id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14183v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14183v1
|
SemEval-2024 Task 8: Multidomain, Multimodel and Multilingual Machine-Generated Text Detection
| 2024-04-22T13:56:07 | 2024-04-22T13:56:07 |
Yuxia Wang, Jonibek Mansurov, Petar Ivanov, Jinyan Su, Artem Shelmanov, Akim Tsvigun, Osama Mohammed Afzal, Tarek Mahmoud, Giovanni Puccetti, Thomas Arnold, Chenxi Whitehouse, Alham Fikri Aji, Nizar Habash, Iryna Gurevych, Preslav Nakov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present the results and the main findings of SemEval-2024 Task 8:
Multigenerator, Multidomain, and Multilingual Machine-Generated Text Detection.
The task featured three subtasks. Subtask A is a binary classification task
determining whether a text is written by a human or generated by a machine.
This subtask has two tracks: a monolingual track focused solely on English
texts and a multilingual track. Subtask B is to detect the exact source of a
text, discerning whether it is written by a human or generated by a specific
LLM. Subtask C aims to identify the changing point within a text, at which the
authorship transitions from human to machine. The task attracted a large number
of participants: subtask A monolingual (126), subtask A multilingual (59),
subtask B (70), and subtask C (30). In this paper, we present the task, analyze
the results, and discuss the system submissions and the methods they used. For
all subtasks, the best systems used LLMs.
|
[
-0.4447827935218811,
-0.5190126895904541,
0.6340456008911133,
0.21865040063858032,
-0.320974737405777,
0.17326851189136505,
0.01915571466088295,
-0.618992269039154,
0.2604910433292389,
0.6591184139251709,
-0.9706748127937317,
-0.6007463932037354,
-0.6617639064788818,
0.6658720970153809,
-0.28311002254486084,
1.184739589691162,
-0.18919262290000916,
-0.2295674979686737,
-0.5907395482063293,
-0.002133272821083665,
-0.4945920705795288,
-0.7063985466957092,
-0.6047621965408325,
-0.4016457200050354,
0.7103461623191833,
0.5623387098312378,
0.0061004869639873505,
0.20142613351345062,
0.5968319177627563,
0.3568042814731598,
0.1634625941514969,
0.20734579861164093,
-0.30108731985092163,
0.39397957921028137,
-0.3689035177230835,
-0.37547755241394043,
-0.558185875415802,
-0.023459775373339653,
0.42151540517807007,
0.29890286922454834,
0.2654187083244324,
0.4518415331840515,
0.10580427944660187,
0.5214368104934692,
-0.6074540615081787,
0.06869788467884064,
-0.455272376537323,
0.05078809708356857,
-0.5787440538406372,
-0.4826928675174713,
-0.5430095195770264,
0.04579484835267067,
-0.21477822959423065,
-0.3537551164627075,
0.44782498478889465,
0.15969203412532806,
0.5366251468658447,
0.2815166711807251,
-0.7814562320709229,
-0.47473791241645813,
-0.3428206443786621,
0.9580991864204407,
-0.5412108302116394,
0.36637330055236816,
0.41018685698509216,
-0.04616781324148178,
-0.08731406927108765,
-0.5709625482559204,
-0.4247903525829315,
0.05190563574433327,
-0.04703539237380028,
0.2938470244407654,
-0.15550750494003296,
-0.06567494571208954,
0.27622702717781067,
0.07346834987401962,
-0.6577990651130676,
0.22191642224788666,
-0.5449966192245483,
-0.5903847217559814,
0.7962449193000793,
0.23357053101062775,
0.5083964467048645,
-0.2723817527294159,
-0.3234992027282715,
0.32451924681663513,
-0.6734184622764587,
0.06047156825661659,
0.7318987250328064,
0.10333439707756042,
-0.11389556527137756,
0.5921233296394348,
-0.14396117627620697,
0.21204635500907898,
-0.12304678559303284,
-0.4924250841140747,
0.5070268511772156,
-0.881865382194519,
0.12895986437797546,
0.2814658284187317,
0.8180890679359436,
0.07604644447565079,
0.09860613942146301,
0.21861521899700165,
-0.3119180500507355,
-0.03661934286355972,
0.32798075675964355,
-0.5325710773468018,
-0.16990894079208374,
0.18344566226005554,
-0.6507355570793152,
-0.35099589824676514,
-0.1832227259874344,
-0.48571181297302246,
-0.5555124282836914,
-0.3113205134868622,
0.4245358407497406,
-0.2774578928947449,
-0.273383766412735,
-0.3028365969657898,
0.00392932491376996,
0.05008142068982124,
0.6902522444725037,
-0.790300726890564,
0.10010024905204773,
0.6168116331100464,
0.49850010871887207,
-0.5958770513534546,
-0.7192319631576538,
-0.4475817382335663,
-0.1106557846069336,
-0.22290001809597015,
1.0096343755722046,
-0.30074283480644226,
-0.19922171533107758,
-0.20322242379188538,
0.6129103899002075,
-0.24582286179065704,
-0.4060122072696686,
0.5807027816772461,
-0.48985278606414795,
0.2702198922634125,
-0.34089022874832153,
-0.4063500165939331,
-0.4294912815093994,
0.2924143373966217,
-0.7445662021636963,
1.167309045791626,
-0.05676178261637688,
-0.9672410488128662,
0.330705463886261,
-0.6040559411048889,
-0.550487756729126,
0.35568347573280334,
-0.14020532369613647,
-0.5376244783401489,
-0.10387757420539856,
0.11466187983751297,
0.6559596657752991,
-0.3051551878452301,
0.05964517965912819,
0.09343770891427994,
-0.31167829036712646,
0.04580535739660263,
-0.30796119570732117,
0.7743935585021973,
0.09028200805187225,
-0.6223201751708984,
0.1413983553647995,
-0.5669630765914917,
-0.20489786565303802,
0.03500653803348541,
-0.6661872863769531,
-0.1988500952720642,
-0.1244422122836113,
0.12639442086219788,
0.121884785592556,
0.7548273801803589,
-0.8490440249443054,
0.007478016894310713,
0.030185170471668243,
0.11577165126800537,
0.7617164254188538,
0.2838868200778961,
0.30579257011413574,
-0.2410687357187271,
0.9620273113250732,
0.28227612376213074,
-0.13308322429656982,
-0.5451832413673401,
-0.7344448566436768,
-0.7389721870422363,
-0.3145345449447632,
0.5319420695304871,
0.8208051323890686,
-0.8577317595481873,
0.14685958623886108,
-0.051195915788412094,
-0.4792628288269043,
-0.2791362702846527,
0.14750097692012787,
0.4384482800960541,
-0.010064257308840752,
0.29450279474258423,
-0.17709174752235413,
-0.9386996626853943,
-1.0762426853179932,
-0.303655207157135,
-0.10128231346607208,
0.3561048209667206,
0.002057615900412202,
1.143308401107788,
-0.5281885266304016,
0.27433934807777405,
-0.26141226291656494,
-0.1511794924736023,
-0.45357298851013184,
0.3553313910961151,
0.02385829947888851,
0.5963576436042786,
0.5062586069107056,
-0.76186203956604,
-0.5059614181518555,
0.09828029572963715,
-0.7929070591926575,
-0.38880565762519836,
0.010036622174084187,
-0.15424476563930511,
0.6106357574462891,
0.749183714389801,
-0.1796724796295166,
0.5252084136009216,
0.5499802231788635,
-0.3205931484699249,
0.7868738174438477,
-0.09773902595043182,
0.5887068510055542,
-1.2203365564346313,
0.030903739854693413,
-0.2939879298210144,
-0.47009894251823425,
-0.5043312311172485,
-0.07328290492296219,
0.20539787411689758,
0.10271543264389038,
-0.44941648840904236,
0.34680643677711487,
-0.4597731828689575,
-0.1718326061964035,
-0.3018632233142853,
-0.2531347870826721,
-0.13116754591464996,
0.43364351987838745,
-0.23196376860141754,
0.8006890416145325,
0.2699299156665802,
-0.4861662685871124,
0.4929243326187134,
-0.03009277768433094,
-0.2835492193698883,
0.5669505000114441,
-0.4036608040332794,
0.43223679065704346,
-0.3041294813156128,
0.09508215636014938,
-1.2685600519180298,
-0.29758694767951965,
0.09930936247110367,
-0.7362589836120605,
-0.013124749064445496,
-0.16928663849830627,
-0.5438656210899353,
-0.19105775654315948,
-0.22201205790042877,
0.41570955514907837,
0.057517342269420624,
-0.1682419776916504,
0.6731553077697754,
0.5902084708213806,
-0.5979984998703003,
-0.44436827301979065,
-0.7999523282051086,
0.16651108860969543,
-0.13139085471630096,
-0.5701278448104858,
0.3201327621936798,
0.016346367076039314,
-0.010296170599758625,
0.13855530321598053,
0.04077965393662453,
-0.018128184601664543,
0.1190662682056427,
0.2847957909107208,
0.22208862006664276,
-0.09198694676160812,
-0.29699429869651794,
0.2682238221168518,
-0.3871021866798401,
-0.0023916135542094707,
-0.08804530650377274,
0.42309460043907166,
0.12451351433992386,
-0.4374314844608307,
-0.29679539799690247,
0.8409959673881531,
0.7076222896575928,
-0.40890663862228394,
0.6430058479309082,
0.8854584693908691,
-0.5184527039527893,
-0.273891419172287,
-0.37633153796195984,
0.10051494836807251,
-0.4017452895641327,
0.3329314589500427,
-0.642293393611908,
-1.1930538415908813,
0.5476089119911194,
0.048223141580820084,
0.28043192625045776,
0.7168878316879272,
0.9803824424743652,
-0.06441132724285126,
1.1737372875213623,
0.6791757941246033,
0.19198383390903473,
0.2900966703891754,
-0.08214748650789261,
0.21735212206840515,
-0.6744164824485779,
-0.46468281745910645,
-0.635372519493103,
-0.4080950915813446,
-0.8169814348220825,
-0.3847932815551758,
0.5184146761894226,
-0.2990420162677765,
-0.06177988648414612,
0.6820639967918396,
-0.3700920343399048,
0.3283070921897888,
0.8829969167709351,
-0.10802607983350754,
0.2177150398492813,
-0.08385370671749115,
-0.48458293080329895,
-0.1580623835325241,
-0.4049803614616394,
-0.5670182108879089,
0.8883480429649353,
0.2298385053873062,
0.5558809638023376,
0.2538354992866516,
1.0726943016052246,
0.6061128377914429,
0.030156519263982773,
-0.7142928242683411,
0.712678074836731,
-0.4199376404285431,
-0.7554687261581421,
-0.2119549810886383,
-0.18536284565925598,
-0.9931542277336121,
0.28453513979911804,
-0.003762827254831791,
-0.5758697390556335,
0.2767714262008667,
-0.03850879147648811,
-0.0950339064002037,
0.021815882995724678,
-0.6534969806671143,
1.0714448690414429,
-0.1390053629875183,
-0.05102710425853729,
-0.1107819452881813,
-0.4871692657470703,
0.20380692183971405,
-0.3810485005378723,
0.3927384316921234,
-0.25784116983413696,
-0.14822997152805328,
1.0282057523727417,
-0.023617302998900414,
0.8449423313140869,
-0.15288645029067993,
-0.21049921214580536,
0.3960949778556824,
0.2472291886806488,
0.5501916408538818,
-0.1777331382036209,
-0.026839908212423325,
0.06107842177152634,
0.25648048520088196,
-0.27947795391082764,
-0.10186488926410675,
0.5769851803779602,
-0.6161410212516785,
-0.3088618516921997,
-0.6451282501220703,
-0.20216237008571625,
0.056939657777547836,
0.465079665184021,
0.6841951608657837,
0.38923391699790955,
-0.07496088743209839,
0.6277198195457458,
0.5014649629592896,
-0.4141353368759155,
0.43192753195762634,
0.5936880111694336,
-0.07866424322128296,
-0.3590279817581177,
0.886502206325531,
0.17835457623004913,
-0.17624728381633759,
0.5365211963653564,
0.05757652595639229,
-0.34561216831207275,
-0.6230059266090393,
-0.45356833934783936,
0.0035402995999902487,
-0.7936204671859741,
-0.24694064259529114,
-1.0254777669906616,
-0.3200073540210724,
-0.8015159964561462,
0.005518710240721703,
-0.2960464656352997,
-0.21454143524169922,
-0.23972415924072266,
-0.006603559013456106,
-0.011209554970264435,
0.7886159420013428,
-0.05154789611697197,
-0.08368512243032455,
-0.8826696872711182,
0.32435938715934753,
0.11538023501634598,
-0.37867653369903564,
-0.34235188364982605,
-0.6947977542877197,
-0.5267444252967834,
-0.2285146415233612,
-0.2517780363559723,
-0.7984132766723633,
0.3715640902519226,
0.03735293447971344,
0.7655300498008728,
-0.14083509147167206,
-0.05827738717198372,
0.3158222734928131,
-0.7120459079742432,
0.9426782131195068,
0.02803443931043148,
-0.8219724297523499,
0.6826719045639038,
-0.4830336272716522,
0.5434757471084595,
0.5576260089874268,
0.4551674723625183,
-0.6758192181587219,
-0.41513580083847046,
-0.4565666913986206,
-0.778024435043335,
0.8832425475120544,
0.40323886275291443,
-0.04748593270778656,
0.2508912980556488,
0.10454382747411728,
0.32990750670433044,
0.39260706305503845,
-0.8073479533195496,
-0.09720570594072342,
0.01575324870646,
-0.41673290729522705,
-0.19803474843502045,
-0.3836837708950043,
0.1537347435951233,
0.0659453421831131,
0.8122705817222595,
-0.18297146260738373,
0.46038851141929626,
0.19258679449558258,
-0.2563934028148651,
-0.044150225818157196,
0.5237089991569519,
0.7894954681396484,
0.5100582838058472,
0.251723051071167,
0.4923796057701111,
0.19680866599082947,
-0.6729435920715332,
0.2658820152282715,
-0.04940077289938927,
-0.3620292544364929,
-0.047269728034734726,
0.9383732676506042,
0.766482949256897,
0.05406709387898445,
-0.4775681495666504,
0.517238974571228,
0.03587983176112175,
-0.5220113396644592,
-0.3070349097251892,
0.027545254677534103,
0.0920819565653801,
0.31880033016204834,
0.3451096713542938,
0.09635652601718903,
0.42291155457496643,
-0.5041826367378235,
0.22601114213466644,
-0.01757505163550377,
-0.16589172184467316,
-0.5516357421875,
0.570335328578949,
0.29398053884506226,
-0.24405263364315033,
0.04237039387226105,
-0.4662046432495117,
-0.993027925491333,
0.7987794876098633,
0.48553821444511414,
1.090195655822754,
-0.2958773672580719,
0.27732351422309875,
0.35403504967689514,
0.6444799900054932,
0.0922827497124672,
0.5915210247039795,
0.07575775682926178,
-0.8894616961479187,
-0.4569858908653259,
-0.6899142861366272,
-0.449534147977829,
0.31275931000709534,
-0.2694835364818573,
0.1953662782907486,
-0.06387969106435776,
-0.10255170613527298,
0.35177093744277954,
0.20746839046478271,
-0.6768035292625427,
0.11224231868982315,
0.14501900970935822,
0.41962629556655884,
-0.9328422546386719,
0.4855111539363861,
1.3700364828109741,
-0.13229261338710785,
-0.6386630535125732,
-0.25367167592048645,
0.5125016570091248,
-0.5167427062988281,
0.8047286868095398,
0.21612200140953064,
-0.20290985703468323,
0.03129597380757332,
-0.4659314751625061,
-0.8408843278884888,
0.9813629388809204,
0.27512019872665405,
-0.31518107652664185,
0.2524681091308594,
0.18130208551883698,
0.4540397822856903,
-0.3819878399372101,
-0.08821696043014526,
0.26736921072006226,
0.43620261549949646,
-0.12841683626174927,
-1.168567180633545,
0.057036276906728745,
-0.4151492416858673,
-0.2500561773777008,
0.2918480634689331,
-0.5398683547973633,
1.0446240901947021,
0.15325793623924255,
-0.08356212824583054,
0.03706821799278259,
0.46349552273750305,
0.4115105867385864,
0.4091584384441376,
0.6841790080070496,
0.5274302959442139,
0.5756170153617859,
0.04016295075416565,
0.6736485958099365,
-0.13627862930297852,
0.3526366651058197,
0.9160870909690857,
-0.2746555507183075,
0.5435126423835754,
0.2259797304868698,
-0.2369203418493271,
0.5827280879020691,
0.8664935827255249,
0.170586958527565,
0.3414138853549957,
-0.07552855461835861,
-0.3908587098121643,
-0.5173555612564087,
-0.15549367666244507,
-0.20092613995075226,
0.7345526814460754,
0.18294981122016907,
-0.20927934348583221,
-0.2858915627002716,
0.4120301902294159,
-0.03434833884239197,
-0.26637887954711914,
-0.1899307668209076,
0.7518731355667114,
0.051238615065813065,
-0.9898629188537598,
0.04897010326385498,
0.4813128113746643,
0.7506892681121826,
-0.4979356527328491,
-0.09350599348545074,
-0.11363284289836884,
0.3594974875450134,
-0.37774771451950073,
-0.7605262994766235,
0.2105676531791687,
0.18868403136730194,
-0.37578243017196655,
-0.5262755155563354,
1.318122148513794,
-0.5343314409255981,
-0.5877048373222351,
0.15523706376552582,
0.5379320979118347,
0.44982266426086426,
-0.13205008208751678,
-0.7884951233863831,
0.07633214443922043,
0.1591920256614685,
-0.23021569848060608,
0.14648669958114624,
0.7550743818283081,
-0.2913762331008911,
0.38485920429229736,
0.6886160373687744,
-0.2685053050518036,
0.1562092900276184,
0.24332112073898315,
0.4943377673625946,
-0.6686611771583557,
-0.6708513498306274,
-0.7663862109184265,
0.26656046509742737,
0.17025507986545563,
-0.34678131341934204,
1.0622749328613281,
0.8544610142707825,
0.8886710405349731,
-0.16492922604084015,
0.997372567653656,
-0.24282929301261902,
0.8066851496696472,
-0.5216911435127258,
0.3950812816619873,
-0.7998049259185791,
0.013341681100428104,
-0.36290407180786133,
-0.7887821793556213,
0.08661772310733795,
0.4103715419769287,
-0.1404312252998352,
0.0782335177063942,
1.0674118995666504,
0.638939380645752,
0.18568155169487,
0.029712436720728874,
0.35673201084136963,
-0.18994057178497314,
0.1956014484167099,
0.4782777428627014,
0.9580085873603821,
-0.5035486221313477,
0.4405083954334259,
-0.2529517412185669,
-0.10344867408275604,
-0.2441743016242981,
-0.7793522477149963,
-0.9638530015945435,
-0.7691428661346436,
-0.4061591923236847,
-0.18074269592761993,
-0.23247914016246796,
0.7263502478599548,
0.5326617956161499,
-1.1158345937728882,
-0.1544632613658905,
0.09560297429561615,
0.08169326186180115,
-0.003296138718724251,
-0.2187524139881134,
0.08107754588127136,
-0.3192202150821686,
-0.8736530542373657,
0.4321686625480652,
0.4694971442222595,
-0.06689083576202393,
-0.36420923471450806,
0.10431196540594101,
-0.5272610187530518,
-0.11543899774551392,
0.7611716985702515,
-0.1439286172389984,
-0.4241834878921509,
-0.40503090620040894,
0.22412027418613434,
-0.19084732234477997,
-0.22313515841960907,
1.0567067861557007,
-0.34244006872177124,
0.2312283217906952,
1.097535252571106,
0.5603215098381042,
0.5648086071014404,
-0.044190049171447754,
0.3391672670841217,
-0.7098719477653503,
-0.0028657785151153803,
0.2594223618507385,
0.42830565571784973,
0.2279539257287979,
-0.5939149260520935,
0.643124520778656,
0.7148182392120361,
-0.8287153840065002,
-0.771572470664978,
0.1984534114599228,
-0.6928298473358154,
-0.3085113763809204,
1.1236093044281006,
-0.13717029988765717,
-0.2847833037376404,
-0.5930219292640686,
-0.2879110276699066,
0.08301828056573868,
-0.26753032207489014,
0.03838805481791496,
0.951525866985321,
-0.37611323595046997,
-0.3464142978191376,
-0.7594833374023438,
0.4246140420436859,
0.2752760052680969,
-1.032218098640442,
-0.3952775299549103,
0.4670218527317047,
0.2675779163837433,
0.35989081859588623,
1.129143476486206,
-0.05450987443327904,
0.3743448853492737,
0.0994507446885109,
0.2489890605211258,
0.108680859208107,
-0.6215817332267761,
0.05530872568488121,
0.23933182656764984,
-0.37395045161247253,
-0.2749108374118805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14122v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14122v1
|
Fine-Tuning Large Language Models to Translate: Will a Touch of Noisy Data in Misaligned Languages Suffice?
| 2024-04-22T12:21:12 | 2024-04-22T12:21:12 |
Dawei Zhu, Pinzhen Chen, Miaoran Zhang, Barry Haddow, Xiaoyu Shen, Dietrich Klakow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Traditionally, success in multilingual machine translation can be attributed
to three key factors in training data: large volume, diverse translation
directions, and high quality. In the current practice of fine-tuning large
language models (LLMs) for translation, we revisit the importance of all these
factors. We find that LLMs display strong translation capability after being
fine-tuned on as few as 32 training instances, and that fine-tuning on a single
translation direction effectively enables LLMs to translate in multiple
directions. However, the choice of direction is critical: fine-tuning LLMs with
English on the target side can lead to task misinterpretation, which hinders
translations into non-English languages. A similar problem arises when noise is
introduced into the target side of parallel data, especially when the target
language is well-represented in the LLM's pre-training. In contrast, noise in
an under-represented language has a less pronounced effect. Our findings
suggest that attaining successful alignment hinges on teaching the model to
maintain a "superficial" focus, thereby avoiding the learning of erroneous
biases beyond translation.
|
[
-0.33709919452667236,
-0.4925810992717743,
0.6119387745857239,
0.23695382475852966,
-0.40414363145828247,
-0.06665094196796417,
-0.5735794305801392,
-0.6195706725120544,
-0.11368300765752792,
0.6583505272865295,
-0.5176226496696472,
-0.39894962310791016,
-0.8962878584861755,
0.13174130022525787,
-0.5871084928512573,
1.1387604475021362,
-0.2617807388305664,
0.4355364739894867,
-0.010447341948747635,
-0.30094459652900696,
-0.5908006429672241,
-0.36618632078170776,
-0.5592395663261414,
-0.5092699527740479,
0.6336931586265564,
0.5552018880844116,
0.970455527305603,
1.000639796257019,
0.6680874824523926,
0.3015478253364563,
0.0034316005185246468,
0.4565356969833374,
-0.7528567910194397,
0.09835633635520935,
-0.12335187196731567,
-0.6597563028335571,
-0.330745130777359,
0.06968361884355545,
0.7195454239845276,
0.9998739361763,
0.09404020011425018,
-0.023794187232851982,
0.3423256278038025,
0.7491948008537292,
-0.1907472014427185,
-0.007204826921224594,
-0.6711533069610596,
-0.10418558120727539,
-0.40450483560562134,
-0.01064897421747446,
-0.25800061225891113,
-0.11444550007581711,
-0.18703602254390717,
-0.530238151550293,
0.18001170456409454,
0.19211596250534058,
0.9969744086265564,
0.47465935349464417,
-0.5989729166030884,
-0.11987419426441193,
-1.0036499500274658,
1.0512454509735107,
-0.6427595615386963,
0.6403406858444214,
0.38761624693870544,
0.16819822788238525,
-0.29063665866851807,
-0.14800353348255157,
-0.1324968934059143,
0.13687573373317719,
0.10136432200670242,
-0.12180195748806,
0.1708178073167801,
-0.08842380344867706,
0.21175695955753326,
0.2868524491786957,
-0.3324882984161377,
0.5785132646560669,
-0.48335835337638855,
-0.05120018124580383,
0.7569858431816101,
0.09229668974876404,
0.1499267965555191,
0.5296353101730347,
-0.09360980242490768,
-0.08028881996870041,
-0.7663466930389404,
-0.20650841295719147,
0.41664034128189087,
0.7620852589607239,
-0.2223977893590927,
0.43412473797798157,
-0.1238318607211113,
0.8135733604431152,
0.30315887928009033,
-0.3061831295490265,
0.13412874937057495,
-0.5752866268157959,
-0.013573996722698212,
0.185360848903656,
0.6759912967681885,
0.3776355981826782,
0.5516292452812195,
-0.28707364201545715,
-0.389173686504364,
-0.23939299583435059,
0.41483399271965027,
-0.7038464546203613,
0.011158431880176067,
0.08449382334947586,
-0.4160243272781372,
-0.13314485549926758,
-0.1427234709262848,
-0.285320907831192,
-0.38571539521217346,
-0.8089001774787903,
0.23275861144065857,
-0.2830178141593933,
-0.058996882289648056,
0.32995128631591797,
0.4096658527851105,
0.18552127480506897,
0.45207467675209045,
-0.9227423667907715,
0.15116944909095764,
0.8226231932640076,
0.7051727175712585,
-0.14881375432014465,
-0.6806334257125854,
-0.46297207474708557,
0.152936190366745,
-0.7174972295761108,
0.5436317920684814,
-0.44857385754585266,
-0.030574675649404526,
0.13373799622058868,
0.1552874892950058,
-0.13165311515331268,
-0.5590207576751709,
0.5608725547790527,
-0.41485172510147095,
0.09240016341209412,
-0.436310350894928,
-0.4398687183856964,
-0.17876605689525604,
0.010218895971775055,
-0.43327441811561584,
0.5733862519264221,
-0.09012173861265182,
-0.3781541585922241,
0.3728359341621399,
-0.028135940432548523,
-0.8328815698623657,
-0.37578487396240234,
-0.04133844003081322,
-0.5550625324249268,
0.4546855688095093,
0.2555277645587921,
0.576835036277771,
-0.2551783323287964,
0.2876705825328827,
-0.3290555477142334,
-0.35729745030403137,
0.25962600111961365,
-0.41017627716064453,
0.412197083234787,
0.3663107454776764,
-0.03875809162855148,
0.02168682962656021,
-0.4287230968475342,
-0.20219863951206207,
-0.0748598724603653,
-0.41448214650154114,
-0.3054330050945282,
-0.05253852903842926,
0.09322084486484528,
0.319158136844635,
0.39348241686820984,
-0.2707817554473877,
0.19016073644161224,
-0.41585689783096313,
0.3663732409477234,
0.513683557510376,
-0.3963397741317749,
0.6953744292259216,
-0.32822462916374207,
0.3662651777267456,
0.19615904986858368,
0.06327427923679352,
0.10194531828165054,
-0.442411333322525,
-0.8099997639656067,
-0.038380056619644165,
0.45098984241485596,
0.31026262044906616,
-0.44841840863227844,
0.11989042162895203,
-0.3417292535305023,
-0.4577586054801941,
-0.8547784090042114,
0.6317250728607178,
0.3328387439250946,
0.3439011573791504,
0.3783072233200073,
-0.34663811326026917,
-0.38244155049324036,
-0.9157806634902954,
-0.385777086019516,
0.185930073261261,
0.25013452768325806,
0.060112036764621735,
0.15417535603046417,
-0.2679283916950226,
0.16591744124889374,
-0.11861038953065872,
-0.5033578276634216,
-0.2905670404434204,
0.0962587296962738,
0.2715452313423157,
0.5857837796211243,
0.401311457157135,
-0.7616695761680603,
-0.5847118496894836,
0.4652216136455536,
-0.4891584813594818,
-0.19030748307704926,
-0.2814008295536041,
-0.22412040829658508,
0.1368076056241989,
0.7839338779449463,
-0.6252620220184326,
-0.06997650861740112,
0.7388302683830261,
0.09883596748113632,
0.192386656999588,
-0.37383779883384705,
0.16767755150794983,
-1.0774047374725342,
-0.07447484880685806,
-0.04019401967525482,
-0.26030251383781433,
-0.6497896909713745,
0.09139090776443481,
0.1846807301044464,
0.11172835528850555,
-0.3707343637943268,
0.3210678994655609,
-0.5219399929046631,
0.09597373008728027,
-0.5415764451026917,
0.08904282748699188,
-0.03250578045845032,
0.1871885508298874,
-0.09125187247991562,
0.7162643074989319,
0.4083750545978546,
-0.7341575026512146,
-0.0018461109139025211,
0.18628495931625366,
-0.36474302411079407,
0.609379231929779,
-0.2972947955131531,
0.04568139836192131,
-0.10452239960432053,
-0.15189149975776672,
-0.7508143186569214,
-0.3764527142047882,
0.03868228197097778,
-0.2292378693819046,
0.9283062219619751,
-0.11673448234796524,
-0.3830936849117279,
-0.24684537947177887,
0.26850858330726624,
0.5303150415420532,
0.20368672907352448,
-0.41545721888542175,
0.20683424174785614,
0.36754748225212097,
-0.06471209973096848,
-0.5538737773895264,
-0.7816907167434692,
0.09024392813444138,
-0.3270256519317627,
-0.43183422088623047,
0.28403228521347046,
0.13652633130550385,
-0.19050610065460205,
-0.30696117877960205,
-0.18508970737457275,
-0.184262216091156,
0.19914793968200684,
0.08824354410171509,
-0.06147428974509239,
-0.19380666315555573,
0.15958133339881897,
-0.03552136942744255,
-0.15023943781852722,
-0.14420992136001587,
-0.5282797813415527,
0.4968548119068146,
-0.08264532685279846,
-0.5055298209190369,
-0.3380047678947449,
0.35628482699394226,
0.9265517592430115,
-0.3439013659954071,
0.7833015322685242,
0.6536905765533447,
-0.29382050037384033,
0.06201864033937454,
-0.5104328393936157,
-0.22126825153827667,
-0.3875415027141571,
0.6907249093055725,
-0.46909070014953613,
-0.6806876063346863,
0.4933917224407196,
-0.13683772087097168,
0.13038381934165955,
0.34680208563804626,
0.5438054800033569,
-0.32037296891212463,
1.5589559078216553,
0.9191150069236755,
-0.4739612340927124,
0.46061742305755615,
0.12078364193439484,
0.38699406385421753,
-0.6079609990119934,
-0.07256773859262466,
-0.7381352782249451,
-0.6921045780181885,
-0.7282500267028809,
-0.3343486189842224,
0.16557244956493378,
0.4008461833000183,
-0.20837223529815674,
0.4311394989490509,
-0.25009921193122864,
0.46985623240470886,
0.4689643383026123,
-0.018118441104888916,
0.3784666359424591,
0.1775495707988739,
0.14914996922016144,
-0.32704299688339233,
-0.7897199988365173,
-0.44609472155570984,
0.9941470623016357,
0.46483656764030457,
0.9743615388870239,
0.048648662865161896,
0.7165668606758118,
-0.578025758266449,
0.1260824352502823,
-0.7785508632659912,
0.12370861321687698,
-0.45102375745773315,
-0.4862162172794342,
-0.3304539620876312,
-0.3570830523967743,
-1.044429063796997,
0.2772460877895355,
-0.15840093791484833,
-0.29712122678756714,
0.11656393110752106,
0.16492877900600433,
-0.25979354977607727,
0.3351997137069702,
-0.5381629467010498,
0.8353710770606995,
-0.6316121220588684,
-0.38297104835510254,
-0.3362097442150116,
-0.5836739540100098,
0.27160000801086426,
-0.4239034056663513,
0.4144573211669922,
-0.09379973262548447,
0.14038226008415222,
0.41408398747444153,
-0.08348498493432999,
0.8328640460968018,
0.12831568717956543,
-0.39035043120384216,
-0.166057288646698,
0.21902380883693695,
0.6289033889770508,
-0.22130587697029114,
0.027804579585790634,
0.36044740676879883,
-0.14317001402378082,
-0.45963892340660095,
-0.37032797932624817,
0.691985011100769,
-0.8935846090316772,
-0.6732029318809509,
-0.023133262991905212,
-1.005080223083496,
-0.30869632959365845,
0.404416561126709,
0.33602195978164673,
0.02115502767264843,
-0.003997404128313065,
0.26382753252983093,
0.7596898674964905,
0.07695239037275314,
0.05634891614317894,
0.6034178137779236,
-0.27744537591934204,
-0.04243640601634979,
1.1846479177474976,
0.3582373857498169,
0.4408460557460785,
0.33087456226348877,
0.033627115190029144,
-0.23946213722229004,
-0.9388497471809387,
-0.6432100534439087,
0.42395105957984924,
-0.4098703861236572,
-0.18073993921279907,
-0.45632702112197876,
-0.06728560477495193,
-0.2951548993587494,
-0.16923750936985016,
-0.8713345527648926,
-0.20451222360134125,
-0.5317714214324951,
0.16426269710063934,
0.08790334314107895,
0.8075792193412781,
-0.038822196424007416,
0.37418267130851746,
-0.8246497511863708,
0.15028534829616547,
0.0172774326056242,
0.36750659346580505,
-0.3725246787071228,
-0.8537248373031616,
-0.7741502523422241,
0.27002596855163574,
-0.3354528248310089,
-0.5736126899719238,
0.463811457157135,
0.17245009541511536,
0.43887126445770264,
0.42026668787002563,
-0.2790030837059021,
0.8992873430252075,
-0.6861204504966736,
0.33863380551338196,
0.09883379191160202,
-0.5775633454322815,
0.24034632742404938,
-0.5117017030715942,
0.5037432909011841,
0.6415092945098877,
0.43691742420196533,
-0.6464526653289795,
-0.6863043308258057,
-0.3323974907398224,
-0.6665151715278625,
0.6108938455581665,
-0.2340429425239563,
0.1817917674779892,
0.25508418679237366,
0.36190152168273926,
0.13550713658332825,
0.3598591387271881,
-0.6329184174537659,
-0.06207791715860367,
0.09554142504930496,
-0.3137277364730835,
-0.49853160977363586,
-0.10838384181261063,
-0.29977017641067505,
-0.25423187017440796,
0.5760864019393921,
-0.17831945419311523,
-0.10649082064628601,
-0.17932964861392975,
-0.10525800287723541,
-0.6483989357948303,
0.17091228067874908,
0.7136046290397644,
0.5211021900177002,
0.11452046036720276,
0.10219511389732361,
0.1197415217757225,
-0.28030306100845337,
0.06052036210894585,
0.08221633732318878,
-0.3435226380825043,
-0.21865582466125488,
0.3742746114730835,
0.8547849655151367,
0.24337787926197052,
-0.07878349721431732,
0.3034127950668335,
0.20890197157859802,
-0.18054550886154175,
0.22258932888507843,
-0.06967514753341675,
0.17522196471691132,
0.30132779479026794,
-0.11751364916563034,
0.3475167155265808,
-0.13258381187915802,
-0.3546752333641052,
-0.1129138171672821,
0.6117141246795654,
-0.5500384569168091,
-0.2736642062664032,
0.7657397985458374,
0.22847618162631989,
-0.2025441825389862,
0.6122280359268188,
0.06033368781208992,
-0.4891704022884369,
0.45377981662750244,
0.6107579469680786,
0.6775481104850769,
-0.35238245129585266,
-0.1946038156747818,
0.2867993116378784,
0.7035808563232422,
-0.5750048756599426,
0.021806687116622925,
0.28595051169395447,
-0.8003397583961487,
-0.6974084973335266,
-0.6717268824577332,
-0.21870139241218567,
0.17940029501914978,
-0.6589362025260925,
0.38261961936950684,
-0.015423046424984932,
-0.024814598262310028,
-0.19224680960178375,
-0.12172987312078476,
-0.8025243282318115,
0.09608626365661621,
0.31490346789360046,
0.6740037798881531,
-1.0225309133529663,
1.0173370838165283,
0.7462167739868164,
-0.20258502662181854,
-0.8448060154914856,
-0.15201643109321594,
-0.05042906850576401,
-0.7402154207229614,
0.5814722776412964,
0.1719595044851303,
-0.09195514023303986,
0.11170325428247452,
-0.6402412056922913,
-1.0361323356628418,
0.6205089092254639,
0.6344281435012817,
-1.0152543783187866,
0.2526523470878601,
0.4941663444042206,
0.5413384437561035,
-0.3139879107475281,
-0.22664648294448853,
0.5757096409797668,
0.6089437007904053,
-0.17389898002147675,
-1.2110320329666138,
-0.20081816613674164,
0.23131684958934784,
-0.08654904365539551,
0.4314795136451721,
-0.8229759335517883,
0.7798025012016296,
-0.351563960313797,
-0.16825716197490692,
0.09404253959655762,
0.47176510095596313,
-0.13815201818943024,
-0.002716783666983247,
0.21025991439819336,
0.6166982054710388,
0.7652403116226196,
-0.19863422214984894,
1.0438874959945679,
-0.4381883144378662,
0.08617749065160751,
1.131185531616211,
-0.24762184917926788,
0.7936643362045288,
0.8307108283042908,
0.12246061861515045,
-0.09865528345108032,
0.7340226769447327,
0.11307177692651749,
0.5409402847290039,
0.00028984397067688406,
0.11715172976255417,
-0.6271725296974182,
-0.20465198159217834,
-0.4720463156700134,
0.48605090379714966,
0.3961784243583679,
-0.37309032678604126,
-0.15317939221858978,
0.058529067784547806,
-0.04153976961970329,
0.3357268273830414,
-0.36941173672676086,
0.6465088725090027,
0.3110104203224182,
-0.7874411344528198,
0.7106410264968872,
0.10509727150201797,
0.39850664138793945,
-0.4069576561450958,
0.15159298479557037,
-0.3067035675048828,
0.38754862546920776,
-0.13816913962364197,
-0.7466870546340942,
0.3744087815284729,
-0.347586989402771,
-0.33675679564476013,
-0.520902156829834,
0.4781831204891205,
-0.884403645992279,
-0.5624744892120361,
0.252177894115448,
0.6649990677833557,
0.31213971972465515,
-0.11281359940767288,
-0.6480677723884583,
0.18828943371772766,
0.1391529142856598,
-0.03240467607975006,
0.5872469544410706,
0.6304696202278137,
-0.08726686239242554,
0.6740080118179321,
0.5208185315132141,
0.4126265347003937,
-0.03416050598025322,
0.17547644674777985,
0.5802217125892639,
-0.4614962637424469,
-0.15303440392017365,
-0.7568636536598206,
0.2650342583656311,
0.2628737688064575,
-0.309011310338974,
0.7804949879646301,
0.3803989589214325,
1.160949468612671,
-0.036392781883478165,
0.41176530718803406,
0.5821752548217773,
0.3854908049106598,
-0.6365768313407898,
0.7409173250198364,
-0.7188079953193665,
0.1272161453962326,
-0.057899363338947296,
-1.0350204706192017,
-0.568365752696991,
0.6384276151657104,
-0.3922867774963379,
-0.025078710168600082,
0.5478995442390442,
0.8949505090713501,
-0.21720369160175323,
-0.14422301948070526,
0.5574103593826294,
0.4085175693035126,
0.04560256004333496,
0.5745745897293091,
0.7205326557159424,
-0.6477571725845337,
0.7288498282432556,
-0.3121708929538727,
0.05987468734383583,
-0.27079474925994873,
-0.6798276901245117,
-0.7717111706733704,
-0.3115263283252716,
-0.39007049798965454,
-0.17193473875522614,
-0.00649680383503437,
0.6805317997932434,
0.7836344838142395,
-0.9652436971664429,
-0.4640771448612213,
-0.15261593461036682,
0.20032671093940735,
-0.31122061610221863,
-0.020139852538704872,
-0.06792498379945755,
-0.7566671371459961,
-1.052718162536621,
0.4298575520515442,
0.21455778181552887,
0.32619765400886536,
-0.19003212451934814,
-0.29697784781455994,
-0.07505947351455688,
-0.2634035050868988,
0.34937915205955505,
0.2655065655708313,
-0.7226892709732056,
-0.12827196717262268,
-0.07771960645914078,
-0.5969694256782532,
0.0858863890171051,
0.576494038105011,
-0.19686086475849152,
0.5092039704322815,
0.19845369458198547,
0.7825561761856079,
0.44051963090896606,
-0.04330483824014664,
0.9234564304351807,
-0.6476210355758667,
0.2617587745189667,
-0.07271908968687057,
0.3097235858440399,
0.4497896432876587,
-0.41498667001724243,
0.378862202167511,
-0.06148969754576683,
-0.7252903580665588,
-0.7779252529144287,
0.18714627623558044,
-0.5328456163406372,
-0.2403685599565506,
1.194078803062439,
0.20227259397506714,
-0.12800201773643494,
-0.17943726480007172,
-0.2777973711490631,
0.4473501145839691,
-0.0246296189725399,
0.6606561541557312,
0.9066027402877808,
0.07069455832242966,
-0.05642864853143692,
-0.813402533531189,
0.5893649458885193,
0.8821309804916382,
-0.2893882095813751,
0.22408436238765717,
0.39291808009147644,
0.07525014132261276,
0.15438717603683472,
0.15704534947872162,
-0.10855841636657715,
-0.030638784170150757,
-0.24108614027500153,
-0.016777625307440758,
0.10272327810525894,
-0.5218105316162109,
-0.6090291142463684,
-0.22667087614536285,
0.5581152439117432,
-0.12095420807600021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14465v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14465v1
|
Benchmarking Advanced Text Anonymisation Methods: A Comparative Study on Novel and Traditional Approaches
| 2024-04-22T12:06:54 | 2024-04-22T12:06:54 |
Dimitris Asimopoulos, Ilias Siniosoglou, Vasileios Argyriou, Thomai Karamitsou, Eleftherios Fountoukidis, Sotirios K. Goudos, Ioannis D. Moscholios, Konstantinos E. Psannis, Panagiotis Sarigiannidis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
In the realm of data privacy, the ability to effectively anonymise text is
paramount. With the proliferation of deep learning and, in particular,
transformer architectures, there is a burgeoning interest in leveraging these
advanced models for text anonymisation tasks. This paper presents a
comprehensive benchmarking study comparing the performance of transformer-based
models and Large Language Models(LLM) against traditional architectures for
text anonymisation. Utilising the CoNLL-2003 dataset, known for its robustness
and diversity, we evaluate several models. Our results showcase the strengths
and weaknesses of each approach, offering a clear perspective on the efficacy
of modern versus traditional methods. Notably, while modern models exhibit
advanced capabilities in capturing con textual nuances, certain traditional
architectures still keep high performance. This work aims to guide researchers
in selecting the most suitable model for their anonymisation needs, while also
shedding light on potential paths for future advancements in the field.
|
[
-0.10509195923805237,
-0.8565657734870911,
0.27015432715415955,
0.00675083976238966,
0.028882550075650215,
0.3520822525024414,
-0.2594188451766968,
-0.8194940090179443,
-0.2256339192390442,
0.6833840608596802,
-0.46031326055526733,
-0.5542516708374023,
-0.6743900179862976,
0.3356579840183258,
-0.8790655136108398,
0.5100226998329163,
-0.010966709814965725,
0.01305705588310957,
-0.1804870218038559,
-0.34331056475639343,
-0.2592192590236664,
-0.6849835515022278,
-0.6905006170272827,
-0.31339317560195923,
0.27826404571533203,
-0.003348492318764329,
0.87021803855896,
1.075247883796692,
0.837425708770752,
0.3899237811565399,
-0.5655795931816101,
0.09695038199424744,
-0.44636183977127075,
0.30961647629737854,
-0.1670585423707962,
-0.3089360296726227,
-0.17492207884788513,
0.06410078704357147,
0.6575935482978821,
0.5689893960952759,
0.0014073102502152324,
0.20236481726169586,
-0.01550065353512764,
0.6140883564949036,
-0.9942482709884644,
-0.14029747247695923,
-0.4492841064929962,
0.12222079187631607,
-0.4264844059944153,
0.209188774228096,
-0.48111677169799805,
-0.6562962532043457,
0.27167680859565735,
-0.4706406891345978,
0.46929892897605896,
0.24183127284049988,
0.9521028399467468,
0.30800846219062805,
-0.23504163324832916,
-0.6502628326416016,
-1.0923829078674316,
0.8991774320602417,
-0.7618514895439148,
0.6084378957748413,
0.15274015069007874,
0.5757831335067749,
0.3453664779663086,
-1.0533908605575562,
-0.36151906847953796,
-0.21429692208766937,
-0.5399956703186035,
-0.11058203876018524,
-0.4857848584651947,
-0.16171346604824066,
0.28385457396507263,
0.6550593376159668,
-0.4704277515411377,
0.6085596084594727,
-0.20061883330345154,
-0.20846761763095856,
0.5499040484428406,
0.13101047277450562,
0.16483145952224731,
0.08066769689321518,
-0.6452824473381042,
0.009096343070268631,
-0.7203592658042908,
-0.06578836590051651,
0.763765811920166,
-0.04578295350074768,
-0.15532484650611877,
0.3691522479057312,
-0.43749532103538513,
0.4397176206111908,
0.004927251022309065,
-0.13811500370502472,
0.14048485457897186,
-0.2609066367149353,
-0.24936366081237793,
-0.1396922618150711,
1.029510498046875,
0.15044525265693665,
0.38753336668014526,
-0.6698631644248962,
-0.19461391866207123,
0.03443156182765961,
0.05187961831688881,
-0.9361584186553955,
-0.27358102798461914,
0.006763503421097994,
-0.6994367241859436,
-0.18301035463809967,
0.005799789912998676,
-1.0282706022262573,
-0.7713425755500793,
-0.30561724305152893,
0.3119078576564789,
-0.30431732535362244,
-0.12473893910646439,
0.10222259163856506,
-0.13385601341724396,
0.13557466864585876,
0.27881088852882385,
-1.0628268718719482,
0.7722080945968628,
0.7649344205856323,
0.6408643126487732,
-0.5481458306312561,
-0.062588170170784,
-0.025489822030067444,
0.0165045615285635,
-0.10044734179973602,
0.6249990463256836,
-0.8497021198272705,
-0.24217569828033447,
0.10020527243614197,
-0.07040886580944061,
-0.10412254929542542,
-0.7921376824378967,
0.6102017760276794,
-0.5664990544319153,
0.3930283486843109,
0.017656510695815086,
-0.749616265296936,
-0.40217411518096924,
0.23029908537864685,
-0.9798640608787537,
1.0724010467529297,
-0.24581676721572876,
-0.9281323552131653,
0.040474746376276016,
-0.46661603450775146,
-0.32409489154815674,
0.028451919555664062,
-0.27220284938812256,
-0.5355130434036255,
0.017956821247935295,
0.12358607351779938,
0.32434195280075073,
-0.6273484826087952,
0.4474024176597595,
0.021438488736748695,
-0.4844401478767395,
0.41476303339004517,
-1.005351185798645,
0.7548401355743408,
0.28598567843437195,
-0.49202990531921387,
-0.07283025234937668,
-1.0616488456726074,
-0.44606438279151917,
-0.08456350117921829,
-0.018656032159924507,
-0.24031656980514526,
0.05874866992235184,
-0.02735951542854309,
-0.29847007989883423,
0.4046512544155121,
-0.6176666617393494,
-0.1630503535270691,
-0.4303198754787445,
0.4559861123561859,
0.3482806980609894,
-0.08577077090740204,
0.6336575150489807,
-0.21723230183124542,
0.5061476230621338,
-0.20814703404903412,
0.1412763148546219,
-0.25638988614082336,
-0.10155997425317764,
-0.588539183139801,
-0.399156391620636,
0.661144495010376,
0.5558552742004395,
-0.31923165917396545,
0.05373169481754303,
-0.3569034934043884,
-0.7709903120994568,
-0.7325442433357239,
-0.07828087359666824,
0.5998018980026245,
0.38137516379356384,
0.3220199644565582,
-0.07521501928567886,
-0.3922809660434723,
-1.0905590057373047,
-0.7254884839057922,
0.22915884852409363,
-0.23701462149620056,
0.4167494773864746,
0.2545440196990967,
-0.016575230285525322,
0.866788387298584,
-0.2601158618927002,
-0.1883455514907837,
-0.11735492199659348,
0.09416131675243378,
0.035928841680288315,
0.39234861731529236,
0.4852703809738159,
-1.158728837966919,
-0.417086660861969,
-0.13315768539905548,
-0.8388538360595703,
0.037663888186216354,
0.06061965972185135,
0.21030744910240173,
0.05137045308947563,
0.5499892234802246,
-0.453946977853775,
0.4437689781188965,
0.74953293800354,
-0.09147360175848007,
0.43081337213516235,
-0.24596169590950012,
0.20869183540344238,
-0.7980546951293945,
0.44935286045074463,
-0.045645520091056824,
-0.15726114809513092,
-0.9192994832992554,
0.11689622700214386,
0.26063966751098633,
-0.059802472591400146,
-0.6032429337501526,
0.7090652585029602,
-0.6811111569404602,
0.28763630986213684,
-0.1627245992422104,
-0.16399317979812622,
-0.039967261254787445,
0.11108390986919403,
0.11006586998701096,
0.6594920754432678,
0.5524879097938538,
-0.45704367756843567,
0.06943542510271072,
0.21355785429477692,
-0.2354518324136734,
0.19334188103675842,
-0.4899231791496277,
0.2666006088256836,
-0.12182823568582535,
0.10492393374443054,
-1.108737587928772,
-0.06468845903873444,
0.10158111900091171,
-0.3783717453479767,
0.44378340244293213,
-0.012054956518113613,
-0.6263388395309448,
-0.07167387753725052,
-0.42166534066200256,
0.5700922608375549,
0.3693898320198059,
-0.6601294875144958,
0.7174845933914185,
0.3263399600982666,
-0.036784715950489044,
-0.8150709271430969,
-0.7143270969390869,
0.47378045320510864,
-0.35712549090385437,
-0.3143656253814697,
0.6164785027503967,
0.00036729563726112247,
-0.387593150138855,
-0.043262772262096405,
-0.1061529889702797,
-0.4741347134113312,
0.3942565619945526,
0.23562271893024445,
0.08910804241895676,
-0.21079382300376892,
-0.1640012562274933,
-0.3421167731285095,
-0.3548387289047241,
0.06918158382177353,
0.30870866775512695,
0.41351744532585144,
0.25148656964302063,
0.09604519605636597,
-0.7731181383132935,
0.3511100709438324,
0.46729686856269836,
-0.4929104745388031,
0.8864141702651978,
0.4383520185947418,
-0.42183658480644226,
-0.09680786728858948,
-0.9204251170158386,
-0.04218606650829315,
-0.5314099788665771,
0.1700366735458374,
-0.009557463228702545,
-0.9138371348381042,
0.5026205778121948,
-0.4053959250450134,
0.20450268685817719,
0.37063536047935486,
0.3148513734340668,
0.19685004651546478,
0.48795297741889954,
0.8343028426170349,
-0.24271170794963837,
0.37568235397338867,
0.02468254044651985,
0.3663288354873657,
-0.415333092212677,
-0.24705442786216736,
-0.9222264289855957,
-0.32482513785362244,
-0.9413074851036072,
-0.06002264469861984,
-0.25314056873321533,
-0.1780053675174713,
-0.22468581795692444,
0.37772855162620544,
-0.5247510671615601,
0.5830672383308411,
0.4730912744998932,
-0.08052603900432587,
0.6663864254951477,
-0.24800699949264526,
0.27162814140319824,
-0.054701391607522964,
-0.33032315969467163,
-0.8218535780906677,
0.972777247428894,
0.3760283291339874,
0.7806287407875061,
0.012213672511279583,
0.5200679302215576,
0.2646366357803345,
0.5273522138595581,
-0.38952186703681946,
0.5364455580711365,
-0.5899918079376221,
-0.637768566608429,
-0.2153356969356537,
-0.47392356395721436,
-0.9727410078048706,
0.2525307834148407,
-0.3911016285419464,
-0.9324577450752258,
0.199149027466774,
0.046790074557065964,
-0.11752023547887802,
0.5050373673439026,
-0.5879758596420288,
0.6951663494110107,
0.19079354405403137,
-0.4442686438560486,
0.24236434698104858,
-0.7526617050170898,
0.27909886837005615,
-0.10696287453174591,
0.3919403851032257,
-0.017061280086636543,
-0.21632669866085052,
0.7134954929351807,
0.06592828780412674,
0.876945972442627,
-0.0025608313735574484,
-0.05425705388188362,
-0.0885574221611023,
-0.01333994884043932,
0.5808117389678955,
-0.23667331039905548,
-0.5038784742355347,
0.41265785694122314,
-0.3028380572795868,
0.02833184041082859,
-0.2617025673389435,
0.6557233929634094,
-0.5138349533081055,
-0.3072459101676941,
-0.02090376988053322,
-0.5767351984977722,
-0.05169496312737465,
0.44134679436683655,
0.5287789702415466,
0.7053135633468628,
-0.4271458089351654,
0.8595553040504456,
0.8458902835845947,
-0.20752651989459991,
0.9895167350769043,
0.6477745771408081,
0.3651583194732666,
-0.43391042947769165,
0.28494325280189514,
0.28919291496276855,
-0.014929531142115593,
0.8730751276016235,
0.27327030897140503,
-0.4634855091571808,
-0.847425639629364,
-0.3350243866443634,
0.038847021758556366,
-0.533708393573761,
-0.2430141568183899,
-0.9053748250007629,
-0.44227293133735657,
-0.14691860973834991,
-0.15210169553756714,
-0.5810465216636658,
-0.399870902299881,
-0.08457028865814209,
-0.029538854956626892,
0.13733811676502228,
0.8318108916282654,
0.5492146015167236,
0.35464993119239807,
-0.39174047112464905,
0.5062674283981323,
-0.0219697505235672,
0.44447654485702515,
0.13864485919475555,
-0.3167553246021271,
0.012006246484816074,
-0.24316991865634918,
-0.304851770401001,
-0.7373998761177063,
0.102235808968544,
0.0938282161951065,
0.6280564069747925,
0.13353285193443298,
0.2055053859949112,
0.23402749001979828,
-0.7299678921699524,
0.7994464635848999,
0.013799441047012806,
-0.7941792011260986,
0.10224490612745285,
-0.04524596780538559,
0.24818846583366394,
0.6917231678962708,
0.33796200156211853,
-0.34614041447639465,
-0.7587244510650635,
-0.6126753091812134,
-0.9693019390106201,
0.312902569770813,
0.3789370357990265,
0.2949708104133606,
0.26541668176651,
0.42346933484077454,
0.5401374101638794,
0.33762994408607483,
-0.8618773818016052,
-0.6121758818626404,
0.2897777259349823,
-0.31689003109931946,
-0.135372593998909,
-0.23457138240337372,
0.15463633835315704,
0.10395467281341553,
0.3140508830547333,
0.3403444290161133,
-0.14080719649791718,
0.08371321856975555,
-0.2086106389760971,
0.27434787154197693,
0.3411772549152374,
0.42891567945480347,
0.6643367409706116,
0.07770684361457825,
0.31967949867248535,
0.3614739179611206,
-0.6763665676116943,
0.21678484976291656,
0.21550410985946655,
-0.6080629229545593,
0.290606826543808,
0.47602903842926025,
0.6348873376846313,
0.28906479477882385,
-0.4150717854499817,
0.5034733414649963,
-0.13638892769813538,
-0.3337993323802948,
0.05272264778614044,
0.14331293106079102,
0.14936788380146027,
0.10974352061748505,
0.3915256857872009,
0.17369936406612396,
0.39263373613357544,
-0.2289462387561798,
0.054617974907159805,
0.3013288676738739,
-0.20963241159915924,
-0.32290273904800415,
0.9726588129997253,
-0.026403581723570824,
-0.7630583047866821,
0.07048119604587555,
0.3256187438964844,
-0.18547727167606354,
0.5064979195594788,
0.36667686700820923,
1.0921860933303833,
-0.5201455950737,
-0.1438419669866562,
0.33032840490341187,
0.29790398478507996,
-0.35163527727127075,
-0.29555854201316833,
-0.10801108181476593,
-0.26598596572875977,
-0.04532669857144356,
-0.41692060232162476,
-0.8781298398971558,
0.16813120245933533,
-0.7943800091743469,
0.11119700223207474,
-0.3871195912361145,
0.00328980665653944,
0.2762872576713562,
0.2331746220588684,
-0.8782094717025757,
0.38922807574272156,
0.21417507529258728,
0.9695175290107727,
-0.777445912361145,
0.7093073129653931,
0.4295405447483063,
0.3182777166366577,
-0.41315603256225586,
0.12143509835004807,
0.09041916579008102,
-0.4106796681880951,
0.026762841269373894,
0.44317737221717834,
-0.3662874698638916,
0.00623066071420908,
-0.3291408121585846,
-0.7268389463424683,
1.1693906784057617,
0.45749762654304504,
-0.7946599125862122,
0.07798030972480774,
0.4730388820171356,
0.8165098428726196,
-0.10517220199108124,
0.37002450227737427,
0.6214569807052612,
0.38624340295791626,
-0.09859635680913925,
-0.7728545069694519,
0.2008407860994339,
-0.016599804162979126,
0.0034515412990003824,
0.2068188637495041,
-0.9114482998847961,
0.7459245920181274,
0.27349743247032166,
-0.4289397597312927,
0.3709981143474579,
0.5232487916946411,
-0.13168345391750336,
0.32526132464408875,
0.2304614931344986,
0.2305864542722702,
0.9430034756660461,
0.005039582494646311,
0.8162449598312378,
-0.3948907256126404,
0.46772006154060364,
1.1926604509353638,
-0.24690738320350647,
0.9338492155075073,
0.23699671030044556,
-0.034055642783641815,
0.3707056939601898,
0.24149617552757263,
-0.2481953203678131,
0.5873535871505737,
0.24197320640087128,
-0.1530665010213852,
0.3238384425640106,
-0.09865494817495346,
-0.28234025835990906,
0.48046499490737915,
-0.12940381467342377,
-0.5859764814376831,
-0.4127044379711151,
-0.15418682992458344,
0.2967926561832428,
0.4138146936893463,
-0.03392617404460907,
1.0267269611358643,
-0.18551523983478546,
-0.504726767539978,
0.23606792092323303,
0.10780484229326248,
0.9051358103752136,
-0.6352986693382263,
0.24734723567962646,
-0.49438199400901794,
0.37850889563560486,
-0.08981670439243317,
-0.49901464581489563,
0.2403375208377838,
0.3771117329597473,
-0.22158576548099518,
-0.4951123893260956,
0.7377176284790039,
-0.3656235337257385,
-0.4244847595691681,
0.3400576412677765,
0.35391363501548767,
-0.04532347619533539,
0.18884795904159546,
-0.4841889441013336,
0.1643889993429184,
-0.3111326992511749,
-0.26240354776382446,
0.16890421509742737,
0.5540928244590759,
0.016333751380443573,
0.6650999188423157,
0.23800994455814362,
-0.1166205108165741,
-0.04992900416254997,
0.11046954244375229,
0.6671232581138611,
-0.6834286451339722,
-0.4839392304420471,
-1.3620126247406006,
0.1295810490846634,
-0.31333139538764954,
-0.4076182246208191,
1.110752820968628,
1.0542834997177124,
0.6778832674026489,
0.24025042355060577,
0.492620050907135,
0.32569971680641174,
0.7038760781288147,
-0.4528462290763855,
0.8693816661834717,
-0.18577158451080322,
0.5904778242111206,
-0.21808096766471863,
-0.9451337456703186,
-0.4702602028846741,
-0.08040472865104675,
-0.1014370396733284,
-0.2776823043823242,
0.5362502336502075,
0.8639355897903442,
-0.20215651392936707,
0.3644578754901886,
0.21523138880729675,
0.16618332266807556,
0.3352454900741577,
0.21878443658351898,
0.7823132276535034,
-0.49054187536239624,
0.525149941444397,
-0.36274591088294983,
-0.15770192444324493,
0.05715765058994293,
-0.9742530584335327,
-1.018191933631897,
-0.08586089313030243,
-0.426253080368042,
0.0745234563946724,
0.27530473470687866,
0.21737264096736908,
0.6099086999893188,
-0.8438776135444641,
-0.22899268567562103,
0.06563224643468857,
-0.061673328280448914,
-0.2826302647590637,
-0.114287368953228,
0.6654192209243774,
0.06524938344955444,
-0.8181405067443848,
0.3260546028614044,
0.2682304084300995,
0.1110396608710289,
-0.12274663895368576,
0.2935011088848114,
0.06658875942230225,
0.2661689221858978,
0.16395632922649384,
-0.009373344480991364,
-0.6237908601760864,
-0.24161621928215027,
0.19589300453662872,
-0.2446281611919403,
0.20925405621528625,
0.7748182415962219,
-0.7667481303215027,
0.4059216380119324,
0.38534075021743774,
0.811914324760437,
0.4988841116428375,
0.2565518915653229,
0.42113691568374634,
-0.6809141039848328,
0.10313483327627182,
0.2600443959236145,
0.07160668075084686,
0.43199029564857483,
-0.35760754346847534,
0.5595645308494568,
-0.06923181563615799,
-0.4352255165576935,
-0.9402502179145813,
-0.26983338594436646,
-0.5914897918701172,
-0.36049583554267883,
1.085863709449768,
-0.2225245237350464,
-0.06249361112713814,
-0.14249074459075928,
-0.14220325648784637,
0.08337537199258804,
0.008923916146159172,
0.7912867069244385,
0.6442133188247681,
0.29739290475845337,
-0.06811696290969849,
-0.6737091541290283,
0.5882912278175354,
0.2171764224767685,
-0.6712766289710999,
0.3765828013420105,
0.08124799281358719,
0.32128629088401794,
-0.1390509456396103,
0.44714194536209106,
-0.18652239441871643,
0.048372168093919754,
0.05557232350111008,
-0.20766328275203705,
-0.11332056671380997,
-0.3477684259414673,
-0.41449597477912903,
0.6649081707000732,
-0.4914464056491852,
-0.3292766213417053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14057v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14057v2
|
Bored to Death: Artificial Intelligence Research Reveals the Role of Boredom in Suicide Behavior
| 2024-04-22T10:16:02 | 2024-04-26T11:50:25 |
Shir Lissak, Yaakov Ophir, Refael Tikochinski, Anat Brunstein Klomek, Itay Sisso, Eyal Fruchter, Roi Reichart
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Background: Recent advancements in Artificial Intelligence (AI) contributed
significantly to suicide assessment, however, our theoretical understanding of
this complex behavior is still limited. Objective: This study aimed to harness
AI methodologies to uncover hidden risk factors that trigger or aggravate
suicide behaviors. Method: The primary dataset included 228,052 Facebook
postings by 1,006 users who completed the gold-standard Columbia Suicide
Severity Rating Scale. This dataset was analyzed using a bottom-up research
pipeline without a-priory hypotheses and its findings were validated using a
top-down analysis of a new dataset. This secondary dataset included responses
by 1,062 participants to the same suicide scale as well as to well-validated
scales measuring depression and boredom. Results: An almost fully automated,
AI-guided research pipeline resulted in four Facebook topics that predicted the
risk of suicide, of which the strongest predictor was boredom. A comprehensive
literature review using APA PsycInfo revealed that boredom is rarely perceived
as a unique risk factor of suicide. A complementing top-down path analysis of
the secondary dataset uncovered an indirect relationship between boredom and
suicide, which was mediated by depression. An equivalent mediated relationship
was observed in the primary Facebook dataset as well. However, here, a direct
relationship between boredom and suicide risk was also observed. Conclusions:
Integrating AI methods allowed the discovery of an under-researched risk factor
of suicide. The study signals boredom as a maladaptive 'ingredient' that might
trigger suicide behaviors, regardless of depression. Further studies are
recommended to direct clinicians' attention to this burdening, and sometimes
existential experience.
|
[
-0.35270774364471436,
-1.088871717453003,
1.0176345109939575,
0.1662527471780777,
-0.08573968708515167,
-0.08537498116493225,
0.10527362674474716,
-0.10621247440576553,
0.3972149193286896,
0.09770776331424713,
-0.968932569026947,
-0.26932939887046814,
-0.38103073835372925,
0.17000247538089752,
-0.38569241762161255,
0.6874114274978638,
0.2578620910644531,
-0.021866023540496826,
-0.44948291778564453,
0.26130568981170654,
-0.30143314599990845,
-0.2608071267604828,
-0.8558478951454163,
-0.2851813733577728,
0.9972333312034607,
0.10650519281625748,
0.9846760034561157,
0.22252050042152405,
0.5631683468818665,
0.3375770151615143,
0.18266694247722626,
-0.21461117267608643,
-0.7505314350128174,
-0.05516815558075905,
0.1889592856168747,
-0.5242933034896851,
-0.04809451848268509,
0.20127840340137482,
-0.19427451491355896,
0.6761520504951477,
0.010525689460337162,
0.24776950478553772,
-0.11378861218690872,
0.8651493191719055,
-0.5152384638786316,
-0.21927538514137268,
0.012220350094139576,
0.32858818769454956,
-0.3308228552341461,
-0.4098303020000458,
-0.21715229749679565,
-0.5115349888801575,
-0.06777812540531158,
-0.6442031860351562,
-0.014804404228925705,
-0.11656001955270767,
0.27001842856407166,
1.1466155052185059,
-0.48702290654182434,
-0.5702936053276062,
-0.9358624219894409,
0.5185548067092896,
-0.4580828547477722,
-0.294940710067749,
0.3733854293823242,
-0.010949229821562767,
-0.295968621969223,
-0.1035427525639534,
-0.6395621299743652,
-0.3553025722503662,
-0.023341231048107147,
0.2584468126296997,
0.05753818154335022,
0.30729296803474426,
0.44615039229393005,
0.5561965703964233,
-0.6510844230651855,
0.07185449451208115,
-0.6537712216377258,
0.03612512722611427,
1.149804949760437,
0.4120575189590454,
0.7759930491447449,
-0.26992881298065186,
-0.025053611025214195,
0.13822995126247406,
-0.06398901343345642,
0.64374840259552,
0.8569093942642212,
-0.3026646673679352,
-0.10136572271585464,
0.9151490330696106,
-0.17112435400485992,
0.4049919545650482,
-0.2076687514781952,
-0.010945692658424377,
0.3511868119239807,
0.11513083428144455,
0.11472136527299881,
0.2282525897026062,
0.9267064332962036,
0.6843075752258301,
0.2185729593038559,
-0.18321730196475983,
0.21264192461967468,
-0.08389386534690857,
0.7462243437767029,
-0.3744339048862457,
-0.3728390634059906,
0.7643812298774719,
-0.666175365447998,
-0.4035818874835968,
0.059837959706783295,
-0.6317052841186523,
-0.39541739225387573,
0.06601395457983017,
0.6901702880859375,
-0.5719972252845764,
-0.10917150229215622,
-0.09432043135166168,
-0.7184115052223206,
-0.35301801562309265,
0.345000684261322,
0.09285618364810944,
-0.051375553011894226,
0.39681392908096313,
1.0208710432052612,
-0.5026062726974487,
-0.19575200974941254,
-0.2844754755496979,
-0.18217527866363525,
-0.48310303688049316,
0.7908018231391907,
-0.15757925808429718,
-0.22669343650341034,
0.08184733986854553,
0.00702042318880558,
0.14629335701465607,
-0.3219873905181885,
0.5907633304595947,
-0.21635304391384125,
0.2955188751220703,
-0.2383691668510437,
-0.3696788549423218,
-0.7362249493598938,
-0.07435476034879684,
-0.8089104294776917,
0.9412494897842407,
0.26503676176071167,
-0.3992460072040558,
0.12712685763835907,
-0.7641890048980713,
-0.5830944180488586,
0.3379274010658264,
-0.06377700716257095,
-0.22015105187892914,
0.21773865818977356,
-0.5701068639755249,
0.3637114465236664,
-0.09777112305164337,
0.2234933078289032,
-0.6537689566612244,
-0.45741602778434753,
0.555817723274231,
-0.33532702922821045,
1.1004153490066528,
0.19004376232624054,
-0.18375007808208466,
-0.1667362004518509,
-0.5409619212150574,
-0.03969141095876694,
0.10990392416715622,
-0.20890027284622192,
-0.5548608899116516,
0.2762458324432373,
-0.21858632564544678,
0.7710669636726379,
0.1872192770242691,
-0.5880555510520935,
-0.24145743250846863,
-0.1589866727590561,
0.11960450559854507,
0.5646568536758423,
0.5753834843635559,
-0.2734696567058563,
-0.9883894324302673,
0.6453366279602051,
-0.10909455269575119,
0.44787806272506714,
0.2762494683265686,
-0.6963882446289062,
-0.37131914496421814,
-0.23867276310920715,
-0.4380066394805908,
0.9102311730384827,
-0.4789241850376129,
0.4127409756183624,
0.1440904438495636,
-0.6768615245819092,
-0.3943057954311371,
-0.05068736523389816,
0.24557112157344818,
0.35012421011924744,
0.552666187286377,
-0.2902214825153351,
-0.12349957227706909,
-0.7242143750190735,
-0.21170133352279663,
-0.021254142746329308,
-0.1211027055978775,
0.5010829567909241,
0.22025451064109802,
-0.15028323233127594,
0.7216982245445251,
-0.5191342830657959,
-0.44303032755851746,
-0.05475099757313728,
0.29017266631126404,
0.22227495908737183,
0.42387551069259644,
0.5629894733428955,
-0.8882595896720886,
-0.4364740550518036,
-0.36685094237327576,
-1.1505588293075562,
-0.02691415138542652,
-0.6427940130233765,
-0.09924430400133133,
-0.2103668749332428,
0.39149010181427,
-0.8787386417388916,
1.1548781394958496,
-0.19231963157653809,
0.12381233274936676,
0.3718148171901703,
0.06998870521783829,
0.1135142371058464,
-0.39034661650657654,
0.27854377031326294,
-0.1533023566007614,
0.3034769892692566,
-0.8106078505516052,
-0.21388688683509827,
-0.5894323587417603,
-0.43309178948402405,
-0.4616607427597046,
0.1878514289855957,
-0.1339552104473114,
0.07637220621109009,
-0.3192639946937561,
-0.04865996167063713,
-0.27421802282333374,
0.429058313369751,
-0.5405060648918152,
0.5332022309303284,
0.48986202478408813,
-0.5679665207862854,
0.49999016523361206,
0.3576532006263733,
0.08430814743041992,
0.1326625645160675,
-0.5146515965461731,
-0.29035356640815735,
-0.5465516448020935,
-0.0052703991532325745,
-1.2795677185058594,
-0.5209087133407593,
0.5009784698486328,
-0.6268449425697327,
-0.25623437762260437,
0.5567460656166077,
-0.18694551289081573,
-0.6869929432868958,
-0.5610100030899048,
0.2977137565612793,
0.5659756660461426,
0.6488422751426697,
0.7512418031692505,
0.1876710206270218,
-0.756287693977356,
-0.2668745517730713,
-0.7119672894477844,
-0.11196498572826385,
-0.34287920594215393,
-0.19425785541534424,
0.3626193404197693,
-0.5460669994354248,
-0.5118372440338135,
-0.08203727006912231,
-0.09936828911304474,
0.14646415412425995,
0.2775132954120636,
0.9611131548881531,
-0.0734235942363739,
0.15039408206939697,
0.12737496197223663,
0.10888683050870895,
-0.10822253674268723,
0.4910300076007843,
0.4786854684352875,
0.691966712474823,
0.5610639452934265,
-0.5191127061843872,
-0.9553343653678894,
0.5274916887283325,
0.7039108276367188,
0.39729440212249756,
0.5302411913871765,
0.23547221720218658,
-0.22908450663089752,
0.02402838133275509,
-0.5074602961540222,
0.2089873105287552,
-0.4573676884174347,
0.058015044778585434,
0.23128913342952728,
-0.4241451621055603,
0.6520079970359802,
-0.2500668466091156,
-0.06977865844964981,
0.36112675070762634,
0.6225009560585022,
-0.4024835526943207,
0.8982970118522644,
0.7369012832641602,
-0.1689707487821579,
0.3686191439628601,
-0.02774062007665634,
0.559540867805481,
-0.27349376678466797,
-0.30858713388442993,
-0.05773963779211044,
-0.5948377847671509,
-0.7277132272720337,
-0.24882446229457855,
0.6499337553977966,
0.05946064367890358,
-0.5708313584327698,
-0.263954222202301,
-0.4005986452102661,
0.3709433376789093,
0.6963129043579102,
0.33228254318237305,
0.1219857782125473,
-0.25917044281959534,
0.2839837670326233,
0.3135664761066437,
-0.41700392961502075,
-0.1595429629087448,
0.9104139804840088,
-0.017150068655610085,
0.5165796875953674,
0.024279210716485977,
1.1295350790023804,
0.8556268215179443,
0.1554676741361618,
-0.5740227103233337,
0.5364081263542175,
-0.1401674598455429,
-0.5892525315284729,
-0.6523745059967041,
-0.37063154578208923,
-0.5164716839790344,
-0.8393310308456421,
0.18852420151233673,
-0.9127491116523743,
0.3692350387573242,
-0.016014352440834045,
-1.0776288509368896,
-0.28804662823677063,
-0.560619056224823,
0.5796210765838623,
-0.7146085500717163,
-0.3505561053752899,
-0.27993127703666687,
-1.0218032598495483,
0.7779099345207214,
-0.3414148688316345,
0.3738027811050415,
-0.3957914113998413,
0.32270339131355286,
0.5921518206596375,
-0.3005582392215729,
0.7709851264953613,
-0.06434065848588943,
0.2613646388053894,
0.40978968143463135,
0.21459856629371643,
0.3728674352169037,
0.19901110231876373,
-0.47133108973503113,
-0.025906620547175407,
-0.23849037289619446,
-0.41755592823028564,
-0.343747079372406,
0.6537229418754578,
-1.081753134727478,
-0.44610822200775146,
-0.4952394664287567,
-0.9463537335395813,
0.1382274180650711,
0.18567639589309692,
0.4160960912704468,
-0.17910993099212646,
0.028747286647558212,
-0.02583026885986328,
0.33144381642341614,
-0.6115350723266602,
0.7072886228561401,
0.11506650596857071,
-0.15831202268600464,
-0.32380080223083496,
1.0468076467514038,
0.1914481818675995,
0.31543654203414917,
0.007420770823955536,
-0.050840504467487335,
0.18068324029445648,
-0.15939106047153473,
0.07420080900192261,
0.22932565212249756,
-0.29088085889816284,
-0.1859087347984314,
-0.9190717339515686,
-0.3719773590564728,
-0.41428467631340027,
-0.2277056872844696,
-0.22668375074863434,
-0.33953016996383667,
-0.6313888430595398,
-0.0617695115506649,
0.4982549846172333,
0.9680636525154114,
-0.3302992880344391,
0.2596026360988617,
-0.5839582085609436,
0.6094660758972168,
0.3181951940059662,
-0.023720337077975273,
0.12618865072727203,
0.1538703739643097,
0.01514382753521204,
0.018284684047102928,
-0.6171746850013733,
-1.0680549144744873,
0.39369648694992065,
0.3620595335960388,
0.6108677387237549,
0.9040451049804688,
0.5711439251899719,
0.8510333299636841,
-0.047033555805683136,
0.999415934085846,
-0.0697498470544815,
-0.3490826189517975,
0.36292406916618347,
-0.4346590042114258,
-0.2341884970664978,
0.6907669305801392,
1.1657675504684448,
-0.56662517786026,
-0.4480770230293274,
-0.7762101888656616,
-0.873381495475769,
0.7087020874023438,
0.2996189594268799,
-0.014206177555024624,
0.14937394857406616,
0.49101051688194275,
0.2668195366859436,
0.37075215578079224,
-0.8132508397102356,
-0.7592722773551941,
-0.31114137172698975,
-0.1457601934671402,
0.028050560504198074,
-0.27822479605674744,
-0.2577933073043823,
-0.11831167340278625,
0.5422343611717224,
0.08475365489721298,
0.5377530455589294,
0.09512092918157578,
0.146724671125412,
-0.9179873466491699,
-0.37238451838493347,
0.5273621678352356,
0.45888543128967285,
-0.4489654004573822,
-0.35420727729797363,
-0.1634770631790161,
-0.17600885033607483,
0.14052627980709076,
0.4936072528362274,
-0.5561574101448059,
-0.21457670629024506,
0.5439864993095398,
0.3509890139102936,
-0.32822075486183167,
-1.0831763744354248,
0.4678111672401428,
-0.05080776661634445,
-0.15120773017406464,
-0.9459255337715149,
0.7011496424674988,
-0.09543588757514954,
0.24856078624725342,
0.6934231519699097,
0.2579532563686371,
0.38737162947654724,
-0.7000839710235596,
0.2777442932128906,
0.5072213411331177,
-0.3367065191268921,
-0.2852720320224762,
0.4654221832752228,
-0.1310730129480362,
-0.927840530872345,
0.5127272009849548,
-0.4200122058391571,
-0.34531012177467346,
0.6847782731056213,
-0.14164818823337555,
0.781397819519043,
-0.1459406614303589,
0.7208521962165833,
0.31018900871276855,
0.19613240659236908,
0.06630901992321014,
0.5416694283485413,
0.1216936707496643,
-0.025691742077469826,
-0.07173623889684677,
-0.7318243980407715,
-0.3179246187210083,
0.4948025643825531,
-0.595878005027771,
0.22007155418395996,
-0.33494701981544495,
0.039089567959308624,
-0.25150299072265625,
-0.1299217939376831,
-0.44888967275619507,
0.36578142642974854,
0.36045801639556885,
0.4989745616912842,
-0.9587110280990601,
-0.03131541609764099,
0.4622148871421814,
-0.793517529964447,
-0.5610758066177368,
0.7353735566139221,
0.20867767930030823,
-0.500980794429779,
0.5126237273216248,
0.6000457406044006,
0.25016939640045166,
0.15337759256362915,
-0.6309739351272583,
-1.2864588499069214,
0.9925550818443298,
-0.0035941919777542353,
0.004775592125952244,
-0.16422925889492035,
0.6608231067657471,
0.6312461495399475,
-0.18847745656967163,
0.3037399351596832,
0.20213952660560608,
0.5846842527389526,
-0.0951816737651825,
-0.4536641836166382,
-0.02989865653216839,
-0.5405685305595398,
-0.2047795206308365,
0.007479678373783827,
-0.8468570709228516,
0.9720121622085571,
-0.40149950981140137,
-0.29620030522346497,
0.23228998482227325,
0.35301893949508667,
0.013180848211050034,
0.9195840358734131,
0.3016171455383301,
0.9101414084434509,
0.3895662724971771,
0.41800856590270996,
0.5579595565795898,
-0.33127322793006897,
0.08925450593233109,
0.5367802977561951,
-0.4393073618412018,
0.5038498640060425,
0.4891965091228485,
0.00047360084136016667,
0.6602515578269958,
0.739628791809082,
0.0389476902782917,
0.5687415599822998,
0.20682178437709808,
-0.23743519186973572,
-0.5418201088905334,
-0.18830206990242004,
-0.1905084103345871,
0.2726379930973053,
0.5224607586860657,
-0.3120509386062622,
-0.37961679697036743,
0.6289385557174683,
-0.23569060862064362,
-0.2822597920894623,
0.11261953413486481,
0.7866401076316833,
0.03963388875126839,
-0.835647702217102,
0.21805787086486816,
-0.46835240721702576,
0.21081091463565826,
-0.40462055802345276,
-0.09317614138126373,
-0.06007501482963562,
0.10973826795816422,
-0.06794246286153793,
-0.6780893802642822,
0.39235377311706543,
-0.20770283043384552,
-0.09564092755317688,
-0.042571473866701126,
0.5983787775039673,
-0.06391549110412598,
-0.5963005423545837,
0.2669382691383362,
0.6283266544342041,
0.32816141843795776,
-0.30581822991371155,
-0.7482730150222778,
-0.2333652824163437,
0.11090358346700668,
-0.46436965465545654,
0.5220293998718262,
0.7521946430206299,
0.03851942718029022,
1.1222445964813232,
0.9303351640701294,
-0.03008151799440384,
-0.04204662889242172,
-0.6081535816192627,
1.07447350025177,
-1.0137288570404053,
-0.24036148190498352,
-0.688777506351471,
0.7320489883422852,
0.030478358268737793,
-0.5444434881210327,
0.6051301956176758,
0.5679166316986084,
0.5039572715759277,
-0.2686360776424408,
0.9118449687957764,
-0.6734184622764587,
0.6466476321220398,
-0.20429854094982147,
1.0041264295578003,
-0.8179829120635986,
0.07536057382822037,
-0.16888417303562164,
-0.5187530517578125,
-0.19515688717365265,
0.18427257239818573,
-0.5758686065673828,
0.049823153764009476,
0.8018452525138855,
0.75087571144104,
0.374498188495636,
-0.3540813624858856,
0.18061025440692902,
0.332462877035141,
0.0874074399471283,
0.491716593503952,
0.7523434162139893,
-0.23979125916957855,
0.42254069447517395,
-0.8744320869445801,
-0.28313004970550537,
-0.7169727683067322,
-0.5205856561660767,
-1.1463373899459839,
-0.5228418707847595,
-0.32880985736846924,
-0.018233858048915863,
0.22507736086845398,
0.7918684482574463,
-0.20732098817825317,
-0.38426274061203003,
0.04175497964024544,
-0.29876962304115295,
0.12409157305955887,
-0.4084475338459015,
-0.2936619222164154,
0.3137277364730835,
-0.45185399055480957,
-0.14676009118556976,
0.17010597884655,
0.44412708282470703,
-0.04820294305682182,
-0.20749004185199738,
0.1233547255396843,
-0.46193891763687134,
-0.07995579391717911,
0.1922243982553482,
0.3769388198852539,
-0.7765964865684509,
-0.048751309514045715,
-0.0860913023352623,
-0.07995500415563583,
-0.22219665348529816,
0.5949463248252869,
-0.7616897225379944,
-0.10468799620866776,
0.6758508682250977,
0.20839427411556244,
-0.37036314606666565,
0.4989655613899231,
0.3222365975379944,
-0.4680003523826599,
-0.05384402722120285,
0.5042298436164856,
-0.15496350824832916,
-0.049481090158224106,
-1.3061524629592896,
0.4019964933395386,
0.4863893389701843,
-0.8817474246025085,
-0.9719617962837219,
-0.040563538670539856,
-1.001308560371399,
-0.3109462559223175,
0.7107797861099243,
0.01838163286447525,
-0.3507941663265228,
-0.2986273467540741,
-0.2509365677833557,
0.3564758002758026,
-0.5233969688415527,
1.3520982265472412,
0.6345146298408508,
-0.7004895806312561,
-0.11447607725858688,
-0.967970609664917,
0.9314849972724915,
0.38629984855651855,
-0.6996854543685913,
0.05824001505970955,
0.4782167077064514,
-0.11334482580423355,
0.4760653078556061,
0.29612189531326294,
0.5725508332252502,
0.6648523807525635,
-0.16409115493297577,
-0.08430096507072449,
-0.11438994854688644,
-0.24478645622730255,
0.2463303953409195,
0.4005419909954071,
-0.4319400489330292,
0.27291280031204224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14052v1
|
Differential contributions of machine learning and statistical analysis to language and cognitive sciences
| 2024-04-22T10:06:21 | 2024-04-22T10:06:21 |
Kun Sun, Rong Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, stat.ME
|
Data-driven approaches have revolutionized scientific research. Machine
learning and statistical analysis are commonly utilized in this type of
research. Despite their widespread use, these methodologies differ
significantly in their techniques and objectives. Few studies have utilized a
consistent dataset to demonstrate these differences within the social sciences,
particularly in language and cognitive sciences. This study leverages the
Buckeye Speech Corpus to illustrate how both machine learning and statistical
analysis are applied in data-driven research to obtain distinct insights. This
study significantly enhances our understanding of the diverse approaches
employed in data-driven strategies.
|
[
-0.04193304479122162,
-1.5140533447265625,
0.4529344141483307,
0.24096691608428955,
0.3922034204006195,
0.41803666949272156,
-0.2929514944553375,
-0.2345653474330902,
0.21784569323062897,
0.4583778977394104,
-0.8593773245811462,
-0.3406839370727539,
-0.44724041223526,
0.18002949655056,
-0.4090995192527771,
0.7665561437606812,
0.29510724544525146,
0.6665681600570679,
-0.3690323233604431,
-0.10805052518844604,
-0.6614882946014404,
-0.5823577642440796,
-0.5925702452659607,
-0.24079746007919312,
0.31133008003234863,
0.5982105731964111,
0.6715691089630127,
0.6110469102859497,
0.7710536122322083,
0.30238860845565796,
0.40080907940864563,
-0.32697823643684387,
-0.46819600462913513,
0.3025151491165161,
-0.15136907994747162,
-0.6977876424789429,
-0.1802719235420227,
0.1637779027223587,
0.9215281009674072,
1.4295793771743774,
-0.047861747443675995,
0.1043652892112732,
0.038300059735774994,
1.0352402925491333,
-0.5259716510772705,
0.7764090299606323,
-0.7331482768058777,
0.07493744790554047,
-0.6208422183990479,
-0.31387633085250854,
-0.44266653060913086,
-0.5746103525161743,
0.24361789226531982,
-0.6187929511070251,
0.3942108750343323,
-0.1577964872121811,
0.4007102847099304,
0.27125439047813416,
-0.27975335717201233,
-0.5536553263664246,
-0.8911296725273132,
1.4255328178405762,
-0.2358289659023285,
0.3157029449939728,
0.44799870252609253,
0.2821539640426636,
-0.4407126307487488,
-0.37468162178993225,
-0.5074834823608398,
-0.11416496336460114,
0.15410518646240234,
-0.04003051295876503,
-0.4599209427833557,
-0.31373047828674316,
0.10885251313447952,
0.1143370270729065,
-0.6416033506393433,
0.44756245613098145,
-0.6784073114395142,
-0.19169029593467712,
0.8289769291877747,
0.64012610912323,
0.2557867467403412,
0.09579384326934814,
0.30084386467933655,
-0.3777438998222351,
-0.3747630715370178,
0.2727159261703491,
0.19836345314979553,
0.6510230898857117,
0.1126897782087326,
0.6314952969551086,
-0.5455800294876099,
0.5992217659950256,
-0.33532872796058655,
-0.05213820934295654,
0.4150330722332001,
-0.26142141222953796,
-0.21744278073310852,
0.18701821565628052,
0.8739715218544006,
0.18058376014232635,
0.3742101788520813,
-0.15213172137737274,
0.1479286551475525,
0.639182448387146,
0.017938587814569473,
-0.4827730059623718,
-0.3389706015586853,
0.11153072118759155,
-0.4033939838409424,
-0.590147078037262,
-0.023300528526306152,
-1.1336613893508911,
-0.2365184724330902,
-0.5169522762298584,
-0.06509251892566681,
-0.3360099792480469,
-0.1983458399772644,
0.028377056121826172,
-0.3557743728160858,
0.17143703997135162,
0.02559753507375717,
-0.9712982177734375,
0.6887691020965576,
0.7931426763534546,
0.6966310739517212,
-0.4866923689842224,
-0.15171441435813904,
-0.38669899106025696,
-0.0609024278819561,
-0.7967440485954285,
0.7867255210876465,
-1.0625877380371094,
-0.39181509613990784,
0.21470162272453308,
-0.09539417922496796,
-0.11460927128791809,
-0.6300141215324402,
0.19324438273906708,
-0.5162680745124817,
0.22479884326457977,
-0.41803261637687683,
-0.47147640585899353,
-0.5699821710586548,
-0.395626038312912,
-0.7268308401107788,
0.980900228023529,
0.021558519452810287,
-0.5461934804916382,
1.0037264823913574,
-0.7748825550079346,
-0.7121006846427917,
0.10200513154268265,
-0.5344607830047607,
-0.6479735970497131,
0.1984575092792511,
-0.05037694051861763,
0.6318917274475098,
-0.23862674832344055,
0.28801268339157104,
-0.6996650099754333,
-0.19330260157585144,
0.6400614380836487,
-0.39551597833633423,
1.248726725578308,
0.41272231936454773,
-0.4381193518638611,
-0.1353287696838379,
-1.0369648933410645,
0.0462871789932251,
0.3822382390499115,
-0.12411196529865265,
-0.3465324640274048,
0.3969230055809021,
0.04904024675488472,
-0.2993106245994568,
-0.07165602594614029,
-0.5214397311210632,
0.11143168807029724,
-0.06077825278043747,
0.47019514441490173,
0.5575063228607178,
-0.13908088207244873,
0.5114614963531494,
-0.2613133192062378,
0.3122265338897705,
-0.10609257966279984,
-0.09793819487094879,
0.24403467774391174,
-0.43621957302093506,
-0.32134610414505005,
-0.4584095776081085,
0.16998526453971863,
0.9270094633102417,
-0.551166832447052,
0.17628350853919983,
-0.20870232582092285,
-0.5569933652877808,
-0.628202497959137,
0.028272299095988274,
-0.1265527606010437,
0.6762716770172119,
0.31239795684814453,
-0.2954254448413849,
-0.6830078363418579,
-0.660825788974762,
-0.22244183719158173,
-0.29749515652656555,
0.178263321518898,
0.29068657755851746,
0.3025679290294647,
-0.354128897190094,
1.2775925397872925,
-0.5967652797698975,
-0.19738522171974182,
-0.1560596078634262,
0.25669386982917786,
0.1305089294910431,
0.43920716643333435,
0.5835504531860352,
-0.7219744920730591,
-0.29195910692214966,
-0.12698866426944733,
-1.1839385032653809,
-0.3246269226074219,
-0.016506854444742203,
0.06169262155890465,
0.3350432515144348,
0.17518463730812073,
-0.09228515625,
0.7756780385971069,
0.35524317622184753,
-0.17742770910263062,
0.4911644458770752,
0.02169295959174633,
0.4898642897605896,
-0.6409091353416443,
-0.14424006640911102,
0.042194169014692307,
0.2095595747232437,
-0.9401497840881348,
-0.5272565484046936,
-0.18370474874973297,
0.0032321480102837086,
0.01258552074432373,
-0.013030560687184334,
-0.2500385046005249,
-0.23605673015117645,
-0.2990555167198181,
-0.26046860218048096,
-0.3637901544570923,
-0.07386383414268494,
0.2403627336025238,
0.6058645248413086,
1.0213894844055176,
-0.8925440311431885,
0.5272964239120483,
0.20038814842700958,
-0.35221433639526367,
0.29027581214904785,
-0.7059354782104492,
0.07502538710832596,
-0.17066845297813416,
0.004957399796694517,
-1.1587941646575928,
-0.29636919498443604,
0.27648526430130005,
-0.7186654806137085,
0.041400253772735596,
0.24584177136421204,
-0.38734954595565796,
-0.16615848243236542,
-0.2577587962150574,
0.1049278974533081,
0.42140111327171326,
0.044665370136499405,
0.0913906991481781,
0.8144670128822327,
-0.6354076862335205,
-0.30474838614463806,
-1.1399791240692139,
-0.12026320397853851,
-0.4970088601112366,
-0.6198105812072754,
0.07695123553276062,
0.007791360840201378,
-0.9843270778656006,
-0.05675167590379715,
0.3846801817417145,
-0.44613996148109436,
0.34260815382003784,
0.19145770370960236,
0.6492470502853394,
-0.473315566778183,
0.41473183035850525,
0.01599576696753502,
-0.04327786713838577,
0.28723761439323425,
-0.09184712171554565,
0.41733694076538086,
0.10983854532241821,
-0.12140598148107529,
-0.704509973526001,
0.5872059464454651,
0.3882477283477783,
0.013761572539806366,
0.7411838173866272,
0.3407166004180908,
-0.08178266882896423,
0.07333903014659882,
-0.4091697335243225,
-0.46117210388183594,
-0.36141690611839294,
0.43256813287734985,
-0.19553641974925995,
-0.7240235209465027,
0.23845292627811432,
0.18513663113117218,
0.14175131916999817,
0.2983158230781555,
0.5918498039245605,
-0.277141273021698,
0.9124557375907898,
0.6708257794380188,
-0.3573189973831177,
0.7135391235351562,
-0.04829985275864601,
0.0775289237499237,
-0.28254440426826477,
0.07475210726261139,
-0.9434382319450378,
0.04641468822956085,
-0.9761269092559814,
-0.10842596739530563,
0.0765208825469017,
-0.3789937496185303,
0.09397807717323303,
-0.03213996812701225,
-0.46200621128082275,
-0.12276729941368103,
0.4534323811531067,
-0.2228108048439026,
0.1865771859884262,
0.3881450891494751,
0.14308185875415802,
-0.2673262357711792,
-0.7055453062057495,
-0.7294517755508423,
1.485185146331787,
0.18747806549072266,
0.775907039642334,
-0.07292436063289642,
0.5612320899963379,
0.5184155702590942,
-0.12295230478048325,
-0.8878408670425415,
0.4835984706878662,
0.03372473269701004,
-0.7690629959106445,
-0.5631313323974609,
-0.7396779656410217,
-1.3405849933624268,
0.17811337113380432,
-0.4617398977279663,
-0.7712261080741882,
0.19923624396324158,
-0.004994362127035856,
0.16037419438362122,
-0.11265978217124939,
-0.7692375183105469,
0.4099414348602295,
-0.01169065572321415,
-0.28187498450279236,
-0.3943736255168915,
-0.386353075504303,
-0.029576890170574188,
-0.21522854268550873,
0.5645200610160828,
-0.03410112485289574,
0.28850629925727844,
1.237382173538208,
0.054725416004657745,
0.7903397679328918,
-0.06685488671064377,
0.21413126587867737,
0.31333455443382263,
0.01967277191579342,
0.09659220278263092,
0.0829622745513916,
-0.23164315521717072,
0.3801211416721344,
0.29092511534690857,
-0.6826410293579102,
-0.3456451892852783,
0.6882005333900452,
-0.5407342314720154,
-0.6191364526748657,
-0.5592713952064514,
-0.846017599105835,
-0.35358908772468567,
0.004125919193029404,
-0.07651172578334808,
0.35715532302856445,
-0.3848457932472229,
0.27930518984794617,
0.7549567818641663,
-0.0008729035034775734,
0.648434042930603,
0.7010490894317627,
-0.09645266830921173,
-0.13322752714157104,
0.8735032677650452,
0.42438197135925293,
0.07169213891029358,
0.35090968012809753,
0.3614240288734436,
-0.10129746794700623,
-0.40003010630607605,
-0.01097605936229229,
0.20672236382961273,
-0.44769200682640076,
0.41660913825035095,
-0.478738397359848,
0.33780479431152344,
-1.0161488056182861,
-0.10277090966701508,
-0.23087561130523682,
-0.42895227670669556,
-0.26898694038391113,
-0.10226579010486603,
0.5243702530860901,
0.8314195275306702,
-0.19380910694599152,
0.040706779807806015,
-0.2792006731033325,
0.21264228224754333,
0.12417374551296234,
-0.22374311089515686,
-0.15874899923801422,
0.19501830637454987,
0.03064793162047863,
0.23718251287937164,
-0.22523853182792664,
-1.0312514305114746,
0.3166860044002533,
0.1418895572423935,
0.6988442540168762,
0.23704269528388977,
-0.16122311353683472,
0.6407636404037476,
-0.4672287702560425,
0.7961007356643677,
0.013099963776767254,
-0.6627235412597656,
0.8221489191055298,
-0.09059195220470428,
0.014572756364941597,
0.4592200517654419,
0.39055103063583374,
-0.20317989587783813,
-0.24143393337726593,
-0.5616481900215149,
-0.49295246601104736,
0.629909873008728,
0.202577605843544,
-0.16433225572109222,
0.09624791145324707,
-0.1133832186460495,
0.5037997961044312,
0.03677823767066002,
-0.006918126717209816,
-0.39036256074905396,
0.061839453876018524,
-0.28193792700767517,
-0.39820796251296997,
0.3370234966278076,
-0.08576805889606476,
-0.3665974736213684,
0.6268844604492188,
-0.1970491111278534,
0.23284560441970825,
0.12720030546188354,
-0.05522555112838745,
0.13189007341861725,
0.3182676136493683,
0.3194161653518677,
0.9699404239654541,
0.09383449703454971,
-0.202310249209404,
0.008549559861421585,
-0.8539822101593018,
-0.12249482423067093,
0.1714784801006317,
-0.2703776955604553,
0.17459239065647125,
0.4370216131210327,
0.574556827545166,
-0.07375799119472504,
-0.6958630681037903,
-0.07295840978622437,
-0.08978317677974701,
-0.3159436583518982,
-0.35481899976730347,
0.05512265861034393,
-0.3008706271648407,
0.17502598464488983,
0.669041097164154,
-0.02223057672381401,
0.3412582278251648,
-0.9541596174240112,
0.3143598735332489,
0.5636624693870544,
-0.5516058802604675,
-0.22121062874794006,
0.25269177556037903,
-0.28504177927970886,
-0.020162779837846756,
0.7818008661270142,
0.47363221645355225,
-0.048573508858680725,
0.6180858612060547,
0.36551299691200256,
0.5260517597198486,
0.005381830036640167,
0.4524649977684021,
-0.10194141417741776,
-0.12130764871835709,
0.341474324464798,
0.34769222140312195,
-0.26232895255088806,
-0.575854480266571,
-0.22515228390693665,
-0.3580176830291748,
-0.24946774542331696,
-0.029010064899921417,
-1.1178033351898193,
0.20980313420295715,
-0.213087797164917,
-0.3723828196525574,
0.6833500266075134,
0.3027721047401428,
-0.8522562384605408,
0.21489763259887695,
-0.15618260204792023,
0.3699999451637268,
-1.0460375547409058,
0.779071033000946,
0.7420538663864136,
-0.33402374386787415,
-0.4699768126010895,
-0.22757156193256378,
0.4157888889312744,
-0.7908610105514526,
1.084529995918274,
-0.23131513595581055,
-0.12468308210372925,
-0.15212006866931915,
-0.6815825700759888,
-0.5979610085487366,
0.8972153663635254,
-0.030700206756591797,
-0.3198835253715515,
0.4793107807636261,
0.3546536862850189,
0.439015656709671,
-0.5113644003868103,
0.06651110202074051,
0.7904872894287109,
0.3034285604953766,
-0.08151432126760483,
-0.8372241854667664,
-0.23949158191680908,
0.21425798535346985,
0.008114062249660492,
0.05932145565748215,
-0.21691861748695374,
0.8114596605300903,
-0.2011358141899109,
-0.28433433175086975,
-0.24452729523181915,
0.8251628875732422,
0.3999279737472534,
0.788680374622345,
0.07719434797763824,
0.26598477363586426,
1.1068525314331055,
-0.07995367050170898,
0.5798636078834534,
0.2836696207523346,
0.39008206129074097,
0.6913400888442993,
-0.50800621509552,
0.8037950992584229,
0.7903903126716614,
-0.6392433643341064,
0.5116305947303772,
0.5463643074035645,
-0.1301763355731964,
0.5465064644813538,
0.27537745237350464,
-0.13063623011112213,
0.17413361370563507,
-0.014143738895654678,
-0.17314960062503815,
0.5858023166656494,
0.6656501293182373,
-0.2973088324069977,
0.12189605087041855,
0.1997690498828888,
0.14939016103744507,
0.16263169050216675,
-0.28269162774086,
0.9811669588088989,
-0.11560027301311493,
-0.40740785002708435,
0.3015567660331726,
-0.5285462141036987,
0.4126729965209961,
-0.5553282499313354,
-0.15725837647914886,
0.07342708855867386,
0.19823934137821198,
-0.26458075642585754,
-0.9637757539749146,
0.5376009345054626,
0.09966511279344559,
-0.374268501996994,
-0.04498179256916046,
0.49457892775535583,
0.02801121398806572,
-0.6108455657958984,
0.05657736212015152,
0.41170355677604675,
0.35892489552497864,
0.3244161903858185,
-0.5271432399749756,
0.31018298864364624,
0.07780967652797699,
0.09457754343748093,
0.1759551614522934,
0.4621841311454773,
-0.27057111263275146,
0.8344615697860718,
0.6956152319908142,
0.3734898567199707,
0.3239673674106598,
-0.071477010846138,
0.5958110690116882,
-0.8219598531723022,
-0.3223941922187805,
-1.0129731893539429,
0.18318551778793335,
-0.15370135009288788,
-0.15514078736305237,
0.8850486874580383,
0.5379249453544617,
0.9297821521759033,
-0.15477599203586578,
1.1319221258163452,
-0.30063462257385254,
0.7513383626937866,
-0.6116555333137512,
0.5090814828872681,
-0.0647510215640068,
0.0358676053583622,
-0.48802441358566284,
-0.6856597661972046,
-0.3240046203136444,
0.5447854399681091,
-0.6859745383262634,
-0.172447070479393,
0.6871169209480286,
0.7326412200927734,
0.37859222292900085,
0.22943365573883057,
0.1647525578737259,
0.03347722813487053,
0.45536112785339355,
0.2469993531703949,
0.716714084148407,
-0.35664838552474976,
0.15929755568504333,
-0.3264879286289215,
-0.7622843980789185,
-0.14497175812721252,
-0.4380161166191101,
-0.7948750257492065,
-0.9717053174972534,
-0.5524175763130188,
0.06591635197401047,
0.10210306197404861,
0.47431498765945435,
0.7070075869560242,
-0.9711185097694397,
-0.5374394655227661,
-0.2180282026529312,
-0.08184704184532166,
-0.41176992654800415,
-0.4163101315498352,
0.14888417720794678,
-0.6312001347541809,
-0.6565873622894287,
0.4246125817298889,
0.15086108446121216,
-0.11784516274929047,
-0.27268487215042114,
0.20149672031402588,
-0.08559708297252655,
0.15720921754837036,
0.4838949739933014,
0.32465070486068726,
-0.5487421751022339,
0.11626291275024414,
0.18282490968704224,
-0.06191859766840935,
0.0633636862039566,
0.8636813163757324,
-0.9277015924453735,
0.47310712933540344,
0.7419471144676208,
0.6110011339187622,
0.18620379269123077,
-0.24480900168418884,
0.7326857447624207,
-0.028844531625509262,
0.0925867110490799,
0.33753448724746704,
0.15055963397026062,
0.33873480558395386,
-0.4410495460033417,
0.3985633850097656,
0.4010218679904938,
-0.8026629686355591,
-0.5606750845909119,
0.10994721949100494,
-0.9046201109886169,
-0.4788389205932617,
0.9196490049362183,
0.2234269380569458,
-0.3513212203979492,
-0.3103628158569336,
-0.1391715258359909,
0.27455994486808777,
-0.6612747311592102,
0.923713207244873,
1.1030217409133911,
-0.6947364807128906,
0.04845060408115387,
-1.0083866119384766,
0.3499222993850708,
0.4345508813858032,
-0.6824949979782104,
0.011414185166358948,
0.49474871158599854,
0.3414970636367798,
0.10689334571361542,
0.219136044383049,
-0.21881507337093353,
0.12009632587432861,
0.09331643581390381,
-0.36165788769721985,
0.44960272312164307,
-0.14026814699172974,
-0.3618682622909546,
0.17057670652866364,
-0.20391376316547394,
-0.5509986281394958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14043v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14043v1
|
LLMs Know What They Need: Leveraging a Missing Information Guided Framework to Empower Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-04-22T09:56:59 | 2024-04-22T09:56:59 |
Keheng Wang, Feiyu Duan, Peiguang Li, Sirui Wang, Xunliang Cai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) demonstrates great value in alleviating
outdated knowledge or hallucination by supplying LLMs with updated and relevant
knowledge. However, there are still several difficulties for RAG in
understanding complex multi-hop query and retrieving relevant documents, which
require LLMs to perform reasoning and retrieve step by step. Inspired by
human's reasoning process in which they gradually search for the required
information, it is natural to ask whether the LLMs could notice the missing
information in each reasoning step. In this work, we first experimentally
verified the ability of LLMs to extract information as well as to know the
missing. Based on the above discovery, we propose a Missing Information Guided
Retrieve-Extraction-Solving paradigm (MIGRES), where we leverage the
identification of missing information to generate a targeted query that steers
the subsequent knowledge retrieval. Besides, we design a sentence-level
re-ranking filtering approach to filter the irrelevant content out from
document, along with the information extraction capability of LLMs to extract
useful information from cleaned-up documents, which in turn to bolster the
overall efficacy of RAG. Extensive experiments conducted on multiple public
datasets reveal the superiority of the proposed MIGRES method, and analytical
experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed modules.
|
[
-0.5422541499137878,
-0.5411822199821472,
0.8558468222618103,
-0.04677961394190788,
-0.13990457355976105,
0.2752920091152191,
0.1541871875524521,
-0.37168341875076294,
0.28042203187942505,
0.5689414143562317,
-0.5970925092697144,
-0.4321013391017914,
-0.7702612280845642,
0.21770329773426056,
-0.5192294716835022,
0.9308139085769653,
0.06813577562570572,
-0.19057603180408478,
-0.4058578908443451,
0.24183078110218048,
-0.5480342507362366,
-0.06222165748476982,
-0.6346255540847778,
-0.4334631562232971,
0.9194140434265137,
0.4879149794578552,
0.12279031425714493,
0.6913646459579468,
0.39921048283576965,
0.11978094279766083,
-0.4875588119029999,
0.8270214200019836,
-0.5791849493980408,
0.1659436970949173,
-0.3075307607650757,
-0.4249882996082306,
-0.34587669372558594,
-0.10240241885185242,
0.36149996519088745,
0.5695213675498962,
-0.0590914711356163,
0.29812222719192505,
0.32458066940307617,
0.9621102213859558,
-0.8426479697227478,
-0.07868663966655731,
-0.8528670072555542,
0.11591177433729172,
-0.1956975907087326,
-0.894522488117218,
-0.5096316337585449,
-0.2716173231601715,
-0.07801714539527893,
-0.7636104822158813,
0.3084072470664978,
0.32242193818092346,
0.9346314668655396,
0.3668227195739746,
-0.4886292517185211,
-0.5556886792182922,
-0.7635030746459961,
0.6173397898674011,
-0.34763139486312866,
0.4868593215942383,
0.571858823299408,
0.11361371725797653,
-0.591731071472168,
-0.6648836731910706,
-0.27200767397880554,
0.031807657331228256,
-0.21598953008651733,
0.19761435687541962,
0.062063030898571014,
-0.15713216364383698,
0.24854034185409546,
0.4074583351612091,
-0.31956222653388977,
-0.3242796063423157,
-0.3421947658061981,
0.031063063070178032,
0.273867130279541,
-0.03812553733587265,
-0.0286320261657238,
-0.48961782455444336,
-0.5595501065254211,
0.25276169180870056,
-0.8184758424758911,
-0.2069745659828186,
0.21606402099132538,
0.23876936733722687,
0.2564140260219574,
0.6541473865509033,
-0.21370291709899902,
0.9297623634338379,
0.23308175802230835,
-0.31098631024360657,
0.05290146917104721,
-0.11616820842027664,
-0.08773917704820633,
-0.16876251995563507,
0.19189639389514923,
-0.06992118805646896,
-0.10622037947177887,
-0.4290810525417328,
-0.5695649981498718,
-0.4641704857349396,
0.34302133321762085,
-0.4566360116004944,
0.0995965301990509,
-0.11178060621023178,
-0.3605903387069702,
-0.26394882798194885,
-0.11251377314329147,
-1.0536689758300781,
-0.6266629695892334,
-0.4581082761287689,
0.663932204246521,
-0.38654670119285583,
-0.2708589732646942,
-0.08927185088396072,
-0.560335099697113,
0.35501629114151,
0.4046659469604492,
-0.6857014894485474,
0.13816185295581818,
0.7570984363555908,
0.7099069952964783,
-0.22931420803070068,
0.06325344741344452,
-0.6779993176460266,
0.5686765313148499,
-0.2853221893310547,
1.1515171527862549,
-0.4513486623764038,
-0.37419354915618896,
-0.17447629570960999,
-0.14680011570453644,
-0.08459214121103287,
-0.5363063216209412,
0.6092134118080139,
-0.7674288153648376,
0.26420658826828003,
-0.4682624936103821,
-0.7152008414268494,
-0.26240137219429016,
0.6288906931877136,
-0.5975234508514404,
1.0473496913909912,
0.10315318405628204,
-0.9487205743789673,
0.387781023979187,
-0.4426347315311432,
-0.26786425709724426,
0.1535281389951706,
-0.3267011046409607,
-0.19373083114624023,
0.1274937093257904,
0.26082709431648254,
0.2684042751789093,
-0.6194233894348145,
0.19859802722930908,
0.08825760334730148,
-0.5577410459518433,
-0.17118914425373077,
-0.31165772676467896,
0.5916164517402649,
0.20951460301876068,
-0.2178850769996643,
-0.3645989000797272,
-0.8734018802642822,
-0.06620247662067413,
0.1793917715549469,
-0.8326596021652222,
-0.42414841055870056,
0.187615767121315,
-0.4685056507587433,
0.06952564418315887,
0.2572309672832489,
-0.5073674321174622,
0.17028982937335968,
-0.3010565936565399,
-0.2113608419895172,
0.8551815748214722,
0.4565500319004059,
0.4457475244998932,
-0.7063722610473633,
0.45896512269973755,
-0.1478334367275238,
-0.033262379467487335,
-0.1537405550479889,
-0.4386273920536041,
-0.9680227637290955,
-0.31461992859840393,
0.24289058148860931,
0.5823395252227783,
-0.888827919960022,
0.19830802083015442,
-0.08071064203977585,
-0.4554236829280853,
-0.49538153409957886,
0.24892406165599823,
0.39047756791114807,
0.9163589477539062,
0.48041343688964844,
0.28113898634910583,
-0.788307785987854,
-0.6622613072395325,
-0.63581782579422,
0.014197246171534061,
-0.0408020094037056,
0.45444256067276,
0.22772559523582458,
-0.28073132038116455,
1.0353832244873047,
-0.5079399943351746,
-0.41673731803894043,
-0.3217872977256775,
0.1726469248533249,
0.2882627248764038,
0.043862633407115936,
-0.10985846817493439,
-1.1149530410766602,
-0.04856028035283089,
0.053435780107975006,
-0.9369484782218933,
-0.3655937612056732,
-0.06502578407526016,
-0.26973092555999756,
0.09259060770273209,
0.4694106876850128,
-0.38894182443618774,
0.5384610891342163,
0.17098085582256317,
-0.18466228246688843,
0.4418927729129791,
-0.1770046502351761,
0.1693950891494751,
-0.9625297784805298,
0.3246685266494751,
-0.14735889434814453,
-0.19411571323871613,
-0.3413209915161133,
-0.22373156249523163,
0.018550796434283257,
0.07359908521175385,
-0.21092791855335236,
0.8001260757446289,
-0.8638350367546082,
-0.2532029449939728,
-0.493587464094162,
0.41028180718421936,
0.39911356568336487,
0.5831984281539917,
-0.2798998951911926,
0.7668769359588623,
0.2126006782054901,
-0.9554126262664795,
-0.09165883809328079,
0.2532172203063965,
-0.0037291599437594414,
0.43662405014038086,
-0.12330763041973114,
0.1457497924566269,
-0.6289047598838806,
-0.048234086483716965,
-0.6859610676765442,
-0.2367716133594513,
0.2453325092792511,
-0.5916762351989746,
0.4051130414009094,
-0.4658891558647156,
-0.6032080054283142,
-0.16732971370220184,
-0.08290866762399673,
0.005014384631067514,
0.40500888228416443,
-0.6784846782684326,
1.161657452583313,
0.5075867772102356,
-0.02200622297823429,
-0.7654104232788086,
-0.2472999095916748,
0.004080199636518955,
-0.2196517437696457,
-0.356919527053833,
0.3741348087787628,
0.09783998876810074,
-0.2350717931985855,
0.12380021065473557,
-0.3320513963699341,
0.07593794912099838,
0.1448458433151245,
0.24425046145915985,
0.2927226722240448,
0.175882950425148,
0.3166709542274475,
-0.0010800748132169247,
-0.21324297785758972,
-0.015542601235210896,
-0.08377877622842789,
0.42896080017089844,
0.1868053674697876,
-0.40800702571868896,
0.017750190570950508,
0.3544904589653015,
0.34754467010498047,
-0.18894968926906586,
0.3406722843647003,
0.6368959546089172,
-0.5202087163925171,
-0.13406720757484436,
-0.8279044032096863,
-0.000038013182347640395,
-0.4591176211833954,
0.10533212125301361,
-0.3141074776649475,
-0.7509550452232361,
0.2539016306400299,
-0.480662077665329,
0.1110336035490036,
0.442975252866745,
0.35905858874320984,
-0.17309682071208954,
0.8966266512870789,
0.7570427656173706,
0.16454240679740906,
0.37276962399482727,
-0.27379634976387024,
0.06820110976696014,
-1.1869456768035889,
-0.7913145422935486,
-0.46718987822532654,
-0.18313278257846832,
-0.27548789978027344,
-0.275916188955307,
0.5791564583778381,
0.2831421494483948,
-0.018934382125735283,
0.09284554421901703,
-0.6259692907333374,
0.36724552512168884,
0.5909004211425781,
0.22364696860313416,
0.5195087790489197,
0.10338380187749863,
-0.3971329927444458,
0.15638485550880432,
-0.7280924320220947,
-0.45453688502311707,
0.9287166595458984,
-0.14128124713897705,
0.7336069345474243,
-0.013538175262510777,
0.9942578673362732,
0.482822060585022,
0.28903794288635254,
-0.7264081835746765,
0.6348384022712708,
0.10620463639497757,
-0.5782772302627563,
0.09337370097637177,
-0.5874003767967224,
-1.1359786987304688,
0.30265554785728455,
-0.28490325808525085,
-0.48818260431289673,
0.14957614243030548,
0.0524611659348011,
-0.09549127519130707,
0.3694193363189697,
-0.5825740098953247,
0.30022719502449036,
-0.2955051064491272,
-0.3737697899341583,
-0.029758285731077194,
-0.4514877498149872,
0.3518983721733093,
-0.30612948536872864,
0.4577971398830414,
-0.19514387845993042,
-0.18062613904476166,
0.7975448966026306,
-0.09740083664655685,
0.4345906376838684,
-0.3334852457046509,
0.04615796357393265,
0.4339284300804138,
0.08547011762857437,
0.6255966424942017,
-0.134832501411438,
-0.0776846632361412,
-0.2343585044145584,
-0.3818005323410034,
-0.12677769362926483,
-0.672343909740448,
0.7078814506530762,
-0.33943110704421997,
-0.9820550084114075,
-0.44870731234550476,
-0.5253499150276184,
-0.2673887610435486,
0.3694286346435547,
0.19440992176532745,
0.08969536423683167,
0.11250187456607819,
0.0055030351504683495,
0.8824880123138428,
-0.07368645071983337,
0.31937912106513977,
0.7229669094085693,
-0.3021318316459656,
-0.3564321994781494,
0.936997652053833,
0.15474045276641846,
-0.11341706663370132,
0.5822785496711731,
0.1963757574558258,
-0.1370287388563156,
-0.3767407238483429,
-0.4310765266418457,
0.34523123502731323,
-0.6406107544898987,
-0.4815242290496826,
-0.8047657608985901,
-0.3056105077266693,
-0.21004462242126465,
0.014737547375261784,
-0.0131593719124794,
-0.18552419543266296,
-0.5817134380340576,
0.005154214333742857,
0.3317314088344574,
0.8396892547607422,
-0.3168487846851349,
-0.03775179758667946,
-0.9523941278457642,
0.637648344039917,
0.1592831164598465,
0.18947350978851318,
0.09356246143579483,
-0.5303406715393066,
-0.26966404914855957,
-0.12707675993442535,
-0.4015417695045471,
-0.9848421216011047,
0.38969507813453674,
-0.05346302315592766,
0.8827841281890869,
0.08297839015722275,
-0.10727940499782562,
0.8241747617721558,
-0.42878255248069763,
0.3468950092792511,
-0.27534186840057373,
-0.5249569416046143,
0.8125807642936707,
-0.340713232755661,
-0.09362765401601791,
0.36307504773139954,
0.28362777829170227,
-0.30587294697761536,
-0.23302312195301056,
-0.6908958554267883,
-1.0313996076583862,
0.5496002435684204,
0.14615227282047272,
-0.36556097865104675,
-0.11704591661691666,
0.5831907391548157,
-0.040665388107299805,
0.13078826665878296,
-0.43504583835601807,
-0.23478737473487854,
0.3689485192298889,
-0.06207956746220589,
0.5122519135475159,
-0.3807750642299652,
-0.06609727442264557,
0.08841471374034882,
0.8411504030227661,
0.2592397630214691,
0.38750800490379333,
0.49638602137565613,
-0.08853337168693542,
-0.17012919485569,
0.26284632086753845,
0.24265116453170776,
0.6347630023956299,
-0.34402525424957275,
0.12124890089035034,
0.019592255353927612,
-0.29975685477256775,
0.22794249653816223,
0.15768778324127197,
-0.36418792605400085,
0.136198490858078,
0.04963706433773041,
0.4216599464416504,
0.05455988645553589,
-0.727399468421936,
0.5116397738456726,
-0.06829158216714859,
-0.06365916132926941,
-0.6189613342285156,
0.2120227962732315,
0.0635887011885643,
0.30040639638900757,
0.9392285346984863,
0.19028307497501373,
0.17913705110549927,
-0.12408313900232315,
0.5017858147621155,
0.4292162358760834,
-0.2048892229795456,
0.11093720048666,
0.5171570181846619,
-0.014687148854136467,
-0.4444279372692108,
0.30465561151504517,
-0.2756456434726715,
-0.2724872827529907,
0.4539337754249573,
0.5472451448440552,
0.6370421051979065,
0.20845231413841248,
-0.06221920624375343,
0.2399389147758484,
0.33120009303092957,
-0.25135597586631775,
0.22108791768550873,
-0.2560974955558777,
-0.4263709783554077,
-0.5590900182723999,
-0.6353135108947754,
-0.23617035150527954,
0.11835630983114243,
-0.7081121802330017,
0.3819848597049713,
-0.3078857362270355,
-0.06960742175579071,
-0.30677148699760437,
0.018715666607022285,
-0.5455882549285889,
0.19423678517341614,
-0.046307049691677094,
1.0632554292678833,
-0.4646924138069153,
0.3712833523750305,
0.33459314703941345,
-0.35892629623413086,
-0.8786638379096985,
0.11283978819847107,
0.02592487819492817,
-0.8970005512237549,
0.8253096342086792,
0.05584639310836792,
-0.3690015375614166,
0.3131917417049408,
-0.4298025369644165,
-1.1310174465179443,
1.394119143486023,
0.27649974822998047,
-0.3488676846027374,
-0.24659915268421173,
-0.4046347141265869,
0.18845728039741516,
-0.19943422079086304,
-0.01770818792283535,
0.46932703256607056,
0.6084397435188293,
0.5934420228004456,
-0.39298945665359497,
-0.20381657779216766,
-0.24536031484603882,
-0.300010621547699,
0.46078020334243774,
-0.2697259783744812,
0.7125264406204224,
-0.23261743783950806,
-0.30153629183769226,
0.022604653611779213,
0.5547177791595459,
0.5357499122619629,
0.5698270797729492,
0.3879474103450775,
0.7213258743286133,
0.8875070810317993,
0.22345976531505585,
1.029995322227478,
-0.08086837083101273,
0.10835082083940506,
1.1278249025344849,
-0.09645793586969376,
0.735670268535614,
0.6115391850471497,
0.3138577938079834,
0.5000234246253967,
0.462765097618103,
0.08003456145524979,
0.5225716829299927,
0.03294471278786659,
-0.5740005970001221,
-0.13265551626682281,
-0.35231244564056396,
-0.15038688480854034,
0.37613168358802795,
0.5535939335823059,
-0.5355529189109802,
-0.3897302746772766,
0.027881622314453125,
0.13003060221672058,
-0.0775085836648941,
-0.4826841950416565,
1.0077595710754395,
-0.07078395038843155,
-0.7910371422767639,
0.6818241477012634,
-0.03680101037025452,
0.5507006645202637,
-0.45592743158340454,
-0.3639950156211853,
-0.45044413208961487,
0.014052527956664562,
-0.2892124652862549,
-0.6396444439888,
0.3225429952144623,
0.20722724497318268,
-0.4195839762687683,
-0.21126364171504974,
1.2402732372283936,
-0.2699630856513977,
-0.36743125319480896,
0.43340933322906494,
0.9151960015296936,
0.3262709975242615,
-0.12269334495067596,
-0.4012087881565094,
-0.20500065386295319,
0.19302964210510254,
-0.25818881392478943,
0.304210364818573,
0.7379140853881836,
0.13192473351955414,
0.8544437289237976,
0.6475062966346741,
0.3989757001399994,
0.06458175182342529,
-0.10372786968946457,
1.0463303327560425,
-0.7529351115226746,
-0.09302082657814026,
-0.7909826636314392,
0.3076406419277191,
-0.24217432737350464,
0.07141482084989548,
0.7369816899299622,
0.7464213371276855,
0.6261309385299683,
0.12144091725349426,
0.7742584943771362,
-0.20691195130348206,
1.1207337379455566,
-0.5190157890319824,
0.5658977627754211,
-0.8442041873931885,
0.44327712059020996,
-0.13591714203357697,
-0.7872955799102783,
-0.25171464681625366,
0.35020455718040466,
-0.04542217403650284,
-0.007217699661850929,
0.49192309379577637,
0.9840645790100098,
0.10873302072286606,
-0.27067965269088745,
0.28380000591278076,
-0.10021056234836578,
0.28812113404273987,
0.5064578056335449,
0.9252443313598633,
-0.4365793466567993,
0.8846782445907593,
0.1886211782693863,
-0.20024365186691284,
-0.10394962131977081,
-0.8272154927253723,
-0.6770804524421692,
-0.4195992648601532,
0.1507706642150879,
-0.23916400969028473,
0.2700161635875702,
0.7465952634811401,
0.40003931522369385,
-0.1321561485528946,
0.14779727160930634,
-0.26784881949424744,
0.5323488712310791,
0.08207572251558304,
-0.22071340680122375,
0.23128095269203186,
-0.5696603059768677,
-0.5336626172065735,
0.6430330872535706,
0.47829359769821167,
0.19785284996032715,
-0.028491759672760963,
-0.016827667132019997,
-0.6183810830116272,
0.015397652052342892,
0.3461230397224426,
0.25743967294692993,
-0.5886930823326111,
-0.10721839964389801,
0.11943608522415161,
-0.14948366582393646,
0.17546644806861877,
0.940362811088562,
-1.1143475770950317,
0.2520875632762909,
0.4230668246746063,
0.9302283525466919,
0.5421447157859802,
0.1477922946214676,
0.29566505551338196,
-0.937661349773407,
-0.015027089044451714,
0.40189188718795776,
0.3092917799949646,
0.4234628975391388,
-0.5650900602340698,
0.6708106994628906,
0.3983040452003479,
-0.6891278624534607,
-0.6400622129440308,
0.16268518567085266,
-0.6746827363967896,
-0.2254261076450348,
1.3221102952957153,
-0.0008630705415271223,
-0.36947423219680786,
-0.30033063888549805,
-0.35366180539131165,
0.43529146909713745,
-0.2678074240684509,
0.9496874809265137,
0.5091782808303833,
-0.25982847809791565,
-0.24804401397705078,
-0.5156817436218262,
0.43211454153060913,
0.3412041962146759,
-0.7833787798881531,
-0.022072790190577507,
0.594713568687439,
0.21954849362373352,
0.253131240606308,
0.7683371305465698,
-0.2535612881183624,
0.005869939457625151,
-0.1653815656900406,
-0.08234131336212158,
-0.3159828186035156,
-0.4763188660144806,
0.13218344748020172,
0.2585753798484802,
0.13253919780254364,
-0.12123313546180725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14024v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14024v1
|
Exploring neural oscillations during speech perception via surrogate gradient spiking neural networks
| 2024-04-22T09:40:07 | 2024-04-22T09:40:07 |
Alexandre Bittar, Philip N. Garner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, q-bio.NC
|
Understanding cognitive processes in the brain demands sophisticated models
capable of replicating neural dynamics at large scales. We present a
physiologically inspired speech recognition architecture, compatible and
scalable with deep learning frameworks, and demonstrate that end-to-end
gradient descent training leads to the emergence of neural oscillations in the
central spiking neural network. Significant cross-frequency couplings,
indicative of these oscillations, are measured within and across network layers
during speech processing, whereas no such interactions are observed when
handling background noise inputs. Furthermore, our findings highlight the
crucial inhibitory role of feedback mechanisms, such as spike frequency
adaptation and recurrent connections, in regulating and synchronising neural
activity to improve recognition performance. Overall, on top of developing our
understanding of synchronisation phenomena notably observed in the human
auditory pathway, our architecture exhibits dynamic and efficient information
processing, with relevance to neuromorphic technology.
|
[
-0.2834588885307312,
-0.6792618632316589,
0.1903059035539627,
0.2203088402748108,
-0.17316775023937225,
0.092404305934906,
-0.2643526792526245,
-0.6371959447860718,
0.5842664241790771,
0.04412519559264183,
-0.8022100925445557,
0.041590020060539246,
-0.3929913640022278,
-0.25664934515953064,
-0.5066432356834412,
0.7436052560806274,
0.3478217124938965,
0.3253615200519562,
-0.008748231455683708,
-0.11737406998872757,
-0.35418370366096497,
-0.3414008617401123,
-0.8331083059310913,
-0.8144399523735046,
0.40811067819595337,
-0.33146053552627563,
0.32946717739105225,
0.5213301777839661,
-0.004090239759534597,
0.1358981877565384,
-0.4668065011501312,
-0.16964507102966309,
-0.21365179121494293,
0.5781720280647278,
-0.11645957082509995,
-0.43915796279907227,
-0.2137666493654251,
-0.24722717702388763,
0.590560257434845,
0.9768313765525818,
-0.5481423735618591,
-0.019079314544796944,
0.16850163042545319,
0.5337833762168884,
-0.4017261266708374,
0.2347167432308197,
-0.5564352869987488,
0.3997592031955719,
-0.22649338841438293,
-0.45234668254852295,
-0.12298908084630966,
-0.01658446155488491,
0.3903529942035675,
-0.32027116417884827,
0.24356511235237122,
-0.32792016863822937,
0.28754204511642456,
0.34896576404571533,
0.08538644015789032,
-0.4257257282733917,
-0.49306514859199524,
0.18289455771446228,
-0.07464490830898285,
0.9148296117782593,
0.1282067894935608,
0.19446773827075958,
-0.2477676421403885,
-0.9052926301956177,
-0.2591695487499237,
-0.32036441564559937,
0.4334847033023834,
0.34063512086868286,
-0.17433911561965942,
0.03682148829102516,
0.31199803948402405,
0.32923752069473267,
-0.46771883964538574,
-0.20432406663894653,
-0.3857242166996002,
-0.2703333795070648,
0.19976769387722015,
0.001375749590806663,
0.2265556901693344,
0.4801308512687683,
-0.19142818450927734,
0.2187177836894989,
-0.2590973377227783,
0.31018683314323425,
0.26886430382728577,
0.16381506621837616,
-0.07081298530101776,
-0.11082294583320618,
-0.004771082662045956,
0.36309441924095154,
0.23584973812103271,
0.47158825397491455,
0.4893113374710083,
0.08089416474103928,
-0.04433128982782364,
0.6579165458679199,
0.5359234809875488,
0.1671753227710724,
0.029911791905760765,
-0.4110397398471832,
-0.13401061296463013,
0.19224795699119568,
0.30785828828811646,
-0.7195751667022705,
-0.31983885169029236,
0.048678189516067505,
-0.35235974192619324,
-0.013196361251175404,
-0.5671488046646118,
-0.5078100562095642,
-0.573900043964386,
-0.3566705584526062,
0.4109903872013092,
-0.6020798683166504,
-0.4576188921928406,
0.543996274471283,
-0.518790066242218,
-0.20326225459575653,
0.24036206305027008,
-1.327273964881897,
0.43076834082603455,
0.5964680910110474,
0.8250241279602051,
0.09391683340072632,
-0.6077387928962708,
-0.2607609033584595,
-0.1384795606136322,
-0.4562940299510956,
0.3644474744796753,
-0.35918092727661133,
-0.35627952218055725,
-0.20445911586284637,
-0.3180045485496521,
0.1559135764837265,
-0.47949811816215515,
0.3716614842414856,
-0.49022918939590454,
-0.5965151786804199,
-0.3057233989238739,
-0.07410479336977005,
0.16908426582813263,
-0.20164324343204498,
-0.352022647857666,
0.8471134901046753,
-0.27090203762054443,
-0.4597955346107483,
0.2579646110534668,
-0.5794000029563904,
-0.5517574548721313,
0.1932293027639389,
-0.4721014201641083,
-0.29087892174720764,
0.5956799983978271,
-0.1480555534362793,
0.14939381182193756,
-0.09679636359214783,
0.20472539961338043,
-0.07067500054836273,
-0.27254483103752136,
0.496526837348938,
-0.6042801737785339,
0.7829827070236206,
0.23384469747543335,
-0.5856168270111084,
0.1437031328678131,
-1.1006721258163452,
-0.2853919565677643,
-0.06270529329776764,
-0.1934693306684494,
-0.12247787415981293,
0.20295822620391846,
-0.21380615234375,
-0.04159640520811081,
0.10395993292331696,
-0.5543031096458435,
-0.22086107730865479,
-0.35564255714416504,
1.0119578838348389,
0.4999617338180542,
0.049554575234651566,
0.27283069491386414,
-0.1906154900789261,
0.016833554953336716,
0.0933917686343193,
0.07048200070858002,
-0.43774348497390747,
-0.5210409164428711,
-0.4599667191505432,
-0.14111536741256714,
-0.1495896428823471,
0.033693235367536545,
-0.22620338201522827,
0.17719660699367523,
-0.1807168573141098,
-0.5706961154937744,
-0.28658604621887207,
-0.40669384598731995,
0.05028532072901726,
0.8523218631744385,
0.48775890469551086,
-0.492971271276474,
-0.587581217288971,
-0.5463172793388367,
-0.2741687595844269,
0.06836855411529541,
-0.0010035631712526083,
0.20865997672080994,
0.2549998462200165,
-0.15965624153614044,
0.6998264789581299,
-0.005072034429758787,
0.09879113733768463,
0.1767469197511673,
0.45901724696159363,
0.2803538739681244,
0.6755733489990234,
0.5204718708992004,
-0.48810875415802,
0.07743806391954422,
0.1169494241476059,
-0.4327610731124878,
-0.18031983077526093,
0.005225441884249449,
0.15512163937091827,
-0.276523232460022,
0.601201593875885,
-0.5768131017684937,
0.5151628851890564,
0.07420484721660614,
0.19432242214679718,
0.390274316072464,
0.06278789043426514,
-0.012193500995635986,
-0.6569528579711914,
-0.03009617328643799,
-0.17046348750591278,
0.08134535700082779,
-0.6798673272132874,
-0.10690775513648987,
0.10674484074115753,
-0.17035478353500366,
-0.13544729351997375,
-0.02372409589588642,
-0.403001070022583,
-0.2642018496990204,
-0.29887500405311584,
-0.06398928910493851,
-0.23502138257026672,
0.4330095946788788,
0.2264278531074524,
0.6451389193534851,
1.1009690761566162,
-0.5906818509101868,
0.340280145406723,
0.007994426414370537,
-0.3287407159805298,
0.5288681387901306,
-0.5837340950965881,
0.0053167748264968395,
-0.4184218943119049,
0.2423289567232132,
-0.7634971737861633,
-0.0011834795586764812,
-0.12442084401845932,
-1.0446534156799316,
0.27106890082359314,
-0.10844902694225311,
-0.1368020623922348,
0.09069094061851501,
-0.010751093737781048,
0.5082508325576782,
0.5618039965629578,
-0.6287574768066406,
0.7878984212875366,
0.549107015132904,
0.19601422548294067,
-0.5132697224617004,
-1.0854731798171997,
-0.07166614383459091,
0.21995633840560913,
-0.23394747078418732,
0.24897107481956482,
0.07611646503210068,
0.23688183724880219,
-0.42480143904685974,
-0.5371885895729065,
0.1541665941476822,
0.23563648760318756,
0.636116087436676,
-0.09872467070817947,
-0.25208112597465515,
0.13084861636161804,
-0.13683189451694489,
0.0981227234005928,
0.36281993985176086,
-0.6442345380783081,
0.9994305968284607,
-0.006534878630191088,
-0.2734709680080414,
-1.025292158126831,
-0.009990866295993328,
0.839449942111969,
-0.3789994716644287,
0.3138834834098816,
0.7003963589668274,
-0.6539793610572815,
-0.4198036789894104,
-0.00001532391797809396,
-0.4547281265258789,
-0.5166977643966675,
0.6710991263389587,
-0.29783138632774353,
-0.4698809087276459,
0.7043451070785522,
-0.16047105193138123,
-0.27238893508911133,
-0.025306634604930878,
0.6492728590965271,
-0.08760426938533783,
0.8751737475395203,
-0.012700504623353481,
0.00242530251853168,
0.8437078595161438,
-0.10939639061689377,
-0.012965098954737186,
-0.9455116987228394,
-0.404889315366745,
-0.4258444309234619,
-0.4873635172843933,
-0.32287782430648804,
-0.1720016896724701,
0.27123984694480896,
0.16534759104251862,
-0.38541993498802185,
0.11364810913801193,
-0.6089671850204468,
0.30520549416542053,
0.20405364036560059,
0.23975130915641785,
-0.3672139644622803,
0.30805131793022156,
-0.5448431372642517,
-0.10168438404798508,
-0.6494925022125244,
0.23521476984024048,
0.7425344586372375,
0.4368179738521576,
0.6930010318756104,
-0.3582521378993988,
0.4444786608219147,
0.12865185737609863,
0.03943294286727905,
-0.6675906181335449,
0.4804464876651764,
-0.02893206849694252,
-0.31478744745254517,
0.006091434042900801,
-0.2640064060688019,
-0.8026553392410278,
0.039838358759880066,
-0.45269376039505005,
-1.045291781425476,
0.44821643829345703,
0.18220919370651245,
-0.7020347714424133,
0.35225382447242737,
-0.11566989868879318,
0.14494366943836212,
-0.08683598786592484,
-0.6288224458694458,
-0.29533323645591736,
-0.5955374836921692,
-0.07472824305295944,
0.3921346962451935,
0.09486827999353409,
0.1849430352449417,
0.170047327876091,
0.33495819568634033,
0.19015762209892273,
0.9163728952407837,
-0.23789559304714203,
0.004476150497794151,
0.029930682852864265,
0.10819736868143082,
0.059776339679956436,
0.11126912385225296,
-0.23223091661930084,
0.43816933035850525,
-0.2881854474544525,
-0.11642340570688248,
-0.5237460732460022,
0.831902801990509,
-0.7883620262145996,
-0.30650296807289124,
-0.44591444730758667,
-0.7677701115608215,
-0.29430094361305237,
0.13871373236179352,
0.13725188374519348,
0.4921841621398926,
-0.15599563717842102,
0.47520148754119873,
0.7292885184288025,
0.32368722558021545,
0.4574691653251648,
0.09670056402683258,
-0.2703000009059906,
-0.6180615425109863,
0.6451137065887451,
0.46059611439704895,
0.21502724289894104,
0.10207517445087433,
0.0936153382062912,
-0.1489492505788803,
-0.7012404203414917,
-0.4834896922111511,
-0.2122231125831604,
-0.4862230122089386,
0.24731723964214325,
-0.6095533967018127,
-0.4367586076259613,
-0.21962033212184906,
0.13163518905639648,
-0.5028908848762512,
-0.32770267128944397,
-0.3481784462928772,
-0.11672450602054596,
0.12027759104967117,
0.508644163608551,
-0.22354882955551147,
0.507707417011261,
-0.4982241988182068,
0.26253843307495117,
0.4990192651748657,
0.5103786587715149,
0.42572489380836487,
-0.485364705324173,
-0.3769002854824066,
0.22291868925094604,
-0.18932266533374786,
-0.8642515540122986,
0.2483477145433426,
0.33785775303840637,
0.5478209853172302,
0.4475391209125519,
-0.45071110129356384,
0.8820125460624695,
-0.7392838001251221,
0.8916855454444885,
0.5370895862579346,
-1.18728506565094,
0.36084315180778503,
-0.1789855659008026,
0.1610131859779358,
0.20572422444820404,
0.33220577239990234,
-0.5518531799316406,
0.23900164663791656,
-0.3388093113899231,
-0.6975588202476501,
0.7589185237884521,
0.2709006071090698,
0.23358683288097382,
0.06498932838439941,
0.737411618232727,
-0.02643703669309616,
0.5173915028572083,
-0.28652358055114746,
-0.42735499143600464,
-0.25064218044281006,
0.08325551450252533,
0.004758371040225029,
0.19939903914928436,
-0.3379698693752289,
-0.21253091096878052,
0.32409173250198364,
-0.018499931320548058,
0.193472221493721,
0.42790487408638,
0.24454377591609955,
-0.3865136504173279,
-0.25345751643180847,
0.7309318780899048,
0.25150954723358154,
-0.07331446558237076,
0.22685857117176056,
0.24602027237415314,
-0.7484292387962341,
-0.14035409688949585,
0.05132828652858734,
-0.035593874752521515,
0.21645894646644592,
-0.011395161040127277,
1.1637086868286133,
0.11137168109416962,
-0.27955183386802673,
0.32655414938926697,
-0.22777165472507477,
-0.07028046250343323,
-0.2056231051683426,
0.2326842099428177,
0.35854753851890564,
0.6098970174789429,
0.5936189293861389,
0.7868078947067261,
0.1379893720149994,
-0.7569438815116882,
0.19273988902568817,
0.5340449810028076,
-0.5227596163749695,
-0.5736433863639832,
0.7712638974189758,
-0.10702525824308395,
-0.8018302917480469,
0.3583792448043823,
0.3515327274799347,
-0.5560534000396729,
0.7363391518592834,
0.7041221261024475,
0.8234548568725586,
-0.5441877841949463,
-0.4070148468017578,
0.15411287546157837,
0.12731145322322845,
-0.13034389913082123,
0.5572475790977478,
-0.8859734535217285,
-0.7045207619667053,
0.1306040734052658,
-0.7695987820625305,
-0.14110948145389557,
-0.017584921792149544,
-0.9910299181938171,
0.23014044761657715,
-0.8758606910705566,
-0.5215916037559509,
0.5775139927864075,
-0.5190964341163635,
-0.21973267197608948,
0.33280470967292786,
0.3895731568336487,
1.03725266456604,
-0.516822874546051,
0.7680397629737854,
0.5833357572555542,
-0.25365781784057617,
-0.3461591899394989,
0.09062118828296661,
-0.1672390252351761,
-0.9542931318283081,
0.675783634185791,
0.16510513424873352,
-0.6874802708625793,
0.049342889338731766,
-0.5994061231613159,
-0.687828540802002,
0.9759882688522339,
0.5502078533172607,
-0.7449964284896851,
0.28031080961227417,
0.12836025655269623,
0.7924708127975464,
-0.2683629095554352,
0.3056221604347229,
0.5138488411903381,
-0.24699071049690247,
0.24687762558460236,
-0.8859722018241882,
-0.32514917850494385,
-0.2698296904563904,
-0.13817285001277924,
0.15243668854236603,
-0.6355370283126831,
1.0129889249801636,
0.13424329459667206,
-0.2003619521856308,
0.1258842647075653,
0.5844740867614746,
0.4888724386692047,
0.5569209456443787,
0.42738232016563416,
0.6802623271942139,
0.6155303120613098,
-0.12118510156869888,
0.39328134059906006,
-0.7451680302619934,
0.162281796336174,
0.9678954482078552,
-0.3389209508895874,
0.8412074446678162,
0.8080658912658691,
-0.07963737845420837,
0.2799830138683319,
0.3948347866535187,
0.3721034824848175,
0.5106284022331238,
0.5100404024124146,
-0.3893546760082245,
-0.22227342426776886,
-0.1970641314983368,
-0.7860614061355591,
0.15926258265972137,
0.808387041091919,
-0.5788885951042175,
0.03184840828180313,
0.07778580486774445,
-0.46645069122314453,
0.014953282661736012,
-0.6878088116645813,
0.40203309059143066,
0.28295502066612244,
-0.2929506003856659,
0.58609539270401,
-0.7052265405654907,
0.6290282607078552,
-0.8247801065444946,
0.02355741709470749,
0.04658506438136101,
-0.04454318434000015,
-0.3251117169857025,
-0.5644091963768005,
0.34784191846847534,
-0.40268826484680176,
-0.26626095175743103,
-0.2733987867832184,
0.3762768507003784,
-0.1397726684808731,
0.13970014452934265,
0.6255525946617126,
-0.06177213788032532,
0.09910629689693451,
0.13380610942840576,
-0.34844061732292175,
0.27049851417541504,
-0.3561946451663971,
-0.032170798629522324,
0.35408613085746765,
0.397806316614151,
0.2674570679664612,
0.5483223795890808,
0.9544670581817627,
0.3677296042442322,
0.44481784105300903,
0.16625350713729858,
0.7559270262718201,
-0.4881882071495056,
-0.939046323299408,
-0.8068332672119141,
0.2104000300168991,
0.00238229357637465,
-0.3315429985523224,
0.2550874948501587,
0.44788405299186707,
0.7653263807296753,
-0.04014236479997635,
0.4775976538658142,
0.2895060181617737,
0.17121265828609467,
-0.20536644756793976,
1.0280534029006958,
-0.5020340085029602,
0.20107713341712952,
0.22927750647068024,
-0.4260508716106415,
-0.4106583297252655,
0.5488932132720947,
-0.05928012728691101,
-0.1313726156949997,
0.3442574739456177,
0.8009856939315796,
-0.013687501661479473,
0.7189658284187317,
0.642575740814209,
0.400477796792984,
-0.12320470809936523,
0.30886030197143555,
0.9362002611160278,
-0.32504406571388245,
0.08088329434394836,
-0.20535148680210114,
-0.12190903723239899,
-0.030598342418670654,
-0.470004677772522,
-0.6114591956138611,
-0.7053484916687012,
-0.2180039882659912,
-0.4863981604576111,
0.36861705780029297,
1.1126097440719604,
0.9642730951309204,
-0.7799767255783081,
-0.35512807965278625,
-0.8154457807540894,
-0.32294341921806335,
-0.4592496156692505,
-0.18799492716789246,
0.02616039291024208,
-0.42037832736968994,
-0.555869996547699,
0.7049721479415894,
0.6468409895896912,
-0.010206211358308792,
-0.1801586002111435,
0.02115061692893505,
0.03242356330156326,
0.1335563212633133,
0.2288668155670166,
0.5331293344497681,
-0.4253632724285126,
0.12732063233852386,
0.006841549649834633,
0.023087548092007637,
0.19213636219501495,
0.7775880098342896,
-0.7634170651435852,
0.5609109401702881,
0.675806999206543,
0.8604767322540283,
0.5193176865577698,
-0.5037521719932556,
0.2963747978210449,
-0.5263069868087769,
0.18299192190170288,
0.42674317955970764,
0.5062323808670044,
0.051879171282052994,
-0.3551909625530243,
-0.019161859527230263,
0.3501439392566681,
-0.5982441306114197,
-1.059011459350586,
0.3969339430332184,
-0.9134491086006165,
0.11696916818618774,
0.39476311206817627,
-0.19847437739372253,
-0.549363911151886,
0.0031677528750151396,
-0.22958889603614807,
0.6030620336532593,
-0.45291224122047424,
0.8120575547218323,
0.5195971727371216,
-0.6486068964004517,
-0.1804915815591812,
-0.43947240710258484,
0.6501049995422363,
0.61439049243927,
-0.14700330793857574,
0.09022960811853409,
0.23660898208618164,
0.396978497505188,
0.5649061799049377,
0.14794763922691345,
0.05828000605106354,
0.6585661172866821,
0.28829002380371094,
-0.022741863504052162,
-0.015434476546943188,
-0.31837958097457886,
-0.8958956599235535,
0.49307575821876526,
-0.22022567689418793,
-0.7359147071838379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14464v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14464v1
|
Tree of Reviews: A Tree-based Dynamic Iterative Retrieval Framework for Multi-hop Question Answering
| 2024-04-22T09:25:05 | 2024-04-22T09:25:05 |
Li Jiapeng, Liu Runze, Li Yabo, Zhou Tong, Li Mingling, Chen Xiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Multi-hop question answering is a knowledge-intensive complex problem. Large
Language Models (LLMs) use their Chain of Thoughts (CoT) capability to reason
complex problems step by step, and retrieval-augmentation can effectively
alleviate factual errors caused by outdated and unknown knowledge in LLMs.
Recent works have introduced retrieval-augmentation in the CoT reasoning to
solve multi-hop question answering. However, these chain methods have the
following problems: 1) Retrieved irrelevant paragraphs may mislead the
reasoning; 2) An error in the chain structure may lead to a cascade of errors.
In this paper, we propose a dynamic retrieval framework called Tree of
Reviews (ToR), where the root node is the question, and the other nodes are
paragraphs from retrieval, extending different reasoning paths from the root
node to other nodes. Our framework dynamically decides to initiate a new
search, reject, or accept based on the paragraphs on the reasoning paths.
Compared to related work, we introduce a tree structure to handle each
retrieved paragraph separately, alleviating the misleading effect of irrelevant
paragraphs on the reasoning path; the diversity of reasoning path extension
reduces the impact of a single reasoning error on the whole. We conducted
experiments on three different multi-hop question answering datasets. The
results show that compared to the baseline methods, ToR achieves
state-of-the-art performance in both retrieval and response generation. In
addition, we propose two tree-based search optimization strategies, pruning and
effective expansion, to reduce time overhead and increase the diversity of path
extension. We will release our code.
|
[
-0.33364158868789673,
-1.259238362312317,
0.7505599856376648,
0.29907405376434326,
-0.2993214726448059,
0.9614829421043396,
0.23782849311828613,
-0.5438917875289917,
0.36754006147384644,
0.14443384110927582,
-0.7299922704696655,
-0.23126675188541412,
-0.43490493297576904,
0.21140244603157043,
-0.45103171467781067,
0.7393624782562256,
-0.056743256747722626,
-0.28162020444869995,
0.24952231347560883,
-0.22070004045963287,
-0.24646395444869995,
-0.17360298335552216,
-0.576134443283081,
0.15144310891628265,
0.6718621850013733,
0.22319206595420837,
0.7238237857818604,
0.418661504983902,
0.4861929714679718,
0.33971789479255676,
-0.584816575050354,
0.40357714891433716,
-0.40354540944099426,
0.5105835795402527,
-0.12181992828845978,
-0.2918546795845032,
-0.4998440444469452,
-0.3542766869068146,
0.8718603253364563,
0.4424615502357483,
-0.032055165618658066,
0.020490286871790886,
-0.07088601589202881,
0.6455169320106506,
-0.7090522646903992,
-0.07520999759435654,
-0.9175662398338318,
0.07242618501186371,
0.010390154086053371,
-0.5419515371322632,
-0.4088987708091736,
-0.594228982925415,
0.2573423683643341,
-0.4936705231666565,
-0.13184967637062073,
0.27632057666778564,
0.564124345779419,
0.08718758076429367,
-0.6266116499900818,
-0.41910916566848755,
-0.7295096516609192,
0.5107207894325256,
-0.49256452918052673,
0.3548811078071594,
0.02652747742831707,
0.48066139221191406,
-0.17585505545139313,
-0.47452110052108765,
-0.6273065805435181,
-0.05239507928490639,
-0.06148390471935272,
0.2267751544713974,
-0.09778992086648941,
0.18140578269958496,
0.19739532470703125,
0.6427512764930725,
-0.3330129384994507,
-0.48351117968559265,
-0.13794909417629242,
-0.008367632515728474,
0.4405824542045593,
0.16509641706943512,
0.1533849686384201,
-0.31701740622520447,
-0.2694605588912964,
-0.3479851186275482,
-0.5618115067481995,
0.42264437675476074,
0.4333536922931671,
0.06424304842948914,
0.5390833616256714,
0.43873777985572815,
-0.3320181965827942,
0.7366428375244141,
0.16277499496936798,
-0.2624592185020447,
0.37828055024147034,
-0.561347246170044,
-0.07422929257154465,
-0.03991438448429108,
0.605010986328125,
0.20925389230251312,
0.002873155986890197,
-0.16980965435504913,
-0.1411009430885315,
-0.29119402170181274,
0.26091721653938293,
-0.6084470152854919,
0.1191568672657013,
0.276391863822937,
-0.35947272181510925,
-0.512093186378479,
0.12147589772939682,
-0.9584143161773682,
-0.2779955267906189,
0.23075014352798462,
0.2837459444999695,
-0.5953376293182373,
-0.45006000995635986,
0.2261173278093338,
-0.16078944504261017,
-0.0014756557065993547,
0.5764268636703491,
0.006107121706008911,
0.4020872712135315,
0.43911051750183105,
0.7025963664054871,
-0.00441496167331934,
-0.3572195768356323,
-0.7161421775817871,
-0.01690845377743244,
-0.3215586245059967,
0.5126215815544128,
-0.8085215091705322,
-0.1758366823196411,
-0.08998741954565048,
0.0017912249313667417,
-0.05798414722084999,
-0.19561445713043213,
0.4626050591468811,
-1.0142295360565186,
0.1140984371304512,
-0.194566011428833,
-0.20189706981182098,
-0.45640382170677185,
0.7893723845481873,
-0.7675178647041321,
0.9215643405914307,
0.13071219623088837,
-1.037357211112976,
-0.10348760336637497,
-0.6065940856933594,
-0.3898754417896271,
-0.08461809903383255,
-0.045428596436977386,
-0.3277137279510498,
-0.06682530790567398,
0.35270825028419495,
-0.2720753252506256,
-0.2750720679759979,
0.49646928906440735,
-0.2069932520389557,
-0.4438802897930145,
0.08883405476808548,
-0.5293880105018616,
0.9614089131355286,
0.45201537013053894,
-0.22815389931201935,
0.19612202048301697,
-0.5704062581062317,
0.3585369288921356,
0.004742433782666922,
-0.4256190061569214,
-0.31330326199531555,
0.17030492424964905,
-0.42382168769836426,
0.19654886424541473,
-0.3485008478164673,
-0.6548900008201599,
0.4520370066165924,
-0.3783246874809265,
0.3564116358757019,
0.5196651220321655,
0.32459115982055664,
0.1267739236354828,
-0.3272639214992523,
0.7693073153495789,
0.16686996817588806,
0.23557431995868683,
-0.7101117968559265,
-0.4165440499782562,
-0.4865487217903137,
0.0024794063065201044,
0.2665018141269684,
0.34162968397140503,
-0.8965181112289429,
0.34747543931007385,
-0.22210076451301575,
-0.3941066265106201,
-0.7032590508460999,
-0.28387951850891113,
0.34844744205474854,
0.5127814412117004,
0.4710121154785156,
-0.11709796637296677,
-0.4716545045375824,
-0.4538936913013458,
-0.22844906151294708,
-0.48714467883110046,
0.44432440400123596,
0.41373777389526367,
0.272157222032547,
-0.2234950214624405,
0.9927160739898682,
-0.49133753776550293,
0.036982398480176926,
-0.15018421411514282,
0.10648361593484879,
0.25216931104660034,
0.10629139095544815,
0.29595425724983215,
-0.7689601182937622,
-0.4597010910511017,
-0.2221457064151764,
-0.2808021605014801,
0.11628248542547226,
-0.29007038474082947,
-0.07027805596590042,
-0.32648807764053345,
0.1685270071029663,
-0.5247060060501099,
0.15179575979709625,
0.38779449462890625,
-0.2606644332408905,
0.7064693570137024,
0.0899924486875534,
0.4433656334877014,
-0.9955571293830872,
0.1004231721162796,
-0.47258368134498596,
-0.36648258566856384,
-0.08694379031658173,
0.3809375762939453,
-0.09569025039672852,
0.03644394874572754,
-0.21168558299541473,
0.2809772789478302,
-0.41978397965431213,
0.1192791536450386,
-0.17488408088684082,
0.1646004319190979,
0.37817853689193726,
0.4455787241458893,
-0.05415314808487892,
0.6957406997680664,
0.5056759119033813,
-0.49809834361076355,
0.4389159083366394,
0.3233204185962677,
-0.21391446888446808,
0.1572740525007248,
-0.35994917154312134,
0.22025184333324432,
-0.39388227462768555,
0.6349469423294067,
-1.096581220626831,
0.22951383888721466,
0.11379548162221909,
-0.5419332981109619,
-0.10769472271203995,
-0.15929526090621948,
-0.5215009450912476,
-0.752993643283844,
-0.7639473080635071,
0.5818250775337219,
0.06474778801202774,
-0.6610496044158936,
0.5350382924079895,
0.258757084608078,
-0.020874805748462677,
-0.9958725571632385,
-0.20556005835533142,
-0.11145058274269104,
0.07765796780586243,
-0.5096898078918457,
0.44008615612983704,
-0.23245558142662048,
-0.13530144095420837,
0.36501631140708923,
-0.411009818315506,
-0.08255331963300705,
0.05838179960846901,
-0.26565417647361755,
-0.07653069496154785,
-0.19290687143802643,
0.329319030046463,
0.2004479020833969,
0.16897843778133392,
0.016849758103489876,
-0.18720853328704834,
0.6156806349754333,
-0.4204421937465668,
-0.4738243818283081,
-0.10155884176492691,
0.31819769740104675,
0.8568449020385742,
-0.4622570276260376,
0.13311441242694855,
0.16476690769195557,
-0.15162166953086853,
-0.15319253504276276,
-0.5024771690368652,
-0.2780211567878723,
-0.449932724237442,
0.5239603519439697,
-0.7035326957702637,
-0.8850951194763184,
0.30104997754096985,
-0.3966478705406189,
0.062484197318553925,
0.3491230309009552,
0.2664094567298889,
-0.30534428358078003,
1.00175142288208,
0.4181534945964813,
-0.07165121287107468,
0.34515032172203064,
-0.3990161716938019,
0.45604243874549866,
-1.0814969539642334,
-0.21021844446659088,
-0.49629974365234375,
-0.4002143144607544,
-0.6320424675941467,
-0.4033220410346985,
0.47644007205963135,
0.3817576467990875,
-0.21916452050209045,
0.20843945443630219,
-0.6914928555488586,
0.46534276008605957,
0.4528304636478424,
0.030896442010998726,
0.7497738003730774,
-0.024553995579481125,
-0.48296791315078735,
0.31895923614501953,
-0.8306377530097961,
-0.20674791932106018,
0.767055332660675,
0.4157582223415375,
0.8570311069488525,
0.14477480947971344,
0.34779003262519836,
0.09317439049482346,
0.029135795310139656,
-0.7321256995201111,
0.4202049672603607,
0.29607418179512024,
-0.60288006067276,
-0.3232460021972656,
-0.4820563793182373,
-0.9307064414024353,
0.4129793345928192,
-0.22120966017246246,
-0.675394594669342,
0.05770937725901604,
0.14807912707328796,
-0.5542322397232056,
0.7523425817489624,
-0.283548504114151,
0.3474772572517395,
-0.5718755722045898,
-0.37338876724243164,
-0.36183100938796997,
-0.841931164264679,
0.435773104429245,
-0.01860855706036091,
0.10426972806453705,
0.2601156532764435,
0.33646562695503235,
0.640484094619751,
-0.3218834102153778,
0.4412047863006592,
-0.07542973756790161,
0.25728392601013184,
0.7294286489486694,
0.501230001449585,
0.8036428093910217,
0.18880626559257507,
-0.22876180708408356,
-0.4300324320793152,
0.3563733398914337,
0.11750049144029617,
-0.6595144867897034,
0.6007944941520691,
-0.6987428069114685,
-0.8101577162742615,
-0.7510338425636292,
-0.6059532761573792,
-0.5455501675605774,
0.30638760328292847,
-0.23812520503997803,
0.17134572565555573,
0.09708331525325775,
0.42361369729042053,
0.37648090720176697,
-0.22254008054733276,
0.47342729568481445,
0.4508857727050781,
-0.6069818735122681,
-0.5541099905967712,
0.44779062271118164,
0.04791080579161644,
0.11750917881727219,
0.4533842206001282,
0.4421529173851013,
-0.5183917284011841,
-0.5113144516944885,
-0.5822014212608337,
0.14771121740341187,
-0.49062973260879517,
-0.32837221026420593,
-0.9942630529403687,
-0.4465714395046234,
-0.08576957881450653,
0.17496590316295624,
-0.22509390115737915,
-0.40909796953201294,
0.6124513149261475,
-0.329364538192749,
0.5938371419906616,
0.5842549204826355,
0.4308824837207794,
0.43926021456718445,
-0.8543568849563599,
0.1901349127292633,
0.07819516956806183,
0.6939185261726379,
0.36911407113075256,
-0.1255149245262146,
0.17250706255435944,
-0.04442451894283295,
-0.7195709347724915,
-1.1413755416870117,
0.11505122482776642,
-0.14841248095035553,
0.44147029519081116,
0.2514912784099579,
0.3071843087673187,
1.0661029815673828,
-0.46763667464256287,
0.37105855345726013,
0.1898808628320694,
-0.7705652713775635,
0.6163468360900879,
-0.19520950317382812,
0.2695205509662628,
0.7845572829246521,
0.37660983204841614,
-0.7035636901855469,
-0.5171632766723633,
-0.8016929030418396,
-0.9506658315658569,
0.7097194194793701,
0.2361280769109726,
-0.05137937143445015,
0.013631368987262249,
0.272352010011673,
0.09440156072378159,
0.5544273257255554,
-0.716818630695343,
0.01256779208779335,
0.0250012818723917,
0.09748277068138123,
0.42328333854675293,
-0.32966384291648865,
0.03321043774485588,
-0.3829873502254486,
0.5771604776382446,
-0.19807623326778412,
0.17976516485214233,
0.41143128275871277,
-0.03864402323961258,
-0.4053763449192047,
0.34823206067085266,
-0.09840270131826401,
0.7248826026916504,
-0.39739444851875305,
0.4134872853755951,
0.11776123195886612,
-0.27810224890708923,
0.2638714909553528,
-0.2535845637321472,
-0.4615285098552704,
0.07559367269277573,
0.31829866766929626,
0.6325104832649231,
-0.2746085226535797,
-0.5778703093528748,
0.49627387523651123,
0.12855426967144012,
0.05540218949317932,
-0.03942278027534485,
-0.05564378574490547,
0.10026341676712036,
0.16104483604431152,
0.34477996826171875,
0.29312920570373535,
0.324824720621109,
-0.8664337992668152,
0.48192375898361206,
0.5667459964752197,
-0.33875593543052673,
-0.254027396440506,
0.3085305988788605,
0.4021688997745514,
-0.5267316699028015,
0.8567335605621338,
-0.28734442591667175,
-0.8442144989967346,
0.4743790328502655,
0.5631612539291382,
0.7745327353477478,
-0.11510448902845383,
0.27141591906547546,
0.61562579870224,
0.3699498474597931,
0.18218103051185608,
0.32497289776802063,
-0.22122758626937866,
-0.6318609714508057,
-0.6645668745040894,
-0.5865763425827026,
-0.40303608775138855,
0.26946043968200684,
-0.135792538523674,
0.20230498909950256,
-0.46670296788215637,
-0.2084631770849228,
-0.4331137239933014,
0.08884381502866745,
-0.14647473394870758,
0.24571886658668518,
-0.31913337111473083,
1.123979926109314,
-0.5123742818832397,
0.8222118616104126,
0.4057430922985077,
-0.4523690342903137,
-0.8586412668228149,
0.5088416934013367,
0.06467859447002411,
-0.38200560212135315,
0.2845360338687897,
0.10310900211334229,
-0.7446050643920898,
0.04075426608324051,
-0.01677558571100235,
-0.9398603439331055,
1.024007797241211,
0.01750611513853073,
-0.7470225691795349,
-0.1771291047334671,
-0.08504729717969894,
0.5639848709106445,
-0.3832484483718872,
0.7606339454650879,
0.054080259054899216,
0.47236859798431396,
0.5529326796531677,
-0.7436021566390991,
0.0030506544280797243,
-0.3358789086341858,
-0.2508077621459961,
0.002746631857007742,
-0.6697742938995361,
0.7438482046127319,
-0.22611010074615479,
-0.13901832699775696,
-0.11439157277345657,
0.05967240035533905,
0.5553901791572571,
0.19494420289993286,
0.8364165425300598,
0.35771289467811584,
0.9233874082565308,
0.04490278288722038,
0.991025447845459,
-0.4686165750026703,
0.4418295621871948,
1.2097618579864502,
-0.25064122676849365,
0.748875617980957,
0.586277961730957,
-0.17367282509803772,
0.5696491599082947,
0.7584322690963745,
0.3365955054759979,
0.5168461203575134,
0.43966564536094666,
-0.08183211833238602,
-0.017071736976504326,
0.05402632802724838,
-0.24771298468112946,
0.16434842348098755,
0.024973591789603233,
-0.21607059240341187,
-0.5008525252342224,
-0.30876314640045166,
-0.0770765095949173,
0.0217660591006279,
-0.07469061017036438,
0.6343926787376404,
-0.22884905338287354,
-0.9448822140693665,
0.44259199500083923,
0.061092525720596313,
0.44017401337623596,
-0.6388137936592102,
-0.1551896631717682,
-0.04134666174650192,
0.1628604531288147,
-0.1595238596200943,
-1.0159212350845337,
0.5898063778877258,
0.06261448562145233,
-0.09589462727308273,
-0.3756040930747986,
0.48063167929649353,
-0.2661537826061249,
-0.577360987663269,
0.6933570504188538,
0.8434204459190369,
-0.059712719172239304,
-0.18742379546165466,
-0.8952153325080872,
0.12713627517223358,
0.011779231950640678,
-0.38415801525115967,
-0.23717372119426727,
0.5565568804740906,
-0.40701720118522644,
0.7557477951049805,
0.5353464484214783,
0.1314588338136673,
0.06396375596523285,
-0.03303041681647301,
1.1062036752700806,
-0.5632988810539246,
-0.605616569519043,
-0.7319555878639221,
0.4366588294506073,
-0.2683725655078888,
-0.023562636226415634,
0.4559687376022339,
0.8195920586585999,
0.68825364112854,
0.1964220404624939,
0.6808825135231018,
-0.2808048725128174,
0.6297798752784729,
-0.22354722023010254,
0.43090274930000305,
-0.6366841197013855,
0.4053856134414673,
-0.4149274230003357,
-1.146657943725586,
-0.19632381200790405,
0.5617310404777527,
-0.1330976039171219,
0.05219356343150139,
1.3163915872573853,
0.7058896422386169,
-0.10752175748348236,
0.15916591882705688,
0.01909451186656952,
0.4584835469722748,
0.5084330439567566,
0.4808701276779175,
1.0187782049179077,
-0.41951045393943787,
0.7931278944015503,
-0.016608761623501778,
-0.22581759095191956,
-0.0163588710129261,
-0.7132745981216431,
-0.2513806223869324,
-0.5279054045677185,
-0.2800702750682831,
-0.512300968170166,
0.2732411324977875,
0.8537619709968567,
0.6206655502319336,
-0.6646497845649719,
-0.18168117105960846,
-0.3812515437602997,
0.5456120371818542,
-0.4498169422149658,
-0.21024654805660248,
0.5103167295455933,
-0.507453203201294,
-0.6182631254196167,
0.42418015003204346,
0.39476278424263,
-0.45561760663986206,
-0.16343571245670319,
-0.062065768986940384,
-0.7307484745979309,
0.06300192326307297,
0.6245588064193726,
-0.0640842616558075,
-0.8325210213661194,
-0.36925333738327026,
0.5164597630500793,
0.14596819877624512,
0.4415435791015625,
0.9050151109695435,
-0.9657688736915588,
0.8670315146446228,
0.7759853005409241,
0.8478110432624817,
0.5623382329940796,
0.2216007262468338,
0.25921738147735596,
-0.6310482025146484,
-0.2763737440109253,
0.6063032150268555,
0.26313209533691406,
-0.059956904500722885,
-0.3134492039680481,
0.5479446649551392,
0.26974618434906006,
-0.20371446013450623,
-0.739952027797699,
0.360372930765152,
-0.9700765609741211,
-0.3702848255634308,
1.047874093055725,
-0.0704144686460495,
-0.3025546669960022,
-0.12247990816831589,
-0.5465754866600037,
0.05636289343237877,
-0.32466641068458557,
0.8443291187286377,
0.8119572401046753,
-0.31125640869140625,
-0.2998400032520294,
-0.06313411891460419,
0.43673497438430786,
0.26541924476623535,
-0.7059449553489685,
0.2524481415748596,
0.4017534554004669,
0.21186287701129913,
0.460366815328598,
0.9304903745651245,
-0.44264060258865356,
0.22796693444252014,
-0.23110102117061615,
-0.41193461418151855,
-0.12059686332941055,
-0.6794334650039673,
-0.042992498725652695,
0.472781777381897,
0.2965339124202728,
-0.23258386552333832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14463v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14463v1
|
DAIC-WOZ: On the Validity of Using the Therapist's prompts in Automatic Depression Detection from Clinical Interviews
| 2024-04-22T09:07:50 | 2024-04-22T09:07:50 |
Sergio Burdisso, Ernesto Reyes-Ramírez, Esaú Villatoro-Tello, Fernando Sánchez-Vega, Pastor López-Monroy, Petr Motlicek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Automatic depression detection from conversational data has gained
significant interest in recent years. The DAIC-WOZ dataset, interviews
conducted by a human-controlled virtual agent, has been widely used for this
task. Recent studies have reported enhanced performance when incorporating
interviewer's prompts into the model. In this work, we hypothesize that this
improvement might be mainly due to a bias present in these prompts, rather than
the proposed architectures and methods. Through ablation experiments and
qualitative analysis, we discover that models using interviewer's prompts learn
to focus on a specific region of the interviews, where questions about past
experiences with mental health issues are asked, and use them as discriminative
shortcuts to detect depressed participants. In contrast, models using
participant responses gather evidence from across the entire interview.
Finally, to highlight the magnitude of this bias, we achieve a 0.90 F1 score by
intentionally exploiting it, the highest result reported to date on this
dataset using only textual information. Our findings underline the need for
caution when incorporating interviewers' prompts into models, as they may
inadvertently learn to exploit targeted prompts, rather than learning to
characterize the language and behavior that are genuinely indicative of the
patient's mental health condition.
|
[
-0.7198245525360107,
-1.0261927843093872,
1.0880305767059326,
-0.010898206382989883,
-0.10431566834449768,
-0.34890496730804443,
-0.04729686304926872,
-0.16127774119377136,
0.0169661995023489,
0.07904113829135895,
-0.9238101243972778,
-0.5409835577011108,
-0.5239261388778687,
0.650912344455719,
-0.24383418262004852,
0.798154354095459,
0.25881320238113403,
0.07966986298561096,
-0.16400904953479767,
0.17497633397579193,
-0.7642845511436462,
-0.19729693233966827,
-0.79991614818573,
-0.034466423094272614,
0.5289099216461182,
0.5009660124778748,
0.7968027591705322,
0.3862704634666443,
0.27009353041648865,
0.2789822220802307,
-0.02159767597913742,
0.1455869823694229,
-0.18802744150161743,
0.12705077230930328,
0.1430252343416214,
-0.5997462868690491,
-0.24571530520915985,
0.2659511864185333,
-0.06863867491483688,
0.8997489213943481,
-0.1326702982187271,
-0.0588047169148922,
0.15978151559829712,
0.1717446893453598,
-0.6967164278030396,
0.03307240083813667,
-0.2015874683856964,
0.356814980506897,
0.08495208621025085,
-0.07787688076496124,
-0.5307056903839111,
-0.4849280118942261,
0.14362691342830658,
-0.29855599999427795,
0.41527631878852844,
-0.31071439385414124,
0.7291297912597656,
0.6031815409660339,
-0.6669946312904358,
-0.3676370084285736,
-0.6780458092689514,
0.5803608894348145,
-0.6607940196990967,
-0.0971868559718132,
0.9221532344818115,
0.44253861904144287,
0.02587311901152134,
-0.163274347782135,
-0.384414941072464,
-0.21990825235843658,
-0.13751862943172455,
0.29040125012397766,
-0.38579878211021423,
0.1803739070892334,
0.8015681505203247,
0.3076512813568115,
-0.5194687247276306,
0.3295360207557678,
-0.23671452701091766,
-0.23468801379203796,
0.5979640483856201,
0.6487467885017395,
0.20817303657531738,
-0.2725849449634552,
-0.24475090205669403,
-0.007071537896990776,
-0.038576360791921616,
0.3232121467590332,
0.189748615026474,
0.21215970814228058,
-0.27213042974472046,
0.47370991110801697,
-0.013311167247593403,
0.8114046454429626,
0.4836537539958954,
-0.15552841126918793,
0.033791013062000275,
0.06551189720630646,
-0.0279365386813879,
-0.015343055129051208,
0.863297700881958,
0.8227251172065735,
0.10452813655138016,
0.07242683321237564,
0.15168312191963196,
0.371319055557251,
0.4401378631591797,
-0.6411066055297852,
-0.47807058691978455,
0.5747057795524597,
-0.5449223518371582,
-0.21275299787521362,
-0.03619803488254547,
-0.8944413661956787,
-0.719774067401886,
-0.27029210329055786,
0.06926736235618591,
-0.3662242293357849,
-0.04544753208756447,
0.049988068640232086,
-0.39052674174308777,
0.046709105372428894,
0.462283194065094,
-0.4599705934524536,
0.15993282198905945,
0.2264147400856018,
0.7323967218399048,
-0.1352742612361908,
0.1465807855129242,
-0.7352802753448486,
-0.45866408944129944,
-0.48423317074775696,
0.9990416765213013,
-0.3272657096385956,
-0.7382116913795471,
0.21569207310676575,
0.18475966155529022,
0.03380050137639046,
-0.5034893751144409,
0.7933441996574402,
-0.09101942181587219,
0.5296080708503723,
-0.7009044289588928,
-0.42355626821517944,
0.13714349269866943,
0.1621994972229004,
-0.6287167072296143,
0.8139424920082092,
0.33890676498413086,
-0.8058962225914001,
0.40889039635658264,
-0.44004788994789124,
-0.12966078519821167,
-0.14097662270069122,
-0.11358654499053955,
-0.23191513121128082,
0.0440334677696228,
0.3050614297389984,
0.33080360293388367,
-0.3514990210533142,
0.17921839654445648,
-0.48838984966278076,
-0.30791839957237244,
0.7358096837997437,
-0.4650000035762787,
1.0672825574874878,
0.28191056847572327,
-0.15977545082569122,
-0.43704667687416077,
-0.6915123462677002,
-0.22436131536960602,
-0.0712011381983757,
-0.03601684793829918,
-0.500335693359375,
-0.45787757635116577,
-0.3270432651042938,
0.3822764754295349,
-0.20017753541469574,
-0.6420148015022278,
-0.1194869801402092,
-0.3051930367946625,
-0.25432172417640686,
0.655430793762207,
0.19751951098442078,
0.11767353117465973,
-0.40154120326042175,
0.9283850789070129,
0.258905291557312,
0.25954216718673706,
-0.3319440186023712,
-0.5152186751365662,
-0.23693855106830597,
-0.7418296337127686,
0.138100728392601,
0.5593885183334351,
-0.44851481914520264,
0.8529175519943237,
0.48742663860321045,
-0.4889174699783325,
-0.588448166847229,
-0.18366846442222595,
0.16484671831130981,
0.990478515625,
0.41003453731536865,
-0.4065273404121399,
-0.2894798517227173,
-0.7987081408500671,
-0.1895817369222641,
0.12411439418792725,
-0.3629455268383026,
0.3721020519733429,
0.048251599073410034,
-0.20705904066562653,
1.2401801347732544,
-0.8830479383468628,
-0.10545261949300766,
-0.28684690594673157,
0.2994544804096222,
0.3101668059825897,
0.18846148252487183,
0.41460636258125305,
-0.5906432867050171,
-0.7389072179794312,
-0.5111672282218933,
-0.9000989198684692,
-0.5660766959190369,
-0.14879052340984344,
-0.028171638026833534,
-0.14800888299942017,
0.21667854487895966,
-0.9074569344520569,
0.6817255616188049,
0.09440889954566956,
-0.717032253742218,
0.7152964472770691,
-0.15214718878269196,
0.27650564908981323,
-0.7625011205673218,
-0.0042432984337210655,
0.2492794245481491,
-0.188594788312912,
-0.5317891240119934,
-0.7234078645706177,
-0.2463909536600113,
-0.1478896141052246,
-0.21090343594551086,
0.2554255425930023,
-0.21988290548324585,
0.27754512429237366,
-0.5973871350288391,
0.09943556785583496,
0.3291819393634796,
0.39542362093925476,
-0.29241153597831726,
0.6226888298988342,
0.7072487473487854,
-0.8812412023544312,
0.48749032616615295,
0.7696512937545776,
-0.08327916264533997,
1.1791136264801025,
-0.5057207345962524,
0.23300303518772125,
-0.42457687854766846,
0.4151204824447632,
-1.164145827293396,
-0.1675630658864975,
0.43246957659721375,
-0.3295840322971344,
-0.04297838732600212,
0.12150600552558899,
-0.011804789304733276,
-0.4740833640098572,
-0.2375258356332779,
0.33905768394470215,
0.5803112387657166,
-0.3484801948070526,
0.28072884678840637,
0.36200112104415894,
-0.23322179913520813,
-0.3681074380874634,
-0.5658619403839111,
-0.005449746735394001,
-0.7388498783111572,
-0.2082374095916748,
0.28004664182662964,
-0.3670605421066284,
-0.4976244568824768,
-0.3170416057109833,
-0.035134997218847275,
-0.1220996081829071,
0.280338853597641,
0.28734245896339417,
0.407106876373291,
0.009477095678448677,
0.0016067491378635168,
0.09111878275871277,
-0.45171430706977844,
0.5481417775154114,
0.2244221568107605,
0.44010472297668457,
0.319322794675827,
-0.315707802772522,
-1.0861073732376099,
0.5047149062156677,
0.20287862420082092,
0.0782620757818222,
0.7843466401100159,
0.4516212046146393,
-0.28763139247894287,
-0.008222528733313084,
-0.46116018295288086,
-0.3859544098377228,
-0.41595765948295593,
-0.1783316731452942,
-0.25611239671707153,
-0.6581729650497437,
0.6039001941680908,
-0.2934335470199585,
-0.25674816966056824,
0.16969305276870728,
0.63625168800354,
-0.4959511160850525,
1.6779214143753052,
0.4847068786621094,
-0.09685329347848892,
0.48866191506385803,
-0.13525888323783875,
0.18399453163146973,
-0.5222346782684326,
0.062257058918476105,
-0.8262232542037964,
-0.07407169044017792,
-0.43036505579948425,
-0.055670157074928284,
0.5765662789344788,
-0.2266750931739807,
-0.038931287825107574,
0.01925007253885269,
-0.3458178639411926,
0.15367001295089722,
0.2607036232948303,
0.386214017868042,
0.1627090871334076,
-0.4401770532131195,
-0.12545591592788696,
-0.4260987639427185,
-0.4443046748638153,
-0.3822164535522461,
0.6849889755249023,
0.24481135606765747,
0.742062509059906,
-0.32723328471183777,
0.3757860064506531,
0.7331594824790955,
0.07123355567455292,
-0.7465153932571411,
0.36019670963287354,
0.39302316308021545,
-0.3439360558986664,
-0.25789403915405273,
-0.3810711205005646,
-1.101482629776001,
0.22181081771850586,
0.21652987599372864,
-0.694108247756958,
0.6044538021087646,
0.115444116294384,
-0.8157483339309692,
-0.32718050479888916,
-0.5826365351676941,
1.120286464691162,
-0.06519407778978348,
-0.0202274639159441,
-0.09488999098539352,
-0.7669539451599121,
0.13432250916957855,
-0.06614594161510468,
0.45577389001846313,
-0.20446783304214478,
0.23326475918293,
0.4644719362258911,
-0.5493977665901184,
0.9508324861526489,
-0.5270936489105225,
-0.4963800013065338,
0.47130563855171204,
0.023397615179419518,
0.40332114696502686,
0.07415831089019775,
-0.13141536712646484,
-0.1906178593635559,
0.15897595882415771,
-0.27907076478004456,
-0.8588458895683289,
0.10696358978748322,
-0.5647886991500854,
-0.6387170553207397,
-0.2903285324573517,
-0.5268388390541077,
-0.38043439388275146,
-0.08854642510414124,
0.2264094352722168,
0.6386160254478455,
-0.47492149472236633,
-0.2962915301322937,
0.5286582112312317,
-0.4573833644390106,
-0.05098264664411545,
0.4648575186729431,
0.11988148093223572,
-0.23244895040988922,
0.30960601568222046,
-0.14134755730628967,
0.2493075728416443,
-0.0725659504532814,
0.35766837000846863,
-0.10626319795846939,
-0.08935634046792984,
0.05317030847072601,
0.4080321192741394,
-0.9017147421836853,
-0.296690434217453,
-0.7198091149330139,
0.32008934020996094,
-0.44849804043769836,
-0.0075224656611680984,
-0.06507152318954468,
-0.3294825851917267,
-0.31353747844696045,
-0.5454952716827393,
0.29396894574165344,
0.26445940136909485,
-0.403969943523407,
0.26293426752090454,
-0.7878510355949402,
0.6053394079208374,
0.22448955476284027,
-0.13721366226673126,
-0.1789529174566269,
-0.41234898567199707,
-0.42398151755332947,
0.32366904616355896,
-0.40807825326919556,
-1.2526365518569946,
0.4474552869796753,
-0.1044936254620552,
0.45398664474487305,
0.6908720135688782,
0.7148985862731934,
0.6994925737380981,
0.0036704177036881447,
0.7878997921943665,
-0.05644144117832184,
-0.6294732689857483,
0.7401578426361084,
-0.3546546697616577,
0.348342627286911,
0.8756870627403259,
0.8670262098312378,
-0.617377758026123,
-0.6770185828208923,
-0.7087079286575317,
-0.42783787846565247,
1.026023268699646,
-0.1378493458032608,
0.09107711911201477,
-0.3888627290725708,
0.3202281892299652,
0.4735441207885742,
0.055228810757398605,
-0.3808005750179291,
-0.34108611941337585,
-0.057840652763843536,
-0.6033304333686829,
0.026014307513833046,
-0.4088839590549469,
-0.38789597153663635,
-0.25902020931243896,
0.40572407841682434,
-0.42345279455184937,
0.5777366757392883,
0.5079615116119385,
0.062419746071100235,
-0.2777303457260132,
0.1357058733701706,
-0.21355779469013214,
0.4190129041671753,
-0.09036176651716232,
0.12213865667581558,
0.26094239950180054,
-0.1669648438692093,
-0.02525981143116951,
0.20494763553142548,
-0.11933139711618423,
0.29761067032814026,
0.10528701543807983,
0.7290504574775696,
-0.2271910458803177,
-0.9401412606239319,
0.6167430281639099,
-0.25776565074920654,
-0.024689503014087677,
-0.3244988024234772,
0.19213473796844482,
-0.4397734999656677,
0.458093523979187,
0.07190605998039246,
-0.061005353927612305,
0.6271321773529053,
-0.4976300597190857,
0.03716826066374779,
0.5315676331520081,
-0.6326225399971008,
-0.4687327742576599,
0.6029545664787292,
-0.13437499105930328,
-0.3344486653804779,
0.8894273042678833,
0.04114509001374245,
-0.49653592705726624,
0.6404269337654114,
0.32255488634109497,
0.8096432685852051,
-0.3150792717933655,
0.5773881673812866,
0.4761016070842743,
-0.219966858625412,
-0.018591206520795822,
0.3041419982910156,
-0.41340214014053345,
-0.638128399848938,
0.11381903290748596,
-0.09133274108171463,
-0.48515066504478455,
-0.06706706434488297,
-0.9888119101524353,
0.45259392261505127,
-0.08386023342609406,
-0.6897531151771545,
-0.2071356475353241,
-0.26506268978118896,
-0.7475054264068604,
0.4328695833683014,
0.32257139682769775,
0.9188094735145569,
-1.0677056312561035,
0.2259892076253891,
0.4838944673538208,
-0.4966271221637726,
-0.5262948870658875,
0.21181561052799225,
0.28367799520492554,
-0.298038125038147,
0.06596425920724869,
0.40956223011016846,
0.3494530916213989,
-0.011822700500488281,
-0.5176145434379578,
-0.5555354952812195,
1.0542645454406738,
0.43422821164131165,
0.14925605058670044,
-0.2442287653684616,
0.2729315161705017,
0.593231737613678,
-0.2681942880153656,
0.7227156162261963,
0.6616234183311462,
0.3256292939186096,
-0.017082491889595985,
-0.9759525656700134,
0.13408681750297546,
-0.23396910727024078,
-0.2757626473903656,
-0.2528705298900604,
-0.5262850522994995,
0.8800723552703857,
-0.2511506676673889,
-0.3062761723995209,
-0.013901546597480774,
0.38358110189437866,
0.22394275665283203,
0.369113028049469,
0.9296741485595703,
0.1751481145620346,
1.1339054107666016,
0.12008211016654968,
1.2710412740707397,
-0.09869219362735748,
0.20864205062389374,
0.5558429956436157,
-0.40411460399627686,
0.028556041419506073,
0.2276090532541275,
-0.18724942207336426,
0.7708330154418945,
0.7050129771232605,
-0.13194352388381958,
0.7767340540885925,
-0.22105900943279266,
-0.30039817094802856,
-0.45900270342826843,
-0.5932849645614624,
-0.11592178791761398,
0.22309409081935883,
0.25572100281715393,
-0.334943026304245,
-0.35396623611450195,
0.4086875319480896,
0.19519689679145813,
-0.07511910796165466,
0.1665591597557068,
0.7969793677330017,
0.6064490675926208,
-0.7982577085494995,
0.6708202362060547,
-0.03269962966442108,
0.27935492992401123,
-0.3916580379009247,
0.10662904381752014,
-0.3430686295032501,
0.15163737535476685,
-0.12637434899806976,
-0.2931104302406311,
0.17995032668113708,
0.38160383701324463,
-0.06871762126684189,
-0.2734736204147339,
0.6071467995643616,
-0.16979393362998962,
-0.12489800900220871,
0.11034402996301651,
0.7408332824707031,
0.2817021608352661,
-0.14061322808265686,
-0.72836834192276,
-0.24008052051067352,
-0.28264057636260986,
-0.23318886756896973,
0.3144317865371704,
0.7353105545043945,
0.1329270750284195,
0.4978906810283661,
0.39436018466949463,
-0.21300092339515686,
-0.3494330644607544,
0.2480626106262207,
0.6477869153022766,
-0.7045983076095581,
-0.7791346311569214,
-0.8579509258270264,
0.6612133383750916,
-0.06640355288982391,
-0.2439260184764862,
0.9527307152748108,
0.3029579520225525,
0.4216564893722534,
-0.06822516769170761,
0.8821789622306824,
-0.11578246206045151,
0.8470479249954224,
-0.32326921820640564,
0.22270628809928894,
-0.4223177134990692,
0.04623345658183098,
-0.47357428073883057,
-0.42652300000190735,
0.06409583985805511,
0.7630966901779175,
-0.4822784960269928,
0.179992213845253,
0.850691556930542,
0.7264493107795715,
0.28985658288002014,
0.2577655613422394,
0.20915783941745758,
0.2866175174713135,
0.35940021276474,
0.33103281259536743,
1.152274250984192,
-0.1915709674358368,
0.15065036714076996,
-0.404367595911026,
-0.3559790253639221,
-0.011211981065571308,
-0.4418617784976959,
-0.9280763268470764,
-0.4583618938922882,
-0.650023341178894,
-0.3946153223514557,
-0.28653016686439514,
1.026631474494934,
0.021879620850086212,
-0.5645735859870911,
0.04123924300074577,
0.20196615159511566,
-0.072413869202137,
-0.4977506995201111,
-0.23028601706027985,
0.2726542353630066,
-0.35400390625,
-0.7111700177192688,
0.5471395254135132,
-0.13690397143363953,
-0.04634551331400871,
-0.1567685306072235,
0.06021912768483162,
0.14712415635585785,
-0.13390357792377472,
0.13735178112983704,
0.03837728500366211,
-0.22470538318157196,
-0.07434301823377609,
0.07039955258369446,
-0.33251750469207764,
0.37915170192718506,
0.7119942903518677,
-0.9100863337516785,
0.29519662261009216,
0.20814184844493866,
0.32596006989479065,
0.047679077833890915,
0.5079184174537659,
0.7648236155509949,
-0.30039966106414795,
0.021633466705679893,
0.218757763504982,
0.26905301213264465,
0.4532042145729065,
-0.6767512559890747,
0.11255155503749847,
0.3388496935367584,
-0.48283952474594116,
-0.882393479347229,
0.05498288571834564,
-0.7990642189979553,
-0.27989208698272705,
1.0447227954864502,
-0.19255422055721283,
-0.2927170693874359,
-0.7130261659622192,
-0.7251154184341431,
0.3092734217643738,
-0.36147433519363403,
1.3344985246658325,
0.6988065242767334,
-0.4381391406059265,
-0.07681168615818024,
-0.49539101123809814,
0.6199591755867004,
0.38483384251594543,
-0.6927257776260376,
0.12068089842796326,
0.789493978023529,
-0.0072976103983819485,
-0.07123927026987076,
0.8976366519927979,
0.05560476332902908,
0.5071151852607727,
-0.216768279671669,
-0.0920356810092926,
0.1386682540178299,
0.01680486463010311,
-0.5349280834197998,
-0.004561127163469791,
0.018028464168310165,
-0.11888469755649567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13985v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13985v2
|
Information Re-Organization Improves Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-22T08:47:27 | 2024-05-24T07:28:49 |
Xiaoxia Cheng, Zeqi Tan, Wei Xue, Weiming Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Improving the reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs) has
attracted considerable interest. Recent approaches primarily focus on improving
the reasoning process to yield a more precise final answer. However, in
scenarios involving contextually aware reasoning, these methods neglect the
importance of first identifying logical relationships from the context before
proceeding with the reasoning. This oversight could lead to a superficial
understanding and interaction with the context, potentially undermining the
quality and reliability of the reasoning outcomes. In this paper, we propose an
information re-organization (InfoRE) method before proceeding with the
reasoning to enhance the reasoning ability of LLMs. Our re-organization method
involves initially extracting logical relationships from the contextual
content, such as documents or paragraphs, and subsequently pruning redundant
content to minimize noise. Then, we utilize the re-organized information in the
reasoning process. This enables LLMs to deeply understand the contextual
content by clearly perceiving these logical relationships, while also ensuring
high-quality responses by eliminating potential noise. To demonstrate the
effectiveness of our approach in improving the reasoning ability, we conduct
experiments using Llama2-70B, GPT-3.5, and GPT-4 on various contextually aware
multi-hop reasoning tasks. Using only a zero-shot setting, our method achieves
an average absolute improvement of 4% across all tasks, highlighting its
potential to improve the reasoning performance of LLMs. Our source code is
available at https://github.com/hustcxx/InfoRE.
|
[
-0.2945747971534729,
-0.9561065435409546,
0.8557159304618835,
-0.10578109323978424,
-0.44332870841026306,
-0.10108480602502823,
-0.38180723786354065,
-0.49610644578933716,
0.11556742340326309,
0.40179014205932617,
-0.39806899428367615,
-0.4516027867794037,
-0.4628079831600189,
0.004344871733337641,
-0.3252655863761902,
0.7364050149917603,
-0.007696923799812794,
-0.20316524803638458,
-0.26694002747535706,
-0.1449396163225174,
-0.5787920951843262,
-0.48078709840774536,
-0.6304835677146912,
-0.3386588394641876,
0.7283493280410767,
0.4227359890937805,
0.5032998323440552,
0.8233919143676758,
0.5003095865249634,
0.364938348531723,
-0.3303481936454773,
0.43193626403808594,
-0.5039882063865662,
0.4658164083957672,
-0.5081329941749573,
-0.4221309721469879,
-0.4504671096801758,
-0.3308578431606293,
0.6178295016288757,
0.4803309440612793,
-0.2300988882780075,
0.1692219227552414,
-0.18847742676734924,
0.4743654131889343,
-0.7650284767150879,
0.3331219255924225,
-0.885644257068634,
-0.25386783480644226,
-0.07016196101903915,
-0.6735756993293762,
-0.5782243013381958,
-0.0752120241522789,
0.08997799456119537,
-0.7864488363265991,
-0.048142652958631516,
0.06306241452693939,
0.7423815727233887,
0.3051726222038269,
-0.20080694556236267,
0.09882160276174545,
-0.7401481866836548,
0.8061580657958984,
-0.6316471099853516,
0.744748055934906,
0.1941768378019333,
0.20839285850524902,
-0.38110044598579407,
-0.607306182384491,
-0.4968295097351074,
0.14521048963069916,
-0.14747779071331024,
-0.02304292842745781,
-0.25943225622177124,
-0.13085350394248962,
0.36190831661224365,
0.019177589565515518,
-0.42273736000061035,
-0.16689984500408173,
-0.20725694298744202,
-0.12508802115917206,
0.3940854072570801,
-0.029901603236794472,
0.1789020448923111,
0.11102310568094254,
-0.21927392482757568,
-0.00866040401160717,
-0.6087767481803894,
-0.10488021373748779,
-0.23812785744667053,
0.09068314731121063,
0.3886715769767761,
0.5909144282341003,
-0.3079238831996918,
0.8284196853637695,
0.20442834496498108,
-0.57623690366745,
0.4353722035884857,
-0.6355739831924438,
-0.4157840609550476,
0.11691705882549286,
0.33829501271247864,
0.25441718101501465,
0.15419527888298035,
-0.11018742620944977,
-0.24289682507514954,
-0.28963080048561096,
0.19523194432258606,
-0.6941741704940796,
0.02001449652016163,
0.2610391676425934,
-0.479827344417572,
-0.03208116441965103,
-0.09133509546518326,
-0.25139549374580383,
-0.2978503406047821,
-0.7184450626373291,
0.3847372233867645,
-0.7193177342414856,
-0.2740360498428345,
0.19225430488586426,
-0.05654912441968918,
0.31518203020095825,
0.8876416087150574,
-0.5788719654083252,
-0.039186205714941025,
0.7373644113540649,
0.5773630142211914,
0.25550103187561035,
-0.3747125566005707,
-0.625267744064331,
0.603468120098114,
-0.24223554134368896,
0.9792333841323853,
-0.5730006694793701,
0.12620186805725098,
-0.2813764214515686,
-0.06685645878314972,
-0.06297033280134201,
-0.6031156778335571,
0.6466152667999268,
-0.739444375038147,
0.0879444107413292,
-0.23585939407348633,
-0.4756075441837311,
-0.31174057722091675,
0.4480130076408386,
-0.47561344504356384,
0.696147620677948,
-0.11707009375095367,
-0.9881393313407898,
0.35972994565963745,
-0.4209953248500824,
-0.47569599747657776,
-0.2168433964252472,
-0.2399008572101593,
-0.2254360467195511,
0.17900598049163818,
0.46830540895462036,
0.33838653564453125,
-0.34798434376716614,
0.3819589614868164,
-0.19522100687026978,
-0.5219777822494507,
0.34628036618232727,
-0.26018059253692627,
0.4750317633152008,
0.21965894103050232,
-0.15054653584957123,
0.25576549768447876,
-0.5588546991348267,
0.15664903819561005,
0.08123107254505157,
-0.6060932874679565,
-0.47755521535873413,
-0.03522205725312233,
-0.4717303216457367,
0.1384771168231964,
0.2393697202205658,
-0.27252107858657837,
0.2855927646160126,
-0.41347160935401917,
0.2994585335254669,
0.7189801335334778,
0.12864607572555542,
0.6579456925392151,
-0.2004351168870926,
0.15244528651237488,
0.11496661603450775,
0.22103671729564667,
-0.30588334798812866,
-0.2545933127403259,
-0.8792456388473511,
-0.29415786266326904,
-0.015052208676934242,
0.5488589406013489,
-0.8607767820358276,
0.4409964084625244,
-0.3869295120239258,
-0.22774752974510193,
-0.2582019865512848,
0.20225617289543152,
0.41502586007118225,
0.7716871500015259,
0.48925504088401794,
0.10730302333831787,
-0.6237146258354187,
-0.9152916073799133,
-0.37517279386520386,
-0.2869579792022705,
0.10129199177026749,
0.15438473224639893,
0.2817172408103943,
-0.4300960898399353,
0.8876072764396667,
-0.45401161909103394,
0.030665531754493713,
-0.22114519774913788,
0.09045208245515823,
0.34011977910995483,
0.2046486884355545,
0.08743418753147125,
-0.7525784373283386,
0.0690019503235817,
0.0484318807721138,
-0.7245689630508423,
-0.24655118584632874,
-0.15284457802772522,
-0.5469678640365601,
0.2137969732284546,
0.4032820165157318,
-0.7587758302688599,
0.5022873878479004,
0.07109610736370087,
-0.24795937538146973,
0.5539063215255737,
-0.22004814445972443,
0.3206631541252136,
-0.9122505187988281,
-0.013863474130630493,
-0.06119938939809799,
-0.07826156914234161,
-0.6963961720466614,
-0.18183989822864532,
0.03995451703667641,
0.17274942994117737,
-0.07709687948226929,
0.45117416977882385,
-0.6403201818466187,
-0.09620510786771774,
-0.2817741334438324,
0.4365212321281433,
0.22315016388893127,
0.4246949553489685,
0.21712784469127655,
0.5889089703559875,
0.39115405082702637,
-0.5804977416992188,
0.08969978988170624,
0.22772493958473206,
-0.6009563207626343,
0.6460620760917664,
-0.28598374128341675,
0.07836242020130157,
-0.5248461961746216,
0.5729042291641235,
-0.934704601764679,
-0.2633797228336334,
0.20886433124542236,
-0.40313419699668884,
0.3752616047859192,
-0.10989179462194443,
-0.5796055793762207,
0.11272008717060089,
-0.10148435831069946,
0.5559703707695007,
0.06671078503131866,
-0.644839346408844,
0.6684767603874207,
0.2835690379142761,
-0.14909878373146057,
-0.7205055952072144,
-0.7082708477973938,
0.1252068728208542,
-0.27711254358291626,
-0.9967550039291382,
0.36032962799072266,
-0.03181003779172897,
-0.6527988910675049,
-0.1329004466533661,
-0.5098834037780762,
-0.3644881844520569,
-0.007275891490280628,
0.03128278627991676,
0.13477405905723572,
-0.20822465419769287,
0.8399628400802612,
0.04294455423951149,
-0.20077280700206757,
-0.19824174046516418,
-0.4871419370174408,
0.3313635587692261,
-0.11606363207101822,
-0.23114266991615295,
-0.4646373391151428,
0.1700030118227005,
0.5744415521621704,
-0.39567145705223083,
0.957311749458313,
0.3886970579624176,
-0.27096524834632874,
-0.09193854033946991,
-0.9727969169616699,
-0.23301193118095398,
-0.41508612036705017,
0.3667159378528595,
-0.5713135004043579,
-0.9326726794242859,
0.18911904096603394,
-0.20933452248573303,
0.12444663047790527,
0.07560347020626068,
0.23950867354869843,
-0.16130772233009338,
0.6974595785140991,
0.4633166193962097,
0.021630017086863518,
0.6352472305297852,
0.030892450362443924,
0.5468945503234863,
-0.916068434715271,
-0.4870666563510895,
-0.21941713988780975,
-0.03327863663434982,
-0.004763686563819647,
-0.7950133681297302,
0.28270453214645386,
0.4503905773162842,
-0.41136249899864197,
0.17256900668144226,
-0.43944883346557617,
0.533280611038208,
0.17695312201976776,
0.25284862518310547,
0.6086046099662781,
0.3058735728263855,
0.2709267735481262,
0.11365094035863876,
-0.8236295580863953,
-0.46356868743896484,
0.6697282791137695,
0.32983461022377014,
0.7804559469223022,
0.3700506091117859,
0.7329598665237427,
-0.16360095143318176,
0.46568307280540466,
-0.8267694711685181,
0.6340770721435547,
0.19754835963249207,
-0.22770945727825165,
-0.4595673084259033,
-0.8138271570205688,
-0.9212217330932617,
0.520330011844635,
-0.060567863285541534,
-1.033750295639038,
0.2726268172264099,
0.05385737493634224,
-0.22120770812034607,
0.23717474937438965,
-0.7542283535003662,
0.423209011554718,
-0.40826505422592163,
-0.5157286524772644,
-0.21302251517772675,
-0.46915778517723083,
0.46165329217910767,
-0.253337025642395,
0.446636438369751,
0.004450798034667969,
-0.06236002966761589,
0.6591650247573853,
-0.5288494825363159,
0.4577139914035797,
0.012778839096426964,
-0.3925618529319763,
0.33482789993286133,
0.2783960998058319,
0.5951048135757446,
0.0031719461549073458,
-0.30196714401245117,
0.09575673937797546,
-0.13755133748054504,
-0.15090011060237885,
-1.0903704166412354,
0.7577765583992004,
-0.4366183876991272,
-0.9644771814346313,
-0.11475642025470734,
-0.7615204453468323,
-0.08577080816030502,
0.25132349133491516,
0.04738263040781021,
0.45475417375564575,
0.27439549565315247,
0.38619810342788696,
0.6887534260749817,
-0.15749087929725647,
0.09347017109394073,
0.47955504059791565,
-0.04763089492917061,
-0.3810292184352875,
0.39977511763572693,
0.25703105330467224,
0.21889705955982208,
0.7811142802238464,
0.1582336127758026,
-0.4102678894996643,
-0.368807852268219,
0.03952494636178017,
0.46193113923072815,
-0.9649385213851929,
-0.15220394730567932,
-0.6901755332946777,
0.11567170917987823,
-0.47603464126586914,
-0.06496856361627579,
-0.19299612939357758,
-0.3876540958881378,
0.038695260882377625,
-0.12210164219141006,
0.16959992051124573,
0.38913843035697937,
0.05440995842218399,
0.08668885380029678,
-0.6324852108955383,
0.1780509650707245,
0.12154996395111084,
0.2109844982624054,
0.07756607234477997,
-0.8022205233573914,
-0.16988234221935272,
-0.07978184521198273,
0.17586234211921692,
-0.7312194108963013,
0.08442185074090958,
-0.11890212446451187,
0.7252764105796814,
0.34885305166244507,
-0.09972701221704483,
1.0176575183868408,
-0.3717854619026184,
0.13610482215881348,
0.19061541557312012,
-0.8870124816894531,
0.7745745778083801,
-0.3400638997554779,
0.47685328125953674,
0.4816625714302063,
-0.10872673988342285,
-0.2080095261335373,
-0.11793719232082367,
-0.5184454321861267,
-0.9413073658943176,
0.7034593224525452,
0.37182945013046265,
-0.3171739876270294,
0.13132140040397644,
0.6172246932983398,
-0.2855079174041748,
0.10539297759532928,
-0.7117325067520142,
0.028480324894189835,
0.10566052049398422,
0.06737686693668365,
0.12102437019348145,
-0.524039089679718,
-0.15036340057849884,
-0.3855527937412262,
0.7405903935432434,
0.02036706544458866,
0.18373386561870575,
0.3505457043647766,
-0.19157885015010834,
0.06660157442092896,
0.5091545581817627,
0.399710476398468,
1.0451089143753052,
-0.23310044407844543,
0.4875814914703369,
0.1508045196533203,
-0.0430598221719265,
0.28915926814079285,
-0.12454976886510849,
0.018197575584053993,
-0.16567371785640717,
0.6588411331176758,
0.5234431028366089,
0.2913595736026764,
-0.5991519689559937,
0.42706409096717834,
-0.16847680509090424,
0.04146523028612137,
-0.23690342903137207,
0.17760181427001953,
0.22875073552131653,
0.5864006280899048,
0.07205090671777725,
-0.11668393760919571,
-0.09807699918746948,
-0.7013551592826843,
0.3182920813560486,
0.17587758600711823,
0.06867958605289459,
0.1277691125869751,
0.11757804453372955,
-0.024475056678056717,
-0.2603229284286499,
0.7434512376785278,
-0.02441311441361904,
-0.3074118196964264,
0.41828984022140503,
0.7689533233642578,
0.566571056842804,
-0.31086355447769165,
0.06216510012745857,
0.5524581074714661,
0.4530305862426758,
-0.22879350185394287,
0.14989466965198517,
-0.32936424016952515,
-1.0727142095565796,
-0.7630614042282104,
-0.3597806990146637,
0.003388854907825589,
0.15538468956947327,
-0.3102962374687195,
0.10797564685344696,
-0.4293939471244812,
-0.14904916286468506,
-0.05620642378926277,
-0.29145026206970215,
-0.38178500533103943,
0.21157512068748474,
-0.02065289579331875,
0.9353693127632141,
-0.4638906419277191,
0.8836580514907837,
0.647346019744873,
-0.39590102434158325,
-0.8115133047103882,
0.3355802297592163,
-0.04154353588819504,
-0.41626977920532227,
0.998856246471405,
0.30731457471847534,
-0.5532388091087341,
-0.2075134962797165,
-0.5997570753097534,
-1.219590187072754,
1.2719875574111938,
0.5108556747436523,
-0.7106993794441223,
0.44562679529190063,
-0.27073490619659424,
0.47926217317581177,
-0.43876489996910095,
0.32534047961235046,
0.5367980599403381,
0.7165602445602417,
0.4160006046295166,
-0.637366771697998,
0.2607770264148712,
-0.313223659992218,
-0.1063227653503418,
0.32086384296417236,
-0.47035446763038635,
0.6621125340461731,
-0.3997046649456024,
-0.5169112086296082,
-0.03197415545582771,
0.39339739084243774,
0.5802417397499084,
0.27797219157218933,
0.7134168148040771,
0.5447887182235718,
1.1536486148834229,
-0.07778303325176239,
0.9222391843795776,
-0.08599411696195602,
0.05595821142196655,
1.5698362588882446,
-0.3567732870578766,
0.6605144739151001,
0.6955171823501587,
0.26257672905921936,
0.5552546381950378,
0.4371386170387268,
0.3189598023891449,
0.2813894748687744,
0.26770177483558655,
-0.3530760705471039,
-0.5738886594772339,
-0.2995784878730774,
-0.21241363883018494,
0.46364259719848633,
0.3033164143562317,
-0.42832714319229126,
-0.20518958568572998,
-0.3513769507408142,
0.10134204477071762,
-0.10185034573078156,
-0.06477173417806625,
0.7729658484458923,
-0.07695420831441879,
-0.6648778319358826,
0.6882583498954773,
0.06382017582654953,
0.21910874545574188,
-0.42730990052223206,
-0.21432605385780334,
-0.22913357615470886,
0.2592537999153137,
-0.3623949885368347,
-0.7950436472892761,
0.253640741109848,
0.039414845407009125,
-0.389281690120697,
-0.14811809360980988,
1.0367447137832642,
-0.4110683500766754,
-0.21910762786865234,
0.5496205687522888,
0.527618408203125,
0.25531014800071716,
-0.22571980953216553,
-0.48627981543540955,
0.19198286533355713,
0.062863789498806,
-0.44696059823036194,
0.1956091970205307,
0.7770107388496399,
-0.2454919070005417,
0.8020808100700378,
0.8110864758491516,
-0.16780470311641693,
-0.3339630663394928,
0.36116501688957214,
0.9822450876235962,
-0.6861668825149536,
-0.251234233379364,
-0.8861948251724243,
0.44804254174232483,
-0.3864803910255432,
0.0162432249635458,
0.6211150288581848,
0.5402611494064331,
0.7296050190925598,
0.15392863750457764,
0.6603475213050842,
0.030607495456933975,
0.22381503880023956,
-0.5599037408828735,
0.27430209517478943,
-0.6187816262245178,
0.6960895657539368,
-0.23911742866039276,
-1.0669958591461182,
-0.5487917065620422,
0.7521491646766663,
-0.5101182460784912,
-0.0894613042473793,
0.695257842540741,
0.9182281494140625,
-0.1507839858531952,
-0.06416105479001999,
0.30496853590011597,
0.4547633230686188,
0.3245235085487366,
0.5874825716018677,
0.971481442451477,
-0.12535953521728516,
0.6833781003952026,
-0.17127439379692078,
-0.45455068349838257,
-0.04536284878849983,
-0.7802115082740784,
-0.646205723285675,
-0.2680709958076477,
-0.3043266236782074,
-0.31872838735580444,
0.09607041627168655,
0.6988457441329956,
0.6120014190673828,
-0.3300408720970154,
-0.07244454324245453,
-0.053439270704984665,
0.4622395932674408,
-0.11258044093847275,
-0.24314594268798828,
0.351040780544281,
-0.34387046098709106,
-0.29123735427856445,
0.6166443824768066,
0.6440337896347046,
-0.35555434226989746,
0.15007731318473816,
-0.0018649802077561617,
-0.5244671106338501,
0.15101519227027893,
0.7873461842536926,
-0.030264055356383324,
-0.8050836324691772,
-0.5383323431015015,
-0.20302048325538635,
0.047442495822906494,
0.1150859147310257,
0.8470476269721985,
-0.6614726781845093,
0.6452822089195251,
0.8147509694099426,
0.5763564109802246,
0.39005836844444275,
0.35091638565063477,
0.5130457282066345,
-0.6277248859405518,
0.09101200103759766,
-0.12867102026939392,
0.6394761800765991,
0.19126741588115692,
-0.5237659215927124,
0.7786243557929993,
0.12384767830371857,
-0.4916516840457916,
-0.5380141139030457,
0.4166213572025299,
-0.8765165209770203,
-0.5980308651924133,
1.3712031841278076,
-0.1896090805530548,
-0.2955165505409241,
-0.15939413011074066,
-0.4021288752555847,
0.3743114769458771,
-0.44761139154434204,
0.7701451778411865,
0.6285921335220337,
-0.44006043672561646,
-0.374318391084671,
-0.31910791993141174,
-0.012951627373695374,
0.4247473180294037,
-1.050134539604187,
0.1678178310394287,
0.7180660963058472,
0.389265775680542,
0.35765892267227173,
0.7984338998794556,
-0.16196520626544952,
0.06395531445741653,
-0.2710384726524353,
-0.06840578466653824,
-0.0660504400730133,
-0.47421446442604065,
-0.15500964224338531,
0.061719853430986404,
-0.13415536284446716,
0.14352938532829285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15154v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15154v1
|
Do not think pink elephant!
| 2024-04-22T08:28:13 | 2024-04-22T08:28:13 |
Kyomin Hwang, Suyoung Kim, JunHoo Lee, Nojun Kwak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Models (LMs) have heightened expectations for the potential of general
AI as they are akin to human intelligence. This paper shows that recent large
models such as Stable Diffusion and DALL-E3 also share the vulnerability of
human intelligence, namely the "white bear phenomenon". We investigate the
causes of the white bear phenomenon by analyzing their representation space.
Based on this analysis, we propose a simple prompt-based attack method, which
generates figures prohibited by the LM provider's policy. To counter these
attacks, we introduce prompt-based defense strategies inspired by cognitive
therapy techniques, successfully mitigating attacks by up to 48.22\%.
|
[
-0.7728586196899414,
-1.1535121202468872,
0.7135215997695923,
-0.09858699142932892,
-0.05022795498371124,
-0.08672955632209778,
-0.07629382610321045,
-0.6125214695930481,
0.2586013674736023,
0.5101709961891174,
-0.7679075598716736,
-0.18982534110546112,
-0.6073911786079407,
-0.0838024765253067,
-0.10214928537607193,
0.9183061718940735,
0.2866193354129791,
-0.17044003307819366,
0.039311110973358154,
-0.3086012601852417,
-0.8225553035736084,
-0.5125110149383545,
-0.9181740880012512,
-0.05740359053015709,
0.5153055787086487,
-0.04054619371891022,
1.1575767993927002,
0.1905364990234375,
0.47962892055511475,
0.2588425576686859,
-0.24855880439281464,
-0.2631521224975586,
-0.4520796835422516,
0.11917559802532196,
-0.003116810228675604,
-0.509885311126709,
-0.4034149646759033,
-0.010618858970701694,
0.43987348675727844,
0.3757435977458954,
-0.25709089636802673,
-0.10439758002758026,
-0.20486214756965637,
0.6898237466812134,
-0.7750380039215088,
-0.23444145917892456,
-0.7570732831954956,
0.17309382557868958,
-0.07034564763307571,
0.413806676864624,
-0.6582974195480347,
0.019202176481485367,
-0.0002433712943457067,
-0.6487224102020264,
0.1752111315727234,
0.18592071533203125,
0.5412726402282715,
0.3155488073825836,
-0.5775705575942993,
-0.21040284633636475,
-0.44284677505493164,
1.009120225906372,
-0.41579174995422363,
-0.30117154121398926,
0.5409993529319763,
0.622245192527771,
-0.46177661418914795,
-0.23439891636371613,
-0.5420052409172058,
-0.7151975631713867,
-0.23945926129817963,
-0.20409835875034332,
-0.37710845470428467,
-0.024210330098867416,
0.7268089056015015,
-0.26430201530456543,
-0.5551181435585022,
0.07400790601968765,
-0.28757861256599426,
-0.3139790892601013,
0.9477121829986572,
0.3343493342399597,
0.6991135478019714,
0.1070898100733757,
-0.3208718001842499,
-0.011660323478281498,
-0.7968664169311523,
0.2038930505514145,
0.12561339139938354,
0.060384415090084076,
0.05049007013440132,
0.4564400315284729,
0.048647183924913406,
0.6294671893119812,
-0.08526378870010376,
0.12871882319450378,
-0.130506232380867,
0.19138026237487793,
-0.2187463790178299,
0.30006903409957886,
0.6208372116088867,
0.3625302016735077,
0.18663640320301056,
-0.023618299514055252,
-0.43704262375831604,
0.191212996840477,
0.4960126578807831,
-0.8919709324836731,
0.02222171612083912,
0.19240067899227142,
-0.5284393429756165,
-0.2438730001449585,
-0.0680365264415741,
-0.6583549380302429,
-0.7001637816429138,
0.0849776417016983,
0.6233026385307312,
-0.4853943884372711,
-0.536346971988678,
-0.09536287933588028,
0.09653639793395996,
0.1499907672405243,
0.2929198741912842,
-0.754863440990448,
0.5968189835548401,
0.7206639051437378,
0.7848513722419739,
-0.08504568785429001,
0.12398675084114075,
-0.40058138966560364,
0.3397536277770996,
-0.5838750600814819,
0.5257170796394348,
-0.37028083205223083,
-0.7623910903930664,
-0.05626608803868294,
0.048001691699028015,
0.39204806089401245,
-0.5976673364639282,
0.37403982877731323,
-0.6902716755867004,
-0.07882718741893768,
-0.6064596772193909,
-0.23011599481105804,
-0.5587211847305298,
0.5531676411628723,
-0.745090126991272,
0.35760530829429626,
-0.20119556784629822,
-0.8071163296699524,
0.03332747891545296,
-1.233908772468567,
-0.3561162054538727,
-0.0004262592119630426,
-0.165699765086174,
-0.2276652753353119,
0.08403278142213821,
0.2761610150337219,
0.40370407700538635,
-0.22776949405670166,
0.021277334541082382,
-0.7976443767547607,
-0.37380191683769226,
0.5861406326293945,
-0.13270142674446106,
1.0503417253494263,
0.44394025206565857,
-0.2046363353729248,
0.08854421228170395,
-0.4999946653842926,
-0.08755583316087723,
0.629688560962677,
0.3606422245502472,
-0.5475928783416748,
-0.005499083548784256,
-0.34359410405158997,
0.20551134645938873,
0.1072169616818428,
-0.40746909379959106,
0.23510384559631348,
0.01752465032041073,
0.5509564876556396,
0.8703400492668152,
0.31830722093582153,
0.4773241877555847,
-0.6190869808197021,
0.5556477308273315,
0.1516115367412567,
0.19831734895706177,
-0.21347074210643768,
-0.6767670512199402,
-0.3629136383533478,
-0.5920612215995789,
-0.1534852534532547,
0.46667197346687317,
-0.630667507648468,
0.11314082890748978,
0.23563401401042938,
-0.4754874110221863,
-0.30463165044784546,
-0.06626150757074356,
0.14094720780849457,
0.44888222217559814,
0.40630674362182617,
0.1686134785413742,
0.18325963616371155,
-0.9365438222885132,
-0.17203739285469055,
0.06112537533044815,
-0.05740281566977501,
-0.03696565702557564,
0.508953869342804,
-0.473175048828125,
0.826492428779602,
-0.8039839863777161,
-0.10166697204113007,
0.08986825495958328,
0.3525606095790863,
0.36140307784080505,
0.7791018486022949,
0.9774623513221741,
-0.9739899635314941,
-0.22737519443035126,
-0.44014787673950195,
-0.6473689079284668,
0.31526875495910645,
-0.08471009135246277,
-0.15857023000717163,
0.44679686427116394,
0.6323532462120056,
-1.134522795677185,
0.3091244697570801,
0.08673956245183945,
-0.4040023386478424,
0.2758207321166992,
-0.3037222623825073,
-0.022727742791175842,
-0.8957688212394714,
-0.036097776144742966,
0.24763163924217224,
0.11531039327383041,
-0.6201799511909485,
0.1182512566447258,
0.002737275091931224,
-0.463897168636322,
-0.39892175793647766,
0.6676731705665588,
-0.3238160312175751,
0.07254143059253693,
-0.2549370229244232,
-0.012739812955260277,
-0.3328501284122467,
0.35929375886917114,
-0.1492231786251068,
0.4850800037384033,
0.6598870158195496,
-0.6970672011375427,
0.18309056758880615,
0.18011215329170227,
-0.23156757652759552,
0.6204518675804138,
-0.6348149180412292,
0.39975666999816895,
-0.350339412689209,
0.2499644160270691,
-1.0746181011199951,
-0.0918494313955307,
0.4726439416408539,
-0.34256330132484436,
0.6336948275566101,
0.3341423273086548,
-0.362002968788147,
-0.37401488423347473,
-0.5230519771575928,
0.5000076293945312,
0.9396187663078308,
-0.3469386696815491,
0.6238654851913452,
0.21702659130096436,
-0.4046492874622345,
-0.6588679552078247,
-0.6905516982078552,
0.1678050011396408,
-0.5560629963874817,
-0.8762909770011902,
0.13902203738689423,
-0.49336734414100647,
-0.5697351694107056,
0.11748979985713959,
0.16125063598155975,
0.0239886287599802,
0.5443513989448547,
0.1810779869556427,
0.24915306270122528,
-0.1978026181459427,
-0.03196091577410698,
-0.33036643266677856,
-0.1313340663909912,
0.44132956862449646,
0.13916996121406555,
0.11970528215169907,
0.1621675044298172,
-0.6633577346801758,
-0.670435905456543,
0.49059998989105225,
0.7606321573257446,
-0.06545183807611465,
0.6658632755279541,
0.3807471692562103,
-0.6758264899253845,
-0.1463015079498291,
-0.42621421813964844,
-0.48579537868499756,
-0.47551870346069336,
0.6164855360984802,
-0.04660220816731453,
-0.5125062465667725,
0.3982076644897461,
0.2825801968574524,
0.15253722667694092,
0.3389233946800232,
0.4419328272342682,
-0.1573803573846817,
1.6190075874328613,
0.4456459879875183,
-0.2912297248840332,
0.38033556938171387,
-0.17733687162399292,
0.052051693201065063,
-0.7499709129333496,
-0.1598861962556839,
-0.2747276723384857,
-0.5890664458274841,
-0.48153671622276306,
-0.003475291421636939,
0.2904163599014282,
-0.06707245111465454,
-0.7822076678276062,
-0.11994319409132004,
-0.52267986536026,
0.18163824081420898,
0.4450007379055023,
0.15007387101650238,
-0.25992485880851746,
-0.11390290409326553,
0.22318415343761444,
-0.08058398962020874,
-0.43615421652793884,
-0.3939884305000305,
0.903635561466217,
0.4501244127750397,
0.8923976421356201,
0.3588496744632721,
0.3551348149776459,
0.7827216982841492,
0.5142306089401245,
-0.5713641047477722,
0.8576211929321289,
0.31965333223342896,
-0.8519288897514343,
-0.5190441012382507,
-0.33545222878456116,
-1.0251983404159546,
0.40311652421951294,
-0.509320855140686,
-0.890900731086731,
-0.21587811410427094,
-0.014818019233644009,
-0.6181037425994873,
0.21604786813259125,
-0.7273025512695312,
0.5976212620735168,
-0.4362297058105469,
-0.12908115983009338,
-0.494530588388443,
-0.36807897686958313,
0.6205872893333435,
-0.35850000381469727,
0.42351004481315613,
-0.19670356810092926,
-0.19866830110549927,
0.7769430875778198,
-0.2585103213787079,
0.7951692938804626,
-0.46829113364219666,
0.10775676369667053,
0.5193762183189392,
0.39909690618515015,
0.7832472920417786,
0.18035699427127838,
0.06591565907001495,
-0.0697598084807396,
-0.20374788343906403,
-0.9347673654556274,
-0.6033916473388672,
0.42571455240249634,
-0.8808838725090027,
-1.161291480064392,
-0.5972200036048889,
-0.6841506958007812,
-0.22476188838481903,
-0.10865302383899689,
0.10258923470973969,
-0.056938521564006805,
-0.3030400276184082,
0.008806400001049042,
0.6846085786819458,
-0.3566003739833832,
0.7179261445999146,
0.5327134728431702,
-0.11194517463445663,
-0.5887492895126343,
0.7301785349845886,
0.3200608193874359,
0.360516756772995,
-0.06682411581277847,
0.010138247162103653,
-0.06845422089099884,
-0.5399217009544373,
0.03533608838915825,
0.4270937144756317,
-0.6534698605537415,
-0.1855924129486084,
-0.658458948135376,
-0.07024890184402466,
-0.3162931203842163,
-0.5167056322097778,
0.012134309858083725,
-0.155221089720726,
-0.2656194269657135,
-0.02064402773976326,
0.38721179962158203,
0.8526061177253723,
0.00765083497390151,
0.4673207998275757,
-0.7367016077041626,
0.26376038789749146,
0.757180392742157,
-0.34650638699531555,
0.2553631365299225,
-0.3258291184902191,
-0.08924490958452225,
0.2810969948768616,
-0.7455517649650574,
-0.7838001251220703,
0.3077540099620819,
-0.5360181331634521,
0.7628006935119629,
0.8090508580207825,
0.3585124611854553,
0.17964471876621246,
-0.25773903727531433,
0.8383685350418091,
0.6661641001701355,
-0.757621705532074,
0.4049629271030426,
-0.34788596630096436,
0.16749678552150726,
-0.07383271306753159,
0.4190234839916229,
-0.20499105751514435,
-0.21616297960281372,
-0.8611662983894348,
-0.4069412350654602,
0.8679912090301514,
0.15998733043670654,
0.29109418392181396,
-0.033724382519721985,
0.3569088876247406,
-0.3285350501537323,
0.06685018539428711,
-0.6683269739151001,
-0.013189445249736309,
-0.07187435030937195,
0.08397403359413147,
-0.0651555135846138,
-0.5366618633270264,
-0.47901850938796997,
0.10668537765741348,
0.6980888843536377,
-0.05858331546187401,
0.1207548975944519,
-0.01214311458170414,
-0.07915126532316208,
-0.18564869463443756,
0.02502988465130329,
0.8594145774841309,
0.5497000813484192,
-0.19629208743572235,
-0.06888514012098312,
0.5818490386009216,
-0.3559703230857849,
0.4024224877357483,
-0.11889322847127914,
-0.2775931656360626,
-0.25473150610923767,
0.5669335126876831,
0.5325059294700623,
0.015508399344980717,
-0.6089823842048645,
0.5189024806022644,
0.008892159909009933,
-0.01297290064394474,
-0.36340323090553284,
0.26409706473350525,
0.0693192332983017,
0.35931816697120667,
0.3884953260421753,
0.0615474097430706,
-0.08760678023099899,
-0.655179500579834,
-0.18623322248458862,
0.8500769734382629,
-0.45644107460975647,
-0.49337249994277954,
0.6714305877685547,
0.1419471949338913,
-0.45858684182167053,
0.805557370185852,
-0.22281791269779205,
-0.4483197331428528,
1.1721280813217163,
0.6662570834159851,
0.7767407894134521,
-0.49210554361343384,
0.26267197728157043,
0.32558730244636536,
0.582726001739502,
-0.13984139263629913,
0.13942626118659973,
0.11404185742139816,
-0.5554117560386658,
-0.12649863958358765,
-0.07535326480865479,
-0.2289365977048874,
0.23761138319969177,
-0.6387688517570496,
0.5498781800270081,
-0.8028364777565002,
-0.3726257085800171,
-0.12589161098003387,
-0.12935718894004822,
-0.26314693689346313,
0.07923127710819244,
0.5179593563079834,
1.1050115823745728,
-0.6005061268806458,
0.5392221808433533,
0.7874555587768555,
-0.3567664921283722,
-0.3366347551345825,
0.10059288889169693,
0.021976657211780548,
-0.7932256460189819,
0.8601117730140686,
0.2820844054222107,
0.3404971659183502,
-0.48541778326034546,
-0.8705974221229553,
-0.7500641345977783,
1.1567599773406982,
0.6656548380851746,
-0.436907559633255,
0.21475203335285187,
-0.2750363349914551,
0.14004401862621307,
-0.4713619351387024,
0.15459512174129486,
0.39219316840171814,
0.722942054271698,
0.1736103743314743,
-0.2744564116001129,
0.39910998940467834,
0.04678483307361603,
0.16820628941059113,
0.3194163143634796,
-0.7696955800056458,
0.9631872773170471,
-0.7224511504173279,
-0.11776730418205261,
0.04611573740839958,
0.5108884572982788,
0.5786288380622864,
0.44976410269737244,
0.782828152179718,
0.5102908611297607,
0.9643550515174866,
0.22653014957904816,
1.1431422233581543,
-0.08978735655546188,
0.16359172761440277,
0.6271073222160339,
-0.48726096749305725,
0.5779498219490051,
0.1900489330291748,
-0.06199181452393532,
0.11484178900718689,
0.6797643899917603,
-0.1705479770898819,
0.7926772832870483,
0.4159851372241974,
-0.3641052842140198,
-0.19966769218444824,
0.16142652928829193,
-0.6161025166511536,
0.011056406423449516,
0.5895764231681824,
0.009258444420993328,
-0.15295815467834473,
0.18653960525989532,
0.34151944518089294,
-0.0167231522500515,
-0.6760284900665283,
0.8193432688713074,
0.205259308218956,
-0.4835401773452759,
0.6727481484413147,
-0.36616775393486023,
0.5468048453330994,
-0.664918839931488,
-0.035875387489795685,
-0.03596735745668411,
-0.05979989096522331,
0.1003703773021698,
-0.49714550375938416,
0.10009019821882248,
-0.2803746163845062,
-0.2653544247150421,
0.2508235573768616,
0.5004383325576782,
0.018194513395428658,
-0.49882763624191284,
0.44790804386138916,
0.0913618877530098,
-0.04281646013259888,
-0.13606584072113037,
-0.9316793084144592,
-0.06913048774003983,
-0.12608566880226135,
-0.4107802212238312,
0.6035448312759399,
0.7717167735099792,
-0.4292025566101074,
0.8481671214103699,
0.5964630842208862,
-0.054980333894491196,
-0.2617284953594208,
-0.5584129095077515,
0.76397305727005,
-0.9998705387115479,
-0.6626587510108948,
-1.0819306373596191,
0.3117976486682892,
-0.28845658898353577,
0.1904430240392685,
0.22390694916248322,
-0.029941406100988388,
0.3456275165081024,
-0.028006628155708313,
0.7572251558303833,
0.14876098930835724,
0.23684512078762054,
-0.5807735323905945,
1.1608293056488037,
-0.5287473797798157,
0.18931809067726135,
-0.15772929787635803,
-1.0550836324691772,
-0.14420925080776215,
0.29827508330345154,
-0.41960668563842773,
0.2255517691373825,
0.7194453477859497,
0.8568361401557922,
0.14384448528289795,
0.16795624792575836,
0.5910148024559021,
0.6891123056411743,
0.5669892430305481,
0.6407231092453003,
1.2054331302642822,
0.24937520921230316,
0.5471118092536926,
0.17478956282138824,
-0.4652450978755951,
-0.5327373147010803,
-0.9200101494789124,
-1.1801692247390747,
-0.29670870304107666,
-0.44760897755622864,
-0.4668216109275818,
-0.0377400666475296,
0.7883158326148987,
0.748198926448822,
-0.8400752544403076,
0.19447392225265503,
0.22072836756706238,
0.22776512801647186,
-0.10377431660890579,
-0.1051739826798439,
0.5195711851119995,
-0.4465624988079071,
-0.3036845028400421,
-0.041530873626470566,
0.10741432011127472,
0.40573883056640625,
-0.38940316438674927,
-0.18071329593658447,
-0.010746435262262821,
0.24074020981788635,
0.514551043510437,
0.36969077587127686,
-0.7949414253234863,
-0.3301681876182556,
-0.31233105063438416,
-0.23893287777900696,
-0.24491332471370697,
0.5330917239189148,
-0.6777967810630798,
0.2102496176958084,
0.08111997693777084,
0.8411403894424438,
0.060293857008218765,
-0.2958666980266571,
0.4781149625778198,
-0.1051705852150917,
0.6505382657051086,
0.2909030020236969,
0.672679603099823,
0.29100677371025085,
-0.7655354142189026,
0.47612905502319336,
0.1885993331670761,
-0.4376735985279083,
-1.0106656551361084,
0.3118545413017273,
-0.719774067401886,
-0.6681649088859558,
0.8808882832527161,
-0.2096947431564331,
-0.45614150166511536,
0.25431522727012634,
-0.652128279209137,
-0.16495244204998016,
-0.6115566492080688,
1.2522627115249634,
0.7741537690162659,
-0.1260671615600586,
0.057550184428691864,
-0.9405928254127502,
0.4744963049888611,
0.3946373462677002,
-0.692233145236969,
-0.23957209289073944,
0.2995840013027191,
0.16301274299621582,
0.544274091720581,
0.4493659436702728,
0.12625105679035187,
0.35456451773643494,
-0.19872401654720306,
-0.06945047527551651,
-0.19260366261005402,
-0.05714390054345131,
-0.32987353205680847,
0.46635550260543823,
0.05764085054397583,
-0.38459134101867676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13968v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13968v2
|
Protecting Your LLMs with Information Bottleneck
| 2024-04-22T08:16:07 | 2024-05-16T13:26:57 |
Zichuan Liu, Zefan Wang, Linjie Xu, Jinyu Wang, Lei Song, Tianchun Wang, Chunlin Chen, Wei Cheng, Jiang Bian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR
|
The advent of large language models (LLMs) has revolutionized the field of
natural language processing, yet they might be attacked to produce harmful
content. Despite efforts to ethically align LLMs, these are often fragile and
can be circumvented by jailbreaking attacks through optimized or manual
adversarial prompts. To address this, we introduce the Information Bottleneck
Protector (IBProtector), a defense mechanism grounded in the information
bottleneck principle, and we modify the objective to avoid trivial solutions.
The IBProtector selectively compresses and perturbs prompts, facilitated by a
lightweight and trainable extractor, preserving only essential information for
the target LLMs to respond with the expected answer. Moreover, we further
consider a situation where the gradient is not visible to be compatible with
any LLM. Our empirical evaluations show that IBProtector outperforms current
defense methods in mitigating jailbreak attempts, without overly affecting
response quality or inference speed. Its effectiveness and adaptability across
various attack methods and target LLMs underscore the potential of IBProtector
as a novel, transferable defense that bolsters the security of LLMs without
requiring modifications to the underlying models.
|
[
-0.7639397382736206,
-0.963667631149292,
0.15377596020698547,
0.17046338319778442,
0.03317148610949516,
0.2856816053390503,
-0.04936656728386879,
-0.5538963675498962,
-0.10095512121915817,
0.8196512460708618,
-0.466415673494339,
-0.09303758293390274,
-0.6475722789764404,
0.07871908694505692,
-0.3194580376148224,
1.256676435470581,
0.11487879604101181,
-0.26013293862342834,
-0.3616917133331299,
0.11032341420650482,
-0.5550899505615234,
-0.44021841883659363,
-0.692854642868042,
-0.23497214913368225,
0.30701303482055664,
0.3435080945491791,
0.6345754265785217,
0.8870691657066345,
0.7808530330657959,
0.2596074044704437,
-0.20405054092407227,
-0.10809372365474701,
-0.4437289535999298,
0.5654515624046326,
-0.26971936225891113,
-0.5294103026390076,
-0.24271394312381744,
-0.2615794539451599,
0.29327407479286194,
0.33314037322998047,
-0.09736362099647522,
0.06800361722707748,
0.13405181467533112,
0.9287354946136475,
-0.9452943801879883,
-0.15336205065250397,
-1.0020030736923218,
0.035824280232191086,
-0.48944589495658875,
-0.04973909258842468,
-0.39867305755615234,
-0.22832094132900238,
-0.0639992505311966,
-0.29202982783317566,
0.16235806047916412,
0.4583989083766937,
0.8323281407356262,
0.2583644390106201,
0.07183360308408737,
-0.2902592420578003,
-0.535205602645874,
0.4051574766635895,
-0.3246554732322693,
-0.06940604001283646,
0.19049938023090363,
0.45546114444732666,
-0.2906256318092346,
-0.5142219662666321,
-0.6189656853675842,
-0.2722223699092865,
0.17058172821998596,
-0.1308339387178421,
-0.807161271572113,
0.38357239961624146,
0.553656280040741,
0.3409792184829712,
-0.7214385271072388,
0.3610481023788452,
-0.611462414264679,
-0.47731393575668335,
0.3732152581214905,
0.19848762452602386,
0.3962041139602661,
-0.04198036715388298,
-0.7952344417572021,
0.05725887417793274,
-1.0442383289337158,
0.3087179362773895,
0.4473678171634674,
0.03578779846429825,
0.22020845115184784,
0.5295911431312561,
-0.04346190765500069,
0.7943545579910278,
0.05130024626851082,
-0.1899372786283493,
-0.12439605593681335,
0.04681013524532318,
-0.026133595034480095,
0.3240753710269928,
0.9905206561088562,
0.35047921538352966,
0.4454410672187805,
-0.2782675325870514,
-0.32878994941711426,
-0.043249715119600296,
0.5585666298866272,
-1.044975996017456,
-0.15504471957683563,
0.36021503806114197,
-0.1785901039838791,
-0.3643742501735687,
0.21947656571865082,
-0.8941453099250793,
-0.6294093132019043,
0.24217063188552856,
0.09847725182771683,
-0.41346532106399536,
-0.09653182327747345,
-0.05532883107662201,
-0.10736244171857834,
-0.019320769235491753,
-0.12875033915042877,
-0.8252034187316895,
0.4644426107406616,
0.8410536050796509,
1.0820887088775635,
-0.19382888078689575,
0.06036316975951195,
-0.753212034702301,
0.2979707419872284,
-0.18331024050712585,
0.8849356770515442,
-0.3077757954597473,
-0.42259785532951355,
-0.18038325011730194,
-0.3870296776294708,
0.10162568837404251,
-0.8352810740470886,
0.6234837770462036,
-0.5766436457633972,
-0.43155115842819214,
-0.10941386967897415,
-0.5145496129989624,
0.17355534434318542,
0.32511094212532043,
-0.899196207523346,
0.7744933366775513,
-0.02222997136414051,
-1.0625790357589722,
0.0008667861693538725,
-0.7034055590629578,
-0.5013684034347534,
0.14388293027877808,
0.02089937962591648,
-0.4892464280128479,
0.078575000166893,
0.2615002989768982,
0.35158535838127136,
-0.5161125659942627,
0.1535569727420807,
-0.4904780387878418,
-0.29116714000701904,
0.27726271748542786,
-0.35188862681388855,
0.672029972076416,
0.5327966213226318,
-0.00886036828160286,
-0.16301625967025757,
-0.6646494269371033,
-0.07787710428237915,
0.11948280036449432,
-0.37747272849082947,
-0.3537609875202179,
-0.12936395406723022,
-0.3543991446495056,
0.07129145413637161,
0.2760719954967499,
-0.7186439037322998,
0.4427683651447296,
-0.25779372453689575,
0.45873475074768066,
0.9617339968681335,
0.04952794313430786,
0.26678040623664856,
-0.45424801111221313,
0.6663549542427063,
-0.07183396071195602,
0.2446657419204712,
-0.09862150251865387,
-0.15505214035511017,
-0.5154870748519897,
-0.564363420009613,
-0.017227619886398315,
0.8738207817077637,
-0.8390384912490845,
0.34714749455451965,
-0.1740359663963318,
-0.4387013614177704,
-0.6943537592887878,
0.5156311392784119,
0.5650027394294739,
0.667884111404419,
0.29813694953918457,
-0.2721378803253174,
-0.5342194437980652,
-0.9579166173934937,
-0.6936486959457397,
-0.2794598340988159,
-0.06826303154230118,
0.0004752280656248331,
0.1553620845079422,
-0.023425672203302383,
0.9587777256965637,
-0.5656736493110657,
-0.192298024892807,
-0.6081404089927673,
0.2671247720718384,
0.39983227849006653,
0.5170175433158875,
0.5269946455955505,
-0.7048927545547485,
-0.3285316228866577,
-0.37925922870635986,
-0.730716347694397,
-0.8047163486480713,
-0.1493285745382309,
-0.06334099173545837,
-0.2998856008052826,
0.70387864112854,
-0.9392086863517761,
0.268868088722229,
0.20766013860702515,
-0.28640276193618774,
0.7011318206787109,
0.13054430484771729,
-0.42358407378196716,
-0.7765029072761536,
-0.06592703610658646,
-0.0435456745326519,
-0.292437881231308,
-0.9380612373352051,
0.06908346712589264,
-0.14933158457279205,
-0.010021848604083061,
-0.31110724806785583,
0.6458794474601746,
-0.2512495219707489,
0.25482237339019775,
-0.532124936580658,
0.17156393826007843,
0.06660950928926468,
0.07138124853372574,
-0.314273476600647,
0.8362601399421692,
0.5968690514564514,
-0.7926892042160034,
0.433040589094162,
0.22334404289722443,
-0.5287768840789795,
1.0311156511306763,
-0.7899392247200012,
0.17934952676296234,
-0.4042719006538391,
0.11743438243865967,
-0.4974372684955597,
0.025194238871335983,
0.37898141145706177,
-0.28463301062583923,
0.5791818499565125,
-0.2257515788078308,
-0.42063969373703003,
-0.5623967051506042,
-0.5868910551071167,
0.104973204433918,
0.2821047008037567,
-0.6467788219451904,
0.6378670334815979,
0.31893280148506165,
-0.5017796158790588,
-0.9644787907600403,
-0.7241599559783936,
0.29899975657463074,
-0.4039797782897949,
-0.6230791211128235,
0.3287224769592285,
-0.4056343734264374,
-0.4827876389026642,
-0.14246082305908203,
-0.2555403709411621,
-0.16674712300300598,
0.529268741607666,
0.46217215061187744,
0.47532758116722107,
-0.05113326013088226,
-0.024398131296038628,
-0.3118799030780792,
-0.18432994186878204,
0.1708352118730545,
-0.2210523635149002,
0.4636046886444092,
-0.0702892392873764,
-0.24506749212741852,
-0.25790131092071533,
0.32465511560440063,
0.6353954672813416,
-0.06416585296392441,
0.6997236609458923,
0.46022433042526245,
-0.12575718760490417,
-0.1183265894651413,
-0.8008179664611816,
-0.06505569815635681,
-0.5435929894447327,
0.5104992389678955,
-0.4983100891113281,
-0.973102331161499,
0.19186435639858246,
-0.03622615709900856,
0.04655921086668968,
0.10489946603775024,
0.3426845371723175,
-0.03817051649093628,
0.6484904289245605,
0.5397281050682068,
-0.6283682584762573,
0.6389771103858948,
0.10031708329916,
0.36658528447151184,
-1.2216660976409912,
-0.06769219785928726,
-0.41012105345726013,
-0.1666145920753479,
-0.3867765963077545,
0.08860024064779282,
0.44320520758628845,
0.6564184427261353,
-0.45383089780807495,
0.44516685605049133,
-0.5262741446495056,
0.7043563723564148,
0.5434713363647461,
-0.07808272540569305,
0.11970797181129456,
-0.2020573914051056,
0.12026580423116684,
0.18954752385616302,
-0.7442451119422913,
-0.640620231628418,
0.9774267673492432,
0.47458651661872864,
1.0668343305587769,
0.26623204350471497,
0.5238032937049866,
0.42462852597236633,
0.5129265189170837,
-0.441935271024704,
0.6707849502563477,
-0.004351537209004164,
-0.8563776016235352,
0.029595470055937767,
-0.6930914521217346,
-0.8256381154060364,
0.40428078174591064,
-0.1346738189458847,
-1.381948709487915,
0.0024702390655875206,
0.4070321023464203,
-0.3525669574737549,
0.46241140365600586,
-0.43791463971138,
0.6687778830528259,
-0.4209846258163452,
-0.6122308373451233,
0.2713949978351593,
-0.6280964612960815,
0.500715434551239,
-0.15303917229175568,
0.2654784619808197,
-0.3178979158401489,
0.11435991525650024,
0.5186538696289062,
-0.5103267431259155,
0.7184919118881226,
-0.2632392346858978,
0.262093722820282,
0.47650274634361267,
0.37743136286735535,
0.7481459975242615,
0.06016901507973671,
0.1188587099313736,
0.07904931902885437,
-0.23409579694271088,
-0.23552893102169037,
-0.4269687831401825,
0.4265688359737396,
-0.2729358673095703,
-1.2149571180343628,
-0.2816947102546692,
-0.6910374164581299,
0.06274887919425964,
0.2595084309577942,
0.5140221118927002,
-0.03458065167069435,
-0.1518346220254898,
0.2516210079193115,
0.7283763289451599,
-0.11362648010253906,
0.480315238237381,
0.7559500336647034,
0.1167626902461052,
-0.28436389565467834,
0.962208092212677,
-0.01879792846739292,
0.5641211271286011,
0.466093510389328,
0.32089462876319885,
-0.017692454159259796,
-0.6868630647659302,
-0.1900339424610138,
-0.2582414746284485,
-0.6774547696113586,
-0.6944665312767029,
-0.7537031769752502,
-0.3597815930843353,
-0.2071898877620697,
-0.11924233287572861,
-0.46266868710517883,
-0.19642317295074463,
0.010725478641688824,
-0.17948396503925323,
0.4014582633972168,
0.4939453899860382,
-0.2038860023021698,
0.513491690158844,
-0.6163753867149353,
0.3991581201553345,
0.07731015235185623,
-0.04129791632294655,
-0.23292610049247742,
-0.3015098571777344,
0.02337043359875679,
-0.3237169086933136,
-0.6167397499084473,
-0.5339199304580688,
0.33905109763145447,
0.19321301579475403,
0.443115770816803,
0.7016645073890686,
0.4534275233745575,
0.3965873718261719,
-0.4950524866580963,
0.5121768712997437,
0.3789966404438019,
-0.9759789705276489,
0.34055012464523315,
0.14060477912425995,
0.317828893661499,
0.6887054443359375,
0.22142821550369263,
-0.382924884557724,
-0.6649536490440369,
-0.16105297207832336,
-1.1463226079940796,
0.307028591632843,
0.07916474342346191,
-0.11365345865488052,
-0.017108343541622162,
0.231745183467865,
-0.056958943605422974,
0.414097398519516,
-0.9778910279273987,
0.032785315066576004,
-0.1053628921508789,
-0.27667751908302307,
0.5073004961013794,
-0.4012910723686218,
-0.22674153745174408,
0.2902850806713104,
0.48405542969703674,
-0.04936264082789421,
0.1657238006591797,
0.22763143479824066,
-0.22483636438846588,
0.14720870554447174,
0.4658408463001251,
0.16256718337535858,
0.168422669172287,
-0.08118093758821487,
0.38832908868789673,
0.08947914838790894,
-0.7375949621200562,
0.23269203305244446,
0.18366195261478424,
-0.3920785188674927,
-0.3708127737045288,
0.6963236927986145,
0.841779887676239,
-0.19618800282478333,
-0.8929336667060852,
0.6629114151000977,
-0.0005945463781245053,
0.23656174540519714,
-0.11254975944757462,
0.3658492863178253,
-0.3169217109680176,
0.3719014823436737,
0.3057869076728821,
0.04208388552069664,
0.0983463004231453,
-0.394792377948761,
0.12548179924488068,
0.700268566608429,
-0.29832667112350464,
0.004554808139801025,
0.6592078804969788,
-0.1483154594898224,
-0.23645468056201935,
0.45539018511772156,
0.03963829204440117,
-0.8159434795379639,
0.5780706405639648,
0.5593203902244568,
0.8452377319335938,
-0.44513967633247375,
-0.23257331550121307,
-0.07557914406061172,
0.6230742931365967,
-0.235234797000885,
0.12734782695770264,
-0.08948329836130142,
-0.8398791551589966,
-0.010078126564621925,
-0.5269812345504761,
-0.3134806156158447,
0.19144412875175476,
-0.7018720507621765,
0.004595773294568062,
-0.7674421668052673,
-0.23160849511623383,
-0.0746193677186966,
-0.40193483233451843,
-0.4492805302143097,
-0.04532332718372345,
0.07543546706438065,
1.122003436088562,
-0.25961288809776306,
0.5633630156517029,
0.014584163203835487,
-0.21404118835926056,
-0.24584169685840607,
0.07938272505998611,
0.25800973176956177,
-0.7790164351463318,
0.7476186752319336,
0.4853678345680237,
-0.24970915913581848,
-0.4299182593822479,
-0.6012296676635742,
-0.7708695530891418,
0.8981533646583557,
0.669550359249115,
-1.0470184087753296,
0.0804881677031517,
0.12368083745241165,
0.24210931360721588,
-0.3881556987762451,
0.11619684100151062,
0.6309453248977661,
0.40124866366386414,
-0.028709910809993744,
-0.5171794295310974,
0.20526856184005737,
-0.2195880115032196,
-0.09234151989221573,
0.21057462692260742,
-0.5127273201942444,
0.8226358294487,
-0.3814341723918915,
-0.31821414828300476,
0.2559302747249603,
0.31592613458633423,
0.23753537237644196,
0.2020304650068283,
0.5589396357536316,
0.6819577813148499,
0.8315159678459167,
-0.2298811972141266,
1.3469183444976807,
-0.6062378287315369,
-0.13946330547332764,
1.14218008518219,
-0.3586776554584503,
0.5772785544395447,
0.5473795533180237,
0.08417048305273056,
0.19014933705329895,
0.30179083347320557,
-0.3126998543739319,
0.5406452417373657,
0.7327085137367249,
-0.5616865158081055,
0.09351181983947754,
-0.36327069997787476,
-0.1991284340620041,
0.39105281233787537,
0.37888404726982117,
-0.2863461375236511,
0.08868606388568878,
0.17415228486061096,
0.5431100130081177,
-0.04989764094352722,
-0.5063604712486267,
0.7803630232810974,
0.16131709516048431,
-0.6053808927536011,
0.6086502075195312,
-0.14918436110019684,
0.6016833186149597,
-0.7777183055877686,
0.3607853055000305,
-0.06460307538509369,
0.309227854013443,
-0.14092770218849182,
-0.7325264811515808,
0.27165359258651733,
0.37267202138900757,
-0.1755046844482422,
-0.06268230825662613,
0.9567211270332336,
-0.23744231462478638,
-0.209300234913826,
0.45376378297805786,
0.02768215909600258,
-0.09212445467710495,
-0.20139114558696747,
-0.5797193050384521,
0.35535717010498047,
-0.2776181697845459,
-0.4673571288585663,
0.3071923851966858,
0.2400805503129959,
0.08763247728347778,
1.1434576511383057,
0.5994420647621155,
0.4379228949546814,
-0.057426758110523224,
-0.28800711035728455,
1.1985466480255127,
-0.5280864834785461,
-0.3688931167125702,
-1.3611342906951904,
0.20469914376735687,
-0.3805399239063263,
-0.167023167014122,
0.5937336087226868,
0.5137552618980408,
0.7059818506240845,
0.2537354528903961,
1.1150903701782227,
0.02002427913248539,
0.41126570105552673,
-0.7546557188034058,
0.6536193490028381,
0.03393295034766197,
0.7582857012748718,
-0.2662428617477417,
-0.8366295099258423,
-0.10240479558706284,
0.4732985198497772,
-0.24183788895606995,
-0.28556039929389954,
0.46178507804870605,
0.8636009693145752,
0.27480024099349976,
-0.10252657532691956,
0.08117171376943588,
0.45039603114128113,
0.5954172015190125,
0.8354891538619995,
0.7139896750450134,
0.11660187691450119,
0.7940479516983032,
-0.05983344092965126,
-0.3282475173473358,
-0.04118701443076134,
-0.9768229722976685,
-1.163875937461853,
0.05345612391829491,
-0.13081426918506622,
-0.5026407241821289,
0.451294481754303,
0.8036814332008362,
0.6795533299446106,
-0.6675732731819153,
-0.2509133815765381,
-0.3697015941143036,
0.3692248463630676,
-0.052757762372493744,
-0.2807721495628357,
-0.09157408028841019,
-0.26343804597854614,
-0.23742564022541046,
0.49689632654190063,
0.5413746237754822,
0.02606772445142269,
-0.22414033114910126,
0.15500697493553162,
0.120663121342659,
0.2874217927455902,
0.2131328582763672,
0.6863886117935181,
-0.46479129791259766,
-0.16452591121196747,
-0.5355989336967468,
-0.13458086550235748,
0.06987117975950241,
0.9848111867904663,
-0.48365291953086853,
0.663141667842865,
0.2339661866426468,
1.0267258882522583,
0.252127468585968,
-0.050594545900821686,
0.7616534233093262,
-0.767275333404541,
0.24594122171401978,
0.2417486310005188,
0.484355628490448,
0.4796753227710724,
-0.6128058433532715,
0.4467456042766571,
0.20254294574260712,
-0.3400557339191437,
-1.0193214416503906,
0.5799411535263062,
-0.6136367917060852,
-0.38831764459609985,
0.8809319138526917,
-0.4002060890197754,
-0.33460256457328796,
-0.14222688972949982,
-0.10473673790693283,
-0.16571037471294403,
-0.455102801322937,
0.9748685956001282,
0.6958555579185486,
-0.0851883813738823,
-0.2123289555311203,
-0.6883478760719299,
0.5126180052757263,
-0.010162335820496082,
-0.8282335996627808,
0.23863215744495392,
0.0013543784152716398,
0.1784677356481552,
0.29193565249443054,
0.21230429410934448,
-0.030520660802721977,
0.013452112674713135,
-0.10331501811742783,
0.1296243667602539,
-0.3758337199687958,
-0.4000938832759857,
-0.14204615354537964,
0.42942318320274353,
-0.012507393024861813,
-0.12535108625888824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13957v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13957v1
|
How Well Can LLMs Echo Us? Evaluating AI Chatbots' Role-Play Ability with ECHO
| 2024-04-22T08:00:51 | 2024-04-22T08:00:51 |
Man Tik Ng, Hui Tung Tse, Jen-tse Huang, Jingjing Li, Wenxuan Wang, Michael R. Lyu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The role-play ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) has emerged as a
popular research direction. However, existing studies focus on imitating
well-known public figures or fictional characters, overlooking the potential
for simulating ordinary individuals. Such an oversight limits the potential for
advancements in digital human clones and non-player characters in video games.
To bridge this gap, we introduce ECHO, an evaluative framework inspired by the
Turing test. This framework engages the acquaintances of the target individuals
to distinguish between human and machine-generated responses. Notably, our
framework focuses on emulating average individuals rather than historical or
fictional figures, presenting a unique advantage to apply the Turing Test. We
evaluated three role-playing LLMs using ECHO, with GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 serving as
foundational models, alongside the online application GPTs from OpenAI. Our
results demonstrate that GPT-4 more effectively deceives human evaluators, and
GPTs achieves a leading success rate of 48.3%. Furthermore, we investigated
whether LLMs could discern between human-generated and machine-generated texts.
While GPT-4 can identify differences, it could not determine which texts were
human-produced. Our code and results of reproducing the role-playing LLMs are
made publicly available via https://github.com/CUHK-ARISE/ECHO.
|
[
-0.5340403914451599,
-0.9607921838760376,
0.6718637943267822,
0.022963084280490875,
-0.22378291189670563,
0.47850698232650757,
-0.12232048064470291,
-0.6441466212272644,
0.2938466966152191,
0.4631919860839844,
-0.423502117395401,
-0.32149770855903625,
-0.5955518484115601,
0.2929770052433014,
-0.5193033814430237,
0.7542641162872314,
0.17629708349704742,
0.08702649176120758,
-0.22139017283916473,
0.2521131634712219,
-0.14934706687927246,
-0.67589271068573,
-0.886468231678009,
-0.35308536887168884,
0.38950836658477783,
0.13211852312088013,
0.6935729384422302,
0.41235461831092834,
0.45830845832824707,
0.35864385962486267,
0.24380441009998322,
0.3035389184951782,
-0.708251953125,
0.18764008581638336,
0.26944974064826965,
-0.5767394304275513,
-0.35462242364883423,
0.21315237879753113,
0.4680211544036865,
0.22270776331424713,
-0.0197458453476429,
0.12063243240118027,
0.3797467350959778,
0.21007686853408813,
-0.32146012783050537,
0.23665161430835724,
-0.6374297738075256,
-0.028889846056699753,
0.03668791428208351,
-0.28080883622169495,
-0.35335615277290344,
-0.38932669162750244,
0.029820572584867477,
-0.7020106315612793,
0.24965298175811768,
0.13640008866786957,
0.6701436638832092,
0.34866711497306824,
-0.03049991838634014,
-0.5129421353340149,
-1.0096077919006348,
0.6300711631774902,
-0.7097214460372925,
0.26772773265838623,
0.5118738412857056,
0.19350850582122803,
-0.2851310968399048,
-0.5665574669837952,
-0.6206488013267517,
-0.4679829478263855,
0.11512953042984009,
0.34143903851509094,
-0.4573984146118164,
0.2201204150915146,
0.3037932217121124,
0.22721192240715027,
-0.3237488865852356,
0.1710284948348999,
-0.29455146193504333,
-0.15764014422893524,
0.5509806871414185,
0.21110501885414124,
0.5496561527252197,
0.12900219857692719,
-0.4359101951122284,
-0.21545971930027008,
-0.5842934250831604,
0.12974397838115692,
0.6512384414672852,
0.20736682415008545,
-0.054273150861263275,
0.49600091576576233,
0.4377695918083191,
0.18104258179664612,
0.1201433315873146,
-0.0050014108419418335,
-0.0834331214427948,
0.11848008632659912,
-0.12446929514408112,
-0.11627094447612762,
0.9877434372901917,
0.2837369441986084,
0.3240467309951782,
-0.04710876941680908,
-0.2872340679168701,
0.2832280397415161,
0.3925832509994507,
-0.5993653535842896,
0.07387040555477142,
0.21360254287719727,
-0.5971437096595764,
-0.28620508313179016,
0.06440874934196472,
-0.9214705228805542,
-0.8411774039268494,
0.03724352642893791,
0.6590516567230225,
-0.2617511451244354,
-0.37258702516555786,
-0.16346167027950287,
-0.21597757935523987,
0.19568213820457458,
0.2505139410495758,
-0.8669279217720032,
0.7635190486907959,
0.9526877403259277,
0.7102635502815247,
-0.28099778294563293,
-0.5767087340354919,
-0.4836491346359253,
-0.3218914270401001,
-0.5343385934829712,
0.7136260271072388,
-0.6008716225624084,
-0.737476646900177,
-0.03741331771016121,
-0.3282327950000763,
0.001645134761929512,
-0.6964253187179565,
0.3153779208660126,
-0.2762145698070526,
0.4560543894767761,
0.03956133872270584,
-0.7255082130432129,
0.015824172645807266,
0.2256602644920349,
-0.7873083353042603,
0.7795891165733337,
-0.01828332617878914,
-0.3531007766723633,
0.10003162175416946,
-0.8222152590751648,
-0.23829934000968933,
0.051742926239967346,
-0.4289126694202423,
-0.48864537477493286,
0.2344050407409668,
0.3036388158798218,
0.47093236446380615,
-0.5038911700248718,
-0.09409637004137039,
-0.3516310751438141,
-1.037485122680664,
0.4572739005088806,
-0.9423123598098755,
0.49190303683280945,
0.045856114476919174,
-0.6616861820220947,
0.10621708631515503,
-0.07837331295013428,
0.011134177446365356,
-0.014166954904794693,
-0.1213303729891777,
0.07825490832328796,
0.28646859526634216,
-0.059197455644607544,
-0.05324212834239006,
-0.034529514610767365,
-0.4031757116317749,
0.056548383086919785,
-0.10607938468456268,
0.32648003101348877,
0.7682788968086243,
0.027610773220658302,
0.16581378877162933,
-0.6535147428512573,
1.0282204151153564,
-0.4836612641811371,
0.06397179514169693,
-0.29155540466308594,
-0.8198617696762085,
-0.4178066551685333,
-0.7053186297416687,
0.220905140042305,
0.607977032661438,
-0.577996551990509,
0.48361942172050476,
-0.21652069687843323,
-0.3988356590270996,
-1.0355720520019531,
0.018764745444059372,
0.3509933650493622,
0.11017143726348877,
0.20438259840011597,
-0.2589409053325653,
-0.6182596683502197,
-0.7990291714668274,
-0.3115694522857666,
-0.6236618757247925,
-0.5024940371513367,
0.5545063018798828,
0.28874677419662476,
-0.2955852448940277,
0.7286423444747925,
-0.03314140811562538,
-0.2757003605365753,
-0.45637884736061096,
0.1987844556570053,
0.03847140073776245,
0.012475315481424332,
0.23007266223430634,
-0.5693027973175049,
-0.39791053533554077,
-0.23124471306800842,
-0.7171425819396973,
-0.20531897246837616,
-0.38566917181015015,
0.14194631576538086,
0.10635755956172943,
0.19202181696891785,
-0.6559511423110962,
0.44471243023872375,
0.8083057403564453,
-0.31501099467277527,
0.3254393935203552,
-0.3582233190536499,
0.6011562347412109,
-1.067001461982727,
0.15017127990722656,
-0.34351566433906555,
-0.3182065486907959,
-0.3173370659351349,
-0.02242632582783699,
-0.44309377670288086,
-0.1615041196346283,
-0.2241509109735489,
0.5103357434272766,
-0.38385432958602905,
-0.38136154413223267,
-0.30245324969291687,
0.21871338784694672,
-0.2232462763786316,
0.32282862067222595,
-0.09295540302991867,
0.9651728868484497,
0.3863113522529602,
-0.31346291303634644,
0.3124183416366577,
0.008825271390378475,
-0.38422295451164246,
0.4959924519062042,
-0.6702678799629211,
0.3819583058357239,
0.18359428644180298,
0.41321107745170593,
-1.1171207427978516,
-0.1771155744791031,
0.3262188136577606,
-0.6034830212593079,
0.033287543803453445,
-0.23234353959560394,
-0.6121851205825806,
-0.345699667930603,
-0.42406243085861206,
0.008234964683651924,
1.2134883403778076,
-0.5813558101654053,
0.8258680105209351,
0.5284684300422668,
-0.04555048793554306,
-0.353812038898468,
-0.3733423352241516,
0.27446088194847107,
-0.42685264348983765,
-0.28203439712524414,
-0.04093227908015251,
-0.17515243589878082,
-0.3127276301383972,
-0.18921087682247162,
0.0767136961221695,
-0.15365761518478394,
0.3458816111087799,
0.4312777817249298,
0.2864467203617096,
-0.19233790040016174,
-0.10613570362329483,
-0.3135848045349121,
-0.0332193449139595,
0.06988687813282013,
0.08617661893367767,
0.6574676036834717,
-0.25200456380844116,
-0.7947739362716675,
-0.7711988091468811,
0.2881559133529663,
0.5843815803527832,
0.020279033109545708,
0.09068161994218826,
0.5933929085731506,
-0.16973894834518433,
-0.12948381900787354,
-0.5489694476127625,
-0.3803226947784424,
-0.4800761044025421,
0.40757158398628235,
-0.16755293309688568,
-0.8100323677062988,
0.4979819059371948,
-0.11123642325401306,
0.14334292709827423,
0.16473954916000366,
0.4229591190814972,
-0.5040897130966187,
1.1942046880722046,
0.17809748649597168,
-0.3018897771835327,
0.3516630530357361,
-0.09106031805276871,
0.03714706376194954,
-0.6845999360084534,
0.25509896874427795,
-0.27450135350227356,
-0.5862843990325928,
-0.8572379946708679,
-0.587551474571228,
0.34764164686203003,
0.04257676750421524,
-0.09586174786090851,
0.07190938293933868,
-0.3756833076477051,
0.6093615889549255,
0.5972915291786194,
0.10099121183156967,
0.20211416482925415,
0.0013751797378063202,
0.3528735637664795,
-0.1207275390625,
-0.35235321521759033,
-0.8023577332496643,
1.1323578357696533,
0.5250857472419739,
0.7453333735466003,
0.1026415079832077,
0.9974498152732849,
0.6085721254348755,
0.5809136033058167,
-0.6524233818054199,
0.6354023814201355,
-0.027732301503419876,
-0.6007416248321533,
-0.43400418758392334,
-0.3709472119808197,
-1.213836431503296,
0.2505527138710022,
-0.29408395290374756,
-0.7689694762229919,
-0.49440404772758484,
0.2866509258747101,
-0.23145122826099396,
0.5203143954277039,
-0.6856130361557007,
0.553002655506134,
-0.29505494236946106,
-0.19000083208084106,
-0.2383909970521927,
-0.23291830718517303,
0.11579155921936035,
-0.067336305975914,
0.25736427307128906,
-0.10802158713340759,
-0.21279504895210266,
0.4181889295578003,
0.0613270178437233,
1.1603622436523438,
-0.16224686801433563,
-0.04957624152302742,
0.6718162298202515,
0.4435732960700989,
0.3008110523223877,
-0.05567777529358864,
0.029441414400935173,
0.39558687806129456,
-0.12908419966697693,
-0.2124747633934021,
-0.8205950856208801,
0.5040311813354492,
-0.7950889468193054,
-0.7817527651786804,
-0.27873820066452026,
-0.20221871137619019,
-0.17187316715717316,
0.1428556740283966,
0.007313551381230354,
0.170559361577034,
-0.6720417141914368,
0.22861264646053314,
0.29447677731513977,
-0.13521794974803925,
0.41434377431869507,
0.3030868470668793,
-0.40393587946891785,
-0.36315932869911194,
1.024242877960205,
-0.3961542844772339,
0.1834593266248703,
0.31001055240631104,
0.38140538334846497,
-0.24626298248767853,
-0.3075059950351715,
-0.5044572949409485,
0.04807164520025253,
-0.2716023623943329,
0.11532082408666611,
-0.251925528049469,
-0.1360088437795639,
-0.1510268598794937,
-0.05543120950460434,
-0.31847307085990906,
-0.06862780451774597,
-0.23150534927845,
0.048155494034290314,
0.13335278630256653,
1.2130333185195923,
-0.06124478578567505,
0.1959255039691925,
-0.7009052634239197,
0.39644962549209595,
0.4578852355480194,
0.3876234292984009,
-0.11054842174053192,
-0.4070652723312378,
0.2512652575969696,
0.2681487202644348,
-0.3313056528568268,
-0.763947606086731,
0.2225062996149063,
0.17328543961048126,
0.7206675410270691,
0.276015043258667,
-0.14570699632167816,
0.7213616371154785,
-0.5957654714584351,
1.1564241647720337,
-0.08721651136875153,
-1.0046844482421875,
0.07692918926477432,
-0.4348530173301697,
0.043003857135772705,
0.3310013711452484,
0.2120908796787262,
-0.6410453915596008,
-0.5470524430274963,
-0.8221237659454346,
-0.41579508781433105,
0.5202459096908569,
0.5164086818695068,
0.38683202862739563,
-0.07999059557914734,
0.09707816690206528,
0.1469935029745102,
0.17306435108184814,
-0.4016836881637573,
-0.10287830233573914,
0.012749423272907734,
-0.36899304389953613,
-0.34039267897605896,
0.019449256360530853,
0.004178015980869532,
0.2700013518333435,
0.18831709027290344,
-0.08742906153202057,
0.6833069920539856,
0.14225544035434723,
0.1321464627981186,
-0.04560057446360588,
0.09161905944347382,
0.5781217217445374,
0.2885251045227051,
-0.009521442465484142,
0.2031880021095276,
0.16693691909313202,
-0.5831435918807983,
-0.01210473757237196,
-0.015990443527698517,
0.06406088173389435,
-0.12383455038070679,
0.8064401149749756,
0.5314420461654663,
0.34463638067245483,
-0.9119861125946045,
0.614983081817627,
-0.26712262630462646,
-0.09823689609766006,
-0.31869909167289734,
0.25461700558662415,
0.30067527294158936,
0.44037213921546936,
0.2716659903526306,
-0.07056016474962234,
0.1339382380247116,
-0.6628638505935669,
0.27949419617652893,
0.4563608169555664,
-0.35093602538108826,
-0.4645410180091858,
0.6812715530395508,
0.30352044105529785,
-1.0043307542800903,
0.644862711429596,
-0.019663972780108452,
-0.6133259534835815,
0.7854887843132019,
0.6706560850143433,
1.0276612043380737,
-0.23555536568164825,
0.20588147640228271,
-0.01566803827881813,
0.19423697888851166,
-0.18361465632915497,
0.36107513308525085,
-0.07108930498361588,
-0.6417569518089294,
-0.09140879660844803,
-0.07457523792982101,
-0.7881201505661011,
0.1161787211894989,
-0.4649454355239868,
0.18380895256996155,
-0.44210168719291687,
-0.254092276096344,
-0.3532734215259552,
0.015284929424524307,
-0.7723935842514038,
-0.22063376009464264,
0.42805665731430054,
0.4286312162876129,
-0.585277259349823,
0.48858603835105896,
0.3249702453613281,
-0.3534714877605438,
-0.5443195104598999,
0.25963181257247925,
0.05204673483967781,
-0.9948980212211609,
0.32326310873031616,
0.1507205069065094,
-0.3735591173171997,
0.09837239235639572,
-0.5429067015647888,
-0.47291842103004456,
1.1230907440185547,
0.3472284972667694,
-0.30547183752059937,
0.012509661726653576,
0.22107256948947906,
0.9676162600517273,
-0.5597810745239258,
0.8531281352043152,
0.3854730427265167,
0.233289435505867,
-0.10588923841714859,
-1.1307543516159058,
-0.27544105052948,
-0.0933525487780571,
-0.12403000891208649,
-0.11808586865663528,
-0.5524592399597168,
0.5666179656982422,
-0.1921372413635254,
-0.2684810161590576,
0.27440038323402405,
0.3202681243419647,
0.4331103265285492,
0.2469266653060913,
0.7140296101570129,
-0.004425580147653818,
0.8444981575012207,
0.11676274240016937,
1.1976045370101929,
-0.30410054326057434,
0.21375294029712677,
1.0667181015014648,
-0.3685207664966583,
1.1633356809616089,
0.46489423513412476,
-0.2693139314651489,
0.4261207580566406,
0.5051388144493103,
-0.09989013522863388,
0.2552427053451538,
0.38092124462127686,
-0.14005500078201294,
-0.23365385830402374,
0.14565667510032654,
-0.057154715061187744,
0.6760557889938354,
0.38796958327293396,
-0.3917975425720215,
0.08063854277133942,
-0.16678732633590698,
-0.02313624694943428,
0.18157657980918884,
0.09930870682001114,
0.8542227149009705,
-0.009332035668194294,
-0.637839674949646,
0.3951055407524109,
-0.44167888164520264,
0.6521177887916565,
-0.6044626832008362,
-0.5364299416542053,
-0.1775815188884735,
0.16727705299854279,
0.17195209860801697,
-0.7901231050491333,
-0.10165395587682724,
0.2070544809103012,
0.19469116628170013,
-0.3665105998516083,
0.3577532470226288,
-0.2404041290283203,
-0.3334500789642334,
0.40252065658569336,
0.623660683631897,
0.6447402238845825,
-0.0054877689108252525,
-0.6452767848968506,
0.3630240261554718,
0.02720165252685547,
-0.13543391227722168,
0.10851208120584488,
0.053940024226903915,
0.029923684895038605,
0.6004809737205505,
0.6283566951751709,
0.1368246227502823,
-0.2329021543264389,
0.03783819451928139,
0.3891851007938385,
-0.49602949619293213,
-0.42569735646247864,
-0.9611200094223022,
0.37089574337005615,
-0.201344296336174,
-0.4692607522010803,
0.5875284671783447,
0.6693189144134521,
0.562045693397522,
-0.009842948988080025,
0.9902584552764893,
0.25744956731796265,
0.6548678874969482,
-0.25841474533081055,
0.7636537551879883,
-0.25843119621276855,
0.46130526065826416,
-0.33307594060897827,
-0.9136208295822144,
-0.04659572243690491,
0.5301067233085632,
0.08203346282243729,
0.23065657913684845,
0.39787402749061584,
0.6748114228248596,
-0.12530843913555145,
0.2048981934785843,
0.6922409534454346,
0.1199905201792717,
0.6286183595657349,
0.5115622282028198,
1.318648099899292,
-0.3204025626182556,
0.515743613243103,
0.11760138720273972,
-0.32008135318756104,
-0.16153815388679504,
-0.647737979888916,
-1.101790189743042,
-0.49220001697540283,
0.0807189792394638,
-0.2596289813518524,
0.14904524385929108,
1.2188782691955566,
0.6472100019454956,
-0.3975953459739685,
-0.6020434498786926,
0.13186973333358765,
0.014944502152502537,
-0.3634262979030609,
-0.17240236699581146,
0.24039126932621002,
-0.13077914714813232,
-1.072450041770935,
0.6231912970542908,
-0.08117597550153732,
0.03582749143242836,
-0.5439462065696716,
-0.22115735709667206,
0.3538081645965576,
0.3579561412334442,
0.33942708373069763,
0.24830855429172516,
-1.0672411918640137,
-0.43573200702667236,
0.23465897142887115,
-0.2510553300380707,
0.09223543852567673,
0.8971650004386902,
-0.7795655727386475,
0.5732346773147583,
0.28747498989105225,
0.8649954795837402,
0.20642994344234467,
0.19035980105400085,
0.8352231979370117,
-0.32227861881256104,
-0.20054134726524353,
0.4638112187385559,
0.15867094695568085,
0.25052210688591003,
-0.33205533027648926,
0.49164190888404846,
0.007290197070688009,
-0.5863338112831116,
-0.6555635333061218,
0.06148034334182739,
-0.5888407826423645,
-0.006580461282283068,
1.2260774374008179,
-0.22850479185581207,
-0.10764341056346893,
-0.014133711345493793,
-0.43722981214523315,
0.02263665199279785,
-0.5278414487838745,
1.1514033079147339,
0.7144134044647217,
-0.47314730286598206,
-0.07759982347488403,
-0.49013328552246094,
0.5393220782279968,
0.1602466106414795,
-0.8802786469459534,
-0.042792849242687225,
0.35382500290870667,
0.12998925149440765,
0.0812745913863182,
0.7953066825866699,
0.06835958361625671,
0.26668494939804077,
0.23975059390068054,
0.18854530155658722,
0.040825605392456055,
-0.0014833502937108278,
-0.49371615052223206,
-0.08135969191789627,
0.1394014209508896,
-0.3272519111633301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13948v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13948v1
|
Typos that Broke the RAG's Back: Genetic Attack on RAG Pipeline by Simulating Documents in the Wild via Low-level Perturbations
| 2024-04-22T07:49:36 | 2024-04-22T07:49:36 |
Sukmin Cho, Soyeong Jeong, Jeongyeon Seo, Taeho Hwang, Jong C. Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The robustness of recent Large Language Models (LLMs) has become increasingly
crucial as their applicability expands across various domains and real-world
applications. Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) is a promising solution for
addressing the limitations of LLMs, yet existing studies on the robustness of
RAG often overlook the interconnected relationships between RAG components or
the potential threats prevalent in real-world databases, such as minor textual
errors. In this work, we investigate two underexplored aspects when assessing
the robustness of RAG: 1) vulnerability to noisy documents through low-level
perturbations and 2) a holistic evaluation of RAG robustness. Furthermore, we
introduce a novel attack method, the Genetic Attack on RAG (\textit{GARAG}),
which targets these aspects. Specifically, GARAG is designed to reveal
vulnerabilities within each component and test the overall system functionality
against noisy documents. We validate RAG robustness by applying our
\textit{GARAG} to standard QA datasets, incorporating diverse retrievers and
LLMs. The experimental results show that GARAG consistently achieves high
attack success rates. Also, it significantly devastates the performance of each
component and their synergy, highlighting the substantial risk that minor
textual inaccuracies pose in disrupting RAG systems in the real world.
|
[
-0.3700551688671112,
-1.0440583229064941,
0.3003677725791931,
-0.2118426263332367,
-0.07804550230503082,
0.6008914709091187,
0.14055988192558289,
-0.634136974811554,
0.2885764241218567,
0.5499007701873779,
-0.3346855044364929,
-0.26335853338241577,
-0.6723207831382751,
0.16739752888679504,
-0.6020416021347046,
1.1261729001998901,
0.23005948960781097,
-0.24177399277687073,
-0.016555745154619217,
-0.23380662500858307,
-0.29784104228019714,
-0.7870639562606812,
-0.6097384095191956,
0.02767922729253769,
0.5623534321784973,
0.25362738966941833,
0.8127116560935974,
0.39480504393577576,
0.5722620487213135,
0.19312863051891327,
-0.4320591688156128,
0.10194484889507294,
-0.7392616868019104,
0.7383658289909363,
-0.027232469990849495,
-0.560640811920166,
-0.6157905459403992,
-0.18477128446102142,
0.5650167465209961,
0.2163299024105072,
-0.0028713797219097614,
0.38807418942451477,
0.26618561148643494,
0.5973981618881226,
-0.7988823652267456,
-0.5029852986335754,
-0.9998456239700317,
0.06075248122215271,
-0.8560748100280762,
-0.36431393027305603,
-0.3356211185455322,
-0.00027150873211212456,
-0.43484291434288025,
-0.3678092658519745,
0.4895579218864441,
0.1701388657093048,
1.2704174518585205,
0.5279455184936523,
0.032742373645305634,
-0.4307885468006134,
-0.8427225947380066,
0.6463481783866882,
-0.5390387177467346,
0.17731252312660217,
0.48134469985961914,
0.40798211097717285,
-0.6175783276557922,
-0.7526037096977234,
-0.6359972953796387,
-0.2860412001609802,
-0.03258421644568443,
-0.01632058247923851,
-0.29531049728393555,
-0.13422176241874695,
0.522732138633728,
0.5992558002471924,
-0.7146094441413879,
0.1257561892271042,
-0.2909834682941437,
-0.06236822530627251,
0.33427944779396057,
0.12261032313108444,
0.6397952437400818,
-0.39506757259368896,
-0.22465160489082336,
-0.3192296624183655,
-0.7103093266487122,
-0.012258113361895084,
0.7787436842918396,
0.2564500868320465,
-0.0273833516985178,
0.7125745415687561,
0.07874170690774918,
0.5270294547080994,
0.3078344762325287,
-0.14658774435520172,
-0.014662708155810833,
-0.4581175148487091,
-0.28891298174858093,
-0.27854466438293457,
0.7933241724967957,
-0.2310323566198349,
0.04376852139830589,
-0.34036222100257874,
-0.25196510553359985,
0.1024547666311264,
0.6661678552627563,
-0.3856599032878876,
0.06583299487829208,
0.35825568437576294,
-0.1791420429944992,
-1.0017800331115723,
-0.000662228325381875,
-1.2883374691009521,
-0.736386239528656,
0.6247826814651489,
0.3503129780292511,
-0.28732436895370483,
0.08274572342634201,
-0.09345497190952301,
-0.21753382682800293,
0.45526307821273804,
-0.12222891300916672,
-0.8068978786468506,
0.17801746726036072,
0.8971773982048035,
0.6946805119514465,
0.05639725178480148,
-0.21733391284942627,
-0.8971824049949646,
0.2730937898159027,
-0.17688147723674774,
0.9383078813552856,
-0.5645655393600464,
-0.667114794254303,
-0.38292601704597473,
-0.2706880569458008,
-0.15872782468795776,
-0.6001186966896057,
0.96506667137146,
-0.5469696521759033,
0.19992056488990784,
-0.028780577704310417,
-0.14933592081069946,
0.21162985265254974,
0.37042707204818726,
-0.7804688215255737,
1.0966328382492065,
0.25962868332862854,
-1.2086073160171509,
0.36475613713264465,
-0.2749600410461426,
-0.40284356474876404,
-0.09169327467679977,
-0.2108321338891983,
-0.6903024911880493,
0.16414067149162292,
0.10662355273962021,
0.19954685866832733,
-0.21039648354053497,
-0.18571339547634125,
-0.48312798142433167,
-0.37742653489112854,
0.20396259427070618,
-0.4257749915122986,
0.8323365449905396,
0.10379030555486679,
-0.3537876307964325,
-0.21169373393058777,
-0.7920657992362976,
0.08332552760839462,
0.3454180061817169,
-0.3309204578399658,
-0.6032984852790833,
-0.11274371296167374,
-0.36779531836509705,
0.017852846533060074,
0.03175034373998642,
-0.28547582030296326,
0.3745349943637848,
-0.5453333854675293,
-0.012234097346663475,
0.49167126417160034,
0.2859559655189514,
0.4943152666091919,
-0.6412577629089355,
1.0115447044372559,
-0.34653240442276,
0.14875827729701996,
0.040925174951553345,
-0.4757876396179199,
-0.5026121139526367,
-0.29571616649627686,
0.49835240840911865,
0.7325169444084167,
-0.7806582450866699,
-0.030520698055624962,
-0.21705561876296997,
-0.5673023462295532,
-0.4632549285888672,
0.18898002803325653,
0.4875932037830353,
0.5985859632492065,
0.3065500855445862,
-0.2080301195383072,
-0.5590829253196716,
-0.5343540906906128,
-0.6177511811256409,
-0.19095468521118164,
-0.047492533922195435,
0.16655194759368896,
0.32299214601516724,
-0.5510371923446655,
0.6489447355270386,
-0.17431065440177917,
-0.17286249995231628,
-0.13680227100849152,
0.28489917516708374,
0.17643019556999207,
0.30528032779693604,
0.737737238407135,
-0.5969579219818115,
-0.34775209426879883,
0.033654067665338516,
-0.6539424657821655,
-0.2794899344444275,
0.03714054450392723,
-0.0905158594250679,
0.4415735602378845,
0.39853912591934204,
-0.6379675269126892,
0.6342419981956482,
0.7849387526512146,
-0.2403351366519928,
0.9060141444206238,
-0.19412747025489807,
0.05776402726769447,
-0.9588689804077148,
0.13247235119342804,
-0.24643917381763458,
0.009669630788266659,
-0.7001657485961914,
0.5773821473121643,
-0.20473229885101318,
-0.02345670573413372,
-0.0660906508564949,
0.5041508674621582,
-0.36550232768058777,
-0.15437942743301392,
-0.08217436075210571,
-0.27085262537002563,
0.046579137444496155,
0.08418489992618561,
-0.8053699135780334,
1.0262703895568848,
0.18922576308250427,
-0.3552943766117096,
0.01658341847360134,
0.23563452064990997,
0.18284854292869568,
0.5910398364067078,
-0.6791049838066101,
0.4176218509674072,
-0.0828724205493927,
0.32371604442596436,
-0.6148517727851868,
-0.5788443684577942,
0.43459492921829224,
-0.7272595763206482,
0.8351348638534546,
-0.43052446842193604,
-0.5615264177322388,
-0.17686206102371216,
-0.5529112815856934,
0.18014933168888092,
0.43684467673301697,
-0.40672188997268677,
0.7332148551940918,
0.5676753520965576,
-0.2992144525051117,
-0.7768641710281372,
-0.575648844242096,
0.39609482884407043,
-0.5019564032554626,
-0.8658336400985718,
0.0766158401966095,
0.2591160535812378,
-0.46137991547584534,
-0.09758423268795013,
-0.2968892753124237,
-0.18912778794765472,
0.40624499320983887,
0.25603652000427246,
0.25466614961624146,
-0.08285093307495117,
-0.2941870093345642,
-0.04844195023179054,
-0.12512096762657166,
-0.05232059583067894,
-0.03854946792125702,
0.5138877034187317,
-0.11968166381120682,
-0.35081562399864197,
0.12489742785692215,
0.2917596399784088,
0.7918993830680847,
-0.276478111743927,
0.43200331926345825,
0.5224192142486572,
-0.2996169328689575,
-0.5088110566139221,
-0.36593693494796753,
-0.07092824578285217,
-0.49655771255493164,
0.2757505476474762,
-0.1979784369468689,
-0.6571676135063171,
0.4439524710178375,
0.14570710062980652,
-0.026956534013152122,
0.46050208806991577,
0.2649432420730591,
-0.48837751150131226,
0.7561424970626831,
0.50875324010849,
0.057695526629686356,
0.05353682488203049,
-0.2271823137998581,
0.15096810460090637,
-0.924034059047699,
0.030011512339115143,
-0.9997550845146179,
-0.25222527980804443,
-0.8729970455169678,
-0.6621779799461365,
0.5019257068634033,
0.2774507403373718,
-0.18947561085224152,
0.22845713794231415,
-0.3188380300998688,
0.39018958806991577,
0.47506454586982727,
-0.20453320443630219,
0.4013911783695221,
0.14347529411315918,
-0.31528201699256897,
-0.07998865097761154,
-0.853739857673645,
-0.7057427763938904,
1.0431228876113892,
0.3294561803340912,
1.0459189414978027,
0.10400548577308655,
0.8288668990135193,
0.2353297472000122,
0.09248662739992142,
-0.5367244482040405,
0.28298723697662354,
-0.5643251538276672,
-0.6429465413093567,
-0.20954760909080505,
-0.3814612329006195,
-1.1152571439743042,
0.02749398909509182,
-0.539004385471344,
-0.8045496940612793,
0.3233833312988281,
0.25528424978256226,
-0.37655943632125854,
0.5053690671920776,
-0.4856615364551544,
0.44281867146492004,
-0.3749319314956665,
-0.42412373423576355,
0.058158911764621735,
-0.6691277027130127,
0.5504505038261414,
-0.5623303055763245,
0.3893422484397888,
0.33773481845855713,
0.16051815450191498,
0.30392929911613464,
-0.42875951528549194,
0.6826292872428894,
0.09658843278884888,
-0.10545170307159424,
0.028405368328094482,
0.3745920956134796,
0.7852337956428528,
-0.08486121892929077,
-0.007347424514591694,
0.10552742332220078,
-0.1272243857383728,
-0.43558308482170105,
-0.5030732750892639,
0.48213204741477966,
-0.42683762311935425,
-0.5873427391052246,
-0.6859830021858215,
-0.32596462965011597,
-0.5779982805252075,
0.035853639245033264,
0.5368495583534241,
0.21039359271526337,
-0.020910006016492844,
0.06853244453668594,
0.7856137752532959,
-0.4954434335231781,
0.10754862427711487,
0.10523270070552826,
-0.16907289624214172,
-0.28482380509376526,
1.050305962562561,
0.18971925973892212,
0.420315146446228,
0.0733158141374588,
0.11243753880262375,
0.07469481229782104,
-0.641463577747345,
-0.4255330562591553,
0.17280268669128418,
-0.38621771335601807,
-0.20017853379249573,
-0.6828736066818237,
-0.20453058183193207,
-0.1674237847328186,
-0.06597749143838882,
-0.13608385622501373,
-0.2980911135673523,
-0.15385299921035767,
0.028010783717036247,
0.09805306792259216,
0.923054575920105,
0.026751134544610977,
0.060975007712841034,
-0.9303476810455322,
0.5976330637931824,
0.47394388914108276,
0.2071802169084549,
-0.07783078402280807,
-0.550774335861206,
-0.04766387119889259,
0.07450827956199646,
-0.40821027755737305,
-1.0416138172149658,
0.35663938522338867,
0.11032833904027939,
0.5043053030967712,
-0.02703132852911949,
-0.01111555751413107,
0.4272804260253906,
-0.49189597368240356,
0.5769278407096863,
-0.3412216603755951,
-0.5761204957962036,
0.35133376717567444,
-0.7857106924057007,
0.10851825773715973,
0.530068039894104,
-0.03115992248058319,
-0.18857060372829437,
-1.0383416414260864,
-1.0520046949386597,
-1.0264848470687866,
0.1552203893661499,
0.21666219830513,
-0.0029604521114379168,
0.20747745037078857,
0.32178735733032227,
0.009433320723474026,
-0.06227268651127815,
-0.26132652163505554,
-0.18343818187713623,
-0.004267648793756962,
0.13719624280929565,
0.34842878580093384,
-0.5142558217048645,
-0.08368603140115738,
0.14081773161888123,
0.6727529168128967,
0.025026606395840645,
0.0356014110147953,
0.17368796467781067,
-0.05415801331400871,
-0.1654190868139267,
0.41871440410614014,
0.7439714670181274,
0.16773349046707153,
-0.12668295204639435,
-0.07269987463951111,
0.11833714693784714,
-0.9591059684753418,
0.13068297505378723,
0.09861785173416138,
-0.39574819803237915,
0.1475634127855301,
0.37838223576545715,
0.43693092465400696,
0.13727721571922302,
-0.4027598202228546,
0.20272468030452728,
-0.2900991439819336,
0.18019850552082062,
-0.11750763654708862,
0.09064753353595734,
-0.18395370244979858,
0.15092192590236664,
0.6351372599601746,
0.3091493248939514,
-0.029740361496806145,
-0.42912933230400085,
0.3016418218612671,
0.6631988883018494,
-0.05167398229241371,
-0.22999070584774017,
0.7985331416130066,
-0.15190762281417847,
-0.22898179292678833,
0.035912394523620605,
-0.307461142539978,
-0.6191205382347107,
0.610797643661499,
0.34428319334983826,
0.9473548531532288,
-0.07997389882802963,
0.17108359932899475,
0.07754841446876526,
0.6461468935012817,
-0.015856312587857246,
0.16887988150119781,
0.3531137704849243,
-0.43864595890045166,
-0.45827600359916687,
-0.8606345057487488,
-0.6213284134864807,
0.13284002244472504,
-0.5967110395431519,
0.1493682712316513,
-0.5100207924842834,
-0.3266085684299469,
-0.24158160388469696,
-0.12277219444513321,
-0.25821927189826965,
0.012230850756168365,
0.09775650501251221,
0.6885853409767151,
-0.3810570240020752,
0.6138466000556946,
0.7456099987030029,
-0.2839979827404022,
-0.8921995162963867,
0.5833948254585266,
0.1721356064081192,
-0.6738914847373962,
0.5630170702934265,
-0.37005653977394104,
-0.18411068618297577,
-0.273091584444046,
-0.536217987537384,
-0.7620551586151123,
0.9323827624320984,
0.6162909269332886,
-0.4134596586227417,
-0.24817197024822235,
-0.0044191814959049225,
0.5695130228996277,
0.2624925971031189,
-0.23039481043815613,
0.5116199851036072,
0.46195748448371887,
0.03067873604595661,
-0.9432982206344604,
-0.11911685019731522,
-0.12081298977136612,
-0.12839077413082123,
0.40661484003067017,
-0.4530225396156311,
0.8487676978111267,
-0.2744313180446625,
-0.49832645058631897,
0.27402007579803467,
0.3373541831970215,
0.6066079139709473,
0.27973246574401855,
0.31732410192489624,
0.9382172226905823,
1.0499516725540161,
-0.17359983921051025,
1.6163631677627563,
-0.25958025455474854,
0.2575223743915558,
1.2193397283554077,
-0.21707920730113983,
0.7777265906333923,
0.5048754215240479,
-0.08875097334384918,
0.35185733437538147,
0.10198356956243515,
0.0016685666050761938,
0.12650412321090698,
0.20721766352653503,
-0.22236338257789612,
0.30497831106185913,
0.1582566648721695,
-0.3851481080055237,
0.48999708890914917,
0.5275092720985413,
-0.1466647982597351,
-0.28627878427505493,
-0.13483554124832153,
0.382829487323761,
0.07261355966329575,
-0.14654622972011566,
0.6037729978561401,
0.024031270295381546,
-0.29310688376426697,
0.7055198550224304,
-0.14396747946739197,
0.89190274477005,
-0.5539872050285339,
0.058055803179740906,
-0.43366825580596924,
-0.08760935068130493,
-0.3245122730731964,
-0.4636203944683075,
0.6128561496734619,
0.484960675239563,
-0.18859195709228516,
0.05882532149553299,
1.1861070394515991,
-0.023922603577375412,
-0.4159623980522156,
0.1710311323404312,
0.5287951231002808,
-0.1832175850868225,
0.1369004100561142,
-0.35969871282577515,
0.35879814624786377,
-0.2652494013309479,
-0.15702351927757263,
0.5380200743675232,
0.4470040798187256,
-0.11305118352174759,
0.6055067181587219,
0.7638570666313171,
0.5741783976554871,
0.32106277346611023,
-0.31692254543304443,
0.8597920536994934,
-0.47235286235809326,
-0.19739703834056854,
-0.6291354894638062,
0.3203791677951813,
-0.0944909006357193,
-0.1903160810470581,
0.9164837002754211,
0.19363653659820557,
0.7095106840133667,
0.1714233011007309,
0.9445123672485352,
-0.16196928918361664,
0.7605895400047302,
-0.47072339057922363,
1.110730528831482,
-0.42288997769355774,
0.5731361508369446,
-0.4426099359989166,
-0.6402356624603271,
-0.25904518365859985,
0.2215864658355713,
-0.05197671428322792,
0.011788325384259224,
0.7498977184295654,
0.8045109510421753,
0.07544419169425964,
-0.2261265516281128,
0.2399667501449585,
0.6309671401977539,
0.3154769837856293,
0.23434953391551971,
0.765950083732605,
-0.3933752775192261,
0.667016863822937,
-0.18854036927223206,
-0.0964483693242073,
0.030147233977913857,
-0.8750813603401184,
-0.5778087377548218,
-0.25902268290519714,
0.04404745250940323,
-0.8080219626426697,
0.5771976113319397,
0.19208969175815582,
0.1366129368543625,
-0.6390857696533203,
0.050544094294309616,
0.124309241771698,
0.13633903861045837,
0.16145624220371246,
-0.2508000433444977,
0.08123332262039185,
-0.47670552134513855,
-0.5050373673439026,
0.48295632004737854,
0.31753283739089966,
0.20022882521152496,
-0.36173808574676514,
0.08899363875389099,
-0.06053760647773743,
0.0389111265540123,
0.1434796005487442,
0.8380626440048218,
-0.3084736168384552,
-0.2332366406917572,
0.138240784406662,
-0.415408194065094,
-0.12576086819171906,
0.6003533601760864,
-0.8090028762817383,
0.2677222192287445,
0.624758780002594,
0.9664446711540222,
0.09864719957113266,
0.15510740876197815,
0.7033268809318542,
-0.857367217540741,
0.08657515794038773,
0.48957008123397827,
0.25892242789268494,
0.3188582956790924,
-0.5919885635375977,
0.6208270192146301,
0.29707035422325134,
-0.6850267052650452,
-1.216463327407837,
0.19412991404533386,
-0.7782676815986633,
-0.14446420967578888,
1.2826430797576904,
0.12068866938352585,
-0.4019298255443573,
-0.19704142212867737,
-0.10545181483030319,
0.060280658304691315,
-0.05719948932528496,
0.9961175918579102,
0.5615216493606567,
0.2622060775756836,
0.26429393887519836,
-0.8976741433143616,
0.5513758063316345,
0.2970649003982544,
-0.7383188605308533,
-0.21974067389965057,
0.33462050557136536,
0.16317403316497803,
0.29895853996276855,
0.31574124097824097,
-0.35260483622550964,
0.3717505931854248,
0.07216237485408783,
-0.3857107162475586,
0.06409357488155365,
-0.05689411982893944,
-0.5291386246681213,
0.4357320964336395,
0.15158401429653168,
0.07811162620782852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13940v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13940v2
|
A User-Centric Benchmark for Evaluating Large Language Models
| 2024-04-22T07:32:03 | 2024-04-23T01:58:24 |
Jiayin Wang, Fengran Mo, Weizhi Ma, Peijie Sun, Min Zhang, Jian-Yun Nie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are essential tools to collaborate with users on
different tasks. Evaluating their performance to serve users' needs in
real-world scenarios is important. While many benchmarks have been created,
they mainly focus on specific predefined model abilities. Few have covered the
intended utilization of LLMs by real users. To address this oversight, we
propose benchmarking LLMs from a user perspective in both dataset construction
and evaluation designs. We first collect 1846 real-world use cases with 15 LLMs
from a user study with 712 participants from 23 countries. These self-reported
cases form the User Reported Scenarios(URS) dataset with a categorization of 7
user intents. Secondly, on this authentic multi-cultural dataset, we benchmark
10 LLM services on their efficacy in satisfying user needs. Thirdly, we show
that our benchmark scores align well with user-reported experience in LLM
interactions across diverse intents, both of which emphasize the overlook of
subjective scenarios. In conclusion, our study proposes to benchmark LLMs from
a user-centric perspective, aiming to facilitate evaluations that better
reflect real user needs. The benchmark dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/Alice1998/URS.
|
[
-0.3765784204006195,
-0.4552318751811981,
0.6279984712600708,
0.47032949328422546,
-0.09835635870695114,
0.12399666756391525,
-0.6740873456001282,
-0.4920993745326996,
-0.033573634922504425,
0.6024526357650757,
-0.3679650127887726,
-0.7256113886833191,
-0.2469410002231598,
0.21149148046970367,
-0.358026921749115,
0.47917675971984863,
-0.0164839718490839,
0.229836568236351,
-0.4716748297214508,
-0.2715774178504944,
-0.32006821036338806,
-0.6884709596633911,
-0.4656129479408264,
-0.4243720471858978,
0.6507922410964966,
0.4579111933708191,
0.5276777744293213,
0.44899246096611023,
0.425713449716568,
0.26676350831985474,
0.06108725443482399,
0.10141801089048386,
-0.5989389419555664,
0.3561578691005707,
-0.1914234310388565,
-0.19721847772598267,
-0.26193588972091675,
0.0791342630982399,
0.6745127439498901,
0.6798465847969055,
-0.28461626172065735,
0.4271315336227417,
0.0216299369931221,
0.34127774834632874,
-0.7408797144889832,
-0.06162577494978905,
-0.4703831374645233,
0.08197531849145889,
-0.24506282806396484,
0.07313711941242218,
-0.366536945104599,
-0.41743004322052,
0.02374926581978798,
-0.30079516768455505,
-0.31422126293182373,
0.20458346605300903,
0.5191451907157898,
-0.03736742585897446,
-0.5920253396034241,
-0.11858910322189331,
-0.5978996753692627,
0.8251508474349976,
-0.9048851132392883,
0.6928396224975586,
0.2076006978750229,
0.47682860493659973,
-0.3652607500553131,
-0.6029062271118164,
-0.39974984526634216,
-0.3795439898967743,
-0.09973147511482239,
-0.056114811450242996,
-0.05858374387025833,
-0.3202863037586212,
0.4036621153354645,
0.4213714301586151,
-0.535658597946167,
0.45990365743637085,
0.013142438605427742,
-0.24689631164073944,
0.7674118876457214,
0.40830519795417786,
0.19216516613960266,
-0.15282326936721802,
-0.41679608821868896,
0.05044543370604515,
-0.7711083292961121,
0.059607211500406265,
0.5030991435050964,
0.3432486653327942,
-0.36391907930374146,
0.601658046245575,
-0.36840954422950745,
0.5750111937522888,
-0.41177722811698914,
-0.2236783504486084,
0.5669037699699402,
-0.1340564787387848,
-0.12082169204950333,
-0.3971608877182007,
1.0063713788986206,
0.5423027276992798,
0.5643299221992493,
-0.3464430570602417,
-0.4515550434589386,
-0.31304463744163513,
0.2263931781053543,
-1.016432285308838,
0.150226891040802,
-0.09296248108148575,
-0.3611505329608917,
0.0917365625500679,
-0.1668008714914322,
-0.7016177177429199,
-0.5532438158988953,
-0.42320606112480164,
0.23050354421138763,
-0.07578249275684357,
-0.24612051248550415,
-0.04148224741220474,
0.4062642455101013,
0.029367143288254738,
0.12821891903877258,
-0.7708725929260254,
0.5910658836364746,
0.9068511724472046,
0.7580803036689758,
-0.41998499631881714,
-0.40227293968200684,
-0.6171966791152954,
-0.15846389532089233,
-0.1565266102552414,
0.7219023108482361,
-0.4723646938800812,
-0.4437743127346039,
0.22342422604560852,
-0.1634228527545929,
0.07469211518764496,
-0.7299304604530334,
0.8441269397735596,
-0.519448459148407,
0.008102362975478172,
-0.48891547322273254,
-0.6384457349777222,
-0.05366502329707146,
0.39549192786216736,
-0.48664867877960205,
1.125485897064209,
0.16031689941883087,
-0.48793160915374756,
0.4336285889148712,
-0.33559396862983704,
-0.5733430981636047,
0.3462560176849365,
-0.3715302646160126,
-0.22421598434448242,
0.28008797764778137,
-0.04933818429708481,
0.5845206379890442,
-0.7529538869857788,
0.3634450137615204,
-0.6031802296638489,
-0.45674994587898254,
0.3851056396961212,
-0.377081036567688,
0.48064085841178894,
0.39214521646499634,
0.07326760143041611,
0.2198340743780136,
-0.7451746463775635,
0.24270310997962952,
0.15970809757709503,
-0.3704458773136139,
-0.28526729345321655,
0.024370187893509865,
0.4901447892189026,
0.3472289443016052,
0.3852945566177368,
-0.6383326649665833,
0.10310795903205872,
-0.19371828436851501,
0.34021785855293274,
0.6173043847084045,
-0.27339646220207214,
0.03376604616641998,
-0.07822804898023605,
0.5395301580429077,
-0.18253561854362488,
0.15649136900901794,
-0.03450522944331169,
-0.10293027758598328,
-0.5502431392669678,
-0.42801645398139954,
0.23190179467201233,
0.2407698780298233,
-0.29441893100738525,
0.4755999445915222,
-0.4376441240310669,
-0.5402840375900269,
-0.4340757429599762,
0.4821877181529999,
0.457242488861084,
0.4573407769203186,
0.09242638945579529,
-0.5319815874099731,
-0.449660062789917,
-1.132497787475586,
-0.4480319023132324,
-0.16507752239704132,
-0.2856815457344055,
0.7468437552452087,
0.2568136751651764,
-0.2367052286863327,
0.867916464805603,
-0.30401182174682617,
-0.19768935441970825,
-0.2969677448272705,
-0.020771196112036705,
0.2849259078502655,
0.11744153499603271,
0.3387884795665741,
-0.5919135212898254,
-0.5499895215034485,
-0.050080422312021255,
-0.8484508395195007,
-0.4376588463783264,
0.2810015082359314,
0.08863802999258041,
0.3206873834133148,
0.3159621059894562,
-0.23138302564620972,
0.06081995368003845,
0.7905259132385254,
-0.2921322286128998,
0.46316730976104736,
-0.3202945291996002,
0.2994671165943146,
-0.9602481126785278,
0.26290640234947205,
0.15459465980529785,
-0.4128650426864624,
-0.35292088985443115,
-0.025765435770154,
0.3240525424480438,
-0.07163593173027039,
-0.5028590559959412,
0.7142854928970337,
-0.41214630007743835,
-0.6937388777732849,
-0.09726519137620926,
0.17386257648468018,
-0.15576273202896118,
0.2367490828037262,
-0.06487145274877548,
0.9651879668235779,
0.362369179725647,
-0.22037871181964874,
0.32360368967056274,
-0.021817412227392197,
-0.8942118883132935,
0.5560288429260254,
-0.7980717420578003,
0.2350507527589798,
0.3007031977176666,
0.1604626178741455,
-0.8949049115180969,
-0.03559180721640587,
0.018145861104130745,
0.07243023067712784,
-0.0757908970117569,
-0.23676501214504242,
-1.0539337396621704,
-0.37753909826278687,
-0.1775294989347458,
0.3701474666595459,
0.3966020941734314,
-0.6064510345458984,
0.6176590323448181,
0.38574039936065674,
0.04063905403017998,
-0.2797160744667053,
-0.43285250663757324,
0.4061128795146942,
-0.5007786750793457,
-0.6577793955802917,
0.17481005191802979,
-0.22531647980213165,
-0.2914828360080719,
-0.07362578064203262,
-0.004171647131443024,
0.20212936401367188,
0.3809812366962433,
0.47708141803741455,
0.11522138118743896,
-0.2162301391363144,
-0.02733944170176983,
-0.4892173707485199,
-0.14620447158813477,
0.09423783421516418,
0.0899135172367096,
0.740109920501709,
-0.24424950778484344,
-0.5618734359741211,
-0.3293519914150238,
0.30691859126091003,
0.5843457579612732,
-0.3180071711540222,
0.5905874371528625,
0.5177805423736572,
-0.20484039187431335,
-0.15615062415599823,
-0.9848015904426575,
-0.03200795128941536,
-0.45332130789756775,
0.38089504837989807,
-0.6886323094367981,
-1.0025920867919922,
0.6476373076438904,
-0.17574046552181244,
0.16011394560337067,
0.06437186151742935,
0.7966951131820679,
0.04070955514907837,
0.7791471481323242,
0.5455218553543091,
-0.3347408175468445,
0.21832722425460815,
0.11601889133453369,
0.2583813965320587,
-0.9723060727119446,
-0.24820826947689056,
-0.513929545879364,
-0.1909838616847992,
-0.45751887559890747,
-0.2596941590309143,
0.3110690414905548,
0.05967603251338005,
-0.2946785092353821,
0.37532103061676025,
0.08060342818498611,
0.47804805636405945,
0.27811622619628906,
-0.31705528497695923,
0.4529058039188385,
0.019128335639834404,
-0.1639919877052307,
-0.20844101905822754,
-0.39071476459503174,
-0.7349255681037903,
1.233408808708191,
0.4538635313510895,
1.0372920036315918,
0.209414541721344,
0.6373662948608398,
0.4006672203540802,
0.5629792213439941,
-0.7564986348152161,
0.6531432867050171,
-0.15717336535453796,
-0.40583598613739014,
-0.1918002963066101,
-0.6297488212585449,
-0.8087349534034729,
0.5843483209609985,
-0.1945590376853943,
-0.9648428559303284,
-0.2965888977050781,
0.012136989273130894,
-0.16509775817394257,
0.024721816182136536,
-0.7375799417495728,
1.0305498838424683,
-0.6112232208251953,
-0.562897264957428,
-0.34178850054740906,
-0.17651750147342682,
0.20823799073696136,
-0.11892203986644745,
0.3398022949695587,
-0.49751177430152893,
-0.1734524518251419,
0.6255735754966736,
-0.07892333716154099,
0.6128777861595154,
-0.07599200308322906,
-0.19965024292469025,
-0.15244610607624054,
0.017800897359848022,
0.2997782230377197,
0.1903698444366455,
-0.4479947090148926,
0.40805965662002563,
-0.14742714166641235,
-0.16060702502727509,
-0.4638078510761261,
1.2210136651992798,
-0.7256524562835693,
-0.6395487189292908,
-0.27384260296821594,
-0.47060197591781616,
-0.5514354109764099,
0.25497326254844666,
-0.17461295425891876,
0.49308711290359497,
-0.4484347701072693,
0.3109455108642578,
0.32072627544403076,
-0.11234870553016663,
0.35820671916007996,
1.0415862798690796,
-0.6197899580001831,
-0.18185754120349884,
0.5356586575508118,
0.0674436166882515,
0.18962979316711426,
0.10411034524440765,
0.23184999823570251,
-0.45710262656211853,
-0.6642631888389587,
-0.6008173227310181,
0.2830277979373932,
-0.7344885468482971,
-0.04082471877336502,
-0.6578865647315979,
-0.007874295115470886,
-0.24895578622817993,
0.10268393158912659,
-0.49525943398475647,
0.0836072564125061,
-0.002227767836302519,
0.14496095478534698,
0.12014918774366379,
0.6157119870185852,
0.2674562633037567,
0.11665043234825134,
-0.5423082709312439,
0.2532089650630951,
0.19898317754268646,
0.7824257612228394,
0.22158698737621307,
-0.5645579099655151,
-0.33765923976898193,
-0.3058995008468628,
-0.04587144777178764,
-0.2647368013858795,
0.1521579474210739,
-0.05369581654667854,
0.8823360204696655,
0.308353066444397,
-0.05521848052740097,
0.5781958699226379,
-0.5431321263313293,
0.5887740850448608,
0.060629941523075104,
-0.8589191436767578,
0.11315879970788956,
-0.17712286114692688,
0.2684091627597809,
0.8779783248901367,
0.40725183486938477,
-0.9032788872718811,
-0.04874899983406067,
-0.15770474076271057,
-0.9105576872825623,
0.5699661374092102,
-0.018066029995679855,
0.25325679779052734,
0.09340289980173111,
0.2374112755060196,
0.1618148237466812,
0.11421683430671692,
-0.7180588841438293,
-0.2583445906639099,
0.2826358377933502,
-0.11954013258218765,
-0.37584778666496277,
-0.41823434829711914,
-0.05284172669053078,
0.10713642835617065,
0.45929619669914246,
-0.04743090271949768,
-0.3890283703804016,
-0.15761764347553253,
-0.2104179710149765,
-0.09851904958486557,
0.3712390661239624,
0.3271564841270447,
1.0590322017669678,
-0.266798734664917,
0.11706569045782089,
0.2367621213197708,
-0.07510019093751907,
0.019028378650546074,
0.1041836217045784,
-0.04611894488334656,
-0.37787580490112305,
0.36535051465034485,
0.5571615695953369,
0.4948267936706543,
-1.111700415611267,
0.544459342956543,
-0.4525564908981323,
0.20589597523212433,
-0.42389416694641113,
0.17892304062843323,
0.5272480845451355,
0.24743057787418365,
0.2438153624534607,
-0.4595004916191101,
0.18250790238380432,
-0.5153593420982361,
-0.055098384618759155,
0.49606508016586304,
-0.34014520049095154,
-0.29125356674194336,
0.3077602982521057,
0.33026501536369324,
-0.5797768831253052,
0.5137180685997009,
0.05040973424911499,
-0.26415136456489563,
0.19672852754592896,
0.5474647879600525,
0.8593653440475464,
-0.07326638698577881,
-0.13041901588439941,
0.29550737142562866,
0.060999441891908646,
-0.012284128926694393,
0.262302041053772,
-0.0844600647687912,
-0.6611407995223999,
-0.3820915222167969,
-0.6741711497306824,
-0.5012204051017761,
0.3507992923259735,
-0.6543231010437012,
0.32343384623527527,
-0.3635152578353882,
-0.08734463900327682,
0.04946831241250038,
0.22775694727897644,
-0.7725964784622192,
0.03409113734960556,
0.30983787775039673,
0.9943827986717224,
-0.8202195167541504,
0.816255509853363,
0.68946772813797,
0.03663840889930725,
-0.3853476941585541,
-0.08695916086435318,
0.09753723442554474,
-0.8879716992378235,
0.5478339195251465,
0.2539726495742798,
-0.22141698002815247,
-0.42721229791641235,
-0.1178748682141304,
-0.6134156584739685,
0.9151518940925598,
0.3304981291294098,
-0.9464293122291565,
0.6116700172424316,
0.3356471657752991,
0.743363082408905,
-0.6506870985031128,
0.3948904871940613,
0.6196402907371521,
0.4102016091346741,
-0.07691007107496262,
-0.9075778126716614,
0.06007424741983414,
-0.209209144115448,
0.19551528990268707,
0.12231665849685669,
-0.7933725118637085,
0.5346477031707764,
-0.007848480716347694,
-0.18755993247032166,
0.14553356170654297,
0.5524290204048157,
0.3673381805419922,
0.294842928647995,
0.7944623231887817,
0.5281376242637634,
0.41788241267204285,
0.18325145542621613,
1.082901954650879,
-0.3043966293334961,
0.19825854897499084,
1.2326512336730957,
-0.8336092829704285,
1.0050491094589233,
0.5116875767707825,
-0.28114911913871765,
0.11800365149974823,
0.42405709624290466,
-0.037738095968961716,
0.27713194489479065,
0.5861117839813232,
-0.2010875642299652,
-0.4609985947608948,
-0.3659648895263672,
-0.31979069113731384,
0.43725132942199707,
0.15535271167755127,
-0.15331880748271942,
-0.21077179908752441,
-0.20326252281665802,
0.07643434405326843,
0.4335981011390686,
0.013726764358580112,
0.8056938052177429,
0.18019917607307434,
-0.6292427778244019,
0.45871400833129883,
0.11091574281454086,
0.6518402695655823,
-0.6452604532241821,
0.3176021873950958,
-0.38598713278770447,
0.22159703075885773,
-0.13881425559520721,
-0.9400491714477539,
-0.04992113634943962,
0.3151357173919678,
-0.10566877573728561,
-0.22681781649589539,
0.35296630859375,
-0.18188539147377014,
-0.5601227879524231,
0.6309753656387329,
0.42935922741889954,
0.21186645328998566,
0.0718919187784195,
-0.4853675365447998,
0.6236947178840637,
-0.1343972086906433,
-0.47511422634124756,
0.565380334854126,
0.2763192355632782,
-0.1789425164461136,
0.8987375497817993,
0.4412309527397156,
0.1280684620141983,
-0.28934696316719055,
0.6696506142616272,
0.7782330513000488,
-0.6609607338905334,
-0.2432655394077301,
-0.8977692723274231,
0.12122815102338791,
-0.09563950449228287,
-0.5868291854858398,
1.064209222793579,
1.0103148221969604,
0.8779756426811218,
0.16150029003620148,
0.683642566204071,
0.10830985009670258,
0.5864782333374023,
-0.27617883682250977,
0.5803204774856567,
-0.6451164484024048,
0.49597883224487305,
-0.11642321199178696,
-1.0263659954071045,
-0.13620780408382416,
0.21581090986728668,
-0.4722270965576172,
0.12457568198442459,
0.1587517261505127,
0.6470222473144531,
-0.24074606597423553,
0.023696258664131165,
0.48859933018684387,
0.06454504281282425,
0.4574523866176605,
0.4146706759929657,
1.1037712097167969,
-0.09324730187654495,
0.17204701900482178,
-0.3103078305721283,
-0.13903656601905823,
-0.3187631070613861,
-1.0980489253997803,
-1.0568774938583374,
-0.40004387497901917,
-0.17342017590999603,
0.001895930035971105,
0.03822285681962967,
1.1242802143096924,
0.8545478582382202,
-0.7263476848602295,
-0.7010106444358826,
0.4894140958786011,
-0.044332195073366165,
0.06406915187835693,
-0.11744477599859238,
0.21624355018138885,
-0.20178964734077454,
-0.6160709857940674,
0.33684131503105164,
0.3610282242298126,
-0.1681668758392334,
-0.6540349125862122,
-0.22389444708824158,
0.10570810735225677,
-0.17784711718559265,
0.5906964540481567,
0.15473398566246033,
-0.8097975254058838,
-0.24971814453601837,
-0.11532012373209,
-0.21526645123958588,
-0.06686285883188248,
0.8935322761535645,
-0.6448241472244263,
0.31147775053977966,
0.2386881411075592,
0.6655846834182739,
0.6156018972396851,
-0.003410572651773691,
0.506957471370697,
-0.39377304911613464,
-0.06478000432252884,
0.09107356518507004,
0.4076496362686157,
0.6442887187004089,
-0.11503216624259949,
0.5930010676383972,
-0.24157720804214478,
-0.5423551797866821,
-0.910297155380249,
0.04470866918563843,
-0.9788634181022644,
0.03540122136473656,
1.18477463722229,
-0.5579320788383484,
0.06190279498696327,
-0.004132432397454977,
0.09978900849819183,
-0.26324978470802307,
-0.4432304799556732,
0.7074224352836609,
0.713742196559906,
0.10545267164707184,
0.09373826533555984,
-0.6249035596847534,
0.06187721714377403,
0.38350409269332886,
-0.8552955389022827,
0.44404637813568115,
0.4989796280860901,
0.514266312122345,
-0.28715768456459045,
0.4747070372104645,
-0.06446927785873413,
-0.08476525545120239,
-0.4653457701206207,
0.08084479719400406,
-0.1068890318274498,
-0.3039737641811371,
-0.3465113639831543,
0.13843639194965363,
0.39225858449935913,
0.28022390604019165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16068v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16068v1
|
SemEval-2024 Task 9: BRAINTEASER: A Novel Task Defying Common Sense
| 2024-04-22T07:21:27 | 2024-04-22T07:21:27 |
Yifan Jiang, Filip Ilievski, Kaixin Ma
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
While vertical thinking relies on logical and commonsense reasoning, lateral
thinking requires systems to defy commonsense associations and overwrite them
through unconventional thinking. Lateral thinking has been shown to be
challenging for current models but has received little attention. A recent
benchmark, BRAINTEASER, aims to evaluate current models' lateral thinking
ability in a zero-shot setting. In this paper, we split the original benchmark
to also support fine-tuning setting and present SemEval Task 9:
BRAIN-TEASER(S), the first task at this competition designed to test the
system's reasoning and lateral thinking ability. As a popular task,
BRAINTEASER(S)'s two subtasks receive 483 team submissions from 182
participants during the competition. This paper provides a fine-grained system
analysis of the competition results, together with a reflection on what this
means for the ability of the systems to reason laterally. We hope that the
BRAINTEASER(S) subtasks and findings in this paper can stimulate future work on
lateral thinking and robust reasoning by computational models.
|
[
-0.5383015275001526,
-0.8196961879730225,
0.6191990375518799,
0.1888093501329422,
-0.33842501044273376,
-0.08611235022544861,
0.118189238011837,
-0.4330320954322815,
0.13871662318706512,
0.3197490870952606,
-0.8841997385025024,
-0.3711714744567871,
-0.48734429478645325,
0.1441216766834259,
0.021142976358532906,
0.8196265697479248,
0.041853390634059906,
-0.07941050082445145,
-0.17278306186199188,
-0.572087287902832,
-1.1322575807571411,
-0.32484951615333557,
-0.6208464503288269,
-0.47640329599380493,
0.38263484835624695,
0.4127461314201355,
0.49905306100845337,
0.2578310966491699,
0.43230047821998596,
0.28035491704940796,
-0.09725967049598694,
-0.11508125811815262,
-0.41307350993156433,
0.30058085918426514,
-0.7953552007675171,
-0.3497980237007141,
-0.5863069891929626,
-0.15024079382419586,
0.3125821650028229,
0.6718080043792725,
0.07077498733997345,
0.27280864119529724,
-0.0010884145740419626,
0.7062161564826965,
-0.7056575417518616,
-0.18938854336738586,
-0.7884543538093567,
0.1739805042743683,
-0.24533763527870178,
-0.22063693404197693,
-0.19178295135498047,
-0.03337159380316734,
-0.11950822919607162,
-0.3370620608329773,
0.07392653822898865,
-0.1414201408624649,
0.7494504451751709,
0.6937817931175232,
-0.49938392639160156,
0.35316768288612366,
-0.20844867825508118,
0.7263063788414001,
-0.37024661898612976,
0.3933033347129822,
0.05474039539694786,
0.7581654787063599,
0.11188871413469315,
-0.34797555208206177,
-0.2623860239982605,
0.05223797634243965,
0.7161415219306946,
0.21742960810661316,
-0.4139852821826935,
-0.32806336879730225,
0.4120236039161682,
-0.20826418697834015,
-0.4962393641471863,
0.1535424292087555,
-0.6273707151412964,
-0.27282461524009705,
0.6864458918571472,
0.562846839427948,
0.19073884189128876,
0.10925085842609406,
-0.5275195837020874,
0.15020610392093658,
-0.48378023505210876,
0.41190850734710693,
0.008525963872671127,
-0.06983152031898499,
0.10818048566579819,
0.5941216945648193,
-0.5939830541610718,
0.4193607270717621,
0.23677708208560944,
0.4319390058517456,
0.3701143264770508,
-0.2892882525920868,
-0.3823748826980591,
0.0362197570502758,
0.2940485179424286,
0.6833731532096863,
0.09199773520231247,
-0.03446446359157562,
-0.3795354962348938,
0.5332353115081787,
0.2654392421245575,
-0.6492652297019958,
-0.24358327686786652,
0.3029627799987793,
-0.20522865653038025,
-0.2964054048061371,
-0.6530806422233582,
-0.5749595761299133,
-0.4721390902996063,
-0.3306053876876831,
0.7480118870735168,
-0.7418183088302612,
-0.0683186873793602,
0.37836402654647827,
-0.45671316981315613,
0.2754831314086914,
0.6469403505325317,
-0.4682990312576294,
0.2286398559808731,
0.8218442797660828,
0.5642040967941284,
-0.33202970027923584,
-0.5947814583778381,
-0.6639670729637146,
-0.1664501577615738,
-0.2614457905292511,
1.1585502624511719,
-0.3891235888004303,
0.023190414533019066,
-0.6365761160850525,
0.03011028654873371,
0.06782867014408112,
-0.38421908020973206,
0.5796161890029907,
-0.4629175066947937,
-0.264563649892807,
-0.8930137157440186,
-0.3249344527721405,
-0.2761381268501282,
0.690202534198761,
-0.41432705521583557,
0.6537028551101685,
-0.33694663643836975,
-0.6609314680099487,
0.6819690465927124,
-0.7133559584617615,
-0.3454647362232208,
0.48524075746536255,
-0.4482610523700714,
-0.05960773676633835,
0.04253658279776573,
0.3255024552345276,
0.3407520055770874,
-0.3314269781112671,
0.10117433965206146,
-0.5170972347259521,
-0.3314969837665558,
0.06883198767900467,
-0.19587573409080505,
1.2607039213180542,
0.07760559022426605,
-0.5127035975456238,
0.0854053720831871,
-0.5592463612556458,
0.1338951140642166,
0.2557591199874878,
0.09940720349550247,
-0.21599771082401276,
-0.19357655942440033,
-0.41706424951553345,
0.3019171953201294,
0.3101733326911926,
-0.6109870672225952,
0.1532997488975525,
-0.2844746708869934,
0.41845589876174927,
0.7532421946525574,
0.2349735051393509,
0.3928268253803253,
-0.27073875069618225,
0.5362908244132996,
0.29194480180740356,
0.1124168261885643,
0.02559310384094715,
-0.668899416923523,
-0.4874567985534668,
-0.13180109858512878,
0.14128971099853516,
0.7039737105369568,
-0.6296141147613525,
0.12549260258674622,
-0.0833519846200943,
-0.6492646932601929,
-0.15629667043685913,
-0.1752927452325821,
0.12618860602378845,
0.7282670140266418,
0.4362606406211853,
-0.3402857482433319,
-0.36178648471832275,
-1.2135273218154907,
-0.6968913674354553,
0.32427674531936646,
0.24556098878383636,
0.00015295048069674522,
0.9150944948196411,
-0.14863793551921844,
0.4459024965763092,
-0.41669413447380066,
-0.10181896388530731,
-0.1777806431055069,
0.3632294535636902,
0.20650069415569305,
0.4952305555343628,
0.3038419783115387,
-0.37186118960380554,
-0.03699105978012085,
-0.20749402046203613,
-0.7220926880836487,
-0.22819510102272034,
0.013824273832142353,
-0.1738308221101761,
0.23195090889930725,
0.48472273349761963,
-0.48414477705955505,
0.7359256148338318,
0.04622994363307953,
-0.6907778382301331,
0.5045859813690186,
-0.021641366183757782,
0.09842968732118607,
-0.3800298869609833,
0.1470329612493515,
-0.12291693687438965,
0.0890306681394577,
-0.5186206102371216,
0.17932391166687012,
0.08317553997039795,
-0.09266232699155807,
-0.3711793124675751,
0.47015297412872314,
-0.38959458470344543,
-0.07548250257968903,
-0.26925668120384216,
0.028706947341561317,
-0.029889864847064018,
0.49949246644973755,
0.001196385477669537,
0.5810772776603699,
0.42902952432632446,
-0.4997364282608032,
0.03636043891310692,
0.08623536676168442,
-0.3967150151729584,
0.7488755583763123,
-0.7544711828231812,
0.32274869084358215,
-0.4296102821826935,
0.19745922088623047,
-0.8585286736488342,
-0.0381661094725132,
-0.056706443428993225,
-0.5457995533943176,
-0.31654807925224304,
0.1684623658657074,
-0.14082464575767517,
-0.3986954987049103,
-0.11635715514421463,
0.4859825074672699,
0.4384963810443878,
-0.19346341490745544,
0.5514594912528992,
0.710896909236908,
-0.11499932408332825,
-0.638739287853241,
-0.8643930554389954,
0.0824117511510849,
-0.4330507814884186,
-0.7679586410522461,
0.24450571835041046,
0.0075951530598104,
-0.16543954610824585,
-0.1832069456577301,
-0.3305647075176239,
-0.16673097014427185,
0.35919779539108276,
0.10457634925842285,
0.19720959663391113,
-0.07027096301317215,
-0.15276303887367249,
0.28706392645835876,
-0.16049715876579285,
0.3828052878379822,
-0.09296281635761261,
0.24652615189552307,
-0.6344025731086731,
-0.4779638946056366,
-0.09753622859716415,
0.23880520462989807,
0.42625024914741516,
-0.30546897649765015,
0.3367755115032196,
0.3366311192512512,
-0.4931500554084778,
-0.48481133580207825,
-0.7041981220245361,
-0.21061065793037415,
-0.4084779918193817,
0.2629770040512085,
-0.771475613117218,
-0.9190511703491211,
0.6333500146865845,
0.10339085757732391,
-0.01876077987253666,
0.4819408059120178,
0.6978949308395386,
0.06521274894475937,
1.0915770530700684,
0.2669939398765564,
0.3322482109069824,
-0.32226598262786865,
-0.12542349100112915,
0.1525954306125641,
-0.573215663433075,
-0.39338400959968567,
-0.3423732817173004,
-0.8694626688957214,
-0.20751088857650757,
-0.5281501412391663,
0.4662719964981079,
0.06274548172950745,
-0.5422335863113403,
0.5618664622306824,
-0.867039680480957,
0.7509729862213135,
0.5110631585121155,
-0.0018885398749262094,
0.05188845098018646,
-0.30084535479545593,
-0.6651308536529541,
-0.2808447778224945,
-0.4947986602783203,
-0.2043706476688385,
0.6877257823944092,
0.23941802978515625,
0.25256040692329407,
0.15312527120113373,
0.686087429523468,
-0.012975776568055153,
-0.08373799175024033,
-0.6323183178901672,
1.1117488145828247,
0.2659602761268616,
-0.9305894374847412,
-0.4082396626472473,
-0.07810091227293015,
-0.9131198525428772,
0.4540441632270813,
0.13940878212451935,
-0.9893720149993896,
0.4748275578022003,
-0.13253436982631683,
-0.7469557523727417,
0.0376194529235363,
-0.3679801821708679,
1.0031954050064087,
-0.19168569147586823,
-0.7559745907783508,
-0.38823848962783813,
-0.6075156927108765,
0.43920472264289856,
0.01092583779245615,
-0.09962358325719833,
-0.44978901743888855,
-0.3425886929035187,
0.5238856673240662,
-0.11412493884563446,
0.4742213785648346,
-0.4214136004447937,
0.262136310338974,
0.4405505955219269,
0.38641709089279175,
0.24504902958869934,
0.1248030811548233,
0.005926423240453005,
0.1792059689760208,
0.25259438157081604,
-0.5087890028953552,
-0.5223177075386047,
0.4939188063144684,
-0.5095974802970886,
-0.8878923058509827,
-0.608420193195343,
-0.463847279548645,
-0.4393906593322754,
0.5156908631324768,
0.23707246780395508,
0.1636664867401123,
-0.30737990140914917,
0.4371277987957001,
0.5166119933128357,
-0.13063576817512512,
0.29966458678245544,
0.43863198161125183,
0.011766314506530762,
-0.5078957676887512,
0.48826080560684204,
0.44602248072624207,
-0.3075133264064789,
0.12727206945419312,
0.13528616726398468,
-0.1657109558582306,
-0.6656884551048279,
-0.273125022649765,
-0.18291598558425903,
-0.7342315912246704,
-0.22432611882686615,
-0.5892804265022278,
-0.21406978368759155,
-0.19996193051338196,
-0.3055764436721802,
-0.34123286604881287,
-0.7366721034049988,
0.2631605267524719,
0.009390599094331264,
-0.29683488607406616,
0.260229229927063,
-0.39484912157058716,
-0.47381290793418884,
-0.5518592596054077,
0.10637280344963074,
0.4288569688796997,
0.00022570490546058863,
-0.08084162324666977,
-0.3611127436161041,
-0.07145439833402634,
-0.07446742802858353,
-0.5558079481124878,
-0.870771050453186,
0.31550535559654236,
-0.5843347311019897,
0.6790453791618347,
0.21435584127902985,
-0.010536912828683853,
0.6166080832481384,
-0.4638320803642273,
0.7473896741867065,
0.30301961302757263,
-0.7755010724067688,
0.7713841795921326,
-0.6581788659095764,
0.8720104694366455,
0.9291020631790161,
0.2193644791841507,
-0.13495050370693207,
-0.12279761582612991,
-0.6421783566474915,
-0.3728522062301636,
0.4614461660385132,
0.27135249972343445,
-0.3136483132839203,
0.035340383648872375,
-0.20886056125164032,
0.20160676538944244,
0.0189321581274271,
-0.44731220602989197,
0.23720690608024597,
-0.19888968765735626,
0.18121296167373657,
0.17852884531021118,
0.2347669154405594,
-0.20379574596881866,
-0.6993544697761536,
0.452957421541214,
-0.19181114435195923,
0.23489023745059967,
0.23070329427719116,
-0.11700323224067688,
0.03959425911307335,
0.4560096561908722,
0.529193639755249,
0.5889338850975037,
-0.10173344612121582,
0.04419029876589775,
0.7487493753433228,
-0.10388170182704926,
0.15935206413269043,
0.16863223910331726,
-0.25911763310432434,
-0.3859507441520691,
0.010797477327287197,
0.682903528213501,
0.3145805895328522,
-0.63444584608078,
0.6128023862838745,
0.18760226666927338,
-0.46779075264930725,
-0.1770363301038742,
0.21239644289016724,
0.2970661222934723,
0.49694377183914185,
0.21007269620895386,
0.6936317682266235,
0.5327053070068359,
-0.3999493718147278,
0.08601710200309753,
0.45365989208221436,
-0.36315152049064636,
-0.5946967601776123,
0.8056699633598328,
0.24416238069534302,
-0.16692839562892914,
0.14170603454113007,
-0.45079612731933594,
-0.6193367838859558,
0.7887565493583679,
0.20872117578983307,
0.9862114787101746,
-0.07337381690740585,
0.0035913100000470877,
0.4001500904560089,
0.3799695372581482,
0.09765146672725677,
0.664701521396637,
-0.20486338436603546,
-0.8943977952003479,
-0.4511030316352844,
-0.061413463205099106,
-0.33350229263305664,
0.39897745847702026,
-0.33199480175971985,
0.5380246639251709,
-0.5595337152481079,
-0.48952716588974,
0.4727092683315277,
0.15027375519275665,
-1.0400497913360596,
0.20874641835689545,
0.4127202332019806,
1.2871594429016113,
-0.48509112000465393,
0.6512718796730042,
1.0383687019348145,
-0.4774642288684845,
-0.6210625171661377,
-0.3130827844142914,
0.3699694573879242,
-0.6763526797294617,
0.9333451390266418,
0.34539270401000977,
-0.3410404324531555,
-0.2730294466018677,
-0.5320215225219727,
-0.7129698991775513,
1.0537477731704712,
0.2332082837820053,
-0.254024863243103,
-0.19133830070495605,
-0.018447471782565117,
0.28518983721733093,
-0.2986997663974762,
0.23161807656288147,
0.5415840148925781,
0.4485975205898285,
0.09904435276985168,
-0.838110625743866,
0.23215653002262115,
-0.4583703577518463,
-0.231557697057724,
0.09905879944562912,
-0.9669057726860046,
0.8625067472457886,
-0.2524418532848358,
-0.23508574068546295,
-0.15123268961906433,
0.6466681361198425,
0.682284414768219,
0.7211897969245911,
0.5725557208061218,
0.9015711545944214,
0.6173142194747925,
0.1563519835472107,
0.4336637556552887,
-0.13702644407749176,
-0.08576590567827225,
1.1868987083435059,
-0.7203239798545837,
0.9662606716156006,
0.436778724193573,
0.16656793653964996,
0.5563235878944397,
0.08793120086193085,
-0.08489632606506348,
0.5504626035690308,
0.06800936162471771,
0.04706196114420891,
-0.6404164433479309,
0.13632731139659882,
-0.37214338779449463,
0.8770171999931335,
0.2780250310897827,
0.17195327579975128,
-0.4949329197406769,
-0.004806810058653355,
-0.2800283133983612,
0.1109314113855362,
-0.36992156505584717,
0.3761841952800751,
0.13166239857673645,
-1.2269158363342285,
0.5342795848846436,
-0.020851492881774902,
0.4237866699695587,
-0.03588135913014412,
0.2572745382785797,
-0.13760966062545776,
0.5970659852027893,
0.1297912299633026,
-0.9191053509712219,
0.4173206090927124,
-0.10941184312105179,
0.2363397181034088,
-0.23684996366500854,
1.2620484828948975,
0.2564909756183624,
-0.195821151137352,
0.21376678347587585,
0.8351616263389587,
0.04858225956559181,
-0.04087654501199722,
-1.0132575035095215,
0.09128482639789581,
0.00835847295820713,
-0.1837574690580368,
0.22163940966129303,
0.8217801451683044,
-0.1520676463842392,
0.6609271168708801,
0.2589426040649414,
-0.25550922751426697,
-0.21166391670703888,
-0.08355458080768585,
0.6881433129310608,
-0.8938570618629456,
-0.7021232843399048,
-0.8814268708229065,
0.528026282787323,
-0.36700063943862915,
-0.7097128629684448,
0.9459484219551086,
0.6991152167320251,
0.6344987154006958,
-0.1319824606180191,
0.5646001696586609,
0.1646566092967987,
0.48114100098609924,
-0.06418932229280472,
0.6364302039146423,
-0.5444430112838745,
-0.0906364694237709,
-0.12340593338012695,
-0.6013655066490173,
-0.06784893572330475,
0.493987500667572,
-0.8301869034767151,
-0.15147756040096283,
0.9036749601364136,
0.6086792349815369,
-0.13513687252998352,
0.6686381697654724,
0.4519096910953522,
0.11053876578807831,
-0.2469649463891983,
1.0375949144363403,
1.0986669063568115,
-0.3254629969596863,
0.3975733816623688,
-0.1644192487001419,
-0.32047417759895325,
-0.13036246597766876,
-0.8315101265907288,
-1.1992676258087158,
-0.5342537760734558,
-0.35846224427223206,
-0.24377897381782532,
0.15936072170734406,
0.7501336336135864,
0.5391514897346497,
-0.7836388349533081,
-0.1436581015586853,
-0.4554594159126282,
-0.3070826232433319,
-0.41028308868408203,
-0.1920914500951767,
-0.2221737504005432,
-0.34984153509140015,
-0.35662275552749634,
0.5439442992210388,
0.5971505641937256,
-0.31824442744255066,
-0.05033089220523834,
0.1998588740825653,
-0.3243975341320038,
0.376137912273407,
0.5820587277412415,
0.2527988851070404,
-0.6023157238960266,
-0.3665131628513336,
0.21917091310024261,
0.008931144140660763,
-0.046057283878326416,
0.5414722561836243,
-1.2471383810043335,
0.02483472414314747,
0.7887648940086365,
0.8651171922683716,
0.6755434274673462,
-0.12240758538246155,
0.47458258271217346,
0.08925832062959671,
0.05378728732466698,
0.6827167272567749,
0.3449589014053345,
0.04013051837682724,
-0.18810780346393585,
0.7084566950798035,
0.28672468662261963,
-0.7138134241104126,
-0.8403657674789429,
0.13987837731838226,
-0.8028975129127502,
-0.5175977349281311,
0.7737506031990051,
0.30374252796173096,
-0.5189076662063599,
-0.1293868124485016,
-0.023880328983068466,
-0.0012308378936722875,
-0.3578469157218933,
0.5518602728843689,
0.8116134405136108,
-0.3210000991821289,
-0.11866171658039093,
-0.5630093812942505,
0.3078034520149231,
1.0414234399795532,
-0.5732982754707336,
-0.2707904875278473,
0.5104302763938904,
0.292690247297287,
0.2118062824010849,
0.7688474655151367,
-0.00657188193872571,
0.653134286403656,
0.33176910877227783,
-0.3909338116645813,
-0.1686391532421112,
-0.35700568556785583,
-0.23189716041088104,
0.4913806915283203,
-0.4162611663341522,
-0.06262274086475372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13925v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13925v1
|
MARIO Eval: Evaluate Your Math LLM with your Math LLM--A mathematical dataset evaluation toolkit
| 2024-04-22T07:03:44 | 2024-04-22T07:03:44 |
Boning Zhang, Chengxi Li, Kai Fan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have been explored in a variety of reasoning
tasks including solving of mathematical problems. Each math dataset typically
includes its own specially designed evaluation script, which, while suitable
for its intended use, lacks generalizability across different datasets.
Consequently, updates and adaptations to these evaluation tools tend to occur
without being systematically reported, leading to inconsistencies and obstacles
to fair comparison across studies. To bridge this gap, we introduce a
comprehensive mathematical evaluation toolkit that not only utilizes a python
computer algebra system (CAS) for its numerical accuracy, but also integrates
an optional LLM, known for its considerable natural language processing
capabilities. To validate the effectiveness of our toolkit, we manually
annotated two distinct datasets. Our experiments demonstrate that the toolkit
yields more robust evaluation results compared to prior works, even without an
LLM. Furthermore, when an LLM is incorporated, there is a notable enhancement.
The code for our method will be made available at
\url{https://github.com/MARIO-Math-Reasoning/math_evaluation}.
|
[
-0.3881530463695526,
-0.9013696908950806,
0.7047540545463562,
0.5142015814781189,
-0.17839765548706055,
0.3353789150714874,
-0.4996531009674072,
-0.17967750132083893,
0.16616882383823395,
0.44555604457855225,
-0.4612463116645813,
-0.5697736740112305,
-0.5431927442550659,
0.23183844983577728,
-0.3028049170970917,
0.9329755902290344,
-0.20181804895401,
0.4388919770717621,
-0.7327923774719238,
0.04955191910266876,
-0.2539207339286804,
-0.2757236063480377,
-0.5999830365180969,
-0.4228927493095398,
0.35648253560066223,
0.20544318854808807,
0.7239195108413696,
0.44817665219306946,
1.093544840812683,
0.38360199332237244,
0.13973653316497803,
0.2408478856086731,
-0.42459267377853394,
0.2753083407878876,
-0.11090333759784698,
-0.3661442995071411,
-0.6466821432113647,
-0.09878269582986832,
0.6459938883781433,
0.7089547514915466,
-0.19168037176132202,
0.3346007168292999,
-0.09496984630823135,
0.5759871006011963,
-0.7488604187965393,
0.5022041201591492,
-0.454511433839798,
0.03170783817768097,
-0.12339247763156891,
-0.05679912492632866,
-0.2864604890346527,
-0.72689288854599,
-0.1495274007320404,
-0.6731773614883423,
-0.33181965351104736,
-0.22020302712917328,
0.3583775460720062,
0.30745407938957214,
-0.23333793878555298,
-0.5085254907608032,
-0.5027885437011719,
0.8356891870498657,
-0.5634408593177795,
0.26605018973350525,
0.33078792691230774,
0.6470404267311096,
-0.334932416677475,
-0.5737181901931763,
-0.3653566241264343,
-0.5717918276786804,
0.16502639651298523,
0.2991243004798889,
-0.258451908826828,
0.04500889778137207,
0.6599941849708557,
0.3586437404155731,
-0.48431554436683655,
0.015238936059176922,
-0.3217514157295227,
-0.3064887821674347,
0.8068835139274597,
0.4427727460861206,
0.36470165848731995,
0.024133911356329918,
-0.09896624833345413,
-0.06753059476613998,
-0.6666381359100342,
-0.11596047878265381,
0.6134748458862305,
0.26774755120277405,
-0.1889253556728363,
0.9671105146408081,
0.10369608551263809,
0.551687479019165,
-0.38591039180755615,
-0.2889261245727539,
0.3006472885608673,
-0.19794267416000366,
-0.18158447742462158,
-0.002010383177548647,
0.9497724175453186,
0.21619726717472076,
0.480581134557724,
0.015577781945466995,
-0.3904147744178772,
0.344608336687088,
0.13543373346328735,
-0.7889730930328369,
-0.24887411296367645,
-0.11544378101825714,
0.08263175934553146,
-0.244881272315979,
0.18051008880138397,
-0.7657336592674255,
-0.4355260133743286,
-0.39341896772384644,
0.44446930289268494,
-0.23457884788513184,
0.21207880973815918,
0.10827706754207611,
0.046214789152145386,
-0.19495433568954468,
0.5305666923522949,
-0.6379896402359009,
0.6308311223983765,
1.1548659801483154,
0.8006253242492676,
-0.1019190326333046,
-0.11358536779880524,
-0.9566349387168884,
-0.2669788897037506,
-0.7662320137023926,
0.6638306379318237,
-0.8614189028739929,
-0.29373669624328613,
-0.061000000685453415,
-0.21552293002605438,
0.07143530994653702,
-0.566494345664978,
0.675786018371582,
-0.4009501039981842,
0.24293376505374908,
-0.19255489110946655,
-0.6237858533859253,
-0.0896262377500534,
0.07305824011564255,
-0.7512765526771545,
0.9574095010757446,
0.419491708278656,
-0.4172939360141754,
0.19163447618484497,
-0.9321838617324829,
-0.29622140526771545,
0.16030435264110565,
0.005098484922200441,
-0.5652499198913574,
0.3404999375343323,
0.3294004201889038,
0.08237266540527344,
-0.5029260516166687,
0.291997492313385,
-0.8022006750106812,
-0.6472771763801575,
0.45246967673301697,
-0.6182934641838074,
0.9345866441726685,
0.2542453110218048,
0.09116677194833755,
-0.05598261207342148,
-0.6266660690307617,
0.1599888950586319,
0.012188364751636982,
-0.30500736832618713,
-0.0843033492565155,
-0.1631840318441391,
-0.1596534252166748,
-0.09632670879364014,
0.51090008020401,
-0.44312959909439087,
0.4816145896911621,
-0.4198356866836548,
0.149994894862175,
0.7676370739936829,
-0.13925595581531525,
0.258228063583374,
-0.19378836452960968,
0.9073861241340637,
-0.21113021671772003,
-0.139614537358284,
-0.26896536350250244,
-0.5938524007797241,
-0.6305348873138428,
-0.2650943696498871,
0.4083806872367859,
0.47477900981903076,
-0.8421681523323059,
0.5304564833641052,
-0.2305937260389328,
-0.34342947602272034,
-0.5332024097442627,
0.49859341979026794,
0.3080753982067108,
0.6226290464401245,
0.13801366090774536,
-0.2001822143793106,
-0.45512235164642334,
-0.9328545331954956,
-0.228513702750206,
-0.1543385088443756,
-0.2873989939689636,
0.4020926356315613,
0.4444742798805237,
-0.15789029002189636,
0.9766900539398193,
-0.364594966173172,
-0.005060964729636908,
-0.5242629051208496,
0.034022245556116104,
0.4948088824748993,
0.2971733808517456,
0.4273836612701416,
-0.25165241956710815,
-0.43671074509620667,
-0.049032196402549744,
-0.6683924794197083,
-0.8018829822540283,
-0.17412805557250977,
-0.15103168785572052,
-0.022748593240976334,
-0.09325447678565979,
-0.28057169914245605,
0.5253589749336243,
0.4185678958892822,
-0.22257564961910248,
0.6424216032028198,
-0.26055869460105896,
0.1997564285993576,
-0.7482053637504578,
0.04400799795985222,
0.15535247325897217,
-0.35827428102493286,
-0.322719931602478,
0.04087182134389877,
0.2212476283311844,
-0.05005970969796181,
-0.38148802518844604,
0.6087114810943604,
-0.12296759337186813,
-0.538727879524231,
-0.010481742210686207,
0.314461350440979,
0.10041748732328415,
0.06301937252283096,
-0.2345014065504074,
1.0486974716186523,
0.7250910401344299,
-0.38920050859451294,
0.8688567876815796,
0.08135849237442017,
-0.6846134066581726,
0.4373219609260559,
-0.5742975473403931,
0.14402851462364197,
0.13500475883483887,
0.1597815603017807,
-0.6239207983016968,
-0.20828679203987122,
0.5164738893508911,
-0.3094508647918701,
0.10013948380947113,
-0.08119155466556549,
-0.761330246925354,
-0.44698837399482727,
-0.5645943284034729,
0.2496502846479416,
0.39629486203193665,
-0.649673581123352,
0.4238656759262085,
0.3299923539161682,
-0.23407557606697083,
-0.5110506415367126,
-0.6169409155845642,
0.2624236047267914,
-0.36052730679512024,
-0.4883216619491577,
-0.22180341184139252,
-0.5163228511810303,
-0.699604868888855,
-0.08646030724048615,
-0.04619124159216881,
-0.29673922061920166,
0.4172437787055969,
0.08704671263694763,
0.5933485627174377,
-0.3636046350002289,
0.13446642458438873,
0.2770698368549347,
-0.4799940884113312,
0.3716542720794678,
0.09003770351409912,
0.3864130973815918,
-0.36543819308280945,
-0.6964420080184937,
-0.42170390486717224,
-0.1964763104915619,
0.44041794538497925,
-0.0138344531878829,
0.23768456280231476,
0.2963683307170868,
-0.3934141993522644,
-0.16782549023628235,
-0.39304283261299133,
0.0738511011004448,
-0.4874390661716461,
0.44059988856315613,
-0.3825083374977112,
-0.6118072867393494,
0.35632482171058655,
0.030512388795614243,
0.08194299787282944,
0.33721259236335754,
0.6907222270965576,
0.07907553762197495,
1.1362097263336182,
0.1558493971824646,
-0.06726505607366562,
0.20365223288536072,
-0.07212186604738235,
0.3473500609397888,
-1.0623263120651245,
-0.04922829195857048,
-0.4305218458175659,
-0.2965236008167267,
-0.36946192383766174,
-0.3952334225177765,
0.24433405697345734,
0.13025407493114471,
-0.23713266849517822,
0.3832088112831116,
-0.09485859423875809,
1.0092284679412842,
0.09153718501329422,
-0.033436331897974014,
0.43506836891174316,
0.03681124001741409,
-0.10481181740760803,
-0.2609061598777771,
-0.39978840947151184,
-0.6875550150871277,
1.3775089979171753,
0.22646628320217133,
0.9345167875289917,
0.06105715036392212,
0.6847613453865051,
0.2948014438152313,
0.7103102803230286,
-0.9909153580665588,
0.6507055759429932,
-0.19149480760097504,
-0.2738844156265259,
-0.1342654824256897,
-0.8731609582901001,
-0.8050842881202698,
0.13469116389751434,
-0.0679173469543457,
-0.932022213935852,
-0.6337579488754272,
-0.16751013696193695,
-0.3440416157245636,
0.1121535524725914,
-0.6040011644363403,
0.752284586429596,
-0.5980446338653564,
-0.57687908411026,
-0.1450769007205963,
0.018902311101555824,
0.528788685798645,
-0.512773334980011,
0.18790468573570251,
-0.3071020543575287,
-0.3461032807826996,
0.5394822359085083,
-0.5436102151870728,
0.31757909059524536,
0.1085285171866417,
-0.11876096576452255,
0.3280695676803589,
0.4974559247493744,
0.0566914826631546,
0.4951564073562622,
-0.33814069628715515,
0.19114182889461517,
-0.02889259345829487,
-0.14264072477817535,
-1.0995351076126099,
0.952564537525177,
-0.5495479106903076,
-0.5493332147598267,
-0.4228363335132599,
-0.828412652015686,
-0.2708560526371002,
0.08906922489404678,
-0.3971022963523865,
0.5615746974945068,
0.05656229704618454,
0.16929547488689423,
0.13731375336647034,
-0.3086249530315399,
0.39538487792015076,
0.3400503993034363,
-0.6726604104042053,
-0.6941297054290771,
0.8400659561157227,
-0.13111473619937897,
0.0933452919125557,
0.17248521745204926,
0.6312496066093445,
-0.5135160684585571,
-0.08894990384578705,
-0.5997666120529175,
0.15601038932800293,
-0.8592106103897095,
-0.301479697227478,
0.005265370476990938,
-0.09551864862442017,
-0.2799779176712036,
-0.3006264865398407,
-0.2701183557510376,
-0.6612331867218018,
-0.10773134231567383,
0.05541704222559929,
0.2577475309371948,
1.0509312152862549,
-0.023184577003121376,
0.25247395038604736,
-0.6247961521148682,
0.1796112358570099,
0.14607930183410645,
0.5400123596191406,
-0.2743167579174042,
-0.4271167516708374,
-0.11599678546190262,
0.22596529126167297,
-0.2607721984386444,
-0.6270583271980286,
0.4634104073047638,
0.1657375991344452,
0.6131714582443237,
0.5176334977149963,
-0.2678864002227783,
1.052276849746704,
-0.35293036699295044,
0.5275430679321289,
0.2731562554836273,
-1.2461001873016357,
0.488574355840683,
-0.0993562862277031,
0.19853131473064423,
0.6937285661697388,
0.17538368701934814,
-0.21355748176574707,
-0.33809036016464233,
-0.5852344036102295,
-0.29648447036743164,
0.6642982363700867,
0.3875647187232971,
0.12077159434556961,
0.15110185742378235,
0.2726570963859558,
0.16744564473628998,
0.3631744086742401,
-0.6102897524833679,
0.0003741814580280334,
0.28143784403800964,
-0.373811811208725,
-0.2666252851486206,
0.01090445090085268,
-0.029726725071668625,
-0.36843907833099365,
0.5218265652656555,
-0.06904352456331253,
-0.028881201520562172,
-0.36022499203681946,
-0.23268340528011322,
-0.13100285828113556,
-0.020601455122232437,
0.42912036180496216,
1.1456836462020874,
0.00583913316950202,
0.12351413071155548,
0.4987993836402893,
-0.5852387547492981,
-0.07816792279481888,
0.00771121121942997,
0.1611679494380951,
0.06910045444965363,
0.5644019842147827,
0.4148271977901459,
0.4627114236354828,
-0.8586400747299194,
0.6337787508964539,
-0.15202192962169647,
0.06392749398946762,
-0.13215960562229156,
0.25879207253456116,
-0.038799624890089035,
0.03633400797843933,
-0.010371718555688858,
-0.10814269632101059,
0.17787806689739227,
-0.37898749113082886,
0.2191285938024521,
0.39580798149108887,
-0.1489226222038269,
-0.21109651029109955,
0.3619968593120575,
-0.10001843422651291,
-0.5946606397628784,
0.7383502721786499,
-0.2377241849899292,
-0.8004027009010315,
0.8538892865180969,
0.6200156807899475,
0.9529675841331482,
-0.08296076208353043,
0.0650080144405365,
0.39193594455718994,
0.26733338832855225,
0.20393747091293335,
0.164030060172081,
-0.24564491212368011,
-0.3577277958393097,
-0.5949962735176086,
-0.7490731477737427,
-0.6903700232505798,
-0.03492545709013939,
-0.5675366520881653,
0.7108278274536133,
-0.5610093474388123,
0.10066814720630646,
-0.2410862147808075,
0.45877090096473694,
-0.6338226199150085,
-0.0828695148229599,
0.3643181025981903,
0.8617150783538818,
-0.8178431987762451,
0.6707122921943665,
0.6585524082183838,
-0.21133756637573242,
-0.45369666814804077,
-0.23863133788108826,
0.054615702480077744,
-1.0939289331436157,
0.6573067307472229,
0.2934972643852234,
-0.16057714819908142,
-0.35486268997192383,
-0.43819084763526917,
-0.7286940217018127,
0.8389990925788879,
0.6753395199775696,
-0.7775614261627197,
0.6207554340362549,
0.44401606917381287,
0.6568305492401123,
-0.5650700330734253,
0.865138590335846,
0.6154131293296814,
0.6522886753082275,
0.27178987860679626,
-0.8577924966812134,
-0.3529666066169739,
-0.2768544852733612,
-0.010937247425317764,
0.20780624449253082,
-0.2950410842895508,
0.5025324821472168,
-0.32512348890304565,
0.01638948544859886,
0.26624181866645813,
0.40627074241638184,
0.48942553997039795,
0.6915203928947449,
0.2763898968696594,
0.7245938777923584,
0.8309290409088135,
-0.28100088238716125,
1.097424864768982,
-0.44569826126098633,
0.6220319867134094,
1.1852763891220093,
-0.36328554153442383,
0.6326161026954651,
0.27010011672973633,
-0.5708008408546448,
0.27066123485565186,
0.49503275752067566,
-0.22830849885940552,
0.09007152169942856,
0.5832404494285583,
-0.3407779633998871,
-0.5554211735725403,
0.13100303709506989,
-0.3398767113685608,
0.42580679059028625,
0.4760018587112427,
-0.14758558571338654,
-0.5311768651008606,
-0.3065582513809204,
0.03428901731967926,
0.04300713166594505,
-0.3371216356754303,
0.5325348377227783,
0.20924052596092224,
-0.4426390528678894,
0.10826528817415237,
-0.21517080068588257,
0.1655007004737854,
-0.7084258794784546,
-0.22882281243801117,
-0.21449652314186096,
0.13704928755760193,
-0.31721943616867065,
-0.970920205116272,
0.341077983379364,
0.4169270396232605,
0.3961073160171509,
-0.06087223440408707,
0.4554515779018402,
-0.278987854719162,
-1.1144814491271973,
0.04389328882098198,
0.5150517821311951,
0.5064677000045776,
0.30039310455322266,
-0.8973386883735657,
0.39192965626716614,
-0.21622925996780396,
-0.1954875886440277,
0.14964720606803894,
0.3742506504058838,
0.010403944179415703,
0.8708819150924683,
0.9735187292098999,
0.37195801734924316,
-0.23950053751468658,
0.5243037939071655,
0.977096438407898,
-0.3980242908000946,
-0.2853384017944336,
-1.1426312923431396,
0.2079598307609558,
-0.09912623465061188,
-0.3524038791656494,
1.0128397941589355,
1.1151010990142822,
0.5509194731712341,
0.1579693853855133,
0.667035698890686,
0.22145366668701172,
0.2245274782180786,
-0.405163049697876,
0.5735642910003662,
-0.3925115168094635,
0.7087170481681824,
-0.47554078698158264,
-1.3705588579177856,
-0.6441060900688171,
0.9713270664215088,
-0.6892632246017456,
0.04157571494579315,
0.7303336262702942,
0.5842536687850952,
-0.06138664111495018,
0.07231546938419342,
0.37752726674079895,
0.057973723858594894,
0.4943290948867798,
0.7941170930862427,
1.1312288045883179,
-0.1962651014328003,
0.3382541537284851,
-0.5349178910255432,
-0.3146655857563019,
0.03018001839518547,
-1.157971978187561,
-0.8804729580879211,
-0.051420699805021286,
-0.47081202268600464,
-0.3795944154262543,
0.03698002174496651,
1.1226491928100586,
0.16110073029994965,
-0.7480823397636414,
-0.5269079208374023,
-0.0013703093864023685,
0.4377734661102295,
0.10544843971729279,
-0.25372400879859924,
0.16471078991889954,
-0.47397729754447937,
-1.0343444347381592,
0.4437480568885803,
0.5081589221954346,
-0.20114490389823914,
-0.4215678572654724,
-0.10287664830684662,
0.4338955283164978,
-0.03998032957315445,
0.3807705044746399,
-0.11449433118104935,
-0.5158040523529053,
-0.10284877568483353,
-0.17319197952747345,
0.019594136625528336,
0.18230988085269928,
0.7991398572921753,
-0.8886556029319763,
0.8935031890869141,
0.4890701174736023,
0.752358078956604,
0.26171115040779114,
0.06219351664185524,
0.4644414782524109,
-0.06095869839191437,
-0.18853354454040527,
0.39209896326065063,
0.6582589149475098,
0.25499486923217773,
-0.12274251878261566,
0.5859133005142212,
0.1390870064496994,
-0.4052799940109253,
-0.9481925368309021,
-0.07454639673233032,
-0.9386179447174072,
0.18890631198883057,
1.0019782781600952,
-0.3568269908428192,
-0.3809664249420166,
0.20926766097545624,
-0.1649876832962036,
-0.14362148940563202,
-0.5347966551780701,
0.8221981525421143,
0.9653372764587402,
-0.22064243257045746,
0.19491896033287048,
-0.49865809082984924,
0.02480590157210827,
0.2331428974866867,
-1.0929557085037231,
-0.019157975912094116,
0.508872389793396,
0.20293425023555756,
0.05530636012554169,
-0.0008937473758123815,
-0.13163955509662628,
0.47378379106521606,
-0.10357947647571564,
-0.357867032289505,
-0.38124457001686096,
-0.43299952149391174,
-0.7864295244216919,
-0.029795443639159203,
-0.19708268344402313,
0.18592508137226105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13919v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13919v1
|
Navigating the Path of Writing: Outline-guided Text Generation with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-22T06:57:43 | 2024-04-22T06:57:43 |
Yukyung Lee, Soonwon Ka, Bokyung Son, Pilsung Kang, Jaewook Kang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly impacted the writing process,
enabling collaborative content creation and enhancing productivity. However,
generating high-quality, user-aligned text remains challenging. In this paper,
we propose Writing Path, a framework that uses explicit outlines to guide LLMs
in generating goal-oriented, high-quality pieces of writing. Our approach draws
inspiration from structured writing planning and reasoning paths, focusing on
capturing and reflecting user intentions throughout the writing process. We
construct a diverse dataset from unstructured blog posts to benchmark writing
performance and introduce a comprehensive evaluation framework assessing the
quality of outlines and generated texts. Our evaluations with GPT-3.5-turbo,
GPT-4, and HyperCLOVA X demonstrate that the Writing Path approach
significantly enhances text quality according to both LLMs and human
evaluations. This study highlights the potential of integrating
writing-specific techniques into LLMs to enhance their ability to meet the
diverse writing needs of users.
|
[
0.027701586484909058,
-0.5743533372879028,
1.0950603485107422,
0.09271254390478134,
-0.17759481072425842,
0.06062208116054535,
-0.3827204406261444,
-0.2938588559627533,
0.2726821303367615,
0.8919118046760559,
-0.8135671019554138,
-0.9836044907569885,
-0.531821072101593,
0.15442050993442535,
-0.4439457356929779,
1.2059781551361084,
-0.5019437074661255,
-0.4596397578716278,
-0.13374806940555573,
0.32354915142059326,
-0.34242579340934753,
-0.21356730163097382,
-0.442402720451355,
-0.09243907779455185,
1.0233447551727295,
0.41986626386642456,
0.6227788329124451,
0.8654926419258118,
0.47142940759658813,
0.08153087645769119,
0.30768489837646484,
0.24770204722881317,
-0.5883564949035645,
0.5937851071357727,
-0.08404432237148285,
0.06475584954023361,
-0.38534969091415405,
-0.18985041975975037,
0.6627946496009827,
0.7925178408622742,
-0.1031978577375412,
0.1686733514070511,
0.22705812752246857,
0.43140265345573425,
-0.4727732241153717,
-0.3521842062473297,
-0.21694505214691162,
-0.15235581994056702,
-0.3348945081233978,
-0.3375946283340454,
-0.42443957924842834,
-0.6177809834480286,
-0.010193247348070145,
-0.7514021992683411,
-0.1312575340270996,
0.09383727610111237,
0.7288352251052856,
-0.19117243587970734,
-0.24518443644046783,
-0.9103837013244629,
-0.8144423365592957,
0.5996559858322144,
-0.653986930847168,
0.23393964767456055,
0.11412601172924042,
0.323599249124527,
-0.33804306387901306,
-0.9226657152175903,
-0.35211876034736633,
0.27391502261161804,
0.14338919520378113,
0.09923943132162094,
0.18805941939353943,
0.12483485788106918,
0.1829146444797516,
0.12867461144924164,
-0.5999260544776917,
0.024617286399006844,
-0.1995309591293335,
-0.03230821341276169,
0.7488264441490173,
0.4274275004863739,
0.2838950455188751,
-0.005139094777405262,
-0.1904459446668625,
0.12700647115707397,
-0.9677819609642029,
0.13807964324951172,
0.7472274899482727,
0.3700595200061798,
0.19730563461780548,
0.7683102488517761,
-0.12738706171512604,
0.7814074158668518,
-0.2768271267414093,
-0.503888726234436,
-0.39418625831604004,
-0.5396057963371277,
0.05312046781182289,
0.05631905049085617,
0.9145882725715637,
0.726976752281189,
0.28576841950416565,
-0.34249651432037354,
-0.5352686047554016,
-0.2382030040025711,
0.17793184518814087,
-0.8819709420204163,
-0.05135088786482811,
-0.06753862649202347,
-0.29712483286857605,
-0.09813839942216873,
-0.021950112655758858,
-0.4512071907520294,
-0.653538703918457,
-0.5342645049095154,
0.1907825618982315,
-0.44469305872917175,
-0.21948905289173126,
0.2119619995355606,
-0.12191414833068848,
0.15428321063518524,
0.5391425490379333,
-1.1794625520706177,
0.4564105272293091,
0.6296976208686829,
0.8213537931442261,
-0.1710101217031479,
-0.28591108322143555,
-0.3696533143520355,
0.7089833617210388,
-0.4530603885650635,
0.8679503202438354,
-0.4269661009311676,
-0.3293148875236511,
0.22927679121494293,
-0.6994272470474243,
0.19413651525974274,
-0.09912798553705215,
0.8100306391716003,
-0.03551279008388519,
0.08863458037376404,
-0.3326711654663086,
-0.6359261274337769,
0.026325955986976624,
0.08499522507190704,
-0.34586355090141296,
0.9493575692176819,
0.1047108843922615,
-0.38923102617263794,
0.6161326766014099,
-0.3566373586654663,
-0.74968022108078,
0.01933884248137474,
-0.14430467784404755,
-0.138621523976326,
0.12397057563066483,
0.13413557410240173,
0.7508373856544495,
-0.320151150226593,
0.39901670813560486,
0.2432193011045456,
-0.44610440731048584,
-0.0946311354637146,
-0.3146614134311676,
0.31361129879951477,
0.022353973239660263,
-0.1288800686597824,
0.47592639923095703,
-0.8249169588088989,
0.11918078362941742,
-0.12429288774728775,
-0.7267066240310669,
-0.09382940083742142,
0.12248535454273224,
0.2175149917602539,
0.3340839147567749,
0.12782630324363708,
-0.3575213849544525,
0.3777308762073517,
0.03276165574789047,
0.2924720346927643,
0.8634529709815979,
0.3275396525859833,
0.2964441776275635,
-0.45833101868629456,
0.5420784950256348,
-0.6032005548477173,
-0.04038490355014801,
-0.45757630467414856,
-0.4990217387676239,
-0.6810659766197205,
-0.034548334777355194,
-0.07466883212327957,
0.010658565908670425,
-0.06691253930330276,
0.6205177307128906,
-0.23876145482063293,
-0.6804553866386414,
-0.4289356768131256,
0.41496801376342773,
0.3572918474674225,
0.41826772689819336,
0.12703688442707062,
-0.06944011151790619,
-0.5095222592353821,
-0.41045889258384705,
-0.3229575455188751,
-0.12997791171073914,
0.024635186418890953,
0.01142111700028181,
0.2700735330581665,
-0.19155994057655334,
0.8082952499389648,
-0.6579063534736633,
-0.22756555676460266,
-0.6803329586982727,
0.2954394221305847,
0.15884247422218323,
0.2529996633529663,
0.08969215303659439,
-0.3707493245601654,
-0.780287504196167,
-0.21882164478302002,
-0.5409465432167053,
-0.33307453989982605,
-0.4550413489341736,
-0.6106836199760437,
0.044103872030973434,
0.5590291023254395,
-0.5535292029380798,
0.23193278908729553,
0.47902053594589233,
-0.509384274482727,
0.7564100623130798,
0.038694679737091064,
0.1297527402639389,
-1.0965033769607544,
0.1489497870206833,
0.08044469356536865,
-0.21791166067123413,
-0.5044621229171753,
-0.3224332928657532,
-0.4041033387184143,
-0.054226309061050415,
0.01831848733127117,
0.5064993500709534,
-0.5298030972480774,
-0.06001225858926773,
-0.133323535323143,
0.10595007240772247,
0.3679681122303009,
0.36433613300323486,
0.2984619438648224,
0.45022884011268616,
0.3882492482662201,
-0.4050034284591675,
0.001920814043842256,
0.23506838083267212,
-0.4082657992839813,
0.4713081419467926,
-0.3969518542289734,
0.0049101319164037704,
-0.019502462819218636,
0.12460435926914215,
-0.8732269406318665,
-0.24676141142845154,
0.032448526471853256,
-0.2387460619211197,
0.13496731221675873,
0.09229987114667892,
-0.7090097069740295,
-0.013922411948442459,
-0.13793352246284485,
-0.09599950164556503,
0.6323547959327698,
-0.10526257008314133,
0.5315031409263611,
-0.040300942957401276,
-0.4110186696052551,
-0.13823197782039642,
-0.2674955427646637,
0.3636215925216675,
-0.034226905554533005,
-0.729328453540802,
0.3879154622554779,
-0.23230141401290894,
-0.19105610251426697,
-0.16772587597370148,
0.09505552053451538,
0.13460567593574524,
0.001491041504777968,
0.48967576026916504,
-0.0790642499923706,
-0.23629707098007202,
-0.030490899458527565,
0.28979653120040894,
0.10924596339464188,
0.15199409425258636,
-0.254881888628006,
0.5476624369621277,
0.36728912591934204,
-0.31529173254966736,
-0.33241015672683716,
0.7118582129478455,
0.40881067514419556,
-0.22457747161388397,
0.3801541328430176,
0.46323326230049133,
-0.412273645401001,
-0.47513145208358765,
-0.31277674436569214,
-0.08015794306993484,
-0.3883117735385895,
0.03382018208503723,
-0.3273431956768036,
-0.6132311224937439,
0.3249288499355316,
-0.11380033940076828,
0.3750820457935333,
0.30481719970703125,
0.41791361570358276,
-0.1293085813522339,
0.8095139861106873,
0.8454002737998962,
0.4899212419986725,
0.19577127695083618,
-0.034504957497119904,
0.43358728289604187,
-0.9382141828536987,
-0.22840021550655365,
-0.3258724808692932,
-0.06160764396190643,
-0.0379355363547802,
-0.20570316910743713,
0.1432250589132309,
0.37764325737953186,
-0.20350904762744904,
0.3695293664932251,
-0.5722079873085022,
0.36271852254867554,
0.4678778648376465,
-0.2458101361989975,
0.5811483860015869,
-0.13519373536109924,
-0.3052979111671448,
-0.2877143323421478,
-0.6580207347869873,
-1.1692991256713867,
1.2507131099700928,
0.3138671815395355,
0.7327490448951721,
-0.03295501321554184,
0.8976616263389587,
0.12345533818006516,
0.4514583945274353,
-0.44912368059158325,
0.6411468982696533,
0.1594410240650177,
-0.3730079233646393,
-0.4664851725101471,
-0.04523847624659538,
-0.5627216696739197,
0.015120945870876312,
-0.4554058909416199,
-0.8251644372940063,
-0.44460874795913696,
0.08282257616519928,
-0.42478740215301514,
0.12939037382602692,
-0.4629797637462616,
0.9050215482711792,
-0.3196926712989807,
-0.7135641574859619,
0.27305421233177185,
-0.4912927746772766,
0.26381009817123413,
-0.06360099464654922,
-0.10268685966730118,
-0.23572701215744019,
0.04161524400115013,
0.895685613155365,
-0.3874293565750122,
0.6539109349250793,
0.10029958933591843,
-0.2641303241252899,
0.6112560033798218,
0.17088449001312256,
0.4304582476615906,
-0.1464204341173172,
-0.26778659224510193,
-0.13735905289649963,
-0.5137767791748047,
0.0937027856707573,
-0.5081958770751953,
0.6675854921340942,
-0.3046426773071289,
-0.42560580372810364,
-0.1678856909275055,
-0.47491735219955444,
-0.26380887627601624,
0.6236260533332825,
0.4565444886684418,
0.5587247610092163,
-0.4543866515159607,
-0.3252566456794739,
0.41414496302604675,
-0.05669518560171127,
0.5166662335395813,
0.23198668658733368,
-0.34407493472099304,
-0.24532687664031982,
0.7281308174133301,
-0.04593748599290848,
0.37507495284080505,
0.3232724666595459,
0.076687753200531,
-0.497050017118454,
-1.1347254514694214,
-0.6621193289756775,
0.2965019643306732,
-0.8186522126197815,
0.05947403982281685,
-0.5048927664756775,
-0.2047533392906189,
-0.5591760277748108,
-0.9559791684150696,
-0.1348150372505188,
-0.15238821506500244,
-0.3037865161895752,
-0.09744560718536377,
0.06615286320447922,
1.186589002609253,
0.3274075984954834,
0.434236615896225,
-0.571101188659668,
0.008785085752606392,
-0.2522191107273102,
0.2930028438568115,
0.010598151944577694,
-0.08092095702886581,
-0.18764401972293854,
-0.25898662209510803,
-0.41910502314567566,
-0.5518483519554138,
0.2785898745059967,
-0.1568538099527359,
0.45319944620132446,
0.3495001494884491,
-0.20106330513954163,
0.6008346676826477,
-0.6821147203445435,
0.7755747437477112,
0.5271759629249573,
-0.8350458145141602,
0.7427867650985718,
-0.8916079998016357,
0.2933730185031891,
0.7085334658622742,
0.5030051469802856,
-0.7434272766113281,
-0.5313992500305176,
-0.18427254259586334,
-0.9305404424667358,
0.22857150435447693,
0.41840845346450806,
-0.1330898255109787,
0.2165701538324356,
0.5370922684669495,
0.2524562478065491,
0.24568967521190643,
-0.7414163947105408,
0.18943224847316742,
-0.029786959290504456,
-0.590293824672699,
-0.08865837007761002,
-0.14816558361053467,
-0.0013440221082419157,
0.029309378936886787,
0.5521095991134644,
-0.12303245067596436,
-0.07660535722970963,
0.14639566838741302,
0.033748410642147064,
-0.14523500204086304,
0.16097435355186462,
0.5597996711730957,
1.1410858631134033,
-0.03090767376124859,
-0.07423215359449387,
-0.5995174646377563,
-0.428229421377182,
0.18629971146583557,
-0.06044880300760269,
-0.3802698850631714,
0.03066985309123993,
0.5525546073913574,
0.6445385813713074,
-0.06261347979307175,
-0.691093385219574,
0.5342000126838684,
0.028318101540207863,
-0.3397457003593445,
-0.18920858204364777,
0.3415316939353943,
0.29853156208992004,
-0.1567305028438568,
0.24594689905643463,
-0.1468389332294464,
0.22231653332710266,
-0.3386048674583435,
-0.09632933884859085,
0.19571304321289062,
-0.6494207382202148,
-0.19834819436073303,
0.530186116695404,
0.584724485874176,
-0.3368884027004242,
0.5584003329277039,
-0.07041692733764648,
-0.11124167591333389,
0.21827703714370728,
0.6733991503715515,
0.8361281752586365,
0.12028205394744873,
0.24443787336349487,
0.3951384425163269,
0.30166518688201904,
-0.1103900820016861,
0.21395453810691833,
-0.004025820642709732,
-0.31189224123954773,
-0.5009446144104004,
-0.9705796241760254,
-0.24693062901496887,
-0.10174914449453354,
-0.26965954899787903,
0.571091890335083,
-0.5203510522842407,
0.046040188521146774,
0.055204156786203384,
-0.14858151972293854,
-0.17111746966838837,
0.19423219561576843,
-0.04855214059352875,
0.8294301629066467,
-0.802115797996521,
0.2624262571334839,
0.6311129331588745,
-0.45716264843940735,
-0.981322169303894,
0.27556392550468445,
-0.04904540255665779,
-0.22409656643867493,
0.2897699177265167,
0.30887654423713684,
-0.46347254514694214,
0.13677944242954254,
-0.1817144900560379,
-0.687329113483429,
1.253851056098938,
0.11988109350204468,
-0.541309654712677,
-0.23693379759788513,
0.3626765012741089,
0.5155383348464966,
-0.5698484778404236,
0.04442105442285538,
0.18920356035232544,
0.4577203691005707,
0.1878398209810257,
-0.45895808935165405,
0.25387585163116455,
-0.009824580512940884,
0.041848160326480865,
0.3992847204208374,
-0.24403417110443115,
0.45083895325660706,
-0.38610729575157166,
-0.38270682096481323,
0.3349256217479706,
0.4608238637447357,
0.16032154858112335,
-0.03061106987297535,
-0.0009469564538449049,
0.4076967239379883,
0.6719836592674255,
-0.02611437998712063,
0.890832781791687,
-0.14972007274627686,
-0.25678688287734985,
0.8841228485107422,
-0.48765575885772705,
0.743548572063446,
0.500943660736084,
0.3476443290710449,
0.7891805768013,
0.44504380226135254,
0.2443162202835083,
0.34929290413856506,
0.5254044532775879,
-0.3566211760044098,
-0.1924360692501068,
-0.2518802285194397,
0.16057835519313812,
0.19010508060455322,
0.20567645132541656,
-0.5972495675086975,
-0.24514740705490112,
-0.260712206363678,
0.436196893453598,
0.7051185965538025,
-0.3796480894088745,
0.7469053268432617,
-0.11093367636203766,
-1.1792370080947876,
0.20533426105976105,
0.11647898703813553,
0.384016215801239,
-0.7551482319831848,
-0.3671148717403412,
-0.01211484707891941,
-0.07085905224084854,
-0.29867634177207947,
-1.2478498220443726,
0.24535617232322693,
0.20737265050411224,
-0.2478480339050293,
-0.8179653882980347,
0.7075816988945007,
-0.4363313913345337,
-0.48756828904151917,
-0.07927560806274414,
0.26693031191825867,
0.00643316050991416,
0.04781820625066757,
-0.2146887481212616,
0.17965567111968994,
-0.14764711260795593,
-0.40351563692092896,
0.07898066192865372,
0.5194955468177795,
-0.0908636823296547,
0.4702253043651581,
0.7809310555458069,
0.16330096125602722,
-0.06985657662153244,
0.16286049783229828,
0.5541694760322571,
-0.6626115441322327,
-0.5303748846054077,
-0.7991393804550171,
0.6508520841598511,
-0.11460240185260773,
-0.8392682671546936,
0.7414950132369995,
0.9673759937286377,
0.4831418991088867,
0.2424248456954956,
0.9785488247871399,
0.08759532123804092,
0.5344246029853821,
-0.7755067944526672,
0.7843651175498962,
-0.1528865396976471,
0.013179964385926723,
-0.5226359367370605,
-1.0655500888824463,
-0.42716220021247864,
0.43191173672676086,
-0.14821545779705048,
-0.008262029848992825,
0.7802214026451111,
0.5814241766929626,
0.09941370785236359,
-0.22660405933856964,
0.23007547855377197,
-0.273539662361145,
0.5451385974884033,
0.7808145880699158,
0.7576692700386047,
-0.2536006569862366,
0.5873623490333557,
0.11618625372648239,
-0.2453296184539795,
0.15863573551177979,
-1.1328781843185425,
-1.0168073177337646,
-0.7398499250411987,
-0.18312406539916992,
-0.29766905307769775,
0.31821197271347046,
0.45082858204841614,
0.6385844349861145,
-0.012304281815886497,
-0.6030646562576294,
-0.4772340953350067,
0.09392543882131577,
-0.0033527796622365713,
-0.13757330179214478,
0.18063189089298248,
-0.2106090933084488,
-0.4808628261089325,
-0.009369761683046818,
0.556289553642273,
0.0956871509552002,
-0.5039721727371216,
-0.4749816954135895,
-0.19782991707324982,
0.1422702670097351,
0.4353095591068268,
-0.01656973920762539,
-0.44652384519577026,
0.07094103842973709,
0.05346258729696274,
-0.47819650173187256,
0.015155375003814697,
0.9646062254905701,
-0.0864848643541336,
0.11220934987068176,
0.43696683645248413,
0.43404242396354675,
0.44070249795913696,
-0.013007618486881256,
0.9107808470726013,
-0.5100297927856445,
-0.64471036195755,
0.4222011864185333,
0.19608284533023834,
0.5335301756858826,
-0.4186249077320099,
0.27818533778190613,
-0.1149825006723404,
-0.6320831179618835,
-0.46249884366989136,
0.2789502739906311,
-0.8379925489425659,
-0.266760915517807,
1.6659637689590454,
-0.2094365656375885,
-0.13563358783721924,
0.08254670351743698,
-0.44812607765197754,
0.1027011126279831,
-0.36812248826026917,
0.38827604055404663,
0.834033191204071,
-0.5230350494384766,
0.020927779376506805,
-0.3990893065929413,
0.786988377571106,
-0.19871670007705688,
-0.9950852394104004,
0.3944072425365448,
0.8642578721046448,
0.18097670376300812,
0.04468904435634613,
1.080385446548462,
0.0494396947324276,
0.12110063433647156,
-0.044649381190538406,
0.21982277929782867,
-0.09328930079936981,
-0.6291192770004272,
0.1578109860420227,
0.11401242017745972,
0.49611398577690125,
0.32875171303749084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13906v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13906v2
|
Generating Attractive and Authentic Copywriting from Customer Reviews
| 2024-04-22T06:33:28 | 2024-05-14T08:05:00 |
Yu-Xiang Lin, Wei-Yun Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The goal of product copywriting is to capture the interest of potential
buyers by emphasizing the features of products through text descriptions. As
e-commerce platforms offer a wide range of services, it's becoming essential to
dynamically adjust the styles of these auto-generated descriptions. Typical
approaches to copywriting generation often rely solely on specified product
attributes, which may result in dull and repetitive content. To tackle this
issue, we propose to generate copywriting based on customer reviews, as they
provide firsthand practical experiences with products, offering a richer source
of information than just product attributes. We have developed a
sequence-to-sequence framework, enhanced with reinforcement learning, to
produce copywriting that is attractive, authentic, and rich in information. Our
framework outperforms all existing baseline and zero-shot large language
models, including LLaMA-2-chat-7B and GPT-3.5, in terms of both attractiveness
and faithfulness. Furthermore, this work features the use of LLMs for
aspect-based summaries collection and argument allure assessment. Experiments
demonstrate the effectiveness of using LLMs for marketing domain corpus
construction. The code and the dataset is publicly available at:
https://github.com/YuXiangLin1234/Copywriting-Generation.
|
[
-0.1783350259065628,
-0.5599126815795898,
0.6340165734291077,
0.5315823554992676,
-0.3574522137641907,
0.04800643026828766,
-0.07197362184524536,
-0.5520890355110168,
0.3876110911369324,
0.8379099369049072,
-0.6642303466796875,
-0.6661303043365479,
-0.045037105679512024,
0.301125705242157,
-0.5817468762397766,
1.4258334636688232,
-0.15944771468639374,
-0.10647811740636826,
-0.3215746283531189,
-0.11269631236791611,
0.08341260999441147,
-0.5225376486778259,
-0.28113052248954773,
-0.015010497532784939,
0.5575374364852905,
0.423862099647522,
0.47699329257011414,
0.39139991998672485,
0.16299158334732056,
0.2586475908756256,
0.041569631546735764,
0.36018258333206177,
-0.571107029914856,
0.6090067028999329,
-0.3271092474460602,
-0.2533451020717621,
-0.5340086221694946,
-0.11061108857393265,
0.4813922941684723,
0.31047558784484863,
-0.13070279359817505,
0.26916974782943726,
0.2559857666492462,
0.7132219076156616,
-0.37687572836875916,
0.09988006949424744,
-0.7024393677711487,
0.16263027489185333,
0.15456058084964752,
-0.4502147436141968,
-0.43554604053497314,
-0.5675743222236633,
0.2144462913274765,
-0.8065890073776245,
0.2776968777179718,
0.22045910358428955,
0.8809189796447754,
-0.25644004344940186,
-0.014577162452042103,
-0.6705518960952759,
-0.7609127163887024,
0.7617883086204529,
-0.7365696430206299,
-0.015584476292133331,
0.1199379563331604,
0.13502678275108337,
-0.24189236760139465,
-0.7072057127952576,
-0.7296190857887268,
-0.2853489816188812,
-0.01720372587442398,
0.3269483149051666,
-0.154936745762825,
-0.39805281162261963,
0.12522709369659424,
0.6904539465904236,
-0.33861592411994934,
-0.025813888758420944,
-0.38903164863586426,
-0.04873592406511307,
0.8163019418716431,
0.2908661365509033,
-0.2155458927154541,
-0.37137797474861145,
-0.6118452548980713,
-0.11984898149967194,
-0.6153094172477722,
0.21893922984600067,
0.6781125068664551,
-0.032671794295310974,
0.19685976207256317,
0.6406397819519043,
-0.5535904169082642,
0.16944897174835205,
0.2789696753025055,
0.015082323923707008,
0.21428148448467255,
-0.30990317463874817,
-0.1545187532901764,
0.12164274603128433,
0.807543933391571,
0.6269513964653015,
0.12530513107776642,
-0.01956300437450409,
-0.60118567943573,
-0.23636239767074585,
0.6084085702896118,
-0.8185958862304688,
-0.09872572869062424,
0.25167521834373474,
-0.591096043586731,
-0.8748831748962402,
0.317763090133667,
-0.8343761563301086,
-0.31170886754989624,
-0.42148351669311523,
0.10425571352243423,
-0.297934889793396,
-0.0057187373749911785,
-0.029624680057168007,
-0.04921432584524155,
0.34890294075012207,
0.1795344352722168,
-0.5806378126144409,
0.32032641768455505,
0.6218001842498779,
0.4505022466182709,
-0.5438835024833679,
-0.33006855845451355,
-0.2673884332180023,
0.19585934281349182,
-0.2887638509273529,
0.9407922625541687,
-0.15422596037387848,
-0.3822113871574402,
0.42125093936920166,
-0.08207382261753082,
0.47364941239356995,
-0.6431936621665955,
0.3229254484176636,
-0.6839552521705627,
0.19364593923091888,
0.056930094957351685,
-0.513201892375946,
-0.0072549935430288315,
0.460224986076355,
-0.6605351567268372,
0.8351267576217651,
0.19254359602928162,
-0.3172912001609802,
0.3526717722415924,
-0.19828613102436066,
-0.9229443073272705,
-0.13054098188877106,
-0.03494151681661606,
-1.099076747894287,
0.5061267614364624,
0.45310986042022705,
0.4111859202384949,
0.08547163009643555,
-0.19632743299007416,
-0.24232693016529083,
0.046105533838272095,
1.0285614728927612,
-0.20903941988945007,
0.1007363498210907,
0.5575541257858276,
-0.4233982563018799,
0.24508145451545715,
-0.7025951743125916,
0.074391670525074,
0.5082528591156006,
-0.4522545337677002,
0.22154732048511505,
-0.19584712386131287,
0.24888747930526733,
0.1349124014377594,
0.08721503615379333,
-0.1365889310836792,
0.257332444190979,
-0.5098452568054199,
0.2992483377456665,
0.7602824568748474,
0.5087369084358215,
0.4038059115409851,
-0.7374018430709839,
0.9235429763793945,
0.037064194679260254,
0.26739582419395447,
-0.6622916460037231,
-0.2576078176498413,
-0.8006105422973633,
0.11962965130805969,
0.011226058006286621,
0.2537486255168915,
-0.859469473361969,
0.39049556851387024,
-0.26517796516418457,
-0.4001527726650238,
-0.4273121654987335,
0.5123962163925171,
0.565200924873352,
0.2228030264377594,
0.3741263747215271,
-0.6933313608169556,
-0.43814966082572937,
-0.9009784460067749,
-0.32509249448776245,
-0.19096872210502625,
-0.068395234644413,
0.42780348658561707,
0.04644574597477913,
0.026338759809732437,
0.8519357442855835,
-0.8006816506385803,
-0.4500327408313751,
-0.857847273349762,
0.010994605720043182,
-0.03251468390226364,
0.16096381843090057,
0.447316437959671,
-0.4100273549556732,
-0.46265584230422974,
-0.14749211072921753,
-0.414487361907959,
-0.30309799313545227,
-0.6490157842636108,
-0.44695496559143066,
0.48503410816192627,
0.27893924713134766,
-0.5691492557525635,
0.34087809920310974,
0.2559361159801483,
-0.016006533056497574,
0.7019535899162292,
-0.12361784279346466,
0.1721300333738327,
-1.3261969089508057,
-0.01905204728245735,
0.2766416668891907,
-0.326397567987442,
-0.21369820833206177,
-0.05489873141050339,
-0.4364979863166809,
-0.19264443218708038,
-0.6082316040992737,
0.32195696234703064,
-0.38378146290779114,
-0.17386290431022644,
-0.2580097019672394,
0.05532139539718628,
0.6352779269218445,
0.6771942377090454,
0.06491202116012573,
0.4078894555568695,
-0.04766014963388443,
-0.5999146699905396,
0.24956518411636353,
0.525598406791687,
-0.6278457641601562,
0.7670426368713379,
-0.5611547231674194,
0.10589709877967834,
-0.01266463566571474,
0.36208271980285645,
-0.6561979055404663,
-0.3141308128833771,
0.26742345094680786,
-0.49124106764793396,
0.09950707852840424,
0.07875199615955353,
-0.4263719916343689,
-0.08633645623922348,
-0.5203555226325989,
-0.06684942543506622,
0.7989508509635925,
-0.6094111800193787,
0.5181307196617126,
0.12102656066417694,
-0.44387567043304443,
-0.24187609553337097,
-0.4624834954738617,
0.16036036610603333,
-0.2056957483291626,
-0.3124597668647766,
0.4144127368927002,
-0.018777048215270042,
0.01069818064570427,
-0.15679524838924408,
0.03222641721367836,
0.07747296988964081,
0.02994908019900322,
0.14197653532028198,
0.14675909280776978,
-0.054724935442209244,
-0.05756242945790291,
-0.020354418084025383,
0.060462672263383865,
0.23093949258327484,
-0.6429172158241272,
0.44164204597473145,
-0.04711928591132164,
-0.1880820393562317,
-0.3265606462955475,
0.3445625603199005,
0.4596070349216461,
-0.06430511176586151,
-0.014254234731197357,
0.2605968117713928,
0.09638645499944687,
-1.0438120365142822,
-0.46305012702941895,
-0.16956546902656555,
-0.5041467547416687,
0.5853061676025391,
-0.3137037754058838,
-0.5785689353942871,
0.1607334464788437,
0.1203811764717102,
0.04312305897474289,
0.31999894976615906,
0.7777255773544312,
-0.32631954550743103,
0.6901898980140686,
0.5665993094444275,
0.16016322374343872,
0.5977346301078796,
-0.043026152998209,
0.22391465306282043,
-0.5813263654708862,
-0.3004001975059509,
-0.16955550014972687,
-0.4753190279006958,
-0.4010319709777832,
-0.15163010358810425,
0.005359631963074207,
0.1962427943944931,
0.08336617052555084,
0.41574496030807495,
-0.5734110474586487,
0.5298945307731628,
0.6511735916137695,
0.2686455249786377,
0.39941832423210144,
0.5830217003822327,
0.04102344065904617,
-0.05108310654759407,
-0.3116748332977295,
-0.6297510862350464,
1.1430896520614624,
0.3231010138988495,
0.835959255695343,
-0.001219659112393856,
0.5737185478210449,
0.34897559881210327,
0.42296722531318665,
-0.7949556708335876,
0.5444369316101074,
0.006608285009860992,
-0.18218675255775452,
0.038305800408124924,
-0.3517936170101166,
-0.7467445731163025,
-0.17640507221221924,
-0.3157444894313812,
-0.09123485535383224,
-0.058691829442977905,
0.421132355928421,
-0.36119142174720764,
-0.042927034199237823,
-0.14307305216789246,
0.640139102935791,
-0.7411978840827942,
-0.7043119668960571,
-0.12584510445594788,
-0.33267688751220703,
0.34678834676742554,
-0.11000922322273254,
-0.043268267065286636,
0.027578886598348618,
0.2279127836227417,
0.4514758586883545,
-0.460498571395874,
0.7848044633865356,
0.25522279739379883,
-0.16290034353733063,
0.49321669340133667,
0.364869624376297,
0.3236870765686035,
0.10460206121206284,
0.13700692355632782,
-0.1840675324201584,
-0.37169232964515686,
-0.24507656693458557,
-0.7359781861305237,
0.6326420307159424,
-0.469104528427124,
-0.39972472190856934,
-0.22212524712085724,
-0.18737509846687317,
-0.25582653284072876,
0.11929024010896683,
0.19262711703777313,
0.30443787574768066,
-0.5400270819664001,
-0.02092316560447216,
0.4801281690597534,
-0.46686384081840515,
0.3269500136375427,
0.3499062657356262,
-0.5929202437400818,
-1.0083600282669067,
1.1329431533813477,
-0.4643961489200592,
0.546390950679779,
0.2591083347797394,
0.09320308268070221,
-0.2843976318836212,
-0.6158379316329956,
-0.5219038128852844,
0.004668876063078642,
-0.791784942150116,
-0.26112812757492065,
-0.6992043852806091,
-0.1665111929178238,
-0.43374767899513245,
-0.3134935796260834,
-0.266632080078125,
-0.6277718544006348,
-0.12482983618974686,
-0.2691396474838257,
0.31448566913604736,
1.096225619316101,
0.3061375021934509,
0.37158820033073425,
-0.7999415397644043,
0.24148355424404144,
0.22453662753105164,
0.35334911942481995,
0.227517232298851,
-0.4079607427120209,
-0.3459143340587616,
-0.247717022895813,
-0.9439190030097961,
-0.5221009850502014,
0.7103974223136902,
0.22524158656597137,
0.4049263298511505,
0.4938191771507263,
0.08453124016523361,
0.4248006343841553,
-0.4247547388076782,
0.9504956603050232,
0.2732439935207367,
-0.8425332903862,
0.5537028312683105,
-0.19277465343475342,
0.12480122596025467,
0.6216519474983215,
0.34135928750038147,
-0.3842592239379883,
-0.5723533034324646,
-0.6993822455406189,
-1.0884608030319214,
0.42793357372283936,
0.30392298102378845,
0.37261050939559937,
-0.11396227031946182,
0.33223235607147217,
0.37421610951423645,
0.5800082087516785,
-0.8731398582458496,
0.032732415944337845,
-0.5008882284164429,
-0.4178008437156677,
0.052015144377946854,
-0.3991786241531372,
0.08657137304544449,
0.17277678847312927,
0.8452281951904297,
-0.22398099303245544,
0.12039953470230103,
0.24971117079257965,
-0.3462037444114685,
0.052576906979084015,
0.4933229982852936,
0.725729763507843,
0.4712752103805542,
0.10846473276615143,
-0.07197313755750656,
-0.0965157002210617,
-0.32488560676574707,
-0.14630769193172455,
-0.07493966072797775,
-0.3576529026031494,
0.05907517299056053,
0.2176332324743271,
0.7235084176063538,
0.32774844765663147,
-0.7168669104576111,
0.8118340969085693,
0.10836606472730637,
-0.3025027811527252,
-0.44757166504859924,
-0.16090527176856995,
-0.09608475863933563,
0.06743905693292618,
0.03907758370041847,
-0.11709856241941452,
0.19298426806926727,
-0.5794047117233276,
0.4811103045940399,
0.2008911371231079,
-0.45421701669692993,
-0.43891671299934387,
0.4728509783744812,
0.4432239532470703,
-0.20318855345249176,
0.7258636355400085,
-0.3662806749343872,
-0.7205853462219238,
0.3634345829486847,
0.6196004152297974,
1.18379807472229,
0.18435733020305634,
0.30573487281799316,
0.201493039727211,
0.06057054176926613,
0.015521899797022343,
0.18564940989017487,
-0.2283756136894226,
-0.4028625786304474,
-0.2383502572774887,
-0.928642988204956,
-0.7029376029968262,
-0.10351313650608063,
-0.5687639117240906,
0.4691588878631592,
-0.7315848469734192,
0.07832913100719452,
-0.15455922484397888,
-0.3256865441799164,
-0.45277154445648193,
0.06259863078594208,
0.21929135918617249,
0.35893285274505615,
-0.5781221389770508,
0.4475511908531189,
0.4277169406414032,
-0.846845805644989,
-0.5289000272750854,
0.1579771637916565,
-0.1287907212972641,
-0.75081866979599,
0.5352450013160706,
0.44673672318458557,
-0.0010939231142401695,
-0.32272884249687195,
-0.5872305035591125,
-0.367581307888031,
1.0014599561691284,
-0.15913431346416473,
-0.4533494710922241,
0.05713292583823204,
0.516594648361206,
0.5520979166030884,
-0.7988322973251343,
0.07318936288356781,
0.3152470886707306,
0.07573232054710388,
0.3530121445655823,
-0.4853053390979767,
0.005015728995203972,
-0.3719036281108856,
0.09755267947912216,
-0.3054388165473938,
-0.3475417196750641,
0.47208040952682495,
-0.10429929941892624,
-0.0706123560667038,
0.4151056408882141,
0.7606497406959534,
0.5089680552482605,
0.2585471570491791,
0.3399374485015869,
0.638075590133667,
0.27621912956237793,
0.29183757305145264,
1.1213409900665283,
-0.28886792063713074,
0.02403319627046585,
1.4213247299194336,
-0.4375523030757904,
1.039149522781372,
0.3406561315059662,
-0.03433692082762718,
0.7348278164863586,
0.3679374158382416,
-0.3685844838619232,
0.5237086415290833,
0.5859832167625427,
-0.1690300703048706,
-0.08239594101905823,
-0.12180478125810623,
-0.03400447964668274,
0.11472815275192261,
0.03495321050286293,
-0.9420437812805176,
0.05558102950453758,
-0.20947568118572235,
-0.01907830871641636,
0.36821094155311584,
-0.1549457311630249,
1.1895391941070557,
0.35262632369995117,
-0.8032130002975464,
0.2507786452770233,
-0.04257795587182045,
0.6413576006889343,
-0.5362273454666138,
-0.16434448957443237,
-0.3264658749103546,
0.3806386888027191,
-0.3481312394142151,
-0.937437117099762,
0.1786382645368576,
0.11881531029939651,
-0.2831209897994995,
-0.7003836035728455,
0.44577038288116455,
-0.5101764798164368,
-0.642484724521637,
-0.12266494333744049,
0.21805238723754883,
0.04375092312693596,
0.0008071362972259521,
-0.5533376932144165,
0.03152705356478691,
0.22971172630786896,
-0.5642374157905579,
0.240149587392807,
0.33938008546829224,
0.054141849279403687,
0.28289636969566345,
0.8556901216506958,
0.2147054523229599,
-0.17364589869976044,
0.1471429318189621,
0.6615328788757324,
-0.6327933073043823,
-0.719395637512207,
-0.6943890452384949,
0.6948832869529724,
-0.4921887218952179,
-0.4953838288784027,
0.7905906438827515,
0.8535116314888,
0.8708308339118958,
-0.3794286549091339,
1.0235509872436523,
0.37855207920074463,
0.4450805187225342,
-0.5715633034706116,
0.8282473087310791,
-0.33232444524765015,
0.4902840852737427,
-0.2748042941093445,
-1.3567711114883423,
-0.1454075425863266,
0.4392697215080261,
-0.03494621813297272,
-0.0903712585568428,
0.7566918730735779,
0.7209461331367493,
0.15417659282684326,
-0.05055723711848259,
0.11062789708375931,
0.11092469096183777,
0.5450100302696228,
0.5507892966270447,
1.1150853633880615,
-0.27215731143951416,
0.8653011322021484,
-0.259708434343338,
-0.0017831141594797373,
-0.17245511710643768,
-1.1553356647491455,
-0.8708153367042542,
-0.2427220344543457,
-0.5333993434906006,
-0.9547110199928284,
-0.17843346297740936,
1.03394615650177,
0.3614653944969177,
-0.7400473356246948,
-0.19038987159729004,
0.12952068448066711,
-0.21582826972007751,
-0.3256000280380249,
-0.24207954108715057,
0.06521730124950409,
-0.5315345525741577,
-0.6415911912918091,
0.2117801457643509,
0.30985158681869507,
0.22508426010608673,
-0.48988112807273865,
-0.1110609918832779,
0.5302824974060059,
0.3318372666835785,
0.622643768787384,
0.21550248563289642,
-0.5171382427215576,
0.1592155247926712,
0.15334567427635193,
-0.16903550922870636,
0.21377216279506683,
0.9859297275543213,
-0.5158455967903137,
0.22595828771591187,
0.3528767228126526,
0.6302715539932251,
0.4725247025489807,
0.2411785125732422,
0.9057862758636475,
-0.7206796407699585,
-0.247846320271492,
0.36400872468948364,
0.22243276238441467,
0.5403886437416077,
-0.19628918170928955,
-0.03379957377910614,
0.044323332607746124,
-0.47289931774139404,
-0.40565794706344604,
0.5506578683853149,
-1.093565821647644,
-0.19662976264953613,
1.3481943607330322,
-0.17620384693145752,
-0.28514236211776733,
0.2754226624965668,
-0.27651914954185486,
-0.2553679645061493,
-0.4722355008125305,
1.086929202079773,
0.3853296935558319,
-0.0357222855091095,
0.14996032416820526,
-0.051083024591207504,
0.6689520478248596,
0.35959142446517944,
-0.9495837092399597,
0.08822835981845856,
0.6395714282989502,
0.33926793932914734,
-0.16351503133773804,
0.37853026390075684,
-0.27201202511787415,
0.24451535940170288,
-0.2568114101886749,
0.18962359428405762,
-0.27637848258018494,
-0.22388263046741486,
-0.37711000442504883,
0.22147507965564728,
0.429123193025589,
0.13189782202243805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15155v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15155v1
|
Adaptive Collaboration Strategy for LLMs in Medical Decision Making
| 2024-04-22T06:30:05 | 2024-04-22T06:30:05 |
Yubin Kim, Chanwoo Park, Hyewon Jeong, Yik Siu Chan, Xuhai Xu, Daniel McDuff, Cynthia Breazeal, Hae Won Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Foundation models have become invaluable in advancing the medical field.
Despite their promise, the strategic deployment of LLMs for effective utility
in complex medical tasks remains an open question. Our novel framework, Medical
Decision-making Agents (MDAgents) aims to address this gap by automatically
assigning the effective collaboration structure for LLMs. Assigned solo or
group collaboration structure is tailored to the complexity of the medical task
at hand, emulating real-world medical decision making processes. We evaluate
our framework and baseline methods with state-of-the-art LLMs across a suite of
challenging medical benchmarks: MedQA, MedMCQA, PubMedQA, DDXPlus, PMC-VQA,
Path-VQA, and MedVidQA, achieving the best performance in 5 out of 7 benchmarks
that require an understanding of multi-modal medical reasoning. Ablation
studies reveal that MDAgents excels in adapting the number of collaborating
agents to optimize efficiency and accuracy, showcasing its robustness in
diverse scenarios. We also explore the dynamics of group consensus, offering
insights into how collaborative agents could behave in complex clinical team
dynamics. Our code can be found at https://github.com/mitmedialab/MDAgents.
|
[
-0.3042922019958496,
-0.5624894499778748,
0.8751725554466248,
0.2580724060535431,
-0.17266592383384705,
0.520782470703125,
-0.038919348269701004,
-0.16423235833644867,
0.2811513841152191,
0.43272310495376587,
-0.7515272498130798,
-0.2613483667373657,
-0.6244418621063232,
0.2860437333583832,
0.25089550018310547,
0.8483094573020935,
-0.3468959331512451,
0.3304474949836731,
-0.6033170819282532,
-0.6452337503433228,
-0.5587966442108154,
-0.3392162621021271,
-0.6249120235443115,
-0.6422867178916931,
0.47422733902931213,
0.47051286697387695,
0.8028157353401184,
0.7869064211845398,
0.8004641532897949,
0.4931919574737549,
0.10318626463413239,
0.342511385679245,
-0.352990061044693,
0.29528799653053284,
-0.40513741970062256,
-0.3743208944797516,
-0.7634884715080261,
-0.13149940967559814,
0.3202849328517914,
1.1485137939453125,
-0.685204267501831,
-0.1728854477405548,
-0.14306072890758514,
0.8115252256393433,
-0.47352975606918335,
-0.0905228853225708,
-0.5181010961532593,
0.059793345630168915,
0.26993218064308167,
-0.4709084630012512,
-0.3601902723312378,
-0.23723506927490234,
0.3665046989917755,
-0.4998256266117096,
0.20508037507534027,
0.07279732078313828,
0.05492005497217178,
0.6877231597900391,
-0.3941379487514496,
-0.4380975365638733,
-0.5864349007606506,
0.36722612380981445,
-0.12500184774398804,
0.15082448720932007,
0.05120627209544182,
0.5470080971717834,
-0.4742792546749115,
-0.9481237530708313,
-0.0024219511542469263,
-0.09514342993497849,
0.19765214622020721,
0.45856791734695435,
-0.012254258617758751,
0.3453772962093353,
-0.16123823821544647,
0.2289026528596878,
-0.3872928321361542,
0.21767747402191162,
-0.22665762901306152,
-0.0041818381287157536,
0.5088412761688232,
0.49867576360702515,
0.10789576172828674,
0.42767849564552307,
-0.6362937092781067,
0.2513885796070099,
-0.13332650065422058,
-0.15413528680801392,
-0.6837133169174194,
0.0907636284828186,
-0.3096103370189667,
0.46305137872695923,
-0.1619369089603424,
0.47259771823883057,
0.5405579805374146,
-0.2712763249874115,
0.4452905058860779,
-0.4093143939971924,
-0.5626930594444275,
0.10721199959516525,
0.5105904936790466,
0.6374819278717041,
-0.20055100321769714,
-0.18850836157798767,
-0.07853055000305176,
0.1584811508655548,
0.29054760932922363,
-0.5035538077354431,
-0.3829590678215027,
0.34565383195877075,
-0.4545825123786926,
-0.4832373857498169,
-0.3486998379230499,
-0.45486751198768616,
-0.8677343726158142,
-0.16574892401695251,
0.5462575554847717,
-0.257218599319458,
-0.13921934366226196,
0.2828659117221832,
-0.05733628198504448,
-0.15753068029880524,
0.7301363945007324,
-0.49981024861335754,
0.5910577178001404,
0.3574075996875763,
0.9514496922492981,
-0.543204128742218,
-0.40528929233551025,
-0.6290614604949951,
0.20322097837924957,
-0.47521498799324036,
0.7876673936843872,
-0.15639205276966095,
-0.6754574775695801,
-0.5159673094749451,
-0.14434045553207397,
-0.4753349721431732,
-0.8019915819168091,
0.36826178431510925,
-0.17784364521503448,
0.054138291627168655,
-0.35101762413978577,
-0.4508250653743744,
0.06415695697069168,
0.37554845213890076,
-0.7275699973106384,
0.2425682544708252,
0.1761869192123413,
-0.3808775246143341,
0.45649734139442444,
-0.9438381791114807,
-0.27591437101364136,
0.18713904917240143,
-0.4207088053226471,
-0.45137643814086914,
0.13267219066619873,
0.149039626121521,
0.4743923544883728,
-0.4292062520980835,
0.18772172927856445,
-0.20447689294815063,
-0.100609689950943,
0.5315506458282471,
-0.1054740697145462,
0.5985158085823059,
0.18229873478412628,
-0.23938634991645813,
0.6781970262527466,
-0.5570539236068726,
-0.05606290325522423,
0.0326063297688961,
-0.3452720642089844,
0.04464683309197426,
0.13628260791301727,
-0.41582992672920227,
0.254559725522995,
-0.08648315072059631,
-0.016052857041358948,
0.22622987627983093,
-0.03483614698052406,
0.34615492820739746,
0.9645787477493286,
0.3847579061985016,
0.48566892743110657,
-0.888974666595459,
0.6584702134132385,
-0.19954460859298706,
0.3879556655883789,
0.3417395055294037,
-0.29465222358703613,
-0.43247121572494507,
-0.7414125800132751,
0.12133970856666565,
0.47611358761787415,
-0.9145240783691406,
0.15271738171577454,
-0.16989681124687195,
-0.3541315793991089,
-0.4327858090400696,
-0.04373776540160179,
0.20371253788471222,
0.6812872886657715,
0.2766760587692261,
-0.42336174845695496,
-0.34030282497406006,
-0.8028718829154968,
0.10186733305454254,
-0.19332309067249298,
0.21712751686573029,
0.2432531714439392,
0.4165990352630615,
-0.5038278102874756,
0.719089150428772,
-0.22860576212406158,
-0.29619601368904114,
-0.2351289838552475,
-0.16048204898834229,
0.21505795419216156,
0.3718091547489166,
0.5299237370491028,
-1.070746898651123,
-0.4143480062484741,
0.07600688189268112,
-0.7594024538993835,
-0.19266289472579956,
-0.066307432949543,
-0.0819912701845169,
0.15172336995601654,
0.43373414874076843,
-0.42918112874031067,
0.13389362394809723,
0.7225051522254944,
-0.421840637922287,
0.45820125937461853,
-0.4165201485157013,
0.43161123991012573,
-1.2936017513275146,
0.03034527227282524,
-0.2313985973596573,
-0.4130460023880005,
-0.7485341429710388,
-0.15339067578315735,
-0.19746972620487213,
0.269161194562912,
-0.36318591237068176,
0.2881608009338379,
-0.5245717763900757,
-0.0013589637819677591,
-0.3605780303478241,
0.007086510770022869,
-0.17339341342449188,
0.30780303478240967,
-0.17218604683876038,
0.6753092408180237,
0.4640670716762543,
-0.5613688230514526,
0.5549766421318054,
0.3080052137374878,
-0.02505183219909668,
1.0913223028182983,
-0.3804242014884949,
0.03043161705136299,
-0.003742563771083951,
0.33293431997299194,
-0.7332887649536133,
-0.3357682526111603,
0.32749035954475403,
-0.3854753375053406,
0.0694195032119751,
-0.2045414298772812,
-0.27927109599113464,
-0.1559734344482422,
-0.24806681275367737,
0.4830755591392517,
0.26064857840538025,
-0.313098281621933,
1.0295847654342651,
0.4972490072250366,
-0.30312424898147583,
-0.38099777698516846,
-0.6942490339279175,
0.13332514464855194,
-0.20225661993026733,
-0.518676221370697,
0.44805827736854553,
-0.49174317717552185,
-0.5995358824729919,
0.05003440007567406,
-0.2649037539958954,
-0.13309258222579956,
0.2293882668018341,
0.6139790415763855,
0.26246801018714905,
-0.00034763733856379986,
0.022024746984243393,
-0.04923021048307419,
-0.22735872864723206,
0.07248129695653915,
-0.0006727853324264288,
0.10493370145559311,
-0.2550703287124634,
-0.5307247638702393,
-0.004126635380089283,
0.34296315908432007,
1.0807502269744873,
-0.20711448788642883,
0.7316207885742188,
0.2987157702445984,
-0.49566444754600525,
-0.20131456851959229,
-0.635608971118927,
-0.0717051550745964,
-0.4783495366573334,
0.46076714992523193,
-0.38340455293655396,
-0.7566415667533875,
0.6929805874824524,
-0.5310952663421631,
-0.002841104520484805,
0.1999955177307129,
1.1943292617797852,
-0.013703636825084686,
1.0130345821380615,
0.38682281970977783,
0.10121482610702515,
-0.09378203004598618,
-0.030835136771202087,
-0.37116995453834534,
-0.5699322819709778,
-0.4015636742115021,
-0.2113027721643448,
-0.308616578578949,
-0.3497115969657898,
-0.7300298810005188,
0.8468437790870667,
-0.24735452234745026,
0.07498771697282791,
-0.29882583022117615,
-0.5317298769950867,
0.4146244525909424,
0.17206352949142456,
0.3564148545265198,
0.39049801230430603,
-0.2291296422481537,
-0.6270291805267334,
0.2659871578216553,
-0.9222431182861328,
-0.06655662506818771,
0.8128592371940613,
0.1650470793247223,
0.5102299451828003,
0.3466465473175049,
0.7353054285049438,
0.42151936888694763,
0.47157934308052063,
-0.7130202651023865,
0.49129199981689453,
0.14000171422958374,
-0.41410428285598755,
0.05570608749985695,
-0.43486490845680237,
-1.083554744720459,
0.49035027623176575,
-0.42609357833862305,
-0.39263248443603516,
0.17681260406970978,
-0.03772697225213051,
-0.45664188265800476,
0.29051822423934937,
-0.5036004185676575,
0.6076525449752808,
-0.3182413578033447,
-0.4925158619880676,
-0.3210269808769226,
-0.8563908934593201,
-0.14771506190299988,
-0.35788026452064514,
0.3711857795715332,
-0.2269778996706009,
-0.590425968170166,
0.2967080771923065,
-0.4936143457889557,
0.610251247882843,
-0.05213763564825058,
0.24473412334918976,
0.12475934624671936,
0.15957306325435638,
0.3882676064968109,
-0.012879876419901848,
-0.3488817811012268,
-0.2038228064775467,
-0.0800669714808464,
-0.38209354877471924,
-0.46283048391342163,
0.7517828345298767,
-0.6163733005523682,
-0.4587477743625641,
-0.5689383149147034,
-0.7971714735031128,
-0.41159915924072266,
0.3185863792896271,
0.16625921428203583,
0.31562477350234985,
-0.3613503575325012,
0.1961168497800827,
0.3508400321006775,
0.30966052412986755,
0.37264829874038696,
0.7008711099624634,
0.01134546473622322,
-0.7941595315933228,
0.5358536243438721,
0.1258568912744522,
0.45871588587760925,
0.18216541409492493,
0.2156190127134323,
-0.050546012818813324,
-1.126662254333496,
-0.43132442235946655,
0.06927406787872314,
-0.7876781225204468,
-0.13791312277317047,
-0.2704797387123108,
0.028843315318226814,
0.05517503619194031,
-0.61463463306427,
-0.3021114468574524,
-0.094972163438797,
-0.057175200432538986,
-0.04230764880776405,
0.14092731475830078,
0.7484289407730103,
-0.04544663429260254,
-0.06441273540258408,
-0.6014859080314636,
0.231275275349617,
0.2227557748556137,
0.4332678020000458,
-0.42016005516052246,
-0.006707145832479,
-0.24286285042762756,
-0.14222702383995056,
-0.1473078727722168,
-0.9015138745307922,
0.019426584243774414,
-0.1801801323890686,
1.0117182731628418,
-0.032524678856134415,
0.16783271729946136,
0.43281805515289307,
-0.36854255199432373,
0.2684973180294037,
0.28254833817481995,
-0.5805754065513611,
0.31791579723358154,
-0.3716181218624115,
0.15436390042304993,
0.8649598956108093,
0.10540462285280228,
-0.08460459113121033,
0.08101595193147659,
-0.5350233912467957,
-0.4582861065864563,
0.5205774307250977,
0.5235636830329895,
-0.6428581476211548,
0.3380100131034851,
0.46636784076690674,
-0.0021916234400123358,
0.25051310658454895,
-0.29602301120758057,
-0.3421906530857086,
0.30385005474090576,
-0.39356479048728943,
-0.005846732761710882,
0.2264237254858017,
-0.7179222106933594,
-0.014251600950956345,
0.2965411841869354,
-0.4435266852378845,
0.0924539566040039,
0.5734080672264099,
-0.06173906847834587,
-0.41983672976493835,
0.05917446315288544,
0.6828230023384094,
1.0033763647079468,
-0.10160934925079346,
-0.07676085829734802,
0.5732811689376831,
-0.3259841501712799,
0.382877916097641,
0.3346825838088989,
0.37597131729125977,
-0.3341940641403198,
0.38785484433174133,
0.35763174295425415,
0.000325255241477862,
-0.6368675827980042,
0.33460092544555664,
-0.23894597589969635,
-0.5221993923187256,
0.10344045609235764,
0.1260967254638672,
0.1106853038072586,
0.6970502138137817,
0.2761002480983734,
0.6397868990898132,
0.13078342378139496,
-0.409060001373291,
0.38790932297706604,
0.25047487020492554,
-0.49996256828308105,
-0.07670359313488007,
0.44053980708122253,
0.504004716873169,
-0.37247440218925476,
-0.03096315637230873,
0.08847841620445251,
-0.34895530343055725,
0.8120818734169006,
0.29481372237205505,
0.7929583191871643,
-0.5258782505989075,
0.10815827548503876,
-0.32232069969177246,
0.31272217631340027,
-0.07416694611310959,
0.059985022991895676,
0.15322379767894745,
-0.7819538712501526,
-0.2793485224246979,
-0.0541888028383255,
-0.8862974047660828,
-0.22601401805877686,
-0.38244712352752686,
0.22545041143894196,
-0.6595273017883301,
-0.2900274395942688,
0.07252726703882217,
0.08528345078229904,
-0.5011465549468994,
0.22275008261203766,
-0.13349859416484833,
0.6523473262786865,
-0.4672752916812897,
0.5900077819824219,
1.1843069791793823,
-0.049363117665052414,
-0.6022206544876099,
-0.25032928586006165,
0.5944105982780457,
-0.8464890122413635,
-0.36937686800956726,
-0.09302841871976852,
-0.3202130198478699,
-0.08445186913013458,
-0.19720493257045746,
-0.6061830520629883,
1.5449329614639282,
0.5263227224349976,
-0.32376885414123535,
0.180739626288414,
-0.13469535112380981,
0.570942759513855,
-0.6805177330970764,
-0.0350610725581646,
0.32287847995758057,
0.22893355786800385,
0.3572828471660614,
-1.215715765953064,
0.26992663741111755,
-0.23056507110595703,
-0.44721534848213196,
0.1178378090262413,
-0.7166225910186768,
0.7309284806251526,
-0.640407145023346,
0.12093529105186462,
0.23671510815620422,
0.06265509873628616,
0.732196033000946,
0.6573797464370728,
0.7441231608390808,
0.2511560320854187,
0.8721873760223389,
0.07386446744203568,
0.7380834817886353,
-0.1239851787686348,
0.05731230229139328,
0.9115427732467651,
-0.5749147534370422,
0.2741253674030304,
0.5178890824317932,
-0.2818298935890198,
0.28897151350975037,
0.5054432153701782,
-0.07781144231557846,
0.3128943145275116,
0.059664417058229446,
-0.4427779018878937,
-0.27908986806869507,
-0.12852463126182556,
-0.34519049525260925,
0.27321240305900574,
0.47284823656082153,
-0.4937421977519989,
0.055788129568099976,
0.12459151446819305,
-0.06939554959535599,
0.10529066622257233,
-0.37385293841362,
1.0763781070709229,
0.07433175295591354,
-0.6813551187515259,
0.444286972284317,
-0.24073879420757294,
0.1756422519683838,
-0.5748053193092346,
-0.0286269448697567,
0.08814403414726257,
0.5224972367286682,
-0.3145110011100769,
-0.5692968368530273,
-0.1491754651069641,
-0.4922054708003998,
-0.36885741353034973,
0.026302004233002663,
0.7100604176521301,
-0.24493709206581116,
-0.4151209890842438,
0.3572920560836792,
0.9162380695343018,
-0.29540732502937317,
0.21018874645233154,
-1.013637661933899,
0.21250781416893005,
-0.04285687208175659,
0.03365660458803177,
0.2668597400188446,
0.35949066281318665,
0.09037263691425323,
0.9717411994934082,
0.5036323666572571,
0.15754109621047974,
-0.3223510682582855,
0.13868361711502075,
0.9230700731277466,
-0.40614053606987,
-0.4211912453174591,
-0.8781252503395081,
0.386569619178772,
0.031698327511548996,
0.0534176230430603,
0.4223633408546448,
0.43778467178344727,
0.2482738047838211,
0.274802565574646,
0.8385224938392639,
0.22985492646694183,
0.315157026052475,
-0.4303056299686432,
0.6911371946334839,
-0.5492557287216187,
0.36716315150260925,
-0.2673631012439728,
-0.6546846032142639,
-0.4769386351108551,
0.461652010679245,
0.17546284198760986,
0.1776866316795349,
0.6346771717071533,
0.4890576899051666,
0.1613989919424057,
-0.03185998648405075,
0.1373618096113205,
0.3424013555049896,
0.5455805063247681,
0.786869466304779,
0.5635507702827454,
0.006315364968031645,
0.4572175145149231,
-0.25922664999961853,
-0.7488071918487549,
-0.2937316298484802,
-0.7912479639053345,
-0.8288313746452332,
-0.398428738117218,
-0.47784504294395447,
-0.3780756890773773,
0.27536165714263916,
1.4829765558242798,
0.8414562940597534,
-0.43838679790496826,
-0.2877342104911804,
-0.10230445116758347,
0.15998885035514832,
-0.36897191405296326,
-0.08525053411722183,
0.2851414382457733,
0.08885061740875244,
-0.3265787661075592,
0.6932255625724792,
0.5214100480079651,
0.14778241515159607,
0.029000768437981606,
-0.5951046943664551,
-0.27533847093582153,
0.1434456706047058,
0.3854888677597046,
0.02014482021331787,
-0.5986194610595703,
-0.07816558331251144,
0.051846928894519806,
-0.2685113251209259,
0.16982914507389069,
0.7592759728431702,
-0.7327357530593872,
0.7501417994499207,
0.18545415997505188,
0.7380973696708679,
0.14530020952224731,
0.1007763221859932,
0.6888259053230286,
-0.2933874726295471,
-0.20411187410354614,
0.4516603946685791,
0.45467522740364075,
0.18205063045024872,
-0.12546293437480927,
0.8414869904518127,
0.396480917930603,
-0.8796109557151794,
-0.8156378269195557,
-0.09393221884965897,
-1.2637149095535278,
-0.24884237349033356,
0.8616166710853577,
0.09853678196668625,
0.05990065261721611,
-0.32298704981803894,
-0.42091527581214905,
0.13010260462760925,
-0.21922504901885986,
0.6419726014137268,
0.37916073203086853,
-0.5983362793922424,
0.03166119381785393,
-0.2706413269042969,
0.4625468850135803,
0.5509976148605347,
-0.8157252669334412,
-0.3478538990020752,
0.527095377445221,
0.37089893221855164,
0.1747143417596817,
1.0766969919204712,
0.003498729085549712,
0.6103132963180542,
-0.21141357719898224,
-0.28303632140159607,
-0.2829323709011078,
-0.33426910638809204,
-0.3387018144130707,
0.23673593997955322,
0.21270571649074554,
-0.333537220954895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13899v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13899v1
|
Towards Better Text-to-Image Generation Alignment via Attention Modulation
| 2024-04-22T06:18:37 | 2024-04-22T06:18:37 |
Yihang Wu, Xiao Cao, Kaixin Li, Zitan Chen, Haonan Wang, Lei Meng, Zhiyong Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM
|
In text-to-image generation tasks, the advancements of diffusion models have
facilitated the fidelity of generated results. However, these models encounter
challenges when processing text prompts containing multiple entities and
attributes. The uneven distribution of attention results in the issues of
entity leakage and attribute misalignment. Training from scratch to address
this issue requires numerous labeled data and is resource-consuming. Motivated
by this, we propose an attribution-focusing mechanism, a training-free
phase-wise mechanism by modulation of attention for diffusion model. One of our
core ideas is to guide the model to concentrate on the corresponding syntactic
components of the prompt at distinct timesteps. To achieve this, we incorporate
a temperature control mechanism within the early phases of the self-attention
modules to mitigate entity leakage issues. An object-focused masking scheme and
a phase-wise dynamic weight control mechanism are integrated into the
cross-attention modules, enabling the model to discern the affiliation of
semantic information between entities more effectively. The experimental
results in various alignment scenarios demonstrate that our model attain better
image-text alignment with minimal additional computational cost.
|
[
-0.2456343024969101,
-0.6014924645423889,
0.7346721887588501,
0.31651726365089417,
-0.5781499743461609,
-0.29454436898231506,
0.009534821845591068,
-0.24473105370998383,
0.006983024999499321,
0.39771905541419983,
-0.7013840079307556,
-0.25227078795433044,
-0.8134018182754517,
0.06291525065898895,
-0.5068824887275696,
0.913759708404541,
-0.36601170897483826,
-0.371050626039505,
-0.35257020592689514,
0.1086052805185318,
-0.4347515404224396,
0.16773778200149536,
-0.7596017122268677,
-0.5005596876144409,
0.80154949426651,
0.29855987429618835,
0.5929344892501831,
1.0938574075698853,
0.4376882016658783,
0.3020646572113037,
0.23116543889045715,
0.06171250715851784,
-0.3958605229854584,
0.2852112352848053,
-0.3347568213939667,
-0.3906683623790741,
-0.1896102875471115,
-0.07507869601249695,
0.7031150460243225,
0.13813677430152893,
-0.053518373519182205,
0.0909225344657898,
0.2647252380847931,
0.6157546043395996,
-0.7526572942733765,
-0.17377206683158875,
-0.8620610237121582,
0.012900988571345806,
-0.12202442437410355,
-0.17381992936134338,
-0.5557025074958801,
-0.1853719800710678,
0.056530311703681946,
-0.7963443398475647,
0.5578522682189941,
-0.023641211912035942,
0.8966914415359497,
0.7340795397758484,
-0.4544222056865692,
-0.05769729986786842,
-0.6010404229164124,
0.7782556414604187,
-0.24771086871623993,
0.34007447957992554,
0.10907582193613052,
-0.1327335089445114,
0.2284594625234604,
-0.4210263192653656,
-0.6267419457435608,
0.5121145248413086,
-0.0513169951736927,
0.2330692857503891,
0.007991072721779346,
-0.20675112307071686,
-0.04804958775639534,
0.028831038624048233,
-0.28776857256889343,
-0.22244802117347717,
-0.021049318835139275,
-0.05779062584042549,
0.3119495213031769,
0.05324622988700867,
0.115738645195961,
-0.27987685799598694,
-0.7529058456420898,
0.00010577496868791059,
-0.5156664848327637,
-0.23368458449840546,
0.3057991862297058,
0.10017623007297516,
-0.19521836936473846,
0.6082472801208496,
0.11568678915500641,
0.5027309060096741,
0.9272364974021912,
0.0568653829395771,
0.07666607201099396,
-0.3935885429382324,
-0.2429138571023941,
0.24466949701309204,
0.9110045433044434,
0.4958301782608032,
-0.07021186500787735,
-0.3396283686161041,
-0.1795310378074646,
-0.0007711363141424954,
0.4469219148159027,
-0.9237781763076782,
-0.09717388451099396,
0.11296376585960388,
-0.44148677587509155,
-0.5254859328269958,
-0.2282998263835907,
-0.7859969139099121,
-0.07878584414720535,
-0.17964671552181244,
0.4914635717868805,
-0.26043060421943665,
-0.22154828906059265,
-0.02602464146912098,
-0.2111167311668396,
0.11407535523176193,
0.2283734828233719,
-1.0978227853775024,
-0.11440005898475647,
0.342073529958725,
0.978987455368042,
-0.5129820108413696,
-0.049775782972574234,
-0.20028097927570343,
1.0028256177902222,
-0.028666218742728233,
1.0111554861068726,
-0.617340087890625,
-0.23046700656414032,
-0.0804579108953476,
0.05588429421186447,
-0.2029321938753128,
-0.26147204637527466,
0.007733437232673168,
-0.6278311014175415,
0.4293309450149536,
-0.13537588715553284,
-0.28673887252807617,
-0.042318668216466904,
0.18049530684947968,
-0.5999929308891296,
1.01114821434021,
-0.07271542400121689,
-0.9324942827224731,
0.4381316304206848,
-0.6139330863952637,
-0.4298095107078552,
0.07495708763599396,
-0.12526939809322357,
-0.6702939867973328,
-0.04977523162961006,
0.30501797795295715,
0.511023759841919,
-0.3474912941455841,
0.22655493021011353,
-0.00394577719271183,
0.14513270556926727,
0.40335676074028015,
-0.3247251510620117,
0.4528616964817047,
0.09876985102891922,
-0.5730444192886353,
0.22075065970420837,
-0.7285374402999878,
-0.018311750143766403,
0.2795565128326416,
-0.13146503269672394,
-0.30651193857192993,
-0.08892761915922165,
-0.1969805508852005,
0.25751322507858276,
0.1780177503824234,
-0.3157161474227905,
0.07182109355926514,
-0.2905115783214569,
0.3139294385910034,
0.5432899594306946,
0.39026927947998047,
1.18234121799469,
-0.12952549755573273,
0.5422592759132385,
0.39987921714782715,
0.10576128959655762,
-0.24806839227676392,
-0.38102591037750244,
-0.7424771785736084,
-0.3874170184135437,
0.1350587010383606,
0.596626341342926,
-0.9131295680999756,
0.24792253971099854,
0.057444870471954346,
-0.26675260066986084,
-0.6968581080436707,
0.2509155869483948,
0.4344421923160553,
0.8669107556343079,
0.3550594747066498,
-0.48717623949050903,
0.10876110196113586,
-0.8692713379859924,
-0.009374148212373257,
0.3257644772529602,
-0.013226024806499481,
0.20576509833335876,
0.2970975637435913,
-0.010918745771050453,
0.7160815000534058,
-0.49745720624923706,
-0.393133282661438,
-0.06079139932990074,
0.23983073234558105,
-0.22204835712909698,
0.8367090225219727,
0.3288516402244568,
-0.6719345450401306,
-0.659041702747345,
-0.12131290882825851,
-0.5309545397758484,
-0.07370636612176895,
-0.26107144355773926,
-0.7774536609649658,
0.12014760076999664,
0.5411014556884766,
-0.7959520220756531,
0.3469354212284088,
0.3256726861000061,
-0.3397444784641266,
0.017712144181132317,
0.08455844968557358,
0.2656455338001251,
-1.2304596900939941,
0.1381790190935135,
0.3305325508117676,
-0.35484564304351807,
-0.7022170424461365,
-0.09443023055791855,
0.467159628868103,
-0.2272796481847763,
-0.7185765504837036,
0.45280081033706665,
-0.7826094627380371,
0.4662822186946869,
-0.4000205397605896,
0.19036966562271118,
0.43732309341430664,
0.49788716435432434,
0.05773721635341644,
0.44584062695503235,
0.7443115711212158,
-0.5707757472991943,
0.3139446973800659,
0.3650570809841156,
-0.1171245127916336,
0.9705762267112732,
-0.6244960427284241,
0.4451032876968384,
-0.389544814825058,
0.20521552860736847,
-0.9582784175872803,
-0.16559453308582306,
0.8121224045753479,
-0.20438168942928314,
0.829348087310791,
-0.05759892612695694,
-0.3883020579814911,
0.03296716511249542,
-0.24736393988132477,
0.911389946937561,
0.2554720640182495,
-0.1873752325773239,
0.7375006675720215,
-0.02098943665623665,
-0.039139676839113235,
-0.4656152129173279,
-0.7380927205085754,
-0.12171304225921631,
-0.5248705148696899,
-0.7614148259162903,
0.6394439339637756,
0.10219835489988327,
0.15858907997608185,
0.2741292119026184,
0.10901175439357758,
-0.049776121973991394,
-0.15742535889148712,
0.04990721121430397,
0.2527730464935303,
-0.05068420246243477,
0.1551755964756012,
0.2677344083786011,
-0.31914323568344116,
0.025595778599381447,
-0.4946445822715759,
0.3635057210922241,
0.8887039422988892,
-0.2458624392747879,
-0.8377736806869507,
0.7771196365356445,
0.24555641412734985,
-0.30409979820251465,
0.9119598269462585,
0.6211205124855042,
-0.33317944407463074,
-0.16973361372947693,
-0.42180997133255005,
-0.322591096162796,
-0.529426097869873,
0.2126213014125824,
-0.10394496470689774,
-0.3607364296913147,
0.46473729610443115,
0.08474227041006088,
0.0891367495059967,
0.4870803654193878,
0.658079206943512,
-0.09540412575006485,
1.0720351934432983,
0.9766362905502319,
0.16957557201385498,
0.8621841669082642,
0.07060740888118744,
0.10662815719842911,
-0.8480837345123291,
-0.2919279634952545,
-0.3806976079940796,
-0.5592354536056519,
0.030233068391680717,
-0.7275404930114746,
0.2629154622554779,
-0.14701347053050995,
-0.054450295865535736,
0.1400614231824875,
-0.9551465511322021,
0.7098104357719421,
0.2425079345703125,
0.3251843750476837,
0.10374461859464645,
0.13223311305046082,
0.21131886541843414,
-0.19752857089042664,
-0.6265343427658081,
-0.24300764501094818,
0.8318632245063782,
0.31854361295700073,
0.9465857148170471,
-0.18981482088565826,
0.6831087470054626,
-0.1097894012928009,
0.18424326181411743,
-0.47630736231803894,
0.41885116696357727,
0.02332211472094059,
-0.6754181385040283,
-0.4187474250793457,
-0.215836301445961,
-0.7471190690994263,
0.1553734540939331,
-0.031780797988176346,
-0.5496051907539368,
0.24663443863391876,
0.4459182024002075,
-0.25840523838996887,
0.019401580095291138,
-0.8866425156593323,
0.940748929977417,
-0.04249949008226395,
-0.7672357559204102,
-0.09179943799972534,
-0.6651986241340637,
0.2571645677089691,
-0.20978140830993652,
-0.08157963305711746,
-0.20132790505886078,
-0.35672417283058167,
0.5308008790016174,
-0.2275705486536026,
0.9885398149490356,
-0.2031531035900116,
-0.511637270450592,
0.2013627290725708,
-0.005875768605619669,
0.7448176145553589,
0.00520322285592556,
0.010202626697719097,
-0.26324617862701416,
-0.5964745879173279,
-0.528030514717102,
-0.45169833302497864,
0.48942771553993225,
-0.5334259271621704,
-0.6796525716781616,
-0.08541544526815414,
-0.6671714186668396,
-0.014037217013537884,
0.19077745079994202,
0.8624601364135742,
0.24482403695583344,
0.11526144295930862,
-0.2066214680671692,
1.1190730333328247,
0.18799035251140594,
0.46543073654174805,
0.1865752637386322,
0.03394254669547081,
-0.3634148836135864,
0.947111964225769,
-0.3215104639530182,
0.8615840077400208,
0.4841994047164917,
-0.02298416756093502,
-0.24058787524700165,
-0.2805365324020386,
-0.5956332683563232,
0.3866084814071655,
-0.7951114773750305,
-0.5313703417778015,
-0.8138179779052734,
0.026023544371128082,
-0.6168249845504761,
-0.5152156949043274,
-0.4040898382663727,
-0.16934671998023987,
-0.8644105792045593,
0.25917676091194153,
0.31774842739105225,
0.3936610817909241,
0.32178404927253723,
0.5805147886276245,
-0.5056540369987488,
0.4724016785621643,
0.23938556015491486,
0.1512770801782608,
0.16869336366653442,
-0.5553141832351685,
-0.16371789574623108,
-0.2144399732351303,
-0.7185004949569702,
-1.2164525985717773,
0.24904735386371613,
0.4076233208179474,
0.2333979457616806,
0.5448586344718933,
-0.18105605244636536,
0.6014280915260315,
-0.5039560794830322,
0.6092775464057922,
0.7166149020195007,
-1.0427311658859253,
0.7296896576881409,
-0.2776872217655182,
0.7954146265983582,
0.32503050565719604,
0.3525253236293793,
-0.3738912343978882,
-0.9792476892471313,
-0.5069407820701599,
-0.9948405027389526,
0.8786407709121704,
0.12991109490394592,
0.14002664387226105,
0.14155028760433197,
0.5969665050506592,
0.21799179911613464,
0.24156276881694794,
-0.8644793033599854,
-0.2582859396934509,
-0.3868429958820343,
-0.550800621509552,
0.11191112548112869,
-0.19390524923801422,
-0.2160189002752304,
-0.11887089908123016,
0.8626270890235901,
-0.16586653888225555,
0.42492905259132385,
0.28510385751724243,
-0.12795861065387726,
-0.6570218205451965,
0.04278554767370224,
0.5962343811988831,
0.2484075129032135,
0.3837254047393799,
0.29156365990638733,
-0.016444573178887367,
-0.4328429698944092,
0.3818438649177551,
0.004337836056947708,
-0.6037726998329163,
-0.023056112229824066,
-0.11134491115808487,
0.8603407144546509,
0.20623767375946045,
0.15339916944503784,
0.4332455098628998,
0.005488844588398933,
-0.4170306921005249,
0.40605124831199646,
0.12856732308864594,
0.2485586553812027,
0.39139866828918457,
0.19662722945213318,
0.11510830372571945,
0.07482575625181198,
-0.2201099991798401,
0.0034905513748526573,
0.5940542817115784,
-0.4658833146095276,
-0.2362249791622162,
1.1207404136657715,
0.3767078220844269,
-0.05151846632361412,
0.45716536045074463,
0.015877600759267807,
-0.5142648816108704,
0.5555840730667114,
0.7259256839752197,
0.9315425753593445,
-0.3967786431312561,
0.35416412353515625,
0.2707868814468384,
0.2993319630622864,
-0.12166228890419006,
0.12277426570653915,
-0.25098127126693726,
-0.6429709792137146,
-0.25921523571014404,
-0.255073219537735,
-0.014520088210701942,
-0.3018701374530792,
-0.30191659927368164,
0.3302445411682129,
-0.33731862902641296,
-0.2741699814796448,
0.12227660417556763,
-0.5844501256942749,
-0.5510207414627075,
0.26440414786338806,
0.22984986007213593,
0.4434727430343628,
-0.8924331068992615,
0.7892380356788635,
0.4845624566078186,
-0.16427640616893768,
-0.703602135181427,
0.13439570367336273,
-0.18255615234375,
-0.7696024775505066,
0.42132601141929626,
0.30699753761291504,
-0.017296189442276955,
0.2488357275724411,
-0.7971072793006897,
-1.0179481506347656,
1.059977412223816,
0.4244335889816284,
-0.5517582297325134,
-0.18320024013519287,
0.16336698830127716,
0.12488830834627151,
-0.6154846549034119,
-0.1383882761001587,
0.2461610734462738,
0.4120822846889496,
0.28538331389427185,
-0.4708031713962555,
0.4467662274837494,
-0.10718230903148651,
0.016707532107830048,
0.5780738592147827,
-0.7830592393875122,
0.41583094000816345,
-0.17532780766487122,
-0.5662692785263062,
-0.24328741431236267,
0.9350857734680176,
-0.10950686782598495,
0.30528053641319275,
0.7014414668083191,
0.6165010929107666,
0.43109825253486633,
-0.06624647229909897,
0.6482093334197998,
-0.20653627812862396,
0.09379464387893677,
0.9223120212554932,
-0.28576818108558655,
0.31499239802360535,
0.904255747795105,
0.2830159664154053,
0.38955163955688477,
0.39544206857681274,
-0.14394477009773254,
0.9988856911659241,
-0.016816722229123116,
-0.3560578227043152,
-0.18606320023536682,
-0.30648258328437805,
-0.18260598182678223,
-0.2978328466415405,
0.10184694081544876,
-0.6324456930160522,
-0.1379925161600113,
0.2126680165529251,
-0.12903831899166107,
-0.048099927604198456,
-0.3271471858024597,
0.9954511523246765,
-0.04333207756280899,
-0.820102334022522,
0.3803902864456177,
-0.25197044014930725,
0.694900631904602,
-0.4771576523780823,
0.3708626627922058,
0.1032041609287262,
0.049932777881622314,
-0.321074515581131,
-0.7043512463569641,
0.2336522340774536,
0.0033050868660211563,
-0.7009356021881104,
-0.618151068687439,
0.7719823122024536,
-0.917111873626709,
-0.44563671946525574,
-0.14363615214824677,
0.06101582199335098,
-0.0950949564576149,
-0.15541303157806396,
-0.696762204170227,
0.08718124777078629,
0.1060139387845993,
-0.3585917353630066,
0.24665533006191254,
0.7397143244743347,
0.10546455532312393,
0.34947726130485535,
0.17331215739250183,
-0.13230156898498535,
0.48954564332962036,
0.010826922953128815,
0.672122597694397,
-0.45338574051856995,
-0.5315085649490356,
-0.874983549118042,
0.6336934566497803,
-0.01537356711924076,
-0.21310313045978546,
0.2876488268375397,
0.29443588852882385,
0.45917123556137085,
-0.08668654412031174,
0.540136456489563,
0.007980613969266415,
0.08614755421876907,
-0.5780001282691956,
0.6842886805534363,
-0.6875967383384705,
-0.3393896222114563,
-0.18853308260440826,
-1.1638349294662476,
-0.10687483847141266,
0.23185297846794128,
-0.008904102258384228,
-0.1920928657054901,
0.9377685189247131,
0.7029975056648254,
-0.062174003571271896,
-0.33771294355392456,
0.1661568284034729,
-0.2821730375289917,
0.26592501997947693,
0.5457326173782349,
0.5530417561531067,
-0.41300031542778015,
0.6968489289283752,
-0.4743262529373169,
-0.10656735301017761,
0.09743430465459824,
-1.0850964784622192,
-0.7789759635925293,
-0.774590253829956,
-0.8445477485656738,
-0.24752642214298248,
-0.17394165694713593,
0.47492608428001404,
0.7824147343635559,
-0.39993783831596375,
0.3166615068912506,
-0.15272557735443115,
-0.17475926876068115,
-0.05787044018507004,
-0.23240935802459717,
0.20934143662452698,
-0.4379647970199585,
-0.8295154571533203,
-0.11092497408390045,
0.5428438782691956,
0.5300151705741882,
-0.2313980609178543,
0.23099587857723236,
-0.17466621100902557,
0.18320873379707336,
0.26034820079803467,
-0.035250525921583176,
-0.5706958174705505,
0.0031334219966083765,
-0.19695092737674713,
-0.4641452729701996,
0.2606537640094757,
0.9851778149604797,
-0.31530311703681946,
0.1845506876707077,
0.4076443016529083,
0.3675346374511719,
0.46821364760398865,
0.23780828714370728,
0.6448808312416077,
-1.0187602043151855,
0.28603190183639526,
-0.0032107371371239424,
0.010468300431966782,
0.5785532593727112,
-0.9235565662384033,
0.038365770131349564,
0.11533985286951065,
-0.6215432286262512,
-0.44926440715789795,
0.18545833230018616,
-1.1012803316116333,
-0.08407460898160934,
1.042140007019043,
0.11403470486402512,
-0.6305269002914429,
0.1620488315820694,
-0.2933497130870819,
0.6571394801139832,
-0.7205149531364441,
0.9570583701133728,
0.7156738638877869,
0.07839684188365936,
-0.42442506551742554,
-0.2329234629869461,
0.500339150428772,
0.6860968470573425,
-0.8390400409698486,
0.09663630276918411,
0.4023667871952057,
0.27726152539253235,
0.22223509848117828,
0.4535254240036011,
-0.08794791996479034,
0.3104240596294403,
-0.32925885915756226,
0.2925826907157898,
0.28506726026535034,
-0.30481579899787903,
-0.26395344734191895,
0.2511761784553528,
-0.21620088815689087,
-0.4064134955406189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13885v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13885v1
|
Surveying Attitudinal Alignment Between Large Language Models Vs. Humans Towards 17 Sustainable Development Goals
| 2024-04-22T05:12:52 | 2024-04-22T05:12:52 |
Qingyang Wu, Ying Xu, Tingsong Xiao, Yunze Xiao, Yitong Li, Tianyang Wang, Yichi Zhang, Shanghai Zhong, Yuwei Zhang, Wei Lu, Yifan Yang
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as potent tools for advancing the
United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). However, the attitudinal
disparities between LLMs and humans towards these goals can pose significant
challenges. This study conducts a comprehensive review and analysis of the
existing literature on the attitudes of LLMs towards the 17 SDGs, emphasizing
the comparison between their attitudes and support for each goal and those of
humans. We examine the potential disparities, primarily focusing on aspects
such as understanding and emotions, cultural and regional differences, task
objective variations, and factors considered in the decision-making process.
These disparities arise from the underrepresentation and imbalance in LLM
training data, historical biases, quality issues, lack of contextual
understanding, and skewed ethical values reflected. The study also investigates
the risks and harms that may arise from neglecting the attitudes of LLMs
towards the SDGs, including the exacerbation of social inequalities, racial
discrimination, environmental destruction, and resource wastage. To address
these challenges, we propose strategies and recommendations to guide and
regulate the application of LLMs, ensuring their alignment with the principles
and goals of the SDGs, and therefore creating a more just, inclusive, and
sustainable future.
|
[
-0.4073133170604706,
-0.3314386308193207,
0.6545373201370239,
-0.12286967039108276,
-0.22237665951251984,
0.7055509686470032,
-0.42572805285453796,
-0.4187552332878113,
0.09854510426521301,
0.358167827129364,
-0.42447027564048767,
-0.552704393863678,
-1.0111534595489502,
0.06832566857337952,
0.009191353805363178,
0.7910691499710083,
0.0037253329064697027,
0.13109144568443298,
-0.18120403587818146,
-0.12853017449378967,
-0.36337360739707947,
-0.25543615221977234,
-0.4770399034023285,
-0.5505855083465576,
0.568687915802002,
0.3776158094406128,
0.7914962768554688,
0.5377552509307861,
0.6116495728492737,
0.28267648816108704,
-0.5863258242607117,
0.05526011437177658,
-0.47603839635849,
-0.23049892485141754,
-0.23594486713409424,
-0.2739764153957367,
-0.3535885512828827,
0.22153668105602264,
0.697838544845581,
0.7548691630363464,
-0.06695118546485901,
0.5116909146308899,
0.2778269052505493,
0.6454783082008362,
-0.41409289836883545,
-0.14765533804893494,
-0.5460034012794495,
0.06799046695232391,
-0.2026500552892685,
0.04880594462156296,
0.1662527322769165,
-0.3141826093196869,
-0.16188685595989227,
-0.30876967310905457,
-0.0008178300922736526,
0.07725957781076431,
0.7229288816452026,
0.5120865702629089,
-0.692807674407959,
-0.41369590163230896,
-0.20428428053855896,
1.1424754858016968,
-0.8454017639160156,
0.38844653964042664,
0.4158843457698822,
-0.21200904250144958,
-0.3434836268424988,
-0.19941431283950806,
-0.6563108563423157,
0.16669116914272308,
0.3232775926589966,
0.21012859046459198,
0.04247167333960533,
0.07895895838737488,
0.41683655977249146,
0.20082414150238037,
-0.3847396969795227,
0.47778555750846863,
-0.5338741540908813,
-0.1105036810040474,
0.9406652450561523,
0.09420766681432724,
0.17302536964416504,
-0.5305702686309814,
-0.5388078093528748,
0.04722202196717262,
-1.0023746490478516,
0.17467236518859863,
0.7640630006790161,
0.4603278338909149,
-0.3267116844654083,
0.6456909775733948,
-0.014467785134911537,
0.5034632682800293,
0.04139842092990875,
-0.2705724239349365,
0.1807851940393448,
-0.515606701374054,
0.18520894646644592,
0.1855810135602951,
0.7115150690078735,
0.7907429337501526,
0.422252357006073,
0.06456248462200165,
-0.28982508182525635,
0.42805784940719604,
0.4165944755077362,
-0.4487989544868469,
0.23333114385604858,
0.07085282355546951,
-0.5700029730796814,
-0.118039071559906,
0.002738146111369133,
-0.651888370513916,
-0.6807858943939209,
-0.8475518226623535,
-0.22566121816635132,
-0.010346601717174053,
-0.13806241750717163,
0.07763954252004623,
0.2056848108768463,
0.5050783157348633,
0.40100327134132385,
-0.683504045009613,
0.1406303346157074,
0.9001694917678833,
0.7696019411087036,
-0.2114853709936142,
-0.030803831294178963,
-0.06786446273326874,
0.028817782178521156,
-0.30260902643203735,
0.4582347571849823,
-0.5002582669258118,
-0.7252952456474304,
-0.12659123539924622,
-0.18028226494789124,
0.12386009097099304,
-0.46133846044540405,
0.7843782901763916,
0.03118029423058033,
-0.0426943264901638,
-0.9485929608345032,
-0.3988265097141266,
0.013109272345900536,
0.24173139035701752,
-0.2422482967376709,
1.0114591121673584,
-0.3304107189178467,
-0.46482473611831665,
0.534727156162262,
-0.5654056668281555,
-0.22475053369998932,
-0.031664539128541946,
-0.3803529739379883,
-0.21952614188194275,
0.36949366331100464,
-0.07396113127470016,
0.4906788170337677,
-0.6109152436256409,
0.6595079898834229,
-0.36373451352119446,
-0.27139756083488464,
0.13066111505031586,
-0.47322022914886475,
1.0576304197311401,
0.3514493405818939,
-0.11423812061548233,
0.31138724088668823,
-0.6557032465934753,
0.04575330391526222,
0.04557901993393898,
-0.5042154788970947,
-0.21038180589675903,
0.49540120363235474,
0.031019391492009163,
0.37616974115371704,
0.5274729132652283,
-0.6476510167121887,
0.1905926614999771,
0.15478552877902985,
0.890596866607666,
1.131589412689209,
-0.2475871592760086,
0.44938910007476807,
-0.4195699691772461,
0.4169347882270813,
-0.09472663700580597,
0.4648315906524658,
0.4446529150009155,
-0.381435751914978,
-0.37563082575798035,
0.00585812097415328,
-0.062079332768917084,
0.35519295930862427,
-0.15205375850200653,
0.8132132291793823,
-0.43642786145210266,
-0.4432465732097626,
-0.6373196840286255,
0.46668723225593567,
0.12652821838855743,
0.3588418662548065,
0.17882035672664642,
-0.2355789989233017,
-0.4442642033100128,
-0.6396015882492065,
-0.2398938685655594,
-0.5818944573402405,
-0.03555998206138611,
0.056752871721982956,
0.6584690809249878,
-0.32692280411720276,
0.7157447934150696,
-0.11367692053318024,
-0.3148857653141022,
-0.07698389142751694,
-0.2909835875034332,
0.010519090108573437,
0.4848201870918274,
0.4369863271713257,
-1.1389096975326538,
-0.26977723836898804,
-0.041345417499542236,
-0.6836440563201904,
-0.13312213122844696,
0.2642740309238434,
0.17671824991703033,
0.05832486227154732,
0.5013889670372009,
-0.5461651682853699,
0.14729148149490356,
0.6462808847427368,
-0.3143020570278168,
0.36896076798439026,
-0.07154993712902069,
0.3288803696632385,
-0.9692419171333313,
-0.09678035229444504,
0.478486567735672,
0.060253605246543884,
-0.3569525480270386,
-0.16942957043647766,
0.07770505547523499,
-0.06983240693807602,
-0.3156448304653168,
0.5181986093521118,
-0.5017955303192139,
-0.08300986886024475,
0.12584587931632996,
0.22610655426979065,
-0.1444799304008484,
-0.08878937363624573,
0.029930127784609795,
0.6709134578704834,
0.258762925863266,
-0.41775795817375183,
0.4948486387729645,
0.3911101818084717,
-0.517859160900116,
0.8628906011581421,
-0.6790079474449158,
0.1327919065952301,
-0.33361759781837463,
0.3420470058917999,
-0.9006331562995911,
-0.059484727680683136,
0.20998549461364746,
-0.589062511920929,
0.08010447770357132,
0.10264639556407928,
-0.4358464777469635,
-0.6167645454406738,
-0.5187117457389832,
0.30283185839653015,
0.5106334090232849,
-0.09488127380609512,
0.38566240668296814,
0.5797037482261658,
-0.304195374250412,
-0.6183759570121765,
-0.750252366065979,
0.37149250507354736,
-0.8168343901634216,
-0.5896105170249939,
0.4038061201572418,
0.05716137960553169,
-0.6865403056144714,
-0.22407689690589905,
-0.33056995272636414,
0.450359582901001,
0.0450187548995018,
0.3262260854244232,
0.17167538404464722,
0.05584927648305893,
-0.060909204185009,
-0.4661749601364136,
-0.1081448569893837,
0.16900226473808289,
-0.0827939510345459,
0.3676718771457672,
-0.07719188183546066,
-0.42345938086509705,
-0.03814052417874336,
0.29539763927459717,
0.7133572697639465,
-0.35723569989204407,
0.6667977571487427,
0.4584123492240906,
-0.3661249279975891,
0.28560930490493774,
-0.6640306711196899,
-0.09112544357776642,
-0.42623645067214966,
0.33832064270973206,
-0.11204057186841965,
-0.7554764747619629,
0.7477619647979736,
-0.08716239035129547,
0.12978382408618927,
0.0644642561674118,
0.4560413658618927,
-0.42646297812461853,
0.8536190390586853,
0.5209546089172363,
-0.322030633687973,
0.5430769324302673,
-0.08944027870893478,
0.32732415199279785,
-1.1965453624725342,
-0.422993540763855,
-0.5643246173858643,
-0.5439285039901733,
-0.6359025239944458,
-0.43995922803878784,
0.25094830989837646,
0.21632251143455505,
-0.5133437514305115,
-0.03278893604874611,
-0.5357721447944641,
0.3152540624141693,
0.21997292339801788,
-0.0985194519162178,
0.16575059294700623,
-0.05840466171503067,
0.13210353255271912,
-0.3111589252948761,
-0.5818097591400146,
-1.1389622688293457,
0.8558045625686646,
0.44312331080436707,
1.0767630338668823,
0.2889471650123596,
0.6683484315872192,
0.6500176191329956,
0.033431343734264374,
-0.7121405601501465,
0.5333817601203918,
-0.19507330656051636,
-0.53315669298172,
-0.4277133643627167,
-0.2273433804512024,
-0.7390028834342957,
0.06853848695755005,
-0.14378474652767181,
-0.9185377955436707,
0.20509253442287445,
0.024425581097602844,
-0.2162487953901291,
0.36863642930984497,
-0.5220767855644226,
0.7413967251777649,
-0.5221582055091858,
-0.43685027956962585,
-0.305217444896698,
-0.8768277764320374,
0.018046842887997627,
-0.10324256867170334,
0.581389844417572,
-0.6281389594078064,
-0.23654013872146606,
0.689551830291748,
-0.13195504248142242,
1.1382356882095337,
-0.2372940629720688,
-0.7060499787330627,
0.3757692575454712,
-0.5078818202018738,
0.5463301539421082,
-0.10040253400802612,
-0.3121575713157654,
0.13388413190841675,
-0.15173475444316864,
-0.5438695549964905,
-0.028569722548127174,
0.7787630558013916,
-1.0010453462600708,
-0.69522625207901,
-0.5773833990097046,
-0.3417919874191284,
0.009733675047755241,
-0.0123019153252244,
0.10135442018508911,
0.08592292666435242,
-0.2690446376800537,
-0.0006064431509003043,
0.8438743948936462,
-0.40723538398742676,
0.3497295081615448,
0.24926821887493134,
-0.026051752269268036,
-0.15165892243385315,
0.8740748763084412,
0.3672444522380829,
0.7115428447723389,
0.05271954461932182,
0.20353832840919495,
-0.8025932908058167,
-0.6304774880409241,
-0.3302273154258728,
0.1896490901708603,
-0.7947608232498169,
-0.2578692138195038,
-0.18996277451515198,
0.009245503693819046,
-0.46040070056915283,
-0.5953866243362427,
-0.25608277320861816,
0.38793694972991943,
-0.33530014753341675,
-0.06840260326862335,
0.36144909262657166,
0.7215959429740906,
-0.14633604884147644,
0.11572246998548508,
-0.5421933531761169,
0.25054579973220825,
-0.17252708971500397,
0.04560348764061928,
-0.12675875425338745,
-0.4757941961288452,
0.1440582573413849,
0.5559664368629456,
-0.41267091035842896,
-0.5683078169822693,
-0.052162595093250275,
0.000054911564802750945,
0.5465426445007324,
0.48043379187583923,
0.3356723189353943,
0.8600597977638245,
-0.3825009763240814,
0.8427582383155823,
0.47255200147628784,
-0.9252312779426575,
0.24854286015033722,
-0.614888072013855,
0.4489270746707916,
0.43850457668304443,
0.4112480580806732,
-0.8883212804794312,
-0.10497190058231354,
-0.33209145069122314,
-0.8959696292877197,
0.4721936583518982,
-0.06721857190132141,
0.18023844063282013,
0.10921987891197205,
0.07413480430841446,
-0.03595932573080063,
0.2216111570596695,
-0.7045658230781555,
-0.05812123045325279,
0.01388359535485506,
-0.41490352153778076,
-0.20977328717708588,
-0.10641695559024811,
-0.12598255276679993,
-0.0960281565785408,
0.5560287237167358,
-0.10229380428791046,
0.02032250165939331,
-0.22968795895576477,
0.005554595962166786,
-0.3418883681297302,
0.5678718686103821,
0.5262478590011597,
0.7879605293273926,
0.020865444093942642,
0.13603584468364716,
0.49134376645088196,
-0.5002838373184204,
0.6320716142654419,
-0.19717024266719818,
-0.18121418356895447,
-0.6610718369483948,
0.20572519302368164,
0.5349122881889343,
0.10714013874530792,
-0.5683389902114868,
0.0036343566607683897,
0.07075625658035278,
-0.010415235534310341,
-0.2610038220882416,
-0.1988253891468048,
0.4732075035572052,
0.2942163944244385,
0.3776228725910187,
-0.05413783714175224,
-0.43262454867362976,
-0.7345536947250366,
-0.35138803720474243,
0.48842430114746094,
-0.36819028854370117,
-0.14254623651504517,
0.5421069860458374,
0.4329289197921753,
-0.3568107783794403,
0.5270981788635254,
0.018597913905978203,
-0.4768696427345276,
0.5060378909111023,
0.2656709849834442,
0.4554300904273987,
-0.23435205221176147,
0.24521797895431519,
0.15107461810112,
0.5103726387023926,
-0.1467900574207306,
0.4399178922176361,
0.06351099163293839,
-0.9610274434089661,
-0.5244295597076416,
-0.9067725539207458,
-0.04981556534767151,
-0.001165717956610024,
-0.718364953994751,
0.2415647804737091,
-0.3368532657623291,
-0.4533250629901886,
0.12053210288286209,
0.36981719732284546,
-0.5875868201255798,
0.24738305807113647,
0.22086238861083984,
0.4258490800857544,
-0.8044089078903198,
0.5363763570785522,
1.065576434135437,
-0.30680936574935913,
-0.44520360231399536,
-0.05538969114422798,
0.4653637409210205,
-0.9531720280647278,
0.4281873404979706,
-0.021654577925801277,
-0.21083998680114746,
0.11365851759910583,
-0.35729044675827026,
-0.8704047203063965,
0.9287810921669006,
0.4743626117706299,
-0.851296067237854,
-0.22076109051704407,
0.49215275049209595,
0.36917009949684143,
-0.16703678667545319,
-0.2634440064430237,
0.5292931199073792,
0.9571496844291687,
-0.11020387709140778,
-0.8682534098625183,
-0.08094458281993866,
0.20335760712623596,
0.17947757244110107,
0.603438138961792,
-0.9473520517349243,
0.5497158169746399,
-0.4178633987903595,
-0.1724606454372406,
-0.04532263055443764,
0.4900166392326355,
0.32737743854522705,
0.03921475261449814,
0.42963576316833496,
0.3710595965385437,
0.6649400591850281,
-0.37030306458473206,
0.8962109088897705,
-0.27864792943000793,
0.3657512962818146,
0.4626600742340088,
-0.4794435203075409,
0.460201233625412,
0.7330071926116943,
-0.7388741970062256,
-0.3003765642642975,
1.0522557497024536,
0.05326676741242409,
0.2994201183319092,
0.7224375605583191,
-0.38376685976982117,
-0.21102337539196014,
-0.5701343417167664,
-0.3239104449748993,
0.6189541220664978,
0.6612061858177185,
-0.07333327829837799,
-0.27753472328186035,
-0.1366640329360962,
-0.029057767242193222,
0.4782567620277405,
-0.6309216022491455,
0.5639192461967468,
0.41872382164001465,
-0.43586868047714233,
0.348084419965744,
0.0635463297367096,
1.0398074388504028,
-0.6249784827232361,
0.24418318271636963,
0.022886671125888824,
0.2241634577512741,
-0.42497339844703674,
-0.9586012363433838,
0.3515976667404175,
0.25746431946754456,
-0.2509540617465973,
-0.46668219566345215,
0.5221977829933167,
-0.5066558122634888,
-0.4777091145515442,
0.1824447065591812,
0.4312429428100586,
0.06394857913255692,
0.25005921721458435,
-0.8527002334594727,
0.5141260027885437,
0.19710664451122284,
0.09468252211809158,
0.30431368947029114,
0.396269291639328,
-0.3929328918457031,
0.7510107159614563,
0.31502336263656616,
0.33285263180732727,
0.1172083392739296,
-0.026112383231520653,
0.4286003112792969,
-0.5659670233726501,
-0.3280993700027466,
-1.1013290882110596,
0.4106910228729248,
-0.04173944890499115,
-0.5139747262001038,
0.8887370228767395,
0.39347490668296814,
0.9151363968849182,
0.20417186617851257,
0.8121163845062256,
-0.3023272752761841,
0.08488964289426804,
-0.40004563331604004,
0.6476224064826965,
-0.5554930567741394,
0.10294094681739807,
-0.404657781124115,
-1.3329575061798096,
0.14478251338005066,
0.8357738256454468,
-0.4267604947090149,
0.2477947622537613,
0.04918806999921799,
0.5028022527694702,
0.1756633222103119,
-0.12942887842655182,
0.10576717555522919,
-0.19653764367103577,
0.39346468448638916,
0.32773861289024353,
0.9890010356903076,
0.02088293433189392,
-0.09529364854097366,
0.214422807097435,
0.0823523998260498,
0.20430921018123627,
-0.991301417350769,
-0.5969335436820984,
-0.5485155582427979,
-0.5597348213195801,
-0.08936004340648651,
0.10765404999256134,
1.3229783773422241,
0.3370162546634674,
-0.6212291121482849,
-0.4902048110961914,
0.008229769766330719,
0.2607761025428772,
0.16904187202453613,
-0.1158599704504013,
0.20754411816596985,
0.18681728839874268,
-0.8718330264091492,
-0.2054208517074585,
0.16999204456806183,
0.2846616804599762,
-0.5853261947631836,
-0.36628955602645874,
-0.4504810571670532,
-0.12098261713981628,
0.5600509643554688,
0.3587060570716858,
-1.0760451555252075,
-0.537148654460907,
-0.20978091657161713,
-0.14071369171142578,
-0.0493142195045948,
0.5100613236427307,
-0.3217177987098694,
-0.06008165702223778,
0.22228007018566132,
0.4517892003059387,
-0.07100996375083923,
0.008382996544241905,
0.559026300907135,
-0.44232097268104553,
0.10479101538658142,
0.323211669921875,
0.37484610080718994,
0.7531641125679016,
-0.0651525929570198,
0.4562104344367981,
-0.029828382655978203,
-0.5310466289520264,
-1.0124088525772095,
0.3462752103805542,
-0.5856553316116333,
0.004764671437442303,
1.273401141166687,
0.07964657247066498,
0.0710323378443718,
0.007562366314232349,
-0.18916481733322144,
0.3021257519721985,
-0.5008798837661743,
0.8594915270805359,
0.915070652961731,
0.025167783722281456,
-0.05527079477906227,
-0.4696044921875,
0.6186731457710266,
0.3441660702228546,
-0.7096637487411499,
0.22583968937397003,
0.6869689226150513,
0.17171287536621094,
0.1804223507642746,
0.32066062092781067,
-0.09930359572172165,
-0.42205509543418884,
-0.29257509112358093,
0.20658360421657562,
0.4302772879600525,
-0.12886172533035278,
-0.1372164934873581,
-0.3809942901134491,
0.23244206607341766,
0.07431982457637787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14461v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14461v2
|
Competition Report: Finding Universal Jailbreak Backdoors in Aligned LLMs
| 2024-04-22T05:08:53 | 2024-06-06T12:45:52 |
Javier Rando, Francesco Croce, Kryštof Mitka, Stepan Shabalin, Maksym Andriushchenko, Nicolas Flammarion, Florian Tramèr
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Large language models are aligned to be safe, preventing users from
generating harmful content like misinformation or instructions for illegal
activities. However, previous work has shown that the alignment process is
vulnerable to poisoning attacks. Adversaries can manipulate the safety training
data to inject backdoors that act like a universal sudo command: adding the
backdoor string to any prompt enables harmful responses from models that,
otherwise, behave safely. Our competition, co-located at IEEE SaTML 2024,
challenged participants to find universal backdoors in several large language
models. This report summarizes the key findings and promising ideas for future
research.
|
[
0.11895808577537537,
-0.3648434579372406,
0.8299683928489685,
0.041912179440259933,
0.089105986058712,
0.13754363358020782,
0.10178948193788528,
-0.6762510538101196,
-0.294028639793396,
0.9752531051635742,
-0.4559619724750519,
-0.876265823841095,
-0.44355157017707825,
0.019726524129509926,
-0.615397036075592,
0.8780527710914612,
-0.10343638807535172,
0.15218082070350647,
-0.1592404544353485,
-0.15862542390823364,
-0.8175392150878906,
-0.8239010572433472,
-0.18992850184440613,
-0.06732550263404846,
0.462238073348999,
0.5400825142860413,
0.7081451416015625,
0.7577411532402039,
0.7793850898742676,
0.33149731159210205,
0.0016933623701334,
-0.2639971077442169,
-0.22140942513942719,
0.44106635451316833,
-0.4331250488758087,
-0.6284540891647339,
-0.4701814353466034,
0.2915688455104828,
0.5276522040367126,
0.24852152168750763,
-0.34810471534729004,
0.03828967362642288,
-0.19002145528793335,
0.6643561124801636,
-0.6670562624931335,
-0.5617213845252991,
-0.944416880607605,
-0.05145012214779854,
-0.3800516724586487,
0.142592191696167,
-0.6413232684135437,
-0.43907850980758667,
-0.3210236430168152,
-0.26298269629478455,
0.020866574719548225,
0.36041221022605896,
0.8887209892272949,
0.34285202622413635,
-0.17856843769550323,
-0.34952765703201294,
-0.29764455556869507,
0.7476539015769958,
-0.8039757609367371,
0.5668409466743469,
-0.06867031008005142,
0.1510723978281021,
-0.4849618971347809,
-0.48314571380615234,
-0.304803729057312,
-0.25644034147262573,
0.0939718633890152,
-0.0956387147307396,
-0.2963537573814392,
0.1155812218785286,
0.03362499922513962,
0.052474021911621094,
-0.6404608488082886,
0.848253071308136,
-0.31523099541664124,
-0.2283804565668106,
0.93431156873703,
0.5068870782852173,
0.8169630765914917,
-0.027947941794991493,
-0.49684417247772217,
0.014076636172831059,
-1.2375421524047852,
-0.1313336342573166,
0.6646910905838013,
0.2309964895248413,
-0.17302222549915314,
0.6498101353645325,
0.13640591502189636,
0.6440033316612244,
-0.2722471058368683,
0.08069366216659546,
-0.03111514076590538,
-0.22118966281414032,
-0.0842573270201683,
0.27711379528045654,
0.8082535266876221,
0.42783457040786743,
0.09197361022233963,
-0.45253637433052063,
-0.35141846537590027,
-0.08015304803848267,
0.40610700845718384,
-0.5957390069961548,
0.059416599571704865,
0.39737892150878906,
-0.17696484923362732,
-0.5277860164642334,
0.2897557318210602,
-0.7625575065612793,
-0.546342670917511,
0.17137393355369568,
0.2880159914493561,
-0.22029204666614532,
0.13929010927677155,
-0.015802273526787758,
-0.1568635106086731,
0.48203450441360474,
0.1319596916437149,
-0.8003447651863098,
0.3909218907356262,
1.2037535905838013,
0.8133110404014587,
-0.277265727519989,
-0.540310800075531,
-0.5297129154205322,
0.38984712958335876,
-0.3703668713569641,
0.5255374312400818,
-0.5051929950714111,
-0.3517829179763794,
-0.17175880074501038,
-0.02972167730331421,
-0.020190035924315453,
-0.5967769026756287,
0.48072555661201477,
-0.8557060360908508,
0.1578519195318222,
-0.12664295732975006,
-0.5531617999076843,
0.06221243739128113,
0.09637021273374557,
-0.5469252467155457,
0.47126227617263794,
-0.3054199814796448,
-0.7001438140869141,
0.052741724997758865,
-0.34276989102363586,
-0.34810274839401245,
-0.027463871985673904,
-0.24313515424728394,
-0.5976387858390808,
0.18108929693698883,
0.017453555017709732,
0.3030524253845215,
-0.21917277574539185,
0.2822107672691345,
-0.43510928750038147,
-0.324871301651001,
0.4207311272621155,
-0.08579759299755096,
1.06195867061615,
0.3544941544532776,
-0.44885528087615967,
0.31754496693611145,
-0.39937132596969604,
-0.34631240367889404,
0.30796265602111816,
-0.17383737862110138,
-0.47993916273117065,
-0.09493479877710342,
-0.3597852885723114,
0.26764747500419617,
0.2771374583244324,
-0.8228128552436829,
0.41847777366638184,
-0.40969687700271606,
0.1918172836303711,
1.076385259628296,
-0.06778199970722198,
0.44186413288116455,
-0.10404643416404724,
0.5875058174133301,
-0.025505362078547478,
0.26842713356018066,
-0.0014464877313002944,
-0.4757605791091919,
-0.29025253653526306,
-0.3430747389793396,
0.32593369483947754,
0.8664315342903137,
-0.05418534576892853,
0.592181384563446,
-0.03004538081586361,
-0.5053172707557678,
-0.6358937621116638,
0.36349377036094666,
0.6472880840301514,
0.36132174730300903,
-0.07782573997974396,
-0.1925734281539917,
-0.5465304851531982,
-0.7965621948242188,
-0.48989027738571167,
0.11298245191574097,
0.08480120450258255,
0.18716131150722504,
0.5880815982818604,
-0.49184781312942505,
0.5712600946426392,
-0.563296377658844,
-0.3152547776699066,
-0.06904827058315277,
-0.17751993238925934,
0.18920470774173737,
0.682786226272583,
0.38005682826042175,
-0.6131518483161926,
-0.3035229742527008,
-0.12373825907707214,
-0.9816620945930481,
-0.2119220644235611,
0.08087603002786636,
0.012572824954986572,
0.3637491464614868,
0.890819251537323,
-0.5262893438339233,
0.3800088167190552,
0.8002810478210449,
-0.42330724000930786,
0.6357083320617676,
0.005342397838830948,
0.09000387787818909,
-1.1531511545181274,
-0.046018730849027634,
-0.2703818678855896,
-0.09005846828222275,
-0.4910300374031067,
0.7283250689506531,
0.17505872249603271,
-0.3861693739891052,
-0.49020281434059143,
0.5354103446006775,
-0.5264929533004761,
-0.18027076125144958,
0.0071198586374521255,
0.37099698185920715,
-0.398982971906662,
-0.05666835978627205,
-0.35339710116386414,
0.9715462327003479,
0.528355062007904,
-0.19611108303070068,
0.7387157082557678,
0.2746563255786896,
-0.3710895776748657,
0.2331918329000473,
-0.5680404901504517,
0.34237682819366455,
0.14469963312149048,
0.2617241144180298,
-1.3602180480957031,
-0.4973490834236145,
0.11332584172487259,
-0.6508262753486633,
0.39771080017089844,
-0.04456336423754692,
-0.48975804448127747,
-0.31366410851478577,
-0.4936019778251648,
0.2882312834262848,
0.4879310727119446,
-0.659222424030304,
0.16749322414398193,
0.6449950933456421,
-0.09287741780281067,
-0.800223171710968,
-0.6000118851661682,
0.30475878715515137,
-0.43976113200187683,
-0.8442664742469788,
0.05571910738945007,
0.031100742518901825,
-0.46912452578544617,
-0.1193147823214531,
-0.09159664809703827,
0.1652454137802124,
0.5824586153030396,
0.5785554647445679,
0.4565812349319458,
-0.10892289131879807,
-0.3426951766014099,
-0.07186215370893478,
-0.1596161425113678,
0.27678850293159485,
-0.2479756623506546,
0.5123408436775208,
-0.20501910150051117,
-0.2671639323234558,
-0.7604444026947021,
0.4542468786239624,
0.6717519164085388,
-0.2127103954553604,
0.8778055906295776,
-0.045960914343595505,
-0.15486745536327362,
-0.048477016389369965,
-0.6329656839370728,
-0.08844950795173645,
-0.5755841135978699,
0.2109716534614563,
-0.1336209625005722,
-1.0974973440170288,
0.6245379447937012,
-0.06951083242893219,
0.2451457381248474,
0.10940080881118774,
0.3833746612071991,
-0.046287864446640015,
1.3636901378631592,
0.7975206971168518,
-0.3468875288963318,
0.15651139616966248,
0.23621781170368195,
0.3388339579105377,
-0.7400049567222595,
-0.40549424290657043,
-0.7313628196716309,
-0.3012351393699646,
-0.6027089357376099,
0.2147969752550125,
0.2293601930141449,
0.1930982917547226,
-0.20892229676246643,
0.47518637776374817,
-0.5318570137023926,
0.6841787695884705,
0.4530690610408783,
-0.11654018610715866,
0.33797332644462585,
-0.26919808983802795,
-0.5511311292648315,
-0.1672140657901764,
-0.3389604687690735,
-0.3828336000442505,
1.1089484691619873,
0.426967978477478,
1.0598292350769043,
0.318552702665329,
1.311923861503601,
0.1472901701927185,
0.5036883354187012,
-0.4507844150066376,
0.7060838341712952,
-0.11609948426485062,
-0.891025960445404,
-0.14880776405334473,
-0.23903167247772217,
-1.0328140258789062,
-0.08743993937969208,
0.20090351998806,
-1.30752694606781,
-0.23122939467430115,
-0.03029763512313366,
-0.42083969712257385,
0.5795863270759583,
-0.5787212252616882,
0.8900608420372009,
-0.5102370381355286,
-0.12195320427417755,
-0.006500644609332085,
-1.0326813459396362,
0.8074841499328613,
-0.20493796467781067,
0.5015813112258911,
-0.15306022763252258,
-0.0654224157333374,
0.8396656513214111,
-0.4364584684371948,
0.6494035720825195,
0.01675875298678875,
-0.3700423836708069,
0.03178323060274124,
0.19976285099983215,
0.417773962020874,
-0.006497850641608238,
0.03947192057967186,
0.17297396063804626,
-0.16571781039237976,
-0.17200522124767303,
-0.3318469226360321,
0.9961090087890625,
-0.7682972550392151,
-1.0693269968032837,
-0.5321774482727051,
-0.5680831670761108,
-0.05249922350049019,
0.18028298020362854,
0.48961934447288513,
0.07510142773389816,
-0.006645459681749344,
0.1266298145055771,
0.7202840447425842,
-0.23495115339756012,
0.48023080825805664,
0.5217620134353638,
-0.32786309719085693,
-0.5322039127349854,
0.7354186773300171,
-0.1251516491174698,
0.2327800691127777,
0.12748460471630096,
0.11068145185709,
-0.1410125344991684,
-0.7648669481277466,
-0.3310592472553253,
0.35668066143989563,
-0.4292452037334442,
-0.503007173538208,
-0.4505422115325928,
-0.3641888201236725,
-0.7478885650634766,
-0.43722012639045715,
-0.5153511166572571,
-0.2644944190979004,
-0.10705741494894028,
-0.14825892448425293,
0.061679400503635406,
0.9348198175430298,
-0.40833088755607605,
0.47696900367736816,
-1.1392557621002197,
0.10124251246452332,
0.19438223540782928,
0.34442785382270813,
-0.04068061709403992,
-0.4925123155117035,
-0.20924441516399384,
-0.3323533833026886,
-0.4095301628112793,
-1.0172215700149536,
0.3671400547027588,
-0.3560359477996826,
0.5628300905227661,
0.38733670115470886,
-0.008724759332835674,
0.330212265253067,
-0.7437885403633118,
0.7782143354415894,
0.3968598544597626,
-1.0303016901016235,
0.6417357325553894,
-0.4579630494117737,
-0.10475951433181763,
0.5370676517486572,
0.470563679933548,
-0.5911470055580139,
-0.6275122761726379,
-0.5396813154220581,
-0.9233850836753845,
0.4628884792327881,
-0.07661399245262146,
0.18698671460151672,
0.25626736879348755,
0.368098646402359,
0.13566511869430542,
0.19195427000522614,
-0.7246862649917603,
-0.14002707600593567,
0.5158395171165466,
-0.31880688667297363,
0.22858037054538727,
-0.3238412141799927,
-0.37350326776504517,
-0.12706032395362854,
0.4874897301197052,
0.46131402254104614,
0.032141976058483124,
-0.0638904720544815,
-0.09718702733516693,
-0.2136661559343338,
0.4576859474182129,
0.5654164552688599,
0.42011839151382446,
-0.11216534674167633,
0.053603727370500565,
-0.017736265435814857,
-0.4876258671283722,
0.4490872025489807,
-0.016094893217086792,
-0.19160108268260956,
-0.3372515141963959,
0.3721413016319275,
0.12789872288703918,
0.23474004864692688,
-0.7863766551017761,
0.5914492607116699,
-0.15276317298412323,
-0.0792120099067688,
-0.3245919346809387,
0.3488049805164337,
-0.07224520295858383,
0.2678511440753937,
0.24615176022052765,
-0.18685981631278992,
0.0025880977045744658,
-0.7494997382164001,
0.5178166627883911,
0.730953574180603,
-0.4484420120716095,
-0.3939860165119171,
0.8721362948417664,
0.2903949022293091,
-0.5568411350250244,
0.8033213019371033,
0.14237423241138458,
-0.8635544776916504,
0.37136948108673096,
0.7728381156921387,
1.0285018682479858,
-0.7466992139816284,
-0.21275945007801056,
-0.02327761985361576,
0.5308632850646973,
-0.013710172846913338,
0.22993026673793793,
0.2010592222213745,
-0.8324249386787415,
-0.13831904530525208,
-0.4384407699108124,
-0.40751877427101135,
0.2202930897474289,
-0.5850953459739685,
0.11325059831142426,
-0.6832384467124939,
0.13315610587596893,
-0.15902197360992432,
-0.2711418569087982,
-0.09041964262723923,
-0.03991793841123581,
0.4135512113571167,
0.9398646950721741,
-0.8974432349205017,
0.7246375679969788,
0.43877869844436646,
-0.06654252856969833,
-0.7601442933082581,
0.03902406245470047,
0.5726792216300964,
-0.7566689252853394,
0.48975515365600586,
0.3659263849258423,
-0.19711509346961975,
-0.11495473235845566,
-1.2886773347854614,
-0.8439837098121643,
0.7828128933906555,
0.2538471519947052,
-0.5195624232292175,
-0.41614410281181335,
-0.042369402945041656,
0.1419091522693634,
-0.2943556308746338,
-0.5498160719871521,
0.9192039966583252,
0.40694281458854675,
-0.16331681609153748,
-0.7895044684410095,
0.31647878885269165,
-0.07271799445152283,
-0.29091981053352356,
0.5280722975730896,
-0.6373429894447327,
0.7360084056854248,
-0.49438944458961487,
-0.28185224533081055,
0.6703652143478394,
0.5980932116508484,
0.6376373171806335,
0.46917903423309326,
0.15149901807308197,
1.091260313987732,
0.5616654753684998,
-0.2085971087217331,
0.8778704404830933,
-0.2179804891347885,
0.11061396449804306,
1.1994956731796265,
-0.6392538547515869,
0.7520474791526794,
0.5357697010040283,
0.15149042010307312,
0.6224555373191833,
0.37250614166259766,
-0.28304460644721985,
0.5665144324302673,
0.30792224407196045,
-0.10611522197723389,
-0.10467492789030075,
0.0013462729984894395,
-0.3549027144908905,
0.4832511246204376,
0.4768397808074951,
-0.11579207330942154,
-0.14406147599220276,
-0.07697370648384094,
0.35806015133857727,
0.22133585810661316,
-0.2168297916650772,
0.833795428276062,
0.25112906098365784,
-0.6823886036872864,
0.28429922461509705,
0.14871063828468323,
0.8028234839439392,
-0.563999354839325,
0.14776897430419922,
-0.14341828227043152,
0.29060694575309753,
-0.331773042678833,
-1.0158650875091553,
0.17099376022815704,
0.20667269825935364,
0.35797733068466187,
-0.049530453979969025,
0.5897324681282043,
-0.13379666209220886,
0.006335326470434666,
0.521659791469574,
0.039876725524663925,
0.0018357782391831279,
0.047025907784700394,
-0.6482077240943909,
0.15896528959274292,
-0.04627847671508789,
-0.10835760086774826,
0.4021046459674835,
0.09615982323884964,
-0.12772972881793976,
0.7792691588401794,
0.6614816784858704,
0.04781520366668701,
0.3140147626399994,
-0.2057184875011444,
0.9380009174346924,
-0.9596152305603027,
-0.4303905963897705,
-1.0523313283920288,
0.4072191119194031,
-0.23171699047088623,
-0.19652457535266876,
1.289646863937378,
0.8285494446754456,
0.8536853194236755,
0.19195373356342316,
0.6391787528991699,
0.24739614129066467,
0.29320457577705383,
-0.5898883938789368,
0.9705660343170166,
-0.6352515816688538,
0.3883334994316101,
-0.4639880955219269,
-0.5748223066329956,
-0.5289332866668701,
-0.019265789538621902,
-0.3895096182823181,
-0.40914386510849,
0.6154940128326416,
0.790411114692688,
0.13793537020683289,
0.004725055769085884,
0.25599485635757446,
0.27643707394599915,
0.3449660539627075,
0.5592310428619385,
1.1967713832855225,
-0.3265124559402466,
0.44774627685546875,
-0.03197436407208443,
-0.27460262179374695,
-0.27978774905204773,
-0.7058809995651245,
-0.767008900642395,
-0.3571091890335083,
0.0326036736369133,
-0.7318372130393982,
0.3283531665802002,
0.6355367302894592,
0.320748507976532,
-1.0336781740188599,
-0.5057806968688965,
0.013098780997097492,
0.6225203275680542,
0.2885534465312958,
-0.1989934891462326,
-0.005736726801842451,
-0.2183552235364914,
-0.27010321617126465,
0.5657762885093689,
0.42301368713378906,
0.07051841169595718,
-0.05277595296502113,
-0.04744284227490425,
-0.161764457821846,
0.06746715307235718,
-0.02143155038356781,
0.48181208968162537,
-0.7641095519065857,
-0.37122440338134766,
-0.07016386836767197,
-0.49126818776130676,
-0.08855903893709183,
0.9173420667648315,
-0.27889418601989746,
0.18509893119335175,
0.4457159638404846,
0.7057435512542725,
-0.06647907942533493,
0.20481272041797638,
0.8861085176467896,
-0.854217529296875,
0.34358611702919006,
0.30868837237358093,
0.40760254859924316,
0.2376767098903656,
-0.535961925983429,
0.42400383949279785,
0.1608845740556717,
-0.8848118185997009,
-1.1285881996154785,
0.47310423851013184,
-0.6977581977844238,
-0.6482017636299133,
1.0464447736740112,
-0.16299979388713837,
-0.5441637635231018,
0.024029072374105453,
0.13777515292167664,
0.060674626380205154,
-0.3272574841976166,
0.8698808550834656,
0.6758962869644165,
-0.026989037171006203,
0.17021462321281433,
-0.39914992451667786,
0.4540257453918457,
0.2924439311027527,
-0.7901877760887146,
0.09752246737480164,
0.4525975286960602,
0.4658697843551636,
0.19066795706748962,
-0.016219934448599815,
-0.4248603880405426,
0.42110273241996765,
-0.1519848257303238,
-0.11243308335542679,
-0.009750450029969215,
-0.6234392523765564,
-0.7273684144020081,
-0.06007268279790878,
0.02146293595433235,
-0.09705324470996857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13874v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13874v2
|
VALOR-EVAL: Holistic Coverage and Faithfulness Evaluation of Large Vision-Language Models
| 2024-04-22T04:49:22 | 2024-06-06T02:53:37 |
Haoyi Qiu, Wenbo Hu, Zi-Yi Dou, Nanyun Peng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) suffer from hallucination issues,
wherein the models generate plausible-sounding but factually incorrect outputs,
undermining their reliability. A comprehensive quantitative evaluation is
necessary to identify and understand the extent of hallucinations in these
models. However, existing benchmarks are often limited in scope, focusing
mainly on object hallucinations. Furthermore, current evaluation methods
struggle to effectively address the subtle semantic distinctions between model
outputs and reference data, as well as the balance between hallucination and
informativeness. To address these issues, we introduce a multi-dimensional
benchmark covering objects, attributes, and relations, with challenging images
selected based on associative biases. Moreover, we propose a large language
model (LLM)-based two-stage evaluation framework that generalizes the popular
CHAIR metric and incorporates both faithfulness and coverage into the
evaluation. Experiments on 10 established LVLMs demonstrate that our evaluation
metric is more comprehensive and better correlated with humans than existing
work when evaluating on our challenging human-annotated benchmark dataset. Our
work also highlights the critical balance between faithfulness and coverage of
model outputs, and encourages future works to address hallucinations in LVLMs
while keeping their outputs informative.
|
[
-0.2967502772808075,
-0.7617704272270203,
0.6367023587226868,
0.35723876953125,
-0.3001984655857086,
-0.09863007813692093,
-0.325655460357666,
-0.5457732081413269,
0.04036838933825493,
0.7320848107337952,
-0.19627000391483307,
-0.6508341431617737,
-0.4055459499359131,
-0.010330324992537498,
-0.5569620132446289,
0.5668240785598755,
-0.0988808199763298,
0.30850863456726074,
-0.44227054715156555,
-0.40485265851020813,
-0.4363456964492798,
-0.5435437560081482,
-0.15125685930252075,
-0.1969883292913437,
0.5383644700050354,
-0.07909457385540009,
0.925148606300354,
0.41345053911209106,
0.8519328832626343,
0.23456595838069916,
0.08694427460432053,
0.3507930338382721,
-0.5153637528419495,
0.28912726044654846,
-0.1378243863582611,
-0.15934768319129944,
-0.43024376034736633,
-0.23007652163505554,
0.7337544560432434,
0.77491694688797,
-0.1820998638868332,
0.06386907398700714,
0.13545387983322144,
0.6036631464958191,
-0.8249831199645996,
0.23599457740783691,
-0.7561373710632324,
0.11402009427547455,
0.09301101416349411,
-0.10012790560722351,
-0.5433822870254517,
-0.30210983753204346,
-0.07828516513109207,
-0.5962021946907043,
0.06968452781438828,
0.10706125199794769,
0.6576730608940125,
0.43097928166389465,
-0.22063696384429932,
-0.052514102309942245,
-0.8072673678398132,
0.8524305820465088,
-0.40113189816474915,
0.7761785387992859,
0.6841736435890198,
0.5036113858222961,
0.07663004100322723,
-0.487716406583786,
-0.4207729995250702,
-0.5415934324264526,
0.05678015947341919,
-0.013628537766635418,
-0.13222874701023102,
0.012143697589635849,
0.19078248739242554,
0.19530929625034332,
-0.5529744625091553,
-0.16758763790130615,
-0.2994343638420105,
-0.429894357919693,
0.8071416616439819,
0.3512439727783203,
0.10971098393201828,
-0.031899794936180115,
-0.38057878613471985,
-0.39449363946914673,
-0.4517664611339569,
-0.2590057849884033,
0.364134818315506,
0.07770836353302002,
0.19194982945919037,
0.8535621762275696,
-0.12898778915405273,
0.6637254953384399,
-0.45225629210472107,
-0.03502973914146423,
0.3667043447494507,
-0.48356854915618896,
-0.2895815670490265,
-0.2527669668197632,
0.6627780795097351,
0.6194512248039246,
0.3317410945892334,
-0.4917377531528473,
-0.4376663267612457,
0.3363948166370392,
0.6548382043838501,
-0.7085118889808655,
0.08071403205394745,
0.3714632987976074,
-0.5345720648765564,
-0.30246591567993164,
0.03940972685813904,
-0.8955089449882507,
-0.8568991422653198,
-0.6225913166999817,
0.6684555411338806,
-0.4348050355911255,
-0.12764981389045715,
0.3731582462787628,
0.1483847051858902,
0.3891315162181854,
0.3756702244281769,
-0.4976489245891571,
0.3001977205276489,
0.7711459994316101,
0.7547954320907593,
-0.37517043948173523,
-0.5414077043533325,
-0.8065156936645508,
-0.2774810194969177,
-0.588098406791687,
0.6510186791419983,
-0.5402330756187439,
-0.3413298726081848,
0.3972107470035553,
0.09234684705734253,
0.09748896956443787,
-0.6057953834533691,
0.7005376219749451,
-0.3294176459312439,
-0.22369082272052765,
-0.3641681671142578,
-0.3948511481285095,
-0.12168937921524048,
0.40029647946357727,
-0.7413150668144226,
0.9456945061683655,
0.3426302969455719,
-0.6872718334197998,
0.5048568248748779,
0.036775145679712296,
-0.181059330701828,
-0.019882336258888245,
-0.3551153540611267,
-0.6899167895317078,
0.31706658005714417,
0.04171529784798622,
0.4796459972858429,
-0.2956738770008087,
0.3926158547401428,
-0.4144543707370758,
-0.5651995539665222,
0.2900371849536896,
-0.44742828607559204,
0.49755728244781494,
-0.16321499645709991,
-0.32796919345855713,
0.4644194543361664,
-0.938239574432373,
-0.190870463848114,
0.005906297359615564,
0.05388388782739639,
-0.5677992105484009,
-0.00927734188735485,
0.39739158749580383,
-0.09757218509912491,
0.1468334197998047,
-0.32433781027793884,
0.09578408300876617,
-0.3479573130607605,
-0.18748991191387177,
0.6300212144851685,
-0.21203535795211792,
0.3546019494533539,
-0.3416292667388916,
0.5166005492210388,
-0.16147391498088837,
0.5160099864006042,
-0.170668363571167,
-0.1695762723684311,
-0.7543241381645203,
-0.2584035098552704,
-0.19001556932926178,
0.22035694122314453,
-0.8897032141685486,
0.36893337965011597,
-0.3409850299358368,
-0.557948648929596,
-0.5687330365180969,
0.05541141703724861,
0.6735923886299133,
0.28586286306381226,
0.5008354187011719,
-0.46504008769989014,
-0.5212745666503906,
-1.1255639791488647,
-0.34641018509864807,
-0.2462613731622696,
0.03474605083465576,
0.45925772190093994,
0.7289989590644836,
-0.5643869042396545,
0.5055902004241943,
-0.11526235193014145,
-0.6276030540466309,
-0.010646304115653038,
0.02340059168636799,
-0.18119817972183228,
0.06656746566295624,
0.4941290318965912,
-0.6354689598083496,
-0.2818235456943512,
0.12423073500394821,
-0.8292109966278076,
0.03131554275751114,
-0.11006125062704086,
-0.15098293125629425,
0.36285173892974854,
0.13941408693790436,
-0.36049801111221313,
0.7090514302253723,
0.4626058042049408,
-0.5636270046234131,
0.8243052363395691,
-0.29831424355506897,
0.34749364852905273,
-0.5864101648330688,
0.0293781366199255,
-0.10823053866624832,
-0.0938275009393692,
-0.4369785785675049,
0.11882058531045914,
0.03273420035839081,
0.28724944591522217,
-0.3124018609523773,
0.7178186178207397,
-0.3489268720149994,
-0.5370519161224365,
-0.04173941910266876,
0.2796992361545563,
0.29519110918045044,
0.26960960030555725,
0.1422373652458191,
0.6515741944313049,
0.6516545414924622,
-0.2963101267814636,
0.6131211519241333,
0.23379099369049072,
-0.6605767607688904,
0.6364104747772217,
-0.7369672060012817,
0.04928112402558327,
-0.13179923593997955,
0.08331585675477982,
-0.8036389946937561,
-0.2978246212005615,
0.13351856172084808,
-0.13285492360591888,
0.04003286734223366,
0.2490777224302292,
-0.5161970257759094,
-0.24495019018650055,
-0.48216983675956726,
0.5529060363769531,
0.5961664319038391,
-0.6250551342964172,
0.699103832244873,
0.3841228485107422,
0.2612820863723755,
-0.5503862500190735,
-0.48063698410987854,
0.12491670995950699,
-0.27064579725265503,
-0.5307182669639587,
0.22188052535057068,
-0.019930416718125343,
-0.6910074949264526,
-0.14907239377498627,
-0.023393023759126663,
-0.052285198122262955,
-0.13829584419727325,
0.27266740798950195,
0.34103623032569885,
-0.1522940695285797,
-0.021656770259141922,
-0.4915025532245636,
0.17307549715042114,
0.3285631239414215,
0.08144623786211014,
0.6266434192657471,
-0.49509650468826294,
-0.8260800838470459,
-0.29460129141807556,
0.05463971942663193,
0.708869993686676,
-0.3294197618961334,
0.6321383118629456,
0.6217978596687317,
-0.5050410032272339,
-0.18929053843021393,
-0.8196879029273987,
-0.3371111750602722,
-0.3151123821735382,
0.6640564799308777,
-0.4000650644302368,
-0.32013601064682007,
0.7163729667663574,
0.4735575020313263,
0.043791383504867554,
0.33772993087768555,
0.6770341992378235,
0.22137326002120972,
0.8123997449874878,
0.34635868668556213,
0.22489820420742035,
0.11227724701166153,
-0.2084021419286728,
-0.0748319923877716,
-1.1092184782028198,
-0.7099030017852783,
-0.3895891308784485,
0.06594531238079071,
-0.1536100208759308,
-0.948127269744873,
0.16720116138458252,
-0.08848119527101517,
0.03219905123114586,
0.24718241393566132,
-0.625290036201477,
0.2733933925628662,
0.16967929899692535,
0.14625848829746246,
0.39382240176200867,
0.22948111593723297,
0.11526593565940857,
-0.24432441592216492,
-0.19788815081119537,
-0.5905654430389404,
1.305409550666809,
0.5015448331832886,
0.9357247948646545,
-0.09870719909667969,
0.34083226323127747,
0.3562200665473938,
0.37317103147506714,
-0.8735295534133911,
0.3878532946109772,
0.029274756088852882,
-0.38702234625816345,
-0.5266551971435547,
-0.24165360629558563,
-0.9400635957717896,
0.7364659905433655,
-0.14814406633377075,
-0.7866846919059753,
0.3063472807407379,
-0.002478985581547022,
-0.20252874493598938,
0.23660793900489807,
-0.1742374300956726,
0.703991711139679,
-0.5380117893218994,
-0.8213596343994141,
-0.33953046798706055,
-0.40634530782699585,
0.5748184323310852,
-0.2747974097728729,
0.3493176996707916,
-0.01029183715581894,
0.09187114983797073,
0.6173935532569885,
-0.14205941557884216,
0.7145890593528748,
0.03637376055121422,
-0.33360177278518677,
0.20623910427093506,
0.3132554590702057,
0.46655499935150146,
-0.012169438414275646,
-0.06715100258588791,
0.3960663378238678,
0.17523233592510223,
-0.21789121627807617,
-0.7362745404243469,
0.3917980492115021,
-0.5267961621284485,
-0.3440309464931488,
-0.424237459897995,
-0.5877885222434998,
-0.33626532554626465,
-0.1316549926996231,
0.03970782831311226,
0.4949257969856262,
-0.577005922794342,
0.584587812423706,
0.658883810043335,
-0.5702793002128601,
-0.03494620323181152,
0.2650783658027649,
-0.8643612861633301,
-0.41754284501075745,
0.8976587057113647,
-0.0879833847284317,
0.18815067410469055,
0.03396368399262428,
0.07481126487255096,
-0.4463612139225006,
-0.3691137731075287,
-0.35992246866226196,
0.231197327375412,
-0.8272913694381714,
0.05916415527462959,
-0.658498227596283,
-0.29177579283714294,
-0.17731262743473053,
-0.0010484619997441769,
-0.6109418272972107,
0.0084498580545187,
-0.01719328574836254,
0.2143605798482895,
0.10488426685333252,
0.7721647024154663,
0.2485673427581787,
-0.0803612619638443,
-0.3258145749568939,
0.623058021068573,
0.2023293375968933,
0.473456472158432,
0.03129662200808525,
-0.7618502974510193,
-0.21210120618343353,
0.1335659623146057,
-0.11375527828931808,
-0.7686498761177063,
0.4528043270111084,
-0.03512329235672951,
0.7137531638145447,
0.47094112634658813,
-0.002841537818312645,
0.543150782585144,
-0.4551098346710205,
0.6974495053291321,
0.24778376519680023,
-0.72419673204422,
0.28568387031555176,
-0.21339061856269836,
-0.11911371350288391,
0.6354926228523254,
-0.10770859569311142,
-0.29928773641586304,
-0.3935685455799103,
-0.5447784662246704,
-0.7336928844451904,
0.2868023216724396,
0.33250340819358826,
0.1636093705892563,
0.07679521292448044,
0.047115154564380646,
0.18381322920322418,
0.13175876438617706,
-0.7244179248809814,
0.0797257125377655,
-0.1940370798110962,
0.06990835815668106,
-0.05697585269808769,
-0.4217085540294647,
-0.33097708225250244,
-0.4168531000614166,
0.4837620258331299,
-0.09433437883853912,
-0.0042894077487289906,
0.2861155569553375,
-0.15801356732845306,
-0.044112350791692734,
0.14732369780540466,
0.8450064063072205,
0.871329128742218,
-0.29951784014701843,
0.3736267685890198,
0.2749205529689789,
-0.4786355495452881,
-0.07190769910812378,
-0.17870816588401794,
0.04015167057514191,
0.24591322243213654,
0.8234851360321045,
1.0742896795272827,
0.1861376315355301,
-0.8691872954368591,
0.9285395741462708,
-0.09815509617328644,
-0.19154120981693268,
-0.481518417596817,
-0.07365960627794266,
-0.3282381296157837,
0.29515522718429565,
0.1291201263666153,
0.11931104958057404,
0.2781648635864258,
-0.6134008765220642,
0.22900326550006866,
0.7588937282562256,
-0.693274736404419,
-0.36118748784065247,
0.7697718143463135,
-0.12702998518943787,
-0.3474690914154053,
0.5182332992553711,
-0.04494914039969444,
-0.5659323334693909,
0.8511932492256165,
0.3199176788330078,
0.9591156840324402,
-0.1335279792547226,
0.27336111664772034,
0.36195072531700134,
0.5782347917556763,
-0.27454760670661926,
0.24756847321987152,
0.06979911774396896,
-0.5889416337013245,
-0.2088918536901474,
-0.9666846990585327,
-0.3604099154472351,
0.21520757675170898,
-0.9090855121612549,
0.3402331471443176,
0.01263753417879343,
-0.011123836040496826,
-0.40291646122932434,
-0.21206170320510864,
-0.7971007227897644,
0.1625746786594391,
0.041778795421123505,
0.6625422835350037,
-0.8923375010490417,
0.7164410352706909,
0.3264278173446655,
-0.5278874039649963,
-0.42099708318710327,
0.06659244000911713,
-0.3986569046974182,
-0.8974871635437012,
0.6138562560081482,
0.15567147731781006,
-0.19320924580097198,
-0.5240589380264282,
-0.2886485457420349,
-0.5075922608375549,
1.0483760833740234,
0.38291871547698975,
-0.745025098323822,
0.1422826051712036,
0.17493945360183716,
0.8499656915664673,
-0.4887714982032776,
0.20374730229377747,
0.7064031362533569,
0.7369669079780579,
0.12980078160762787,
-0.8744135499000549,
-0.036550719290971756,
0.004530912730842829,
0.17600157856941223,
-0.338092178106308,
-0.555370569229126,
0.5163571834564209,
-0.3628702461719513,
0.03425346314907074,
0.10053598135709763,
0.4374552071094513,
0.5989317297935486,
0.4949283301830292,
0.581838071346283,
0.37446826696395874,
0.6907128095626831,
0.01708270236849785,
1.4597129821777344,
-0.234845831990242,
0.43677836656570435,
1.1374034881591797,
-0.45750853419303894,
0.9288831949234009,
0.6183580756187439,
-0.2452867329120636,
0.044205788522958755,
0.3393101096153259,
-0.2775825262069702,
0.49247676134109497,
0.46877744793891907,
-0.07513818144798279,
-0.3345629870891571,
-0.32641541957855225,
-0.43279075622558594,
0.4222058951854706,
0.18937179446220398,
-0.4703073799610138,
-0.034498829394578934,
0.2891809046268463,
-0.34178176522254944,
0.20693859457969666,
-0.0963616669178009,
0.5258405804634094,
0.03461726754903793,
-0.7350562810897827,
0.7616937160491943,
-0.27652662992477417,
0.26022589206695557,
-0.2604699730873108,
-0.21087515354156494,
-0.33829542994499207,
0.20448929071426392,
-0.16760143637657166,
-0.6704061031341553,
0.44541001319885254,
-0.09554292261600494,
0.06618285924196243,
-0.1509295105934143,
0.5491153597831726,
-0.4344692528247833,
-0.6314710378646851,
0.6533107161521912,
0.2545740008354187,
0.42790839076042175,
-0.2683301568031311,
-0.3725375831127167,
0.7426520586013794,
-0.15203899145126343,
-0.4426499009132385,
0.04504944011569023,
0.2642492949962616,
-0.24794626235961914,
0.6279683709144592,
0.3806740641593933,
0.3035200834274292,
0.05391813442111015,
0.5601454377174377,
0.7586728930473328,
-0.2514348030090332,
0.1083860695362091,
-1.014689326286316,
0.566801905632019,
-0.0826052874326706,
-0.3114025592803955,
0.6664401292800903,
0.8577613234519958,
0.5099456310272217,
-0.15710106492042542,
0.5650759935379028,
0.34026357531547546,
0.0012748842127621174,
-0.49777671694755554,
0.834024965763092,
-0.8778355717658997,
0.38639333844184875,
-0.3420487344264984,
-1.381178855895996,
-0.4391040802001953,
0.9568973183631897,
-0.2340599149465561,
0.0667542889714241,
0.7093789577484131,
0.7618023753166199,
-0.1367262899875641,
-0.4164195954799652,
0.9358408451080322,
0.3727722764015198,
0.12953287363052368,
0.40735432505607605,
1.061671257019043,
-0.507607638835907,
0.3192506432533264,
-0.2340201735496521,
-0.15726478397846222,
-0.4178878962993622,
-0.6928263306617737,
-1.1021673679351807,
-0.8318392634391785,
-0.26615962386131287,
-0.7413585782051086,
0.09654001146554947,
0.522935688495636,
0.6381931900978088,
-0.7088390588760376,
-0.10739872604608536,
-0.029003197327256203,
0.026884086430072784,
-0.12577632069587708,
-0.18038220703601837,
0.7080898880958557,
-0.2680937647819519,
-0.6818757653236389,
0.22001205384731293,
0.5009434223175049,
-0.12014809995889664,
-1.0526959896087646,
-0.3028281629085541,
0.48901236057281494,
0.270600825548172,
0.7332520484924316,
-0.18917636573314667,
-1.3285571336746216,
-0.2895079255104065,
0.24603164196014404,
-0.3764026463031769,
-0.01107352040708065,
0.5356116890907288,
-0.798188328742981,
0.7899259924888611,
0.36641228199005127,
0.758300244808197,
0.31092318892478943,
0.011786893010139465,
0.2634084224700928,
-0.347466379404068,
0.19151055812835693,
0.3716595470905304,
0.5276293754577637,
0.4606376886367798,
-0.28493136167526245,
0.7524864077568054,
0.08597102761268616,
-0.4559086859226227,
-1.2120474576950073,
0.12986770272254944,
-1.1462386846542358,
-0.2038705199956894,
1.5951555967330933,
0.04280644655227661,
-0.3385334014892578,
-0.04505535960197449,
-0.4253122806549072,
0.04982998967170715,
0.17297528684139252,
1.2127292156219482,
0.8868018984794617,
0.1260644644498825,
-0.10035784542560577,
-0.7494754195213318,
0.4248000979423523,
0.4035496413707733,
-0.8873292207717896,
0.36457622051239014,
0.671347439289093,
-0.02313084900379181,
0.16487278044223785,
0.5065076351165771,
-0.2746851444244385,
0.21107572317123413,
0.11676806211471558,
0.3169816732406616,
0.056577056646347046,
-0.6804226040840149,
-0.35808512568473816,
0.04765576124191284,
0.02291424572467804,
0.058941181749105453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13865v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13865v1
|
Context-Enhanced Language Models for Generating Multi-Paper Citations
| 2024-04-22T04:30:36 | 2024-04-22T04:30:36 |
Avinash Anand, Kritarth Prasad, Ujjwal Goel, Mohit Gupta, Naman Lal, Astha Verma, Rajiv Ratn Shah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Citation text plays a pivotal role in elucidating the connection between
scientific documents, demanding an in-depth comprehension of the cited paper.
Constructing citations is often time-consuming, requiring researchers to delve
into extensive literature and grapple with articulating relevant content. To
address this challenge, the field of citation text generation (CTG) has
emerged. However, while earlier methods have primarily centered on creating
single-sentence citations, practical scenarios frequently necessitate citing
multiple papers within a single paragraph. To bridge this gap, we propose a
method that leverages Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate multi-citation
sentences. Our approach involves a single source paper and a collection of
target papers, culminating in a coherent paragraph containing multi-sentence
citation text. Furthermore, we introduce a curated dataset named MCG-S2ORC,
composed of English-language academic research papers in Computer Science,
showcasing multiple citation instances. In our experiments, we evaluate three
LLMs LLaMA, Alpaca, and Vicuna to ascertain the most effective model for this
endeavor. Additionally, we exhibit enhanced performance by integrating
knowledge graphs from target papers into the prompts for generating citation
text. This research underscores the potential of harnessing LLMs for citation
generation, opening a compelling avenue for exploring the intricate connections
between scientific documents.
|
[
-0.24085302650928497,
-0.7121816873550415,
0.9390684962272644,
0.20997947454452515,
-0.33561569452285767,
-0.04667012393474579,
-0.2090410739183426,
-0.46234557032585144,
0.14657554030418396,
0.3432437479496002,
-0.3102456331253052,
-0.3585958480834961,
-0.4691029489040375,
0.5534535646438599,
-0.29177728295326233,
1.0288560390472412,
0.12591136991977692,
-0.040288325399160385,
-0.4721050560474396,
-0.0509222038090229,
-0.326200395822525,
-0.4127683937549591,
-0.29392126202583313,
-0.28757941722869873,
0.9128172397613525,
0.36862415075302124,
0.2370292693376541,
0.4805656969547272,
0.34912094473838806,
0.14350076019763947,
-0.051186494529247284,
0.6131601333618164,
-0.19249986112117767,
0.4842422604560852,
-0.1534034013748169,
-0.03078443929553032,
-0.23795145750045776,
-0.11545717716217041,
0.75123530626297,
0.5818469524383545,
0.308084636926651,
0.09961485117673874,
0.2705807387828827,
0.2509199380874634,
-0.5206710696220398,
0.15054646134376526,
-0.8856684565544128,
-0.33850887417793274,
-0.3835940957069397,
-0.5893272161483765,
-0.6816907525062561,
-0.21591249108314514,
0.017549807205796242,
-0.43104711174964905,
-0.045013703405857086,
-0.07689472287893295,
0.5133240222930908,
-0.029803231358528137,
-0.7861688733100891,
-0.40271255373954773,
-0.3169838488101959,
0.6678075194358826,
-0.43470436334609985,
0.16506612300872803,
0.12287994474172592,
-0.012539846822619438,
-0.18414582312107086,
-1.0264698266983032,
-0.41743004322052,
-0.3708832859992981,
-0.18629537522792816,
0.02847905457019806,
0.05850392207503319,
-0.45050299167633057,
0.10793637484312057,
-0.17538368701934814,
-0.49014121294021606,
-0.333479106426239,
-0.2812415361404419,
0.10392428934574127,
0.4353819489479065,
-0.126706063747406,
-0.006330170203000307,
-0.4060880243778229,
-0.3248429596424103,
-0.16385780274868011,
-0.8677565455436707,
-0.3604620099067688,
0.13972805440425873,
0.8038631081581116,
0.25519293546676636,
0.5930643677711487,
0.21930022537708282,
0.6278843879699707,
-0.30982136726379395,
-0.18866300582885742,
0.008947495371103287,
-0.5586473345756531,
0.0949760302901268,
0.07722578942775726,
0.8431863188743591,
0.05088956281542778,
0.18592312932014465,
-0.41069480776786804,
0.21810570359230042,
-0.21624918282032013,
0.21047024428844452,
-0.9855862259864807,
0.02275918237864971,
0.1406455785036087,
-0.38100138306617737,
-0.28697824478149414,
0.0900244489312172,
-0.6925837993621826,
-0.43979641795158386,
-0.3565525412559509,
0.022499525919556618,
-0.3811861276626587,
-0.12194251269102097,
-0.2756675183773041,
-0.15551765263080597,
-0.10639806091785431,
0.1444944590330124,
-0.34021613001823425,
-0.27615854144096375,
0.35577449202537537,
1.114319086074829,
-0.11402421444654465,
-0.5253372192382812,
-0.6391969919204712,
0.7351924777030945,
-0.030988376587629318,
1.0832864046096802,
-0.8539279699325562,
-0.5568516254425049,
0.15643014013767242,
-0.14355599880218506,
-0.1878241002559662,
-0.17862629890441895,
0.6795485019683838,
-0.5109049081802368,
0.10085783898830414,
-0.5996478796005249,
-0.42595845460891724,
0.03640228882431984,
0.18796871602535248,
-0.6469049453735352,
1.0865755081176758,
-0.16472868621349335,
-1.035544514656067,
0.1719588041305542,
-0.9243668913841248,
-0.6355298161506653,
0.1493179351091385,
-0.26756641268730164,
-0.3256935179233551,
0.0835113376379013,
0.24011659622192383,
0.5818373560905457,
-0.5310259461402893,
0.7700715065002441,
-0.596439003944397,
0.113394595682621,
0.30626437067985535,
-0.15945333242416382,
0.7263337969779968,
0.4667406976222992,
0.13122305274009705,
0.11896990984678268,
-0.8507325649261475,
0.027705270797014236,
0.16399630904197693,
-0.5288915038108826,
-0.5705898404121399,
0.22344158589839935,
0.5178965926170349,
0.28731778264045715,
0.386769562959671,
-0.4160654842853546,
0.35749903321266174,
0.32794201374053955,
0.5810820460319519,
0.4037926197052002,
0.08012112230062485,
0.13476267457008362,
-0.2280396670103073,
0.42645514011383057,
-0.26274946331977844,
-0.3840124011039734,
-0.6985597610473633,
-0.22661201655864716,
-0.39067795872688293,
-0.34563544392585754,
0.07889038324356079,
0.2406686544418335,
-0.6062769889831543,
0.2659459710121155,
-0.4810107350349426,
-0.3161511719226837,
-0.11168058961629868,
0.12245327979326248,
0.13607828319072723,
0.5504564642906189,
0.45767223834991455,
0.35664740204811096,
-0.748076319694519,
-0.6407727599143982,
-0.4991103410720825,
-0.1274450272321701,
0.04228854179382324,
0.4900323450565338,
0.6804824471473694,
-0.21446458995342255,
1.0624734163284302,
-0.5633793473243713,
-0.1239536926150322,
-0.14819498360157013,
0.3600800931453705,
-0.17512118816375732,
0.31248795986175537,
0.6291253566741943,
-0.7578195929527283,
-0.542471170425415,
0.054026152938604355,
-0.9024164080619812,
-0.3492347300052643,
-0.27715906500816345,
-0.24634145200252533,
0.09130142629146576,
0.718312680721283,
-0.29539814591407776,
-0.09391868114471436,
0.4193541407585144,
-0.36262837052345276,
0.6416807770729065,
-0.1022021695971489,
0.1049422100186348,
-1.352050542831421,
0.6708251237869263,
0.04005297273397446,
-0.15744861960411072,
-0.45343291759490967,
0.3430565893650055,
0.16873799264431,
-0.13565167784690857,
-0.22248946130275726,
0.6075525879859924,
-0.5352980494499207,
0.11127784103155136,
-0.4848310947418213,
0.1388026773929596,
0.18236424028873444,
0.09057529270648956,
0.1945839524269104,
0.7124950885772705,
0.3207813501358032,
-0.43834030628204346,
-0.21265217661857605,
0.17913885414600372,
-0.12256723642349243,
0.5226004123687744,
-0.7118527293205261,
0.19082295894622803,
-0.033428072929382324,
0.5822950005531311,
-0.7540770173072815,
-0.256693959236145,
-0.29448702931404114,
-0.13155505061149597,
0.15083588659763336,
-0.09375718981027603,
-0.8570745587348938,
-0.19415810704231262,
-0.19647382199764252,
0.5488972067832947,
-0.3018842935562134,
-0.7453989386558533,
0.580069363117218,
0.3750605583190918,
-0.3954780101776123,
-0.3819626271724701,
-0.6022414565086365,
0.4252498745918274,
-0.39659935235977173,
-0.7513765096664429,
0.49083080887794495,
-0.24256891012191772,
-0.10154849290847778,
-0.17349249124526978,
0.10732630640268326,
-0.0038894207682460546,
0.09792759269475937,
0.076234832406044,
0.2138412445783615,
-0.04098653048276901,
0.48506423830986023,
0.2584083080291748,
0.18269547820091248,
-0.10016702115535736,
-0.48315441608428955,
0.5683890581130981,
-0.14840565621852875,
-0.17496760189533234,
0.08639488369226456,
0.9282733201980591,
0.6483494639396667,
-0.33741021156311035,
0.7787783741950989,
0.5725604295730591,
-0.21680471301078796,
0.07591181993484497,
-0.440267950296402,
-0.2210533171892166,
-0.36604055762290955,
0.2646065056324005,
-0.6368896961212158,
-0.9466704726219177,
0.5302878022193909,
-0.19277672469615936,
0.1863882690668106,
0.3274000585079193,
0.4592461884021759,
0.08574390411376953,
0.753154993057251,
0.47482427954673767,
0.17421068251132965,
0.5766346454620361,
0.18022672832012177,
0.14339059591293335,
-0.7904734015464783,
-0.2854629456996918,
-1.0235048532485962,
0.17293567955493927,
-0.5596522688865662,
-0.39669331908226013,
0.5894588828086853,
0.34575292468070984,
-0.2769318222999573,
0.22239525616168976,
-0.39839479327201843,
0.44847458600997925,
0.5662959218025208,
-0.057747118175029755,
0.4518904983997345,
0.42530542612075806,
-0.4444652199745178,
0.19627128541469574,
-0.7289999723434448,
-0.9169151782989502,
1.1239038705825806,
0.036267854273319244,
0.4953780472278595,
0.14207704365253448,
0.8473144769668579,
0.09450472891330719,
0.3630155622959137,
-0.44517990946769714,
0.47184640169143677,
-0.08541204780340195,
-0.3772278130054474,
-0.006030411459505558,
-0.31945279240608215,
-1.133776307106018,
0.5540632009506226,
-0.12812097370624542,
-0.6324280500411987,
-0.02177250012755394,
0.011596170254051685,
-0.08706457167863846,
0.029157277196645737,
-0.426960825920105,
0.5981305837631226,
-0.22098900377750397,
-0.725863516330719,
-0.05623921751976013,
-0.5288009643554688,
0.449942946434021,
-0.23877063393592834,
0.36040931940078735,
0.17307932674884796,
0.16750627756118774,
0.6478318572044373,
-0.21228383481502533,
0.5926083326339722,
0.033115509897470474,
-0.06868677586317062,
0.5351495742797852,
0.09803630411624908,
0.6986473798751831,
0.32034623622894287,
-0.23702175915241241,
0.052636243402957916,
-0.012708755210042,
-0.41734325885772705,
-0.012915186583995819,
0.9559691548347473,
-0.4458625912666321,
-0.37773004174232483,
-0.48233139514923096,
-0.896538496017456,
-0.23102353513240814,
0.3712244927883148,
0.02177915722131729,
0.22143834829330444,
-0.2521490752696991,
0.3557940721511841,
0.3741605579853058,
-0.19531723856925964,
0.6970192193984985,
0.5137582421302795,
-0.08236810564994812,
-0.5278264880180359,
0.49274942278862,
-0.050765056163072586,
-0.06724212318658829,
0.3577508330345154,
0.23238295316696167,
-0.49819719791412354,
-0.36205238103866577,
-0.23305974900722504,
0.4490261971950531,
-0.6258834600448608,
-0.3978700041770935,
-1.0049679279327393,
-0.070855051279068,
-0.8416841626167297,
-0.16783446073532104,
0.0034154439345002174,
-0.4127991497516632,
-0.488528311252594,
-0.06761563569307327,
0.37335559725761414,
0.5080245733261108,
-0.12557609379291534,
0.2182396501302719,
-0.8081105947494507,
0.09526502341032028,
0.1330752670764923,
0.08462484180927277,
0.03541234880685806,
-0.2578198313713074,
-0.23948952555656433,
-0.21321187913417816,
-0.40793707966804504,
-1.0591908693313599,
0.47968509793281555,
0.2697678208351135,
0.49591711163520813,
0.2345544993877411,
-0.13803064823150635,
0.8114572167396545,
-0.8058251738548279,
0.6937012076377869,
0.2910173535346985,
-0.7364584803581238,
0.6601671576499939,
-0.7115230560302734,
0.3332631289958954,
0.5300504565238953,
0.24553140997886658,
-0.32686537504196167,
-0.3475134074687958,
-0.36707136034965515,
-1.213589072227478,
0.5076929926872253,
0.09677452594041824,
-0.028559239581227303,
-0.3945591151714325,
0.20774942636489868,
0.18221355974674225,
0.11927676945924759,
-1.157175064086914,
-0.0686105266213417,
-0.2016410529613495,
-0.09745755046606064,
-0.0053794230334460735,
-0.3696539103984833,
-0.4339161515235901,
0.15230430662631989,
0.630068838596344,
-0.6079888939857483,
0.10665736347436905,
0.17271852493286133,
-0.2234061360359192,
0.07981064915657043,
0.5089616775512695,
0.933260440826416,
0.7347263097763062,
-0.18422099947929382,
0.40071743726730347,
-0.24897100031375885,
-0.10529762506484985,
-0.18346771597862244,
0.30813688039779663,
-0.23372100293636322,
0.018699277192354202,
0.34416085481643677,
0.3665710389614105,
-0.006222199182957411,
-0.5894676446914673,
0.151566281914711,
0.04358774796128273,
-0.2008947730064392,
-0.21194703876972198,
-0.40390700101852417,
0.287104070186615,
0.2567797005176544,
0.7834688425064087,
-0.06770752370357513,
0.13167791068553925,
-0.5226588249206543,
0.17428003251552582,
0.5971497893333435,
0.11165393143892288,
-0.04254348576068878,
0.7148839831352234,
0.2419358342885971,
0.14479006826877594,
0.1946684569120407,
-0.10860751569271088,
-0.30493324995040894,
0.4206838309764862,
0.8665920495986938,
0.793101966381073,
0.13217410445213318,
0.24347686767578125,
0.5813409090042114,
0.18646764755249023,
-0.22993595898151398,
0.13225342333316803,
-0.14136625826358795,
-0.4089183807373047,
-0.46160873770713806,
-0.7708469033241272,
-0.05180313065648079,
0.3456277847290039,
-0.5336366891860962,
0.17464031279087067,
0.01129894144833088,
-0.11630526930093765,
0.040536753833293915,
0.06785336136817932,
-0.6245190501213074,
-0.19909240305423737,
0.19471658766269684,
0.7530583143234253,
-1.0059006214141846,
1.05008864402771,
0.8326310515403748,
-0.4337382912635803,
-0.5591198801994324,
-0.09170688688755035,
-0.14599445462226868,
-0.3382894694805145,
0.5776572823524475,
0.1399347484111786,
-0.2164919674396515,
-0.12433654069900513,
-0.6347734332084656,
-1.0358614921569824,
1.2525666952133179,
0.4360787272453308,
-0.5400758981704712,
0.12121040374040604,
-0.030437452718615532,
0.507560670375824,
-0.7883608937263489,
0.4446875751018524,
0.3181121349334717,
0.6561428904533386,
0.18177767097949982,
-0.6438625454902649,
0.20677754282951355,
-0.32592499256134033,
0.19021296501159668,
-0.12711389362812042,
-0.6836147904396057,
0.8499395251274109,
-0.2339913696050644,
-0.10617250204086304,
0.11577677726745605,
0.8133017420768738,
0.9653823971748352,
0.3758564293384552,
0.25026339292526245,
0.20934170484542847,
1.0155092477798462,
0.20180079340934753,
1.044570803642273,
-0.4982719421386719,
0.17198675870895386,
1.5778509378433228,
-0.48103079199790955,
0.8135531544685364,
0.8285987377166748,
0.006190379150211811,
0.6830986738204956,
0.4186207950115204,
0.03156544640660286,
0.4446718394756317,
0.01668298803269863,
-0.24325399100780487,
-0.3666478395462036,
-0.3956504762172699,
-0.44086554646492004,
0.37975940108299255,
0.24723033607006073,
-0.7580904364585876,
-0.3243188261985779,
0.02092474326491356,
0.26068833470344543,
0.23400968313217163,
-0.07090577483177185,
0.4516838788986206,
-0.0009141776827163994,
-0.9434710144996643,
0.2554675340652466,
0.06768640875816345,
0.45215603709220886,
-0.6097849607467651,
0.08958488702774048,
-0.18941926956176758,
-0.15604686737060547,
-0.010580119676887989,
-0.5250304937362671,
0.07287127524614334,
0.4187980592250824,
-0.49102988839149475,
-0.36439141631126404,
0.7110702395439148,
-0.6172560453414917,
-0.6232861876487732,
0.24304789304733276,
0.6792961359024048,
0.17668907344341278,
0.03607083112001419,
-0.44977739453315735,
-0.10095284134149551,
0.027847371995449066,
-0.4012645483016968,
0.40307918190956116,
0.45717984437942505,
-0.0394473597407341,
0.5154247283935547,
0.736627995967865,
0.030655840411782265,
0.10685282200574875,
0.3422902524471283,
0.8343387246131897,
-0.5276266932487488,
-0.4404761493206024,
-0.8383450508117676,
0.4497641324996948,
-0.330544114112854,
-0.13931725919246674,
0.7182872891426086,
0.6959579586982727,
0.4946495592594147,
-0.009217054583132267,
1.2220587730407715,
-0.23366260528564453,
0.4198262691497803,
-0.402143657207489,
0.5043691992759705,
-0.6789780855178833,
0.40237993001937866,
-0.3839603066444397,
-0.745498776435852,
-0.4527985751628876,
0.5888563990592957,
0.04767364263534546,
0.17196060717105865,
0.9331017732620239,
0.621839702129364,
0.01583826169371605,
-0.10789008438587189,
0.01982729695737362,
0.08633927255868912,
0.6706551909446716,
0.40946948528289795,
0.6085740327835083,
-0.2299337238073349,
0.8793452382087708,
0.15509265661239624,
0.07748632878065109,
-0.23850859701633453,
-1.3946179151535034,
-0.9455391764640808,
-0.5946648120880127,
-0.4295896887779236,
-0.47868719696998596,
-0.14568203687667847,
0.7541638016700745,
0.5949781537055969,
-0.625400722026825,
-0.1491989940404892,
-0.263065904378891,
-0.06712069362401962,
-0.00828439649194479,
-0.2782956063747406,
0.6260581016540527,
-0.5378105044364929,
-0.8454211950302124,
0.6182066202163696,
0.2176435887813568,
-0.027119023725390434,
-0.09318440407514572,
-0.020571516826748848,
-0.5337866544723511,
0.15843218564987183,
0.7481926679611206,
0.1212497353553772,
-0.6109604239463806,
-0.2684483528137207,
0.04953301325440407,
-0.32113683223724365,
-0.12080718576908112,
1.1997822523117065,
-0.7383944988250732,
0.28430670499801636,
0.49173253774642944,
0.4522355794906616,
0.5706887245178223,
-0.019246801733970642,
0.4366855025291443,
-0.8594481945037842,
-0.1456378549337387,
0.12273634970188141,
0.5955143570899963,
0.4557116627693176,
-0.1724933683872223,
0.5616838335990906,
0.053826384246349335,
-0.7563420534133911,
-1.0337495803833008,
0.20294739305973053,
-1.1228903532028198,
-0.7645031213760376,
1.4835319519042969,
-0.237280935049057,
0.16080717742443085,
0.07835520803928375,
-0.10474897921085358,
0.315673291683197,
-0.4725361168384552,
0.9490784406661987,
0.7256582379341125,
-0.11730708926916122,
-0.11250453442335129,
-0.15197935700416565,
0.17331381142139435,
0.3448024392127991,
-1.0148849487304688,
0.1881946325302124,
0.7113342881202698,
0.20569223165512085,
0.4271247386932373,
0.32926666736602783,
-0.06582906097173691,
0.10280486196279526,
0.019111327826976776,
-0.07955076545476913,
-0.3469768762588501,
-0.5181111693382263,
-0.06720636785030365,
0.661458432674408,
0.05053529888391495,
0.34104862809181213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13855v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13855v1
|
Understanding the role of FFNs in driving multilingual behaviour in LLMs
| 2024-04-22T03:47:00 | 2024-04-22T03:47:00 |
Sunit Bhattacharya, Ondřej Bojar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multilingualism in Large Language Models (LLMs) is an yet under-explored
area. In this paper, we conduct an in-depth analysis of the multilingual
capabilities of a family of a Large Language Model, examining its architecture,
activation patterns, and processing mechanisms across languages. We introduce
novel metrics to probe the model's multilingual behaviour at different layers
and shed light on the impact of architectural choices on multilingual
processing.
Our findings reveal different patterns of multilinugal processing in the
sublayers of Feed-Forward Networks of the models. Furthermore, we uncover the
phenomenon of "over-layerization" in certain model configurations, where
increasing layer depth without corresponding adjustments to other parameters
may degrade model performance. Through comparisons within and across languages,
we demonstrate the interplay between model architecture, layer depth, and
multilingual processing capabilities of LLMs trained on multiple languages.
|
[
-0.5252311825752258,
-0.5387417078018188,
0.29263609647750854,
0.5458940267562866,
0.015822164714336395,
0.1645120233297348,
-0.07024897634983063,
-0.6871601343154907,
0.06616417318582535,
0.5433967709541321,
-0.5832708477973938,
-0.031005019322037697,
-0.5014541745185852,
0.23205970227718353,
-0.26369354128837585,
0.6993795037269592,
-0.044001758098602295,
0.34042835235595703,
-0.12050370872020721,
-0.2511429190635681,
0.12526072561740875,
-0.7586105465888977,
-0.8529296517372131,
-0.7434248328208923,
0.8799331784248352,
0.01406864169985056,
0.7565134167671204,
0.7489255666732788,
0.26679882407188416,
0.35533633828163147,
-0.39723873138427734,
0.0697159469127655,
-0.4631664454936981,
0.3468768894672394,
-0.08111393451690674,
-0.33261173963546753,
-0.4499700665473938,
-0.29447564482688904,
1.0874985456466675,
0.8374339938163757,
0.048475418239831924,
0.14237312972545624,
0.3038487136363983,
0.5748708248138428,
-0.3005239963531494,
0.42031800746917725,
-0.2665802240371704,
0.20835797488689423,
-0.3272117078304291,
-0.23161761462688446,
-0.3904358148574829,
0.3323580324649811,
0.030704323202371597,
-0.19851253926753998,
-0.06553490459918976,
-0.28630852699279785,
0.3167230188846588,
-0.10149707645177841,
-0.6663427948951721,
-0.24338985979557037,
-0.6140260100364685,
0.7590748071670532,
-0.6673521995544434,
0.8801478743553162,
0.11303303390741348,
-0.14828568696975708,
-0.022010669112205505,
-0.28406956791877747,
-0.2505599558353424,
-0.08977412432432175,
-0.4158999025821686,
-0.26976731419563293,
-0.029698260128498077,
-0.05845107510685921,
0.2527349889278412,
0.2883671224117279,
-0.6856893301010132,
0.3886227309703827,
-0.4751568138599396,
-0.09089559316635132,
0.4713332951068878,
0.023624518886208534,
0.16088709235191345,
-0.13412801921367645,
-0.4205091595649719,
0.1327466517686844,
-0.6625187397003174,
0.38679346442222595,
0.41726383566856384,
0.6202967166900635,
-0.12116637825965881,
0.4345541000366211,
-0.09038464725017548,
0.5711210370063782,
-0.3515551686286926,
-0.24515566229820251,
0.34320926666259766,
-0.26846855878829956,
-0.24093197286128998,
0.13073822855949402,
0.756382405757904,
-0.12878531217575073,
0.4054812788963318,
-0.17814558744430542,
-0.4899756908416748,
-0.41898277401924133,
-0.03554420918226242,
-0.7892772555351257,
0.1844663769006729,
0.21951012313365936,
-0.34647127985954285,
-0.2367514669895172,
-0.1921139359474182,
-0.38372308015823364,
-0.35512855648994446,
-0.35673582553863525,
0.11317602545022964,
-0.3148690462112427,
-0.7131896018981934,
0.19062697887420654,
-0.014558283612132072,
0.41947707533836365,
-0.08291075378656387,
-0.8904257416725159,
0.3927643895149231,
0.844729483127594,
0.8688298463821411,
-0.09874916821718216,
-0.9327691793441772,
-0.3612596094608307,
0.19360587000846863,
-0.3963875472545624,
0.6009348034858704,
-0.6528135538101196,
-0.22034621238708496,
0.08732908964157104,
0.2602035105228424,
-0.34394311904907227,
-0.41049930453300476,
0.145634725689888,
-0.8916083574295044,
-0.081169493496418,
-0.4364997148513794,
-0.2487783133983612,
-0.5173835158348083,
0.3051718771457672,
-0.9138500690460205,
0.8962413668632507,
-0.04709723964333534,
-0.4035237729549408,
0.26743757724761963,
-0.4727511703968048,
-0.755946695804596,
0.033599965274333954,
-0.09396182000637054,
-0.08211115747690201,
0.33162516355514526,
0.12527287006378174,
0.8839668035507202,
-0.2714439034461975,
0.23341438174247742,
-0.2437802255153656,
-0.30193498730659485,
0.3973349630832672,
-0.47691774368286133,
0.8343726396560669,
-0.0184375811368227,
-0.08608704805374146,
0.16530616581439972,
-0.8470150828361511,
-0.17826786637306213,
0.19743284583091736,
-0.5828202366828918,
-0.3713153898715973,
-0.04812134802341461,
-0.03647904470562935,
0.8081320524215698,
0.031427107751369476,
-0.3459164500236511,
0.007290134206414223,
-0.42437273263931274,
0.6918891668319702,
0.5753562450408936,
-0.16399845480918884,
0.5375049114227295,
-0.11577814072370529,
0.6535669565200806,
0.36079633235931396,
0.19984915852546692,
-0.5643396377563477,
-0.43976959586143494,
-0.5935887098312378,
-0.06909330189228058,
-0.005218769423663616,
0.5414164066314697,
-0.714850902557373,
-0.3502397835254669,
-0.31781110167503357,
-0.19767414033412933,
-0.4645901024341583,
0.5466142296791077,
0.6598555445671082,
0.007272450253367424,
0.12619684636592865,
-0.17191413044929504,
-0.23995837569236755,
-1.0694276094436646,
0.08835579454898834,
0.13416336476802826,
0.32454121112823486,
0.17633746564388275,
0.4685259461402893,
-0.2142263501882553,
0.2368830442428589,
0.045234888792037964,
-0.22660504281520844,
-0.3846007287502289,
-0.1488218456506729,
0.20224155485630035,
0.2918526530265808,
0.7352956533432007,
-0.8943705558776855,
-0.2773728370666504,
0.49629512429237366,
-0.6050431728363037,
0.0432671457529068,
-0.1555449664592743,
0.08225761353969574,
0.38363444805145264,
0.6647831201553345,
-0.5650547742843628,
-0.0779801607131958,
0.8144941329956055,
-0.15745440125465393,
0.4269653856754303,
-0.16041022539138794,
0.10580164939165115,
-0.832952618598938,
-0.19728238880634308,
0.1455589383840561,
0.07923585921525955,
-0.9219549894332886,
0.552937924861908,
0.019226258620619774,
0.04926440864801407,
-0.7844356894493103,
0.5600626468658447,
-0.6482611894607544,
-0.6999243497848511,
-0.015868689864873886,
0.029353732243180275,
0.32662248611450195,
0.679793655872345,
0.13308870792388916,
0.6867383718490601,
0.7050145268440247,
-0.6338236331939697,
0.5379300713539124,
-0.05269106850028038,
-0.46734312176704407,
0.2809411883354187,
-0.5677566528320312,
-0.15154677629470825,
-0.1315663605928421,
-0.07710026204586029,
-1.2410292625427246,
-0.13639770448207855,
0.014721826650202274,
-0.21718952059745789,
0.4495866298675537,
-0.3332298696041107,
-0.5865966081619263,
-0.3322867453098297,
-0.2740994095802307,
0.6096228957176208,
-0.26683759689331055,
-0.37748733162879944,
0.9667705297470093,
0.2641184329986572,
-0.13937361538410187,
-0.5388262271881104,
-1.087143898010254,
0.010582571849226952,
-0.19923964142799377,
-1.0082515478134155,
0.21729055047035217,
0.11447073519229889,
-0.40356436371803284,
-0.3441471755504608,
0.17500710487365723,
-0.03042713925242424,
0.2372320145368576,
0.07951667159795761,
-0.05762195214629173,
-0.8638421893119812,
0.046200450509786606,
0.1621515452861786,
0.05148979648947716,
0.25436219573020935,
-0.4241592586040497,
0.8682215213775635,
-0.34500065445899963,
-0.3365475833415985,
-0.20820724964141846,
0.5225859880447388,
0.8781317472457886,
-0.6113981604576111,
1.155166506767273,
0.5773566365242004,
-0.2295544147491455,
-0.30664122104644775,
-0.4303213059902191,
0.050244882702827454,
-0.5337272882461548,
0.510887861251831,
-0.7263863682746887,
-0.954620361328125,
1.1616190671920776,
0.2322705090045929,
0.018230069428682327,
0.2854078412055969,
0.6576453447341919,
0.06745095551013947,
0.9374843835830688,
0.3443213403224945,
-0.023127537220716476,
0.33884871006011963,
-0.2517794370651245,
-0.0249172393232584,
-0.98981112241745,
-0.36029282212257385,
-0.3177987039089203,
-0.2456255555152893,
-0.5753375887870789,
-0.5173527598381042,
0.08419683575630188,
0.042018841952085495,
-0.22221776843070984,
0.1855934113264084,
0.1111108586192131,
0.5192103385925293,
0.14862875640392303,
-0.24916981160640717,
0.17575442790985107,
0.12615975737571716,
-0.3486410081386566,
0.19658470153808594,
-0.8937940001487732,
-0.263887494802475,
0.5633599758148193,
0.599418044090271,
0.5780742168426514,
0.434818297624588,
0.3231790065765381,
-0.000009853060873865616,
0.034415557980537415,
-0.7408766746520996,
0.46220502257347107,
-0.44556087255477905,
-0.5370748043060303,
-0.39816245436668396,
-0.39533331990242004,
-0.6951504945755005,
0.8145940899848938,
-0.007443825714290142,
-0.49664559960365295,
0.32548069953918457,
-0.12225119769573212,
-0.36050835251808167,
0.41570407152175903,
-0.596494197845459,
0.7552481889724731,
-0.5371374487876892,
-0.5590940713882446,
-0.020615501329302788,
-0.42229458689689636,
0.5140740275382996,
-0.2523585855960846,
0.5879716873168945,
0.1343805342912674,
0.026524700224399567,
0.36407211422920227,
0.34186112880706787,
0.9335440397262573,
0.0547371432185173,
-0.8450027108192444,
-0.13073602318763733,
0.4274190664291382,
0.2629031538963318,
-0.018611740320920944,
-0.40526723861694336,
0.436616450548172,
-0.05650535598397255,
-0.3060380816459656,
-0.36085090041160583,
1.0734115839004517,
-0.7577018141746521,
-0.5724312663078308,
-0.13847529888153076,
-0.4327402710914612,
-0.3784022629261017,
0.1740042120218277,
-0.09532433748245239,
0.8240199089050293,
-0.088919498026371,
0.21323606371879578,
0.7884504795074463,
-0.3322165012359619,
0.5564772486686707,
0.5748478174209595,
-0.7137455940246582,
-0.04624668508768082,
0.9191532135009766,
0.2605490982532501,
0.5781868696212769,
0.5925528407096863,
0.22684448957443237,
-0.311922550201416,
-0.5843478441238403,
-0.6684316396713257,
0.2819676697254181,
-0.9104269742965698,
0.21773594617843628,
-0.6841741800308228,
-0.39510929584503174,
-0.593326985836029,
-0.10406150668859482,
-0.33723756670951843,
-0.31203970313072205,
-0.2772729992866516,
-0.26378655433654785,
-0.05265147238969803,
0.9667394161224365,
0.14808468520641327,
0.45481717586517334,
-0.8745713233947754,
0.11004817485809326,
0.2917124032974243,
0.6011435389518738,
0.5748885869979858,
-0.502913236618042,
-0.3943254351615906,
-0.016544878482818604,
0.13822387158870697,
-0.4693317115306854,
0.30903586745262146,
0.3980814218521118,
0.7911093831062317,
0.5483036041259766,
-0.6400633454322815,
0.5133328437805176,
-0.5598515868186951,
0.7747777700424194,
-0.2202509343624115,
-0.8038791418075562,
-0.05070733651518822,
-0.5317735075950623,
0.5629900097846985,
-0.09205015748739243,
0.4060746133327484,
-0.7183402180671692,
-0.27447429299354553,
-0.07710393518209457,
-0.8940059542655945,
1.069183588027954,
0.006409419700503349,
0.3411584496498108,
0.14610892534255981,
0.392570823431015,
0.06518668681383133,
0.15672965347766876,
-1.062400460243225,
-0.09278742969036102,
-0.0590902641415596,
0.580649733543396,
-0.26650723814964294,
-0.5507422685623169,
-0.02706017903983593,
-0.05133335664868355,
0.6015688180923462,
-0.20181669294834137,
-0.06125012785196304,
-0.2157168835401535,
-0.29630139470100403,
-0.22027498483657837,
0.22635839879512787,
1.0796092748641968,
0.6291362047195435,
0.18020430207252502,
0.12029756605625153,
0.0711442157626152,
-0.14005200564861298,
-0.06704279035329819,
-0.05525168403983116,
0.036200910806655884,
-0.38029807806015015,
0.8780362606048584,
1.117722749710083,
0.6005170345306396,
-0.14534048736095428,
0.11427070945501328,
0.08074254542589188,
-0.2774677574634552,
-0.17101457715034485,
0.06233220919966698,
0.3721323609352112,
0.5326210856437683,
0.28122952580451965,
0.010862201452255249,
-0.06250973790884018,
-0.6172086596488953,
0.14843235909938812,
0.3998298645019531,
-0.32716062664985657,
-0.5546512603759766,
0.2555028200149536,
0.04840534180402756,
-0.31885433197021484,
0.45283856987953186,
0.026603983715176582,
-0.7372176051139832,
0.5414223074913025,
0.4608912467956543,
0.7068369388580322,
-0.5422935485839844,
0.3191981911659241,
0.039120785892009735,
0.5761595964431763,
-0.0029074307531118393,
0.25736913084983826,
-0.026347797363996506,
-1.0540869235992432,
-0.7011654376983643,
-0.9734055399894714,
0.2230101227760315,
0.13453984260559082,
-0.6260778307914734,
-0.09728928655385971,
-0.3447798192501068,
0.08557206392288208,
0.302011102437973,
-0.38747546076774597,
-0.45882076025009155,
0.09100918471813202,
0.7145538330078125,
0.913712739944458,
-0.8059768080711365,
0.9562718868255615,
0.6523259878158569,
-0.09930864721536636,
-0.7118188738822937,
-0.12117812037467957,
0.1664627343416214,
-0.8585561513900757,
1.0022649765014648,
0.19613207876682281,
-0.6691092848777771,
-0.10893358290195465,
0.08829520642757416,
-1.0533310174942017,
0.7385514974594116,
0.3289072811603546,
-0.3881527781486511,
-0.13532374799251556,
0.7256519794464111,
0.683872640132904,
-0.5332213044166565,
-0.03745581954717636,
0.5823241472244263,
0.46708956360816956,
0.19798581302165985,
-0.9465743899345398,
-0.14387604594230652,
-0.23387324810028076,
0.1850467473268509,
0.3810665011405945,
-0.8421679735183716,
1.040146827697754,
-0.06928230822086334,
-0.02439316175878048,
-0.21989241242408752,
0.3735102713108063,
0.026028834283351898,
-0.1483239084482193,
0.3511498272418976,
0.19901861250400543,
0.3637716770172119,
0.007593975868076086,
1.1969741582870483,
-0.47905269265174866,
0.03257299214601517,
0.8624898195266724,
-0.5917420983314514,
0.882503092288971,
0.5065609216690063,
-0.047176241874694824,
0.32485029101371765,
0.437380313873291,
0.21574410796165466,
0.26988744735717773,
0.19134773313999176,
-0.0944092646241188,
-0.3344019651412964,
-0.046096619218587875,
-0.23123304545879364,
0.7233046889305115,
0.5776429176330566,
-0.5296968221664429,
-0.19569993019104004,
0.30737176537513733,
-0.07836262881755829,
-0.17104953527450562,
-0.5099648833274841,
0.7125757932662964,
0.25473806262016296,
-0.5636135339736938,
0.4758015275001526,
0.17994549870491028,
0.5667456984519958,
-0.7964270710945129,
0.32428571581840515,
-0.2642975151538849,
0.2659361660480499,
-0.34008684754371643,
-1.0930266380310059,
0.42174044251441956,
-0.41905367374420166,
-0.3433891534805298,
-0.6793334484100342,
0.5439610481262207,
-0.4942268431186676,
-0.6123800873756409,
1.1235946416854858,
0.70560222864151,
-0.16153115034103394,
-0.04951434209942818,
-0.7514122128486633,
0.35113629698753357,
-0.12490762770175934,
-0.6567391157150269,
0.5233359336853027,
0.7784572839736938,
-0.2697690427303314,
0.7336594462394714,
0.7633067965507507,
0.07708294689655304,
0.262399286031723,
0.4651610553264618,
0.7989656925201416,
-0.4842289984226227,
-0.4505975842475891,
-1.056576132774353,
0.3330126702785492,
0.35611000657081604,
-0.32754501700401306,
0.833914577960968,
0.5688145160675049,
1.1539689302444458,
-0.019237332046031952,
0.23952285945415497,
0.44218435883522034,
0.05500985309481621,
-0.6766594648361206,
0.6964045763015747,
-0.7846840023994446,
0.526587188243866,
-0.2326636165380478,
-0.8396211266517639,
-0.2908523678779602,
0.3737843632698059,
-0.1622527539730072,
0.11173355579376221,
0.3224440813064575,
0.834770679473877,
-0.09339626878499985,
0.2907303273677826,
0.4913497865200043,
0.38719502091407776,
0.34751415252685547,
0.33001312613487244,
0.9735345244407654,
-0.052403904497623444,
0.351494699716568,
-0.3645555377006531,
0.07075639069080353,
0.1403365582227707,
-0.7145646214485168,
-0.9859367609024048,
-0.7644992470741272,
-0.02212795428931713,
-0.07834924757480621,
-0.21831969916820526,
0.6859782934188843,
0.6066569089889526,
-0.889435887336731,
-0.6949289441108704,
0.4153105616569519,
0.12917514145374298,
-0.16125120222568512,
-0.20207765698432922,
0.067116878926754,
-0.14454811811447144,
-0.3660319149494171,
0.6872907876968384,
0.5074451565742493,
-0.0326087512075901,
-0.8191731572151184,
-0.04442361742258072,
-0.5524060726165771,
0.06800992786884308,
0.9800267815589905,
0.018445800989866257,
-0.7136266231536865,
0.1679980754852295,
0.2143191397190094,
-0.14835871756076813,
0.044788166880607605,
1.0205752849578857,
-0.4813600778579712,
0.03772618621587753,
0.37311410903930664,
0.4190928637981415,
0.2568388879299164,
-0.446744829416275,
0.6244176030158997,
-1.0061986446380615,
0.28575828671455383,
-0.06676042079925537,
0.5442865490913391,
0.4582709074020386,
-0.4487975835800171,
0.1393021047115326,
0.10537772625684738,
-0.21268969774246216,
-0.7463229894638062,
0.2806662619113922,
-0.5286975502967834,
-0.47127336263656616,
1.3456562757492065,
-0.06608517467975616,
-0.3003484010696411,
-0.07144974172115326,
0.10094687342643738,
-0.21278242766857147,
-0.2069229632616043,
0.2495112270116806,
1.1488755941390991,
-0.10024058818817139,
-0.5381030440330505,
-0.6486014127731323,
0.42955106496810913,
0.035383593291044235,
-0.2775091528892517,
0.2617534399032593,
0.28048476576805115,
0.15617792308330536,
0.38923150300979614,
0.34268227219581604,
-0.022885119542479515,
-0.007441899739205837,
-0.3309866786003113,
-0.41981571912765503,
-0.29346421360969543,
-0.5947319865226746,
-0.6936385035514832,
0.38083311915397644,
-0.10882197320461273,
0.4451301395893097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13847v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13847v1
|
EventLens: Leveraging Event-Aware Pretraining and Cross-modal Linking Enhances Visual Commonsense Reasoning
| 2024-04-22T03:05:32 | 2024-04-22T03:05:32 |
Mingjie Ma, Zhihuan Yu, Yichao Ma, Guohui Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Visual Commonsense Reasoning (VCR) is a cognitive task, challenging models to
answer visual questions requiring human commonsense, and to provide rationales
explaining why the answers are correct. With emergence of Large Language Models
(LLMs), it is natural and imperative to explore their applicability to VCR.
However, VCR task demands more external knowledge to tackle its challenging
questions, necessitating special designs to activate LLMs' commonsense
reasoning abilities. Also, most existing Multimodal LLMs adopted an abstraction
of entire input image, which makes it difficult to comprehend VCR's unique
co-reference tags between image regions and text, posing challenges for
fine-grained alignment. To address these issues, we propose EventLens that
leverages Event-Aware Pretraining and Cross-modal Linking and EnhanceS VCR.
First, by emulating the cognitive process of human reasoning, an Event-Aware
Pretraining auxiliary task is introduced to better activate LLM's global
comprehension of intricate scenarios. Second, during fine-tuning, we further
utilize reference tags to bridge RoI features with texts, while preserving both
modality semantics. Finally, we use instruct-style prompts to narrow the gap
between pretraining and fine-tuning, and task-specific adapters to better
integrate LLM's inherent knowledge with new commonsense. Experimental results
show the effectiveness of our proposed auxiliary task and fine-grained linking
strategy.
|
[
-0.5141794085502625,
-0.6819912195205688,
0.5555888414382935,
-0.20801639556884766,
-0.4733026921749115,
-0.25143933296203613,
-0.3805001378059387,
-0.5282813906669617,
-0.23524245619773865,
0.23151762783527374,
-0.5490201711654663,
-0.3472512364387512,
-0.2596701979637146,
0.1050756424665451,
0.08158726990222931,
0.8564249277114868,
-0.09385617822408676,
0.029124099761247635,
-0.4711119532585144,
0.006247259676456451,
-0.38191118836402893,
-0.3484565019607544,
-0.687976062297821,
-0.17276641726493835,
0.604357123374939,
0.5037450790405273,
0.4006269574165344,
0.5040768980979919,
0.5341041684150696,
0.3237922787666321,
-0.045334309339523315,
0.6148703694343567,
-0.38291364908218384,
0.06063529849052429,
-0.5021532773971558,
-0.39203524589538574,
-0.2828356623649597,
-0.3158498704433441,
0.3692254424095154,
0.1839950680732727,
0.1253969371318817,
0.14218083024024963,
0.12977759540081024,
0.2931206226348877,
-1.03468656539917,
-0.011846113950014114,
-0.841727614402771,
0.09239038079977036,
-0.295963853597641,
-0.48940619826316833,
-0.2529812753200531,
0.1803276538848877,
0.012045304290950298,
-1.0414767265319824,
0.36717697978019714,
0.10551353543996811,
0.9132919311523438,
0.44475483894348145,
-0.3570030629634857,
0.08146373927593231,
-0.5546696186065674,
0.6648250818252563,
-0.43183884024620056,
0.7770143151283264,
0.38319751620292664,
0.2988012433052063,
0.09166707843542099,
-0.7146729230880737,
-0.9336379766464233,
-0.2072451114654541,
-0.010642584413290024,
0.2731102406978607,
-0.17294655740261078,
0.13080331683158875,
0.3110245168209076,
-0.10148091614246368,
-0.6337755918502808,
0.15043003857135773,
-0.31006139516830444,
-0.12773163616657257,
0.4629984498023987,
0.3307889401912689,
0.24664565920829773,
-0.3137316405773163,
-0.6178353428840637,
-0.009365936741232872,
-0.49792546033859253,
0.09278851002454758,
0.0029427260160446167,
0.23127059638500214,
-0.16321353614330292,
0.4718755781650543,
-0.2220865786075592,
0.8527047038078308,
0.26802560687065125,
0.006481677293777466,
0.137344628572464,
-0.8408125042915344,
-0.35866034030914307,
0.10371561348438263,
0.5593305826187134,
0.496581494808197,
0.27498459815979004,
0.08312028646469116,
-0.04505498707294464,
0.11819612979888916,
0.16084380447864532,
-0.6571329832077026,
-0.1221807450056076,
-0.04729430004954338,
-0.5853546857833862,
-0.055938802659511566,
-0.06615127623081207,
-0.5558744072914124,
-0.26950588822364807,
-0.7067645192146301,
0.5840908885002136,
-0.46509695053100586,
-0.11898569017648697,
0.060641098767519,
-0.2181302011013031,
0.29634469747543335,
0.706982433795929,
-0.8026083111763,
-0.09187231957912445,
0.621017336845398,
0.4519021511077881,
-0.10872656106948853,
-0.41388899087905884,
-0.8110478520393372,
0.5310862064361572,
0.056236397475004196,
0.8208061456680298,
-0.8479641675949097,
-0.16388852894306183,
-0.09663733094930649,
0.11448458582162857,
-0.17470192909240723,
-0.43144339323043823,
0.4976840615272522,
-0.6080970168113708,
-0.08095410466194153,
-0.480172723531723,
-0.3050246834754944,
0.20342764258384705,
0.6091195344924927,
-0.4575302004814148,
0.8375164270401001,
-0.403369665145874,
-0.6638359427452087,
0.5962291955947876,
-0.5636871457099915,
-0.42196187376976013,
0.07278342545032501,
-0.33077770471572876,
-0.1807340532541275,
0.03777551278471947,
0.5812499523162842,
0.5979747772216797,
-0.04771367460489273,
0.1858682632446289,
-0.3128724694252014,
-0.11897764354944229,
0.25763601064682007,
-0.6422404050827026,
0.2927171587944031,
0.2148621529340744,
-0.1694742888212204,
0.2791253924369812,
-0.7153051495552063,
-0.26232093572616577,
-0.16253462433815002,
-0.1645742952823639,
-0.5638725161552429,
-0.0777471661567688,
0.14675599336624146,
0.33460235595703125,
0.2992503046989441,
-0.40257853269577026,
0.02589658461511135,
-0.019057828933000565,
0.09423922747373581,
0.67762690782547,
-0.05571865290403366,
0.5815147757530212,
-0.28306660056114197,
0.2869226634502411,
0.23225679993629456,
0.4748544692993164,
-0.4146944582462311,
-0.3550685942173004,
-0.7882722616195679,
-0.1794082373380661,
-0.2555471360683441,
0.6219953894615173,
-1.0961954593658447,
0.2049477994441986,
-0.13785310089588165,
-0.3037566542625427,
-0.28911489248275757,
0.2965365946292877,
0.599608302116394,
0.6551048755645752,
0.5917065739631653,
-0.24744340777397156,
-0.6533361673355103,
-0.6199367642402649,
-0.16057094931602478,
-0.10698480904102325,
0.17673946917057037,
0.28581503033638,
0.42522305250167847,
-0.20890501141548157,
0.8470848202705383,
-0.21077270805835724,
-0.4395647943019867,
-0.18078121542930603,
0.25951260328292847,
-0.2783191502094269,
0.48828116059303284,
0.2140568196773529,
-0.991482138633728,
-0.11233989894390106,
0.21929696202278137,
-0.5790689587593079,
-0.1449471414089203,
-0.4238668978214264,
-0.17448833584785461,
0.29328787326812744,
0.8751457333564758,
-0.32256466150283813,
0.5340680480003357,
0.35737472772598267,
-0.5209173560142517,
0.5750436186790466,
-0.30705714225769043,
0.3205011487007141,
-0.9459797739982605,
-0.1482679545879364,
0.10877163708209991,
-0.1946990191936493,
-0.4201158583164215,
-0.19742640852928162,
-0.0714874416589737,
0.1445610672235489,
-0.6328568458557129,
0.8269027471542358,
-0.5530410408973694,
0.07642503082752228,
-0.13619820773601532,
0.1805589497089386,
0.24816009402275085,
0.45307064056396484,
0.36913442611694336,
0.597472608089447,
0.3444206714630127,
-0.5995012521743774,
0.44073039293289185,
0.33894801139831543,
-0.30325600504875183,
0.8538082242012024,
-0.41739621758461,
-0.26717597246170044,
-0.21316365897655487,
0.03702167794108391,
-0.7634333372116089,
-0.08456781506538391,
0.06644673645496368,
-0.3405272662639618,
0.28766345977783203,
-0.1747978925704956,
-0.30437836050987244,
-0.20806817710399628,
-0.03701406717300415,
0.6289567947387695,
0.2975682020187378,
-0.7950311303138733,
0.856495201587677,
0.04953114315867424,
-0.02248428761959076,
-0.5591021776199341,
-0.7161963582038879,
-0.005592814180999994,
-0.08185216039419174,
-0.6300438642501831,
0.2510862946510315,
-0.005568309687077999,
-0.22453573346138,
0.2057679146528244,
-0.09008501470088959,
-0.17649860680103302,
-0.26999688148498535,
0.07754592597484589,
0.43448343873023987,
-0.26581138372421265,
0.2953680157661438,
-0.09770174324512482,
-0.1732846200466156,
-0.225286602973938,
-0.21691766381263733,
0.3038110136985779,
-0.2842691242694855,
-0.8742889165878296,
-0.5975175499916077,
0.19900205731391907,
0.48815640807151794,
-0.5459514856338501,
0.36256271600723267,
1.0427896976470947,
-0.12784448266029358,
-0.03146963566541672,
-0.8380972146987915,
-0.20311078429222107,
-0.4740552306175232,
0.5151214599609375,
-0.3274206519126892,
-1.1096456050872803,
0.35667186975479126,
0.011851942166686058,
-0.2994350790977478,
0.07472656667232513,
0.6095730662345886,
-0.27090877294540405,
0.8259479403495789,
0.3255612254142761,
0.38827061653137207,
0.9164897799491882,
-0.04383082315325737,
-0.08102131634950638,
-1.0531747341156006,
-0.5244093537330627,
-0.17972907423973083,
-0.2978742718696594,
-0.1973535716533661,
-1.0936952829360962,
0.3498293459415436,
0.18812772631645203,
-0.4789307713508606,
0.05434119701385498,
-0.38994771242141724,
0.7464350461959839,
0.6911650896072388,
0.26263532042503357,
0.43974095582962036,
-0.19125761091709137,
0.09120277315378189,
-0.1013171523809433,
-0.8178128004074097,
-0.3288811147212982,
0.6282790303230286,
-0.07565590739250183,
1.0163873434066772,
-0.17187562584877014,
0.5346672534942627,
-0.1508406698703766,
0.04029529541730881,
-0.533832848072052,
0.6275054216384888,
-0.13398024439811707,
-0.5907809734344482,
-0.40130215883255005,
-0.24279144406318665,
-0.8473037481307983,
0.09805254638195038,
-0.45683687925338745,
-0.7845895886421204,
0.5439037084579468,
0.44382232427597046,
-0.41618794202804565,
0.3819262981414795,
-0.6260176301002502,
1.1403722763061523,
-0.5726791620254517,
-0.7157691121101379,
-0.21573702991008759,
-0.7011234164237976,
0.24410319328308105,
0.16705270111560822,
0.23509469628334045,
-0.036288708448410034,
-0.1609932780265808,
0.5365369319915771,
-0.31443047523498535,
1.1611034870147705,
0.11823251098394394,
0.0405113510787487,
0.38609448075294495,
-0.0332227423787117,
0.5888527631759644,
0.20989564061164856,
0.24862685799598694,
-0.10219518840312958,
-0.175546795129776,
-0.10788099467754364,
-0.7280135154724121,
0.6077191829681396,
-0.6292467713356018,
-0.6138964891433716,
-0.08899897336959839,
-0.5041099786758423,
-0.1291932612657547,
-0.00816346239298582,
0.27063804864883423,
0.7705495357513428,
-0.3509817123413086,
0.06119249388575554,
0.8874314427375793,
-0.10358089208602905,
0.56594318151474,
0.41584211587905884,
0.056728433817625046,
-0.39153456687927246,
0.8551551699638367,
-0.2512824833393097,
0.4011552929878235,
0.7843836545944214,
0.04905087500810623,
-0.2060665637254715,
-0.38533157110214233,
-0.4285265803337097,
-0.049394942820072174,
-0.7801345586776733,
-0.2882865369319916,
-0.652243435382843,
0.0642661601305008,
-0.3717421889305115,
-0.7314121127128601,
-0.4050297737121582,
-0.3275812268257141,
-0.5089624524116516,
0.01582736149430275,
0.417438805103302,
0.24179497361183167,
-0.45662084221839905,
0.06271421909332275,
-1.040228247642517,
0.5664821863174438,
0.7502543926239014,
0.25386127829551697,
0.0501643605530262,
-0.47867530584335327,
-0.14253857731819153,
-0.13198576867580414,
-0.21009299159049988,
-0.6510143876075745,
0.14776551723480225,
0.2171906977891922,
0.7057327032089233,
0.7363589406013489,
0.14079102873802185,
0.9780076146125793,
-0.6005986332893372,
0.6844133138656616,
0.569769024848938,
-0.9777565002441406,
0.825550377368927,
-0.3213825225830078,
0.3300902843475342,
0.6046067476272583,
0.23954184353351593,
-0.4660479426383972,
-0.2904829978942871,
-0.5568283796310425,
-0.7692519426345825,
0.5357032418251038,
0.04624959081411362,
0.022126425057649612,
-0.10731394588947296,
-0.12989288568496704,
-0.04096746817231178,
-0.1339750587940216,
-0.554416298866272,
0.07992099225521088,
-0.3580516576766968,
-0.12468314170837402,
-0.01544210035353899,
-0.10453351587057114,
-0.24064937233924866,
-0.5559541583061218,
0.5271705985069275,
-0.1978742629289627,
0.01415002066642046,
0.4162154197692871,
-0.19715870916843414,
-0.12023498862981796,
0.4778021275997162,
0.581265926361084,
0.6334220170974731,
0.0841185450553894,
0.3019108474254608,
0.5541054606437683,
-0.40196433663368225,
-0.012025561183691025,
0.2831278443336487,
0.12221191823482513,
-0.16966187953948975,
0.5608232617378235,
1.1139676570892334,
0.5050752758979797,
-0.8226814270019531,
0.6942808032035828,
-0.10469193756580353,
0.050420962274074554,
-0.08703677356243134,
0.19474725425243378,
0.04893207550048828,
0.7569566965103149,
0.17917737364768982,
0.12462599575519562,
-0.03980403393507004,
-0.46632033586502075,
0.3424347937107086,
0.5071922540664673,
-0.5252930521965027,
-0.25063538551330566,
0.7375805974006653,
0.47333306074142456,
-0.1077735647559166,
0.31037113070487976,
-0.29510098695755005,
-0.6309881210327148,
0.5979021787643433,
0.6096829175949097,
0.6184738874435425,
-0.14302346110343933,
0.12037433683872223,
0.35609570145606995,
0.4643861651420593,
0.1382504403591156,
0.3752519488334656,
-0.43710857629776,
-0.9440180659294128,
-0.6577363014221191,
-0.5471174120903015,
-0.3247675895690918,
-0.07367581129074097,
-0.5707710981369019,
0.4853663444519043,
-0.07022859901189804,
0.08327293395996094,
-0.22127088904380798,
-0.3249475657939911,
-0.976421058177948,
0.34377139806747437,
0.6228040456771851,
0.9807713627815247,
-0.8528627157211304,
0.6072323322296143,
0.9600892066955566,
-0.5551806688308716,
-0.7527471780776978,
-0.16575582325458527,
0.015161359682679176,
-0.8330060839653015,
1.0349513292312622,
-0.07733993232250214,
0.04962284490466118,
-0.060873132199048996,
-0.4294660687446594,
-0.781586766242981,
1.1055119037628174,
0.0576993003487587,
-0.7920745611190796,
-0.07054592669010162,
-0.01183983962982893,
0.2133822739124298,
-0.21515361964702606,
0.25964874029159546,
0.2537233233451843,
0.631104052066803,
0.5690826177597046,
-1.0731433629989624,
0.1586364507675171,
-0.23839907348155975,
0.029613319784402847,
0.20775043964385986,
-0.4387521743774414,
0.5697187781333923,
-0.5480822324752808,
0.021591583266854286,
-0.20631444454193115,
0.7253669500350952,
0.45678576827049255,
0.6969646215438843,
0.5159375071525574,
0.7700638771057129,
0.6960378885269165,
0.017607178539037704,
0.8188462257385254,
0.06501229107379913,
-0.03525706008076668,
1.416637659072876,
-0.210198312997818,
0.8819124102592468,
0.6477847099304199,
0.2866117060184479,
0.3586674630641937,
0.2945217490196228,
-0.05547785013914108,
0.5456513166427612,
-0.08828835934400558,
-0.4942200779914856,
-0.9740920066833496,
-0.369790256023407,
-0.48336729407310486,
0.6888223886489868,
0.35653671622276306,
-0.19418200850486755,
-0.35576772689819336,
0.46417665481567383,
-0.29370278120040894,
0.00895449984818697,
-0.6044451594352722,
0.8666803240776062,
0.05938005447387695,
-0.48372501134872437,
0.24972327053546906,
-0.5310284495353699,
0.8022281527519226,
-0.5481184124946594,
-0.009200140833854675,
0.1423778086900711,
0.295492023229599,
-0.1219780445098877,
-0.7850934267044067,
0.18174955248832703,
0.010664224624633789,
-0.13916555047035217,
-0.14169085025787354,
0.9997354745864868,
-0.61277174949646,
-0.3586810231208801,
0.12508180737495422,
0.5967034697532654,
-0.17691296339035034,
0.06248890236020088,
-0.49968281388282776,
0.31227633357048035,
-0.27358418703079224,
-0.26574116945266724,
0.24195361137390137,
0.9184595942497253,
-0.20422570407390594,
0.48211249709129333,
0.72346431016922,
-0.06908764690160751,
0.030512172728776932,
0.21502771973609924,
1.0310213565826416,
-0.6330669522285461,
-0.5463395118713379,
-0.8156964182853699,
0.6967242360115051,
-0.1926129311323166,
-0.43362846970558167,
0.602039635181427,
0.5085405111312866,
1.21053147315979,
-0.06559934467077255,
0.7611452341079712,
0.07551886886358261,
-0.15947315096855164,
-0.743127167224884,
0.5077019929885864,
-0.7763394117355347,
-0.006510624196380377,
-0.2862534821033478,
-0.5685237050056458,
-0.31029224395751953,
0.48823943734169006,
-0.46214422583580017,
-0.12103144824504852,
0.6008817553520203,
0.921301007270813,
-0.2639088034629822,
0.0260474793612957,
0.4965161383152008,
-0.0016735687386244535,
0.08516915142536163,
0.8353018760681152,
1.2712548971176147,
-0.029094720259308815,
0.7856085896492004,
-0.051011718809604645,
-0.1974012404680252,
-0.3703918755054474,
-1.2289167642593384,
-1.0971136093139648,
-0.7901723980903625,
-0.3497934937477112,
-0.059345345944166183,
0.3253982663154602,
1.078467845916748,
0.7163974642753601,
-0.588356614112854,
0.16177839040756226,
-0.04814612865447998,
0.03207094222307205,
-0.039197444915771484,
-0.16744577884674072,
0.1597076803445816,
-0.5458989143371582,
-0.5420325994491577,
0.24777932465076447,
0.2892419397830963,
0.13644914329051971,
0.14990215003490448,
-0.1330702155828476,
-0.35189124941825867,
-0.04435131698846817,
0.7028853297233582,
0.4069228768348694,
-0.6810998916625977,
-0.39072370529174805,
-0.13782915472984314,
-0.12046351283788681,
-0.11398247629404068,
0.9605112075805664,
-0.9000792503356934,
0.6139925718307495,
0.7161747813224792,
0.6782718896865845,
0.5544413328170776,
-0.09027301520109177,
0.4688689708709717,
-0.6719042062759399,
0.2260855734348297,
0.18340463936328888,
0.4877304434776306,
0.30629077553749084,
-0.305427610874176,
0.23949483036994934,
0.24984435737133026,
-0.4237786829471588,
-0.5673932433128357,
0.370073527097702,
-1.2244350910186768,
-0.38750532269477844,
1.239884853363037,
0.24458594620227814,
-0.30162641406059265,
-0.3912696838378906,
-0.34090977907180786,
0.5431352853775024,
-0.17868377268314362,
0.47492924332618713,
0.28832706809043884,
-0.22570224106311798,
-0.4044075608253479,
-0.31643253564834595,
0.6009103059768677,
0.3275214731693268,
-0.925549328327179,
0.13490977883338928,
0.5908054709434509,
-0.09481360763311386,
0.1761324554681778,
0.651672899723053,
0.12168673425912857,
0.5940056443214417,
-0.030415335670113564,
0.17180891335010529,
-0.5932437181472778,
-0.4269444942474365,
-0.06313314288854599,
-0.06365782022476196,
-0.352714478969574,
-0.2402946949005127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13846v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13846v2
|
Filtered Direct Preference Optimization
| 2024-04-22T03:05:19 | 2024-04-23T11:56:45 |
Tetsuro Morimura, Mitsuki Sakamoto, Yuu Jinnai, Kenshi Abe, Kaito Ariu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) plays a crucial role in
aligning language models with human preferences. While the significance of
dataset quality is generally recognized, explicit investigations into its
impact within the RLHF framework, to our knowledge, have been limited. This
paper addresses the issue of text quality within the preference dataset by
focusing on Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), an increasingly adopted
reward-model-free RLHF method. We confirm that text quality significantly
influences the performance of models optimized with DPO more than those
optimized with reward-model-based RLHF. Building on this new insight, we
propose an extension of DPO, termed filtered direct preference optimization
(fDPO). fDPO uses a trained reward model to monitor the quality of texts within
the preference dataset during DPO training. Samples of lower quality are
discarded based on comparisons with texts generated by the model being
optimized, resulting in a more accurate dataset. Experimental results
demonstrate that fDPO enhances the final model performance. Our code is
available at https://github.com/CyberAgentAILab/filtered-dpo.
|
[
-0.20109082758426666,
-0.4407660961151123,
0.6796045303344727,
0.026281727477908134,
-0.52098149061203,
0.0058036488480865955,
-0.2363566905260086,
-0.2938547432422638,
-0.07200802862644196,
0.7705241441726685,
-0.7134289741516113,
-0.4535641372203827,
-0.6501061320304871,
0.2688762843608856,
-0.03473663330078125,
1.0063121318817139,
-0.2603428363800049,
-0.056460801512002945,
-0.3326278328895569,
0.08620179444551468,
-0.34266477823257446,
-0.4945582449436188,
-0.6070343255996704,
-0.8163425922393799,
0.5630530118942261,
0.5143658518791199,
0.8091722726821899,
0.9348865747451782,
0.3119812309741974,
0.22978278994560242,
0.020725179463624954,
0.3477628231048584,
-0.7589770555496216,
0.2687932848930359,
-0.18726567924022675,
-0.36199426651000977,
-0.18889248371124268,
0.260253369808197,
0.5726902484893799,
0.3442477583885193,
-0.2354252189397812,
-0.23706969618797302,
0.2249698042869568,
1.1163074970245361,
-0.6255512833595276,
0.08838938176631927,
-0.3566185235977173,
0.12615926563739777,
0.30555400252342224,
-0.46421298384666443,
-0.5991827845573425,
-0.5476416349411011,
0.30672723054885864,
-0.920225977897644,
-0.02594185806810856,
0.07070144265890121,
1.1054121255874634,
0.6213459372520447,
-0.40976858139038086,
-0.2686615586280823,
-0.6899645328521729,
1.0490566492080688,
-0.41436517238616943,
0.4240492284297943,
0.7607024312019348,
-0.10972988605499268,
-0.25773611664772034,
-0.18238483369350433,
-0.5293214321136475,
-0.3941696584224701,
-0.23816826939582825,
0.15701179206371307,
-0.007287962827831507,
0.3160141110420227,
-0.25029516220092773,
0.5366682410240173,
-0.3856768310070038,
0.2149207592010498,
-0.00037763043656013906,
-0.08779919147491455,
0.6940811276435852,
-0.005351184867322445,
0.1533060073852539,
-0.24107219278812408,
-0.27587127685546875,
-0.5160560607910156,
-0.47331398725509644,
0.523739755153656,
0.6611832976341248,
0.31115591526031494,
0.22818751633167267,
0.30300745368003845,
-0.3492131233215332,
0.9472175240516663,
0.16796092689037323,
-0.3972975015640259,
0.10175576061010361,
-0.16005103290081024,
-0.17681138217449188,
0.00392515305429697,
0.7442232370376587,
0.316753625869751,
0.26263609528541565,
-0.027490179985761642,
-0.5238804221153259,
-0.07766558974981308,
0.3981403708457947,
-0.9320998787879944,
-0.17995287477970123,
0.36989468336105347,
-0.6694055199623108,
-0.8354941606521606,
-0.0016900328919291496,
-0.6298121809959412,
-0.37456223368644714,
-0.6001914143562317,
0.2538895010948181,
-0.31649449467658997,
-0.35219264030456543,
0.29914355278015137,
-0.01205961499363184,
-0.3126069903373718,
0.31837713718414307,
-1.1182897090911865,
0.23569177091121674,
0.7831109166145325,
0.48053187131881714,
-0.41277092695236206,
-0.2472604364156723,
-0.8692230582237244,
-0.2412373274564743,
-0.4108430743217468,
0.7731823325157166,
-0.6386638879776001,
-0.6034685373306274,
0.05242140218615532,
-0.2833435535430908,
0.11412599682807922,
-0.5929278135299683,
1.040175437927246,
-0.6635822057723999,
0.35174357891082764,
-0.10401513427495956,
-0.5747667551040649,
-0.17729048430919647,
0.11734647303819656,
-0.7769584655761719,
1.0601379871368408,
0.12040502578020096,
-0.5983652472496033,
0.6666519045829773,
-0.20892640948295593,
-0.3181573450565338,
-0.25818291306495667,
-0.07058092206716537,
-0.40039971470832825,
0.1144297644495964,
0.3510649800300598,
0.294528990983963,
-0.14769688248634338,
0.7321892976760864,
-0.23494881391525269,
-0.6460002064704895,
0.3380272090435028,
-0.3777380585670471,
0.20116157829761505,
0.2031240165233612,
-0.10974183678627014,
0.5323761701583862,
-0.8824734091758728,
0.008395588956773281,
-0.05274501070380211,
-0.7458221316337585,
-0.6327102184295654,
0.26546451449394226,
-0.0989374965429306,
0.18293698132038116,
-0.030799221247434616,
-0.652482807636261,
0.025288542732596397,
-0.6719763278961182,
0.2786654233932495,
1.068170428276062,
-0.09029646217823029,
0.608781099319458,
-0.39673110842704773,
0.40803587436676025,
-0.1318359225988388,
0.31122270226478577,
0.29196810722351074,
-0.2761276066303253,
-0.6073713898658752,
-0.34883689880371094,
0.40016108751296997,
0.40320098400115967,
-0.8741543292999268,
0.6285118460655212,
-0.2329896241426468,
-0.1789095252752304,
-0.5439209938049316,
0.1110062524676323,
0.43211260437965393,
0.5416319370269775,
0.23218172788619995,
-0.16518105566501617,
-0.1627236306667328,
-0.9810494184494019,
-0.17111453413963318,
-0.24669353663921356,
-0.056471552699804306,
0.6162951588630676,
0.10730651021003723,
-0.13890831172466278,
1.1517013311386108,
-0.6833541393280029,
-0.1627674400806427,
-0.18797197937965393,
-0.06653785705566406,
0.4051635265350342,
0.34589555859565735,
0.3790584206581116,
-0.8363078832626343,
-0.4001379609107971,
-0.27585241198539734,
-0.17113852500915527,
-0.12375710159540176,
0.03678712248802185,
-0.30439063906669617,
0.2460600733757019,
-0.18011003732681274,
-0.12263909727334976,
0.08577868342399597,
0.8145012259483337,
-0.5404151678085327,
0.3779861629009247,
-0.49865904450416565,
0.5039249658584595,
-0.5618003010749817,
0.15301908552646637,
0.1468069702386856,
-0.2599140405654907,
-0.4309147596359253,
-0.356825053691864,
0.15488797426223755,
-0.14933905005455017,
-0.354247510433197,
0.8987888097763062,
0.07335182279348373,
0.11631262302398682,
-0.5373028516769409,
0.08261897414922714,
0.39411529898643494,
0.5798438787460327,
0.37378162145614624,
0.8187204003334045,
0.009137480519711971,
-0.9034383296966553,
0.1847112774848938,
0.3386199176311493,
-0.33926689624786377,
0.3765257000923157,
-0.6295726895332336,
0.09242124110460281,
-0.23803457617759705,
0.16922509670257568,
-0.8865761756896973,
-0.055503156036138535,
0.3178943991661072,
-0.39919257164001465,
0.32083427906036377,
0.012535203248262405,
-0.3655345141887665,
-0.11753033846616745,
-0.44577091932296753,
0.1563776582479477,
0.2550722062587738,
-0.8434308767318726,
-0.023313771933317184,
0.37266573309898376,
0.09132479876279831,
-0.8372854590415955,
-0.18499481678009033,
-0.30098432302474976,
0.09974143654108047,
-0.30802813172340393,
0.5818951725959778,
-0.025404948741197586,
-0.12911206483840942,
-0.06829056143760681,
-0.24931158125400543,
-0.14089998602867126,
0.18989698588848114,
0.13851168751716614,
0.4077930748462677,
0.41181889176368713,
0.3296581506729126,
0.25647106766700745,
-0.3178468346595764,
-0.10674101114273071,
-0.18907615542411804,
0.47635772824287415,
0.36592793464660645,
0.15454652905464172,
-0.6647520661354065,
0.14043216407299042,
0.12236516922712326,
-0.14062681794166565,
0.498045951128006,
0.17578579485416412,
0.08412347733974457,
-0.5291607975959778,
-0.12661047279834747,
-0.5454524755477905,
-0.5582769513130188,
0.1864989846944809,
-0.3954569697380066,
-0.9988914132118225,
-0.1605609655380249,
0.24942222237586975,
-0.10721971094608307,
0.16154609620571136,
0.02502504363656044,
0.06590381264686584,
1.0765483379364014,
0.5099973678588867,
-0.1347927749156952,
0.8845822215080261,
0.062214311212301254,
-0.10562454909086227,
-0.4418174922466278,
-0.06720703095197678,
-0.59151291847229,
-0.2209186851978302,
-0.6559137105941772,
-0.24803879857063293,
-0.0667143315076828,
0.04230976104736328,
-0.3884137272834778,
-0.017832256853580475,
-0.8824220895767212,
0.360945463180542,
0.8993738889694214,
0.6092343926429749,
0.5358300805091858,
0.22006502747535706,
-0.17948146164417267,
-0.2368130087852478,
-0.5768316984176636,
-0.5454952120780945,
1.0423825979232788,
0.47432830929756165,
0.8220884203910828,
-0.3291339874267578,
0.8244808316230774,
0.5517626404762268,
0.25011003017425537,
-0.8003532290458679,
0.3322509229183197,
-0.36507123708724976,
-0.2996090054512024,
-0.35612478852272034,
-0.7767850756645203,
-0.9457142949104309,
0.22821441292762756,
-0.19505611062049866,
-0.3645226061344147,
0.4578409790992737,
0.3182562589645386,
-0.30125686526298523,
0.04695634916424751,
-0.421202152967453,
0.6735784411430359,
-0.2866806387901306,
-0.5102919340133667,
-0.4758046269416809,
-0.1538161337375641,
0.33099380135536194,
0.2792782187461853,
-0.015397013165056705,
-0.33996644616127014,
-0.001311414991505444,
0.8125607371330261,
-0.3004019558429718,
0.4797496199607849,
-0.18542303144931793,
-0.2809252142906189,
0.14326977729797363,
0.11944557726383209,
0.5900896191596985,
0.20856471359729767,
-0.29202330112457275,
-0.034332357347011566,
-0.009460982866585255,
-0.28126001358032227,
-0.4205121099948883,
0.9096890091896057,
-1.210844874382019,
-0.4621581435203552,
-0.5419932007789612,
-0.12906895577907562,
-0.3044881224632263,
0.11625072360038757,
0.013150633312761784,
0.4201063811779022,
-0.09405814111232758,
-0.00829129759222269,
0.7555480003356934,
-0.5639139413833618,
0.3097204566001892,
0.47571197152137756,
-0.23063057661056519,
-0.8815435171127319,
0.9932444095611572,
-0.30882591009140015,
0.27019473910331726,
0.7998881340026855,
0.439859002828598,
-0.5251278281211853,
-0.5385656356811523,
-0.5269142389297485,
0.3117963373661041,
-0.6012489199638367,
-0.10908506065607071,
-0.37659215927124023,
0.12466152012348175,
-0.09760935604572296,
0.06443237513303757,
-0.41886836290359497,
-0.23862753808498383,
-0.5158177614212036,
-0.14641284942626953,
0.46266108751296997,
0.4641232490539551,
0.11462228000164032,
0.09748377650976181,
-0.7834200263023376,
0.3592015206813812,
0.4032749831676483,
0.856961727142334,
-0.1131209135055542,
-0.4368098974227905,
-0.08345357328653336,
0.21008478105068207,
-0.20564663410186768,
-0.6061998009681702,
0.5680071711540222,
-0.025729328393936157,
0.5574201345443726,
0.18158793449401855,
0.4391510486602783,
0.0893147885799408,
-0.18723419308662415,
0.499011754989624,
0.038280922919511795,
-0.9149903059005737,
0.8432695269584656,
-0.4657137095928192,
0.07208032160997391,
0.9244154691696167,
0.3568822741508484,
-0.5355711579322815,
0.056595589965581894,
-0.2897350490093231,
-0.609819233417511,
1.0088763236999512,
0.05576474219560623,
0.035347096621990204,
0.08150631934404373,
0.6660041809082031,
0.2700301706790924,
0.41809210181236267,
-0.7019516229629517,
-0.2901919186115265,
-0.37116774916648865,
-0.12527455389499664,
-0.1447649598121643,
-0.5867988467216492,
-0.009426678530871868,
-0.08479595929384232,
0.8508355021476746,
-0.0721396803855896,
0.1547166258096695,
0.400665819644928,
0.08672665059566498,
-0.23458054661750793,
0.2565389573574066,
0.6402841210365295,
0.5086475610733032,
-0.5460320711135864,
-0.2691102921962738,
-0.6045870184898376,
-0.5788934826850891,
0.5411655902862549,
-0.06664422899484634,
-0.4481341540813446,
-0.01770513318479061,
-0.07540817558765411,
1.143368124961853,
0.14121690392494202,
-0.735718846321106,
0.44256162643432617,
-0.2938365042209625,
-0.2281988263130188,
0.21430377662181854,
0.42042380571365356,
-0.41925957798957825,
-0.21882109344005585,
0.2834957540035248,
-0.09839905053377151,
0.1521325409412384,
-0.30149102210998535,
0.34055399894714355,
-0.019053705036640167,
-0.794866144657135,
0.006923491135239601,
0.42831969261169434,
0.7052979469299316,
-0.4028729498386383,
0.6302472352981567,
-0.02453673630952835,
-0.3652958571910858,
0.42803147435188293,
0.20022957026958466,
0.6840401291847229,
-0.04940894618630409,
0.6069629192352295,
0.5924788117408752,
0.06220569461584091,
-0.20496195554733276,
0.021314242854714394,
-0.22985531389713287,
-0.9235171675682068,
-0.6113488674163818,
-0.7714832425117493,
-0.7949522137641907,
0.09790683537721634,
-0.5626082420349121,
0.20960018038749695,
-0.46135765314102173,
-0.0754137709736824,
-0.3124019503593445,
0.484835684299469,
-0.39852479100227356,
0.5577819347381592,
-0.13480323553085327,
0.5497562289237976,
-0.4990554749965668,
1.0759481191635132,
0.42245593667030334,
-0.2291889488697052,
-0.6766100525856018,
0.06743401288986206,
-0.23903025686740875,
-0.6600759625434875,
0.8112418055534363,
0.0371522381901741,
-0.16728408634662628,
0.09150385111570358,
-0.01426015980541706,
-0.8231920599937439,
0.8462780117988586,
0.364931583404541,
-0.5532293915748596,
0.2989719808101654,
0.06846953928470612,
0.45577287673950195,
-0.13960544764995575,
0.24109844863414764,
0.6148170232772827,
0.5760473012924194,
-0.16054274141788483,
-0.8475601673126221,
-0.00019351641822140664,
-0.09710430353879929,
0.13943247497081757,
0.245611771941185,
-0.6574148535728455,
0.40637972950935364,
0.10970817506313324,
-0.15073144435882568,
-0.15859951078891754,
0.3373289704322815,
0.42077380418777466,
0.10575727373361588,
0.6083642840385437,
0.38126495480537415,
0.6201310753822327,
-0.12604977190494537,
1.3650773763656616,
-0.08029625564813614,
0.45417773723602295,
0.9946379661560059,
-0.35563647747039795,
0.8945868611335754,
0.5238412618637085,
-0.26201683282852173,
0.3314908742904663,
1.032779335975647,
0.3439447283744812,
1.0462086200714111,
0.35654717683792114,
-0.16714037954807281,
-0.20050054788589478,
-0.2392510622739792,
-0.09689611941576004,
0.329792857170105,
-0.14889761805534363,
-0.44478899240493774,
0.04799973592162132,
0.07104959338903427,
-0.03460110351443291,
0.6014962196350098,
-0.10982339829206467,
0.8288490772247314,
-0.2523719072341919,
-1.1424721479415894,
0.7678899168968201,
0.040640853345394135,
0.9054949879646301,
-0.4696645438671112,
0.09632918238639832,
-0.4788028299808502,
0.436099112033844,
-0.024908117949962616,
-0.7837737798690796,
0.18848542869091034,
-0.34809112548828125,
-0.5842381119728088,
-0.6703070998191833,
0.6957037448883057,
-0.42724236845970154,
-0.16127140820026398,
0.5138959884643555,
0.15445809066295624,
-0.2320541888475418,
-0.35205721855163574,
-0.6164954900741577,
0.19831308722496033,
0.25867021083831787,
-0.5190106630325317,
0.5031218528747559,
0.061725471168756485,
0.4044753611087799,
0.6657690405845642,
0.7314582467079163,
0.11684176325798035,
-0.6536696553230286,
0.0742781013250351,
0.660682737827301,
-0.46586915850639343,
-0.657815158367157,
-0.795630693435669,
0.2864728271961212,
-0.22818970680236816,
-0.49539676308631897,
0.3105566203594208,
0.39617612957954407,
0.8643391132354736,
-0.15510743856430054,
0.607216477394104,
0.4715287685394287,
0.6681843400001526,
-0.5115087032318115,
0.8845515251159668,
-0.6105058789253235,
0.13120877742767334,
-0.2765926420688629,
-0.8078988194465637,
-0.12771391868591309,
0.6305630207061768,
-0.4252265989780426,
-0.27104049921035767,
0.583371639251709,
0.7182405591011047,
0.17553892731666565,
-0.008489721454679966,
0.46090641617774963,
-0.38059404492378235,
0.4103091359138489,
0.4570097327232361,
0.7324268817901611,
-0.3573835790157318,
0.6295518279075623,
-0.5365979671478271,
-0.2844305634498596,
-0.2532448172569275,
-0.9466990828514099,
-0.6350314617156982,
-0.6255545020103455,
-0.3329674303531647,
-0.3299320936203003,
0.19846729934215546,
0.8769913911819458,
0.8089503645896912,
-0.6814717054367065,
-0.17188136279582977,
-0.2658870220184326,
0.5461684465408325,
-0.2670232057571411,
-0.2611972689628601,
0.3685957193374634,
-0.31349098682403564,
-0.9145938754081726,
0.3455880880355835,
0.1987455040216446,
-0.04538106918334961,
-0.04346159100532532,
-0.4523254632949829,
-0.10158373415470123,
0.068730428814888,
0.5430822968482971,
0.01974530518054962,
-0.5709733963012695,
-0.38425934314727783,
0.07089307904243469,
-0.3402029871940613,
0.06181958317756653,
0.9994056820869446,
-0.8715580701828003,
0.5092888474464417,
0.703037440776825,
0.7131991982460022,
0.38570719957351685,
0.07426252961158752,
0.8055115342140198,
-0.7298882603645325,
0.1841738522052765,
0.3324819505214691,
0.07509107142686844,
0.24010069668293,
-0.6754767894744873,
0.40169796347618103,
0.18727637827396393,
-0.7377818822860718,
-0.7558780312538147,
0.1375178098678589,
-0.6864545345306396,
-0.484687864780426,
1.2985719442367554,
-0.06229867786169052,
-0.16189643740653992,
0.10368027538061142,
-0.49124273657798767,
0.06250747293233871,
-0.9294511675834656,
0.9587224125862122,
0.8545011281967163,
-0.14866958558559418,
-0.25244277715682983,
-0.40071386098861694,
1.0257751941680908,
0.5048916935920715,
-0.8352550864219666,
0.08935720473527908,
0.6031194925308228,
0.13252177834510803,
-0.36829710006713867,
0.8203786015510559,
0.20597030222415924,
0.28001245856285095,
-0.2112966924905777,
0.0011597010307013988,
-0.26067498326301575,
-0.2698995769023895,
-0.3937389552593231,
0.08233566582202911,
0.2504750192165375,
-0.2592429518699646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15159v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15159v2
|
MixLoRA: Enhancing Large Language Models Fine-Tuning with LoRA-based Mixture of Experts
| 2024-04-22T02:15:52 | 2024-05-23T05:16:33 |
Dengchun Li, Yingzi Ma, Naizheng Wang, Zhengmao Ye, Zhiyuan Cheng, Yinghao Tang, Yan Zhang, Lei Duan, Jie Zuo, Cal Yang, Mingjie Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Fine-tuning Large Language Models (LLMs) is a common practice to adapt
pre-trained models for specific applications. While methods like LoRA have
effectively addressed GPU memory constraints during fine-tuning, their
performance often falls short, especially in multi-task scenarios. In contrast,
Mixture-of-Expert (MoE) models, such as Mixtral 8x7B, demonstrate remarkable
performance in multi-task learning scenarios while maintaining a reduced
parameter count. However, the resource requirements of these MoEs remain
challenging, particularly for consumer-grade GPUs with less than 24GB memory.
To tackle these challenges, we propose MixLoRA, an approach to construct a
resource-efficient sparse MoE model based on LoRA. MixLoRA inserts multiple
LoRA-based experts within the feed-forward network block of a frozen
pre-trained dense model and employs a commonly used top-k router. Unlike other
LoRA-based MoE methods, MixLoRA enhances model performance by utilizing
independent attention-layer LoRA adapters. Additionally, an auxiliary load
balance loss is employed to address the imbalance problem of the router. Our
evaluations show that MixLoRA improves about 9% accuracy compared to
state-of-the-art PEFT methods in multi-task learning scenarios. We also propose
a new high-throughput framework to alleviate the computation and memory
bottlenecks during the training and inference of MOE models. This framework
reduces GPU memory consumption by 40% and token computation latency by 30%
during both training and inference.
|
[
-0.7222850918769836,
-1.0202704668045044,
0.25679609179496765,
0.28438225388526917,
-0.23668640851974487,
-0.003963766619563103,
-0.5039721727371216,
-0.5503929257392883,
0.25798773765563965,
0.5717005729675293,
-0.2913760542869568,
-0.12953150272369385,
-0.47566524147987366,
-0.2973212003707886,
-0.07418481260538101,
0.7682247161865234,
0.09386104345321655,
-0.0077935210429131985,
0.2703970968723297,
-0.30507680773735046,
-0.8889580965042114,
-0.240049809217453,
-0.8322915434837341,
-0.5581277012825012,
0.8088884353637695,
0.4181504547595978,
0.7052238583564758,
0.31173041462898254,
0.08391430974006653,
0.35812121629714966,
-0.2141403704881668,
0.7159627676010132,
-0.865481436252594,
0.032121527940034866,
-0.33974575996398926,
-0.346223384141922,
-0.7786422371864319,
-0.23509900271892548,
0.409849613904953,
0.5955138206481934,
-0.44826942682266235,
0.019796043634414673,
0.09230248630046844,
0.5688986778259277,
-0.9401764273643494,
-0.0038237841799855232,
-1.0391311645507812,
-0.06780310720205307,
-0.23165294528007507,
-0.30026277899742126,
-0.3144306540489197,
0.2229887992143631,
0.021639397367835045,
-0.7049534320831299,
0.11543739587068558,
0.10460971295833588,
0.5772997736930847,
0.5025977492332458,
-0.18244187533855438,
0.16017059981822968,
-0.6801390051841736,
0.7971619367599487,
-1.0274109840393066,
0.26673227548599243,
0.14345882833003998,
0.2933613657951355,
-0.3279963731765747,
-0.13057604432106018,
-0.6757116317749023,
0.35262879729270935,
0.2991195619106293,
0.011825744062662125,
-0.0530342273414135,
0.06804964691400528,
0.1273840218782425,
0.4411519169807434,
-0.34414663910865784,
0.32232290506362915,
-0.30092835426330566,
0.06738198548555374,
0.5685765743255615,
0.0973491370677948,
0.23806972801685333,
0.4325641691684723,
-0.10799530148506165,
0.07379186898469925,
-0.7700255513191223,
-0.47516825795173645,
0.25486859679222107,
0.5802309513092041,
0.0023591038770973682,
0.41544607281684875,
-0.20296521484851837,
0.7930644154548645,
0.19269230961799622,
-0.3156147599220276,
0.22663836181163788,
-0.12344051897525787,
-0.47960165143013,
0.15960219502449036,
0.5514590740203857,
0.08215302973985672,
0.13761508464813232,
-0.1407279223203659,
-0.20734357833862305,
0.08790642023086548,
0.21002055704593658,
-0.7455474138259888,
-0.44304701685905457,
0.1293327659368515,
-0.1510760635137558,
-0.05920117348432541,
-0.37497198581695557,
-0.882312536239624,
-0.49477681517601013,
-0.43089935183525085,
0.460970938205719,
-0.3149847686290741,
-0.40416646003723145,
0.26724129915237427,
0.17018014192581177,
0.08111847192049026,
0.7242650985717773,
-0.9244579076766968,
0.43282952904701233,
0.6587857007980347,
0.5591720342636108,
-0.3159867823123932,
-0.4777047336101532,
-0.7034193277359009,
0.2868173122406006,
-0.10389670729637146,
0.7985395193099976,
-0.4293006956577301,
-0.15853464603424072,
-0.2426784485578537,
-0.39522606134414673,
-0.3826693892478943,
-0.8243915438652039,
0.18546167016029358,
-0.6382862329483032,
0.05851120501756668,
-0.13318389654159546,
-0.42073535919189453,
-0.3590182662010193,
0.13067783415317535,
-0.6948071718215942,
1.1546969413757324,
0.13333620131015778,
-0.7205213308334351,
0.165488600730896,
-0.5530416965484619,
-0.4687737226486206,
0.10487020760774612,
-0.07905609160661697,
-0.13964593410491943,
0.2445642501115799,
0.3493232727050781,
0.3511297106742859,
-0.41358256340026855,
0.28826531767845154,
-0.37465423345565796,
-0.3632645010948181,
0.033418409526348114,
-0.46200644969940186,
0.49746575951576233,
0.4372338056564331,
-0.27983686327934265,
0.4544496536254883,
-0.7527642250061035,
0.07383089512586594,
-0.013699046336114407,
-0.6090829372406006,
-0.27591198682785034,
-0.006685678381472826,
0.5087677836418152,
0.21357153356075287,
0.38784271478652954,
-0.31504347920417786,
0.15662018954753876,
-0.1980690062046051,
0.43828654289245605,
0.7826377749443054,
-0.3073728084564209,
0.19084060192108154,
-0.274981826543808,
0.30101892352104187,
0.15500198304653168,
-0.0052948566153645515,
-0.06554748862981796,
-0.6350120902061462,
-0.968468964099884,
-0.3998425006866455,
0.19753290712833405,
0.5466970205307007,
-0.7900395393371582,
0.4875950515270233,
-0.2795802354812622,
-0.4489652216434479,
-0.6423056721687317,
0.7746468782424927,
0.2887086868286133,
0.43768343329429626,
0.5195091366767883,
-0.2598540484905243,
-0.37551507353782654,
-0.5973193049430847,
-0.06589147448539734,
0.2540504038333893,
0.22279633581638336,
0.4519500136375427,
0.16108636558055878,
-0.2956083416938782,
0.8018993139266968,
-0.5451615452766418,
-0.37663984298706055,
-0.438811719417572,
-0.15710704028606415,
0.3274153769016266,
0.6079053282737732,
0.5779566168785095,
-0.6754230856895447,
-0.6218573451042175,
0.3513985276222229,
-0.46802932024002075,
-0.07193146646022797,
0.08934929966926575,
-0.2706249952316284,
0.05343518778681755,
0.2674306035041809,
-0.6125741004943848,
0.1085038110613823,
0.7739554643630981,
-0.3662753999233246,
0.2554807662963867,
-0.5459442138671875,
-0.12208306789398193,
-1.0896974802017212,
0.02343030273914337,
-0.0039014588110148907,
-0.32738837599754333,
-0.46292829513549805,
0.30511197447776794,
-0.19871732592582703,
-0.17414872348308563,
-0.44165071845054626,
0.6306792497634888,
-0.25518545508384705,
-0.02545982226729393,
-0.5967954993247986,
0.02773861587047577,
-0.035619765520095825,
0.7418021559715271,
-0.17284619808197021,
0.9789909720420837,
0.5703133940696716,
-0.5954703092575073,
0.25037258863449097,
-0.09130579233169556,
-0.11790136247873306,
0.6035420298576355,
-0.5878365635871887,
0.2081853598356247,
0.12865805625915527,
0.11557798087596893,
-0.6669530868530273,
-0.26688331365585327,
0.22959762811660767,
0.19697751104831696,
0.30957522988319397,
-0.030641697347164154,
-0.6389402747154236,
0.029870398342609406,
-0.050526492297649384,
0.5814189314842224,
0.5436517596244812,
-0.5926845073699951,
1.0646586418151855,
0.5230823755264282,
-0.11250344663858414,
-0.46014776825904846,
-0.4955406188964844,
0.0967840850353241,
-0.23862899839878082,
-0.6287309527397156,
0.31860464811325073,
-0.3696644902229309,
-0.18960747122764587,
-0.18967284262180328,
-0.040971286594867706,
-0.32748112082481384,
0.2314450442790985,
0.06464912742376328,
0.059271190315485,
-0.4356778860092163,
-0.18355770409107208,
0.24277947843074799,
-0.006075817625969648,
-0.35404789447784424,
-0.1943899542093277,
0.7605724930763245,
-0.09607789665460587,
-0.40555790066719055,
-0.3463783860206604,
0.40377867221832275,
0.49653565883636475,
-0.22377373278141022,
0.8297604918479919,
0.8199872970581055,
-0.32439860701560974,
-0.5251956582069397,
-0.8817012906074524,
0.006933926604688168,
-0.5020867586135864,
0.37856239080429077,
-0.27022585272789,
-0.7518349289894104,
0.6541118621826172,
-0.06834179908037186,
0.17405062913894653,
0.3739035427570343,
0.6439904570579529,
0.1407158523797989,
0.599229097366333,
0.4702797830104828,
-0.516991376876831,
0.6960722208023071,
-0.12146614491939545,
0.08193757385015488,
-0.7772949934005737,
0.04895830899477005,
-0.23865962028503418,
-0.47644516825675964,
-0.15769752860069275,
-0.7104764580726624,
0.35548684000968933,
0.12465881556272507,
-0.2543908357620239,
-0.0023621059954166412,
-0.21521620452404022,
0.7291162610054016,
0.5303966403007507,
0.45970654487609863,
0.37337616086006165,
0.10908608138561249,
0.16563571989536285,
0.3242133855819702,
-1.1157656908035278,
-0.1077495738863945,
1.0462398529052734,
0.2880079448223114,
0.8676658272743225,
0.05579942837357521,
0.5145063400268555,
0.1426483541727066,
0.2720716893672943,
-0.4572829604148865,
0.6345334649085999,
-0.32213374972343445,
-0.5513851046562195,
-0.3062590956687927,
-0.444947749376297,
-0.6911508440971375,
0.6740157008171082,
-0.2830350399017334,
-0.7043542265892029,
0.08402706682682037,
0.47747382521629333,
-0.48724666237831116,
0.5593922734260559,
-0.6538718938827515,
0.7504774332046509,
-0.1576567441225052,
-0.5536172986030579,
-0.5842264294624329,
-0.20542429387569427,
0.3069210648536682,
-0.24980108439922333,
0.1912790834903717,
-0.22520050406455994,
0.08488209545612335,
0.5300114154815674,
-0.5914682149887085,
1.0613924264907837,
-0.11783458292484283,
-0.5712454915046692,
0.24057352542877197,
-0.11500586569309235,
0.46104803681373596,
-0.18711592257022858,
-0.0638904720544815,
0.18582184612751007,
-0.3284342288970947,
-0.6067646741867065,
-0.5090746283531189,
1.1027262210845947,
-0.9864201545715332,
-0.3889823257923126,
0.05916982516646385,
-0.9118521213531494,
-0.3449677526950836,
0.25937849283218384,
0.020299220457673073,
0.34838950634002686,
0.10442408174276352,
0.0929955244064331,
0.9953087568283081,
-0.15415512025356293,
0.2095355987548828,
0.37304630875587463,
-0.17431868612766266,
-0.5130555033683777,
1.138436198234558,
0.0849035307765007,
0.1451236754655838,
0.1952357441186905,
0.10688816756010056,
0.22892290353775024,
-0.7999552488327026,
-0.5208666324615479,
0.16242510080337524,
-0.7398508787155151,
-0.19044342637062073,
-0.4045385420322418,
-0.10556761175394058,
-0.031591642647981644,
-0.09142608940601349,
-0.7709985375404358,
-0.12192058563232422,
-0.5312587022781372,
0.32319608330726624,
0.29205647110939026,
0.5557070374488831,
0.3344050943851471,
0.8347392082214355,
-0.5739563703536987,
0.4034685790538788,
0.2915283739566803,
0.5383479595184326,
0.34819039702415466,
-0.48996126651763916,
-0.36816760897636414,
-0.07699602842330933,
-0.24219301342964172,
-0.5101132392883301,
0.43410179018974304,
0.3057800531387329,
0.560599684715271,
0.5970458984375,
-0.19456759095191956,
1.0928837060928345,
-0.5398538708686829,
0.34642571210861206,
0.015864279121160507,
-0.8422170877456665,
0.20247291028499603,
-0.5643811821937561,
0.2526710033416748,
0.5757686495780945,
-0.08950579166412354,
0.016322996467351913,
-0.15573939681053162,
-0.353596568107605,
-0.8569415807723999,
0.5811100006103516,
0.04799535870552063,
0.06640370935201645,
0.3450760543346405,
0.24607884883880615,
0.20358672738075256,
0.2220207154750824,
-0.5753335356712341,
-0.3010922074317932,
0.01425766758620739,
-0.39898940920829773,
-0.40225091576576233,
-0.18104679882526398,
-0.26580810546875,
-0.25163960456848145,
0.7057632803916931,
-0.32812702655792236,
-0.164352685213089,
-0.27767959237098694,
-0.16315685212612152,
-0.24287915229797363,
0.2516363561153412,
0.5514098405838013,
0.9327520132064819,
-0.15802539885044098,
0.08317402750253677,
0.5272932648658752,
-0.35560914874076843,
-0.16943737864494324,
0.1564754843711853,
-0.19783297181129456,
-0.15175123512744904,
0.14697782695293427,
0.8783853650093079,
0.7067131996154785,
-0.8691925406455994,
0.023257793858647346,
0.14143610000610352,
0.09321392327547073,
-0.019705161452293396,
0.5528789162635803,
0.1913912147283554,
0.4040624499320984,
0.3551107347011566,
0.27239784598350525,
-0.1175723522901535,
-0.3580920696258545,
-0.262496680021286,
0.38147059082984924,
0.07118130475282669,
-0.28522205352783203,
0.543316662311554,
0.2995315194129944,
-0.00886551570147276,
0.4158408045768738,
0.0953700914978981,
-0.37293440103530884,
0.40936902165412903,
0.5789910554885864,
0.5837168097496033,
-0.26185426115989685,
-0.28339576721191406,
-0.08842890709638596,
0.11162637919187546,
-0.27964159846305847,
0.5848449468612671,
0.009081609547138214,
-0.8439982533454895,
-0.46474626660346985,
-0.5535939931869507,
-0.3125374913215637,
0.19112637639045715,
-0.4529038667678833,
0.0613110326230526,
-0.5112284421920776,
-0.14306491613388062,
-0.14902310073375702,
-0.052303723990917206,
-0.7051927447319031,
0.07153526693582535,
0.3132711350917816,
0.8633355498313904,
-0.820212185382843,
1.0531798601150513,
0.5521652102470398,
-0.034478917717933655,
-0.7937242984771729,
-0.36714687943458557,
-0.36173680424690247,
-0.6098706126213074,
0.46841153502464294,
-0.03877393156290054,
-0.1893714964389801,
-0.037974558770656586,
-0.35054564476013184,
-0.740373969078064,
1.0331575870513916,
0.645760178565979,
-0.6206175684928894,
-0.08000107854604721,
-0.11351459473371506,
0.44504302740097046,
-0.37699195742607117,
0.12877538800239563,
0.25994375348091125,
0.30505645275115967,
0.12018071860074997,
-1.1292532682418823,
-0.0499221533536911,
-0.20091001689434052,
-0.0709690973162651,
0.023741338402032852,
-0.6939210891723633,
1.2646257877349854,
-0.03671383112668991,
0.21682420372962952,
-0.14210905134677887,
0.82533198595047,
0.5694625377655029,
0.3092179000377655,
0.5702493786811829,
0.7517011761665344,
0.8692296147346497,
0.24521295726299286,
0.8250340819358826,
-0.46802467107772827,
0.2065124213695526,
1.3632173538208008,
-0.4503694772720337,
1.1624119281768799,
0.6024233102798462,
-0.12870104610919952,
0.3921007215976715,
0.4629327058792114,
0.2255699783563614,
0.3865339159965515,
-0.009468263946473598,
-0.25135719776153564,
-0.5670440196990967,
0.03921281173825264,
-0.4666004180908203,
0.22290503978729248,
0.5071207284927368,
-0.21436193585395813,
-0.3031318187713623,
0.01783631183207035,
0.059070609509944916,
-0.2013421356678009,
-0.6887219548225403,
0.6893064379692078,
0.10039014369249344,
-0.6769365668296814,
0.6906784772872925,
0.08015875518321991,
0.9094948768615723,
-0.5393556952476501,
0.01789471134543419,
-0.2558755874633789,
0.559174656867981,
-0.16934853792190552,
-0.26916712522506714,
-0.1965344399213791,
-0.1468382179737091,
-0.12854577600955963,
0.14043240249156952,
0.6758902072906494,
-0.6633697748184204,
-0.5034621953964233,
0.2604130208492279,
0.6029505729675293,
-0.0008258257294073701,
-0.27523818612098694,
-0.6076765656471252,
0.31215471029281616,
-0.19595418870449066,
-0.12211184948682785,
0.7287557125091553,
0.46669772267341614,
0.1294875144958496,
0.9055286049842834,
0.6879246830940247,
0.3309982419013977,
0.40414488315582275,
0.0393095463514328,
1.267335057258606,
-0.26720142364501953,
-0.6166436076164246,
-0.6866920590400696,
0.042822565883398056,
0.13276703655719757,
-0.22039945423603058,
0.6917464733123779,
0.49126094579696655,
0.7658360004425049,
-0.1658751666545868,
0.6484132409095764,
0.313170462846756,
0.14987896382808685,
-0.6886180639266968,
0.7091277241706848,
-0.6312772631645203,
0.3028044104576111,
-0.23598222434520721,
-0.9936361312866211,
-0.0391068235039711,
0.4560660719871521,
-0.168939009308815,
0.20648357272148132,
0.19769899547100067,
0.6032734513282776,
-0.6023436784744263,
-0.06762189418077469,
0.3557358980178833,
0.18029646575450897,
0.21947930753231049,
0.7726297378540039,
0.40682584047317505,
-0.2506389021873474,
0.22609038650989532,
-0.22475920617580414,
-0.015546427108347416,
-0.4503571093082428,
-0.7419166564941406,
-1.0789051055908203,
-0.10182274132966995,
-0.37113016843795776,
-0.03752892464399338,
0.11784571409225464,
1.0611196756362915,
0.9889081120491028,
-0.9110193252563477,
-0.3687429428100586,
0.038817062973976135,
0.022209452465176582,
-0.2061305046081543,
-0.16111816465854645,
0.30488988757133484,
-0.3729041814804077,
-0.6984721422195435,
0.6542981266975403,
0.05191970244050026,
-0.024507349357008934,
-0.567324697971344,
-0.27420249581336975,
-0.1211671382188797,
0.13001172244548798,
0.620445191860199,
0.23054417967796326,
-0.7536967992782593,
0.11384106427431107,
-0.5061578154563904,
0.12163103371858597,
0.10451284050941467,
0.6791409254074097,
-0.7921031713485718,
0.3149105906486511,
0.46364787220954895,
0.8024888038635254,
0.3885863423347473,
0.06376615166664124,
0.6017893552780151,
-0.4911018908023834,
0.3398393392562866,
-0.049895305186510086,
0.7018623948097229,
0.19144663214683533,
-0.31130698323249817,
0.23153449594974518,
0.08190400153398514,
-0.3731389343738556,
-0.7546948790550232,
-0.06456682085990906,
-1.326000452041626,
-0.37308233976364136,
0.9925894141197205,
-0.19755218923091888,
-0.21935506165027618,
-0.15607614815235138,
-0.40984752774238586,
-0.07982602715492249,
-0.5715214014053345,
0.7022755146026611,
0.3884495198726654,
0.017579998821020126,
-0.2220306694507599,
-0.6717400550842285,
0.1412900984287262,
0.5780527591705322,
-1.0019571781158447,
0.11443136632442474,
0.49398624897003174,
0.3808616101741791,
0.0015096095157787204,
0.5906772017478943,
0.36083564162254333,
0.05769909545779228,
-0.11364280432462692,
-0.06264514476060867,
-0.2779752016067505,
-0.49330249428749084,
-0.1245734840631485,
0.4231417179107666,
0.14990416169166565,
0.1482904702425003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13813v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13813v1
|
From LLM to NMT: Advancing Low-Resource Machine Translation with Claude
| 2024-04-22T01:22:23 | 2024-04-22T01:22:23 |
Maxim Enis, Mark Hopkins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We show that Claude 3 Opus, a large language model (LLM) released by
Anthropic in March 2024, exhibits stronger machine translation competence than
other LLMs. Though we find evidence of data contamination with Claude on
FLORES-200, we curate new benchmarks that corroborate the effectiveness of
Claude for low-resource machine translation into English. We find that Claude
has remarkable \textit{resource efficiency} -- the degree to which the quality
of the translation model depends on a language pair's resource level. Finally,
we show that advancements in LLM translation can be compressed into traditional
neural machine translation (NMT) models. Using Claude to generate synthetic
data, we demonstrate that knowledge distillation advances the state-of-the-art
in Yoruba-English translation, meeting or surpassing strong baselines like
NLLB-54B and Google Translate.
|
[
-0.32068318128585815,
-0.840549886226654,
0.9877344965934753,
-0.058392174541950226,
-0.16588686406612396,
0.1501207798719406,
-0.4706316888332367,
-0.645833432674408,
0.31965336203575134,
0.6836473345756531,
-0.5222187638282776,
-0.18222083151340485,
-1.0965943336486816,
0.4208361804485321,
-0.47224947810173035,
0.688442587852478,
-0.019891934469342232,
0.18214911222457886,
-0.2164895236492157,
-0.2934826612472534,
-0.26671990752220154,
-0.3907274901866913,
-0.7003799676895142,
-0.6506639719009399,
0.9026912450790405,
0.29772964119911194,
0.5963542461395264,
0.9900839328765869,
0.4997987449169159,
0.3898671865463257,
-0.19473327696323395,
0.4504230320453644,
-0.4537234306335449,
0.26700273156166077,
-0.07936017960309982,
-0.47094428539276123,
-1.034919261932373,
0.08594179898500443,
0.5012235641479492,
0.7407473921775818,
0.18373937904834747,
0.06652630865573883,
0.1056925356388092,
1.0471959114074707,
-0.40024644136428833,
0.11348661780357361,
-0.7794192433357239,
-0.16118375957012177,
-0.24095208942890167,
-0.26443788409233093,
-0.493959903717041,
-0.3251006007194519,
-0.004402468912303448,
-0.6671660542488098,
-0.2625218331813812,
-0.003028318053111434,
0.7358880043029785,
0.6676083207130432,
-0.6647344827651978,
-0.12106496840715408,
-0.6144835352897644,
1.1260535717010498,
-0.5666621327400208,
0.36559662222862244,
0.6052087545394897,
0.3172946572303772,
-0.09186536818742752,
-1.0437692403793335,
-0.5146942138671875,
-0.0952049195766449,
0.20831705629825592,
0.0185182336717844,
-0.4211004972457886,
-0.24981118738651276,
0.26744544506073,
0.4854864180088043,
-0.11488446593284607,
0.14269959926605225,
-0.7687862515449524,
-0.11260469257831573,
0.5564799308776855,
0.029520308598876,
0.04508482292294502,
-0.22647324204444885,
-0.3929592967033386,
-0.1744043529033661,
-0.6112989783287048,
-0.4697990119457245,
0.23820503056049347,
0.22976745665073395,
0.02571464143693447,
0.5814562439918518,
-0.19153445959091187,
0.8488845229148865,
-0.2710675597190857,
-0.01423007994890213,
0.13841524720191956,
-0.2100333571434021,
-0.2570051848888397,
0.020987171679735184,
1.0577598810195923,
0.3171424865722656,
0.16778485476970673,
-0.08917877823114395,
-0.18269914388656616,
-0.19184209406375885,
0.3779149353504181,
-0.8933831453323364,
-0.24456338584423065,
0.06100848689675331,
-0.34235984086990356,
-0.445658802986145,
-0.2078264057636261,
-0.5127643346786499,
-0.6538199186325073,
-0.4520854353904724,
0.26469874382019043,
-0.6034311056137085,
-0.14290930330753326,
-0.03991074115037918,
0.06555097550153732,
0.11462311446666718,
0.5717152953147888,
-0.7735652923583984,
0.14030200242996216,
0.5703598856925964,
0.946433961391449,
-0.3150896728038788,
-0.20732249319553375,
-0.619023859500885,
-0.20810289680957794,
-0.4301944375038147,
0.439992219209671,
-0.07864924520254135,
-0.17728818953037262,
-0.2610738277435303,
0.11534716933965683,
0.23836058378219604,
-0.5345390439033508,
0.49868547916412354,
-0.8448736667633057,
0.1450059413909912,
-0.5152568817138672,
-0.3384329378604889,
-0.6145121455192566,
0.405582994222641,
-0.7492371201515198,
0.960599422454834,
0.39171260595321655,
-0.4969737231731415,
0.1319255381822586,
-0.7611107230186462,
-0.37564072012901306,
-0.07537772506475449,
0.3547046482563019,
-0.304034948348999,
0.27625522017478943,
0.2254481017589569,
0.4049307405948639,
-0.7112426161766052,
0.04865388199687004,
-0.3935326337814331,
-0.04145254194736481,
0.4683856666088104,
-0.6066442131996155,
1.1199517250061035,
0.6040092706680298,
0.09936021268367767,
-0.28919094800949097,
-0.7823108434677124,
0.06716739386320114,
0.14456605911254883,
-0.5704984068870544,
-0.2542523741722107,
-0.14019303023815155,
-0.0814993679523468,
0.23092886805534363,
0.523932695388794,
-0.38718312978744507,
0.42708322405815125,
-0.022670414298772812,
0.9725770354270935,
0.5780564546585083,
0.060363058000802994,
0.6119173169136047,
-0.22570788860321045,
0.44618406891822815,
-0.21712395548820496,
-0.005271168891340494,
-0.08315446972846985,
-0.6562178730964661,
-0.9299865365028381,
-0.15265874564647675,
0.5949252247810364,
0.6450921297073364,
-0.9501484036445618,
0.24834921956062317,
-0.48428067564964294,
-0.4530523717403412,
-0.8573020100593567,
0.3843849301338196,
0.10944703966379166,
0.6338639259338379,
0.7388402223587036,
-0.33175578713417053,
-0.5168517231941223,
-1.0468189716339111,
-0.0013651878107339144,
-0.02012125588953495,
-0.10253932327032089,
0.14011743664741516,
0.27214980125427246,
-0.5086963176727295,
0.46790364384651184,
-0.45050498843193054,
-0.059759996831417084,
-0.3923873007297516,
0.11031314730644226,
0.3666205406188965,
0.41631197929382324,
0.5749921202659607,
-0.5972000956535339,
-0.5216057896614075,
0.40644213557243347,
-0.8935969471931458,
-0.14812561869621277,
0.4306296110153198,
-0.35899078845977783,
0.2955693006515503,
0.5191718339920044,
-0.1223936378955841,
-0.1475873738527298,
0.7065399885177612,
0.0007865398656576872,
-0.007743665482848883,
-0.4118115305900574,
0.2946959137916565,
-1.45769202709198,
-0.016666920855641365,
-0.25215640664100647,
-0.7663108706474304,
-0.6117502450942993,
-0.05448183789849281,
0.2669064402580261,
-0.05591748282313347,
-0.6680200099945068,
0.13136282563209534,
-0.3672963082790375,
-0.021997269243001938,
-0.38881608843803406,
0.3595457077026367,
0.04055125266313553,
0.2050696462392807,
-0.11124498397111893,
0.6781594753265381,
0.36981305480003357,
-0.6889604330062866,
0.6993035078048706,
0.11605975776910782,
-0.1464771181344986,
0.620643675327301,
-0.5103548765182495,
0.33092746138572693,
0.24815919995307922,
-0.0796377882361412,
-0.4575427770614624,
-0.22164639830589294,
0.02274264767765999,
-0.4944016933441162,
0.4629499912261963,
-0.24639210104942322,
-0.5362606048583984,
-0.25418806076049805,
-0.13318462669849396,
0.12032920122146606,
0.8681212663650513,
-0.3496790826320648,
0.3524373769760132,
0.42614102363586426,
-0.15381333231925964,
-0.42562559247016907,
-1.1365848779678345,
0.40190523862838745,
-0.33124661445617676,
-0.6684544086456299,
0.11185997724533081,
0.012306411750614643,
-0.3401799201965332,
-0.020503433421254158,
0.004842981230467558,
-0.2854189872741699,
0.2232426106929779,
-0.4106161594390869,
0.29592591524124146,
-0.29028061032295227,
-0.12504704296588898,
-0.10006548464298248,
-0.27258357405662537,
0.16317859292030334,
-0.8992746472358704,
0.4746319055557251,
-0.29975631833076477,
0.14365148544311523,
-0.3231876790523529,
-0.18540476262569427,
0.7156220078468323,
-0.023892704397439957,
0.7357999086380005,
0.6268970966339111,
-0.2654303014278412,
0.00573746906593442,
-0.45340192317962646,
-0.2731650769710541,
-0.4466197192668915,
0.38497358560562134,
-0.24119405448436737,
-0.6558523178100586,
0.3315335810184479,
-0.4046374559402466,
-0.12023478746414185,
0.579604983329773,
0.5934345126152039,
-0.29598918557167053,
0.57632976770401,
0.750270664691925,
0.0723247155547142,
0.4542635381221771,
-0.7530388236045837,
-0.11538271605968475,
-1.0795775651931763,
-0.001541981240734458,
-0.2428237497806549,
-0.6413869261741638,
-0.9965248703956604,
-0.6951372027397156,
0.4576934576034546,
0.15891899168491364,
0.10329988598823547,
1.046756386756897,
-0.378935307264328,
0.4955967664718628,
0.7527998089790344,
0.16370292007923126,
0.5801199674606323,
-0.01438113208860159,
0.022993391379714012,
-0.29480963945388794,
-0.7770401835441589,
-0.5521087050437927,
1.3170323371887207,
0.13699156045913696,
0.3275279402732849,
0.17595140635967255,
0.7371053695678711,
0.4270581305027008,
0.3918454051017761,
-0.6652148962020874,
0.47672179341316223,
-0.1879921406507492,
-0.5971364378929138,
-0.3151298761367798,
-0.6941340565681458,
-0.8101323246955872,
0.2907237708568573,
-0.37734514474868774,
-0.4467746317386627,
0.0811011791229248,
0.10719111561775208,
0.005829637870192528,
0.41842204332351685,
-0.5763433575630188,
0.9751160144805908,
-0.42589595913887024,
-0.7926585078239441,
-0.28187671303749084,
-0.6114030480384827,
0.4088802635669708,
-0.47669363021850586,
0.294998437166214,
-0.2006978839635849,
-0.30508214235305786,
0.3602556586265564,
-0.5983871817588806,
0.30788904428482056,
-0.04239337518811226,
-0.2630816400051117,
0.29926156997680664,
0.33321428298950195,
0.5962043404579163,
0.042984310537576675,
-0.3913646638393402,
0.3144240081310272,
-0.33540964126586914,
-0.5778924226760864,
-0.5795776844024658,
0.787104070186615,
-0.7114960551261902,
-0.3116798400878906,
-0.3001290261745453,
-0.647709310054779,
-0.07659127563238144,
0.38174375891685486,
0.4993933439254761,
0.1476782262325287,
-0.04387393593788147,
0.4753730893135071,
0.8074368834495544,
-0.2220197170972824,
0.43506669998168945,
0.591429591178894,
-0.11273358017206192,
-0.7231423258781433,
1.0410152673721313,
0.19576960802078247,
0.4985659122467041,
0.5461007952690125,
0.21210412681102753,
-0.36216503381729126,
-0.4940931499004364,
-0.6879630088806152,
0.08058075606822968,
-0.5278063416481018,
-0.43029943108558655,
-0.6778293251991272,
-0.012178744189441204,
-0.08082784712314606,
-0.27094876766204834,
-0.7346514463424683,
-0.8954718708992004,
0.029572488740086555,
-0.008613134734332561,
0.525479793548584,
0.9251325726509094,
-0.24261756241321564,
0.3393220603466034,
-0.7517963647842407,
0.17711947858333588,
0.35844430327415466,
-0.15876471996307373,
-0.40008628368377686,
-0.7091675400733948,
-0.3679358661174774,
0.07891710102558136,
-0.6593661308288574,
-0.9222952127456665,
0.5050438046455383,
-0.07688337564468384,
0.12848323583602905,
0.26939743757247925,
0.08430428057909012,
0.44806528091430664,
-0.4812384247779846,
0.6309744119644165,
0.31646230816841125,
-0.9345273971557617,
0.5848484039306641,
-0.5774586796760559,
0.12083641439676285,
0.4790879189968109,
0.27520695328712463,
-0.46737945079803467,
-0.3713631331920624,
-0.5746573805809021,
-0.9310836791992188,
0.8410978317260742,
0.3316698670387268,
-0.08418978005647659,
0.2204151749610901,
0.1573319435119629,
-0.006971211172640324,
0.3712404668331146,
-0.9599899649620056,
-0.14342831075191498,
-0.11799155175685883,
0.023049894720315933,
-0.16709163784980774,
-0.12878331542015076,
0.05637218430638313,
-0.34141412377357483,
0.9642775058746338,
0.04027803614735603,
0.004941183608025312,
0.10191813111305237,
-0.33987072110176086,
0.05859867110848427,
0.39400404691696167,
0.5910248160362244,
0.4894069731235504,
-0.15672941505908966,
0.26800039410591125,
0.7067492604255676,
-0.2921546399593353,
0.338299959897995,
0.11708811670541763,
-0.279657781124115,
-0.29870298504829407,
0.5771966576576233,
0.6428408026695251,
0.12506812810897827,
-0.11326494812965393,
0.25205138325691223,
0.17344823479652405,
-0.39123833179473877,
-0.20589260756969452,
0.07759421318769455,
0.3294185698032379,
0.19447866082191467,
-0.009353057481348515,
0.23230184614658356,
0.04137364774942398,
-0.4976901412010193,
0.0317574180662632,
-0.02494930475950241,
-0.5603062510490417,
-0.3047204315662384,
1.1463736295700073,
0.4454863965511322,
-0.12772122025489807,
0.691619336605072,
-0.49645355343818665,
-0.3471696376800537,
0.28514593839645386,
0.23231126368045807,
0.9154379367828369,
-0.1443256288766861,
-0.18847937881946564,
0.43634915351867676,
0.6584088802337646,
-0.13042835891246796,
0.17332620918750763,
-0.18356801569461823,
-0.5315685868263245,
-0.6616750955581665,
-0.7209937572479248,
-0.43492674827575684,
0.21595676243305206,
-0.6572065353393555,
0.33359673619270325,
-0.08149775862693787,
-0.34114083647727966,
-0.04006689414381981,
0.25696513056755066,
-0.5805188417434692,
-0.33050036430358887,
-0.05318785086274147,
0.7845872640609741,
-0.5718070864677429,
1.252226710319519,
0.8089097142219543,
-0.4151533246040344,
-0.2948390543460846,
-0.14041054248809814,
0.13950757682323456,
-0.8519986867904663,
0.7860764265060425,
-0.11694595962762833,
-0.11817507445812225,
0.27316898107528687,
-0.3391176462173462,
-0.560482382774353,
1.4028234481811523,
0.8558418154716492,
-0.6635274291038513,
0.3380414843559265,
0.11445900797843933,
0.5318333506584167,
-0.06701362133026123,
-0.1031515970826149,
0.6044550538063049,
0.866794228553772,
-0.060840167105197906,
-0.7518370151519775,
-0.24496789276599884,
-0.10294351726770401,
0.14024008810520172,
0.24104617536067963,
-0.5758437514305115,
0.8287366032600403,
-0.289005309343338,
-0.01290976908057928,
-0.07298114895820618,
0.6371333003044128,
-0.06491914391517639,
0.15794870257377625,
0.27564361691474915,
0.7041203379631042,
0.8255060911178589,
-0.40447312593460083,
1.3023239374160767,
-0.5025569200515747,
0.19187942147254944,
0.8490952253341675,
-0.05713812634348869,
0.7923628687858582,
0.5092725157737732,
-0.35947930812835693,
0.42107683420181274,
0.5014697313308716,
0.17168322205543518,
0.3976289629936218,
0.1252046823501587,
-0.27276715636253357,
-0.4297686219215393,
-0.04426407068967819,
-0.27566778659820557,
0.4443958103656769,
0.30674710869789124,
-0.3927154242992401,
0.051856499165296555,
-0.052619993686676025,
0.23695987462997437,
0.2903551161289215,
-0.13216014206409454,
0.849398136138916,
0.4551961123943329,
-0.6453799605369568,
0.9355475902557373,
0.2271529734134674,
0.5339678525924683,
-0.5006160140037537,
0.09139630943536758,
-0.28335878252983093,
0.3406585156917572,
0.0674813836812973,
-0.5597075819969177,
0.3883926272392273,
0.15941540896892548,
-0.36342212557792664,
-0.7769359946250916,
0.5779138803482056,
-0.5810629725456238,
-0.48680245876312256,
0.5170900225639343,
0.8223556876182556,
0.37190520763397217,
-0.0061986856162548065,
-0.45547765493392944,
0.14317938685417175,
-0.02669498138129711,
-0.1452200710773468,
0.07107797265052795,
0.8951258659362793,
0.23219668865203857,
0.5343267321586609,
0.5849432945251465,
0.46049079298973083,
-0.07803986221551895,
-0.3050946593284607,
0.7405280470848083,
-0.5371139049530029,
-0.20975928008556366,
-1.1016509532928467,
0.33483943343162537,
-0.2831352949142456,
0.000006325919002847513,
0.6721259355545044,
0.6903552412986755,
0.7517212629318237,
-0.10123994946479797,
0.7617397308349609,
-0.1434527337551117,
0.17672553658485413,
-0.6789824962615967,
0.8144784569740295,
-0.7561337351799011,
0.3655124604701996,
-0.020758703351020813,
-1.1725713014602661,
-0.016187185421586037,
0.5717931985855103,
-0.1843363493680954,
-0.23529914021492004,
0.9555944800376892,
0.43224474787712097,
-0.3097655475139618,
-0.29880985617637634,
0.461075097322464,
0.47655439376831055,
0.19015423953533173,
0.7264788746833801,
0.7693567276000977,
-0.7054868936538696,
0.6938539147377014,
-0.2546750009059906,
-0.20692382752895355,
-0.14644193649291992,
-1.1384297609329224,
-0.7579555511474609,
-0.6053770184516907,
-0.20546990633010864,
-0.46597355604171753,
-0.005530775059014559,
0.95322185754776,
0.7317246198654175,
-0.6706222295761108,
-0.19225138425827026,
-0.3141680359840393,
0.19772444665431976,
-0.3489733338356018,
-0.14938707649707794,
0.011208218522369862,
-0.3812108635902405,
-1.193140983581543,
0.8914898037910461,
0.38823559880256653,
0.2099369913339615,
-0.33937200903892517,
-0.3790745735168457,
0.0805019810795784,
-0.09381528943777084,
0.7913503050804138,
0.13034428656101227,
-0.5336069464683533,
0.06399694830179214,
0.21104077994823456,
-0.22796490788459778,
0.09817436337471008,
0.6797072887420654,
-0.6797418594360352,
0.49641841650009155,
0.5658569931983948,
0.7557573318481445,
0.8251955509185791,
-0.22196808457374573,
0.9253144860267639,
-0.8012924194335938,
0.37286943197250366,
0.14088411629199982,
0.5167490243911743,
0.5841108560562134,
-0.007730740588158369,
0.8497938513755798,
0.533542811870575,
-0.6072465181350708,
-0.7946939468383789,
0.3383146822452545,
-0.9708772897720337,
-0.06685883551836014,
1.0912479162216187,
0.06630180031061172,
-0.32861605286598206,
0.04788012430071831,
0.008894732221961021,
0.34070032835006714,
-0.31826192140579224,
0.7315534949302673,
0.8264573812484741,
0.025976289063692093,
-0.03899550810456276,
-1.2215380668640137,
0.47644683718681335,
0.05996478348970413,
-0.8390026092529297,
0.1358281672000885,
0.3933683931827545,
0.11198379099369049,
0.2942434549331665,
0.6159517168998718,
-0.3242543637752533,
0.06924787908792496,
-0.12110348045825958,
0.047908633947372437,
-0.5069005489349365,
-0.19244924187660217,
-0.1125367283821106,
-0.31769859790802,
0.23972530663013458,
-0.11382275074720383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15157v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15157v1
|
FASTTRACK: Fast and Accurate Fact Tracing for LLMs
| 2024-04-22T00:07:55 | 2024-04-22T00:07:55 |
Si Chen, Feiyang Kang, Ning Yu, Ruoxi Jia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Fact tracing seeks to identify specific training examples that serve as the
knowledge source for a given query. Existing approaches to fact tracing rely on
assessing the similarity between each training sample and the query along a
certain dimension, such as lexical similarity, gradient, or embedding space.
However, these methods fall short of effectively distinguishing between samples
that are merely relevant and those that actually provide supportive evidence
for the information sought by the query. This limitation often results in
suboptimal effectiveness. Moreover, these approaches necessitate the
examination of the similarity of individual training points for each query,
imposing significant computational demands and creating a substantial barrier
for practical applications. This paper introduces FASTTRACK, a novel approach
that harnesses the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) to validate
supportive evidence for queries and at the same time clusters the training
database towards a reduced extent for LLMs to trace facts. Our experiments show
that FASTTRACK substantially outperforms existing methods in both accuracy and
efficiency, achieving more than 100\% improvement in F1 score over the
state-of-the-art methods while being X33 faster than \texttt{TracIn}.
|
[
-0.25760146975517273,
-0.7833974957466125,
0.8057769536972046,
-0.05996512994170189,
-0.3868520259857178,
0.47001031041145325,
-0.147401362657547,
-0.3279780447483063,
0.325102299451828,
0.40872398018836975,
-0.5513827204704285,
-0.8266379237174988,
-0.5979059934616089,
-0.23332814872264862,
-0.8319828510284424,
0.7967051863670349,
-0.043707042932510376,
-0.11587635427713394,
-0.32122108340263367,
-0.5427239537239075,
-0.1934327781200409,
-0.45159515738487244,
-0.6651945114135742,
0.0027498200070112944,
0.674892246723175,
0.5328077077865601,
0.4570969045162201,
0.9320085644721985,
0.4814465045928955,
0.29446351528167725,
0.11691531538963318,
0.21944226324558258,
-0.6090031266212463,
0.29999619722366333,
-0.13265235722064972,
-0.6895351409912109,
-0.2389250248670578,
-0.0327056348323822,
0.694252610206604,
0.30931785702705383,
-0.19627319276332855,
0.5377154350280762,
-0.20681044459342957,
0.6148572564125061,
-0.8465263247489929,
0.1023775041103363,
-0.6640506386756897,
-0.183568075299263,
-0.5930333137512207,
-0.34276413917541504,
-0.44847381114959717,
-0.8130879402160645,
0.13833032548427582,
-0.5436466336250305,
0.6111941337585449,
0.1630346179008484,
0.6862749457359314,
0.1343756765127182,
-0.574521005153656,
-0.5164992809295654,
-0.5019218325614929,
0.552419900894165,
-0.4608912765979767,
0.5359160304069519,
0.1871858537197113,
0.527199923992157,
0.006643675267696381,
-0.8504984378814697,
-0.48029759526252747,
-0.28517016768455505,
-0.24190063774585724,
-0.38881948590278625,
0.21013951301574707,
-0.26233407855033875,
0.5117624402046204,
0.1670708805322647,
-0.49297407269477844,
0.13933265209197998,
-0.03098115138709545,
-0.6701922416687012,
0.5186787247657776,
0.3388601541519165,
0.04163699224591255,
0.1353580206632614,
-0.6344150304794312,
-0.15137642621994019,
-0.9392373561859131,
0.08531035482883453,
0.0664229765534401,
0.3799560070037842,
0.0342053659260273,
0.3097842335700989,
-0.43455204367637634,
0.7008458375930786,
-0.24860189855098724,
-0.5298089385032654,
0.11238174885511398,
-0.5116748213768005,
0.12551000714302063,
0.12574969232082367,
0.6991350054740906,
0.2532472610473633,
0.05775408819317818,
-0.09533027559518814,
0.01247361395508051,
-0.03034156933426857,
-0.2425318956375122,
-1.029547929763794,
-0.02585476078093052,
-0.003940575756132603,
-0.1621529757976532,
-0.003967646975070238,
-0.1569659411907196,
-0.9818573594093323,
-0.7988930344581604,
-0.15331007540225983,
0.29457464814186096,
-0.3327123522758484,
-0.15259726345539093,
-0.10433198511600494,
0.11860333383083344,
0.5199140906333923,
0.6048005819320679,
-0.6511309146881104,
0.038869086652994156,
0.8747965097427368,
1.1464018821716309,
-0.16465260088443756,
-0.1560649573802948,
-1.0325989723205566,
0.0041911667212843895,
-0.24140867590904236,
0.9651857614517212,
-0.36799177527427673,
0.0822269394993782,
-0.013477667234838009,
-0.08442013710737228,
-0.0069043817929923534,
-0.39910319447517395,
0.5596137642860413,
-0.6432295441627502,
-0.21135905385017395,
-0.47643882036209106,
-0.784018874168396,
-0.29377010464668274,
0.40154510736465454,
-0.8454380631446838,
0.9464888572692871,
-0.004722427111119032,
-0.7782140970230103,
0.3886917233467102,
-0.31620508432388306,
-0.5879813432693481,
-0.07218657433986664,
-0.15822327136993408,
-0.3796349763870239,
0.021274374797940254,
0.10572414845228195,
0.5568068623542786,
-0.45482486486434937,
0.17473317682743073,
-0.5113979578018188,
-0.505348265171051,
0.252865731716156,
0.06280948966741562,
0.835584819316864,
0.035429149866104126,
-0.5776442885398865,
0.16468824446201324,
-1.1684000492095947,
-0.00862057227641344,
0.08849559724330902,
-0.4278492331504822,
-0.7835627794265747,
0.003676762105897069,
-0.3279067277908325,
0.2848464846611023,
-0.14804652333259583,
-0.6553654074668884,
0.07470899075269699,
-0.06098293140530586,
0.26927292346954346,
0.7131565809249878,
-0.22484314441680908,
0.19147749245166779,
0.005747206974774599,
0.4952290654182434,
-0.28770124912261963,
-0.07279631495475769,
-0.2035331279039383,
-0.30343300104141235,
-0.9167138338088989,
-0.6665253639221191,
0.6758723258972168,
0.4582068920135498,
-0.7187675833702087,
0.1327638477087021,
-0.49235233664512634,
-0.5918190479278564,
-0.5437197685241699,
0.07282764464616776,
0.21826259791851044,
0.702675998210907,
0.1669149249792099,
-0.2909649610519409,
-0.5507533550262451,
-0.668198823928833,
-0.6489855051040649,
-0.05086267739534378,
-0.03929302096366882,
-0.11339602619409561,
0.4842672348022461,
0.05328742042183876,
0.8592170476913452,
-0.5150388479232788,
-0.25185734033584595,
0.003955396357923746,
0.13102754950523376,
-0.19448459148406982,
0.16802369058132172,
0.5514898300170898,
-0.3438079357147217,
-0.5291650295257568,
-0.28275924921035767,
-0.5367103219032288,
0.17772193253040314,
-0.07086559385061264,
-0.33523645997047424,
0.1547044962644577,
0.6471688747406006,
-0.7882528305053711,
0.3583437204360962,
0.340915322303772,
-0.6674396395683289,
0.23717190325260162,
0.20445619523525238,
0.2566172182559967,
-0.6249833703041077,
0.2810516357421875,
-0.05071467533707619,
-0.5636669993400574,
-0.37793904542922974,
0.14002028107643127,
0.18676257133483887,
0.07203158736228943,
-0.5170230269432068,
0.6353802680969238,
-0.2917822003364563,
-0.1362186074256897,
-0.08809018135070801,
0.25771933794021606,
-0.009709076024591923,
0.3083033561706543,
-0.07366296648979187,
0.7902449369430542,
0.519804060459137,
-0.4713427722454071,
0.594188392162323,
0.1664111614227295,
-0.9173545837402344,
0.4023705720901489,
-0.13148099184036255,
0.3024322986602783,
0.05148692801594734,
0.4544549584388733,
-1.1470295190811157,
0.12685313820838928,
-0.1342702955007553,
-0.218465194106102,
0.06115562841296196,
-0.15769989788532257,
-0.6336077451705933,
-0.08354765921831131,
-0.5384829640388489,
0.1563671976327896,
0.4889547824859619,
-0.6618418097496033,
0.5657510161399841,
0.3562309741973877,
-0.028513865545392036,
-0.6835562586784363,
-0.4486108422279358,
-0.1782875955104828,
-0.26781272888183594,
-0.5329853296279907,
-0.01909448206424713,
0.18910102546215057,
-0.2153005301952362,
-0.2504618167877197,
-0.3371424674987793,
-0.18834719061851501,
0.35926690697669983,
-0.03632935509085655,
0.06469523906707764,
-0.3903271555900574,
0.0934213250875473,
-0.43418481945991516,
-0.1434796005487442,
0.22056332230567932,
0.060707442462444305,
0.25583282113075256,
0.16459867358207703,
-0.31581735610961914,
-0.2478901445865631,
0.35991793870925903,
0.9001696705818176,
-0.4233287274837494,
0.810509979724884,
0.7748995423316956,
-0.17422306537628174,
-0.5359311103820801,
-0.8000883460044861,
-0.46329522132873535,
-0.45096009969711304,
0.3042919933795929,
-0.2332341969013214,
-1.1023813486099243,
0.6045975089073181,
-0.17961686849594116,
0.13609154522418976,
0.3227051794528961,
0.5425117611885071,
0.0080358125269413,
0.8642750978469849,
0.6233647465705872,
0.03581511229276657,
0.4318560063838959,
-0.17575882375240326,
0.26764270663261414,
-0.3654974400997162,
-0.40280258655548096,
-0.7649737000465393,
-0.20720624923706055,
-0.5574766993522644,
-0.5859271883964539,
0.18378110229969025,
-0.37036433815956116,
-0.09079694747924805,
0.006121838930994272,
-0.0019572267774492502,
0.531289279460907,
0.6803915500640869,
0.017120927572250366,
0.5310989618301392,
0.14762140810489655,
-0.22039085626602173,
-0.01631217636168003,
-0.831042468547821,
-0.14099295437335968,
1.2129096984863281,
0.2318839132785797,
0.716170072555542,
-0.07442375272512436,
0.5174365639686584,
0.2408074140548706,
0.5907898545265198,
-0.7994584441184998,
0.8367140293121338,
-0.08992519229650497,
-0.9148516058921814,
-0.21438263356685638,
-0.47847431898117065,
-0.3825916647911072,
0.4471283555030823,
-0.3510991036891937,
-0.32004842162132263,
0.027816032990813255,
0.2776644825935364,
-0.5405641198158264,
0.41558709740638733,
-0.6952047348022461,
0.7749761343002319,
-0.2595166862010956,
-0.7411031126976013,
-0.2756718397140503,
-0.6506748795509338,
0.7202803492546082,
-0.1654297560453415,
0.288387656211853,
-0.4962514340877533,
-0.010373793542385101,
1.044291615486145,
-0.5828465223312378,
0.7794073224067688,
-0.36848998069763184,
-0.02561437524855137,
0.6178135871887207,
0.24874790012836456,
0.761766791343689,
-0.06875614076852798,
0.05362505465745926,
0.048380058258771896,
-0.0010023739887401462,
-0.2425643801689148,
-0.7900317311286926,
0.8553388118743896,
-0.25811105966567993,
-0.4918283522129059,
-0.5917936563491821,
-0.43003159761428833,
-0.4363097846508026,
0.13772930204868317,
-0.14872008562088013,
0.44583502411842346,
-0.07928138226270676,
0.2683970332145691,
0.7958266735076904,
0.03406741842627525,
0.25298893451690674,
1.0675064325332642,
-0.004963629879057407,
-0.053897105157375336,
0.8887224197387695,
0.1557997167110443,
-0.06456207484006882,
0.4742755591869354,
0.12544895708560944,
-0.7037143707275391,
-0.6655838489532471,
-0.2653825283050537,
0.48245760798454285,
-0.9085978865623474,
-0.4376279413700104,
-0.5028989315032959,
0.1833617389202118,
-0.1545683592557907,
0.19693170487880707,
-0.6075024604797363,
-0.6137606501579285,
0.18138833343982697,
-0.30268019437789917,
0.6288712620735168,
0.42388781905174255,
0.18890568614006042,
0.22529545426368713,
-0.8291873931884766,
0.22107842564582825,
0.4959488809108734,
0.6616827845573425,
-0.04028976708650589,
-0.3362976610660553,
-0.5616741180419922,
-0.32491984963417053,
-0.15433792769908905,
-0.6610795855522156,
-0.032267652451992035,
0.07440034300088882,
0.5213338732719421,
0.26288753747940063,
0.21603785455226898,
0.8272103071212769,
-0.5432755947113037,
0.5975430607795715,
0.06753529608249664,
-1.069936990737915,
0.545022189617157,
0.047955263406038284,
0.07341116666793823,
0.8402966260910034,
0.5776865482330322,
-0.18483947217464447,
-0.39049845933914185,
-0.4613197147846222,
-0.7726984620094299,
0.5479089617729187,
-0.010444100946187973,
-0.6021700501441956,
0.322820246219635,
0.4617997705936432,
0.09196531027555466,
0.13187947869300842,
-0.2807566821575165,
-0.24722492694854736,
0.05669233947992325,
-0.33200299739837646,
-0.30404841899871826,
-0.3468799889087677,
-0.2671855092048645,
-0.3193858861923218,
0.5299066305160522,
-0.37209588289260864,
0.18306095898151398,
0.08008263260126114,
-0.3708781599998474,
0.1481577455997467,
0.1822693943977356,
0.7463003396987915,
0.9356685876846313,
-0.23943862318992615,
0.5125840306282043,
0.14732962846755981,
-0.4567628800868988,
0.39787229895591736,
0.1043260395526886,
-0.1710902601480484,
0.335743248462677,
0.6813923716545105,
0.585102915763855,
0.13283638656139374,
-0.8007547855377197,
0.6062427163124084,
-0.0908847376704216,
-0.06659472733736038,
0.18661589920520782,
0.0776483416557312,
0.255050390958786,
0.2002570778131485,
0.13205182552337646,
-0.14600959420204163,
0.1937353014945984,
-0.43792638182640076,
0.3951108157634735,
0.4241955876350403,
-0.14568467438220978,
-0.4072451889514923,
0.3895985782146454,
0.4946857690811157,
-0.023300103843212128,
0.6156659126281738,
0.09224273264408112,
-0.43842214345932007,
0.5978702306747437,
0.23758117854595184,
0.733847975730896,
-0.36598727107048035,
0.07836532592773438,
0.5307973027229309,
0.2689224183559418,
-0.1918262392282486,
0.16004715859889984,
-0.14487311244010925,
-0.40173715353012085,
-0.7648192048072815,
-0.5913591980934143,
-0.44626230001449585,
0.10048827528953552,
-0.5985890626907349,
0.20744775235652924,
-0.5270364880561829,
-0.020427586510777473,
0.02155344933271408,
0.08625581115484238,
-0.8500528335571289,
0.12227532267570496,
0.2129928469657898,
1.2338589429855347,
-0.9704475998878479,
1.1768693923950195,
0.5387895703315735,
0.06362602859735489,
-0.8472901582717896,
-0.17531326413154602,
0.2968156933784485,
-0.989641010761261,
0.6166684031486511,
0.12643639743328094,
-0.3862955868244171,
-0.09641769528388977,
-0.44441893696784973,
-0.9222246408462524,
1.2526507377624512,
0.7084087133407593,
-0.7814784049987793,
-0.004146188963204622,
0.08033497631549835,
0.30090415477752686,
-0.4037911891937256,
0.3272644579410553,
0.9658929109573364,
0.3598029613494873,
0.1595493108034134,
-0.6082298755645752,
0.5482100248336792,
0.2235644906759262,
-0.3227817416191101,
0.17126522958278656,
-0.7353858351707458,
0.7105581760406494,
-0.3023618459701538,
-0.334286630153656,
-0.22803163528442383,
0.6823940277099609,
0.2710477113723755,
0.39167988300323486,
0.6830623745918274,
0.4226427376270294,
0.9251777529716492,
-0.13928456604480743,
0.8861157894134521,
-0.15522600710391998,
0.49387282133102417,
1.1308817863464355,
-0.36023107171058655,
0.796166181564331,
0.4681711494922638,
-0.020412743091583252,
0.6440134644508362,
0.42678335309028625,
0.2729419767856598,
0.5903198719024658,
0.1763637512922287,
-0.08729776740074158,
-0.42039623856544495,
0.03758636489510536,
-0.19498418271541595,
0.4742608666419983,
0.3854246735572815,
-0.13596850633621216,
-0.5245324969291687,
-0.18739598989486694,
0.18106049299240112,
-0.14337794482707977,
-0.22787562012672424,
0.5253861546516418,
-0.090131975710392,
-0.7063536047935486,
0.8303973078727722,
-0.1187540590763092,
0.5105552673339844,
-0.9310782551765442,
-0.13524718582630157,
-0.55555659532547,
0.373404860496521,
-0.1532030701637268,
-0.5683302283287048,
0.29232263565063477,
0.12070879340171814,
0.17576386034488678,
-0.20095199346542358,
0.6061332821846008,
-0.41745108366012573,
-0.21024172008037567,
0.1775805652141571,
0.5311216711997986,
-0.14184293150901794,
-0.015935203060507774,
-0.6003486514091492,
0.36537349224090576,
0.05491776764392853,
-0.2756146192550659,
0.3086877167224884,
0.43276867270469666,
-0.12240631878376007,
0.8178149461746216,
0.5048238635063171,
-0.017725476995110512,
0.3404725193977356,
-0.16180121898651123,
0.6951011419296265,
-0.9543845057487488,
-0.7472441792488098,
-1.010563611984253,
0.4774533808231354,
-0.06548117846250534,
-0.18048745393753052,
1.0486974716186523,
0.6837323307991028,
0.6755221486091614,
0.0003900738665834069,
0.6251122951507568,
0.04839978367090225,
0.9632799625396729,
-0.760184645652771,
0.6273289322853088,
-0.3678344786167145,
0.2815360128879547,
0.14417758584022522,
-0.656138002872467,
-0.3926929831504822,
0.45012059807777405,
0.005114934407174587,
-0.39410510659217834,
1.1278948783874512,
0.7954060435295105,
-0.1814095377922058,
0.03637465089559555,
0.04328950121998787,
0.38133805990219116,
0.45166444778442383,
0.49921536445617676,
1.09309983253479,
-0.2536908984184265,
0.6899480223655701,
-0.21277515590190887,
-0.250590056180954,
-0.5420926809310913,
-1.0072492361068726,
-0.9164279103279114,
-0.3991713225841522,
-0.628717839717865,
-0.4029654860496521,
0.04033992812037468,
0.5941218137741089,
0.9086788892745972,
-0.8770900964736938,
-0.24627062678337097,
0.16492635011672974,
0.442417711019516,
-0.19479794800281525,
-0.18891678750514984,
0.6087515950202942,
-0.12183962762355804,
-0.24911238253116608,
0.369256854057312,
-0.047234732657670975,
-0.04156573861837387,
-0.3632310926914215,
0.2495482712984085,
-0.38075870275497437,
0.10191819816827774,
0.7185280323028564,
0.35150226950645447,
-0.5207703709602356,
-0.5006191730499268,
-0.04034858196973801,
-0.17252303659915924,
0.031520769000053406,
1.4954299926757812,
-1.0172855854034424,
0.26919615268707275,
0.7563831806182861,
0.7147397994995117,
0.837195098400116,
-0.14629200100898743,
0.2443346083164215,
-0.7912678122520447,
0.30237501859664917,
0.12089276313781738,
0.17363746464252472,
0.5175939798355103,
-0.15086162090301514,
0.4104052186012268,
0.49882251024246216,
-0.2288079559803009,
-0.9490150213241577,
0.1363046020269394,
-0.9024597406387329,
-0.0755266398191452,
0.9914999008178711,
-0.3959403932094574,
-0.3477969169616699,
0.011125799268484116,
0.18773986399173737,
0.10923004150390625,
-0.20741327106952667,
0.6112107038497925,
0.624931275844574,
-0.08075203001499176,
0.008081765845417976,
-0.6661500930786133,
0.7316935658454895,
0.23035302758216858,
-0.7806066870689392,
0.3383679687976837,
0.4183975160121918,
0.8272144794464111,
0.06111873686313629,
0.835559070110321,
0.16658435761928558,
0.130251944065094,
-0.0715518593788147,
-0.13361647725105286,
-0.10254072397947311,
-0.3903898596763611,
-0.17657308280467987,
0.6219653487205505,
0.07003278285264969,
-0.4340291917324066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13793v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13793v1
|
Lightweight Connective Detection Using Gradient Boosting
| 2024-04-21T23:14:02 | 2024-04-21T23:14:02 |
Mustafa Erolcan Er, Murathan Kurfalı, Deniz Zeyrek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
In this work, we introduce a lightweight discourse connective detection
system. Employing gradient boosting trained on straightforward, low-complexity
features, this proposed approach sidesteps the computational demands of the
current approaches that rely on deep neural networks. Considering its
simplicity, our approach achieves competitive results while offering
significant gains in terms of time even on CPU. Furthermore, the stable
performance across two unrelated languages suggests the robustness of our
system in the multilingual scenario. The model is designed to support the
annotation of discourse relations, particularly in scenarios with limited
resources, while minimizing performance loss.
|
[
-0.39640012383461,
-0.630897045135498,
0.21140728890895844,
0.30135077238082886,
-0.4390760660171509,
0.06529809534549713,
-0.2747977375984192,
-0.6936957836151123,
0.5926418900489807,
0.03070683218538761,
-0.406985878944397,
-0.051864542067050934,
-0.40146833658218384,
-0.09122679382562637,
-0.12387830764055252,
1.090553879737854,
0.354232519865036,
0.14330758154392242,
-0.07962861657142639,
-0.6635650992393494,
-0.32496213912963867,
-0.06085371971130371,
-0.9700958132743835,
-0.5644304752349854,
0.589464008808136,
0.46313056349754333,
0.5667185187339783,
0.605305016040802,
0.35374370217323303,
0.3445250988006592,
-0.5054519772529602,
0.2071872055530548,
-0.45332905650138855,
0.3042946755886078,
0.16428877413272858,
-0.44787877798080444,
-0.4339825510978699,
-0.2869468033313751,
0.5536964535713196,
0.7083424925804138,
0.2729036509990692,
0.33512434363365173,
0.30223068594932556,
0.6929705739021301,
-0.9494979977607727,
0.04963012784719467,
-0.6827401518821716,
0.041590817272663116,
-0.4268554151058197,
-0.1168706864118576,
-0.3233843743801117,
-0.19194521009922028,
-0.12497103959321976,
-0.32182857394218445,
0.06515975296497345,
0.06142554432153702,
0.654860258102417,
0.2322574108839035,
-0.3918149769306183,
0.07849453389644623,
-0.3937295973300934,
0.507519543170929,
-0.5916684865951538,
0.10121942311525345,
-0.00015917533892206848,
0.24038970470428467,
0.2250150591135025,
-0.7574798464775085,
-0.4466014504432678,
-0.040433119982481,
-0.37734439969062805,
0.05051397532224655,
-0.06957440078258514,
0.13554030656814575,
0.3363100588321686,
0.5130504369735718,
-0.3037613034248352,
0.2605816125869751,
-0.10009416192770004,
-0.4610987901687622,
0.11648248881101608,
0.07220859825611115,
0.34553515911102295,
-0.4756297469139099,
-0.45998525619506836,
0.4593546390533447,
-0.7741717100143433,
0.4312851130962372,
0.31168749928474426,
0.6110192537307739,
-0.17047972977161407,
0.3162733316421509,
-0.07833077013492584,
0.4908047616481781,
0.13647675514221191,
-0.29682761430740356,
0.18404152989387512,
-0.3462824821472168,
-0.067183718085289,
0.07288150489330292,
1.0115495920181274,
0.20777899026870728,
0.11209803819656372,
0.03627442196011543,
-0.26490288972854614,
0.04327559471130371,
-0.4498721659183502,
-1.0447369813919067,
-0.33212143182754517,
-0.21402235329151154,
-0.7622625827789307,
-0.3136746883392334,
-0.4714832305908203,
-0.6427549123764038,
-0.727873682975769,
-0.13932572305202484,
-0.15526247024536133,
-0.5025832653045654,
-0.34654077887535095,
-0.1426616907119751,
-0.13250289857387543,
0.2256287932395935,
0.32050666213035583,
-0.9592931270599365,
0.5468122363090515,
0.5453639626502991,
1.187656283378601,
-0.13787199556827545,
0.17336469888687134,
-1.084654450416565,
-0.1174682155251503,
-0.10083421319723129,
0.8489643335342407,
-0.28608644008636475,
-0.07541274279356003,
0.09919974207878113,
0.16451925039291382,
0.030983490869402885,
-0.3029139041900635,
1.0791767835617065,
-0.25381243228912354,
0.05167430639266968,
-0.2629639208316803,
-0.4767140746116638,
0.05874897167086601,
0.2447151243686676,
-0.704218864440918,
1.2224923372268677,
-0.09487899392843246,
-1.4677823781967163,
0.32157716155052185,
-0.29197004437446594,
-0.6762855052947998,
0.5478633642196655,
-0.16224469244480133,
-0.44634273648262024,
-0.23132482171058655,
0.2356330156326294,
0.4609651565551758,
-0.3329029083251953,
0.14551332592964172,
-0.4887068569660187,
-0.7709341049194336,
-0.19092877209186554,
-0.2622784972190857,
1.0148911476135254,
-0.012641658075153828,
-0.3721928894519806,
0.062150876969099045,
-0.955495297908783,
-0.21356017887592316,
-0.09216096252202988,
-0.42583879828453064,
-0.5309146642684937,
-0.05013136565685272,
0.3714616000652313,
0.2718994617462158,
0.25848984718322754,
-0.8272744417190552,
-0.07718661427497864,
-0.43768829107284546,
0.3694768249988556,
0.6450703740119934,
-0.3227485120296478,
0.5621576309204102,
-0.1721225380897522,
0.6700217127799988,
0.1662941426038742,
-0.47858983278274536,
-0.4926571547985077,
-0.6967307329177856,
-1.1441394090652466,
-0.599746584892273,
0.45896071195602417,
0.9275627136230469,
-1.2770133018493652,
0.4392947852611542,
-0.29779741168022156,
-0.28119251132011414,
-0.46663984656333923,
0.25704696774482727,
0.5229014754295349,
0.9198658466339111,
0.24931155145168304,
-0.020030692219734192,
-0.6308749914169312,
-1.0680196285247803,
-0.3707145154476166,
-0.3038145899772644,
-0.184067964553833,
0.5427196025848389,
0.33410683274269104,
0.1583859771490097,
0.5541155934333801,
-0.42526930570602417,
-0.35202986001968384,
-0.10949421674013138,
0.29644739627838135,
0.08686959743499756,
0.658991813659668,
0.8529940843582153,
-0.4234325587749481,
-0.5536535382270813,
0.26522955298423767,
-0.7256360054016113,
-0.17751935124397278,
0.030524514615535736,
0.250740647315979,
-0.041222766041755676,
0.8092632293701172,
-0.3816371560096741,
0.13874836266040802,
0.29354578256607056,
-0.10016357898712158,
0.34416717290878296,
-0.04137140512466431,
-0.044479578733444214,
-0.9819908738136292,
0.36959394812583923,
0.5087388753890991,
-0.8467063903808594,
-0.551049530506134,
-0.34543663263320923,
0.11015738546848297,
-0.2155250608921051,
-0.6239487528800964,
0.3816293179988861,
-0.45378631353378296,
0.13968625664710999,
-0.11435359716415405,
0.19955632090568542,
0.045276496559381485,
0.6009935736656189,
-0.010408321395516396,
0.9216036796569824,
0.503746509552002,
-0.25815337896347046,
0.14960768818855286,
0.0695832371711731,
-0.2342546284198761,
0.9865483641624451,
-0.7035239934921265,
-0.02739834599196911,
-0.3061451017856598,
0.3138519823551178,
-1.3199855089187622,
0.037674762308597565,
0.29892003536224365,
-0.30538174510002136,
0.3501001000404358,
-0.5315355062484741,
-0.16163185238838196,
-0.3336087167263031,
-0.8039716482162476,
0.6842870712280273,
0.38768842816352844,
-0.7361506819725037,
0.4772074222564697,
0.5151883959770203,
-0.35230553150177,
-0.7598057389259338,
-0.7722834348678589,
0.04691512510180473,
-0.31392526626586914,
-0.7876973152160645,
0.3010895252227783,
0.2506326138973236,
0.11919547617435455,
-0.3777830898761749,
0.21047551929950714,
-0.38733968138694763,
0.184259831905365,
0.2772039473056793,
0.298936665058136,
-0.5247238278388977,
0.19237548112869263,
0.06949781626462936,
-0.11006126552820206,
-0.05044391006231308,
-0.15165144205093384,
0.10809310525655746,
-0.2733868360519409,
0.09967415034770966,
-0.7029632329940796,
0.3806585669517517,
0.4515884518623352,
-0.007457237225025892,
0.5365798473358154,
0.9658172726631165,
-0.44553142786026,
-0.2669607698917389,
-0.3453896939754486,
-0.2076331079006195,
-0.5726580619812012,
-0.02171984128654003,
-0.3085511028766632,
-1.25226628780365,
0.8324479460716248,
-0.4481068551540375,
-0.4714262783527374,
0.30447736382484436,
0.3430567681789398,
-0.1477884203195572,
0.8233601450920105,
0.6187520027160645,
-0.29984796047210693,
0.6267666220664978,
0.10466871410608292,
0.2159387469291687,
-1.1056219339370728,
0.03551672399044037,
-0.7610769867897034,
-0.5216795802116394,
-0.734557032585144,
-0.29914411902427673,
0.15342257916927338,
0.06299499422311783,
-0.0424310602247715,
0.20075921714305878,
-0.7022467255592346,
0.6116085052490234,
0.24279557168483734,
0.12398558109998703,
0.2322555035352707,
-0.27762511372566223,
-0.36171281337738037,
-0.5320088863372803,
-0.7743036150932312,
-0.37784403562545776,
0.7040346264839172,
0.3879343271255493,
0.663112223148346,
-0.07484706491231918,
0.2188742458820343,
0.25554367899894714,
0.49192267656326294,
-1.0294277667999268,
0.6665433049201965,
-0.20696084201335907,
-0.17187857627868652,
0.1253679394721985,
-0.4870988726615906,
-0.87267005443573,
0.4523123800754547,
-0.5849135518074036,
-0.949711263179779,
0.4138500690460205,
0.2615174949169159,
-0.30107685923576355,
0.5833750367164612,
-0.4593126177787781,
0.6537055373191833,
0.2529606819152832,
-0.6867274045944214,
0.27947768568992615,
-0.8414994478225708,
0.9187387228012085,
0.5125338435173035,
0.002946792170405388,
-0.1252761334180832,
-0.09521689265966415,
0.8041131496429443,
-0.2138490527868271,
0.978013813495636,
-0.1589740663766861,
-0.03292433172464371,
0.2792471945285797,
0.1294352114200592,
0.2762456238269806,
0.22761131823062897,
-0.05595908313989639,
-0.15936411917209625,
-0.4031815826892853,
-0.3786231279373169,
-0.3758549988269806,
0.8915196657180786,
-0.20875702798366547,
-0.2839498221874237,
-0.2531195878982544,
-0.35908177495002747,
-0.10672366619110107,
0.19142380356788635,
0.09414374083280563,
0.3227367401123047,
-0.5527543425559998,
0.21887542307376862,
0.5728050470352173,
0.27573254704475403,
0.9360490441322327,
0.16822363436222076,
-0.1558036506175995,
-0.48100611567497253,
1.1137264966964722,
-0.03462323173880577,
-0.1799076795578003,
0.12362835556268692,
0.09257330000400543,
-0.2473558634519577,
-0.4331646263599396,
-0.7439982891082764,
0.2784998416900635,
-0.8147304654121399,
-0.3250824213027954,
-0.5934755802154541,
0.06604223698377609,
-0.04802213981747627,
-0.13733994960784912,
-0.4483663737773895,
-0.8483738303184509,
-0.48252829909324646,
0.03148888424038887,
0.0063056424260139465,
0.43634435534477234,
0.14762632548809052,
0.342671662569046,
-0.616884708404541,
0.3009073734283447,
0.5157751441001892,
0.23009830713272095,
0.027690473943948746,
-0.2439676970243454,
-0.19571080803871155,
-0.3948540687561035,
-0.444691002368927,
-0.5002177953720093,
0.006262109614908695,
0.42105498909950256,
0.09770958125591278,
0.7926826477050781,
0.0392511710524559,
0.43544715642929077,
-0.49043214321136475,
0.844590425491333,
0.46550023555755615,
-1.2092515230178833,
0.44094663858413696,
-0.670836865901947,
0.30570828914642334,
0.8938543796539307,
0.27827686071395874,
-0.38577336072921753,
-0.09284910559654236,
-0.22583691775798798,
-0.6227905750274658,
0.48603546619415283,
0.029467755928635597,
-0.0015039780410006642,
0.07654662430286407,
0.37811651825904846,
-0.14940716326236725,
0.1950807273387909,
-0.9384531378746033,
-0.39529091119766235,
0.07136482000350952,
-0.03534034267067909,
0.38438156247138977,
-0.23416787385940552,
-0.24491415917873383,
-0.5905987024307251,
0.4887330234050751,
-0.763702392578125,
0.0034138441551476717,
-0.015719346702098846,
-0.08587821573019028,
-0.18210935592651367,
0.12700338661670685,
0.6068504452705383,
0.2757394015789032,
0.004066249821335077,
0.3369092345237732,
0.25787344574928284,
-0.2599198520183563,
0.39327698945999146,
0.20967228710651398,
-0.32521218061447144,
0.2842443585395813,
0.49259117245674133,
0.7561032176017761,
0.405868262052536,
-0.3761531710624695,
0.9600584506988525,
-0.27242451906204224,
0.034591127187013626,
0.23879490792751312,
-0.24564684927463531,
0.41127386689186096,
-0.12773197889328003,
0.15919440984725952,
0.5664042830467224,
0.3593752980232239,
-0.22727268934249878,
0.22181425988674164,
0.7374135255813599,
-0.6171175837516785,
-0.4133824110031128,
0.6418167948722839,
0.7037322521209717,
-0.42448607087135315,
0.10958816111087799,
-0.4698828458786011,
-0.694953441619873,
0.4447114169597626,
0.5471394062042236,
0.6957083940505981,
-0.2606291174888611,
0.32390719652175903,
0.3148650527000427,
0.21651847660541534,
0.09579337388277054,
0.31656160950660706,
-0.24285659193992615,
-0.6629648208618164,
-0.5632362365722656,
-0.23267191648483276,
-0.274349570274353,
0.06548257172107697,
-0.5640860199928284,
0.4067176878452301,
-0.6260681748390198,
-0.20384357869625092,
0.28905341029167175,
-0.19624018669128418,
-0.3552188277244568,
-0.01644386351108551,
0.28934812545776367,
0.7934271693229675,
-1.0794450044631958,
0.7572615742683411,
0.5429702401161194,
0.009431744925677776,
-0.39268723130226135,
-0.17035414278507233,
0.17355623841285706,
-0.48139986395835876,
0.8539091348648071,
0.5573077201843262,
-0.7275152802467346,
-0.2999812662601471,
-0.17899632453918457,
-0.2816803753376007,
1.01885986328125,
0.938000500202179,
-0.32068324089050293,
0.12187110632658005,
-0.2843419909477234,
0.5764540433883667,
-0.5445728898048401,
0.44984665513038635,
0.5078080892562866,
0.3090376555919647,
0.08604701608419418,
-0.824301540851593,
0.301772803068161,
-0.4868215322494507,
0.020605100318789482,
0.30553966760635376,
-0.8342469334602356,
1.1446142196655273,
0.267196387052536,
-0.4846177101135254,
0.04422491416335106,
0.7422192692756653,
-0.10075760632753372,
0.29502248764038086,
0.6238948702812195,
0.7276515364646912,
1.018134593963623,
-0.11793027073144913,
0.7796048521995544,
-0.424420028924942,
0.32328009605407715,
1.045540690422058,
-0.3122832477092743,
0.6682115197181702,
0.47875845432281494,
-0.00649148877710104,
0.6806584000587463,
0.3938548266887665,
0.3625161349773407,
0.11826387047767639,
0.23709723353385925,
-0.7443051338195801,
-0.3545408844947815,
-0.7618252635002136,
-0.3332749605178833,
0.3983086049556732,
0.34719640016555786,
-0.18166109919548035,
-0.1945958286523819,
-0.12362178415060043,
0.16404856741428375,
0.16713692247867584,
-0.44418394565582275,
0.6862393617630005,
0.21992892026901245,
-0.6124407052993774,
0.7422798871994019,
-0.2477240264415741,
1.159868836402893,
-0.2494259625673294,
-0.023393690586090088,
-0.0007650394691154361,
0.2550605535507202,
-0.3577703833580017,
-0.4510672390460968,
0.10016506910324097,
-0.293996125459671,
0.10584741085767746,
0.040632497519254684,
1.536882996559143,
-0.479911744594574,
-0.47764748334884644,
0.6705990433692932,
0.904933512210846,
-0.3182857632637024,
0.49238958954811096,
-0.6807795166969299,
-0.039403460919857025,
-0.32925519347190857,
-0.11199984699487686,
0.34162822365760803,
0.5526204705238342,
0.232692152261734,
0.7575313448905945,
0.5399287343025208,
0.06361732631921768,
-0.19599822163581848,
-0.07971635460853577,
1.2275002002716064,
-0.3430812656879425,
-0.8111981153488159,
-0.8740737438201904,
0.5528774857521057,
-0.5427290201187134,
-0.3940759301185608,
0.752644419670105,
0.5116959810256958,
0.16902600228786469,
0.18708524107933044,
0.5367321968078613,
0.2860007584095001,
0.33939579129219055,
-0.366338849067688,
0.6379861235618591,
-0.34349966049194336,
0.2943859100341797,
-0.37005871534347534,
-0.6598953008651733,
-0.403095543384552,
0.4907953441143036,
0.1655072718858719,
-0.2010425627231598,
0.8217001557350159,
0.5924543142318726,
-0.3296808898448944,
0.19713635742664337,
0.1818678379058838,
-0.3294590413570404,
0.11686484515666962,
0.542578399181366,
0.7010595202445984,
-0.3812466859817505,
0.471211701631546,
0.001326110796071589,
-0.25647202134132385,
-0.16589105129241943,
-1.2158148288726807,
-1.3340486288070679,
-0.16883739829063416,
-0.367705762386322,
-0.43798828125,
-0.3264096677303314,
0.6055105328559875,
0.9299710392951965,
-0.730279266834259,
-0.1679713875055313,
-0.08130516856908798,
0.37761563062667847,
-0.025402486324310303,
-0.2558010220527649,
0.26702582836151123,
-0.4573519229888916,
-0.39674481749534607,
0.5506911873817444,
0.47836655378341675,
-0.12925419211387634,
-0.3679206669330597,
0.14318177103996277,
-0.551275908946991,
-0.03344158083200455,
0.5062217712402344,
0.4247054159641266,
-0.24539804458618164,
-0.37587428092956543,
-0.42086076736450195,
-0.14056701958179474,
0.46071967482566833,
1.2916637659072876,
-0.9626798033714294,
0.30368131399154663,
0.7003066539764404,
0.9616618156433105,
0.5947858095169067,
-0.00681237131357193,
0.3255261480808258,
-1.1493163108825684,
0.91269850730896,
0.3774537742137909,
0.8289995789527893,
0.713111400604248,
-0.4110991358757019,
0.3397409915924072,
0.4562678337097168,
-0.656151294708252,
-0.6978344917297363,
0.39061275124549866,
-1.015928864479065,
-0.047942690551280975,
0.5645846128463745,
-0.592685878276825,
-0.21579283475875854,
-0.38696613907814026,
-0.3763672113418579,
-0.001561674871481955,
-0.4834066927433014,
0.3427108824253082,
0.4938095211982727,
-0.18423496186733246,
-0.42519739270210266,
-0.1720537543296814,
0.8209628462791443,
0.5398150086402893,
-0.7953424453735352,
-0.14079461991786957,
0.35963237285614014,
0.030501393601298332,
0.5584229230880737,
0.95551997423172,
0.4858720600605011,
0.3742930591106415,
-0.01987854205071926,
-0.348227858543396,
0.1621999889612198,
-0.07568152248859406,
-0.6279098391532898,
0.632578432559967,
-0.040288295596838,
-0.20632484555244446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13792v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13792v1
|
Counterfactual Reasoning Using Predicted Latent Personality Dimensions for Optimizing Persuasion Outcome
| 2024-04-21T23:03:47 | 2024-04-21T23:03:47 |
Donghuo Zeng, Roberto S. Legaspi, Yuewen Sun, Xinshuai Dong, Kazushi Ikeda, Peter Spirtes, kun Zhang
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Customizing persuasive conversations related to the outcome of interest for
specific users achieves better persuasion results. However, existing persuasive
conversation systems rely on persuasive strategies and encounter challenges in
dynamically adjusting dialogues to suit the evolving states of individual users
during interactions. This limitation restricts the system's ability to deliver
flexible or dynamic conversations and achieve suboptimal persuasion outcomes.
In this paper, we present a novel approach that tracks a user's latent
personality dimensions (LPDs) during ongoing persuasion conversation and
generates tailored counterfactual utterances based on these LPDs to optimize
the overall persuasion outcome. In particular, our proposed method leverages a
Bi-directional Generative Adversarial Network (BiCoGAN) in tandem with a
Dialogue-based Personality Prediction Regression (DPPR) model to generate
counterfactual data. This enables the system to formulate alternative
persuasive utterances that are more suited to the user. Subsequently, we
utilize the D3QN model to learn policies for optimized selection of system
utterances on counterfactual data. Experimental results we obtained from using
the PersuasionForGood dataset demonstrate the superiority of our approach over
the existing method, BiCoGAN. The cumulative rewards and Q-values produced by
our method surpass ground truth benchmarks, showcasing the efficacy of
employing counterfactual reasoning and LPDs to optimize reinforcement learning
policy in online interactions.
|
[
-0.5792975425720215,
-1.113051414489746,
0.7006253004074097,
0.14910057187080383,
-0.20897722244262695,
0.24089409410953522,
-0.024757230654358864,
0.27699464559555054,
0.25516989827156067,
0.5397618412971497,
-0.8605890870094299,
-0.4797900319099426,
-0.15599185228347778,
-0.31371763348579407,
0.12820228934288025,
1.1219195127487183,
0.2563961148262024,
0.15419436991214752,
-0.31242260336875916,
-0.016490159556269646,
-0.5817991495132446,
-0.6660236716270447,
-0.7069129943847656,
-0.6885166764259338,
0.7086114883422852,
0.71097731590271,
0.7377176880836487,
-0.05972959101200104,
-0.12165577709674835,
0.21524913609027863,
-0.024672096595168114,
0.22411197423934937,
-0.7117484211921692,
0.14300577342510223,
-0.5200522541999817,
-0.5265499949455261,
-0.3840692341327667,
0.15054285526275635,
0.18910276889801025,
0.49484679102897644,
-0.37592625617980957,
-0.2540658116340637,
-0.04564214125275612,
0.35463660955429077,
-0.3602255880832672,
-0.07139060646295547,
-0.697475790977478,
0.25051799416542053,
-0.03891977295279503,
-0.22923211753368378,
-0.2467345893383026,
-0.41117677092552185,
0.36995723843574524,
-0.5618496537208557,
0.05022084340453148,
-0.17653468251228333,
0.48262497782707214,
0.021364938467741013,
-0.41274622082710266,
-0.20693649351596832,
-0.9063099026679993,
0.5633605122566223,
-0.683270275592804,
0.2081538289785385,
0.5257277488708496,
0.20994031429290771,
-0.209282785654068,
-0.4470602869987488,
-0.9488792419433594,
-0.17628136277198792,
-0.004316413775086403,
0.37488725781440735,
-0.41810163855552673,
-0.16258981823921204,
0.2762357294559479,
-0.04053238034248352,
-0.7851732969284058,
0.2641160190105438,
0.1661243438720703,
-0.11904510110616684,
0.6403387784957886,
0.3327838182449341,
-0.11156898736953735,
-0.13188065588474274,
-0.23026907444000244,
-0.3445054292678833,
-0.754440426826477,
0.13336993753910065,
0.7596220970153809,
0.13639430701732635,
-0.12496349960565567,
0.38277512788772583,
-0.3051629960536957,
0.2540379464626312,
0.7741166949272156,
0.08510542660951614,
-0.07894580811262131,
-0.5773134827613831,
-0.08301331102848053,
0.1669476479291916,
0.9232968688011169,
0.3793273866176605,
0.12905766069889069,
0.050180673599243164,
0.09035157412290573,
0.02293228544294834,
0.3132879137992859,
-0.765392541885376,
-0.6854204535484314,
0.3065873384475708,
-0.47411730885505676,
-0.47438713908195496,
-0.16108742356300354,
-1.0594706535339355,
-0.4555189907550812,
-0.22863374650478363,
0.35928046703338623,
-0.4455268383026123,
-0.37237921357154846,
-0.2588171064853668,
0.0028857735451310873,
-0.13202880322933197,
0.2318810671567917,
-0.8665592670440674,
-0.16534432768821716,
0.49385175108909607,
0.818636417388916,
0.0634484514594078,
0.12743350863456726,
-0.7882685661315918,
0.17988601326942444,
-0.5196322798728943,
0.6537340879440308,
-0.7349128127098083,
-0.6787869930267334,
-0.06913026422262192,
-0.04297413304448128,
0.07830200344324112,
-0.4307346045970917,
0.3817750811576843,
-0.43207767605781555,
0.4384528398513794,
-0.5227210521697998,
-0.3303529620170593,
-0.0638490542769432,
0.534125804901123,
-0.23027987778186798,
0.370890349149704,
-0.06601094454526901,
-0.5097389221191406,
0.3168914318084717,
-0.5758569836616516,
-0.44359728693962097,
0.19772207736968994,
-0.3769736588001251,
-0.7907084226608276,
-0.1194223165512085,
0.20683255791664124,
0.3907751142978668,
0.0073037175461649895,
0.5805616974830627,
-0.494059681892395,
0.02654021792113781,
0.6983774304389954,
-0.683199405670166,
0.7851850390434265,
0.10554809123277664,
-0.5028776526451111,
0.4132576584815979,
-0.642279863357544,
-0.09647279977798462,
0.18356376886367798,
-0.12292083352804184,
-0.1903447061777115,
0.25860363245010376,
-0.36075443029403687,
0.09933530539274216,
0.1830388307571411,
-0.6880078911781311,
0.13000909984111786,
-0.41032764315605164,
0.23963765799999237,
0.7193498015403748,
0.2866949141025543,
0.2248992621898651,
-0.4021495580673218,
0.41991230845451355,
0.13504815101623535,
0.2782013416290283,
0.1595316380262375,
-0.4704790711402893,
-0.49614378809928894,
-0.09577026218175888,
-0.1794660985469818,
0.5906862020492554,
-1.1031142473220825,
0.47354522347450256,
-0.039646685123443604,
-0.5412613749504089,
0.15632770955562592,
-0.07653243094682693,
0.6381313800811768,
0.7423049211502075,
0.34056541323661804,
-0.09444558620452881,
-0.4092419147491455,
-0.7940895557403564,
-0.16340450942516327,
-0.6105008721351624,
-0.12462742626667023,
0.4290000796318054,
0.3953422009944916,
0.05277993530035019,
0.8707383275032043,
-0.5615472793579102,
-0.04995034635066986,
-0.21953676640987396,
0.728954553604126,
0.08732276409864426,
0.3027592599391937,
0.6135303974151611,
-0.9826552867889404,
-0.5711625814437866,
-0.1125805675983429,
-0.47501835227012634,
-0.24364784359931946,
-0.5969194173812866,
-0.04725566506385803,
0.14164511859416962,
0.29940688610076904,
-0.45614734292030334,
0.6932776570320129,
0.3696244955062866,
-0.5111401677131653,
0.7906624674797058,
-0.13097819685935974,
0.11376314610242844,
-0.6525239944458008,
-0.10547799617052078,
-0.03148095682263374,
-0.1705981194972992,
-0.7634260058403015,
-0.5724316239356995,
-0.3779516816139221,
-0.09602472931146622,
-0.28390923142433167,
0.26085519790649414,
0.03460071235895157,
0.09749294817447662,
-0.26101911067962646,
0.09274624288082123,
0.07782814651727676,
0.7289415597915649,
0.30864962935447693,
0.7371827960014343,
0.1947147101163864,
-0.5310022234916687,
0.7822054624557495,
0.5667754411697388,
-0.26313260197639465,
1.2704483270645142,
-0.7188794612884521,
0.24231554567813873,
-0.07959850877523422,
0.5070323348045349,
-1.0642257928848267,
0.15050365030765533,
0.47051969170570374,
-0.4424360394477844,
-0.008556857705116272,
-0.07155545800924301,
-0.09342316538095474,
-0.07939282059669495,
-0.14464960992336273,
-0.3141786456108093,
0.20702189207077026,
-0.6151449680328369,
0.5881397724151611,
0.0015662949299439788,
-0.3607071340084076,
-0.17181120812892914,
-0.4752838611602783,
0.3143065273761749,
-0.3294484615325928,
-0.35982224345207214,
0.5728528499603271,
-0.3958904445171356,
-0.22793884575366974,
-0.22527430951595306,
0.10961337387561798,
0.5339136123657227,
-0.11739426851272583,
0.13937805593013763,
0.37542083859443665,
0.029895536601543427,
0.0334467738866806,
0.12073425948619843,
-0.0708996132016182,
0.2332008183002472,
-0.19749779999256134,
0.4924653172492981,
-0.08368473500013351,
-0.29054349660873413,
-0.4488740563392639,
0.5393421053886414,
0.3022444248199463,
0.05930972471833229,
0.9064367413520813,
0.7700657844543457,
0.0005532506620511413,
-0.03134903684258461,
-0.37771496176719666,
-0.3795372545719147,
-0.43710240721702576,
0.3942060172557831,
-0.5123612284660339,
-0.4033219516277313,
0.4155700206756592,
-0.1790212243795395,
0.06201738864183426,
-0.08137147128582001,
0.8465338945388794,
-0.18848885595798492,
1.4258884191513062,
0.0050042071379721165,
0.520798921585083,
0.6881808042526245,
-0.21119962632656097,
0.3640960454940796,
-0.711889386177063,
-0.7195121645927429,
-0.206792950630188,
-0.26621896028518677,
-0.34572699666023254,
-0.2897527515888214,
0.4204188585281372,
-0.057890668511390686,
-0.5086303353309631,
0.20540693402290344,
-0.34401199221611023,
-0.042821984738111496,
0.5567363500595093,
0.2771459221839905,
-0.047756925225257874,
0.1284535527229309,
-0.4460654556751251,
-0.19049397110939026,
-0.542747974395752,
-0.43915900588035583,
0.9169967770576477,
0.13263563811779022,
0.4662378430366516,
0.6713815331459045,
0.10467106103897095,
0.3748506009578705,
0.37399032711982727,
-0.6109597086906433,
0.6779892444610596,
-0.17815335094928741,
-0.5019814968109131,
-0.48176637291908264,
-0.6065284013748169,
-0.7524715065956116,
0.20182214677333832,
-0.6645438075065613,
-0.9449703693389893,
0.5741338729858398,
0.2385554015636444,
-0.40293386578559875,
0.3040325343608856,
-0.5015601515769958,
0.8899968266487122,
-0.5130671262741089,
-0.8009346723556519,
-0.48452693223953247,
-0.5773545503616333,
-0.09381847083568573,
-0.02365081012248993,
-0.2363625466823578,
0.04009862244129181,
0.38275575637817383,
0.6438373923301697,
-0.6239184141159058,
0.9554269313812256,
-0.42478081583976746,
-0.0845283716917038,
0.10582582652568817,
0.15643958747386932,
0.7914279699325562,
0.2700323164463043,
-0.13094791769981384,
0.19919340312480927,
0.04722338914871216,
-0.15086707472801208,
-0.863993227481842,
0.7512440085411072,
-0.7978505492210388,
-0.7879295945167542,
-0.27537715435028076,
-0.22757765650749207,
-0.6149827837944031,
-0.05792795494198799,
0.20886723697185516,
0.36925816535949707,
-0.9234976768493652,
0.36501866579055786,
0.794094443321228,
-0.49883833527565,
0.3951300084590912,
0.7987470626831055,
-0.016395382583141327,
-0.4320598244667053,
1.0920661687850952,
0.03064224310219288,
0.25087860226631165,
0.5091030597686768,
0.7303187251091003,
-0.680411696434021,
-0.429399698972702,
-0.48603978753089905,
-0.10276689380407333,
-0.5486714839935303,
-0.03548724949359894,
-0.5606037974357605,
0.03222445771098137,
-0.543616771697998,
-0.1266956925392151,
-0.2155526876449585,
-0.09219278395175934,
-0.5180701017379761,
0.02970241755247116,
0.058428410440683365,
0.4309529662132263,
-0.22850488126277924,
0.4959621727466583,
-0.17981214821338654,
0.3239736258983612,
0.8440589904785156,
0.014546315185725689,
-0.04210791736841202,
-0.5740013122558594,
0.05579685419797897,
0.4208054542541504,
-0.7781507968902588,
-1.0393195152282715,
0.4825887084007263,
0.009851189330220222,
0.753711462020874,
0.7292078137397766,
0.1981734037399292,
0.38642430305480957,
-0.09318482875823975,
0.7159988880157471,
0.6026188731193542,
-0.7801845669746399,
0.7424700260162354,
-0.42303332686424255,
0.25345131754875183,
0.2816910743713379,
0.49919286370277405,
-0.487764835357666,
0.0559355765581131,
-0.5397279858589172,
-0.5124914646148682,
0.610916256904602,
0.23811663687229156,
-0.026792526245117188,
0.049281083047389984,
0.07164526730775833,
0.15350911021232605,
0.2153024673461914,
-0.3742269277572632,
-0.24107231199741364,
-0.9367662668228149,
-0.1653425693511963,
-0.15935422480106354,
-0.13598763942718506,
-0.3739689588546753,
-0.123986154794693,
0.792685329914093,
-0.3064027726650238,
-0.04304128140211105,
0.17447920143604279,
0.3976247310638428,
0.039372947067022324,
0.3523422181606293,
0.7148648500442505,
0.6087558269500732,
-0.3115296959877014,
-0.04770767316222191,
0.12879659235477448,
-0.2791266143321991,
0.1076294481754303,
0.15525196492671967,
-0.1915902942419052,
-0.21160286664962769,
-0.008689642883837223,
1.139674186706543,
-0.24147634208202362,
-0.35701921582221985,
0.5208534598350525,
-0.2617521286010742,
-0.39900287985801697,
-0.47772279381752014,
0.024772629141807556,
0.2404021918773651,
0.41992172598838806,
0.24621494114398956,
-0.08287717401981354,
-0.1009206473827362,
-0.7814089059829712,
0.04363725334405899,
0.49274054169654846,
-0.4421049952507019,
-0.4017372131347656,
0.605564296245575,
0.4262924790382385,
-0.6094768643379211,
0.5028817057609558,
-0.2616654634475708,
-0.5506113171577454,
0.45511117577552795,
0.4910167455673218,
0.7320694923400879,
-0.3054334819316864,
0.7157167196273804,
0.2701139450073242,
-0.13836635649204254,
0.30116260051727295,
0.11845732480287552,
-0.16900211572647095,
-0.797048807144165,
0.03193824738264084,
-0.2616218030452728,
-0.6309151649475098,
0.5402302742004395,
-0.3200773298740387,
0.04681749269366264,
-0.800788164138794,
-0.3076266348361969,
0.3099069595336914,
0.16003037989139557,
-0.5024083256721497,
0.2958418130874634,
0.24240775406360626,
0.10279189795255661,
-0.829907238483429,
0.4322904050350189,
0.6569936871528625,
-0.4300020635128021,
-0.4955819845199585,
0.27146613597869873,
0.38721737265586853,
-0.4915028512477875,
0.5985564589500427,
-0.2715170085430145,
-0.40168359875679016,
-0.38692042231559753,
-0.5064708590507507,
-0.4009570777416229,
0.8156304955482483,
0.24661967158317566,
-0.831092357635498,
0.33382296562194824,
0.07620713114738464,
0.547719419002533,
-0.6445210576057434,
0.4512643814086914,
0.25097405910491943,
0.456005334854126,
0.5233973264694214,
-0.44953596591949463,
0.1383470892906189,
-0.07768095284700394,
0.05127158761024475,
-0.3306150436401367,
-0.7107434868812561,
0.5599172711372375,
-0.23619233071804047,
-0.03581918776035309,
-0.08465022593736649,
0.7440400123596191,
0.36261776089668274,
0.44515255093574524,
0.7915627956390381,
0.28175103664398193,
0.680563747882843,
0.011188480071723461,
0.6699361205101013,
0.012535164132714272,
-0.13848085701465607,
1.086001992225647,
-0.34925010800361633,
0.5715111494064331,
0.3422005772590637,
-0.1960812211036682,
0.9611555337905884,
0.4960700273513794,
-0.013083912432193756,
0.6435611248016357,
0.32804587483406067,
-0.4910237193107605,
-0.6639488339424133,
-0.3963150978088379,
0.0336964949965477,
0.6369403004646301,
0.6229269504547119,
0.04915260896086693,
0.19119594991207123,
0.21524368226528168,
0.17245826125144958,
0.5322920680046082,
0.13083776831626892,
0.8205654621124268,
-0.22571128606796265,
-1.0092138051986694,
0.3366587162017822,
-0.02885047160089016,
0.48422011733055115,
-0.4240768551826477,
-0.2165544331073761,
-0.3106844425201416,
0.3108118176460266,
-0.12119753658771515,
-0.8996047973632812,
0.2093343734741211,
-0.13487814366817474,
-0.14116798341274261,
-0.5190256237983704,
0.42594924569129944,
-0.5700616836547852,
-0.3045220673084259,
0.1270597279071808,
0.30767881870269775,
0.04935409128665924,
-0.0419185496866703,
-0.9042681455612183,
-0.13110359013080597,
0.05680839344859123,
-0.2180051952600479,
0.20330770313739777,
0.36956584453582764,
-0.02573329024016857,
0.6049498915672302,
0.9574010968208313,
0.1187514066696167,
-0.7573558688163757,
0.4328714609146118,
0.8730128407478333,
-0.38760071992874146,
-0.9311012625694275,
-0.6594513654708862,
0.1419086456298828,
-0.44433191418647766,
-0.36460670828819275,
0.6464976668357849,
0.4308103919029236,
0.7192531824111938,
0.25701117515563965,
0.7853295207023621,
0.11287088692188263,
0.6859243512153625,
-0.3918552100658417,
0.4899854362010956,
-0.47235068678855896,
0.39887961745262146,
-0.14445377886295319,
-0.6300287246704102,
0.3971391022205353,
0.7487739324569702,
-0.7665525078773499,
0.12365742772817612,
0.4009387195110321,
0.9270675778388977,
0.05476204678416252,
0.27394041419029236,
0.48765572905540466,
0.2566308379173279,
0.7265074253082275,
0.7080154418945312,
0.7971462607383728,
0.11348268389701843,
0.7518060207366943,
-0.11115573346614838,
-0.2870446443557739,
-0.3305216133594513,
-0.7725518941879272,
-1.139405608177185,
-0.5077003836631775,
-0.5550425052642822,
-0.46052274107933044,
0.2655102014541626,
0.5427839159965515,
0.6364222764968872,
-0.6209748387336731,
0.13511449098587036,
-0.15035958588123322,
0.11096229404211044,
-0.17060250043869019,
-0.31416815519332886,
0.09640795737504959,
0.34436172246932983,
-0.5145962238311768,
0.4921864867210388,
0.3155510127544403,
0.04112347215414047,
-0.650051474571228,
-0.2893749475479126,
-0.5482351779937744,
0.49072471261024475,
0.45038163661956787,
0.39795219898223877,
-0.6607166528701782,
-0.3310556709766388,
-0.1205117404460907,
0.011197040788829327,
0.0023750951513648033,
0.8728348016738892,
-0.8359677195549011,
0.4754508435726166,
0.5114728212356567,
0.0995103269815445,
0.7909733653068542,
0.2646045982837677,
0.718052327632904,
-0.6280017495155334,
-0.21046534180641174,
0.30420982837677,
-0.11137651652097702,
0.520672082901001,
-0.5882361531257629,
-0.0013659920077770948,
0.393677294254303,
-0.3085557818412781,
-0.41461142897605896,
0.6529995203018188,
-0.620625913143158,
-0.6640186309814453,
1.0291510820388794,
-0.43843045830726624,
0.19641967117786407,
-0.6291049122810364,
-0.08840212225914001,
0.28604990243911743,
-0.4544134736061096,
0.7232871055603027,
0.4866492748260498,
-0.45700570940971375,
-0.2840314209461212,
-0.05768147483468056,
0.43861815333366394,
0.8096319437026978,
-0.7392652034759521,
0.11455515772104263,
0.4999876618385315,
0.1777496486902237,
0.2572697699069977,
0.5852916836738586,
0.09739450365304947,
0.06488657742738724,
0.28415706753730774,
-0.3016405403614044,
-0.1894625425338745,
-0.2760891914367676,
0.012738069519400597,
0.09548205882310867,
-0.5840136408805847,
-0.009024877101182938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16873v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16873v1
|
AdvPrompter: Fast Adaptive Adversarial Prompting for LLMs
| 2024-04-21T22:18:13 | 2024-04-21T22:18:13 |
Anselm Paulus, Arman Zharmagambetov, Chuan Guo, Brandon Amos, Yuandong Tian
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
While recently Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable
successes, they are vulnerable to certain jailbreaking attacks that lead to
generation of inappropriate or harmful content. Manual red-teaming requires
finding adversarial prompts that cause such jailbreaking, e.g. by appending a
suffix to a given instruction, which is inefficient and time-consuming. On the
other hand, automatic adversarial prompt generation often leads to semantically
meaningless attacks that can easily be detected by perplexity-based filters,
may require gradient information from the TargetLLM, or do not scale well due
to time-consuming discrete optimization processes over the token space. In this
paper, we present a novel method that uses another LLM, called the AdvPrompter,
to generate human-readable adversarial prompts in seconds, $\sim800\times$
faster than existing optimization-based approaches. We train the AdvPrompter
using a novel algorithm that does not require access to the gradients of the
TargetLLM. This process alternates between two steps: (1) generating
high-quality target adversarial suffixes by optimizing the AdvPrompter
predictions, and (2) low-rank fine-tuning of the AdvPrompter with the generated
adversarial suffixes. The trained AdvPrompter generates suffixes that veil the
input instruction without changing its meaning, such that the TargetLLM is
lured to give a harmful response. Experimental results on popular open source
TargetLLMs show state-of-the-art results on the AdvBench dataset, that also
transfer to closed-source black-box LLM APIs. Further, we demonstrate that by
fine-tuning on a synthetic dataset generated by AdvPrompter, LLMs can be made
more robust against jailbreaking attacks while maintaining performance, i.e.
high MMLU scores.
|
[
-0.5234121680259705,
-1.0407682657241821,
0.32011890411376953,
0.07960658520460129,
-0.15988990664482117,
0.07844231277704239,
-0.11927583068609238,
-0.06386642158031464,
0.11052048206329346,
0.37416279315948486,
-0.8714958429336548,
-0.3854212760925293,
-0.6257588267326355,
0.01930861920118332,
-0.12721310555934906,
1.0378293991088867,
0.05660778284072876,
-0.005635364912450314,
0.16997043788433075,
-0.0701378583908081,
-0.5944362878799438,
-0.4310763478279114,
-0.9701873660087585,
-0.06049260124564171,
0.5984939932823181,
0.3464660346508026,
0.7268908023834229,
0.6054059863090515,
0.4139407277107239,
0.28274571895599365,
-0.07394979149103165,
0.30752506852149963,
-0.42501765489578247,
0.3581368625164032,
-0.0280129536986351,
-0.3642374873161316,
-0.39718079566955566,
0.04365832358598709,
0.23160670697689056,
0.0222918763756752,
-0.051254551857709885,
0.0791834145784378,
-0.17719563841819763,
0.6266961097717285,
-0.7379668354988098,
-0.37283462285995483,
-0.961570143699646,
-0.004230155609548092,
-0.15358759462833405,
-0.3589651584625244,
-0.43159982562065125,
-0.3828210234642029,
-0.1959320306777954,
-0.5715140104293823,
0.3677164316177368,
0.08194338530302048,
0.6394008994102478,
0.504538357257843,
-0.06195138394832611,
-0.36794331669807434,
-0.5394027233123779,
0.49655982851982117,
-0.4765779674053192,
0.001784586813300848,
-0.04273490607738495,
0.4644140303134918,
-0.6151888370513916,
-0.5180269479751587,
-0.49344703555107117,
-0.3843584954738617,
0.21635332703590393,
0.15733535587787628,
-0.497433066368103,
-0.026363827288150787,
0.3074883818626404,
-0.02115792967379093,
-0.601652979850769,
0.3423102796077728,
-0.31820425391197205,
-0.3122219443321228,
0.5115556716918945,
0.30109500885009766,
0.3563971519470215,
0.08266381174325943,
-0.6173261404037476,
-0.16348896920681,
-0.9011975526809692,
0.11841689795255661,
0.6594244241714478,
0.19160065054893494,
0.20394691824913025,
0.35835230350494385,
0.0840606614947319,
0.8070382475852966,
0.1302475482225418,
0.04245912656188011,
-0.18363822996616364,
-0.057859934866428375,
-0.006431315094232559,
0.2605559825897217,
1.0319706201553345,
0.3509841561317444,
0.3871208429336548,
-0.01205813605338335,
-0.2830808460712433,
0.30643272399902344,
0.49005183577537537,
-0.8581095337867737,
-0.5887302160263062,
0.24382427334785461,
-0.0027535876724869013,
-0.601901113986969,
0.07886849343776703,
-0.8187147378921509,
-0.7593637108802795,
0.012862359173595905,
0.35633376240730286,
-0.5610794425010681,
0.12590603530406952,
-0.1450478583574295,
-0.23847246170043945,
0.07665811479091644,
0.32440808415412903,
-0.7438721656799316,
0.17112383246421814,
0.6030916571617126,
0.8657797574996948,
-0.26772311329841614,
-0.2534542679786682,
-1.136163592338562,
-0.1467226892709732,
-0.30699315667152405,
0.7044739127159119,
-0.19029057025909424,
-0.3031039237976074,
-0.33430227637290955,
-0.09262393414974213,
-0.12524546682834625,
-0.6526665687561035,
0.3507722318172455,
-0.7751510143280029,
0.10088974982500076,
0.04817364364862442,
-0.29689303040504456,
0.09571961313486099,
0.3367597460746765,
-0.6666638851165771,
0.7023937106132507,
-0.11521515995264053,
-0.6722590923309326,
0.3331105709075928,
-0.7142005562782288,
-0.41305166482925415,
0.22277289628982544,
0.12383591383695602,
-0.5407044291496277,
-0.024901632219552994,
0.6325070261955261,
0.46691837906837463,
-0.23473146557807922,
0.03613591566681862,
-0.2511039078235626,
-0.3443572521209717,
0.3555452525615692,
-0.5937580466270447,
0.8332254886627197,
0.22336643934249878,
-0.36156097054481506,
0.4503597915172577,
-0.6394999027252197,
-0.24147076904773712,
0.42207810282707214,
-0.27434760332107544,
-0.2713202238082886,
-0.0384984128177166,
-0.24460822343826294,
0.15447862446308136,
0.19225314259529114,
-0.5097151398658752,
0.3243347406387329,
-0.5046351552009583,
0.4369856119155884,
1.0995315313339233,
0.14784623682498932,
0.2795833349227905,
-0.18908676505088806,
0.7837285995483398,
-0.0941937193274498,
0.3353447914123535,
-0.2662951648235321,
-0.43673568964004517,
-0.5561330318450928,
-0.5785380601882935,
0.17946770787239075,
0.932047426700592,
-0.8781799674034119,
0.4074195623397827,
0.02503051981329918,
-0.38523605465888977,
-0.7694602608680725,
0.4021774232387543,
0.5222672820091248,
0.4666222333908081,
0.42812785506248474,
0.014101722277700901,
-0.4911782145500183,
-0.6144723296165466,
-0.318596214056015,
-0.19014358520507812,
-0.03972015529870987,
0.30406343936920166,
0.3685247004032135,
-0.15904617309570312,
0.5582464337348938,
-0.6607204079627991,
-0.1953982710838318,
-0.2628893554210663,
0.1320139765739441,
0.08245167881250381,
0.19172032177448273,
0.5400160551071167,
-0.7831127047538757,
-0.36334502696990967,
-0.42707616090774536,
-0.4524775445461273,
-0.2847374379634857,
-0.18035337328910828,
-0.02372891828417778,
0.10391900688409805,
0.6320617198944092,
-0.3941650390625,
0.05576423555612564,
0.4498652517795563,
-0.5522922277450562,
0.7619999051094055,
-0.2675102651119232,
-0.021434661000967026,
-1.1143629550933838,
-0.12222371250391006,
0.032279349863529205,
-0.31759852170944214,
-0.6284525990486145,
0.21957966685295105,
0.06793376803398132,
-0.16613644361495972,
-0.8625491857528687,
0.6588810086250305,
-0.33774566650390625,
0.3000643849372864,
-0.36032119393348694,
0.27287569642066956,
-0.11667916178703308,
0.3118421137332916,
-0.47739729285240173,
1.0872468948364258,
0.5587174892425537,
-0.7131748199462891,
1.0154958963394165,
0.07525154948234558,
-0.036481354385614395,
0.545242428779602,
-0.7095444798469543,
0.06983800232410431,
-0.08099230378866196,
0.10958557575941086,
-0.9059429168701172,
-0.1583489179611206,
0.4480898082256317,
-0.5824238657951355,
0.3454180955886841,
-0.17907775938510895,
-0.3416970670223236,
-0.5078213810920715,
-0.6410626769065857,
0.1387006789445877,
0.587226927280426,
-0.7917636632919312,
0.214685320854187,
0.12771055102348328,
-0.012433120049536228,
-0.5640995502471924,
-0.3851642608642578,
0.24781054258346558,
-0.5043559074401855,
-0.5830976366996765,
0.2013183832168579,
-0.13368389010429382,
-0.2742219567298889,
-0.07118072360754013,
0.11461960524320602,
0.247203066945076,
0.5666691064834595,
0.3592644929885864,
0.5655224323272705,
-0.16425512731075287,
-0.2713949978351593,
-0.31662553548812866,
-0.26323583722114563,
0.2905922532081604,
-0.39301005005836487,
0.30288517475128174,
-0.06497038900852203,
-0.32869622111320496,
-0.35764288902282715,
0.08768409490585327,
0.6953797340393066,
-0.10563650727272034,
0.8150038123130798,
0.7507947087287903,
-0.14658121764659882,
-0.5123254060745239,
-0.2855788767337799,
-0.28732311725616455,
-0.5411189198493958,
0.27239054441452026,
-0.309721440076828,
-0.8127947449684143,
0.3570583462715149,
-0.15908315777778625,
-0.014432135038077831,
0.15094701945781708,
0.6294819712638855,
0.17613612115383148,
1.2405728101730347,
0.23327074944972992,
-0.19099228084087372,
0.5703824758529663,
-0.13656550645828247,
-0.025087745860219002,
-0.8613519072532654,
-0.12994801998138428,
-0.10809123516082764,
-0.30313268303871155,
-0.350589781999588,
-0.23363538086414337,
0.5519701242446899,
0.0676087811589241,
-0.2562495172023773,
0.3608187139034271,
-0.6060745716094971,
0.5009875297546387,
0.7278216481208801,
0.07067051529884338,
-0.14528146386146545,
-0.18173344433307648,
-0.29318544268608093,
-0.03051002509891987,
-0.6931112408638,
-0.30793043971061707,
0.9355109930038452,
0.310305655002594,
0.8498844504356384,
0.14943979680538177,
0.5593857169151306,
0.4672970771789551,
0.23739103972911835,
-1.029307246208191,
0.6359891295433044,
-0.3490016758441925,
-0.29007676243782043,
-0.0624423548579216,
-0.4113899767398834,
-0.9672918319702148,
0.1573643982410431,
-0.24783934652805328,
-0.6492499709129333,
-0.11091085523366928,
0.39961671829223633,
-0.6610223054885864,
0.40211737155914307,
-0.6618168354034424,
0.8123486638069153,
-0.21053878962993622,
-0.2569011449813843,
0.11713303625583649,
-0.5488552451133728,
0.49544739723205566,
-0.12566624581813812,
0.12530548870563507,
-0.13131818175315857,
-0.06985458731651306,
0.7919400334358215,
-0.49581098556518555,
0.6665745377540588,
-0.5681788921356201,
-0.08361916989088058,
0.2743590176105499,
0.3587719202041626,
0.9063165783882141,
0.11412277072668076,
-0.036917805671691895,
-0.4046805202960968,
-0.562647819519043,
-0.30148589611053467,
-0.741732120513916,
0.8455139398574829,
-0.6746323108673096,
-0.9645651578903198,
-0.2938281297683716,
-0.5838980078697205,
-0.03050115518271923,
0.05670516565442085,
0.31497475504875183,
0.4053727984428406,
-0.2419682741165161,
-0.10299232602119446,
0.9187106490135193,
-0.3097706437110901,
0.36259663105010986,
0.6705743074417114,
0.3370712101459503,
-0.5168415307998657,
1.1782314777374268,
-0.191404327750206,
0.23888744413852692,
0.2112182378768921,
0.21263645589351654,
-0.228696808218956,
-0.7010346055030823,
-0.6649352312088013,
0.034272510558366776,
-0.5709846019744873,
-0.43063420057296753,
-0.41631320118904114,
-0.22237971425056458,
-0.22878438234329224,
-0.36759963631629944,
-0.2914479970932007,
-0.3162256181240082,
-0.4304853677749634,
0.11954612284898758,
0.6428462862968445,
0.6321271061897278,
0.097414530813694,
0.34881648421287537,
-0.6855352520942688,
0.5308824181556702,
0.4946354925632477,
-0.15006062388420105,
-0.32893580198287964,
-0.6462771892547607,
-0.004410089924931526,
-0.09096387773752213,
-0.37611138820648193,
-0.8950835466384888,
0.3684692978858948,
0.09320847690105438,
0.3836739957332611,
0.3394269645214081,
0.40373843908309937,
0.5228927731513977,
-0.6091597676277161,
0.809109628200531,
0.15783247351646423,
-0.6546587347984314,
0.9337590932846069,
-0.28347331285476685,
0.21348637342453003,
0.4030497670173645,
0.2189532220363617,
-0.2335178256034851,
-0.5446235537528992,
-0.4664182960987091,
-1.01025390625,
0.7885406017303467,
-0.04470711201429367,
0.005720458459109068,
-0.06904696673154831,
0.383270263671875,
-0.21376334130764008,
-0.16811873018741608,
-0.3256271183490753,
-0.5167282819747925,
-0.1836887151002884,
-0.26885440945625305,
-0.02616886794567108,
-0.25147590041160583,
-0.29896989464759827,
0.01594550721347332,
0.7978917956352234,
-0.11758078634738922,
0.0651542916893959,
0.05761990323662758,
-0.16850237548351288,
-0.0587485246360302,
0.47773778438568115,
0.65016108751297,
0.21563033759593964,
-0.14543534815311432,
0.2137659788131714,
0.36898088455200195,
-0.5837158560752869,
0.5615193843841553,
0.29213961958885193,
-0.21964289247989655,
-0.3073645830154419,
0.3336904048919678,
1.0158909559249878,
-0.16761118173599243,
-0.751072108745575,
0.7587563991546631,
-0.36363744735717773,
-0.26503077149391174,
-0.21705670654773712,
0.5152799487113953,
-0.29761677980422974,
0.34996315836906433,
0.3308391869068146,
0.32007527351379395,
-0.058932386338710785,
-0.2538151741027832,
0.24762828648090363,
0.6134287714958191,
-0.5064061880111694,
-0.25415942072868347,
1.0953906774520874,
0.166604682803154,
-0.42307496070861816,
0.45955270528793335,
-0.4052915871143341,
-0.7175517678260803,
0.5837196707725525,
0.6320316791534424,
0.9178680777549744,
-0.4377806484699249,
0.11809270083904266,
0.1022452786564827,
0.35509321093559265,
0.007861962541937828,
0.020290696993470192,
0.2233552187681198,
-0.5785025358200073,
-0.2642735242843628,
-0.5159693956375122,
-0.35162314772605896,
0.37702906131744385,
-0.5430258512496948,
0.34542664885520935,
-0.6119166612625122,
-0.016578389331698418,
0.1554650068283081,
-0.14576974511146545,
-0.2887498438358307,
0.1664717197418213,
0.19515667855739594,
0.9480963945388794,
-0.784124493598938,
0.62339848279953,
1.0032888650894165,
0.07093236595392227,
-0.47418972849845886,
0.10620561987161636,
0.40312284231185913,
-0.9940418601036072,
0.5901567935943604,
0.14463262259960175,
-0.20824337005615234,
0.15498007833957672,
-0.30855634808540344,
-0.4576052129268646,
0.9693151712417603,
0.5451549887657166,
-0.4421120584011078,
0.101499043405056,
-0.3229753077030182,
0.2897927165031433,
-0.20740906894207,
-0.02702886424958706,
0.6652185320854187,
0.3562401533126831,
0.13642388582229614,
-0.41754117608070374,
0.5553207993507385,
-0.438505083322525,
-0.09390711039304733,
0.3659890294075012,
-0.494386225938797,
0.6988052725791931,
-0.5166829228401184,
-0.18181248009204865,
-0.04115317016839981,
0.4396055340766907,
0.4182378351688385,
0.03462475538253784,
0.6539600491523743,
0.4802685081958771,
0.5875808596611023,
-0.07083972543478012,
1.0885884761810303,
-0.3805426061153412,
-0.18410857021808624,
0.8641185164451599,
0.019605157896876335,
0.5699235200881958,
0.33789965510368347,
-0.1259266585111618,
0.29611659049987793,
0.49902981519699097,
-0.29020899534225464,
0.6365828514099121,
0.4791751801967621,
-0.555689811706543,
-0.13335739076137543,
-0.06869649142026901,
-0.08085961639881134,
0.19903846085071564,
0.4992139935493469,
-0.213321715593338,
-0.117316834628582,
0.3358696699142456,
0.1515342742204666,
0.16844633221626282,
-0.39194348454475403,
1.0028659105300903,
-0.054897114634513855,
-0.7565701007843018,
0.9114372730255127,
0.1343749612569809,
0.9173159003257751,
-0.630088210105896,
0.1377752125263214,
0.07042938470840454,
0.4293772578239441,
0.02713237702846527,
-0.6669904589653015,
0.19981153309345245,
0.2259654849767685,
-0.15065503120422363,
-0.12399796396493912,
0.8255771398544312,
-0.1615115851163864,
-0.274935781955719,
0.36718931794166565,
0.19121307134628296,
-0.03176070749759674,
-0.20266343653202057,
-0.9599300622940063,
-0.015422136522829533,
-0.12365709990262985,
-0.449115127325058,
0.27059289813041687,
0.31317102909088135,
0.014977997168898582,
0.7662259340286255,
0.7637515068054199,
0.5305332541465759,
0.09081985056400299,
0.1700267642736435,
1.0846433639526367,
-0.48274362087249756,
-0.40062984824180603,
-1.312454342842102,
0.26047492027282715,
0.1266099214553833,
-0.1525830775499344,
0.8321375846862793,
0.3320247530937195,
0.5122013092041016,
0.1255766749382019,
0.8918468356132507,
0.04201492294669151,
0.27269095182418823,
-0.5742815732955933,
0.6237813234329224,
-0.403382807970047,
0.513003408908844,
0.01975776068866253,
-0.48742493987083435,
-0.3309878408908844,
0.1765776425600052,
-0.23994062840938568,
-0.3026299774646759,
0.37418192625045776,
1.0536222457885742,
-0.01657472923398018,
-0.3563796877861023,
0.18386931717395782,
0.15543416142463684,
0.42454785108566284,
0.7625811696052551,
0.8376777768135071,
-0.3429647982120514,
0.7910410761833191,
-0.021979784592986107,
-0.3024427592754364,
-0.3430401384830475,
-0.698691725730896,
-1.123742938041687,
-0.1554296761751175,
-0.272308886051178,
-0.5607859492301941,
0.5416803359985352,
1.010448694229126,
0.4765686094760895,
-0.9857235550880432,
0.30383941531181335,
-0.29903367161750793,
0.20381422340869904,
-0.17689011991024017,
-0.2876022756099701,
0.2748452425003052,
-0.4425111413002014,
-0.5536584258079529,
0.8434522151947021,
0.02611394226551056,
0.24645942449569702,
-0.345489501953125,
-0.17451117932796478,
0.07230282574892044,
0.11195521056652069,
0.32677802443504333,
0.3027443587779999,
-0.6631593108177185,
0.016012463718652725,
-0.07719056308269501,
-0.05104241147637367,
-0.1591929942369461,
0.7494156956672668,
-0.7646884918212891,
0.5394190549850464,
0.3746630847454071,
0.6088111400604248,
0.06597064435482025,
0.23912134766578674,
0.7434049248695374,
-1.0600999593734741,
0.27770501375198364,
0.15465688705444336,
0.3055689334869385,
0.45104438066482544,
-0.6841900944709778,
0.12570010125637054,
0.32752788066864014,
-0.42725852131843567,
-0.8536167144775391,
0.3696306347846985,
-0.46382805705070496,
-0.5490989685058594,
1.1660791635513306,
-0.3360837996006012,
-0.4552794396877289,
-0.19592903554439545,
-0.3782137334346771,
0.2709813714027405,
-0.5581401586532593,
0.7164817452430725,
0.2877654731273651,
-0.0365830734372139,
-0.06618274748325348,
-0.49049392342567444,
0.7363693714141846,
0.22092539072036743,
-0.599071741104126,
0.15824836492538452,
0.23389364778995514,
0.27548035979270935,
-0.020500371232628822,
0.2952727973461151,
0.12380634248256683,
0.545132577419281,
0.06244034320116043,
-0.18468181788921356,
-0.7380362153053284,
-0.5006533265113831,
-0.514819860458374,
0.2808481454849243,
0.0324460007250309,
-0.367184042930603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13784v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13784v1
|
Iteratively Prompting Multimodal LLMs to Reproduce Natural and AI-Generated Images
| 2024-04-21T21:30:17 | 2024-04-21T21:30:17 |
Ali Naseh, Katherine Thai, Mohit Iyyer, Amir Houmansadr
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
With the digital imagery landscape rapidly evolving, image stocks and
AI-generated image marketplaces have become central to visual media.
Traditional stock images now exist alongside innovative platforms that trade in
prompts for AI-generated visuals, driven by sophisticated APIs like DALL-E 3
and Midjourney. This paper studies the possibility of employing multi-modal
models with enhanced visual understanding to mimic the outputs of these
platforms, introducing an original attack strategy. Our method leverages
fine-tuned CLIP models, a multi-label classifier, and the descriptive
capabilities of GPT-4V to create prompts that generate images similar to those
available in marketplaces and from premium stock image providers, yet at a
markedly lower expense. In presenting this strategy, we aim to spotlight a new
class of economic and security considerations within the realm of digital
imagery. Our findings, supported by both automated metrics and human
assessment, reveal that comparable visual content can be produced for a
fraction of the prevailing market prices ($0.23 - $0.27 per image), emphasizing
the need for awareness and strategic discussions about the integrity of digital
media in an increasingly AI-integrated landscape. Our work also contributes to
the field by assembling a dataset consisting of approximately 19 million
prompt-image pairs generated by the popular Midjourney platform, which we plan
to release publicly.
|
[
-0.5013120174407959,
-0.6463812589645386,
0.480983167886734,
0.15501779317855835,
-0.47117212414741516,
0.16368651390075684,
0.14424732327461243,
-0.43906140327453613,
0.1369566023349762,
0.4900916516780853,
-0.870815098285675,
-0.3450273275375366,
-0.5062435865402222,
0.2531563341617584,
-0.35115528106689453,
0.6671849489212036,
0.10584232211112976,
-0.20755921304225922,
-0.05183877795934677,
-0.14314432442188263,
-0.5805335640907288,
-0.6198010444641113,
-0.5920429229736328,
0.3169037699699402,
0.638009250164032,
0.17438958585262299,
0.7943872213363647,
0.45269975066185,
0.6262683272361755,
0.3387640416622162,
0.4444638192653656,
0.34047582745552063,
-0.5525333285331726,
0.23441176116466522,
0.19504471123218536,
-0.25448986887931824,
-0.14351944625377655,
0.3628094792366028,
0.308454304933548,
-0.15624485909938812,
0.20254531502723694,
0.2645688056945801,
-0.024136777967214584,
0.46636781096458435,
-0.6160664558410645,
-0.07257231324911118,
-0.9648479223251343,
0.018335789442062378,
-0.380965918302536,
-0.6660215854644775,
-0.5137596130371094,
0.09024390578269958,
-0.14210443198680878,
-0.823007345199585,
-0.07112311571836472,
0.23928461968898773,
1.1044447422027588,
0.28021717071533203,
-0.41478127241134644,
-0.4910467863082886,
-0.49643978476524353,
0.6522205471992493,
-0.270269513130188,
0.05080832540988922,
0.062257491052150726,
0.6255219578742981,
-0.09772585332393646,
-0.9243856072425842,
-0.6792477369308472,
-0.20842128992080688,
0.22437508404254913,
0.32406583428382874,
-0.8010342121124268,
-0.21375340223312378,
0.20521794259548187,
0.06556686013936996,
-0.2831164598464966,
0.0743841901421547,
-0.573495626449585,
-0.2602362036705017,
0.4995518922805786,
0.2856890559196472,
0.5291147232055664,
-0.3426130414009094,
-0.9001777172088623,
-0.2688017189502716,
-0.8772494196891785,
0.13857898116111755,
0.6531243920326233,
0.030829768627882004,
-0.1715160310268402,
0.6755279898643494,
0.13964210450649261,
0.47765085101127625,
0.28193408250808716,
-0.2431124597787857,
0.025476686656475067,
-0.6948776245117188,
-0.12602312862873077,
-0.19864600896835327,
0.7745143175125122,
1.0327808856964111,
-0.16015270352363586,
0.1528899371623993,
-0.5703063607215881,
0.3473721742630005,
0.5502681732177734,
-0.7509087920188904,
-0.19611917436122894,
0.10544764250516891,
-0.5343855023384094,
-0.47992032766342163,
0.026232974603772163,
-0.9647623300552368,
-0.370700478553772,
-0.3120774030685425,
0.7233737111091614,
-0.3272314667701721,
0.007381960283964872,
-0.22330565750598907,
-0.39380908012390137,
0.50996994972229,
0.6088971495628357,
-0.3096827268600464,
-0.2036558985710144,
0.28485316038131714,
1.1094063520431519,
-0.07779105752706528,
-0.17968833446502686,
-0.5215328931808472,
0.3051778972148895,
-0.44118279218673706,
0.8790410757064819,
-0.43737930059432983,
-0.6294719576835632,
-0.22276271879673004,
-0.13418520987033844,
0.34888705611228943,
-0.3565140664577484,
0.21025970578193665,
-1.0865994691848755,
0.12785440683364868,
-0.5299737453460693,
-0.03185540437698364,
-0.17933553457260132,
0.8592537045478821,
-0.9095339775085449,
0.6496289372444153,
-0.26170870661735535,
-0.9163063764572144,
0.543505847454071,
-0.8614919185638428,
0.1776999682188034,
0.16050182282924652,
-0.39792951941490173,
-0.28474339842796326,
-0.36729222536087036,
0.7117447853088379,
0.3244422376155853,
-0.1598375141620636,
-0.21692347526550293,
-0.4797930121421814,
-0.11375889927148819,
0.6062403917312622,
-0.9436037540435791,
0.45826125144958496,
0.3116244673728943,
-0.2670043706893921,
0.20766983926296234,
-0.5624414682388306,
-0.2803167402744293,
0.35782667994499207,
-0.055869538336992264,
-0.19830496609210968,
-0.3553692698478699,
0.06879225373268127,
0.1921401470899582,
0.2584555447101593,
-0.17645849287509918,
0.4089793860912323,
0.12624146044254303,
0.4862922728061676,
1.1856008768081665,
0.46552836894989014,
0.5164107084274292,
-0.4789053499698639,
0.7483084797859192,
0.18632951378822327,
0.48895755410194397,
-0.8318079113960266,
-0.42615243792533875,
-0.15711814165115356,
-0.9133749008178711,
-0.0138204051181674,
0.4576663076877594,
-1.1465716361999512,
-0.4086124300956726,
-0.09245789051055908,
-0.3140396177768707,
-0.5093926191329956,
0.1038236916065216,
0.009366215206682682,
0.48317813873291016,
0.26838818192481995,
-0.38782328367233276,
-0.2451428472995758,
-0.9529335498809814,
-0.06956246495246887,
0.29026177525520325,
-0.10320191830396652,
0.4577505588531494,
0.3912607431411743,
-0.4934975504875183,
0.725525975227356,
-0.20098309218883514,
-0.2588912546634674,
0.1567980945110321,
0.4845028221607208,
0.2885139286518097,
0.20269176363945007,
0.9135833382606506,
-0.8042587041854858,
-0.3438723087310791,
-0.32784223556518555,
-0.7764738202095032,
-0.03615870699286461,
-0.719127893447876,
-0.21036556363105774,
0.18646275997161865,
0.4011746644973755,
-0.642200231552124,
0.5000516772270203,
0.24711626768112183,
-0.1253749281167984,
0.6243531703948975,
-0.2776390612125397,
0.5012830495834351,
-0.9696491956710815,
-0.14652864634990692,
0.15569275617599487,
-0.07755540311336517,
-0.3740803599357605,
0.32910647988319397,
-0.1434776335954666,
-0.3207426071166992,
-0.5755562782287598,
0.34600573778152466,
-0.6674336791038513,
-0.217118039727211,
-0.3054061830043793,
0.09622786939144135,
0.15674851834774017,
0.22852803766727448,
-0.39827290177345276,
1.0787382125854492,
0.8246693015098572,
-0.45827463269233704,
0.6342164278030396,
0.10705328732728958,
-0.07528217136859894,
1.0281596183776855,
-0.6686842441558838,
0.35376885533332825,
-0.31549856066703796,
0.35094818472862244,
-1.1451926231384277,
-0.31097209453582764,
0.6241993308067322,
-0.27406108379364014,
0.2827170789241791,
-0.2251279056072235,
-0.47682878375053406,
-0.3360447287559509,
-0.8041852712631226,
0.5318390727043152,
0.3412880301475525,
-0.7872746586799622,
0.7759451866149902,
0.10291176289319992,
-0.15617182850837708,
-0.631668210029602,
-0.5966783165931702,
0.8202215433120728,
-0.6693492531776428,
-0.8489493727684021,
0.3092905580997467,
-0.12087684869766235,
-0.31091997027397156,
-0.0259020384401083,
0.20833079516887665,
0.26228761672973633,
-0.00992496032267809,
0.2409331500530243,
0.8635701537132263,
-0.13835297524929047,
-0.33017197251319885,
-0.35377129912376404,
-0.21801678836345673,
0.15237149596214294,
-0.5040638446807861,
0.19976945221424103,
-0.1437019258737564,
-0.7469152212142944,
-0.8141395449638367,
0.550156831741333,
0.851529061794281,
-0.16915147006511688,
0.19831764698028564,
0.6416649222373962,
-0.1313236504793167,
-0.02629230171442032,
-0.46173545718193054,
-0.3359365463256836,
-0.6303584575653076,
-0.056806910783052444,
-0.37272387742996216,
-0.3331742286682129,
0.38420283794403076,
-0.10203169286251068,
0.20658381283283234,
0.2306406944990158,
0.7949434518814087,
-0.17187879979610443,
1.0524390935897827,
0.26752641797065735,
0.11257783323526382,
0.34884679317474365,
-0.3685024380683899,
0.20224176347255707,
-0.30781611800193787,
-0.39665114879608154,
0.09199973195791245,
-0.6469443440437317,
-0.518420934677124,
-0.6770442128181458,
0.933276891708374,
-0.1870163232088089,
-0.16007842123508453,
0.014169723726809025,
-0.4044630229473114,
0.4027232229709625,
1.0359843969345093,
0.2549499273300171,
0.24604789912700653,
0.2397468239068985,
-0.025275371968746185,
-0.15740905702114105,
-0.4116680324077606,
-0.6440779566764832,
1.2456903457641602,
0.28755104541778564,
1.036738634109497,
0.11328853666782379,
0.5620453357696533,
0.8450301885604858,
0.13760808110237122,
-0.7699275016784668,
0.4489099681377411,
0.24673479795455933,
-0.21329627931118011,
0.173737034201622,
-0.010492818430066109,
-0.8948633074760437,
0.028737302869558334,
-0.5390347242355347,
-0.42449644207954407,
0.2976216971874237,
0.2607871890068054,
-0.49394044280052185,
0.14108158648014069,
-0.647373616695404,
0.6704794764518738,
-0.7167682647705078,
-0.5341998934745789,
-0.331401526927948,
-0.5230472683906555,
0.4050367772579193,
-0.15364821255207062,
0.40086236596107483,
0.06638094782829285,
-0.33574655652046204,
0.3016233444213867,
-0.18387727439403534,
1.0175938606262207,
-0.08850888907909393,
0.14306029677391052,
0.4847642183303833,
0.20438076555728912,
0.5092462301254272,
0.09682897478342056,
0.4648285508155823,
0.01586255058646202,
-0.10193607956171036,
-0.5068569183349609,
-0.49429139494895935,
0.46216249465942383,
-0.7968324422836304,
-0.654057502746582,
-0.26175862550735474,
-0.43443331122398376,
0.2573060095310211,
0.05385749787092209,
0.3281036615371704,
0.5552581548690796,
0.0529480054974556,
-0.060556452721357346,
0.19408784806728363,
-0.31893646717071533,
0.620839536190033,
-0.037019167095422745,
-0.018371619284152985,
-0.7676064372062683,
0.9191994071006775,
0.04336434230208397,
0.2734694480895996,
-0.12223115563392639,
-0.0494065098464489,
-0.5178151726722717,
-0.39841437339782715,
-0.7102612257003784,
-0.12032213807106018,
-0.9486311674118042,
-0.5133658051490784,
-0.4163396656513214,
0.1349593847990036,
-0.1371385008096695,
-0.5403517484664917,
-0.18394020199775696,
-0.08116243034601212,
-0.4718078076839447,
-0.024350805208086967,
0.4025338590145111,
0.7857392430305481,
-0.25290295481681824,
0.34904152154922485,
-0.8556798100471497,
0.4938361346721649,
0.7053061723709106,
-0.1543864607810974,
0.01691342703998089,
-0.32082289457321167,
0.23042058944702148,
0.10173162072896957,
-0.7206104397773743,
-1.160405158996582,
0.47882989048957825,
0.03639189898967743,
0.5892572999000549,
0.6875649094581604,
0.1371619552373886,
0.7188424468040466,
-0.38557496666908264,
1.026933193206787,
0.5894245505332947,
-0.8688411712646484,
0.4909404516220093,
-0.3966872990131378,
0.034172698855400085,
0.13457973301410675,
0.5224210023880005,
-0.2058981955051422,
-0.14640140533447266,
-0.6501907110214233,
-0.9748501777648926,
0.3754025101661682,
0.13159248232841492,
0.3833921253681183,
0.0007479109335690737,
0.07936377078294754,
0.05134330317378044,
0.23444731533527374,
-0.8184984922409058,
0.024470629170536995,
-0.6936150193214417,
0.01480432040989399,
0.6449542045593262,
-0.10957827419042587,
-0.5451385974884033,
0.1575796753168106,
0.31423264741897583,
-0.3606187701225281,
0.3163323998451233,
0.20928752422332764,
-0.07740501314401627,
0.2933137118816376,
0.11058193445205688,
0.3991386890411377,
0.4021986126899719,
0.15253379940986633,
0.30486947298049927,
-0.17976602911949158,
-0.0901959016919136,
0.10857176035642624,
-0.12409061193466187,
-0.3295266032218933,
-0.2213985025882721,
0.11123692244291306,
0.7795054912567139,
-0.02551249973475933,
-0.7338918447494507,
0.7740463614463806,
0.08108852058649063,
-0.41029220819473267,
-0.3184809982776642,
-0.33081066608428955,
-0.15896090865135193,
0.7582775950431824,
0.5112561583518982,
0.3657814562320709,
0.29592907428741455,
-0.716376006603241,
0.40415289998054504,
0.6727344989776611,
0.09920428693294525,
-0.5709803104400635,
0.866418182849884,
0.11351168900728226,
-0.004923671949654818,
0.7113723754882812,
-0.34707123041152954,
-0.5259255766868591,
0.6290103197097778,
0.4796381890773773,
0.5825195908546448,
0.334078848361969,
0.2973690629005432,
0.21692408621311188,
0.5614874362945557,
-0.07759584486484528,
0.33480900526046753,
0.030063889920711517,
-0.6064510345458984,
-0.1562408059835434,
-0.009449223056435585,
-0.5317463278770447,
-0.03387985751032829,
-0.36244890093803406,
0.6265711188316345,
-0.714623749256134,
-0.4430767595767975,
0.009638527408242226,
-0.6549201607704163,
-0.7951318621635437,
-0.11622675508260727,
0.7330524921417236,
0.5950679183006287,
-0.5447285175323486,
0.34288275241851807,
0.5265249013900757,
-0.7171195149421692,
-0.56242436170578,
-0.09314391016960144,
0.3433877229690552,
-1.1239136457443237,
0.6447624564170837,
0.44885560870170593,
-0.10664340853691101,
-0.15021765232086182,
-0.9661867618560791,
-0.6478482484817505,
1.1227470636367798,
0.26997387409210205,
-0.324005663394928,
0.1073453277349472,
-0.11400271207094193,
0.056587494909763336,
-0.5547853708267212,
0.21816323697566986,
0.2879053056240082,
0.6246881484985352,
0.5401391983032227,
-0.2961999177932739,
0.07446863502264023,
-0.34715431928634644,
-0.10468918085098267,
-0.20418843626976013,
-0.4606361985206604,
0.8019884824752808,
-0.5989108085632324,
-0.4816920757293701,
-0.12324205040931702,
0.4762510657310486,
0.3966444730758667,
0.6113570928573608,
0.7630852460861206,
0.35385894775390625,
0.7727912664413452,
0.18268784880638123,
0.9235929846763611,
-0.35444778203964233,
-0.03262815624475479,
0.6282644271850586,
-0.19649654626846313,
0.588530421257019,
0.6665969491004944,
0.05054076388478279,
0.2360600233078003,
0.8363776206970215,
-0.7254980206489563,
0.8130466938018799,
-0.09628613293170929,
-0.30693042278289795,
-0.23835070431232452,
-0.23535430431365967,
-0.20255476236343384,
0.5166715979576111,
0.33456435799598694,
-0.191142737865448,
-0.23805424571037292,
0.26219362020492554,
-0.23223859071731567,
-0.08734245598316193,
-0.3658027946949005,
0.7049049735069275,
-0.022257639095187187,
-0.19227048754692078,
0.49274182319641113,
-0.03941997140645981,
0.9211419224739075,
-0.4738665521144867,
0.06057807058095932,
-0.020979370921850204,
-0.24164873361587524,
0.03215722367167473,
-0.5639150142669678,
0.21331796050071716,
0.15105123817920685,
0.10216312855482101,
-0.5113281607627869,
0.7248251438140869,
-0.14687283337116241,
-0.5132333040237427,
0.004179293755441904,
0.4155327379703522,
-0.08364436030387878,
-0.1682826727628708,
-0.8928672075271606,
0.12537124752998352,
-0.1457982063293457,
-0.16707924008369446,
0.1995285302400589,
0.45925238728523254,
-0.0877750813961029,
0.5054004192352295,
0.9449804425239563,
-0.15617471933364868,
0.1927601397037506,
-0.11052227020263672,
1.0573002099990845,
-0.5392491817474365,
-0.6580950021743774,
-0.9652402400970459,
0.49346432089805603,
-0.36215344071388245,
0.07037752121686935,
0.6147050261497498,
0.13257311284542084,
0.5617683529853821,
-0.13583096861839294,
0.8901601433753967,
0.27822011709213257,
-0.2800329029560089,
-0.648977518081665,
0.4350300133228302,
-0.6731097102165222,
0.4510587453842163,
-0.11749640852212906,
-0.4598903954029083,
-0.09590726345777512,
0.21121375262737274,
-0.15906280279159546,
-0.2824692130088806,
0.3683302402496338,
1.0596290826797485,
-0.12383119761943817,
0.04908077418804169,
0.1788015514612198,
-0.07079081237316132,
0.46708109974861145,
0.23908400535583496,
1.1580077409744263,
-0.14343945682048798,
0.7562648057937622,
-0.08727896958589554,
-0.2793886363506317,
-0.0612252913415432,
-1.2016321420669556,
-0.739184558391571,
-0.3944939970970154,
-0.19889730215072632,
-0.3506276607513428,
-0.13593485951423645,
0.9134095907211304,
0.5906937718391418,
-0.32961857318878174,
0.15049944818019867,
0.48799633979797363,
-0.2183259129524231,
-0.1446482539176941,
-0.22833310067653656,
0.21806824207305908,
-0.24559436738491058,
-0.5876619219779968,
0.30770623683929443,
0.6869698762893677,
0.3326157033443451,
-0.36293044686317444,
0.10258866101503372,
0.18126243352890015,
0.32834339141845703,
0.5762438774108887,
0.07246033847332001,
-0.7713501453399658,
-0.13843625783920288,
0.28140437602996826,
-0.04338472709059715,
0.26230552792549133,
0.8283172249794006,
-0.6085044741630554,
0.46882325410842896,
0.28538778424263,
0.9160671234130859,
0.21792632341384888,
0.15982000529766083,
0.5744012594223022,
-0.6639076471328735,
0.3024303615093231,
-0.03401152789592743,
0.37928369641304016,
0.5319676995277405,
-0.44622719287872314,
0.08167009800672531,
0.5473323464393616,
-0.19902221858501434,
-0.6645285487174988,
0.18210332095623016,
-1.1097311973571777,
-0.3386255204677582,
0.8499122262001038,
-0.10173793882131577,
-0.29998260736465454,
0.14877451956272125,
-0.40088677406311035,
-0.2366025745868683,
-0.6213719844818115,
0.9860577583312988,
0.3972987234592438,
0.19590574502944946,
-0.2512715458869934,
-0.523087203502655,
-0.0065465099178254604,
-0.08939803391695023,
-0.7028086185455322,
-0.3445374667644501,
0.9227941036224365,
0.02196951024234295,
0.23517444729804993,
0.5776351690292358,
-0.2182624787092209,
0.3165073096752167,
0.26764732599258423,
-0.17714840173721313,
-0.25905731320381165,
-0.38788026571273804,
-0.11614653468132019,
0.47443994879722595,
0.019662750884890556,
-0.5498577356338501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13781v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13781v1
|
Evaluating Retrieval Quality in Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-04-21T21:22:28 | 2024-04-21T21:22:28 |
Alireza Salemi, Hamed Zamani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Evaluating retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) presents challenges,
particularly for retrieval models within these systems. Traditional end-to-end
evaluation methods are computationally expensive. Furthermore, evaluation of
the retrieval model's performance based on query-document relevance labels
shows a small correlation with the RAG system's downstream performance. We
propose a novel evaluation approach, eRAG, where each document in the retrieval
list is individually utilized by the large language model within the RAG
system. The output generated for each document is then evaluated based on the
downstream task ground truth labels. In this manner, the downstream performance
for each document serves as its relevance label. We employ various downstream
task metrics to obtain document-level annotations and aggregate them using
set-based or ranking metrics. Extensive experiments on a wide range of datasets
demonstrate that eRAG achieves a higher correlation with downstream RAG
performance compared to baseline methods, with improvements in Kendall's $\tau$
correlation ranging from 0.168 to 0.494. Additionally, eRAG offers significant
computational advantages, improving runtime and consuming up to 50 times less
GPU memory than end-to-end evaluation.
|
[
-0.538422167301178,
-0.7405700087547302,
0.3638027012348175,
-0.17720940709114075,
-0.39162784814834595,
0.21039935946464539,
-0.18095390498638153,
-0.36397626996040344,
0.16401882469654083,
0.43439289927482605,
-0.2128954827785492,
-0.3201884329319,
-0.6090521812438965,
0.022752931341528893,
-0.42873984575271606,
0.8832395076751709,
0.2449694275856018,
-0.170321524143219,
-0.2782995402812958,
-0.1890876591205597,
-0.40529751777648926,
-0.3730810880661011,
-0.609980583190918,
-0.4498794972896576,
0.30522575974464417,
0.16540847718715668,
0.5517961382865906,
0.7308922410011292,
0.6286507248878479,
0.25135329365730286,
-0.19006843864917755,
0.5325577259063721,
-0.776435136795044,
0.475187748670578,
-0.2696813941001892,
-0.002724266843870282,
-0.4531100392341614,
0.19925448298454285,
0.58741295337677,
0.5629425644874573,
-0.07221392542123795,
0.6656027436256409,
0.1994291990995407,
0.8071231245994568,
-1.0031663179397583,
-0.30313554406166077,
-0.6423516869544983,
-0.06953833252191544,
-0.3237212300300598,
-0.6981359124183655,
-0.7336859703063965,
-0.20672214031219482,
-0.07208091765642166,
-0.8201906681060791,
0.4547843933105469,
0.5143470168113708,
1.0896601676940918,
0.2464730441570282,
-0.24489054083824158,
-0.40327268838882446,
-0.6915746927261353,
0.6921728849411011,
-0.4810340702533722,
0.6047214865684509,
0.5428945422172546,
0.29435089230537415,
-0.228111132979393,
-0.8452330231666565,
-0.2743156850337982,
-0.27673420310020447,
-0.06490430235862732,
0.5788248777389526,
0.0302437637001276,
-0.08095115423202515,
0.18513548374176025,
0.7297869920730591,
-0.5669847726821899,
-0.22193391621112823,
-0.04546704515814781,
0.09171170741319656,
0.5462132692337036,
-0.025872688740491867,
0.13448631763458252,
-0.5032448768615723,
-0.4905853569507599,
-0.12857821583747864,
-0.5530200004577637,
-0.24846753478050232,
0.4314196705818176,
0.5178142189979553,
0.5235236883163452,
0.5310819745063782,
-0.2020883411169052,
0.8869594931602478,
0.344204306602478,
-0.08754895627498627,
0.25051331520080566,
-0.39743492007255554,
-0.14206810295581818,
-0.315273642539978,
0.49239015579223633,
0.35733017325401306,
-0.3897482752799988,
-0.38212835788726807,
-0.49687182903289795,
-0.4453723430633545,
0.6169127821922302,
-0.7838246822357178,
0.16863490641117096,
-0.03984059765934944,
-0.6691402196884155,
-0.059758249670267105,
-0.01076257973909378,
-0.9371008276939392,
-0.4628652334213257,
-0.46519774198532104,
0.9276516437530518,
-0.4916822016239166,
-0.05533883720636368,
-0.47387436032295227,
-0.4255779981613159,
0.31539419293403625,
0.1252817064523697,
-0.6154191493988037,
0.2637607753276825,
0.7742372155189514,
0.7302334308624268,
-0.049532558768987656,
0.05588645488023758,
-1.0286757946014404,
0.03561915084719658,
-0.5026365518569946,
0.9731747508049011,
-0.7165108323097229,
-0.7365654706954956,
-0.19415634870529175,
-0.34487348794937134,
-0.1304216980934143,
-0.6852465271949768,
0.8230231404304504,
-0.9528302550315857,
0.09851254522800446,
-0.23955214023590088,
-0.7180421948432922,
-0.013161415234208107,
0.18342849612236023,
-0.5591033697128296,
1.513261079788208,
0.4722093343734741,
-0.680927574634552,
0.7349133491516113,
-0.22414179146289825,
-0.4396977722644806,
0.5034582018852234,
-0.08651202917098999,
-0.1816568225622177,
0.36819255352020264,
0.2353905439376831,
0.08921026438474655,
-0.689494788646698,
0.055919475853443146,
0.01098957285284996,
-0.591923713684082,
-0.1891394406557083,
-0.2701903283596039,
0.4635230302810669,
0.5233994126319885,
-0.07703592628240585,
-0.28356805443763733,
-0.8331044912338257,
0.19654962420463562,
-0.1916845291852951,
-0.48093029856681824,
-0.7303363680839539,
-0.06469264626502991,
-0.20224407315254211,
-0.1180674135684967,
0.36367806792259216,
-0.6230471730232239,
0.033881887793540955,
-0.17580851912498474,
-0.370279997587204,
0.5989536643028259,
0.2129766047000885,
0.45932069420814514,
-0.4394247829914093,
0.5624744892120361,
-0.6667472124099731,
0.2770691514015198,
-0.1585354506969452,
-0.32794657349586487,
-0.8980437517166138,
-0.13043217360973358,
0.620634138584137,
0.2823418080806732,
-0.8849095106124878,
0.32027795910835266,
-0.45932629704475403,
-0.5476288795471191,
-0.6029463410377502,
0.10947015881538391,
0.6874133348464966,
0.7406765222549438,
0.4378686249256134,
-0.2967982590198517,
-0.3757730722427368,
-0.7150641083717346,
-0.354618638753891,
-0.3513869047164917,
-0.040739379823207855,
0.7166010737419128,
0.21950623393058777,
0.07410566508769989,
0.823974609375,
-0.32195228338241577,
-0.11006050556898117,
0.12882956862449646,
0.5279754996299744,
0.24740272760391235,
0.25329670310020447,
0.31443265080451965,
-0.8103293776512146,
-0.43375837802886963,
0.21577778458595276,
-0.6105867624282837,
-0.44498276710510254,
-0.015900349244475365,
-0.4923454225063324,
0.3255689740180969,
0.4323084354400635,
-0.06806166470050812,
0.4318295121192932,
0.3376013934612274,
-0.371798038482666,
0.6494646668434143,
-0.382330060005188,
0.8049836754798889,
-0.7633697390556335,
0.3898259997367859,
-0.1925712376832962,
-0.07103852927684784,
-0.30699554085731506,
0.476667582988739,
0.031690485775470734,
0.021011030301451683,
-0.05518878996372223,
0.6316460371017456,
-0.6156432628631592,
-0.42355063557624817,
-0.3878292739391327,
0.33660364151000977,
0.25413715839385986,
0.05157267302274704,
-0.333187997341156,
1.1260093450546265,
-0.0339156910777092,
-0.6889670491218567,
0.013018620200455189,
0.05617072060704231,
-0.09319741278886795,
0.7188907265663147,
-0.3503623604774475,
0.3842853307723999,
-0.19925250113010406,
0.09206580370664597,
-0.8616296648979187,
-0.07002554088830948,
-0.29202717542648315,
-0.8867752552032471,
0.7065984010696411,
-0.44910553097724915,
-0.5570667386054993,
-0.16207586228847504,
-0.2895466983318329,
0.14397574961185455,
0.699803352355957,
-0.8036969304084778,
0.9211888313293457,
0.3990475833415985,
-0.06336121261119843,
-0.6297870874404907,
-0.21448944509029388,
0.10747566819190979,
-0.18837903439998627,
-0.5482831597328186,
0.4746703803539276,
0.2785303592681885,
-0.0793323963880539,
0.14514479041099548,
-0.2933012545108795,
0.23705920577049255,
-0.06099493056535721,
0.14548233151435852,
0.2293558120727539,
-0.013759413734078407,
0.2657606601715088,
0.06465192139148712,
-0.1973513513803482,
-0.2451053410768509,
-0.2407979816198349,
0.4716331362724304,
0.16072390973567963,
-0.18901203572750092,
0.5403354167938232,
0.29452279210090637,
0.10481812804937363,
-0.46539998054504395,
0.5678194165229797,
0.7702820301055908,
-0.28525686264038086,
-0.36081838607788086,
-0.6730588674545288,
0.21717654168605804,
-0.4467765986919403,
0.11758967489004135,
-0.6041150093078613,
-0.6221379637718201,
0.5475535988807678,
-0.10916248708963394,
0.2333800345659256,
0.7665898203849792,
0.39267057180404663,
-0.07461735606193542,
0.8511709570884705,
0.3815985918045044,
0.4738348722457886,
0.41441628336906433,
-0.35607844591140747,
0.14334499835968018,
-1.4038379192352295,
-0.3177894353866577,
-0.7517472505569458,
-0.0544995442032814,
-0.555345356464386,
-0.6440973877906799,
0.5972281694412231,
0.7150196433067322,
-0.35237568616867065,
0.2971965968608856,
-0.6865339875221252,
0.16463926434516907,
0.5826514959335327,
0.06583303213119507,
0.4761021137237549,
0.0889013484120369,
-0.15964993834495544,
0.06941037625074387,
-0.7226912975311279,
-0.6862258911132812,
1.351047396659851,
-0.040071193128824234,
0.6319929361343384,
0.24658161401748657,
0.9196707010269165,
0.6856789588928223,
0.8132777214050293,
-0.4779205918312073,
0.5521794557571411,
-0.6921201944351196,
-0.5580265522003174,
-0.1784473955631256,
-0.5915205478668213,
-1.0734331607818604,
0.5660858750343323,
-0.19397397339344025,
-0.6839983463287354,
0.10942714661359787,
-0.014724993146955967,
-0.3384527266025543,
0.06943224370479584,
-0.6639074683189392,
0.27102169394493103,
-0.12947964668273926,
-0.5641844272613525,
-0.2061738669872284,
-0.39348721504211426,
0.2519615888595581,
-0.2529202401638031,
0.299839049577713,
-0.021500857546925545,
-0.1767905354499817,
0.8851520419120789,
-0.48623064160346985,
-0.04267767816781998,
-0.15791481733322144,
0.15417349338531494,
0.5346130132675171,
0.14505892992019653,
0.2359907478094101,
-0.11654441803693771,
-0.46887877583503723,
-0.1974591612815857,
-0.1747654527425766,
-0.13835757970809937,
-0.642648458480835,
0.8962125182151794,
-0.5899960398674011,
-0.5893274545669556,
-0.44410568475723267,
-0.4018668830394745,
-0.24512237310409546,
0.21067573130130768,
0.4316036105155945,
0.6187812089920044,
-0.08954712748527527,
0.06706814467906952,
0.466330349445343,
-0.5282599925994873,
0.2885691821575165,
0.4565933644771576,
-0.5677198767662048,
-0.6163517236709595,
1.090988278388977,
0.4251915216445923,
0.3996348977088928,
0.3227482736110687,
0.19321449100971222,
-0.5699701905250549,
-0.44220343232154846,
-0.7440066933631897,
0.0913386270403862,
-0.8262186646461487,
-0.4522955119609833,
-0.6486009359359741,
-0.1994420289993286,
-0.4712214767932892,
0.01548220869153738,
-0.2643698453903198,
-0.31609028577804565,
-0.08027045428752899,
0.20862524211406708,
0.3675250709056854,
0.6168505549430847,
-0.2237187772989273,
0.0868598073720932,
-0.8781805634498596,
0.5579736828804016,
0.2048529088497162,
0.612898051738739,
0.1401025801897049,
-1.015832543373108,
-0.33376020193099976,
-0.26050275564193726,
-0.36847347021102905,
-0.7557684183120728,
0.3183576166629791,
0.33492106199264526,
0.7186598181724548,
-0.08036530017852783,
0.11583679914474487,
0.9454095363616943,
-0.5188633799552917,
0.7346367239952087,
-0.21086083352565765,
-0.7687216401100159,
0.5355990529060364,
-0.39489424228668213,
0.013958021067082882,
0.7650175094604492,
0.09177333861589432,
-0.18569624423980713,
-0.2194904386997223,
-0.6727875471115112,
-1.4391106367111206,
0.5769244432449341,
0.2541595995426178,
-0.12137125432491302,
-0.27487364411354065,
0.5005413889884949,
0.030953455716371536,
-0.058553002774715424,
-0.02032819762825966,
-0.35269421339035034,
0.1023915633559227,
0.16461049020290375,
0.305447518825531,
-0.24087707698345184,
0.07738542556762695,
0.040074873715639114,
0.9197239875793457,
0.06487171351909637,
0.24232541024684906,
0.38465628027915955,
-0.24920092523097992,
-0.21225541830062866,
0.2769548296928406,
-0.07201927900314331,
0.7136284708976746,
-0.615240216255188,
-0.03458886221051216,
0.09269826114177704,
-0.44048139452934265,
0.17892493307590485,
0.3890376687049866,
-0.3835563063621521,
0.24095390737056732,
0.32113412022590637,
0.5437787175178528,
-0.05120699480175972,
-0.4553092122077942,
0.2351549118757248,
0.028943456709384918,
0.18636386096477509,
-0.2131667584180832,
-0.12075955420732498,
-0.3203386664390564,
0.013737601228058338,
0.9146723747253418,
-0.2823302149772644,
0.6160800457000732,
-0.408701092004776,
0.3666965067386627,
0.25921303033828735,
-0.06534604728221893,
0.23019495606422424,
0.6722153425216675,
0.22436995804309845,
-0.3114730715751648,
0.5950807929039001,
-0.5305672287940979,
-0.39594390988349915,
0.5321391820907593,
0.46066051721572876,
0.8931585550308228,
-0.1372785121202469,
-0.01694512367248535,
0.6177481412887573,
0.20092304050922394,
0.06352201104164124,
0.17416760325431824,
-0.0877109244465828,
-0.35016998648643494,
-0.7331735491752625,
-1.1782981157302856,
-0.3255999684333801,
-0.07907100766897202,
-0.8852940201759338,
-0.017640842124819756,
-0.10015685111284256,
-0.6201616525650024,
-0.03261740878224373,
0.024497123435139656,
-0.6718617081642151,
0.30983081459999084,
-0.057985249906778336,
0.780014157295227,
-0.4383609890937805,
0.14510302245616913,
0.7506890296936035,
-0.5739728212356567,
-0.6327767372131348,
-0.0861409530043602,
-0.32954004406929016,
-0.5114774107933044,
0.972850501537323,
0.07222387194633484,
-0.34307020902633667,
0.08632086217403412,
-0.021714109927415848,
-1.0177963972091675,
1.1541672945022583,
0.04037203639745712,
-0.31131455302238464,
0.2306951880455017,
-0.3655742406845093,
0.5825955271720886,
-0.2116711139678955,
0.7302734851837158,
0.6660435199737549,
0.39878615736961365,
0.03897169977426529,
-1.0352333784103394,
-0.12623146176338196,
-0.41177064180374146,
0.3198479115962982,
0.5748401880264282,
-0.6406314969062805,
0.6375536918640137,
0.04208352044224739,
-0.6558825373649597,
0.04115067794919014,
0.6524581909179688,
0.5262436866760254,
0.4550042450428009,
0.5343931317329407,
0.9680269360542297,
0.5359552502632141,
-0.19857153296470642,
1.3786529302597046,
-0.425826758146286,
0.5912389159202576,
1.1262636184692383,
-0.23508861660957336,
0.9612680077552795,
0.3229939341545105,
-0.27109402418136597,
0.15760844945907593,
0.5253751873970032,
0.27095121145248413,
0.3673856854438782,
0.26779329776763916,
-0.3297666609287262,
-0.08777350187301636,
-0.4997898042201996,
-0.23325644433498383,
0.14313474297523499,
0.4083090126514435,
-0.44096481800079346,
-0.4691300690174103,
-0.17891748249530792,
-0.19290411472320557,
0.295461505651474,
-0.4244441092014313,
0.7978640794754028,
-0.11406540125608444,
-0.9584620594978333,
0.7256986498832703,
-0.06515870988368988,
0.540595531463623,
-0.24434277415275574,
-0.31391453742980957,
-0.36950644850730896,
0.017656587064266205,
-0.29058459401130676,
-0.6111058592796326,
0.2620792090892792,
0.25745075941085815,
-0.13554981350898743,
-0.20805208384990692,
0.8242092728614807,
-0.18491233885288239,
-0.4187765419483185,
0.40149492025375366,
0.5346531867980957,
0.16098777949810028,
0.09488442540168762,
-0.4349154531955719,
0.14025260508060455,
-0.22148767113685608,
-0.49209800362586975,
0.36252546310424805,
0.34814804792404175,
-0.02004639431834221,
0.48380520939826965,
0.6721327900886536,
0.17189696431159973,
0.23925913870334625,
0.42051735520362854,
0.884774923324585,
-0.37242117524147034,
-0.17540554702281952,
-0.36383968591690063,
0.42857545614242554,
-0.177678182721138,
-0.34351417422294617,
0.8868884444236755,
0.8082823753356934,
0.6933215856552124,
0.3939136266708374,
0.7090768218040466,
-0.4768758714199066,
0.8443025350570679,
-0.47768837213516235,
0.6535560488700867,
-0.6831462979316711,
0.3880005180835724,
-0.19349652528762817,
-1.1380422115325928,
0.07949573546648026,
0.46104609966278076,
-0.24330611526966095,
0.3507547676563263,
0.5208368301391602,
0.6259980797767639,
0.0704435259103775,
-0.21117717027664185,
0.3096316158771515,
-0.13263079524040222,
0.3379233479499817,
0.20094268023967743,
0.7040234804153442,
-0.6743997931480408,
0.4492267668247223,
-0.09448964893817902,
-0.4987836480140686,
-0.1273256093263626,
-0.7568668723106384,
-0.35281890630722046,
-0.612812876701355,
-0.07389207929372787,
-0.6228156089782715,
0.3769584894180298,
0.6201767325401306,
0.6631782054901123,
-0.32918041944503784,
-0.0030408911406993866,
0.2619730532169342,
-0.351910263299942,
-0.02611282281577587,
-0.2968387305736542,
0.5936844348907471,
-0.7473305463790894,
-0.6444047689437866,
0.3887369930744171,
0.2899852693080902,
-0.4164241850376129,
-0.1475331038236618,
-0.0417192243039608,
-0.34967294335365295,
0.0002246362273581326,
0.7357454299926758,
0.12520645558834076,
-0.5781441330909729,
-0.2920903265476227,
0.05085078626871109,
0.007230984978377819,
-0.13811425864696503,
0.6598464846611023,
-0.9563807249069214,
0.8095053434371948,
0.7376344799995422,
0.9790824055671692,
0.7626400589942932,
0.7361932396888733,
0.44546517729759216,
-0.809780478477478,
-0.2528502643108368,
0.3945467472076416,
0.1434633433818817,
0.39299702644348145,
-0.4214499294757843,
0.8571420907974243,
0.04056747257709503,
-0.8956676125526428,
-0.7130094766616821,
-0.04585041478276253,
-0.7120718359947205,
-0.09370215982198715,
1.2735276222229004,
-0.21009229123592377,
-0.07431616634130478,
0.005809847731143236,
0.024686863645911217,
0.5005208253860474,
-0.45665302872657776,
0.6066304445266724,
0.564462423324585,
-0.27982011437416077,
0.007748839445412159,
-0.835816502571106,
0.17247717082500458,
0.3559044599533081,
-0.6463319063186646,
0.004877896048128605,
0.7856346964836121,
-0.017733518034219742,
0.4164709448814392,
0.6305242776870728,
-0.45263051986694336,
0.2533718943595886,
0.14068499207496643,
0.15866908431053162,
-0.10709492117166519,
-0.14777913689613342,
-0.20928582549095154,
0.13485053181648254,
0.20651847124099731,
-0.1656406968832016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13779v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13779v1
|
Automated Text Mining of Experimental Methodologies from Biomedical Literature
| 2024-04-21T21:19:36 | 2024-04-21T21:19:36 |
Ziqing Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Biomedical literature is a rapidly expanding field of science and technology.
Classification of biomedical texts is an essential part of biomedicine
research, especially in the field of biology. This work proposes the fine-tuned
DistilBERT, a methodology-specific, pre-trained generative classification
language model for mining biomedicine texts. The model has proven its
effectiveness in linguistic understanding capabilities and has reduced the size
of BERT models by 40\% but by 60\% faster. The main objective of this project
is to improve the model and assess the performance of the model compared to the
non-fine-tuned model. We used DistilBert as a support model and pre-trained on
a corpus of 32,000 abstracts and complete text articles; our results were
impressive and surpassed those of traditional literature classification methods
by using RNN or LSTM. Our aim is to integrate this highly specialised and
specific model into different research industries.
|
[
0.004118714947253466,
-0.7570249438285828,
0.5589216947555542,
0.10658764839172363,
-0.3706192374229431,
-0.015594051219522953,
-0.08897176384925842,
-0.6358901858329773,
0.11719676107168198,
0.36998051404953003,
-0.3178078532218933,
-0.7332136631011963,
-0.647357702255249,
0.5827213525772095,
-0.6282367706298828,
1.2150033712387085,
0.1367332935333252,
0.43888750672340393,
-0.1285509318113327,
-0.14429771900177002,
0.1179276555776596,
-0.4652916491031647,
-0.3451460897922516,
-0.5404289960861206,
0.7598153352737427,
-0.07215438783168793,
0.41316747665405273,
0.5477078557014465,
0.7356259226799011,
0.44377657771110535,
-0.48647043108940125,
0.12408019602298737,
-0.4966549277305603,
0.05198369920253754,
-0.42411333322525024,
-0.5886115431785583,
-0.4592907130718231,
-0.036723122000694275,
0.2671401798725128,
0.8679125905036926,
-0.19058018922805786,
0.25390660762786865,
0.28179800510406494,
0.5785765051841736,
-0.10858655720949173,
0.26118868589401245,
-0.43212199211120605,
0.09007620066404343,
-0.3084706962108612,
-0.32928889989852905,
-0.492007851600647,
-0.4571757912635803,
0.24671614170074463,
-0.38722753524780273,
0.5295019745826721,
-0.010175534524023533,
0.7168189287185669,
0.2907346785068512,
-0.1743353009223938,
-0.3545902967453003,
-0.4456120431423187,
0.7006282210350037,
-0.7640828490257263,
0.008813940919935703,
0.35291194915771484,
0.14117595553398132,
-0.44009360671043396,
-1.1039783954620361,
-0.1779198944568634,
-0.4716293513774872,
-0.48384615778923035,
-0.09200374037027359,
-0.1394934356212616,
0.46072471141815186,
0.16276174783706665,
0.5309296250343323,
-0.5758835673332214,
0.2374979704618454,
-0.7587053179740906,
-0.15219180285930634,
0.5950953960418701,
0.10036752372980118,
0.14968043565750122,
-0.22987252473831177,
-0.006803698837757111,
0.040077224373817444,
-0.14339454472064972,
-0.22940196096897125,
0.031840793788433075,
0.15930692851543427,
0.31895798444747925,
0.48696792125701904,
-0.3483614921569824,
0.7408110499382019,
-0.016798166558146477,
0.011206437833607197,
0.4803893268108368,
-0.4254228472709656,
-0.33093056082725525,
0.2432599812746048,
0.8391963839530945,
0.02208225429058075,
-0.12077430635690689,
-0.05777764320373535,
-0.09183494746685028,
-0.03878089040517807,
0.454607218503952,
-0.9789919257164001,
-0.5440347790718079,
0.15354162454605103,
-0.7209470868110657,
-0.7503803372383118,
-0.32879745960235596,
-0.4889666736125946,
-0.3214222192764282,
-0.26018989086151123,
0.30360761284828186,
-0.8376408219337463,
-0.1932154893875122,
0.27662187814712524,
-0.10511919856071472,
-0.1670360416173935,
0.3556941747665405,
-0.5756133794784546,
0.1113734096288681,
0.39548537135124207,
1.088644027709961,
-0.05647190287709236,
-0.11669038236141205,
-0.17732012271881104,
-0.020818140357732773,
-0.09224649518728256,
0.7390312552452087,
-0.366438627243042,
-0.4228072762489319,
-0.1479853391647339,
0.17910663783550262,
0.19397662580013275,
-0.45648330450057983,
0.803582489490509,
-0.5512431263923645,
0.006946191191673279,
0.0303109809756279,
-0.825105607509613,
-0.25774070620536804,
0.18405835330486298,
-0.7734304666519165,
0.6984689831733704,
0.2645248472690582,
-1.0085947513580322,
0.40260645747184753,
-0.7888814806938171,
-0.5811728835105896,
0.3759724497795105,
-0.0736958235502243,
-0.5021626949310303,
0.20654872059822083,
-0.1209491640329361,
0.612210214138031,
-0.25517359375953674,
0.5032442212104797,
-0.36432498693466187,
-0.377840131521225,
0.29045629501342773,
-0.061439692974090576,
1.0491701364517212,
0.45190590620040894,
-0.07460720092058182,
0.07970486581325531,
-0.8014132976531982,
0.08085712045431137,
-0.2655413746833801,
-0.39977970719337463,
-0.8167111277580261,
-0.0445106066763401,
0.3907282054424286,
-0.2063179910182953,
0.16314376890659332,
-0.6963138580322266,
0.3363509178161621,
-0.6712165474891663,
0.7242337465286255,
0.3117605447769165,
-0.17054034769535065,
0.34420445561408997,
-0.31400248408317566,
0.17383353412151337,
-0.11438798159360886,
0.15782728791236877,
0.008670558221638203,
-0.25009432435035706,
-0.3374636173248291,
-0.6243507862091064,
0.8486484289169312,
0.35211271047592163,
-0.5132555365562439,
0.7156107425689697,
0.03834839537739754,
-0.8043266534805298,
-0.8213268518447876,
-0.11176446825265884,
0.20893195271492004,
0.5119038224220276,
0.53667813539505,
-0.24075812101364136,
-0.5506002306938171,
-0.9574549198150635,
0.04576755315065384,
-0.19168438017368317,
-0.04129524901509285,
-0.1498946249485016,
0.47012263536453247,
-0.7624578475952148,
0.9474126100540161,
-0.6133316159248352,
-0.29496073722839355,
-0.2583317458629608,
0.6446893811225891,
0.5005068182945251,
0.5298759937286377,
0.792125403881073,
-0.8646863698959351,
-0.32200971245765686,
0.20870712399482727,
-0.8366763591766357,
-0.48630550503730774,
0.2745119035243988,
-0.11741035431623459,
-0.0947520062327385,
0.7446265816688538,
-0.35572510957717896,
0.37483105063438416,
0.34440675377845764,
-0.10400152951478958,
0.4914761185646057,
-0.6008355617523193,
0.4656759202480316,
-1.0099178552627563,
0.3425014615058899,
0.11738051474094391,
-0.32415157556533813,
-0.659120500087738,
-0.026641687378287315,
0.09267459809780121,
0.26131489872932434,
-0.25838780403137207,
0.3590793013572693,
-0.3817839026451111,
0.5530469417572021,
-0.3884274363517761,
-0.5079477429389954,
0.029572928324341774,
0.05437754467129707,
0.14625513553619385,
0.3617725074291229,
0.42647576332092285,
-0.7682984471321106,
0.3930651843547821,
0.3633602261543274,
-0.4769188165664673,
0.24700574576854706,
-0.8452568650245667,
-0.33066490292549133,
-0.34648048877716064,
0.25253990292549133,
-0.7147607803344727,
-0.16754664480686188,
-0.18780720233917236,
-0.37357059121131897,
0.4537367820739746,
0.04450079798698425,
-0.6524332165718079,
-0.4388766884803772,
-0.21616029739379883,
0.2872317433357239,
0.6183890104293823,
-0.2459293156862259,
0.3766182065010071,
0.36716365814208984,
-0.484570175409317,
-0.3299744427204132,
-0.5961960554122925,
-0.2869822084903717,
-0.1652902364730835,
-0.1961435228586197,
0.7342904806137085,
-0.022417010739445686,
-0.12275460362434387,
0.11388478428125381,
0.18140609562397003,
-0.4328401982784271,
0.01220809854567051,
0.09634070843458176,
0.2934902310371399,
0.028362544253468513,
0.4576784074306488,
0.5827509760856628,
0.13038699328899384,
-0.09542689472436905,
-0.06846486032009125,
0.2735535800457001,
0.16072602570056915,
-0.04365840554237366,
-0.2309390753507614,
0.14383113384246826,
0.6195765137672424,
0.020936354994773865,
0.6824910640716553,
0.6438157558441162,
-0.2090156525373459,
-0.04457426443696022,
-0.33092617988586426,
-0.346218079328537,
-0.43655720353126526,
0.7839443683624268,
0.07322695851325989,
-0.7341554760932922,
0.33845528960227966,
-0.44745784997940063,
0.03832445666193962,
0.49119237065315247,
0.5303966403007507,
-0.35736045241355896,
0.785053551197052,
0.8322394490242004,
-0.14515848457813263,
0.2814323902130127,
-0.16067178547382355,
-0.1877475380897522,
-0.3976186513900757,
-0.2028769552707672,
-0.841755747795105,
-0.39744317531585693,
-0.5497506856918335,
-0.3787485361099243,
0.5141494870185852,
0.11221220344305038,
0.049304209649562836,
0.37449392676353455,
-0.7884135842323303,
0.34198880195617676,
0.3236652612686157,
0.36351147294044495,
0.5542644262313843,
0.08933175355195999,
-0.3507455885410309,
0.22079426050186157,
-0.773128867149353,
-0.7180342674255371,
1.1301299333572388,
0.5112316608428955,
0.8847971558570862,
-0.2267678827047348,
0.90852952003479,
0.4010321795940399,
0.7621989250183105,
-0.6248016953468323,
0.31134283542633057,
-0.3098090589046478,
-1.0695936679840088,
-0.3365352749824524,
-0.4153355360031128,
-1.0113285779953003,
-0.04151615500450134,
-0.3116500973701477,
-0.381320059299469,
0.09535013139247894,
0.22713030874729156,
-0.502466082572937,
0.014287627302110195,
-0.450382798910141,
0.6099676489830017,
-0.30336007475852966,
-0.2553093135356903,
-0.35273420810699463,
-0.674104630947113,
0.24354957044124603,
-0.44075092673301697,
0.25362199544906616,
0.021435128524899483,
0.2625742554664612,
0.7220804691314697,
-0.44241398572921753,
0.841606855392456,
-0.07746550440788269,
0.11192421615123749,
0.13008785247802734,
-0.13298937678337097,
0.10986871272325516,
0.17128443717956543,
-0.3580573797225952,
0.450613409280777,
0.5498441457748413,
-0.3000127375125885,
-0.03136196732521057,
0.45744428038597107,
-0.6256765723228455,
-0.0909186527132988,
-0.6216400861740112,
-0.3342243432998657,
0.008734597824513912,
0.22493094205856323,
0.7354723215103149,
0.21878863871097565,
-0.5408710837364197,
0.25592732429504395,
0.7885041832923889,
-0.4301930367946625,
0.1541478931903839,
0.7104048132896423,
-0.18638402223587036,
-0.027838511392474174,
0.32016992568969727,
-0.012419525533914566,
-0.15634256601333618,
0.4843079149723053,
0.07916472852230072,
-0.48023709654808044,
-0.9704858064651489,
-0.20254923403263092,
0.15689493715763092,
-0.32176193594932556,
-0.39250874519348145,
-0.909328281879425,
-0.40110787749290466,
-0.33159974217414856,
-0.014860771596431732,
-0.10083065181970596,
-0.19415289163589478,
-0.586495578289032,
-0.16961689293384552,
0.773428201675415,
0.6972706913948059,
-0.11136854439973831,
0.3942278325557709,
-1.119938611984253,
0.24297919869422913,
-0.11318793147802353,
0.44232603907585144,
-0.24803359806537628,
-0.4818636178970337,
-0.42183107137680054,
-0.12970343232154846,
-0.2917712330818176,
-1.0030256509780884,
0.590440034866333,
0.3973127603530884,
0.6902719140052795,
0.18110904097557068,
0.11758168041706085,
0.48876315355300903,
-0.7406749725341797,
0.22659441828727722,
0.22034995257854462,
-0.5487940311431885,
0.7606960535049438,
-0.27986449003219604,
0.06682746112346649,
1.0423996448516846,
0.6421351432800293,
-0.04896853119134903,
-0.4718218445777893,
-0.47525516152381897,
-0.8299277424812317,
0.6138629913330078,
0.26833128929138184,
-0.15124835073947906,
0.0577043741941452,
0.452709436416626,
0.6148298382759094,
0.278803288936615,
-0.6620345115661621,
-0.05599368363618851,
0.21948570013046265,
-0.6486851572990417,
-0.11179133504629135,
-0.18081504106521606,
-0.13570287823677063,
-0.6357408761978149,
0.6326851844787598,
0.0313664972782135,
-0.04461067542433739,
0.542421817779541,
-0.44973844289779663,
0.11606187373399734,
0.16998252272605896,
0.1645544022321701,
0.48138946294784546,
-0.4494442939758301,
-0.15555761754512787,
0.11724834144115448,
-0.7577250003814697,
0.23834869265556335,
0.679865300655365,
-0.17099358141422272,
0.39875221252441406,
0.48531168699264526,
0.17994174361228943,
0.06586030125617981,
-0.7763977646827698,
0.15168465673923492,
-0.11221157014369965,
-0.37257638573646545,
-0.06889403611421585,
0.13447809219360352,
-0.15242552757263184,
0.3186263144016266,
0.29679757356643677,
0.07246799767017365,
0.8676276206970215,
-0.3604294955730438,
0.36344730854034424,
0.17911368608474731,
-0.4277607798576355,
-0.19064690172672272,
0.45478299260139465,
0.3577386736869812,
-0.0386267751455307,
0.39868298172950745,
-0.251884788274765,
-0.23387174308300018,
0.5707875490188599,
0.1843055784702301,
0.5938794016838074,
-0.39710602164268494,
0.30543744564056396,
0.3407316207885742,
0.09211274981498718,
-0.32974308729171753,
0.018637901172041893,
0.04996759817004204,
-0.4084952771663666,
-0.5634424686431885,
-1.3169227838516235,
-0.1407046616077423,
0.397968053817749,
-0.5460022687911987,
0.6057417392730713,
-0.09590397775173187,
-0.40367090702056885,
0.5402989387512207,
-0.09361040592193604,
-0.44431039690971375,
0.1215846985578537,
-0.15356652438640594,
0.8996140360832214,
-0.8702987432479858,
1.1023223400115967,
0.9141175746917725,
-0.2410932034254074,
-0.478342205286026,
-0.3531579375267029,
-0.21063733100891113,
-0.19501861929893494,
0.9484044909477234,
0.03679201379418373,
0.15038438141345978,
0.014619426801800728,
-0.44887611269950867,
-0.5034807920455933,
0.9870133399963379,
0.19358660280704498,
-1.0562373399734497,
-0.0507311187684536,
-0.13388359546661377,
1.0206118822097778,
-0.13823147118091583,
0.4368375539779663,
0.5698255896568298,
0.2759874165058136,
0.06679025292396545,
-1.2969348430633545,
-0.2505605220794678,
-0.4214843213558197,
-0.0500217080116272,
0.12611553072929382,
-0.1010894775390625,
0.7972601652145386,
0.11356514692306519,
0.11505737155675888,
0.37294837832450867,
0.39276981353759766,
0.21181276440620422,
0.5941003561019897,
0.3026582896709442,
0.4141330420970917,
0.7706190943717957,
0.006022160407155752,
0.6438047289848328,
-0.18468235433101654,
0.5086584687232971,
0.662781298160553,
-0.3974827527999878,
0.34378108382225037,
0.17194326221942902,
-0.3492966592311859,
0.533560574054718,
0.82243812084198,
-0.031601760536432266,
0.7005223631858826,
0.5083544254302979,
-0.24050657451152802,
0.025585174560546875,
0.12293016910552979,
-0.6906211376190186,
0.39080914855003357,
0.4193895757198334,
-0.7839199900627136,
-0.08433211594820023,
0.3635629713535309,
-0.18642204999923706,
0.2409214824438095,
-0.44810765981674194,
0.8163476586341858,
0.04794078692793846,
-0.33602118492126465,
0.5142795443534851,
0.07435503602027893,
0.872580885887146,
-0.7155662178993225,
-0.02563142031431198,
-0.07248308509588242,
0.42700454592704773,
-0.21326971054077148,
-0.4366990029811859,
0.41666293144226074,
0.13510139286518097,
-0.269176185131073,
0.12331631779670715,
0.8124683499336243,
-0.5626444816589355,
-0.9146285057067871,
0.3244470953941345,
0.3337145149707794,
0.23384402692317963,
0.2518995702266693,
-0.7247276306152344,
-0.12553879618644714,
-0.031155956909060478,
-0.1355612874031067,
0.23814213275909424,
0.7730426788330078,
0.029013091698288918,
0.4017607271671295,
0.3908859193325043,
0.4243026077747345,
-0.4523518979549408,
-0.11453232914209366,
0.9693288207054138,
-0.6285263299942017,
-0.48765212297439575,
-1.1299890279769897,
0.29344284534454346,
-0.4701526463031769,
-0.009483378380537033,
0.3412039279937744,
0.6164226531982422,
0.4844931662082672,
-0.31552717089653015,
0.8973202109336853,
-0.10262876749038696,
0.7697609066963196,
-0.380643755197525,
1.1704344749450684,
-0.5021978616714478,
0.10067888349294662,
-0.5024787783622742,
-0.5909618139266968,
-0.37370458245277405,
0.8171685934066772,
0.03679512068629265,
-0.07918865978717804,
0.8144592642784119,
0.5659223794937134,
-0.1543194055557251,
0.10847592353820801,
0.016494745388627052,
0.43158257007598877,
0.1703025847673416,
0.22888776659965515,
0.50559401512146,
-0.11840587109327316,
0.268058717250824,
-0.14975786209106445,
-0.8011310696601868,
-0.45027241110801697,
-0.9982138872146606,
-0.8801491856575012,
-0.6332114934921265,
-0.4249471426010132,
-0.20439310371875763,
0.16148950159549713,
0.8596143126487732,
0.818112850189209,
-0.7687696814537048,
-0.03739028424024582,
-0.23046986758708954,
-0.30525174736976624,
-0.1666928231716156,
-0.14759469032287598,
0.27775055170059204,
-0.503106415271759,
-0.6795592308044434,
0.0923783928155899,
0.39732199907302856,
0.08110136538743973,
-0.15616615116596222,
0.1937418282032013,
-0.3708714246749878,
-0.05039427801966667,
0.6568798422813416,
0.16618889570236206,
-0.18859104812145233,
0.35673895478248596,
-0.017131824046373367,
-0.21381747722625732,
-0.36317896842956543,
0.7336878776550293,
-0.8863349556922913,
0.3434194326400757,
0.407461553812027,
0.4589029550552368,
0.4674237072467804,
-0.12405545264482498,
0.5772302150726318,
-0.6494621634483337,
0.40444132685661316,
0.6264448165893555,
0.24274992942810059,
0.14634232223033905,
-0.5062406659126282,
0.6140885949134827,
0.05987304449081421,
-0.7826697826385498,
-0.8980246186256409,
-0.06195225939154625,
-0.8636999130249023,
-0.7271581888198853,
0.9868871569633484,
-0.035213541239500046,
-0.2614595890045166,
-0.3714831471443176,
-0.5854457020759583,
0.5398160219192505,
-0.13488417863845825,
0.9786219596862793,
0.5625303387641907,
-0.24023564159870148,
0.3869108557701111,
-0.48799559473991394,
0.8061538934707642,
0.22970488667488098,
-0.7518013119697571,
-0.17749889194965363,
0.48430687189102173,
0.17519186437129974,
0.30339691042900085,
0.8011935949325562,
-0.24789126217365265,
0.07984161376953125,
-0.49189093708992004,
0.22153225541114807,
-0.026771562173962593,
-0.12792424857616425,
-0.14698196947574615,
0.17499449849128723,
0.22122807800769806,
0.0256944727152586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13764v1
|
Using Adaptive Empathetic Responses for Teaching English
| 2024-04-21T20:21:24 | 2024-04-21T20:21:24 |
Li Siyan, Teresa Shao, Zhou Yu, Julia Hirschberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing English-teaching chatbots rarely incorporate empathy explicitly in
their feedback, but empathetic feedback could help keep students engaged and
reduce learner anxiety. Toward this end, we propose the task of negative
emotion detection via audio, for recognizing empathetic feedback opportunities
in language learning. We then build the first spoken English-teaching chatbot
with adaptive, empathetic feedback. This feedback is synthesized through
automatic prompt optimization of ChatGPT and is evaluated with English
learners. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our system through a preliminary
user study.
|
[
-0.46985897421836853,
-0.9427403807640076,
0.3065378963947296,
0.145260289311409,
0.048341043293476105,
0.11633321642875671,
-0.4899080693721771,
-0.2038467675447464,
0.41870617866516113,
-0.2719739079475403,
-0.5853157639503479,
-0.4156014323234558,
-0.5825482606887817,
0.18704120814800262,
-0.20160669088363647,
0.8975143432617188,
0.1092776283621788,
0.296373575925827,
0.09118399769067764,
-0.19843338429927826,
-0.5842212438583374,
-0.3754637837409973,
-1.4228363037109375,
-0.3541405200958252,
0.418549507856369,
0.9758723378181458,
0.3803711533546448,
-0.20782355964183807,
0.22177094221115112,
0.3380642831325531,
0.3594045341014862,
-0.017371557652950287,
-0.19051691889762878,
0.24274948239326477,
-0.13002175092697144,
-0.46448513865470886,
-0.507743239402771,
-0.0650208443403244,
0.2500878870487213,
0.02412569150328636,
-0.36482712626457214,
-0.03050469234585762,
0.22178849577903748,
0.3446769714355469,
-0.42515337467193604,
-0.034006837755441666,
-0.23084311187267303,
0.49919408559799194,
0.3784831762313843,
-0.4630280137062073,
-0.6027522087097168,
-0.3910377323627472,
0.18918652832508087,
-0.606292188167572,
-0.14080902934074402,
0.01717602275311947,
0.43824294209480286,
0.3756933808326721,
-0.2466917484998703,
-0.6115306615829468,
-0.49956756830215454,
1.011542558670044,
-0.6042928695678711,
0.5486843585968018,
0.548387885093689,
0.49867409467697144,
0.2685571014881134,
-0.1470465362071991,
-0.5498656034469604,
-0.3129776418209076,
0.2062615603208542,
0.8400993943214417,
-0.3394712805747986,
0.08379519730806351,
-0.13851101696491241,
0.10874179005622864,
-0.5558406710624695,
0.3077909052371979,
-0.16970022022724152,
-0.035183388739824295,
0.49383866786956787,
0.16449014842510223,
0.7539173364639282,
-0.0809784010052681,
0.1953890472650528,
-0.042122259736061096,
-0.047239985316991806,
0.11902035772800446,
0.48562759160995483,
0.2694726288318634,
-0.424331933259964,
0.23175133764743805,
0.488007128238678,
0.4234996736049652,
0.1408456563949585,
-0.15043199062347412,
0.17703381180763245,
0.4207998216152191,
0.0045065139420330524,
0.19003421068191528,
0.49334126710891724,
0.855465829372406,
0.4760443866252899,
0.12417047470808029,
-0.02491692826151848,
0.4663974940776825,
0.16788192093372345,
-0.8515927791595459,
-0.2104446291923523,
0.6229979991912842,
-0.1895896941423416,
-0.2395818531513214,
-0.6092744469642639,
-0.9978013634681702,
-0.4026346802711487,
-0.10570979863405228,
0.6338430643081665,
-0.6887441277503967,
-0.30914637446403503,
0.21966546773910522,
-0.392109215259552,
0.20951569080352783,
0.6510851979255676,
-0.8630616068840027,
0.5687984228134155,
0.39072173833847046,
0.9195206761360168,
0.14454753696918488,
-0.44335034489631653,
-0.48872092366218567,
-0.35672566294670105,
0.052064426243305206,
0.9062654972076416,
-0.6957752704620361,
-0.438791424036026,
0.023739755153656006,
0.1917690485715866,
0.04396955668926239,
-0.24293659627437592,
0.5604599118232727,
0.22438158094882965,
0.8313559293746948,
0.1984834372997284,
-0.8836987018585205,
-0.09401212632656097,
0.7385477423667908,
-0.2792186439037323,
0.6841509342193604,
0.25176167488098145,
-0.6917425394058228,
0.06308325380086899,
-0.8648827075958252,
-0.3692317605018616,
-0.09385454654693604,
0.25448891520500183,
-0.29854995012283325,
-0.07405967265367508,
0.22553884983062744,
0.3314664959907532,
-0.11737698316574097,
-0.25505226850509644,
-0.1377297341823578,
-0.48189401626586914,
0.057441942393779755,
-0.32375064492225647,
0.5227940082550049,
0.14075244963169098,
-0.5343590974807739,
-0.09671690315008163,
-0.6782070398330688,
-0.09609057754278183,
0.16289858520030975,
-0.1346539705991745,
-0.26854169368743896,
0.19364561140537262,
0.06286118179559708,
0.00999230332672596,
-0.29349997639656067,
-0.7286902666091919,
0.04359458386898041,
-0.3243195712566376,
0.2157033383846283,
0.837295651435852,
0.1403847336769104,
0.25035372376441956,
-0.4260696470737457,
1.1520923376083374,
-0.13552357256412506,
0.06574314087629318,
-0.3263700008392334,
-0.2711656987667084,
-0.797096848487854,
-0.09963741153478622,
-0.3222060203552246,
0.7839763164520264,
-0.3211445212364197,
0.32985928654670715,
0.24794211983680725,
-0.7176113724708557,
-1.0343581438064575,
-0.043253328651189804,
0.2458457350730896,
0.5119588375091553,
0.38138842582702637,
-0.2802630364894867,
-0.5263319611549377,
-0.3844863772392273,
-0.4910295307636261,
-0.12304920703172684,
-0.035394616425037384,
0.606304407119751,
-0.0066660805605351925,
-0.16837376356124878,
0.3583911955356598,
-0.4167335331439972,
-0.30637645721435547,
-0.0020517162047326565,
-0.014652791433036327,
-0.008965321816504002,
0.352328896522522,
0.5747941732406616,
-0.43252110481262207,
-0.9098247289657593,
0.09420064091682434,
-0.33010172843933105,
-0.311982661485672,
-0.19393333792686462,
-0.0553831085562706,
0.22597309947013855,
0.2000807374715805,
-0.2754294276237488,
0.051892850548028946,
0.7880949378013611,
-0.48207592964172363,
0.0822732001543045,
0.03508104756474495,
0.4840908944606781,
-1.1185559034347534,
-0.31736209988594055,
0.06689804047346115,
-0.3524298667907715,
-0.3780839741230011,
-0.4727107584476471,
-0.13749682903289795,
-0.28387728333473206,
-0.5082535147666931,
0.6398906707763672,
-0.17150695621967316,
0.23012392222881317,
-0.4562593698501587,
0.6085561513900757,
-0.040099550038576126,
0.48616328835487366,
0.14649759232997894,
0.4540775418281555,
0.6318265199661255,
-0.4486919641494751,
0.5778984427452087,
0.42118218541145325,
0.314341276884079,
1.179325819015503,
-0.46702951192855835,
0.3585681617259979,
-0.2834493815898895,
0.13090188801288605,
-1.0032182931900024,
-0.10018415004014969,
0.2453867346048355,
-0.9322162866592407,
0.3546925485134125,
-0.2786542773246765,
0.2414519339799881,
-0.4611663818359375,
-0.5666654706001282,
-0.07910048961639404,
0.8970586061477661,
-0.621425449848175,
0.5738760828971863,
0.3217114508152008,
-0.3603050708770752,
-0.3556491732597351,
-0.6567779779434204,
-0.2426401972770691,
-0.1352364718914032,
-0.29724669456481934,
-0.3012238144874573,
-0.3787311911582947,
-0.29416829347610474,
0.0661313459277153,
0.07752441614866257,
-0.00626092916354537,
0.20886263251304626,
0.2912585735321045,
-0.2077217698097229,
0.06190073862671852,
0.5697468519210815,
0.17416192591190338,
-0.18444284796714783,
0.2437765896320343,
0.008396136574447155,
0.6285916566848755,
-0.1704319566488266,
-0.4084545373916626,
-0.6679806113243103,
0.13489992916584015,
0.5149677991867065,
0.07961117476224899,
0.34092164039611816,
0.9031895399093628,
-0.28739216923713684,
-0.44205132126808167,
-0.20060649514198303,
-0.5385069251060486,
-0.47619807720184326,
0.5028989315032959,
0.055347051471471786,
-0.9039155840873718,
0.33679571747779846,
0.16830915212631226,
0.019913004711270332,
-0.06192804500460625,
0.726563036441803,
-0.2267897129058838,
1.1198984384536743,
0.1996239572763443,
-0.017377037554979324,
0.7758183479309082,
0.18206867575645447,
0.3101394772529602,
-0.5075889229774475,
0.05413538217544556,
-0.5421826243400574,
-0.3595896065235138,
-0.6102779507637024,
0.15087012946605682,
0.018268169835209846,
-0.5737154483795166,
-0.39514806866645813,
0.07059256732463837,
-0.6353558897972107,
0.35123711824417114,
0.39848631620407104,
0.27891162037849426,
-0.1933656483888626,
-0.479843407869339,
0.4910050928592682,
-0.3125922381877899,
-0.33791235089302063,
-0.35436534881591797,
0.6860920786857605,
0.45874863862991333,
0.9556683301925659,
0.27083590626716614,
0.9889461994171143,
0.27255183458328247,
0.6169231534004211,
-1.1649322509765625,
0.22902746498584747,
-0.012791253626346588,
-0.3399704396724701,
-0.3654518723487854,
-0.14029087126255035,
-0.8662317395210266,
-0.0845298022031784,
-0.025576774030923843,
-0.530014157295227,
-0.3359248638153076,
0.4165988862514496,
-0.2787199318408966,
0.24461007118225098,
-1.3150873184204102,
0.6336578130722046,
-0.1758243590593338,
-0.4336363673210144,
-0.20836785435676575,
-0.32421815395355225,
-0.26548251509666443,
-0.11276791989803314,
0.41238075494766235,
-0.17017188668251038,
0.14208823442459106,
0.6720616221427917,
-0.296039342880249,
0.9835830330848694,
-0.7791483998298645,
-0.2268829494714737,
0.4881531894207001,
0.5209189057350159,
0.2872532904148102,
0.05138593167066574,
-0.1036180928349495,
-0.6450739502906799,
-0.20893165469169617,
-0.44979971647262573,
-0.8787398338317871,
0.5437498688697815,
-0.8103745579719543,
-0.722218930721283,
-0.08215691149234772,
-0.3140881061553955,
-0.2993491291999817,
-0.05439566820859909,
0.1697831004858017,
-0.026246121153235435,
-0.19552122056484222,
0.052483052015304565,
0.0733860433101654,
-0.5956946611404419,
0.47635379433631897,
0.8577197790145874,
-0.2676345705986023,
-0.2234061062335968,
0.9446898102760315,
-0.03605471923947334,
0.09897740185260773,
0.3556363582611084,
0.5379655957221985,
0.03764842450618744,
0.058244120329618454,
-0.09557939320802689,
-0.17158983647823334,
-0.6521056294441223,
-0.3390308618545532,
-0.6369391679763794,
0.18699195981025696,
-0.2877468466758728,
-0.7594868540763855,
-0.6332637071609497,
-0.3327101469039917,
-0.19345244765281677,
-0.4961177408695221,
0.7864464521408081,
0.7168641090393066,
-0.3415631949901581,
0.37973859906196594,
-0.8839854001998901,
-0.23301301896572113,
0.5516976714134216,
0.38261112570762634,
0.11151988059282303,
-0.7717124223709106,
-0.17935752868652344,
-0.0006704620900563896,
-0.4868451952934265,
-0.9226260781288147,
0.7873578667640686,
0.5303764939308167,
0.0849037915468216,
0.3332488238811493,
0.05555568262934685,
0.256139874458313,
-0.37262532114982605,
0.9482397437095642,
0.16146913170814514,
-1.3037313222885132,
0.9025776386260986,
-0.23934456706047058,
0.13128787279129028,
0.22682134807109833,
0.6807469129562378,
-0.8746877908706665,
-0.6907864212989807,
-0.5841795802116394,
-0.7296431660652161,
0.6750617623329163,
-0.10278615355491638,
0.7032105922698975,
-0.191133052110672,
0.004744835197925568,
0.2502799332141876,
-0.2302110493183136,
-0.7573241591453552,
-0.09247218072414398,
-0.42416226863861084,
-0.6530869007110596,
-0.062064722180366516,
-0.1078023612499237,
-0.05148698762059212,
-0.3164863884449005,
0.8060351610183716,
-0.10205574333667755,
0.5821433067321777,
0.2339339554309845,
-0.13421882688999176,
-0.4146503210067749,
0.4952297508716583,
0.37119191884994507,
0.0399683341383934,
-0.42889273166656494,
0.17127501964569092,
0.5127078890800476,
-0.7567610144615173,
0.4444316625595093,
-0.23127879202365875,
0.4467882513999939,
0.1150522455573082,
0.4082111418247223,
0.6578097939491272,
0.35801246762275696,
-0.8129327893257141,
0.9221405386924744,
-0.33075082302093506,
-0.064566969871521,
-0.4292125999927521,
0.1436542570590973,
0.1927972286939621,
0.3119211792945862,
-0.06614391505718231,
-0.1851699948310852,
0.20692215859889984,
-0.2783536911010742,
0.4338962733745575,
-0.06805089116096497,
-0.6960670948028564,
-0.6616165041923523,
0.3520893156528473,
0.5871042013168335,
-0.8760133981704712,
0.5760189890861511,
-0.18776758015155792,
-0.9990522265434265,
0.5284103751182556,
0.971047043800354,
1.024721384048462,
-0.799115002155304,
0.3649292588233948,
0.4366632401943207,
0.14851371943950653,
0.5522416234016418,
0.8005338311195374,
-0.11755896359682083,
-0.8867732882499695,
-0.051009271293878555,
-0.14002667367458344,
-1.159002423286438,
-0.44252219796180725,
-0.9446395635604858,
0.5007484555244446,
-0.5560997724533081,
-0.027809295803308487,
0.026966657489538193,
-0.11938256025314331,
-0.7232001423835754,
0.39449432492256165,
0.10388819128274918,
0.6027127504348755,
-1.1723835468292236,
0.49085676670074463,
0.9416317343711853,
-0.3238295018672943,
-0.852459192276001,
-0.18949826061725616,
0.20750495791435242,
-1.154478669166565,
0.49849605560302734,
0.1584700345993042,
-0.3076806366443634,
0.24029232561588287,
-0.5598856210708618,
-0.0868702307343483,
0.8157541751861572,
0.3437928259372711,
-0.5379095077514648,
0.42336541414260864,
-0.45783308148384094,
0.8154020309448242,
-0.09867024421691895,
0.9207213521003723,
0.1873558759689331,
0.38509586453437805,
-0.31424736976623535,
-0.70817631483078,
-0.2569372057914734,
-0.5235665440559387,
-0.6192671656608582,
0.15399976074695587,
-0.964104413986206,
0.5749233961105347,
-0.07866156101226807,
-0.10815152525901794,
-0.45880961418151855,
0.14002908766269684,
-0.12409105896949768,
0.4909266233444214,
0.568146288394928,
0.47573769092559814,
0.7988575100898743,
0.025332244113087654,
0.9269494414329529,
-0.4874210059642792,
0.47705188393592834,
0.9699133634567261,
-0.2879031002521515,
1.034233570098877,
0.5948899388313293,
-0.38253581523895264,
0.5538591742515564,
0.599121630191803,
0.08496005833148956,
0.1008269265294075,
0.16772308945655823,
-0.4262564778327942,
0.061405476182699203,
-0.3810320794582367,
-0.09880891442298889,
0.48746949434280396,
0.3784542977809906,
-0.2081035077571869,
0.018791140988469124,
0.5494875311851501,
0.34829413890838623,
0.031161680817604065,
-0.33844858407974243,
0.650108814239502,
0.132134348154068,
-0.5548169612884521,
0.4255877137184143,
-0.40673062205314636,
0.8811373114585876,
-0.30416300892829895,
-0.16470056772232056,
-0.4653567671775818,
0.16486918926239014,
-0.48470425605773926,
-0.8843339681625366,
0.13095635175704956,
0.21919941902160645,
0.1755037158727646,
-0.17477107048034668,
0.5999082922935486,
-0.7105262279510498,
0.019953664392232895,
0.7556993365287781,
0.3032875061035156,
0.15263834595680237,
0.2928580641746521,
-0.34136292338371277,
-0.04842500388622284,
0.020875737071037292,
-0.4908774793148041,
0.030022593215107918,
0.5343000292778015,
0.5496730804443359,
0.6390870809555054,
0.21290460228919983,
-0.0829719603061676,
-0.31287476420402527,
0.38056710362434387,
0.6263628602027893,
-0.7715793251991272,
-0.529804527759552,
-0.7982184290885925,
0.5724091529846191,
0.19220498204231262,
-0.1368420571088791,
0.8503384590148926,
0.0269430223852396,
0.7548485994338989,
-0.3270776569843292,
0.9093570113182068,
-0.051262155175209045,
0.7354145646095276,
-0.23536838591098785,
0.4675769507884979,
-0.7494099140167236,
-0.11124400794506073,
-0.6666955947875977,
-0.7467865943908691,
-0.38888683915138245,
0.8612891435623169,
-0.06011505052447319,
-0.024222807958722115,
0.7981219291687012,
0.7586228847503662,
0.16006846725940704,
0.37502774596214294,
0.5841520428657532,
0.21469898521900177,
0.3073742091655731,
0.7898548245429993,
1.0802109241485596,
-0.4536976218223572,
0.34094226360321045,
-0.2799002528190613,
-0.32920628786087036,
-0.19386745989322662,
-0.7790163159370422,
-0.8109756708145142,
-0.39594295620918274,
-0.4356876015663147,
-0.5089446306228638,
0.14036302268505096,
1.3951472043991089,
0.3366405963897705,
-0.889488160610199,
-0.09790670871734619,
-0.100099578499794,
0.03890587016940117,
0.06698563694953918,
-0.2988892197608948,
0.41227665543556213,
-0.5058997273445129,
-1.0638000965118408,
0.13126780092716217,
0.31222060322761536,
0.3660837411880493,
0.07743187993764877,
-0.5282056927680969,
0.1323094367980957,
0.21474070847034454,
0.639780580997467,
0.32138919830322266,
-0.0693383440375328,
-0.7823616862297058,
0.14827503263950348,
0.06697937101125717,
-0.0023897315841168165,
0.4158118963241577,
-0.07045146077871323,
0.6942911744117737,
0.2088242918252945,
0.8819310665130615,
0.1000269204378128,
-0.2535882294178009,
0.6249688267707825,
-0.5726639032363892,
0.4867981970310211,
0.6062963604927063,
0.2812611162662506,
0.4221004843711853,
-0.4397251009941101,
0.5446419715881348,
0.09345629811286926,
-0.7615024447441101,
-0.8176755905151367,
-0.13470730185508728,
-0.7967144250869751,
0.15443095564842224,
1.015930414199829,
-0.3523338735103607,
-0.10495369881391525,
0.12527288496494293,
-0.7081112861633301,
0.24321624636650085,
-0.6759726405143738,
0.7783403396606445,
0.8777389526367188,
-0.33507028222084045,
-0.49561750888824463,
-0.1879061907529831,
0.3390851318836212,
0.8052228689193726,
-0.8262266516685486,
-0.2166968584060669,
0.270835280418396,
0.06276935338973999,
-0.1325342357158661,
0.6394286155700684,
0.17543819546699524,
0.5874157547950745,
0.1748315691947937,
0.5011634230613708,
0.3225763142108917,
-0.06587506085634232,
-0.5838533043861389,
-0.1277748942375183,
0.43732306361198425,
-0.25998201966285706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13760v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13760v1
|
How to Encode Domain Information in Relation Classification
| 2024-04-21T20:16:35 | 2024-04-21T20:16:35 |
Elisa Bassignana, Viggo Unmack Gascou, Frida Nøhr Laustsen, Gustav Kristensen, Marie Haahr Petersen, Rob van der Goot, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current language models require a lot of training data to obtain high
performance. For Relation Classification (RC), many datasets are
domain-specific, so combining datasets to obtain better performance is
non-trivial. We explore a multi-domain training setup for RC, and attempt to
improve performance by encoding domain information. Our proposed models improve
> 2 Macro-F1 against the baseline setup, and our analysis reveals that not all
the labels benefit the same: The classes which occupy a similar space across
domains (i.e., their interpretation is close across them, for example
"physical") benefit the least, while domain-dependent relations (e.g.,
"part-of'') improve the most when encoding domain information.
|
[
-0.5138378143310547,
-0.10959728807210922,
0.11134376376867294,
-0.015409578569233418,
-0.017927564680576324,
0.06354792416095734,
-0.2663728594779968,
-0.7934961915016174,
-0.0350181870162487,
0.39513641595840454,
-0.4703516960144043,
-0.31161996722221375,
-0.8451151251792908,
0.07500706613063812,
0.22347235679626465,
1.1572949886322021,
0.0663897693157196,
0.21288035809993744,
-0.6129462122917175,
-0.40854763984680176,
-0.2527121305465698,
-1.3135641813278198,
-0.3714156150817871,
-0.4601902365684509,
0.3850390315055847,
0.4082167446613312,
0.8936662077903748,
0.7102609872817993,
0.650708019733429,
0.19532066583633423,
-0.050030212849378586,
0.6952367424964905,
-0.4861404001712799,
0.1130746528506279,
-0.10879039764404297,
-0.3411767780780792,
-0.630111575126648,
-0.01567528210580349,
0.5026741027832031,
0.9979673027992249,
0.1741994172334671,
0.007394402287900448,
-0.026052772998809814,
0.5463677644729614,
-0.8791742920875549,
0.599509596824646,
-0.2694166898727417,
-0.07802420109510422,
-0.13576196134090424,
-0.4323429465293884,
-0.6875935196876526,
-0.06709305942058563,
0.2434125542640686,
-0.6782958507537842,
0.39729034900665283,
0.2991518974304199,
1.0493097305297852,
-0.0807192474603653,
-0.6680599451065063,
-0.09194056689739227,
-1.0358264446258545,
0.7309333682060242,
-0.4452435076236725,
0.8053746223449707,
0.5848584771156311,
0.23927949368953705,
0.10230117291212082,
-0.4832228124141693,
-0.24923279881477356,
0.26836904883384705,
-0.4736385643482208,
-0.028691645711660385,
0.10954859107732773,
0.15912364423274994,
0.34313148260116577,
0.3348798155784607,
-0.45617175102233887,
-0.13863740861415863,
-0.21731562912464142,
-0.030058186501264572,
0.569558322429657,
0.23873797059059143,
0.20006971061229706,
0.09627682715654373,
-0.3031025528907776,
-0.22067886590957642,
-0.83846116065979,
-0.09096965938806534,
0.11978567391633987,
0.5108711123466492,
0.10933038592338562,
0.31147173047065735,
-0.016769342124462128,
0.8513034582138062,
-0.026654714718461037,
-0.4018232524394989,
0.2520991563796997,
-0.1901605725288391,
-0.21030260622501373,
-0.19991569221019745,
0.5838844180107117,
0.27295321226119995,
0.6684344410896301,
-0.36525899171829224,
-0.13485880196094513,
0.2683459520339966,
0.17911885678768158,
-0.9420517086982727,
-0.35987982153892517,
-0.04093671217560768,
-0.22206367552280426,
0.05298294126987457,
0.17509675025939941,
-0.4016825258731842,
0.04353513568639755,
-0.6543246507644653,
0.21344590187072754,
-0.5020144581794739,
-0.27850964665412903,
0.08995789289474487,
-0.13304761052131653,
0.11276547610759735,
0.2329498529434204,
-1.2297308444976807,
0.7951307892799377,
0.579166054725647,
0.4159218668937683,
0.005747957155108452,
-0.35214006900787354,
-0.5460215210914612,
0.5592191815376282,
-0.03155544772744179,
0.8383027911186218,
-0.8410423994064331,
-0.29829803109169006,
0.28391578793525696,
-0.08099663257598877,
-0.3406530022621155,
-0.7428877353668213,
0.01900029554963112,
-0.9845597743988037,
0.04398179054260254,
-0.13397018611431122,
-0.8236901760101318,
0.09622786194086075,
0.020860014483332634,
-0.8795696496963501,
0.6607691645622253,
0.4186187982559204,
-1.0723483562469482,
0.5006131529808044,
-0.27510711550712585,
-0.6606511473655701,
0.013339023105800152,
-0.25999218225479126,
-0.40780937671661377,
-0.1129223182797432,
0.16166257858276367,
0.5741147398948669,
-0.21867585182189941,
0.06003136560320854,
-0.2817694842815399,
-0.12010207027196884,
0.38780778646469116,
0.10430888086557388,
0.4551616609096527,
0.1282733678817749,
0.2753276228904724,
-0.3345170021057129,
-0.7099493145942688,
0.005696094129234552,
-0.1075175404548645,
-0.33884063363075256,
-0.7284647822380066,
-0.24143216013908386,
-0.0479532890021801,
0.2136642336845398,
0.08241023868322372,
-0.2148120254278183,
0.40380123257637024,
-0.2341333031654358,
-0.0016174805350601673,
0.3088357150554657,
0.2626793682575226,
0.8491867184638977,
-0.35684481263160706,
0.576375424861908,
0.40825921297073364,
-0.0020613919477909803,
0.22165006399154663,
-0.5875526666641235,
-0.6907762885093689,
-0.07884053140878677,
0.8812012076377869,
0.3905082643032074,
-0.8579162955284119,
0.10232895612716675,
-0.5403925180435181,
0.060630492866039276,
-0.2670668065547943,
0.1472494751214981,
0.5978187918663025,
0.1062263771891594,
0.4906042516231537,
-0.5003165006637573,
-0.5042822360992432,
-0.7551819682121277,
-0.0063228667713701725,
0.03230990096926689,
0.20969273149967194,
0.3616417646408081,
0.52396559715271,
-0.35686928033828735,
0.9347045421600342,
-0.9683881402015686,
-0.41959959268569946,
-0.2515343427658081,
0.06120122969150543,
-0.05904556065797806,
0.31814882159233093,
0.6636899709701538,
-1.093172311782837,
-0.684307873249054,
0.15280094742774963,
-0.7122554183006287,
0.3683727979660034,
0.154060497879982,
-0.2497974932193756,
-0.13074561953544617,
0.16032761335372925,
-0.4829411506652832,
0.3507448732852936,
0.13386981189250946,
0.017041636630892754,
0.3861154317855835,
-0.11798878759145737,
0.040996503084897995,
-0.6559845209121704,
-0.27049756050109863,
0.29390057921409607,
-0.31464359164237976,
-1.1501299142837524,
0.05163189768791199,
0.11748445779085159,
-0.04367990419268608,
-0.3027305006980896,
0.3372177183628082,
-0.7106265425682068,
0.1027170792222023,
-0.23273293673992157,
0.10257472842931747,
0.0988687127828598,
0.8902267813682556,
0.5059719085693359,
0.6518421173095703,
0.5513227581977844,
-1.0476717948913574,
0.20874133706092834,
0.6455175876617432,
-0.10361839830875397,
0.5258737802505493,
0.05895534157752991,
0.27791306376457214,
-0.20306038856506348,
0.17202384769916534,
-0.5682122707366943,
-0.5232768654823303,
-0.040862757712602615,
-0.6236069798469543,
0.8602028489112854,
-0.30121251940727234,
-0.47732290625572205,
-0.05108179897069931,
-0.22674082219600677,
0.6565033197402954,
0.33878904581069946,
-0.8419186472892761,
0.4229186177253723,
0.6675679683685303,
0.21113193035125732,
-0.7319037914276123,
-0.5676336288452148,
-0.47066739201545715,
-0.07558886706829071,
-0.5346583724021912,
0.6678138375282288,
0.15652525424957275,
-0.07166026532649994,
0.2882547676563263,
-0.2965554893016815,
-0.7295039892196655,
-0.3451120853424072,
0.1866346001625061,
0.06839543581008911,
-0.164850115776062,
0.4417826235294342,
-0.09535106271505356,
-0.08070437610149384,
0.02741842158138752,
-0.14289571344852448,
0.1948193460702896,
0.11480319499969482,
0.19937770068645477,
-0.2837596833705902,
0.3793075978755951,
0.498984158039093,
-0.23889367282390594,
1.3162416219711304,
0.10614538937807083,
-0.7038120031356812,
-0.5846390724182129,
-0.07404602319002151,
-0.062284644693136215,
-0.43035849928855896,
0.08063452690839767,
-0.8891429305076599,
-0.8383006453514099,
0.3163447380065918,
-0.4531240463256836,
-0.11866983771324158,
0.3522753417491913,
0.06894625723361969,
0.005301008466631174,
0.9049121141433716,
1.0187784433364868,
-0.21264038980007172,
0.3089961111545563,
-0.6178302764892578,
0.3473881185054779,
-0.9498085975646973,
-0.536837100982666,
-0.5121893882751465,
0.18035510182380676,
-0.3588048815727234,
-0.35108405351638794,
0.09066712111234665,
0.2500886917114258,
-0.25647780299186707,
0.8465889692306519,
-0.36995959281921387,
0.3362835943698883,
0.29718565940856934,
0.21674147248268127,
0.429139643907547,
0.1718684434890747,
0.17460915446281433,
-0.3689158260822296,
-1.2150988578796387,
-0.26948070526123047,
0.9898683428764343,
0.2499423325061798,
0.8864320516586304,
0.3044089674949646,
0.5835414528846741,
0.004314514808356762,
0.5876361727714539,
-0.7145854234695435,
0.19609375298023224,
-0.5363748073577881,
-0.5344896912574768,
-0.04402337223291397,
-0.8050224184989929,
-0.8125379681587219,
0.16725116968154907,
-0.25898048281669617,
-0.3810000419616699,
0.4970332086086273,
0.2464132457971573,
-0.14993704855442047,
0.15104565024375916,
-0.5135666131973267,
0.8168467879295349,
-0.14194755256175995,
-0.18745072185993195,
0.04497925564646721,
-0.6480026245117188,
0.41285640001296997,
-0.12657471001148224,
0.46492037177085876,
0.13684971630573273,
0.25350990891456604,
0.8004683256149292,
-0.5888961553573608,
0.6917666792869568,
-0.10057912021875381,
0.05479913204908371,
0.21110019087791443,
-0.1495254933834076,
0.21002048254013062,
-0.15554414689540863,
0.05592935532331467,
-0.10622004419565201,
0.008582010865211487,
-0.2808266878128052,
-0.9504503011703491,
0.4486961364746094,
-0.971596896648407,
-0.18090862035751343,
-0.38148096203804016,
-0.35082533955574036,
-0.8108416199684143,
-0.2545212209224701,
0.35546064376831055,
0.7806044220924377,
-0.17467190325260162,
-0.024315379559993744,
0.8430455327033997,
-0.022244052961468697,
-0.15747036039829254,
0.31747135519981384,
-0.025789199396967888,
-0.4597439765930176,
0.8989105224609375,
0.2203623205423355,
0.4689382314682007,
0.8963260650634766,
-0.26996541023254395,
-0.4800074100494385,
-0.02592330425977707,
-0.2673603296279907,
0.5195736289024353,
-1.0425264835357666,
-0.7524285316467285,
-0.5439832210540771,
-0.5711120963096619,
-0.6422167420387268,
0.19781705737113953,
-0.179347962141037,
-0.5535330772399902,
-0.22578632831573486,
-0.0056010652333498,
0.46769922971725464,
0.8218952417373657,
0.06562969088554382,
0.7403556704521179,
-0.8015651702880859,
0.395654559135437,
0.40605098009109497,
0.5728247165679932,
0.09958072751760483,
-0.6864248514175415,
-0.7728697657585144,
-0.17283423244953156,
-0.232249453663826,
-0.8923424482345581,
0.3135659992694855,
0.6807163953781128,
0.5570428371429443,
0.43802139163017273,
0.25239241123199463,
0.8537346124649048,
-0.7279176115989685,
0.2921003997325897,
0.21700988709926605,
-0.9108654260635376,
0.536037266254425,
0.1945309340953827,
-0.04460100829601288,
0.4209836423397064,
0.9107698798179626,
-0.40635553002357483,
-0.2634328305721283,
-0.7587875127792358,
-0.7152634859085083,
0.9946512579917908,
0.37351828813552856,
-0.0021105394698679447,
0.0019943169318139553,
0.5821825861930847,
-0.09700900316238403,
0.09179709106683731,
-0.8169723153114319,
-0.6009780168533325,
0.0813150629401207,
-0.14897270500659943,
0.2234584391117096,
-0.33519065380096436,
-0.16691893339157104,
-0.4731520116329193,
0.6535466313362122,
0.04063254967331886,
0.5774204730987549,
-0.009582426398992538,
-0.29344579577445984,
-0.19052185118198395,
0.01884223334491253,
0.2398930937051773,
0.6958388090133667,
-0.22346006333827972,
0.44627413153648376,
0.20654897391796112,
-0.30726492404937744,
0.3757651150226593,
-0.23410813510417938,
0.5076730847358704,
0.17474479973316193,
0.7980135679244995,
0.8477134108543396,
0.17483174800872803,
-0.11289101839065552,
0.6774417757987976,
-0.03172901272773743,
-0.32884591817855835,
0.02708653174340725,
0.2507827579975128,
0.041772402822971344,
-0.17620424926280975,
-0.028523968532681465,
0.10706495493650436,
0.07634255290031433,
-0.710763692855835,
0.3967689573764801,
0.11617647856473923,
0.013428832404315472,
-0.2995493710041046,
0.5915158987045288,
0.14499211311340332,
-0.25526297092437744,
0.7233415842056274,
-0.17876549065113068,
-0.8744795322418213,
0.5346371531486511,
0.6164020299911499,
0.5405447483062744,
-0.4949782192707062,
0.06494244933128357,
0.5081803798675537,
-0.012890268117189407,
-0.20450952649116516,
-0.10485797375440598,
-0.15276747941970825,
-1.1488999128341675,
-0.5166166424751282,
-0.603134274482727,
-0.8415928483009338,
0.17455609142780304,
-0.9775413274765015,
0.12875492870807648,
-0.37623080611228943,
-0.3882850706577301,
0.342885285615921,
-0.13121584057807922,
-0.922149121761322,
0.5180380344390869,
-0.07676966488361359,
0.8288633823394775,
-1.0254017114639282,
1.2633721828460693,
0.772735595703125,
-0.39087048172950745,
-0.7353737950325012,
-0.05478748679161072,
-0.4721532166004181,
-0.2517746686935425,
1.213612675666809,
0.2920798063278198,
-0.42694634199142456,
-0.35905787348747253,
-0.38585421442985535,
-0.6689040660858154,
0.5740207433700562,
0.1289791464805603,
-0.5350006222724915,
0.06317687779664993,
0.39827194809913635,
0.7652323246002197,
-0.8540368676185608,
-0.16760216653347015,
0.6622834801673889,
0.27079781889915466,
-0.09782817959785461,
-0.8524341583251953,
-0.17301321029663086,
-0.3320266902446747,
0.2012224793434143,
0.28169184923171997,
-0.47041255235671997,
0.42232343554496765,
-0.02478768490254879,
-0.38555195927619934,
-0.34615689516067505,
0.6465960144996643,
-0.1333608329296112,
0.2707049250602722,
0.31211838126182556,
0.35969626903533936,
0.7662258148193359,
-0.1969136744737625,
1.0317033529281616,
-0.48075783252716064,
0.6193689703941345,
1.2245278358459473,
-0.27054306864738464,
0.7815468907356262,
0.020548658445477486,
-0.3664192259311676,
0.33342888951301575,
0.6599702835083008,
0.09258098155260086,
0.7505097389221191,
0.12839935719966888,
-0.40532276034355164,
-0.4322882294654846,
0.06549300998449326,
-0.4166458547115326,
0.1516096591949463,
0.5852779150009155,
-0.3047928810119629,
0.14550237357616425,
0.2435293346643448,
-0.15680725872516632,
0.13476631045341492,
-0.0689987987279892,
0.8171045780181885,
0.30101317167282104,
-0.4464535713195801,
0.7155038714408875,
0.05392984673380852,
0.44300031661987305,
-0.3597111999988556,
-0.033253300935029984,
-0.27892810106277466,
0.38470959663391113,
-0.42872872948646545,
-0.5238207578659058,
0.3059925436973572,
-0.030049558728933334,
-0.5377388000488281,
-0.24574612081050873,
0.583993673324585,
-0.7594351172447205,
-0.06361188739538193,
0.6067618131637573,
0.466229110956192,
0.2093985229730606,
0.1379692107439041,
-0.27785056829452515,
-0.04429128021001816,
-0.2443392425775528,
0.008124597370624542,
0.38429775834083557,
0.7079551815986633,
-0.09777683019638062,
0.4803849756717682,
0.22339969873428345,
0.10106119513511658,
-0.08124735951423645,
0.31318995356559753,
1.1223206520080566,
-0.7128126621246338,
-0.15930268168449402,
-0.6157591938972473,
0.030835481360554695,
-0.06377814710140228,
-0.2744905650615692,
0.5643426179885864,
0.652513325214386,
1.107879400253296,
-0.3474673628807068,
0.6339601874351501,
0.16909903287887573,
0.3845772445201874,
-0.42349931597709656,
0.2445726990699768,
-0.42208749055862427,
0.32690340280532837,
-0.11779951304197311,
-1.0463323593139648,
-0.7091763615608215,
0.7167608737945557,
-0.18120673298835754,
0.11846493184566498,
0.9218801856040955,
0.453436017036438,
-0.30735650658607483,
-0.020193887874484062,
0.4713031053543091,
-0.07242707908153534,
0.05098981782793999,
0.8470057845115662,
0.9775100350379944,
-0.5543919801712036,
0.44891032576560974,
-0.449540913105011,
-0.32505884766578674,
-0.1313953697681427,
-0.3672979772090912,
-1.1023041009902954,
-0.5958254337310791,
-0.5640978217124939,
-0.34350648522377014,
0.23764577507972717,
0.8191773295402527,
1.0610908269882202,
-0.8776412010192871,
-0.3991149961948395,
0.38691189885139465,
-0.03718358650803566,
-0.26791781187057495,
-0.1458996683359146,
0.3330900967121124,
-0.48843756318092346,
-0.6922799944877625,
0.08893853425979614,
0.12895986437797546,
0.029894940555095673,
0.2277475744485855,
-0.2737814486026764,
-0.047708503901958466,
-0.01764087751507759,
0.7927893400192261,
0.10988219827413559,
-0.1509108543395996,
-0.3097960650920868,
-0.15519468486309052,
-0.2790415585041046,
0.5113561749458313,
1.0733094215393066,
-0.5501275062561035,
0.14961613714694977,
0.23838382959365845,
0.6042938232421875,
0.786145806312561,
0.16375140845775604,
0.6410307884216309,
-1.149201512336731,
0.002430578460916877,
0.09848292917013168,
0.325552374124527,
0.38395199179649353,
-0.6460121870040894,
0.8527148365974426,
0.21259412169456482,
-0.5922643542289734,
-0.5773253440856934,
0.3812751770019531,
-0.9141491651535034,
-0.3588835895061493,
1.1801317930221558,
-0.36227279901504517,
-0.15022388100624084,
-0.29778048396110535,
0.10849346220493317,
0.35432156920433044,
-0.24736182391643524,
0.2540827989578247,
0.8661009073257446,
-0.65789794921875,
0.038523901253938675,
-0.37165823578834534,
0.8615607023239136,
0.016728341579437256,
-0.815418004989624,
0.20360589027404785,
0.39343881607055664,
0.4178716540336609,
0.4195154011249542,
0.6163626313209534,
-0.05857871472835541,
0.1701550930738449,
0.04896775633096695,
0.011433855630457401,
0.16776235401630402,
-0.9919828176498413,
-0.286464661359787,
0.20726378262043,
0.2682178020477295,
-0.1834183931350708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13752v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13752v2
|
Towards General Conceptual Model Editing via Adversarial Representation Engineering
| 2024-04-21T19:24:15 | 2024-05-23T13:06:59 |
Yihao Zhang, Zeming Wei, Jun Sun, Meng Sun
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, math.OC
|
Since the development of Large Language Models (LLMs) has achieved remarkable
success, understanding and controlling their internal complex mechanisms has
become an urgent problem. Recent research has attempted to interpret their
behaviors through the lens of inner representation. However, developing
practical and efficient methods for applying these representations for general
and flexible model editing remains challenging. In this work, we explore how to
use representation engineering methods to guide the editing of LLMs by
deploying a representation sensor as an oracle. We first identify the
importance of a robust and reliable sensor during editing, then propose an
Adversarial Representation Engineering (ARE) framework to provide a unified and
interpretable approach for conceptual model editing without compromising
baseline performance. Experiments on multiple model editing paradigms
demonstrate the effectiveness of ARE in various settings. Code and data are
available at
https://github.com/Zhang-Yihao/Adversarial-Representation-Engineering.
|
[
-0.26960140466690063,
-0.7429201006889343,
0.7282317280769348,
-0.049400944262742996,
-0.18872004747390747,
0.001875758171081543,
-0.32673320174217224,
-0.661990225315094,
0.3255161941051483,
0.5168816447257996,
-0.42555591464042664,
-0.4948006570339203,
-0.5650681853294373,
-0.1276807337999344,
-0.46262213587760925,
0.5160304307937622,
-0.20979692041873932,
0.16991199553012848,
-0.04776274785399437,
-0.09631314873695374,
-0.4107891023159027,
-0.48817455768585205,
-0.7122623324394226,
-0.43338385224342346,
0.2906123101711273,
-0.41882550716400146,
1.0316855907440186,
0.7122868895530701,
0.14039836823940277,
0.4529532194137573,
-0.4895637631416321,
0.4706130921840668,
-0.10189954936504364,
0.20003020763397217,
-0.3431042730808258,
-0.5837506651878357,
-0.5672192573547363,
-0.05533406883478165,
0.7876011729240417,
0.5874783992767334,
-0.11246252804994583,
-0.005018229596316814,
0.11839471012353897,
0.411937952041626,
-0.9295401573181152,
0.3203800320625305,
-0.9533911347389221,
-0.1269003301858902,
-0.14263464510440826,
0.14538705348968506,
-0.6594078540802002,
0.020929312333464622,
-0.41709384322166443,
-1.0232601165771484,
-0.07261262089014053,
-0.09871812164783478,
0.7631299495697021,
0.6066380739212036,
-0.28355178236961365,
-0.3073662519454956,
-0.8694993853569031,
0.31310975551605225,
-0.580656111240387,
0.14843294024467468,
0.1390952616930008,
0.14750057458877563,
-0.2547735273838043,
-0.6520031690597534,
-0.701376736164093,
-0.11240973323583603,
-0.2541967034339905,
-0.03220060467720032,
-0.4253145456314087,
0.3903118968009949,
0.07678607106208801,
-0.07374096661806107,
-0.33983832597732544,
0.34878745675086975,
0.11966177821159363,
-0.2176835983991623,
0.800355076789856,
0.2671678066253662,
0.4651159644126892,
-0.10306747257709503,
-0.046420980244874954,
-0.05390821769833565,
-0.702412486076355,
-0.3117639422416687,
0.27535274624824524,
0.2946203947067261,
0.2708522081375122,
0.7228142023086548,
0.249968484044075,
0.7425506114959717,
0.14357350766658783,
0.5136951804161072,
-0.28943249583244324,
0.035973843187093735,
-0.41374343633651733,
0.08171265572309494,
0.8247532844543457,
0.17024455964565277,
0.15041373670101166,
-0.3148582875728607,
-0.3711200952529907,
0.41826996207237244,
0.863084614276886,
-0.2137562334537506,
-0.1112404465675354,
0.20891128480434418,
-0.12628132104873657,
-0.44384947419166565,
0.08954226225614548,
-0.524398148059845,
-0.817035973072052,
-0.5966050624847412,
0.47816145420074463,
-0.4202814996242523,
-0.21579496562480927,
0.2214612066745758,
0.014758399687707424,
-0.07416978478431702,
0.5034940838813782,
-1.0537705421447754,
0.16854062676429749,
0.7434375286102295,
0.7943823933601379,
0.23614922165870667,
-0.3336229622364044,
-0.07939454913139343,
0.636152982711792,
-0.7017683982849121,
0.5675775408744812,
-0.5757262110710144,
-0.5981838703155518,
-0.14134617149829865,
-0.298071950674057,
-0.25386786460876465,
-0.5498831868171692,
0.4610051214694977,
-1.0503665208816528,
-0.1631067395210266,
-0.24712444841861725,
-0.6591547131538391,
-0.38022249937057495,
0.1562182605266571,
-0.7780042886734009,
0.8066380023956299,
-0.06904521584510803,
-0.6642041802406311,
0.03268606588244438,
-0.8465932607650757,
-0.07903115451335907,
-0.31386882066726685,
-0.1538202315568924,
-0.295594722032547,
0.29331496357917786,
0.5988861322402954,
0.38810861110687256,
-0.05301404371857643,
0.1847081035375595,
-0.42481258511543274,
-0.38097772002220154,
0.2734379172325134,
-0.16782017052173615,
0.8227770328521729,
0.22279056906700134,
-0.2535184621810913,
0.4903385043144226,
-0.6851329803466797,
-0.13856545090675354,
0.37317144870758057,
0.04033603146672249,
-0.5816320776939392,
-0.024743303656578064,
-0.08307279646396637,
-0.22646422684192657,
0.12991537153720856,
-0.5933043956756592,
0.49495601654052734,
-0.41877102851867676,
0.4643942713737488,
1.0623570680618286,
-0.05018136650323868,
0.6182554364204407,
0.11502065509557724,
0.5766229629516602,
-0.188299298286438,
0.07437165081501007,
0.11655218154191971,
-0.21742425858974457,
-0.7350725531578064,
-0.2719570994377136,
0.4215490221977234,
0.6173807382583618,
-0.9292140007019043,
0.28003162145614624,
-0.268426775932312,
-0.5458498597145081,
-0.6646088361740112,
0.22236444056034088,
0.2828306257724762,
0.27052152156829834,
0.32901519536972046,
-0.06577292084693909,
-0.5662744641304016,
-0.7379513382911682,
-0.4966718256473541,
-0.5444671511650085,
-0.14064575731754303,
-0.17975768446922302,
0.5224868059158325,
-0.3041110336780548,
1.015568733215332,
-0.5473709106445312,
-0.10058578848838806,
-0.035850025713443756,
0.027072012424468994,
-0.05496596172451973,
0.32832011580467224,
0.825208842754364,
-0.8331563472747803,
-0.09536127001047134,
0.07011792808771133,
-1.2494174242019653,
-0.19389458000659943,
-0.26206067204475403,
-0.25657594203948975,
0.06278020143508911,
0.6852775812149048,
-1.1514544486999512,
0.47958824038505554,
0.427598237991333,
-0.15163883566856384,
0.7347346544265747,
-0.15936797857284546,
0.04025612026453018,
-0.8550195097923279,
-0.0023249208461493254,
-0.037740182131528854,
-0.003294622991234064,
-0.6875677704811096,
0.8162010908126831,
0.23953737318515778,
-0.1766718626022339,
-0.4469490945339203,
0.550694465637207,
-0.4122955799102783,
0.06464611738920212,
-0.3302213251590729,
-0.07733120769262314,
0.0982198715209961,
0.3156742751598358,
-0.08319280296564102,
0.7502609491348267,
0.45145705342292786,
-0.6031086444854736,
0.7226685285568237,
0.18884435296058655,
-0.36484894156455994,
0.5941617488861084,
-0.8532968163490295,
0.290519118309021,
-0.29144200682640076,
0.21564605832099915,
-0.8127936720848083,
-0.15194907784461975,
0.5785569548606873,
-0.27642184495925903,
0.6410624980926514,
-0.13665790855884552,
-0.7789214253425598,
-0.12622754275798798,
-0.09427831321954727,
0.004975874442607164,
-0.23035173118114471,
-0.8229950070381165,
1.033696174621582,
0.545591413974762,
-0.0023241054732352495,
-0.5145421624183655,
-0.9681688547134399,
0.327164888381958,
-0.35352352261543274,
-0.9859543442726135,
0.6512525081634521,
0.2988584637641907,
-0.44057151675224304,
0.2828829288482666,
0.01726960390806198,
0.0802396684885025,
0.1870502531528473,
0.09228625148534775,
0.317145437002182,
-0.21531760692596436,
0.2683323621749878,
0.1517319679260254,
-0.31984612345695496,
0.2859300971031189,
-0.17699727416038513,
0.10431229323148727,
0.12912636995315552,
-0.7440035343170166,
-0.501495361328125,
0.32598453760147095,
0.7345629930496216,
-0.32081925868988037,
0.7112053036689758,
0.22453226149082184,
-0.7057374715805054,
-0.22980330884456635,
-0.2851639986038208,
-0.07131747156381607,
-0.5518568754196167,
0.6521971821784973,
-0.5638418793678284,
-0.5928098559379578,
0.6874526739120483,
-0.10114479064941406,
0.047949906438589096,
0.24798665940761566,
0.36144396662712097,
-0.08591689169406891,
1.1014158725738525,
0.5749146342277527,
-0.26219063997268677,
0.2624734044075012,
-0.2771679759025574,
0.17733736336231232,
-1.0479944944381714,
0.0809011161327362,
-0.42828646302223206,
-0.3065272867679596,
-0.14598459005355835,
-0.5045002102851868,
0.6482717394828796,
0.28576725721359253,
-0.4682087302207947,
0.16518644988536835,
-0.5913674831390381,
0.5000889301300049,
0.28267037868499756,
0.16210536658763885,
0.3382587730884552,
-0.14297865331172943,
-0.15021981298923492,
-0.25439453125,
-0.45577922463417053,
-0.7661288380622864,
0.8203184604644775,
0.34336742758750916,
0.9701908230781555,
0.2001093029975891,
0.3441573977470398,
0.2607630491256714,
0.3469298183917999,
-0.4459473490715027,
0.6463838219642639,
-0.3250504434108734,
-0.6926959753036499,
-0.28736165165901184,
-0.053749870508909225,
-0.5600298047065735,
0.7398363351821899,
-0.05905810371041298,
-0.8422523736953735,
0.334438294172287,
0.38918641209602356,
-0.1450994461774826,
0.8578080534934998,
-0.8339988589286804,
0.7879853844642639,
-0.12658502161502838,
-0.1059522032737732,
-0.21720466017723083,
-0.4187540113925934,
0.47988593578338623,
0.00839623436331749,
0.1977209895849228,
0.4199981391429901,
-0.1164066419005394,
0.1903146207332611,
-0.5756853222846985,
1.0687068700790405,
-0.3801833987236023,
-0.12701359391212463,
0.4347895681858063,
0.3050737977027893,
0.8678176999092102,
0.17637819051742554,
-0.4364336133003235,
-0.04246765747666359,
-0.3320447504520416,
-0.17404508590698242,
-1.1011788845062256,
0.5207609534263611,
-0.8039929866790771,
-0.5950563549995422,
-0.36916282773017883,
-0.2837804853916168,
-0.3341619372367859,
-0.1384839564561844,
0.24219989776611328,
-0.08880092948675156,
-0.4453567564487457,
-0.2544887661933899,
0.44347670674324036,
-0.19622047245502472,
0.1870100200176239,
0.1822313517332077,
-0.32902249693870544,
-0.11446059495210648,
0.7865377068519592,
0.06499029695987701,
0.19734257459640503,
0.42259669303894043,
-0.09112975746393204,
-0.3323516845703125,
-0.6197577714920044,
-0.8350309729576111,
0.03028625249862671,
-0.9639604687690735,
-0.11502523720264435,
-0.6259868741035461,
-0.35415223240852356,
-0.3068983256816864,
-0.24138736724853516,
-0.5975667238235474,
-0.4254951477050781,
-0.4630282521247864,
-0.19929461181163788,
0.27319371700286865,
0.9116750359535217,
-0.21548140048980713,
0.6307010054588318,
-0.25266414880752563,
0.4047197699546814,
0.4666427671909332,
0.1762726604938507,
0.25022369623184204,
-0.41981324553489685,
-0.2798181474208832,
0.3384470045566559,
-0.3054070770740509,
-0.9110981225967407,
0.2153458148241043,
0.13147686421871185,
0.47232937812805176,
0.06183137744665146,
-0.14195114374160767,
0.7947373986244202,
-0.22678270936012268,
0.7660291790962219,
-0.2135086953639984,
-1.4019943475723267,
0.5937047004699707,
-0.30340510606765747,
0.19019071757793427,
0.0677553191781044,
-0.00848914310336113,
-0.6414276957511902,
-0.4654027819633484,
-0.1961866021156311,
-0.7004592418670654,
0.7463839054107666,
0.031235652044415474,
0.23987817764282227,
0.44110599160194397,
0.7177066206932068,
-0.3397343158721924,
0.07079929113388062,
-0.6599752902984619,
-0.30002880096435547,
-0.48888492584228516,
-0.006667194422334433,
0.06028752401471138,
-0.1504034548997879,
-0.025139663368463516,
0.002990606939420104,
0.8691430687904358,
-0.1259348839521408,
0.06668876111507416,
0.039706721901893616,
-0.325756311416626,
-0.11949243396520615,
0.32070037722587585,
0.3733685612678528,
0.4871777594089508,
-0.05495866760611534,
0.06436461955308914,
0.11720959842205048,
-0.3560170829296112,
0.17853893339633942,
0.18647539615631104,
-0.624963104724884,
-0.0066691613756120205,
0.5249054431915283,
0.9127681255340576,
0.08475032448768616,
-0.1757376343011856,
0.12803472578525543,
-0.05755579099059105,
-0.0009337692754343152,
-0.09439630806446075,
0.16580386459827423,
0.387360543012619,
0.16727547347545624,
0.13041286170482635,
0.2242392599582672,
-0.12410976737737656,
-0.1900297999382019,
-0.11767271161079407,
0.2918376624584198,
-0.24152420461177826,
-0.3355443477630615,
1.1391583681106567,
-0.08496332168579102,
0.0905226543545723,
0.6478571891784668,
-0.21741844713687897,
-0.3830220401287079,
0.43428200483322144,
0.4175304174423218,
0.8044254779815674,
-0.5147454738616943,
0.33753058314323425,
0.11013191938400269,
0.6393914222717285,
0.297451913356781,
-0.16588257253170013,
0.447174072265625,
-1.0406235456466675,
-0.708305835723877,
-0.47195231914520264,
-0.47540122270584106,
0.11947271227836609,
-0.512103796005249,
0.2303541600704193,
-0.5916770696640015,
-0.06006307527422905,
0.3089296519756317,
-0.49363765120506287,
-0.3468839228153229,
0.3245827555656433,
0.25265321135520935,
0.6030228137969971,
-0.7684233784675598,
0.8492012619972229,
1.1341924667358398,
-0.2569168508052826,
-0.6597928404808044,
-0.38132965564727783,
0.5150444507598877,
-0.9350807070732117,
0.3611988127231598,
-0.22059643268585205,
-0.1407128870487213,
-0.3348672389984131,
-0.6959185004234314,
-0.6481893658638,
0.7958778142929077,
1.0001190900802612,
-0.425321489572525,
-0.18383055925369263,
0.27529966831207275,
0.7555012702941895,
-0.3064499497413635,
0.11501476913690567,
0.3947187066078186,
0.6486309766769409,
-0.09070144593715668,
-0.6461898684501648,
0.1588013470172882,
-0.4840175211429596,
0.3237208425998688,
0.042867954820394516,
-0.5032559037208557,
0.5741527676582336,
-0.061077866703271866,
-0.2456568479537964,
0.24944227933883667,
0.6803185343742371,
0.23101601004600525,
-0.02532724291086197,
0.6581682562828064,
0.7399405837059021,
0.739552915096283,
-0.1053750142455101,
1.0817052125930786,
-0.09340345114469528,
0.03707616403698921,
1.3469510078430176,
-0.25552377104759216,
0.4692423343658447,
0.3596488833427429,
-0.19078172743320465,
0.21545729041099548,
0.6963127255439758,
0.1567804515361786,
0.34235885739326477,
0.3241167962551117,
-0.436137855052948,
-0.2136492133140564,
0.008926106616854668,
-0.33768805861473083,
0.7470030188560486,
0.8129798173904419,
-0.23828820884227753,
-0.1739007830619812,
0.08058065176010132,
0.06788728386163712,
0.5052063465118408,
-0.21523699164390564,
0.5885231494903564,
-0.012157551012933254,
-0.20176050066947937,
0.4661544859409332,
0.4986874461174011,
0.46067288517951965,
-0.7613700032234192,
0.06090757995843887,
0.15173904597759247,
0.14770732820034027,
-0.03403596580028534,
-0.7729859352111816,
0.6927484273910522,
0.056757137179374695,
-0.21761886775493622,
-0.2115406095981598,
0.6689547896385193,
-0.15498381853103638,
-0.477324903011322,
0.5243881940841675,
0.17753319442272186,
-0.3685324490070343,
-0.6341633796691895,
-0.785103440284729,
0.43878719210624695,
-0.03869040310382843,
-0.3756319284439087,
0.13020551204681396,
0.5067265033721924,
-0.11876215785741806,
0.636339545249939,
0.5338398218154907,
0.42859312891960144,
0.07715204358100891,
-0.008153139613568783,
0.882438600063324,
-0.6531316637992859,
-0.4440793991088867,
-0.8105139136314392,
0.6308861374855042,
0.08974695950746536,
-0.3426375985145569,
0.3557725250720978,
0.11725164204835892,
0.8351688385009766,
0.00964505597949028,
0.9146528840065002,
0.041909120976924896,
0.27224278450012207,
-0.798227071762085,
0.859079122543335,
-0.5057793855667114,
0.5508347153663635,
-0.44844841957092285,
-0.9627838134765625,
-0.6616201996803284,
0.5059623122215271,
-0.13801461458206177,
-0.17371560633182526,
0.2754245698451996,
1.0948033332824707,
-0.19764377176761627,
0.41495460271835327,
0.12517397105693817,
0.6816051602363586,
0.7119988799095154,
0.26708468794822693,
0.9116646647453308,
-0.4847751259803772,
0.2909320294857025,
-0.45008790493011475,
-0.012730499729514122,
0.2698897123336792,
-0.7184848785400391,
-0.6065837740898132,
-0.47344979643821716,
-0.2404351681470871,
-0.22166681289672852,
0.4010588824748993,
0.5184826850891113,
0.6342447400093079,
-0.6737729907035828,
-0.015743732452392578,
0.008584165945649147,
0.22772768139839172,
-0.1832101047039032,
-0.1275995373725891,
0.7341862320899963,
-0.2027086764574051,
-0.8068626523017883,
0.5617643594741821,
0.23919005692005157,
-0.05595078319311142,
-0.44267216324806213,
-0.016905350610613823,
-0.0027704983949661255,
-0.22908256947994232,
0.45935767889022827,
0.19403882324695587,
-0.9121732115745544,
-0.38157397508621216,
-0.2535027265548706,
-0.01281797606498003,
-0.24848595261573792,
0.6760580539703369,
-0.5721714496612549,
0.9732876420021057,
0.16457058489322662,
0.8276088237762451,
0.27659788727760315,
-0.1548827439546585,
0.8327529430389404,
-0.790780246257782,
0.22941133379936218,
0.155451238155365,
0.5265910625457764,
0.5324866771697998,
-0.3979618549346924,
0.6025266647338867,
0.20480597019195557,
-0.4332578182220459,
-0.8107766509056091,
0.1888061761856079,
-0.6572525501251221,
-0.40344706177711487,
0.805604875087738,
-0.25709208846092224,
-0.20079344511032104,
0.1128968596458435,
-0.35420212149620056,
0.28408282995224,
-0.06607881188392639,
0.8623178601264954,
0.8477079272270203,
-0.04125415161252022,
-0.15424507856369019,
-0.27996882796287537,
0.11491639912128448,
0.4346173405647278,
-0.6157992482185364,
0.09539420902729034,
0.49636557698249817,
-0.1720094531774521,
0.2999597489833832,
0.3106875717639923,
-0.23952428996562958,
0.21680769324302673,
0.10563410073518753,
0.22247660160064697,
-0.22289925813674927,
-0.0688154473900795,
-0.3821122348308563,
-0.06198062375187874,
0.09334535896778107,
-0.1288497895002365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13751v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13751v1
|
Embarrassingly Simple Unsupervised Aspect Based Sentiment Tuple Extraction
| 2024-04-21T19:20:42 | 2024-04-21T19:20:42 |
Kevin Scaria, Abyn Scaria, Ben Scaria
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aspect Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) tasks involve the extraction of
fine-grained sentiment tuples from sentences, aiming to discern the author's
opinions. Conventional methodologies predominantly rely on supervised
approaches; however, the efficacy of such methods diminishes in low-resource
domains lacking labeled datasets since they often lack the ability to
generalize across domains. To address this challenge, we propose a simple and
novel unsupervised approach to extract opinion terms and the corresponding
sentiment polarity for aspect terms in a sentence. Our experimental
evaluations, conducted on four benchmark datasets, demonstrate compelling
performance to extract the aspect oriented opinion words as well as assigning
sentiment polarity. Additionally, unsupervised approaches for opinion word
mining have not been explored and our work establishes a benchmark for the
same.
|
[
-0.6398041844367981,
-0.6707133054733276,
0.43899351358413696,
0.1636749804019928,
-0.789450466632843,
0.17322522401809692,
-0.03457615152001381,
-0.301967054605484,
0.606512725353241,
0.6567860841751099,
-0.38956525921821594,
-0.501135528087616,
-0.5402305126190186,
0.011857898905873299,
-0.1522388458251953,
1.2593690156936646,
0.24433061480522156,
0.025731869041919708,
-0.33325421810150146,
-0.5988945364952087,
-0.05356844514608383,
-0.6933711171150208,
-0.26532894372940063,
-0.4563186764717102,
0.21266810595989227,
0.6347596049308777,
0.5656978487968445,
0.11710959672927856,
0.5067691802978516,
0.16883884370326996,
-0.35187098383903503,
0.23905940353870392,
0.0479133166372776,
0.07616686820983887,
-0.36338427662849426,
-0.3106730580329895,
-0.41225412487983704,
0.3350318372249603,
0.08946779370307922,
1.0348126888275146,
0.05618133768439293,
0.04242713376879692,
0.20184212923049927,
1.2888776063919067,
-0.5122703313827515,
0.37144479155540466,
-0.5876752138137817,
-0.05763839930295944,
-0.2720552384853363,
0.06586721539497375,
-0.12368655204772949,
-0.20215381681919098,
0.14177413284778595,
-0.35856953263282776,
0.36950036883354187,
0.10945162177085876,
0.5315961241722107,
-0.12336070835590363,
-0.19363000988960266,
-0.2830188572406769,
-0.5543760061264038,
0.8644587993621826,
-0.6974571943283081,
0.13882698118686676,
0.031536515802145004,
-0.2151947170495987,
0.02107706293463707,
-0.38341599702835083,
-0.6208186149597168,
0.46185851097106934,
-0.053525447845458984,
0.21650563180446625,
-0.2922990620136261,
0.05788068473339081,
-0.15879133343696594,
0.8991631865501404,
0.06321997195482254,
-0.12670846283435822,
0.007567829452455044,
-0.016734654083848,
0.6183677315711975,
-0.29599592089653015,
-0.12610739469528198,
-1.0094480514526367,
-0.2677723467350006,
0.06250783801078796,
-0.7301132082939148,
0.6268782615661621,
0.43368178606033325,
0.571084201335907,
-0.1636052280664444,
1.065203070640564,
-0.5987632274627686,
0.34329795837402344,
0.12264306843280792,
0.241059347987175,
0.43596526980400085,
0.02621493488550186,
-0.17388135194778442,
-0.23490890860557556,
1.0429680347442627,
0.4348181486129761,
-0.08069369941949844,
-0.2774339020252228,
-0.42268428206443787,
0.0780477374792099,
0.3661718964576721,
-0.445608526468277,
-0.3865220248699188,
0.5265136361122131,
-0.565951943397522,
-0.5934174060821533,
0.39678943157196045,
-1.4783389568328857,
-0.7696105241775513,
-0.04785154014825821,
0.30440598726272583,
-0.49357640743255615,
-0.20288509130477905,
-0.1928076148033142,
-0.16173291206359863,
0.18243467807769775,
0.012337146326899529,
-0.4964267909526825,
-0.077799491584301,
1.2340714931488037,
0.7475702166557312,
-0.4187137186527252,
0.1771695762872696,
-0.4069293439388275,
-0.5197778940200806,
-0.1537514328956604,
1.158603310585022,
-0.8599151372909546,
-0.464616060256958,
0.060124751180410385,
0.09078740328550339,
0.3245268762111664,
-0.4121328294277191,
0.5788370966911316,
-0.3190608620643616,
0.41044357419013977,
-0.25996702909469604,
-0.4417831599712372,
-0.6599751114845276,
0.10425306856632233,
-0.3881746828556061,
0.9510478973388672,
0.1703953891992569,
-0.8031480312347412,
0.19295255839824677,
-0.541401743888855,
-0.6618126630783081,
-0.055577684193849564,
-0.21140387654304504,
-0.6841639876365662,
0.8821601271629333,
0.5895252227783203,
0.5060365200042725,
-0.3259684145450592,
0.007051405031234026,
-0.40306180715560913,
0.22819054126739502,
0.48195886611938477,
-0.17827671766281128,
0.7025012969970703,
0.14434602856636047,
-0.3458312153816223,
0.03073878213763237,
-0.5963187217712402,
-0.008888285607099533,
-0.05604536458849907,
0.026516810059547424,
-0.8344161510467529,
0.1275145560503006,
-0.02148980274796486,
-0.13867349922657013,
0.3460702896118164,
-0.9105700254440308,
0.46159490942955017,
-0.7192972898483276,
0.330240935087204,
0.5450000762939453,
0.34162256121635437,
0.6547037363052368,
-0.043967876583337784,
0.42675283551216125,
0.2832941710948944,
0.23424971103668213,
0.2505086064338684,
-0.4317052364349365,
-0.9590545296669006,
-0.36910486221313477,
0.15597322583198547,
0.24887481331825256,
-0.972931981086731,
0.5858631134033203,
-0.07165396213531494,
-0.6271215677261353,
-0.6712532639503479,
0.5070580244064331,
0.6204661130905151,
0.3480406403541565,
0.25890669226646423,
-0.766004741191864,
-0.3285320997238159,
-1.0533322095870972,
-0.5415956377983093,
-0.30090323090553284,
0.13573704659938812,
0.1800774335861206,
0.12397975474596024,
0.05120469257235527,
1.1726354360580444,
-0.6869637966156006,
-0.5309339761734009,
-0.6876431703567505,
0.8004662394523621,
0.37556034326553345,
0.2288428544998169,
0.407141774892807,
-0.9411028623580933,
-0.08708273619413376,
0.01531822420656681,
-0.7023530602455139,
-0.18225513398647308,
0.14399142563343048,
-0.07511267066001892,
0.25905922055244446,
0.1417563408613205,
-0.4920414686203003,
0.3383682668209076,
0.24613787233829498,
-0.10251748561859131,
0.24035583436489105,
0.11810313165187836,
0.015634862706065178,
-1.0759963989257812,
-0.11043758690357208,
0.32230144739151,
-0.2140652984380722,
-0.3795449733734131,
0.19611681997776031,
-0.1637042611837387,
-0.0071237762458622456,
-0.49342650175094604,
0.026154642924666405,
-0.7288471460342407,
-0.13463765382766724,
-0.5122828483581543,
-0.020754128694534302,
0.16954992711544037,
0.8440675735473633,
0.25227075815200806,
0.3834537863731384,
0.5239800810813904,
-0.34440845251083374,
0.25488558411598206,
0.1325840950012207,
-0.18683427572250366,
0.8039720058441162,
-0.4416373372077942,
0.44786080718040466,
-0.362013041973114,
-0.3919389247894287,
-0.6478925347328186,
0.05687526986002922,
0.14046087861061096,
-0.28992313146591187,
0.21888349950313568,
-0.48866063356399536,
-0.016376003623008728,
-0.11396083980798721,
-0.8117716908454895,
0.1617376208305359,
0.2817353904247284,
-0.4509395360946655,
0.8592157959938049,
0.9719377756118774,
-0.27692684531211853,
-0.5136240720748901,
-0.20657098293304443,
-0.09457779675722122,
-0.39555856585502625,
0.09213483333587646,
0.12990547716617584,
0.33334803581237793,
-0.5175057649612427,
-0.017754800617694855,
-0.12888097763061523,
-0.09538202732801437,
-0.08605291694402695,
0.5484256148338318,
0.2518230080604553,
-0.105858713388443,
-0.26395538449287415,
0.2093098908662796,
0.0032154808286577463,
0.2571321427822113,
0.33262622356414795,
0.5487863421440125,
-0.5006287097930908,
-0.05933355912566185,
-0.24080555140972137,
0.6901395916938782,
0.5847463011741638,
-0.21580156683921814,
0.33291834592819214,
0.03658037260174751,
-0.35967177152633667,
-0.25050508975982666,
-0.40555649995803833,
-0.010484384372830391,
-0.3772113025188446,
0.4138036072254181,
-0.19602817296981812,
-0.2811151444911957,
0.3587587773799896,
-0.2204914689064026,
0.2563628852367401,
0.41698938608169556,
0.16673046350479126,
-0.3650805652141571,
0.7791178822517395,
0.827945351600647,
-0.3843340575695038,
0.4258541762828827,
-0.3362199068069458,
0.4896891117095947,
-1.13270902633667,
-0.2506222426891327,
-0.4795965254306793,
-0.12123189866542816,
-0.42106926441192627,
-0.0919286236166954,
0.3628852069377899,
0.4742523431777954,
0.2808692753314972,
0.1669120043516159,
-0.7132098078727722,
0.23690921068191528,
0.5128771662712097,
0.2563118636608124,
0.3839837312698364,
0.11553860455751419,
0.38445553183555603,
-0.19007959961891174,
-0.23262062668800354,
-0.5034835338592529,
0.8969531059265137,
0.07480283826589584,
0.32137081027030945,
0.10922644287347794,
0.6155508756637573,
0.4864177107810974,
0.37157994508743286,
-1.1295002698898315,
0.569216251373291,
-0.6535554528236389,
-0.09598525613546371,
-0.07059052586555481,
-0.16537588834762573,
-0.6472459435462952,
0.2794744074344635,
-0.5080873370170593,
-0.6318057179450989,
0.38148075342178345,
-0.14976823329925537,
-0.22110220789909363,
0.3168564736843109,
-0.6347464919090271,
0.6574031710624695,
-0.0318276584148407,
-0.14452216029167175,
-0.09306009113788605,
-0.3898160755634308,
0.2837783694267273,
-0.10726343840360641,
0.5246883630752563,
-0.15448778867721558,
0.2739502787590027,
1.0521315336227417,
-0.6968839168548584,
0.8253587484359741,
-0.44200399518013,
0.3972589373588562,
0.4034174382686615,
0.2050759643316269,
0.2480551153421402,
0.29659220576286316,
0.06754973530769348,
0.61231529712677,
-0.15394721925258636,
-0.19248585402965546,
-0.6111578345298767,
0.7958465218544006,
-0.844393253326416,
-0.6472590565681458,
-0.6766868233680725,
-0.29540446400642395,
-0.6777563095092773,
0.07739964872598648,
0.2898085117340088,
0.508809506893158,
-0.24611566960811615,
0.12066058814525604,
0.3811456859111786,
-0.014826618134975433,
0.7880155444145203,
0.41800984740257263,
-0.2757207453250885,
-0.5152945518493652,
0.909309983253479,
-0.25403138995170593,
-0.322950541973114,
0.38500842452049255,
0.3885495960712433,
-0.20104898512363434,
-0.6483596563339233,
-0.36631500720977783,
0.2934376895427704,
-0.3396959602832794,
-0.5451264381408691,
-0.7416201233863831,
-0.11261383444070816,
-0.5792302489280701,
-0.0939890667796135,
-0.8191406726837158,
-0.6444430351257324,
-0.16415196657180786,
0.012667444534599781,
0.6466307044029236,
0.8885623812675476,
0.017110930755734444,
0.532239556312561,
-0.5039178133010864,
0.45426687598228455,
0.1733103096485138,
0.10237687826156616,
-0.28723689913749695,
-0.4364367723464966,
0.1257612109184265,
-0.008034002035856247,
-0.4948928654193878,
-0.8445749878883362,
0.643683671951294,
0.2009112387895584,
0.2747861444950104,
0.7409281730651855,
0.37218359112739563,
0.2951383590698242,
0.05269757658243179,
0.914322555065155,
0.24096842110157013,
-1.031665325164795,
0.7160459756851196,
0.14521248638629913,
-0.06777254492044449,
0.7291068434715271,
0.2602330148220062,
-0.24169163405895233,
-0.4438363015651703,
-0.6663126945495605,
-1.1702500581741333,
0.5018628835678101,
0.11892697960138321,
-0.0570671521127224,
0.05948419123888016,
0.507995069026947,
0.6587032675743103,
0.49808797240257263,
-0.6197479367256165,
-0.4485134780406952,
-0.5304123759269714,
-0.2226155400276184,
-0.0801260843873024,
-0.47924235463142395,
-0.08746697008609772,
-0.03532855212688446,
0.7948263883590698,
-0.09091297537088394,
0.2018977552652359,
0.25352126359939575,
-0.042968057096004486,
0.36400964856147766,
0.624809205532074,
-0.2513897120952606,
0.20409180223941803,
-0.3536567687988281,
0.32745876908302307,
-0.41508230566978455,
-0.4932596683502197,
-0.17792177200317383,
0.09580578655004501,
-0.3672228157520294,
0.044883374124765396,
0.3009631931781769,
0.3574270009994507,
-0.15007589757442474,
-0.22511355578899384,
0.9167875647544861,
-0.00018113017722498626,
0.3750867545604706,
-0.33890968561172485,
-0.2638925611972809,
-0.26851919293403625,
0.049377355724573135,
0.3882228136062622,
0.2467339187860489,
0.2243596911430359,
-0.6745165586471558,
0.09032080322504044,
0.7347577810287476,
-0.8533077239990234,
-0.6293784379959106,
0.3317774534225464,
0.4684021770954132,
-0.24011094868183136,
0.36106494069099426,
-0.3549768924713135,
-0.6156803369522095,
0.19729214906692505,
0.05137559771537781,
1.1573033332824707,
0.1817958950996399,
0.49595052003860474,
-0.10283401608467102,
0.14019303023815155,
-0.018558012321591377,
0.4425792396068573,
0.09600009769201279,
-0.7877264618873596,
-0.13565172255039215,
-0.6877337098121643,
-0.4746994376182556,
0.28450441360473633,
-1.1348756551742554,
0.04523802176117897,
-0.5105128288269043,
-0.016798099502921104,
0.27549299597740173,
0.027970463037490845,
-0.40112587809562683,
0.13978509604930878,
-0.18254788219928741,
0.29948896169662476,
-1.0813500881195068,
0.654751718044281,
1.1563832759857178,
-0.49306806921958923,
-0.4865432679653168,
-0.09612225741147995,
0.09644342213869095,
-0.5702270865440369,
-0.18049141764640808,
0.28564324975013733,
-0.12098407745361328,
-0.5546557307243347,
-0.5068137645721436,
-0.1736152619123459,
0.3712071180343628,
-0.11640450358390808,
-0.32149654626846313,
0.28873002529144287,
0.3680437505245209,
0.6086220741271973,
-0.5910373330116272,
-0.06367504596710205,
0.5533309578895569,
0.0943959578871727,
-0.17389531433582306,
-0.20017863810062408,
-0.08666346222162247,
-0.3755629062652588,
-0.25179386138916016,
-0.013332885690033436,
-0.6497663855552673,
0.7681561708450317,
-0.00200631027109921,
-0.019710632041096687,
-0.13398377597332,
1.275856375694275,
-0.13354140520095825,
0.5211407542228699,
0.8440660238265991,
0.35705116391181946,
0.4792935848236084,
-0.09453792870044708,
0.7809507250785828,
-0.34586387872695923,
0.40372931957244873,
0.9241313338279724,
-0.08528802543878555,
0.8643364310264587,
0.777485728263855,
0.030998360365629196,
0.5964340567588806,
0.4183845520019531,
0.43971678614616394,
0.8606702089309692,
-0.3648977279663086,
-0.1747024953365326,
-0.35053539276123047,
-0.3454042971134186,
0.05366990715265274,
0.7402474284172058,
0.24393385648727417,
-0.08968105912208557,
0.058450847864151,
0.06721939891576767,
0.1920206993818283,
0.3616132438182831,
-0.6325821280479431,
0.8474621772766113,
0.32515501976013184,
-0.729549765586853,
-0.23265168070793152,
0.00035147785092704,
0.9731152653694153,
-0.13625892996788025,
0.038396019488573074,
-0.7152839303016663,
0.2220434844493866,
-0.430812805891037,
-1.1006542444229126,
0.5016278624534607,
0.31312495470046997,
-0.3372059762477875,
-0.06604846566915512,
0.36930379271507263,
-0.005673099774867296,
-0.7817384600639343,
-0.05271719768643379,
0.6842197179794312,
0.1817600429058075,
-0.5263941884040833,
-0.4097299873828888,
-0.47114309668540955,
0.3800528049468994,
-0.40852680802345276,
0.21681621670722961,
0.8213071227073669,
-0.21164827048778534,
0.31268781423568726,
0.39242804050445557,
0.3772454559803009,
-0.5491217970848083,
-0.04757458716630936,
0.9651256203651428,
-0.9183913469314575,
-0.4225638508796692,
-0.5664232969284058,
0.2300836145877838,
-0.2718488276004791,
-0.6648969650268555,
0.7035757899284363,
0.7351422309875488,
0.3628356158733368,
0.09955263882875443,
0.8904289603233337,
-0.33824607729911804,
0.8612217307090759,
-0.43380311131477356,
0.5110328197479248,
-0.556006133556366,
0.5699155330657959,
-0.3717843294143677,
-0.9581220149993896,
-0.09071838110685349,
0.4499662518501282,
-0.19812463223934174,
-0.4729682207107544,
0.8160994052886963,
0.7008222937583923,
-0.13413898646831512,
0.4133163094520569,
-0.2703816294670105,
0.2648579180240631,
0.35349375009536743,
0.2005874514579773,
0.5465089082717896,
-0.2143602818250656,
0.19729481637477875,
-1.0284945964813232,
-0.5978723168373108,
0.022389432415366173,
-0.9707968831062317,
-1.0162612199783325,
-0.7091859579086304,
-0.6691341996192932,
-0.43997952342033386,
-0.3042764663696289,
0.7621220946311951,
0.1422407031059265,
-1.1289690732955933,
0.2502557039260864,
-0.02489568293094635,
0.23827596008777618,
-0.5614774823188782,
-0.3292850852012634,
0.7139496207237244,
0.060843825340270996,
-0.73841792345047,
0.3657781481742859,
0.22046776115894318,
-0.22262981534004211,
-0.24659529328346252,
0.6147210001945496,
0.14159879088401794,
0.11954419314861298,
0.5045419335365295,
0.46924158930778503,
-0.47526222467422485,
-0.7307412028312683,
-0.32395488023757935,
0.12372790277004242,
0.3027879595756531,
1.0043870210647583,
-0.606747031211853,
0.29226624965667725,
0.4441996216773987,
0.2390933632850647,
0.23136335611343384,
0.5053243041038513,
0.3982565999031067,
-0.9170317053794861,
0.3834455609321594,
0.26089560985565186,
0.5784948468208313,
0.6651196479797363,
-0.4636766314506531,
0.3723030388355255,
0.39011287689208984,
-0.2685486078262329,
-0.5383481383323669,
0.17268015444278717,
-1.6961115598678589,
-0.31074103713035583,
1.2978262901306152,
-0.1340211182832718,
-0.43287044763565063,
-0.34399738907814026,
-0.15259574353694916,
-0.038649167865514755,
-0.6649875640869141,
1.107283592224121,
0.284498393535614,
-0.5755645036697388,
0.1443033069372177,
0.1785038560628891,
0.43538936972618103,
0.422572523355484,
-0.72423255443573,
0.4311297833919525,
0.4386858344078064,
0.20279230177402496,
0.23220448195934296,
0.3699575960636139,
-0.2860371172428131,
-0.14857439696788788,
-0.3223956227302551,
0.47727319598197937,
-0.3175467848777771,
-0.1725906878709793,
-0.3962099552154541,
0.5389358997344971,
-0.05633825808763504,
-0.48355138301849365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13721v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13721v1
|
The Framework of a Design Process Language
| 2024-04-21T17:20:19 | 2024-04-21T17:20:19 |
Arnulf Hagen
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The thesis develops a view of design in a concept formation framework and
outlines a language to describe both the object of the design and the process
of designing. The unknown object at the outset of the design work may be seen
as an unknown concept that the designer is to define. Throughout the process,
she develops a description of this object by relating it to known concepts. The
search stops when the designer is satisfied that the design specification is
complete enough to satisfy the requirements from it once built. It is then a
collection of propositions that all contribute towards defining the design
object - a collection of sentences describing relationships between the object
and known concepts. Also, the design process itself may be described by
relating known concepts - by organizing known abilities into particular
patterns of activation, or mobilization. In view of the demands posed to a
language to use in this concept formation process, the framework of a Design
Process Language (DPL) is developed. The basis for the language are linguistic
categories that act as classes of relations used to combine concepts,
containing relations used for describing process and object within the same
general system, with some relations being process specific, others being object
specific, and with the bulk being used both for process and object description.
Another outcome is the distinction of modal relations, or relations describing
futurity, possibility, willingness, hypothetical events, and the like. The
design process almost always includes aspects such as these, and it is thus
necessary for a language facilitating design process description to support
such relationships to be constructed. The DPL is argued to be a foundation
whereupon to build a language that can be used for enabling computers to be
more useful - act more intelligently - in the design process.
|
[
-0.713571310043335,
-0.7639914155006409,
0.5674278736114502,
0.25740987062454224,
-0.3544371426105499,
0.23298227787017822,
0.12287170439958572,
-0.5431951284408569,
0.0721108466386795,
0.385108083486557,
-0.7384081482887268,
-0.1317015439271927,
-0.0684199184179306,
0.015542530454695225,
-0.27104452252388,
0.3553934097290039,
-0.6687057018280029,
-0.195301815867424,
-0.0034279562532901764,
0.1813531070947647,
-0.5996506214141846,
-0.2856774628162384,
-0.42737776041030884,
-0.4206223785877228,
0.20886525511741638,
0.20282787084579468,
0.6196240782737732,
0.7393612265586853,
0.43126773834228516,
0.3326493203639984,
-0.20938873291015625,
-0.38234755396842957,
-0.1812829226255417,
0.27635422348976135,
-0.2922055423259735,
-0.39472082257270813,
-0.5874689221382141,
0.012990923598408699,
0.3791548013687134,
1.1702741384506226,
0.1633542776107788,
0.15114960074424744,
0.2751207947731018,
0.9147861003875732,
-0.4902649223804474,
0.6800417304039001,
0.11100496351718903,
0.34457406401634216,
-0.27223020792007446,
-0.22267232835292816,
-0.22147639095783234,
-0.11079233139753342,
0.1332968920469284,
-0.5387201905250549,
0.06702307611703873,
-0.03515869006514549,
0.5026400685310364,
-0.04033636674284935,
0.0059172469191253185,
-0.6794629096984863,
-0.8545554876327515,
0.6024964451789856,
-0.4881581664085388,
0.3048059940338135,
0.33231616020202637,
0.2505604922771454,
-0.47862908244132996,
-0.4421467185020447,
-0.6981748342514038,
-0.1412484496831894,
-0.20602019131183624,
-0.12988974153995514,
0.4607458710670471,
0.4080699384212494,
0.3100491762161255,
0.6711056232452393,
-0.49249976873397827,
-0.07899859547615051,
-0.4386453628540039,
-0.1949024200439453,
0.7517623901367188,
0.10753046721220016,
0.22886601090431213,
-0.1768844723701477,
-0.5411587357521057,
0.13080976903438568,
-0.49684232473373413,
-0.11014962196350098,
0.30699294805526733,
0.4953095316886902,
-0.051068875938653946,
0.5239270329475403,
-0.447638601064682,
0.7279651761054993,
-0.08955128490924835,
-0.4627326726913452,
0.2682006061077118,
-0.0978153645992279,
-0.4283185303211212,
-0.03671913594007492,
0.5129043459892273,
0.10699629783630371,
0.14418752491474152,
-0.00822235457599163,
-0.46030938625335693,
0.3614530563354492,
0.38938266038894653,
-0.5965116024017334,
-0.20596905052661896,
0.28145039081573486,
-0.7557309865951538,
-0.4322853982448578,
0.2544716000556946,
-0.45799267292022705,
-0.06316833943128586,
-0.7079675793647766,
0.07721245288848877,
-0.042522091418504715,
-0.9792779684066772,
0.24533309042453766,
-0.34960484504699707,
0.22524595260620117,
0.2938191890716553,
-0.8758879899978638,
0.41730567812919617,
0.6490189433097839,
0.5703792572021484,
-0.2054080069065094,
-0.09881249070167542,
0.4575604200363159,
0.3644859790802002,
-0.7877581715583801,
0.774158239364624,
-0.48802483081817627,
-0.8620483875274658,
0.21734897792339325,
-0.056918058544397354,
0.18236953020095825,
-0.33401599526405334,
0.5897191166877747,
-0.4367298483848572,
0.26235029101371765,
-0.18296778202056885,
-0.7721736431121826,
-0.3255353569984436,
-0.09674383699893951,
-0.6986416578292847,
0.9050411581993103,
0.30991899967193604,
-0.6493645310401917,
0.618474006652832,
-1.15122389793396,
-0.5642223358154297,
0.5202006697654724,
-0.6727637648582458,
-0.0750437006354332,
0.4771140515804291,
-0.7511410117149353,
0.5803090929985046,
-0.26657432317733765,
0.16957987844944,
-0.4198938310146332,
-0.2871427834033966,
0.2993532121181488,
0.1518803834915161,
0.7881599068641663,
0.6279021501541138,
-0.4038925766944885,
-0.07238949090242386,
-1.0821330547332764,
0.17039230465888977,
0.09572349488735199,
-0.7847091555595398,
-0.43321558833122253,
0.21766537427902222,
0.07857818156480789,
0.36715394258499146,
0.13102005422115326,
-0.41131073236465454,
0.12765908241271973,
-0.5316675305366516,
0.41738972067832947,
0.669856071472168,
0.024493500590324402,
0.7636870741844177,
-0.25619781017303467,
0.5468276739120483,
-0.13189783692359924,
-0.18059931695461273,
-0.25492921471595764,
-0.33553117513656616,
-0.9405008554458618,
-0.01343916729092598,
-0.28585341572761536,
0.17362019419670105,
-0.5852689146995544,
0.428272008895874,
0.3078293204307556,
-0.2172384411096573,
0.043202955275774,
-0.04243452101945877,
0.3375682532787323,
0.3560485541820526,
-0.2131233811378479,
-0.3369821608066559,
-0.8055332899093628,
-0.9730893969535828,
0.47731760144233704,
-0.7779540419578552,
-0.03845993056893349,
-0.03669172525405884,
0.43195784091949463,
-0.0025924688670784235,
1.0564228296279907,
-0.6165241003036499,
-0.09689278155565262,
-0.3691216707229614,
0.3382986783981323,
0.45865368843078613,
0.512357234954834,
0.7920160889625549,
-0.9133265614509583,
-0.2620515525341034,
0.01916196011006832,
-0.879240095615387,
-0.21838143467903137,
-0.0043966337107121944,
-0.3782476484775543,
0.269407719373703,
0.2002420723438263,
-0.42405349016189575,
0.6558621525764465,
-0.03161834925413132,
-0.3486172556877136,
0.5575116276741028,
-0.060027431696653366,
0.021824728697538376,
-1.2601330280303955,
0.24949145317077637,
-0.20274212956428528,
0.5452526211738586,
-0.7894948720932007,
0.2619524896144867,
0.002486771671101451,
-0.25598713755607605,
-0.6767666339874268,
0.5236293077468872,
-0.690788745880127,
0.04739844426512718,
-0.7100830078125,
-0.08187997341156006,
0.25273093581199646,
0.4932667315006256,
0.4403037428855896,
0.5058228969573975,
0.7628645300865173,
-1.1787399053573608,
0.3532937467098236,
0.14837323129177094,
-0.3294471800327301,
0.9936667084693909,
-0.5862990021705627,
-0.10244466364383698,
-0.13514389097690582,
-0.3834240734577179,
-1.107824444770813,
-0.09818963706493378,
0.30394548177719116,
-0.06431594491004944,
0.48426470160484314,
0.0033958940766751766,
-0.5635300278663635,
-0.7610636949539185,
0.12215998768806458,
0.2598833739757538,
0.08985107392072678,
-0.0026426136028021574,
0.25869470834732056,
0.6977311968803406,
-0.08755157142877579,
-0.21340663731098175,
-0.9321361184120178,
-0.11580877006053925,
-0.21943658590316772,
-0.9366912245750427,
0.6281750798225403,
-0.26418551802635193,
-0.5994073748588562,
-0.1344357281923294,
-0.29416561126708984,
-0.4795597195625305,
0.3962482511997223,
0.31253743171691895,
0.1691991239786148,
-0.25559717416763306,
0.47591736912727356,
-0.10047597438097,
-0.24004405736923218,
0.28244420886039734,
-0.17634235322475433,
0.3951970636844635,
0.2586771845817566,
-0.39737388491630554,
-0.7611184120178223,
0.7817873358726501,
0.8297141194343567,
0.2672601044178009,
0.38253599405288696,
0.0888672024011612,
-0.661055326461792,
-0.25442636013031006,
-0.18927791714668274,
0.034671422094106674,
-0.5074988007545471,
0.12304634600877762,
-1.1063600778579712,
-0.3960721790790558,
0.626927375793457,
-0.07064114511013031,
0.07666797935962677,
0.3726721704006195,
0.5687350630760193,
-0.11125697940587997,
0.746914803981781,
1.3566207885742188,
0.1834794133901596,
0.4547424614429474,
-0.21254263818264008,
0.20148135721683502,
-0.7934727668762207,
-0.24421806633472443,
-0.5137256383895874,
-0.23823478817939758,
-0.5338020324707031,
-0.12063571065664291,
-0.21324311196804047,
0.33758872747421265,
-0.04991869255900383,
0.6769509315490723,
-0.6223953366279602,
0.07210288196802139,
0.1682509332895279,
-0.36442363262176514,
0.18129761517047882,
-0.12610465288162231,
-0.6015757322311401,
-0.11092983186244965,
-0.4642925560474396,
-1.03986656665802,
0.6428357362747192,
0.46450749039649963,
1.2061160802841187,
0.1714015007019043,
0.7867969870567322,
0.38650643825531006,
0.04781968146562576,
-0.8329096436500549,
0.6814154386520386,
0.4909142553806305,
-0.7220935821533203,
-0.06795535981655121,
0.056748777627944946,
-0.8313750624656677,
0.2629084885120392,
0.09514270722866058,
-0.6187304258346558,
0.38306692242622375,
-0.030875282362103462,
-0.07977349311113358,
0.023170463740825653,
-0.3867782950401306,
0.6679063439369202,
-0.31274673342704773,
-0.5379766821861267,
-0.3496621549129486,
-0.2651035189628601,
0.34619924426078796,
-0.061744365841150284,
0.3601204454898834,
-0.3201751410961151,
0.016001252457499504,
0.7685800790786743,
-0.2870565950870514,
0.8575648069381714,
0.06321088969707489,
-0.5225792527198792,
0.5506337285041809,
0.4077494144439697,
-0.06381446868181229,
-0.017279844731092453,
-0.3216005563735962,
-0.4382413923740387,
0.1373910754919052,
-0.09106934815645218,
-0.3706724941730499,
0.314314067363739,
-0.3579803705215454,
-0.7157566547393799,
-0.32666993141174316,
-0.23229975998401642,
0.05925976485013962,
0.402017205953598,
-0.1641305685043335,
0.38388025760650635,
-0.7155392169952393,
-0.012012042105197906,
0.5788642168045044,
-0.04061836749315262,
0.6237266063690186,
0.5271964073181152,
-0.5543948411941528,
0.058633457869291306,
0.41699540615081787,
0.15379148721694946,
0.15105535089969635,
0.6391693353652954,
0.24239382147789001,
-0.3586331903934479,
-0.46688711643218994,
-0.43129047751426697,
-0.06925525516271591,
-0.7185769081115723,
0.03273855522274971,
-0.3501227796077728,
-0.2560007572174072,
-0.2582785487174988,
-0.2631860673427582,
-0.19595161080360413,
-0.6412989497184753,
-0.27662086486816406,
-0.12024832516908646,
-0.0022859161254018545,
1.1087164878845215,
0.018259799107909203,
0.03661834076046944,
-0.39930734038352966,
0.2826114594936371,
0.10751417279243469,
0.5503238439559937,
-0.0841405987739563,
-0.08792845159769058,
-0.236558198928833,
0.00199326709844172,
-0.4403840899467468,
-1.1257044076919556,
0.15462228655815125,
-0.02569011226296425,
1.1716312170028687,
0.5400952696800232,
0.23994140326976776,
0.43183520436286926,
-0.2981213331222534,
0.5497502684593201,
0.19118854403495789,
-0.7253599166870117,
0.9335090517997742,
-0.47017377614974976,
0.03550931066274643,
0.13871945440769196,
0.18234235048294067,
-0.5061510801315308,
-0.14935337007045746,
-0.7284475564956665,
-0.6717192530632019,
0.5272010564804077,
0.043341513723134995,
0.04687393829226494,
-0.21988368034362793,
0.3875232934951782,
0.17538948357105255,
0.5497112274169922,
-0.5286787152290344,
-0.2644813358783722,
-0.005392291583120823,
0.023709436878561974,
0.5335787534713745,
-0.5587992668151855,
-0.2989490330219269,
-0.012251527048647404,
0.365487277507782,
-0.08042401075363159,
0.32639482617378235,
-0.15066103637218475,
0.05082792416214943,
-0.1931968480348587,
0.3799803555011749,
0.682353138923645,
1.1899359226226807,
0.20593087375164032,
0.20364084839820862,
-0.4243954122066498,
-0.15284359455108643,
0.3217727839946747,
-0.14026154577732086,
-0.06490255892276764,
-0.09601803869009018,
0.15846894681453705,
0.5154097080230713,
0.23158136010169983,
-0.27931973338127136,
0.09432867914438248,
0.09220127016305923,
-0.3980567753314972,
-0.4459083080291748,
0.12993375957012177,
0.025932062417268753,
0.12699194252490997,
0.5508494973182678,
-0.17764067649841309,
0.16234740614891052,
-0.8430653214454651,
0.458498477935791,
0.1983412206172943,
-0.10513675957918167,
-0.38072630763053894,
0.623009204864502,
0.5380613207817078,
-0.49578848481178284,
0.19796758890151978,
-0.3422476351261139,
-0.307464599609375,
0.5014042258262634,
0.5851578712463379,
0.9820373058319092,
-0.12015868723392487,
0.5574214458465576,
0.263755738735199,
-0.07185246050357819,
-0.05904707312583923,
0.7058210372924805,
-0.41668424010276794,
-0.7335782051086426,
-0.33662766218185425,
-1.0610990524291992,
-0.2188396006822586,
-0.0439906120300293,
-0.4310826361179352,
0.41216811537742615,
-0.5955120325088501,
-0.2230759561061859,
-0.17590346932411194,
0.11764939874410629,
-0.491441547870636,
0.20661816000938416,
0.13010676205158234,
0.6873927712440491,
-0.8037852644920349,
0.6532934308052063,
0.9382039904594421,
-0.7407853007316589,
-0.5160369873046875,
-0.2492886483669281,
0.23224329948425293,
-0.5849770903587341,
1.175136685371399,
-0.0134735107421875,
-0.10532383620738983,
-0.34117692708969116,
0.07970218360424042,
-1.1744416952133179,
0.7816459536552429,
0.12074767798185349,
-0.3469301164150238,
0.24461448192596436,
0.2767191529273987,
0.5977498292922974,
-0.7457526326179504,
-0.4126781225204468,
0.35454505681991577,
0.5174508690834045,
0.3999442160129547,
-0.9173372983932495,
0.2933371663093567,
-0.334157258272171,
0.3118523955345154,
0.247738316655159,
-0.3134908676147461,
0.7879503965377808,
-0.058328382670879364,
-0.8644290566444397,
0.30789685249328613,
0.5225011110305786,
0.13228395581245422,
0.007975058630108833,
0.156835675239563,
0.3671590983867645,
0.49119389057159424,
-0.1913386881351471,
0.5707338452339172,
-0.44717156887054443,
-0.025520475581288338,
0.5129097700119019,
-0.20146003365516663,
0.7085400819778442,
0.6208505630493164,
-0.4387495815753937,
0.5537273287773132,
0.7140703797340393,
0.4186089038848877,
0.39677539467811584,
0.6462042927742004,
-0.16576072573661804,
0.05155160278081894,
0.042661264538764954,
-0.43693265318870544,
0.4840307831764221,
0.6151781678199768,
-0.5628787279129028,
-0.11370328813791275,
0.024148698896169662,
-0.12048275768756866,
0.3147715926170349,
-0.15920917689800262,
0.822476863861084,
0.09614367038011551,
-0.584796667098999,
0.40886390209198,
-0.23061324656009674,
0.13957180082798004,
-0.3420737683773041,
-0.017761332914233208,
0.060700491070747375,
0.4312973618507385,
-0.13953715562820435,
-1.1526470184326172,
0.632325291633606,
-0.5678847432136536,
-0.5057668089866638,
-0.5290778279304504,
0.5111818909645081,
-0.1964859813451767,
-0.7108131647109985,
0.188301220536232,
0.8334882855415344,
0.12581053376197815,
0.3855193853378296,
-0.7386128306388855,
0.5693671107292175,
-0.26325830817222595,
-0.18521817028522491,
0.12427285313606262,
0.7202804684638977,
0.04202615097165108,
0.6404274702072144,
0.2616482973098755,
0.1203489899635315,
-0.21435436606407166,
0.2663874924182892,
0.7786193490028381,
-0.500583827495575,
-0.6021335124969482,
-0.5514669418334961,
0.6373744606971741,
-0.1252388209104538,
-0.07441707700490952,
0.3607298731803894,
0.509345531463623,
0.9436986446380615,
-0.0606309175491333,
1.1519237756729126,
-0.6306489109992981,
0.39282506704330444,
-0.4748282730579376,
0.5999659299850464,
-0.24705231189727783,
0.3466121554374695,
-0.6327916979789734,
-1.1546894311904907,
-0.38540199398994446,
1.2431515455245972,
0.08657689392566681,
0.1380310207605362,
0.8179104924201965,
0.6531450152397156,
0.19000934064388275,
0.049171969294548035,
0.37188875675201416,
-0.2716660797595978,
0.49902546405792236,
0.2473142296075821,
0.9203439950942993,
-0.11072678864002228,
0.27415236830711365,
-0.42084357142448425,
-0.6064274311065674,
-0.034875255078077316,
-0.9618340134620667,
-0.9584363102912903,
-1.0289324522018433,
-0.45998653769493103,
0.09264593571424484,
-0.3184404671192169,
0.574390172958374,
0.7370993494987488,
-0.6254874467849731,
-0.8343075513839722,
-0.37529000639915466,
0.10696008801460266,
-0.4583417475223541,
-0.2716526687145233,
0.06482125073671341,
-0.5491819977760315,
-0.6576942801475525,
0.25321462750434875,
0.6234134435653687,
0.37130939960479736,
-0.8723649382591248,
-0.1595975011587143,
-0.10104526579380035,
-0.15563175082206726,
0.7826275825500488,
0.4332182705402374,
-0.6825250387191772,
-0.2859821617603302,
-0.05377034470438957,
0.09601578861474991,
-0.04220879077911377,
1.1855117082595825,
-0.43858474493026733,
0.6456071138381958,
0.8861663341522217,
0.22091902792453766,
0.18869920074939728,
-0.4318963885307312,
1.106388807296753,
-0.4692496359348297,
0.263044536113739,
-0.13637326657772064,
0.6589767932891846,
0.23478251695632935,
-0.16372214257717133,
0.6162149310112,
0.4332939386367798,
-0.3351868689060211,
-0.4685932695865631,
0.9676781296730042,
-0.6270372271537781,
-0.559169352054596,
0.8784151673316956,
0.24707932770252228,
-0.20467238128185272,
-0.5125545263290405,
-0.5657552480697632,
0.08774075657129288,
-0.24903137981891632,
0.9135433435440063,
0.8295718431472778,
-0.6963239908218384,
-0.037212073802948,
-0.4064541161060333,
0.7022600769996643,
-0.20796003937721252,
-0.3608165979385376,
0.29752102494239807,
0.36068195104599,
0.07316851615905762,
0.5335026979446411,
0.7391552925109863,
-0.13002318143844604,
0.07884684950113297,
0.1271921843290329,
0.040146604180336,
0.2089097797870636,
-0.11830829828977585,
0.4182899296283722,
0.5722288489341736,
0.3610135316848755,
-0.3069765269756317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13660v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13660v1
|
Trojan Detection in Large Language Models: Insights from The Trojan Detection Challenge
| 2024-04-21T13:31:16 | 2024-04-21T13:31:16 |
Narek Maloyan, Ekansh Verma, Bulat Nutfullin, Bislan Ashinov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in
various domains, but their vulnerability to trojan or backdoor attacks poses
significant security risks. This paper explores the challenges and insights
gained from the Trojan Detection Competition 2023 (TDC2023), which focused on
identifying and evaluating trojan attacks on LLMs. We investigate the
difficulty of distinguishing between intended and unintended triggers, as well
as the feasibility of reverse engineering trojans in real-world scenarios. Our
comparative analysis of various trojan detection methods reveals that achieving
high Recall scores is significantly more challenging than obtaining high
Reverse-Engineering Attack Success Rate (REASR) scores. The top-performing
methods in the competition achieved Recall scores around 0.16, comparable to a
simple baseline of randomly sampling sentences from a distribution similar to
the given training prefixes. This finding raises questions about the
detectability and recoverability of trojans inserted into the model, given only
the harmful targets. Despite the inability to fully solve the problem, the
competition has led to interesting observations about the viability of trojan
detection and improved techniques for optimizing LLM input prompts. The
phenomenon of unintended triggers and the difficulty in distinguishing them
from intended triggers highlights the need for further research into the
robustness and interpretability of LLMs. The TDC2023 has provided valuable
insights into the challenges and opportunities associated with trojan detection
in LLMs, laying the groundwork for future research in this area to ensure their
safety and reliability in real-world applications.
|
[
-0.17102555930614471,
-0.6520399451255798,
0.7012518048286438,
0.025138409808278084,
-0.26248764991760254,
0.27401068806648254,
-0.05045420303940773,
-0.7853147387504578,
-0.03872758150100708,
0.5115090012550354,
-0.4209216833114624,
-0.560732364654541,
-0.7278708219528198,
0.14039242267608643,
-0.700981855392456,
0.7619857788085938,
0.028476055711507797,
-0.283387154340744,
0.17000330984592438,
0.04723716899752617,
-0.7617474794387817,
-0.8558024168014526,
-0.8070594668388367,
0.011093595065176487,
0.5582199096679688,
0.31017744541168213,
0.21942278742790222,
0.5608086585998535,
0.611829400062561,
0.23502665758132935,
-0.3768233060836792,
-0.029605064541101456,
-0.424565851688385,
0.3455946743488312,
-0.10402174293994904,
-0.6262931227684021,
-0.4751054048538208,
0.13194438815116882,
0.5419703125953674,
0.27195996046066284,
-0.06814755499362946,
0.1995828002691269,
-0.03266262263059616,
0.5426424741744995,
-0.7316922545433044,
-0.05729774385690689,
-0.9878714084625244,
0.11727079749107361,
-0.7380855679512024,
-0.46522340178489685,
-0.7890012860298157,
0.04105902463197708,
-0.05998976156115532,
-0.1430085003376007,
0.22524577379226685,
0.42741701006889343,
0.6265767216682434,
-0.17075900733470917,
-0.5429204106330872,
-0.3036157488822937,
-0.8681176900863647,
0.8222067356109619,
-0.5441945791244507,
0.5051538944244385,
0.08877430111169815,
0.1768898367881775,
-0.7079711556434631,
-0.5967902541160583,
-0.48346948623657227,
-0.3262273669242859,
0.3426036536693573,
0.003550297813490033,
-0.7012873291969299,
-0.11171888560056686,
0.21409152448177338,
0.19117110967636108,
-0.6970104575157166,
0.6375676393508911,
-0.5408436059951782,
-0.4005695879459381,
0.4802330434322357,
0.44211989641189575,
0.32911890745162964,
0.04914814606308937,
-0.2653796672821045,
0.19458648562431335,
-1.0072637796401978,
0.020857546478509903,
0.43170759081840515,
0.2421770542860031,
-0.017697123810648918,
0.4923133850097656,
0.09871231764554977,
0.5759809017181396,
-0.10715208202600479,
-0.06174018234014511,
-0.05281030759215355,
-0.08826852589845657,
-0.07710900902748108,
0.1921239197254181,
0.686203122138977,
-0.027330638840794563,
0.2120160609483719,
-0.2212551385164261,
-0.435833603143692,
-0.15063071250915527,
0.531173586845398,
-0.2193661332130432,
0.0001992788165807724,
0.3974338471889496,
-0.3274335265159607,
-0.4884036183357239,
0.0931539461016655,
-0.7352343797683716,
-0.4985573887825012,
0.11826191842556,
0.35472363233566284,
-0.052079714834690094,
0.03524927794933319,
0.2826409935951233,
-0.001502856146544218,
0.5805560350418091,
0.46373674273490906,
-0.7634173631668091,
0.30291417241096497,
1.0560086965560913,
0.7822182774543762,
-0.6101399660110474,
-0.20349881052970886,
-0.8406724333763123,
0.13315577805042267,
-0.4056175947189331,
0.7107394933700562,
-0.2076561450958252,
-0.2656865417957306,
-0.006455030292272568,
0.023214051499962807,
-0.1496034562587738,
-0.7360775470733643,
0.5788015127182007,
-0.9906539916992188,
0.17814038693904877,
-0.061761319637298584,
-0.42662015557289124,
-0.019548391923308372,
0.4450104534626007,
-0.8129546046257019,
0.7963984608650208,
-0.3281341791152954,
-1.0541969537734985,
0.22077633440494537,
-0.2815225422382355,
-0.45991212129592896,
0.07946642488241196,
-0.025550276041030884,
-0.5643075704574585,
0.30334800481796265,
-0.03747471794486046,
0.4070725739002228,
-0.4767214357852936,
0.22798775136470795,
-0.47975751757621765,
-0.47966060042381287,
0.37607860565185547,
-0.41663238406181335,
0.8675742149353027,
0.1368451714515686,
-0.5536963939666748,
0.19223742187023163,
-0.5740187168121338,
-0.5893922448158264,
0.40193238854408264,
-0.32294273376464844,
-0.06032644212245941,
-0.11948531121015549,
-0.3615418076515198,
0.18496078252792358,
0.09772943705320358,
-0.6897525191307068,
0.0855194702744484,
-0.2771610915660858,
0.3004077076911926,
0.8797560930252075,
0.017474262043833733,
0.08516214042901993,
-0.1303805559873581,
0.7894983291625977,
0.29992765188217163,
0.38380324840545654,
-0.052068375051021576,
-0.6880054473876953,
-0.6483550071716309,
-0.2845873236656189,
0.25916945934295654,
0.864629328250885,
-0.5712463855743408,
0.3520140051841736,
-0.01408760342746973,
-0.45125481486320496,
-0.2528221309185028,
0.0014838390052318573,
0.25204575061798096,
0.5062891840934753,
0.22556841373443604,
-0.28330570459365845,
-0.4834911525249481,
-0.8670961260795593,
-0.49286124110221863,
-0.27769094705581665,
0.10577932000160217,
0.0014165162574499846,
0.7944797277450562,
-0.04601580277085304,
0.7275266647338867,
-0.5140354633331299,
-0.38363805413246155,
-0.5857080817222595,
-0.02601778134703636,
0.22270168364048004,
0.4232673943042755,
0.394295871257782,
-0.7548181414604187,
0.0032231619115918875,
-0.12665978074073792,
-0.7668367624282837,
-0.026723356917500496,
0.0648694783449173,
0.36588531732559204,
0.38038018345832825,
0.8336800932884216,
-0.6895725131034851,
0.5871819853782654,
0.4639891982078552,
-0.17413364350795746,
0.9803029894828796,
-0.21024678647518158,
0.14128845930099487,
-0.8700166940689087,
0.10168132185935974,
-0.1370600461959839,
-0.01806139200925827,
-0.8654536008834839,
0.1614808589220047,
0.12834420800209045,
0.10002495348453522,
-0.7491492629051208,
0.5072982311248779,
-0.2301204949617386,
-0.17704464495182037,
-0.16041257977485657,
0.3385735750198364,
-0.16680678725242615,
0.04183425381779671,
-0.30721861124038696,
0.745442271232605,
0.4337939918041229,
-0.5216070413589478,
0.7839382290840149,
-0.126080721616745,
-0.5346375107765198,
0.21503472328186035,
-0.6727338433265686,
0.2550840675830841,
0.05768406391143799,
0.41558679938316345,
-1.1257928609848022,
-0.15170671045780182,
0.3841571509838104,
-0.6513397693634033,
0.41962218284606934,
-0.021275974810123444,
-0.6237812042236328,
-0.4968765676021576,
-0.5849459767341614,
0.489589124917984,
0.33204105496406555,
-0.5742977857589722,
0.5074566006660461,
0.42215240001678467,
0.02763400971889496,
-0.920600950717926,
-0.6527122855186462,
0.3201262652873993,
-0.7143961191177368,
-0.5020455718040466,
0.04184497520327568,
0.33013731241226196,
-0.3326440453529358,
-0.4111340641975403,
-0.1269945502281189,
0.2698085606098175,
0.7267940044403076,
0.22903954982757568,
0.45719948410987854,
-0.15884970128536224,
0.03576920926570892,
-0.23714470863342285,
-0.3325340151786804,
0.34986934065818787,
-0.6328539252281189,
0.4208793342113495,
0.03729696944355965,
-0.5389346480369568,
-0.6006278991699219,
0.12042208760976791,
0.5669844746589661,
-0.29836761951446533,
0.9155088663101196,
0.373940110206604,
-0.4724859893321991,
-0.05838986113667488,
-0.6882519125938416,
-0.2907867431640625,
-0.4612346887588501,
0.2623070180416107,
-0.25933802127838135,
-1.1563526391983032,
0.6806829571723938,
-0.02347153052687645,
-0.031623393297195435,
0.5222185850143433,
0.6194179058074951,
0.01681046187877655,
0.7937437295913696,
0.5594460964202881,
-0.2910721004009247,
0.25992292165756226,
0.18300598859786987,
0.3784773647785187,
-0.7314199209213257,
-0.5357279777526855,
-0.7858310341835022,
-0.10808447748422623,
-0.6353427767753601,
-0.12579582631587982,
0.37772443890571594,
-0.2755707800388336,
-0.14461153745651245,
0.43742635846138,
0.01153878215700388,
0.3743395507335663,
0.6199491024017334,
-0.12622329592704773,
0.5820001363754272,
-0.1309375911951065,
-0.36149829626083374,
0.0069082980044186115,
-0.5293979048728943,
-0.4591023027896881,
0.9248981475830078,
0.4424198269844055,
0.732147216796875,
0.35910362005233765,
0.8393732905387878,
0.33743545413017273,
0.03357194736599922,
-0.5913642048835754,
0.6787084341049194,
-0.06686832010746002,
-0.8598343133926392,
-0.07213235646486282,
-0.31920453906059265,
-1.2919164896011353,
0.012054401449859142,
-0.3943719267845154,
-1.4650472402572632,
-0.04766567796468735,
0.14979176223278046,
-0.34572160243988037,
0.5937241911888123,
-0.2964839041233063,
0.8654440641403198,
-0.1761675477027893,
-0.3104122281074524,
-0.10934358835220337,
-0.648989200592041,
0.702377200126648,
-0.5938657522201538,
0.36687666177749634,
-0.041053302586078644,
0.17150041460990906,
0.8092978000640869,
-0.0066012111492455006,
0.7358497381210327,
0.19609051942825317,
-0.44237202405929565,
0.26596352458000183,
0.27952495217323303,
0.603267252445221,
0.07776987552642822,
0.08966825157403946,
-0.04014268517494202,
-0.11310391873121262,
-0.23235785961151123,
-0.39163699746131897,
0.6331624388694763,
-0.52324378490448,
-1.126869559288025,
-0.6454862356185913,
-0.26025471091270447,
-0.11644721031188965,
0.11836293339729309,
0.28759363293647766,
0.28134453296661377,
-0.10795344412326813,
0.08567443490028381,
0.8421840667724609,
-0.6507483720779419,
0.2625780701637268,
0.5719391107559204,
-0.3321912884712219,
-0.1639479547739029,
0.9413071870803833,
-0.127900168299675,
0.20126508176326752,
0.5049609541893005,
0.04744986444711685,
-0.07176019996404648,
-0.9578225612640381,
-0.3022058606147766,
0.3502986431121826,
-0.6376756429672241,
-0.1774696260690689,
-0.5389071702957153,
-0.14909428358078003,
-0.3643627464771271,
0.1273709535598755,
-0.4401257634162903,
-0.33516553044319153,
-0.5401960015296936,
-0.07178200781345367,
0.21347609162330627,
0.9103060364723206,
-0.02230411395430565,
0.15489110350608826,
-0.9915175437927246,
0.1454266905784607,
0.21603690087795258,
0.16574205458164215,
0.10263370722532272,
-0.9399968385696411,
-0.11234798282384872,
-0.4015248715877533,
-0.35146117210388184,
-0.889101505279541,
0.3879329562187195,
-0.41591203212738037,
0.4749457836151123,
0.29099997878074646,
0.04584512487053871,
0.28493818640708923,
-0.398894339799881,
0.8265120983123779,
-0.1036766842007637,
-0.970672607421875,
0.4911271929740906,
-0.286872923374176,
0.1226220354437828,
0.1938210427761078,
0.44886741042137146,
-0.5290405750274658,
-0.49142614006996155,
-0.49588215351104736,
-0.872399628162384,
0.6677064299583435,
0.18897950649261475,
-0.06943480670452118,
0.08799057453870773,
0.5235819816589355,
-0.08020886033773422,
-0.019596951082348824,
-0.5403519868850708,
-0.15895874798297882,
0.6382100582122803,
-0.0068695866502821445,
0.044838231056928635,
-0.3670542240142822,
0.05540527030825615,
0.07149038463830948,
0.5576398372650146,
0.36375150084495544,
0.18905392289161682,
-0.2328340858221054,
0.008830920793116093,
0.06172316148877144,
0.3128109276294708,
0.7956316471099854,
0.20559543371200562,
-0.09343719482421875,
0.27486005425453186,
0.37576645612716675,
-0.7620015144348145,
0.26770636439323425,
-0.024798857048153877,
0.033600594848394394,
-0.3705902397632599,
0.7810945510864258,
0.404052197933197,
0.00892794132232666,
-0.8667860627174377,
0.5567216873168945,
-0.3300747275352478,
-0.010713801719248295,
-0.4755522310733795,
0.05581742152571678,
-0.01855669729411602,
0.5485905408859253,
0.6500441431999207,
-0.37872761487960815,
0.1638878732919693,
-0.45924922823905945,
0.14028427004814148,
0.5970048308372498,
-0.4065275490283966,
-0.4543546438217163,
0.6808041334152222,
-0.06667020171880722,
-0.3051699101924896,
0.784418523311615,
-0.028273766860365868,
-0.8589307069778442,
0.751347005367279,
0.6120546460151672,
0.8689500093460083,
-0.26873287558555603,
-0.26328927278518677,
-0.15473327040672302,
0.5918458700180054,
-0.07021692395210266,
0.13724182546138763,
0.4708418548107147,
-0.7424051761627197,
-0.1938074678182602,
-0.26890435814857483,
-0.5069704055786133,
0.4268134534358978,
-0.5919196605682373,
0.4811578392982483,
-0.3649004101753235,
-0.21567519009113312,
0.09149212390184402,
-0.20680660009384155,
-0.3249075412750244,
-0.03087736666202545,
0.3847428262233734,
1.001956820487976,
-0.731508195400238,
0.6845176815986633,
0.520783543586731,
0.1805989295244217,
-0.633460521697998,
-0.03704163059592247,
0.5451253652572632,
-0.6448249220848083,
0.8355290293693542,
0.21152406930923462,
-0.31860193610191345,
-0.183343306183815,
-0.6170870065689087,
-0.6448741555213928,
1.0292130708694458,
0.4391002953052521,
-0.31327638030052185,
-0.06351600587368011,
0.2696702778339386,
0.4115605354309082,
-0.28527870774269104,
-0.17369870841503143,
0.8105031847953796,
0.2264322191476822,
0.10999063402414322,
-0.9464513063430786,
0.15239767730236053,
0.11249728500843048,
-0.266887903213501,
0.28201475739479065,
-0.3853595554828644,
0.8273237347602844,
-0.3258321285247803,
-0.31560760736465454,
0.11894860118627548,
0.6094763278961182,
0.6274217963218689,
0.5209067463874817,
0.1712045520544052,
0.4051969647407532,
0.40254807472229004,
-0.1669178456068039,
0.8785648941993713,
-0.07375393807888031,
0.2866514027118683,
0.9438868165016174,
-0.40329915285110474,
0.8945305943489075,
0.43239474296569824,
-0.10178110748529434,
0.2552589774131775,
0.5526596903800964,
-0.07243789732456207,
0.13212700188159943,
0.4288783073425293,
-0.43720829486846924,
-0.3277375102043152,
-0.048183560371398926,
-0.179007425904274,
0.7005954384803772,
0.502726674079895,
-0.2875383794307709,
-0.09625589847564697,
0.13858364522457123,
0.06607289612293243,
-0.24524477124214172,
-0.16841818392276764,
0.5315783023834229,
0.21446630358695984,
-0.38849547505378723,
0.32236620783805847,
0.24750913679599762,
0.4833962619304657,
-0.3824034035205841,
0.145451620221138,
-0.24803496897220612,
0.403546005487442,
0.022281724959611893,
-0.7656694054603577,
0.17377667129039764,
0.12179519981145859,
0.28812727332115173,
0.19964231550693512,
0.8285644054412842,
-0.0362374447286129,
0.029065996408462524,
0.4899187982082367,
0.41611483693122864,
0.19109073281288147,
-0.1777639389038086,
-0.38198766112327576,
0.5705422759056091,
-0.2597070336341858,
-0.3500671684741974,
0.4332254230976105,
0.4473761022090912,
-0.3100448250770569,
1.0288439989089966,
0.5004380345344543,
-0.07788015902042389,
0.02153833582997322,
-0.2831140160560608,
0.837260901927948,
-0.746558666229248,
-0.13051095604896545,
-1.117537260055542,
0.08551016449928284,
0.19340430200099945,
-0.027529388666152954,
0.8248916864395142,
0.584819495677948,
0.7742515802383423,
-0.20433759689331055,
0.4723081886768341,
0.4856642484664917,
0.2828519344329834,
-0.5389981865882874,
0.5884563326835632,
-0.45232927799224854,
0.6310860514640808,
-0.303855836391449,
-0.6647176146507263,
-0.6947724223136902,
0.05781206116080284,
-0.4072447717189789,
0.00732634961605072,
0.6739264130592346,
0.6027844548225403,
0.13259311020374298,
0.14976690709590912,
0.2839759886264801,
0.26436948776245117,
0.5550650954246521,
0.7139608860015869,
1.14299476146698,
-0.32549917697906494,
0.6115127801895142,
0.18275392055511475,
-0.1444569230079651,
-0.45123133063316345,
-0.9974600076675415,
-0.9229022264480591,
-0.46898147463798523,
-0.15323707461357117,
-0.5475744605064392,
0.38525205850601196,
0.8223395347595215,
0.14518208801746368,
-1.110737681388855,
-0.20472221076488495,
0.16118860244750977,
0.42545074224472046,
0.05636671930551529,
-0.17464300990104675,
0.23120644688606262,
-0.06946162134408951,
-0.42720282077789307,
0.389259397983551,
0.5589796900749207,
0.2866058051586151,
-0.1164991706609726,
0.2903748154640198,
-0.23410600423812866,
0.09396043419837952,
0.5678867101669312,
0.5675702691078186,
-0.6868361234664917,
-0.44601714611053467,
0.07648671418428421,
-0.20973104238510132,
-0.2993434965610504,
0.8894127607345581,
-0.6704743504524231,
0.05383092537522316,
0.39985498785972595,
0.7378607392311096,
0.38606372475624084,
-0.31365281343460083,
0.5520308613777161,
-0.3847074806690216,
0.0693344920873642,
0.1359197050333023,
0.43863046169281006,
0.14938026666641235,
-0.1861710101366043,
0.29537782073020935,
0.4943968951702118,
-0.5171089768409729,
-1.0142509937286377,
0.3980628550052643,
-1.0041491985321045,
-0.21027104556560516,
1.0431307554244995,
-0.333581805229187,
-0.17980492115020752,
-0.4892004728317261,
-0.019047202542424202,
0.23945215344429016,
-0.09498913586139679,
1.0496807098388672,
0.6516320109367371,
-0.01576908677816391,
-0.04958997666835785,
-0.7305902242660522,
0.4043583869934082,
0.23493526875972748,
-0.6860714554786682,
0.21346254646778107,
0.19983550906181335,
0.14785338938236237,
0.09735741466283798,
0.18399639427661896,
-0.3172779977321625,
0.4364418387413025,
-0.3004210889339447,
-0.29824891686439514,
0.06169635057449341,
-0.5614767670631409,
-0.5983336567878723,
0.27280911803245544,
0.3362060785293579,
-0.01440234761685133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13645v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13645v1
|
PEACH: Pretrained-embedding Explanation Across Contextual and Hierarchical Structure
| 2024-04-21T12:41:02 | 2024-04-21T12:41:02 |
Feiqi Cao, Caren Han, Hyunsuk Chung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we propose a novel tree-based explanation technique, PEACH
(Pretrained-embedding Explanation Across Contextual and Hierarchical
Structure), that can explain how text-based documents are classified by using
any pretrained contextual embeddings in a tree-based human-interpretable
manner. Note that PEACH can adopt any contextual embeddings of the PLMs as a
training input for the decision tree. Using the proposed PEACH, we perform a
comprehensive analysis of several contextual embeddings on nine different NLP
text classification benchmarks. This analysis demonstrates the flexibility of
the model by applying several PLM contextual embeddings, its attribute
selections, scaling, and clustering methods. Furthermore, we show the utility
of explanations by visualising the feature selection and important trend of
text classification via human-interpretable word-cloud-based trees, which
clearly identify model mistakes and assist in dataset debugging. Besides
interpretability, PEACH outperforms or is similar to those from pretrained
models.
|
[
-0.2743281126022339,
-0.9493396282196045,
0.6549479365348816,
0.21201974153518677,
-0.3230349123477936,
0.04878424480557442,
-0.24061046540737152,
-0.187311589717865,
0.10233049094676971,
0.2774158716201782,
-0.9053459763526917,
-0.44975006580352783,
-0.515937864780426,
0.07866609841585159,
-0.4430468678474426,
1.3052654266357422,
-0.23783408105373383,
-0.21151356399059296,
-0.5737179517745972,
0.05757800117135048,
-0.7176073789596558,
-0.5566452741622925,
-0.410516619682312,
-0.19601379334926605,
0.3124311864376068,
0.3463631272315979,
0.699347972869873,
0.7530656456947327,
0.2741805911064148,
0.2956847548484802,
-0.21494029462337494,
-0.26067447662353516,
-0.2400575578212738,
0.0019610209856182337,
-0.16885784268379211,
-0.8066927790641785,
-0.4438735842704773,
0.13220518827438354,
0.7068467140197754,
0.7572553753852844,
-0.14801029860973358,
-0.11689582467079163,
0.39570721983909607,
0.4111210107803345,
-0.504770040512085,
0.5018491744995117,
-0.6795328259468079,
0.4139977991580963,
-0.32697001099586487,
-0.39670270681381226,
-0.6110453605651855,
-0.09642361849546432,
0.15768790245056152,
-0.8371872901916504,
0.36105719208717346,
0.16734494268894196,
0.92961186170578,
0.4504704475402832,
-0.3731232285499573,
-0.1041080579161644,
-0.2780730724334717,
0.8070558309555054,
-0.37214773893356323,
0.25127243995666504,
0.31360936164855957,
0.5290132164955139,
0.06370376795530319,
-0.873669445514679,
-0.30451005697250366,
0.2636091113090515,
-0.3698233664035797,
0.1462089866399765,
0.21748438477516174,
0.1684475541114807,
0.2969868779182434,
0.5172539353370667,
-0.25640594959259033,
0.01595950312912464,
0.2603328227996826,
-0.19081108272075653,
0.46757572889328003,
-0.05143218860030174,
0.40713629126548767,
-0.2481662780046463,
-0.38164427876472473,
0.1448846310377121,
-0.5234551429748535,
0.2442847192287445,
-0.2328152358531952,
0.345965713262558,
-0.15004079043865204,
0.216385155916214,
0.11446688324213028,
0.6806562542915344,
-0.019556347280740738,
-0.1192248985171318,
0.3584091067314148,
-0.34982800483703613,
-0.43124109506607056,
0.24323517084121704,
0.7456799745559692,
0.22481735050678253,
0.08745598047971725,
-0.42096298933029175,
-0.004136740695685148,
0.00004847622767556459,
0.29396265745162964,
-0.9634155631065369,
-0.17614975571632385,
0.08666486293077469,
-0.6983799338340759,
-0.40035492181777954,
0.16179664433002472,
-0.8639943599700928,
-0.3847707211971283,
-0.014225762337446213,
0.1663195937871933,
-0.2821286618709564,
-0.2016245275735855,
-0.1118372306227684,
-0.21034279465675354,
0.04199368506669998,
0.4034707844257355,
-1.2483996152877808,
0.4682139754295349,
0.8857318162918091,
0.8890190124511719,
0.023177413269877434,
-0.352311909198761,
-0.426785945892334,
0.05400148034095764,
-0.3660017251968384,
0.6517035365104675,
-0.6254656314849854,
-0.06657914072275162,
-0.2084815949201584,
0.26738855242729187,
-0.24386456608772278,
-0.062248799949884415,
0.8296767473220825,
-0.16957691311836243,
0.4782138466835022,
-0.5044893622398376,
-0.5592035055160522,
-0.6123778223991394,
0.17843230068683624,
-0.4950035512447357,
0.7575929164886475,
0.2302282452583313,
-1.2259167432785034,
0.8405900001525879,
-0.829594075679779,
-0.25333699584007263,
0.24947194755077362,
-0.3396214246749878,
-0.6082867980003357,
0.07360632717609406,
0.5737754106521606,
0.5325828790664673,
-0.2072136253118515,
0.6063418388366699,
-0.24873696267604828,
-0.3124701678752899,
-0.05193963274359703,
-0.3836270868778229,
0.8834890723228455,
0.30324748158454895,
-0.4267304241657257,
0.19169765710830688,
-0.2130805104970932,
0.020668065175414085,
0.3200618028640747,
-0.0404101125895977,
-0.3525056838989258,
0.497674822807312,
-0.09201715141534805,
-0.10464002192020416,
0.152555450797081,
-0.4613504707813263,
0.1766369491815567,
-0.3692118227481842,
0.7974105477333069,
0.337152898311615,
-0.12662027776241302,
0.5490401983261108,
-0.2771744728088379,
0.7538736462593079,
0.15492825210094452,
0.12592585384845734,
-0.8597842454910278,
-0.605534553527832,
-0.1738443225622177,
-0.11054320633411407,
0.48598799109458923,
0.4339997172355652,
-0.41241347789764404,
0.38895195722579956,
-0.2761729955673218,
0.0421740747988224,
-0.21818678081035614,
-0.14445248246192932,
0.22850994765758514,
0.9019303917884827,
0.2782827317714691,
-0.46704503893852234,
-0.5098617672920227,
-0.7548918724060059,
-0.3748460114002228,
-0.01843702606856823,
0.0397147573530674,
0.49499911069869995,
0.41839858889579773,
-0.312427282333374,
1.423594355583191,
-0.2550411522388458,
-0.12533435225486755,
-0.17118501663208008,
0.3371846675872803,
0.1914326399564743,
0.2987668514251709,
0.6269672513008118,
-1.0650646686553955,
-0.31552979350090027,
-0.06801215559244156,
-0.6837325096130371,
-0.27253177762031555,
-0.4482777714729309,
0.01283634826540947,
-0.06336217373609543,
0.4252684414386749,
-0.2879856526851654,
0.33195367455482483,
0.2652822434902191,
-0.6504879593849182,
0.6463897824287415,
-0.12353377789258957,
0.07002406567335129,
-0.9882333874702454,
-0.2048497200012207,
-0.03843557834625244,
-0.5690008401870728,
-0.2762558162212372,
0.15396064519882202,
0.29810792207717896,
-0.24987463653087616,
-0.14426830410957336,
0.20096857845783234,
-0.525148332118988,
-0.4004623293876648,
0.12177817523479462,
0.1996239721775055,
0.2812409996986389,
0.4004873037338257,
0.16915342211723328,
0.7598165273666382,
0.6113294363021851,
-0.3335038423538208,
0.023612402379512787,
0.6068658828735352,
-0.3107028901576996,
0.4050768315792084,
-0.40866705775260925,
-0.15084506571292877,
-0.2481304556131363,
0.4872250556945801,
-0.8292255997657776,
-0.20439022779464722,
0.1268659383058548,
-0.39562416076660156,
0.18889282643795013,
-0.40580040216445923,
-0.23749393224716187,
-0.36921021342277527,
-0.37843236327171326,
0.17393453419208527,
0.25590434670448303,
-0.7640263438224792,
0.5581631660461426,
0.4013236165046692,
-0.36373573541641235,
-0.42577236890792847,
-0.8687663674354553,
0.08054481446743011,
-0.595994234085083,
-0.6242943406105042,
0.8592305779457092,
0.04388369247317314,
-0.020026374608278275,
0.099917471408844,
-0.20088854432106018,
-0.3463267982006073,
0.646609902381897,
0.5886747241020203,
0.09818243980407715,
-0.4699518382549286,
0.3675599992275238,
0.18681210279464722,
-0.1004423052072525,
0.1904343068599701,
-0.2298058569431305,
0.08964807540178299,
-0.49566882848739624,
-0.1252361536026001,
-0.450116902589798,
0.2160208374261856,
0.3784621059894562,
-0.3313746750354767,
0.8269274830818176,
0.41853928565979004,
-0.25020599365234375,
-0.3620310425758362,
0.001827000523917377,
-0.03089413046836853,
-0.42498326301574707,
0.25846990942955017,
-0.5234360694885254,
-0.7626866698265076,
0.3495926856994629,
-0.3761975169181824,
0.24627970159053802,
0.4724314212799072,
0.23259687423706055,
-0.15372924506664276,
1.2497799396514893,
0.7460773587226868,
-0.09050582349300385,
0.6065457463264465,
-0.19446003437042236,
0.04888518899679184,
-0.6821827292442322,
-0.3031066358089447,
-0.6082526445388794,
-0.21481288969516754,
-0.423004150390625,
-0.3061995208263397,
-0.10002586245536804,
0.5944053530693054,
-0.4064733386039734,
0.12779434025287628,
-0.6803529262542725,
0.6652724742889404,
0.33015355467796326,
-0.18404945731163025,
0.22343593835830688,
-0.04103482887148857,
-0.2845558822154999,
-0.1876804530620575,
-0.8424422144889832,
-0.6711179614067078,
0.7507296800613403,
0.7315336465835571,
0.45662233233451843,
-0.20676378905773163,
0.746181070804596,
0.06515687704086304,
0.49274423718452454,
-1.025605320930481,
0.13516229391098022,
-0.23463110625743866,
-0.46045631170272827,
-0.20456789433956146,
-0.5138898491859436,
-0.9938951134681702,
0.429688423871994,
-0.46404165029525757,
-0.9932422637939453,
-0.1378728300333023,
0.17814268171787262,
-0.494176983833313,
0.1394248902797699,
-1.0464732646942139,
1.493614912033081,
-0.6258032917976379,
-0.0787590965628624,
0.045184843242168427,
-0.3188551664352417,
0.3872964680194855,
-0.16325296461582184,
0.6290658712387085,
0.15697868168354034,
-0.08605758100748062,
1.1640266180038452,
-0.7298201322555542,
0.5216330289840698,
-0.3543659448623657,
0.2334308922290802,
0.17242728173732758,
0.016496865078806877,
0.3556174039840698,
-0.008062115870416164,
-0.08435135334730148,
0.12951040267944336,
0.15202867984771729,
-0.12134527415037155,
-0.7708112001419067,
0.4984032213687897,
-0.627454936504364,
-0.6140711903572083,
-0.37128961086273193,
-0.4694141745567322,
-0.29231250286102295,
0.24433523416519165,
0.17492660880088806,
0.630741536617279,
0.03627957031130791,
0.5954152345657349,
0.2502604126930237,
-0.25140923261642456,
0.47880035638809204,
0.25022679567337036,
-0.49530091881752014,
0.1005890965461731,
0.6178913116455078,
-0.05044200271368027,
-0.4069449007511139,
0.3951677978038788,
0.6345558166503906,
-0.5701544880867004,
-0.8028727769851685,
-0.35124671459198,
0.04611486196517944,
-0.4378963112831116,
0.15325894951820374,
-0.5560464859008789,
0.018230680376291275,
-0.09819116443395615,
-0.3486820459365845,
-0.054274559020996094,
-0.4309197962284088,
-0.4944661855697632,
-0.19441072642803192,
0.1774963140487671,
0.8519442081451416,
0.4126059412956238,
0.7819250822067261,
-0.7497748136520386,
0.31183332204818726,
0.18804585933685303,
0.6487933397293091,
-0.09538565576076508,
-0.4340575635433197,
-0.2372232973575592,
0.23272095620632172,
-0.495889812707901,
-1.3470392227172852,
0.5661607384681702,
0.5374647974967957,
0.6941673755645752,
0.5679475665092468,
-0.07813861966133118,
0.6513241529464722,
-0.472732275724411,
0.832058310508728,
0.2229013442993164,
-1.12493896484375,
0.915922999382019,
-0.3813631534576416,
0.052632659673690796,
0.6350369453430176,
0.4217342734336853,
-0.3502846658229828,
-0.054079096764326096,
-0.8396807909011841,
-0.7589607834815979,
1.1088855266571045,
-0.12326069921255112,
-0.283680260181427,
0.182500958442688,
0.4454154372215271,
0.1609736979007721,
0.17084994912147522,
-0.9346888661384583,
-0.0029848122503608465,
-0.4920223653316498,
-0.25163543224334717,
-0.2928719222545624,
-0.33399248123168945,
-0.00950867123901844,
-0.16617757081985474,
0.5126850008964539,
-0.24960635602474213,
0.06297089904546738,
0.0320822149515152,
-0.40787971019744873,
-0.008455461822450161,
0.3022514879703522,
-0.08983483910560608,
0.7832129001617432,
-0.26012513041496277,
0.06775274127721786,
-0.05261268466711044,
-0.29545456171035767,
-0.18073689937591553,
0.11345015466213226,
-0.21221405267715454,
0.016154726967215538,
0.4996795952320099,
1.0114370584487915,
0.457064151763916,
-0.3703821301460266,
0.7456547617912292,
-0.32469674944877625,
-0.15738625824451447,
0.013647681102156639,
0.05451645702123642,
0.10299594700336456,
0.0034291804768145084,
0.27283158898353577,
-0.2021341621875763,
0.14776310324668884,
-0.7904897332191467,
0.3739195764064789,
0.47060561180114746,
-0.41799813508987427,
-0.17806455492973328,
0.8687803149223328,
0.3847355246543884,
-0.3656487762928009,
0.5034205913543701,
-0.12283749133348465,
-0.8709276914596558,
0.6180421710014343,
0.5815334320068359,
0.8161110877990723,
0.11615515500307083,
0.6425372362136841,
0.20438048243522644,
0.2689036726951599,
-0.07891622930765152,
-0.0244771558791399,
-0.6500849723815918,
-0.6276809573173523,
-0.5995206236839294,
-0.8089675307273865,
-0.45201727747917175,
-0.04890580102801323,
-0.6893407106399536,
0.07765189558267593,
-0.40296000242233276,
-0.05552972853183746,
0.36750078201293945,
0.14687566459178925,
-0.5107586979866028,
0.32986900210380554,
0.1503913849592209,
0.9898388981819153,
-1.0757596492767334,
0.72282874584198,
0.697010338306427,
-0.3096981644630432,
-1.0639034509658813,
0.1641526073217392,
0.16346335411071777,
-0.4258514642715454,
0.5338610410690308,
0.5689475536346436,
0.2904168665409088,
-0.12715564668178558,
-0.3639812767505646,
-0.6331244707107544,
1.1410177946090698,
0.499785840511322,
-0.7418590188026428,
-0.061444271355867386,
-0.23689749836921692,
0.41288113594055176,
-0.5254338979721069,
0.6570097208023071,
0.6462236642837524,
0.4579370319843292,
-0.05186736583709717,
-0.9308146834373474,
0.025592636317014694,
-0.17580246925354004,
0.02012879028916359,
0.08534973114728928,
-0.09566580504179001,
0.9255372881889343,
-0.021805137395858765,
-0.5983513593673706,
-0.3423709273338318,
0.4227142632007599,
0.025042708963155746,
0.42784297466278076,
0.6022154092788696,
0.597952663898468,
1.0046772956848145,
-0.4096897542476654,
1.418663740158081,
-0.2006206214427948,
0.5445197224617004,
1.185523509979248,
0.1795842945575714,
0.7281599044799805,
0.19546735286712646,
-0.431471586227417,
0.9329131245613098,
1.0686911344528198,
0.28932955861091614,
0.4684925675392151,
-0.11083287745714188,
0.030202100053429604,
-0.13884273171424866,
0.046397265046834946,
-0.4681941866874695,
0.4282490611076355,
0.5259830355644226,
-0.49172887206077576,
-0.44707807898521423,
0.023196781054139137,
-0.1377858817577362,
0.06669538468122482,
-0.5349900722503662,
0.7595130205154419,
0.11350928246974945,
-0.7692610621452332,
0.47689348459243774,
0.04295990988612175,
0.831993043422699,
-0.4682973623275757,
0.11493265628814697,
0.11240950226783752,
0.08790706843137741,
-0.5541431903839111,
-0.9373345971107483,
0.5317749381065369,
0.009174064733088017,
-0.1569846123456955,
-0.7623370289802551,
0.6981638073921204,
-0.33059555292129517,
-0.21743588149547577,
0.10137966275215149,
0.3068198263645172,
0.2645343542098999,
-0.4082641005516052,
-1.058184266090393,
-0.09484045952558517,
-0.045469895005226135,
-0.31275129318237305,
0.17024186253547668,
0.6484494805335999,
-0.25382712483406067,
0.5765204429626465,
0.46489372849464417,
-0.010542519390583038,
-0.24774259328842163,
0.09379550069570541,
0.5260408520698547,
-0.6120732426643372,
-1.2081630229949951,
-0.8331608176231384,
0.38449206948280334,
-0.01400008611381054,
0.005394700448960066,
0.843660295009613,
0.37750333547592163,
0.3692794144153595,
0.19098643958568573,
0.7759186625480652,
-0.02076328545808792,
0.5273671746253967,
-0.491979718208313,
0.7734514474868774,
-0.5849255323410034,
0.27129849791526794,
-0.4304894804954529,
-0.9322472214698792,
-0.10686161369085312,
0.9344621896743774,
-0.520038902759552,
0.023820750415325165,
0.9903919696807861,
0.3204415738582611,
-0.11187759041786194,
0.5920335054397583,
-0.07824375480413437,
0.41313061118125916,
0.1281842589378357,
0.6194559335708618,
0.6686448454856873,
-0.10438678413629532,
0.3554055988788605,
-0.12342479825019836,
-0.5068124532699585,
-0.16493943333625793,
-1.305694818496704,
-0.5854548215866089,
-0.6849247813224792,
-0.37130245566368103,
0.09501754492521286,
-0.14455461502075195,
0.4215179681777954,
1.0117311477661133,
-0.7649111151695251,
0.17745326459407806,
-0.5087486505508423,
0.5043289661407471,
-0.2231883853673935,
-0.30237048864364624,
0.273711621761322,
-0.442439466714859,
-0.33687904477119446,
0.42590317130088806,
0.14951781928539276,
-0.13267311453819275,
-0.018445158377289772,
-0.11161218583583832,
0.07841742783784866,
-0.32715436816215515,
0.5916881561279297,
0.21288160979747772,
-0.6544015407562256,
-0.17722181975841522,
-0.5447739362716675,
0.27448514103889465,
0.2180991917848587,
0.907312273979187,
-1.1308326721191406,
0.6248375177383423,
0.5002994537353516,
0.8041282296180725,
0.6224648356437683,
0.4130474030971527,
0.6532944440841675,
-0.8618529438972473,
0.1479642540216446,
0.2245304435491562,
0.627768874168396,
0.332969605922699,
-0.47084543108940125,
0.37089312076568604,
0.16346804797649384,
-0.3324127197265625,
-0.711481511592865,
-0.0357447974383831,
-0.9082761406898499,
-0.6076138615608215,
0.8083589673042297,
-0.47470808029174805,
-0.45396265387535095,
-0.26514193415641785,
-0.2760515809059143,
0.1049487367272377,
-0.157049298286438,
0.5727552175521851,
0.7145054936408997,
-0.043291378766298294,
-0.44860801100730896,
-0.4453165531158447,
0.7168288826942444,
0.43839138746261597,
-1.2307556867599487,
0.1599052995443344,
0.4693937301635742,
0.23700015246868134,
0.1357727199792862,
0.7195771932601929,
-0.19627325236797333,
0.2843274176120758,
0.051855750381946564,
-0.3137403428554535,
-0.42564642429351807,
-0.5085474848747253,
-0.5511132478713989,
0.2901412546634674,
0.0026116040535271168,
-0.1696305125951767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13633v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13633v1
|
Incorporating Different Verbal Cues to Improve Text-Based Computer-Delivered Health Messaging
| 2024-04-21T12:15:44 | 2024-04-21T12:15:44 |
Samuel Rhys Cox
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
The ubiquity of smartphones has led to an increase in on demand healthcare
being supplied. For example, people can share their illness-related experiences
with others similar to themselves, and healthcare experts can offer advice for
better treatment and care for remediable, terminal and mental illnesses. As
well as this human-to-human communication, there has been an increased use of
human-to-computer digital health messaging, such as chatbots. These can prove
advantageous as they offer synchronous and anonymous feedback without the need
for a human conversational partner. However, there are many subtleties involved
in human conversation that a computer agent may not properly exhibit. For
example, there are various conversational styles, etiquettes, politeness
strategies or empathic responses that need to be chosen appropriately for the
conversation. Encouragingly, computers are social actors (CASA) posits that
people apply the same social norms to computers as they would do to people. On
from this, previous studies have focused on applying conversational strategies
to computer agents to make them embody more favourable human characteristics.
However, if a computer agent fails in this regard it can lead to negative
reactions from users. Therefore, in this dissertation we describe a series of
studies we carried out to lead to more effective human-to-computer digital
health messaging.
In our first study, we use the crowd [...]
Our second study investigates the effect of a health chatbot's conversational
style [...]
In our final study, we investigate the format used by a chatbot when [...]
In summary, we have researched how to create more effective digital health
interventions starting from generating health messages, to choosing an
appropriate formality of messaging, and finally to formatting messages which
reference a user's previous utterances.
|
[
0.024172374978661537,
-1.1144587993621826,
0.7632054090499878,
0.303205668926239,
-0.31185585260391235,
0.008735165931284428,
-0.22906924784183502,
-0.7438943982124329,
0.722513735294342,
0.34567487239837646,
-0.45180070400238037,
-0.4128194749355316,
-0.584953784942627,
0.27834317088127136,
-0.22316987812519073,
0.9476553201675415,
0.36384302377700806,
0.20109502971172333,
-0.21380123496055603,
0.05222658812999725,
-0.6498852372169495,
-0.8346613049507141,
-0.9133115410804749,
-0.6062694787979126,
0.626457154750824,
0.6845256686210632,
1.1204698085784912,
0.3763795495033264,
0.5435767769813538,
0.2949698269367218,
0.08487753570079803,
0.3605673313140869,
-0.37463897466659546,
0.362191766500473,
-0.0479816198348999,
-0.2454918473958969,
-0.46156394481658936,
-0.16383162140846252,
0.14265307784080505,
0.38307762145996094,
-0.1806558221578598,
0.02412077598273754,
0.2303873896598816,
0.547566831111908,
-0.40304818749427795,
0.07118215411901474,
-0.2966742515563965,
0.18089421093463898,
-0.13711710274219513,
-0.4985772967338562,
-0.6028014421463013,
-0.19377358257770538,
0.11980008333921432,
-0.7391977310180664,
-0.2524196207523346,
-0.24340231716632843,
0.8958473801612854,
0.3292338252067566,
-0.5773237347602844,
-0.5105432271957397,
-1.0366370677947998,
0.4060141146183014,
-0.7301346659660339,
0.16487817466259003,
0.6623074412345886,
0.27472761273384094,
-0.22176019847393036,
-0.6667240262031555,
-0.20785118639469147,
-0.11713311076164246,
-0.10774052888154984,
0.33655086159706116,
-0.25264987349510193,
0.32120639085769653,
-0.05685780197381973,
0.021790115162730217,
-0.2435532808303833,
0.0669274851679802,
-0.32083776593208313,
-0.3794976472854614,
0.9092957377433777,
0.278110533952713,
0.5984129309654236,
-0.23256805539131165,
0.06670796126127243,
-0.22435155510902405,
-0.21927893161773682,
-0.057635195553302765,
0.04619615897536278,
0.2695768475532532,
-0.5822585225105286,
0.4624622166156769,
0.00523312296718359,
0.32535460591316223,
0.5673649907112122,
-0.349226713180542,
0.22318215668201447,
-0.3677041232585907,
-0.15296676754951477,
0.14516888558864594,
0.8173094391822815,
0.818644642829895,
0.36237889528274536,
0.22887974977493286,
0.3704642951488495,
0.3136026859283447,
0.5921988487243652,
-0.7115858793258667,
-0.34320202469825745,
0.40537509322166443,
-0.8532289862632751,
-0.31649360060691833,
0.02703273482620716,
-0.9412409663200378,
-0.6081140041351318,
-0.14231301844120026,
0.33658596873283386,
-0.4469321370124817,
-0.09102868288755417,
0.1231774240732193,
-0.16648060083389282,
0.2609340250492096,
0.24536481499671936,
-0.9199255108833313,
0.6225754022598267,
0.40667739510536194,
0.7167912721633911,
0.188059002161026,
0.3425105810165405,
-0.46137136220932007,
-0.04037041217088699,
-0.19670790433883667,
0.7779492735862732,
-0.6851988434791565,
-0.6083952784538269,
0.14190338551998138,
-0.06691912561655045,
-0.12637357413768768,
-0.506218433380127,
0.5872026681900024,
0.008757400326430798,
0.5327228903770447,
-0.428137868642807,
-0.2665925621986389,
0.3257085978984833,
0.21360516548156738,
-0.36788037419319153,
0.8672866821289062,
-0.06771011650562286,
-0.8021021485328674,
-0.004733760841190815,
-0.8559132218360901,
-0.847488522529602,
0.11794537305831909,
-0.39299002289772034,
-0.6707575917243958,
0.08928529918193817,
0.38897132873535156,
0.5346364974975586,
-0.11268458515405655,
-0.13598965108394623,
-0.20157593488693237,
-0.461418092250824,
0.6246746778488159,
-0.3171989619731903,
0.6293010711669922,
0.30362141132354736,
-0.5312640070915222,
0.3999346196651459,
-0.41656169295310974,
0.19021588563919067,
0.1713080108165741,
-0.07494736462831497,
-0.31188544631004333,
0.3166589140892029,
0.14014515280723572,
0.0963001623749733,
-0.064719058573246,
-0.18351992964744568,
-0.15319782495498657,
-0.5359845161437988,
0.6542460918426514,
0.3820349872112274,
0.34925004839897156,
0.31172052025794983,
-0.8423205614089966,
0.4394056797027588,
-0.15428754687309265,
0.8065057992935181,
-0.400100976228714,
-0.8410884737968445,
-0.1382533311843872,
-0.2844398617744446,
-0.21773667633533478,
0.8793324828147888,
-0.8527652621269226,
0.27635130286216736,
-0.004880682099610567,
-0.3057871162891388,
-0.705978274345398,
-0.21053752303123474,
0.4551934599876404,
0.3953709602355957,
0.2980465292930603,
-0.5845451951026917,
-0.319404274225235,
-0.6037745475769043,
-0.1323142796754837,
-0.6434349417686462,
-0.05921592190861702,
0.7572352886199951,
-0.0945679172873497,
-0.45896852016448975,
0.5513736605644226,
-0.3876117765903473,
0.046209339052438736,
-0.26246148347854614,
0.005743755027651787,
-0.4154040813446045,
0.15243090689182281,
0.29928216338157654,
-0.7773414254188538,
-0.5168622136116028,
0.04980595037341118,
-0.6763810515403748,
-0.24811327457427979,
-0.5348762273788452,
0.06114577874541283,
-0.10085095465183258,
0.3456955850124359,
-0.30801787972450256,
0.7227019667625427,
0.5362197756767273,
-0.36062178015708923,
0.500952959060669,
-0.49273788928985596,
0.6035054922103882,
-1.3447586297988892,
-0.2857505977153778,
0.27549314498901367,
-0.2909381091594696,
-1.014991283416748,
-0.28940412402153015,
-0.24915844202041626,
-0.20196948945522308,
-0.49654191732406616,
0.6237944960594177,
-0.5218387246131897,
0.09420930594205856,
-0.4536598026752472,
0.06794888526201248,
0.08441263437271118,
0.1261000633239746,
-0.18885929882526398,
0.5433777570724487,
0.43924811482429504,
-0.5727620720863342,
0.33370164036750793,
0.3087966740131378,
0.3882234990596771,
1.3123284578323364,
-0.836502194404602,
0.39479222893714905,
-0.22795188426971436,
0.3805687129497528,
-0.8664663434028625,
-0.5617728233337402,
0.6923550963401794,
-0.8784669041633606,
0.13378024101257324,
0.42497047781944275,
-0.45337608456611633,
-0.4095618426799774,
-0.4596770703792572,
0.31421777606010437,
0.5082632899284363,
-0.11059149354696274,
0.48562678694725037,
0.6400063037872314,
-0.29938533902168274,
-0.017598789185285568,
-0.951058030128479,
0.5463676452636719,
-0.35226738452911377,
-0.6440235376358032,
0.520099401473999,
-0.08946824818849564,
-0.6310420036315918,
-0.24290268123149872,
0.2169044017791748,
-0.36830934882164,
0.18656302988529205,
0.607170581817627,
0.3038128614425659,
0.2517252266407013,
0.5343989133834839,
0.17772267758846283,
0.01779332384467125,
0.16112643480300903,
-0.09480691701173782,
0.41857022047042847,
0.0569014810025692,
-0.44920843839645386,
-1.098626732826233,
0.8396950364112854,
0.35691341757774353,
-0.030346255749464035,
0.8315045833587646,
0.6837194561958313,
-0.325725793838501,
0.2308221161365509,
-0.39355549216270447,
-0.8546413779258728,
-0.4696863889694214,
0.11142617464065552,
0.10031022131443024,
-0.6526581048965454,
0.28534024953842163,
-0.07792896777391434,
-0.15574979782104492,
-0.11348051577806473,
0.6663564443588257,
-0.41249528527259827,
1.089685082435608,
0.4712764620780945,
-0.10689219832420349,
0.6105020642280579,
0.28812822699546814,
0.015204044058918953,
-0.3407532572746277,
-0.25855812430381775,
-0.6107131242752075,
-0.20661398768424988,
-0.7600401043891907,
-0.4204433560371399,
0.4895888566970825,
-0.5199488401412964,
-0.24581709504127502,
0.18872174620628357,
-0.9258798360824585,
-0.06698603183031082,
0.44428351521492004,
0.95743727684021,
0.04834989085793495,
-0.06268107146024704,
-0.15309830009937286,
-0.07114776223897934,
-0.6506027579307556,
-0.594978928565979,
0.7726200819015503,
0.3689086437225342,
0.8286169171333313,
-0.052652135491371155,
0.6423249244689941,
0.409260094165802,
0.425056129693985,
-0.5604363083839417,
0.40777578949928284,
0.13454966247081757,
-0.6830760836601257,
-0.12745848298072815,
-0.43322935700416565,
-1.2819085121154785,
-0.16408705711364746,
-0.4409210681915283,
-0.9898402094841003,
-0.04929916560649872,
0.3075638711452484,
-0.5135157704353333,
-0.13331298530101776,
-0.8979807496070862,
0.6794849038124084,
-0.23385249078273773,
-0.2927777171134949,
-0.2734921872615814,
-1.0904209613800049,
-0.33429795503616333,
0.24251480400562286,
0.37771549820899963,
-0.04289282113313675,
0.07210223376750946,
0.29089656472206116,
-0.5534281134605408,
1.2844042778015137,
0.14196376502513885,
-0.03662028908729553,
0.46892425417900085,
-0.36649060249328613,
0.36598479747772217,
-0.05497068539261818,
-0.038389526307582855,
-0.01671922765672207,
0.2218056470155716,
-0.47080570459365845,
-0.5354593396186829,
0.32744869589805603,
-0.9085208773612976,
-0.4802730679512024,
-0.17194439470767975,
-0.2551918625831604,
-0.29532843828201294,
-0.17335863411426544,
0.25627264380455017,
0.7087121605873108,
-0.32617029547691345,
-0.16357891261577606,
0.5636721253395081,
-0.7931116819381714,
0.17843428254127502,
0.2985426187515259,
0.18042801320552826,
-0.4828506410121918,
0.5985990762710571,
-0.313373327255249,
0.3872244954109192,
0.46925678849220276,
0.5527670979499817,
-0.20722146332263947,
0.06240057200193405,
-0.14996257424354553,
0.44878390431404114,
-0.5602182745933533,
0.05688152089715004,
-0.4228225648403168,
-0.2897668778896332,
-0.7387906312942505,
-0.3478986322879791,
0.07074908167123795,
0.046293023973703384,
-0.7382712364196777,
0.04121726378798485,
0.551635205745697,
0.6299740672111511,
-0.010299544781446457,
0.6388844847679138,
-0.971997857093811,
0.1565941423177719,
0.4305153489112854,
0.051857758313417435,
0.008588414639234543,
-0.3097822666168213,
-0.030743300914764404,
0.26183730363845825,
-0.46832337975502014,
-1.6322592496871948,
0.17979606986045837,
0.15458066761493683,
0.4566035270690918,
0.4895695745944977,
0.20754393935203552,
0.6031396389007568,
-0.3011031746864319,
0.8128774762153625,
0.40474170446395874,
-0.8585171699523926,
0.7793124914169312,
-0.4053262174129486,
0.4597252309322357,
0.570798933506012,
0.2996833622455597,
-1.1885432004928589,
-0.3567631244659424,
-0.7044577598571777,
-0.45288917422294617,
0.19457606971263885,
0.3284963369369507,
0.5291178226470947,
-0.4228553771972656,
0.45683753490448,
-0.19983340799808502,
-0.061835311353206635,
-0.43858370184898376,
-0.45999985933303833,
-0.22374005615711212,
-0.6372841000556946,
0.4019712805747986,
-0.2119070440530777,
0.011097940616309643,
0.02854074537754059,
0.3897757828235626,
-0.1764015257358551,
0.5574057102203369,
0.5670114159584045,
0.26647695899009705,
-0.05715961381793022,
0.6153894066810608,
0.5173537731170654,
0.1706364005804062,
0.1973554491996765,
0.1587941199541092,
0.048914238810539246,
-0.6708477139472961,
0.03365803509950638,
-0.011802400462329388,
0.013747798278927803,
0.11882476508617401,
0.272087037563324,
0.5442081093788147,
0.3677434027194977,
-0.7015409469604492,
0.4112541973590851,
-0.14050261676311493,
-0.04754781350493431,
0.11710723489522934,
0.051320627331733704,
0.12524163722991943,
0.0950138047337532,
0.05875345319509506,
-0.25126469135284424,
0.3018856644630432,
-0.8405631184577942,
0.3249906003475189,
0.3702079951763153,
-0.8101783394813538,
-0.4645695388317108,
0.7229102253913879,
0.7176525592803955,
-0.7196298837661743,
0.25658556818962097,
-0.0629555806517601,
-0.3220716416835785,
0.5090048909187317,
0.5584927797317505,
0.6706061959266663,
-0.6112123727798462,
0.7446017861366272,
0.13296695053577423,
0.1795639842748642,
-0.07560651749372482,
0.27969464659690857,
-0.19515816867351532,
-0.5597036480903625,
-0.47607651352882385,
0.3386021554470062,
-0.6490317583084106,
-0.20297077298164368,
-0.5296872854232788,
0.06939776241779327,
-0.4200301468372345,
-0.8871840238571167,
0.3702428340911865,
0.17661145329475403,
-0.5160742998123169,
0.17846053838729858,
0.32783836126327515,
0.428236722946167,
-0.8415573239326477,
0.5073588490486145,
0.9304460287094116,
-0.26487278938293457,
-0.9837341904640198,
0.25198057293891907,
0.5502978563308716,
-0.6314126253128052,
0.10337276756763458,
0.19490675628185272,
-0.1168726459145546,
-0.4944266080856323,
-0.48294922709465027,
-0.3785536587238312,
0.7385699152946472,
0.28940466046333313,
-0.46127966046333313,
0.03483361750841141,
0.3622679114341736,
0.8395129442214966,
-0.1588166207075119,
0.6201213598251343,
0.1615433692932129,
0.42300260066986084,
0.1480109989643097,
-1.3567882776260376,
0.23566700518131256,
-0.3439544141292572,
-0.12662042677402496,
0.012582662515342236,
-0.7785784602165222,
0.2851281762123108,
-0.3543063998222351,
-0.5844622254371643,
0.071375772356987,
0.39942631125450134,
-0.026392420753836632,
0.7000601887702942,
0.32468026876449585,
0.048997972160577774,
1.048831820487976,
0.1597461849451065,
1.2178293466567993,
-0.17582233250141144,
-0.22093403339385986,
1.0820971727371216,
-0.4345128536224365,
0.639858067035675,
0.1585003286600113,
-0.037494439631700516,
0.5258456468582153,
0.5884190201759338,
0.3937491178512573,
0.1517830640077591,
0.14773912727832794,
-0.5425899624824524,
0.10109894722700119,
-0.5010973811149597,
-0.24061620235443115,
0.3531934320926666,
0.5901824831962585,
-0.5322076082229614,
-0.04770120233297348,
0.30432751774787903,
0.4281313419342041,
0.6235458254814148,
-0.19801925122737885,
1.04034423828125,
0.20020854473114014,
-0.4884476959705353,
0.20687949657440186,
-0.011013266630470753,
0.6241908669471741,
-0.2215375006198883,
-0.03782270476222038,
-0.004681495483964682,
-0.009538711979985237,
-0.3626958727836609,
-0.36025524139404297,
0.36953815817832947,
0.0460580438375473,
-0.017325252294540405,
-0.30356666445732117,
1.2799495458602905,
-0.1729363650083542,
-0.4961566627025604,
0.2055806964635849,
0.5515977740287781,
0.3931364119052887,
-0.1817208081483841,
-1.0717272758483887,
0.37934190034866333,
-0.23304562270641327,
0.26858365535736084,
0.08359301835298538,
0.3761582374572754,
-0.08163227140903473,
0.4485987722873688,
0.4584444463253021,
0.3075997531414032,
-0.39392849802970886,
0.3610658347606659,
0.6571885347366333,
-0.6922333240509033,
-0.5264879465103149,
-0.9327949285507202,
0.3171302080154419,
-0.33915919065475464,
-0.154103621840477,
0.7695236206054688,
0.10914292931556702,
0.11550889164209366,
0.3395361304283142,
0.6872333288192749,
0.12863099575042725,
0.3939153552055359,
-0.02301253005862236,
0.5564223527908325,
-0.13438212871551514,
-0.07365884631872177,
-0.5292699933052063,
-0.18400537967681885,
-0.1634533852338791,
0.4704304337501526,
-0.15353821218013763,
0.1260642558336258,
0.5385013818740845,
0.6063905358314514,
0.6640427112579346,
0.1519450694322586,
0.2894223630428314,
-0.055370695888996124,
0.3523097336292267,
0.5870215892791748,
0.7456643581390381,
-0.2389094978570938,
0.37015506625175476,
0.04433564841747284,
-0.5138304233551025,
-0.4892115294933319,
-0.6443729400634766,
-0.9118794202804565,
-0.5263224244117737,
-0.4905417561531067,
-0.5539888739585876,
0.4726733863353729,
1.1364063024520874,
0.9347608685493469,
-0.32943958044052124,
0.1049584224820137,
0.36671391129493713,
-0.015724578872323036,
-0.5164396166801453,
-0.2210838794708252,
-0.016190920025110245,
-0.057835012674331665,
-0.3608167767524719,
0.2163485884666443,
0.5219516754150391,
0.2307368516921997,
-0.08451247960329056,
0.025411395356059074,
0.11010207235813141,
0.5869882702827454,
0.6633686423301697,
0.4067383110523224,
-0.30912983417510986,
-0.3415411114692688,
0.23761382699012756,
-0.4781392812728882,
0.2987992465496063,
0.7614154815673828,
-0.6210404634475708,
0.2730640769004822,
0.08752978593111038,
0.6106788516044617,
0.25565946102142334,
0.30772191286087036,
0.48492908477783203,
-0.6486871838569641,
0.06765049695968628,
0.3333965837955475,
-0.1522587239742279,
0.7151958346366882,
-0.8218231797218323,
0.11145487427711487,
0.06410159170627594,
-0.4687006175518036,
-0.29394519329071045,
-0.05906670168042183,
-1.1052629947662354,
-0.48634088039398193,
1.3499419689178467,
0.2856016755104065,
-0.3992551863193512,
-0.4784519672393799,
-0.725379228591919,
0.2896745502948761,
-0.7011115550994873,
1.0797622203826904,
0.5580650568008423,
-0.26305386424064636,
-0.007769919000566006,
-0.47773119807243347,
0.4017990231513977,
0.2570476830005646,
-1.4950541257858276,
-0.20149309933185577,
0.5475246906280518,
0.046041958034038544,
0.07314042747020721,
1.2450551986694336,
-0.19704151153564453,
0.38714709877967834,
-0.05418269708752632,
-0.07288668304681778,
0.21666404604911804,
-0.02760816551744938,
-0.11358208954334259,
-0.13323348760604858,
-0.10829781740903854,
-0.3566584587097168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13630v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13630v2
|
Utilizing Deep Learning to Optimize Software Development Processes
| 2024-04-21T12:06:05 | 2024-05-03T13:07:18 |
Keqin Li, Armando Zhu, Peng Zhao, Jintong Song, Jiabei Liu
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This study explores the application of deep learning technologies in software
development processes, particularly in automating code reviews, error
prediction, and test generation to enhance code quality and development
efficiency. Through a series of empirical studies, experimental groups using
deep learning tools and control groups using traditional methods were compared
in terms of code error rates and project completion times. The results
demonstrated significant improvements in the experimental group, validating the
effectiveness of deep learning technologies. The research also discusses
potential optimization points, methodologies, and technical challenges of deep
learning in software development, as well as how to integrate these
technologies into existing software development workflows.
|
[
-0.44133850932121277,
-0.48420608043670654,
0.21908354759216309,
0.22805781662464142,
-0.17708705365657806,
0.5703875422477722,
-0.3708544969558716,
-0.36649149656295776,
-0.2654784321784973,
0.15902359783649445,
-0.499620646238327,
-0.4095161259174347,
-0.11268360167741776,
-0.04760538041591644,
-0.36936014890670776,
0.6628209352493286,
-0.4717288017272949,
0.35360708832740784,
0.3257749378681183,
0.15535221993923187,
-0.5586435794830322,
-0.17849110066890717,
-0.7957904934883118,
-0.40511876344680786,
0.46247702836990356,
0.57655930519104,
0.8300616145133972,
0.3496357202529907,
0.9150899648666382,
0.14722596108913422,
0.5669286251068115,
-0.007186674512922764,
-0.17569325864315033,
0.08896439522504807,
0.296101838350296,
-0.42806223034858704,
-0.1519683450460434,
0.07396408170461655,
0.013999506831169128,
0.647199809551239,
-0.10586686432361603,
0.2586039900779724,
0.17516210675239563,
0.8621881008148193,
-0.6880146861076355,
0.06660142540931702,
0.04617501422762871,
0.9484291672706604,
0.29673856496810913,
-0.24450311064720154,
-0.07017569243907928,
-0.9204764366149902,
0.20941580832004547,
-0.3918476700782776,
0.29503050446510315,
-0.25856518745422363,
0.4766165614128113,
0.4790211617946625,
0.14528577029705048,
-0.5261139869689941,
-1.0001550912857056,
0.597895622253418,
-1.0848580598831177,
0.26162052154541016,
0.23896673321723938,
0.3175109922885895,
-0.13972780108451843,
-0.47761040925979614,
-0.34373411536216736,
-0.5261001586914062,
0.2640315294265747,
0.2563430964946747,
0.537367045879364,
0.12081088870763779,
0.37143775820732117,
0.6392293572425842,
-0.8904287815093994,
0.573312520980835,
-0.615011990070343,
-0.1397012323141098,
1.105118751525879,
0.11919011920690536,
0.15333114564418793,
0.5037230253219604,
-0.0786508247256279,
-0.21558856964111328,
-0.3706566095352173,
0.3275996446609497,
0.27094027400016785,
0.1413545459508896,
0.15464447438716888,
0.47599563002586365,
-0.08757198601961136,
0.40299561619758606,
-0.21716147661209106,
0.2446666657924652,
0.6173951625823975,
-0.2039933055639267,
-0.8293279409408569,
-0.2527913451194763,
0.4571272134780884,
0.2849210500717163,
0.26124587655067444,
-0.08336479961872101,
-0.33827632665634155,
0.45586076378822327,
0.6322685480117798,
-0.7493494749069214,
-0.5372769832611084,
0.30129459500312805,
-0.5834725499153137,
-0.7363372445106506,
-0.02754700742661953,
-0.5028694868087769,
-0.8021073937416077,
-0.4890863001346588,
-0.01103146281093359,
-0.2998243570327759,
-0.5731146335601807,
0.23352140188217163,
-0.4091234803199768,
0.48619842529296875,
0.40116146206855774,
-0.5036118030548096,
-0.019623825326561928,
0.5956312417984009,
0.39461782574653625,
-0.2870308756828308,
-0.35856306552886963,
-0.26962602138519287,
-0.365993857383728,
-1.0937086343765259,
0.16986683011054993,
-0.435068279504776,
-0.4523341953754425,
0.04121173545718193,
-0.46736857295036316,
0.5724228620529175,
-0.6355827450752258,
0.10586851835250854,
-0.501211404800415,
-0.11845406144857407,
0.2464800924062729,
-0.600884735584259,
-0.12017304450273514,
0.13776953518390656,
-0.5960270762443542,
1.052465558052063,
0.49478399753570557,
-0.011943732388317585,
0.9264954924583435,
-0.8030650615692139,
-0.6431121230125427,
0.1921474188566208,
-0.2509631812572479,
-0.6314378380775452,
0.6345837116241455,
-0.1293259859085083,
0.7360280156135559,
-0.08206731081008911,
0.17849189043045044,
-0.26437604427337646,
-0.8397865295410156,
0.14631497859954834,
0.07906166464090347,
0.6590331196784973,
0.7323479056358337,
-0.9541513323783875,
0.06749731302261353,
-0.538813591003418,
0.3971973955631256,
0.06118578836321831,
-0.7112464308738708,
0.022716136649250984,
0.02969111129641533,
-0.41734570264816284,
0.10984138399362564,
-0.4122920334339142,
-0.10431510955095291,
0.41186103224754333,
-0.20024487376213074,
0.3007579445838928,
0.5118969082832336,
-0.01080070249736309,
0.6976577639579773,
0.1357782632112503,
0.5292086601257324,
0.04678279906511307,
0.6644113659858704,
-0.017205560579895973,
-0.10025215148925781,
-0.8818286061286926,
0.5744629502296448,
0.41066446900367737,
0.5387778282165527,
-0.5745242238044739,
0.32588818669319153,
0.3958998918533325,
-0.5708156228065491,
-0.7252174019813538,
0.667107880115509,
0.35272645950317383,
0.03587909787893295,
0.09093952924013138,
-0.7172591090202332,
-0.439678817987442,
-0.5141451358795166,
0.06794700771570206,
-0.11762882024049759,
0.09682024270296097,
0.19483141601085663,
0.2808622717857361,
-0.44184646010398865,
0.5197096467018127,
-0.4446568489074707,
-0.12908422946929932,
0.0460708886384964,
0.24985337257385254,
0.16028642654418945,
0.6729200482368469,
0.3831017017364502,
-1.0937517881393433,
-0.470319926738739,
0.06665225327014923,
-0.7542778253555298,
0.34855973720550537,
-0.24913188815116882,
0.09419867396354675,
0.44032561779022217,
0.6730161905288696,
-0.036481451243162155,
0.7232484221458435,
0.31156036257743835,
-0.07666411995887756,
0.47898876667022705,
-0.28610676527023315,
0.2426554560661316,
-0.23678986728191376,
-0.1147690936923027,
0.0017734426073729992,
0.22165778279304504,
-0.41664430499076843,
0.29145485162734985,
0.3798236846923828,
-0.32495391368865967,
-0.44358745217323303,
-0.3670620322227478,
-0.596317708492279,
-0.21256238222122192,
-0.41923829913139343,
-0.06407417356967926,
0.044212765991687775,
0.37771275639533997,
-0.18848387897014618,
1.098102331161499,
0.5989004969596863,
-0.9518219828605652,
0.6265234351158142,
-0.4321601390838623,
-0.44873881340026855,
-0.14542187750339508,
-0.5590444207191467,
0.24525852501392365,
0.041534215211868286,
-0.3900455832481384,
-0.6197395324707031,
-0.1165352463722229,
0.019965119659900665,
-0.7300510406494141,
0.4335572421550751,
0.06965496391057968,
-0.57998126745224,
-0.7795632481575012,
-0.49704408645629883,
-0.12520243227481842,
0.9311142563819885,
-0.002448153216391802,
0.1415097564458847,
0.2172740250825882,
0.36326098442077637,
-0.7096319198608398,
-1.2079379558563232,
-0.11462165415287018,
-0.10134965181350708,
-0.2771756052970886,
0.06274955719709396,
-0.1676054149866104,
-0.21794039011001587,
-0.034817591309547424,
-0.10639122873544693,
-0.23937375843524933,
0.611376166343689,
0.1627473533153534,
-0.030229108408093452,
-0.41198673844337463,
0.5202848315238953,
-0.03312807157635689,
-0.09441307187080383,
0.17098768055438995,
-0.37459883093833923,
0.2749670147895813,
0.05463976785540581,
-0.276237815618515,
-0.3941905200481415,
0.22741574048995972,
0.26858317852020264,
-0.23612648248672485,
0.3304729163646698,
0.8146235942840576,
-0.24983356893062592,
-0.6017458438873291,
-0.7030684351921082,
-0.06670087575912476,
-0.455252081155777,
0.1875811219215393,
-0.1956915408372879,
-0.8906378746032715,
0.39413899183273315,
-0.6172904968261719,
0.2545953392982483,
0.24759939312934875,
0.2647208273410797,
-0.40879151225090027,
0.9658177495002747,
1.0418345928192139,
-0.1483001857995987,
0.44400423765182495,
-0.7106410264968872,
0.26194295287132263,
-0.5574232935905457,
-0.0277273990213871,
-0.35180699825286865,
-0.30200955271720886,
-0.35708844661712646,
-0.45925185084342957,
-0.10966139286756516,
0.5347615480422974,
-0.4656510651111603,
0.35565516352653503,
-0.9678236842155457,
0.5259511470794678,
0.7571609616279602,
0.05683787539601326,
0.05439518019556999,
-0.21351636946201324,
-0.14081628620624542,
-0.03379221633076668,
-0.5648629069328308,
-0.27874845266342163,
1.1345219612121582,
0.40784233808517456,
0.9099456071853638,
-0.293265163898468,
0.8489935994148254,
0.7974337935447693,
0.27776241302490234,
-0.5368278622627258,
0.013721676543354988,
0.0834987610578537,
-0.4343447983264923,
-0.5155665278434753,
-0.21015410125255585,
-0.7602834105491638,
-0.3382050395011902,
-0.006042510736733675,
0.09294597059488297,
0.22645960748195648,
0.100037582218647,
-0.6891400814056396,
0.1314583420753479,
-1.144109845161438,
0.8529539704322815,
-0.49848559498786926,
0.04338373616337776,
-0.36001861095428467,
-0.5557323694229126,
-0.12894004583358765,
-0.22636643052101135,
-0.0960070788860321,
-0.05827181041240692,
-0.0640120878815651,
0.515433669090271,
-0.19578900933265686,
0.8749364614486694,
-0.3507244288921356,
-0.19132234156131744,
0.5849937796592712,
0.03369957208633423,
0.3512228727340698,
0.1039818599820137,
-0.2841760814189911,
-0.2750222086906433,
-0.6031963229179382,
-0.3636150360107422,
-0.7389191389083862,
0.7573815584182739,
-0.8473867177963257,
-0.1455124169588089,
-0.21125778555870056,
-0.3470519483089447,
0.09027335792779922,
0.26206907629966736,
-0.04700694605708122,
-0.03344930335879326,
0.008833927102386951,
-0.06970991939306259,
0.8155215978622437,
-0.42448192834854126,
0.8194719552993774,
0.344475656747818,
-0.3752966523170471,
-0.3856408894062042,
0.7038913369178772,
0.17374177277088165,
0.07288867980241776,
-0.18678522109985352,
0.05235791951417923,
0.44921913743019104,
-1.2273426055908203,
-0.40171828866004944,
-0.39300987124443054,
-0.4717150926589966,
-0.33042916655540466,
-0.18716149032115936,
-0.2203664630651474,
-0.52543044090271,
-0.43387994170188904,
-0.33755555748939514,
-0.034619130194187164,
-0.21891620755195618,
-0.3511658310890198,
0.07001648843288422,
0.8523956537246704,
0.09747608751058578,
-0.08168435096740723,
-0.6442975997924805,
0.3048173785209656,
0.18410222232341766,
0.59941565990448,
0.08898978680372238,
0.3603193461894989,
-0.5454630851745605,
-0.013598768971860409,
-0.29160407185554504,
-0.5901042222976685,
0.26635804772377014,
-0.05718836933374405,
0.6096319556236267,
0.016506783664226532,
0.10783320665359497,
0.5574612021446228,
-0.023810429498553276,
0.7884460091590881,
0.1404210776090622,
-0.8135267496109009,
1.0260095596313477,
0.08880776166915894,
0.29322585463523865,
0.7778114080429077,
0.3363626301288605,
-0.09311477094888687,
-0.21379035711288452,
-0.3456534147262573,
-0.6875209808349609,
0.1679677963256836,
0.24726614356040955,
0.06826979666948318,
0.5040908455848694,
0.6844431161880493,
0.21010343730449677,
0.35181015729904175,
-0.44096559286117554,
-0.1898389458656311,
0.043085649609565735,
0.09354371577501297,
-0.22144199907779694,
-0.10892107337713242,
0.029381807893514633,
-0.44511014223098755,
0.4987487196922302,
-0.20811934769153595,
0.14159640669822693,
0.385469526052475,
-0.2683865427970886,
-0.20152299106121063,
-0.09305072575807571,
0.7131434679031372,
1.1335186958312988,
0.10188855230808258,
-0.1912880837917328,
0.21915091574192047,
-0.5186322331428528,
0.15515993535518646,
-0.014312926679849625,
0.019087670370936394,
-0.20073369145393372,
0.16032664477825165,
0.6573241949081421,
-0.42949289083480835,
-0.5129863023757935,
0.20063328742980957,
-0.07372650504112244,
-0.2927616238594055,
-0.7855436205863953,
0.5725632309913635,
-0.16051578521728516,
0.7344033718109131,
0.5864196419715881,
0.2555978000164032,
0.5332385897636414,
-0.4310246706008911,
0.20057033002376556,
0.1164289340376854,
-0.6501911282539368,
0.2678699493408203,
0.3210287392139435,
0.3568790555000305,
-0.5667845606803894,
0.9279780387878418,
-0.2981773316860199,
-0.2782108783721924,
1.1641515493392944,
0.02583487704396248,
1.1599383354187012,
-0.21299631893634796,
0.28021201491355896,
-0.06975529342889786,
0.39816606044769287,
0.38892674446105957,
0.710896372795105,
-0.17788967490196228,
-0.2685106694698334,
-1.0216189622879028,
-0.31286653876304626,
-0.3785678744316101,
-0.027943991124629974,
-0.35572487115859985,
0.3450406491756439,
-0.6607120633125305,
-0.3462711274623871,
0.03190271556377411,
0.4598195552825928,
-0.7262464761734009,
0.422801673412323,
0.4447435438632965,
1.0389375686645508,
-0.590111255645752,
0.7743690609931946,
0.8226979970932007,
-0.5773165225982666,
-0.9062967896461487,
-0.13639573752880096,
-0.2361307293176651,
-0.5119338631629944,
0.7738675475120544,
0.10997258126735687,
-0.026418311521410942,
-0.20942020416259766,
-0.7004916667938232,
-0.5247001647949219,
1.097302794456482,
0.0863511860370636,
-0.410863995552063,
0.17438329756259918,
0.13623540103435516,
0.7692015171051025,
-0.3067728281021118,
0.030755506828427315,
0.4171496629714966,
0.488246887922287,
-0.25815096497535706,
-0.7149665951728821,
-0.18666359782218933,
-0.43244415521621704,
0.245810404419899,
0.5225974917411804,
-0.3561893701553345,
0.4176621735095978,
-0.538202166557312,
0.021454399451613426,
-0.3254593312740326,
0.7379227876663208,
-0.04397829249501228,
0.4965222179889679,
0.16836881637573242,
0.3203886151313782,
0.6488741636276245,
-0.08019766956567764,
0.8181710243225098,
-0.20431894063949585,
0.33907395601272583,
0.8458421230316162,
-0.22500154376029968,
0.3942725658416748,
0.36503344774246216,
-0.22173991799354553,
0.2690930664539337,
0.8303699493408203,
-0.5471706986427307,
0.37473392486572266,
0.7296746969223022,
0.024312112480401993,
0.199202299118042,
0.16115044057369232,
-0.4330572485923767,
-0.15604311227798462,
0.1749270260334015,
-0.6049695611000061,
0.3108013868331909,
0.5549740791320801,
0.04250666871666908,
-0.10012058168649673,
-0.4014710485935211,
0.7891048789024353,
0.03415064886212349,
-0.7050619125366211,
0.25524595379829407,
-0.2361525446176529,
0.7234534621238708,
-0.1837833821773529,
-0.2576873302459717,
-0.2948955297470093,
0.733713686466217,
-0.35398584604263306,
-1.0152409076690674,
0.3334816098213196,
-0.2434820681810379,
0.06963790208101273,
-0.2182089388370514,
0.7429894208908081,
0.02426302060484886,
-0.3798891603946686,
0.5090540051460266,
0.30042749643325806,
0.025134533643722534,
-0.06698576360940933,
-0.8694525361061096,
0.16659775376319885,
0.04557299613952637,
-0.15002334117889404,
0.020583245903253555,
0.3781432807445526,
0.24752528965473175,
0.8007628321647644,
0.5273529887199402,
0.09494280070066452,
0.35065943002700806,
0.2603951394557953,
1.0278053283691406,
-0.9326900243759155,
-0.055169619619846344,
-0.9509274959564209,
0.5161024928092957,
-0.34670403599739075,
-0.43672287464141846,
0.8005488514900208,
0.6963344216346741,
1.1271462440490723,
-0.1745867133140564,
0.8252833485603333,
-0.13430599868297577,
0.10076484084129333,
-0.28820934891700745,
0.6989514827728271,
-0.12345658242702484,
0.04645981639623642,
-0.38351643085479736,
-0.847315788269043,
-0.7992814183235168,
0.4216614067554474,
0.18487562239170074,
0.09855261445045471,
0.7019528150558472,
0.414264440536499,
0.19440220296382904,
-0.07239275425672531,
0.2203683853149414,
-0.27981477975845337,
0.5019923448562622,
0.692136287689209,
0.8397325277328491,
-0.6180292963981628,
0.2109612226486206,
-0.9514502286911011,
-0.16655482351779938,
-0.15280961990356445,
-0.7607752680778503,
-0.8598178625106812,
-0.3638533055782318,
-0.7534410953521729,
-0.4706425368785858,
0.20938001573085785,
0.5939644575119019,
0.7599382400512695,
-0.8648805618286133,
-0.3906741142272949,
-0.5510988831520081,
-0.12249751389026642,
-0.5788595676422119,
-0.23407861590385437,
0.1262224167585373,
-0.9757891893386841,
-0.273538202047348,
0.2139887809753418,
0.21998633444309235,
0.2965920865535736,
-0.6891881823539734,
-0.4661572575569153,
0.016842477023601532,
-0.45105600357055664,
0.4181548058986664,
0.07149568945169449,
-0.12342597544193268,
0.10596548020839691,
0.3450050950050354,
-0.17840512096881866,
0.0064276582561433315,
1.1827534437179565,
-0.7978201508522034,
0.2590509057044983,
0.544814944267273,
0.7927750945091248,
0.4295365810394287,
-0.2394135743379593,
0.8665428161621094,
-0.2415917068719864,
-0.1230865940451622,
0.6391822099685669,
-0.09201439470052719,
0.03274630755186081,
-0.6458412408828735,
1.09682297706604,
-0.3086394965648651,
-0.8923537135124207,
-0.6910849213600159,
-0.08671923726797104,
-0.4105284810066223,
-0.31310272216796875,
0.69949871301651,
-0.24978961050510406,
0.04836106300354004,
-0.23119428753852844,
-0.2897815406322479,
0.3173658847808838,
-0.24274316430091858,
0.6726034879684448,
0.5025252103805542,
-0.5172293186187744,
-0.2539445757865906,
-0.8666767477989197,
0.8338226675987244,
0.4209046959877014,
-0.802245020866394,
-0.24755597114562988,
0.38271453976631165,
-0.07047847658395767,
0.28281646966934204,
0.17533759772777557,
0.012891176156699657,
0.51413494348526,
-0.07210124284029007,
0.38375335931777954,
-0.16571137309074402,
-0.22395581007003784,
-0.594445526599884,
0.2213175743818283,
0.3272254467010498,
-0.1770409345626831
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13628v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13628v1
|
Mixture of LoRA Experts
| 2024-04-21T11:59:53 | 2024-04-21T11:59:53 |
Xun Wu, Shaohan Huang, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
LoRA has gained widespread acceptance in the fine-tuning of large pre-trained
models to cater to a diverse array of downstream tasks, showcasing notable
effectiveness and efficiency, thereby solidifying its position as one of the
most prevalent fine-tuning techniques. Due to the modular nature of LoRA's
plug-and-play plugins, researchers have delved into the amalgamation of
multiple LoRAs to empower models to excel across various downstream tasks.
Nonetheless, extant approaches for LoRA fusion grapple with inherent
challenges. Direct arithmetic merging may result in the loss of the original
pre-trained model's generative capabilities or the distinct identity of LoRAs,
thereby yielding suboptimal outcomes. On the other hand, Reference tuning-based
fusion exhibits limitations concerning the requisite flexibility for the
effective combination of multiple LoRAs. In response to these challenges, this
paper introduces the Mixture of LoRA Experts (MoLE) approach, which harnesses
hierarchical control and unfettered branch selection. The MoLE approach not
only achieves superior LoRA fusion performance in comparison to direct
arithmetic merging but also retains the crucial flexibility for combining LoRAs
effectively. Extensive experimental evaluations conducted in both the Natural
Language Processing (NLP) and Vision & Language (V&L) domains substantiate the
efficacy of MoLE.
|
[
-0.7888577580451965,
-0.7055436372756958,
0.40064364671707153,
-0.09262401610612869,
-0.4173256456851959,
0.6728370189666748,
-0.029212601482868195,
-0.7185913920402527,
0.43760162591934204,
0.6602798700332642,
-0.6128974556922913,
-0.3130987882614136,
-0.6108426451683044,
-0.10749498754739761,
-0.5037940144538879,
0.81918865442276,
0.14083324372768402,
-0.25239297747612,
-0.04744056612253189,
-0.3406989872455597,
-0.5291606187820435,
-0.24491047859191895,
-0.4019995629787445,
-0.6081706881523132,
0.8287052512168884,
0.15508851408958435,
0.7245314717292786,
0.6618754267692566,
0.6235817074775696,
0.4187186360359192,
-0.41546720266342163,
0.9162424206733704,
-0.5661938786506653,
-0.1949726641178131,
-0.5313153862953186,
-0.1839119791984558,
-0.6356517672538757,
-0.0317404605448246,
0.25169989466667175,
0.7914048433303833,
-0.42591190338134766,
-0.0848877802491188,
-0.02810654789209366,
0.8813209533691406,
-0.995993435382843,
-0.4555011987686157,
-1.1676712036132812,
0.012968625873327255,
-0.154494509100914,
-0.0874713584780693,
-0.19150514900684357,
-0.44569090008735657,
-0.11878618597984314,
-0.5353472828865051,
-0.13137286901474,
-0.14343230426311493,
0.7958325743675232,
0.8272800445556641,
-0.6489682793617249,
0.13284161686897278,
-0.7797597646713257,
0.6475809216499329,
-0.8418596982955933,
-0.1304360330104828,
0.21908842027187347,
0.5733067989349365,
-0.10105400532484055,
-0.2248280644416809,
-0.34091395139694214,
0.4144423305988312,
0.16131816804409027,
0.16384504735469818,
-0.3412420451641083,
0.015929115936160088,
-0.16043654084205627,
0.48242658376693726,
0.031596630811691284,
0.6312405467033386,
-0.31864506006240845,
-0.07456717640161514,
0.4913828670978546,
0.17548838257789612,
-0.18545670807361603,
-0.03975135087966919,
-0.39637988805770874,
0.048223551362752914,
-0.6663806438446045,
-0.25384044647216797,
0.49438050389289856,
0.43003347516059875,
0.31810203194618225,
0.7308474779129028,
-0.459179162979126,
1.0606038570404053,
0.2951816916465759,
-0.27145498991012573,
0.11274605244398117,
-0.47049441933631897,
-0.509559154510498,
-0.2592867612838745,
0.9174895286560059,
-0.05252609774470329,
0.10707665979862213,
-0.1455879658460617,
-0.22112450003623962,
0.23446598649024963,
0.22336126863956451,
-0.32496917247772217,
-0.007657674141228199,
0.24909056723117828,
-0.034685906022787094,
-0.5551114082336426,
0.028674427419900894,
-0.889484703540802,
-0.5354303121566772,
-0.5092792510986328,
0.763954758644104,
-0.5535222291946411,
-0.09858658909797668,
0.112054243683815,
-0.07790222018957138,
-0.11154355108737946,
0.320235013961792,
-1.0458810329437256,
0.38542312383651733,
0.8439162969589233,
0.5288854241371155,
-0.22841477394104004,
-0.23456408083438873,
-0.7167791724205017,
0.23955337703227997,
-0.12356473505496979,
0.9631698131561279,
-0.3365563452243805,
-0.5213387608528137,
-0.28229525685310364,
-0.6730740070343018,
-0.28655916452407837,
-0.8301776647567749,
0.17979639768600464,
-0.55452960729599,
0.06800657510757446,
-0.06969232857227325,
-0.14301040768623352,
-0.18534128367900848,
0.13478873670101166,
-0.5987367033958435,
0.802004873752594,
0.4123113751411438,
-0.6141409873962402,
0.2933402359485626,
-0.48380106687545776,
-0.49802377820014954,
-0.15509726107120514,
-0.3062366843223572,
-0.3569576144218445,
0.1371828019618988,
0.4661218822002411,
0.11685382574796677,
-0.2601827085018158,
0.1769399493932724,
-0.03153296187520027,
-0.13093692064285278,
0.13865360617637634,
-0.0232118908315897,
0.6563686728477478,
0.049278970807790756,
-0.12814782559871674,
0.656956136226654,
-0.819261372089386,
0.16051527857780457,
-0.3844199478626251,
-0.23184512555599213,
-0.3316373825073242,
-0.047094497829675674,
-0.3553241789340973,
0.24494650959968567,
0.37739405035972595,
-0.1695459634065628,
0.252071350812912,
-0.38088324666023254,
0.4184148609638214,
0.8656163811683655,
0.09853855520486832,
0.5393150448799133,
-0.3756029009819031,
0.30315926671028137,
0.06881634145975113,
0.16297698020935059,
0.13692255318164825,
-0.5302430391311646,
-0.9517695307731628,
-0.36293941736221313,
0.6084303259849548,
0.487839937210083,
-0.9526325464248657,
0.962120771408081,
-0.03611608222126961,
-0.7911124229431152,
-0.6288118958473206,
0.7030926942825317,
0.44213610887527466,
0.8343946933746338,
0.3595086336135864,
-0.21144026517868042,
-0.5981234908103943,
-0.9840893149375916,
0.013999701477587223,
0.03814676031470299,
0.1322043240070343,
0.15293240547180176,
0.49481314420700073,
-0.4696585536003113,
1.2463785409927368,
-0.5415533781051636,
-0.5558873414993286,
-0.011958655901253223,
0.22270427644252777,
0.38873153924942017,
0.35396432876586914,
0.37139415740966797,
-0.8300634026527405,
-0.33841365575790405,
0.6058496832847595,
-0.5721397995948792,
0.006655889097601175,
0.2575831711292267,
-0.2981260418891907,
0.09363149106502533,
0.25796592235565186,
-0.6190569996833801,
0.3839106559753418,
0.7751007676124573,
-0.15331928431987762,
0.3522075116634369,
-0.36185622215270996,
0.057745400816202164,
-1.2462122440338135,
0.04886031523346901,
-0.22661922872066498,
-0.14584532380104065,
-0.4140092432498932,
0.17986996471881866,
0.03265734761953354,
0.16953957080841064,
-0.5774673223495483,
0.21230988204479218,
-0.20355767011642456,
-0.10657966881990433,
-0.29743683338165283,
0.13108249008655548,
-0.09384305030107498,
0.47749873995780945,
-0.2943260967731476,
0.5222808718681335,
0.475033164024353,
-0.8194999098777771,
0.4207846522331238,
0.27988287806510925,
-0.45731139183044434,
0.35719379782676697,
-0.6063457727432251,
0.06241919472813606,
0.1518816351890564,
-0.016490433365106583,
-0.6203157901763916,
-0.3557954430580139,
-0.023619165644049644,
-0.12390583753585815,
0.006751853507012129,
0.07479751855134964,
-0.4089115560054779,
-0.2683718800544739,
-0.13577800989151,
0.17124834656715393,
0.9407821893692017,
-0.3814246952533722,
1.2616691589355469,
0.3783039450645447,
0.18275214731693268,
-0.7925757765769958,
-0.5090766549110413,
-0.27501824498176575,
-0.3276267945766449,
-0.7766993045806885,
0.5172637104988098,
0.15299849212169647,
-0.443551242351532,
0.06157032027840614,
-0.1421070098876953,
-0.14693038165569305,
-0.013955464586615562,
0.39966535568237305,
0.408102810382843,
-0.0965360477566719,
-0.38873884081840515,
0.15442496538162231,
-0.2723325490951538,
-0.39091405272483826,
0.11916889995336533,
0.6040900349617004,
0.14710146188735962,
-0.6811295747756958,
-0.1769298017024994,
0.25696301460266113,
0.8243182301521301,
-0.48634961247444153,
0.7989295125007629,
0.43171465396881104,
-0.08946840465068817,
-0.19818049669265747,
-0.7913211584091187,
0.011965976096689701,
-0.5381246209144592,
0.23034033179283142,
-0.2136349081993103,
-0.6767992377281189,
0.8539774417877197,
-0.24347853660583496,
0.15771017968654633,
0.5864381790161133,
0.4390535056591034,
-0.06174498051404953,
0.8325298428535461,
0.8587431311607361,
-0.22117629647254944,
0.4296586811542511,
-0.30776357650756836,
0.23075613379478455,
-0.9331598281860352,
-0.47734057903289795,
-0.5397156476974487,
-0.48508381843566895,
-0.2699892520904541,
-0.536153256893158,
0.4981130063533783,
-0.02080438658595085,
-0.1034015491604805,
0.3973401188850403,
-0.42995864152908325,
0.6258803606033325,
0.5286009311676025,
0.2674645185470581,
0.6032892465591431,
0.037233348935842514,
0.05926201865077019,
0.28454771637916565,
-0.863675594329834,
0.040910981595516205,
0.5499961376190186,
0.10983701795339584,
0.9453223943710327,
0.15300680696964264,
0.689671516418457,
-0.09672827273607254,
-0.028230026364326477,
-0.872435986995697,
0.7018057107925415,
-0.5142045021057129,
-0.35100194811820984,
-0.34779831767082214,
-0.47539204359054565,
-0.8438446521759033,
0.4761427938938141,
-0.4412890374660492,
-0.6809623837471008,
0.37714502215385437,
0.1793840080499649,
-0.7885532975196838,
0.49611803889274597,
-0.5652889013290405,
0.45947152376174927,
-0.12310481816530228,
-0.15759386122226715,
-0.3391945958137512,
-0.6444981098175049,
0.7468143701553345,
-0.6303488612174988,
0.3188602328300476,
-0.13567514717578888,
-0.07678326219320297,
0.667481005191803,
-0.7503588199615479,
0.7578204870223999,
0.24440748989582062,
-0.284967839717865,
0.2026553750038147,
0.005122852977365255,
0.4111473858356476,
-0.2658844292163849,
-0.07444089651107788,
0.036438219249248505,
-0.5110877156257629,
-0.2886292338371277,
-0.6506858468055725,
0.7520201802253723,
-1.0971263647079468,
-0.5713610649108887,
-0.16221444308757782,
-0.627593457698822,
-0.7148380279541016,
0.12846709787845612,
0.46749380230903625,
0.23764725029468536,
-0.016643479466438293,
0.23993927240371704,
0.727877676486969,
0.18707340955734253,
0.5163350105285645,
0.4284477233886719,
-0.6593291759490967,
-0.6282342672348022,
0.8592302799224854,
-0.038930587470531464,
0.5716562867164612,
0.27437251806259155,
0.09374880790710449,
0.09966697543859482,
-0.5505155324935913,
-0.22271797060966492,
0.09276900440454483,
-0.599052906036377,
-0.4478486180305481,
-0.404157817363739,
-0.5374182462692261,
-0.06660975515842438,
-0.2775489389896393,
-0.6041865348815918,
-0.24617290496826172,
-0.3547244966030121,
0.2147025465965271,
0.39787736535072327,
0.819093644618988,
0.10482729226350784,
0.5661375522613525,
-0.7445446252822876,
0.7225523591041565,
0.8042227625846863,
0.0818643644452095,
-0.209749236702919,
-0.40613600611686707,
-0.07188848406076431,
0.13777078688144684,
-0.05171235650777817,
-0.686419665813446,
0.38807201385498047,
0.17198793590068817,
0.5181667804718018,
0.48953405022621155,
-0.2464449554681778,
0.8757966160774231,
-0.26746273040771484,
0.36902308464050293,
0.3591947555541992,
-0.9401155114173889,
0.70639568567276,
-0.5925734043121338,
0.24281424283981323,
0.7935858964920044,
0.04849407821893692,
0.1477661430835724,
-0.206705704331398,
-0.3782457411289215,
-1.0003628730773926,
0.3665420413017273,
0.2709219455718994,
-0.2739098072052002,
0.5741949677467346,
-0.26550427079200745,
0.3311760127544403,
0.2960108518600464,
-0.22838467359542847,
-0.013778211548924446,
0.02274296246469021,
-0.09193486720323563,
-0.11565552651882172,
0.12500928342342377,
-0.5667028427124023,
-0.41987287998199463,
0.492863267660141,
-0.0901956632733345,
-0.3110308051109314,
-0.2737615406513214,
0.18362027406692505,
-0.3088240921497345,
0.13813768327236176,
0.35072678327560425,
0.9119513630867004,
-0.42185676097869873,
-0.058199893683195114,
0.1550976186990738,
-0.16377712786197662,
0.003743903012946248,
-0.15212388336658478,
-0.11973366141319275,
-0.05535556375980377,
0.30718326568603516,
0.7059382796287537,
0.36126822233200073,
-0.5574238300323486,
0.05287822708487511,
0.3106237053871155,
-0.6104536652565002,
0.2091398388147354,
0.48482000827789307,
0.1411101222038269,
-0.06050998345017433,
0.4878388047218323,
0.8193604946136475,
-0.3230416476726532,
-0.7221704125404358,
-0.15312308073043823,
0.5929722189903259,
-0.15149836242198944,
0.09528064727783203,
0.2063809484243393,
0.5988759398460388,
-0.2255072444677353,
0.4130094647407532,
0.20513786375522614,
-0.48902592062950134,
0.6968587636947632,
0.383306622505188,
0.5241694450378418,
-0.11016014963388443,
0.1279732584953308,
-0.1168471947312355,
0.15070170164108276,
-0.0563739649951458,
0.060254957526922226,
0.14044751226902008,
-0.8708733320236206,
-0.8062856793403625,
-0.6338037252426147,
-0.635147750377655,
-0.07626518607139587,
-0.6278390884399414,
0.17982575297355652,
-0.4450400769710541,
-0.15940549969673157,
0.16374416649341583,
-0.14383715391159058,
-0.2957514226436615,
0.15427406132221222,
-0.0852283239364624,
1.0847657918930054,
-0.9103657007217407,
0.8688075542449951,
0.6661037802696228,
-0.22297503054141998,
-0.8228365182876587,
-0.3887055516242981,
-0.009854014031589031,
-0.753484308719635,
0.4565620422363281,
-0.2820749282836914,
-0.4710213541984558,
0.008809525519609451,
-0.2065938264131546,
-0.8133655786514282,
1.1668974161148071,
0.33323511481285095,
-0.6241746544837952,
-0.15857546031475067,
-0.13647784292697906,
0.49577653408050537,
-0.3521203398704529,
-0.18388895690441132,
0.7823545336723328,
0.46098217368125916,
0.7714152932167053,
-1.1869958639144897,
-0.41444578766822815,
-0.16871745884418488,
-0.2587486505508423,
0.5642240643501282,
-0.6626909971237183,
1.1634635925292969,
-0.1067923754453659,
0.14514586329460144,
0.14744332432746887,
0.6396339535713196,
0.44129711389541626,
0.11334153264760971,
0.6998060345649719,
0.6559879183769226,
0.9873143434524536,
-0.09415706992149353,
0.8029216527938843,
-0.1103362888097763,
0.05801665410399437,
1.0604822635650635,
-0.3315470814704895,
1.0198583602905273,
0.6544174551963806,
-0.30440768599510193,
0.6633301973342896,
0.537462592124939,
0.22234168648719788,
0.7520042061805725,
-0.3513358533382416,
-0.3884216547012329,
-0.2872610092163086,
-0.20715603232383728,
-0.6310681700706482,
0.5909041166305542,
0.27820584177970886,
-0.04960567131638527,
-0.23596790432929993,
-0.22331874072551727,
-0.4590216279029846,
0.16603435575962067,
-0.6747823357582092,
0.8568874597549438,
0.0015928004868328571,
-0.8003240823745728,
0.3508273661136627,
-0.26906242966651917,
0.9728374481201172,
-0.9383363127708435,
0.2591518759727478,
-0.09148300439119339,
0.2442043274641037,
-0.5637543201446533,
-0.6434569954872131,
0.30026307702064514,
-0.16110984981060028,
-0.11808256804943085,
0.059705499559640884,
0.8918167352676392,
-0.3115341067314148,
-0.37321504950523376,
0.2051708996295929,
0.8358497023582458,
-0.28247562050819397,
-0.21074476838111877,
-0.24944603443145752,
0.0317087359726429,
0.13182875514030457,
0.1866052746772766,
0.4557836651802063,
0.25419357419013977,
0.21445605158805847,
0.7317470908164978,
0.709296464920044,
0.2252124547958374,
-0.11806749552488327,
0.09577415883541107,
1.3397252559661865,
-0.6348463892936707,
-0.4226594865322113,
-0.9684043526649475,
0.6022123098373413,
-0.1209779903292656,
-0.41987666487693787,
0.7408971190452576,
0.35697782039642334,
0.34922492504119873,
-0.0831710621714592,
0.6407307982444763,
-0.05122874304652214,
0.34706565737724304,
-0.8609882593154907,
0.5645400881767273,
-0.44978025555610657,
0.05639738589525223,
-0.1853727102279663,
-1.1527996063232422,
0.0058123827911913395,
0.28857699036598206,
-0.118532694876194,
0.15987640619277954,
0.7732473015785217,
0.46602490544319153,
-0.2188941240310669,
-0.2273169606924057,
0.44264933466911316,
0.08483050763607025,
0.0010526420082896948,
0.7861443161964417,
0.8273225426673889,
-0.14987881481647491,
0.4879471957683563,
-0.29254698753356934,
-0.09385387599468231,
-0.4726892411708832,
-0.9233960509300232,
-0.9130648374557495,
-0.32947418093681335,
-0.16035670042037964,
-0.05417277663946152,
-0.306173712015152,
0.6600308418273926,
0.9680044054985046,
-0.5989785194396973,
0.045844901353120804,
-0.08687054365873337,
0.3054836690425873,
-0.09121496230363846,
-0.0705019161105156,
0.05294518545269966,
-0.06231909245252609,
-0.5660616755485535,
0.6405569911003113,
0.49271565675735474,
0.13119326531887054,
-0.48984360694885254,
-0.030324552208185196,
-0.15743328630924225,
0.1935512125492096,
0.45218905806541443,
0.400378942489624,
-0.8483129143714905,
0.21593981981277466,
-0.11505971848964691,
-0.19763684272766113,
0.04058545455336571,
0.6547521352767944,
-1.2526377439498901,
0.22860844433307648,
0.5340132713317871,
0.596457839012146,
0.3028993010520935,
0.5024313926696777,
0.671316921710968,
-0.611226499080658,
0.17375949025154114,
0.2064281702041626,
0.4327007532119751,
0.18370920419692993,
-0.1664894074201584,
0.7966998219490051,
-0.05038108304142952,
-0.4514455199241638,
-0.7244365811347961,
0.2814323604106903,
-1.5734102725982666,
-0.31757795810699463,
1.0325285196304321,
0.31169334053993225,
-0.3193614184856415,
0.019298020750284195,
-0.5254744291305542,
0.09578736126422882,
-0.24609453976154327,
0.720365047454834,
0.4453156888484955,
-0.2763827443122864,
0.19524258375167847,
0.0002749323030002415,
0.1984555721282959,
0.5193520188331604,
-1.1805319786071777,
-0.30086249113082886,
0.26177242398262024,
-0.03167319297790527,
0.5668355822563171,
0.3353736400604248,
0.19125670194625854,
0.1183311715722084,
-0.042072560638189316,
-0.14389508962631226,
-0.32266440987586975,
-0.28562280535697937,
-0.2934367060661316,
0.3014340102672577,
0.022919250652194023,
0.13661472499370575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13627v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13627v1
|
NegotiationToM: A Benchmark for Stress-testing Machine Theory of Mind on Negotiation Surrounding
| 2024-04-21T11:51:13 | 2024-04-21T11:51:13 |
Chunkit Chan, Cheng Jiayang, Yauwai Yim, Zheye Deng, Wei Fan, Haoran Li, Xin Liu, Hongming Zhang, Weiqi Wang, Yangqiu Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have sparked substantial interest and debate
concerning their potential emergence of Theory of Mind (ToM) ability. Theory of
mind evaluations currently focuses on testing models using machine-generated
data or game settings prone to shortcuts and spurious correlations, which lacks
evaluation of machine ToM ability in real-world human interaction scenarios.
This poses a pressing demand to develop new real-world scenario benchmarks. We
introduce NegotiationToM, a new benchmark designed to stress-test machine ToM
in real-world negotiation surrounding covered multi-dimensional mental states
(i.e., desires, beliefs, and intentions). Our benchmark builds upon the
Belief-Desire-Intention (BDI) agent modeling theory and conducts the necessary
empirical experiments to evaluate large language models. Our findings
demonstrate that NegotiationToM is challenging for state-of-the-art LLMs, as
they consistently perform significantly worse than humans, even when employing
the chain-of-thought (CoT) method.
|
[
-0.8669568300247192,
-0.7454649209976196,
0.8612691760063171,
0.011528837494552135,
-0.38601475954055786,
-0.012992463074624538,
-0.5270322561264038,
-0.7239927053451538,
0.00926128588616848,
0.3080827593803406,
-0.6462885737419128,
-0.1004633978009224,
-0.5996325016021729,
0.10233194380998611,
-0.09848861396312714,
0.46682628989219666,
-0.10660605132579803,
0.03733477741479874,
-0.3414474129676819,
-0.16286984086036682,
-0.3705114424228668,
-0.5775240063667297,
-0.9090192317962646,
-0.6986649632453918,
0.395724892616272,
-0.07581915706396103,
0.8155646324157715,
0.18743862211704254,
0.746787428855896,
0.28684598207473755,
-0.06627413630485535,
0.08995798975229263,
-0.1567225307226181,
0.47632622718811035,
-0.5728713274002075,
-0.5662924647331238,
-0.4191259443759918,
0.5371153950691223,
0.2442847341299057,
0.44885343313217163,
-0.1411990225315094,
0.11846335977315903,
-0.1185896247625351,
0.3152308464050293,
-0.6669131517410278,
-0.052459437400102615,
-1.0723944902420044,
0.14659512042999268,
0.0735909566283226,
-0.2967197000980377,
-0.572257399559021,
-0.37987375259399414,
0.41013309359550476,
-0.4196762144565582,
-0.012606116011738777,
0.19949182868003845,
1.133100152015686,
0.3587234914302826,
-0.6527065634727478,
-0.32082435488700867,
-0.6562991738319397,
0.5944223403930664,
-0.4310147762298584,
0.5326396822929382,
0.30788373947143555,
0.6842419505119324,
-0.3243628740310669,
-0.5449885129928589,
-0.7252835631370544,
-0.5266709923744202,
0.07101026177406311,
0.279712438583374,
-0.10700984299182892,
0.16146241128444672,
0.35793691873550415,
0.32766637206077576,
-0.5392827391624451,
-0.059627994894981384,
-0.09646706283092499,
-0.049396902322769165,
0.7128706574440002,
0.2762465178966522,
-0.0013273742515593767,
0.06442482024431229,
-0.6951658129692078,
-0.3236871659755707,
-0.39565330743789673,
-0.1700594127178192,
0.060586366802453995,
0.27036646008491516,
0.08383533358573914,
0.4598557949066162,
0.07495175302028656,
0.6858491897583008,
-0.1230393499135971,
0.11116121709346771,
-0.05121671035885811,
0.08076826483011246,
-0.6578964591026306,
-0.2897881269454956,
0.7044761776924133,
0.6494508981704712,
0.36876723170280457,
-0.02415500208735466,
-0.24957849085330963,
0.44530701637268066,
0.6424641609191895,
-0.6997823715209961,
0.01968921348452568,
0.4245465397834778,
-0.4726293087005615,
-0.29828959703445435,
-0.2063155472278595,
-1.3503835201263428,
-0.5666874051094055,
-0.09562204033136368,
0.4361985921859741,
-0.5300276875495911,
-0.39343810081481934,
0.19178764522075653,
-0.1269293874502182,
0.6510698199272156,
0.21045678853988647,
-0.27782803773880005,
0.6237218976020813,
0.6269530653953552,
0.7691611647605896,
-0.23987829685211182,
-0.562258243560791,
-0.14449793100357056,
0.009250687435269356,
-0.6004488468170166,
0.9133195281028748,
-0.7694581151008606,
-0.609974205493927,
-0.09592796862125397,
-0.4660865068435669,
-0.17046493291854858,
-0.7471100091934204,
0.5821612477302551,
-0.3863884210586548,
0.039479419589042664,
-0.2550632953643799,
-0.7622202634811401,
0.10615003108978271,
0.8296698927879333,
-0.5164481997489929,
0.7972819209098816,
0.08508887141942978,
-0.17572800815105438,
0.4225969910621643,
-0.823409378528595,
-0.33191728591918945,
-0.020266208797693253,
-0.37828510999679565,
-0.24168278276920319,
0.12205276638269424,
-0.32248654961586,
0.4783036708831787,
-1.1191508769989014,
0.32114773988723755,
-0.527945339679718,
-0.24694836139678955,
0.9392460584640503,
-0.39398086071014404,
0.44769287109375,
0.43901684880256653,
-0.341484934091568,
-0.1346292346715927,
-0.39341604709625244,
0.2021714597940445,
0.5052192211151123,
-0.09269991517066956,
-0.3835989236831665,
-0.03355417028069496,
-0.17105042934417725,
0.5983431935310364,
0.280018150806427,
-0.2513820230960846,
0.3310396373271942,
-0.07145611196756363,
0.19233572483062744,
0.7681883573532104,
-0.08522282540798187,
-0.06907707452774048,
-0.5341551899909973,
0.738259494304657,
-0.024893734604120255,
0.09936434030532837,
0.33404168486595154,
-0.37091967463493347,
-0.7703881859779358,
-0.10046009719371796,
0.09140454977750778,
0.21513374149799347,
-0.5999875664710999,
0.2296164184808731,
-0.19723065197467804,
-0.8259710669517517,
-0.6965392827987671,
-0.18992872536182404,
0.7067347764968872,
0.15254594385623932,
0.228469580411911,
-0.21133889257907867,
-0.5194138288497925,
-0.9225184917449951,
-0.5659441947937012,
-0.10715924948453903,
0.09480694681406021,
0.33544862270355225,
0.41612643003463745,
-0.16278797388076782,
0.7187684178352356,
-0.7006683349609375,
-0.15727239847183228,
-0.13198798894882202,
0.36920008063316345,
-0.08487655967473984,
0.3410097360610962,
0.6271644234657288,
-0.7938516139984131,
0.0019857154693454504,
-0.04838751256465912,
-0.4935401678085327,
0.2629897892475128,
-0.04728776216506958,
-0.3462182283401489,
0.3507594168186188,
0.29740065336227417,
-0.9929578900337219,
0.3854277431964874,
0.5349346995353699,
-0.3241681456565857,
0.6293720006942749,
-0.26244407892227173,
0.27555254101753235,
-1.0687843561172485,
0.09484304487705231,
0.15696077048778534,
0.05261029675602913,
-0.3831322491168976,
0.5359591245651245,
0.11449296772480011,
-0.2641095817089081,
-0.46926236152648926,
0.5055081248283386,
-0.34558138251304626,
-0.33816707134246826,
-0.21646223962306976,
0.5050899386405945,
-0.23025453090667725,
0.532753586769104,
0.13258032500743866,
0.8464140295982361,
0.2738153040409088,
-0.9497271776199341,
0.34327659010887146,
0.08442787081003189,
-0.4150342643260956,
1.0921120643615723,
-0.3620772361755371,
0.3570908010005951,
0.3103656768798828,
0.19923639297485352,
-0.9246892929077148,
-0.047415364533662796,
0.025201810523867607,
-0.29279446601867676,
-0.01753106527030468,
-0.09316100180149078,
-0.3583633005619049,
-0.4130686819553375,
-0.04116285592317581,
0.4193434715270996,
0.6633236408233643,
-0.35148635506629944,
0.5837231874465942,
0.3545312285423279,
0.369476318359375,
0.027946842834353447,
-0.6056339740753174,
0.2018992304801941,
-0.5174406170845032,
-0.1665789633989334,
0.4162500202655792,
-0.34980905055999756,
-0.4955861270427704,
-0.3154756426811218,
-0.11088201403617859,
-0.21493394672870636,
0.2990800738334656,
-0.03236691653728485,
0.1077950969338417,
0.16709402203559875,
0.2053014487028122,
-0.14186523854732513,
-0.2699742317199707,
0.4125792384147644,
-0.08438464254140854,
0.8704599142074585,
-0.08922157436609268,
-0.3201245963573456,
-0.22518713772296906,
-0.1478271484375,
0.9210386276245117,
-0.3967668414115906,
0.4030221700668335,
0.09347742050886154,
-0.6698986887931824,
-0.16262362897396088,
-0.4740922152996063,
-0.07581858336925507,
-0.452234148979187,
0.26511150598526,
-0.9857839941978455,
-0.5053523182868958,
0.32088738679885864,
-0.7467319965362549,
-0.054240450263023376,
0.2964315116405487,
0.6178452968597412,
0.12999366223812103,
0.9467488527297974,
0.13808836042881012,
0.011109772138297558,
0.02464485354721546,
-0.21537701785564423,
0.15524062514305115,
-1.0749077796936035,
-0.0822061225771904,
-0.5832250118255615,
-0.49510934948921204,
-0.464854896068573,
-0.5870336890220642,
0.2333332747220993,
-0.32268789410591125,
-0.2008437216281891,
0.41463685035705566,
-0.44716766476631165,
0.441769003868103,
0.2054639458656311,
0.14099402725696564,
0.14313678443431854,
-0.5005603432655334,
-0.3349384665489197,
-0.21399742364883423,
-0.14378955960273743,
-0.6376714110374451,
1.0026644468307495,
0.08770923316478729,
0.33952978253364563,
0.2902594804763794,
0.3498315215110779,
0.19758933782577515,
0.23678380250930786,
-0.8850651979446411,
0.9620956778526306,
0.2539350092411041,
-0.7845037579536438,
-0.21165341138839722,
-0.45172107219696045,
-1.3069578409194946,
0.6890296936035156,
-0.22279924154281616,
-0.8228620886802673,
-0.0675709918141365,
0.11455145478248596,
-0.13583870232105255,
0.44906026124954224,
-0.3714181184768677,
0.6795279383659363,
-0.47125858068466187,
-0.44587650895118713,
-0.6937792301177979,
-0.27432185411453247,
0.4511067271232605,
-0.0350150503218174,
0.12724341452121735,
-0.38284507393836975,
-0.27432748675346375,
0.5899662971496582,
-0.06480802595615387,
0.44166994094848633,
-0.15871432423591614,
-0.38305971026420593,
-0.07786096632480621,
0.7983656525611877,
0.48121413588523865,
-0.2833617329597473,
-0.421924352645874,
-0.2807702422142029,
0.003109812270849943,
-0.40609827637672424,
-0.7627363801002502,
0.49159809947013855,
-0.7012194395065308,
-0.5966528058052063,
-0.5406230688095093,
-0.5957547426223755,
-0.715366542339325,
0.07664777338504791,
0.2082689255475998,
0.16369786858558655,
-0.5295481085777283,
-0.1544458419084549,
0.5715176463127136,
-0.02709920145571232,
-0.009716006927192211,
0.46314841508865356,
-0.4380740523338318,
-0.2615988254547119,
0.892484188079834,
0.036905087530612946,
0.23209354281425476,
0.13044369220733643,
0.2609090507030487,
-0.07665359973907471,
-0.46445152163505554,
0.1060742661356926,
0.06217029318213463,
-0.5267838835716248,
-0.3131885528564453,
-0.12548984587192535,
-0.2341133952140808,
-0.06542307138442993,
-0.21653223037719727,
-0.6262763738632202,
-0.04330813139677048,
0.307160884141922,
-0.20165513455867767,
0.23265619575977325,
0.6365932822227478,
0.31186094880104065,
0.047500137239694595,
-0.31298044323921204,
0.27638643980026245,
0.3631286323070526,
0.6031382083892822,
0.0977880209684372,
-0.289627343416214,
-0.16962583363056183,
0.1854303777217865,
-0.42933428287506104,
-0.8569476008415222,
0.19602972269058228,
-0.2404201626777649,
0.5763738751411438,
0.42099830508232117,
0.32019031047821045,
0.9619726538658142,
-0.0748521015048027,
0.7266284227371216,
-0.04294406622648239,
-1.097760796546936,
0.6644159555435181,
-0.23633058369159698,
0.05615219101309776,
0.36598798632621765,
0.41654688119888306,
-0.5768388509750366,
-0.36808112263679504,
-0.8391517996788025,
-0.535220205783844,
0.4438117444515228,
0.12674392759799957,
-0.14013805985450745,
-0.04941640794277191,
0.3969665467739105,
0.15238013863563538,
0.36502689123153687,
-0.4819674491882324,
-0.000004353588792582741,
0.3972280025482178,
-0.019942820072174072,
-0.20719334483146667,
-0.07286161929368973,
-0.304505854845047,
-0.29803669452667236,
0.617967426776886,
-0.0383710078895092,
0.4974048137664795,
0.23276405036449432,
-0.27992919087409973,
-0.13774868845939636,
0.21607016026973724,
0.806157648563385,
0.7166840434074402,
-0.34888607263565063,
0.371327668428421,
0.334867388010025,
-0.007557801436632872,
0.448590487241745,
-0.02591978758573532,
0.3254512846469879,
-0.37714362144470215,
0.1792054921388626,
0.6663334369659424,
0.4108274281024933,
-0.9601296782493591,
0.26427894830703735,
-0.13182339072227478,
-0.5866761803627014,
-0.38596442341804504,
0.20527054369449615,
-0.09672493487596512,
0.48275554180145264,
0.17132197320461273,
-0.17081330716609955,
-0.02119469828903675,
-0.5945941209793091,
0.19479113817214966,
0.4172690808773041,
-0.44785642623901367,
-0.30335816740989685,
0.5026233792304993,
0.34968045353889465,
-0.6137430667877197,
0.5293392539024353,
-0.40837085247039795,
-0.6336724162101746,
0.6143903136253357,
0.5416677594184875,
0.9762131571769714,
-0.24685487151145935,
0.1127069815993309,
0.062657929956913,
0.44173815846443176,
0.1867372691631317,
0.38271236419677734,
-0.024333003908395767,
-0.9434589147567749,
0.1372450888156891,
-0.10603663325309753,
-0.9081398844718933,
0.35137060284614563,
-0.9806386828422546,
0.041313014924526215,
-0.5852178931236267,
-0.49534279108047485,
-0.33382168412208557,
0.5341120958328247,
-0.8841407895088196,
0.36771178245544434,
0.06136526167392731,
1.0645062923431396,
-0.505837619304657,
0.8618563413619995,
0.8787205219268799,
-0.18398763239383698,
-0.3402749001979828,
0.38996949791908264,
-0.007389709819108248,
-0.8910149931907654,
0.12724636495113373,
0.13442999124526978,
-0.35352805256843567,
-0.1139775738120079,
-0.542991578578949,
-0.6073868274688721,
1.2165518999099731,
0.7307307720184326,
-0.4281732439994812,
0.23495325446128845,
0.04947497695684433,
0.5984893441200256,
-0.3652240037918091,
0.31330177187919617,
0.9360194206237793,
0.7751015424728394,
-0.07731335610151291,
-0.6756727695465088,
0.34323182702064514,
-0.31099191308021545,
0.15576690435409546,
0.316536545753479,
-1.2175235748291016,
0.7450354099273682,
0.20485463738441467,
0.004236531909555197,
0.19425977766513824,
0.5110940933227539,
0.5829676985740662,
0.3883357346057892,
0.8469028472900391,
0.7080715894699097,
0.9901458024978638,
-0.1602303385734558,
1.1114298105239868,
-0.3727146089076996,
0.405767023563385,
0.988658607006073,
-0.9720649719238281,
0.9313827157020569,
0.4702436625957489,
-0.3393763601779938,
0.3775416612625122,
0.7384058237075806,
0.10979300737380981,
0.2868075668811798,
0.645964503288269,
0.049135319888591766,
-0.5118494033813477,
-0.0018347298027947545,
-0.16430386900901794,
0.6507323384284973,
0.49814411997795105,
0.010867304168641567,
0.046977702528238297,
-0.0103217838332057,
0.16934671998023987,
0.23035985231399536,
0.001867320155724883,
0.6501445174217224,
-0.03136702999472618,
-0.8557189702987671,
0.4624749720096588,
-0.12317483872175217,
0.5122073292732239,
-0.5298302173614502,
0.227815642952919,
-0.11425300687551498,
0.2994718551635742,
0.421982079744339,
-0.7209249138832092,
0.1796346753835678,
-0.13805131614208221,
0.2900683581829071,
-0.13312897086143494,
0.5436844229698181,
-0.31928277015686035,
-0.184848353266716,
0.8002002239227295,
0.4340503513813019,
0.3842340409755707,
-0.052914559841156006,
-0.8081855773925781,
0.42458969354629517,
-0.44167137145996094,
-0.5288982391357422,
0.5241283774375916,
0.5381327867507935,
0.28730663657188416,
0.9083541035652161,
0.33600521087646484,
0.051951829344034195,
-0.36707058548927307,
-0.27938929200172424,
0.6447069048881531,
-1.0171700716018677,
-0.19455090165138245,
-0.8246042132377625,
0.13982342183589935,
-0.16009707748889923,
-0.6341234445571899,
0.32451650500297546,
0.47970256209373474,
0.8295075297355652,
0.32175037264823914,
0.7367051839828491,
0.029303936287760735,
0.19735603034496307,
-0.7319797277450562,
0.7505186796188354,
-0.7695966958999634,
-0.033136460930109024,
-0.4583682715892792,
-0.7406441569328308,
0.06272866576910019,
0.6244411468505859,
-0.190121591091156,
0.2697809934616089,
1.1206609010696411,
0.4644653797149658,
-0.0088735893368721,
0.13323824107646942,
0.7436540126800537,
0.402913361787796,
0.317562460899353,
0.8372864723205566,
1.0021827220916748,
-0.30308738350868225,
0.6566203236579895,
-0.27327752113342285,
-0.04275587573647499,
-0.22529208660125732,
-0.7519333362579346,
-1.0653382539749146,
-0.9390419125556946,
-0.27110499143600464,
-0.25885009765625,
0.09530922025442123,
1.3321435451507568,
0.5625247359275818,
-0.20946462452411652,
-0.766743004322052,
0.0697173923254013,
0.14097382128238678,
-0.5733174085617065,
-0.20652979612350464,
0.10248704999685287,
-0.3378501236438751,
-0.7525317072868347,
0.34131577610969543,
0.10919569432735443,
0.2460247129201889,
-0.4014303386211395,
-0.280474454164505,
-0.326021283864975,
0.5186012387275696,
0.5421791672706604,
-0.06697529554367065,
-0.7612971067428589,
-0.49998682737350464,
-0.37149327993392944,
-0.15982311964035034,
0.018102314323186874,
1.208174705505371,
-0.8459917902946472,
0.30065101385116577,
-0.09668159484863281,
0.6631551384925842,
0.42162778973579407,
-0.3120163381099701,
0.8885519504547119,
-0.3086933195590973,
0.31529825925827026,
0.17885105311870575,
0.45557698607444763,
-0.058747339993715286,
-0.1823364794254303,
0.7122572660446167,
0.05210324376821518,
-0.299868643283844,
-0.9566424489021301,
0.4608211815357208,
-0.7931468486785889,
-0.5114202499389648,
0.6383497714996338,
-0.06856729090213776,
-0.2309274673461914,
0.18079297244548798,
-0.1875176727771759,
0.2801096737384796,
-0.21858467161655426,
1.0471395254135132,
0.94840008020401,
-0.08975901454687119,
-0.2920251190662384,
-0.31396767497062683,
0.4697003960609436,
0.6541767716407776,
-0.9492123126983643,
0.3324824869632721,
0.17049746215343475,
-0.3301672339439392,
0.09128814935684204,
0.5644689202308655,
0.12478353828191757,
0.314554363489151,
-0.12980929017066956,
0.2496076077222824,
0.14171476662158966,
-0.2758944034576416,
-0.2503461241722107,
0.05067126452922821,
0.28642311692237854,
-0.11532697081565857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13613v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13613v1
|
The Branch Not Taken: Predicting Branching in Online Conversations
| 2024-04-21T10:49:41 | 2024-04-21T10:49:41 |
Shai Meital, Lior Rokach, Roman Vainshtein, Nir Grinberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Multi-participant discussions tend to unfold in a tree structure rather than
a chain structure. Branching may occur for multiple reasons -- from the
asynchronous nature of online platforms to a conscious decision by an
interlocutor to disengage with part of the conversation. Predicting branching
and understanding the reasons for creating new branches is important for many
downstream tasks such as summarization and thread disentanglement and may help
develop online spaces that encourage users to engage in online discussions in
more meaningful ways. In this work, we define the novel task of branch
prediction and propose GLOBS (Global Branching Score) -- a deep neural network
model for predicting branching. GLOBS is evaluated on three large discussion
forums from Reddit, achieving significant improvements over an array of
competitive baselines and demonstrating better transferability. We affirm that
structural, temporal, and linguistic features contribute to GLOBS success and
find that branching is associated with a greater number of conversation
participants and tends to occur in earlier levels of the conversation tree. We
publicly release GLOBS and our implementation of all baseline models to allow
reproducibility and promote further research on this important task.
|
[
-0.7476327419281006,
-1.2067384719848633,
0.7324320077896118,
0.08856864273548126,
-0.39556390047073364,
0.5694178342819214,
-0.0045785787515342236,
-0.9797139167785645,
0.7501861453056335,
0.15611465275287628,
-1.0633422136306763,
-0.2996535897254944,
-0.8001987934112549,
-0.35878369212150574,
-0.7428886890411377,
1.118691086769104,
0.2068270891904831,
-0.05488865450024605,
-0.2708042562007904,
0.21936072409152985,
-0.4069002866744995,
-0.3610008955001831,
-0.6599220037460327,
-0.2892867922782898,
0.7903013825416565,
0.30614492297172546,
0.5038917064666748,
0.425446480512619,
0.6031738519668579,
0.2975237965583801,
-0.6813738942146301,
-0.1499372273683548,
-0.49125316739082336,
0.16860412061214447,
0.17368896305561066,
-0.36237049102783203,
-0.42343494296073914,
-0.44358766078948975,
0.3266645073890686,
0.7999154329299927,
-0.05444222688674927,
0.19591811299324036,
0.06668628752231598,
0.6119795441627502,
-0.16548371315002441,
0.17826031148433685,
-0.921528697013855,
-0.03317275270819664,
0.07631156593561172,
-0.05557761713862419,
-0.13157154619693756,
-0.8006611466407776,
0.45722874999046326,
-0.04474848136305809,
0.16272100806236267,
-0.3858804404735565,
0.6927179098129272,
-0.11623221635818481,
-0.4622032940387726,
-0.5410220623016357,
-0.6013947129249573,
0.1198691874742508,
-0.7188013195991516,
0.1152111068367958,
0.46637192368507385,
0.46136701107025146,
-0.01115543581545353,
-0.6335338950157166,
0.041097261011600494,
-0.10065434128046036,
-0.08764376491308212,
-0.11857643723487854,
-0.3059081733226776,
0.1260499209165573,
-0.08296909928321838,
0.33326655626296997,
-0.19858524203300476,
-0.02270018681883812,
-0.8803160190582275,
-0.09653337299823761,
0.38006365299224854,
0.25101959705352783,
0.15039224922657013,
-0.2162664532661438,
-0.10122834146022797,
0.3431810438632965,
-0.3851924538612366,
0.2419390082359314,
0.4156568646430969,
0.33116111159324646,
0.02007707580924034,
0.40339356660842896,
-0.12212219834327698,
0.3623492121696472,
0.2573586106300354,
0.050286322832107544,
0.051845017820596695,
-0.7765030264854431,
-0.06239404156804085,
-0.08587069064378738,
0.5796867609024048,
0.43419593572616577,
0.2340322732925415,
0.00821810681372881,
0.23821230232715607,
-0.040098775178194046,
0.34422898292541504,
-0.91916424036026,
-0.31245481967926025,
0.25843721628189087,
-0.5556483268737793,
-0.2498849630355835,
0.24307750165462494,
-0.8206878900527954,
-0.36380815505981445,
-0.13335031270980835,
-0.15797941386699677,
-0.2720032036304474,
-0.3242250382900238,
-0.6202149987220764,
-0.16518916189670563,
-0.3331097960472107,
0.7919257879257202,
-0.681062638759613,
0.5028039813041687,
0.7865173816680908,
1.2207952737808228,
-0.05675598233938217,
-0.22359193861484528,
-0.17329825460910797,
-0.368185430765152,
-0.6411043405532837,
0.6414034962654114,
-0.5397276878356934,
-0.37876373529434204,
-0.23001132905483246,
0.02911776304244995,
0.37666159868240356,
-0.04321790114045143,
0.3080534338951111,
-0.46586179733276367,
0.2348850518465042,
-0.06701774895191193,
-0.6327459216117859,
-0.575674831867218,
0.37360745668411255,
-0.5718183517456055,
0.08030746132135391,
-0.08617185801267624,
-0.7745392322540283,
0.3559753894805908,
-0.6437667608261108,
-0.23699751496315002,
0.1434774547815323,
-0.013549307361245155,
-0.42598259449005127,
0.22322922945022583,
0.20762333273887634,
0.27498260140419006,
0.05547172203660011,
0.5739951133728027,
-0.6324723362922668,
-0.27666690945625305,
0.33726614713668823,
-0.35685062408447266,
0.7074933052062988,
-0.07446113228797913,
-0.16618120670318604,
0.5286808013916016,
0.1759042888879776,
0.3802795708179474,
-0.3301507830619812,
-0.0507575161755085,
0.005317810922861099,
0.2895762622356415,
-0.302333265542984,
0.11151941865682602,
-0.03188244625926018,
-0.4465029537677765,
0.43578559160232544,
-0.4575114846229553,
0.6624836325645447,
0.74248868227005,
0.5622501969337463,
0.30215659737586975,
-0.09027788788080215,
0.39490875601768494,
-0.07636664062738419,
0.5127947926521301,
-0.26798292994499207,
-1.0230661630630493,
-0.4301142692565918,
0.015461761504411697,
0.33109861612319946,
0.2077120542526245,
-0.21139773726463318,
0.3823632597923279,
-0.1906043291091919,
-0.9289682507514954,
-0.08573437482118607,
0.10700914263725281,
0.2567807137966156,
-0.10063624382019043,
0.27928444743156433,
-0.5918425917625427,
-0.6279317736625671,
-0.6396304368972778,
-0.002690024906769395,
-0.4680354595184326,
-0.015788471326231956,
0.44857078790664673,
0.4389747977256775,
-0.6230905652046204,
1.0643181800842285,
-0.4637151062488556,
-0.506980836391449,
-0.3769294023513794,
0.5775879621505737,
0.2654123306274414,
0.0859895721077919,
0.04875953495502472,
-0.7290521264076233,
-0.5639314651489258,
0.14159537851810455,
-0.48574283719062805,
0.3813207149505615,
-0.1283424198627472,
0.08470392972230911,
0.03574075177311897,
0.7241982817649841,
-0.6862781643867493,
0.48914772272109985,
0.9322510361671448,
-0.5339623093605042,
0.3634178638458252,
-0.13114894926548004,
-0.07324185222387314,
-0.9639975428581238,
-0.157040536403656,
-0.3211592733860016,
-0.25192612409591675,
-0.5755809545516968,
-0.35172075033187866,
0.05178435146808624,
-0.01329064555466175,
-0.44620567560195923,
0.2725197374820709,
-0.5659618973731995,
-0.22437334060668945,
-0.2260969877243042,
-0.0636981800198555,
-0.21721938252449036,
0.5717812180519104,
-0.2592247724533081,
0.3570678234100342,
0.5956125259399414,
-0.6178194284439087,
0.19364717602729797,
0.28555092215538025,
-0.48866453766822815,
-0.27140671014785767,
-0.6051780581474304,
0.09603910893201828,
-0.03824080899357796,
0.48914605379104614,
-1.0082228183746338,
-0.3663812279701233,
0.2581281065940857,
-0.8474939465522766,
0.10627145320177078,
-0.2662784159183502,
-0.0218756552785635,
-0.5929621458053589,
-0.3240533471107483,
0.370819091796875,
0.37058210372924805,
-0.09141033887863159,
0.364467054605484,
0.7294034957885742,
-0.4324168562889099,
-0.2597833275794983,
-0.7042402029037476,
0.11966922134160995,
-0.2349233329296112,
-0.5754989385604858,
0.2521267831325531,
-0.12369440495967865,
-0.08444555848836899,
0.31221309304237366,
-0.013733184896409512,
-0.34328004717826843,
0.3414582908153534,
0.6152286529541016,
0.2006274312734604,
-0.13678008317947388,
0.29471510648727417,
-0.17237938940525055,
0.14653019607067108,
0.3831673562526703,
-0.07190155237913132,
0.41320469975471497,
-0.3846118152141571,
-0.6632210612297058,
-0.30027103424072266,
0.21056970953941345,
0.7841826677322388,
0.0602991096675396,
0.5715062022209167,
0.3087858259677887,
-0.345400869846344,
0.05338475853204727,
-0.5052956342697144,
-0.47329556941986084,
-0.3893902599811554,
0.5639079809188843,
0.22618527710437775,
-1.1434452533721924,
0.6012488603591919,
-0.07628650218248367,
0.10102296620607376,
0.13616016507148743,
0.6351878643035889,
-0.14054468274116516,
0.9462114572525024,
0.777016818523407,
0.07733415067195892,
0.7109882235527039,
-0.0302107036113739,
0.4093541204929352,
-0.7096247673034668,
-0.16803428530693054,
-0.1144029051065445,
-0.6232798099517822,
-0.7141537070274353,
-0.708085298538208,
0.0023618813138455153,
0.4542534351348877,
0.3816286623477936,
0.38107064366340637,
-0.35737138986587524,
0.7170801162719727,
0.3533267378807068,
-0.22890734672546387,
0.2627035975456238,
0.0220014750957489,
0.06804288178682327,
0.007732492405921221,
-0.2909442186355591,
-0.0773579403758049,
1.0086671113967896,
0.6289730668067932,
0.48428255319595337,
0.04658680036664009,
0.6136522889137268,
0.36814194917678833,
0.5318734645843506,
-0.9522939324378967,
0.43164893984794617,
0.1894904226064682,
-1.0121245384216309,
-0.5931305289268494,
-0.6141066551208496,
-1.1128352880477905,
0.16133743524551392,
0.0006775350775569677,
-1.3333427906036377,
-0.0847698524594307,
0.0599999874830246,
-0.40784621238708496,
0.446492999792099,
-0.6709135174751282,
0.8495954871177673,
-0.524997889995575,
-0.042956236749887466,
-0.35799476504325867,
-0.7051396369934082,
0.6122553944587708,
-0.18761980533599854,
0.378890722990036,
-0.410143107175827,
0.29311278462409973,
0.578037440776825,
-0.09251127392053604,
0.9791817665100098,
-0.06049909442663193,
0.5138776898384094,
0.7504579424858093,
0.3218477964401245,
0.24661822617053986,
0.2200614959001541,
0.4324476420879364,
0.4300563931465149,
-0.18483367562294006,
0.16183380782604218,
-0.39025992155075073,
0.5093730092048645,
-0.7890289425849915,
-0.46017685532569885,
-0.25261595845222473,
-0.11638478189706802,
-0.20720930397510529,
0.11284350603818893,
0.18954361975193024,
0.1121862381696701,
-0.5026713013648987,
0.6067413091659546,
0.029466858133673668,
0.1873396635055542,
0.7008693218231201,
-0.05060720071196556,
-0.9571365714073181,
-0.5658957958221436,
0.8904423117637634,
0.3156520128250122,
0.36743953824043274,
-0.049285564571619034,
0.41174930334091187,
-0.4309629797935486,
-0.5252864956855774,
-0.2780430316925049,
0.13745251297950745,
-0.8161190748214722,
-0.3270772695541382,
-0.6265905499458313,
-0.5704196691513062,
-0.06781044602394104,
-0.016706718131899834,
-0.28712213039398193,
-0.4309071898460388,
-0.22543105483055115,
-0.4671112298965454,
0.34695225954055786,
1.1928998231887817,
0.06184737756848335,
0.058452121913433075,
-1.0651527643203735,
0.026049939915537834,
0.47385263442993164,
0.369284987449646,
0.26807039976119995,
-0.4187047779560089,
-0.22578653693199158,
0.19665564596652985,
-0.5899112820625305,
-0.9303650259971619,
0.5857958793640137,
0.3207018971443176,
0.5240224003791809,
0.4248596727848053,
-0.3034377098083496,
0.8007055521011353,
-0.18753597140312195,
0.5638975501060486,
0.49111413955688477,
-1.031703233718872,
0.5951455235481262,
-0.28402820229530334,
0.352012574672699,
0.5151538252830505,
0.6191504001617432,
-0.7450902462005615,
-0.6919640898704529,
-0.960735559463501,
-1.0670320987701416,
0.7099297046661377,
0.3587626516819,
0.3805890679359436,
0.13593952357769012,
-0.21382737159729004,
0.2682421803474426,
0.4358331859111786,
-0.8257461190223694,
0.10910003632307053,
0.04062328860163689,
0.45719948410987854,
0.031392455101013184,
-0.2823178768157959,
0.010822830721735954,
-0.3777817189693451,
0.3189043700695038,
-0.3385941684246063,
0.3816632926464081,
0.058755986392498016,
0.19020473957061768,
-0.602301836013794,
0.23374436795711517,
0.5379077196121216,
1.115450382232666,
-0.4182339906692505,
-0.12690888345241547,
0.31105828285217285,
-0.108400858938694,
-0.07304435223340988,
-0.4435163736343384,
-0.10941573232412338,
0.1733068823814392,
0.4481073021888733,
1.0283645391464233,
0.19347405433654785,
-0.33409571647644043,
0.34047943353652954,
-0.447477251291275,
-0.44482284784317017,
-0.27454426884651184,
-0.20943139493465424,
0.7748681306838989,
0.280659019947052,
0.24161331355571747,
0.32544445991516113,
0.12109922617673874,
-0.8060237765312195,
0.4495738446712494,
0.43562495708465576,
-0.7961240410804749,
-0.33210375905036926,
0.11072208732366562,
0.2544911503791809,
-0.6524627804756165,
0.7785751223564148,
-0.2552146315574646,
-0.6053177714347839,
0.7644831538200378,
0.14703592658042908,
1.1217361688613892,
0.11054270714521408,
0.5280632376670837,
0.58345627784729,
0.10631725937128067,
0.14743207395076752,
-0.40177106857299805,
0.02231621742248535,
-0.46505531668663025,
-0.485293447971344,
-0.7075543403625488,
-0.7730519771575928,
-0.049989815801382065,
-0.3540213704109192,
0.2177838832139969,
-0.5356718897819519,
-0.5616547465324402,
-0.07360866665840149,
-0.13506990671157837,
-0.15331339836120605,
-0.06923528760671616,
0.6581615209579468,
0.6620891690254211,
-0.6793010830879211,
0.7928482890129089,
0.1921258419752121,
-0.2844960391521454,
-0.6800817251205444,
0.2887876033782959,
0.11413975805044174,
-0.25764331221580505,
0.5256166458129883,
0.7439771294593811,
0.18128274381160736,
-0.35133638978004456,
-0.06321977823972702,
-1.2343343496322632,
0.9264103770256042,
0.2603764533996582,
-0.5097110271453857,
-0.44766974449157715,
-0.1059938594698906,
0.7332763075828552,
-0.32934531569480896,
0.8956314325332642,
-0.06968466192483902,
0.271344393491745,
0.6143606901168823,
-0.9138944745063782,
-0.17704568803310394,
-0.038843970745801926,
-0.23401828110218048,
0.3351474702358246,
-0.28293704986572266,
1.2071688175201416,
-0.33391427993774414,
-0.48870646953582764,
-0.19976192712783813,
0.5717154741287231,
-0.07068727910518646,
0.07846269756555557,
0.522973895072937,
0.14353971183300018,
0.8348152041435242,
-0.20378494262695312,
0.8414154052734375,
-0.21624970436096191,
0.5462934970855713,
0.9877269864082336,
0.1428731381893158,
0.9498952627182007,
0.5216798186302185,
-0.008497320115566254,
0.6714473962783813,
0.7760300040245056,
0.05168706178665161,
0.4724617600440979,
0.2327822893857956,
0.2565308213233948,
-0.07680121064186096,
-0.05633440613746643,
-0.6255870461463928,
0.4371313452720642,
0.5319404006004333,
-0.43829166889190674,
-0.3731423318386078,
-0.38115477561950684,
-0.18802949786186218,
-0.4679008424282074,
-0.3665502369403839,
1.1666873693466187,
0.09219595789909363,
-1.123902440071106,
0.3424012064933777,
-0.2682466208934784,
0.42954713106155396,
-0.8410773277282715,
0.027778049930930138,
-0.2141575962305069,
0.5570741295814514,
-0.3093148171901703,
-1.1316076517105103,
0.8405448794364929,
-0.2049059271812439,
0.14108331501483917,
-0.48586800694465637,
0.6366139054298401,
-0.253502756357193,
-0.7286031246185303,
1.139639973640442,
0.8964152336120605,
0.12370084971189499,
-0.2697768211364746,
-0.7969950437545776,
0.04190994054079056,
0.1479431390762329,
-0.4296455383300781,
0.5222734808921814,
0.5503250360488892,
-0.17682179808616638,
0.6754283905029297,
0.7897312641143799,
-0.020530030131340027,
0.09168457239866257,
-0.14909225702285767,
0.9870029091835022,
-0.6234193444252014,
-0.5775035619735718,
-1.1006156206130981,
0.6346690654754639,
-0.11531896144151688,
-0.39951086044311523,
0.571123480796814,
0.27917611598968506,
0.720838189125061,
0.007404035422950983,
0.5399402379989624,
-0.11285533010959625,
0.39793792366981506,
-0.27456510066986084,
0.7112695574760437,
-0.4194747507572174,
-0.0772799476981163,
-0.3012602627277374,
-0.9554185271263123,
0.017959853634238243,
0.41870999336242676,
-0.2992362678050995,
-0.25917837023735046,
0.9511092305183411,
0.45609718561172485,
0.0865418016910553,
0.27543705701828003,
0.20656508207321167,
0.05954741686582565,
0.5559104084968567,
0.4833846390247345,
0.8885026574134827,
-0.042700596153736115,
0.9200379848480225,
-0.25584450364112854,
-0.0349092036485672,
-0.5035234093666077,
-0.718409538269043,
-0.959477424621582,
-0.4769226610660553,
-0.19587558507919312,
-0.11685507744550705,
-0.07466229796409607,
0.7434380054473877,
0.8003425002098083,
-0.971327543258667,
-0.6168924570083618,
-0.8059954643249512,
0.38519740104675293,
-0.09978099167346954,
-0.17446526885032654,
-0.2422950565814972,
-0.34310150146484375,
-0.2890942692756653,
0.36197391152381897,
0.20764672756195068,
-0.0727933794260025,
-0.3403211832046509,
-0.10148931294679642,
-0.49776074290275574,
-0.1714412271976471,
0.28931576013565063,
0.3115606904029846,
-1.0807565450668335,
-0.21238885819911957,
0.11131840944290161,
-0.16456016898155212,
0.3828542232513428,
0.7620259523391724,
-0.5457788705825806,
0.5121292471885681,
0.6968968510627747,
0.7095262408256531,
0.7834909558296204,
0.34239205718040466,
0.5345413684844971,
-0.631290853023529,
-0.2861158847808838,
0.6045814156532288,
0.17076633870601654,
0.24914446473121643,
-0.2876465320587158,
0.4846724271774292,
0.10061566531658173,
-0.601658046245575,
-0.5803342461585999,
0.1185692772269249,
-0.5829737782478333,
-0.6875028014183044,
0.7940834164619446,
-0.20005661249160767,
-0.1785816252231598,
-0.06785890460014343,
-0.3835398554801941,
0.13823875784873962,
-0.5875839591026306,
0.8247751593589783,
1.0264784097671509,
-0.3094455897808075,
-0.22760823369026184,
-0.3214779794216156,
0.339510977268219,
0.12495674192905426,
-1.0910124778747559,
0.351584792137146,
0.4622664451599121,
-0.1487124264240265,
0.8029274344444275,
0.6849334239959717,
0.29623422026634216,
0.09535364806652069,
0.07185215502977371,
-0.271535724401474,
-0.024385755881667137,
-0.7034943103790283,
-0.09311773627996445,
0.6856256723403931,
0.17374689877033234,
0.08584289997816086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13611v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13611v2
|
Video sentence grounding with temporally global textual knowledge
| 2024-04-21T10:41:04 | 2024-06-01T06:56:16 |
Cai Chen, Runzhong Zhang, Jianjun Gao, Kejun Wu, Kim-Hui Yap, Yi Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Temporal sentence grounding involves the retrieval of a video moment with a
natural language query. Many existing works directly incorporate the given
video and temporally localized query for temporal grounding, overlooking the
inherent domain gap between different modalities. In this paper, we utilize
pseudo-query features containing extensive temporally global textual knowledge
sourced from the same video-query pair, to enhance the bridging of domain gaps
and attain a heightened level of similarity between multi-modal features.
Specifically, we propose a Pseudo-query Intermediary Network (PIN) to achieve
an improved alignment of visual and comprehensive pseudo-query features within
the feature space through contrastive learning. Subsequently, we utilize
learnable prompts to encapsulate the knowledge of pseudo-queries, propagating
them into the textual encoder and multi-modal fusion module, further enhancing
the feature alignment between visual and language for better temporal
grounding. Extensive experiments conducted on the Charades-STA and
ActivityNet-Captions datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our method.
|
[
-0.213068887591362,
-1.0025118589401245,
0.6817407608032227,
0.194680854678154,
-0.5802128911018372,
0.04575233906507492,
-0.06319224089384079,
-0.1595117300748825,
0.4898914396762848,
0.22884467244148254,
-0.7616428732872009,
-0.4741487503051758,
-0.2913494110107422,
-0.23684607446193695,
-0.26666080951690674,
0.8038995265960693,
0.0002792603336274624,
0.015000530518591404,
-0.23749606311321259,
-0.4922363758087158,
-0.5927917957305908,
-0.5810443758964539,
-0.18520627915859222,
-0.05765494331717491,
0.07247009128332138,
0.3121463358402252,
0.6128652691841125,
0.38504159450531006,
0.41897663474082947,
0.34527114033699036,
0.21117644011974335,
0.4854734539985657,
-0.4280319809913635,
0.05879721790552139,
-0.4455583691596985,
-0.5228731036186218,
0.06301853805780411,
-0.18686053156852722,
0.6543166041374207,
0.5148000717163086,
0.2299516350030899,
-0.08181801438331604,
-0.13118600845336914,
0.5586238503456116,
-0.5508663058280945,
0.19786818325519562,
-0.9036957025527954,
0.2818830609321594,
-0.13772746920585632,
-0.7360387444496155,
-0.10903024673461914,
-0.2994886636734009,
0.18202175199985504,
-0.6626549363136292,
0.4212525188922882,
0.2682308256626129,
1.3333165645599365,
0.4019245207309723,
-0.3341190218925476,
0.0722043365240097,
-0.38667377829551697,
0.48304158449172974,
-0.3430853486061096,
0.40156930685043335,
0.6559363603591919,
0.47177666425704956,
0.16651247441768646,
-0.7286897301673889,
-0.8397912979125977,
-0.24331097304821014,
-0.22823359072208405,
0.21151848137378693,
0.03587351366877556,
0.06240500882267952,
0.23273247480392456,
0.293827086687088,
-0.7945773005485535,
-0.2914360761642456,
-0.09455478191375732,
-0.16223548352718353,
0.04095941036939621,
0.10198447108268738,
0.6061499714851379,
-0.5038926005363464,
-0.3094668686389923,
-0.04362056776881218,
-0.5305598974227905,
0.18269343674182892,
0.2475711852312088,
0.1165870651602745,
-0.22814807295799255,
0.8189114928245544,
-0.3727044463157654,
0.6238489151000977,
0.3686327338218689,
0.022292768582701683,
0.2951217293739319,
-0.6098026633262634,
-0.35473987460136414,
0.12261040508747101,
0.6217125058174133,
0.8600668907165527,
0.007364020682871342,
-0.2817094326019287,
0.23045264184474945,
0.33089298009872437,
0.19595898687839508,
-0.6799247860908508,
-0.3815167546272278,
-0.0719376802444458,
-0.548894464969635,
0.10270959883928299,
0.47593966126441956,
-0.5916116237640381,
-0.0067934151738882065,
-0.5228506922721863,
0.4612506926059723,
-0.5008041262626648,
0.06536053121089935,
-0.14762870967388153,
-0.05398264527320862,
0.34117650985717773,
0.004492791369557381,
-0.6995993256568909,
0.1300833821296692,
0.17385219037532806,
1.1097379922866821,
0.31118831038475037,
-0.27928051352500916,
-0.8324703574180603,
0.348389208316803,
-0.24545755982398987,
0.732714056968689,
-0.570059597492218,
-0.05488446727395058,
0.15627674758434296,
0.4274192750453949,
-0.13814420998096466,
-0.449489951133728,
0.2562761604785919,
-0.8703914880752563,
0.48946741223335266,
-0.3359663784503937,
-0.23739147186279297,
-0.10923711210489273,
0.5441731214523315,
-0.5246935486793518,
1.0047508478164673,
-0.1892208307981491,
-0.8707764148712158,
0.4719148278236389,
-0.2775953710079193,
-0.47863852977752686,
-0.27224692702293396,
-0.49737799167633057,
-0.47717034816741943,
-0.12862247228622437,
0.6841287612915039,
0.3161580264568329,
-0.05083151534199715,
0.7158090472221375,
-0.23839735984802246,
-0.48490071296691895,
-0.0211550984531641,
-0.314208447933197,
0.27439212799072266,
0.11824096739292145,
-0.6356553435325623,
0.17473405599594116,
-0.5624178647994995,
-0.030301913619041443,
-0.0463453009724617,
0.14809373021125793,
-0.39360669255256653,
0.04084354639053345,
-0.16454581916332245,
0.47334393858909607,
-0.014176204800605774,
-0.16128075122833252,
0.08010212332010269,
-0.4749155342578888,
0.5965584516525269,
0.4479767382144928,
0.3571982681751251,
0.6237696409225464,
-0.17932169139385223,
0.25274109840393066,
0.16337192058563232,
0.013865032233297825,
-0.5942226648330688,
-0.1720590740442276,
-0.6575353145599365,
-0.03342602774500847,
-0.17733986675739288,
0.7612770199775696,
-1.234131932258606,
0.6194996237754822,
-0.45141252875328064,
-0.18627113103866577,
-0.29279816150665283,
0.13967333734035492,
0.5017048716545105,
0.8343635201454163,
0.6944419741630554,
0.005072715692222118,
-0.5699235200881958,
-0.9326761364936829,
0.001582267927005887,
-0.36972102522850037,
-0.0644642561674118,
0.5751392245292664,
0.35990649461746216,
0.053636807948350906,
1.012718677520752,
-0.5199494361877441,
-0.5604779124259949,
0.10994301736354828,
0.39967232942581177,
0.24262838065624237,
0.3586222231388092,
0.6610382795333862,
-1.1926409006118774,
-0.4382663071155548,
-0.1951127052307129,
-1.0994044542312622,
-0.21967002749443054,
-0.3834679126739502,
-0.3102930784225464,
-0.22457650303840637,
0.9556629657745361,
-0.608207643032074,
0.284379243850708,
0.23586374521255493,
-0.3448214828968048,
0.3285137712955475,
-0.27046605944633484,
0.8810955882072449,
-0.9898216128349304,
-0.05880492925643921,
-0.07494404911994934,
-0.258892297744751,
-0.03181347995996475,
-0.2079865038394928,
0.07659002393484116,
-0.317093163728714,
-0.5330122709274292,
0.348389208316803,
-0.5570234656333923,
-0.12174924463033676,
-0.10973242670297623,
0.40216928720474243,
0.1130586788058281,
0.5523295402526855,
0.26831451058387756,
1.0703593492507935,
0.7331841588020325,
-0.6501343846321106,
0.4082300066947937,
0.4437161982059479,
-0.28108084201812744,
0.8011614084243774,
-0.6460481286048889,
-0.060070473700761795,
-0.36827659606933594,
0.2361995428800583,
-1.1890884637832642,
-0.14206057786941528,
0.09541132301092148,
-0.49507614970207214,
0.03480949625372887,
-0.42525458335876465,
-0.44067949056625366,
-0.043517518788576126,
-0.31495046615600586,
0.582813024520874,
0.31467026472091675,
-0.6852036714553833,
0.4189031422138214,
0.1484709233045578,
-0.057269513607025146,
-0.4932587742805481,
-0.6930056810379028,
0.4395129084587097,
-0.3700200021266937,
-0.8320668339729309,
0.854965090751648,
0.06395034492015839,
-0.1970507651567459,
0.17479833960533142,
-0.1884755939245224,
-0.12545618414878845,
-0.37236857414245605,
0.2011108100414276,
0.14396876096725464,
-0.3834303319454193,
0.2463836669921875,
0.18590570986270905,
-0.09297414124011993,
-0.21550150215625763,
-0.5817659497261047,
0.4185127317905426,
-0.06868337094783783,
-0.5295208692550659,
-0.3418741226196289,
0.4632316529750824,
0.20357178151607513,
-0.32922929525375366,
0.7412956357002258,
0.48388445377349854,
-0.4031221568584442,
0.04654152691364288,
-0.6349955797195435,
-0.2781520485877991,
-0.45894914865493774,
0.16142749786376953,
-0.4595559239387512,
-0.9093406200408936,
0.36888888478279114,
-0.2258034497499466,
-0.47379374504089355,
0.15684136748313904,
0.28304001688957214,
-0.44404327869415283,
0.5792815089225769,
0.5508906841278076,
0.024753833189606667,
0.8306170701980591,
-0.44975247979164124,
0.08817865699529648,
-0.40066593885421753,
-0.4136219024658203,
-0.21881668269634247,
-0.25203782320022583,
-0.14144600927829742,
-0.6453145146369934,
0.3794565796852112,
0.5051925778388977,
-0.1332181990146637,
0.1998702436685562,
-0.005631968379020691,
0.6581343412399292,
0.36791688203811646,
0.3453024923801422,
-0.06080174073576927,
0.15513524413108826,
-0.4401888847351074,
-0.6593052744865417,
-0.5820410251617432,
-0.33025485277175903,
0.44116905331611633,
-0.2959195375442505,
0.36507126688957214,
0.28549623489379883,
0.12581434845924377,
0.5389387607574463,
-0.46763086318969727,
-0.39085882902145386,
0.4577915668487549,
-0.157454714179039,
-0.25225526094436646,
-0.1107344850897789,
-0.22668839991092682,
-0.5512335896492004,
0.18700946867465973,
-0.433157742023468,
-0.5344585180282593,
0.01521893497556448,
0.08484476804733276,
-0.13870224356651306,
0.2971859872341156,
-0.7231038808822632,
0.9863616824150085,
-0.35728439688682556,
-0.7316403985023499,
-0.08656399697065353,
-1.2361292839050293,
0.05595947802066803,
0.3447270691394806,
0.17924576997756958,
0.1906178891658783,
0.10942919552326202,
0.3960712254047394,
-0.6163480877876282,
0.7839568257331848,
-0.20097200572490692,
0.49199622869491577,
0.3615008294582367,
0.019514087587594986,
0.3000045418739319,
0.2994467616081238,
0.27273276448249817,
-0.08969666063785553,
-0.5038260221481323,
-0.41305088996887207,
-0.7618029117584229,
0.699187695980072,
-0.5431342124938965,
-0.5098152160644531,
-0.2677440047264099,
-0.09633361548185349,
-0.3307048976421356,
0.23201903700828552,
0.2826158404350281,
0.7189354300498962,
-0.31227290630340576,
0.3407503366470337,
0.9597323536872864,
-0.10659186542034149,
0.7505520582199097,
0.3023468255996704,
0.21725085377693176,
-0.6120390892028809,
0.7749085426330566,
-0.18356379866600037,
0.019599871709942818,
1.0758205652236938,
-0.17202170193195343,
-0.5652457475662231,
-0.5374539494514465,
-0.43612366914749146,
0.23521530628204346,
-0.7566290497779846,
-0.36185336112976074,
-0.8340578079223633,
0.004255249630659819,
-0.5290185809135437,
-0.5047965049743652,
-0.018474092707037926,
-0.1015942245721817,
-0.36094462871551514,
-0.6623135209083557,
0.44184982776641846,
-0.17049725353717804,
0.10406748205423355,
0.6440308094024658,
-0.9851685762405396,
0.9646186232566833,
0.36033785343170166,
0.240341916680336,
-0.48043471574783325,
-0.5997357964515686,
-0.1206187978386879,
-0.41736266016960144,
-0.05737137421965599,
-0.8609411716461182,
0.20036302506923676,
0.5606151223182678,
0.6959617137908936,
0.5174397230148315,
0.029540659859776497,
1.1193056106567383,
-0.8483433723449707,
1.1644822359085083,
0.329475075006485,
-1.001975655555725,
0.9046398401260376,
-0.41779014468193054,
0.332608699798584,
0.7268016338348389,
0.5194960832595825,
-0.3894905745983124,
-0.16344964504241943,
-0.4155315160751343,
-1.0529059171676636,
0.5411114692687988,
0.4104796350002289,
0.20888866484165192,
-0.2550539970397949,
0.36501166224479675,
-0.05175760015845299,
0.1298508644104004,
-0.7570009827613831,
-0.17399004101753235,
-0.7673344016075134,
-0.054199159145355225,
0.0025607727002352476,
-0.17849373817443848,
-0.03300471603870392,
0.012281185016036034,
0.4007357358932495,
-0.3125944435596466,
0.050913505256175995,
0.4294407367706299,
-0.7050518989562988,
0.04785985127091408,
0.21667134761810303,
0.34535786509513855,
0.6917725801467896,
-0.3095380663871765,
0.3961397707462311,
0.12524071335792542,
-0.21209019422531128,
0.2923884689807892,
0.14271636307239532,
-0.06890708208084106,
0.05469296872615814,
0.5996230840682983,
0.8265789747238159,
0.4196305572986603,
-0.5372419953346252,
0.5720861554145813,
-0.033990297466516495,
-0.11411918699741364,
-0.09527940303087234,
-0.3210166394710541,
-0.18047258257865906,
0.46076154708862305,
0.34202057123184204,
-0.04763415455818176,
0.12758579850196838,
-0.6782855987548828,
0.6900665163993835,
0.20224229991436005,
-0.4297398328781128,
-0.3061286509037018,
0.8981004953384399,
0.14965403079986572,
-0.06544581055641174,
0.4830988645553589,
-0.1388775259256363,
-0.5471712350845337,
0.38687801361083984,
0.5441888570785522,
0.5611984133720398,
0.06869243085384369,
0.3712261915206909,
0.40934622287750244,
0.3205225169658661,
-0.06954652816057205,
0.3298829197883606,
-0.34308716654777527,
-0.36858057975769043,
-0.5072789788246155,
-0.16406458616256714,
-0.008955984376370907,
-0.11011169105768204,
-0.38019171357154846,
0.4825282692909241,
-0.4813661277294159,
-0.12963853776454926,
-0.5407461524009705,
-0.025771675631403923,
-0.5084865093231201,
0.614009439945221,
0.09586537629365921,
0.5104095339775085,
-1.113175630569458,
0.687613844871521,
0.9925026893615723,
-0.9322333931922913,
-0.43014290928840637,
0.15617181360721588,
-0.07231812924146652,
-0.5486151576042175,
0.8880125880241394,
0.28052622079849243,
-0.425119012594223,
-0.3590484857559204,
-0.3286590278148651,
-0.4929649829864502,
1.2525510787963867,
0.37975451350212097,
-0.39586275815963745,
-0.35829687118530273,
0.003999724518507719,
0.4812292754650116,
-0.2918000817298889,
0.39218980073928833,
0.08736472576856613,
0.20273683965206146,
0.2154180109500885,
-0.704251229763031,
0.039055235683918,
-0.47846612334251404,
-0.175486758351326,
0.13288940489292145,
-0.5654804110527039,
0.5723522901535034,
0.11791639029979706,
-0.253342866897583,
-0.2518314719200134,
1.0043623447418213,
0.18384423851966858,
0.5204350352287292,
0.5628973245620728,
0.6105356216430664,
0.6111443638801575,
-0.042231570929288864,
0.6769824028015137,
-0.08377321809530258,
-0.023032277822494507,
1.2836527824401855,
-0.11068926006555557,
0.4955722987651825,
0.6661050319671631,
0.09515305608510971,
0.5370055437088013,
0.49067267775535583,
0.1666984260082245,
1.014340877532959,
-0.01988152228295803,
-0.03445102646946907,
-0.5851485729217529,
-0.32871711254119873,
-0.5049993395805359,
0.19413070380687714,
0.208266019821167,
-0.2257867455482483,
-0.3283918797969818,
0.16792336106300354,
-0.23137922585010529,
0.5815824270248413,
-0.3191866874694824,
0.776043713092804,
0.024728180840611458,
-0.43802714347839355,
0.22193878889083862,
-0.14606061577796936,
0.692795991897583,
-0.8580493927001953,
-0.2906745374202728,
-0.3796493411064148,
-0.21772128343582153,
-0.2155550867319107,
-0.6623520851135254,
0.38011130690574646,
0.03995148465037346,
-0.39431795477867126,
-0.21542681753635406,
0.7151898741722107,
-0.5262557864189148,
-0.05499431490898132,
0.323762983083725,
0.44521284103393555,
-0.037746742367744446,
-0.18309520184993744,
-0.7230601906776428,
-0.10769147425889969,
-0.3360452651977539,
0.18313293159008026,
0.1589692384004593,
0.8763586282730103,
-0.27427542209625244,
0.4151362478733063,
0.6148470044136047,
-0.11793523281812668,
0.021772706881165504,
0.43133917450904846,
1.0569273233413696,
-0.9875401258468628,
-1.0781371593475342,
-0.8119394779205322,
0.5582044720649719,
-0.1856391578912735,
-0.07533709704875946,
0.687836766242981,
0.5798983573913574,
0.7318838238716125,
0.08846139907836914,
0.5079500079154968,
-0.049245722591876984,
-0.02873959392309189,
-1.2838852405548096,
0.37991881370544434,
-0.5512406826019287,
0.16726064682006836,
-0.3589686155319214,
-1.0880522727966309,
-0.3450171947479248,
0.41952580213546753,
-0.2992612421512604,
-0.1780686229467392,
1.0403761863708496,
0.701893150806427,
-0.4672573506832123,
-0.20493364334106445,
0.32258090376853943,
0.024595264345407486,
0.4860802888870239,
0.4094003736972809,
0.9514153599739075,
-0.380277544260025,
0.8285784125328064,
-0.108664371073246,
-0.14442186057567596,
-0.13600881397724152,
-1.189781904220581,
-1.1538885831832886,
-0.7334465384483337,
-0.2585255205631256,
-0.14680591225624084,
0.35272806882858276,
0.8860703110694885,
0.8375861048698425,
-0.7144911885261536,
0.09980688244104385,
0.047308750450611115,
-0.08108411729335785,
-0.10260951519012451,
-0.2470286786556244,
0.7443934679031372,
-0.35968589782714844,
-0.37655875086784363,
0.6930020451545715,
0.359787255525589,
-0.0736260637640953,
0.23091630637645721,
0.20630116760730743,
-0.5629366636276245,
-0.16879908740520477,
0.5870911478996277,
0.1667417287826538,
-0.5299014449119568,
-0.3879518210887909,
0.30294185876846313,
0.15156015753746033,
0.22864751517772675,
1.30766761302948,
-0.9603791832923889,
0.5155782699584961,
0.5668146014213562,
0.7122644782066345,
0.6779190897941589,
0.2650989592075348,
0.5077886581420898,
-1.1830625534057617,
0.5898916125297546,
0.08572110533714294,
0.5576958656311035,
0.5325243473052979,
-0.40170738101005554,
0.3180038332939148,
0.5348635315895081,
-0.21604448556900024,
-0.3681826591491699,
0.15330491960048676,
-1.0508582592010498,
-0.2323678731918335,
0.8623144626617432,
-0.13573195040225983,
0.016526123508810997,
-0.3359125852584839,
-0.41140949726104736,
0.4066477417945862,
-0.32434478402137756,
0.8063540458679199,
0.6796154379844666,
-0.04390834644436836,
-0.2408163994550705,
-0.29894959926605225,
0.3877134919166565,
0.49137574434280396,
-0.8234639763832092,
-0.26939690113067627,
0.7839873433113098,
0.04095344990491867,
0.03234072029590607,
0.8160232901573181,
-0.16298535466194153,
0.24315498769283295,
0.024649854749441147,
-0.5054260492324829,
-0.20658466219902039,
-0.6711507439613342,
-0.17756429314613342,
0.3092953860759735,
-0.4387389123439789,
-0.3219715356826782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13599v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13599v2
|
"A good pun is its own reword": Can Large Language Models Understand Puns?
| 2024-04-21T09:42:05 | 2024-06-16T11:31:18 |
Zhijun Xu, Siyu Yuan, Lingjie Chen, Deqing Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Puns play a vital role in academic research due to their distinct structure
and clear definition, which aid in the comprehensive analysis of linguistic
humor. However, the understanding of puns in large language models (LLMs) has
not been thoroughly examined, limiting their use in creative writing and humor
creation. In this paper, we leverage three popular tasks, i.e., pun
recognition, explanation and generation to systematically evaluate the
capabilities of LLMs in pun understanding. In addition to adopting the
automated evaluation metrics from prior research, we introduce new evaluation
methods and metrics that are better suited to the in-context learning paradigm
of LLMs. These new metrics offer a more rigorous assessment of an LLM's ability
to understand puns and align more closely with human cognition than previous
metrics. Our findings reveal the "lazy pun generation" pattern and identify the
primary challenges LLMs encounter in understanding puns.
|
[
-0.25152289867401123,
-0.7549517154693604,
0.8567463159561157,
0.6313394904136658,
-0.6028467416763306,
0.1832192987203598,
-0.5179995894432068,
-0.4494578242301941,
0.2278803139925003,
0.3403541147708893,
-0.4101802110671997,
-0.18251043558120728,
-0.6692770719528198,
0.7515609264373779,
-0.2716100513935089,
0.9422299265861511,
-0.001758588245138526,
0.13909012079238892,
-0.8100452423095703,
0.009612641297280788,
-0.6584942936897278,
-0.251526802778244,
-0.6763342618942261,
-0.23186445236206055,
0.7037559151649475,
0.3915247619152069,
0.4595169126987457,
0.582878828048706,
0.7287840247154236,
0.4399724006652832,
-0.2794322371482849,
0.1236225813627243,
-0.43699583411216736,
-0.03486862778663635,
-0.26457443833351135,
-0.620742917060852,
0.0047361827455461025,
0.07503385096788406,
0.8987181186676025,
1.211238980293274,
0.21313229203224182,
0.21284423768520355,
0.05224786326289177,
0.3765242397785187,
-0.5124781131744385,
0.04680182412266731,
-0.5344086289405823,
0.10699029266834259,
-0.37122297286987305,
-0.09744089841842651,
-0.5061675906181335,
-0.43918099999427795,
0.03548629209399223,
-0.7261872887611389,
0.08396849036216736,
0.382815957069397,
0.5911287069320679,
0.2932245135307312,
-0.21508559584617615,
-0.6051227450370789,
-0.27030453085899353,
0.8455634117126465,
-0.5558890104293823,
0.3889804482460022,
0.0604499988257885,
0.16005511581897736,
-0.3947125971317291,
-0.7348410487174988,
-0.6013985872268677,
-0.15964898467063904,
-0.08800427615642548,
-0.13373970985412598,
-0.2298879325389862,
-0.4931904375553131,
0.12652695178985596,
0.5776473879814148,
-0.29809117317199707,
0.4055849313735962,
-0.3955048620700836,
-0.10707147419452667,
0.4527009427547455,
0.4259527027606964,
0.2089584469795227,
-0.545830488204956,
-0.612175703048706,
0.38954371213912964,
-0.4883175790309906,
0.12601760029792786,
0.45110660791397095,
0.04248560592532158,
-0.18848741054534912,
0.39431843161582947,
0.28339770436286926,
0.6895767450332642,
-0.3248158395290375,
-0.26172828674316406,
0.29363763332366943,
-0.39828070998191833,
-0.2306678742170334,
-0.38904306292533875,
1.0181691646575928,
0.015279069542884827,
0.6336184740066528,
-0.4616091847419739,
-0.27857673168182373,
-0.14213745296001434,
0.13537797331809998,
-0.27971911430358887,
-0.05893932282924652,
-0.15342620015144348,
-0.24991697072982788,
-0.35027968883514404,
-0.09649533778429031,
-0.5843101143836975,
-0.5565371513366699,
-0.22755859792232513,
0.18337705731391907,
-0.4030725359916687,
-0.04074159637093544,
0.4249567985534668,
-0.5843833088874817,
0.1207008808851242,
0.20926088094711304,
-0.42484626173973083,
0.3222774267196655,
0.8589403629302979,
0.8243198394775391,
-0.4003573954105377,
-0.640466034412384,
-0.4406052231788635,
-0.021709047257900238,
-0.33910056948661804,
1.0973842144012451,
-0.5969657897949219,
-0.3124997913837433,
-0.3328971266746521,
0.056607697159051895,
-0.358877032995224,
-0.6794161200523376,
0.7881374955177307,
-0.2427891492843628,
0.4601796865463257,
-0.38987401127815247,
-0.7017537355422974,
-0.18516233563423157,
0.26815077662467957,
-0.49305233359336853,
0.411106139421463,
0.1081123873591423,
-1.0627007484436035,
0.3537432551383972,
-0.4818395972251892,
-0.5982349514961243,
0.18854589760303497,
0.004686659201979637,
-0.33474522829055786,
0.7812340259552002,
0.24545502662658691,
0.32800471782684326,
-0.6239323616027832,
0.24779510498046875,
-0.1558561474084854,
-0.5723870396614075,
0.7441274523735046,
-0.15461677312850952,
0.939116895198822,
0.20138749480247498,
-0.054325275123119354,
-0.10699014365673065,
-0.5108014941215515,
-0.12858332693576813,
0.5067489147186279,
-0.5741956233978271,
-0.4167143404483795,
-0.04711626470088959,
-0.37785574793815613,
-0.09102169424295425,
0.23646026849746704,
-0.5068058967590332,
0.09472301602363586,
-0.5497588515281677,
0.6334700584411621,
0.6688327193260193,
-0.17702153325080872,
0.12425976991653442,
-0.14087992906570435,
0.5381991267204285,
-0.15233762562274933,
0.12688575685024261,
-0.35964304208755493,
-0.26774847507476807,
-0.8889549970626831,
-0.5178971290588379,
0.29204362630844116,
0.29631316661834717,
-0.4795701503753662,
0.4195725917816162,
-0.2682205140590668,
-0.3815471827983856,
-0.4694143831729889,
0.5860177278518677,
0.45315808057785034,
0.38284286856651306,
0.10251911729574203,
-0.6928911209106445,
-0.3933386206626892,
-0.7603038549423218,
-0.7411426305770874,
-0.05057978257536888,
0.10141339153051376,
0.5507233142852783,
0.4952528476715088,
0.00020861858502030373,
0.7366250157356262,
-0.22420431673526764,
0.028978213667869568,
-0.5367683172225952,
0.1664334386587143,
0.27410194277763367,
0.08909320086240768,
0.4924471080303192,
-0.2509172260761261,
-0.1792467087507248,
-0.4133546054363251,
-0.8643403053283691,
-0.44824618101119995,
0.04821939766407013,
0.14954505860805511,
-0.3821214735507965,
0.5652881264686584,
-0.5390809178352356,
0.06701493263244629,
0.29939964413642883,
-0.6400467753410339,
0.9272738099098206,
0.18500728905200958,
-0.13599422574043274,
-0.5181697010993958,
0.04688894376158714,
-0.036116670817136765,
-0.25770509243011475,
-0.2745077610015869,
0.3455757796764374,
-0.11588571965694427,
-0.10466766357421875,
-0.605739951133728,
0.6829028725624084,
-0.6610075235366821,
-0.44238150119781494,
-0.3372749090194702,
0.27413198351860046,
0.31900131702423096,
0.10299596935510635,
-0.23190276324748993,
0.7391607761383057,
0.5627104640007019,
-0.47149723768234253,
0.4163667559623718,
0.05852928012609482,
-0.7260152101516724,
0.4963589310646057,
-0.7852053642272949,
0.24191568791866302,
-0.1524156928062439,
0.2885451316833496,
-0.9924429655075073,
-0.10366644710302353,
0.17820672690868378,
-0.28485792875289917,
0.057357057929039,
0.07239481061697006,
-0.82155442237854,
-0.6781735420227051,
-0.02932487614452839,
0.6220413446426392,
0.3579334616661072,
-0.5211403369903564,
0.22935253381729126,
0.1233641728758812,
-0.1432291865348816,
-0.5229156017303467,
-0.44182252883911133,
0.248773455619812,
-0.6003040075302124,
-0.6982989311218262,
-0.1276199221611023,
0.04193689301609993,
-0.6177045702934265,
-0.228300079703331,
0.2703697681427002,
0.1547272801399231,
0.3365887403488159,
0.025461461395025253,
-0.11854385584592819,
-0.2335294932126999,
0.24249856173992157,
-0.451761394739151,
-0.05518079176545143,
0.3889472484588623,
-0.08945714682340622,
0.5819154381752014,
0.08136123418807983,
-0.18178631365299225,
-0.5282015800476074,
0.13964597880840302,
0.6979084014892578,
-0.31864964962005615,
0.3778804838657379,
0.4745667278766632,
0.0007175017963163555,
-0.24935205280780792,
-0.6021552085876465,
0.01582726463675499,
-0.4676458239555359,
0.16562378406524658,
-0.29173916578292847,
-0.6981064081192017,
0.3725142776966095,
-0.18615476787090302,
-0.08215650916099548,
0.46952298283576965,
0.43083786964416504,
-0.1807224154472351,
0.45638009905815125,
0.7546497583389282,
0.07664956152439117,
0.3027951419353485,
0.09875515103340149,
0.27312278747558594,
-0.8787834644317627,
-0.22341647744178772,
-0.5150834918022156,
-0.3095894455909729,
0.059474121779203415,
-0.5823606848716736,
0.22292888164520264,
0.1452990025281906,
-0.23166628181934357,
0.05586560443043709,
-0.15935102105140686,
0.6966278553009033,
0.2943350374698639,
-0.25797438621520996,
0.3614920973777771,
0.13206340372562408,
-0.3792153298854828,
-0.08804363757371902,
-0.5102394819259644,
-0.4516037404537201,
0.6830130815505981,
0.6720561981201172,
0.8309005498886108,
0.05057816952466965,
0.6609481573104858,
0.06029144674539566,
0.2005862146615982,
-0.9427710771560669,
0.6449579000473022,
-0.4259873926639557,
-0.29335159063339233,
-0.0018479719292372465,
-0.5198321342468262,
-0.9033896327018738,
0.05977771431207657,
-0.04767008125782013,
-0.8307812809944153,
-0.12364189326763153,
-0.06538365036249161,
-0.3340211510658264,
0.2588212490081787,
-0.7659907937049866,
0.8411042094230652,
-0.4862854778766632,
-0.34424832463264465,
-0.22285564243793488,
-0.3610617220401764,
0.6051236987113953,
-0.09400270134210587,
0.5625417232513428,
-0.13993844389915466,
-0.11848708242177963,
0.9882999062538147,
-0.07098846137523651,
0.779661238193512,
0.06895782798528671,
-0.10166322439908981,
0.519490122795105,
0.32176002860069275,
0.3040865957736969,
0.06049934774637222,
-0.24947905540466309,
0.16553731262683868,
-0.34863927960395813,
-0.26968568563461304,
-0.5112000107765198,
0.6064414381980896,
-0.6152263283729553,
-0.7123486995697021,
-0.2544114887714386,
-0.76421719789505,
-0.0719795972108841,
-0.05659639835357666,
0.16085296869277954,
0.04770340770483017,
-0.2938256859779358,
0.10908325761556625,
0.17016355693340302,
-0.6905316114425659,
0.41155606508255005,
0.5220211148262024,
-0.1434890627861023,
-0.2886630892753601,
0.866218090057373,
-0.31341418623924255,
0.09797435998916626,
-0.02597968466579914,
0.5616550445556641,
-0.3022710084915161,
-0.4980623126029968,
-0.2664918005466461,
0.637472927570343,
-0.9584792256355286,
-0.03754732012748718,
-0.7457538843154907,
0.07000040262937546,
-0.2906647324562073,
-0.17124031484127045,
-0.211548313498497,
-0.18607774376869202,
-0.40503570437431335,
0.13766084611415863,
0.14783059060573578,
1.097144365310669,
-0.07466182857751846,
0.5663538575172424,
-0.39798516035079956,
0.013434906490147114,
0.16941240429878235,
0.41663500666618347,
0.06857097893953323,
-0.7617121338844299,
-0.12736250460147858,
-0.5716284513473511,
-0.3748577833175659,
-0.7644603252410889,
0.16291996836662292,
0.24366115033626556,
0.3803284466266632,
0.5371983647346497,
-0.44011160731315613,
0.46274128556251526,
-0.6629357933998108,
0.8983802795410156,
0.42901501059532166,
-1.0342158079147339,
0.33162984251976013,
-0.056675370782613754,
0.12616227567195892,
0.2726093828678131,
0.36648938059806824,
-0.38320067524909973,
-0.4173305630683899,
-0.5501447319984436,
-0.5444866418838501,
0.2925296127796173,
0.10471640527248383,
0.42763668298721313,
-0.36602169275283813,
0.4162731170654297,
0.44186174869537354,
0.19326013326644897,
-0.980992317199707,
0.160500630736351,
-0.0049563138745725155,
0.08489318192005157,
-0.35672900080680847,
-0.3649028241634369,
-0.07284224033355713,
-0.34663259983062744,
0.09390779584646225,
0.12274758517742157,
0.19222919642925262,
-0.10011237859725952,
-0.23553138971328735,
-0.26921847462654114,
0.3364279270172119,
0.27212777733802795,
0.8529411554336548,
0.13954143226146698,
0.2963835895061493,
0.16329987347126007,
-0.20334915816783905,
-0.18348388373851776,
-0.15176232159137726,
0.3829529881477356,
0.1622147411108017,
0.6969989538192749,
0.6345133185386658,
0.3786812126636505,
-0.7582377195358276,
0.7622132897377014,
-0.044060200452804565,
-0.015462187118828297,
-0.29476335644721985,
0.22798173129558563,
0.2973652184009552,
0.14637871086597443,
0.1271560788154602,
-0.2932681143283844,
-0.027584504336118698,
-0.779832124710083,
0.12456054985523224,
0.47058120369911194,
-0.1772300899028778,
-0.4343417286872864,
0.36277860403060913,
0.394640177488327,
-0.441766619682312,
0.6714123487472534,
-0.3362043499946594,
-0.7036421895027161,
0.7591663002967834,
0.9013797044754028,
0.6697633266448975,
0.1490986943244934,
-0.002638839418068528,
0.34014132618904114,
0.25656983256340027,
0.11955166608095169,
0.26752033829689026,
0.19250990450382233,
-0.6501573324203491,
-0.5919986367225647,
-0.9784795045852661,
-0.17667429149150848,
0.2429598718881607,
-0.22338619828224182,
0.4997093081474304,
-0.5466823577880859,
-0.038638949394226074,
0.3162306249141693,
-0.12407127767801285,
-1.077454686164856,
0.18233589828014374,
0.11868969351053238,
0.9728230834007263,
-0.8930161595344543,
0.2247675061225891,
0.7436319589614868,
-0.24220994114875793,
-0.4841441810131073,
0.060264043509960175,
-0.21439680457115173,
-1.0246878862380981,
0.7420350313186646,
0.3491365611553192,
0.07968132197856903,
-0.012067219242453575,
-0.6985058784484863,
-0.6089302897453308,
0.5750880837440491,
0.4593367278575897,
-0.6639801859855652,
-0.08667183667421341,
0.0324065126478672,
0.41414177417755127,
-0.5400416851043701,
0.2910670340061188,
0.6183873414993286,
0.5516514182090759,
-0.20179732143878937,
-0.9410067200660706,
0.018746517598628998,
0.030310506001114845,
-0.5286609530448914,
0.10830766707658768,
-0.6682963371276855,
0.9196859002113342,
-0.5866541862487793,
-0.26646897196769714,
0.2220679521560669,
0.5394335985183716,
0.25817054510116577,
0.5567119717597961,
0.7899602651596069,
0.8134403824806213,
0.5768105387687683,
0.04414622113108635,
1.1723086833953857,
-0.10681301355361938,
0.1889488399028778,
0.8987023830413818,
0.03245193138718605,
0.46366992592811584,
0.5914452075958252,
-0.1140652596950531,
0.7136255502700806,
0.5995083451271057,
-0.2015789896249771,
0.15742263197898865,
0.8189619183540344,
-0.04271702468395233,
-0.620190441608429,
-0.35298651456832886,
-0.06781575083732605,
0.7778810858726501,
0.46937188506126404,
-0.6908219456672668,
-0.16717417538166046,
-0.01687801629304886,
0.019296841695904732,
0.21490378677845,
-0.296659380197525,
0.7147535085678101,
0.4662010669708252,
-0.6179420948028564,
0.36482614278793335,
-0.06899333000183105,
0.6747955083847046,
-0.25895360112190247,
0.24037164449691772,
-0.1715608388185501,
-0.14273469150066376,
-0.1270669549703598,
-0.9424597024917603,
0.19989416003227234,
0.27545166015625,
0.05319967120885849,
0.40288782119750977,
0.5064684152603149,
0.18463651835918427,
-0.6761050224304199,
0.3583909869194031,
0.982512891292572,
0.7109015583992004,
0.2124369740486145,
-0.5651112794876099,
0.2775713801383972,
-0.2860126495361328,
-0.05813620984554291,
-0.1064366027712822,
0.9005734920501709,
0.01852697879076004,
0.7220184206962585,
0.42715317010879517,
0.2551746368408203,
0.03036177158355713,
0.25091707706451416,
0.7879946231842041,
-0.830258846282959,
-0.4798867702484131,
-0.8985289931297302,
0.23045331239700317,
0.0463583879172802,
-0.5981511473655701,
0.6837154030799866,
0.3488563001155853,
0.6301652193069458,
-0.0355038121342659,
0.7518764734268188,
0.056907471269369125,
0.33844059705734253,
-0.28256139159202576,
0.2850269675254822,
-0.8635446429252625,
0.23548418283462524,
-0.33425232768058777,
-0.94346684217453,
-0.20860934257507324,
0.5192260146141052,
-0.6139799356460571,
-0.0113828144967556,
0.8493554592132568,
0.2062474489212036,
-0.4001508057117462,
-0.05092368274927139,
0.21145623922348022,
0.22097395360469818,
0.04952143877744675,
0.5787466168403625,
1.2500503063201904,
0.019754933193325996,
0.5285857915878296,
-0.07916899025440216,
-0.010580566711723804,
-0.08596453070640564,
-1.0334033966064453,
-1.0511348247528076,
-0.1821618676185608,
-0.2130434513092041,
0.02782452665269375,
0.13924705982208252,
0.6294704079627991,
0.22842557728290558,
-0.43513476848602295,
-0.19529053568840027,
0.06131703034043312,
0.382655531167984,
-0.04021091014146805,
-0.23985613882541656,
0.3596547842025757,
-0.8554990291595459,
-0.7417840957641602,
0.45042797923088074,
0.2845698893070221,
-0.1745801568031311,
-0.4601741135120392,
0.04681606590747833,
0.12063811719417572,
0.24599547684192657,
0.4715630114078522,
0.20438162982463837,
-0.874377965927124,
-0.3954944908618927,
-0.13449467718601227,
0.06592412292957306,
-0.0447416678071022,
1.1787217855453491,
-0.6247949600219727,
0.4380677044391632,
0.5019531846046448,
0.6225166916847229,
-0.23617590963840485,
-0.09600396454334259,
0.5492177605628967,
-0.7136560082435608,
0.11628629267215729,
0.17344047129154205,
0.7133421897888184,
0.7545373439788818,
-0.24178875982761383,
0.4692392945289612,
0.5749425888061523,
-0.5218152403831482,
-0.9830582737922668,
0.296709805727005,
-0.6717237234115601,
-0.5250654816627502,
1.2569971084594727,
-0.2936916947364807,
-0.3763715326786041,
-0.18718291819095612,
0.16431404650211334,
0.2720164656639099,
0.08440078794956207,
0.8175643086433411,
0.6506569385528564,
0.011540571227669716,
-0.16119885444641113,
-0.5525614023208618,
0.21902093291282654,
0.6642411947250366,
-0.3839094936847687,
0.10724188387393951,
0.251306414604187,
0.7087393403053284,
0.2179732322692871,
0.39204853773117065,
-0.1650971621274948,
0.32147160172462463,
-0.30178043246269226,
0.024385377764701843,
-0.1219252496957779,
-0.4728948473930359,
-0.10638562589883804,
0.006749007850885391,
0.2698008716106415,
0.04573408141732216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14454v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14454v2
|
Reinforcement of Explainability of ChatGPT Prompts by Embedding Breast Cancer Self-Screening Rules into AI Responses
| 2024-04-21T09:20:16 | 2024-06-02T22:42:00 |
Yousef Khan, Ahmed Abdeen Hamed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2; I.2.1
|
Addressing the global challenge of breast cancer, this research explores the
fusion of generative AI, focusing on ChatGPT 3.5 turbo model, and the
intricacies of breast cancer risk assessment. The research aims to evaluate
ChatGPT's reasoning capabilities, emphasizing its potential to process rules
and provide explanations for screening recommendations. The study seeks to
bridge the technology gap between intelligent machines and clinicians by
demonstrating ChatGPT's unique proficiency in natural language reasoning. The
methodology employs a supervised prompt-engineering approach to enforce
detailed explanations for ChatGPT's recommendations. Synthetic use cases,
generated algorithmically, serve as the testing ground for the encoded rules,
evaluating the model's processing prowess. Findings highlight ChatGPT's
promising capacity in processing rules comparable to Expert System Shells, with
a focus on natural language reasoning. The research introduces the concept of
reinforcement explainability, showcasing its potential in elucidating outcomes
and facilitating user-friendly interfaces for breast cancer risk assessment.
|
[
-0.37432295083999634,
-0.9129811525344849,
0.7793565392494202,
0.25328144431114197,
-0.13783006370067596,
-0.014498149044811726,
0.29742416739463806,
-0.2456655502319336,
-0.12977153062820435,
0.47269102931022644,
-1.0471073389053345,
-0.37589630484580994,
-0.5511735677719116,
0.20806379616260529,
-0.4576086401939392,
1.1533937454223633,
-0.052354563027620316,
0.04712628573179245,
-0.14893005788326263,
0.36426588892936707,
-0.6443459391593933,
-0.11380935460329056,
-1.0941327810287476,
-0.2834210693836212,
0.6196650266647339,
0.40359845757484436,
0.7832565307617188,
0.6808910369873047,
0.31568002700805664,
0.25320976972579956,
0.14098744094371796,
0.14813128113746643,
-0.24439111351966858,
0.21716712415218353,
-0.07525210827589035,
-0.3158135712146759,
-0.11576926708221436,
-0.0006283223628997803,
0.19292019307613373,
0.4832068383693695,
-0.15632133185863495,
-0.20034143328666687,
0.17664934694766998,
0.6553975939750671,
-0.2852248549461365,
0.4285445213317871,
-0.32568398118019104,
0.018322888761758804,
0.2761819660663605,
-0.45806974172592163,
-0.329650342464447,
-0.7045902013778687,
0.12651970982551575,
-0.6359862685203552,
0.3072880208492279,
0.06825360655784607,
0.5949362516403198,
0.3943184018135071,
-0.4608180522918701,
-0.39655742049217224,
-0.6839665770530701,
0.10300593823194504,
-0.5731251835823059,
-0.18394388258457184,
0.45639652013778687,
0.7436253428459167,
-0.496809184551239,
-0.5356387495994568,
-0.37884917855262756,
-0.2822412848472595,
-0.1259486973285675,
0.1895054429769516,
-0.4524504244327545,
0.3865611255168915,
0.17395535111427307,
0.3706510365009308,
-0.9804962277412415,
0.17588068544864655,
-0.3936597406864166,
-0.53029865026474,
0.5545768141746521,
0.10486196726560593,
0.614527702331543,
-0.08595874160528183,
-0.18079401552677155,
0.17768852412700653,
-0.7447307705879211,
0.26775315403938293,
0.23786020278930664,
0.26040342450141907,
-0.007034033536911011,
0.5595069527626038,
-0.40459683537483215,
0.6064566373825073,
-0.12553660571575165,
0.4792739450931549,
-0.24944309890270233,
-0.44300881028175354,
-0.14517147839069366,
0.3792972266674042,
0.8381637334823608,
0.41697385907173157,
0.15287625789642334,
0.020031364634633064,
0.45103222131729126,
0.07999406009912491,
0.4221794605255127,
-0.9277592897415161,
-0.30840975046157837,
0.4419736862182617,
-0.4263540208339691,
-0.17012862861156464,
-0.15932658314704895,
-0.661309540271759,
-0.5196564197540283,
0.10529601573944092,
0.8037595152854919,
-0.6355974078178406,
-0.16899292171001434,
0.4411642551422119,
-0.25616344809532166,
0.11945737153291702,
0.21171824634075165,
-0.8220404386520386,
0.17677105963230133,
0.7590283751487732,
0.7470518946647644,
0.19664935767650604,
-0.03276747092604637,
-0.36808332800865173,
-0.006434518378227949,
-0.052470337599515915,
1.1003707647323608,
-0.4606333374977112,
-0.6543065309524536,
-0.16186082363128662,
0.06531032919883728,
-0.32984280586242676,
-0.10785473138093948,
0.6694811582565308,
-0.1005222424864769,
0.49248287081718445,
-0.2137567549943924,
-0.4885706305503845,
-0.46339744329452515,
0.24566271901130676,
-0.3764435350894928,
0.654642641544342,
0.09285285323858261,
-0.6825278401374817,
0.45890921354293823,
-0.9288883805274963,
-0.3887488543987274,
0.16392073035240173,
-0.03134789690375328,
-0.43148964643478394,
-0.31900548934936523,
0.5795366168022156,
0.4838140606880188,
-0.1076706275343895,
0.10500217974185944,
-0.4911666810512543,
-0.474915474653244,
0.41897472739219666,
-0.666286826133728,
0.7404686212539673,
0.3732038140296936,
-0.4239909052848816,
0.34551793336868286,
-0.4247109591960907,
-0.08866260945796967,
0.16568657755851746,
0.09971783310174942,
0.034109752625226974,
0.19817622005939484,
-0.5657581686973572,
0.1796577423810959,
0.0017740732291713357,
-0.4334416687488556,
0.3159315884113312,
-0.5646349787712097,
0.8401151299476624,
0.6103060841560364,
0.3007130026817322,
-0.02562093548476696,
-0.6001882553100586,
0.6556891798973083,
-0.22216735780239105,
0.4185425639152527,
-0.3992657959461212,
-0.8917478919029236,
-0.5056840777397156,
-0.3306881785392761,
-0.021944502368569374,
0.44479498267173767,
-0.648984968662262,
0.06786856800317764,
0.1294552981853485,
-0.47516268491744995,
-0.6335418820381165,
-0.20490889251232147,
0.42072924971580505,
0.6481578946113586,
0.3885252773761749,
-0.22326315939426422,
-0.5467076897621155,
-1.18031907081604,
-0.204001784324646,
-0.3825785517692566,
0.08959155529737473,
0.22082412242889404,
0.2204405963420868,
-0.11004574596881866,
1.0440386533737183,
-0.42088618874549866,
0.24828460812568665,
-0.3043718934059143,
0.4744204580783844,
0.278130441904068,
0.4455653727054596,
0.1721009761095047,
-0.7445012927055359,
-0.117078498005867,
-0.053541749715805054,
-0.5196400284767151,
-0.3194442391395569,
-0.13830897212028503,
-0.20333845913410187,
-0.2815122902393341,
0.36049243807792664,
-0.6568636298179626,
0.7545140981674194,
0.3750287592411041,
-0.5108019709587097,
0.619341254234314,
-0.5120084881782532,
0.3803003132343292,
-0.8397716879844666,
-0.3909892439842224,
0.1920308917760849,
-0.3423321843147278,
-0.434683620929718,
-0.34236693382263184,
-0.40801674127578735,
-0.3165023624897003,
-0.07482504844665527,
0.5213125944137573,
-0.008155961520969868,
-0.1488397866487503,
-0.42677560448646545,
-0.1493467092514038,
0.017027640715241432,
0.2831403613090515,
-0.136392742395401,
0.9141570329666138,
0.3986135423183441,
-0.9163495898246765,
0.2024892121553421,
0.14509110152721405,
-0.1827930063009262,
0.4910641312599182,
-0.8696067929267883,
-0.420764297246933,
-0.08463151752948761,
0.5202725529670715,
-1.430388331413269,
-0.22179602086544037,
0.45102551579475403,
-0.6499618291854858,
-0.12079403549432755,
-0.31149372458457947,
-0.18370874226093292,
-0.6490173935890198,
0.04998001083731651,
0.11279351264238358,
0.7389107942581177,
-0.3600229322910309,
0.3523857593536377,
0.25235220789909363,
-0.5470749139785767,
-0.26855993270874023,
-0.4373115003108978,
-0.08752533048391342,
-0.398409366607666,
-0.7008231282234192,
0.25995975732803345,
-0.3778989315032959,
-0.017944445833563805,
-0.036002371460199356,
0.08555027097463608,
-0.23208560049533844,
0.35842153429985046,
0.5848087668418884,
0.1344718486070633,
-0.04939211532473564,
0.24037334322929382,
0.14066855609416962,
-0.3690478801727295,
0.3326520323753357,
-0.23871073126792908,
0.3490089476108551,
-0.21048255264759064,
-0.7115556597709656,
-0.5412808060646057,
0.3317194879055023,
0.4426836371421814,
-0.003205407876521349,
0.4583355784416199,
0.8557965159416199,
-0.19360469281673431,
-0.008725816383957863,
-0.37560492753982544,
-0.2758696973323822,
-0.4348738491535187,
0.041728559881448746,
-0.3143356740474701,
-1.132392168045044,
0.4919641613960266,
0.12116140872240067,
-0.09030025452375412,
0.7250534892082214,
1.0209741592407227,
-0.187395378947258,
1.631327509880066,
0.3484542965888977,
0.16891951858997345,
0.2636782228946686,
0.08285995572805405,
0.23184968531131744,
-0.3506970703601837,
-0.28881916403770447,
-0.49498251080513,
0.06960203498601913,
-0.7910264134407043,
-0.20994700491428375,
0.6365795731544495,
-0.2981709837913513,
-0.5911747217178345,
0.2837488353252411,
-0.8709157109260559,
0.1786898821592331,
0.7325485348701477,
0.40908434987068176,
0.20408864319324493,
-0.37462756037712097,
-0.2859347462654114,
0.25858595967292786,
-1.0322552919387817,
-0.37579354643821716,
0.7742950320243835,
0.4101380705833435,
0.47540998458862305,
0.10183925926685333,
0.41324901580810547,
0.4611596465110779,
0.15741518139839172,
-0.5682618618011475,
0.40905508399009705,
0.1669539362192154,
-0.6869197487831116,
-0.2617168426513672,
-0.45729273557662964,
-1.1220636367797852,
0.06859499961137772,
-0.07336073368787766,
-0.8320950865745544,
-0.18756191432476044,
0.2536517381668091,
-0.7642145156860352,
-0.049671124666929245,
-0.8957822918891907,
1.0834338665008545,
-0.10868410021066666,
-0.3374021351337433,
-0.20903028547763824,
-0.5439883470535278,
0.4958467185497284,
0.19287800788879395,
0.35752472281455994,
-0.44328752160072327,
0.3531186282634735,
0.4776607155799866,
-0.7552321553230286,
0.9480320811271667,
0.006980117876082659,
0.11729703098535538,
0.3984697759151459,
0.24619364738464355,
0.1708424836397171,
0.18132911622524261,
-0.04708459600806236,
-0.23813509941101074,
0.27341750264167786,
-0.5449740290641785,
-0.6538466811180115,
0.5409523248672485,
-0.4921712577342987,
-0.612940788269043,
-0.2901885509490967,
-0.45906075835227966,
-0.21045419573783875,
-0.08029817044734955,
0.17090468108654022,
0.19665458798408508,
-0.31038767099380493,
-0.11705593019723892,
0.5775083899497986,
-0.3765883147716522,
0.22744905948638916,
0.48404359817504883,
-0.1295524686574936,
0.1393985152244568,
1.0002402067184448,
-0.15628360211849213,
0.026930417865514755,
0.34671419858932495,
0.5531367659568787,
-0.3960605561733246,
-0.4822063446044922,
-0.49219027161598206,
-0.20467711985111237,
-0.41216200590133667,
0.14478519558906555,
-0.6706632971763611,
-0.3659624457359314,
-0.430646151304245,
-0.1641000658273697,
-0.1598941534757614,
-0.46895429491996765,
-0.05345344915986061,
-0.14626917243003845,
0.6901569366455078,
0.7197089195251465,
-0.24809043109416962,
0.36889177560806274,
-0.6643281579017639,
0.09824126213788986,
0.7253857254981995,
0.2110360562801361,
-0.3432716727256775,
-0.4710027277469635,
-0.013164420612156391,
0.07743137329816818,
-0.15488998591899872,
-1.0139186382293701,
0.3887597620487213,
-0.09900166094303131,
0.761908233165741,
0.4379217326641083,
-0.019368605688214302,
0.2792345881462097,
-0.27157488465309143,
0.7565313577651978,
-0.009448598138988018,
-0.7026964426040649,
0.8231874108314514,
-0.8436880111694336,
0.2610843777656555,
0.32923123240470886,
0.5453112721443176,
-0.5415010452270508,
-0.25661584734916687,
-0.842380166053772,
-0.6115349531173706,
0.47375017404556274,
0.4606437683105469,
-0.17159493267536163,
-0.08699246495962143,
0.3873974680900574,
0.3572355806827545,
-0.009592861868441105,
-0.47240784764289856,
0.11088301241397858,
-0.4410012364387512,
-0.3422245681285858,
0.02934388816356659,
-0.4425603449344635,
-0.3178211748600006,
0.014888003468513489,
0.8575689196586609,
-0.20029808580875397,
0.5713269114494324,
0.16182063519954681,
0.12474821507930756,
0.44332605600357056,
0.46642178297042847,
0.6654787063598633,
0.3632321357727051,
-0.37361961603164673,
0.11202863603830338,
0.03769570216536522,
-0.19250257313251495,
0.022851955145597458,
0.531707227230072,
0.016933882609009743,
-0.31023678183555603,
0.3155847191810608,
0.6373752355575562,
0.2992061972618103,
-0.6390494704246521,
0.39604541659355164,
-0.31900301575660706,
-0.3134959638118744,
-0.024875326082110405,
0.33511000871658325,
-0.04965018108487129,
0.14990298449993134,
0.07417810708284378,
-0.19204917550086975,
0.49428847432136536,
-0.4333883821964264,
0.3119319975376129,
0.2999589741230011,
-0.8592501282691956,
0.018496308475732803,
0.6431617736816406,
0.10094151645898819,
-0.04660433903336525,
0.4612785875797272,
-0.24318039417266846,
-0.4487641453742981,
0.9207954406738281,
0.440344899892807,
0.6656309366226196,
-0.17317034304141998,
0.616510272026062,
0.5072013139724731,
0.40430331230163574,
-0.0728721097111702,
0.10976934432983398,
0.04045420140028,
-0.7332314848899841,
-0.5035586357116699,
-0.12064595520496368,
-0.8095046281814575,
-0.2366572469472885,
-0.3140956461429596,
0.02126702293753624,
-0.4892461895942688,
-0.03484822064638138,
0.33859390020370483,
-0.2443593591451645,
-0.3755933940410614,
0.25323623418807983,
0.02526034601032734,
0.6127704381942749,
-0.7748557925224304,
0.2503555417060852,
0.3304111361503601,
-0.8455959558486938,
-0.9075823426246643,
-0.30889466404914856,
0.3450498580932617,
-1.339065432548523,
0.42412611842155457,
0.4474763870239258,
0.09774650633335114,
-0.17251889407634735,
-0.475350558757782,
-0.6282649040222168,
0.9061346054077148,
0.2943132221698761,
0.00251184799708426,
0.011651563458144665,
-0.09389536827802658,
0.38216763734817505,
-0.3728780150413513,
0.9970381855964661,
0.5954435467720032,
0.5702357292175293,
0.41164132952690125,
-0.7850131988525391,
0.06491078436374664,
-0.3228612542152405,
-0.12333447486162186,
-0.16660615801811218,
-0.32642635703086853,
0.6085633635520935,
-0.3261336386203766,
-0.1763499230146408,
0.07302577048540115,
0.4020253121852875,
0.3062278628349304,
0.4646478295326233,
0.3292448818683624,
0.35510140657424927,
0.6263934969902039,
-0.28592318296432495,
1.4212944507598877,
-0.1744096279144287,
0.019055357202887535,
0.8524959683418274,
0.10491818189620972,
0.2813257873058319,
0.04998881369829178,
-0.28166475892066956,
0.8409186601638794,
1.2241402864456177,
0.18145951628684998,
0.2972186207771301,
0.2778981029987335,
-0.407427042722702,
-0.4186588227748871,
-0.3035009801387787,
-0.33599308133125305,
0.38082483410835266,
0.5765452980995178,
-0.28105273842811584,
-0.4261634945869446,
0.19920530915260315,
-0.010529330000281334,
-0.07675846666097641,
-0.4926273226737976,
0.7135220170021057,
-0.0911494642496109,
-0.6903449296951294,
0.13810308277606964,
-0.12961873412132263,
0.18694646656513214,
-0.6658392548561096,
-0.22180739045143127,
-0.0723879262804985,
0.03672482445836067,
-0.24347005784511566,
-0.8940444588661194,
0.22968710958957672,
-0.13423340022563934,
-0.16550007462501526,
-0.23912498354911804,
0.8463618159294128,
-0.18733827769756317,
-0.4868814945220947,
-0.11995630711317062,
0.42974963784217834,
0.4963967204093933,
-0.17042793333530426,
-1.028748869895935,
-0.2139085978269577,
0.0057857707142829895,
-0.056682340800762177,
0.2506285011768341,
0.41355398297309875,
-0.03624776378273964,
1.1942154169082642,
0.7180489897727966,
-0.158469095826149,
-0.2383693903684616,
-0.08507297188043594,
0.7412995100021362,
-0.5351296663284302,
-0.574834406375885,
-0.9611853361129761,
0.4188791811466217,
-0.04429641366004944,
-0.16591112315654755,
0.7653780579566956,
0.3392535150051117,
0.21369390189647675,
0.28726449608802795,
0.8892963528633118,
0.14281518757343292,
0.650440514087677,
-0.7416572570800781,
0.6609203219413757,
-0.21563370525836945,
0.17235520482063293,
-0.029241209849715233,
-0.34612879157066345,
-0.15762485563755035,
0.7073683142662048,
-0.6630884408950806,
0.372140109539032,
0.6633301377296448,
0.9659484028816223,
0.27881330251693726,
0.4003090262413025,
0.12592226266860962,
0.33515313267707825,
0.4098573327064514,
0.7774945497512817,
0.7595816850662231,
-0.12882231175899506,
0.7672259211540222,
0.06718580424785614,
-0.3866124153137207,
-0.5320802330970764,
-1.0382678508758545,
-0.6335493922233582,
-0.6140527725219727,
-0.40720367431640625,
-0.580787718296051,
0.38785669207572937,
0.822442889213562,
0.8612017631530762,
-0.39165782928466797,
0.20215125381946564,
-0.33705878257751465,
0.5163038969039917,
-0.39621829986572266,
-0.2692539393901825,
0.2696952521800995,
-0.22080889344215393,
-0.3328288495540619,
0.7525709867477417,
0.41966506838798523,
0.050607044249773026,
-0.40877652168273926,
-0.05919501930475235,
0.02775735780596733,
0.11188666522502899,
0.29246607422828674,
0.7666091918945312,
-0.4537840783596039,
-0.23298215866088867,
-0.38669756054878235,
-0.10635056346654892,
-0.06404976546764374,
0.7129426002502441,
-0.9581971764564514,
0.6967859268188477,
0.32146286964416504,
0.7012489438056946,
0.5183912515640259,
-0.102797731757164,
1.0065040588378906,
-0.07242178171873093,
-0.2603205740451813,
0.1348550021648407,
0.3214400112628937,
0.1998373419046402,
-0.6744405627250671,
0.538742184638977,
0.19305403530597687,
-0.6638423204421997,
-0.31832385063171387,
0.3532450199127197,
-1.2090903520584106,
-0.3407774567604065,
1.1487905979156494,
-0.12394022941589355,
-0.2148224264383316,
-0.5206611752510071,
-0.5307928919792175,
0.3582783043384552,
-0.5481463074684143,
0.8758335709571838,
0.6414490342140198,
-0.6133045554161072,
-0.4868922829627991,
-0.7259083986282349,
0.7480701804161072,
0.3898692727088928,
-0.8774771690368652,
-0.03960869088768959,
0.36520740389823914,
0.22385679185390472,
-0.41565847396850586,
0.966230034828186,
-0.18770316243171692,
0.5379754900932312,
-0.07100051641464233,
0.043297626078128815,
-0.3888228237628937,
0.18975862860679626,
-0.26493218541145325,
0.06609940528869629,
-0.03992389887571335,
-0.056423384696245193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15190v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15190v1
|
Socratic Planner: Inquiry-Based Zero-Shot Planning for Embodied Instruction Following
| 2024-04-21T08:10:20 | 2024-04-21T08:10:20 |
Suyeon Shin, Sujin jeon, Junghyun Kim, Gi-Cheon Kang, Byoung-Tak Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.RO, 68T01 (Primary) 68T40, 68T50, 68T45 (Secondary)
|
Embodied Instruction Following (EIF) is the task of executing natural
language instructions by navigating and interacting with objects in 3D
environments. One of the primary challenges in EIF is compositional task
planning, which is often addressed with supervised or in-context learning with
labeled data. To this end, we introduce the Socratic Planner, the first
zero-shot planning method that infers without the need for any training data.
Socratic Planner first decomposes the instructions into substructural
information of the task through self-questioning and answering, translating it
into a high-level plan, i.e., a sequence of subgoals. Subgoals are executed
sequentially, with our visually grounded re-planning mechanism adjusting plans
dynamically through a dense visual feedback. We also introduce an evaluation
metric of high-level plans, RelaxedHLP, for a more comprehensive evaluation.
Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of the Socratic Planner, achieving
competitive performance on both zero-shot and few-shot task planning in the
ALFRED benchmark, particularly excelling in tasks requiring higher-dimensional
inference. Additionally, a precise adjustments in the plan were achieved by
incorporating environmental visual information.
|
[
-0.2187737077474594,
-0.7660893201828003,
0.6237237453460693,
0.32957923412323,
-0.1388217955827713,
-0.06693389266729355,
0.27842220664024353,
-0.4261693060398102,
0.47503674030303955,
0.43690091371536255,
-0.9069320559501648,
-0.893661618232727,
-0.2816924750804901,
-0.1942669004201889,
-0.08636558055877686,
0.5739166736602783,
-0.19844767451286316,
-0.29657191038131714,
-0.17122560739517212,
0.16928254067897797,
-0.47543370723724365,
-0.24394115805625916,
-0.4556463360786438,
-0.31279075145721436,
0.3977731168270111,
0.8457424640655518,
0.33601027727127075,
0.39562731981277466,
-0.07229239493608475,
0.16353021562099457,
0.14427345991134644,
0.2070118486881256,
-0.7820364236831665,
0.34316280484199524,
0.09724298864603043,
-0.45673274993896484,
-0.33865493535995483,
-0.23076829314231873,
0.4276687204837799,
0.5986326932907104,
-0.09973853826522827,
0.25720667839050293,
-0.2123432457447052,
0.5554140210151672,
-1.2533133029937744,
0.44419851899147034,
-0.06270492821931839,
0.6060124635696411,
0.41885945200920105,
-0.32398077845573425,
-0.4126830995082855,
-0.11351267993450165,
0.05796588584780693,
-0.5939487814903259,
0.27660977840423584,
-0.17746418714523315,
0.13484695553779602,
0.36934787034988403,
-0.2092219442129135,
0.12300879508256912,
-1.0116287469863892,
0.5995972752571106,
-0.30338171124458313,
0.34168562293052673,
0.4861878454685211,
0.25446125864982605,
-0.2825317680835724,
-0.31530287861824036,
-0.41056394577026367,
0.03666562959551811,
0.03754642233252525,
0.4869229793548584,
0.043069709092378616,
0.472646564245224,
0.4057847261428833,
-0.13515357673168182,
-0.8408401608467102,
-0.14020703732967377,
-0.4824984073638916,
0.016335807740688324,
0.7986369132995605,
0.35395675897598267,
0.12481226772069931,
-0.01844695396721363,
-0.4428003430366516,
-0.025513727217912674,
-0.8313202261924744,
0.18762093782424927,
-0.09403731673955917,
-0.12037414312362671,
-0.34469544887542725,
0.7474712133407593,
-0.7492265105247498,
0.724114716053009,
0.010890611447393894,
-0.10390697419643402,
-0.3069137930870056,
-0.20921266078948975,
-0.32914626598358154,
0.33327770233154297,
0.32702410221099854,
0.5378883481025696,
-0.01655922643840313,
-0.35163614153862,
-0.2378886640071869,
-0.14757680892944336,
0.30980515480041504,
-0.925715982913971,
-0.21282653510570526,
0.2785109579563141,
0.08584745973348618,
-0.10739883780479431,
-0.4815725088119507,
-0.7487643957138062,
-0.04996722936630249,
-0.3666621148586273,
0.5936221480369568,
-0.45256465673446655,
0.1488773226737976,
0.2523563802242279,
-0.08209089189767838,
0.6486583352088928,
0.7501690983772278,
-0.9454454183578491,
0.28610000014305115,
0.654888391494751,
0.8896452784538269,
0.5629616975784302,
-0.36690494418144226,
-0.5017784833908081,
0.754173755645752,
-0.503047525882721,
1.1687517166137695,
-0.4183671474456787,
-0.8409445881843567,
0.07417139410972595,
-0.2265699803829193,
0.041717275977134705,
-0.055481646209955215,
0.25796762108802795,
-0.0027711710426956415,
0.0428803525865078,
-0.4543217122554779,
-0.3174454867839813,
-0.2352052927017212,
0.45981091260910034,
-0.24308578670024872,
1.0466892719268799,
0.19934508204460144,
-0.44960999488830566,
0.5457109808921814,
-0.5612459778785706,
-0.5573552846908569,
0.2867897152900696,
-0.7723732590675354,
0.06452646106481552,
-0.0373099148273468,
0.2226596176624298,
0.4455674886703491,
-0.01705714873969555,
-0.16574537754058838,
-0.17384806275367737,
-0.7901828289031982,
-0.5711139440536499,
0.084293432533741,
0.6934710144996643,
-0.3514856994152069,
-0.8124960660934448,
0.24025999009609222,
-0.6495193243026733,
0.22744935750961304,
0.12645065784454346,
-0.06109528988599777,
0.05022820830345154,
0.1400398463010788,
-0.3681076467037201,
0.11883540451526642,
0.0343034490942955,
-0.7905171513557434,
0.31238001585006714,
-0.41871577501296997,
0.01954611949622631,
0.8922693729400635,
0.2715677320957184,
0.6940032839775085,
-0.5308871269226074,
0.8288429379463196,
-0.5824013352394104,
0.4549313485622406,
-0.24271784722805023,
-0.5236845016479492,
-0.7287194728851318,
-0.17532669007778168,
-0.5200676918029785,
0.4550294578075409,
-0.912116289138794,
0.021978141739964485,
-0.021947074681520462,
-0.8263077139854431,
-0.023915041238069534,
-0.34326639771461487,
0.5725283622741699,
0.4279188811779022,
0.25459444522857666,
-0.126971036195755,
-0.18206726014614105,
-0.7644973397254944,
0.2594464123249054,
-0.3942748010158539,
0.1652025431394577,
0.17786858975887299,
0.5056696534156799,
0.1683068871498108,
0.7100822925567627,
-0.9804766774177551,
-0.15702463686466217,
-0.19892621040344238,
0.663192093372345,
-0.1936986893415451,
0.3739611506462097,
0.7772824764251709,
-0.3633575141429901,
-0.6427378058433533,
-0.2307843714952469,
-0.5853874087333679,
-0.11782722920179367,
-0.314299613237381,
-0.6159101724624634,
-0.14731080830097198,
0.2801024317741394,
-0.6195811033248901,
0.9492143988609314,
0.12452657520771027,
-0.16841672360897064,
0.808179497718811,
-0.06327355653047562,
0.04082233086228371,
-0.7151804566383362,
0.01365454401820898,
-0.11119138449430466,
-0.084230437874794,
-0.7547032833099365,
0.3723190128803253,
-0.15654857456684113,
-0.3080691695213318,
-0.4779541492462158,
0.5461540818214417,
-0.6851415634155273,
-0.25344106554985046,
-0.33907565474510193,
-0.08677543699741364,
0.019620340317487717,
0.9552006721496582,
0.3024626076221466,
0.6072661876678467,
0.5062772035598755,
-0.6852717399597168,
0.33076637983322144,
0.4612380862236023,
-0.12137051671743393,
0.6765577793121338,
-0.8139939308166504,
0.49257558584213257,
-0.5656805038452148,
0.37545493245124817,
-0.8853296637535095,
-0.04469149559736252,
0.5434359312057495,
-0.3891341984272003,
0.3497532904148102,
-0.2252652496099472,
-0.10596324503421783,
-0.046702586114406586,
-0.55051189661026,
0.26121288537979126,
0.05230412632226944,
-0.12433180212974548,
0.8004269003868103,
0.21076273918151855,
-0.08238722383975983,
-0.7566995620727539,
-0.494809091091156,
-0.2117726355791092,
0.44518837332725525,
-0.5141099095344543,
0.5003995895385742,
-0.1753077656030655,
0.01377914659678936,
-0.13347813487052917,
-0.4149594306945801,
-0.025532899424433708,
-0.14266438782215118,
0.6614516377449036,
0.25186848640441895,
-0.04186910018324852,
-0.25172126293182373,
0.18607281148433685,
-0.18874457478523254,
0.2706393897533417,
0.16373197734355927,
0.4852064251899719,
0.2443748414516449,
-0.48955845832824707,
-0.5494562387466431,
0.625676691532135,
0.4513530433177948,
-0.19015829265117645,
0.596458911895752,
0.2976038157939911,
-0.6220816969871521,
-0.313081830739975,
-0.20176582038402557,
-0.12778939306735992,
-0.37116673588752747,
0.016371548175811768,
-0.39439475536346436,
-0.5666540861129761,
0.08740288764238358,
0.011777185834944248,
0.5871589183807373,
-0.15441802144050598,
0.17967544496059418,
0.020981397479772568,
1.0053058862686157,
0.9913898706436157,
0.4031451344490051,
0.46931350231170654,
-0.8003624081611633,
0.21060402691364288,
-0.8663851618766785,
-0.6508703231811523,
-0.504423975944519,
-0.6945716738700867,
-0.04057628661394119,
-0.6700626611709595,
0.41165217757225037,
-0.06173967197537422,
-0.3866107165813446,
0.4732046127319336,
-0.4675130546092987,
0.4101358652114868,
0.6440754532814026,
0.21946296095848083,
0.011570864357054234,
-0.28378185629844666,
-0.1586347371339798,
0.2146446704864502,
-0.6631277799606323,
-0.33710479736328125,
0.8900845646858215,
-0.2747247517108917,
0.7763329744338989,
0.03900320827960968,
1.1764965057373047,
-0.07329125702381134,
0.2910163402557373,
-1.043272614479065,
0.9101566076278687,
0.46828290820121765,
-0.5521463751792908,
-0.5486458539962769,
-0.0233618076890707,
-0.5231122970581055,
0.30090466141700745,
-0.539101779460907,
-1.0118398666381836,
0.7785115242004395,
0.07524911314249039,
-0.7189971804618835,
-0.012102718465030193,
-0.8584677577018738,
0.7373829483985901,
-0.42727240920066833,
-0.6634977459907532,
-0.22411790490150452,
-0.5906363129615784,
0.06605730205774307,
0.23833239078521729,
-0.3229840099811554,
-0.2418908327817917,
-0.09738662093877792,
0.4720305800437927,
-0.15108254551887512,
0.8895109295845032,
-0.43658187985420227,
0.3279919922351837,
0.28313523530960083,
0.4017658233642578,
0.4391343593597412,
-0.03961426392197609,
0.016585927456617355,
-0.27167701721191406,
0.36989763379096985,
-0.7105229496955872,
-0.6710801124572754,
0.4496937394142151,
-0.6487318873405457,
-0.6370108723640442,
-0.5828589200973511,
-0.37511906027793884,
-0.2577766478061676,
0.2708970010280609,
0.21326133608818054,
0.47677406668663025,
-0.707122802734375,
0.1381017565727234,
0.38802650570869446,
-0.28870895504951477,
0.34643667936325073,
0.7609877586364746,
-0.1905280351638794,
-0.10491214692592621,
0.4303656816482544,
0.28747379779815674,
0.2577471435070038,
0.7771269083023071,
-0.027220478281378746,
-0.1070113554596901,
-0.4724181592464447,
-0.5350432395935059,
0.04184539616107941,
-0.549526035785675,
-0.216044083237648,
-0.67659991979599,
-0.15222112834453583,
-0.5546290874481201,
-0.668341338634491,
-0.23771557211875916,
-0.26705169677734375,
-0.07415023446083069,
-0.20463663339614868,
-0.2655262053012848,
0.7646071314811707,
-0.16981427371501923,
0.288056343793869,
-0.5516423583030701,
0.32302817702293396,
0.44260430335998535,
-0.011607852764427662,
-0.07268616557121277,
0.12163588404655457,
-0.15095506608486176,
0.225119948387146,
-0.4027051031589508,
-1.2213155031204224,
0.3409707546234131,
0.22247236967086792,
0.6632235646247864,
0.6241769790649414,
0.43173497915267944,
0.9843463897705078,
-0.36675941944122314,
0.5899050235748291,
0.12000416964292526,
-0.49779173731803894,
0.8192365765571594,
-0.14936624467372894,
0.6196694374084473,
0.5555528402328491,
0.7252483367919922,
-0.47077155113220215,
-0.20602241158485413,
-0.5062587261199951,
-0.6931610703468323,
0.8744655847549438,
0.09543291479349136,
0.06280336529016495,
-0.052583642303943634,
0.4748319089412689,
-0.04027269408106804,
0.18641524016857147,
-0.3696884512901306,
-0.006140285171568394,
-0.14992357790470123,
0.326185941696167,
0.029082881286740303,
-0.24903492629528046,
-0.2506754696369171,
-0.40303266048431396,
0.5420436263084412,
-0.3801006078720093,
0.5792350769042969,
0.4939979612827301,
0.012722226791083813,
-0.3733070194721222,
0.18579484522342682,
0.7714370489120483,
0.7760128974914551,
-0.4013029634952545,
0.10260246694087982,
0.12864720821380615,
-0.4489835202693939,
0.10792002826929092,
-0.12787389755249023,
-0.5076697468757629,
-0.2024911791086197,
0.2982986867427826,
0.554678738117218,
0.6807526350021362,
-0.6461556553840637,
0.41079357266426086,
-0.054150745272636414,
-0.4400932490825653,
-0.42869365215301514,
0.31796711683273315,
-0.17175714671611786,
0.2958041727542877,
0.19727268815040588,
-0.23301710188388824,
0.34671205282211304,
-0.8131313920021057,
-0.06689205765724182,
0.2526398301124573,
-0.5669072866439819,
-0.41904768347740173,
0.46785393357276917,
0.10696502029895782,
-0.26923033595085144,
0.431826651096344,
-0.22241242229938507,
-0.46563878655433655,
0.6513009667396545,
0.6799832582473755,
0.9454442262649536,
-0.27578064799308777,
0.9832988381385803,
0.5816070437431335,
0.55864018201828,
0.23439274728298187,
0.8081333637237549,
-0.5786543488502502,
-0.5877150893211365,
-0.406040757894516,
-0.4154309928417206,
-0.6116792559623718,
-0.26620572805404663,
-0.49339020252227783,
0.302993506193161,
-1.0307574272155762,
0.249130517244339,
-0.059069279581308365,
-0.0009632637957111001,
-0.5998405814170837,
0.15803728997707367,
0.10481905192136765,
0.7491916418075562,
-0.7355722188949585,
0.261020690202713,
0.9107447266578674,
-0.5144317150115967,
-0.7951392531394958,
0.09917887300252914,
0.28638750314712524,
-0.9568473696708679,
0.4915713369846344,
0.2113095372915268,
-0.7470899224281311,
-0.0386665053665638,
-0.8493223190307617,
-0.6495375633239746,
1.3201748132705688,
0.5090239644050598,
-0.28774145245552063,
-0.37660595774650574,
0.01302380207926035,
0.3869195878505707,
-0.22593553364276886,
0.2504611313343048,
0.12401365488767624,
0.28189077973365784,
0.7846666574478149,
-0.407076895236969,
0.040806591510772705,
-0.22217324376106262,
-0.3072327971458435,
0.4697447121143341,
-0.7543812990188599,
0.4022994637489319,
-0.4635239541530609,
-0.5958008170127869,
0.04655655845999718,
0.5887904167175293,
0.014186580665409565,
0.5507574677467346,
0.23153652250766754,
0.6875154376029968,
0.39113667607307434,
0.1154387965798378,
0.7251072525978088,
-0.311849981546402,
0.0011119409464299679,
1.4256898164749146,
-0.49976134300231934,
0.9996630549430847,
0.19379007816314697,
0.15514831244945526,
0.440976083278656,
0.46752825379371643,
0.40148937702178955,
0.6116209626197815,
-0.10836665332317352,
-0.6181836724281311,
-0.21001620590686798,
-0.19307200610637665,
-0.2046217918395996,
0.7868554592132568,
0.23147320747375488,
0.16810128092765808,
-0.40504807233810425,
-0.24951808154582977,
-0.1801949292421341,
-0.15275835990905762,
-0.25352907180786133,
0.7577610015869141,
-0.12329156696796417,
-0.7219271659851074,
0.3786386549472809,
-0.033537235110998154,
0.013998315669596195,
-0.36178871989250183,
-0.5068626999855042,
-0.2628645896911621,
-0.24124428629875183,
-0.32420551776885986,
-0.8213923573493958,
0.30267223715782166,
-0.21506240963935852,
0.3583696782588959,
-0.39700573682785034,
0.8062828183174133,
-0.10470385104417801,
-0.0685829222202301,
0.14723046123981476,
0.47648385167121887,
0.10772006213665009,
-0.1381584256887436,
-0.5994473099708557,
-0.43330398201942444,
-0.14658020436763763,
0.003203905187547207,
0.11704786866903305,
0.3644710183143616,
0.11033283174037933,
0.5474933981895447,
0.4839783310890198,
-0.23502115905284882,
0.029814831912517548,
-0.22059090435504913,
0.9054319858551025,
-0.7450185418128967,
-0.6070095300674438,
-0.3210691809654236,
0.4039772152900696,
-0.06426689028739929,
-0.2860901951789856,
0.28898531198501587,
0.7277261018753052,
0.929265022277832,
0.0655578225851059,
0.31962648034095764,
-0.08499269187450409,
-0.06503283232450485,
-0.3752429485321045,
0.3403218388557434,
-0.3768428862094879,
-0.0632983073592186,
-0.12888231873512268,
-1.13690984249115,
-0.08313725888729095,
0.8514569401741028,
-0.634208083152771,
-0.12541477382183075,
0.5397161841392517,
0.8871759176254272,
0.16645941138267517,
0.20723606646060944,
0.5239605903625488,
-0.13741958141326904,
0.25620144605636597,
0.7712885141372681,
0.6866539120674133,
0.009734248742461205,
0.14339278638362885,
-0.69197016954422,
-0.5167931914329529,
-0.27650365233421326,
-0.4961184859275818,
-0.8213454484939575,
-0.3681095838546753,
-0.15542471408843994,
0.17847555875778198,
0.32364019751548767,
1.0526161193847656,
0.9057735204696655,
-0.19824618101119995,
-0.3087718188762665,
-0.17034192383289337,
-0.010527496226131916,
-0.24338595569133759,
-0.19413897395133972,
0.027564579620957375,
0.14118394255638123,
-0.5120288133621216,
0.5694291591644287,
0.828429102897644,
0.08487660437822342,
-0.401379257440567,
-0.12638477981090546,
-0.3925776779651642,
0.07088667899370193,
0.8430042862892151,
0.6884281039237976,
-0.2615039050579071,
-0.5157872438430786,
0.3279900848865509,
0.015279322862625122,
-0.1895918846130371,
0.7556803822517395,
-0.7343456149101257,
0.8724901080131531,
0.6016673445701599,
0.2629353106021881,
1.1515886783599854,
-0.1466292142868042,
0.7455257773399353,
-0.6493510007858276,
0.297277569770813,
0.5575681328773499,
0.03377634659409523,
-0.14176645874977112,
-0.5133896470069885,
0.6949660181999207,
-0.0845596045255661,
-0.5388368964195251,
-0.4158536195755005,
0.3054010570049286,
-1.0840877294540405,
-0.07819293439388275,
0.7704133987426758,
-0.19582295417785645,
-0.42960262298583984,
-0.0606197826564312,
-0.542823076248169,
0.2069438099861145,
-0.17196685075759888,
0.8611878752708435,
0.4494692087173462,
-0.6874632239341736,
-0.5491017699241638,
-0.6040523052215576,
0.19401869177818298,
0.216744527220726,
-0.8013820052146912,
-0.3269914388656616,
0.9546303153038025,
-0.1998681277036667,
0.044761721044778824,
1.1734148263931274,
0.13376910984516144,
0.5609093904495239,
0.3098244369029999,
0.19925782084465027,
0.04662064462900162,
-0.6380763649940491,
0.33115923404693604,
0.10728368163108826,
-0.03727928176522255,
-0.26484209299087524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13565v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13565v2
|
Exploring Diverse Methods in Visual Question Answering
| 2024-04-21T07:34:44 | 2024-05-21T02:38:35 |
Panfeng Li, Qikai Yang, Xieming Geng, Wenjing Zhou, Zhicheng Ding, Yi Nian
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This study explores innovative methods for improving Visual Question
Answering (VQA) using Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs), autoencoders, and
attention mechanisms. Leveraging a balanced VQA dataset, we investigate three
distinct strategies. Firstly, GAN-based approaches aim to generate answer
embeddings conditioned on image and question inputs, showing potential but
struggling with more complex tasks. Secondly, autoencoder-based techniques
focus on learning optimal embeddings for questions and images, achieving
comparable results with GAN due to better ability on complex questions. Lastly,
attention mechanisms, incorporating Multimodal Compact Bilinear pooling (MCB),
address language priors and attention modeling, albeit with a
complexity-performance trade-off. This study underscores the challenges and
opportunities in VQA and suggests avenues for future research, including
alternative GAN formulations and attentional mechanisms.
|
[
-0.8169155120849609,
-1.2231073379516602,
0.36964109539985657,
-0.08254484832286835,
-0.18071706593036652,
0.2332974523305893,
0.1935967206954956,
-0.21618033945560455,
-0.03458353877067566,
0.38986384868621826,
-0.6406108736991882,
0.03484553098678589,
-0.40775203704833984,
-0.005573091562837362,
-0.1611715406179428,
0.5397645235061646,
-0.15784578025341034,
0.4214552640914917,
-0.5816779136657715,
-0.46181055903434753,
-0.6068463325500488,
-0.3398590385913849,
-0.7474328279495239,
0.2098081111907959,
0.7609251141548157,
0.20515625178813934,
0.7923961281776428,
0.43609607219696045,
0.6245360970497131,
0.30728232860565186,
-0.0842626765370369,
0.20604869723320007,
-0.4517935812473297,
-0.0007144416449591517,
-0.02552756294608116,
-0.7721570134162903,
0.025590743869543076,
-0.28812819719314575,
0.131438210606575,
0.4929465651512146,
-0.16723383963108063,
0.3767724335193634,
-0.15535558760166168,
0.46276527643203735,
-0.9223489165306091,
-0.19915111362934113,
-0.4287812113761902,
0.24470622837543488,
0.009265322238206863,
-0.38562583923339844,
0.16509391367435455,
-0.152985081076622,
0.3421783745288849,
-0.6155832409858704,
0.42798393964767456,
-0.004679915029555559,
0.8817182779312134,
0.6879910230636597,
-0.3280371129512787,
-0.12991032004356384,
-0.4586675763130188,
0.37618499994277954,
-0.2731268107891083,
0.09290128946304321,
-0.02390318736433983,
0.8118951916694641,
0.3283904492855072,
-0.8853479027748108,
-0.6489021182060242,
0.3981560170650482,
0.11799740791320801,
0.5768143534660339,
-0.31297972798347473,
0.04351230338215828,
0.38716068863868713,
0.7116305232048035,
-0.8725232481956482,
-0.35239431262016296,
-0.515674352645874,
0.1387287825345993,
0.3908149003982544,
0.26315924525260925,
0.5656554698944092,
-0.2610301375389099,
-0.5455164313316345,
-0.3815709948539734,
-0.4817592203617096,
0.6088594794273376,
0.06418111175298691,
-0.3436676561832428,
0.09126919507980347,
0.9180421829223633,
-0.4706197679042816,
0.7764325737953186,
0.06968213617801666,
0.693838894367218,
-0.1258358359336853,
-0.5385870933532715,
-0.47875070571899414,
-0.5036930441856384,
0.5497704744338989,
0.6624301075935364,
0.3077225089073181,
-0.055399056524038315,
0.08150812983512878,
-0.03698062524199486,
0.4644954800605774,
-0.4666716754436493,
-0.5019684433937073,
0.08753928542137146,
-0.2625575363636017,
-0.11141122877597809,
0.02549145743250847,
-0.9401224851608276,
-0.12131524085998535,
-0.29605793952941895,
0.9139668345451355,
-0.24778620898723602,
0.07896413654088974,
0.0647919550538063,
-0.533201277256012,
1.0811952352523804,
0.5540686845779419,
-0.7301219701766968,
0.11160197108983994,
0.09919742494821548,
0.423187255859375,
0.1643221229314804,
-0.039239007979631424,
-0.7941765785217285,
-0.07839708775281906,
-0.4245002269744873,
0.606575071811676,
-0.20561110973358154,
0.06355899572372437,
0.010117688216269016,
0.060228511691093445,
-0.19056890904903412,
-0.5537815093994141,
0.061344992369413376,
-0.9587709903717041,
0.4615400731563568,
-0.8290886878967285,
-0.1358545571565628,
-0.4561060070991516,
0.45743346214294434,
-0.8348405957221985,
0.7543194890022278,
0.16624179482460022,
-0.716668963432312,
0.10022391378879547,
-0.500738263130188,
-0.1533161848783493,
0.18836292624473572,
-0.4186774790287018,
-0.24520330131053925,
0.18736399710178375,
0.951663613319397,
0.28320854902267456,
-0.3134361207485199,
-0.15937364101409912,
-0.28352025151252747,
-0.30319514870643616,
0.34921956062316895,
-0.4776369035243988,
0.7881785035133362,
0.25958532094955444,
-0.5012443661689758,
0.22850555181503296,
-0.33849725127220154,
0.3038942813873291,
0.48003607988357544,
0.10857760161161423,
-0.10157890617847443,
-0.3791019916534424,
-0.13081860542297363,
0.2430131882429123,
0.07053913176059723,
-0.38929587602615356,
0.03011312149465084,
-0.11454397439956665,
0.41761645674705505,
0.4988454282283783,
0.305764377117157,
0.20487558841705322,
-0.22581885755062103,
1.0536788702011108,
0.05200507491827011,
0.44185671210289,
-0.07439105957746506,
-0.5007798671722412,
-1.0478345155715942,
0.029852820560336113,
0.1756284385919571,
0.8364695906639099,
-1.4912384748458862,
-0.48486077785491943,
0.03281186893582344,
-0.0026474588084965944,
-0.8515046238899231,
0.23920924961566925,
0.5867708325386047,
0.39942264556884766,
0.5424889922142029,
-0.5156942009925842,
-0.2916449010372162,
-0.9177653193473816,
-0.043245378881692886,
-0.1379869133234024,
0.1852055937051773,
0.44034746289253235,
0.40838345885276794,
0.2653312683105469,
0.7468807101249695,
-0.8151816129684448,
0.21481463313102722,
-0.169847771525383,
0.20923130214214325,
-0.3805278241634369,
0.0012400929117575288,
0.8526868224143982,
-1.2474080324172974,
-0.3820185959339142,
-0.32631322741508484,
-1.0185532569885254,
0.3898313343524933,
-0.19999220967292786,
-0.14985695481300354,
-0.24337944388389587,
0.7469664812088013,
-0.4182921051979065,
0.6897287964820862,
0.1427876353263855,
0.013891525566577911,
0.14339132606983185,
-0.014161832630634308,
0.4923320710659027,
-0.6867559552192688,
-0.1479583978652954,
-0.05786356329917908,
-0.23151451349258423,
-0.5698163509368896,
0.373960018157959,
0.021012993529438972,
-0.24939794838428497,
-0.6975926756858826,
0.4873785376548767,
-0.6924418807029724,
-0.0985012874007225,
-0.02084261365234852,
0.053159814327955246,
0.16954956948757172,
0.7969531416893005,
-0.07786469161510468,
0.9030800461769104,
0.68900066614151,
-0.3562043607234955,
0.9498898983001709,
0.5208572745323181,
-0.1476282775402069,
0.5674992799758911,
-1.1381149291992188,
0.19872477650642395,
-0.8706233501434326,
-0.3406791090965271,
-1.732674241065979,
-0.26945462822914124,
0.4693188965320587,
-0.5993748903274536,
0.4055818021297455,
-0.1319853514432907,
-0.20495454967021942,
-0.657844603061676,
-0.3867482841014862,
0.6377376317977905,
0.35023972392082214,
-0.5504297614097595,
0.5853513479232788,
0.008611630648374557,
-0.4173968732357025,
-0.7077813148498535,
-0.8753392696380615,
0.25824031233787537,
-0.23274686932563782,
-0.7047188878059387,
0.022265473380684853,
-0.2809247374534607,
-0.10727129131555557,
0.26787611842155457,
0.08796452730894089,
-0.13526184856891632,
0.08320502936840057,
-0.16739153861999512,
0.305038720369339,
-0.3704749643802643,
-0.13503696024417877,
-0.20587800443172455,
0.27645161747932434,
0.09425124526023865,
0.030290838330984116,
0.23109100759029388,
-0.2692497968673706,
-0.35059940814971924,
-0.028793590143322945,
0.8534817099571228,
0.726517379283905,
-0.848050594329834,
0.45384684205055237,
0.8238922953605652,
-0.15650421380996704,
-0.04011949151754379,
-0.5449185967445374,
-0.03843596205115318,
-0.39551717042922974,
0.42602336406707764,
-0.4279802441596985,
-0.824319064617157,
0.4953218400478363,
0.42672690749168396,
-0.03970785066485405,
0.06012338399887085,
0.6846204996109009,
-0.47477197647094727,
0.9152640104293823,
0.5548014640808105,
0.3227629065513611,
0.5139882564544678,
-0.3128136694431305,
0.12837284803390503,
-0.984228253364563,
-0.2811657786369324,
0.10222078859806061,
-0.3020590543746948,
-0.35575973987579346,
-0.6732931733131409,
0.5712074041366577,
0.25257599353790283,
-0.027484478428959846,
0.06888838112354279,
-0.4446781277656555,
0.34956347942352295,
0.7632120847702026,
0.24966749548912048,
-0.10007118433713913,
0.056276824325323105,
0.1480722874403,
0.07557737082242966,
-1.1318035125732422,
-0.01909940503537655,
1.00973379611969,
0.10406053066253662,
0.744830846786499,
0.22267380356788635,
0.21537144482135773,
-0.13392004370689392,
0.22998614609241486,
-0.4751124382019043,
0.4045320153236389,
-0.016307249665260315,
-0.7496037483215332,
-0.5489878058433533,
-0.25987371802330017,
-0.7447479963302612,
0.41349729895591736,
-0.2242787629365921,
-0.2604711055755615,
0.4001689851284027,
0.1895361989736557,
-0.7143670916557312,
0.03587746620178223,
-0.7572408318519592,
1.1369155645370483,
-0.47749122977256775,
-0.6335959434509277,
0.36800897121429443,
-0.9637018442153931,
0.34402841329574585,
0.7392498850822449,
-0.2618521749973297,
0.4915921688079834,
0.0438556931912899,
0.28040292859077454,
-0.12879398465156555,
0.5783565640449524,
-0.027716903015971184,
0.12223515659570694,
0.6258077025413513,
-0.39238956570625305,
0.15203003585338593,
0.21338050067424774,
0.5685173869132996,
-0.33531665802001953,
-0.12355986982584,
-0.8039483428001404,
-1.0079878568649292,
0.37200793623924255,
-0.7111736536026001,
-0.7244390845298767,
-0.22916279733181,
-0.39010700583457947,
-0.4689047634601593,
-0.19008038938045502,
0.5584555268287659,
0.6098372936248779,
-0.10459931194782257,
0.3341096341609955,
1.2236346006393433,
-0.3184957206249237,
0.6793508529663086,
-0.05019843578338623,
0.05427001789212227,
-0.8995330333709717,
0.5954604148864746,
0.049780286848545074,
0.48439377546310425,
0.4607434570789337,
-0.2306072860956192,
-0.47089964151382446,
-0.47758111357688904,
-1.1180437803268433,
0.12524083256721497,
-0.9162396788597107,
-0.0851183608174324,
-0.6682180166244507,
-0.32690608501434326,
-0.36746710538864136,
0.0452541820704937,
-0.027355875819921494,
-0.20589879155158997,
-0.21525035798549652,
-0.21066084504127502,
0.33976390957832336,
0.15748390555381775,
0.2690832018852234,
0.026804985478520393,
-0.49217548966407776,
1.0355006456375122,
1.3306324481964111,
0.08451271057128906,
-0.04605470225214958,
-0.1623641550540924,
0.06870374828577042,
0.1286800503730774,
-0.19308139383792877,
-1.101393699645996,
0.043609268963336945,
0.08313345164060593,
0.7289599776268005,
-0.0932762399315834,
0.03840544447302818,
0.9569352865219116,
-0.2714824080467224,
0.8245547413825989,
0.25767403841018677,
-0.5463829040527344,
0.4812934100627899,
-0.3914530873298645,
0.4767058789730072,
0.6033641695976257,
0.4145958721637726,
-0.38566723465919495,
-0.07683250308036804,
-0.3680717945098877,
-0.8327370882034302,
0.20892293751239777,
0.5131222009658813,
0.19644929468631744,
0.07449008524417877,
0.3349020481109619,
-0.34448015689849854,
0.6087985634803772,
-0.5738922953605652,
-0.48446935415267944,
-0.6274756789207458,
-0.24357961118221283,
-0.044409144669771194,
0.03774017095565796,
-0.3938676118850708,
-0.22129912674427032,
0.21576592326164246,
-0.27109047770500183,
0.23717354238033295,
0.6674851179122925,
-0.2119767963886261,
-0.07562185078859329,
0.11967957764863968,
0.43383339047431946,
0.6463727355003357,
0.08315964788198471,
0.024843357503414154,
0.2558816969394684,
-0.15647979080677032,
0.041827473789453506,
0.13324709236621857,
-0.44142717123031616,
-0.15609785914421082,
0.1914953887462616,
1.0198299884796143,
-0.3092062473297119,
-0.6553034782409668,
0.6737753748893738,
-0.5515029430389404,
-0.3015873432159424,
-0.2215951383113861,
0.16861937940120697,
0.2292037159204483,
0.35246551036834717,
0.22239898145198822,
-0.03942069411277771,
0.32851260900497437,
-0.7970559000968933,
0.17709527909755707,
0.5054343938827515,
-0.7417502999305725,
0.13245688378810883,
0.8906980752944946,
-0.022447314113378525,
0.06890168786048889,
0.42947232723236084,
0.10755254328250885,
-0.48496243357658386,
0.8535957932472229,
-0.04702982306480408,
0.7018799185752869,
-0.1439661830663681,
0.48748424649238586,
0.20763590931892395,
0.4580378234386444,
0.37591075897216797,
0.7788388133049011,
-0.15250547230243683,
-0.2949678599834442,
-0.39368462562561035,
-0.11693962663412094,
-0.30549776554107666,
0.18899746239185333,
-0.8921716809272766,
-0.16718578338623047,
-0.2519506812095642,
0.07384482771158218,
0.05210961028933525,
-0.20141418278217316,
-0.9124104380607605,
0.6565101742744446,
0.39264029264450073,
0.45347803831100464,
-0.7322219014167786,
0.10642091184854507,
1.143090009689331,
-0.7280087471008301,
-0.5988704562187195,
-0.02548828348517418,
-0.07975781708955765,
-0.6264106631278992,
0.3986969292163849,
-0.12883929908275604,
-0.1869601160287857,
0.16364848613739014,
-0.9305710196495056,
-0.9117301106452942,
0.9820033311843872,
0.17143039405345917,
-0.10957923531532288,
-0.08373696357011795,
-0.043202925473451614,
0.4561910927295685,
-0.08689040690660477,
0.3526199162006378,
0.024357445538043976,
0.23184789717197418,
0.4785975217819214,
-0.3165803551673889,
-0.1449916511774063,
-0.7442911863327026,
0.35232022404670715,
-0.11186161637306213,
-0.8424047827720642,
0.7049264311790466,
-0.392744779586792,
-0.27725252509117126,
0.2858874201774597,
0.8534572720527649,
-0.03773576766252518,
0.2660311162471771,
0.40812453627586365,
0.6053414940834045,
0.5128505229949951,
-0.09746163338422775,
1.0366146564483643,
0.2318497747182846,
0.06647315621376038,
0.963899552822113,
0.055789150297641754,
0.467533677816391,
0.623725950717926,
-0.07860596477985382,
0.17435023188591003,
0.7153213620185852,
-0.11974415928125381,
0.6772345304489136,
0.46209487318992615,
-0.12173347920179367,
-0.5215698480606079,
0.06667754799127579,
-0.35366663336753845,
0.25873979926109314,
0.004140518140047789,
0.01871044747531414,
-0.2762731909751892,
0.43927401304244995,
-0.5529350638389587,
0.07807646691799164,
-0.2963999807834625,
0.921930193901062,
-0.0717264786362648,
-0.8171724081039429,
0.6418091058731079,
-0.39819514751434326,
0.1499684900045395,
-0.32631027698516846,
-0.17002876102924347,
-0.3011166453361511,
-0.18010295927524567,
0.25043153762817383,
-0.9452730417251587,
0.05568080022931099,
-0.035887494683265686,
-0.2982129156589508,
-0.043139319866895676,
0.3496714234352112,
-0.6187849640846252,
-0.4634362757205963,
-0.09233408421278,
0.7254722714424133,
-0.3409704566001892,
-0.056427620351314545,
-0.7602008581161499,
-0.37137794494628906,
-0.0566227063536644,
-0.32253068685531616,
-0.012224284000694752,
0.7745463848114014,
-0.039298441261053085,
0.6990461349487305,
0.4279615581035614,
-0.36467912793159485,
0.6218886971473694,
0.03078499250113964,
0.9256381988525391,
-0.5821693539619446,
-0.3569771647453308,
-0.38282510638237,
0.851087212562561,
-0.32871681451797485,
-0.5618456602096558,
0.777763307094574,
0.20147204399108887,
0.7583930492401123,
-0.35166752338409424,
0.6865934729576111,
0.050301775336265564,
0.05451439693570137,
-0.6222917437553406,
0.3625389337539673,
-0.9467185139656067,
-0.03100784495472908,
-0.2923906743526459,
-0.6926141381263733,
-0.24338902533054352,
0.3532964289188385,
-0.15365323424339294,
-0.034820444881916046,
0.5869103074073792,
0.6703724265098572,
0.07823862880468369,
-0.12385974079370499,
0.2717059552669525,
-0.1938314437866211,
0.15137216448783875,
0.8214153051376343,
1.1686656475067139,
-0.6916654109954834,
0.7071560025215149,
-0.3302035629749298,
-0.13942183554172516,
-0.20934738218784332,
-0.22549040615558624,
-0.9465737342834473,
-0.4814949333667755,
-0.49866920709609985,
0.0019286914030089974,
0.19090628623962402,
0.04414314404129982,
0.6257776021957397,
-0.5191486477851868,
0.2676900625228882,
-0.13421441614627838,
-0.08771156519651413,
-0.35696443915367126,
-0.1847674548625946,
0.30718451738357544,
-0.21095627546310425,
-0.5969364643096924,
-0.08371158689260483,
0.3441636860370636,
0.32343196868896484,
-0.2511657774448395,
0.389907568693161,
-0.2852761149406433,
0.11736666411161423,
0.573329508304596,
0.45331287384033203,
-0.6692676544189453,
-0.22676970064640045,
0.6567391753196716,
-0.22219939529895782,
0.1416255533695221,
0.5141915678977966,
-0.5712575912475586,
0.7196992039680481,
0.9385263919830322,
1.0060324668884277,
0.6804149150848389,
0.5564452409744263,
0.6902589201927185,
-0.3845601975917816,
-0.3348899781703949,
0.3269612491130829,
0.21633531153202057,
0.5312460660934448,
-0.3208690583705902,
0.4141572117805481,
0.04744795709848404,
-0.12103486806154251,
-0.34807801246643066,
0.41475439071655273,
-1.1772401332855225,
-0.4107186496257782,
0.7516253590583801,
-0.0814422145485878,
-0.48160672187805176,
-0.20691615343093872,
-0.4806872308254242,
0.061802465468645096,
0.382694810628891,
0.31359636783599854,
0.720906138420105,
-0.22578296065330505,
-0.8396618962287903,
-0.7779645919799805,
0.4343183934688568,
0.7764025926589966,
-0.8563066124916077,
-0.17017023265361786,
0.49067607522010803,
0.1978491097688675,
-0.04056362062692642,
0.40479880571365356,
-0.21217362582683563,
0.8629743456840515,
-0.15246295928955078,
-0.024513965472579002,
-0.09505786746740341,
-0.4603566527366638,
-0.41342487931251526,
0.4519105553627014,
-0.3009336292743683,
-0.539688229560852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13556v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13556v1
|
ChatRetriever: Adapting Large Language Models for Generalized and Robust Conversational Dense Retrieval
| 2024-04-21T07:03:55 | 2024-04-21T07:03:55 |
Kelong Mao, Chenlong Deng, Haonan Chen, Fengran Mo, Zheng Liu, Tetsuya Sakai, Zhicheng Dou
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Conversational search requires accurate interpretation of user intent from
complex multi-turn contexts. This paper presents ChatRetriever, which inherits
the strong generalization capability of large language models to robustly
represent complex conversational sessions for dense retrieval. To achieve this,
we propose a simple and effective dual-learning approach that adapts LLM for
retrieval via contrastive learning while enhancing the complex session
understanding through masked instruction tuning on high-quality conversational
instruction tuning data. Extensive experiments on five conversational search
benchmarks demonstrate that ChatRetriever substantially outperforms existing
conversational dense retrievers, achieving state-of-the-art performance on par
with LLM-based rewriting approaches. Furthermore, ChatRetriever exhibits
superior robustness in handling diverse conversational contexts. Our work
highlights the potential of adapting LLMs for retrieval with complex inputs
like conversational search sessions and proposes an effective approach to
advance this research direction.
|
[
-0.06101268529891968,
-0.9916611909866333,
0.3881019651889801,
0.14933450520038605,
-0.14112159609794617,
0.4983496367931366,
-0.6758182048797607,
-0.24464668333530426,
0.11208171397447586,
0.4967934191226959,
-0.4492354393005371,
-0.5482766032218933,
-0.38285765051841736,
-0.324758917093277,
-0.21928159892559052,
0.7398374080657959,
0.3180174231529236,
0.25898897647857666,
-0.09025286138057709,
-0.12758205831050873,
-0.6462836265563965,
-0.611028790473938,
-0.8513782620429993,
-0.3408946096897125,
0.39371031522750854,
0.7178428173065186,
0.873882532119751,
-0.11599625647068024,
0.543391227722168,
0.39179500937461853,
0.06101104989647865,
0.4555140733718872,
-1.2811464071273804,
0.7529871463775635,
-0.3640221059322357,
-0.5033630728721619,
-0.20866936445236206,
-0.46576279401779175,
0.7147743701934814,
0.5983526110649109,
-0.6108827590942383,
-0.3658909499645233,
0.17409314215183258,
0.49430346488952637,
-0.6472979187965393,
0.10467615723609924,
-1.043839454650879,
-0.04511493816971779,
0.21550710499286652,
-0.4237150251865387,
-0.7216693162918091,
-0.179554745554924,
0.2807200253009796,
-0.49460941553115845,
0.6731579899787903,
0.233104407787323,
0.6089943051338196,
0.06262624263763428,
-0.5419961810112,
-0.4070011377334595,
-0.9347626566886902,
1.073711633682251,
-0.3595890700817108,
0.5378473997116089,
0.21726094186306,
0.8199435472488403,
-0.4494819641113281,
-0.9425457715988159,
-0.10637396574020386,
-0.13388696312904358,
-0.24651648104190826,
0.15764717757701874,
-0.328290730714798,
0.3669867515563965,
-0.10817573964595795,
0.5835953950881958,
-0.6559906005859375,
0.06336522102355957,
-0.154277503490448,
-0.2366311103105545,
0.5787459015846252,
0.349338561296463,
0.4197436273097992,
0.3051745593547821,
-0.2809044420719147,
-0.21827708184719086,
-0.3825545012950897,
-0.0931783989071846,
0.052196331322193146,
0.3765229284763336,
-0.13757692277431488,
0.2788042724132538,
-0.23858413100242615,
0.5028982162475586,
0.1366327404975891,
-0.043429695069789886,
0.07521998882293701,
-0.4313487410545349,
-0.19954855740070343,
-0.047025978565216064,
0.5969024896621704,
0.2803986072540283,
0.12129933387041092,
-0.4105486571788788,
-0.23513808846473694,
-0.46581509709358215,
0.3484712541103363,
-1.0752933025360107,
-0.3286817669868469,
0.019774682819843292,
-0.2901517152786255,
-0.13886331021785736,
0.07631402462720871,
-0.997359037399292,
-0.2400180697441101,
-0.2050173133611679,
0.3236965537071228,
-0.4223555326461792,
-0.13526181876659393,
0.5020379424095154,
0.04063337668776512,
0.4845149517059326,
0.6043582558631897,
-1.1078639030456543,
0.6093729138374329,
0.6988720297813416,
0.830051600933075,
-0.11173385381698608,
0.10229640454053879,
-0.8510578274726868,
0.17254801094532013,
-0.06999582797288895,
0.6227983832359314,
-0.9993320107460022,
-0.6940329074859619,
0.23923611640930176,
0.04987698793411255,
-0.3170420527458191,
-0.6186519861221313,
0.6790746450424194,
-0.9221854209899902,
0.3758412301540375,
-0.13869614899158478,
-0.31601884961128235,
-0.30713653564453125,
0.2703888416290283,
-0.4277421236038208,
0.9810225963592529,
0.10836387425661087,
-0.42617419362068176,
-0.06394778937101364,
-0.3499119281768799,
-0.48754972219467163,
0.2620638906955719,
-0.18486106395721436,
-0.3658049404621124,
0.2713124454021454,
0.13089483976364136,
0.39906445145606995,
-0.16504187881946564,
0.3681567907333374,
-0.3752582371234894,
-0.6672235727310181,
0.21215486526489258,
-0.45327115058898926,
0.33319470286369324,
0.1211811974644661,
-0.07460048049688339,
0.2518087923526764,
-0.4049032926559448,
0.011596258729696274,
0.18504388630390167,
-0.5600648522377014,
-0.25416550040245056,
0.1546545922756195,
0.28712019324302673,
-0.13933245837688446,
0.17030072212219238,
-0.3808723986148834,
0.17674988508224487,
-0.2629270553588867,
0.5158515572547913,
0.5000787973403931,
-0.12652350962162018,
0.5897493362426758,
-0.28320565819740295,
0.48418834805488586,
-0.2001434564590454,
-0.04106498509645462,
-0.19128476083278656,
-0.17416664958000183,
-1.0165672302246094,
-0.29437825083732605,
0.09300996363162994,
0.5634468197822571,
-0.6966042518615723,
0.28237462043762207,
-0.4246338903903961,
-0.24672859907150269,
-0.40316009521484375,
0.23525024950504303,
0.5503843426704407,
0.41222795844078064,
0.4538549780845642,
-0.41116073727607727,
-0.5642566680908203,
-0.8369379639625549,
-0.2748395800590515,
-0.02404928207397461,
-0.1270514577627182,
0.9532698392868042,
0.12034671753644943,
-0.6378294825553894,
0.46187832951545715,
-0.6854140758514404,
-0.3141213655471802,
-0.2725856304168701,
-0.033089809119701385,
0.12821558117866516,
0.398253470659256,
0.26979711651802063,
-1.0846859216690063,
-0.547721803188324,
0.14389389753341675,
-0.6380500197410583,
0.1885661482810974,
-0.017267713323235512,
-0.4561123251914978,
-0.2020168900489807,
0.7279492020606995,
-0.33291471004486084,
0.03199243173003197,
0.42145368456840515,
-0.3574235737323761,
0.35785946249961853,
-0.34993940591812134,
0.16464388370513916,
-1.010741114616394,
-0.0963745266199112,
-0.2697397768497467,
-0.5887660980224609,
-0.7613708972930908,
0.2668558955192566,
0.017527902498841286,
-0.17210909724235535,
-0.2967761754989624,
0.5767189860343933,
-0.46186691522598267,
0.004429054446518421,
-0.1794174313545227,
0.2366809844970703,
0.11396627873182297,
0.43010827898979187,
-0.03972483053803444,
0.9369535446166992,
0.4364005923271179,
-0.5036603808403015,
0.41426950693130493,
0.2955828309059143,
-0.24630363285541534,
0.5094103217124939,
-0.7786868214607239,
0.3025765120983124,
-0.3149198591709137,
0.3170488476753235,
-1.2116761207580566,
-0.4088708460330963,
0.03446218743920326,
-0.12797704339027405,
0.6161726117134094,
-0.36929911375045776,
-0.24037864804267883,
0.08101630955934525,
-0.2869217097759247,
0.401035875082016,
0.46575435996055603,
-0.7120574116706848,
0.9741382002830505,
0.15012991428375244,
-0.27322813868522644,
-0.5449285507202148,
-0.5612020492553711,
0.31204652786254883,
-0.10734473168849945,
-0.6995779871940613,
0.44616445899009705,
-0.39255571365356445,
-0.19919629395008087,
-0.46651583909988403,
-0.0482628270983696,
-0.10264041274785995,
0.17572860419750214,
0.12372457981109619,
0.1553499400615692,
-0.4676707684993744,
0.26694104075431824,
-0.0701388269662857,
-0.021719280630350113,
-0.21549087762832642,
0.1054202988743782,
0.7390274405479431,
-0.2975127100944519,
-0.34741589426994324,
0.009991287253797054,
0.4240971505641937,
0.3871615529060364,
0.024266690015792847,
0.593189001083374,
0.7948201894760132,
0.06676538288593292,
-0.417610764503479,
-0.9625335335731506,
-0.4739874005317688,
-0.5734612345695496,
0.6072194576263428,
-0.4828841984272003,
-1.438152551651001,
0.38366764783859253,
-0.05513378232717514,
-0.06017167493700981,
-0.0819140374660492,
0.6499218940734863,
-0.054749857634305954,
0.9394650459289551,
0.5722890496253967,
0.03312516584992409,
0.6964664459228516,
0.030392294749617577,
0.17687156796455383,
-0.7501879930496216,
-0.4352720081806183,
-0.4287497401237488,
-0.4457077085971832,
-0.48857805132865906,
-0.45221689343452454,
0.23642680048942566,
0.09324678033590317,
-0.042941831052303314,
-0.0962074026465416,
-0.4745970666408539,
0.6093363165855408,
0.571376383304596,
0.5483248233795166,
0.39587077498435974,
0.2657748758792877,
0.01738593727350235,
-0.1580394059419632,
-0.5797016024589539,
-0.29614248871803284,
0.8978760242462158,
0.04880988597869873,
1.026589274406433,
0.5678003430366516,
0.41622209548950195,
0.2079317718744278,
-0.06726682186126709,
-0.8669305443763733,
0.4225884675979614,
-0.2934916913509369,
-0.5238862037658691,
-0.12796613574028015,
-0.5485345721244812,
-1.1214441061019897,
0.7538374662399292,
-0.16379578411579132,
-0.59223473072052,
0.1438930630683899,
0.06932076811790466,
-0.14614206552505493,
0.008410783484578133,
-0.8893091082572937,
0.7848089337348938,
-0.404422402381897,
-0.49093616008758545,
-0.5565004944801331,
-0.46033230423927307,
0.4512089192867279,
0.1925441175699234,
0.026660358533263206,
-0.09808101505041122,
-0.1609654724597931,
0.4268577992916107,
0.11880084127187729,
0.8748510479927063,
-0.020150188356637955,
0.23563382029533386,
-0.07694258540868759,
0.4136727750301361,
0.5107766389846802,
0.32963329553604126,
-0.18238329887390137,
-0.16184525191783905,
-0.08924081176519394,
-0.5981961488723755,
-0.7325871586799622,
1.0004240274429321,
-0.846354603767395,
-0.9555031657218933,
-0.2587968111038208,
-0.6253765821456909,
-0.2497655749320984,
0.3115023970603943,
-0.08158028870820999,
0.3330386281013489,
-0.6556963324546814,
0.6288741827011108,
1.1197773218154907,
-0.2273838222026825,
0.16307596862316132,
0.7658214569091797,
-0.2261730134487152,
-0.23125803470611572,
0.8374460339546204,
-0.5215068459510803,
0.24767723679542542,
0.7374740242958069,
0.21654196083545685,
-0.11513089388608932,
-0.6773221492767334,
-0.0944320410490036,
0.19561119377613068,
-0.7231670022010803,
-0.12107253819704056,
-0.7611681818962097,
-0.24975228309631348,
-0.10075417160987854,
-0.286530077457428,
-0.19118863344192505,
-0.061263084411621094,
-0.6008809804916382,
0.17043501138687134,
0.3055669963359833,
0.24042105674743652,
0.30842989683151245,
0.37883996963500977,
-0.5715885162353516,
0.31092801690101624,
0.7367180585861206,
0.3146587014198303,
-0.0866943970322609,
-0.773638904094696,
-0.07589923590421677,
0.05820292979478836,
-0.23946261405944824,
-0.24675500392913818,
0.29971617460250854,
0.7238985300064087,
0.5525190830230713,
0.44180575013160706,
0.08925744146108627,
0.8030291795730591,
-0.4360189437866211,
0.48431798815727234,
0.1842411607503891,
-0.5562354922294617,
0.47035837173461914,
-0.24759840965270996,
0.3916737139225006,
0.9366886019706726,
0.24101710319519043,
-0.6090694665908813,
-0.03243513032793999,
-0.29356148838996887,
-0.7769129276275635,
0.7029953598976135,
0.08080768585205078,
0.5789145231246948,
0.2643009424209595,
0.3224482536315918,
0.08252211660146713,
0.02030317671597004,
-0.3654424548149109,
-0.029358526691794395,
-0.221828892827034,
-0.23719976842403412,
-0.2306535243988037,
-0.6556422114372253,
-0.17610898613929749,
0.038135189563035965,
0.5144312381744385,
-0.26611942052841187,
0.20783457159996033,
0.07440926134586334,
-0.26871663331985474,
0.04402114823460579,
0.5113576650619507,
0.4778057336807251,
0.4214925765991211,
-0.4430990517139435,
0.4157278835773468,
0.17479246854782104,
-0.6490954160690308,
0.027487335726618767,
0.08824536204338074,
0.04823186248540878,
0.003731010714545846,
0.30246275663375854,
0.6723191142082214,
0.974066436290741,
-0.9337308406829834,
0.680465817451477,
-0.5335347056388855,
-0.012646932154893875,
-0.27315786480903625,
0.5944594144821167,
0.1684136688709259,
0.3081338703632355,
0.3179120421409607,
-0.0857655331492424,
0.2924323081970215,
-0.4981188476085663,
0.12610045075416565,
0.8000304102897644,
-0.6210579872131348,
-0.3460862636566162,
0.47376754879951477,
0.3353811502456665,
-0.33796945214271545,
0.7875586748123169,
-0.026477249339222908,
-0.30450552701950073,
0.1039336547255516,
0.6144180297851562,
0.8216860890388489,
-0.4490203559398651,
0.03225298970937729,
0.2840810716152191,
-0.07057502865791321,
-0.1395191103219986,
0.126272514462471,
-0.2550548315048218,
-0.8513026833534241,
-0.16623647511005402,
-0.5104918479919434,
-0.3886076807975769,
-0.001851890585385263,
-0.7224591970443726,
0.19161035120487213,
-0.4174080193042755,
0.07832363247871399,
-0.06409643590450287,
0.02283073402941227,
-0.745493471622467,
-0.20928263664245605,
0.010294594801962376,
0.6229766011238098,
-0.3410009741783142,
0.8264420628547668,
0.5004224181175232,
-0.22996020317077637,
-0.23565562069416046,
-0.30924588441848755,
0.07581312954425812,
-1.2555346488952637,
0.4615272879600525,
-0.0783282220363617,
-0.38789835572242737,
0.046530187129974365,
-0.48460254073143005,
-0.7972571849822998,
1.151383876800537,
0.5302268862724304,
-0.9697325825691223,
-0.20525115728378296,
-0.18922650814056396,
0.4430724084377289,
-0.3350582718849182,
0.6265586018562317,
0.4895394444465637,
0.0647888109087944,
0.6642018556594849,
-0.6000540852546692,
0.0005659108282998204,
-0.0444045215845108,
0.22498583793640137,
0.0848940908908844,
-0.8542047142982483,
0.3807201683521271,
0.0068207127042114735,
-0.35424837470054626,
0.05794674530625343,
0.3782322406768799,
0.24117456376552582,
0.23155465722084045,
0.22754186391830444,
0.23711077868938446,
0.6472570896148682,
-0.07133615761995316,
0.8124459981918335,
-0.09760512411594391,
0.34355267882347107,
1.317566156387329,
-0.29190680384635925,
0.9738289713859558,
0.34190455079078674,
-0.12168063968420029,
0.628602921962738,
0.24644777178764343,
0.06883479654788971,
0.5875478386878967,
0.030626047402620316,
-0.6262545585632324,
-0.6268832683563232,
-0.09371719509363174,
-0.1200122982263565,
0.37986522912979126,
0.6685693264007568,
-0.3383873999118805,
-0.3303705155849457,
-0.18326538801193237,
0.09640361368656158,
0.28900471329689026,
-0.037331558763980865,
1.0194299221038818,
0.15486747026443481,
-0.6030093431472778,
0.7414219975471497,
0.041922107338905334,
0.7766062617301941,
-0.6334017515182495,
-0.1481662541627884,
-0.40266337990760803,
0.43141767382621765,
-0.30923211574554443,
-0.5414127111434937,
-0.09093695878982544,
-0.4986620843410492,
-0.16543740034103394,
-0.09836209565401077,
0.9720042943954468,
-0.6367043256759644,
-0.5146626234054565,
0.46743306517601013,
0.3942342698574066,
-0.060456883162260056,
0.05797169357538223,
-0.9408178925514221,
0.34365686774253845,
0.23294037580490112,
-0.12041584402322769,
0.5426855087280273,
0.3473796546459198,
0.2884332239627838,
0.7430593967437744,
0.5656526684761047,
-0.3563762903213501,
-0.010645054280757904,
0.32532942295074463,
0.9120520353317261,
-0.5960527658462524,
-0.2569347023963928,
-0.6992415189743042,
0.24050608277320862,
-0.07908614724874496,
0.06445425748825073,
0.7451645731925964,
0.6947757005691528,
0.6845200657844543,
0.12197727710008621,
0.5851786136627197,
0.38416537642478943,
0.3930254876613617,
-0.6341409087181091,
0.3769172132015228,
-0.20661863684654236,
0.47063547372817993,
0.09667233377695084,
-1.0039565563201904,
-0.46587038040161133,
0.5261739492416382,
-0.3783569037914276,
0.13564223051071167,
0.3801209628582001,
1.1922414302825928,
-0.7456644773483276,
0.06133364886045456,
0.5046026110649109,
0.25888168811798096,
0.5270271301269531,
0.8415504097938538,
0.8515844345092773,
-0.46749556064605713,
0.7640979290008545,
0.17624390125274658,
-0.30421724915504456,
-0.8307322263717651,
-0.4353625178337097,
-1.0863841772079468,
-0.2791435122489929,
-0.24445104598999023,
-0.23048393428325653,
0.24484682083129883,
0.6470724940299988,
0.9521399736404419,
-0.8291277289390564,
-0.39429494738578796,
-0.0533500500023365,
0.05115337297320366,
0.13314621150493622,
-0.27869924902915955,
0.24773766100406647,
-0.7714072465896606,
-0.6585733890533447,
0.705340564250946,
0.3328056037425995,
-0.10723167657852173,
-0.17155501246452332,
-0.3647593557834625,
-0.21111375093460083,
-0.06457946449518204,
0.786549985408783,
0.24966970086097717,
-0.697013795375824,
-0.2875460982322693,
-0.0070645976811647415,
-0.3218185603618622,
0.28101399540901184,
1.0132739543914795,
-0.7091403603553772,
0.849105954170227,
0.20048551261425018,
0.7805655598640442,
1.1005924940109253,
0.01982131600379944,
0.5664092302322388,
-0.665379524230957,
0.1865834891796112,
0.4814240634441376,
0.2616312801837921,
0.4705886244773865,
-0.41525426506996155,
0.4264404773712158,
-0.12963442504405975,
-0.7302557826042175,
-0.6586814522743225,
0.32594454288482666,
-1.0527267456054688,
-0.36503490805625916,
1.2219734191894531,
-0.014021272771060467,
0.13789871335029602,
-0.36012911796569824,
-0.4128752648830414,
-0.058596063405275345,
-0.7319488525390625,
0.7264086008071899,
0.5072525143623352,
-0.05292138829827309,
-0.3660781979560852,
-0.4305371642112732,
0.23902417719364166,
0.4847932755947113,
-0.29910632967948914,
0.10880669951438904,
0.5327634811401367,
0.30323120951652527,
-0.17602930963039398,
0.4689924418926239,
-0.021161921322345734,
0.27212023735046387,
-0.23266832530498505,
-0.16793297231197357,
0.1133783832192421,
0.029041992500424385,
-0.39690202474594116,
0.20405445992946625,
0.3791264295578003,
0.1492478996515274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13547v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13547v1
|
E-QGen: Educational Lecture Abstract-based Question Generation System
| 2024-04-21T06:03:43 | 2024-04-21T06:03:43 |
Mao-Siang Chen, An-Zi Yen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To optimize the preparation process for educators in academic lectures and
associated question-and-answer sessions, this paper presents E-QGen, a lecture
abstract-based question generation system. Given a lecture abstract, E-QGen
generates potential student inquiries. The questions suggested by our system
are expected to not only facilitate teachers in preparing answers in advance
but also enable them to supply additional resources when necessary.
|
[
-0.7020590305328369,
-0.8339305520057678,
0.5801384449005127,
-0.3454301059246063,
-0.19201388955116272,
0.16160166263580322,
0.22753684222698212,
-0.3346494734287262,
0.23844000697135925,
0.08161552995443344,
-0.7140231728553772,
-0.19828759133815765,
-0.13365332782268524,
0.4029814600944519,
-0.664763331413269,
0.7600417733192444,
0.1285993605852127,
0.2583940327167511,
-0.6769636273384094,
0.2984243631362915,
0.07443451881408691,
-0.36284616589546204,
-1.0447790622711182,
-0.280898779630661,
0.32660314440727234,
0.8603973984718323,
0.13244007527828217,
0.3022249639034271,
0.24390903115272522,
0.27443748712539673,
0.3575141429901123,
0.006833535619080067,
-0.2555459439754486,
0.36742767691612244,
-0.18058529496192932,
-0.61353999376297,
-0.2675769329071045,
-0.4014783203601837,
0.5860188603401184,
0.5988696217536926,
-0.2993195056915283,
0.32582685351371765,
-0.0873672142624855,
0.3559471070766449,
-0.714677631855011,
-0.5368034839630127,
-0.10069462656974792,
0.3258800208568573,
0.11279468238353729,
-0.6862330436706543,
-0.4416547119617462,
-0.9740986824035645,
0.18600010871887207,
-0.7090296149253845,
0.32363200187683105,
0.030599132180213928,
0.5233169198036194,
0.021781645715236664,
-0.3582468330860138,
-0.1651611328125,
-0.6741636395454407,
0.6700044870376587,
-0.20589736104011536,
0.3706134855747223,
0.19342336058616638,
0.49011898040771484,
-0.1935737431049347,
-1.0724537372589111,
-0.5348796248435974,
0.38348621129989624,
0.0126305827870965,
0.15029475092887878,
0.3556455969810486,
0.4724240303039551,
0.33233001828193665,
0.4252506196498871,
-0.8135432004928589,
-0.3433264195919037,
-0.6389450430870056,
-0.17750732600688934,
0.663785457611084,
0.3521658182144165,
0.5745058655738831,
-0.017869293689727783,
-0.31041058897972107,
-0.32438963651657104,
-0.8275015950202942,
-0.11090003699064255,
0.45992594957351685,
-0.28989744186401367,
0.29272890090942383,
0.283318430185318,
-0.350751668214798,
0.9512446522712708,
0.11141670495271683,
-0.10873661190271378,
-0.10710550844669342,
-0.1812383085489273,
0.06163296103477478,
0.6465661525726318,
0.35918527841567993,
0.5108694434165955,
-0.035870857536792755,
0.1962212473154068,
-0.10495041310787201,
0.09244988858699799,
-0.1494942158460617,
-1.2022578716278076,
-0.5108733177185059,
0.7520890235900879,
-0.3648342192173004,
-0.41504716873168945,
-0.04295309633016586,
-1.2168115377426147,
0.3008970618247986,
-0.1930432915687561,
0.6205428838729858,
-0.2783524692058563,
-0.38079267740249634,
0.048677511513233185,
-0.6339899301528931,
0.24996088445186615,
0.4797085225582123,
-0.9787563681602478,
0.33301615715026855,
0.03759864345192909,
0.32073864340782166,
0.15551027655601501,
0.1299462914466858,
-0.44504278898239136,
0.3606618046760559,
-0.0855381190776825,
1.0164015293121338,
-0.7840654850006104,
-0.9783371686935425,
0.32121753692626953,
-0.0740189403295517,
0.14690572023391724,
-0.4639432430267334,
0.42275744676589966,
-0.5963844656944275,
0.6840724945068359,
-0.16416122019290924,
-1.0603834390640259,
0.07414964586496353,
0.28114163875579834,
-0.12284236401319504,
0.9702234268188477,
0.1205761730670929,
-0.67083740234375,
0.23993416130542755,
-0.6651220917701721,
0.009833278134465218,
0.599283754825592,
-0.6216604709625244,
0.08794022351503372,
-0.3569360375404358,
0.04547157511115074,
0.06826654076576233,
-0.240339994430542,
-0.09843731671571732,
0.28536123037338257,
-0.3059810698032379,
-0.07707425951957703,
0.12963473796844482,
0.5855404734611511,
0.5350109934806824,
-0.41888269782066345,
0.05173749104142189,
-1.1581774950027466,
0.8810833096504211,
0.34363916516304016,
-0.61259925365448,
-0.5136604905128479,
0.18454448878765106,
-0.19892291724681854,
0.2005680501461029,
0.27697819471359253,
-0.8442307114601135,
0.14106829464435577,
-0.29140332341194153,
0.21321772038936615,
0.7329738140106201,
0.4180353283882141,
0.11230190843343735,
-0.2501930296421051,
0.9854932427406311,
-0.11004724353551865,
0.012985426932573318,
-0.5422565340995789,
-0.3733159601688385,
-0.6717400550842285,
0.3590051829814911,
0.2981545329093933,
0.6059641242027283,
-1.005056381225586,
-0.04399881139397621,
0.3031131625175476,
-0.3309280276298523,
-0.3602268099784851,
-0.14015275239944458,
0.411112904548645,
0.5178350210189819,
0.1574247032403946,
-0.06525208055973053,
-0.7165099382400513,
-0.7323658466339111,
0.24938133358955383,
-0.31527000665664673,
-0.17908503115177155,
0.13784678280353546,
0.38550522923469543,
0.30281150341033936,
0.8070918321609497,
-0.9621946811676025,
0.6921489238739014,
-0.153599813580513,
0.21331486105918884,
-0.44596508145332336,
0.5365442037582397,
0.6096373796463013,
-0.9500597715377808,
-0.5778416395187378,
-0.41621845960617065,
-0.5324916839599609,
-0.35766783356666565,
-0.09427671134471893,
-0.4033513069152832,
-0.17898067831993103,
0.7219117283821106,
-0.331013947725296,
0.04549049213528633,
0.13827073574066162,
-0.3995100259780884,
0.6514328718185425,
-0.18977710604667664,
0.19606055319309235,
-0.9349537491798401,
-0.03361295536160469,
-0.29509836435317993,
-0.21413809061050415,
-0.567261815071106,
0.16662341356277466,
-0.04973822087049484,
-0.39941319823265076,
-0.5884159803390503,
0.48331761360168457,
-0.0010233354987576604,
0.06440591812133789,
-0.4718995690345764,
0.7013704776763916,
0.35005486011505127,
0.18753641843795776,
-0.005508453119546175,
0.9236188530921936,
0.43996185064315796,
-1.1649587154388428,
0.512151837348938,
0.5718204379081726,
-0.15584173798561096,
0.9411729574203491,
-0.7507641911506653,
0.34361031651496887,
-0.24335172772407532,
0.16369442641735077,
-1.0263372659683228,
-0.5612319111824036,
0.21598491072654724,
-0.43331173062324524,
0.36989712715148926,
0.2517378032207489,
-0.25626662373542786,
-0.438529372215271,
-0.2602407932281494,
0.6195218563079834,
0.44302499294281006,
-0.7019267082214355,
0.07670973986387253,
0.11942771077156067,
-0.8015308976173401,
-0.37886956334114075,
-0.06932584196329117,
-0.1247711107134819,
0.21258199214935303,
-0.8314329981803894,
0.5816500186920166,
-0.25507739186286926,
-0.4165767431259155,
0.2184504270553589,
0.1403014063835144,
0.16027560830116272,
-0.15357203781604767,
-0.20383384823799133,
0.19440552592277527,
-0.2582358419895172,
0.5071303844451904,
0.5557566285133362,
0.18578623235225677,
0.3799620568752289,
-0.35779300332069397,
0.6046021580696106,
0.24629689753055573,
-0.35786697268486023,
-0.17601202428340912,
0.9867408871650696,
0.3658565580844879,
-0.08754006773233414,
0.34804975986480713,
0.17561215162277222,
-0.28303763270378113,
-0.37823620438575745,
-0.25818192958831787,
-0.5792034864425659,
-0.5363129377365112,
0.37989068031311035,
-0.10095889121294022,
-0.7638114094734192,
0.17507700622081757,
-0.3287387192249298,
0.39985913038253784,
0.4479885399341583,
0.5607481002807617,
0.06995438039302826,
1.5590919256210327,
0.5500345230102539,
0.6495147943496704,
0.4099079668521881,
-0.18047241866588593,
0.12297289073467255,
-0.6036304831504822,
-0.5752137899398804,
-0.7034448981285095,
-0.2267344743013382,
-0.37670767307281494,
0.05023513361811638,
0.33934059739112854,
-0.08267302066087723,
-0.31603437662124634,
-0.13774079084396362,
-0.9488874673843384,
0.3266753852367401,
0.8209201693534851,
-0.12202102690935135,
0.027652081102132797,
-0.3469361662864685,
-0.18932147324085236,
0.1798340529203415,
-0.8695735335350037,
-0.7949234247207642,
1.1447198390960693,
0.06897154450416565,
0.5067383050918579,
0.12367915362119675,
1.2128355503082275,
0.01158210076391697,
0.005553589668124914,
-0.4039101302623749,
0.9647253155708313,
0.535184919834137,
-0.9040163159370422,
-0.5859134197235107,
-0.15389788150787354,
-0.7521263360977173,
0.3442031741142273,
-0.12673449516296387,
-0.4199010729789734,
0.2478189617395401,
0.10821941494941711,
-0.8320250511169434,
0.35582950711250305,
-0.7165215015411377,
0.4565441608428955,
-0.340859591960907,
-0.4375409483909607,
-0.24612562358379364,
-0.6495914459228516,
0.2140783667564392,
-0.047674600034952164,
0.018647469580173492,
0.21807092428207397,
0.19508792459964752,
1.061718225479126,
-0.5294507741928101,
0.37228161096572876,
-0.4276009798049927,
0.07995646446943283,
0.9643936157226562,
-0.11464983969926834,
0.26821520924568176,
0.03085777722299099,
0.17709404230117798,
-0.9465457201004028,
0.35842084884643555,
-0.46533167362213135,
-0.42050984501838684,
0.44459107518196106,
-0.8365212678909302,
-0.9593068361282349,
-0.2831122577190399,
-0.1510991007089615,
-0.18180735409259796,
0.249718576669693,
0.6175746917724609,
0.6598990559577942,
-0.21278253197669983,
-0.12128183990716934,
1.1661391258239746,
-0.7394182682037354,
0.4609227776527405,
0.2617255449295044,
-0.42734861373901367,
-0.3324142396450043,
1.0566407442092896,
0.03592987731099129,
0.4610297679901123,
0.3373342752456665,
0.11703367531299591,
-0.40553343296051025,
-0.39329126477241516,
-0.697451114654541,
-0.16176556050777435,
-0.8956183791160583,
-0.13717037439346313,
-0.8131821751594543,
-0.322128564119339,
-0.5041681528091431,
-0.23364363610744476,
0.24846673011779785,
-0.8700196743011475,
-0.1872771978378296,
-0.653225839138031,
0.3219364881515503,
0.49494248628616333,
-0.23712611198425293,
0.20713888108730316,
-1.0342472791671753,
0.07424581795930862,
1.1588637828826904,
0.05041690170764923,
-0.2531510889530182,
-0.18859617412090302,
-0.07459224760532379,
0.01677711308002472,
-1.0801947116851807,
-1.017828345298767,
0.1592678725719452,
0.6423903107643127,
0.6511370539665222,
0.6509745717048645,
0.3117344081401825,
0.01497937086969614,
-0.4018959403038025,
1.0989103317260742,
0.3929561376571655,
-0.4847992956638336,
1.0517634153366089,
-0.34581995010375977,
0.11061606556177139,
0.37246719002723694,
0.45208102464675903,
-0.2693953812122345,
-0.6126009821891785,
-0.8972049355506897,
-1.1887294054031372,
0.6140895485877991,
-0.006754752714186907,
0.09796075522899628,
-0.21440356969833374,
0.24583159387111664,
0.1634293794631958,
0.44858109951019287,
-0.2900331914424896,
-0.5493045449256897,
-0.5235386490821838,
-0.05042894184589386,
0.1962715983390808,
-0.359561562538147,
-0.34644702076911926,
-0.2570554316043854,
0.6847679615020752,
0.20553669333457947,
0.4684201180934906,
0.568936288356781,
0.22863933444023132,
-0.5705597400665283,
0.7060258984565735,
1.1332210302352905,
0.5953673720359802,
-0.46110671758651733,
0.015508294105529785,
0.00871557742357254,
-0.5869629979133606,
0.6088885068893433,
-0.18103821575641632,
-0.07900242507457733,
0.4175955355167389,
-0.42286360263824463,
0.25838977098464966,
0.037871357053518295,
-0.8282460570335388,
0.23646582663059235,
-0.16558559238910675,
-0.7664275765419006,
-0.5960671901702881,
0.4909835755825043,
-0.12204098701477051,
-0.06952035427093506,
0.6702851057052612,
-0.5327683091163635,
0.25742533802986145,
-0.568203866481781,
0.5602772831916809,
-0.10089919716119766,
-0.039878759533166885,
-0.03480168804526329,
1.0458849668502808,
0.7083402276039124,
-0.4838656485080719,
0.6803508400917053,
-0.23058490455150604,
-0.6909803152084351,
0.7193769216537476,
0.7184515595436096,
0.6716648936271667,
-0.5927151441574097,
0.6099885702133179,
0.8372135162353516,
-0.27734261751174927,
0.12380155920982361,
0.9165599346160889,
0.005998553708195686,
-0.5858846306800842,
-0.2959538400173187,
-0.4628128409385681,
-0.9743149876594543,
-0.03645968809723854,
-0.7587702870368958,
0.2353152483701706,
-0.6967938542366028,
-0.2506498694419861,
-0.024802712723612785,
-0.19767840206623077,
-0.2984062731266022,
0.682060956954956,
0.11843004077672958,
1.0351015329360962,
-0.7804002165794373,
0.5090410113334656,
1.0680991411209106,
-0.17835912108421326,
-0.6954859495162964,
-0.48029565811157227,
-0.19580483436584473,
-0.270090252161026,
0.9182485342025757,
-0.23984083533287048,
-0.04192367568612099,
0.4232272505760193,
-0.5435632467269897,
-0.7113505601882935,
1.0186229944229126,
-0.09561704099178314,
-0.5854752659797668,
-0.040294352918863297,
0.07320600003004074,
0.3191167116165161,
-0.32438963651657104,
0.16454549133777618,
0.32134053111076355,
0.5130909085273743,
0.18836642801761627,
-0.202058807015419,
-0.08328632265329361,
-0.622576117515564,
-0.39957574009895325,
0.7710913419723511,
-0.519513726234436,
0.822024941444397,
-0.19784201681613922,
-0.12434163689613342,
-0.1429864913225174,
0.5186472535133362,
0.3468577563762665,
0.5480566024780273,
0.32399147748947144,
0.594041109085083,
0.816342830657959,
-0.24150899052619934,
0.9848679304122925,
-0.6101596355438232,
0.014022418297827244,
0.6119875311851501,
0.049300745129585266,
0.5668326616287231,
0.6693920493125916,
-0.29099956154823303,
0.5999564528465271,
1.0200878381729126,
-0.002573940670117736,
0.733628511428833,
0.38160741329193115,
-0.8843045830726624,
-0.4597267806529999,
-0.1620500236749649,
-0.9283703565597534,
-0.0027650517877191305,
0.5928041934967041,
-0.048012830317020416,
-0.21862736344337463,
0.09113093465566635,
-0.37435147166252136,
-0.04947049915790558,
-0.5151352286338806,
0.5045690536499023,
0.1811853051185608,
-0.8091128468513489,
0.18458156287670135,
0.09109536558389664,
0.2451445609331131,
-0.32819774746894836,
-0.2665441334247589,
0.048331473022699356,
-0.17397229373455048,
-0.44101208448410034,
-0.4393550157546997,
-0.08072152733802795,
-0.13038448989391327,
0.019043320789933205,
-0.06482131779193878,
0.8608791828155518,
-0.4930557608604431,
-0.21924848854541779,
-0.46175330877304077,
0.6174936890602112,
0.1535266488790512,
0.5539063215255737,
-0.4590681493282318,
-0.5540045499801636,
0.008298218250274658,
-0.25598400831222534,
0.5616896152496338,
0.30015167593955994,
0.29180940985679626,
0.5435753464698792,
0.35767674446105957,
0.010756653733551502,
0.39267587661743164,
-0.21621090173721313,
0.7545219659805298,
-0.4399358630180359,
-0.7115002870559692,
-0.3167916238307953,
0.5869390368461609,
-0.22483476996421814,
-0.3947223722934723,
0.531365692615509,
0.48334479331970215,
1.0417331457138062,
-0.045008182525634766,
1.3763340711593628,
-0.20542705059051514,
0.7588748931884766,
-0.31465378403663635,
0.3491404056549072,
-0.6186660528182983,
-0.0920034795999527,
-0.37986817955970764,
-0.9088469743728638,
0.34564918279647827,
0.7285871505737305,
-0.16389895975589752,
0.05283243954181671,
0.852670431137085,
0.44999825954437256,
0.45773452520370483,
0.5157331824302673,
0.4040316641330719,
-0.47085461020469666,
0.3184259235858917,
0.6077262759208679,
1.2645013332366943,
-0.5095535516738892,
0.5440008640289307,
-0.38563042879104614,
0.007014046423137188,
-0.5237671136856079,
-0.375815212726593,
-0.7348741888999939,
-0.5444173812866211,
-0.7481111884117126,
-0.09754475951194763,
0.008195445872843266,
1.2142977714538574,
0.1914215236902237,
-0.804991602897644,
-0.05914681404829025,
-0.21621257066726685,
-0.0366407074034214,
0.20334288477897644,
-0.2486715465784073,
0.4129496216773987,
-0.33454960584640503,
-0.7508330345153809,
-0.009743349626660347,
-0.09448251873254776,
0.509453535079956,
-0.21563006937503815,
0.04426521435379982,
-0.04401617869734764,
0.34058305621147156,
0.6220672726631165,
0.5312476754188538,
0.04797941446304321,
-0.4621165692806244,
0.17636075615882874,
-0.1230679377913475,
-0.08801020681858063,
0.8558057546615601,
-0.4256819784641266,
0.4841008186340332,
0.6164034605026245,
0.5134403705596924,
0.14594121277332306,
0.032657042145729065,
0.8584527969360352,
-0.7043668031692505,
0.09615790843963623,
0.557651937007904,
0.17039626836776733,
0.02732672728598118,
-0.46694216132164,
0.25841373205184937,
0.02985638752579689,
-0.9008600115776062,
-0.8646798729896545,
0.22956565022468567,
-0.4018274247646332,
-0.40822622179985046,
0.939567506313324,
-0.1124412789940834,
0.08436807990074158,
-0.47718849778175354,
-0.4595266580581665,
0.1960110068321228,
-0.07392026484012604,
0.9346869587898254,
0.6328979730606079,
-0.4270535111427307,
-0.3116876780986786,
-0.7723388075828552,
0.5941682457923889,
0.509864091873169,
-0.8426427245140076,
-0.6758917570114136,
0.2635771334171295,
0.06425412744283676,
0.1649659276008606,
0.6214210391044617,
-0.18095356225967407,
0.8298317790031433,
0.296779990196228,
0.40051308274269104,
0.07899150252342224,
-0.3193461298942566,
0.38847771286964417,
0.574843168258667,
0.14745651185512543,
-0.5378825068473816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13530v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13530v1
|
Listen Then See: Video Alignment with Speaker Attention
| 2024-04-21T04:55:13 | 2024-04-21T04:55:13 |
Aviral Agrawal, Carlos Mateo Samudio Lezcano, Iqui Balam Heredia-Marin, Prabhdeep Singh Sethi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Video-based Question Answering (Video QA) is a challenging task and becomes
even more intricate when addressing Socially Intelligent Question Answering
(SIQA). SIQA requires context understanding, temporal reasoning, and the
integration of multimodal information, but in addition, it requires processing
nuanced human behavior. Furthermore, the complexities involved are exacerbated
by the dominance of the primary modality (text) over the others. Thus, there is
a need to help the task's secondary modalities to work in tandem with the
primary modality. In this work, we introduce a cross-modal alignment and
subsequent representation fusion approach that achieves state-of-the-art
results (82.06\% accuracy) on the Social IQ 2.0 dataset for SIQA. Our approach
exhibits an improved ability to leverage the video modality by using the audio
modality as a bridge with the language modality. This leads to enhanced
performance by reducing the prevalent issue of language overfitting and
resultant video modality bypassing encountered by current existing techniques.
Our code and models are publicly available at
https://github.com/sts-vlcc/sts-vlcc
|
[
-0.41045013070106506,
-0.6583564877510071,
0.5329362750053406,
-0.0018774273339658976,
-0.3215081989765167,
0.28158122301101685,
-0.10033965110778809,
-0.20036804676055908,
0.3672265112400055,
0.29085615277290344,
-0.6718555688858032,
-0.26153621077537537,
-0.6540433168411255,
-0.43513983488082886,
-0.3109671473503113,
0.6173611879348755,
0.15595877170562744,
0.4304043650627136,
-0.3728695809841156,
-0.34086111187934875,
-0.7569426894187927,
-0.011108067817986012,
-0.3889368176460266,
-0.0750337764620781,
0.29424920678138733,
0.6424403786659241,
0.8594602942466736,
0.5301893949508667,
0.2832852303981781,
0.29352349042892456,
0.12813584506511688,
0.21293817460536957,
-0.4672858417034149,
-0.06864399462938309,
-0.4115314185619354,
0.037864767014980316,
-0.32680124044418335,
-0.2698177993297577,
0.8597403168678284,
0.4548532962799072,
0.15629811584949493,
0.5146003365516663,
-0.07499519735574722,
0.49833542108535767,
-0.542213499546051,
-0.07582785189151764,
-0.8183758854866028,
-0.15849967300891876,
0.09407804906368256,
-0.4498084783554077,
-0.32387709617614746,
-0.0655723512172699,
0.13099850714206696,
-0.5679448843002319,
-0.21535353362560272,
-0.04794555529952049,
0.7388812899589539,
0.8732208013534546,
-0.7007502913475037,
0.31943225860595703,
-1.0163681507110596,
0.5799999237060547,
-0.47904300689697266,
0.9279254078865051,
0.29061684012413025,
0.6692942976951599,
0.1579887717962265,
-0.285297691822052,
-0.8005185127258301,
0.3333760201931,
0.1720203012228012,
0.12713970243930817,
0.017151154577732086,
-0.004289798904210329,
0.2945524752140045,
0.24162687361240387,
-0.8517548441886902,
-0.1563282012939453,
-0.5221985578536987,
-0.2992880046367645,
0.7321746945381165,
0.011460387147963047,
0.5549066662788391,
-0.2621285617351532,
-0.5561339259147644,
-0.19826006889343262,
-0.31945571303367615,
0.2737886309623718,
0.12089942395687103,
0.0009496554848738015,
-0.018096202984452248,
0.8021064400672913,
-0.29085543751716614,
0.37228888273239136,
0.2798454165458679,
-0.09570714831352234,
0.3927428126335144,
-0.7913525104522705,
-0.3479800820350647,
0.274930477142334,
0.6205370426177979,
0.5696791410446167,
0.04595813900232315,
0.058931246399879456,
0.302929550409317,
0.1579100638628006,
0.26567021012306213,
-0.3885771334171295,
-0.06397823989391327,
0.2257726937532425,
-0.31529465317726135,
0.2639378011226654,
0.029986649751663208,
-0.6090329885482788,
-0.24359925091266632,
-0.40741443634033203,
0.883516252040863,
-0.4260063171386719,
-0.4403667747974396,
0.008524920791387558,
-0.020460719242691994,
0.7287711501121521,
0.34054726362228394,
-0.8005194067955017,
0.2747165858745575,
0.6726484894752502,
0.4313737154006958,
0.15980397164821625,
-0.034443698823451996,
-1.0053441524505615,
0.5967203378677368,
-0.056797999888658524,
0.6304680705070496,
-0.6119484901428223,
-0.027497872710227966,
-0.10368402302265167,
0.1531350016593933,
-0.2566656768321991,
-0.18350814282894135,
0.3418070375919342,
-0.6105925440788269,
0.5068652033805847,
-0.46965283155441284,
-0.32337889075279236,
-0.19618293642997742,
0.09515686333179474,
-0.603493869304657,
1.1460702419281006,
0.022101465612649918,
-0.6214079856872559,
0.24665319919586182,
-0.23600758612155914,
-0.23716701567173004,
0.01634278893470764,
-0.5894516110420227,
-0.25437647104263306,
-0.3454054296016693,
0.4539285898208618,
0.1293531060218811,
-0.24177180230617523,
0.2432146817445755,
-0.07098376005887985,
-0.49893394112586975,
0.14289584755897522,
-0.21333128213882446,
0.4155580699443817,
-0.1403869092464447,
-0.7610607147216797,
0.2751345932483673,
-0.512243390083313,
0.11881579458713531,
-0.2001718431711197,
0.2310553342103958,
-0.3257094919681549,
0.04281027987599373,
0.07677414268255234,
0.5292354822158813,
0.15442192554473877,
-0.6145603060722351,
-0.38544732332229614,
-0.38797134160995483,
0.2941954731941223,
0.7851521968841553,
-0.2074812948703766,
0.5518990159034729,
-0.150229811668396,
0.5317280888557434,
-0.0938994362950325,
0.11304497718811035,
0.07920176535844803,
-0.4657118022441864,
-0.2697283625602722,
-0.20433451235294342,
0.13733038306236267,
0.8135877251625061,
-1.0593417882919312,
0.10338587313890457,
-0.4864549934864044,
-0.4938012659549713,
-0.9381836652755737,
0.38833120465278625,
0.6495212912559509,
0.3844466805458069,
0.45221802592277527,
-0.36912772059440613,
-0.5669848322868347,
-1.0665175914764404,
-0.14083337783813477,
-0.5552216172218323,
-0.09856214374303818,
0.5886000394821167,
-0.10221787542104721,
-0.15330269932746887,
0.7803796529769897,
-0.31885191798210144,
-0.21989290416240692,
-0.11008498072624207,
-0.05382696911692619,
-0.13662192225456238,
0.5195552706718445,
0.25767800211906433,
-1.3501582145690918,
-0.44788047671318054,
0.19029226899147034,
-0.5203602313995361,
-0.038084980100393295,
-0.28071868419647217,
-0.42512667179107666,
0.0438813753426075,
0.7043171525001526,
-0.5177765488624573,
0.33194130659103394,
0.41630256175994873,
-0.39718684554100037,
0.02026233822107315,
0.3123461902141571,
0.6086090803146362,
-1.154746174812317,
-0.06702768057584763,
-0.02441754750907421,
-0.26523637771606445,
-0.48304107785224915,
-0.4240587055683136,
-0.10479599982500076,
-0.2476731240749359,
-0.7148692607879639,
0.38781842589378357,
-0.3151606023311615,
-0.5279934406280518,
-0.037862326949834824,
0.507717490196228,
0.05429799109697342,
0.6945514678955078,
0.022758187726140022,
0.8725303411483765,
0.4427247643470764,
-0.17248810827732086,
0.5207659006118774,
0.4984331429004669,
-0.11656056344509125,
0.6168275475502014,
-0.8256962299346924,
0.1486785113811493,
-0.31107786297798157,
0.031180163845419884,
-1.4553008079528809,
-0.3886176347732544,
0.41662225127220154,
-0.8769519925117493,
0.35461774468421936,
0.12943382561206818,
-0.0925188884139061,
-0.01790670119225979,
-0.40813618898391724,
0.9524999260902405,
0.4189085364341736,
-0.321423202753067,
0.9036843776702881,
0.7279345989227295,
-0.4429018199443817,
-0.5552746057510376,
-0.5073054432868958,
-0.0719894990324974,
-0.07654488831758499,
-1.0391227006912231,
0.5767565965652466,
-0.26821303367614746,
-0.19222113490104675,
-0.01981123723089695,
-0.3061019778251648,
-0.015413633547723293,
-0.3171723186969757,
0.2666809856891632,
0.24200661480426788,
-0.4371599555015564,
0.2852936387062073,
0.2521120011806488,
-0.10518096387386322,
-0.03903656452894211,
0.05747794732451439,
0.4308678209781647,
-0.050942178815603256,
-0.476925790309906,
-0.7515032291412354,
0.9238150119781494,
0.7638486623764038,
-0.4442478120326996,
0.5403455495834351,
0.8409807682037354,
-0.4808840751647949,
0.360397607088089,
-0.7807108163833618,
-0.1248994693160057,
-0.44831642508506775,
0.5768604278564453,
-0.1726050227880478,
-1.0032368898391724,
0.3069379925727844,
0.26515379548072815,
-0.07811670005321503,
0.09569095820188522,
0.5580572485923767,
-0.11718819290399551,
1.4875093698501587,
0.5780177116394043,
0.11510488390922546,
0.7284706830978394,
0.18443092703819275,
0.48906323313713074,
-0.7255122065544128,
-0.5774078369140625,
-0.23002220690250397,
-0.307512104511261,
-0.3537992537021637,
-0.6350775361061096,
0.5264110565185547,
-0.2439144402742386,
-0.20650523900985718,
0.3906107544898987,
-0.3395777940750122,
0.40096426010131836,
0.4413754642009735,
0.23593629896640778,
0.04649558663368225,
-0.009236743673682213,
0.6161441802978516,
-0.41790106892585754,
-0.642768144607544,
-0.3230847418308258,
0.5257984399795532,
0.4248986840248108,
0.6622949242591858,
0.4642602503299713,
0.3643684387207031,
0.38520359992980957,
-0.31960007548332214,
-0.6594718098640442,
0.8509101271629333,
0.023499399423599243,
-0.3738388419151306,
-0.5776254534721375,
-0.16597038507461548,
-0.4884707033634186,
0.18977141380310059,
-0.1583210676908493,
-0.750725269317627,
0.27735981345176697,
0.20415931940078735,
-0.6082983613014221,
0.00655463756993413,
-0.8690502643585205,
1.1473548412322998,
-0.1622413694858551,
-0.46981674432754517,
-0.44051268696784973,
-1.051927089691162,
0.23161520063877106,
0.32979249954223633,
0.32308077812194824,
0.04300282150506973,
0.03895979002118111,
0.6379075050354004,
-0.11443502455949783,
0.6309077739715576,
-0.02638971246778965,
0.09570804983377457,
0.28038936853408813,
-0.21707747876644135,
0.2478220909833908,
0.2455078512430191,
0.264308899641037,
-0.40369173884391785,
0.22430798411369324,
-0.6105626225471497,
-0.9034053683280945,
0.5882871150970459,
-0.8539642691612244,
-0.9025286436080933,
-0.20577634871006012,
-0.5352650880813599,
-0.4942989945411682,
-0.08055081218481064,
-0.13626481592655182,
0.45681852102279663,
-0.011414771899580956,
0.36735787987709045,
1.0461680889129639,
-0.09356315433979034,
0.17874430119991302,
0.2319156974554062,
0.07592342793941498,
-0.6135674715042114,
1.0717509984970093,
0.09222552180290222,
0.530661940574646,
0.38400787115097046,
-0.23136402666568756,
-0.21978607773780823,
-0.3143623173236847,
-0.6854070425033569,
0.2585733234882355,
-0.655922532081604,
-0.06505080312490463,
-0.872020423412323,
-0.3238224387168884,
-1.0334222316741943,
-0.09488746523857117,
-0.24947047233581543,
-0.367853581905365,
-0.11812702566385269,
-0.37658798694610596,
0.2452578991651535,
0.15153838694095612,
-0.05323956161737442,
0.30223608016967773,
-0.9366212487220764,
0.5595624446868896,
0.8264989852905273,
0.01845233514904976,
-0.3796182870864868,
-0.5434678792953491,
-0.2990957200527191,
0.0870586633682251,
-0.12857496738433838,
-1.1770150661468506,
-0.0022066840901970863,
0.4041154980659485,
0.706269383430481,
0.0967755988240242,
0.018877100199460983,
0.7795084714889526,
-0.334256649017334,
0.9680086970329285,
0.1120552122592926,
-1.030656337738037,
0.7679745554924011,
-0.28085657954216003,
0.4944203197956085,
0.810375452041626,
0.46068739891052246,
-0.6559401750564575,
-0.24944260716438293,
-0.5783945322036743,
-1.04324471950531,
0.5678710341453552,
0.0747433751821518,
0.08802933245897293,
0.17135503888130188,
-0.11621780693531036,
0.03544803708791733,
0.11527948826551437,
-0.5684835314750671,
0.09850682318210602,
-0.3803809583187103,
-0.34719592332839966,
0.18010295927524567,
-0.21334795653820038,
-0.21911485493183136,
-0.2834071218967438,
1.0594098567962646,
-0.43219828605651855,
0.10456296056509018,
0.39714962244033813,
-0.2508561611175537,
-0.39991655945777893,
0.22369439899921417,
0.49413353204727173,
0.5949382781982422,
0.003895152360200882,
0.02213815413415432,
0.2218298763036728,
-0.25097760558128357,
-0.025499368086457253,
0.139250710606575,
-0.08976803719997406,
0.05265933275222778,
0.19240228831768036,
0.7071821093559265,
0.35714685916900635,
-1.0255016088485718,
0.6533433198928833,
-0.10023370385169983,
0.05151832476258278,
-0.3501173257827759,
0.015455866232514381,
-0.029200410470366478,
0.7446700930595398,
0.33744341135025024,
-0.01926429569721222,
0.32745617628097534,
-0.7250413298606873,
0.4352755546569824,
0.5636275410652161,
-0.7076917290687561,
-0.20186108350753784,
0.7026667594909668,
0.2040298879146576,
-0.4907377362251282,
0.22290575504302979,
0.21961718797683716,
-0.6533549427986145,
0.48558104038238525,
0.18981516361236572,
0.7815605998039246,
-0.29252469539642334,
0.5644749402999878,
0.25731348991394043,
0.18717297911643982,
0.32677677273750305,
0.6566740274429321,
-0.47594326734542847,
-0.5130342841148376,
-0.7210750579833984,
-0.1330430656671524,
-0.3259071409702301,
-0.21658876538276672,
-0.7155038714408875,
0.25975894927978516,
-0.3809647858142853,
-0.06819995492696762,
0.10455773770809174,
-0.20092178881168365,
-0.3674464523792267,
0.35565754771232605,
0.6131830811500549,
0.566662073135376,
-1.1139886379241943,
0.7559954524040222,
0.8432980179786682,
-0.35985082387924194,
-1.052964687347412,
-0.008597422391176224,
0.1775151938199997,
-0.584502100944519,
0.36804667115211487,
0.12439379096031189,
-0.3266110420227051,
-0.16507577896118164,
-0.5625423192977905,
-1.1115257740020752,
1.2744641304016113,
0.41521644592285156,
-0.3471274971961975,
-0.07071404159069061,
0.15431572496891022,
0.43178701400756836,
-0.37862056493759155,
0.2681260108947754,
0.4070162773132324,
0.3028375804424286,
0.45531412959098816,
-1.0418795347213745,
0.03616899251937866,
-0.6223695874214172,
-0.03918970748782158,
0.21422356367111206,
-0.8340017199516296,
0.20915330946445465,
-0.08046802133321762,
-0.29255643486976624,
-0.21083825826644897,
1.0072344541549683,
0.19490177929401398,
0.6918795704841614,
0.7224514484405518,
0.28549206256866455,
0.34714195132255554,
0.06267648935317993,
0.4718635678291321,
-0.025327976793050766,
-0.124482661485672,
1.331820011138916,
-0.33611607551574707,
0.7587824463844299,
1.0179238319396973,
-0.03281998634338379,
0.37308016419410706,
0.6420510411262512,
0.3833707869052887,
0.5537431836128235,
-0.3130485713481903,
-0.19947195053100586,
-0.9208360910415649,
-0.6724433302879333,
-0.5433299541473389,
0.5292238593101501,
0.08144475519657135,
-0.1755722165107727,
0.07018348574638367,
0.1955040544271469,
-0.3820129632949829,
0.5205095410346985,
-0.38266775012016296,
0.8735404014587402,
-0.10715591162443161,
-0.691897988319397,
0.24499393999576569,
-0.6035760641098022,
0.32229968905448914,
-0.440328449010849,
-0.2375132441520691,
0.13957500457763672,
-0.1575470119714737,
-0.3284419775009155,
-0.737785279750824,
0.4351716637611389,
-0.19917206466197968,
-0.4544309377670288,
-0.1799885481595993,
0.6082754135131836,
-0.9208899140357971,
-0.2861427962779999,
0.4097651243209839,
0.3407277762889862,
-0.07106634974479675,
0.21101751923561096,
-0.4050098955631256,
0.2095535397529602,
0.1566363126039505,
0.07073739916086197,
0.11041945219039917,
0.4264286756515503,
-0.23321345448493958,
0.35793596506118774,
0.3386104702949524,
-0.4289287328720093,
0.09165392071008682,
0.13223987817764282,
1.0465610027313232,
-0.5804817080497742,
-0.47001057863235474,
-0.5426408648490906,
0.789267361164093,
-0.24488912522792816,
-0.29853808879852295,
0.6017168164253235,
0.4553023874759674,
1.082592248916626,
0.20762409269809723,
0.4645595848560333,
-0.09137219190597534,
0.5219460129737854,
-0.514680027961731,
0.19634081423282623,
-0.7776762247085571,
0.18158620595932007,
-0.6157112121582031,
-0.8601270914077759,
-0.09444011002779007,
0.20360977947711945,
-0.413291335105896,
-0.3559407889842987,
0.4542774260044098,
0.960267186164856,
0.004015727899968624,
0.1797226518392563,
0.34206998348236084,
0.024624980986118317,
0.18029752373695374,
0.7077592611312866,
0.8130807876586914,
-0.8126193284988403,
0.8847257494926453,
-0.15894795954227448,
-0.26173514127731323,
-0.15044952929019928,
-0.4978730082511902,
-0.6005538702011108,
-0.7604652643203735,
-0.6385252475738525,
-0.46141505241394043,
0.18525001406669617,
1.1365512609481812,
0.6039116382598877,
-0.6017602682113647,
0.06588716059923172,
0.5990754961967468,
0.1540762037038803,
-0.31431844830513,
-0.20558296144008636,
0.2957645058631897,
0.2982524335384369,
-0.6428416967391968,
0.5340349674224854,
0.4968172311782837,
-0.18269678950309753,
-0.2579192519187927,
-0.23387634754180908,
-0.5624485611915588,
0.16280630230903625,
0.5065957903862,
0.49050548672676086,
-0.6284205317497253,
-0.8211256861686707,
0.39147597551345825,
-0.12868736684322357,
0.0959615632891655,
0.709150493144989,
-0.7787430286407471,
0.5074785947799683,
1.0106757879257202,
1.0836666822433472,
0.48316845297813416,
0.2601451575756073,
0.8270451426506042,
-0.44964003562927246,
-0.014563401229679585,
0.34892913699150085,
0.23987363278865814,
0.5422161817550659,
-0.5195765495300293,
0.31715869903564453,
0.20402498543262482,
-0.5032310485839844,
-0.8822782635688782,
0.3256072998046875,
-1.5704954862594604,
0.06184905394911766,
1.1483889818191528,
0.2453736960887909,
-0.4443907141685486,
-0.19259899854660034,
-0.6373897790908813,
0.4891708493232727,
-0.3560173809528351,
0.533198893070221,
0.5215024948120117,
0.10395839065313339,
-0.5822069048881531,
-0.35700923204421997,
0.2412375956773758,
1.2275941371917725,
-0.4891915023326874,
-0.26858171820640564,
0.5119468569755554,
0.03410880267620087,
0.20286375284194946,
0.7566381096839905,
-0.19363094866275787,
0.9821994304656982,
-0.3264921307563782,
-0.17468823492527008,
0.20013880729675293,
-0.35893192887306213,
-0.268134206533432,
0.10104004293680191,
-0.3235395848751068,
-0.4659115970134735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14453v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14453v1
|
EPI-SQL: Enhancing Text-to-SQL Translation with Error-Prevention Instructions
| 2024-04-21T03:52:46 | 2024-04-21T03:52:46 |
Xiping Liu, Zhao Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB
|
The conversion of natural language queries into SQL queries, known as
Text-to-SQL, is a critical yet challenging task. This paper introduces EPI-SQL,
a novel methodological framework leveraging Large Language Models (LLMs) to
enhance the performance of Text-to-SQL tasks. EPI-SQL operates through a
four-step process. Initially, the method involves gathering instances from the
Spider dataset on which LLMs are prone to failure. These instances are then
utilized to generate general error-prevention instructions (EPIs).
Subsequently, LLMs craft contextualized EPIs tailored to the specific context
of the current task. Finally, these context-specific EPIs are incorporated into
the prompt used for SQL generation. EPI-SQL is distinguished in that it
provides task-specific guidance, enabling the model to circumvent potential
errors for the task at hand. Notably, the methodology rivals the performance of
advanced few-shot methods despite being a zero-shot approach. An empirical
assessment using the Spider benchmark reveals that EPI-SQL achieves an
execution accuracy of 85.1\%, underscoring its effectiveness in generating
accurate SQL queries through LLMs. The findings indicate a promising direction
for future research, i.e. enhancing instructions with task-specific and
contextualized rules, for boosting LLMs' performance in NLP tasks.
|
[
0.017560986801981926,
-0.9040600657463074,
0.6568325757980347,
0.3175011873245239,
-0.2766284942626953,
-0.21826054155826569,
-0.25316953659057617,
-0.13888970017433167,
0.25603187084198,
0.725346028804779,
-0.542656660079956,
-0.7562341094017029,
-0.2860415279865265,
0.49846044182777405,
-0.47577905654907227,
0.967329740524292,
0.09554006904363632,
0.1547400951385498,
-0.26707208156585693,
0.13156338036060333,
-0.2864670753479004,
-0.7233104109764099,
-0.5284334421157837,
0.18009725213050842,
0.3511624038219452,
0.4444710314273834,
0.28841108083724976,
0.6197560429573059,
0.49644771218299866,
0.1564587652683258,
-0.072714664041996,
0.5325016379356384,
-0.5008131861686707,
0.12935946881771088,
-0.3339065909385681,
-1.1054096221923828,
-0.5288403034210205,
-0.5079749822616577,
0.5167401432991028,
0.7622214555740356,
-0.5251478552818298,
-0.14183804392814636,
0.021522045135498047,
0.8207172155380249,
-0.6839943528175354,
-0.06705012172460556,
-0.7461452484130859,
0.08356789499521255,
-0.3031015694141388,
-0.6249008178710938,
-0.8001638650894165,
-0.17554651200771332,
-0.17639605700969696,
-0.452876478433609,
0.1026700809597969,
0.3121049106121063,
0.7086374759674072,
0.1836298257112503,
-0.436730295419693,
-0.18918554484844208,
-0.7269454002380371,
0.8721629977226257,
-0.8331573605537415,
0.11601182073354721,
0.419577032327652,
0.2545025050640106,
-0.5794984698295593,
-0.4429248571395874,
-0.5115050077438354,
-0.03619294986128807,
-0.14325439929962158,
0.00618565222248435,
0.04521581903100014,
0.15278762578964233,
0.2406672090291977,
-0.012899122200906277,
-0.47670817375183105,
0.06287113577127457,
-0.023752378299832344,
0.23390312492847443,
0.5146613121032715,
0.35799503326416016,
0.393208771944046,
0.00663394620642066,
-0.1829657256603241,
0.28047531843185425,
-1.1018038988113403,
-0.37733572721481323,
0.10298437625169754,
0.6072339415550232,
0.01831655576825142,
0.9178256988525391,
-0.4556310474872589,
1.039738655090332,
-0.040660955011844635,
0.039486031979322433,
-0.06469905376434326,
-0.5275607109069824,
-0.15139882266521454,
0.11213844269514084,
0.5917572379112244,
0.5042175054550171,
0.04394253343343735,
-0.4793911278247833,
-0.255837082862854,
-0.03652506694197655,
0.26329725980758667,
-0.7741096019744873,
0.14005699753761292,
0.47851231694221497,
-0.3179270327091217,
-0.24371060729026794,
-0.18418589234352112,
-0.8768479228019714,
-0.3489496409893036,
-0.2554621994495392,
0.26559239625930786,
-0.47141358256340027,
-0.17816758155822754,
-0.14768049120903015,
0.08118831366300583,
0.5116129517555237,
0.38304203748703003,
-0.578986406326294,
0.5481031537055969,
0.7810017466545105,
0.8901587724685669,
-0.44557759165763855,
-0.12342623621225357,
-0.5171841979026794,
0.8243818283081055,
-0.517509400844574,
0.8217986822128296,
-0.5534062385559082,
-0.33630430698394775,
0.09010583907365799,
0.09157926589250565,
-0.13676699995994568,
-0.4160926938056946,
0.6786431670188904,
-0.2898857891559601,
0.2457558661699295,
-0.13043862581253052,
-0.7945699095726013,
-0.007468538358807564,
0.23298878967761993,
-0.3868536353111267,
0.8753548264503479,
-0.1550900638103485,
-0.5175282955169678,
0.37805482745170593,
-0.9836068749427795,
-0.613608181476593,
0.050654083490371704,
-0.12484709173440933,
-0.32636556029319763,
0.4152251183986664,
0.2062007635831833,
0.4633858799934387,
-0.686863362789154,
-0.03536396846175194,
-0.09843505173921585,
-0.41215780377388,
0.07672832161188126,
-0.07428990304470062,
0.6141179203987122,
0.07347565144300461,
-0.38876646757125854,
-0.050620175898075104,
-0.7509844303131104,
0.2260299175977707,
0.2381383776664734,
-0.26840201020240784,
-0.4197036921977997,
0.37631529569625854,
-0.10734293609857559,
0.03926627337932587,
0.045854274183511734,
-0.5634751319885254,
-0.15587662160396576,
-0.7389203906059265,
0.41111963987350464,
0.31514298915863037,
-0.05687617510557175,
0.4550684094429016,
-0.141807422041893,
0.1825563758611679,
0.044146135449409485,
0.0720151886343956,
-0.4545792043209076,
-0.4902133047580719,
-0.8277920484542847,
-0.07945652306079865,
0.11416427791118622,
1.0888967514038086,
-0.7009651064872742,
0.72616046667099,
-0.28151077032089233,
-0.4261794984340668,
-0.20781195163726807,
-0.022953135892748833,
0.3406442403793335,
0.15544652938842773,
0.4373661279678345,
-0.10829640924930573,
-0.516303539276123,
-0.7598084807395935,
-0.6189894080162048,
-0.1925535947084427,
-0.1784629374742508,
0.3867013156414032,
0.40307921171188354,
0.09014781564474106,
0.7851549386978149,
-0.4595027565956116,
-0.44155335426330566,
-0.2038331776857376,
0.0499165803194046,
0.34127286076545715,
0.531020998954773,
0.2681257724761963,
-0.6585320830345154,
-0.6020724773406982,
0.17522920668125153,
-0.7476866245269775,
-0.08385345339775085,
-0.2577486038208008,
-0.2878844141960144,
0.6681515574455261,
0.2982541024684906,
-0.569195032119751,
0.4925048351287842,
0.21440251171588898,
-0.5075988173484802,
0.4306665062904358,
-0.3130366802215576,
0.4215596318244934,
-1.2295737266540527,
0.008093388751149178,
0.26033228635787964,
-0.2176833152770996,
-0.8357734084129333,
0.1808462142944336,
-0.030353231355547905,
-0.12644062936306,
-0.4063010811805725,
-0.02951424941420555,
-0.5651763677597046,
0.09163165837526321,
-0.09856321662664413,
-0.07589229941368103,
-0.0988152027130127,
0.36967501044273376,
0.06871876865625381,
0.8654858469963074,
0.3745281994342804,
-0.7780535221099854,
0.2241729497909546,
0.24456384778022766,
-0.008713623508810997,
0.9751797318458557,
-0.712523341178894,
0.39011475443840027,
-0.0479743555188179,
-0.032266903668642044,
-0.954937219619751,
-0.2962352931499481,
0.0319729819893837,
-0.4678998291492462,
0.46479374170303345,
-0.2911672592163086,
-0.5916100144386292,
0.05830693617463112,
-0.20562420785427094,
-0.18131858110427856,
0.36088088154792786,
-0.43204015493392944,
0.8420847654342651,
0.40643763542175293,
-0.23545272648334503,
-0.3820505142211914,
-1.0721116065979004,
0.623354971408844,
-0.19539009034633636,
-0.5667762160301208,
0.6545841693878174,
0.2717607915401459,
-0.21618059277534485,
-0.08449894934892654,
0.17529907822608948,
-0.44883087277412415,
-0.052921488881111145,
-0.03255591541528702,
0.3290838897228241,
0.032037023454904556,
-0.030484892427921295,
0.23440676927566528,
0.13913236558437347,
-0.01725945807993412,
-0.21556581556797028,
0.2947300374507904,
0.18037885427474976,
-0.37263238430023193,
-0.7662776708602905,
0.7686720490455627,
0.37716859579086304,
-0.09861406683921814,
1.2380789518356323,
0.09222763776779175,
-0.3708762228488922,
-0.36670759320259094,
-0.631759524345398,
-0.39959070086479187,
-0.35532093048095703,
0.549839198589325,
-0.5466687083244324,
-0.4084990620613098,
0.11416919529438019,
-0.4048551321029663,
0.07388230413198471,
0.1912522315979004,
0.2749869227409363,
-0.23434120416641235,
1.3594970703125,
0.8150136470794678,
0.30177372694015503,
0.34459760785102844,
0.05130372196435928,
0.34384679794311523,
-0.5180475115776062,
-0.2189629077911377,
-0.8964930176734924,
0.18919259309768677,
-0.3535136580467224,
-0.5553553700447083,
0.3955256938934326,
0.1373802125453949,
-0.1246965304017067,
0.44624996185302734,
-0.5975511074066162,
0.6120944023132324,
0.0008491309708915651,
0.12202244997024536,
0.23853154480457306,
0.5653210878372192,
0.052802592515945435,
-0.3003195822238922,
-0.7201907634735107,
-0.6467006206512451,
1.2045191526412964,
0.06181410327553749,
0.5129668712615967,
0.3960511088371277,
0.8281926512718201,
0.2641659677028656,
0.05164928734302521,
-0.5598616003990173,
0.7604587078094482,
-0.18320100009441376,
-0.4853885769844055,
-0.28430548310279846,
-0.5337480306625366,
-0.5135607719421387,
0.22303688526153564,
-0.34938642382621765,
-0.735242486000061,
0.08288654685020447,
0.12324986606836319,
-0.030790936201810837,
0.34485116600990295,
-1.0441946983337402,
0.6875348091125488,
-0.35191115736961365,
-0.7967445850372314,
-0.3287564218044281,
-0.470463365316391,
0.0772840604186058,
-0.07079487293958664,
0.1382438689470291,
0.12820519506931305,
-0.7023535370826721,
0.5345869660377502,
-0.510148286819458,
0.8996397852897644,
-0.3612249493598938,
0.1374952793121338,
0.19675198197364807,
0.165034681558609,
1.0101224184036255,
-0.39564210176467896,
-0.3747768700122833,
0.1646212637424469,
0.17661312222480774,
-0.4485635459423065,
-0.6184191703796387,
0.5534580945968628,
-0.3004031777381897,
-0.5405965447425842,
-0.2590533494949341,
-0.22994789481163025,
-0.2107185423374176,
-0.034328147768974304,
-0.02135048806667328,
0.2717169523239136,
-0.196693554520607,
0.12432047724723816,
0.6738367676734924,
-0.40170538425445557,
0.27295517921447754,
0.6916884183883667,
0.014134877361357212,
-0.21979530155658722,
0.9138334393501282,
0.10082249343395233,
0.23420260846614838,
0.7181400060653687,
-0.1268293410539627,
-0.516745388507843,
-0.9683525562286377,
-0.566075325012207,
0.32208630442619324,
-0.5512126684188843,
-0.15468883514404297,
-0.6544613838195801,
0.31907397508621216,
-0.2693333029747009,
0.0908396989107132,
-0.2774099111557007,
-0.5423415899276733,
-0.15714573860168457,
0.0864248052239418,
0.3942033350467682,
0.4707892835140228,
0.429564505815506,
0.21482808887958527,
-0.8460175395011902,
-0.1938771903514862,
-0.24077342450618744,
0.31181496381759644,
-0.33287808299064636,
-0.45646077394485474,
-0.12965206801891327,
-0.21890471875667572,
0.05306288227438927,
-1.2956347465515137,
0.6006373167037964,
0.5892404913902283,
0.5081761479377747,
-0.10681481659412384,
0.20395731925964355,
0.744249701499939,
-0.7657281756401062,
0.789069414138794,
0.31472349166870117,
-0.8759835958480835,
0.9616780877113342,
-0.34449127316474915,
-0.023503901436924934,
0.5216196775436401,
0.41964390873908997,
-0.27040842175483704,
-0.2745290696620941,
-0.19128960371017456,
-1.115644931793213,
0.8354570269584656,
0.31348633766174316,
-0.022271038964390755,
-0.15357662737369537,
0.6294965147972107,
-0.18272127211093903,
0.23098894953727722,
-0.4484733045101166,
-0.19664253294467926,
0.19832034409046173,
-0.33328309655189514,
0.1757795512676239,
-0.4160842001438141,
-0.2466486543416977,
-0.14413805305957794,
0.6461368799209595,
-0.4121880829334259,
0.45597442984580994,
0.3577626645565033,
-0.27646347880363464,
-0.02812887169420719,
0.5125981569290161,
0.43923819065093994,
0.812915563583374,
-0.09237265586853027,
-0.2610381543636322,
0.530302882194519,
-0.2291755974292755,
-0.09272890537977219,
-0.12489698082208633,
-0.26091891527175903,
0.013563410378992558,
0.01840447075664997,
0.534176230430603,
-0.12949848175048828,
-0.718829870223999,
0.5088835954666138,
-0.08267439156770706,
0.24806886911392212,
-0.47419673204421997,
-0.2170804888010025,
0.007703355047851801,
-0.3471713662147522,
0.4681711196899414,
-0.08309340476989746,
0.3320448696613312,
-0.5047956109046936,
0.15156520903110504,
0.27668309211730957,
-0.3590632677078247,
-0.24091282486915588,
0.50970858335495,
0.5170699954032898,
-0.4964596927165985,
0.2652040719985962,
-0.30235055088996887,
-0.23156395554542542,
0.40589630603790283,
0.9235789775848389,
0.7627909779548645,
-0.2518550753593445,
0.03501996397972107,
0.5045846700668335,
0.36044439673423767,
-0.0961085855960846,
0.5954050421714783,
0.09625519067049026,
-0.41860535740852356,
-0.8227691650390625,
-0.6117863059043884,
-0.3834974765777588,
-0.35750290751457214,
-0.43684709072113037,
0.4576830565929413,
-0.4025864899158478,
-0.014681614004075527,
-0.18759813904762268,
-0.39201119542121887,
-0.28969869017601013,
0.021082982420921326,
-0.20900538563728333,
0.8375008702278137,
-0.6626759767532349,
0.753391444683075,
0.8974066972732544,
-0.3428548276424408,
-0.5914669036865234,
-0.08653157949447632,
0.06677334010601044,
-0.2217807024717331,
0.42159998416900635,
-0.01550271175801754,
0.04422371834516525,
0.09924843907356262,
-0.4266434609889984,
-0.42979928851127625,
0.849020779132843,
0.3886106312274933,
-0.8345680832862854,
-0.09716352820396423,
0.4660033583641052,
0.4760386049747467,
-0.71296226978302,
0.49298277497291565,
0.8959991335868835,
0.32940390706062317,
-0.03178856521844864,
-0.7979447841644287,
0.21281978487968445,
-0.1254364550113678,
0.2937367856502533,
0.48712843656539917,
-0.10366301238536835,
0.560151219367981,
-0.23370426893234253,
-0.3099653124809265,
0.08925433456897736,
0.5303747653961182,
0.2403523325920105,
0.16887922585010529,
0.5349953174591064,
0.47842732071876526,
0.5930843949317932,
-0.3567120134830475,
1.401996374130249,
-0.4352533519268036,
-0.07662186771631241,
0.9916770458221436,
-0.6282473802566528,
1.224088430404663,
0.7943748831748962,
-0.45707133412361145,
0.5168183445930481,
0.19906578958034515,
0.21297979354858398,
0.3295575976371765,
0.00630745105445385,
-0.4104384183883667,
-0.28076907992362976,
-0.3191009759902954,
-0.04729870334267616,
0.32570233941078186,
0.6037415862083435,
-0.36090540885925293,
-0.08624587953090668,
-0.3366270065307617,
0.02270224317908287,
0.5676546692848206,
-0.25649794936180115,
1.0031087398529053,
-0.07884027808904648,
-0.6227914690971375,
0.5244942307472229,
0.16923600435256958,
0.8147281408309937,
-0.6286450624465942,
-0.4216991662979126,
0.07016776502132416,
0.30090439319610596,
-0.45970290899276733,
-0.5666570067405701,
0.6770188212394714,
0.20183715224266052,
-0.12731896340847015,
0.22312632203102112,
0.7470937967300415,
-0.41023844480514526,
-0.39441990852355957,
0.27191364765167236,
0.4468437135219574,
0.4115969240665436,
-0.1570572704076767,
-0.7641503810882568,
-0.06939911842346191,
0.19010789692401886,
0.015242032706737518,
0.2910465896129608,
0.38762256503105164,
0.051319848746061325,
0.4200740456581116,
0.6316359043121338,
0.40539586544036865,
0.09968649595975876,
0.023854736238718033,
0.4653162658214569,
-0.7741870284080505,
-0.5136401653289795,
-0.7851668000221252,
0.519547700881958,
-0.6073206067085266,
0.054101474583148956,
0.7179628610610962,
0.6649317741394043,
0.5295009613037109,
-0.10585781931877136,
0.6549469828605652,
-0.14678941667079926,
0.7702144384384155,
-0.5565178394317627,
0.6661784052848816,
-0.460664838552475,
0.538049042224884,
-0.011478248983621597,
-0.9880037307739258,
-0.464530348777771,
0.28547319769859314,
-0.30681365728378296,
-0.18214206397533417,
0.8188388347625732,
1.2937870025634766,
0.4760238528251648,
0.10540267825126648,
0.3843371868133545,
0.11914292722940445,
0.2473933845758438,
0.49441051483154297,
0.6341254711151123,
-0.46616435050964355,
0.6986678838729858,
-0.10199502110481262,
-0.3072408139705658,
-0.0377894826233387,
-0.841168224811554,
-0.7052637338638306,
-0.2859395444393158,
-0.39136624336242676,
-0.41596871614456177,
0.514120876789093,
0.9751982688903809,
0.7324995994567871,
-1.0760586261749268,
-0.44986581802368164,
-0.5388866066932678,
-0.11883631348609924,
-0.3511143922805786,
-0.20256619155406952,
0.22428883612155914,
-0.6422818899154663,
-0.8718118071556091,
0.6165601015090942,
0.4094226658344269,
-0.14451062679290771,
-0.07877574115991592,
-0.024820571765303612,
-0.4842571020126343,
0.3033640682697296,
0.6970337629318237,
0.07976498454809189,
-0.5855724811553955,
0.10444267094135284,
-0.2139088660478592,
-0.06430377811193466,
0.0008790854481048882,
0.7728561162948608,
-0.5374958515167236,
0.30122455954551697,
0.596184253692627,
0.7102742791175842,
0.45478886365890503,
-0.23995691537857056,
0.9738478660583496,
-0.8715506196022034,
0.10986702889204025,
0.27201950550079346,
0.2830459475517273,
0.4922308921813965,
-0.6609415411949158,
0.8024672269821167,
0.28946399688720703,
-0.41122615337371826,
-1.1347999572753906,
0.1376502513885498,
-0.710746705532074,
-0.2735140323638916,
1.0716816186904907,
-0.24236348271369934,
-0.7611319422721863,
-0.3471016585826874,
-0.11616701632738113,
0.053936272859573364,
-0.2945634126663208,
0.4510902464389801,
0.3346231281757355,
-0.0807073786854744,
-0.1381377875804901,
-0.535730242729187,
0.545473575592041,
0.7221243381500244,
-1.123134970664978,
0.09832941740751266,
0.465185284614563,
0.2452327162027359,
0.22737394273281097,
0.317599892616272,
-0.4511612057685852,
0.2862366735935211,
0.027532612904906273,
0.17487384378910065,
0.037775419652462006,
-0.22939056158065796,
-0.3364183306694031,
0.3451412320137024,
0.11087160557508469,
-0.02552199736237526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13506v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13506v2
|
Parameter Efficient Fine Tuning: A Comprehensive Analysis Across Applications
| 2024-04-21T02:26:15 | 2024-04-23T21:28:26 |
Charith Chandra Sai Balne, Sreyoshi Bhaduri, Tamoghna Roy, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The rise of deep learning has marked significant progress in fields such as
computer vision, natural language processing, and medical imaging, primarily
through the adaptation of pre-trained models for specific tasks. Traditional
fine-tuning methods, involving adjustments to all parameters, face challenges
due to high computational and memory demands. This has led to the development
of Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) techniques, which selectively update
parameters to balance computational efficiency with performance. This review
examines PEFT approaches, offering a detailed comparison of various strategies
highlighting applications across different domains, including text generation,
medical imaging, protein modeling, and speech synthesis. By assessing the
effectiveness of PEFT methods in reducing computational load, speeding up
training, and lowering memory usage, this paper contributes to making deep
learning more accessible and adaptable, facilitating its wider application and
encouraging innovation in model optimization. Ultimately, the paper aims to
contribute towards insights into PEFT's evolving landscape, guiding researchers
and practitioners in overcoming the limitations of conventional fine-tuning
approaches.
|
[
-0.5722720623016357,
-0.9786806702613831,
0.614280641078949,
-0.032589804381132126,
-0.35869845747947693,
0.031247032806277275,
-0.5463060140609741,
-0.3387269973754883,
-0.48206549882888794,
0.36637812852859497,
-0.3872527480125427,
-0.2713354527950287,
-0.5411128401756287,
0.0462796576321125,
-0.16151763498783112,
0.8025102615356445,
-0.12074320763349533,
0.1285858005285263,
-0.15015213191509247,
-0.2132463902235031,
-0.24813136458396912,
-0.38848820328712463,
-1.1518515348434448,
-0.4782193601131439,
0.33274751901626587,
0.23155200481414795,
0.6342570185661316,
0.5915344953536987,
0.8600437045097351,
0.26333123445510864,
-0.06100741773843765,
0.5087764859199524,
-0.6023176908493042,
0.1430094838142395,
-0.2485751211643219,
-0.06433090567588806,
-0.48985159397125244,
-0.15578009188175201,
0.9203333854675293,
1.1073962450027466,
0.07231836020946503,
0.15470868349075317,
0.29923370480537415,
1.0322532653808594,
-0.906146228313446,
-0.14913378655910492,
-0.7566754221916199,
0.0004886193783022463,
-0.0451243631541729,
-0.4072067439556122,
-0.12122587114572525,
-0.1692303866147995,
0.2673809826374054,
-0.7123888731002808,
0.4111945629119873,
-0.3731660842895508,
0.8484914302825928,
0.603105902671814,
-0.143312007188797,
0.03342883288860321,
-0.8714135885238647,
0.8877869248390198,
-0.6276280283927917,
0.7282207012176514,
0.2674652636051178,
0.3147686719894409,
-0.2058907449245453,
-0.9990475177764893,
-0.025408895686268806,
-0.164571613073349,
0.3130309283733368,
-0.008363707922399044,
-0.10438814014196396,
0.36404964327812195,
0.1579003781080246,
0.3938252925872803,
-0.24482420086860657,
0.14653660356998444,
-0.3034346103668213,
-0.11884884536266327,
0.5611667037010193,
0.035659532994031906,
0.010350316762924194,
0.5029043555259705,
-0.022088278084993362,
-0.19649067521095276,
-0.584833562374115,
0.05938492715358734,
0.36931225657463074,
0.38511964678764343,
0.2614612579345703,
0.11056714504957199,
-0.42251482605934143,
1.0145809650421143,
0.5071717500686646,
-0.041809190064668655,
0.022334827110171318,
-0.3769110441207886,
-0.5317680239677429,
-0.12677358090877533,
0.5033353567123413,
0.45224910974502563,
0.17594175040721893,
-0.023021245375275612,
-0.10940219461917877,
-0.37133729457855225,
0.3891134560108185,
-0.8869910836219788,
-0.30688875913619995,
0.04896201193332672,
-0.6451231241226196,
-0.23937946557998657,
-0.3777855634689331,
-0.7491913437843323,
-0.4157969355583191,
-0.5323322415351868,
0.387967586517334,
-0.5048767924308777,
-0.040672216564416885,
0.300687313079834,
-0.025740046054124832,
0.24747629463672638,
0.5179949402809143,
-0.9769577980041504,
0.252550333738327,
0.6449049711227417,
0.680340051651001,
-0.11903758347034454,
-0.1590808629989624,
-0.530780553817749,
0.03844248875975609,
-0.5000563859939575,
0.7671729922294617,
-0.7101120948791504,
-0.24083128571510315,
-0.3611833155155182,
-0.10095327347517014,
-0.18382279574871063,
-0.6590719223022461,
0.7224761247634888,
-0.2704542279243469,
-0.2944701910018921,
-0.2208014577627182,
-0.5011453628540039,
-0.3538895845413208,
0.094206802546978,
-0.5170992612838745,
0.8520262241363525,
0.046648260205984116,
-0.3279583156108856,
0.6466982364654541,
-0.6186606287956238,
-0.43778252601623535,
-0.12431386113166809,
0.04994340240955353,
-0.6772587895393372,
0.6321523785591125,
0.4511738121509552,
0.7293634414672852,
-0.32019877433776855,
0.2814791798591614,
-0.38092634081840515,
-0.5291905403137207,
-0.05415203794836998,
-0.5082167983055115,
0.3078891634941101,
0.5821523666381836,
-0.31800100207328796,
0.0435299389064312,
-0.9733151793479919,
0.1886918842792511,
0.019478436559438705,
-0.5249512791633606,
-0.23592209815979004,
0.2107839435338974,
-0.06084757670760155,
-0.34336522221565247,
0.09657944738864899,
-0.17317098379135132,
0.11740552634000778,
-0.6224404573440552,
0.7970864176750183,
0.4848739802837372,
0.09960589557886124,
0.5023989677429199,
-0.16694867610931396,
0.11672297865152359,
-0.3244323134422302,
0.423896849155426,
-0.23905211687088013,
-0.08643955737352371,
-0.5532723665237427,
-0.22980087995529175,
0.6402548551559448,
0.2506231963634491,
-0.18652668595314026,
0.15753819048404694,
0.2539227604866028,
-0.6622039079666138,
-0.5074920058250427,
0.22672419250011444,
0.22922076284885406,
0.6401888132095337,
0.3720444440841675,
-0.10215682536363602,
-0.36217013001441956,
-1.0263854265213013,
-0.6847636699676514,
0.05913359299302101,
0.05508653074502945,
0.4899372160434723,
0.009883999824523926,
-0.10723607987165451,
0.26690831780433655,
-0.28627896308898926,
0.012505837716162205,
0.03708723187446594,
0.023614419624209404,
0.23551130294799805,
0.7303600311279297,
0.7966300249099731,
-0.8706592917442322,
-0.7429162263870239,
0.2481951266527176,
-0.2788947522640228,
0.09393853694200516,
-0.5185167789459229,
0.005561890080571175,
-0.054136838763952255,
0.6689401865005493,
-0.10427588224411011,
0.12373076379299164,
0.18782342970371246,
-0.13279841840267181,
0.27453726530075073,
-0.5707663893699646,
0.47168710827827454,
-0.43985962867736816,
0.15351833403110504,
0.12263030558824539,
-0.3102003037929535,
-0.7093897461891174,
0.31236886978149414,
0.24392466247081757,
-0.07827744632959366,
-0.4541401267051697,
0.29845917224884033,
-0.4883684813976288,
0.3374653458595276,
-0.34384045004844666,
-0.43536290526390076,
0.054137203842401505,
0.24553132057189941,
-0.11128092557191849,
0.7775717973709106,
0.9135541915893555,
-0.7124042510986328,
0.03565144166350365,
-0.1744777411222458,
-0.05141395330429077,
0.4840189814567566,
-0.6615352630615234,
0.31791555881500244,
-0.1636403501033783,
-0.3413781523704529,
-0.8151653409004211,
-0.20021118223667145,
0.21369700133800507,
-0.15960904955863953,
0.6473721861839294,
-0.07372914254665375,
-0.5077335834503174,
-0.03867778554558754,
-0.36500051617622375,
0.4462675154209137,
0.6262015104293823,
-0.5352743864059448,
0.6605940461158752,
0.2362566590309143,
0.03375668078660965,
-0.1350911557674408,
-0.36330482363700867,
-0.11224688589572906,
-0.4061117470264435,
-0.2896046042442322,
0.8266431093215942,
-0.08816464245319366,
-0.08679702877998352,
-0.2921009659767151,
-0.2783631980419159,
-0.3070516586303711,
0.38169968128204346,
-0.13284677267074585,
-0.24837204813957214,
-0.25349700450897217,
0.050224900245666504,
0.5683375000953674,
-0.03174951300024986,
-0.3022271394729614,
-0.3325662314891815,
0.29268568754196167,
-0.21584947407245636,
-0.09965726733207703,
-0.5073645114898682,
0.44655537605285645,
0.5162465572357178,
-0.2631451487541199,
0.4719178080558777,
0.7527748942375183,
-0.471558541059494,
-0.09769483655691147,
-0.5852694511413574,
-0.12460210174322128,
-0.5603786706924438,
0.6309184432029724,
-0.3768085837364197,
-0.6385534405708313,
0.24703319370746613,
-0.8925119042396545,
0.009554736316204071,
0.49994802474975586,
0.6153836846351624,
-0.24566350877285004,
1.2394003868103027,
0.8491359353065491,
0.370752215385437,
0.634777843952179,
-0.12781000137329102,
0.11324658244848251,
-0.6638182997703552,
-0.06770937144756317,
-0.5467796921730042,
-0.557296633720398,
-0.4609418511390686,
-0.14156478643417358,
0.32842475175857544,
0.4933318793773651,
-0.3961544334888458,
0.03194490820169449,
-0.9815282821655273,
0.7144367694854736,
0.5767305493354797,
0.24945004284381866,
0.07672885060310364,
0.17673808336257935,
-0.040369872003793716,
0.005463294684886932,
-0.6199185252189636,
-0.3252109885215759,
1.245954990386963,
0.3042443096637726,
0.6031324863433838,
-0.4787772595882416,
0.47021567821502686,
0.05165427178144455,
-0.34976229071617126,
-0.644813597202301,
0.35717496275901794,
-0.6607008576393127,
-0.2688717246055603,
-0.34727993607521057,
-0.12554620206356049,
-0.7415701150894165,
-0.10676384717226028,
-0.35176998376846313,
-0.48063409328460693,
0.45147156715393066,
0.5008627772331238,
-0.7438247799873352,
0.4048828184604645,
-0.8645793795585632,
0.6932918429374695,
-0.36417272686958313,
-0.4307700991630554,
-0.4094372093677521,
-0.4474058151245117,
-0.23581621050834656,
-0.5446447730064392,
-0.3682328760623932,
-0.2733839154243469,
-0.31352290511131287,
0.646034836769104,
-0.09695266932249069,
0.6397675275802612,
-0.3899567723274231,
0.21813300251960754,
0.16793730854988098,
-0.12582603096961975,
0.29076769948005676,
0.06174418702721596,
-0.4076312482357025,
0.31487372517585754,
0.26499852538108826,
-0.4562957286834717,
-0.5575132369995117,
0.6734808087348938,
-0.7123242020606995,
-0.33746519684791565,
0.13023845851421356,
-0.5603139400482178,
-0.5578441619873047,
0.3531643748283386,
0.32594114542007446,
0.23632076382637024,
-0.11765752732753754,
0.4961685836315155,
0.766981840133667,
-0.36363616585731506,
0.45734846591949463,
0.17688657343387604,
0.4077412188053131,
-0.3815491199493408,
0.9048940539360046,
0.30886638164520264,
0.0915483608841896,
0.3990974426269531,
0.3034312427043915,
-0.11312098801136017,
-1.3606725931167603,
-0.18020376563072205,
0.10808957368135452,
-0.4795781373977661,
-0.22709810733795166,
-0.3482358455657959,
-0.06049081310629845,
-0.22262582182884216,
-0.46807578206062317,
-0.7050111889839172,
-0.30673903226852417,
-0.5712824463844299,
0.16691817343235016,
0.42780789732933044,
0.11040107160806656,
-0.023543165996670723,
0.48519882559776306,
-0.5732172131538391,
0.5043659806251526,
0.3087761104106903,
0.7550088763237,
-0.16998770833015442,
-0.2515868544578552,
-0.24451926350593567,
-0.12189246714115143,
-0.5520374774932861,
-0.6312640309333801,
0.10290481895208359,
0.9920196533203125,
0.8381686806678772,
0.3437989354133606,
0.045919548720121384,
0.8235988616943359,
-0.4703527092933655,
0.6721997857093811,
0.22078265249729156,
-0.883004367351532,
0.8736873269081116,
-0.28155097365379333,
0.2295013666152954,
0.9731730818748474,
0.42059069871902466,
0.07866935431957245,
-0.03222178295254707,
-0.3762836754322052,
-1.0041342973709106,
0.26050126552581787,
-0.02510996162891388,
0.3527278006076813,
0.47643783688545227,
1.0799463987350464,
0.5314029455184937,
0.1044117659330368,
-0.053500447422266006,
-0.11991389095783234,
-0.10044235736131668,
-0.3500796854496002,
-0.00006965276406845078,
-0.06484182178974152,
0.008125118911266327,
-0.8855910897254944,
0.5488476157188416,
-0.4934011697769165,
0.24357351660728455,
0.2604829967021942,
0.013234497047960758,
-0.125155970454216,
-0.013073422946035862,
0.5686693787574768,
0.7703184485435486,
-0.1676865816116333,
-0.012488274835050106,
0.31835314631462097,
-0.5375916957855225,
-0.03008628822863102,
0.20198586583137512,
-0.24439841508865356,
-0.21761924028396606,
0.059816278517246246,
0.995103120803833,
0.06913167983293533,
-0.6813652515411377,
0.137494295835495,
-0.018210479989647865,
-0.6750832200050354,
0.19272610545158386,
0.5370829105377197,
-0.2073812633752823,
0.4831225574016571,
0.40356728434562683,
0.4468362033367157,
0.48590946197509766,
-0.2311244159936905,
0.17732475697994232,
0.48008888959884644,
-0.43939486145973206,
-0.2260848432779312,
0.788897693157196,
0.08822596818208694,
-0.28852275013923645,
0.37237128615379333,
0.30647793412208557,
0.08189132809638977,
0.3971703052520752,
0.29658085107803345,
0.8748653531074524,
-0.029966970905661583,
-0.045430902391672134,
0.25678539276123047,
0.13205157220363617,
0.007703261915594339,
0.3001866936683655,
-0.2271101176738739,
-0.4546719491481781,
-0.48599645495414734,
-0.7806720733642578,
-0.3648805618286133,
0.2689671516418457,
-0.4914863407611847,
0.20892314612865448,
-0.7983026504516602,
-0.48280006647109985,
0.46591851115226746,
0.2877764403820038,
-0.8104892373085022,
0.28661561012268066,
0.17356781661510468,
0.953991174697876,
-0.5374471545219421,
0.764837384223938,
0.9231520891189575,
0.02984803356230259,
-0.6811614632606506,
0.002988671651110053,
-0.29146474599838257,
-0.6292979121208191,
0.23824912309646606,
-0.2130652517080307,
-0.03413696959614754,
0.18650056421756744,
-0.6030262112617493,
-0.6419292092323303,
0.71214359998703,
0.9493364095687866,
-0.7174803614616394,
0.07300224155187607,
0.0694388598203659,
0.5586531758308411,
-0.13712237775325775,
-0.1165233626961708,
0.93974769115448,
0.5485459566116333,
-0.1213231310248375,
-0.8873300552368164,
-0.03928174078464508,
-0.16706977784633636,
0.05286458134651184,
0.2514256238937378,
-0.714911699295044,
0.6236224174499512,
-0.009488319978117943,
0.05947810411453247,
0.1196058839559555,
0.40930163860321045,
0.1172739714384079,
0.40923890471458435,
0.4093179404735565,
0.24965816736221313,
0.8893566131591797,
-0.16841967403888702,
0.7228250503540039,
-0.37918439507484436,
0.41513094305992126,
0.7184783220291138,
0.04132448509335518,
0.5885277390480042,
0.6899065971374512,
-0.3201608955860138,
-0.15553797781467438,
0.9761479496955872,
-0.3948499262332916,
0.8678690195083618,
-0.00995539128780365,
-0.04160526394844055,
-0.46536871790885925,
0.0845913514494896,
-0.37954846024513245,
0.4622519314289093,
0.31360140442848206,
-0.6317827701568604,
-0.25395843386650085,
0.2613520324230194,
-0.3786720931529999,
0.099977046251297,
-0.686008870601654,
0.8957255482673645,
0.039142366498708725,
-0.5244588255882263,
0.8125210404396057,
-0.028741193935275078,
0.531936526298523,
-0.3744048476219177,
-0.1269475221633911,
0.05701981857419014,
0.37185728549957275,
-0.14286920428276062,
-0.49279388785362244,
0.46717000007629395,
-0.20557059347629547,
-0.2446729689836502,
-0.2700617015361786,
1.0317376852035522,
0.002064273227006197,
-0.5961858630180359,
0.11125702410936356,
0.3545930087566376,
-0.012892230413854122,
-0.394633412361145,
-1.1346431970596313,
0.15747444331645966,
0.0017624703468754888,
-0.20143845677375793,
0.3726907968521118,
0.1900908499956131,
0.23105770349502563,
0.31505805253982544,
0.6680740118026733,
0.25563672184944153,
-0.019247638061642647,
-0.054177507758140564,
0.834643542766571,
-0.5591757893562317,
-0.30018869042396545,
-0.9084678292274475,
0.32226794958114624,
0.012776254676282406,
-0.3386888802051544,
0.3858488202095032,
0.35265102982521057,
0.8581175804138184,
-0.04299406334757805,
0.5914138555526733,
0.3137185573577881,
0.43592506647109985,
-0.5564826130867004,
0.8476637601852417,
-0.8353842496871948,
0.0018109322991222143,
-0.36642494797706604,
-0.8205628991127014,
-0.7271186709403992,
0.5865129232406616,
-0.26191022992134094,
0.14485235512256622,
0.47754934430122375,
0.48380047082901,
-0.2868717908859253,
-0.012854206375777721,
0.36772653460502625,
-0.06163490191102028,
0.10902822017669678,
0.474317342042923,
0.45225322246551514,
-0.49124494194984436,
0.35133853554725647,
-0.43412086367607117,
-0.1609456092119217,
-0.18763336539268494,
-1.0061956644058228,
-0.693920910358429,
-0.537647545337677,
-0.726019024848938,
0.15137979388237,
0.25996312499046326,
0.5333172678947449,
1.2285751104354858,
-0.9202143549919128,
0.25905272364616394,
-0.3102004826068878,
-0.26815322041511536,
-0.6970996260643005,
-0.08153730630874634,
0.5888891816139221,
-0.4295004606246948,
-0.845355749130249,
0.48630857467651367,
0.42118576169013977,
-0.01823040284216404,
0.10900412499904633,
-0.08265843987464905,
0.10936582088470459,
0.23440463840961456,
0.5797092318534851,
0.4108254015445709,
-0.5804229378700256,
-0.1919708251953125,
0.10014493018388748,
0.30329352617263794,
0.23308974504470825,
0.8087304830551147,
-0.844371497631073,
0.5003679394721985,
0.6068777441978455,
1.0062090158462524,
0.5680978894233704,
-0.24517928063869476,
0.6865180134773254,
-0.5007089376449585,
-0.025827694684267044,
0.29970237612724304,
0.15864816308021545,
0.2462729662656784,
-0.6326214075088501,
0.4929024875164032,
0.059312090277671814,
-0.6579211950302124,
-1.0267030000686646,
-0.0681176707148552,
-1.045784831047058,
-0.6529991626739502,
0.5771496295928955,
0.12432803958654404,
-0.15202130377292633,
0.07719873636960983,
-0.3051334023475647,
0.38960060477256775,
-0.18042027950286865,
0.5973882675170898,
0.2572706341743469,
-0.6502088308334351,
-0.27495077252388,
-0.5550094246864319,
0.6477702260017395,
0.48665353655815125,
-0.5878583192825317,
-0.08757741749286652,
0.16413527727127075,
0.2427932322025299,
-0.1836436688899994,
0.4355201721191406,
-0.06561455875635147,
0.3883380591869354,
-0.21366916596889496,
-0.5062927007675171,
-0.2825448513031006,
-0.4163273274898529,
-0.5061305165290833,
0.5538341999053955,
0.21087093651294708,
-0.12500683963298798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13504v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13504v1
|
IMO: Greedy Layer-Wise Sparse Representation Learning for Out-of-Distribution Text Classification with Pre-trained Models
| 2024-04-21T02:15:59 | 2024-04-21T02:15:59 |
Tao Feng, Lizhen Qu, Zhuang Li, Haolan Zhan, Yuncheng Hua, Gholamreza Haffari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Machine learning models have made incredible progress, but they still
struggle when applied to examples from unseen domains. This study focuses on a
specific problem of domain generalization, where a model is trained on one
source domain and tested on multiple target domains that are unseen during
training. We propose IMO: Invariant features Masks for Out-of-Distribution text
classification, to achieve OOD generalization by learning invariant features.
During training, IMO would learn sparse mask layers to remove irrelevant
features for prediction, where the remaining features keep invariant.
Additionally, IMO has an attention module at the token level to focus on tokens
that are useful for prediction. Our comprehensive experiments show that IMO
substantially outperforms strong baselines in terms of various evaluation
metrics and settings.
|
[
-0.34679070115089417,
-0.5666770339012146,
0.4423249065876007,
0.09747859835624695,
-0.3637395203113556,
0.05703601986169815,
-0.05894174426794052,
-0.634790301322937,
0.3515661954879761,
0.7609770894050598,
-0.5526189804077148,
-0.257074236869812,
-1.0845168828964233,
-0.04652804508805275,
-0.3861963152885437,
1.0327341556549072,
-0.047341931611299515,
-0.1053866595029831,
-0.40331408381462097,
-0.4441591799259186,
-0.36042895913124084,
-0.753153920173645,
-0.2758994400501251,
-0.3303036689758301,
0.12397564947605133,
0.4880155920982361,
0.5009199380874634,
0.5541772246360779,
0.28748905658721924,
0.34234675765037537,
0.37250691652297974,
0.2893798053264618,
-0.43779394030570984,
0.054158687591552734,
-0.18163485825061798,
-0.3855646252632141,
-0.3304547369480133,
0.22287388145923615,
0.8131911158561707,
0.577476978302002,
-0.07709003984928131,
-0.026124734431505203,
0.4535888433456421,
0.5000236630439758,
-0.9294267892837524,
0.06142188608646393,
-0.9338108897209167,
0.18459771573543549,
0.009439397603273392,
-0.2282586693763733,
-0.6586034297943115,
0.16879169642925262,
0.34326067566871643,
-1.022881269454956,
0.22312164306640625,
0.3591238856315613,
0.9150951504707336,
0.24114808440208435,
-0.3446311056613922,
-0.2600318491458893,
-0.5838593244552612,
1.1107497215270996,
-0.26864001154899597,
0.21974390745162964,
0.7072110772132874,
0.20404691994190216,
0.08624393492937088,
-0.7454196214675903,
-0.38085153698921204,
-0.09049876034259796,
-0.025092260912060738,
0.21546295285224915,
-0.15801028907299042,
0.05017780885100365,
-0.0648094043135643,
0.2687068283557892,
-0.383355051279068,
0.11072499305009842,
-0.14353078603744507,
-0.021935444325208664,
0.4489248991012573,
-0.274092435836792,
0.14332130551338196,
0.2054527997970581,
-0.6765291690826416,
0.07194887846708298,
-0.4636588394641876,
-0.2951139509677887,
0.39574429392814636,
0.27123335003852844,
-0.06651756912469864,
0.4817558825016022,
-0.09688252955675125,
0.72243732213974,
0.0963764488697052,
-0.0037562090437859297,
0.16823992133140564,
0.026768585667014122,
-0.32253286242485046,
0.011687541380524635,
0.5521133542060852,
-0.2803120017051697,
0.14401593804359436,
-0.3335598111152649,
-0.20572926104068756,
-0.28422462940216064,
0.5008360147476196,
-0.918846845626831,
0.08631758391857147,
0.11503488570451736,
-0.5672767162322998,
-0.2510838806629181,
0.34391355514526367,
-0.6221591830253601,
-0.4028199017047882,
-0.36532309651374817,
0.7377718687057495,
-0.1502034068107605,
-0.11174998432397842,
0.14210748672485352,
-0.13840292394161224,
-0.3839496374130249,
0.39278873801231384,
-0.9453439712524414,
0.33281123638153076,
0.3428580164909363,
0.9424887895584106,
-0.11881160736083984,
-0.5299559235572815,
-0.654350221157074,
0.2796751856803894,
0.0643584355711937,
0.7923924922943115,
-0.6514026522636414,
0.22205129265785217,
0.009936357848346233,
-0.06958497315645218,
-0.3177672326564789,
-0.782662034034729,
0.3028481900691986,
-0.6012066006660461,
0.2443828582763672,
0.4078133702278137,
-0.5791792869567871,
-0.2632778584957123,
0.47325026988983154,
-0.678180456161499,
0.7782769203186035,
0.6608867645263672,
-0.7532544732093811,
0.5138944387435913,
-0.4696151316165924,
-0.1063726618885994,
0.08231063187122345,
0.042604006826877594,
-0.8398685455322266,
0.08817347139120102,
0.22917205095291138,
0.6724802851676941,
-0.22360821068286896,
0.0584605373442173,
-0.587551474571228,
-0.44998636841773987,
0.3217550814151764,
-0.22616632282733917,
0.5156612992286682,
0.3093225061893463,
-0.32959797978401184,
-0.08523451536893845,
-0.8683096170425415,
0.11373234540224075,
0.16144438087940216,
-0.2707045078277588,
-0.668097198009491,
-0.12145794928073883,
-0.014909714460372925,
-0.0346282534301281,
-0.016566039994359016,
-0.4086478650569916,
0.2981213629245758,
-0.3707008361816406,
0.7804799675941467,
0.8096193671226501,
0.07095701992511749,
0.8301151394844055,
-0.24619948863983154,
0.5677633881568909,
0.407996267080307,
0.25021323561668396,
-0.043414242565631866,
-0.6255142688751221,
-0.4975503087043762,
-0.6601268649101257,
0.5555965304374695,
0.5215309858322144,
-0.8688063621520996,
0.6395443081855774,
-0.04835151135921478,
-0.07098697125911713,
-0.11929413676261902,
0.39777934551239014,
0.3818794786930084,
0.3041347861289978,
0.20816397666931152,
-0.43596941232681274,
-0.24466954171657562,
-0.46013298630714417,
-0.21132582426071167,
-0.1830080896615982,
0.19918285310268402,
0.2250729650259018,
0.41768118739128113,
-0.651541531085968,
0.9028574228286743,
-0.42725205421447754,
-0.8279328346252441,
-0.3025761842727661,
0.20341011881828308,
-0.1473812609910965,
0.4989108443260193,
0.6309944987297058,
-1.0145840644836426,
-0.5374516844749451,
0.30576685070991516,
-0.6266044974327087,
0.151542067527771,
-0.05779016762971878,
-0.2983771562576294,
-0.003526104614138603,
0.5031800270080566,
-0.4212546944618225,
0.18406598269939423,
0.5658616423606873,
-0.00931371096521616,
-0.08560530841350555,
-0.3164246082305908,
-0.034470777958631516,
-0.9882171154022217,
-0.22731296718120575,
0.15079690515995026,
-0.38900405168533325,
-0.43629589676856995,
0.06627999991178513,
0.22093744575977325,
-0.4301663935184479,
-0.2934643626213074,
0.7439436912536621,
-0.4890078008174896,
0.10463354736566544,
-0.28373992443084717,
0.05383625999093056,
0.2107812762260437,
0.6370006203651428,
-0.11584413796663284,
0.6095016598701477,
0.546666145324707,
-0.7945454716682434,
-0.12179549038410187,
0.06992783397436142,
-0.4431946873664856,
0.5235200524330139,
-0.2588798999786377,
0.20941685140132904,
-0.2899552881717682,
0.1003977507352829,
-0.7810240983963013,
-0.41623157262802124,
0.47705233097076416,
-0.3779165744781494,
0.49772167205810547,
-0.3477361500263214,
-0.42322540283203125,
-0.06017420440912247,
-0.2601231038570404,
0.7546749114990234,
0.4236796498298645,
-0.7216238975524902,
0.5882300734519958,
0.7877808213233948,
0.2514371871948242,
-0.9418569207191467,
-0.5892529487609863,
-0.20182658731937408,
-0.5304042100906372,
-0.1820947676897049,
0.447299063205719,
-0.048634085804224014,
0.01927155815064907,
0.18552803993225098,
0.08689414709806442,
-0.648614764213562,
0.21120119094848633,
0.16657032072544098,
-0.16564270853996277,
-0.02428266406059265,
0.33405429124832153,
0.25916245579719543,
-0.01262639369815588,
-0.25380420684814453,
-0.7395410537719727,
0.3298840820789337,
0.1952160894870758,
-0.10586240142583847,
-0.0652112066745758,
0.4713458716869354,
0.3922804594039917,
-0.21055695414543152,
0.7352930307388306,
0.2617582380771637,
-0.711509108543396,
-0.9304639101028442,
-0.13811393082141876,
0.08551406115293503,
-0.43630602955818176,
0.46514901518821716,
-0.2922247648239136,
-0.8191712498664856,
0.46030130982398987,
-0.32389989495277405,
-0.33545783162117004,
0.4127553403377533,
0.12409697473049164,
-0.07203040271997452,
1.2634477615356445,
1.2999778985977173,
-0.04586838185787201,
0.7492570281028748,
-0.5571895837783813,
0.12127700448036194,
-0.5082271695137024,
-0.027660224586725235,
-0.4292824864387512,
-0.1587970107793808,
-0.16981370747089386,
-0.22845283150672913,
0.3403906226158142,
0.4416988790035248,
-0.02710888162255287,
0.2590750455856323,
-0.6357289552688599,
0.7711794376373291,
0.4330344796180725,
0.4885352551937103,
0.10811184346675873,
0.2573225498199463,
0.23717646300792694,
0.08618702739477158,
-0.7351678609848022,
-0.2692646086215973,
1.1107709407806396,
0.3090602159500122,
0.5980754494667053,
-0.11073335260152817,
0.7496498823165894,
0.789608359336853,
0.6709027290344238,
-0.9241589307785034,
0.18010173738002777,
-0.41833218932151794,
-0.47753003239631653,
-0.20600499212741852,
-0.4723817706108093,
-0.8436270952224731,
0.3212745189666748,
-0.2613048255443573,
-0.389459490776062,
0.545219361782074,
0.2973101735115051,
-0.08431442081928253,
0.2705553472042084,
-1.0281660556793213,
0.8795837163925171,
0.050080325454473495,
-0.017038652673363686,
-0.06316544860601425,
-0.4894099235534668,
0.34020623564720154,
-0.36558592319488525,
0.18961207568645477,
0.03946497663855553,
-0.1820722371339798,
0.5002052187919617,
-0.5644441246986389,
0.9414332509040833,
-0.14631859958171844,
0.1663329303264618,
0.5509887337684631,
-0.3702072501182556,
0.4951005280017853,
0.1262369006872177,
-0.08757978677749634,
0.3429727256298065,
-0.34350505471229553,
-0.4728431701660156,
-0.6219080686569214,
0.49069303274154663,
-0.9935817718505859,
-0.08562973886728287,
-0.5886070728302002,
-0.36962246894836426,
-0.3543674051761627,
0.40092146396636963,
0.6737456321716309,
0.4371752440929413,
-0.1360137164592743,
-0.03749914467334747,
0.9079262614250183,
0.07004794478416443,
0.24456724524497986,
0.15730303525924683,
0.11311030387878418,
-0.6371848583221436,
1.0463272333145142,
0.38611024618148804,
0.292544424533844,
0.7622760534286499,
0.19249416887760162,
-0.21099013090133667,
-0.6911844611167908,
-0.6680494546890259,
0.14067675173282623,
-1.0279583930969238,
-0.5539308190345764,
-0.7638140916824341,
-0.36302289366722107,
-0.26385509967803955,
-0.19424287974834442,
-0.09887704998254776,
-0.3310141861438751,
-0.7204912900924683,
0.07824185490608215,
-0.0032999543473124504,
1.0171635150909424,
0.17137260735034943,
0.707895815372467,
-0.6192101836204529,
0.2315041869878769,
0.22034704685211182,
0.3956746757030487,
-0.0678449422121048,
-0.6435494422912598,
-0.6964378952980042,
-0.1763601452112198,
-0.5637120604515076,
-0.5302098393440247,
0.5681982636451721,
0.5416610836982727,
0.517673671245575,
0.6276350617408752,
0.2421993762254715,
0.6174120306968689,
-0.37819865345954895,
0.19022764265537262,
0.21287159621715546,
-1.0775370597839355,
0.45882612466812134,
-0.037586092948913574,
-0.026361463591456413,
0.4647894501686096,
0.5324646830558777,
0.10555426776409149,
-0.602466344833374,
-0.6305090188980103,
-0.5809977054595947,
1.023217797279358,
-0.08716420829296112,
0.33380961418151855,
0.18209074437618256,
0.6212405562400818,
0.578799843788147,
0.3047143816947937,
-1.0403838157653809,
-0.04189356416463852,
-0.33942025899887085,
-0.23529987037181854,
-0.14866915345191956,
-0.33294740319252014,
0.07260400801897049,
0.010337992571294308,
0.6553859710693359,
-0.42289578914642334,
0.2754932641983032,
0.18519090116024017,
-0.5027896761894226,
-0.3098325729370117,
0.0830717459321022,
0.48265233635902405,
0.7240583300590515,
-0.26432403922080994,
0.29702746868133545,
-0.21426166594028473,
-0.8124957084655762,
0.29144564270973206,
0.06352049857378006,
-0.23812739551067352,
-0.17834007740020752,
0.1793188899755478,
0.6024776697158813,
-0.022038491442799568,
-0.603710412979126,
0.8114286065101624,
-0.10588350892066956,
-0.3410576581954956,
-0.12154654413461685,
-0.019949719309806824,
-0.5634482502937317,
0.10881812125444412,
0.18565745651721954,
0.562477707862854,
0.3840086758136749,
-0.5661472082138062,
0.2070041447877884,
0.4037158787250519,
-0.6633293628692627,
-0.20758669078350067,
0.7311158180236816,
-0.1271771937608719,
0.17142067849636078,
0.39391833543777466,
-0.3233850598335266,
-0.44327259063720703,
0.727380633354187,
0.7533791065216064,
1.0625818967819214,
0.0009095909772440791,
0.3224315047264099,
0.14915336668491364,
0.4237167239189148,
-0.1636343002319336,
-0.04106880724430084,
-0.3164973855018616,
-0.790838360786438,
-0.24431312084197998,
-0.32426977157592773,
-0.6220136880874634,
0.014443036168813705,
-0.37739837169647217,
0.44562146067619324,
-0.6816228628158569,
-0.11841180175542831,
-0.18133613467216492,
-0.20868907868862152,
-0.36472201347351074,
0.30344101786613464,
-0.12191566824913025,
0.5083014965057373,
-0.8939478993415833,
1.0177873373031616,
0.8742693662643433,
-0.2694353759288788,
-0.28045302629470825,
0.2689931094646454,
-0.6116422414779663,
-0.8711085915565491,
0.5673217177391052,
0.45980650186538696,
-0.027608798816800117,
-0.01616002433001995,
-0.8611095547676086,
-0.9213330745697021,
0.8285882472991943,
0.7664714455604553,
-0.16006088256835938,
0.41439303755760193,
0.19449098408222198,
0.2129644900560379,
-0.5682519674301147,
0.11011634021997452,
-0.20097389817237854,
0.00495439488440752,
-0.04966392368078232,
-0.5208700299263,
-0.25999414920806885,
-0.2712797224521637,
-0.08411210775375366,
0.29273515939712524,
-0.8746907711029053,
0.9966436624526978,
-0.13610319793224335,
-0.1967136561870575,
0.10674183815717697,
0.6914642453193665,
0.0536280982196331,
0.6733463406562805,
0.5305901765823364,
0.6966955065727234,
0.7233688831329346,
-0.007385507225990295,
1.0904780626296997,
0.16375340521335602,
0.49870967864990234,
0.7855649590492249,
-0.25644442439079285,
0.564971923828125,
0.08076019585132599,
0.08387744426727295,
0.3610343635082245,
0.5770547389984131,
0.4699881076812744,
1.0008864402770996,
0.13703881204128265,
-0.3524080514907837,
-0.2127213180065155,
-0.08462116867303848,
-0.3395804166793823,
0.305849552154541,
0.4125415086746216,
-0.28562262654304504,
-0.07308074831962585,
0.4780964255332947,
-0.20100973546504974,
0.04001991078257561,
-0.5698749423027039,
0.7384238243103027,
0.12125346064567566,
-0.45698148012161255,
0.5375682711601257,
0.19092515110969543,
0.6191862225532532,
-0.8806189894676208,
-0.22670844197273254,
-0.15796321630477905,
0.6876945495605469,
-0.11775361001491547,
-0.3632698953151703,
0.18190422654151917,
-0.3051901161670685,
-0.5633345246315002,
-0.4019086956977844,
0.9509704113006592,
-0.36624675989151,
-0.32734912633895874,
0.3773159086704254,
0.20205067098140717,
0.008754381909966469,
-0.5322049260139465,
-0.7210282683372498,
-0.12413467466831207,
-0.2600313127040863,
-0.0808001309633255,
0.782676100730896,
1.0111712217330933,
-0.34849831461906433,
0.6111250519752502,
0.25807344913482666,
-0.1670597642660141,
0.4048842489719391,
-0.07319413870573044,
0.8294536471366882,
-0.3809191584587097,
-0.7875980138778687,
-0.5775359272956848,
0.3275560736656189,
-0.002999355550855398,
-0.48953816294670105,
0.6202200055122375,
0.423715740442276,
1.006528377532959,
-0.3093603253364563,
0.7963629961013794,
0.2056226134300232,
0.43911001086235046,
-0.671989381313324,
0.6432774066925049,
-0.7908767461776733,
0.08091560751199722,
-0.12371101975440979,
-1.1813703775405884,
-0.5526466965675354,
0.4920823574066162,
0.1913720965385437,
0.09274299442768097,
0.6908959150314331,
0.2327214777469635,
-0.48627835512161255,
-0.1649174988269806,
0.5372444987297058,
-0.036799341440200806,
0.045513737946748734,
0.4835675358772278,
1.0697187185287476,
-0.7116740345954895,
0.3281439542770386,
-0.48556479811668396,
-0.46129462122917175,
-0.18365272879600525,
-0.8726538419723511,
-0.9480725526809692,
-0.7842974662780762,
-0.46113505959510803,
-0.27878040075302124,
-0.006401315331459045,
0.6636962294578552,
1.097111701965332,
-0.8368303179740906,
-0.03150489181280136,
-0.1513504683971405,
0.2812490165233612,
-0.37658336758613586,
-0.2237032800912857,
0.25500088930130005,
-0.5726525783538818,
-0.8346980214118958,
0.0521167516708374,
0.4904351830482483,
0.1937679946422577,
-0.09112407267093658,
-0.07165401428937912,
0.16616623103618622,
0.08022557199001312,
0.7943874597549438,
0.3549017012119293,
-0.25251710414886475,
-0.11417146027088165,
-0.29636523127555847,
0.02531922049820423,
0.1034846380352974,
1.0451587438583374,
-0.7835080623626709,
0.42187923192977905,
0.3660775423049927,
0.7881888151168823,
0.3016974925994873,
0.11494601517915726,
0.1831766813993454,
-1.102203130722046,
0.5640556812286377,
0.29501116275787354,
0.45007824897766113,
0.021246107295155525,
-0.6248348951339722,
0.3973308205604553,
0.3541620373725891,
-0.5941765308380127,
-0.9686335921287537,
0.011962037533521652,
-1.1244083642959595,
-0.41852930188179016,
0.8084233999252319,
-0.3263934552669525,
-0.17234811186790466,
-0.2922586500644684,
-0.09604818373918533,
-0.1903643161058426,
-0.23215973377227783,
0.7546764016151428,
0.5633436441421509,
-0.010970392264425755,
-0.19458188116550446,
-0.479437917470932,
0.2648492157459259,
0.2548964023590088,
-0.9537609219551086,
-0.1344580352306366,
0.2081814408302307,
-0.07535429298877716,
0.10645930469036102,
0.8849530816078186,
-0.16346557438373566,
-0.06853768974542618,
-0.16461504995822906,
-0.18706457316875458,
0.1561686247587204,
-0.8241667747497559,
-0.37666821479797363,
0.2021203488111496,
0.17988194525241852,
-0.3914962410926819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13465v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13465v1
|
Do "English" Named Entity Recognizers Work Well on Global Englishes?
| 2024-04-20T20:48:42 | 2024-04-20T20:48:42 |
Alexander Shan, John Bauer, Riley Carlson, Christopher Manning
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The vast majority of the popular English named entity recognition (NER)
datasets contain American or British English data, despite the existence of
many global varieties of English. As such, it is unclear whether they
generalize for analyzing use of English globally. To test this, we build a
newswire dataset, the Worldwide English NER Dataset, to analyze NER model
performance on low-resource English variants from around the world. We test
widely used NER toolkits and transformer models, including models using the
pre-trained contextual models RoBERTa and ELECTRA, on three datasets: a
commonly used British English newswire dataset, CoNLL 2003, a more American
focused dataset OntoNotes, and our global dataset. All models trained on the
CoNLL or OntoNotes datasets experienced significant performance drops-over 10
F1 in some cases-when tested on the Worldwide English dataset. Upon examination
of region-specific errors, we observe the greatest performance drops for
Oceania and Africa, while Asia and the Middle East had comparatively strong
performance. Lastly, we find that a combined model trained on the Worldwide
dataset and either CoNLL or OntoNotes lost only 1-2 F1 on both test sets.
|
[
-0.40609052777290344,
-0.37745195627212524,
0.3539202809333801,
0.14253821969032288,
-0.13799791038036346,
-0.08722894638776779,
-0.33476462960243225,
-1.0384411811828613,
0.3155352771282196,
0.18971408903598785,
-0.19562333822250366,
-0.21533802151679993,
-0.7285019159317017,
0.8744133710861206,
-0.5520443320274353,
0.761834979057312,
-0.09415178000926971,
0.26608726382255554,
-0.03220426291227341,
-0.3794650435447693,
-0.5307068228721619,
-0.6182570457458496,
-1.1546218395233154,
-0.2585112750530243,
0.7048899531364441,
0.4325156807899475,
0.499385803937912,
0.1432206779718399,
0.8349210619926453,
0.27128663659095764,
-0.29835274815559387,
0.2266945093870163,
-0.30361607670783997,
-0.04107212647795677,
-0.39600637555122375,
-0.35723960399627686,
-0.2203570455312729,
-0.06523425877094269,
0.5710397362709045,
0.48477333784103394,
-0.0380435548722744,
0.013507054187357426,
-0.049956560134887695,
-0.007847443222999573,
-0.4415299594402313,
-0.14129237830638885,
-0.9398667812347412,
0.08702846616506577,
-0.2905980348587036,
0.13711316883563995,
-0.41058844327926636,
-0.07415720820426941,
0.4811832010746002,
-0.6648943424224854,
0.5210320949554443,
0.26590538024902344,
1.2605550289154053,
-0.030137330293655396,
-0.8849422335624695,
-0.38142135739326477,
-1.1043078899383545,
0.7119518518447876,
-0.3209426999092102,
0.7405385971069336,
0.16241799294948578,
0.43226712942123413,
-0.13318194448947906,
-0.5775743722915649,
-0.44952625036239624,
-0.07831823825836182,
-0.3883747160434723,
0.029111096635460854,
-0.5624087452888489,
-0.1660984307527542,
0.30102404952049255,
0.4356119930744171,
-0.4771822392940521,
0.25218892097473145,
-0.49182942509651184,
-0.318642258644104,
0.5301658511161804,
-0.12381070107221603,
0.37701573967933655,
-0.28385624289512634,
-0.3062053620815277,
0.46377062797546387,
-0.9613226652145386,
0.1576043963432312,
0.011606050655245781,
0.6105047464370728,
-0.14819729328155518,
0.2190212905406952,
0.08769802004098892,
0.5080124735832214,
-0.005672236904501915,
-0.309536337852478,
0.08782298117876053,
-0.013099052011966705,
-0.2673368752002716,
0.1323550045490265,
0.4493021070957184,
0.3971582055091858,
0.5557377934455872,
-0.6703732013702393,
-0.35166841745376587,
-0.02912437915802002,
-0.08128950744867325,
-0.8294798731803894,
-0.4196443259716034,
-0.1766611635684967,
-0.19919605553150177,
0.2668331265449524,
0.19510939717292786,
-0.159138023853302,
-0.3457868695259094,
-0.26874908804893494,
0.5386578440666199,
-0.18383236229419708,
-0.38633009791374207,
0.025370538234710693,
-0.2503235638141632,
0.30592769384384155,
0.12264201790094376,
-0.5694668292999268,
0.3973213732242584,
0.4317222833633423,
0.7189372181892395,
-0.35030922293663025,
-0.24623623490333557,
-0.38087040185928345,
0.04304077848792076,
-0.0882837325334549,
0.9834133386611938,
-0.49871522188186646,
-0.21699117124080658,
-0.1948007345199585,
0.5341964364051819,
-0.20407123863697052,
-0.7090139985084534,
0.35808053612709045,
-0.6363914608955383,
0.21974778175354004,
-0.5350853204727173,
-0.5253458619117737,
-0.1077042743563652,
0.35456401109695435,
-1.1593890190124512,
0.5914384722709656,
-0.20217061042785645,
-0.9896852970123291,
0.7818346619606018,
-0.2858498692512512,
-0.7446862459182739,
-0.08258356153964996,
-0.11807627975940704,
-0.24680383503437042,
0.2922136187553406,
0.4215228259563446,
0.46504920721054077,
-0.4259960949420929,
0.3753855228424072,
0.21107836067676544,
-0.6402557492256165,
0.15580616891384125,
-0.7378739714622498,
0.4700443148612976,
-0.14278845489025116,
-0.2081238478422165,
-0.8188719749450684,
-0.9281076192855835,
-0.2755345106124878,
0.30744490027427673,
-0.3236539959907532,
-0.7993400692939758,
0.07332316040992737,
0.23190554976463318,
0.12521612644195557,
-0.3651721775531769,
-0.8259658217430115,
0.1183847188949585,
-0.23009297251701355,
0.46311989426612854,
0.2703396677970886,
0.24987377226352692,
0.3066309988498688,
-0.08606021851301193,
0.6164177060127258,
0.16415514051914215,
-0.30660778284072876,
0.008765935897827148,
-0.37777087092399597,
-0.8680486679077148,
-0.20602606236934662,
0.7836933135986328,
0.6661871671676636,
-0.5636800527572632,
-0.11527471989393234,
-0.5056294798851013,
-0.49118638038635254,
-0.46894708275794983,
-0.33580562472343445,
0.3401744067668915,
0.4251117706298828,
0.4225647449493408,
0.07794494926929474,
-0.8016100525856018,
-1.167940616607666,
-0.4015004336833954,
0.15629644691944122,
-0.1614966094493866,
0.4875915050506592,
0.4695538282394409,
-0.029384450986981392,
0.911035418510437,
0.03955911099910736,
-0.2517330050468445,
-0.4076874554157257,
-0.021840758621692657,
0.14202608168125153,
0.022195812314748764,
0.39454373717308044,
-0.9948779940605164,
-0.33266744017601013,
-0.03579050302505493,
-0.5897656083106995,
0.038759659975767136,
-0.22932903468608856,
0.09969595074653625,
0.3834191858768463,
0.1852392703294754,
-0.37640613317489624,
0.40443575382232666,
0.7021793127059937,
-0.38152602314949036,
0.2515212297439575,
-0.03317875787615776,
0.2792704999446869,
-1.2145609855651855,
0.06199676916003227,
0.10535987466573715,
-0.21242518723011017,
-0.4812500476837158,
-0.3136883080005646,
0.3610079884529114,
0.009212014265358448,
-0.6400923132896423,
0.9359864592552185,
-0.8315051198005676,
0.006185364443808794,
0.160195454955101,
0.08711392432451248,
0.21505238115787506,
-0.05944636091589928,
0.22458070516586304,
1.045988917350769,
0.4716501832008362,
-0.7700558304786682,
0.04035808891057968,
0.2103477567434311,
-0.4644266664981842,
0.6963028907775879,
-0.7105460166931152,
0.046626016497612,
-0.22645467519760132,
0.10624164342880249,
-0.6089361906051636,
-0.24070410430431366,
-0.20211289823055267,
-0.07744713127613068,
0.2729657292366028,
-0.3504965901374817,
-0.1599423885345459,
-0.4386836290359497,
0.22211676836013794,
0.18354663252830505,
0.1398252546787262,
-0.9736968278884888,
0.48913997411727905,
0.5441761612892151,
-0.033122967928647995,
-0.572035014629364,
-1.040101170539856,
0.2853585481643677,
-0.37168651819229126,
-0.5462140440940857,
0.6974680423736572,
0.3260139524936676,
-0.30787044763565063,
0.009383061900734901,
-0.38961082696914673,
-0.30006644129753113,
0.11955166608095169,
0.13721467554569244,
0.10671625286340714,
-0.32613471150398254,
0.22812707722187042,
-0.17934280633926392,
-0.0804562196135521,
0.071382075548172,
0.05896464362740517,
0.018914097920060158,
0.02667047828435898,
-0.08129511773586273,
-0.23554092645645142,
0.255125492811203,
0.33759841322898865,
-0.47101566195487976,
0.8111725449562073,
0.20765197277069092,
-0.6426162719726562,
-0.28999441862106323,
-0.6259486079216003,
-0.06149325147271156,
-0.41373786330223083,
0.41025930643081665,
-0.6502730846405029,
-0.7549306154251099,
0.8223285675048828,
0.2404278814792633,
-0.08811696618795395,
0.4276229739189148,
-0.1309158205986023,
0.06890668720006943,
0.8032768964767456,
0.6902117729187012,
-0.21407447755336761,
0.19126828014850616,
-0.5377482175827026,
0.6616622805595398,
-0.6804189085960388,
-0.16088512539863586,
-0.5131980180740356,
-0.5450949668884277,
-0.8134064674377441,
0.034250885248184204,
0.08887847512960434,
0.12153563648462296,
0.033204905688762665,
0.5512862205505371,
-0.3929918110370636,
1.0501867532730103,
0.2730632424354553,
-0.3535785973072052,
0.48980993032455444,
0.09757141023874283,
-0.019813809543848038,
-0.4380761682987213,
-0.5880637764930725,
-0.5112078785896301,
0.909208357334137,
0.016750270500779152,
0.7441737651824951,
0.1279851496219635,
0.7564135789871216,
0.07251576334238052,
0.36142870783805847,
-0.6439984440803528,
0.43981263041496277,
-0.37311825156211853,
-0.454497367143631,
0.05065881088376045,
-0.395297110080719,
-1.362117052078247,
0.15332326292991638,
-0.07781731337308884,
-0.49576786160469055,
0.19291026890277863,
0.11936845630407333,
-0.2968465983867645,
0.6149224638938904,
-0.5663893222808838,
0.7577432990074158,
-0.28445035219192505,
0.22860392928123474,
0.2913815677165985,
-0.14591161906719208,
0.1992443948984146,
-0.10669046640396118,
0.39669689536094666,
-0.1902962476015091,
0.030150925740599632,
0.707292914390564,
0.12147438526153564,
0.19681617617607117,
-0.3020806908607483,
-0.009339914657175541,
0.10209855437278748,
0.021393436938524246,
0.526412308216095,
0.3632870018482208,
-0.08099696040153503,
0.7242319583892822,
-0.3339152932167053,
-0.039973121136426926,
-0.47902044653892517,
0.6584934592247009,
-0.6548795700073242,
-0.32477083802223206,
-0.40947920083999634,
-0.20056815445423126,
-0.05653044208884239,
0.18981356918811798,
0.6832787394523621,
0.8083529472351074,
-0.41232722997665405,
0.2961410880088806,
0.39997345209121704,
0.09603354334831238,
0.447512686252594,
0.8932505249977112,
-0.11076018214225769,
-0.3435628414154053,
0.6922899484634399,
0.6350534558296204,
-0.05742897093296051,
0.42723548412323,
-0.14924542605876923,
-0.05979315564036369,
-0.649679958820343,
-0.30907294154167175,
0.2071039229631424,
-0.42468100786209106,
-0.4252640902996063,
-0.6717616319656372,
-0.3758247196674347,
0.03820233419537544,
-0.16728900372982025,
-0.07995367795228958,
-0.3555183708667755,
0.04743189364671707,
-0.2310289442539215,
0.3281075358390808,
0.7959371209144592,
0.15476128458976746,
0.059489838778972626,
-0.7919384837150574,
0.24623973667621613,
0.22712428867816925,
0.2562483251094818,
-0.3636705279350281,
-0.602281928062439,
-0.3281765580177307,
-0.09367892891168594,
0.14829757809638977,
-1.01300048828125,
0.2906310260295868,
0.42766493558883667,
0.5617789030075073,
0.128801628947258,
-0.004008917137980461,
0.7290372252464294,
-0.8416492938995361,
0.7249584197998047,
-0.43276387453079224,
-0.654106855392456,
0.46806806325912476,
-0.08701702207326889,
0.14298787713050842,
0.6347059607505798,
0.5899785161018372,
-0.9007912874221802,
-0.6987431049346924,
-0.6072235703468323,
-0.9605823755264282,
0.4868168532848358,
0.07655796408653259,
0.32631364464759827,
-0.4778119921684265,
0.3185194134712219,
0.10745241492986679,
-0.010574504733085632,
-0.8973138332366943,
-0.33797687292099,
0.5365567803382874,
0.030393123626708984,
-0.0364561565220356,
0.06421791762113571,
0.46058931946754456,
-0.12376372516155243,
0.8804067373275757,
0.13222286105155945,
0.16390372812747955,
0.5380386710166931,
-0.5115903615951538,
0.07913511246442795,
0.4444984197616577,
-0.06195739656686783,
0.6695475578308105,
-0.0792812928557396,
0.04460548609495163,
0.3438623249530792,
-0.5170132517814636,
0.32364729046821594,
0.4014475345611572,
-0.6872855424880981,
0.40381985902786255,
0.24977914988994598,
0.6487112045288086,
0.6082139015197754,
-0.5056474804878235,
0.4100498855113983,
-0.600608766078949,
0.04789220541715622,
-0.5594519376754761,
-0.015560820698738098,
0.078070268034935,
0.09363006055355072,
0.5383129715919495,
0.22303809225559235,
0.19967448711395264,
-0.1251276731491089,
0.03305281698703766,
0.5576611757278442,
-0.02503061108291149,
-0.3846680521965027,
0.7197033762931824,
0.35234707593917847,
-0.6180746555328369,
0.7855184674263,
-0.6199498176574707,
-0.5792965292930603,
0.8966023325920105,
0.8547659516334534,
0.7329012155532837,
-0.1761048436164856,
-0.02174968644976616,
0.42137840390205383,
0.5567391514778137,
-0.10366795212030411,
0.34546276926994324,
0.2649732530117035,
-0.9889007806777954,
-0.36128857731819153,
-0.4179520010948181,
-0.5625402927398682,
0.45302528142929077,
-0.7847834229469299,
0.4694754481315613,
-0.015668310225009918,
-0.2022668570280075,
0.22213025391101837,
0.008559947833418846,
-1.3411508798599243,
0.3974069356918335,
0.37896713614463806,
1.0612919330596924,
-1.0746508836746216,
0.5958079695701599,
1.1705437898635864,
-0.2617183327674866,
-1.2077670097351074,
0.2193562537431717,
0.004461524076759815,
-0.3388802707195282,
0.6350003480911255,
0.7710018157958984,
0.06899277865886688,
0.06551899015903473,
-0.051201384514570236,
-1.4473024606704712,
1.1544513702392578,
0.31825247406959534,
-0.6730207204818726,
-0.08199068158864975,
0.13499081134796143,
0.36551496386528015,
-0.30632129311561584,
0.49645957350730896,
0.6126915216445923,
0.29931777715682983,
-0.1816479116678238,
-1.216953992843628,
-0.23516468703746796,
-0.2972147762775421,
-0.03343928977847099,
0.566294252872467,
-0.6606162786483765,
0.8123651742935181,
-0.1958148032426834,
-0.542043924331665,
-0.26725712418556213,
0.5226708054542542,
0.04068455100059509,
0.26059532165527344,
0.5278832316398621,
0.6854296922683716,
1.174146056175232,
-0.2704187333583832,
0.9140410423278809,
-0.31166931986808777,
0.29436179995536804,
1.089247703552246,
-0.5763146281242371,
1.1045989990234375,
0.1608392894268036,
-0.289120614528656,
0.5204616189002991,
0.4446273446083069,
-0.18700216710567474,
0.43443793058395386,
0.03667725250124931,
-0.04572368413209915,
-0.16266803443431854,
-0.1338208168745041,
-0.20192879438400269,
0.6800890564918518,
0.018727010115981102,
-0.14371097087860107,
-0.2204681932926178,
0.35774531960487366,
0.2957787811756134,
-0.23214352130889893,
-0.44485360383987427,
0.631104588508606,
-0.02302488498389721,
-0.6967242360115051,
0.4667243957519531,
0.08632583916187286,
1.0197653770446777,
-0.46108660101890564,
0.1577191799879074,
-0.6405361294746399,
0.18359410762786865,
-0.08371489495038986,
-0.35375022888183594,
0.3548263907432556,
0.31847116351127625,
-0.3320261240005493,
0.12633702158927917,
0.8823646306991577,
-0.4993138015270233,
-0.7332811951637268,
0.5849671363830566,
0.4706711173057556,
0.325388103723526,
-0.09867154806852341,
-0.2683095633983612,
-0.22341148555278778,
-0.18624132871627808,
-0.2572495639324188,
0.12770353257656097,
0.5012773871421814,
-0.11403957009315491,
0.42604419589042664,
0.2728399336338043,
0.35304567217826843,
-0.047029219567775726,
0.2214268445968628,
0.3034915328025818,
-0.667589545249939,
-0.34527072310447693,
-0.6628640294075012,
0.4951367974281311,
-0.29265451431274414,
-0.29212120175361633,
0.8872777223587036,
0.8191665410995483,
1.285408854484558,
0.31497427821159363,
0.7485561370849609,
-0.0842265635728836,
0.783694863319397,
-0.5211585760116577,
0.6543385982513428,
-0.6046054363250732,
0.11816918104887009,
-0.016182955354452133,
-1.0724815130233765,
-0.366036981344223,
0.577587902545929,
-0.27778175473213196,
-0.13030585646629333,
0.7288074493408203,
0.6755614280700684,
-0.4737362861633301,
0.15649116039276123,
0.27419525384902954,
0.22797814011573792,
0.2246202826499939,
0.5318405032157898,
0.79062819480896,
-0.6913231015205383,
0.6415005326271057,
-0.27705639600753784,
0.3400648534297943,
0.11693163216114044,
-1.0280264616012573,
-0.831337034702301,
-0.1940387487411499,
-0.35893872380256653,
-0.22307270765304565,
0.2802381217479706,
0.9686718583106995,
0.6865829825401306,
-1.106626272201538,
0.3092089295387268,
0.09403201937675476,
0.010655841790139675,
0.023658977821469307,
-0.23630045354366302,
0.2793142795562744,
0.03656349703669548,
-0.7906402945518494,
0.579098105430603,
-0.1194940134882927,
0.10373010486364365,
0.02675950527191162,
0.10770528018474579,
0.13970868289470673,
0.10855598747730255,
0.31115636229515076,
0.17655427753925323,
-0.8438092470169067,
-0.539546549320221,
0.3002345860004425,
-0.2065996378660202,
0.021109193563461304,
0.7149145603179932,
-0.9804911017417908,
0.07522229105234146,
0.08021169155836105,
0.5557234287261963,
0.003067143028602004,
-0.045214973390102386,
0.373233437538147,
-0.9798306226730347,
0.10293614119291306,
0.16074210405349731,
0.7842880487442017,
0.7374776005744934,
-0.5029979348182678,
0.5602648854255676,
0.13294421136379242,
-0.7897786498069763,
-0.6862617135047913,
-0.2643738090991974,
-0.3416302502155304,
0.17240644991397858,
1.2344996929168701,
-0.169918492436409,
0.10667009651660919,
-0.21865525841712952,
0.11535698920488358,
-0.13156341016292572,
-0.3623346984386444,
0.47276008129119873,
0.8038679957389832,
0.053367216140031815,
0.11130045354366302,
-0.6774954795837402,
0.3424137830734253,
0.18712107837200165,
-0.7151594161987305,
-0.19391001760959625,
0.5928099751472473,
0.6061583161354065,
0.18058915436267853,
0.6419905424118042,
0.31412437558174133,
0.24316468834877014,
-0.2612518072128296,
0.00669085094705224,
0.0745469331741333,
-0.7534518837928772,
-0.48033270239830017,
-0.1139759048819542,
0.007080717943608761,
-0.06021273136138916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13439v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13439v1
|
Fine-Grained Named Entities for Corona News
| 2024-04-20T18:22:49 | 2024-04-20T18:22:49 |
Sefika Efeoglu, Adrian Paschke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Information resources such as newspapers have produced unstructured text data
in various languages related to the corona outbreak since December 2019.
Analyzing these unstructured texts is time-consuming without representing them
in a structured format; therefore, representing them in a structured format is
crucial. An information extraction pipeline with essential tasks -- named
entity tagging and relation extraction -- to accomplish this goal might be
applied to these texts. This study proposes a data annotation pipeline to
generate training data from corona news articles, including generic and
domain-specific entities. Named entity recognition models are trained on this
annotated corpus and then evaluated on test sentences manually annotated by
domain experts evaluating the performance of a trained model. The code base and
demonstration are available at https://github.com/sefeoglu/coronanews-ner.git.
|
[
-0.29036659002304077,
-0.859582245349884,
0.6498225927352905,
0.3966509997844696,
-0.2408665120601654,
0.2276366800069809,
-0.3185436427593231,
-0.758886456489563,
0.3210049569606781,
0.6844131946563721,
-0.2735041379928589,
-0.6528472900390625,
-0.431546688079834,
-0.016911737620830536,
-0.8179238438606262,
1.5258278846740723,
-0.10167089849710464,
-0.11182604730129242,
-0.07429496943950653,
0.3395400643348694,
-0.17834357917308807,
-0.18453837931156158,
-0.8784183263778687,
-0.17270776629447937,
0.7186934947967529,
0.48982176184654236,
0.3790897727012634,
0.620731770992279,
0.7061916589736938,
0.09270881116390228,
0.21966423094272614,
0.22593896090984344,
-0.2976604998111725,
-0.02575233392417431,
-0.29000306129455566,
-0.20226262509822845,
-0.3548997938632965,
0.17013834416866302,
0.3066290616989136,
0.44459208846092224,
0.2356794774532318,
0.26200950145721436,
-0.04403056204319,
0.44651663303375244,
-0.6008988618850708,
0.24285012483596802,
-0.9207980036735535,
-0.12484358996152878,
-0.4839465916156769,
-0.344454288482666,
-0.4299742579460144,
-0.10459326952695847,
0.24643701314926147,
-0.68541419506073,
0.3003605008125305,
0.17152473330497742,
1.3573817014694214,
0.09803932905197144,
-0.23759035766124725,
-0.41651347279548645,
-0.9623866081237793,
0.6080244183540344,
-0.1726003736257553,
0.24177280068397522,
0.4173218607902527,
0.14222797751426697,
-0.14509570598602295,
-0.9139266610145569,
-0.23682332038879395,
-0.009015921503305435,
0.09613753855228424,
0.17081882059574127,
-0.30434703826904297,
-0.018085654824972153,
-0.1772267073392868,
0.570301353931427,
-0.29805120825767517,
0.3425825536251068,
-0.5203176736831665,
-0.08505088090896606,
0.6943213939666748,
-0.052969928830862045,
0.14376838505268097,
-0.5559535026550293,
-0.676137387752533,
0.4758925139904022,
-0.5164942145347595,
0.04215417057275772,
0.3128974735736847,
0.43020784854888916,
-0.07746998220682144,
0.6517155766487122,
-0.15507373213768005,
0.5753375887870789,
0.12932650744915009,
-0.33416271209716797,
0.09765952080488205,
0.14535368978977203,
-0.5880630612373352,
0.3139296770095825,
0.6017317175865173,
0.3950788080692291,
0.26418203115463257,
-0.7054550647735596,
-0.1498207002878189,
0.13164107501506805,
0.4701085388660431,
-0.6839881539344788,
-0.6342381834983826,
0.2746109366416931,
-0.2933051884174347,
-0.5991318821907043,
0.30374640226364136,
-0.8348096013069153,
-0.3160839378833771,
-0.433003306388855,
0.10848689079284668,
-0.40492671728134155,
0.09378323704004288,
-0.10218232870101929,
-0.5166613459587097,
0.16894227266311646,
0.5006169676780701,
-0.5900404453277588,
0.12560540437698364,
0.5534349083900452,
0.4831875264644623,
-0.2610824406147003,
-0.015010574832558632,
-0.7276293635368347,
0.35081395506858826,
0.07061293721199036,
1.1736198663711548,
-0.7668420672416687,
-0.09460395574569702,
-0.18305794894695282,
0.13523800671100616,
-0.04034189134836197,
-0.37694433331489563,
0.6286118030548096,
-0.6744553446769714,
-0.05313664674758911,
0.054345034062862396,
-0.777262270450592,
0.13425275683403015,
0.05758803337812424,
-0.6309391260147095,
1.00567626953125,
0.33605149388313293,
-1.1809465885162354,
0.34518465399742126,
-0.2567068040370941,
-0.5024048686027527,
0.19680316746234894,
-0.09978987276554108,
-0.530548632144928,
0.06297138333320618,
0.3632134795188904,
0.5549030303955078,
-0.2512935698032379,
0.3609674870967865,
-0.1714530885219574,
0.1436397284269333,
0.008461975492537022,
-0.009868068620562553,
0.5357685089111328,
0.2345641404390335,
-0.10126501321792603,
-0.13065166771411896,
-1.2116310596466064,
-0.2764908969402313,
0.011074801906943321,
-0.47807368636131287,
-0.7982758283615112,
-0.07081322371959686,
0.4929068088531494,
-0.048648007214069366,
0.05230148881673813,
-0.6122835874557495,
0.4204654097557068,
-0.08787353336811066,
0.36234521865844727,
0.38485509157180786,
0.5610074400901794,
0.5468884110450745,
-0.01517481915652752,
0.45229455828666687,
0.21549655497074127,
0.06763533502817154,
-0.13561639189720154,
-0.3781365752220154,
-0.9483675360679626,
-0.4587966203689575,
0.6155030131340027,
0.6402009725570679,
-1.1231663227081299,
0.31121164560317993,
-0.15297143161296844,
-0.8186375498771667,
-0.3625738024711609,
-0.06192708760499954,
0.2433701455593109,
0.8111463785171509,
0.3793938457965851,
-0.14914001524448395,
-1.0215381383895874,
-0.88565593957901,
-0.27296537160873413,
0.09936867654323578,
0.015027305111289024,
0.22253760695457458,
0.6073929667472839,
-0.3599342107772827,
1.3201115131378174,
-0.6566931009292603,
-0.372303307056427,
-0.022268440574407578,
0.6284444332122803,
-0.26836442947387695,
0.3689199984073639,
0.33108147978782654,
-0.9601765871047974,
-0.13709503412246704,
0.06347311288118362,
-0.5957805514335632,
-0.07657542824745178,
-0.3094549775123596,
-0.045966096222400665,
-0.1468368023633957,
0.49392539262771606,
-0.396557480096817,
0.4914197623729706,
0.39890536665916443,
-0.03838259354233742,
0.6837722063064575,
0.1353113353252411,
-0.033022522926330566,
-1.1300204992294312,
0.035418231040239334,
0.3464856445789337,
-0.5765793323516846,
-0.5972014665603638,
-0.1085914820432663,
0.10579642653465271,
-0.17076578736305237,
-0.7311128973960876,
0.6962369084358215,
-0.48318591713905334,
-0.24254335463047028,
-0.3465092182159424,
0.4001098871231079,
0.26947668194770813,
0.08782713115215302,
0.5073941349983215,
0.5126863121986389,
0.6919503808021545,
-0.8661082983016968,
0.5484166145324707,
0.033210258930921555,
-0.2826543152332306,
0.6118781566619873,
-0.3456471264362335,
-0.17651253938674927,
-0.3742349147796631,
0.18197061121463776,
-0.2742895781993866,
-0.37463611364364624,
0.04621677100658417,
-0.28521692752838135,
0.1780090481042862,
-0.28200262784957886,
-0.44034138321876526,
-0.4494641125202179,
-0.16057947278022766,
0.01646333560347557,
-0.010954806581139565,
-0.419821172952652,
0.1773505061864853,
0.7648020386695862,
-0.07421701401472092,
-0.2859821617603302,
-0.6309174299240112,
0.1313410997390747,
-0.4238060712814331,
-0.3003445565700531,
0.6781185865402222,
0.3882189095020294,
-0.24027758836746216,
0.2623746395111084,
-0.07517674565315247,
-0.7349488735198975,
0.3440038859844208,
0.28079062700271606,
0.35101306438446045,
-0.1939762681722641,
0.4463862478733063,
0.08620141446590424,
-0.04597899317741394,
-0.2742518484592438,
-0.18285420536994934,
0.4048740863800049,
-0.05368468537926674,
0.3499508798122406,
-0.43696945905685425,
0.20579147338867188,
0.21276767551898956,
-0.617821216583252,
0.6807266473770142,
0.7502050995826721,
-0.75911945104599,
-0.09335719794034958,
-0.21786047518253326,
0.17361438274383545,
-0.2944386303424835,
0.020635174587368965,
-0.27685508131980896,
-0.7912962436676025,
0.6728013753890991,
-0.24981820583343506,
-0.09319619089365005,
0.8379722237586975,
0.17743687331676483,
-0.05674378573894501,
0.2861444652080536,
0.7478649020195007,
-0.20217269659042358,
0.38783854246139526,
-0.3048616945743561,
0.10612299293279648,
-0.9395142197608948,
-0.3825177550315857,
-0.5821648240089417,
-0.003364875679835677,
-0.31338411569595337,
-0.40265291929244995,
-0.0523623451590538,
0.5057867169380188,
0.10802007466554642,
0.867569625377655,
-0.482369989156723,
0.31316956877708435,
0.3907858729362488,
-0.17593863606452942,
0.543120801448822,
-0.15358269214630127,
0.25460779666900635,
0.023025497794151306,
-0.15072135627269745,
-0.7104759812355042,
0.7513585090637207,
0.546531617641449,
1.0140726566314697,
-0.44040846824645996,
0.8499245047569275,
0.34835517406463623,
0.47709643840789795,
-0.8369544148445129,
0.011018297635018826,
-0.2400040179491043,
-0.38404396176338196,
0.006150904111564159,
-0.26130080223083496,
-1.2147032022476196,
-0.4308733344078064,
-0.10793611407279968,
-0.9705876708030701,
0.42521119117736816,
-0.2425900399684906,
-0.6406744718551636,
0.11227991431951523,
-0.506650447845459,
0.568070113658905,
-0.06188904494047165,
0.3050079643726349,
0.21747587621212006,
-0.2872181236743927,
0.4724782407283783,
-0.3726677894592285,
0.28146252036094666,
-0.32937899231910706,
0.10739347338676453,
0.8142247200012207,
-0.19154514372348785,
0.5080457329750061,
0.0762469694018364,
-0.0974879190325737,
0.5023952126502991,
-0.3245548605918884,
0.4763946235179901,
0.5908448696136475,
0.17032375931739807,
0.08968444168567657,
-0.33423954248428345,
-0.17778833210468292,
-0.18270570039749146,
0.7439271807670593,
-0.45228663086891174,
-0.031759653240442276,
-0.322089284658432,
-0.2575756013393402,
-0.0010154170449823141,
0.2589235007762909,
0.4886270761489868,
0.5333604216575623,
-0.3690379858016968,
0.026899397373199463,
0.5294148325920105,
0.003468514885753393,
0.5568019151687622,
0.50938880443573,
-0.44622039794921875,
-0.4041185677051544,
0.8425506949424744,
0.11497488617897034,
-0.256691575050354,
0.6770583391189575,
-0.303835928440094,
0.24694503843784332,
-0.43992114067077637,
-0.40486592054367065,
-0.09211765974760056,
-0.20875228941440582,
-0.7274741530418396,
-0.7921903133392334,
-0.6100190281867981,
-0.36146271228790283,
-0.2584620714187622,
-0.6845960021018982,
-0.4593735635280609,
-0.8459976315498352,
-0.1176910325884819,
0.34550735354423523,
0.7365643978118896,
0.44449111819267273,
0.5872943997383118,
-0.921177864074707,
0.4226875305175781,
0.207307830452919,
0.1491411030292511,
-0.35004276037216187,
-0.010232816450297832,
-0.48668941855430603,
-0.10032760351896286,
-0.4944418966770172,
-0.8496809005737305,
0.42578235268592834,
0.22794635593891144,
0.1868797391653061,
0.6046727299690247,
0.24796916544437408,
0.9493748545646667,
-0.5678560137748718,
0.6941621899604797,
-0.040087342262268066,
-0.8952778577804565,
1.0904090404510498,
-0.40063825249671936,
-0.16956225037574768,
0.5396984219551086,
0.4283798933029175,
-0.4008125066757202,
-0.8117685914039612,
-0.9008621573448181,
-0.7519352436065674,
0.5398404598236084,
0.4278213381767273,
-0.24959531426429749,
-0.46967893838882446,
0.49174943566322327,
0.13220351934432983,
0.30149003863334656,
-0.5657935738563538,
-0.3966485857963562,
0.15066254138946533,
-0.0331374853849411,
0.3034800589084625,
-0.1831342577934265,
0.1758662760257721,
-0.06308534741401672,
0.7221078276634216,
0.16101038455963135,
0.2851736545562744,
0.5534660816192627,
-0.3767138719558716,
-0.07951613515615463,
0.23295728862285614,
0.3426092267036438,
0.41412585973739624,
-0.11148250848054886,
0.27551063895225525,
-0.39644360542297363,
-0.3964223861694336,
-0.2379164695739746,
0.5046954154968262,
-0.1081242710351944,
0.24685604870319366,
0.32792824506759644,
0.8405175805091858,
0.5881263017654419,
-0.5657068490982056,
0.5357795357704163,
-0.11554396152496338,
0.2137969583272934,
-0.7005727887153625,
0.06656042486429214,
-0.1742403358221054,
0.4028016924858093,
0.5239836573600769,
0.2810765206813812,
0.33992496132850647,
-0.6478930115699768,
0.44674935936927795,
0.28149041533470154,
-0.37269169092178345,
-0.3968712091445923,
0.8037281632423401,
0.270138680934906,
-0.0657423660159111,
0.5225767493247986,
-0.39322414994239807,
-0.3224155008792877,
0.5869584679603577,
0.4232747554779053,
0.6858367919921875,
-0.1558270901441574,
0.47741636633872986,
0.09867912530899048,
0.14485138654708862,
-0.12595634162425995,
-0.007920905016362667,
0.20835086703300476,
-0.5972069501876831,
-0.21744105219841003,
-0.8567866086959839,
-0.028001733124256134,
0.4876318573951721,
-0.8630340099334717,
0.6924357414245605,
-0.3122752904891968,
-0.2730638384819031,
0.7201508283615112,
0.2774643301963806,
-0.8618354201316833,
0.4087885320186615,
0.5382621884346008,
1.1910321712493896,
-0.9521195888519287,
0.9737746715545654,
0.7589495182037354,
-0.5521418452262878,
-0.7489907145500183,
0.05246854946017265,
-0.4450668394565582,
-0.6040482521057129,
0.636313259601593,
0.3008272051811218,
0.5042794346809387,
0.19280527532100677,
-0.3717617392539978,
-0.9506960511207581,
1.0985585451126099,
0.3743783235549927,
-0.5411707162857056,
-0.4259166121482849,
-0.11018936336040497,
0.42909863591194153,
-0.8757508993148804,
-0.03548811003565788,
0.5705567002296448,
0.5116420388221741,
-0.18475647270679474,
-1.0141451358795166,
-0.4783722758293152,
0.014698904938995838,
0.11373350769281387,
0.25062379240989685,
-0.5548945665359497,
0.7000842094421387,
-0.0573725588619709,
-0.3485526740550995,
0.033256325870752335,
0.9714111685752869,
-0.1370004266500473,
0.6734026074409485,
0.1363082230091095,
0.9376655220985413,
1.1505295038223267,
-0.12219294905662537,
1.0428125858306885,
0.026961522176861763,
0.7379490733146667,
1.3724442720413208,
0.0034112122375518084,
0.7244458794593811,
0.36816686391830444,
-0.026314150542020798,
0.7957415580749512,
0.8559648394584656,
-0.31420308351516724,
0.6623868346214294,
0.03743581846356392,
-0.16728666424751282,
-0.045745477080345154,
-0.4502003490924835,
0.05041326582431793,
0.7358152866363525,
0.36351707577705383,
-0.842658281326294,
-0.529106616973877,
0.533241868019104,
0.3585262894630432,
-0.16421326994895935,
-0.8277690410614014,
0.6710370182991028,
0.1249881237745285,
-0.48910510540008545,
0.0036382379475980997,
0.4239391088485718,
0.3138861060142517,
-0.056716445833444595,
0.2210918515920639,
0.1524686962366104,
-0.06913445144891739,
-0.5176841020584106,
-0.7215216159820557,
0.4231830835342407,
0.4020674228668213,
-0.5376496911048889,
0.12510742247104645,
0.9098060131072998,
-0.669813334941864,
-0.5659285187721252,
0.06320858746767044,
0.2972158193588257,
0.31892016530036926,
-0.4000968933105469,
-0.4226000905036926,
-0.12903855741024017,
-0.1883821040391922,
-0.3122136890888214,
0.08061789721250534,
0.3497866094112396,
-0.2625528872013092,
0.2729196846485138,
0.35797983407974243,
0.22558651864528656,
0.1424143761396408,
0.1312008798122406,
0.9789382219314575,
-0.5994791984558105,
-0.29899507761001587,
-0.7223032712936401,
0.5528175234794617,
-0.2936345636844635,
-0.4107055962085724,
0.7265902161598206,
1.011497139930725,
0.6616566181182861,
-0.14229930937290192,
0.6453396081924438,
-0.17368167638778687,
0.38440951704978943,
-0.5072283744812012,
0.4775538742542267,
-0.14154702425003052,
0.10038947314023972,
-0.3105795979499817,
-1.012988567352295,
-0.3462524712085724,
0.31028276681900024,
-0.28348368406295776,
-0.4945496618747711,
0.7346982955932617,
0.12929201126098633,
-0.047169193625450134,
0.0751192569732666,
-0.14950662851333618,
0.011047130450606346,
0.3571247458457947,
0.40842461585998535,
0.4974178671836853,
-0.5353665947914124,
0.22438620030879974,
-0.4885248839855194,
-0.035645078867673874,
-0.28879448771476746,
-0.9340962171554565,
-0.9344387054443359,
-0.6512765288352966,
-0.6708685755729675,
-0.09401322156190872,
-0.05153777077794075,
0.6649599671363831,
0.6925833821296692,
-0.6079511642456055,
0.5878801941871643,
-0.4358178377151489,
0.13278377056121826,
0.184748575091362,
-0.39552080631256104,
0.5320029258728027,
-0.49173733592033386,
-0.8290843367576599,
0.265970379114151,
0.41374051570892334,
0.11378821730613708,
-0.1912151426076889,
0.4333791434764862,
-0.029623601585626602,
-0.05024426057934761,
0.44808557629585266,
0.30247801542282104,
-0.5334765911102295,
-0.5092222094535828,
-0.2781928479671478,
-0.3021935820579529,
0.03317746892571449,
0.8150667548179626,
-1.006432294845581,
0.17570431530475616,
0.13516634702682495,
0.6626666784286499,
0.40905219316482544,
0.3107638657093048,
0.14764095842838287,
-1.267957091331482,
0.14327555894851685,
0.22282828390598297,
0.28483808040618896,
0.37662041187286377,
-0.759238064289093,
0.33483463525772095,
0.24776776134967804,
-0.6171719431877136,
-0.7000690698623657,
0.03145121783018112,
-1.1820400953292847,
-0.10455627739429474,
1.25737726688385,
-0.29152247309684753,
-0.47856709361076355,
-0.18106764554977417,
-0.09176190942525864,
0.34935247898101807,
-0.6142025589942932,
0.7025002241134644,
0.6100845336914062,
-0.18445494771003723,
-0.20150962471961975,
-0.40019506216049194,
0.5809621214866638,
-0.5638900399208069,
-1.1597014665603638,
-0.05227476730942726,
0.22037027776241302,
0.2869131863117218,
0.2758939266204834,
0.5892390608787537,
-0.05464937537908554,
0.10270810127258301,
-0.24464507400989532,
0.15916724503040314,
0.12395481765270233,
-0.7658292651176453,
-0.011275545693933964,
0.09984982758760452,
-0.13104397058486938,
-0.16805753111839294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14449v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14449v1
|
Predicting Question Quality on StackOverflow with Neural Networks
| 2024-04-20T16:48:18 | 2024-04-20T16:48:18 |
Mohammad Al-Ramahi, Izzat Alsmadi, Abdullah Wahbeh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The wealth of information available through the Internet and social media is
unprecedented. Within computing fields, websites such as Stack Overflow are
considered important sources for users seeking solutions to their computing and
programming issues. However, like other social media platforms, Stack Overflow
contains a mixture of relevant and irrelevant information. In this paper, we
evaluated neural network models to predict the quality of questions on Stack
Overflow, as an example of Question Answering (QA) communities. Our results
demonstrate the effectiveness of neural network models compared to baseline
machine learning models, achieving an accuracy of 80%. Furthermore, our
findings indicate that the number of layers in the neural network model can
significantly impact its performance.
|
[
-0.4844946563243866,
-0.8630328178405762,
0.5513797998428345,
0.1444808393716812,
-0.001995559548959136,
0.20961767435073853,
0.3322014808654785,
-0.5332277417182922,
0.42745235562324524,
0.35601380467414856,
-0.31876736879348755,
-0.2508451044559479,
-0.4089698791503906,
-0.3503085970878601,
-0.7436702251434326,
0.9067068099975586,
0.2451566755771637,
0.366446316242218,
-0.7130580544471741,
0.13880810141563416,
-0.33006641268730164,
-0.4632796347141266,
-1.0513485670089722,
-0.23041898012161255,
0.8137533068656921,
-0.15644992887973785,
0.770444393157959,
0.42886677384376526,
0.4532133936882019,
0.2873571813106537,
-0.453500896692276,
0.19216008484363556,
-0.4166714549064636,
0.062236227095127106,
-0.14457009732723236,
-0.4468008875846863,
-0.10098128765821457,
-0.29478898644447327,
0.32400408387184143,
0.705750584602356,
-0.08373004198074341,
0.5494681000709534,
0.1490749716758728,
0.4177674949169159,
-0.5853621959686279,
-0.1080690324306488,
-0.5950387716293335,
-0.08431509137153625,
0.42497527599334717,
-0.30869022011756897,
0.09212110191583633,
-0.916508138179779,
0.0302409827709198,
-0.3415190577507019,
-0.13410627841949463,
-0.08999969810247421,
0.6378348469734192,
0.25048741698265076,
-0.17633281648159027,
-0.17860326170921326,
-0.6981001496315002,
0.6157090663909912,
-0.919947624206543,
0.14981535077095032,
0.5457497239112854,
0.4029232859611511,
-0.21048018336296082,
-0.5668362975120544,
-0.5114061832427979,
-0.033281952142715454,
0.009382828138768673,
0.2605898976325989,
-0.3917606770992279,
-0.2223808914422989,
0.08044975996017456,
0.15235300362110138,
-0.6866926550865173,
0.20025339722633362,
-0.7882149815559387,
0.04955023527145386,
0.49591511487960815,
0.1962602138519287,
0.5010124444961548,
-0.41025492548942566,
-0.3175412118434906,
0.3761909008026123,
-0.18258193135261536,
0.3416092097759247,
0.38659581542015076,
0.08028586208820343,
0.49670013785362244,
0.400433748960495,
-0.09919831156730652,
0.6887996196746826,
-0.013357318006455898,
0.1633615344762802,
-0.031394459307193756,
-0.37363937497138977,
-0.061238572001457214,
-0.24609586596488953,
0.5832496881484985,
0.4560210704803467,
0.2653339207172394,
-0.20539233088493347,
-0.10083744674921036,
-0.16847825050354004,
0.7519540190696716,
-0.7786062359809875,
-0.054792679846286774,
0.7238542437553406,
-0.5642569065093994,
-0.4125339388847351,
0.04561992362141609,
-0.32050302624702454,
-0.5163555145263672,
-0.12170086801052094,
0.2865956127643585,
-0.22669453918933868,
-0.4987022876739502,
-0.06407728046178818,
-0.3414238691329956,
-0.1412033587694168,
0.33573606610298157,
-0.34043949842453003,
0.19718345999717712,
0.8708688616752625,
0.9701203107833862,
-0.12699538469314575,
-0.19545653462409973,
-0.35276660323143005,
-0.5979036092758179,
-0.3442104756832123,
0.7434220910072327,
-0.3212991952896118,
0.09554331004619598,
0.13737979531288147,
-0.3666420578956604,
-0.1003214418888092,
-0.3878195583820343,
0.3157833218574524,
-1.225252628326416,
0.10809648036956787,
-0.15443746745586395,
-0.9300423860549927,
-0.21421438455581665,
0.6920091509819031,
-0.900915801525116,
0.6808425188064575,
0.04527386277914047,
-0.5526010394096375,
0.07106754928827286,
-0.6611024737358093,
-0.28536516427993774,
0.08841616660356522,
0.23467488586902618,
-0.23009929060935974,
0.1126556545495987,
0.24555404484272003,
0.4788668751716614,
-0.07642471790313721,
0.028327638283371925,
-0.2870539724826813,
-0.3385106027126312,
0.7876190543174744,
-0.14313103258609772,
1.0447335243225098,
0.3532851040363312,
0.1620807647705078,
0.0064497278071939945,
-0.568594217300415,
0.5262202620506287,
-0.25562453269958496,
-0.35641852021217346,
-0.2938992381095886,
-0.07670842111110687,
-0.008181986398994923,
0.6373478174209595,
0.19043901562690735,
-0.7522608041763306,
-0.2802515923976898,
-0.49563533067703247,
0.741005539894104,
0.4732641279697418,
0.32428237795829773,
0.019866937771439552,
-0.48538222908973694,
0.8570964932441711,
0.17491652071475983,
0.24489988386631012,
0.2906750440597534,
-0.9091020822525024,
-0.2887328267097473,
0.4863276481628418,
0.5412228107452393,
0.5693654417991638,
-0.783037543296814,
0.3945748507976532,
-0.1154552772641182,
-0.6463942527770996,
-0.5031469464302063,
0.2162320464849472,
0.38589972257614136,
0.4194391667842865,
0.48537883162498474,
-0.16149459779262543,
-0.36373278498649597,
-0.36737412214279175,
-0.060476161539554596,
-0.47414666414260864,
-0.24115990102291107,
0.4223274886608124,
0.5102192163467407,
-0.004432035144418478,
0.957580029964447,
-0.3219796121120453,
-0.06594633311033249,
-0.15970517694950104,
0.3121951222419739,
0.33405205607414246,
0.3981815278530121,
0.2884775698184967,
-1.0464648008346558,
-0.3012910485267639,
-0.1254226565361023,
-0.5051965117454529,
0.1400873214006424,
-0.01483234390616417,
-0.07447776198387146,
0.009923785924911499,
0.4230978488922119,
-0.45042362809181213,
0.11563599109649658,
0.7407290935516357,
-0.22425560653209686,
0.3281104266643524,
0.10811436176300049,
0.14876729249954224,
-1.430158019065857,
0.14690746366977692,
0.3268515467643738,
-0.11965183168649673,
-0.7109931111335754,
0.06349644064903259,
0.2131360024213791,
-0.27901285886764526,
-0.6935724020004272,
0.4223313629627228,
-0.10678967833518982,
-0.2628638744354248,
-0.3484109938144684,
-0.0018104519695043564,
0.4596486985683441,
0.4606618583202362,
-0.23507530987262726,
0.5628324747085571,
0.2623068690299988,
-0.45699578523635864,
0.6631773114204407,
0.07751508057117462,
-0.7808847427368164,
0.2556972801685333,
-1.186238169670105,
0.0019001555629074574,
-0.18620780110359192,
0.2853550612926483,
-1.3209517002105713,
-0.017590707167983055,
-0.08603028953075409,
-1.0425145626068115,
-0.24872377514839172,
-0.3043913245201111,
-0.41899123787879944,
-0.7709735035896301,
-0.13299444317817688,
0.6053781509399414,
0.604249894618988,
-0.28098249435424805,
0.3919942378997803,
0.403597891330719,
0.00042372700409032404,
-0.6984128952026367,
-0.8235687613487244,
-0.193556010723114,
0.27447274327278137,
-0.8591702580451965,
0.16857734322547913,
-0.05097059905529022,
0.04986675828695297,
0.3178213834762573,
0.21050986647605896,
-0.7454874515533447,
0.4059964120388031,
0.42351865768432617,
0.022293873131275177,
-0.5684108138084412,
0.22035005688667297,
-0.3027397692203522,
0.16251881420612335,
0.4602316915988922,
-0.5339536666870117,
0.6388683915138245,
-0.06638000905513763,
-0.5323002338409424,
-0.5573239326477051,
0.17742687463760376,
0.7851542830467224,
-0.4688708782196045,
0.9898079633712769,
0.4830353260040283,
-0.6593887209892273,
-0.1399400234222412,
-0.6410702466964722,
-0.41297319531440735,
-0.39184892177581787,
0.4300094544887543,
0.26127827167510986,
-0.7225164175033569,
1.021401047706604,
0.24602703750133514,
-0.14131799340248108,
0.40021631121635437,
0.13596497476100922,
-0.5418767929077148,
1.4075952768325806,
0.31180697679519653,
-0.19099590182304382,
0.6248357892036438,
-0.2570849359035492,
0.053872883319854736,
-0.655777096748352,
-0.25013142824172974,
-0.5445742607116699,
-0.6270385384559631,
-0.2802746891975403,
-0.25679537653923035,
0.22037629783153534,
0.1527017056941986,
-0.04653371125459671,
0.33232277631759644,
-0.4171987771987915,
0.7157186269760132,
0.6742895245552063,
0.3070847988128662,
-0.06320613622665405,
0.01593628339469433,
0.34600287675857544,
0.43841227889060974,
-0.8353280425071716,
-0.2409564107656479,
0.8130379319190979,
0.6645158529281616,
0.5923366546630859,
-0.12874333560466766,
0.30952051281929016,
0.29245710372924805,
0.07374947518110275,
-0.5186052322387695,
0.21691304445266724,
-0.25778859853744507,
-0.8045389652252197,
-0.49088406562805176,
-0.8801108598709106,
-0.8098226189613342,
-0.21370123326778412,
-0.2550349533557892,
-0.33113980293273926,
0.27126118540763855,
0.08896848559379578,
-1.220310926437378,
0.6150407791137695,
-0.38215115666389465,
0.8615811467170715,
-0.35724130272865295,
-0.0075585488229990005,
-0.052503809332847595,
-0.5067458152770996,
0.019853826612234116,
0.03490360453724861,
-0.18702539801597595,
0.07306626439094543,
0.14417381584644318,
0.7607086300849915,
-0.3190309703350067,
0.8614912033081055,
0.03179670497775078,
0.2540467381477356,
0.6498643755912781,
-0.06257621943950653,
0.2232891321182251,
0.12904880940914154,
-0.5735462307929993,
0.4062209129333496,
0.15887896716594696,
-0.5584157705307007,
-0.8910690546035767,
0.7726897597312927,
-1.133381962776184,
-0.009687152691185474,
-0.06476207077503204,
-0.20731855928897858,
-0.14384140074253082,
0.20119088888168335,
0.3249049186706543,
0.6980500221252441,
-0.03576509654521942,
0.37726184725761414,
0.7005017995834351,
-0.22333456575870514,
0.2603318393230438,
0.06470664590597153,
-0.22436566650867462,
-0.4187547266483307,
0.8864443898200989,
0.6520867347717285,
0.29890385270118713,
0.15995898842811584,
0.1584915965795517,
-0.5517623424530029,
-0.8208959698677063,
-0.7326907515525818,
-0.26633167266845703,
-0.6392694711685181,
-0.4926484525203705,
-0.7775694131851196,
-0.8948962092399597,
-0.3958640992641449,
0.05352712422609329,
-0.3062000572681427,
-0.43237167596817017,
-0.5388609170913696,
-0.06148619204759598,
0.3479110300540924,
0.6533252000808716,
0.40256839990615845,
0.1041732206940651,
-0.8789267539978027,
0.08368479460477829,
0.48131418228149414,
0.6063436269760132,
0.16581089794635773,
-0.7186487317085266,
-0.2867754101753235,
0.37790369987487793,
-0.16706377267837524,
-0.7139158248901367,
0.2551543116569519,
0.08848055452108383,
0.5226128101348877,
0.2807312607765198,
0.14361214637756348,
0.28148114681243896,
0.029856257140636444,
0.7686023116111755,
0.21656450629234314,
-0.537102997303009,
0.49972838163375854,
-0.2634751796722412,
0.46448954939842224,
0.5801635384559631,
0.9141509532928467,
-0.7855716943740845,
-0.4859330952167511,
-0.6515191793441772,
-0.5717016458511353,
0.1710992008447647,
0.18113169074058533,
0.6890043020248413,
-0.12949948012828827,
0.4197740852832794,
-0.1537095606327057,
0.33659738302230835,
-0.496905654668808,
-0.0287774708122015,
-0.4697682559490204,
-0.018616145476698875,
0.3944505751132965,
-0.23717427253723145,
0.34500864148139954,
-0.12891314923763275,
0.44725820422172546,
0.0730697438120842,
0.10262645035982132,
-0.13958072662353516,
0.15764804184436798,
-0.38434523344039917,
-0.04821459576487541,
0.47097694873809814,
1.3360145092010498,
-0.17882561683654785,
0.0639570951461792,
0.40816807746887207,
-0.15719661116600037,
-0.2401941418647766,
-0.2327292114496231,
-0.35477694869041443,
0.03910314664244652,
0.19515414535999298,
0.6586511731147766,
-0.12334392219781876,
-0.40766555070877075,
0.6875655055046082,
-0.020880628377199173,
-0.12413807213306427,
-0.5191726684570312,
0.29844993352890015,
0.19721555709838867,
0.32166844606399536,
0.3408222198486328,
0.34354162216186523,
0.10971302539110184,
-0.607675313949585,
0.36600443720817566,
0.2982570230960846,
-0.6980637311935425,
-0.03800719231367111,
0.39658865332603455,
0.21224230527877808,
-0.5565362572669983,
0.9377092719078064,
0.03568931668996811,
-0.8988710641860962,
1.2195202112197876,
0.26961320638656616,
0.5765050649642944,
-0.1408122032880783,
0.4849604666233063,
0.6123406887054443,
0.0015355999348685145,
-0.07058156281709671,
0.36623284220695496,
0.5204933285713196,
-0.8453665375709534,
-0.7265127897262573,
-0.7085759043693542,
-0.5824559330940247,
0.2272258996963501,
-0.4665653109550476,
-0.15343427658081055,
-0.8079473972320557,
-0.4351988732814789,
0.17643824219703674,
-0.08028858155012131,
-0.2971598505973816,
0.6262654662132263,
0.12179432809352875,
0.780756950378418,
-0.7380057573318481,
0.5197096467018127,
0.6815007328987122,
-0.7496358752250671,
-0.6852886080741882,
-0.17663684487342834,
-0.4104234278202057,
-0.6759368181228638,
0.5536134839057922,
0.05752946808934212,
0.09686041623353958,
0.041524339467287064,
-0.41460978984832764,
-0.9379181861877441,
0.8543459177017212,
0.09775221347808838,
0.020436260849237442,
0.19286662340164185,
0.24932943284511566,
0.9557817578315735,
-0.2023838758468628,
0.6977585554122925,
-0.21630658209323883,
0.08717723935842514,
0.29719603061676025,
-0.5537149310112,
-0.2243213653564453,
-0.7281013131141663,
0.20665869116783142,
0.07767965644598007,
-0.2955220639705658,
1.043331503868103,
0.02481418289244175,
-0.0012265125988051295,
-0.03197511285543442,
0.9359415173530579,
-0.09675054997205734,
0.35687005519866943,
0.5611164569854736,
0.26449427008628845,
0.7631151676177979,
0.093271404504776,
1.0234339237213135,
-0.5258840322494507,
0.2541305720806122,
0.6899065375328064,
0.14820119738578796,
1.342801570892334,
0.17930246889591217,
0.14338764548301697,
0.5818322896957397,
0.7126432657241821,
-0.17300304770469666,
0.169503316283226,
0.5093137621879578,
0.12224073708057404,
-0.30142155289649963,
-0.35798215866088867,
-0.5082526803016663,
0.22978901863098145,
0.14041019976139069,
-0.6118544340133667,
0.04631586745381355,
0.03817380592226982,
-0.4465197026729584,
0.09864029288291931,
-0.7423244714736938,
0.7378190159797668,
-0.14848001301288605,
-0.8424277305603027,
0.6380364298820496,
-0.05631609261035919,
0.5820636749267578,
-0.09865057468414307,
0.03743697702884674,
-0.6095941662788391,
0.08269525319337845,
-0.5400804281234741,
-1.3185324668884277,
0.5140374898910522,
-0.19300736486911774,
-0.44824862480163574,
-0.2679103910923004,
0.8890113830566406,
-0.4258069396018982,
-0.8665367364883423,
0.30692052841186523,
0.6558411717414856,
0.24800018966197968,
-0.5454094409942627,
-0.9221758246421814,
-0.5244888663291931,
-0.35664939880371094,
-0.1360945999622345,
0.14723792672157288,
0.17352735996246338,
0.10113503038883209,
0.8720749616622925,
0.779371440410614,
0.10949952900409698,
0.27245205640792847,
-0.017409687861800194,
0.8221979141235352,
-0.2836369574069977,
-0.579630434513092,
-0.6727921366691589,
0.6596353650093079,
-0.38500744104385376,
-0.6374673843383789,
0.6007417440414429,
0.2634698450565338,
0.8614921569824219,
0.16948795318603516,
0.5194384455680847,
0.2527911067008972,
0.6002430319786072,
-0.32428720593452454,
1.2282919883728027,
-0.7491607069969177,
0.06382644176483154,
-0.080755814909935,
-0.9175029397010803,
-0.24153727293014526,
0.317550927400589,
-0.4644385576248169,
0.3139667212963104,
0.2904486656188965,
0.7668339610099792,
-0.2950621545314789,
0.26886269450187683,
0.3527723252773285,
-0.08560935407876968,
-0.03766579553484917,
0.5716313719749451,
1.1575069427490234,
-0.37048575282096863,
0.8444690108299255,
-0.4591712951660156,
0.1264529824256897,
-0.5402060151100159,
-0.6068052053451538,
-0.8766350746154785,
-0.5803508758544922,
-0.30610474944114685,
-0.6825315356254578,
0.1016257181763649,
0.7571029663085938,
0.8816973567008972,
-1.143006682395935,
0.06875431537628174,
-0.19326946139335632,
0.4163702428340912,
-0.28592175245285034,
-0.12397833168506622,
0.26420527696609497,
-0.17365072667598724,
-0.12960508465766907,
0.05972154811024666,
-0.09233996272087097,
-0.23323550820350647,
-0.5606315732002258,
0.17870250344276428,
-0.26327401399612427,
0.17280784249305725,
0.45721858739852905,
0.4437907934188843,
-0.37180134654045105,
-0.24185232818126678,
0.468353271484375,
-0.5294994115829468,
-0.011445506475865841,
0.3343052268028259,
-0.3861008584499359,
0.12078800797462463,
1.1611201763153076,
1.1963016986846924,
0.14336657524108887,
0.5101113319396973,
0.4655698239803314,
-0.7006528377532959,
-0.7457432746887207,
0.6160482168197632,
0.26521235704421997,
0.06494290381669998,
-0.5062753558158875,
0.2165221869945526,
-0.23382844030857086,
-0.7409079074859619,
-0.46498236060142517,
-0.06303713470697403,
-0.5421436429023743,
-0.5283628702163696,
1.2585246562957764,
-0.2759897708892822,
-0.37928059697151184,
-0.3445007801055908,
0.03609628602862358,
0.14026546478271484,
-0.26512575149536133,
1.1108171939849854,
0.49587830901145935,
0.09285144507884979,
-0.2249380648136139,
-0.8018001914024353,
0.21439281105995178,
0.7354932427406311,
-0.9952665567398071,
-0.4844152629375458,
0.44151872396469116,
0.19861939549446106,
0.5565264225006104,
0.222134068608284,
0.3096979260444641,
0.6618227958679199,
-0.35586926341056824,
-0.200852632522583,
-0.2779010534286499,
-0.3495386838912964,
-0.25927895307540894,
0.72846519947052,
-0.04752244055271149,
-0.3251098096370697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13402v1
|
Intrusion Detection at Scale with the Assistance of a Command-line Language Model
| 2024-04-20T15:04:25 | 2024-04-20T15:04:25 |
Jiongliang Lin, Yiwen Guo, Hao Chen
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Intrusion detection is a long standing and crucial problem in security. A
system capable of detecting intrusions automatically is on great demand in
enterprise security solutions. Existing solutions rely heavily on hand-crafted
rules designed by security operators, which suffer from high false negative
rates and poor generalization ability to new, zero-day attacks at scale. AI and
machine learning offer promising solutions to address the issues, by inspecting
abnormal user behaviors intelligently and automatically from data. However,
existing learning-based intrusion detection systems in the literature are
mostly designed for small data, and they lack the ability to leverage the power
of big data in cloud environments. In this paper, we target at this problem and
introduce an intrusion detection system which incorporates large-scale
pre-training, so as to train a large language model based on tens of millions
of command lines for AI-based intrusion detection. Experiments performed on 30
million training samples and 10 million test samples verify the effectiveness
of our solution.
|
[
-0.7441748380661011,
-1.128400444984436,
0.5040556788444519,
-0.1207871362566948,
-0.05898674577474594,
-0.13696272671222687,
-0.0942719504237175,
-0.3930421471595764,
0.17805789411067963,
0.7459831833839417,
-0.5895732641220093,
-0.4532777965068817,
-0.7156175971031189,
-0.0012110217940062284,
-0.4130845069885254,
0.9390301704406738,
0.2316598743200302,
-0.12104767560958862,
-0.09287112951278687,
0.16736681759357452,
-0.6100883483886719,
-0.7589054703712463,
-0.7095856070518494,
-0.10257451981306076,
0.05540496110916138,
0.7019428610801697,
0.3035683333873749,
0.5812225341796875,
0.7253023386001587,
0.3620600700378418,
0.2861388623714447,
0.29357898235321045,
-0.23780426383018494,
-0.019648948684334755,
-0.036973223090171814,
-0.6079027652740479,
-0.3922775089740753,
-0.15601950883865356,
0.6313106417655945,
0.5089515447616577,
-0.08572282642126083,
0.022985247895121574,
-0.19442738592624664,
0.4158116281032562,
-0.36009809374809265,
0.062434833496809006,
-0.7010946869850159,
-0.09635703265666962,
-0.20677675306797028,
0.22569577395915985,
-0.5373851656913757,
0.1887182891368866,
0.1760941594839096,
-0.41947153210639954,
-0.013292706571519375,
0.3641153573989868,
0.5852721929550171,
0.2793101370334625,
-0.26374274492263794,
-0.28888043761253357,
-0.6924450993537903,
0.8023359775543213,
-0.6308093070983887,
0.3113556504249573,
0.4192022383213043,
0.3753066062927246,
-0.3821733593940735,
-0.6762723922729492,
-0.5312598943710327,
-0.41220220923423767,
-0.006873121485114098,
-0.4149956703186035,
-0.37628620862960815,
-0.05905798822641373,
0.5057832598686218,
0.01501457579433918,
-0.7696872353553772,
0.5891132354736328,
-0.12788653373718262,
0.04914684221148491,
0.559796154499054,
0.323280930519104,
0.3380946218967438,
0.21787399053573608,
-0.30154353380203247,
-0.024034181609749794,
-0.27825236320495605,
0.11452188342809677,
0.28052395582199097,
0.5051349997520447,
-0.06095489114522934,
0.004938038531690836,
-0.360675573348999,
0.7019087076187134,
0.13582247495651245,
0.034805234521627426,
-0.042494650930166245,
-0.08882582187652588,
-0.3246040642261505,
-0.03147231787443161,
0.9258252382278442,
-0.057755548506975174,
0.30500495433807373,
-0.21260465681552887,
-0.25869882106781006,
-0.037287287414073944,
0.5555474758148193,
-1.2624642848968506,
-0.5259866714477539,
0.19236423075199127,
-0.6183276772499084,
-0.3610873818397522,
0.24540752172470093,
-0.8211268782615662,
-0.738667368888855,
-0.4429251551628113,
0.25122779607772827,
-0.5974363684654236,
-0.3647577464580536,
-0.043547552078962326,
0.27203279733657837,
0.28482505679130554,
0.3707696199417114,
-0.6079566478729248,
0.46105897426605225,
0.7125623822212219,
0.7642087340354919,
-0.29606834053993225,
-0.3508835434913635,
-1.0569967031478882,
-0.257136732339859,
-0.38518646359443665,
0.5366367697715759,
-0.45231202244758606,
-0.29358071088790894,
-0.30381226539611816,
0.04764635115861893,
-0.05468008667230606,
-0.6726003289222717,
0.36042675375938416,
-0.6492137908935547,
-0.09434047341346741,
0.15642765164375305,
-0.681942343711853,
0.043405063450336456,
0.4145183563232422,
-0.5678544640541077,
0.5336647629737854,
-0.10667846351861954,
-0.4848763942718506,
0.36991676688194275,
-1.034597396850586,
-0.48058459162712097,
0.5801102519035339,
-0.08080292493104935,
-0.5765439867973328,
-0.12493884563446045,
0.408281147480011,
0.587252140045166,
-0.3910096287727356,
0.2534840404987335,
-0.44676297903060913,
-0.10189460217952728,
0.0850154310464859,
-0.20809306204319,
0.6554147601127625,
0.3293030560016632,
-0.384336918592453,
-0.19075573980808258,
-0.6075496077537537,
0.17410962283611298,
0.20790840685367584,
-0.16715604066848755,
-0.3694925308227539,
0.1059713140130043,
-0.15526176989078522,
-0.15790116786956787,
0.41383007168769836,
-0.6271442770957947,
0.23297417163848877,
-0.05152096971869469,
0.14730142056941986,
0.5446709394454956,
0.08650734275579453,
0.33421358466148376,
0.1479327231645584,
0.5187479853630066,
0.5070359110832214,
0.2831246852874756,
-0.3068535029888153,
-0.2936204969882965,
-0.4917866885662079,
-0.6311836242675781,
0.13059988617897034,
0.8617967367172241,
-0.49189072847366333,
0.9549925327301025,
-0.2615424692630768,
-0.5475412011146545,
0.04153510928153992,
0.2641736567020416,
-0.11355932801961899,
0.3843996226787567,
0.4050009548664093,
-0.01447981409728527,
-0.4797629415988922,
-0.8282871842384338,
-0.2607986032962799,
-0.002589754993095994,
-0.3325757682323456,
0.2897706627845764,
0.7519516348838806,
-0.5636616349220276,
0.949307382106781,
-0.8826446533203125,
-0.4423741400241852,
-0.14919163286685944,
0.3578650653362274,
0.25317060947418213,
0.6075571775436401,
0.47699299454689026,
-0.8184429407119751,
-0.38060590624809265,
0.16840316355228424,
-0.8692765831947327,
-0.09066613763570786,
-0.10592639446258545,
0.1735554337501526,
-0.14345373213291168,
0.9823079109191895,
-0.1975603699684143,
0.2950137257575989,
0.23853203654289246,
-0.27270424365997314,
0.3442111313343048,
-0.3218199908733368,
-0.04644079878926277,
-1.1199268102645874,
0.043245866894721985,
0.08242036402225494,
-0.1913207471370697,
-1.1548843383789062,
0.11823214590549469,
0.2503117620944977,
-0.5789694786071777,
-0.1469563990831375,
0.16144432127475739,
-0.2884003520011902,
0.31206366419792175,
-0.32033878564834595,
-0.3982253074645996,
-0.31850665807724,
0.3364078402519226,
0.0695292130112648,
0.6779801845550537,
0.7167888879776001,
-0.8209729790687561,
0.7997678518295288,
-0.014530209824442863,
-0.3035757839679718,
1.021791934967041,
-0.5427244901657104,
0.19508592784404755,
0.03931088745594025,
0.3407440781593323,
-0.8577958941459656,
-0.3201807737350464,
0.07183032482862473,
-0.24883179366588593,
0.1616424322128296,
-0.37828919291496277,
-0.44161999225616455,
-0.45633044838905334,
-0.14203236997127533,
0.35171425342559814,
0.4620599150657654,
-0.758385419845581,
0.7733269929885864,
0.33936741948127747,
0.13762441277503967,
-0.4392421245574951,
-0.4860606789588928,
0.4335649907588959,
-0.4694105088710785,
-0.6021921038627625,
-0.2243833988904953,
0.03968137130141258,
-0.2435474842786789,
-0.3011222779750824,
0.15953567624092102,
-0.560837984085083,
0.5484272837638855,
0.4218236207962036,
0.23694398999214172,
-0.335215300321579,
0.019699212163686752,
-0.45420804619789124,
0.23805899918079376,
0.29023095965385437,
-0.770215630531311,
0.7358909845352173,
-0.3037554621696472,
-0.37134861946105957,
-0.8665933012962341,
0.4953516125679016,
1.1781879663467407,
-0.47336024045944214,
0.9708731770515442,
0.4868607819080353,
-0.46512898802757263,
-0.49157631397247314,
-0.2767981290817261,
-0.3263678550720215,
-0.5197396874427795,
0.47931182384490967,
-0.36507153511047363,
-0.499210000038147,
0.29738491773605347,
-0.4706538915634155,
-0.11424316465854645,
0.26137325167655945,
0.025092938914895058,
-0.13159306347370148,
0.9593713283538818,
0.7787011861801147,
-0.7290390133857727,
0.7760255336761475,
-0.4279981851577759,
0.7154126167297363,
-0.455514132976532,
0.23633147776126862,
-0.43673887848854065,
-0.16170118749141693,
-0.6464965343475342,
-0.0026112974155694246,
0.5583673119544983,
0.032868485897779465,
-0.43143197894096375,
0.3798903226852417,
-0.2709636092185974,
0.432443231344223,
0.5254678726196289,
0.3211422562599182,
-0.08267249912023544,
-0.25732189416885376,
0.17417775094509125,
0.2938023507595062,
-0.3358464241027832,
-0.24780093133449554,
1.2511242628097534,
0.4465557634830475,
0.7559773921966553,
0.12337435036897659,
0.7024131417274475,
0.831286609172821,
0.007208538707345724,
-0.8814861178398132,
0.6150857210159302,
-0.24629424512386322,
-0.2565213143825531,
-0.757341742515564,
-0.5420374870300293,
-0.9996545314788818,
-0.26249533891677856,
-0.1786716878414154,
-0.7429881691932678,
0.06209731847047806,
0.07588169723749161,
-0.24978646636009216,
0.5263231992721558,
-0.8138687014579773,
0.8066009879112244,
-0.33338984847068787,
0.2197599858045578,
-0.2362053543329239,
-0.4381978213787079,
0.4104829728603363,
-0.4604804217815399,
0.03626950457692146,
0.2510834336280823,
0.21801744401454926,
0.7754800915718079,
-0.6753664016723633,
0.7461703419685364,
-0.6482627987861633,
-0.0690079927444458,
0.20695345103740692,
0.05205674096941948,
0.944101870059967,
0.03352751210331917,
0.2925505042076111,
0.26682350039482117,
-0.36648818850517273,
-0.3454790711402893,
-0.43899205327033997,
0.3636952042579651,
-0.6213570833206177,
-0.40689894556999207,
-0.1862564980983734,
-0.5631474852561951,
0.04867146909236908,
0.31035664677619934,
0.19980911910533905,
0.4471779465675354,
-0.3336852192878723,
0.48534125089645386,
1.0616440773010254,
-0.28829583525657654,
0.26776137948036194,
0.5553200244903564,
-0.10332350432872772,
-0.034645359963178635,
0.8720721006393433,
0.08126161247491837,
0.25702863931655884,
0.3755720853805542,
0.15269406139850616,
-0.08960870653390884,
-0.5312308669090271,
-0.6118785738945007,
0.031646229326725006,
-0.20332543551921844,
-0.3571144640445709,
-0.7084497809410095,
-0.4677404761314392,
-0.433226078748703,
-0.08114796131849289,
-0.1471845805644989,
0.16512486338615417,
-0.2320929765701294,
0.3663187026977539,
0.5565712451934814,
0.5474048852920532,
0.13163284957408905,
0.7427992224693298,
-0.48351946473121643,
0.4709228277206421,
0.5575737953186035,
0.2588139474391937,
0.0011415942572057247,
-0.49249550700187683,
-0.490369975566864,
-0.05329066514968872,
-0.0786934643983841,
-0.4327390491962433,
0.4065316319465637,
0.21668201684951782,
0.30436021089553833,
0.9028896689414978,
0.17395330965518951,
0.14551760256290436,
-0.47937819361686707,
0.6389312744140625,
-0.06276696175336838,
-0.8577110767364502,
0.6905832290649414,
-0.3560129404067993,
0.24204251170158386,
0.43426188826560974,
0.3369978070259094,
-0.6741691827774048,
-0.23162396252155304,
-0.48037874698638916,
-0.5384953618049622,
0.8810375928878784,
-0.3156149983406067,
-0.02376973256468773,
0.285648912191391,
0.04256129637360573,
-0.22923801839351654,
0.1964704543352127,
-0.3414146602153778,
-0.1728319525718689,
-0.008464641869068146,
0.009608007036149502,
0.007836945354938507,
0.21802324056625366,
0.0044729444198310375,
0.06360311061143875,
0.43246152997016907,
-0.1188262552022934,
0.1790347397327423,
-0.43874698877334595,
-0.2324756532907486,
0.24346685409545898,
0.12611225247383118,
0.40388739109039307,
0.35266610980033875,
-0.02229921519756317,
-0.050818126648664474,
0.5646904706954956,
-0.9047443270683289,
0.15507957339286804,
0.09869692474603653,
-0.0928162932395935,
-0.1702171415090561,
0.2628178894519806,
0.49133193492889404,
-0.6033170223236084,
-0.5773470401763916,
0.7709600329399109,
-0.136009082198143,
-0.1920812875032425,
-0.618611752986908,
0.3555977940559387,
-0.1271946132183075,
0.12744855880737305,
0.4286460280418396,
-0.07340249419212341,
0.09004558622837067,
-0.3981055021286011,
0.39516645669937134,
0.7400974631309509,
-0.16623058915138245,
0.031460121273994446,
0.29471856355667114,
0.1866038590669632,
-0.463143914937973,
0.938076376914978,
-0.22913861274719238,
-0.8130531311035156,
0.9760735630989075,
0.33464980125427246,
0.7720800638198853,
-0.6454038023948669,
-0.1781219244003296,
0.06988272070884705,
0.5048407316207886,
-0.037010230123996735,
0.027379389852285385,
-0.06363468617200851,
-0.7620217204093933,
0.003350829239934683,
-0.4231320321559906,
-0.5383030772209167,
0.8705523014068604,
-0.446695476770401,
0.5011923313140869,
-1.0061640739440918,
0.204456627368927,
0.06077558919787407,
-0.08912566304206848,
-0.7902601361274719,
0.365574449300766,
0.3870609998703003,
0.9265316128730774,
-1.1996906995773315,
0.8437263369560242,
0.5009368062019348,
-0.11387282609939575,
-0.5325665473937988,
0.04292002692818642,
-0.05713939294219017,
-0.6512914299964905,
0.74928218126297,
0.43996986746788025,
-0.10017227381467819,
-0.14824503660202026,
-0.7501934170722961,
-0.605008602142334,
0.6677286028862,
0.030679961666464806,
-0.4233080744743347,
0.3123548924922943,
0.3622579872608185,
0.5736665725708008,
-0.5496022701263428,
0.02522200159728527,
0.8678508996963501,
0.5041565299034119,
-0.5771576762199402,
-0.603013277053833,
-0.2557721436023712,
-0.07287662476301193,
-0.2881384491920471,
0.5982823371887207,
-0.31459322571754456,
1.031107783317566,
0.26803654432296753,
0.13985534012317657,
-0.43961459398269653,
0.6642982959747314,
-0.23087051510810852,
0.22788120806217194,
0.8952113389968872,
0.6625038385391235,
0.850980281829834,
0.2103813886642456,
0.6105148792266846,
-0.28069689869880676,
0.005378565285354853,
1.0675122737884521,
-0.36051157116889954,
0.6999713778495789,
-0.07409225404262543,
-0.21039511263370514,
0.5307312607765198,
0.4154365658760071,
-0.1403583437204361,
0.30288049578666687,
0.3729928433895111,
-0.592377245426178,
-0.2660190165042877,
-0.24698033928871155,
-0.11922449618577957,
0.6101846098899841,
0.7511270046234131,
-0.34025096893310547,
-0.012433618307113647,
0.18914657831192017,
0.15116599202156067,
-0.18073399364948273,
-0.6241853833198547,
0.7779608368873596,
-0.17140533030033112,
-0.3893352746963501,
0.6177104711532593,
0.09309420734643936,
0.8143882751464844,
-0.7622320055961609,
0.1313038468360901,
-0.03786475956439972,
0.3534458577632904,
-0.1892397552728653,
-0.564625084400177,
-0.005124692339450121,
0.40546250343322754,
-0.2563337981700897,
-0.015695905312895775,
0.5564329028129578,
-0.18008962273597717,
-0.2721114158630371,
0.32645776867866516,
0.2158731073141098,
0.3859243094921112,
-0.449873685836792,
-0.3224877119064331,
-0.3560866117477417,
-0.09371894598007202,
-0.030667366459965706,
0.26947498321533203,
0.6270385384559631,
-0.29576078057289124,
0.7698427438735962,
0.7916322350502014,
0.16778531670570374,
-0.07130896300077438,
-0.1613907814025879,
0.7265997529029846,
-0.2049747109413147,
-0.9093755483627319,
-0.9957608580589294,
0.029201719909906387,
-0.5813875794410706,
-0.09424049407243729,
0.3911931812763214,
0.49936842918395996,
0.596488893032074,
-0.09027830511331558,
0.9626449346542358,
-0.08943907916545868,
0.5280619263648987,
-0.20037290453910828,
0.6846285462379456,
-0.29869386553764343,
0.2070295214653015,
-0.005652420688420534,
-0.6679760217666626,
-0.19917917251586914,
0.260121613740921,
-0.49081307649612427,
-0.0006598528125323355,
0.7675026655197144,
0.9941238164901733,
-0.4527747333049774,
-0.046335045248270035,
0.392863005399704,
0.1725633293390274,
0.5868175625801086,
0.3470384180545807,
0.6354634761810303,
-0.1161651685833931,
0.37222427129745483,
0.2074335664510727,
-0.5339404344558716,
-0.497391939163208,
-0.9010074734687805,
-1.03993821144104,
-0.4429108202457428,
0.07506044209003448,
0.013722527772188187,
-0.2333506941795349,
0.9779609441757202,
0.8743785619735718,
-1.0818798542022705,
-0.11930716037750244,
-0.22149041295051575,
-0.20410189032554626,
-0.12993964552879333,
-0.1890663504600525,
0.31613242626190186,
-0.48254841566085815,
-0.4114013612270355,
0.48319628834724426,
-0.026004711166024208,
-0.04999983683228493,
-0.2946571707725525,
0.17561830580234528,
-0.159324049949646,
0.06811445206403732,
0.2735142111778259,
0.39303839206695557,
-0.15534164011478424,
-0.20977173745632172,
-0.20435307919979095,
-0.1486513763666153,
-0.21130751073360443,
0.6916333436965942,
-0.6570020914077759,
0.17318035662174225,
0.3523973524570465,
1.1656116247177124,
0.16202402114868164,
0.13423281908035278,
0.5161455869674683,
-0.5950593948364258,
0.08328866213560104,
0.08792926371097565,
0.3369976878166199,
0.14767490327358246,
-0.7974108457565308,
0.22789041697978973,
0.1526496559381485,
-0.7383797764778137,
-0.713281512260437,
0.4122576415538788,
-0.5171881914138794,
-0.3826189935207367,
0.557615339756012,
-0.3560630977153778,
-0.054196637123823166,
-0.23156434297561646,
-0.06400728225708008,
-0.028897667303681374,
-0.4482053220272064,
0.7514848709106445,
0.6239551901817322,
-0.20371751487255096,
0.3470412790775299,
-0.4614276885986328,
0.42354610562324524,
0.4098825454711914,
-1.2282484769821167,
0.3774906098842621,
0.3696797788143158,
0.03158918395638466,
0.1754988580942154,
0.09914186596870422,
0.4969410300254822,
0.3324807286262512,
-0.10247734189033508,
0.12510542571544647,
0.07154864817857742,
-0.6966661214828491,
-0.6057921051979065,
-0.05103592574596405,
0.015143949538469315,
-0.6860867738723755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13397v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13397v1
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation-based Relation Extraction
| 2024-04-20T14:42:43 | 2024-04-20T14:42:43 |
Sefika Efeoglu, Adrian Paschke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Information Extraction (IE) is a transformative process that converts
unstructured text data into a structured format by employing entity and
relation extraction (RE) methodologies. The identification of the relation
between a pair of entities plays a crucial role within this framework. Despite
the existence of various techniques for relation extraction, their efficacy
heavily relies on access to labeled data and substantial computational
resources. In addressing these challenges, Large Language Models (LLMs) emerge
as promising solutions; however, they might return hallucinating responses due
to their own training data. To overcome these limitations, Retrieved-Augmented
Generation-based Relation Extraction (RAG4RE) in this work is proposed,
offering a pathway to enhance the performance of relation extraction tasks.
This work evaluated the effectiveness of our RAG4RE approach utilizing
different LLMs. Through the utilization of established benchmarks, such as
TACRED, TACREV, Re-TACRED, and SemEval RE datasets, our aim is to
comprehensively evaluate the efficacy of our RAG4RE approach. In particularly,
we leverage prominent LLMs including Flan T5, Llama2, and Mistral in our
investigation. The results of our study demonstrate that our RAG4RE approach
surpasses performance of traditional RE approaches based solely on LLMs,
particularly evident in the TACRED dataset and its variations. Furthermore, our
approach exhibits remarkable performance compared to previous RE methodologies
across both TACRED and TACREV datasets, underscoring its efficacy and potential
for advancing RE tasks in natural language processing.
|
[
-0.4241071939468384,
-0.6180981397628784,
0.47956061363220215,
0.14700210094451904,
-0.23490077257156372,
0.24253351986408234,
-0.2737794518470764,
-0.7800332307815552,
0.1522418111562729,
0.6222099661827087,
-0.19634275138378143,
-0.19707456231117249,
-0.5489994883537292,
0.52852463722229,
-0.24090206623077393,
0.9454749226570129,
-0.07414773851633072,
-0.2620454728603363,
-0.17125988006591797,
-0.20202955603599548,
-0.5467616319656372,
-0.3800378739833832,
-0.5808834433555603,
-0.39812180399894714,
0.5691756010055542,
0.320289671421051,
0.09816325455904007,
0.5864615440368652,
0.7305174469947815,
0.3034413754940033,
-0.07713843137025833,
0.43438491225242615,
-0.549688994884491,
0.4971400499343872,
-0.4336818754673004,
-0.19337421655654907,
-0.36201757192611694,
0.13647744059562683,
0.6028976440429688,
0.26240959763526917,
-0.2159341424703598,
0.5448969006538391,
0.09762204438447952,
0.5881989598274231,
-0.762273371219635,
0.22767138481140137,
-0.8822340965270996,
-0.10833477228879929,
-0.43904343247413635,
-0.6127261519432068,
-0.48600295186042786,
-0.24211853742599487,
0.09125342965126038,
-0.6876592636108398,
0.2920225262641907,
0.21876050531864166,
1.3263566493988037,
-0.030595188960433006,
-0.20727890729904175,
-0.4176272451877594,
-0.8572405576705933,
0.8086028099060059,
-0.5069565773010254,
0.9192016124725342,
0.307268351316452,
0.2882300019264221,
-0.2773148715496063,
-1.0575971603393555,
-0.32190096378326416,
-0.04389485716819763,
-0.12945175170898438,
0.1534072756767273,
-0.040228221565485,
-0.2598182260990143,
0.41060948371887207,
0.7006191611289978,
-0.09254328906536102,
-0.06869958341121674,
-0.11445877701044083,
-0.06315108388662338,
0.28198665380477905,
-0.011045950464904308,
0.16359037160873413,
-0.5621511340141296,
-0.6558777093887329,
0.03292810171842575,
-0.6892188787460327,
-0.13583913445472717,
0.019478842616081238,
0.3902648687362671,
0.19236885011196136,
0.5828381776809692,
0.0931958332657814,
0.524368166923523,
0.23671682178974152,
-0.46786975860595703,
0.3474748432636261,
-0.4002256393432617,
-0.09570856392383575,
-0.47364330291748047,
0.8814033269882202,
0.053689826279878616,
0.3316415250301361,
-0.5860413908958435,
-0.4138674736022949,
-0.2917264699935913,
0.18629087507724762,
-0.7837158441543579,
-0.014177232049405575,
-0.09363727271556854,
-0.5049731731414795,
-0.3571538031101227,
-0.04674125462770462,
-1.3012769222259521,
-0.27406635880470276,
-0.2796995937824249,
0.22779233753681183,
-0.5977972745895386,
-0.570995569229126,
-0.4143142104148865,
-0.2882697284221649,
0.5992609262466431,
0.17211149632930756,
-0.791424036026001,
0.3799959719181061,
0.8188413977622986,
0.6794456243515015,
-0.4577697217464447,
0.17400798201560974,
-0.7070590257644653,
0.35055986046791077,
-0.14354191720485687,
0.7459596991539001,
-0.6648447513580322,
-0.4305329918861389,
-0.1792835295200348,
-0.13923773169517517,
-0.1016751155257225,
-0.9407851099967957,
0.7152180075645447,
-1.0537774562835693,
0.2548367977142334,
-0.15294687449932098,
-0.40668854117393494,
-0.00037615722976624966,
0.42475536465644836,
-1.0572363138198853,
1.2353843450546265,
0.31048688292503357,
-0.9722083806991577,
0.16884547472000122,
-0.22372230887413025,
-0.3073800206184387,
0.17429307103157043,
-0.46335726976394653,
-0.48885640501976013,
-0.14273200929164886,
0.3207743763923645,
0.39221134781837463,
-0.8688820004463196,
0.0967613011598587,
-0.09833677858114243,
-0.02044033072888851,
0.07339704781770706,
-0.22751757502555847,
0.5207485556602478,
0.2642058730125427,
-0.17074818909168243,
-0.3698972165584564,
-0.8316315412521362,
-0.022188838571310043,
0.19104309380054474,
-0.4353998899459839,
-0.6078987121582031,
-0.28039202094078064,
-0.15206116437911987,
0.38528892397880554,
0.16447919607162476,
-0.6836527585983276,
0.04537460580468178,
-0.6544234156608582,
0.04686755686998367,
0.532549262046814,
0.6283949613571167,
0.4853440821170807,
-0.030314229428768158,
0.7617014050483704,
-0.18146158754825592,
-0.4627496302127838,
-0.07831522822380066,
-0.26903557777404785,
-0.5181282162666321,
-0.3204149007797241,
0.7312436103820801,
0.5308042168617249,
-1.1906529664993286,
0.07917454093694687,
-0.4918493628501892,
-0.1948421448469162,
-0.4307936728000641,
0.2441718876361847,
0.687239408493042,
0.944758951663971,
0.4067660868167877,
-0.039935819804668427,
-0.7921647429466248,
-0.7309665083885193,
-0.46393775939941406,
-0.09173111617565155,
0.06458418071269989,
0.4009110629558563,
0.14789147675037384,
-0.09841781109571457,
0.9217537045478821,
-0.4486787021160126,
-0.3514822721481323,
-0.3805166482925415,
0.09912211447954178,
0.15916533768177032,
0.06058521941304207,
0.3426513075828552,
-1.0034147500991821,
-0.3454282879829407,
0.31063804030418396,
-0.9147417545318604,
-0.15347151458263397,
0.07830159366130829,
-0.2795960009098053,
0.18886645138263702,
0.22821946442127228,
-0.5310501456260681,
0.4719568192958832,
0.31515973806381226,
0.07382404804229736,
0.5557830333709717,
0.09961173683404922,
0.2534046173095703,
-1.1641713380813599,
0.3567938506603241,
0.14264260232448578,
-0.4689364433288574,
-0.518965482711792,
0.08539093285799026,
0.13817809522151947,
0.09330517053604126,
-0.11039825528860092,
0.5365186929702759,
-0.8223468065261841,
-0.36176490783691406,
0.04497212544083595,
0.2687016725540161,
0.1841205358505249,
0.3400638699531555,
-0.05460277944803238,
0.996773362159729,
-0.12203802913427353,
-0.45939281582832336,
0.11170899868011475,
0.5287804007530212,
0.00436297245323658,
0.2932322323322296,
-0.281363844871521,
0.18503916263580322,
-0.043857187032699585,
-0.025203602388501167,
-0.5763208866119385,
-0.09359709918498993,
0.1681107133626938,
-0.5509849786758423,
0.6807674169540405,
-0.11651311814785004,
-0.3973501920700073,
-0.056761596351861954,
-0.33936914801597595,
0.15438193082809448,
0.24642178416252136,
-0.7676816582679749,
1.062048077583313,
0.5543676018714905,
-0.2790338099002838,
-0.7802708745002747,
-0.20950748026371002,
0.13156941533088684,
-0.4613226652145386,
-0.34522098302841187,
0.5458218455314636,
0.39472946524620056,
-0.38274669647216797,
0.09594428539276123,
-0.24739697575569153,
-0.1316598355770111,
-0.19346942007541656,
0.19137056171894073,
0.4128504991531372,
-0.04481274634599686,
0.15598714351654053,
-0.4197566509246826,
-0.12128986418247223,
0.023999866098165512,
0.5473106503486633,
0.4946545660495758,
0.15279416739940643,
0.26197731494903564,
-0.23145100474357605,
0.22013917565345764,
0.3398621380329132,
-0.6358610987663269,
0.5910569429397583,
0.5215754508972168,
-0.3350831866264343,
-0.10288634896278381,
-0.9388237595558167,
-0.07159802317619324,
-0.4270462393760681,
0.2751822769641876,
-0.777772843837738,
-0.8187767267227173,
0.4348298907279968,
-0.5309257507324219,
0.08601024001836777,
0.45208439230918884,
0.27945569157600403,
-0.022694338113069534,
0.4538344442844391,
0.548076868057251,
-0.12192576378583908,
0.5229052305221558,
-0.3970606029033661,
0.15706326067447662,
-1.437080979347229,
-0.48067155480384827,
-0.6447681784629822,
0.19121308624744415,
-0.6560121178627014,
-0.23249971866607666,
0.11807812750339508,
0.15975777804851532,
0.0756065770983696,
0.4555197060108185,
-0.2165416181087494,
0.11666203290224075,
0.0324283167719841,
-0.020405471324920654,
0.5660644173622131,
0.24137131869792938,
0.036022771149873734,
-0.4113995134830475,
-0.48325052857398987,
-0.4396628737449646,
1.02908194065094,
0.30953603982925415,
0.5049470067024231,
0.24287903308868408,
0.9660742878913879,
0.06944000720977783,
0.6837748289108276,
-0.6766554713249207,
0.5856732726097107,
-0.03879239037632942,
-0.4047066569328308,
-0.08835355192422867,
-0.8373034596443176,
-1.4611756801605225,
0.2642044723033905,
-0.45841503143310547,
-0.7384722232818604,
0.1947270780801773,
-0.1008274108171463,
0.05611001327633858,
0.2845785319805145,
-0.6206954121589661,
0.3367036283016205,
-0.09177114814519882,
-0.5823379158973694,
0.14495418965816498,
-0.48570874333381653,
0.6226689219474792,
-0.4578632414340973,
0.3741925060749054,
0.013054809533059597,
-0.16432932019233704,
0.8062106370925903,
-0.10744384676218033,
0.003893817076459527,
-0.05683824047446251,
-0.08210750669240952,
0.13786502182483673,
0.027285775169730186,
0.6178493499755859,
-0.036743853241205215,
-0.4629603624343872,
0.04381183907389641,
-0.09989873319864273,
0.21002304553985596,
-0.8451746702194214,
0.8710402250289917,
-0.5111698508262634,
-0.4813060164451599,
-0.4563426971435547,
-0.33510851860046387,
-0.44283539056777954,
0.2821427285671234,
0.05780217796564102,
0.560191810131073,
-0.12515680491924286,
0.2619294822216034,
0.4192536175251007,
-0.25604838132858276,
0.4867691695690155,
0.3716681897640228,
-0.5203251838684082,
-0.7911044359207153,
0.8260557055473328,
0.0014386286493390799,
0.16492240130901337,
0.4632495939731598,
-0.11384355276823044,
-0.4957014322280884,
-0.19376078248023987,
-0.21112002432346344,
0.4925256371498108,
-0.3485354781150818,
-0.6806478500366211,
-0.6737720370292664,
-0.268899142742157,
-0.40228623151779175,
0.548275887966156,
-0.24251247942447662,
-0.30140265822410583,
-0.23614560067653656,
0.04877306893467903,
0.28345614671707153,
0.6706005930900574,
0.09857706725597382,
-0.19561418890953064,
-0.9278177618980408,
0.8012255430221558,
-0.04636184871196747,
0.22032739222049713,
0.13661016523838043,
-0.47455230355262756,
-0.013917033560574055,
-0.4630683958530426,
-0.2829708755016327,
-1.079891324043274,
0.6333916783332825,
0.2339792549610138,
0.5503573417663574,
0.0809372067451477,
-0.12741385400295258,
0.9863662123680115,
-0.653797447681427,
0.3702739477157593,
0.07724718004465103,
-0.3935493528842926,
0.42138540744781494,
-0.2174537479877472,
-0.22700193524360657,
0.5967267751693726,
0.27877822518348694,
-0.008387185633182526,
-0.04482867196202278,
-0.9547132253646851,
-0.972534716129303,
0.5579245686531067,
0.5491064190864563,
-0.34289705753326416,
0.011206869967281818,
0.8157778382301331,
-0.07906811684370041,
0.18982012569904327,
-0.4695102274417877,
-0.2753824293613434,
0.3775967061519623,
-0.01674703322350979,
0.20983955264091492,
-0.45577844977378845,
0.22566981613636017,
-0.045189373195171356,
0.6616484522819519,
0.5511226058006287,
0.2667032778263092,
0.29708319902420044,
-0.03741581737995148,
-0.10792215168476105,
0.33564987778663635,
-0.04940085485577583,
0.7953090667724609,
-0.3908669054508209,
0.13615697622299194,
0.21446555852890015,
-0.5285910367965698,
0.044148363173007965,
0.4349076449871063,
-0.0006155850715003908,
0.11061947792768478,
0.48824670910835266,
0.2820168733596802,
0.20196528732776642,
-0.43209412693977356,
0.5062638521194458,
-0.20195314288139343,
0.12599092721939087,
-0.48203393816947937,
-0.16594122350215912,
-0.000498468813020736,
0.16784168779850006,
0.47160348296165466,
-0.22521048784255981,
0.23281720280647278,
-0.4425303041934967,
0.5377984642982483,
0.46418341994285583,
-0.007879639975726604,
-0.22075721621513367,
0.4548276662826538,
0.021942978724837303,
-0.5241081118583679,
0.5897824168205261,
-0.09448979049921036,
-0.32468265295028687,
0.20734643936157227,
0.7996384501457214,
0.6348250508308411,
-0.338234543800354,
-0.1174764335155487,
0.6841627955436707,
0.10339593887329102,
0.04795468971133232,
0.1055663675069809,
-0.02985270880162716,
-0.82920902967453,
-0.8534396886825562,
-0.7865006327629089,
-0.14263993501663208,
0.4488316774368286,
-1.0574718713760376,
0.21850581467151642,
-0.1693255454301834,
-0.2789957523345947,
0.01865093782544136,
0.23760122060775757,
-0.659165620803833,
0.1443159133195877,
-0.20167005062103271,
0.8321763277053833,
-0.3686998188495636,
0.7150576710700989,
0.5052285194396973,
-0.5538077354431152,
-1.2798463106155396,
0.04405329003930092,
-0.25766998529434204,
-0.46058595180511475,
0.8365588188171387,
0.04847231134772301,
-0.2590009868144989,
0.1814541071653366,
-0.22289510071277618,
-0.8714354634284973,
1.2008979320526123,
0.34983548521995544,
-0.5688562989234924,
-0.11825767159461975,
-0.11481637507677078,
0.4784887731075287,
-0.4289092421531677,
0.2285720258951187,
0.8973671197891235,
0.2223142832517624,
0.3128017783164978,
-0.8197759985923767,
0.09742353856563568,
-0.24823342263698578,
0.15335100889205933,
0.6785019040107727,
-0.2654222249984741,
0.3834713101387024,
0.10624783486127853,
-0.4639299511909485,
0.11450187116861343,
0.7652755379676819,
0.6543011665344238,
0.2688567042350769,
0.47136542201042175,
0.7369439601898193,
0.5316546559333801,
0.04791448637843132,
1.101372480392456,
-0.0921744629740715,
0.2644300162792206,
1.3470485210418701,
-0.43179556727409363,
1.094277024269104,
0.7365213632583618,
-0.1431378573179245,
0.7286450862884521,
0.24907048046588898,
0.2702397108078003,
0.457755446434021,
-0.21287208795547485,
-0.26596498489379883,
0.026472311466932297,
-0.19709506630897522,
-0.2634562849998474,
0.40486767888069153,
0.5345340371131897,
-0.5051157474517822,
-0.35873526334762573,
-0.15453550219535828,
0.16510345041751862,
0.2413044273853302,
-0.06282457709312439,
1.0919815301895142,
0.19536031782627106,
-0.668707013130188,
0.4871036410331726,
-0.177467480301857,
0.4174199104309082,
-0.4326290786266327,
-0.7008447647094727,
-0.14174480736255646,
0.02818313241004944,
-0.20361380279064178,
-0.5001934170722961,
0.086593858897686,
0.2962149977684021,
-0.18670891225337982,
-0.054606933146715164,
1.1636914014816284,
-0.3305198848247528,
-0.23307836055755615,
0.4588403105735779,
0.7270849943161011,
0.11868329346179962,
0.130992591381073,
-0.47421208024024963,
0.11958632618188858,
0.24807322025299072,
-0.3827432692050934,
0.33975422382354736,
0.6663658022880554,
-0.09566986560821533,
0.5105193257331848,
0.7084468007087708,
0.5336744785308838,
-0.23172469437122345,
-0.06912811845541,
1.0828105211257935,
-0.7808412313461304,
0.035870954394340515,
-0.6931982636451721,
0.2540085017681122,
-0.4953175187110901,
-0.11278751492500305,
0.8907283544540405,
0.7431862354278564,
0.3525806665420532,
0.29830458760261536,
0.6116245985031128,
-0.1705884337425232,
1.190772294998169,
-0.34855037927627563,
0.20816674828529358,
-0.26211073994636536,
0.575965940952301,
-0.47285348176956177,
-1.2243623733520508,
-0.22055381536483765,
0.41632285714149475,
-0.3837692141532898,
0.027509134262800217,
0.6521801352500916,
0.8314626216888428,
-0.027386726811528206,
-0.12384792417287827,
0.031576577574014664,
0.11130688339471817,
0.6091931462287903,
0.3136461079120636,
0.880567193031311,
-0.4719240069389343,
0.7291324138641357,
-0.1657387614250183,
-0.2333294153213501,
0.2607191503047943,
-0.8161814212799072,
-0.7277445793151855,
-0.49591898918151855,
0.046934712678194046,
-0.4150441586971283,
0.14004117250442505,
0.7386534214019775,
0.16535450518131256,
-0.3896279036998749,
0.015189903788268566,
0.06269149482250214,
-0.15138089656829834,
0.19796466827392578,
-0.31591376662254333,
0.5124756097793579,
-0.30770444869995117,
-0.5080541968345642,
0.4183228015899658,
0.2290785163640976,
-0.15950660407543182,
0.047506097704172134,
-0.06914354115724564,
-0.6021703481674194,
-0.3474719524383545,
0.5990464687347412,
0.38289937376976013,
-0.5375149846076965,
-0.23166415095329285,
-0.13507692515850067,
-0.07178477197885513,
0.17510224878787994,
0.5779404044151306,
-0.9553039073944092,
0.4607199430465698,
0.4154004156589508,
0.9424880146980286,
0.7593635320663452,
0.6042953133583069,
0.665145218372345,
-0.8521794080734253,
-0.03191858530044556,
0.3110903799533844,
0.08003079891204834,
0.5257211327552795,
-0.3992810845375061,
0.9690629243850708,
0.026800064370036125,
-0.7134976983070374,
-0.7296290397644043,
0.044184859842061996,
-0.8844325542449951,
0.14954803884029388,
1.4418232440948486,
-0.17418089509010315,
-0.12896786630153656,
-0.19351619482040405,
-0.20923778414726257,
0.39696216583251953,
-0.3998437523841858,
0.44862791895866394,
0.3474023640155792,
-0.3565550744533539,
-0.4397560954093933,
-0.8079959154129028,
0.4751470983028412,
0.06763157248497009,
-0.8804150223731995,
-0.07737713307142258,
0.4120439291000366,
0.3817175328731537,
0.2746482193470001,
0.6097819805145264,
-0.48590996861457825,
-0.12323517352342606,
-0.49788838624954224,
0.13029344379901886,
-0.015272023156285286,
-0.14457634091377258,
-0.20447564125061035,
0.29843974113464355,
0.11643743515014648,
-0.17779898643493652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13390v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13390v1
|
Explanation based Bias Decoupling Regularization for Natural Language Inference
| 2024-04-20T14:20:24 | 2024-04-20T14:20:24 |
Jianxiang Zang, Hui Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The robustness of Transformer-based Natural Language Inference encoders is
frequently compromised as they tend to rely more on dataset biases than on the
intended task-relevant features. Recent studies have attempted to mitigate this
by reducing the weight of biased samples during the training process. However,
these debiasing methods primarily focus on identifying which samples are biased
without explicitly determining the biased components within each case. This
limitation restricts those methods' capability in out-of-distribution
inference. To address this issue, we aim to train models to adopt the logic
humans use in explaining causality. We propose a simple, comprehensive, and
interpretable method: Explanation based Bias Decoupling Regularization
(EBD-Reg). EBD-Reg employs human explanations as criteria, guiding the encoder
to establish a tripartite parallel supervision of Distinguishing, Decoupling
and Aligning. This method enables encoders to identify and focus on keywords
that represent the task-relevant features during inference, while discarding
the residual elements acting as biases. Empirical evidence underscores that
EBD-Reg effectively guides various Transformer-based encoders to decouple
biases through a human-centric lens, significantly surpassing other methods in
terms of out-of-distribution inference capabilities.
|
[
-0.6068063974380493,
-0.9662593007087708,
0.42155614495277405,
0.2250164896249771,
-0.37494346499443054,
-0.3397209048271179,
-0.43603599071502686,
-0.3144270181655884,
0.04752379283308983,
0.3909951448440552,
-0.7346389293670654,
-0.21663758158683777,
-0.6013908386230469,
0.3587830066680908,
-0.14930665493011475,
1.1115336418151855,
0.016798298805952072,
0.09039387851953506,
-0.3004498779773712,
-0.026090353727340698,
-0.7033182382583618,
-0.13901740312576294,
-0.6040804386138916,
-0.4457233250141144,
0.20129814743995667,
0.2354111224412918,
0.5822796821594238,
0.8068228960037231,
0.22353681921958923,
0.17462265491485596,
-0.12483516335487366,
0.12980201840400696,
-0.441890686750412,
-0.06730487197637558,
-0.2615831792354584,
-0.4428257346153259,
-0.10217702388763428,
0.034308161586523056,
0.3939121663570404,
1.1139819622039795,
-0.27509763836860657,
0.013881255872547626,
0.20076219737529755,
0.6718651652336121,
-0.7637848258018494,
0.16873155534267426,
-0.3721456825733185,
-0.08280544728040695,
0.01993185468018055,
-0.21844708919525146,
-0.5555734038352966,
-0.46512937545776367,
0.2477893829345703,
-0.6087480783462524,
0.7936166524887085,
0.09923494607210159,
1.0019258260726929,
0.6061741709709167,
-0.5646877884864807,
-0.013160536997020245,
-0.9063817858695984,
0.8476959466934204,
-0.6650934219360352,
0.6170855164527893,
0.49289801716804504,
0.280760794878006,
-0.16420873999595642,
-0.3376285433769226,
-0.60406893491745,
0.19534729421138763,
-0.44568854570388794,
0.27988481521606445,
-0.18771228194236755,
0.35722634196281433,
0.41930055618286133,
0.2379857748746872,
-0.5247036218643188,
0.006405492313206196,
-0.042712222784757614,
-0.21267743408679962,
0.3291715979576111,
-0.14203333854675293,
0.2316104620695114,
-0.09506860375404358,
-0.4521326720714569,
0.06917323172092438,
-0.5121811628341675,
0.08143142610788345,
0.35679420828819275,
0.013640223070979118,
-0.10977771878242493,
0.25140371918678284,
-0.27183306217193604,
0.9136839509010315,
0.442800909280777,
-0.0529097281396389,
0.07753665000200272,
-0.20883256196975708,
-0.5158500671386719,
0.22693967819213867,
0.4811606705188751,
0.4768076241016388,
0.13088025152683258,
-0.5345174670219421,
-0.032708585262298584,
0.3278663456439972,
0.09700468927621841,
-0.7980560660362244,
-0.14675021171569824,
0.25755372643470764,
-0.775852382183075,
-0.16558288037776947,
0.13970117270946503,
-1.3551915884017944,
-0.4907890856266022,
-0.3977144956588745,
0.2295546978712082,
-0.09530261158943176,
-0.25051742792129517,
0.39907336235046387,
-0.5386818647384644,
0.34904706478118896,
0.012639714404940605,
-0.9583981037139893,
0.4797256886959076,
0.3774005174636841,
0.48921242356300354,
-0.09015733748674393,
0.0049787238240242004,
-0.5502583384513855,
0.31802305579185486,
-0.0698380321264267,
0.759549081325531,
-0.491592675447464,
0.13883455097675323,
-0.06359582394361496,
0.04655746743083,
-0.11791778355836868,
-0.5731348395347595,
0.9415183067321777,
-0.5229904651641846,
0.3857481777667999,
-0.34343472123146057,
-0.6026780009269714,
-0.42859965562820435,
0.10892026126384735,
-0.7841314673423767,
0.9444539546966553,
-0.06954757124185562,
-1.0853676795959473,
0.8620602488517761,
-0.6022104024887085,
-0.41471540927886963,
-0.3202739357948303,
-0.06720921397209167,
-0.42748749256134033,
0.14049901068210602,
0.7311913371086121,
0.20112282037734985,
-0.6895526051521301,
0.6491963863372803,
-0.3872678577899933,
-0.2898866832256317,
0.050211403518915176,
-0.805898904800415,
1.0049822330474854,
0.17803625762462616,
-0.5688984990119934,
0.04724390059709549,
-0.8052738904953003,
-0.46382081508636475,
0.03801027685403824,
-0.23289091885089874,
-0.5398995876312256,
0.07599678635597229,
-0.1671508103609085,
0.158931702375412,
-0.12698854506015778,
-0.655437171459198,
-0.2301463782787323,
-0.5718277096748352,
0.36046257615089417,
0.6260819435119629,
0.2051248401403427,
0.727724015712738,
-0.13945573568344116,
0.4994843006134033,
0.20374253392219543,
0.12626932561397552,
-0.15013670921325684,
-0.6011014580726624,
-0.5382501482963562,
-0.7560293674468994,
0.289689302444458,
0.5073103904724121,
-0.41269880533218384,
0.8331797122955322,
-0.2678605914115906,
0.04539825767278671,
-0.6747643351554871,
0.04675600677728653,
0.4418204724788666,
1.0068506002426147,
0.5959111452102661,
-0.14631186425685883,
-0.6242595314979553,
-1.0748965740203857,
-0.6268052458763123,
0.17604169249534607,
-0.26067644357681274,
-0.06888966262340546,
0.26057490706443787,
-0.23980262875556946,
1.4553813934326172,
-0.4395265281200409,
-0.2138880044221878,
-0.3843381106853485,
0.2903016209602356,
0.13517536222934723,
0.2617071568965912,
0.3092738091945648,
-0.76271653175354,
-0.130660280585289,
-0.260418176651001,
-0.5949826836585999,
-0.4731188118457794,
-0.5649591684341431,
-0.40808895230293274,
0.10861468315124512,
0.4628759026527405,
-0.7220710515975952,
0.585708737373352,
0.23259659111499786,
-0.3861241042613983,
0.33733364939689636,
-0.21900351345539093,
-0.17267511785030365,
-0.9055935740470886,
-0.02200770005583763,
0.26471275091171265,
-0.21341300010681152,
-0.7009257674217224,
-0.19971826672554016,
0.054993003606796265,
0.1820494830608368,
0.11585986614227295,
0.4125460982322693,
-0.6415383219718933,
0.11081226170063019,
-0.10266025364398956,
0.2075250893831253,
0.516666054725647,
0.4871642589569092,
0.05319146811962128,
0.16941070556640625,
0.4958421289920807,
-0.5207064151763916,
0.16890422999858856,
0.23486416041851044,
-0.006575279403477907,
0.5347333550453186,
-0.5073971152305603,
-0.0848047137260437,
-0.6087846755981445,
0.6324416399002075,
-1.0850385427474976,
-0.3181016743183136,
0.4196690320968628,
-0.2304634302854538,
0.27126410603523254,
-0.30554479360580444,
-0.3264092803001404,
-0.32364481687545776,
-0.31382110714912415,
0.4123222827911377,
0.5164856314659119,
-0.9065473079681396,
0.8656644821166992,
0.2650509774684906,
0.16836963593959808,
-0.5662808418273926,
-0.8524892926216125,
-0.09618760645389557,
-0.5747424364089966,
-0.6113682389259338,
0.504261314868927,
0.14918190240859985,
-0.3971599340438843,
0.06106889620423317,
-0.34232547879219055,
-0.2964070737361908,
0.05703864246606827,
0.10836868733167648,
0.181071475148201,
-0.013688339851796627,
0.11400005966424942,
0.4671810567378998,
-0.17817577719688416,
0.36821022629737854,
-0.1291216015815735,
0.15817168354988098,
0.23842370510101318,
-0.30943310260772705,
-0.771612286567688,
0.46310561895370483,
0.3285936117172241,
-0.2859431803226471,
0.8722484111785889,
0.6467107534408569,
-0.556727945804596,
-0.3031846880912781,
-0.8162592053413391,
-0.5976064205169678,
-0.3569050431251526,
0.1612541228532791,
-0.10841640830039978,
-0.45127326250076294,
0.517755925655365,
-0.10055091232061386,
-0.0018528018845245242,
0.1438363790512085,
0.4043342173099518,
0.10666558891534805,
1.122912049293518,
0.5759006142616272,
-0.16268201172351837,
0.32932740449905396,
0.016903413459658623,
0.4995967745780945,
-0.6562486290931702,
-0.10847678035497665,
-0.4438064992427826,
-0.18721239268779755,
-0.29196175932884216,
-0.21197564899921417,
-0.17933543026447296,
0.3640430271625519,
-0.09153567254543304,
0.018742134794592857,
-0.46029138565063477,
0.5009996294975281,
0.5867416858673096,
0.2778846323490143,
0.41027694940567017,
0.03297378495335579,
0.09389494359493256,
-0.010880030691623688,
-0.5485996603965759,
-0.31390517950057983,
0.8122159838676453,
0.36585110425949097,
0.7938602566719055,
-0.016406506299972534,
0.8149295449256897,
0.09914608299732208,
0.3710569143295288,
-0.6985619068145752,
0.14595739543437958,
0.26502543687820435,
-0.7276181578636169,
-0.23051860928535461,
-0.468535453081131,
-0.7761846780776978,
0.411796510219574,
-0.08460836857557297,
-0.5335474014282227,
0.6011815071105957,
0.3920876979827881,
-0.2300165444612503,
0.033956486731767654,
-1.0621057748794556,
1.0474529266357422,
0.15663009881973267,
-0.18219028413295746,
-0.0755617544054985,
-0.8764944672584534,
0.5007743835449219,
0.13619114458560944,
0.41942471265792847,
0.26199498772621155,
0.29484641551971436,
0.7613879442214966,
-0.23385301232337952,
1.0194703340530396,
-0.47277483344078064,
-0.025720885023474693,
0.19662228226661682,
-0.09061270952224731,
0.6764452457427979,
0.13963359594345093,
0.07182402908802032,
0.14002664387226105,
-0.33490604162216187,
-0.32852888107299805,
-0.9178605079650879,
0.28998881578445435,
-0.4122195243835449,
-0.5756326913833618,
-0.016956908628344536,
-0.6651735305786133,
-0.2698960304260254,
0.2287493497133255,
0.3713996708393097,
0.5915167331695557,
-0.013050361536443233,
0.03851672634482384,
0.783060610294342,
-0.28945744037628174,
0.36038458347320557,
0.3091823160648346,
0.1449369490146637,
-0.3229433000087738,
0.7321900725364685,
-0.248881995677948,
0.21933519840240479,
0.4907500147819519,
0.38017943501472473,
-0.48790162801742554,
-0.39092734456062317,
-0.33021482825279236,
0.2027338296175003,
-0.762913703918457,
-0.03504238277673721,
-0.6048574447631836,
0.34825700521469116,
-0.27868515253067017,
-0.19580967724323273,
-0.06433108448982239,
-0.15407125651836395,
-0.15935438871383667,
-0.4158751368522644,
0.042388882488012314,
0.4842030107975006,
-0.0017772444989532232,
0.15699203312397003,
-0.6193123459815979,
0.797313392162323,
0.13907936215400696,
0.22181253135204315,
-0.08974074572324753,
-0.6372454762458801,
-0.15394076704978943,
0.14679890871047974,
-0.08295993506908417,
-1.2449619770050049,
0.3930368721485138,
0.13344794511795044,
0.7311024069786072,
0.9013931751251221,
0.306973934173584,
0.7196831703186035,
-0.2411673367023468,
0.4500715136528015,
0.14074711501598358,
-0.9328845143318176,
0.5158119797706604,
-0.20869429409503937,
-0.11402382701635361,
0.31363242864608765,
0.1984117478132248,
-0.30372554063796997,
-0.47895196080207825,
-0.4269442856311798,
-0.8393269777297974,
0.7211312651634216,
0.1579577773809433,
-0.3035881519317627,
-0.3146970272064209,
0.3378911018371582,
0.25533950328826904,
-0.03265102580189705,
-0.6738119721412659,
-0.38511788845062256,
-0.2844110131263733,
-0.4123043119907379,
0.15981146693229675,
-0.3110989034175873,
-0.40855610370635986,
-0.3140988349914551,
0.4432874023914337,
-0.17805536091327667,
0.2363979071378708,
0.3879365026950836,
-0.4785383641719818,
-0.017965739592909813,
0.45232903957366943,
0.5015912652015686,
0.646540105342865,
-0.4104824364185333,
0.2620609700679779,
0.06986112147569656,
-0.3970000743865967,
-0.05695828050374985,
0.3739301264286041,
-0.2841237783432007,
0.10712417960166931,
0.36162710189819336,
0.7758771777153015,
-0.03284875303506851,
-0.5635212063789368,
0.5974251627922058,
-0.10254259407520294,
-0.023678535595536232,
0.14140525460243225,
-0.46339529752731323,
-0.00031720229890197515,
0.1394897997379303,
0.33553972840309143,
0.3171798288822174,
0.3327588140964508,
-0.22491061687469482,
0.15609093010425568,
0.4891285002231598,
-0.4575813412666321,
-0.40092387795448303,
0.7996603846549988,
0.3637397289276123,
0.2152896225452423,
0.4457572400569916,
-0.3005378246307373,
-0.39452293515205383,
0.6853395700454712,
0.7238683104515076,
1.1675442457199097,
0.15174102783203125,
0.15175385773181915,
0.2958368957042694,
0.5422221422195435,
-0.2845705449581146,
0.120937280356884,
-0.13257989287376404,
-0.9597839117050171,
-0.8007684946060181,
-0.535185694694519,
-0.07406192272901535,
-0.1311389058828354,
-1.1309643983840942,
0.07123198360204697,
-0.014451795257627964,
0.051329102367162704,
-0.22770901024341583,
-0.5647895932197571,
-0.6800528168678284,
0.1688230037689209,
0.026848390698432922,
0.8253048658370972,
-1.3331613540649414,
0.5787280201911926,
0.500230073928833,
-0.4829595386981964,
-0.6183256506919861,
0.46105122566223145,
0.05418459698557854,
-0.35271745920181274,
0.7396354079246521,
0.2774070203304291,
-0.023569175973534584,
0.12765562534332275,
-0.30963173508644104,
-0.4470262825489044,
0.9661056399345398,
0.7814929485321045,
-0.3405754864215851,
-0.013611909002065659,
-0.1045786663889885,
0.3791922926902771,
-0.19063590466976166,
0.34177708625793457,
0.988361120223999,
0.6399877071380615,
-0.43090906739234924,
-0.6049438714981079,
0.4536222219467163,
0.13820981979370117,
-0.01291908510029316,
0.2601328492164612,
-0.10167764127254486,
0.46181929111480713,
-0.26385697722435,
-0.33502626419067383,
-0.47091150283813477,
0.5694060325622559,
0.07884865999221802,
0.1928771287202835,
0.6380856037139893,
0.8617066740989685,
0.7682122588157654,
-0.10035401582717896,
1.123874306678772,
-0.15760914981365204,
0.47979676723480225,
1.040095567703247,
-0.04790444299578667,
0.2565663456916809,
0.8109990954399109,
-0.0012376396916806698,
0.5682028532028198,
0.6716265678405762,
0.2396865040063858,
0.6786794662475586,
-0.08010256290435791,
-0.2625172734260559,
-0.3872489929199219,
-0.14432519674301147,
-0.04844469204545021,
0.20752263069152832,
0.20649468898773193,
-0.42598938941955566,
-0.5508852601051331,
-0.003660549409687519,
-0.05687098205089569,
0.009897694922983646,
-0.157842218875885,
0.7050636410713196,
-0.1595396250486374,
-0.700394332408905,
0.3551202118396759,
-0.06817423552274704,
0.6602420210838318,
-0.20536892116069794,
-0.2918643057346344,
-0.3770292401313782,
0.257773220539093,
-0.38408899307250977,
-0.4063471257686615,
0.40791186690330505,
-0.21820630133152008,
-0.5261912941932678,
-0.3659994900226593,
0.6484951376914978,
-0.47494077682495117,
-0.14934943616390228,
0.405735582113266,
0.31204381585121155,
-0.15090066194534302,
-0.2123967558145523,
-0.3544062674045563,
-0.2126408964395523,
0.014017888344824314,
-0.32964804768562317,
0.1864374279975891,
0.5510386824607849,
-0.20133183896541595,
0.5322465896606445,
0.6618527770042419,
0.08389650285243988,
0.17371220886707306,
0.465041846036911,
0.759316623210907,
-0.6307299733161926,
-0.5451027154922485,
-1.0492271184921265,
0.5682742595672607,
-0.12308584153652191,
-0.11614824086427689,
0.7547368407249451,
0.3199779689311981,
0.6747386455535889,
-0.22575046122074127,
0.8812730312347412,
-0.06639036536216736,
0.4793090224266052,
-0.5586381554603577,
0.485115647315979,
-0.26606401801109314,
0.2993777394294739,
-0.163051575422287,
-0.9456102848052979,
-0.49742594361305237,
0.5652766227722168,
-0.27648118138313293,
0.03616417571902275,
0.9076784253120422,
0.8431408405303955,
-0.19534584879875183,
0.10001636296510696,
0.004014866892248392,
0.2802444398403168,
0.4354138970375061,
0.1837550699710846,
0.5294526815414429,
-0.10831742733716965,
0.7101801633834839,
-0.36631548404693604,
-0.5166695713996887,
-0.17465534806251526,
-1.0084272623062134,
-1.0369714498519897,
-0.20473487675189972,
-0.31245654821395874,
-0.2040950357913971,
-0.09748747944831848,
0.8697992563247681,
0.48948997259140015,
-0.8666334748268127,
0.22899256646633148,
-0.6865864992141724,
0.32304075360298157,
-0.5785737037658691,
-0.35646405816078186,
0.4031113088130951,
-0.36513257026672363,
-0.6489807367324829,
0.2928164303302765,
0.2632404565811157,
-0.4321252703666687,
-0.12509827315807343,
0.038206785917282104,
-0.03777739033102989,
0.08563580363988876,
0.42596009373664856,
0.19262176752090454,
-0.914813756942749,
-0.3098143935203552,
-0.2951906621456146,
0.21028535068035126,
-0.019565118476748466,
0.8385328650474548,
-0.8381703495979309,
0.7374290227890015,
0.7451550364494324,
0.8306383490562439,
0.15706275403499603,
0.39105579257011414,
0.8005253672599792,
-0.7870242595672607,
0.2236480414867401,
-0.1180616244673729,
0.4853995740413666,
0.2838101089000702,
-0.2675245702266693,
0.303124338388443,
0.3669544756412506,
-0.4116305410861969,
-0.8890593647956848,
0.3283913731575012,
-0.8923375010490417,
-0.0410011000931263,
1.1147496700286865,
-0.15407699346542358,
-0.20103590190410614,
-0.6921464204788208,
-0.3035517632961273,
0.550590455532074,
-0.3787619471549988,
0.8973459005355835,
0.5570496320724487,
-0.17367355525493622,
-0.1340348720550537,
-0.4322040379047394,
0.5878053307533264,
0.406455397605896,
-0.8356664180755615,
0.429217666387558,
0.5058740377426147,
0.3238834738731384,
-0.08578406274318695,
0.34854599833488464,
0.04444558173418045,
0.1574723720550537,
-0.08220457285642624,
0.22891353070735931,
0.07236509025096893,
-0.18223297595977783,
-0.610655665397644,
-0.2064560055732727,
-0.23835714161396027,
-0.2724767327308655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13370v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13370v1
|
Movie101v2: Improved Movie Narration Benchmark
| 2024-04-20T13:15:27 | 2024-04-20T13:15:27 |
Zihao Yue, Yepeng Zhang, Ziheng Wang, Qin Jin
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Automatic movie narration targets at creating video-aligned plot descriptions
to assist visually impaired audiences. It differs from standard video
captioning in that it requires not only describing key visual details but also
inferring the plots developed across multiple movie shots, thus posing unique
and ongoing challenges. To advance the development of automatic movie narrating
systems, we first revisit the limitations of existing datasets and develop a
large-scale, bilingual movie narration dataset, Movie101v2. Second, taking into
account the essential difficulties in achieving applicable movie narration, we
break the long-term goal into three progressive stages and tentatively focus on
the initial stages featuring understanding within individual clips. We also
introduce a new narration assessment to align with our staged task goals.
Third, using our new dataset, we baseline several leading large vision-language
models, including GPT-4V, and conduct in-depth investigations into the
challenges current models face for movie narration generation. Our findings
reveal that achieving applicable movie narration generation is a fascinating
goal that requires thorough research.
|
[
-0.10784028470516205,
-0.44701266288757324,
0.48138028383255005,
0.38242506980895996,
-0.1942337155342102,
0.05333453044295311,
0.21580827236175537,
-0.3635322153568268,
-0.15433184802532196,
0.35709601640701294,
-0.5987171530723572,
-0.0055319517850875854,
-0.6645681858062744,
0.2824145257472992,
-0.4950309991836548,
0.9740537405014038,
-0.4002247452735901,
0.125419020652771,
-0.30342480540275574,
-0.0717785507440567,
-0.7436473369598389,
-0.243233323097229,
-0.42984092235565186,
-0.07297559082508087,
0.3378976881504059,
0.46769440174102783,
0.7195509076118469,
1.0122365951538086,
0.6167902946472168,
0.16578145325183868,
0.26862093806266785,
0.19230113923549652,
-0.21856464445590973,
0.2147771418094635,
0.10615764558315277,
-0.13077344000339508,
-0.4073948860168457,
0.06418025493621826,
0.8770186305046082,
0.8097679018974304,
-0.06513252854347229,
0.4168688654899597,
0.08490258455276489,
0.6466861367225647,
-0.6388349533081055,
0.4376705586910248,
-0.09444372355937958,
0.20220403373241425,
-0.114407017827034,
0.11648760735988617,
-0.16955463588237762,
-0.3379155695438385,
0.22012481093406677,
-0.6611239314079285,
0.2865143418312073,
0.09336303919553757,
0.9151306748390198,
0.41797998547554016,
-0.43947967886924744,
-0.048086073249578476,
-0.9253998398780823,
0.4534842371940613,
-0.3183317184448242,
0.15442213416099548,
0.4890359044075012,
0.5885870456695557,
0.3917820453643799,
-0.9349898099899292,
-0.362176775932312,
-0.14575235545635223,
0.11012249439954758,
0.0508473664522171,
-0.4166103005409241,
-0.1639086902141571,
0.43705013394355774,
0.42188331484794617,
-0.5991893410682678,
0.13644446432590485,
-0.6780186891555786,
-0.3980284333229065,
0.38940346240997314,
0.5361123085021973,
-0.10746920108795166,
-0.44602933526039124,
-0.5133249759674072,
-0.22520111501216888,
-0.41665276885032654,
0.27729523181915283,
0.392482727766037,
-0.06090522184967995,
-0.12669500708580017,
0.48518460988998413,
-0.5880219340324402,
0.36656805872917175,
-0.0641719400882721,
-0.0738280862569809,
0.3870782256126404,
-0.611326277256012,
-0.25598105788230896,
0.17607459425926208,
0.3206104636192322,
0.9742269515991211,
0.5065507292747498,
0.10823976993560791,
-0.07205132395029068,
0.016210094094276428,
0.3908410370349884,
-0.7262352705001831,
-0.2967214286327362,
0.041632991284132004,
-0.3479115068912506,
-0.2048003375530243,
0.04664986953139305,
-0.8695796728134155,
-0.7806785702705383,
-0.416180819272995,
0.6466946005821228,
-0.40079203248023987,
-0.04878329113125801,
-0.15524038672447205,
-0.48199227452278137,
0.6230244040489197,
0.6125705242156982,
-0.8826315402984619,
0.5073147416114807,
0.39609020948410034,
0.7472442388534546,
-0.3810931146144867,
-0.3504393994808197,
-0.934210479259491,
0.3315217196941376,
-0.5383901596069336,
0.6663245558738708,
-0.35528564453125,
0.03604119271039963,
0.030507519841194153,
-0.08450146019458771,
0.1553371697664261,
-0.41559770703315735,
0.3740655779838562,
-0.011509685777127743,
0.43117061257362366,
-0.24670250713825226,
-0.2545473575592041,
-0.10951065272092819,
0.3836210072040558,
-0.5306912064552307,
0.7061358094215393,
0.3853533864021301,
-0.28835105895996094,
0.44527992606163025,
-0.3490276634693146,
-0.21667934954166412,
0.06849178671836853,
-0.376662939786911,
-0.3611249327659607,
0.2607564926147461,
0.46592384576797485,
0.10410141944885254,
-0.5122731328010559,
0.4209059178829193,
0.33261939883232117,
-0.39580249786376953,
-0.17613013088703156,
-0.6372682452201843,
0.4177382290363312,
0.2648014426231384,
-0.2944563031196594,
-0.02150372415781021,
-0.6832424402236938,
0.052158866077661514,
0.09772176295518875,
0.10785012692213058,
0.2544897794723511,
0.021167587488889694,
-0.07815373688936234,
-0.1009640246629715,
0.10672125220298767,
-0.14433424174785614,
0.08287439495325089,
-0.2304968386888504,
0.20966042578220367,
0.6213746070861816,
0.10349703580141068,
0.34512028098106384,
-0.17101341485977173,
0.8399233222007751,
-0.16354522109031677,
0.48607710003852844,
-0.8448176980018616,
-0.45906323194503784,
-0.6990789771080017,
0.04893752187490463,
0.06476680934429169,
0.7323315143585205,
-0.7328285574913025,
-0.04701592028141022,
-0.21640285849571228,
-0.13907741010189056,
-0.20036856830120087,
0.0366777665913105,
0.5426418781280518,
0.5531697869300842,
0.5584282875061035,
-0.6279140114784241,
-0.7205538153648376,
-1.0819708108901978,
0.19184739887714386,
-0.34977543354034424,
-0.2602922320365906,
0.08179692924022675,
0.254241406917572,
0.22990629076957703,
0.5964733958244324,
-0.28180044889450073,
-0.5450583100318909,
-0.3797459602355957,
0.04454530403017998,
0.12137648463249207,
0.3975437879562378,
0.14596813917160034,
-0.7216777205467224,
-0.5475959777832031,
-0.18307392299175262,
-0.9950355887413025,
-0.0017499561654403806,
-0.23482398688793182,
0.4984072148799896,
-0.1284147948026657,
0.701720118522644,
-0.19814689457416534,
0.612529456615448,
0.34537485241889954,
-0.4113166332244873,
0.6264170408248901,
-0.574947714805603,
0.42456158995628357,
-0.518987238407135,
-0.2595936954021454,
-0.020277105271816254,
-0.00804776232689619,
-0.7004871964454651,
-0.32476216554641724,
-0.025478776544332504,
-0.14614859223365784,
-0.42453330755233765,
0.29029372334480286,
-0.49463215470314026,
-0.2890036702156067,
-0.2236260622739792,
0.1105770692229271,
0.17991378903388977,
0.36378782987594604,
-0.012630000710487366,
0.535012423992157,
0.6641890406608582,
-0.44542598724365234,
0.708195149898529,
0.49915754795074463,
-0.709395706653595,
0.5051845908164978,
-0.6273360848426819,
-0.20628494024276733,
-0.2571931481361389,
0.2634221315383911,
-1.1232860088348389,
-0.6340056657791138,
0.13486668467521667,
-0.28153151273727417,
0.23842887580394745,
-0.1469506174325943,
-0.3688814640045166,
-0.25969433784484863,
-0.14771056175231934,
0.2702350914478302,
0.8016059994697571,
-0.14471526443958282,
0.4677307903766632,
0.1516173630952835,
-0.45876824855804443,
-0.24891728162765503,
-0.4269258975982666,
0.4354519248008728,
-0.6081949472427368,
-0.6334670782089233,
0.42225220799446106,
0.25015318393707275,
-0.3500267565250397,
-0.5687716603279114,
-0.3133169114589691,
-0.1834246814250946,
-0.19315209984779358,
0.23729729652404785,
0.31752461194992065,
-0.1254400908946991,
0.14437976479530334,
-0.06069643795490265,
-0.4035956859588623,
0.15408101677894592,
0.03908849507570267,
0.17114044725894928,
0.12530109286308289,
0.0963779091835022,
-0.5834143757820129,
0.5103669166564941,
0.4340204894542694,
-0.4103598892688751,
0.0121573181822896,
0.8105245232582092,
-0.15870216488838196,
0.10293197631835938,
-0.6710541248321533,
0.02505001425743103,
-0.4166480302810669,
0.5954939126968384,
-0.5705804228782654,
-0.4165765047073364,
0.25334152579307556,
-0.1441533863544464,
-0.2549077868461609,
0.37045812606811523,
0.27634719014167786,
-0.10626834630966187,
1.1612869501113892,
0.7793853282928467,
0.3955806791782379,
0.4062739312648773,
0.0009580294718034565,
-0.09227046370506287,
-0.6795624494552612,
-0.42559921741485596,
-0.3103630840778351,
-0.13870687782764435,
-0.2863765060901642,
-0.5455561876296997,
0.4876096248626709,
0.3700960874557495,
-0.4418829083442688,
0.35429269075393677,
-0.43542975187301636,
0.6828909516334534,
0.42134252190589905,
-0.2573065757751465,
0.37743711471557617,
0.20568329095840454,
-0.04699208587408066,
-0.32525789737701416,
-0.5915780067443848,
-0.6395775675773621,
0.7098536491394043,
0.5755229592323303,
0.6602960824966431,
0.21186815202236176,
0.22333362698554993,
0.46876728534698486,
-0.13069094717502594,
-0.2968185544013977,
0.46322113275527954,
-0.33406996726989746,
-0.5434157252311707,
-0.43039897084236145,
0.11150330305099487,
-0.6562314033508301,
-0.06800917536020279,
0.08115994930267334,
-1.099186658859253,
0.36094242334365845,
0.21982601284980774,
-0.5150368213653564,
-0.1783391535282135,
-0.8742501735687256,
1.1819922924041748,
-0.32118356227874756,
-0.592545211315155,
-0.03593754395842552,
-1.0988742113113403,
0.08400322496891022,
0.08048224449157715,
0.11519116163253784,
-0.21916092932224274,
-0.11000801622867584,
0.708899736404419,
-0.2187989503145218,
0.6294932961463928,
-0.3607993423938751,
0.15104196965694427,
0.4474988877773285,
0.20207512378692627,
0.6679887175559998,
-0.13232123851776123,
-0.028325818479061127,
-0.20577871799468994,
0.05860556662082672,
-0.2615194320678711,
-0.4551472067832947,
0.3184790015220642,
-0.3749169111251831,
-0.6963415741920471,
-0.4723229706287384,
-0.3953133821487427,
-0.4095733165740967,
-0.14449962973594666,
0.19678863883018494,
0.5652894377708435,
-0.20650595426559448,
0.23618967831134796,
0.4826951026916504,
-0.4577080309391022,
0.6451554298400879,
0.3236573040485382,
-0.4161170721054077,
-0.6602704524993896,
0.8486210107803345,
-0.01968834176659584,
0.43800869584083557,
0.08079800754785538,
0.009610745124518871,
-0.17778851091861725,
-0.7902080416679382,
-0.7031915187835693,
-0.15211932361125946,
-0.7279994487762451,
-0.0825207531452179,
-0.3617422580718994,
-0.11629106104373932,
-0.2953706979751587,
-0.04488809406757355,
-0.440543532371521,
-0.3325618803501129,
0.1044141948223114,
-0.4684062898159027,
0.1985829472541809,
0.7828409671783447,
-0.16403040289878845,
0.15524005889892578,
-0.6197993159294128,
0.5473051071166992,
0.413664311170578,
0.3627890646457672,
-0.3000398874282837,
-0.8493700623512268,
-0.3606348931789398,
-0.40631890296936035,
-0.3331957757472992,
-0.5836901664733887,
0.40749475359916687,
0.2135399430990219,
0.4513072967529297,
0.162462055683136,
-0.14985275268554688,
0.8798651099205017,
-0.7120435833930969,
0.996429443359375,
0.4329708218574524,
-0.7885366082191467,
0.8141321539878845,
-0.3074203431606293,
0.48855721950531006,
0.48708683252334595,
0.32472625374794006,
-0.33838990330696106,
-0.009343468584120274,
-0.4443759024143219,
-0.7901209592819214,
0.7882675528526306,
0.714061439037323,
0.24783669412136078,
0.24963334202766418,
0.09894857555627823,
0.4851277768611908,
0.0838770866394043,
-0.5190324187278748,
-0.24281291663646698,
-0.49784988164901733,
0.07625308632850647,
-0.42774492502212524,
-0.3133152723312378,
-0.06023907661437988,
-0.47528332471847534,
0.18834275007247925,
-0.1311274617910385,
0.10959427803754807,
0.3514210283756256,
0.10038439929485321,
-0.21419024467468262,
0.057325880974531174,
0.43226417899131775,
0.7551973462104797,
-0.36387741565704346,
0.025064406916499138,
0.2183520793914795,
-0.3302006423473358,
0.24233576655387878,
0.3411957025527954,
-0.09484846889972687,
0.0794663056731224,
0.5955891013145447,
1.194107174873352,
-0.12267541885375977,
-0.7587276101112366,
0.4871659278869629,
0.2155572921037674,
-0.49355241656303406,
-0.44643351435661316,
0.02735709957778454,
-0.3098698854446411,
0.29044675827026367,
0.8069207668304443,
-0.2020549327135086,
0.22620736062526703,
-0.7382861971855164,
0.33024635910987854,
-0.08613463491201401,
-0.571516752243042,
-0.07452092319726944,
0.9452897310256958,
0.29261747002601624,
-0.4022527039051056,
0.7516278028488159,
-0.10567675530910492,
-0.12447641044855118,
0.8133374452590942,
0.2867587208747864,
0.7652682065963745,
-0.1709287315607071,
0.5020408630371094,
0.6398625373840332,
0.31125226616859436,
-0.21365384757518768,
-0.09074986726045609,
-0.2220459282398224,
-0.44087958335876465,
-0.3634476959705353,
-0.5267916321754456,
-0.5225772857666016,
-0.008461945690214634,
-0.7434375286102295,
0.26338204741477966,
-0.17003455758094788,
0.1597571074962616,
0.3049025237560272,
-0.1192261278629303,
-0.3858053982257843,
0.4583342969417572,
0.5724076628684998,
0.5893560647964478,
-0.6513856053352356,
0.8766107559204102,
0.26525241136550903,
-0.7028082013130188,
-0.5860998630523682,
-0.2574548125267029,
0.06804932653903961,
-0.5970072150230408,
0.8143836259841919,
0.49496981501579285,
0.2514316439628601,
0.0970953181385994,
-0.4928428530693054,
-0.8291966319084167,
1.3413625955581665,
0.26981276273727417,
-0.4710046947002411,
-0.6062381863594055,
0.2521318197250366,
0.5962430834770203,
-0.692747950553894,
0.14565670490264893,
0.659293532371521,
0.6409085988998413,
0.12135767936706543,
-1.2607392072677612,
-0.23754549026489258,
-0.23485687375068665,
-0.1387907713651657,
0.019080471247434616,
-0.46891942620277405,
0.637234091758728,
-0.39587172865867615,
-0.05911945179104805,
0.27175652980804443,
0.4476983845233917,
-0.04181985184550285,
0.611771821975708,
0.48986324667930603,
0.01573878712952137,
0.3784928023815155,
-0.26526883244514465,
1.276938796043396,
0.3277876377105713,
-0.10227915644645691,
1.479913592338562,
-0.33036932349205017,
0.45554444193840027,
0.5158402919769287,
-0.4074343144893646,
0.44716283679008484,
0.3581802248954773,
-0.43310800194740295,
0.49720299243927,
0.17681831121444702,
0.004600147251039743,
-0.5221235156059265,
-0.17893634736537933,
-0.24015869200229645,
0.7407238483428955,
0.18574568629264832,
-0.5495691299438477,
-0.2445937842130661,
0.36463314294815063,
-0.5826815962791443,
0.2794913947582245,
-0.2415616661310196,
0.9668663144111633,
-0.17680290341377258,
-0.8402333855628967,
0.4236070513725281,
-0.3004370331764221,
0.005118866451084614,
-0.7205963730812073,
-0.21950940787792206,
-0.48580121994018555,
0.05602645128965378,
0.19377189874649048,
-0.6001777052879333,
0.11207617074251175,
0.38980162143707275,
-0.24491503834724426,
-0.5521219968795776,
0.1346701979637146,
-0.3689350187778473,
-0.34376850724220276,
-0.08845006674528122,
0.48908182978630066,
0.502976655960083,
-0.14059364795684814,
-0.4706485867500305,
0.3155856430530548,
0.38806432485580444,
-0.02813066355884075,
0.2030373066663742,
0.2691360414028168,
-0.25195735692977905,
0.6307210326194763,
-0.13312377035617828,
-0.21956294775009155,
0.025482313707470894,
0.2001664936542511,
0.3712543547153473,
-0.8743960857391357,
-0.31853508949279785,
-0.6185362339019775,
0.9058241248130798,
-0.23557505011558533,
-0.47975775599479675,
0.7301265597343445,
0.6684215068817139,
0.6173605918884277,
-0.19489102065563202,
0.6021501421928406,
-0.15342502295970917,
0.37126240134239197,
-0.5911633372306824,
0.10005968064069748,
-0.2898055613040924,
0.3464340269565582,
-0.18070602416992188,
-1.2670992612838745,
-0.21112987399101257,
0.3447224199771881,
-0.14423033595085144,
-0.039414357393980026,
1.0127449035644531,
0.6795554757118225,
0.16499648988246918,
-0.23093906044960022,
0.4179840683937073,
-0.0038729063235223293,
0.31912338733673096,
0.48811689019203186,
0.8562723398208618,
-0.7993088960647583,
1.0288219451904297,
-0.3844309449195862,
-0.0651758536696434,
0.020691219717264175,
-0.7979171276092529,
-0.4297499656677246,
-0.6432745456695557,
-0.8121196031570435,
-0.19621072709560394,
0.369263619184494,
0.5117800235748291,
0.5917447209358215,
-0.673275351524353,
-0.35896098613739014,
-0.1795257329940796,
-0.2670985162258148,
-0.45589303970336914,
-0.2378235012292862,
0.320804238319397,
-0.12035591900348663,
-0.8953437805175781,
0.6496036052703857,
0.5264890193939209,
0.14788004755973816,
-0.303274542093277,
-0.34116607904434204,
-0.03447738289833069,
0.09763438999652863,
0.422471284866333,
0.26520824432373047,
-0.6832038164138794,
-0.26892367005348206,
-0.3506394028663635,
0.05148565024137497,
0.2176373451948166,
0.7176533341407776,
-0.8438650965690613,
0.8764427900314331,
0.1846587359905243,
0.17310087382793427,
0.7901610732078552,
0.2550010085105896,
1.0079879760742188,
-0.5464458465576172,
-0.03284510225057602,
0.07740075886249542,
0.1680353581905365,
0.4894842207431793,
0.013017685152590275,
0.8092274069786072,
0.049966465681791306,
-0.4123993217945099,
-0.9209030270576477,
0.198961079120636,
-1.2161587476730347,
-0.10521554946899414,
1.0270397663116455,
0.004533556755632162,
0.2771824896335602,
-0.23889504373073578,
-0.49439147114753723,
-0.006341249216347933,
-0.14727388322353363,
0.47887542843818665,
0.749543309211731,
-0.3549928367137909,
-0.4391340911388397,
-0.6356180310249329,
0.7980220317840576,
0.2301502525806427,
-0.6361846923828125,
0.40177857875823975,
0.870980978012085,
-0.016081059351563454,
-0.005338534712791443,
0.44341281056404114,
-0.18286582827568054,
0.6449199318885803,
0.5629400014877319,
-0.14694657921791077,
-0.4259740114212036,
-0.5152488946914673,
-0.3975240886211395,
0.5063502788543701,
-0.17617210745811462,
-0.11424411833286285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13364v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13364v1
|
MahaSQuAD: Bridging Linguistic Divides in Marathi Question-Answering
| 2024-04-20T12:16:35 | 2024-04-20T12:16:35 |
Ruturaj Ghatage, Aditya Kulkarni, Rajlaxmi Patil, Sharvi Endait, Raviraj Joshi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Question-answering systems have revolutionized information retrieval, but
linguistic and cultural boundaries limit their widespread accessibility. This
research endeavors to bridge the gap of the absence of efficient QnA datasets
in low-resource languages by translating the English Question Answering Dataset
(SQuAD) using a robust data curation approach. We introduce MahaSQuAD, the
first-ever full SQuAD dataset for the Indic language Marathi, consisting of
118,516 training, 11,873 validation, and 11,803 test samples. We also present a
gold test set of manually verified 500 examples. Challenges in maintaining
context and handling linguistic nuances are addressed, ensuring accurate
translations. Moreover, as a QnA dataset cannot be simply converted into any
low-resource language using translation, we need a robust method to map the
answer translation to its span in the translated passage. Hence, to address
this challenge, we also present a generic approach for translating SQuAD into
any low-resource language. Thus, we offer a scalable approach to bridge
linguistic and cultural gaps present in low-resource languages, in the realm of
question-answering systems. The datasets and models are shared publicly at
https://github.com/l3cube-pune/MarathiNLP .
|
[
-0.441781610250473,
-0.8068484663963318,
0.2003166824579239,
0.18361766636371613,
-0.3943529725074768,
0.4951130747795105,
-0.10661008208990097,
-0.22334833443164825,
0.3309057950973511,
0.47736766934394836,
-0.9241344928741455,
-0.23326516151428223,
-0.4293358325958252,
0.306174099445343,
-0.23415100574493408,
1.031329870223999,
-0.08093871921300888,
0.029244041070342064,
-0.3165096342563629,
-0.7278422117233276,
-0.4867085814476013,
-0.4821845591068268,
-0.44557493925094604,
0.0744490921497345,
0.09490656852722168,
0.6723912954330444,
0.6675518751144409,
0.3189672827720642,
0.5346894264221191,
0.2117406725883484,
-0.0380004458129406,
0.5802258253097534,
-0.47732916474342346,
0.6072648763656616,
-0.1974049210548401,
-0.4580257534980774,
-0.04925871267914772,
-0.32423079013824463,
0.4711682200431824,
0.5914256572723389,
-0.3646829426288605,
0.3619580566883087,
0.06183085963129997,
0.7119226455688477,
-0.6690070033073425,
0.2254512757062912,
-0.6358626484870911,
-0.044107772409915924,
-0.5198185443878174,
0.01473577506840229,
-0.22791022062301636,
-0.5961220264434814,
-0.31489911675453186,
-0.5958762168884277,
0.08800128102302551,
-0.08936037123203278,
0.8347471952438354,
0.34439030289649963,
-0.3796587586402893,
-0.21008941531181335,
-0.6915561556816101,
0.7681311368942261,
-0.4925757944583893,
-0.16756387054920197,
0.549399197101593,
0.7411286234855652,
0.196573406457901,
-0.17705652117729187,
-0.47258415818214417,
0.5419204831123352,
0.1718047559261322,
0.21277795732021332,
-0.11639190465211868,
-0.2959522604942322,
0.005996059160679579,
0.6191942095756531,
-0.7337261438369751,
-0.2806222140789032,
-0.6499733328819275,
-0.048788152635097504,
0.8692317605018616,
0.39570730924606323,
0.6963887810707092,
-0.30159419775009155,
-0.17637194693088531,
0.08556309342384338,
-0.5618821978569031,
0.12444992363452911,
0.16881822049617767,
0.5201480984687805,
-0.21842439472675323,
0.8175987005233765,
-0.6862475872039795,
0.5486602783203125,
-0.16026130318641663,
0.20054353773593903,
0.14871248602867126,
-0.5309416651725769,
0.007606376428157091,
0.02069837786257267,
0.8807482123374939,
0.21136194467544556,
0.34735989570617676,
-0.12489339709281921,
-0.0018136089202016592,
0.27829837799072266,
0.07093725353479385,
-0.6411271691322327,
-0.26762089133262634,
0.13499662280082703,
0.01058909110724926,
-0.33401912450790405,
-0.25096896290779114,
-0.811771810054779,
-0.2529537081718445,
0.2497984766960144,
0.16855299472808838,
-0.4962981641292572,
-0.34139251708984375,
0.07770393788814545,
0.23381569981575012,
0.8007264137268066,
0.03567042946815491,
-0.8225465416908264,
0.3235345482826233,
0.4259730279445648,
0.8094922304153442,
-0.25911641120910645,
0.156989187002182,
-0.4484168589115143,
0.11155933886766434,
-0.5294952988624573,
0.7429476380348206,
-0.5347317457199097,
-0.5077820420265198,
0.0897178128361702,
-0.11063215881586075,
-0.09909748286008835,
-0.4801982641220093,
0.4949057400226593,
-0.8277292251586914,
0.148421049118042,
-0.35189345479011536,
-0.3556843101978302,
-0.07750259339809418,
0.38186347484588623,
-0.5081799626350403,
1.1623235940933228,
0.36073681712150574,
-0.7101699113845825,
-0.013509614393115044,
-0.5163282752037048,
-0.5537810921669006,
0.5185149312019348,
-0.12318668514490128,
-0.1463487595319748,
-0.03258923813700676,
0.6533576846122742,
0.11365803331136703,
-0.4414811134338379,
0.21115775406360626,
-0.07147594541311264,
-0.0018137177685275674,
0.2157680243253708,
-0.1553167700767517,
1.1909301280975342,
0.6083551049232483,
0.11594892293214798,
-0.1786089986562729,
-0.39591485261917114,
0.3113895356655121,
0.13735900819301605,
-0.10285904258489609,
-0.3221593201160431,
-0.0345698781311512,
-0.02539573237299919,
0.47794029116630554,
0.18434157967567444,
-0.8385698199272156,
0.22738341987133026,
-0.3889327943325043,
0.5820246338844299,
0.3965361416339874,
0.17655357718467712,
0.5742583870887756,
-0.3595500588417053,
1.1033138036727905,
0.280064195394516,
0.29925471544265747,
0.025723367929458618,
-0.8465337753295898,
-0.551912784576416,
-0.1887119859457016,
0.10512083768844604,
0.8942621946334839,
-1.3486422300338745,
0.07086475193500519,
-0.36379683017730713,
-0.4851061999797821,
-1.0532845258712769,
0.3599006235599518,
0.3757360577583313,
0.4348261058330536,
0.5574166774749756,
-0.22987723350524902,
-0.45730268955230713,
-1.0433951616287231,
-0.10613476485013962,
-0.17903561890125275,
0.07668592035770416,
0.08086463063955307,
0.21127116680145264,
-0.14836950600147247,
0.9681574106216431,
-0.5040596723556519,
-0.1861613541841507,
-0.5511679649353027,
-0.29255783557891846,
0.0028352667577564716,
0.40564411878585815,
0.037291426211595535,
-0.8063989281654358,
-0.43897750973701477,
-0.17436730861663818,
-0.8381417989730835,
-0.21264326572418213,
0.3079579174518585,
-0.6776803135871887,
0.048286307603120804,
0.4525858461856842,
-0.6623126268386841,
0.30528292059898376,
0.7556626796722412,
-0.04351939260959625,
0.3530263900756836,
0.18626335263252258,
0.38272395730018616,
-1.5763887166976929,
-0.2374221831560135,
-0.3021676242351532,
-0.16886843740940094,
-0.5373812317848206,
0.5156496167182922,
0.07681845873594284,
-0.46004921197891235,
-0.3782420754432678,
0.3611160218715668,
-0.21123333275318146,
0.19254152476787567,
0.2364659607410431,
0.35551419854164124,
0.04670276865363121,
0.3480069041252136,
-0.32319003343582153,
1.2015279531478882,
0.42287150025367737,
-0.43692663311958313,
0.4435109496116638,
0.8685268759727478,
-0.4068775177001953,
0.721203088760376,
-0.6136351823806763,
0.12590892612934113,
-0.13065418601036072,
0.03996115177869797,
-1.287071704864502,
-0.26160505414009094,
0.3695414662361145,
-0.547565758228302,
-0.024571441113948822,
-0.3831053078174591,
-0.5189183354377747,
-0.11862307786941528,
-0.08842583000659943,
0.97793048620224,
0.5413131713867188,
-0.10840762406587601,
0.2130727469921112,
0.7717241048812866,
-0.5894129872322083,
-0.2957051694393158,
-1.039542317390442,
0.08857983350753784,
-0.02189663238823414,
-0.7239042520523071,
-0.17717885971069336,
-0.21045495569705963,
-0.31411710381507874,
-0.10567771643400192,
-0.11014915257692337,
-0.6629806160926819,
-0.10353443026542664,
0.18569262325763702,
0.4231177568435669,
-0.4151446521282196,
0.19521334767341614,
0.17157456278800964,
0.0679803192615509,
-0.0283296387642622,
-0.08465157449245453,
0.3624146580696106,
-0.23814398050308228,
-0.19838614761829376,
-0.051724888384342194,
0.7258058190345764,
0.6530876159667969,
-0.8315809965133667,
0.6758491396903992,
0.21120288968086243,
-0.16295818984508514,
-0.17692218720912933,
-0.3410772979259491,
0.13293282687664032,
-0.4038008153438568,
0.10961119085550308,
-0.5118420124053955,
-0.7557119727134705,
0.4842297434806824,
0.2429863065481186,
0.1392122060060501,
0.5515891909599304,
0.35486364364624023,
-0.24597357213497162,
1.005691409111023,
0.5102055668830872,
-0.29921436309814453,
-0.03959326818585396,
-0.13638634979724884,
0.3351711928844452,
-0.8370120525360107,
-0.15024520456790924,
-0.5274341106414795,
-0.12939712405204773,
-0.7445052862167358,
-0.6168115735054016,
0.43634936213493347,
-0.23103633522987366,
-0.012265540659427643,
0.3062153458595276,
-0.5738703012466431,
0.36315491795539856,
0.19275546073913574,
0.20662158727645874,
0.3959183990955353,
-0.09523800015449524,
0.1552146077156067,
-0.19515898823738098,
-0.9664597511291504,
-0.4310035705566406,
0.9141204357147217,
-0.3083629310131073,
0.6184754371643066,
0.4503729045391083,
0.5511686205863953,
0.20268556475639343,
0.16034583747386932,
-0.6914649605751038,
0.6513119339942932,
0.03992873430252075,
-0.9262271523475647,
-0.4106515645980835,
-0.5080309510231018,
-0.7888466119766235,
0.26136302947998047,
-0.23763488233089447,
-0.1215701699256897,
-0.01564362272620201,
-0.2291877120733261,
-0.28847581148147583,
0.33819547295570374,
-0.5594684481620789,
0.6768715977668762,
-0.03147513046860695,
-0.2747223675251007,
-0.022437099367380142,
-0.7048588991165161,
0.6499055624008179,
-0.021359438076615334,
0.40159106254577637,
-0.239023819565773,
-0.0637950673699379,
0.7127317190170288,
-0.5190562009811401,
0.2936849296092987,
0.08780092746019363,
-0.007901139557361603,
0.42115676403045654,
0.34570616483688354,
0.07869517803192139,
-0.005808801855891943,
-0.24836786091327667,
-0.1252242475748062,
0.4170379638671875,
-1.1188713312149048,
-0.4839514195919037,
0.46753302216529846,
-0.6740519404411316,
-0.3299284875392914,
-0.38430163264274597,
-0.8979560732841492,
-0.6569169759750366,
-0.05757032334804535,
0.32147514820098877,
0.5904569625854492,
-0.05766376480460167,
0.16458065807819366,
0.8970625400543213,
-0.08541757613420486,
0.223732128739357,
0.37803733348846436,
-0.2139391005039215,
-0.10766785591840744,
0.722919225692749,
0.12127409130334854,
0.31362780928611755,
0.2379167526960373,
-0.22737902402877808,
-0.4446473717689514,
-0.28122827410697937,
-0.9388055801391602,
0.097139872610569,
-0.5443801283836365,
-0.2927038371562958,
-0.37088462710380554,
-0.4073631763458252,
-0.2503921687602997,
-0.05928749963641167,
-0.3612064719200134,
-0.5281098484992981,
0.3115940988063812,
-0.06203046068549156,
0.5280436277389526,
0.642744779586792,
0.425990492105484,
0.04603764787316322,
-0.6724487543106079,
0.4508209824562073,
0.3783889710903168,
0.22585603594779968,
-0.48941317200660706,
-0.607491135597229,
-0.19592075049877167,
0.2077542543411255,
-0.01654212921857834,
-1.0833029747009277,
0.30937081575393677,
0.23787695169448853,
0.21350276470184326,
0.04739576205611229,
0.4974170923233032,
0.7769407033920288,
-0.30652549862861633,
0.766782820224762,
-0.15068867802619934,
-0.595224916934967,
0.8474545478820801,
-0.4268364906311035,
0.7080577611923218,
1.1481552124023438,
0.43184828758239746,
-0.5511996150016785,
-0.6829425692558289,
-0.5532882213592529,
-0.8223450779914856,
0.36256733536720276,
0.2788585126399994,
0.1643594354391098,
-0.19992831349372864,
0.2743682265281677,
-0.09782011061906815,
0.24873532354831696,
-0.09789907187223434,
-0.17201857268810272,
0.014411166310310364,
-0.3979354798793793,
-0.2664128839969635,
0.025748122483491898,
-0.004741345532238483,
-0.36630257964134216,
0.6555113196372986,
0.024440567940473557,
-0.21797503530979156,
0.11792108416557312,
-0.5836808085441589,
0.08933842182159424,
0.37382379174232483,
0.23638081550598145,
0.49948063492774963,
0.08327163755893707,
-0.11029166728258133,
0.37774375081062317,
-0.584871232509613,
0.4156302809715271,
-0.1277981549501419,
-0.39907875657081604,
0.14689679443836212,
-0.030060680583119392,
0.16563120484352112,
0.16797687113285065,
-0.7676188349723816,
0.5613771080970764,
-0.08737291395664215,
0.09586828947067261,
-0.10179057717323303,
-0.09318548440933228,
-0.024781009182333946,
-0.12246564030647278,
0.26699674129486084,
0.007376560941338539,
0.039588697254657745,
-0.5462291240692139,
0.19318321347236633,
0.3284745216369629,
-0.6200527548789978,
-0.033134445548057556,
0.6684789657592773,
0.28398606181144714,
-0.13901621103286743,
0.8805969953536987,
-0.3341245651245117,
-0.38089001178741455,
0.39561960101127625,
0.07510948181152344,
0.6595120429992676,
-0.5220299363136292,
0.39696478843688965,
0.37565430998802185,
0.5066156983375549,
0.11846122145652771,
0.4267038106918335,
-0.29694652557373047,
-0.5198457837104797,
-0.5074023008346558,
-0.5886849761009216,
-0.5587730407714844,
-0.258948415517807,
-1.0228297710418701,
0.021815119311213493,
-0.30059176683425903,
0.07295956462621689,
-0.3431272804737091,
0.14680954813957214,
-0.5975821614265442,
0.05582933872938156,
0.004615298938006163,
0.9599740505218506,
-1.1231353282928467,
0.8394094109535217,
0.8458499908447266,
-0.7410376071929932,
-0.680291473865509,
-0.20196877419948578,
-0.08993680775165558,
-0.7801268696784973,
0.19148774445056915,
-0.19106227159500122,
-0.21322211623191833,
0.1275218427181244,
-0.5494130849838257,
-0.46633073687553406,
0.7516425251960754,
0.07221871614456177,
-0.22746390104293823,
0.11346670985221863,
0.28443434834480286,
0.40056994557380676,
-0.2078160047531128,
0.07094769179821014,
0.6191309690475464,
0.12780283391475677,
-0.043226391077041626,
-0.5482025146484375,
0.06899918615818024,
-0.6458389163017273,
0.07831117510795593,
0.303794801235199,
-0.529080867767334,
0.5965412259101868,
-0.10792015492916107,
-0.32006293535232544,
0.2127416431903839,
0.5862066745758057,
0.28182530403137207,
-0.10018621385097504,
0.2871175706386566,
0.5573716163635254,
0.7233812212944031,
-0.17194348573684692,
0.9886380434036255,
-0.3020625710487366,
0.11356708407402039,
0.8558849692344666,
-0.2460363209247589,
0.9959617853164673,
0.5230887532234192,
-0.3405032157897949,
0.5549992322921753,
0.48612526059150696,
0.43038615584373474,
0.43785256147384644,
0.17164242267608643,
-0.5276873707771301,
-0.4044245481491089,
-0.12381739914417267,
-0.2649920880794525,
0.41627880930900574,
0.2929227948188782,
0.4132832884788513,
-0.4953344762325287,
0.05857511982321739,
-0.11559169739484787,
0.4389675259590149,
-0.1809128075838089,
0.7664201259613037,
-0.07271597534418106,
-0.6509262919425964,
0.6307297348976135,
-0.19946174323558807,
0.6099408268928528,
-0.7487287521362305,
0.11592072248458862,
-0.7235409021377563,
-0.25012829899787903,
-0.22519727051258087,
-1.0010712146759033,
0.5586754679679871,
0.22714993357658386,
-0.18551313877105713,
-0.14765219390392303,
0.42188870906829834,
-0.7356734275817871,
-0.5150893330574036,
-0.19159597158432007,
0.7922549247741699,
0.33516526222229004,
-0.12168805301189423,
-0.5734965801239014,
0.02784658968448639,
-0.16506779193878174,
0.3219621181488037,
0.18937811255455017,
0.5351189970970154,
-0.27846190333366394,
0.8837319612503052,
0.4212099015712738,
0.08548554033041,
0.30734607577323914,
-0.29861360788345337,
0.5924237966537476,
-0.36901387572288513,
-0.7093744277954102,
-0.5216776728630066,
0.44645434617996216,
-0.07957112789154053,
-0.4516909420490265,
0.8133388161659241,
0.7978808879852295,
0.6571338176727295,
0.03255839645862579,
0.9643478989601135,
-0.10331576317548752,
0.5032870173454285,
-0.2160428762435913,
0.9530097246170044,
-0.37325456738471985,
0.05477409064769745,
-0.026636643335223198,
-0.5728088021278381,
-0.01708938181400299,
0.34933602809906006,
-0.26039329171180725,
-0.318117618560791,
0.463169127702713,
0.995190441608429,
-0.12831135094165802,
0.19467486441135406,
0.31048786640167236,
0.04325934499502182,
0.058725133538246155,
0.8493866920471191,
0.8487066626548767,
-0.8206348419189453,
1.0463727712631226,
-0.25833025574684143,
-0.13896764814853668,
-0.08758293092250824,
-0.21013130247592926,
-0.4525531828403473,
-0.9984562397003174,
-0.37411484122276306,
-0.45364588499069214,
0.15213876962661743,
0.6461670994758606,
0.7468783855438232,
-1.0054079294204712,
-0.2646108567714691,
0.1964414119720459,
0.09018753468990326,
-0.1584806591272354,
-0.19984985888004303,
0.07764380425214767,
-0.4890654385089874,
-0.5073121190071106,
0.23961469531059265,
0.2830914855003357,
-0.3461078703403473,
-0.2077753245830536,
0.06340493261814117,
-0.46535569429397583,
0.25886934995651245,
0.7561019062995911,
0.5947180986404419,
-0.32025739550590515,
0.09401000291109085,
0.13193736970424652,
-0.5209349393844604,
0.1802922636270523,
0.46063703298568726,
-0.7120389342308044,
0.638920783996582,
0.41062983870506287,
1.1853231191635132,
0.445992112159729,
0.14556875824928284,
0.4830222427845001,
-0.6779605746269226,
0.18354088068008423,
0.36292633414268494,
0.04219578951597214,
0.5440670847892761,
-0.051264677196741104,
0.5708359479904175,
0.10233628749847412,
-0.3360074758529663,
-0.7081611752510071,
0.4343705475330353,
-1.0317354202270508,
0.012723441235721111,
1.1369041204452515,
0.11282236874103546,
-0.2837882936000824,
-0.5638143420219421,
-0.30269330739974976,
0.2874578833580017,
-0.05675922706723213,
0.7748834490776062,
0.8263711333274841,
0.13243132829666138,
-0.21930421888828278,
-1.0424830913543701,
0.4525679051876068,
0.5638933777809143,
-0.9443137645721436,
-0.05260671675205231,
0.3202153444290161,
0.26307469606399536,
-0.2068377137184143,
0.8437076210975647,
-0.4270492196083069,
0.36397382616996765,
-0.2570441663265228,
-0.01546070259064436,
0.16761791706085205,
0.11562026292085648,
-0.4188894033432007,
0.007205989211797714,
-0.04305500537157059,
-0.6512529850006104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13362v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13362v1
|
Semantically Corrected Amharic Automatic Speech Recognition
| 2024-04-20T12:08:00 | 2024-04-20T12:08:00 |
Samuael Adnew, Paul Pu Liang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) can play a crucial role in enhancing the
accessibility of spoken languages worldwide. In this paper, we build a set of
ASR tools for Amharic, a language spoken by more than 50 million people
primarily in eastern Africa. Amharic is written in the Ge'ez script, a sequence
of graphemes with spacings denoting word boundaries. This makes computational
processing of Amharic challenging since the location of spacings can
significantly impact the meaning of formed sentences. We find that existing
benchmarks for Amharic ASR do not account for these spacings and only measure
individual grapheme error rates, leading to significantly inflated measurements
of in-the-wild performance. In this paper, we first release corrected
transcriptions of existing Amharic ASR test datasets, enabling the community to
accurately evaluate progress. Furthermore, we introduce a post-processing
approach using a transformer encoder-decoder architecture to organize raw ASR
outputs into a grammatically complete and semantically meaningful Amharic
sentence. Through experiments on the corrected test dataset, our model enhances
the semantic correctness of Amharic speech recognition systems, achieving a
Character Error Rate (CER) of 5.5\% and a Word Error Rate (WER) of 23.3\%.
|
[
-0.11722186207771301,
-0.7412109375,
-0.14504219591617584,
0.208596870303154,
-0.05824821814894676,
0.37777984142303467,
-0.5213298201560974,
-0.8086078763008118,
0.5351414084434509,
0.2926276624202728,
-0.3059888780117035,
-0.5940929651260376,
-0.6756138801574707,
0.38557156920433044,
-0.551262378692627,
0.5426692366600037,
-0.2532822787761688,
0.11300428956747055,
0.28301337361335754,
-0.47021484375,
-0.292704313993454,
-0.6462263464927673,
-0.6224397420883179,
-0.0916808694601059,
0.4420356750488281,
0.4958941638469696,
0.8732714056968689,
0.601040780544281,
0.0800062045454979,
0.3399966359138489,
-0.2493157684803009,
0.2670570909976959,
-0.14380528032779694,
-0.06532467901706696,
0.47140973806381226,
0.030750971287488937,
-0.40671998262405396,
-0.3419102430343628,
0.6388283371925354,
0.8017370104789734,
-0.5593482255935669,
-0.026226630434393883,
0.12762555480003357,
0.44272300601005554,
-0.5731563568115234,
0.09478174895048141,
-0.646323025226593,
-0.11575129628181458,
-0.4978337287902832,
0.0554426945745945,
-0.16734984517097473,
-0.3209565281867981,
-0.15393272042274475,
-0.6129606366157532,
0.4108352065086365,
-0.050805214792490005,
0.8328014016151428,
0.3135678768157959,
-0.13967959582805634,
-0.7957963347434998,
-0.7012880444526672,
0.38020312786102295,
-0.7047514319419861,
0.4261331260204315,
0.3545844852924347,
0.594179093837738,
-0.19665421545505524,
-0.5644710063934326,
-0.8396816253662109,
-0.05972403660416603,
-0.1017744392156601,
0.06785967946052551,
-0.2940269708633423,
0.07446161657571793,
0.45049309730529785,
0.3415120840072632,
-0.40542539954185486,
0.016558663919568062,
-0.4949953258037567,
-0.67336505651474,
0.5294875502586365,
-0.0008202979224734008,
0.49130967259407043,
-0.1659345179796219,
0.05355742201209068,
-0.23902657628059387,
-0.5771409273147583,
0.3361823558807373,
0.746787428855896,
0.45965543389320374,
-0.09366939961910248,
0.859097957611084,
-0.170591801404953,
0.8825763463973999,
-0.3121720552444458,
0.1952904611825943,
0.4631173610687256,
-0.307738333940506,
0.012037199921905994,
0.6014569997787476,
0.6233893036842346,
0.2217993438243866,
0.4363221228122711,
-0.21863457560539246,
-0.34998929500579834,
0.4365200698375702,
0.5835126042366028,
-0.4851849377155304,
-0.2798598110675812,
-0.063824862241745,
-0.02377714216709137,
0.1658228486776352,
-0.045650552958250046,
-0.4291146397590637,
-0.05525856092572212,
-0.2131497859954834,
0.47066590189933777,
-0.47350770235061646,
0.3867422044277191,
0.12075883150100708,
0.10534348338842392,
0.23253163695335388,
0.5779083371162415,
-0.7982711791992188,
0.5130659937858582,
0.1628304421901703,
0.7826260924339294,
0.32570159435272217,
-0.2104937881231308,
-0.5689361095428467,
0.12551374733448029,
-0.09365838766098022,
0.7705190777778625,
-0.48953771591186523,
-0.6682226657867432,
-0.05954104661941528,
0.0288743507117033,
-0.12744006514549255,
-0.616935670375824,
0.7612549662590027,
-0.5384697914123535,
-0.3457598090171814,
-0.21184328198432922,
-0.37685251235961914,
-0.262252539396286,
-0.06379541009664536,
-0.565512478351593,
0.5439198017120361,
-0.06403913348913193,
-0.6198715567588806,
0.42320600152015686,
-0.7618897557258606,
-0.7789209485054016,
-0.025188961997628212,
-0.11754889041185379,
-0.3667866885662079,
-0.24605879187583923,
0.3898250460624695,
-0.07735130935907364,
0.13546927273273468,
-0.058376625180244446,
-0.01648520678281784,
-0.3941974937915802,
0.37798550724983215,
-0.40487632155418396,
0.6410171985626221,
0.17944832146167755,
-0.26732388138771057,
0.16536349058151245,
-0.9129987955093384,
0.27530157566070557,
-0.31944215297698975,
-0.550530731678009,
-0.08474764972925186,
0.08075479418039322,
0.3261983096599579,
0.1335427612066269,
0.040510304272174835,
-1.040431261062622,
-0.17783281207084656,
-0.7286459803581238,
0.6451316475868225,
0.46102070808410645,
-0.3890215754508972,
0.2560191750526428,
-0.17094770073890686,
0.1829584240913391,
0.015862872824072838,
-0.15376710891723633,
0.033280450850725174,
-0.478026419878006,
-1.0102795362472534,
-0.15816359221935272,
0.7193195223808289,
0.6343498229980469,
-0.4905560314655304,
0.5894761085510254,
-0.3974710702896118,
-0.39892804622650146,
-0.9392731189727783,
-0.06664471328258514,
0.3565753996372223,
0.6679617166519165,
0.6262004375457764,
-0.3152548372745514,
-0.6617172956466675,
-0.7696599364280701,
-0.40774238109588623,
-0.23527076840400696,
-0.3070237636566162,
0.5382434725761414,
0.30857759714126587,
-0.462545782327652,
0.6783666610717773,
-0.42162421345710754,
-0.47830677032470703,
0.09356934577226639,
0.20068328082561493,
0.07068928331136703,
0.3741048276424408,
-0.09924039244651794,
-0.5707404613494873,
-0.3869369924068451,
0.029667483642697334,
-0.35628220438957214,
-0.38121795654296875,
0.44831499457359314,
0.18336477875709534,
0.46667078137397766,
0.5700028538703918,
-0.37891826033592224,
0.7717322111129761,
0.4393441677093506,
-0.3205369710922241,
0.43058711290359497,
-0.4573105573654175,
0.3767258822917938,
-0.689009964466095,
0.207491934299469,
-0.4237377643585205,
-0.05200788751244545,
-0.47453954815864563,
-0.3844497799873352,
0.21422143280506134,
-0.18462415039539337,
-0.14415107667446136,
0.48587554693222046,
-0.35955020785331726,
-0.2543115019798279,
-0.2685279846191406,
0.16124093532562256,
-0.30142682790756226,
0.19357232749462128,
-0.24687007069587708,
0.9837306141853333,
0.3118553161621094,
-0.7511715292930603,
0.30272334814071655,
0.7261793613433838,
-0.27022427320480347,
0.1161981001496315,
-0.8306390643119812,
0.0452006570994854,
0.03152606263756752,
0.21210841834545135,
-0.9761748909950256,
-0.5176330804824829,
0.25458309054374695,
-0.8424681425094604,
0.42344242334365845,
0.14605942368507385,
-0.4899977445602417,
-0.33122336864471436,
0.08848775178194046,
0.32684341073036194,
0.3903411328792572,
-0.4886276125907898,
0.5789822340011597,
0.5863103270530701,
-0.14916785061359406,
-0.6698253154754639,
-0.7091375589370728,
0.34371140599250793,
0.12933868169784546,
-1.0598338842391968,
0.4673779010772705,
0.3105331361293793,
-0.13501177728176117,
0.008717144839465618,
-0.08379066735506058,
0.17269882559776306,
0.01369447074830532,
0.40088942646980286,
-0.1706925928592682,
-0.10374299436807632,
-0.012993364594876766,
-0.10830257833003998,
-0.3166516125202179,
-0.2254091501235962,
-0.09514056891202927,
0.4063049852848053,
-0.06758055090904236,
-0.4018380641937256,
-0.019466491416096687,
0.17728786170482635,
0.23505540192127228,
-0.18024034798145294,
0.6055876016616821,
0.36746475100517273,
-0.6466162204742432,
0.031234288588166237,
-0.4537642002105713,
0.10536348819732666,
-0.391010046005249,
-0.0006022604065947235,
-0.36772027611732483,
-0.8020240068435669,
0.9097366333007812,
0.23189188539981842,
-0.07875218987464905,
0.2944487929344177,
0.28680649399757385,
-0.06334703415632248,
0.7739126086235046,
0.36491966247558594,
0.029604604467749596,
0.1202380433678627,
-0.016081947833299637,
0.44283732771873474,
-0.9133119583129883,
-0.18143516778945923,
-0.7579289674758911,
-0.38959425687789917,
-0.6347779631614685,
-0.5263789296150208,
0.6125211715698242,
-0.076591856777668,
0.048309076577425,
0.5561406016349792,
-0.14634381234645844,
0.2742190361022949,
0.4343368709087372,
0.27394840121269226,
0.29350847005844116,
0.1180623397231102,
-0.2415488213300705,
-0.04544040560722351,
-0.3599602282047272,
-0.7152813673019409,
0.6010439395904541,
-0.057552531361579895,
0.8404061198234558,
0.2706702649593353,
0.34264466166496277,
0.36366721987724304,
-0.005785836838185787,
-0.8697212934494019,
0.26253780722618103,
-0.587651789188385,
-0.1796025037765503,
-0.5410147905349731,
-0.20896746218204498,
-0.8969945907592773,
0.03829900547862053,
0.019125502556562424,
-0.5510837435722351,
0.08660097420215607,
0.43520790338516235,
-0.4216306209564209,
0.09513397514820099,
-0.8713744878768921,
0.9206440448760986,
0.0643068253993988,
0.13193795084953308,
-0.25446978211402893,
-1.0489802360534668,
-0.14030416309833527,
-0.09014081209897995,
0.21228204667568207,
-0.08175826817750931,
-0.0007797952275723219,
0.681212842464447,
-0.9341805577278137,
0.5310654044151306,
-0.2824013829231262,
0.09593161940574646,
0.23891641199588776,
-0.17262451350688934,
0.40168488025665283,
-0.27986133098602295,
-0.15461041033267975,
0.3235514461994171,
-0.32336780428886414,
-0.4294159710407257,
-0.5763436555862427,
0.419608473777771,
-0.8178677558898926,
-0.1740710288286209,
-0.22773873805999756,
-0.17908433079719543,
-0.29140302538871765,
-0.14642037451267242,
0.3955560624599457,
0.7755119204521179,
-0.46453869342803955,
-0.08326257765293121,
0.241164892911911,
-0.4075112044811249,
0.31282663345336914,
0.5411698222160339,
0.18814656138420105,
-0.5438645482063293,
0.6408916711807251,
0.49563995003700256,
0.11498169600963593,
0.17602850496768951,
-0.1080024242401123,
-0.5686431527137756,
-0.5296327471733093,
-0.880892276763916,
0.12759767472743988,
-0.835673451423645,
-0.31913286447525024,
-1.1354042291641235,
-0.3919233977794647,
-0.4135795831680298,
-0.37691956758499146,
-0.11138631403446198,
-0.551718533039093,
-0.19324982166290283,
0.022794272750616074,
0.5440055727958679,
0.42292967438697815,
-0.1600106954574585,
0.6498452425003052,
-0.8502550721168518,
0.24009348452091217,
-0.0035586156882345676,
0.10739534348249435,
-0.1283671259880066,
-0.7325083017349243,
-0.05057607963681221,
0.40343987941741943,
-0.09327540546655655,
-0.5094742178916931,
0.5402380228042603,
0.5578321218490601,
0.18564151227474213,
-0.12456260621547699,
-0.036955222487449646,
1.1495656967163086,
-0.9322304129600525,
0.5948172807693481,
-0.025036821141839027,
-1.2100886106491089,
0.6838670969009399,
0.012980884872376919,
0.42607933282852173,
0.48020806908607483,
-0.0421254001557827,
-0.8428656458854675,
-0.523125946521759,
-0.5649104714393616,
-1.0753355026245117,
0.7326955199241638,
0.39800581336021423,
0.0723935216665268,
-0.0515422560274601,
0.21728751063346863,
-0.08233720064163208,
0.035978712141513824,
-0.13882119953632355,
-0.21807976067066193,
-0.36282894015312195,
-0.4194357395172119,
-0.3101637661457062,
-0.23759832978248596,
0.1818380206823349,
-0.03825868293642998,
0.776386022567749,
-0.05557512491941452,
0.15452007949352264,
0.3485100567340851,
-0.5374699234962463,
-0.2277640849351883,
0.4157916307449341,
0.45807167887687683,
0.4131113886833191,
-0.052611902356147766,
0.1359916776418686,
0.3161029815673828,
-0.8274989128112793,
0.248496875166893,
0.49106359481811523,
-0.252256840467453,
0.11521266400814056,
0.09054479748010635,
0.677031397819519,
0.43273770809173584,
-0.759200930595398,
0.4713380038738251,
-0.227457195520401,
0.18975722789764404,
-0.5798883438110352,
0.08914858847856522,
-0.09837684035301208,
-0.08040240406990051,
0.16554495692253113,
0.5325854420661926,
0.5142743587493896,
-0.17992617189884186,
0.39151936769485474,
0.2467978447675705,
-0.4123538136482239,
-0.32156798243522644,
0.6481655240058899,
0.2683095633983612,
-0.3472945988178253,
0.856046736240387,
-0.0061731841415166855,
-0.6863600611686707,
0.5687848925590515,
0.5230949521064758,
0.6104069352149963,
-0.46724146604537964,
-0.03338788449764252,
0.6629140973091125,
0.3341790437698364,
0.13690795004367828,
0.2941250503063202,
-0.06632675975561142,
-0.9844974875450134,
-0.3698814809322357,
-0.9489352107048035,
-0.436285138130188,
-0.44701120257377625,
-0.5138877630233765,
0.5988208055496216,
-0.1984262317419052,
-0.18073947727680206,
0.38527384400367737,
-0.20912717282772064,
-0.3163614273071289,
0.2953770160675049,
0.13525903224945068,
0.7787603139877319,
-0.5823017358779907,
0.7262868285179138,
0.6499456763267517,
-0.04211488366127014,
-1.0638518333435059,
-0.021317293867468834,
-0.10345777869224548,
-0.9559834599494934,
0.46512371301651,
0.4461633265018463,
-0.5282337069511414,
0.18347695469856262,
-0.24109606444835663,
-0.704328715801239,
0.7962913513183594,
0.28300753235816956,
-0.442783921957016,
0.11449488252401352,
0.04789505526423454,
0.6709720492362976,
-0.12558864057064056,
0.012549776583909988,
0.37610509991645813,
0.33883997797966003,
0.5331653356552124,
-1.2239952087402344,
-0.0794590413570404,
-0.41284072399139404,
-0.0332331620156765,
0.580767810344696,
-0.278839647769928,
0.42613229155540466,
-0.5134165287017822,
-0.5956119298934937,
0.15664644539356232,
0.6049870252609253,
-0.029834402725100517,
0.11902596801519394,
0.5835747718811035,
0.5790022015571594,
0.9040062427520752,
-0.12702547013759613,
0.9744348526000977,
-0.07934074103832245,
-0.12904943525791168,
0.9325398802757263,
-0.3681148886680603,
0.8827148079872131,
0.2740773856639862,
-0.21401292085647583,
0.35599464178085327,
0.4324924349784851,
0.2767155170440674,
0.2873179316520691,
0.43405166268348694,
-0.6011265516281128,
-0.005001635290682316,
-0.24714861810207367,
-0.09491622447967529,
0.7183749079704285,
0.5982621908187866,
-0.16204972565174103,
-0.23367615044116974,
0.07474332302808762,
0.023913320153951645,
0.2175009399652481,
-0.3210671544075012,
0.7491098642349243,
-0.0058583165518939495,
-0.26801592111587524,
0.6473858952522278,
0.21354272961616516,
0.6298009753227234,
-0.6793839335441589,
-0.0188332200050354,
0.17402905225753784,
0.34489136934280396,
-0.34263381361961365,
-0.6028428673744202,
0.7800893783569336,
0.3299553692340851,
-0.11394865810871124,
0.12126507610082626,
0.8144816160202026,
-0.6318488121032715,
-0.3592226803302765,
0.2962521016597748,
0.2383490651845932,
0.32858556509017944,
-0.03627311438322067,
-0.27508896589279175,
0.11558263748884201,
-0.053448375314474106,
0.5091235041618347,
-0.09093204140663147,
0.3533882200717926,
-0.10330309718847275,
0.575376570224762,
0.5294694900512695,
0.21576696634292603,
0.35179412364959717,
0.27220743894577026,
0.7845443487167358,
-0.6315039396286011,
-0.5675222873687744,
-0.8154094219207764,
0.39153724908828735,
0.02426776848733425,
-0.14138591289520264,
0.8114063739776611,
0.5176781415939331,
0.9361408352851868,
-0.011210212484002113,
0.646311342716217,
-0.31724295020103455,
0.6961735486984253,
-0.6524224281311035,
0.6278454661369324,
-0.19129180908203125,
0.23515932261943817,
-0.2009185552597046,
-0.5476416349411011,
-0.5232952833175659,
0.8496425747871399,
-0.12413453310728073,
-0.11491016298532486,
0.4103018641471863,
1.0648577213287354,
0.07346030324697495,
0.36708542704582214,
0.31785231828689575,
0.3917471766471863,
0.19151552021503448,
0.23331058025360107,
0.9442039132118225,
-0.7307353615760803,
0.4592413604259491,
-0.04039204493165016,
-0.11197617650032043,
0.006635640747845173,
-0.46406957507133484,
-0.3274213373661041,
-0.4242875576019287,
-0.3122726380825043,
-0.5622158050537109,
0.25113245844841003,
0.9711117148399353,
0.18547497689723969,
-1.1431485414505005,
-0.2645878493785858,
0.011692211031913757,
-0.11736897379159927,
0.04850105941295624,
-0.11439082026481628,
0.24646863341331482,
-0.35234329104423523,
-0.4606526792049408,
0.20262251794338226,
0.21195678412914276,
0.33094117045402527,
0.35050755739212036,
-0.1436966210603714,
0.08646540343761444,
-0.253683865070343,
0.49129414558410645,
0.22009813785552979,
-0.7522110939025879,
-0.5380198955535889,
0.11545217782258987,
0.00323969847522676,
0.17727158963680267,
0.7954068183898926,
-0.6523197889328003,
0.6104865074157715,
0.145748570561409,
0.568795919418335,
0.3191085159778595,
0.15409108996391296,
0.6537858247756958,
-0.8042097091674805,
-0.06344527751207352,
0.3797622621059418,
0.4727792739868164,
0.7649151682853699,
-0.21612341701984406,
0.5430647730827332,
0.11631528288125992,
-0.5880467295646667,
-0.5562264323234558,
-0.027229545637965202,
-0.9185993671417236,
0.2543620765209198,
0.9662088751792908,
-0.16197705268859863,
-0.3459224998950958,
-0.4776274561882019,
-0.39315834641456604,
0.5353764891624451,
-0.539486825466156,
0.635562002658844,
0.8029333353042603,
-0.09125742316246033,
0.3509736657142639,
-0.4393419325351715,
0.4075462520122528,
0.018869424238801003,
-0.5526208877563477,
0.35602277517318726,
0.7511559128761292,
0.17012430727481842,
0.286175936460495,
0.6873446702957153,
-0.29499757289886475,
0.24838663637638092,
0.06532672047615051,
0.14069229364395142,
0.31287553906440735,
-0.23991084098815918,
-0.5649561882019043,
-0.24962511658668518,
0.13377951085567474,
-0.1637488305568695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13350v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13350v1
|
Swa Bhasha: Message-Based Singlish to Sinhala Transliteration
| 2024-04-20T11:10:37 | 2024-04-20T11:10:37 |
Maneesha U. Athukorala, Deshan K. Sumanathilaka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Machine Transliteration provides the ability to transliterate a basic
language into different languages in a computational way. Transliteration is an
important technical process that has caught the attention most recently. The
Sinhala transliteration has many constraints because of the insufficiency of
resources in the Sinhala language. Due to these limitations, Sinhala
Transliteration is highly complex and time-consuming. Therefore, the majority
of the Sri Lankans uses non-formal texting language named 'Singlish' to make
that process simple. This study has focused on the transliteration of the
Singlish language at the word level by reducing the complication in the
transliteration. A new approach of coding system has invented with the
rule-based approach that can map the matching Sinhala words even without the
vowels. Various typing patterns were collected by different communities for
this. The collected data have analyzed with every Sinhala character and unique
Singlish patterns related to them were generated. The system has introduced a
newly initiated numeric coding system to use with the Singlish letters by
matching with the recognized typing patterns. For the mapping process, fuzzy
logic-based implementation has used. A codified dictionary has also implemented
including unique numeric values. In this system, Each Romanized English letter
was assigned with a unique numeric code that can construct a unique pattern for
each word. The system can identify the most relevant Sinhala word that matches
with the pattern of the Singlish word or it gives the most related word
suggestions. For example, the word 'kiyanna,kianna, kynna, kynn, kiynna' have
mapped with the accurate Sinhala word "kiyanna". These results revealed that
the 'Swa Bhasha' transliteration system has the ability to enhance the Sinhala
users' experience while conducting the texting in Singlish to Sinhala.
|
[
0.34983229637145996,
-0.46271201968193054,
0.06910039484500885,
0.6828824281692505,
-0.3521747589111328,
0.3139389455318451,
-0.4004162847995758,
-0.5424683094024658,
0.5490984320640564,
0.6122511625289917,
-0.36404237151145935,
-0.1709003746509552,
-0.41385534405708313,
0.3369573950767517,
-0.3156917989253998,
0.42035967111587524,
-0.02758707106113434,
0.20473109185695648,
0.3943660259246826,
-0.09827693551778793,
-1.0147584676742554,
-0.5707727074623108,
-0.40874165296554565,
-0.07853706181049347,
0.37478435039520264,
0.5250661373138428,
0.47569435834884644,
0.11758534610271454,
0.750163197517395,
0.3402045965194702,
-0.3999316096305847,
0.2778477668762207,
-0.6867523789405823,
0.5861644148826599,
-0.1762968748807907,
-0.7995891571044922,
-0.023121315985918045,
-0.4263029098510742,
0.45836400985717773,
0.316112220287323,
-0.33557239174842834,
0.3646470010280609,
-0.32538992166519165,
0.9264370203018188,
-0.46877366304397583,
0.11137297004461288,
-0.8493861556053162,
0.05261737480759621,
-0.3683377802371979,
-0.7016926407814026,
-0.6819281578063965,
-0.6825665235519409,
-0.32196077704429626,
-0.5128321051597595,
-0.04228523373603821,
0.5097600221633911,
0.7596102952957153,
0.1736651360988617,
-0.26631712913513184,
-0.8207185864448547,
-0.787651777267456,
0.7534179091453552,
-0.851742148399353,
0.3294874131679535,
0.17972609400749207,
0.704495370388031,
-0.15687622129917145,
-0.187516450881958,
-0.5339562296867371,
-0.029935086145997047,
-0.09484084695577621,
-0.10009238868951797,
0.17918440699577332,
0.10210856795310974,
0.16926053166389465,
0.3924131691455841,
-0.673871636390686,
-0.19804804027080536,
-0.7058684229850769,
-0.08973424881696701,
0.7743722200393677,
-0.024461613968014717,
0.8994957804679871,
-0.6340290307998657,
-0.5928492546081543,
0.07109672576189041,
-0.8354215025901794,
-0.24476724863052368,
0.14842678606510162,
0.866847813129425,
-0.11952317506074905,
0.7367523312568665,
-0.25910258293151855,
0.5784207582473755,
0.20007380843162537,
-0.5176449418067932,
0.42625170946121216,
-0.28861004114151,
-0.49090608954429626,
0.5411242246627808,
0.3441344201564789,
0.22670237720012665,
0.4954650104045868,
-0.08614987879991531,
-0.1357908695936203,
-0.018159788101911545,
0.30241259932518005,
-0.6777666807174683,
0.38451477885246277,
0.08138076215982437,
-0.8880352973937988,
-0.5572410225868225,
-0.21470367908477783,
-0.7056475281715393,
-0.49690479040145874,
-0.3486907184123993,
0.7040673494338989,
-0.47578316926956177,
-0.5316466093063354,
-0.1684282422065735,
-0.2239525020122528,
0.3574836254119873,
0.45369982719421387,
-0.7688131332397461,
0.09227266162633896,
0.5028031468391418,
0.7567570209503174,
-0.0818256214261055,
-0.2551823854446411,
-0.018152711912989616,
0.15093179047107697,
-0.5455672740936279,
0.5497437119483948,
-0.3481454849243164,
-0.18889306485652924,
0.1295660138130188,
-0.17227785289287567,
-0.43693146109580994,
-0.7649409770965576,
0.21899878978729248,
-0.8497133851051331,
0.10132059454917908,
-0.2516591250896454,
-0.6114831566810608,
-0.6677340269088745,
-0.029893234372138977,
-0.5364828109741211,
0.7682783603668213,
0.29870256781578064,
-0.706479012966156,
0.35104990005493164,
-0.5194545388221741,
-0.8125803470611572,
0.6939288377761841,
-0.011508588679134846,
0.018060674890875816,
0.35380786657333374,
-0.19414295256137848,
0.17899267375469208,
-0.28695860505104065,
0.3262161314487457,
0.1787755787372589,
-0.8557344079017639,
0.21718207001686096,
-0.1547372043132782,
1.0624380111694336,
0.4886542856693268,
-0.6768917441368103,
0.1041584238409996,
-0.5752776265144348,
0.3671855330467224,
-0.07654917985200882,
-0.267588347196579,
-0.16925488412380219,
-0.14643053710460663,
0.4289942979812622,
0.32171329855918884,
0.3254970610141754,
-0.5153684020042419,
0.01146306749433279,
-0.595329999923706,
0.005464964080601931,
0.6453199982643127,
0.23385395109653473,
0.3037649989128113,
-0.3150165379047394,
0.6817100644111633,
-0.03129057213664055,
0.068717360496521,
0.020761381834745407,
-0.4240245819091797,
-0.5491154193878174,
-0.19262199103832245,
0.4291217029094696,
0.8377886414527893,
-0.5762321949005127,
0.03958490863442421,
-0.15287092328071594,
-0.5120827555656433,
-0.8602843880653381,
0.21439237892627716,
0.24594992399215698,
0.16717949509620667,
0.4458966553211212,
-0.2029605656862259,
-0.9865283370018005,
-0.590092122554779,
-0.13469141721725464,
-0.376038134098053,
0.449655681848526,
0.1791592240333557,
0.046313732862472534,
-0.08888265490531921,
0.3284375071525574,
-0.47088348865509033,
-0.4636475145816803,
-0.6208735108375549,
-0.15531383454799652,
0.413448691368103,
0.09821636974811554,
0.31514278054237366,
-0.9453767538070679,
-0.7525650262832642,
0.1894887089729309,
-0.710444986820221,
-0.23830917477607727,
-0.24311138689517975,
-0.09072693437337875,
0.5544039011001587,
0.4819070100784302,
-0.38272130489349365,
0.6898828744888306,
0.46254080533981323,
-0.3512144386768341,
0.6773657202720642,
-0.1450219750404358,
0.6093494296073914,
-1.077391266822815,
0.3880600333213806,
-0.7857398390769958,
-0.0955401062965393,
-0.759292721748352,
0.5083747506141663,
-0.08707661181688309,
-0.2147749662399292,
-0.23326373100280762,
0.4391561448574066,
-0.514266312122345,
0.05637460947036743,
-0.38867419958114624,
-0.12263534963130951,
-0.520854651927948,
0.4695921838283539,
0.02213304117321968,
0.6461342573165894,
0.3413040041923523,
-0.37422990798950195,
0.21785058081150055,
0.29343804717063904,
-0.05767034739255905,
0.6936780214309692,
-0.3541908860206604,
-0.1875753104686737,
-0.13629136979579926,
0.042521651834249496,
-0.9055019021034241,
0.030206352472305298,
0.1333061158657074,
-0.5549465417861938,
0.3014056086540222,
-0.10167117416858673,
-0.48278990387916565,
-0.047607019543647766,
-0.06078129634261131,
0.41729918122291565,
0.7778712511062622,
-0.3879302740097046,
0.303333044052124,
0.2007187157869339,
-0.3004165589809418,
-0.44223594665527344,
-0.6492061018943787,
0.31717613339424133,
-0.22501559555530548,
-0.36689749360084534,
0.03932938724756241,
-0.13880202174186707,
-0.09194336086511612,
-0.30099770426750183,
0.01922598108649254,
-0.19363024830818176,
-0.16571566462516785,
0.5511069297790527,
0.19829238951206207,
-0.312050998210907,
-0.12277112156152725,
0.05081880837678909,
0.08769012987613678,
-0.29773834347724915,
0.02373342029750347,
0.7469332814216614,
0.3068617284297943,
-0.20341850817203522,
-0.5261637568473816,
0.8037072420120239,
0.7036007046699524,
-0.10330304503440857,
0.6944060921669006,
0.4764814078807831,
-0.4534149467945099,
-0.5712208151817322,
-0.5274146795272827,
0.23493210971355438,
-0.46533745527267456,
-0.054103605449199677,
-0.22568945586681366,
-0.6225947737693787,
0.22399841248989105,
-0.1438320279121399,
-0.36424288153648376,
0.34999629855155945,
0.8009467720985413,
-0.25105020403862,
0.4672001898288727,
0.6765380501747131,
-0.0765933245420456,
0.29083916544914246,
0.16719812154769897,
0.627845048904419,
-0.565621018409729,
-0.3266247808933258,
-0.5128892660140991,
-0.3871408998966217,
-0.6565435528755188,
-0.5904411673545837,
0.07526370137929916,
0.029867008328437805,
0.07747281342744827,
0.5031169056892395,
-0.6483603119850159,
0.043002016842365265,
0.325131356716156,
-0.15874166786670685,
0.22626736760139465,
0.14461146295070648,
-0.303082674741745,
-0.15636755526065826,
-0.483089417219162,
-0.10369621217250824,
0.8836811184883118,
0.07241679728031158,
0.8449605107307434,
0.12196644395589828,
1.1080224514007568,
0.547940194606781,
0.2196539342403412,
-0.6112875938415527,
0.7185285091400146,
-0.18367433547973633,
-0.6351878643035889,
-0.10733438283205032,
-0.5009934902191162,
-0.778597891330719,
0.04512273147702217,
0.019041357561945915,
-0.46987184882164,
0.01813448779284954,
-0.06715556979179382,
0.15777279436588287,
0.2536097466945648,
-0.7629410028457642,
0.23444199562072754,
-0.17779450118541718,
0.27281737327575684,
-0.3956722021102905,
-0.7619845271110535,
0.2801738679409027,
-0.03166345879435539,
0.3410531282424927,
0.09376821666955948,
0.4068041741847992,
0.604634165763855,
-0.6245176792144775,
0.8105335235595703,
-0.41173046827316284,
-0.20115651190280914,
0.3156278431415558,
0.2688677906990051,
0.006390064023435116,
-0.4366900324821472,
-0.24437472224235535,
-0.06365995854139328,
0.2819952964782715,
-0.3497113883495331,
-0.5171698927879333,
0.4868023693561554,
-0.368010938167572,
-0.004548090044409037,
-0.5010778307914734,
-0.4119702875614166,
-0.00017490975733380765,
0.5521548390388489,
0.10636715590953827,
0.4496353268623352,
-0.011806892231106758,
-0.26956620812416077,
0.3901047110557556,
-0.21845898032188416,
0.36452972888946533,
0.49106156826019287,
-0.46865805983543396,
-0.5541171431541443,
1.2109867334365845,
0.2268049120903015,
0.04869231954216957,
0.8789994716644287,
0.061552904546260834,
-0.3267136216163635,
-0.4556207060813904,
-0.586117684841156,
0.4298110902309418,
-0.6213900446891785,
-0.6010814309120178,
-0.04316805675625801,
-0.5386189222335815,
-0.380397766828537,
-0.39646971225738525,
0.12702612578868866,
-0.5014322400093079,
0.06876924633979797,
0.2075783908367157,
0.2394952028989792,
1.1935616731643677,
0.16118882596492767,
0.15982738137245178,
-0.43084731698036194,
0.44824737310409546,
-0.013927371241152287,
0.3303316533565521,
0.26995518803596497,
-0.3885387182235718,
-0.11320789158344269,
-0.042674120515584946,
0.1448996514081955,
-1.460394024848938,
0.3773372173309326,
0.05843530222773552,
0.3265678286552429,
0.00731364730745554,
-0.2106245905160904,
0.8923658132553101,
-0.4619411528110504,
0.6463173031806946,
0.015482677146792412,
-0.9417271018028259,
0.6014617681503296,
-0.0439932607114315,
0.12650814652442932,
0.8072123527526855,
-0.004943863023072481,
-1.0761420726776123,
-0.3581361770629883,
-0.6323022246360779,
-0.7422385215759277,
0.3644917607307434,
0.16702494025230408,
-0.061490606516599655,
0.13819964230060577,
0.2709786295890808,
0.13437055051326752,
0.5850313305854797,
-0.24554231762886047,
-0.19186146557331085,
0.020685778930783272,
-0.5941138863563538,
0.07644925266504288,
-0.227632537484169,
0.4482840299606323,
-0.050409987568855286,
0.640190601348877,
0.15344607830047607,
0.3701263666152954,
0.14902329444885254,
-0.6748751997947693,
-0.29600057005882263,
0.3316017985343933,
0.8862990140914917,
0.3132840096950531,
-0.03943409398198128,
0.08586493134498596,
0.16405990719795227,
-0.7364142537117004,
0.27756261825561523,
-0.3503079116344452,
-0.6711288690567017,
0.2802726626396179,
0.5254704356193542,
0.5678187012672424,
0.4187641739845276,
-0.7197821140289307,
0.44374725222587585,
0.19039863348007202,
-0.11330127716064453,
-0.03186621889472008,
-0.16232851147651672,
0.09716787189245224,
-0.07813075929880142,
0.5121256113052368,
0.2326764166355133,
0.14607463777065277,
-0.4373821020126343,
0.2107679843902588,
0.26228785514831543,
-0.29915115237236023,
-0.18771682679653168,
0.28621411323547363,
0.19989009201526642,
-0.7071159482002258,
0.3824731111526489,
-0.3493722081184387,
-0.9182054996490479,
0.4148273468017578,
1.0325772762298584,
0.6295701265335083,
-0.6898722052574158,
0.5248063206672668,
0.561432957649231,
0.5865002870559692,
0.02063276804983616,
0.9628225564956665,
-0.16672611236572266,
-0.15261487662792206,
-0.27021023631095886,
-0.9235341548919678,
-0.3390403389930725,
-0.3176620900630951,
-0.42140257358551025,
0.25207754969596863,
-0.4843115210533142,
0.39447271823883057,
-0.4634600281715393,
0.3773230314254761,
-0.39678123593330383,
0.5932436585426331,
0.19881980121135712,
1.0565133094787598,
-0.8981594443321228,
0.32645103335380554,
0.5187953114509583,
-0.19339238107204437,
-1.389283299446106,
-0.05675597861409187,
-0.05733046308159828,
-1.0033379793167114,
0.655809760093689,
0.24724945425987244,
-0.12399996072053909,
-0.2745535373687744,
-0.2599647045135498,
-1.015640139579773,
0.979831874370575,
-0.03858858346939087,
-0.34467610716819763,
-0.11405706405639648,
0.13263995945453644,
0.8793830275535583,
-0.20388735830783844,
0.2589075565338135,
0.0850505605340004,
0.5775822997093201,
0.2774814963340759,
-0.953467845916748,
0.539590060710907,
-0.4749104678630829,
0.14553825557231903,
0.27153894305229187,
-0.5730413794517517,
0.30079954862594604,
-0.16846758127212524,
-0.38405677676200867,
0.097786083817482,
0.6666044592857361,
0.12826533615589142,
0.10986997187137604,
0.36842864751815796,
0.30986863374710083,
0.8262758255004883,
0.35660773515701294,
0.5088151693344116,
-0.16021929681301117,
0.22447596490383148,
0.7266915440559387,
-0.39816486835479736,
1.190642237663269,
0.6148733496665955,
-0.24177731573581696,
0.7071049213409424,
0.15815208852291107,
0.020206378772854805,
0.3151417672634125,
0.5842017531394958,
0.03652205318212509,
0.31438472867012024,
-0.07824407517910004,
-0.25717127323150635,
0.5278151035308838,
0.2211242914199829,
-0.23914052546024323,
-0.32452017068862915,
-0.10116546601057053,
0.0401519313454628,
0.09926658123731613,
-0.1659211367368698,
0.741958498954773,
-0.06110240891575813,
-0.7803235054016113,
0.8672133684158325,
0.06030837818980217,
1.059546709060669,
-0.7039653658866882,
-0.18912941217422485,
-0.20367039740085602,
-0.16256281733512878,
-0.4859527349472046,
-0.32573816180229187,
0.39833736419677734,
-0.14585323631763458,
0.03432515263557434,
-0.3913198709487915,
1.1239299774169922,
-0.8543926477432251,
-0.5690817832946777,
0.2237895131111145,
0.2679722309112549,
0.2537623643875122,
0.250741571187973,
-0.47790399193763733,
0.3183040916919708,
0.14603173732757568,
0.2679887115955353,
0.05645743012428284,
0.02056664414703846,
-0.0656176507472992,
0.48525285720825195,
0.45796623826026917,
0.7122463583946228,
0.3527032732963562,
0.250680148601532,
0.2899898588657379,
-0.7914296388626099,
-0.6658830642700195,
-0.3256101906299591,
0.05818092077970505,
0.004935975652188063,
-0.2749970257282257,
0.723983645439148,
0.4851437509059906,
0.09798210859298706,
-0.21686503291130066,
0.7132309675216675,
-0.3261364996433258,
0.7396287322044373,
-0.3269220292568207,
1.0091516971588135,
-0.5912509560585022,
-0.11064135283231735,
-0.4654960334300995,
-0.6746549010276794,
-0.22611625492572784,
0.42191118001937866,
0.17806121706962585,
-0.04425488039851189,
0.8298166394233704,
0.7903643250465393,
0.044089607894420624,
0.18967922031879425,
0.27445271611213684,
0.09359876811504364,
-0.028456538915634155,
0.482431560754776,
0.51891028881073,
-0.5101628303527832,
0.35880401730537415,
-0.08171480894088745,
-0.26590588688850403,
-0.6729018688201904,
-0.4179626703262329,
-0.5996609330177307,
-0.8841714262962341,
-0.062256358563899994,
-0.25482919812202454,
-0.005968151614069939,
0.70197993516922,
0.607359766960144,
-0.7276755571365356,
-0.5407090783119202,
0.24342215061187744,
0.4985225200653076,
-0.6123843193054199,
-0.2985319197177887,
0.3433923125267029,
-0.47306740283966064,
-0.22812579572200775,
0.4497743844985962,
0.5428907871246338,
-0.16794300079345703,
-0.20871728658676147,
0.1839950680732727,
-0.43937885761260986,
0.4023762345314026,
0.5504610538482666,
0.25854867696762085,
-0.3731285333633423,
-0.07039798051118851,
0.1446801871061325,
-0.42063048481941223,
0.08881738781929016,
0.9345651268959045,
-0.3664259612560272,
0.21759307384490967,
0.8038129806518555,
0.4145687520503998,
0.23876196146011353,
0.0338590145111084,
0.4387090802192688,
-0.5928365588188171,
-0.005230532959103584,
0.1965547353029251,
-0.21477048099040985,
0.5993455648422241,
-0.7802680730819702,
0.30730894207954407,
0.17668041586875916,
-0.3944425582885742,
-0.992953896522522,
0.21960102021694183,
-1.1725233793258667,
-0.11781946569681168,
1.2327653169631958,
0.17542217671871185,
-0.5420724153518677,
-0.06427526473999023,
-0.7121475338935852,
0.13770975172519684,
-0.03198578953742981,
0.5567554235458374,
0.49461615085601807,
0.13045673072338104,
0.12502311170101166,
-0.19396670162677765,
0.6492140293121338,
0.7941840291023254,
-0.7668327689170837,
-0.014605708420276642,
-0.0038902501109987497,
0.635330855846405,
0.32732173800468445,
1.0194462537765503,
-0.2435794472694397,
0.414008766412735,
0.049947597086429596,
-0.034631792455911636,
0.32375508546829224,
-0.3368908762931824,
-0.39073747396469116,
0.47377973794937134,
0.13261568546295166,
-0.14819039404392242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13343v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13343v1
|
UnibucLLM: Harnessing LLMs for Automated Prediction of Item Difficulty and Response Time for Multiple-Choice Questions
| 2024-04-20T10:41:02 | 2024-04-20T10:41:02 |
Ana-Cristina Rogoz, Radu Tudor Ionescu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This work explores a novel data augmentation method based on Large Language
Models (LLMs) for predicting item difficulty and response time of retired USMLE
Multiple-Choice Questions (MCQs) in the BEA 2024 Shared Task. Our approach is
based on augmenting the dataset with answers from zero-shot LLMs (Falcon,
Meditron, Mistral) and employing transformer-based models based on six
alternative feature combinations. The results suggest that predicting the
difficulty of questions is more challenging. Notably, our top performing
methods consistently include the question text, and benefit from the
variability of LLM answers, highlighting the potential of LLMs for improving
automated assessment in medical licensing exams. We make our code available
https://github.com/ana-rogoz/BEA-2024.
|
[
-0.4402402937412262,
-0.731069803237915,
0.6693849563598633,
0.059761058539152145,
-0.2275434136390686,
0.43613922595977783,
-0.10809466987848282,
-0.5448750257492065,
-0.012624557130038738,
0.7289811968803406,
-0.8489612936973572,
-0.2870545983314514,
-0.3587600588798523,
0.505847692489624,
0.0758851021528244,
0.8142887949943542,
-0.1971753090620041,
0.3752588927745819,
-0.44187766313552856,
-0.07476303726434708,
-0.6213333010673523,
-0.4342414140701294,
-0.25897344946861267,
-0.4925694167613983,
0.46669766306877136,
0.3815286457538605,
0.43779468536376953,
0.22607900202274323,
0.9328333139419556,
0.26631051301956177,
-0.08560442924499512,
0.26227083802223206,
-0.18417543172836304,
0.029823608696460724,
-0.18830043077468872,
-0.29697203636169434,
-0.6950806379318237,
0.05789420008659363,
0.2033042311668396,
0.9927862286567688,
-0.1708894670009613,
0.1881868690252304,
-0.027033427730202675,
0.40893059968948364,
-0.36543816328048706,
-0.06591050326824188,
-0.7574527263641357,
0.01275094598531723,
-0.07883308082818985,
-0.41644948720932007,
-0.4007183015346527,
-0.17463411390781403,
0.07700300961732864,
-0.28326618671417236,
0.14398734271526337,
0.08914446085691452,
0.43126341700553894,
0.5770640969276428,
-0.7317317128181458,
-0.35997191071510315,
-0.5134112238883972,
0.9127436876296997,
-0.6332096457481384,
0.3043627142906189,
0.09393147379159927,
0.29446375370025635,
-0.38084039092063904,
-0.826772153377533,
-0.33299288153648376,
-0.3471270203590393,
0.016744019463658333,
0.20822568237781525,
0.08850512653589249,
0.13059833645820618,
0.10589626431465149,
0.40766215324401855,
-0.5986742377281189,
0.13714443147182465,
-0.6599993109703064,
-0.12138695269823074,
0.8450120687484741,
0.5590690970420837,
0.11542941629886627,
-0.1215052679181099,
-0.4521244168281555,
0.2774187922477722,
-0.6102380752563477,
0.09197308123111725,
-0.011584063060581684,
0.039185646921396255,
0.31395938992500305,
0.8934581875801086,
-0.2723858952522278,
0.8616621494293213,
0.03195160627365112,
0.001475619268603623,
0.5405272245407104,
-0.4449334144592285,
-0.24224945902824402,
-0.14142370223999023,
0.7369281053543091,
0.2721279561519623,
-0.10269590467214584,
-0.07420529425144196,
-0.030475419014692307,
-0.17364975810050964,
0.17414598166942596,
-0.652531623840332,
-0.13209298253059387,
0.5237035751342773,
-0.2687026262283325,
-0.21653693914413452,
-0.02045333757996559,
-0.7844446897506714,
-0.39294615387916565,
-0.30846530199050903,
0.42596691846847534,
-0.19536644220352173,
0.3345591723918915,
0.25933218002319336,
0.3190181851387024,
-0.014417928643524647,
0.3750198185443878,
-0.340240478515625,
0.2372104972600937,
0.3439263701438904,
0.5504820942878723,
-0.5773817896842957,
-0.1460290551185608,
-0.6532531976699829,
0.06134863570332527,
-0.12782903015613556,
0.9322100877761841,
-0.6360586881637573,
-0.551539421081543,
-0.5679078102111816,
0.28974419832229614,
-0.01921352557837963,
-0.47128939628601074,
0.5579652190208435,
-0.5714114308357239,
0.2955680191516876,
-0.09432312846183777,
-0.5607471466064453,
-0.22678829729557037,
0.24957317113876343,
-0.7216046452522278,
0.8797585964202881,
0.2797035574913025,
-0.5724172592163086,
0.13210687041282654,
-0.950782299041748,
-0.2925202250480652,
0.20498761534690857,
-0.06220482662320137,
-0.43303319811820984,
0.010370813310146332,
0.3789844810962677,
0.6271238327026367,
-0.3618505299091339,
0.22188031673431396,
-0.3774676024913788,
-0.5277314782142639,
0.5111039280891418,
-0.6460338234901428,
0.912987232208252,
0.14866890013217926,
-0.07102266699075699,
0.02478531189262867,
-0.8255906105041504,
0.17459110915660858,
-0.06465470790863037,
-0.72760009765625,
0.23340943455696106,
-0.29241853952407837,
-0.15307538211345673,
0.19089637696743011,
0.4014478027820587,
-0.6787891983985901,
0.4116092622280121,
-0.2738727033138275,
-0.0056988829746842384,
0.7416399717330933,
0.1341651976108551,
0.4160626530647278,
-0.4082544147968292,
0.7886569499969482,
-0.07896833121776581,
0.3175659775733948,
-0.004277713596820831,
-0.7312270402908325,
-0.32265543937683105,
-0.14433102309703827,
0.5292147397994995,
0.8591451644897461,
-0.5781489610671997,
0.22297543287277222,
-0.004199252929538488,
-0.5186989903450012,
-0.8033090829849243,
0.4783642888069153,
0.15741921961307526,
0.4547977149486542,
0.5798421502113342,
-0.3712068498134613,
-0.6658650040626526,
-0.39272764325141907,
0.2865794599056244,
-0.1648775190114975,
-0.23595401644706726,
0.5471142530441284,
0.37132781744003296,
-0.6097983717918396,
0.4844934940338135,
-0.6181337237358093,
-0.3292640745639801,
-0.20237311720848083,
0.3140825629234314,
0.3951506018638611,
0.2206137776374817,
0.008842707611620426,
-0.6473880410194397,
-0.4084562659263611,
-0.06381294876337051,
-0.5641646385192871,
-0.3621698021888733,
-0.11172633618116379,
0.22873544692993164,
0.4012889564037323,
0.40673914551734924,
-0.2544267475605011,
0.3865467607975006,
0.5349076390266418,
-0.18662691116333008,
0.6009300947189331,
-0.37207379937171936,
0.45265161991119385,
-1.0565998554229736,
-0.23031696677207947,
-0.30806735157966614,
0.059129755944013596,
-0.3809255361557007,
-0.07799798995256424,
0.22657743096351624,
0.19515611231327057,
-0.6569385528564453,
0.5589399337768555,
-0.5832061767578125,
-0.09949809312820435,
-0.24800638854503632,
0.029970286414027214,
0.06343437731266022,
0.29743826389312744,
-0.07236510515213013,
0.9086067080497742,
0.43125486373901367,
-0.5279706716537476,
0.7846004962921143,
0.15988674759864807,
-0.1465693861246109,
0.545090913772583,
-0.6903398036956787,
0.13682597875595093,
-0.10359574109315872,
0.19919763505458832,
-1.0207072496414185,
-0.29217851161956787,
-0.21981097757816315,
-0.45050445199012756,
0.24086587131023407,
0.17391492426395416,
-0.19005897641181946,
-0.8326805233955383,
-0.37632662057876587,
0.47453629970550537,
0.313882440328598,
-0.40844762325286865,
0.7910074591636658,
0.11179054528474808,
-0.32081231474876404,
-0.7721841335296631,
-0.7749303579330444,
0.07033126056194305,
-0.12717562913894653,
-0.5906326174736023,
0.40829282999038696,
-0.7904626727104187,
-0.17748495936393738,
-0.12794744968414307,
0.18474893271923065,
-0.15928532183170319,
0.28218260407447815,
0.4026314914226532,
0.740698516368866,
0.07098411023616791,
0.10326020419597626,
0.0549035482108593,
0.0012339354725554585,
-0.03010878525674343,
0.28140580654144287,
0.4819207191467285,
-0.04006998986005783,
-0.6299272775650024,
-0.2510265111923218,
0.32356080412864685,
0.4419654905796051,
-0.11398684233427048,
0.20182497799396515,
0.5499654412269592,
-0.11784123629331589,
0.14607283473014832,
-0.6740204095840454,
-0.21175187826156616,
-0.4728175401687622,
0.36474359035491943,
-0.2826012969017029,
-0.8194990158081055,
0.6041972637176514,
-0.011127437464892864,
0.07185716181993484,
0.2247527539730072,
0.7930858135223389,
-0.3012874126434326,
1.134824514389038,
0.3122732937335968,
0.1084938570857048,
-0.028009748086333275,
-0.18558301031589508,
-0.12552791833877563,
-1.144144892692566,
-0.6674432158470154,
-0.2053678184747696,
-0.3303030729293823,
-0.4252367615699768,
-0.7804819345474243,
0.41927918791770935,
-0.17704658210277557,
-0.05446353554725647,
0.09673352539539337,
-0.4801284670829773,
0.414110004901886,
0.45139575004577637,
0.16822345554828644,
0.5685714483261108,
-0.2886693775653839,
-0.3421991467475891,
0.05777834728360176,
-0.43140506744384766,
-0.31576186418533325,
1.7776306867599487,
0.1893928498029709,
1.0794246196746826,
0.04510585218667984,
0.6043750047683716,
0.07964245975017548,
0.3491141200065613,
-0.8000338077545166,
0.535533607006073,
-0.048215847462415695,
-0.704682469367981,
-0.26760363578796387,
-0.43209055066108704,
-1.0106602907180786,
-0.07476337999105453,
-0.17013314366340637,
-0.5614138841629028,
-0.005454032216221094,
-0.21647070348262787,
-0.6271014213562012,
0.1612265557050705,
-0.36244964599609375,
0.2081892341375351,
-0.5009527802467346,
-0.2068699151277542,
0.2616238594055176,
-0.7393762469291687,
0.36520901322364807,
-0.5074368119239807,
0.24995103478431702,
-0.15138107538223267,
-0.32967332005500793,
0.7458170652389526,
-0.1893506944179535,
0.4787837564945221,
0.26683011651039124,
0.015309990383684635,
0.2115718275308609,
-0.06556643545627594,
0.24648913741111755,
0.3152112066745758,
-0.35315921902656555,
-0.01927419751882553,
0.030984515324234962,
-0.3844956159591675,
-0.5245203375816345,
0.6799153685569763,
-0.4205833077430725,
-0.5521843433380127,
-0.5466250777244568,
-1.1456140279769897,
-0.4886540174484253,
-0.025642400607466698,
0.17862091958522797,
0.5108379125595093,
0.003281925106421113,
0.22611594200134277,
0.5919027328491211,
-0.06663177907466888,
0.6382185816764832,
0.7433897852897644,
-0.08682309091091156,
-0.5636041164398193,
0.43202468752861023,
0.2965603172779083,
0.12857727706432343,
0.12565787136554718,
-0.02881404012441635,
-0.6417205333709717,
-0.8497337102890015,
-0.4710828959941864,
0.25785598158836365,
-0.5738679766654968,
-0.47257739305496216,
-0.6419461965560913,
-0.2874257266521454,
-0.3453024625778198,
-0.19966967403888702,
-0.08489378541707993,
-0.428964227437973,
-0.7320583462715149,
-0.28721633553504944,
0.4913412928581238,
0.930206298828125,
-0.11886744201183319,
0.33484122157096863,
-0.8711163997650146,
0.21606923639774323,
0.5177904963493347,
0.411536306142807,
-0.42523106932640076,
-0.851251482963562,
0.12785565853118896,
0.05010705068707466,
-0.624459981918335,
-0.7605103254318237,
0.3880642354488373,
-0.006285644136369228,
0.6905626654624939,
0.1999654471874237,
0.11585642397403717,
0.6960675716400146,
-0.5577336549758911,
0.9182330965995789,
0.23247312009334564,
-0.5748389959335327,
0.43047595024108887,
0.0880364179611206,
0.12795139849185944,
0.6540622115135193,
0.3694305419921875,
-0.050805527716875076,
-0.3326120674610138,
-0.5274099111557007,
-0.6990097165107727,
0.5361210703849792,
-0.012740714475512505,
0.17455033957958221,
0.041862502694129944,
0.36109912395477295,
0.19318586587905884,
0.09845951199531555,
-0.6581594944000244,
-0.37239307165145874,
0.18647637963294983,
-0.41142934560775757,
-0.15354043245315552,
-0.31735146045684814,
0.0790477842092514,
-0.5358381867408752,
0.603236973285675,
-0.20369258522987366,
0.24077388644218445,
0.10777866095304489,
-0.062137290835380554,
-0.3145190477371216,
0.5505999326705933,
0.4568316638469696,
0.8633102178573608,
-0.7482989430427551,
-0.053503185510635376,
0.6421833038330078,
-0.42642322182655334,
0.3302319049835205,
0.38352999091148376,
0.14786569774150848,
-0.01594969443976879,
0.15712182223796844,
0.6061497330665588,
0.04033595696091652,
-0.8136473894119263,
0.341422438621521,
-0.20549756288528442,
-0.44248947501182556,
-0.2819608449935913,
-0.07245409488677979,
0.01464923843741417,
0.34871870279312134,
0.5917823910713196,
-0.18159694969654083,
0.391432523727417,
-0.583558201789856,
0.5599330067634583,
0.5285829901695251,
-0.6076669692993164,
-0.07081029564142227,
0.652344822883606,
0.04276369884610176,
-0.20768170058727264,
0.16282382607460022,
-0.2558090388774872,
-0.4038045108318329,
0.5424458980560303,
0.6973920464515686,
0.252044141292572,
-0.6512956619262695,
0.27777528762817383,
0.12480288743972778,
0.09688438475131989,
-0.02896188013255596,
0.7064037322998047,
0.45611101388931274,
-0.2858189344406128,
-0.6364877223968506,
-0.552433431148529,
-0.6413491368293762,
0.1943884938955307,
-0.5529170632362366,
0.3563595116138458,
-0.290993869304657,
-0.1640310436487198,
-0.32774659991264343,
0.4526410698890686,
-0.63021320104599,
0.5644028782844543,
-0.04533706605434418,
0.8560460805892944,
-0.5339562892913818,
0.590041995048523,
0.8093148469924927,
-0.400638610124588,
-0.808297872543335,
-0.30526596307754517,
-0.023753425106406212,
-0.6819279193878174,
0.34497082233428955,
-0.02503344416618347,
0.20595937967300415,
0.02767661213874817,
-0.19997204840183258,
-0.7189278602600098,
1.552835464477539,
0.2791893482208252,
-0.5611999034881592,
-0.14881771802902222,
0.2799423336982727,
0.34865036606788635,
-0.47989946603775024,
0.7085822820663452,
0.7202762961387634,
0.2801226079463959,
0.46375253796577454,
-1.0060539245605469,
0.0018830084009096026,
-0.09749264270067215,
-0.3133890926837921,
0.09341325610876083,
-0.18293677270412445,
0.9671292901039124,
-0.5300647020339966,
0.23177526891231537,
0.1431014984846115,
0.48949989676475525,
0.5256769061088562,
0.6727713346481323,
0.25573667883872986,
0.4840119481086731,
1.102211833000183,
-0.003059835871681571,
0.7605081796646118,
-0.05624699220061302,
0.39290744066238403,
1.2257461547851562,
-0.39006778597831726,
0.8484357595443726,
0.7261131405830383,
-0.4889727234840393,
0.6860232949256897,
0.7933126091957092,
-0.07341362535953522,
0.26199081540107727,
0.17282268404960632,
-0.36897048354148865,
-0.21833978593349457,
-0.13259132206439972,
-0.4146687984466553,
0.523695170879364,
0.348676860332489,
-0.24340637028217316,
-0.13495345413684845,
0.2809653878211975,
-0.3725031912326813,
-0.08947295695543289,
-0.4115808606147766,
0.8261719346046448,
0.053333841264247894,
-0.40981289744377136,
0.5366308093070984,
-0.2495127022266388,
0.7163951992988586,
-0.14618346095085144,
0.01330555696040392,
-0.28026190400123596,
-0.04376574605703354,
-0.0877784714102745,
-1.0981534719467163,
0.24726180732250214,
-0.1342671513557434,
-0.10082254558801651,
0.2720527946949005,
0.554904580116272,
-0.4241834282875061,
-0.9940983653068542,
0.3950622081756592,
0.6258358359336853,
0.2222205549478531,
0.07370122522115707,
-0.9731795191764832,
-0.05706783011555672,
0.07460109144449234,
-0.19552356004714966,
0.16189295053482056,
0.24670429527759552,
0.05288359895348549,
0.9995597004890442,
0.4872209131717682,
0.26471391320228577,
0.25852644443511963,
-0.047092147171497345,
0.7868998646736145,
-0.4555354416370392,
0.009721803478896618,
-0.7490140795707703,
0.7119960188865662,
-0.023479605093598366,
0.15158474445343018,
0.3800971508026123,
0.4278354048728943,
0.5943793058395386,
-0.014579554088413715,
0.7553146481513977,
0.2345031499862671,
0.8341130614280701,
-0.48920074105262756,
0.4370979964733124,
-0.7180665731430054,
0.7183941006660461,
-0.22553345561027527,
-0.8239578604698181,
-0.4493578374385834,
0.13711027801036835,
-0.193344846367836,
0.051985759288072586,
0.8236903548240662,
1.018956184387207,
-0.07041313499212265,
-0.2505151927471161,
0.428999125957489,
-0.16424442827701569,
0.08558929711580276,
0.969754159450531,
0.6058131456375122,
-0.5323120951652527,
0.9687967300415039,
-0.6258724927902222,
-0.18066665530204773,
-0.37496766448020935,
-0.8054267764091492,
-0.9384191632270813,
-0.5481998920440674,
-0.3614104390144348,
-0.2954966425895691,
-0.2981313467025757,
1.131495475769043,
0.41850772500038147,
-0.9884010553359985,
-0.1255558580160141,
0.10865423083305359,
0.1285773515701294,
0.19011585414409637,
-0.1624312549829483,
0.34857556223869324,
-0.27210095524787903,
-0.7632187008857727,
0.4600493311882019,
0.15433189272880554,
0.3406723737716675,
-0.08081129193305969,
-0.2157473862171173,
-0.31563472747802734,
0.4756729304790497,
0.3413495719432831,
-0.12410059571266174,
-0.7474870085716248,
-0.10339516401290894,
0.3585575222969055,
-0.0123320072889328,
0.14868995547294617,
0.5120453834533691,
-0.8734766244888306,
0.5921303033828735,
0.332917720079422,
0.6209947466850281,
0.10365203768014908,
0.3005073666572571,
0.42748478055000305,
-0.576354444026947,
-0.23020488023757935,
0.39694929122924805,
0.5569301247596741,
0.35367289185523987,
-0.5451861619949341,
0.6513500213623047,
0.22873400151729584,
-0.7571669816970825,
-0.9109531044960022,
0.03923088684678078,
-1.160794973373413,
-0.4091615080833435,
1.1111046075820923,
-0.1311224400997162,
-0.20659026503562927,
-0.5313640832901001,
-0.46262621879577637,
0.24085254967212677,
-0.2308758944272995,
0.8250278830528259,
0.4763495922088623,
-0.3887687027454376,
-0.34138599038124084,
-0.5534988045692444,
0.31341272592544556,
0.4704936444759369,
-1.0021990537643433,
-0.16573789715766907,
0.4341414272785187,
0.40096402168273926,
0.17742037773132324,
0.6265625357627869,
-0.1640118807554245,
0.5046209096908569,
-0.610346794128418,
-0.03804421052336693,
-0.3617279529571533,
-0.29783695936203003,
-0.47109174728393555,
0.22551394999027252,
0.004258780274540186,
-0.06637987494468689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14445v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14445v1
|
A Multi-Faceted Evaluation Framework for Assessing Synthetic Data Generated by Large Language Models
| 2024-04-20T08:08:28 | 2024-04-20T08:08:28 |
Yefeng Yuan, Yuhong Liu, Liang Cheng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The rapid advancements in generative AI and large language models (LLMs) have
opened up new avenues for producing synthetic data, particularly in the realm
of structured tabular formats, such as product reviews. Despite the potential
benefits, concerns regarding privacy leakage have surfaced, especially when
personal information is utilized in the training datasets. In addition, there
is an absence of a comprehensive evaluation framework capable of quantitatively
measuring the quality of the generated synthetic data and their utility for
downstream tasks. In response to this gap, we introduce SynEval, an open-source
evaluation framework designed to assess the fidelity, utility, and privacy
preservation of synthetically generated tabular data via a suite of diverse
evaluation metrics. We validate the efficacy of our proposed framework -
SynEval - by applying it to synthetic product review data generated by three
state-of-the-art LLMs: ChatGPT, Claude, and Llama. Our experimental findings
illuminate the trade-offs between various evaluation metrics in the context of
synthetic data generation. Furthermore, SynEval stands as a critical instrument
for researchers and practitioners engaged with synthetic tabular data,,
empowering them to judiciously determine the suitability of the generated data
for their specific applications, with an emphasis on upholding user privacy.
|
[
-0.23208750784397125,
-0.8871625065803528,
0.3444514572620392,
0.4101112484931946,
0.19226090610027313,
0.37532663345336914,
-0.468171089887619,
-0.402300626039505,
0.04253077879548073,
0.23256105184555054,
-0.3056428134441376,
-0.9202702641487122,
-0.13558699190616608,
0.04546215757727623,
-0.7465949058532715,
1.3225010633468628,
-0.08885201811790466,
0.03781602904200554,
-0.3869645595550537,
-0.09444229304790497,
-0.14164039492607117,
-0.5808145403862,
-0.32717519998550415,
0.10967650264501572,
0.4350802004337311,
0.08386730402708054,
0.7700850367546082,
0.32903987169265747,
0.5620154738426208,
0.38603755831718445,
0.09890898317098618,
0.1826285719871521,
-0.5464931130409241,
0.5525933504104614,
-0.3018398582935333,
-0.3184219002723694,
-0.6051891446113586,
-0.024087190628051758,
0.8133823275566101,
0.4422246217727661,
-0.39659151434898376,
0.7611984014511108,
0.2180677205324173,
0.7214747667312622,
-0.7077628970146179,
0.3371598422527313,
-0.6971168518066406,
0.2480560839176178,
-0.3345738351345062,
0.10559612512588501,
-0.29813772439956665,
-0.7741949558258057,
0.07491087168455124,
-0.4638574719429016,
0.2713468372821808,
0.2554226219654083,
0.5012978911399841,
0.061101242899894714,
0.03797464072704315,
-0.1321645975112915,
-0.9684826135635376,
0.6268112063407898,
-0.7935006022453308,
0.6531879305839539,
0.11396390199661255,
0.6992677450180054,
-0.2680826485157013,
-0.9094482660293579,
-1.0394679307937622,
-0.49555888772010803,
-0.01582932658493519,
0.20000995695590973,
0.004611280746757984,
-0.03136693686246872,
0.07630077004432678,
0.7132874131202698,
-0.7756155133247375,
-0.20212945342063904,
-0.40902402997016907,
-0.3549472987651825,
0.892128050327301,
0.20753608644008636,
0.4168035089969635,
-0.2075166255235672,
-0.5643222332000732,
-0.28068509697914124,
-0.7774525880813599,
0.03475450351834297,
0.6179966926574707,
0.2577514350414276,
-0.19472023844718933,
0.7317453026771545,
-0.17231027781963348,
0.3998687267303467,
-0.2875453531742096,
-0.024301422759890556,
0.5199732184410095,
-0.6801760196685791,
-0.32911133766174316,
-0.10544893145561218,
1.0918054580688477,
0.32114139199256897,
0.11269715428352356,
-0.2784762382507324,
-0.3209376633167267,
0.3450344502925873,
0.42766469717025757,
-0.7361790537834167,
-0.10695312917232513,
0.4823763072490692,
-0.4221794903278351,
-0.44899892807006836,
0.17566490173339844,
-0.9581087231636047,
-0.4907432496547699,
-0.3918918967247009,
0.30761170387268066,
0.023078812286257744,
-0.05815477296710014,
-0.09205977618694305,
0.007827475666999817,
0.0011945771984755993,
0.08014187216758728,
-0.7203567624092102,
0.4906562566757202,
0.7801926136016846,
0.6858328580856323,
-0.4789768159389496,
-0.24312998354434967,
-0.43689772486686707,
0.012905321083962917,
-0.3878132998943329,
0.7043311595916748,
-0.3691859543323517,
-0.42779067158699036,
0.03127549961209297,
0.006042554974555969,
0.06403322517871857,
-0.6797293424606323,
0.4626254141330719,
-0.45088252425193787,
0.1741764396429062,
-0.0623619370162487,
-0.24968406558036804,
0.19212988018989563,
0.6171813011169434,
-0.7483725547790527,
0.9199354648590088,
0.25194188952445984,
-0.5893375873565674,
0.5779343247413635,
-0.5473572611808777,
-0.36441507935523987,
0.242857426404953,
-0.4413111209869385,
-0.6980522871017456,
0.027475975453853607,
0.05982157960534096,
0.05498415231704712,
-0.548569917678833,
0.4377609193325043,
-0.4684813618659973,
0.03125686198472977,
0.5541686415672302,
-0.4033689498901367,
0.43527621030807495,
0.2014453113079071,
-0.30558115243911743,
0.44672447443008423,
-0.7625694870948792,
0.29515358805656433,
-0.20005758106708527,
-0.42943841218948364,
0.05239596962928772,
-0.025598838925361633,
0.28764331340789795,
0.08094444870948792,
0.21905772387981415,
-0.9125549793243408,
-0.2591414153575897,
-0.49368688464164734,
0.2937996983528137,
0.7581244707107544,
0.1475585401058197,
0.2488253116607666,
-0.2735193371772766,
0.7935212254524231,
-0.13619102537631989,
0.3782796859741211,
0.10415380448102951,
-0.21290196478366852,
-0.5782260298728943,
0.02838379330933094,
0.520438551902771,
0.31014469265937805,
-0.3903979957103729,
0.35221800208091736,
-0.2560132145881653,
-0.650749146938324,
-0.5802286863327026,
0.24092824757099152,
0.4805941879749298,
0.28421756625175476,
0.21377265453338623,
-0.305174320936203,
-0.4855823516845703,
-1.3081023693084717,
-0.4663478434085846,
-0.3510638177394867,
-0.10286837071180344,
0.3975095748901367,
0.3520546853542328,
-0.25149816274642944,
0.9132378697395325,
-0.0227894876152277,
-0.3130274713039398,
-0.31636977195739746,
0.037583719938993454,
0.004579782485961914,
0.4391162693500519,
0.28197211027145386,
-0.4827950894832611,
-0.5262022614479065,
0.1431393176317215,
-0.7256799340248108,
-0.05083974078297615,
-0.23510590195655823,
-0.2266159951686859,
0.043080128729343414,
-0.003956275526434183,
-0.6804006099700928,
0.36553895473480225,
0.7373189330101013,
-0.014000069350004196,
0.6757537722587585,
-0.11111041903495789,
0.18428874015808105,
-0.9623532295227051,
0.22701223194599152,
-0.14613918960094452,
-0.14589835703372955,
-0.46766331791877747,
0.11860755831003189,
0.03282914310693741,
-0.303847074508667,
-0.44528236985206604,
0.5677255392074585,
-0.35671496391296387,
-0.33487096428871155,
0.25596892833709717,
0.22137880325317383,
0.20576846599578857,
0.10501787066459656,
-0.12872539460659027,
0.8964295983314514,
0.2168504297733307,
-0.10395816713571548,
0.2592722475528717,
0.47373729944229126,
-0.5753726363182068,
0.4990556240081787,
-0.859841525554657,
0.18205294013023376,
-0.04470125958323479,
0.31800323724746704,
-0.8592649102210999,
-0.3271980583667755,
0.1131460964679718,
-0.4429610073566437,
0.23132337629795074,
0.14839237928390503,
-0.6154336333274841,
-0.25316813588142395,
-0.49224773049354553,
0.34311529994010925,
0.40398767590522766,
-0.5129551887512207,
0.4556410312652588,
0.7133027911186218,
-0.3093811273574829,
-0.45273706316947937,
-0.6711161732673645,
0.1425779014825821,
-0.17309355735778809,
-0.8490180969238281,
0.47935011982917786,
-0.06744030117988586,
-0.3718653917312622,
-0.05635719373822212,
-0.29382187128067017,
0.21602775156497955,
-0.16302306950092316,
0.32069143652915955,
0.2388526201248169,
-0.1770840287208557,
0.020527344197034836,
0.12921838462352753,
-0.01751050353050232,
0.30909043550491333,
-0.10164505243301392,
0.4218340814113617,
-0.4211788773536682,
-0.27051761746406555,
-0.3219251036643982,
0.06780977547168732,
0.49320846796035767,
-0.35488182306289673,
0.6471397876739502,
0.4595465660095215,
-0.2744315564632416,
-0.8902196288108826,
-0.44564247131347656,
-0.015437214635312557,
-0.48737022280693054,
0.2767179012298584,
-0.015054791234433651,
-0.4142454266548157,
0.55417799949646,
0.1518687605857849,
0.12366756796836853,
0.27898749709129333,
0.8689261674880981,
0.10153611749410629,
0.7599484324455261,
0.27578964829444885,
0.28136515617370605,
0.1315862089395523,
-0.2841210663318634,
0.535593569278717,
-0.7667750716209412,
-0.6611315608024597,
-0.3946395814418793,
-0.47852104902267456,
-0.721186101436615,
-0.250344455242157,
0.7600831389427185,
-0.1500258445739746,
-0.08549327403306961,
0.2957509458065033,
-0.3908916711807251,
0.517795205116272,
0.25190743803977966,
-0.04311555624008179,
0.391997367143631,
0.05416515842080116,
0.06659015268087387,
0.039387647062540054,
-0.30523771047592163,
-0.6937310695648193,
1.2489346265792847,
0.384691447019577,
0.8190051317214966,
0.013768347911536694,
0.6998881697654724,
0.47945454716682434,
0.5653398633003235,
-0.5145373940467834,
0.5631014108657837,
-0.0921865850687027,
-0.6585820913314819,
-0.27579042315483093,
-0.4489162862300873,
-0.8618003726005554,
0.3102734684944153,
-0.26508864760398865,
-0.7278147339820862,
0.1480388194322586,
0.23793816566467285,
-0.40442153811454773,
0.01668247953057289,
-0.6072120070457458,
1.0851411819458008,
-0.44975870847702026,
-0.8158856630325317,
-0.2120889574289322,
-0.5133745670318604,
0.5139068365097046,
-0.31674984097480774,
0.15152284502983093,
-0.15623869001865387,
0.11628569662570953,
0.6891855001449585,
-0.5651695132255554,
0.5358717441558838,
-0.22885508835315704,
-0.00226939027197659,
0.28999391198158264,
0.45257997512817383,
0.3011155128479004,
0.38326743245124817,
-0.11939744651317596,
0.2539316713809967,
0.21075615286827087,
0.13740651309490204,
-0.791583776473999,
0.9297336339950562,
-0.5699688792228699,
-0.47106021642684937,
-0.3178502917289734,
-0.6126670241355896,
-0.5747942328453064,
0.0583706796169281,
-0.09369614720344543,
0.22209906578063965,
-0.4469894766807556,
0.4293181002140045,
0.023283017799258232,
-0.638218343257904,
0.040645781904459,
0.31967470049858093,
-0.3319249749183655,
-0.5275509357452393,
0.9798939228057861,
0.006621011067181826,
0.2805895209312439,
0.005123212933540344,
0.35727035999298096,
-0.6559544205665588,
-0.6051055192947388,
-0.6275016069412231,
-0.022174760699272156,
-0.41162967681884766,
-0.32954642176628113,
-0.41724470257759094,
-0.4384761452674866,
-0.1997944563627243,
0.2622949779033661,
-0.518982470035553,
-0.5986059308052063,
0.2716698944568634,
-0.2499982863664627,
0.021935774013400078,
0.7265974879264832,
0.11857286095619202,
-0.020894961431622505,
-0.6838837265968323,
0.4018878638744354,
-0.05535408854484558,
0.3338572680950165,
-0.025286687538027763,
-0.02298997901380062,
-0.035538580268621445,
0.19202616810798645,
-0.4517075717449188,
-0.664962649345398,
0.5622813105583191,
0.2531794309616089,
0.6757358312606812,
-0.020862456411123276,
0.15010659396648407,
0.45478570461273193,
-0.3980516493320465,
0.9228792786598206,
-0.02335621975362301,
-0.8838425874710083,
0.3286610245704651,
-0.3291770815849304,
-0.07447565346956253,
0.7221652269363403,
0.14895455539226532,
-0.34870046377182007,
-0.49429765343666077,
-0.5057235956192017,
-0.9269766211509705,
0.3551066219806671,
0.4159530997276306,
0.12994566559791565,
0.07953968644142151,
-0.15619638562202454,
0.3421569764614105,
0.6598508358001709,
-0.7677682638168335,
0.13743622601032257,
-0.13720689713954926,
-0.33395475149154663,
0.2891288995742798,
0.12058931589126587,
-0.10017461329698563,
0.049981970340013504,
0.43786245584487915,
0.12095389515161514,
-0.07008754462003708,
0.04294545575976372,
-0.18262481689453125,
0.18180423974990845,
0.5499246120452881,
0.13756690919399261,
0.6942617297172546,
-0.10565360635519028,
0.046963825821876526,
-0.04286020249128342,
-0.41510817408561707,
0.039969440549612045,
0.07591754198074341,
-0.31472569704055786,
-0.19616463780403137,
0.10282736271619797,
0.39314326643943787,
-0.16247764229774475,
-0.7387643456459045,
0.6163787245750427,
-0.008329849690198898,
-0.022613689303398132,
-0.3252306282520294,
-0.06074380874633789,
-0.13894082605838776,
0.11611806601285934,
-0.10498672723770142,
0.08933669328689575,
0.43144914507865906,
-0.7172415852546692,
0.23300260305404663,
0.5500583648681641,
0.09579282999038696,
-0.586708664894104,
0.6234793066978455,
0.12243232876062393,
-0.2858182489871979,
0.6107650399208069,
-0.04687610641121864,
-0.2919255793094635,
0.3722621202468872,
0.5476741194725037,
1.028995394706726,
-0.22715771198272705,
0.4623493552207947,
0.2608695328235626,
0.27623459696769714,
0.28340235352516174,
0.34966155886650085,
-0.34825536608695984,
-0.5458188652992249,
-0.034509945660829544,
-1.1495683193206787,
-0.2733845114707947,
0.1876329630613327,
-0.5765268802642822,
-0.07639314979314804,
-0.6021023392677307,
-0.38730016350746155,
0.040208812803030014,
-0.22237169742584229,
-0.7938311696052551,
-0.034358758479356766,
0.025189971551299095,
0.6390318870544434,
-0.6416345834732056,
0.5089111328125,
0.15224775671958923,
-0.4488896131515503,
-0.5962116122245789,
0.00004724760583485477,
0.06429586559534073,
-0.6835649609565735,
0.6491121649742126,
0.09985644370317459,
-0.13295090198516846,
-0.620073676109314,
-0.06005151942372322,
-0.6415289640426636,
0.8798913955688477,
0.3740737736225128,
-0.8087415099143982,
-0.03999165818095207,
0.7239415645599365,
1.0523144006729126,
-0.2815510630607605,
0.03499678522348404,
0.8173054456710815,
0.5562514662742615,
-0.15409688651561737,
-0.9093073010444641,
0.0680726170539856,
-0.5480449795722961,
0.1337215006351471,
0.08407003432512283,
-0.44153693318367004,
0.6169986128807068,
-0.19301088154315948,
-0.6779402494430542,
0.20727457106113434,
0.25580430030822754,
0.34851452708244324,
0.30121758580207825,
0.28538429737091064,
0.39025604724884033,
0.6243486404418945,
-0.037204839289188385,
1.24481999874115,
-0.5032278895378113,
0.17079810798168182,
1.2512298822402954,
-0.6612786054611206,
1.0802792310714722,
0.3452725410461426,
-0.33061331510543823,
0.4753517210483551,
0.3202299177646637,
-0.22340093553066254,
0.36105993390083313,
0.6459144949913025,
-0.16722846031188965,
0.12273377180099487,
-0.2386689931154251,
-0.3051401376724243,
0.3199450373649597,
0.4120301902294159,
-0.5178760886192322,
-0.2545296847820282,
-0.2917938232421875,
-0.41209876537323,
0.1447932869195938,
0.18402855098247528,
0.8070321679115295,
0.08898581564426422,
-0.5535147786140442,
0.4607946276664734,
-0.056376539170742035,
0.022657504305243492,
-0.4267134368419647,
-0.03443878889083862,
-0.24217213690280914,
0.3337695598602295,
-0.4773560166358948,
-0.8563522696495056,
0.4733799695968628,
0.19125735759735107,
0.10888247936964035,
-0.18755514919757843,
0.38511043787002563,
-0.5092712044715881,
-0.5818262100219727,
0.1827777922153473,
0.626605212688446,
0.049773432314395905,
0.22792135179042816,
-0.6127610802650452,
0.28251785039901733,
-0.34142860770225525,
-0.3395617604255676,
0.18742305040359497,
-0.009224982932209969,
-0.23733338713645935,
0.4383130967617035,
1.0155620574951172,
0.48087161779403687,
0.04161285236477852,
0.37942954897880554,
0.8276379108428955,
-0.34154361486434937,
-0.4849832355976105,
-0.8083437085151672,
0.6486278176307678,
-0.16897426545619965,
-0.3876081705093384,
1.1612248420715332,
0.9277271032333374,
0.8084622025489807,
0.011962318792939186,
0.8259221911430359,
0.0976470336318016,
0.43502748012542725,
-0.4499738812446594,
1.0069223642349243,
-0.14683453738689423,
0.5411871075630188,
-0.26003217697143555,
-1.381583571434021,
-0.21472157537937164,
0.4532569646835327,
-0.3861699104309082,
0.04141923040151596,
0.6289851665496826,
1.108622431755066,
-0.08297132700681686,
0.2196827232837677,
0.08555391430854797,
0.3157489001750946,
0.35733896493911743,
0.24450981616973877,
1.2357563972473145,
-0.32383835315704346,
0.23871101438999176,
-0.07988210767507553,
-0.029411587864160538,
0.4177255928516388,
-0.7031580805778503,
-0.7704458236694336,
-0.39909887313842773,
-0.15360252559185028,
-0.44104522466659546,
0.1850191205739975,
0.756386399269104,
0.7967469692230225,
-0.9304022192955017,
-0.40117406845092773,
-0.17614109814167023,
-0.2636619210243225,
0.18079963326454163,
-0.2539871335029602,
0.4496992826461792,
-0.33208170533180237,
-0.5326040387153625,
0.5974105596542358,
0.36914992332458496,
-0.08158241212368011,
-0.769561767578125,
0.04603811353445053,
0.578770101070404,
0.11178204417228699,
0.6524398922920227,
0.10355211794376373,
-0.739697277545929,
-0.03100235015153885,
0.017493950203061104,
0.19121289253234863,
0.000758933019824326,
0.8243053555488586,
-0.8231064081192017,
0.716758131980896,
0.7390305995941162,
0.7123129367828369,
0.6441993713378906,
0.26111069321632385,
0.8624367713928223,
-0.7803088426589966,
-0.1894722729921341,
0.33347606658935547,
0.24725162982940674,
0.5080644488334656,
-0.17487652599811554,
0.3328697085380554,
-0.345906525850296,
-0.6508626937866211,
-1.1007729768753052,
0.01609409973025322,
-0.8883920907974243,
0.20287470519542694,
1.070590853691101,
-0.14878331124782562,
-0.3510991930961609,
0.2550923824310303,
-0.03683000057935715,
-0.22005435824394226,
-0.4459836483001709,
0.9821308255195618,
0.31915175914764404,
0.006069751922041178,
0.28969165682792664,
-0.5476121306419373,
0.7394695281982422,
0.061202120035886765,
-1.3034619092941284,
0.382085382938385,
0.6895157098770142,
0.2387411892414093,
0.14231924712657928,
0.10294371098279953,
-0.6003314852714539,
0.12960442900657654,
0.07440586388111115,
-0.23380005359649658,
-0.10905864089727402,
-0.7042353749275208,
-0.17881931364536285,
0.2724612355232239,
-0.007685183547437191,
-0.07370826601982117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13307v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13307v1
|
Beyond Accuracy: Investigating Error Types in GPT-4 Responses to USMLE Questions
| 2024-04-20T07:29:06 | 2024-04-20T07:29:06 |
Soumyadeep Roy, Aparup Khatua, Fatemeh Ghoochani, Uwe Hadler, Wolfgang Nejdl, Niloy Ganguly
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
GPT-4 demonstrates high accuracy in medical QA tasks, leading with an
accuracy of 86.70%, followed by Med-PaLM 2 at 86.50%. However, around 14% of
errors remain. Additionally, current works use GPT-4 to only predict the
correct option without providing any explanation and thus do not provide any
insight into the thinking process and reasoning used by GPT-4 or other LLMs.
Therefore, we introduce a new domain-specific error taxonomy derived from
collaboration with medical students. Our GPT-4 USMLE Error (G4UE) dataset
comprises 4153 GPT-4 correct responses and 919 incorrect responses to the
United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) respectively. These
responses are quite long (258 words on average), containing detailed
explanations from GPT-4 justifying the selected option. We then launch a
large-scale annotation study using the Potato annotation platform and recruit
44 medical experts through Prolific, a well-known crowdsourcing platform. We
annotated 300 out of these 919 incorrect data points at a granular level for
different classes and created a multi-label span to identify the reasons behind
the error. In our annotated dataset, a substantial portion of GPT-4's incorrect
responses is categorized as a "Reasonable response by GPT-4," by annotators.
This sheds light on the challenge of discerning explanations that may lead to
incorrect options, even among trained medical professionals. We also provide
medical concepts and medical semantic predications extracted using the SemRep
tool for every data point. We believe that it will aid in evaluating the
ability of LLMs to answer complex medical questions. We make the resources
available at https://github.com/roysoumya/usmle-gpt4-error-taxonomy .
|
[
-0.10618171095848083,
-0.6733732223510742,
0.8728393316268921,
0.014594824984669685,
-0.013033749535679817,
0.27743107080459595,
0.1663658171892166,
-0.5681705474853516,
0.021663226187229156,
0.1615060716867447,
-0.33359530568122864,
-0.4222201108932495,
-0.7791208624839783,
0.42076927423477173,
0.048349592834711075,
0.931037187576294,
-0.35161441564559937,
0.2819383144378662,
-0.20023325085639954,
-0.3008696436882019,
-0.5517169833183289,
-0.7126510143280029,
-0.5641092658042908,
-0.0780225396156311,
0.7154128551483154,
0.4097338318824768,
0.6448258757591248,
0.291759729385376,
0.7629529237747192,
0.21494600176811218,
0.36643970012664795,
0.12068626284599304,
-0.19701151549816132,
-0.2687113583087921,
-0.20256005227565765,
-0.4477916657924652,
-0.8544078469276428,
0.41191452741622925,
0.22196455299854279,
0.5141127109527588,
-0.08985965698957443,
0.08060276508331299,
-0.25596773624420166,
0.550202488899231,
-0.3772241771221161,
0.1938020884990692,
-0.37725740671157837,
0.07179028540849686,
-0.44309473037719727,
-0.408504456281662,
-0.20537883043289185,
-0.5316640734672546,
0.2865445017814636,
-0.7614333629608154,
0.40080341696739197,
-0.16926978528499603,
0.9172777533531189,
0.4311399459838867,
-0.31335023045539856,
-0.29953449964523315,
-0.4207559823989868,
0.3053649663925171,
-0.8216415047645569,
0.19551806151866913,
0.42993631958961487,
0.34489697217941284,
-0.051366567611694336,
-0.9191282391548157,
-0.5565881133079529,
0.04840444028377533,
0.04248407110571861,
0.36160221695899963,
0.015244408510625362,
0.33439546823501587,
0.3676234781742096,
0.3110692799091339,
-0.560665488243103,
-0.03312229737639427,
-0.42613404989242554,
-0.3601172864437103,
0.5021213293075562,
0.010463309474289417,
0.38988301157951355,
0.1856120526790619,
-0.21915976703166962,
0.19788475334644318,
-0.7061391472816467,
-0.09660190343856812,
0.06627219170331955,
-0.18382766842842102,
0.1958068609237671,
0.5744160413742065,
0.13773830235004425,
0.6937952041625977,
0.11166742444038391,
-0.009076829999685287,
0.6378850340843201,
-0.5415036678314209,
-0.20693926513195038,
-0.15944485366344452,
0.6362261772155762,
0.7120721340179443,
0.13360391557216644,
-0.0014742085477337241,
-0.21727433800697327,
0.21825359761714935,
0.4718658924102783,
-0.5158113837242126,
-0.3422500491142273,
0.4781830310821533,
-0.07901627570390701,
-0.11557754129171371,
-0.14292222261428833,
-0.6186614632606506,
-0.33015018701553345,
-0.11618021130561829,
0.6525636911392212,
-0.41683635115623474,
-0.0660325288772583,
0.20201709866523743,
-0.040304820984601974,
0.15401503443717957,
0.5012681484222412,
-0.6758537888526917,
0.36907759308815,
0.43740272521972656,
0.7156023979187012,
-0.259697824716568,
-0.30351221561431885,
-0.2997729480266571,
-0.060223180800676346,
-0.5217235684394836,
0.8312642574310303,
-0.31236836314201355,
-0.43109115958213806,
-0.1304740309715271,
0.033417314291000366,
-0.19300179183483124,
-0.5682569742202759,
0.6952876448631287,
-0.4696636497974396,
0.2563595473766327,
-0.5641931891441345,
-0.8039214015007019,
-0.40653759241104126,
0.36486148834228516,
-0.5024093985557556,
0.771917998790741,
0.39638155698776245,
-0.7743356823921204,
0.556134819984436,
-0.9953442215919495,
0.038084425032138824,
0.1986030489206314,
-0.44363442063331604,
-0.4445227086544037,
-0.06958089023828506,
0.12024322897195816,
0.4553084075450897,
-0.17676131427288055,
0.5159105658531189,
-0.10514777153730392,
-0.2879577577114105,
0.35273298621177673,
-0.20136480033397675,
0.6068868637084961,
-0.09655240923166275,
-0.5030099153518677,
0.06486111879348755,
-0.6044391989707947,
0.03430168703198433,
0.20699959993362427,
-0.16824816167354584,
-0.04585344344377518,
-0.3257114887237549,
-0.31148478388786316,
0.25645163655281067,
0.18921135365962982,
-0.6225767731666565,
0.2712133824825287,
-0.014201875776052475,
0.35017305612564087,
0.6407504081726074,
0.17846736311912537,
0.16580939292907715,
-0.39736050367355347,
0.8233588933944702,
-0.01568988710641861,
0.5755764842033386,
0.1830577552318573,
-0.9920976758003235,
-0.17744849622249603,
-0.0023959665559232235,
0.406876802444458,
0.6415829658508301,
-0.7714569568634033,
0.15778635442256927,
-0.2291785329580307,
-0.41174718737602234,
-0.5483506917953491,
-0.11908116191625595,
0.3939564526081085,
0.9823811650276184,
0.6202446818351746,
-0.39079686999320984,
-0.5231037139892578,
-0.7698808312416077,
-0.19025415182113647,
-0.2423621416091919,
0.07246825098991394,
0.3324449956417084,
0.5416867733001709,
-0.6180729866027832,
0.7878027558326721,
-0.43212488293647766,
-0.22865243256092072,
0.1261066347360611,
0.0947871282696724,
0.14060504734516144,
0.2793275713920593,
0.4347623586654663,
-0.7760514616966248,
-0.2951423227787018,
-0.15363359451293945,
-0.5932973027229309,
-0.29658061265945435,
-0.1267438530921936,
0.010208521038293839,
0.377941370010376,
-0.045094072818756104,
-0.500580370426178,
0.33071428537368774,
0.5668809413909912,
-0.39281466603279114,
0.571543276309967,
-0.3513730764389038,
0.3754912316799164,
-0.7187342047691345,
-0.12199296057224274,
0.06269951164722443,
0.049106936901807785,
-0.5185756683349609,
-0.07839321345090866,
0.23080645501613617,
0.5307888984680176,
-0.14916035532951355,
0.31952276825904846,
-0.36393076181411743,
-0.2298250049352646,
0.09383709728717804,
0.07012701779603958,
0.11430267244577408,
0.137891948223114,
-0.13019859790802002,
0.8769466280937195,
0.4609937369823456,
-0.08664102107286453,
0.43286260962486267,
0.2944725453853607,
0.3106779158115387,
0.6615698337554932,
-0.40311747789382935,
0.08189993351697922,
0.20565901696681976,
0.38011807203292847,
-0.9937052130699158,
-0.6735212206840515,
0.4428498446941376,
-0.6307292580604553,
0.47624436020851135,
-0.11541412770748138,
-0.31043532490730286,
-0.6844251155853271,
-0.42048412561416626,
0.4019260108470917,
0.3712739646434784,
-0.2815036177635193,
0.4312548339366913,
0.4597141742706299,
-0.17743568122386932,
-0.7268149256706238,
-0.595441997051239,
0.17346784472465515,
-0.10493454337120056,
-0.5091302990913391,
0.08034534007310867,
-0.3075217306613922,
-0.09231802821159363,
-0.16001880168914795,
-0.3209243714809418,
-0.4560699164867401,
-0.03460775315761566,
0.20651085674762726,
0.4986377954483032,
-0.26183754205703735,
0.22391346096992493,
-0.24004818499088287,
-0.05283355712890625,
0.3354843258857727,
0.0206963699311018,
0.15431711077690125,
-0.27402928471565247,
-0.41985180974006653,
-0.48822084069252014,
0.05207691714167595,
0.4073973000049591,
0.06966985017061234,
0.06200354918837547,
0.4547158181667328,
-0.3425872325897217,
0.44180741906166077,
-0.6764989495277405,
-0.24007195234298706,
-0.38121330738067627,
0.34209415316581726,
-0.40440815687179565,
-0.7848687767982483,
0.5465698838233948,
0.2921229898929596,
0.214441180229187,
0.5980406999588013,
0.3017711937427521,
-0.2117343544960022,
0.6843910217285156,
0.1265357881784439,
0.3945792019367218,
-0.27743449807167053,
-0.197772815823555,
0.06231086328625679,
-0.6782053112983704,
-0.3306180238723755,
-0.23298907279968262,
-0.09425807744264603,
-0.5255004167556763,
-0.8693561553955078,
0.35926324129104614,
-0.26583147048950195,
-0.3152509033679962,
-0.17691031098365784,
-0.6448599100112915,
0.32109978795051575,
0.4615575671195984,
0.08717852830886841,
0.2590682804584503,
-0.2306879609823227,
0.11282968521118164,
-0.22298890352249146,
-0.6376019716262817,
-0.49666136503219604,
1.4251724481582642,
0.5474341511726379,
0.39090946316719055,
0.1030864417552948,
0.7099865674972534,
0.08821680396795273,
0.7726170420646667,
-0.8740651607513428,
0.21468909084796906,
0.026970116421580315,
-0.8311094045639038,
-0.3001476228237152,
-0.37933075428009033,
-0.7158958315849304,
-0.04479191452264786,
-0.14277899265289307,
-0.34693214297294617,
-0.08642742037773132,
0.34676140546798706,
-0.5315727591514587,
0.3021003305912018,
-0.8008049130439758,
0.9614263772964478,
-0.39319220185279846,
-0.04519716277718544,
0.328031063079834,
-1.1815255880355835,
0.38157641887664795,
-0.6308565735816956,
0.34563586115837097,
-0.055337853729724884,
-0.47235026955604553,
0.612739622592926,
-0.41445380449295044,
0.7945128679275513,
-0.2825303077697754,
-0.19762136042118073,
0.29021158814430237,
-0.207843616604805,
0.3496643006801605,
0.05841047316789627,
0.16933107376098633,
0.46412360668182373,
0.15258876979351044,
-0.5137757062911987,
-0.5793949961662292,
0.3074037432670593,
-0.7522030472755432,
-0.49216166138648987,
-0.6738545894622803,
-0.29228243231773376,
-0.512019157409668,
0.08250930160284042,
0.5373137593269348,
0.5300580859184265,
0.16138723492622375,
-0.4381532371044159,
0.5490533709526062,
-0.09777837991714478,
0.07515649497509003,
0.48759305477142334,
-0.05458955466747284,
-0.34406232833862305,
0.6830646395683289,
0.4920092821121216,
0.14326068758964539,
0.07442726194858551,
0.16125480830669403,
-0.6703967452049255,
-0.9729597568511963,
-0.7199599742889404,
0.4401831030845642,
-0.7360115647315979,
-0.22568605840206146,
-0.7040693163871765,
-0.10219025611877441,
-0.19108495116233826,
-0.03881487995386124,
-0.19117537140846252,
-0.3330055773258209,
-0.2963916063308716,
-0.487801194190979,
0.45135408639907837,
0.9337878823280334,
-0.039461757987737656,
0.1588372439146042,
-1.0642377138137817,
0.09818731248378754,
0.1757572889328003,
0.4322803020477295,
-0.6460965871810913,
-0.5889518857002258,
0.0877651572227478,
-0.0642232671380043,
-0.25787678360939026,
-1.0911527872085571,
0.0024565791245549917,
0.1188729777932167,
0.5038860440254211,
0.16620709002017975,
-0.22125357389450073,
0.6505608558654785,
-0.6226268410682678,
1.0548094511032104,
0.23962470889091492,
-0.7746954560279846,
0.37372466921806335,
-0.4169304370880127,
-0.1875118613243103,
0.491266131401062,
0.5720069408416748,
-0.3166290521621704,
-0.39338499307632446,
-1.0201570987701416,
-0.8226019740104675,
0.28267866373062134,
0.07861079275608063,
-0.12348459661006927,
-0.19360539317131042,
0.7558547258377075,
0.3116512596607208,
-0.026914875954389572,
-0.5932794213294983,
-0.3297000825405121,
-0.2120281606912613,
-0.23369470238685608,
-0.22459059953689575,
-0.37385356426239014,
-0.3350403606891632,
-0.1648094654083252,
0.6662024855613708,
-0.32118192315101624,
0.17420077323913574,
0.5343323349952698,
0.09824486821889877,
-0.07387932389974594,
0.2768067419528961,
0.8855466246604919,
1.2037979364395142,
-0.3543332815170288,
0.3087356388568878,
0.2033616453409195,
-0.9495744705200195,
0.3229351341724396,
0.32631728053092957,
0.2958333492279053,
0.10036497563123703,
0.3206089735031128,
0.13673537969589233,
-0.06758685410022736,
-0.5889015197753906,
0.8745310306549072,
-0.27300113439559937,
-0.3404446542263031,
-0.41616949439048767,
-0.2186337262392044,
0.020067868754267693,
-0.03541532903909683,
0.3385556936264038,
0.2217267006635666,
0.4483594596385956,
-0.13398072123527527,
0.47744184732437134,
0.06167490407824516,
-0.3428111970424652,
-0.5492969751358032,
0.6919600367546082,
0.2845900058746338,
0.17739316821098328,
0.24752923846244812,
-0.245004341006279,
-0.34716543555259705,
0.49979081749916077,
0.392166405916214,
0.5225641131401062,
-0.30208998918533325,
0.44361987709999084,
0.32274189591407776,
0.10743354260921478,
-0.30904221534729004,
0.5533227920532227,
0.5449659824371338,
-0.7737190127372742,
-0.8415774703025818,
-0.12540224194526672,
-0.6010544300079346,
0.1441832035779953,
-0.5052820444107056,
-0.20733480155467987,
-0.5592004656791687,
-0.48793429136276245,
-0.029615063220262527,
-0.054056309163570404,
-0.32543471455574036,
0.518140435218811,
-0.009600557386875153,
0.8010696768760681,
-0.8162591457366943,
0.531875491142273,
1.1107370853424072,
-0.5123957395553589,
-1.1984533071517944,
-0.1288711428642273,
0.22199353575706482,
-0.9080643057823181,
0.6196597814559937,
0.01763632334768772,
0.04651930183172226,
-0.10583453625440598,
-0.5169878005981445,
-0.6026452779769897,
1.031264066696167,
0.038138166069984436,
-0.5083371996879578,
-0.07516613602638245,
0.015546838752925396,
0.5358054637908936,
-0.16798920929431915,
0.35301798582077026,
0.801336944103241,
0.3786739706993103,
0.16660133004188538,
-1.1003320217132568,
0.25518155097961426,
0.05953960493206978,
-0.15601453185081482,
0.19305747747421265,
-0.28171586990356445,
0.6836767792701721,
-0.5314348340034485,
0.20104144513607025,
-0.09574124962091446,
-0.06431758403778076,
0.32331958413124084,
0.6024618148803711,
0.26429247856140137,
0.6253950595855713,
1.0540194511413574,
-0.32032352685928345,
1.0775935649871826,
0.08047153800725937,
0.38156822323799133,
0.9833633899688721,
-0.18676051497459412,
0.6047057509422302,
0.5262107253074646,
-0.46048983931541443,
0.21121619641780853,
1.0358068943023682,
0.103021539747715,
0.0994701087474823,
0.15788982808589935,
-0.3906879127025604,
-0.013527415692806244,
0.28884124755859375,
-0.4473825693130493,
0.15365388989448547,
0.6013818979263306,
-0.2723214626312256,
0.028373030945658684,
-0.23725152015686035,
0.0789862871170044,
-0.17635808885097504,
-0.33199331164360046,
0.550992488861084,
-0.02685457654297352,
-0.42191335558891296,
0.6278886795043945,
-0.46711862087249756,
0.5567821264266968,
-0.2520712912082672,
-0.2985357642173767,
-0.2261100709438324,
-0.023058442398905754,
-0.5032196640968323,
-1.0472034215927124,
0.18476754426956177,
-0.12258444726467133,
0.025119667872786522,
0.046586181968450546,
0.42405468225479126,
-0.10786765813827515,
-0.11896557360887527,
-0.03785507380962372,
0.5035969018936157,
0.5126770734786987,
-0.044135160744190216,
-0.9240223169326782,
-0.08185652643442154,
0.16432729363441467,
-0.018241139128804207,
-0.060665152966976166,
0.5403762459754944,
-0.11273372173309326,
0.4715350866317749,
0.3881062865257263,
0.2641461491584778,
0.22662825882434845,
0.04291042312979698,
0.6107794046401978,
-0.46497371792793274,
-0.16373513638973236,
-0.6564728617668152,
0.6282428503036499,
-0.08493893593549728,
-0.3410860300064087,
0.4439173936843872,
0.42072322964668274,
0.6219921708106995,
-0.11048627644777298,
0.9085745811462402,
0.16394825279712677,
0.7625144720077515,
-0.41015270352363586,
0.28280365467071533,
-0.43385255336761475,
0.3402169942855835,
-0.31344953179359436,
-0.6868195533752441,
-0.6588606238365173,
0.4992532730102539,
-0.3605700135231018,
0.24131804704666138,
0.8083198666572571,
0.4662177264690399,
0.1687641590833664,
0.15593543648719788,
0.4535338878631592,
0.5036233067512512,
0.3790225088596344,
0.5369070768356323,
0.7235885262489319,
-0.3790381848812103,
0.314237117767334,
-0.10480237752199173,
-0.5031915903091431,
-0.3299088776111603,
-0.6244328022003174,
-0.5746294260025024,
-0.332014262676239,
-0.5429164171218872,
-0.7106448411941528,
0.060527730733156204,
0.8074930310249329,
0.3387354612350464,
-0.694354772567749,
0.34029465913772583,
-0.05393137037754059,
-0.21068960428237915,
0.14937689900398254,
-0.1967228651046753,
0.5340334177017212,
-0.4233371317386627,
-0.4123564660549164,
-0.014085456728935242,
0.33927077054977417,
0.38146743178367615,
0.20924049615859985,
-0.06464316695928574,
0.06644318997859955,
-0.1467922329902649,
0.3886074423789978,
0.3063373267650604,
-0.7328565716743469,
-0.5948286652565002,
0.0014592853840440512,
-0.23924148082733154,
0.494346559047699,
0.5435417890548706,
-0.2616758346557617,
0.6302440762519836,
0.022901564836502075,
0.8155810236930847,
0.07423237711191177,
0.24788403511047363,
0.5341020822525024,
-0.4537365436553955,
-0.4443952739238739,
0.5454860925674438,
0.4192572236061096,
0.5104871988296509,
-0.43897539377212524,
0.858853816986084,
0.5946301817893982,
-0.8408533930778503,
-0.4536561667919159,
0.06552502512931824,
-1.07452392578125,
-0.17321430146694183,
1.201223611831665,
-0.41577622294425964,
-0.01710628531873226,
-0.5005194544792175,
-0.4864215552806854,
0.08606801182031631,
-0.32957714796066284,
0.6385520696640015,
0.6247371435165405,
-0.6669558882713318,
-0.029948074370622635,
-1.105462670326233,
0.8487261533737183,
0.2754141092300415,
-0.9959462285041809,
-0.1831914633512497,
0.8429018259048462,
0.7484456896781921,
0.3577592372894287,
1.1710548400878906,
-0.2552628815174103,
0.6377274990081787,
-0.1910526007413864,
0.13507500290870667,
0.18384599685668945,
0.07690257579088211,
-0.36240354180336,
-0.13609705865383148,
0.41597339510917664,
-0.3475969433784485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13292v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13292v1
|
Evaluating Subword Tokenization: Alien Subword Composition and OOV Generalization Challenge
| 2024-04-20T06:49:15 | 2024-04-20T06:49:15 |
Khuyagbaatar Batsuren, Ekaterina Vylomova, Verna Dankers, Tsetsuukhei Delgerbaatar, Omri Uzan, Yuval Pinter, Gábor Bella
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The popular subword tokenizers of current language models, such as Byte-Pair
Encoding (BPE), are known not to respect morpheme boundaries, which affects the
downstream performance of the models. While many improved tokenization
algorithms have been proposed, their evaluation and cross-comparison is still
an open problem. As a solution, we propose a combined intrinsic-extrinsic
evaluation framework for subword tokenization. Intrinsic evaluation is based on
our new UniMorph Labeller tool that classifies subword tokenization as either
morphological or alien. Extrinsic evaluation, in turn, is performed via the
Out-of-Vocabulary Generalization Challenge 1.0 benchmark, which consists of
three newly specified downstream text classification tasks. Our empirical
findings show that the accuracy of UniMorph Labeller is 98%, and that, in all
language models studied (including ALBERT, BERT, RoBERTa, and DeBERTa), alien
tokenization leads to poorer generalizations compared to morphological
tokenization for semantic compositionality of word meanings.
|
[
-0.20915567874908447,
-0.6595758199691772,
0.201655775308609,
-0.1221642941236496,
-0.7563394904136658,
0.30407169461250305,
-0.27356910705566406,
-0.5863138437271118,
0.13884174823760986,
0.1559540033340454,
-0.29424530267715454,
-0.5576850771903992,
-0.7849069833755493,
0.06800999492406845,
-0.3587108552455902,
1.0038251876831055,
-0.07629220187664032,
0.10006608068943024,
-0.30920785665512085,
-0.315422922372818,
-0.4801464080810547,
-0.6550135016441345,
-0.3582998216152191,
-0.37191903591156006,
0.12278903275728226,
-0.1285107135772705,
0.5220479965209961,
0.5483263731002808,
0.7990726232528687,
0.34260088205337524,
-0.4022027552127838,
-0.07232444733381271,
-0.32316431403160095,
0.03195451200008392,
-0.7173885107040405,
-0.26269182562828064,
-0.1233019232749939,
-0.14432932436466217,
0.5963289737701416,
0.8995160460472107,
-0.04399610310792923,
0.21183867752552032,
-0.42617058753967285,
0.5923576951026917,
-0.6035254597663879,
0.02175070531666279,
-0.8194581270217896,
0.15505008399486542,
-0.12944158911705017,
0.03307099640369415,
-0.3413325846195221,
0.04171166941523552,
0.16475620865821838,
-0.2433052659034729,
0.12887042760849,
0.26889568567276,
0.4422418177127838,
0.1831435114145279,
-0.1792335957288742,
-0.49029919505119324,
-0.469517320394516,
0.6438584923744202,
-0.6095418334007263,
0.5568631887435913,
-0.2289489060640335,
-0.1356327086687088,
-0.11906728893518448,
-0.6601784825325012,
-0.5714393854141235,
-0.3533666729927063,
-0.030973078683018684,
0.278266042470932,
-0.6355469822883606,
0.08933869004249573,
-0.32821211218833923,
0.7698209285736084,
-0.43910011649131775,
0.24254663288593292,
-0.6010638475418091,
-0.20340271294116974,
0.34169527888298035,
0.07718726992607117,
0.4832040071487427,
-0.13491766154766083,
-0.5638121366500854,
0.0827164277434349,
-0.5078853368759155,
0.14298276603221893,
0.4288160502910614,
0.2602384686470032,
0.03762070834636688,
1.0006943941116333,
-0.018263665959239006,
0.3771843910217285,
0.1062503308057785,
0.2665693461894989,
0.3227003216743469,
-0.6012238264083862,
0.0010097731137648225,
0.03205548971891403,
0.6929121017456055,
0.42542725801467896,
-0.13715918362140656,
-0.4798508882522583,
-0.27317672967910767,
0.31482475996017456,
0.19611035287380219,
-0.6344140768051147,
0.12390483170747757,
0.46600574254989624,
-0.6281716227531433,
-0.0716550350189209,
0.37452226877212524,
-0.45897969603538513,
-0.32330596446990967,
-0.2069058120250702,
0.41834115982055664,
-0.5464558601379395,
-0.191094771027565,
0.15184825658798218,
-0.5361671447753906,
0.053703803569078445,
-0.08970467746257782,
-0.9644942879676819,
0.33726415038108826,
1.0040351152420044,
0.9021976590156555,
-0.49506059288978577,
-0.2750954031944275,
-0.53578782081604,
-0.12158263474702835,
-0.3776654303073883,
0.8757174015045166,
-0.9296775460243225,
-0.7562453150749207,
-0.19956006109714508,
-0.16637389361858368,
-0.14225053787231445,
-0.7117418050765991,
0.4581821858882904,
-0.30275702476501465,
0.07332929968833923,
0.19194790720939636,
-0.7247153520584106,
-0.1042315885424614,
0.11143583059310913,
-0.2601427137851715,
1.1152989864349365,
0.5804157853126526,
-0.6035261154174805,
0.46653276681900024,
-0.8273961544036865,
-0.29974254965782166,
0.368524968624115,
-0.1201489269733429,
0.01495057437568903,
0.8040458559989929,
-0.04068274050951004,
0.06805194169282913,
-0.25136736035346985,
-0.05540304630994797,
0.14595112204551697,
-0.5940884947776794,
0.24722231924533844,
-0.07811203598976135,
0.4592078924179077,
-0.18132741749286652,
-0.6266766786575317,
0.38080912828445435,
-0.6897913217544556,
0.03364567831158638,
-0.22671176493167877,
-0.5182976126670837,
-0.5996350049972534,
-0.043958332389593124,
-0.08684414625167847,
-0.16749578714370728,
0.3650870621204376,
-1.1003811359405518,
0.19864289462566376,
-0.5642188191413879,
0.4779188334941864,
0.7352033257484436,
-0.22377018630504608,
0.4586758017539978,
0.1517735868692398,
0.4590575098991394,
0.32210126519203186,
0.2535630166530609,
-0.14391885697841644,
-0.5101946592330933,
-0.7498144507408142,
-0.35593920946121216,
0.39403414726257324,
0.5348645448684692,
-0.5561965107917786,
0.7244826555252075,
-0.5763330459594727,
-0.8032834529876709,
-0.4655483663082123,
0.03010530211031437,
0.8192249536514282,
0.27679356932640076,
0.5983664393424988,
-0.616606593132019,
-0.40742558240890503,
-0.7417011260986328,
-0.37438344955444336,
-0.5110227465629578,
-0.009041795507073402,
0.20173168182373047,
0.7239969968795776,
-0.5890905857086182,
0.8176839351654053,
-0.15295636653900146,
-0.5013947486877441,
-0.3201797604560852,
0.602554440498352,
0.3109477758407593,
0.7416450381278992,
0.4151126742362976,
-0.5558311939239502,
-0.4781509041786194,
0.5583418011665344,
-0.2696917951107025,
-0.013152112253010273,
0.3273763656616211,
0.10611145943403244,
0.3803217113018036,
0.5749945640563965,
-0.45453235507011414,
0.42285576462745667,
0.5748195052146912,
-0.446010947227478,
0.2721100449562073,
-0.3555371165275574,
-0.06615335494279861,
-0.6271962523460388,
0.14880797266960144,
-0.36164143681526184,
0.18616607785224915,
-0.5044277310371399,
0.45164501667022705,
-0.14425870776176453,
0.026793884113430977,
-0.6232252717018127,
0.6017544865608215,
-0.533765971660614,
0.07023303210735321,
-0.22848030924797058,
0.06194059178233147,
-0.3643430769443512,
0.4223168194293976,
0.25836291909217834,
0.5453099608421326,
0.5667456984519958,
-0.4646405577659607,
0.6977192759513855,
0.10836180299520493,
-0.45164695382118225,
0.6297966241836548,
-0.9987939596176147,
0.5302974581718445,
-0.5255064368247986,
0.1643354594707489,
-0.9627942442893982,
0.2005242556333542,
0.46673181653022766,
-0.5751497149467468,
0.29453662037849426,
-0.11686599254608154,
-0.17004337906837463,
-0.16727511584758759,
-0.541774332523346,
0.6176702380180359,
0.5366668105125427,
-0.382183313369751,
0.9616798758506775,
0.2293424904346466,
-0.04300658032298088,
-0.5237506628036499,
-0.6881803274154663,
0.091341532766819,
0.01726217195391655,
-0.3506597578525543,
0.60628342628479,
-0.031114066019654274,
-0.2421560287475586,
0.5160914063453674,
-0.21301408112049103,
0.22254514694213867,
-0.16820251941680908,
0.16978617012500763,
0.2005547732114792,
-0.19898030161857605,
-0.20039667189121246,
0.1898883581161499,
-0.23111753165721893,
-0.036953046917915344,
-0.583106279373169,
0.6706115007400513,
-0.2114311158657074,
-0.4769881069660187,
-0.044997718185186386,
0.6090238690376282,
0.41997015476226807,
-0.3302583694458008,
0.7509002089500427,
0.6803433895111084,
-0.34077244997024536,
0.09749545156955719,
-0.4288250803947449,
0.15998856723308563,
-0.37316960096359253,
0.6927303671836853,
-0.5026079416275024,
-0.9363730549812317,
0.521793782711029,
0.21127159893512726,
0.20994216203689575,
0.5579075813293457,
0.4984292984008789,
0.35267144441604614,
0.85349041223526,
0.5288764238357544,
0.16527840495109558,
0.2610549330711365,
-0.14900565147399902,
0.36073774099349976,
-1.2130165100097656,
-0.6351288557052612,
-0.4990053176879883,
-0.29104864597320557,
-0.599656343460083,
-0.5091582536697388,
0.30467337369918823,
-0.04850781336426735,
0.3524405062198639,
0.6897552609443665,
-0.5663309097290039,
0.4774891138076782,
0.6230673789978027,
-0.21284471452236176,
0.12116553634405136,
0.08501970022916794,
-0.3878503739833832,
0.04430161789059639,
-0.37256836891174316,
-0.39907190203666687,
0.8403038382530212,
0.3401848077774048,
0.6981852054595947,
0.23680655658245087,
0.4346592128276825,
0.39587435126304626,
0.5519677400588989,
-0.9803600311279297,
0.41266509890556335,
-0.6567220091819763,
-0.7245796918869019,
-0.2602037191390991,
-0.4394319951534271,
-0.8274071216583252,
0.5695381164550781,
-0.0936528742313385,
-1.0632573366165161,
0.4754508137702942,
-0.11335067451000214,
-0.30228546261787415,
0.2549264132976532,
-0.7083861231803894,
0.7816479206085205,
-0.15316832065582275,
0.0016600528033450246,
-0.12705571949481964,
-0.6307343244552612,
-0.015678228810429573,
-0.22358793020248413,
0.2065669149160385,
-0.058818917721509933,
-0.42211347818374634,
0.7939488291740417,
-0.44673624634742737,
0.5896447896957397,
-0.12238481640815735,
-0.11647506803274155,
0.3971322178840637,
-0.09805308282375336,
0.20701172947883606,
-0.05133340507745743,
-0.10988661646842957,
0.5323262810707092,
0.3134396970272064,
-0.21040388941764832,
-0.6648418307304382,
0.2950466573238373,
-0.6196199059486389,
-0.422455757856369,
-0.42555058002471924,
-0.1683531254529953,
-0.08927857130765915,
0.30257928371429443,
0.7260326147079468,
0.5768565535545349,
-0.366584837436676,
0.47666195034980774,
0.2655665874481201,
-0.2747558653354645,
0.24280589818954468,
0.5731498599052429,
-0.217675119638443,
-0.6678323745727539,
1.1214640140533447,
-0.040072545409202576,
0.07890060544013977,
0.8285341262817383,
0.5156763195991516,
-0.773622453212738,
-0.7899425625801086,
-0.4417991042137146,
0.04527119919657707,
-0.8468328714370728,
-0.007579058408737183,
-0.5989073514938354,
-0.0606188103556633,
-0.536011278629303,
0.04851245880126953,
-0.3916625678539276,
-0.20380766689777374,
-0.1456386297941208,
0.008318454958498478,
-0.18495407700538635,
0.9313340783119202,
-0.19679264724254608,
0.3144659996032715,
-1.0279245376586914,
0.10129742324352264,
0.12856072187423706,
0.13889344036579132,
-0.28439953923225403,
-0.8005222678184509,
-0.10316931456327438,
0.013447972014546394,
0.10504092276096344,
-0.5477304458618164,
-0.1331057995557785,
0.336723268032074,
0.7023881673812866,
0.5220583081245422,
-0.020459100604057312,
0.5819113850593567,
-0.473418653011322,
0.8885231018066406,
0.4492884576320648,
-1.5348705053329468,
0.2534966468811035,
0.04554786533117294,
0.11204933375120163,
0.7282527089118958,
0.14678509533405304,
-0.8020867109298706,
-0.3118583858013153,
-0.28236228227615356,
-1.0991851091384888,
0.4948720335960388,
0.22864389419555664,
0.6047260761260986,
-0.31547027826309204,
0.2977808117866516,
0.38442742824554443,
0.29873842000961304,
-0.6026272177696228,
-0.23077312111854553,
-0.23119772970676422,
-0.12723979353904724,
0.011621732264757156,
-0.4349139332771301,
0.2716747224330902,
-0.27402180433273315,
0.5557249784469604,
-0.09499959647655487,
0.355922669172287,
0.25942033529281616,
-0.16088348627090454,
0.027773795649409294,
0.3169453740119934,
0.6439915895462036,
0.5965926051139832,
-0.23679275810718536,
0.3403862416744232,
0.17809957265853882,
-0.599396824836731,
0.27420949935913086,
-0.11047597229480743,
-0.17008528113365173,
0.3070179224014282,
0.6133033633232117,
0.7498819828033447,
0.11570059508085251,
-0.9154632687568665,
0.6042285561561584,
-0.1541968286037445,
-0.08333129435777664,
-0.10629022866487503,
-0.09337800741195679,
-0.17899829149246216,
-0.1164645180106163,
0.3609510064125061,
0.05791674554347992,
0.1464681774377823,
-0.819122850894928,
-0.19036106765270233,
0.6530137062072754,
-0.7316398024559021,
-0.5576961040496826,
0.43933844566345215,
0.2748521864414215,
-0.2137768268585205,
0.5748373866081238,
-0.2558145523071289,
-0.8740929961204529,
0.4099394381046295,
0.5246532559394836,
0.9271966218948364,
-0.19015644490718842,
-0.05311364307999611,
0.11206482350826263,
0.6102855205535889,
0.3667667508125305,
0.4042513370513916,
-0.18049760162830353,
-0.6585286855697632,
-0.2686022222042084,
-0.6432456970214844,
-0.5167644619941711,
-0.07772333920001984,
-0.5635155439376831,
0.05897416174411774,
-0.3669057786464691,
-0.08755890280008316,
-0.022910086438059807,
-0.37899714708328247,
-0.2680937647819519,
0.31466805934906006,
-0.07564736157655716,
0.8533397912979126,
-0.5522417426109314,
0.21424666047096252,
1.3190698623657227,
-0.24089916050434113,
-0.21921060979366302,
-0.3269144594669342,
-0.4448277950286865,
-0.735718309879303,
0.883986234664917,
0.3207387924194336,
-0.3031994104385376,
-0.14008620381355286,
-0.11160784214735031,
-0.8033846616744995,
0.605273425579071,
0.21508824825286865,
-0.3668424189090729,
0.12190043181180954,
0.3860425353050232,
0.6891734004020691,
-0.38460156321525574,
0.46598514914512634,
0.482085645198822,
0.4519117474555969,
0.16443492472171783,
-0.8412294983863831,
0.0007874088478274643,
-0.6111507415771484,
0.3425586223602295,
0.2756834924221039,
-0.47630685567855835,
0.8209609389305115,
-0.004360121674835682,
-0.5302757620811462,
0.25477471947669983,
0.8277439475059509,
-0.21676461398601532,
0.05183437839150429,
0.6170927882194519,
0.6495898962020874,
0.3846301734447479,
-0.07379837334156036,
0.8470146656036377,
-0.390340656042099,
0.3080817461013794,
0.9707267880439758,
-0.1224379688501358,
0.8357225060462952,
0.6369005441665649,
-0.33107879757881165,
0.49958735704421997,
0.43988507986068726,
-0.026962753385305405,
0.42156320810317993,
0.4801817834377289,
-0.26343563199043274,
0.04929059371352196,
-0.5155112743377686,
-0.5078061819076538,
0.7780202031135559,
0.12371005117893219,
-0.2719807028770447,
-0.15599371492862701,
-0.08520034700632095,
-0.1851363480091095,
-0.08225808292627335,
-0.316577672958374,
0.7811588644981384,
-0.031809817999601364,
-0.7911228537559509,
0.25059273838996887,
0.5009639263153076,
0.8866881728172302,
-0.5639548897743225,
0.17087984085083008,
-0.3825419247150421,
0.39616483449935913,
-0.2603970170021057,
-0.42434564232826233,
0.5390800833702087,
0.07681512832641602,
0.09910329431295395,
0.09033651649951935,
0.40799427032470703,
-0.3186805248260498,
-0.5247889161109924,
0.3103368878364563,
0.254986971616745,
0.2600400745868683,
-0.16200143098831177,
-0.3457527756690979,
0.2209250032901764,
-0.313203364610672,
-0.02568335272371769,
0.021231435239315033,
0.308487206697464,
-0.011211730539798737,
0.3971903324127197,
0.7709653377532959,
0.05845249444246292,
0.3482121527194977,
0.052541036158800125,
0.8686355948448181,
-0.553335428237915,
-0.44434332847595215,
-1.1351314783096313,
0.42098939418792725,
0.12452882528305054,
-0.6834714412689209,
0.6455404162406921,
0.7993170619010925,
0.9602835774421692,
-0.2695068120956421,
0.6514540314674377,
-0.3275934159755707,
0.2932993471622467,
-0.47267451882362366,
0.2705135941505432,
-0.6078175902366638,
-0.05577833577990532,
-0.289485365152359,
-1.1616331338882446,
-0.10730663686990738,
0.443690687417984,
0.03363298624753952,
-0.044969409704208374,
1.0398883819580078,
0.4763375520706177,
0.03211142122745514,
-0.20620159804821014,
0.3292972147464752,
-0.19512270390987396,
0.15758953988552094,
0.3971075117588043,
1.2031408548355103,
-0.39728787541389465,
0.4029873013496399,
-0.33129677176475525,
-0.4498579204082489,
-0.005288492422550917,
-0.9496740102767944,
-1.1385917663574219,
-0.5649521946907043,
-0.4552743434906006,
-0.10032029449939728,
-0.07447009533643723,
1.0807931423187256,
0.5331103205680847,
-0.9455225467681885,
-0.012365737929940224,
-0.34834423661231995,
0.009820759296417236,
-0.3176981806755066,
-0.1950676292181015,
0.30010852217674255,
-0.14126180112361908,
-1.026982307434082,
0.3918057680130005,
0.7540801763534546,
0.13843686878681183,
-0.4167533218860626,
0.16871067881584167,
0.21315793693065643,
0.32600727677345276,
0.6386301517486572,
-0.04385892301797867,
-0.7861842513084412,
-0.31270870566368103,
0.1302676498889923,
0.14905111491680145,
-0.09918980300426483,
1.0543384552001953,
-0.4356401562690735,
0.40242886543273926,
0.8288495540618896,
0.575849175453186,
0.04919727146625519,
0.3224422335624695,
0.2686905860900879,
-0.5489983558654785,
0.11021788418292999,
0.19607029855251312,
0.4522897005081177,
0.29609882831573486,
-0.2874302268028259,
0.5920293927192688,
0.5431569218635559,
0.056930772960186005,
-0.8438202738761902,
0.26879802346229553,
-0.7838261723518372,
-0.38169682025909424,
1.093137264251709,
-0.35863614082336426,
-0.5162557363510132,
-0.2757198214530945,
-0.3407438397407532,
0.008327657356858253,
-0.31048205494880676,
0.5175817012786865,
0.6456276178359985,
-0.1779819279909134,
0.09547669440507889,
0.5220065116882324,
-0.14163726568222046,
0.6074286103248596,
-0.7080222368240356,
-0.15424810349941254,
0.1645173281431198,
0.13122540712356567,
0.6693646311759949,
0.5543263554573059,
-0.29085198044776917,
0.11668579280376434,
0.15446016192436218,
0.04015647619962692,
-0.2508387267589569,
-0.09074658900499344,
-0.32235321402549744,
0.011420611292123795,
-0.11948695033788681,
-0.3632827699184418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13289v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13289v1
|
Double Mixture: Towards Continual Event Detection from Speech
| 2024-04-20T06:32:00 | 2024-04-20T06:32:00 |
Jingqi Kang, Tongtong Wu, Jinming Zhao, Guitao Wang, Yinwei Wei, Hao Yang, Guilin Qi, Yuan-Fang Li, Gholamreza Haffari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.MM, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Speech event detection is crucial for multimedia retrieval, involving the
tagging of both semantic and acoustic events. Traditional ASR systems often
overlook the interplay between these events, focusing solely on content, even
though the interpretation of dialogue can vary with environmental context. This
paper tackles two primary challenges in speech event detection: the continual
integration of new events without forgetting previous ones, and the
disentanglement of semantic from acoustic events. We introduce a new task,
continual event detection from speech, for which we also provide two benchmark
datasets. To address the challenges of catastrophic forgetting and effective
disentanglement, we propose a novel method, 'Double Mixture.' This method
merges speech expertise with robust memory mechanisms to enhance adaptability
and prevent forgetting. Our comprehensive experiments show that this task
presents significant challenges that are not effectively addressed by current
state-of-the-art methods in either computer vision or natural language
processing. Our approach achieves the lowest rates of forgetting and the
highest levels of generalization, proving robust across various continual
learning sequences. Our code and data are available at
https://anonymous.4open.science/status/Continual-SpeechED-6461.
|
[
-0.1595977246761322,
-0.6513438820838928,
0.26919493079185486,
0.23579935729503632,
-0.3991190791130066,
0.4002937972545624,
-0.31211474537849426,
-0.4466632902622223,
0.09958036988973618,
0.3769555687904358,
-0.5163825154304504,
-0.10797359049320221,
-0.695449948310852,
-0.5255557894706726,
-0.600156307220459,
0.7308864593505859,
-0.0061337584629654884,
-0.10864032059907913,
-0.2594439685344696,
-0.5550438761711121,
-0.7938472628593445,
-0.486054390668869,
-1.1655889749526978,
-0.7743319869041443,
0.34526535868644714,
0.30020979046821594,
0.20269575715065002,
0.3785534203052521,
0.181544229388237,
0.23603564500808716,
-0.29663440585136414,
0.23520666360855103,
-0.4370860159397125,
0.5081488490104675,
-0.3728020191192627,
-0.37121254205703735,
0.16780376434326172,
-0.14379656314849854,
1.1857397556304932,
0.6360102295875549,
-0.40674126148223877,
-0.016102276742458344,
0.2666836380958557,
0.6971566677093506,
-0.6339150071144104,
-0.010382192209362984,
-0.9350956678390503,
0.25872546434402466,
-0.4749271869659424,
-0.1564393937587738,
-0.17800870537757874,
0.3491044044494629,
-0.023633260279893875,
-0.2332748919725418,
0.2318861484527588,
-0.2348634898662567,
0.5961378216743469,
0.6335657835006714,
-0.3727456331253052,
-0.44630172848701477,
-1.0201702117919922,
0.9057064056396484,
-0.19693998992443085,
0.48864904046058655,
0.44263944029808044,
0.204743891954422,
-0.2835340201854706,
-0.7709022760391235,
-1.0425232648849487,
-0.09398253262042999,
0.4757485091686249,
0.2614729106426239,
-0.4696120321750641,
-0.2140146791934967,
-0.16451464593410492,
0.301504522562027,
-0.7375339865684509,
0.25954529643058777,
-0.06763086467981339,
-0.4937764108181,
0.5128628015518188,
0.09564198553562164,
0.5992872714996338,
0.20210711658000946,
-0.1797284036874771,
-0.013340574689209461,
-0.2899574935436249,
-0.16956199705600739,
0.17042255401611328,
-0.08808544278144836,
-0.1389571726322174,
0.27138686180114746,
0.21738021075725555,
0.34555327892303467,
-0.03905922546982765,
-0.17030324041843414,
0.22715207934379578,
-0.5204465985298157,
0.2716597616672516,
0.3726232051849365,
0.732625424861908,
0.01232023723423481,
0.003798160469159484,
-0.23438423871994019,
-0.0769515335559845,
0.47571173310279846,
0.01633279398083687,
-0.11991874128580093,
-0.5563035011291504,
0.30601224303245544,
-0.2136826515197754,
0.17167505621910095,
-0.13412411510944366,
-0.5460078716278076,
-0.32457223534584045,
-0.42152443528175354,
0.6061577796936035,
-0.5539953112602234,
-0.560671329498291,
0.13533498346805573,
-0.6161954998970032,
0.058374013751745224,
0.05038076639175415,
-0.6172463297843933,
0.3448282480239868,
0.7918412685394287,
0.8875318169593811,
-0.36364006996154785,
-0.25526681542396545,
-0.9842408299446106,
0.43678754568099976,
-0.03821597248315811,
1.0642808675765991,
-0.6110201478004456,
-0.4724934697151184,
-0.3357948660850525,
-0.2927287817001343,
-0.03316214308142662,
-1.042397379875183,
0.49246567487716675,
-0.3307863473892212,
0.04309968650341034,
-0.07576000690460205,
-0.5673679113388062,
0.03478105738759041,
-0.16526594758033752,
-0.3888653814792633,
1.3187165260314941,
-0.3266122341156006,
-0.5650097727775574,
0.7155206203460693,
-0.24155771732330322,
-0.495138943195343,
0.15729384124279022,
-0.3920314908027649,
-0.5180146098136902,
0.12472931295633316,
-0.04685593768954277,
-0.25812557339668274,
0.13386760652065277,
0.6458572745323181,
-0.27222907543182373,
-0.27449390292167664,
0.2307618111371994,
-0.521893322467804,
0.44198355078697205,
0.02023245207965374,
-0.4267626404762268,
-0.06603270769119263,
-0.9021742939949036,
-0.4105894863605499,
-0.0030781191308051348,
-0.3521893322467804,
-0.21250294148921967,
0.6552318334579468,
0.13635112345218658,
0.34145626425743103,
0.16271425783634186,
-0.6669689416885376,
-0.26915836334228516,
-0.17074275016784668,
0.3731655776500702,
0.5881066918373108,
0.22499997913837433,
0.29972976446151733,
-0.44497615098953247,
0.1282467097043991,
0.61033034324646,
-0.4341052770614624,
-0.19919031858444214,
-0.5727535486221313,
-0.8009615540504456,
-0.2689571678638458,
-0.0949912965297699,
0.8091896176338196,
-0.828417181968689,
0.7449551820755005,
-0.008842199109494686,
-0.08498425781726837,
-0.3432474434375763,
0.3327133357524872,
0.3542453646659851,
0.5601005554199219,
0.3854268193244934,
-0.5137856006622314,
-0.9717373847961426,
-0.45091795921325684,
-0.23752456903457642,
-0.33738359808921814,
-0.27364256978034973,
0.018816106021404266,
0.4034128487110138,
-0.3465559780597687,
1.14517343044281,
-0.36542046070098877,
-0.4357870817184448,
-0.15261928737163544,
0.41302254796028137,
-0.15234775841236115,
0.6497359275817871,
0.29163113236427307,
-1.0544614791870117,
-0.3207578957080841,
-0.10277064144611359,
-0.8478254079818726,
-0.10433270782232285,
-0.3391425609588623,
0.1761682629585266,
0.24752268195152283,
0.43116581439971924,
-0.12556809186935425,
0.478814035654068,
0.27156251668930054,
-0.18675187230110168,
0.3219332993030548,
-0.2219596654176712,
-0.28227698802948,
-0.7156321406364441,
-0.09661223739385605,
0.0008823376265354455,
-0.2360835075378418,
-0.739453911781311,
-0.37022316455841064,
-0.25455886125564575,
-0.1251879781484604,
-0.1831911951303482,
0.5699172019958496,
-0.3142045736312866,
-0.04511234536767006,
-0.675013542175293,
0.2041957676410675,
-0.06726761162281036,
0.19223850965499878,
0.23334257304668427,
0.5488752722740173,
0.8026202321052551,
-0.7701981067657471,
0.5942303538322449,
0.2894994914531708,
-0.2036971002817154,
0.813300371170044,
-0.5012016296386719,
0.31649526953697205,
-0.5033713579177856,
0.4609338641166687,
-1.1061086654663086,
-0.09732666611671448,
0.28761252760887146,
-0.5338262319564819,
0.5668985843658447,
-0.13617338240146637,
-0.7147724628448486,
-0.30746912956237793,
-0.08064515143632889,
0.21685929596424103,
0.6308059096336365,
-0.5055628418922424,
0.6409415602684021,
0.9366491436958313,
-0.45176783204078674,
-0.2513534128665924,
-0.9686248898506165,
0.46550875902175903,
-0.28101664781570435,
-0.7342984676361084,
0.41017019748687744,
-0.07663382589817047,
-0.0383472740650177,
0.08350653201341629,
-0.660296618938446,
-0.4060140550136566,
-0.19485154747962952,
0.23472276329994202,
-0.05550788715481758,
-0.12589497864246368,
0.11049611866474152,
0.0018772399052977562,
-0.3341633677482605,
-0.17682281136512756,
-0.725606381893158,
0.5174812078475952,
0.22916415333747864,
-0.4315354526042938,
-0.9413356781005859,
0.8728643655776978,
0.3563101589679718,
-0.13837717473506927,
0.6487213373184204,
1.211806297302246,
-0.5235598087310791,
0.07164878398180008,
-0.901075005531311,
0.017466552555561066,
-0.49052944779396057,
0.2973956763744354,
-0.11928921192884445,
-1.0947436094284058,
0.6644177436828613,
0.16009584069252014,
-0.05895756557583809,
0.25889432430267334,
0.3973769247531891,
-0.5347397923469543,
0.6654253005981445,
0.35087281465530396,
-0.3218214213848114,
0.6536244750022888,
0.07390858978033066,
0.07640586793422699,
-0.7519908547401428,
-0.4131857752799988,
-0.2885212302207947,
-0.3769499361515045,
-0.09625542163848877,
-0.37670204043388367,
0.4669629633426666,
0.1185593381524086,
0.11043818295001984,
-0.09396660327911377,
-0.30859968066215515,
0.413302481174469,
0.6103413105010986,
0.1764174848794937,
0.28611716628074646,
0.13364210724830627,
0.2636016011238098,
-0.18010739982128143,
-0.5837949514389038,
-0.10571354627609253,
0.5957338213920593,
0.10996057093143463,
0.4599076509475708,
0.2764587998390198,
0.86574387550354,
0.3029537498950958,
-0.31940558552742004,
-0.5754419565200806,
0.5131668448448181,
-0.2944464683532715,
-0.3746402859687805,
-0.15214261412620544,
-0.614906370639801,
-0.9487758278846741,
0.22855690121650696,
0.004146764054894447,
-1.030901551246643,
0.21046529710292816,
0.368954062461853,
-0.3870150148868561,
0.23261883854866028,
-0.3163182735443115,
0.42908117175102234,
0.09562164545059204,
-0.34674710035324097,
-0.5053837299346924,
-0.7334095239639282,
0.08754844963550568,
-0.23204579949378967,
0.2732059359550476,
-0.23009024560451508,
-0.12136631458997726,
0.9171605706214905,
-0.0066782524809241295,
0.7555631399154663,
-0.2753521502017975,
0.23501639068126678,
0.711168646812439,
-0.24476352334022522,
0.23799686133861542,
0.08848359435796738,
0.23389974236488342,
-0.019592540338635445,
0.08489111065864563,
-0.4699574410915375,
-0.37376657128334045,
0.6551287174224854,
-0.5290791392326355,
-0.22547310590744019,
-0.4659666121006012,
-0.37448352575302124,
-0.1782962679862976,
-0.1165340319275856,
0.1380804479122162,
0.6265745162963867,
-0.12656892836093903,
0.12196055054664612,
1.0061657428741455,
-0.17197391390800476,
0.6397897601127625,
0.596071183681488,
0.07208552211523056,
-0.3723730146884918,
1.2982395887374878,
0.20343990623950958,
0.013413171283900738,
0.18370385468006134,
0.2599952220916748,
-0.28396573662757874,
-0.8039519786834717,
-0.26864051818847656,
0.11602092534303665,
-0.45832234621047974,
0.11125499755144119,
-1.0985163450241089,
-0.23441368341445923,
-0.44150641560554504,
0.16244369745254517,
-0.3902263641357422,
-0.3695545792579651,
-0.6514652967453003,
0.16117732226848602,
0.1129622757434845,
0.3126371204853058,
-0.727932333946228,
0.10313213616609573,
-1.065550684928894,
0.8195275068283081,
0.5308427810668945,
0.11444736272096634,
-0.09050861746072769,
-0.7802347540855408,
0.12926995754241943,
0.049353133887052536,
-0.29150792956352234,
-0.6218445897102356,
0.1729067862033844,
0.8904086947441101,
0.8481542468070984,
0.3634902238845825,
-0.1996918022632599,
0.6694917678833008,
-0.481467068195343,
0.8826887011528015,
0.21057067811489105,
-0.8323229551315308,
0.8206657767295837,
-0.18614576756954193,
0.5712373852729797,
0.7777059674263,
0.07864168286323547,
-0.8908136487007141,
-0.3681393563747406,
-0.572757363319397,
-0.9857113361358643,
0.6849460601806641,
0.32120180130004883,
0.03734182193875313,
-0.035705387592315674,
0.08671224117279053,
-0.16443762183189392,
0.13768011331558228,
-0.3046725392341614,
-0.23914124071598053,
0.09156090766191483,
-0.1312214732170105,
-0.013022761791944504,
-0.48938700556755066,
-0.028625572100281715,
-0.21199136972427368,
0.5899247527122498,
0.3357096314430237,
0.11585794389247894,
-0.03988192230463028,
-0.32871198654174805,
0.11640215665102005,
0.11156775057315826,
0.4971475601196289,
0.2926204800605774,
-0.2124030888080597,
0.2064174860715866,
0.1582084745168686,
-0.7841068506240845,
0.2231873720884323,
0.18730320036411285,
0.2578337788581848,
0.3166440427303314,
0.38138672709465027,
0.527660608291626,
0.5194462537765503,
-0.9157227277755737,
0.27964919805526733,
0.11932989954948425,
0.01779179833829403,
-0.747785747051239,
0.13762108981609344,
0.21560753881931305,
0.16661328077316284,
0.6075563430786133,
0.08344229310750961,
0.28468766808509827,
-0.9206861853599548,
0.9179101586341858,
0.126394122838974,
-0.6345271468162537,
-0.29983535408973694,
0.530218780040741,
0.12305646389722824,
-0.26551100611686707,
0.6489918828010559,
-0.5820213556289673,
-0.3908153772354126,
0.6177550554275513,
0.6047327518463135,
0.6862801313400269,
-0.4206058382987976,
-0.06592550873756409,
0.06063225120306015,
-0.03637908771634102,
-0.21851877868175507,
0.5620777606964111,
-0.28931480646133423,
-0.9898569583892822,
-0.34648597240448,
-0.628410816192627,
-0.34049853682518005,
0.08561069518327713,
-0.895715594291687,
-0.13879913091659546,
-0.23430494964122772,
-0.0790317952632904,
0.34042084217071533,
-0.21571797132492065,
-0.19467945396900177,
-0.13205267488956451,
0.6192562580108643,
0.5967246890068054,
-0.8713741898536682,
0.8817099332809448,
0.5837298035621643,
-0.058339428156614304,
-0.16204839944839478,
-0.12186701595783234,
0.7006732821464539,
-0.4388105273246765,
0.33652839064598083,
0.12638013064861298,
-0.32084283232688904,
-0.07748956978321075,
-0.1289183646440506,
-0.7152827978134155,
0.6917920112609863,
0.15045194327831268,
-0.5135424137115479,
0.011792889796197414,
-0.14971397817134857,
0.3226760923862457,
0.11312174052000046,
-0.2873515188694,
1.0407025814056396,
0.3138827085494995,
0.9016640782356262,
-0.9289751052856445,
-0.7132744193077087,
-0.03329040855169296,
-0.08894933760166168,
0.4635997414588928,
-0.3646872341632843,
0.2767065465450287,
0.18994376063346863,
-0.5113904476165771,
-0.07976502180099487,
0.9247596859931946,
0.4933750629425049,
1.097737193107605,
0.544794499874115,
0.7636633515357971,
0.9097216129302979,
-0.1243743821978569,
0.46890777349472046,
0.19600526988506317,
0.22571469843387604,
1.5799580812454224,
-0.5055890083312988,
0.8099762797355652,
0.4090369939804077,
-0.45548364520072937,
0.26277124881744385,
0.2594996988773346,
0.13772428035736084,
0.6716246604919434,
-0.00857404712587595,
-0.9999141693115234,
-0.29790908098220825,
-0.23216430842876434,
-0.3154134750366211,
0.7207314372062683,
0.7875295281410217,
0.36150920391082764,
-0.31661027669906616,
0.4620059132575989,
-0.03311607241630554,
0.26334530115127563,
-0.3016166388988495,
1.055686116218567,
0.29083251953125,
-0.3744770288467407,
0.1711476743221283,
-0.38703835010528564,
0.9524593949317932,
-0.5453437566757202,
-0.005980445072054863,
-0.0513509102165699,
0.1402433216571808,
-0.08974853903055191,
-0.7522135972976685,
0.8530080318450928,
-0.08590968698263168,
-0.25632038712501526,
-0.0008835452026687562,
0.7719056010246277,
-0.8214068412780762,
-0.3916003406047821,
0.245877206325531,
0.0699523538351059,
0.21499662101268768,
-0.31352877616882324,
-0.5290226340293884,
0.4382089078426361,
0.05537822097539902,
0.34281325340270996,
0.4427086114883423,
0.2830323278903961,
0.16587801277637482,
0.6682777404785156,
0.5024694204330444,
-0.02780374512076378,
0.17625810205936432,
0.04338076710700989,
0.7795915603637695,
-0.5043200850486755,
-0.6553402543067932,
-0.8487158417701721,
0.4841636121273041,
-0.29036861658096313,
-0.011796205304563046,
0.24503371119499207,
0.6934367418289185,
0.6643707752227783,
0.2772555947303772,
0.8132463097572327,
0.10296816378831863,
0.39671528339385986,
-0.503938615322113,
0.5287189483642578,
-0.370438814163208,
0.011092149652540684,
-0.08382561802864075,
-0.49961164593696594,
-0.32287272810935974,
0.45149651169776917,
0.15802142024040222,
-0.3359534740447998,
0.5537406802177429,
0.568523645401001,
-0.22916433215141296,
0.15036840736865997,
0.20610903203487396,
-0.03696097433567047,
0.39999961853027344,
0.6506298780441284,
0.975616991519928,
-0.14613528549671173,
0.5209000706672668,
0.024271836504340172,
-0.34276673197746277,
-0.024772465229034424,
-0.6419535875320435,
-0.5087957382202148,
-0.9486335515975952,
-0.8096890449523926,
-0.21015171706676483,
0.09627862274646759,
0.6926308870315552,
0.6953539252281189,
-1.008967638015747,
-0.03739526495337486,
-0.005665406584739685,
0.005708652548491955,
-0.2625366151332855,
-0.19423949718475342,
0.019201498478651047,
-0.30861806869506836,
-0.4557136297225952,
0.8997073173522949,
0.8548159599304199,
0.08558052778244019,
0.11308489739894867,
0.27168530225753784,
-0.4037887454032898,
-0.024138016626238823,
0.47943565249443054,
0.6060587763786316,
-0.5717553496360779,
-0.5332950353622437,
-0.7753096222877502,
0.26220688223838806,
0.0925581082701683,
0.8042681217193604,
-0.7824698686599731,
0.6574224829673767,
0.2582896947860718,
0.6932589411735535,
0.8771266937255859,
-0.327725350856781,
0.3579188883304596,
-0.8877353072166443,
0.65154629945755,
0.6135393381118774,
0.2441311925649643,
0.39362749457359314,
-0.18731887638568878,
0.1587781459093094,
0.5467996597290039,
-0.568475604057312,
-0.9006985425949097,
0.46363428235054016,
-1.3016784191131592,
0.00973565224558115,
0.8602198958396912,
-0.036210738122463226,
0.18911123275756836,
-0.6572322249412537,
0.008166267536580563,
0.34078091382980347,
-0.173659086227417,
0.6288970112800598,
0.6433098912239075,
-0.38365885615348816,
-0.3183375298976898,
-0.37614041566848755,
0.06921439617872238,
0.33518293499946594,
-0.31534406542778015,
-0.19021542370319366,
0.653058648109436,
0.4651881456375122,
0.1480785608291626,
0.8553513288497925,
0.12965218722820282,
0.40237972140312195,
0.324796199798584,
-0.21444901823997498,
0.11181742697954178,
-0.48990702629089355,
-0.6257190108299255,
0.0873250812292099,
-0.20775915682315826,
-0.40516197681427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14443v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14443v1
|
Evaluation of Machine Translation Based on Semantic Dependencies and Keywords
| 2024-04-20T04:14:28 | 2024-04-20T04:14:28 |
Kewei Yuan, Qiurong Zhao, Yang Xu, Xiao Zhang, Huansheng Ning
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In view of the fact that most of the existing machine translation evaluation
algorithms only consider the lexical and syntactic information, but ignore the
deep semantic information contained in the sentence, this paper proposes a
computational method for evaluating the semantic correctness of machine
translations based on reference translations and incorporating semantic
dependencies and sentence keyword information. Use the language technology
platform developed by the Social Computing and Information Retrieval Research
Center of Harbin Institute of Technology to conduct semantic dependency
analysis and keyword analysis on sentences, and obtain semantic dependency
graphs, keywords, and weight information corresponding to keywords. It includes
all word information with semantic dependencies in the sentence and keyword
information that affects semantic information. Construct semantic association
pairs including word and dependency multi-features. The key semantics of the
sentence cannot be highlighted in the semantic information extracted through
semantic dependence, resulting in vague semantics analysis. Therefore, the
sentence keyword information is also included in the scope of machine
translation semantic evaluation. To achieve a comprehensive and in-depth
evaluation of the semantic correctness of sentences, the experimental results
show that the accuracy of the evaluation algorithm has been improved compared
with similar methods, and it can more accurately measure the semantic
correctness of machine translation.
|
[
-0.1739015132188797,
-0.6816858649253845,
0.6476380825042725,
0.23444968461990356,
-0.3966837227344513,
-0.10455135256052017,
-0.29390689730644226,
-0.3655606508255005,
0.24834345281124115,
0.7839329242706299,
-0.42544466257095337,
-0.5059942603111267,
-0.8001661896705627,
0.34696006774902344,
-0.16195285320281982,
0.8620912432670593,
-0.40882596373558044,
0.24339023232460022,
-0.47646215558052063,
-0.3231632709503174,
-0.8277717232704163,
-0.248788520693779,
0.147560715675354,
-0.03616582602262497,
0.10287570208311081,
0.3275880217552185,
0.9071028232574463,
0.7210449576377869,
1.0129863023757935,
0.5451950430870056,
-0.04338402673602104,
0.161635160446167,
-0.23831044137477875,
0.1370212584733963,
-0.42254096269607544,
-0.28072264790534973,
-0.44357019662857056,
-0.20795691013336182,
0.7543777823448181,
0.5022199749946594,
0.47109416127204895,
0.15588988363742828,
0.09947774559259415,
0.737941324710846,
-0.6302343010902405,
0.5048542618751526,
-0.8803300857543945,
-0.06472764164209366,
-0.14364750683307648,
-0.2901904881000519,
-0.17744062840938568,
-0.26285845041275024,
0.13894663751125336,
-0.39797648787498474,
0.1163991242647171,
-0.047713808715343475,
0.8162919282913208,
0.44518640637397766,
-0.3627660870552063,
-0.45292654633522034,
-0.5334774851799011,
0.7489567995071411,
-0.7562956213951111,
0.38118892908096313,
0.32666441798210144,
0.36567625403404236,
-0.2881569564342499,
-0.4597485661506653,
-0.5122737884521484,
-0.5717677474021912,
-0.21250873804092407,
0.10532351583242416,
0.18007980287075043,
0.14128543436527252,
0.005681249313056469,
0.29208970069885254,
-0.521925151348114,
-0.3610427677631378,
-0.457133024930954,
-0.22903507947921753,
0.5145736336708069,
0.24001114070415497,
0.4994661808013916,
-0.5516149401664734,
-0.33648908138275146,
-0.1997460275888443,
-0.23483316600322723,
-0.40680205821990967,
-0.16766357421875,
0.3741794228553772,
-0.058689117431640625,
0.9155809879302979,
-0.42003560066223145,
0.6836773157119751,
-0.040295276790857315,
-0.11327296495437622,
0.6745286583900452,
-0.8183203935623169,
-0.18803642690181732,
0.12427841126918793,
0.8944708704948425,
0.5045212507247925,
0.2219923883676529,
-0.5755504965782166,
-0.10507044941186905,
0.26679497957229614,
0.36608386039733887,
-0.6267997026443481,
0.3800688683986664,
0.21502146124839783,
-0.47774627804756165,
-0.20052899420261383,
0.20542629063129425,
-0.4994414150714874,
-0.07408498227596283,
-0.1745896339416504,
0.5954347848892212,
-0.578728437423706,
0.07996673882007599,
-0.033805396407842636,
0.005463022738695145,
0.15075276792049408,
0.09549804031848907,
-0.3672226667404175,
0.3124998211860657,
0.6844933032989502,
0.7568893432617188,
-0.16126327216625214,
-0.4844648540019989,
-0.5731759667396545,
0.29125136137008667,
-0.032842185348272324,
0.533812940120697,
-0.3947838246822357,
-0.20979349315166473,
0.02279624529182911,
0.20048511028289795,
-0.3655053675174713,
-0.5707538723945618,
0.8574613332748413,
-0.6816943287849426,
-0.01754404418170452,
0.036857135593891144,
-0.949184775352478,
-0.5434460639953613,
0.2631186246871948,
-0.6894519329071045,
0.5759302973747253,
0.1960061937570572,
-0.8399917483329773,
0.22991777956485748,
-0.553704023361206,
-0.6031405329704285,
0.24856211245059967,
-0.011779196560382843,
-0.3777537941932678,
0.004043697379529476,
0.04146130383014679,
0.38947856426239014,
-0.20838840305805206,
0.40791431069374084,
-0.3209780156612396,
-0.41459667682647705,
0.27638062834739685,
0.06903968006372452,
0.6426878571510315,
0.2574453353881836,
-0.4553784430027008,
0.2238614410161972,
-0.7632526159286499,
0.11864817142486572,
-0.07889018207788467,
-0.18161006271839142,
-0.28327080607414246,
0.03391703590750694,
0.08280275017023087,
0.3063913881778717,
0.46355006098747253,
-0.526220977306366,
-0.05810501053929329,
-0.767894446849823,
0.31975528597831726,
0.27861425280570984,
0.08468858897686005,
0.38233083486557007,
0.05656871944665909,
0.39013317227363586,
-0.07057805359363556,
0.03856291621923447,
0.030865980312228203,
-0.5943438410758972,
-0.7487379908561707,
0.14489471912384033,
0.466914564371109,
0.8523791432380676,
-0.7021818161010742,
0.8514434695243835,
-0.4967673122882843,
-0.19590678811073303,
-0.5519487857818604,
0.34790414571762085,
0.5781390070915222,
0.26802974939346313,
0.38820338249206543,
-0.2886638939380646,
-0.6950281858444214,
-0.6912448406219482,
-0.29568248987197876,
-0.2855164706707001,
0.16660258173942566,
-0.11482461541891098,
0.7291406989097595,
-0.3303435742855072,
0.679563581943512,
-0.37172216176986694,
-0.33449727296829224,
-0.1421479880809784,
0.16082021594047546,
0.15984630584716797,
0.4951835870742798,
0.19357101619243622,
-0.7059201598167419,
-0.32913926243782043,
0.15110208094120026,
-0.6830341219902039,
-0.10619862377643585,
0.2104363888502121,
-0.12411350011825562,
-0.01533621083945036,
0.2712690532207489,
-0.748827338218689,
0.4503156542778015,
0.3833375573158264,
-0.26398324966430664,
0.13889415562152863,
-0.34318190813064575,
0.39936718344688416,
-1.032112717628479,
0.3264741599559784,
-0.41643303632736206,
-0.15923896431922913,
-0.3177889883518219,
0.3844936490058899,
0.1779719740152359,
0.0006966479704715312,
-0.4783848226070404,
0.29810410737991333,
-0.2548447251319885,
-0.10407888144254684,
-0.3131140470504761,
0.6364457011222839,
0.0728110522031784,
0.20041707158088684,
-0.10550643503665924,
0.43245628476142883,
0.045793838798999786,
-0.5201699137687683,
0.6350184082984924,
0.3100716769695282,
-0.3397063612937927,
0.3454194664955139,
-0.5706735253334045,
0.30182918906211853,
-0.010157519951462746,
-0.012373830191791058,
-0.9047666192054749,
-0.06692966818809509,
0.6458276510238647,
-0.5364798307418823,
0.007558214012533426,
0.222065269947052,
-0.7822104096412659,
-0.24734243750572205,
-0.04722703620791435,
0.06284243613481522,
0.17437803745269775,
0.06792251765727997,
0.32530519366264343,
0.28887614607810974,
-0.009723578579723835,
-0.2940830588340759,
-0.42958974838256836,
0.311062216758728,
-0.028341257944703102,
-0.918150782585144,
0.3635595440864563,
0.11160120368003845,
-0.280293732881546,
0.27076709270477295,
0.08731476217508316,
-0.24642974138259888,
0.09839175641536713,
0.1720363050699234,
0.3155311048030853,
0.07964079082012177,
0.2135116010904312,
-0.12236148118972778,
-0.4067993462085724,
-0.15135973691940308,
-0.3592439293861389,
0.2911530137062073,
-0.3731207251548767,
-0.1987949013710022,
-0.4107044041156769,
0.18663552403450012,
0.5072383880615234,
-0.3060739040374756,
0.4320092499256134,
0.7323495149612427,
-0.34237200021743774,
0.3070783317089081,
-0.43425101041793823,
0.09826059639453888,
-0.3430034816265106,
0.5625224709510803,
-0.594375729560852,
-0.6870411038398743,
0.337863564491272,
0.04682280123233795,
-0.23565755784511566,
0.8556243777275085,
0.5534209609031677,
0.13577482104301453,
0.9196437001228333,
0.5371044874191284,
-0.06699083745479584,
0.07144933193922043,
0.05727582052350044,
0.07318028062582016,
-0.5136164426803589,
-0.08242900669574738,
-0.8986392617225647,
0.04424062371253967,
-0.7873782515525818,
-0.47490862011909485,
0.281215637922287,
0.11950789391994476,
0.07494356483221054,
0.8030047416687012,
-0.46046748757362366,
0.04742428660392761,
0.2633277177810669,
-0.008115963079035282,
0.3583163321018219,
-0.16319528222084045,
-0.3582725524902344,
-0.1414918601512909,
-0.1868939846754074,
-0.636142909526825,
0.915016233921051,
0.13851632177829742,
0.2729593515396118,
-0.1055154874920845,
0.43129244446754456,
0.41913214325904846,
-0.07972408831119537,
-0.7970883250236511,
0.6045936942100525,
-0.3321833610534668,
-0.34064000844955444,
-0.056862615048885345,
-0.637938916683197,
-0.8061673045158386,
0.21906369924545288,
-0.20968082547187805,
-0.5217045545578003,
-0.3552491366863251,
-0.21932202577590942,
0.1398746222257614,
-0.322675883769989,
-0.6261630654335022,
1.139038324356079,
-0.4046857953071594,
-0.03461332619190216,
-0.5452154874801636,
-0.9775788187980652,
0.05784953758120537,
-0.11810841411352158,
0.15972398221492767,
0.10624799877405167,
-0.07826413214206696,
0.7421109676361084,
-0.7760818600654602,
0.621093213558197,
0.13624320924282074,
0.08091633766889572,
0.34802374243736267,
-0.09428238123655319,
0.47086670994758606,
-0.3478231132030487,
-0.20618663728237152,
0.16048964858055115,
0.25636595487594604,
-0.2931256890296936,
-0.7613823413848877,
0.5615734457969666,
-0.6875768303871155,
-0.24472607672214508,
-0.08264738321304321,
-0.5641661882400513,
-0.23116876184940338,
0.5642552971839905,
0.22825101017951965,
-0.18153589963912964,
-0.2641095221042633,
-0.09663782268762589,
0.20481905341148376,
-0.11966995894908905,
0.03239806368947029,
0.42872369289398193,
-0.30305367708206177,
-0.6330763697624207,
0.8568083047866821,
0.18326938152313232,
0.24456651508808136,
0.7178838849067688,
0.2718709111213684,
-0.21682381629943848,
-0.34907302260398865,
-0.858940601348877,
0.17062929272651672,
-0.6137984991073608,
-0.05829395726323128,
-0.7297982573509216,
-0.19332905113697052,
-0.5248669385910034,
0.005670507904142141,
-0.21080923080444336,
-0.49385687708854675,
0.18792571127414703,
0.2333691418170929,
0.29372459650039673,
0.6877382397651672,
0.40147554874420166,
0.34597182273864746,
-1.2106939554214478,
0.2235926389694214,
-0.19584864377975464,
0.19305448234081268,
-0.2608933448791504,
-0.35073912143707275,
-0.5233585238456726,
-0.11649738997220993,
-0.4114507734775543,
-0.9066911339759827,
-0.019330982118844986,
-0.031010476872324944,
0.4871480464935303,
0.28524038195610046,
-0.16279971599578857,
0.5805876851081848,
-0.6006951928138733,
0.6496801972389221,
0.12552660703659058,
-1.282794713973999,
0.6264098286628723,
0.03572305664420128,
0.4709949493408203,
0.7955436110496521,
-0.038847893476486206,
-0.36478373408317566,
-0.6848813891410828,
-0.652895987033844,
-0.7284725904464722,
0.4480535089969635,
0.4522072374820709,
-0.02120525762438774,
0.08561218529939651,
0.47853222489356995,
-0.09671101719141006,
0.26025885343551636,
-0.24668119847774506,
-0.020827291533350945,
-0.020557932555675507,
-0.28777602314949036,
-0.037182215601205826,
-0.04475106671452522,
0.3068726360797882,
0.05131789296865463,
0.7027979493141174,
0.1532566398382187,
0.08743850141763687,
-0.00018556763825472444,
-0.3256509304046631,
-0.07344646006822586,
0.2981509268283844,
0.3532501757144928,
0.5045197010040283,
-0.4954250752925873,
0.0879383310675621,
0.29318922758102417,
-0.536378800868988,
-0.0002291645505465567,
-0.01685037650167942,
-0.43306171894073486,
0.6135748624801636,
0.47459736466407776,
0.6941540241241455,
0.23685835301876068,
-0.5625746846199036,
0.651152491569519,
0.25502797961235046,
0.2449299395084381,
-0.14826653897762299,
-0.11293941736221313,
0.14349907636642456,
-0.07453738152980804,
-0.37587985396385193,
0.30075177550315857,
0.41251853108406067,
-0.3593073785305023,
0.3909089267253876,
0.3096902370452881,
-0.7418148517608643,
-0.07295965403318405,
0.25841066241264343,
0.09119242429733276,
-0.2544597089290619,
0.5502724051475525,
-0.10170112550258636,
-0.7612835764884949,
0.6026051640510559,
0.3643432557582855,
1.1270091533660889,
-0.2865801155567169,
0.040272850543260574,
0.2794745862483978,
0.44938933849334717,
0.10578522086143494,
0.20508871972560883,
-0.084345743060112,
-0.6312407851219177,
-0.7684921622276306,
-0.4461575448513031,
-0.45970314741134644,
-0.24266417324543,
-0.38199755549430847,
0.5825128555297852,
-0.12705375254154205,
-0.2692442536354065,
0.011934423819184303,
0.07733678072690964,
-0.6205061078071594,
0.36101341247558594,
-0.24292756617069244,
0.5599712133407593,
-0.5680155158042908,
0.8435482978820801,
0.97287517786026,
-0.6746772527694702,
-0.47353971004486084,
0.032349977642297745,
-0.27320143580436707,
-0.7086315155029297,
0.9742429256439209,
0.1361900269985199,
-0.3691577613353729,
-0.38673800230026245,
-0.17915776371955872,
-0.7637975811958313,
0.6890026330947876,
0.3551938831806183,
-0.4742983281612396,
0.2880239486694336,
0.49009546637535095,
0.5962117910385132,
-0.2722463309764862,
0.2276991903781891,
0.18394429981708527,
0.6828513741493225,
0.284271776676178,
-1.125475287437439,
0.3587491810321808,
-0.40074843168258667,
0.4083935022354126,
0.1862490475177765,
-0.2806105315685272,
0.3100541830062866,
0.05320358648896217,
-0.22729447484016418,
0.2229802906513214,
0.615902841091156,
-0.16869883239269257,
0.1214396059513092,
0.5259916186332703,
0.4812741279602051,
0.3055892586708069,
0.3026185631752014,
0.8693686723709106,
-0.6259770393371582,
0.6807745695114136,
1.1839293241500854,
-0.19312536716461182,
0.9093892574310303,
0.4822893738746643,
-0.25381752848625183,
0.18112751841545105,
0.30040243268013,
-0.20896966755390167,
0.4055231511592865,
0.6034473180770874,
-0.09359977394342422,
0.09635646641254425,
-0.12245919555425644,
-0.3017685115337372,
0.48111891746520996,
0.17044372856616974,
-0.6155173182487488,
-0.47480347752571106,
0.01665836200118065,
0.15527144074440002,
0.15052147209644318,
0.06373931467533112,
0.6779686808586121,
0.14297477900981903,
-0.6009136438369751,
0.6667745113372803,
0.5115485191345215,
0.2445756494998932,
-0.3912990093231201,
-0.17720548808574677,
0.2736393213272095,
0.3718036413192749,
-0.2946721613407135,
-0.4993692934513092,
0.6892591714859009,
0.013678140006959438,
-0.2197943478822708,
-0.0013805748894810677,
0.9606932997703552,
-0.1749786138534546,
-0.7046156525611877,
0.5023853182792664,
0.4304324984550476,
0.4502251446247101,
-0.0848468467593193,
-0.7214993238449097,
0.25616028904914856,
-0.23534555733203888,
0.3065089285373688,
0.08188419789075851,
0.478513240814209,
-0.0025611803866922855,
0.3524244725704193,
0.16728061437606812,
0.1471259593963623,
-0.11526390165090561,
0.028069326654076576,
0.5783004760742188,
-0.7293729782104492,
-0.30884799361228943,
-0.9099112749099731,
0.31948018074035645,
-0.025137748569250107,
-0.3956003487110138,
0.8405998349189758,
0.4626986086368561,
0.8135343194007874,
-0.10632185637950897,
0.9242592453956604,
-0.2770124077796936,
0.34767845273017883,
-0.4793953001499176,
0.5387629270553589,
-0.2654733657836914,
0.1066296398639679,
-0.680280864238739,
-1.0663385391235352,
-0.48460960388183594,
0.6090697646141052,
-0.49823758006095886,
-0.03961735963821411,
0.9692168831825256,
0.6987173557281494,
0.10187903791666031,
0.20491285622119904,
0.27092868089675903,
0.3596641421318054,
-0.20707063376903534,
0.3480716943740845,
0.6244048476219177,
-0.8296474814414978,
0.5659099221229553,
-0.1846444308757782,
-0.4112618565559387,
-0.3843148648738861,
-0.8368550539016724,
-0.5111500024795532,
-0.6176062226295471,
-0.5080412030220032,
-0.7752426266670227,
0.1475437730550766,
0.689873456954956,
0.27668339014053345,
-0.928442656993866,
-0.38747185468673706,
-0.18263857066631317,
0.41001060605049133,
-0.3756851553916931,
-0.23719283938407898,
0.6534563899040222,
-0.8397899866104126,
-0.6220062971115112,
0.22943128645420074,
0.4798535406589508,
-0.4166434705257416,
-0.2073880434036255,
-0.12699605524539948,
-0.22403791546821594,
-0.27343472838401794,
0.5324038863182068,
-0.3633262515068054,
-0.7818052172660828,
-0.35490676760673523,
0.03787561133503914,
-0.3395615518093109,
0.06424655765295029,
0.5589832067489624,
-0.47309383749961853,
0.6634997725486755,
0.8438608646392822,
0.8832994103431702,
0.421461284160614,
-0.246100515127182,
0.5619505047798157,
0.09449803829193115,
-0.1016228124499321,
-0.040105659514665604,
0.22093842923641205,
0.37056663632392883,
-0.3331553637981415,
0.5781235098838806,
0.4686852991580963,
-0.4627297520637512,
-0.09754803776741028,
0.16824686527252197,
-0.9904285669326782,
-0.09657029807567596,
0.9304797053337097,
-0.5401175022125244,
-0.5053911209106445,
-0.20162765681743622,
-0.23839132487773895,
0.6804826855659485,
0.005518237128853798,
0.7334251403808594,
0.8286228775978088,
0.12761534750461578,
0.10465140640735626,
-0.7050942182540894,
-0.04860908165574074,
0.6789644360542297,
-0.5585336089134216,
-0.4635615646839142,
0.49150949716567993,
0.15211334824562073,
0.4259640872478485,
0.37267163395881653,
-0.4660941958427429,
0.040692321956157684,
-0.1639222949743271,
0.15088380873203278,
0.42895984649658203,
0.09943944215774536,
-0.07523122429847717,
0.0320570282638073,
-0.0544201098382473,
-0.5087002515792847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13246v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13246v1
|
ISQA: Informative Factuality Feedback for Scientific Summarization
| 2024-04-20T03:16:13 | 2024-04-20T03:16:13 |
Zekai Li, Yanxia Qin, Qian Liu, Min-Yen Kan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose Iterative Facuality Refining on Informative Scientific
Question-Answering (ISQA) feedback\footnote{Code is available at
\url{https://github.com/lizekai-richard/isqa}}, a method following human
learning theories that employs model-generated feedback consisting of both
positive and negative information. Through iterative refining of summaries, it
probes for the underlying rationale of statements to enhance the factuality of
scientific summarization. ISQA does this in a fine-grained manner by asking a
summarization agent to reinforce validated statements in positive feedback and
fix incorrect ones in negative feedback. Our findings demonstrate that the ISQA
feedback mechanism significantly improves the factuality of various open-source
LLMs on the summarization task, as evaluated across multiple scientific
datasets.
|
[
-0.32802531123161316,
-0.6221737265586853,
0.6174061298370361,
0.37997376918792725,
-0.41506850719451904,
0.19562549889087677,
-0.2288978397846222,
-0.18479163944721222,
0.6984341144561768,
0.3258984684944153,
-0.5035263299942017,
-0.43910273909568787,
-0.30970144271850586,
0.250105082988739,
-0.5212326645851135,
1.57167387008667,
0.1711423397064209,
0.3939874768257141,
-0.748958170413971,
-0.12075114250183105,
0.11244118213653564,
-0.3339146673679352,
-0.37697046995162964,
-0.3037152588367462,
0.6653861999511719,
0.6142264008522034,
0.41071388125419617,
0.522951602935791,
0.4697979986667633,
0.28705018758773804,
-0.06288745254278183,
0.3278428018093109,
-0.6079496741294861,
0.0412261039018631,
-0.3451780676841736,
-0.6243779063224792,
-0.2640784680843353,
0.016426274552941322,
0.6792547106742859,
0.610110878944397,
-0.18424496054649353,
0.5741495490074158,
0.16723310947418213,
0.7918704152107239,
-0.6497225165367126,
0.32974421977996826,
-0.3395490050315857,
-0.07526572793722153,
0.0834629088640213,
-0.6186704039573669,
-0.3481219708919525,
-0.746269166469574,
-0.007965002208948135,
-0.675804853439331,
0.3173111081123352,
0.09837308526039124,
0.9458873271942139,
0.6586992144584656,
-0.44873717427253723,
-0.2722448706626892,
-0.6311148405075073,
0.5416646599769592,
-0.8981589078903198,
0.11671754717826843,
0.2315834015607834,
0.2714298963546753,
0.16989904642105103,
-0.7146507501602173,
-0.5809733867645264,
-0.5693659782409668,
-0.07552459836006165,
0.4722694754600525,
-0.0904562696814537,
0.12776876986026764,
0.31991899013519287,
0.5202980637550354,
-0.2758675813674927,
-0.35684284567832947,
-0.8213697671890259,
-0.3788824677467346,
0.6380990147590637,
-0.07331283390522003,
0.08068123459815979,
0.013832949101924896,
-0.3596458435058594,
0.3019208610057831,
-0.820466935634613,
0.26929542422294617,
0.1338079273700714,
0.07781832665205002,
0.0831199362874031,
0.894065797328949,
-0.682295560836792,
0.26042813062667847,
0.2954466640949249,
-0.1487867385149002,
0.05708025395870209,
-0.6889756321907043,
0.2257174849510193,
0.2918727695941925,
0.32172709703445435,
0.7836992144584656,
-0.210677370429039,
-0.4068296253681183,
-0.1327274888753891,
0.07961446791887283,
0.3477323353290558,
-0.9285458326339722,
-0.3397795855998993,
0.375980406999588,
-0.3095756471157074,
-0.3515782952308655,
0.21596559882164001,
-0.4752672016620636,
-0.45702415704727173,
-0.44303423166275024,
0.5670154094696045,
-0.2993755638599396,
-0.03997842222452164,
-0.08246017247438431,
-0.36278730630874634,
0.0832902267575264,
0.7305124998092651,
-0.6221138834953308,
0.33747628331184387,
0.40065041184425354,
0.9208864569664001,
-0.02736409567296505,
-0.30374789237976074,
-0.7434784770011902,
-0.06915396451950073,
-0.07138965278863907,
1.1096127033233643,
-0.11444703489542007,
-0.29851603507995605,
-0.5685818195343018,
-0.025727124884724617,
0.16979709267616272,
-0.5544368028640747,
0.298182874917984,
-0.5590593814849854,
0.21144281327724457,
-0.819942831993103,
-0.5071486830711365,
-0.6132619976997375,
0.4873151183128357,
-0.6631616950035095,
0.9384206533432007,
-0.12430061399936676,
-0.898841917514801,
0.313566118478775,
-0.8704191446304321,
-0.10957442969083786,
-0.019817734137177467,
-0.018998360261321068,
-0.4053701162338257,
0.0032506880816072226,
0.15948815643787384,
0.08511973172426224,
-0.3485512137413025,
0.39456960558891296,
-0.30672428011894226,
-0.26263442635536194,
0.5031948685646057,
-0.07984858006238937,
0.5149924755096436,
0.2945529818534851,
-0.4927613139152527,
0.5102564096450806,
-0.9232516884803772,
0.06860198080539703,
-0.32217130064964294,
-0.5142025351524353,
0.03929134085774422,
-0.030093923211097717,
-0.41251397132873535,
0.09023530036211014,
0.1344495713710785,
-0.7775405049324036,
0.2189784049987793,
-0.21897459030151367,
0.3193971812725067,
0.48183706402778625,
0.4540896415710449,
0.3627704083919525,
-0.8789128065109253,
0.38464173674583435,
-0.059283170849084854,
-0.014115148223936558,
-0.14661672711372375,
-0.4110918939113617,
-1.0170680284500122,
-0.40255507826805115,
0.5328981876373291,
0.5000896453857422,
-0.9296872019767761,
0.14793673157691956,
-0.1712518334388733,
-0.5440194606781006,
-0.46508222818374634,
0.0850343331694603,
0.3819860816001892,
0.8976684808731079,
0.48785334825515747,
-0.33563217520713806,
-0.6088053584098816,
-0.6572561264038086,
-0.25026682019233704,
-0.5080045461654663,
-0.0648689940571785,
-0.2704359292984009,
0.7138472199440002,
-0.005446750670671463,
0.9910683035850525,
-0.2909434735774994,
0.15359407663345337,
0.11416112631559372,
0.32498079538345337,
0.23217043280601501,
0.20662610232830048,
0.35104900598526,
-0.5911666750907898,
-0.05497882142663002,
-0.4448484778404236,
-0.8072729110717773,
-0.295781672000885,
-0.028225863352417946,
0.026979070156812668,
0.004093272611498833,
0.37965717911720276,
-0.5462648272514343,
0.594362735748291,
0.14622557163238525,
-0.4389033317565918,
0.8568242192268372,
0.029712243005633354,
0.6097482442855835,
-0.7527912855148315,
0.4013303220272064,
-0.19979989528656006,
-0.24755442142486572,
-0.40075409412384033,
0.14064094424247742,
0.08229424059391022,
0.2992352247238159,
-0.21076346933841705,
0.2491881251335144,
-0.2684342563152313,
0.044558435678482056,
-0.39482372999191284,
0.2319447547197342,
0.09922151267528534,
0.42408472299575806,
-0.034894656389951706,
0.8027766346931458,
0.13493923842906952,
-0.9887473583221436,
0.3471355736255646,
0.20907068252563477,
-0.29284751415252686,
0.49646759033203125,
-0.8505746722221375,
-0.1858396828174591,
-0.4672423005104065,
0.3959718346595764,
-1.1675573587417603,
-0.4591898024082184,
0.1865888088941574,
-0.6386869549751282,
-0.25917571783065796,
0.10998561233282089,
-0.388693630695343,
-0.22188492119312286,
-0.7555304169654846,
0.10673805326223373,
0.05021992698311806,
-0.6806248426437378,
0.5349695086479187,
0.16604386270046234,
-0.5087797045707703,
-0.8258405327796936,
-0.41910722851753235,
0.03393873944878578,
0.036512162536382675,
-0.6842802166938782,
0.14355172216892242,
-0.5816099047660828,
-0.6037663221359253,
0.1343734711408615,
-0.23154115676879883,
0.16778936982154846,
0.2869516611099243,
0.28697776794433594,
0.5453732013702393,
-0.14785513281822205,
0.28499069809913635,
0.27064916491508484,
-0.04626666009426117,
0.3782532513141632,
-0.12877868115901947,
0.10833241045475006,
-0.30374258756637573,
-0.21886064112186432,
-0.217139333486557,
0.1784900724887848,
0.5475363731384277,
-0.0496627502143383,
0.3480405807495117,
0.2173958569765091,
-0.2786652445793152,
0.0461551807820797,
-0.46512410044670105,
-0.6785326600074768,
-0.41681569814682007,
0.20911218225955963,
0.007110538426786661,
-0.967547595500946,
0.47720375657081604,
-0.051399361342191696,
0.3138539493083954,
0.4637638330459595,
0.7363131642341614,
-0.27891555428504944,
0.6579996347427368,
0.41321295499801636,
0.29422324895858765,
-0.11114359647035599,
-0.2895675599575043,
-0.0032340185716748238,
-0.5193694829940796,
-0.4231857359409332,
-0.4981088638305664,
-0.03480187803506851,
0.011080211959779263,
-0.315675288438797,
0.6346065998077393,
0.10744386166334152,
-0.050283629447221756,
-0.32212409377098083,
-0.2866296172142029,
0.697660505771637,
0.7347127199172974,
0.2611999213695526,
0.6668810844421387,
-0.23080819845199585,
-0.040207140147686005,
0.1487836092710495,
-0.566274881362915,
-0.5390484929084778,
0.8823702931404114,
0.2738841474056244,
0.7006034255027771,
0.39460015296936035,
0.5638715028762817,
0.42420464754104614,
0.6910837888717651,
-1.0424716472625732,
0.4463687837123871,
0.3630739450454712,
-0.6020018458366394,
-0.22427794337272644,
-0.3729884624481201,
-0.3323443830013275,
0.17431947588920593,
-0.49780401587486267,
-0.3902128040790558,
-0.050315313041210175,
0.6191555261611938,
-0.5926449298858643,
0.1350211203098297,
-0.4724922180175781,
0.1284964680671692,
-0.02376132272183895,
-0.27584826946258545,
-0.1971602737903595,
-0.9027194976806641,
0.5845615267753601,
0.1449432075023651,
0.14671555161476135,
0.20931361615657806,
0.053216371685266495,
0.7187519073486328,
-0.9101953506469727,
0.940457284450531,
-0.2703832983970642,
-0.11251694709062576,
0.35988786816596985,
-0.1575656682252884,
0.4168202877044678,
0.4579305052757263,
0.04286716878414154,
-0.161367729306221,
0.25792062282562256,
-0.5676427483558655,
-0.8281675577163696,
0.34721872210502625,
-0.6436785459518433,
-0.7158593535423279,
-0.5305135846138,
-0.47948533296585083,
-0.29549944400787354,
0.10285905748605728,
0.6432151794433594,
0.2660382390022278,
-0.06673175096511841,
0.10801181942224503,
0.8764326572418213,
0.15444821119308472,
0.05444879084825516,
0.8278382420539856,
-0.45768702030181885,
-0.6603684425354004,
0.7200523614883423,
0.28275033831596375,
0.1468062400817871,
0.31367331743240356,
0.13633757829666138,
-0.38211071491241455,
-0.6854004859924316,
-0.42916595935821533,
0.520331621170044,
-0.9485613107681274,
-0.4224250018596649,
-0.7278137803077698,
-0.3344249129295349,
-0.4006989300251007,
0.12502868473529816,
-0.09499628841876984,
-1.1421059370040894,
-0.2859746813774109,
-0.5568552613258362,
0.4778701364994049,
0.9185878038406372,
-0.24623847007751465,
0.12164396047592163,
-0.8255250453948975,
0.36990684270858765,
0.3899916112422943,
0.10689088702201843,
-0.03278215602040291,
-0.6602278351783752,
-0.4537980258464813,
0.13974027335643768,
-0.4182170629501343,
-0.7142079472541809,
-0.027295272797346115,
0.23698841035366058,
0.35410863161087036,
0.3505781590938568,
0.20654036104679108,
0.4195363521575928,
-0.11139451712369919,
1.0793871879577637,
0.11594339460134506,
-0.9879210591316223,
0.4401784837245941,
-0.14250953495502472,
0.522333025932312,
0.8148905634880066,
0.5535122752189636,
-0.34103289246559143,
-0.6044812202453613,
-0.39114394783973694,
-0.7794862389564514,
0.4289793372154236,
0.011247288435697556,
-0.4618971049785614,
0.24197715520858765,
0.6006802320480347,
0.3756612539291382,
0.5692247152328491,
-0.6386996507644653,
-0.3290987014770508,
-0.6402645111083984,
-0.08429189771413803,
0.21486896276474,
-0.3746557831764221,
-0.5430477857589722,
-0.1267719715833664,
1.1703035831451416,
-0.41962024569511414,
0.09626903384923935,
0.45599132776260376,
-0.19234560430049896,
-0.11521367728710175,
0.383165568113327,
0.7974722385406494,
0.8156391978263855,
-0.35879912972450256,
0.3484192192554474,
0.059039436280727386,
-0.5848623514175415,
0.045991450548172,
0.054797302931547165,
-0.5251738429069519,
0.0028053985442966223,
0.34144657850265503,
0.4893067479133606,
-0.09306612610816956,
-0.554992139339447,
0.4748629629611969,
-0.25613704323768616,
-0.5478740930557251,
-0.19049949944019318,
0.2429734617471695,
-0.11014197766780853,
0.3711501955986023,
0.5859092473983765,
0.379726380109787,
0.7159968614578247,
-0.48877671360969543,
0.3124295473098755,
0.10524202883243561,
-0.25922149419784546,
-0.5455395579338074,
0.7986404299736023,
0.20993176102638245,
0.220690056681633,
0.43006908893585205,
-0.12710438668727875,
-0.5832521319389343,
0.5187795758247375,
0.5113472938537598,
0.5413113236427307,
0.0793815478682518,
0.6878557801246643,
0.7712011337280273,
0.28057339787483215,
-0.06109802797436714,
0.7995797991752625,
-0.5153957009315491,
-0.40106987953186035,
-0.6927326321601868,
-0.23671314120292664,
-0.9399279356002808,
-0.23363091051578522,
-0.7207857370376587,
0.2268998622894287,
-0.5802988409996033,
-0.2118784487247467,
0.026283573359251022,
-0.1026400700211525,
0.026488931849598885,
0.244154155254364,
-0.15228210389614105,
0.9946790337562561,
-0.6032620668411255,
0.40956518054008484,
0.6595678329467773,
-0.6939296722412109,
-0.7059627175331116,
-0.08150210976600647,
0.3003925383090973,
-0.4716232717037201,
0.6840574741363525,
0.021715329959988594,
-0.5318368077278137,
-0.11989288032054901,
-1.1773186922073364,
-1.1413090229034424,
1.280927300453186,
0.4055088758468628,
-0.2354164868593216,
-0.010031696408987045,
-0.20507188141345978,
0.5413587689399719,
-0.06373060494661331,
0.4093417823314667,
0.13127025961875916,
0.6576195359230042,
0.1796494871377945,
-0.5808466076850891,
0.3162493109703064,
-0.8580562472343445,
-0.38032373785972595,
0.010239366441965103,
-0.8828344345092773,
0.5279690623283386,
-0.746340811252594,
-0.35281622409820557,
0.41659674048423767,
0.9851726293563843,
0.5811449885368347,
0.7455294728279114,
0.49898138642311096,
0.5205933451652527,
1.2175371646881104,
-0.1743478924036026,
0.9182797074317932,
-0.31939461827278137,
0.24163401126861572,
1.257192611694336,
0.0352713018655777,
0.32670456171035767,
0.6541274785995483,
-0.1722833663225174,
0.5097469687461853,
0.5941146612167358,
0.009126590564846992,
0.5662150382995605,
0.2893114686012268,
-0.29509055614471436,
0.037483297288417816,
-0.17451806366443634,
-0.3204500675201416,
0.3036712110042572,
0.2986072599887848,
-0.05813373625278473,
-0.28658315539360046,
-0.025700556114315987,
0.3010655343532562,
0.016695594415068626,
-0.37497955560684204,
0.6618064641952515,
-0.14157158136367798,
-0.9336416721343994,
0.717275857925415,
-0.22970785200595856,
0.5173358917236328,
-0.6455398201942444,
-0.3284691572189331,
-0.19661693274974823,
-0.3830624222755432,
-0.6817790865898132,
-0.3636132776737213,
0.20413200557231903,
0.07567007839679718,
-0.539588987827301,
0.3691461682319641,
0.26684075593948364,
-0.5155468583106995,
0.05489782989025116,
-0.33355480432510376,
0.20862561464309692,
0.06093446910381317,
0.09417302906513214,
-0.43291014432907104,
-0.2714642882347107,
0.1900089681148529,
-0.07792255282402039,
-0.12397327274084091,
0.32044538855552673,
0.07664366066455841,
0.7131833434104919,
0.6465452313423157,
0.19767315685749054,
0.06984471529722214,
-0.023631760850548744,
1.0516525506973267,
-0.7532099485397339,
-0.5560105443000793,
-0.5441716909408569,
0.6567488312721252,
-0.28057944774627686,
-0.2669636309146881,
1.1148827075958252,
0.6057699918746948,
0.5065729022026062,
-0.23686113953590393,
1.0641061067581177,
0.0471552349627018,
0.6879451274871826,
-0.7880799174308777,
0.6423473358154297,
-0.24141712486743927,
0.5743978023529053,
0.01458407286554575,
-0.8313053250312805,
-0.36924752593040466,
0.2206350862979889,
-0.12382873892784119,
-0.1726696640253067,
0.8515815138816833,
0.856332540512085,
0.25653091073036194,
0.4366629719734192,
0.012541072443127632,
0.5774223804473877,
0.2582349181175232,
-0.20294858515262604,
1.2140694856643677,
-0.17018181085586548,
0.18418963253498077,
-0.4163537323474884,
-0.5759185552597046,
-0.31310659646987915,
-0.8292074799537659,
-0.6743605136871338,
-0.5435012578964233,
-0.5863000154495239,
-0.7297964096069336,
0.06394153088331223,
1.1579293012619019,
0.2713684141635895,
-0.9631053805351257,
-0.05380263924598694,
0.08413078635931015,
0.03826173022389412,
-0.09729746729135513,
-0.2997281551361084,
0.16293248534202576,
-0.4316564202308655,
-0.3569086194038391,
0.3618897795677185,
0.5341183543205261,
-0.06716535240411758,
-0.18025076389312744,
0.035981256514787674,
-0.17130041122436523,
0.40617984533309937,
0.5116958618164062,
0.539467990398407,
-0.4324115216732025,
-0.17848505079746246,
0.12078960984945297,
0.22553925216197968,
0.13205569982528687,
0.8711652159690857,
-0.6288086175918579,
0.5723757147789001,
0.44116276502609253,
0.615021288394928,
0.4274373948574066,
0.1998317390680313,
0.4414181709289551,
-0.6462579369544983,
-0.3172123432159424,
0.22108973562717438,
0.28542643785476685,
0.3301598131656647,
-0.573902428150177,
0.7224581837654114,
0.15376107394695282,
-0.759968638420105,
-0.7699616551399231,
0.0648002102971077,
-1.119286298751831,
-0.06329070031642914,
1.0209527015686035,
-0.10651712864637375,
-0.3381824195384979,
-0.13031154870986938,
-0.5271164178848267,
0.19407574832439423,
-0.5409122109413147,
1.2797218561172485,
0.7501608729362488,
-0.335055947303772,
0.0758884847164154,
-0.0003597159229684621,
0.4603092074394226,
0.445060133934021,
-0.9918525815010071,
-0.17497076094150543,
0.7170960903167725,
0.3269899785518646,
0.46958667039871216,
0.8382511138916016,
-0.204095259308815,
0.8369457125663757,
-0.1799446940422058,
0.06708052009344101,
-0.1548616886138916,
-0.30976614356040955,
-0.29815417528152466,
0.017938954755663872,
0.2902865707874298,
0.22496424615383148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13238v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13238v1
|
Personalized Wireless Federated Learning for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-20T02:30:21 | 2024-04-20T02:30:21 |
Feibo Jiang, Li Dong, Siwei Tu, Yubo Peng, Kezhi Wang, Kun Yang, Cunhua Pan, Dusit Niyato
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized natural language processing
tasks. However, their deployment in wireless networks still face challenges,
i.e., a lack of privacy and security protection mechanisms. Federated Learning
(FL) has emerged as a promising approach to address these challenges. Yet, it
suffers from issues including inefficient handling with big and heterogeneous
data, resource-intensive training, and high communication overhead. To tackle
these issues, we first compare different learning stages and their features of
LLMs in wireless networks. Next, we introduce two personalized wireless
federated fine-tuning methods with low communication overhead, i.e., (1)
Personalized Federated Instruction Tuning (PFIT), which employs reinforcement
learning to fine-tune local LLMs with diverse reward models to achieve
personalization; (2) Personalized Federated Task Tuning (PFTT), which can
leverage global adapters and local Low-Rank Adaptations (LoRA) to
collaboratively fine-tune local LLMs, where the local LoRAs can be applied to
achieve personalization without aggregation. Finally, we perform simulations to
demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed two methods and comprehensively
discuss open issues.
|
[
-0.19511282444000244,
-0.720410168170929,
0.3609315752983093,
0.3199840486049652,
0.1516273468732834,
0.24898064136505127,
-0.6257545948028564,
-0.5533609986305237,
0.14987602829933167,
0.4928353428840637,
-0.735262393951416,
-0.5363343358039856,
-0.4742336571216583,
0.19287152588367462,
0.11904598772525787,
1.1906399726867676,
-0.050689179450273514,
-0.28132328391075134,
-0.08980240672826767,
-0.24587370455265045,
-0.3163850009441376,
-0.25675246119499207,
-0.7075749635696411,
-0.5305172801017761,
0.7745234370231628,
0.6646409630775452,
0.5973560214042664,
0.49804192781448364,
0.469169020652771,
0.4794102609157562,
0.0522901676595211,
0.32375824451446533,
-0.7072168588638306,
0.2445622831583023,
-0.42402783036231995,
-0.2643045485019684,
-0.12275835871696472,
-0.1121009811758995,
0.5190651416778564,
0.8753730058670044,
-0.12762421369552612,
0.27370014786720276,
-0.18616531789302826,
0.7690078020095825,
-0.6603299975395203,
0.3763963282108307,
-0.6995898485183716,
0.10015017539262772,
-0.1901322454214096,
-0.19606266915798187,
-0.4329501688480377,
-0.35576027631759644,
0.33696481585502625,
-0.6578191518783569,
0.15423472225666046,
0.18621030449867249,
0.6580638885498047,
0.05799141526222229,
-0.4722777307033539,
-0.2721002697944641,
-0.9055666327476501,
0.8972946405410767,
-0.6854375004768372,
0.1794341653585434,
0.4145245850086212,
0.299803227186203,
-0.4916403591632843,
-0.6690581440925598,
-0.2966250479221344,
-0.16848544776439667,
-0.21239203214645386,
-0.14658983051776886,
-0.27958476543426514,
0.30672696232795715,
0.0963786244392395,
0.5181562304496765,
-0.5103593468666077,
0.5766939520835876,
0.0765228345990181,
-0.1976006180047989,
0.7284531593322754,
0.1701812893152237,
0.06661595404148102,
0.3906604051589966,
-0.35426855087280273,
0.09528319537639618,
-0.36847153306007385,
0.16374965012073517,
0.3345416188240051,
0.6099186539649963,
-0.2665329873561859,
0.3738649785518646,
-1.1026595830917358,
0.7557267546653748,
0.29023972153663635,
-0.39233747124671936,
0.4856795370578766,
0.09569968283176422,
-0.331218957901001,
-0.046257223933935165,
0.8793383836746216,
-0.19231629371643066,
0.07363869994878769,
-0.5933480262756348,
-0.3452918231487274,
-0.4494876563549042,
-0.13950656354427338,
-0.6710149645805359,
-0.21592077612876892,
0.14832304418087006,
-0.47250714898109436,
-0.47725027799606323,
-0.12133312225341797,
-0.3827906847000122,
-0.2483191192150116,
-0.28966373205184937,
0.5844980478286743,
-0.1475745141506195,
-0.039307788014411926,
0.1973789632320404,
0.27640846371650696,
-0.18653057515621185,
0.2381369173526764,
-1.5287187099456787,
0.22392538189888,
0.7897982597351074,
0.8220627307891846,
0.0930878221988678,
-0.42472386360168457,
-0.7104088664054871,
0.1381077915430069,
0.19592787325382233,
0.6393190026283264,
-0.3838191330432892,
-0.04786430671811104,
0.15823271870613098,
0.015826808288693428,
-0.28210416436195374,
-0.1573466807603836,
0.3966815173625946,
-0.7346222400665283,
0.34656912088394165,
-0.27593716979026794,
-0.5945581197738647,
-0.10106439143419266,
0.18648840487003326,
-0.27967339754104614,
0.43942391872406006,
0.20549039542675018,
-1.0024490356445312,
-0.07555670291185379,
-0.5489645004272461,
-0.6891002655029297,
0.22222411632537842,
-0.04872141033411026,
-0.5193668603897095,
0.30813854932785034,
0.1899118423461914,
0.7751820087432861,
-0.1175789088010788,
0.12994611263275146,
-0.42829999327659607,
-0.45501774549484253,
-0.03895875811576843,
-0.20110711455345154,
0.5896779298782349,
0.28068000078201294,
-0.42426198720932007,
0.31745263934135437,
-0.7951496243476868,
0.19309021532535553,
0.1745811551809311,
-0.6213326454162598,
-0.37019264698028564,
0.19740226864814758,
-0.13785836100578308,
0.0570736862719059,
0.3653769791126251,
-0.8528637290000916,
0.18223825097084045,
-0.7713214159011841,
0.5110825300216675,
0.7758168578147888,
-0.056738950312137604,
0.5615493059158325,
-0.5108557343482971,
0.10140298306941986,
-0.18789644539356232,
-0.013237128034234047,
-0.10012930631637573,
-0.10487144440412521,
-0.5694800019264221,
-0.2510032057762146,
0.09146887809038162,
0.3573267161846161,
-0.7979802489280701,
0.4849831461906433,
-0.4268215596675873,
-0.4142805337905884,
-0.15319716930389404,
0.25100383162498474,
0.43963950872421265,
0.5481433272361755,
0.15679271519184113,
0.06818816810846329,
-0.17873647809028625,
-0.7810462713241577,
-0.21454791724681854,
0.07510830461978912,
-0.14963504672050476,
0.4239270091056824,
0.3695516586303711,
-0.47793540358543396,
0.8325692415237427,
-0.5290822982788086,
-0.5086754560470581,
-0.1350204348564148,
0.18828903138637543,
0.11195068061351776,
0.329852432012558,
0.29962655901908875,
-0.5950794816017151,
-0.45963552594184875,
0.46260538697242737,
-0.4594966471195221,
-0.08631445467472076,
-0.031660694628953934,
0.1453760266304016,
0.14867174625396729,
0.06126941740512848,
-0.39049050211906433,
-0.045753538608551025,
0.8899509906768799,
-0.43070390820503235,
0.30665692687034607,
-0.4011625647544861,
0.0835803970694542,
-0.9799394011497498,
-0.18496176600456238,
-0.03885279968380928,
-0.39387592673301697,
-0.5915067195892334,
0.03569710627198219,
-0.17711734771728516,
-0.08306529372930527,
-0.02768952213227749,
0.43102917075157166,
-0.24562911689281464,
-0.10143622010946274,
-0.41565266251564026,
-0.09141425043344498,
-0.20842362940311432,
0.5237849950790405,
-0.05516228452324867,
0.5682533383369446,
0.2286492884159088,
-0.3958912789821625,
0.38049575686454773,
0.36835482716560364,
-0.33536574244499207,
0.08536139130592346,
-0.4906400144100189,
0.1692945957183838,
-0.03834041580557823,
0.5190036296844482,
-0.6561129093170166,
-0.509056568145752,
0.007782247383147478,
-0.14715205132961273,
-0.0136826541274786,
0.23489093780517578,
-0.31772854924201965,
-0.07307983189821243,
-0.24285981059074402,
0.05162854120135307,
0.16478939354419708,
-1.0112146139144897,
0.3826485574245453,
0.1580919325351715,
-0.009865783154964447,
-0.5716125965118408,
-0.4399210810661316,
-0.2921909689903259,
-0.022473178803920746,
-0.7889764308929443,
0.5302386283874512,
0.0670185312628746,
-0.0860009640455246,
-0.20122861862182617,
-0.15412810444831848,
0.12128621339797974,
0.3580939471721649,
0.4542722702026367,
-0.31816819310188293,
-0.28903114795684814,
0.30624088644981384,
0.2997042238712311,
-0.12477279454469681,
-0.11886266618967056,
-0.37180960178375244,
0.3543691337108612,
-0.21612852811813354,
-0.10478775948286057,
-0.49321654438972473,
0.35116371512413025,
0.3267310559749603,
-0.49259087443351746,
0.9531540274620056,
0.8905225992202759,
-0.24155360460281372,
-0.47153714299201965,
-0.6897942423820496,
-0.24352960288524628,
-0.5651939511299133,
0.26837536692619324,
-0.24445845186710358,
-1.7045217752456665,
0.2840173542499542,
-0.4237028956413269,
0.35114404559135437,
-0.06513292342424393,
0.6346830129623413,
-0.3863135874271393,
0.8207876682281494,
0.9035464525222778,
-0.40999770164489746,
0.7605037093162537,
0.08408651500940323,
0.39073875546455383,
-0.5600982904434204,
-0.2746177911758423,
-0.5112247467041016,
-0.4431023597717285,
-0.7317708134651184,
-0.002939017955213785,
0.17263293266296387,
-0.05747814476490021,
-0.5624458193778992,
0.058676790446043015,
-0.3026658296585083,
0.5570880174636841,
0.43690744042396545,
0.26006177067756653,
0.37233689427375793,
0.36120760440826416,
0.04707834869623184,
0.1843825876712799,
-0.6623964905738831,
-0.20674379169940948,
0.7126256227493286,
0.4961436986923218,
0.6884036064147949,
0.14109553396701813,
0.9387397766113281,
0.01791687309741974,
0.34389206767082214,
-0.5236564874649048,
0.3086858093738556,
-0.3375444710254669,
-0.25747862458229065,
-0.39676418900489807,
-0.8576942086219788,
-0.8932981491088867,
0.2812241017818451,
-0.566625714302063,
-1.0670533180236816,
0.00027591566322371364,
0.20518772304058075,
-0.39351269602775574,
0.30761635303497314,
-0.7242494821548462,
0.6050037741661072,
-0.1014983057975769,
-0.45680809020996094,
-0.2793886661529541,
-0.5444319248199463,
0.4250832200050354,
0.002026920672506094,
0.2349235713481903,
-0.24735045433044434,
0.1422944962978363,
0.6137869954109192,
-0.36046192049980164,
0.8289985060691833,
-0.2187507152557373,
0.1308167278766632,
-0.29942402243614197,
-0.15146148204803467,
0.828122079372406,
0.33997371792793274,
-0.09628729522228241,
0.1405930072069168,
-0.20213526487350464,
-0.3492997884750366,
-0.38179346919059753,
1.2110815048217773,
-0.9241045713424683,
-0.4709315001964569,
-0.24170218408107758,
-0.6115525364875793,
-0.6091147661209106,
0.21774427592754364,
0.3540807068347931,
0.3479377031326294,
-0.10098493844270706,
0.4000554382801056,
0.7792070508003235,
-0.44433706998825073,
0.5565077662467957,
0.8006572723388672,
0.045735348016023636,
-0.4354066252708435,
0.967962920665741,
-0.2611837089061737,
0.1805308759212494,
0.7591227293014526,
0.5110552906990051,
0.008212115615606308,
-0.7800659537315369,
-0.008220264688134193,
0.25347334146499634,
-0.42762458324432373,
-0.4015146791934967,
-0.5681306719779968,
-0.001625600503757596,
-0.24733254313468933,
-0.3892151415348053,
-0.44383516907691956,
0.021578658372163773,
-0.37424102425575256,
0.08808238059282303,
0.52463299036026,
0.3500518500804901,
0.2178083211183548,
0.7003097534179688,
-0.7941675186157227,
0.13595318794250488,
0.31528744101524353,
0.6864237785339355,
-0.06003949046134949,
-0.2988530397415161,
-0.5310470461845398,
0.1243303194642067,
-0.11897189170122147,
-0.2898499369621277,
0.19203391671180725,
0.3368486762046814,
0.3394460380077362,
0.32999318838119507,
0.30580687522888184,
0.5342420935630798,
-0.5020663738250732,
0.34649208188056946,
0.1717679500579834,
-0.8145539164543152,
0.23104755580425262,
-0.5698204636573792,
0.34137848019599915,
0.7906489968299866,
0.22464661300182343,
-0.5405808687210083,
-0.22202660143375397,
-0.21964210271835327,
-0.6541213989257812,
0.6900542378425598,
0.015111676417291164,
0.3923657238483429,
0.037729810923337936,
0.42000386118888855,
0.07526662200689316,
0.013256092555820942,
-0.6209577322006226,
-0.07812179625034332,
0.045618072152137756,
-0.3146194517612457,
-0.12460047006607056,
-0.025737710297107697,
-0.0867670327425003,
-0.3369823396205902,
0.6296205520629883,
-0.25325533747673035,
0.12890733778476715,
0.05538354814052582,
-0.06795017421245575,
-0.24418941140174866,
0.19043481349945068,
0.5797661542892456,
0.46365058422088623,
-0.17233337461948395,
-0.251735121011734,
0.1738436371088028,
-0.22520235180854797,
0.08110284805297852,
0.16095949709415436,
-0.13418111205101013,
-0.07079138606786728,
0.5549666285514832,
1.2359620332717896,
0.686815619468689,
-0.42614567279815674,
0.5088052749633789,
-0.27840423583984375,
-0.37164151668548584,
-0.25796809792518616,
0.23048149049282074,
0.30291980504989624,
0.4562165439128876,
0.14152158796787262,
-0.010860388167202473,
-0.13762487471103668,
-0.259220689535141,
-0.13417930901050568,
0.6516671776771545,
-0.010651650838553905,
-0.26475465297698975,
0.4389631450176239,
0.5125041007995605,
-0.35032495856285095,
0.4471798837184906,
-0.06134245917201042,
-0.23002421855926514,
0.24195723235607147,
0.5946458578109741,
0.6870586276054382,
-0.2973717451095581,
0.4210526943206787,
0.10749701410531998,
0.18316751718521118,
-0.25583308935165405,
-0.10305347293615341,
-0.40111061930656433,
-0.7628368735313416,
-0.3537115752696991,
-0.7456861734390259,
-0.3773081600666046,
0.27428436279296875,
-0.48870208859443665,
0.03492654487490654,
-0.6069369316101074,
0.22919760644435883,
0.07840131223201752,
0.4591127932071686,
-0.5627609491348267,
0.1798700988292694,
0.15581069886684418,
0.8695818781852722,
-0.7095739245414734,
1.141272783279419,
0.468015193939209,
0.03520529717206955,
-0.971457302570343,
0.013834066689014435,
-0.15717259049415588,
-0.21352533996105194,
0.47403594851493835,
0.08271998912096024,
-0.13472722470760345,
0.18849991261959076,
-0.20796236395835876,
-0.843574583530426,
1.3457865715026855,
0.38604411482810974,
-0.9225669503211975,
-0.1146494671702385,
-0.057169053703546524,
0.5215018391609192,
-0.3754432201385498,
0.10246646404266357,
0.41826194524765015,
0.170915424823761,
-0.0008128174813464284,
-0.8661335110664368,
-0.13300834596157074,
0.2842554450035095,
0.12189419567584991,
0.06299882382154465,
-0.9308933615684509,
0.776255190372467,
-0.20626422762870789,
-0.1350088119506836,
-0.07291865348815918,
0.7583668828010559,
-0.00860615074634552,
0.4185640811920166,
0.4667758345603943,
0.24460820853710175,
0.8687775731086731,
0.03520504757761955,
0.8843016028404236,
-0.045528560876846313,
0.6819671988487244,
1.154608964920044,
-0.4169538915157318,
0.7979845404624939,
0.24181614816188812,
0.04052529111504555,
0.2650626301765442,
0.44650790095329285,
0.24695730209350586,
0.7454255223274231,
0.10036183893680573,
-0.7048865556716919,
-0.08078107982873917,
0.21735845506191254,
-0.23410916328430176,
0.6573564410209656,
0.2249268889427185,
-0.46793678402900696,
-0.44675588607788086,
0.38320037722587585,
-0.025371849536895752,
0.3240669071674347,
-0.39141157269477844,
0.969393789768219,
-0.046859532594680786,
-0.2504386901855469,
0.4514462351799011,
0.5473318099975586,
1.0674166679382324,
-0.7955203652381897,
0.30494484305381775,
-0.4179385304450989,
0.3154374957084656,
-0.48011472821235657,
-0.09802698343992233,
0.3075367212295532,
-0.09560772776603699,
-0.24688123166561127,
-0.3962182402610779,
0.8549748659133911,
-0.35524865984916687,
-0.17660251259803772,
0.2843581736087799,
0.10057275742292404,
-0.4150553345680237,
0.0865151584148407,
-0.47215214371681213,
0.2549879848957062,
0.058309972286224365,
-0.68546462059021,
0.8978180289268494,
0.14405548572540283,
-0.044558990746736526,
0.8163836598396301,
0.6963708996772766,
0.055794667452573776,
-0.13745446503162384,
-0.10013873875141144,
0.892135500907898,
-0.29669633507728577,
-0.521567165851593,
-0.7141941785812378,
0.018544306978583336,
0.004254521336406469,
-0.3832709789276123,
0.6918640732765198,
0.22638441622257233,
1.0778042078018188,
-0.17591574788093567,
0.711652934551239,
0.022195231169462204,
0.40105754137039185,
-0.5498380064964294,
0.9159597158432007,
-0.21700066328048706,
0.26501938700675964,
-0.06986450403928757,
-0.5954270958900452,
-0.17657580971717834,
0.6846607327461243,
-0.5485686659812927,
-0.18284481763839722,
0.3398039638996124,
0.5902988910675049,
-0.20075665414333344,
0.4471298158168793,
0.2792927920818329,
0.019118964672088623,
0.322885662317276,
0.7775835394859314,
0.3569278120994568,
-0.10185251384973526,
0.1435154676437378,
-0.752796471118927,
-0.2536851763725281,
-0.4113180935382843,
-0.7567052841186523,
-1.0240815877914429,
-0.5836939215660095,
-0.41286593675613403,
0.025657717138528824,
0.19688987731933594,
1.3135030269622803,
0.8575513958930969,
-0.7727622389793396,
-0.04155566170811653,
-0.1919601708650589,
0.33876410126686096,
-0.2183116227388382,
-0.12922324240207672,
0.14671485126018524,
-0.4473346769809723,
-0.4827274680137634,
0.5732870101928711,
0.25853726267814636,
-0.24746276438236237,
-0.06414495408535004,
-0.08064950257539749,
-0.09299495816230774,
-0.09498273581266403,
0.7011686563491821,
0.5393621325492859,
-0.5379176735877991,
-0.5657212734222412,
-0.43087857961654663,
-0.26785773038864136,
-0.27825042605400085,
0.8729945421218872,
-0.8676403164863586,
0.24684326350688934,
0.5518525242805481,
0.9373295903205872,
0.3912293314933777,
0.09996287524700165,
0.38042759895324707,
-1.0352529287338257,
0.3135632872581482,
0.20363298058509827,
0.03948419168591499,
0.21666599810123444,
-0.6542912125587463,
0.06454344093799591,
-0.010240722447633743,
-0.8257032632827759,
-0.8338618874549866,
0.22265088558197021,
-0.8196492791175842,
-0.11973747611045837,
0.9670700430870056,
-0.5633573532104492,
-0.009064455516636372,
-0.04031338542699814,
0.11800456792116165,
0.0860363245010376,
-0.22025078535079956,
0.8049898743629456,
0.4883456528186798,
-0.18609008193016052,
-0.07705649733543396,
-0.5624192953109741,
0.5173789262771606,
0.27459579706192017,
-0.8237658739089966,
0.14832399785518646,
0.3015410900115967,
0.5474252104759216,
-0.18799474835395813,
0.6319699287414551,
0.376761794090271,
-0.05480300635099411,
-0.43885672092437744,
-0.2021838128566742,
-0.6236907839775085,
-0.08130919933319092,
-0.5978577136993408,
0.3087773621082306,
0.06394120305776596,
-0.25587406754493713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13208v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13208v1
|
The Instruction Hierarchy: Training LLMs to Prioritize Privileged Instructions
| 2024-04-19T22:55:23 | 2024-04-19T22:55:23 |
Eric Wallace, Kai Xiao, Reimar Leike, Lilian Weng, Johannes Heidecke, Alex Beutel
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Today's LLMs are susceptible to prompt injections, jailbreaks, and other
attacks that allow adversaries to overwrite a model's original instructions
with their own malicious prompts. In this work, we argue that one of the
primary vulnerabilities underlying these attacks is that LLMs often consider
system prompts (e.g., text from an application developer) to be the same
priority as text from untrusted users and third parties. To address this, we
propose an instruction hierarchy that explicitly defines how models should
behave when instructions of different priorities conflict. We then propose a
data generation method to demonstrate this hierarchical instruction following
behavior, which teaches LLMs to selectively ignore lower-privileged
instructions. We apply this method to GPT-3.5, showing that it drastically
increases robustness -- even for attack types not seen during training -- while
imposing minimal degradations on standard capabilities.
|
[
-0.06836453825235367,
-0.6016466021537781,
0.5513710379600525,
-0.11684085428714752,
0.01502482034265995,
0.12375915050506592,
0.29995158314704895,
-0.27028870582580566,
-0.2497081309556961,
0.5760676860809326,
-0.6261749863624573,
-0.6354530453681946,
-0.7986684441566467,
-0.1761772781610489,
-0.20044302940368652,
1.1615220308303833,
0.07099424302577972,
-0.12376286089420319,
-0.326393723487854,
0.3214174807071686,
-0.550071656703949,
-0.968151330947876,
-0.5831090211868286,
-0.0885973796248436,
0.4048435091972351,
0.7130734324455261,
0.8627503514289856,
0.8155384659767151,
0.6253873109817505,
0.3302202522754669,
0.027713051065802574,
-0.1180829182267189,
-0.4461117386817932,
0.4333001375198364,
0.03987640514969826,
-0.39292189478874207,
-0.8461208343505859,
-0.060006048530340195,
0.40214428305625916,
0.43941444158554077,
0.04028595983982086,
-0.009264123626053333,
0.2781321406364441,
0.5701006650924683,
-0.6850435733795166,
-0.16492876410484314,
-0.8478116393089294,
0.14358381927013397,
-0.18437916040420532,
-0.5717416405677795,
-0.5631734728813171,
-0.26518967747688293,
0.057716336101293564,
-0.3362768888473511,
0.26497775316238403,
0.022282132878899574,
0.616165816783905,
0.28185439109802246,
-0.37976935505867004,
-0.09087667614221573,
-0.3499929904937744,
0.6613211035728455,
-0.23294202983379364,
-0.056454092264175415,
0.474857896566391,
0.10802695900201797,
-0.3186437487602234,
-0.37721607089042664,
0.12697277963161469,
-0.41481852531433105,
-0.008131752721965313,
0.07504498213529587,
-0.2769858241081238,
0.4020954668521881,
0.45427241921424866,
0.22306585311889648,
-0.5734445452690125,
0.45200011134147644,
-0.3365291953086853,
-0.13230612874031067,
0.3739071488380432,
0.4697871804237366,
0.31290555000305176,
-0.05732524022459984,
-0.7920876145362854,
0.10561610013246536,
-1.2072824239730835,
0.0759161040186882,
0.5131232142448425,
0.2557412087917328,
-0.02950136922299862,
0.4814680218696594,
-0.0895301103591919,
0.7026951909065247,
0.25967028737068176,
0.010870045982301235,
-0.038158487528562546,
0.06731411814689636,
-0.5022547841072083,
0.2154306322336197,
0.5041598677635193,
0.4085273742675781,
-0.09537791460752487,
-0.2275952845811844,
-0.35505205392837524,
-0.14492106437683105,
0.44028520584106445,
-0.714055597782135,
-0.08976345509290695,
0.3294740915298462,
-0.22589901089668274,
-0.6738654971122742,
-0.04560884088277817,
-0.6344000697135925,
-0.6210620403289795,
-0.01730361394584179,
0.3184959590435028,
-0.2897915840148926,
0.2910122275352478,
-0.015883125364780426,
0.07596506923437119,
0.2509494423866272,
0.22497734427452087,
-1.4382015466690063,
0.39122703671455383,
0.9199123382568359,
0.5087217092514038,
-0.2367364466190338,
-0.33411192893981934,
-0.7678452134132385,
0.5969585180282593,
-0.21538758277893066,
0.4961205720901489,
-0.5286075472831726,
-0.6245297789573669,
-0.08640781044960022,
-0.15496982634067535,
-0.09512511640787125,
-0.6686935424804688,
0.37837398052215576,
-0.6490659713745117,
-0.025456028059124947,
-0.32022276520729065,
-0.5379989743232727,
0.4180121421813965,
0.1610819548368454,
-0.2647462487220764,
0.8560498952865601,
0.05166028439998627,
-0.8190737366676331,
0.23434998095035553,
-0.5094568729400635,
-0.4293918311595917,
0.1146550253033638,
-0.27474263310432434,
-0.3375391960144043,
-0.07226457446813583,
0.30724233388900757,
0.5993014574050903,
-0.11617176979780197,
-0.019226619973778725,
-0.15376827120780945,
-0.4228658080101013,
-0.09435965120792389,
-0.3906612992286682,
0.6969478130340576,
0.11120598018169403,
-0.46075326204299927,
0.2943369746208191,
-0.5851578116416931,
0.06103263050317764,
0.08165701478719711,
-0.39982402324676514,
-0.3362202048301697,
0.016535194590687752,
-0.7487156391143799,
-0.12685365974903107,
0.5018947124481201,
-0.07188031822443008,
0.6009431481361389,
-0.2637285888195038,
0.3476703464984894,
1.260791540145874,
0.22610534727573395,
0.5383814573287964,
-0.4673709571361542,
0.5043981075286865,
0.15550576150417328,
0.6618174314498901,
-0.022099554538726807,
-0.601239025592804,
-0.6534582376480103,
-0.1336066871881485,
-0.23635916411876678,
0.9321393370628357,
-0.6358767747879028,
0.4280550479888916,
-0.14888189733028412,
-0.28313836455345154,
-0.19538132846355438,
0.2722603976726532,
0.6099004745483398,
0.5177438259124756,
0.4295755922794342,
-0.04883057624101639,
-0.44019997119903564,
-0.9440717101097107,
-0.12707018852233887,
-0.4141470789909363,
-0.14983345568180084,
-0.004817251116037369,
0.22273020446300507,
-0.21361300349235535,
0.4881640076637268,
-0.42571333050727844,
0.1738618016242981,
-0.13571490347385406,
0.04051667079329491,
-0.062431346625089645,
0.7710551023483276,
0.3632843494415283,
-0.44766125082969666,
-0.06561461091041565,
-0.21313315629959106,
-0.7342560291290283,
-0.3509407937526703,
0.04956500232219696,
-0.29180070757865906,
-0.022624582052230835,
0.7842715978622437,
-0.4565637707710266,
0.3320279121398926,
0.2287411093711853,
0.03648943081498146,
0.3499172329902649,
-0.22655537724494934,
0.153750941157341,
-1.0800145864486694,
-0.415823757648468,
-0.1961464285850525,
0.038280509412288666,
-0.7947084903717041,
0.21922247111797333,
-0.008646169677376747,
-0.22332358360290527,
-0.4851880967617035,
0.27815476059913635,
-0.38474035263061523,
-0.26768049597740173,
0.012727003544569016,
-0.14400050044059753,
-0.1435628980398178,
0.31887108087539673,
-0.12256160378456116,
1.012679934501648,
0.6947389841079712,
-0.7669298052787781,
0.18601182103157043,
-0.018832162022590637,
0.03242992237210274,
0.5824252367019653,
-0.6207225322723389,
0.33266985416412354,
0.012395037338137627,
-0.18572171032428741,
-0.8393346071243286,
-0.26036378741264343,
0.45432236790657043,
-0.20043635368347168,
0.6251296401023865,
-0.4315982460975647,
-0.38041287660598755,
-0.27745744585990906,
-0.44693461060523987,
-0.006923603359609842,
0.6448410153388977,
-0.5406742095947266,
0.1587980091571808,
0.3594937324523926,
-0.12543371319770813,
-0.946902334690094,
-0.4998927414417267,
-0.04005919396877289,
-0.39947816729545593,
-0.46113866567611694,
0.36923590302467346,
-0.10049737989902496,
-0.1778857707977295,
-0.269734650850296,
-0.25499215722084045,
-0.14759546518325806,
0.5354585647583008,
0.501531183719635,
0.5779178738594055,
-0.12494596093893051,
-0.17854146659374237,
0.03576614707708359,
-0.13162797689437866,
0.1701701581478119,
-0.3101365566253662,
0.22716015577316284,
-0.07992776483297348,
-0.7374119758605957,
-0.5314327478408813,
0.39459583163261414,
0.4637875258922577,
0.09073123335838318,
0.4154895842075348,
0.0658394917845726,
-0.125733882188797,
-0.00028653544723056257,
-0.1538396179676056,
-0.20608611404895782,
-0.5933168530464172,
0.3671647310256958,
-0.25110745429992676,
-0.7762951254844666,
0.2558327615261078,
0.054803572595119476,
0.35946884751319885,
0.021748235449194908,
0.37061962485313416,
-0.09267968684434891,
1.2199552059173584,
0.7118804454803467,
-0.32221662998199463,
0.6522210240364075,
-0.07694448530673981,
-0.01884475350379944,
-0.6146314144134521,
-0.12568077445030212,
-0.4158321022987366,
-0.2233511060476303,
-0.6836618781089783,
-0.2431952804327011,
0.3914899230003357,
0.12797965109348297,
-0.6500921249389648,
0.28689056634902954,
-0.7199994921684265,
0.8196914196014404,
0.6634311676025391,
0.1726548671722412,
0.12165545672178268,
0.17592863738536835,
-0.1934337615966797,
0.1722029447555542,
-0.7670505046844482,
-0.8172387480735779,
1.010133147239685,
0.4257655441761017,
0.9725772142410278,
0.12099584192037582,
1.2253438234329224,
0.2563687562942505,
0.4685567021369934,
-0.587734043598175,
0.8642767071723938,
-0.20402978360652924,
-0.441712886095047,
0.006052406504750252,
-0.48600104451179504,
-1.0161784887313843,
0.08609097450971603,
0.1955012083053589,
-0.817375123500824,
-0.04645964130759239,
0.30934619903564453,
-0.6436125636100769,
0.3665010333061218,
-1.1063740253448486,
0.6939713358879089,
-0.21509172022342682,
-0.4923076033592224,
0.2601467967033386,
-0.7413473129272461,
0.40189027786254883,
0.3042512834072113,
-0.1302090585231781,
0.0800718143582344,
-0.2319953888654709,
0.48321831226348877,
-0.48829010128974915,
1.174170970916748,
-0.2941431403160095,
-0.25472670793533325,
0.06517823785543442,
0.09449625760316849,
0.47673407196998596,
0.08025302737951279,
0.11358973383903503,
-0.2645566463470459,
-0.41674336791038513,
-0.6042255163192749,
-0.40681856870651245,
0.7332675457000732,
-0.9378774762153625,
-1.3476648330688477,
-0.3167836666107178,
-0.5348526239395142,
-0.4213280975818634,
-0.0463276244699955,
0.48842841386795044,
0.32307687401771545,
-0.010748650878667831,
-0.09514901787042618,
0.9396623373031616,
-0.08865278959274292,
0.3212727904319763,
0.3169696033000946,
0.2855320870876312,
-0.1917484998703003,
0.7670247554779053,
0.07540752738714218,
0.7279632091522217,
0.43125811219215393,
-0.06685216724872589,
0.13698816299438477,
-0.7658296227455139,
-0.5885640382766724,
-0.4438639283180237,
-0.8667122721672058,
-0.3945050835609436,
-0.40730345249176025,
-0.458441823720932,
-0.33705365657806396,
-0.5592654347419739,
-0.004323120228946209,
-0.2787289321422577,
-0.37715163826942444,
-0.3299643397331238,
0.28672412037849426,
0.7743622660636902,
0.16580727696418762,
0.5675247311592102,
-0.809137225151062,
0.22609668970108032,
0.7420634031295776,
0.03550351411104202,
-0.11235584318637848,
-0.4542901813983917,
0.028584420680999756,
-0.15572303533554077,
-0.789176881313324,
-0.8448371291160583,
-0.009959584102034569,
-0.20819804072380066,
0.8127226829528809,
0.301196813583374,
-0.011158900335431099,
0.49261248111724854,
-0.5353570580482483,
0.8326337337493896,
0.05437084287405014,
-0.9008997678756714,
0.9172142148017883,
-0.3573675751686096,
0.12928232550621033,
0.44186368584632874,
0.5311713814735413,
-0.012105735950171947,
-0.7396279573440552,
-0.7728899717330933,
-0.9941810369491577,
0.6798355579376221,
0.11508993804454803,
0.2457227259874344,
-0.14257963001728058,
0.3352598547935486,
-0.12313075363636017,
0.13019168376922607,
-0.657748818397522,
-0.36288753151893616,
-0.09094855934381485,
-0.10766618698835373,
0.410656213760376,
-0.38632482290267944,
-0.34851551055908203,
0.008947915397584438,
0.3672993779182434,
0.20232979953289032,
0.2810329496860504,
-0.019785834476351738,
0.03662038967013359,
-0.035502657294273376,
0.5726920962333679,
0.5332139134407043,
0.2884882092475891,
-0.21285367012023926,
0.46268558502197266,
0.20249710977077484,
-0.7774435877799988,
0.4593096077442169,
-0.05955079570412636,
-0.3069537580013275,
-0.5656261444091797,
0.5358497500419617,
0.7316957712173462,
0.3433113992214203,
-0.20455940067768097,
0.42824286222457886,
0.05836434289813042,
-0.17977122962474823,
0.23757115006446838,
0.6682140231132507,
-0.18417894840240479,
0.16611532866954803,
0.3180253505706787,
0.2950805723667145,
0.021838178858160973,
-0.5061225295066833,
0.3397786021232605,
0.3062496483325958,
-0.20071643590927124,
-0.22294200956821442,
0.5535034537315369,
0.21106131374835968,
-0.03410307317972183,
0.26808544993400574,
-0.1171785220503807,
-0.6048510074615479,
0.782871663570404,
0.5247851610183716,
0.889091432094574,
-0.6693747639656067,
0.13516750931739807,
-0.012878687120974064,
0.642163097858429,
0.02592983841896057,
0.3313969075679779,
0.11282261461019516,
-0.5297762155532837,
0.13622139394283295,
-0.15355952084064484,
-0.6951701045036316,
0.2577632963657379,
-0.6529882550239563,
0.20451225340366364,
-0.9246591925621033,
-0.14177101850509644,
-0.07294191420078278,
-0.16318237781524658,
-0.2975870966911316,
-0.017959434539079666,
0.2555356025695801,
0.594172477722168,
-0.7039699554443359,
0.7326564788818359,
0.5003660917282104,
-0.19609543681144714,
-0.6000807881355286,
0.37688103318214417,
0.22539524734020233,
-1.0904731750488281,
0.854264497756958,
0.22571048140525818,
-0.17218835651874542,
0.016581010073423386,
-0.6872560381889343,
-0.5967434644699097,
1.0673065185546875,
0.5759530067443848,
-0.3183082342147827,
0.032646652311086655,
0.06543156504631042,
0.22323136031627655,
-0.38987308740615845,
-0.03860798105597496,
0.36568450927734375,
0.2617037296295166,
0.16289108991622925,
-0.4197281301021576,
0.0956069752573967,
-0.11528802663087845,
-0.09732136875391006,
0.1445639431476593,
-0.41723448038101196,
0.9728060960769653,
-0.4968258738517761,
-0.2862061858177185,
0.10348355025053024,
0.4115139842033386,
0.42584115266799927,
0.1519571840763092,
0.32923805713653564,
0.4713461101055145,
0.7977953553199768,
-0.03193194791674614,
1.0934135913848877,
-0.1926737278699875,
-0.22539512813091278,
1.181449294090271,
-0.4981316328048706,
0.6987497210502625,
0.380586177110672,
0.03064509853720665,
0.1932590901851654,
0.8114022612571716,
0.06230469420552254,
0.6571581363677979,
0.2695414125919342,
-0.3799975514411926,
-0.13596069812774658,
0.13244827091693878,
-0.5988763570785522,
0.029716242104768753,
0.306623637676239,
-0.401793897151947,
-0.3327502906322479,
-0.10518894344568253,
0.23272106051445007,
-0.19106262922286987,
-0.5718592405319214,
0.8182728290557861,
-0.116934634745121,
-0.5419570803642273,
1.0415668487548828,
-0.08905873447656631,
0.4857172966003418,
-0.5693954825401306,
0.14133493602275848,
-0.16234718263149261,
0.01085228007286787,
-0.2835982143878937,
-0.8813024163246155,
0.02554268203675747,
0.3114171028137207,
-0.3661036491394043,
-0.3898128569126129,
0.6474663615226746,
-0.0686173215508461,
-0.11926852911710739,
0.2358427494764328,
0.30856460332870483,
-0.05256034806370735,
0.3104839622974396,
-0.8470512628555298,
-0.037610121071338654,
-0.10063375532627106,
-0.3333781361579895,
0.62558513879776,
0.4477710425853729,
-0.3276435434818268,
0.7160624861717224,
0.4875612258911133,
-0.03058370016515255,
0.22903943061828613,
0.26771873235702515,
1.172616958618164,
-0.3272210955619812,
-0.3205687999725342,
-1.0821640491485596,
0.32900193333625793,
-0.17174898087978363,
-0.0766248106956482,
0.7408137321472168,
0.41610848903656006,
0.7716049551963806,
0.08084597438573837,
0.906335711479187,
0.15354220569133759,
0.08435121923685074,
-0.7813169956207275,
0.41061726212501526,
-0.1787368357181549,
0.9224874377250671,
-0.20769017934799194,
-0.46510064601898193,
-0.24585959315299988,
0.33398523926734924,
-0.6798784732818604,
0.22578279674053192,
0.5888372659683228,
0.9090158939361572,
-0.061601422727108,
0.0641409382224083,
0.3003714084625244,
0.08892121911048889,
0.2596890330314636,
0.8887410163879395,
1.1438323259353638,
-0.31244605779647827,
0.39074888825416565,
-0.10446149855852127,
-0.46073246002197266,
-0.19251790642738342,
-0.9012448191642761,
-1.0326836109161377,
-0.2016482651233673,
-0.11700713634490967,
-0.22779478132724762,
0.40195152163505554,
0.8681085705757141,
0.6514335870742798,
-0.621322751045227,
-0.1832735240459442,
-0.11992180347442627,
0.4110229015350342,
-0.09942828863859177,
-0.1274750679731369,
0.19355469942092896,
-0.55460125207901,
-0.28889694809913635,
0.5693206191062927,
0.2847052812576294,
0.5323273539543152,
-0.10365588217973709,
0.025182342156767845,
0.26344114542007446,
-0.03442251682281494,
0.44088685512542725,
0.10512369871139526,
-0.3989614248275757,
-0.45899975299835205,
0.03215301036834717,
-0.49057143926620483,
0.1134524866938591,
0.8992468118667603,
-0.3957147002220154,
0.028471222147345543,
0.31972917914390564,
0.6343238949775696,
-0.20624499022960663,
-0.06284935027360916,
0.5793927907943726,
-1.137864351272583,
0.08346988260746002,
0.20781946182250977,
0.24953706562519073,
0.25356489419937134,
-0.9000381827354431,
0.2508365213871002,
0.16141819953918457,
-0.5784822702407837,
-0.8213881850242615,
0.44418662786483765,
-0.6291429996490479,
-0.1451718807220459,
1.019777536392212,
-0.3142992854118347,
-0.29981037974357605,
-0.20424941182136536,
-0.24859532713890076,
-0.11554134637117386,
-0.4122134745121002,
0.7566103935241699,
0.4673095643520355,
-0.10990230739116669,
-0.01791878417134285,
-0.8994890451431274,
0.7600793242454529,
0.35458433628082275,
-0.9671804308891296,
0.4749547243118286,
0.3578941524028778,
0.11554547399282455,
-0.12625931203365326,
0.6108049750328064,
-0.2029411941766739,
0.25210297107696533,
-0.1482698917388916,
-0.28175050020217896,
-0.04570990800857544,
-0.5630567073822021,
-0.3368157148361206,
0.32851749658584595,
0.18429367244243622,
-0.33270344138145447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13192v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13192v1
|
Heterogeneous Subgraph Transformer for Fake News Detection
| 2024-04-19T21:39:37 | 2024-04-19T21:39:37 |
Yuchen Zhang, Xiaoxiao Ma, Jia Wu, Jian Yang, Hao Fan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Fake news is pervasive on social media, inflicting substantial harm on public
discourse and societal well-being. We investigate the explicit structural
information and textual features of news pieces by constructing a heterogeneous
graph concerning the relations among news topics, entities, and content.
Through our study, we reveal that fake news can be effectively detected in
terms of the atypical heterogeneous subgraphs centered on them, which
encapsulate the essential semantics and intricate relations between news
elements. However, suffering from the heterogeneity, exploring such
heterogeneous subgraphs remains an open problem. To bridge the gap, this work
proposes a heterogeneous subgraph transformer (HeteroSGT) to exploit subgraphs
in our constructed heterogeneous graph. In HeteroSGT, we first employ a
pre-trained language model to derive both word-level and sentence-level
semantics. Then the random walk with restart (RWR) is applied to extract
subgraphs centered on each news, which are further fed to our proposed subgraph
Transformer to quantify the authenticity. Extensive experiments on five
real-world datasets demonstrate the superior performance of HeteroSGT over five
baselines. Further case and ablation studies validate our motivation and
demonstrate that performance improvement stems from our specially designed
components.
|
[
-0.36947235465049744,
-1.3386861085891724,
0.5623471140861511,
0.24863992631435394,
-0.47377562522888184,
0.3336045444011688,
0.15700405836105347,
-0.4729490280151367,
0.6723751425743103,
0.34726619720458984,
-0.5359747409820557,
-0.49298277497291565,
-0.5910232067108154,
-0.10343442857265472,
-0.6380811333656311,
0.903030514717102,
0.010877811349928379,
-0.21230778098106384,
-0.03646833077073097,
-0.116580531001091,
-0.12170659005641937,
-0.09013106673955917,
-0.18118324875831604,
-0.5407866835594177,
0.4256790578365326,
0.1605549454689026,
0.9160263538360596,
0.6084526777267456,
0.013835861347615719,
0.2711225748062134,
0.18233957886695862,
0.17248688638210297,
-0.5772814750671387,
-0.3230307102203369,
-0.2081012725830078,
-0.17758677899837494,
-0.2274235486984253,
0.3230728507041931,
0.7006800174713135,
0.42563214898109436,
-0.01763112097978592,
0.18187490105628967,
-0.40831077098846436,
0.2082403302192688,
-0.32623395323753357,
-0.04845884069800377,
-0.6701516509056091,
0.2720050811767578,
-0.4999538064002991,
-0.4499532878398895,
-0.3907000720500946,
-0.5282790660858154,
-0.1773572862148285,
-0.7138283252716064,
0.48028984665870667,
0.3223494589328766,
1.4609280824661255,
0.1326640397310257,
-0.3237411379814148,
0.08564519882202148,
-0.7390191555023193,
0.3274112045764923,
-0.4582199454307556,
0.6218727827072144,
0.024894308298826218,
0.6089719533920288,
-0.03687793388962746,
-1.0532314777374268,
-0.8870070576667786,
-0.12433147430419922,
-0.3745777904987335,
0.22599701583385468,
-0.6359773278236389,
-0.3773958683013916,
0.18049202859401703,
0.41517624258995056,
-0.6067413687705994,
0.18989433348178864,
-0.230921670794487,
-0.6966781616210938,
0.2252189815044403,
-0.06262777745723724,
0.6108600497245789,
-0.3984677195549011,
-0.5062536597251892,
0.11314874142408371,
-0.4563683569431305,
-0.308819055557251,
0.8874339461326599,
0.3687303364276886,
-0.02347572334110737,
0.5424203872680664,
-0.25553226470947266,
0.40445101261138916,
0.20259644091129303,
-0.30937644839286804,
0.679751992225647,
-0.2221069037914276,
-0.07106681913137436,
0.2822220027446747,
0.6327740550041199,
0.09955300390720367,
0.25165918469429016,
-0.26657065749168396,
-0.21383900940418243,
0.3658536970615387,
0.38980963826179504,
-0.632497251033783,
-0.3166010081768036,
0.006656541023403406,
-0.7657375335693359,
-0.44153961539268494,
0.2262057662010193,
-0.7649670243263245,
-0.32700634002685547,
-0.10932787507772446,
0.311551570892334,
-0.5047323703765869,
-0.429578959941864,
0.008045782335102558,
-0.466539204120636,
-0.018490085378289223,
0.32227206230163574,
-0.1265169382095337,
0.1019255667924881,
0.3826009929180145,
0.6652549505233765,
0.06148446351289749,
-0.37041962146759033,
-0.7592689394950867,
-0.030923768877983093,
-0.28845760226249695,
1.071547269821167,
-0.4318370819091797,
0.006881856359541416,
0.057030219584703445,
0.17778079211711884,
0.13116975128650665,
-0.3173064589500427,
0.6192574501037598,
-0.6709770560264587,
0.4205609858036041,
-0.07997183501720428,
-0.5368502736091614,
0.17919021844863892,
0.559481143951416,
-0.8637739419937134,
0.9954349398612976,
0.3823252022266388,
-1.1021013259887695,
0.3710644543170929,
-0.4551517963409424,
-0.8160427212715149,
0.26763513684272766,
-0.20050197839736938,
-0.6894707083702087,
-0.056457385420799255,
0.31251585483551025,
0.18900346755981445,
0.08575432747602463,
-0.028551658615469933,
-0.10171757638454437,
-0.37579619884490967,
-0.025373166427016258,
-0.6815417408943176,
0.7604186534881592,
0.11311027407646179,
-0.27063047885894775,
0.05730189010500908,
-0.708821713924408,
-0.1802523285150528,
0.2270079106092453,
-0.28683218359947205,
-0.40960079431533813,
-0.17728526890277863,
0.1448814421892166,
0.15212947130203247,
0.006502717267721891,
-0.9091314673423767,
-0.02300485037267208,
-0.05145207419991493,
0.07028687000274658,
0.6093644499778748,
0.1601717174053192,
0.4109122157096863,
-0.29045745730400085,
0.361983984708786,
0.1488889455795288,
0.19632373750209808,
-0.13371698558330536,
-0.5395201444625854,
-0.36019518971443176,
-0.28398165106773376,
0.4154183268547058,
0.6169933676719666,
-0.9290295243263245,
0.3163560628890991,
-0.5051248669624329,
-0.5342147946357727,
-0.5407583117485046,
-0.27268511056900024,
0.2133341282606125,
0.6903038620948792,
0.5997874140739441,
0.04568510875105858,
-0.5621374249458313,
-0.9667976498603821,
-0.7393398880958557,
0.04348022863268852,
0.11724299937486649,
-0.0075772833079099655,
0.37909016013145447,
-0.42652076482772827,
1.1938867568969727,
-0.4121563732624054,
-0.3520238399505615,
-0.1380765736103058,
0.34162867069244385,
-0.00813381839543581,
0.25225621461868286,
0.660515546798706,
-1.1793545484542847,
-0.4779183864593506,
0.03826984390616417,
-0.555647611618042,
-0.16114716231822968,
-0.12053230404853821,
0.10999607294797897,
0.32357752323150635,
0.773494303226471,
-0.5219500660896301,
0.6646655201911926,
0.5764752626419067,
-0.3507081866264343,
0.7027734518051147,
0.051591288298368454,
0.25822755694389343,
-0.7792381048202515,
-0.23463308811187744,
0.15492525696754456,
-0.6583281755447388,
-0.5933449864387512,
-0.4230852723121643,
0.006663141306489706,
-0.06422290205955505,
-0.4601869583129883,
0.31420445442199707,
-0.32988429069519043,
-0.19457201659679413,
-0.30280688405036926,
0.030950237065553665,
-0.007247284986078739,
0.156634122133255,
-0.12901094555854797,
0.23985932767391205,
0.16957098245620728,
-0.0757465735077858,
0.5127161145210266,
-0.01749015785753727,
-0.47559496760368347,
0.548719584941864,
-0.5701854825019836,
0.0176628977060318,
-0.4062349796295166,
0.8429322838783264,
-1.040242314338684,
-0.4548916220664978,
0.40976953506469727,
-0.6310935020446777,
-0.04429464787244797,
-0.19526374340057373,
-0.6852132081985474,
-0.5761318206787109,
-0.06930606812238693,
0.06633702665567398,
0.49243706464767456,
-0.6612133979797363,
1.0298433303833008,
0.2390812635421753,
0.4871748387813568,
-0.3810443580150604,
-0.7827625274658203,
-0.034262195229530334,
0.016633810475468636,
-0.6888135075569153,
0.5768745541572571,
0.43324923515319824,
-0.16311399638652802,
0.681791365146637,
-0.38050416111946106,
0.10502219200134277,
-0.17841777205467224,
0.33005833625793457,
0.0827871561050415,
-0.37573960423469543,
0.10964646935462952,
0.17472966015338898,
-0.2699855864048004,
-0.21075715124607086,
-0.33141472935676575,
0.7528645992279053,
-0.09221918135881424,
-0.4610477387905121,
-0.6057301759719849,
0.256938099861145,
0.6741509437561035,
-0.17494988441467285,
0.9111064076423645,
0.9703333973884583,
-0.6048551797866821,
-0.31985706090927124,
-0.4849860370159149,
-0.10645923763513565,
-0.43479299545288086,
0.38929885625839233,
-0.32996082305908203,
-0.680211067199707,
0.38913610577583313,
-0.16958339512348175,
-0.25148722529411316,
0.43000346422195435,
0.34217217564582825,
0.1178920641541481,
0.9113094806671143,
0.6990754008293152,
-0.3308495879173279,
0.5573590993881226,
0.15457595884799957,
0.4949131906032562,
-0.08061305433511734,
-0.23997992277145386,
-0.3632243573665619,
-0.28260931372642517,
-0.5792402029037476,
-0.374409943819046,
0.3393082022666931,
-0.32304298877716064,
-0.13221168518066406,
0.36894676089286804,
-0.2873774766921997,
0.5874326825141907,
0.3610326945781708,
0.19027233123779297,
0.5451956987380981,
0.34496116638183594,
0.13603805005550385,
0.005968810059130192,
-0.7560269236564636,
-0.45020389556884766,
0.44084060192108154,
0.6510048508644104,
0.9184625148773193,
-0.1179284080862999,
0.43530741333961487,
0.5154255032539368,
0.6499817371368408,
-0.5550830960273743,
0.25784748792648315,
-0.19121477007865906,
-0.4218171238899231,
-0.40773752331733704,
-0.5051701068878174,
-0.6961475014686584,
0.3127986788749695,
-0.36554837226867676,
-0.5164690613746643,
0.10202819854021072,
0.2679298222064972,
-0.018654216080904007,
0.5561431050300598,
-0.631519079208374,
0.6593353748321533,
0.09907539188861847,
0.09754743427038193,
-0.0531119629740715,
-0.5992646217346191,
0.3803706467151642,
-0.027574962005019188,
0.4369218945503235,
-0.012111099436879158,
0.48317161202430725,
0.3945729434490204,
-0.18875259160995483,
0.8208913803100586,
-0.17733131349086761,
-0.07780714333057404,
0.1252450793981552,
-0.0024838829413056374,
0.6741628050804138,
0.19733482599258423,
0.1713707149028778,
0.23088324069976807,
-0.5044247508049011,
-0.45978471636772156,
-0.4222148358821869,
0.5972018241882324,
-0.6434427499771118,
-0.3018544018268585,
-0.32853958010673523,
-0.5848886370658875,
-0.2149939239025116,
0.4941180646419525,
0.705574095249176,
0.36474522948265076,
-0.4286382794380188,
0.0391911044716835,
0.6953608393669128,
-0.13442206382751465,
0.12835173308849335,
0.3420524001121521,
-0.32759565114974976,
0.016571305692195892,
1.1078226566314697,
0.26285460591316223,
0.10521971434354782,
0.30403071641921997,
0.27077189087867737,
-0.19727373123168945,
-0.2928580045700073,
-0.32972484827041626,
0.20825450122356415,
-0.6014205813407898,
-0.1076834499835968,
-0.8858448266983032,
-0.35237056016921997,
-0.7581334710121155,
-0.11014820635318756,
-0.6380272507667542,
-0.17432214319705963,
-0.03879307210445404,
-0.25980037450790405,
0.013281135819852352,
0.4081174433231354,
-0.06723907589912415,
0.16845837235450745,
-0.6107470989227295,
0.822644829750061,
0.37412354350090027,
0.23435509204864502,
-0.27608612179756165,
-0.3780783712863922,
-0.12330666184425354,
0.13967721164226532,
0.06479279696941376,
-0.7621967792510986,
0.18409596383571625,
-0.2776069939136505,
0.6700893044471741,
0.2911548614501953,
0.2302800565958023,
0.4764825403690338,
-0.547199547290802,
0.6075048446655273,
0.15250016748905182,
-0.8805772066116333,
0.3538531959056854,
-0.4679943025112152,
-0.04394247755408287,
0.1309812366962433,
0.547772228717804,
-0.5146811604499817,
-0.44843560457229614,
-0.8486025929450989,
-0.6784855723381042,
0.4955301284790039,
0.22613602876663208,
0.1755896359682083,
0.07686686515808105,
0.10475035756826401,
0.01009534765034914,
0.20852309465408325,
-0.9714866876602173,
-0.3065584599971771,
-0.9474326372146606,
-0.0457763634622097,
0.1931132823228836,
0.013791893608868122,
-0.34325504302978516,
-0.04740585759282112,
0.6647594571113586,
-0.20759491622447968,
0.3645062744617462,
0.1881037950515747,
-0.10900740325450897,
-0.2611352503299713,
0.029738718643784523,
0.35393184423446655,
0.3899170756340027,
-0.026681439951062202,
0.3698994517326355,
-0.06295882165431976,
-0.5848712921142578,
-0.15822388231754303,
0.338699609041214,
-0.21123690903186798,
0.358803927898407,
0.7335219979286194,
0.7547120451927185,
-0.2364991456270218,
-0.30983966588974,
0.6727949976921082,
-0.04931815341114998,
-0.3256668448448181,
-0.1737401783466339,
-0.26004841923713684,
0.029418636113405228,
0.3398803770542145,
0.6307209730148315,
0.06533323228359222,
-0.021039189770817757,
-0.9496785402297974,
0.334787517786026,
0.21979275345802307,
-0.5091845989227295,
-0.23124155402183533,
0.3912951648235321,
-0.030382562428712845,
-0.38743582367897034,
0.5724583268165588,
-0.21536803245544434,
-0.8939726948738098,
0.5705345869064331,
0.9457137584686279,
0.3869304358959198,
-0.05548730865120888,
0.6581875681877136,
-0.14297603070735931,
0.696830689907074,
-0.051631007343530655,
-0.21363681554794312,
0.43133464455604553,
-1.142328143119812,
-0.18533955514431,
-0.5109999179840088,
-0.12010671198368073,
0.27668192982673645,
-0.2799445390701294,
0.13316063582897186,
-0.2982860803604126,
0.25226351618766785,
0.12375706434249878,
-0.13381372392177582,
-0.23203712701797485,
0.4795722961425781,
0.1333952695131302,
0.9525617957115173,
-1.2647857666015625,
0.7973555326461792,
0.501849353313446,
-0.27455025911331177,
-0.8372088670730591,
0.484556645154953,
0.012928548268973827,
-0.7229205965995789,
0.2886311113834381,
0.07094559073448181,
-0.0596330389380455,
0.1545102298259735,
-0.6469941139221191,
-0.36726438999176025,
0.9508705735206604,
0.5550577640533447,
-0.3003135919570923,
0.03799477219581604,
0.2894379198551178,
0.5347879528999329,
-0.3683941662311554,
-0.16132155060768127,
0.3639601171016693,
0.7446101903915405,
0.05692997947335243,
-0.5486701726913452,
0.22227193415164948,
-0.16457992792129517,
-0.11864083260297775,
0.2982387840747833,
-0.6404507160186768,
1.113423466682434,
0.30915382504463196,
-0.3957970142364502,
-0.37862879037857056,
0.8274314999580383,
0.041939184069633484,
0.5867922902107239,
0.8071828484535217,
0.6334958076477051,
0.773283064365387,
-0.13678087294101715,
1.16537344455719,
0.1243622899055481,
0.422092467546463,
0.983381986618042,
-0.12906970083713531,
0.027936622500419617,
0.3901899456977844,
0.3162141740322113,
0.9475983381271362,
0.30813726782798767,
-0.07596071809530258,
0.4866296350955963,
0.26009702682495117,
-0.064003124833107,
-0.3486923575401306,
-0.1504237800836563,
-0.35608959197998047,
0.24040375649929047,
0.22409766912460327,
-0.29067185521125793,
-0.6411252617835999,
0.37262988090515137,
0.1953294724225998,
0.47242996096611023,
-0.15553025901317596,
-0.026296958327293396,
-0.3200204372406006,
-0.32773348689079285,
-0.022604195401072502,
0.29723262786865234,
0.6542530655860901,
-0.5158454775810242,
-0.05086524412035942,
-0.2629515528678894,
0.016227537766098976,
-0.497344434261322,
-0.5946312546730042,
0.4792111814022064,
-0.3152204751968384,
-0.27760109305381775,
-0.39293012022972107,
1.336030125617981,
-0.23669125139713287,
-0.15612977743148804,
0.238299161195755,
0.5201282501220703,
-0.15895414352416992,
-0.2040511965751648,
-0.32621702551841736,
0.25754067301750183,
-0.12548469007015228,
-0.4996922016143799,
0.15553006529808044,
0.6982635855674744,
-0.28778794407844543,
0.3757643699645996,
0.8517245650291443,
-0.11560383439064026,
0.13652274012565613,
0.2208772599697113,
0.9773687720298767,
-0.3407759964466095,
-0.680618941783905,
-0.5940032601356506,
0.2825818359851837,
-0.375702828168869,
-0.3180667459964752,
1.1357249021530151,
0.6371059417724609,
0.8072908520698547,
0.06217444688081741,
0.8806295394897461,
-0.28466102480888367,
0.571467399597168,
-0.47461044788360596,
0.7729478478431702,
-0.42098307609558105,
0.1513368785381317,
-0.3277483880519867,
-0.6464203596115112,
-0.25403109192848206,
0.5091797113418579,
-0.2630058228969574,
-0.24278607964515686,
0.6551387310028076,
0.6094024181365967,
-0.5508009195327759,
0.11198946833610535,
0.13052119314670563,
0.4041019082069397,
0.4705851376056671,
-0.062221743166446686,
0.7983988523483276,
-0.48351362347602844,
0.5258461236953735,
-0.09690279513597488,
-0.17642104625701904,
-0.25709328055381775,
-0.8859398365020752,
-0.8379997611045837,
-0.4007583260536194,
-0.4406190812587738,
-0.8303216099739075,
0.03581748530268669,
0.43446460366249084,
0.6588869094848633,
-0.34001272916793823,
0.42083120346069336,
-0.3725869655609131,
0.40363210439682007,
-0.1367463320493698,
-0.34883323311805725,
0.34607139229774475,
0.028886428102850914,
-0.6255002021789551,
0.3624679744243622,
0.1338804066181183,
0.05790584906935692,
-0.2278406322002411,
0.1073102131485939,
-0.29387253522872925,
0.28974953293800354,
0.3288532495498657,
0.30087485909461975,
-0.2542477250099182,
-0.714947521686554,
-0.07913259416818619,
-0.2507028877735138,
-0.0447734035551548,
0.910495936870575,
-1.0732028484344482,
-0.06619640439748764,
0.5427573323249817,
0.5111239552497864,
0.6800452470779419,
0.2698366045951843,
0.10912293195724487,
-1.0554049015045166,
0.33353370428085327,
0.2003374546766281,
0.1851491630077362,
0.1787204146385193,
-0.5811378359794617,
0.31815105676651,
0.8797984719276428,
-0.11437695473432541,
-0.9985793232917786,
0.42178940773010254,
-0.9720270037651062,
-0.5936760902404785,
1.1024483442306519,
0.11949563026428223,
-0.47661930322647095,
-0.39998820424079895,
-0.14897452294826508,
0.5002647042274475,
-0.26655784249305725,
0.5804896354675293,
0.3817577064037323,
-0.044058069586753845,
0.06297487020492554,
-0.2916390597820282,
0.1990826278924942,
-0.08614249527454376,
-0.9067025780677795,
-0.46196895837783813,
0.4946643114089966,
0.4992171823978424,
0.6083375215530396,
0.9170700907707214,
-0.20652851462364197,
0.1973877102136612,
0.33953857421875,
-0.27713119983673096,
-0.23256023228168488,
-0.4249926209449768,
0.23232711851596832,
0.5085591077804565,
-0.9057871699333191,
-0.2270241379737854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13163v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13163v1
|
A national longitudinal dataset of skills taught in U.S. higher education curricula
| 2024-04-19T20:14:15 | 2024-04-19T20:14:15 |
Alireza Javadian Sabet, Sarah H. Bana, Renzhe Yu, Morgan R. Frank
|
econ.GN
|
econ.GN, cs.CL, q-fin.EC
|
Higher education plays a critical role in driving an innovative economy by
equipping students with knowledge and skills demanded by the workforce. While
researchers and practitioners have developed data systems to track detailed
occupational skills, such as those established by the U.S. Department of Labor
(DOL), much less effort has been made to document skill development in higher
education at a similar granularity. Here, we fill this gap by presenting a
longitudinal dataset of skills inferred from over three million course syllabi
taught at nearly three thousand U.S. higher education institutions. To
construct this dataset, we apply natural language processing to extract from
course descriptions detailed workplace activities (DWAs) used by the DOL to
describe occupations. We then aggregate these DWAs to create skill profiles for
institutions and academic majors. Our dataset offers a large-scale
representation of college-educated workers and their role in the economy. To
showcase the utility of this dataset, we use it to 1) compare the similarity of
skills taught and skills in the workforce according to the US Bureau of Labor
Statistics, 2) estimate gender differences in acquired skills based on
enrollment data, 3) depict temporal trends in the skills taught in social
science curricula, and 4) connect college majors' skill distinctiveness to
salary differences of graduates. Overall, this dataset can enable new research
on the source of skills in the context of workforce development and provide
actionable insights for shaping the future of higher education to meet evolving
labor demands especially in the face of new technologies.
|
[
0.02529917284846306,
-0.9922552108764648,
0.3363732397556305,
-0.08962488174438477,
0.26027050614356995,
0.42949962615966797,
0.0029171863570809364,
-0.29615965485572815,
0.14208146929740906,
0.5238206386566162,
-0.5490134358406067,
-0.5261006951332092,
-0.2997440993785858,
-0.061302971094846725,
-0.30251359939575195,
0.9941862225532532,
0.4788193106651306,
-0.1502886265516281,
-0.4163602292537689,
-0.0646200031042099,
-0.7692277431488037,
-0.3027856647968292,
-0.5151974558830261,
-0.49605369567871094,
0.5237434506416321,
0.505794107913971,
0.7458004951477051,
0.553764820098877,
0.45559030771255493,
0.18459580838680267,
0.07254363596439362,
-0.10600576549768448,
-0.5434988737106323,
-0.19695794582366943,
0.07411439716815948,
-0.3817407786846161,
-0.6925082802772522,
0.2346934974193573,
0.8513692021369934,
1.350967526435852,
-0.07270098477602005,
0.5163214802742004,
0.15906958281993866,
0.7671693563461304,
-0.41762474179267883,
0.5567436814308167,
-0.2604134678840637,
-0.14229559898376465,
-0.5823554992675781,
-0.07859563827514648,
-0.386752724647522,
-0.7092427015304565,
0.22882063686847687,
-0.6182466745376587,
0.3438587188720703,
-0.44029656052589417,
0.47027865052223206,
-0.08413399755954742,
-0.6449163556098938,
0.1677059680223465,
-0.4583081007003784,
0.8587855696678162,
-0.45955437421798706,
0.5641926527023315,
0.2026967853307724,
0.04796629026532173,
-0.16660615801811218,
-0.6230624914169312,
-0.14895017445087433,
0.09070698171854019,
-0.14822615683078766,
0.11680202931165695,
0.3055129945278168,
-0.2224053293466568,
0.17370270192623138,
0.4998338222503662,
-0.6930460929870605,
0.3597399592399597,
-0.9576553106307983,
-0.005869826301932335,
0.8311816453933716,
0.7360981702804565,
0.07624734938144684,
0.3581283688545227,
-0.04540928825736046,
-0.452409029006958,
-0.7565637230873108,
0.45978015661239624,
0.5092035531997681,
0.33594807982444763,
0.02576068602502346,
0.3904625177383423,
-0.32826703786849976,
0.687213659286499,
-0.372226744890213,
-0.31582576036453247,
0.2262735515832901,
-0.0069991229102015495,
0.07997070997953415,
-0.10553016513586044,
0.3487749397754669,
0.11521049588918686,
0.0776234045624733,
-0.3263649344444275,
0.15719226002693176,
0.13597068190574646,
0.2696838974952698,
-0.28684163093566895,
-0.13946570456027985,
-0.28951534628868103,
-0.3339889347553253,
-0.24071599543094635,
0.02932966686785221,
-0.8172350525856018,
-0.47434085607528687,
-0.4898844361305237,
0.051225464791059494,
0.0002394018811173737,
0.006682794541120529,
-0.0783667042851448,
-0.2567185163497925,
0.23057857155799866,
-0.03347216919064522,
-0.9710010886192322,
0.3576238453388214,
0.7982645630836487,
0.809169590473175,
-0.346976637840271,
-0.4609055519104004,
-0.29594287276268005,
0.04783808812499046,
-0.20147429406642914,
0.30107802152633667,
-0.6561515927314758,
-0.265495240688324,
0.4883342981338501,
0.13900017738342285,
-0.060406316071748734,
-0.40407395362854004,
0.16919226944446564,
-0.6345797181129456,
0.13500386476516724,
-0.33341923356056213,
-0.622381865978241,
-0.30321231484413147,
0.0355529710650444,
-0.7513580918312073,
1.2245887517929077,
0.5955487489700317,
-0.5356639623641968,
0.7335078120231628,
-0.8129200339317322,
-0.4300840497016907,
0.2339995801448822,
-0.47738009691238403,
-0.4082125127315521,
-0.1681365668773651,
-0.22696329653263092,
0.5919533371925354,
0.00007385484786937013,
0.7505933046340942,
-0.22830121219158173,
-0.49659156799316406,
0.17736594378948212,
-0.43395811319351196,
1.2764716148376465,
-0.17328472435474396,
-0.2292647808790207,
-0.28114283084869385,
-0.624652624130249,
-0.32988008856773376,
-0.039866428822278976,
-0.48359614610671997,
-0.1255163997411728,
-0.17943502962589264,
-0.15026813745498657,
-0.03173249959945679,
0.36294323205947876,
-0.3478833734989166,
0.24419833719730377,
-0.19238923490047455,
0.16672900319099426,
0.7239174842834473,
-0.11956262588500977,
0.49457064270973206,
-0.26707887649536133,
0.3606119751930237,
-0.35250797867774963,
0.14428472518920898,
-0.04525879770517349,
-0.5499569773674011,
-0.3828214704990387,
0.04622236639261246,
-0.3277134895324707,
0.37121516466140747,
-0.1414237916469574,
0.20534728467464447,
-0.0031761645805090666,
-0.7136530876159668,
-0.4259473383426666,
0.11133692413568497,
0.2919532060623169,
0.6987056732177734,
0.5743327140808105,
-0.2284603863954544,
-0.4239388108253479,
-0.6436046957969666,
-0.4546583592891693,
-0.029551107436418533,
-0.1128867045044899,
-0.028404545038938522,
0.3979335427284241,
0.051268260926008224,
0.8587886691093445,
-0.9108250737190247,
-0.4324452579021454,
0.026181353256106377,
0.44549113512039185,
0.3690030574798584,
0.327818900346756,
0.33494484424591064,
-0.31819790601730347,
-0.14003033936023712,
0.010442362166941166,
-1.1064027547836304,
-0.07916877418756485,
-0.19366304576396942,
-0.34256041049957275,
-0.15807665884494781,
0.3767288327217102,
-0.024543069303035736,
0.5371555089950562,
0.04255032539367676,
-0.8232239484786987,
0.6039735078811646,
-0.09473421424627304,
0.0659121423959732,
-0.4248776435852051,
0.3411998450756073,
-0.021293295547366142,
0.30987784266471863,
-0.5622754096984863,
-0.2548316419124603,
-0.03883588686585426,
-0.15433242917060852,
-0.047006845474243164,
0.789589524269104,
-0.4330797493457794,
-0.372542142868042,
0.04673977568745613,
-0.005950501654297113,
0.044826652854681015,
0.28879761695861816,
0.05208577215671539,
0.7305684685707092,
0.6139888167381287,
-0.4372340440750122,
0.1173224225640297,
0.6230108737945557,
-0.3450711667537689,
0.7361853718757629,
-0.34824809432029724,
-0.0035775185097008944,
-0.08742793649435043,
0.12261492758989334,
-0.0780501589179039,
-0.2125989943742752,
-0.43307772278785706,
0.024685276672244072,
0.060593679547309875,
0.13433656096458435,
0.14433801174163818,
-0.530198335647583,
-0.12153586000204086,
-0.08380621671676636,
0.4823368489742279,
-0.13346892595291138,
0.3010774254798889,
0.46028202772140503,
-0.4646534323692322,
-0.9290924072265625,
-0.4671744704246521,
-0.10258075594902039,
-0.2007489800453186,
-0.47195106744766235,
0.5682736039161682,
0.3152904808521271,
-0.25129255652427673,
-0.04397212341427803,
-0.07439326494932175,
-0.5944416522979736,
0.4390219449996948,
0.3390888571739197,
0.7527366280555725,
-0.2953795790672302,
0.03169501945376396,
-0.01070162933319807,
-0.11731837689876556,
0.32943063974380493,
-0.27388736605644226,
0.1498590111732483,
0.05196591094136238,
-0.3620266914367676,
-0.2930045425891876,
0.2807063162326813,
0.6040326952934265,
-0.08527153730392456,
0.733268141746521,
0.8090181946754456,
-0.1291780024766922,
0.03247132897377014,
-0.5149421691894531,
-0.6199595928192139,
-0.49191516637802124,
0.44300371408462524,
0.21904343366622925,
-0.9323500990867615,
0.19606512784957886,
0.45942333340644836,
0.8180893659591675,
0.11963561177253723,
0.10699093341827393,
-0.05533847212791443,
0.23925064504146576,
0.7045381665229797,
-0.2260989546775818,
0.5498634576797485,
-0.6318833827972412,
0.3361568748950958,
-0.7480723857879639,
-0.8508354425430298,
-0.2817936837673187,
-0.4259833097457886,
-0.1982586681842804,
-0.31376218795776367,
0.3055058717727661,
-0.19322150945663452,
-0.45805826783180237,
0.22087574005126953,
-0.13660088181495667,
0.40676605701446533,
0.7427384257316589,
0.16267195343971252,
0.3861161768436432,
0.030413564294576645,
0.40882328152656555,
-0.0203715693205595,
-0.25719520449638367,
-0.7645361423492432,
1.260501503944397,
0.3607814908027649,
0.4950787127017975,
-0.05452990159392357,
0.4771137535572052,
0.608604371547699,
0.3302239179611206,
-0.36524689197540283,
0.5319250226020813,
-0.4787476658821106,
-0.5564749240875244,
-0.7210415601730347,
-0.34027454257011414,
-0.8852582573890686,
-0.2765420973300934,
-0.37478703260421753,
-0.41193029284477234,
0.04021492600440979,
0.1803237497806549,
-0.2809434235095978,
0.3490617573261261,
-0.22311800718307495,
0.9973995089530945,
-0.18513451516628265,
-0.6101202368736267,
-0.33005115389823914,
-0.5529478192329407,
-0.035927824676036835,
-0.013854584656655788,
0.2837783396244049,
-0.38334572315216064,
0.27747446298599243,
1.1534059047698975,
-0.09693902730941772,
0.8723048567771912,
-0.3099019229412079,
0.04741373285651207,
0.2624509036540985,
-0.05606035888195038,
0.23594149947166443,
0.01969229243695736,
-0.40359431505203247,
0.12796726822853088,
-0.16057607531547546,
-0.45175042748451233,
-0.18883182108402252,
0.6117518544197083,
-0.5828356146812439,
-0.41007107496261597,
-0.10865236818790436,
-0.7378562688827515,
-0.21179454028606415,
0.12996016442775726,
0.0833834707736969,
0.6437671780586243,
-0.6151954531669617,
0.27672335505485535,
0.5500608682632446,
0.19033639132976532,
0.43823081254959106,
0.2587098181247711,
0.29261553287506104,
0.05726461857557297,
0.8931831121444702,
0.7186636924743652,
0.008720869198441505,
0.21738211810588837,
0.010844225063920021,
-0.4129452705383301,
-0.005920322611927986,
-0.04670747369527817,
0.21815620362758636,
-0.6762972474098206,
-0.16227863729000092,
-0.6477788686752319,
-0.1976962685585022,
-0.554094672203064,
-0.8436535596847534,
0.18227362632751465,
-0.059868257492780685,
-0.45439720153808594,
-0.334806352853775,
0.4920397698879242,
0.993658721446991,
0.008865159936249256,
0.12365647405385971,
-0.5599375367164612,
0.14278867840766907,
0.8780158758163452,
0.4453165829181671,
0.16925875842571259,
-0.3860343396663666,
-0.35410556197166443,
0.06186351180076599,
-0.5166376233100891,
-0.7622019648551941,
0.3650391697883606,
0.40775266289711,
0.7235868573188782,
0.5217012166976929,
-0.03283020481467247,
0.4970422089099884,
-0.19075484573841095,
0.7625007629394531,
0.13928008079528809,
-0.6601160168647766,
0.2873936593532562,
-0.44830599427223206,
0.07417071610689163,
0.5504137277603149,
0.6529201865196228,
-0.4992774724960327,
-0.45385271310806274,
-0.6874025464057922,
-1.019899606704712,
0.5822513699531555,
0.03859485313296318,
0.39656057953834534,
0.03163774684071541,
0.09113749116659164,
0.5502732992172241,
0.09547357261180878,
-0.43611621856689453,
-0.3514688014984131,
-0.061951667070388794,
-0.33422935009002686,
-0.09956104308366776,
-0.08855366706848145,
0.04112069308757782,
-0.34584978222846985,
0.5068541765213013,
0.042679086327552795,
-0.17109377682209015,
-0.3095816671848297,
-0.14836204051971436,
0.12198425084352493,
0.4185008704662323,
0.1362401843070984,
1.0629836320877075,
-0.23997816443443298,
0.12093531340360641,
0.37271666526794434,
-0.7739314436912537,
0.10232798010110855,
-0.3238561153411865,
-0.011569385416805744,
-0.05168401077389717,
0.2266237437725067,
0.515365481376648,
0.2997009754180908,
-0.7105128169059753,
0.3981364965438843,
0.5105471611022949,
-0.2777407467365265,
-0.5463694930076599,
0.3774222731590271,
-0.04461100324988365,
0.24642431735992432,
0.7868673801422119,
-0.18916697800159454,
0.2847318947315216,
-0.48574644327163696,
0.33549177646636963,
0.14157873392105103,
-0.4546559751033783,
-0.3765162229537964,
0.6742140054702759,
0.24224258959293365,
-0.02278263121843338,
0.8121705055236816,
0.2198728621006012,
0.21609945595264435,
0.7227380275726318,
0.5995067358016968,
0.5313762426376343,
-0.018557874485850334,
0.2992219626903534,
0.5255714654922485,
-0.19135385751724243,
-0.3573458194732666,
0.21341527998447418,
0.15930365025997162,
-0.32683849334716797,
-0.1008031815290451,
-0.6722527146339417,
-0.31394052505493164,
0.25648102164268494,
-0.9413217902183533,
0.35135987401008606,
-0.26378023624420166,
-0.20724886655807495,
0.04936365783214569,
-0.23147565126419067,
-1.2510017156600952,
0.4993850290775299,
-0.01769164390861988,
0.5416455864906311,
-1.502315640449524,
0.5371392369270325,
0.6502876281738281,
-0.3631318211555481,
-0.4384192228317261,
-0.4892388880252838,
0.09223723411560059,
-0.5696080923080444,
0.8825891613960266,
0.15310081839561462,
0.10136584937572479,
0.1172364205121994,
-0.021471716463565826,
-0.5532822608947754,
1.4182758331298828,
0.23878265917301178,
-0.4995895326137543,
-0.432749480009079,
0.22262917459011078,
0.10522423684597015,
-0.408784955739975,
0.21522198617458344,
0.8969012498855591,
0.3617642819881439,
-0.47150829434394836,
-0.6858459711074829,
-0.19176630675792694,
-0.019390519708395004,
-0.3174039125442505,
0.07375065982341766,
-0.23117594420909882,
0.8907846212387085,
-0.29834771156311035,
-0.1373443305492401,
-0.6122764348983765,
0.5580453276634216,
0.15837670862674713,
0.6971533298492432,
-0.002030189149081707,
0.3920946419239044,
1.1079955101013184,
-0.12580448389053345,
0.17691835761070251,
0.09171487390995026,
0.1520676612854004,
1.032366156578064,
0.0207681804895401,
0.8232019543647766,
0.37022754549980164,
-0.4021708071231842,
0.9234298467636108,
0.24430634081363678,
-0.23478268086910248,
0.08523568511009216,
-0.004809739999473095,
-0.3275432586669922,
-0.07861723750829697,
-0.1868198812007904,
-0.6136682033538818,
0.5842803120613098,
0.3475189507007599,
-0.2677064836025238,
-0.010339860804378986,
0.15152454376220703,
0.08508332818746567,
0.19945837557315826,
-0.37468621134757996,
0.6315606236457825,
-0.08496232330799103,
-0.36651667952537537,
0.0724661648273468,
-0.6327807307243347,
0.5587078928947449,
-0.2887490689754486,
-0.30690595507621765,
-0.4092179238796234,
-0.2590702772140503,
-0.5434437990188599,
-1.2507294416427612,
0.5231890082359314,
0.2218349128961563,
-0.2828328609466553,
-0.24468429386615753,
0.34964922070503235,
-0.3317386507987976,
-0.33021992444992065,
-0.005206609610468149,
0.3859720826148987,
0.19097793102264404,
0.5251497030258179,
0.17187704145908356,
-0.2528570592403412,
-0.19899530708789825,
0.12739931046962738,
0.1547297090291977,
0.2946109175682068,
-0.25691691040992737,
0.7193740010261536,
0.46821320056915283,
0.10390560328960419,
0.2743690609931946,
0.056761398911476135,
0.5130774974822998,
-0.8578432202339172,
-0.5407981276512146,
-0.5309599041938782,
0.8787311911582947,
-0.48250696063041687,
-0.7044102549552917,
0.32627859711647034,
0.502745509147644,
1.1247004270553589,
-0.1444137990474701,
0.831787109375,
-0.31412461400032043,
0.09639564156532288,
-0.2268749177455902,
0.576185941696167,
-0.17564934492111206,
0.2413407266139984,
-0.1175050437450409,
-0.7022936940193176,
-0.10469507426023483,
0.5094059109687805,
-0.43663689494132996,
0.07912643998861313,
0.25217771530151367,
0.4259934723377228,
0.11338751763105392,
-0.15412116050720215,
0.4137150049209595,
-0.3350973427295685,
0.03138280287384987,
0.1101875901222229,
0.3629729151725769,
-0.2375834882259369,
0.24738669395446777,
-0.5273873805999756,
-0.14652150869369507,
-0.4887748956680298,
-0.5886415839195251,
-0.8577311038970947,
-0.6396828293800354,
-0.7813525795936584,
0.059065695852041245,
0.13277994096279144,
0.4651513397693634,
0.4407636821269989,
-0.468788206577301,
-0.731191098690033,
0.044539086520671844,
-0.08042681962251663,
-0.5953508019447327,
-0.35983768105506897,
0.2746220827102661,
-0.2649984061717987,
-0.14449875056743622,
0.47193530201911926,
0.24113528430461884,
-0.06307527422904968,
-0.23113740980625153,
0.1641584038734436,
0.00020224577747285366,
-0.36518046259880066,
0.43755510449409485,
0.49732518196105957,
-0.6008097529411316,
-0.18292610347270966,
0.3858952522277832,
0.08978051692247391,
-0.245492622256279,
0.9246225357055664,
-0.6543853282928467,
0.255631685256958,
0.4710027575492859,
0.3937167227268219,
0.07420160621404648,
-0.3702918589115143,
0.43535077571868896,
-0.8615680932998657,
0.08373524993658066,
0.2791202962398529,
0.20441776514053345,
0.2010037899017334,
-0.5885530710220337,
0.5138039588928223,
0.08727184683084488,
-0.5419958233833313,
-0.6890963912010193,
-0.07783755660057068,
-0.5868620276451111,
-0.2795313000679016,
0.3168608546257019,
-0.22579798102378845,
0.3350319564342499,
-0.8270485401153564,
0.18209344148635864,
0.5025091171264648,
-0.3827540874481201,
1.1632342338562012,
0.14244775474071503,
-0.19364778697490692,
-0.006499797571450472,
-0.7450559735298157,
0.46152687072753906,
-0.10051896423101425,
-0.7110286355018616,
0.3303880989551544,
0.533180296421051,
0.18724854290485382,
-0.11230585724115372,
0.6402547955513,
-0.08247440308332443,
0.4935065507888794,
0.1928960233926773,
0.1436823010444641,
-0.11353012919425964,
-0.632692813873291,
0.20704327523708344,
0.3119891881942749,
0.16050201654434204,
0.13289403915405273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13149v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13149v1
|
Beyond Self-Consistency: Ensemble Reasoning Boosts Consistency and Accuracy of LLMs in Cancer Staging
| 2024-04-19T19:34:35 | 2024-04-19T19:34:35 |
Chia-Hsuan Chang, Mary M. Lucas, Yeawon Lee, Christopher C. Yang, Grace Lu-Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Advances in large language models (LLMs) have encouraged their adoption in
the healthcare domain where vital clinical information is often contained in
unstructured notes. Cancer staging status is available in clinical reports, but
it requires natural language processing to extract the status from the
unstructured text. With the advance in clinical-oriented LLMs, it is promising
to extract such status without extensive efforts in training the algorithms.
Prompting approaches of the pre-trained LLMs that elicit a model's reasoning
process, such as chain-of-thought, may help to improve the trustworthiness of
the generated responses. Using self-consistency further improves model
performance, but often results in inconsistent generations across the multiple
reasoning paths. In this study, we propose an ensemble reasoning approach with
the aim of improving the consistency of the model generations. Using an open
access clinical large language model to determine the pathologic cancer stage
from real-world pathology reports, we show that the ensemble reasoning approach
is able to improve both the consistency and performance of the LLM in
determining cancer stage, thereby demonstrating the potential to use these
models in clinical or other domains where reliability and trustworthiness are
critical.
|
[
0.0552244558930397,
-0.21476620435714722,
1.0535163879394531,
0.22896359860897064,
-0.08280748128890991,
0.14052456617355347,
-0.1268518716096878,
-0.5539045333862305,
0.23570390045642853,
0.770224392414093,
-0.34346768260002136,
-0.7045130729675293,
-0.534691572189331,
0.17955990135669708,
-0.45369213819503784,
0.7535675168037415,
-0.022116538137197495,
0.23284630477428436,
-0.47801345586776733,
-0.2190467268228531,
-0.006972725037485361,
-0.14518390595912933,
-0.9102056622505188,
-0.46095654368400574,
0.5257915258407593,
0.39941537380218506,
0.5428274869918823,
1.015170931816101,
0.5616530776023865,
0.3288748264312744,
0.26841121912002563,
0.33028942346572876,
-0.1301022171974182,
0.5802329778671265,
-0.2891439199447632,
-0.37432679533958435,
-0.4040205776691437,
-0.04319079592823982,
0.47086843848228455,
0.48316746950149536,
-0.4321681559085846,
-0.4961576759815216,
0.11318685859441757,
0.4286273419857025,
-0.5673559904098511,
0.09311769157648087,
-0.6577498912811279,
-0.10825957357883453,
-0.026208626106381416,
-0.3217647671699524,
-0.39023450016975403,
-0.46111854910850525,
-0.07355710119009018,
-0.6825007796287537,
-0.046234045177698135,
-0.2123030424118042,
0.4223436117172241,
0.18090640008449554,
-0.2852126657962799,
-0.3264394700527191,
-0.7598055005073547,
0.5574973821640015,
-0.8988674879074097,
0.2703407108783722,
0.424241840839386,
0.25986167788505554,
-0.31429219245910645,
-0.8600642085075378,
-0.3510687053203583,
-0.22032755613327026,
-0.06814394891262054,
0.30610930919647217,
0.013020580634474754,
0.35583487153053284,
-0.03245459124445915,
0.45663997530937195,
-0.5386427044868469,
0.38233283162117004,
0.022342514246702194,
-0.5055447816848755,
0.8572370409965515,
0.09063802659511566,
0.19487397372722626,
-0.04591846838593483,
-0.41748592257499695,
-0.00045503629371523857,
-0.6726280450820923,
-0.28751426935195923,
-0.09080133587121964,
0.26571032404899597,
0.32007426023483276,
0.3040957748889923,
-0.4309656322002411,
0.549765408039093,
0.2321765124797821,
-0.37657177448272705,
-0.1114143431186676,
-0.20281881093978882,
-0.2883073091506958,
0.4275503158569336,
0.8933836817741394,
0.10843559354543686,
-0.013045071624219418,
-0.05021382495760918,
0.01819809526205063,
0.15701988339424133,
0.2386319786310196,
-0.39324381947517395,
-0.28945860266685486,
0.5771854519844055,
-0.5487637519836426,
-0.29313233494758606,
-0.30287107825279236,
-0.7532416582107544,
-0.5886356234550476,
-0.11872310191392899,
0.6921519637107849,
-0.5412561893463135,
0.0029798769392073154,
0.0874769389629364,
0.22512508928775787,
-0.3111244738101959,
0.7476974129676819,
-0.681249737739563,
0.1575721800327301,
0.7057061195373535,
0.5673902034759521,
0.02720142900943756,
-0.06498327851295471,
-0.5404778718948364,
0.41238152980804443,
-0.32318899035453796,
1.0608261823654175,
-0.718207061290741,
-0.3890208601951599,
-0.16414859890937805,
-0.026701634749770164,
-0.3342229127883911,
-0.4151833653450012,
0.7626435160636902,
-0.1751760095357895,
0.48981061577796936,
0.02222011797130108,
-0.843981921672821,
0.20885086059570312,
0.43063873052597046,
-0.3254477083683014,
0.8209441304206848,
-0.2662573754787445,
-0.2984359562397003,
0.53065425157547,
-0.25928714871406555,
-0.3124050199985504,
0.15606005489826202,
-0.4268075227737427,
-0.2731350064277649,
-0.15078464150428772,
0.3152535557746887,
0.5231448411941528,
-0.009854010306298733,
0.06971917301416397,
-0.4050147831439972,
-0.14268849790096283,
-0.153420090675354,
-0.1535644829273224,
0.3241519033908844,
0.509075403213501,
-0.18077734112739563,
-0.07771600782871246,
-0.8127163052558899,
0.34231245517730713,
-0.19752049446105957,
-0.2045760303735733,
-0.3832368850708008,
0.3000999093055725,
-0.7183541655540466,
0.2815009653568268,
0.23229800164699554,
-0.6326576471328735,
0.38919100165367126,
-0.42391011118888855,
0.2617013454437256,
0.5839850902557373,
-0.009634274058043957,
0.2314232736825943,
-0.3804207444190979,
0.3364757001399994,
0.14051474630832672,
-0.032255545258522034,
-0.3943485915660858,
-0.6495315432548523,
-0.29542356729507446,
-0.1802247166633606,
0.3333330750465393,
0.46016421914100647,
-0.47517213225364685,
0.4283202290534973,
-0.13989652693271637,
-0.5545207858085632,
-0.519346296787262,
-0.0605660155415535,
0.3857243061065674,
0.7906306385993958,
0.444262832403183,
-0.3425053060054779,
-0.6428856253623962,
-0.6815782785415649,
-0.3211223781108856,
-0.40628764033317566,
0.05161440744996071,
0.136069193482399,
0.14363934099674225,
-0.08266974985599518,
0.6350125670433044,
-0.21917079389095306,
-0.24465827643871307,
-0.11934509873390198,
0.11642373353242874,
0.24406029284000397,
0.7259364128112793,
-0.17165100574493408,
-0.3169673979282379,
-0.1587357074022293,
0.26824885606765747,
-0.8454904556274414,
-0.14770345389842987,
-0.1676224023103714,
-0.2569316327571869,
0.19725294411182404,
0.5318562388420105,
-0.559340238571167,
0.5070840716362,
0.6343259215354919,
-0.1911117285490036,
0.37093228101730347,
-0.6796666979789734,
0.49943193793296814,
-0.9270544648170471,
-0.10505305230617523,
0.11182216554880142,
-0.3923940360546112,
-0.3068716526031494,
-0.2383471429347992,
-0.1201343908905983,
0.29753613471984863,
0.062160342931747437,
0.4803757965564728,
-0.3311297297477722,
-0.16637465357780457,
-0.29124194383621216,
0.13557317852973938,
0.20502956211566925,
-0.038543783128261566,
0.35379624366760254,
0.5127282738685608,
0.4183264970779419,
-0.6254147291183472,
0.1058761477470398,
0.0984223484992981,
-0.30810844898223877,
0.7057231664657593,
-0.33227771520614624,
0.09325806796550751,
0.02926803007721901,
0.5822073817253113,
-1.011744737625122,
-0.3954119086265564,
0.10370811820030212,
-0.2348208874464035,
0.3489367961883545,
-0.30956634879112244,
-0.3722119629383087,
-0.4836418330669403,
0.1412096470594406,
0.16868363320827484,
0.5457206964492798,
-0.38551652431488037,
0.6454322338104248,
0.1077500581741333,
0.036358315497636795,
-0.40588971972465515,
-0.6506297588348389,
-0.0894462913274765,
-0.18943189084529877,
-0.8288540244102478,
0.4165133237838745,
0.05512070283293724,
-0.39134451746940613,
-0.3549495339393616,
-0.26377514004707336,
-0.1274484544992447,
-0.09077813476324081,
-0.07419830560684204,
0.0029849556740373373,
-0.2685191333293915,
0.5223270654678345,
0.07601267844438553,
-0.014740285463631153,
-0.07757443189620972,
-0.5645553469657898,
0.3456350266933441,
0.27461734414100647,
-0.5425020456314087,
-0.501235842704773,
0.049828775227069855,
0.5485773086547852,
-0.034836627542972565,
0.5804368853569031,
0.13313454389572144,
-0.4495951235294342,
-0.10129790008068085,
-0.6503027677536011,
-0.2500889301300049,
-0.3672434091567993,
-0.13803209364414215,
-0.08906704932451248,
-0.8727194666862488,
0.7167896628379822,
-0.320678174495697,
-0.022942371666431427,
0.7433773875236511,
0.6850483417510986,
-0.36357149481773376,
1.183380126953125,
-0.009021816775202751,
0.1602621078491211,
-0.06077457591891289,
0.2924799621105194,
-0.10778012871742249,
-0.7172191739082336,
-0.3670499324798584,
-0.5559139847755432,
-0.12898045778274536,
-0.5465433597564697,
-0.5463463664054871,
0.7404220104217529,
-0.04769517108798027,
-0.26888033747673035,
0.049747344106435776,
-0.7283117175102234,
0.3195470869541168,
0.296070396900177,
0.4861662983894348,
0.6951998472213745,
-0.0555877685546875,
-0.17693834006786346,
0.22059231996536255,
-0.7953078746795654,
-0.7583089470863342,
1.1224855184555054,
0.31890684366226196,
0.6735638976097107,
-0.07745547592639923,
0.9702727794647217,
0.14522235095500946,
0.13803033530712128,
-0.35848385095596313,
0.3546335697174072,
-0.31349024176597595,
-0.6441438794136047,
-0.5819060802459717,
-0.45241954922676086,
-1.144492745399475,
0.26681533455848694,
-0.17394475638866425,
-1.073266625404358,
0.2512277364730835,
0.42857953906059265,
-0.7145095467567444,
0.2816413640975952,
-0.2244570255279541,
0.7043905258178711,
-0.3039725720882416,
-0.5976173877716064,
-0.2143339067697525,
-0.7758396863937378,
0.3864845037460327,
0.010456164367496967,
0.41114675998687744,
-0.04556512087583542,
0.20272475481033325,
0.5710115432739258,
-0.558562695980072,
0.6751598715782166,
0.12795771658420563,
-0.3195813298225403,
0.4216393232345581,
0.3351828157901764,
0.7898511290550232,
0.09178273379802704,
-0.34778520464897156,
0.00798032432794571,
0.20583371818065643,
-0.33383476734161377,
-0.5965067744255066,
0.8787311911582947,
-0.4601435363292694,
-0.6099879741668701,
-0.3478419780731201,
-0.44533056020736694,
-0.6019302606582642,
0.16307878494262695,
0.37697771191596985,
0.4324260652065277,
-0.12644349038600922,
0.04631137102842331,
0.8909695744514465,
0.06483590602874756,
0.24882976710796356,
0.23431816697120667,
-0.23575459420681,
-0.16055577993392944,
0.48356351256370544,
0.008533467538654804,
0.4615718424320221,
0.4854298532009125,
0.33682453632354736,
-0.3485831022262573,
-0.6591229438781738,
-0.35001543164253235,
-0.01770085282623768,
-0.630353569984436,
-0.13565108180046082,
-0.8628858923912048,
-0.19792310893535614,
-0.5692298412322998,
0.028708824887871742,
-0.424582839012146,
-0.541150689125061,
-0.09826529026031494,
0.000887189176864922,
0.31339019536972046,
0.6329392194747925,
-0.40673956274986267,
0.07818570733070374,
-0.9126501083374023,
-0.23946155607700348,
0.36936673521995544,
0.41176557540893555,
-0.07586320489645004,
-0.4760265648365021,
-0.17642459273338318,
0.21735844016075134,
-0.28632405400276184,
-0.658361554145813,
0.2721482217311859,
0.17054800689220428,
0.8509280681610107,
0.40200960636138916,
-0.1643516719341278,
0.557185709476471,
-0.1577034443616867,
0.7290291786193848,
0.15334291756153107,
-0.7717858552932739,
0.7797325849533081,
-0.7552326321601868,
0.1413908302783966,
0.6689409613609314,
0.3130621016025543,
-0.34347301721572876,
-0.5025757551193237,
-0.9318019151687622,
-0.3398089110851288,
0.5776984095573425,
0.38591328263282776,
-0.49456819891929626,
-0.17547836899757385,
0.29877978563308716,
0.1998508870601654,
0.11606653034687042,
-0.44612374901771545,
0.2110232263803482,
-0.31796127557754517,
-0.5339148044586182,
-0.18430005013942719,
-0.06677190959453583,
-0.5202324390411377,
-0.2726444900035858,
0.5774194598197937,
-0.3461161255836487,
0.2549370527267456,
0.6319170594215393,
0.330306738615036,
-0.31929266452789307,
0.2834375202655792,
0.6621543765068054,
0.5403170585632324,
-0.09568984806537628,
0.28915736079216003,
0.17719770967960358,
-0.2739313542842865,
0.0655493512749672,
-0.15400831401348114,
0.2978256344795227,
-0.354850709438324,
0.740134060382843,
0.25763383507728577,
0.2671531140804291,
-0.6568583250045776,
0.3307068943977356,
0.28377586603164673,
-0.2681155800819397,
-0.08397570997476578,
0.1912541687488556,
0.09818588942289352,
0.2593352198600769,
0.17432457208633423,
0.2240142524242401,
0.2538876235485077,
-0.7501636743545532,
0.40283018350601196,
0.31299567222595215,
-0.3947436809539795,
0.06479663401842117,
0.6225697994232178,
-0.01546543650329113,
-0.034809891134500504,
0.5314231514930725,
0.1536358743906021,
-0.28209900856018066,
0.7523131370544434,
0.6214509606361389,
0.5058841109275818,
-0.5177642107009888,
0.2976624667644501,
0.31753677129745483,
0.1418801099061966,
-0.6461988091468811,
0.12524478137493134,
0.2433314025402069,
-0.884978711605072,
-0.5023924112319946,
-0.5203403234481812,
-0.432528555393219,
-0.13156697154045105,
-0.3352193236351013,
0.05997788533568382,
-0.573462724685669,
0.1816093623638153,
-0.22209617495536804,
-0.21282754838466644,
-0.15267197787761688,
0.7349004745483398,
0.3843766152858734,
0.8141511082649231,
-0.41512730717658997,
0.8400492072105408,
0.46697771549224854,
-0.10620924830436707,
-1.1980559825897217,
0.005297381430864334,
0.09804795682430267,
-1.05574631690979,
0.2901211678981781,
-0.06196514889597893,
0.13675041496753693,
-0.065110944211483,
-0.5268386602401733,
-1.2273588180541992,
1.236031174659729,
0.08389183133840561,
-0.8673447966575623,
0.009383676573634148,
-0.2063228338956833,
0.8560590147972107,
-0.8043956756591797,
0.5773515701293945,
0.3671342730522156,
0.5774064064025879,
0.8603062629699707,
-1.1222434043884277,
0.07579819858074188,
0.19238165020942688,
-0.39616578817367554,
0.2255970686674118,
-0.4950185716152191,
0.786971390247345,
-0.1465636044740677,
-0.059400007128715515,
0.2908895015716553,
0.47257333993911743,
0.6723312735557556,
0.7420214414596558,
0.3860568106174469,
0.8334864974021912,
1.1554057598114014,
-0.13127611577510834,
1.3064137697219849,
-0.4381555914878845,
0.2590208351612091,
0.8147515654563904,
-0.5565703511238098,
0.5953671336174011,
0.07470828294754028,
-0.18135784566402435,
1.0502817630767822,
0.580580472946167,
0.27033811807632446,
0.4029777944087982,
-0.05777248367667198,
-0.2974770963191986,
-0.939113199710846,
0.14923714101314545,
-0.4233827590942383,
0.5847347974777222,
0.4746125042438507,
-0.7419520616531372,
-0.2789973318576813,
-0.19852015376091003,
0.13218751549720764,
0.27282726764678955,
-0.6479001045227051,
0.6703788042068481,
0.14560075104236603,
-1.0280097723007202,
0.20352326333522797,
-0.40817195177078247,
0.24719874560832977,
-0.5625133514404297,
-0.06679277122020721,
-0.036277174949645996,
0.22326262295246124,
-0.5305266976356506,
-0.8267880082130432,
0.282214492559433,
-0.4827912449836731,
-0.031046081334352493,
-0.026064317673444748,
1.0066263675689697,
-0.4639475643634796,
-0.6921901106834412,
0.05134791508316994,
0.5821459293365479,
0.24949201941490173,
0.01389604713767767,
-0.4882006049156189,
-0.025931891053915024,
-0.11779958754777908,
0.096424899995327,
0.48815393447875977,
0.4757140874862671,
-0.04632951319217682,
0.7363532185554504,
0.5267525315284729,
0.1176486536860466,
-0.2907553017139435,
-0.13195855915546417,
0.595220148563385,
-0.49592259526252747,
-0.4612874388694763,
-0.7885337471961975,
0.35577356815338135,
-0.32328370213508606,
-0.2747822105884552,
0.6942409873008728,
0.31614577770233154,
0.3957774043083191,
0.4479581117630005,
0.6751908659934998,
0.20707248151302338,
0.7799978852272034,
-0.7894535660743713,
0.6338414549827576,
-0.5368230938911438,
0.5895233750343323,
-0.3174009323120117,
-0.5019046068191528,
-0.32255080342292786,
0.5933167934417725,
-0.513136088848114,
0.3601295053958893,
0.8110812902450562,
0.5619891285896301,
0.16702912747859955,
0.37024402618408203,
0.3461281359195709,
0.5105873942375183,
0.20740924775600433,
0.6560086607933044,
0.6423978209495544,
-0.24652151763439178,
0.2752190828323364,
-0.1491558998823166,
-0.3473640978336334,
0.007690701633691788,
-0.898651123046875,
-0.49132776260375977,
-0.27198606729507446,
-0.4835967421531677,
-0.6428940892219543,
0.3814135491847992,
1.0636382102966309,
0.7436400651931763,
-0.6567128300666809,
-0.07831466943025589,
-0.32287728786468506,
0.17041295766830444,
-0.3523149788379669,
-0.16389892995357513,
0.21954184770584106,
-0.28393179178237915,
-0.41297194361686707,
0.7608394622802734,
0.5334084033966064,
-0.20252397656440735,
-0.24891507625579834,
-0.026548830792307854,
-0.341327965259552,
0.25633949041366577,
0.3111957907676697,
0.3895619809627533,
-0.6051753163337708,
-0.4613106846809387,
-0.3036929965019226,
-0.2595672607421875,
0.3175731301307678,
0.5234729647636414,
-1.1175310611724854,
0.5598069429397583,
0.22501592338085175,
0.1851225048303604,
0.2940540313720703,
0.0901891216635704,
0.7228088974952698,
-0.3405754566192627,
-0.3852646052837372,
0.5109280347824097,
0.38422730565071106,
0.08645884692668915,
-0.7652236819267273,
0.5913541316986084,
0.3777702748775482,
-0.9353759288787842,
-0.5426067113876343,
0.23202697932720184,
-1.0580224990844727,
-0.2616419494152069,
1.17548406124115,
-0.24802076816558838,
-0.07577270269393921,
-0.18409264087677002,
0.050375305116176605,
0.09597014635801315,
-0.39332064986228943,
0.9950111508369446,
0.5356147289276123,
-0.7309334874153137,
-0.3965197801589966,
0.168121337890625,
0.5597028732299805,
0.4145732522010803,
-0.903001070022583,
-0.330461710691452,
0.37111273407936096,
0.2574410140514374,
0.2469584345817566,
0.8863261938095093,
-0.38063469529151917,
0.29493629932403564,
-0.11983060836791992,
-0.10731641203165054,
0.2743929326534271,
-0.17869612574577332,
-0.06011347472667694,
0.37562987208366394,
-0.10959301888942719,
0.21026793122291565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13043v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13043v1
|
Data Alignment for Zero-Shot Concept Generation in Dermatology AI
| 2024-04-19T17:57:29 | 2024-04-19T17:57:29 |
Soham Gadgil, Mahtab Bigverdi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
AI in dermatology is evolving at a rapid pace but the major limitation to
training trustworthy classifiers is the scarcity of data with ground-truth
concept level labels, which are meta-labels semantically meaningful to humans.
Foundation models like CLIP providing zero-shot capabilities can help alleviate
this challenge by leveraging vast amounts of image-caption pairs available on
the internet. CLIP can be fine-tuned using domain specific image-caption pairs
to improve classification performance. However, CLIP's pre-training data is not
well-aligned with the medical jargon that clinicians use to perform diagnoses.
The development of large language models (LLMs) in recent years has led to the
possibility of leveraging the expressive nature of these models to generate
rich text. Our goal is to use these models to generate caption text that aligns
well with both the clinical lexicon and with the natural human language used in
CLIP's pre-training data. Starting with captions used for images in PubMed
articles, we extend them by passing the raw captions through an LLM fine-tuned
on the field's several textbooks. We find that using captions generated by an
expressive fine-tuned LLM like GPT-3.5 improves downstream zero-shot concept
classification performance.
|
[
-0.1448918730020523,
-0.5304232239723206,
0.8592392206192017,
-0.38180944323539734,
-0.5558512210845947,
0.2359125018119812,
-0.058496344834566116,
-0.6143308877944946,
0.22688284516334534,
0.6646308302879333,
-0.43264779448509216,
-0.8029101490974426,
-0.5406501889228821,
0.16894005239009857,
-0.407924085855484,
1.2604347467422485,
-0.175526425242424,
0.09404748678207397,
-0.4676783084869385,
-0.2900232672691345,
-0.4235193133354187,
-0.227023646235466,
-0.3293401896953583,
-0.2954998016357422,
0.29989778995513916,
0.6989425420761108,
0.7963412404060364,
1.1140905618667603,
0.8542361259460449,
0.14993909001350403,
0.2680585980415344,
-0.0818575918674469,
-0.2404811829328537,
0.22688153386116028,
-0.1653720736503601,
-0.32846248149871826,
-0.5754590630531311,
0.06753403693437576,
0.41241639852523804,
0.6261869072914124,
-0.11364112794399261,
-0.12411818653345108,
-0.5068951845169067,
0.5669464468955994,
-0.42186641693115234,
-0.1197395995259285,
-0.570553183555603,
0.12460528314113617,
-0.110952228307724,
-0.19129374623298645,
-0.05030673369765282,
-0.16663961112499237,
0.4190935492515564,
-0.5996922850608826,
0.7152166366577148,
-0.24302078783512115,
1.2348605394363403,
0.4649656414985657,
-0.09993446618318558,
0.044346556067466736,
-0.6676270365715027,
0.43423008918762207,
-0.8481512665748596,
-0.06509022414684296,
0.070530466735363,
0.5460755825042725,
0.3545609712600708,
-0.5557795166969299,
-0.528742253780365,
-0.07727689296007156,
0.051893576979637146,
0.20685622096061707,
-0.016692936420440674,
0.12912121415138245,
0.2056296467781067,
0.38500186800956726,
-0.47578540444374084,
0.246435284614563,
-0.371020644903183,
-0.10667214542627335,
0.8818803429603577,
0.3398974537849426,
0.3509798049926758,
0.0870051234960556,
-0.5987014174461365,
-0.09820783883333206,
-0.960182249546051,
-0.48815178871154785,
-0.15305878221988678,
0.29856759309768677,
-0.07282644510269165,
0.7380221486091614,
-0.2672644257545471,
0.8859649300575256,
0.08810414373874664,
-0.279284805059433,
0.17625337839126587,
-0.4576207995414734,
-0.218001127243042,
0.40028640627861023,
0.8661907315254211,
0.6643843054771423,
0.2851174771785736,
-0.14803777635097504,
0.015802504494786263,
0.09346382319927216,
0.5372176766395569,
-1.0788171291351318,
-0.1253417283296585,
0.4488769769668579,
-0.038887299597263336,
-0.7947905659675598,
0.0777357667684555,
-0.6921625733375549,
-0.41095906496047974,
-0.24114979803562164,
0.47750160098075867,
-0.409341961145401,
0.01464735995978117,
0.22187361121177673,
-0.03359641134738922,
0.2025122344493866,
0.4876954257488251,
-0.7148346304893494,
0.20429743826389313,
0.2724305987358093,
1.0504754781723022,
-0.18186625838279724,
-0.07876028120517731,
-0.35418152809143066,
0.5310149788856506,
-0.4673144519329071,
0.7947791814804077,
-0.43707793951034546,
-0.18542468547821045,
0.04074351117014885,
-0.14610950648784637,
-0.12625902891159058,
-0.3916876018047333,
0.418765664100647,
-0.16274790465831757,
0.2856963276863098,
0.05903768166899681,
-0.8144682049751282,
-0.04161868989467621,
0.3024776577949524,
-0.35536330938339233,
0.4888114035129547,
0.45957812666893005,
-0.5915728211402893,
0.4146290421485901,
-0.7398739457130432,
-0.3743766248226166,
0.3101252615451813,
-0.2673211991786957,
-0.7839497327804565,
0.06077601760625839,
0.3185179829597473,
0.6195327043533325,
-0.18910348415374756,
0.30990591645240784,
-0.2350420355796814,
-0.3252488970756531,
0.3477433919906616,
0.0551639050245285,
0.28807133436203003,
0.013872236013412476,
-0.49710413813591003,
0.2757820785045624,
-0.6717492341995239,
-0.24879257380962372,
0.38352170586586,
0.3505566716194153,
-0.24449077248573303,
-0.03735186159610748,
-0.24830806255340576,
0.13989077508449554,
0.013305841013789177,
-0.8183629512786865,
0.3797360360622406,
-0.4518909156322479,
0.48761987686157227,
0.40161949396133423,
0.2184416651725769,
0.33701983094215393,
-0.5729532241821289,
0.4483793079853058,
0.2628295123577118,
0.13087376952171326,
-0.34273770451545715,
-0.4368464946746826,
-0.5570688843727112,
-0.39825892448425293,
0.41895705461502075,
0.4830203950405121,
-0.44794076681137085,
0.41339778900146484,
-0.4571458697319031,
-0.5401183366775513,
-0.5648470520973206,
0.020443757995963097,
0.3370583653450012,
0.8833904266357422,
0.3898046016693115,
-0.6362630128860474,
-0.2051355242729187,
-0.9250077605247498,
0.23440097272396088,
0.17204585671424866,
0.05396687984466553,
0.5968306064605713,
0.19213859736919403,
-0.33676138520240784,
0.9829544425010681,
-0.844919741153717,
-0.7365126609802246,
-0.17891602218151093,
0.02361234650015831,
0.07044745981693268,
0.3882789611816406,
0.6235799789428711,
-0.5402879118919373,
-0.6684408783912659,
0.2349466234445572,
-0.5925647020339966,
-0.30892255902290344,
-0.16299811005592346,
-0.07227855175733566,
0.1951816976070404,
0.470302551984787,
-0.8055713176727295,
0.45334309339523315,
0.27774757146835327,
-0.2700463831424713,
0.3618510961532593,
-0.037780534476041794,
0.11105923354625702,
-1.1333502531051636,
0.21520018577575684,
0.0852094441652298,
-0.44813087582588196,
-0.6181102395057678,
0.02106912061572075,
-0.06960425525903702,
-0.3104861378669739,
-0.46913614869117737,
0.5875958204269409,
-0.17753668129444122,
0.09212035685777664,
-0.21392202377319336,
0.30142441391944885,
0.2535616457462311,
0.08554001897573471,
0.3403605818748474,
0.8527091145515442,
0.6241952776908875,
-0.34395769238471985,
0.28222957253456116,
0.6472121477127075,
-0.05795654281973839,
0.7706495523452759,
-0.6394641399383545,
0.016136057674884796,
0.02835380844771862,
0.1291617453098297,
-0.817550539970398,
-0.6097185611724854,
0.37853536009788513,
-0.3636685013771057,
0.6522846817970276,
-0.12566566467285156,
-0.23896779119968414,
-0.2955777943134308,
-0.36089780926704407,
0.4806593060493469,
0.3967472314834595,
-0.2349228858947754,
-0.0070479148998856544,
0.2601190209388733,
-0.2598807215690613,
-0.4606282114982605,
-0.45047086477279663,
0.157257080078125,
-0.27679678797721863,
-0.23670455813407898,
0.6263819932937622,
-0.002226437907665968,
-0.006297903601080179,
0.07668448984622955,
-0.18146872520446777,
-0.17611730098724365,
-0.058242067694664,
0.2748273015022278,
0.5722644329071045,
-0.3711112439632416,
0.06658392399549484,
-0.12929095327854156,
0.09066224843263626,
-0.2134176343679428,
-0.16998672485351562,
0.2959747314453125,
0.04283604770898819,
-0.5675713419914246,
-0.5232971906661987,
0.11074841022491455,
0.7004613280296326,
-0.12091587483882904,
0.5057064294815063,
0.3572533130645752,
-0.21363948285579681,
-0.049320247024297714,
-0.3988374173641205,
-0.13065561652183533,
-0.31274107098579407,
0.1728219836950302,
-0.0407690592110157,
-0.8767197728157043,
0.3437156677246094,
0.15361441671848297,
-0.03878561034798622,
0.6256058216094971,
0.5174736380577087,
-0.2057574987411499,
0.7908721566200256,
0.6825644969940186,
0.052359603345394135,
0.28738513588905334,
-0.23126083612442017,
0.14823094010353088,
-0.6769583225250244,
-0.2028699815273285,
-0.24883195757865906,
-0.2200387865304947,
-0.2540943920612335,
-0.4297846853733063,
0.21951889991760254,
0.19989459216594696,
-0.20673179626464844,
0.43690815567970276,
-0.9266564249992371,
0.5516791939735413,
0.4421415328979492,
0.1980651468038559,
0.1567954123020172,
0.06930612027645111,
0.11887990683317184,
-0.03436030447483063,
-0.628677487373352,
-0.42302656173706055,
1.5102778673171997,
0.3613699972629547,
0.5301860570907593,
0.00971011258661747,
0.8144157528877258,
0.25551658868789673,
0.5639607906341553,
-0.9958556890487671,
0.1987764686346054,
-0.3022747039794922,
-0.6061677932739258,
-0.1660645455121994,
-0.23182052373886108,
-0.822799563407898,
-0.1578819453716278,
-0.29419979453086853,
-0.5344708561897278,
0.07991836965084076,
-0.07269372791051865,
-0.7780048251152039,
0.20477129518985748,
-0.4349134564399719,
0.9685144424438477,
-0.28403881192207336,
-0.2657385766506195,
0.07719603925943375,
-0.8350368738174438,
0.4476916193962097,
-0.3041963577270508,
-0.14695224165916443,
-0.339782178401947,
-0.11719689518213272,
0.4733223617076874,
-0.5666580200195312,
0.8573190569877625,
-0.08318431675434113,
-0.10640192031860352,
0.2590106129646301,
0.0508422814309597,
-0.06406409293413162,
-0.07846073806285858,
0.49866053462028503,
0.3292483985424042,
0.19558916985988617,
-0.38747942447662354,
-0.3160187602043152,
0.48261570930480957,
-0.7563571333885193,
-0.5133435130119324,
-0.5418040156364441,
-0.6393445730209351,
-0.4093349575996399,
0.22155840694904327,
0.35432422161102295,
0.32405924797058105,
-0.2725489139556885,
0.036683063954114914,
0.6418176889419556,
-0.13117678463459015,
0.22752338647842407,
0.6281958818435669,
-0.02359597198665142,
-0.6733968257904053,
0.8827518224716187,
-0.07306820899248123,
0.3265267014503479,
0.37198659777641296,
0.07788657397031784,
-0.16493044793605804,
-0.8091172575950623,
-0.7842182517051697,
0.2396104782819748,
-0.33032098412513733,
-0.875040590763092,
-0.4130898714065552,
-0.6512225866317749,
-0.42639023065567017,
-0.394432008266449,
-0.13905754685401917,
-0.4936235845088959,
-0.35723090171813965,
-0.08212910592556,
0.6182069182395935,
0.8488538861274719,
-0.07400523871183395,
0.6855964660644531,
-1.1307785511016846,
0.3646429181098938,
0.012990965507924557,
0.5000854134559631,
-0.49423691630363464,
-0.38850975036621094,
-0.2783690094947815,
0.0035089137963950634,
-0.46954545378685,
-0.926568865776062,
0.4950947165489197,
0.4797280728816986,
0.28258761763572693,
0.7620850801467896,
0.0074050212278962135,
0.4408089518547058,
-0.7019464373588562,
0.6285536885261536,
0.45078709721565247,
-0.7145600318908691,
0.8164587020874023,
-0.5732455849647522,
0.055834148079156876,
0.6796604990959167,
0.3341563642024994,
-0.2890544533729553,
-0.45349133014678955,
-0.8826889395713806,
-0.6740170121192932,
0.8413181900978088,
0.09100881963968277,
0.05823810026049614,
-0.12916477024555206,
0.4062143564224243,
0.22170384228229523,
0.26785585284233093,
-0.37269946932792664,
0.022813240066170692,
-0.30693909525871277,
-0.5990266799926758,
-0.11551252752542496,
-0.3167937397956848,
-0.7090262770652771,
-0.2901118993759155,
0.440694123506546,
-0.46902912855148315,
0.24661844968795776,
0.4917542636394501,
-0.04476086422801018,
-0.46762052178382874,
0.06844453513622284,
0.9407300353050232,
0.5865018367767334,
-0.47814011573791504,
-0.03948725014925003,
-0.15177442133426666,
-0.536244809627533,
0.2418878823518753,
0.22603954374790192,
-0.3533730208873749,
0.29268938302993774,
0.343891978263855,
0.6946507692337036,
0.23892435431480408,
-0.726456880569458,
0.9848610758781433,
0.16623951494693756,
-0.7401559352874756,
0.08958549797534943,
0.19789591431617737,
-0.14085841178894043,
0.04317479953169823,
0.18201400339603424,
0.2590540051460266,
-0.10202392935752869,
-0.10949103534221649,
0.5812476277351379,
0.5640798211097717,
-0.5835052728652954,
-0.23085327446460724,
0.7022964954376221,
0.24469129741191864,
-0.09996335953474045,
0.5921118855476379,
0.185212641954422,
-0.48851466178894043,
0.6105011701583862,
0.5193995833396912,
0.7833279371261597,
0.019590847194194794,
0.5696582198143005,
0.4029647707939148,
-0.06584370136260986,
0.01872359588742256,
-0.12597894668579102,
-0.037602536380290985,
-0.7227774262428284,
-0.5652680993080139,
-0.6884764432907104,
-0.6041160821914673,
0.09148292988538742,
-0.6067655682563782,
0.29976731538772583,
-0.7398300170898438,
-0.11851819604635239,
0.16578714549541473,
0.06426052004098892,
-0.49781209230422974,
0.35492435097694397,
0.28677845001220703,
0.8431575894355774,
-0.9549041390419006,
0.8050644993782043,
0.5556215643882751,
-0.7271034717559814,
-0.674841582775116,
-0.05193009972572327,
-0.07778806984424591,
-0.9135433435440063,
0.39082100987434387,
0.3279520571231842,
0.22507378458976746,
-0.0074404566548764706,
-0.8443854451179504,
-0.7953302264213562,
1.1554402112960815,
0.4012086093425751,
-0.5797861814498901,
0.07709037512540817,
0.24641159176826477,
0.6784329414367676,
-0.693976640701294,
0.0063715409487485886,
0.5331493020057678,
0.15970595180988312,
0.5170015096664429,
-0.915729284286499,
0.012577316723763943,
0.08801620453596115,
-0.24380680918693542,
0.2216409295797348,
-0.23695418238639832,
0.561475932598114,
-0.5388385653495789,
-0.3575055003166199,
0.2099969983100891,
0.18430693447589874,
0.0997534990310669,
0.29684481024742126,
0.04648672789335251,
1.094061017036438,
0.33325326442718506,
-0.22512699663639069,
1.1308403015136719,
-0.4087250232696533,
0.21633893251419067,
1.0387461185455322,
-0.43791958689689636,
0.769069492816925,
0.280511736869812,
-0.23556868731975555,
0.506657063961029,
0.6564618349075317,
-0.3987799882888794,
0.4423803687095642,
-0.1186027005314827,
-0.27404487133026123,
-0.1363779902458191,
-0.3801630437374115,
-0.45647913217544556,
0.5091677904129028,
0.23972108960151672,
-0.4419228732585907,
-0.3523922562599182,
-0.26581960916519165,
-0.1971692442893982,
0.021823326125741005,
-0.2652014195919037,
1.2052252292633057,
-0.06870728731155396,
-0.2957327961921692,
0.5973559021949768,
-0.2020634412765503,
0.35657691955566406,
-0.4586186707019806,
-0.1315949559211731,
-0.2515338063240051,
0.06405553221702576,
-0.32550448179244995,
-0.9699448347091675,
0.39643245935440063,
0.031687330454587936,
-0.07282870262861252,
0.058561164885759354,
0.5264431238174438,
-0.5867554545402527,
-0.4925181269645691,
-0.17833900451660156,
0.6856216192245483,
0.2836781442165375,
-0.01055042166262865,
-0.6478379368782043,
-0.16277940571308136,
-0.0818319320678711,
0.2475859373807907,
0.32969942688941956,
0.33814337849617004,
-0.10493040084838867,
0.3593113124370575,
0.6899431943893433,
0.4601031541824341,
-0.2957323491573334,
0.23462553322315216,
0.7563581466674805,
-0.5859413146972656,
0.035350825637578964,
-0.8946982622146606,
0.2878187596797943,
-0.22136500477790833,
-0.1633160412311554,
0.3491975963115692,
0.5322770476341248,
0.7015885710716248,
-0.1403764933347702,
0.6261058449745178,
0.07146403938531876,
0.49441656470298767,
-0.24532249569892883,
0.7925283908843994,
-0.6040027141571045,
-0.015930812805891037,
-0.3142361044883728,
-0.969035804271698,
-0.8076409697532654,
0.49749594926834106,
-0.09213852137327194,
-0.2584523558616638,
0.6028213500976562,
0.5232627391815186,
-0.02974134311079979,
-0.2928582727909088,
0.3767361342906952,
-0.0019729805644601583,
0.2025279700756073,
0.5439115166664124,
0.4903617203235626,
-0.45259881019592285,
0.35072576999664307,
-0.4002784788608551,
-0.1841019093990326,
-0.355778306722641,
-0.8406997919082642,
-0.7135341167449951,
-0.25619587302207947,
-0.6282938122749329,
-0.24289771914482117,
-0.06235311180353165,
0.6878670454025269,
0.8714653849601746,
-1.0248123407363892,
0.10620059072971344,
-0.27638670802116394,
-0.10246317088603973,
0.003110659308731556,
-0.2472492903470993,
0.4278617799282074,
-0.38481825590133667,
-0.5994564890861511,
0.15156328678131104,
0.576816201210022,
0.5557287931442261,
-0.05415941774845123,
0.03817855566740036,
-0.004951800685375929,
0.007990319281816483,
0.3909592628479004,
0.3836213946342468,
-0.6120193004608154,
-0.3153471350669861,
-0.002687082625925541,
-0.2934207320213318,
0.43931975960731506,
0.7264443635940552,
-0.7680536508560181,
0.49329930543899536,
0.024565603584051132,
0.8167306184768677,
0.16681095957756042,
0.3462649881839752,
0.7535679936408997,
-0.7558175325393677,
-0.11433684080839157,
0.4890938699245453,
0.1421050727367401,
0.5900015830993652,
-0.3438504934310913,
0.6542258262634277,
0.4105331599712372,
-0.34731367230415344,
-0.8896600008010864,
0.11495372653007507,
-1.1479580402374268,
-0.33704543113708496,
0.9831506609916687,
-0.07256536185741425,
-0.24674507975578308,
0.08662942051887512,
-0.3139004707336426,
0.1698560267686844,
-0.12025684118270874,
0.7626288533210754,
0.45477139949798584,
-0.3232031464576721,
-0.37722212076187134,
-0.2861233949661255,
0.7263882160186768,
0.31069082021713257,
-0.8329980373382568,
-0.09915640205144882,
0.6701106429100037,
0.4034295082092285,
0.32463303208351135,
0.7209515571594238,
-0.2226712554693222,
0.2763627767562866,
-0.12936070561408997,
0.3027174770832062,
-0.2601540982723236,
-0.3250192403793335,
-0.30653831362724304,
-0.046955496072769165,
0.11111018806695938,
-0.3164801299571991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13039v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13039v1
|
LaPA: Latent Prompt Assist Model For Medical Visual Question Answering
| 2024-04-19T17:51:52 | 2024-04-19T17:51:52 |
Tiancheng Gu, Kaicheng Yang, Dongnan Liu, Weidong Cai
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Medical visual question answering (Med-VQA) aims to automate the prediction
of correct answers for medical images and questions, thereby assisting
physicians in reducing repetitive tasks and alleviating their workload.
Existing approaches primarily focus on pre-training models using additional and
comprehensive datasets, followed by fine-tuning to enhance performance in
downstream tasks. However, there is also significant value in exploring
existing models to extract clinically relevant information. In this paper, we
propose the Latent Prompt Assist model (LaPA) for medical visual question
answering. Firstly, we design a latent prompt generation module to generate the
latent prompt with the constraint of the target answer. Subsequently, we
propose a multi-modal fusion block with latent prompt fusion module that
utilizes the latent prompt to extract clinical-relevant information from
uni-modal and multi-modal features. Additionally, we introduce a prior
knowledge fusion module to integrate the relationship between diseases and
organs with the clinical-relevant information. Finally, we combine the final
integrated information with image-language cross-modal information to predict
the final answers. Experimental results on three publicly available Med-VQA
datasets demonstrate that LaPA outperforms the state-of-the-art model ARL,
achieving improvements of 1.83%, 0.63%, and 1.80% on VQA-RAD, SLAKE, and
VQA-2019, respectively. The code is publicly available at
https://github.com/GaryGuTC/LaPA_model.
|
[
-0.38010990619659424,
-1.2023426294326782,
0.9679657816886902,
-0.08675949275493622,
-0.5596988797187805,
-0.07987535744905472,
0.38895493745803833,
-0.4633817970752716,
0.25861984491348267,
0.45889806747436523,
-0.6758654713630676,
-0.25038403272628784,
-0.30118268728256226,
-0.012796028517186642,
0.25503280758857727,
0.5958305597305298,
-0.11973904818296432,
0.6916590929031372,
-0.6181893944740295,
-0.07133235782384872,
-0.9138648509979248,
-0.23190869390964508,
-0.4536970853805542,
0.24586108326911926,
0.7434589266777039,
0.29627853631973267,
0.5359127521514893,
0.27379900217056274,
0.7141684889793396,
0.23082779347896576,
0.043091557919979095,
0.12451328337192535,
0.04315103217959404,
0.24694626033306122,
0.10631120204925537,
-0.4984908998012543,
-0.5839769244194031,
-0.03094670921564102,
0.31365251541137695,
0.45354440808296204,
-0.050774138420820236,
0.1613599956035614,
-0.4698210060596466,
0.4368164837360382,
-0.3978618085384369,
-0.043667037039995193,
-0.5894038677215576,
-0.05349959060549736,
0.07513093948364258,
-0.5053223967552185,
-0.07898125052452087,
-0.3226701617240906,
0.20890238881111145,
-0.7205125689506531,
-0.010429056361317635,
0.07477433234453201,
0.7498919367790222,
0.697645366191864,
-0.23069776594638824,
0.12002258002758026,
-0.29225048422813416,
0.3700697124004364,
-0.5239716172218323,
0.18970979750156403,
0.39909666776657104,
0.7382803559303284,
0.03656382858753204,
-0.6225513815879822,
-0.7102181911468506,
-0.18237410485744476,
0.07142283767461777,
0.4638620615005493,
-0.1340346485376358,
0.03699987754225731,
0.07814748585224152,
0.366519033908844,
-0.8837197422981262,
-0.12287425994873047,
-0.5425319075584412,
0.0009543485357426107,
0.32859545946121216,
0.41233453154563904,
0.6646192669868469,
-0.41601207852363586,
-0.6059314012527466,
0.14576512575149536,
-0.6200087666511536,
0.41634565591812134,
-0.4837973713874817,
-0.014972846955060959,
-0.24793510138988495,
0.7769740223884583,
-0.10194013267755508,
0.8996017575263977,
-0.08296854794025421,
-0.05215241387486458,
0.2145800143480301,
-0.5561528205871582,
-0.2945658564567566,
-0.3700060546398163,
0.5573709607124329,
0.4890238642692566,
-0.24332305788993835,
0.16663502156734467,
-0.0891459658741951,
0.1796053946018219,
0.2898046374320984,
-0.570277750492096,
-0.2758917808532715,
0.34798434376716614,
-0.7553160786628723,
-0.3338390588760376,
-0.3058567941188812,
-0.74644935131073,
-0.47591596841812134,
-0.2989048659801483,
0.7838874459266663,
-0.2725866734981537,
0.061889659613370895,
-0.09559984505176544,
-0.012976957485079765,
0.36945974826812744,
0.9144620895385742,
-0.27808040380477905,
-0.10028628259897232,
0.12669162452220917,
0.6524892449378967,
-0.1709088832139969,
0.0838843435049057,
-0.9882237315177917,
-0.23487231135368347,
-0.1644635796546936,
0.8767902851104736,
-0.7037346959114075,
-0.33212316036224365,
-0.25481104850769043,
0.27501896023750305,
-0.3242228627204895,
-0.3991440236568451,
0.22085486352443695,
-0.7997279763221741,
0.43309178948402405,
-0.5690994262695312,
-0.30630823969841003,
-0.2751780152320862,
0.19847950339317322,
-0.6851661205291748,
0.537580132484436,
0.23066774010658264,
-0.6892241835594177,
0.10956757515668869,
-0.5450112223625183,
0.00018642064242158085,
0.4459551274776459,
-0.7261230945587158,
-0.3135424256324768,
0.06331836432218552,
0.6653417944908142,
0.4775134325027466,
-0.681213915348053,
0.2831941246986389,
-0.2601642906665802,
-0.07189192622900009,
0.4646143615245819,
-0.33091476559638977,
0.4092246890068054,
0.15417329967021942,
-0.005693262908607721,
0.4871564209461212,
-0.6595669388771057,
-0.11694299429655075,
0.29118579626083374,
0.10471320897340775,
-0.21336710453033447,
-0.3843023478984833,
-0.02171032503247261,
0.5453343987464905,
0.3316844701766968,
-0.5409079194068909,
0.16828468441963196,
0.021380145102739334,
-0.04347458854317665,
0.6284632086753845,
0.4798065721988678,
0.1039741262793541,
-0.44204065203666687,
1.10105562210083,
0.013230188749730587,
0.4474470317363739,
-0.2632676362991333,
-1.003778338432312,
-0.2600429654121399,
-0.4725455343723297,
0.3260384500026703,
0.8533448576927185,
-1.2802191972732544,
-0.056708794087171555,
0.22468461096286774,
-0.3408864736557007,
-0.6814226508140564,
-0.16717354953289032,
0.43204325437545776,
1.0373497009277344,
0.5509626865386963,
-0.3899327218532562,
-0.30724817514419556,
-0.88651442527771,
0.2829517424106598,
-0.19057101011276245,
0.008192285895347595,
0.6375938653945923,
0.2133973389863968,
0.0062786187045276165,
0.5875418186187744,
-0.6089328527450562,
-0.2740963101387024,
-0.06434981524944305,
0.07794560492038727,
0.16540534794330597,
0.40058401226997375,
0.5195713639259338,
-1.0752439498901367,
-0.2809886634349823,
-0.09982883930206299,
-0.9267345070838928,
-0.03237305209040642,
-0.1487758904695511,
0.09564124047756195,
-0.07310505211353302,
0.38428357243537903,
-0.37184250354766846,
0.7663535475730896,
0.33722105622291565,
-0.39394882321357727,
0.486208438873291,
-0.3842030167579651,
0.5481627583503723,
-1.3005789518356323,
0.34751760959625244,
-0.09756891429424286,
-0.21831141412258148,
-0.4722106456756592,
0.051742102950811386,
0.12184777855873108,
-0.4125467538833618,
-0.4325163662433624,
0.6330103874206543,
-0.18688872456550598,
0.14188601076602936,
-0.12009114027023315,
-0.12028732895851135,
-0.12873604893684387,
0.4736984670162201,
0.2408420592546463,
1.0745882987976074,
0.6191072463989258,
-0.3944968283176422,
0.3700345754623413,
0.3112758696079254,
-0.22552794218063354,
0.6350520849227905,
-1.0168637037277222,
-0.08878554403781891,
-0.4104524254798889,
-0.025273717939853668,
-1.2443346977233887,
-0.2618459463119507,
0.35738545656204224,
-0.5872474908828735,
0.30314338207244873,
-0.20462572574615479,
-0.01632903702557087,
-0.4508405923843384,
0.01016326155513525,
0.578627347946167,
0.5101940631866455,
-0.31525298953056335,
0.7853773236274719,
0.3682746887207031,
-0.65155428647995,
-0.7082740664482117,
-0.2960108816623688,
-0.07524430006742477,
0.07009842991828918,
-0.6541294455528259,
0.21920156478881836,
-0.3952564299106598,
-0.06512022018432617,
0.022718440741300583,
0.05763394385576248,
-0.26571419835090637,
-0.1257787048816681,
0.3456765115261078,
0.9556820392608643,
-0.2811364531517029,
0.17635343968868256,
0.04362700134515762,
-0.034414246678352356,
-0.1272318959236145,
0.14282336831092834,
0.3868008852005005,
-0.12763287127017975,
-0.4701371192932129,
-0.5542255640029907,
0.6973774433135986,
0.7131909132003784,
-0.5458043217658997,
0.5612738728523254,
0.5320168137550354,
-0.4711275100708008,
0.585325300693512,
-0.5871778726577759,
-0.22940289974212646,
-0.37359708547592163,
0.32080432772636414,
-0.3845035135746002,
-0.5820925831794739,
0.5728333592414856,
0.2222604602575302,
-0.10016562789678574,
0.2671515643596649,
0.684504508972168,
-0.3567124605178833,
1.1502183675765991,
0.6097919940948486,
0.4596845805644989,
0.3525570034980774,
-0.09889280796051025,
-0.23163668811321259,
-0.7623351812362671,
-0.58140629529953,
-0.31113946437835693,
0.1644253134727478,
-0.018639927729964256,
-0.8983829021453857,
0.9648523330688477,
0.04818245396018028,
0.21012170612812042,
-0.18783560395240784,
-0.4747579097747803,
0.20178265869617462,
0.4708445966243744,
0.4490630328655243,
0.037948302924633026,
-0.09825313836336136,
-0.21340642869472504,
-0.07307063788175583,
-0.8660016655921936,
-0.22944475710391998,
0.9578115940093994,
0.2535127103328705,
0.8523026704788208,
-0.04000753536820412,
0.2529490292072296,
0.18796004354953766,
0.012588524259626865,
-0.5205422043800354,
0.41748180985450745,
-0.018939565867185593,
-0.36272069811820984,
-0.24520081281661987,
-0.15444040298461914,
-0.6492235064506531,
0.03714918717741966,
-0.5965507626533508,
-0.4732421338558197,
0.34696975350379944,
0.3314424753189087,
-0.6743824481964111,
0.08174514770507812,
-0.4565976858139038,
0.954962432384491,
-0.23345059156417847,
-0.423822820186615,
0.007519583683460951,
-1.001128911972046,
0.2915288507938385,
-0.06113909184932709,
0.12493936717510223,
0.15349175035953522,
-0.13697415590286255,
0.6285091042518616,
-0.5058245062828064,
0.7138587832450867,
-0.34474635124206543,
-0.010719907470047474,
0.20077826082706451,
-0.2544032037258148,
0.37267568707466125,
0.32279470562934875,
0.45489171147346497,
-0.19982142746448517,
0.2782030701637268,
-0.5394501090049744,
-0.6298776865005493,
0.5383599400520325,
-0.5226150751113892,
-0.4719415307044983,
-0.20059740543365479,
-0.5035936236381531,
-0.24235863983631134,
-0.038154128938913345,
0.2980191707611084,
0.7747519612312317,
0.06089639663696289,
0.01621391624212265,
0.9721967577934265,
-0.520709753036499,
0.31951287388801575,
0.38265088200569153,
-0.07362337410449982,
-0.5310747027397156,
0.7942290902137756,
-0.1818983256816864,
0.13466185331344604,
0.5361581444740295,
0.06324657052755356,
-0.5808975696563721,
-0.486826628446579,
-1.054008960723877,
0.3379831910133362,
-0.7393947243690491,
-0.2668969929218292,
-0.7835634350776672,
-0.04621657729148865,
-0.23534423112869263,
-0.12273099273443222,
-0.04546472057700157,
-0.4471322000026703,
-0.319682240486145,
0.4625025689601898,
0.46479251980781555,
0.4919334053993225,
0.159913569688797,
-0.030153464525938034,
-0.9473713636398315,
0.853733241558075,
0.857580840587616,
0.2395309954881668,
-0.24702470004558563,
-0.43351486325263977,
0.25991714000701904,
-0.21557055413722992,
0.07653322070837021,
-1.2388464212417603,
0.12382394075393677,
-0.23130498826503754,
0.6188479661941528,
0.011304420419037342,
-0.032180555164813995,
0.5639246106147766,
-0.48779433965682983,
1.0467209815979004,
0.5679102540016174,
-0.3283275067806244,
0.6887485384941101,
-0.2733648419380188,
0.3065257966518402,
0.47873395681381226,
0.44258150458335876,
-0.34471839666366577,
-0.022840924561023712,
-0.41551923751831055,
-0.4951567053794861,
0.17491768300533295,
-0.09707365930080414,
-0.2647811472415924,
0.2063612937927246,
0.339383602142334,
0.19451536238193512,
0.2524520456790924,
-0.40483903884887695,
-0.2518838346004486,
-0.13734889030456543,
-0.17274127900600433,
0.06449583917856216,
-0.19339238107204437,
-0.20179979503154755,
-0.32525238394737244,
0.5522810220718384,
-0.29082733392715454,
0.3269306719303131,
0.5377542972564697,
-0.17563071846961975,
-0.17383097112178802,
0.27797940373420715,
0.6594388484954834,
0.7303968071937561,
-0.04880854859948158,
-0.09003719687461853,
0.07179886847734451,
-0.5200989842414856,
-0.009148459881544113,
0.39006471633911133,
-0.12386075407266617,
-0.045835934579372406,
0.10649528354406357,
0.7827942967414856,
-0.362949401140213,
-0.8586742281913757,
0.803913950920105,
-0.5697036981582642,
0.024957114830613136,
-0.16575920581817627,
-0.06550925225019455,
-0.08871910721063614,
0.3837359845638275,
0.4097515940666199,
0.25229310989379883,
0.20611274242401123,
-0.2291816920042038,
0.32342392206192017,
0.4913825988769531,
-0.6426973342895508,
-0.1092533990740776,
0.9676856398582458,
0.04297017306089401,
-0.04191698506474495,
0.29381102323532104,
0.34203004837036133,
-0.4026387333869934,
0.6153221726417542,
0.1851944625377655,
0.4125142991542816,
-0.3233541250228882,
0.3089388608932495,
0.22376272082328796,
0.08244980871677399,
0.5874661207199097,
0.9880001544952393,
0.0006565255462191999,
-0.10230894386768341,
-0.5685409307479858,
-0.4500526785850525,
-0.24298399686813354,
0.2672727108001709,
-0.4826880991458893,
0.15653330087661743,
-0.29579484462738037,
-0.1108071357011795,
0.2392241209745407,
-0.09267906099557877,
-0.7712852358818054,
0.5359043478965759,
0.24451370537281036,
0.7922917604446411,
-0.8616206645965576,
0.6029416918754578,
0.9938055872917175,
-0.9021226763725281,
-0.8285775780677795,
-0.2632889747619629,
-0.13137120008468628,
-0.8803437352180481,
0.3050869107246399,
-0.18221506476402283,
0.14115802943706512,
-0.2704641819000244,
-0.6281977891921997,
-0.619790256023407,
0.9382205009460449,
0.08362769335508347,
-0.3202736973762512,
-0.04736689105629921,
-0.2341262549161911,
0.3584785461425781,
-0.41751182079315186,
0.3022659718990326,
-0.08600745350122452,
0.1910373866558075,
0.4684832692146301,
-0.9253554940223694,
0.2989422082901001,
-0.5782806277275085,
0.009842886589467525,
-0.18657082319259644,
-0.18382249772548676,
0.866100549697876,
-0.7105182409286499,
0.20220787823200226,
0.42700010538101196,
0.42325443029403687,
0.41183075308799744,
0.353244423866272,
0.4736311435699463,
0.18398913741111755,
0.7806388139724731,
0.03612444922327995,
1.1408653259277344,
-0.22302094101905823,
-0.1887381225824356,
0.899167001247406,
0.15041512250900269,
0.7250970005989075,
0.7191649079322815,
-0.03464416041970253,
0.39361250400543213,
0.7818374633789062,
0.1989414244890213,
0.5615376234054565,
-0.142645001411438,
-0.4293149411678314,
-0.5951340198516846,
-0.2911333739757538,
-0.9062252640724182,
0.26109278202056885,
0.28068897128105164,
-0.3854147791862488,
0.03670993074774742,
0.2540799677371979,
-0.5476492047309875,
-0.16967858374118805,
-0.30097952485084534,
0.87859046459198,
-0.05747558921575546,
-0.6536203026771545,
0.7814570069313049,
-0.39230605959892273,
0.2612939476966858,
-0.46057945489883423,
-0.45107772946357727,
-0.12982359528541565,
-0.33822110295295715,
0.07264066487550735,
-0.5903213620185852,
-0.18613868951797485,
-0.2662222385406494,
-0.42880406975746155,
0.44047343730926514,
0.7316529750823975,
-0.539078950881958,
-0.403274267911911,
-0.3297397494316101,
0.872724711894989,
0.13381990790367126,
0.07028334587812424,
-0.9198861122131348,
-0.12337808310985565,
-0.11029788851737976,
0.1638130396604538,
0.2261386662721634,
0.034864719957113266,
-0.2373310625553131,
0.6524343490600586,
0.6707437038421631,
-0.013360642828047276,
0.11942248791456223,
-0.005489138420671225,
1.0268974304199219,
-0.41355422139167786,
-0.5971678495407104,
-0.09542303532361984,
0.6168787479400635,
-0.09698730707168579,
-0.18137046694755554,
0.27507174015045166,
0.06889916956424713,
0.07935304194688797,
-0.3978213369846344,
0.6599453687667847,
0.025704635307192802,
0.528904914855957,
-0.7940717935562134,
0.7983903884887695,
-1.1380424499511719,
0.11993025243282318,
-0.345519483089447,
-0.5244370698928833,
-0.3499346971511841,
0.43258658051490784,
-0.238016739487648,
-0.03830018267035484,
0.6205459833145142,
0.8519783020019531,
-0.07544054090976715,
0.006631872151046991,
0.449721097946167,
-0.07894428074359894,
0.15397313237190247,
0.6286237835884094,
0.8912444710731506,
-0.33546197414398193,
0.2408326417207718,
-0.2603866159915924,
-0.5267839431762695,
-0.25662022829055786,
-0.5567029714584351,
-0.8760384917259216,
-0.8948018550872803,
-0.4221154451370239,
-0.41819241642951965,
0.016889384016394615,
0.7554287314414978,
0.773894727230072,
-0.5305336117744446,
0.4668973386287689,
0.20639051496982574,
0.014278329908847809,
-0.11916772276163101,
-0.13177885115146637,
0.6350952982902527,
-0.20973233878612518,
-0.336165189743042,
0.5528501272201538,
0.22990480065345764,
0.35531070828437805,
-0.07412316650152206,
0.08531225472688675,
-0.25992801785469055,
-0.03155035153031349,
0.38314831256866455,
0.4650239944458008,
-0.7643795013427734,
0.028079168871045113,
0.3408558666706085,
-0.12448044866323471,
0.19818148016929626,
0.7336347103118896,
-1.0489873886108398,
0.8272199034690857,
0.6118189096450806,
0.790402889251709,
0.23440846800804138,
0.13859009742736816,
0.6239680051803589,
-0.4127365052700043,
-0.013160331174731255,
0.25080931186676025,
0.36303457617759705,
0.2726590037345886,
-0.47089171409606934,
0.1027342677116394,
0.3464818596839905,
-0.3804320693016052,
-0.5996052622795105,
0.22047635912895203,
-1.3144162893295288,
-0.4233405888080597,
0.8535188436508179,
-0.07020511478185654,
-0.47420191764831543,
-0.23963241279125214,
-0.6333810687065125,
0.17662042379379272,
-0.1745489537715912,
0.45628464221954346,
0.057108476758003235,
-0.2116403728723526,
-0.6488946080207825,
-0.4813982844352722,
0.621055006980896,
0.6717837452888489,
-1.1144707202911377,
-0.3678246736526489,
0.7629900574684143,
0.31246790289878845,
-0.03472822159528732,
0.824680507183075,
-0.3475900888442993,
1.1385234594345093,
-0.26199430227279663,
-0.13820123672485352,
-0.23040637373924255,
-0.5455532670021057,
-0.5970050692558289,
0.28546521067619324,
-0.07584453374147415,
-0.5412502884864807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13033v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13033v1
|
Sample Design Engineering: An Empirical Study of What Makes Good Downstream Fine-Tuning Samples for LLMs
| 2024-04-19T17:47:02 | 2024-04-19T17:47:02 |
Biyang Guo, He Wang, Wenyilin Xiao, Hong Chen, Zhuxin Lee, Songqiao Han, Hailiang Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the burgeoning field of Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT and
LLaMA, Prompt Engineering (PE) is renowned for boosting zero-shot or in-context
learning (ICL) through prompt modifications. Yet, the realm of the sample
design for downstream fine-tuning, crucial for task-specific LLM adaptation, is
largely unexplored. This paper introduces Sample Design Engineering (SDE), a
methodical approach to enhancing LLMs' post-tuning performance by refining
input, output, and reasoning designs. We conduct a series of in-domain (ID) and
out-of-domain (OOD) experiments to assess the impact of various design options
on LLMs' downstream performance, revealing several intriguing patterns that
hold consistently across different LLMs. Based on these insights, we propose an
integrated SDE strategy, combining the most effective options, and validate its
consistent superiority over heuristic sample designs in complex downstream
tasks like multi-aspect sentiment analysis, event extraction, and nested entity
recognition. Additionally, analyses of LLMs' inherent prompt/output perplexity,
zero-shot, and ICL abilities illustrate that good PE strategies may not always
translate to good SDE strategies. Code available at
https://github.com/beyondguo/LLM-Tuning.
|
[
-0.7688791751861572,
-0.4763634204864502,
0.6714418530464172,
0.09134964644908905,
-0.46160197257995605,
0.38916751742362976,
-0.3394032418727875,
-0.2766147255897522,
-0.045956652611494064,
0.4202406406402588,
-0.872746467590332,
-0.59721440076828,
-0.37631744146347046,
0.0032577100209891796,
0.03565233200788498,
0.9449511766433716,
-0.29932793974876404,
-0.029644401744008064,
0.11200109124183655,
0.19178876280784607,
-0.8072541356086731,
-0.22226455807685852,
-0.9921673536300659,
-0.054707545787096024,
0.5722615122795105,
0.7046146988868713,
-0.0028366215992718935,
0.4483719766139984,
0.23849277198314667,
0.12639477849006653,
-0.2388889491558075,
0.24011318385601044,
-0.7692359685897827,
0.2506386935710907,
-0.43221980333328247,
-0.49229052662849426,
-0.30160874128341675,
0.1018524244427681,
0.26937806606292725,
0.5373808145523071,
0.18424971401691437,
0.5079440474510193,
0.5665950179100037,
0.3979818820953369,
-0.8685263395309448,
0.19281676411628723,
-0.6642816066741943,
-0.3559390902519226,
-0.2630501091480255,
-0.385165810585022,
-0.5009008646011353,
-0.26782259345054626,
-0.24520765244960785,
-0.33233511447906494,
0.18972793221473694,
0.2287161648273468,
0.7717602849006653,
0.4952296018600464,
-0.14309217035770416,
-0.34671899676322937,
-0.5919937491416931,
0.9726628661155701,
-0.9551478028297424,
0.28945404291152954,
0.0413968600332737,
0.26152166724205017,
-0.5772504806518555,
-0.3234754204750061,
-0.3164758086204529,
-0.1142527237534523,
0.1186988577246666,
0.1779860109090805,
0.26202937960624695,
0.17086376249790192,
0.10321004688739777,
0.39604657888412476,
-0.34942933917045593,
0.6140778064727783,
-0.328520268201828,
-0.08892036229372025,
0.7474066615104675,
-0.16259509325027466,
0.28954407572746277,
0.21089866757392883,
-0.3284624516963959,
-0.04477926716208458,
-1.0039411783218384,
0.42768383026123047,
0.33867910504341125,
0.5294898748397827,
-0.03550317510962486,
0.4328610897064209,
-0.4266480505466461,
0.527350902557373,
0.21461939811706543,
-0.0797085165977478,
0.004488901235163212,
-0.2673526704311371,
-0.13344168663024902,
0.009335004724562168,
0.5621421933174133,
0.3262207508087158,
0.1437172144651413,
-0.17350341379642487,
-0.4875580072402954,
-0.12518705427646637,
0.28135350346565247,
-0.847153902053833,
-0.15470881760120392,
0.4977170526981354,
-0.40607938170433044,
-0.30853915214538574,
-0.15376155078411102,
-0.5852507948875427,
-0.38403409719467163,
-0.8053998351097107,
0.2818187475204468,
-0.39707010984420776,
-0.20048631727695465,
0.024055901914834976,
-0.3670274615287781,
0.3520456850528717,
0.23473487794399261,
-0.793580949306488,
0.0659932866692543,
0.8607102036476135,
0.6848701238632202,
-0.4785653054714203,
-0.21657797694206238,
-0.7457100749015808,
-0.15141507983207703,
-0.4900764524936676,
1.303408145904541,
-0.38148537278175354,
-0.6691063046455383,
-0.13461318612098694,
-0.18057797849178314,
0.03838171437382698,
-0.6806971430778503,
0.9091005921363831,
-0.6861972212791443,
-0.11343936622142792,
-0.3995530605316162,
-0.7329508662223816,
-0.021767016500234604,
-0.055209048092365265,
-0.4225445091724396,
0.7921068668365479,
-0.054099999368190765,
-0.29213640093803406,
0.7404645681381226,
-0.6114072799682617,
-0.17867954075336456,
0.1064993292093277,
-0.3092893660068512,
-0.16142667829990387,
0.5610663294792175,
0.3277550935745239,
0.42947521805763245,
-0.1012217178940773,
-0.17117483913898468,
-0.5732403993606567,
-0.6100112795829773,
-0.03595435619354248,
-0.13100634515285492,
0.6445732116699219,
0.454743891954422,
-0.029011985287070274,
0.2814163565635681,
-0.8976994752883911,
0.24658730626106262,
-0.10005678981542587,
-0.4649088978767395,
-0.39379197359085083,
0.26417210698127747,
0.02887718752026558,
0.11619609594345093,
-0.02500557154417038,
-0.6099523305892944,
0.22341404855251312,
-0.4231608808040619,
0.444045752286911,
0.9041383862495422,
0.2358211874961853,
0.7337789535522461,
-0.4121648371219635,
0.49561938643455505,
-0.23692576587200165,
-0.02656164951622486,
-0.409447580575943,
-0.23050694167613983,
-0.6065528988838196,
-0.5777061581611633,
0.344616174697876,
0.5181174874305725,
-0.6523503065109253,
0.4544369876384735,
0.028758833184838295,
-0.17925794422626495,
-0.47553279995918274,
0.38872790336608887,
-0.04238961264491081,
0.29043787717819214,
0.16927553713321686,
-0.20271387696266174,
-0.5804644227027893,
-0.7133181691169739,
-0.24991631507873535,
-0.032002661377191544,
-0.4898308515548706,
0.16280581057071686,
0.15688900649547577,
0.08229624480009079,
1.2281949520111084,
-0.4921990633010864,
-0.03081350587308407,
-0.4033361077308655,
0.036835480481386185,
0.5019789338111877,
0.19606785476207733,
0.7355188727378845,
-0.2207338809967041,
-0.23419150710105896,
-0.21507962048053741,
-0.41250425577163696,
-0.647198498249054,
-0.2640071213245392,
-0.3253844976425171,
-0.19180458784103394,
0.5589059591293335,
-0.3383689820766449,
0.192003533244133,
0.31708967685699463,
-0.025332525372505188,
0.45058539509773254,
-0.09547015279531479,
0.05082137510180473,
-1.0200464725494385,
-0.40778058767318726,
0.1349967122077942,
0.14693506062030792,
-0.34464889764785767,
0.38275498151779175,
0.17912057042121887,
-0.1282927542924881,
-0.4916563630104065,
0.6168992519378662,
-0.5784153342247009,
0.2907995581626892,
-0.7266424298286438,
-0.042472582310438156,
-0.02278035692870617,
0.4577272832393646,
-0.19002395868301392,
1.045922875404358,
0.3908981382846832,
-0.8094764351844788,
-0.012635534629225731,
-0.18727846443653107,
-0.49188604950904846,
0.6741322875022888,
-0.6393047571182251,
0.2866709530353546,
-0.31726211309432983,
0.10791441053152084,
-1.3293828964233398,
-0.018596388399600983,
0.004833032377064228,
-0.18254446983337402,
0.503825306892395,
-0.2977476119995117,
-0.3700796663761139,
-0.15645186603069305,
-0.491168737411499,
0.15775753557682037,
0.6376866698265076,
-0.7227894067764282,
0.2633272707462311,
0.21101324260234833,
-0.5366950035095215,
-0.018363967537879944,
-0.2927870750427246,
0.03319944813847542,
-0.3173338770866394,
-0.4891432225704193,
0.48483380675315857,
-0.16259247064590454,
-0.339910089969635,
-0.3442079424858093,
-0.3224625289440155,
0.0029443949460983276,
0.26469093561172485,
-0.09676247835159302,
0.2810794413089752,
-0.3880642354488373,
0.017233798280358315,
0.5075107216835022,
-0.09647753089666367,
0.08190865814685822,
-0.272344708442688,
0.43792879581451416,
0.3569958209991455,
-0.39579010009765625,
-0.3484646677970886,
0.37406158447265625,
0.3023279905319214,
-0.013102343305945396,
0.1463489681482315,
0.18321861326694489,
-0.13211485743522644,
-0.9222632050514221,
-0.4129047393798828,
-0.4129376709461212,
-0.5119842886924744,
0.2335759401321411,
-0.5873610973358154,
-0.7739855051040649,
0.34428274631500244,
-0.5637962818145752,
0.5292978286743164,
0.0003089791280217469,
0.4517503082752228,
-0.5818319916725159,
0.5736119151115417,
0.7795895934104919,
-0.06320448219776154,
0.6774550080299377,
-0.14998884499073029,
0.3408224284648895,
-0.8887330889701843,
0.4669095575809479,
-0.48933011293411255,
-0.49108192324638367,
-0.4884590208530426,
-0.2539306879043579,
0.12731178104877472,
0.5684194564819336,
-0.1485493779182434,
0.17660421133041382,
-0.24821625649929047,
0.7373812794685364,
0.6379548907279968,
0.01953047513961792,
0.22021956741809845,
-0.05824223905801773,
-0.05981167033314705,
-0.011819440871477127,
-0.397705078125,
-0.9237722754478455,
0.8831163048744202,
0.31620392203330994,
0.9739534258842468,
-0.08114036917686462,
0.9073536992073059,
0.17660583555698395,
0.3075631856918335,
-0.9805219173431396,
0.4269739091396332,
-0.15052028000354767,
-0.2586069703102112,
-0.11246071010828018,
0.04753465577960014,
-0.6329923868179321,
0.28888463973999023,
0.0789204016327858,
-0.722669780254364,
0.3897915780544281,
0.21951062977313995,
-0.5184783935546875,
0.08148995041847229,
-0.9611494541168213,
0.41036897897720337,
-0.1435474008321762,
-0.1944953352212906,
-0.12389718741178513,
-0.17627809941768646,
0.361685574054718,
-0.15232433378696442,
0.1730513870716095,
-0.16500157117843628,
-0.04931704327464104,
0.23715034127235413,
-0.3125063180923462,
1.0225741863250732,
-0.0286434143781662,
-0.48849180340766907,
0.2980821132659912,
-0.12353414297103882,
0.5324231386184692,
0.20601598918437958,
-0.1333949714899063,
0.11458349972963333,
-0.014982463791966438,
-0.4856805205345154,
-0.6790271997451782,
0.7320281863212585,
-0.6398131251335144,
-0.6813948154449463,
0.1204466000199318,
-0.3619635999202728,
-0.5176739692687988,
0.0060186381451785564,
0.3412885367870331,
0.14488549530506134,
-0.029641833156347275,
0.07160467654466629,
0.8466387391090393,
-0.3492952883243561,
0.5675636529922485,
0.5095970034599304,
0.0581887811422348,
-0.2031683623790741,
0.9634478092193604,
0.10224408656358719,
0.34640753269195557,
0.4691520631313324,
0.10128361731767654,
-0.23231454193592072,
-0.8516819477081299,
-0.7322021126747131,
0.05675983428955078,
-0.5957866907119751,
0.015680620446801186,
-0.17605745792388916,
-0.3163195848464966,
-0.37502560019493103,
-0.2949622869491577,
-0.3432558476924896,
-0.06918475031852722,
-0.4201570749282837,
-0.04660657048225403,
0.1893162876367569,
0.5636187791824341,
0.23781274259090424,
0.3720441460609436,
-0.6214052438735962,
0.18068161606788635,
0.14721764624118805,
0.46255332231521606,
-0.08293895423412323,
-0.628881573677063,
0.06825198978185654,
0.16623260080814362,
-0.5420211553573608,
-0.6440111994743347,
-0.07712160050868988,
0.07510966807603836,
0.8863434791564941,
0.28905513882637024,
0.18330466747283936,
0.4833112359046936,
-0.6363328099250793,
0.7119564414024353,
-0.269800066947937,
-0.666752278804779,
0.7107229828834534,
-0.2442917823791504,
0.2104172259569168,
0.5986231565475464,
0.1701914668083191,
-0.32592228055000305,
-0.3472355306148529,
-0.18500752747058868,
-0.8405623435974121,
0.43298277258872986,
0.04582039266824722,
0.07759159058332443,
0.2721344828605652,
0.5759344696998596,
0.3523262143135071,
0.15141481161117554,
-0.1360684484243393,
-0.06634001433849335,
0.01757369376718998,
-0.3737364411354065,
0.01439020223915577,
-0.2592233121395111,
0.11805418878793716,
0.09650328010320663,
0.614475429058075,
-0.2776584327220917,
-0.14399661123752594,
-0.10193248838186264,
-0.13352881371974945,
0.3063398003578186,
0.5313023924827576,
0.6990313529968262,
0.6317020654678345,
-0.19985119998455048,
-0.013643652200698853,
0.2769644260406494,
-0.35647353529930115,
0.15250694751739502,
0.013324419967830181,
-0.40813982486724854,
-0.208934023976326,
0.31970685720443726,
0.7320258021354675,
0.10968481749296188,
-0.5335952639579773,
0.10289407521486282,
-0.04548432305455208,
-0.1371171772480011,
0.12979362905025482,
0.42321673035621643,
-0.046830542385578156,
0.2777247428894043,
0.41135773062705994,
-0.08466248214244843,
0.24044854938983917,
-0.44898679852485657,
0.06577051430940628,
0.3395431935787201,
-0.13948984444141388,
-0.409531831741333,
0.6205596923828125,
0.31313350796699524,
-0.3122599422931671,
0.2892058491706848,
-0.20172826945781708,
0.07899212092161179,
0.5825695991516113,
0.36101141571998596,
0.9520529508590698,
0.013503415510058403,
0.000485835422296077,
0.12636427581310272,
0.21208928525447845,
0.22688892483711243,
0.39588576555252075,
-0.1962871104478836,
-0.671248197555542,
-0.9863743185997009,
-0.7508167028427124,
-0.4967108368873596,
0.4195480942726135,
-0.4273529052734375,
0.7328839302062988,
-0.3728669285774231,
0.044944990426301956,
-0.18604591488838196,
-0.1181034967303276,
-0.5301011800765991,
0.08457522839307785,
0.28173449635505676,
1.0703505277633667,
-0.6525629162788391,
0.6275414228439331,
0.7673469185829163,
-0.31783172488212585,
-0.6308701038360596,
0.13390865921974182,
0.125215083360672,
-0.8168500661849976,
0.7200604677200317,
-0.14042170345783234,
-0.04399118572473526,
0.03237602487206459,
-0.6348184943199158,
-0.959091067314148,
0.8522445559501648,
0.33145737648010254,
-0.7955920100212097,
0.12852753698825836,
0.005176446866244078,
0.40418776869773865,
-0.2228466421365738,
0.29328665137290955,
0.5703771710395813,
-0.008728792890906334,
0.2625059485435486,
-0.7542011737823486,
-0.022366566583514214,
-0.22454096376895905,
0.35041794180870056,
0.11222756654024124,
-0.6916068196296692,
0.5163298845291138,
-0.2942604124546051,
-0.39107808470726013,
-0.017933137714862823,
0.6898806095123291,
0.7616123557090759,
0.21823878586292267,
0.5387183427810669,
0.33236294984817505,
0.6383143663406372,
0.00897143129259348,
0.8341670632362366,
-0.36673688888549805,
0.06939873844385147,
1.4764339923858643,
-0.46321114897727966,
0.9431551694869995,
0.7340070009231567,
-0.09596332907676697,
0.11474644392728806,
1.0892516374588013,
0.232613205909729,
0.7891381978988647,
0.5574350953102112,
-0.21526432037353516,
-0.007812013383954763,
-0.08713040500879288,
-0.22904843091964722,
0.1965491622686386,
0.33878278732299805,
-0.21767626702785492,
-0.5036414861679077,
0.02823556773364544,
-0.18780335783958435,
-0.09954631328582764,
-0.23116660118103027,
0.8343419432640076,
0.3278960585594177,
-0.5227015018463135,
0.4372139871120453,
-0.20219166576862335,
0.8351055383682251,
-0.2519509494304657,
-0.09142378717660904,
-0.5028170347213745,
0.2764512300491333,
0.002074125688523054,
-0.8509780764579773,
0.23892782628536224,
-0.11117149889469147,
-0.28527548909187317,
-0.5444141030311584,
0.567010223865509,
0.009414280764758587,
-0.3122791647911072,
0.0619671493768692,
0.4106128215789795,
-0.0064640408381819725,
-0.14418868720531464,
-0.2400798201560974,
0.19269432127475739,
-0.09687571972608566,
-0.27068477869033813,
0.4115263521671295,
0.5858557820320129,
-0.11133745312690735,
0.4236668646335602,
0.7441295981407166,
0.36903202533721924,
-0.02864464558660984,
0.3959299325942993,
0.9159656167030334,
-0.5358378887176514,
-0.3876968324184418,
-0.8720487356185913,
0.5111182928085327,
-0.16395917534828186,
-0.5616227388381958,
0.6236395239830017,
0.5703940391540527,
1.2147799730300903,
-0.11106593906879425,
1.1236698627471924,
0.20893895626068115,
0.5911949276924133,
-0.7708266973495483,
0.48242783546447754,
-0.3743370771408081,
0.5337812900543213,
-0.059727635234594345,
-0.8085469603538513,
0.03050573542714119,
0.2840723395347595,
-0.298022985458374,
-0.13170740008354187,
0.5190904140472412,
0.787263810634613,
-0.1293317824602127,
0.26858165860176086,
0.2217532843351364,
0.022659331560134888,
0.7619722485542297,
0.527057409286499,
1.032038688659668,
-0.18865038454532623,
0.377338707447052,
-0.2158585488796234,
-0.507827639579773,
-0.06733701378107071,
-0.9082509875297546,
-0.9016404151916504,
-0.2977684438228607,
-0.277295857667923,
0.092705637216568,
-0.11885819584131241,
0.9487016201019287,
0.7819486856460571,
-0.9820910692214966,
-0.2894747257232666,
-0.12573565542697906,
0.03686996176838875,
-0.2185678333044052,
-0.21064789593219757,
0.018830982968211174,
-1.0057915449142456,
-0.9187026023864746,
0.5396214127540588,
0.37825825810432434,
-0.02821793220937252,
-0.18163494765758514,
0.27115997672080994,
0.31778985261917114,
0.058344755321741104,
0.8388204574584961,
0.041628655046224594,
-0.7271743416786194,
-0.15410077571868896,
0.17755845189094543,
0.03917745500802994,
0.021503228694200516,
1.0221883058547974,
-0.5872896313667297,
0.08316107094287872,
0.7181188464164734,
0.9045966267585754,
0.20617035031318665,
-0.013624558225274086,
0.7369242310523987,
-0.7777843475341797,
-0.09018634259700775,
0.04221713915467262,
0.45653679966926575,
-0.026459824293851852,
-0.44304385781288147,
0.3450881540775299,
0.017661064863204956,
-0.6610185503959656,
-0.6927869319915771,
0.303659051656723,
-0.8410302996635437,
-0.5659767389297485,
1.2491410970687866,
0.08159035444259644,
-0.1617506444454193,
-0.2163352370262146,
-0.7517515420913696,
-0.044093430042266846,
-0.5008221864700317,
0.8821789026260376,
1.0068320035934448,
-0.31813567876815796,
-0.31019628047943115,
-0.7764686346054077,
0.3278498947620392,
0.0983102098107338,
-0.8331453800201416,
-0.10156909376382828,
0.21811826527118683,
0.5027743577957153,
-0.06840381771326065,
0.40352219343185425,
0.29430925846099854,
0.02232224866747856,
-0.31267762184143066,
0.01758480817079544,
0.18232882022857666,
0.05579579994082451,
-0.17412905395030975,
0.15946762263774872,
0.39951011538505554,
-0.4818020164966583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13020v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13020v1
|
Stronger Random Baselines for In-Context Learning
| 2024-04-19T17:30:10 | 2024-04-19T17:30:10 |
Gregory Yauney, David Mimno
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Evaluating the in-context learning classification performance of language
models poses challenges due to small dataset sizes, extensive prompt-selection
using the validation set, and intentionally difficult tasks that lead to
near-random performance. The standard random baseline -- the expected accuracy
of guessing labels uniformly at random -- is stable when the evaluation set is
used only once or when the dataset is large. We account for the common practice
of validation set reuse and existing small datasets with a stronger random
baseline: the expected maximum accuracy across multiple random classifiers.
When choosing the best prompt demonstrations across six quantized language
models applied to 16 BIG-bench Lite tasks, more than 20\% of the few-shot
results that exceed the standard baseline do not exceed this stronger random
baseline. When held-out test sets are available, this stronger baseline is also
a better predictor of held-out performance than the standard baseline, avoiding
unnecessary test set evaluations. This maximum random baseline provides an
easily calculated drop-in replacement for the standard baseline.
|
[
-0.31709107756614685,
-0.534115731716156,
0.2781355082988739,
0.1180032268166542,
-0.061905622482299805,
-0.2710931599140167,
-0.5409957766532898,
-0.34063446521759033,
-0.663109302520752,
0.1747744381427765,
-0.21707451343536377,
-0.3996416926383972,
-0.5692045092582703,
0.14052249491214752,
-0.5505015254020691,
1.0780055522918701,
0.014032267034053802,
0.14481551945209503,
-0.5732500553131104,
-0.6439662575721741,
-0.6096439957618713,
-0.3978497087955475,
-0.5542333126068115,
-0.497346431016922,
0.4116705060005188,
0.6136875152587891,
0.5699155330657959,
0.45625337958335876,
0.48620855808258057,
0.24189960956573486,
-0.11154622584581375,
-0.2248889058828354,
-0.5185574293136597,
0.12232677638530731,
-0.04391827434301376,
-0.44087401032447815,
0.08377592265605927,
0.061356160789728165,
1.0046653747558594,
1.0557410717010498,
-0.2995739281177521,
0.28716418147087097,
0.23981422185897827,
0.32329705357551575,
-0.7856433987617493,
-0.01074778288602829,
-0.43803635239601135,
0.12204819917678833,
-0.13565696775913239,
-0.05162458494305611,
-0.6690146923065186,
-0.4153633415699005,
0.37203818559646606,
-0.4409327805042267,
0.04254990816116333,
0.06261561810970306,
1.0234417915344238,
0.19189733266830444,
-0.5161636471748352,
-0.026698516681790352,
-0.600009024143219,
0.9874295592308044,
-0.35614463686943054,
0.47279271483421326,
0.42015597224235535,
0.6738459467887878,
-0.13797242939472198,
-0.8626126646995544,
-0.33613139390945435,
-0.48866844177246094,
0.13410137593746185,
0.02922140434384346,
-0.011518861167132854,
-0.00026341830380260944,
0.5698175430297852,
0.4098123610019684,
-0.3544743061065674,
0.4159698784351349,
-0.23987524211406708,
-0.11229941993951797,
0.2303391695022583,
0.0978768989443779,
0.13599227368831635,
0.07710672169923782,
-0.36874642968177795,
-0.31134480237960815,
-0.8702009320259094,
0.31381428241729736,
-0.12309136986732483,
0.39134901762008667,
0.0028994183521717787,
0.3550185561180115,
-0.46172842383384705,
0.9565158486366272,
0.09821821749210358,
-0.3451892137527466,
0.4024795889854431,
-0.33750325441360474,
-0.4470732510089874,
-0.2625160217285156,
0.5583788752555847,
0.24630425870418549,
0.3175464868545532,
-0.03277262672781944,
-0.44274353981018066,
-0.2807717025279999,
-0.015017015859484673,
-0.6605069637298584,
-0.2049359828233719,
0.05528213828802109,
-0.423801064491272,
-0.20238849520683289,
-0.0430573932826519,
-0.22414211928844452,
-0.29775139689445496,
-0.5359755754470825,
0.5370687246322632,
-0.44355034828186035,
0.30170151591300964,
-0.07148554176092148,
-0.3733580708503723,
0.06082354485988617,
0.5052258968353271,
-0.586958646774292,
0.31043902039527893,
0.3924556076526642,
0.4927137494087219,
-0.12016641348600388,
-0.5117635130882263,
-0.5682289600372314,
-0.12272514402866364,
-0.4095328450202942,
0.6701855063438416,
-0.420855313539505,
-0.21429549157619476,
0.10128256678581238,
-0.22634710371494293,
0.011804000474512577,
-0.6520749926567078,
0.42776286602020264,
-0.39786699414253235,
0.5402641892433167,
-0.6337435245513916,
-0.8225594162940979,
0.2135719358921051,
0.11457255482673645,
-0.4452105164527893,
1.2577165365219116,
0.5193902254104614,
-0.6637013554573059,
1.201882004737854,
0.0006123650819063187,
-0.32752496004104614,
0.2727418541908264,
-0.27720561623573303,
-0.36194074153900146,
0.16617044806480408,
0.11590079218149185,
0.5328934192657471,
-0.21745774149894714,
0.23961962759494781,
-0.4095272719860077,
-0.6414813995361328,
0.23342572152614594,
-0.46824365854263306,
0.9525694847106934,
0.22844022512435913,
-0.3376421630382538,
-0.07665593922138214,
-0.9711534976959229,
0.16635708510875702,
-0.14436449110507965,
-0.3809341788291931,
-0.5420444011688232,
-0.0506817102432251,
-0.0042580971494317055,
0.27431192994117737,
0.05074035003781319,
-0.3725315034389496,
-0.12534071505069733,
-0.1386200189590454,
0.0010727735934779048,
0.8183518052101135,
0.09501954168081284,
0.5507813692092896,
-0.46098124980926514,
0.3006896376609802,
-0.04977532848715782,
0.06466109305620193,
-0.09794316440820694,
-0.40788400173187256,
-0.45624691247940063,
-0.4960574805736542,
0.5524502992630005,
0.360842764377594,
-0.5266983509063721,
0.42741015553474426,
-0.48552361130714417,
-0.3753814399242401,
-0.22016508877277374,
0.32907044887542725,
0.706668496131897,
0.734985888004303,
0.2182624787092209,
-0.17399704456329346,
-0.37799426913261414,
-0.9658686518669128,
-0.04752408713102341,
-0.05255982279777527,
-0.2617814838886261,
0.1830713003873825,
0.5337681770324707,
-0.041064389050006866,
1.2101410627365112,
-0.05291788652539253,
0.019009370356798172,
-0.3319730758666992,
0.1973119080066681,
-0.029058735817670822,
0.5192771553993225,
0.6048288345336914,
-0.6912055611610413,
-0.5719094276428223,
-0.0552954375743866,
-0.8784192800521851,
-0.11293414980173111,
-0.05324605852365494,
0.16298311948776245,
0.11003100872039795,
0.40401238203048706,
-0.21938972175121307,
0.22668913006782532,
0.37127506732940674,
0.0052364361472427845,
0.5513725280761719,
0.053259383887052536,
0.0723997950553894,
-0.9579694867134094,
-0.027405939996242523,
0.12583771347999573,
-0.19124732911586761,
-0.4980930685997009,
0.12569570541381836,
0.36145955324172974,
-0.1283409148454666,
-0.5335512757301331,
0.8196011781692505,
-0.18329136073589325,
-0.03936219587922096,
-0.02596117928624153,
0.10707946121692657,
-0.1438349038362503,
0.13530704379081726,
-0.007957196794450283,
0.9119443893432617,
0.5119994878768921,
-0.728027880191803,
0.012707866728305817,
0.07062947005033493,
-0.8197760581970215,
0.8170145750045776,
-0.4832674264907837,
-0.16418662667274475,
0.00006989148096181452,
0.6644962430000305,
-0.870408296585083,
-0.5187749862670898,
-0.29164785146713257,
-0.25896549224853516,
0.38347727060317993,
0.10220351070165634,
-0.5350951552391052,
-0.2390643209218979,
-0.21169506013393402,
0.33702176809310913,
0.5831501483917236,
-1.041326880455017,
0.014080416411161423,
0.3234749138355255,
0.1899246871471405,
-0.885103702545166,
-0.6070030331611633,
-0.12011951953172684,
-0.33833539485931396,
-0.3626038134098053,
0.10897219181060791,
-0.03143326938152313,
-0.3831675052642822,
-0.26034021377563477,
-0.3317470848560333,
-0.1046500951051712,
0.322242796421051,
0.2803347110748291,
-0.06003475934267044,
-0.11989715695381165,
0.3623262643814087,
-0.11488907784223557,
-0.017687015235424042,
-0.09760259836912155,
-0.09271927922964096,
0.12229432910680771,
-0.279511958360672,
-0.16080619394779205,
-0.44276031851768494,
0.06665981560945511,
0.30326488614082336,
0.2853652238845825,
0.9063473343849182,
0.3572213053703308,
-0.6251133680343628,
-0.5964908599853516,
-0.44980770349502563,
-0.22733475267887115,
-0.430531769990921,
0.42113837599754333,
-0.7127389311790466,
-0.9587671160697937,
0.5621541142463684,
0.1865864098072052,
0.11344003677368164,
0.3421061635017395,
0.4598546624183655,
-0.47502657771110535,
0.9696288704872131,
0.516765296459198,
-0.021104546263813972,
0.6169965267181396,
-0.02731914632022381,
-0.12149208784103394,
-0.59441739320755,
-0.05211234465241432,
-0.6080390810966492,
-0.13452740013599396,
-0.3615064322948456,
-0.14930453896522522,
0.029980216175317764,
0.2858704924583435,
-0.42824986577033997,
0.33446770906448364,
-0.33399009704589844,
0.6687526106834412,
0.6781579256057739,
0.10214673727750778,
0.04544105380773544,
0.09328141063451767,
-0.39474067091941833,
-0.003958567976951599,
-0.7910398840904236,
-0.5489538908004761,
1.1420118808746338,
0.3154354989528656,
0.5382825136184692,
-0.2720896303653717,
0.8038578033447266,
0.05071649327874184,
0.7714816331863403,
-0.4818359911441803,
0.5292845964431763,
0.022494947537779808,
-0.7254074811935425,
-0.43819814920425415,
-0.6189405918121338,
-0.8743348121643066,
0.20618192851543427,
-0.04634847119450569,
-0.8010877966880798,
0.12376391887664795,
0.16638167202472687,
-0.49256035685539246,
0.09467345476150513,
-0.7791720032691956,
0.898312509059906,
0.22612139582633972,
-0.12369634956121445,
0.11052751541137695,
-0.717612624168396,
0.4065380394458771,
-0.025982718914747238,
0.12942485511302948,
0.05455143377184868,
0.09731880575418472,
0.6933948397636414,
-0.3756447732448578,
0.7568326592445374,
-0.1763334423303604,
0.07780240476131439,
0.42671361565589905,
-0.17880350351333618,
0.4136725068092346,
0.058428723365068436,
-0.02732107974588871,
0.009279230609536171,
-0.04690507426857948,
-0.6629119515419006,
-0.7153787016868591,
0.4397386312484741,
-0.7878291606903076,
-0.18558791279792786,
-0.5232714414596558,
-0.2672024667263031,
-0.43090325593948364,
-0.0705919861793518,
0.6897304058074951,
0.6864581108093262,
-0.41563886404037476,
0.7874356508255005,
0.8449923992156982,
-0.006432653404772282,
0.24624328315258026,
0.29125770926475525,
0.07792205363512039,
-0.46927526593208313,
0.8628421425819397,
0.3601301312446594,
0.5054606795310974,
0.49603599309921265,
0.27044183015823364,
-0.15276247262954712,
-0.7675697803497314,
-0.22531573474407196,
-0.2741442024707794,
-1.1379363536834717,
-0.2705589830875397,
-0.38199979066848755,
-0.12775935232639313,
-0.22190484404563904,
-0.4893343448638916,
-0.20471175014972687,
-0.572830319404602,
0.014946259558200836,
-0.3130245804786682,
-0.03825828805565834,
0.34478506445884705,
-0.02775000035762787,
0.4199960231781006,
-0.4466429650783539,
0.02409198135137558,
0.5704827904701233,
0.38964417576789856,
-0.10720440745353699,
-0.7827180624008179,
-0.4530145227909088,
-0.16198848187923431,
-0.022529559209942818,
-0.5917201042175293,
-0.017558829858899117,
0.2332056611776352,
0.6851292252540588,
0.39693158864974976,
-0.12488077580928802,
0.6513800024986267,
-0.39093372225761414,
0.7323877811431885,
0.12774056196212769,
-0.6510398983955383,
0.4004480838775635,
-0.40216678380966187,
0.5413656234741211,
1.1161487102508545,
0.3498326539993286,
-0.3839479982852936,
-0.5660032033920288,
-0.8362811803817749,
-0.8326177597045898,
0.6264205574989319,
0.18597668409347534,
-0.08466844260692596,
-0.24759480357170105,
0.30634790658950806,
0.15601769089698792,
0.22655217349529266,
-0.8767938017845154,
-0.2670251429080963,
0.11582044512033463,
-0.33841896057128906,
-0.19897809624671936,
-0.1831311285495758,
-0.29461362957954407,
-0.3486716151237488,
0.49127933382987976,
-0.16360390186309814,
0.14439672231674194,
-0.2807193994522095,
-0.5309902429580688,
-0.0524679571390152,
0.22973735630512238,
0.5090094208717346,
0.8478246331214905,
-0.45413893461227417,
0.11616051942110062,
0.673899233341217,
-0.33345967531204224,
0.07212621718645096,
-0.09072823077440262,
-0.2597378194332123,
-0.14448051154613495,
0.517500638961792,
0.749348521232605,
0.9317483305931091,
-0.8134795427322388,
0.49343931674957275,
-0.10638107359409332,
-0.07050130516290665,
-0.3782590329647064,
0.060173869132995605,
-0.31541457772254944,
-0.15375356376171112,
0.5110740065574646,
0.12919481098651886,
0.04837249219417572,
-0.42525094747543335,
0.5725864768028259,
0.23511578142642975,
-0.3797900676727295,
-0.061551064252853394,
0.34408295154571533,
-0.010072928853332996,
-0.05831727758049965,
0.7677775621414185,
-0.24598293006420135,
-0.2110125571489334,
0.8116819262504578,
0.5653668642044067,
0.7052850723266602,
-0.12787677347660065,
0.1792399287223816,
0.540534257888794,
0.09219680726528168,
-0.5547876358032227,
0.002185514895245433,
-0.28068989515304565,
-0.7592355608940125,
-0.16415710747241974,
-0.5941291451454163,
-0.6329305171966553,
0.07341121137142181,
-0.8494864702224731,
0.3138628304004669,
-0.5964017510414124,
-0.12939144670963287,
-0.22936111688613892,
0.07623903453350067,
-0.7325575947761536,
0.6679148077964783,
0.15201832354068756,
0.8898718357086182,
-0.95273357629776,
0.7938495874404907,
0.5919149518013,
-0.43766459822654724,
-0.7232497930526733,
-0.17581036686897278,
0.16178622841835022,
-0.5721908211708069,
0.7015068531036377,
0.33158978819847107,
0.39993467926979065,
-0.1698905974626541,
-0.5541729927062988,
-1.008058786392212,
0.996509850025177,
0.1845415085554123,
-0.43147167563438416,
0.13382482528686523,
-0.21107475459575653,
0.6664096117019653,
-0.459437757730484,
0.5477555990219116,
0.5456555485725403,
0.23063918948173523,
0.04271688312292099,
-0.8497008085250854,
-0.0379612073302269,
-0.011737815104424953,
0.07986821979284286,
0.023568924516439438,
-0.6161496639251709,
0.7101576328277588,
0.06927267462015152,
-0.19170337915420532,
0.07248279452323914,
0.7777695059776306,
0.8081580996513367,
0.4416942596435547,
0.4829784035682678,
0.7065081596374512,
1.0234489440917969,
-0.3037523627281189,
1.4350789785385132,
0.088934987783432,
0.2658480405807495,
1.3973344564437866,
-0.25780194997787476,
1.1716853380203247,
0.23024508357048035,
-0.21285998821258545,
0.33672067523002625,
0.8869476914405823,
-0.003330039558932185,
0.47159072756767273,
0.17255046963691711,
-0.1337212175130844,
-0.21432426571846008,
0.1727677434682846,
-0.2961761951446533,
0.2522556483745575,
0.23987802863121033,
-0.13687218725681305,
-0.3105347454547882,
0.32704880833625793,
-0.05815538763999939,
0.07925339788198471,
-0.17146623134613037,
0.4725501239299774,
0.1691409796476364,
-0.7035550475120544,
0.67128986120224,
-0.2856541872024536,
0.44882136583328247,
-0.3551942706108093,
0.26827406883239746,
-0.20324043929576874,
0.2642683982849121,
-0.05247404798865318,
-0.7151086330413818,
-0.1559196412563324,
-0.028276268392801285,
-0.2828683853149414,
-0.5377645492553711,
0.4648350775241852,
-0.2945193648338318,
-0.25862917304039,
0.06981449574232101,
0.2008277326822281,
0.04204206541180611,
0.24214719235897064,
-0.6591909527778625,
-0.09967535734176636,
-0.18099574744701385,
-0.5198725461959839,
0.9120190143585205,
0.5545697212219238,
-0.2703413665294647,
0.7695236802101135,
0.3970935046672821,
-0.23274436593055725,
0.23985323309898376,
0.3433704674243927,
0.6024251580238342,
-0.40317291021347046,
-0.3331121802330017,
-0.44246596097946167,
0.5051245093345642,
-0.2529947757720947,
-0.7851799130439758,
1.0778840780258179,
0.4899977147579193,
1.1085751056671143,
0.12514688074588776,
0.7213123440742493,
0.0026666682679206133,
0.4309872090816498,
-0.3958187997341156,
0.48070579767227173,
-0.5523378849029541,
0.15266431868076324,
-0.2696666717529297,
-0.9254699349403381,
-0.33173659443855286,
0.7384000420570374,
-0.265342116355896,
0.33199596405029297,
0.9356209635734558,
0.32094407081604004,
0.08812009543180466,
0.044944386929273605,
0.49698397517204285,
-0.10331465303897858,
0.21425531804561615,
0.5571854710578918,
0.8954777121543884,
-0.5014880895614624,
0.35119879245758057,
-0.6201260089874268,
-0.36241641640663147,
-0.21117109060287476,
-0.8225739598274231,
-0.9551748633384705,
-0.6172299981117249,
-0.5341469049453735,
-0.44513842463493347,
0.08676312863826752,
0.9965127110481262,
0.732504665851593,
-1.0244332551956177,
-0.2473129779100418,
-0.1322934776544571,
-0.0003670254081953317,
-0.547804594039917,
-0.26500973105430603,
0.26683664321899414,
-0.8057805299758911,
-0.6876832246780396,
0.4327166974544525,
-0.01958398148417473,
0.013071279041469097,
0.11081171035766602,
-0.03564697131514549,
-0.0005591503577306867,
-0.09835914522409439,
0.48256716132164,
0.6636434197425842,
-0.492844820022583,
-0.43005698919296265,
-0.29507210850715637,
-0.5669841170310974,
-0.05016063153743744,
0.4718375504016876,
-0.9357895255088806,
0.4737855792045593,
0.5696444511413574,
0.6755263805389404,
0.32659927010536194,
0.0997525081038475,
0.7003800868988037,
-1.0857592821121216,
0.24714899063110352,
0.37368273735046387,
0.4512466490268707,
0.22260110080242157,
-0.030661744996905327,
0.45548397302627563,
0.17626239359378815,
-0.5773093104362488,
-1.3798201084136963,
-0.1094493493437767,
-0.8228697180747986,
-0.17205986380577087,
1.1480330228805542,
-0.12687964737415314,
-0.17840485274791718,
-0.0859261229634285,
0.2428443729877472,
0.0008691712864674628,
-0.27293649315834045,
0.6862130761146545,
1.0139491558074951,
0.1694149523973465,
-0.12485632300376892,
-0.6956105828285217,
0.7099783420562744,
0.5083630084991455,
-0.5099387764930725,
0.011705196462571621,
0.4747820496559143,
0.4265404939651489,
0.1446533054113388,
0.525467038154602,
0.011654380708932877,
0.4898095726966858,
0.12347371876239777,
-0.13298843801021576,
0.19953981041908264,
-0.599817156791687,
-0.6399162411689758,
0.5040138363838196,
0.07633151113986969,
0.07768479734659195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13013v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13013v1
|
Groma: Localized Visual Tokenization for Grounding Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-04-19T17:22:51 | 2024-04-19T17:22:51 |
Chuofan Ma, Yi Jiang, Jiannan Wu, Zehuan Yuan, Xiaojuan Qi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We introduce Groma, a Multimodal Large Language Model (MLLM) with grounded
and fine-grained visual perception ability. Beyond holistic image
understanding, Groma is adept at region-level tasks such as region captioning
and visual grounding. Such capabilities are built upon a localized visual
tokenization mechanism, where an image input is decomposed into regions of
interest and subsequently encoded into region tokens. By integrating region
tokens into user instructions and model responses, we seamlessly enable Groma
to understand user-specified region inputs and ground its textual output to
images. Besides, to enhance the grounded chat ability of Groma, we curate a
visually grounded instruction dataset by leveraging the powerful GPT-4V and
visual prompting techniques. Compared with MLLMs that rely on the language
model or external module for localization, Groma consistently demonstrates
superior performances in standard referring and grounding benchmarks,
highlighting the advantages of embedding localization into image tokenization.
Project page: https://groma-mllm.github.io/.
|
[
-0.25654539465904236,
-0.980399489402771,
0.6626018285751343,
0.2420293688774109,
-0.39987796545028687,
-0.12139645963907242,
-0.33960509300231934,
-0.11122525483369827,
0.012925778515636921,
0.6940335035324097,
-0.040872201323509216,
-1.0180118083953857,
-0.5891179442405701,
-0.37185138463974,
-0.33236801624298096,
0.9020794630050659,
0.07132526487112045,
0.1560286581516266,
-0.7053285837173462,
-0.20596949756145477,
-0.779949963092804,
-0.6745501160621643,
-0.755131185054779,
-0.3036421239376068,
0.3744785487651825,
0.35998716950416565,
0.7594084143638611,
0.6807292699813843,
0.5300629138946533,
0.3428964614868164,
-0.17309534549713135,
0.10446285456418991,
-0.3948880136013031,
-0.022270437330007553,
-0.10012245923280716,
-0.5463829636573792,
-0.36975759267807007,
-0.326159805059433,
0.7712207436561584,
0.5932788848876953,
-0.07122914493083954,
0.059833139181137085,
-0.2882058322429657,
0.5598549842834473,
-0.5267212986946106,
0.30394476652145386,
-0.7261197566986084,
-0.04827287048101425,
-0.18432395160198212,
-0.2862030267715454,
-0.39388781785964966,
-0.05020308867096901,
-0.05266202986240387,
-0.5923956632614136,
0.373188316822052,
-0.11238763481378555,
0.9430478811264038,
0.28856661915779114,
-0.6518654823303223,
-0.1137264221906662,
-0.44873765110969543,
0.6907004117965698,
-0.5293196439743042,
0.3952605724334717,
0.4787519574165344,
0.6245906949043274,
-0.15073895454406738,
-0.9963870644569397,
-0.35234737396240234,
-0.3547147214412689,
-0.2185516059398651,
0.068792924284935,
-0.14865140616893768,
0.22623538970947266,
0.20535820722579956,
0.4455121159553528,
-0.4665791988372803,
-0.13923798501491547,
-0.22684547305107117,
-0.22828339040279388,
-0.004114741459488869,
-0.006852245889604092,
0.5441312789916992,
0.08061014860868454,
-0.2836896777153015,
-0.008826911449432373,
-0.6659866571426392,
-0.04391174390912056,
0.09354107081890106,
0.4208100438117981,
-0.3618970811367035,
0.4978082478046417,
-0.25847870111465454,
0.8751204013824463,
-0.049356140196323395,
-0.334750771522522,
0.37983882427215576,
-0.1183464527130127,
-0.4100635349750519,
-0.2063717395067215,
0.6680636405944824,
0.510231614112854,
-0.1440369188785553,
-0.0261395126581192,
-0.3421616554260254,
0.07667304575443268,
-0.049039166420698166,
-0.7136929631233215,
-0.13233615458011627,
0.12227015942335129,
-0.5784544348716736,
-0.22418047487735748,
0.03984204679727554,
-0.9189589619636536,
-0.759501039981842,
-0.3290901482105255,
0.33109748363494873,
-0.09816526621580124,
-0.08613358438014984,
0.04190775752067566,
-0.2663115859031677,
-0.05537930503487587,
0.4649753272533417,
-0.9451285600662231,
0.1309712529182434,
0.5165454149246216,
1.0602940320968628,
0.20646601915359497,
-0.45680007338523865,
-0.8649327158927917,
0.3736656606197357,
-0.16892988979816437,
0.6487537622451782,
-0.8768279552459717,
-0.2159884124994278,
0.052579548209905624,
0.13766640424728394,
0.02057499811053276,
-0.4126572012901306,
0.41035857796669006,
-0.35535508394241333,
0.4394998550415039,
-0.23815511167049408,
-0.14678381383419037,
-0.3509114384651184,
0.4059956669807434,
-0.4661771357059479,
0.7537062168121338,
-0.027935199439525604,
-0.6581447720527649,
0.3378430902957916,
-0.7684974670410156,
-0.3265496790409088,
0.0736139789223671,
-0.4731485843658447,
-0.06395453959703445,
0.038336560130119324,
0.7074398994445801,
0.6214501857757568,
-0.26178768277168274,
0.5656632781028748,
-0.1316693127155304,
-0.4244779646396637,
-0.2513684034347534,
-0.5791036486625671,
0.19631391763687134,
0.1302611529827118,
-0.48961812257766724,
0.5684612989425659,
-0.7111374735832214,
-0.12649650871753693,
0.20195013284683228,
-0.13784828782081604,
-0.3621791899204254,
0.06258593499660492,
0.07641179859638214,
0.13946782052516937,
0.39107006788253784,
-0.02398223616182804,
0.18686920404434204,
-0.038887929171323776,
0.5758888721466064,
0.6066644787788391,
-0.07966843247413635,
0.646868884563446,
0.23045100271701813,
0.5213831067085266,
0.08398441225290298,
0.1803174763917923,
-0.9743014574050903,
-0.6513872146606445,
-0.7773074507713318,
-0.695365846157074,
0.05772434175014496,
0.4278254806995392,
-0.8935582637786865,
0.12557333707809448,
-0.37770771980285645,
-0.46201789379119873,
-0.325905442237854,
0.03474576398730278,
0.4370548129081726,
0.7310183048248291,
0.4050687849521637,
-0.013059640303254128,
-0.2956569194793701,
-0.9243312478065491,
0.2281203418970108,
-0.031197156757116318,
0.03719421103596687,
0.4027029871940613,
0.3913915455341339,
-0.5750604867935181,
0.8361717462539673,
-0.35771384835243225,
-0.471272736787796,
-0.10100599378347397,
0.2964869439601898,
0.3156994581222534,
0.4407975375652313,
1.0114670991897583,
-0.9067726135253906,
-0.3717188537120819,
0.8253786563873291,
-1.0096585750579834,
-0.10688795149326324,
-0.19894416630268097,
-0.1636960506439209,
-0.007274004630744457,
0.5694966316223145,
-0.6064696907997131,
0.4439130425453186,
0.871153712272644,
-0.6102473139762878,
0.1555633395910263,
-0.32868197560310364,
0.47812211513519287,
-1.0995421409606934,
0.23866111040115356,
-0.17343051731586456,
-0.4456343352794647,
-0.5992961525917053,
0.34948423504829407,
0.06103905290365219,
-0.5175954103469849,
-0.29903706908226013,
0.7469887137413025,
-0.5976442694664001,
-0.2660506069660187,
-0.26877203583717346,
0.07311338931322098,
0.0924374908208847,
0.450501024723053,
0.08095910400152206,
1.063546895980835,
1.0312036275863647,
-0.34997421503067017,
0.41776221990585327,
0.11546560376882553,
-0.10881564766168594,
0.46358659863471985,
-0.8645213842391968,
0.175114706158638,
-0.30664920806884766,
0.35892969369888306,
-0.870210587978363,
-0.5274578332901001,
0.23988845944404602,
-0.3440290689468384,
0.1554058939218521,
-0.8152056336402893,
-0.2159702628850937,
-0.10293992608785629,
0.0043955412693321705,
0.42261773347854614,
0.4794936776161194,
-0.782426655292511,
0.8220323324203491,
0.3766806125640869,
-0.007573739159852266,
-0.5785669684410095,
-0.5730830430984497,
0.420698344707489,
-0.39173218607902527,
-0.5415551066398621,
-0.06575942784547806,
0.3005428910255432,
-0.13487005233764648,
-0.0919479951262474,
0.1845846027135849,
-0.07339886575937271,
0.09851871430873871,
0.5715432167053223,
-0.006902732420712709,
-0.20055435597896576,
0.25428393483161926,
0.07535624504089355,
-0.17983698844909668,
-0.1264933943748474,
-0.5521423816680908,
0.7597150206565857,
-0.5028705596923828,
-0.6100497841835022,
-0.5254539251327515,
0.3826388418674469,
0.9837954640388489,
-0.4538155496120453,
0.7878267765045166,
0.7266507148742676,
-0.5227518081665039,
0.3356507420539856,
-0.48125773668289185,
0.1152285486459732,
-0.4955288767814636,
0.4263140857219696,
-0.42680057883262634,
-0.9690727591514587,
0.7791749835014343,
0.010558467358350754,
-0.2282526195049286,
0.25312259793281555,
0.6546928882598877,
0.18499627709388733,
1.1904176473617554,
0.5397616028785706,
-0.18093523383140564,
0.6587532758712769,
-0.17421633005142212,
0.020327128469944,
-0.4859282970428467,
-0.30199843645095825,
-0.4176543056964874,
-0.022356105968356133,
-0.06339578330516815,
-0.7417195439338684,
0.24269892275333405,
0.3554455637931824,
-0.16852597892284393,
-0.15688756108283997,
-0.34027689695358276,
0.8686509132385254,
0.7496479153633118,
-0.05516139417886734,
0.007434315979480743,
0.23744836449623108,
-0.2385290563106537,
-0.1313638836145401,
-0.6542996168136597,
-0.7850306034088135,
0.7550542950630188,
0.6682173609733582,
0.8515273928642273,
-0.144296795129776,
0.45689499378204346,
0.4183163046836853,
0.3611316680908203,
-0.7721116542816162,
0.46618396043777466,
0.024451611563563347,
-0.23193956911563873,
-0.18338105082511902,
-0.42908039689064026,
-0.7285957336425781,
0.44963538646698,
-0.11713358014822006,
-0.7082284688949585,
0.04513673484325409,
0.3737979531288147,
0.03615525737404823,
0.3480898141860962,
-1.006581425666809,
1.1240607500076294,
-0.17184428870677948,
-0.16682212054729462,
0.06202196329832077,
-0.5052386522293091,
0.24530458450317383,
0.19020995497703552,
0.2155962437391281,
0.08965421468019485,
0.15878897905349731,
0.49331173300743103,
-0.11490271985530853,
1.072378396987915,
-0.6036929488182068,
-0.31224551796913147,
0.1858191043138504,
-0.041306644678115845,
0.5191942453384399,
0.28752246499061584,
0.3310904800891876,
0.496417373418808,
-0.3028757572174072,
-0.5161154270172119,
-0.8275405168533325,
0.8653199672698975,
-0.7031193375587463,
-0.4584893584251404,
-0.2083476185798645,
-0.4369874596595764,
-0.15986368060112,
0.502357542514801,
0.03661996126174927,
0.8263998627662659,
0.004546581767499447,
0.4088904857635498,
0.41655051708221436,
-0.2974301874637604,
0.13847962021827698,
0.03539193421602249,
-0.6629894971847534,
-0.9404826164245605,
1.168921709060669,
-0.3350634276866913,
0.11958571523427963,
0.4932934045791626,
0.03421879559755325,
-0.21300740540027618,
-0.6371561884880066,
-0.4923236072063446,
0.2498229742050171,
-1.1331640481948853,
-0.11943355947732925,
-0.525992214679718,
0.3242794871330261,
-0.3342456817626953,
-0.4409991502761841,
-0.37559452652931213,
-0.06531088799238205,
-0.3373025953769684,
-0.11193016916513443,
0.01636345684528351,
0.6971796154975891,
0.2577833831310272,
0.7026742100715637,
-0.9495759010314941,
0.36079370975494385,
0.47923222184181213,
0.25942450761795044,
-0.1638016253709793,
-0.4970077574253082,
-0.3773984909057617,
0.23179768025875092,
0.14096736907958984,
-0.5687832832336426,
0.3103710412979126,
0.03528773412108421,
0.5714863538742065,
0.8212125897407532,
-0.5648599863052368,
1.2054085731506348,
-0.6989539861679077,
0.998333215713501,
0.3649359345436096,
-1.1179178953170776,
0.8316643834114075,
-0.7039132714271545,
0.32354670763015747,
0.30541256070137024,
-0.02297166734933853,
-0.7546818256378174,
-0.38582271337509155,
-0.19726291298866272,
-0.8608421683311462,
0.34668096899986267,
0.10641749203205109,
0.49496233463287354,
-0.29066333174705505,
0.23431234061717987,
0.08402399718761444,
0.25120434165000916,
-0.7417476177215576,
-0.1229342371225357,
-0.3581966459751129,
-0.11983320116996765,
-0.17374834418296814,
-0.5007947683334351,
-0.6315864324569702,
-0.1285908818244934,
0.28720274567604065,
-0.5662481188774109,
0.552194356918335,
0.02319302409887314,
-0.2473628669977188,
0.08408461511135101,
0.036657895892858505,
1.1097369194030762,
0.9331769347190857,
-0.12298784404993057,
0.3603192865848541,
-0.005161593202501535,
-0.40131452679634094,
-0.09137830883264542,
-0.12123051285743713,
-0.15587550401687622,
0.1867033690214157,
0.6557206511497498,
1.2768841981887817,
0.06367901712656021,
-0.6508657932281494,
0.5797987580299377,
-0.1856868863105774,
-0.08129603415727615,
-0.020484887063503265,
-0.1571274846792221,
-0.13313861191272736,
0.31945496797561646,
0.44142112135887146,
0.12669353187084198,
-0.06823362410068512,
-0.468589186668396,
0.027280433103442192,
0.46824705600738525,
-0.47258260846138,
-0.400957316160202,
0.8338996171951294,
0.4589235186576843,
0.0037843622267246246,
0.2625451683998108,
0.016642237082123756,
-0.5749585628509521,
0.5472545623779297,
0.8955103158950806,
0.7118057012557983,
0.15154601633548737,
0.4003746211528778,
0.2512942850589752,
0.45839306712150574,
-0.09089931845664978,
0.06349684298038483,
-0.06320717930793762,
-0.5452976822853088,
-0.3156455457210541,
-0.18547633290290833,
-0.38259968161582947,
0.026200849562883377,
-0.6054065823554993,
0.2352483868598938,
-0.5654681324958801,
-0.16362735629081726,
-0.6350321769714355,
-0.5274454951286316,
-0.4928233325481415,
0.35833778977394104,
0.5240628123283386,
0.6745202541351318,
-1.0652114152908325,
0.516595721244812,
1.2088419198989868,
-0.10224266350269318,
-0.3077528476715088,
-0.130567267537117,
-0.21613216400146484,
-0.7520352005958557,
0.7511940002441406,
0.521592378616333,
-0.17491067945957184,
-0.009430180303752422,
-0.8015298843383789,
-0.7430195212364197,
1.3059383630752563,
0.6050103306770325,
-0.2868098318576813,
0.2879471182823181,
-0.0931556448340416,
0.4752363860607147,
-0.4584924578666687,
0.37018731236457825,
0.2672417163848877,
0.42552781105041504,
0.10194197297096252,
-0.7983613014221191,
-0.14017723500728607,
-0.2742273807525635,
0.10525272786617279,
0.24466891586780548,
-0.5672582387924194,
0.7748703956604004,
-0.08812392503023148,
-0.3262248635292053,
-0.06972925364971161,
0.8422273993492126,
0.1800323873758316,
0.6338385939598083,
0.3720182478427887,
0.6742042899131775,
1.1041682958602905,
-0.27882152795791626,
1.0939418077468872,
-0.11443144828081131,
0.3701724112033844,
1.1665782928466797,
-0.23245322704315186,
0.5859599113464355,
0.6582233905792236,
0.24003800749778748,
0.35568639636039734,
0.373738557100296,
0.24210737645626068,
0.6551529765129089,
-0.2898189127445221,
-0.33305585384368896,
-0.339404433965683,
-0.384684294462204,
-0.705766499042511,
0.43487119674682617,
0.3197905719280243,
-0.33492517471313477,
-0.30132055282592773,
0.243615984916687,
-0.013473397120833397,
0.1814645379781723,
-0.49030885100364685,
0.5045593976974487,
-0.2567257881164551,
-0.1763860136270523,
0.5264028906822205,
0.05951421335339546,
0.43667641282081604,
-0.7421972155570984,
-0.3785104751586914,
-0.6028652787208557,
-0.037066441029310226,
-0.13606145977973938,
-0.5659670829772949,
-0.01728898473083973,
0.15295900404453278,
-0.21608954668045044,
-0.2707076370716095,
0.7687747478485107,
-0.5046939253807068,
-0.2953195571899414,
0.12152085453271866,
0.2989712357521057,
0.1584336757659912,
-0.22414831817150116,
-0.525911808013916,
0.16659417748451233,
-0.03662300854921341,
-0.1765286922454834,
0.2694743573665619,
0.7774890661239624,
-0.419138640165329,
0.9817440509796143,
0.9719967842102051,
-0.2008073925971985,
0.05728543549776077,
0.5532273054122925,
1.0325850248336792,
-0.7495757937431335,
-0.5466352701187134,
-0.7423176765441895,
0.6927823424339294,
-0.16825582087039948,
-0.2980690896511078,
0.8812422752380371,
0.3598819375038147,
0.5810070037841797,
-0.4231739342212677,
0.7246333360671997,
-0.03770026937127113,
-0.19979502260684967,
-0.8831230998039246,
0.6628177762031555,
-0.573948323726654,
-0.041129086166620255,
-0.2172713428735733,
-0.9467307925224304,
-0.72844398021698,
0.6712415814399719,
-0.32203465700149536,
-0.10038556903600693,
0.6446646451950073,
0.7614706158638,
-0.12148524075746536,
-0.5925642848014832,
0.7580262422561646,
-0.04131148383021355,
0.5821040272712708,
0.1700669229030609,
1.001870036125183,
-0.27616041898727417,
0.27020522952079773,
0.09541496634483337,
-0.24310441315174103,
-0.0935756117105484,
-1.0158419609069824,
-1.4562898874282837,
-0.4176957607269287,
-0.08179552108049393,
0.022357381880283356,
-0.10612628608942032,
0.8075202107429504,
0.6771963238716125,
-0.8206403851509094,
-0.03577214851975441,
-0.15488092601299286,
0.18098343908786774,
0.006886499002575874,
-0.2429719865322113,
0.18190209567546844,
-0.3252700865268707,
-0.8863874077796936,
0.5709415674209595,
0.5218389630317688,
0.19702477753162384,
-0.12323692440986633,
-0.2024652361869812,
0.06852321326732635,
-0.44798576831817627,
0.6924068331718445,
0.1877385526895523,
-0.8501990437507629,
-0.41574111580848694,
-0.16217733919620514,
-0.1731816679239273,
-0.10049758851528168,
0.7466941475868225,
-0.7846515774726868,
0.6945286393165588,
0.3768015503883362,
0.7725548148155212,
0.08471835404634476,
0.2943795919418335,
0.6657282114028931,
-0.8780640363693237,
0.8026376366615295,
-0.09417996555566788,
0.5787183046340942,
0.48505929112434387,
-0.34021416306495667,
0.5158604383468628,
0.3615249693393707,
-0.492351770401001,
-0.934336245059967,
-0.03719106316566467,
-0.8883368968963623,
0.18347902595996857,
1.206722378730774,
-0.2955344319343567,
-0.14257168769836426,
0.23064930737018585,
-0.8325968384742737,
-0.09114398807287216,
-0.3454933762550354,
0.4107515513896942,
0.659247636795044,
0.668059229850769,
-0.34901073575019836,
-0.6164048910140991,
0.049659062176942825,
0.3523053526878357,
-0.9488850831985474,
-0.039924222975969315,
0.8407414555549622,
-0.08807592839002609,
0.2896558940410614,
0.6285204887390137,
0.08828728646039963,
0.3110140562057495,
0.05457058548927307,
0.3134589195251465,
-0.3286038339138031,
-0.7046959400177002,
-0.6501319408416748,
0.13160426914691925,
-0.009786488488316536,
-0.4481610059738159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12994v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12994v2
|
Rethinking the Evaluation of Dialogue Systems: Effects of User Feedback on Crowdworkers and LLMs
| 2024-04-19T16:45:50 | 2024-04-29T19:00:34 |
Clemencia Siro, Mohammad Aliannejadi, Maarten de Rijke
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
In ad-hoc retrieval, evaluation relies heavily on user actions, including
implicit feedback. In a conversational setting such signals are usually
unavailable due to the nature of the interactions, and, instead, the evaluation
often relies on crowdsourced evaluation labels. The role of user feedback in
annotators' assessment of turns in a conversational perception has been little
studied. We focus on how the evaluation of task-oriented dialogue systems
(TDSs), is affected by considering user feedback, explicit or implicit, as
provided through the follow-up utterance of a turn being evaluated. We explore
and compare two methodologies for assessing TDSs: one includes the user's
follow-up utterance and one without. We use both crowdworkers and large
language models (LLMs) as annotators to assess system responses across four
aspects: relevance, usefulness, interestingness, and explanation quality. Our
findings indicate that there is a distinct difference in ratings assigned by
both annotator groups in the two setups, indicating user feedback does
influence system evaluation. Workers are more susceptible to user feedback on
usefulness and interestingness compared to LLMs on interestingness and
relevance. User feedback leads to a more personalized assessment of usefulness
by workers, aligning closely with the user's explicit feedback. Additionally,
in cases of ambiguous or complex user requests, user feedback improves
agreement among crowdworkers. These findings emphasize the significance of user
feedback in refining system evaluations and suggest the potential for automated
feedback integration in future research. We publicly release the annotated data
to foster research in this area.
|
[
-0.4323956370353699,
-0.325212687253952,
0.6753359436988831,
0.36172935366630554,
-0.2198825478553772,
0.11885116994380951,
-0.23434962332248688,
-0.6681627631187439,
0.24617910385131836,
0.5971418023109436,
-0.5372326970100403,
-0.051071442663669586,
-0.5429688692092896,
0.3527451455593109,
-0.5124549865722656,
1.1206670999526978,
0.13697810471057892,
0.10245360434055328,
-0.23292627930641174,
-0.02355421707034111,
-0.5702464580535889,
-0.756253182888031,
-0.5980357527732849,
-0.43166017532348633,
0.7787876725196838,
0.29772138595581055,
0.9844712018966675,
0.12577730417251587,
0.276364803314209,
0.4730024039745331,
-0.08494161814451218,
-0.02807612158358097,
-0.4938719570636749,
0.35867637395858765,
-0.10119481384754181,
-0.24964551627635956,
-0.0826239287853241,
0.0839996337890625,
0.2938702702522278,
0.8475793600082397,
-0.08071552962064743,
0.21321018040180206,
0.3176470994949341,
0.4962439239025116,
-0.6317182779312134,
0.28909483551979065,
-0.31351086497306824,
0.029481105506420135,
-0.09893933683633804,
-0.21903885900974274,
-0.4160524904727936,
-0.5196239352226257,
0.5195292830467224,
-0.5256094336509705,
0.08587338775396347,
-0.027677105739712715,
0.4053841233253479,
0.14074602723121643,
-0.20333333313465118,
-0.4539807140827179,
-0.8510129451751709,
0.666847288608551,
-0.6253814697265625,
0.224397212266922,
0.2200692743062973,
0.12277163565158844,
-0.25305992364883423,
-0.3370572030544281,
-0.5874943137168884,
-0.4678017199039459,
-0.30163484811782837,
0.24210533499717712,
-0.1422298699617386,
0.26067426800727844,
0.4078150987625122,
0.2359560877084732,
0.03993699327111244,
0.01650194637477398,
-0.4628477692604065,
-0.18652835488319397,
0.9368725419044495,
0.2611789405345917,
0.14391741156578064,
-0.42358914017677307,
-0.4011003375053406,
-0.012139882892370224,
-0.2951747179031372,
0.21283887326717377,
0.4872269034385681,
0.1944880336523056,
0.3558468520641327,
0.6564125418663025,
-0.6251963973045349,
0.7049772143363953,
0.1258791834115982,
0.0433252714574337,
0.2882911264896393,
-0.3002965748310089,
-0.09771962463855743,
-0.31168919801712036,
0.9151775240898132,
0.5664478540420532,
0.3112321197986603,
-0.2934400141239166,
-0.5714188814163208,
-0.07640831917524338,
0.27309757471084595,
-0.46521711349487305,
-0.09801830351352692,
-0.03705700486898422,
-0.4402213990688324,
-0.29948562383651733,
0.35110026597976685,
-0.5124305486679077,
-0.7876924872398376,
-0.6682719588279724,
0.41508564352989197,
0.012683425098657608,
-0.2465297281742096,
-0.2834834158420563,
-0.3430922031402588,
-0.1718301773071289,
0.8852047920227051,
-0.5873942971229553,
0.36369866132736206,
0.8202350735664368,
0.6675110459327698,
-0.22286497056484222,
-0.30620095133781433,
-0.7046064138412476,
-0.21842877566814423,
-0.05135011300444603,
0.8156653642654419,
-0.7666656970977783,
-0.7302727699279785,
0.25620919466018677,
0.09113658219575882,
-0.18366537988185883,
-0.7129163146018982,
0.35519689321517944,
-0.5540048480033875,
0.3112581670284271,
-0.5894151926040649,
-0.1645628660917282,
-0.16048675775527954,
-0.08147425949573517,
-0.577271580696106,
0.9690119624137878,
-0.054233577102422714,
-0.7076837420463562,
0.5355587005615234,
-0.8492624163627625,
-0.3600085973739624,
0.3681023120880127,
-0.014837488532066345,
0.1396523267030716,
0.4084639251232147,
0.013943975791335106,
0.23140601813793182,
0.01593376137316227,
0.14814050495624542,
-0.43929824233055115,
-0.6826717853546143,
0.8132849931716919,
-0.389936238527298,
0.43537601828575134,
0.1614495813846588,
-0.4760638177394867,
0.31599605083465576,
-0.30968037247657776,
0.06072208657860756,
-0.3545213043689728,
-0.4124891757965088,
-0.21552859246730804,
0.05946923419833183,
0.12855851650238037,
0.13461679220199585,
-0.04332707077264786,
-0.5824275612831116,
-0.019830372184515,
-0.2091624140739441,
0.4799184501171112,
0.7847789525985718,
0.12003578990697861,
0.12535730004310608,
-0.30554574728012085,
0.48028695583343506,
-0.20649150013923645,
0.2538587152957916,
-0.32447877526283264,
-0.5623252987861633,
-0.8550882339477539,
-0.02280603162944317,
0.19819337129592896,
0.4167110025882721,
-0.7511888742446899,
-0.010882983915507793,
-0.1818036437034607,
-0.3594568371772766,
-0.625074565410614,
0.19824743270874023,
0.6337776184082031,
0.0361345037817955,
0.09052625298500061,
-0.9124893546104431,
-0.34689122438430786,
-0.7157024145126343,
-0.40892019867897034,
-0.6930580735206604,
-0.3723523020744324,
0.4260323643684387,
0.282366544008255,
-0.0822417289018631,
1.0218125581741333,
-0.19347284734249115,
0.09403096139431,
-0.18591193854808807,
0.4046712815761566,
-0.28955507278442383,
0.11845007538795471,
-0.07042432576417923,
-0.4473421275615692,
-0.01484853308647871,
-0.21048234403133392,
-0.39391666650772095,
-0.49699997901916504,
-0.043052446097135544,
0.13571134209632874,
0.3169271945953369,
0.16391561925411224,
-0.5476465225219727,
0.7079384326934814,
0.283431738615036,
-0.3667188584804535,
0.7266705632209778,
0.1500479131937027,
0.43372631072998047,
-0.24855566024780273,
0.1080254316329956,
-0.18165810406208038,
-0.2443327009677887,
-0.5570544004440308,
-0.35903045535087585,
-0.5072278380393982,
-0.2873784601688385,
-0.21722663938999176,
0.4745250940322876,
-0.4698733687400818,
-0.6553967595100403,
-0.399183988571167,
0.5780462622642517,
0.019999811425805092,
0.5345062613487244,
0.07629577070474625,
0.8149305582046509,
-0.12353692948818207,
-0.45628753304481506,
0.41793811321258545,
0.20434211194515228,
-0.4403504431247711,
0.6613199710845947,
-0.7288681864738464,
0.6605408191680908,
0.1041981503367424,
0.4706345796585083,
-1.3152952194213867,
-0.10917383432388306,
0.3801591992378235,
-0.5478708148002625,
-0.18443770706653595,
-0.10834489017724991,
-0.5552518963813782,
-0.6192600727081299,
-0.3219252824783325,
-0.10438045859336853,
0.14515995979309082,
-0.3449251353740692,
0.21796025335788727,
0.39253613352775574,
-0.4061206579208374,
-0.25180166959762573,
-0.33992430567741394,
0.2735731601715088,
0.005012620240449905,
-0.6781541705131531,
-0.23092009127140045,
0.09550788253545761,
-0.6348586082458496,
-0.29627278447151184,
-0.22268672287464142,
-0.008925490081310272,
0.17789553105831146,
0.6501696705818176,
0.21973520517349243,
0.34295690059661865,
0.19301940500736237,
-0.3058735728263855,
-0.23615948855876923,
0.2927335202693939,
0.04717857763171196,
0.3569856286048889,
-0.1849554032087326,
-0.6812801361083984,
-0.5782175064086914,
0.3577335774898529,
0.48508134484291077,
-0.0149788623675704,
0.23469772934913635,
0.7107510566711426,
0.07856129854917526,
0.4222615957260132,
-1.021578073501587,
-0.3431469798088074,
-0.4555814862251282,
0.275578111410141,
-0.2622150778770447,
-1.0337218046188354,
0.4186001420021057,
-0.06785468012094498,
0.26088792085647583,
0.3853081464767456,
0.6632383465766907,
-0.23983310163021088,
1.0643905401229858,
0.3553287982940674,
0.1645297259092331,
0.7420778870582581,
0.10974793881177902,
0.02544419653713703,
-0.9626360535621643,
-0.4804985225200653,
-0.7241872549057007,
-0.31347957253456116,
-0.3759114146232605,
-0.3393150866031647,
0.12690936028957367,
-0.030223576352000237,
0.11101984232664108,
0.21475942432880402,
-0.2693820595741272,
0.06455174833536148,
0.48095834255218506,
0.14938627183437347,
0.5834489464759827,
-0.24621114134788513,
0.17299222946166992,
0.003605509176850319,
-0.5208652019500732,
-0.7366400957107544,
0.7416609525680542,
0.29917263984680176,
0.5656690001487732,
-0.18184888362884521,
0.621250331401825,
0.6453016996383667,
0.7359024882316589,
-0.8216843605041504,
0.680521547794342,
0.40193819999694824,
-0.4609156847000122,
-0.600560188293457,
-0.2110486626625061,
-0.8429833650588989,
0.5892183780670166,
-0.08025799691677094,
-1.0606188774108887,
0.23534899950027466,
-0.04037371650338173,
-0.3788948357105255,
-0.07652545720338821,
-1.035229206085205,
0.4604542553424835,
-0.07146647572517395,
-0.3412947356700897,
-0.36967912316322327,
-0.5365089178085327,
0.036018695682287216,
0.13611061871051788,
0.35735198855400085,
-0.09852887690067291,
0.12558436393737793,
1.1251051425933838,
-0.8853987455368042,
1.0637474060058594,
-0.5789406299591064,
-0.06125376746058464,
0.4636009633541107,
0.06602305173873901,
0.36867234110832214,
0.10987045615911484,
-0.1851036697626114,
0.17620693147182465,
0.0484052449464798,
-0.09956693649291992,
-0.8636353611946106,
0.6936734914779663,
-0.7984986305236816,
-1.2005869150161743,
-0.17132923007011414,
-0.401580810546875,
-0.3156187832355499,
-0.05724586173892021,
-0.21099843084812164,
0.47434985637664795,
-0.09244037419557571,
-0.07689481228590012,
0.16015766561031342,
0.050959836691617966,
0.4307194948196411,
0.6805277466773987,
-0.36429837346076965,
-0.3631763160228729,
0.43887707591056824,
0.1056610494852066,
0.29225486516952515,
-0.10384577512741089,
-0.0818982794880867,
-0.2543589770793915,
-0.291816771030426,
-0.789151668548584,
0.10354481637477875,
-0.6335099339485168,
-0.039786387234926224,
-0.5167018175125122,
0.21915757656097412,
-0.0625397264957428,
0.07052288949489594,
-0.12686675786972046,
-0.5208256244659424,
-0.21078519523143768,
-0.24216154217720032,
0.29570257663726807,
1.2593744993209839,
-0.015545460395514965,
0.2567143142223358,
-0.5460835695266724,
-0.2620079219341278,
0.49742430448532104,
0.4456890821456909,
0.30538785457611084,
-0.47561514377593994,
-0.2954360842704773,
0.06801590323448181,
-0.3354984223842621,
-0.9798120260238647,
-0.0558297373354435,
-0.30756399035453796,
0.48727497458457947,
0.43696850538253784,
-0.07780394703149796,
0.7219249606132507,
-0.20175841450691223,
0.9418247938156128,
0.2546873390674591,
-1.099761962890625,
0.2699619233608246,
-0.16395549476146698,
0.4441765546798706,
0.74556964635849,
0.0395219549536705,
-0.8639901876449585,
-0.4754405915737152,
-0.3502936363220215,
-0.7472656965255737,
0.9254918694496155,
0.3476048707962036,
0.09689652919769287,
-0.0021660837810486555,
0.25911250710487366,
0.20469467341899872,
0.3732391893863678,
-0.3749794363975525,
0.035827334970235825,
-0.24262581765651703,
0.420670747756958,
0.028138402849435806,
-0.5199543237686157,
-0.27370813488960266,
0.08530200272798538,
0.24502526223659515,
0.08616120368242264,
0.3503742516040802,
0.375046044588089,
-0.11302730441093445,
-0.38645172119140625,
0.6364299654960632,
0.3617860674858093,
0.8390870094299316,
-0.0066903503611683846,
-0.19365474581718445,
0.37687647342681885,
-0.18464766442775726,
-0.07841219007968903,
0.10839404910802841,
-0.07413996011018753,
0.34578937292099,
0.33958858251571655,
0.985499918460846,
0.3569851815700531,
-0.5784204006195068,
0.48029136657714844,
0.022656043991446495,
-0.02358938567340374,
-0.2738945186138153,
0.02950471267104149,
-0.1747138351202011,
0.34133943915367126,
0.7179569005966187,
0.17113631963729858,
0.508080244064331,
-0.6096829771995544,
-0.06852316111326218,
0.47523948550224304,
-0.896050751209259,
-0.6449792981147766,
0.12316131591796875,
0.6365252137184143,
-0.7464548349380493,
0.3325463533401489,
0.07307438552379608,
-0.6573427319526672,
0.2389076054096222,
0.06025708094239235,
1.1056870222091675,
-0.2551845908164978,
0.2826198637485504,
-0.050165340304374695,
0.3073616027832031,
0.17355862259864807,
0.1316390037536621,
-0.47369927167892456,
-0.2588701844215393,
-0.6356089115142822,
-0.4103281497955322,
-0.7813228368759155,
-0.08742038905620575,
-0.823056697845459,
0.02915078029036522,
-0.21516405045986176,
-0.568170428276062,
-0.042939964681863785,
0.07338358461856842,
-0.8284485936164856,
0.08848827332258224,
0.2732170522212982,
0.5083149075508118,
-0.7124847173690796,
0.22584286332130432,
0.7801048159599304,
-0.29667431116104126,
-0.5697252750396729,
0.11867748945951462,
0.0860682874917984,
-0.7188002467155457,
0.7578325867652893,
0.27250242233276367,
-0.360821008682251,
-0.47164759039878845,
-0.3939240276813507,
-0.8180621266365051,
0.9392702579498291,
-0.02950037084519863,
-0.5831689238548279,
0.25608935952186584,
0.06564022600650787,
0.8664644956588745,
-0.2733380198478699,
1.1408929824829102,
0.5797888040542603,
0.6141447424888611,
0.1920730471611023,
-1.5420631170272827,
0.17349068820476532,
-0.29889753460884094,
0.3871576488018036,
0.07075270265340805,
-0.8003863096237183,
0.27801671624183655,
-0.42696335911750793,
-0.4056609570980072,
0.15209242701530457,
0.5683459043502808,
0.16902008652687073,
0.5334982872009277,
0.9199660420417786,
0.14217546582221985,
0.5380488634109497,
-0.23692308366298676,
1.1691465377807617,
0.13494326174259186,
0.11606653779745102,
0.8184853196144104,
-0.30304428935050964,
0.8114160299301147,
0.7211141586303711,
-0.4111621379852295,
0.6908352971076965,
0.3846819996833801,
0.30454352498054504,
0.198917955160141,
0.6778203248977661,
-0.07756346464157104,
-0.2560279369354248,
-0.40503185987472534,
-0.26165762543678284,
0.3479664921760559,
0.262387752532959,
-0.25035977363586426,
0.01496911607682705,
0.05115917697548866,
0.11882621794939041,
-0.25700464844703674,
-0.18707293272018433,
1.1168231964111328,
0.018020901829004288,
-0.9730123281478882,
0.30578383803367615,
-0.16502590477466583,
0.4110020101070404,
-0.13987712562084198,
-0.031913772225379944,
-0.26525965332984924,
-0.18295346200466156,
-0.6095194816589355,
-0.7969223856925964,
0.23866206407546997,
0.15777987241744995,
-0.12238497287034988,
-0.30838942527770996,
0.5908997654914856,
-0.02527727745473385,
-0.16734465956687927,
0.3315550982952118,
0.46297746896743774,
0.2864636480808258,
-0.08090714365243912,
-0.5345020890235901,
0.47608745098114014,
0.18685919046401978,
-0.6096154451370239,
0.10264664888381958,
0.4105096161365509,
-0.20520198345184326,
0.7300410866737366,
0.7491543292999268,
-0.22066546976566315,
-0.19590160250663757,
0.4687805473804474,
1.1214518547058105,
-0.5957310199737549,
-0.18778523802757263,
-0.5271092057228088,
0.4639957845211029,
-0.0992191955447197,
-0.28341397643089294,
0.7899028658866882,
0.31120532751083374,
0.8629246354103088,
0.05345755070447922,
0.9940225481987,
-0.000937709934078157,
0.7040987014770508,
-0.15212124586105347,
0.24809546768665314,
-0.13804206252098083,
0.45509541034698486,
-0.6464474201202393,
-0.898888111114502,
0.2448110431432724,
0.18052370846271515,
-0.8472801446914673,
0.2903165817260742,
0.4591273069381714,
0.4526559114456177,
0.35683780908584595,
0.4542541801929474,
0.11487885564565659,
0.19017015397548676,
0.2400829792022705,
0.05893713980913162,
1.4325777292251587,
-0.13055796921253204,
0.780556321144104,
0.023062320426106453,
-0.37310636043548584,
-0.49857762455940247,
-0.3433627188205719,
-0.8386688232421875,
-0.5110145807266235,
-0.32299938797950745,
-0.263298898935318,
0.29500719904899597,
0.6509196758270264,
0.5515344738960266,
-0.8312975764274597,
-0.5549952983856201,
0.47023433446884155,
0.04689718782901764,
-0.0397656187415123,
-0.3220333158969879,
-0.0037470085080713034,
-0.3473915755748749,
-0.7459904551506042,
0.2943035066127777,
0.47054964303970337,
-0.40694236755371094,
-0.5910967588424683,
-0.05121530592441559,
0.23441407084465027,
-0.033051181584596634,
0.6760959625244141,
0.20269109308719635,
-1.1869350671768188,
-0.5581087470054626,
0.08895052969455719,
-0.0023852300364524126,
-0.19040359556674957,
0.9409119486808777,
-0.9683086276054382,
0.6667234301567078,
0.44838279485702515,
0.12988291680812836,
0.59058678150177,
0.37907326221466064,
0.8424355983734131,
-0.15258537232875824,
-0.08705451339483261,
0.1158212199807167,
0.20549172163009644,
0.5926940441131592,
-0.17222948372364044,
0.3863085210323334,
0.27911388874053955,
-0.5870668292045593,
-0.5745333433151245,
0.07005040347576141,
-0.8403353691101074,
0.2286132127046585,
1.3329259157180786,
-0.38252174854278564,
0.11788356304168701,
-0.44892847537994385,
-0.4932332932949066,
0.0166372861713171,
-0.9003727436065674,
0.9800483584403992,
0.8444409966468811,
-0.2343643307685852,
0.08045341819524765,
-0.3351728618144989,
0.3406408131122589,
0.606144905090332,
-0.4446150064468384,
0.07779156416654587,
0.6898820996284485,
0.02976018749177456,
0.4882742762565613,
0.7706189751625061,
-0.00320095825009048,
0.1540311723947525,
-0.37803366780281067,
-0.09668463468551636,
-0.09086181223392487,
-0.11382033675909042,
-0.3808058500289917,
0.12885139882564545,
0.23447585105895996,
-0.0680495873093605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12957v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12957v1
|
Towards Reliable Latent Knowledge Estimation in LLMs: In-Context Learning vs. Prompting Based Factual Knowledge Extraction
| 2024-04-19T15:40:39 | 2024-04-19T15:40:39 |
Qinyuan Wu, Mohammad Aflah Khan, Soumi Das, Vedant Nanda, Bishwamittra Ghosh, Camila Kolling, Till Speicher, Laurent Bindschaedler, Krishna P. Gummadi, Evimaria Terzi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We propose an approach for estimating the latent knowledge embedded inside
large language models (LLMs). We leverage the in-context learning (ICL)
abilities of LLMs to estimate the extent to which an LLM knows the facts stored
in a knowledge base. Our knowledge estimator avoids reliability concerns with
previous prompting-based methods, is both conceptually simpler and easier to
apply, and we demonstrate that it can surface more of the latent knowledge
embedded in LLMs. We also investigate how different design choices affect the
performance of ICL-based knowledge estimation. Using the proposed estimator, we
perform a large-scale evaluation of the factual knowledge of a variety of open
source LLMs, like OPT, Pythia, Llama(2), Mistral, Gemma, etc. over a large set
of relations and facts from the Wikidata knowledge base. We observe differences
in the factual knowledge between different model families and models of
different sizes, that some relations are consistently better known than others
but that models differ in the precise facts they know, and differences in the
knowledge of base models and their finetuned counterparts.
|
[
-0.09328076988458633,
-0.8197024464607239,
0.996970534324646,
0.04838360846042633,
-0.1774234026670456,
0.15340125560760498,
-0.4030846655368805,
-0.41258320212364197,
-0.2731834650039673,
0.2031104564666748,
-0.24716949462890625,
-0.3508435785770416,
-0.44919660687446594,
-0.16583892703056335,
-0.1571343094110489,
0.7092882394790649,
0.06881596148014069,
0.26971182227134705,
-0.7725200653076172,
0.153459370136261,
-0.3719855844974518,
-0.3022611737251282,
-0.36567240953445435,
-0.39009591937065125,
0.5202935934066772,
0.591274619102478,
0.414608359336853,
0.17603442072868347,
0.12351281940937042,
0.1598854660987854,
-0.46939828991889954,
0.4555194079875946,
-0.5219099521636963,
0.20767663419246674,
-0.30429524183273315,
-0.6111534833908081,
-0.249525249004364,
0.017913250252604485,
0.5833286643028259,
0.7798576354980469,
-0.0508369579911232,
0.18191809952259064,
0.2103661596775055,
0.40102964639663696,
-0.8222885727882385,
0.26698094606399536,
-0.8772901892662048,
0.038107190281152725,
-0.044717829674482346,
-0.11580920219421387,
-0.5401527881622314,
-0.4069351255893707,
0.4243201017379761,
-0.43364179134368896,
-0.21505899727344513,
0.07142402231693268,
0.6465719938278198,
0.3957703709602356,
-0.4509797990322113,
-0.5382291674613953,
-0.6875872015953064,
0.9582782983779907,
-0.8768433332443237,
0.7632200121879578,
0.5515275597572327,
0.1744377315044403,
-0.31138986349105835,
-0.7195417881011963,
-0.6773276329040527,
-0.5937315225601196,
-0.1664179265499115,
0.08372101932764053,
0.026041513308882713,
-0.2450404167175293,
0.36185869574546814,
0.35357940196990967,
-0.3184453547000885,
0.24570879340171814,
0.0035006776452064514,
-0.1884068101644516,
0.285948783159256,
-0.015892140567302704,
0.20119304955005646,
-0.2782648503780365,
-0.4162023663520813,
0.43489739298820496,
-1.2242825031280518,
0.04151550307869911,
0.17500941455364227,
-0.02016001008450985,
-0.19617362320423126,
0.5805487036705017,
0.03685830160975456,
0.7410183548927307,
0.25287193059921265,
-0.7563753128051758,
0.041978903114795685,
-0.2943613827228546,
-0.013384384103119373,
-0.06049986556172371,
0.7677375078201294,
0.11234623938798904,
0.12905149161815643,
-0.4794556200504303,
-0.32748284935951233,
-0.3473818004131317,
-0.10813978314399719,
-0.5131866335868835,
-0.15116818249225616,
0.04692433774471283,
-0.3186110258102417,
-0.10065808147192001,
0.025915101170539856,
-0.6997647285461426,
-0.38674288988113403,
-0.38556548953056335,
0.44909346103668213,
-0.3976241946220398,
-0.2763253152370453,
-0.5162758231163025,
0.05432550609111786,
0.4103335738182068,
0.43918704986572266,
-0.8826842308044434,
-0.013221030123531818,
0.568336009979248,
0.8895885944366455,
-0.30017295479774475,
0.046664897352457047,
-0.49948471784591675,
0.23893535137176514,
-0.3629923164844513,
0.7686216235160828,
-0.2535589337348938,
-0.2680151164531708,
-0.14362816512584686,
-0.12431028485298157,
0.041194263845682144,
-0.5461564660072327,
0.24486690759658813,
-1.0335201025009155,
0.2761978507041931,
-0.4825570285320282,
-0.9562853574752808,
-0.06611834466457367,
0.42437446117401123,
-0.6647545099258423,
1.0594207048416138,
0.09929796308279037,
-0.957960307598114,
0.6030920743942261,
-0.4183182120323181,
-0.1932007074356079,
0.08923032879829407,
-0.2480354756116867,
-0.22722609341144562,
0.11717580258846283,
0.22432225942611694,
0.6556940078735352,
-0.33297452330589294,
0.45070016384124756,
-0.4596801996231079,
-0.20207136869430542,
0.5830745697021484,
-0.7563466429710388,
0.9262644052505493,
0.2765405774116516,
-0.2985156178474426,
-0.1632450819015503,
-0.6198992133140564,
-0.2543279528617859,
-0.05953137204051018,
-0.6285924911499023,
-0.4182497560977936,
0.32958167791366577,
-0.35129809379577637,
0.15522906184196472,
0.5602716207504272,
-0.5899322032928467,
0.09029994904994965,
-0.5493407249450684,
-0.012510106898844242,
0.7425893545150757,
0.30008161067962646,
0.4851587414741516,
-0.1659511923789978,
0.32734259963035583,
-0.0826166421175003,
0.0951090008020401,
0.11445114761590958,
-0.32264965772628784,
-0.5884474515914917,
-0.199376180768013,
0.4251011610031128,
0.44789788126945496,
-0.7969415187835693,
0.38086050748825073,
-0.2767164409160614,
-0.46131032705307007,
0.10465911030769348,
0.2767990827560425,
0.4289916753768921,
0.8549238443374634,
0.2018776386976242,
0.1630174219608307,
-0.4068956971168518,
-0.381243497133255,
-0.05964506044983864,
-0.5080651044845581,
0.012778358533978462,
0.33470869064331055,
0.47025129199028015,
0.016438134014606476,
1.2271738052368164,
-0.4665523171424866,
0.2676806151866913,
-0.172737255692482,
-0.22916758060455322,
0.1577686071395874,
0.20788343250751495,
0.5351231098175049,
-0.8027815222740173,
-0.6937412023544312,
0.14445284008979797,
-1.1441065073013306,
-0.08218619227409363,
0.2108488827943802,
0.17808163166046143,
0.3729367256164551,
0.7272776365280151,
-0.6224773526191711,
0.20080254971981049,
0.56647127866745,
-0.18644875288009644,
0.7498030066490173,
-0.03451739251613617,
-0.12313108146190643,
-1.2023347616195679,
0.05903429538011551,
-0.08270435035228729,
-0.2929784059524536,
-0.472910076379776,
-0.10081884264945984,
0.21345487236976624,
0.3862544000148773,
-0.5507524013519287,
0.9078595042228699,
-0.5727846622467041,
-0.1920151710510254,
-0.13533876836299896,
0.28163471817970276,
-0.16497594118118286,
0.25695809721946716,
0.03140506520867348,
1.1171516180038452,
0.34610193967819214,
-0.741369366645813,
0.2848997116088867,
0.14900560677051544,
-0.7924906611442566,
0.45858490467071533,
-0.4501318633556366,
0.12885800004005432,
0.11996722966432571,
0.14922897517681122,
-0.9208834767341614,
-0.23454967141151428,
0.3423641324043274,
-0.5284712314605713,
0.4015193581581116,
-0.46084651350975037,
-0.5896762609481812,
-0.020651839673519135,
0.08681188523769379,
0.045339830219745636,
0.42443931102752686,
-0.9010990858078003,
0.4909091591835022,
0.5533458590507507,
-0.2513747811317444,
-0.7857757210731506,
-0.3431227505207062,
0.04663892462849617,
-0.3954322934150696,
-0.502932608127594,
0.18236160278320312,
-0.24971042573451996,
-0.6978631615638733,
0.16992244124412537,
-0.14785346388816833,
-0.30953171849250793,
0.20704102516174316,
0.1686512976884842,
0.3269007205963135,
-0.41268065571784973,
0.505624532699585,
0.17050154507160187,
0.03785278648138046,
0.19446206092834473,
-0.4154382050037384,
0.26911506056785583,
0.015811119228601456,
-0.5396312475204468,
-0.11151004582643509,
-0.05598310008645058,
0.4905347526073456,
-0.0590042881667614,
1.0320383310317993,
0.37316757440567017,
-0.49188533425331116,
-0.1923895925283432,
-0.7676296234130859,
-0.0383697971701622,
-0.3921104073524475,
0.14431920647621155,
-0.281355082988739,
-0.8521032333374023,
0.6307076811790466,
-0.16657094657421112,
0.03429032117128372,
0.4949820935726166,
0.5700545907020569,
-0.29762059450149536,
0.6722596287727356,
0.7163721323013306,
-0.07292795926332474,
0.5908992886543274,
-0.1684606820344925,
-0.12750045955181122,
-0.8740985989570618,
-0.36658230423927307,
-0.359345406293869,
0.30851221084594727,
-0.18813036382198334,
-0.3100510835647583,
0.5807220935821533,
0.23535333573818207,
-0.09759698063135147,
-0.1333036720752716,
0.22898919880390167,
0.4407217800617218,
0.3687990605831146,
0.2226831316947937,
0.46817857027053833,
0.07235865294933319,
-0.1967839151620865,
-0.03501594439148903,
-0.8597805500030518,
-0.6710806488990784,
1.2437007427215576,
0.26403748989105225,
0.7706651091575623,
0.38929954171180725,
0.3589118421077728,
0.1445576697587967,
0.5712044835090637,
-0.9818273186683655,
0.2262313961982727,
0.1772986352443695,
-0.5933383107185364,
-0.29070141911506653,
-0.5598422884941101,
-0.5558070540428162,
-0.014803200028836727,
-0.27096158266067505,
-0.7651442885398865,
0.09131280332803726,
0.16285832226276398,
-0.3195621371269226,
0.4432404041290283,
-0.6018013954162598,
0.44037988781929016,
-0.41462141275405884,
-0.3877623975276947,
-0.1575024127960205,
-0.48462745547294617,
0.374226838350296,
-0.28123241662979126,
0.10063431411981583,
0.049746714532375336,
-0.03741864487528801,
0.8109447956085205,
-0.5544539093971252,
0.9878985285758972,
-0.4050326645374298,
-0.24687741696834564,
0.4178467392921448,
-0.1930149793624878,
0.5945553183555603,
0.18088674545288086,
-0.22331427037715912,
0.13876211643218994,
-0.0005021562683396041,
-0.17224885523319244,
-0.7783069014549255,
0.673982560634613,
-0.7566778659820557,
-0.5829027891159058,
-0.18734002113342285,
-0.38359320163726807,
-0.5896689891815186,
0.03370174765586853,
0.398688942193985,
0.5071850419044495,
-0.33312633633613586,
0.385705828666687,
1.072165608406067,
-0.29622507095336914,
0.45021700859069824,
0.6392350196838379,
0.07649590075016022,
-0.33044931292533875,
0.76030433177948,
0.4037492871284485,
0.36182862520217896,
0.7068700194358826,
0.4172731339931488,
-0.5066846609115601,
-0.6252143383026123,
-0.4398469924926758,
0.3174324631690979,
-0.9941155910491943,
-0.22998851537704468,
-0.6472338438034058,
-0.25044235587120056,
-0.18532103300094604,
0.07851136475801468,
-0.14996832609176636,
-0.1717437356710434,
-0.501514196395874,
-0.15882672369480133,
0.45962288975715637,
0.941521167755127,
0.0904105082154274,
0.29365918040275574,
-0.6829989552497864,
-0.16578201949596405,
0.4480760097503662,
0.26411139965057373,
0.18993699550628662,
-0.764933705329895,
-0.5494375228881836,
-0.08793322741985321,
0.004862373229116201,
-1.0041202306747437,
0.09155665338039398,
-0.057944297790527344,
1.0912208557128906,
0.5044530630111694,
0.019835524260997772,
0.5531511902809143,
-0.3197782337665558,
0.8893539905548096,
0.06363293528556824,
-0.7024416923522949,
0.35091474652290344,
-0.2248201221227646,
0.14290153980255127,
0.49964043498039246,
0.4650309979915619,
-0.363505482673645,
-0.15765710175037384,
-0.6147921085357666,
-0.5651943683624268,
0.43738532066345215,
-0.20990769565105438,
0.007567800115793943,
-0.025934843346476555,
0.5134692192077637,
0.22990430891513824,
0.23888413608074188,
-0.7437329888343811,
-0.22048671543598175,
0.15382274985313416,
-0.32732221484184265,
0.1577133685350418,
-0.6468626856803894,
0.07250791788101196,
-0.11125075072050095,
0.8955935835838318,
-0.2927432060241699,
0.11082754284143448,
0.017627660185098648,
-0.6712368130683899,
-0.07590626925230026,
0.12923762202262878,
0.40156134963035583,
1.2377029657363892,
-0.18357223272323608,
0.15992778539657593,
0.6189420819282532,
-0.3374139368534088,
-0.07567226886749268,
-0.039846569299697876,
-0.3306458592414856,
-0.005136064253747463,
0.6124101281166077,
0.7037457823753357,
0.545215368270874,
-0.6204387545585632,
0.6607126593589783,
-0.018265273422002792,
0.13504022359848022,
-0.6468570232391357,
-0.07681248337030411,
0.19573579728603363,
0.3934664726257324,
0.4113427400588989,
-0.21131910383701324,
-0.1346256285905838,
-0.2747367322444916,
0.27490127086639404,
0.5553118586540222,
-0.558504045009613,
-0.3359239995479584,
0.3167661726474762,
0.03952834755182266,
0.01959230937063694,
0.4011220633983612,
-0.11287133395671844,
-0.37338221073150635,
0.4091886281967163,
0.569767415523529,
0.530543327331543,
-0.23569409549236298,
0.009506836533546448,
0.3600708246231079,
0.06166532263159752,
-0.002114283386617899,
-0.05490616708993912,
-0.27510878443717957,
-0.9370943307876587,
-0.7226296067237854,
-0.5745604634284973,
-0.5923915505409241,
0.32384926080703735,
-0.24319249391555786,
0.12714801728725433,
-0.3242223262786865,
0.06814894825220108,
-0.3017338514328003,
0.292612761259079,
-0.5548310875892639,
0.08576683700084686,
0.08744898438453674,
1.0216856002807617,
-0.6719545125961304,
0.8755627274513245,
0.5854231119155884,
-0.4324638843536377,
-1.0365036725997925,
0.34206148982048035,
0.03856096789240837,
-0.5690887570381165,
0.8027035593986511,
-0.22223293781280518,
-0.1884046494960785,
-0.059006378054618835,
-0.8203930258750916,
-1.118408441543579,
1.311192274093628,
0.6034931540489197,
-0.38193216919898987,
0.0008697285084053874,
-0.43319451808929443,
0.2340090125799179,
-0.3013383448123932,
0.31715497374534607,
0.274982750415802,
0.4091973304748535,
0.24993367493152618,
-0.8325710296630859,
-0.12118557840585709,
0.05574950948357582,
-0.3686314821243286,
-0.11154253780841827,
-0.38307392597198486,
0.6184616684913635,
-0.2189268171787262,
-0.25403475761413574,
0.05518301576375961,
0.9610629081726074,
0.5328200459480286,
0.3406953811645508,
0.6089863777160645,
0.10060537606477737,
1.1491806507110596,
0.13653047382831573,
0.9689784646034241,
-0.3554380238056183,
0.319889098405838,
1.1535896062850952,
-0.017688555642962456,
0.8002445101737976,
0.6197717785835266,
-0.18969827890396118,
0.5853152871131897,
0.7524447441101074,
0.3286930024623871,
0.36796170473098755,
-0.2863176465034485,
-0.4377906024456024,
-0.19340826570987701,
-0.09054634720087051,
-0.2632184624671936,
0.4037238359451294,
0.6271908283233643,
-0.3228220045566559,
-0.05056741461157799,
-0.31500372290611267,
0.3956317901611328,
-0.2209257185459137,
-0.20444519817829132,
1.0351481437683105,
0.2901194393634796,
-0.7748018503189087,
0.2662118971347809,
-0.17022065818309784,
0.5067207217216492,
-0.6072646975517273,
-0.10244571417570114,
-0.22921079397201538,
-0.06754898279905319,
-0.22096627950668335,
-0.822723388671875,
0.11939596384763718,
0.10127633810043335,
-0.3432706594467163,
0.1385888308286667,
0.9700663685798645,
-0.498351126909256,
-0.3284973204135895,
0.21535924077033997,
0.9801743030548096,
0.08436081558465958,
-0.019604507833719254,
-0.43322065472602844,
-0.1745976358652115,
-0.10220727324485779,
-0.4206813871860504,
0.2546229362487793,
0.5042781233787537,
-0.16862733662128448,
0.6131354570388794,
0.6781135201454163,
0.18516606092453003,
-0.02217651717364788,
-0.1899755895137787,
0.8440082669258118,
-0.2858041822910309,
-0.3553253710269928,
-0.8881319761276245,
0.5488697290420532,
-0.18230557441711426,
-0.0802077129483223,
0.9565416574478149,
0.34463170170783997,
0.6503469347953796,
0.03267347812652588,
0.922860324382782,
-0.16926166415214539,
0.4594934284687042,
-0.9109923839569092,
0.7949616312980652,
-0.4816543757915497,
0.4653886556625366,
-0.23875045776367188,
-1.0835837125778198,
-0.10398612916469574,
0.541602373123169,
-0.6415960192680359,
-0.02351163513958454,
0.4536726474761963,
0.7657638192176819,
-0.2535368502140045,
-0.06269949674606323,
0.4484961926937103,
0.31280773878097534,
0.28807416558265686,
0.09103136509656906,
1.1760588884353638,
0.04297281429171562,
0.26020070910453796,
-0.1355641484260559,
-0.3489265739917755,
-0.17851024866104126,
-1.0265061855316162,
-0.7882812023162842,
-0.6849735975265503,
-0.006837472785264254,
-0.17212055623531342,
-0.0025123492814600468,
1.0589439868927002,
0.7421050071716309,
-0.7241723537445068,
-0.2089179903268814,
0.21550911664962769,
0.6525980830192566,
0.014815328642725945,
-0.2450796663761139,
0.5094590783119202,
-0.3832058906555176,
-0.4689490795135498,
0.7156310677528381,
0.149905726313591,
-0.1337435245513916,
-0.4425104260444641,
-0.2878684401512146,
-0.29807403683662415,
-0.11236562579870224,
0.8050006628036499,
0.26602163910865784,
-0.7368258833885193,
-0.49519771337509155,
-0.08899989724159241,
-0.08869382739067078,
-0.037679657340049744,
0.5284584164619446,
-0.8892527222633362,
0.33999407291412354,
0.4842167794704437,
0.5935681462287903,
0.38566699624061584,
-0.10140782594680786,
0.5289474129676819,
-0.8170748949050903,
-0.060786835849285126,
0.008453099057078362,
0.5097506046295166,
0.6026341319084167,
-0.47272196412086487,
0.4540994167327881,
0.3446164131164551,
-0.5400089025497437,
-0.6727842092514038,
0.2768665850162506,
-0.6472421884536743,
-0.27505138516426086,
1.3969899415969849,
-0.45485439896583557,
-0.23239701986312866,
-0.35027727484703064,
0.13841558992862701,
0.264867901802063,
-0.27655288577079773,
0.5211823582649231,
0.6149455308914185,
-0.027108147740364075,
-0.16753362119197845,
-0.6846706867218018,
0.5785988569259644,
-0.008282876573503017,
-0.7442241311073303,
-0.12846356630325317,
0.593399167060852,
0.6812969446182251,
0.16063709557056427,
0.5437413454055786,
-0.11353529989719391,
0.09291230887174606,
-0.1920422613620758,
-0.17307275533676147,
0.0630461648106575,
-0.47157981991767883,
-0.22737491130828857,
0.17614859342575073,
0.494981586933136,
0.3110482096672058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12938v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12938v2
|
MAiDE-up: Multilingual Deception Detection of GPT-generated Hotel Reviews
| 2024-04-19T15:08:06 | 2024-06-19T03:34:42 |
Oana Ignat, Xiaomeng Xu, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Deceptive reviews are becoming increasingly common, especially given the
increase in performance and the prevalence of LLMs. While work to date has
addressed the development of models to differentiate between truthful and
deceptive human reviews, much less is known about the distinction between real
reviews and AI-authored fake reviews. Moreover, most of the research so far has
focused primarily on English, with very little work dedicated to other
languages. In this paper, we compile and make publicly available the MAiDE-up
dataset, consisting of 10,000 real and 10,000 AI-generated fake hotel reviews,
balanced across ten languages. Using this dataset, we conduct extensive
linguistic analyses to (1) compare the AI fake hotel reviews to real hotel
reviews, and (2) identify the factors that influence the deception detection
model performance. We explore the effectiveness of several models for deception
detection in hotel reviews across three main dimensions: sentiment, location,
and language. We find that these dimensions influence how well we can detect
AI-generated fake reviews.
|
[
-0.3425307273864746,
-0.5963213443756104,
0.7630202174186707,
0.3747437596321106,
-0.29862838983535767,
0.10639388114213943,
0.18621014058589935,
-0.6966383457183838,
0.33870378136634827,
0.6654256582260132,
-0.4363134801387787,
-0.4239398241043091,
-0.5160408020019531,
0.5306245684623718,
-0.1265355497598648,
0.9246859550476074,
-0.09453994780778885,
0.7188781499862671,
-0.19405315816402435,
0.006797201465815306,
-0.38795870542526245,
-0.7226845026016235,
-0.6053153872489929,
-0.36296042799949646,
0.14994075894355774,
-0.08114124089479446,
0.6994338035583496,
-0.14125172793865204,
0.2902020812034607,
0.20871712267398834,
0.4498961865901947,
0.6780680418014526,
-0.1417299509048462,
-0.11853618174791336,
0.14806824922561646,
-0.3817006051540375,
-0.19914279878139496,
0.2416342943906784,
0.4696153700351715,
-0.0031289735343307257,
-0.19159775972366333,
0.37015196681022644,
-0.2011118084192276,
0.7840000987052917,
-0.4870530664920807,
0.3782082200050354,
-0.5431010127067566,
-0.11237426847219467,
0.07713177055120468,
0.2709696292877197,
-0.42693501710891724,
-0.4417652189731598,
-0.2574395537376404,
-0.33444058895111084,
0.38310378789901733,
-0.057077355682849884,
1.0810410976409912,
0.21310082077980042,
-0.5436990261077881,
-0.43413153290748596,
-0.9398464560508728,
0.5733774900436401,
-0.6289973258972168,
0.4727379381656647,
0.5851892828941345,
0.38960185647010803,
0.0914963111281395,
-0.17274081707000732,
-0.930166482925415,
-0.6900909543037415,
-0.3035432696342468,
0.2482009381055832,
-0.1466444581747055,
-0.320487916469574,
0.09906939417123795,
0.2587805390357971,
-0.4537683427333832,
-0.2235511839389801,
-0.0031498658936470747,
-0.3801709711551666,
0.7617970108985901,
-0.06045902147889137,
0.6561309695243835,
-0.09008672833442688,
-0.2628893256187439,
0.01059644017368555,
-0.7560853958129883,
-0.2294686883687973,
0.6577709317207336,
-0.06862407922744751,
-0.036675840616226196,
0.20426608622074127,
0.0039317673072218895,
0.45783722400665283,
-0.13148604333400726,
-0.09845828264951706,
0.10834304243326187,
-0.5223085284233093,
-0.3938603103160858,
0.196428120136261,
0.7806851267814636,
0.6004007458686829,
0.5213857889175415,
-0.030319005250930786,
-0.5595303177833557,
0.5434627532958984,
0.4360162317752838,
-0.7191561460494995,
-0.1637651026248932,
0.10597823560237885,
-0.5662024021148682,
-0.7448862791061401,
0.35987725853919983,
-0.4481661915779114,
-0.652583122253418,
-0.3326275050640106,
0.2842795252799988,
-0.137606680393219,
-0.42987966537475586,
0.1316436529159546,
-0.1955060213804245,
0.2538556754589081,
0.31276601552963257,
-0.1329365074634552,
0.28728896379470825,
0.4120040237903595,
0.6179850101470947,
-0.18015964329242706,
-0.3824458718299866,
-0.4515288174152374,
-0.1612323522567749,
-0.4047538936138153,
0.713027834892273,
-0.4137779176235199,
-0.44171175360679626,
0.15865077078342438,
0.011529942974448204,
-0.20311826467514038,
-0.5918647050857544,
0.8574100136756897,
-0.6334298253059387,
0.6335009932518005,
-0.3412560224533081,
-0.20755237340927124,
-0.392778217792511,
0.4754749536514282,
-0.8393418788909912,
0.9874672293663025,
0.04727095738053322,
-0.6046447157859802,
0.34458744525909424,
-0.6419641971588135,
-0.43730801343917847,
-0.139876127243042,
-0.21331961452960968,
-0.7687578797340393,
0.4955836534500122,
0.8327181935310364,
0.30740562081336975,
-0.03619575873017311,
0.2751108407974243,
0.13053736090660095,
-0.41810843348503113,
0.6389760375022888,
-0.8503003120422363,
0.9321930408477783,
0.32957085967063904,
-0.4264717400074005,
-0.11032912135124207,
-0.6886470317840576,
-0.36343541741371155,
0.40781089663505554,
-0.18860939145088196,
-0.2610088884830475,
-0.16623088717460632,
-0.03453516215085983,
0.135365292429924,
0.08211521059274673,
-0.5852567553520203,
0.10197803378105164,
-0.3157900273799896,
0.12406470626592636,
0.21232569217681885,
0.3737374246120453,
0.23563742637634277,
-0.559054970741272,
0.8067675828933716,
0.15454110503196716,
0.2598502039909363,
-0.09929703921079636,
-0.4615267217159271,
-0.6391270756721497,
-0.4048410952091217,
0.2849344313144684,
0.5719349980354309,
-0.92989182472229,
0.19662661850452423,
-0.2913476824760437,
-0.35980796813964844,
-0.8756850361824036,
-0.2670176923274994,
0.6510390639305115,
0.2579023838043213,
0.2862801253795624,
0.1818663328886032,
-0.1479986160993576,
-0.8839357495307922,
-0.594832718372345,
-0.3632022440433502,
-0.185201957821846,
-0.02091391384601593,
0.4975399971008301,
-0.3026007413864136,
0.4004315435886383,
-0.29335275292396545,
-0.5953702926635742,
-0.057333823293447495,
-0.12851351499557495,
0.07889010012149811,
0.06675200909376144,
0.8656286597251892,
-0.8181192874908447,
-0.6477577090263367,
-0.23540624976158142,
-0.5967523455619812,
-0.055502429604530334,
-0.3707948327064514,
0.16582821309566498,
0.5551100969314575,
0.10192181915044785,
-0.5907338261604309,
0.37556397914886475,
0.5891522765159607,
-0.13815882802009583,
1.035252571105957,
-0.12963250279426575,
0.586207389831543,
-1.0721031427383423,
-0.3789288401603699,
0.01093184482306242,
-0.2287357598543167,
-0.5627852082252502,
0.2045024335384369,
0.018667370080947876,
-0.15899576246738434,
-0.31245577335357666,
0.5670570731163025,
-0.659792959690094,
0.2522337734699249,
-0.19930262863636017,
-0.12026114761829376,
0.23414964973926544,
0.43776774406433105,
0.11305895447731018,
0.8402572274208069,
0.5660107135772705,
-0.4103905260562897,
0.3211214542388916,
0.17858310043811798,
-0.6705735325813293,
0.5880064964294434,
-0.4462457001209259,
0.25092631578445435,
0.0696006789803505,
0.38474154472351074,
-1.2694203853607178,
-0.38560864329338074,
0.35005900263786316,
-0.7690781950950623,
0.22576728463172913,
-0.30802851915359497,
-0.6947519779205322,
-0.31481480598449707,
-0.4776450991630554,
0.07362763583660126,
0.3585498034954071,
-0.8138846755027771,
1.0668565034866333,
0.39898937940597534,
0.13103367388248444,
-0.6263558864593506,
-0.6774970293045044,
0.34898558259010315,
-0.11339981108903885,
-0.5245406627655029,
-0.014182944782078266,
0.35417744517326355,
-0.6335957646369934,
-0.15999029576778412,
-0.3311835825443268,
0.051071301102638245,
-0.18420681357383728,
0.19230398535728455,
0.3100143373012543,
0.05620165541768074,
-0.10226128995418549,
-0.20710860192775726,
0.08579524606466293,
0.3565855026245117,
-0.23320555686950684,
0.5573230981826782,
-0.3478882908821106,
-0.43244829773902893,
-0.6655779480934143,
0.25411832332611084,
0.8197426199913025,
-0.21349726617336273,
0.6952915191650391,
0.8281521797180176,
-0.30318593978881836,
-0.3077141344547272,
-0.767275869846344,
-0.24828223884105682,
-0.38019707798957825,
0.1310141533613205,
-0.6365412473678589,
-0.4890761077404022,
0.7106013894081116,
0.28963181376457214,
-0.02368791773915291,
0.30647456645965576,
0.6760888695716858,
-0.21987497806549072,
1.4129348993301392,
0.5301497578620911,
-0.2804994285106659,
0.18226991593837738,
-0.035873375833034515,
0.549992561340332,
-0.4243646264076233,
-0.28615817427635193,
-0.6524196267127991,
-0.0274303387850523,
-0.9657773971557617,
-0.30984553694725037,
0.5169110894203186,
-0.055173780769109726,
0.05819462239742279,
0.11804144084453583,
-0.6456940770149231,
0.7843921184539795,
0.5469649434089661,
-0.03798140585422516,
0.6111032962799072,
0.3240486979484558,
-0.11627308279275894,
0.12994684278964996,
-0.3367116153240204,
-0.789330780506134,
0.7535077333450317,
0.25791579484939575,
0.5683901309967041,
0.1714445948600769,
0.45832306146621704,
0.6073439717292786,
0.39775651693344116,
-0.5918238759040833,
0.5263918042182922,
-0.02389371208846569,
-0.5701514482498169,
-0.16358336806297302,
-0.24188430607318878,
-0.5070342421531677,
0.4949820041656494,
0.00026266873464919627,
-0.1216890886425972,
0.09409506618976593,
-0.06677571684122086,
-0.09964019805192947,
0.40919315814971924,
-0.8209298849105835,
0.18775732815265656,
-0.5839436054229736,
0.08998073637485504,
-0.2878929376602173,
-0.4798244833946228,
0.5987592935562134,
-0.3283003866672516,
0.49359753727912903,
-0.27680346369743347,
0.17145681381225586,
0.5050130486488342,
-0.3100588917732239,
0.7877174615859985,
-0.3470194637775421,
-0.42364948987960815,
0.1003045067191124,
0.6475781202316284,
0.6334546804428101,
0.4646134674549103,
0.08873765915632248,
0.7220596075057983,
-0.06006104499101639,
-0.2838851809501648,
-0.4718490242958069,
0.7666774392127991,
-0.9018712043762207,
-0.5433102250099182,
-0.6430588364601135,
-0.13704153895378113,
-0.43344593048095703,
0.18544374406337738,
0.3539893925189972,
0.3383236229419708,
-0.3227059245109558,
-0.5212914943695068,
0.3742188811302185,
-0.24384871125221252,
0.2897982597351074,
0.8183252215385437,
-0.5271109938621521,
-0.47963741421699524,
0.9012198448181152,
-0.19440561532974243,
-0.13831636309623718,
0.274210125207901,
0.3376406729221344,
-0.6694962978363037,
-0.4703165888786316,
-0.7447649240493774,
0.4696861207485199,
-0.5244565606117249,
-0.046922467648983,
-0.47866305708885193,
-0.06662307679653168,
-0.4315323233604431,
0.0008940368425101042,
-0.38615167140960693,
-0.4477275311946869,
0.12974512577056885,
-0.04975448548793793,
-0.011791138909757137,
0.9043409824371338,
0.08627862483263016,
0.36147376894950867,
-0.7532091736793518,
0.656166672706604,
0.10806070268154144,
0.31101590394973755,
-0.2927425503730774,
-0.48424458503723145,
-0.1649731546640396,
0.3448047637939453,
0.03172801434993744,
-0.8967953324317932,
0.39344942569732666,
-0.14489039778709412,
0.5606139302253723,
0.5567283034324646,
0.03352119028568268,
0.17369017004966736,
-0.3093136250972748,
1.203794240951538,
0.1291290670633316,
-0.7059558033943176,
0.28984740376472473,
-0.2800598442554474,
0.12099481374025345,
0.47595492005348206,
0.6890343427658081,
-0.41703084111213684,
-0.4834233820438385,
-0.6392462849617004,
-0.168495774269104,
0.246900737285614,
0.24307534098625183,
0.4303932785987854,
0.10894525796175003,
0.09082677215337753,
0.24737021327018738,
0.5781496167182922,
-1.2113072872161865,
-0.1957637071609497,
-0.1591113954782486,
0.34396272897720337,
-0.01763029582798481,
-0.30776217579841614,
-0.33621981739997864,
-0.11637505143880844,
0.8795308470726013,
0.0642019584774971,
0.5442728400230408,
-0.02762906812131405,
-0.29376327991485596,
-0.11012536287307739,
0.06442847102880478,
0.9031668901443481,
0.7332557439804077,
-0.10722813010215759,
0.20989398658275604,
-0.056884367018938065,
-0.6159165501594543,
0.14892423152923584,
-0.10839693993330002,
-0.4955061376094818,
0.41378188133239746,
0.5341415405273438,
0.7407394051551819,
-0.5972629189491272,
-0.24745383858680725,
0.6658975481987,
-0.2886502742767334,
-0.2502720057964325,
-0.5971866846084595,
-0.14988963305950165,
-0.2530548870563507,
-0.10972043871879578,
0.1741493046283722,
0.4384978115558624,
0.11413142085075378,
-0.5388062596321106,
0.05723540112376213,
0.6324031352996826,
-0.2889684736728668,
-0.35613521933555603,
0.7006761431694031,
0.5182828307151794,
-0.3675403296947479,
0.8155729174613953,
-0.4710208475589752,
-0.940625786781311,
0.3009023666381836,
0.1649409979581833,
1.2107011079788208,
-0.33912980556488037,
0.6634178757667542,
0.2980809509754181,
0.7317926287651062,
0.03335081413388252,
0.33740922808647156,
-0.15330906212329865,
-1.1238502264022827,
-0.6029052138328552,
-0.8376602530479431,
-0.2728339731693268,
0.484097957611084,
-0.46827876567840576,
0.26370739936828613,
-0.026320934295654297,
0.026212617754936218,
-0.2258400022983551,
0.02086043730378151,
-0.5838247537612915,
0.14208650588989258,
0.37169837951660156,
0.5624163150787354,
-1.0506399869918823,
0.7709096670150757,
0.5830488801002502,
-0.5730252265930176,
-0.6866435408592224,
0.45653340220451355,
0.11737480014562607,
-1.1692712306976318,
0.3129112720489502,
0.20529627799987793,
-0.8274251818656921,
-0.21120165288448334,
-0.5987122058868408,
-0.16637887060642242,
0.34373554587364197,
0.14010557532310486,
-0.5899010300636292,
-0.04978583753108978,
0.43273860216140747,
0.7645127177238464,
-0.3901101052761078,
0.23352870345115662,
0.7248252630233765,
0.5214755535125732,
-0.27269983291625977,
-0.9052140116691589,
-0.0930834636092186,
0.04253118857741356,
-0.0652192234992981,
0.006583645474165678,
-0.5763905048370361,
0.279531866312027,
-0.23172059655189514,
-0.2971620559692383,
-0.3210918605327606,
0.13404563069343567,
0.22457650303840637,
0.427961140871048,
0.5143506526947021,
0.561008632183075,
0.7055397033691406,
-0.31171461939811707,
1.2858989238739014,
-0.33924996852874756,
0.1325378268957138,
1.0279113054275513,
-0.4963897168636322,
0.6113449335098267,
0.13602931797504425,
-0.19858665764331818,
0.7590572834014893,
0.5920334458351135,
-0.4552786648273468,
0.5643280148506165,
0.28452661633491516,
-0.27916795015335083,
-0.15562282502651215,
0.002874374855309725,
-0.15529556572437286,
0.49678879976272583,
0.2623109221458435,
-0.23461268842220306,
-0.17363357543945312,
0.3545955717563629,
0.2371416538953781,
-0.041708000004291534,
-0.3332461416721344,
0.895178496837616,
-0.05635252222418785,
-0.8207393288612366,
0.6923061609268188,
0.1127355545759201,
0.5793418884277344,
-0.3947297930717468,
-0.16974472999572754,
-0.5529413819313049,
-0.060789261013269424,
-0.18640103936195374,
-0.6258046627044678,
0.07355131953954697,
-0.05760505422949791,
-0.16085030138492584,
-0.3905353844165802,
0.896552324295044,
-0.43582072854042053,
-0.6886297464370728,
0.06615262478590012,
0.8704690933227539,
0.32582151889801025,
-0.5507258176803589,
-0.8390489816665649,
-0.05018889158964157,
0.14759984612464905,
-0.12483388185501099,
0.13918620347976685,
0.18807002902030945,
-0.22360114753246307,
0.6311354637145996,
0.7700063586235046,
0.276947945356369,
0.06404829770326614,
0.4785633087158203,
0.33589696884155273,
-0.3073666989803314,
-0.7040017247200012,
-0.911236584186554,
0.20346243679523468,
-0.19638365507125854,
0.032841309905052185,
1.0558180809020996,
0.7885829210281372,
1.093003273010254,
-0.5904338955879211,
0.8350811004638672,
0.5040175914764404,
0.5246237516403198,
-0.5198723077774048,
0.8326095938682556,
-0.360204815864563,
0.44498077034950256,
-0.05266614630818367,
-1.0700401067733765,
-0.25069987773895264,
0.5781587958335876,
-0.26294630765914917,
0.12938125431537628,
0.7433252334594727,
0.9534127712249756,
0.12434978038072586,
0.01081445999443531,
0.44981157779693604,
0.22438859939575195,
0.460342139005661,
-0.019675103947520256,
1.4326553344726562,
-0.48663410544395447,
0.32541775703430176,
-0.03171393275260925,
0.19345249235630035,
-0.1832280457019806,
-0.892115592956543,
-0.9522439241409302,
-0.43798577785491943,
-0.60178542137146,
-0.6573030352592468,
-0.2266605794429779,
0.49707111716270447,
0.479688435792923,
-1.0631227493286133,
-0.01260960754007101,
0.02494421973824501,
0.13116955757141113,
-0.4891666769981384,
-0.2507528066635132,
0.6267659664154053,
-0.027564696967601776,
-0.9285107851028442,
0.5199156999588013,
0.06635767966508865,
0.05257980898022652,
-0.5846748948097229,
0.057501956820487976,
0.197612464427948,
0.46156367659568787,
0.5004953742027283,
-0.368251234292984,
-0.8798118829727173,
-0.02447676844894886,
-0.08799058198928833,
-0.1535060852766037,
-0.07130240648984909,
1.0456342697143555,
-0.5501525402069092,
0.41181129217147827,
0.3920366168022156,
0.30088040232658386,
0.3763405978679657,
0.005124853458255529,
0.39347007870674133,
-0.9198126792907715,
-0.2254684716463089,
0.2599101960659027,
0.32713907957077026,
0.2837333679199219,
-0.5575858950614929,
0.525179386138916,
0.38364776968955994,
-0.634216845035553,
-0.9706606268882751,
0.19629259407520294,
-0.782219648361206,
-0.3337063193321228,
1.2053515911102295,
0.23711033165454865,
0.06095612049102783,
-0.30695030093193054,
-0.3479340970516205,
-0.1609083116054535,
-0.25693556666374207,
1.1195673942565918,
1.1003957986831665,
-0.2695167660713196,
0.24389861524105072,
-0.7090626358985901,
1.052604079246521,
0.10653882473707199,
-0.7603747844696045,
0.018206462264060974,
0.7896220684051514,
0.4923976957798004,
0.3820160925388336,
0.6930215954780579,
-0.3325726389884949,
0.4084051847457886,
-0.1750081479549408,
-0.023232126608490944,
-0.4126768708229065,
-0.4973660409450531,
-0.5790311694145203,
0.08356114476919174,
-0.13491301238536835,
-0.3663695752620697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12933v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12933v2
|
Cross-cultural Inspiration Detection and Analysis in Real and LLM-generated Social Media Data
| 2024-04-19T15:04:30 | 2024-06-19T03:27:43 |
Oana Ignat, Gayathri Ganesh Lakshmy, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Inspiration is linked to various positive outcomes, such as increased
creativity, productivity, and happiness. Although inspiration has great
potential, there has been limited effort toward identifying content that is
inspiring, as opposed to just engaging or positive. Additionally, most research
has concentrated on Western data, with little attention paid to other cultures.
This work is the first to study cross-cultural inspiration through machine
learning methods. We aim to identify and analyze real and AI-generated
cross-cultural inspiring posts. To this end, we compile and make publicly
available the InspAIred dataset, which consists of 2,000 real inspiring posts,
2,000 real non-inspiring posts, and 2,000 generated inspiring posts evenly
distributed across India and the UK. The real posts are sourced from Reddit,
while the generated posts are created using the GPT-4 model. Using this
dataset, we conduct extensive computational linguistic analyses to (1) compare
inspiring content across cultures, (2) compare AI-generated inspiring posts to
real inspiring posts, and (3) determine if detection models can accurately
distinguish between inspiring content across cultures and data sources.
|
[
-0.35113605856895447,
-0.6721352338790894,
0.41376906633377075,
0.5736441612243652,
-0.5699073672294617,
0.35744553804397583,
-0.2862669825553894,
-0.7047240734100342,
0.34376081824302673,
0.09864427894353867,
-0.9807800650596619,
-0.5473752617835999,
-0.7553266882896423,
0.4510299861431122,
-0.369997501373291,
0.9052451252937317,
-0.3624940812587738,
0.15950003266334534,
-0.3052634596824646,
-0.12633946537971497,
-0.6160899996757507,
-0.1593971848487854,
-0.3519188463687897,
-0.08644100278615952,
0.470276802778244,
0.4885973036289215,
0.04323963075876236,
0.13525022566318512,
0.49314165115356445,
0.14706146717071533,
0.31875503063201904,
0.3539893329143524,
-0.8873215317726135,
-0.16226445138454437,
-0.3583585321903229,
-0.31066957116127014,
0.3673838675022125,
0.22003372013568878,
0.5815133452415466,
0.02324615977704525,
0.07897217571735382,
0.5429274439811707,
0.2781822681427002,
0.6980825066566467,
-0.34843093156814575,
0.20426778495311737,
-0.7820831537246704,
0.42383554577827454,
-0.11177802085876465,
-0.37208646535873413,
-0.025436149910092354,
-0.9488746523857117,
-0.31306350231170654,
-0.4276217818260193,
0.29866278171539307,
-0.21191442012786865,
0.8975759744644165,
0.11703987419605255,
-0.3016304671764374,
-0.7158440351486206,
-0.6767823100090027,
0.8299639821052551,
-0.09727508574724197,
0.3587925434112549,
0.1445755660533905,
0.27353405952453613,
-0.06194908916950226,
-0.4452114403247833,
-0.814913809299469,
0.14532174170017242,
-0.07646244019269943,
0.29268455505371094,
-0.6025305986404419,
-0.8448989987373352,
0.16304932534694672,
0.39714691042900085,
-0.7553735971450806,
-0.08115945011377335,
-0.33688846230506897,
0.032448746263980865,
0.8290560245513916,
0.1035185232758522,
0.8416099548339844,
-0.06557343900203705,
-0.34765905141830444,
-0.12232671678066254,
-0.7375729084014893,
0.1424233615398407,
0.40089279413223267,
-0.014993516728281975,
-0.5879631042480469,
0.48312216997146606,
-0.5720329880714417,
0.4244649112224579,
-0.19320663809776306,
-0.04986385256052017,
0.21954089403152466,
-0.5147674679756165,
0.22845731675624847,
0.024303436279296875,
0.8466009497642517,
0.39218416810035706,
0.47208264470100403,
-0.2215980887413025,
-0.219867542386055,
0.256247878074646,
0.07301211357116699,
-0.9395887851715088,
0.0029254809487611055,
-0.2843131422996521,
-0.8271914720535278,
-0.3935677111148834,
0.4107925593852997,
-0.5040586590766907,
-0.6064937114715576,
-0.3598245680332184,
0.2804337441921234,
-0.30430591106414795,
-0.3982006907463074,
-0.2979680597782135,
-0.2883334159851074,
0.4670241177082062,
0.11579569429159164,
-0.9037441611289978,
-0.14245936274528503,
0.9270733594894409,
0.9553078413009644,
-0.11273090541362762,
-0.19918370246887207,
-0.008497764356434345,
-0.33350273966789246,
-0.6161623597145081,
0.7478603720664978,
-0.5269896984100342,
-0.17246779799461365,
0.0100281136110425,
0.20060190558433533,
0.29266151785850525,
-0.3922916650772095,
0.9486056566238403,
-0.40323495864868164,
0.26673054695129395,
-0.6088382601737976,
-0.370301216840744,
-0.4312474727630615,
0.3200802206993103,
-0.5947097539901733,
0.6882269382476807,
0.2048158496618271,
-0.6519233584403992,
0.7953577637672424,
-0.7094502449035645,
-0.4279648959636688,
0.19379471242427826,
-0.38210970163345337,
-0.3316313624382019,
0.4615872800350189,
0.4797976613044739,
0.4302074909210205,
-0.821156919002533,
0.12712937593460083,
-0.19978266954421997,
-0.38162875175476074,
0.20972955226898193,
-0.45884501934051514,
1.1164040565490723,
0.5172746181488037,
-0.401463121175766,
0.10548196732997894,
-0.7740218639373779,
-0.07945273071527481,
0.5957584977149963,
-0.15503360331058502,
-0.3709076941013336,
-0.5016530156135559,
-0.15521863102912903,
0.5802533030509949,
0.06790074706077576,
-0.9354798197746277,
0.09393557161092758,
0.04880175739526749,
0.27222156524658203,
0.7331033945083618,
0.45222729444503784,
0.014870013110339642,
-0.354839563369751,
0.9780817031860352,
-0.09194845706224442,
0.011838768608868122,
0.013772044330835342,
-0.6661322712898254,
-0.010190146043896675,
-0.23614992201328278,
0.18849417567253113,
0.5477086305618286,
-0.7424391508102417,
0.22886578738689423,
-0.3995778262615204,
-1.0453379154205322,
-0.8475773334503174,
0.36256030201911926,
0.059720635414123535,
0.6533541083335876,
0.12493225187063217,
-0.3400351107120514,
-0.6807276606559753,
-0.7676358222961426,
-0.6273648142814636,
0.13168059289455414,
-0.01206554938107729,
0.10063210874795914,
0.5204492807388306,
-0.3359370231628418,
0.6436201930046082,
-0.17427927255630493,
-0.16733744740486145,
-0.22344635426998138,
0.34188374876976013,
0.4596257209777832,
0.3833904564380646,
0.7311132550239563,
-0.9126657843589783,
-1.1915124654769897,
0.10581351071596146,
-1.2691614627838135,
-0.4969521164894104,
-0.29268577694892883,
-0.43167975544929504,
-0.07337463647127151,
0.1341647207736969,
-0.517158031463623,
0.5828685164451599,
0.6637659668922424,
-0.1138237938284874,
0.5149981379508972,
0.239474818110466,
0.5260802507400513,
-1.094205379486084,
-0.20642311871051788,
0.1267746388912201,
0.25907060503959656,
-0.2589755058288574,
-0.400716096162796,
0.20659160614013672,
-0.4971131384372711,
-0.4205344617366791,
0.6746426224708557,
-0.2667916715145111,
-0.05338330566883087,
-0.24069556593894958,
-0.31645849347114563,
-0.057063449174165726,
0.3343972861766815,
0.27626317739486694,
0.45554161071777344,
0.7652806639671326,
-0.02822454459965229,
0.5122395753860474,
0.1015813946723938,
-0.7236088514328003,
0.7066117525100708,
-0.48147058486938477,
0.15686917304992676,
-0.26645907759666443,
0.23792476952075958,
-1.077298879623413,
-0.3787391185760498,
0.39197736978530884,
-0.7137736082077026,
-0.23432160913944244,
-0.06921922415494919,
-0.6382246613502502,
-0.5425336956977844,
-0.18394434452056885,
0.27937668561935425,
0.6577824950218201,
-0.8905547857284546,
0.39765605330467224,
0.11206851154565811,
-0.20216061174869537,
-0.33169886469841003,
-0.5661997199058533,
0.055372580885887146,
-0.6480835676193237,
-0.6244621872901917,
0.2915455102920532,
-0.045836761593818665,
-0.2366107702255249,
0.12953832745552063,
0.27824723720550537,
0.4816245436668396,
0.026226837188005447,
0.4450860023498535,
-0.024607257917523384,
-0.13202713429927826,
-0.2563064396381378,
-0.1585109680891037,
0.15632888674736023,
0.27537667751312256,
-0.24884650111198425,
0.6783552765846252,
-0.07870025187730789,
-0.4944596588611603,
-1.1443077325820923,
0.5477242469787598,
0.3768329322338104,
-0.24837055802345276,
0.6615349054336548,
1.0667140483856201,
-0.49007195234298706,
-0.23785293102264404,
-0.36803779006004333,
-0.11576724052429199,
-0.4603364169597626,
0.13369740545749664,
-0.2587633430957794,
-0.514175534248352,
0.4733693599700928,
0.23532526195049286,
0.03760923817753792,
0.4845612943172455,
0.8106847405433655,
-0.25701630115509033,
0.9162704348564148,
0.7811615467071533,
-0.16022181510925293,
0.7735273241996765,
-0.2031388133764267,
0.17609372735023499,
-0.26528096199035645,
-0.1349448710680008,
-0.32585203647613525,
-0.6257375478744507,
-0.9033485651016235,
-0.10910046100616455,
0.23555058240890503,
-0.1819268763065338,
0.04694736376404762,
0.14928950369358063,
-0.6442505717277527,
0.5592721104621887,
0.7542992830276489,
-0.07422757893800735,
-0.07663533836603165,
0.33486148715019226,
0.012330024503171444,
-0.16244186460971832,
-0.6393173336982727,
-0.305340439081192,
1.1181436777114868,
0.12458831071853638,
0.9030275344848633,
0.11836204677820206,
0.9159494638442993,
0.705021321773529,
0.731249213218689,
-0.671901524066925,
0.40121352672576904,
-0.027317073196172714,
-0.20454896986484528,
0.1389784961938858,
-0.5072404146194458,
-0.8984813094139099,
-0.2166285663843155,
-0.382425457239151,
-0.36781075596809387,
0.20231248438358307,
-0.09482299536466599,
0.001891737338155508,
0.26115262508392334,
-0.6120402812957764,
0.8039544224739075,
-0.6375681161880493,
-0.24784649908542633,
-0.25661027431488037,
-0.3938307762145996,
0.4637351930141449,
-0.24135419726371765,
0.20511282980442047,
0.02753753773868084,
0.5563968420028687,
0.8328647017478943,
0.07213208079338074,
0.7499346137046814,
-0.23391017317771912,
-0.022609414532780647,
0.5896868705749512,
-0.00995576474815607,
0.5575813055038452,
-0.08809154480695724,
-0.12473657727241516,
0.4270128011703491,
-0.46681901812553406,
-0.42590340971946716,
-0.5902138948440552,
0.7519757151603699,
-0.8497739434242249,
-0.24835722148418427,
0.014442164450883865,
-0.45159146189689636,
-0.03544484078884125,
0.13216745853424072,
0.42885449528694153,
0.10703440755605698,
-0.0630650520324707,
0.45971792936325073,
0.012569441460072994,
-0.2956128716468811,
0.3934279680252075,
0.2834654450416565,
-0.007688410580158234,
-0.535994827747345,
1.109857201576233,
0.11235197633504868,
0.08566828072071075,
0.2578205466270447,
0.35023942589759827,
-0.4487841725349426,
-0.24042001366615295,
-0.6356143951416016,
0.2310381978750229,
-0.9190188646316528,
0.041169747710227966,
-0.398699551820755,
-0.01823575608432293,
-0.6029635071754456,
-0.24816423654556274,
-0.16244329512119293,
-0.36468419432640076,
-0.25616705417633057,
-0.2188178449869156,
0.29051995277404785,
0.863844633102417,
-0.5136202573776245,
0.0882885605096817,
-0.6799757480621338,
0.3223309814929962,
0.32898494601249695,
0.13304239511489868,
0.12327921390533447,
-0.3266623914241791,
-0.49275100231170654,
0.06287501007318497,
-0.42880377173423767,
-0.8105128407478333,
0.54421466588974,
0.08156437426805496,
0.7146949172019958,
0.6671568751335144,
-0.12881174683570862,
0.6472082138061523,
-0.09247738867998123,
0.7110623717308044,
0.2111223042011261,
-0.37339749932289124,
0.6836578845977783,
-0.18840396404266357,
0.20329096913337708,
0.3704356849193573,
0.9052096009254456,
-0.7406487464904785,
-0.1895589828491211,
-0.6220253705978394,
-0.5489210486412048,
0.36652159690856934,
0.013114958070218563,
0.29075148701667786,
0.13537977635860443,
0.21956203877925873,
0.4620021879673004,
0.08913547545671463,
-0.9898880124092102,
0.14274455606937408,
-0.41863059997558594,
-0.26134759187698364,
0.25719648599624634,
0.07050444930791855,
-0.13659030199050903,
-0.2839248776435852,
0.7957252860069275,
-0.06887619197368622,
0.3269367218017578,
0.06789722293615341,
-0.10593805462121964,
-0.4193568229675293,
-0.18841975927352905,
0.3889288306236267,
0.729740560054779,
0.2009275108575821,
-0.07360042631626129,
0.19990429282188416,
-0.271645724773407,
0.14619474112987518,
0.015129223465919495,
-0.2659057378768921,
-0.08480560034513474,
0.49176016449928284,
0.8641006350517273,
-0.54793781042099,
-0.5220035314559937,
0.12208636850118637,
-0.633174479007721,
-0.00792390014976263,
-0.5160019993782043,
0.16292572021484375,
0.010183329693973064,
0.33463162183761597,
0.6163350343704224,
-0.10561832785606384,
-0.19657975435256958,
-0.8561499714851379,
0.2123764604330063,
0.7120484113693237,
-0.6223393082618713,
-0.5165030360221863,
0.6955606341362,
-0.06154020503163338,
-0.5837096571922302,
0.6849576830863953,
-0.4392448365688324,
-0.5904960036277771,
0.6933625340461731,
0.7034344673156738,
1.0089894533157349,
0.23091188073158264,
0.12200552970170975,
0.42519786953926086,
0.15430249273777008,
0.2728452980518341,
0.5163100957870483,
-0.35458695888519287,
-0.877106785774231,
-0.281620055437088,
-0.8043368458747864,
-0.35300377011299133,
0.12118716537952423,
-0.5528568029403687,
0.5699074268341064,
-0.12374826520681381,
0.22708946466445923,
-0.041115496307611465,
-0.017000027000904083,
-0.9789530634880066,
0.4525075852870941,
0.5164929032325745,
0.6353207230567932,
-1.4638230800628662,
0.7409310340881348,
0.5490055084228516,
-0.4660132825374603,
-0.7880043387413025,
0.2357919067144394,
0.14793866872787476,
-0.9360741972923279,
0.8444099426269531,
0.34773126244544983,
-0.12211702764034271,
0.11114726960659027,
-0.6301653385162354,
-0.6299560070037842,
0.9863381385803223,
0.029141686856746674,
-0.1493590623140335,
0.3828604817390442,
0.44550055265426636,
0.7017682790756226,
-0.7029404044151306,
0.04435088858008385,
0.10143574327230453,
0.2985827326774597,
0.0256451815366745,
-0.44173675775527954,
-0.12331785261631012,
-0.49749770760536194,
-0.19797131419181824,
-0.17590948939323425,
-0.6937192678451538,
0.6658573150634766,
-0.08155461400747299,
-0.28915107250213623,
-0.13626223802566528,
0.7843636870384216,
0.5232064127922058,
0.20356912910938263,
0.5275450348854065,
0.6207567453384399,
0.6653686761856079,
0.021969936788082123,
1.153414011001587,
-0.515312671661377,
0.28359052538871765,
0.6762405633926392,
-0.14882375299930573,
0.46993786096572876,
0.30524033308029175,
0.07692916691303253,
0.8078032732009888,
0.9255161285400391,
-0.29206451773643494,
0.6805844306945801,
-0.06108686327934265,
-0.29318946599960327,
0.05658450350165367,
-0.3941580653190613,
-0.4294838607311249,
0.6666444540023804,
0.2786930501461029,
-0.7370006442070007,
-0.22095268964767456,
0.20038798451423645,
-0.16828283667564392,
0.011359027586877346,
-0.3679737448692322,
0.6922975778579712,
-0.0465477854013443,
-0.9054487943649292,
0.7715659737586975,
-0.25925031304359436,
0.5798327922821045,
-0.5983712077140808,
-0.28439968824386597,
-0.270955890417099,
-0.06012146547436714,
-0.21795539557933807,
-0.8472715020179749,
0.5862230658531189,
0.3235713243484497,
-0.013234265148639679,
-0.6410029530525208,
1.1166330575942993,
-0.17415975034236908,
-0.7825189232826233,
0.3822803497314453,
0.472788542509079,
0.255933940410614,
-0.12519799172878265,
-0.8349238038063049,
-0.02688959799706936,
0.22237230837345123,
-0.24679256975650787,
0.20160506665706635,
0.8812986612319946,
-0.34009701013565063,
0.4353981614112854,
1.0621416568756104,
0.1536937803030014,
-0.2084367722272873,
-0.017593413591384888,
0.6392948031425476,
-0.8291995525360107,
-0.8131565451622009,
-1.2260346412658691,
0.2947995960712433,
-0.1557416468858719,
-0.142648383975029,
1.0002973079681396,
0.6453945636749268,
0.8831431269645691,
-0.33829110860824585,
1.0844316482543945,
-0.43138670921325684,
0.4600391983985901,
-0.10447695851325989,
0.9468419551849365,
-0.7464556694030762,
-0.14527691900730133,
-0.35513508319854736,
-0.8305954933166504,
-0.1983727663755417,
0.31284797191619873,
-0.5003045201301575,
-0.3297920525074005,
0.1667507439851761,
0.8876887559890747,
-0.06097927689552307,
0.42883747816085815,
0.06814392656087875,
-0.04653783142566681,
0.3180927336215973,
0.23129959404468536,
1.4178171157836914,
0.2162804901599884,
0.4300582706928253,
-0.6101803183555603,
-0.3827258348464966,
-0.09571346640586853,
-0.9704519510269165,
-0.6465164422988892,
-0.574212372303009,
-0.09838072955608368,
-0.2488592118024826,
-0.2548852562904358,
0.9822659492492676,
0.5622962117195129,
-0.6906352639198303,
-0.09776056557893753,
-0.13622304797172546,
0.2381034791469574,
-0.3620080351829529,
-0.26556551456451416,
0.3930429518222809,
-0.06872968375682831,
-0.5631073117256165,
0.3751992881298065,
0.13638123869895935,
-0.08042546361684799,
-0.3457724153995514,
0.047571711242198944,
0.024469323456287384,
0.00451652193441987,
0.7065016627311707,
0.31456682085990906,
-0.38458219170570374,
-0.3978361487388611,
-0.10068672895431519,
0.10168547183275223,
0.18178614974021912,
0.7605794668197632,
-0.6917508840560913,
0.2925090491771698,
0.8959811925888062,
0.7912443280220032,
0.37360548973083496,
0.4280373156070709,
0.332989901304245,
-0.6812097430229187,
0.03591151908040047,
0.1511203646659851,
0.49345287680625916,
0.5011491179466248,
-0.36290520429611206,
0.8545607924461365,
0.6021416783332825,
-0.7089521884918213,
-0.6205922365188599,
0.16317249834537506,
-0.5383296608924866,
0.013625597581267357,
0.9941710829734802,
-0.25024983286857605,
-0.41852205991744995,
0.1725117266178131,
-0.260591596364975,
0.3442791998386383,
-0.17163361608982086,
1.1736397743225098,
0.8796802163124084,
-0.6217731237411499,
-0.04462732374668121,
-0.5141257047653198,
0.3793022036552429,
0.29983144998550415,
-0.923942506313324,
-0.13057328760623932,
0.4537007212638855,
0.37908878922462463,
0.16271410882472992,
0.41657018661499023,
-0.09732167422771454,
0.40380027890205383,
-0.19025841355323792,
0.08359910547733307,
0.35029280185699463,
-0.1110784187912941,
-0.3023085296154022,
0.29667383432388306,
-0.18827344477176666,
-0.2926640212535858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12897v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12897v2
|
Enabling Natural Zero-Shot Prompting on Encoder Models via Statement-Tuning
| 2024-04-19T14:05:03 | 2024-04-22T10:17:07 |
Ahmed Elshabrawy, Yongxin Huang, Iryna Gurevych, Alham Fikri Aji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit remarkable capabilities in
zero-shot and few-shot scenarios, they often require computationally
prohibitive sizes. Conversely, smaller Masked Language Models (MLMs) like BERT
and RoBERTa achieve state-of-the-art results through fine-tuning but struggle
with extending to few-shot and zero-shot settings due to their architectural
constraints. Hence, we propose Statement-Tuning, a technique that models
discriminative tasks as a set of finite statements and trains an Encoder model
to discriminate between the potential statements to determine the label. We do
Statement-Tuning on multiple tasks to enable cross-task generalization.
Experimental results demonstrate that Statement Tuning achieves competitive
performance compared to state-of-the-art LLMs with significantly fewer
parameters. Moreover, the study investigates the impact of several design
choices on few-shot and zero-shot generalization, revealing that Statement
Tuning can achieve sufficient performance with modest training data and
benefits from task and statement diversity for unseen task generalizability.
|
[
-0.37034597992897034,
-0.9602863192558289,
0.3987124562263489,
0.056082531809806824,
-0.25748762488365173,
0.02440515160560608,
-0.6145044565200806,
-0.46988645195961,
-0.0324753113090992,
0.5397999286651611,
-0.7770890593528748,
-0.6877131462097168,
-0.6311447620391846,
0.37147119641304016,
-0.06738986074924469,
1.0763616561889648,
0.09154832363128662,
-0.07454685121774673,
-0.06205630674958229,
-0.040310535579919815,
-0.9492446184158325,
-0.059460513293743134,
-0.6171515583992004,
-0.32734546065330505,
0.4551165699958801,
0.39250448346138,
0.5385299324989319,
0.624787449836731,
0.26816993951797485,
0.15616542100906372,
0.218740314245224,
0.44841694831848145,
-0.5376647114753723,
0.24856644868850708,
-0.05778573825955391,
-0.8340396285057068,
-0.11224443465471268,
-0.07364851981401443,
0.49903520941734314,
0.6649054884910583,
0.09117026627063751,
0.22922523319721222,
0.12776820361614227,
0.524080216884613,
-1.018556833267212,
0.08522151410579681,
-0.975145161151886,
0.27067503333091736,
-0.08974342793226242,
-0.32404476404190063,
-0.5126402378082275,
-0.287118136882782,
-0.13876008987426758,
-0.6044784784317017,
0.6253946423530579,
0.06998042017221451,
0.9804114103317261,
0.5431172847747803,
-0.20268917083740234,
-0.21314655244350433,
-0.8462764620780945,
0.8061128854751587,
-0.5972205996513367,
0.23846344649791718,
0.43918663263320923,
0.2223510891199112,
0.04039958119392395,
-0.055537883192300797,
-0.5144131183624268,
-0.1910649538040161,
-0.046017877757549286,
0.08999647945165634,
-0.4014981985092163,
0.444404274225235,
0.4846021234989166,
0.23355893790721893,
-0.6842038035392761,
0.394693523645401,
-0.12279818952083588,
-0.05358026176691055,
0.3256664276123047,
0.19332391023635864,
-0.07664276659488678,
0.20070189237594604,
0.03495313599705696,
0.19385962188243866,
-0.9135785102844238,
-0.08939755707979202,
0.2526228427886963,
0.7945092916488647,
-0.14985881745815277,
0.5890049934387207,
-0.6493862867355347,
1.506970763206482,
0.48882219195365906,
0.13181760907173157,
-0.13209734857082367,
-0.27354514598846436,
-0.524025559425354,
0.181819349527359,
0.5079784393310547,
0.3656942844390869,
0.37505629658699036,
-0.3814355134963989,
-0.13467589020729065,
0.4814026653766632,
0.3705598711967468,
-0.9094105958938599,
-0.06359966099262238,
0.14633700251579285,
-0.27046582102775574,
-0.17815272510051727,
-0.14423543214797974,
-0.6533772349357605,
-0.34961697459220886,
-0.43536803126335144,
0.5853018164634705,
-0.29536429047584534,
0.10820208489894867,
0.4376777410507202,
-0.3744295835494995,
0.5376034379005432,
0.08805414289236069,
-1.0811823606491089,
0.07051514834165573,
0.6269490122795105,
0.8422889113426208,
-0.0296645425260067,
0.16335564851760864,
-0.7467313408851624,
0.2946024537086487,
-0.5791078805923462,
0.5936982035636902,
-0.984998881816864,
-0.4359075427055359,
0.23741190135478973,
-0.18980462849140167,
-0.2504566013813019,
-0.6893064379692078,
0.3768186569213867,
-0.3126501739025116,
-0.03410385176539421,
-0.3166387677192688,
-0.5388154983520508,
0.16956372559070587,
0.4041200280189514,
-0.2274238020181656,
0.8242759108543396,
-0.06130344793200493,
-0.27630162239074707,
0.7629300355911255,
-0.7874841690063477,
-0.6663703918457031,
0.2546314001083374,
-0.4503189027309418,
-0.4382867217063904,
0.5908833146095276,
0.5020191073417664,
0.4639450013637543,
-0.2397717833518982,
0.10309771448373795,
-0.20380449295043945,
-0.5737840533256531,
0.03340962156653404,
-0.2969372868537903,
0.46871885657310486,
0.20102432370185852,
-0.2895238697528839,
-0.08039300888776779,
-0.7143276333808899,
0.15974974632263184,
-0.06922223418951035,
-0.40841060876846313,
-0.09320902079343796,
-0.13056135177612305,
-0.5930303931236267,
0.08485058695077896,
0.30030450224876404,
-0.8720425367355347,
0.2645397484302521,
-0.5303173065185547,
0.07687127590179443,
0.4823985695838928,
-0.07570202648639679,
0.4247486889362335,
-0.4475787580013275,
0.7470529079437256,
-0.10863108187913895,
0.04923182725906372,
-0.42970308661460876,
-0.5619785785675049,
-1.0756345987319946,
-0.2504602074623108,
0.3617900013923645,
0.6504579186439514,
-0.8871303200721741,
0.5882749557495117,
-0.04946156591176987,
-0.1432187855243683,
-0.9095863103866577,
0.18560300767421722,
0.5212993621826172,
0.6210435628890991,
0.3976464569568634,
0.01903538592159748,
-0.688829779624939,
-0.9883117079734802,
-0.49561646580696106,
0.14251773059368134,
-0.2674403190612793,
0.4149817228317261,
0.3074811100959778,
0.24440479278564453,
1.2248802185058594,
-0.6836469769477844,
-0.47951123118400574,
-0.2446901649236679,
0.34163448214530945,
0.43152323365211487,
0.3342314064502716,
0.5124503374099731,
-0.4718874990940094,
-0.7243778705596924,
0.06468036025762558,
-0.7961516380310059,
-0.1602177619934082,
-0.28095272183418274,
-0.07619667798280716,
0.28856799006462097,
0.28517982363700867,
-0.6878255009651184,
0.49140486121177673,
0.4109151363372803,
-0.07717854529619217,
0.379198282957077,
-0.2922583222389221,
0.025679709389805794,
-0.6128626465797424,
-0.2572251260280609,
0.24110420048236847,
-0.14303945004940033,
-0.7772628664970398,
0.16280177235603333,
0.018259979784488678,
-0.23273611068725586,
-0.22099129855632782,
0.187851220369339,
-0.5393596887588501,
0.1965554803609848,
-0.3935777544975281,
-0.10616735368967056,
0.04029875621199608,
0.4848450720310211,
0.2689412534236908,
0.6380912065505981,
1.0813478231430054,
-0.9289905428886414,
-0.02193843200802803,
0.20491188764572144,
-0.2421073466539383,
0.840675950050354,
-0.8456987738609314,
0.2241934835910797,
-0.36043596267700195,
0.06023899465799332,
-0.8190256953239441,
-0.11668076366186142,
0.22003012895584106,
-0.4579799473285675,
0.4728119373321533,
-0.3101467192173004,
-0.40863150358200073,
-0.4091172218322754,
-0.1455611139535904,
0.017993712797760963,
0.5889080166816711,
-0.5495503544807434,
0.4540320932865143,
-0.0111591387540102,
0.17701473832130432,
-0.27993738651275635,
-0.7535160183906555,
0.1781710833311081,
-0.14089390635490417,
-0.4101765751838684,
0.4840698540210724,
-0.11949596554040909,
0.14434842765331268,
-0.31839314103126526,
-0.22609393298625946,
0.08319511264562607,
-0.14141319692134857,
0.2085016965866089,
0.36094576120376587,
-0.27391767501831055,
0.24658942222595215,
0.16619856655597687,
0.040165651589632034,
-0.2405230700969696,
-0.5035702586174011,
0.2958284616470337,
0.008999591693282127,
-0.3441033959388733,
-0.12064947187900543,
0.38909727334976196,
-0.13540039956569672,
-0.3444652855396271,
0.7600324153900146,
0.5254275798797607,
-0.26657286286354065,
-0.5103597640991211,
-0.47417160868644714,
-0.25360485911369324,
-0.527728796005249,
0.188229501247406,
-0.4781288206577301,
-1.4015473127365112,
0.061431512236595154,
-0.1339500993490219,
0.15569724142551422,
0.05944366380572319,
0.7325056195259094,
-0.11557625234127045,
1.1985117197036743,
0.8534848093986511,
0.1280137598514557,
0.4082551896572113,
0.003999895881861448,
0.30597731471061707,
-0.5407296419143677,
0.008796085603535175,
-0.6887548565864563,
-0.5869959592819214,
-0.6070364117622375,
-0.4604654312133789,
0.5858173966407776,
0.07224281132221222,
-0.16713565587997437,
0.3549991846084595,
-0.8638221025466919,
0.9061869382858276,
0.5381778478622437,
0.17357975244522095,
0.12798906862735748,
-0.045652855187654495,
-0.006701204925775528,
0.02851710096001625,
-0.7649727463722229,
-0.26046255230903625,
1.1024794578552246,
-0.03930819034576416,
0.8034917116165161,
-0.04245932400226593,
0.9215878248214722,
0.1371064931154251,
-0.12876282632350922,
-0.7520049214363098,
0.496952086687088,
-0.470296174287796,
-0.8586739301681519,
-0.32945916056632996,
-0.3194126784801483,
-1.0840407609939575,
0.20880800485610962,
-0.324558824300766,
-0.8204733729362488,
0.4180782437324524,
0.3942939043045044,
-0.8818206787109375,
0.028191685676574707,
-0.524961531162262,
0.7296346426010132,
-0.05819088593125343,
-0.18228940665721893,
-0.16945403814315796,
-0.566395103931427,
0.36036545038223267,
0.04449083283543587,
-0.1705896258354187,
-0.2512712776660919,
-0.06086236983537674,
0.36314183473587036,
-0.07055159658193588,
1.2976372241973877,
-0.4759291112422943,
-0.16140934824943542,
0.16866625845432281,
0.1206534281373024,
0.5957104563713074,
-0.15783455967903137,
-0.10259509831666946,
0.046773478388786316,
-0.34471890330314636,
-0.3378947973251343,
-0.6518232226371765,
0.6444817185401917,
-0.48741212487220764,
-0.7287469506263733,
-0.07434388995170593,
-0.5083543062210083,
-0.5719816088676453,
0.08665455132722855,
0.44804468750953674,
0.2842507064342499,
-0.23999711871147156,
0.30252525210380554,
0.986671507358551,
-0.3075745701789856,
0.5019930005073547,
0.9199000000953674,
0.02562912553548813,
0.0700085237622261,
1.0785353183746338,
-0.02427336387336254,
0.3918605446815491,
0.6187628507614136,
-0.004794901702553034,
-0.13062162697315216,
-0.5691127777099609,
-0.35878613591194153,
0.06225505843758583,
-0.36582130193710327,
-0.49985435605049133,
-0.3864996135234833,
-0.037122443318367004,
-0.37325653433799744,
-0.33070310950279236,
-0.2504445016384125,
-0.3783939778804779,
-0.43290308117866516,
-0.13007807731628418,
0.3370904326438904,
0.4624188244342804,
-0.07221367210149765,
0.45178648829460144,
-0.5748201608657837,
0.7240214347839355,
0.3631972372531891,
0.5305942296981812,
-0.37579604983329773,
-0.6224265098571777,
-0.42200398445129395,
0.2065047174692154,
-0.42543166875839233,
-0.6204531788825989,
0.3071267306804657,
0.7543540596961975,
0.5213329792022705,
0.4207504689693451,
0.22115960717201233,
0.7572302222251892,
-0.5258377194404602,
0.6451807618141174,
0.18798714876174927,
-0.7793422341346741,
1.019197940826416,
-0.4393794536590576,
0.6902564764022827,
0.5709486603736877,
0.32892876863479614,
-0.4132624566555023,
-0.5516684651374817,
0.005553471855819225,
-0.4140864908695221,
0.8167533874511719,
0.15947338938713074,
0.32080236077308655,
-0.2989005744457245,
0.17738302052021027,
0.2705323100090027,
0.3598458170890808,
-0.4324648082256317,
-0.31213250756263733,
-0.30038249492645264,
-0.04885530099272728,
0.09902423620223999,
0.1821325719356537,
-0.3128586411476135,
-0.3230389356613159,
0.4559890031814575,
-0.582327127456665,
0.3805074691772461,
-0.0542348213493824,
-0.14809486269950867,
-0.20172032713890076,
0.5300033688545227,
0.6074501276016235,
0.3682379424571991,
-0.20545460283756256,
-0.08870820701122284,
0.1928434818983078,
0.12514881789684296,
0.03136039897799492,
0.0746346116065979,
-0.5734180808067322,
0.12123551219701767,
0.012125605717301369,
1.4662994146347046,
0.25159019231796265,
-0.36894920468330383,
0.14936912059783936,
0.03332005813717842,
-0.41674986481666565,
0.16729967296123505,
0.4772217571735382,
-0.1635560691356659,
0.10259710997343063,
0.27634865045547485,
0.10009095072746277,
-0.040942806750535965,
-0.42175641655921936,
-0.031037744134664536,
0.822837769985199,
-0.4620571732521057,
-0.147081658244133,
0.7483391165733337,
0.25213709473609924,
-0.33216336369514465,
0.5175553560256958,
-0.28497809171676636,
-0.006044282577931881,
0.6288140416145325,
0.7157204747200012,
1.0228431224822998,
0.05828782543540001,
0.6202901601791382,
0.38750162720680237,
0.39042654633522034,
0.09436482936143875,
0.30422428250312805,
-0.41883739829063416,
-0.9831358194351196,
-0.5130245089530945,
-0.8419215679168701,
-0.348804235458374,
-0.08062709867954254,
-0.8690995573997498,
0.21801021695137024,
-0.5132346153259277,
-0.3041520416736603,
0.07631217688322067,
-0.275701642036438,
-0.9052159786224365,
0.21176086366176605,
0.4516601860523224,
0.8112158179283142,
-0.6005306839942932,
0.8384923338890076,
0.37462636828422546,
-0.32287535071372986,
-0.395571768283844,
-0.0866190642118454,
-0.04547346010804176,
-1.03960382938385,
0.5024199485778809,
0.22466892004013062,
-0.05383826419711113,
0.1133451983332634,
-0.7697175145149231,
-0.41579097509384155,
0.9080265164375305,
0.6693279147148132,
-0.9353959560394287,
-0.19064629077911377,
0.5261747241020203,
0.5098623037338257,
-0.6064733862876892,
-0.09117130190134048,
0.883313775062561,
0.4378686547279358,
0.24266678094863892,
-0.94622403383255,
0.005681101232767105,
0.13763432204723358,
0.14375287294387817,
0.2759549915790558,
-0.5681487917900085,
0.6889688372612,
-0.23643627762794495,
-0.26893824338912964,
0.02540671080350876,
0.5015773177146912,
0.41038626432418823,
0.045213114470243454,
0.2684710621833801,
0.5162534117698669,
0.7267059683799744,
-0.26236411929130554,
1.0370731353759766,
-0.5247668623924255,
0.05806177482008934,
1.281140923500061,
-0.44398224353790283,
0.6109194755554199,
0.24780768156051636,
-0.19109143316745758,
0.2960186004638672,
0.3305548429489136,
-0.2544369399547577,
0.6469817757606506,
0.1965559422969818,
-0.5406627655029297,
-0.6202018857002258,
-0.4064139723777771,
-0.22217047214508057,
0.6246962547302246,
0.5004472732543945,
-0.2486209273338318,
-0.4599262773990631,
0.04248682036995888,
-0.31925541162490845,
-0.08325657993555069,
-0.4907236695289612,
0.8794342875480652,
0.07702700048685074,
-0.8677756190299988,
0.818040668964386,
0.05671118572354317,
1.0649276971817017,
-0.7691758871078491,
-0.17820076644420624,
-0.16193003952503204,
-0.0540446974337101,
-0.11265838146209717,
-0.5295347571372986,
0.35335567593574524,
0.07759858667850494,
-0.31522053480148315,
-0.4021565318107605,
0.803059995174408,
-0.5786311030387878,
-0.5700005888938904,
-0.013057922013103962,
0.3382609784603119,
-0.19862613081932068,
-0.16285216808319092,
-0.552242636680603,
0.055642496794462204,
-0.004708769265562296,
0.23932044208049774,
0.533358633518219,
0.33035215735435486,
0.2343084067106247,
0.5062478184700012,
0.5155652165412903,
0.20144981145858765,
0.19607344269752502,
0.3218877911567688,
0.7095819711685181,
-0.6530991792678833,
-0.4790841341018677,
-0.8717307448387146,
0.287004679441452,
-0.009296705015003681,
-0.2625540792942047,
0.7156786322593689,
0.4518774151802063,
0.8291066288948059,
-0.2385619729757309,
1.0065765380859375,
-0.044950686395168304,
0.4815925657749176,
-0.6004658341407776,
0.42008259892463684,
-0.30449044704437256,
0.06580176949501038,
0.14003558456897736,
-0.649026095867157,
-0.35392123460769653,
0.5618367195129395,
-0.189994677901268,
0.05348591506481171,
0.2876303195953369,
1.1919879913330078,
0.20503757894039154,
0.023628955706954002,
0.7642707824707031,
0.06189993768930435,
0.05785384401679039,
0.7439605593681335,
0.5015830397605896,
-0.06353894621133804,
0.5519946813583374,
0.07699848711490631,
-0.12172815203666687,
-0.0419674888253212,
-0.875879168510437,
-1.1283049583435059,
-0.1503969132900238,
-0.5923603773117065,
0.046695057302713394,
0.29217126965522766,
0.6918656826019287,
0.8359676003456116,
-1.0264173746109009,
-0.133900985121727,
-0.17579156160354614,
-0.0652439072728157,
-0.26488640904426575,
-0.23531574010849,
-0.25229138135910034,
-0.6435816884040833,
-0.7191326022148132,
0.7456342577934265,
0.5042626857757568,
-0.06200273707509041,
-0.16647373139858246,
-0.21004608273506165,
-0.11099585890769958,
0.3953551948070526,
0.566229522228241,
0.5551148056983948,
-0.718723475933075,
-0.2677318751811981,
-0.010471060872077942,
0.22154301404953003,
0.13652117550373077,
0.958388090133667,
-1.093193769454956,
0.6994840502738953,
0.11542361229658127,
0.624852180480957,
0.681141197681427,
-0.07419193536043167,
0.8001278638839722,
-1.4871522188186646,
-0.014036806300282478,
0.1181379109621048,
0.022728076204657555,
0.2223772257566452,
-0.3719472587108612,
0.3348032534122467,
-0.07319314777851105,
-0.34128546714782715,
-0.719397246837616,
0.4372677803039551,
-0.5159586668014526,
-0.27504417300224304,
0.8465670347213745,
-0.010988575406372547,
0.10209010541439056,
-0.20499533414840698,
-0.024382874369621277,
0.15890458226203918,
-0.4531783163547516,
0.6836946606636047,
0.6958528757095337,
-0.4417816400527954,
-0.29300105571746826,
-0.49564024806022644,
0.5625609159469604,
0.47785982489585876,
-0.6285238862037659,
0.056224219501018524,
0.537937343120575,
0.045622337609529495,
-0.061137013137340546,
0.6288658976554871,
0.2763225734233856,
0.24538873136043549,
-0.036898937076330185,
-0.08589822798967361,
-0.21830137073993683,
-0.3293847143650055,
-0.590976357460022,
0.1324232965707779,
0.04850805550813675,
-0.5360339283943176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12879v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12879v1
|
Unlocking Multi-View Insights in Knowledge-Dense Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-04-19T13:27:38 | 2024-04-19T13:27:38 |
Guanhua Chen, Wenhan Yu, Lei Sha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) plays a crucial role in the
application of Large Language Models (LLMs), existing retrieval methods in
knowledge-dense domains like law and medicine still suffer from a lack of
multi-perspective views, which are essential for improving interpretability and
reliability. Previous research on multi-view retrieval often focused solely on
different semantic forms of queries, neglecting the expression of specific
domain knowledge perspectives. This paper introduces a novel multi-view RAG
framework, MVRAG, tailored for knowledge-dense domains that utilizes
intention-aware query rewriting from multiple domain viewpoints to enhance
retrieval precision, thereby improving the effectiveness of the final
inference. Experiments conducted on legal and medical case retrieval
demonstrate significant improvements in recall and precision rates with our
framework. Our multi-perspective retrieval approach unleashes the potential of
multi-view information enhancing RAG tasks, accelerating the further
application of LLMs in knowledge-intensive fields.
|
[
-0.26303258538246155,
-0.49336546659469604,
0.9129064679145813,
-0.05389057472348213,
-0.19566063582897186,
0.02321864292025566,
0.03184440732002258,
-0.15055301785469055,
0.5166465044021606,
0.8294652700424194,
-0.20835676789283752,
-0.3550693988800049,
-0.7451057434082031,
-0.253446489572525,
-0.18427328765392303,
0.9307337999343872,
0.009064052253961563,
0.08770277351140976,
-0.35997068881988525,
-0.4310261309146881,
-0.3146914541721344,
-0.6859923005104065,
-0.4493902325630188,
-0.19283826649188995,
0.8793396353721619,
0.4147779047489166,
0.29193949699401855,
0.4081592559814453,
0.4472019672393799,
0.2637253701686859,
0.0034584878012537956,
0.6523607969284058,
-0.5478743314743042,
0.34758704900741577,
-0.13961607217788696,
-0.4840751886367798,
-0.5677745342254639,
-0.05679130181670189,
0.8132122755050659,
0.7835720181465149,
-0.4680560529232025,
0.003989305347204208,
0.132595956325531,
1.0531468391418457,
-1.2159512042999268,
-0.10675308853387833,
-0.7728639841079712,
-0.10757488757371902,
-0.17001771926879883,
-0.5990754961967468,
-0.6367536187171936,
-0.1398441344499588,
0.016144689172506332,
-0.8339377641677856,
0.24779671430587769,
0.28183189034461975,
0.6211768984794617,
0.44758954644203186,
-0.6854034662246704,
0.14018134772777557,
-0.5348888039588928,
0.9456511735916138,
-0.35838648676872253,
0.6654583215713501,
0.16361968219280243,
0.5467771887779236,
-0.24807687103748322,
-0.7276130318641663,
-0.5061882138252258,
0.3144495487213135,
-0.12864014506340027,
0.22369696199893951,
0.12661121785640717,
0.10703010857105255,
0.05599113553762436,
0.27881094813346863,
-0.2904275357723236,
-0.3973606526851654,
-0.38669657707214355,
-0.04885134845972061,
0.5638892650604248,
0.06236592307686806,
-0.1397070437669754,
-0.4311572313308716,
-0.30651766061782837,
0.054578378796577454,
-0.7832413911819458,
-0.2775520384311676,
0.10035107284784317,
0.061519838869571686,
0.15281924605369568,
0.6875495910644531,
-0.3466402590274811,
0.8956314325332642,
0.049336519092321396,
-0.4553593695163727,
0.2730367183685303,
-0.2669526934623718,
-0.3280660808086395,
-0.07188235223293304,
0.4241333305835724,
0.42527487874031067,
-0.16487187147140503,
0.13825497031211853,
0.06631603837013245,
-0.38513991236686707,
0.675256609916687,
-0.7697685360908508,
-0.05477694049477577,
0.22000306844711304,
-0.551889181137085,
-0.3387127220630646,
-0.1090669333934784,
-0.8808048963546753,
-0.904404878616333,
-0.33805960416793823,
0.3155044913291931,
-0.46093302965164185,
-0.38337400555610657,
0.36828458309173584,
-0.3213850259780884,
0.3535938858985901,
0.6136398315429688,
-0.45599809288978577,
-0.06252385675907135,
0.7754441499710083,
0.3540792465209961,
-0.0294296033680439,
-0.38901424407958984,
-0.8053203225135803,
0.703250527381897,
-0.41304928064346313,
0.8102843761444092,
-0.8152402639389038,
-0.23821887373924255,
-0.1310432255268097,
-0.3890789747238159,
-0.15154621005058289,
-0.5156273245811462,
0.6324265003204346,
-0.7748779058456421,
0.23550596833229065,
-0.28245770931243896,
-0.4247601628303528,
-0.5417035222053528,
0.5730952620506287,
-0.540823757648468,
0.7327540516853333,
-0.12431850284337997,
-0.8213403224945068,
0.8261343836784363,
-0.4228114187717438,
-0.44847843050956726,
-0.11778140068054199,
-0.5140715837478638,
-0.3469270169734955,
0.4334867000579834,
0.3295385539531708,
0.5009265542030334,
-0.30125629901885986,
0.45453065633773804,
-0.16007035970687866,
0.09063861519098282,
-0.16035301983356476,
-0.5311254262924194,
0.28710436820983887,
0.08919239789247513,
0.22112618386745453,
0.14143602550029755,
-0.7604830861091614,
0.18213725090026855,
0.07520683109760284,
-0.6894831657409668,
-0.6960639357566833,
0.1876721829175949,
-0.3112938404083252,
0.25620755553245544,
0.13435052335262299,
-0.3694734275341034,
0.2130962759256363,
-0.2469794601202011,
-0.09097900986671448,
0.3983300030231476,
0.25677067041397095,
0.5509986281394958,
-0.28779083490371704,
0.4796094596385956,
0.3257763981819153,
0.14703115820884705,
-0.35026079416275024,
-0.45762231945991516,
-0.6060446500778198,
-0.40570956468582153,
0.23548278212547302,
0.2587948441505432,
-0.981907308101654,
-0.17152397334575653,
-0.37808719277381897,
-0.3715750277042389,
-0.8373895883560181,
0.04473164677619934,
0.6522369384765625,
0.716054379940033,
0.48308366537094116,
-0.2692684233188629,
-0.5788633823394775,
-1.0638985633850098,
-0.8103824257850647,
0.10044076293706894,
0.21722853183746338,
0.7430106997489929,
0.3007666766643524,
-0.10471596568822861,
0.5546323657035828,
-0.6170506477355957,
-0.3131134808063507,
-0.4781894385814667,
-0.04016201198101044,
0.24193845689296722,
0.28063350915908813,
0.47652360796928406,
-1.4538781642913818,
-0.4995730221271515,
0.1279146522283554,
-0.6822223663330078,
0.17630723118782043,
0.07569027692079544,
-0.4337620139122009,
0.19983018934726715,
0.2746753692626953,
-0.4767661988735199,
0.48773983120918274,
0.4420969486236572,
-0.15559177100658417,
0.5401743650436401,
-0.260161429643631,
0.564215362071991,
-1.286299228668213,
0.09556463360786438,
-0.13625697791576385,
-0.22045010328292847,
-0.6073645353317261,
0.1408442109823227,
0.3208296597003937,
0.3071547746658325,
-0.6184521913528442,
0.602169930934906,
-0.5940229296684265,
-0.2025214284658432,
-0.18373353779315948,
0.1914697289466858,
0.6638949513435364,
0.40361467003822327,
-0.03650654852390289,
0.7555378079414368,
0.27808335423469543,
-0.6894053816795349,
-0.16982725262641907,
0.17399027943611145,
-0.34504014253616333,
0.7914915680885315,
-0.32056114077568054,
-0.1268550306558609,
-0.5374327301979065,
0.2820412516593933,
-0.4851045608520508,
-0.7170132994651794,
-0.060223598033189774,
-0.4154943823814392,
0.5666003823280334,
-0.5212281942367554,
-0.41702935099601746,
0.016794199123978615,
-0.37213173508644104,
0.6188862323760986,
0.09279024600982666,
-0.5607109665870667,
0.9962829947471619,
0.6893249154090881,
0.06297488510608673,
-1.2227877378463745,
-0.31749340891838074,
0.01721237599849701,
-0.29751676321029663,
-0.45124250650405884,
0.4539891183376312,
0.2246718406677246,
-0.39411118626594543,
-0.20149792730808258,
-0.16625428199768066,
-0.19314531981945038,
-0.1620306372642517,
-0.12190189212560654,
0.15555357933044434,
-0.16127599775791168,
0.07808493077754974,
0.4053618013858795,
0.0570569783449173,
-0.08761519938707352,
-0.30702248215675354,
0.5432405471801758,
0.23234649002552032,
-0.5675004124641418,
-0.012035024352371693,
0.5912060737609863,
0.6286506652832031,
-0.5841689705848694,
0.8362414240837097,
0.2283383011817932,
-0.34762659668922424,
-0.21419799327850342,
-0.8721731305122375,
0.03756590560078621,
-0.4256023168563843,
0.46285611391067505,
-0.5912362337112427,
-0.9066335558891296,
0.14423935115337372,
-0.2982175052165985,
0.13321760296821594,
0.3797908127307892,
0.5794907808303833,
0.08261967450380325,
0.8961508870124817,
0.7460076212882996,
0.04092632234096527,
0.2538619637489319,
-0.12278018146753311,
0.23686887323856354,
-1.3870214223861694,
-0.46406182646751404,
-0.38462474942207336,
-0.21128679811954498,
-0.21235284209251404,
-0.7551582455635071,
0.8507730960845947,
0.2946036159992218,
-0.16904255747795105,
-0.13649524748325348,
-0.5312244296073914,
0.6036140322685242,
0.42082729935646057,
0.06274406611919403,
0.6326856017112732,
-0.011966249905526638,
-0.254727840423584,
-0.2176504135131836,
-0.839942216873169,
-0.18850578367710114,
1.2290186882019043,
-0.1728930026292801,
0.5737859606742859,
0.3653174340724945,
0.7637243270874023,
-0.1769854724407196,
0.2152872532606125,
-0.7345666885375977,
0.25142839550971985,
-0.19666923582553864,
-0.7587125897407532,
0.010556754656136036,
-0.43663209676742554,
-0.8318958878517151,
0.9383865594863892,
-0.1944045126438141,
-0.3986080586910248,
0.24305768311023712,
0.2136792093515396,
-0.40288031101226807,
0.36990195512771606,
-0.7280416488647461,
0.651397705078125,
-0.17427970468997955,
-0.6348890662193298,
-0.32765287160873413,
-0.5767707824707031,
0.5762813687324524,
-0.2550734877586365,
0.39008229970932007,
0.04150142893195152,
-0.16004228591918945,
0.34822767972946167,
-0.29462653398513794,
0.5341269373893738,
-0.40807297825813293,
-0.1085311621427536,
0.24538910388946533,
0.08603456616401672,
0.2864956855773926,
0.20400655269622803,
-0.27519842982292175,
-0.18217936158180237,
-0.31116288900375366,
-0.16619062423706055,
-0.6649675965309143,
0.687499463558197,
-0.26084092259407043,
-0.7436877489089966,
-0.2985495328903198,
-0.8259152770042419,
-0.4033519923686981,
0.5136314034461975,
0.08036936074495316,
0.4343431293964386,
0.035967666655778885,
0.3146435022354126,
0.8613498210906982,
-0.49356624484062195,
-0.09513208270072937,
0.6126870512962341,
-0.4645976126194,
-0.2428249716758728,
0.7185468077659607,
0.018495768308639526,
0.23775191605091095,
0.7206308245658875,
0.06981991231441498,
-0.2115970104932785,
-0.576047956943512,
-0.7288552522659302,
0.18712975084781647,
-0.5857310891151428,
-0.37309855222702026,
-1.0718324184417725,
-0.11176720261573792,
-0.4918293356895447,
-0.17192251980304718,
-0.47011566162109375,
-0.45595118403434753,
0.2678057551383972,
0.0922887772321701,
0.41772961616516113,
0.581146240234375,
0.0041701835580170155,
0.01625053957104683,
-0.7676252722740173,
0.671607255935669,
0.11395950615406036,
0.4287666976451874,
-0.0749235600233078,
-0.4765317142009735,
-0.16673697531223297,
-0.11199156939983368,
-0.30050310492515564,
-0.520369291305542,
0.556520938873291,
0.264038622379303,
0.640252947807312,
0.1862991452217102,
0.019603518769145012,
0.9547494053840637,
-0.9149060845375061,
0.40698477625846863,
0.03978651389479637,
-0.3747757375240326,
0.7117210626602173,
-0.32421863079071045,
0.0253746397793293,
0.631473958492279,
0.2751711905002594,
-0.3932948410511017,
-0.16813750565052032,
-0.5398040413856506,
-0.9550176858901978,
0.5089912414550781,
-0.1622956395149231,
-0.019114907830953598,
0.26221176981925964,
0.6047943234443665,
0.24607916176319122,
0.5237264633178711,
-0.1512123942375183,
-0.25541648268699646,
0.07623514533042908,
-0.05030205100774765,
0.08824960142374039,
-0.33178332448005676,
-0.23979942500591278,
-0.32214677333831787,
0.49530622363090515,
-0.254827082157135,
0.10438606888055801,
0.31360048055648804,
0.02871120162308216,
0.20558613538742065,
0.45140063762664795,
0.4427124261856079,
0.5872541069984436,
0.09631355106830597,
0.0733698382973671,
0.017400797456502914,
-0.567205011844635,
-0.14246346056461334,
0.03566155955195427,
-0.056046564131975174,
-0.06160305440425873,
0.04422416165471077,
0.5244158506393433,
0.26183417439460754,
-0.5036777257919312,
0.6396788954734802,
-0.10531311482191086,
-0.2721152603626251,
-0.4386821389198303,
0.14840205013751984,
0.039093323051929474,
0.34776854515075684,
0.3440381586551666,
0.3498910665512085,
0.5904422998428345,
-0.2544197738170624,
0.2679590582847595,
0.5299274325370789,
-0.18401280045509338,
0.08023308962583542,
1.0019782781600952,
-0.13282990455627441,
0.20586144924163818,
0.25758519768714905,
0.09938368201255798,
-0.34834229946136475,
0.24825185537338257,
0.2546704113483429,
0.5435206890106201,
-0.11104897409677505,
-0.05472707003355026,
0.29594287276268005,
0.008293169550597668,
-0.19014795124530792,
0.49122846126556396,
-0.15904048085212708,
-0.7545399069786072,
-0.8020321130752563,
-0.8858249187469482,
-0.38792458176612854,
-0.045167773962020874,
-0.8296883702278137,
0.14284327626228333,
-0.09517953544855118,
0.15552093088626862,
0.061341919004917145,
-0.16282494366168976,
-0.4301542043685913,
0.22593766450881958,
-0.25969424843788147,
0.7132039070129395,
-0.10020747780799866,
1.0943288803100586,
0.7389089465141296,
-0.17122910916805267,
-0.789310872554779,
0.0016489640111103654,
0.25165238976478577,
-0.7829679846763611,
0.40515971183776855,
0.0640634223818779,
-0.5770487785339355,
-0.13661229610443115,
-0.46699556708335876,
-0.8094378113746643,
1.0620543956756592,
0.3221515119075775,
-0.2930344045162201,
0.0485408753156662,
-0.10191358625888824,
0.37954607605934143,
-0.3571806252002716,
-0.18454095721244812,
0.5298364758491516,
0.4595414698123932,
0.15024042129516602,
-0.8103629350662231,
-0.35707810521125793,
-0.3128879964351654,
-0.176673024892807,
0.5968157052993774,
-0.6077591180801392,
0.756653904914856,
-0.43510738015174866,
0.17019321024417877,
-0.24093270301818848,
0.5564833879470825,
0.7651157975196838,
0.40673282742500305,
0.20352359116077423,
0.6899000406265259,
0.7217459082603455,
0.20805363357067108,
1.4685178995132446,
-0.3113270103931427,
0.053973570466041565,
1.282961368560791,
-0.37176862359046936,
0.9705612659454346,
0.7211770415306091,
0.168754443526268,
0.36113548278808594,
-0.0736740455031395,
0.5075880289077759,
0.5546427369117737,
-0.1040051281452179,
-0.4254639744758606,
-0.3682209253311157,
-0.2069617211818695,
-0.28635263442993164,
0.5163782835006714,
0.7017977237701416,
-0.47950172424316406,
0.002200834220275283,
-0.03622222691774368,
0.2997283637523651,
0.190309077501297,
-0.408086359500885,
0.8281468749046326,
0.12663349509239197,
-0.7632826566696167,
0.43241366744041443,
0.0295708067715168,
0.6859423518180847,
-0.38345080614089966,
-0.3034444749355316,
0.01745927892625332,
0.3720472455024719,
-0.2255888730287552,
-0.8229508996009827,
0.4465707838535309,
-0.00634522270411253,
-0.5253169536590576,
-0.36815452575683594,
1.0344144105911255,
-0.2702323794364929,
-0.5298997163772583,
0.311736524105072,
0.9238108396530151,
0.1661600023508072,
-0.39416787028312683,
-0.42960211634635925,
-0.14256499707698822,
0.012124433182179928,
-0.42814767360687256,
0.44681990146636963,
0.9416703581809998,
-0.03794651851058006,
0.6211541295051575,
0.411037415266037,
0.06405236572027206,
0.28650689125061035,
0.2095680832862854,
1.0045114755630493,
-0.586992621421814,
-0.021922064945101738,
-0.4826589524745941,
0.5904630422592163,
-0.2950020432472229,
-0.2192002683877945,
0.7403078675270081,
0.8793042302131653,
0.7931553721427917,
0.021795427426695824,
0.9338197708129883,
-0.21843339502811432,
1.0400737524032593,
-0.49815982580184937,
1.0627959966659546,
-1.0902458429336548,
0.11009806394577026,
-0.18247714638710022,
-0.6648049354553223,
-0.5853583216667175,
0.45262575149536133,
-0.2823405861854553,
0.1330685019493103,
0.4805554151535034,
0.7548109292984009,
-0.16706785559654236,
-0.3618234097957611,
0.5253673791885376,
0.1842910200357437,
0.22553801536560059,
0.40659669041633606,
0.5830562114715576,
-0.5173584818840027,
0.5853764414787292,
-0.22675354778766632,
-0.08816495537757874,
-0.16713176667690277,
-0.6381577849388123,
-0.5242570638656616,
-0.5379955768585205,
0.12205798178911209,
-0.1422942727804184,
-0.017232265323400497,
0.4287932515144348,
0.588955819606781,
-0.3550010919570923,
0.14703767001628876,
0.28035667538642883,
0.11917754262685776,
-0.049607258290052414,
-0.210094153881073,
0.26518678665161133,
-0.432058185338974,
-0.7423728108406067,
0.576029360294342,
0.4469381868839264,
-0.5522953867912292,
-0.0984991192817688,
-0.004493693821132183,
-0.26112380623817444,
-0.02989540621638298,
0.9973478317260742,
0.018162032589316368,
-0.632605254650116,
-0.17793753743171692,
0.012351000681519508,
-0.046845417469739914,
0.36647969484329224,
0.8956648111343384,
-0.9979887008666992,
0.41814061999320984,
0.3892413079738617,
0.7021640539169312,
0.47468945384025574,
0.161714106798172,
0.6157822608947754,
-0.8850612640380859,
0.19381923973560333,
0.30542999505996704,
0.5654579997062683,
0.2708894908428192,
-0.3768520951271057,
0.463367223739624,
0.015006929636001587,
-0.6422484517097473,
-0.5890745520591736,
0.4568667411804199,
-0.8408722281455994,
-0.304288774728775,
1.1993365287780762,
0.18364299833774567,
-0.20348313450813293,
-0.3034385144710541,
-0.3389924168586731,
0.03843790665268898,
-0.3332105875015259,
0.5802446007728577,
0.4028705060482025,
-0.3040536642074585,
-0.22794094681739807,
-1.067079782485962,
0.5184755921363831,
0.45692288875579834,
-0.8018121123313904,
0.10732770711183548,
0.858164370059967,
0.1238570362329483,
0.21412226557731628,
0.8118161559104919,
-0.5775476098060608,
0.17811672389507294,
-0.08716119080781937,
0.03246178478002548,
0.16908365488052368,
-0.7550475001335144,
-0.00016179461090359837,
0.4363625943660736,
-0.033976394683122635,
0.0792762041091919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12872v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12872v1
|
LLM-R2: A Large Language Model Enhanced Rule-based Rewrite System for Boosting Query Efficiency
| 2024-04-19T13:17:07 | 2024-04-19T13:17:07 |
Zhaodonghui Li, Haitao Yuan, Huiming Wang, Gao Cong, Lidong Bing
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.CL
|
Query rewrite, which aims to generate more efficient queries by altering a
SQL query's structure without changing the query result, has been an important
research problem. In order to maintain equivalence between the rewritten query
and the original one during rewriting, traditional query rewrite methods always
rewrite the queries following certain rewrite rules. However, some problems
still remain. Firstly, existing methods of finding the optimal choice or
sequence of rewrite rules are still limited and the process always costs a lot
of resources. Methods involving discovering new rewrite rules typically require
complicated proofs of structural logic or extensive user interactions.
Secondly, current query rewrite methods usually rely highly on DBMS cost
estimators which are often not accurate. In this paper, we address these
problems by proposing a novel method of query rewrite named LLM-R2, adopting a
large language model (LLM) to propose possible rewrite rules for a database
rewrite system. To further improve the inference ability of LLM in recommending
rewrite rules, we train a contrastive model by curriculum to learn query
representations and select effective query demonstrations for the LLM.
Experimental results have shown that our method can significantly improve the
query execution efficiency and outperform the baseline methods. In addition,
our method enjoys high robustness across different datasets.
|
[
-0.09558366984128952,
-1.129051685333252,
0.28878721594810486,
0.02635185793042183,
-0.5074734687805176,
-0.19126704335212708,
-0.19592973589897156,
-0.2858162522315979,
0.46370795369148254,
0.9104714393615723,
-0.8359524607658386,
-0.4378203749656677,
-0.21614980697631836,
0.029031826183199883,
-0.14633570611476898,
0.5350928902626038,
0.17473480105400085,
0.20434649288654327,
-0.14598628878593445,
0.05001121759414673,
-0.47922399640083313,
-0.3538738191127777,
-0.8230346441268921,
-0.32367226481437683,
0.5886773467063904,
0.5816963911056519,
0.499881386756897,
0.6670563817024231,
0.5914413332939148,
0.20000627636909485,
-0.10479151457548141,
0.4901820719242096,
-0.7904998660087585,
0.4891003668308258,
-0.40245723724365234,
-0.9511330127716064,
-0.6146188974380493,
-0.4228839576244354,
0.44104987382888794,
0.5117335915565491,
-0.47363442182540894,
-0.013102453202009201,
-0.008240411058068275,
0.9815701842308044,
-0.4703907370567322,
0.060146305710077286,
-1.1619954109191895,
-0.1362842619419098,
0.025399941951036453,
-0.4504760801792145,
-0.5362749695777893,
-0.6693933010101318,
-0.24749648571014404,
-0.5038815140724182,
0.24224461615085602,
0.3602895736694336,
0.6077185869216919,
0.18451586365699768,
-0.3868600130081177,
-0.1876169592142105,
-0.260129451751709,
0.7340620756149292,
-0.7232555150985718,
0.48158159852027893,
0.1941693127155304,
0.6026449203491211,
-0.3564772307872772,
-0.6515741348266602,
-0.42162784934043884,
-0.16213999688625336,
-0.05694319307804108,
-0.12694460153579712,
-0.05504315346479416,
-0.20208115875720978,
0.1986672580242157,
0.07488684356212616,
-0.432295024394989,
0.23312492668628693,
-0.1814430207014084,
-0.08836155384778976,
0.6505162715911865,
0.2843828797340393,
-0.024306265637278557,
-0.10922729969024658,
-0.3794041872024536,
0.0691109299659729,
-1.1541489362716675,
-0.4487382173538208,
0.3646664023399353,
0.3833998739719391,
0.2746503949165344,
0.6638697981834412,
-0.35337597131729126,
0.5837864279747009,
-0.06955525279045105,
-0.16257748007774353,
0.02581535279750824,
-0.3485989570617676,
-0.06909053027629852,
-0.22543609142303467,
0.23750777542591095,
0.9399033784866333,
0.3974514901638031,
-0.15469029545783997,
-0.24534933269023895,
-0.20646227896213531,
0.14068390429019928,
-1.2035268545150757,
0.08654079586267471,
0.061752934008836746,
-0.5187091827392578,
-0.09727278351783752,
-0.17095820605754852,
-0.9503412246704102,
-0.32005953788757324,
-0.32990553975105286,
0.3263782858848572,
-0.3477350175380707,
-0.3928472101688385,
0.05766543373465538,
0.1561378538608551,
0.5951752066612244,
0.5063540935516357,
-0.8360465168952942,
0.30755874514579773,
0.9873421788215637,
0.6543286442756653,
-0.10676951706409454,
0.005862817168235779,
-0.3403308689594269,
0.24050459265708923,
-0.34757912158966064,
0.9519685506820679,
-0.6671296954154968,
-0.5314416289329529,
0.03972228243947029,
0.12048906832933426,
0.09195912629365921,
-0.7553327083587646,
0.6587210893630981,
-1.026394009590149,
0.014779188670217991,
-0.29050758481025696,
-0.7782228589057922,
-0.15130674839019775,
0.039280641824007034,
-0.4925234019756317,
0.873028039932251,
-0.010734625160694122,
-0.4378911852836609,
0.4035686254501343,
-0.26942136883735657,
-0.615739643573761,
-0.0034926459193229675,
0.028611058369278908,
-0.6895310282707214,
0.11184267699718475,
0.19296471774578094,
0.030531125143170357,
-0.5317238569259644,
0.26190775632858276,
-0.18371474742889404,
-0.6190890073776245,
-0.03589165210723877,
-0.2488066852092743,
0.5364677906036377,
0.05211268737912178,
-0.23124383389949799,
0.0810045599937439,
-0.4579240083694458,
0.33684486150741577,
0.2893860638141632,
-0.5839818120002747,
-0.3121492564678192,
0.07993140816688538,
-0.16228702664375305,
-0.09643787145614624,
0.1051526889204979,
-0.26585566997528076,
0.5450204014778137,
-0.5825133919715881,
0.2994793951511383,
0.5101808309555054,
0.152055561542511,
0.39852583408355713,
-0.2546733319759369,
0.5532306432723999,
-0.40294575691223145,
-0.052397727966308594,
-0.1352986842393875,
-0.34721285104751587,
-0.9215946793556213,
-0.1695922613143921,
0.18944913148880005,
0.5755189657211304,
-0.5196447968482971,
0.2774333357810974,
-0.22925429046154022,
-0.38086196780204773,
-0.6519950032234192,
0.19972680509090424,
0.4978771507740021,
0.5175885558128357,
0.46319836378097534,
0.1382533758878708,
-0.7820457816123962,
-0.9998192191123962,
-0.6412346363067627,
0.048036787658929825,
0.1501150131225586,
0.705491840839386,
0.4524588882923126,
-0.17139875888824463,
0.4094766080379486,
-0.9219823479652405,
-0.2078114002943039,
-0.35787123441696167,
-0.3707007169723511,
0.253980427980423,
0.424357146024704,
0.2203468382358551,
-0.5148489475250244,
-0.49246832728385925,
-0.35248473286628723,
-0.4284212291240692,
-0.2545583248138428,
0.15570034086704254,
-0.5516007542610168,
0.417087197303772,
0.7739852666854858,
-0.24576221406459808,
0.16080814599990845,
-0.15841171145439148,
-0.29035475850105286,
0.49206510186195374,
-0.41944968700408936,
0.24582991003990173,
-0.9478533864021301,
-0.330318421125412,
-0.11004634946584702,
-0.15334729850292206,
-0.24355757236480713,
0.33603912591934204,
0.2585242688655853,
0.08305308222770691,
-0.2142295241355896,
0.36216577887535095,
-0.5978931188583374,
-0.10214046388864517,
-0.5231401920318604,
0.2193773090839386,
0.12205999344587326,
0.4756072163581848,
-0.017706846818327904,
0.8795264363288879,
0.40659573674201965,
-0.4900859594345093,
0.32315531373023987,
0.23482711613178253,
-0.5045180320739746,
0.7307329773902893,
-0.6789311170578003,
0.3197903335094452,
-0.17775049805641174,
0.4929678440093994,
-0.9692951440811157,
-0.053601570427417755,
0.08991355448961258,
-0.24333003163337708,
0.42475709319114685,
-0.41927146911621094,
-0.5564893484115601,
-0.04999754577875137,
-0.3229568600654602,
0.1496935784816742,
0.5967519879341125,
-0.6743391156196594,
0.4110155403614044,
0.25004062056541443,
-0.14495159685611725,
-0.4974849224090576,
-0.7849520444869995,
0.2801225781440735,
-0.37092700600624084,
-0.6959699392318726,
0.4544122815132141,
0.25018298625946045,
-0.10232989490032196,
-0.23991410434246063,
0.006110126152634621,
-0.04114589840173721,
-0.01586112380027771,
-0.038439180701971054,
0.23018521070480347,
-0.4464685618877411,
0.09818921238183975,
0.25461483001708984,
-0.042640432715415955,
0.09219729900360107,
-0.04819241538643837,
0.5419335961341858,
0.3955877721309662,
-0.3261657953262329,
-0.8021981716156006,
0.4718174338340759,
0.4031734764575958,
-0.3165987432003021,
0.7079852223396301,
0.22628004848957062,
-0.11983037739992142,
-0.5293178558349609,
-0.722670316696167,
-0.5656140446662903,
-0.44948965311050415,
0.8176988959312439,
-0.6236252188682556,
-0.8165602684020996,
0.1165594831109047,
-0.37413933873176575,
-0.004383909981697798,
0.2978399991989136,
0.5705856680870056,
0.13227804005146027,
0.7355760931968689,
0.40444010496139526,
0.3209957480430603,
0.4641515612602234,
-0.18841229379177094,
0.06555838137865067,
-0.8499383926391602,
-0.4759841859340668,
-0.7097660899162292,
-0.13792887330055237,
-0.511335551738739,
-0.786169171333313,
0.09675244241952896,
0.2633708417415619,
-0.3910914957523346,
0.2881646752357483,
-0.37647730112075806,
0.6614550352096558,
0.4243840277194977,
0.43287330865859985,
0.4131847620010376,
0.35760873556137085,
-0.10717061161994934,
-0.22888962924480438,
-0.5855576992034912,
-0.3851848542690277,
1.2428011894226074,
-0.017214173451066017,
0.9778961539268494,
0.6153557896614075,
0.4940803349018097,
0.2975090742111206,
0.29288870096206665,
-0.7633745670318604,
0.6574323177337646,
-0.04261479899287224,
-0.5889107584953308,
-0.30261772871017456,
-0.3572809100151062,
-0.7111846804618835,
0.6324333548545837,
-0.31856462359428406,
-0.3784072995185852,
-0.003633344080299139,
0.1821335256099701,
0.09354335069656372,
0.358835369348526,
-0.7728061676025391,
0.45423147082328796,
-0.05959416180849075,
-0.8576990962028503,
-0.6391075849533081,
-0.3685992956161499,
0.3875499665737152,
-0.038361646234989166,
0.12189606577157974,
-0.0021512850653380156,
-0.32535433769226074,
0.5273619294166565,
-0.6284005641937256,
0.678604006767273,
-0.3664809465408325,
-0.1513897031545639,
0.35971799492836,
0.408210426568985,
0.9791202545166016,
0.1281047761440277,
-0.6151499152183533,
-0.36934924125671387,
-0.30423805117607117,
-0.13944125175476074,
-0.766560971736908,
0.8303996920585632,
-0.24368275701999664,
-0.9719829559326172,
0.021207379177212715,
-0.38379254937171936,
-0.03537125140428543,
0.18678957223892212,
-0.21498575806617737,
0.36460036039352417,
-0.13545779883861542,
0.42151886224746704,
0.49362918734550476,
-0.3239210844039917,
-0.1567433476448059,
0.9854546189308167,
-0.2905687093734741,
-0.3593652844429016,
0.6147496700286865,
-0.08081654459238052,
0.2933366298675537,
0.6687159538269043,
0.03583833947777748,
-0.7326259613037109,
-0.591083288192749,
-0.31136754155158997,
0.48965442180633545,
-0.6439684629440308,
-0.2818402945995331,
-0.6486753821372986,
0.2917589545249939,
-0.5289071202278137,
-0.14574028551578522,
-0.08424627780914307,
-0.46668297052383423,
0.004031364340335131,
0.06795796006917953,
0.39435386657714844,
0.2778613269329071,
0.21738901734352112,
0.1370200514793396,
-0.06421627849340439,
0.323864221572876,
0.2094569057226181,
0.5711548328399658,
0.2011980563402176,
-0.8097850680351257,
0.07771681249141693,
-0.36917853355407715,
-0.1588079035282135,
-0.6791346669197083,
0.22648204863071442,
0.30242931842803955,
0.5094254016876221,
0.3160223364830017,
0.06415221095085144,
0.6842684745788574,
-0.7942295074462891,
0.21939551830291748,
-0.075128935277462,
-0.436154305934906,
0.6217555999755859,
-0.14814960956573486,
-0.13101065158843994,
0.50106281042099,
0.01714821718633175,
-0.14586445689201355,
-0.04038955643773079,
-0.20475275814533234,
-0.8794631958007812,
0.45129451155662537,
-0.0165749192237854,
0.16803355515003204,
0.09845301508903503,
0.7836326360702515,
0.048904817551374435,
0.007773376535624266,
-0.2553584575653076,
-0.3452644348144531,
-0.0008523333817720413,
0.20958903431892395,
0.026789261028170586,
-0.8337568640708923,
0.16803289949893951,
-0.1654089093208313,
0.8208011388778687,
0.08103406429290771,
0.11290694028139114,
-0.022013386711478233,
0.02923956699669361,
-0.10591696202754974,
0.5094813108444214,
0.44513288140296936,
0.5011120438575745,
-0.47904759645462036,
-0.11969637870788574,
0.34377267956733704,
-0.050723928958177567,
0.1316978633403778,
-0.102690190076828,
-0.24588339030742645,
-0.2104802131652832,
0.13326016068458557,
0.485561728477478,
0.31971725821495056,
-0.6342265009880066,
0.2949990928173065,
0.0348471961915493,
-0.3665187656879425,
-0.08305121958255768,
0.34918126463890076,
0.6400025486946106,
0.2665097117424011,
0.06634047627449036,
-0.5426414608955383,
0.16328026354312897,
-0.40380334854125977,
0.27031561732292175,
0.6493246555328369,
-0.046558815985918045,
0.20555123686790466,
0.7237654328346252,
0.3450537621974945,
-0.5594997406005859,
0.5212503671646118,
0.18908876180648804,
-0.27768993377685547,
0.4809347093105316,
0.9008902907371521,
0.39662182331085205,
-0.26768940687179565,
-0.11240288615226746,
0.6612647771835327,
0.33072251081466675,
-0.14437662065029144,
0.5226402282714844,
0.013194305822253227,
-0.451478511095047,
-0.24887417256832123,
-0.5974275469779968,
-0.4572335481643677,
-0.11988528817892075,
-0.6359720230102539,
0.44139528274536133,
-0.21512429416179657,
0.15327046811580658,
0.07858572155237198,
0.12585966289043427,
-0.24224244058132172,
0.20262247323989868,
-0.5431213974952698,
1.1707171201705933,
-0.39918288588523865,
0.7993245720863342,
0.5490346550941467,
-0.31898507475852966,
-0.6343668699264526,
-0.2647929787635803,
0.02321062609553337,
-0.9203750491142273,
0.5927116870880127,
-0.013095375150442123,
-0.481524795293808,
0.024025514721870422,
-0.3474927544593811,
-0.6725759506225586,
1.1583760976791382,
0.5087991952896118,
-0.9131709337234497,
0.03380278870463371,
-0.10803600400686264,
0.43448731303215027,
-0.5418460369110107,
0.3326764702796936,
0.4835457503795624,
0.4387390911579132,
0.3846914768218994,
-0.36808887124061584,
0.32719922065734863,
0.02830515243113041,
0.08852887898683548,
0.28416311740875244,
-0.7053818702697754,
0.49538755416870117,
-0.6784378886222839,
-0.04490511491894722,
0.39341139793395996,
0.5926609635353088,
0.35308754444122314,
0.217766672372818,
0.37136200070381165,
0.4245242774486542,
0.5729441046714783,
-0.013889321126043797,
1.0010852813720703,
-0.2510570287704468,
0.37566903233528137,
1.4352672100067139,
-0.6760516166687012,
1.1416468620300293,
0.4279470443725586,
-0.4304029941558838,
0.5025939345359802,
0.21200832724571228,
-0.22437050938606262,
0.43284550309181213,
0.69027179479599,
-0.11917457729578018,
-0.5059168338775635,
-0.05865628644824028,
-0.46265631914138794,
0.4094705283641815,
0.11765594780445099,
-0.5558231472969055,
-0.30034035444259644,
-0.6286394000053406,
0.2892807126045227,
0.2941051721572876,
-0.060904476791620255,
0.8044614791870117,
0.017008056864142418,
-0.8198184967041016,
0.7699234485626221,
0.2843285799026489,
0.7281770706176758,
-0.4680248498916626,
-0.17237846553325653,
-0.5535440444946289,
0.3635251820087433,
-0.2306010127067566,
-0.5049262642860413,
0.21598796546459198,
-0.01150936633348465,
-0.24295885860919952,
0.11744485050439835,
0.6846538186073303,
-0.3842483162879944,
-0.5265976786613464,
0.2773855924606323,
0.510676383972168,
0.35278427600860596,
-0.08018841594457626,
-0.6726462244987488,
-0.09589637815952301,
0.27915677428245544,
-0.25290095806121826,
0.34852051734924316,
0.4286256432533264,
0.06729940325021744,
0.8340516686439514,
0.5756366848945618,
0.11821752041578293,
-0.32935789227485657,
0.31500521302223206,
0.8617275953292847,
-0.7831169962882996,
-0.5604889392852783,
-0.7813758254051208,
0.08768727630376816,
-0.12734200060367584,
0.1830504983663559,
0.6561654210090637,
0.9085834622383118,
0.4622243642807007,
0.0648030936717987,
0.522946298122406,
0.41286227107048035,
0.8713496923446655,
-0.6496717929840088,
0.6318975687026978,
-0.8265389800071716,
0.6441466212272644,
-0.1513742059469223,
-0.9982172250747681,
-0.45454129576683044,
0.3124734163284302,
-0.21038484573364258,
0.17938505113124847,
0.41937893629074097,
1.6068620681762695,
0.07502022385597229,
0.0035931786987930536,
0.28146418929100037,
0.23428954184055328,
0.25726133584976196,
0.4801878333091736,
0.37489181756973267,
-0.14508666098117828,
0.6525557637214661,
0.1559799760580063,
-0.13942088186740875,
-0.6936761140823364,
-0.6852279305458069,
-0.7554370164871216,
-0.08112842589616776,
-0.35546520352363586,
-0.6132321953773499,
0.47187867760658264,
0.8152039647102356,
0.511119544506073,
-0.6679078340530396,
-0.17841270565986633,
-0.057590190321207047,
0.24170616269111633,
-0.06242315098643303,
-0.24178488552570343,
0.8184210658073425,
-0.1427469104528427,
-0.5470382571220398,
0.5233527421951294,
0.16963738203048706,
-0.2081652730703354,
-0.04707309231162071,
-0.05932154878973961,
-0.37730422616004944,
0.20825502276420593,
0.5781186819076538,
-0.028503691777586937,
-0.772093653678894,
0.03599992021918297,
-0.16490145027637482,
-0.0932968258857727,
0.11764924973249435,
0.7826671600341797,
-0.6641450524330139,
0.2637875974178314,
0.28340044617652893,
0.5722541213035583,
0.4598953127861023,
0.16998928785324097,
0.36409738659858704,
-0.23981261253356934,
-0.09271145612001419,
-0.06396625190973282,
0.35061439871788025,
0.24533018469810486,
-0.43904995918273926,
0.5645014047622681,
0.15703535079956055,
-0.5125681161880493,
-0.7146271467208862,
0.45156562328338623,
-0.751239001750946,
-0.4330853521823883,
1.478614330291748,
0.04585499316453934,
-0.08516819030046463,
0.05695026367902756,
-0.4811379313468933,
0.18966273963451385,
-0.51300048828125,
0.5656383037567139,
0.055912382900714874,
-0.1352214813232422,
-0.2521878778934479,
-0.4057081639766693,
0.3310762047767639,
0.4585517346858978,
-0.6545480489730835,
0.3529878556728363,
0.6130233407020569,
0.6625579595565796,
-0.5740154385566711,
0.4870816469192505,
-0.3486339747905731,
0.08219138532876968,
0.04738009721040726,
-0.17874492704868317,
-0.14236877858638763,
-0.0009958695154637098,
-0.08541212230920792,
0.39012834429740906,
0.10986952483654022,
0.11654668301343918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12866v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12866v1
|
How Does the Textual Information Affect the Retrieval of Multimodal In-Context Learning?
| 2024-04-19T13:05:37 | 2024-04-19T13:05:37 |
Yang Luo, Zangwei Zheng, Zirui Zhu, Yang You
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
The increase in parameter size of multimodal large language models (MLLMs)
introduces significant capabilities, particularly in-context learning, where
MLLMs enhance task performance without updating pre-trained parameters. This
effectiveness, however, hinges on the appropriate selection of in-context
examples, a process that is currently biased towards visual data, overlooking
textual information. Furthermore, the area of supervised retrievers for MLLMs,
crucial for optimal in-context example selection, continues to be
uninvestigated. Our study offers an in-depth evaluation of the impact of
textual information on the unsupervised selection of in-context examples in
multimodal contexts, uncovering a notable sensitivity of retriever performance
to the employed modalities. Responding to this, we introduce a novel supervised
MLLM-retriever MSIER that employs a neural network to select examples that
enhance multimodal in-context learning efficiency. This approach is validated
through extensive testing across three distinct tasks, demonstrating the
method's effectiveness. Additionally, we investigate the influence of
modalities on our supervised retrieval method's training and pinpoint factors
contributing to our model's success. This exploration paves the way for future
advancements, highlighting the potential for refined in-context learning in
MLLMs through the strategic use of multimodal data.
|
[
-0.1468496024608612,
-0.7174393534660339,
0.6104137897491455,
0.07649386674165726,
-0.3593166768550873,
-0.3807506859302521,
-0.4410080015659332,
-0.29653918743133545,
-0.130149245262146,
0.313825398683548,
-0.26704931259155273,
-0.22308853268623352,
-0.7094088196754456,
0.1687653809785843,
-0.3704988360404968,
0.9926087856292725,
0.2510543763637543,
0.16201433539390564,
-0.5401514768600464,
-0.19014741480350494,
-0.3533785939216614,
-0.8440242409706116,
-0.4225284159183502,
-0.26936039328575134,
0.8071779608726501,
0.22707349061965942,
0.38324403762817383,
0.4387831687927246,
0.45438575744628906,
0.3617500960826874,
-0.17202787101268768,
0.3239557147026062,
-0.4550008475780487,
0.466596782207489,
0.044973552227020264,
-0.35432466864585876,
0.12212087213993073,
-0.019524313509464264,
0.8881316781044006,
0.5601320862770081,
0.13141798973083496,
0.07634419202804565,
0.24830645322799683,
0.4694143533706665,
-1.0323505401611328,
0.2345835119485855,
-0.730116605758667,
0.028765074908733368,
-0.1988111138343811,
-0.5326448082923889,
-0.9370356202125549,
0.10660997033119202,
0.40034550428390503,
-0.6145553588867188,
0.10903255641460419,
-0.004830129910260439,
0.5381922721862793,
0.09563785046339035,
-1.0440987348556519,
-0.4470829367637634,
-0.39813777804374695,
1.020361304283142,
-0.4697679877281189,
0.5117411017417908,
0.7158128023147583,
0.15818998217582703,
-0.07255151867866516,
-0.8043943047523499,
-0.24112166464328766,
-0.37377896904945374,
-0.4960765540599823,
0.14956071972846985,
0.16991792619228363,
-0.0950053259730339,
0.3998206555843353,
-0.0635390654206276,
-0.4890573024749756,
-0.16149139404296875,
-0.25386789441108704,
-0.1788037270307541,
0.2985149919986725,
0.00008841806265991181,
0.15095296502113342,
-0.46561816334724426,
-0.47892630100250244,
-0.2623743414878845,
-0.40855076909065247,
0.1142645999789238,
0.10569795221090317,
0.38128650188446045,
0.1851804256439209,
0.6782504320144653,
-0.07627668976783752,
0.6951048374176025,
-0.2841433882713318,
-0.23968227207660675,
0.507296085357666,
-0.6269176006317139,
-0.18744488060474396,
-0.15362784266471863,
0.6205336451530457,
0.33078381419181824,
-0.07918142527341843,
-0.20518679916858673,
-0.3609553873538971,
-0.29779502749443054,
0.27108141779899597,
-1.0010864734649658,
-0.09282927215099335,
-0.2575090527534485,
-0.7719537019729614,
-0.05845305323600769,
0.2317696064710617,
-0.7867733836174011,
-0.26881179213523865,
-0.42034491896629333,
0.5055909156799316,
-0.6284464001655579,
-0.16646212339401245,
-0.20179036259651184,
-0.5403279662132263,
0.007110321894288063,
0.37977540493011475,
-0.7444857358932495,
-0.12682627141475677,
0.3892196714878082,
0.5699312686920166,
-0.08876501023769379,
-0.2759513854980469,
-0.8394134044647217,
0.24205686151981354,
-0.10998909920454025,
0.3602079749107361,
-0.9356918334960938,
-0.2577606737613678,
0.011101257987320423,
0.08384882658720016,
-0.442780077457428,
-0.46927550435066223,
0.5398434996604919,
-0.6228591203689575,
0.360956609249115,
-0.36336591839790344,
-0.4252488315105438,
-0.33927613496780396,
0.10677940398454666,
-0.7966833710670471,
0.9582144021987915,
-0.24546678364276886,
-0.8370081782341003,
0.6535799503326416,
-0.5576090216636658,
-0.4490415155887604,
-0.14301683008670807,
-0.24508433043956757,
-0.3453788757324219,
0.23448306322097778,
0.2214628905057907,
0.7221132516860962,
0.07040220499038696,
0.19223237037658691,
-0.21930623054504395,
-0.5615112781524658,
0.5745471715927124,
-0.9238136410713196,
0.7240676879882812,
0.20294752717018127,
-0.19094222784042358,
0.09995090961456299,
-0.6193552017211914,
0.03392462059855461,
-0.04091602563858032,
-0.6679965853691101,
-0.8382733464241028,
-0.03016470931470394,
0.5560562014579773,
0.5008071660995483,
0.0892081931233406,
-0.5504424571990967,
-0.14036260545253754,
-0.10315719991922379,
0.2708212733268738,
0.6510867476463318,
-0.06005169823765755,
0.6084567904472351,
-0.013552526012063026,
0.1454930454492569,
0.06367821246385574,
0.09622731059789658,
-0.6186513900756836,
-0.22378456592559814,
-0.42806023359298706,
-0.5940415263175964,
0.32945719361305237,
0.14415757358074188,
-1.1880406141281128,
-0.001229459885507822,
-0.06261217594146729,
-0.16925348341464996,
-0.3227856159210205,
0.371218204498291,
0.7056204676628113,
0.4508850574493408,
0.40349918603897095,
0.011119218543171883,
-0.45139074325561523,
-1.0287295579910278,
-0.2737397253513336,
0.2665230631828308,
-0.0834602490067482,
0.44847002625465393,
0.5504009127616882,
-0.24481360614299774,
0.891977846622467,
-0.1301898956298828,
-0.2319348007440567,
-0.21863709390163422,
0.16322968900203705,
-0.0640304684638977,
0.39253148436546326,
0.634908139705658,
-1.330258846282959,
-0.33856236934661865,
0.011654844507575035,
-1.0306956768035889,
0.2585524320602417,
-0.062421463429927826,
-0.14571614563465118,
0.17714346945285797,
0.5765243768692017,
-0.6340605616569519,
0.48553797602653503,
0.3321954309940338,
-0.39941635727882385,
0.16877350211143494,
-0.5458799004554749,
0.13188453018665314,
-1.0361266136169434,
0.12730106711387634,
0.18946059048175812,
-0.17484290897846222,
-0.4731123745441437,
0.10809164494276047,
0.7478993535041809,
0.18302404880523682,
-0.48903170228004456,
0.525711178779602,
-0.6481199264526367,
0.07901723682880402,
-0.08795112371444702,
0.15874359011650085,
0.1447819173336029,
0.5828208327293396,
-0.13917280733585358,
0.761747419834137,
0.2321464568376541,
-0.631612241268158,
0.047080714255571365,
0.11797512322664261,
-0.3136368989944458,
0.5998128056526184,
-0.277556836605072,
0.01637459173798561,
-0.629146933555603,
0.34101393818855286,
-0.9237799048423767,
-0.23698236048221588,
-0.1399679183959961,
-0.2126093953847885,
0.6181735992431641,
-0.024720290675759315,
-0.7624273300170898,
0.008823578245937824,
-0.35167115926742554,
0.5528860092163086,
-0.046660616993904114,
-0.721558153629303,
0.772205114364624,
0.20466011762619019,
0.0332590751349926,
-0.8272855281829834,
-0.5738517045974731,
0.07307833433151245,
-0.26735350489616394,
-0.14586471021175385,
0.09099171310663223,
-0.2289377897977829,
-0.17104347050189972,
-0.24526645243167877,
-0.05580255761742592,
0.023287344723939896,
0.2017141580581665,
0.20290134847164154,
0.19659917056560516,
0.01764068566262722,
0.6123172044754028,
0.06693717837333679,
0.034395329654216766,
0.017130373045802116,
-0.04727969691157341,
0.30509087443351746,
-0.12636429071426392,
-0.369251012802124,
-0.3382636606693268,
0.385847270488739,
0.39271649718284607,
-0.5230570435523987,
0.883613109588623,
0.7096689343452454,
-0.17867186665534973,
-0.100108303129673,
-0.46282488107681274,
-0.33435526490211487,
-0.4327893853187561,
0.6650221943855286,
-0.4273585379123688,
-0.7790945172309875,
0.022790804505348206,
0.09562814980745316,
-0.18299540877342224,
0.22071897983551025,
0.35896721482276917,
-0.19180524349212646,
1.0624736547470093,
0.4625670313835144,
0.09690160304307938,
0.855435848236084,
-0.24729877710342407,
-0.20073731243610382,
-0.974219024181366,
-0.5372165441513062,
-0.4116828441619873,
-0.3063473701477051,
-0.36926501989364624,
-0.3096981644630432,
0.3959774374961853,
-0.046948835253715515,
-0.07716654241085052,
0.17942531406879425,
-0.17668846249580383,
0.46259257197380066,
0.6047053933143616,
0.5205963253974915,
0.44009101390838623,
0.008108443580567837,
-0.3605591058731079,
-0.21501605212688446,
-0.6918415427207947,
-0.401769757270813,
1.161528468132019,
0.10418691486120224,
0.5385150909423828,
0.3458496034145355,
0.12897202372550964,
0.11841787397861481,
0.4034249186515808,
-0.5318187475204468,
0.37194180488586426,
-0.15779076516628265,
-0.7087810039520264,
-0.2074557989835739,
-0.5232762098312378,
-1.079292893409729,
0.8699682354927063,
-0.3923620283603668,
-0.5950170755386353,
0.13503558933734894,
-0.1491447538137436,
0.038439638912677765,
0.022819997742772102,
-0.8378415107727051,
0.8363296389579773,
-0.25767743587493896,
-0.44666197896003723,
-0.15793976187705994,
-0.8856234550476074,
0.05720464885234833,
-0.23263238370418549,
0.15250171720981598,
0.2209274172782898,
-0.2065901905298233,
0.42640045285224915,
0.137145534157753,
0.8123465776443481,
-0.21990209817886353,
-0.01110825128853321,
-0.14510966837406158,
-0.006097091361880302,
0.3069278299808502,
0.05565692484378815,
-0.37274864315986633,
-0.08988448232412338,
-0.197459876537323,
-0.30591562390327454,
-0.7610641717910767,
0.7020149827003479,
-0.4565489590167999,
-0.17928455770015717,
-0.14736779034137726,
-0.7958553433418274,
-0.12626570463180542,
0.09654896706342697,
0.30120688676834106,
0.9851951003074646,
-0.036547061055898666,
0.9642567038536072,
0.6878292560577393,
-0.21890559792518616,
0.9381393194198608,
0.3484252393245697,
-0.15962836146354675,
-0.2278464138507843,
0.8466812968254089,
0.12645967304706573,
0.27855753898620605,
0.7637147307395935,
0.020839354023337364,
-0.5416848063468933,
-0.25280141830444336,
-0.50218266248703,
0.10105882585048676,
-1.0238462686538696,
-0.22300954163074493,
-0.8173381686210632,
0.029117679223418236,
0.04226135089993477,
0.2139309197664261,
0.007022493984550238,
-0.17793206870555878,
-0.5421432256698608,
-0.10860277712345123,
0.10237579047679901,
0.5599524974822998,
0.4892968237400055,
0.23215381801128387,
-0.5654230117797852,
-0.010161635465919971,
0.16337084770202637,
0.21426217257976532,
0.09673922508955002,
-0.518364667892456,
-0.35496869683265686,
0.11153750121593475,
-0.17345879971981049,
-0.6585537791252136,
0.308910071849823,
0.3923940062522888,
0.8843045234680176,
0.3731638491153717,
-0.06785230338573456,
0.4701160490512848,
-0.3724006712436676,
0.499079167842865,
0.059969812631607056,
-0.6356357336044312,
0.427482545375824,
-0.26420971751213074,
0.3692660629749298,
0.5088775753974915,
0.45157763361930847,
-0.1644154042005539,
-0.21618761122226715,
-0.26189011335372925,
-0.7279337644577026,
0.5884706377983093,
0.2748852074146271,
0.4010518789291382,
-0.17671723663806915,
0.14876669645309448,
0.1090264692902565,
0.4270382225513458,
-0.8058397769927979,
-0.09073221683502197,
-0.10570861399173737,
-0.2259538322687149,
-0.3706265389919281,
-0.3586661219596863,
0.04812253266572952,
-0.20728319883346558,
0.35890698432922363,
-0.3371465504169464,
-0.0025332614313811064,
0.16727997362613678,
-0.6588812470436096,
0.26203930377960205,
0.36937180161476135,
0.7055283188819885,
0.7493492960929871,
-0.2205323427915573,
0.29516610503196716,
0.13362017273902893,
-0.36053213477134705,
-0.1809113323688507,
0.08048790693283081,
-0.10784587264060974,
0.2440178394317627,
0.44317683577537537,
0.8302487134933472,
0.6360076665878296,
-0.8410056233406067,
0.8749396204948425,
-0.18664614856243134,
-0.02332688681781292,
-0.238058403134346,
-0.28256916999816895,
-0.20184540748596191,
0.48519861698150635,
0.7186791896820068,
0.23848848044872284,
0.3453695476055145,
-0.5571444034576416,
0.3270273506641388,
0.7851220369338989,
-0.4891488552093506,
-0.053155314177274704,
0.6121298670768738,
-0.10203222185373306,
-0.12032390385866165,
0.6316909790039062,
0.0747179165482521,
-0.23380176723003387,
0.41306859254837036,
0.7482520937919617,
0.41692915558815,
-0.04066614434123039,
0.01903485506772995,
0.10304924845695496,
0.20091702044010162,
-0.02690299227833748,
-0.0694565698504448,
-0.3106814920902252,
-0.5218892097473145,
-0.4532371461391449,
-0.48814770579338074,
0.12653608620166779,
-0.18619748950004578,
-0.7304373383522034,
0.05556238442659378,
-0.07052051275968552,
-0.4046028256416321,
-0.22498686611652374,
-0.2878881096839905,
-0.6498011350631714,
0.229630246758461,
0.14110060036182404,
0.7297903299331665,
-0.41887030005455017,
0.9001191258430481,
0.6410053372383118,
-0.4721294939517975,
-0.4678995907306671,
0.017966248095035553,
-0.04079180210828781,
-0.34718087315559387,
0.9862901568412781,
0.42161962389945984,
-0.23483701050281525,
-0.19497770071029663,
-0.3347479999065399,
-0.8237361907958984,
1.2415087223052979,
0.4387170672416687,
-0.13060428202152252,
-0.006436616647988558,
-0.2700628638267517,
0.5843316316604614,
-0.41042426228523254,
0.755955159664154,
0.10242146253585815,
0.3177737295627594,
0.04210400581359863,
-0.8950493335723877,
-0.047719795256853104,
-0.49332934617996216,
0.3467402756214142,
0.18650823831558228,
-0.4609479308128357,
0.8846129179000854,
-0.15089167654514313,
-0.05209258198738098,
0.02771207131445408,
0.4275446832180023,
0.16323715448379517,
0.4226257801055908,
0.40219321846961975,
0.1995747834444046,
0.6328409314155579,
0.09705847501754761,
1.4262903928756714,
0.13143664598464966,
0.2685857117176056,
1.0284630060195923,
-0.0865156352519989,
1.1209125518798828,
0.7610735893249512,
0.4269569516181946,
0.4703296720981598,
0.32173019647598267,
0.23437723517417908,
0.667482852935791,
-0.08299922943115234,
-0.21897044777870178,
-0.18351735174655914,
-0.28015953302383423,
-0.23958826065063477,
0.6902124285697937,
0.3006788492202759,
-0.8311465382575989,
-0.17701807618141174,
0.5475092530250549,
-0.05539390817284584,
0.18175050616264343,
-0.21911711990833282,
0.8052176833152771,
-0.06317080557346344,
-0.41021063923835754,
0.4002241790294647,
-0.1298438012599945,
0.8876277804374695,
-0.6107198596000671,
-0.17095178365707397,
0.001094335108064115,
0.2411055713891983,
-0.1156967282295227,
-0.47333696484565735,
-0.09335831552743912,
-0.38917627930641174,
-0.31927359104156494,
-0.4378352463245392,
0.6555580496788025,
-0.616005539894104,
-0.4229435920715332,
0.6259169578552246,
0.5738605260848999,
-0.12516765296459198,
-0.3941664397716522,
-0.35231301188468933,
0.045894771814346313,
-0.14000657200813293,
-0.41949406266212463,
0.5873729586601257,
0.6299497485160828,
-0.06035108119249344,
0.6923835277557373,
0.6864122748374939,
-0.42853084206581116,
0.05367867648601532,
0.1509382575750351,
0.9358530044555664,
-0.4947361946105957,
-0.15894487500190735,
-1.0300235748291016,
0.6297081708908081,
-0.2914358973503113,
-0.25398141145706177,
1.1026407480239868,
0.8147808909416199,
1.0341360569000244,
-0.16149769723415375,
0.5166914463043213,
0.2305450737476349,
0.32373443245887756,
-0.6489781141281128,
0.8124918341636658,
-0.8874734044075012,
0.22804619371891022,
-0.5123037099838257,
-0.7096214294433594,
-0.23120911419391632,
0.5748358368873596,
-0.28195425868034363,
0.24599207937717438,
0.8079225420951843,
0.7628723978996277,
-0.14058992266654968,
0.10456801950931549,
0.5478731393814087,
-0.035977695137262344,
0.10555326193571091,
0.2522495985031128,
0.9854193925857544,
-0.4096405804157257,
0.6589300036430359,
-0.21741491556167603,
-0.12884116172790527,
-0.24982348084449768,
-0.8172801733016968,
-1.0350438356399536,
-0.9080411195755005,
0.2743963599205017,
-0.12209988385438919,
-0.05406767874956131,
1.0466200113296509,
0.7263734936714172,
-0.3654507100582123,
-0.1366826295852661,
0.6103155016899109,
-0.11239174753427505,
-0.07242188602685928,
-0.21357658505439758,
0.22311262786388397,
-0.4410851299762726,
-0.6929643154144287,
0.5780203938484192,
0.2635551393032074,
-0.19576367735862732,
0.1825665682554245,
-0.010862987488508224,
-0.5881511569023132,
-0.34921884536743164,
1.1807787418365479,
-0.32386165857315063,
-0.749482274055481,
-0.09854026883840561,
0.1404050886631012,
-0.40660959482192993,
-0.0835370197892189,
0.9369561076164246,
-0.8134384751319885,
0.611115574836731,
0.23488350212574005,
0.8862455487251282,
0.6749422550201416,
-0.031790804117918015,
0.3971486985683441,
-0.9925534725189209,
0.3754395544528961,
0.07027072459459305,
0.5751575827598572,
0.31578969955444336,
-0.3975813686847687,
0.3162413537502289,
0.14974641799926758,
-0.40454885363578796,
-0.6129270792007446,
-0.010885234922170639,
-0.7352703213691711,
-0.6029164791107178,
1.2047027349472046,
0.10168243944644928,
-0.0006791455671191216,
-0.19294078648090363,
-0.47443702816963196,
0.10357531160116196,
-0.523751437664032,
0.48573654890060425,
0.5986132621765137,
0.16893643140792847,
-0.44462910294532776,
-0.8891616463661194,
0.35456883907318115,
0.5444639325141907,
-0.44866058230400085,
-0.05452490970492363,
0.6388329267501831,
0.12264389544725418,
0.04047301411628723,
0.3595289885997772,
0.02044079266488552,
0.013620369136333466,
-0.2759864926338196,
-0.23547887802124023,
-0.1331435590982437,
-0.46048423647880554,
-0.3688174784183502,
0.3378358483314514,
-0.2633971571922302,
0.0402812585234642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13104v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13104v1
|
Multi Class Depression Detection Through Tweets using Artificial Intelligence
| 2024-04-19T12:47:56 | 2024-04-19T12:47:56 |
Muhammad Osama Nusrat, Waseem Shahzad, Saad Ahmed Jamal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Depression is a significant issue nowadays. As per the World Health
Organization (WHO), in 2023, over 280 million individuals are grappling with
depression. This is a huge number; if not taken seriously, these numbers will
increase rapidly. About 4.89 billion individuals are social media users. People
express their feelings and emotions on platforms like Twitter, Facebook,
Reddit, Instagram, etc. These platforms contain valuable information which can
be used for research purposes. Considerable research has been conducted across
various social media platforms. However, certain limitations persist in these
endeavors. Particularly, previous studies were only focused on detecting
depression and the intensity of depression in tweets. Also, there existed
inaccuracies in dataset labeling. In this research work, five types of
depression (Bipolar, major, psychotic, atypical, and postpartum) were predicted
using tweets from the Twitter database based on lexicon labeling. Explainable
AI was used to provide reasoning by highlighting the parts of tweets that
represent type of depression. Bidirectional Encoder Representations from
Transformers (BERT) was used for feature extraction and training. Machine
learning and deep learning methodologies were used to train the model. The BERT
model presented the most promising results, achieving an overall accuracy of
0.96.
|
[
-0.3681458532810211,
-0.7949495911598206,
0.6996669173240662,
0.7791874408721924,
-0.17538098990917206,
0.47699570655822754,
-0.282291978597641,
-0.4378330409526825,
0.4035016894340515,
-0.12893232703208923,
-0.623660683631897,
-0.7107681035995483,
-0.9067219495773315,
0.2829352915287018,
-0.557577908039093,
0.6371431946754456,
-0.11368025094270706,
0.10868114233016968,
0.23220299184322357,
-0.04541957005858421,
-0.36731797456741333,
-0.39733821153640747,
-0.855316162109375,
-0.08463902771472931,
0.5082659125328064,
0.46879979968070984,
0.4943595826625824,
-0.30704620480537415,
0.6853454113006592,
0.4378300607204437,
-0.011079559102654457,
0.08749770373106003,
-0.15235881507396698,
0.006404627114534378,
0.03642343357205391,
-0.05399726331233978,
-0.31871986389160156,
-0.321792870759964,
0.27387112379074097,
0.12145259231328964,
0.0814708024263382,
0.14289551973342896,
0.15125949680805206,
0.5374280214309692,
-0.47663938999176025,
0.15154337882995605,
-0.44399040937423706,
0.3132705092430115,
0.03410430997610092,
0.05370524153113365,
-0.09426520019769669,
-0.6622830033302307,
-0.0049246796406805515,
-0.1274508833885193,
0.38663148880004883,
-0.48690542578697205,
0.792285680770874,
0.4102229177951813,
-0.47910481691360474,
-0.34285420179367065,
-0.5959045886993408,
0.7753112316131592,
-0.6673579812049866,
0.15902885794639587,
0.326271116733551,
0.4396582841873169,
0.06977374106645584,
-0.3672638237476349,
-0.472698450088501,
0.2651202976703644,
-0.07761026173830032,
0.12608112394809723,
0.08589857816696167,
-0.01312976237386465,
0.038492023944854736,
0.3210642337799072,
-0.5488492846488953,
0.09041542559862137,
-0.06808796525001526,
-0.03897640109062195,
0.5999739170074463,
0.018876507878303528,
0.533793568611145,
-0.39647364616394043,
-0.19191640615463257,
0.17822766304016113,
0.48643720149993896,
0.011183978989720345,
0.06998386234045029,
0.22864854335784912,
-0.36617597937583923,
0.5539736151695251,
0.08638656139373779,
0.42109349370002747,
-0.012651870027184486,
-0.19539453089237213,
0.41050484776496887,
-0.011622447520494461,
-0.2901204526424408,
0.13928601145744324,
0.8806143999099731,
0.48561954498291016,
0.5334739685058594,
0.06661652773618698,
-0.13293838500976562,
0.41043686866760254,
0.30481359362602234,
-0.6073336005210876,
-0.1807456761598587,
0.42701610922813416,
-0.7636727690696716,
-0.36500200629234314,
-0.27187755703926086,
-1.0550633668899536,
-0.8529775738716125,
-0.15691860020160675,
0.33943673968315125,
-0.8440758585929871,
-0.46188634634017944,
0.06339135020971298,
-0.32869473099708557,
-0.12243335694074631,
0.40506356954574585,
-0.7337027192115784,
-0.20052215456962585,
0.46062690019607544,
1.2111351490020752,
0.10366851091384888,
0.13330000638961792,
0.21880130469799042,
0.07102637737989426,
-0.07393574714660645,
1.034143328666687,
-0.3982252776622772,
-0.048510149121284485,
0.2667444944381714,
-0.0567285530269146,
-0.31383445858955383,
-0.08900702744722366,
0.8879511952400208,
-0.17666544020175934,
-0.0018892628140747547,
-0.004422185942530632,
-0.6252854466438293,
-0.18950387835502625,
0.3548860549926758,
-0.7302916049957275,
0.5693753361701965,
0.3454687297344208,
-0.995556116104126,
0.30286917090415955,
-0.8545702695846558,
-0.5831751823425293,
0.15644335746765137,
0.041739869862794876,
-0.8033531308174133,
0.11938337236642838,
0.5645390152931213,
0.85875403881073,
-0.07060126215219498,
0.4537907540798187,
-0.7203553318977356,
-0.29871249198913574,
0.14993059635162354,
-0.16930191218852997,
0.6464558243751526,
0.10848011821508408,
-0.4187701344490051,
0.22741839289665222,
-0.581384003162384,
-0.09098517894744873,
0.03745710849761963,
-0.20713219046592712,
-0.278070330619812,
0.04540790989995003,
0.19747596979141235,
0.29771044850349426,
-0.03875887021422386,
-0.7663828730583191,
-0.01759244129061699,
0.05491211265325546,
0.7111333012580872,
0.6823071241378784,
0.2462262362241745,
-0.057818856090307236,
-0.17061519622802734,
0.3696032464504242,
0.21096254885196686,
0.563508152961731,
0.2445400208234787,
-0.6168496012687683,
-0.4000789523124695,
-0.660798192024231,
0.22131897509098053,
0.5361924767494202,
-0.5685873031616211,
0.6817538738250732,
-0.015256823040544987,
-0.4629969000816345,
-0.8791252970695496,
-0.34599369764328003,
-0.11829673498868942,
0.41181206703186035,
0.6826176643371582,
0.2331923544406891,
-0.6784016489982605,
-0.8798655867576599,
-0.33807775378227234,
0.06417887657880783,
-0.03189241886138916,
-0.04779277369379997,
0.23222532868385315,
-0.6339114904403687,
0.6941971778869629,
-0.49523067474365234,
-0.46078333258628845,
-0.47965964674949646,
0.3723978102207184,
0.10139244794845581,
0.3386304974555969,
0.5155239105224609,
-0.9097169041633606,
-0.7515471577644348,
-0.23293811082839966,
-0.925073504447937,
0.16169114410877228,
-0.3429737389087677,
-0.040341008454561234,
0.3336878716945648,
0.04909573867917061,
-0.5350425243377686,
0.6786679029464722,
0.39290887117385864,
-0.18433469533920288,
0.11504389345645905,
0.23154322803020477,
0.20869112014770508,
-1.1518691778182983,
-0.20991775393486023,
0.5917086005210876,
-0.11961299926042557,
-0.5221962928771973,
-0.7821484804153442,
0.2790035307407379,
-0.11777296662330627,
-0.057135965675115585,
0.14229808747768402,
-0.14131247997283936,
0.16115787625312805,
-0.1174905002117157,
-0.13032567501068115,
-0.1610155552625656,
0.19473984837532043,
-0.23527058959007263,
0.2506241202354431,
0.8485713005065918,
-0.28954750299453735,
0.3148490786552429,
0.30079713463783264,
-0.2343696504831314,
0.35463330149650574,
-0.28370413184165955,
-0.288333922624588,
-0.34100449085235596,
0.34751787781715393,
-1.1208268404006958,
-0.28630688786506653,
0.3953719437122345,
-0.7181283831596375,
0.11914460361003876,
0.27344468235969543,
-0.7078948616981506,
-0.8113248944282532,
-0.5231441259384155,
0.21995480358600616,
0.1624274104833603,
-0.4073401093482971,
0.64776611328125,
0.28899946808815,
0.05541105195879936,
-0.3652981221675873,
-0.6591134071350098,
0.2262611836194992,
-0.4349249303340912,
-0.6473549008369446,
0.3885083794593811,
0.00737566314637661,
-0.04040886461734772,
0.1233794316649437,
0.04433010518550873,
-0.21888858079910278,
0.1352725774049759,
0.20222407579421997,
0.04983563348650932,
0.1482122391462326,
0.573237955570221,
0.0131813520565629,
0.10490487515926361,
-0.002632960444316268,
0.352464884519577,
0.8080478310585022,
-0.20774777233600616,
-0.015182663686573505,
-1.0372740030288696,
0.5411123037338257,
0.598429799079895,
0.055652469396591187,
1.0054285526275635,
1.080880880355835,
-0.7060793042182922,
-0.07467707991600037,
-0.5557728409767151,
-0.1331149786710739,
-0.4696546196937561,
0.10796315222978592,
-0.13430650532245636,
-0.49989843368530273,
0.5137476325035095,
-0.16900095343589783,
-0.20384488999843597,
0.39033690094947815,
0.45547324419021606,
-0.14040525257587433,
1.3776905536651611,
0.7124788165092468,
-0.2535892426967621,
0.5503755807876587,
-0.3274838626384735,
0.7537729740142822,
-0.34670543670654297,
-0.181657612323761,
-0.3317204415798187,
-0.5519184470176697,
-0.7900344133377075,
0.15690065920352936,
0.2799065411090851,
-0.01737520471215248,
-0.33637386560440063,
0.2826433479785919,
-0.8615710735321045,
0.11940865963697433,
0.5145859122276306,
0.6019605994224548,
0.009274237789213657,
-0.09026750177145004,
0.3140811622142792,
0.008146213367581367,
-0.19751621782779694,
-0.4986322224140167,
0.8165411949157715,
0.4087288975715637,
0.5537099242210388,
0.08288811147212982,
0.7810468673706055,
0.7305626273155212,
0.5720226168632507,
-0.8380195498466492,
0.3903878629207611,
-0.3665711283683777,
-0.5092567205429077,
-0.36116427183151245,
-0.398327112197876,
-0.6981244087219238,
-0.1412735879421234,
-0.21300634741783142,
-0.5378978848457336,
0.18819086253643036,
-0.21464844048023224,
-0.44241270422935486,
0.4561857283115387,
-1.0164250135421753,
0.7848261594772339,
-0.3370380997657776,
0.21248222887516022,
-0.29938435554504395,
-0.8526511788368225,
0.42313551902770996,
-0.3648342788219452,
0.2891477942466736,
-0.4626138210296631,
0.2422240823507309,
0.6517377495765686,
-0.05347246304154396,
0.9384943842887878,
-0.1819126456975937,
0.025129398331046104,
0.1218491867184639,
-0.3956944942474365,
-0.06932898610830307,
0.13530957698822021,
-0.21381832659244537,
0.1040784940123558,
-0.13314282894134521,
-0.597804844379425,
-0.1750555783510208,
0.493243008852005,
-1.0393990278244019,
-0.14593076705932617,
-0.26183944940567017,
-0.40111926198005676,
-0.3643592298030853,
0.1058509573340416,
0.23836958408355713,
0.30357083678245544,
0.09227044880390167,
-0.10252691060304642,
0.18872888386249542,
-0.4764814078807831,
0.8869484066963196,
-0.03173757344484329,
0.13646292686462402,
-0.4980892837047577,
0.8666663765907288,
0.02871941402554512,
-0.22839349508285522,
0.36057227849960327,
0.3797439932823181,
-0.27202653884887695,
-0.143034890294075,
-0.12897711992263794,
0.3709772229194641,
-0.5306909084320068,
-0.6060960292816162,
-0.8879889249801636,
-0.17571201920509338,
-0.9084259867668152,
-0.2770727574825287,
-0.22465401887893677,
-0.32937926054000854,
-0.7151545882225037,
-0.2203010618686676,
0.5299993753433228,
0.6495124697685242,
-0.2907058596611023,
0.36036789417266846,
-1.0037506818771362,
0.8174872398376465,
0.2411372810602188,
0.46927887201309204,
0.2384156584739685,
0.1021210104227066,
-0.0870072990655899,
0.012987775728106499,
-0.5875933170318604,
-1.0092052221298218,
0.6420068144798279,
0.2450108379125595,
0.23551850020885468,
0.9242274761199951,
0.3501025438308716,
0.7172136902809143,
-0.0027450944762676954,
0.4581429660320282,
0.4828915297985077,
-0.9640676975250244,
0.7829559445381165,
-0.16659888625144958,
-0.040169086307287216,
0.4679754376411438,
0.8707080483436584,
-0.744212806224823,
-0.49695461988449097,
-0.6247221231460571,
-0.7439548969268799,
0.7158257365226746,
0.12818223237991333,
-0.015112193301320076,
-0.13630151748657227,
0.20662778615951538,
0.2134343683719635,
0.18715105950832367,
-0.6337677836418152,
-0.16794508695602417,
-0.454912930727005,
-0.6871932744979858,
-0.009301950223743916,
-0.2924168109893799,
0.16303864121437073,
-0.33402013778686523,
0.40048331022262573,
0.21479900181293488,
0.5901277661323547,
0.14352166652679443,
0.1490393877029419,
-0.29267215728759766,
0.12700314819812775,
0.3744087219238281,
0.5073232650756836,
-0.5928010940551758,
0.19990970194339752,
-0.3522251844406128,
-0.1689913123846054,
-0.033485207706689835,
0.33734461665153503,
0.0741770789027214,
0.32028257846832275,
0.5150448083877563,
0.5629250407218933,
-0.2617247998714447,
-0.5342350602149963,
0.43774452805519104,
-0.38979166746139526,
-0.19981670379638672,
-0.7938679456710815,
-0.22551703453063965,
0.2922794818878174,
0.5011009573936462,
0.33388304710388184,
0.21693210303783417,
0.26188021898269653,
-0.6342492699623108,
0.08874979615211487,
0.19017860293388367,
-0.32647398114204407,
-0.4017866849899292,
0.3119147717952728,
0.18800108134746552,
-0.6375868320465088,
0.6181646585464478,
-0.1295892894268036,
-0.8240082859992981,
0.6956180334091187,
0.26244407892227173,
1.0475373268127441,
-0.5221109986305237,
0.7016623020172119,
0.34844961762428284,
0.12186509370803833,
-0.2153012454509735,
0.5594559907913208,
0.1943245381116867,
-0.83116614818573,
-0.147826686501503,
-0.5825778245925903,
-0.2696177363395691,
0.28620490431785583,
-0.4542270302772522,
0.4733472466468811,
-0.43260061740875244,
-0.5566686987876892,
0.20809000730514526,
-0.2283371239900589,
-0.519644021987915,
0.292419970035553,
0.456328421831131,
0.591118574142456,
-1.12921941280365,
0.489603191614151,
0.7067832946777344,
-0.3749304413795471,
-0.5721980929374695,
0.5150523781776428,
-0.08771122992038727,
-0.7073222398757935,
0.335725337266922,
0.8003284931182861,
0.14277493953704834,
0.04855871573090553,
-0.5787466764450073,
-0.547835111618042,
0.6773216128349304,
0.000624591251835227,
-0.22959166765213013,
0.15172474086284637,
0.25011545419692993,
0.7357234954833984,
-0.23897579312324524,
0.30031850934028625,
0.40428611636161804,
0.7300269603729248,
-0.05100347101688385,
-0.7558175921440125,
-0.17760206758975983,
-0.10165015608072281,
-0.07617256045341492,
0.2578916847705841,
-0.6623016595840454,
0.8360187411308289,
-0.09803307056427002,
-0.4142446517944336,
-0.4194599688053131,
0.2108219563961029,
0.13223432004451752,
0.4781768023967743,
0.6336468458175659,
0.7438868284225464,
0.5822980999946594,
0.15229998528957367,
0.7657946944236755,
-0.14233466982841492,
0.6437864303588867,
0.4476223886013031,
-0.10639772564172745,
0.5437201261520386,
0.11958944797515869,
-0.01042451523244381,
0.39906346797943115,
0.9773966073989868,
-0.09034579992294312,
0.6952311992645264,
0.06766361743211746,
-0.5217587947845459,
-0.4216236472129822,
-0.21196645498275757,
-0.34170934557914734,
0.06909779459238052,
0.6697564721107483,
-0.46798908710479736,
-0.4290352165699005,
0.4092773497104645,
-0.05713626369833946,
-0.1167156770825386,
-0.3187128007411957,
0.7126368880271912,
0.02775600552558899,
-0.3677438199520111,
0.6846517324447632,
0.0767834410071373,
0.7739449739456177,
-0.02188824862241745,
0.04829041659832001,
-0.09536992758512497,
0.5822924375534058,
-0.28434067964553833,
-0.8390467762947083,
0.426026314496994,
-0.005857192445546389,
0.004129631910473108,
-0.4085536301136017,
1.0173773765563965,
-0.19777491688728333,
-0.9177001714706421,
0.7980769276618958,
0.5377964377403259,
0.018447326496243477,
-0.45094263553619385,
-0.9327291250228882,
-0.07446186989545822,
0.010601578280329704,
-0.09413178265094757,
-0.04406069964170456,
0.8407461643218994,
0.11371985822916031,
0.778472363948822,
0.08066189289093018,
-0.13652537763118744,
0.07052389532327652,
0.477596640586853,
0.9109787940979004,
-0.7692191004753113,
-0.36249250173568726,
-0.9944929480552673,
0.31111449003219604,
-0.31186559796333313,
-0.1114421859383583,
0.49534690380096436,
0.2837885320186615,
0.4081607162952423,
-0.14993318915367126,
0.9305264353752136,
-0.2992769181728363,
1.0884665250778198,
0.1614856868982315,
0.4722684919834137,
-0.6267063617706299,
-0.1535932570695877,
-0.45952683687210083,
-0.3859049081802368,
-0.6509983539581299,
0.5978748202323914,
-0.30412551760673523,
-0.02035490795969963,
0.7328762412071228,
0.3160227835178375,
-0.00168509257491678,
0.3499227464199066,
-0.01907206140458584,
0.229075625538826,
0.500788152217865,
0.4125576615333557,
0.8770431280136108,
-0.16335104405879974,
0.4538158178329468,
-0.5524078607559204,
-0.3146783113479614,
-0.5353440642356873,
-0.3999010920524597,
-1.170971155166626,
-0.4146881401538849,
-0.4163562059402466,
-0.1636597216129303,
-0.08824724704027176,
0.6874569654464722,
0.34658125042915344,
-0.8569393754005432,
0.15724311769008636,
-0.23870281875133514,
0.38434702157974243,
-0.18956980109214783,
-0.3023831844329834,
0.7405416369438171,
-0.47622647881507874,
-0.37714940309524536,
-0.20881341397762299,
0.07819505780935287,
-0.007883015088737011,
0.04217345267534256,
0.4852130711078644,
-0.6301355957984924,
-0.2506992816925049,
0.7260087728500366,
-0.28790608048439026,
-0.41580596566200256,
-0.28937244415283203,
-0.2877269387245178,
-0.16473405063152313,
0.26615914702415466,
0.5985334515571594,
-0.5301325917243958,
-0.0584588460624218,
0.5190259218215942,
0.4418615400791168,
0.18548421561717987,
0.35272109508514404,
0.02401774935424328,
-0.4398922324180603,
-0.283773273229599,
0.5552477240562439,
0.2811391353607178,
0.577130913734436,
-0.5791915655136108,
0.4658723771572113,
0.3458694815635681,
-0.6769382357597351,
-0.556877613067627,
-0.05477552115917206,
-1.0072041749954224,
-0.7190074920654297,
0.8119350075721741,
0.12452422082424164,
-0.049372587352991104,
-0.46862852573394775,
-0.1372469961643219,
0.755137026309967,
-0.882742702960968,
1.5738141536712646,
0.47642284631729126,
-0.5743288993835449,
-0.25805386900901794,
-0.5513457655906677,
0.2877458930015564,
0.12882983684539795,
-0.8354706764221191,
-0.2919725179672241,
0.18064865469932556,
-0.058370038866996765,
0.09094780683517456,
0.5910024046897888,
0.19742746651172638,
-0.23108085989952087,
-0.5459498763084412,
0.35511496663093567,
0.47503167390823364,
-0.03289056569337845,
-0.06858470290899277,
0.34350287914276123,
-0.6316943764686584,
-0.6220257878303528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12845v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12845v1
|
TartuNLP @ SIGTYP 2024 Shared Task: Adapting XLM-RoBERTa for Ancient and Historical Languages
| 2024-04-19T12:26:28 | 2024-04-19T12:26:28 |
Aleksei Dorkin, Kairit Sirts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present our submission to the unconstrained subtask of the SIGTYP 2024
Shared Task on Word Embedding Evaluation for Ancient and Historical Languages
for morphological annotation, POS-tagging, lemmatization, character- and
word-level gap-filling. We developed a simple, uniform, and computationally
lightweight approach based on the adapters framework using parameter-efficient
fine-tuning. We applied the same adapter-based approach uniformly to all tasks
and 16 languages by fine-tuning stacked language- and task-specific adapters.
Our submission obtained an overall second place out of three submissions, with
the first place in word-level gap-filling. Our results show the feasibility of
adapting language models pre-trained on modern languages to historical and
ancient languages via adapter training.
|
[
-0.3964654505252838,
-0.4211379587650299,
0.6639861464500427,
0.08150765299797058,
-0.4637603461742401,
-0.29635053873062134,
-0.5071555972099304,
-0.5323339104652405,
0.16221478581428528,
0.4091240465641022,
-0.19991084933280945,
-0.47642046213150024,
-0.6914759874343872,
0.14661188423633575,
0.22333836555480957,
0.8025134205818176,
-0.6013215780258179,
0.16890834271907806,
-0.1783238798379898,
-0.5064707398414612,
-0.5871046185493469,
-0.49624282121658325,
-0.45364823937416077,
-0.13457952439785004,
0.1731550246477127,
0.17645546793937683,
0.4119417667388916,
0.6812011003494263,
0.29122334718704224,
0.3049662113189697,
-0.05955779552459717,
0.25125741958618164,
-0.18717049062252045,
0.10282472521066666,
-0.4287550747394562,
-0.31801503896713257,
-0.8103036284446716,
-0.15943843126296997,
0.7150799036026001,
0.5828971266746521,
-0.02296851947903633,
0.20067444443702698,
0.20213943719863892,
0.3677566647529602,
-0.693992018699646,
0.29228881001472473,
-0.8449822664260864,
0.10913560539484024,
-0.39814284443855286,
-0.6688949465751648,
-0.34579095244407654,
-0.260808527469635,
0.08889175206422806,
-0.7753206491470337,
-0.0943799763917923,
-0.008929337374866009,
0.3811347484588623,
0.4562697112560272,
0.10913672298192978,
-0.4759891629219055,
-0.5081980228424072,
0.7431349158287048,
-0.8068190813064575,
0.26178762316703796,
0.25152087211608887,
-0.09386631846427917,
-0.10277385264635086,
-0.628467857837677,
-0.2689645290374756,
-0.1555400788784027,
0.15508434176445007,
0.13332055509090424,
-0.36396393179893494,
0.08161299675703049,
0.060781314969062805,
0.32646799087524414,
-0.5492134094238281,
0.2249680608510971,
-0.2968169152736664,
-0.20145995914936066,
0.29277750849723816,
0.13072596490383148,
0.5004662871360779,
0.3544699251651764,
-0.1713801473379135,
0.17309801280498505,
-0.6005117893218994,
-0.3981786072254181,
0.3143764138221741,
0.3936358690261841,
-0.20202220976352692,
0.49857622385025024,
0.09073347598314285,
0.8378045558929443,
0.07041356712579727,
0.19517292082309723,
0.17295999825000763,
-0.39247581362724304,
-0.008451538160443306,
-0.01488089095801115,
0.40523749589920044,
0.1505902111530304,
0.2854830324649811,
-0.10142822563648224,
-0.028238115832209587,
-0.01140650175511837,
0.072089284658432,
-0.6344074606895447,
-0.28253334760665894,
-0.30866891145706177,
-0.16201075911521912,
0.0993904396891594,
-0.003947017248719931,
-0.6999276876449585,
-0.35988086462020874,
0.024118421599268913,
0.6265454888343811,
-0.5050538778305054,
0.014437522739171982,
0.2523660361766815,
-0.08661816269159317,
-0.07299191504716873,
0.7465724349021912,
-1.0065264701843262,
0.43043577671051025,
0.6665908694267273,
0.8440566062927246,
0.08385176956653595,
-0.4224097728729248,
-0.5834776163101196,
0.31846392154693604,
-0.15275563299655914,
0.8400901556015015,
-0.7299219965934753,
-0.27580535411834717,
-0.06126043200492859,
0.2623887062072754,
-0.321417897939682,
-0.4376215934753418,
0.9442099332809448,
-0.21597473323345184,
0.2464013695716858,
0.10566201061010361,
-0.6717629432678223,
-0.12940090894699097,
0.16895805299282074,
-0.49792537093162537,
1.005456566810608,
0.3670378029346466,
-0.6718034744262695,
0.2299835979938507,
-0.7514073252677917,
-0.06631258875131607,
0.5663200616836548,
-0.17992888391017914,
-0.3429088592529297,
0.20206952095031738,
0.3185442388057709,
0.199544295668602,
-0.02058251202106476,
-0.009552008472383022,
-0.22986960411071777,
-0.3926559090614319,
-0.14784832298755646,
-0.21086937189102173,
0.40132519602775574,
0.001758781261742115,
-0.5188854932785034,
0.2567148506641388,
-0.36441078782081604,
0.015685221180319786,
-0.1032881811261177,
-0.48973020911216736,
-0.5503451228141785,
-0.1854882836341858,
0.20025119185447693,
-0.08462146669626236,
0.5645260810852051,
-0.5881426930427551,
0.5954158902168274,
-0.35205501317977905,
0.5065205693244934,
0.759233832359314,
-0.3287903368473053,
0.4890393614768982,
-0.24121256172657013,
0.5999661684036255,
-0.17838524281978607,
-0.13646596670150757,
-0.1305859237909317,
-0.46935611963272095,
-0.6103691458702087,
-0.15939101576805115,
0.8172313570976257,
0.5137126445770264,
-0.5574145913124084,
0.33901962637901306,
-0.3358703553676605,
-0.5565188527107239,
-0.4767972230911255,
-0.05097874626517296,
0.2293451875448227,
-0.056662749499082565,
0.32882726192474365,
-0.6429305672645569,
-0.7881424427032471,
-0.5223057270050049,
-0.17796559631824493,
-0.11658899486064911,
0.0035216882824897766,
0.3231385350227356,
0.48746728897094727,
-0.298239529132843,
0.26981785893440247,
-0.17791153490543365,
-0.5108274817466736,
-0.18007655441761017,
0.18404336273670197,
0.001601643394678831,
0.716641902923584,
0.8477821350097656,
-0.5024449229240417,
-0.4938509166240692,
0.15227395296096802,
-0.3639580011367798,
-0.0942150130867958,
0.30333247780799866,
0.1217481717467308,
0.4672897160053253,
0.5274724960327148,
-0.0846899077296257,
0.45204904675483704,
0.9632490277290344,
-0.3815567195415497,
0.15740111470222473,
-0.703203558921814,
0.22720810770988464,
-1.2154293060302734,
-0.0698363184928894,
-0.23421606421470642,
-0.3463534712791443,
-0.403266578912735,
-0.006514603737741709,
0.14401935040950775,
-0.18231101334095,
-0.390648752450943,
0.7498070001602173,
-0.6792489290237427,
0.0565229170024395,
-0.28423580527305603,
0.1930495649576187,
-0.6359241604804993,
0.2669941484928131,
0.02991671860218048,
0.6905356049537659,
0.67084801197052,
-0.41478362679481506,
-0.04917605221271515,
0.1632402241230011,
-0.1349734514951706,
0.44929856061935425,
-0.46664655208587646,
0.3455672264099121,
0.01768239215016365,
0.24217601120471954,
-0.7738386988639832,
-0.03595738857984543,
0.3691703975200653,
-0.391452819108963,
0.30902934074401855,
-0.4781937003135681,
-0.37688496708869934,
0.012823948636651039,
-0.4465409815311432,
0.8791636228561401,
0.3821090757846832,
-0.20436003804206848,
0.7905081510543823,
0.5695220232009888,
-0.3143985867500305,
-0.2624613046646118,
-0.5706429481506348,
0.17398394644260406,
-0.3803420960903168,
-0.515080451965332,
0.6412349343299866,
-0.22025370597839355,
-0.035294461995363235,
0.31491032242774963,
-0.1113334596157074,
0.01507946103811264,
0.14989052712917328,
0.31094852089881897,
0.0919085219502449,
-0.48983392119407654,
-0.38052642345428467,
-0.12602059543132782,
-0.30367159843444824,
-0.5284402966499329,
-0.6365630626678467,
0.8027304410934448,
-0.24833334982395172,
-0.37033265829086304,
-0.4461196959018707,
0.1277645230293274,
0.4818800389766693,
-0.16893939673900604,
0.5732526779174805,
0.6735861301422119,
-0.6719473600387573,
-0.04222656041383743,
-0.43648916482925415,
0.21388281881809235,
-0.3928343951702118,
0.4108654260635376,
-0.38145115971565247,
-1.2929364442825317,
0.3110470175743103,
-0.3756057322025299,
0.08946771174669266,
0.6274675130844116,
0.7261693477630615,
0.10977140814065933,
0.7434092164039612,
0.9618680477142334,
-0.13708962500095367,
0.6737757921218872,
0.0591614693403244,
-0.053328074514865875,
-1.012557864189148,
0.1681153029203415,
-0.7018321752548218,
-0.1550782322883606,
-1.0020941495895386,
-0.6546738147735596,
0.1803385317325592,
0.19531548023223877,
0.3208072781562805,
0.5334817171096802,
-0.23365847766399384,
0.08230546861886978,
0.2973496913909912,
-0.16213229298591614,
0.0705794245004654,
-0.14782752096652985,
-0.03357817977666855,
-0.2425752580165863,
-0.6330345273017883,
-0.6428787112236023,
0.979209840297699,
0.16336730122566223,
0.8034467697143555,
0.06047358736395836,
0.8019554615020752,
0.32101547718048096,
-0.025982964783906937,
-0.5912957787513733,
0.3870384693145752,
-0.709191620349884,
-0.13962946832180023,
-0.3234734833240509,
-0.07007261365652084,
-0.9327430129051208,
0.16131366789340973,
-0.017283571884036064,
-1.03985595703125,
0.10117599368095398,
0.26771682500839233,
-0.2915399670600891,
0.37110698223114014,
-0.30374595522880554,
0.8910717368125916,
0.019998420029878616,
-0.03754964843392372,
-0.3741365075111389,
-0.3539395034313202,
-0.25901761651039124,
-0.06596274673938751,
0.3664149343967438,
-0.09589415788650513,
-0.1452956199645996,
0.8832849860191345,
-0.1689060479402542,
0.6930968761444092,
-0.21249158680438995,
-0.07758154720067978,
0.08999231457710266,
0.09644149988889694,
0.4381582736968994,
0.10867135971784592,
-0.13137133419513702,
-0.05592245236039162,
0.3646292984485626,
-0.4570588171482086,
-0.37572795152664185,
0.7549006938934326,
-0.598566472530365,
-0.5331320762634277,
-0.7032560706138611,
-0.8835814595222473,
-0.06635751575231552,
0.12440288811922073,
-0.005320003721863031,
0.5867453813552856,
-0.37668007612228394,
0.1942429393529892,
0.5305284857749939,
-0.08342623710632324,
0.36566677689552307,
0.3933119773864746,
0.012154633179306984,
-0.4713256061077118,
0.7003366947174072,
0.18183445930480957,
-0.10180258750915527,
0.46535974740982056,
0.2824004888534546,
-0.03755495697259903,
-0.990447998046875,
-0.8547889590263367,
0.1933959275484085,
-0.42238086462020874,
0.10153191536664963,
-0.4122801721096039,
-0.14953269064426422,
-0.48685839772224426,
-0.25247272849082947,
-0.2735711336135864,
-0.7313631176948547,
-0.3894447088241577,
0.3015875518321991,
0.28208762407302856,
0.9408324956893921,
-0.24846485257148743,
0.11609403789043427,
-0.7191816568374634,
0.06738302111625671,
-0.015666181221604347,
0.12171751260757446,
-0.3581182360649109,
-0.6800209283828735,
-0.2865888774394989,
-0.06596491485834122,
-0.20729905366897583,
-0.5092042088508606,
0.08189016580581665,
0.4499751031398773,
0.800388753414154,
-0.07075940817594528,
-0.09483149647712708,
0.9078220725059509,
-0.8203775882720947,
0.7628925442695618,
-0.20306292176246643,
-0.989314615726471,
0.6199662685394287,
-0.2918097972869873,
0.44982996582984924,
0.5863350629806519,
0.2806418538093567,
-0.6204594969749451,
-0.44970452785491943,
-0.40082570910453796,
-1.056275486946106,
0.7252753376960754,
0.13233710825443268,
0.25659433007240295,
0.27233392000198364,
0.40459129214286804,
0.239968940615654,
-0.12247809767723083,
-0.5409834980964661,
-0.05813312903046608,
0.05571804568171501,
-0.33436691761016846,
0.07531574368476868,
-0.3193455934524536,
0.09571677446365356,
-0.18788915872573853,
0.7367246747016907,
-0.2409650832414627,
0.2310633659362793,
0.06735937297344208,
-0.4814036190509796,
-0.2435842603445053,
0.7221857309341431,
0.8845072388648987,
0.9588161110877991,
-0.12944571673870087,
0.32979288697242737,
0.5579620003700256,
-0.49625083804130554,
-0.2533707022666931,
0.39969974756240845,
-0.20943093299865723,
0.11131475120782852,
0.38462328910827637,
0.8788818120956421,
0.35447055101394653,
-0.43076053261756897,
0.1460583508014679,
-0.28443101048469543,
-0.032689642161130905,
-0.45651108026504517,
-0.003615145804360509,
0.05319353565573692,
0.3501417636871338,
0.2661714255809784,
0.15156862139701843,
-0.09520601481199265,
-0.7836331725120544,
0.08797304332256317,
0.4247807562351227,
-0.6300643682479858,
-0.6116374731063843,
0.6444150805473328,
0.02007933519780636,
-0.36089909076690674,
-0.06523586064577103,
-0.20378899574279785,
-0.7079533338546753,
0.23149219155311584,
0.7509650588035583,
0.6023211479187012,
-0.47126802802085876,
-0.21266432106494904,
0.5008349418640137,
0.2540792226791382,
-0.029971322044730186,
0.5607173442840576,
0.03892890736460686,
-0.2844415307044983,
-0.18659046292304993,
-0.7345853447914124,
-0.3386818468570709,
0.03555144742131233,
-0.5870932340621948,
0.4075179100036621,
-0.21017378568649292,
-0.04976363107562065,
-0.0796607956290245,
0.02315727435052395,
-0.723837673664093,
0.0008648824295960367,
0.17011572420597076,
0.9687053561210632,
-0.6320208311080933,
0.8473039269447327,
1.0315039157867432,
-0.1074955090880394,
-0.5323804020881653,
0.05051438510417938,
0.00940499734133482,
-0.9069575071334839,
0.2815289795398712,
-0.13061369955539703,
-0.12195280939340591,
0.1650574952363968,
-0.10126841068267822,
-0.7511169910430908,
1.0453355312347412,
0.4348655045032501,
-0.49926722049713135,
-0.1533893644809723,
0.10964995622634888,
0.5155044794082642,
-0.34537431597709656,
0.21272273361682892,
0.22495293617248535,
0.5763428211212158,
-0.16438555717468262,
-1.2482837438583374,
0.23498645424842834,
-0.2946985065937042,
0.18012139201164246,
0.362035870552063,
-0.29482999444007874,
0.7381061315536499,
0.13550736010074615,
-0.17428557574748993,
0.9482592940330505,
0.7099206447601318,
0.23017209768295288,
0.06966151297092438,
0.5940806865692139,
0.8318168520927429,
0.514823317527771,
-0.29061341285705566,
0.8019183278083801,
-0.42650121450424194,
0.27015066146850586,
1.1316052675247192,
0.023151954635977745,
0.7713099122047424,
0.4755237400531769,
-0.13650619983673096,
0.4056910276412964,
0.5427030920982361,
0.02922438085079193,
0.4956037402153015,
0.3547837436199188,
-0.22700747847557068,
-0.03818422183394432,
-0.3760065734386444,
-0.7494243383407593,
0.30642250180244446,
0.40521883964538574,
-0.2459244281053543,
-0.3720260560512543,
-0.08033039420843124,
0.29408004879951477,
0.00020066105935256928,
-0.47416913509368896,
0.7648439407348633,
0.08655355125665665,
-0.5309208035469055,
0.32406455278396606,
0.14467008411884308,
0.9097005128860474,
-0.669148862361908,
-0.1783662736415863,
0.006287297699600458,
0.3373452126979828,
-0.12340487539768219,
-0.7807600498199463,
0.2505565285682678,
0.015885639935731888,
0.21714994311332703,
-0.13972413539886475,
0.5213605761528015,
-0.6202099323272705,
-0.44973650574684143,
0.2930210828781128,
0.4260927438735962,
0.226897194981575,
0.1324169635772705,
-0.4811159670352936,
0.24114854633808136,
-0.14175322651863098,
0.06679638475179672,
0.32668524980545044,
0.7976441979408264,
-0.38386279344558716,
0.10915020108222961,
0.2543080747127533,
0.3846389651298523,
0.11624906212091446,
0.34106454253196716,
0.697092592716217,
-0.5154339075088501,
-0.4274470806121826,
-0.9268777966499329,
0.33842048048973083,
0.49628978967666626,
-0.32428473234176636,
0.7647116184234619,
0.7331678867340088,
1.0635656118392944,
-0.1126113086938858,
0.7713743448257446,
-0.2054833173751831,
0.12434838712215424,
-0.5745643973350525,
0.6723576188087463,
-0.5885830521583557,
-0.13754184544086456,
-0.5041909217834473,
-0.8604003190994263,
-0.27788159251213074,
0.4217355251312256,
-0.26821327209472656,
-0.11325113475322723,
0.7560575604438782,
0.4057491421699524,
-0.1746612936258316,
-0.18448397517204285,
0.36735838651657104,
0.020998600870370865,
-0.010924466885626316,
0.630918562412262,
0.8194809556007385,
-0.3536756932735443,
0.49889299273490906,
-0.14964638650417328,
-0.2648772895336151,
-0.23121677339076996,
-0.9618144631385803,
-0.7000032663345337,
-0.970794141292572,
-0.3493051528930664,
-0.1534072309732437,
0.35700228810310364,
0.9292075037956238,
0.4715156853199005,
-0.9854552745819092,
-0.17381742596626282,
0.045824941247701645,
-0.24006089568138123,
-0.06748631596565247,
-0.10545702278614044,
0.4618445932865143,
-0.12665632367134094,
-1.0300328731536865,
0.4017959535121918,
0.539385974407196,
0.12642964720726013,
0.06596929579973221,
-0.12969394028186798,
-0.12350128591060638,
-0.16565795242786407,
0.2791174352169037,
0.23739764094352722,
-0.8771467208862305,
-0.6382979154586792,
-0.17422029376029968,
0.15539561212062836,
0.32565420866012573,
1.0474469661712646,
-0.534013032913208,
0.4191734790802002,
0.5331518650054932,
0.6290877461433411,
0.6075860261917114,
-0.20579048991203308,
0.6469842195510864,
-0.41470950841903687,
0.38305145502090454,
0.29910990595817566,
0.9333891272544861,
0.41834694147109985,
-0.12386025488376617,
0.6178364157676697,
0.15763504803180695,
-0.5219751596450806,
-0.7679616212844849,
0.1544293910264969,
-1.1690785884857178,
-0.15398363769054413,
0.7510061860084534,
-0.46518659591674805,
-0.29664555191993713,
-0.2209792286157608,
-0.41871780157089233,
0.595588743686676,
-0.17713141441345215,
0.6856400370597839,
0.7117347121238708,
-0.05707526206970215,
-0.30034223198890686,
-0.46892738342285156,
0.3647792339324951,
0.35716351866722107,
-0.9366838335990906,
-0.16740092635154724,
0.1947491466999054,
0.3631286323070526,
0.351629376411438,
0.5964833498001099,
-0.38050028681755066,
0.45928025245666504,
-0.14487528800964355,
-0.0041796923615038395,
-0.1069922000169754,
-0.07454168796539307,
-0.505903422832489,
-0.07748601585626602,
0.4493103325366974,
-0.12124407291412354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12843v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12843v1
|
Towards Logically Consistent Language Models via Probabilistic Reasoning
| 2024-04-19T12:23:57 | 2024-04-19T12:23:57 |
Diego Calanzone, Stefano Teso, Antonio Vergari
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are a promising venue for natural language
understanding and generation tasks. However, current LLMs are far from
reliable: they are prone to generate non-factual information and, more
crucially, to contradict themselves when prompted to reason about beliefs of
the world. These problems are currently addressed with large scale fine-tuning
or by delegating consistent reasoning to external tools. In this work, we
strive for a middle ground and introduce a training objective based on
principled probabilistic reasoning that teaches a LLM to be consistent with
external knowledge in the form of a set of facts and rules. Fine-tuning with
our loss on a limited set of facts enables our LLMs to be more logically
consistent than previous baselines and allows them to extrapolate to unseen but
semantically similar factual knowledge more systematically.
|
[
-0.019178811460733414,
-0.9086681604385376,
0.9862470626831055,
-0.081261046230793,
-0.1273140013217926,
-0.2809339761734009,
-0.5840457677841187,
-0.08002472668886185,
-0.3074011206626892,
0.7391794323921204,
-0.6474546194076538,
-0.4166205823421478,
-0.46792998909950256,
-0.13757437467575073,
-0.2657063901424408,
0.8798934817314148,
-0.007991354912519455,
-0.12743008136749268,
0.05956770479679108,
-0.07260069996118546,
-0.3574095070362091,
-0.3249202072620392,
-0.736716628074646,
-0.4842073321342468,
0.3967527151107788,
0.5029693841934204,
0.9733135104179382,
0.5416541695594788,
0.3578636050224304,
0.2240481674671173,
0.19782686233520508,
0.6112325191497803,
-0.5457795262336731,
0.020608197897672653,
-0.7509462833404541,
-0.6177778244018555,
0.23006537556648254,
0.05332056060433388,
0.6829373836517334,
0.831547200679779,
-0.4004332721233368,
0.027481500059366226,
0.16349981725215912,
0.5076006650924683,
-0.5898095369338989,
0.4722455143928528,
-1.117513656616211,
-0.09730535745620728,
-0.06850045919418335,
-0.24116210639476776,
-0.6083728075027466,
-0.5740146636962891,
-0.1115279346704483,
-0.7254118323326111,
0.19029439985752106,
0.15241390466690063,
0.809073805809021,
0.28479447960853577,
-0.39716556668281555,
-0.2571861743927002,
-0.7341473698616028,
0.8221933841705322,
-0.704306960105896,
0.5734396576881409,
0.5392230749130249,
0.1852860152721405,
-0.7445852756500244,
-0.34903332591056824,
-0.8848271369934082,
-0.3957705795764923,
0.1376013308763504,
-0.08387334644794464,
0.166610985994339,
-0.02070835791528225,
0.17499355971813202,
-0.036732934415340424,
-0.38261640071868896,
0.08751051872968674,
0.22948488593101501,
-0.09968042373657227,
0.6944104433059692,
0.0316099114716053,
-0.015511409379541874,
0.21768274903297424,
-0.12038079649209976,
0.03700249269604683,
-0.9894886016845703,
-0.08251296728849411,
0.5511971712112427,
0.4379325211048126,
0.008369612507522106,
0.6939913630485535,
-0.29010045528411865,
0.8484380841255188,
0.17036016285419464,
-0.5331119298934937,
0.013466528616845608,
-0.19185438752174377,
-0.24507297575473785,
0.05884791165590286,
0.6523603200912476,
0.40712329745292664,
0.7238681316375732,
-0.10145861655473709,
-0.1893271803855896,
0.2819163501262665,
0.020522797480225563,
-0.41342827677726746,
-0.4157256782054901,
-0.04527682811021805,
-0.1542700231075287,
-0.3156369626522064,
-0.08736975491046906,
-0.11160501837730408,
-0.2741333246231079,
-0.8114994168281555,
0.6017348170280457,
-0.7378228306770325,
-0.1499911993741989,
0.3894888460636139,
0.16716043651103973,
0.07368198782205582,
0.5636319518089294,
-1.0949797630310059,
0.09245289117097855,
0.9745079278945923,
0.42932000756263733,
0.36325737833976746,
-0.1754898875951767,
-0.768149197101593,
0.5627607107162476,
-0.7284324169158936,
0.6023162007331848,
-0.6737892031669617,
0.05998195335268974,
0.1622011661529541,
-0.02944372594356537,
0.07542555779218674,
-0.5333350300788879,
0.7582194805145264,
-0.41297492384910583,
0.06891972571611404,
-0.3483341634273529,
-0.8056870698928833,
-0.12337977439165115,
0.46932363510131836,
-0.09128490835428238,
0.6974127888679504,
-0.0673586055636406,
-0.7863790392875671,
0.5952449440956116,
0.1129799634218216,
-0.27290254831314087,
-0.12122011929750443,
-0.4315774738788605,
-0.3655467629432678,
0.1841287910938263,
-0.008641685359179974,
0.47280776500701904,
-0.37172889709472656,
0.7669059038162231,
-0.4527309834957123,
-0.1739557832479477,
0.25942355394363403,
-0.5673677325248718,
0.547403872013092,
0.24945880472660065,
-0.2793428897857666,
-0.010740923695266247,
-0.8096150159835815,
0.015837429091334343,
0.025745920836925507,
-0.5048822164535522,
-0.2151661217212677,
0.45610129833221436,
-0.23898380994796753,
0.27780428528785706,
0.11480904370546341,
-0.6270760297775269,
0.15095601975917816,
-0.3161121904850006,
0.2584656774997711,
0.8583853840827942,
-0.025927597656846046,
0.20337530970573425,
-0.6335723996162415,
-0.17213338613510132,
0.16704405844211578,
-0.016399264335632324,
-0.07182776182889938,
-0.42438068985939026,
-0.6869864463806152,
-0.34403228759765625,
0.0892728865146637,
0.4775755703449249,
-0.6100567579269409,
0.8154030442237854,
-0.08245735615491867,
-0.3819357752799988,
-0.34554895758628845,
0.4064810276031494,
0.1894892305135727,
0.7549461722373962,
0.21029764413833618,
0.020251167938113213,
-0.6749786138534546,
-0.8899458050727844,
-0.3797604441642761,
-0.2743232846260071,
-0.07698282599449158,
-0.054419949650764465,
0.3064576983451843,
-0.22672352194786072,
0.9748982191085815,
-0.21824227273464203,
-0.2699800431728363,
-0.5024339556694031,
0.06027762591838837,
0.4227919280529022,
0.6501762866973877,
0.055071134120225906,
-0.5902831554412842,
-0.3791757822036743,
-0.06337765604257584,
-0.8448500633239746,
-0.05402755364775658,
-0.42369145154953003,
-0.04314688965678215,
0.2965405583381653,
0.6839558482170105,
-0.8810573220252991,
0.1067504808306694,
0.5156508684158325,
-0.12402737885713577,
0.5491659641265869,
-0.44925960898399353,
-0.12806716561317444,
-0.9255402684211731,
-0.17435814440250397,
0.21198421716690063,
-0.38697224855422974,
-0.31564030051231384,
-0.0680428221821785,
-0.1744062453508377,
0.13810785114765167,
-0.2371097058057785,
0.5702590942382812,
-0.18168069422245026,
0.26327693462371826,
-0.2318786233663559,
0.19813306629657745,
0.01714886911213398,
0.1832490712404251,
0.362842321395874,
0.527643620967865,
0.5272218585014343,
-0.5854718685150146,
0.3776519000530243,
0.1491347998380661,
-0.6362388730049133,
0.636053740978241,
-0.4495694935321808,
-0.29287487268447876,
-0.24951419234275818,
0.3963530659675598,
-0.6313043832778931,
-0.22267644107341766,
0.14711256325244904,
-0.17946851253509521,
0.3276672661304474,
-0.11927354335784912,
-0.8403202295303345,
-0.03921796381473541,
0.04793364554643631,
-0.059005361050367355,
0.785163402557373,
-0.7029960751533508,
0.4805673658847809,
0.2838408052921295,
0.07270430028438568,
-0.4518386423587799,
-0.46104589104652405,
-0.11353226751089096,
-0.02633056603372097,
-0.6450175642967224,
0.051125604659318924,
0.09083981812000275,
-0.5495271682739258,
-0.06066037714481354,
-0.21963974833488464,
0.1823156774044037,
0.12019497901201248,
0.09318413585424423,
0.010146950371563435,
-0.22641803324222565,
0.2724783718585968,
-0.24107247591018677,
-0.17826581001281738,
0.12295182049274445,
-0.7126013040542603,
0.31638792157173157,
-0.13476185500621796,
-0.6993255019187927,
-0.6645686030387878,
0.12406650930643082,
0.1117921769618988,
-0.06389261037111282,
1.0876356363296509,
0.41647210717201233,
-0.5042928457260132,
-0.518253743648529,
-0.6878722906112671,
-0.15253597497940063,
-0.4437505006790161,
0.24422825872898102,
-0.5716853737831116,
-0.8053113222122192,
0.3391360938549042,
-0.18113884329795837,
0.16912445425987244,
0.4417766332626343,
0.6458575129508972,
-0.24385327100753784,
0.9747252464294434,
0.6527547240257263,
0.2847559154033661,
0.16117198765277863,
0.11636827141046524,
0.2950928509235382,
-0.41820430755615234,
-0.3010740280151367,
-0.32043400406837463,
0.11787358671426773,
-0.7119370698928833,
-0.44387587904930115,
0.01633782498538494,
0.5393100380897522,
-0.6245840787887573,
0.11852805316448212,
-0.1102222353219986,
0.6573764085769653,
0.849204421043396,
0.16875120997428894,
0.13846655189990997,
-0.16902419924736023,
-0.3223971724510193,
0.03545070067048073,
-0.7741712331771851,
-0.8841887712478638,
0.9397187232971191,
0.3180428445339203,
1.0820285081863403,
0.021885305643081665,
0.7008944153785706,
-0.04972945898771286,
0.2631167769432068,
-0.4495687186717987,
0.5670766234397888,
-0.09271162003278732,
-0.5706320405006409,
-0.3197319209575653,
-0.5253129005432129,
-0.6668162941932678,
0.047210462391376495,
-0.3110692799091339,
-0.890620768070221,
-0.10588766634464264,
0.3804384469985962,
-0.07922545820474625,
0.5685864090919495,
-0.4585532546043396,
0.9565752148628235,
-0.14764592051506042,
-0.5197626948356628,
-0.3363502621650696,
-0.7218315601348877,
0.39676710963249207,
-0.1768837869167328,
0.42717140913009644,
-0.4636514186859131,
0.34599271416664124,
0.27232638001441956,
-0.42533570528030396,
1.0212147235870361,
-0.15130658447742462,
-0.296808660030365,
0.541858434677124,
0.28694579005241394,
0.772558867931366,
0.35339680314064026,
-0.09283879399299622,
0.0291108600795269,
-0.15491034090518951,
-0.3578481376171112,
-0.48603764176368713,
0.5457293391227722,
-0.7411817312240601,
-0.8060172200202942,
-0.30013853311538696,
-0.7717459797859192,
-0.48435336351394653,
0.03026026301085949,
0.06872740387916565,
0.37241795659065247,
-0.022899441421031952,
0.1795126497745514,
1.1225942373275757,
-0.28828009963035583,
-0.04731805622577667,
0.5139862298965454,
-0.005618705414235592,
-0.04173247516155243,
0.9049996137619019,
0.023971153423190117,
0.3154808580875397,
0.8068675994873047,
0.32325416803359985,
-0.4807419180870056,
-0.5154802203178406,
-0.19935554265975952,
0.16227181255817413,
-0.8022993206977844,
-0.16846443712711334,
-0.435246080160141,
-0.16293081641197205,
-0.28709080815315247,
-0.2479572594165802,
-0.33694782853126526,
-0.2536865174770355,
-0.22466956079006195,
-0.05622722953557968,
0.2513470947742462,
0.4030037224292755,
-0.2772125005722046,
0.2826961576938629,
-0.83414626121521,
0.3237472474575043,
0.3900373578071594,
0.2996745705604553,
-0.49345964193344116,
-0.8490403294563293,
-0.07391460239887238,
0.2078671008348465,
-0.326682984828949,
-0.5483677387237549,
0.03904636576771736,
0.3843212127685547,
0.7601768970489502,
0.5083144903182983,
0.09464161098003387,
0.41558200120925903,
-0.9082269072532654,
0.46076419949531555,
0.31141340732574463,
-0.9186192750930786,
0.7779238224029541,
-0.6665441393852234,
0.10557655990123749,
0.593616247177124,
0.4183900058269501,
-0.5875733494758606,
-0.6817764639854431,
-0.8378321528434753,
-0.5476375818252563,
0.4981011748313904,
-0.04222119227051735,
0.06238076835870743,
-0.36353421211242676,
0.3668557107448578,
0.2049824446439743,
0.2561788260936737,
-0.5073230862617493,
0.22986456751823425,
-0.01696295291185379,
-0.8392984867095947,
-0.2971476912498474,
-0.15916943550109863,
-0.35600441694259644,
0.004308410454541445,
1.0433367490768433,
-0.3984392285346985,
-0.22581663727760315,
-0.04872780293226242,
-0.06647400557994843,
-0.11477350443601608,
0.358006089925766,
0.6247193813323975,
0.903824508190155,
-0.17713934183120728,
0.6131804585456848,
0.10824636369943619,
0.020951077342033386,
0.18292418122291565,
-0.027070509269833565,
-0.28123563528060913,
-0.05838864669203758,
0.5017588138580322,
0.6210143566131592,
0.27453330159187317,
-0.90262770652771,
0.48528149724006653,
0.21561454236507416,
-0.28597620129585266,
-0.40764617919921875,
0.32960766553878784,
0.40707942843437195,
0.3970429003238678,
0.0657542273402214,
0.19463896751403809,
-0.3299942910671234,
-0.8107869029045105,
0.39284494519233704,
0.5163585543632507,
-0.14321528375148773,
-0.29304811358451843,
0.7518714070320129,
-0.034733884036540985,
-0.1469448059797287,
0.6722703576087952,
-0.3262568414211273,
-0.31048908829689026,
0.31684035062789917,
0.6775084137916565,
0.5027045011520386,
-0.0382160022854805,
0.1571933627128601,
0.26038825511932373,
0.4468638300895691,
-0.702381432056427,
0.4209585189819336,
0.22207631170749664,
-1.1337367296218872,
-0.6398136019706726,
-0.8930357098579407,
-0.5288932919502258,
0.14424245059490204,
-0.1872047781944275,
0.31913328170776367,
-0.6012260913848877,
0.10905176401138306,
-0.1390881985425949,
-0.12208912521600723,
-0.5750771164894104,
0.46329474449157715,
0.25971078872680664,
1.088842749595642,
-0.8869102597236633,
1.10707426071167,
0.5098951458930969,
-0.36672651767730713,
-1.1036930084228516,
-0.06534896790981293,
0.03337018936872482,
-0.7319623827934265,
0.8029602766036987,
0.1787525713443756,
-0.055527910590171814,
-0.16827405989170074,
-0.6001083850860596,
-0.796642541885376,
0.5255131721496582,
0.8631464242935181,
-1.052108883857727,
0.19870568811893463,
0.16202309727668762,
0.3885834217071533,
-0.35528144240379333,
-0.12724721431732178,
0.5393823385238647,
0.38366401195526123,
0.1540716588497162,
-0.856853723526001,
0.041415970772504807,
0.27309080958366394,
-0.09587673842906952,
0.1270550787448883,
-0.5735616683959961,
0.7067784667015076,
-0.5630246996879578,
0.04676924645900726,
-0.11516523361206055,
0.7177783846855164,
0.6147040724754333,
0.04952717944979668,
0.41906923055648804,
0.9306498765945435,
0.9719086289405823,
-0.2555566728115082,
0.959723711013794,
-0.4427019953727722,
0.30199134349823,
1.4854930639266968,
-0.5019373893737793,
0.9238626956939697,
0.39476919174194336,
0.019953029230237007,
0.3632625341415405,
0.5686516761779785,
0.10131148993968964,
0.6027811169624329,
0.3702656924724579,
-0.47117623686790466,
-0.8481610417366028,
-0.11380509287118912,
-0.08792520314455032,
0.4456530213356018,
0.2508704662322998,
-0.21454063057899475,
-0.19639725983142853,
-0.29555296897888184,
-0.01712854579091072,
0.5076609253883362,
-0.2988361716270447,
0.6534162163734436,
0.13463658094406128,
-0.6769671440124512,
0.537950336933136,
0.18518121540546417,
0.4214296042919159,
-0.6569894552230835,
0.022059770300984383,
-0.008599591441452503,
0.6427760124206543,
-0.13377562165260315,
-0.9167143702507019,
0.43805211782455444,
-0.18442915380001068,
-0.19901143014431,
-0.21095488965511322,
0.5348902940750122,
-0.626741886138916,
-0.5757886171340942,
-0.10434489697217941,
0.3585529923439026,
-0.014514237642288208,
0.09223929792642593,
-0.4733780026435852,
0.003376223612576723,
-0.05408160388469696,
-0.16468249261379242,
0.3217346668243408,
1.030194640159607,
-0.0787094235420227,
0.8315070867538452,
0.6335378885269165,
0.18524718284606934,
-0.0725637897849083,
0.2340272217988968,
0.5219793915748596,
-0.4739890992641449,
-0.49541911482810974,
-0.9928085803985596,
0.21658232808113098,
0.16163493692874908,
-0.22681400179862976,
0.7473006844520569,
0.45973721146583557,
1.0851329565048218,
0.06540753692388535,
0.8241310715675354,
0.19226570427417755,
0.5027478337287903,
-0.7952158451080322,
0.3435720205307007,
-0.24949988722801208,
0.16575610637664795,
0.012756605632603168,
-0.9692038893699646,
-0.2948755919933319,
0.9786385297775269,
-0.24769774079322815,
-0.18130873143672943,
0.48768818378448486,
0.6826991438865662,
-0.11436168849468231,
0.02098379097878933,
0.36694806814193726,
0.22905872762203217,
0.3568464517593384,
0.5698726773262024,
0.9599536061286926,
-0.0857226774096489,
0.26995161175727844,
0.05838892236351967,
-0.16739562153816223,
-0.008747012354433537,
-1.0291694402694702,
-0.7808319926261902,
-0.29732462763786316,
-0.43961653113365173,
-0.20682628452777863,
0.3550359010696411,
1.1772868633270264,
0.7068373560905457,
-0.8972528576850891,
-0.09478931128978729,
-0.5981261730194092,
0.12360331416130066,
-0.13578267395496368,
-0.15396879613399506,
0.13942918181419373,
-0.8342087268829346,
-0.3892037570476532,
0.3024139702320099,
0.31853488087654114,
-0.2137591540813446,
-0.08419926464557648,
-0.17312869429588318,
-0.3295074701309204,
0.34695470333099365,
0.5223221182823181,
0.2073720544576645,
-0.7930248379707336,
-0.8445078134536743,
-0.5094408392906189,
-0.12678200006484985,
-0.15121176838874817,
0.4851084053516388,
-0.6601206660270691,
0.11994317173957825,
0.3968062400817871,
0.7426551580429077,
0.1567443162202835,
-0.08896537125110626,
0.594521701335907,
-0.8582069277763367,
0.1874401569366455,
0.08989524841308594,
0.5357625484466553,
0.5347413420677185,
-0.0191855076700449,
0.43057507276535034,
0.3618117868900299,
-0.6800260543823242,
-0.7335936427116394,
0.45439645648002625,
-0.7223076820373535,
-0.28866371512413025,
1.2580592632293701,
-0.36299747228622437,
-0.028050344437360764,
-0.1150415688753128,
-0.09098687767982483,
0.361120343208313,
-0.137064129114151,
0.6665210723876953,
0.5912759304046631,
-0.062277473509311676,
-0.11839606612920761,
-0.5746809244155884,
0.5316253304481506,
0.3692432641983032,
-0.7887125611305237,
0.2749028503894806,
0.5235915780067444,
0.5745736956596375,
0.0308395866304636,
0.6146718859672546,
0.22831082344055176,
-0.013584727421402931,
0.1235937774181366,
-0.09144587814807892,
0.2261117845773697,
-0.5339662432670593,
0.027514565736055374,
0.14945460855960846,
0.37620747089385986,
0.13990065455436707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12829v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12829v1
|
LiMe: a Latin Corpus of Late Medieval Criminal Sentences
| 2024-04-19T12:06:28 | 2024-04-19T12:06:28 |
Alessandra Bassani, Beatrice Del Bo, Alfio Ferrara, Marta Mangini, Sergio Picascia, Ambra Stefanello
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Latin language has received attention from the computational linguistics
research community, which has built, over the years, several valuable
resources, ranging from detailed annotated corpora to sophisticated tools for
linguistic analysis. With the recent advent of large language models,
researchers have also started developing models capable of generating vector
representations of Latin texts. The performances of such models remain behind
the ones for modern languages, given the disparity in available data. In this
paper, we present the LiMe dataset, a corpus of 325 documents extracted from a
series of medieval manuscripts called Libri sententiarum potestatis Mediolani,
and thoroughly annotated by experts, in order to be employed for masked
language model, as well as supervised natural language processing tasks.
|
[
0.24635185301303864,
-0.7088857293128967,
0.4916534423828125,
0.12383589893579483,
-0.21615365147590637,
0.2701963186264038,
-0.19841091334819794,
-0.5432984232902527,
0.4666065573692322,
0.9648916721343994,
-0.04546911641955376,
-0.5121826529502869,
-0.15698416531085968,
0.15323345363140106,
-0.5439710021018982,
1.0640956163406372,
-0.01729547046124935,
0.3532664477825165,
0.4982825517654419,
0.0475018173456192,
-0.796349048614502,
-0.5651803612709045,
-0.18502068519592285,
-0.060799162834882736,
0.3626485764980316,
0.011824646033346653,
0.7772882580757141,
0.41246628761291504,
0.53260737657547,
0.3720020353794098,
0.05736858770251274,
0.5181054472923279,
-0.74418044090271,
0.21383629739284515,
-0.4721123278141022,
-0.506829559803009,
-0.3362184762954712,
0.17766091227531433,
0.3241911828517914,
0.3825836181640625,
0.23493824899196625,
-0.25642260909080505,
-0.3738923668861389,
0.5473242998123169,
-0.5841090679168701,
0.1212349608540535,
-0.6836888194084167,
-0.08468097448348999,
-0.567535400390625,
-0.5165264010429382,
-0.976650059223175,
-0.771172821521759,
-0.059775568544864655,
-0.8798224925994873,
0.22945436835289001,
0.029708977788686752,
0.4914586544036865,
-0.057200267910957336,
-0.20325928926467896,
-0.6416775584220886,
-0.9473559856414795,
0.6812663674354553,
-0.06748773157596588,
-0.343015193939209,
0.4297604560852051,
0.4590683579444885,
-0.6772888898849487,
-0.9594786167144775,
-0.32942941784858704,
-0.08848385512828827,
-0.25716885924339294,
0.019578762352466583,
-0.29011666774749756,
0.10703016817569733,
-0.15162311494350433,
0.25654464960098267,
-0.592276930809021,
-0.24278524518013,
-0.8423835039138794,
-0.5381269454956055,
0.5517522096633911,
0.19497473537921906,
-0.047079749405384064,
0.020435987040400505,
-0.14283597469329834,
-0.11321967095136642,
-0.9988538026809692,
-0.061996717005968094,
0.7818941473960876,
0.3189358711242676,
-0.05220983177423477,
0.5199242830276489,
0.09016487747430801,
0.6898840665817261,
-0.058595068752765656,
-0.3587096333503723,
0.25681817531585693,
-0.1601610630750656,
-0.09705092012882233,
0.23620007932186127,
0.42358025908470154,
0.414057195186615,
0.7927725911140442,
-0.17486540973186493,
-0.18141813576221466,
0.44328010082244873,
0.5185834169387817,
-0.8951525092124939,
-0.5700471997261047,
0.26214444637298584,
-0.386603981256485,
-0.41436561942100525,
0.016633333638310432,
-0.37919381260871887,
-0.683221697807312,
-0.12753543257713318,
-0.15387378633022308,
-0.5560987591743469,
-0.02731781266629696,
0.07415894418954849,
-0.3934078812599182,
-0.008901126682758331,
0.8204939365386963,
-0.39440298080444336,
0.3728047013282776,
0.5478410124778748,
0.7513119578361511,
-0.27176958322525024,
0.30293557047843933,
-0.7679435014724731,
0.2832149863243103,
-0.5420086979866028,
0.5677068829536438,
-0.7135500907897949,
-0.4165953993797302,
0.25085628032684326,
0.4652232527732849,
0.2483072578907013,
-0.5250272750854492,
0.8411788940429688,
-0.8319519758224487,
-0.09390181303024292,
0.2541878819465637,
-0.593320906162262,
-0.1867751032114029,
-0.09313030540943146,
-0.6436725854873657,
0.8007479310035706,
0.24083934724330902,
-0.948428750038147,
0.062293656170368195,
-0.13470524549484253,
-0.3334898352622986,
0.6852089762687683,
-0.6094523668289185,
0.13496804237365723,
0.22151416540145874,
-0.27056795358657837,
0.31206488609313965,
-0.13471798598766327,
0.5610280632972717,
-0.19487158954143524,
-0.566967785358429,
0.6792237758636475,
-0.337058424949646,
1.1225961446762085,
0.5498834848403931,
-0.10138987004756927,
-0.000519817927852273,
-0.6545344591140747,
-0.3740556836128235,
-0.1641213297843933,
-0.14421086013317108,
-0.5400597453117371,
-0.05872892215847969,
0.8670231103897095,
0.050899021327495575,
0.3782377243041992,
-0.9053800702095032,
0.23158171772956848,
-0.4035927355289459,
0.4283255934715271,
0.7758700847625732,
-0.12748607993125916,
0.11870773881673813,
-0.2781766951084137,
0.6879507303237915,
-0.10029648244380951,
-0.12862585484981537,
-0.18034444749355316,
-0.37832748889923096,
-0.34481003880500793,
-0.6401804685592651,
0.6384015679359436,
0.9657289385795593,
-0.8079562187194824,
0.2299780696630478,
-0.13199299573898315,
-0.5310141444206238,
-0.7081203460693359,
-0.2328091412782669,
0.28930044174194336,
0.08620668947696686,
0.12496858835220337,
-0.25290000438690186,
-0.4780130684375763,
-1.0557115077972412,
-0.08956345170736313,
-0.20378872752189636,
0.14464665949344635,
0.3695805072784424,
0.878900408744812,
-0.022206049412488937,
1.2151602506637573,
-0.6517016291618347,
-0.4519631862640381,
-0.10671857744455338,
0.16647368669509888,
0.5159432888031006,
0.481785386800766,
0.7195561528205872,
-0.8235270977020264,
-0.3028625249862671,
0.11558118462562561,
-0.6716840863227844,
-0.27429598569869995,
-0.13986192643642426,
-0.048597048968076706,
0.11794324964284897,
0.6883834004402161,
-0.16505181789398193,
0.87221360206604,
0.10762307792901993,
-0.5078988671302795,
0.7698073387145996,
-0.33404260873794556,
0.23130424320697784,
-0.8439669609069824,
0.033586885780096054,
-0.5329921245574951,
-0.8696866631507874,
-0.7591215968132019,
0.024183599278330803,
0.2634618580341339,
0.016398174688220024,
-0.7156349420547485,
0.6184209585189819,
-0.3800458312034607,
0.2409561723470688,
-0.44130799174308777,
0.1300571709871292,
-0.35005319118499756,
0.3154720962047577,
0.41186052560806274,
0.6872279047966003,
0.4450235664844513,
-0.05993242934346199,
0.46797993779182434,
-0.005299634300172329,
-0.24103102087974548,
0.5480353832244873,
-0.6345883011817932,
0.028832674026489258,
-0.12349037826061249,
0.0825691893696785,
-0.7005128860473633,
-0.2312781661748886,
-0.14719605445861816,
-0.3586467504501343,
0.3854996860027313,
-0.5346866250038147,
-0.6978483200073242,
-0.13884755969047546,
-0.35900449752807617,
0.6848894357681274,
0.10022478550672531,
0.0342000275850296,
0.21369624137878418,
0.6819729804992676,
-0.28523313999176025,
-0.6946277618408203,
-0.6025854349136353,
0.16949725151062012,
-0.2605939507484436,
-0.6722698211669922,
0.6490349173545837,
-0.1622554063796997,
-0.7480971217155457,
-0.13282255828380585,
0.41597142815589905,
-0.287343829870224,
0.12525179982185364,
0.600174605846405,
0.3866880238056183,
-0.1449984908103943,
0.19382941722869873,
-0.07104609906673431,
0.1975158303976059,
-0.18192891776561737,
-0.11311624944210052,
0.7242655158042908,
-0.05822800472378731,
0.13140346109867096,
-0.05353319272398949,
0.4798126816749573,
0.3406165838241577,
-0.14810657501220703,
0.6738043427467346,
0.0016176976496353745,
-0.4153297245502472,
-0.09443334490060806,
-0.2876984775066376,
0.007368287071585655,
-0.45163583755493164,
-0.04510272666811943,
-0.36077621579170227,
-1.0700485706329346,
0.5835720896720886,
0.07799924910068512,
0.08165017515420914,
0.31320491433143616,
0.723490834236145,
0.1289578378200531,
0.20834732055664062,
0.5253849029541016,
-0.2837718725204468,
0.2592892646789551,
0.0010292315855622292,
-0.020653098821640015,
-0.1284230798482895,
0.21094007790088654,
-0.46103769540786743,
0.06328210234642029,
-1.028399109840393,
-0.6486132740974426,
0.4667726755142212,
-0.05407250300049782,
0.037736114114522934,
0.34317833185195923,
-0.29139551520347595,
0.6048119068145752,
0.36354249715805054,
-0.03310808166861534,
0.3062354624271393,
0.0686824768781662,
-0.16785089671611786,
0.03835137188434601,
-0.19553150236606598,
-0.8486696481704712,
1.2124522924423218,
0.2598024606704712,
0.7714032530784607,
0.3728850781917572,
0.6200070977210999,
0.9746720194816589,
0.06366721540689468,
-0.27287670969963074,
0.22859066724777222,
-0.26241764426231384,
-1.1539511680603027,
0.22198420763015747,
-0.14514416456222534,
-1.3510806560516357,
0.24485278129577637,
-0.034324295818805695,
-0.7189528942108154,
0.6080527305603027,
-0.24786680936813354,
-0.5769985318183899,
-0.2761497497558594,
-0.37974536418914795,
0.6926814317703247,
0.03162279352545738,
-0.615451991558075,
-0.298820823431015,
-0.6740522980690002,
0.46145421266555786,
-0.1575344055891037,
0.43733349442481995,
0.11752034723758698,
0.25922664999961853,
0.8373045325279236,
-0.7413667440414429,
0.8471553325653076,
-0.007389528211206198,
-0.03876461088657379,
0.5575469136238098,
0.4535607099533081,
0.5364627242088318,
0.15123635530471802,
0.22774598002433777,
-0.3778105676174164,
0.3169000446796417,
-0.5280274748802185,
-0.00407981313765049,
0.6160626411437988,
-0.4718233048915863,
-0.07993259280920029,
-0.9470260143280029,
-0.7661424279212952,
0.4408963918685913,
0.17773638665676117,
0.2131875455379486,
0.7318031787872314,
-0.4308411180973053,
0.28692004084587097,
0.7593792676925659,
-0.2352149784564972,
0.5692695379257202,
0.7129607200622559,
-0.34384849667549133,
-0.4189595878124237,
0.5217930674552917,
0.09265808761119843,
-0.022736147046089172,
0.36345043778419495,
-0.39504432678222656,
0.23367878794670105,
-0.7209516763687134,
-0.3438248932361603,
0.3089369833469391,
-0.49410635232925415,
-0.18560698628425598,
-0.5701335072517395,
-0.22275610268115997,
-0.5814323425292969,
-0.47722482681274414,
-0.2471427023410797,
-0.6107693910598755,
-0.3902996778488159,
0.04610063508152962,
0.5320780873298645,
0.8888228535652161,
0.2102496474981308,
0.6500729322433472,
-0.4475352466106415,
0.30788591504096985,
-0.1466778963804245,
-0.27695292234420776,
-0.5877599716186523,
-0.538233757019043,
-0.3674289882183075,
-0.25988638401031494,
-0.1595924198627472,
-1.4014769792556763,
0.9530442357063293,
-0.1803448349237442,
0.06403205543756485,
0.4022625684738159,
0.21792489290237427,
0.4040684998035431,
-0.6794130206108093,
0.5710411071777344,
-0.3133798837661743,
-0.4084360599517822,
0.4850505590438843,
-0.6673951148986816,
-0.12001939117908478,
0.5650334358215332,
0.19697235524654388,
-0.41393083333969116,
-0.6288046836853027,
-0.624221920967102,
-0.8028469681739807,
0.5836936831474304,
0.8412131071090698,
-0.15319040417671204,
-0.1421028971672058,
0.1994478404521942,
0.335799902677536,
0.26981601119041443,
-0.9001287817955017,
-0.3107911944389343,
0.11009757965803146,
-0.2854923903942108,
0.035713374614715576,
-0.1300405114889145,
0.07191325724124908,
0.07033579051494598,
0.6332219839096069,
-0.03738422691822052,
0.1607998013496399,
0.15282824635505676,
-0.8222731351852417,
0.23101969063282013,
0.14195337891578674,
0.774664580821991,
0.8342733383178711,
-0.5903462171554565,
0.16591188311576843,
-0.2809517979621887,
-0.9774571061134338,
-0.024278586730360985,
0.2858048677444458,
-0.4656812250614166,
0.14886046946048737,
0.6339524984359741,
0.3558153212070465,
-0.3909726142883301,
-1.0099751949310303,
0.7171370387077332,
-0.1363932490348816,
0.3076537251472473,
-1.2357240915298462,
-0.017974382266402245,
-0.35781219601631165,
0.49417173862457275,
0.4428688585758209,
-0.13385266065597534,
0.34718677401542664,
-0.8384915590286255,
0.16350118815898895,
0.25435173511505127,
-0.354483962059021,
-0.1731024831533432,
0.3405910134315491,
-0.03334444761276245,
-0.11751243472099304,
0.2460685819387436,
-0.43298283219337463,
-0.5300008654594421,
0.29309317469596863,
0.31654804944992065,
0.5655099749565125,
-0.16617414355278015,
0.31183919310569763,
0.035315174609422684,
0.6289473176002502,
0.1272950917482376,
0.49504804611206055,
0.1697646826505661,
-0.5021475553512573,
-0.3805456757545471,
-0.8084469437599182,
0.10190846025943756,
0.14832213521003723,
-0.2720205783843994,
0.16750800609588623,
-0.3844650089740753,
-0.07906151562929153,
0.17433695495128632,
-0.00903522688895464,
-0.4327186048030853,
0.06072556599974632,
-0.07763129472732544,
0.8650462627410889,
-0.938190758228302,
1.117711067199707,
0.12045612931251526,
-0.3506716191768646,
-0.08408861607313156,
-0.7988810539245605,
0.02058374136686325,
-0.647610068321228,
0.9291632175445557,
0.06426312774419785,
-0.160088911652565,
-0.553939700126648,
-0.6423419713973999,
-0.3726273477077484,
0.7200477719306946,
0.25067993998527527,
-0.6077324151992798,
-0.004669560585170984,
0.14179769158363342,
0.8337085843086243,
-0.9075110554695129,
0.2956011891365051,
0.662830650806427,
0.18922464549541473,
-0.13513292372226715,
-0.6581523418426514,
-0.23731473088264465,
-0.5873767137527466,
-0.28758710622787476,
0.2100527286529541,
-0.1533573716878891,
1.1023740768432617,
0.4455612599849701,
-0.0750354528427124,
0.3425792455673218,
0.7879144549369812,
0.15178745985031128,
0.06380555778741837,
0.13525089621543884,
0.43673422932624817,
0.9001681804656982,
-0.15344838798046112,
0.9587163925170898,
-0.04902871698141098,
-0.15343403816223145,
1.2853827476501465,
-0.2812425196170807,
0.6421898007392883,
0.32287395000457764,
-0.07829585671424866,
0.6167696118354797,
0.8288077116012573,
-0.023143768310546875,
0.6533510684967041,
0.721502959728241,
-0.26725858449935913,
-0.10319046676158905,
-0.3565865159034729,
-0.06140177324414253,
0.3637681007385254,
0.5848760604858398,
-0.6923847198486328,
0.16177886724472046,
-0.05477898195385933,
0.29078319668769836,
0.13999637961387634,
-0.5577825307846069,
0.6352046728134155,
-0.18939806520938873,
-0.5688551664352417,
0.4536469578742981,
0.21073271334171295,
0.32477128505706787,
-0.22716973721981049,
-0.24686715006828308,
-0.2837027609348297,
0.3593278229236603,
-0.0626039132475853,
-0.651157557964325,
0.04820043966174126,
0.39823606610298157,
-0.34629541635513306,
-0.33034786581993103,
0.8182550668716431,
-0.4487491250038147,
-0.6837053298950195,
0.13341550529003143,
0.14705820381641388,
0.9641227722167969,
-0.1899825930595398,
-0.09488607943058014,
-0.3640456199645996,
-0.002103666542097926,
0.22619768977165222,
-0.10090825706720352,
0.6013315916061401,
-0.5896130204200745,
0.11869235336780548,
0.42805397510528564,
0.42788299918174744,
0.4149610996246338,
-0.07456284761428833,
0.828333854675293,
-0.8312925100326538,
-0.6028059124946594,
-0.7205291390419006,
0.413570761680603,
-0.34945473074913025,
-0.4586293399333954,
0.5540419816970825,
0.9593872427940369,
0.6049391627311707,
-0.05637800320982933,
0.7044671773910522,
-0.06146615371108055,
0.7783957719802856,
-0.5272921919822693,
0.6824564337730408,
-0.08674957603216171,
0.07799838483333588,
-0.3977585732936859,
-0.6606847047805786,
0.15237143635749817,
0.5881264209747314,
-0.030764341354370117,
-0.2917805314064026,
0.7779965996742249,
0.9183348417282104,
-0.032914627343416214,
0.07485923171043396,
0.23654668033123016,
0.3725714683532715,
0.10452200472354889,
0.5799451470375061,
0.7070543169975281,
-0.128030925989151,
0.23158913850784302,
0.03652516379952431,
-0.21815983951091766,
-0.53179532289505,
-0.7082634568214417,
-1.1743143796920776,
-0.535542368888855,
-0.03254295140504837,
-0.41034483909606934,
0.2004985362291336,
0.7942110300064087,
0.43354082107543945,
-1.2160284519195557,
-0.4895738661289215,
-0.000031415282137459144,
-0.16280438005924225,
0.22442921996116638,
-0.14435938000679016,
0.5797836780548096,
-0.05415699630975723,
-0.5266870856285095,
0.6645826697349548,
0.17147177457809448,
0.13523294031620026,
-0.27364009618759155,
0.026220079511404037,
-0.382416307926178,
0.2673960328102112,
0.40782630443573,
-0.16340534389019012,
-0.6302773356437683,
-0.07895340025424957,
-0.04515925422310829,
-0.23496371507644653,
0.008527753874659538,
1.095611810684204,
-0.874893307685852,
0.643067479133606,
0.4744725525379181,
0.5064859390258789,
0.9485440850257874,
-0.37227970361709595,
0.6988449096679688,
-0.8062299489974976,
0.62894606590271,
0.49636030197143555,
0.6639645099639893,
0.3177972435951233,
-0.28901737928390503,
0.7728944420814514,
0.4160378575325012,
-0.4288908839225769,
-0.8742815256118774,
0.27818894386291504,
-0.9864727258682251,
-0.7934180498123169,
0.851486325263977,
-0.4716818630695343,
-0.5057264566421509,
-0.5582075715065002,
-0.39201271533966064,
0.2632589042186737,
-0.6095214486122131,
0.35738134384155273,
0.933793306350708,
0.42540857195854187,
0.24228528141975403,
-0.8557541966438293,
0.6605743765830994,
0.05905988812446594,
-0.5680856704711914,
0.17696607112884521,
1.085720419883728,
-0.11969263106584549,
0.5376355051994324,
0.4804899990558624,
-0.3051145076751709,
0.4659980237483978,
-0.21492865681648254,
0.06867633014917374,
0.3152056932449341,
-0.6267125010490417,
-0.3364768922328949,
0.5847824215888977,
-0.23167391121387482,
0.14435741305351257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12827v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12827v1
|
CT-ADE: An Evaluation Benchmark for Adverse Drug Event Prediction from Clinical Trial Results
| 2024-04-19T12:04:32 | 2024-04-19T12:04:32 |
Anthony Yazdani, Alban Bornet, Boya Zhang, Philipp Khlebnikov, Poorya Amini, Douglas Teodoro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Adverse drug events (ADEs) significantly impact clinical research and public
health, contributing to failures in clinical trials and leading to increased
healthcare costs. The accurate prediction and management of ADEs are crucial
for improving the development of safer, more effective medications, and
enhancing patient outcomes. To support this effort, we introduce CT-ADE, a
novel dataset compiled to enhance the predictive modeling of ADEs. Encompassing
over 12,000 instances extracted from clinical trial results, the CT-ADE dataset
integrates drug, patient population, and contextual information for multilabel
ADE classification tasks in monopharmacy treatments, providing a comprehensive
resource for developing advanced predictive models. To mirror the complex
nature of ADEs, annotations are standardized at the system organ class level of
the Medical Dictionary for Regulatory Activities (MedDRA) ontology. Preliminary
analyses using baseline models have demonstrated promising results, achieving
73.33% F1 score and 81.54% balanced accuracy, highlighting CT-ADE's potential
to advance ADE prediction. CT-ADE provides an essential tool for researchers
aiming to leverage the power of artificial intelligence and machine learning to
enhance patient safety and minimize the impact of ADEs on pharmaceutical
research and development. Researchers interested in using the CT-ADE dataset
can find all necessary resources at https://github.com/xxxx/xxxx.
|
[
-0.17078249156475067,
-0.44324883818626404,
0.6086472868919373,
-0.2820608913898468,
-0.03208218142390251,
-0.3103852868080139,
0.00778959272429347,
-0.5221599340438843,
0.13159067928791046,
0.6600273847579956,
-0.3476306200027466,
-0.8440006971359253,
-0.8376075029373169,
-0.1369106024503708,
-0.27418094873428345,
0.9714426398277283,
0.09121155738830566,
0.35751402378082275,
0.39852726459503174,
-0.2866052985191345,
-0.7062758207321167,
-0.41956841945648193,
-0.9003865718841553,
0.09455186873674393,
0.9071841239929199,
0.056553784757852554,
0.4107673168182373,
0.5489811897277832,
0.7933165431022644,
0.22448468208312988,
0.11876057088375092,
-0.051155880093574524,
-0.28231316804885864,
-0.09698303788900375,
-0.029127171263098717,
-0.46722498536109924,
-0.8301577568054199,
0.32779669761657715,
0.08147108554840088,
0.5484898686408997,
-0.27196407318115234,
-0.12273067235946655,
-0.17771218717098236,
0.42651811242103577,
-0.8551259636878967,
-0.02690848894417286,
-0.3876442611217499,
0.020160628482699394,
-0.019441235810518265,
-0.0239159744232893,
-0.48120006918907166,
-0.7001518607139587,
0.615573525428772,
-0.9177390336990356,
0.05906257778406143,
-0.1584092080593109,
0.4060248136520386,
0.25690367817878723,
-0.8733261823654175,
-0.31343016028404236,
-0.2036517858505249,
0.5728532075881958,
-0.5190682411193848,
0.10375804454088211,
-0.10417111963033676,
0.6017979383468628,
-0.4946681261062622,
-0.8371421694755554,
-0.2639380097389221,
-0.1347702592611313,
-0.16596122086048126,
0.09324125945568085,
0.2021731734275818,
0.5173537731170654,
-0.02658294513821602,
0.23705796897411346,
-0.6940502524375916,
0.19676415622234344,
-0.4392922520637512,
-0.22859220206737518,
0.5167255997657776,
0.43667325377464294,
0.2765231728553772,
0.046075981110334396,
-0.8141682744026184,
-0.17411461472511292,
-0.6205399036407471,
-0.16793449223041534,
-0.3506687879562378,
0.4804977476596832,
0.025222307071089745,
0.3278076946735382,
0.170975923538208,
0.4241945445537567,
-0.0721365287899971,
0.43423205614089966,
0.23013032972812653,
-0.5093506574630737,
-0.2874735891819,
0.3412308990955353,
0.8350045084953308,
0.5154666304588318,
-0.06948725134134293,
0.051134586334228516,
0.13092799484729767,
0.3493039011955261,
0.2420646697282791,
-0.989910900592804,
-0.47100457549095154,
0.6268414855003357,
-0.28871119022369385,
-0.7090525031089783,
0.3356074392795563,
-1.0854408740997314,
-0.9567614197731018,
-0.174104243516922,
0.5531702637672424,
-0.5624765753746033,
-0.11006689071655273,
0.3147561550140381,
-0.29931390285491943,
-0.24224916100502014,
0.47073954343795776,
-0.07188478112220764,
0.4750882089138031,
0.3878444731235504,
0.5876994132995605,
-0.6631941199302673,
-0.3027520179748535,
-0.44082531332969666,
-0.03353400528430939,
-0.5080804824829102,
1.1169301271438599,
-0.2690331041812897,
-0.5168458819389343,
0.14482936263084412,
0.037033941596746445,
-0.43695127964019775,
-0.61459881067276,
0.9673312306404114,
-0.3120001554489136,
0.16823817789554596,
-0.04582862928509712,
-0.6459294557571411,
-0.3996852934360504,
0.014330467209219933,
-0.8424421548843384,
0.11776059120893478,
-0.22938257455825806,
-0.5629566311836243,
0.7677302360534668,
-1.189224123954773,
-0.11215081065893173,
0.019674373790621758,
-0.09061433374881744,
-0.5510956048965454,
0.3419151306152344,
0.1294684261083603,
0.012418236583471298,
-0.3447563052177429,
0.4355544447898865,
-0.4726475179195404,
-0.29897499084472656,
0.02273600734770298,
-0.28085070848464966,
0.7821900248527527,
0.4488391578197479,
0.004829337354749441,
0.17685462534427643,
-0.8169907331466675,
0.09399691969156265,
0.0667819157242775,
-0.35056760907173157,
-0.24673813581466675,
-0.34278252720832825,
0.5049223303794861,
0.5040781497955322,
0.20282495021820068,
-0.6455212235450745,
0.21696355938911438,
-0.28381189703941345,
-0.010022163391113281,
0.8211293816566467,
0.35517463088035583,
-0.04083362594246864,
-0.22787119448184967,
0.380230575799942,
0.4055960476398468,
0.5122369527816772,
-0.3095313310623169,
-0.2671405076980591,
-0.14396733045578003,
-0.2348974049091339,
0.6483032703399658,
0.6585250496864319,
-0.2761304974555969,
0.5229952335357666,
-0.17180918157100677,
-0.3456396758556366,
-0.2316252589225769,
-0.39207276701927185,
0.3287336528301239,
0.16490301489830017,
0.34765803813934326,
-0.2295716404914856,
-0.6639804244041443,
-0.8005966544151306,
-0.22546666860580444,
0.035823430866003036,
-0.03844384476542473,
0.10128697752952576,
0.46292948722839355,
-0.28775596618652344,
0.4544842541217804,
-0.8163508176803589,
-0.632175087928772,
0.028621533885598183,
0.2894187867641449,
0.03746020048856735,
0.5925564169883728,
0.504758894443512,
-0.663358747959137,
-0.2988414764404297,
-0.07829274982213974,
-0.7423081994056702,
-0.06881705671548843,
0.014398125000298023,
-0.1914391666650772,
-0.1294870525598526,
0.1829795390367508,
-0.2205706238746643,
0.5903801918029785,
0.5151314735412598,
-0.6498550772666931,
0.31404513120651245,
-0.2516922056674957,
0.6487508416175842,
-0.9776788949966431,
0.14052636921405792,
0.3073025941848755,
0.2790653705596924,
-0.8203122019767761,
-0.37696003913879395,
0.029146771878004074,
-0.2539871633052826,
-0.5374995470046997,
0.4515482783317566,
0.05311201885342598,
0.44778233766555786,
-0.1869296431541443,
-0.03318306803703308,
0.18853148818016052,
0.12341870367527008,
0.020885799080133438,
0.6437199115753174,
0.4809413254261017,
-0.41913989186286926,
0.047387197613716125,
0.301332950592041,
-0.299176961183548,
0.46275004744529724,
-0.4607706665992737,
-0.09723645448684692,
0.22532765567302704,
0.1873471885919571,
-0.6396152973175049,
-0.1631675362586975,
-0.18905502557754517,
-0.42512521147727966,
0.4936089813709259,
-0.19430238008499146,
-0.369513601064682,
-0.48629674315452576,
-0.4901496469974518,
0.46573013067245483,
0.0319112166762352,
-0.3370097279548645,
0.5198879837989807,
0.7765458226203918,
-0.1327965408563614,
-0.5158193111419678,
-0.41119110584259033,
0.2705272436141968,
-0.3287687599658966,
-0.3432466387748718,
0.09503667801618576,
-0.08787737786769867,
-0.07347408682107925,
-0.134721577167511,
0.09169122576713562,
-0.60518479347229,
-0.06933446228504181,
0.2536163330078125,
0.5631787180900574,
-0.24824607372283936,
0.18369221687316895,
-0.05312506482005119,
-0.3220936357975006,
0.1906639188528061,
-0.24809548258781433,
0.12926726043224335,
0.038278769701719284,
-0.061673037707805634,
-0.7733312845230103,
0.449343204498291,
0.8202056884765625,
0.05501063913106918,
0.3750731647014618,
0.11844925582408905,
-0.7786039710044861,
0.2617342472076416,
-0.25727948546409607,
-0.3940533399581909,
-0.3525281250476837,
0.6183602809906006,
-0.20491771399974823,
0.07010235637426376,
0.5459274649620056,
-0.13880683481693268,
0.14439250528812408,
0.4988729655742645,
0.19546830654144287,
0.17394158244132996,
1.193658471107483,
0.36881059408187866,
0.3346560299396515,
0.3967384099960327,
-0.248297780752182,
-0.03295600041747093,
-0.6449407339096069,
-0.139383465051651,
-0.2587951123714447,
-0.20247964560985565,
-0.710989236831665,
-0.3554826080799103,
0.9016251564025879,
-0.3929208815097809,
-0.4901585876941681,
0.3330121636390686,
-0.4731457531452179,
0.15556927025318146,
0.2584347724914551,
0.2639758288860321,
0.4038780629634857,
-0.333624929189682,
0.07341405004262924,
-0.0037028773222118616,
-0.5944246053695679,
-0.46517255902290344,
1.6127389669418335,
0.1909913271665573,
0.4378012716770172,
-0.24696895480155945,
0.47459447383880615,
0.5217564702033997,
0.4645691514015198,
-0.5760459303855896,
0.29683342576026917,
-0.641951322555542,
-0.9069787859916687,
0.1306881159543991,
-0.15080660581588745,
-0.9558703899383545,
0.09474781155586243,
-0.37503576278686523,
-0.684842050075531,
0.5298948287963867,
0.07234887778759003,
-0.8154988288879395,
0.10758156329393387,
-1.0157629251480103,
1.236565113067627,
-0.24796448647975922,
-0.07405439019203186,
-0.39148035645484924,
-0.5907480716705322,
0.22539785504341125,
-0.3770066201686859,
0.3174533247947693,
-0.08873584866523743,
-0.15406297147274017,
0.760453462600708,
-0.4686414301395416,
0.6658240556716919,
-0.2324848622083664,
0.046321336179971695,
0.3740784823894501,
0.00461353687569499,
0.40459534525871277,
0.09960895776748657,
-0.21515357494354248,
0.37133631110191345,
0.18897023797035217,
-0.5020319223403931,
-0.5102258324623108,
0.9602833986282349,
-0.6234675645828247,
-0.15755601227283478,
-0.5574405193328857,
-0.45403972268104553,
0.030455688014626503,
0.30529019236564636,
0.24292708933353424,
0.7926961183547974,
-0.3660064935684204,
-0.31885528564453125,
0.41148442029953003,
-0.4375911355018616,
-0.027209686115384102,
0.7734698057174683,
0.20535655319690704,
-0.7389147877693176,
0.5787321925163269,
0.31889164447784424,
0.04612850397825241,
0.21660003066062927,
0.22898922860622406,
-0.4081264138221741,
-0.8589214086532593,
-0.1696384996175766,
-0.18985378742218018,
-0.8131297826766968,
-0.18593008816242218,
-0.5326486825942993,
0.05052882060408592,
-0.3934415280818939,
-0.18174386024475098,
-0.758453369140625,
-0.3931165933609009,
0.18981720507144928,
-0.2085818350315094,
0.18050852417945862,
1.0370322465896606,
0.09183099865913391,
0.2650768756866455,
-0.8292490243911743,
-0.08022619038820267,
-0.1874169558286667,
0.5227580666542053,
-0.5219796299934387,
-0.2272845357656479,
-0.2292087823152542,
0.00866746250540018,
-0.6222173571586609,
-0.6871958374977112,
-0.045246612280607224,
0.014490656554698944,
0.6002324223518372,
0.4113103747367859,
0.2856684923171997,
0.4720081090927124,
-0.1698198914527893,
0.5643880367279053,
0.40617576241493225,
-0.4737483561038971,
1.095058560371399,
-0.3948422968387604,
-0.055308107286691666,
0.7993972301483154,
0.03804512694478035,
-0.18253065645694733,
-0.13485057651996613,
-0.6295915842056274,
-0.9718167185783386,
0.7835365533828735,
0.36089766025543213,
-0.6281556487083435,
-0.1622096449136734,
0.33708736300468445,
0.41233232617378235,
0.06746256351470947,
-0.3592357039451599,
-0.44334977865219116,
0.09709568321704865,
-0.3069112002849579,
-0.03353997319936752,
-0.014904542826116085,
-0.12069322913885117,
0.14059491455554962,
0.6476624608039856,
-0.011079018004238605,
0.09859767556190491,
0.18964706361293793,
0.1682523787021637,
-0.11749321967363358,
0.20616057515144348,
0.4197693467140198,
0.5264479517936707,
-0.6443601846694946,
0.06595858931541443,
0.1994783580303192,
-0.9471569061279297,
-0.09110252559185028,
0.6257045269012451,
0.3556291162967682,
-0.36040163040161133,
0.13121242821216583,
0.2085423320531845,
-0.2207200974225998,
-0.9014536142349243,
0.47029370069503784,
-0.3236989974975586,
0.08464006334543228,
-0.5040171146392822,
-0.06848322600126266,
-0.8435328602790833,
-0.046602193266153336,
0.4152434766292572,
0.4157975912094116,
0.7234676480293274,
-0.2446308583021164,
0.6529123783111572,
-0.05334651470184326,
-0.9090580344200134,
-0.29058775305747986,
0.8397495150566101,
0.4957667887210846,
0.2789950966835022,
0.30523955821990967,
0.3253147602081299,
0.006335580721497536,
1.0980428457260132,
0.07574594020843506,
0.9779868125915527,
-0.27203142642974854,
-0.18549276888370514,
0.6852021813392639,
-0.009570232592523098,
0.3589048981666565,
0.16207662224769592,
0.8632467985153198,
-0.30000627040863037,
-0.18676504492759705,
-0.15726186335086823,
-0.10553830862045288,
0.3505913317203522,
-0.5060732364654541,
1.0334166288375854,
-0.3162638545036316,
-0.3818126320838928,
0.3987812101840973,
0.26420849561691284,
-0.3415201008319855,
0.3441578149795532,
0.2102842777967453,
0.9741050004959106,
-0.9753801822662354,
0.7277541756629944,
0.9925402998924255,
-0.27352482080459595,
-0.2258146107196808,
-0.14689403772354126,
0.3427991569042206,
-0.4966275095939636,
0.30747777223587036,
0.4138701856136322,
0.08151347935199738,
-0.2515123188495636,
-0.11918387562036514,
-0.4502219259738922,
1.1166001558303833,
-0.08953743427991867,
-0.3863156735897064,
0.1256445348262787,
0.12610501050949097,
0.5789704322814941,
-0.6539881825447083,
0.435980886220932,
0.7214260101318359,
0.42436501383781433,
0.17098864912986755,
-0.8610252737998962,
0.1775471568107605,
-0.24050801992416382,
-0.09145878255367279,
0.3639436960220337,
-0.19232118129730225,
0.5369879603385925,
-0.6665436625480652,
-0.09421545267105103,
0.05112854018807411,
0.02302861586213112,
0.23123709857463837,
0.7687786221504211,
0.446651428937912,
0.524861216545105,
0.4990987181663513,
-0.29591846466064453,
1.0037564039230347,
-0.4172127842903137,
0.3300180435180664,
0.989651083946228,
-0.2588299810886383,
0.5893605947494507,
0.11985709518194199,
-0.19393356144428253,
0.09035713225603104,
0.6260424256324768,
0.06888283789157867,
0.7411878705024719,
-0.0953194797039032,
-0.23078173398971558,
-0.22231946885585785,
-0.28805026412010193,
-0.3805096745491028,
0.3298627734184265,
0.697126567363739,
-0.47733545303344727,
-0.3014802634716034,
0.21306714415550232,
-0.2943611443042755,
0.040110424160957336,
-0.16691376268863678,
0.8759735226631165,
-0.15749478340148926,
-0.4744609296321869,
0.531080424785614,
-0.5377779603004456,
0.2255985140800476,
-0.4511585831642151,
-0.18270258605480194,
0.0748680830001831,
0.7982288002967834,
-0.07068143039941788,
-0.8004699349403381,
0.23234398663043976,
-0.36809954047203064,
-0.06341437995433807,
0.6228005290031433,
0.22185541689395905,
-0.10348889976739883,
-0.3464656174182892,
0.5059663653373718,
0.18633830547332764,
-0.17437973618507385,
-0.041607100516557693,
-0.7914104461669922,
-0.047211065888404846,
-0.20342102646827698,
-0.22607861459255219,
0.3997940421104431,
0.44408077001571655,
-0.013431179337203503,
0.452140748500824,
0.3301069438457489,
0.09251399338245392,
-0.16100268065929413,
-0.02969604730606079,
0.8145529627799988,
-0.599703848361969,
-0.35316193103790283,
-0.45451173186302185,
0.7248214483261108,
-0.16373293101787567,
-0.5048418641090393,
0.12385283410549164,
0.9801176190376282,
0.12202457338571548,
0.04700755700469017,
0.9262703657150269,
0.05001957342028618,
0.5402965545654297,
-0.14352445304393768,
0.575525164604187,
-0.4789316654205322,
0.43007731437683105,
0.18874967098236084,
-0.3393441438674927,
-0.493609756231308,
0.042673226445913315,
-0.334455668926239,
0.013645988889038563,
0.8653950691223145,
0.4791003465652466,
0.19416441023349762,
0.3084425628185272,
0.18163886666297913,
0.5158312916755676,
0.5497651100158691,
0.8695418238639832,
0.46336522698402405,
-1.1020065546035767,
0.6728231906890869,
-0.24218136072158813,
-0.530637264251709,
-0.20916977524757385,
-0.5551902055740356,
-0.8045143485069275,
-0.4240466058254242,
-0.6101096272468567,
-0.4735487997531891,
0.5015963912010193,
1.242171049118042,
0.7019110918045044,
-1.4747991561889648,
0.030413268133997917,
-0.22054816782474518,
-0.03536519035696983,
-0.32236021757125854,
-0.19724640250205994,
0.7051292061805725,
-0.37295395135879517,
-0.9335962533950806,
0.1914825588464737,
0.40976226329803467,
0.2547967731952667,
0.4360244572162628,
0.1683008074760437,
-0.2913956344127655,
0.01561382133513689,
0.4390164315700531,
0.018764669075608253,
-0.4623631238937378,
0.04169189929962158,
-0.2709008753299713,
-0.32312914729118347,
0.09740416705608368,
0.8789100646972656,
-0.5341099500656128,
0.7893019318580627,
0.4090193212032318,
0.11955037713050842,
-0.04168345779180527,
-0.15658433735370636,
0.9228232502937317,
-0.07475902885198593,
0.05066472664475441,
0.4215981066226959,
0.5595791339874268,
-0.30048269033432007,
-0.4881700873374939,
0.45337238907814026,
0.10721582919359207,
-0.636214017868042,
-0.7048024535179138,
0.0818324163556099,
-0.9609081149101257,
-0.43232807517051697,
0.7552041411399841,
-0.2600488066673279,
-0.09921491891145706,
-0.5216242671012878,
-0.3092975616455078,
0.19996845722198486,
-0.6340908408164978,
1.087617039680481,
0.09294969588518143,
-0.255689799785614,
0.11953126639127731,
-0.9592390060424805,
0.511237621307373,
0.09263674914836884,
-0.8256052732467651,
0.569491982460022,
0.6697288155555725,
-0.0020870452281087637,
0.17834261059761047,
0.36567944288253784,
-0.471031129360199,
0.5458022952079773,
0.06055011600255966,
0.2779400050640106,
-0.024595515802502632,
-0.3093383312225342,
-0.23614832758903503,
0.2582387626171112,
-0.20873969793319702,
-0.5220005512237549
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.