,
-0.14370207488536835,
0.06865981221199036,
0.5756236910820007,
0.5262090563774109,
-0.3288087248802185,
-0.38236406445503235,
-0.17848309874534607,
-0.14083963632583618,
0.34296733140945435,
0.19680292904376984,
-0.26460525393486023,
-0.3941531181335449,
1.1422884464263916,
0.0007128876750357449,
0.012783302925527096,
0.05974063649773598,
0.34036868810653687,
-0.06087799370288849,
-0.7657383680343628,
-0.28103315830230713,
-0.03772367537021637,
-0.7809288501739502,
-0.43769371509552,
-0.30686843395233154,
-0.5437126159667969,
-0.4428045153617859,
-0.0974181666970253,
-0.010622241534292698,
-0.1546810269355774,
-0.24791578948497772,
-0.29632291197776794,
0.25776511430740356,
0.9137240648269653,
0.11373263597488403,
0.3308323621749878,
-0.761583685874939,
0.053020577877759933,
0.0513342060148716,
0.17442244291305542,
-0.2770201861858368,
-0.2169252187013626,
-0.039879411458969116,
0.14618608355522156,
-0.45861881971359253,
-0.9584985971450806,
0.7939786911010742,
0.1830400824546814,
0.4221518039703369,
0.3897136151790619,
-0.24043773114681244,
0.7557781338691711,
-0.548953115940094,
1.0528796911239624,
0.4877215027809143,
-0.8805106282234192,
0.7515429258346558,
-0.6579922437667847,
0.2671225368976593,
-0.16024574637413025,
0.4353683292865753,
-0.5967642664909363,
-0.5969091057777405,
-0.858052670955658,
-0.5554477572441101,
0.4941056966781616,
0.5708407759666443,
0.20095445215702057,
-0.2376401424407959,
0.07730383425951004,
0.16682493686676025,
0.19982106983661652,
-0.5945905447006226,
0.02490377239882946,
-0.9404707551002502,
-0.12254087626934052,
-0.576324462890625,
-0.21887660026550293,
-0.18849918246269226,
-0.17893745005130768,
0.26333484053611755,
-0.18925538659095764,
0.6222699880599976,
0.3013251721858978,
0.3629148602485657,
-0.021162234246730804,
0.2835589051246643,
0.5616953372955322,
0.7285162806510925,
0.1141444742679596,
0.4250548481941223,
-0.03777338191866875,
-0.6885220408439636,
-0.142464742064476,
0.3865412771701813,
0.051627080887556076,
-0.22240425646305084,
0.6298205852508545,
0.7543910145759583,
0.10294897854328156,
-0.49665501713752747,
0.658812403678894,
-0.052648015320301056,
-0.27519673109054565,
-0.4272010922431946,
-0.040918026119470596,
-0.08156585693359375,
0.12986239790916443,
0.2577364444732666,
0.45401087403297424,
0.37752941250801086,
-0.6681889891624451,
-0.2864302396774292,
0.1477905809879303,
-0.14630360901355743,
-0.8426755666732788,
0.9447581768035889,
0.4110420048236847,
-0.029154516756534576,
0.7691131830215454,
-0.06356006860733032,
-0.5923864245414734,
0.8269660472869873,
0.6780266165733337,
0.6804436445236206,
-0.28060147166252136,
0.4187335968017578,
0.31165391206741333,
0.5250895619392395,
-0.16798320412635803,
0.6013810634613037,
0.2025078684091568,
-0.8755771517753601,
-0.2731456160545349,
-0.34822481870651245,
-0.39123132824897766,
0.11509014666080475,
-0.1985097974538803,
-0.007065952755510807,
-0.4630593955516815,
-0.21894460916519165,
0.12762382626533508,
-0.509763240814209,
-1.0408284664154053,
0.19033142924308777,
0.45531317591667175,
0.7775813937187195,
-0.868617832660675,
0.4977673292160034,
0.7256971001625061,
-0.5725504159927368,
-0.788270890712738,
0.16608500480651855,
0.22955216467380524,
-0.8028812408447266,
0.5364019870758057,
0.2658262550830841,
0.003647103440016508,
0.10649845749139786,
-0.5275537967681885,
-0.7643250823020935,
1.034603238105774,
0.34825947880744934,
-0.4289495646953583,
-0.09991679340600967,
0.07187310606241226,
0.7391589879989624,
0.0033794280607253313,
0.41693052649497986,
0.5043007731437683,
0.6132237315177917,
0.1537257879972458,
-1.3010083436965942,
-0.07501929253339767,
-0.1740037351846695,
0.13840411603450775,
0.11126743257045746,
-0.32284703850746155,
0.5039637684822083,
-0.38513368368148804,
-0.5112032890319824,
0.17796988785266876,
0.712730348110199,
-0.5600010752677917,
0.3755749464035034,
0.24806256592273712,
0.17457905411720276,
0.7011200189590454,
-0.37588876485824585,
1.4438295364379883,
0.025389214977622032,
0.15652400255203247,
0.7936122417449951,
0.07567224651575089,
0.7096215486526489,
0.13545610010623932,
-0.48066461086273193,
0.5711191892623901,
0.63495272397995,
0.04990990459918976,
0.6527951955795288,
-0.1684287041425705,
-0.5153895020484924,
0.0043421522714197636,
0.30748867988586426,
-0.28845885396003723,
0.4405589699745178,
0.5836524367332458,
-0.03304360434412956,
-0.3159683346748352,
0.3496445119380951,
-0.19294433295726776,
-0.04070698469877243,
-0.31873854994773865,
0.5972836017608643,
0.013032765127718449,
-0.6114989519119263,
0.3679780662059784,
-0.009262870997190475,
0.4200071394443512,
-0.2991780936717987,
-0.017475273460149765,
0.27278342843055725,
-0.05331670865416527,
-0.3646177649497986,
-1.2583640813827515,
0.5839996337890625,
0.0691835954785347,
0.205942302942276,
-0.1793093979358673,
0.49064186215400696,
-0.07607784122228622,
-0.28530746698379517,
-0.014553472399711609,
0.3575286269187927,
0.47499626874923706,
-0.3536090552806854,
-0.4086237847805023,
-0.046647656708955765,
-0.11493783444166183,
0.05142250284552574,
0.19258703291416168,
0.3013277053833008,
-0.1292128711938858,
0.8230852484703064,
0.4840227961540222,
0.1657133400440216,
0.023983648046851158,
0.24490568041801453,
0.8273053169250488,
-0.6962373852729797,
-0.686102569103241,
-0.7666904926300049,
0.32033514976501465,
0.040651995688676834,
-0.09172476828098297,
0.6184365749359131,
0.3607090413570404,
0.4190549850463867,
-0.2751275300979614,
1.2635220289230347,
-0.02540697157382965,
-0.11201128363609314,
-0.4655360281467438,
0.34192749857902527,
0.09501763433218002,
-0.030267972499132156,
-0.2271617352962494,
-0.7493873238563538,
-0.3316461741924286,
0.5682149529457092,
-0.5937089920043945,
0.12204314768314362,
0.6927080154418945,
0.2856367230415344,
0.1912965178489685,
0.17506572604179382,
0.5380573272705078,
0.28989824652671814,
0.6873685717582703,
0.4503417909145355,
1.0128281116485596,
-0.23979692161083221,
0.647315502166748,
-0.2652391791343689,
-0.5961163640022278,
0.08805634826421738,
-1.0125432014465332,
-0.8627544045448303,
-0.7982664108276367,
-0.12553687393665314,
-0.22414420545101166,
0.1906387209892273,
0.6303873658180237,
0.5116634964942932,
-0.40258821845054626,
0.1883886158466339,
-0.3330528438091278,
-0.24959762394428253,
0.04477297142148018,
-0.23807109892368317,
0.29032379388809204,
-0.30017855763435364,
-0.6491830348968506,
0.4192795753479004,
0.4975949227809906,
0.5479164123535156,
-0.2870437204837799,
-0.038415826857089996,
0.7881501317024231,
-0.22843463718891144,
0.557669997215271,
0.16277600824832916,
-0.8915565013885498,
-0.5413386821746826,
-0.39082351326942444,
-0.15793447196483612,
0.10294614732265472,
0.4327549636363983,
-0.7463259696960449,
0.6944194436073303,
0.3086795508861542,
0.38850146532058716,
0.3955988585948944,
-0.048456959426403046,
0.8585713505744934,
-0.5334799289703369,
0.33969220519065857,
0.24249514937400818,
0.32564133405685425,
0.5384528040885925,
-0.6730454564094543,
0.4609842598438263,
0.3035091757774353,
-0.6398532390594482,
-0.22064241766929626,
0.08976487815380096,
-0.7529245018959045,
-0.00974773894995451,
1.224117636680603,
0.008709121495485306,
0.14508675038814545,
-0.23486609756946564,
-0.4977165460586548,
-0.19123657047748566,
-0.350699782371521,
0.8197904825210571,
0.7506673336029053,
-0.2053956240415573,
-0.31318891048431396,
-0.8407076597213745,
0.6124261617660522,
-0.4099516272544861,
-0.9920873641967773,
-0.20971360802650452,
0.5558521151542664,
0.2726981043815613,
0.10506651550531387,
0.7504525780677795,
0.043202098459005356,
0.49336889386177063,
0.06782298535108566,
-0.030049562454223633,
0.07959675043821335,
-0.42925891280174255,
-0.15579496324062347,
-0.12781468033790588,
0.23678423464298248,
-0.17212364077568054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14372v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14372v1
|
Beyond Scaling: Predicting Patent Approval with Domain-specific Fine-grained Claim Dependency Graph
| 2024-04-22T17:22:31 | 2024-04-22T17:22:31 |
Xiaochen Kev Gao, Feng Yao, Kewen Zhao, Beilei He, Animesh Kumar, Vish Krishnan, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Model scaling is becoming the default choice for many language tasks due to
the success of large language models (LLMs). However, it can fall short in
specific scenarios where simple customized methods excel. In this paper, we
delve into the patent approval pre-diction task and unveil that simple
domain-specific graph methods outperform enlarging the model, using the
intrinsic dependencies within the patent data. Specifically, we first extend
the embedding-based state-of-the-art (SOTA) by scaling up its backbone model
with various sizes of open-source LLMs, then explore prompt-based methods to
harness proprietary LLMs' potential, but find the best results close to random
guessing, underlining the ineffectiveness of model scaling-up. Hence, we
propose a novel Fine-grained cLAim depeNdency (FLAN) Graph through meticulous
patent data analyses, capturing the inherent dependencies across segments of
the patent text. As it is model-agnostic, we apply cost-effective graph models
to our FLAN Graph to obtain representations for approval prediction. Extensive
experiments and detailed analyses prove that incorporating FLAN Graph via
various graph models consistently outperforms all LLM baselines significantly.
We hope that our observations and analyses in this paper can bring more
attention to this challenging task and prompt further research into the
limitations of LLMs. Our source code and dataset can be obtained from
http://github.com/ShangDataLab/FLAN-Graph.
|
[
-0.3751782178878784,
-0.5953552722930908,
0.6993545889854431,
0.19439570605754852,
0.1603255718946457,
0.08235979825258255,
0.07872123271226883,
-0.6237143278121948,
0.4078158736228943,
0.7209576964378357,
-0.2613181471824646,
-0.37735268473625183,
-0.8697336316108704,
-0.1640290766954422,
-0.15308968722820282,
0.93658447265625,
-0.25723797082901,
-0.13228164613246918,
-0.2858840227127075,
0.002217549365013838,
-0.18560053408145905,
-0.2757575511932373,
-0.22054605185985565,
-0.651767373085022,
0.473514199256897,
0.5732936859130859,
0.6001498699188232,
0.5916754603385925,
0.3957712650299072,
0.3017520308494568,
-0.30893003940582275,
0.012268813326954842,
-0.33221837878227234,
-0.26267197728157043,
-0.112457275390625,
-0.5953218936920166,
-0.8627771735191345,
0.08464673906564713,
0.47024834156036377,
0.8270387053489685,
0.0001830267283366993,
0.11338942497968674,
0.25693279504776,
0.5943745970726013,
-0.4488779306411743,
0.45366302132606506,
-0.9242507219314575,
-0.0994965210556984,
-0.31025558710098267,
0.14522700011730194,
-0.49990779161453247,
-0.2225373536348343,
0.4885367155075073,
-0.5461174845695496,
0.14433321356773376,
0.35696157813072205,
1.2282910346984863,
-0.09547378122806549,
-0.37114572525024414,
-0.4439297914505005,
-0.4658396244049072,
0.501977264881134,
-0.6558108329772949,
-0.14114245772361755,
0.4413851201534271,
0.2625817656517029,
-0.340891569852829,
-1.2968482971191406,
-0.5027589797973633,
-0.5912965536117554,
-0.05066011846065521,
-0.38667428493499756,
-0.32154881954193115,
0.2341734617948532,
0.24026764929294586,
0.4947156012058258,
-0.3397131860256195,
0.42816483974456787,
-0.3170281648635864,
-0.3911116123199463,
0.22486534714698792,
0.016972051933407784,
0.3184911012649536,
-0.15657766163349152,
-0.5122697353363037,
0.2870539724826813,
-0.9217073917388916,
0.04684944450855255,
-0.07646169513463974,
0.8480137586593628,
0.022584829479455948,
0.6258800625801086,
-0.25989773869514465,
0.5962976217269897,
0.3136001527309418,
0.3731658160686493,
0.2992858290672302,
-0.21752122044563293,
-0.29974499344825745,
0.17750728130340576,
0.6824313998222351,
0.10804886370897293,
0.34314385056495667,
0.2272079437971115,
-0.31152257323265076,
-0.20597852766513824,
0.01994810812175274,
-1.0590065717697144,
-0.16692686080932617,
0.2632279396057129,
-0.5190527439117432,
-0.13349702954292297,
-0.06408125907182693,
-0.6711403131484985,
-0.9724173545837402,
-0.27380743622779846,
0.6719586849212646,
-0.16829045116901398,
-0.28145235776901245,
0.1109750047326088,
0.17760373651981354,
-0.20447514951229095,
0.3646637797355652,
-0.8206782341003418,
0.10389652103185654,
0.7827743887901306,
1.1575053930282593,
0.32284390926361084,
-0.3965604305267334,
-0.5692893862724304,
-0.17661592364311218,
-0.4236675500869751,
1.057599663734436,
-0.34279218316078186,
-0.10288698971271515,
0.013135962188243866,
-0.028002608567476273,
-0.18733806908130646,
-0.67295902967453,
0.5131345391273499,
-0.6759204268455505,
-0.2661215364933014,
-0.28699707984924316,
-0.6723966598510742,
-0.17822058498859406,
0.29406580328941345,
-0.8821203708648682,
0.4182112514972687,
0.22821353375911713,
-0.7817220687866211,
0.8186383247375488,
-0.6562261581420898,
-0.5287880897521973,
0.07139851897954941,
0.07045261561870575,
-0.43649721145629883,
0.04594855383038521,
0.08224844187498093,
0.6734099984169006,
-0.541774570941925,
0.17768584191799164,
-0.7152640223503113,
0.17454202473163605,
0.024140220135450363,
0.06767681241035461,
0.6929024457931519,
0.3837263584136963,
-0.3036877512931824,
0.3906153738498688,
-0.9051530361175537,
-0.11019917577505112,
0.07742488384246826,
0.16141244769096375,
-0.34732604026794434,
0.028110923245549202,
-0.330780953168869,
0.13526402413845062,
0.4564948081970215,
-0.5954213738441467,
0.022599177435040474,
-0.5710134506225586,
0.6769825220108032,
0.8231287002563477,
-0.11591602861881256,
0.515367865562439,
-0.24320615828037262,
0.5851103067398071,
-0.16480229794979095,
0.11802283674478531,
-0.2959836721420288,
-0.5516340732574463,
-0.4967901408672333,
-0.4119681715965271,
0.5831403136253357,
0.15620851516723633,
-0.2960296869277954,
0.2373068630695343,
-0.487989604473114,
-0.6127288341522217,
-0.010221452452242374,
0.00045156333362683654,
0.17717231810092926,
0.5032669305801392,
0.07505227625370026,
-0.35637399554252625,
-0.4050765633583069,
-0.5380789637565613,
-0.2024204134941101,
-0.3279464542865753,
-0.015025424771010876,
0.34128615260124207,
0.45778223872184753,
-0.1931900531053543,
1.0530894994735718,
-0.7259172201156616,
-0.8895052671432495,
-0.4513738453388214,
0.2844161093235016,
0.5034001469612122,
0.24566762149333954,
0.703509509563446,
-0.5727078318595886,
-0.8115993142127991,
0.3707636892795563,
-0.2313280999660492,
-0.22180533409118652,
-0.05429663881659508,
0.16080057621002197,
-0.026851292699575424,
0.43932896852493286,
-0.6193268299102783,
0.35455116629600525,
0.6383016705513,
-0.5040362477302551,
0.7216702699661255,
-0.38278138637542725,
0.09623431414365768,
-0.9680192470550537,
0.1006152555346489,
0.13379091024398804,
-0.3407767713069916,
-0.7090246677398682,
-0.004405270330607891,
0.1474027782678604,
0.028179854154586792,
-0.31655192375183105,
0.5126298069953918,
-0.43584585189819336,
0.08644396811723709,
-0.3023357689380646,
-0.014096442610025406,
0.15366996824741364,
0.03128860145807266,
-0.20200149714946747,
0.5407034754753113,
0.6968177556991577,
-0.6374841928482056,
-0.06064903736114502,
-0.03217602148652077,
-0.6206222772598267,
0.26903361082077026,
-0.8391223549842834,
-0.26098692417144775,
0.22172237932682037,
0.3227323591709137,
-1.157701015472412,
-0.29915744066238403,
-0.14713142812252045,
-0.16808632016181946,
0.45389261841773987,
-0.32161954045295715,
-0.4527125060558319,
-0.511017382144928,
-0.2894784212112427,
0.012217559851706028,
0.15222568809986115,
-0.7656742930412292,
0.9372748732566833,
0.6926276087760925,
-0.23928791284561157,
-0.3508104979991913,
-0.725625216960907,
-0.0029872520826756954,
-0.21925373375415802,
-0.8064647912979126,
0.5589115023612976,
0.11832407861948013,
-0.11610322445631027,
-0.06098726764321327,
-0.006450139917433262,
-0.41248154640197754,
-0.11554960906505585,
0.4409501552581787,
0.08675265312194824,
-0.3880241811275482,
-0.24212037026882172,
-0.01889563910663128,
-0.16424299776554108,
-0.011888084001839161,
-0.46645301580429077,
0.420263409614563,
-0.15530423820018768,
-0.07346600294113159,
-0.3572717607021332,
-0.19404330849647522,
0.9973939657211304,
0.033283792436122894,
0.28819966316223145,
0.04490211606025696,
-0.4251839518547058,
-0.39947906136512756,
-0.25466418266296387,
0.16308924555778503,
-0.5258499979972839,
0.3700954020023346,
-0.6733994483947754,
-0.8228442668914795,
0.770645022392273,
-0.5929595232009888,
0.06455928832292557,
0.6905811429023743,
0.6032820343971252,
0.2742292881011963,
0.9116202592849731,
0.7936376929283142,
-0.17748013138771057,
0.6064820289611816,
-0.3651391267776489,
0.3825487494468689,
-0.4990755617618561,
-0.0038922219537198544,
-0.5736244320869446,
-0.19667775928974152,
-0.49610957503318787,
-0.4592190086841583,
0.11707685887813568,
0.11898928880691528,
-0.09953393042087555,
0.5331282019615173,
-0.3919426202774048,
0.4056943953037262,
0.3521941900253296,
-0.063582643866539,
0.2566129267215729,
0.22276759147644043,
-0.3847869038581848,
-0.022649280726909637,
-0.4775420129299164,
-0.5049638152122498,
1.3694285154342651,
0.5116816759109497,
0.6971458196640015,
-0.3339807689189911,
0.5217634439468384,
0.5512806177139282,
0.5413519740104675,
-0.8053971529006958,
0.3999534249305725,
-0.49231842160224915,
-0.6572229266166687,
-0.25020766258239746,
-0.31800776720046997,
-0.983718991279602,
0.10281725227832794,
0.1799231767654419,
-0.7780410051345825,
0.32392725348472595,
0.3770463466644287,
-0.5863999128341675,
0.2992400527000427,
-0.9308408498764038,
0.8861197829246521,
-0.07790204137563705,
-0.13779699802398682,
-0.43060222268104553,
-0.3485892415046692,
0.32318222522735596,
-0.4126709997653961,
0.2874324321746826,
-0.2117457091808319,
0.24074456095695496,
0.5877031683921814,
-1.0661804676055908,
0.9199720621109009,
-0.3762734830379486,
-0.3583678901195526,
0.6724693179130554,
0.18233373761177063,
0.6231549382209778,
-0.22400763630867004,
-0.3144505023956299,
0.2784099578857422,
0.18340684473514557,
-0.1273820847272873,
-0.5652785897254944,
0.7532368898391724,
-0.3370696008205414,
-0.5132097005844116,
-0.4067866802215576,
-0.27302825450897217,
-0.1955970674753189,
0.5806597471237183,
0.28926774859428406,
0.31936126947402954,
-0.17011260986328125,
-0.08159608393907547,
0.20473678410053253,
0.02080460451543331,
0.17587119340896606,
0.4461377263069153,
-0.5739779472351074,
-0.4468643367290497,
1.1694140434265137,
0.5855309367179871,
0.37552884221076965,
0.32737457752227783,
0.5484396815299988,
-0.46289464831352234,
-0.7120488882064819,
-0.3305089771747589,
0.12983645498752594,
-0.5932192802429199,
-0.20247435569763184,
-0.5667056441307068,
-0.26340973377227783,
-0.36113661527633667,
-0.01155997347086668,
-0.4877365529537201,
-0.7366335988044739,
-0.3401032090187073,
-0.18470017611980438,
0.27768635749816895,
1.0083214044570923,
-0.10202831029891968,
0.2648649215698242,
-0.4910140335559845,
0.22685475647449493,
0.20216873288154602,
0.6721684336662292,
0.24688486754894257,
-0.5714210271835327,
-0.3192023038864136,
0.05364745110273361,
-0.4361691176891327,
-0.32372933626174927,
0.14457879960536957,
0.44900551438331604,
0.27982988953590393,
0.6517015099525452,
0.16114698350429535,
0.6910465955734253,
-0.6450314521789551,
0.7825071215629578,
0.3995267450809479,
-1.0089545249938965,
0.5064014792442322,
-0.17234590649604797,
-0.2246306836605072,
0.4035193622112274,
0.2203538566827774,
0.005079947412014008,
-0.35868436098098755,
-0.505163848400116,
-1.0037986040115356,
0.6148086190223694,
-0.3500996232032776,
0.2789528965950012,
0.3512038588523865,
0.3050306737422943,
0.2933841943740845,
-0.12391576170921326,
-0.5360027551651001,
0.03992623835802078,
-0.016016123816370964,
-0.10052440315485,
0.12524686753749847,
-0.38116806745529175,
0.11982163786888123,
-0.16159604489803314,
0.5010368824005127,
-0.21473290026187897,
-0.2283107042312622,
0.054456111043691635,
-0.0010394032578915358,
-0.029294833540916443,
0.08830957114696503,
0.49751314520835876,
0.6214339137077332,
-0.17951543629169464,
0.10997361689805984,
-0.10785914212465286,
-0.7183002829551697,
0.06538593024015427,
0.21153824031352997,
-0.1829896867275238,
-0.06587982177734375,
0.33015385270118713,
0.6172948479652405,
-0.04514196515083313,
-0.6370590925216675,
0.518730640411377,
0.08961611986160278,
-0.4207056164741516,
0.0979626402258873,
-0.15153519809246063,
-0.0843660831451416,
0.3136139512062073,
0.26829081773757935,
0.11214190721511841,
0.20814700424671173,
-0.26466676592826843,
0.5502972602844238,
0.35217076539993286,
-0.5080481767654419,
-0.5649392008781433,
0.7332991361618042,
0.12906035780906677,
0.07253257930278778,
0.038694530725479126,
-0.1652279794216156,
-0.532106876373291,
0.7253112196922302,
0.5438514947891235,
1.015779972076416,
0.005505799315869808,
0.32890841364860535,
0.14276587963104248,
0.2403232753276825,
-0.3272276520729065,
0.2731659412384033,
0.21503353118896484,
-0.6882504224777222,
-0.2661382555961609,
-0.48976173996925354,
-0.4692671597003937,
0.05193881690502167,
-0.21232649683952332,
0.3845173418521881,
-0.9923603534698486,
-0.6135080456733704,
0.2018577754497528,
0.23951011896133423,
-0.452694296836853,
0.10863767564296722,
-0.05011126399040222,
0.7895599007606506,
-0.7833703756332397,
0.7238008975982666,
0.557101309299469,
-0.48988959193229675,
-1.0284281969070435,
0.22441506385803223,
0.12890294194221497,
-0.7917966842651367,
0.7618408203125,
0.35031697154045105,
-0.10973618179559708,
0.020918991416692734,
-0.2704477906227112,
-0.9412872791290283,
0.9785181283950806,
0.6335564255714417,
-0.5321379899978638,
0.1537313610315323,
0.1922706812620163,
0.48986443877220154,
-0.5835333466529846,
0.15707312524318695,
0.5908298492431641,
0.40295344591140747,
0.25228288769721985,
-1.0651694536209106,
0.3308332860469818,
0.05979115143418312,
0.013033455237746239,
-0.14765813946723938,
-0.5244227647781372,
0.9978330731391907,
-0.5069619417190552,
-0.19190798699855804,
0.16015616059303284,
0.7641984224319458,
0.28228604793548584,
0.6728341579437256,
0.6987709999084473,
0.3787243664264679,
0.9125585556030273,
0.14426462352275848,
1.0474249124526978,
-0.45131680369377136,
0.4177619516849518,
1.341726541519165,
-0.6230247616767883,
0.9001807570457458,
0.21503515541553497,
-0.49025845527648926,
0.7139158248901367,
0.792951762676239,
0.07399667799472809,
0.2651365399360657,
0.4102374017238617,
0.001379304681904614,
0.09540872275829315,
-0.5978377461433411,
-0.24112437665462494,
0.20032396912574768,
0.42111140489578247,
-0.6582664251327515,
-0.13733556866645813,
-0.14261844754219055,
-0.018191780894994736,
0.04723253846168518,
-0.350035160779953,
0.3863011598587036,
0.2811075747013092,
-0.40743961930274963,
0.6739115715026855,
-0.1457178145647049,
0.5527704358100891,
-0.65617835521698,
0.1756586879491806,
0.00922977365553379,
0.44670841097831726,
-0.387215793132782,
-0.6674923896789551,
0.05216802656650543,
0.06460100412368774,
-0.3832767903804779,
-0.2449192851781845,
0.7097637057304382,
-0.12186966091394424,
-0.5667302012443542,
0.6095089912414551,
0.11063378304243088,
0.025327982380986214,
-0.23895247280597687,
-0.6165645718574524,
-0.02570497617125511,
-0.02340468391776085,
-0.41437920928001404,
0.4493524432182312,
0.7190923690795898,
-0.2913951277732849,
0.5754780173301697,
0.3933975398540497,
0.5369095802307129,
0.002431002678349614,
0.4365602433681488,
0.8189632892608643,
-0.2138320505619049,
-0.6503971219062805,
-0.8339653611183167,
0.4738268256187439,
-0.00306298746727407,
-0.062485214322805405,
0.6091007590293884,
0.5057414770126343,
0.42944449186325073,
0.10570962727069855,
0.790718674659729,
-0.27560409903526306,
0.35024046897888184,
-0.3987177908420563,
0.9973686933517456,
-0.6334114074707031,
0.3978601396083832,
-0.5941129922866821,
-0.5709056854248047,
-0.7108716368675232,
0.24316361546516418,
-0.5031393766403198,
0.0259915329515934,
0.6607557535171509,
1.0033481121063232,
-0.01993926428258419,
0.0032009948045015335,
0.24123536050319672,
0.5039366483688354,
0.5933189392089844,
0.27606484293937683,
0.7074306011199951,
-0.2397962510585785,
0.5247626304626465,
0.00960408616811037,
-0.6612012982368469,
-0.35679152607917786,
-1.0930922031402588,
-0.6208860874176025,
-0.5541879534721375,
-0.466899573802948,
-0.6543333530426025,
-0.583782434463501,
0.7832285165786743,
0.8642256259918213,
-1.066175937652588,
-0.2376377284526825,
-0.4646604657173157,
0.37642747163772583,
-0.17985233664512634,
-0.22909384965896606,
0.5767961144447327,
-0.4563784897327423,
-0.6158953309059143,
0.14473704993724823,
0.3749425709247589,
0.1115134134888649,
-0.09410493075847626,
-0.0977948009967804,
-0.05922127887606621,
0.2781952917575836,
0.5787026286125183,
0.4691230356693268,
-0.7037510275840759,
-0.14453384280204773,
-0.2992320954799652,
-0.08203310519456863,
0.057032063603401184,
1.1195968389511108,
-0.5003714561462402,
0.6888593435287476,
0.7481664419174194,
0.5261338353157043,
0.3754942715167999,
-0.04612397402524948,
0.6715507507324219,
-0.3170013725757599,
0.04781525209546089,
-0.04812673479318619,
0.46298953890800476,
0.008863784372806549,
-0.3618049919605255,
0.2732374668121338,
0.161324143409729,
-0.4801179766654968,
-0.9093078374862671,
0.1965058296918869,
-0.6827059388160706,
-0.24642165005207062,
0.938239336013794,
-0.6309463977813721,
-0.27542445063591003,
-0.046229034662246704,
-0.275054007768631,
-0.1744757741689682,
-0.24799038469791412,
0.6806445121765137,
0.6948954463005066,
-0.18174347281455994,
0.328207403421402,
-0.1289311945438385,
0.4775780737400055,
0.3396957218647003,
-0.46488311886787415,
0.5379889011383057,
0.40520745515823364,
0.34900450706481934,
0.31221872568130493,
0.9880664348602295,
-0.08823199570178986,
-0.1179538443684578,
0.12332932651042938,
-0.1758352667093277,
-0.003133380087092519,
-0.4523632824420929,
-0.28294163942337036,
0.4624990224838257,
0.6943368911743164,
-0.10850746184587479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14368v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14368v1
|
Graphic Design with Large Multimodal Model
| 2024-04-22T17:20:38 | 2024-04-22T17:20:38 |
Yutao Cheng, Zhao Zhang, Maoke Yang, Hui Nie, Chunyuan Li, Xinglong Wu, Jie Shao
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In the field of graphic design, automating the integration of design elements
into a cohesive multi-layered artwork not only boosts productivity but also
paves the way for the democratization of graphic design. One existing practice
is Graphic Layout Generation (GLG), which aims to layout sequential design
elements. It has been constrained by the necessity for a predefined correct
sequence of layers, thus limiting creative potential and increasing user
workload. In this paper, we present Hierarchical Layout Generation (HLG) as a
more flexible and pragmatic setup, which creates graphic composition from
unordered sets of design elements. To tackle the HLG task, we introduce
Graphist, the first layout generation model based on large multimodal models.
Graphist efficiently reframes the HLG as a sequence generation problem,
utilizing RGB-A images as input, outputs a JSON draft protocol, indicating the
coordinates, size, and order of each element. We develop new evaluation metrics
for HLG. Graphist outperforms prior arts and establishes a strong baseline for
this field. Project homepage: https://github.com/graphic-design-ai/graphist
|
[
-0.5067707300186157,
-0.8390512466430664,
0.5172961354255676,
0.20076030492782593,
-0.338821142911911,
0.3592667281627655,
0.2814024090766907,
-0.5352808237075806,
0.23001925647258759,
0.3926989436149597,
-0.8079026341438293,
-0.6894651055335999,
-0.32498955726623535,
-0.17188811302185059,
0.10144319385290146,
0.7170695066452026,
-0.14035147428512573,
-0.5504065155982971,
0.05957086756825447,
0.007851534523069859,
-0.7013488411903381,
-0.10637195408344269,
-0.5919241905212402,
-0.38871142268180847,
0.8195171356201172,
0.12683789432048798,
1.0762958526611328,
0.7540712952613831,
0.361529141664505,
0.3882927894592285,
0.0650109350681305,
0.45469343662261963,
-0.4966358542442322,
0.13973981142044067,
-0.0032497155480086803,
0.20758147537708282,
-0.6788594722747803,
-0.03498939424753189,
0.46668922901153564,
0.635931670665741,
0.05601157993078232,
0.2544403076171875,
-0.12240961194038391,
0.6772245168685913,
-0.585554301738739,
0.33197498321533203,
-0.0594610720872879,
0.3799248933792114,
-0.06886529922485352,
-0.14738424122333527,
-0.6281558871269226,
-0.3743130564689636,
-0.09601666033267975,
-1.1399550437927246,
-0.08011311292648315,
0.2567770183086395,
0.7120679020881653,
0.19022667407989502,
-0.5032452940940857,
-0.006507702637463808,
-0.6670106649398804,
0.5477731227874756,
-0.5909971594810486,
0.42137181758880615,
-0.31620630621910095,
0.29569023847579956,
-0.08176235854625702,
-0.952215313911438,
-0.43708622455596924,
-0.10313654690980911,
-0.12144030630588531,
0.30322346091270447,
-0.05803424492478371,
0.2212061882019043,
0.25145480036735535,
0.2800910472869873,
-0.902763843536377,
0.07776740938425064,
-0.1386232078075409,
-0.20067821443080902,
0.5965753197669983,
0.3702920377254486,
0.7141344547271729,
-0.36180630326271057,
-0.41166752576828003,
-0.23647962510585785,
-0.46123480796813965,
-0.1103951558470726,
0.7326056361198425,
0.22762145102024078,
-0.08276721835136414,
0.45756199955940247,
0.22404201328754425,
0.6259672045707703,
0.2674398124217987,
-0.2875995635986328,
0.23088699579238892,
-0.5272745490074158,
-0.05983252823352814,
-0.2330058217048645,
0.8979666233062744,
0.3200441002845764,
-0.048823535442352295,
0.07331675291061401,
-0.14062097668647766,
0.10036338120698929,
0.524421751499176,
-0.9290355443954468,
-0.6619003415107727,
0.18297672271728516,
-0.5375450253486633,
-0.22443413734436035,
-0.06758439540863037,
-0.6474254131317139,
-0.440088152885437,
-0.34772273898124695,
0.12818410992622375,
-0.2650589644908905,
-0.337889164686203,
-0.11022316664457321,
-0.22360925376415253,
-0.46102404594421387,
0.5868885517120361,
-0.6210306286811829,
-0.30432015657424927,
0.40022191405296326,
0.799889087677002,
-0.18922626972198486,
-0.24299836158752441,
-0.07850593328475952,
0.43547534942626953,
-0.6550896167755127,
0.5904329419136047,
-0.15440165996551514,
-0.5621576905250549,
-0.02508564665913582,
-0.1901063770055771,
0.15815085172653198,
-0.20830826461315155,
0.2505614161491394,
-0.5481758117675781,
0.19202470779418945,
0.028485529124736786,
-0.08647297322750092,
-0.05910661444067955,
0.31745296716690063,
-0.9183425307273865,
0.7039880156517029,
0.14835844933986664,
-1.1111952066421509,
0.6712364554405212,
-0.6065735816955566,
-0.615362286567688,
0.5628471374511719,
-0.3845767676830292,
-0.5474334359169006,
0.03120281919836998,
0.17540647089481354,
0.13430552184581757,
0.11234945803880692,
0.24542412161827087,
-0.6145164370536804,
-0.18198511004447937,
-0.2699553668498993,
0.04151567444205284,
0.5728830695152283,
0.3761613667011261,
0.04336940869688988,
0.4661577045917511,
-0.7317656874656677,
0.42836883664131165,
0.35415777564048767,
-0.724270224571228,
0.033597223460674286,
0.001372003462165594,
0.4338241219520569,
0.5521278381347656,
0.4049249291419983,
-0.38710305094718933,
0.3285614848136902,
0.038291722536087036,
0.4357689321041107,
0.9297058582305908,
0.01516200602054596,
0.6063936948776245,
-0.42853856086730957,
0.5758785605430603,
-0.20405757427215576,
0.11772634088993073,
-0.535607635974884,
-0.45829036831855774,
-0.20869597792625427,
-0.5478202700614929,
0.07839520275592804,
0.3838692009449005,
-0.9860383868217468,
0.48084741830825806,
-0.17367051541805267,
-0.41087204217910767,
0.19204644858837128,
0.26885560154914856,
0.21959145367145538,
0.01286656316369772,
-0.06521791964769363,
-0.6124960780143738,
-0.44138723611831665,
-0.8849651217460632,
0.3699488639831543,
-0.014564801938831806,
0.22389879822731018,
0.3563685715198517,
0.2586331367492676,
-0.5123415589332581,
0.6045687794685364,
-0.6818345785140991,
-0.12873438000679016,
-0.27622610330581665,
0.6506877541542053,
0.12338312715291977,
0.4361686408519745,
0.6825585961341858,
-0.5379512906074524,
-0.4517284035682678,
0.10391498357057571,
-0.8694758415222168,
0.025904078036546707,
-0.2247278392314911,
-0.4396553337574005,
0.13240958750247955,
0.23553290963172913,
-0.9077938795089722,
0.3487989902496338,
0.5920933485031128,
-0.08193418383598328,
0.654816746711731,
-0.3723464608192444,
-0.127446711063385,
-1.140220284461975,
0.2775067985057831,
0.19723251461982727,
-0.09524039924144745,
-0.46948495507240295,
0.39435479044914246,
-0.16306401789188385,
-0.744857132434845,
-0.04086926579475403,
0.433238685131073,
-0.6790578365325928,
-0.1339929848909378,
-0.3664212226867676,
-0.21379564702510834,
0.37518608570098877,
0.5800986289978027,
-0.062465839087963104,
0.3598158657550812,
0.2501913011074066,
-0.10663178563117981,
0.394001841545105,
0.2249302864074707,
-0.5992328524589539,
0.5343156456947327,
-0.7331514954566956,
0.33541321754455566,
-0.3312380611896515,
0.7924002408981323,
-1.5074678659439087,
-0.5074241757392883,
0.2586928904056549,
0.057249825447797775,
0.38044095039367676,
-0.03886411339044571,
-0.8680620193481445,
-0.7826076149940491,
-0.09921412914991379,
0.7790932059288025,
0.2365451157093048,
-0.4628738462924957,
0.5404466390609741,
0.3206122815608978,
-0.3946295380592346,
-0.40389367938041687,
-0.24893158674240112,
0.08521632850170135,
-0.058930158615112305,
-1.1141328811645508,
0.3165222406387329,
-0.2207341194152832,
0.0034040112514048815,
-0.28065645694732666,
-0.02625396102666855,
0.2713501751422882,
-0.23182731866836548,
0.3689461946487427,
0.3666248321533203,
-0.3016241490840912,
-0.14903077483177185,
-0.03126724436879158,
0.008913631550967693,
-0.1968432068824768,
-0.21008072793483734,
0.826770544052124,
0.29068440198898315,
-0.48686540126800537,
-0.7444133758544922,
0.6163382530212402,
0.8876075744628906,
-0.16346414387226105,
0.05352315679192543,
0.6366367936134338,
-0.19131475687026978,
-0.26977771520614624,
-0.07401488721370697,
0.3329232335090637,
-0.5035388469696045,
0.435350626707077,
-0.31530362367630005,
-0.5194856524467468,
0.353797972202301,
-0.3477880656719208,
0.5350358486175537,
0.23394879698753357,
0.3631468415260315,
-0.10518061369657516,
1.626347541809082,
0.6335433721542358,
0.16327697038650513,
0.7903104424476624,
-0.35542964935302734,
0.22189660370349884,
-0.46198007464408875,
0.04373612254858017,
-0.14526212215423584,
-0.5760579705238342,
-0.5559700131416321,
-0.32899239659309387,
0.5843996405601501,
-0.04065375030040741,
-0.4909049868583679,
0.1670563966035843,
-0.6271104216575623,
0.23846566677093506,
0.37429991364479065,
0.2766045331954956,
0.10134849697351456,
0.1395503729581833,
-0.17088299989700317,
0.11472545564174652,
-0.6725803017616272,
-0.2785662114620209,
0.7039849758148193,
0.33316802978515625,
1.2253063917160034,
0.12418009340763092,
0.8371610641479492,
0.26802924275398254,
0.32732629776000977,
-0.6123852133750916,
0.4878844618797302,
-0.1044110357761383,
-0.4964839220046997,
-0.28831908106803894,
-0.3255887031555176,
-0.8179856538772583,
0.1105106845498085,
-0.41202181577682495,
-0.6066873073577881,
0.14516770839691162,
0.2692760229110718,
-0.24543479084968567,
0.08771257847547531,
-0.6684446334838867,
0.9421179294586182,
-0.38428646326065063,
-0.5236282348632812,
0.0016912193968892097,
-0.43046537041664124,
0.6122075319290161,
-0.06703219562768936,
0.346070796251297,
0.04705457389354706,
0.45855316519737244,
0.33035850524902344,
-0.5040680170059204,
0.8068573474884033,
-0.2450179159641266,
-0.331155389547348,
0.3131891191005707,
0.39221981167793274,
0.5378035306930542,
-0.15313857793807983,
0.2964991629123688,
-0.12493015080690384,
-0.23630499839782715,
-0.2420053482055664,
-0.5369574427604675,
0.5751407742500305,
-0.8820706605911255,
-0.44957560300827026,
0.06247590109705925,
-0.9929147362709045,
0.06154081970453262,
0.43647363781929016,
0.3443140387535095,
0.52359539270401,
-0.34187421202659607,
-0.034244149923324585,
0.2174612283706665,
-0.43278419971466064,
0.2865159809589386,
-0.4504329562187195,
-0.6328206658363342,
-0.6667233109474182,
0.7840874195098877,
0.089961476624012,
0.242562934756279,
0.1595786213874817,
0.26773008704185486,
-0.34638503193855286,
-0.29810312390327454,
-1.0401068925857544,
-0.003665134310722351,
-0.7635665535926819,
0.11516109853982925,
-0.31588828563690186,
-0.3099581301212311,
-0.40993157029151917,
-0.38360595703125,
-0.10405983775854111,
-0.4088354706764221,
-0.01874999888241291,
0.20224042236804962,
-0.34929803013801575,
1.0301910638809204,
0.075424425303936,
0.3350462317466736,
-0.39449548721313477,
0.4668441116809845,
0.4391162097454071,
0.09077733010053635,
0.16677561402320862,
-0.11718674004077911,
-0.09805259108543396,
-0.25069066882133484,
-0.8992696404457092,
-0.5599056482315063,
0.1969337910413742,
-0.1341184824705124,
0.6391686201095581,
0.5228835344314575,
-0.4741343557834625,
0.6936978101730347,
-0.5662815570831299,
0.5125202536582947,
0.7092443108558655,
-0.6115778088569641,
0.3673129975795746,
-0.8938863277435303,
0.672861635684967,
0.07586152106523514,
0.2107987254858017,
-0.4875452220439911,
-0.2221287339925766,
-0.6926547288894653,
-1.0650492906570435,
0.4021613895893097,
-0.14135803282260895,
0.015432336367666721,
0.17464497685432434,
0.08460400998592377,
0.1623212695121765,
0.22800549864768982,
-0.7990120649337769,
0.0396588109433651,
-0.6265462040901184,
-0.10744016617536545,
-0.11482378095388412,
0.026982098817825317,
-0.41506537795066833,
-0.2900119125843048,
0.44236233830451965,
-0.45947185158729553,
0.20737040042877197,
-0.24867479503154755,
0.03661150485277176,
-0.35365551710128784,
0.08331426978111267,
0.6469372510910034,
1.106553316116333,
0.13701912760734558,
0.07817674428224564,
-0.4821082651615143,
0.04830379784107208,
0.2520599365234375,
-0.029750265181064606,
-0.32614830136299133,
-0.15002861618995667,
0.4840461015701294,
0.7145223617553711,
0.06498581916093826,
-0.35844552516937256,
0.39840561151504517,
0.30581873655319214,
-0.2519822418689728,
-0.0727313682436943,
-0.07465259730815887,
0.02516508847475052,
0.16475710272789001,
0.27359771728515625,
-0.052595529705286026,
0.03190666809678078,
-0.736696183681488,
0.3085331320762634,
0.4483717381954193,
0.03209920600056648,
-0.29844722151756287,
1.0026977062225342,
0.20930910110473633,
-0.32279494404792786,
0.5070508122444153,
-0.11463191360235214,
-0.2903667390346527,
0.7509118318557739,
0.7969503998756409,
0.6466954350471497,
0.15390290319919586,
0.5442186594009399,
0.5968802571296692,
0.0691378265619278,
0.09214284271001816,
0.17142413556575775,
0.024092352017760277,
-0.6166293025016785,
-0.5583512187004089,
-0.35578253865242004,
-0.32129979133605957,
-0.08777937293052673,
-0.2366023063659668,
-0.032569415867328644,
-0.9795998334884644,
-0.5092465281486511,
0.2318265587091446,
-0.1378667801618576,
-0.43959176540374756,
0.03838535025715828,
0.5260478854179382,
0.684447169303894,
-0.6113139390945435,
0.31715020537376404,
0.9924501180648804,
-0.35674139857292175,
-0.6383615732192993,
-0.07270951569080353,
0.200903058052063,
-0.7829106450080872,
0.7905993461608887,
0.1285000741481781,
-0.02693096362054348,
-0.11103646457195282,
-0.5136973857879639,
-0.5992944836616516,
1.180324912071228,
0.09864513576030731,
-0.4137424826622009,
-0.26842981576919556,
0.08432353287935257,
0.5283430814743042,
-0.35416311025619507,
-0.043135032057762146,
-0.12791238725185394,
0.5069646835327148,
0.5755152106285095,
-0.5346764326095581,
0.08021081984043121,
-0.5209922790527344,
0.3674052953720093,
0.376171350479126,
-0.8420745730400085,
1.2577896118164062,
-0.30253130197525024,
-0.4516506791114807,
0.3396821618080139,
0.47126686573028564,
0.4899183213710785,
0.15097028017044067,
0.6047291159629822,
0.7912083268165588,
0.670565664768219,
-0.06484424322843552,
0.93673175573349,
-0.4045563042163849,
0.16788141429424286,
0.9676312804222107,
-0.1962129920721054,
0.1158844530582428,
0.08803287893533707,
0.21991048753261566,
0.6809447407722473,
0.7522290945053101,
0.1224629208445549,
0.5124228596687317,
0.22176136076450348,
-0.0325733907520771,
-0.400109201669693,
-0.07126393914222717,
-0.2718662619590759,
0.27916115522384644,
0.0195385180413723,
-0.3427300453186035,
-0.4442812204360962,
-0.24398471415042877,
-0.025853319093585014,
-0.12193357199430466,
-0.17951691150665283,
0.6314858794212341,
-0.2059827595949173,
-0.4335067868232727,
0.380249559879303,
-0.012873000465333462,
0.2256482094526291,
-0.509913980960846,
-0.10844315588474274,
-0.10839226841926575,
0.18507419526576996,
-0.18659056723117828,
-0.9356510043144226,
-0.10060257464647293,
-0.6592772603034973,
-0.02029433660209179,
-0.4494328796863556,
0.65774005651474,
-0.05405433848500252,
-0.5331534743309021,
0.07425196468830109,
0.6528346538543701,
-0.3995511829853058,
0.17288562655448914,
-0.82570481300354,
0.2538558542728424,
-0.47121793031692505,
-0.04697611927986145,
0.1666852831840515,
0.5495035648345947,
-0.23405160009860992,
0.4838010370731354,
0.656944751739502,
-0.16477854549884796,
0.04504343122243881,
0.24436688423156738,
0.6554791331291199,
-0.3217748701572418,
-0.7626141309738159,
-0.5063775777816772,
0.5085516571998596,
-0.13856610655784607,
-0.2805229723453522,
0.6131671071052551,
0.7600756287574768,
0.709169328212738,
-0.14110557734966278,
1.0311388969421387,
-0.05643831565976143,
-0.3175625205039978,
-0.1881585270166397,
0.6312635540962219,
-0.5879250764846802,
-0.47134295105934143,
-0.7531663179397583,
-0.8949947357177734,
-0.3647502660751343,
0.5157301425933838,
-0.22379329800605774,
0.11899156123399734,
0.5099478960037231,
0.5619902610778809,
-0.272620290517807,
0.08255045115947723,
0.19810675084590912,
-0.21192753314971924,
0.5019397735595703,
0.4932228624820709,
1.242877721786499,
-0.03744548186659813,
0.2494255155324936,
-0.26463159918785095,
-0.2760292589664459,
-0.007999400608241558,
-0.7597634792327881,
-0.9126754403114319,
-0.39405545592308044,
-0.14006158709526062,
-0.2626703977584839,
-0.3784405291080475,
0.6408457159996033,
1.0240437984466553,
-0.2088620960712433,
-0.32845672965049744,
0.09050735831260681,
0.08719617873430252,
-0.2489938884973526,
-0.21455225348472595,
0.14633379876613617,
0.13346286118030548,
-0.50655198097229,
0.16576851904392242,
0.4472503066062927,
0.037770405411720276,
-0.41912856698036194,
-0.11648452281951904,
0.04396964982151985,
-0.08440458029508591,
0.9431890845298767,
0.3330364227294922,
-0.49027955532073975,
-0.6107028126716614,
-0.5096619725227356,
-0.26900508999824524,
0.4027414321899414,
1.0418803691864014,
-0.2397727072238922,
0.3851547837257385,
0.7974777221679688,
0.42630118131637573,
0.3343665897846222,
0.36268797516822815,
0.3689691424369812,
-0.8315185904502869,
0.09777317941188812,
-0.3371167480945587,
0.48756861686706543,
0.08274378627538681,
-0.2237241119146347,
0.3517143428325653,
0.3133220076560974,
-0.5199256539344788,
-0.5142362713813782,
0.6832428574562073,
-1.0348889827728271,
-0.36735427379608154,
0.6717271208763123,
0.1787213385105133,
-0.07403002679347992,
0.09818287938833237,
-0.5245773792266846,
0.08942649513483047,
-0.2042965590953827,
0.909694254398346,
0.7102080583572388,
-0.34520354866981506,
-0.21634794771671295,
-0.2955790162086487,
-0.043868012726306915,
-0.22849272191524506,
-1.040605068206787,
-0.10597014427185059,
1.1484334468841553,
0.08253432810306549,
0.7318179607391357,
0.7654369473457336,
0.04646983742713928,
0.3390677869319916,
0.25924649834632874,
0.3241886496543884,
-0.20500779151916504,
-0.6647580862045288,
0.33516931533813477,
0.6094940304756165,
0.11161024123430252,
0.05380537360906601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14361v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14361v3
|
Better Synthetic Data by Retrieving and Transforming Existing Datasets
| 2024-04-22T17:15:32 | 2024-04-26T19:02:23 |
Saumya Gandhi, Ritu Gala, Vijay Viswanathan, Tongshuang Wu, Graham Neubig
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite recent advances in large language models, building dependable and
deployable NLP models typically requires abundant, high-quality training data.
However, task-specific data is not available for many use cases, and manually
curating task-specific data is labor-intensive. Recent work has studied
prompt-driven synthetic data generation using large language models, but these
generated datasets tend to lack complexity and diversity. To address these
limitations, we introduce a method, DataTune, to make better use of existing,
publicly available datasets to improve automatic dataset generation. DataTune
performs dataset transformation, enabling the repurposing of publicly available
datasets into a format that is directly aligned with the specific requirements
of target tasks. On a diverse set of language-based tasks from the BIG-Bench
benchmark, we find that finetuning language models via DataTune improves over a
few-shot prompting baseline by 49% and improves over existing methods that use
synthetic or retrieved training data by 34%. We find that dataset
transformation significantly increases the diversity and difficulty of
generated data on many tasks. We integrate DataTune into an open-source
repository to make this method accessible to the community:
https://github.com/neulab/prompt2model.
|
[
-0.2156221717596054,
-0.6532053351402283,
0.3004673421382904,
0.3656226694583893,
-0.010274985805153847,
-0.15174119174480438,
-0.5594822764396667,
-0.20342189073562622,
-0.046336643397808075,
0.3965849280357361,
-0.6071768403053284,
-0.4410354197025299,
-0.21991804242134094,
0.3332067131996155,
-0.6160807609558105,
1.1007505655288696,
0.1419723629951477,
0.03401879966259003,
-0.14861369132995605,
0.10974724590778351,
-0.6785497069358826,
-0.33488067984580994,
-0.6910062432289124,
-0.2032601535320282,
0.5379115343093872,
0.564815104007721,
0.6795068383216858,
0.845204770565033,
0.2519957721233368,
0.2450687736272812,
0.06995052844285965,
0.3048388361930847,
-0.6301575899124146,
0.33214038610458374,
-0.2640047073364258,
-0.495993971824646,
-0.12183889746665955,
0.02739391103386879,
0.6050011515617371,
0.9297878742218018,
-0.22212520241737366,
0.2122119963169098,
0.23867790400981903,
0.6681661009788513,
-0.18384060263633728,
0.3239319920539856,
-0.735256552696228,
-0.10208375006914139,
-0.33670511841773987,
0.019555578008294106,
-0.35386598110198975,
-0.5277243256568909,
0.07955653220415115,
-0.8296641111373901,
0.612633228302002,
0.011749808676540852,
0.4109886586666107,
0.39432814717292786,
-0.13698162138462067,
0.02336898446083069,
-0.8343624472618103,
1.0366616249084473,
-0.6043919324874878,
0.4927147924900055,
0.28104767203330994,
0.6217284798622131,
-0.3472154140472412,
-0.8053610920906067,
-0.7121918797492981,
-0.14899182319641113,
-0.07406217604875565,
-0.05410609766840935,
-0.30255264043807983,
-0.22613167762756348,
0.6167483925819397,
0.43027064204216003,
-0.7141920924186707,
0.07068389654159546,
-0.46126872301101685,
-0.06164442375302315,
0.8076240420341492,
0.23416578769683838,
0.3346341848373413,
-0.40419673919677734,
0.10078438371419907,
-0.33821582794189453,
-0.6234830021858215,
-0.10581520944833755,
0.43407928943634033,
0.8439108729362488,
0.16402442753314972,
0.6016517877578735,
-0.5306956171989441,
0.8705395460128784,
0.033893339335918427,
0.3134003281593323,
0.4078376591205597,
-0.5991626977920532,
-0.1612938493490219,
-0.0043310984037816525,
0.4168407917022705,
0.4464167058467865,
0.23205885291099548,
-0.23779694736003876,
-0.28201383352279663,
0.07204613834619522,
0.24930645525455475,
-0.6715815663337708,
-0.486563503742218,
0.5351114273071289,
-0.14243562519550323,
-0.2921693027019501,
-0.12351179122924805,
-0.7844273447990417,
-0.5209200382232666,
-1.0348966121673584,
0.0074064661748707294,
-0.3904266953468323,
-0.28394103050231934,
0.11392049491405487,
-0.08910210430622101,
0.031274888664484024,
0.3385299742221832,
-0.7520279288291931,
0.2991601526737213,
0.6699627041816711,
0.8276875019073486,
-0.4757285416126251,
-0.16885752975940704,
-0.8262936472892761,
-0.07996176183223724,
-0.47022202610969543,
0.6252073049545288,
-0.3250811696052551,
-0.10627447068691254,
-0.015621647238731384,
0.25126174092292786,
0.12301262468099594,
-0.8210658431053162,
0.5070144534111023,
-0.19425112009048462,
0.3878882825374603,
-0.31769225001335144,
-0.5017543435096741,
0.10355107486248016,
0.15836046636104584,
-1.0026675462722778,
1.238006591796875,
0.32508689165115356,
-0.42054224014282227,
0.42667195200920105,
-0.8505671620368958,
-0.4122420847415924,
0.12204886972904205,
-0.04841627925634384,
-0.18978852033615112,
0.04434054344892502,
0.4965805113315582,
0.4079224765300751,
-0.538362443447113,
0.688014030456543,
-0.036589138209819794,
-0.15614819526672363,
0.1035909354686737,
-0.33707284927368164,
0.773914098739624,
0.22421549260616302,
-0.09603946655988693,
0.013311287388205528,
-0.9139533042907715,
0.08657050877809525,
0.030677227303385735,
-0.32313573360443115,
-0.18219992518424988,
-0.23069608211517334,
0.34808269143104553,
0.2487432211637497,
-0.027378221973776817,
-0.6579477190971375,
0.3423570990562439,
-0.6835479736328125,
0.3565222918987274,
0.5430736541748047,
-0.019832691177725792,
0.5531060695648193,
-0.5056679844856262,
0.5074716210365295,
-0.05614389479160309,
0.04347337409853935,
0.0379117950797081,
-0.301857054233551,
-0.5986834168434143,
-0.1493924856185913,
0.44064250588417053,
0.5916908383369446,
-0.9671079516410828,
0.4360293745994568,
-0.4533804953098297,
-0.5052895545959473,
-0.6509785056114197,
0.3651573359966278,
-0.00514474930241704,
0.7146682143211365,
0.6320708394050598,
0.12521928548812866,
-0.8990715146064758,
-0.8659859895706177,
-0.2009608894586563,
0.13558141887187958,
-0.374777615070343,
0.14971701800823212,
0.10335961729288101,
-0.18775254487991333,
1.1886595487594604,
-0.37051644921302795,
-0.13752961158752441,
-0.4197349548339844,
0.21088163554668427,
0.5961779356002808,
0.7409620881080627,
0.3386188745498657,
-0.7063648700714111,
-0.4050922095775604,
-0.16347432136535645,
-0.5284621715545654,
-0.35279643535614014,
-0.4246629476547241,
-0.24276673793792725,
0.1030537337064743,
0.4474921226501465,
-0.6059885621070862,
0.11201468110084534,
0.497763067483902,
0.004877178929746151,
0.5075767040252686,
0.2607993483543396,
-0.05415879935026169,
-1.2907787561416626,
0.3439037501811981,
-0.13178309798240662,
-0.26570090651512146,
-0.7427352666854858,
-0.29298079013824463,
-0.1135389432311058,
-0.48796311020851135,
-0.3597678542137146,
0.693058967590332,
-0.1530662477016449,
-0.07839260995388031,
-0.12130829691886902,
-0.10987558215856552,
-0.0029230015352368355,
0.2996821701526642,
0.03224829211831093,
0.8407711386680603,
0.6218392252922058,
-0.690223753452301,
0.7284204363822937,
0.7009626626968384,
-0.33560702204704285,
0.4618673622608185,
-0.8294093012809753,
0.11544524878263474,
-0.16157199442386627,
0.2897011935710907,
-0.8376555442810059,
-0.6329664587974548,
0.23097673058509827,
-0.244522362947464,
0.18754060566425323,
-0.3712860345840454,
-0.6203962564468384,
-0.31306758522987366,
-0.10997819900512695,
0.28605061769485474,
0.5691965222358704,
-0.8539049029350281,
0.3100340962409973,
0.07557127624750137,
-0.5023922920227051,
-0.29065239429473877,
-0.7572526931762695,
0.2634414732456207,
-0.2120484858751297,
-0.528051495552063,
0.5088387727737427,
0.02626519463956356,
-0.22717159986495972,
-0.17438609898090363,
-0.12102342396974564,
-0.07345961779356003,
-0.25297680497169495,
-0.04721009358763695,
0.22679834067821503,
0.009597819298505783,
0.6150350570678711,
0.0764053463935852,
-0.29667073488235474,
-0.023620693013072014,
-0.49507468938827515,
0.4567740261554718,
0.3078162670135498,
-0.047824520617723465,
-0.4457135796546936,
0.4473535120487213,
0.32574379444122314,
-0.2392302304506302,
0.4522693455219269,
0.5555129051208496,
-0.4304831624031067,
-0.616269052028656,
-0.3041991889476776,
-0.49119672179222107,
-0.47253182530403137,
0.23947682976722717,
-0.12370029091835022,
-0.43501386046409607,
0.15556789934635162,
-0.16231247782707214,
0.44584956765174866,
0.20083321630954742,
0.3516392707824707,
-0.0766904428601265,
0.9597657322883606,
0.2902919352054596,
0.036972418427467346,
0.5441486835479736,
-0.28234440088272095,
0.05030442401766777,
-0.46905550360679626,
-0.019911067560315132,
-0.41934800148010254,
-0.4555448293685913,
-0.42103877663612366,
-0.48193347454071045,
0.2525147795677185,
-0.20627067983150482,
-0.13493895530700684,
0.5364072918891907,
-0.6139522790908813,
0.44329163432121277,
0.6676347255706787,
0.35109981894493103,
0.2224365919828415,
0.31127044558525085,
0.2947559952735901,
-0.16521212458610535,
-0.8957406282424927,
-0.43913158774375916,
1.379769206047058,
0.07585668563842773,
0.6337353587150574,
-0.04080350324511528,
0.681689977645874,
0.19380499422550201,
0.07792513072490692,
-0.8165885210037231,
0.4796440601348877,
-0.3782607913017273,
-0.48205751180648804,
-0.4438285827636719,
-0.6655948162078857,
-1.0122126340866089,
-0.46162086725234985,
-0.2984958589076996,
-0.31780433654785156,
0.3058062195777893,
0.3790724575519562,
-0.34106722474098206,
-0.10874507576227188,
-0.6150516271591187,
0.7057154774665833,
0.06268985569477081,
-0.3242497742176056,
0.15238802134990692,
-0.43909960985183716,
0.17438693344593048,
-0.3356529176235199,
-0.04005174711346626,
-0.09813317656517029,
0.26417383551597595,
0.7425476908683777,
-0.663981556892395,
0.8117194175720215,
-0.37498658895492554,
-0.2929683029651642,
0.27805599570274353,
0.10565795004367828,
0.7733997702598572,
0.19756779074668884,
-0.41130539774894714,
-0.05783984437584877,
-0.3748026192188263,
-0.4824153482913971,
-0.9504311680793762,
0.6533613801002502,
-0.47465112805366516,
-0.36003872752189636,
0.06036759167909622,
-0.847855269908905,
-0.3970016837120056,
-0.04923184588551521,
0.30777621269226074,
0.7341066002845764,
-0.0037240288220345974,
0.3318909704685211,
0.5219514966011047,
-0.19702506065368652,
0.25881174206733704,
0.16704970598220825,
-0.06062937527894974,
-0.37457433342933655,
0.8478390574455261,
0.09535285085439682,
0.14918841421604156,
0.1065376028418541,
0.05712627246975899,
-0.5336483716964722,
-0.34847432374954224,
-0.3783792555332184,
-0.13292479515075684,
-0.49373772740364075,
-0.3663416802883148,
-0.48033833503723145,
0.0015999453607946634,
-0.47612228989601135,
-0.03189096599817276,
-0.5276023149490356,
-0.8565977811813354,
-0.13471172749996185,
-0.20470452308654785,
0.7439325451850891,
0.3263615369796753,
-0.33259302377700806,
0.34294629096984863,
-0.6519002914428711,
0.4922609031200409,
0.4882020652294159,
0.30533936619758606,
-0.44129088521003723,
-0.39986756443977356,
-0.0978342741727829,
0.3126065135002136,
0.13143181800842285,
-0.6277852058410645,
0.36508050560951233,
0.3474738597869873,
0.42766284942626953,
-0.28540369868278503,
0.24758589267730713,
0.5116503238677979,
-0.4112446904182434,
0.6586090922355652,
0.037733256816864014,
-0.8012571930885315,
0.8002469539642334,
-0.4726078510284424,
0.45687735080718994,
0.6805221438407898,
0.3586398959159851,
-0.6389546990394592,
-0.1702379733324051,
-0.4547930955886841,
-0.8582633137702942,
0.7639477252960205,
0.5633087754249573,
0.238433375954628,
0.15486440062522888,
0.31735172867774963,
0.503860592842102,
0.1621430218219757,
-0.38743510842323303,
-0.007975931279361248,
-0.4412574768066406,
-0.5628366470336914,
-0.08362513035535812,
0.28387293219566345,
-0.15149982273578644,
-0.3958258628845215,
0.7083553075790405,
-0.25121739506721497,
0.21694040298461914,
0.10480236262083054,
-0.15532514452934265,
0.07924330234527588,
0.2093895524740219,
-0.04270351305603981,
0.47469186782836914,
0.05629424750804901,
-0.008067473769187927,
0.16623982787132263,
-0.3701779544353485,
0.24813924729824066,
0.44031235575675964,
-0.31995630264282227,
0.3389187455177307,
0.14105287194252014,
0.7251539826393127,
0.06149173527956009,
-0.630294144153595,
0.20006157457828522,
0.03828227147459984,
-0.13443289697170258,
-0.04268056899309158,
0.34912481904029846,
-0.20620934665203094,
0.17781728506088257,
0.2884312570095062,
0.03891483694314957,
0.17534220218658447,
-0.24886532127857208,
0.5945782661437988,
-0.19231438636779785,
0.011757326312363148,
-0.17813895642757416,
0.5275977849960327,
0.21505291759967804,
-0.11869862675666809,
1.0697027444839478,
-0.1545642763376236,
-0.034358758479356766,
0.531116783618927,
0.510594367980957,
0.673625648021698,
-0.27542638778686523,
0.5042122006416321,
0.7650561928749084,
-0.02585512213408947,
-0.29189255833625793,
0.6268557906150818,
0.10468922555446625,
-0.6393093466758728,
-0.6530001163482666,
-0.4283144772052765,
-0.25199657678604126,
0.32967081665992737,
-0.5981860160827637,
0.5874519944190979,
-0.4110148251056671,
-0.19534367322921753,
0.13448365032672882,
-0.1814456284046173,
-0.8761588931083679,
0.272095650434494,
-0.027214815840125084,
0.8371220827102661,
-0.8650340437889099,
0.5685874819755554,
0.5513622164726257,
-0.3156789541244507,
-0.7338216304779053,
-0.16067372262477875,
-0.10386837273836136,
-0.5016734600067139,
0.5906118750572205,
0.24986934661865234,
0.48841962218284607,
0.3833566904067993,
-0.7656232118606567,
-0.7201083898544312,
0.8709766864776611,
0.6514050960540771,
-0.792621910572052,
-0.08706219494342804,
0.4882919192314148,
0.37737247347831726,
-0.20659418404102325,
-0.14097771048545837,
0.6362574100494385,
0.5832235217094421,
-0.08916277438402176,
-0.7902474403381348,
0.21653036773204803,
-0.38718414306640625,
0.12541618943214417,
0.04837699607014656,
0.030565619468688965,
0.6547178030014038,
0.06595023721456528,
-0.34353482723236084,
-0.04308035597205162,
0.38060498237609863,
0.3359494209289551,
0.04373756796121597,
0.5721948742866516,
0.3835294544696808,
1.0274938344955444,
-0.22794289886951447,
0.740768313407898,
-0.0871279388666153,
0.1535733938217163,
1.370969295501709,
-0.20520883798599243,
0.5660429000854492,
0.42566531896591187,
-0.0581243596971035,
0.2998458445072174,
0.4527568817138672,
-0.4193357527256012,
0.3523867726325989,
0.37915974855422974,
-0.08641895651817322,
-0.376027375459671,
-0.3680312931537628,
-0.25359484553337097,
0.4948875904083252,
0.18462340533733368,
-0.3322008550167084,
-0.531745433807373,
0.312225878238678,
-0.17905916273593903,
0.18316999077796936,
-0.04665013402700424,
0.7773227691650391,
-0.16926811635494232,
-0.6590174436569214,
0.8019369840621948,
-0.27619993686676025,
0.30559930205345154,
-0.45272502303123474,
-0.2738886773586273,
-0.350483775138855,
-0.11881522834300995,
-0.36684298515319824,
-0.762270987033844,
0.5513332486152649,
0.2449231594800949,
-0.27247825264930725,
-0.5072447657585144,
0.6407471299171448,
-0.7373462319374084,
-0.5337358713150024,
-0.21872328221797943,
0.6241097450256348,
0.18702095746994019,
-0.2602236270904541,
-0.6518867611885071,
-0.09460083395242691,
-0.03125252202153206,
-0.19949482381343842,
-0.11537934839725494,
0.3275332748889923,
-0.00363090424798429,
0.5033100843429565,
1.031835675239563,
0.07032483071088791,
-0.022458292543888092,
0.1516229808330536,
0.8842422366142273,
-0.557942271232605,
-0.4729652404785156,
-0.4885268211364746,
0.6006662249565125,
-0.38867470622062683,
-0.3176811933517456,
0.49384090304374695,
0.7048805952072144,
0.7239117622375488,
-0.22991982102394104,
0.9780641794204712,
-0.1558028608560562,
0.8357012867927551,
-0.6857879757881165,
0.5325270891189575,
-0.30144262313842773,
0.1834910362958908,
-0.03133660927414894,
-1.1793144941329956,
-0.33212360739707947,
0.4336349666118622,
-0.2108050137758255,
-0.12697722017765045,
0.3757783770561218,
1.0881762504577637,
-0.32252728939056396,
0.15848387777805328,
-0.024835890159010887,
0.10933103412389755,
0.39340031147003174,
0.40130865573883057,
0.7279390692710876,
-0.4040168523788452,
0.5965945720672607,
-0.3398970067501068,
-0.13870088756084442,
0.08982250839471817,
-0.860897958278656,
-0.6830911040306091,
-0.699921190738678,
-0.6431264877319336,
-0.2363307923078537,
0.05012767016887665,
1.2030925750732422,
0.9305481910705566,
-0.9479457139968872,
-0.05422481149435043,
-0.6993032693862915,
-0.24970857799053192,
-0.3106258809566498,
-0.2831920087337494,
0.1635136753320694,
-0.6924481391906738,
-0.9296096563339233,
0.7633447051048279,
-0.3427446782588959,
0.1931726336479187,
-0.062033429741859436,
0.15210789442062378,
0.18644413352012634,
-0.17091576755046844,
0.4548390805721283,
0.30536776781082153,
-0.2999822199344635,
0.024381794035434723,
0.14522193372249603,
0.03837244212627411,
-0.014524565078318119,
0.7554923295974731,
-0.9200807809829712,
0.4896490275859833,
0.6068609356880188,
0.914006233215332,
0.24816957116127014,
0.03811091184616089,
1.121423363685608,
-1.2121703624725342,
0.07194752246141434,
0.30830052495002747,
0.14453962445259094,
0.6083170175552368,
-0.5017408728599548,
0.7639176249504089,
0.14417031407356262,
-0.225581094622612,
-0.7681719064712524,
0.31184136867523193,
-0.8391135334968567,
-0.13666604459285736,
1.3218525648117065,
0.17536096274852753,
-0.04561088606715202,
-0.2474219799041748,
-0.39676633477211,
0.3866170644760132,
-0.5210610628128052,
0.7743681073188782,
0.4252573549747467,
0.05362677946686745,
0.05935804545879364,
-0.6870629191398621,
0.8899253010749817,
0.3610183298587799,
-1.0395764112472534,
0.5709689259529114,
0.6472711563110352,
0.1173311099410057,
-0.024729378521442413,
0.10427786409854889,
0.011899636127054691,
0.3206328749656677,
-0.1597348004579544,
0.027374936267733574,
-0.2405695766210556,
-0.40649333596229553,
-0.3807326853275299,
-0.12905265390872955,
-0.414661169052124,
-0.09109852463006973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14355v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14355v3
|
Pre-Calc: Learning to Use the Calculator Improves Numeracy in Language Models
| 2024-04-22T17:07:25 | 2024-06-26T03:52:24 |
Vishruth Veerendranath, Vishwa Shah, Kshitish Ghate
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Quantitative and numerical comprehension in language is an important task in
many fields like education and finance, but still remains a challenging task
for language models. While tool and calculator usage has shown to be helpful to
improve mathematical reasoning in large pretrained decoder-only language
models, this remains unexplored for smaller language models with encoders. In
this paper, we propose Pre-Calc, a simple pre-finetuning objective of learning
to use the calculator for both encoder-only and encoder-decoder architectures,
formulated as a discriminative and generative task respectively. We pre-train
BERT and RoBERTa for discriminative calculator use and Flan-T5 for generative
calculator use on the MAWPS, SVAMP, and AsDiv-A datasets, which improves
performance on downstream tasks that require numerical understanding. Our code
and data are available at https://github.com/calc-cmu/pre-calc.
|
[
-0.5751380324363708,
-0.5131604671478271,
0.3766283094882965,
0.21864546835422516,
-0.29212260246276855,
-0.07334093004465103,
-0.24728882312774658,
0.3081001937389374,
-0.22067363560199738,
0.5086049437522888,
-0.34587162733078003,
-0.5559886693954468,
-0.42991241812705994,
0.09443265944719315,
-0.05360042303800583,
0.9395222067832947,
-0.02213354967534542,
0.41938483715057373,
-0.7105912566184998,
0.29813191294670105,
-0.1785491704940796,
-0.6672957539558411,
-0.4630378186702728,
-0.3714756369590759,
0.38442355394363403,
0.326633483171463,
0.6429498195648193,
0.09173190593719482,
0.5269662141799927,
0.2643078863620758,
0.5447835326194763,
0.052630405873060226,
-0.543693482875824,
-0.18718506395816803,
0.13619138300418854,
-0.8248196840286255,
-0.34432196617126465,
-0.16867098212242126,
0.25647348165512085,
0.8497604131698608,
-0.19898658990859985,
0.17640317976474762,
0.13536067306995392,
0.6640943884849548,
-1.1846171617507935,
0.6485252976417542,
-0.1619098037481308,
-0.00921480730175972,
-0.20377422869205475,
-0.531470537185669,
-0.6660180687904358,
-0.8234866857528687,
-0.12489967048168182,
-0.7459602952003479,
0.24553340673446655,
-0.6108957529067993,
0.5274268388748169,
0.5277556777000427,
-0.5033329725265503,
-0.2535439729690552,
-0.7698999643325806,
0.7623111009597778,
-0.49659356474876404,
0.6913759112358093,
0.8324366807937622,
0.14698557555675507,
0.09957773983478546,
-0.5780312418937683,
-0.28700900077819824,
-0.16140422224998474,
0.05765683948993683,
0.25241661071777344,
-0.13190042972564697,
0.2523088753223419,
0.5184728503227234,
0.2294326275587082,
-0.4772608280181885,
-0.06175984442234039,
-0.5364925861358643,
-0.127646341919899,
0.31294211745262146,
-0.0635734498500824,
-0.014120329171419144,
0.16863766312599182,
0.06613633781671524,
-0.437511146068573,
-0.956716775894165,
-0.04693117365241051,
0.08806613087654114,
-0.07910920679569244,
-0.12369906157255173,
0.41841036081314087,
0.39300569891929626,
0.7143330574035645,
-0.13406801223754883,
0.10954830050468445,
0.39403781294822693,
-0.2505287528038025,
-0.18847395479679108,
0.008777068927884102,
0.538286030292511,
-0.28690412640571594,
0.7625901103019714,
0.16234350204467773,
-0.31074732542037964,
0.31777405738830566,
0.3687359690666199,
-1.0809364318847656,
-0.7022780179977417,
-0.31744471192359924,
-0.06629937887191772,
-0.20724208652973175,
0.018337585031986237,
-0.30504894256591797,
0.1378275603055954,
-0.48849233984947205,
0.6769037246704102,
-0.3294963240623474,
-0.14354456961154938,
0.31923672556877136,
0.03962886333465576,
0.2711006700992584,
0.32693955302238464,
-0.8081558346748352,
0.5183773636817932,
0.6244388818740845,
0.37694013118743896,
0.6089093685150146,
-0.04294706508517265,
-0.6514757871627808,
-0.28911182284355164,
-0.5894965529441833,
0.5527417063713074,
-0.4808245003223419,
-0.619189977645874,
-0.10705847293138504,
-0.4035950303077698,
-0.19430895149707794,
-0.4049854278564453,
0.2922171354293823,
-0.7755275964736938,
0.042986348271369934,
-0.3506637513637543,
-0.4200700521469116,
-0.3679473400115967,
-0.07292097806930542,
-0.905927836894989,
0.6380941271781921,
0.13779370486736298,
-0.5314332246780396,
0.21544432640075684,
-0.9110741019248962,
-0.6899949908256531,
0.19925443828105927,
-0.28717494010925293,
-0.3133412301540375,
0.44860735535621643,
0.43892547488212585,
0.1763114631175995,
-0.48037293553352356,
0.11592813581228256,
-0.18818843364715576,
-0.4393366873264313,
0.20977216958999634,
-0.7657051086425781,
0.6429818868637085,
0.31728288531303406,
-0.00038211155333556235,
0.10236425697803497,
-0.3461686074733734,
0.20331622660160065,
0.03878336027264595,
-0.10551822185516357,
-0.2582813501358032,
-0.1852731704711914,
-0.42651236057281494,
-0.011502239853143692,
0.41079047322273254,
-0.24653860926628113,
-0.34384986758232117,
-0.6448918581008911,
0.19756081700325012,
0.4893134832382202,
-0.2686581313610077,
0.5593515634536743,
-0.1735876351594925,
0.9360790252685547,
0.012933451682329178,
-0.14459389448165894,
-0.40395089983940125,
-0.03900263458490372,
-0.6438948512077332,
-0.08240418136119843,
0.6337701082229614,
0.6814929246902466,
-1.1038235425949097,
0.3650375306606293,
-0.22342877089977264,
-0.367848664522171,
-0.49513858556747437,
0.2348039150238037,
0.7500305771827698,
0.3042973577976227,
0.19655261933803558,
-0.3844589591026306,
-0.3619392216205597,
-0.42232006788253784,
-0.02518223598599434,
0.13391606509685516,
-0.3383030593395233,
0.25700291991233826,
0.33471864461898804,
0.029866520315408707,
0.8231292366981506,
-0.8132436275482178,
-0.20827209949493408,
-0.17303508520126343,
0.29372158646583557,
0.10964180529117584,
0.42261597514152527,
0.5128111839294434,
-0.8864730000495911,
-0.37938573956489563,
-0.15078949928283691,
-0.6425561308860779,
-0.2279425710439682,
0.22050727903842926,
-0.073551706969738,
-0.0933704525232315,
0.3640669286251068,
-0.48237115144729614,
0.7797063589096069,
0.426234632730484,
0.05998696759343147,
0.6767634153366089,
-0.7267653942108154,
0.27963465452194214,
-0.7076698541641235,
-0.06627891957759857,
0.07380843162536621,
-0.2059403657913208,
-0.5513907670974731,
-0.05032019317150116,
0.43127015233039856,
-0.40266868472099304,
-0.4284919798374176,
0.13190476596355438,
-0.2485482096672058,
-0.07888244837522507,
-0.028448650613427162,
-0.139773428440094,
0.20167121291160583,
0.2838122844696045,
0.10067130625247955,
1.2348811626434326,
0.4246668219566345,
-0.6884073615074158,
0.028720149770379066,
0.12314383685588837,
-0.33544817566871643,
0.03428759425878525,
-0.6311531662940979,
0.33992716670036316,
-0.317754328250885,
0.18763287365436554,
-0.5872423052787781,
0.18876393139362335,
-0.2436346560716629,
-0.5563511848449707,
0.1184200868010521,
0.1119612455368042,
-0.49651843309402466,
-0.5226953029632568,
-0.27672550082206726,
0.9933894872665405,
0.5175753831863403,
-0.5892015099525452,
0.8420560956001282,
0.26527827978134155,
-0.014055795036256313,
-0.4391935467720032,
-0.5404367446899414,
-0.5323069095611572,
0.10844692587852478,
-0.5278501510620117,
0.20097365975379944,
-0.16207006573677063,
-0.13478024303913116,
-0.19923874735832214,
-0.04132029414176941,
-0.36750414967536926,
0.07969625294208527,
0.11845626682043076,
0.4062509834766388,
-0.5715524554252625,
0.2893233895301819,
0.04469989985227585,
-0.40843847393989563,
0.34196555614471436,
-0.0736704096198082,
0.8908066153526306,
-0.3278837203979492,
-0.4092981815338135,
-0.29747745394706726,
0.05761506408452988,
0.3419325649738312,
-0.9383092522621155,
0.5588252544403076,
0.3988443613052368,
-0.5079926252365112,
-0.01570483297109604,
-0.5863810181617737,
-0.4347330629825592,
-0.5140377879142761,
0.4297367334365845,
-0.877891480922699,
-0.5480164289474487,
0.3913840055465698,
-0.13944993913173676,
0.010258813388645649,
0.34529221057891846,
0.41484588384628296,
0.24847082793712616,
1.2095285654067993,
0.4604955315589905,
0.20838689804077148,
0.4712894558906555,
-0.4666023850440979,
0.3633142113685608,
-0.5127655267715454,
-0.022641900926828384,
-0.5630009770393372,
0.1112692728638649,
-0.06510796397924423,
-0.542296290397644,
0.27151110768318176,
0.2501835823059082,
-0.39364996552467346,
0.3259967267513275,
-0.1036120131611824,
0.8754534721374512,
0.48568791151046753,
0.20399178564548492,
-0.12379874289035797,
-0.14495430886745453,
-0.28588688373565674,
-0.2601861357688904,
-0.5218476057052612,
-0.4104633927345276,
1.2811280488967896,
0.08759303390979767,
0.9873732328414917,
-0.10982891172170639,
1.0094289779663086,
-0.042109981179237366,
0.4846533536911011,
-0.7903038859367371,
0.4335290491580963,
-0.7596553564071655,
-0.1749197542667389,
-0.053663138300180435,
-0.7912064790725708,
-0.7953295707702637,
0.24792955815792084,
0.04835429787635803,
-0.256866991519928,
0.18949972093105316,
0.3429478704929352,
-0.6764868497848511,
-0.04319141432642937,
-1.057830572128296,
1.1808921098709106,
-0.5358908176422119,
-0.25137996673583984,
-0.5098341107368469,
-0.020484376698732376,
0.15137508511543274,
-0.35429084300994873,
0.4039345979690552,
0.19109487533569336,
0.2517811059951782,
0.5808767676353455,
-0.7394809722900391,
0.5525091886520386,
-0.3162175416946411,
-0.15444441139698029,
0.31535571813583374,
0.31599441170692444,
0.0977209210395813,
-0.06541740894317627,
-0.18217365443706512,
0.019923236221075058,
0.30229976773262024,
-0.1991187185049057,
-0.7270532846450806,
0.537880003452301,
-0.7457247972488403,
-0.5725764632225037,
-0.20049796998500824,
-0.2875540256500244,
-0.0842444971203804,
0.14227919280529022,
0.2511219382286072,
0.6867993474006653,
-0.26066213846206665,
0.5227074027061462,
0.6698535680770874,
0.06660733371973038,
0.11453766375780106,
0.33835965394973755,
-0.1026356890797615,
-0.4629457890987396,
0.952248215675354,
-0.10965327173471451,
0.29645079374313354,
0.5172342658042908,
0.28321006894111633,
-0.36192041635513306,
0.10647953301668167,
-0.10986396670341492,
0.14455635845661163,
-0.9177253246307373,
-0.4567987620830536,
-0.3272976875305176,
-0.38928961753845215,
-0.35121268033981323,
-0.41004478931427,
-0.2884743809700012,
-0.15938453376293182,
-0.681578516960144,
-0.08360663056373596,
0.19068746268749237,
0.3850802779197693,
-0.23896631598472595,
0.3629419207572937,
-0.717562198638916,
0.4391440153121948,
0.3897268772125244,
-0.13105222582817078,
0.04186264052987099,
-0.31087249517440796,
-0.04737827554345131,
0.5002555251121521,
-0.20333853363990784,
-0.609103262424469,
0.6367422342300415,
0.40955138206481934,
0.2483184039592743,
0.5696829557418823,
0.21355392038822174,
0.8194642066955566,
-0.35563766956329346,
0.21612489223480225,
0.40589022636413574,
-1.1227214336395264,
0.41920700669288635,
0.25044184923171997,
0.7590098977088928,
0.7941195964813232,
0.4244924485683441,
0.0310750063508749,
0.19777849316596985,
-0.22862163186073303,
-0.350446879863739,
0.515350878238678,
0.1829044371843338,
0.28132370114326477,
-0.11684580892324448,
0.2130696326494217,
0.17429982125759125,
0.2570865750312805,
-0.4249126613140106,
0.05514025315642357,
-0.40264493227005005,
-0.5680800676345825,
-0.3703066110610962,
-0.15592657029628754,
0.10197580605745316,
-0.6222951412200928,
0.399036705493927,
-0.21628893911838531,
0.09621873497962952,
-0.24586741626262665,
-0.4804759621620178,
0.08853260427713394,
0.2677557170391083,
0.33877328038215637,
0.7742881178855896,
-0.07460696995258331,
0.2817007899284363,
0.37253934144973755,
-0.8125826716423035,
-0.10623978823423386,
0.38732993602752686,
-0.07714814692735672,
-0.2594466209411621,
0.01385905034840107,
0.8310821652412415,
0.8819594383239746,
-0.5209304690361023,
0.6143302917480469,
-0.22826889157295227,
-0.3833928108215332,
-0.505432665348053,
0.19532842934131622,
-0.08927436918020248,
-0.18661808967590332,
0.23704464733600616,
0.014988809823989868,
0.015515555627644062,
-0.17871734499931335,
0.24817636609077454,
0.31357264518737793,
-0.19450992345809937,
-0.3860583007335663,
0.638175904750824,
0.2947427034378052,
-0.40783217549324036,
0.8281765580177307,
-0.13737374544143677,
-0.8020856976509094,
0.7619097828865051,
0.8522037267684937,
0.7552225589752197,
-0.3517005741596222,
0.24293024837970734,
0.3854318857192993,
0.029421323910355568,
0.008106343448162079,
0.40673452615737915,
-0.6222061514854431,
-0.9589435458183289,
-0.5346745848655701,
-0.6937371492385864,
-0.10134704411029816,
-0.23555724322795868,
-0.8611778616905212,
0.37637633085250854,
-0.48310914635658264,
-0.31485670804977417,
0.32358789443969727,
0.08076940476894379,
-1.2676361799240112,
0.242496520280838,
0.07640273123979568,
0.6088023781776428,
-0.6238959431648254,
0.9228252172470093,
0.5334088206291199,
-0.475740909576416,
-0.9253486394882202,
-0.36725956201553345,
-0.2890465557575226,
-0.652911901473999,
0.9272909760475159,
0.3632029592990875,
-0.46414220333099365,
0.5587833523750305,
-0.259281724691391,
-0.5622842311859131,
0.6701622009277344,
0.7169432044029236,
-0.7179533243179321,
-0.20484240353107452,
0.21765956282615662,
0.2381676882505417,
-0.3032408058643341,
0.632646381855011,
0.6027822494506836,
0.253406822681427,
0.32745322585105896,
-1.0355322360992432,
-0.26030153036117554,
-0.2724710702896118,
-0.09727605432271957,
0.5369065999984741,
0.1002357229590416,
0.899634838104248,
-0.5649327039718628,
-0.15971621870994568,
-0.13771292567253113,
0.5173981785774231,
0.2811008095741272,
0.2797006666660309,
0.5455749034881592,
0.6701540350914001,
0.5652656555175781,
-0.21409666538238525,
0.9401015043258667,
-0.2664787471294403,
0.38459312915802,
0.9620130658149719,
-0.055131036788225174,
0.9625484943389893,
0.0796012282371521,
-0.43768808245658875,
0.4570130705833435,
0.3717578053474426,
0.22832569479942322,
0.53346186876297,
0.45429763197898865,
-0.7569195032119751,
-0.688080370426178,
0.35830041766166687,
-0.43886712193489075,
0.4101385176181793,
0.6447306275367737,
-0.1286676973104477,
-0.3599292039871216,
0.32801133394241333,
-0.05120277404785156,
0.11187488585710526,
-0.43328267335891724,
0.7298413515090942,
0.5783817172050476,
-0.5383998155593872,
0.6658957004547119,
-0.1713314652442932,
0.5204452276229858,
-0.9259614944458008,
-0.20776493847370148,
0.20043665170669556,
0.6112290620803833,
-0.1382550597190857,
-0.5496802926063538,
0.13594019412994385,
-0.038318946957588196,
0.017076807096600533,
-0.07785863429307938,
0.5816503763198853,
-0.48325371742248535,
-0.7436797618865967,
0.03710152208805084,
0.2656139135360718,
0.2609882950782776,
-0.3444903492927551,
-0.42156773805618286,
0.007704704534262419,
-0.19964833557605743,
0.20405206084251404,
-0.11844195425510406,
0.29403844475746155,
-0.056370001286268234,
0.4247535765171051,
0.938014566898346,
-0.1783408671617508,
0.017940504476428032,
0.7381319999694824,
0.8414298295974731,
-0.5158581733703613,
-0.5642184615135193,
-0.7564127445220947,
0.17576177418231964,
0.35566744208335876,
-0.09066678583621979,
0.5686090588569641,
0.7281914353370667,
0.9734527468681335,
-0.33629652857780457,
0.34111258387565613,
0.2213120013475418,
-0.06993477791547775,
-0.457723468542099,
0.7631098628044128,
-0.3352782130241394,
0.10583268105983734,
-0.029014458879828453,
-0.9884873628616333,
-0.4707394242286682,
1.0652472972869873,
-0.912837564945221,
0.21597284078598022,
0.6842804551124573,
0.6296423673629761,
-0.017214663326740265,
0.2584605813026428,
0.3655129671096802,
-0.26055875420570374,
0.28680622577667236,
0.7583187222480774,
0.49521371722221375,
-0.3126852810382843,
0.3861336410045624,
-0.4269571006298065,
-0.2918824255466461,
-0.02134806104004383,
-0.5555413365364075,
-0.8656188249588013,
-0.5017584562301636,
-0.35510483384132385,
-0.1111203208565712,
-0.09790944308042526,
0.8595936894416809,
0.52695631980896,
-0.7499501705169678,
-0.38920268416404724,
-0.41364195942878723,
-0.043424926698207855,
0.18163533508777618,
-0.19477781653404236,
0.3591175675392151,
-0.4106732904911041,
-0.46537989377975464,
0.06251685321331024,
0.12967567145824432,
-0.03978687524795532,
-0.2807222902774811,
-0.2071572244167328,
0.2202908843755722,
0.15190327167510986,
0.6807989478111267,
0.44382208585739136,
-0.3682764172554016,
0.22238989174365997,
-0.026864908635616302,
0.14902912080287933,
0.004749678540974855,
0.9723856449127197,
-1.1433619260787964,
0.7741150856018066,
0.4401278495788574,
0.5582095980644226,
0.8267226815223694,
0.13337941467761993,
0.8418897390365601,
-0.33766046166419983,
0.20472286641597748,
0.4362877905368805,
0.2369142472743988,
0.19366352260112762,
-0.20769289135932922,
0.04514757916331291,
-0.37059780955314636,
-0.3024224638938904,
-0.6247338652610779,
0.1649937629699707,
-0.2809113562107086,
0.08589871227741241,
0.6050521731376648,
-0.21074849367141724,
-0.4672822654247284,
0.13858023285865784,
-0.0559055358171463,
0.1706181913614273,
-0.18493756651878357,
0.343649297952652,
0.38149043917655945,
0.37523844838142395,
-0.3739282190799713,
-0.4028240442276001,
0.3432345986366272,
0.5792136788368225,
-0.9182677268981934,
-0.1444794237613678,
0.36424151062965393,
0.06639787554740906,
0.05718844383955002,
0.6716905832290649,
-0.23520782589912415,
0.5416709780693054,
0.037224747240543365,
0.18139435350894928,
-0.0975959450006485,
-0.2890983521938324,
-0.11572455614805222,
-0.04251367971301079,
-0.0328577496111393,
-0.3423561453819275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14339v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14339v1
|
Zero-shot Cross-lingual Stance Detection via Adversarial Language Adaptation
| 2024-04-22T16:56:43 | 2024-04-22T16:56:43 |
Bharathi A, Arkaitz Zubiaga
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Stance detection has been widely studied as the task of determining if a
social media post is positive, negative or neutral towards a specific issue,
such as support towards vaccines. Research in stance detection has however
often been limited to a single language and, where more than one language has
been studied, research has focused on few-shot settings, overlooking the
challenges of developing a zero-shot cross-lingual stance detection model. This
paper makes the first such effort by introducing a novel approach to zero-shot
cross-lingual stance detection, Multilingual Translation-Augmented BERT (MTAB),
aiming to enhance the performance of a cross-lingual classifier in the absence
of explicit training data for target languages. Our technique employs
translation augmentation to improve zero-shot performance and pairs it with
adversarial learning to further boost model efficacy. Through experiments on
datasets labeled for stance towards vaccines in four languages English, German,
French, Italian. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed approach,
showcasing improved results in comparison to a strong baseline model as well as
ablated versions of our model. Our experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of
model components, not least the translation-augmented data as well as the
adversarial learning component, to the improved performance of the model. We
have made our source code accessible on GitHub.
|
[
-0.37982460856437683,
-0.9256637692451477,
0.17639301717281342,
0.1040058508515358,
-0.3737974166870117,
0.07743198424577713,
-0.11091539263725281,
-0.3003261983394623,
0.670139729976654,
0.08129607886075974,
-0.4740857481956482,
-0.6833586692810059,
-0.9412120580673218,
-0.0755276158452034,
0.10047552734613419,
1.1755807399749756,
0.0982440859079361,
0.576249361038208,
0.23065683245658875,
-0.6730402112007141,
-0.33542600274086,
-0.23146739602088928,
-0.570536196231842,
-0.448172003030777,
0.5759391188621521,
0.3057840168476105,
0.6844024658203125,
0.09003959596157074,
0.03476530686020851,
0.13744114339351654,
-0.032074447721242905,
-0.10210384428501129,
-0.26877278089523315,
-0.13225844502449036,
-0.17190225422382355,
-0.4777945876121521,
-0.5757566690444946,
-0.13791437447071075,
0.7841804623603821,
0.5525534749031067,
-0.015007714740931988,
-0.08190979063510895,
-0.20615313947200775,
0.4551824927330017,
-0.4319104254245758,
-0.2393496036529541,
-0.6984246373176575,
0.10570906847715378,
-0.15297463536262512,
-0.11671958118677139,
-0.38930872082710266,
0.04359081760048866,
-0.24391205608844757,
-0.5217807292938232,
0.04996756464242935,
-0.4960647225379944,
0.9161757826805115,
-0.21006381511688232,
-0.4590344727039337,
0.034483734518289566,
-0.23347656428813934,
0.7247774600982666,
-0.9248368144035339,
0.5155727863311768,
0.2220107614994049,
0.049962736666202545,
-0.2731199562549591,
-0.0299701951444149,
-0.6570094227790833,
-0.05026934668421745,
0.3189986050128937,
0.31088539958000183,
-0.5041577816009521,
-0.06938308477401733,
-0.06622427701950073,
-0.07128117978572845,
-0.8420230746269226,
0.127010315656662,
-0.03866187110543251,
-0.10827377438545227,
0.3283441960811615,
-0.4094734787940979,
0.5388315916061401,
-0.4360825717449188,
-0.5417682528495789,
-0.2439216524362564,
-0.663953959941864,
0.31764087080955505,
0.5317756533622742,
0.5718944668769836,
-0.3218633532524109,
0.6407748460769653,
-0.04833132401108742,
0.5880894064903259,
0.4414108991622925,
0.040620461106300354,
0.3182251751422882,
-0.058016203343868256,
-0.23644164204597473,
0.17531603574752808,
0.7829641699790955,
0.2541200518608093,
-0.010867176577448845,
0.06838494539260864,
-0.08782507479190826,
-0.09677189588546753,
0.2304171323776245,
-0.7926117777824402,
-0.1557798981666565,
0.20749697089195251,
-0.25632524490356445,
-0.41917702555656433,
-0.21265709400177002,
-0.503010630607605,
-0.6122352480888367,
-0.10385291278362274,
0.5860377550125122,
-0.8342415690422058,
-0.437910258769989,
0.13926240801811218,
-0.1300657093524933,
0.6293595433235168,
0.26752057671546936,
-0.6931029558181763,
-0.3274845480918884,
0.7802006602287292,
0.7864530086517334,
0.0158541239798069,
-0.3410351276397705,
-0.6497094035148621,
0.16308407485485077,
-0.7039682269096375,
0.7858928442001343,
-0.5439011454582214,
-0.4568348526954651,
0.09619937092065811,
0.05888193100690842,
0.09909623861312866,
-0.11236609518527985,
0.32069334387779236,
-0.5615493059158325,
0.2939823269844055,
-0.22803589701652527,
-0.3792629539966583,
-0.32906195521354675,
0.9059219360351562,
-0.49786216020584106,
0.8985860347747803,
-0.11951260268688202,
-0.7655684351921082,
0.6681249737739563,
-0.697852611541748,
-0.8988194465637207,
0.0004824993957299739,
-0.22631052136421204,
-0.5342497229576111,
0.07461490482091904,
0.5581722855567932,
0.4521906077861786,
0.25604376196861267,
0.276563823223114,
-0.7297359704971313,
0.022357629612088203,
0.09310426563024521,
-0.42398205399513245,
1.3686208724975586,
-0.2886188328266144,
-0.23842774331569672,
0.30481547117233276,
-0.5701611638069153,
-0.14609435200691223,
0.1559561789035797,
-0.2167065292596817,
-0.536064624786377,
-0.17535191774368286,
-0.2021123468875885,
0.2902388274669647,
0.09690231084823608,
-0.6413809657096863,
0.468679279088974,
-0.5558438301086426,
-0.13963355123996735,
0.7481994032859802,
0.02839326113462448,
0.4200141727924347,
-0.13538116216659546,
0.5246862769126892,
0.06513693183660507,
0.1510019153356552,
-0.09135040640830994,
-0.6303709745407104,
-0.6546423435211182,
-0.37310338020324707,
0.3554094731807709,
0.5995316505432129,
-1.3309478759765625,
0.35459986329078674,
-0.293512761592865,
-0.3916493058204651,
-0.7380087971687317,
0.2963319420814514,
0.3970754146575928,
0.427411288022995,
0.32929351925849915,
-0.4341723620891571,
-0.4488416910171509,
-0.6739314794540405,
-0.3467889428138733,
-0.6615934371948242,
0.1103045865893364,
0.01841454580426216,
0.5119354724884033,
-0.09342726320028305,
0.4794198274612427,
-0.056798867881298065,
-0.24481095373630524,
-0.4894099235534668,
0.7309627532958984,
0.21379663050174713,
0.17506985366344452,
1.1084575653076172,
-0.7795069813728333,
-0.6909021139144897,
0.30326783657073975,
-0.6827050447463989,
-0.06548747420310974,
-0.2814517021179199,
-0.2694641351699829,
0.5672250390052795,
0.0362035371363163,
-0.4556739628314972,
0.26280125975608826,
0.7861418724060059,
-0.3113027513027191,
0.4036365747451782,
-0.03349416330456734,
0.3573971092700958,
-1.3660650253295898,
-0.018550975248217583,
0.1764228790998459,
-0.4191119968891144,
-1.0053943395614624,
0.09293831139802933,
0.2524898648262024,
-0.12413240224123001,
-0.9135252237319946,
0.6724816560745239,
-0.17456123232841492,
0.08687043190002441,
-0.3261711299419403,
-0.09084662795066833,
0.098403200507164,
0.5164804458618164,
0.3391217589378357,
0.5388104915618896,
0.7820701599121094,
-0.42438608407974243,
0.1449238806962967,
0.21990589797496796,
0.12785862386226654,
1.0926218032836914,
-0.44960522651672363,
-0.0815875232219696,
-0.2082425206899643,
0.3052876591682434,
-1.0057613849639893,
-0.13489596545696259,
0.6358776688575745,
-1.0487323999404907,
0.6871570944786072,
-0.37982064485549927,
-0.35587775707244873,
-0.12120532244443893,
-0.7020384669303894,
0.0940404161810875,
0.15723149478435516,
-0.6695122718811035,
0.767853319644928,
0.3911544978618622,
-0.23814620077610016,
-0.9716187715530396,
-0.7673189640045166,
0.31202536821365356,
-0.06737381964921951,
-0.5620928406715393,
0.1917281448841095,
0.0480491928756237,
0.038929905742406845,
-0.08361370861530304,
0.011619260534644127,
-0.1586853265762329,
-0.08641354739665985,
-0.1392085701227188,
0.3483331501483917,
-0.3024407923221588,
0.06929972022771835,
0.09513592720031738,
0.10124790668487549,
-0.16161781549453735,
-0.32969504594802856,
0.416789174079895,
-0.05487114563584328,
-0.5492478609085083,
-0.45306605100631714,
0.42547017335891724,
0.7342883348464966,
-0.09038907289505005,
0.8046894073486328,
1.0778186321258545,
-0.34576675295829773,
-0.04113356024026871,
-0.28056973218917847,
-0.05014067143201828,
-0.4137360453605652,
0.2906963527202606,
-0.1588183045387268,
-0.3396121561527252,
0.40449610352516174,
0.2903563380241394,
0.0034106499515473843,
0.2456236481666565,
0.6714380383491516,
-0.29568934440612793,
1.1690956354141235,
0.6495405435562134,
-0.5502293109893799,
0.7155680656433105,
-0.08835560828447342,
0.1968177855014801,
-0.429514616727829,
0.17442463338375092,
-0.09342037886381149,
-0.34445127844810486,
-0.4882796108722687,
-0.5007885694503784,
0.5175443887710571,
-0.03969692438840866,
-0.04206138476729393,
0.5124527812004089,
-0.17446593940258026,
0.005071172956377268,
0.5153918862342834,
0.21074849367141724,
-0.059839826077222824,
0.11982376128435135,
-0.156828835606575,
-0.17039687931537628,
-0.7301086783409119,
-0.11448991298675537,
0.9280617833137512,
0.30469903349876404,
0.36796844005584717,
0.3723914921283722,
0.7192816138267517,
0.3743835389614105,
0.4680688977241516,
-1.0368554592132568,
0.5665074586868286,
-0.3787592053413391,
-0.7635186910629272,
-0.1457969844341278,
-0.18890927731990814,
-0.8974443674087524,
0.44016435742378235,
-0.3462405502796173,
-0.38465505838394165,
0.23184318840503693,
0.14842058718204498,
-0.06993088126182556,
0.5024374723434448,
-0.5307294726371765,
1.0256458520889282,
-0.6377167701721191,
-0.4166935384273529,
-0.046898942440748215,
-0.6547189950942993,
0.18923062086105347,
-0.012375297956168652,
0.19526249170303345,
-0.02055002748966217,
0.1397726833820343,
0.4338407814502716,
0.021009385585784912,
1.254265308380127,
-0.5793898105621338,
-0.2598956823348999,
0.06409172713756561,
0.07907497137784958,
0.49329039454460144,
-0.024488044902682304,
-0.17093153297901154,
0.4358155131340027,
-0.19629256427288055,
-0.6812913417816162,
-0.330692857503891,
0.5722048282623291,
-0.5753090977668762,
-0.5638843774795532,
-0.55335533618927,
-0.687339186668396,
-0.33322975039482117,
0.43195804953575134,
-0.012741470709443092,
0.02406262792646885,
-0.6665797233581543,
0.24188856780529022,
0.4601585566997528,
-0.5937330722808838,
0.4262263774871826,
1.0193395614624023,
-0.18548037111759186,
-0.5011606812477112,
0.9691113233566284,
0.06447545439004898,
0.1636609584093094,
0.4525619149208069,
0.23610907793045044,
-0.4000839591026306,
-0.4783121645450592,
-0.8915143013000488,
0.183893084526062,
-0.5767949223518372,
-0.14037907123565674,
-0.43906381726264954,
0.1507878452539444,
-0.7728830575942993,
-0.4521915018558502,
-0.38724443316459656,
-0.5001923441886902,
-0.15084435045719147,
-0.24956509470939636,
0.26722654700279236,
0.240148663520813,
-0.37329286336898804,
0.2373482584953308,
-0.7628986835479736,
0.774061918258667,
0.053908511996269226,
0.16668438911437988,
-0.5186145305633545,
-0.5163909792900085,
-0.012588000856339931,
0.3460562229156494,
-0.4644840657711029,
-1.0312384366989136,
0.5411393046379089,
0.18462464213371277,
0.6651293635368347,
0.6478921175003052,
0.15693818032741547,
0.7982748746871948,
-0.4473819434642792,
0.7625107765197754,
0.5110633373260498,
-0.8977688550949097,
0.6531962156295776,
-0.5949597358703613,
0.33407920598983765,
0.40242937207221985,
0.5580154061317444,
-0.487856388092041,
-0.5051020979881287,
-0.43340760469436646,
-0.7430333495140076,
0.7788271307945251,
-0.005087158177047968,
0.39696282148361206,
-0.0649348795413971,
-0.15819816291332245,
0.1970781683921814,
0.0516618937253952,
-1.0252000093460083,
-0.14530447125434875,
-0.43890756368637085,
-0.06707029789686203,
0.022408252581954002,
0.17416468262672424,
-0.30781492590904236,
-0.39595237374305725,
1.012543797492981,
-0.25316566228866577,
0.08062700182199478,
-0.1060524731874466,
-0.37940603494644165,
-0.16590455174446106,
0.4130899906158447,
0.5001994967460632,
0.17464624345302582,
-0.17108690738677979,
0.0025176669005304575,
0.3048504590988159,
-0.2466534823179245,
0.13189256191253662,
0.36338502168655396,
-0.5162113904953003,
0.3833477199077606,
0.21574585139751434,
0.8606786131858826,
0.11054183542728424,
-0.4122925400733948,
0.8137897253036499,
0.20863541960716248,
-0.27659061551094055,
0.014173796400427818,
-0.43873167037963867,
-0.07802717387676239,
0.17358596622943878,
0.17983554303646088,
-0.04243026673793793,
0.00781843438744545,
-0.690753161907196,
0.44684481620788574,
0.8836960196495056,
-0.6266664862632751,
-0.5104407668113708,
0.5068813562393188,
0.14065127074718475,
-0.09112745523452759,
-0.0876561775803566,
-0.2958196997642517,
-0.591055154800415,
0.546183705329895,
0.6539667844772339,
0.7691038846969604,
-0.4929914176464081,
0.7115625739097595,
0.27858802676200867,
0.3744528293609619,
0.28404518961906433,
0.32843178510665894,
0.10924594849348068,
-0.8537219166755676,
-0.3104211688041687,
-0.24161313474178314,
-0.44889891147613525,
0.13836055994033813,
-0.7328685522079468,
0.44787585735321045,
-0.2772133946418762,
-0.1160561591386795,
0.225934237241745,
-0.06681700795888901,
-0.3435851037502289,
0.05181897431612015,
0.3963140845298767,
0.7078119516372681,
-1.1091670989990234,
1.1564640998840332,
1.160398006439209,
-0.4771011173725128,
-0.14098934829235077,
0.3242214024066925,
0.4142165780067444,
-1.0892969369888306,
0.3575546443462372,
0.08294342458248138,
-0.2974678575992584,
-0.3331861197948456,
-0.2542788088321686,
-0.22510549426078796,
0.6985335350036621,
0.5054062604904175,
-0.030070800334215164,
0.37708210945129395,
0.24803940951824188,
0.573737621307373,
-0.10141543298959732,
-0.14284402132034302,
0.052773367613554,
0.5977699756622314,
0.07782506942749023,
-0.4928560256958008,
-0.22134673595428467,
-0.2616937756538391,
-0.21098892390727997,
0.23249748349189758,
-0.44037100672721863,
0.6097800731658936,
-0.08520275354385376,
-0.09052103757858276,
-0.19648392498493195,
0.5679407715797424,
0.20446458458900452,
0.4279354512691498,
0.507935106754303,
0.5981802344322205,
0.42270269989967346,
0.17532306909561157,
0.9614569544792175,
-0.45406827330589294,
0.268195778131485,
0.8485344648361206,
-0.5636336207389832,
1.045712947845459,
0.6206166744232178,
0.041665345430374146,
0.45264166593551636,
0.46300753951072693,
0.016373518854379654,
0.49570611119270325,
-0.5506824254989624,
-0.3925018906593323,
-0.2718042731285095,
-0.32065340876579285,
-0.25367650389671326,
0.5078732371330261,
0.5444362759590149,
-0.23062404990196228,
-0.39500588178634644,
0.16274414956569672,
0.2838960587978363,
-0.040438324213027954,
-0.3825846016407013,
0.7999539971351624,
-0.19028213620185852,
-0.5768411755561829,
0.742272138595581,
0.04284423589706421,
0.729033350944519,
-0.745948314666748,
-0.01698899269104004,
-0.03237698972225189,
0.18555812537670135,
0.04962778836488724,
-1.0320236682891846,
0.22091607749462128,
0.16051054000854492,
-0.03605472296476364,
-0.30228784680366516,
0.8696041703224182,
-0.568050742149353,
-0.7805639505386353,
0.6916399598121643,
0.5285505056381226,
0.03508329391479492,
0.2356080710887909,
-1.0928966999053955,
-0.22310486435890198,
0.02081305719912052,
-0.21684740483760834,
0.5043486952781677,
0.47037380933761597,
-0.023075345903635025,
0.20506098866462708,
0.7620776891708374,
0.1999279260635376,
-0.01025969348847866,
0.2963586747646332,
0.8028990030288696,
-0.3140372335910797,
-0.31334418058395386,
-0.8222604990005493,
0.6077172756195068,
-0.07716483622789383,
-0.0678897574543953,
0.8270553946495056,
0.35694584250450134,
0.9923950433731079,
-0.049037180840969086,
1.0066405534744263,
-0.2395375818014145,
0.26618319749832153,
-0.3255341053009033,
0.8052959442138672,
-0.8696743249893188,
-0.09739310294389725,
-0.23472456634044647,
-0.2988319396972656,
-0.8051102757453918,
0.5525529980659485,
-0.39692285656929016,
-0.3043496906757355,
0.2513475716114044,
0.9662540555000305,
-0.3035939335823059,
-0.4306567907333374,
0.6121826171875,
0.13332398235797882,
0.2730521261692047,
0.38099658489227295,
0.4283457398414612,
-0.3300613462924957,
0.7386239767074585,
-0.4424497187137604,
-0.12394507974386215,
-0.44196173548698425,
-1.0530951023101807,
-1.0591967105865479,
-0.2772281765937805,
-0.3325742781162262,
-0.36069491505622864,
0.2550986111164093,
0.8989025950431824,
0.7063698768615723,
-1.1448554992675781,
0.06808806210756302,
0.0640995129942894,
0.09865708649158478,
-0.4149790406227112,
-0.1930282860994339,
0.2689606845378876,
-0.3775230348110199,
-0.7370875477790833,
0.6104156970977783,
0.25619882345199585,
-0.008497907780110836,
0.004251912701874971,
-0.20444326102733612,
-0.6807516813278198,
0.3481736183166504,
0.8130627274513245,
0.6757656931877136,
-0.8275620937347412,
-0.42430755496025085,
0.12602511048316956,
-0.06993486732244492,
0.3611941635608673,
0.42543432116508484,
-0.3544119596481323,
1.0002351999282837,
0.6152082085609436,
0.8422477841377258,
0.1469397246837616,
0.08041175454854965,
0.681776225566864,
-1.2830983400344849,
0.35731667280197144,
0.19403907656669617,
0.5596596002578735,
0.49607542157173157,
-0.1718771755695343,
0.1512807160615921,
0.20762641727924347,
0.015360785648226738,
-0.7819404006004333,
0.3360540568828583,
-1.0789220333099365,
-0.509473443031311,
1.2864543199539185,
-0.23008409142494202,
-0.14255960285663605,
-0.11721917241811752,
-0.33875834941864014,
0.5077329874038696,
-0.49832823872566223,
0.8211522698402405,
0.774115800857544,
-0.10099752247333527,
-0.18900835514068604,
-0.5918635725975037,
-0.04111244156956673,
0.728081226348877,
-0.5137200355529785,
-0.17129290103912354,
0.4361959993839264,
0.24125246703624725,
0.13615480065345764,
0.46131014823913574,
-0.08802150934934616,
0.5143166780471802,
-0.19013133645057678,
0.4420517385005951,
0.0976991355419159,
-0.2269369512796402,
-0.6483567953109741,
0.06032375991344452,
-0.014829137362539768,
-0.5566502809524536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14467v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14467v1
|
Integrating Chemistry Knowledge in Large Language Models via Prompt Engineering
| 2024-04-22T16:55:44 | 2024-04-22T16:55:44 |
Hongxuan Liu, Haoyu Yin, Zhiyao Luo, Xiaonan Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper presents a study on the integration of domain-specific knowledge
in prompt engineering to enhance the performance of large language models
(LLMs) in scientific domains. A benchmark dataset is curated to encapsulate the
intricate physical-chemical properties of small molecules, their drugability
for pharmacology, alongside the functional attributes of enzymes and crystal
materials, underscoring the relevance and applicability across biological and
chemical domains.The proposed domain-knowledge embedded prompt engineering
method outperforms traditional prompt engineering strategies on various
metrics, including capability, accuracy, F1 score, and hallucination drop. The
effectiveness of the method is demonstrated through case studies on complex
materials including the MacMillan catalyst, paclitaxel, and lithium cobalt
oxide. The results suggest that domain-knowledge prompts can guide LLMs to
generate more accurate and relevant responses, highlighting the potential of
LLMs as powerful tools for scientific discovery and innovation when equipped
with domain-specific prompts. The study also discusses limitations and future
directions for domain-specific prompt engineering development.
|
[
-0.16737601161003113,
-0.6349930167198181,
1.2547227144241333,
0.3316698968410492,
0.30916282534599304,
0.35145774483680725,
-0.33918705582618713,
-0.22492191195487976,
0.011585566215217113,
0.21101579070091248,
-0.5804556012153625,
-0.5542448163032532,
-0.44483014941215515,
0.2810174822807312,
0.2170112431049347,
0.42083996534347534,
-0.43359068036079407,
0.2474919855594635,
-0.38661208748817444,
0.3854694664478302,
-0.6419333219528198,
-0.34604308009147644,
-0.4111044108867645,
-0.1666276454925537,
0.6491504907608032,
0.24337346851825714,
0.2536866366863251,
0.33396583795547485,
0.33511239290237427,
0.2213531881570816,
-0.20603282749652863,
0.2117241770029068,
-0.20457053184509277,
0.016228314489126205,
-0.5862086415290833,
-0.2815173268318176,
-0.4005925953388214,
0.29398438334465027,
0.41101720929145813,
1.0712512731552124,
0.31361818313598633,
-0.13534726202487946,
0.3315143287181854,
0.28009670972824097,
-0.4604291319847107,
0.3374544084072113,
-0.46480152010917664,
0.12538422644138336,
-0.014332526363432407,
-0.2722040116786957,
-0.579757571220398,
-0.2639687657356262,
0.21407096087932587,
-0.7764114737510681,
-0.002390878042206168,
0.35800495743751526,
0.5395414233207703,
0.30666425824165344,
-0.4490497410297394,
-0.5433334112167358,
-0.39218011498451233,
0.9782050848007202,
-0.5648797750473022,
0.39356499910354614,
-0.05075949430465698,
0.5215455889701843,
-0.6096985936164856,
-0.7068429589271545,
-0.4205712676048279,
-0.4407704770565033,
-0.17335925996303558,
-0.17415395379066467,
0.29834723472595215,
0.42580074071884155,
0.17507517337799072,
0.1397055834531784,
-0.8164355158805847,
0.16537241637706757,
0.014666944742202759,
-0.38954687118530273,
0.20571653544902802,
0.3253733217716217,
0.40735650062561035,
-0.003561938414350152,
-0.3486960828304291,
0.14402925968170166,
-0.7016373872756958,
0.07054861634969711,
-0.23799529671669006,
0.7814479470252991,
0.09188050031661987,
0.6079344749450684,
-0.24511778354644775,
0.3496887981891632,
-0.07166452705860138,
0.08914147317409515,
0.06644397228956223,
-0.4927982985973358,
-0.057204969227313995,
0.2744131088256836,
0.7445103526115417,
0.008399798534810543,
0.04116927459836006,
-0.10484528541564941,
-0.11039842665195465,
0.040422406047582626,
-0.10168808698654175,
-1.1080323457717896,
-0.14613692462444305,
0.5294402241706848,
-0.1960109919309616,
-0.021690836176276207,
-0.2805316746234894,
-0.6888822913169861,
-0.6175734400749207,
-0.30229783058166504,
0.31866878271102905,
-0.30037981271743774,
0.11586719006299973,
0.22109703719615936,
-0.30436840653419495,
-0.09289385378360748,
0.4622115194797516,
-0.9736371040344238,
0.0976334810256958,
0.9164239168167114,
0.8778986930847168,
-0.380830317735672,
-0.3341823220252991,
-0.7071473002433777,
-0.10310480743646622,
-0.13059738278388977,
0.88397616147995,
-0.7235909104347229,
-0.6184964776039124,
0.07792682200670242,
0.1595562845468521,
-0.028091777116060257,
-0.7129358649253845,
0.4734303057193756,
-0.6538825035095215,
-0.0754648819565773,
-0.4422490894794464,
-0.4630754292011261,
0.1133911982178688,
0.04879120737314224,
-0.37947726249694824,
0.7071440815925598,
0.2541831433773041,
-0.14807596802711487,
0.3005232810974121,
-0.5930656790733337,
-0.1869743913412094,
0.22599957883358002,
-0.29062750935554504,
0.05988220125436783,
0.09260605275630951,
0.07798850536346436,
0.44424596428871155,
-0.5707261562347412,
0.45285511016845703,
-0.37458565831184387,
0.011308490298688412,
0.47577765583992004,
0.0009251217707060277,
0.5891249775886536,
0.23737290501594543,
-0.10081787407398224,
0.07440495491027832,
-0.7235929369926453,
0.013791417703032494,
-0.20187893509864807,
-0.21154478192329407,
-0.231424018740654,
-0.5474512577056885,
0.09000048786401749,
0.4284750521183014,
0.49097833037376404,
-0.5448548793792725,
0.5872109532356262,
-0.2818685472011566,
0.4167105555534363,
0.7576388120651245,
0.4400880038738251,
0.6447996497154236,
-0.11843138188123703,
0.48966893553733826,
-0.21966515481472015,
0.03062012977898121,
-0.10237407684326172,
-0.5594239830970764,
-0.21051166951656342,
-0.4587783217430115,
0.3531203269958496,
0.44460079073905945,
-0.6029855012893677,
0.33268672227859497,
-0.04226936027407646,
-0.3348822295665741,
-0.2454155832529068,
0.25701063871383667,
0.04263683781027794,
0.7331200242042542,
0.43000489473342896,
-0.0574815608561039,
-0.36225271224975586,
-0.7104184031486511,
-0.391710489988327,
-0.058754079043865204,
-0.21180851757526398,
0.5207549929618835,
0.5123075842857361,
-0.4266063868999481,
1.2075275182724,
-0.744132399559021,
0.002905713627114892,
0.02114500291645527,
0.15268471837043762,
0.6296015381813049,
0.5470679998397827,
0.37267452478408813,
-0.5406526923179626,
-0.6275596618652344,
0.1495433747768402,
-0.9995633959770203,
-0.5338018536567688,
-0.08395111560821533,
-0.44202476739883423,
-0.36412501335144043,
0.31166917085647583,
-0.9382002949714661,
-0.10032514482736588,
0.20868515968322754,
-0.4464532732963562,
0.6811783909797668,
0.040479447692632675,
0.5297405123710632,
-0.8476967215538025,
0.16485485434532166,
0.18876443803310394,
0.11580455303192139,
-0.7973876595497131,
-0.18291571736335754,
0.07921867072582245,
-0.517687976360321,
-0.7749156355857849,
1.1801588535308838,
-0.41344183683395386,
0.234099879860878,
-0.3941977918148041,
0.1096368357539177,
0.2296983152627945,
0.31524398922920227,
0.26352474093437195,
0.966086208820343,
0.6514045000076294,
-0.7246213555335999,
0.24339531362056732,
0.41462817788124084,
-0.3086523115634918,
0.5642927289009094,
-0.6914735436439514,
-0.1433180421590805,
0.30916261672973633,
-0.027220875024795532,
-0.9637163877487183,
-0.3177158236503601,
0.11174312978982925,
-0.4164039194583893,
0.4577360153198242,
-0.05202483385801315,
-0.45490962266921997,
-0.2034110724925995,
-0.17790071666240692,
0.2878449559211731,
0.5235265493392944,
-0.5898951292037964,
0.7545495629310608,
0.11079519242048264,
-0.5906444191932678,
-0.2795577347278595,
-0.25577327609062195,
0.03110618330538273,
-0.22591936588287354,
-0.8683618307113647,
0.5233545303344727,
-0.4364894926548004,
-0.26111871004104614,
-0.2420986145734787,
-0.2128155529499054,
0.03331298381090164,
0.18950946629047394,
0.0612281896173954,
0.3238874077796936,
-0.17239321768283844,
0.25721073150634766,
0.33040523529052734,
-0.23906517028808594,
0.3056166172027588,
-0.3589077591896057,
0.4401409327983856,
0.25196805596351624,
-0.12804220616817474,
-0.3912822902202606,
0.5122609734535217,
0.7182483673095703,
-0.072395920753479,
0.7004704475402832,
-0.06264080852270126,
-0.43139761686325073,
-0.6002477407455444,
-0.04719877615571022,
-0.6359540820121765,
-0.5884528160095215,
0.1536596715450287,
-0.5549574494361877,
-0.7934484481811523,
0.6261459589004517,
-0.8463332056999207,
-0.17615428566932678,
0.23440851271152496,
0.4451325833797455,
-0.03668128699064255,
0.8979777693748474,
0.6883226633071899,
0.28720447421073914,
0.23958849906921387,
-0.034970201551914215,
0.4081684648990631,
-0.7698651552200317,
-0.2396550476551056,
-0.6499331593513489,
0.016596218571066856,
-0.040759433060884476,
-0.5567676424980164,
0.6121949553489685,
0.06227301433682442,
-0.42883309721946716,
0.060305241495370865,
-0.3557792007923126,
0.2723185420036316,
0.13225415349006653,
-0.04227807745337486,
0.22600923478603363,
-0.029844099655747414,
-0.3619142472743988,
-0.1434355527162552,
-0.6955353617668152,
-0.6559032201766968,
0.7486407160758972,
0.3355683982372284,
0.9702510833740234,
-0.13609501719474792,
0.3838629424571991,
0.519385814666748,
0.03417041525244713,
-0.8938661217689514,
0.5878124833106995,
0.3355393409729004,
-0.2948300838470459,
-0.13219250738620758,
-0.36829516291618347,
-0.6636717915534973,
-0.08632081747055054,
-0.05500337854027748,
-0.578496515750885,
0.4828140437602997,
-0.13058802485466003,
-0.45926931500434875,
-0.2969222366809845,
-0.7109984755516052,
0.9307605028152466,
-0.31163063645362854,
-0.5027381777763367,
0.11528117954730988,
-0.4741411507129669,
0.08057967573404312,
-0.43888232111930847,
0.32586169242858887,
-0.09789390116930008,
-0.13352355360984802,
0.6228602528572083,
-0.7048238515853882,
0.91135174036026,
-0.17391133308410645,
-0.4432065784931183,
0.20517025887966156,
0.061998818069696426,
0.6285023093223572,
0.13441993296146393,
-0.05324552208185196,
0.08295506238937378,
-0.30670467019081116,
-0.39794325828552246,
-1.0093653202056885,
1.004411220550537,
-0.5228415131568909,
-0.7301719784736633,
-0.34556862711906433,
-0.47162413597106934,
-0.6333876252174377,
0.17045167088508606,
-0.05566335469484329,
0.27631157636642456,
-0.007070673163980246,
-0.37056055665016174,
0.9913228154182434,
-0.4027180075645447,
0.2702150046825409,
0.8456624150276184,
-0.042808372527360916,
-0.32630684971809387,
0.9890861511230469,
-0.042603638023138046,
0.27359816431999207,
0.5279266834259033,
0.13382919132709503,
-0.2082546055316925,
-0.4312053620815277,
-0.32133060693740845,
0.4479212760925293,
-0.9174078106880188,
-0.08087297528982162,
-0.8405677676200867,
-0.06488052010536194,
-0.5581839084625244,
-0.6387581825256348,
-0.32674065232276917,
-0.38603636622428894,
-0.37726226449012756,
-0.0869407132267952,
0.5366297960281372,
0.36564645171165466,
0.10436152666807175,
0.18068049848079681,
-1.0469647645950317,
0.050028588622808456,
0.23512692749500275,
0.22333070635795593,
-0.08261382579803467,
-0.45428624749183655,
-0.33748531341552734,
-0.16339215636253357,
-0.04728095978498459,
-0.8914076685905457,
0.18573801219463348,
-0.0023121482226997614,
0.8555593490600586,
0.03874381259083748,
0.06985116750001907,
0.1273551881313324,
-0.7063516974449158,
1.0113006830215454,
-0.07259969413280487,
-0.9882852435112,
0.8753148913383484,
-0.3267872631549835,
0.15689396858215332,
0.41475099325180054,
0.8103023767471313,
-0.4678809344768524,
-0.1672741174697876,
-0.18889157474040985,
-0.8419235944747925,
0.34649690985679626,
-0.04820951074361801,
-0.23153983056545258,
0.013790225610136986,
0.4087826907634735,
0.30324381589889526,
0.21970264613628387,
-0.1617649346590042,
-0.2354010045528412,
0.25143006443977356,
-0.4522600769996643,
0.20057673752307892,
0.07434173673391342,
-0.14350149035453796,
0.03995206579566002,
0.8857625126838684,
-0.2807310223579407,
0.0379054956138134,
0.08803750574588776,
-0.2191133052110672,
0.2423829585313797,
0.39019575715065,
0.4951208531856537,
0.39476463198661804,
-0.21072721481323242,
-0.022356417030096054,
0.055504780262708664,
-0.6694583892822266,
0.35917147994041443,
0.2111041396856308,
0.01948661170899868,
-0.12546275556087494,
0.18859051167964935,
0.3143593966960907,
-0.05950786918401718,
-0.9902796149253845,
0.0884711742401123,
-0.0024087217170745134,
0.15184485912322998,
0.35257214307785034,
0.03589997813105583,
-0.27180004119873047,
0.3809327781200409,
0.468067467212677,
0.005247395019978285,
0.32812875509262085,
-0.6858119368553162,
0.21092073619365692,
0.3122698962688446,
-0.39339083433151245,
-0.3156740367412567,
0.7244843244552612,
0.3857361972332001,
-0.04891105368733406,
0.20358529686927795,
-0.015683529898524284,
-0.4038620889186859,
0.5734659433364868,
0.4524827003479004,
0.8324848413467407,
-0.29035666584968567,
0.06942438334226608,
0.3041404187679291,
0.03471101075410843,
0.17654050886631012,
0.17803075909614563,
-0.050823088735342026,
-0.4420130252838135,
-0.26543861627578735,
-0.5808049440383911,
-0.5230728387832642,
-0.16185934841632843,
0.059687938541173935,
0.39965277910232544,
-0.5059462785720825,
-0.17272894084453583,
0.21183191239833832,
0.1457405835390091,
-0.4465875029563904,
0.0007224561995826662,
-0.07689215987920761,
1.1105669736862183,
-1.1038947105407715,
0.5059216618537903,
0.7276902794837952,
-0.419157475233078,
-0.6135627627372742,
-0.28524214029312134,
0.1489550769329071,
-0.5721561312675476,
1.138857126235962,
0.03281889110803604,
-0.054296813905239105,
-0.10018082708120346,
-0.562671422958374,
-0.8910347819328308,
1.0541486740112305,
0.08881645649671555,
-0.4207601249217987,
0.06809666007757187,
0.31532296538352966,
0.4032878875732422,
-0.6058378219604492,
0.3803981840610504,
0.6476847529411316,
0.5434578061103821,
0.16510948538780212,
-0.9444618821144104,
0.44026070833206177,
-0.47755712270736694,
0.014150155708193779,
0.0892496109008789,
-0.5621891617774963,
0.7123761177062988,
-0.13745759427547455,
-0.2531745731830597,
0.19421318173408508,
0.5928621888160706,
0.6363322138786316,
0.48699095845222473,
-0.13941414654254913,
0.12739627063274384,
0.9994234442710876,
-0.07699166983366013,
0.8051161170005798,
-0.5346829295158386,
0.1794138252735138,
0.7837811708450317,
-0.7419581413269043,
0.38434287905693054,
0.6006702780723572,
-0.14330632984638214,
0.39613595604896545,
0.7281595468521118,
0.06982634961605072,
0.8761634230613708,
0.3747686445713043,
-0.6851345896720886,
-0.29302260279655457,
-0.6086775660514832,
-0.3985747992992401,
-0.22325436770915985,
0.7054179310798645,
-0.32017555832862854,
-0.10710787773132324,
0.371950626373291,
-0.056584540754556656,
-0.05799379572272301,
-0.32897520065307617,
0.5561917424201965,
0.3011198043823242,
-0.5558988451957703,
0.5011662840843201,
-0.15174780786037445,
0.43465131521224976,
-0.6762322783470154,
-0.28855100274086,
-0.1850803643465042,
0.00223721144720912,
-0.037468645721673965,
-0.8867783546447754,
-0.1564023196697235,
-0.14647381007671356,
-0.40793541073799133,
-0.19771704077720642,
0.6588571667671204,
-0.19798815250396729,
0.052234578877687454,
0.09248559921979904,
0.4743749797344208,
0.08443909883499146,
-0.11271810531616211,
-0.2864026427268982,
0.09450084716081619,
-0.13622426986694336,
-0.019496971741318703,
0.4081008732318878,
0.6556071639060974,
0.02678251452744007,
0.6081607937812805,
0.6561912894248962,
-0.07550182193517685,
-0.18901638686656952,
-0.06925253570079803,
1.1454442739486694,
-0.7188203930854797,
-0.28661760687828064,
-0.654619574546814,
0.6834294199943542,
0.0029500010423362255,
-0.07810115814208984,
0.8518827557563782,
0.5641937851905823,
0.2925862967967987,
-0.40767595171928406,
1.0097646713256836,
0.2418648898601532,
0.3455347418785095,
-0.7540984749794006,
0.6371662020683289,
-0.28123441338539124,
0.5694118738174438,
-0.15003061294555664,
-0.933744490146637,
-0.3110225200653076,
0.18308749794960022,
-0.31273436546325684,
0.03789808228611946,
0.9747897386550903,
0.9842844009399414,
0.0996793583035469,
0.01182298082858324,
0.06391920149326324,
0.38114824891090393,
0.6899567246437073,
0.7889301180839539,
0.9919812083244324,
-0.26895591616630554,
-0.02674269676208496,
0.09417390823364258,
-0.4466246962547302,
-0.15328927338123322,
-0.8049064874649048,
-1.0881454944610596,
-0.3807283341884613,
-0.36301448941230774,
-0.4393283724784851,
-0.04037667438387871,
1.1076395511627197,
0.45531728863716125,
-0.8282346725463867,
-0.03228778392076492,
-0.08225251734256744,
0.10902689397335052,
0.02604416199028492,
-0.27032598853111267,
0.44789522886276245,
-0.4719564914703369,
-0.7713009119033813,
0.8056781888008118,
0.5397207140922546,
0.2050565779209137,
-0.2454528659582138,
-0.10070010274648666,
0.13747650384902954,
0.3166397213935852,
0.657820999622345,
0.4623558223247528,
-0.3850077688694,
0.006241268012672663,
0.4387021064758301,
-0.19795997440814972,
-0.06981302052736282,
0.9739452004432678,
-0.8788443803787231,
0.2592298686504364,
0.7838048338890076,
0.7834845185279846,
-0.0134348189458251,
-0.20771841704845428,
0.7918671369552612,
-0.6184555888175964,
-0.17212696373462677,
0.376436322927475,
0.506280243396759,
0.2439035326242447,
-0.6354042887687683,
0.3404157757759094,
0.3324933350086212,
-0.7962376475334167,
-0.7311360239982605,
0.09121949970722198,
-1.2704004049301147,
-0.4960460066795349,
1.1898592710494995,
0.00677861412987113,
-0.3591984212398529,
-0.17659404873847961,
-0.4479087293148041,
-0.12195460498332977,
-0.6702913641929626,
0.6497560143470764,
0.6503819823265076,
-0.2450980395078659,
-0.000907018780708313,
-0.5044329166412354,
0.6207872033119202,
0.3165957033634186,
-1.0195010900497437,
0.217042937874794,
0.48177194595336914,
0.1082126647233963,
0.36351385712623596,
0.325603723526001,
0.06794845312833786,
0.25958412885665894,
-0.016031159088015556,
-0.015457871370017529,
0.09010989218950272,
-0.44907763600349426,
-0.3392690122127533,
0.1309971660375595,
0.11746514588594437,
0.34384140372276306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15153v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15153v1
|
Expert Router: Orchestrating Efficient Language Model Inference through Prompt Classification
| 2024-04-22T16:33:42 | 2024-04-22T16:33:42 |
Josef Pichlmeier, Philipp Ross, Andre Luckow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.PF
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have experienced widespread adoption across
scientific and industrial domains due to their versatility and utility for
diverse tasks. Nevertheless, deploying and serving these models at scale with
optimal throughput and latency remains a significant challenge, primarily
because of the high computational and memory demands associated with LLMs. To
tackle this limitation, we introduce Expert Router, a system designed to
orchestrate multiple expert models efficiently, thereby enhancing scalability.
Expert Router is a parallel inference system with a central routing gateway
that distributes incoming requests using a clustering method. This approach
effectively partitions incoming requests among available LLMs, maximizing
overall throughput. Our extensive evaluations encompassed up to 1,000
concurrent users, providing comprehensive insights into the system's behavior
from user and infrastructure perspectives. The results demonstrate Expert
Router's effectiveness in handling high-load scenarios and achieving higher
throughput rates, particularly under many concurrent users.
|
[
-0.5448286533355713,
-0.7175354361534119,
0.6961890459060669,
0.45809701085090637,
0.18094879388809204,
0.228814959526062,
-0.1048307791352272,
-0.31402304768562317,
0.11540810018777847,
0.5963402390480042,
-0.20854438841342926,
-0.19961149990558624,
-0.5850061774253845,
0.07830940932035446,
-0.7445535659790039,
0.5284483432769775,
0.34917306900024414,
0.18173053860664368,
-0.2897908389568329,
0.02512470632791519,
-0.38517752289772034,
-0.3890515863895416,
-1.353755235671997,
-0.2996363937854767,
0.732695996761322,
0.42285874485969543,
0.790736973285675,
0.875360906124115,
0.6123020052909851,
0.5678811073303223,
-0.06695368140935898,
0.10409045964479446,
-0.26664113998413086,
0.2960931956768036,
-0.22860492765903473,
-0.5072216987609863,
-0.6624505519866943,
-0.4781900644302368,
0.4712464511394501,
0.8072440028190613,
-0.4642857313156128,
-0.05583478510379791,
-0.25092217326164246,
0.524493932723999,
-0.46089598536491394,
0.09683188050985336,
-0.5932471752166748,
-0.14558611810207367,
-0.3278895318508148,
0.07881400734186172,
-0.5130409002304077,
-0.2368582785129547,
0.2634124457836151,
-0.49332234263420105,
0.2715829312801361,
0.5469717383384705,
0.22847110033035278,
0.4523193836212158,
-0.44069910049438477,
0.0400514230132103,
-0.6278066635131836,
0.6535976529121399,
-0.6068977117538452,
0.5952401161193848,
0.1271921992301941,
0.8560545444488525,
-0.28077730536460876,
-0.765802800655365,
-0.5689768195152283,
0.2652868330478668,
-0.13823243975639343,
-0.14045998454093933,
-0.39789336919784546,
0.14869995415210724,
0.19550630450248718,
0.18274305760860443,
-0.7229570150375366,
0.480108380317688,
-0.16430963575839996,
-0.09653693437576294,
0.5910526514053345,
0.39831483364105225,
0.32462504506111145,
0.21795567870140076,
0.06036558747291565,
0.22209180891513824,
-0.308634489774704,
-0.16159863770008087,
0.16674065589904785,
0.1437520533800125,
0.21110571920871735,
0.29600223898887634,
-0.6137444376945496,
1.1177390813827515,
0.14900951087474823,
-0.16977646946907043,
0.17257142066955566,
0.10650121420621872,
-0.13894866406917572,
0.06609862297773361,
0.8332120180130005,
0.2738158702850342,
0.12256006896495819,
-0.3514920175075531,
-0.3591992259025574,
-0.16898714005947113,
0.3929566442966461,
-0.683412492275238,
-0.40791594982147217,
0.1644708663225174,
-0.2951068580150604,
-0.19948211312294006,
-0.20954078435897827,
-1.1668386459350586,
-0.5496988892555237,
-0.16205894947052002,
0.10768306255340576,
-0.12706021964550018,
-0.3124459385871887,
0.16808229684829712,
0.017333853989839554,
-0.06415656208992004,
0.49649208784103394,
-0.8926017880439758,
0.6698079705238342,
0.7356830835342407,
0.8599815964698792,
-0.22555606067180634,
-0.35880979895591736,
-0.7537503838539124,
0.15591323375701904,
-0.19468048214912415,
0.9603275060653687,
-0.6924506425857544,
-0.159009650349617,
-0.19525529444217682,
-0.1809733510017395,
-0.4351184070110321,
-0.43104997277259827,
0.7139180302619934,
-1.1753922700881958,
-0.23958410322666168,
-0.08653078228235245,
-0.6412990689277649,
-0.2418690174818039,
0.0021325284615159035,
-0.5854381322860718,
0.6652655601501465,
-0.1489744782447815,
-0.5397188067436218,
0.01827387884259224,
-0.5051207542419434,
-0.372465044260025,
0.3650902509689331,
-0.3330565392971039,
0.009789017029106617,
0.12330543994903564,
0.3074251711368561,
0.5840903520584106,
-0.5051117539405823,
0.2777201235294342,
-0.30446842312812805,
-0.028744881972670555,
0.08972695469856262,
-0.2556733191013336,
0.432675302028656,
0.5814343690872192,
-0.05361250415444374,
0.30992066860198975,
-0.9157158136367798,
-0.16973137855529785,
0.09245239198207855,
-0.4584713876247406,
-0.36796191334724426,
0.41783684492111206,
0.006967483554035425,
0.0021691732108592987,
0.22058075666427612,
-0.3940938413143158,
0.08659163862466812,
-0.265462189912796,
0.3782516419887543,
0.7615097761154175,
-0.30754539370536804,
0.5240263938903809,
-0.33178651332855225,
0.4944401681423187,
-0.12976017594337463,
-0.000921758939512074,
-0.2338293343782425,
-0.5884742140769958,
-1.0747846364974976,
-0.2598879039287567,
0.06743491441011429,
0.6363437175750732,
-0.6136624217033386,
0.4075324237346649,
-0.3754967451095581,
-0.6164148449897766,
-0.6531779170036316,
0.1331366002559662,
0.23782987892627716,
0.7262628078460693,
0.4107787311077118,
-0.01754787005484104,
-0.22833405435085297,
-0.9988629817962646,
-0.31870150566101074,
-0.009166289120912552,
-0.14528796076774597,
0.33704957365989685,
-0.04461415484547615,
-0.243194580078125,
0.9819242358207703,
-0.5393968820571899,
0.010747193358838558,
-0.3047276735305786,
0.23382529616355896,
0.37623319029808044,
0.4686911106109619,
0.5833554863929749,
-0.7747108340263367,
-0.6559748649597168,
0.22789689898490906,
-0.6308481693267822,
-0.4065120816230774,
-0.0022560544312000275,
-0.14580145478248596,
-0.0016117914346978068,
0.5279629230499268,
-0.5650222897529602,
-0.10579966753721237,
0.588168203830719,
-0.1674271523952484,
0.3444221317768097,
-0.22047357261180878,
0.1765759289264679,
-0.8834629654884338,
-0.3674660921096802,
0.01582060568034649,
-0.2467201054096222,
-0.9254346489906311,
0.21793311834335327,
-0.08564915508031845,
-0.029520567506551743,
-0.02042672596871853,
0.5711203813552856,
-0.41610825061798096,
-0.10173825919628143,
-0.31131190061569214,
-0.24485039710998535,
-0.2781287431716919,
0.301259309053421,
0.07674288749694824,
0.7883985638618469,
1.0047502517700195,
-0.6152380704879761,
0.4934175908565521,
0.07259424775838852,
-0.33013200759887695,
0.5347045063972473,
-0.7502206563949585,
0.36633312702178955,
0.02594989351928234,
0.08005654811859131,
-0.9622587561607361,
-0.6536386609077454,
0.11877885460853577,
-0.2096518725156784,
0.053077492862939835,
-0.23033647239208221,
-0.5483630299568176,
-0.5121908187866211,
0.4453023374080658,
0.2677694857120514,
0.7028276920318604,
-0.5864834189414978,
0.9671341180801392,
0.43208861351013184,
-0.4576493799686432,
-0.2530657649040222,
-0.5033664107322693,
0.17678767442703247,
-0.09221502393484116,
-0.7157308459281921,
-0.0658203735947609,
-0.12533791363239288,
-0.45275038480758667,
-0.19157882034778595,
-0.009756072424352169,
-0.35576558113098145,
0.030136847868561745,
0.2224523276090622,
-0.26043498516082764,
-0.1435532569885254,
0.0275123193860054,
0.20825527608394623,
-0.1763378232717514,
0.2681025564670563,
-0.5384140014648438,
0.5284598469734192,
-0.11761188507080078,
-0.79952472448349,
-0.50199955701828,
0.5373191237449646,
0.9984831809997559,
-0.3776588439941406,
0.6401260495185852,
0.43807253241539,
-0.1449766904115677,
-0.30521151423454285,
-1.0655491352081299,
-0.026778263971209526,
-0.5339239239692688,
0.35652539134025574,
-0.5886483788490295,
-0.9148843288421631,
0.5608917474746704,
-0.3284394443035126,
0.10171069204807281,
0.22758449614048004,
0.3496186435222626,
-0.07823486626148224,
1.2881641387939453,
0.683967649936676,
-0.3607827425003052,
0.2859959602355957,
0.1587700992822647,
0.20915374159812927,
-0.4324509799480438,
-0.3244621753692627,
-0.7602908611297607,
-0.20281963050365448,
-0.20849567651748657,
-0.6069455742835999,
0.606634795665741,
0.018408194184303284,
-0.2978261411190033,
-0.10934804379940033,
-0.32445061206817627,
0.4952293336391449,
0.6404562592506409,
0.16248908638954163,
0.48879677057266235,
0.18141672015190125,
-0.09077262878417969,
0.30869972705841064,
-1.111009955406189,
-0.4898420572280884,
0.6399102210998535,
0.3886072635650635,
0.7511954307556152,
0.1960982382297516,
0.329672247171402,
0.1880677044391632,
0.24125957489013672,
-0.7258370518684387,
0.8361482620239258,
-0.11398059129714966,
-0.46624889969825745,
-0.3329620063304901,
-0.520168125629425,
-0.645460844039917,
0.4001503884792328,
-0.13832883536815643,
-0.6320649981498718,
0.16757600009441376,
0.34380826354026794,
-0.3787845969200134,
0.5680289268493652,
-0.4472987949848175,
0.562560498714447,
-0.31840136647224426,
-0.1730201244354248,
-0.5743616819381714,
-0.6704143285751343,
0.32894957065582275,
-0.47668206691741943,
0.5029187202453613,
0.03770275413990021,
-0.11700508743524551,
0.7330912351608276,
-0.6903927326202393,
0.7529684901237488,
-0.1358780711889267,
0.2897775173187256,
0.023477593436837196,
0.2631794512271881,
0.7937426567077637,
-0.27892565727233887,
-0.48030194640159607,
0.17360062897205353,
-0.72910076379776,
-0.3927748501300812,
-0.5910876989364624,
0.7521650791168213,
-0.82928067445755,
-0.7869040369987488,
-0.06802952289581299,
-0.5421957969665527,
-0.14557214081287384,
0.42661309242248535,
-0.04076210781931877,
0.3857885003089905,
0.10494552552700043,
-0.0022011264227330685,
0.9148287773132324,
-0.1272239089012146,
0.5029466152191162,
0.7478713989257812,
-0.1638852059841156,
-0.2463844120502472,
0.8010827898979187,
0.010422849096357822,
0.1428355574607849,
0.44057679176330566,
0.18326033651828766,
-0.09089347720146179,
-1.1186823844909668,
-0.651494026184082,
-0.02008405141532421,
-0.5257168412208557,
0.022527633234858513,
-1.271799921989441,
-0.13241635262966156,
-0.23225322365760803,
-0.3996444344520569,
-0.3899703919887543,
-0.1727396696805954,
-0.18848846852779388,
-0.018209433183073997,
0.5565469264984131,
0.7614617347717285,
0.16476047039031982,
1.0022943019866943,
-0.927882969379425,
0.07732746750116348,
0.5451958775520325,
0.33036333322525024,
0.3364454209804535,
-0.5672544240951538,
-0.2881327271461487,
-0.6068312525749207,
0.04786624759435654,
-0.7709004878997803,
0.4444202780723572,
0.08080175518989563,
1.0369882583618164,
0.7332558631896973,
0.04483696445822716,
0.506070077419281,
-0.9948932528495789,
0.45426085591316223,
0.0828605368733406,
-0.8143280148506165,
0.36217084527015686,
-0.5159227252006531,
0.2907266616821289,
0.5251576900482178,
0.672846257686615,
-0.40694117546081543,
-0.4788494408130646,
-0.2373577505350113,
-0.8603477478027344,
0.5519986748695374,
-0.22391802072525024,
-0.08155009895563126,
0.017189860343933105,
0.32895028591156006,
0.07813762128353119,
0.18270647525787354,
-0.11019349843263626,
-0.18975643813610077,
0.07143235951662064,
-0.20040173828601837,
-0.18370871245861053,
-0.21964401006698608,
0.026193395256996155,
-0.1353210061788559,
0.37918609380722046,
-0.140824556350708,
-0.09133712202310562,
-0.019243523478507996,
-0.11379959434270859,
-0.18004731833934784,
0.2619759142398834,
0.19514572620391846,
0.7878332138061523,
0.06883391737937927,
0.28957483172416687,
0.4655018150806427,
-0.08718812465667725,
0.15068422257900238,
0.2054414004087448,
-0.22475118935108185,
0.04002348706126213,
0.403536319732666,
0.7901543378829956,
0.2476172298192978,
-0.540773332118988,
0.2616114914417267,
-0.06789672374725342,
0.11351905018091202,
-0.0722026452422142,
0.3881947994232178,
0.23081821203231812,
0.506028413772583,
0.5122028589248657,
0.39420074224472046,
0.3711813688278198,
0.22535720467567444,
0.1252032220363617,
0.1469464898109436,
-0.09095872938632965,
-0.18301691114902496,
0.8582192063331604,
0.4779627323150635,
-0.6039523482322693,
0.7559141516685486,
0.017299091443419456,
-0.6164755821228027,
0.49633726477622986,
0.2129698544740677,
0.9097500443458557,
-0.5884504914283752,
-0.159796342253685,
0.14203517138957977,
0.1746731549501419,
-0.36444956064224243,
-0.005719679873436689,
0.09742486476898193,
-0.7542490363121033,
-0.4957602024078369,
-0.9190136790275574,
-0.5553795099258423,
-0.2853408455848694,
-0.6570179462432861,
-0.03269432112574577,
-0.209614098072052,
-0.10077369958162308,
0.08112028241157532,
-0.4682256281375885,
-0.6204569339752197,
-0.014771685004234314,
0.11177506297826767,
1.2336254119873047,
-0.9179708361625671,
0.8910586833953857,
0.9919451475143433,
0.051846105605363846,
-0.7363312840461731,
-0.4284161627292633,
0.247248575091362,
-0.6586135625839233,
0.7945588231086731,
-0.16388355195522308,
-0.3513983488082886,
0.38747671246528625,
-0.28393909335136414,
-0.777168333530426,
0.9886125922203064,
0.1541810929775238,
-1.0428466796875,
0.09492874890565872,
-0.016004763543605804,
0.3746250867843628,
-0.4417099952697754,
0.6290517449378967,
0.30288946628570557,
0.533574640750885,
0.18618328869342804,
-0.9733960032463074,
0.06836080551147461,
-0.06895730644464493,
-0.019322630017995834,
0.00047267184709198773,
-0.8449145555496216,
0.7660581469535828,
-0.16986612975597382,
0.19682522118091583,
-0.010118050500750542,
1.0052145719528198,
0.32567334175109863,
0.3359084725379944,
1.0191311836242676,
0.4961254596710205,
0.9710394144058228,
0.15784864127635956,
0.9587180018424988,
-0.3801717162132263,
-0.12034774571657181,
1.0240834951400757,
-0.2481856644153595,
0.7856559753417969,
0.37572988867759705,
-0.10736211389303207,
0.35814085602760315,
0.7576972246170044,
0.08941653370857239,
0.4938558340072632,
0.27122125029563904,
-0.4666404724121094,
-0.47099295258522034,
-0.12271340936422348,
-0.1595354527235031,
0.1825500875711441,
0.3043687045574188,
-0.1566409021615982,
-0.31447577476501465,
-0.09880327433347702,
0.07089845091104507,
-0.03413621336221695,
-0.6481742858886719,
0.8255706429481506,
0.014913453720510006,
-0.6358639001846313,
0.05165848881006241,
-0.015995481982827187,
0.6955721974372864,
-0.5872761011123657,
0.24157504737377167,
-0.3221420645713806,
0.24270041286945343,
-0.21459177136421204,
-0.4822334349155426,
0.15796887874603271,
0.08529660850763321,
-0.4064255952835083,
-0.311541885137558,
0.7053335309028625,
-0.21126514673233032,
-0.6083499193191528,
0.43879392743110657,
0.7254613041877747,
0.5385755896568298,
-0.1364295482635498,
-0.4585842490196228,
0.1743590533733368,
-0.31094813346862793,
-0.4631330072879791,
0.4787876307964325,
0.5089545845985413,
-0.09230899065732956,
1.1571824550628662,
0.5157829523086548,
0.22993339598178864,
0.3856866955757141,
0.20529969036579132,
0.979546070098877,
-0.2948291301727295,
-0.409951776266098,
-0.77589350938797,
0.3290838599205017,
-0.1364799290895462,
0.0033990496303886175,
0.835826575756073,
0.42094409465789795,
0.7195507287979126,
-0.11045238375663757,
0.7984225153923035,
0.0866440013051033,
0.3507988154888153,
-0.3109579384326935,
0.7635341882705688,
-0.469325453042984,
0.4446873366832733,
-0.06674543023109436,
-0.6237505078315735,
-0.24599094688892365,
0.4461181163787842,
-0.3409523665904999,
-0.06321382522583008,
0.29291510581970215,
0.8458669185638428,
-0.20188336074352264,
0.15994830429553986,
0.2553236782550812,
0.3377484679222107,
0.32293593883514404,
0.3561171293258667,
0.8468207716941833,
0.20944806933403015,
0.4486760199069977,
-0.2149360179901123,
-0.5574365258216858,
-0.333136647939682,
-0.733454704284668,
-0.9974132776260376,
-0.15311262011528015,
-0.22715093195438385,
0.21313080191612244,
0.256206214427948,
0.9756430983543396,
1.0141955614089966,
-0.9269853234291077,
-0.5757118463516235,
-0.369478702545166,
0.22583511471748352,
-0.21274226903915405,
-0.1973496973514557,
0.17388394474983215,
-0.5269813537597656,
-0.8024027943611145,
0.8171615600585938,
0.12510721385478973,
-0.26594415307044983,
-0.30077189207077026,
-0.03406250476837158,
0.04733111709356308,
-0.02245934121310711,
0.5370222330093384,
0.007743426598608494,
-0.6493461728096008,
-0.029451634734869003,
0.012716714292764664,
-0.025677049532532692,
-0.35891595482826233,
0.6928877234458923,
-0.6383897662162781,
0.3652563989162445,
0.7298011779785156,
1.076489806175232,
0.23285959661006927,
0.052238330245018005,
0.825829803943634,
-0.2660205066204071,
-0.2809145450592041,
0.07504409551620483,
0.42895227670669556,
0.04870880767703056,
-0.49886658787727356,
0.42383742332458496,
0.25190311670303345,
-0.9384138584136963,
-0.7623130679130554,
0.10330774635076523,
-0.9191908240318298,
-0.29685845971107483,
0.7948752641677856,
-0.1446922868490219,
-0.020745165646076202,
-0.31350430846214294,
0.115348681807518,
-0.006585491821169853,
-0.7082425355911255,
0.44080987572669983,
0.5246968269348145,
-0.4322505295276642,
-0.5307024121284485,
-0.970608651638031,
0.07032667100429535,
0.468924343585968,
-0.6633362770080566,
-0.05707883834838867,
0.5335856080055237,
0.3035394549369812,
0.16858342289924622,
0.5735415816307068,
0.4290698170661926,
-0.2859500050544739,
-0.037751805037260056,
0.0348459854722023,
-0.22134649753570557,
-0.6260825991630554,
-0.3269798159599304,
0.5096520185470581,
0.12784284353256226,
-0.02357036992907524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14316v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14316v1
|
Automated Long Answer Grading with RiceChem Dataset
| 2024-04-22T16:28:09 | 2024-04-22T16:28:09 |
Shashank Sonkar, Kangqi Ni, Lesa Tran Lu, Kristi Kincaid, John S. Hutchinson, Richard G. Baraniuk
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce a new area of study in the field of educational Natural Language
Processing: Automated Long Answer Grading (ALAG). Distinguishing itself from
Automated Short Answer Grading (ASAG) and Automated Essay Grading (AEG), ALAG
presents unique challenges due to the complexity and multifaceted nature of
fact-based long answers. To study ALAG, we introduce RiceChem, a dataset
derived from a college chemistry course, featuring real student responses to
long-answer questions with an average word count notably higher than typical
ASAG datasets. We propose a novel approach to ALAG by formulating it as a
rubric entailment problem, employing natural language inference models to
verify whether each criterion, represented by a rubric item, is addressed in
the student's response. This formulation enables the effective use of MNLI for
transfer learning, significantly improving the performance of models on the
RiceChem dataset. We demonstrate the importance of rubric-based formulation in
ALAG, showcasing its superiority over traditional score-based approaches in
capturing the nuances of student responses. We also investigate the performance
of models in cold start scenarios, providing valuable insights into the
practical deployment considerations in educational settings. Lastly, we
benchmark state-of-the-art open-sourced Large Language Models (LLMs) on
RiceChem and compare their results to GPT models, highlighting the increased
complexity of ALAG compared to ASAG. Despite leveraging the benefits of a
rubric-based approach and transfer learning from MNLI, the lower performance of
LLMs on RiceChem underscores the significant difficulty posed by the ALAG task.
With this work, we offer a fresh perspective on grading long, fact-based
answers and introduce a new dataset to stimulate further research in this
important area. Code:
\url{https://github.com/luffycodes/Automated-Long-Answer-Grading}.
|
[
-0.15007898211479187,
-1.051904559135437,
0.4483945369720459,
-0.006294711958616972,
0.15028274059295654,
0.26238539814949036,
-0.3014281988143921,
-0.7181733250617981,
0.019916854798793793,
0.6765134930610657,
-0.36333855986595154,
-0.5905601382255554,
-0.4721336364746094,
0.1916494071483612,
-0.39020633697509766,
1.309805989265442,
-0.28041744232177734,
0.0029527051374316216,
-0.6429620385169983,
-0.13685260713100433,
-0.01663612760603428,
-0.12206649035215378,
-0.9706799983978271,
-0.6513943672180176,
0.26053711771965027,
0.6619086265563965,
0.48144373297691345,
0.7576168775558472,
0.8994858264923096,
0.24155683815479279,
0.14455297589302063,
0.09100940823554993,
0.020853914320468903,
0.07348021864891052,
-0.01866959221661091,
-0.5708531141281128,
-0.6311001777648926,
0.3961598575115204,
0.5194018483161926,
0.8340922594070435,
-0.1656312346458435,
0.5598100423812866,
0.1408679485321045,
0.8296567797660828,
-0.6085433959960938,
0.25159379839897156,
-0.18443414568901062,
-0.08347930014133453,
0.014662222005426884,
0.13472184538841248,
-0.5643449425697327,
-0.6898044347763062,
0.24836918711662292,
-0.6899973154067993,
0.11967606097459793,
0.058540552854537964,
0.8849957585334778,
0.4076515734195709,
-0.5990033149719238,
-0.7827996611595154,
-0.7124965190887451,
0.9110681414604187,
-0.4444256126880646,
-0.067478246986866,
0.6028430461883545,
0.5663793087005615,
-0.14766573905944824,
-0.7493422031402588,
-0.5426564812660217,
-0.5977581143379211,
-0.10208392888307571,
0.4397997558116913,
0.35793644189834595,
0.2617209851741791,
0.03383701294660568,
0.6874372959136963,
-0.7511945366859436,
0.044605839997529984,
-0.3138858675956726,
-0.11072026938199997,
0.6043031215667725,
0.20752175152301788,
-0.049388587474823,
-0.2873351275920868,
-0.6890521049499512,
-0.19223172962665558,
-0.39263778924942017,
0.34435537457466125,
0.45257824659347534,
0.4444448947906494,
0.03153429925441742,
0.5154874920845032,
-0.19581535458564758,
0.7474203109741211,
-0.18135465681552887,
0.019664764404296875,
0.03737198933959007,
-0.2596823275089264,
-0.18340571224689484,
0.12826873362064362,
0.5872700214385986,
0.23383893072605133,
0.30061307549476624,
0.13313600420951843,
-0.179330512881279,
0.18635253608226776,
0.0600762739777565,
-0.8946810364723206,
-0.40337735414505005,
0.3822634816169739,
-0.1320960521697998,
-0.21741825342178345,
-0.0729672983288765,
-0.8685992956161499,
-0.39051011204719543,
-0.5315878987312317,
0.5724409818649292,
-0.1864408701658249,
0.2480105608701706,
0.14035706222057343,
0.18111523985862732,
0.3468377888202667,
0.6014736890792847,
-0.34552377462387085,
0.6782504320144653,
0.6665424108505249,
0.7691137790679932,
-0.39721032977104187,
-0.10137750953435898,
-0.56623774766922,
0.001775791053660214,
-0.12514808773994446,
0.8769938945770264,
-0.6578173041343689,
-0.20439758896827698,
-0.16432639956474304,
-0.02589350752532482,
-0.08486343175172806,
-0.7139405608177185,
0.8518843054771423,
-0.32805880904197693,
0.5621448159217834,
0.004991090390831232,
-0.9652482867240906,
-0.2902255952358246,
0.39128822088241577,
-0.5691046714782715,
1.0517359972000122,
0.04078676551580429,
-0.3626427948474884,
0.03382685035467148,
-1.1579195261001587,
-0.5063798427581787,
0.018728574737906456,
0.2575022578239441,
-0.45560136437416077,
-0.40476107597351074,
-0.1065056324005127,
0.4086243510246277,
-0.4300176203250885,
-0.04851720482110977,
-0.20771190524101257,
-0.20412522554397583,
0.43620002269744873,
-0.16671711206436157,
0.6933180093765259,
0.3462112247943878,
0.0241449773311615,
-0.08808164298534393,
-0.9612075686454773,
0.33756908774375916,
-0.1069059669971466,
-0.4615578055381775,
-0.3165157437324524,
-0.22300176322460175,
0.04768740013241768,
0.0004070329014211893,
0.3502761721611023,
-0.5375931859016418,
0.15842179954051971,
-0.13270527124404907,
-0.05635664612054825,
0.8221965432167053,
-0.09895678609609604,
0.5736572742462158,
-0.38872963190078735,
0.7334771752357483,
-0.040941350162029266,
0.02924272045493126,
-0.27788686752319336,
-0.32863035798072815,
-0.985231876373291,
-0.1275196224451065,
0.4814477264881134,
0.834407389163971,
-0.4973416030406952,
0.271974116563797,
-0.07355630397796631,
-0.40537285804748535,
-0.7464542984962463,
0.3909130394458771,
0.3538079559803009,
0.6751448512077332,
0.6155996322631836,
-0.16792665421962738,
-0.278356671333313,
-0.8884170055389404,
-0.22369690239429474,
-0.16250453889369965,
-0.013200611807405949,
0.3581773638725281,
0.5853952169418335,
0.12428596615791321,
0.934567928314209,
-0.8945690989494324,
-0.46798938512802124,
-0.16936787962913513,
0.5707658529281616,
0.20633849501609802,
0.31705114245414734,
0.2967720329761505,
-0.5162863731384277,
-0.7666927576065063,
0.07179559022188187,
-0.5747009515762329,
-0.25239986181259155,
0.0024321498349308968,
-0.2551685571670532,
0.2641746699810028,
0.39382022619247437,
-0.4880152642726898,
0.2714459300041199,
0.3836914002895355,
-0.24021753668785095,
0.632155179977417,
0.02951057069003582,
0.3330169916152954,
-1.1066280603408813,
0.1603267788887024,
0.3317159116268158,
-0.3192542493343353,
-0.5985015034675598,
0.3186889588832855,
0.10002158582210541,
0.025104694068431854,
-0.37988364696502686,
0.7220165729522705,
-0.2184264063835144,
0.27644699811935425,
-0.7471179962158203,
-0.024578815326094627,
0.1560703068971634,
0.29253533482551575,
-0.0788053348660469,
0.6775846481323242,
0.44304150342941284,
-0.6681581139564514,
0.6908855438232422,
-0.07107818871736526,
-0.23358112573623657,
0.6754158735275269,
-0.5015925765037537,
0.03717595338821411,
-0.13448505103588104,
0.6042042374610901,
-0.9849699139595032,
-0.31377679109573364,
0.1889294683933258,
-0.5057600736618042,
0.36821335554122925,
-0.37777647376060486,
-0.22078447043895721,
-0.3516633212566376,
-0.15919165313243866,
0.32336851954460144,
0.5716857314109802,
-0.3965979814529419,
0.5196750164031982,
0.08679964393377304,
-0.13102580606937408,
-0.5116766691207886,
-0.3344736397266388,
-0.03876229748129845,
-0.4273499548435211,
-0.4527612030506134,
0.09806113690137863,
-0.1964145302772522,
-0.40659299492836,
-0.05622334033250809,
-0.1951475292444229,
-0.37749117612838745,
0.11201392114162445,
0.11249253898859024,
0.27057552337646484,
-0.39799997210502625,
0.38536882400512695,
-0.3016871511936188,
-0.09062256664037704,
0.3851044774055481,
-0.10752814263105392,
0.16239121556282043,
-0.31352120637893677,
-0.08867790549993515,
0.046850915998220444,
0.2839462459087372,
0.448253333568573,
-0.4071367084980011,
0.7136299014091492,
0.5979359745979309,
-0.48352810740470886,
-0.582737922668457,
-0.24741826951503754,
-0.2775667607784271,
-0.4732227027416229,
0.21199679374694824,
0.026606934145092964,
-0.5186527371406555,
0.6167857050895691,
-0.09391751885414124,
0.33279159665107727,
0.22091512382030487,
0.10194175690412521,
-0.2827902138233185,
0.5362497568130493,
0.52464759349823,
0.13931354880332947,
0.08478265255689621,
-0.3387399911880493,
0.14781293272972107,
-0.6337918043136597,
-0.1489601880311966,
-0.7579357624053955,
-0.2602488696575165,
-0.5992302298545837,
-0.5179067254066467,
0.2242746204137802,
-0.1712319403886795,
0.18303053081035614,
0.026119153946638107,
-0.08954508602619171,
0.868495762348175,
0.22190552949905396,
0.09111005067825317,
0.3872726559638977,
-0.2533453404903412,
0.10872197896242142,
0.33992916345596313,
-0.184141144156456,
-0.6781900525093079,
1.1482735872268677,
0.21301421523094177,
0.9996883273124695,
0.05553365498781204,
0.6014525890350342,
0.47760748863220215,
0.6953640580177307,
-1.1830183267593384,
0.7703760266304016,
-0.3520776033401489,
-0.6165366768836975,
-0.4491874873638153,
-0.6023538708686829,
-0.8241521120071411,
-0.028955595567822456,
-0.04270877316594124,
-0.28110620379447937,
-0.5300993919372559,
0.1594020128250122,
-0.2766425609588623,
0.032149121165275574,
-0.9685924649238586,
0.620109498500824,
-0.20478756725788116,
-0.7857780456542969,
-0.017919039353728294,
-0.6578114628791809,
0.4756757616996765,
-0.07711346447467804,
0.27612635493278503,
-0.2887786328792572,
0.22834499180316925,
0.9052314162254333,
-0.2693842351436615,
0.49390876293182373,
-0.016974948346614838,
-0.30129721760749817,
0.6718050837516785,
0.05702342838048935,
0.37756550312042236,
-0.08565600961446762,
-0.2151133269071579,
-0.3246428966522217,
-0.17584876716136932,
-0.5011414289474487,
-0.7993800640106201,
0.935298502445221,
-0.5701889395713806,
-0.7184798717498779,
-0.7439547777175903,
-0.5278211832046509,
-0.03827545419335365,
-0.012299184687435627,
-0.11607939004898071,
0.2245427817106247,
0.03542911261320114,
0.09684617817401886,
0.7646998167037964,
-0.08772897720336914,
0.37459972500801086,
0.6672751903533936,
-0.35400721430778503,
0.0011254121782258153,
0.9818021655082703,
0.17706483602523804,
0.4529845118522644,
0.37462013959884644,
0.3360559642314911,
-0.4956870377063751,
-0.21287377178668976,
-0.3016819357872009,
0.167650043964386,
-0.9765210747718811,
-0.31209737062454224,
-0.43857473134994507,
-0.3985302448272705,
-0.36636650562286377,
0.018718382343649864,
-0.38618165254592896,
-0.6000666618347168,
-0.17861312627792358,
-0.07595494389533997,
0.4254969358444214,
0.6764904856681824,
0.17889969050884247,
0.19458554685115814,
-0.5709100365638733,
0.47155317664146423,
0.3318907916545868,
0.6030849814414978,
-0.16235607862472534,
-0.7274731397628784,
-0.5282835364341736,
0.18998466432094574,
-0.6001424789428711,
-0.6383549571037292,
-0.044569287449121475,
0.5281795859336853,
0.21333301067352295,
0.06562856584787369,
0.28522008657455444,
0.6471077799797058,
-0.3189049959182739,
0.6495569348335266,
-0.19766734540462494,
-0.6955727934837341,
0.5330067873001099,
-0.16108199954032898,
0.4561937153339386,
0.6054960489273071,
0.6061635613441467,
-0.5732910633087158,
-0.5177611708641052,
-0.16552948951721191,
-0.9443890452384949,
0.5314506888389587,
0.06337541341781616,
-0.17459648847579956,
0.035730376839637756,
0.31134548783302307,
0.29087916016578674,
-0.10047316551208496,
-0.7267112731933594,
-0.47490596771240234,
-0.07706932723522186,
-0.38149577379226685,
-0.1786821186542511,
0.24985504150390625,
-0.05645565316081047,
-0.25190019607543945,
0.9008112549781799,
-0.27367162704467773,
-0.19822394847869873,
0.07958520948886871,
-0.2505492866039276,
-0.10958408564329147,
0.6850107312202454,
0.4762907922267914,
0.5288230776786804,
-0.4193543493747711,
0.18120282888412476,
0.13877533376216888,
-0.5766435861587524,
0.3777175843715668,
0.19863364100456238,
0.030909476801753044,
-0.27674049139022827,
0.13685962557792664,
0.24953654408454895,
-0.3483496904373169,
-0.7019845247268677,
0.2574516534805298,
-0.1049296036362648,
-0.1907859891653061,
-0.5438436269760132,
0.250093013048172,
-0.18341749906539917,
-0.3128649592399597,
0.5796677470207214,
-0.0944327712059021,
0.4102696478366852,
-0.5266041159629822,
0.1810861974954605,
0.34834790229797363,
-0.13029935956001282,
-0.0961788147687912,
0.2620336711406708,
0.334566205739975,
-0.190482497215271,
0.5422337651252747,
-0.06311364471912384,
-0.36864960193634033,
0.886721670627594,
0.4440731108188629,
0.8755916357040405,
-0.46297019720077515,
0.4174523949623108,
0.40507566928863525,
0.12949912250041962,
0.023132190108299255,
0.006633459590375423,
-0.04614889994263649,
-0.30252110958099365,
-0.5369341969490051,
-1.0094599723815918,
-0.7102206945419312,
0.43406733870506287,
-0.8276423215866089,
0.3103005290031433,
-0.5069756507873535,
-0.06510954350233078,
0.0477069616317749,
0.23738357424736023,
-0.5917004942893982,
0.5433980226516724,
-0.009042056277394295,
0.6334196329116821,
-1.0758689641952515,
0.5676026344299316,
1.2478636503219604,
0.04963516443967819,
-0.49717265367507935,
0.022386115044355392,
-0.14681193232536316,
-0.446358323097229,
0.428440660238266,
0.3933624029159546,
-0.2822577953338623,
-0.1284686177968979,
-0.46360155940055847,
-0.6176995038986206,
0.7786135673522949,
-0.04377545788884163,
-0.0784878358244896,
0.20334704220294952,
0.464373916387558,
0.7957398295402527,
-0.08163812011480331,
0.6049819588661194,
0.633000373840332,
0.536970853805542,
0.26690757274627686,
-0.828174352645874,
-0.18152089416980743,
-0.3760334551334381,
-0.6623185276985168,
0.3602893650531769,
-0.6530804634094238,
0.47498923540115356,
-0.3991425633430481,
-0.18611332774162292,
0.026231398805975914,
0.7615636587142944,
0.03243150934576988,
0.6753287315368652,
0.239500030875206,
0.685965895652771,
0.7521175146102905,
-0.23449772596359253,
0.799708366394043,
-0.20474328100681305,
0.2417520433664322,
1.2830997705459595,
-0.35824742913246155,
0.7877417206764221,
0.5547760128974915,
-0.33671167492866516,
0.4949303865432739,
0.5510014891624451,
0.16216520965099335,
0.05960055813193321,
0.6191459894180298,
-0.4716937839984894,
-0.3296188414096832,
-0.3732515275478363,
-0.1396140605211258,
0.7775172591209412,
0.35691988468170166,
-0.20597140491008759,
-0.46481361985206604,
0.02200925163924694,
-0.10256654769182205,
0.4247022867202759,
-0.3397735357284546,
0.6615609526634216,
0.14597344398498535,
-0.9537408351898193,
0.4385288655757904,
0.16937567293643951,
0.4543916583061218,
-0.5715495347976685,
-0.35460513830184937,
-0.42416834831237793,
0.27546852827072144,
-0.26876160502433777,
-1.0310450792312622,
0.09813372045755386,
0.12027919292449951,
-0.18350479006767273,
-0.2476995587348938,
0.35695356130599976,
-0.7156075239181519,
-0.7468275427818298,
-0.10698513686656952,
0.2878764867782593,
0.0858234241604805,
0.3945322632789612,
-0.5323542952537537,
-0.41998353600502014,
-0.22307580709457397,
-0.21438990533351898,
0.23307563364505768,
0.22046278417110443,
0.029768792912364006,
1.0145069360733032,
0.5326765775680542,
-0.08660028129816055,
0.07015394419431686,
-0.19736948609352112,
0.35056424140930176,
-0.45620909333229065,
-0.5484609603881836,
-0.6920936107635498,
0.32565364241600037,
0.09339384734630585,
-0.02662450075149536,
0.901224672794342,
0.7493613958358765,
0.7635005116462708,
0.09056001901626587,
0.8208975195884705,
0.19324533641338348,
0.6962581872940063,
-0.7584307789802551,
0.5613040924072266,
-0.46174490451812744,
0.4089105427265167,
-0.11010614037513733,
-0.8681128025054932,
-0.16813789308071136,
0.5675334334373474,
-0.2727883756160736,
0.15912476181983948,
0.850964367389679,
0.5608141422271729,
-0.017932675778865814,
0.16427117586135864,
-0.024205412715673447,
0.09442834556102753,
0.5282651782035828,
0.6619744896888733,
0.8401650786399841,
-0.5150378346443176,
0.5329670906066895,
-0.29502832889556885,
-0.13014335930347443,
-0.03879112750291824,
-0.8148578405380249,
-0.8923612833023071,
-0.5411900877952576,
-0.6213915348052979,
-0.4171050786972046,
0.08759842067956924,
1.153602123260498,
0.19828331470489502,
-0.7939082384109497,
-0.5818302035331726,
0.18678991496562958,
0.10381339490413666,
0.06037386134266853,
-0.3907319903373718,
0.45454397797584534,
-0.21047405898571014,
-0.658505916595459,
0.12947340309619904,
0.025221779942512512,
0.4332948327064514,
-0.048223599791526794,
-0.0002205036289524287,
-0.19749058783054352,
0.2585657238960266,
0.4565064311027527,
0.2485329657793045,
-0.5333466529846191,
-0.35256335139274597,
0.13417929410934448,
-0.11526341736316681,
0.1846383512020111,
0.5815392732620239,
-0.7278400659561157,
0.31850042939186096,
0.24094025790691376,
0.5292232036590576,
0.23392558097839355,
0.339028924703598,
0.2826502025127411,
-0.6786041855812073,
-0.34170350432395935,
0.29151979088783264,
0.008819245733320713,
0.5219584107398987,
-0.21551981568336487,
0.31504660844802856,
-0.04402585327625275,
-0.7218829989433289,
-0.747143030166626,
0.2940799295902252,
-0.9221208095550537,
-0.19550999999046326,
1.1810691356658936,
-0.2548679709434509,
-0.35593748092651367,
-0.09960688650608063,
-0.0435030572116375,
0.20999836921691895,
-0.39387381076812744,
1.1070955991744995,
1.0399302244186401,
-0.19173432886600494,
-0.19873741269111633,
-0.3581593334674835,
0.6241224408149719,
0.4750560522079468,
-1.2969845533370972,
0.2844669222831726,
0.3857797384262085,
0.1598440408706665,
0.2238510698080063,
0.13486430048942566,
0.13511507213115692,
0.3625945746898651,
-0.4948934316635132,
0.0072038848884403706,
-0.1225474402308464,
-0.5647273063659668,
-0.2619249224662781,
0.19553695619106293,
-0.02449844777584076,
-0.0910898819565773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14313v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14313v2
|
Self-Supervised Alignment with Mutual Information: Learning to Follow Principles without Preference Labels
| 2024-04-22T16:20:36 | 2024-05-21T17:31:27 |
Jan-Philipp Fränken, Eric Zelikman, Rafael Rafailov, Kanishk Gandhi, Tobias Gerstenberg, Noah D. Goodman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
When prompting a language model (LM), users often expect the model to adhere
to a set of behavioral principles across diverse tasks, such as producing
insightful content while avoiding harmful or biased language. Instilling such
principles (i.e., a constitution) into a model is resource-intensive,
technically challenging, and generally requires human preference labels or
examples. We introduce SAMI, an iterative algorithm that finetunes a pretrained
language model (without requiring preference labels or demonstrations) to
increase the conditional mutual information between constitutions and
self-generated responses given queries from a dataset. On single-turn dialogue
and summarization, a SAMI-trained mistral-7b outperforms the initial pretrained
model, with win rates between 66% and 77%. Strikingly, it also surpasses an
instruction-finetuned baseline (mistral-7b-instruct) with win rates between 55%
and 57% on single-turn dialogue. SAMI requires a model that writes the
principles. To avoid dependence on strong models for writing principles, we
align a strong pretrained model (mixtral-8x7b) using constitutions written by a
weak instruction-finetuned model (mistral-7b-instruct), achieving a 65% win
rate on summarization. Finally, we investigate whether SAMI generalizes to
diverse summarization principles (e.g., "summaries should be scientific") and
scales to stronger models (llama3-70b), finding that it achieves win rates of
up to 68% for learned and 67% for held-out principles compared to the base
model. Our results show that a pretrained LM can learn to follow constitutions
without using preference labels, demonstrations, or human oversight.
|
[
-0.3398612439632416,
0.013639668934047222,
0.4715559780597687,
0.16928216814994812,
-0.42716848850250244,
-0.12096327543258667,
-0.45982104539871216,
-0.15676739811897278,
0.4549391567707062,
0.6134142279624939,
-0.4983908534049988,
-0.6132691502571106,
-0.5597147941589355,
-0.08517970889806747,
-0.08844748884439468,
1.4496814012527466,
-0.12193144857883453,
0.2014203816652298,
-0.2891705632209778,
-0.2794474959373474,
-0.333139568567276,
-0.4642128348350525,
0.018337560817599297,
-0.46946248412132263,
0.5673023462295532,
0.34638863801956177,
0.6769498586654663,
0.9549542665481567,
0.3500593602657318,
0.34752583503723145,
0.20892830193042755,
-0.09829529374837875,
-0.6305234432220459,
0.18556466698646545,
-0.37141212821006775,
-0.5510251522064209,
-0.26730841398239136,
0.20644927024841309,
0.6139021515846252,
0.6616925001144409,
-0.427904337644577,
-0.024032071232795715,
0.299821674823761,
0.8372902870178223,
-0.5956029295921326,
0.09259218722581863,
-0.6662341356277466,
-0.04651760682463646,
-0.18372288346290588,
-0.024702155962586403,
-0.12559133768081665,
-0.5780753493309021,
0.35231828689575195,
-0.8259823322296143,
0.1295223981142044,
0.04460015147924423,
0.9934465289115906,
0.3436987102031708,
-0.4302663207054138,
-0.4692913591861725,
-0.46290338039398193,
0.9166838526725769,
-0.6332771182060242,
0.37627989053726196,
0.5138850808143616,
0.0375237800180912,
-0.06318183988332748,
-0.48273804783821106,
-0.5636252760887146,
-0.1354304850101471,
-0.2331361323595047,
0.1782573014497757,
0.15693703293800354,
0.4526476562023163,
0.11518201231956482,
0.26019155979156494,
-0.445875346660614,
0.04763535037636757,
-0.6073093414306641,
-0.1397671401500702,
0.6811510324478149,
0.09220327436923981,
0.08312670886516571,
-0.23145514726638794,
-0.4835056960582733,
-0.2592380940914154,
-0.49885544180870056,
0.20527169108390808,
0.56251060962677,
0.3234803080558777,
-0.15296874940395355,
0.6744402647018433,
-0.46186894178390503,
0.6994419693946838,
0.6385448575019836,
-0.16129620373249054,
0.09993107616901398,
-0.4974745810031891,
-0.07402615994215012,
0.13535957038402557,
0.8911165595054626,
0.428189754486084,
0.1485440582036972,
-0.16268539428710938,
-0.3733464181423187,
0.33716878294944763,
0.3620187044143677,
-0.49860602617263794,
-0.4331074357032776,
0.07657291740179062,
-0.4629875123500824,
-0.16019733250141144,
-0.20648807287216187,
-0.2987908720970154,
-0.29321616888046265,
-0.7987368106842041,
0.8237910866737366,
-0.4310021996498108,
-0.16035614907741547,
0.16788531839847565,
-0.06747540831565857,
0.5109536051750183,
0.2608495354652405,
-1.2215238809585571,
0.44063466787338257,
0.7897709608078003,
0.5773653388023376,
-0.22077934443950653,
-0.4350259602069855,
-0.23760686814785004,
0.2193158119916916,
-0.47872695326805115,
0.7203152179718018,
-0.40281370282173157,
-0.1738300770521164,
-0.23178166151046753,
-0.4071582853794098,
-0.1508082002401352,
-0.16424168646335602,
0.3662148714065552,
-0.37321439385414124,
0.5923919081687927,
-0.4025571048259735,
-0.9396535158157349,
0.01611560769379139,
0.03214616701006889,
-0.5973469614982605,
0.6289593577384949,
-0.15175536274909973,
-0.8607945442199707,
0.5453892350196838,
-0.48654139041900635,
-0.38553956151008606,
-0.3338376581668854,
-0.38996201753616333,
-0.30701392889022827,
0.03690728545188904,
0.006053135730326176,
0.45646950602531433,
0.01119340118020773,
0.6388925909996033,
-0.4314129650592804,
-0.1354028880596161,
-0.10377563536167145,
0.146501362323761,
0.4955367147922516,
0.21248331665992737,
-0.25499364733695984,
0.28139814734458923,
-0.5998156070709229,
0.13497117161750793,
-0.1828642338514328,
-0.2979719936847687,
-0.5578950047492981,
-0.03899121284484863,
-0.5983178019523621,
0.15274696052074432,
0.2804984748363495,
-0.3895672559738159,
0.33019739389419556,
-0.42181912064552307,
-0.142959326505661,
0.9202265739440918,
-0.24739544093608856,
0.9436802864074707,
-0.7203561663627625,
0.338858962059021,
-0.37025871872901917,
0.01142950914800167,
-0.05455987527966499,
0.021150505170226097,
-0.8033384084701538,
-0.20225568115711212,
0.48617231845855713,
0.30525702238082886,
-0.6331871151924133,
0.5146945118904114,
-0.3177095353603363,
-0.47126245498657227,
-0.8057401776313782,
0.5124562382698059,
0.6795870065689087,
0.6818591356277466,
0.3996199667453766,
-0.45004940032958984,
-0.6583235859870911,
-0.9125139117240906,
-0.29284313321113586,
-0.31640034914016724,
0.18245501816272736,
-0.08621163666248322,
0.2806423008441925,
0.21012744307518005,
0.8437107801437378,
-0.3869626522064209,
-0.2377871721982956,
-0.352478563785553,
0.33151161670684814,
0.32737186551094055,
0.7051118612289429,
0.3571484684944153,
-0.5990095734596252,
-0.5374619364738464,
-0.2559410035610199,
-0.7852195501327515,
-0.2680392861366272,
-0.035891398787498474,
-0.3531894385814667,
0.1658758968114853,
0.2677423059940338,
-0.3859517276287079,
0.20972788333892822,
0.5424553751945496,
-0.16864901781082153,
0.4579140543937683,
-0.140181303024292,
0.00042612035758793354,
-1.1868939399719238,
-0.0872560515999794,
-0.06916359812021255,
-0.22673223912715912,
-0.5796008706092834,
-0.11901679635047913,
0.06323966383934021,
0.2860986888408661,
-0.0970829650759697,
0.49864259362220764,
-0.41430431604385376,
0.0027789503801614046,
-0.24927212297916412,
0.02859959937632084,
0.052091311663389206,
0.6613606214523315,
0.4958110749721527,
0.5282101035118103,
0.3523390591144562,
-0.910938560962677,
0.09107513725757599,
0.42002686858177185,
-0.4040687084197998,
0.7045085430145264,
-0.761972963809967,
-0.04875312000513077,
-0.418575644493103,
0.16421766579151154,
-0.7755522727966309,
-0.27934667468070984,
0.09384222328662872,
-0.34069475531578064,
0.4117710590362549,
-0.15528932213783264,
0.12399984896183014,
0.05850910395383835,
-0.5306847095489502,
0.14912056922912598,
0.5108555555343628,
-0.5810499787330627,
0.5997565388679504,
0.4882381558418274,
-0.20154468715190887,
-1.0720692873001099,
-0.20823398232460022,
-0.3610096573829651,
-0.17595666646957397,
-0.5327006578445435,
0.26964542269706726,
-0.15590675175189972,
-0.21941092610359192,
0.08589184284210205,
-0.3583683967590332,
0.02228827029466629,
0.17410647869110107,
0.25849851965904236,
0.23600658774375916,
-0.2126760631799698,
0.28058940172195435,
0.13450267910957336,
0.002776936162263155,
-0.22570568323135376,
-0.473055362701416,
0.38841530680656433,
-0.0869721993803978,
-0.23622383177280426,
-0.7059217691421509,
0.22605140507221222,
0.22796401381492615,
-0.15756583213806152,
0.6531297564506531,
0.19431903958320618,
-0.044800493866205215,
-0.0971161425113678,
-0.49901682138442993,
-0.26530343294143677,
-0.44367870688438416,
0.09466661512851715,
-0.3527829349040985,
-0.7139021158218384,
0.24904675781726837,
0.04310494288802147,
0.2686408460140228,
0.5749071836471558,
0.28409942984580994,
-0.7582066059112549,
0.707872748374939,
0.8074483275413513,
-0.21089306473731995,
0.6689957976341248,
-0.19690090417861938,
-0.2906896471977234,
-0.7741401791572571,
-0.24292849004268646,
-0.4590180516242981,
-0.4292028248310089,
-0.582040548324585,
-0.046841543167829514,
0.35285887122154236,
0.3118983805179596,
-0.32660141587257385,
0.4932422339916229,
-0.23424282670021057,
0.617967963218689,
0.8581845760345459,
0.10748035460710526,
0.22240565717220306,
-0.2752854526042938,
-0.5176146030426025,
-0.2287459820508957,
-0.8154978156089783,
-0.43221136927604675,
1.3729922771453857,
0.09292301535606384,
1.3935364484786987,
0.24708373844623566,
1.3054801225662231,
0.31368276476860046,
0.45789647102355957,
-0.5612794160842896,
0.3179989159107208,
0.057853780686855316,
-0.4802444279193878,
-0.4684065580368042,
-0.35102882981300354,
-0.7824757099151611,
0.33681541681289673,
-0.5913519859313965,
-0.34254705905914307,
0.12633928656578064,
0.5597832798957825,
-0.441584050655365,
-0.010738368146121502,
-0.6201431155204773,
0.7011314630508423,
-0.29801973700523376,
-0.40293675661087036,
-0.19865068793296814,
-0.9258285760879517,
0.5520772337913513,
-0.004611617419868708,
0.00141679379157722,
-0.09510299563407898,
0.09575887769460678,
0.774423360824585,
-0.48656266927719116,
1.0516481399536133,
-0.10762007534503937,
-0.10827335715293884,
0.15704795718193054,
0.013682967983186245,
0.4761544167995453,
-0.31748178601264954,
0.03250417858362198,
-0.17775242030620575,
0.047356970608234406,
-0.31293410062789917,
-0.74686598777771,
0.4728713929653168,
-0.9527872800827026,
-0.7668629288673401,
-0.4555366635322571,
-0.2439526468515396,
-0.039722416549921036,
0.2076164335012436,
0.3372255563735962,
0.40331000089645386,
-0.28161054849624634,
0.1836192011833191,
0.7561503648757935,
0.22897830605506897,
0.249210923910141,
0.5007797479629517,
-0.26316916942596436,
-0.7791858911514282,
0.8962021470069885,
0.029596436768770218,
0.6205964088439941,
0.33391696214675903,
0.3040415644645691,
-0.6969488859176636,
-0.5068157315254211,
-0.350070983171463,
0.4126238226890564,
-0.7021787762641907,
-0.38694921135902405,
-0.7460641860961914,
0.015676073729991913,
-0.33615583181381226,
-0.2015850841999054,
-0.504045844078064,
-0.7127658724784851,
-0.12632721662521362,
0.08656175434589386,
-0.033096395432949066,
0.726710319519043,
-0.3712726831436157,
0.613121509552002,
-0.5564984083175659,
0.41838499903678894,
0.5279735326766968,
0.38405683636665344,
-0.3783990144729614,
-0.6712228059768677,
0.01693829335272312,
0.15210497379302979,
-0.34729430079460144,
-0.7623224258422852,
0.0697978138923645,
0.35918229818344116,
0.6864498257637024,
0.4138071537017822,
0.35427963733673096,
0.7821235060691833,
-0.44415050745010376,
0.45158851146698,
0.29835495352745056,
-1.1092321872711182,
0.4096064865589142,
-0.2824227511882782,
0.11232937127351761,
0.9704502820968628,
0.6904287338256836,
-0.6168195605278015,
-0.41031771898269653,
-0.6080846190452576,
-0.2870733439922333,
0.7292658090591431,
0.04109962284564972,
0.15363045036792755,
0.2391965240240097,
0.28194722533226013,
0.2262231558561325,
0.3771964907646179,
-0.8954600691795349,
-0.05092020705342293,
-0.36083489656448364,
-0.6460268497467041,
0.024055520072579384,
-0.09799572825431824,
-0.26657211780548096,
-0.26194044947624207,
0.8003911375999451,
-0.22855760157108307,
-0.07715774327516556,
0.24357935786247253,
-0.27676501870155334,
0.08342190086841583,
0.24002215266227722,
0.6503769755363464,
0.6017641425132751,
-0.16133031249046326,
0.19558468461036682,
-0.03569361940026283,
-0.09193770587444305,
0.19632889330387115,
0.02023644745349884,
-0.28009146451950073,
-0.20884770154953003,
0.470885694026947,
0.8375758528709412,
0.3522706925868988,
-0.16761545836925507,
0.6170209646224976,
-0.15302900969982147,
-0.2969287931919098,
0.06054012104868889,
0.29600539803504944,
-0.018746450543403625,
0.15405341982841492,
0.006537103094160557,
-0.1104668378829956,
-0.020735347643494606,
-0.4135853946208954,
0.2984597384929657,
0.7261945605278015,
-0.28048980236053467,
-0.5228357315063477,
0.6413892507553101,
0.3195849657058716,
0.14234966039657593,
0.14366282522678375,
-0.07403123378753662,
-0.7010670304298401,
0.23566539585590363,
0.5376374125480652,
0.5496752262115479,
-0.5514512062072754,
0.3345143496990204,
0.42981767654418945,
0.2806999683380127,
-0.48804378509521484,
0.34543704986572266,
-0.4601235091686249,
-0.9083695411682129,
-0.28934112191200256,
-0.6660219430923462,
-0.5665580630302429,
-0.1695031225681305,
-0.7598180174827576,
0.3569753170013428,
-0.5183923244476318,
-0.025002071633934975,
0.11207260191440582,
0.07926657795906067,
-0.4293765425682068,
0.13745707273483276,
-0.06551165133714676,
0.6156980395317078,
-0.8856024146080017,
0.7420957684516907,
0.38409310579299927,
-0.3819853663444519,
-0.838688850402832,
-0.11487148702144623,
-0.017580265179276466,
-0.7243297100067139,
0.45398783683776855,
-0.13515782356262207,
-0.16130663454532623,
-0.06750587373971939,
-0.8682159781455994,
-0.9929312467575073,
0.9618014097213745,
0.39992955327033997,
-0.4710107743740082,
-0.06076274439692497,
-0.3776087164878845,
0.37776726484298706,
-0.49546897411346436,
0.018841328099370003,
0.21290624141693115,
0.20700331032276154,
0.25639206171035767,
-1.0914465188980103,
-0.21493586897850037,
0.062438659369945526,
-0.29591649770736694,
0.3162197768688202,
-0.6378995180130005,
0.7930810451507568,
-0.4627552628517151,
-0.3255375325679779,
0.1264214664697647,
0.969803512096405,
0.050422102212905884,
0.24754580855369568,
0.48747992515563965,
0.5937404632568359,
0.9953213930130005,
0.15702027082443237,
0.8373294472694397,
-0.3506767749786377,
0.24590961635112762,
1.6621625423431396,
-0.3323124051094055,
0.7141790986061096,
0.35124316811561584,
0.14074406027793884,
0.5928388833999634,
0.34940391778945923,
0.3322785496711731,
0.8146028518676758,
0.11304885149002075,
-0.3224737048149109,
-0.41876253485679626,
-0.1864849179983139,
-0.39325466752052307,
0.70655357837677,
0.16922378540039062,
-0.3718092143535614,
-0.22884923219680786,
-0.2719837725162506,
0.09047118574380875,
0.5514677166938782,
-0.27376413345336914,
1.177719235420227,
-0.038405682891607285,
-0.9409870505332947,
0.640532910823822,
-0.18461868166923523,
0.770659863948822,
-0.8391547203063965,
-0.09595505148172379,
-0.2507008910179138,
0.008355941623449326,
0.029843570664525032,
-0.6893650889396667,
0.20757412910461426,
-0.09987291693687439,
-0.18562862277030945,
-0.2094799280166626,
0.5851043462753296,
-0.8220704197883606,
-0.0874723568558693,
-0.1160164400935173,
0.3633871078491211,
0.0226291436702013,
0.38796430826187134,
-0.3764694929122925,
-0.0689258798956871,
0.08424144238233566,
0.12948483228683472,
0.26850301027297974,
0.2282382994890213,
-0.07596896588802338,
0.6016303896903992,
0.5580295920372009,
0.05872950702905655,
-0.06732434034347534,
-0.26811718940734863,
1.1131829023361206,
-0.7170807123184204,
-0.49756866693496704,
-0.8079135417938232,
0.2533716559410095,
-0.21502962708473206,
-0.1906227469444275,
0.575244128704071,
0.48354771733283997,
0.9980854988098145,
0.12962128221988678,
0.7877532243728638,
0.09247364848852158,
0.39176708459854126,
-0.7451668977737427,
0.7936004400253296,
-0.2783920168876648,
0.004272374790161848,
-0.18830688297748566,
-0.7623533010482788,
-0.09350796043872833,
0.7303555607795715,
-0.27400094270706177,
-0.15966945886611938,
0.537684977054596,
0.5465736985206604,
0.01093146950006485,
0.028221366927027702,
0.2560485303401947,
-0.10239484906196594,
0.08119465410709381,
0.4408791959285736,
0.8462851643562317,
-0.11954513937234879,
0.37220385670661926,
-0.35809022188186646,
-0.20377255976200104,
0.16831959784030914,
-0.963147759437561,
-1.094237208366394,
-0.7637243270874023,
-0.12046508491039276,
-0.48882049322128296,
0.08783924579620361,
1.436115026473999,
0.6818070411682129,
-0.6153041124343872,
-0.3109833896160126,
0.18167263269424438,
0.42603734135627747,
0.0829910859465599,
-0.06004328653216362,
0.2347610741853714,
-0.5696406960487366,
-0.5697414875030518,
0.240695521235466,
-0.12660345435142517,
0.3234618008136749,
-0.0782516747713089,
-0.36874085664749146,
-0.20634378492832184,
0.061073459684848785,
0.1078038364648819,
0.5827272534370422,
-0.6304119229316711,
-0.23452338576316833,
-0.018618937581777573,
-0.436963826417923,
0.04192253574728966,
0.7127395272254944,
-0.7412042021751404,
0.6798856258392334,
0.37270301580429077,
0.7251662611961365,
0.32072263956069946,
0.44289064407348633,
0.8650320768356323,
-0.708739697933197,
-0.17876993119716644,
0.22852736711502075,
0.12494932115077972,
0.28997474908828735,
-0.13680094480514526,
0.3729715347290039,
0.1681973934173584,
-0.47902342677116394,
-0.5378127098083496,
0.21330037713050842,
-0.6982015371322632,
0.11835461109876633,
0.9314621686935425,
-0.11566710472106934,
-0.3891443908214569,
-0.017633909359574318,
-0.22873812913894653,
0.2355433851480484,
-0.4180881083011627,
0.8367611765861511,
0.6436343789100647,
-0.19518324732780457,
0.13295340538024902,
0.006528510246425867,
0.941006064414978,
0.619434654712677,
-0.622917890548706,
0.023077767342329025,
0.5943494439125061,
0.5417009592056274,
0.08920057862997055,
0.9673965573310852,
0.22618818283081055,
0.19879752397537231,
-0.2748161554336548,
0.42196163535118103,
0.07188092172145844,
-0.4173630475997925,
-0.5719655752182007,
-0.1657148152589798,
0.012648159638047218,
-0.33484306931495667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14301v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14301v1
|
Marking: Visual Grading with Highlighting Errors and Annotating Missing Bits
| 2024-04-22T16:00:46 | 2024-04-22T16:00:46 |
Shashank Sonkar, Naiming Liu, Debshila B. Mallick, Richard G. Baraniuk
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce "Marking", a novel grading task that enhances
automated grading systems by performing an in-depth analysis of student
responses and providing students with visual highlights. Unlike traditional
systems that provide binary scores, "marking" identifies and categorizes
segments of the student response as correct, incorrect, or irrelevant and
detects omissions from gold answers. We introduce a new dataset meticulously
curated by Subject Matter Experts specifically for this task. We frame
"Marking" as an extension of the Natural Language Inference (NLI) task, which
is extensively explored in the field of Natural Language Processing. The gold
answer and the student response play the roles of premise and hypothesis in
NLI, respectively. We subsequently train language models to identify
entailment, contradiction, and neutrality from student response, akin to NLI,
and with the added dimension of identifying omissions from gold answers. Our
experimental setup involves the use of transformer models, specifically BERT
and RoBERTa, and an intelligent training step using the e-SNLI dataset. We
present extensive baseline results highlighting the complexity of the "Marking"
task, which sets a clear trajectory for the upcoming study. Our work not only
opens up new avenues for research in AI-powered educational assessment tools,
but also provides a valuable benchmark for the AI in education community to
engage with and improve upon in the future. The code and dataset can be found
at https://github.com/luffycodes/marking.
|
[
-0.3374059796333313,
-0.9589606523513794,
0.20318317413330078,
0.17264588177204132,
0.030647296458482742,
0.22911004722118378,
-0.03278790041804314,
-0.5010999441146851,
0.19671626389026642,
0.6237289905548096,
-0.4363703727722168,
-0.39690664410591125,
-0.5680987238883972,
0.03751254081726074,
-0.45240920782089233,
1.3625707626342773,
-0.11618533730506897,
-0.01066962257027626,
-0.5202311873435974,
-0.27588221430778503,
-0.545688807964325,
-0.29483622312545776,
-0.738315761089325,
-0.2177882194519043,
0.5817578434944153,
0.5647478103637695,
0.4280679225921631,
1.1418159008026123,
0.7137511968612671,
0.3288724422454834,
-0.05686825141310692,
0.07999197393655777,
-0.16469693183898926,
-0.03980620950460434,
-0.04691360145807266,
-0.4029717445373535,
-0.5971285700798035,
0.15660026669502258,
0.5147110819816589,
0.9478608965873718,
0.5988134741783142,
0.37122756242752075,
0.16829870641231537,
0.6689444780349731,
-0.7904494404792786,
0.380421906709671,
-0.14139385521411896,
0.24081122875213623,
-0.151109516620636,
0.04586207494139671,
-0.6222406029701233,
-0.4846717417240143,
0.05928594619035721,
-0.6386143565177917,
0.07895564287900925,
-0.2989065647125244,
1.123541235923767,
0.4698375463485718,
-0.411875456571579,
-0.28730520606040955,
-0.6209403276443481,
0.9871818423271179,
-0.42718595266342163,
0.05006534978747368,
0.5407092571258545,
0.48537567257881165,
0.4782014787197113,
-0.845708429813385,
-0.4716236889362335,
0.051853448152542114,
-0.1271301507949829,
0.4956231117248535,
0.18347223103046417,
0.06902274489402771,
0.5012850761413574,
0.6098634600639343,
-0.33731892704963684,
-0.03141137585043907,
-0.42950013279914856,
-0.17382904887199402,
0.6219111084938049,
0.2593647837638855,
0.2588407099246979,
-0.042830776423215866,
-0.243178591132164,
-0.4146338105201721,
-0.37514668703079224,
0.272341787815094,
0.4336715638637543,
0.38245102763175964,
0.13210149109363556,
0.6068565249443054,
-0.26646360754966736,
0.8455185890197754,
-0.212362140417099,
0.1424444615840912,
0.10768276453018188,
-0.42049795389175415,
-0.2464292347431183,
0.025293946266174316,
0.48953142762184143,
0.7327070236206055,
0.3649468421936035,
0.12266156822443008,
-0.32338380813598633,
0.5018572211265564,
0.058900896459817886,
-0.6631816625595093,
-0.7241705060005188,
-0.10319355875253677,
-0.0015480059664696455,
-0.3519945442676544,
0.1518218070268631,
-0.843320369720459,
-0.535356342792511,
-0.5236521363258362,
0.8802987933158875,
-0.1404918134212494,
0.15306226909160614,
0.06187957152724266,
-0.29981815814971924,
0.18440040946006775,
0.7979533672332764,
-0.7226550579071045,
0.3831101655960083,
0.6752734780311584,
0.30249151587486267,
-0.006071966141462326,
-0.4746748208999634,
-0.7995359897613525,
-0.22982177138328552,
-0.3552166819572449,
0.706281840801239,
-0.6236358880996704,
-0.015882395207881927,
0.16836336255073547,
-0.04371211305260658,
0.015067827887833118,
-0.44515129923820496,
0.5631110072135925,
-0.38879334926605225,
0.3944271504878998,
-0.41260984539985657,
-0.9066399335861206,
-0.5164163112640381,
0.4705892503261566,
-0.7565969824790955,
1.289613127708435,
0.037432458251714706,
-0.486914724111557,
0.5793601274490356,
-0.6674046516418457,
-0.2156720608472824,
0.32059168815612793,
0.019783038645982742,
-0.48524147272109985,
-0.3812726140022278,
0.09095386415719986,
0.20862185955047607,
0.31502896547317505,
0.1636355072259903,
-0.0004052508738823235,
-0.6454248428344727,
0.14201171696186066,
-0.24639150500297546,
0.6294853091239929,
-0.2068101465702057,
-0.5148628950119019,
0.36754417419433594,
-1.0482795238494873,
0.13708814978599548,
-0.01581304334104061,
-0.45073240995407104,
-0.374385803937912,
-0.06997393071651459,
0.3267908990383148,
0.09541714191436768,
0.39223945140838623,
-0.6000604033470154,
0.09475816041231155,
-0.018633190542459488,
0.16847161948680878,
0.9441084861755371,
-0.12094184756278992,
0.5171981453895569,
-0.2780747711658478,
0.37578943371772766,
-0.19088195264339447,
0.3283989429473877,
-0.4092230498790741,
-0.6945855617523193,
-1.2877408266067505,
-0.2828958034515381,
0.5920392870903015,
0.5201414823532104,
-0.5340620279312134,
0.48618364334106445,
-0.30506524443626404,
-0.3342815339565277,
-0.6415824294090271,
0.11422149091959,
0.3790264129638672,
0.5612357258796692,
0.5665977597236633,
-0.2048671841621399,
-0.48942700028419495,
-0.5380845069885254,
-0.34778058528900146,
-0.25958776473999023,
-0.01735088974237442,
-0.001889921841211617,
0.6302044987678528,
-0.075550876557827,
1.2023800611495972,
-0.4336596131324768,
-0.6633240580558777,
-0.08484847843647003,
0.2894784212112427,
0.08140793442726135,
0.6540024876594543,
0.19805292785167694,
-0.7154145836830139,
-0.43058761954307556,
-0.041993387043476105,
-0.8962450623512268,
-0.3807092607021332,
-0.2016720473766327,
-0.213212251663208,
-0.1278230994939804,
0.4532885253429413,
0.26940831542015076,
0.7783519625663757,
0.09423817694187164,
-0.5394925475120544,
0.3849392533302307,
0.024784358218312263,
0.20508255064487457,
-0.30687952041625977,
0.04575371742248535,
0.11143893003463745,
-0.21871569752693176,
-0.6270471215248108,
0.08504217118024826,
0.16090063750743866,
0.09700950235128403,
-0.28482234477996826,
0.7749251127243042,
0.010888717137277126,
0.06353448331356049,
-0.37163564562797546,
0.08396077901124954,
0.3804300129413605,
0.643932044506073,
0.06629416346549988,
0.3859715461730957,
0.2588435113430023,
-0.2535392940044403,
0.037137992680072784,
0.25529277324676514,
-0.05694465711712837,
0.7748314142227173,
-0.530531108379364,
0.036792486906051636,
-0.0025314721278846264,
-0.0394752211868763,
-1.0905711650848389,
-0.15189415216445923,
0.36187219619750977,
-0.34210407733917236,
0.03463088348507881,
-0.5919157266616821,
-0.4824988842010498,
-0.2116294801235199,
-0.3872607946395874,
0.4072437286376953,
0.2731406092643738,
-0.5999138951301575,
0.705467164516449,
-0.07082487642765045,
0.020537346601486206,
-0.5917329788208008,
-0.660176694393158,
0.11278792470693588,
-0.13179616630077362,
-0.24937210977077484,
-0.1324278563261032,
-0.34314537048339844,
-0.20563438534736633,
0.1054726243019104,
0.04564906284213066,
-0.3684019148349762,
0.4753902852535248,
0.5970889329910278,
0.48549509048461914,
-0.1561698615550995,
-0.027123937383294106,
-0.0703052505850792,
-0.20131917297840118,
0.2565058171749115,
0.028640691190958023,
0.055168189108371735,
-0.3685714304447174,
-0.6230527758598328,
-0.3318324387073517,
0.3885033428668976,
0.4074006676673889,
-0.49968022108078003,
0.17905518412590027,
0.5572866201400757,
-0.6138722896575928,
-0.13352954387664795,
-0.4208832383155823,
-0.10746367275714874,
-0.5038408637046814,
0.3440641760826111,
-0.09119076281785965,
-0.7019913196563721,
0.32432693243026733,
0.2348565012216568,
0.4862961769104004,
0.32322490215301514,
-0.030871352180838585,
-0.21428446471691132,
1.0576598644256592,
0.8352199792861938,
0.20261934399604797,
0.7363229990005493,
-0.37160131335258484,
0.2563176155090332,
-0.6839110851287842,
-0.12468648701906204,
-0.5421507358551025,
-0.4201544523239136,
-0.44852912425994873,
-0.21586206555366516,
0.1270523965358734,
0.34237709641456604,
-0.3836768865585327,
0.0032116982620209455,
-0.7803389430046082,
0.8417034149169922,
0.9444414973258972,
0.0707411840558052,
0.35128578543663025,
-0.029678143560886383,
0.24162112176418304,
-0.3242245018482208,
-0.13756108283996582,
-0.8608561158180237,
0.9531746506690979,
0.10647677630186081,
0.41563040018081665,
-0.26903340220451355,
0.6289418935775757,
0.5578454732894897,
0.7636195421218872,
-0.7775739431381226,
0.6969416737556458,
-0.0454925000667572,
-0.435114324092865,
-0.37832921743392944,
-0.3476327359676361,
-0.7720991969108582,
0.21039220690727234,
-0.4155225157737732,
-0.5306251645088196,
-0.13260486721992493,
0.02682231180369854,
-0.09288245439529419,
0.34158217906951904,
-0.8638251423835754,
1.1411805152893066,
-0.09657352417707443,
-0.6338517069816589,
0.3508967161178589,
-0.6584509611129761,
0.025138432160019875,
0.04404487833380699,
0.20524625480175018,
-0.025357486680150032,
0.35122084617614746,
1.2343531847000122,
-0.343546599149704,
0.8858065605163574,
-0.2918691337108612,
0.09100031852722168,
0.3566654622554779,
0.12889514863491058,
0.19588413834571838,
-0.3340562582015991,
-0.1114875003695488,
-0.21732880175113678,
-0.13412249088287354,
-0.5896754264831543,
-0.6809314489364624,
0.45629096031188965,
-0.4504282772541046,
-0.1362142115831375,
-0.47766587138175964,
-0.32366931438446045,
0.12954795360565186,
0.3845101296901703,
-0.12049806118011475,
0.5154903531074524,
0.16029329597949982,
-0.40694352984428406,
0.605570375919342,
-0.10476689040660858,
0.5270014405250549,
0.35689666867256165,
-0.21619491279125214,
-0.3680398464202881,
1.4224827289581299,
0.24273750185966492,
-0.05325302109122276,
0.19440676271915436,
0.19889043271541595,
-0.32509711384773254,
-0.4845198094844818,
-0.72361159324646,
0.31359729170799255,
-1.4301578998565674,
-0.08518950641155243,
-0.6158137917518616,
-0.04008076339960098,
-0.1799531877040863,
-0.46454179286956787,
-0.07359122484922409,
-0.35749873518943787,
-0.34672388434410095,
-0.25566673278808594,
0.1834588646888733,
1.187177062034607,
0.07745949923992157,
0.29535436630249023,
-0.4829755425453186,
-0.15604940056800842,
0.7145645618438721,
0.4346373677253723,
-0.11584734171628952,
-0.37657564878463745,
-0.33104410767555237,
-0.02891327254474163,
-0.4509667456150055,
-0.43289029598236084,
0.018170280382037163,
0.3098386228084564,
0.22193603217601776,
0.28480833768844604,
0.027168184518814087,
0.8244448900222778,
-0.2985013723373413,
0.9659520387649536,
0.1524263322353363,
-1.0661107301712036,
0.77516770362854,
-0.13209566473960876,
0.15478655695915222,
0.790510356426239,
-0.09662875533103943,
-0.5011616349220276,
-0.8761531114578247,
-0.5701141357421875,
-1.09519624710083,
0.49119168519973755,
-0.026507101953029633,
-0.11506623029708862,
-0.1278943419456482,
0.15852296352386475,
-0.03497353568673134,
0.14769332110881805,
-0.9957770109176636,
-0.3146885931491852,
-0.2923174202442169,
-0.6167774796485901,
-0.08909773081541061,
-0.239669069647789,
-0.13408932089805603,
-0.24412915110588074,
0.6557936072349548,
-0.4335991442203522,
-0.17824280261993408,
0.15960362553596497,
-0.4963873624801636,
-0.02303309552371502,
0.18104781210422516,
0.5444316267967224,
0.5565763711929321,
-0.20500648021697998,
0.2059609591960907,
0.05739428848028183,
-0.4258885383605957,
-0.04581218957901001,
0.03211453929543495,
-0.2606401741504669,
0.010171561501920223,
0.6482667922973633,
0.43892765045166016,
0.07107791304588318,
-0.7745570540428162,
0.7725183963775635,
-0.22491355240345,
-0.06852439045906067,
-0.27555814385414124,
-0.038344696164131165,
-0.45095327496528625,
0.025044133886694908,
0.4341491758823395,
0.2669059932231903,
0.23767463862895966,
-0.1401987224817276,
0.28988561034202576,
-0.0593554861843586,
-0.9093488454818726,
-0.3620756268501282,
0.7178894281387329,
0.15032537281513214,
-0.2956417500972748,
0.5901235342025757,
-0.05088571086525917,
-0.664168119430542,
0.7433987259864807,
0.01758958026766777,
0.608777642250061,
0.20372655987739563,
0.23204338550567627,
0.3900071680545807,
0.3267141282558441,
0.07998861372470856,
0.22331495583057404,
-0.2981165647506714,
-0.2932215631008148,
-0.4214017987251282,
-0.5457353591918945,
-0.6543514728546143,
-0.22921934723854065,
-1.020386815071106,
0.12350630015134811,
-0.752082109451294,
-0.0009518720908090472,
0.20816810429096222,
-0.001863769837655127,
-0.499653697013855,
0.7578248977661133,
0.38030415773391724,
0.5369465351104736,
-1.3505194187164307,
0.353667289018631,
1.1213817596435547,
-0.3836503028869629,
-0.6870877742767334,
-0.37555235624313354,
-0.03163988143205643,
-0.4401182532310486,
0.83915114402771,
0.5170668363571167,
0.02768305130302906,
-0.10225753486156464,
-0.45327115058898926,
-0.33178165555000305,
0.531897246837616,
0.049953803420066833,
0.16003021597862244,
0.2889659106731415,
0.3224499523639679,
0.7850155830383301,
0.06401284784078598,
0.8157082200050354,
0.5309287309646606,
0.6116284728050232,
-0.3275906443595886,
-0.422921746969223,
-0.2287389189004898,
-0.5269166231155396,
-0.42585498094558716,
0.09480050206184387,
-0.2806990146636963,
0.6014789342880249,
0.03192410618066788,
-0.13118647038936615,
-0.02166096679866314,
0.6502965092658997,
-0.012959803454577923,
0.7225887775421143,
0.49249395728111267,
0.7904219627380371,
0.6965388059616089,
-0.6677395701408386,
0.7611045837402344,
0.2336038202047348,
0.4265545606613159,
1.0587202310562134,
-0.1453474909067154,
0.8079442381858826,
0.5808202624320984,
-0.031174179166555405,
0.5602489709854126,
0.5682995915412903,
-0.24898317456245422,
0.18954117596149445,
0.39250749349594116,
-0.1710791438817978,
-0.45618245005607605,
-0.40754345059394836,
-0.05046948790550232,
0.29949501156806946,
0.1535797119140625,
-0.20476031303405762,
-0.15669989585876465,
0.10329177975654602,
-0.1566150188446045,
0.5185890197753906,
-0.406532347202301,
0.8458445072174072,
-0.3727464973926544,
-0.7715044617652893,
0.38400721549987793,
-0.15829306840896606,
0.6630476117134094,
-0.33059707283973694,
-0.471652626991272,
-0.5810623168945312,
0.26812228560447693,
-0.43826526403427124,
-0.9653083086013794,
0.08191396296024323,
0.05897676572203636,
-0.2633212208747864,
-0.4521348476409912,
0.23400573432445526,
-0.48181504011154175,
-0.6653788089752197,
0.20776475965976715,
0.17406611144542694,
0.00002041070365521591,
0.1802230030298233,
-0.5631446838378906,
0.11846935749053955,
0.0157768614590168,
0.1666387915611267,
0.11014275997877121,
0.449859619140625,
-0.1391148716211319,
0.6862275004386902,
0.5028089284896851,
-0.18671593070030212,
0.38542360067367554,
0.2855782210826874,
0.4570067524909973,
-0.5874386429786682,
-0.6142139434814453,
-0.6329823136329651,
0.6280760765075684,
-0.16579359769821167,
-0.4071131646633148,
1.0022149085998535,
0.7506460547447205,
1.0284137725830078,
-0.06205928325653076,
0.5466452240943909,
0.224603071808815,
0.39709755778312683,
-0.15532715618610382,
0.40556567907333374,
-0.5003780722618103,
0.24059966206550598,
-0.6570715308189392,
-0.5655019879341125,
-0.685073733329773,
0.5314041376113892,
-0.3163725435733795,
-0.05270383879542351,
0.5045103430747986,
0.48842620849609375,
0.31255918741226196,
0.2142607420682907,
0.11234688758850098,
-0.38590022921562195,
0.47509846091270447,
0.5134569406509399,
1.2854245901107788,
-0.8857594132423401,
0.5815975069999695,
-0.581275224685669,
-0.25792932510375977,
-0.12752443552017212,
-0.46462321281433105,
-1.0145765542984009,
-0.3485833704471588,
-1.1464018821716309,
-0.45745590329170227,
-0.08073525130748749,
0.602408230304718,
0.4310186505317688,
-0.9422869682312012,
-0.17664669454097748,
0.02654201164841652,
0.36968520283699036,
-0.5939694046974182,
-0.3207454979419708,
0.4720773994922638,
-0.27028459310531616,
-0.9114109873771667,
0.14132320880889893,
0.2728167176246643,
0.3281794786453247,
0.1950928270816803,
0.16724015772342682,
-0.13464868068695068,
-0.234930619597435,
0.39384499192237854,
0.1718214750289917,
-0.5844190120697021,
-0.3829006552696228,
-0.12035056203603745,
-0.10385823994874954,
0.29089590907096863,
0.5583100318908691,
-0.6961119174957275,
0.6182738542556763,
0.3468671143054962,
0.6805868148803711,
0.2717215418815613,
0.05147232487797737,
0.1246589869260788,
-0.826734721660614,
-0.1676686704158783,
0.38584432005882263,
0.3117038309574127,
0.6878431439399719,
-0.18729989230632782,
0.4938690960407257,
0.35769030451774597,
-0.47621485590934753,
-0.9671042561531067,
-0.11493135243654251,
-0.8942946791648865,
-0.0038263231981545687,
0.5578616857528687,
-0.44853049516677856,
-0.3911552131175995,
-0.24575677514076233,
-0.26725566387176514,
0.09017588943243027,
-0.08940082043409348,
0.7904677391052246,
0.6821321845054626,
0.2781296372413635,
-0.05748230591416359,
-0.38814544677734375,
0.2932116687297821,
0.8089072704315186,
-0.7755639553070068,
-0.05013670399785042,
0.47284576296806335,
0.1754307895898819,
0.46210649609565735,
0.3782746195793152,
0.011812657117843628,
0.5112541913986206,
-0.07523252069950104,
0.18528708815574646,
-0.05833982303738594,
-0.4304940402507782,
-0.6475574970245361,
0.2949126064777374,
-0.11484228074550629,
-0.45218127965927124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14294v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14294v2
|
A Survey on Efficient Inference for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-22T15:53:08 | 2024-06-08T04:49:51 |
Zixuan Zhou, Xuefei Ning, Ke Hong, Tianyu Fu, Jiaming Xu, Shiyao Li, Yuming Lou, Luning Wang, Zhihang Yuan, Xiuhong Li, Shengen Yan, Guohao Dai, Xiao-Ping Zhang, Yuhan Dong, Yu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have attracted extensive attention due to their
remarkable performance across various tasks. However, the substantial
computational and memory requirements of LLM inference pose challenges for
deployment in resource-constrained scenarios. Efforts within the field have
been directed towards developing techniques aimed at enhancing the efficiency
of LLM inference. This paper presents a comprehensive survey of the existing
literature on efficient LLM inference. We start by analyzing the primary causes
of the inefficient LLM inference, i.e., the large model size, the
quadratic-complexity attention operation, and the auto-regressive decoding
approach. Then, we introduce a comprehensive taxonomy that organizes the
current literature into data-level, model-level, and system-level optimization.
Moreover, the paper includes comparative experiments on representative methods
within critical sub-fields to provide quantitative insights. Last but not
least, we provide some knowledge summary and discuss future research
directions.
|
[
-0.24561242759227753,
-0.8810548186302185,
0.8105533123016357,
0.32159650325775146,
0.020431647077202797,
0.10871822386980057,
-0.46043166518211365,
-0.442753404378891,
-0.22423245012760162,
0.4310499429702759,
-0.3258625268936157,
-0.4524819254875183,
-0.5082116723060608,
0.09420598298311234,
-0.49177467823028564,
0.3385213017463684,
0.15309038758277893,
0.008996635675430298,
-0.19215700030326843,
-0.0972650945186615,
-0.015397686511278152,
-0.6395821571350098,
-0.6734352111816406,
-0.3140825033187866,
0.41081827878952026,
0.15508721768856049,
0.35605576634407043,
0.6858561635017395,
0.4936429262161255,
0.3311002254486084,
-0.3794311583042145,
0.4256095588207245,
-0.6225605607032776,
0.27695804834365845,
-0.0746769830584526,
-0.5006480813026428,
-0.2841433882713318,
-0.2545296847820282,
1.0126620531082153,
0.8262051939964294,
-0.2241128385066986,
0.19091559946537018,
0.06451218575239182,
0.47966790199279785,
-1.04513418674469,
0.1887742429971695,
-0.7151955962181091,
-0.0550602450966835,
-0.15241004526615143,
0.06422068923711777,
-0.6149902939796448,
-0.32423922419548035,
0.0723380297422409,
-0.5319304466247559,
0.11627456545829773,
0.2610143721103668,
0.4579285681247711,
0.44688472151756287,
-0.46478259563446045,
-0.20594385266304016,
-0.9035747051239014,
1.1915779113769531,
-0.8543528914451599,
0.6072561144828796,
0.3470011055469513,
0.011533834971487522,
-0.2704646587371826,
-0.536021888256073,
-0.430693656206131,
-0.2006431221961975,
-0.037267204374074936,
-0.03579714894294739,
-0.4900204837322235,
0.37492358684539795,
0.36069923639297485,
0.4284098446369171,
-0.38472992181777954,
0.4801996350288391,
0.23766985535621643,
-0.11533226072788239,
0.516444742679596,
0.24233564734458923,
0.07153159379959106,
0.06837673485279083,
-0.0488089844584465,
0.16269636154174805,
-0.657103955745697,
-0.3715440332889557,
0.26925286650657654,
-0.10528367012739182,
0.11201626807451248,
0.45592349767684937,
-0.19474947452545166,
0.9254591464996338,
-0.27140799164772034,
-0.3344900608062744,
-0.07957298308610916,
-0.5059110522270203,
-0.3544178903102875,
-0.44114312529563904,
0.7868478894233704,
0.20613528788089752,
0.21228379011154175,
-0.3534485697746277,
-0.3991527557373047,
-0.2066069096326828,
-0.018373742699623108,
-0.6671649813652039,
-0.12111914902925491,
0.12802010774612427,
-0.49610084295272827,
0.03315719962120056,
-0.44596385955810547,
-0.7035067081451416,
-0.31496354937553406,
-0.18366242945194244,
0.14368849992752075,
-0.30820444226264954,
-0.23305682837963104,
0.08327095955610275,
0.0749974325299263,
0.4096255600452423,
0.2381080985069275,
-0.9426289200782776,
0.15608209371566772,
0.8305607438087463,
0.8018441796302795,
-0.1989755779504776,
0.043522339314222336,
-0.42608174681663513,
0.14624318480491638,
-0.37806379795074463,
0.7460322380065918,
-0.4267515242099762,
-0.1298481971025467,
0.05208251625299454,
-0.11051655560731888,
-0.19576749205589294,
-0.6542930603027344,
0.5509331226348877,
-0.7843260169029236,
-0.18855680525302887,
-0.13162103295326233,
-0.7007792592048645,
-0.23817729949951172,
0.07907163351774216,
-0.6734058260917664,
0.900734543800354,
0.023230593651533127,
-0.6284396052360535,
0.0774209126830101,
-0.2656900882720947,
-0.39690130949020386,
-0.12963998317718506,
-0.011541093699634075,
-0.3158618211746216,
0.47326183319091797,
0.20212140679359436,
0.5147372484207153,
-0.8157386779785156,
0.30324918031692505,
-0.4351342022418976,
-0.2140539586544037,
0.22388416528701782,
-0.535679280757904,
0.813078761100769,
0.5469298362731934,
-0.1896222084760666,
-0.12190999835729599,
-0.6272668242454529,
-0.05011603236198425,
0.17006978392601013,
-0.3553665280342102,
-0.4626545011997223,
0.20745569467544556,
-0.20348714292049408,
-0.3471445143222809,
0.18563951551914215,
-0.31067314743995667,
0.1522749662399292,
-0.3019181489944458,
0.4663647413253784,
0.4233807623386383,
-0.02881457284092903,
0.5713209509849548,
0.1529034674167633,
0.6435867547988892,
-0.32011690735816956,
0.14772365987300873,
-0.2155420333147049,
0.05708491429686546,
-0.7316417098045349,
-0.5988960862159729,
0.3544267416000366,
0.43816816806793213,
-0.5035519599914551,
0.2731482982635498,
-0.02487870678305626,
-0.32927972078323364,
-0.5433209538459778,
0.30063027143478394,
0.5229450464248657,
0.24955938756465912,
0.14726881682872772,
0.21754102408885956,
-0.35926932096481323,
-1.0676920413970947,
-0.2938506603240967,
-0.1290203332901001,
0.17082159221172333,
0.41875118017196655,
0.1711190640926361,
-0.16631151735782623,
0.5520605444908142,
-0.5071566104888916,
0.29650044441223145,
-0.5836985111236572,
-0.11612390726804733,
0.29718661308288574,
0.17324647307395935,
0.6229451298713684,
-0.4069153666496277,
-0.4458518624305725,
-0.14179998636245728,
-0.5933794975280762,
-0.4893404245376587,
-0.15074211359024048,
-0.13477276265621185,
0.3798831105232239,
0.8039950728416443,
-0.7079667448997498,
-0.058394547551870346,
0.7259559631347656,
-0.017958516255021095,
0.41171228885650635,
-0.3088769018650055,
-0.06648646295070648,
-0.6210928559303284,
0.09468334913253784,
0.26136472821235657,
-0.3012799918651581,
-0.6779049634933472,
0.3806753158569336,
0.18956275284290314,
0.27291339635849,
0.045288439840078354,
0.5434419512748718,
-1.023372769355774,
-0.14073358476161957,
-0.262633353471756,
0.1274130791425705,
-0.15023012459278107,
0.301857054233551,
0.02906583808362484,
0.7986506819725037,
0.3888136148452759,
-0.4439910650253296,
0.2864736318588257,
-0.12979353964328766,
-0.5676533579826355,
0.0036749106366187334,
-0.5232778787612915,
-0.046058349311351776,
-0.22276553511619568,
0.198292076587677,
-1.1633079051971436,
-0.17667679488658905,
0.1268334686756134,
0.0463448129594326,
0.5642154812812805,
-0.054145410656929016,
-0.7833267450332642,
-0.2687477469444275,
-0.10753591358661652,
0.5058860182762146,
0.5892941951751709,
-0.5842804908752441,
0.562981128692627,
0.6359683275222778,
-0.015347447246313095,
-0.6193211078643799,
-0.49282577633857727,
0.11408156156539917,
-0.44940197467803955,
-0.3222917318344116,
-0.0515231192111969,
0.08239223808050156,
-0.610902726650238,
-0.20920664072036743,
-0.04996170103549957,
-0.01789066009223461,
0.3416982889175415,
-0.2389519065618515,
0.029414279386401176,
-0.3267894387245178,
0.3339402675628662,
-0.11091766506433487,
0.04905952513217926,
0.22450858354568481,
-0.19410179555416107,
0.5034745931625366,
0.0019262791611254215,
-0.2844797968864441,
-0.3521616756916046,
0.4729549288749695,
0.5598865151405334,
-0.27943238615989685,
0.695467472076416,
0.3000708818435669,
-0.09295277297496796,
-0.482234388589859,
-1.0224307775497437,
-0.14955423772335052,
-0.36751145124435425,
0.5828381776809692,
-0.15355324745178223,
-0.8217737078666687,
0.4723295271396637,
-0.2602119743824005,
0.18584133684635162,
0.3649430572986603,
0.6852583289146423,
0.09909901767969131,
1.0171462297439575,
0.5813272595405579,
-0.2798651456832886,
0.5253136157989502,
-0.34146231412887573,
0.3571488857269287,
-0.7215923070907593,
-0.09756690263748169,
-0.6297135949134827,
-0.01687619276344776,
-0.44111406803131104,
-0.6275132894515991,
0.16262100636959076,
0.18300767242908478,
-0.11292226612567902,
0.017800182104110718,
-0.17235594987869263,
0.4063575863838196,
0.43955329060554504,
-0.09059462696313858,
0.5808387994766235,
0.07008406519889832,
0.07615747302770615,
0.1787223219871521,
-1.0265614986419678,
-0.4164799749851227,
0.8536934852600098,
0.5327837467193604,
0.9503776431083679,
0.2471199929714203,
0.4176401197910309,
-0.04904051870107651,
0.34077540040016174,
-0.9183291792869568,
0.5486778020858765,
-0.19544410705566406,
-0.7028716206550598,
-0.41960740089416504,
-0.5883957147598267,
-0.8380860686302185,
0.39145034551620483,
-0.06815223395824432,
-0.6403438448905945,
0.07420800626277924,
0.39856022596359253,
-0.3833408057689667,
0.23580148816108704,
-0.7607783675193787,
0.6227412223815918,
-0.22343337535858154,
-0.4759555459022522,
-0.4703456163406372,
-0.43919190764427185,
0.6307957172393799,
-0.3930526375770569,
0.21148177981376648,
-0.19217027723789215,
-0.26289865374565125,
0.39891812205314636,
-0.31079792976379395,
0.6715174913406372,
-0.14667043089866638,
-0.320254921913147,
0.30639705061912537,
-0.18950155377388,
0.6085155606269836,
-0.09938988834619522,
-0.3923206329345703,
0.16170388460159302,
-0.06172008067369461,
-0.2759515941143036,
-0.5935036540031433,
0.6431136131286621,
-0.5504035949707031,
-0.6520639061927795,
-0.20548954606056213,
-0.7055178284645081,
-0.48525890707969666,
0.009729566052556038,
0.11629125475883484,
0.34263935685157776,
-0.0350714810192585,
0.3176637589931488,
0.9268218874931335,
-0.5129509568214417,
0.5488885641098022,
0.5076737403869629,
-0.13812367618083954,
-0.09819725155830383,
0.6360933780670166,
0.21328483521938324,
0.42913058400154114,
0.43925559520721436,
0.1074715107679367,
-0.4215504825115204,
-1.0383509397506714,
-0.2437974363565445,
0.6081196069717407,
-0.48437249660491943,
-0.2069072127342224,
-0.8374244570732117,
-0.08612433075904846,
-0.3181706964969635,
0.2214154452085495,
-0.33737388253211975,
-0.24887922406196594,
-0.346466064453125,
0.08633827418088913,
0.3019186556339264,
0.5582886934280396,
0.021790742874145508,
0.5638558864593506,
-0.6318341493606567,
0.34679484367370605,
-0.011531777679920197,
0.19313423335552216,
0.4682219624519348,
-0.4883124530315399,
-0.34581488370895386,
-0.2901724576950073,
0.014584067277610302,
-0.6167656779289246,
0.33845269680023193,
0.3284738063812256,
0.9102721214294434,
0.4306490421295166,
0.05985920503735542,
0.6055318713188171,
-0.34578967094421387,
0.4797540307044983,
0.018969256430864334,
-0.6704506874084473,
0.06747271865606308,
-0.2843802273273468,
0.381409227848053,
0.2831162214279175,
0.4495132565498352,
-0.30824536085128784,
-0.4972512423992157,
-0.25608229637145996,
-1.0267536640167236,
0.48006030917167664,
-0.05774422734975815,
0.16088034212589264,
-0.13742849230766296,
0.5582471489906311,
-0.0876898318529129,
0.008021796122193336,
-0.3943965435028076,
-0.1587122678756714,
0.5589185953140259,
-0.2471587359905243,
-0.27232852578163147,
-0.5827293395996094,
0.1822964996099472,
-0.23241500556468964,
0.6179382801055908,
-0.10127609968185425,
0.01653401367366314,
0.052138376981019974,
-0.4084550142288208,
0.16606612503528595,
0.1546548455953598,
0.4457440674304962,
0.6426680088043213,
0.08050986379384995,
0.20458312332630157,
0.4176681935787201,
-0.15976105630397797,
0.19531776010990143,
-0.062147051095962524,
-0.07789818942546844,
-0.10662531852722168,
0.6591315269470215,
0.6514571905136108,
0.2186126857995987,
-0.7892654538154602,
0.30587685108184814,
-0.10267720371484756,
-0.0677013024687767,
-0.38120537996292114,
0.14655858278274536,
0.4314253628253937,
0.5984715819358826,
0.396407812833786,
-0.6428835988044739,
0.2584562599658966,
-0.48219624161720276,
-0.22401033341884613,
0.7816115617752075,
0.11025071889162064,
-0.028032217174768448,
0.5009472370147705,
0.12076769769191742,
-0.0077090151607990265,
0.6309564709663391,
-0.11023426800966263,
-0.3037852346897125,
0.4530131220817566,
0.5268402695655823,
0.7079519629478455,
-0.16754619777202606,
-0.23021863400936127,
0.3594170808792114,
0.1864103376865387,
-0.3100137412548065,
0.1827276051044464,
-0.2377420961856842,
-0.641011655330658,
-0.911104142665863,
-0.8009074926376343,
-0.2854350805282593,
0.35674992203712463,
-0.4051031470298767,
-0.18309840559959412,
-0.3776044547557831,
-0.30680280923843384,
-0.06044519320130348,
-0.020926566794514656,
-0.4599955379962921,
-0.16283026337623596,
0.21558493375778198,
1.0335533618927002,
-0.5698477625846863,
0.6712948083877563,
0.3999941647052765,
0.20248165726661682,
-0.7035943865776062,
-0.061801161617040634,
-0.073857381939888,
-0.8464511036872864,
0.6952436566352844,
-0.2725883424282074,
-0.4667845666408539,
0.2046598494052887,
-0.48023274540901184,
-0.8767961263656616,
0.6742502450942993,
0.6186602115631104,
-0.8997001051902771,
-0.1252671182155609,
-0.15283238887786865,
0.494302898645401,
-0.22219577431678772,
0.372099369764328,
0.9563510417938232,
0.44159838557243347,
-0.1550064980983734,
-0.7379649877548218,
-0.0027500572614371777,
0.07707617431879044,
0.23861947655677795,
0.28343772888183594,
-0.906532883644104,
0.4000367820262909,
-0.18697750568389893,
-0.13483290374279022,
0.2093680053949356,
0.7615892887115479,
0.24304285645484924,
0.10604236274957657,
0.6562511324882507,
0.4576042592525482,
0.6910830140113831,
0.08422178030014038,
1.0380334854125977,
-0.5144298076629639,
0.41186606884002686,
0.8990070223808289,
-0.21697711944580078,
0.7100197672843933,
0.5318256616592407,
-0.2088657021522522,
0.042509112507104874,
0.6781805157661438,
-0.0368465818464756,
0.3297117352485657,
0.4396822452545166,
-0.5482348799705505,
-0.599942147731781,
-0.13862167298793793,
-0.016160588711500168,
0.6419456005096436,
0.4441613256931305,
-0.5747812986373901,
-0.30922600626945496,
-0.20298486948013306,
0.05470326542854309,
-0.14879688620567322,
-0.2598390579223633,
0.8863792419433594,
0.2583836317062378,
-0.644518256187439,
0.5821759700775146,
-0.05901108682155609,
0.5952262282371521,
-0.4098159372806549,
0.07723303139209747,
-0.3337607979774475,
0.31903254985809326,
-0.03572218120098114,
-0.470998078584671,
0.11805301904678345,
0.07769786566495895,
-0.2254635989665985,
-0.21558183431625366,
0.6042964458465576,
-0.34991636872291565,
-0.3265461027622223,
0.4043758809566498,
0.6222798824310303,
0.2959514558315277,
-0.05168382078409195,
-0.4138087034225464,
0.3355150520801544,
-0.060204215347766876,
-0.6268316507339478,
0.2253381609916687,
0.5987157225608826,
0.02586752362549305,
0.8719070553779602,
0.36771145462989807,
0.35506802797317505,
0.11926873028278351,
0.17365477979183197,
0.6341817378997803,
-0.665940523147583,
-0.08703950047492981,
-1.0334032773971558,
0.11881671845912933,
-0.08589348942041397,
-0.0008823394891805947,
0.8854487538337708,
0.5734622478485107,
0.43318885564804077,
-0.005032129120081663,
0.8363642692565918,
0.35372716188430786,
0.6163913607597351,
-0.6058288812637329,
0.6128051280975342,
-0.6435739994049072,
0.3608115315437317,
-0.04274887219071388,
-0.975975513458252,
-0.4044857323169708,
0.5359082818031311,
-0.35920581221580505,
0.013409214094281197,
0.4445445239543915,
0.8249817490577698,
-0.14276617765426636,
-0.23259525001049042,
0.3568100035190582,
0.39118635654449463,
0.18733809888362885,
0.5155534148216248,
0.908677339553833,
0.08923979103565216,
0.4626881778240204,
-0.12576831877231598,
-0.3491915762424469,
-0.49148479104042053,
-1.03233802318573,
-0.725442111492157,
-0.3266617953777313,
-0.2741466462612152,
-0.1221742331981659,
0.1231130063533783,
0.8042788505554199,
0.690176248550415,
-0.6495802402496338,
-0.3856961131095886,
0.04696250334382057,
0.16135510802268982,
0.17062097787857056,
-0.10464069247245789,
0.35482844710350037,
-0.5468809604644775,
-0.9736477136611938,
0.3357865810394287,
0.20927149057388306,
-0.18371036648750305,
-0.4170709550380707,
0.17961128056049347,
-0.1184755265712738,
0.11694768071174622,
0.9210163354873657,
0.3884601593017578,
-0.7046180963516235,
-0.08784535527229309,
0.11837887763977051,
-0.1763533651828766,
-0.2518889605998993,
0.9225098490715027,
-0.3698793053627014,
0.05909264087677002,
0.7490512132644653,
0.9603884816169739,
0.5158889889717102,
0.0143819535151124,
0.7724941968917847,
-0.2706729769706726,
-0.10878505557775497,
0.189906507730484,
0.46762457489967346,
0.24909305572509766,
-0.22566604614257812,
0.46897152066230774,
0.11064805090427399,
-0.7177685499191284,
-0.989666223526001,
0.22608518600463867,
-0.7476320862770081,
-0.40126273036003113,
1.4537431001663208,
-0.1694048047065735,
-0.33690327405929565,
-0.1282162070274353,
0.05071275681257248,
0.3048914968967438,
-0.19599765539169312,
0.6069603562355042,
0.7677720785140991,
-0.2982689440250397,
-0.43295201659202576,
-0.8250856995582581,
0.3170466125011444,
0.5378413200378418,
-0.7826901078224182,
0.5639131665229797,
0.6686021685600281,
0.17354413866996765,
-0.25165119767189026,
0.39898765087127686,
0.06481605768203735,
-0.13462650775909424,
-0.14312191307544708,
-0.0574708953499794,
0.20167900621891022,
-0.24248799681663513,
-0.5302732586860657,
0.16534721851348877,
0.4534253776073456,
0.264192134141922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14270v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14270v1
|
What do Transformers Know about Government?
| 2024-04-22T15:15:50 | 2024-04-22T15:15:50 |
Jue Hou, Anisia Katinskaia, Lari Kotilainen, Sathianpong Trangcasanchai, Anh-Duc Vu, Roman Yangarber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper investigates what insights about linguistic features and what
knowledge about the structure of natural language can be obtained from the
encodings in transformer language models.In particular, we explore how BERT
encodes the government relation between constituents in a sentence. We use
several probing classifiers, and data from two morphologically rich languages.
Our experiments show that information about government is encoded across all
transformer layers, but predominantly in the early layers of the model. We find
that, for both languages, a small number of attention heads encode enough
information about the government relations to enable us to train a classifier
capable of discovering new, previously unknown types of government, never seen
in the training data. Currently, data is lacking for the research community
working on grammatical constructions, and government in particular. We release
the Government Bank -- a dataset defining the government relations for
thousands of lemmas in the languages in our experiments.
|
[
-0.47513681650161743,
-0.5770753622055054,
0.7133258581161499,
-0.21386714279651642,
0.05530255660414696,
0.008861206471920013,
-0.36266735196113586,
-0.2679881155490875,
0.15407243371009827,
0.8218488693237305,
-0.27852463722229004,
-0.11027900129556656,
-0.751447319984436,
-0.15094001591205597,
-0.6023245453834534,
0.9689815640449524,
0.482464998960495,
0.04173329845070839,
-0.02034473419189453,
0.20549161732196808,
0.27487659454345703,
-0.8975335359573364,
-0.09717448800802231,
-0.4803747832775116,
0.5311493873596191,
0.06763043254613876,
1.0416936874389648,
0.6204332113265991,
0.4071977138519287,
0.2932462990283966,
-0.20894283056259155,
-0.20500899851322174,
-0.46557340025901794,
-0.3806546926498413,
-0.28438398241996765,
-0.8742719292640686,
0.051908887922763824,
-0.16586874425411224,
0.684808075428009,
0.6360294818878174,
-0.06412146240472794,
0.25379371643066406,
-0.02558303438127041,
0.759904146194458,
-0.4982999861240387,
0.9117034673690796,
-0.7584904432296753,
-0.07700368762016296,
-0.35800087451934814,
0.06645376980304718,
-0.5652543306350708,
-0.4953981041908264,
0.37356019020080566,
-0.11727072298526764,
0.47141918540000916,
-0.15566681325435638,
1.0977897644042969,
0.3531992733478546,
-0.535271406173706,
-0.301827996969223,
-0.776058554649353,
0.4419739842414856,
-0.3134569823741913,
0.7978311777114868,
0.4810452163219452,
0.5131688714027405,
-0.1592068374156952,
-0.7397258281707764,
-0.5275319218635559,
-0.0158318430185318,
-0.7267283797264099,
0.015844497829675674,
-0.18339581787586212,
0.18506436049938202,
0.034921795129776,
0.6440895199775696,
-0.2941135764122009,
-0.30106428265571594,
-0.39928293228149414,
-0.3333229124546051,
0.4166038930416107,
-0.3304295241832733,
0.04836011677980423,
-0.826885461807251,
-0.12789343297481537,
-0.43898987770080566,
-0.5973725914955139,
0.4461662471294403,
0.5474385023117065,
0.41806626319885254,
-0.09836060553789139,
0.6082638502120972,
0.546061098575592,
0.4424717426300049,
-0.03130998834967613,
0.35019949078559875,
0.060611456632614136,
-0.005801450926810503,
-0.525399923324585,
0.03177579119801521,
0.7089397311210632,
-0.38955894112586975,
0.5980056524276733,
-0.6237737536430359,
-0.24846886098384857,
0.08376070857048035,
0.6043440103530884,
-0.3698875904083252,
-0.1727316528558731,
-0.1024436429142952,
-0.48910510540008545,
-0.10563141107559204,
0.5850188136100769,
-0.4506724774837494,
-0.02608324959874153,
-0.4064318537712097,
0.29896804690361023,
-0.4534763991832733,
-0.3643205761909485,
-0.02986080013215542,
-0.32704171538352966,
0.7460974454879761,
-0.13388614356517792,
-1.526738166809082,
0.4286920130252838,
0.9964507222175598,
0.25270316004753113,
0.39593589305877686,
-0.07017360627651215,
-0.17703217267990112,
0.14278894662857056,
-0.1614827811717987,
0.6671520471572876,
-0.7103075385093689,
-0.1016700491309166,
0.30147090554237366,
0.24191969633102417,
-0.17182661592960358,
-0.4262646436691284,
0.274274617433548,
-0.44936612248420715,
0.3074232041835785,
-0.17749476432800293,
-0.5568519830703735,
-0.028195573017001152,
-0.006988570559769869,
-0.946009635925293,
0.8616894483566284,
0.47142478823661804,
-0.6428820490837097,
0.5056714415550232,
-0.6281245946884155,
-0.379780113697052,
-0.14025655388832092,
-0.5290386080741882,
-0.2682947814464569,
0.7626459002494812,
0.3462328612804413,
0.35930028557777405,
0.015190842561423779,
0.6276929974555969,
0.28977516293525696,
-0.008058191277086735,
0.36156103014945984,
-0.01583295501768589,
0.8116182088851929,
0.06774543225765228,
-0.0074760643765330315,
-0.0600639209151268,
-0.7283844351768494,
-0.24134397506713867,
-0.029524795711040497,
-0.46527427434921265,
-0.10692121833562851,
0.23320145905017853,
0.009200154803693295,
-0.18948327004909515,
0.209972083568573,
-0.6276716589927673,
0.39201101660728455,
-0.3135228455066681,
0.7581968307495117,
0.7126244902610779,
-0.04398767277598381,
0.6080310344696045,
0.0014204218750819564,
0.11755524575710297,
-0.044815048575401306,
0.26286351680755615,
-0.1568729281425476,
-0.48869991302490234,
-0.9178367853164673,
0.1573067605495453,
0.6009084582328796,
0.4567737579345703,
-0.4031893014907837,
0.609982430934906,
-0.3272382616996765,
-0.23929236829280853,
-0.8539106845855713,
-0.37013429403305054,
0.06455457210540771,
0.12995462119579315,
0.19657978415489197,
-0.04091901704668999,
-0.5389623045921326,
-1.4408961534500122,
-0.37202608585357666,
-0.40161243081092834,
-0.3907071352005005,
0.28444185853004456,
0.7250656485557556,
-0.13043344020843506,
1.3172111511230469,
-0.4203540086746216,
-0.14915552735328674,
-0.40150365233421326,
0.24308940768241882,
0.34742459654808044,
0.1056964173913002,
0.7423303723335266,
-0.6795198321342468,
0.07191894203424454,
0.13026529550552368,
-0.36536407470703125,
0.3968915343284607,
-0.24435390532016754,
-0.10464970767498016,
-0.24710415303707123,
0.23351949453353882,
-0.6004594564437866,
0.18759532272815704,
0.4640187919139862,
-0.22231139242649078,
-0.08339263498783112,
-0.187734916806221,
-0.21462255716323853,
-0.985983669757843,
-0.22602735459804535,
-0.38597479462623596,
-0.25385722517967224,
-0.8532857298851013,
0.05267004296183586,
0.3641481101512909,
-0.07596666365861893,
-0.30601373314857483,
0.052179135382175446,
-0.39821258187294006,
-0.27701839804649353,
0.25750359892845154,
-0.18678733706474304,
-0.2524825930595398,
0.7261312007904053,
0.14642885327339172,
0.6997455358505249,
0.6460127234458923,
-0.2830229103565216,
0.08197395503520966,
0.5724257230758667,
-0.5078100562095642,
0.13643087446689606,
-0.30505380034446716,
0.18975916504859924,
-0.7053963541984558,
-0.045506592839956284,
-0.7424728274345398,
-0.5517590045928955,
-0.23537810146808624,
-0.5330834984779358,
0.3274565637111664,
-0.31437018513679504,
-0.7766095995903015,
-0.41911718249320984,
0.15590615570545197,
-0.27018630504608154,
0.6912088990211487,
-0.44748473167419434,
0.8521620035171509,
0.7200823426246643,
0.16851872205734253,
-0.43415045738220215,
-1.2812796831130981,
-0.03101758286356926,
0.20307184755802155,
-0.5404514670372009,
0.15762633085250854,
0.6040210723876953,
-0.13017256557941437,
0.40703245997428894,
-0.0767972469329834,
-0.5339550375938416,
0.03064076043665409,
0.20299877226352692,
-0.12787558138370514,
-0.45280343294143677,
0.306687593460083,
-0.06300262361764908,
0.11162196844816208,
0.5945946574211121,
-0.10307511687278748,
0.42011499404907227,
-0.046327244490385056,
-0.027921345084905624,
-0.1411443054676056,
0.18348398804664612,
0.6926916837692261,
-0.2998862862586975,
0.9713258147239685,
0.23872441053390503,
-0.4973333775997162,
-0.22739148139953613,
-0.5174366235733032,
-0.12233597040176392,
-0.46706852316856384,
0.17749276757240295,
-0.40936505794525146,
-0.8104177713394165,
0.6080061197280884,
0.22864046692848206,
0.031260982155799866,
0.5018464922904968,
0.33084648847579956,
0.20036081969738007,
0.5077465772628784,
0.9181053042411804,
-0.5027762651443481,
0.5687263607978821,
-0.32845643162727356,
0.32706308364868164,
-0.40241196751594543,
-0.5793600678443909,
-0.7403870224952698,
-0.122117780148983,
-0.8016594052314758,
-0.05944167450070381,
0.18446442484855652,
-0.13624505698680878,
-0.25935009121894836,
0.9168492555618286,
-0.36249372363090515,
0.5281563401222229,
0.583514928817749,
0.15057750046253204,
-0.10101494938135147,
-0.08394189178943634,
0.18607482314109802,
-0.009009525179862976,
-0.5810338258743286,
-0.5424488186836243,
0.8089859485626221,
0.5837455987930298,
0.8909804821014404,
0.11919502168893814,
0.7973342537879944,
0.23198580741882324,
0.07442101091146469,
-0.77419513463974,
0.2574608623981476,
-0.27933135628700256,
-0.6520738005638123,
-0.07813069969415665,
-0.449013888835907,
-0.8824005722999573,
-0.0022752208169549704,
-0.13938671350479126,
-0.5507729649543762,
0.3987761437892914,
-0.18919101357460022,
-0.15727166831493378,
0.3480706810951233,
-0.9227122068405151,
0.799927294254303,
-0.33054620027542114,
0.2811402678489685,
-0.20507563650608063,
-0.8596451282501221,
0.14948958158493042,
0.13335978984832764,
0.10070903599262238,
0.2927650213241577,
0.30493712425231934,
0.5529995560646057,
-0.10394695401191711,
0.6610339283943176,
0.02311292476952076,
-0.4433876872062683,
0.13913071155548096,
-0.3560127019882202,
0.27940985560417175,
-0.005275629926472902,
-0.007440545596182346,
0.0745103657245636,
-0.3283160328865051,
-0.225333571434021,
-0.7743132710456848,
0.2759639024734497,
-1.0911555290222168,
-0.45584726333618164,
-0.21870511770248413,
-0.58491450548172,
-0.06287778913974762,
0.10371819138526917,
0.2083420753479004,
0.4480682909488678,
-0.35208746790885925,
0.46755367517471313,
0.5468093156814575,
-0.06576691567897797,
0.48416292667388916,
0.21016210317611694,
-0.030899038538336754,
-0.22707325220108032,
0.5066284537315369,
0.2772485911846161,
0.26959165930747986,
0.946164071559906,
0.0794222429394722,
-0.48371005058288574,
-0.09860147535800934,
-0.163143590092659,
0.2194906622171402,
-0.6334311962127686,
-0.06099491938948631,
-0.5975203514099121,
-0.7968323826789856,
-0.46278682351112366,
0.1596052497625351,
-0.3546990156173706,
-0.5357992649078369,
-0.1424640566110611,
-0.17810773849487305,
0.23067788779735565,
1.5031507015228271,
0.04770472273230553,
0.3624173104763031,
-0.6250372529029846,
0.5116668343544006,
0.4202038049697876,
0.47514262795448303,
-0.23749132454395294,
-0.16810092329978943,
-0.22794292867183685,
-0.06492570787668228,
-0.04651116952300072,
-0.9586107134819031,
0.12025850266218185,
0.3079305589199066,
0.7237878441810608,
0.4829627573490143,
-0.13254784047603607,
0.460539847612381,
-0.6689693331718445,
0.9274623394012451,
-0.23425772786140442,
-1.080712914466858,
0.6582515239715576,
-0.04401334002614021,
0.18521717190742493,
0.2643178701400757,
0.19997315108776093,
-0.2727292478084564,
-1.016315221786499,
-0.822237491607666,
-0.4530670940876007,
0.9037518501281738,
0.5908138155937195,
0.5626338720321655,
-0.24086901545524597,
0.38705992698669434,
0.10896216332912445,
0.3783758282661438,
-0.8773593306541443,
-0.3317032754421234,
-0.5583086609840393,
-0.05392790213227272,
0.06618446111679077,
-0.399791419506073,
-0.0017056558281183243,
-0.1800447553396225,
0.04744510352611542,
0.25112929940223694,
0.5996779203414917,
0.14125768840312958,
-0.41751715540885925,
-0.05148493871092796,
0.8347132205963135,
0.4403769075870514,
0.6126047372817993,
-0.34770214557647705,
0.5060022473335266,
-0.153024360537529,
-0.5590634942054749,
-0.025048498064279556,
-0.026378806680440903,
0.026164859533309937,
0.23820427060127258,
0.5960108637809753,
0.9799913763999939,
0.24002370238304138,
-0.09514530748128891,
0.3464578092098236,
-0.03938155993819237,
-0.3144254684448242,
-0.36053091287612915,
0.05568395182490349,
0.014785652048885822,
0.26023298501968384,
0.6970873475074768,
0.03618280589580536,
-0.12238584458827972,
-1.137365460395813,
0.4937993288040161,
0.39715343713760376,
-0.1804341971874237,
-0.6679414510726929,
0.5861789584159851,
0.07121981680393219,
-0.3735933005809784,
0.5695567727088928,
0.031497158110141754,
-0.8542299270629883,
0.5609415769577026,
0.5133461356163025,
0.8491813540458679,
-0.18988430500030518,
0.2774610221385956,
0.3359849452972412,
0.7861427664756775,
0.08259236067533493,
0.19324542582035065,
-0.11068432778120041,
-0.5579060912132263,
-0.42750468850135803,
-0.5858635902404785,
-0.4250047206878662,
0.5269910097122192,
-0.9264056086540222,
0.16594348847866058,
-0.5332013368606567,
-0.20637507736682892,
0.011192108504474163,
-0.20128870010375977,
-0.7179262638092041,
-0.06680665165185928,
0.44967448711395264,
0.9310277700424194,
-0.8972323536872864,
0.8895043730735779,
0.2336583286523819,
-0.36965057253837585,
-0.7890469431877136,
0.03205843269824982,
-0.47696298360824585,
-0.952365517616272,
0.8002505898475647,
0.2986695468425751,
0.17789992690086365,
-0.12366464734077454,
-0.39063698053359985,
-0.8499457836151123,
0.6292010545730591,
0.8526996970176697,
-0.6622242331504822,
-0.37863385677337646,
0.7278916239738464,
0.6614584922790527,
-0.2051405906677246,
0.3311102092266083,
0.8939207196235657,
0.8051341772079468,
-0.4548952579498291,
-0.7532241940498352,
-0.3164953589439392,
-0.04687408730387688,
-0.12877896428108215,
0.5987091064453125,
-0.39819419384002686,
0.9659295082092285,
0.1188509613275528,
-0.5213869214057922,
-0.2190239429473877,
0.6661919951438904,
-0.9746725559234619,
-0.4331498146057129,
0.31008389592170715,
0.5197421312332153,
0.580411970615387,
-0.5019736289978027,
1.1492156982421875,
-0.3677596151828766,
0.5096816420555115,
0.7368943095207214,
0.15047752857208252,
0.6319773197174072,
0.4951631724834442,
-0.12704047560691833,
0.8115653395652771,
0.2722424864768982,
-0.46087637543678284,
0.7692864537239075,
0.23529505729675293,
0.14633719623088837,
-0.04196727275848389,
-0.03234515339136124,
-0.26385048031806946,
0.5432754755020142,
0.31385287642478943,
-0.5891621112823486,
-0.5148124694824219,
-0.0698273703455925,
-0.16376782953739166,
0.0815194845199585,
-0.32684779167175293,
1.0122520923614502,
-0.11277411133050919,
-0.5586979985237122,
0.3953060507774353,
-0.4580860435962677,
0.09638655930757523,
-0.6974281668663025,
-0.015032158233225346,
-0.14584563672542572,
0.25150853395462036,
-0.3334898054599762,
-1.2234954833984375,
0.5060826539993286,
0.04898736998438835,
-0.35628774762153625,
-0.48331061005592346,
0.16454902291297913,
-0.5374408960342407,
-0.24253304302692413,
0.35718944668769836,
0.33842507004737854,
0.09501239657402039,
-0.007688191719353199,
-0.27497443556785583,
-0.13054615259170532,
-0.15647344291210175,
-0.218168705701828,
0.028898993507027626,
0.6458202600479126,
0.09274730831384659,
0.29920491576194763,
0.2682594954967499,
0.036042340099811554,
0.23445959389209747,
0.3990834355354309,
1.0231220722198486,
-0.7671258449554443,
-0.3775649666786194,
-0.7967471480369568,
0.5006004571914673,
0.02402852289378643,
-0.15004517138004303,
0.5970208644866943,
0.8243847489356995,
0.9902446269989014,
-0.4306102991104126,
0.7673197388648987,
-0.18454645574092865,
0.23422162234783173,
-0.5630199313163757,
0.8245424032211304,
0.004593157675117254,
-0.19631829857826233,
0.17711099982261658,
-0.9905368089675903,
-0.193070650100708,
0.7380114197731018,
-0.27852463722229004,
-0.5394244194030762,
0.7215694785118103,
0.6183076500892639,
-0.4941864311695099,
-0.025967197492718697,
0.12610982358455658,
0.1164960116147995,
0.2877277433872223,
0.49692022800445557,
0.8975018262863159,
-0.40898650884628296,
0.6670708656311035,
-0.3449486792087555,
0.19798338413238525,
0.09430687874555588,
-0.49246522784233093,
-1.2599493265151978,
-0.7307447791099548,
0.34021130204200745,
-0.02494019642472267,
-0.12448862940073013,
0.6481419205665588,
0.7084022760391235,
-0.9894993305206299,
-0.3429126739501953,
-0.37635529041290283,
0.15672101080417633,
0.1613471657037735,
-0.2514389753341675,
0.34048858284950256,
-0.5195887088775635,
-0.6401016712188721,
0.25763821601867676,
0.0703585296869278,
-0.017453383654356003,
-0.49762529134750366,
0.23842519521713257,
-0.07417037338018417,
0.2868088185787201,
0.32909801602363586,
-0.02871885523200035,
-1.0750627517700195,
-0.7229057550430298,
0.11586912721395493,
-0.19732029736042023,
0.2556985914707184,
1.290043592453003,
-0.7545260787010193,
0.24491992592811584,
0.5971647500991821,
0.7543851137161255,
0.5251542925834656,
-0.02261696383357048,
0.6241257786750793,
-1.134145975112915,
0.3860722780227661,
0.10326258093118668,
0.5194185376167297,
0.26590919494628906,
-0.5478989481925964,
0.488040953874588,
-0.2824914753437042,
-0.48464396595954895,
-0.5505087375640869,
0.5614390969276428,
-0.7177587151527405,
-0.011764446273446083,
0.6007120609283447,
-0.05393092334270477,
-0.7481359243392944,
0.06196456775069237,
-0.09648213535547256,
0.23971033096313477,
-0.4694351851940155,
0.6827629804611206,
0.8813756704330444,
-0.020853040739893913,
-0.48119091987609863,
-0.31209656596183777,
0.6136630177497864,
-0.08492115885019302,
-0.6895710825920105,
0.1413591504096985,
0.07455434650182724,
0.056514814496040344,
0.6002255082130432,
0.057447176426649094,
-0.013025064952671528,
0.06958227604627609,
0.023223325610160828,
-0.09811243414878845,
0.09414369612932205,
-0.32309821248054504,
-0.2947003245353699,
0.2730751633644104,
-0.3145352900028229,
-0.17402097582817078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14233v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14233v1
|
Detecting and Mitigating Hallucination in Large Vision Language Models via Fine-Grained AI Feedback
| 2024-04-22T14:46:10 | 2024-04-22T14:46:10 |
Wenyi Xiao, Ziwei Huang, Leilei Gan, Wanggui He, Haoyuan Li, Zhelun Yu, Hao Jiang, Fei Wu, Linchao Zhu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The rapidly developing Large Vision Language Models (LVLMs) have shown
notable capabilities on a range of multi-modal tasks, but still face the
hallucination phenomena where the generated texts do not align with the given
contexts, significantly restricting the usages of LVLMs. Most previous work
detects and mitigates hallucination at the coarse-grained level or requires
expensive annotation (e.g., labeling by proprietary models or human experts).
To address these issues, we propose detecting and mitigating hallucinations in
LVLMs via fine-grained AI feedback. The basic idea is that we generate a
small-size sentence-level hallucination annotation dataset by proprietary
models, whereby we train a hallucination detection model which can perform
sentence-level hallucination detection, covering primary hallucination types
(i.e., object, attribute, and relationship). Then, we propose a
detect-then-rewrite pipeline to automatically construct preference dataset for
training hallucination mitigating model. Furthermore, we propose
differentiating the severity of hallucinations, and introducing a Hallucination
Severity-Aware Direct Preference Optimization (HSA-DPO) for mitigating
hallucination in LVLMs by incorporating the severity of hallucinations into
preference learning. Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our
method.
|
[
-0.4166564345359802,
-0.8770444989204407,
0.6399834156036377,
-0.01890966109931469,
-0.2603577673435211,
-0.5172669887542725,
-0.3394712507724762,
-0.5353151559829712,
0.49323558807373047,
0.9129002690315247,
-0.4385523200035095,
-0.45823511481285095,
-0.3580673635005951,
-0.057389240711927414,
-0.18941038846969604,
0.7774423956871033,
0.1090020015835762,
0.06182951107621193,
-0.34800389409065247,
-0.006805972661823034,
-0.5946630835533142,
-0.699089765548706,
-0.5987788438796997,
-0.2358153760433197,
0.5394795536994934,
0.3037204146385193,
0.6462084054946899,
0.44874444603919983,
0.6613115668296814,
0.2493877410888672,
0.007219763472676277,
0.4829196631908417,
-0.3904992341995239,
0.1926387995481491,
0.15104912221431732,
-0.23657017946243286,
-0.4647534489631653,
-0.3890896439552307,
0.48343533277511597,
0.587448239326477,
-0.20401471853256226,
-0.011955006048083305,
0.2761017680168152,
0.8388957381248474,
-0.676128625869751,
0.2151700109243393,
-0.8656306266784668,
0.3834308385848999,
-0.06799376755952835,
-0.4069891571998596,
-0.6317877769470215,
-0.14382989704608917,
0.014971520751714706,
-0.3185088336467743,
0.2108687311410904,
0.1797640174627304,
0.5872551202774048,
0.8540799021720886,
0.08037218451499939,
-0.21753640472888947,
-0.7096269130706787,
0.7960640788078308,
-0.5930960774421692,
0.3888854682445526,
0.587746798992157,
0.23697370290756226,
-0.14789816737174988,
-0.3340035378932953,
-0.5294984579086304,
-0.7360373139381409,
-0.12938138842582703,
-0.14760637283325195,
0.06516990065574646,
0.1869775652885437,
0.28884613513946533,
0.2671065032482147,
-0.4630165994167328,
0.21084187924861908,
-0.28004199266433716,
-0.41559547185897827,
0.5190639495849609,
0.31634217500686646,
-0.026215417310595512,
-0.24487051367759705,
-0.18409287929534912,
-0.002737869508564472,
-0.3971174657344818,
-0.0635417029261589,
0.16169027984142303,
0.3526208698749542,
0.2951575219631195,
0.7619057893753052,
-0.2895474433898926,
0.5889620184898376,
0.003098227083683014,
0.009301015175879002,
0.38405826687812805,
-0.06152316555380821,
-0.35883429646492004,
0.18366415798664093,
0.6020832657814026,
0.6394137144088745,
0.37333524227142334,
-0.31220096349716187,
-0.48191550374031067,
0.35665813088417053,
0.4417680501937866,
-0.8044089674949646,
-0.3077901303768158,
0.30348414182662964,
-0.6534931063652039,
-0.4830177128314972,
-0.21485209465026855,
-0.9054004549980164,
-0.9742201566696167,
-0.4828242063522339,
0.5414496064186096,
-0.3235786259174347,
-0.05307510867714882,
0.4053531885147095,
0.13853494822978973,
0.21219466626644135,
0.4387378990650177,
-1.0502313375473022,
0.055496346205472946,
0.5005940198898315,
0.8040869832038879,
-0.35510513186454773,
-0.4863932132720947,
-0.9901790022850037,
0.023107528686523438,
-0.1665520966053009,
0.8936402797698975,
-0.5806295871734619,
-0.061445098370313644,
0.04024003446102142,
0.004170894622802734,
0.10026871412992477,
-0.7934505939483643,
0.41360142827033997,
0.05794667452573776,
-0.06112204119563103,
-0.05825551599264145,
-0.3937661051750183,
0.03492344170808792,
0.33445367217063904,
-0.5645216703414917,
0.7878965139389038,
-0.09319040924310684,
-0.6958600282669067,
0.3719385862350464,
-0.2547927796840668,
-0.30822640657424927,
0.062392011284828186,
-0.32165032625198364,
-0.5785714387893677,
0.39053305983543396,
0.3613392412662506,
0.5576968193054199,
0.0011247341753914952,
0.4537450969219208,
-0.37154388427734375,
-0.4470917284488678,
-0.04893400892615318,
-0.5371208786964417,
0.26421982049942017,
-0.022422706708312035,
-0.6441549062728882,
0.6464537382125854,
-0.8320029973983765,
-0.3099716603755951,
0.0031988187693059444,
0.028118183836340904,
-0.37370389699935913,
0.3169174790382385,
0.09554784744977951,
0.02048620954155922,
0.11250832676887512,
-0.19609549641609192,
0.3387472927570343,
-0.31458979845046997,
0.16953471302986145,
0.9531434178352356,
-0.14742277562618256,
0.32012733817100525,
-0.21813105046749115,
0.1916768103837967,
0.10053743422031403,
0.47402071952819824,
0.1599821299314499,
-0.37591320276260376,
-1.0533647537231445,
-0.1687246710062027,
-0.31824058294296265,
0.2909851670265198,
-0.8164198994636536,
0.7473355531692505,
-0.0585673563182354,
-0.1959313303232193,
-0.5307633876800537,
0.019541433081030846,
0.3059639036655426,
0.4905136525630951,
0.5317683219909668,
-0.3232499659061432,
-0.4321988523006439,
-0.9911190867424011,
0.12152861058712006,
-0.12541812658309937,
-0.0305348951369524,
0.426615834236145,
0.5079306960105896,
-0.4942207932472229,
0.6554375886917114,
-0.6275265216827393,
-0.9675495028495789,
-0.0923185795545578,
-0.13304854929447174,
-0.40043050050735474,
0.3544585406780243,
0.4862411916255951,
-0.7800125479698181,
-0.04514985904097557,
0.09123869985342026,
-0.6997865438461304,
-0.13800092041492462,
-0.25042322278022766,
0.08740651607513428,
0.5598782300949097,
0.6135240793228149,
-0.4117843508720398,
0.6045975685119629,
0.3696126639842987,
-0.44620949029922485,
0.6621791124343872,
-0.2326284945011139,
0.049953509122133255,
-0.7857465147972107,
-0.08173355460166931,
-0.14006122946739197,
-0.05137941613793373,
-0.4300867021083832,
-0.0203432384878397,
-0.31511345505714417,
0.2068512737751007,
-0.417116641998291,
0.38124358654022217,
-0.09409581124782562,
-0.1326168328523636,
-0.3682306706905365,
0.048798635601997375,
-0.13016360998153687,
0.6030381917953491,
0.3913396894931793,
0.46628695726394653,
0.6280193328857422,
-0.5344631671905518,
0.46082767844200134,
0.18450480699539185,
-0.24776946008205414,
0.31514307856559753,
-0.36338528990745544,
0.0560343898832798,
-0.24349084496498108,
0.16191034018993378,
-0.6433793902397156,
-0.2310844212770462,
0.5098986029624939,
-0.31764647364616394,
-0.14512872695922852,
0.030297888442873955,
-0.32748380303382874,
-0.1818406581878662,
-0.49547433853149414,
0.17443719506263733,
0.246748685836792,
-0.5909786224365234,
0.7016826868057251,
0.3440247178077698,
0.2775786817073822,
-0.4520108699798584,
-0.6700202822685242,
0.09541279077529907,
-0.11575770378112793,
-0.45158377289772034,
0.12122027575969696,
-0.3098776936531067,
-0.21464352309703827,
-0.1048993319272995,
-0.021241294220089912,
0.10347823053598404,
0.11683940887451172,
0.37875109910964966,
0.19804979860782623,
-0.16901549696922302,
0.2026340812444687,
-0.22627763450145721,
-0.16882139444351196,
0.042748503386974335,
-0.36206531524658203,
0.9937950968742371,
-0.34269675612449646,
-0.3595336377620697,
-0.5700650811195374,
0.34627652168273926,
0.7115117311477661,
-0.29294082522392273,
0.7043052911758423,
0.8193270564079285,
-0.5999162197113037,
-0.22800777852535248,
-0.547622561454773,
-0.6689223647117615,
-0.4182766377925873,
0.46997174620628357,
-0.37889060378074646,
-0.8127989172935486,
0.4502566456794739,
0.339103102684021,
-0.20433677732944489,
0.3146555721759796,
0.8063490390777588,
0.1970207840204239,
1.0357635021209717,
0.4760371148586273,
-0.20402055978775024,
0.3990333378314972,
-0.14398957788944244,
0.3722556531429291,
-0.7319689393043518,
-0.30743682384490967,
-0.33253276348114014,
-0.3015752136707306,
-0.41380593180656433,
-0.33661535382270813,
0.11724303662776947,
-0.13964514434337616,
-0.02440064214169979,
-0.02836393378674984,
-0.8700847029685974,
0.6096336841583252,
0.7055442929267883,
0.3170630633831024,
0.20650307834148407,
0.19746451079845428,
0.2286442667245865,
-0.06508522480726242,
-0.2870340347290039,
-0.4447442591190338,
0.7270363569259644,
0.3089672923088074,
0.8608718514442444,
-0.2450319230556488,
0.8050054311752319,
0.4088203012943268,
-0.13237601518630981,
-1.1511590480804443,
0.6795963048934937,
-0.3209330439567566,
-0.055800847709178925,
-0.5089405179023743,
-0.3772348165512085,
-0.5823115706443787,
0.18915201723575592,
-0.3233844041824341,
-0.9829120635986328,
0.2033105492591858,
0.31192082166671753,
-0.4741441309452057,
0.4275233745574951,
-0.4804944694042206,
0.9059434533119202,
-0.1280045509338379,
-0.4246779978275299,
-0.21279282867908478,
-0.4698319733142853,
0.27863696217536926,
0.0469905249774456,
-0.13661344349384308,
0.0508858747780323,
0.38500794768333435,
0.551629900932312,
-0.17099902033805847,
1.114354133605957,
-0.2989973723888397,
-0.3247239887714386,
0.06871657073497772,
0.1532246172428131,
0.5621832013130188,
0.1240757405757904,
0.1797167956829071,
0.10313960164785385,
-0.1735190749168396,
-0.12859953939914703,
-0.41154032945632935,
0.7155622243881226,
-0.5381831526756287,
-0.629278302192688,
-0.35580265522003174,
-0.7303817868232727,
-0.08466406166553497,
0.009784475900232792,
0.35643482208251953,
0.41507816314697266,
0.13514165580272675,
0.29028740525245667,
0.7089333534240723,
-0.19146087765693665,
0.25774118304252625,
0.04415241628885269,
-0.6054257750511169,
-0.30591052770614624,
1.1612305641174316,
-0.07078946381807327,
0.08707170188426971,
0.2062634974718094,
0.37789058685302734,
-0.022004351019859314,
-0.8391989469528198,
-0.35421276092529297,
-0.023981455713510513,
-0.6335558891296387,
-0.1453292965888977,
-0.7170341610908508,
-0.2474549561738968,
-0.5230840444564819,
-0.23362676799297333,
-0.48581966757774353,
-0.138738214969635,
-0.34624722599983215,
0.1567506641149521,
0.2723217308521271,
0.5124549865722656,
0.14394545555114746,
0.022555146366357803,
-0.6463898420333862,
0.634351372718811,
0.2877891957759857,
0.4171693027019501,
0.1731349378824234,
-0.4001106023788452,
-0.07056491076946259,
-0.021117424592375755,
-0.07571087777614594,
-0.3421172499656677,
0.5602642893791199,
0.007339028641581535,
0.24341340363025665,
0.6004818677902222,
0.21926669776439667,
0.6194803714752197,
-0.4845259487628937,
0.9067246317863464,
0.09112589061260223,
-0.9074608087539673,
0.6673011183738708,
0.07361670583486557,
-0.03227977454662323,
0.492406964302063,
-0.09993574023246765,
-0.4502963423728943,
-0.5590871572494507,
-0.14189231395721436,
-0.8364854454994202,
0.5539858937263489,
0.18592184782028198,
0.08958825469017029,
0.09227392822504044,
0.28801336884498596,
0.22188887000083923,
0.21374772489070892,
-0.9042097926139832,
-0.00975226704031229,
-0.17535066604614258,
-0.16816025972366333,
0.011026807129383087,
-0.3283599317073822,
-0.1279410868883133,
-0.405408650636673,
0.5367371439933777,
-0.3101481795310974,
0.08536744117736816,
0.2726396322250366,
-0.1671573370695114,
-0.08405110239982605,
0.016780754551291466,
0.8355356454849243,
0.3188101649284363,
-0.46292486786842346,
0.26088446378707886,
-0.1261247992515564,
-0.708711564540863,
-0.14366929233074188,
-0.07807563245296478,
-0.4491002857685089,
-0.029384315013885498,
0.3438422977924347,
1.098355770111084,
-0.2325122356414795,
-0.7223389744758606,
0.46597036719322205,
-0.09538957476615906,
-0.18092791736125946,
-0.4250873327255249,
0.13538259267807007,
-0.2935837209224701,
0.34939146041870117,
0.11595915257930756,
0.202055424451828,
0.3057084381580353,
-0.4116716682910919,
0.2591041326522827,
0.5301555395126343,
-0.6334240436553955,
-0.11535952985286713,
0.6392368078231812,
0.14025439321994781,
-0.4464348256587982,
0.5470579862594604,
-0.14960159361362457,
-0.6049662232398987,
0.5841410160064697,
0.388271689414978,
1.0701359510421753,
-0.15488554537296295,
0.2296476513147354,
0.1382785588502884,
0.5245506763458252,
-0.20691891014575958,
0.131818950176239,
-0.016996271908283234,
-0.8181058764457703,
-0.11839555948972702,
-0.7974599003791809,
-0.29894328117370605,
0.40292245149612427,
-0.6379871368408203,
0.4022892117500305,
-0.21635028719902039,
0.0762883722782135,
0.10058088600635529,
-0.22121471166610718,
-0.3671583831310272,
0.14444135129451752,
0.5159501433372498,
0.34784623980522156,
-0.8241106867790222,
0.8918003439903259,
0.2923356294631958,
-0.5503681898117065,
-0.356749564409256,
0.46560484170913696,
-0.13485956192016602,
-0.7069056034088135,
0.5745879411697388,
0.6363359689712524,
-0.3533872067928314,
-0.12228238582611084,
-0.5134261250495911,
-0.347375750541687,
0.7821473479270935,
0.24063214659690857,
-0.7248969078063965,
-0.028685545548796654,
0.15770520269870758,
0.5100178122520447,
-0.45630839467048645,
-0.22823241353034973,
0.7032508850097656,
0.48041653633117676,
0.04304042458534241,
-0.8020848035812378,
-0.011917656287550926,
-0.02923980914056301,
-0.08710259199142456,
0.24313586950302124,
-0.49605363607406616,
0.5351043343544006,
-0.30250707268714905,
0.1341240555047989,
0.03247060999274254,
0.5348770022392273,
0.10332369804382324,
0.6234169602394104,
0.7462618947029114,
0.5768172740936279,
0.7496113777160645,
0.10648120194673538,
0.8427107930183411,
-0.0959615558385849,
0.2428954690694809,
1.1726288795471191,
-0.48926112055778503,
0.9768950343132019,
0.8624258637428284,
0.22319521009922028,
0.08902672678232193,
0.5045967102050781,
-0.19388419389724731,
0.6577376127243042,
0.3178943991661072,
-0.12537716329097748,
-0.4156198501586914,
-0.35260337591171265,
-0.4146747887134552,
0.549314022064209,
0.22386674582958221,
-0.3434559404850006,
0.23916982114315033,
0.4533230662345886,
-0.3482951521873474,
0.012733363546431065,
-0.4768489897251129,
0.8536909222602844,
-0.06250530481338501,
-0.6748755574226379,
0.7588602900505066,
-0.49480578303337097,
0.8279763460159302,
-0.25420117378234863,
-0.09403197467327118,
-0.3547726273536682,
0.4279153645038605,
-0.31355416774749756,
-0.5671394467353821,
0.45063701272010803,
-0.09639783948659897,
-0.3677544891834259,
0.1698460578918457,
0.6490344405174255,
-0.5749961733818054,
-0.46101394295692444,
0.5199269652366638,
0.10766175389289856,
0.23003742098808289,
-0.4173453152179718,
-0.20391052961349487,
0.2750990390777588,
0.1414574533700943,
-0.13733112812042236,
0.27225297689437866,
0.2402353435754776,
-0.1842462122440338,
0.6432804465293884,
0.46962806582450867,
0.2053777128458023,
-0.05801324546337128,
0.505144476890564,
0.8537916541099548,
-0.5523961186408997,
-0.3015008270740509,
-0.9766063094139099,
0.19948126375675201,
-0.1338999718427658,
-0.17668969929218292,
0.40753239393234253,
0.40937933325767517,
0.7621418237686157,
-0.4014248549938202,
0.6047488451004028,
0.1872495710849762,
-0.058405812829732895,
-0.8030248880386353,
0.8114131093025208,
-0.7576910257339478,
0.40397909283638,
-0.21391336619853973,
-1.1531031131744385,
-0.7048044800758362,
0.7386510968208313,
-0.15223421156406403,
-0.2526436150074005,
0.7445557713508606,
0.9876360297203064,
0.05277317762374878,
-0.23399566113948822,
0.5744854807853699,
0.3010540008544922,
0.21226021647453308,
0.6515274047851562,
0.8199928998947144,
-0.03959585726261139,
0.4899282157421112,
-0.41795244812965393,
-0.1512898951768875,
-0.6094359159469604,
-0.7815201878547668,
-1.0363363027572632,
-0.7468674778938293,
-0.3921479880809784,
-0.5480842590332031,
-0.035062335431575775,
0.9105128645896912,
0.38708198070526123,
-0.940796971321106,
0.0027419012039899826,
-0.14675702154636383,
-0.01608843356370926,
-0.16363881528377533,
-0.25544410943984985,
0.5896435976028442,
-0.4925243854522705,
-0.6610476970672607,
0.0949365422129631,
0.6098963618278503,
0.024135136976838112,
-0.6455069780349731,
-0.211125910282135,
0.24377210438251495,
-0.03215533494949341,
0.8321832418441772,
-0.1746494174003601,
-1.1529613733291626,
-0.6289535760879517,
0.07745996862649918,
-0.20305794477462769,
0.17306692898273468,
0.7406446933746338,
-0.7341814637184143,
0.48277103900909424,
0.38148558139801025,
0.6724001169204712,
0.15360236167907715,
-0.4305529296398163,
0.15409566462039948,
-0.5240168571472168,
0.41342872381210327,
0.3712240755558014,
0.3940380811691284,
0.3658067286014557,
-0.5883370041847229,
0.4542008936405182,
0.2575004994869232,
-0.5762237310409546,
-0.9534096717834473,
0.2312414050102234,
-1.1553629636764526,
-0.32970812916755676,
1.2702231407165527,
0.29251828789711,
-0.25011923909187317,
-0.030635694041848183,
-0.7512120604515076,
-0.07305743545293808,
-0.24231159687042236,
1.3847135305404663,
0.557019829750061,
-0.03738696873188019,
-0.037352871149778366,
-0.3719240128993988,
0.7558800578117371,
0.5518010258674622,
-0.9293845891952515,
0.5562751889228821,
0.7702692151069641,
-0.3541637659072876,
0.2526865303516388,
0.4901640713214874,
0.22101566195487976,
0.16216935217380524,
-0.11517459154129028,
0.29345813393592834,
-0.002316984347999096,
-0.6751728653907776,
-0.4478320777416229,
0.12374062836170197,
-0.03693464770913124,
-0.41705402731895447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14219v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14219v3
|
Phi-3 Technical Report: A Highly Capable Language Model Locally on Your Phone
| 2024-04-22T14:32:33 | 2024-05-23T22:42:40 |
Marah Abdin, Sam Ade Jacobs, Ammar Ahmad Awan, Jyoti Aneja, Ahmed Awadallah, Hany Awadalla, Nguyen Bach, Amit Bahree, Arash Bakhtiari, Jianmin Bao, Harkirat Behl, Alon Benhaim, Misha Bilenko, Johan Bjorck, Sébastien Bubeck, Qin Cai, Martin Cai, Caio César Teodoro Mendes, Weizhu Chen, Vishrav Chaudhary, Dong Chen, Dongdong Chen, Yen-Chun Chen, Yi-Ling Chen, Parul Chopra, Xiyang Dai, Allie Del Giorno, Gustavo de Rosa, Matthew Dixon, Ronen Eldan, Victor Fragoso, Dan Iter, Mei Gao, Min Gao, Jianfeng Gao, Amit Garg, Abhishek Goswami, Suriya Gunasekar, Emman Haider, Junheng Hao, Russell J. Hewett, Jamie Huynh, Mojan Javaheripi, Xin Jin, Piero Kauffmann, Nikos Karampatziakis, Dongwoo Kim, Mahoud Khademi, Lev Kurilenko, James R. Lee, Yin Tat Lee, Yuanzhi Li, Yunsheng Li, Chen Liang, Lars Liden, Ce Liu, Mengchen Liu, Weishung Liu, Eric Lin, Zeqi Lin, Chong Luo, Piyush Madan, Matt Mazzola, Arindam Mitra, Hardik Modi, Anh Nguyen, Brandon Norick, Barun Patra, Daniel Perez-Becker, Thomas Portet, Reid Pryzant, Heyang Qin, Marko Radmilac, Corby Rosset, Sambudha Roy, Olatunji Ruwase, Olli Saarikivi, Amin Saied, Adil Salim, Michael Santacroce, Shital Shah, Ning Shang, Hiteshi Sharma, Swadheen Shukla, Xia Song, Masahiro Tanaka, Andrea Tupini, Xin Wang, Lijuan Wang, Chunyu Wang, Yu Wang, Rachel Ward, Guanhua Wang, Philipp Witte, Haiping Wu, Michael Wyatt, Bin Xiao, Can Xu, Jiahang Xu, Weijian Xu, Sonali Yadav, Fan Yang, Jianwei Yang, Ziyi Yang, Yifan Yang, Donghan Yu, Lu Yuan, Chengruidong Zhang, Cyril Zhang, Jianwen Zhang, Li Lyna Zhang, Yi Zhang, Yue Zhang, Yunan Zhang, Xiren Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce phi-3-mini, a 3.8 billion parameter language model trained on
3.3 trillion tokens, whose overall performance, as measured by both academic
benchmarks and internal testing, rivals that of models such as Mixtral 8x7B and
GPT-3.5 (e.g., phi-3-mini achieves 69% on MMLU and 8.38 on MT-bench), despite
being small enough to be deployed on a phone. The innovation lies entirely in
our dataset for training, a scaled-up version of the one used for phi-2,
composed of heavily filtered publicly available web data and synthetic data.
The model is also further aligned for robustness, safety, and chat format. We
also provide some initial parameter-scaling results with a 7B and 14B models
trained for 4.8T tokens, called phi-3-small and phi-3-medium, both
significantly more capable than phi-3-mini (e.g., respectively 75% and 78% on
MMLU, and 8.7 and 8.9 on MT-bench). Moreover, we also introduce phi-3-vision, a
4.2 billion parameter model based on phi-3-mini with strong reasoning
capabilities for image and text prompts.
|
[
-0.24117843806743622,
-0.6769747138023376,
0.32025086879730225,
0.41227105259895325,
-0.29208022356033325,
-0.08101940155029297,
0.10508795827627182,
-0.8979871273040771,
0.11911198496818542,
0.4385184645652771,
-0.07922868430614471,
-0.1297224909067154,
-0.13712164759635925,
-0.02732810564339161,
-0.2915079593658447,
0.5702757239341736,
0.25063472986221313,
0.2459123581647873,
0.42293399572372437,
-0.012046832591295242,
-0.005990804173052311,
-0.5733435153961182,
-0.8133422136306763,
-0.09068821370601654,
0.6223581433296204,
0.9928788542747498,
0.9265111088752747,
1.0322120189666748,
0.6658948063850403,
0.13536791503429413,
0.255135178565979,
-0.40723514556884766,
-0.22864565253257751,
-0.35406845808029175,
0.30422404408454895,
-0.4296897053718567,
-0.8996984362602234,
0.12445972114801407,
0.48898765444755554,
0.6955693364143372,
-0.07632175087928772,
0.15590853989124298,
-0.023214809596538544,
0.6839742660522461,
-0.42237788438796997,
0.33098697662353516,
-0.7615105509757996,
-0.08727393299341202,
-0.6379669904708862,
0.13156621158123016,
-0.2774510979652405,
-0.41972604393959045,
0.39206480979919434,
-0.6115014553070068,
0.07617554813623428,
0.32337215542793274,
0.6961696743965149,
-0.14623446762561798,
-0.5439021587371826,
-0.18596255779266357,
-0.9120208024978638,
0.6720631718635559,
-0.7960274815559387,
0.529089093208313,
0.6986515522003174,
0.6754334568977356,
0.261563241481781,
-0.9533639550209045,
-0.864362895488739,
-0.3005342483520508,
0.48500776290893555,
-0.23482723534107208,
-0.2404686063528061,
0.04997650161385536,
0.2043662965297699,
0.6487737894058228,
-0.4791484475135803,
0.10004676133394241,
-0.5638296604156494,
-0.4182717800140381,
0.33107149600982666,
0.1342211663722992,
0.294337660074234,
-0.09285341203212738,
0.11892567574977875,
0.30256178975105286,
-0.8775696158409119,
0.10972785949707031,
0.24829928576946259,
0.5748134851455688,
-0.38338783383369446,
0.5848978757858276,
-0.6036337614059448,
0.8302586674690247,
-0.0636889785528183,
-0.30614930391311646,
0.3014698028564453,
-0.39532387256622314,
-0.12302878499031067,
-0.042729493230581284,
0.9777337908744812,
0.47684887051582336,
0.09671282768249512,
0.11104243993759155,
-0.018472986295819283,
-0.17010939121246338,
-0.017960313707590103,
-0.8498587608337402,
-0.358286052942276,
0.1259823590517044,
-0.6799350380897522,
-0.32857462763786316,
-0.3070394992828369,
-0.7464073896408081,
-0.7787640690803528,
0.1443765014410019,
0.18402539193630219,
-0.5086792707443237,
-0.3620085120201111,
0.2085643857717514,
0.5392374396324158,
0.37628012895584106,
0.21806807816028595,
-1.4809383153915405,
0.4590030610561371,
0.3610427975654602,
1.1024818420410156,
-0.1340324431657791,
-0.41907742619514465,
-0.51903235912323,
0.03132522106170654,
-0.218487948179245,
0.7182140350341797,
-0.4484004080295563,
-0.4475741386413574,
-0.012064404785633087,
-0.34387969970703125,
-0.10543086379766464,
-0.5978315472602844,
0.8848286867141724,
-0.2560129463672638,
0.2550910711288452,
-0.1510753333568573,
-0.31165823340415955,
-0.24511735141277313,
-0.04618045315146446,
-0.9770664572715759,
1.1568326950073242,
0.18691635131835938,
-1.0122445821762085,
0.37394285202026367,
-0.7441637516021729,
-0.4267238676548004,
0.17351187765598297,
0.0068245236761868,
-0.36349308490753174,
0.0157054141163826,
0.2980487644672394,
0.4942568838596344,
-0.5872525572776794,
-0.28636279702186584,
-0.809396505355835,
-0.7147388458251953,
-0.06389941275119781,
-0.238956019282341,
0.8628544211387634,
0.308925062417984,
-0.7018750905990601,
0.050359707325696945,
-1.0043280124664307,
-0.0006203752127476037,
-0.025858242064714432,
-0.34902656078338623,
0.017071262001991272,
-0.24612239003181458,
0.0061467792838811874,
0.31619980931282043,
0.34543970227241516,
-0.756986141204834,
-0.011765697970986366,
-0.5742636919021606,
0.5949666500091553,
0.21467924118041992,
-0.19898705184459686,
0.8130961656570435,
-0.2597675621509552,
0.521276593208313,
-0.06679333746433258,
0.5265234708786011,
-0.22754962742328644,
-0.761451244354248,
-0.8988499641418457,
-0.4242255687713623,
0.34274032711982727,
0.6319140791893005,
-0.5967531800270081,
0.041162654757499695,
-0.5108404755592346,
-0.8428324460983276,
-0.29303476214408875,
0.12733635306358337,
0.0913514643907547,
0.6121099591255188,
0.13492700457572937,
0.15476718544960022,
-0.4580592215061188,
-1.151892900466919,
-0.19508560001850128,
-0.5243197679519653,
-0.1223798543214798,
0.2713063657283783,
0.3898090124130249,
-0.1427667886018753,
0.9535295963287354,
-0.0661831870675087,
-0.0987601950764656,
-0.6648916006088257,
-0.10685666650533676,
0.033079031854867935,
0.6244266629219055,
0.5253762006759644,
-0.634224534034729,
-0.672614336013794,
0.22988122701644897,
-0.7019973397254944,
0.0973232090473175,
0.1227598562836647,
0.31633689999580383,
0.09371798485517502,
0.3330516815185547,
-0.6201502084732056,
0.23776891827583313,
0.6461133360862732,
-0.1131756603717804,
0.24059262871742249,
-0.11674526333808899,
-0.07936332374811172,
-1.2341781854629517,
0.097939632833004,
0.25123822689056396,
-0.19576339423656464,
-0.6588886380195618,
-0.085293710231781,
0.49355804920196533,
-0.5834488272666931,
-0.7379846572875977,
0.795695424079895,
-0.15158461034297943,
-0.2933279871940613,
-0.211028054356575,
-0.013921498320996761,
-0.2559487223625183,
0.5195093750953674,
-0.26112502813339233,
0.8736060857772827,
0.8700853586196899,
-0.775720477104187,
0.6513531804084778,
-0.3023330271244049,
-0.4962587356567383,
0.4388396739959717,
-0.7787314057350159,
0.17233379185199738,
0.6813986897468567,
0.2468269169330597,
-0.5024611949920654,
-0.6372360587120056,
0.42945465445518494,
-0.30017566680908203,
-0.3093721866607666,
-0.05533650889992714,
-0.8845032453536987,
-0.5617497563362122,
-0.45129549503326416,
0.6392328143119812,
0.39093902707099915,
-0.4326111674308777,
0.9048622846603394,
0.6159642934799194,
-0.3275422751903534,
0.07136523723602295,
-0.6553804874420166,
0.0361713208258152,
-0.6292485594749451,
-0.744480311870575,
0.1974160373210907,
0.14664191007614136,
-0.15423379838466644,
-0.4527173638343811,
-0.034167323261499405,
-0.3785761296749115,
-0.02365228906273842,
0.4674217998981476,
0.17631974816322327,
-0.21826370060443878,
-0.20341384410858154,
-0.3015584945678711,
-0.19262252748012543,
-0.058320507407188416,
-0.35394009947776794,
0.43147674202919006,
-0.6130734086036682,
-0.3252723515033722,
-1.0549514293670654,
0.060681771486997604,
0.8311275839805603,
-0.21264833211898804,
0.42269307374954224,
0.48300960659980774,
-0.7833258509635925,
0.34564682841300964,
-0.5275054574012756,
-0.0388542078435421,
-0.5549556612968445,
0.1067456305027008,
-0.576322615146637,
-0.8173305988311768,
0.7861364483833313,
-0.03663288429379463,
0.09218370914459229,
0.19409282505512238,
0.47358155250549316,
-0.07015623152256012,
1.4185404777526855,
0.9455143213272095,
-0.19743111729621887,
0.6081793308258057,
0.01986047998070717,
0.36134573817253113,
-0.5893679857254028,
-0.3588528335094452,
-0.6908838152885437,
-0.008933408185839653,
-0.5522703528404236,
-0.376090943813324,
0.3754732012748718,
0.4258084297180176,
-0.37409183382987976,
0.3535727262496948,
0.061615124344825745,
0.4050231873989105,
0.7784704566001892,
0.09024719148874283,
0.24064518511295319,
0.17767299711704254,
-0.2423553466796875,
-0.24140478670597076,
-0.6448125243186951,
-0.6700400114059448,
1.3715275526046753,
0.7976613640785217,
0.5636039972305298,
0.19348356127738953,
0.4012894928455353,
-0.026413261890411377,
0.16983354091644287,
-0.733588457107544,
0.6617854237556458,
0.28425171971321106,
-0.6228781342506409,
-0.2480907440185547,
-0.4514184892177582,
-0.7198946475982666,
0.010950716212391853,
0.14549441635608673,
-1.1341160535812378,
-0.07762309908866882,
0.3158654272556305,
-0.8236547112464905,
0.3459412455558777,
-0.9177771806716919,
0.8822742104530334,
-0.15140321850776672,
-0.2024827003479004,
-0.12149792164564133,
-0.3797464966773987,
0.5540534257888794,
-0.31921085715293884,
0.386187881231308,
-0.23688851296901703,
-0.10428755730390549,
0.7474282383918762,
-0.4378126859664917,
0.7582340836524963,
-0.26283469796180725,
-0.17483827471733093,
0.27193525433540344,
0.17843526601791382,
0.4379582405090332,
0.20889684557914734,
-0.42046666145324707,
-0.003965437412261963,
-0.054395634680986404,
-0.649189293384552,
-0.6970013380050659,
0.7122204899787903,
-0.6853449940681458,
-0.19878175854682922,
-0.26175522804260254,
-0.40061914920806885,
-0.6205762028694153,
0.5306368470191956,
0.445945680141449,
0.7652004361152649,
0.06415962427854538,
0.38495299220085144,
0.5084693431854248,
-0.24961186945438385,
0.6252602338790894,
0.5037634372711182,
-0.7115129232406616,
-0.36782145500183105,
1.172281265258789,
-0.008637317456305027,
0.0024937246926128864,
0.2233228236436844,
0.3390294909477234,
-0.39435866475105286,
-0.7153344750404358,
-0.7081709504127502,
0.11054815351963043,
-0.5026010870933533,
-0.10432858020067215,
-0.6600670218467712,
-0.03933866322040558,
-0.33887049555778503,
0.03182351216673851,
-0.8210347294807434,
-0.7243154644966125,
-0.03224676474928856,
-0.06149987131357193,
0.1284605860710144,
0.7989339828491211,
-0.1356094777584076,
0.7001895904541016,
-0.7699985504150391,
0.32655060291290283,
0.5154963135719299,
0.6631637811660767,
-0.24438422918319702,
-0.6534765362739563,
-0.67524254322052,
0.2693653106689453,
-0.24762745201587677,
-0.7398521304130554,
0.028659682720899582,
0.2589859366416931,
0.32258766889572144,
0.545396089553833,
-0.1163325086236,
0.4539624750614166,
-0.2927659749984741,
1.069580078125,
0.23541828989982605,
-1.1250108480453491,
0.612254798412323,
-1.068847894668579,
0.3686407208442688,
0.4868657886981964,
0.12171606719493866,
-0.2332516312599182,
-0.3156520426273346,
-0.7146865725517273,
-0.43103909492492676,
0.6453976035118103,
0.3752012550830841,
0.38823121786117554,
0.1341513842344284,
0.49989932775497437,
-0.09670928865671158,
-0.14325110614299774,
-0.9810128211975098,
-0.1621747612953186,
-0.3355432450771332,
-0.1250150501728058,
0.43748632073402405,
-0.4230884909629822,
0.2990095615386963,
-0.4668082594871521,
0.4349847137928009,
-0.16753731667995453,
0.2649734318256378,
-0.29918619990348816,
0.1424686759710312,
0.07801097631454468,
-0.1448332965373993,
0.6904593110084534,
0.7860925197601318,
-0.25304755568504333,
0.0871104821562767,
0.286511093378067,
-0.7478755116462708,
-0.19130368530750275,
0.24448934197425842,
-0.05598815158009529,
-0.07665520906448364,
0.35598137974739075,
0.6103786826133728,
0.5050802230834961,
-0.5427801609039307,
0.5033994317054749,
-0.3929046392440796,
-0.06954333186149597,
-0.13562650978565216,
-0.16998066008090973,
-0.03728971630334854,
0.04819941893219948,
0.4440250098705292,
0.11045323312282562,
0.2227478325366974,
-0.5118089914321899,
0.15093523263931274,
0.056204378604888916,
-0.589889645576477,
-0.4197772741317749,
0.7913784980773926,
0.6420813798904419,
-0.252166211605072,
0.6409459710121155,
-0.2747427821159363,
-0.4571591913700104,
0.218523308634758,
0.49796977639198303,
0.4938660264015198,
-0.3546160161495209,
0.3520895540714264,
0.40377357602119446,
0.3384254276752472,
-0.3046124279499054,
0.5506697297096252,
0.1788763850927353,
-0.6386129856109619,
-0.06830058246850967,
-0.30881521105766296,
-0.5667749643325806,
0.3314231038093567,
-0.5383028388023376,
0.33076322078704834,
-0.7196736335754395,
-0.24244660139083862,
0.06308242678642273,
0.3189760446548462,
-0.505083441734314,
0.17775140702724457,
0.0821666419506073,
1.2554714679718018,
-0.31037822365760803,
1.4497337341308594,
0.595797598361969,
-0.2425941675901413,
-1.3297538757324219,
0.08488740026950836,
0.12814107537269592,
-0.5970221161842346,
0.4259568750858307,
0.2890188992023468,
-0.301540344953537,
0.1761653870344162,
-0.27901336550712585,
-0.8420871496200562,
1.103069543838501,
0.7792331576347351,
-0.38816139101982117,
0.005721877794712782,
0.3127875328063965,
0.31030210852622986,
-0.4450377821922302,
0.15630418062210083,
0.6291788816452026,
0.07636048644781113,
-0.15733003616333008,
-1.7028075456619263,
-0.30412307381629944,
-0.5731656551361084,
0.02637658640742302,
-0.2746623158454895,
-0.6890296936035156,
0.8461342453956604,
-0.314041405916214,
-0.17871268093585968,
0.264558345079422,
0.6932418346405029,
0.29954779148101807,
0.19026944041252136,
0.478239506483078,
0.15399481356143951,
0.9069984555244446,
-0.002941292244940996,
1.2531787157058716,
-0.7046222686767578,
0.05939435958862305,
1.1134461164474487,
-0.4581625461578369,
1.1517088413238525,
0.2976316511631012,
0.09906212985515594,
0.41914102435112,
0.8706274032592773,
0.3792770206928253,
0.5416296124458313,
-0.026403337717056274,
-0.46366387605667114,
-0.03964205086231232,
-0.16378942131996155,
-0.5299980640411377,
0.6276383996009827,
0.2686815857887268,
-0.07075565308332443,
0.05608513578772545,
0.20717410743236542,
0.042615488171577454,
-0.17569150030612946,
-0.3915809988975525,
0.3463646173477173,
0.011784004978835583,
-0.28136682510375977,
0.4191868007183075,
0.45791158080101013,
0.5137647390365601,
-0.4401731491088867,
0.28236135840415955,
-0.5808559656143188,
0.3339836001396179,
-0.0713544562458992,
-0.4124731123447418,
0.2260296791791916,
0.06548690795898438,
0.12626144289970398,
-0.026741070672869682,
0.5756694674491882,
0.1482289731502533,
-0.6723764538764954,
-0.06286297738552094,
0.4313378632068634,
-0.023762257769703865,
-0.31693124771118164,
-0.6780796051025391,
0.45856133103370667,
-0.07461807131767273,
-0.13722899556159973,
0.1982160061597824,
0.6243149638175964,
-0.003927592188119888,
1.1853201389312744,
0.3923926055431366,
0.1759723573923111,
0.4108533561229706,
0.1517346352338791,
0.7967200875282288,
-0.5852380394935608,
-0.7860320806503296,
-0.687702476978302,
0.3067026436328888,
-0.27849969267845154,
-0.5080607533454895,
0.9413955211639404,
1.086837887763977,
0.813430905342102,
0.21220436692237854,
0.8078566789627075,
0.08112859725952148,
0.6888194680213928,
-0.28120872378349304,
0.45438480377197266,
-0.2612619698047638,
0.5215595364570618,
-0.20760740339756012,
-0.9612249732017517,
-0.41873612999916077,
0.7731143832206726,
-0.4473239779472351,
0.09908431023359299,
0.6827911138534546,
0.7371115684509277,
-0.33681610226631165,
0.689571738243103,
0.21740375459194183,
-0.16818203032016754,
0.31548872590065,
0.5003023743629456,
0.7342748641967773,
-0.6492673754692078,
0.9834347367286682,
-0.627111554145813,
-0.35478639602661133,
-0.16486844420433044,
-0.5814603567123413,
-0.9757774472236633,
-0.6739211082458496,
-0.20658990740776062,
-0.20780633389949799,
-0.21210823953151703,
0.7551245093345642,
1.1481295824050903,
-0.6142144203186035,
-0.49164828658103943,
-0.2882564663887024,
-0.17551541328430176,
0.013154629617929459,
-0.11451473832130432,
0.17550112307071686,
0.09175273776054382,
-0.6252836585044861,
0.4674353301525116,
0.38828131556510925,
0.3399982154369354,
-0.3168853521347046,
-0.32624995708465576,
0.284458726644516,
-0.11262412369251251,
0.46696746349334717,
0.5001310706138611,
-0.7405122518539429,
-0.30008387565612793,
-0.03271195665001869,
-0.5170630812644958,
-0.18956108391284943,
1.2503013610839844,
-0.6114956140518188,
0.29457733035087585,
0.24467962980270386,
0.4589662551879883,
0.30663901567459106,
-0.34063515067100525,
1.0293724536895752,
-0.39874130487442017,
0.43299025297164917,
0.20813938975334167,
0.5096787810325623,
0.5304405689239502,
-0.05886608362197876,
0.45859360694885254,
0.08900001645088196,
-0.3773370087146759,
-0.8628602027893066,
0.3688349425792694,
-0.9438991546630859,
0.2231372743844986,
1.1240839958190918,
-0.1875046193599701,
0.15352003276348114,
-0.44969114661216736,
-0.28919339179992676,
0.07495326548814774,
-0.29961898922920227,
0.7887863516807556,
0.46959424018859863,
-0.27693626284599304,
-0.6358798146247864,
-0.9869049787521362,
0.7642673254013062,
0.24908721446990967,
-0.9792079925537109,
0.1271362006664276,
0.27967971563339233,
0.23129844665527344,
-0.07030991464853287,
1.2418335676193237,
-0.2542150318622589,
0.5356853604316711,
0.2720703184604645,
-0.32765600085258484,
-0.042514968663454056,
-0.345450758934021,
-0.3032177984714508,
0.20085260272026062,
0.3452508747577667,
-0.2466271072626114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14215v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14215v1
|
Text-Tuple-Table: Towards Information Integration in Text-to-Table Generation via Global Tuple Extraction
| 2024-04-22T14:31:28 | 2024-04-22T14:31:28 |
Zheye Deng, Chunkit Chan, Weiqi Wang, Yuxi Sun, Wei Fan, Tianshi Zheng, Yauwai Yim, Yangqiu Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The task of condensing large chunks of textual information into concise and
structured tables has gained attention recently due to the emergence of Large
Language Models (LLMs) and their potential benefit for downstream tasks, such
as text summarization and text mining. Previous approaches often generate
tables that directly replicate information from the text, limiting their
applicability in broader contexts, as text-to-table generation in real-life
scenarios necessitates information extraction, reasoning, and integration.
However, there is a lack of both datasets and methodologies towards this task.
In this paper, we introduce LiveSum, a new benchmark dataset created for
generating summary tables of competitions based on real-time commentary texts.
We evaluate the performances of state-of-the-art LLMs on this task in both
fine-tuning and zero-shot settings, and additionally propose a novel pipeline
called $T^3$(Text-Tuple-Table) to improve their performances. Extensive
experimental results demonstrate that LLMs still struggle with this task even
after fine-tuning, while our approach can offer substantial performance gains
without explicit training. Further analyses demonstrate that our method
exhibits strong generalization abilities, surpassing previous approaches on
several other text-to-table datasets. Our code and data can be found at
https://github.com/HKUST-KnowComp/LiveSum-TTT.
|
[
-0.18736262619495392,
-0.8281383514404297,
0.558864951133728,
0.08802110701799393,
-0.5791505575180054,
0.1632198989391327,
-0.28632113337516785,
-0.602214515209198,
0.2074805200099945,
0.4112192392349243,
-0.21593406796455383,
-0.5375352501869202,
-0.6189902424812317,
0.02110643871128559,
-0.5105371475219727,
1.2832591533660889,
0.01563946157693863,
-0.1862204521894455,
-0.12253007292747498,
-0.05433802679181099,
-0.4158291816711426,
-0.614353358745575,
-0.12160814553499222,
-0.24170833826065063,
0.3826383948326111,
0.7553998231887817,
0.4108598530292511,
0.7799033522605896,
0.3457788825035095,
0.11698135733604431,
0.004107156302779913,
0.4112388789653778,
-0.5822960734367371,
0.5667091608047485,
0.08954405784606934,
-0.19350722432136536,
-0.48792383074760437,
-0.07857300341129303,
0.8693386316299438,
0.5734121203422546,
-0.09237842261791229,
0.3778991103172302,
0.41514769196510315,
0.7190916538238525,
-0.6155837774276733,
0.442035436630249,
-0.6865280866622925,
0.4129785895347595,
-0.39232712984085083,
-0.28842586278915405,
-0.40457937121391296,
-0.6038805246353149,
-0.01153278537094593,
-0.41927677392959595,
0.08039557933807373,
-0.10478261858224869,
0.88182133436203,
0.08160259574651718,
-0.23326267302036285,
-0.12647081911563873,
-0.8019973039627075,
0.5662553906440735,
-0.8191056251525879,
0.327324777841568,
-0.10180030763149261,
0.23932179808616638,
-0.3289768099784851,
-0.799635112285614,
-0.38583922386169434,
-0.1364181935787201,
-0.17835502326488495,
0.21878986060619354,
0.07885100692510605,
-0.25447365641593933,
0.1411893367767334,
0.38325628638267517,
-0.47235631942749023,
-0.35535258054733276,
-0.24089916050434113,
0.2824752926826477,
0.584555447101593,
0.04786631092429161,
0.12196057289838791,
-0.16820259392261505,
0.031818464398384094,
0.254439115524292,
-0.7015287280082703,
-0.40987780690193176,
0.061401549726724625,
0.5864565372467041,
-0.412080317735672,
0.8445041179656982,
-0.3889109492301941,
0.7619056105613708,
-0.3456357717514038,
-0.031884271651506424,
-0.009090824984014034,
-0.3534385859966278,
-0.10312531143426895,
-0.007742358837276697,
0.9962925314903259,
0.2729962468147278,
0.7470915913581848,
-0.6548258662223816,
0.030525919049978256,
0.13905192911624908,
0.035978153347969055,
-0.7664873600006104,
-0.10529810935258865,
0.09218034148216248,
-0.11224623769521713,
-0.6356186270713806,
0.1857234239578247,
-1.0865180492401123,
-0.40299367904663086,
-0.13476990163326263,
0.380018413066864,
-0.1659785360097885,
-0.06690722703933716,
-0.09712274372577667,
-0.1824028491973877,
0.18071748316287994,
0.09902415424585342,
-0.5481176972389221,
0.41910213232040405,
0.7156093120574951,
1.1537755727767944,
-0.6099360585212708,
-0.14775462448596954,
-1.1715900897979736,
0.5701999664306641,
-0.07924862951040268,
1.126366376876831,
-0.4603320062160492,
-0.5478661060333252,
0.23365160822868347,
-0.31643447279930115,
0.205962136387825,
-0.49629315733909607,
0.38830408453941345,
-0.22040630877017975,
0.24420534074306488,
-0.26188722252845764,
-0.5612044930458069,
0.3608309030532837,
0.3469364643096924,
-0.6430587768554688,
1.3621472120285034,
-0.19711269438266754,
-0.7651118040084839,
0.30286872386932373,
-0.6296708583831787,
-0.8631231784820557,
0.06694157421588898,
-0.5651689767837524,
-0.8685473203659058,
0.12808898091316223,
0.15917275846004486,
0.8233458995819092,
-0.406960129737854,
0.5088821649551392,
-0.40702322125434875,
-0.2692916691303253,
0.0741797685623169,
-0.08148914575576782,
0.363617479801178,
0.20312200486660004,
-0.3654436767101288,
-0.1868262141942978,
-1.025097131729126,
-0.047261349856853485,
0.16107478737831116,
-0.5829809904098511,
0.14865507185459137,
0.4553764760494232,
0.015003811568021774,
0.054008256644010544,
-0.15594014525413513,
-0.40573495626449585,
0.39494141936302185,
-0.2055758535861969,
0.5915340781211853,
0.1991245299577713,
0.3659575879573822,
0.44644248485565186,
-0.5661001801490784,
0.27900105714797974,
-0.08775913715362549,
-0.26029860973358154,
-0.026075715199112892,
-0.37258803844451904,
-0.7730140089988708,
0.02459879033267498,
0.5676343441009521,
0.5300606489181519,
-0.5540909171104431,
0.43567055463790894,
-0.7088884115219116,
-0.7320621609687805,
0.18709678947925568,
-0.10244446992874146,
0.20488512516021729,
0.6075359582901001,
0.26043701171875,
0.007115162443369627,
-0.6113536953926086,
-0.6076598763465881,
-0.6647401452064514,
0.014520364813506603,
-0.10872799903154373,
-0.05789388343691826,
0.4047645628452301,
0.18255595862865448,
0.8848910331726074,
-0.5571921467781067,
-0.4398837685585022,
-0.6569093465805054,
0.20000578463077545,
0.13416893780231476,
0.5463746786117554,
0.3648318648338318,
-0.41033226251602173,
-0.6653860211372375,
0.04585995152592659,
-0.806526780128479,
-0.32359954714775085,
-0.0568866990506649,
-0.223822221159935,
0.2180318981409073,
0.6453965306282043,
-0.2733893394470215,
0.4875554144382477,
0.3696819543838501,
-0.24621456861495972,
0.5470863580703735,
0.012819812633097172,
0.09449898451566696,
-1.2161401510238647,
0.36090371012687683,
0.09060866385698318,
-0.5482842922210693,
-0.569473385810852,
-0.1459144949913025,
-0.01795976795256138,
-0.12696918845176697,
-0.3550322651863098,
0.7275770902633667,
-0.6010000109672546,
-0.30411356687545776,
0.13454501330852509,
0.5506904125213623,
0.1265164613723755,
0.5286933183670044,
0.24626657366752625,
0.8142416477203369,
-0.024474546313285828,
-0.8720949292182922,
0.05557132139801979,
0.2753228545188904,
-0.49971237778663635,
0.36926543712615967,
-0.4710000455379486,
-0.012055279687047005,
0.12395261228084564,
0.10236217826604843,
-0.922042727470398,
-0.4407586455345154,
0.22186823189258575,
-0.4707380533218384,
0.1685163527727127,
-0.14801770448684692,
-0.5088488459587097,
0.15214870870113373,
-0.5051460862159729,
0.1520962119102478,
0.27979281544685364,
-0.24579720199108124,
0.8371641039848328,
0.8474467396736145,
-0.22575631737709045,
-0.602847695350647,
-0.8150683045387268,
0.14196720719337463,
-0.26545968651771545,
-0.3392958343029022,
0.6111246943473816,
0.07275836169719696,
-0.2711835503578186,
-0.12205561995506287,
-0.055506642907857895,
0.10973041504621506,
0.09828857332468033,
0.08193597942590714,
0.16806598007678986,
0.15790916979312897,
0.1503448635339737,
0.08539651334285736,
-0.055568769574165344,
-0.17599710822105408,
-0.06433092057704926,
0.5557023286819458,
0.08161457628011703,
0.17841772735118866,
-0.3299312889575958,
0.39572787284851074,
0.302467405796051,
-0.1916305273771286,
0.5967296361923218,
0.07750347256660461,
-0.5034613013267517,
-0.3167586624622345,
-0.596900224685669,
0.16343699395656586,
-0.34785372018814087,
0.40096747875213623,
-0.4082472026348114,
-0.5841804146766663,
0.6928485631942749,
0.04250070080161095,
0.6520634293556213,
0.5245521068572998,
0.7002595067024231,
-0.27262789011001587,
0.8689605593681335,
0.5226910710334778,
-0.03460503742098808,
0.6785122752189636,
-0.22750547528266907,
-0.09364648163318634,
-0.5726933479309082,
-0.26269418001174927,
-0.852975070476532,
-0.26525455713272095,
-0.43513140082359314,
-0.08821512013673782,
0.499470591545105,
-0.27479416131973267,
-0.3220842480659485,
0.2288465052843094,
-0.32087787985801697,
0.6286244988441467,
0.3504715859889984,
-0.0037431700620800257,
0.7297449111938477,
0.17835761606693268,
-0.07559704780578613,
-0.09621543437242508,
-0.899228036403656,
-0.5012147426605225,
0.9698032140731812,
0.009800199419260025,
0.7114680409431458,
0.002816525287926197,
0.54811692237854,
0.6180388927459717,
0.504708468914032,
-0.8016541004180908,
0.6112100481987,
-0.20366734266281128,
-0.398686945438385,
-0.20402321219444275,
-0.47037026286125183,
-0.7440899610519409,
0.16347560286521912,
-0.6026973724365234,
-0.7219708561897278,
-0.30218857526779175,
0.23421674966812134,
-0.3474598526954651,
0.41033580899238586,
-0.560271143913269,
0.7457818388938904,
-0.08443790674209595,
-0.7065498232841492,
0.3127146363258362,
-0.5965461134910583,
0.3478260934352875,
-0.12408037483692169,
0.49897897243499756,
-0.11012694984674454,
0.09003493189811707,
1.0126622915267944,
-0.7089914679527283,
0.5867549777030945,
-0.013999073766171932,
-0.07536827772855759,
0.29973483085632324,
0.2822791039943695,
0.7251161336898804,
0.27457988262176514,
-0.16511604189872742,
0.0362539067864418,
0.13119128346443176,
-0.21580421924591064,
-0.35723039507865906,
0.5633846521377563,
-0.5240627527236938,
-0.1219118982553482,
-0.6329730153083801,
-0.4073302447795868,
-0.7227095365524292,
0.20357616245746613,
0.46223095059394836,
0.6398998498916626,
-0.22913171350955963,
0.3537815809249878,
0.28548315167427063,
-0.06101532280445099,
0.43604063987731934,
0.21022580564022064,
-0.24238160252571106,
-0.5837549567222595,
0.7415580153465271,
0.3798366189002991,
0.08055073767900467,
0.4685926139354706,
0.08930835872888565,
-0.20428071916103363,
-0.48179519176483154,
-0.33572107553482056,
0.38635769486427307,
-0.3781069815158844,
-0.6217019557952881,
-0.7528848648071289,
-0.28410688042640686,
-0.3815397024154663,
-0.03430020064115524,
-0.30462995171546936,
-0.7409608364105225,
-0.2409452646970749,
-0.09632086008787155,
0.18514332175254822,
0.8086680173873901,
-0.06990325450897217,
0.5995662212371826,
-1.170536756515503,
0.4014829993247986,
0.15809737145900726,
0.510353684425354,
-0.021631646901369095,
-0.5545759201049805,
-0.4367716610431671,
-0.3293655514717102,
-0.2294764667749405,
-1.0488659143447876,
0.4380987584590912,
0.39649930596351624,
0.3597838878631592,
-0.09576507657766342,
0.017081305384635925,
0.689910352230072,
-0.6558641791343689,
0.7580795884132385,
-0.11975175142288208,
-0.9011104106903076,
0.36693307757377625,
-0.35794365406036377,
0.3643820881843567,
0.786132276058197,
-0.047624621540308,
-0.8900119066238403,
-0.4769207239151001,
-0.5638325214385986,
-0.6938576102256775,
0.6773601770401001,
0.3112117350101471,
-0.19097404181957245,
0.19120362401008606,
0.5412307977676392,
0.18936607241630554,
0.2503412961959839,
-0.9930394291877747,
-0.08539064973592758,
0.17753559350967407,
-0.3349086046218872,
0.20896455645561218,
-0.327668160200119,
0.16292297840118408,
0.017438581213355064,
0.976732075214386,
-0.0315043106675148,
0.15345293283462524,
0.009722204878926277,
-0.2568831145763397,
-0.1391506791114807,
0.23158898949623108,
0.32329079508781433,
0.5661628842353821,
-0.29242733120918274,
0.17917178571224213,
0.2592054307460785,
-0.5619343519210815,
-0.15926621854305267,
0.21600095927715302,
-0.29275286197662354,
0.16888736188411713,
0.4357430934906006,
0.31374070048332214,
0.24135611951351166,
-0.6086074709892273,
0.3957194685935974,
-0.32945701479911804,
-0.3366106152534485,
-0.2804994285106659,
0.07025231420993805,
-0.04894912987947464,
0.10848134011030197,
0.35446691513061523,
-0.42628851532936096,
0.09668580442667007,
-0.5409253835678101,
0.32391753792762756,
0.3633289933204651,
-0.41222476959228516,
-0.2950831949710846,
0.9155054688453674,
0.299112468957901,
-0.35686391592025757,
0.3004835844039917,
0.05252543091773987,
-0.36685609817504883,
0.2519659399986267,
0.3658243715763092,
0.6784414649009705,
0.22911223769187927,
0.13617660105228424,
0.4407363831996918,
-0.06483659148216248,
-0.1654142439365387,
0.4674880802631378,
-0.3098221719264984,
-0.6188151836395264,
-0.6140674352645874,
-0.46918848156929016,
-0.588921844959259,
0.5142881870269775,
-0.4076075255870819,
0.5743322372436523,
-0.19693388044834137,
-0.048406053334474564,
0.14720560610294342,
0.1525970995426178,
-0.3969794511795044,
0.027813881635665894,
0.19699177145957947,
0.9727439880371094,
-0.7815477848052979,
0.7411686182022095,
0.41373908519744873,
-0.31863126158714294,
-0.5211883187294006,
0.00390799343585968,
-0.16490322351455688,
-0.27963975071907043,
-0.005105148069560528,
0.1056981086730957,
0.03384331986308098,
0.01580660790205002,
-0.6760271787643433,
-0.5906748175621033,
0.7331823706626892,
0.44093459844589233,
-0.5698246955871582,
-0.3614387512207031,
0.5334885120391846,
0.22266973555088043,
-0.22474423050880432,
0.045662280172109604,
0.9085264801979065,
0.41972312331199646,
-0.04232539236545563,
-0.5761474967002869,
-0.21435557305812836,
-0.3199980556964874,
-0.3076888620853424,
0.3402903378009796,
-0.6241254210472107,
0.4055764377117157,
0.10382470488548279,
-0.43993550539016724,
0.010739692486822605,
0.8703224658966064,
0.5347549915313721,
0.030897311866283417,
0.3070363700389862,
0.3405446410179138,
0.3689267337322235,
-0.2829305827617645,
0.6977820992469788,
-0.3865832984447479,
0.3763273060321808,
1.4167425632476807,
-0.21880517899990082,
0.8104387521743774,
0.4247148931026459,
-0.11639682948589325,
0.3420601487159729,
0.3755279779434204,
0.1874675750732422,
0.37005674839019775,
0.1128966435790062,
-0.163854718208313,
-0.2954750657081604,
0.04631728306412697,
-0.34978437423706055,
0.33438920974731445,
0.40497472882270813,
-0.04512147605419159,
-0.6280447840690613,
-0.34370821714401245,
0.4127149283885956,
0.2579643130302429,
0.051241204142570496,
0.9986157417297363,
-0.07513610273599625,
-0.8444119691848755,
0.23013587296009064,
-0.1578710675239563,
0.5008572340011597,
-0.5341587662696838,
-0.2725783586502075,
-0.43404287099838257,
0.05937280133366585,
-0.12385798245668411,
-0.782871663570404,
0.27196043729782104,
0.47647207975387573,
0.2137184739112854,
0.03902628645300865,
0.6254578828811646,
-0.39834800362586975,
-0.44793063402175903,
-0.03209769353270531,
0.739844560623169,
0.19038477540016174,
-0.045584388077259064,
-0.3885248005390167,
0.1551908403635025,
-0.0840970128774643,
-0.4076370298862457,
0.133948415517807,
0.513313353061676,
0.07098416984081268,
0.32607609033584595,
0.264371782541275,
0.3426850140094757,
-0.029793070629239082,
0.07202279567718506,
0.8245626091957092,
-0.8374765515327454,
-0.6352980136871338,
-1.0139193534851074,
0.6151900291442871,
-0.3307690918445587,
-0.24771267175674438,
0.37170174717903137,
1.1670851707458496,
0.5794607996940613,
0.007665240205824375,
1.1770472526550293,
-0.21806509792804718,
0.8725365400314331,
-0.41540732979774475,
0.7155237793922424,
-0.6342617273330688,
0.25273221731185913,
-0.29224634170532227,
-1.0921790599822998,
-0.7445882558822632,
0.3232763707637787,
-0.13876332342624664,
-0.269308477640152,
0.4052641987800598,
0.4030218720436096,
-0.09701688587665558,
-0.06800458580255508,
0.12641823291778564,
0.15507102012634277,
0.6653039455413818,
0.41966453194618225,
0.6716891527175903,
-0.5848863124847412,
0.923346996307373,
-0.07851477712392807,
-0.07055453211069107,
-0.2597309947013855,
-1.2792226076126099,
-0.7166305780410767,
-0.6472430229187012,
-0.14053203165531158,
-0.6072733998298645,
0.2181565761566162,
0.9557294845581055,
0.4164535701274872,
-0.8658164739608765,
-0.4301907420158386,
-0.2265215814113617,
-0.08426636457443237,
0.03006083518266678,
-0.18462015688419342,
0.4689747989177704,
-0.44634243845939636,
-0.8303648233413696,
0.03509904444217682,
0.2824103534221649,
0.05136087164282799,
-0.08755169808864594,
0.19574233889579773,
-0.31397372484207153,
0.07325868308544159,
0.6148537397384644,
0.42095422744750977,
-0.027597960084676743,
-0.2985280752182007,
-0.21570032835006714,
0.024977542459964752,
0.49835366010665894,
0.6847588419914246,
-1.005757451057434,
0.1862475723028183,
0.6762362122535706,
0.6580030918121338,
0.9361186623573303,
0.08854221552610397,
0.7018570899963379,
-0.857398509979248,
0.07722669094800949,
0.17847204208374023,
0.3526286780834198,
0.23320268094539642,
-0.1326671689748764,
1.0181382894515991,
0.20042750239372253,
-0.587515115737915,
-1.018373727798462,
0.06388814002275467,
-1.0319724082946777,
-0.047248709946870804,
1.3036787509918213,
0.25580742955207825,
-0.31136032938957214,
-0.05610765144228935,
-0.19018016755580902,
0.7321798801422119,
-0.4495168626308441,
1.035651445388794,
0.6710662245750427,
-0.14919036626815796,
0.12674497067928314,
-0.594257116317749,
0.7247506976127625,
0.1461358219385147,
-1.3273226022720337,
0.5203189253807068,
0.5394721031188965,
0.0963909924030304,
-0.11138809472322464,
0.5918200612068176,
-0.3387090861797333,
0.13861697912216187,
-0.36537033319473267,
-0.01039308775216341,
0.0749828889966011,
-0.277041494846344,
-0.016306720674037933,
0.3943959176540375,
-0.09628540277481079,
0.008718352764844894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14209v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14209v1
|
EnzChemRED, a rich enzyme chemistry relation extraction dataset
| 2024-04-22T14:18:34 | 2024-04-22T14:18:34 |
Po-Ting Lai, Elisabeth Coudert, Lucila Aimo, Kristian Axelsen, Lionel Breuza, Edouard de Castro, Marc Feuermann, Anne Morgat, Lucille Pourcel, Ivo Pedruzzi, Sylvain Poux, Nicole Redaschi, Catherine Rivoire, Anastasia Sveshnikova, Chih-Hsuan Wei, Robert Leaman, Ling Luo, Zhiyong Lu, Alan Bridge
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Expert curation is essential to capture knowledge of enzyme functions from
the scientific literature in FAIR open knowledgebases but cannot keep pace with
the rate of new discoveries and new publications. In this work we present
EnzChemRED, for Enzyme Chemistry Relation Extraction Dataset, a new training
and benchmarking dataset to support the development of Natural Language
Processing (NLP) methods such as (large) language models that can assist enzyme
curation. EnzChemRED consists of 1,210 expert curated PubMed abstracts in which
enzymes and the chemical reactions they catalyze are annotated using
identifiers from the UniProt Knowledgebase (UniProtKB) and the ontology of
Chemical Entities of Biological Interest (ChEBI). We show that fine-tuning
pre-trained language models with EnzChemRED can significantly boost their
ability to identify mentions of proteins and chemicals in text (Named Entity
Recognition, or NER) and to extract the chemical conversions in which they
participate (Relation Extraction, or RE), with average F1 score of 86.30% for
NER, 86.66% for RE for chemical conversion pairs, and 83.79% for RE for
chemical conversion pairs and linked enzymes. We combine the best performing
methods after fine-tuning using EnzChemRED to create an end-to-end pipeline for
knowledge extraction from text and apply this to abstracts at PubMed scale to
create a draft map of enzyme functions in literature to guide curation efforts
in UniProtKB and the reaction knowledgebase Rhea. The EnzChemRED corpus is
freely available at https://ftp.expasy.org/databases/rhea/nlp/.
|
[
-0.42914652824401855,
-0.4761524796485901,
0.6303048133850098,
-0.19815054535865784,
0.01441335678100586,
0.08916987478733063,
-0.3215574026107788,
-0.5234041213989258,
0.32783904671669006,
0.7815867066383362,
-0.5987980961799622,
-0.5307012796401978,
-0.7008705139160156,
0.6755024194717407,
-0.12264680862426758,
1.075173258781433,
-0.18101318180561066,
0.28724730014801025,
-0.31476882100105286,
0.18361219763755798,
0.34679993987083435,
-0.08711570501327515,
-0.4936148524284363,
-0.5875150561332703,
0.536919116973877,
0.4513189494609833,
0.31265053153038025,
0.566398024559021,
0.8156529664993286,
0.216399148106575,
0.1599711924791336,
0.3593582510948181,
-0.29059889912605286,
0.43641966581344604,
-0.5188284516334534,
-0.180841326713562,
-0.5134039521217346,
0.21564479172229767,
0.1783819943666458,
0.7635143399238586,
0.0389404222369194,
0.3436447083950043,
0.04752064868807793,
0.9770042300224304,
-0.7696419954299927,
0.4274538457393646,
-0.565886378288269,
0.11942176520824432,
-0.32864126563072205,
-0.1253807693719864,
-0.291770339012146,
-0.3602551817893982,
0.06291225552558899,
-0.49444547295570374,
0.35626062750816345,
0.13290220499038696,
0.9518742561340332,
0.33603474497795105,
-0.38224461674690247,
-0.17281991243362427,
-0.4378872215747833,
0.5153400897979736,
-0.5162644386291504,
0.5536788105964661,
0.3868720531463623,
0.45803362131118774,
-0.6093567609786987,
-0.9644949436187744,
-0.6470313668251038,
0.02568730339407921,
0.04537367820739746,
0.1368042528629303,
0.09128772467374802,
0.17458531260490417,
0.24474377930164337,
0.59553062915802,
-0.3273499011993408,
-0.2206742912530899,
-0.40261390805244446,
-0.2568443715572357,
0.39251551032066345,
0.19515757262706757,
0.3376099765300751,
-0.10092167556285858,
-0.2478569746017456,
-0.025964340195059776,
-0.5864275097846985,
-0.021478265523910522,
0.26969558000564575,
0.37079983949661255,
0.37852224707603455,
0.5885103940963745,
-0.5335763096809387,
0.4793510138988495,
0.07309676706790924,
0.36661139130592346,
0.3824547231197357,
-0.3832329213619232,
-0.12448123097419739,
0.27857905626296997,
0.734071671962738,
0.2223186045885086,
0.28357404470443726,
-0.5127995610237122,
0.013041084632277489,
0.14390014111995697,
0.22704501450061798,
-1.2178089618682861,
-0.7316083312034607,
0.3127692639827728,
-0.15541592240333557,
0.04161911457777023,
0.17001821100711823,
-0.9654455780982971,
-0.38636770844459534,
-0.0884462371468544,
0.2335738241672516,
-0.18962623178958893,
-0.1554265320301056,
0.40072691440582275,
-0.5801428556442261,
0.1460370570421219,
0.047659981995821,
-0.759861409664154,
0.6796838045120239,
0.5011884570121765,
0.42124465107917786,
-0.49824240803718567,
-0.03936868533492088,
-0.7364850640296936,
0.3276762068271637,
0.014496013522148132,
0.8593553304672241,
-0.7482201457023621,
0.343865305185318,
-0.22503991425037384,
0.2741377055644989,
-0.18980391323566437,
-0.7685036659240723,
0.5725765824317932,
-0.4935750961303711,
-0.03495107591152191,
-0.3457278609275818,
-0.6179745197296143,
-0.08642863482236862,
0.01217623520642519,
-1.0492621660232544,
0.8846075534820557,
0.22982904314994812,
-0.7740185856819153,
0.3238505423069,
-0.6929110288619995,
-0.3529452681541443,
0.24603521823883057,
-0.08287867903709412,
-0.16881690919399261,
-0.02744428627192974,
0.22759300470352173,
0.28236687183380127,
-0.5789933204650879,
0.2582853138446808,
-0.33386456966400146,
0.19151441752910614,
0.3003966510295868,
0.35447418689727783,
0.57952880859375,
0.3031497299671173,
-0.08576600253582001,
-0.07072053849697113,
-1.0222114324569702,
0.2040715515613556,
-0.29788070917129517,
-0.4495275914669037,
-0.25119709968566895,
-0.0030090606305748224,
0.09011906385421753,
0.48063597083091736,
0.13998836278915405,
-1.0138976573944092,
-0.11518897116184235,
-0.6001488566398621,
0.5345272421836853,
0.3404066860675812,
0.6413139700889587,
0.23129451274871826,
0.11262454837560654,
0.24235230684280396,
-0.14363588392734528,
-0.0835300087928772,
0.2180301696062088,
-0.47534430027008057,
-0.8766720294952393,
-0.2733277380466461,
0.49513617157936096,
0.2555087208747864,
-0.5907274484634399,
0.5698952078819275,
-0.27723801136016846,
-0.44979482889175415,
-0.8971803784370422,
0.4706255793571472,
0.4377323389053345,
0.6704432368278503,
0.6236966848373413,
-0.4783971905708313,
-0.5477981567382812,
-1.00322687625885,
-0.656907320022583,
0.0848594605922699,
-0.17358025908470154,
-0.164790078997612,
0.6837635040283203,
-0.32981687784194946,
0.9978837966918945,
-0.5600101947784424,
-0.5009410381317139,
-0.18625681102275848,
-0.009448220953345299,
0.309247225522995,
0.26675888895988464,
0.1003163754940033,
-0.4510827958583832,
-0.6689902544021606,
0.1821078509092331,
-0.5667932629585266,
-0.3396153450012207,
0.5019623637199402,
-0.7382614612579346,
-0.15316297113895416,
0.4851366877555847,
-0.7575719356536865,
-0.01675243116915226,
0.15237541496753693,
-0.3571590483188629,
0.2179732471704483,
0.23884490132331848,
0.13709717988967896,
-0.9098345637321472,
0.5187541246414185,
0.08094550669193268,
-0.24660220742225647,
-0.6429985165596008,
0.17750658094882965,
0.03365243971347809,
-0.028025155887007713,
-0.44036203622817993,
0.4327537715435028,
-0.5575292110443115,
0.23394817113876343,
-0.11687206476926804,
0.04654238000512123,
0.35113877058029175,
0.4562222361564636,
0.26143261790275574,
0.11268573999404907,
0.3899216055870056,
-0.4919414520263672,
0.3159860372543335,
0.47484150528907776,
-0.18969406187534332,
0.14388038218021393,
-0.5047386288642883,
0.010174990631639957,
0.14554020762443542,
0.02990175224840641,
-0.9482833743095398,
-0.37770897150039673,
0.33973169326782227,
-0.4058306813240051,
0.3061455488204956,
-0.19626514613628387,
-0.63555508852005,
-0.14318124949932098,
-0.2622539699077606,
-0.21811449527740479,
0.2792757749557495,
-0.4189727306365967,
0.6919265389442444,
0.6320135593414307,
-0.20595496892929077,
-0.2573778033256531,
-0.30853116512298584,
-0.20227792859077454,
0.05410107225179672,
-0.33648577332496643,
0.1274680644273758,
0.040336161851882935,
-0.0452575646340847,
0.11243598908185959,
-0.5557668209075928,
-0.21435712277889252,
-0.12971681356430054,
0.2693474292755127,
-0.030824515968561172,
0.18094706535339355,
0.21376122534275055,
0.09326670318841934,
-0.30156657099723816,
0.39061933755874634,
0.2746710777282715,
0.3737848699092865,
0.07954937219619751,
0.13664138317108154,
0.002936928765848279,
0.09936301410198212,
0.42123037576675415,
-0.4773690104484558,
0.6129027009010315,
0.6057575941085815,
-0.48269298672676086,
-0.15605905652046204,
-0.27470433712005615,
-0.546230137348175,
-0.4479125738143921,
0.46593937277793884,
-0.20430608093738556,
-0.6899346709251404,
0.5200036764144897,
-0.38057005405426025,
0.07659252732992172,
0.7070087194442749,
0.22022949159145355,
0.0863499864935875,
0.649077296257019,
0.6057734489440918,
-0.06760834902524948,
-0.10183602571487427,
-0.056507840752601624,
0.3629295527935028,
-0.9763154983520508,
-0.4764338433742523,
-0.856377363204956,
-0.26008978486061096,
-0.22519908845424652,
-0.4442461431026459,
0.1876527965068817,
-0.11836947500705719,
-0.44046592712402344,
0.36473551392555237,
-0.24184150993824005,
0.44908633828163147,
0.12943513691425323,
0.3143771290779114,
0.47170644998550415,
0.4604853689670563,
-0.14666302502155304,
-0.2101096212863922,
-0.5661045908927917,
-0.3034188449382782,
1.1773813962936401,
0.28426703810691833,
0.696825385093689,
-0.1499215066432953,
0.6285271048545837,
0.09055599570274353,
0.3949105441570282,
-0.5718483328819275,
0.5170126557350159,
0.07991576939821243,
-0.5901908874511719,
-0.22666142880916595,
-0.5137231349945068,
-0.7186282873153687,
0.01511986181139946,
-0.5155321359634399,
-0.508246898651123,
0.14354142546653748,
-0.09345986694097519,
0.06795989722013474,
0.05963750183582306,
-0.41110759973526,
0.8044785261154175,
0.05393477529287338,
-0.5165520906448364,
0.06035662442445755,
-0.8014799952507019,
0.020765015855431557,
-0.19698479771614075,
-0.006453588139265776,
-0.19232241809368134,
0.11560197919607162,
1.0155085325241089,
-0.497423380613327,
0.5051953792572021,
0.1262899786233902,
0.04353366792201996,
0.2054925560951233,
0.18918651342391968,
0.3556666970252991,
-0.23433728516101837,
-0.2382589876651764,
0.20826774835586548,
-0.21998052299022675,
-0.035544052720069885,
-0.5039092302322388,
0.6125611662864685,
-0.45999711751937866,
-0.34767577052116394,
-0.3235242962837219,
-0.1895182728767395,
-0.329211950302124,
0.5138023495674133,
0.23464088141918182,
0.15205447375774384,
-0.014418442733585835,
0.19757841527462006,
0.758928656578064,
0.1272367238998413,
0.33837878704071045,
0.7776204347610474,
0.009702859446406364,
-0.46917641162872314,
0.6507546901702881,
-0.2320280224084854,
0.0887976661324501,
0.5433939695358276,
-0.1521381288766861,
-0.32400625944137573,
-0.18782712519168854,
-0.2694002091884613,
0.17808178067207336,
-0.8198595643043518,
-0.4335593283176422,
-0.9602674245834351,
-0.2799361050128937,
-0.45859330892562866,
0.13470914959907532,
-0.522816002368927,
-0.46272987127304077,
-0.04256683588027954,
-0.441737562417984,
0.6849325895309448,
0.22361963987350464,
0.13152070343494415,
-0.17339439690113068,
-0.7987982630729675,
0.4630597233772278,
-0.08457630127668381,
0.49053317308425903,
-0.2140990048646927,
-0.20988497138023376,
-0.3021092712879181,
-0.2721045911312103,
-0.19077201187610626,
-1.1476662158966064,
0.4960736632347107,
0.7136907577514648,
0.9388771057128906,
0.16179729998111725,
0.26221486926078796,
0.4015882611274719,
-0.37560322880744934,
0.34838587045669556,
-0.018766017630696297,
-0.546159029006958,
0.5905677676200867,
-0.048031117767095566,
0.1507558822631836,
1.0258475542068481,
0.8532102108001709,
-0.42751815915107727,
-0.5682862997055054,
-0.4130997657775879,
-1.1463711261749268,
0.4888596534729004,
0.2939617931842804,
-0.4036365747451782,
-0.20166203379631042,
0.32689255475997925,
0.36262598633766174,
0.23785801231861115,
-0.546673059463501,
-0.338306725025177,
0.32298746705055237,
-0.48664677143096924,
0.027719145640730858,
0.02033926174044609,
-0.16225364804267883,
-0.47257140278816223,
0.9885596036911011,
-0.07724461704492569,
-0.0459916852414608,
0.2750154435634613,
-0.3754272162914276,
-0.4249970614910126,
0.25750020146369934,
-0.5379906892776489,
0.42269542813301086,
-0.4045608937740326,
0.3696590065956116,
-0.2120603322982788,
-0.7229062914848328,
-0.2855968773365021,
0.29831939935684204,
0.07959725707769394,
-0.13745225965976715,
0.1840054839849472,
0.21091561019420624,
0.11082345992326736,
-0.9528248310089111,
0.1219753623008728,
0.00025767707847990096,
-0.11599179357290268,
0.16083799302577972,
0.28771379590034485,
0.17606061697006226,
0.26332157850265503,
0.26861944794654846,
0.051089413464069366,
0.6490594744682312,
-0.25645342469215393,
0.3987247943878174,
0.2896837890148163,
-0.4014403820037842,
-0.13541802763938904,
0.6487786769866943,
0.38766270875930786,
0.14948128163814545,
0.8633907437324524,
-0.07389452308416367,
-0.4807063937187195,
0.46461713314056396,
0.46700602769851685,
0.8697664737701416,
-0.09831497073173523,
0.1582040637731552,
0.6534377336502075,
0.26502928137779236,
-0.01741623692214489,
0.2871190309524536,
-0.2212235927581787,
-0.6901002526283264,
0.03716472536325455,
-1.1210685968399048,
-0.35312390327453613,
0.20318786799907684,
-0.6814907789230347,
0.19871516525745392,
-0.12615694105625153,
-0.17077793180942535,
0.48708340525627136,
0.445035845041275,
-0.7244133353233337,
-0.1575288623571396,
-0.33179816603660583,
0.7452548742294312,
-1.2354555130004883,
0.5495451092720032,
0.9641949534416199,
-0.4209744930267334,
-0.42859479784965515,
-0.23417752981185913,
-0.31410208344459534,
-0.05113813653588295,
0.626552164554596,
0.23403599858283997,
-0.12234774231910706,
0.08221592009067535,
-0.54901522397995,
-0.7364510297775269,
0.7051997184753418,
0.3785557150840759,
-0.34484773874282837,
0.40492889285087585,
0.2141287475824356,
0.8147900104522705,
-0.44402387738227844,
0.20591193437576294,
0.8172352910041809,
0.6014965176582336,
-0.2584329843521118,
-0.7370398640632629,
0.3822360038757324,
-0.9382004141807556,
-0.4200494587421417,
0.38982462882995605,
-0.2907848358154297,
0.8336706161499023,
-0.07403632253408432,
-0.22037562727928162,
-0.23843523859977722,
0.3650294244289398,
0.1943676918745041,
0.2702539563179016,
-0.10061898082494736,
0.5788731575012207,
0.5412135720252991,
-0.016829077154397964,
0.6281344294548035,
-0.24081085622310638,
0.0538969524204731,
0.9862977862358093,
-0.3562792241573334,
0.8280746340751648,
0.721506655216217,
-0.0314873605966568,
0.7120146155357361,
0.6341147422790527,
-0.27210870385169983,
0.775092601776123,
0.07551540434360504,
-0.19076266884803772,
-0.45494014024734497,
0.07408398389816284,
-0.19330959022045135,
0.10170221328735352,
0.5175341963768005,
-0.720421552658081,
-0.59783536195755,
-0.2186531275510788,
0.082662433385849,
0.21787942945957184,
-0.23872904479503632,
0.6705054640769958,
0.027364365756511688,
-0.6985931396484375,
0.22501002252101898,
-0.0895238146185875,
0.013431483879685402,
-0.5133023262023926,
-0.4803661108016968,
-0.08734948933124542,
0.31027284264564514,
-0.33882203698158264,
-0.7179538607597351,
-0.09555841982364655,
-0.16213184595108032,
-0.4146904945373535,
0.21494293212890625,
1.0646467208862305,
-0.7844699621200562,
-0.3814876675605774,
0.3160748779773712,
0.6400461792945862,
0.3188645541667938,
-0.13833485543727875,
-0.3042994737625122,
-0.2566327452659607,
-0.12600965797901154,
-0.24270565807819366,
0.4688112437725067,
0.39450666308403015,
-0.04662978649139404,
0.673432469367981,
0.6188434958457947,
0.1471836268901825,
-0.128214031457901,
-0.1358518749475479,
1.0622901916503906,
-0.5086103081703186,
-0.32648804783821106,
-0.7474530339241028,
0.08334898948669434,
-0.1652260273694992,
-0.18740306794643402,
0.899665892124176,
0.726392388343811,
0.8317832946777344,
-0.4527381956577301,
0.7019559741020203,
0.028534693643450737,
0.27754849195480347,
-0.37651821970939636,
0.8382174968719482,
-0.2575770318508148,
-0.08668660372495651,
-0.266417533159256,
-1.0045069456100464,
-0.23367151618003845,
0.5206847190856934,
-0.09038088470697403,
0.011870955117046833,
0.8574000000953674,
0.7363505363464355,
0.11269521713256836,
0.1636085957288742,
-0.35440191626548767,
0.14224094152450562,
0.2489195019006729,
0.6728337407112122,
0.1640341877937317,
-0.4455934166908264,
0.0993766337633133,
-0.2135087251663208,
-0.020202552899718285,
-0.07055015116930008,
-0.8796035051345825,
-0.9750550389289856,
-0.4614923298358917,
-0.543231725692749,
-0.34028318524360657,
0.2748280167579651,
1.0289850234985352,
0.21209679543972015,
-0.7566007971763611,
-0.10972519963979721,
-0.1433592140674591,
-0.18028980493545532,
-0.28581929206848145,
-0.19402308762073517,
0.4337906837463379,
-0.2899715304374695,
-0.4524075388908386,
0.2608768343925476,
0.24719367921352386,
-0.41698017716407776,
0.050461191684007645,
-0.11930996924638748,
-0.23844853043556213,
-0.16723781824111938,
0.42858707904815674,
0.4128945767879486,
-0.07645601779222488,
0.07699553668498993,
-0.09850353002548218,
-0.08447235822677612,
0.01350732147693634,
0.5740535855293274,
-0.7616233825683594,
0.6699819564819336,
0.6774410009384155,
0.5870149731636047,
0.5695760846138,
-0.1269722431898117,
0.6513410210609436,
-0.6400706171989441,
-0.4147098660469055,
0.09376221895217896,
0.08404447883367538,
0.37457600235939026,
-0.4705948829650879,
0.7706753015518188,
0.24171249568462372,
-0.3730946481227875,
-0.60350501537323,
-0.11810887604951859,
-0.9107969403266907,
-0.14429114758968353,
1.0351608991622925,
-0.07113678008317947,
-0.5132722854614258,
-0.44169750809669495,
0.07581973820924759,
0.5255587100982666,
-0.534925639629364,
0.7839522361755371,
0.6266359686851501,
-0.4389817714691162,
0.015824493020772934,
-0.49548205733299255,
0.8715718388557434,
0.015316028147935867,
-0.9938865900039673,
0.37257352471351624,
0.4727235436439514,
0.4872797429561615,
0.12535476684570312,
0.5266249775886536,
-0.48871707916259766,
0.20281846821308136,
-0.15927347540855408,
0.5014875531196594,
-0.2916816473007202,
-0.414252907037735,
0.024362890049815178,
0.048634763807058334,
-0.1367025077342987,
0.17511598765850067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14192v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14192v3
|
Swap distance minimization beyond entropy minimization in word order variation
| 2024-04-22T14:01:09 | 2024-05-25T14:10:05 |
Víctor Franco-Sánchez, Arnau Martí-Llobet, Ramon Ferrer-i-Cancho
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, physics.soc-ph
|
Here we consider the problem of all the possible orders of a linguistic
structure formed by $n$ elements, for instance, subject, direct object and verb
($n=3$) or subject, direct object, indirect object and verb ($n=4$). We
investigate if the frequency of the $n!$ possible orders is constrained by two
principles. First, entropy minimization, a principle that has been suggested to
shape natural communication systems at distinct levels of organization. Second,
swap distance minimization, namely a preference for word orders that require
fewer swaps of adjacent elements to be produced from a source order. Here we
present average swap distance, a novel score for research on swap distance
minimization, and investigate the theoretical distribution of that score for
any $n$: its minimum and maximum values and its expected value in die rolling
experiments or when the word order frequencies are shuffled. We investigate
whether entropy and average swap distance are significantly small in distinct
linguistic structures with $n=3$ or $n=4$ in agreement with the corresponding
minimization principles. We find strong evidence of entropy minimization and
swap distance minimization with respect to a die rolling experiment. The
evidence of these two forces with respect to a Polya urn process is strong for
$n=4$ but weaker for $n=3$. We still find evidence of swap distance
minimization when word order frequencies are shuffled, indicating that swap
distance minimization effects are beyond pressure to minimize word order
entropy.
|
[
-0.4500066041946411,
-0.7579205632209778,
0.6329575181007385,
0.16365408897399902,
-0.3250699043273926,
-0.4751855134963989,
0.03228892385959625,
-0.7619851231575012,
0.5506117343902588,
0.1698375791311264,
-0.30851924419403076,
-0.2022719830274582,
-0.6840461492538452,
0.15338504314422607,
-0.43574202060699463,
0.6453025937080383,
0.19989964365959167,
-0.006596015300601721,
-0.12143123149871826,
-0.32400956749916077,
-0.01352315116673708,
-0.5006928443908691,
-0.4373030960559845,
-0.30793073773384094,
0.49687057733535767,
0.18583272397518158,
1.0563242435455322,
0.8815545439720154,
0.5114728212356567,
0.2799156606197357,
-0.29934611916542053,
-0.014076515100896358,
-0.3324134349822998,
0.07760413736104965,
0.0891454815864563,
-0.7698607444763184,
-0.09565980732440948,
0.3631555140018463,
0.7507842779159546,
0.8109346032142639,
-0.4007926285266876,
-0.0005048125749453902,
-0.5039312243461609,
0.8940003514289856,
-0.4307456910610199,
-0.2246474325656891,
-0.601355254650116,
-0.05586322396993637,
-0.6960775852203369,
-0.15778863430023193,
-0.15024222433567047,
-0.5701419711112976,
-0.038997478783130646,
-0.5771043300628662,
0.26806390285491943,
0.3267503082752228,
0.9908769130706787,
0.10359339416027069,
-0.26696571707725525,
-0.044237785041332245,
-0.6358020305633545,
0.8128845691680908,
-0.29591166973114014,
0.5056253671646118,
0.5767381191253662,
0.12757055461406708,
-0.3489556908607483,
-0.22972840070724487,
-0.7246978282928467,
-0.04882035404443741,
0.23279599845409393,
0.13607852160930634,
-0.18692471086978912,
0.18032677471637726,
0.407205730676651,
0.34759417176246643,
-0.3903016149997711,
0.29674631357192993,
-0.46155089139938354,
-0.09938008338212967,
0.5426458716392517,
0.21747063100337982,
0.2744741439819336,
-0.19817155599594116,
-0.42209821939468384,
-0.2850908637046814,
-0.6505163311958313,
-0.009133812971413136,
0.818428099155426,
0.07777688652276993,
0.025004100054502487,
0.6559377312660217,
-0.2163655310869217,
0.6090235114097595,
-0.19147419929504395,
0.1562466025352478,
0.2998804450035095,
-0.3940616548061371,
-0.03608951345086098,
-0.18876002728939056,
0.8281645774841309,
0.3958013951778412,
-0.27284514904022217,
0.028099214658141136,
-0.1990121454000473,
0.08086871355772018,
0.09947017580270767,
-0.3577800691127777,
-0.07308206707239151,
-0.28254345059394836,
-0.6873801946640015,
-0.14239689707756042,
0.36360403895378113,
-0.7045796513557434,
-0.23988884687423706,
-0.24418315291404724,
0.23963488638401031,
-0.5544188618659973,
-0.24470695853233337,
0.19886721670627594,
-0.34715723991394043,
0.40085673332214355,
0.3117629587650299,
-0.9028454422950745,
0.880085289478302,
0.8260066509246826,
1.146275281906128,
-0.40070146322250366,
-0.4123397171497345,
-0.21154269576072693,
0.09021716564893723,
-0.5864661931991577,
0.8726084232330322,
-0.7267217636108398,
-0.4604136347770691,
-0.4835076928138733,
-0.7336292266845703,
-0.022370412945747375,
-0.4868074655532837,
0.06819974631071091,
-0.5494019985198975,
0.4045849144458771,
0.03225510194897652,
-0.7987733483314514,
-0.13655443489551544,
-0.1662459373474121,
-0.6665319800376892,
1.1025421619415283,
0.053706325590610504,
-0.7392416000366211,
0.17452378571033478,
-0.5110945701599121,
-0.4180513620376587,
-0.21926331520080566,
-0.11988912522792816,
0.09438619017601013,
0.6409217715263367,
-0.6472273468971252,
-0.09133761376142502,
-0.4207592010498047,
-0.3738231658935547,
-0.476982057094574,
-0.3872961699962616,
0.3015093505382538,
-0.5668777227401733,
0.6865235567092896,
0.3033207952976227,
-0.25599905848503113,
-0.2172645777463913,
-0.6904249787330627,
0.23445464670658112,
-0.16128651797771454,
-0.48351815342903137,
-0.5967162251472473,
0.06342975050210953,
-0.13266782462596893,
0.1433834284543991,
0.044078242033720016,
-0.3227402865886688,
0.16229142248630524,
-0.5434073209762573,
0.05633125826716423,
0.9996827244758606,
-0.03438699245452881,
0.8436999917030334,
-0.36482852697372437,
0.3479524254798889,
0.2098471075296402,
0.3523053228855133,
0.4518395960330963,
-0.7089876532554626,
-0.5684912204742432,
-0.0962345078587532,
0.2944371998310089,
0.44194209575653076,
-0.4602132737636566,
0.2173933982849121,
-0.13019081950187683,
-0.14732976257801056,
-0.3785983920097351,
-0.05159803852438927,
0.09351889789104462,
-0.04541877284646034,
0.31256064772605896,
-0.2695564329624176,
-0.08145125210285187,
-0.9403238296508789,
-0.3220508098602295,
-0.45128169655799866,
-0.03344300761818886,
-0.024042785167694092,
0.02340615540742874,
-0.1801038682460785,
0.8456358909606934,
-0.8606973886489868,
0.027823658660054207,
0.02096458524465561,
0.3659425973892212,
0.43571585416793823,
0.31021299958229065,
0.4997917115688324,
-0.7126187682151794,
-0.2840069830417633,
-0.10506373643875122,
0.053484026342630386,
-0.26884257793426514,
0.13516387343406677,
-0.3077993094921112,
0.5161678194999695,
0.5819931626319885,
-0.9307390451431274,
0.5372723937034607,
0.2764546573162079,
-0.15841135382652283,
0.31462526321411133,
-0.4172617793083191,
-0.3087697923183441,
-1.0531333684921265,
-0.385389119386673,
-0.1940915435552597,
-0.29563629627227783,
-0.8212680220603943,
-0.18214182555675507,
-0.29863184690475464,
0.2581808567047119,
-0.472532719373703,
0.63897705078125,
-0.5096165537834167,
-0.06605029851198196,
-0.5876665711402893,
0.18000644445419312,
-0.25019603967666626,
0.11633195728063583,
-0.0025427413638681173,
0.007633542641997337,
0.41289252042770386,
-0.8032994866371155,
0.2638128399848938,
0.18107660114765167,
-0.5739247798919678,
0.6560193300247192,
-0.240589439868927,
-0.017744868993759155,
-0.30764561891555786,
0.11221566051244736,
-0.77406245470047,
0.17001834511756897,
0.4628363251686096,
-0.30083081126213074,
0.19378916919231415,
0.2209005504846573,
-0.4463256597518921,
-0.1939113587141037,
-0.42278119921684265,
0.4692847728729248,
0.702031135559082,
-0.19842565059661865,
-0.01397459302097559,
0.2707502543926239,
0.1535288393497467,
-0.36500468850135803,
-0.4689277708530426,
-0.17439642548561096,
-0.2210242599248886,
-0.5483545660972595,
0.44384193420410156,
-0.5066887140274048,
-0.6861819624900818,
-0.19605961441993713,
-0.5608110427856445,
-0.1660182625055313,
-0.08773906528949738,
0.010045613162219524,
-0.20725858211517334,
0.10311512649059296,
0.2403182089328766,
-0.11613982915878296,
-0.3046486973762512,
0.0503452867269516,
-0.15209096670150757,
0.3625924587249756,
0.028158053755760193,
-0.20528358221054077,
-0.034157928079366684,
0.4205886423587799,
0.6075024008750916,
0.4183937609195709,
0.6966211795806885,
0.43232548236846924,
-0.38887283205986023,
-0.18315677344799042,
-0.8993594646453857,
-0.18155640363693237,
-0.5144984126091003,
0.0843292623758316,
-0.43883228302001953,
-0.6827095150947571,
0.34228041768074036,
0.3071586489677429,
-0.24502408504486084,
0.3617892861366272,
0.44370508193969727,
-0.11969979107379913,
0.5247679352760315,
0.5899129509925842,
-0.16833558678627014,
0.7735584378242493,
0.03349519520998001,
0.2679101228713989,
-0.5765135884284973,
0.016169419512152672,
-0.6497249603271484,
-0.535997211933136,
-0.8783669471740723,
-0.8773881196975708,
0.27064141631126404,
0.07566011697053909,
0.019924888387322426,
-0.018148336559534073,
-0.07904448360204697,
0.9333828687667847,
0.7952733635902405,
0.03172537684440613,
0.03111150674521923,
-0.07542561739683151,
-0.37654703855514526,
0.18498684465885162,
-0.7125565409660339,
-0.08744575083255768,
0.3219377398490906,
0.14758576452732086,
0.9280338287353516,
0.11395466327667236,
0.9971178770065308,
0.14738374948501587,
-0.22111675143241882,
-0.7349748015403748,
0.787753701210022,
-0.0942436158657074,
-0.40082067251205444,
-0.6357137560844421,
-0.7744268178939819,
-1.091418981552124,
0.3652607202529907,
0.0704151839017868,
-0.5388346314430237,
0.17043255269527435,
-0.3181028664112091,
-0.09672369062900543,
0.3660930395126343,
-0.6571202874183655,
0.3398545980453491,
-0.07689058035612106,
0.14540037512779236,
-0.3915376663208008,
-0.8509086966514587,
0.2162468284368515,
0.2181011289358139,
0.3310708701610565,
-0.5278068780899048,
-0.2677787244319916,
0.7696492671966553,
-0.7497403025627136,
0.5986276268959045,
-0.033018164336681366,
0.07941041141748428,
0.2776387333869934,
0.33167019486427307,
0.3213360607624054,
-0.1240990087389946,
-0.2178473025560379,
0.15263241529464722,
-0.010395465418696404,
-0.3059462904930115,
-0.39432018995285034,
0.6940618753433228,
-0.8153947591781616,
-0.7068737745285034,
-0.5033938884735107,
-0.5714181661605835,
0.01177460141479969,
0.38530483841896057,
0.4059411287307739,
0.1828814297914505,
0.0379524864256382,
0.17875269055366516,
0.39372244477272034,
-0.0011363644152879715,
0.7941697239875793,
0.5798892378807068,
0.290828138589859,
-0.40846964716911316,
0.8904089331626892,
0.31456315517425537,
0.327465683221817,
0.7110427618026733,
0.8186289668083191,
-0.3476470708847046,
-0.5988537669181824,
0.16684146225452423,
0.3480246663093567,
-0.6047816276550293,
-0.19233344495296478,
-0.32196280360221863,
-0.03277494013309479,
-0.12039981782436371,
-0.04861028492450714,
-0.5439409017562866,
-0.8021102547645569,
-0.3754841685295105,
-0.2114647477865219,
0.5216591358184814,
0.8110435605049133,
-0.3564694821834564,
0.072219617664814,
-0.7469047904014587,
0.7145642042160034,
0.11702843010425568,
0.7990766763687134,
-0.13873854279518127,
-0.45221495628356934,
-0.1317349374294281,
0.20647503435611725,
-0.34403809905052185,
-0.967719316482544,
0.051105860620737076,
0.14562733471393585,
0.6941174268722534,
0.5499734878540039,
0.13701707124710083,
0.895421028137207,
-0.8191834688186646,
0.7934048771858215,
0.6457244157791138,
-1.0343579053878784,
0.18633399903774261,
-0.394100159406662,
0.19169855117797852,
0.41918978095054626,
0.319262832403183,
-0.8104417324066162,
-0.6872968077659607,
-0.9296904802322388,
-0.8585845232009888,
0.8931648135185242,
0.49981558322906494,
0.23669253289699554,
-0.4035015106201172,
0.43562933802604675,
0.2420189529657364,
0.1278437376022339,
-0.7491930723190308,
-0.44912081956863403,
0.015868330374360085,
-0.045391496270895004,
0.2047078013420105,
-0.05714361369609833,
0.11035068333148956,
-0.17294445633888245,
0.47714880108833313,
0.08087636530399323,
0.45315635204315186,
-0.20188316702842712,
-0.008816860616207123,
-0.1730998456478119,
0.04279523715376854,
1.0660183429718018,
0.6139432787895203,
0.06836918741464615,
0.20623554289340973,
0.08806094527244568,
-0.5353189706802368,
0.3926939368247986,
-0.2453901171684265,
-0.20889359712600708,
0.11568764597177505,
-0.043707240372896194,
0.8547971844673157,
0.1667390614748001,
0.059428997337818146,
0.3713335692882538,
0.03176802769303322,
-0.1537436544895172,
-0.018054936081171036,
0.19980593025684357,
-0.053114354610443115,
0.24780194461345673,
0.11257156729698181,
0.22487640380859375,
0.008356309495866299,
-0.301679402589798,
0.24126115441322327,
0.4693760871887207,
0.07998743653297424,
-0.5739932656288147,
0.31850603222846985,
-0.08666057139635086,
-0.48309770226478577,
0.7581121325492859,
-0.13653048872947693,
-0.15390610694885254,
0.5534548759460449,
0.41548076272010803,
0.7904859781265259,
-0.4180532395839691,
0.417706161737442,
-0.010962176136672497,
0.4007040858268738,
-0.6909459233283997,
0.39511364698410034,
0.029908251017332077,
-0.8000977039337158,
0.14265042543411255,
-0.540603756904602,
-0.5639779567718506,
-0.1970929503440857,
-0.6303514242172241,
0.42266222834587097,
-0.45016536116600037,
-0.16301919519901276,
-0.21145863831043243,
-0.1842774748802185,
-0.2675897181034088,
-0.09780363738536835,
0.2677324116230011,
0.7756346464157104,
-0.5674704313278198,
0.6196575164794922,
0.40574416518211365,
-0.1176726445555687,
-0.5613327026367188,
0.07008886337280273,
-0.00833055842667818,
-0.7847792506217957,
0.7379100322723389,
0.1256682127714157,
-0.18860584497451782,
-0.31683430075645447,
-0.3862270712852478,
-1.1825188398361206,
0.8477622270584106,
0.2768698036670685,
0.020994583144783974,
0.013392835855484009,
0.22479891777038574,
0.5960240364074707,
-0.04338415339589119,
0.5291016101837158,
0.4053485691547394,
0.5240657329559326,
0.17863817512989044,
-0.5981801152229309,
-0.17919519543647766,
-0.24771548807621002,
0.39486783742904663,
0.7580216526985168,
-1.038633942604065,
0.629021167755127,
-0.003775235265493393,
-0.1808195859193802,
0.16901355981826782,
0.6230355501174927,
0.0462595634162426,
0.19856864213943481,
0.5224596261978149,
0.7177703380584717,
0.8075478076934814,
-0.12885303795337677,
1.0493148565292358,
-0.11553637683391571,
0.2060084193944931,
0.8091093897819519,
-0.4301307499408722,
0.7165452241897583,
0.8346836566925049,
-0.6217151284217834,
0.46265295147895813,
0.6082473397254944,
0.24045473337173462,
0.5022269487380981,
0.7068777680397034,
-0.0338343046605587,
0.16541112959384918,
0.1304112821817398,
-0.21193037927150726,
0.47885769605636597,
0.26735153794288635,
0.2327720820903778,
-0.14192268252372742,
0.028989797458052635,
-0.03014570288360119,
-0.33820077776908875,
-0.08012509346008301,
0.8027439117431641,
0.2716560363769531,
-0.22952109575271606,
0.49249792098999023,
0.18800288438796997,
0.5444332957267761,
-0.7177429795265198,
0.14030499756336212,
-0.5261023640632629,
-0.08706770092248917,
0.11576981097459793,
-0.4696815013885498,
0.41701096296310425,
-0.4400087594985962,
-0.5143113136291504,
-0.4774148464202881,
0.2686600983142853,
-0.31608736515045166,
-0.3431144058704376,
0.09561910480260849,
0.29111355543136597,
0.34554120898246765,
0.39142826199531555,
-0.4450075924396515,
-0.16126775741577148,
-0.4170258343219757,
-0.6929319500923157,
0.44085413217544556,
0.6718860864639282,
0.023025276139378548,
0.6238190531730652,
0.5355616807937622,
0.4759516716003418,
0.6557450890541077,
-0.061951685696840286,
0.37808480858802795,
-0.8427350521087646,
-0.884894609451294,
-0.7642245292663574,
-0.151832714676857,
0.05259046331048012,
-0.20654325187206268,
0.6785463690757751,
0.34658128023147583,
0.8492872714996338,
-0.15576830506324768,
0.24226269125938416,
-0.053592197597026825,
0.3191649615764618,
-0.5963653326034546,
0.278187096118927,
-0.4440656304359436,
0.14027024805545807,
-0.3791077136993408,
-1.2597479820251465,
-0.48028919100761414,
0.6915478110313416,
-0.2563115656375885,
0.09624724835157394,
1.2843565940856934,
0.7455877065658569,
-0.0565904900431633,
0.03578285500407219,
0.5484029650688171,
0.09498151391744614,
0.2508033812046051,
0.20057231187820435,
0.8541516065597534,
-0.30312880873680115,
0.5509169101715088,
-0.41396817564964294,
0.005908305756747723,
-0.06227860599756241,
-0.8717106580734253,
-0.49770304560661316,
-0.5284146666526794,
-0.45095372200012207,
-0.20893752574920654,
-0.3341267704963684,
0.9866424798965454,
0.47284847497940063,
-0.32367515563964844,
-0.5446145534515381,
-0.3074009418487549,
0.6125323176383972,
-0.5684118866920471,
-0.34087055921554565,
0.26445329189300537,
-0.26523357629776,
-0.634509801864624,
0.2644234299659729,
0.35378140211105347,
0.33175796270370483,
0.38952043652534485,
-0.14079932868480682,
-0.2980183959007263,
0.37935325503349304,
0.529931366443634,
0.22348962724208832,
-0.7873920798301697,
-0.43154850602149963,
0.04922819882631302,
-0.1565365046262741,
0.17185859382152557,
0.9090525507926941,
-0.3091336786746979,
0.30207502841949463,
0.9508194923400879,
0.30455392599105835,
0.3205353319644928,
-0.06169827654957771,
0.3825986683368683,
-0.8037229180335999,
0.196106418967247,
0.10053657740354538,
0.197981059551239,
-0.15372391045093536,
-0.2485237419605255,
0.5158975124359131,
0.5578093528747559,
-0.2835339903831482,
-0.6725476384162903,
0.6155252456665039,
-0.9304487705230713,
-0.3043074905872345,
1.376224398612976,
0.40213847160339355,
-0.2990359365940094,
-0.07037769258022308,
0.11335358023643494,
0.09666089713573456,
-0.28453734517097473,
0.8765244483947754,
0.8860874176025391,
-0.6063336133956909,
-0.10430621355772018,
-0.37526819109916687,
0.5209438800811768,
0.5658308863639832,
-0.7343184351921082,
0.0058504557237029076,
0.6552813053131104,
0.33105605840682983,
0.3351162075996399,
0.7190670967102051,
-0.21657393872737885,
0.2956002354621887,
-0.11571604758501053,
-0.10942979902029037,
0.11135142296552658,
-0.3337680697441101,
-0.32202503085136414,
-0.003938303329050541,
-0.0763184130191803,
-0.21026746928691864
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.