id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11532v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11532v1
|
Select and Reorder: A Novel Approach for Neural Sign Language Production
| 2024-04-17T16:25:19 | 2024-04-17T16:25:19 |
Harry Walsh, Ben Saunders, Richard Bowden
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sign languages, often categorised as low-resource languages, face significant
challenges in achieving accurate translation due to the scarcity of parallel
annotated datasets. This paper introduces Select and Reorder (S&R), a novel
approach that addresses data scarcity by breaking down the translation process
into two distinct steps: Gloss Selection (GS) and Gloss Reordering (GR). Our
method leverages large spoken language models and the substantial lexical
overlap between source spoken languages and target sign languages to establish
an initial alignment. Both steps make use of Non-AutoRegressive (NAR) decoding
for reduced computation and faster inference speeds. Through this
disentanglement of tasks, we achieve state-of-the-art BLEU and Rouge scores on
the Meine DGS Annotated (mDGS) dataset, demonstrating a substantial BLUE-1
improvement of 37.88% in Text to Gloss (T2G) Translation. This innovative
approach paves the way for more effective translation models for sign
languages, even in resource-constrained settings.
|
[
0.08863359689712524,
-0.25893574953079224,
0.14887766540050507,
0.01826702430844307,
-0.40559372305870056,
0.3742687404155731,
-0.1583467423915863,
-0.5737073421478271,
0.5485689043998718,
0.5695168972015381,
-0.5049960613250732,
-0.55784672498703,
-0.9606831669807434,
0.011151008307933807,
-0.2799282968044281,
0.8266520500183105,
-0.024911874905228615,
0.06302648037672043,
0.21253907680511475,
-0.34073156118392944,
-0.21546514332294464,
-0.2871842682361603,
-0.956361711025238,
-0.26304012537002563,
0.5505209565162659,
0.4068930447101593,
1.0504621267318726,
0.8462784290313721,
0.5266909599304199,
0.2677718698978424,
-0.1346091777086258,
0.30080512166023254,
-0.3513015806674957,
0.461102157831192,
0.04706370830535889,
-0.20169681310653687,
-0.5318989753723145,
0.07118771225214005,
0.3936653733253479,
0.8044825196266174,
0.02403516136109829,
0.13015688955783844,
-0.22730481624603271,
0.7435069680213928,
-0.5899595618247986,
-0.08402789384126663,
-0.5166335105895996,
0.03519871458411217,
-0.1603071093559265,
0.2420901358127594,
-0.40263357758522034,
-0.49651429057121277,
0.043472159653902054,
-0.43728139996528625,
0.28974005579948425,
0.04978758469223976,
0.6521896123886108,
0.5231813788414001,
-0.41586118936538696,
0.007642339915037155,
-0.6358630657196045,
0.8104185461997986,
-0.6509849429130554,
0.7556926012039185,
0.3230029344558716,
0.3650042414665222,
-0.05970998853445053,
-0.7586552500724792,
-0.34222859144210815,
-0.3216613531112671,
-0.1181056872010231,
0.0327574759721756,
0.13387779891490936,
0.0799868255853653,
0.1968170702457428,
0.42871883511543274,
-0.4700980484485626,
0.23847870528697968,
-0.42793983221054077,
-0.27006569504737854,
0.9826669096946716,
0.08650491386651993,
0.4201483726501465,
-0.026088735088706017,
-0.29389241337776184,
-0.3302081823348999,
-0.4325175881385803,
-0.4961942434310913,
0.01658802479505539,
0.7077433466911316,
-0.03379424288868904,
0.46777158975601196,
-0.24518783390522003,
0.8304629921913147,
0.1176198273897171,
-0.08942488580942154,
0.3716193437576294,
-0.4111745059490204,
-0.16955190896987915,
-0.15798339247703552,
0.9969543218612671,
0.21822823584079742,
0.07292310893535614,
-0.20628933608531952,
-0.4503556787967682,
-0.2559780478477478,
0.02700897492468357,
-0.39444074034690857,
-0.15119554102420807,
0.12712429463863373,
-0.40563249588012695,
-0.1003989726305008,
-0.4275171160697937,
-0.7702201008796692,
-0.6861187815666199,
-0.38585227727890015,
0.10748294740915298,
-0.1546347439289093,
-0.2981854975223541,
-0.09159591794013977,
0.04247460141777992,
-0.04609791934490204,
0.22538748383522034,
-1.1440478563308716,
0.3102787733078003,
0.41937896609306335,
0.9592921137809753,
-0.39897334575653076,
-0.18774212896823883,
-0.4171024560928345,
-0.09148873388767242,
-0.34200021624565125,
0.20251087844371796,
-0.270208477973938,
-0.1305321753025055,
-0.1847383975982666,
-0.2682795524597168,
-0.15154333412647247,
-0.5119594931602478,
0.425616592168808,
-0.6314333081245422,
-0.06142144650220871,
-0.010639852844178677,
-0.09313606470823288,
-0.009737670421600342,
-0.21894043684005737,
-0.7377183437347412,
0.943601131439209,
0.27889755368232727,
-0.17942355573177338,
0.5343203544616699,
-0.15249350666999817,
-0.7868400812149048,
-0.024542082101106644,
-0.2754056751728058,
-0.4194856584072113,
0.2439732700586319,
0.16954240202903748,
0.20334471762180328,
-0.3805021643638611,
-0.03882316127419472,
0.11894668638706207,
0.006287735886871815,
0.15257896482944489,
-0.3355695903301239,
0.6180868744850159,
0.3881296217441559,
-0.5288248658180237,
0.17824432253837585,
-0.5969527363777161,
0.22920109331607819,
0.10705582797527313,
-0.41352152824401855,
-0.13205081224441528,
-0.18782636523246765,
0.2389763742685318,
0.5238564014434814,
0.3610561490058899,
-0.4045720398426056,
0.015241958200931549,
-0.3241286277770996,
0.3502630591392517,
0.3101061284542084,
-0.24738889932632446,
0.6865648031234741,
0.053473979234695435,
0.5087104439735413,
-0.2602919638156891,
0.4717848002910614,
0.3575485348701477,
-0.4630879759788513,
-0.9212549328804016,
-0.09085502475500107,
0.32412242889404297,
0.6830776333808899,
-0.6798070073127747,
0.22853213548660278,
-0.3088702857494354,
-0.49296241998672485,
-0.7350305914878845,
0.11740551143884659,
0.890151858329773,
0.16255484521389008,
0.4843301773071289,
-0.4524272382259369,
-0.22388578951358795,
-0.8867502808570862,
-0.035647474229335785,
-0.012858064845204353,
0.0249125137925148,
-0.016702983528375626,
0.016626248136162758,
0.22606851160526276,
0.19023293256759644,
-0.5660515427589417,
-0.27776649594306946,
-0.26847168803215027,
-0.004813936538994312,
0.2882896661758423,
0.44880199432373047,
0.3472342789173126,
-0.9190568327903748,
-0.4988711476325989,
0.27684882283210754,
-0.5544820427894592,
-0.09224460273981094,
-0.2585800290107727,
-0.3380506634712219,
0.4287862181663513,
0.7797365784645081,
-0.4762871265411377,
0.367717981338501,
0.5339944958686829,
-0.21358749270439148,
0.28442132472991943,
-0.09156199544668198,
0.13906987011432648,
-0.9516624808311462,
-0.03185955062508583,
-0.22348558902740479,
-0.1600302904844284,
-0.7942360639572144,
-0.013755925931036472,
-0.01495220884680748,
-0.19465157389640808,
-0.4352593421936035,
0.45452192425727844,
-1.0022064447402954,
-0.3099135756492615,
-0.35168612003326416,
0.5264281630516052,
-0.12317250669002533,
0.4072113037109375,
0.15850959718227386,
0.6594830751419067,
0.40932583808898926,
-0.5075955986976624,
0.09420005232095718,
0.5806210041046143,
-0.3491840958595276,
0.11871337890625,
-0.3198518455028534,
0.16050314903259277,
0.09361670911312103,
-0.16171379387378693,
-0.9768715500831604,
0.0069190748035907745,
0.5252702832221985,
-0.3721156120300293,
0.7846925258636475,
-0.4076911509037018,
-0.22496214509010315,
-0.19120246171951294,
0.41651272773742676,
0.3946097195148468,
0.5431968569755554,
-0.3657580614089966,
0.573394238948822,
0.593338131904602,
-0.18640083074569702,
-0.7043649554252625,
-1.0320425033569336,
0.20483164489269257,
0.04711563140153885,
-0.34401312470436096,
0.20736761391162872,
0.2663075923919678,
-0.2374245822429657,
-0.3922964930534363,
-0.4971450865268707,
-0.08484897017478943,
-0.05193815380334854,
-0.0050642602145671844,
0.08123674988746643,
-0.09760303795337677,
0.05312168598175049,
0.12149891257286072,
-0.4052800238132477,
-0.2557477653026581,
-0.2562693655490875,
0.29750722646713257,
0.2927097976207733,
-0.38907983899116516,
-0.39211228489875793,
0.3225640654563904,
0.8685204386711121,
-0.3968006372451782,
0.5728858709335327,
0.2474953979253769,
-0.1752057671546936,
-0.3477913439273834,
-0.4032366871833801,
-0.308537095785141,
-0.46877506375312805,
0.4630086421966553,
-0.20289528369903564,
-0.6616746783256531,
0.2822253406047821,
0.09466290473937988,
0.37131789326667786,
-0.022547323256731033,
0.241762176156044,
0.27694931626319885,
0.7610575556755066,
0.31270748376846313,
0.0619916096329689,
0.8516282439231873,
-0.010435348376631737,
0.4426731765270233,
-0.5489782094955444,
-0.20542629063129425,
-0.05798852816224098,
-0.6368704438209534,
-0.4275842308998108,
-0.7467620968818665,
0.08221101760864258,
0.3113792836666107,
0.1350012719631195,
0.5923647880554199,
-0.7528513669967651,
0.5486777424812317,
0.4539623260498047,
0.12560106813907623,
0.21760572493076324,
0.15618734061717987,
-0.00294473092071712,
-0.11492033302783966,
-0.6506012082099915,
-0.4804781675338745,
1.018311858177185,
-0.07429219782352448,
0.33417195081710815,
0.29410168528556824,
0.7982366681098938,
0.0886218398809433,
0.5205363035202026,
-0.80198073387146,
0.7867475748062134,
-0.5229932069778442,
-0.4401293098926544,
-0.5521365404129028,
-0.2737087309360504,
-1.0047848224639893,
0.6663016676902771,
-0.3600844740867615,
-0.4842337369918823,
0.29458409547805786,
0.12575140595436096,
-0.32691794633865356,
0.14294302463531494,
-0.8443611860275269,
0.7569743990898132,
-0.6614526510238647,
-0.33091992139816284,
-0.04804603382945061,
-0.8114126920700073,
0.27360841631889343,
-0.06791069358587265,
0.04459334537386894,
-0.2921159267425537,
-0.1854732632637024,
0.5913821458816528,
-0.45547714829444885,
0.7480147480964661,
-0.12459103018045425,
-0.2587710916996002,
0.20311780273914337,
0.36857059597969055,
0.429387629032135,
-0.3286159634590149,
-0.25476202368736267,
0.19793029129505157,
-0.481611967086792,
-0.383507639169693,
-0.7214499711990356,
0.6197800636291504,
-0.4622012972831726,
-0.5955315828323364,
-0.4285425543785095,
-0.6581143736839294,
-0.10596664249897003,
0.414188414812088,
0.2363765686750412,
0.1291312724351883,
-0.04481564089655876,
-0.5665435791015625,
0.24974389374256134,
0.07194159179925919,
0.5080037713050842,
0.48193225264549255,
-0.06690678000450134,
-0.962559700012207,
0.7960780262947083,
0.3387984335422516,
0.7895129323005676,
0.3357563018798828,
-0.11183881014585495,
-0.4446831941604614,
-1.0990755558013916,
-0.396483838558197,
0.5959766507148743,
-0.6578853130340576,
-0.09529852122068405,
-0.42251336574554443,
-0.03664446622133255,
-0.4760034382343292,
-0.17797107994556427,
-0.4630240797996521,
-0.8104076981544495,
0.007712735328823328,
-0.2519170343875885,
0.4336196780204773,
0.6719585061073303,
-0.30878910422325134,
0.4056317210197449,
-0.6453380584716797,
0.4075579345226288,
0.04296315461397171,
0.1354636400938034,
-0.06423116475343704,
-0.3511401116847992,
-0.2939251661300659,
0.021133555099368095,
-0.25663691759109497,
-0.8899949789047241,
0.412204384803772,
0.11636117845773697,
0.48592686653137207,
0.27342233061790466,
0.1713332235813141,
0.5082067251205444,
-0.4192151427268982,
0.44883036613464355,
0.5022820234298706,
-0.7929086685180664,
0.5961503982543945,
-0.3354904353618622,
0.14215801656246185,
0.7316221594810486,
0.13885410130023956,
-0.6856483221054077,
-0.34960314631462097,
-0.5477656722068787,
-1.3707202672958374,
0.9144739508628845,
0.43507707118988037,
-0.19178524613380432,
-0.22323763370513916,
0.3468520939350128,
0.00336602795869112,
0.20226798951625824,
-0.5083664059638977,
-0.5189425349235535,
-0.031060945242643356,
-0.1661161482334137,
-0.3663805425167084,
0.023901529610157013,
-0.13362479209899902,
0.01493815053254366,
0.5762317776679993,
0.026427384465932846,
-0.128452330827713,
0.05791936814785004,
-0.09055744111537933,
-0.02815033495426178,
0.025546355172991753,
0.5212181210517883,
0.5433829426765442,
0.07949325442314148,
0.009943569079041481,
0.10602464526891708,
-0.5368198752403259,
0.21543629467487335,
-0.019731886684894562,
-0.33497682213783264,
0.09484211355447769,
0.158114954829216,
0.8992632627487183,
0.0946933776140213,
-0.290185809135437,
0.24906423687934875,
0.2123500257730484,
-0.023175068199634552,
-0.08789244294166565,
-0.14265674352645874,
0.013936182484030724,
0.24509721994400024,
0.04399450495839119,
0.19510096311569214,
-0.114800363779068,
0.03805442899465561,
0.44237759709358215,
0.15190881490707397,
-0.3130885660648346,
-0.07160725444555283,
0.7638540863990784,
0.40758752822875977,
-0.5323111414909363,
0.9286649823188782,
-0.1664099544286728,
-0.09926999360322952,
0.5917254686355591,
0.4363850951194763,
1.0281381607055664,
-0.32473474740982056,
0.4737864136695862,
0.558742880821228,
0.45973527431488037,
-0.27905574440956116,
0.49926868081092834,
0.0629039779305458,
-0.7474234104156494,
-0.5132341980934143,
-0.47908318042755127,
-0.2795940041542053,
0.10228242725133896,
-0.7495638728141785,
0.04342348128557205,
-0.7229328155517578,
-0.492826372385025,
-0.20969867706298828,
-0.25747188925743103,
-0.22847376763820648,
0.22789771854877472,
0.4442124366760254,
0.6424508094787598,
-1.1487772464752197,
0.5584994554519653,
0.40510326623916626,
-0.6289627552032471,
-0.5126277804374695,
0.13535232841968536,
0.16712914407253265,
-0.694904625415802,
0.7809773087501526,
-0.09349791705608368,
-0.27592888474464417,
0.14596772193908691,
-0.11482518166303635,
-1.266637921333313,
0.9087502360343933,
0.47476378083229065,
-0.5438123941421509,
0.3462201654911041,
0.1477205902338028,
0.6402318477630615,
-0.1523793488740921,
0.07387718558311462,
0.8420047760009766,
0.4888305068016052,
0.27017760276794434,
-0.8625366687774658,
0.38312986493110657,
-0.11443958431482315,
0.03683292493224144,
0.796623170375824,
-0.796032726764679,
0.35852816700935364,
-0.4484436511993408,
-0.7041652798652649,
0.09955372661352158,
0.8798398971557617,
0.3885901868343353,
0.1654626578092575,
0.3870319426059723,
0.5393807888031006,
0.9004191756248474,
-0.2980901598930359,
0.7558019757270813,
-0.29624414443969727,
-0.0341370590031147,
1.109299659729004,
-0.3159296214580536,
0.8884137868881226,
0.7239351272583008,
-0.18939834833145142,
0.024625714868307114,
0.6981388330459595,
0.18333730101585388,
0.5344722270965576,
0.43322789669036865,
-0.2734861373901367,
-0.45206016302108765,
-0.08957843482494354,
-0.03264399617910385,
0.2313203662633896,
0.2802028954029083,
-0.4114910662174225,
-0.13358864188194275,
-0.09772896021604538,
0.11695108562707901,
0.29534024000167847,
-0.13792617619037628,
0.5264080762863159,
0.3385240435600281,
-0.7042060494422913,
1.0361230373382568,
-0.350331574678421,
0.5084799528121948,
-0.5251551866531372,
0.04229998588562012,
-0.5288360714912415,
0.13655473291873932,
-0.1995648890733719,
-0.6460258364677429,
0.4501253366470337,
-0.3423616290092468,
-0.2068723440170288,
-0.7208356857299805,
0.26695114374160767,
-0.6015241742134094,
-0.407703697681427,
0.5748840570449829,
0.501981258392334,
0.39026689529418945,
0.47458091378211975,
-0.8161306381225586,
-0.18488137423992157,
0.11582222580909729,
-0.15763582289218903,
0.3275649845600128,
0.3115982413291931,
-0.3601599335670471,
0.7456706166267395,
0.7172242403030396,
0.21160869300365448,
0.37985047698020935,
0.3507981598377228,
0.5306463241577148,
-0.6156632304191589,
-0.381460577249527,
-0.37476301193237305,
0.45779430866241455,
-0.10032089799642563,
-0.6004181504249573,
0.6528139114379883,
0.49467793107032776,
0.8204424977302551,
-0.1568562388420105,
0.7349558472633362,
-0.24172084033489227,
0.1492331624031067,
-0.527423083782196,
0.7966508865356445,
-0.4384225904941559,
0.04463212192058563,
-0.1345306634902954,
-0.9281246662139893,
-0.7136659622192383,
0.4166737198829651,
-0.45528721809387207,
0.015533540397882462,
0.780238687992096,
1.0037236213684082,
0.010267688892781734,
-0.3178544342517853,
0.46112826466560364,
-0.007315613329410553,
-0.05354488641023636,
0.5209120512008667,
0.5046495199203491,
-0.7211391925811768,
0.6923645734786987,
-0.14440317451953888,
-0.21913377940654755,
-0.014774486422538757,
-0.5974806547164917,
-0.6148965954780579,
-0.575935423374176,
-0.8281264901161194,
-0.3661750853061676,
-0.04274779185652733,
0.7702528238296509,
0.5650166273117065,
-0.9372461438179016,
-0.5171658992767334,
-0.15335948765277863,
0.3251294195652008,
-0.7461960315704346,
-0.13653188943862915,
0.49215376377105713,
-0.29239150881767273,
-0.9628749489784241,
0.9290334582328796,
0.04522072896361351,
0.3375104069709778,
0.26105818152427673,
-0.12859703600406647,
-0.33516189455986023,
-0.2295045256614685,
0.25296032428741455,
0.6729297041893005,
-0.8088492155075073,
0.029731566086411476,
-0.21549004316329956,
-0.25477999448776245,
-0.0033451293129473925,
0.7194980382919312,
-0.3656773269176483,
0.3016042113304138,
0.7969896197319031,
0.4938119947910309,
0.4379643201828003,
-0.12060310691595078,
0.685736358165741,
-0.8315313458442688,
0.09655904024839401,
0.1404198706150055,
0.2878133952617645,
0.42404767870903015,
-0.356851190328598,
0.6042942404747009,
0.1839173436164856,
-0.36739447712898254,
-0.5385380983352661,
0.786056399345398,
-0.8786538243293762,
-0.16448596119880676,
1.1659094095230103,
0.10339779406785965,
-0.29465150833129883,
-0.35993364453315735,
0.02356208860874176,
0.5432338714599609,
-0.38234081864356995,
0.7110209465026855,
0.30787256360054016,
-0.2106032520532608,
-0.3166864216327667,
-0.2571369409561157,
0.6790830492973328,
0.6042093634605408,
-0.36089515686035156,
0.4902712106704712,
0.7233426570892334,
0.1189899817109108,
0.4593501687049866,
0.6891867518424988,
-0.17475450038909912,
0.06722524017095566,
0.10871116816997528,
0.4228837192058563,
-0.18825861811637878,
-0.2529858946800232,
-0.4228854179382324,
-0.025134820491075516,
0.06600045412778854,
-0.5996856689453125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11531v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11531v1
|
Pack of LLMs: Model Fusion at Test-Time via Perplexity Optimization
| 2024-04-17T16:24:07 | 2024-04-17T16:24:07 |
Costas Mavromatis, Petros Karypis, George Karypis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Fusing knowledge from multiple Large Language Models (LLMs) can combine their
diverse strengths to achieve improved performance on a given task. However,
current fusion approaches either rely on learning-based fusers that do not
generalize to new LLMs, or do not take into account how well each LLM
understands the input. In this work, we study LLM fusion at test-time, which
enables leveraging knowledge from arbitrary user-specified LLMs during
inference. We introduce Pack of LLMs (PackLLM), an effective method for
test-time fusion that leverages each LLM's expertise, given an input prompt.
PackLLM performs model fusion by solving an optimization problem for
determining each LLM's importance, so that perplexity over the input prompt is
minimized. First, our simple PackLLM-sim variant validates that perplexity is a
good indicator for measuring each LLM's expertise. Second, our PackLLM-opt
variant approximately solves the perplexity minimization problem via a greedy
algorithm. The derived importance weights are used to combine the LLMs during
inference. We conduct experiments with over 100 total LLMs on a diverse set of
tasks. Experimental results show that (i) perplexity is a reliable measure for
LLM fusion, (ii) PackLLM outperforms test-time fusion baselines by 1.89%
accuracy points, and (iii) PackLLM can leverage new LLMs to improve performance
over learning-based fusion approaches by 3.92-11.94% accuracy points.
|
[
-0.42936018109321594,
-0.5462366938591003,
0.5542126297950745,
0.175841823220253,
-0.209234818816185,
0.3890594244003296,
0.010462750680744648,
-0.22320476174354553,
-0.07249443978071213,
0.3450072407722473,
-0.6809507608413696,
-0.42775192856788635,
-0.4527662694454193,
0.07660788297653198,
-0.33793047070503235,
0.6337178349494934,
-0.20039066672325134,
-0.040321480482816696,
-0.5276210308074951,
-0.005183079279959202,
-0.047197531908750534,
-0.39292606711387634,
-0.04403865337371826,
-0.7595630884170532,
0.5926260948181152,
0.44559553265571594,
0.392473965883255,
0.6238648891448975,
0.4473987817764282,
0.3382137715816498,
-0.16893993318080902,
0.3366927206516266,
-0.67400723695755,
0.11098378151655197,
-0.18087460100650787,
-0.6453314423561096,
-0.3437434732913971,
0.010515322908759117,
0.6546838879585266,
0.6021530628204346,
-0.04178595170378685,
0.14556974172592163,
-0.1117779016494751,
0.23935270309448242,
-0.745768129825592,
-0.24526606500148773,
-0.78067946434021,
0.12734584510326385,
-0.04840580374002457,
-0.2913776636123657,
-0.3226913511753082,
-0.29034027457237244,
0.14449605345726013,
-0.49978142976760864,
0.1255670040845871,
0.27510538697242737,
0.7304913401603699,
0.49633562564849854,
-0.37561583518981934,
0.15709933638572693,
-0.8066233396530151,
1.1418519020080566,
-0.7277953624725342,
0.13089977204799652,
0.028600912541151047,
0.5119880437850952,
-0.5079703330993652,
-0.17121301591396332,
-0.7720819711685181,
-0.01402082946151495,
0.06325491517782211,
0.202362060546875,
-0.14763499796390533,
0.0628531351685524,
0.32862210273742676,
0.3972328305244446,
-0.6401515007019043,
0.45473289489746094,
-0.09715262800455093,
-0.1724637895822525,
0.9368736147880554,
0.267556756734848,
0.23019100725650787,
-0.14921145141124725,
-0.8061141967773438,
-0.29595375061035156,
-0.8607822060585022,
-0.04311366751790047,
0.45593351125717163,
0.003252887399867177,
0.05607740953564644,
0.7378551959991455,
-0.23602880537509918,
0.7619706988334656,
-0.053343698382377625,
-0.4863992929458618,
0.20799824595451355,
-0.3338314890861511,
-0.2634876072406769,
-0.026345672085881233,
0.6041625142097473,
-0.1332663893699646,
-0.18349704146385193,
-0.21404944360256195,
-0.44426271319389343,
0.040253039449453354,
0.10680211335420609,
-0.4184950292110443,
0.011846696957945824,
0.38904091715812683,
-0.23282967507839203,
-0.3689773976802826,
-0.150288388133049,
-0.662747323513031,
-0.5721509456634521,
-0.10645990818738937,
0.6624229550361633,
-0.4290767014026642,
-0.26046013832092285,
0.2561124563217163,
-0.20194430649280548,
0.5902335047721863,
0.3044893145561218,
-0.5828537940979004,
0.1706324815750122,
0.6931986808776855,
0.4149269461631775,
-0.4824622571468353,
-0.46254634857177734,
-0.5641583204269409,
0.31119880080223083,
0.0023175172973424196,
1.1602880954742432,
-0.4179685711860657,
-0.4733369052410126,
-0.12144589424133301,
-0.4432879090309143,
-0.1723153442144394,
-0.6375005841255188,
0.2075834721326828,
-0.5188153386116028,
0.0017351653659716249,
-0.21217243373394012,
-1.0028681755065918,
-0.23472896218299866,
0.4559224545955658,
-0.47546881437301636,
0.950242817401886,
0.27131637930870056,
-0.5163869261741638,
0.1777096837759018,
-0.4890615940093994,
-0.453147828578949,
0.287901908159256,
-0.3182224631309509,
-0.30396559834480286,
0.1839783936738968,
0.11307662725448608,
0.4604152739048004,
-0.6142895817756653,
-0.02450508438050747,
-0.4720781147480011,
-0.5212787389755249,
0.3215136229991913,
0.05345265194773674,
0.6141805648803711,
0.0919741541147232,
-0.35493823885917664,
0.2857440412044525,
-0.5407088994979858,
-0.014831253327429295,
0.26163217425346375,
-0.4304471015930176,
-0.27775970101356506,
0.04463578760623932,
-0.3800809383392334,
0.11641691625118256,
0.11817795783281326,
-0.26370692253112793,
0.3933354318141937,
-0.5499215722084045,
0.14793691039085388,
0.8002472519874573,
-0.09910311549901962,
0.3925062119960785,
-0.6514880061149597,
0.689922034740448,
0.0012710425071418285,
0.15513986349105835,
-0.08453067392110825,
-0.2935684621334076,
-0.8569639921188354,
-0.24012522399425507,
0.29821717739105225,
0.830514669418335,
-0.7284194231033325,
0.6754785180091858,
-0.21795684099197388,
-0.6091096997261047,
-0.3840710520744324,
0.3836876451969147,
0.5735187530517578,
0.39096421003341675,
0.19785331189632416,
-0.19047506153583527,
-0.25649532675743103,
-1.0407767295837402,
-0.3467198312282562,
-0.320271372795105,
-0.2246224731206894,
0.40862250328063965,
0.36964190006256104,
-0.13470031321048737,
0.8773353695869446,
-0.6341454982757568,
-0.16954319179058075,
-0.5258756279945374,
0.08948899805545807,
0.11816509813070297,
0.40656837821006775,
0.24914869666099548,
-0.851879358291626,
-0.0670141726732254,
-0.06801187992095947,
-0.5753084421157837,
-0.21463683247566223,
-0.029833698645234108,
-0.048950791358947754,
0.21193726360797882,
0.2108495980501175,
-0.40916475653648376,
0.09219883382320404,
0.5775279402732849,
-0.12352390587329865,
0.6969249844551086,
-0.17522476613521576,
0.13265812397003174,
-0.9896809458732605,
-0.09337085485458374,
-0.12766407430171967,
0.03075529634952545,
-0.5745962262153625,
0.036321550607681274,
0.010487708263099194,
0.0652657151222229,
-0.8172721862792969,
0.8875404000282288,
-0.48169296979904175,
-0.1304938793182373,
-0.1333332061767578,
0.25064435601234436,
-0.1453953981399536,
0.4412805438041687,
-0.3266445994377136,
0.5702342987060547,
0.4051757752895355,
-0.4801470935344696,
0.413472443819046,
0.18468739092350006,
-0.39232322573661804,
0.39991769194602966,
-0.3949468433856964,
0.2804229259490967,
-0.03135119751095772,
0.048761121928691864,
-1.253849983215332,
-0.3322177231311798,
0.024656791239976883,
-0.09764067828655243,
0.33304449915885925,
0.13360565900802612,
-0.7325077652931213,
-0.341316282749176,
-0.250642329454422,
0.6904081106185913,
0.8463091850280762,
-0.5938277840614319,
1.052467703819275,
0.466572642326355,
0.10545738786458969,
-0.4650852382183075,
-0.4723745584487915,
-0.2808091938495636,
-0.34277597069740295,
-0.8736802935600281,
0.5552849173545837,
-0.09637091308832169,
-0.2941848933696747,
-0.13148322701454163,
-0.34674307703971863,
0.05892788618803024,
0.18956111371517181,
0.26550647616386414,
0.36521509289741516,
0.00916554406285286,
0.2873169183731079,
0.17694249749183655,
-0.18398083746433258,
-0.18709687888622284,
-0.20187832415103912,
0.6250871419906616,
-0.06604104489088058,
-0.6417544484138489,
-0.00496731698513031,
0.3958113193511963,
0.2607784569263458,
-0.17725160717964172,
0.5407581329345703,
0.41762351989746094,
-0.24837885797023773,
-0.4953172504901886,
-1.2802095413208008,
-0.3385721743106842,
-0.4993281662464142,
0.23992973566055298,
-0.4574151635169983,
-1.0319565534591675,
0.5587284564971924,
-0.47440120577812195,
0.12556597590446472,
0.25756749510765076,
0.4701656401157379,
-0.18882346153259277,
0.8321311473846436,
0.5449525117874146,
-0.1772630363702774,
0.169061079621315,
-0.18986067175865173,
0.22734767198562622,
-0.7283872365951538,
-0.3833127021789551,
-0.45818817615509033,
-0.6324383020401001,
-0.2536129951477051,
-0.682202935218811,
0.5550681352615356,
-0.015217834152281284,
-0.016071012243628502,
0.15371079742908478,
-0.2384617030620575,
0.6621289849281311,
0.5258089900016785,
0.1294354349374771,
0.4455989897251129,
0.020687296986579895,
-0.2727181911468506,
0.23287616670131683,
-1.098496913909912,
-0.278160035610199,
0.93547523021698,
0.1372462660074234,
0.9321292638778687,
-0.04877190664410591,
0.866834819316864,
-0.24440699815750122,
0.13478407263755798,
-0.619976818561554,
0.874262273311615,
-0.15578480064868927,
-0.32947513461112976,
-0.19578304886817932,
-0.5424445271492004,
-0.8386004567146301,
0.18813492357730865,
-0.36086711287498474,
-0.6781304478645325,
-0.10978715866804123,
0.28312453627586365,
-0.4618348777294159,
0.30459463596343994,
-0.6547074913978577,
0.6387496590614319,
-0.43703410029411316,
-0.11812575906515121,
-0.34129461646080017,
-0.6835416555404663,
0.752524197101593,
-0.09504693001508713,
-0.046438440680503845,
-0.2877751886844635,
-0.2542745769023895,
0.6117963790893555,
0.06683262437582016,
0.6702976226806641,
0.2277229279279709,
-0.10992156714200974,
-0.09111262112855911,
0.11157680302858353,
0.5152467489242554,
-0.16760501265525818,
-0.07723764330148697,
0.13609251379966736,
-0.27764320373535156,
-0.448113352060318,
-0.6990416646003723,
0.858898401260376,
-0.7787082195281982,
-0.9381200671195984,
-0.19441942870616913,
-1.0930873155593872,
-0.3255087435245514,
0.1137881651520729,
0.10953683406114578,
0.23040322959423065,
0.1318213939666748,
-0.12915092706680298,
1.0682860612869263,
-0.3655562996864319,
0.3113304078578949,
0.5360612273216248,
-0.12436366826295853,
-0.1707325428724289,
0.9558634757995605,
-0.001250123605132103,
0.49389684200286865,
0.5752073526382446,
0.36506709456443787,
-0.3216457664966583,
-0.7980689406394958,
-0.052496109157800674,
0.5170703530311584,
-0.6832022666931152,
-0.1695510745048523,
-0.771864652633667,
-0.20218093693256378,
-0.2971387505531311,
-0.2831692695617676,
-0.31480878591537476,
-0.40681853890419006,
-0.08031335473060608,
0.18323421478271484,
0.07102610915899277,
0.31222400069236755,
0.22307349741458893,
0.16124394536018372,
-0.8988052606582642,
0.2250683605670929,
0.45524218678474426,
0.16671665012836456,
-0.24048787355422974,
-0.1938079297542572,
0.17368477582931519,
-0.3568684160709381,
-0.28502118587493896,
-0.9713169932365417,
0.1065666601061821,
-0.1485244333744049,
0.9262580871582031,
0.340392142534256,
0.22812792658805847,
0.5961080193519592,
-0.053806569427251816,
0.6676952838897705,
0.12813527882099152,
-0.8654257655143738,
0.6144338846206665,
-0.24617645144462585,
0.6211296916007996,
0.3589150309562683,
0.3711516261100769,
-0.10713642835617065,
-0.6339361667633057,
-0.6640180349349976,
-0.8100083470344543,
0.5269545912742615,
0.1310410052537918,
-0.3021354377269745,
0.42700594663619995,
0.311683714389801,
0.1303103119134903,
0.09502408653497696,
-0.31456929445266724,
-0.31377747654914856,
0.3930297791957855,
-0.1350036859512329,
-0.23377037048339844,
-0.34224769473075867,
-0.45450878143310547,
-0.24852001667022705,
0.635681688785553,
-0.16372442245483398,
0.020229853689670563,
0.11099276691675186,
-0.2115132361650467,
0.06670920550823212,
0.22698794305324554,
0.6381959319114685,
0.6385776400566101,
-0.034823644906282425,
0.2634408175945282,
0.5250982642173767,
-0.03506609797477722,
0.44492387771606445,
0.3148936629295349,
-0.15069812536239624,
-0.2691851258277893,
0.34200629591941833,
0.5992136001586914,
0.4659898281097412,
-0.9371540546417236,
0.19528216123580933,
0.054072827100753784,
-0.28247854113578796,
-0.09014402329921722,
0.49814751744270325,
0.1329774260520935,
0.5553193688392639,
0.33879873156547546,
-0.16110216081142426,
-0.05667463690042496,
-0.14740148186683655,
0.10366850346326828,
0.6286956667900085,
0.039655543863773346,
-0.12092173099517822,
0.3796970546245575,
0.3232174217700958,
-0.25816288590431213,
0.45461946725845337,
-0.29844120144844055,
-0.7523979544639587,
0.6497210264205933,
0.488119512796402,
0.8762344717979431,
-0.5184034705162048,
0.07744091749191284,
0.13210010528564453,
0.20210446417331696,
-0.12231285870075226,
0.2471810132265091,
0.04406864196062088,
-0.8817898631095886,
-0.5179120302200317,
-0.6211876273155212,
-0.5304788947105408,
0.14940917491912842,
-0.15919381380081177,
0.3788337707519531,
-0.10691613703966141,
0.17362840473651886,
-0.2829931378364563,
0.19303277134895325,
-0.6738625764846802,
-0.14864379167556763,
0.023385683074593544,
1.0899008512496948,
-0.7806745767593384,
0.7041524648666382,
0.734553873538971,
0.06391093879938126,
-1.0375735759735107,
-0.13872408866882324,
0.396066278219223,
-0.816599428653717,
0.48621484637260437,
0.0814792588353157,
-0.07935994118452072,
0.11987311393022537,
-0.23885251581668854,
-0.7641497254371643,
1.238783597946167,
0.5734672546386719,
-0.5938069224357605,
0.12089986354112625,
0.11268191784620285,
0.05607542023062706,
-0.5196735858917236,
0.1571396142244339,
0.7613716125488281,
0.5416955351829529,
0.5505576729774475,
-0.7483254671096802,
0.18477162718772888,
-0.1471889615058899,
0.06476665288209915,
0.33188942074775696,
-0.46893125772476196,
0.7318239212036133,
-0.33714285492897034,
-0.3100438416004181,
-0.18290069699287415,
0.4859611988067627,
0.709575355052948,
0.11806916445493698,
0.909280002117157,
0.5979623794555664,
0.7943633794784546,
-0.04001713916659355,
1.3130627870559692,
-0.09577391296625137,
0.24583974480628967,
0.9114869832992554,
-0.4932378828525543,
0.6174976229667664,
0.7280063629150391,
-0.2024921476840973,
0.02776947058737278,
0.5667756795883179,
-0.10281100124120712,
0.28117576241493225,
0.5187852382659912,
-0.4400927722454071,
-0.5928341150283813,
-0.06697819381952286,
-0.21300360560417175,
0.35323163866996765,
-0.04690327122807503,
0.015720516443252563,
-0.41332903504371643,
-0.009676244109869003,
-0.18992933630943298,
-0.1786440908908844,
-0.07857275754213333,
0.8778148293495178,
0.0308710727840662,
-0.7998386025428772,
0.6144616007804871,
-0.2924981415271759,
0.6367449760437012,
-0.6937499046325684,
0.08212704956531525,
-0.23624542355537415,
0.35139694809913635,
-0.1530599296092987,
-0.5409491658210754,
0.06895045191049576,
-0.3159205913543701,
-0.1517406851053238,
-0.1306220442056656,
0.9787018895149231,
-0.639394223690033,
-0.6177146434783936,
0.340576171875,
0.6057490706443787,
0.12885543704032898,
0.03551250696182251,
-0.3432260751724243,
0.3193871080875397,
-0.08282212913036346,
-0.2533775568008423,
0.7161514759063721,
-0.1898326575756073,
0.20642459392547607,
0.9461672902107239,
0.5768351554870605,
0.2370927482843399,
0.12899428606033325,
-0.12987270951271057,
1.0957614183425903,
-0.46452465653419495,
-0.21819192171096802,
-0.9055951833724976,
0.6146911382675171,
-0.08888337761163712,
-0.20816314220428467,
0.7420122027397156,
0.41305312514305115,
0.8132301568984985,
-0.007111761253327131,
0.845373809337616,
0.21990302205085754,
0.2922709286212921,
-0.6416236162185669,
0.6340875029563904,
-0.7857509255409241,
0.4672893285751343,
-0.023998524993658066,
-1.0258510112762451,
-0.4322417378425598,
0.2675263285636902,
-0.2252112627029419,
-0.18428710103034973,
0.5918278694152832,
0.9672066569328308,
0.044552844017744064,
-0.008213496766984463,
0.30859610438346863,
0.16174383461475372,
0.47849389910697937,
1.051557183265686,
0.8747928738594055,
-0.20920969545841217,
0.5974247455596924,
-0.4301646053791046,
-0.5611812472343445,
-0.23666682839393616,
-1.0828014612197876,
-1.033201813697815,
-0.5393829941749573,
-0.3787374496459961,
-0.127119243144989,
-0.051355551928281784,
0.9986637234687805,
0.6697341203689575,
-0.5081832408905029,
-0.38986125588417053,
0.22099633514881134,
0.6176268458366394,
-0.35023969411849976,
-0.1378834843635559,
0.12758256494998932,
-0.5127473473548889,
-0.6444068551063538,
0.6314713358879089,
0.3843159079551697,
0.14780889451503754,
-0.49479004740715027,
-0.14164654910564423,
-0.2248610258102417,
0.23038341104984283,
0.43964073061943054,
0.10132387280464172,
-0.8809980750083923,
-0.1791440099477768,
0.1343289315700531,
0.04776474088430405,
-0.16363538801670074,
0.8654365539550781,
-0.8027217984199524,
0.5183010697364807,
0.7284459471702576,
0.9171196818351746,
0.5044755935668945,
-0.0045764553360641,
0.8228796720504761,
-0.564828097820282,
0.04282332956790924,
0.414899080991745,
0.2782456576824188,
0.10234891623258591,
-0.24894854426383972,
0.43641775846481323,
0.1546895056962967,
-0.554979145526886,
-1.1301442384719849,
0.3623543381690979,
-1.1312439441680908,
-0.23113073408603668,
1.3835477828979492,
-0.1784774363040924,
-0.34088465571403503,
-0.03474302962422371,
0.13079625368118286,
0.10432994365692139,
-0.11962119489908218,
1.028264045715332,
0.7475088834762573,
-0.32868120074272156,
-0.22670729458332062,
-0.13241200149059296,
0.3143574297428131,
0.7009772658348083,
-1.0777108669281006,
-0.25125402212142944,
0.12046746164560318,
0.22318920493125916,
0.24636125564575195,
0.32884684205055237,
0.0544835664331913,
0.20030508935451508,
-0.11863084882497787,
-0.02113378793001175,
-0.3247821629047394,
-0.19308483600616455,
-0.32602086663246155,
0.3071001470088959,
-0.18023347854614258,
-0.021261224523186684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11502v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11502v1
|
Towards Coarse-to-Fine Evaluation of Inference Efficiency for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-17T15:57:50 | 2024-04-17T15:57:50 |
Yushuo Chen, Tianyi Tang, Erge Xiang, Linjiang Li, Wayne Xin Zhao, Jing Wang, Yunpeng Chai, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In real world, large language models (LLMs) can serve as the assistant to
help users accomplish their jobs, and also support the development of advanced
applications. For the wide application of LLMs, the inference efficiency is an
essential concern, which has been widely studied in existing work, and numerous
optimization algorithms and code libraries have been proposed to improve it.
Nonetheless, users still find it challenging to compare the effectiveness of
all the above methods and understand the underlying mechanisms. In this work,
we perform a detailed coarse-to-fine analysis of the inference performance of
various code libraries. To evaluate the overall effectiveness, we examine four
usage scenarios within two practical applications. We further provide both
theoretical and empirical fine-grained analyses of each module in the
Transformer architecture. Our experiments yield comprehensive results that are
invaluable for researchers to evaluate code libraries and improve inference
strategies.
|
[
-0.35495248436927795,
-0.8073980212211609,
0.7706900238990784,
0.09137528389692307,
-0.019816100597381592,
-0.35949644446372986,
-0.7443963885307312,
-0.3375537693500519,
-0.4690289795398712,
0.4237383306026459,
-0.2817395031452179,
-0.4545769989490509,
-0.5394524335861206,
0.10792133957147598,
-0.567242443561554,
0.5306630730628967,
0.2853653132915497,
0.005792306736111641,
-0.19660764932632446,
0.07347843050956726,
-0.04661929979920387,
-0.15356864035129547,
-0.5960627198219299,
-0.5032702088356018,
0.46058520674705505,
0.2862166464328766,
0.8453932404518127,
0.47350654006004333,
0.5575157999992371,
0.3739141523838043,
-0.20680487155914307,
0.1434490829706192,
-0.5573733448982239,
-0.22158783674240112,
-0.2842373251914978,
-0.5878604054450989,
-0.3428184688091278,
-0.3646474778652191,
0.5326380133628845,
0.823141872882843,
0.058796148747205734,
0.21579821407794952,
0.2865184545516968,
0.6011559367179871,
-0.7929612994194031,
0.15224409103393555,
-0.5635474920272827,
-0.018444985151290894,
-0.07556407153606415,
-0.01944003812968731,
-0.6482318639755249,
-0.4580521881580353,
0.0757739320397377,
-0.2581794559955597,
0.149889275431633,
0.018902452662587166,
0.8605281710624695,
0.381575345993042,
-0.24262844026088715,
-0.3536989390850067,
-0.9124969840049744,
1.0798918008804321,
-1.17699134349823,
0.5910894870758057,
0.19316190481185913,
0.26766237616539,
-0.17571401596069336,
-0.9335886836051941,
-0.5005870461463928,
-0.5258088707923889,
-0.36101996898651123,
0.0068246000446379185,
-0.5954638719558716,
0.39503559470176697,
0.3013242185115814,
0.5160143971443176,
-0.33025696873664856,
0.4753304719924927,
-0.0955561101436615,
-0.049136292189359665,
0.4413118064403534,
0.1447192132472992,
0.049533743411302567,
-0.21655888855457306,
0.050663989037275314,
-0.13402137160301208,
-0.3550225794315338,
-0.06779339164495468,
0.4586293399333954,
0.2107563018798828,
-0.20280267298221588,
0.5310434699058533,
-0.16036556661128998,
0.7964848875999451,
-0.029221849516034126,
-0.2622906267642975,
0.08440780639648438,
-0.24138575792312622,
-0.3988023102283478,
-0.6604517698287964,
0.8335061073303223,
0.36633965373039246,
0.4386007487773895,
-0.5794337391853333,
-0.497407466173172,
-0.002827836899086833,
0.3907848298549652,
-0.928520143032074,
-0.22887252271175385,
0.2044309377670288,
-0.671687662601471,
-0.17645977437496185,
-0.15860845148563385,
-0.8271324038505554,
-0.2789723873138428,
-0.5170807242393494,
0.39653828740119934,
-0.367012619972229,
-0.13293315470218658,
0.16821932792663574,
-0.15403424203395844,
0.3652938902378082,
0.16612671315670013,
-0.726919412612915,
0.4181266725063324,
0.8422873616218567,
0.7205178141593933,
-0.3094017803668976,
-0.12839461863040924,
-0.3965970575809479,
-0.2687218189239502,
-0.20831036567687988,
0.937023937702179,
-0.5971705913543701,
-0.21394330263137817,
0.054212167859077454,
-0.16491463780403137,
-0.16140717267990112,
-0.6927750706672668,
1.0837063789367676,
-0.5705183148384094,
-0.42345568537712097,
0.20819205045700073,
-0.7097480893135071,
-0.016021883115172386,
0.020222904160618782,
-0.8675886988639832,
0.9888429045677185,
0.20199070870876312,
-0.5158078670501709,
0.05260343477129936,
-0.5195796489715576,
-0.3532566726207733,
-0.1966247707605362,
-0.03939324617385864,
-0.47117552161216736,
0.6405149102210999,
0.07518993318080902,
0.7424387335777283,
-0.5881733298301697,
0.38331568241119385,
-0.3958369195461273,
-0.6321449875831604,
0.30022332072257996,
-0.841768741607666,
0.4809587895870209,
0.4535222053527832,
-0.38632169365882874,
0.09121498465538025,
-0.7257786393165588,
-0.08249393850564957,
-0.1624632328748703,
-0.4247218668460846,
-0.4591892659664154,
0.16830682754516602,
-0.017083678394556046,
-0.19262106716632843,
0.02997196651995182,
-0.2933677136898041,
0.14025664329528809,
-0.3122682571411133,
0.34603527188301086,
0.545560896396637,
-0.30103161931037903,
0.679780900478363,
-0.06711698323488235,
0.5021587014198303,
-0.33477601408958435,
0.2086665779352188,
-0.04782068729400635,
-0.14434225857257843,
-0.7891121506690979,
-0.5305967926979065,
0.6425985097885132,
0.30651625990867615,
-0.655846893787384,
0.43888261914253235,
-0.4430180788040161,
-0.5829938650131226,
-0.4748258888721466,
0.13030563294887543,
0.5290381908416748,
0.10980398207902908,
0.23077456653118134,
0.0777704045176506,
-0.22275103628635406,
-1.045883297920227,
-0.4905148446559906,
0.009862477891147137,
-0.25231167674064636,
0.585421621799469,
0.41398170590400696,
-0.3845042288303375,
1.0230473279953003,
-0.5246008038520813,
0.3710494041442871,
-0.5268717408180237,
-0.05665598809719086,
0.3768371641635895,
0.31754350662231445,
0.5054168105125427,
-0.5927531123161316,
-0.16309978067874908,
0.08490648865699768,
-0.457466721534729,
-0.5761986374855042,
-0.19293834269046783,
-0.15832069516181946,
0.15126632153987885,
0.6306983828544617,
-0.36371099948883057,
0.37178972363471985,
0.8943948745727539,
-0.12142235040664673,
0.8403410911560059,
-0.260590523481369,
0.18024055659770966,
-0.5716037154197693,
0.13298676908016205,
0.2026708871126175,
-0.14923708140850067,
-0.6963624954223633,
0.3919035494327545,
0.2802278995513916,
0.14040344953536987,
-0.31037023663520813,
0.6083758473396301,
-0.3570350706577301,
-0.21419286727905273,
-0.07577499002218246,
0.18097521364688873,
0.06443247944116592,
0.48202967643737793,
-0.1523878127336502,
1.051238775253296,
0.43453970551490784,
-0.6521125435829163,
-0.1485653668642044,
-0.25158387422561646,
-0.6812372207641602,
0.19588257372379303,
-0.8178898692131042,
-0.03525698557496071,
0.10357771068811417,
0.024463318288326263,
-1.1463912725448608,
-0.0673048198223114,
-0.15376242995262146,
-0.05790187045931816,
0.3614700138568878,
-0.2269909381866455,
-0.7373893857002258,
-0.32142961025238037,
-0.3492821455001831,
0.24917753040790558,
0.5753915905952454,
-0.679858386516571,
0.8486416339874268,
0.2167120724916458,
0.24631230533123016,
-0.4735530912876129,
-0.6471899151802063,
0.028595181182026863,
-0.5269384980201721,
-0.5952325463294983,
0.21620838344097137,
0.058073461055755615,
-0.6384427547454834,
-0.21020005643367767,
-0.1688980609178543,
-0.15942275524139404,
0.3290020227432251,
-0.029228046536445618,
0.04126368835568428,
-0.3450622260570526,
0.10693933814764023,
0.2022622674703598,
-0.1334686428308487,
0.016596725210547447,
-0.1074080541729927,
0.4910413920879364,
-0.32434386014938354,
-0.4945642948150635,
-0.4512925148010254,
-0.06252992153167725,
0.3709994852542877,
-0.06454936414957047,
0.5979618430137634,
0.5558412075042725,
-0.023383410647511482,
-0.339711457490921,
-0.8921928405761719,
0.009495783597230911,
-0.5005079507827759,
0.3933992385864258,
-0.4894361197948456,
-0.6562625765800476,
0.6423395276069641,
-0.5708214640617371,
0.13982707262039185,
0.38729679584503174,
0.5820124745368958,
0.23744063079357147,
0.7650384902954102,
0.4809371531009674,
0.08391818404197693,
0.454546719789505,
-0.3637278974056244,
0.4426766335964203,
-0.6889451146125793,
0.03663118928670883,
-0.9185185432434082,
-0.2187548726797104,
-0.4944051206111908,
-0.7080516815185547,
0.17254184186458588,
0.4700256288051605,
-0.03874420002102852,
0.49125829339027405,
-0.1552746742963791,
0.4890095889568329,
0.3253381550312042,
0.08894893527030945,
0.6318507194519043,
-0.053210362792015076,
0.01514840591698885,
0.21722018718719482,
-0.7094717621803284,
-0.8528082966804504,
0.887138843536377,
0.5105909705162048,
1.1344794034957886,
0.1703435331583023,
0.45238709449768066,
0.19401240348815918,
0.2842314839363098,
-1.1514679193496704,
0.4795893430709839,
-0.4231342077255249,
-0.19508768618106842,
-0.21831728518009186,
-0.5632101893424988,
-0.8604104518890381,
0.34697970747947693,
-0.025864161550998688,
-0.7540358901023865,
0.17119218409061432,
0.23695266246795654,
-0.30093538761138916,
0.28072237968444824,
-1.1236251592636108,
0.9557521939277649,
-0.04833300784230232,
-0.41121068596839905,
-0.3242703974246979,
-0.32065269351005554,
0.3448926508426666,
-0.3138655126094818,
0.39477667212486267,
0.0020641114097088575,
-0.10124101489782333,
0.4745546579360962,
-0.21055811643600464,
0.7969377636909485,
-0.018124407157301903,
-0.37161529064178467,
0.241719052195549,
-0.025675497949123383,
0.41429901123046875,
-0.1486946940422058,
-0.7361759543418884,
0.4507279098033905,
-0.08879781514406204,
-0.16868464648723602,
-0.7596986889839172,
0.715777575969696,
-0.5791890025138855,
-0.3241475522518158,
0.24586157500743866,
-0.6630873084068298,
-0.16812239587306976,
0.1403675228357315,
0.1510094255208969,
0.7930779457092285,
-0.16121642291545868,
0.2815318703651428,
0.5885104537010193,
-0.47471681237220764,
0.573150098323822,
0.41950634121894836,
-0.07425295561552048,
0.16544391214847565,
0.5485692620277405,
-0.0751432552933693,
0.5366637110710144,
0.46667346358299255,
0.47246265411376953,
-0.35583043098449707,
-0.8763859272003174,
-0.5067377686500549,
0.1935223788022995,
-0.7103883624076843,
-0.15114277601242065,
-0.592063844203949,
0.11625895649194717,
-0.22869817912578583,
-0.14450232684612274,
-0.37259700894355774,
-0.3011343777179718,
-0.10919326543807983,
0.13738267123699188,
0.23401890695095062,
0.6501206755638123,
0.1322956383228302,
0.646291971206665,
-0.672578752040863,
0.32653746008872986,
0.0488072969019413,
0.522629976272583,
0.3567691743373871,
-0.6943544745445251,
-0.41206812858581543,
-0.20108456909656525,
-0.21230871975421906,
-0.4106532037258148,
0.10130108147859573,
0.301508367061615,
0.7161276936531067,
0.5423725843429565,
0.13232280313968658,
0.9410070776939392,
-0.6322690844535828,
0.7448528409004211,
-0.24041563272476196,
-1.0682817697525024,
-0.018637018278241158,
-0.045690491795539856,
0.21233028173446655,
0.5835703015327454,
0.02622132934629917,
-0.070559561252594,
-0.5222247242927551,
-0.48405495285987854,
-0.8579874634742737,
0.4515608251094818,
0.3339337110519409,
0.2898983955383301,
0.014017115347087383,
0.40589237213134766,
0.08839080482721329,
-0.17288394272327423,
-0.5085120797157288,
-0.3898829221725464,
0.445808082818985,
-0.1608746349811554,
-0.05094079673290253,
-0.23517824709415436,
0.29161199927330017,
-0.2155144065618515,
0.49619925022125244,
-0.22667263448238373,
0.2794201970100403,
-0.16196896135807037,
-0.3108883798122406,
0.2613259553909302,
0.440525621175766,
0.44121575355529785,
0.8525838851928711,
0.02965969778597355,
0.30307021737098694,
0.4985547363758087,
-0.28870975971221924,
-0.27766844630241394,
-0.043803516775369644,
0.20667457580566406,
0.04212890565395355,
0.6730692982673645,
0.7682368755340576,
0.6600971817970276,
-0.9192194938659668,
0.44463059306144714,
-0.22889591753482819,
0.04119165241718292,
-0.18657533824443817,
0.3192560374736786,
0.22047670185565948,
0.507472813129425,
0.1776323914527893,
-0.02289939671754837,
0.5332105755805969,
-0.3535778522491455,
0.18583305180072784,
0.49667802453041077,
-0.07308817654848099,
-0.1055959090590477,
0.30730921030044556,
0.05834930017590523,
-0.3558570146560669,
0.342510461807251,
-0.13473470509052277,
-0.3302421271800995,
0.6156600117683411,
0.4564723074436188,
0.7704529762268066,
0.023592719808220863,
-0.23091258108615875,
0.20217663049697876,
0.13032536208629608,
-0.21594907343387604,
-0.2747999429702759,
-0.17010851204395294,
-0.6378220319747925,
-0.9195139408111572,
-0.8937056064605713,
-0.332453191280365,
0.09596868604421616,
-0.811640202999115,
0.34319135546684265,
0.2153577357530594,
-0.12510453164577484,
0.2164580225944519,
-0.03184257447719574,
-0.694787323474884,
-0.12515217065811157,
0.1433439552783966,
1.2127054929733276,
-0.7933866381645203,
0.8550330996513367,
0.36991211771965027,
0.15894727408885956,
-1.0135517120361328,
0.1849980354309082,
-0.26950541138648987,
-0.7946789860725403,
0.5543542504310608,
0.06857619434595108,
-0.46759679913520813,
-0.02613881044089794,
-0.3777731657028198,
-0.5238227844238281,
0.8908721804618835,
0.5155423283576965,
-0.7270979285240173,
0.029432451352477074,
0.0861542820930481,
0.6523118615150452,
-0.12060417979955673,
0.8124755024909973,
1.31106698513031,
0.6639447808265686,
-0.03446714207530022,
-0.9788551926612854,
-0.16250137984752655,
-0.04963051155209541,
0.3891296684741974,
0.35887250304222107,
-0.24255596101284027,
0.49208614230155945,
-0.14772991836071014,
-0.08053013682365417,
0.3244958221912384,
0.6499331593513489,
0.019851217046380043,
0.22576995193958282,
0.6409626603126526,
0.5186748504638672,
0.5524640679359436,
-0.043161094188690186,
1.425508975982666,
-0.5079428553581238,
0.7874007821083069,
0.8628354668617249,
0.04519560933113098,
0.8116323947906494,
0.43990179896354675,
-0.46630337834358215,
0.3478715121746063,
0.2671147584915161,
-0.0462043397128582,
0.3056087791919708,
0.36734843254089355,
-0.21318577229976654,
-0.24448122084140778,
0.08410907536745071,
0.0991729125380516,
0.3630948066711426,
0.41925016045570374,
-0.3422568142414093,
-0.41969260573387146,
-0.12087730318307877,
0.19980435073375702,
0.01185272354632616,
-0.3434387147426605,
0.7041329741477966,
0.14820332825183868,
-0.6232554316520691,
0.6799628734588623,
0.11390916258096695,
0.8579923510551453,
-0.4448128640651703,
0.027259396389126778,
-0.24114428460597992,
0.5552905201911926,
-0.3821851909160614,
-0.7539086937904358,
0.5230163931846619,
0.32125213742256165,
0.0032282297033816576,
0.09678436070680618,
0.7462099194526672,
-0.1037554144859314,
-0.37873575091362,
0.4281270205974579,
0.3751671314239502,
0.487961083650589,
-0.01689041033387184,
-0.6135828495025635,
0.3419252932071686,
-0.023369817063212395,
-0.43802034854888916,
0.2101181149482727,
0.5014617443084717,
0.10801071673631668,
0.5962879061698914,
0.43772637844085693,
0.033545054495334625,
0.041708022356033325,
0.4784383773803711,
0.758784294128418,
-0.3415661156177521,
-0.025256501510739326,
-1.1984127759933472,
0.5279887914657593,
-0.011001579463481903,
-0.23443818092346191,
0.9211098551750183,
0.5892394185066223,
0.6968145370483398,
-0.1551429182291031,
0.5167244076728821,
-0.14993415772914886,
0.2362905889749527,
-0.6945247650146484,
0.4259962737560272,
-0.4963257610797882,
0.624904215335846,
-0.46805331110954285,
-1.0218636989593506,
-0.3688753545284271,
0.6552583575248718,
-0.4993188679218292,
0.04511051997542381,
0.6281065940856934,
1.0650404691696167,
-0.3975190222263336,
-0.021530529484152794,
0.4959452152252197,
0.2753443121910095,
0.34970822930336,
0.3251672089099884,
0.7684308886528015,
-0.31618010997772217,
0.544381856918335,
-0.4621312618255615,
-0.31068935990333557,
-0.2545015215873718,
-1.185350775718689,
-1.0070489645004272,
-0.24675555527210236,
-0.0690682977437973,
-0.24997830390930176,
-0.15449117124080658,
0.8842048048973083,
0.6251992583274841,
-0.718029797077179,
-0.4799156188964844,
-0.06688089668750763,
-0.009680713526904583,
-0.23751908540725708,
-0.2069290280342102,
0.504073441028595,
-0.5268695950508118,
-1.1223244667053223,
0.2838747799396515,
0.028176764026284218,
-0.44169846177101135,
-0.25158941745758057,
-0.06883171200752258,
0.18562346696853638,
0.23919694125652313,
0.8886570334434509,
-0.1452653408050537,
-0.8053780198097229,
-0.29346963763237,
-0.11801278591156006,
-0.18014024198055267,
-0.07831286638975143,
0.989091157913208,
-0.7229496836662292,
0.07245079427957535,
0.5292031168937683,
0.8908562660217285,
0.42215022444725037,
0.1273096352815628,
0.4817497730255127,
-0.49585747718811035,
-0.048851415514945984,
-0.005531822796911001,
0.47861769795417786,
0.1278856247663498,
-0.09823527932167053,
0.6794878840446472,
-0.2559708058834076,
-0.7760117053985596,
-0.8926520943641663,
0.04576483368873596,
-0.9160054326057434,
-0.4244956076145172,
1.5481606721878052,
-0.3541686236858368,
-0.15767939388751984,
-0.14228828251361847,
-0.15565602481365204,
0.25066450238227844,
-0.4084317982196808,
0.5246570110321045,
0.39588913321495056,
-0.195278599858284,
0.009381942451000214,
-0.9938170909881592,
0.21541328728199005,
0.35941430926322937,
-0.8771398067474365,
0.28720858693122864,
0.4650987684726715,
0.18597005307674408,
0.1151372492313385,
0.10178815573453903,
0.0811128243803978,
-0.09368258714675903,
-0.13363251090049744,
-0.024360308423638344,
0.07637389749288559,
-0.1567295342683792,
-0.7275440692901611,
-0.03230559453368187,
0.30049270391464233,
0.3873169422149658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11500v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11500v1
|
Paraphrase and Solve: Exploring and Exploiting the Impact of Surface Form on Mathematical Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-17T15:53:49 | 2024-04-17T15:53:49 |
Yue Zhou, Yada Zhu, Diego Antognini, Yoon Kim, Yang Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper studies the relationship between the surface form of a
mathematical problem and its solvability by large language models. We find that
subtle alterations in the surface form can significantly impact the answer
distribution and the solve rate, exposing the language model's lack of
robustness and sensitivity to the surface form in reasoning through complex
problems. To improve mathematical reasoning performance, we propose
Self-Consistency-over-Paraphrases (SCoP), which diversifies reasoning paths
from specific surface forms of the problem. We evaluate our approach on four
mathematics reasoning benchmarks over three large language models and show that
SCoP improves mathematical reasoning performance over vanilla self-consistency,
particularly for problems initially deemed unsolvable. Finally, we provide
additional experiments and discussion regarding problem difficulty and surface
forms, including cross-model difficulty agreement and paraphrasing
transferability, and Variance of Variations (VOV) for language model
evaluation.
|
[
-0.06178846210241318,
-0.7803747653961182,
1.211446762084961,
0.7254850268363953,
0.005676387809216976,
-0.07459412515163422,
-0.16861118376255035,
-0.1556423455476761,
-0.11298906803131104,
0.7273392081260681,
-0.057973042130470276,
-0.16649752855300903,
-0.778126060962677,
0.039016999304294586,
-0.2413731813430786,
0.6579471826553345,
-0.4356918931007385,
0.0965980589389801,
-1.0736854076385498,
-0.1702227145433426,
-0.0890028178691864,
-0.7405186295509338,
-0.27780017256736755,
-0.15435676276683807,
0.1823129504919052,
0.4226644039154053,
0.9694640636444092,
0.6087953448295593,
0.758446216583252,
0.3596346080303192,
-0.230006143450737,
0.014786950312554836,
-0.17863793671131134,
0.719354510307312,
-0.4597015380859375,
-0.613228440284729,
0.009722292423248291,
-0.30526700615882874,
0.5436477661132812,
0.9657634496688843,
-0.4740769863128662,
-0.03317819908261299,
0.12653803825378418,
0.4679710566997528,
-0.6416530013084412,
0.5331813097000122,
-0.5746529698371887,
-0.42347511649131775,
-0.26720839738845825,
-0.003162091365084052,
-0.267141193151474,
-0.23604655265808105,
0.0690947100520134,
-0.6732997298240662,
0.01896052248775959,
-0.40594610571861267,
0.4196588397026062,
0.2122482806444168,
-0.06312894821166992,
-0.34492090344429016,
-0.7139761447906494,
0.9425535202026367,
-0.9371808171272278,
0.2569931745529175,
0.3780510723590851,
0.4865613281726837,
-0.24526634812355042,
-0.808051586151123,
-0.2868817150592804,
-0.37643590569496155,
0.13136334717273712,
-0.13987553119659424,
-0.39849987626075745,
-0.2447921484708786,
0.41600722074508667,
0.08967597782611847,
-0.3478691279888153,
-0.5260034203529358,
-0.49339428544044495,
-0.22546790540218353,
0.7120013236999512,
0.0791221484541893,
0.7629727721214294,
-0.14070342481136322,
0.08078987896442413,
0.1272752285003662,
-0.7449114322662354,
0.39782044291496277,
-0.04380396008491516,
0.33519867062568665,
0.2477642446756363,
0.6856405138969421,
-0.2531980276107788,
0.6245031952857971,
-0.5531994104385376,
-0.2539682984352112,
0.0064939577132463455,
-0.07537679374217987,
0.038117628544569016,
-0.3382207453250885,
0.34458157420158386,
0.053743090480566025,
0.172943115234375,
-0.1246296614408493,
-0.15716107189655304,
-0.15719009935855865,
-0.1076478436589241,
-0.5952913165092468,
-0.1996181309223175,
-0.1581588238477707,
-0.36936628818511963,
0.10833016037940979,
0.017714109271764755,
-0.5065116882324219,
-0.2931085526943207,
-0.6577309370040894,
0.6494801640510559,
-0.53704434633255,
-0.26255837082862854,
0.43050289154052734,
-0.19791965186595917,
-0.11487314105033875,
0.8087191581726074,
-0.5259534120559692,
0.4294680655002594,
0.8034168481826782,
0.8377821445465088,
-0.054710324853658676,
-0.395174503326416,
-0.5318797826766968,
0.2714383602142334,
-0.2733736038208008,
0.9879376888275146,
-0.8468583226203918,
-0.3865028917789459,
-0.26740533113479614,
-0.3406994342803955,
-0.30955275893211365,
-0.6828019022941589,
0.6881685853004456,
0.16892525553703308,
0.2654375731945038,
-0.5152024626731873,
-0.37592607736587524,
0.013156992383301258,
-0.13004079461097717,
-0.4645116329193115,
1.0353881120681763,
0.02442947030067444,
-0.3579808175563812,
-0.3362620174884796,
-0.5466580986976624,
-0.4495779275894165,
-0.11401979625225067,
-0.20998041331768036,
-0.270027220249176,
0.7788465023040771,
0.3266899287700653,
0.13324429094791412,
-0.31875234842300415,
0.2557762563228607,
-0.6117745637893677,
-0.06379515677690506,
0.3650875985622406,
-0.3105618357658386,
0.7460921406745911,
0.41692104935646057,
-0.33911940455436707,
-0.26518237590789795,
-0.641563892364502,
0.2157670110464096,
0.2400442659854889,
0.2235063910484314,
-0.5056555271148682,
0.12510737776756287,
-0.12619410455226898,
0.44764986634254456,
0.4814440608024597,
-0.5811672210693359,
0.20282059907913208,
-0.1390262395143509,
0.796018123626709,
0.45402202010154724,
0.11445344984531403,
0.2514124810695648,
-0.22296802699565887,
0.5929943919181824,
-0.08628997951745987,
0.08974165469408035,
0.08198799937963486,
-0.8143714666366577,
-0.423246830701828,
-0.0938338041305542,
0.07918603718280792,
0.4671488106250763,
-0.5922409892082214,
-0.39243564009666443,
-0.10929480940103531,
-0.7675604224205017,
-0.20669977366924286,
0.3561454713344574,
0.40598076581954956,
0.4038811922073364,
0.5506361722946167,
0.4822443127632141,
-0.20395956933498383,
-1.0983824729919434,
-0.8513590693473816,
0.26778843998908997,
-0.017429770901799202,
0.38023942708969116,
0.4017725884914398,
0.12384028732776642,
0.8455654382705688,
-0.6086702346801758,
0.024632353335618973,
-0.490041047334671,
0.22408665716648102,
-0.06512607634067535,
0.47566327452659607,
0.6611338257789612,
-0.6231853365898132,
-0.6413570642471313,
-0.22450987994670868,
-0.8943201899528503,
-0.4201541543006897,
0.20799490809440613,
-0.16263121366500854,
-0.08682786673307419,
0.8356825113296509,
-0.9072205424308777,
0.5540657639503479,
0.2946392595767975,
-0.3196587562561035,
0.24142974615097046,
-0.5735266804695129,
0.1216689944267273,
-0.6633836030960083,
-0.08502735197544098,
0.036034420132637024,
0.09761583805084229,
-0.36524030566215515,
0.08627664297819138,
0.008792277425527573,
-0.7164294123649597,
-0.3512299060821533,
0.479182630777359,
-0.42539745569229126,
-0.025315916165709496,
-0.21536628901958466,
0.12231320142745972,
0.2837584912776947,
0.10709143429994583,
-0.018907897174358368,
0.9887717366218567,
0.5828797221183777,
-0.5707443356513977,
0.0011356764007359743,
0.1348593682050705,
0.0005655738059431314,
0.5605835914611816,
-1.1346750259399414,
0.014157663099467754,
-0.41363659501075745,
0.1353619396686554,
-1.162370204925537,
-0.16040955483913422,
-0.17446674406528473,
-0.2594005763530731,
-0.11793296784162521,
0.023718876764178276,
-0.2598099708557129,
-0.07525285333395004,
-0.19627752900123596,
0.6326039433479309,
0.33523446321487427,
-0.20951837301254272,
0.9372034668922424,
0.2346351146697998,
-0.645388126373291,
-0.10032165795564651,
-0.5232073068618774,
0.2750359773635864,
-0.22374746203422546,
-0.8887898921966553,
0.4977036714553833,
-0.17187240719795227,
-0.4362543225288391,
-0.1495046317577362,
-0.43390145897865295,
-0.16165730357170105,
0.02209923416376114,
0.094092458486557,
-0.2971101999282837,
-0.18725556135177612,
-0.0868815928697586,
0.3387622535228729,
-0.11662452667951584,
0.34296077489852905,
0.05538731440901756,
0.48494017124176025,
-0.2462998479604721,
-0.38441571593284607,
-0.4674472510814667,
0.5740492939949036,
0.8685311079025269,
-0.5059022307395935,
0.46381375193595886,
-0.37652483582496643,
-0.6490993499755859,
-0.014959186315536499,
-0.28885290026664734,
0.1623568832874298,
-0.41444990038871765,
-0.01978810876607895,
-1.025084376335144,
-0.21653184294700623,
0.7197205424308777,
0.06657058745622635,
-0.19168083369731903,
0.776114284992218,
0.27844664454460144,
-0.14898952841758728,
1.2790849208831787,
0.329241544008255,
0.6155245900154114,
0.27448779344558716,
-0.26521918177604675,
0.1687566488981247,
-0.48379191756248474,
-0.5280007123947144,
-0.7139830589294434,
-0.012088759802281857,
-0.015216175466775894,
-0.4426850378513336,
0.33370327949523926,
0.6510514616966248,
-0.08617185801267624,
0.6353746652603149,
-0.3692721426486969,
0.3990880846977234,
0.5383065938949585,
0.316371887922287,
0.29138636589050293,
0.04168526455760002,
-0.07180201262235641,
-0.5901731252670288,
-0.6062950491905212,
-0.45163097977638245,
0.9813153743743896,
0.17172132432460785,
0.667290449142456,
0.4097093939781189,
0.7571762800216675,
0.06589717417955399,
0.07736935466527939,
-0.057578686624765396,
0.46901845932006836,
-0.2224956899881363,
-0.33859071135520935,
-0.46553465723991394,
-0.5094925761222839,
-0.9715494513511658,
0.2108249068260193,
0.13750562071800232,
-0.68426114320755,
0.1335422545671463,
-0.04949015751481056,
-0.10897166281938553,
-0.013285228982567787,
-0.4863947629928589,
1.1405333280563354,
-0.3476516008377075,
-0.2111196517944336,
-0.23320087790489197,
-0.36612939834594727,
0.009004883468151093,
0.26988324522972107,
0.5168168544769287,
-0.15796588361263275,
0.0002600582374725491,
0.6458037495613098,
-0.7299066781997681,
0.4608864486217499,
-0.22501108050346375,
-0.3336421847343445,
0.45059099793434143,
0.49543195962905884,
0.3978191614151001,
0.14589790999889374,
-0.019746897742152214,
0.11055880784988403,
0.205661803483963,
-0.7901676297187805,
-1.3790664672851562,
0.712516725063324,
-0.6772716641426086,
-0.8348853588104248,
-0.35908085107803345,
-0.7165915369987488,
-0.2847597002983093,
0.07142580300569534,
0.4050973951816559,
0.6452939510345459,
0.2846139967441559,
0.4098356068134308,
0.6263523101806641,
-0.009713806211948395,
0.22616221010684967,
0.07784391194581985,
-0.3876112401485443,
-0.6610036492347717,
0.9725217819213867,
0.5654395818710327,
0.5259347558021545,
0.20634712278842926,
0.5384475588798523,
-0.3365906774997711,
-0.47955521941185,
-0.34238293766975403,
0.38763588666915894,
-0.8828399181365967,
-0.17307157814502716,
-0.6600810885429382,
-0.3561709523200989,
-0.4607871174812317,
-0.07517000287771225,
-0.467185378074646,
-0.9573753476142883,
0.13711410760879517,
0.3124335706233978,
0.42189374566078186,
0.5280513763427734,
-0.15458793938159943,
0.2397024929523468,
-0.53970867395401,
0.3782392144203186,
0.27062469720840454,
0.09799143671989441,
-0.31720343232154846,
-0.7709346413612366,
0.2520269453525543,
0.3210606276988983,
-0.13117212057113647,
-0.8267475962638855,
0.03937608376145363,
0.2667534351348877,
1.0444018840789795,
0.08657215535640717,
-0.03353727608919144,
0.6418222784996033,
-0.42230358719825745,
0.5322660207748413,
0.07190772145986557,
-1.447641372680664,
0.7999680638313293,
-0.34803661704063416,
0.16270208358764648,
0.4380114674568176,
0.3429914712905884,
-0.20068056881427765,
-0.5103153586387634,
-0.8756309747695923,
-0.5337914824485779,
0.15251557528972626,
0.5614311695098877,
0.27539002895355225,
0.1269201785326004,
0.6662787199020386,
0.09067526459693909,
0.11551249772310257,
-0.5944124460220337,
-0.0329718142747879,
-0.3331966996192932,
-0.27563220262527466,
-0.026295198127627373,
-0.26380717754364014,
-0.15110333263874054,
-0.4686511158943176,
0.29908761382102966,
0.0984364002943039,
0.07260110974311829,
0.2107512205839157,
-0.3769659399986267,
-0.04027610644698143,
0.09438316524028778,
0.8761886954307556,
1.3015201091766357,
0.13831350207328796,
0.3536953628063202,
0.11211812496185303,
-0.2265334576368332,
-0.005243746098130941,
0.3309336006641388,
-0.16852177679538727,
0.20875422656536102,
0.5383625626564026,
0.41121798753738403,
0.5078460574150085,
-0.5883736610412598,
0.4455404579639435,
0.2488938868045807,
-0.41966086626052856,
0.10102586448192596,
0.07288392633199692,
0.1444968730211258,
0.1432984620332718,
0.42981332540512085,
0.11500032991170883,
0.38800641894340515,
-0.6492496132850647,
0.17130060493946075,
0.33339568972587585,
0.08631858229637146,
-0.062227994203567505,
0.6966810822486877,
-0.15250372886657715,
-0.5922461152076721,
0.5630543828010559,
0.14152395725250244,
-0.8211654424667358,
0.7189775109291077,
0.9082655310630798,
0.34736257791519165,
-0.46015194058418274,
0.4271806478500366,
0.06066002696752548,
-0.08833970874547958,
-0.40561187267303467,
0.3513423502445221,
-0.030844779685139656,
-0.4237273335456848,
-0.4580582082271576,
-0.20010431110858917,
-0.5750149488449097,
0.11558347195386887,
-0.6373805999755859,
0.18120728433132172,
-0.6457040905952454,
0.2614936828613281,
0.3265504837036133,
-0.2905443608760834,
-0.242435485124588,
0.1649089902639389,
0.11919457465410233,
0.6976801753044128,
-0.8639305233955383,
0.2866553068161011,
0.7846135497093201,
-0.6431800127029419,
-0.7248635292053223,
-0.1265685111284256,
-0.4800403118133545,
-0.7318015098571777,
0.6290958523750305,
0.2596983313560486,
-0.2787007689476013,
-0.06719936430454254,
-0.5798697471618652,
-1.4223264455795288,
0.6945691704750061,
0.8682658672332764,
-0.19176273047924042,
0.0205690898001194,
0.28006184101104736,
0.5876456499099731,
-0.21589137613773346,
0.20322342216968536,
0.28929057717323303,
0.3926367163658142,
0.21701815724372864,
-1.1248865127563477,
0.16356134414672852,
-0.2207135409116745,
0.27988293766975403,
0.1608908623456955,
-0.4068002998828888,
1.1165211200714111,
-0.1146085262298584,
0.04909243434667587,
0.13382579386234283,
0.9090664386749268,
0.6658051013946533,
0.54526287317276,
0.2391253411769867,
0.685904324054718,
0.470467746257782,
-0.05596330761909485,
0.8573065400123596,
-0.2591342329978943,
0.6070385575294495,
0.8298109173774719,
-0.19746513664722443,
0.9291248321533203,
0.5421115756034851,
-0.4304219186306,
0.7475824952125549,
0.22892217338085175,
0.4199480712413788,
0.6313374042510986,
0.3947426378726959,
-0.20350924134254456,
-0.7816182971000671,
0.3657459020614624,
-0.6748165488243103,
0.5623723268508911,
0.40028616786003113,
-0.02552844025194645,
-0.8922236561775208,
0.4801505208015442,
0.12067566066980362,
0.9050953984260559,
-0.33826956152915955,
0.27867209911346436,
0.23655147850513458,
-0.631741464138031,
0.5748171806335449,
0.11159784346818924,
-0.11648200452327728,
-0.33704426884651184,
-0.39457419514656067,
-0.339476078748703,
0.24565763771533966,
-0.18071825802326202,
-0.9026772379875183,
0.5366485714912415,
-0.4335443377494812,
-0.09606210887432098,
-0.25853824615478516,
0.6168645620346069,
-0.40982505679130554,
-0.8609331846237183,
0.06509330123662949,
0.666780412197113,
0.3443388044834137,
-0.6148660778999329,
-0.914026141166687,
0.16119834780693054,
-0.1606038361787796,
-0.14702598750591278,
0.18641774356365204,
0.9433450102806091,
-0.3624023199081421,
0.904042661190033,
0.6720144152641296,
-0.32439014315605164,
0.05378475785255432,
-0.0789417251944542,
0.7389417886734009,
-0.6690766215324402,
-0.37767860293388367,
-0.93039470911026,
0.41259288787841797,
-0.3285773694515228,
-0.502557635307312,
0.9080088138580322,
0.8626025915145874,
0.2760534882545471,
-0.09372801333665848,
0.7244371771812439,
0.0715021938085556,
0.6681936383247375,
-0.4922425150871277,
0.28758513927459717,
-0.4312869906425476,
0.18893283605575562,
-0.44749966263771057,
-1.137927770614624,
-0.5129793882369995,
0.9961785078048706,
-0.7947798371315002,
0.0005375855253078043,
0.6610231399536133,
0.2791154980659485,
-0.29541388154029846,
-0.21354307234287262,
0.19622725248336792,
-0.02943677082657814,
0.43993645906448364,
0.5033009052276611,
0.79818195104599,
-0.3803267478942871,
0.7010986804962158,
-0.43262141942977905,
-0.2425476312637329,
-0.172721266746521,
-0.8562014698982239,
-0.6997492909431458,
-0.44734007120132446,
-0.4892376661300659,
-0.7518804669380188,
0.03944368287920952,
0.44148990511894226,
0.22643312811851501,
-0.7243428826332092,
-0.14680209755897522,
-0.659591794013977,
0.08221039921045303,
-0.30158481001853943,
-0.2616218030452728,
0.46741732954978943,
-0.7438338994979858,
-0.6336471438407898,
0.30286017060279846,
0.31108322739601135,
-0.037047769874334335,
-0.15081624686717987,
0.12039269506931305,
0.165662944316864,
0.34367164969444275,
0.5055112838745117,
0.4812908470630646,
-0.8279054760932922,
-0.2588711380958557,
0.2737462818622589,
-0.22220644354820251,
0.0349259153008461,
1.0707061290740967,
-0.4567258656024933,
0.16023719310760498,
0.45874372124671936,
0.6989940404891968,
0.69710373878479,
0.1612306833267212,
0.8323624730110168,
0.02852076105773449,
-0.05522829294204712,
0.2004755735397339,
0.5922310948371887,
0.19521977007389069,
-0.3263118863105774,
0.14473377168178558,
0.4440644085407257,
-0.4390524923801422,
-0.916232168674469,
0.3473338484764099,
-0.8855406045913696,
-0.7412582039833069,
1.065285325050354,
-0.21507440507411957,
-0.21861109137535095,
0.04142484441399574,
-0.37174275517463684,
-0.19199976325035095,
-0.08528456091880798,
0.6392754912376404,
1.0464614629745483,
-0.5130608677864075,
-0.4275013208389282,
-0.4812670052051544,
0.5772445201873779,
0.7998515963554382,
-0.8431140184402466,
0.2515316605567932,
0.2647882103919983,
0.659188449382782,
0.34842467308044434,
0.31802433729171753,
-0.24360105395317078,
0.3304736018180847,
-0.05870700255036354,
-0.3475548326969147,
-0.12467554211616516,
-0.4837908446788788,
-0.1710832417011261,
0.11877915263175964,
0.020803529769182205,
0.09003666043281555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11499v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11499v1
|
A Data-Driven Representation for Sign Language Production
| 2024-04-17T15:52:38 | 2024-04-17T15:52:38 |
Harry Walsh, Abolfazl Ravanshad, Mariam Rahmani, Richard Bowden
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Phonetic representations are used when recording spoken languages, but no
equivalent exists for recording signed languages. As a result, linguists have
proposed several annotation systems that operate on the gloss or sub-unit
level; however, these resources are notably irregular and scarce.
Sign Language Production (SLP) aims to automatically translate spoken
language sentences into continuous sequences of sign language. However, current
state-of-the-art approaches rely on scarce linguistic resources to work. This
has limited progress in the field. This paper introduces an innovative solution
by transforming the continuous pose generation problem into a discrete sequence
generation problem. Thus, overcoming the need for costly annotation. Although,
if available, we leverage the additional information to enhance our approach.
By applying Vector Quantisation (VQ) to sign language data, we first learn a
codebook of short motions that can be combined to create a natural sequence of
sign. Where each token in the codebook can be thought of as the lexicon of our
representation. Then using a transformer we perform a translation from spoken
language text to a sequence of codebook tokens. Each token can be directly
mapped to a sequence of poses allowing the translation to be performed by a
single network. Furthermore, we present a sign stitching method to effectively
join tokens together. We evaluate on the RWTH-PHOENIX-Weather-2014T
(PHOENIX14T) and the more challenging Meine DGS Annotated (mDGS) datasets. An
extensive evaluation shows our approach outperforms previous methods,
increasing the BLEU-1 back translation score by up to 72%.
|
[
-0.007138637825846672,
0.25268810987472534,
0.3524358868598938,
0.05823375657200813,
-0.6145827770233154,
0.1416253000497818,
0.08952087163925171,
-0.31315508484840393,
0.4012831151485443,
0.49884289503097534,
-0.5864631533622742,
-0.9098083972930908,
-0.5487060546875,
0.0869150161743164,
-0.41550734639167786,
0.7155654430389404,
0.0381794311106205,
-0.020957963541150093,
0.10708461701869965,
-0.3829997777938843,
-0.3888694643974304,
-0.6223796010017395,
-0.5593544244766235,
-0.22699128091335297,
0.14232803881168365,
0.21576495468616486,
0.9623795747756958,
0.867560088634491,
0.2496853768825531,
0.24895469844341278,
0.23132947087287903,
0.31658557057380676,
-0.21706977486610413,
0.22589045763015747,
0.26334160566329956,
-0.14168260991573334,
-0.37074771523475647,
-0.08814667910337448,
0.9021204113960266,
0.7746638655662537,
0.1350921094417572,
0.18139305710792542,
-0.3952201008796692,
0.5679692625999451,
-0.3196530044078827,
0.13574597239494324,
-0.3758002817630768,
0.2916980981826782,
-0.5032962560653687,
0.04456367343664169,
-0.45604923367500305,
-0.4039398431777954,
-0.2825813293457031,
-0.6759719848632812,
-0.020491452887654305,
0.059351444244384766,
0.7398656010627747,
0.3362123370170593,
-0.4087423086166382,
-0.0932462215423584,
-0.911676287651062,
0.5634818077087402,
-0.8834946155548096,
0.4133554697036743,
0.022206494584679604,
0.42021626234054565,
-0.2646404504776001,
-0.7585933804512024,
-0.7536334991455078,
0.02928251028060913,
-0.17578579485416412,
0.06758397817611694,
0.21465156972408295,
-0.051908183842897415,
0.5507534146308899,
0.4469332993030548,
-0.763534665107727,
0.03073815256357193,
-0.30144304037094116,
-0.2918313443660736,
1.0291786193847656,
0.17822985351085663,
0.4820026457309723,
-0.3596750795841217,
-0.4630031883716583,
-0.5250213146209717,
-0.7363712787628174,
-0.08719636499881744,
0.17006726562976837,
0.5863656401634216,
-0.10491648316383362,
0.7315530776977539,
-0.0728108212351799,
0.7311469912528992,
-0.0856466144323349,
-0.09152510017156601,
0.18784689903259277,
-0.08304914832115173,
-0.10421021282672882,
0.04361996427178383,
0.9903548955917358,
0.19728344678878784,
0.23086106777191162,
0.10361652076244354,
-0.3313295841217041,
0.10383658856153488,
-0.1516011506319046,
-0.5516150593757629,
-0.1913270801305771,
0.3062945008277893,
-0.01649230159819126,
-0.06180737540125847,
0.21038444340229034,
-0.4963901937007904,
-0.5578818321228027,
-0.531784176826477,
0.2882215082645416,
-0.4982143044471741,
-0.2994636297225952,
0.1265747994184494,
-0.05613452568650246,
0.453742116689682,
0.017307566478848457,
-0.7968215346336365,
0.11094244569540024,
0.6117782592773438,
0.8473125696182251,
-0.1621866524219513,
0.11957276612520218,
-0.5457939505577087,
0.24058157205581665,
-0.528569221496582,
0.2646508812904358,
-0.327372282743454,
-0.4328160583972931,
0.13287177681922913,
-0.3584508001804352,
-0.017035573720932007,
-0.4421335756778717,
0.2765996754169464,
-0.3266199231147766,
0.1662483960390091,
-0.03747893497347832,
-0.5622740983963013,
0.04228277504444122,
-0.1838504821062088,
-0.7168744206428528,
1.1829665899276733,
0.37196868658065796,
-0.2522881329059601,
0.5298078060150146,
-0.288851261138916,
-0.5185117721557617,
0.6034618616104126,
-0.6584057807922363,
-0.6202502250671387,
-0.03926008939743042,
0.08069663494825363,
0.4656810462474823,
0.055104635655879974,
-0.04629146680235863,
0.15026335418224335,
-0.2243223786354065,
0.3534311056137085,
0.16057884693145752,
0.5507631301879883,
0.1469796597957611,
-0.5135589241981506,
0.09946960210800171,
-1.0457749366760254,
0.1455506682395935,
0.10077957808971405,
-0.2417932003736496,
-0.3203771710395813,
-0.25212258100509644,
-0.07139871269464493,
0.4619963765144348,
0.04684893414378166,
-0.46815523505210876,
0.2717296779155731,
-0.380404531955719,
0.21997389197349548,
0.4965987205505371,
0.0653974786400795,
0.3826102316379547,
-0.10242825746536255,
0.6978240609169006,
0.09250563383102417,
0.12716305255889893,
-0.31748655438423157,
-0.5797529816627502,
-0.7639583945274353,
-0.23910841345787048,
0.26642853021621704,
0.3809451162815094,
-0.8694856762886047,
0.2843870222568512,
-0.41264697909355164,
-0.2804874777793884,
-0.5174140334129333,
-0.19354476034641266,
0.6629348397254944,
0.11035531014204025,
0.16625253856182098,
-0.6142253279685974,
-0.5889720916748047,
-0.45514506101608276,
0.07644353806972504,
-0.18564042448997498,
-0.2055654674768448,
-0.3115882873535156,
0.08359368145465851,
0.14883270859718323,
0.6261125206947327,
-0.4187606871128082,
-0.37231525778770447,
0.22686627507209778,
0.16970665752887726,
0.45292943716049194,
0.627338171005249,
0.43306922912597656,
-0.8600285649299622,
-0.408735066652298,
0.26762229204177856,
-0.5981948375701904,
-0.03679618239402771,
-0.6015294194221497,
-0.3406810164451599,
0.36764973402023315,
0.5780846476554871,
-0.6772661209106445,
0.3763327896595001,
0.643625795841217,
-0.4209577739238739,
0.4487621486186981,
0.22448091208934784,
0.04961283132433891,
-0.9146855473518372,
0.05890088900923729,
-0.057886794209480286,
-0.5619750618934631,
-0.5629093647003174,
0.09006208926439285,
-0.24209119379520416,
-0.7759621143341064,
-0.569030225276947,
0.3739790916442871,
-0.593424379825592,
-0.5075014233589172,
-0.10923191159963608,
0.37051892280578613,
-0.13436739146709442,
0.5460248589515686,
0.07055479288101196,
0.4770568013191223,
0.523986279964447,
-0.6653915643692017,
0.44636282324790955,
0.4216514229774475,
-0.026148337870836258,
0.4465154707431793,
-0.40534719824790955,
0.3418605625629425,
-0.04804679751396179,
0.0058280653320252895,
-0.8403773903846741,
-0.161055326461792,
0.6458664536476135,
-0.525961697101593,
0.5938244462013245,
-0.1907745599746704,
-0.32502639293670654,
-0.4640873968601227,
-0.027358336374163628,
0.30176982283592224,
0.80199134349823,
-0.4913337230682373,
0.5880797505378723,
0.35150524973869324,
0.028206223621964455,
-0.2559052109718323,
-0.5896322131156921,
0.1374102681875229,
-0.18064753711223602,
-0.6447774767875671,
0.3503500819206238,
0.16465461254119873,
-0.15173104405403137,
-0.2948746085166931,
-0.38170766830444336,
0.23989011347293854,
-0.4132983386516571,
0.28023868799209595,
0.04536396637558937,
-0.27697548270225525,
0.1785157322883606,
-0.17502173781394958,
-0.45362722873687744,
-0.16824761033058167,
-0.6043808460235596,
0.3992096185684204,
0.13143335282802582,
-0.5476315021514893,
-0.5295853018760681,
0.43997520208358765,
0.8010319471359253,
-0.18010598421096802,
0.4520494043827057,
0.4090191423892975,
-0.5427442193031311,
-0.4637944996356964,
0.1716846078634262,
0.052013322710990906,
-0.47522810101509094,
-0.11698958277702332,
-0.4481769800186157,
-0.6352348327636719,
0.3199528157711029,
-0.4210626780986786,
0.4356330335140228,
0.4716579020023346,
0.3244316279888153,
-0.014068915508687496,
0.9444149732589722,
0.33195239305496216,
0.24491040408611298,
0.4355746805667877,
-0.3195227086544037,
0.22364003956317902,
-0.4329186677932739,
-0.14703090488910675,
-0.24188008904457092,
-0.3111170828342438,
-0.40265536308288574,
-0.7472970485687256,
0.39581429958343506,
0.22353164851665497,
-0.1861594170331955,
0.8207894563674927,
-0.845485270023346,
-0.04516654834151268,
0.5711838006973267,
0.024949893355369568,
0.33862772583961487,
-0.0890720784664154,
0.03822267800569534,
-0.1742330938577652,
-0.5233616828918457,
-0.7842031717300415,
0.9202103018760681,
0.11122892051935196,
0.24980570375919342,
0.24911974370479584,
1.0140831470489502,
0.36504828929901123,
0.18532225489616394,
-0.6630679965019226,
0.7834652066230774,
-0.27022093534469604,
-0.08963850885629654,
-0.6286199688911438,
-0.2020484060049057,
-0.7760863304138184,
0.2868496775627136,
-0.3556150496006012,
-0.4015096127986908,
0.15739396214485168,
0.3310531675815582,
-0.2424023449420929,
-0.1255127489566803,
-0.5508527755737305,
0.7175905108451843,
-0.29026779532432556,
0.039921678602695465,
0.14433865249156952,
-0.6001099944114685,
0.41342055797576904,
-0.24722833931446075,
0.3441583812236786,
-0.19233717024326324,
0.18322880566120148,
0.6150844097137451,
-0.8455997705459595,
0.9453229308128357,
-0.22899308800697327,
-0.27297765016555786,
0.41147246956825256,
0.0895567312836647,
0.5918055176734924,
-0.15186262130737305,
-0.22469231486320496,
-0.06433003395795822,
0.08454862236976624,
-0.4316091537475586,
-0.6475324034690857,
0.31094247102737427,
-0.42065510153770447,
-0.36128461360931396,
-0.4975261390209198,
-0.21604761481285095,
-0.0281966719776392,
0.09656094759702682,
0.1645175963640213,
0.4291788637638092,
-0.1211228147149086,
-0.4478081464767456,
0.37938886880874634,
-0.07337204366922379,
0.4180290699005127,
0.17790232598781586,
-0.36297789216041565,
-0.5616152286529541,
0.8577157258987427,
0.029761087149381638,
0.36165356636047363,
0.26797357201576233,
0.2300630658864975,
-0.27356353402137756,
-0.5563883781433105,
-0.6123412251472473,
0.3258090913295746,
-0.8067072629928589,
-0.35852065682411194,
-0.017591344192624092,
-0.10115548968315125,
-0.596603512763977,
-0.09829304367303848,
-0.2541728913784027,
-0.8694663047790527,
0.034859225153923035,
-0.134319469332695,
0.6201464533805847,
0.6867082118988037,
-0.44512444734573364,
0.5011231303215027,
-0.7038134932518005,
0.5064078569412231,
0.3524888753890991,
0.057881757616996765,
-0.37336912751197815,
-0.12930209934711456,
-0.29210594296455383,
0.0029362922068685293,
-0.27531445026397705,
-0.8226352334022522,
0.30222848057746887,
0.49362313747406006,
0.23449362814426422,
0.30838578939437866,
0.4545787274837494,
0.6065478920936584,
-0.3821278214454651,
0.8430119752883911,
0.5311613082885742,
-1.0783700942993164,
0.6055542826652527,
-0.4684787690639496,
0.2167646735906601,
0.11345158517360687,
0.33007320761680603,
-0.9142117500305176,
-0.529800534248352,
-0.6753702759742737,
-1.0754659175872803,
0.49041247367858887,
0.46525338292121887,
-0.024009859189391136,
-0.17999444901943207,
0.41132956743240356,
0.024986762553453445,
0.02787543274462223,
-0.6921030879020691,
-0.20631727576255798,
-0.34518441557884216,
-0.40095385909080505,
0.11647673696279526,
0.18464317917823792,
-0.10795295238494873,
-0.09572583436965942,
0.8486197590827942,
-0.20591580867767334,
0.07689535617828369,
0.12470747530460358,
0.042043864727020264,
-0.2063809335231781,
-0.15132464468479156,
0.6314563155174255,
0.5131458640098572,
0.34344011545181274,
0.11971025168895721,
-0.2352716028690338,
-0.4323517084121704,
0.17349755764007568,
-0.0020202817395329475,
-0.3623093366622925,
0.5733305215835571,
0.3307052552700043,
0.9846729636192322,
0.023027298972010612,
-0.47718697786331177,
0.4914006292819977,
0.3684968054294586,
-0.02049212157726288,
-0.6445208191871643,
-0.11560606956481934,
-0.07548654079437256,
0.23580680787563324,
0.3520316183567047,
-0.24782073497772217,
-0.26966843008995056,
-0.29842787981033325,
0.5784949660301208,
0.12592993676662445,
-0.2028258591890335,
-0.35928070545196533,
0.8349209427833557,
0.2069171667098999,
-0.6308773756027222,
0.5547963380813599,
-0.2746126353740692,
-0.4143913984298706,
0.5551791787147522,
0.42400434613227844,
0.7174046635627747,
-0.3963508605957031,
0.46200400590896606,
0.6584587693214417,
0.06269465386867523,
-0.0027812968473881483,
0.5213324427604675,
-0.03811177238821983,
-0.46985772252082825,
-0.6021572947502136,
-0.6843379139900208,
-0.5261147022247314,
-0.09321380406618118,
-0.5147961378097534,
0.5417659878730774,
-0.5598180294036865,
-0.211848184466362,
-0.16921573877334595,
-0.23554076254367828,
-0.6454453468322754,
0.45417866110801697,
0.6920427083969116,
0.3753219246864319,
-1.0517500638961792,
0.6580586433410645,
0.5286697149276733,
-0.6822769641876221,
-0.8020586967468262,
-0.055440086871385574,
0.0012453467352315784,
-0.939138650894165,
0.5571584105491638,
0.02840552106499672,
-0.011871572583913803,
0.3015367090702057,
-0.2858597934246063,
-0.9129204750061035,
0.9720108509063721,
0.38341405987739563,
-0.7551817893981934,
0.2718633711338043,
0.6956390142440796,
0.5472601056098938,
-0.2684948146343231,
-0.5077228546142578,
0.609440803527832,
0.4230524003505707,
0.41757652163505554,
-0.5949324369430542,
0.39705175161361694,
-0.006831247825175524,
0.2730671167373657,
0.5602558255195618,
-0.30256879329681396,
0.2429322749376297,
-0.043105415999889374,
-0.8900437951087952,
0.15804342925548553,
0.9481343626976013,
0.6597264409065247,
0.24473464488983154,
0.27704155445098877,
0.6042918562889099,
0.8768037557601929,
-0.24668124318122864,
0.7852139472961426,
-0.2567467987537384,
0.1842765063047409,
0.8400763869285583,
-0.12297708541154861,
0.7068011164665222,
0.4993167817592621,
-0.42755964398384094,
0.4606415927410126,
0.5025883913040161,
0.11744628846645355,
0.286722332239151,
0.9126617312431335,
-0.5375842452049255,
-0.20522458851337433,
0.022785799577832222,
-0.06361587345600128,
0.3007194995880127,
0.41482076048851013,
-0.27215129137039185,
0.004324277397245169,
0.2713625729084015,
-0.018349282443523407,
0.5740224719047546,
-0.19665032625198364,
0.6056302189826965,
0.4573965072631836,
-0.37380728125572205,
0.7657357454299927,
-0.2242455780506134,
0.4034367501735687,
-0.6163742542266846,
-0.19429484009742737,
-0.17771919071674347,
-0.06448092311620712,
-0.2394201159477234,
-0.6890549063682556,
0.583938717842102,
-0.3523782789707184,
0.14040105044841766,
-0.6693044304847717,
0.36519405245780945,
-0.51161789894104,
-0.4755387604236603,
-0.11970566213130951,
0.04491304233670235,
0.5464553833007812,
0.29907485842704773,
-0.30843114852905273,
0.3163470923900604,
-0.09399856626987457,
0.013796960934996605,
-0.0040366374887526035,
0.7052963376045227,
-0.31196239590644836,
0.2782362401485443,
0.5354873538017273,
0.10416341572999954,
0.5001968145370483,
0.2975829839706421,
0.5408570170402527,
-0.7487429976463318,
-0.4198266863822937,
-0.35286059975624084,
0.9117166996002197,
-0.14016717672348022,
-0.5181483030319214,
0.5156871676445007,
0.3736676275730133,
0.7848766446113586,
-0.13751742243766785,
0.8370020985603333,
-0.18554478883743286,
0.26424261927604675,
-0.6900246143341064,
0.5143342018127441,
-0.0031302152201533318,
-0.016043763607740402,
-0.3877917230129242,
-0.8335975408554077,
-0.7110405564308167,
0.4073089361190796,
0.10772610455751419,
-0.3408896028995514,
0.5877423286437988,
0.4447430968284607,
0.2446783035993576,
-0.3581722378730774,
0.5440957546234131,
-0.2952779233455658,
0.3839588761329651,
0.6878259778022766,
0.4240554869174957,
-0.9590750336647034,
0.6446185111999512,
-0.15658782422542572,
-0.15084189176559448,
0.21538807451725006,
-0.9697232246398926,
-0.584461510181427,
-1.046866774559021,
-0.9454252123832703,
-0.3767143487930298,
-0.16914622485637665,
0.6610352993011475,
0.6932886838912964,
-0.8468908667564392,
-0.1521221548318863,
-0.17964445054531097,
-0.08317394554615021,
-0.525658369064331,
-0.19147957861423492,
0.5783557295799255,
-0.18516115844249725,
-0.813641369342804,
0.47139009833335876,
0.1843998283147812,
0.3765696585178375,
-0.2744266986846924,
-0.277396559715271,
0.17916877567768097,
-0.08396347612142563,
0.6241938471794128,
0.7998985648155212,
-0.4792022109031677,
-0.48379841446876526,
-0.367487370967865,
-0.061978232115507126,
0.06763351708650589,
0.8465477228164673,
-0.7793099284172058,
0.3271026611328125,
0.4210611581802368,
0.5074692964553833,
0.735434353351593,
0.03061974234879017,
0.9406299591064453,
-1.2697924375534058,
0.16915225982666016,
0.41619616746902466,
0.15772321820259094,
0.633083164691925,
-0.48807865381240845,
0.4783153235912323,
0.37225624918937683,
-0.177700474858284,
-0.5446621775627136,
0.7631115913391113,
-1.075485110282898,
0.0008336210739798844,
1.019983172416687,
-0.021910781040787697,
-0.23145094513893127,
-0.12401292473077774,
-0.09559140354394913,
0.5633601546287537,
-0.09561598300933838,
0.4564649760723114,
0.20147646963596344,
-0.13598549365997314,
-0.3337216377258301,
-0.11070520430803299,
0.6395837068557739,
0.07586073130369186,
-0.4714125096797943,
0.1242043599486351,
0.6361719965934753,
-0.20749008655548096,
0.4395841062068939,
0.871576189994812,
-0.3587327003479004,
0.1538473665714264,
0.04883648082613945,
0.5294326543807983,
0.05641196668148041,
0.0072012958116829395,
-0.3493266999721527,
-0.01101730391383171,
0.1965593546628952,
-0.7583720684051514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11470v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11470v1
|
A Federated Learning Approach to Privacy Preserving Offensive Language Identification
| 2024-04-17T15:23:12 | 2024-04-17T15:23:12 |
Marcos Zampieri, Damith Premasiri, Tharindu Ranasinghe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The spread of various forms of offensive speech online is an important
concern in social media. While platforms have been investing heavily in ways of
coping with this problem, the question of privacy remains largely unaddressed.
Models trained to detect offensive language on social media are trained and/or
fine-tuned using large amounts of data often stored in centralized servers.
Since most social media data originates from end users, we propose a privacy
preserving decentralized architecture for identifying offensive language online
by introducing Federated Learning (FL) in the context of offensive language
identification. FL is a decentralized architecture that allows multiple models
to be trained locally without the need for data sharing hence preserving users'
privacy. We propose a model fusion approach to perform FL. We trained multiple
deep learning models on four publicly available English benchmark datasets
(AHSD, HASOC, HateXplain, OLID) and evaluated their performance in detail. We
also present initial cross-lingual experiments in English and Spanish. We show
that the proposed model fusion approach outperforms baselines in all the
datasets while preserving privacy.
|
[
-0.1529121696949005,
-0.9460912346839905,
-0.016619006171822548,
0.1548113226890564,
-0.009539466351270676,
0.31820544600486755,
-0.3910473883152008,
-0.7205660343170166,
0.09400627762079239,
0.4987756907939911,
-0.3267531991004944,
-0.6278972029685974,
-0.49866387248039246,
0.059680256992578506,
-0.538155734539032,
1.0811907052993774,
0.19083108007907867,
0.0724145919084549,
0.0394502654671669,
-0.42290839552879333,
-0.01061349455267191,
-0.45253434777259827,
-0.5721622705459595,
-0.18826404213905334,
0.40266352891921997,
0.20444199442863464,
0.7004506587982178,
0.85024094581604,
0.5373454093933105,
0.45922502875328064,
0.1834668517112732,
0.3014078140258789,
-0.8248145580291748,
0.1892787516117096,
-0.5090852379798889,
-0.2827346920967102,
-0.18831130862236023,
-0.024844834581017494,
0.6304628849029541,
0.3459756076335907,
-0.13206659257411957,
-0.10956156998872757,
-0.35445982217788696,
0.36393558979034424,
-0.9820014834403992,
0.13281236588954926,
-0.5393078923225403,
0.20938640832901,
-0.1949922889471054,
0.30095142126083374,
-0.5739356875419617,
-0.4751485586166382,
0.139567032456398,
-0.3133866786956787,
0.2935052216053009,
-0.06561948359012604,
0.7555878758430481,
-0.11217986047267914,
-0.07979511469602585,
0.018752984702587128,
-0.8394696116447449,
0.6772986054420471,
-0.5916048288345337,
0.6934535503387451,
0.560494065284729,
0.4594850540161133,
0.20520558953285217,
-0.6142022609710693,
-0.5286805629730225,
0.14258043467998505,
-0.27458474040031433,
-0.10672657936811447,
-0.5370957851409912,
0.0199604295194149,
-0.247361421585083,
0.49527138471603394,
-0.5763774514198303,
0.526818573474884,
-0.29935750365257263,
-0.42773178219795227,
1.1393206119537354,
-0.07122837752103806,
0.29233500361442566,
0.015259472653269768,
-0.6994657516479492,
-0.11918392777442932,
-0.3791067600250244,
-0.06694700568914413,
0.530620813369751,
0.8418751955032349,
-0.31589749455451965,
0.17733904719352722,
-0.35891804099082947,
0.33612650632858276,
0.2703362703323364,
-0.2529388964176178,
0.4127744734287262,
0.02216757833957672,
-0.3708217144012451,
0.07954271137714386,
1.1172398328781128,
0.14494134485721588,
0.17699705064296722,
-0.5238362550735474,
-0.49467405676841736,
0.17288345098495483,
0.13355572521686554,
-0.5597290396690369,
-0.20356112718582153,
0.20437505841255188,
-0.2928376793861389,
-0.42959532141685486,
0.10423443466424942,
-0.8493536114692688,
-0.7496376633644104,
-0.10689233988523483,
0.33561474084854126,
-0.4696662127971649,
-0.6292983889579773,
-0.21554787456989288,
0.009708104655146599,
0.1287585347890854,
-0.06882690638303757,
-1.1609618663787842,
0.5169969797134399,
1.1255062818527222,
0.6186760663986206,
-0.11756285279989243,
-0.34324902296066284,
-0.48622843623161316,
-0.14769330620765686,
-0.24126024544239044,
0.2352159321308136,
-0.6157698035240173,
0.03718485310673714,
0.4466763436794281,
0.1222073957324028,
-0.00525911059230566,
-0.3258169889450073,
0.16729341447353363,
-0.8799055218696594,
0.4276454746723175,
-0.047986481338739395,
-0.678962767124176,
-0.37438908219337463,
0.3343880772590637,
-0.6178700923919678,
0.5194839835166931,
0.16157469153404236,
-0.9451930522918701,
0.042128536850214005,
-0.4066610038280487,
-0.5906437039375305,
0.34186723828315735,
-0.11394471675157547,
-0.7542812824249268,
0.012395044788718224,
0.20836210250854492,
0.6362239122390747,
0.015061593614518642,
0.29003262519836426,
-0.41174113750457764,
-0.17715239524841309,
0.00485239177942276,
-0.30142003297805786,
1.197230577468872,
0.5415483713150024,
-0.5043018460273743,
0.1737917810678482,
-0.6510688066482544,
-0.2796817421913147,
0.34426507353782654,
0.02613256126642227,
-0.6251401901245117,
-0.12845568358898163,
-0.15981630980968475,
-0.06531772762537003,
0.29462170600891113,
-0.8839447498321533,
-0.5304630398750305,
-0.6369170546531677,
0.20979566872119904,
0.7880237698554993,
-0.14033237099647522,
0.6345558166503906,
-0.3006695806980133,
0.43415766954421997,
0.12337781488895416,
0.26414045691490173,
0.05816587060689926,
-0.2926074266433716,
-0.5816985964775085,
-0.17500293254852295,
0.0411192886531353,
0.5170983672142029,
-0.6947036385536194,
0.3840198218822479,
-0.33201542496681213,
-0.6438031196594238,
-0.6020730137825012,
0.13156355917453766,
0.6996943950653076,
0.33864182233810425,
0.09542441368103027,
-0.038753047585487366,
-0.48601242899894714,
-0.8705736994743347,
-0.15667451918125153,
-0.13221383094787598,
0.12380514293909073,
0.4135826528072357,
0.14868031442165375,
-0.27410611510276794,
0.85640949010849,
-0.04878437891602516,
-0.44841769337654114,
-0.10534210503101349,
0.12047579139471054,
-0.45983967185020447,
0.4070155918598175,
0.6442739963531494,
-1.0192160606384277,
-0.6567013263702393,
0.38541150093078613,
-0.6831902861595154,
-0.08364444226026535,
0.33083847165107727,
0.04568611830472946,
0.3255624771118164,
0.11332745105028152,
-0.01276120450347662,
0.00248489691875875,
0.8990305066108704,
-0.2918551564216614,
-0.050934091210365295,
0.055987920612096786,
0.23729278147220612,
-1.2246278524398804,
-0.24486248195171356,
0.04923578351736069,
-0.37572604417800903,
-1.028053879737854,
0.5519329905509949,
0.05417804792523384,
-0.3084893822669983,
-0.6993229389190674,
0.48205864429473877,
-0.28576594591140747,
0.09828829765319824,
-0.24640953540802002,
0.04036976397037506,
-0.20928005874156952,
0.42635899782180786,
0.21764442324638367,
0.5202990174293518,
0.6683630347251892,
-0.20532214641571045,
0.4588943123817444,
0.13591328263282776,
-0.07832852005958557,
0.5065054297447205,
-0.07002855837345123,
0.39719897508621216,
-0.3082652688026428,
-0.0758364200592041,
-0.8876698613166809,
-0.4720255136489868,
0.44109031558036804,
-0.4104834496974945,
0.1709161102771759,
0.040958210825920105,
-0.27024829387664795,
-0.1484462171792984,
-0.22222870588302612,
0.27062949538230896,
0.326760470867157,
-0.8888763785362244,
0.7748492956161499,
0.9800496697425842,
0.13054917752742767,
-0.909199595451355,
-0.6723517179489136,
-0.3424844443798065,
-0.26978811621665955,
-0.6662265062332153,
0.23689641058444977,
0.3034202456474304,
-0.42936113476753235,
-0.10363224893808365,
0.24480167031288147,
-0.5950570702552795,
0.2635485529899597,
0.38877546787261963,
0.05047666281461716,
-0.3242337107658386,
0.21763363480567932,
-0.05061044171452522,
0.3043666183948517,
0.05059187114238739,
0.12556356191635132,
0.5446978211402893,
-0.2790032923221588,
-0.02553948387503624,
-0.7064131498336792,
0.6004748940467834,
0.5384395718574524,
-0.4698188602924347,
0.8502641916275024,
0.8254791498184204,
-0.6661211848258972,
-0.46968650817871094,
-0.6623411178588867,
-0.21446672081947327,
-0.5288963317871094,
0.05467340350151062,
0.07567645609378815,
-1.1155387163162231,
0.6653742790222168,
0.19734767079353333,
0.34710147976875305,
0.18692855536937714,
0.48610591888427734,
0.1877530962228775,
0.795165479183197,
1.0113403797149658,
-0.39111244678497314,
0.6582626700401306,
0.0028389343060553074,
0.3932030200958252,
0.01779796928167343,
-0.16392241418361664,
-0.30576881766319275,
-0.23482871055603027,
-0.8010748028755188,
-0.17792899906635284,
-0.13645952939987183,
-0.36887338757514954,
-0.20992526412010193,
0.48656317591667175,
-0.4031694233417511,
0.7755590081214905,
0.2946716547012329,
0.34811046719551086,
0.08403411507606506,
0.10226554423570633,
0.22060993313789368,
0.12757965922355652,
-0.5744436979293823,
-0.03633880242705345,
0.8604045510292053,
0.6913989186286926,
0.5947588086128235,
0.4110684096813202,
1.0633044242858887,
0.38017016649246216,
0.4528926908969879,
-0.5508101582527161,
0.42524540424346924,
-0.42337021231651306,
-0.7727845907211304,
-0.4007156789302826,
-0.6146107316017151,
-0.8100709319114685,
0.25419455766677856,
-0.41322484612464905,
-0.7118746042251587,
0.39807432889938354,
0.14943966269493103,
-0.49977344274520874,
0.49376392364501953,
-0.6686872243881226,
0.6529369950294495,
-0.1425645798444748,
-0.6279507875442505,
-0.0759740024805069,
-0.7024691700935364,
0.7004232406616211,
-0.2315802127122879,
0.5490782856941223,
-0.07275575399398804,
0.2575797438621521,
0.8610127568244934,
-0.3180951476097107,
1.035700798034668,
-0.27149060368537903,
-0.03141067549586296,
-0.001356738735921681,
-0.15067864954471588,
0.46189093589782715,
-0.23238509893417358,
-0.10002753138542175,
0.40793395042419434,
-0.45539891719818115,
-0.15536600351333618,
-0.26706045866012573,
0.8993186354637146,
-0.780481219291687,
-0.37132254242897034,
-0.12484744191169739,
-0.528096616268158,
-0.12156704813241959,
0.34061798453330994,
0.20795941352844238,
0.2252272218465805,
-0.2730324864387512,
0.2765601873397827,
0.6724163293838501,
-0.0018671955913305283,
0.5732593536376953,
0.7580015659332275,
-0.16821403801441193,
-0.40605247020721436,
1.0335783958435059,
-0.017195018008351326,
0.15548352897167206,
0.37053894996643066,
0.5336350202560425,
-0.4688050150871277,
-0.3629979193210602,
-0.08225735276937485,
0.2638550102710724,
-0.7569718956947327,
-0.3124164938926697,
-0.7258317470550537,
-0.3586350977420807,
-0.6380558609962463,
-0.28174713253974915,
-0.5729949474334717,
0.02394651621580124,
-0.20088529586791992,
-0.09249673038721085,
0.4175604581832886,
0.672426700592041,
-0.3162144720554352,
0.472307950258255,
-0.6003113985061646,
0.20718958973884583,
0.32074981927871704,
0.5782425403594971,
0.027936182916164398,
-0.31812164187431335,
0.027226785197854042,
0.23991958796977997,
0.12028012424707413,
-0.8315485715866089,
0.4667246639728546,
0.35489869117736816,
0.4275408685207367,
0.880979597568512,
0.5486456751823425,
0.45398449897766113,
-0.44882649183273315,
0.4998040199279785,
0.2405729591846466,
-0.7181161046028137,
0.38973045349121094,
-0.23063655197620392,
-0.12162870913743973,
0.5362381935119629,
0.7701788544654846,
-0.28003373742103577,
-0.6953185200691223,
-0.6991918683052063,
-0.6493557691574097,
0.6392860412597656,
0.0021805204451084137,
0.48631682991981506,
-0.17606888711452484,
-0.1582421213388443,
0.18171674013137817,
0.022704241797327995,
-0.9078392386436462,
-0.3536270558834076,
-0.17572595179080963,
-0.1237863227725029,
0.05658729374408722,
-0.017751352861523628,
-0.4845449924468994,
-0.20156042277812958,
0.5114132761955261,
0.21309782564640045,
0.0008689393289387226,
-0.31835734844207764,
-0.14836740493774414,
-0.2068718671798706,
0.19426558911800385,
0.32720115780830383,
0.3962136507034302,
-0.025942232459783554,
0.03730105981230736,
-0.08437056839466095,
-0.3039616346359253,
0.0644599050283432,
0.24585293233394623,
-0.2230740785598755,
0.09975829720497131,
0.15519535541534424,
0.8095215559005737,
0.37040334939956665,
-0.43057626485824585,
0.9682587385177612,
-0.05982993543148041,
-0.259685218334198,
-0.21226391196250916,
0.15610849857330322,
-0.14692574739456177,
0.38659122586250305,
0.11213840544223785,
-0.09914206713438034,
0.06698784977197647,
-0.44257232546806335,
0.49548667669296265,
0.47644561529159546,
-0.2986423671245575,
-0.27593737840652466,
0.6259491443634033,
0.3613273501396179,
-0.7529985904693604,
0.4620751142501831,
-0.0649087131023407,
-0.7054980397224426,
0.11038713157176971,
0.6000393629074097,
0.8905743956565857,
-0.7725972533226013,
0.5240768790245056,
0.32399916648864746,
0.14175137877464294,
0.024751264601945877,
0.08727873861789703,
-0.33212167024612427,
-1.014262080192566,
0.1400212198495865,
-0.6629685163497925,
-0.29991480708122253,
0.20797227323055267,
-0.6818145513534546,
-0.003118303371593356,
-1.010260820388794,
-0.041959796100854874,
0.2151300609111786,
-0.12440802156925201,
-0.49294063448905945,
0.14885638654232025,
0.6671172976493835,
0.474435031414032,
-1.5207364559173584,
0.8117278218269348,
0.18262015283107758,
-0.30140531063079834,
-0.8381522297859192,
-0.31945744156837463,
0.30776500701904297,
-0.8367569446563721,
0.24824258685112,
0.16700387001037598,
-0.14807404577732086,
0.07582873106002808,
-0.5657268166542053,
-0.6026933789253235,
0.7902704477310181,
0.23087447881698608,
-0.5528663396835327,
0.3357078731060028,
0.31706172227859497,
0.7962377071380615,
-0.46642014384269714,
-0.3391222059726715,
0.54525226354599,
0.06541940569877625,
-0.011429516598582268,
-0.7689374685287476,
-0.14032144844532013,
-0.012397561222314835,
-0.24276478588581085,
0.209051251411438,
-0.6043909192085266,
0.9699732065200806,
-0.029073497280478477,
-0.8075438141822815,
-0.37263232469558716,
0.7504234910011292,
-0.12063127011060715,
0.3363550901412964,
0.46330276131629944,
0.5086612701416016,
1.0517407655715942,
-0.05191290006041527,
0.8120790123939514,
-0.08610417693853378,
0.5604472756385803,
1.1202794313430786,
-0.27615997195243835,
1.0649442672729492,
0.03546936810016632,
0.05071701109409332,
0.24749760329723358,
0.3072117865085602,
-0.12444837391376495,
0.7019980549812317,
-0.06654193997383118,
-0.4348408579826355,
-0.039324864745140076,
-0.29704806208610535,
-0.2496088594198227,
0.8487436771392822,
0.24407048523426056,
-0.8404123783111572,
-0.43584027886390686,
0.360923171043396,
0.18504346907138824,
0.5936633348464966,
-0.35876327753067017,
1.0656075477600098,
-0.3082316219806671,
-0.44549670815467834,
0.6369515061378479,
0.12579087913036346,
0.7521453499794006,
-0.5060094594955444,
0.25710129737854004,
-0.3493053913116455,
0.26862871646881104,
-0.33109498023986816,
-0.45797309279441833,
0.44311386346817017,
0.02171924337744713,
-0.05873150750994682,
-0.15537098050117493,
0.5680551528930664,
-0.8375695943832397,
-0.4100818336009979,
0.4466601014137268,
0.18910954892635345,
-0.0028676821384578943,
0.3402203619480133,
-0.63923579454422,
0.18078716099262238,
-0.1335282176733017,
0.28066879510879517,
0.4046548902988434,
0.2025877982378006,
-0.02448367327451706,
0.4820447266101837,
0.6506330370903015,
-0.11055922508239746,
0.1266973912715912,
0.08056680858135223,
0.7754860520362854,
-0.04639852046966553,
-0.7485786080360413,
-0.8970929980278015,
0.26442888379096985,
-0.3007550835609436,
-0.1941877007484436,
0.7978600263595581,
0.310858815908432,
1.1512806415557861,
0.09344637393951416,
0.5775305032730103,
-0.026954403147101402,
0.6040206551551819,
-0.18865880370140076,
1.1746550798416138,
-0.32647421956062317,
0.023583395406603813,
-0.35612383484840393,
-0.5181311964988708,
-0.4943087100982666,
0.5874705910682678,
-0.30552810430526733,
-0.38749662041664124,
0.30118006467819214,
1.0054821968078613,
-0.19231130182743073,
0.3544667065143585,
0.5121157169342041,
0.06354646384716034,
0.2845509648323059,
0.28958210349082947,
0.37842223048210144,
-0.47633227705955505,
0.03145122155547142,
-0.9761120676994324,
-0.23788544535636902,
-0.22208701074123383,
-0.6152416467666626,
-0.9718722701072693,
-0.6166216731071472,
-0.3715953528881073,
-0.1655319482088089,
0.2431212067604065,
0.8071585297584534,
0.7640853524208069,
-1.1408501863479614,
-0.16976729035377502,
0.12033756077289581,
0.05360507592558861,
-0.23636211454868317,
-0.2410593330860138,
0.24516621232032776,
-0.04626932367682457,
-0.7807130813598633,
0.47772446274757385,
0.0944509357213974,
0.027711372822523117,
-0.43224748969078064,
-0.055003680288791656,
-0.49283677339553833,
0.07707449048757553,
0.41159123182296753,
0.6000593304634094,
-0.8300245404243469,
-0.4855106770992279,
-0.20158228278160095,
-0.23667754232883453,
-0.0829642191529274,
0.3933979570865631,
-0.5190126895904541,
0.819146454334259,
0.6155694127082825,
1.1639058589935303,
-0.040034592151641846,
0.3387431800365448,
0.5895388722419739,
-1.066616415977478,
0.3797844350337982,
0.46627017855644226,
0.3569319248199463,
0.5729420185089111,
-0.5656179785728455,
0.2841896116733551,
0.10944491624832153,
-0.4327654540538788,
-0.9549771547317505,
0.0032920914236456156,
-0.5800884962081909,
-0.2203073501586914,
0.9864682555198669,
-0.5954785943031311,
-0.3400578498840332,
-0.22012066841125488,
0.46224749088287354,
0.22108004987239838,
-0.3201102614402771,
0.8221818804740906,
0.3838344216346741,
0.4131670892238617,
-0.35005655884742737,
0.10541859269142151,
0.6123892664909363,
-0.020445208996534348,
-0.5511816740036011,
0.37589097023010254,
0.5433619618415833,
0.22771137952804565,
0.3087245225906372,
0.4897649884223938,
0.04998202621936798,
0.37655287981033325,
0.07740911841392517,
-0.25828325748443604,
-0.1151496022939682,
-0.5065823197364807,
-0.6222301125526428,
0.5904521346092224,
-0.6218773126602173,
-0.5626530647277832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11459v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11459v2
|
Octopus v3: Technical Report for On-device Sub-billion Multimodal AI Agent
| 2024-04-17T15:07:06 | 2024-04-18T07:32:52 |
Wei Chen, Zhiyuan Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
A multimodal AI agent is characterized by its ability to process and learn
from various types of data, including natural language, visual, and audio
inputs, to inform its actions. Despite advancements in large language models
that incorporate visual data, such as GPT-4V, effectively translating
image-based data into actionable outcomes for AI agents continues to be
challenging. In this paper, we introduce a multimodal model that incorporates
the concept of functional token specifically designed for AI agent
applications. To ensure compatibility with edge devices, our model is optimized
to a compact size of less than 1B parameters. Like GPT-4, our model can process
both English and Chinese. We demonstrate that this model is capable of
operating efficiently on a wide range of edge devices, including as constrained
as a Raspberry Pi.
|
[
-0.3303021490573883,
-0.7649581432342529,
0.5104465484619141,
-0.006606948561966419,
-0.2634916305541992,
-0.22950564324855804,
0.11452581733465195,
-0.7533560395240784,
0.47726354002952576,
0.3252709209918976,
-0.265056312084198,
-0.30880558490753174,
-0.32627782225608826,
0.14863164722919464,
0.0054902685806155205,
0.7958081364631653,
0.19052255153656006,
-0.29010558128356934,
-0.03355278819799423,
-0.32950359582901,
-0.39948034286499023,
-0.2564769983291626,
-0.7211137413978577,
-0.14753615856170654,
0.6277867555618286,
0.6812618374824524,
1.0553627014160156,
0.7497309446334839,
0.6486149430274963,
0.4435797929763794,
0.45851361751556396,
0.0699605792760849,
0.0031110343988984823,
-0.14022140204906464,
-0.11636646836996078,
-0.5040392875671387,
-1.0168143510818481,
0.04417690634727478,
0.46848243474960327,
0.14768388867378235,
0.06273943185806274,
-0.06605859100818634,
-0.4935649037361145,
0.1781359165906906,
-0.194003626704216,
0.5437893867492676,
-0.7070614099502563,
0.05361642688512802,
-0.20361372828483582,
0.11296819150447845,
-0.4341675937175751,
0.1416899561882019,
0.04123023897409439,
-1.124772310256958,
-0.27696219086647034,
-0.10860871523618698,
0.6826868653297424,
0.41419491171836853,
-0.7756320834159851,
-0.04201478138566017,
-0.5928272008895874,
0.6152427196502686,
-0.6248239278793335,
0.6217439770698547,
0.32743123173713684,
0.2991637587547302,
0.1721375733613968,
-1.2114803791046143,
-1.054630160331726,
-0.4326651692390442,
0.15700475871562958,
-0.012870877981185913,
-0.22181673347949982,
0.2914979159832001,
0.18343937397003174,
-0.07167573273181915,
-0.4567926824092865,
0.15505021810531616,
-0.512177050113678,
-0.3699832558631897,
0.6434111595153809,
0.12470218539237976,
0.5788938403129578,
-0.1089881956577301,
-0.5465140342712402,
0.12089081108570099,
-0.7124361395835876,
0.10952308773994446,
0.2144819051027298,
0.16751867532730103,
-0.35141271352767944,
0.7681828141212463,
-0.21777206659317017,
0.48569533228874207,
-0.1380096822977066,
-0.5780267715454102,
0.5578032732009888,
-0.6013754606246948,
0.14175477623939514,
-0.1389741152524948,
0.6981759667396545,
0.6546592116355896,
-0.029314707964658737,
-0.032915838062763214,
-0.4748012125492096,
-0.11145812273025513,
0.3233058750629425,
-0.7780823111534119,
-0.2038215696811676,
0.34072813391685486,
-0.4876202344894409,
0.11096267402172089,
-0.1700104922056198,
-0.47758951783180237,
-0.4062071740627289,
-0.08219987154006958,
0.566746175289154,
-0.6469646096229553,
-0.4846828281879425,
-0.09303954243659973,
-0.28446680307388306,
0.29236316680908203,
0.36904582381248474,
-0.8552011251449585,
0.0653776153922081,
0.47680220007896423,
1.0290826559066772,
-0.2036278247833252,
-0.33904939889907837,
-0.41752374172210693,
0.3673741817474365,
-0.0411657951772213,
0.6666163206100464,
-0.7104618549346924,
-0.34102270007133484,
-0.2701563239097595,
-0.006970463786274195,
-0.32324498891830444,
-0.10656504333019257,
0.40704554319381714,
-0.4814458191394806,
-0.11674541234970093,
0.24328358471393585,
-0.2452961951494217,
-0.6453132629394531,
0.4049068093299866,
-1.056257963180542,
0.5010567307472229,
0.10233862698078156,
-0.5572898387908936,
0.45659542083740234,
-1.368791103363037,
-0.5755043029785156,
0.6115735173225403,
-0.10124185681343079,
-0.4215117394924164,
-0.14456559717655182,
0.10673913359642029,
0.4848458170890808,
-0.07084179669618607,
-0.25454214215278625,
-0.4851348102092743,
-0.3475388288497925,
0.2081373631954193,
-0.3976891338825226,
0.16760848462581635,
0.5263886451721191,
-0.3496650457382202,
0.3603345453739166,
-0.6634480357170105,
-0.1844736486673355,
-0.020558791235089302,
-0.21881414949893951,
-0.27767205238342285,
0.14879149198532104,
0.11687131226062775,
0.004728384781628847,
0.4457535147666931,
-0.9883100390434265,
0.5802304744720459,
0.09488868713378906,
0.9574175477027893,
0.5483794808387756,
-0.2374725192785263,
0.3777974843978882,
-0.15344460308551788,
0.495699942111969,
0.030083199962973595,
0.3413940370082855,
-0.6731851100921631,
-0.8257237672805786,
-0.49732327461242676,
-0.889029324054718,
0.0931190699338913,
0.5979833006858826,
-1.4734776020050049,
-0.15712977945804596,
-0.3669069707393646,
-0.6789673566818237,
-0.45166200399398804,
-0.06316011399030685,
-0.07941325753927231,
0.2515161335468292,
0.24646344780921936,
-0.2615076005458832,
-0.05018167197704315,
-0.9945990443229675,
0.08755972236394882,
-0.32879897952079773,
0.1745872050523758,
0.49711138010025024,
0.5541443228721619,
-0.8372805118560791,
0.9498486518859863,
-0.11298706382513046,
-0.3826584815979004,
-0.6338576674461365,
0.22524745762348175,
0.1500975340604782,
0.562109112739563,
0.5824853181838989,
-1.1705526113510132,
-0.26385170221328735,
0.6282708048820496,
-0.568592369556427,
0.25245869159698486,
-0.16867826879024506,
0.4352022111415863,
0.28636184334754944,
0.3719629943370819,
-1.0957084894180298,
0.3012875020503998,
0.5193249583244324,
-0.26808884739875793,
0.1696685254573822,
-0.27761903405189514,
0.0698988288640976,
-1.0455602407455444,
-0.05338449776172638,
0.13314706087112427,
-0.24773336946964264,
-0.6324495673179626,
0.0893821194767952,
0.16839851438999176,
-0.34101977944374084,
-0.8562523722648621,
0.6177747845649719,
-0.08561442047357559,
-0.09975025057792664,
-0.14691542088985443,
-0.09884747862815857,
-0.26066920161247253,
0.4962344467639923,
0.31993165612220764,
0.8660088777542114,
0.5188616514205933,
-0.5877038836479187,
0.5999152660369873,
-0.12787383794784546,
0.1571202576160431,
0.7038885354995728,
-0.9388079047203064,
0.12162359058856964,
0.10209804773330688,
0.15331944823265076,
-0.8929569721221924,
-0.49852654337882996,
0.26109543442726135,
-0.3075787127017975,
-0.09573429077863693,
-0.058710694313049316,
-0.46931248903274536,
-0.26928794384002686,
-0.4579678475856781,
0.8333030343055725,
0.33458709716796875,
-0.3609401285648346,
1.209205985069275,
0.6054871082305908,
-0.3875627815723419,
-0.1919315904378891,
-0.46984657645225525,
-0.0431489571928978,
-0.45019957423210144,
-0.9478351473808289,
0.3408610224723816,
0.07832209765911102,
0.083163782954216,
0.11974839121103287,
0.32479044795036316,
-0.21661779284477234,
0.010154270566999912,
0.21694238483905792,
0.2493060678243637,
-0.2723831534385681,
0.11525999754667282,
-0.03843997046351433,
-0.32449644804000854,
-0.2600736618041992,
-0.31882646679878235,
0.16982907056808472,
-0.45779526233673096,
-0.4906146824359894,
-0.8826056718826294,
0.1431470364332199,
1.1106584072113037,
-0.48661988973617554,
0.3775019347667694,
0.8992948532104492,
-0.39250943064689636,
0.05383951961994171,
-0.2331649661064148,
-0.09587626159191132,
-0.5842950940132141,
0.62580406665802,
-0.8230789303779602,
-0.560876190662384,
0.5009441375732422,
0.09217327833175659,
0.059231918305158615,
0.5413246750831604,
0.5927196741104126,
0.05232177674770355,
1.166915774345398,
0.7220995426177979,
0.15309211611747742,
0.6801828145980835,
-0.24811923503875732,
0.3666854500770569,
-0.6240102648735046,
-0.3591154217720032,
-0.10998812317848206,
-0.29283979535102844,
-0.6929186582565308,
-0.41739383339881897,
0.7370115518569946,
-0.6287816166877747,
-0.18361744284629822,
0.32073384523391724,
-0.3271469473838806,
0.2613835632801056,
0.7297595739364624,
-0.017012836411595345,
0.17434076964855194,
-0.19185535609722137,
-0.06218668073415756,
0.0904756486415863,
-0.6688127517700195,
-0.5871148705482483,
1.0740784406661987,
0.7911984920501709,
0.854651689529419,
0.2545653283596039,
0.20587407052516937,
0.6013539433479309,
0.23277539014816284,
-0.6290376782417297,
0.6147599220275879,
0.10213186591863632,
-0.5668120384216309,
-0.39321067929267883,
-0.13083767890930176,
-0.9505890607833862,
0.6522608399391174,
0.027119392529129982,
-0.8597589135169983,
-0.033200763165950775,
0.12016993016004562,
-0.3507517874240875,
0.37453529238700867,
-1.0838032960891724,
1.1113778352737427,
-0.459768682718277,
-0.2392517775297165,
-0.3625888228416443,
-0.4638233482837677,
0.2725543677806854,
0.021840212866663933,
0.15703044831752777,
-0.19894130527973175,
-0.4853436052799225,
0.5219058990478516,
-0.5073975920677185,
0.722789466381073,
-0.3040463328361511,
0.08497589826583862,
0.5124956965446472,
-0.03498353064060211,
0.33128878474235535,
0.27862608432769775,
-0.04520256817340851,
0.2720555067062378,
0.018854156136512756,
-0.3980649709701538,
-0.34972721338272095,
0.4347078204154968,
-0.9718379974365234,
-0.3369334936141968,
-0.29825952649116516,
-0.7098944783210754,
0.0002900855615735054,
0.48181381821632385,
-0.027548804879188538,
0.4244999587535858,
0.056212738156318665,
0.3717091381549835,
0.15515929460525513,
-0.05494481325149536,
0.8367538452148438,
0.5659211874008179,
0.09180095791816711,
-0.38271746039390564,
1.51353120803833,
0.16291137039661407,
0.12432888150215149,
0.15280167758464813,
-0.19826671481132507,
-0.5076264142990112,
-0.5391402840614319,
-0.8286531567573547,
0.1629120260477066,
-0.5019239783287048,
-0.11188188940286636,
-0.6183832883834839,
0.056443434208631516,
-0.3321469724178314,
-0.12405771017074585,
-0.5676430463790894,
-0.5240960121154785,
-0.17068244516849518,
-0.2758583724498749,
0.2807951867580414,
0.9457710981369019,
-0.16956935822963715,
0.5854926705360413,
-0.7712495923042297,
0.4700053334236145,
0.3479878306388855,
0.25195494294166565,
-0.4085270166397095,
0.056843820959329605,
-0.2563878893852234,
0.12192177772521973,
-0.5214197635650635,
-0.7669543027877808,
0.16526585817337036,
0.41288939118385315,
0.7309910655021667,
0.699470043182373,
-0.13823017477989197,
0.33110660314559937,
-0.2258554846048355,
1.1552700996398926,
0.16449938714504242,
-0.9781428575515747,
0.22541645169258118,
-0.5403509736061096,
0.2757722735404968,
0.05043279007077217,
0.3257591426372528,
-0.5366266965866089,
-0.16777478158473969,
-0.5050427317619324,
-0.9294006824493408,
0.7129709124565125,
0.06600434333086014,
0.22564025223255157,
0.11238943040370941,
0.06618694961071014,
0.2130904197692871,
0.2960198223590851,
-1.041635274887085,
0.2759457230567932,
-0.5483927726745605,
-0.32247644662857056,
0.02158314734697342,
0.12699992954730988,
0.11791986972093582,
-0.18201060593128204,
0.36900794506073,
-0.46667176485061646,
0.5300037264823914,
0.18318717181682587,
-0.22587665915489197,
0.4962407648563385,
-0.032176993787288666,
0.8161316514015198,
0.4805566072463989,
0.1353743076324463,
0.20244842767715454,
0.16265513002872467,
-0.7675739526748657,
0.015313669107854366,
0.3270403742790222,
-0.08695011585950851,
-0.1903914362192154,
0.5590959787368774,
0.7338151931762695,
-0.23663318157196045,
-0.7302272319793701,
0.6250637173652649,
-0.13638277351856232,
0.05250043421983719,
-0.3353583812713623,
0.07271470129489899,
-0.12255221605300903,
0.46785202622413635,
0.4078305661678314,
0.01432902179658413,
0.27570459246635437,
-0.526506245136261,
0.40646892786026,
0.415029376745224,
-0.4832608699798584,
-0.7400861978530884,
0.9262259006500244,
0.8135506510734558,
-0.28804922103881836,
0.801137387752533,
-0.42094388604164124,
-0.4997583329677582,
0.7921180129051208,
0.5755530595779419,
0.6266827583312988,
-0.17595428228378296,
0.35814765095710754,
-0.1786339282989502,
0.5904041528701782,
0.45437324047088623,
0.5749915838241577,
-0.11796077340841293,
-0.7192662358283997,
-0.1342187374830246,
-0.13974615931510925,
-0.4120701551437378,
-0.18310163915157318,
0.023132534697651863,
0.17559251189231873,
-0.37224915623664856,
-0.4160793125629425,
-0.0478629395365715,
-0.3536359667778015,
-0.8070868849754333,
0.23869121074676514,
0.2719990015029907,
0.8281565308570862,
-0.5946285128593445,
0.9958907961845398,
1.081089973449707,
-0.6887124180793762,
-0.8234438300132751,
-0.3947882652282715,
-0.042554449290037155,
-0.8359610438346863,
0.47570469975471497,
0.3272183835506439,
-0.18818381428718567,
-0.023231957107782364,
-0.4681861102581024,
-0.7386171221733093,
1.2088274955749512,
0.28058573603630066,
0.003493183758109808,
0.23918943107128143,
0.46836623549461365,
0.47938454151153564,
-0.6722366809844971,
0.8094081282615662,
0.2344347983598709,
0.7344191074371338,
0.025638096034526825,
-1.245241641998291,
-0.10793574899435043,
-0.5606911182403564,
-0.10047642886638641,
-0.19677914679050446,
-0.9264965057373047,
1.2408502101898193,
-0.41853266954421997,
0.03297841548919678,
0.002840082161128521,
0.6556920409202576,
-0.07244095206260681,
0.5063027143478394,
0.7094579935073853,
0.4328845143318176,
0.6453731060028076,
-0.13493019342422485,
1.1930168867111206,
-0.38954588770866394,
0.08980871737003326,
0.3175135552883148,
-0.5176650881767273,
0.6925408840179443,
0.3715990483760834,
0.3158630132675171,
0.36297717690467834,
0.5896930694580078,
0.12348882853984833,
0.5297767519950867,
-0.34746265411376953,
-0.15443839132785797,
-0.0036045967135578394,
-0.20034033060073853,
-0.3035256862640381,
0.6838407516479492,
0.5473811030387878,
0.06545485556125641,
0.287346214056015,
0.44297486543655396,
0.015266367234289646,
-0.6354748010635376,
-0.4685742259025574,
0.769023060798645,
-0.23402933776378632,
-0.6124556064605713,
0.1345062106847763,
0.40426862239837646,
0.48952755331993103,
-0.44174546003341675,
-0.2979237735271454,
-0.14823253452777863,
0.4842093288898468,
-0.23366689682006836,
-0.6626819372177124,
0.07374872267246246,
-0.28400400280952454,
0.2531689405441284,
0.041371870785951614,
0.6514207124710083,
-0.23382890224456787,
-0.37116578221321106,
-0.05919282138347626,
0.15810802578926086,
0.20549403131008148,
0.1005459725856781,
-0.5962054133415222,
0.4307812452316284,
-0.15497860312461853,
-0.21742430329322815,
-0.15365318953990936,
0.5839235186576843,
-0.22300080955028534,
1.0526037216186523,
0.6519377827644348,
-0.1684364676475525,
0.1789809614419937,
-0.5444293022155762,
0.7756624221801758,
-0.6450671553611755,
-0.8360127210617065,
-0.6248970627784729,
0.9760822653770447,
-0.11320091784000397,
-0.5003122687339783,
0.5959576964378357,
0.5269147157669067,
0.8046377897262573,
-0.008104842156171799,
0.9000032544136047,
-0.24094799160957336,
-0.03375476226210594,
-0.3092986047267914,
0.44989582896232605,
-0.8370959162712097,
0.13658864796161652,
-0.13962538540363312,
-0.7573475241661072,
-0.13906018435955048,
0.5798761248588562,
-0.13096392154693604,
0.06203050538897514,
0.569200336933136,
0.5925097465515137,
-0.3334878385066986,
0.2520577907562256,
0.38526400923728943,
0.1198858842253685,
0.6669681668281555,
0.3810077905654907,
0.632163405418396,
-0.2394983172416687,
0.40128326416015625,
0.09900635480880737,
-0.26005005836486816,
-0.3268999755382538,
-0.6557812690734863,
-0.7008281350135803,
-0.7761372923851013,
-0.13150693476200104,
0.14477448165416718,
-0.0368516631424427,
0.7988205552101135,
1.0373119115829468,
-0.26314106583595276,
-0.07838848233222961,
0.31503647565841675,
0.3769961893558502,
-0.18830303847789764,
-0.12109454721212387,
0.0012169999536126852,
-0.1401837021112442,
-0.9197442531585693,
0.4368517994880676,
0.42018675804138184,
-0.01638812944293022,
-0.3465047776699066,
-0.34023982286453247,
0.09763572365045547,
0.2338472455739975,
0.7832260727882385,
0.4342533349990845,
-0.6625797152519226,
-0.6187880039215088,
-0.06514296680688858,
-0.07909847795963287,
0.0034959905315190554,
0.7636281251907349,
-0.5166688561439514,
0.5013807415962219,
0.3073461651802063,
0.6286887526512146,
0.3788640797138214,
-0.02964016981422901,
0.7290542721748352,
-0.3425579369068146,
0.5573185682296753,
0.1883169561624527,
0.5708540081977844,
0.129983589053154,
-0.26729249954223633,
0.45216795802116394,
0.4398150146007538,
-0.42080092430114746,
-0.585026204586029,
0.3876003921031952,
-1.1778905391693115,
-0.11030665040016174,
1.0938652753829956,
-0.29182687401771545,
-0.24021410942077637,
-0.19963449239730835,
-0.4533693492412567,
-0.18216846883296967,
-0.6567453145980835,
0.312483012676239,
0.3034859001636505,
-0.5120267271995544,
-0.31744906306266785,
-0.41266196966171265,
0.13001802563667297,
0.07442132383584976,
-0.8176025152206421,
-0.5739704370498657,
0.3875691890716553,
0.023748263716697693,
0.27495694160461426,
0.8451217412948608,
0.046100012958049774,
0.5650399923324585,
0.33890673518180847,
0.2538759112358093,
-0.2856042981147766,
-0.6021588444709778,
0.1278022825717926,
0.4338168501853943,
0.19959993660449982,
-0.585712194442749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11457v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11457v1
|
Unifying Bias and Unfairness in Information Retrieval: A Survey of Challenges and Opportunities with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-17T15:05:03 | 2024-04-17T15:05:03 |
Sunhao Dai, Chen Xu, Shicheng Xu, Liang Pang, Zhenhua Dong, Jun Xu
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the rapid advancement of large language models (LLMs), information
retrieval (IR) systems, such as search engines and recommender systems, have
undergone a significant paradigm shift. This evolution, while heralding new
opportunities, introduces emerging challenges, particularly in terms of biases
and unfairness, which may threaten the information ecosystem. In this paper, we
present a comprehensive survey of existing works on emerging and pressing bias
and unfairness issues in IR systems when the integration of LLMs. We first
unify bias and unfairness issues as distribution mismatch problems, providing a
groundwork for categorizing various mitigation strategies through distribution
alignment. Subsequently, we systematically delve into the specific bias and
unfairness issues arising from three critical stages of LLMs integration into
IR systems: data collection, model development, and result evaluation. In doing
so, we meticulously review and analyze recent literature, focusing on the
definitions, characteristics, and corresponding mitigation strategies
associated with these issues. Finally, we identify and highlight some open
problems and challenges for future work, aiming to inspire researchers and
stakeholders in the IR field and beyond to better understand and mitigate bias
and unfairness issues of IR in this LLM era. We also consistently maintain a
GitHub repository for the relevant papers and resources in this rising
direction at https://github.com/KID-22/LLM-IR-Bias-Fairness-Survey.
|
[
-0.3692825138568878,
-0.2745683491230011,
0.577734112739563,
0.16513307392597198,
0.047691237181425095,
0.07290683686733246,
-0.08806775510311127,
-0.5657933354377747,
-0.08234240859746933,
0.5921481251716614,
-0.45299971103668213,
-0.07548550516366959,
-0.8003436923027039,
-0.11309529840946198,
-0.39930230379104614,
1.1429954767227173,
-0.039716899394989014,
0.5370275378227234,
-0.18411782383918762,
-0.36550384759902954,
-0.6667929291725159,
-0.5599223971366882,
0.09586633741855621,
-0.5996027588844299,
0.43523359298706055,
0.39372092485427856,
0.7080984115600586,
0.19563713669776917,
0.9244140982627869,
0.19153548777103424,
-0.10983193665742874,
-0.16511979699134827,
-0.4512690603733063,
0.49790260195732117,
-0.4218790829181671,
-0.3948920667171478,
-0.14484165608882904,
-0.06140519306063652,
0.6541695594787598,
0.8338524103164673,
-0.4100711941719055,
0.3535879850387573,
0.26274076104164124,
1.0403660535812378,
-0.9910073280334473,
-0.11615850031375885,
-0.736882209777832,
0.11579648405313492,
-0.544959306716919,
-0.12247832864522934,
-0.45803287625312805,
-0.4604202210903168,
0.32991495728492737,
-0.3401371240615845,
0.072945237159729,
0.20247703790664673,
0.6124167442321777,
0.24982675909996033,
-0.5752761960029602,
-0.47234776616096497,
-0.8400237560272217,
1.0524039268493652,
-0.5496625304222107,
0.3704342842102051,
-0.1427757889032364,
0.5377245545387268,
-0.25258174538612366,
-0.6122666597366333,
-0.33712252974510193,
0.24166400730609894,
0.22035937011241913,
-0.12375421822071075,
-0.28619423508644104,
-0.08476486802101135,
0.2204599529504776,
0.2845643162727356,
-0.2841810882091522,
0.10315286368131638,
-0.2416025698184967,
0.08697047829627991,
0.4363496005535126,
-0.0666503831744194,
0.2897531986236572,
-0.18236824870109558,
-0.29278481006622314,
-0.15644103288650513,
-0.7836247086524963,
-0.2982114553451538,
0.8299359083175659,
0.3366711735725403,
0.28883489966392517,
0.7841528654098511,
-0.12550143897533417,
0.39613470435142517,
-0.13031357526779175,
0.20937994122505188,
0.36039969325065613,
-0.23486989736557007,
-0.05461884289979935,
-0.05767331272363663,
0.627680778503418,
0.2913307547569275,
0.3784889578819275,
-0.059816695749759674,
-0.5286218523979187,
-0.3732384145259857,
0.13564522564411163,
-0.401927649974823,
0.42183130979537964,
0.10366526991128922,
-0.7793682813644409,
-0.26405563950538635,
0.2084895819425583,
-1.1113561391830444,
-0.8328614234924316,
-0.2974396347999573,
0.3395150899887085,
0.06891179829835892,
-0.4136705696582794,
-0.0053284550085663795,
-0.19156000018119812,
0.3130809962749481,
0.31878358125686646,
-0.6370999217033386,
0.20447510480880737,
0.6498730182647705,
0.48398807644844055,
0.052723951637744904,
-0.06854739785194397,
-0.2597399055957794,
0.08837039023637772,
0.1686682552099228,
0.624462366104126,
-0.5451546907424927,
-0.07767697423696518,
0.4073621332645416,
-0.3554733991622925,
0.18872776627540588,
-0.907916247844696,
0.5770997405052185,
-0.7885547280311584,
0.28744620084762573,
-0.3322383761405945,
-0.31007638573646545,
0.1329483538866043,
0.18018028140068054,
-0.6854922771453857,
0.9045417904853821,
-0.0051751513965427876,
-1.0633208751678467,
0.31339362263679504,
-0.4881722033023834,
-0.14571769535541534,
0.025195356458425522,
-0.355571448802948,
-0.15138547122478485,
0.16566191613674164,
-0.037859003990888596,
0.2585114538669586,
-0.7471731305122375,
0.7215477228164673,
-0.46577566862106323,
-0.3801194131374359,
0.11055399477481842,
-0.4617677330970764,
0.8541481494903564,
0.5034500360488892,
-0.5222466588020325,
-0.32658395171165466,
-0.4198685586452484,
0.07357756793498993,
0.09779682010412216,
-0.19718028604984283,
-0.37760448455810547,
0.29665350914001465,
0.13430370390415192,
0.20779654383659363,
0.4020937383174896,
-0.2288859486579895,
0.3655731678009033,
0.06959481537342072,
0.2146078646183014,
1.0917412042617798,
-0.4127930700778961,
0.6373278498649597,
-0.33584317564964294,
0.48662427067756653,
0.08868265151977539,
0.5050467252731323,
0.13035166263580322,
-0.21181419491767883,
-0.37231209874153137,
0.17623701691627502,
0.4664779603481293,
0.6735938787460327,
-0.8066973686218262,
0.2607347369194031,
-0.3594342768192291,
-0.23741091787815094,
-0.7206045985221863,
0.16839942336082458,
0.29853323101997375,
0.06920047849416733,
0.12308334559202194,
-0.2281908392906189,
-0.5218684077262878,
-1.0001643896102905,
-0.612638533115387,
-0.06559702754020691,
-0.07387451827526093,
0.5161577463150024,
0.4467279613018036,
-0.26545923948287964,
0.9602988958358765,
-0.3726039230823517,
-0.62961745262146,
-0.015048917382955551,
-0.09622103720903397,
0.2805124819278717,
0.2894834876060486,
0.2649494409561157,
-1.1838518381118774,
-0.30435580015182495,
-0.007333750836551189,
-0.897140622138977,
-0.5218136310577393,
0.3744683861732483,
-0.029179543256759644,
0.07147831469774246,
0.4533675014972687,
-0.3248275816440582,
0.2561742663383484,
0.3680571913719177,
-0.3250380754470825,
0.4760056138038635,
0.08135166019201279,
0.22779306769371033,
-0.8055263161659241,
0.28808218240737915,
0.15736904740333557,
0.07356646656990051,
-0.3378584682941437,
0.16734038293361664,
-0.06373680382966995,
0.23881515860557556,
-0.27612245082855225,
0.5717843174934387,
-0.6099914908409119,
-0.1964655965566635,
-0.07811043411493301,
0.19191953539848328,
-0.16047623753547668,
-0.0836687758564949,
-0.6226332187652588,
0.6811063885688782,
0.2611110806465149,
-0.35181716084480286,
0.08036460727453232,
0.05363475903868675,
-0.4147855043411255,
0.6942728161811829,
-0.3672662377357483,
-0.0636511743068695,
-0.4766252338886261,
0.38018766045570374,
-0.5093441009521484,
-0.10257870703935623,
0.24809814989566803,
-0.26337361335754395,
0.158391535282135,
-0.15437090396881104,
-0.6908292174339294,
-0.2658482491970062,
-0.48912742733955383,
0.8232870101928711,
0.47321975231170654,
-0.5724507570266724,
0.6100314855575562,
0.6213491559028625,
-0.21966244280338287,
-1.5108819007873535,
-0.5614965558052063,
0.12346358597278595,
-0.29108545184135437,
-0.46806544065475464,
0.3102986812591553,
-0.2434317022562027,
-0.7616675496101379,
0.12019401788711548,
-0.060906171798706055,
0.05577712878584862,
-0.11545256525278091,
-0.08194632083177567,
0.22431357204914093,
0.05449735000729561,
0.00845656543970108,
-0.19489741325378418,
0.2226821333169937,
-0.12252863496541977,
-0.40105557441711426,
0.4473922550678253,
0.1094403862953186,
-0.5021000504493713,
0.11495767533779144,
0.515988826751709,
0.5198041796684265,
0.07441011816263199,
0.5469458103179932,
0.31383928656578064,
-0.30279678106307983,
-0.11549225449562073,
-1.1882976293563843,
0.04463517665863037,
-0.4501986801624298,
0.20606882870197296,
0.004004071466624737,
-0.8697522282600403,
0.6894269585609436,
0.0002606628695502877,
0.18371516466140747,
0.2988941967487335,
0.33450156450271606,
0.08478118479251862,
1.1765291690826416,
0.8086384534835815,
-0.2208746373653412,
0.7867032289505005,
0.14805789291858673,
0.5586578249931335,
-0.8504170179367065,
-0.49123820662498474,
-0.8506688475608826,
-0.3421754837036133,
-0.7510213851928711,
-0.29068523645401,
0.2819253206253052,
0.15772250294685364,
-0.2940398156642914,
-0.4057980179786682,
-0.5779489874839783,
0.5181968212127686,
0.43969088792800903,
-0.1536000669002533,
0.5515425205230713,
0.1058850884437561,
-0.2274312824010849,
-0.22458218038082123,
-0.5082062482833862,
-0.5010694861412048,
1.265016794204712,
0.26687711477279663,
1.165511965751648,
0.35636645555496216,
0.446649968624115,
0.6028791069984436,
0.3559185266494751,
-0.49254313111305237,
0.3548024296760559,
-0.22389721870422363,
-0.8516286015510559,
0.019001677632331848,
-0.6355714797973633,
-0.8720488548278809,
0.5148742198944092,
-0.1290418952703476,
-0.7729487419128418,
0.4850477874279022,
-0.14283344149589539,
0.3163906931877136,
0.4473033845424652,
-0.8077605366706848,
0.4334297776222229,
-0.3173765540122986,
-0.56060391664505,
0.036868661642074585,
-0.7240562438964844,
0.3881875276565552,
-0.09218113869428635,
0.590472936630249,
-0.19216148555278778,
0.13945241272449493,
0.6706809997558594,
-0.05390749126672745,
0.38927528262138367,
-0.4190180003643036,
-0.1375647932291031,
0.15178024768829346,
0.015185873955488205,
0.4368879497051239,
-0.2784663438796997,
-0.3631788492202759,
0.23448446393013,
0.00718686543405056,
-0.46123364567756653,
-0.4197057783603668,
0.7556108236312866,
-0.7676904201507568,
-0.5449764132499695,
-0.7635936737060547,
-0.4809812903404236,
-0.060414668172597885,
0.5665507912635803,
0.13599970936775208,
0.07833369821310043,
-0.15461096167564392,
0.09955102950334549,
0.9243069887161255,
-0.2911725342273712,
0.153353750705719,
0.5870229005813599,
-0.4185674488544464,
-0.23739226162433624,
0.7410375475883484,
0.3179543912410736,
0.18766839802265167,
0.1447187066078186,
-0.15099887549877167,
-0.24494390189647675,
-0.5893763899803162,
-0.08228806406259537,
0.21567226946353912,
-0.8323636651039124,
-0.3985026776790619,
-0.48902270197868347,
-0.12189313769340515,
-0.7694958448410034,
0.1177523210644722,
-0.237301304936409,
-0.005370899569243193,
-0.20844995975494385,
0.40803706645965576,
-0.036745622754096985,
1.2823373079299927,
-0.036969128996133804,
0.22926543653011322,
-0.46872302889823914,
-0.00926034152507782,
-0.0794479176402092,
0.8168731331825256,
0.3084510862827301,
-0.5069225430488586,
-0.2114897072315216,
-0.2049454152584076,
-0.4848440885543823,
-0.5950426459312439,
0.24745675921440125,
-0.34283339977264404,
0.6279869079589844,
0.2555130422115326,
0.051934320479631424,
0.519383430480957,
-0.7132784724235535,
0.5354644656181335,
0.21709439158439636,
-0.6772533655166626,
0.32232990860939026,
-0.32297995686531067,
-0.012751564383506775,
0.7630751132965088,
0.3339805603027344,
-0.7151222825050354,
-0.18088093400001526,
-0.4838402569293976,
-1.3261537551879883,
0.7534258365631104,
0.0873887836933136,
0.009678106755018234,
0.23204098641872406,
0.29087504744529724,
0.11977230757474899,
0.4605752229690552,
-0.9901660680770874,
-0.41736990213394165,
0.3987760543823242,
-0.21383020281791687,
0.20861300826072693,
-0.2873348593711853,
-0.11983154714107513,
0.07550741732120514,
0.8058815598487854,
-0.07548344135284424,
0.19080987572669983,
0.016644109040498734,
-0.3553178608417511,
-0.2658652365207672,
0.588623046875,
0.13684341311454773,
0.6233445405960083,
-0.2601162791252136,
0.03266884759068489,
-0.23910777270793915,
-0.3605816960334778,
0.16678251326084137,
0.3625214099884033,
-0.3792702555656433,
-0.13527192175388336,
0.0356627032160759,
0.31388184428215027,
0.1621513068675995,
-0.9061678647994995,
0.8484719395637512,
-0.23450008034706116,
-0.050365131348371506,
-0.3913235366344452,
-0.22860081493854523,
-0.2922108769416809,
0.47526243329048157,
0.9574991464614868,
-0.14464397728443146,
0.4405001997947693,
-0.4428471326828003,
-0.14800184965133667,
0.8918070197105408,
-0.2745864987373352,
0.11622203886508942,
0.5680518746376038,
0.10269631445407867,
-0.1583320051431656,
0.5150424242019653,
0.03270930424332619,
-0.36848169565200806,
0.34751030802726746,
0.35119539499282837,
0.6782251000404358,
-0.10302607715129852,
-0.023853234946727753,
-0.28435882925987244,
0.3757346272468567,
-0.49945205450057983,
0.03600846603512764,
0.14295850694179535,
-0.7343775033950806,
-0.11324259638786316,
-0.49644291400909424,
-0.47811558842658997,
-0.02616162598133087,
-0.8223010301589966,
0.3944723904132843,
-0.026580223813652992,
-0.13540954887866974,
-0.11765339225530624,
0.08161189407110214,
-0.7979961037635803,
-0.29420530796051025,
0.24267521500587463,
0.851650059223175,
-0.7167942523956299,
0.24336081743240356,
0.6906678080558777,
-0.3809520900249481,
-0.31545501947402954,
0.10834376513957977,
0.0849381610751152,
-0.785448431968689,
0.6996330618858337,
0.050085339695215225,
-0.010774137452244759,
-0.26112842559814453,
-0.6740021109580994,
-0.8684146404266357,
1.1476826667785645,
0.5810229182243347,
-0.6115893721580505,
-0.2797428369522095,
0.195450559258461,
0.329118013381958,
-0.1916871815919876,
0.7454861998558044,
0.4905940890312195,
0.4997735023498535,
-0.06822919100522995,
-1.0117989778518677,
-0.14960728585720062,
-0.22232848405838013,
0.12993144989013672,
0.3142002820968628,
-0.7421890497207642,
0.8028061985969543,
0.1029331311583519,
-0.17611578106880188,
0.010293289087712765,
0.2897579073905945,
0.22816525399684906,
0.5454175472259521,
0.42821192741394043,
0.5036212205886841,
0.7449654340744019,
-0.12587933242321014,
0.8863335847854614,
0.04369053989648819,
0.49999505281448364,
0.7866852879524231,
-0.8414798378944397,
0.4855995774269104,
0.8773247599601746,
-0.20888446271419525,
0.44527915120124817,
0.4172799587249756,
0.13694998621940613,
0.47063854336738586,
0.4369785785675049,
-0.4627267122268677,
0.1315309852361679,
-0.5219948887825012,
-0.6161466836929321,
0.0340309664607048,
0.2568775713443756,
-0.38334715366363525,
-0.5068700313568115,
0.11013532429933548,
-0.11402879655361176,
0.09565889835357666,
-0.21258336305618286,
0.6003121137619019,
0.03703727945685387,
-0.6701985597610474,
-0.09781622141599655,
-0.012202235870063305,
1.2544831037521362,
-0.5669909119606018,
-0.16062411665916443,
-0.388772189617157,
0.29387637972831726,
-0.2887048125267029,
-0.8985452651977539,
-0.17586283385753632,
0.1007486954331398,
-0.4577119052410126,
-0.4314185082912445,
0.7826422452926636,
-0.1537681519985199,
-0.19021563231945038,
0.747730016708374,
0.758512556552887,
0.06906970590353012,
0.06250620633363724,
-0.8407678008079529,
0.45226216316223145,
0.06829921156167984,
-0.2623734772205353,
0.7581501007080078,
0.6274144649505615,
-0.039899203926324844,
0.835616946220398,
0.2674771547317505,
0.20878946781158447,
0.17540079355239868,
0.2638465166091919,
0.7599101662635803,
-0.7469491958618164,
-0.2012883871793747,
-0.7243135571479797,
0.2572857737541199,
-0.09481988847255707,
0.0215534009039402,
0.6039354801177979,
0.4230843186378479,
0.8831685781478882,
0.24946720898151398,
0.8810195326805115,
-0.25540685653686523,
0.4291701018810272,
-0.3671932816505432,
0.6509060263633728,
-0.6920061707496643,
0.6622872352600098,
-0.4385211765766144,
-1.1709253787994385,
-0.2335725575685501,
0.24301832914352417,
-0.18248046934604645,
0.47887536883354187,
0.5094816088676453,
0.6569386720657349,
-0.06738605350255966,
-0.16671216487884521,
-0.020578620955348015,
0.11219588667154312,
0.3260132670402527,
0.2712952792644501,
0.9567857384681702,
-0.515232503414154,
0.6487864255905151,
0.1203465536236763,
-0.19764326512813568,
-0.48802947998046875,
-0.8734887838363647,
-0.18694192171096802,
-0.3935125172138214,
-0.060945868492126465,
-0.6778376698493958,
0.31511491537094116,
0.9104347825050354,
0.42119526863098145,
-0.6439774632453918,
-0.4360463321208954,
0.21178023517131805,
0.7296744585037231,
0.33927205204963684,
-0.34746256470680237,
-0.038097355514764786,
-0.22652648389339447,
-0.6554365754127502,
-0.1676771640777588,
0.015409780666232109,
-0.0892956331372261,
-0.35690566897392273,
0.06031307950615883,
-0.3526092767715454,
-0.17971855401992798,
0.4724145531654358,
0.3281082808971405,
-0.49481001496315,
-0.2931709885597229,
-0.1932745724916458,
-0.31548887491226196,
-0.050332531332969666,
0.9966045618057251,
-0.7036417722702026,
0.35806894302368164,
0.34967154264450073,
0.7253214120864868,
0.019282320514321327,
-0.24565567076206207,
0.5183680653572083,
-0.5959109663963318,
-0.11568368226289749,
0.4561055600643158,
0.31239452958106995,
0.3997262716293335,
-0.4480425715446472,
0.5652334690093994,
0.09113777428865433,
-0.9454500079154968,
-1.3381767272949219,
0.14919917285442352,
-0.730618417263031,
-0.3140391409397125,
1.0510520935058594,
0.38199177384376526,
0.029018584638834,
-0.025089893490076065,
0.014351890422403812,
0.14973676204681396,
-0.36664509773254395,
0.9193415641784668,
0.972550630569458,
-0.03678882122039795,
0.20582689344882965,
-0.8986476063728333,
0.17281222343444824,
0.7097774147987366,
-0.5913026928901672,
0.17340180277824402,
0.6781291961669922,
0.29836758971214294,
0.03857284411787987,
0.6900913715362549,
-0.41127756237983704,
0.013128490187227726,
-0.5718770623207092,
0.45177844166755676,
0.6522012948989868,
-0.17955830693244934,
-0.7395362854003906,
0.04187186062335968,
0.32914215326309204,
0.3112111985683441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11449v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11449v1
|
AI-Enhanced Cognitive Behavioral Therapy: Deep Learning and Large Language Models for Extracting Cognitive Pathways from Social Media Texts
| 2024-04-17T14:55:27 | 2024-04-17T14:55:27 |
Meng Jiang, Yi Jing Yu, Qing Zhao, Jianqiang Li, Changwei Song, Hongzhi Qi, Wei Zhai, Dan Luo, Xiaoqin Wang, Guanghui Fu, Bing Xiang Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) is an effective technique for addressing
the irrational thoughts stemming from mental illnesses, but it necessitates
precise identification of cognitive pathways to be successfully implemented in
patient care. In current society, individuals frequently express negative
emotions on social media on specific topics, often exhibiting cognitive
distortions, including suicidal behaviors in extreme cases. Yet, there is a
notable absence of methodologies for analyzing cognitive pathways that could
aid psychotherapists in conducting effective interventions online. In this
study, we gathered data from social media and established the task of
extracting cognitive pathways, annotating the data based on a cognitive
theoretical framework. We initially categorized the task of extracting
cognitive pathways as a hierarchical text classification with four main
categories and nineteen subcategories. Following this, we structured a text
summarization task to help psychotherapists quickly grasp the essential
information. Our experiments evaluate the performance of deep learning and
large language models (LLMs) on these tasks. The results demonstrate that our
deep learning method achieved a micro-F1 score of 62.34% in the hierarchical
text classification task. Meanwhile, in the text summarization task, GPT-4
attained a Rouge-1 score of 54.92 and a Rouge-2 score of 30.86, surpassing the
experimental deep learning model's performance. However, it may suffer from an
issue of hallucination. We have made all models and codes publicly available to
support further research in this field.
|
[
-0.26262831687927246,
-1.3191205263137817,
0.8151734471321106,
0.15985257923603058,
-0.3019859492778778,
0.28701773285865784,
-0.47603940963745117,
-0.49979403614997864,
0.2662762999534607,
0.31121304631233215,
-0.7099148035049438,
-0.5275822877883911,
-0.8230083584785461,
-0.12399525940418243,
-0.4520223140716553,
1.180877923965454,
-0.02431049942970276,
0.28110530972480774,
0.19295527040958405,
0.22413866221904755,
-0.7392706871032715,
-0.542373538017273,
-1.0018969774246216,
-0.3405260145664215,
0.5008329749107361,
0.177345409989357,
0.4389454424381256,
0.07045980542898178,
0.6922945380210876,
0.2682170271873474,
0.025408875197172165,
-0.09930958598852158,
-0.44163715839385986,
0.1862088441848755,
-0.07869604229927063,
0.004149169661104679,
-0.5012590885162354,
-0.19119635224342346,
0.2950223982334137,
0.5601611733436584,
-0.19340917468070984,
0.06260368227958679,
0.21293862164020538,
0.6974171996116638,
-0.32876235246658325,
0.08039773255586624,
-0.4756523072719574,
0.24397115409374237,
0.10900935530662537,
-0.14412488043308258,
-0.1308109015226364,
-0.517458438873291,
0.21819455921649933,
-0.5342275500297546,
0.13146422803401947,
-0.4812091886997223,
0.42311081290245056,
0.2434631884098053,
-0.6868570446968079,
-0.6029784679412842,
-1.0307068824768066,
0.5230855345726013,
-0.7193395495414734,
0.21716469526290894,
0.5343790650367737,
0.4728985130786896,
0.10782133042812347,
-0.6300355195999146,
-0.22796481847763062,
-0.35652098059654236,
-0.10713428258895874,
0.29013746976852417,
-0.044729068875312805,
0.26540911197662354,
0.3391111195087433,
0.16858386993408203,
-0.6605497002601624,
-0.0100163035094738,
-0.4672708511352539,
-0.32639652490615845,
0.7877323031425476,
0.5342188477516174,
0.2759677767753601,
0.08008970320224762,
0.039754562079906464,
0.14717936515808105,
-0.02859182097017765,
-0.05283453315496445,
-0.07333267480134964,
0.20099899172782898,
-0.13533532619476318,
0.59621661901474,
-0.17446184158325195,
0.30812352895736694,
-0.0034150059800595045,
-0.26058629155158997,
-0.10127299278974533,
-0.14970208704471588,
-0.12780769169330597,
0.21982520818710327,
0.8732061982154846,
0.3951842188835144,
0.27551084756851196,
-0.10853148996829987,
0.0900774598121643,
0.2470918595790863,
0.4616468548774719,
-0.913773775100708,
-0.2848997116088867,
0.33574727177619934,
-0.4833754301071167,
-0.22003275156021118,
-0.30611705780029297,
-0.7568429112434387,
-0.5826785564422607,
-0.40784287452697754,
0.2832774221897125,
-0.8523798584938049,
-0.519085705280304,
0.07318204641342163,
-0.12722094357013702,
0.22882750630378723,
0.5436102747917175,
-0.7438800930976868,
0.5228294134140015,
0.5971220135688782,
1.1949200630187988,
-0.19954995810985565,
0.05438985303044319,
-0.19887590408325195,
0.1621868908405304,
-0.2246641218662262,
0.8543903231620789,
-0.6573978066444397,
-0.2649742066860199,
0.23417329788208008,
-0.2912745177745819,
-0.11281956732273102,
-0.16759616136550903,
0.5911428928375244,
-0.46350470185279846,
0.16180482506752014,
-0.2954545021057129,
-0.8027632832527161,
-0.22262802720069885,
0.4924905598163605,
-0.5519428253173828,
0.8022811412811279,
-0.050194717943668365,
-0.5508260130882263,
-0.04624742269515991,
-0.8665146231651306,
-0.801917552947998,
0.03573549911379814,
-0.12906210124492645,
-0.05154338479042053,
0.1042436733841896,
0.4442806541919708,
0.745603084564209,
-0.27734044194221497,
0.4431033730506897,
-0.3486064374446869,
-0.41815903782844543,
0.3033452332019806,
-0.5542901754379272,
1.0223554372787476,
0.3454539477825165,
-0.49768802523612976,
0.08099082857370377,
-0.6951056122779846,
-0.04768291488289833,
0.16473707556724548,
-0.43704402446746826,
-0.3411286473274231,
-0.18529470264911652,
0.1707155853509903,
0.3851706385612488,
-0.021414119750261307,
-0.37707990407943726,
0.09480854123830795,
-0.17636601626873016,
0.5637992024421692,
0.780020534992218,
0.37697553634643555,
-0.01078536082059145,
-0.2341429591178894,
0.5639877319335938,
-0.11745026707649231,
0.18834085762500763,
-0.04550950229167938,
-0.5458122491836548,
-0.42342573404312134,
-0.4147682785987854,
-0.21309641003608704,
0.5159384608268738,
-0.6698139905929565,
0.5118692517280579,
-0.2010093629360199,
-0.827277421951294,
-0.37393420934677124,
0.005058205686509609,
0.30054810643196106,
0.4063812792301178,
0.5337601900100708,
-0.20423421263694763,
-0.22684797644615173,
-0.42529281973838806,
-0.5602893233299255,
0.04263519495725632,
0.03287690877914429,
0.23189303278923035,
0.4469323754310608,
-0.39064034819602966,
0.5629627704620361,
-0.6099633574485779,
-0.5545771718025208,
-0.28752151131629944,
0.20661135017871857,
-0.04803207144141197,
0.3246871531009674,
0.13010969758033752,
-0.5560804009437561,
-0.7123253345489502,
-0.03175807371735573,
-0.8555483222007751,
0.13878244161605835,
-0.3706749975681305,
0.00543172936886549,
-0.0923345685005188,
0.5491254329681396,
-0.7560802698135376,
0.41532108187675476,
0.0658501386642456,
-0.2501987814903259,
0.42446768283843994,
-0.04240685701370239,
0.11124739050865173,
-1.002089500427246,
0.05746333673596382,
0.15509115159511566,
-0.18430617451667786,
-0.692242443561554,
-0.28846195340156555,
-0.25659170746803284,
-0.15044960379600525,
-0.25422441959381104,
0.27383914589881897,
-0.2115878462791443,
0.003945412579923868,
-0.29773280024528503,
0.13664984703063965,
-0.3070243000984192,
0.7853618860244751,
0.1754058301448822,
0.04127781093120575,
0.5470708608627319,
-0.4218865633010864,
0.3354843258857727,
0.2150789201259613,
0.007681271061301231,
0.49874669313430786,
-0.35807856917381287,
0.4463821351528168,
-0.034432943910360336,
0.46193498373031616,
-0.9823970198631287,
-0.2839694619178772,
0.36543768644332886,
-0.447603315114975,
0.12582075595855713,
0.2024804651737213,
-0.2865754961967468,
-0.08660416305065155,
-0.37699952721595764,
0.46425971388816833,
0.3501340448856354,
-0.01950712688267231,
0.6161208748817444,
0.33066052198410034,
-0.2585447430610657,
-0.20602630078792572,
-0.624958336353302,
0.13548964262008667,
-0.3135311007499695,
-0.3007209897041321,
0.30384016036987305,
-0.17239154875278473,
-0.18472245335578918,
-0.08758887648582458,
0.10228771716356277,
-0.010620524175465107,
0.15879037976264954,
0.29021456837654114,
0.005886538419872522,
-0.08463126420974731,
0.18110007047653198,
0.3719823360443115,
-0.12259377539157867,
0.2945282757282257,
-0.08951208740472794,
0.7910259366035461,
-0.23545773327350616,
-0.29362940788269043,
-0.6988681554794312,
0.5165051221847534,
0.3485545217990875,
-0.13879920542240143,
0.7377377152442932,
1.0611774921417236,
-0.8078857064247131,
0.15737678110599518,
-0.5040795207023621,
-0.3047791123390198,
-0.40186700224876404,
0.2612065374851227,
0.08106955140829086,
-0.9751426577568054,
0.39043521881103516,
-0.2760700583457947,
0.016934199258685112,
0.38908252120018005,
0.8100485801696777,
-0.09636694192886353,
1.177046775817871,
0.5375593900680542,
-0.13231292366981506,
0.6979443430900574,
-0.35068073868751526,
0.2686273455619812,
-0.7352498173713684,
-0.08214659243822098,
-0.10359963029623032,
-0.12097075581550598,
-0.4473482072353363,
-0.10736265778541565,
0.40817415714263916,
0.06791796535253525,
-0.5271502733230591,
0.1481914520263672,
-0.5662906169891357,
0.1425996869802475,
0.37934601306915283,
0.5528067350387573,
0.4125475287437439,
0.1094856709241867,
0.04506395757198334,
-0.1860159933567047,
-0.3162726163864136,
-0.41481316089630127,
1.1459650993347168,
0.359271764755249,
0.3886094093322754,
0.1031351238489151,
0.5938949584960938,
0.5664247870445251,
0.6487615704536438,
-1.0454556941986084,
0.6062431335449219,
0.12365502864122391,
-0.8706532716751099,
-0.2878366708755493,
-0.21672317385673523,
-0.75466388463974,
0.03081662952899933,
-0.3630789816379547,
-0.9316962957382202,
-0.07932834327220917,
0.002858551684767008,
-0.5725415945053101,
0.040605928748846054,
-0.5578356385231018,
0.7718192934989929,
-0.7187868356704712,
-0.19629138708114624,
-0.6906720995903015,
-0.6694057583808899,
0.5065204501152039,
-0.4568019509315491,
0.16418194770812988,
-0.030982989817857742,
0.21089980006217957,
0.8423227667808533,
-0.288251131772995,
0.9909640550613403,
-0.187623530626297,
0.10473576933145523,
0.23593345284461975,
0.23555517196655273,
0.40550392866134644,
-0.08255675435066223,
0.10929793864488602,
0.23991641402244568,
0.059320054948329926,
-0.32011479139328003,
-0.7502508759498596,
0.49023711681365967,
-0.7753168344497681,
-0.3871774971485138,
-0.3311690390110016,
-0.3526993691921234,
-0.40458357334136963,
0.3821190893650055,
0.19430556893348694,
0.31157946586608887,
-0.2947311997413635,
0.008462872356176376,
0.33424001932144165,
-0.40888944268226624,
0.3322046995162964,
0.5418117642402649,
-0.11111294478178024,
-0.5029535889625549,
0.9437675476074219,
0.07991140335798264,
0.07232241332530975,
0.2634648084640503,
0.3659503161907196,
-0.059181686490774155,
-0.7142572999000549,
0.12861967086791992,
0.2252107709646225,
-0.8054601550102234,
-0.07585974782705307,
-0.702319860458374,
-0.45442548394203186,
-0.6840412020683289,
-0.25914266705513,
-0.2328435182571411,
-0.276728093624115,
-0.14272238314151764,
-0.48948436975479126,
0.35985085368156433,
0.8379230499267578,
-0.015404460951685905,
0.3059937655925751,
-0.8330588340759277,
0.3570632338523865,
0.019938401877880096,
0.17926537990570068,
0.43081432580947876,
-0.15828733146190643,
-0.5347251296043396,
0.12421015650033951,
-0.620328426361084,
-1.0504333972930908,
0.4563579261302948,
0.07479988038539886,
0.206114262342453,
0.585350513458252,
-0.005712161306291819,
0.9237555861473083,
-0.2989443242549896,
0.7948217391967773,
0.4014551639556885,
-0.7597707509994507,
0.7049214839935303,
-0.48529279232025146,
0.004449126776307821,
0.4497997760772705,
0.7268747687339783,
-0.7022011280059814,
-0.4182722270488739,
-0.5184792280197144,
-1.002240777015686,
0.5584601163864136,
0.3686321973800659,
0.14772829413414001,
-0.13519252836704254,
0.5302364826202393,
0.09848111122846603,
0.023016681894659996,
-0.69637531042099,
-0.05006455257534981,
-0.27814269065856934,
-0.5653281807899475,
-0.04595240578055382,
0.03335704281926155,
-0.0908256471157074,
-0.4407934546470642,
0.6619265675544739,
-0.10242854058742523,
0.5115092992782593,
0.4854644536972046,
-0.2905937433242798,
-0.25769704580307007,
-0.0741020143032074,
0.3537009060382843,
0.3615560233592987,
-0.28381597995758057,
-0.026026654988527298,
0.06569292396306992,
-0.679177463054657,
0.060998350381851196,
0.23521123826503754,
0.17623524367809296,
-0.33308207988739014,
0.8426474928855896,
0.5096974968910217,
-0.25033968687057495,
-0.8211106657981873,
0.4076520502567291,
-0.31771084666252136,
-0.11042704433202744,
-0.6939494013786316,
0.1084529384970665,
0.14979560673236847,
0.635848879814148,
0.26915866136550903,
-0.07156956940889359,
0.5497277975082397,
-0.6210179924964905,
0.08067646622657776,
0.5808634757995605,
-0.6547210216522217,
-0.3404013216495514,
0.4443349838256836,
-0.00009291090827900916,
-0.7030460238456726,
0.7035464644432068,
0.1925419718027115,
-0.38196054100990295,
0.4697234332561493,
0.42300042510032654,
1.1886842250823975,
-0.04574056714773178,
0.3581268787384033,
0.2594269812107086,
0.2610282897949219,
0.05074724927544594,
-0.10197179764509201,
-0.16362690925598145,
-0.5972564816474915,
-0.14908713102340698,
-0.44619354605674744,
-0.14394940435886383,
0.32052356004714966,
-0.7062164545059204,
0.07347569614648819,
-0.7285577654838562,
-0.3068428039550781,
0.18579798936843872,
0.14262357354164124,
-0.7719792723655701,
0.1956467479467392,
0.33512791991233826,
0.643674373626709,
-0.8946346044540405,
0.7878906726837158,
0.7259600162506104,
-0.6289724707603455,
-0.8448796272277832,
0.37976136803627014,
0.14356555044651031,
-0.556747555732727,
0.185685932636261,
0.3251208961009979,
-0.11436837911605835,
0.09436975419521332,
-0.33027327060699463,
-0.8087753653526306,
1.2057421207427979,
0.4661482572555542,
-0.3034440875053406,
-0.07641155272722244,
0.392909437417984,
0.9757653474807739,
-0.40437641739845276,
0.5261459350585938,
0.5803496837615967,
0.32876041531562805,
-0.07776030153036118,
-0.5147974491119385,
0.47699832916259766,
-0.2731458842754364,
-0.09529402107000351,
-0.10837221890687943,
-0.5471320152282715,
0.3334865868091583,
-0.045541055500507355,
-0.18990559875965118,
-0.08289842307567596,
0.2457776665687561,
0.04413994029164314,
0.4195798635482788,
0.2575404942035675,
0.29567065834999084,
0.8440396785736084,
0.332143098115921,
0.9513880610466003,
-0.19920410215854645,
0.32678288221359253,
0.7976886034011841,
-0.20336425304412842,
0.7321516871452332,
0.16680067777633667,
0.01780000701546669,
0.5034927725791931,
0.8614476323127747,
0.18791912496089935,
0.5034084916114807,
-0.13728807866573334,
-0.1321847140789032,
-0.23061613738536835,
-0.008221830241382122,
-0.06880388408899307,
0.0034512558486312628,
0.6202514171600342,
-0.34619632363319397,
-0.04264071583747864,
0.17095635831356049,
0.15207652747631073,
-0.09848882257938385,
-0.31503912806510925,
1.0567537546157837,
0.39688432216644287,
-0.7219298481941223,
0.3862735629081726,
-0.05244198814034462,
0.24266524612903595,
-0.5156988501548767,
-0.12415172904729843,
-0.2964426875114441,
0.3838295042514801,
-0.2568831443786621,
-0.5757049322128296,
0.4811924695968628,
0.09988060593605042,
0.23507630825042725,
-0.08167838305234909,
1.0122919082641602,
-0.2737518548965454,
-0.7359907031059265,
0.623929500579834,
0.6183997988700867,
0.10338861495256424,
-0.38120096921920776,
-1.1586811542510986,
-0.1790475845336914,
-0.10279708355665207,
-0.5640354752540588,
0.28742989897727966,
0.38596993684768677,
-0.2742575705051422,
0.5588727593421936,
0.7918007969856262,
-0.14054615795612335,
-0.17476622760295868,
0.06882499158382416,
0.9446239471435547,
-1.0473212003707886,
-0.3250234127044678,
-1.2426141500473022,
0.5091381072998047,
-0.20246438682079315,
-0.2832769751548767,
0.5350918173789978,
0.3121948838233948,
0.44227173924446106,
0.21067842841148376,
0.8009241223335266,
0.07108020782470703,
0.3468802273273468,
-0.5078137516975403,
0.5574924945831299,
-0.502538800239563,
0.29294553399086,
-0.5845391750335693,
-0.7858275175094604,
-0.45481669902801514,
0.5956566333770752,
-0.4503699541091919,
0.18315242230892181,
0.9769281148910522,
0.5050808191299438,
0.13520468771457672,
0.20196124911308289,
-0.06841841340065002,
0.46692001819610596,
0.6468721032142639,
0.7010364532470703,
0.8476845026016235,
-0.17264758050441742,
0.4692983627319336,
-0.33564409613609314,
-0.2986663579940796,
-0.15750522911548615,
-0.6554177403450012,
-1.1290147304534912,
-0.5462960004806519,
-0.24236653745174408,
-0.33463627099990845,
0.2156279981136322,
1.0740654468536377,
0.38067665696144104,
-0.5530683398246765,
-0.07276192307472229,
-0.30695047974586487,
-0.06261517107486725,
-0.5949215292930603,
-0.23955385386943817,
0.6211453080177307,
-0.12873581051826477,
-0.09647757560014725,
0.04987157881259918,
0.2377406507730484,
-0.18237079679965973,
-0.26690226793289185,
-0.1729191094636917,
-0.22487439215183258,
0.0558905303478241,
0.6924371123313904,
-0.1724834144115448,
-0.5188921093940735,
-0.031539756804704666,
0.02996048517525196,
-0.1618097722530365,
-0.015339303761720657,
1.0615746974945068,
-0.5960868000984192,
0.09718608856201172,
0.285462886095047,
0.7424739003181458,
0.7886426448822021,
-0.001202718704007566,
0.5429937243461609,
-0.25094839930534363,
-0.23492059111595154,
0.4969881474971771,
0.14995697140693665,
0.35978010296821594,
-0.7161474823951721,
0.5016948580741882,
0.3072846531867981,
-0.3425184190273285,
-0.6874200701713562,
0.04238478094339371,
-1.0292049646377563,
-0.7336643934249878,
1.1162952184677124,
-0.15782028436660767,
-0.11551093310117722,
-0.2606430947780609,
-0.5131157636642456,
0.6339055299758911,
-0.33229729533195496,
1.2163491249084473,
0.655949056148529,
-0.4160681962966919,
-0.05716254189610481,
-0.6957002282142639,
0.5285678505897522,
0.1760764867067337,
-0.8633676767349243,
0.10341238975524902,
0.4414343237876892,
0.18544083833694458,
0.19228799641132355,
1.0386767387390137,
-0.03847184777259827,
0.1043560653924942,
-0.23173317313194275,
-0.16756708920001984,
-0.0007412352715618908,
-0.046277936547994614,
-0.40345078706741333,
0.017650181427598,
-0.28368812799453735,
0.3787727355957031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11447v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11447v1
|
Research on emotionally intelligent dialogue generation based on automatic dialogue system
| 2024-04-17T14:55:03 | 2024-04-17T14:55:03 |
Jin Wang, JinFei Wang, Shuying Dai, Jiqiang Yu, Keqin Li
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Automated dialogue systems are important applications of artificial
intelligence, and traditional systems struggle to understand user emotions and
provide empathetic feedback. This study integrates emotional intelligence
technology into automated dialogue systems and creates a dialogue generation
model with emotional intelligence through deep learning and natural language
processing techniques. The model can detect and understand a wide range of
emotions and specific pain signals in real time, enabling the system to provide
empathetic interaction. By integrating the results of the study "Can artificial
intelligence detect pain and express pain empathy?", the model's ability to
understand the subtle elements of pain empathy has been enhanced, setting
higher standards for emotional intelligence dialogue systems. The project aims
to provide theoretical understanding and practical suggestions to integrate
advanced emotional intelligence capabilities into dialogue systems, thereby
improving user experience and interaction quality.
|
[
-0.627041757106781,
-0.980877161026001,
0.7205578684806824,
0.020510394126176834,
0.008358112536370754,
0.28636252880096436,
0.12665563821792603,
-0.698717474937439,
0.2627665400505066,
0.3972169756889343,
-0.8325726985931396,
-0.2886876165866852,
-0.2450028508901596,
0.3717714548110962,
-0.15930798649787903,
0.5656216144561768,
0.14849065244197845,
0.2530367970466614,
0.10846154391765594,
-0.20709672570228577,
-0.4070385992527008,
-0.3904036283493042,
-0.7240816950798035,
-0.28875353932380676,
0.1556011438369751,
0.550558865070343,
0.5166052579879761,
0.13219405710697174,
0.679548442363739,
0.4596152603626251,
0.3995688855648041,
0.17618826031684875,
0.06841274350881577,
0.27144888043403625,
0.1065635159611702,
-0.14972229301929474,
-0.6792372465133667,
0.10819845646619797,
-0.05428066477179527,
0.034629449248313904,
-0.17210280895233154,
-0.007353974971920252,
-0.2028530240058899,
0.4739851951599121,
-0.2383871078491211,
0.04103770852088928,
-0.3277718126773834,
0.5898486375808716,
0.39942365884780884,
-0.056267667561769485,
-0.2687229514122009,
-0.49343928694725037,
0.2003946155309677,
-0.429719477891922,
-0.34387922286987305,
0.3084411919116974,
0.7482275366783142,
0.5951091647148132,
-0.5153788924217224,
-0.5119168162345886,
-0.8840922117233276,
0.7141642570495605,
-0.9926203489303589,
-0.05270271375775337,
0.044488225132226944,
0.4650603234767914,
0.1721159964799881,
-0.5185472369194031,
-0.7760300040245056,
-0.3574662208557129,
0.07543201744556427,
0.2854868471622467,
-0.3765396773815155,
0.36758795380592346,
0.20044004917144775,
0.22718317806720734,
-0.3663434684276581,
0.03532709181308746,
-0.08982909470796585,
0.23653385043144226,
1.0644794702529907,
0.5643458962440491,
0.5947405099868774,
-0.3052822947502136,
-0.008667523972690105,
0.17133352160453796,
-0.08945684880018234,
-0.029497381299734116,
0.4139958322048187,
0.06060120835900307,
0.048486314713954926,
0.47808387875556946,
-0.23247922956943512,
0.4775872528553009,
0.2653734087944031,
0.3865233361721039,
0.3216448128223419,
-0.17073297500610352,
-0.4530501663684845,
0.19008687138557434,
0.9394547939300537,
0.6458404660224915,
0.512769341468811,
0.36567965149879456,
-0.1939791440963745,
0.011016882956027985,
0.3573753833770752,
-0.8277004361152649,
-0.06072342023253441,
0.31421276926994324,
-0.6402415633201599,
-0.5977985858917236,
-0.14798365533351898,
-0.7106780409812927,
-0.42891138792037964,
-0.4701704978942871,
0.11105333268642426,
-0.6164625883102417,
-0.5170754790306091,
0.05272819474339485,
-0.08387192338705063,
0.1819794476032257,
0.34310483932495117,
-0.7152239084243774,
0.34313568472862244,
0.4285455048084259,
0.47669100761413574,
0.330417662858963,
0.0748884379863739,
-0.2862071692943573,
-0.15427617728710175,
0.01716618984937668,
0.9014169573783875,
-0.7413344979286194,
-0.31562453508377075,
0.03368430584669113,
-0.2295491248369217,
0.05472927168011665,
-0.5192425847053528,
0.4719070494174957,
-0.16128331422805786,
0.06709353625774384,
0.2759534418582916,
-0.45971184968948364,
-0.28991150856018066,
0.33302053809165955,
-0.39464113116264343,
0.6148400902748108,
0.17438535392284393,
-0.27738896012306213,
0.10286717116832733,
-1.0941060781478882,
-0.36718887090682983,
0.29637882113456726,
-0.07118640840053558,
-0.12803618609905243,
0.30186572670936584,
0.19257156550884247,
0.3910087049007416,
-0.42992138862609863,
0.423321008682251,
-0.26619476079940796,
-0.1006445661187172,
0.3977353870868683,
-0.34773433208465576,
0.5360482335090637,
0.4852869510650635,
-0.6365145444869995,
0.05461513251066208,
-0.6256542801856995,
0.23511528968811035,
0.11736944317817688,
0.05852832645177841,
-0.11536949872970581,
0.007916385307908058,
-0.08510346710681915,
0.3783455193042755,
-0.000621659797616303,
-0.6482666730880737,
0.21029213070869446,
-0.5859583616256714,
0.418295294046402,
0.4915134310722351,
0.21070852875709534,
0.46295303106307983,
0.006317456718534231,
0.550476610660553,
0.05699422210454941,
0.32375892996788025,
-0.07765759527683258,
-0.4202430248260498,
-0.9557970762252808,
0.09795081615447998,
-0.036575451493263245,
1.046028971672058,
-0.3923362195491791,
0.770912230014801,
0.22555264830589294,
-0.5113644599914551,
-0.942279577255249,
-0.14222869277000427,
0.3390170931816101,
0.4991048276424408,
0.11843696981668472,
-0.33132317662239075,
-0.45118796825408936,
-0.9507637023925781,
-0.17646238207817078,
-0.16924959421157837,
-0.04730306565761566,
0.8251527547836304,
0.4054877758026123,
-0.489217609167099,
0.9435738921165466,
-0.38146811723709106,
-0.08710738271474838,
-0.26869145035743713,
0.6681360602378845,
-0.11724916100502014,
0.6689351201057434,
0.39806386828422546,
-0.738555371761322,
-0.5017184615135193,
0.02428826130926609,
-1.0482287406921387,
-0.38223668932914734,
0.02925003692507744,
-0.09419221431016922,
0.12322475761175156,
0.3028257489204407,
-0.7076675891876221,
0.6185194849967957,
0.20730939507484436,
-0.4106912910938263,
0.19625993072986603,
-0.034236934036016464,
0.6004003286361694,
-1.05472731590271,
-0.021019140258431435,
0.024241458624601364,
0.24182583391666412,
-0.8509529232978821,
-0.4135500490665436,
-0.3322662115097046,
-0.5110015273094177,
-0.4604037404060364,
0.5228204727172852,
-0.05679170787334442,
-0.026807455345988274,
-0.32073330879211426,
0.05410143733024597,
0.1316712349653244,
0.452808141708374,
0.007573575247079134,
0.15757940709590912,
0.2862832546234131,
-0.43059611320495605,
1.0164719820022583,
0.35738328099250793,
-0.0891859158873558,
0.9591864943504333,
-0.6232688426971436,
0.16008205711841583,
0.20754018425941467,
0.10303165018558502,
-0.649142861366272,
-0.48395052552223206,
0.4012244641780853,
-0.7301322221755981,
0.2033589482307434,
0.5037435293197632,
-0.22732630372047424,
-0.5354874730110168,
0.023606514558196068,
0.37412652373313904,
0.6556034684181213,
-0.12689965963363647,
0.8955329060554504,
0.3594585955142975,
-0.6619863510131836,
-0.1074107438325882,
-0.35833436250686646,
0.35852277278900146,
-0.15843704342842102,
-0.8796637654304504,
-0.03785670921206474,
-0.30657365918159485,
-0.7810857892036438,
0.03554070368409157,
0.5398305654525757,
-0.060431089252233505,
0.14303435385227203,
0.2982955873012543,
-0.04299915209412575,
-0.13765358924865723,
0.31464511156082153,
0.45429420471191406,
-0.26948481798171997,
0.30822473764419556,
0.05224275216460228,
0.4877530038356781,
-0.34142282605171204,
-0.7192351818084717,
-1.0921303033828735,
0.9085747003555298,
0.784931480884552,
-0.41994187235832214,
0.33501723408699036,
0.5136920213699341,
-0.3681163787841797,
-0.008913304656744003,
-0.6460463404655457,
-0.37558692693710327,
-0.44992128014564514,
0.2611382305622101,
-0.2407558560371399,
-0.47927209734916687,
0.26625892519950867,
-0.47011512517929077,
0.03182756528258324,
0.4627552628517151,
0.5910066962242126,
-0.2725732922554016,
2.0746824741363525,
0.4730096161365509,
0.005254783667623997,
0.46776655316352844,
-0.005619838368147612,
0.5309234261512756,
-0.6015019416809082,
-0.22636757791042328,
-0.41896575689315796,
-0.565283477306366,
-0.25368377566337585,
0.23905307054519653,
0.07461047172546387,
-0.2827851474285126,
-0.7039142847061157,
-0.26948845386505127,
-0.8649576902389526,
-0.005746110342442989,
0.7687010169029236,
0.139350026845932,
-0.08045394718647003,
-0.19832591712474823,
0.011220968328416348,
0.005859570112079382,
-0.29752644896507263,
-0.5395739674568176,
0.5283561944961548,
0.40986788272857666,
0.6244511604309082,
-0.03762029483914375,
0.7319930791854858,
0.5373706221580505,
0.17488859593868256,
-1.0248721837997437,
0.4826992452144623,
0.20749498903751373,
-0.25042784214019775,
-0.3103111684322357,
-0.05997642129659653,
-0.6276781558990479,
-0.5135679244995117,
-0.10340381413698196,
-0.6539259552955627,
0.17061196267604828,
-0.009229930117726326,
-0.7979242205619812,
0.05609700456261635,
-0.8725998401641846,
0.3921163082122803,
-0.543317973613739,
-0.06676070392131805,
-0.34130924940109253,
-0.9020764827728271,
0.14165814220905304,
0.0845869779586792,
0.09784211963415146,
-0.26783016324043274,
0.4899060130119324,
0.6799398064613342,
-0.3928326666355133,
0.8402941226959229,
-0.3799586594104767,
-0.0047554876655340195,
0.35012710094451904,
0.24947737157344818,
0.3990582823753357,
0.018174882978200912,
-0.32424482703208923,
-0.17448435723781586,
-0.6181176900863647,
-0.13980552554130554,
-0.7913433909416199,
0.5182474255561829,
-0.8467980027198792,
-0.5884537696838379,
-0.23193193972110748,
-0.7634471654891968,
-0.21783585846424103,
-0.15161782503128052,
-0.027259916067123413,
0.20624443888664246,
-0.2509758770465851,
-0.16416864097118378,
0.5981893539428711,
-0.34438014030456543,
0.43469077348709106,
0.354459673166275,
0.22943300008773804,
-0.3869030475616455,
0.8041780591011047,
-0.121319979429245,
0.03771510347723961,
0.09466781467199326,
0.04857155308127403,
0.1586047112941742,
-0.16787154972553253,
-0.6801791787147522,
0.0005063400021754205,
-0.3856840133666992,
-0.3586820363998413,
-0.7436128854751587,
-0.4332462251186371,
-0.6410694122314453,
-0.5400427579879761,
-0.2569011449813843,
-0.13788637518882751,
-0.3855401575565338,
-0.35436519980430603,
0.6463125348091125,
1.1420761346817017,
-0.043417759239673615,
0.24711349606513977,
-1.341921329498291,
0.05157119408249855,
0.5294488668441772,
0.06316948682069778,
-0.0007625588332302868,
0.020286157727241516,
-0.2963211238384247,
0.08076666295528412,
-0.36859092116355896,
-0.9196537137031555,
1.0206700563430786,
0.21785292029380798,
0.41067513823509216,
0.6962063312530518,
0.223716139793396,
0.37422096729278564,
-0.32852882146835327,
0.9895194172859192,
0.21554255485534668,
-1.1820091009140015,
0.9063902497291565,
-0.2686160206794739,
0.43464231491088867,
0.4399011731147766,
0.04908837750554085,
-0.36270856857299805,
-0.4968685507774353,
-0.7825661897659302,
-0.6234589219093323,
0.7623359560966492,
0.07658492773771286,
0.17609064280986786,
0.0680423304438591,
0.2454674243927002,
-0.06003876030445099,
0.2849765717983246,
-0.44506216049194336,
0.09596582502126694,
-0.14066056907176971,
-0.8804482817649841,
0.3569850027561188,
-0.10583982616662979,
-0.2731681168079376,
-0.2619428038597107,
0.6105390191078186,
-0.2119024693965912,
0.6241507530212402,
0.09798036515712738,
0.01794496178627014,
-0.5009000301361084,
0.17440253496170044,
0.3673590421676636,
0.010536412708461285,
-0.11618134379386902,
-0.31580543518066406,
0.4005603790283203,
-0.22734007239341736,
0.05974433198571205,
0.12633082270622253,
0.21961966156959534,
-0.12368986010551453,
0.04278687387704849,
0.8165801763534546,
-0.11031563580036163,
-0.9748796820640564,
0.3241027593612671,
-0.38947397470474243,
-0.22204895317554474,
-0.47316059470176697,
0.24964380264282227,
-0.05429035797715187,
0.7811333537101746,
0.35665932297706604,
0.13431698083877563,
0.46774882078170776,
-0.5016919374465942,
0.14499548077583313,
0.3387185335159302,
-0.7042467594146729,
-0.13389979302883148,
0.24512235820293427,
0.8417362570762634,
-0.9805236458778381,
1.0209758281707764,
-0.10340405255556107,
-0.8186075091362,
0.8672751188278198,
0.28241023421287537,
1.1155805587768555,
-0.6649112701416016,
0.17361436784267426,
0.15067067742347717,
-0.059304654598236084,
0.4971725642681122,
0.6100888252258301,
-0.08165918290615082,
-0.6103350520133972,
-0.03619280084967613,
-0.38163015246391296,
-0.7272360324859619,
-0.38398340344429016,
-0.5746893882751465,
0.09500882029533386,
-0.26768016815185547,
-0.13990572094917297,
-0.32688847184181213,
0.1408918797969818,
-0.6536422371864319,
0.7264347076416016,
0.5257163047790527,
0.704904317855835,
-0.8330727815628052,
0.45363283157348633,
0.4056745767593384,
-0.25453826785087585,
-0.9442639350891113,
-0.25179335474967957,
0.08323647081851959,
-0.8761330842971802,
1.0621325969696045,
0.34361732006073,
-0.34789782762527466,
0.27086588740348816,
-0.8070040941238403,
-0.48499757051467896,
1.1198524236679077,
-0.07489140331745148,
-0.3879028558731079,
-0.05729907751083374,
0.05048968642950058,
0.6314396858215332,
-0.9594497084617615,
0.8046135902404785,
0.49433156847953796,
0.6472965478897095,
0.046686261892318726,
-0.7140272259712219,
0.02503032051026821,
-0.9155817627906799,
-0.3046722114086151,
0.2871190011501312,
-0.6808486580848694,
0.7218843698501587,
-0.01727466471493244,
-0.016247540712356567,
0.2816961705684662,
0.47990867495536804,
-0.003081862349063158,
0.6169272661209106,
0.43020549416542053,
0.6253363490104675,
0.6481019854545593,
-0.06270746141672134,
0.7159644961357117,
-0.6333121061325073,
0.021335089579224586,
0.577006459236145,
-0.5962802767753601,
0.45540109276771545,
0.2462238073348999,
0.47914400696754456,
0.8005692958831787,
0.7084600329399109,
-0.11468849331140518,
0.22013896703720093,
0.10682235658168793,
-0.61214280128479,
-0.35549718141555786,
-0.573843777179718,
-0.2921667993068695,
0.4935626685619354,
0.6967543959617615,
-0.5723735690116882,
0.3365699052810669,
0.5527791976928711,
-0.1358996331691742,
-0.29318058490753174,
-0.2298654019832611,
1.2054386138916016,
0.09742898494005203,
-0.7148725986480713,
0.053834207355976105,
-0.30272021889686584,
0.38418182730674744,
-0.41131117939949036,
-0.2540593147277832,
-0.09148833900690079,
0.10696855187416077,
-0.2376440018415451,
-0.7800918221473694,
0.15211400389671326,
0.27415409684181213,
0.09043598175048828,
-0.1906944364309311,
0.8537721037864685,
-0.021018125116825104,
-0.42641302943229675,
0.4286830425262451,
0.6732856631278992,
0.2461787462234497,
-0.014958341605961323,
-0.9179414510726929,
-0.16528499126434326,
0.05651215836405754,
-0.6336334943771362,
0.06756224483251572,
0.8218587040901184,
0.4510415196418762,
0.7671085000038147,
0.42016395926475525,
-0.16274285316467285,
-0.4693203866481781,
0.24917884171009064,
0.8109936714172363,
-1.0298609733581543,
-0.10119842737913132,
-0.8270717263221741,
0.7906922698020935,
-0.48820602893829346,
-0.21280518174171448,
0.3529428541660309,
0.07228394597768784,
0.15013857185840607,
0.06337804347276688,
1.054819941520691,
-0.17426683008670807,
0.4826640188694,
-0.11491876095533371,
0.6984888911247253,
-0.6121734976768494,
-0.12486390769481659,
-0.4714665114879608,
-0.4709702432155609,
-0.38379549980163574,
0.6417406797409058,
-0.23222170770168304,
0.026231899857521057,
0.48885366320610046,
0.6063082218170166,
0.2651936411857605,
0.3773742914199829,
0.3394119441509247,
0.2244042307138443,
0.2753853499889374,
0.7251713275909424,
1.1215347051620483,
-0.22303210198879242,
0.35652822256088257,
-0.12951427698135376,
-0.3722875714302063,
-0.5636885762214661,
-0.5055240392684937,
-0.5466241240501404,
-0.35354992747306824,
-0.2242947220802307,
-0.26578837633132935,
-0.015471366234123707,
1.1970497369766235,
0.4973822832107544,
-0.7315443754196167,
-0.1573551446199417,
-0.26798298954963684,
-0.17775680124759674,
0.041506052017211914,
-0.34410712122917175,
-0.0372948981821537,
-0.19787196815013885,
-1.108858585357666,
0.286284476518631,
0.6325876116752625,
0.11970784515142441,
-0.24985328316688538,
-0.4549632966518402,
-0.10162016749382019,
0.6522353291511536,
0.40879133343696594,
0.2352936714887619,
-0.4570685029029846,
-0.3186928331851959,
0.27147358655929565,
-0.20163777470588684,
0.054763905704021454,
0.6751292943954468,
-0.8830959796905518,
0.47008031606674194,
0.4403688311576843,
0.47293224930763245,
-0.10334677249193192,
0.052032068371772766,
0.9903349280357361,
-0.04099355265498161,
-0.09415704756975174,
0.7574344277381897,
0.37497439980506897,
0.1403774619102478,
-0.7429177165031433,
0.36826249957084656,
0.05669428035616875,
-0.9873673319816589,
-0.7070833444595337,
0.5148420333862305,
-0.8702738881111145,
-0.06772354990243912,
0.736625611782074,
-0.14241977035999298,
0.011576694436371326,
-0.2281075417995453,
-0.8433268666267395,
0.6953403949737549,
-0.7184867262840271,
0.8198051452636719,
0.38233327865600586,
-0.8703305721282959,
-0.34687548875808716,
-0.28375038504600525,
0.32334592938423157,
0.504274845123291,
-1.0472630262374878,
-0.2878788411617279,
0.46446549892425537,
-0.5825014710426331,
0.273213267326355,
0.2531008720397949,
0.3051946461200714,
0.3143080472946167,
0.043061502277851105,
0.2963773012161255,
0.0569608099758625,
-0.010311668738722801,
-0.3048248589038849,
0.22981610894203186,
-0.1963980346918106,
0.1414981633424759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11446v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11446v1
|
Open-Ended Wargames with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-17T14:54:58 | 2024-04-17T14:54:58 |
Daniel P. Hogan, Andrea Brennen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Wargames are a powerful tool for understanding and rehearsing real-world
decision making. Automated play of wargames using artificial intelligence (AI)
enables possibilities beyond those of human-conducted games, such as playing
the game many times over to see a range of possible outcomes. There are two
categories of wargames: quantitative games, with discrete types of moves, and
qualitative games, which revolve around open-ended responses. Historically,
automation efforts have focused on quantitative games, but large language
models (LLMs) make it possible to automate qualitative wargames. We introduce
"Snow Globe," an LLM-powered multi-agent system for playing qualitative
wargames. With Snow Globe, every stage of a text-based qualitative wargame from
scenario preparation to post-game analysis can be optionally carried out by AI,
humans, or a combination thereof. We describe its software architecture
conceptually and release an open-source implementation alongside this
publication. As case studies, we simulate a tabletop exercise about an AI
incident response and a political wargame about a geopolitical crisis. We
discuss potential applications of the approach and how it fits into the broader
wargaming ecosystem.
|
[
-0.38711652159690857,
-0.9501234889030457,
0.6096835136413574,
0.18357598781585693,
-0.07417825609445572,
0.11184216290712357,
-0.2832021713256836,
-0.2999584972858429,
-0.10831521451473236,
0.8321069478988647,
-0.6213663220405579,
-0.7705336809158325,
-0.23699474334716797,
-0.3440839648246765,
-0.2897980511188507,
0.8856111764907837,
-0.007971148937940598,
-0.21724414825439453,
-0.34826284646987915,
-0.25686484575271606,
-0.09145563095808029,
-0.5461689233779907,
-0.5904010534286499,
-0.7539863586425781,
0.22218869626522064,
0.5465459227561951,
1.235231637954712,
0.48989832401275635,
0.6136538982391357,
0.4149044156074524,
0.20342423021793365,
0.08010531961917877,
-0.6987316608428955,
0.30058929324150085,
-0.14666087925434113,
-0.5266693830490112,
-0.21068257093429565,
0.28068649768829346,
0.28977465629577637,
0.05801653116941452,
-0.4114780128002167,
0.3365928530693054,
-0.3236847519874573,
0.2598072588443756,
-0.31331178545951843,
0.35161206126213074,
-0.22706761956214905,
0.36856600642204285,
0.23933985829353333,
0.12475099414587021,
-0.22186769545078278,
-0.041079580783843994,
0.24785205721855164,
-1.1951473951339722,
-0.10318146646022797,
0.2894989252090454,
0.525885820388794,
0.31698524951934814,
-0.20890024304389954,
-0.1628299206495285,
-1.0945541858673096,
0.672928512096405,
-0.8159778714179993,
0.08148400485515594,
0.24856260418891907,
0.45902037620544434,
-0.4175303876399994,
-0.57328861951828,
-0.5403040647506714,
-0.3295053243637085,
0.2769679129123688,
0.6678148508071899,
-0.4541340172290802,
0.34542116522789,
0.2678634822368622,
0.10359048843383789,
-0.5903913974761963,
0.3047182857990265,
-0.22396588325500488,
0.3370392620563507,
0.901261568069458,
0.40924501419067383,
0.47752150893211365,
0.221191868185997,
-0.27071696519851685,
0.064371258020401,
-0.5297386050224304,
0.064676433801651,
0.3101006746292114,
-0.024727342650294304,
-0.5426238775253296,
0.9827962517738342,
-0.05673016607761383,
0.6012767553329468,
-0.1082056313753128,
-0.14879539608955383,
-0.36371198296546936,
0.12190525233745575,
-0.22553330659866333,
0.21190841495990753,
0.8694485425949097,
0.5876414775848389,
0.26340919733047485,
-0.24601377546787262,
-0.2193894237279892,
0.1907958835363388,
0.22649289667606354,
-0.5369736552238464,
-0.080643430352211,
0.561529815196991,
-0.5431272387504578,
-0.27765294909477234,
-0.17866256833076477,
-0.7516553401947021,
-0.6128636598587036,
-0.17558333277702332,
0.48002928495407104,
-0.38559961318969727,
-0.24244002997875214,
0.18977315723896027,
-0.4408893585205078,
0.21124793589115143,
0.2741718888282776,
-0.4333210587501526,
0.3887977600097656,
0.7383642196655273,
1.055570125579834,
-0.052903831005096436,
-0.40837177634239197,
-0.5537773370742798,
0.1317846029996872,
-0.4918176829814911,
0.7197396159172058,
-0.494159460067749,
-0.5215756297111511,
0.18441349267959595,
-0.43192750215530396,
0.6517929434776306,
-0.7614691257476807,
0.13236118853092194,
-0.8078757524490356,
0.5493709444999695,
0.5390354990959167,
-0.4693218469619751,
-0.242798313498497,
0.5678500533103943,
-0.8642250895500183,
0.7941167950630188,
0.04600272327661514,
-0.4177314043045044,
0.16598881781101227,
-1.0233854055404663,
-0.36553630232810974,
0.20134495198726654,
-0.001983840484172106,
-0.2899884879589081,
0.2609228491783142,
0.021395571529865265,
0.026175474748015404,
-0.8109354376792908,
0.08600971102714539,
-0.4292096793651581,
-0.2691153585910797,
0.0956481322646141,
-0.00629126001149416,
0.707301676273346,
0.13337260484695435,
-0.531894326210022,
0.5334923267364502,
-0.3626320958137512,
0.09654203057289124,
0.24513530731201172,
-0.24311424791812897,
-0.1324732005596161,
0.4713371694087982,
-0.34177297353744507,
0.3716224730014801,
0.007386363577097654,
-0.381865918636322,
0.29167038202285767,
-0.41197019815444946,
0.409633070230484,
0.4471595585346222,
-0.106147900223732,
0.5196018815040588,
-0.665902316570282,
0.738490641117096,
0.10057365149259567,
0.43926548957824707,
0.25277355313301086,
-0.7437425255775452,
-0.40089306235313416,
-0.19491378962993622,
0.2968500554561615,
0.9957202076911926,
-1.3384793996810913,
0.1520397663116455,
0.035909246653318405,
-0.7935015559196472,
-0.652345597743988,
-0.4264269471168518,
-0.041012242436409,
0.08636343479156494,
0.14405786991119385,
-0.18316876888275146,
-0.4613609313964844,
-0.3785313069820404,
-0.052571382373571396,
-0.6574970483779907,
-0.05956251919269562,
0.3551931083202362,
0.39153534173965454,
0.03224525973200798,
1.0997157096862793,
-0.4232948422431946,
-0.22203433513641357,
-0.3868590295314789,
0.44463905692100525,
-0.1527385413646698,
0.06122835353016853,
0.26709336042404175,
-0.7454984784126282,
-0.026581427082419395,
0.05953650549054146,
-1.1613612174987793,
0.009149555116891861,
-0.27702757716178894,
-0.05797392874956131,
-0.019690126180648804,
0.45909446477890015,
-0.7906249761581421,
0.42571645975112915,
0.6316602826118469,
-0.2852891981601715,
0.7139028906822205,
-0.3712383806705475,
0.3752295970916748,
-0.7568479776382446,
0.04697563871741295,
-0.242855966091156,
-0.10743040591478348,
-0.8180091977119446,
0.47223472595214844,
-0.5178484916687012,
-0.43714600801467896,
-0.7415969967842102,
0.7193506956100464,
-0.46260979771614075,
-0.28236204385757446,
-0.25791606307029724,
0.5924673676490784,
-0.09627491980791092,
0.03885188326239586,
0.20201218128204346,
0.5402622818946838,
0.47655561566352844,
-0.4952039420604706,
0.8379095196723938,
0.2465924173593521,
-0.5127630233764648,
0.4749060273170471,
-0.6793117523193359,
-0.18616072833538055,
-0.08577409386634827,
0.10438868403434753,
-0.42254239320755005,
0.046662259846925735,
0.2040552943944931,
-0.3027489483356476,
-0.4193895757198334,
0.15004295110702515,
-0.5391724109649658,
-0.4331094026565552,
-0.20552170276641846,
0.3874955177307129,
0.6894955039024353,
-0.26908475160598755,
0.7161046862602234,
0.7235697507858276,
-0.11960150301456451,
-0.3177560567855835,
-0.5561096668243408,
0.23333634436130524,
-0.42018282413482666,
-0.2989611327648163,
0.23382867872714996,
-0.26059019565582275,
-0.8635830283164978,
0.048198919743299484,
0.5173947811126709,
-0.15804480016231537,
0.07629463076591492,
0.5091515779495239,
0.038172606378793716,
-0.34517836570739746,
0.04067212715744972,
-0.44315582513809204,
0.039651308208703995,
0.15786749124526978,
-0.3245406150817871,
0.39679431915283203,
0.02481626532971859,
-0.4718776047229767,
0.07058823853731155,
0.6398196220397949,
0.7920646667480469,
-0.3521116375923157,
0.5581218004226685,
0.38693729043006897,
-0.4781154990196228,
-0.032721202820539474,
-0.4766795039176941,
0.06265371292829514,
-0.43292051553726196,
0.27801939845085144,
-0.0763433650135994,
-0.8321399092674255,
0.6451058387756348,
-0.3847722113132477,
0.4586069583892822,
0.22070938348770142,
0.7083280682563782,
-0.01210282277315855,
1.2497695684432983,
0.6370468139648438,
-0.2577638626098633,
0.2983545660972595,
-0.033818960189819336,
0.16714367270469666,
-0.3002985715866089,
-0.18248996138572693,
-0.24582481384277344,
-0.3430143892765045,
-0.32169798016548157,
-0.46503883600234985,
0.6246047019958496,
-0.24954043328762054,
-0.6682258248329163,
-0.31002017855644226,
-0.3094845712184906,
0.5445756912231445,
0.8105120658874512,
0.0009311650064773858,
0.24601441621780396,
-0.21398039162158966,
0.11445413529872894,
0.13615505397319794,
-1.178296685218811,
-0.29959776997566223,
0.5186855792999268,
0.10248018801212311,
0.733332633972168,
0.2786389887332916,
0.7831803560256958,
0.43424132466316223,
0.4711959660053253,
-0.8986456990242004,
0.5497443079948425,
0.1992114633321762,
-0.725854754447937,
-0.8621360659599304,
-0.4467643201351166,
-0.9957059025764465,
0.13905327022075653,
-0.5192331671714783,
-0.23111669719219208,
-0.34188133478164673,
-0.2747642695903778,
-0.7386040091514587,
0.5293946266174316,
-0.3958812355995178,
0.7212072014808655,
-0.46998274326324463,
-0.22720006108283997,
-0.28371840715408325,
-0.49173176288604736,
0.43481773138046265,
0.3118957579135895,
0.6350798010826111,
0.03935856372117996,
-0.1552787870168686,
0.6232144236564636,
-0.01922527514398098,
0.6605333089828491,
-0.02953326143324375,
0.007091333623975515,
0.6574789881706238,
0.4147210121154785,
0.02693229541182518,
0.03027091734111309,
-0.06134670972824097,
0.2888756990432739,
-0.013448381796479225,
-0.2650294899940491,
-0.5986743569374084,
0.4920782446861267,
-1.1337827444076538,
-0.8717759251594543,
-0.724073588848114,
-0.8484640121459961,
0.11120878905057907,
0.41012200713157654,
0.06618763506412506,
0.21520861983299255,
-0.9217972159385681,
-0.21928280591964722,
0.47937634587287903,
-0.39383089542388916,
0.38792383670806885,
0.6850408911705017,
-0.44135260581970215,
-0.4398875832557678,
0.7524288892745972,
0.13630057871341705,
0.15799233317375183,
0.28824207186698914,
0.27548131346702576,
-0.06338414549827576,
-0.5113380551338196,
-0.5855080485343933,
0.1836043745279312,
-0.34619438648223877,
-0.33200109004974365,
-0.07170547544956207,
-0.08243956416845322,
-0.0403793603181839,
-0.3826368451118469,
0.07491323351860046,
-0.13898639380931854,
-0.3095110058784485,
0.04207339137792587,
0.38422074913978577,
1.1997661590576172,
-0.4418433904647827,
0.46958333253860474,
-0.8344997763633728,
0.47360315918922424,
0.11972593516111374,
0.4127141237258911,
-0.21858404576778412,
-0.15069563686847687,
-0.23590317368507385,
0.13688459992408752,
-0.12199767678976059,
-0.9543507099151611,
0.492774099111557,
0.19960631430149078,
0.34319791197776794,
0.2350063920021057,
0.35072723031044006,
0.5678255558013916,
-0.9109635353088379,
1.2105352878570557,
0.20303364098072052,
-0.8077289462089539,
0.10893966257572174,
-0.33521443605422974,
0.6724312901496887,
0.127497598528862,
0.38223955035209656,
-0.6517713665962219,
-0.5461822748184204,
-0.8841034770011902,
-0.6632044315338135,
0.8693179488182068,
-0.10418523102998734,
-0.2276850789785385,
0.04092688485980034,
0.16639789938926697,
-0.04714589938521385,
0.45992085337638855,
-0.3059755861759186,
-0.10640563070774078,
-0.12548169493675232,
-0.10365358740091324,
-0.6991916298866272,
0.09769543260335922,
-0.6960509419441223,
0.2954268753528595,
0.6652944087982178,
-0.03889601677656174,
0.09965749830007553,
0.030035782605409622,
-0.10164998471736908,
-0.3483315110206604,
0.13330163061618805,
0.4960377812385559,
0.3668656647205353,
0.116919606924057,
0.16578204929828644,
0.2300189733505249,
-0.26994970440864563,
0.37351590394973755,
0.2122381329536438,
-0.29373881220817566,
-0.1502787321805954,
0.484567791223526,
0.40674981474876404,
0.28198492527008057,
-1.0951775312423706,
0.3550807535648346,
-0.18452055752277374,
-0.31206265091896057,
-0.4362359046936035,
-0.05914251506328583,
0.1503174602985382,
0.8111489415168762,
0.043728530406951904,
-0.5519219040870667,
0.21356172859668732,
-0.8941823244094849,
0.3187221586704254,
0.62614506483078,
-0.32960256934165955,
-0.08692315965890884,
0.5241126418113708,
0.08942560106515884,
-0.7652967572212219,
0.5998045206069946,
-0.2658635079860687,
-0.49800825119018555,
0.6046336889266968,
0.6024412512779236,
0.6092147827148438,
-0.13134066760540009,
0.6896326541900635,
-0.14412277936935425,
0.493897408246994,
-0.05686086043715477,
0.37715986371040344,
0.41774651408195496,
-0.42002081871032715,
-0.3956920802593231,
-0.14985854923725128,
-0.7644951343536377,
0.3114287257194519,
-0.36435142159461975,
0.027979539707303047,
-0.5165793299674988,
-0.23694637417793274,
-0.37263911962509155,
0.005298248492181301,
-0.6673195958137512,
0.09084954857826233,
0.42924147844314575,
0.9186039566993713,
-0.5999149084091187,
0.0039017375092953444,
0.8321420550346375,
-0.34251099824905396,
-0.29185062646865845,
-0.1793825626373291,
0.17415426671504974,
-0.5205920934677124,
0.2573954164981842,
-0.34033140540122986,
-0.004529139958322048,
0.03707919269800186,
-0.5918693542480469,
-0.7708350419998169,
0.9396178722381592,
0.2553689777851105,
-0.284221351146698,
-0.24298906326293945,
0.3468737006187439,
0.514866054058075,
-0.4362078607082367,
0.6358314752578735,
0.5757462382316589,
0.5969045758247375,
-0.26732540130615234,
-0.7242041826248169,
-0.22900286316871643,
0.14722636342048645,
-0.33546698093414307,
0.1164952963590622,
-0.9479025602340698,
0.5980653166770935,
-0.3204011619091034,
-0.2635444402694702,
0.028184272348880768,
1.0517882108688354,
0.09088534861803055,
0.43941232562065125,
0.500312089920044,
0.6604448556900024,
0.35422399640083313,
-0.2120841145515442,
0.7224673628807068,
-0.2937535345554352,
0.09773051738739014,
0.602430522441864,
-0.6452624797821045,
0.6651103496551514,
-0.08352121710777283,
0.13778840005397797,
0.43447524309158325,
0.6891701817512512,
0.22806116938591003,
0.3402248024940491,
0.43482398986816406,
-0.3967755138874054,
-0.20589879155158997,
-0.20945699512958527,
-0.08978932350873947,
0.6197245121002197,
0.45333439111709595,
0.3679791986942291,
-0.6361441612243652,
0.18740738928318024,
0.0333244688808918,
0.06727773696184158,
-0.3795746862888336,
1.1145727634429932,
0.014203174971044064,
-0.7656670212745667,
0.34627586603164673,
-0.07436199486255646,
0.33331000804901123,
-0.7258861064910889,
-0.26130107045173645,
0.12067095935344696,
0.0926683247089386,
-0.023198509588837624,
-0.9150927066802979,
-0.06572634726762772,
-0.06894397735595703,
-0.08916722238063812,
0.173234760761261,
0.32536715269088745,
-0.5254718661308289,
-0.32195428013801575,
0.25040295720100403,
0.9013394713401794,
0.07332184165716171,
-0.10039999336004257,
-0.9318252801895142,
0.25194793939590454,
-0.4968108534812927,
-0.30293840169906616,
0.40889009833335876,
0.8027960062026978,
0.005316752474755049,
0.6279528141021729,
0.3760700523853302,
0.35452818870544434,
-0.33994030952453613,
-0.15158087015151978,
0.6875970959663391,
-0.5230541825294495,
-0.6364402174949646,
-0.7414766550064087,
0.28228721022605896,
-0.16554613411426544,
-0.3482489287853241,
0.5292888283729553,
0.5634950399398804,
0.5617620348930359,
0.02347053959965706,
1.1611889600753784,
0.037888165563344955,
0.18364745378494263,
-0.38127225637435913,
0.6538814306259155,
-0.38019126653671265,
-0.43052637577056885,
0.040864117443561554,
-0.639039158821106,
-0.6533517837524414,
0.239671528339386,
-0.33111026883125305,
-0.26385489106178284,
0.3759329617023468,
0.5301527380943298,
-0.041874516755342484,
-0.0039848266169428825,
0.6607808470726013,
0.2518969476222992,
0.47251221537590027,
0.41527271270751953,
1.0441561937332153,
0.08355557918548584,
0.3955132067203522,
-0.023760179057717323,
-0.7586314678192139,
-0.34662145376205444,
-0.8174875974655151,
-0.9846599102020264,
-0.592907726764679,
-0.04428921639919281,
-0.4443277418613434,
0.3474462628364563,
1.0417075157165527,
0.5054724216461182,
-0.3429488241672516,
-0.79103684425354,
0.6289021968841553,
0.24473237991333008,
-0.5040124654769897,
-0.22116617858409882,
0.029089773073792458,
-0.03943227604031563,
-0.4836985766887665,
0.4197232723236084,
0.2711907923221588,
-0.1612236052751541,
-0.4534209370613098,
0.0705975666642189,
-0.1544269621372223,
0.5728199481964111,
0.9187521934509277,
0.5899746417999268,
-0.6873340606689453,
-0.3678581416606903,
0.05199272558093071,
0.2515868842601776,
-0.21145030856132507,
1.0090036392211914,
-0.8554603457450867,
0.4021243751049042,
0.23394615948200226,
0.6903070211410522,
0.12937889993190765,
-0.0165353212505579,
0.8566188216209412,
-0.17781712114810944,
0.3183530569076538,
0.5656920671463013,
-0.0122561976313591,
0.17012211680412292,
-0.22481229901313782,
0.4597255289554596,
-0.14415845274925232,
-0.7575666308403015,
-0.7867113947868347,
0.41192519664764404,
-0.3442320227622986,
-0.3525480031967163,
1.2031886577606201,
-0.11749140173196793,
-0.3107752203941345,
-0.08643942326307297,
-0.2645684778690338,
0.4221836030483246,
-0.37725743651390076,
0.9723437428474426,
1.029128074645996,
-0.16016191244125366,
-0.10801541060209274,
-0.6014114618301392,
0.5712080001831055,
0.05335520580410957,
-0.9448042511940002,
0.05489497259259224,
0.8251025080680847,
-0.47107449173927307,
0.22562675178050995,
0.2969100773334503,
0.21350780129432678,
0.34366679191589355,
0.11894598603248596,
0.28467369079589844,
-0.045578088611364365,
-0.5197795033454895,
-0.3223419189453125,
0.311276376247406,
0.16356682777404785,
0.02504848502576351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11384v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11384v1
|
Exploring Key Point Analysis with Pairwise Generation and Graph Partitioning
| 2024-04-17T13:44:29 | 2024-04-17T13:44:29 |
Xiao Li, Yong Jiang, Shen Huang, Pengjun Xie, Gong Cheng, Fei Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Key Point Analysis (KPA), the summarization of multiple arguments into a
concise collection of key points, continues to be a significant and unresolved
issue within the field of argument mining. Existing models adapt a two-stage
pipeline of clustering arguments or generating key points for argument
clusters. This approach rely on semantic similarity instead of measuring the
existence of shared key points among arguments. Additionally, it only models
the intra-cluster relationship among arguments, disregarding the inter-cluster
relationship between arguments that do not share key points. To address these
limitations, we propose a novel approach for KPA with pairwise generation and
graph partitioning. Our objective is to train a generative model that can
simultaneously provide a score indicating the presence of shared key point
between a pair of arguments and generate the shared key point. Subsequently, to
map generated redundant key points to a concise set of key points, we proceed
to construct an arguments graph by considering the arguments as vertices, the
generated key points as edges, and the scores as edge weights. We then propose
a graph partitioning algorithm to partition all arguments sharing the same key
points to the same subgraph. Notably, our experimental findings demonstrate
that our proposed model surpasses previous models when evaluated on both the
ArgKP and QAM datasets.
|
[
-0.5022830963134766,
-0.5069859027862549,
0.8126555681228638,
-0.09406045079231262,
-0.7911626696586609,
-0.008203946985304356,
0.16874949634075165,
0.01124920230358839,
0.1676131784915924,
0.27315449714660645,
-0.38056331872940063,
-0.7423901557922363,
-0.6402140259742737,
-0.11393370479345322,
-0.12042060494422913,
0.8731912970542908,
0.1832164078950882,
-0.007707799784839153,
-0.43103229999542236,
-0.7710840106010437,
-0.6242449879646301,
-0.3007158637046814,
-0.6690356731414795,
-0.3574361205101013,
0.4578549265861511,
0.3932357132434845,
0.5401800274848938,
0.28549036383628845,
0.012285075150430202,
0.26193761825561523,
0.013615080155432224,
0.10951399803161621,
-0.2484605312347412,
0.24883989989757538,
0.12773801386356354,
-0.11426790058612823,
-0.3184179961681366,
-0.15173622965812683,
0.762349545955658,
0.7220768332481384,
0.25841066241264343,
0.11101499199867249,
-0.0732235461473465,
0.7356656193733215,
-0.5071746110916138,
0.23372235894203186,
-0.8699501156806946,
-0.05782066285610199,
-0.04548823460936546,
-0.3296968638896942,
-0.28424271941185,
-0.48086997866630554,
0.02994818612933159,
-0.5633664727210999,
0.3452397584915161,
-0.23174230754375458,
0.834091305732727,
0.14396275579929352,
-0.5630954504013062,
-0.468117356300354,
-0.2614521384239197,
0.3001132011413574,
-0.9538621306419373,
0.10548530519008636,
-0.12006285041570663,
0.1345803439617157,
-0.13186727464199066,
-0.6493222117424011,
-0.6104434728622437,
0.14886502921581268,
-0.23155003786087036,
0.10640189796686172,
-0.07381554692983627,
0.128602996468544,
0.038822025060653687,
0.09020717442035675,
-0.48829391598701477,
0.04811479151248932,
-0.5054602026939392,
-0.15971660614013672,
0.8081207871437073,
0.20868448913097382,
0.292499303817749,
-0.5094701051712036,
-0.2665403187274933,
-0.45673391222953796,
-0.7603129148483276,
0.2798754870891571,
0.6552625894546509,
0.41360026597976685,
-0.17431248724460602,
0.289193719625473,
-0.09341979771852493,
0.832612931728363,
0.06838688999414444,
0.013815026730298996,
-0.024490300565958023,
-0.20506396889686584,
0.031844716519117355,
0.21770824491977692,
1.2592687606811523,
0.7997862100601196,
-0.10331933945417404,
-0.18043380975723267,
0.48562225699424744,
0.2001880407333374,
0.03506145998835564,
-1.0530487298965454,
-0.6578934192657471,
0.20597058534622192,
-0.7743565440177917,
-0.6320714354515076,
-0.1364736706018448,
-1.1139514446258545,
-0.5925595164299011,
0.1764628142118454,
0.2583993673324585,
-0.3567044734954834,
-0.39187753200531006,
-0.165955051779747,
-0.3645936846733093,
0.2689834535121918,
-0.3022213280200958,
-0.8330090641975403,
0.22701755166053772,
0.8422375917434692,
0.9038651585578918,
-0.10212870687246323,
-0.10275056213140488,
-0.46037882566452026,
0.08553315699100494,
-0.41858038306236267,
1.1324527263641357,
-0.9711198210716248,
-0.8582839965820312,
-0.09353717416524887,
-0.2602456212043762,
-0.03814053535461426,
-0.738673746585846,
0.5765349864959717,
-0.6471611261367798,
0.10226238518953323,
-0.5624427795410156,
-0.8819696307182312,
-0.30557993054389954,
0.28572356700897217,
-0.5211114883422852,
0.7043009400367737,
-0.000762424897402525,
-0.44059664011001587,
0.8684926629066467,
-0.7123922109603882,
-0.5088567137718201,
0.35074537992477417,
-0.6478736400604248,
-0.7768710851669312,
0.11806972324848175,
0.28474706411361694,
0.4624609053134918,
-0.02797703817486763,
0.17318478226661682,
-0.5340909361839294,
0.1903073936700821,
-0.0337003618478775,
0.17874272167682648,
0.5278019309043884,
-0.05413287132978439,
-0.052957672625780106,
0.3536907136440277,
-0.8163501620292664,
0.2443646788597107,
0.22316235303878784,
-0.17359142005443573,
-0.4622010290622711,
0.32326260209083557,
-0.41973987221717834,
0.36984387040138245,
0.13436713814735413,
-0.5528298020362854,
0.26624348759651184,
-0.33667322993278503,
0.6669702529907227,
0.6234052181243896,
0.723866879940033,
0.25323286652565,
0.1435295045375824,
0.39515450596809387,
0.17971567809581757,
-0.19683170318603516,
-0.20089776813983917,
-0.8431220054626465,
-0.36918768286705017,
0.07119042426347733,
0.3478838801383972,
0.06735330820083618,
-0.1858665943145752,
0.31157106161117554,
-0.3702481687068939,
-0.4423818588256836,
-0.4477078914642334,
-0.16248135268688202,
0.24800461530685425,
0.5330862402915955,
0.0943574458360672,
-0.13647480309009552,
-0.4770956337451935,
-0.8324221968650818,
-0.2786303460597992,
-0.33847272396087646,
0.17508557438850403,
0.2917998135089874,
0.23025798797607422,
0.2904815971851349,
0.9088146686553955,
-0.7317020297050476,
-0.035512760281562805,
-0.16188348829746246,
0.41782352328300476,
0.08277734369039536,
0.36050379276275635,
0.5200162529945374,
-0.6224730610847473,
-0.6312618851661682,
-0.0548013374209404,
-0.6934143304824829,
0.04240640625357628,
-0.07556062191724777,
-0.05508480593562126,
-0.2816835641860962,
0.681988000869751,
-0.47997888922691345,
0.21807736158370972,
0.3228801488876343,
-0.3451995551586151,
0.25113973021507263,
0.0031445499043911695,
0.07325868308544159,
-1.3400006294250488,
-0.13772885501384735,
-0.28654858469963074,
-0.04008694365620613,
-0.5149020552635193,
0.25713565945625305,
-0.4305105209350586,
-0.519712507724762,
-0.0045607006177306175,
0.4082147479057312,
-0.2355930209159851,
0.006841481197625399,
-0.5644996762275696,
0.019667237997055054,
0.003936301916837692,
0.6813774704933167,
-0.01816692017018795,
0.2761929929256439,
0.40831097960472107,
-0.19864961504936218,
0.135488361120224,
0.21036872267723083,
-0.04277265816926956,
0.7793656587600708,
-0.7819291353225708,
0.36672288179397583,
-0.04736209288239479,
0.24889974296092987,
-1.3737331628799438,
-0.08104211837053299,
0.32469940185546875,
-0.6030459403991699,
0.0621335543692112,
-0.5234730839729309,
-0.1903843879699707,
0.025772515684366226,
-0.3787568509578705,
0.6417555809020996,
0.4140527844429016,
-0.5455516576766968,
0.5636066198348999,
0.6168394684791565,
-0.3340725600719452,
0.09102391451597214,
0.3155255615711212,
-0.053401850163936615,
-0.5578646063804626,
-0.8362388610839844,
0.47862935066223145,
0.25663402676582336,
-0.08757757395505905,
0.3600081503391266,
-0.029877344146370888,
0.21956400573253632,
-0.16132524609565735,
0.7785044312477112,
-0.038388315588235855,
-0.14472761750221252,
0.10948220640420914,
0.3312036097049713,
-0.3882301449775696,
0.24832753837108612,
-0.21324650943279266,
0.6678074598312378,
-0.1544816792011261,
-0.142416849732399,
-0.005665669217705727,
0.8311195969581604,
0.49595797061920166,
-0.1601356714963913,
0.3972046971321106,
0.31025752425193787,
-0.2632973790168762,
-0.19047333300113678,
-0.027379395440220833,
-0.013914274983108044,
-0.4372723400592804,
0.12604743242263794,
-0.4830533564090729,
-0.7174484729766846,
0.6220132112503052,
-0.5331687331199646,
0.5417340397834778,
0.6320198774337769,
0.6580248475074768,
0.03505992144346237,
1.3322277069091797,
0.041561778634786606,
-0.08904349058866501,
0.2488815188407898,
-0.5186999440193176,
0.6627712249755859,
-0.6829109191894531,
-0.168431356549263,
-0.34209492802619934,
-0.6251370310783386,
-0.4804580509662628,
-0.3083086311817169,
0.7061471939086914,
0.3800426125526428,
0.004054561723023653,
-0.11155788600444794,
-0.6208747625350952,
0.4951818883419037,
0.5980808138847351,
-0.08772061765193939,
0.08659718185663223,
0.09357891231775284,
-0.2782331705093384,
0.21025463938713074,
-0.7492257356643677,
-0.39013075828552246,
1.301874041557312,
-0.046302810311317444,
-0.13903984427452087,
-0.17902593314647675,
1.175472617149353,
0.28025123476982117,
0.02799346297979355,
-0.8348625898361206,
0.7954162955284119,
-0.05426691472530365,
-0.2470642775297165,
-0.3633369207382202,
-0.3357934355735779,
-1.0423364639282227,
0.5770801305770874,
-0.10490867495536804,
-0.8304625153541565,
0.13799762725830078,
0.13783828914165497,
-0.5329390168190002,
0.316521018743515,
-0.7709038853645325,
1.2999541759490967,
0.272258996963501,
-0.1112823560833931,
-0.50328528881073,
-0.635658323764801,
0.5041084289550781,
0.3287592828273773,
-0.07850831001996994,
-0.060334254056215286,
0.5373391509056091,
1.2012087106704712,
-1.0553406476974487,
0.5197334289550781,
-0.6590084433555603,
0.06222957372665405,
0.6735544204711914,
-0.07124708592891693,
0.481052041053772,
-0.025834621861577034,
0.13866353034973145,
-0.014228121377527714,
0.17632222175598145,
-0.36271610856056213,
-0.8676823973655701,
0.8557283878326416,
-0.7619165778160095,
-0.4568788707256317,
-0.07990603148937225,
-0.552042543888092,
-0.4642432928085327,
0.012514915317296982,
0.3049481213092804,
0.444790780544281,
-0.02867528423666954,
-0.15742000937461853,
0.1546076089143753,
0.0983288362622261,
0.4481821060180664,
0.09270261973142624,
0.20150922238826752,
-0.6430765986442566,
1.30403470993042,
0.023949431255459785,
0.009622127749025822,
-0.1633116900920868,
0.6924909353256226,
-0.45409122109413147,
-0.7777471542358398,
-0.42184948921203613,
0.1474412977695465,
-0.6311614513397217,
-0.059149425476789474,
-0.5878891944885254,
-0.12343578040599823,
-0.44518059492111206,
-0.29722872376441956,
-0.17608581483364105,
-0.6118632555007935,
0.19445617496967316,
-0.3508302569389343,
0.2329390048980713,
0.49580487608909607,
-0.16610270738601685,
0.5101536512374878,
-0.8833259344100952,
0.4855758249759674,
0.6284126043319702,
0.1675003170967102,
0.4296843111515045,
0.28050336241722107,
0.13580891489982605,
-0.2351227104663849,
-0.6976925730705261,
-1.2661041021347046,
0.06804447621107101,
0.2048705816268921,
0.32639622688293457,
0.6649694442749023,
0.23685842752456665,
0.7521742582321167,
-0.323923796415329,
0.9901630282402039,
0.28086650371551514,
-0.7106579542160034,
0.4568656086921692,
-0.20200850069522858,
0.08943872898817062,
0.6747892498970032,
0.21378235518932343,
-0.4722656011581421,
-0.21600931882858276,
-1.0437732934951782,
-0.9654313921928406,
0.4035390019416809,
-0.15351985394954681,
-0.282389372587204,
-0.07958364486694336,
0.1507595181465149,
0.1260632425546646,
-0.05090534687042236,
-0.6191180944442749,
0.04525790363550186,
-0.1795525848865509,
-0.31406381726264954,
0.32090771198272705,
-0.21516603231430054,
-0.48955830931663513,
-0.12751254439353943,
0.6118918061256409,
-0.23589006066322327,
0.042660560458898544,
-0.13003583252429962,
0.2034868597984314,
-0.13687463104724884,
0.36514243483543396,
0.4696808457374573,
0.24475854635238647,
-0.0910310372710228,
0.1886814385652542,
-0.08211376518011093,
-0.0852477103471756,
0.3155347406864166,
0.07995574921369553,
-0.37460002303123474,
0.19190721213817596,
0.3288029432296753,
0.925553023815155,
-0.06475915014743805,
-0.3643921911716461,
0.5070859789848328,
0.05937076732516289,
-0.40582868456840515,
0.12929651141166687,
-0.26383671164512634,
0.36627790331840515,
0.308165043592453,
0.01471220888197422,
-0.06524956971406937,
0.04409877210855484,
-0.4596204459667206,
0.04168574512004852,
0.7730401158332825,
-0.25087594985961914,
-0.4330596923828125,
0.5004115700721741,
0.2722860276699066,
-0.2424793392419815,
0.5008774399757385,
-0.6516937017440796,
-0.7751849889755249,
0.49562934041023254,
0.26174062490463257,
0.9039883017539978,
0.12642760574817657,
0.5438965559005737,
0.49266964197158813,
-0.07876062393188477,
0.6197071075439453,
0.34927645325660706,
-0.5242160558700562,
-0.6555052995681763,
0.022560562938451767,
-0.4572707712650299,
-0.1115911453962326,
0.23692061007022858,
-0.5565615892410278,
-0.04235844686627388,
-0.42668673396110535,
0.05191873386502266,
0.09187003970146179,
0.11449091136455536,
-0.28012534976005554,
-0.027666667476296425,
0.0028411424718797207,
0.1630386859178543,
-1.2392572164535522,
0.4054636061191559,
0.5315651893615723,
-0.23656430840492249,
-1.0433800220489502,
-0.06751015782356262,
-0.19738739728927612,
-0.8260738849639893,
0.3201899528503418,
0.004291362129151821,
0.10304321348667145,
-0.24019162356853485,
-0.11959191411733627,
-0.4104529917240143,
0.8636345863342285,
0.02051376737654209,
-0.24790745973587036,
-0.059322942048311234,
0.6622458100318909,
0.36941781640052795,
-0.3142099380493164,
-0.29213979840278625,
0.5796382427215576,
0.37222930788993835,
0.34714803099632263,
-0.2219162881374359,
0.5033345818519592,
-0.2232457846403122,
-0.17102265357971191,
0.6413516998291016,
-0.6273967027664185,
0.5668455362319946,
-0.2508563995361328,
-0.41860440373420715,
-0.2191169708967209,
0.7169261574745178,
0.5347824096679688,
0.6351050734519958,
0.8927001357078552,
1.0445315837860107,
0.6369104981422424,
0.18823105096817017,
0.4579099416732788,
-0.5972549915313721,
0.2178138643503189,
1.1730947494506836,
-0.4036491811275482,
0.8718379139900208,
0.5864400267601013,
-0.15616481006145477,
0.6637160778045654,
0.6018363237380981,
0.09164206683635712,
0.6849860548973083,
0.18649636209011078,
-0.4507259428501129,
-0.36754080653190613,
-0.1338578313589096,
-0.5566115379333496,
0.26667675375938416,
0.3274258077144623,
-0.4019801616668701,
-0.609747052192688,
-0.3209725022315979,
0.034323982894420624,
-0.07158219069242477,
-0.22512075304985046,
1.010411024093628,
0.08323362469673157,
-0.9100543856620789,
0.34428465366363525,
-0.0113601079210639,
0.15582142770290375,
-0.5034317970275879,
-0.21856491267681122,
-0.01378560159355402,
-0.2532152533531189,
-0.2424420714378357,
-0.5830432176589966,
0.3705204725265503,
-0.06889180839061737,
-0.16331423819065094,
0.057691093534231186,
0.7132682800292969,
-0.24646520614624023,
-0.5776888132095337,
0.12891077995300293,
0.22300410270690918,
0.03381624445319176,
-0.09069301187992096,
-0.38576406240463257,
-0.07849495857954025,
-0.2149045318365097,
0.1634695827960968,
0.4042970836162567,
0.20782782137393951,
-0.09522594511508942,
0.02546996809542179,
0.7085167765617371,
0.050495583564043045,
0.5636878609657288,
0.10180558264255524,
0.8999798893928528,
-0.320300430059433,
-0.5861267447471619,
-0.9838983416557312,
0.4941789507865906,
-0.3039514124393463,
-0.47770828008651733,
0.46964389085769653,
0.7045277953147888,
0.5272700786590576,
0.08398072421550751,
0.8280941247940063,
-0.09252595901489258,
0.22907666862010956,
-0.31688055396080017,
0.3984796702861786,
-0.3961297869682312,
-0.24913746118545532,
-0.4628635048866272,
-0.7327957153320312,
-0.10242735594511032,
0.28744950890541077,
-0.2156624048948288,
-0.4330978989601135,
0.4594511091709137,
0.7843689918518066,
0.019519049674272537,
0.14135229587554932,
0.1454530656337738,
-0.09297341853380203,
0.706939160823822,
0.9085017442703247,
0.7635650634765625,
-0.6105555891990662,
0.5911622047424316,
-0.10650959610939026,
-0.10380122065544128,
-0.08533007651567459,
-0.8603373765945435,
-0.6959453821182251,
-0.9444804191589355,
-0.5739069581031799,
-0.2630968391895294,
-0.20895375311374664,
0.5317816138267517,
0.8195009827613831,
-0.6982120871543884,
-0.13058260083198547,
-0.37672287225723267,
0.3040861487388611,
-0.3002215325832367,
-0.27496376633644104,
0.7384368777275085,
-0.30747145414352417,
-0.20802173018455505,
0.5927480459213257,
0.3293217718601227,
-0.33413031697273254,
-0.19503718614578247,
-0.20978911221027374,
-0.060699861496686935,
0.16585348546504974,
0.5818893909454346,
0.5034533739089966,
-0.565163791179657,
-0.41875359416007996,
-0.5489652156829834,
0.5420764684677124,
0.2813226878643036,
1.2296476364135742,
-0.8231763243675232,
0.6095383167266846,
0.8780336380004883,
0.4504786729812622,
0.5644322037696838,
0.1902618706226349,
0.6571306586265564,
-0.7645585536956787,
0.03133907914161682,
-0.003169685835018754,
0.5218408703804016,
0.14749550819396973,
0.056853171437978745,
0.20330969989299774,
0.23995499312877655,
-0.38055673241615295,
-0.8281490206718445,
0.3972904682159424,
-1.2253806591033936,
-0.25636032223701477,
0.915759265422821,
-0.30230429768562317,
0.01878969743847847,
0.28774747252464294,
-0.1983741819858551,
0.4034987986087799,
-0.21100541949272156,
0.8747785687446594,
0.6934971213340759,
-0.2607194781303406,
-0.02094506099820137,
0.17275850474834442,
0.3823765814304352,
0.3658381402492523,
-0.6962365508079529,
0.13405360281467438,
0.4838208556175232,
0.20590928196907043,
0.3752857744693756,
0.674375593662262,
-0.13201552629470825,
0.17057909071445465,
0.3660847842693329,
-0.4407538175582886,
-0.12694422900676727,
-0.22810563445091248,
-0.22705426812171936,
1.0742508172988892,
0.07711350172758102,
-0.7590495944023132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11349v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11349v1
|
TeClass: A Human-Annotated Relevance-based Headline Classification and Generation Dataset for Telugu
| 2024-04-17T13:07:56 | 2024-04-17T13:07:56 |
Gopichand Kanumolu, Lokesh Madasu, Nirmal Surange, Manish Shrivastava
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
News headline generation is a crucial task in increasing productivity for
both the readers and producers of news. This task can easily be aided by
automated News headline-generation models. However, the presence of irrelevant
headlines in scraped news articles results in sub-optimal performance of
generation models. We propose that relevance-based headline classification can
greatly aid the task of generating relevant headlines. Relevance-based headline
classification involves categorizing news headlines based on their relevance to
the corresponding news articles. While this task is well-established in
English, it remains under-explored in low-resource languages like Telugu due to
a lack of annotated data. To address this gap, we present TeClass, the
first-ever human-annotated Telugu news headline classification dataset,
containing 78,534 annotations across 26,178 article-headline pairs. We
experiment with various baseline models and provide a comprehensive analysis of
their results. We further demonstrate the impact of this work by fine-tuning
various headline generation models using TeClass dataset. The headlines
generated by the models fine-tuned on highly relevant article-headline pairs,
showed about a 5 point increment in the ROUGE-L scores. To encourage future
research, the annotated dataset as well as the annotation guidelines will be
made publicly available.
|
[
-0.043624214828014374,
-0.608944296836853,
0.3481172025203705,
0.10988806933164597,
-0.5592426657676697,
0.14710620045661926,
-0.12999218702316284,
-0.466633677482605,
0.2995598316192627,
0.19002380967140198,
-0.11305194348096848,
-0.4768872559070587,
-0.41743162274360657,
0.08406290411949158,
-0.6800736784934998,
0.9697439670562744,
0.4382043182849884,
-0.24481093883514404,
0.08027235418558121,
0.16866442561149597,
-0.49156829714775085,
-0.09305548667907715,
-0.7189560532569885,
-0.02441098541021347,
0.636144757270813,
0.5715808868408203,
0.751422107219696,
0.7450599670410156,
0.31640347838401794,
0.1804526299238205,
-0.09235068410634995,
0.2673783600330353,
-0.34149882197380066,
-0.02946150116622448,
-0.34979012608528137,
-0.2512776255607605,
-0.32751592993736267,
0.03412957116961479,
0.9050055146217346,
0.6489880084991455,
-0.08041749149560928,
0.44291210174560547,
0.24313829839229584,
0.4114876389503479,
-0.586635410785675,
-0.005717315245419741,
-0.6006625890731812,
-0.16317835450172424,
-0.7450366020202637,
-0.45156651735305786,
-0.5175877213478088,
-0.6229958534240723,
-0.18026965856552124,
-0.5293750762939453,
0.3060617744922638,
0.07370059937238693,
1.330816626548767,
0.27627915143966675,
-0.6950995326042175,
0.1873803436756134,
-0.6310641765594482,
0.5811702609062195,
-0.28291380405426025,
0.22363854944705963,
0.5016818642616272,
0.38320282101631165,
0.05091789737343788,
-0.5388280153274536,
-0.24398085474967957,
0.12129037827253342,
-0.14067940413951874,
0.10929537564516068,
0.15291550755500793,
-0.08160486072301865,
-0.026471080258488655,
0.4833565652370453,
-0.3754810392856598,
0.22436019778251648,
-0.8077207803726196,
-0.4282756745815277,
0.5124887228012085,
0.15820272266864777,
0.36337003111839294,
-0.5109984874725342,
-0.23870614171028137,
0.3279073238372803,
-0.7352942228317261,
-0.0775742456316948,
0.35520923137664795,
0.5948861241340637,
-0.2173393815755844,
0.5808349847793579,
-0.4015378952026367,
1.0761070251464844,
-0.0013227821327745914,
-0.4533122777938843,
0.28390082716941833,
-0.24608945846557617,
0.07890107482671738,
0.47836431860923767,
0.5731514096260071,
0.6163056492805481,
-0.00466119172051549,
-0.17888304591178894,
-0.08542521297931671,
0.25171613693237305,
0.6088584065437317,
-0.5692006349563599,
0.44388923048973083,
0.07841701805591583,
-0.096329465508461,
-0.6788584589958191,
0.10432791709899902,
-0.8261603713035583,
-0.24669930338859558,
-0.2839242219924927,
0.34004324674606323,
-0.30009156465530396,
-0.3300515413284302,
-0.2525198757648468,
0.0012743681436404586,
0.466132789850235,
0.4881020486354828,
-0.7595803141593933,
-0.1586381196975708,
0.6664314270019531,
0.806275486946106,
-0.3049792945384979,
-0.4340016841888428,
-0.5372127890586853,
0.3001942038536072,
-0.5111696124076843,
1.0290043354034424,
-0.46526604890823364,
0.20082734525203705,
0.057499032467603683,
-0.3760643005371094,
0.05584920570254326,
-0.339306503534317,
0.8638562560081482,
-0.6480277180671692,
0.23119550943374634,
0.012001626193523407,
-0.6107710599899292,
-0.036771513521671295,
0.13407154381275177,
-0.4752380847930908,
0.8780896067619324,
0.5832483172416687,
-0.8202077150344849,
0.7384030222892761,
-0.5245581269264221,
-0.887589156627655,
0.3558787405490875,
-0.002170991152524948,
-0.42103683948516846,
0.18446747958660126,
0.019309217110276222,
0.4264736473560333,
-0.48128780722618103,
0.6591344475746155,
0.17027786374092102,
-0.46974673867225647,
-0.10596735030412674,
-0.103116475045681,
0.49914678931236267,
0.5578913688659668,
-0.05245114117860794,
-0.09665434807538986,
-0.7148592472076416,
-0.06961457431316376,
-0.13148050010204315,
-0.5245980024337769,
-0.26220640540122986,
-0.3675519526004791,
0.35388264060020447,
0.020090293139219284,
0.046044643968343735,
-0.5790144801139832,
-0.1978866159915924,
-0.23007138073444366,
0.16974124312400818,
0.5348097681999207,
0.18498465418815613,
0.522234320640564,
-0.5300371646881104,
0.3479282557964325,
0.28277578949928284,
-0.0014146157773211598,
-0.5102638006210327,
-0.5752195715904236,
-0.5305025577545166,
0.1519969254732132,
0.736031711101532,
0.386415034532547,
-0.7988041043281555,
0.2489272654056549,
-0.26821860671043396,
-0.7110040187835693,
-0.6215182542800903,
-0.2567550539970398,
0.2698206305503845,
0.9735944867134094,
0.4458654224872589,
-0.03676160052418709,
-0.6112480163574219,
-1.0290734767913818,
-0.6021428108215332,
-0.060470275580883026,
0.14301951229572296,
-0.1176401823759079,
-0.007933296263217926,
0.0035036855842918158,
1.1919736862182617,
-0.5279573798179626,
-0.5152845978736877,
-0.2868768572807312,
0.11225280165672302,
0.16927000880241394,
0.30789899826049805,
0.5979843735694885,
-1.1634689569473267,
-0.4600294828414917,
-0.11788906902074814,
-0.9071348905563354,
-0.31421375274658203,
-0.11930873990058899,
-0.11913206428289413,
0.508579432964325,
0.27978578209877014,
-0.34868812561035156,
0.5704725980758667,
-0.10598674416542053,
-0.6044104099273682,
0.49392667412757874,
0.0577227920293808,
0.3454294800758362,
-1.3447164297103882,
-0.11303337663412094,
0.39544233679771423,
-0.3880669176578522,
-0.782291829586029,
0.014037325978279114,
0.15853753685951233,
-0.2932107746601105,
-0.5433747172355652,
0.739327073097229,
-0.13379819691181183,
-0.15747395157814026,
-0.3738744854927063,
-0.06102640554308891,
-0.09924879670143127,
0.17036236822605133,
0.2812861204147339,
0.7411770820617676,
0.7028042078018188,
-0.8810381293296814,
-0.013070106506347656,
-0.01863381825387478,
-0.289353609085083,
0.47930780053138733,
-0.3105695843696594,
-0.3401324450969696,
-0.30176201462745667,
-0.31887900829315186,
-0.7612556219100952,
-0.7257625460624695,
0.1599309742450714,
-0.5597085952758789,
0.35056012868881226,
-0.13952086865901947,
-0.6128883957862854,
-0.07640501856803894,
-0.1742333024740219,
0.07519381493330002,
0.5639386773109436,
-0.35961735248565674,
0.3833840489387512,
0.782118022441864,
0.024824677035212517,
-0.40094122290611267,
-0.47380855679512024,
0.1818542629480362,
-0.49787694215774536,
-0.26195329427719116,
0.4033365547657013,
0.357880562543869,
-0.13768793642520905,
0.00928825419396162,
-0.17159761488437653,
-0.1152796819806099,
0.04925336688756943,
0.1742054522037506,
0.23598919808864594,
-0.2346908003091812,
0.3164009749889374,
0.47310248017311096,
-0.2754265069961548,
-0.20007088780403137,
-0.15298639237880707,
0.41339799761772156,
-0.18609125912189484,
0.24123740196228027,
-0.37076401710510254,
0.029579631984233856,
0.42958125472068787,
-0.14224395155906677,
0.7625221610069275,
0.8057241439819336,
-0.6363851428031921,
0.025657309219241142,
-0.5379490852355957,
-0.077324777841568,
-0.41478270292282104,
0.31665003299713135,
-0.27257856726646423,
-0.5767247080802917,
0.08419300615787506,
-0.09124112874269485,
0.023089608177542686,
0.77579665184021,
0.3594519793987274,
-0.0031354078091681004,
0.2969192564487457,
0.545129120349884,
-0.08494807779788971,
0.47168871760368347,
0.02566169574856758,
-0.2558386027812958,
-0.462863951921463,
-0.17704132199287415,
-0.36668911576271057,
-0.260947048664093,
-0.4926683008670807,
-0.06001237779855728,
0.3610069155693054,
-0.19674238562583923,
-0.2114294022321701,
0.5100622773170471,
-0.6605716347694397,
0.8055670261383057,
0.49844232201576233,
0.3098204433917999,
0.5147449374198914,
0.34311363101005554,
0.27465981245040894,
-0.17072837054729462,
-0.543178141117096,
-0.5062975287437439,
1.1938546895980835,
-0.07589466869831085,
0.5558348894119263,
0.11737671494483948,
0.7993206977844238,
0.7734611630439758,
0.41100797057151794,
-0.47201889753341675,
0.6888355612754822,
-0.05107302591204643,
-0.5400035381317139,
-0.34213295578956604,
-0.6015956997871399,
-1.1069189310073853,
0.09027739614248276,
-0.21093715727329254,
-0.531181275844574,
-0.007552637252956629,
-0.1625022143125534,
-0.5369859337806702,
0.32059431076049805,
-0.9035659432411194,
0.6492120623588562,
-0.010495583526790142,
-0.5969481468200684,
-0.2855904996395111,
-0.6729796528816223,
0.3891984224319458,
-0.4493492543697357,
0.2963930368423462,
-0.20017576217651367,
-0.3540685772895813,
0.7682502865791321,
-0.2619461119174957,
0.7607825398445129,
-0.05789109691977501,
-0.007743427064269781,
0.5384407639503479,
-0.149677112698555,
-0.2064189314842224,
0.28921565413475037,
-0.3764249086380005,
0.11076508462429047,
-0.6784588694572449,
-0.4297066628932953,
-0.06185663118958473,
0.6752368807792664,
-0.8044116497039795,
-0.6628522276878357,
-0.7013379335403442,
-0.4572012722492218,
-0.02864697016775608,
0.426327109336853,
0.6577213406562805,
0.5136423110961914,
0.255596786737442,
-0.07548945397138596,
0.3019458055496216,
-0.055196363478899,
0.5491573810577393,
0.4905089735984802,
-0.3008851408958435,
-0.19180011749267578,
1.1449334621429443,
0.42570391297340393,
-0.08815956115722656,
0.5107583403587341,
0.2366458922624588,
-0.2623004913330078,
-0.4292525053024292,
-0.6540516018867493,
0.12073882669210434,
-0.46689754724502563,
-0.5725842714309692,
-0.4298318028450012,
-0.4375728368759155,
-0.31147730350494385,
-0.13241244852542877,
-0.25102725625038147,
-0.5947889685630798,
-0.3398508131504059,
-0.03927558287978172,
0.3150545060634613,
0.7445271611213684,
0.009948528371751308,
0.1933305710554123,
-0.8072690367698669,
0.6448163390159607,
0.12654677033424377,
0.526550829410553,
-0.2472521960735321,
-0.9215282201766968,
-0.38814616203308105,
0.025150606408715248,
-0.694344162940979,
-1.0945464372634888,
0.2950327396392822,
0.4178730547428131,
0.3771314322948456,
0.32868319749832153,
0.37120917439460754,
0.3522304594516754,
-0.15576545894145966,
0.5990638732910156,
-0.01596585102379322,
-0.7153111100196838,
1.2283269166946411,
-0.6494327783584595,
0.25149843096733093,
0.44389504194259644,
0.6243212223052979,
-0.10058069229125977,
-0.5438182950019836,
-0.7566192150115967,
-0.8676818609237671,
1.135462760925293,
0.33692067861557007,
0.040731072425842285,
-0.14534534513950348,
0.7127113938331604,
0.29857730865478516,
0.251583993434906,
-0.6367968320846558,
-0.34728026390075684,
-0.1769534945487976,
0.001611063489690423,
0.05072961002588272,
-0.2715245485305786,
0.5466163158416748,
-0.4220428764820099,
0.7751736640930176,
0.08158678561449051,
0.00034089855034835637,
0.09851144254207611,
-0.31977811455726624,
-0.25756901502609253,
0.394832581281662,
0.6443992257118225,
0.7685033679008484,
-0.1959075927734375,
-0.0359768383204937,
0.16104207932949066,
-0.6834260821342468,
0.2425883561372757,
0.1706697642803192,
-0.6667304635047913,
0.2465435117483139,
0.020945440977811813,
0.5527013540267944,
0.2714119851589203,
-0.42284920811653137,
0.16433250904083252,
0.06395968049764633,
0.47608447074890137,
-0.4135931730270386,
0.2566552460193634,
-0.1627853363752365,
0.026016462594270706,
0.8303682804107666,
0.21465206146240234,
0.28887510299682617,
-0.7673752307891846,
0.3146030306816101,
-0.240442156791687,
-0.17158427834510803,
-0.2785108685493469,
0.9878145456314087,
0.15515364706516266,
-0.44851091504096985,
0.6157260537147522,
-0.4487208127975464,
-0.3423931896686554,
0.6081279516220093,
0.5100129246711731,
0.6156172156333923,
-0.5685762763023376,
0.4288251996040344,
0.8606980443000793,
0.1937318742275238,
-0.19079749286174774,
0.09879357367753983,
0.16390809416770935,
-0.48504969477653503,
-0.31930023431777954,
-0.9485284686088562,
-0.42155590653419495,
0.09097829461097717,
-0.6145703196525574,
0.8066457509994507,
-0.12420020997524261,
-0.4166262745857239,
0.29881563782691956,
-0.024453649297356606,
-0.14219625294208527,
0.25951582193374634,
0.2919253408908844,
0.7279996275901794,
-0.8067502975463867,
0.8415245413780212,
1.2149083614349365,
-0.5096460580825806,
-0.5098698735237122,
0.21280841529369354,
-0.18181473016738892,
-0.37379300594329834,
0.42648571729660034,
0.4545325040817261,
0.35033512115478516,
0.2810194492340088,
-0.06908413767814636,
-0.6133993268013,
1.050494909286499,
0.7292617559432983,
-0.15935905277729034,
-0.24007759988307953,
0.6876257658004761,
0.603151261806488,
-0.3340783417224884,
0.15805386006832123,
0.46943116188049316,
0.5112729668617249,
0.11565804481506348,
-0.963720440864563,
-0.12994125485420227,
-0.38867321610450745,
-0.04797178506851196,
0.3944721817970276,
-0.9734819531440735,
0.7447995543479919,
-0.5161272883415222,
-0.2577771842479706,
-0.2137439101934433,
0.8386294841766357,
0.15403838455677032,
0.6948158144950867,
0.2640526592731476,
0.6144195795059204,
0.6534570455551147,
-0.43855440616607666,
1.0933598279953003,
-0.2582528293132782,
0.2972302734851837,
1.083364725112915,
-0.06665024906396866,
0.6414670348167419,
0.11108334362506866,
-0.09276590496301651,
0.334261417388916,
0.8079178333282471,
0.03520769625902176,
0.48134931921958923,
-0.0301662664860487,
-0.14694873988628387,
-0.43959560990333557,
-0.5303891897201538,
-0.5447432398796082,
0.590492844581604,
0.423187792301178,
-0.2291989028453827,
-0.7387946844100952,
0.17053315043449402,
-0.0025964498054236174,
0.16749335825443268,
-0.7547467350959778,
0.7451888918876648,
0.03842005506157875,
-0.9312359094619751,
0.4493003189563751,
0.10039560496807098,
0.5377652645111084,
-0.4267171621322632,
-0.011706535704433918,
-0.3897339105606079,
0.16323412954807281,
-0.4620733857154846,
-1.1318256855010986,
0.6579927206039429,
0.1419307142496109,
-0.1305740475654602,
-0.054081741720438004,
1.1179563999176025,
-0.5447578430175781,
-0.4509594142436981,
-0.21394047141075134,
0.4324798285961151,
0.19083668291568756,
-0.29994261264801025,
-0.06588034331798553,
-0.07034272700548172,
-0.2539602816104889,
-0.1779046207666397,
0.6465285420417786,
0.32658499479293823,
-0.18111665546894073,
0.48222580552101135,
0.30330660939216614,
-0.09819003939628601,
-0.02158314548432827,
-0.22795110940933228,
0.7983779311180115,
-0.836240291595459,
-0.753836452960968,
-0.825244665145874,
0.43805643916130066,
-0.1056721955537796,
-0.3853585422039032,
0.7406334280967712,
1.1660230159759521,
0.48721015453338623,
-0.1753048151731491,
0.6150928139686584,
-0.1622660607099533,
0.6186707615852356,
-0.2661803960800171,
0.8835263848304749,
-0.7770676016807556,
0.32307231426239014,
-0.07199372351169586,
-0.941076397895813,
-0.2927742302417755,
0.19579100608825684,
-0.1452256590127945,
0.13439154624938965,
0.38529422879219055,
0.48537594079971313,
-0.14541424810886383,
0.25364065170288086,
0.3330218493938446,
0.03981913626194,
-0.28825822472572327,
0.45908984541893005,
0.7741906642913818,
-0.6607459783554077,
0.5675844550132751,
-0.41194263100624084,
-0.048205889761447906,
-0.3282904326915741,
-0.7941994071006775,
-0.8885429501533508,
-0.8846642374992371,
-0.5993511080741882,
-0.3973873555660248,
0.16986888647079468,
0.8214242458343506,
0.526386559009552,
-0.640964925289154,
-0.1480511724948883,
0.13470719754695892,
0.3605256676673889,
-0.010365541093051434,
-0.343539297580719,
0.5764415264129639,
-0.613739550113678,
-0.6997035145759583,
0.0722457766532898,
0.1450902670621872,
-0.018880566582083702,
0.2559901475906372,
0.12983785569667816,
-0.23669497668743134,
-0.2515046298503876,
0.6281319260597229,
0.3027527332305908,
-0.4208526015281677,
-0.09925953298807144,
-0.25446760654449463,
-0.19112378358840942,
0.3104083836078644,
0.529666006565094,
-1.1835980415344238,
0.04160691052675247,
0.2739814221858978,
0.5266324281692505,
0.31481438875198364,
0.0373261496424675,
0.06897535175085068,
-1.1008312702178955,
0.1325983703136444,
0.1495121419429779,
0.32175973057746887,
0.3087873160839081,
-0.6283291578292847,
0.9077383279800415,
0.3791668713092804,
-0.3450423777103424,
-1.0069090127944946,
-0.05668764188885689,
-1.015917420387268,
0.08478181809186935,
1.2170841693878174,
0.29402604699134827,
-0.3855745196342468,
-0.41484636068344116,
-0.15978819131851196,
0.5258942246437073,
-0.6186491847038269,
0.9667836427688599,
0.299431711435318,
0.24052266776561737,
-0.3009411692619324,
-0.35755088925361633,
0.4484280049800873,
0.03161582350730896,
-1.1651033163070679,
-0.009087922982871532,
0.2626870274543762,
0.12543433904647827,
0.31182053685188293,
0.5136030316352844,
-0.13214172422885895,
0.7567700743675232,
-0.09537285566329956,
-0.2236187607049942,
-0.29323625564575195,
-0.5362759232521057,
-0.0010930642019957304,
0.41734981536865234,
-0.12921009957790375,
0.036623239517211914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11315v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11315v1
|
To Drop or Not to Drop? Predicting Argument Ellipsis Judgments: A Case Study in Japanese
| 2024-04-17T12:26:52 | 2024-04-17T12:26:52 |
Yukiko Ishizuki, Tatsuki Kuribayashi, Yuichiroh Matsubayashi, Ryohei Sasano, Kentaro Inui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Speakers sometimes omit certain arguments of a predicate in a sentence; such
omission is especially frequent in pro-drop languages. This study addresses a
question about ellipsis -- what can explain the native speakers' ellipsis
decisions? -- motivated by the interest in human discourse processing and
writing assistance for this choice. To this end, we first collect large-scale
human annotations of whether and why a particular argument should be omitted
across over 2,000 data points in the balanced corpus of Japanese, a
prototypical pro-drop language. The data indicate that native speakers overall
share common criteria for such judgments and further clarify their quantitative
characteristics, e.g., the distribution of related linguistic factors in the
balanced corpus. Furthermore, the performance of the language model-based
argument ellipsis judgment model is examined, and the gap between the systems'
prediction and human judgments in specific linguistic aspects is revealed. We
hope our fundamental resource encourages further studies on natural human
ellipsis judgment.
|
[
-0.8372052311897278,
-0.9907768368721008,
0.47108736634254456,
-0.055783119052648544,
-0.34287405014038086,
-0.05911441892385483,
-0.10401894897222519,
-0.8323020935058594,
0.3000754714012146,
0.49294519424438477,
-0.6783758401870728,
-0.41537901759147644,
-0.442069947719574,
0.4709767997264862,
-0.27567431330680847,
1.0903440713882446,
-0.009644614532589912,
-0.14472852647304535,
-0.17872534692287445,
-0.058468542993068695,
-0.5757095217704773,
-0.4992242157459259,
-0.6441829800605774,
-0.22158096730709076,
0.5399107933044434,
0.5668315291404724,
0.7819986939430237,
0.6050397753715515,
0.4130997061729431,
0.28234946727752686,
-0.13205623626708984,
-0.24478627741336823,
0.1370490938425064,
-0.2693996727466583,
-0.2020895779132843,
-0.7604653239250183,
-0.11996488273143768,
0.15616163611412048,
0.2182733714580536,
1.1014152765274048,
-0.10196178406476974,
0.037929583340883255,
-0.21685004234313965,
0.5369726419448853,
-0.8419660329818726,
-0.26132580637931824,
-0.41666242480278015,
0.30455222725868225,
-0.7091366052627563,
0.021389752626419067,
-0.3346768021583557,
-0.29177552461624146,
0.5506163835525513,
-0.6838235259056091,
0.30980995297431946,
0.1402379423379898,
0.888270378112793,
0.11957745254039764,
-0.24871419370174408,
-0.19753673672676086,
-0.5102631449699402,
0.47141289710998535,
-0.377420574426651,
0.05004313588142395,
0.7160628437995911,
0.15762118995189667,
0.08349557220935822,
-0.2500056326389313,
-0.42638257145881653,
-0.43978095054626465,
-0.06534779816865921,
0.3019769489765167,
0.23444630205631256,
0.4676744043827057,
0.4415103495121002,
0.2501125931739807,
-0.314804345369339,
0.27482110261917114,
-0.3598650097846985,
-0.273000568151474,
0.32078033685684204,
0.044030774384737015,
0.44393110275268555,
-0.6958141922950745,
-0.12897732853889465,
0.35181090235710144,
-0.9797704815864563,
0.15547479689121246,
0.5801751017570496,
0.23899485170841217,
-0.02518163062632084,
0.4839515686035156,
-0.09725602716207504,
0.5607092976570129,
-0.11780035495758057,
0.2124432623386383,
-0.023406174033880234,
-0.07688955217599869,
0.10655317455530167,
0.10671287775039673,
0.8360399603843689,
0.5734758973121643,
0.4203151762485504,
0.2414817065000534,
0.21155063807964325,
0.19024167954921722,
0.021820906549692154,
-0.5813434720039368,
-0.4106321632862091,
-0.12409031391143799,
-0.4785735011100769,
-0.15511782467365265,
0.1652015745639801,
-0.9665346741676331,
-0.44484493136405945,
0.01714072935283184,
-0.05853928253054619,
-0.2767541706562042,
-0.21271581947803497,
0.2373722940683365,
-0.31294015049934387,
-0.2388041764497757,
0.4174117147922516,
-0.7637430429458618,
0.6331691145896912,
0.5243910551071167,
0.5778876543045044,
-0.14634737372398376,
-0.3158405125141144,
-0.31478649377822876,
-0.01858184114098549,
-0.5141919255256653,
0.7908291220664978,
-0.6354706883430481,
-0.6837432980537415,
0.07962506264448166,
-0.09572862088680267,
0.033258263021707535,
-0.6883541345596313,
1.1328027248382568,
0.07274823635816574,
0.5133092999458313,
-0.45771703124046326,
-0.6569728255271912,
-0.5038214921951294,
-0.26849231123924255,
-0.5646325349807739,
0.469562828540802,
-0.31374889612197876,
-0.8360369801521301,
0.7820475697517395,
-0.5846379995346069,
-0.750704288482666,
0.48156288266181946,
-0.3495314419269562,
-0.39929836988449097,
0.09630517661571503,
0.11624101549386978,
0.14080771803855896,
-0.40692657232284546,
0.1267671436071396,
-0.519616425037384,
-0.10897427797317505,
0.17325833439826965,
-0.4025847315788269,
0.7136335372924805,
0.10081668943166733,
-0.31897100806236267,
-0.5266590118408203,
-0.644905686378479,
-0.29674792289733887,
0.14338348805904388,
-0.23640751838684082,
-0.6788567304611206,
0.5557332038879395,
0.04523203521966934,
-0.011142500676214695,
0.006097909063100815,
-0.7595287561416626,
0.06507938355207443,
-0.6665124893188477,
0.4879991412162781,
0.32902804017066956,
0.2656872570514679,
0.3024234175682068,
0.02511705830693245,
0.6840742826461792,
-0.15384234488010406,
0.39265963435173035,
-0.2679077386856079,
-0.795665442943573,
-0.7893510460853577,
-0.06571276485919952,
0.24426889419555664,
0.6358909606933594,
-0.39762407541275024,
0.2335839718580246,
0.18658125400543213,
-0.04192207381129265,
-0.6631543040275574,
-0.21026010811328888,
0.6556124091148376,
0.6598196029663086,
0.08408606797456741,
-0.06699015200138092,
-0.9251862168312073,
-1.1724541187286377,
-0.5016770958900452,
-0.5467580556869507,
0.16829434037208557,
0.10185886174440384,
0.46622395515441895,
0.2726042866706848,
1.2861946821212769,
-0.4091838300228119,
-0.12273873388767242,
-0.23252272605895996,
0.3191491663455963,
0.21818764507770538,
0.1294470727443695,
0.8045315742492676,
-0.7588987350463867,
-0.21690769493579865,
0.1404716521501541,
-0.5377345085144043,
-0.2691127359867096,
-0.1446230560541153,
0.010417438112199306,
0.311448872089386,
0.3020463287830353,
-0.8986178040504456,
0.9053763151168823,
-0.08011414855718613,
-0.27938902378082275,
0.7718725800514221,
-0.013239381834864616,
-0.06701553612947464,
-0.9028509259223938,
0.10207877308130264,
0.2716969847679138,
-0.24714739620685577,
-0.538125216960907,
-0.23001866042613983,
-0.10358645021915436,
0.18606700003147125,
-0.4594964385032654,
0.4835522174835205,
-0.033312804996967316,
0.024576811119914055,
-0.13514460623264313,
0.2054215967655182,
0.14908182621002197,
0.14801904559135437,
0.42489126324653625,
0.23044395446777344,
0.1323527991771698,
-0.8011528253555298,
-0.19576941430568695,
0.22855015099048615,
-0.5370211005210876,
0.5207028985023499,
-0.6072421073913574,
-0.08346767723560333,
-0.15330009162425995,
0.05490767955780029,
-0.8779937028884888,
-0.213441401720047,
0.3918686807155609,
-0.3846745491027832,
-0.19723714888095856,
-0.33284634351730347,
-0.2439223825931549,
-0.6323570609092712,
-0.3472301661968231,
-0.07341588288545609,
0.12895037233829498,
-0.3632147014141083,
0.04151764512062073,
0.5130681395530701,
-0.44647273421287537,
-0.6835467219352722,
-0.7133110761642456,
0.20415547490119934,
-0.32532113790512085,
0.07886940240859985,
0.4462989270687103,
-0.18562044203281403,
-0.39701882004737854,
0.06638617813587189,
0.3341767489910126,
0.053147464990615845,
0.40288516879081726,
0.43806689977645874,
0.3750331699848175,
0.05695220082998276,
0.034318018704652786,
0.11872828006744385,
-0.2825329899787903,
0.3088800311088562,
0.22360841929912567,
0.14977288246154785,
0.07671733945608139,
-0.38022753596305847,
-0.6618767380714417,
0.40429624915122986,
0.350911408662796,
0.20309996604919434,
0.45931464433670044,
-0.04884406551718712,
-0.409757137298584,
0.1270739734172821,
-0.4185284674167633,
0.04124774783849716,
-0.37926027178764343,
0.6847478747367859,
-0.5394907593727112,
-0.4787120819091797,
0.6064791679382324,
0.26576533913612366,
0.4360170364379883,
0.5708889365196228,
0.32818031311035156,
-0.4193693995475769,
1.1479586362838745,
0.3064751625061035,
-0.12444103509187698,
0.604158341884613,
-0.13360872864723206,
0.24159415066242218,
-0.5012609362602234,
0.1079147607088089,
-0.7724156975746155,
-0.0510634109377861,
-0.5242187976837158,
0.14619414508342743,
0.04005945101380348,
0.3115953803062439,
-0.1474543958902359,
-0.01608443632721901,
-0.25835102796554565,
0.7935715913772583,
0.2382274866104126,
-0.30672818422317505,
0.2640049159526825,
-0.31295186281204224,
-0.28786319494247437,
-0.42313143610954285,
-0.35820990800857544,
-0.5696009397506714,
0.5676213502883911,
0.3389250636100769,
0.029195411130785942,
-0.051949791610240936,
0.5422558188438416,
0.39159563183784485,
0.1435232013463974,
-0.8636519312858582,
0.7432917952537537,
-0.23130248486995697,
-0.6868727803230286,
-0.23777532577514648,
-0.3898243010044098,
-1.0567821264266968,
0.3459969162940979,
-0.11297975480556488,
-0.7079406976699829,
-0.05110415816307068,
-0.0026358249597251415,
-0.5022103190422058,
0.09159142524003983,
-0.6485971808433533,
0.8939488530158997,
-0.2451901137828827,
0.1208144798874855,
-0.23632730543613434,
-0.516746461391449,
0.3252139389514923,
0.14866049587726593,
0.5638746619224548,
-0.25651028752326965,
-0.14451727271080017,
1.0327810049057007,
-0.6695188283920288,
0.8284264206886292,
-0.43759727478027344,
0.2431955486536026,
0.6884478330612183,
0.3515643775463104,
0.010891507379710674,
0.16272595524787903,
-0.18550510704517365,
0.07278745621442795,
-0.07156956195831299,
0.09055519849061966,
-0.5611034631729126,
0.04380130395293236,
-0.9384832382202148,
-0.6761948466300964,
-0.12665414810180664,
0.12426891177892685,
0.09164305776357651,
0.09198740869760513,
0.702477753162384,
0.278128981590271,
-0.43675917387008667,
-0.1324540227651596,
-0.05967474728822708,
-0.27470842003822327,
0.7587062120437622,
0.6042947769165039,
-0.6163649559020996,
-0.7189158201217651,
0.7605258822441101,
0.5315603613853455,
0.01794792339205742,
0.5045182108879089,
0.7040950059890747,
-0.5758106112480164,
-0.6825997233390808,
-0.4941202700138092,
0.29409167170524597,
-0.7360507845878601,
0.13069401681423187,
-0.36345425248146057,
0.05419762805104256,
-0.018581876531243324,
-0.10322435200214386,
-0.32835128903388977,
-0.7598161101341248,
-0.14588923752307892,
-0.5175184011459351,
0.29436033964157104,
0.8946170210838318,
0.358853280544281,
0.19286105036735535,
-0.7374800443649292,
0.16656242311000824,
0.028296783566474915,
0.10786569863557816,
-0.07565581798553467,
-0.46064090728759766,
-0.1765117198228836,
-0.08108706772327423,
-0.3802364468574524,
-0.9123855233192444,
0.3376483619213104,
0.3091295659542084,
0.6167671084403992,
0.7041335105895996,
0.3223714828491211,
0.8892593383789062,
-0.39081352949142456,
0.8229494690895081,
0.3501364290714264,
-1.0483543872833252,
0.8537688255310059,
-0.6144528985023499,
0.22423751652240753,
0.6616317629814148,
0.34479790925979614,
-0.7749823331832886,
-0.5009375214576721,
-0.6083163619041443,
-0.8010331392288208,
0.6851791143417358,
-0.1656506210565567,
-0.3015861511230469,
-0.4859207272529602,
0.6025291681289673,
0.4922194480895996,
0.23581944406032562,
-0.8120221495628357,
-0.17166157066822052,
0.06649378687143326,
-0.09624968469142914,
-0.09856396168470383,
-0.0015133748529478908,
0.24839238822460175,
-0.28931793570518494,
0.2194904088973999,
0.011095996014773846,
-0.23429055511951447,
0.06158309429883957,
-0.27778738737106323,
-0.2585546374320984,
0.06200551986694336,
0.5511066317558289,
0.5603629946708679,
0.006089915055781603,
-0.057456981390714645,
0.15362289547920227,
-0.5195258259773254,
-0.09963888674974442,
-0.3216283321380615,
-0.7162330746650696,
0.2003742754459381,
0.4092654883861542,
0.9803284406661987,
0.36789605021476746,
-0.6764460206031799,
0.35148149728775024,
-0.044141851365566254,
-0.39679816365242004,
-0.45852822065353394,
-0.35322079062461853,
-0.06454858183860779,
-0.5584595799446106,
0.33904629945755005,
0.3136046826839447,
0.3424389660358429,
-0.5265530347824097,
0.026140928268432617,
0.12357374280691147,
-0.022319981828331947,
-0.7447449564933777,
0.47678619623184204,
0.5012105703353882,
-0.4530484676361084,
0.6361189484596252,
-0.1838647872209549,
-0.7003234624862671,
0.6919443011283875,
0.205984964966774,
0.8707561492919922,
-0.10189743340015411,
0.545353353023529,
0.32861801981925964,
0.1275753527879715,
-0.08236708492040634,
0.169002503156662,
0.050151754170656204,
-0.7589938044548035,
-0.5161548256874084,
-0.3760618567466736,
-0.6480908393859863,
0.0016826008213683963,
-0.6744559407234192,
0.48659271001815796,
-0.862393856048584,
-0.5461037755012512,
0.135918989777565,
0.1818368285894394,
-0.4155184328556061,
-0.08061729371547699,
0.49613985419273376,
0.4696006178855896,
-1.097657322883606,
0.42779096961021423,
0.7322449088096619,
-0.5143924951553345,
-0.3493176996707916,
-0.040675461292266846,
0.1467411071062088,
-0.09479566663503647,
0.4972134232521057,
0.3756576478481293,
-0.1369027942419052,
-0.6713100671768188,
-0.02272687666118145,
-0.6711593866348267,
-0.012434461154043674,
0.6881240606307983,
-0.5575429797172546,
0.16472898423671722,
0.31706398725509644,
0.5618388652801514,
-0.29396864771842957,
0.7133587598800659,
0.649161696434021,
0.5124056339263916,
-0.11476260423660278,
-0.9283671975135803,
-0.2450171411037445,
-0.19044840335845947,
-0.05332165211439133,
0.5770031809806824,
-0.5735059380531311,
0.9219589829444885,
-0.38888150453567505,
-0.4057011008262634,
0.07773704826831818,
0.4147069454193115,
0.18559019267559052,
0.548035204410553,
0.4863664209842682,
0.5320535898208618,
0.7575454115867615,
0.11931435018777847,
1.1477601528167725,
-0.05636700615286827,
0.08250149339437485,
1.0357738733291626,
-0.43340975046157837,
1.3009777069091797,
0.39093294739723206,
-0.5309642553329468,
0.5536449551582336,
1.064084768295288,
0.48136448860168457,
0.5076696872711182,
0.005808835383504629,
0.01016996894031763,
-0.26411598920822144,
-0.17103178799152374,
0.16423149406909943,
0.657243549823761,
0.5973305106163025,
0.020697390660643578,
0.15861229598522186,
0.0490131676197052,
0.1618153154850006,
0.21546460688114166,
-0.36586302518844604,
0.7290459275245667,
0.024644076824188232,
-1.1669541597366333,
0.44718095660209656,
-0.1330701857805252,
0.5349492430686951,
-0.07941865175962448,
-0.023975512012839317,
-0.03824124112725258,
-0.011510685086250305,
-0.48520877957344055,
-0.888640284538269,
0.3524613678455353,
-0.044966429471969604,
-0.3131391108036041,
0.06829988211393356,
0.357066810131073,
0.11425445973873138,
-0.2813497483730316,
0.42429664731025696,
0.5531708002090454,
0.3584248423576355,
0.37932682037353516,
-0.8176756501197815,
-0.3769229054450989,
-0.05523503199219704,
-0.29711174964904785,
0.24593627452850342,
0.3794647753238678,
-0.37945908308029175,
0.6029709577560425,
0.42363619804382324,
0.3645794689655304,
0.24467317759990692,
0.5430799126625061,
0.1427602767944336,
-0.6138339638710022,
-0.6036106944084167,
-1.0980157852172852,
0.3292379081249237,
-0.18644094467163086,
-0.5579071044921875,
0.5555413961410522,
0.4477198123931885,
0.63764888048172,
0.04820479080080986,
1.0617725849151611,
-0.023292826488614082,
1.0299737453460693,
-0.32690414786338806,
0.4450497627258301,
-0.22698764503002167,
0.05215854197740555,
-0.5783304572105408,
-0.7855865359306335,
-0.2269601821899414,
0.8325434923171997,
-0.5478707551956177,
0.14378751814365387,
0.8368741869926453,
0.3034307360649109,
0.5363277196884155,
0.4399663507938385,
0.2017158418893814,
0.019285904243588448,
0.2755139470100403,
0.4990743100643158,
1.185207724571228,
-0.21308840811252594,
0.31251612305641174,
-0.338707834482193,
0.05063817650079727,
-0.3745301067829132,
-0.7347097992897034,
-0.7899292707443237,
-0.45699551701545715,
-0.6749699711799622,
0.37399107217788696,
-0.09137521684169769,
0.9881210923194885,
0.5094828009605408,
-0.6229414343833923,
-0.31627464294433594,
-0.36098867654800415,
0.35591796040534973,
-0.14025992155075073,
-0.20679399371147156,
0.1651168167591095,
-0.07706759870052338,
-0.8330816030502319,
0.2237660437822342,
0.2596026062965393,
-0.01618407666683197,
-0.07539401948451996,
-0.06158957630395889,
-0.06015023589134216,
-0.1113642081618309,
0.4226853847503662,
0.5908345580101013,
-1.002297282218933,
-0.4156307280063629,
-0.429578572511673,
0.2640663683414459,
0.1408761888742447,
0.8347826600074768,
-0.7118926048278809,
0.3920212686061859,
0.4970836937427521,
0.2402588129043579,
-0.022221896797418594,
-0.028188109397888184,
0.6617372632026672,
-0.8024832606315613,
0.37298887968063354,
0.2190490961074829,
0.6089615225791931,
0.23943999409675598,
-0.23479151725769043,
0.26117172837257385,
0.4822967052459717,
-0.34517529606819153,
-0.8697206377983093,
0.1883152276277542,
-0.5099270939826965,
-0.1608131229877472,
0.8265272378921509,
-0.17134857177734375,
-0.32351523637771606,
-0.5535265207290649,
-0.3755934536457062,
0.005737763363867998,
-0.5212134718894958,
0.7363947033882141,
0.8900537490844727,
-0.14912520349025726,
-0.5425668358802795,
-0.7162923812866211,
0.6097784042358398,
0.740081250667572,
-0.6363168358802795,
0.27800771594047546,
0.5109683871269226,
0.03369336575269699,
0.4353735148906708,
0.4580293297767639,
0.19221006333827972,
0.6073375344276428,
-0.09970070421695709,
0.14613385498523712,
0.22369924187660217,
-0.43168407678604126,
-0.2650584280490875,
0.47884443402290344,
0.4749913811683655,
-0.4345174729824066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11288v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11288v1
|
A Preference-driven Paradigm for Enhanced Translation with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-17T11:52:47 | 2024-04-17T11:52:47 |
Dawei Zhu, Sony Trenous, Xiaoyu Shen, Dietrich Klakow, Bill Byrne, Eva Hasler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent research has shown that large language models (LLMs) can achieve
remarkable translation performance through supervised fine-tuning (SFT) using
only a small amount of parallel data. However, SFT simply instructs the model
to imitate the reference translations at the token level, making it vulnerable
to the noise present in the references. Hence, the assistance from SFT often
reaches a plateau once the LLMs have achieved a certain level of translation
capability, and further increasing the size of parallel data does not provide
additional benefits. To overcome this plateau associated with imitation-based
SFT, we propose a preference-based approach built upon the Plackett-Luce model.
The objective is to steer LLMs towards a more nuanced understanding of
translation preferences from a holistic view, while also being more resilient
in the absence of gold translations. We further build a dataset named MAPLE to
verify the effectiveness of our approach, which includes multiple translations
of varying quality for each source sentence. Extensive experiments demonstrate
the superiority of our approach in "breaking the plateau" across diverse LLMs
and test settings. Our in-depth analysis underscores the pivotal role of
diverse translations and accurate preference scores in the success of our
approach.
|
[
-0.2454276829957962,
-0.6011705994606018,
0.7282423377037048,
0.40088558197021484,
-0.3211084008216858,
0.08646237105131149,
-0.5709443688392639,
-0.10790934413671494,
0.235843226313591,
0.9483596682548523,
-0.3080855906009674,
-0.42540818452835083,
-0.7817553281784058,
0.2779899537563324,
-0.29311999678611755,
1.1614211797714233,
-0.3229561448097229,
0.03677155822515488,
-0.012892709113657475,
-0.06540469825267792,
-0.42238950729370117,
-0.4805503189563751,
-0.35064661502838135,
-0.3038480579853058,
0.4108767509460449,
0.264506995677948,
1.0153249502182007,
0.7895455956459045,
0.5822476744651794,
0.20302745699882507,
-0.18411697447299957,
0.36001458764076233,
-0.6121816635131836,
-0.03424083814024925,
-0.0959731861948967,
-0.791121780872345,
-0.6394363045692444,
0.04176812618970871,
0.6148183941841125,
0.7269539833068848,
-0.049166999757289886,
0.008879237808287144,
0.23563764989376068,
0.8300961852073669,
-0.22677986323833466,
0.16580291092395782,
-0.8566399216651917,
0.20917846262454987,
-0.18955278396606445,
-0.38902747631073,
-0.6333862543106079,
-0.27758607268333435,
-0.016499929130077362,
-0.8079376816749573,
0.0612775981426239,
0.14641687273979187,
0.6599898934364319,
0.26691779494285583,
-0.5912351012229919,
0.13683800399303436,
-0.4857424795627594,
1.007269263267517,
-0.7217405438423157,
0.3627054989337921,
0.4368177354335785,
0.08012444525957108,
-0.3491753041744232,
-0.33989933133125305,
-0.24198514223098755,
-0.3327755331993103,
-0.06133585050702095,
0.2527538537979126,
0.1367950737476349,
0.004741146694868803,
0.10060315579175949,
0.64554363489151,
-0.5690300464630127,
0.08224017173051834,
-0.2505604028701782,
0.1339740753173828,
0.40773919224739075,
0.23360037803649902,
0.26826781034469604,
-0.11340954154729843,
-0.2614463269710541,
0.04014277830719948,
-0.7197109460830688,
0.08158790320158005,
0.1609668731689453,
0.6177915334701538,
0.09552246332168579,
0.5847015380859375,
-0.39176449179649353,
0.7415016293525696,
0.4008941352367401,
-0.08680235594511032,
0.5443965196609497,
-0.17561709880828857,
-0.20382221043109894,
-0.0073744612745940685,
0.721688449382782,
0.5391801595687866,
0.3030335605144501,
-0.44045448303222656,
-0.33833760023117065,
0.06400877982378006,
0.20804107189178467,
-0.7882125973701477,
-0.0171209704130888,
0.24484169483184814,
-0.45056867599487305,
-0.28979116678237915,
-0.20150437951087952,
-0.5348729491233826,
-0.41106048226356506,
-0.6947400569915771,
0.30654504895210266,
-0.4810951054096222,
-0.3107417821884155,
0.4031093716621399,
0.17538563907146454,
-0.005702640861272812,
0.4123559892177582,
-1.0860846042633057,
0.1860426962375641,
0.8280612826347351,
1.0655949115753174,
-0.6430282592773438,
-0.4227263033390045,
-0.7648417353630066,
0.2711706757545471,
-0.5238201022148132,
0.7676646709442139,
-0.5639744997024536,
-0.5065694451332092,
-0.18171770870685577,
-0.033755164593458176,
0.11967223137617111,
-0.7693782448768616,
0.5336036682128906,
-0.4448889195919037,
-0.1729206144809723,
-0.4300825595855713,
-0.48594844341278076,
0.08498837798833847,
0.29872769117355347,
-0.517005980014801,
0.819060742855072,
0.24916350841522217,
-0.42865249514579773,
0.616622269153595,
-0.5886049270629883,
-0.5188220739364624,
0.052699945867061615,
-0.03545624017715454,
-0.03410114720463753,
0.4505681097507477,
0.34809067845344543,
0.4145064353942871,
-0.38132768869400024,
0.5234594941139221,
-0.3649689555168152,
-0.2898707985877991,
0.1376810371875763,
-0.298168420791626,
0.513888955116272,
0.18042108416557312,
-0.03877048194408417,
0.3718603849411011,
-0.48409029841423035,
-0.18751434981822968,
0.1199784129858017,
-0.5330550670623779,
-0.5610091686248779,
-0.2850937247276306,
0.03295671194791794,
0.2587920129299164,
0.4780758023262024,
-0.5720414519309998,
0.34974342584609985,
-0.7189488410949707,
0.5051378011703491,
0.9975295066833496,
-0.3402842879295349,
0.7029229998588562,
-0.40052253007888794,
0.4489682912826538,
0.032777924090623856,
0.36166876554489136,
0.1938754916191101,
-0.28740862011909485,
-0.6628259420394897,
-0.13661547005176544,
0.2357955425977707,
0.3915891945362091,
-0.4058898687362671,
0.33722391724586487,
-0.5233277678489685,
-0.16733284294605255,
-0.7761069536209106,
0.4192836880683899,
0.05984066426753998,
0.2524472177028656,
0.6555688977241516,
-0.396420419216156,
-0.20331723988056183,
-1.0840091705322266,
-0.39425304532051086,
0.10156018286943436,
0.006661694031208754,
0.34929290413856506,
0.17231152951717377,
-0.05305478721857071,
0.8757940530776978,
-0.475885272026062,
-0.4195750951766968,
-0.28211069107055664,
-0.04350350797176361,
0.49645453691482544,
0.4648665487766266,
0.5041038393974304,
-1.0375117063522339,
-0.9315260052680969,
0.3873361349105835,
-0.38604825735092163,
-0.11796721816062927,
-0.0488327257335186,
-0.35210758447647095,
-0.04260016605257988,
0.320455938577652,
-0.399658739566803,
0.03964740410447121,
0.7269899249076843,
-0.048009879887104034,
0.39208850264549255,
-0.23092572391033173,
0.16235101222991943,
-1.1454471349716187,
-0.08136486262083054,
-0.12638787925243378,
-0.26366710662841797,
-0.5182480812072754,
0.25058111548423767,
0.13607557117938995,
0.2608458995819092,
-0.3903510272502899,
0.3660094141960144,
-0.12102577835321426,
-0.09324683994054794,
-0.2557029724121094,
-0.026818256825208664,
0.02187495306134224,
0.3482118248939514,
0.20564262568950653,
1.0188710689544678,
0.18296578526496887,
-0.38999658823013306,
0.050845466554164886,
0.6298854351043701,
-0.31215447187423706,
0.5585606098175049,
-0.6710869669914246,
-0.010938555002212524,
-0.056856490671634674,
0.21015827357769012,
-0.7084949612617493,
-0.24137350916862488,
-0.03188728168606758,
-0.2084484100341797,
0.26589715480804443,
-0.2771017849445343,
-0.6606130003929138,
0.11736591160297394,
-0.2429441660642624,
0.18466496467590332,
0.5832568407058716,
-0.6144667863845825,
0.46409380435943604,
0.3214333951473236,
-0.30463144183158875,
-0.46160075068473816,
-0.6662295460700989,
0.2117835432291031,
-0.2761043310165405,
-0.5295441746711731,
0.5096171498298645,
-0.3755320608615875,
-0.13676385581493378,
-0.2558880150318146,
-0.07903309911489487,
0.00661562941968441,
0.06906597316265106,
0.21957094967365265,
0.25849005579948425,
-0.2311048060655594,
-0.09335572272539139,
0.1846221685409546,
-0.3002161979675293,
-0.44167473912239075,
-0.4274604320526123,
0.5688318014144897,
-0.3310115337371826,
0.016094131395220757,
-0.09810389578342438,
0.4963214695453644,
0.9086506962776184,
-0.5929170846939087,
0.7653847932815552,
0.3665880262851715,
0.15974551439285278,
-0.1140810027718544,
-0.38274550437927246,
-0.12694206833839417,
-0.457317054271698,
0.2533791661262512,
-0.5547418594360352,
-0.9873446822166443,
0.24462741613388062,
-0.33237847685813904,
0.27855557203292847,
0.35554805397987366,
0.5097233653068542,
0.14797234535217285,
1.2932952642440796,
0.5840905904769897,
-0.10927034914493561,
0.5126327872276306,
-0.0941043347120285,
0.10529542714357376,
-1.1841647624969482,
0.2942644953727722,
-0.15182948112487793,
-0.2999895513057709,
-0.5846893787384033,
-0.29885175824165344,
0.6365466713905334,
0.1345013678073883,
-0.20275120437145233,
0.38774213194847107,
-0.3837027847766876,
0.38927653431892395,
0.39996767044067383,
0.0945124477148056,
0.6647200584411621,
0.13927634060382843,
-0.17615918815135956,
-0.1868731677532196,
-0.5923795104026794,
-0.5116226673126221,
1.2359458208084106,
0.2146662026643753,
0.48218655586242676,
0.3425092101097107,
0.6429369449615479,
-0.0941043347120285,
0.5615438222885132,
-0.7683398127555847,
0.4439237117767334,
-0.7013141512870789,
-0.46966299414634705,
-0.2767844498157501,
-0.45730477571487427,
-0.8688526749610901,
0.42319029569625854,
-0.16081266105175018,
-0.4687850773334503,
0.06310679018497467,
0.17525187134742737,
-0.3549993336200714,
0.03453903645277023,
-0.42155927419662476,
0.8858043551445007,
-0.471888929605484,
-0.5719749331474304,
-0.43405765295028687,
-0.45370298624038696,
0.4094513952732086,
-0.3925717771053314,
0.19918902218341827,
-0.20680435001850128,
-0.037074267864227295,
0.42818719148635864,
-0.10970350354909897,
0.7302289009094238,
0.1355852633714676,
-0.08083958923816681,
-0.3369942605495453,
0.38123854994773865,
0.6940251588821411,
-0.08991175144910812,
-0.34395474195480347,
0.13069581985473633,
0.07411715388298035,
-0.4519641101360321,
-0.5444946885108948,
0.8396545648574829,
-0.8099319934844971,
-0.6910557150840759,
-0.09882757812738419,
-0.9454489946365356,
-0.43102625012397766,
0.31720614433288574,
0.16274452209472656,
0.12740358710289001,
-0.038392435759305954,
0.3266567587852478,
0.5952357053756714,
-0.16530172526836395,
-0.142838254570961,
0.7404958605766296,
-0.5484245419502258,
-0.21957466006278992,
1.0094234943389893,
0.29574495553970337,
0.5304995775222778,
0.3997463583946228,
0.48654040694236755,
-0.21580690145492554,
-0.9538619518280029,
-0.5403344631195068,
0.21701200306415558,
-0.4284783601760864,
0.052198369055986404,
-0.6707392930984497,
0.2223135083913803,
-0.2843274474143982,
-0.4252554774284363,
-0.5568421483039856,
-0.24734751880168915,
-0.12864914536476135,
-0.0827171728014946,
0.3924502432346344,
0.4599349796772003,
0.10433870553970337,
0.3567127585411072,
-0.7351029515266418,
0.29697003960609436,
0.18865424394607544,
0.43113064765930176,
-0.20672938227653503,
-0.7900896072387695,
-0.1870601922273636,
-0.07855761051177979,
-0.19390736520290375,
-0.5100336074829102,
0.5834909081459045,
-0.03137674927711487,
0.42626088857650757,
0.06465309858322144,
0.11832108348608017,
0.6953325271606445,
-0.6416751146316528,
0.6998746395111084,
0.04859405383467674,
-0.8641958236694336,
0.40664777159690857,
-0.6458852291107178,
0.22676238417625427,
0.8815860152244568,
0.1854388415813446,
-0.553625226020813,
-0.41939347982406616,
-0.4091769754886627,
-1.077816367149353,
0.4248850643634796,
-0.0357910580933094,
0.21786212921142578,
0.06517956405878067,
0.343484491109848,
0.42741283774375916,
0.4603179395198822,
-0.5705816745758057,
0.17797788977622986,
-0.12581706047058105,
-0.18589968979358673,
-0.3960626423358917,
0.03048512525856495,
-0.09855178743600845,
-0.16829952597618103,
0.6536116003990173,
-0.33448344469070435,
-0.3547908663749695,
-0.03481859341263771,
-0.2628869116306305,
-0.13090302050113678,
0.42095884680747986,
0.35802310705184937,
0.5066890716552734,
-0.40172961354255676,
0.026387976482510567,
0.051256004720926285,
-0.18970808386802673,
0.0753972977399826,
-0.2010054737329483,
-0.5479615926742554,
-0.18663696944713593,
-0.05406130477786064,
0.8852359652519226,
0.1504446268081665,
-0.4396432340145111,
0.3863086700439453,
0.1633910834789276,
-0.03969239443540573,
-0.0017601187573745847,
-0.017072182148694992,
-0.03173867613077164,
-0.06946517527103424,
0.06084848940372467,
0.1993715763092041,
0.0646955668926239,
-0.46276646852493286,
0.1604587286710739,
0.4294617772102356,
-0.3996409773826599,
-0.258929967880249,
0.4932083189487457,
0.23993226885795593,
-0.08562908321619034,
0.23944608867168427,
0.09179260581731796,
-0.40507644414901733,
0.24007944762706757,
0.6707233190536499,
0.6735363602638245,
-0.19849315285682678,
0.26909133791923523,
0.21143221855163574,
0.30987977981567383,
-0.6710700392723083,
-0.08063023537397385,
0.08924756199121475,
-0.7932376861572266,
-0.6207121014595032,
-0.8298221826553345,
-0.3630177974700928,
0.20391513407230377,
-0.8005673289299011,
0.09266693145036697,
-0.44704538583755493,
-0.12729988992214203,
-0.11786044389009476,
-0.33950215578079224,
-0.4444162845611572,
-0.09124533087015152,
-0.282932311296463,
0.8613934516906738,
-0.8329043388366699,
0.8866567611694336,
0.5926561951637268,
-0.44934889674186707,
-0.4835682511329651,
0.2439086139202118,
-0.12140019237995148,
-0.7632034420967102,
0.5728623270988464,
-0.04717724770307541,
-0.08224482089281082,
0.33372199535369873,
-0.18659473955631256,
-0.7161175608634949,
0.762969970703125,
0.6962980628013611,
-0.6469174027442932,
0.23606793582439423,
0.13556984066963196,
0.4577797055244446,
-0.38453933596611023,
-0.20105323195457458,
0.8552916049957275,
0.6419471502304077,
-0.15109574794769287,
-1.1708911657333374,
-0.11888924241065979,
-0.02076663449406624,
0.00984310545027256,
0.40761128067970276,
-0.915675938129425,
0.8221536874771118,
0.03516640514135361,
0.13109326362609863,
0.13449937105178833,
0.3463936150074005,
0.02452429197728634,
-0.18855436146259308,
0.4716334939002991,
0.25176793336868286,
0.6685694456100464,
0.18820606172084808,
1.2456554174423218,
-0.4961862862110138,
0.2310895323753357,
1.2404053211212158,
-0.4009421169757843,
1.1683716773986816,
0.8123079538345337,
-0.211200550198555,
0.12547719478607178,
0.5416677594184875,
0.08520319312810898,
0.6279739141464233,
0.020325303077697754,
-0.095252126455307,
-0.6826521754264832,
-0.532341480255127,
-0.32965296506881714,
0.35228201746940613,
0.27068984508514404,
-0.4985390603542328,
-0.07361875474452972,
-0.033575184643268585,
-0.09521087259054184,
0.3945477604866028,
-0.33639103174209595,
0.6511731147766113,
0.19172202050685883,
-0.7734041213989258,
0.7029147744178772,
0.12895627319812775,
0.6712373495101929,
-0.7198004126548767,
0.11032722145318985,
-0.28265318274497986,
0.11174512654542923,
-0.14123421907424927,
-0.8610517978668213,
0.2535266876220703,
-0.07777027785778046,
-0.30181676149368286,
-0.6131975650787354,
0.2686915397644043,
-0.516261637210846,
-0.4754410684108734,
0.22284850478172302,
0.4562741816043854,
0.10342998802661896,
-0.15728838741779327,
-0.48551100492477417,
0.10543446242809296,
0.05617325380444527,
-0.18884089589118958,
0.7413154244422913,
0.17272667586803436,
-0.08256348222494125,
0.3574366569519043,
0.8122247457504272,
0.3157900273799896,
-0.19742104411125183,
-0.08517666161060333,
0.6311596632003784,
-0.2875542640686035,
-0.6709092855453491,
-0.844448983669281,
0.35910874605178833,
-0.0916302278637886,
-0.3764982521533966,
0.8822711706161499,
0.6637957692146301,
0.6825848817825317,
-0.06918590515851974,
1.0400055646896362,
0.38146886229515076,
0.3984825015068054,
-0.5945584774017334,
0.47563207149505615,
-0.5698481202125549,
0.2712119519710541,
-0.2366587519645691,
-0.9302065372467041,
-0.42768263816833496,
0.746841549873352,
-0.7372651100158691,
-0.38266104459762573,
0.49540674686431885,
0.7907975316047668,
-0.2796367406845093,
-0.01120541337877512,
0.4912213385105133,
0.40837931632995605,
0.3049215078353882,
0.7768648862838745,
0.6572273373603821,
-0.1279565989971161,
0.39687496423721313,
0.1317872256040573,
-0.4762260317802429,
-0.2222154438495636,
-0.8137032985687256,
-0.771110475063324,
-0.41092735528945923,
-0.10250332951545715,
-0.3660110831260681,
-0.06804622709751129,
1.2456051111221313,
0.4950112998485565,
-0.8343065977096558,
-0.2382209450006485,
-0.25499972701072693,
-0.19223083555698395,
-0.31586286425590515,
-0.10680944472551346,
0.3205694556236267,
-0.36669299006462097,
-0.8143235445022583,
0.6268572807312012,
0.5966922044754028,
0.05007355660200119,
-0.2784954905509949,
-0.1505526751279831,
0.29815617203712463,
0.12094192206859589,
0.7844727039337158,
-0.011597768403589725,
-0.8549289107322693,
-0.19262085855007172,
0.10049044340848923,
-0.008488170802593231,
0.3925039768218994,
0.8531932830810547,
-0.529986560344696,
0.4909716546535492,
0.38265368342399597,
0.8791252374649048,
0.55353844165802,
-0.08701466023921967,
0.900632381439209,
-0.3487620949745178,
0.11815705895423889,
0.03472540155053139,
0.15048885345458984,
0.4990311563014984,
-0.43212953209877014,
0.46678927540779114,
0.10131276398897171,
-0.37746793031692505,
-0.8466827273368835,
0.3280872106552124,
-0.9040122628211975,
-0.34401315450668335,
1.3994812965393066,
-0.07451797276735306,
-0.12271163612604141,
-0.13986872136592865,
-0.46357497572898865,
-0.048911359161138535,
-0.5720927119255066,
0.9444730281829834,
0.7382951974868774,
-0.03322555124759674,
0.07569824159145355,
-0.9325537085533142,
0.4145873785018921,
0.7138555645942688,
-0.465930700302124,
0.4594269394874573,
0.26567086577415466,
0.28126513957977295,
0.05719181150197983,
0.5699150562286377,
-0.23249687254428864,
0.06533268839120865,
-0.40544044971466064,
-0.3778083622455597,
-0.11200765520334244,
-0.26927968859672546,
-0.4158449172973633,
0.2193547934293747,
0.5261155366897583,
0.16244307160377502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11262v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11262v1
|
Sampling-based Pseudo-Likelihood for Membership Inference Attacks
| 2024-04-17T11:12:59 | 2024-04-17T11:12:59 |
Masahiro Kaneko, Youmi Ma, Yuki Wata, Naoaki Okazaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are trained on large-scale web data, which makes
it difficult to grasp the contribution of each text. This poses the risk of
leaking inappropriate data such as benchmarks, personal information, and
copyrighted texts in the training data. Membership Inference Attacks (MIA),
which determine whether a given text is included in the model's training data,
have been attracting attention. Previous studies of MIAs revealed that
likelihood-based classification is effective for detecting leaks in LLMs.
However, the existing methods cannot be applied to some proprietary models like
ChatGPT or Claude 3 because the likelihood is unavailable to the user. In this
study, we propose a Sampling-based Pseudo-Likelihood (\textbf{SPL}) method for
MIA (\textbf{SaMIA}) that calculates SPL using only the text generated by an
LLM to detect leaks. The SaMIA treats the target text as the reference text and
multiple outputs from the LLM as text samples, calculates the degree of
$n$-gram match as SPL, and determines the membership of the text in the
training data. Even without likelihoods, SaMIA performed on par with existing
likelihood-based methods.
|
[
-0.2031307965517044,
-0.6854097843170166,
0.6262779235839844,
-0.2338428795337677,
-0.44785067439079285,
0.03346722573041916,
0.1883707046508789,
-0.5219964981079102,
0.3141377568244934,
0.37034159898757935,
-0.7820952534675598,
-0.5836407542228699,
-0.6027871966362,
0.1851484179496765,
-0.6218003034591675,
0.8147363066673279,
0.36654019355773926,
0.182853564620018,
-0.23476828634738922,
-0.03583481162786484,
-0.18173150718212128,
-0.9295505285263062,
-0.2335442751646042,
0.23904117941856384,
0.4833519458770752,
0.09986837953329086,
0.2950105667114258,
0.2669094502925873,
0.2266860455274582,
0.26959237456321716,
0.03147801756858826,
0.06912187486886978,
-0.5224433541297913,
0.02768365852534771,
-0.30130138993263245,
-0.8651475310325623,
-0.3080002963542938,
0.0840202048420906,
0.6493397951126099,
0.32678186893463135,
-0.12598316371440887,
0.1389712691307068,
0.025157500058412552,
0.4196334481239319,
-0.9214125275611877,
0.05429499223828316,
-1.0101982355117798,
-0.14333494007587433,
-0.5933796763420105,
-0.16559091210365295,
-0.6033074259757996,
-0.34361904859542847,
0.08813481032848358,
-0.24613867700099945,
0.30269840359687805,
0.10034606605768204,
0.8741191029548645,
0.004063931759446859,
-0.17804157733917236,
-0.46431100368499756,
-0.3990165889263153,
0.9026095271110535,
-0.9574183821678162,
0.43505600094795227,
0.839738130569458,
0.2472791224718094,
-0.3485446572303772,
-0.5503520369529724,
-0.8983818888664246,
-0.06131928786635399,
-0.06375634670257568,
0.031796734780073166,
-0.0355093777179718,
0.0013070477871224284,
0.08467260003089905,
0.27029097080230713,
-0.662705659866333,
0.10387032479047775,
-0.2980995178222656,
-0.1887071430683136,
0.7432680726051331,
-0.2787172794342041,
0.5084459781646729,
-0.15567618608474731,
-0.712105929851532,
-0.1664862036705017,
-0.8917260766029358,
-0.39131930470466614,
0.49600207805633545,
0.2997996509075165,
-0.28303250670433044,
0.6494083404541016,
0.057763077318668365,
0.6890206933021545,
-0.1410697102546692,
-0.2791091501712799,
0.0534973219037056,
-0.10657142847776413,
-0.34438174962997437,
-0.1857520490884781,
0.779941737651825,
0.026525508612394333,
0.12437610328197479,
-0.1684090793132782,
-0.22956646978855133,
0.027506478130817413,
0.06602777540683746,
-0.7112670540809631,
-0.40787068009376526,
0.4227517545223236,
-0.4784460961818695,
-0.3050765097141266,
0.35460060834884644,
-1.0320483446121216,
-0.5025030374526978,
0.030104268342256546,
0.5710062384605408,
-0.3958834707736969,
-0.23599348962306976,
-0.11064155399799347,
-0.11061839759349823,
-0.03661096468567848,
0.07091958820819855,
-0.577613890171051,
0.04092909395694733,
0.36652547121047974,
0.8036735653877258,
-0.24791517853736877,
-0.22669366002082825,
-0.5747568607330322,
0.11699997633695602,
-0.08407795429229736,
0.9088486433029175,
-0.4475080668926239,
-0.3880878686904907,
0.39072147011756897,
-0.35272878408432007,
-0.35946935415267944,
-0.4366041421890259,
0.38396888971328735,
-0.9508406519889832,
0.19630283117294312,
-0.0005265852669253945,
-1.038703441619873,
0.07102810591459274,
0.30693280696868896,
-0.8794507384300232,
0.9087321758270264,
0.10019834339618683,
-0.991990327835083,
0.25761738419532776,
-0.32443469762802124,
0.018452512100338936,
0.037973981350660324,
-0.2760973572731018,
-0.7178698778152466,
0.044053371995687485,
0.26815128326416016,
0.5269403457641602,
0.02597731538116932,
0.09130054712295532,
-0.6280801892280579,
-0.289206326007843,
0.7825754284858704,
-0.415097713470459,
0.8206103444099426,
0.20743803679943085,
-0.25767379999160767,
0.04576771333813667,
-0.6000016331672668,
0.021756146103143692,
0.04124607518315315,
-0.3339807093143463,
-0.46499747037887573,
0.3867102265357971,
-0.19347158074378967,
0.17561174929141998,
0.25117015838623047,
-0.5104351043701172,
0.17473948001861572,
-0.5487872958183289,
-0.17969739437103271,
0.8648915886878967,
0.2719147205352783,
0.34475284814834595,
-0.5273081064224243,
0.5368548631668091,
-0.10025200992822647,
0.07315420359373093,
-0.03280407190322876,
-0.5515320897102356,
-0.629295825958252,
-0.8888928294181824,
0.6035143733024597,
0.41408711671829224,
-1.0413731336593628,
0.6679307222366333,
-0.28711235523223877,
-0.7101166844367981,
-0.26065823435783386,
-0.020499859005212784,
0.2957253158092499,
0.04073041304945946,
0.40716496109962463,
-0.09767133742570877,
-0.32343611121177673,
-0.653748631477356,
-0.4255342483520508,
-0.5413265228271484,
-0.4091421067714691,
0.1704694777727127,
0.4628903865814209,
0.08782435208559036,
1.232757329940796,
-0.5635814070701599,
-0.45425018668174744,
-0.39337271451950073,
0.1699233502149582,
0.04451506957411766,
0.3399287462234497,
0.7046670913696289,
-0.5747032165527344,
-0.46629035472869873,
-0.46325019001960754,
-0.5498177409172058,
-0.3324746787548065,
-0.3988078832626343,
-0.06114219129085541,
0.17295955121517181,
0.36310267448425293,
-0.5267328023910522,
0.8176446557044983,
0.8683780431747437,
-0.3490808308124542,
0.6430740356445312,
0.12610968947410583,
-0.16850923001766205,
-1.1251128911972046,
0.06972098350524902,
-0.16628497838974,
-0.43751347064971924,
-0.6998451948165894,
0.4127761125564575,
0.20992626249790192,
-0.12228011339902878,
-0.5330718755722046,
0.6397773623466492,
-0.6088495850563049,
-0.02742006443440914,
-0.32925090193748474,
-0.13189469277858734,
-0.299143522977829,
0.44290709495544434,
0.1841026395559311,
0.7395924925804138,
0.4086601138114929,
-0.6975329518318176,
-0.139587864279747,
0.19688557088375092,
-0.29332399368286133,
0.3344804346561432,
-0.29625195264816284,
0.4130171537399292,
0.006506430916488171,
0.6303724646568298,
-0.8171857595443726,
-0.19171451032161713,
0.4720580279827118,
-0.6166201829910278,
0.29233318567276,
-0.4471513330936432,
-0.6338830590248108,
-0.014835168607532978,
-0.5105991363525391,
0.2606057822704315,
0.11445001512765884,
-0.6866450309753418,
0.5912196636199951,
0.4899768829345703,
-0.12244061380624771,
-0.7519544959068298,
-0.48771101236343384,
-0.006897385232150555,
-0.2505435049533844,
-0.40825405716896057,
0.34277236461639404,
-0.260606974363327,
0.0326874703168869,
-0.2076469361782074,
-0.3108137547969818,
-0.41524264216423035,
0.2327694445848465,
0.10452066361904144,
0.46671241521835327,
0.09041158109903336,
-0.13642293214797974,
0.043370284140110016,
0.15006862580776215,
-0.04732971638441086,
-0.19526530802249908,
0.8387535810470581,
0.3907829523086548,
-0.7093791961669922,
-0.924126386642456,
0.4899258613586426,
0.46289587020874023,
-0.19550198316574097,
1.1303390264511108,
0.13924743235111237,
-0.33574509620666504,
-0.7580260038375854,
-0.42757678031921387,
-0.5285717248916626,
-0.4583304524421692,
0.27460724115371704,
-0.19028142094612122,
-0.652819037437439,
0.5559966564178467,
-0.015077396295964718,
0.26609325408935547,
0.18072521686553955,
0.39105910062789917,
-0.395052045583725,
0.39612123370170593,
0.49465832114219666,
-0.39762651920318604,
0.473563551902771,
-0.12291507422924042,
0.2883089482784271,
-0.167403906583786,
-0.07933320850133896,
-0.7880004644393921,
-0.2693966031074524,
-0.2898441255092621,
-0.6636824011802673,
0.27698466181755066,
0.2847123444080353,
0.3109017610549927,
0.3658912479877472,
0.10273264348506927,
0.5211014747619629,
0.4373496472835541,
0.009049571119248867,
0.22025643289089203,
0.33623552322387695,
-0.16988606750965118,
0.00243998016230762,
-0.632663905620575,
-0.2909969687461853,
1.1642554998397827,
0.49960824847221375,
0.6933285593986511,
0.5791882276535034,
0.8611473441123962,
0.46892479062080383,
0.531208872795105,
-0.7278453707695007,
0.6093409657478333,
0.2833959758281708,
-0.8799765706062317,
-0.17948465049266815,
-0.6152292490005493,
-0.7605754733085632,
0.354038804769516,
-0.3680761456489563,
-0.9284369945526123,
0.5187576413154602,
0.08718663454055786,
-0.04043377563357353,
0.5779414772987366,
-0.33632075786590576,
0.302934855222702,
0.16632235050201416,
0.028065761551260948,
0.009014148265123367,
-0.501527726650238,
0.46507909893989563,
-0.5604520440101624,
0.3196403384208679,
0.09710683673620224,
0.030232900753617287,
0.7336661219596863,
-0.6195785999298096,
1.240910291671753,
-0.24811439216136932,
-0.1930254101753235,
0.2931993007659912,
0.22156402468681335,
0.7744468450546265,
0.1534259021282196,
-0.1317715048789978,
0.4150654673576355,
0.016599038615822792,
-0.4698731303215027,
-0.5729033350944519,
0.19083908200263977,
-0.608517050743103,
-0.3270336091518402,
-0.9140195250511169,
-0.1758805364370346,
-0.4073288142681122,
0.06893821805715561,
0.4266957640647888,
0.20611539483070374,
-0.057719118893146515,
0.1681959331035614,
0.5889034271240234,
-0.2515554428100586,
0.48194676637649536,
0.7646157145500183,
-0.1774611920118332,
-0.31640148162841797,
0.8786050081253052,
-0.05833407863974571,
0.4747593104839325,
0.3389545977115631,
0.032392602413892746,
-0.5303952097892761,
-0.9707470536231995,
-0.5383442044258118,
0.4037949740886688,
-0.4091649055480957,
-0.6620222926139832,
-0.4801522493362427,
-0.40702614188194275,
-0.16600899398326874,
0.19064030051231384,
-0.33944448828697205,
-0.25647854804992676,
-0.3136709928512573,
-0.05228135734796524,
0.013692309148609638,
0.31998538970947266,
0.11128728836774826,
0.6022698879241943,
-1.0945723056793213,
0.1879596710205078,
0.09504063427448273,
0.10590039938688278,
0.015812929719686508,
-0.5743204355239868,
-0.07917027920484543,
-0.017239481210708618,
-0.08855839818716049,
-1.4794976711273193,
0.5337068438529968,
0.344868928194046,
0.526274561882019,
0.7568206787109375,
0.43755584955215454,
0.45805129408836365,
-0.467086523771286,
0.87763911485672,
0.10144443809986115,
-0.8640880584716797,
0.2990832030773163,
-0.25118470191955566,
-0.16442427039146423,
0.6335409283638,
0.4880310297012329,
-0.2607533633708954,
-0.590803325176239,
-0.6909546852111816,
-0.72345370054245,
0.889118492603302,
0.6237897276878357,
0.2205285131931305,
-0.09126901626586914,
0.16408459842205048,
-0.13013112545013428,
0.1529265195131302,
-1.0751463174819946,
-0.5211921334266663,
0.12303875386714935,
-0.17048753798007965,
0.4433758556842804,
-0.43382740020751953,
-0.02026563137769699,
0.16231669485569,
0.8648411631584167,
-0.1401064544916153,
0.36842310428619385,
0.12720897793769836,
-0.3751484751701355,
0.25009819865226746,
0.2153211236000061,
0.31334733963012695,
0.7777078747749329,
-0.21431207656860352,
0.19059999287128448,
0.2108277827501297,
-0.6623223423957825,
0.1337798535823822,
0.07084817439317703,
-0.3689969480037689,
0.29702913761138916,
0.5315287113189697,
0.22574524581432343,
0.03439624607563019,
-0.8256630301475525,
0.893757164478302,
-0.1210094466805458,
-0.04803818091750145,
-0.41776397824287415,
0.042160943150520325,
0.16635359823703766,
-0.03292706608772278,
0.5814844965934753,
-0.09437532722949982,
-0.10693086683750153,
-0.5905219912528992,
0.570435106754303,
0.4176466763019562,
-0.26603052020072937,
-0.22531069815158844,
0.19424378871917725,
-0.052856817841529846,
-0.013532714918255806,
0.34143516421318054,
-0.13048067688941956,
-0.6362628936767578,
0.25059542059898376,
0.7842521071434021,
0.464361310005188,
-0.7465511560440063,
0.2403637021780014,
0.35369613766670227,
0.2177288830280304,
0.19393454492092133,
0.1503770500421524,
0.05181175470352173,
-0.830094039440155,
-0.3451867997646332,
-1.0128188133239746,
-0.07365922629833221,
0.5961635708808899,
-0.6094669699668884,
0.1488979160785675,
-0.5714592933654785,
-0.0239216648042202,
-0.38523387908935547,
-0.16604338586330414,
-0.07472851127386093,
0.1799570918083191,
0.013055154122412205,
0.9315587878227234,
-0.9639683961868286,
1.0187387466430664,
0.24060042202472687,
-0.2371113896369934,
-0.6549498438835144,
0.45988231897354126,
0.34027713537216187,
-0.4547036588191986,
0.3432617783546448,
-0.08906861394643784,
0.010149369947612286,
-0.2575313448905945,
-0.3773064911365509,
-0.8738720417022705,
0.7850683331489563,
0.37026169896125793,
-0.7217898964881897,
-0.13690875470638275,
0.2531718611717224,
0.055488936603069305,
0.1735091507434845,
0.015247768722474575,
0.2916465103626251,
0.18755149841308594,
-0.06532146781682968,
-0.6416760683059692,
-0.20206773281097412,
-0.05398936942219734,
-0.23612825572490692,
0.06531129777431488,
-0.26285257935523987,
0.744951069355011,
0.36786240339279175,
-0.6067342162132263,
0.33639606833457947,
1.10342276096344,
0.7544026970863342,
0.29383471608161926,
0.7973817586898804,
0.41047948598861694,
1.0074501037597656,
0.35432764887809753,
1.0519840717315674,
-0.05273862183094025,
0.5157145261764526,
1.34935462474823,
-0.26245638728141785,
1.2219375371932983,
0.267121285200119,
-0.4209115505218506,
0.37369537353515625,
0.59609055519104,
0.0010469555854797363,
0.5282511115074158,
0.4685805141925812,
-0.7519032955169678,
-0.00558006577193737,
0.27864620089530945,
-0.33466118574142456,
0.46167951822280884,
0.550456166267395,
-0.42443814873695374,
-0.269503653049469,
-0.2996440529823303,
0.3531453609466553,
0.046883948147296906,
-0.04987707734107971,
0.895753026008606,
0.2533906102180481,
-0.319051593542099,
0.3895910084247589,
0.40806344151496887,
0.7895809412002563,
-0.892540693283081,
0.04806121811270714,
-0.22347667813301086,
0.0025902711786329746,
-0.14812806248664856,
-0.29400917887687683,
0.297739177942276,
0.3525276482105255,
0.011048620566725731,
0.18079745769500732,
0.7571219205856323,
-0.41463392972946167,
-0.5325509309768677,
0.22193081676959991,
0.5101501941680908,
0.2987251877784729,
-0.3122590184211731,
-0.5169175863265991,
-0.06773658841848373,
0.16086463630199432,
-0.05936819314956665,
0.6719502806663513,
-0.12549984455108643,
-0.0499909371137619,
0.5653974413871765,
1.0228134393692017,
0.3076178729534149,
0.1602734476327896,
-0.07515878230333328,
0.8769848346710205,
-0.18984976410865784,
-0.7090606689453125,
-0.9736461639404297,
0.253277987241745,
-0.3467947840690613,
-0.052324216812849045,
0.7923017144203186,
0.6404045820236206,
0.6307893991470337,
-0.155605748295784,
0.7596720457077026,
0.01085738930851221,
0.5753098130226135,
-0.9818857312202454,
1.2479901313781738,
-0.4214513301849365,
0.5488991737365723,
-0.2177889496088028,
-1.0915446281433105,
-0.2907528579235077,
0.598630964756012,
-0.04296046122908592,
-0.024758048355579376,
0.8512719869613647,
0.9381401538848877,
-0.32185420393943787,
0.1035400852560997,
0.3365893065929413,
0.1196218878030777,
0.5075466632843018,
0.15966758131980896,
0.7715902328491211,
-0.16290830075740814,
0.43252161145210266,
0.018702441826462746,
-0.2905023694038391,
-0.16002292931079865,
-0.8375827074050903,
-1.139817237854004,
-0.5646259188652039,
-0.11591944098472595,
-0.46873801946640015,
-0.04694158583879471,
0.8042203187942505,
0.8682989478111267,
-0.849567711353302,
-0.024298060685396194,
0.11571359634399414,
-0.10154228657484055,
0.02291693538427353,
-0.2140463888645172,
0.777913510799408,
-0.17036214470863342,
-0.8365575075149536,
0.7511906623840332,
-0.17452183365821838,
-0.019445763900876045,
-0.21686257421970367,
0.1879444569349289,
-0.5107427835464478,
0.4618069529533386,
0.22796274721622467,
0.22934198379516602,
-0.562441349029541,
-0.18364249169826508,
-0.3754100203514099,
0.1356019377708435,
-0.16170328855514526,
0.6763702630996704,
-0.6832702159881592,
0.21407224237918854,
0.6151060461997986,
0.8498039245605469,
0.42193615436553955,
0.18873344361782074,
0.6206567883491516,
-1.213401436805725,
0.08775901794433594,
0.4100838899612427,
0.42291271686553955,
0.08151886612176895,
-0.3414458632469177,
0.2533484697341919,
0.34635913372039795,
-0.2057323455810547,
-0.8980634212493896,
0.3327106833457947,
-0.8954359292984009,
-0.6727986335754395,
0.9605599641799927,
-0.6615132689476013,
-0.3820171654224396,
-0.38505232334136963,
0.08399317413568497,
0.19291813671588898,
-0.3429882228374481,
0.818917453289032,
0.6282995939254761,
0.367196261882782,
0.04752244055271149,
-0.6175846457481384,
0.7485864758491516,
0.325504332780838,
-1.0605485439300537,
0.11414966732263565,
0.54581618309021,
0.4243220388889313,
0.065408855676651,
0.6930376887321472,
-0.2878965437412262,
0.1671072393655777,
-0.2681557536125183,
-0.15838029980659485,
0.14915935695171356,
-0.44189727306365967,
-0.1939334124326706,
0.3788888156414032,
-0.13839125633239746,
-0.14426486194133759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11225v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11225v1
|
In-Context Learning State Vector with Inner and Momentum Optimization
| 2024-04-17T10:19:15 | 2024-04-17T10:19:15 |
Dongfang Li, Zhenyu Liu, Xinshuo Hu, Zetian Sun, Baotian Hu, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have exhibited an impressive ability to perform
In-Context Learning (ICL) from only a few examples. Recent works have indicated
that the functions learned by ICL can be represented through compressed vectors
derived from the transformer. However, the working mechanisms and optimization
of these vectors are yet to be thoroughly explored. In this paper, we address
this gap by presenting a comprehensive analysis of these compressed vectors,
drawing parallels to the parameters trained with gradient descent, and
introduce the concept of state vector. Inspired by the works on model soup and
momentum-based gradient descent, we propose inner and momentum optimization
methods that are applied to refine the state vector progressively as test-time
adaptation. Moreover, we simulate state vector aggregation in the multiple
example setting, where demonstrations comprising numerous examples are usually
too lengthy for regular ICL, and further propose a divide-and-conquer
aggregation method to address this challenge. We conduct extensive experiments
using Llama-2 and GPT-J in both zero-shot setting and few-shot setting. The
experimental results show that our optimization method effectively enhances the
state vector and achieves the state-of-the-art performance on diverse tasks.
Code is available at https://github.com/HITsz-TMG/ICL-State-Vector
|
[
-0.2103026658296585,
-0.3981705605983734,
0.3556833565235138,
0.1938486099243164,
-0.4831865727901459,
0.4078480005264282,
-0.30400076508522034,
0.09570697695016861,
-0.186106875538826,
-0.2176215797662735,
-0.6556941270828247,
-0.25107455253601074,
-0.5342634320259094,
-0.003022691234946251,
-0.44552934169769287,
0.9533202052116394,
-0.31686732172966003,
0.27288752794265747,
-0.25527387857437134,
-0.2165445238351822,
-0.44353002309799194,
-0.41675296425819397,
-0.5150863528251648,
-0.4238034784793854,
-0.0014004925033077598,
0.44287461042404175,
-0.11931652575731277,
0.3423393666744232,
0.3032214939594269,
0.2912905514240265,
-0.19689840078353882,
0.173569917678833,
-1.0037105083465576,
0.236954927444458,
-0.047212328761816025,
-0.4984273612499237,
0.1754254400730133,
-0.24818821251392365,
1.0547924041748047,
0.3206169307231903,
-0.23146159946918488,
0.19402307271957397,
0.37533891201019287,
0.5507863759994507,
-0.9252581000328064,
0.26456010341644287,
-0.6506252884864807,
0.2668124735355377,
-0.10008952021598816,
-0.1120767742395401,
-0.16566908359527588,
-0.21922117471694946,
-0.15241068601608276,
-0.5932207703590393,
-0.01869824528694153,
0.2167646884918213,
0.7574682235717773,
0.4129183888435364,
-0.4166991710662842,
-0.13019412755966187,
-0.8476458191871643,
1.0813922882080078,
-0.3173586130142212,
0.5249046683311462,
-0.25168466567993164,
0.16990703344345093,
-0.48132824897766113,
-0.6754325032234192,
-0.7315584421157837,
-0.1389465481042862,
0.21704404056072235,
0.27793651819229126,
-0.3811728358268738,
-0.008599412627518177,
0.025329140946269035,
0.36592617630958557,
-0.28816959261894226,
0.4025558531284332,
-0.4546879231929779,
-0.10322585701942444,
0.38051995635032654,
0.22403234243392944,
0.13031624257564545,
0.017333030700683594,
-0.828147292137146,
-0.47662848234176636,
-0.6810564994812012,
0.5124316811561584,
0.1387806236743927,
0.2651766240596771,
-0.2625456154346466,
0.36963531374931335,
0.049820370972156525,
0.4664532244205475,
0.11825515329837799,
-0.4580162465572357,
0.2731393277645111,
-0.09725531190633774,
-0.21311117708683014,
0.05708639323711395,
0.6434000730514526,
0.10961359739303589,
0.05274948477745056,
-0.17052054405212402,
-0.4198559820652008,
0.11658523976802826,
0.3856815993785858,
-0.8552262187004089,
0.16027836501598358,
0.26509639620780945,
-0.33943477272987366,
-0.20637711882591248,
0.029086178168654442,
-0.4029915928840637,
-0.14742019772529602,
-0.4966754913330078,
0.6062175035476685,
-0.5307190418243408,
-0.09909608960151672,
0.03400406241416931,
-0.14868442714214325,
0.4637620747089386,
0.03541130945086479,
-0.5534782409667969,
0.41845372319221497,
0.9359810948371887,
0.9681227803230286,
-0.5037925839424133,
-0.06494247168302536,
-0.7814569473266602,
-0.16345658898353577,
-0.4664723575115204,
0.6749362945556641,
-0.4106704294681549,
-0.5641143321990967,
0.07044937461614609,
-0.33444055914878845,
-0.04728654399514198,
-0.44046473503112793,
0.6246188282966614,
-0.4982304573059082,
-0.11202993243932724,
-0.1598358303308487,
-0.7700225710868835,
-0.3909575939178467,
0.24172425270080566,
-0.37750932574272156,
1.234483003616333,
0.4452807605266571,
-0.4798077642917633,
0.5479379296302795,
-0.7513088583946228,
-0.5606221556663513,
0.15888717770576477,
-0.26438984274864197,
-0.37048789858818054,
0.4486006498336792,
0.2295009046792984,
0.7084678411483765,
-0.2667056918144226,
-0.09842497110366821,
-0.1824052333831787,
-0.6248618960380554,
0.1860610395669937,
0.018424421548843384,
0.7297597527503967,
0.17674247920513153,
0.023956360295414925,
0.31229710578918457,
-0.5764098763465881,
-0.2508847415447235,
0.14684143662452698,
-0.43685799837112427,
-0.36918625235557556,
0.29373401403427124,
-0.2858392298221588,
0.20177865028381348,
-0.1053680032491684,
-0.6386423110961914,
0.34447112679481506,
-0.6001138091087341,
0.44793176651000977,
0.8477382659912109,
0.26618143916130066,
0.6794692873954773,
0.06580154597759247,
0.777881383895874,
0.48385435342788696,
0.24603500962257385,
0.01724676787853241,
0.09534589946269989,
-0.7272141575813293,
-0.32240453362464905,
-0.00007810507668182254,
0.5322001576423645,
-1.0035648345947266,
0.3432590663433075,
-0.4342096149921417,
-0.3816831111907959,
-0.44320908188819885,
0.1716063767671585,
0.17476440966129303,
0.8057440519332886,
0.4681923985481262,
-0.2136228084564209,
-0.2872121036052704,
-0.7075819969177246,
-0.2805373966693878,
-0.0652485117316246,
-0.010222751647233963,
0.025087369605898857,
0.546125054359436,
0.1319642812013626,
0.9323644638061523,
-0.444664865732193,
-0.38801655173301697,
-0.3961496949195862,
-0.3237747251987457,
0.2824003994464874,
0.24780412018299103,
0.386629581451416,
-0.643340528011322,
-0.21928542852401733,
-0.24811379611492157,
-0.5418287515640259,
0.1866929531097412,
0.0390947200357914,
-0.08777181059122086,
0.0315835066139698,
0.6986005902290344,
-0.1884431391954422,
0.3518836498260498,
0.681102454662323,
-0.002205535303801298,
0.17059142887592316,
-0.11051461100578308,
-0.34820353984832764,
-1.1600805521011353,
-0.39141032099723816,
0.43423938751220703,
-0.14905814826488495,
-0.6555408835411072,
0.26719486713409424,
0.4005706310272217,
-0.11150258034467697,
-0.8148812651634216,
0.4929259121417999,
-0.5484801530838013,
-0.00692668417468667,
-0.3433111310005188,
0.12603838741779327,
-0.33051061630249023,
0.6402515172958374,
-0.3790813088417053,
0.7799871563911438,
0.8091900944709778,
-0.8586403727531433,
0.15152432024478912,
0.07326463609933853,
-0.6613438725471497,
0.5547731518745422,
-0.42458102107048035,
0.20344647765159607,
-0.6848055124282837,
0.3802584409713745,
-0.9475131630897522,
0.2288760542869568,
0.30718669295310974,
0.08761478215456009,
0.4543288052082062,
-0.173705592751503,
-0.4586312472820282,
-0.19943475723266602,
-0.30801481008529663,
0.44821467995643616,
0.6544725298881531,
-0.887343168258667,
0.7527186274528503,
0.41211944818496704,
0.37392815947532654,
-0.6913586258888245,
-0.39040374755859375,
-0.3141220510005951,
-0.39330726861953735,
-0.16921421885490417,
0.38477182388305664,
-0.11125902086496353,
-0.32682105898857117,
-0.09354258328676224,
-0.21222688257694244,
0.21812963485717773,
0.15300339460372925,
0.23409104347229004,
0.0645761489868164,
-0.07546249777078629,
0.40172621607780457,
0.3979642391204834,
0.005246036220341921,
-0.05739730969071388,
-0.5323386788368225,
0.5577771663665771,
-0.2348279356956482,
-0.1846495419740677,
-0.10015665739774704,
0.16368883848190308,
0.07110349088907242,
-0.22529049217700958,
0.696703314781189,
0.5664075016975403,
-0.1349581629037857,
-0.8989453911781311,
0.051831163465976715,
-0.2867281436920166,
-0.5310320258140564,
0.5258779525756836,
-0.3783608078956604,
-1.0144485235214233,
0.15030865371227264,
-0.411173015832901,
0.31699544191360474,
0.35602882504463196,
0.7480927109718323,
-0.14226587116718292,
0.4826108515262604,
0.6416984796524048,
-0.4125024974346161,
0.5412084460258484,
-0.43580949306488037,
0.25480157136917114,
-1.044562578201294,
-0.1518537700176239,
-0.2491896003484726,
-0.6555604934692383,
-0.4694758355617523,
-0.7191175222396851,
0.8404923677444458,
0.2556336224079132,
-0.3124801218509674,
0.13919897377490997,
-0.3246369957923889,
0.5337628722190857,
0.34982550144195557,
0.13115160167217255,
-0.03714502230286598,
0.1843821257352829,
-0.2197842299938202,
-0.02001349627971649,
-0.8188186883926392,
0.11502323299646378,
0.8361819982528687,
0.1906541883945465,
0.7731754779815674,
0.029149828478693962,
0.5984389185905457,
0.06472493708133698,
0.31778955459594727,
-1.1331881284713745,
0.5479623675346375,
-0.31634199619293213,
-0.06114865839481354,
-0.1373983472585678,
-0.3560411334037781,
-0.8417012691497803,
0.6315545439720154,
-0.18069329857826233,
-0.5754532217979431,
0.07954274117946625,
0.14488078653812408,
-0.2727494239807129,
0.2629697620868683,
-0.46547389030456543,
0.26157939434051514,
-0.1225556954741478,
0.0065727317705750465,
-0.30323874950408936,
-0.578218936920166,
0.3507990539073944,
-0.11876681447029114,
0.007474255748093128,
-0.08471700549125671,
-0.30905911326408386,
0.3683827221393585,
-0.27748414874076843,
0.6819730401039124,
-0.13010358810424805,
-0.16825313866138458,
0.29044580459594727,
0.13384608924388885,
0.5437636375427246,
-0.0344138965010643,
-0.1163533478975296,
0.329428493976593,
-0.42051947116851807,
-0.1965763419866562,
-0.7049636244773865,
0.45496678352355957,
-0.7051626443862915,
-0.28777164220809937,
-0.256928950548172,
-0.44605815410614014,
-0.20499099791049957,
-0.10759097337722778,
0.24727647006511688,
0.7063964009284973,
-0.08032906800508499,
0.21149121224880219,
0.5961498618125916,
-0.08204296976327896,
0.924288272857666,
0.42167338728904724,
-0.08023792505264282,
-0.07848331332206726,
0.8653134107589722,
0.06939336657524109,
0.15592265129089355,
0.7107867002487183,
0.4407097101211548,
-0.35024499893188477,
-0.5231727957725525,
-0.30777591466903687,
0.07647662609815598,
-0.8886645436286926,
-0.3298957943916321,
-0.2571936845779419,
-0.12678468227386475,
-0.13799679279327393,
-0.12171998620033264,
-0.31786036491394043,
-0.089054636657238,
-0.5422922372817993,
-0.08952364325523376,
0.21878492832183838,
0.5071188807487488,
0.1769319325685501,
0.30791398882865906,
-0.4597679078578949,
0.21162283420562744,
0.05293445661664009,
0.2562810480594635,
0.10108181089162827,
-0.6405333876609802,
-0.2543320059776306,
-0.33053478598594666,
-0.23482365906238556,
-0.6133873462677002,
0.2766527533531189,
0.5988092422485352,
0.45469608902931213,
0.46174731850624084,
0.12767143547534943,
0.7006754875183105,
-0.6812217235565186,
0.7877639532089233,
-0.016041291877627373,
-0.9068047404289246,
0.25031962990760803,
0.1830761432647705,
0.35351309180259705,
0.30306851863861084,
0.632021963596344,
-0.484162837266922,
-0.31473734974861145,
-0.311568021774292,
-0.8464693427085876,
0.39165863394737244,
-0.024417463690042496,
0.31746000051498413,
0.12472385913133621,
0.5998436808586121,
0.03912297636270523,
-0.021764876320958138,
-0.3623444437980652,
-0.3798927068710327,
0.019112009555101395,
-0.2043246328830719,
-0.1170065775513649,
-0.19413909316062927,
-0.12717188894748688,
-0.37869736552238464,
0.6321509480476379,
-0.4324788451194763,
0.21164263784885406,
-0.039873044937849045,
-0.40093061327934265,
0.029920032247900963,
0.10990171879529953,
0.6370850801467896,
0.4967682957649231,
0.36754655838012695,
-0.21662183105945587,
0.3580690920352936,
-0.48566100001335144,
0.44035735726356506,
-0.04917389899492264,
-0.2300606518983841,
-0.3022961914539337,
0.15663455426692963,
1.0515239238739014,
0.4587523341178894,
-0.5149833559989929,
0.7548574805259705,
-0.06774748116731644,
-0.12915724515914917,
-0.5311373472213745,
0.2950242757797241,
-0.29328063130378723,
0.4873458743095398,
0.49559521675109863,
-0.1837487518787384,
0.007479778490960598,
-0.1417812705039978,
0.04201129823923111,
0.49284401535987854,
-0.4067212641239166,
-0.3223141133785248,
0.4999244213104248,
0.019366469234228134,
-0.2428911179304123,
0.7454994320869446,
-0.41429322957992554,
-0.5972530841827393,
0.19387656450271606,
0.7763893008232117,
0.9310423731803894,
-0.06663379073143005,
-0.027073310688138008,
0.30660679936408997,
0.2140377014875412,
-0.10886169224977493,
0.45335960388183594,
-0.12900090217590332,
-1.0554163455963135,
-0.7015388011932373,
-0.7428083419799805,
-0.24858872592449188,
0.0340898372232914,
-0.546235203742981,
0.2825169563293457,
-0.4468912184238434,
0.1299140304327011,
-0.5694167613983154,
0.026242854073643684,
-0.7922878265380859,
0.04790592938661575,
-0.0022665755823254585,
0.8609756231307983,
-0.6941767930984497,
0.8645498752593994,
0.589559018611908,
-0.024157682433724403,
-0.9170379638671875,
0.15083666145801544,
0.08107177168130875,
-0.8674631118774414,
0.8231173753738403,
-0.07701250165700912,
-0.30165770649909973,
0.15976250171661377,
-0.6382278800010681,
-0.966812789440155,
0.9787520170211792,
0.43056046962738037,
-0.6885945200920105,
0.297462522983551,
-0.24654892086982727,
0.3414918780326843,
-0.17396020889282227,
-0.0976865217089653,
0.4875348210334778,
0.05717618763446808,
-0.07616806775331497,
-0.3080207407474518,
-0.047135356813669205,
0.08624126762151718,
0.37590348720550537,
0.4086456894874573,
-0.9017520546913147,
0.915953516960144,
-0.0361817441880703,
-0.42786645889282227,
-0.4812844395637512,
1.4195733070373535,
0.33265504240989685,
-0.3048509657382965,
0.8634677529335022,
0.41603049635887146,
0.6229070425033569,
0.05376220494508743,
1.1521345376968384,
-0.3424158990383148,
0.4051976203918457,
0.8413404226303101,
-0.31181371212005615,
0.8390383124351501,
0.6353687644004822,
-0.18122243881225586,
0.702639639377594,
0.3201424777507782,
-0.041723400354385376,
0.3436858355998993,
0.6038188934326172,
-0.4562864601612091,
0.029305260628461838,
0.024493779987096786,
0.22143204510211945,
0.7299184203147888,
0.4767954647541046,
-0.08222342282533646,
-0.2947775721549988,
0.26181724667549133,
0.032813746482133865,
-0.1257234364748001,
-0.4571598470211029,
0.708820641040802,
0.2629990875720978,
-0.39086171984672546,
0.35701724886894226,
-0.006703965365886688,
0.7476634383201599,
-0.545724093914032,
-0.03616434335708618,
-0.26403138041496277,
0.2833559215068817,
0.16438724100589752,
-0.48313990235328674,
-0.1590307652950287,
-0.13848701119422913,
0.12380000203847885,
-0.2434467375278473,
0.7238324284553528,
-0.36094731092453003,
-0.5086745023727417,
0.19714123010635376,
0.07114629447460175,
0.15952935814857483,
0.03373659774661064,
-0.5192480087280273,
0.22320899367332458,
-0.4363346993923187,
-0.3494010865688324,
0.33189043402671814,
0.12868277728557587,
-0.0255009476095438,
0.8089442253112793,
0.40731361508369446,
0.26715928316116333,
0.07344256341457367,
0.0532141737639904,
0.8845359086990356,
-0.2412368804216385,
-0.636576235294342,
-0.9695160984992981,
0.4761885404586792,
0.09598163515329361,
-0.5906568169593811,
0.6735698580741882,
0.570952296257019,
1.1183980703353882,
0.027475127950310707,
0.625171959400177,
0.02913755364716053,
0.43987661600112915,
-0.7668492197990417,
0.4443616271018982,
-0.7741135954856873,
-0.16405096650123596,
-0.011401932686567307,
-0.9169554710388184,
-0.2050853669643402,
0.3692607879638672,
0.11244035512208939,
-0.02959582395851612,
0.6476425528526306,
0.6742101311683655,
-0.11509880423545837,
-0.2671913206577301,
0.2563311457633972,
0.012081083841621876,
0.42674604058265686,
0.6566034555435181,
0.7350716590881348,
-0.3430584669113159,
0.35404980182647705,
-0.4939218759536743,
-0.047427285462617874,
-0.13781239092350006,
-1.1464606523513794,
-0.7321341633796692,
-0.9094167351722717,
-0.1824500560760498,
-0.22607731819152832,
-0.24828532338142395,
1.2742503881454468,
0.7846152186393738,
-0.5425553321838379,
-0.33629411458969116,
0.1657307744026184,
-0.08252458274364471,
-0.37772664427757263,
-0.17783264815807343,
0.3572205603122711,
-0.6256133913993835,
-0.7962522506713867,
0.9895954728126526,
0.3627583086490631,
-0.18155881762504578,
-0.4600709080696106,
0.044188160449266434,
0.20401641726493835,
-0.09012237936258316,
0.8830281496047974,
0.26194024085998535,
-0.46786803007125854,
-0.17143528163433075,
-0.29189157485961914,
0.12491357326507568,
0.26452985405921936,
1.1553393602371216,
-0.8620904684066772,
0.38794365525245667,
0.47210296988487244,
0.8095675706863403,
0.5196588039398193,
0.08429490029811859,
0.5342609882354736,
-1.1900489330291748,
0.2999010384082794,
0.3104248642921448,
0.39048686623573303,
0.2087816447019577,
-0.2707781493663788,
0.29876425862312317,
0.005354391876608133,
-0.40483999252319336,
-0.6712685227394104,
0.27224335074424744,
-0.8111061453819275,
-0.3238725960254669,
1.3374409675598145,
0.12441319227218628,
-0.4009052813053131,
0.22381922602653503,
0.14269140362739563,
0.5054281949996948,
-0.4532248377799988,
0.5562101006507874,
0.4324459433555603,
-0.16939707100391388,
-0.20462101697921753,
-0.4263620674610138,
0.5060204863548279,
0.19743502140045166,
-0.6292970776557922,
-0.3754713535308838,
0.07741954177618027,
0.2713933289051056,
-0.36751657724380493,
0.31582707166671753,
0.06214021146297455,
-0.20704376697540283,
-0.3418801724910736,
0.053752921521663666,
-0.022295160219073296,
-0.33028313517570496,
-0.9544411897659302,
0.22612878680229187,
-0.16862182319164276,
-0.38652148842811584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11216v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11216v1
|
Position Engineering: Boosting Large Language Models through Positional Information Manipulation
| 2024-04-17T10:00:56 | 2024-04-17T10:00:56 |
Zhiyuan He, Huiqiang Jiang, Zilong Wang, Yuqing Yang, Luna Qiu, Lili Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The performance of large language models (LLMs) is significantly influenced
by the quality of the prompts provided. In response, researchers have developed
enormous prompt engineering strategies aimed at modifying the prompt text to
enhance task performance. In this paper, we introduce a novel technique termed
position engineering, which offers a more efficient way to guide large language
models. Unlike prompt engineering, which requires substantial effort to modify
the text provided to LLMs, position engineering merely involves altering the
positional information in the prompt without modifying the text itself. We have
evaluated position engineering in two widely-used LLM scenarios:
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) and in-context learning (ICL). Our
findings show that position engineering substantially improves upon the
baseline in both cases. Position engineering thus represents a promising new
strategy for exploiting the capabilities of large language models.
|
[
-0.1208733394742012,
-0.6220150589942932,
0.7396360039710999,
0.28092074394226074,
0.06029515713453293,
0.22158169746398926,
-0.22182218730449677,
-0.42254406213760376,
0.045906003564596176,
0.37224331498146057,
-0.29070448875427246,
-0.45223405957221985,
-0.46126484870910645,
-0.14469873905181885,
-0.1374785453081131,
0.6748249530792236,
-0.09842517971992493,
0.03560565039515495,
-0.09464465081691742,
0.32726410031318665,
-0.8309802412986755,
-0.810767412185669,
-0.6282034516334534,
-0.20946121215820312,
0.6245235204696655,
0.4545484781265259,
0.6928806900978088,
0.6304835677146912,
0.2434060126543045,
0.39123988151550293,
-0.5045475959777832,
0.0298682302236557,
-0.3587525486946106,
0.33561450242996216,
-0.39386940002441406,
-0.4726369082927704,
-0.25092920660972595,
0.1498904973268509,
0.8332911133766174,
0.8584657907485962,
0.1789778470993042,
0.002115621231496334,
0.2315608114004135,
0.40510064363479614,
-0.7823839783668518,
0.15809611976146698,
-0.6611533164978027,
-0.22913505136966705,
-0.1867053508758545,
-0.7163190841674805,
-0.840003252029419,
-0.19911529123783112,
-0.02125900238752365,
-0.36876365542411804,
-0.03769395500421524,
0.13287149369716644,
0.7619072794914246,
0.19362173974514008,
-0.4911426603794098,
-0.10775139927864075,
-0.7081893086433411,
0.9230331778526306,
-0.6396016478538513,
0.39028725028038025,
0.277741402387619,
0.29081350564956665,
-0.4728514552116394,
-0.2805628478527069,
-0.20014706254005432,
-0.40789106488227844,
-0.2056552767753601,
-0.19186411798000336,
0.3954088091850281,
0.2232518196105957,
0.4884967803955078,
-0.04649094119668007,
-0.2509954869747162,
0.5818472504615784,
-0.09027749300003052,
0.031219232827425003,
0.6423448920249939,
-0.19031713902950287,
0.5846046209335327,
-0.25406110286712646,
-0.41721102595329285,
-0.34923771023750305,
-1.0699127912521362,
0.3065195381641388,
0.2690218687057495,
0.44185808300971985,
0.4340539276599884,
0.7533224821090698,
-0.11877865344285965,
0.7541499733924866,
0.29444605112075806,
-0.1167554184794426,
-0.14024212956428528,
0.04192207008600235,
-0.2422281950712204,
0.4846605956554413,
0.46884235739707947,
0.11170561611652374,
-0.40142756700515747,
-0.024098480120301247,
-0.5586951971054077,
-0.39171749353408813,
0.33923256397247314,
-0.7245255708694458,
0.06885745376348495,
-0.04922661930322647,
-0.37177935242652893,
-0.3683890998363495,
0.2199302613735199,
-0.3473679721355438,
-0.6268970370292664,
-0.5152301788330078,
0.20812982320785522,
-0.4318130612373352,
0.05356592684984207,
-0.1037195548415184,
0.014955945312976837,
0.5242806673049927,
0.35359543561935425,
-1.0375864505767822,
-0.22876939177513123,
1.081394910812378,
0.7399770021438599,
-0.3170458674430847,
-0.32065534591674805,
-0.668456494808197,
0.37073519825935364,
-0.5788121223449707,
0.7572718262672424,
-0.7900872826576233,
-0.7456501722335815,
0.03037056140601635,
-0.07768583297729492,
0.15080517530441284,
-0.6056572198867798,
0.490594744682312,
-0.9756503105163574,
0.3239046633243561,
-0.36960113048553467,
-0.5968642234802246,
-0.1123562604188919,
0.18551801145076752,
-0.6472363471984863,
1.0345913171768188,
-0.005190484691411257,
-0.4056948125362396,
0.046324532479047775,
-0.7370741963386536,
-0.3947332501411438,
-0.039947859942913055,
-0.006219143979251385,
0.0023420078214257956,
0.173199862241745,
0.30547434091567993,
0.5135249495506287,
-0.05847712978720665,
0.3001909554004669,
-0.13393068313598633,
-0.4322124421596527,
0.34942343831062317,
-0.11664760857820511,
0.6295809149742126,
0.12464670091867447,
-0.06610392779111862,
0.20477460324764252,
-0.49215051531791687,
-0.19711163640022278,
-0.23058398067951202,
-0.44687628746032715,
-0.7196833491325378,
-0.05038859322667122,
-0.1713889241218567,
0.3517724871635437,
0.42108088731765747,
-0.23121041059494019,
0.6368666887283325,
-0.790421187877655,
0.23041972517967224,
0.8624997138977051,
0.047351837158203125,
1.0418615341186523,
-0.16694559156894684,
0.7057313323020935,
-0.4445558488368988,
-0.07688551396131516,
-0.2561430037021637,
-0.2012982964515686,
-0.3056543469429016,
-0.12967877089977264,
0.36521652340888977,
0.7269116044044495,
-1.0004466772079468,
0.2603323757648468,
-0.0729680210351944,
-0.24025407433509827,
-0.35776302218437195,
0.03068474680185318,
0.16240628063678741,
0.5915805101394653,
0.41999855637550354,
0.43717730045318604,
-0.5642097592353821,
-0.7147035598754883,
-0.4479219913482666,
-0.35880863666534424,
-0.15091440081596375,
-0.10639067739248276,
0.021178489550948143,
-0.005027507431805134,
0.9687017202377319,
-0.3868454098701477,
0.1410803198814392,
-0.23287609219551086,
0.20911292731761932,
0.5213673710823059,
0.6443373560905457,
0.5804892182350159,
-0.8379238247871399,
-0.5049600601196289,
0.0012406097957864404,
-0.6510517001152039,
-0.2872620224952698,
-0.1538359820842743,
-0.2585945129394531,
0.19388151168823242,
0.9022901654243469,
-0.9385373592376709,
0.07530440390110016,
0.46324804425239563,
-0.27259328961372375,
0.6666775345802307,
-0.17726784944534302,
0.48316171765327454,
-1.1382616758346558,
-0.04051482304930687,
0.06394903361797333,
-0.22304680943489075,
-0.6669110059738159,
0.46628665924072266,
0.3439673185348511,
-0.33755409717559814,
-0.5267693996429443,
0.7956780791282654,
-0.8118888735771179,
0.06608259677886963,
-0.7193183898925781,
0.16388095915317535,
-0.0879632830619812,
0.08008897304534912,
-0.2623963952064514,
1.0340484380722046,
0.3636079728603363,
-0.6936079263687134,
0.2254880666732788,
0.26936832070350647,
-0.6473769545555115,
0.4645957052707672,
-0.5058733224868774,
0.15775880217552185,
-0.24436020851135254,
0.22209428250789642,
-1.1556817293167114,
-0.2107500582933426,
-0.03284776955842972,
-0.29516369104385376,
0.847909152507782,
-0.41303324699401855,
-0.5042588114738464,
-0.07596580684185028,
-0.2798677384853363,
0.3736822307109833,
0.45507919788360596,
-0.8791438937187195,
0.3378145694732666,
0.5426278114318848,
-0.7699238657951355,
-0.7410987615585327,
-0.35754862427711487,
0.34170985221862793,
-0.5219279527664185,
-0.5920934677124023,
0.9153385758399963,
-0.025658052414655685,
-0.5629750490188599,
-0.3765874207019806,
-0.10039302706718445,
0.1517699807882309,
0.41231346130371094,
0.03069221042096615,
0.5171065330505371,
-0.04880623146891594,
0.41284796595573425,
0.18900765478610992,
-0.293167382478714,
0.0710899755358696,
-0.2578589916229248,
0.4828379452228546,
0.4766208529472351,
-0.2427079677581787,
-0.46730196475982666,
0.29278790950775146,
0.33268415927886963,
-0.2535536289215088,
0.7742119431495667,
-0.06376234441995621,
-0.36684417724609375,
-0.20711900293827057,
-0.5023117065429688,
-0.39575111865997314,
-0.6050649881362915,
0.3884980380535126,
-0.4422566294670105,
-0.8944031000137329,
0.12683901190757751,
-0.4714629650115967,
0.26911795139312744,
0.1084338128566742,
0.1929657757282257,
-0.28048521280288696,
1.3889882564544678,
0.9801139831542969,
-0.2906038165092468,
0.896023690700531,
0.04081306979060173,
0.31351274251937866,
-0.6531025171279907,
0.162266805768013,
-0.7187316417694092,
-0.5232394933700562,
-0.4028940796852112,
-0.5479252338409424,
0.581682026386261,
0.4554119110107422,
-0.08825290948152542,
0.24037949740886688,
-0.38057178258895874,
0.6535786986351013,
0.32026952505111694,
-0.01579640805721283,
0.09768933057785034,
-0.02389521151781082,
0.03361985459923744,
0.016988331452012062,
-0.5576028227806091,
-0.8048996925354004,
0.4901607930660248,
0.31883931159973145,
0.800897479057312,
0.10374840348958969,
0.5309324860572815,
-0.01718214340507984,
0.1746653914451599,
-0.8882602453231812,
0.7629094123840332,
-0.06650882959365845,
-0.07319949567317963,
-0.4946820139884949,
-0.2795613706111908,
-0.8883309364318848,
0.23112377524375916,
-0.14678558707237244,
-0.7010536193847656,
0.11009315401315689,
0.14708936214447021,
-0.3023928105831146,
0.227281391620636,
-0.6828031539916992,
0.45220646262168884,
-0.3250008523464203,
-0.2447369545698166,
-0.21492303907871246,
-0.43994444608688354,
0.038727808743715286,
0.16130565106868744,
0.15208882093429565,
0.19535548985004425,
-0.15382778644561768,
0.49172207713127136,
-0.601353108882904,
0.7183056473731995,
-0.5653415322303772,
-0.6076188087463379,
0.0036807777360081673,
0.3028060793876648,
1.0305020809173584,
0.06442064791917801,
-0.6174901127815247,
-0.28961122035980225,
-0.3704165816307068,
-0.395976722240448,
-0.9733828902244568,
1.0892037153244019,
-0.4597555696964264,
-0.9816259145736694,
-0.09239756315946579,
-0.7968470454216003,
-0.565239667892456,
0.08830098807811737,
0.18520492315292358,
0.41324999928474426,
-0.06813850998878479,
0.15174835920333862,
0.7921484708786011,
-0.7126508951187134,
0.6372129321098328,
0.29708990454673767,
-0.16883890330791473,
-0.1070110946893692,
0.6562963724136353,
0.14084067940711975,
0.10323596745729446,
1.080342411994934,
0.2710054814815521,
-0.5112492442131042,
-0.4073111414909363,
-0.3925832509994507,
0.19338759779930115,
-0.739593505859375,
0.005733385682106018,
-0.5921161770820618,
-0.15859200060367584,
-0.5888057947158813,
-0.6530895829200745,
-0.3309519588947296,
-0.6346480846405029,
-0.23678091168403625,
-0.40782320499420166,
0.23840844631195068,
0.4946364164352417,
0.24420829117298126,
0.45879852771759033,
-0.640114426612854,
-0.035687513649463654,
0.30197134613990784,
0.04958903044462204,
-0.2291306108236313,
-0.48444637656211853,
-0.25523847341537476,
0.14303046464920044,
-0.22956345975399017,
-0.9976426959037781,
0.31338489055633545,
-0.20855717360973358,
0.7489456534385681,
0.09412912279367447,
-0.023564353585243225,
0.6626947522163391,
-0.5875507593154907,
0.9207199811935425,
-0.025053927674889565,
-1.041384220123291,
0.6889593601226807,
-0.26705554127693176,
0.4487358331680298,
0.2389836609363556,
0.33791252970695496,
-0.5453886389732361,
-0.19620738923549652,
-0.3671109974384308,
-0.9762492179870605,
0.7458838224411011,
-0.2603706121444702,
0.08901870250701904,
0.07244478911161423,
0.5688292980194092,
-0.011940415017306805,
0.035899870097637177,
-0.42014291882514954,
-0.04987183213233948,
0.2167952060699463,
-0.22250089049339294,
-0.12461788207292557,
-0.5400367975234985,
0.05731437727808952,
-0.06969232112169266,
1.026841163635254,
-0.14796432852745056,
0.10066801309585571,
0.04174162819981575,
-0.335804283618927,
0.01611955091357231,
0.34772753715515137,
0.5392731428146362,
0.8315632343292236,
0.13286270201206207,
0.15159451961517334,
0.28204891085624695,
0.07231517136096954,
0.3588535189628601,
0.1245134249329567,
-0.5278018712997437,
0.03486480191349983,
0.16312085092067719,
0.7531521320343018,
0.655089795589447,
-0.4249856173992157,
0.32000118494033813,
0.4210052192211151,
0.26627346873283386,
0.055097538977861404,
0.05325339362025261,
-0.1228368878364563,
0.3328840136528015,
0.37197375297546387,
-0.22015011310577393,
0.0681791752576828,
-0.5046250224113464,
0.07281734049320221,
0.4699847996234894,
-0.2999061048030853,
-0.3545326292514801,
0.7238731980323792,
-0.00019797927234321833,
-0.5759345293045044,
0.2719448208808899,
0.07584944367408752,
-0.1874586045742035,
0.42925313115119934,
0.7364738583564758,
0.6678184866905212,
-0.7360284328460693,
0.4606091380119324,
0.3665916919708252,
0.027779892086982727,
-0.3313945531845093,
0.10512422770261765,
0.20442257821559906,
-0.5018631815910339,
-1.0184741020202637,
-0.3115141987800598,
-0.38303253054618835,
-0.00935099646449089,
-0.27544379234313965,
0.5664231181144714,
-0.27154096961021423,
-0.04681987315416336,
-0.18599392473697662,
-0.2818154990673065,
-0.2692342698574066,
-0.056888435035943985,
0.1496189385652542,
0.9618224501609802,
-0.24219439923763275,
0.6995657086372375,
1.226401925086975,
0.07509537041187286,
-0.8231892585754395,
0.11903276294469833,
-0.17225687205791473,
-0.5037355422973633,
0.761089563369751,
0.3521941602230072,
-0.21934272348880768,
0.03930506110191345,
-0.9349309206008911,
-0.9896798729896545,
1.0535603761672974,
0.5915865302085876,
-0.4336397647857666,
-0.3548440635204315,
-0.026835989207029343,
0.3925822377204895,
-0.1452247053384781,
0.23795568943023682,
0.1126105934381485,
0.3210015296936035,
-0.022633541375398636,
-0.766852855682373,
0.11002852022647858,
-0.16664713621139526,
0.4532112181186676,
0.34239858388900757,
-0.5328525304794312,
0.6324001550674438,
-0.04538271948695183,
-0.4217403531074524,
0.24630512297153473,
0.7033507227897644,
0.6951155662536621,
-0.013217480853199959,
0.6355488896369934,
0.0923495814204216,
0.9393523335456848,
0.12087518721818924,
1.0810742378234863,
-0.5126562118530273,
0.24567292630672455,
1.0427193641662598,
-0.4823959469795227,
0.830679714679718,
0.6318597197532654,
0.2603916823863983,
0.4265286922454834,
0.4784044027328491,
0.4097585082054138,
0.42494240403175354,
0.010129663161933422,
-0.22528044879436493,
-0.2410338968038559,
-0.11433576047420502,
-0.25867003202438354,
0.36160746216773987,
0.3490681052207947,
-0.4317686855792999,
-0.14086103439331055,
0.32881584763526917,
0.047125622630119324,
0.27428168058395386,
-0.396785169839859,
0.6031596064567566,
0.1301846206188202,
-0.7379146814346313,
0.5889750123023987,
0.40301647782325745,
0.5461811423301697,
-0.4477299749851227,
-0.201468363404274,
0.04381277784705162,
-0.16275189816951752,
0.11623100936412811,
-0.8559978604316711,
0.12636792659759521,
-0.03749006986618042,
-0.3099333643913269,
-1.0454061031341553,
0.9387097954750061,
-0.29741379618644714,
-0.2534187436103821,
0.2671450078487396,
0.2413288652896881,
-0.11054079979658127,
-0.2605126202106476,
-0.4608304500579834,
-0.32952001690864563,
-0.24564753472805023,
-0.30786198377609253,
0.4577734172344208,
0.6034149527549744,
-0.21923792362213135,
0.6554262638092041,
0.721291184425354,
0.042354848235845566,
-0.160238578915596,
-0.09378820657730103,
0.72882479429245,
-0.9167380332946777,
-0.786856472492218,
-0.8921087980270386,
0.42095279693603516,
-0.11413007974624634,
0.12863127887248993,
0.8929464221000671,
0.3702612817287445,
0.778962254524231,
-0.20759911835193634,
0.851780891418457,
0.005430166609585285,
0.6869384050369263,
-0.8330993056297302,
0.5430249571800232,
-0.3948448598384857,
0.6166859269142151,
-0.3672854006290436,
-1.0989573001861572,
-0.3424627482891083,
0.45621761679649353,
-0.6552711725234985,
-0.19243432581424713,
0.39218589663505554,
1.0112642049789429,
0.02068213000893593,
-0.03580964356660843,
0.32273122668266296,
0.4819691479206085,
0.553162157535553,
0.2723802328109741,
1.2448443174362183,
-0.18877024948596954,
0.25292181968688965,
-0.30169013142585754,
-0.33334144949913025,
-0.15894059836864471,
-0.9257479906082153,
-0.6311172246932983,
-0.4104560911655426,
-0.13274693489074707,
-0.20778536796569824,
-0.10640677064657211,
1.288901448249817,
0.8199594020843506,
-0.7696625590324402,
-0.30663448572158813,
0.2718832194805145,
0.3572070300579071,
-0.3654402494430542,
-0.2388596087694168,
0.31494301557540894,
-0.5109868049621582,
-0.96113520860672,
1.2125415802001953,
0.4707610011100769,
-0.06643841415643692,
-0.17495690286159515,
0.05960538610816002,
-0.3502750098705292,
-0.13359610736370087,
0.9824548363685608,
0.25345054268836975,
-0.4942410886287689,
-0.43832117319107056,
0.24203699827194214,
-0.2457984983921051,
0.07510694861412048,
1.0750349760055542,
-0.6958940029144287,
0.17212408781051636,
0.8767074942588806,
0.878025233745575,
-0.07873580604791641,
0.4577549993991852,
0.8077283501625061,
-1.1181395053863525,
0.18765364587306976,
0.023230139166116714,
0.3961414396762848,
0.4453267455101013,
-0.816748857498169,
0.29320237040519714,
-0.11337579041719437,
-0.7449227571487427,
-0.7237988114356995,
0.26057693362236023,
-0.7616360187530518,
-0.5811561346054077,
1.4806238412857056,
0.20983999967575073,
-0.1503622680902481,
0.15561510622501373,
-0.6245350241661072,
0.23828084766864777,
-0.1777273714542389,
1.0356688499450684,
0.6682772040367126,
0.0003403536102268845,
-0.1785784661769867,
-0.5972602963447571,
0.3334711194038391,
0.6193791627883911,
-0.7132341265678406,
-0.1400385946035385,
0.4846257269382477,
0.15188804268836975,
0.2108842134475708,
0.3198905289173126,
-0.09990723431110382,
-0.14067085087299347,
-0.7174996137619019,
0.10681946575641632,
0.16594509780406952,
-0.4782847762107849,
-0.42006954550743103,
0.3440011441707611,
0.19609782099723816,
-0.052131328731775284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11206v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11206v1
|
Prompt-tuning for Clickbait Detection via Text Summarization
| 2024-04-17T09:39:02 | 2024-04-17T09:39:02 |
Haoxiang Deng, Yi Zhu, Ye Wang, Jipeng Qiang, Yunhao Yuan, Yun Li, Runmei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Clickbaits are surprising social posts or deceptive news headlines that
attempt to lure users for more clicks, which have posted at unprecedented rates
for more profit or commercial revenue. The spread of clickbait has significant
negative impacts on the users, which brings users misleading or even
click-jacking attacks. Different from fake news, the crucial problem in
clickbait detection is determining whether the headline matches the
corresponding content. Most existing methods compute the semantic similarity
between the headlines and contents for detecting clickbait. However, due to
significant differences in length and semantic features between headlines and
contents, directly calculating semantic similarity is often difficult to
summarize the relationship between them. To address this problem, we propose a
prompt-tuning method for clickbait detection via text summarization in this
paper, text summarization is introduced to summarize the contents, and
clickbait detection is performed based on the similarity between the generated
summary and the contents. Specifically, we first introduce a two-stage text
summarization model to produce high-quality news summaries based on pre-trained
language models, and then both the headlines and new generated summaries are
incorporated as the inputs for prompt-tuning. Additionally, a variety of
strategies are conducted to incorporate external knowledge for improving the
performance of clickbait detection. The extensive experiments on well-known
clickbait detection datasets demonstrate that our method achieved
state-of-the-art performance.
|
[
-0.507190465927124,
-0.7791671752929688,
0.6693358421325684,
0.4197567403316498,
-0.6526090502738953,
-0.038518134504556656,
-0.11446218937635422,
-0.10353252291679382,
0.5585809946060181,
0.6074490547180176,
-0.7753289937973022,
-0.5109833478927612,
-0.5779288411140442,
0.63821941614151,
-0.3010495901107788,
1.3204529285430908,
0.36631444096565247,
-0.25164541602134705,
-0.23109132051467896,
0.008004306815564632,
-0.7828871607780457,
0.23214417695999146,
-0.7704342007637024,
0.213419109582901,
0.5697256922721863,
0.3992111384868622,
0.5245803594589233,
0.3839094936847687,
0.3491867482662201,
0.2755584120750427,
-0.2476532757282257,
0.4531427323818207,
-0.4897657334804535,
-0.029576335102319717,
-0.2279169261455536,
-0.34288692474365234,
-0.15445275604724884,
0.1279047280550003,
0.5151887536048889,
0.4164910316467285,
0.26898449659347534,
0.14591404795646667,
0.2206851989030838,
0.7344881892204285,
-0.44362807273864746,
-0.04622441530227661,
-0.6413435935974121,
-0.3327782452106476,
-0.07944894582033157,
-0.8679317831993103,
-0.39941635727882385,
-0.8468139171600342,
-0.03962094336748123,
-0.6470081210136414,
0.3749021887779236,
0.4417389929294586,
0.7903015613555908,
0.4025583565235138,
-0.6877956390380859,
-0.3685474097728729,
-0.013715259730815887,
0.5072797536849976,
-0.6787315607070923,
0.0020218698773533106,
0.3682542145252228,
0.13314633071422577,
-0.2953115701675415,
-0.2579170763492584,
-0.3081428110599518,
-0.35843777656555176,
-0.43104568123817444,
0.253484845161438,
-0.14345256984233856,
-0.06463946402072906,
0.3510964512825012,
0.1183452159166336,
-0.9504095315933228,
-0.034434475004673004,
-0.3200058341026306,
-0.3889487683773041,
0.4827427566051483,
0.18837925791740417,
0.41328638792037964,
-0.48113659024238586,
-0.5105996131896973,
0.08898641914129257,
-0.37596675753593445,
0.12632176280021667,
0.6505459547042847,
0.3635912239551544,
-0.13232533633708954,
0.36107930541038513,
-0.7004994750022888,
0.8133899569511414,
0.4957917332649231,
-0.25762778520584106,
0.27247774600982666,
-0.5000321269035339,
0.21485839784145355,
0.4444117248058319,
0.6487184762954712,
1.0831332206726074,
0.45791587233543396,
0.06075116619467735,
-0.09180689603090286,
-0.016897615045309067,
0.1806478500366211,
-0.7940868139266968,
-0.20306898653507233,
0.16508963704109192,
-0.7101987600326538,
-0.8252254128456116,
0.15642285346984863,
-0.6897875070571899,
-0.4160955250263214,
-0.35018399357795715,
0.6749280691146851,
-0.4097283184528351,
-0.1292242705821991,
0.01981537789106369,
-0.4790462851524353,
0.1667538434267044,
0.20013634860515594,
-0.7213438749313354,
-0.09464765340089798,
0.6264727711677551,
0.9155324101448059,
-0.4133848547935486,
-0.41797348856925964,
-1.1214228868484497,
0.024295587092638016,
-0.30216535925865173,
1.181465744972229,
-0.392636239528656,
-0.26883527636528015,
0.044747352600097656,
0.15113332867622375,
-0.12899476289749146,
-0.469329833984375,
0.45549702644348145,
-0.7795126438140869,
0.26358821988105774,
-0.637002170085907,
-0.5006266236305237,
-0.26691946387290955,
0.41405415534973145,
-0.713935911655426,
0.8317136168479919,
-0.16099542379379272,
-1.0236018896102905,
0.627582311630249,
-0.626537561416626,
-0.898401141166687,
0.08284261077642441,
0.36734139919281006,
-0.3134486973285675,
0.2332495003938675,
0.5571192502975464,
0.29913684725761414,
0.0837230533361435,
0.15771526098251343,
0.06519696116447449,
-0.4744144082069397,
0.303667277097702,
-0.12948165833950043,
0.6728046536445618,
0.11465145647525787,
-0.10168416053056717,
0.28092876076698303,
-0.5585755705833435,
-0.31716617941856384,
-0.1356470286846161,
-0.30790168046951294,
-0.6242601275444031,
-0.31109490990638733,
-0.09737856686115265,
-0.00716292904689908,
0.4220917224884033,
-0.23738853633403778,
-0.00954497791826725,
-0.5478450655937195,
-0.0858636125922203,
0.4808628559112549,
0.4339875280857086,
0.397830605506897,
-0.511357843875885,
0.5640991926193237,
0.08768977224826813,
0.18475273251533508,
-1.0010147094726562,
-0.3595597445964813,
-0.2880885601043701,
0.16497507691383362,
0.3152250051498413,
0.7021450996398926,
-0.7884560227394104,
0.6517369747161865,
-0.10600199550390244,
-0.22634181380271912,
-0.2616434395313263,
0.11173667758703232,
0.15212701261043549,
0.7319387197494507,
0.3903333246707916,
0.15057240426540375,
-0.2857646346092224,
-0.560409665107727,
-1.0221202373504639,
0.1773575097322464,
-0.22309981286525726,
-0.06582654267549515,
0.448897123336792,
0.342075914144516,
1.0992379188537598,
-0.8399578928947449,
-0.560257613658905,
-0.2291615754365921,
0.5025820136070251,
0.3754008710384369,
0.2075989842414856,
0.6835910081863403,
-1.1686760187149048,
-0.5975457429885864,
-0.335412859916687,
-0.45478782057762146,
-0.487104207277298,
-0.2942444682121277,
0.06504318863153458,
-0.02692333422601223,
0.6586223840713501,
-0.36464008688926697,
0.201066792011261,
0.19233007729053497,
-0.7150953412055969,
0.8182593584060669,
-0.1559601128101349,
0.6760367751121521,
-1.2202177047729492,
-0.014981732703745365,
0.08233824372291565,
-0.4288194179534912,
-0.417595237493515,
-0.27046167850494385,
0.24954712390899658,
-0.04683098942041397,
-0.3647729456424713,
0.39014601707458496,
-0.29458189010620117,
0.21404306590557098,
-0.7391682267189026,
0.42377933859825134,
0.057094547897577286,
0.32576486468315125,
-0.06504858285188675,
0.9296499490737915,
0.4110413193702698,
-0.9248294830322266,
0.45311546325683594,
0.27088528871536255,
-0.2025870382785797,
0.8370661735534668,
-0.8069530129432678,
-0.4671129584312439,
-0.5233830809593201,
0.4461512267589569,
-1.3484396934509277,
-0.2604553997516632,
0.40709230303764343,
-0.8511787056922913,
-0.024946928024291992,
-0.2599003314971924,
-0.44718438386917114,
-0.12740901112556458,
-0.860498309135437,
0.23872138559818268,
0.28783562779426575,
-0.4257168471813202,
0.45373716950416565,
-0.0953301414847374,
-0.4101767838001251,
-0.3215813934803009,
-0.20381738245487213,
0.19315174221992493,
-0.28550663590431213,
-0.40834325551986694,
0.3184879720211029,
-0.09320171177387238,
0.23703210055828094,
0.07322552800178528,
0.017628362402319908,
0.42688077688217163,
0.0852743610739708,
-0.14848767220973969,
0.1576484888792038,
0.04916089400649071,
0.14823204278945923,
0.40299075841903687,
-0.6254333257675171,
0.019891146570444107,
-0.37300825119018555,
0.40861251950263977,
0.32035723328590393,
-0.07865622639656067,
-0.6100991368293762,
0.39205992221832275,
0.4639298617839813,
-0.43970367312431335,
0.5846304297447205,
0.8826836347579956,
-0.12299405038356781,
-0.0810592770576477,
-0.5090171098709106,
-0.4960474669933319,
-0.4838680624961853,
0.14944173395633698,
0.04305528849363327,
-0.6041934490203857,
0.32043659687042236,
-0.35763853788375854,
-0.2556701600551605,
0.503212034702301,
0.23489125072956085,
-0.057505760341882706,
1.1285483837127686,
0.6571813821792603,
0.023274777457118034,
0.5107386112213135,
0.06102271378040314,
0.036101505160331726,
-0.3651427626609802,
-0.07253982871770859,
-0.3784162998199463,
-0.44540661573410034,
-0.542551577091217,
0.05754736810922623,
0.6375336647033691,
-0.16038352251052856,
0.14095908403396606,
0.4355306923389435,
-0.31095513701438904,
0.8566993474960327,
0.643059492111206,
0.1858806014060974,
0.5969069004058838,
-0.06789209693670273,
0.10961034893989563,
-0.073976069688797,
-0.30156031250953674,
-0.31018969416618347,
0.676831066608429,
-0.2484935224056244,
0.6980168223381042,
-0.07998927682638168,
0.42621204257011414,
0.7342531085014343,
-0.1923770159482956,
-0.7023011445999146,
0.4781506061553955,
-0.05983218178153038,
-0.20618242025375366,
-0.23321419954299927,
-0.4422993063926697,
-0.8373346924781799,
0.08955919742584229,
-0.29079297184944153,
-0.3936901390552521,
-0.05499829724431038,
0.17898325622081757,
-0.4562307298183441,
0.11669788509607315,
-0.4425927400588989,
0.7443618774414062,
0.033224865794181824,
0.11889787763357162,
-0.41061490774154663,
-0.674720823764801,
0.3763854503631592,
0.08698995411396027,
0.2086179405450821,
-0.17623098194599152,
-0.21073026955127716,
0.7729789018630981,
-0.26222145557403564,
0.8676142692565918,
-0.179648295044899,
-0.28401193022727966,
0.09714066982269287,
0.0010035316227003932,
0.8094425201416016,
0.33546459674835205,
0.40110570192337036,
-0.3127347230911255,
-0.1842776983976364,
-0.469431072473526,
-0.398065447807312,
0.6771143078804016,
-0.11622506380081177,
-0.37322720885276794,
-0.2934122383594513,
-0.39450398087501526,
-0.057249221950769424,
0.5004915595054626,
0.7597643136978149,
0.6629216074943542,
-0.06704949587583542,
-0.040211182087659836,
0.8299040794372559,
-0.26561152935028076,
0.7752668857574463,
0.6084592342376709,
-0.0760987177491188,
-0.5641478300094604,
0.9930006265640259,
-0.08625525236129761,
-0.12349599599838257,
0.4762141704559326,
0.12941987812519073,
-0.5235790014266968,
-0.4543987810611725,
-0.45202937722206116,
0.32498854398727417,
-0.3079477846622467,
-0.4532148838043213,
-0.8167360424995422,
0.1337330937385559,
-0.48880794644355774,
-0.43977823853492737,
-0.008647916838526726,
-0.09384840726852417,
-0.46595898270606995,
0.12347792088985443,
0.7314851880073547,
0.37834712862968445,
0.06932391971349716,
0.5847412347793579,
-1.0392335653305054,
0.7944333553314209,
0.3188580274581909,
0.2047390192747116,
-0.16800925135612488,
-0.6820023059844971,
-0.29744842648506165,
-0.15489870309829712,
-0.304169237613678,
-1.0985665321350098,
0.2390744388103485,
-0.018616802990436554,
0.22388845682144165,
0.7053946852684021,
0.5408477187156677,
0.16037710011005402,
-0.19995644688606262,
0.8194330930709839,
0.14828689396381378,
-0.7942973971366882,
0.914566695690155,
-0.7501237392425537,
0.573718249797821,
0.7733587026596069,
0.6251504421234131,
-0.48794230818748474,
-0.37781479954719543,
-0.29920694231987,
-0.7422852516174316,
0.7143111824989319,
0.1443708837032318,
0.20767006278038025,
-0.034892093390226364,
0.08668588101863861,
0.32616257667541504,
0.44788506627082825,
-0.4180356562137604,
-0.266353040933609,
0.0843881145119667,
-0.18110238015651703,
-0.1274109184741974,
-0.4818439185619354,
0.3537231385707855,
0.1307523250579834,
0.7118332982063293,
-0.2741059362888336,
-0.354889839887619,
-0.05572735518217087,
-0.5142476558685303,
0.023097887635231018,
0.22331736981868744,
0.538800060749054,
0.7600647807121277,
-0.157383993268013,
-0.09774845838546753,
0.23783235251903534,
-0.5668871402740479,
0.1276778280735016,
0.14379964768886566,
-0.5094348788261414,
0.27021971344947815,
0.31401142477989197,
0.6084835529327393,
0.6328911185264587,
-0.6737905740737915,
0.8175058960914612,
-0.0051920111291110516,
-0.07236025482416153,
-0.04473571851849556,
0.07366734743118286,
-0.13047966361045837,
0.1457400619983673,
0.656230628490448,
0.1014338880777359,
0.5427121520042419,
-0.17266494035720825,
0.26857197284698486,
0.25925055146217346,
-0.1851814091205597,
-0.24836775660514832,
0.7648127675056458,
0.528064489364624,
-0.18157276511192322,
0.3703935146331787,
-0.2200736403465271,
-0.6350134611129761,
0.6705270409584045,
0.528861403465271,
0.9524676203727722,
-0.22188501060009003,
0.530573844909668,
0.43585947155952454,
0.33912965655326843,
-0.05455061420798302,
0.2488296926021576,
-0.3182663023471832,
-0.42487451434135437,
-0.5942850112915039,
-0.5283633470535278,
-0.2643031179904938,
-0.03877350315451622,
-0.6535488963127136,
0.6657902598381042,
0.05633559823036194,
-0.05422494187951088,
0.015735911205410957,
0.10930274426937103,
-0.218309223651886,
0.035351697355508804,
-0.0363239161670208,
0.9420386552810669,
-1.119170904159546,
0.08235905319452286,
0.7887123227119446,
-0.2591058909893036,
-0.1968947947025299,
0.42734748125076294,
0.10264058411121368,
-0.3182087540626526,
0.07903482764959335,
0.47975555062294006,
-0.172681987285614,
0.44559091329574585,
-0.5067859292030334,
-0.5671434998512268,
0.9424529075622559,
0.23825784027576447,
-0.33910292387008667,
0.036923959851264954,
-0.1350027471780777,
0.034935519099235535,
-0.09126532077789307,
0.21225577592849731,
0.6116584539413452,
0.7433644533157349,
0.051574498414993286,
-0.8184980154037476,
0.2585103511810303,
0.03918447345495224,
-0.16926398873329163,
0.3853534460067749,
-0.7292926907539368,
0.5712440609931946,
-0.32969018816947937,
-0.06447809934616089,
-0.14000940322875977,
0.5347926020622253,
0.1309160441160202,
0.6821788549423218,
0.659047544002533,
0.36776575446128845,
0.4575883746147156,
0.021249325945973396,
0.7232059836387634,
-0.36583411693573,
0.34125131368637085,
0.8182204365730286,
0.08403417468070984,
0.255546510219574,
0.15612229704856873,
-0.013198979198932648,
0.3025082051753998,
0.6209557056427002,
-0.18714872002601624,
0.6426778435707092,
-0.15463125705718994,
-0.10294836014509201,
-0.3718929886817932,
-0.3212757408618927,
-0.5149366855621338,
0.3512657582759857,
0.1899087131023407,
-0.3772260546684265,
-0.6600731611251831,
0.37203890085220337,
0.22288009524345398,
0.33715900778770447,
-0.5803446769714355,
1.034804105758667,
-0.15711575746536255,
-0.6776236891746521,
0.28856319189071655,
-0.036782894283533096,
1.0264228582382202,
-0.632198691368103,
0.12455204874277115,
-0.2689879536628723,
-0.4064018428325653,
-0.2758616805076599,
-0.4984091818332672,
0.1177372857928276,
0.05471356213092804,
-0.46799081563949585,
-0.07120835781097412,
0.9357202053070068,
-0.4630611836910248,
-0.24232709407806396,
-0.023317795246839523,
0.4138355553150177,
0.01573917828500271,
-0.5848428010940552,
-0.3095342814922333,
-0.07056014984846115,
-0.07676684111356735,
-0.24296577274799347,
0.11730613559484482,
0.3292924463748932,
0.16454188525676727,
0.41862380504608154,
0.7521700859069824,
-0.008998437784612179,
-0.3322738707065582,
0.0003947069635614753,
0.7792516350746155,
-0.9404229521751404,
-1.395627498626709,
-0.9498181343078613,
0.32506322860717773,
-0.34647315740585327,
-0.3514571189880371,
0.7626035213470459,
0.7124969959259033,
0.4905450940132141,
-0.3423667848110199,
0.7373084425926208,
0.12734262645244598,
0.6236343383789062,
-0.6724400520324707,
0.8559607863426208,
-0.5689049959182739,
0.07990578562021255,
-0.278887003660202,
-0.9816524982452393,
-0.11067409813404083,
0.016302574425935745,
-0.31533390283584595,
0.14011143147945404,
0.6453632116317749,
0.7173410654067993,
-0.12428797036409378,
0.08358046412467957,
0.17582739889621735,
0.13557963073253632,
-0.11719615757465363,
0.12463254481554031,
0.7007077932357788,
-0.24662862718105316,
0.7647813558578491,
0.09834352880716324,
-0.38946542143821716,
-0.8574163317680359,
-1.144369125366211,
-1.0599316358566284,
-0.5767556428909302,
-0.47937944531440735,
-0.024300120770931244,
-0.04427342116832733,
0.7480596303939819,
0.34138596057891846,
-0.7941452860832214,
0.31883713603019714,
0.1563977301120758,
0.26998305320739746,
-0.382156103849411,
-0.3633042871952057,
0.45644545555114746,
-0.6454946398735046,
-0.6537023186683655,
0.3568616509437561,
0.28315839171409607,
0.042867958545684814,
0.15146325528621674,
0.32450762391090393,
-0.033893391489982605,
0.2249307930469513,
0.6354583501815796,
0.018670596182346344,
-0.33986207842826843,
-0.048693541437387466,
-0.007910587824881077,
0.15214411914348602,
-0.33294105529785156,
0.993901252746582,
-1.1580883264541626,
0.09608510881662369,
0.618074357509613,
0.2545259892940521,
0.17070403695106506,
0.5689042210578918,
0.27197495102882385,
-0.7401698231697083,
0.07458998262882233,
-0.125738725066185,
-0.07472085952758789,
0.25172823667526245,
-0.7427530884742737,
-0.05795716494321823,
0.23110821843147278,
-0.3781987428665161,
-0.5608683228492737,
0.14691856503486633,
-1.010898470878601,
-0.28982603549957275,
0.9382858276367188,
0.3529210388660431,
-0.11132250726222992,
-0.16524137556552887,
-0.5980316996574402,
0.30509209632873535,
-0.7003744840621948,
0.9228845238685608,
0.2893390953540802,
0.19355028867721558,
0.023427706211805344,
-0.2772482633590698,
0.8578543663024902,
0.11722102016210556,
-0.7011104822158813,
-0.09418211132287979,
0.4330446720123291,
0.5277705192565918,
0.0414937324821949,
0.434696227312088,
0.20482589304447174,
0.5658140778541565,
-0.18024764955043793,
-0.617382287979126,
-0.36947301030158997,
-0.2708769738674164,
-0.3567027151584625,
0.19575689733028412,
-0.45407578349113464,
-0.5100557208061218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11205v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11205v2
|
Pose2Gest: A Few-Shot Model-Free Approach Applied In South Indian Classical Dance Gesture Recognition
| 2024-04-17T09:37:25 | 2024-05-17T10:14:10 |
Kavitha Raju, Nandini J. Warrier, Manu Madhavan, Selvi C., Arun B. Warrier, Thulasi Kumar
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
The classical dances from India utilize a set of hand gestures known as
Mudras, serving as the foundational elements of its posture vocabulary.
Identifying these mudras represents a primary task in digitizing the dance
performances. With Kathakali, a dance-drama, as the focus, this work addresses
mudra recognition by framing it as a 24-class classification problem and
proposes a novel vector-similarity-based approach leveraging pose estimation
techniques. This method obviates the need for extensive training or
fine-tuning, thus mitigating the issue of limited data availability common in
similar AI applications. Achieving an accuracy rate of 92%, our approach
demonstrates comparable or superior performance to existing
model-training-based methodologies in this domain. Notably, it remains
effective even with small datasets comprising just 1 or 5 samples, albeit with
a slightly diminished performance. Furthermore, our system supports processing
images, videos, and real-time streams, accommodating both hand-cropped and
full-body images. As part of this research, we have curated and released a
publicly accessible Hasta Mudra dataset, which applies to multiple South Indian
art forms including Kathakali. The implementation of the proposed method is
also made available as a web application.
|
[
-0.012270049192011356,
0.2130347490310669,
0.07746478915214539,
-0.05541269853711128,
-0.6864852905273438,
-0.010775500908493996,
0.35774287581443787,
-0.6024413108825684,
0.4929616153240204,
0.057669322937726974,
-0.480502188205719,
-0.2535497546195984,
-0.8397689461708069,
-0.4745090901851654,
-0.5059955716133118,
0.42023783922195435,
0.043431881815195084,
0.3010788857936859,
-0.19171348214149475,
-0.5026735067367554,
-0.32765501737594604,
0.16893815994262695,
-0.3059034049510956,
-0.43093717098236084,
-0.12466928362846375,
0.5647730231285095,
0.3808184862136841,
0.13007014989852905,
0.4772733151912689,
0.1909838616847992,
0.08040817826986313,
0.2956062853336334,
-0.35506966710090637,
0.27019792795181274,
-0.0648120790719986,
-0.7370082139968872,
-0.20780959725379944,
0.3018563687801361,
0.47989577054977417,
0.06621377915143967,
-0.3108479678630829,
0.6935657858848572,
0.0075014205649495125,
0.8816115856170654,
-0.8272340297698975,
0.041362252086400986,
-0.1687154918909073,
0.3200141489505768,
-0.5949362516403198,
0.163377583026886,
-0.06033574789762497,
-0.490596204996109,
-0.2954660952091217,
-0.4928981363773346,
0.27125781774520874,
-0.15717747807502747,
0.7553741931915283,
0.29916271567344666,
0.018176479265093803,
-0.09707822650671005,
-0.5199225544929504,
0.47768014669418335,
-0.3246728777885437,
0.4254034757614136,
0.7132004499435425,
1.0122884511947632,
0.08885057270526886,
-0.41161733865737915,
-0.4063571095466614,
0.29876434803009033,
0.2876518964767456,
0.03245430439710617,
-0.2439809888601303,
-0.3686363697052002,
0.3819831907749176,
0.3745015859603882,
-0.8689852952957153,
-0.1921767294406891,
-0.49784940481185913,
-0.14903783798217773,
0.7482759356498718,
0.29153022170066833,
0.19148008525371552,
-0.3527877926826477,
-0.31743693351745605,
-0.09290855377912521,
-0.735623836517334,
0.49739015102386475,
0.2480257898569107,
0.16965588927268982,
-0.6407266855239868,
0.7530468702316284,
-0.1430061161518097,
0.6934299468994141,
0.22062520682811737,
-0.4182927906513214,
0.050354789942502975,
0.19449187815189362,
-0.19722914695739746,
-0.22626210749149323,
0.5103982090950012,
0.44857463240623474,
0.23766006529331207,
-0.03036210499703884,
0.029810113832354546,
0.43818703293800354,
-0.14641731977462769,
-0.7022768259048462,
-0.4667898118495941,
0.04992089793086052,
-0.5007985830307007,
-0.4069434106349945,
0.059771303087472916,
-0.9770076870918274,
-1.21783447265625,
-0.5296345353126526,
0.3668214678764343,
-0.3421112298965454,
-0.5243625640869141,
-0.32269522547721863,
-0.28922078013420105,
1.1326864957809448,
0.5150195956230164,
-0.7363101243972778,
0.3662621080875397,
0.7934900522232056,
1.1882660388946533,
-0.02884667180478573,
0.13997961580753326,
-0.37581944465637207,
0.20851479470729828,
-0.6354205012321472,
0.7965274453163147,
-0.5461580753326416,
-0.35913386940956116,
-0.32560065388679504,
-0.27395880222320557,
0.11347763985395432,
-0.6988277435302734,
0.1761542409658432,
-0.22527451813220978,
-0.19055399298667908,
-0.27919939160346985,
-0.35247018933296204,
-0.24459515511989594,
0.345466673374176,
-0.6143108606338501,
1.1369061470031738,
-0.10623736679553986,
-0.8010801076889038,
0.4579089283943176,
-0.31177183985710144,
-0.3793541491031647,
-0.017988266423344612,
-0.4577076733112335,
-0.6096793413162231,
0.1948716938495636,
0.07478135079145432,
0.5669745206832886,
-0.4783334732055664,
-0.29675382375717163,
-0.4703208804130554,
-0.6070176959037781,
0.157669335603714,
0.04225786030292511,
0.5523509979248047,
0.28535521030426025,
-0.2845364809036255,
0.012378660030663013,
-1.0224589109420776,
-0.010830799117684364,
0.19445370137691498,
0.24366691708564758,
-0.47613590955734253,
-0.0476912185549736,
0.009012138471007347,
0.4304092526435852,
-0.04122030735015869,
-0.38793841004371643,
0.32782819867134094,
-0.38536110520362854,
0.23390570282936096,
0.5117645263671875,
-0.20818935334682465,
0.7366978526115417,
-0.4544558823108673,
0.7587243914604187,
-0.12304189801216125,
0.11602924019098282,
0.22183065116405487,
-0.5068364143371582,
-0.49365168809890747,
-0.49853503704071045,
0.09591303765773773,
0.5901584625244141,
-0.5163577795028687,
-0.3019096553325653,
-0.3277413249015808,
-0.9127154350280762,
-0.7701502442359924,
0.03167455270886421,
0.38589170575141907,
0.06470037996768951,
0.15037815272808075,
-0.44620630145072937,
-0.8298119902610779,
-0.5166484713554382,
-0.3177677094936371,
-0.0047034588642418385,
0.011283637955784798,
-0.14287076890468597,
0.26441067457199097,
0.31311729550361633,
0.821047842502594,
-0.3678455650806427,
-0.41353511810302734,
-0.0010189716704189777,
0.2598581314086914,
-0.052247680723667145,
0.6377319097518921,
0.7722934484481812,
-0.5018275380134583,
-0.4068637192249298,
-0.19310124218463898,
-0.9854028820991516,
0.5172141194343567,
0.29829326272010803,
-0.2682075798511505,
0.06124614551663399,
0.1726188063621521,
-0.37498801946640015,
0.7187058925628662,
0.5076990127563477,
-0.005779426544904709,
0.14191082119941711,
0.15845996141433716,
0.2719375491142273,
-1.303307056427002,
0.3199024796485901,
-0.05074908584356308,
-0.3768119513988495,
-0.4941231608390808,
0.26291584968566895,
0.022537091746926308,
-0.6591217517852783,
-0.513833224773407,
0.7340230941772461,
-0.6101548075675964,
-0.5874015688896179,
-0.4647596478462219,
-0.005425365176051855,
-0.4652419090270996,
0.2517213225364685,
0.2137356847524643,
0.46348848938941956,
0.8303781747817993,
-0.400484174489975,
0.10759627819061279,
0.3129907548427582,
-0.45097512006759644,
1.2923192977905273,
-0.2538391649723053,
0.4762757420539856,
-0.23255467414855957,
0.06191212311387062,
-1.4627397060394287,
-0.6578394174575806,
0.6005861759185791,
-0.7659561634063721,
0.5627024173736572,
-0.6739267706871033,
-0.0196993388235569,
-0.37608441710472107,
-0.6104545593261719,
0.3651310205459595,
0.6745458245277405,
-0.6001498699188232,
0.8352315425872803,
0.5979025363922119,
0.12802541255950928,
-0.7196739912033081,
-0.7592895030975342,
-0.19757528603076935,
-0.49085694551467896,
-0.4051140546798706,
-0.22591134905815125,
0.2943122088909149,
0.02446879632771015,
-0.4057653546333313,
-0.4769146740436554,
-0.12093149870634079,
-0.16624628007411957,
0.8351683616638184,
0.21978850662708282,
0.0646337941288948,
-0.1623913049697876,
0.05083515867590904,
-0.0848260149359703,
-0.28840306401252747,
0.06911471486091614,
0.44742169976234436,
0.0742897242307663,
-0.3905843496322632,
-1.0748329162597656,
0.14883580803871155,
0.9651419520378113,
-0.20214961469173431,
0.08764642477035522,
0.8149687051773071,
-0.6863059997558594,
0.15351909399032593,
-0.3878234028816223,
0.040479522198438644,
-0.393503338098526,
-0.12803736329078674,
-0.49390316009521484,
-0.359318345785141,
0.6032564640045166,
-0.1658116728067398,
-0.11113157868385315,
0.06677519530057907,
0.4311656951904297,
-0.3798494338989258,
0.6638756394386292,
0.34086787700653076,
-0.15178367495536804,
0.5318200588226318,
-0.6414316296577454,
-0.05312784016132355,
-0.6797022223472595,
-0.5492002964019775,
-0.6044424772262573,
-0.8110628724098206,
-0.5611838698387146,
-0.917733371257782,
0.289855420589447,
0.11046455800533295,
-0.3966819643974304,
0.42646604776382446,
-0.35649529099464417,
0.5447907447814941,
0.37533798813819885,
0.43596351146698,
-0.018498003482818604,
0.208106130361557,
-0.008662146516144276,
-0.11046700179576874,
-0.20796266198158264,
-0.32549381256103516,
1.0698364973068237,
0.036011870950460434,
1.008628249168396,
0.4610722064971924,
0.9873507022857666,
0.26055410504341125,
0.1248813048005104,
-1.0283451080322266,
0.6289283037185669,
-0.0453643836081028,
-0.8100296258926392,
-0.23952613770961761,
0.2424297332763672,
-0.7694495320320129,
0.26503899693489075,
-0.34248295426368713,
-0.5563663840293884,
0.4773869812488556,
0.5538402795791626,
-0.25880497694015503,
0.24212317168712616,
-0.3079281151294708,
0.5464191436767578,
0.20054398477077484,
-0.6659161448478699,
-0.28562748432159424,
-1.1145007610321045,
0.6553558707237244,
0.15954266488552094,
0.32742857933044434,
-0.553438663482666,
0.11387229710817337,
0.783950686454773,
-0.4369312822818756,
1.1261454820632935,
-0.6257421970367432,
0.23025061190128326,
0.4616906940937042,
0.4976363778114319,
0.6004902124404907,
-0.32171231508255005,
0.008514410816133022,
0.001320952083915472,
0.21086937189102173,
-0.6847668886184692,
-0.3821060359477997,
0.5883366465568542,
-0.5732720494270325,
0.19341866672039032,
-0.7117534875869751,
0.015600101090967655,
-0.3495907485485077,
-0.1777888834476471,
0.3405790627002716,
0.33167406916618347,
-0.21031847596168518,
-0.1669013798236847,
0.34551966190338135,
0.4543824791908264,
0.7106044888496399,
0.22882480919361115,
-0.20231415331363678,
-0.33387327194213867,
0.8185096383094788,
0.13035514950752258,
-0.14890068769454956,
0.29683274030685425,
0.15704523026943207,
-0.5122278332710266,
-0.35034188628196716,
-0.6850111484527588,
0.20186442136764526,
-0.6972466111183167,
-0.46486547589302063,
0.08053887635469437,
0.30532124638557434,
-0.46176677942276,
-0.24962776899337769,
-0.3832842707633972,
-0.7781261205673218,
-0.15122878551483154,
-0.12635087966918945,
0.43619897961616516,
0.6337606906890869,
-0.43765389919281006,
0.35709524154663086,
-0.5163437128067017,
0.2787056863307953,
0.6134692430496216,
0.4513082504272461,
-0.007249030284583569,
-0.5523989796638489,
0.25948336720466614,
-0.3140977919101715,
-0.3693428337574005,
-0.9915758371353149,
0.05466460809111595,
0.4103887975215912,
0.46304455399513245,
0.6196240186691284,
-0.0693918988108635,
0.9389092326164246,
-0.26266026496887207,
0.7656761407852173,
0.6296000480651855,
-0.6527844071388245,
0.7882533073425293,
-0.181253582239151,
0.15562254190444946,
0.6136905550956726,
0.5973964929580688,
-0.5025280117988586,
0.2825956344604492,
-0.3942403197288513,
-0.443710595369339,
0.705501914024353,
0.0031590608414262533,
0.17893272638320923,
0.3022647500038147,
0.3466639220714569,
0.1654001921415329,
0.13300572335720062,
-0.3896256685256958,
-0.12826423346996307,
-0.3091726005077362,
-0.3184747099876404,
0.07496810704469681,
0.0996391773223877,
-0.12644167244434357,
-0.39787766337394714,
0.6062273979187012,
0.07282587140798569,
0.21110497415065765,
-0.3073049783706665,
-0.3252488076686859,
-0.4916802644729614,
0.060048095881938934,
0.6609826683998108,
0.4311489164829254,
0.05355263501405716,
0.01290127169340849,
0.007291601970791817,
-0.7684417366981506,
0.4943169355392456,
-0.03324791043996811,
-0.16779835522174835,
-0.14698724448680878,
0.009275505319237709,
0.7580091953277588,
0.3193162977695465,
-0.45273539423942566,
0.7104892134666443,
0.38453102111816406,
0.08333656191825867,
-0.4462180435657501,
-0.1283019334077835,
-0.05287244915962219,
0.6198477745056152,
0.09104198962450027,
0.4553198516368866,
0.35615965723991394,
-0.4367484152317047,
0.0938868373632431,
0.32519271969795227,
-0.6153907775878906,
-0.5152285099029541,
0.7450604438781738,
-0.04386790469288826,
-0.27202099561691284,
0.2879229784011841,
-0.3383164703845978,
-0.05469735339283943,
0.292384535074234,
0.21063227951526642,
0.7690577507019043,
-0.8618862628936768,
0.33776187896728516,
0.8013407588005066,
-0.15299935638904572,
-0.43923985958099365,
0.7476359605789185,
-0.1688632369041443,
-0.3159528076648712,
-0.041107453405857086,
-0.6002880930900574,
-0.4073231816291809,
-0.0469641350209713,
-0.695959746837616,
0.8102658987045288,
-0.5711408853530884,
-0.04429318383336067,
-0.022498352453112602,
-0.20894794166088104,
-0.5201528072357178,
-0.018801920115947723,
0.41485536098480225,
0.5184410214424133,
-1.2079190015792847,
0.7233769297599792,
0.8912328481674194,
-0.5909823179244995,
-0.6710559725761414,
-0.061801642179489136,
0.8382511138916016,
-0.8923948407173157,
0.10746479779481888,
0.04387205094099045,
-0.44638481736183167,
-0.13152441382408142,
-0.6532923579216003,
-0.7553912997245789,
1.3467533588409424,
0.3504607081413269,
-0.6343724727630615,
-0.0784618929028511,
-0.08443446457386017,
0.39805468916893005,
0.23967710137367249,
-0.3063705265522003,
0.518729031085968,
0.17249247431755066,
0.9350537061691284,
-0.7508754730224609,
-0.3047086298465729,
-0.03233450651168823,
0.058863744139671326,
0.5611338019371033,
-0.46647992730140686,
0.3007352948188782,
-0.40639349818229675,
0.058297544717788696,
0.4217909872531891,
0.627967357635498,
0.6042686104774475,
0.6314772367477417,
0.11533934623003006,
0.728193998336792,
0.8230933547019958,
0.0726412758231163,
0.762302041053772,
0.024655833840370178,
0.43077215552330017,
1.140172004699707,
-0.24130210280418396,
1.0853909254074097,
0.3701038062572479,
-0.5938665270805359,
0.2575029134750366,
0.89777672290802,
0.20460151135921478,
0.825638473033905,
0.5155215263366699,
-0.3492654860019684,
-0.2923634350299835,
0.4709950387477875,
-0.25426235795021057,
0.9425694346427917,
0.32314446568489075,
-0.014103974215686321,
-0.3368707597255707,
0.43054741621017456,
0.17603592574596405,
0.1303633749485016,
-0.7664353847503662,
0.6280533671379089,
0.01383205782622099,
-0.2653439939022064,
0.4582197070121765,
-0.25779783725738525,
0.699561595916748,
-0.43674206733703613,
-0.13939982652664185,
-0.20490281283855438,
-0.013177284970879555,
-0.40937429666519165,
-0.503522515296936,
0.27769389748573303,
-0.024921001866459846,
0.08700994402170181,
0.30804353952407837,
1.0206187963485718,
-0.13115549087524414,
-0.5301576852798462,
-0.38426610827445984,
0.4651558995246887,
0.7828197479248047,
0.02468595653772354,
-0.5221942663192749,
-0.09340418875217438,
-0.4098908007144928,
0.27299952507019043,
0.4899042546749115,
0.004717637784779072,
-0.5060724020004272,
0.3425907790660858,
0.03146348148584366,
-0.24071289598941803,
0.200887531042099,
-0.22678379714488983,
0.4232267439365387,
-0.3325813412666321,
-0.4815531075000763,
-0.37370195984840393,
0.309417724609375,
-0.0729079470038414,
-0.08130649477243423,
0.18951085209846497,
0.6591818928718567,
0.6439934372901917,
-0.3561566472053528,
0.5620034337043762,
-0.3147872984409332,
0.8716875314712524,
-0.4370662569999695,
0.7846901416778564,
-0.525855541229248,
-0.24279436469078064,
-0.35450512170791626,
-0.4989481270313263,
-0.5300154089927673,
0.8948062658309937,
-0.3130124509334564,
-0.23078814148902893,
0.0854419469833374,
0.7432504296302795,
-0.4405468702316284,
-0.12116522341966629,
0.2650838792324066,
-0.41597995162010193,
-0.16203799843788147,
0.16605369746685028,
0.7117542028427124,
-0.6348296999931335,
0.23303258419036865,
-0.2251858115196228,
-0.23417243361473083,
-0.4776449203491211,
-0.822390079498291,
-0.591942548751831,
-0.77167809009552,
-0.47449973225593567,
-0.22309300303459167,
0.07397951930761337,
1.3636722564697266,
1.0075371265411377,
-0.97109454870224,
-0.47448691725730896,
0.4005983769893646,
-0.34736260771751404,
-0.5678461790084839,
-0.07857587188482285,
0.5882372260093689,
0.18393941223621368,
-0.776203453540802,
0.3454457223415375,
0.09048029035329819,
0.4112966060638428,
0.15902133285999298,
-0.19597095251083374,
-0.19932633638381958,
-0.0913466140627861,
0.785402238368988,
0.8183488249778748,
-0.629788339138031,
-0.277665376663208,
-0.2509441077709198,
0.16552363336086273,
0.11921564489603043,
0.8190422058105469,
-0.49784985184669495,
0.49295464158058167,
0.6047565340995789,
0.3838967978954315,
1.0027962923049927,
0.1695787012577057,
-0.2819879353046417,
-0.9206027984619141,
0.41577622294425964,
0.14972855150699615,
0.2246101051568985,
0.41271957755088806,
0.08848205953836441,
0.8795425891876221,
0.43212947249412537,
-0.008663563057780266,
-0.7488217949867249,
0.11846257746219635,
-1.5158559083938599,
0.03300802409648895,
0.9324987530708313,
-0.09138453751802444,
-0.0595548041164875,
-0.04754140228033066,
-0.453908234834671,
0.3340469300746918,
-0.04800183326005936,
0.5191450119018555,
0.4707379639148712,
-0.6231697797775269,
-0.4739745259284973,
-0.4208197295665741,
0.6348360776901245,
-0.15418435633182526,
-0.6045401096343994,
-0.17708401381969452,
0.8357588648796082,
0.7699138522148132,
0.010113280266523361,
0.8697397112846375,
-0.5435466170310974,
0.5245590806007385,
-0.1454472839832306,
0.29069221019744873,
0.13313619792461395,
-0.30406704545021057,
-0.5850816369056702,
0.4180104732513428,
0.20239004492759705,
-0.8643920421600342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11201v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11201v1
|
Neuron Specialization: Leveraging intrinsic task modularity for multilingual machine translation
| 2024-04-17T09:33:19 | 2024-04-17T09:33:19 |
Shaomu Tan, Di Wu, Christof Monz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Training a unified multilingual model promotes knowledge transfer but
inevitably introduces negative interference. Language-specific modeling methods
show promise in reducing interference. However, they often rely on heuristics
to distribute capacity and struggle to foster cross-lingual transfer via
isolated modules. In this paper, we explore intrinsic task modularity within
multilingual networks and leverage these observations to circumvent
interference under multilingual translation. We show that neurons in the
feed-forward layers tend to be activated in a language-specific manner.
Meanwhile, these specialized neurons exhibit structural overlaps that reflect
language proximity, which progress across layers. Based on these findings, we
propose Neuron Specialization, an approach that identifies specialized neurons
to modularize feed-forward layers and then continuously updates them through
sparse networks. Extensive experiments show that our approach achieves
consistent performance gains over strong baselines with additional analyses
demonstrating reduced interference and increased knowledge transfer.
|
[
-0.13003894686698914,
-0.6867234110832214,
0.27922436594963074,
0.5263761878013611,
-0.005318977404385805,
0.03475150093436241,
-0.3997610807418823,
-0.5225031971931458,
0.305715948343277,
0.2145729660987854,
-0.3861348330974579,
-0.08128959685564041,
-0.7012301683425903,
0.07497779279947281,
-0.3218725323677063,
0.8520438075065613,
0.09148630499839783,
0.08884047716856003,
-0.29245230555534363,
-0.25653669238090515,
-0.2763666808605194,
-0.786970853805542,
-0.41035038232803345,
-0.7339546084403992,
0.9367391467094421,
0.17084847390651703,
0.4681120812892914,
0.4221198856830597,
0.2757440507411957,
0.34721675515174866,
-0.26977303624153137,
0.3635244369506836,
0.09270554780960083,
0.015938786789774895,
-0.29613780975341797,
-0.5158735513687134,
-0.6754891276359558,
-0.5132359266281128,
0.8682053685188293,
0.8777366280555725,
0.06931937485933304,
-0.10000074654817581,
0.09149385243654251,
0.4342910349369049,
-0.3789754807949066,
0.18131163716316223,
-0.6880502700805664,
0.2820132076740265,
-0.15534910559654236,
0.09868766367435455,
-0.4161902666091919,
0.09096194058656693,
-0.09363588690757751,
-0.3587389588356018,
0.11035341024398804,
-0.4018521010875702,
0.5482273101806641,
-0.04987436160445213,
-0.5230417251586914,
0.2612229287624359,
-0.44983720779418945,
0.5802741646766663,
-0.7664293050765991,
0.07538263499736786,
0.45961081981658936,
-0.18875940144062042,
0.1532936990261078,
-0.367586225271225,
-0.4420357644557953,
-0.3298276364803314,
-0.2914056181907654,
-0.06861872225999832,
-0.13669554889202118,
-0.0130109041929245,
0.20134542882442474,
0.12462184578180313,
-0.39826709032058716,
0.20381908118724823,
-0.5004104971885681,
-0.29096904397010803,
0.41385340690612793,
-0.11888955533504486,
0.7579894065856934,
-0.06891553848981857,
-0.2282738983631134,
0.2664582133293152,
-0.6087937951087952,
0.04778978228569031,
0.6851930618286133,
0.27669835090637207,
0.1346644014120102,
0.5352593660354614,
-0.2221430391073227,
0.7063372135162354,
0.056996285915374756,
0.107004314661026,
0.5593044757843018,
-0.42489147186279297,
-0.0016883607022464275,
0.05763790383934975,
0.685437798500061,
-0.14771679043769836,
0.23894062638282776,
-0.6120302677154541,
-0.4666019082069397,
-0.3341156542301178,
0.5725017189979553,
-0.4605160057544708,
-0.07816499471664429,
0.02007043920457363,
-0.2932511270046234,
0.03611195459961891,
-0.4232972264289856,
-0.15203332901000977,
0.18003781139850616,
-0.49084797501564026,
0.5492279529571533,
-0.4364919364452362,
-0.5141247510910034,
-0.010864782147109509,
-0.14955930411815643,
-0.40193915367126465,
-0.01182330958545208,
-1.3747440576553345,
0.30326759815216064,
0.49687764048576355,
1.003423810005188,
-0.3743593692779541,
-0.8931226134300232,
-0.2840479016304016,
0.4238358438014984,
-0.3043699264526367,
0.7529496550559998,
-0.29040929675102234,
0.04828155040740967,
-0.15693879127502441,
0.2769797742366791,
-0.497832715511322,
-0.5846493244171143,
0.14521582424640656,
-0.6433655619621277,
-0.36676374077796936,
-0.2094598114490509,
-0.051607973873615265,
-0.4248422384262085,
0.40267622470855713,
-0.5470371246337891,
0.7844724655151367,
0.09436102211475372,
-0.43901166319847107,
0.15681135654449463,
-0.45999234914779663,
-1.005632758140564,
0.039070822298526764,
0.12108120322227478,
-0.08183401077985764,
0.38413479924201965,
0.09222289174795151,
0.4401637017726898,
0.1271628439426422,
0.2396976798772812,
-0.09567970037460327,
-0.09745390713214874,
0.22757358849048615,
-0.10770556330680847,
0.49451518058776855,
-0.05956612899899483,
-0.42210686206817627,
0.4959753155708313,
-0.28034064173698425,
-0.022765178233385086,
-0.3361433446407318,
-0.3252953886985779,
-0.40331506729125977,
0.0014131417265161872,
0.02072501927614212,
0.4156631529331207,
0.23924212157726288,
-0.41141244769096375,
0.33968961238861084,
-0.23339687287807465,
0.816476047039032,
0.6223858594894409,
-0.269866019487381,
0.9456705451011658,
-0.3800114691257477,
0.18816660344600677,
0.48170948028564453,
0.14319708943367004,
-0.016864260658621788,
-0.6670857071876526,
-0.5640753507614136,
-0.15327215194702148,
0.04813665524125099,
0.49319639801979065,
-0.7560088038444519,
0.4935319423675537,
-0.38206028938293457,
-0.34741291403770447,
-0.24681206047534943,
0.41985124349594116,
0.23958982527256012,
0.3964807093143463,
0.5507329702377319,
-0.6315782070159912,
-0.03822243958711624,
-1.2130521535873413,
-0.08484740555286407,
0.2780095338821411,
0.266938716173172,
0.11421789228916168,
0.49613019824028015,
-0.1809568554162979,
0.40966081619262695,
-0.10511787980794907,
-0.3074447810649872,
-0.31795474886894226,
0.2517189681529999,
0.3814711570739746,
1.1695187091827393,
0.3349226713180542,
-0.7829369902610779,
-0.5984740853309631,
0.7639577388763428,
-0.6941701173782349,
0.19659720361232758,
-0.47553884983062744,
-0.23712241649627686,
-0.005438543856143951,
0.39963090419769287,
-0.7661717534065247,
0.02229708805680275,
0.49452558159828186,
0.04430234432220459,
0.4845370054244995,
-0.4282000660896301,
0.14268648624420166,
-0.9505909085273743,
0.32119297981262207,
-0.19536517560482025,
-0.14420832693576813,
-0.8037392497062683,
0.23541754484176636,
0.3687802255153656,
0.16950424015522003,
-0.33849942684173584,
0.33106884360313416,
-0.5126555562019348,
-0.0918993353843689,
-0.24559670686721802,
-0.12605729699134827,
-0.11086484789848328,
0.6790858507156372,
0.0793742835521698,
0.6418590545654297,
0.6411787867546082,
-0.47145161032676697,
0.17799843847751617,
0.2452244907617569,
-0.38339054584503174,
0.35332557559013367,
-0.7083719968795776,
0.055368103086948395,
0.05130641162395477,
-0.08053027838468552,
-0.4479539692401886,
-0.12114089727401733,
0.09303639084100723,
-0.31173309683799744,
0.584770917892456,
-0.3863009512424469,
-0.46798282861709595,
0.010875031352043152,
0.11999572813510895,
0.8079937696456909,
0.3595774173736572,
-0.17000015079975128,
0.5925660729408264,
0.3145602345466614,
-0.2646597623825073,
-0.7464419603347778,
-1.184308409690857,
0.28177088499069214,
0.27727067470550537,
-0.7900028228759766,
0.6117352247238159,
-0.1361950784921646,
0.1543453186750412,
0.08173035085201263,
-0.21795004606246948,
-0.48586416244506836,
0.06104070693254471,
0.007303796708583832,
0.0007709483033977449,
-0.30014097690582275,
0.05178657919168472,
0.4136444628238678,
0.06448931246995926,
-0.0949564054608345,
-0.7226932048797607,
0.5937843322753906,
0.19144046306610107,
-0.46417027711868286,
-0.42470574378967285,
0.5689420700073242,
0.654538094997406,
-0.4347304403781891,
0.6485990285873413,
0.7626808285713196,
-0.259748250246048,
-0.2438013255596161,
-0.435891330242157,
-0.2553457021713257,
-0.4594476819038391,
0.7573581337928772,
-0.49201148748397827,
-0.6789770722389221,
0.5560487508773804,
0.1702982634305954,
-0.0941675454378128,
0.28238561749458313,
0.568593442440033,
0.2964824140071869,
0.9616447687149048,
0.5967586636543274,
0.0737246721982956,
0.6335551142692566,
-0.23502206802368164,
0.1674535572528839,
-1.2123119831085205,
-0.43096357583999634,
-0.21475572884082794,
-0.5604827404022217,
0.05352817848324776,
-0.6302689909934998,
0.24262896180152893,
0.23154062032699585,
0.008903486654162407,
0.6879575252532959,
-0.45354077219963074,
0.568096399307251,
0.517828106880188,
0.16256263852119446,
0.18747705221176147,
0.18936072289943695,
-0.46604055166244507,
-0.01338239200413227,
-0.8652563095092773,
-0.13775615394115448,
0.6607270240783691,
-0.03008137084543705,
0.28534820675849915,
0.07275073975324631,
0.3933064043521881,
0.29611507058143616,
0.3064412772655487,
-0.6856777667999268,
0.38169196248054504,
-0.30706486105918884,
-0.6764544248580933,
-0.02697918191552162,
-0.5890947580337524,
-0.64528888463974,
0.5063939690589905,
0.01040242426097393,
-0.7624353766441345,
0.320273756980896,
-0.01418847031891346,
-0.058016907423734665,
0.6434974074363708,
-0.761562168598175,
0.8047820925712585,
-0.18652205169200897,
-0.4806293547153473,
-0.5121954083442688,
-0.41556376218795776,
0.19171123206615448,
-0.10251808166503906,
0.046561483293771744,
-0.11666657030582428,
-0.21602706611156464,
0.17041538655757904,
0.12679362297058105,
0.9444891810417175,
0.29309219121932983,
-0.08929779380559921,
-0.041495803743600845,
0.2688615322113037,
0.2957988679409027,
0.12900328636169434,
-0.24845215678215027,
0.45183536410331726,
-0.5031105875968933,
-0.7734058499336243,
-0.3176621198654175,
0.9177695512771606,
-0.8564141988754272,
-0.5868437886238098,
-0.0679241344332695,
-0.9491189122200012,
-0.10127993673086166,
0.4892217814922333,
0.21939213573932648,
0.40546348690986633,
0.001169370487332344,
-0.05834241956472397,
0.6085704565048218,
0.11314957588911057,
0.6824551820755005,
0.2500973343849182,
0.12113811820745468,
-0.3776865303516388,
1.1426520347595215,
0.4292968809604645,
0.5110074281692505,
0.5574403405189514,
-0.16827915608882904,
0.1426558941602707,
-0.7349386811256409,
-0.6678489446640015,
0.06265389174222946,
-0.7679915428161621,
-0.08837374299764633,
-1.0738005638122559,
-0.2987608313560486,
-0.43267351388931274,
-0.17714548110961914,
-0.2921774387359619,
-0.6116911172866821,
-0.1550462394952774,
-0.02134166844189167,
-0.2423611581325531,
0.843666136264801,
-0.29026612639427185,
0.11006095260381699,
-1.009064793586731,
0.15251506865024567,
0.5594773292541504,
0.16402924060821533,
0.4656532108783722,
-0.465394526720047,
-0.7064723372459412,
0.02624630741775036,
-0.26450541615486145,
-0.8591884970664978,
0.4260196387767792,
0.3409132659435272,
0.8297104835510254,
0.09425460547208786,
-0.5390835404396057,
0.4207729399204254,
-0.6423255801200867,
0.7038491368293762,
0.45800071954727173,
-1.2027400732040405,
-0.02625809796154499,
-0.4077700674533844,
0.5409144163131714,
0.15547403693199158,
0.39065635204315186,
-0.6729453802108765,
-0.2579439878463745,
-0.23856370151042938,
-1.0221441984176636,
0.7945029139518738,
0.18157027661800385,
0.49345967173576355,
0.009454547427594662,
0.2331448793411255,
0.09325025230646133,
0.3345679044723511,
-0.9191775918006897,
-0.04574934393167496,
-0.15931858122348785,
0.2599930763244629,
-0.10853353142738342,
0.042583268135786057,
-0.3171893060207367,
-0.5033261775970459,
0.44473719596862793,
-0.42135828733444214,
0.16450732946395874,
0.3523768186569214,
-0.5314667820930481,
-0.004351111128926277,
0.1499498039484024,
0.862213671207428,
0.6672735214233398,
0.4082074761390686,
0.2969759702682495,
0.4001311957836151,
-0.3761647641658783,
0.20898205041885376,
-0.2775688171386719,
-0.27649039030075073,
0.06782092154026031,
0.5003340840339661,
0.6432176232337952,
0.292969286441803,
-0.1128854751586914,
0.314557284116745,
0.24931354820728302,
-0.28246280550956726,
0.09146181493997574,
-0.05931657925248146,
0.4823369085788727,
0.3019164502620697,
0.31526869535446167,
0.9077337980270386,
-0.0773947611451149,
-0.40487533807754517,
0.1928454488515854,
0.22393055260181427,
-0.453348845243454,
-0.8350068926811218,
0.34204211831092834,
0.24303047358989716,
-0.3580566942691803,
0.5467775464057922,
-0.14154507219791412,
-0.7367445826530457,
0.8840027451515198,
0.7598967552185059,
0.9554815888404846,
-0.17254313826560974,
0.2385331690311432,
0.3802054524421692,
0.6791067123413086,
-0.28630203008651733,
0.05540970712900162,
-0.37770020961761475,
-0.7011803388595581,
-0.8188278675079346,
-0.32307156920433044,
-0.024021616205573082,
-0.40812256932258606,
-0.520491361618042,
-0.21448105573654175,
-0.27458450198173523,
-0.20994335412979126,
-0.08006343990564346,
-0.6465131640434265,
-0.3046971261501312,
-0.2655915915966034,
0.28310462832450867,
0.7660722136497498,
-0.6829072833061218,
1.2706984281539917,
0.8988834023475647,
-0.3782244622707367,
-0.33956754207611084,
-0.1537337750196457,
-0.39319300651550293,
-0.5656124353408813,
1.004629135131836,
0.11769261956214905,
0.07174999266862869,
-0.08865993469953537,
-0.2202797681093216,
-0.7082720398902893,
0.7000081539154053,
0.4379652142524719,
-0.42218583822250366,
-0.11124784499406815,
0.03887025639414787,
0.33485597372055054,
-0.2953531742095947,
0.10907804220914841,
0.11352784931659698,
0.5605438947677612,
-0.24984246492385864,
-0.8824644684791565,
0.003976184409111738,
-0.556273341178894,
-0.0677911564707756,
0.32226648926734924,
-0.6263486742973328,
1.1852473020553589,
-0.07656741142272949,
0.13933078944683075,
-0.059126514941453934,
0.4105679988861084,
-0.4788084626197815,
-0.27239927649497986,
0.25403496623039246,
0.5402986407279968,
0.5015033483505249,
0.06790399551391602,
0.8289394378662109,
-0.3861113488674164,
0.09243541210889816,
0.9356814026832581,
-0.1250511258840561,
0.782874584197998,
0.7010617256164551,
0.2319764494895935,
0.47946518659591675,
0.14589154720306396,
-0.03466423600912094,
0.4497396647930145,
0.01007719337940216,
-0.5187788009643555,
-0.49601686000823975,
-0.30516794323921204,
-0.38275426626205444,
0.006496896967291832,
0.18569545447826385,
-0.22575993835926056,
-0.010971827432513237,
0.055171724408864975,
-0.04552052170038223,
0.04245157539844513,
-0.3247218728065491,
0.6882621645927429,
0.18056757748126984,
-0.9223893880844116,
0.44374141097068787,
-0.016345497220754623,
0.9249182343482971,
-0.9079696536064148,
0.16530819237232208,
-0.3471221625804901,
0.20614056289196014,
-0.47462889552116394,
-0.4678884744644165,
0.564544141292572,
-0.46069028973579407,
-0.5404732823371887,
-0.5184073448181152,
0.496450811624527,
-0.686234176158905,
-0.18090710043907166,
0.5841779708862305,
0.5685962438583374,
-0.3459959030151367,
-0.2743050456047058,
-0.5579830408096313,
-0.2901241183280945,
-0.04133686050772667,
-0.08310198783874512,
0.7402973771095276,
0.30128732323646545,
-0.016559863463044167,
0.4302792251110077,
0.8854168653488159,
0.4140416383743286,
0.36810219287872314,
-0.0954878032207489,
0.9835126996040344,
-0.4323677718639374,
-0.5146047472953796,
-0.81827712059021,
0.48760247230529785,
-0.2199077606201172,
-0.49965545535087585,
0.6985722780227661,
0.3799457848072052,
0.8439279198646545,
-0.3406277894973755,
0.5279915928840637,
-0.14533203840255737,
-0.4557875394821167,
-0.30054739117622375,
0.9696931838989258,
-0.7054183483123779,
-0.004890497773885727,
0.09814725816249847,
-0.8276859521865845,
-0.3362021744251251,
0.4204528033733368,
-0.19407470524311066,
-0.27107518911361694,
0.9483006000518799,
0.8608916401863098,
-0.41952911019325256,
-0.31993892788887024,
0.5560240745544434,
0.0830339789390564,
0.12009426206350327,
0.5958393812179565,
0.7568764090538025,
-0.223824605345726,
0.43169257044792175,
-0.45638179779052734,
-0.04013241082429886,
0.11704625189304352,
-0.7197492718696594,
-0.8486654162406921,
-0.5481897592544556,
-0.29381394386291504,
-0.07611260563135147,
0.04400435462594032,
0.6789980530738831,
1.2722822427749634,
-0.7687305212020874,
-0.6602829098701477,
-0.12496241927146912,
0.4182729125022888,
-0.749353289604187,
-0.1083609014749527,
0.0032002937514334917,
-0.9833976030349731,
-0.7704210877418518,
0.6675342321395874,
0.5359189510345459,
-0.15437142550945282,
-0.17159539461135864,
0.161993607878685,
-0.5957580208778381,
-0.10888101905584335,
0.5629260540008545,
0.24721397459506989,
-0.30301040410995483,
0.10647042095661163,
0.19965150952339172,
-0.28314247727394104,
0.1155458316206932,
1.13471257686615,
-0.2015293538570404,
0.37239065766334534,
0.8023918867111206,
0.7599456310272217,
0.38654324412345886,
-0.5499531030654907,
0.8521053791046143,
-0.9988776445388794,
0.550754725933075,
0.3766356408596039,
0.3932786285877228,
0.35556718707084656,
-0.3439003527164459,
0.19230350852012634,
0.3268698453903198,
-0.5818421244621277,
-0.549735963344574,
0.23373417556285858,
-0.7564470767974854,
-0.40345337986946106,
1.1360180377960205,
-0.5184084177017212,
-0.4364980161190033,
-0.2570706009864807,
0.03129061684012413,
-0.00679269153624773,
-0.1572268009185791,
0.621674656867981,
0.7649507522583008,
0.0954262986779213,
0.18435823917388916,
-0.5424899458885193,
0.3494831919670105,
0.7896092534065247,
-0.6277788877487183,
-0.2476140558719635,
-0.0050170230679214,
0.20095102488994598,
0.35807451605796814,
0.36110952496528625,
-0.06350129097700119,
0.4061584174633026,
-0.0013946779072284698,
0.3303802013397217,
-0.1478453427553177,
-0.4559083580970764,
-0.4982050955295563,
0.2751963138580322,
0.02263471856713295,
0.06866993010044098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11184v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11184v2
|
FIZZ: Factual Inconsistency Detection by Zoom-in Summary and Zoom-out Document
| 2024-04-17T09:01:02 | 2024-04-18T03:57:17 |
Joonho Yang, Seunghyun Yoon, Byeongjeong Kim, Hwanhee Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Through the advent of pre-trained language models, there have been notable
advancements in abstractive summarization systems. Simultaneously, a
considerable number of novel methods for evaluating factual consistency in
abstractive summarization systems has been developed. But these evaluation
approaches incorporate substantial limitations, especially on refinement and
interpretability. In this work, we propose highly effective and interpretable
factual inconsistency detection method metric Factual Inconsistency Detection
by Zoom-in Summary and Zoom-out Document for abstractive summarization systems
that is based on fine-grained atomic facts decomposition. Moreover, we align
atomic facts decomposed from the summary with the source document through
adaptive granularity expansion. These atomic facts represent a more
fine-grained unit of information, facilitating detailed understanding and
interpretability of the summary's factual inconsistency. Experimental results
demonstrate that our proposed factual consistency checking system significantly
outperforms existing systems.
|
[
-0.504568874835968,
-1.0007915496826172,
0.6822301745414734,
-0.2665080726146698,
-0.12643933296203613,
0.1614297330379486,
-0.36096733808517456,
-0.2579757869243622,
0.15502037107944489,
0.13873131573200226,
-0.5822538137435913,
-0.340778648853302,
-0.6457607746124268,
0.3302187919616699,
-0.3883642852306366,
1.2067615985870361,
0.026107216253876686,
-0.16413936018943787,
-0.49729815125465393,
-0.33982717990875244,
-0.3400910794734955,
-0.16115407645702362,
-0.12384814023971558,
-0.1363658905029297,
-0.13486410677433014,
0.9847428202629089,
1.127608060836792,
0.5245112776756287,
0.6117646098136902,
0.38967812061309814,
-0.2582422196865082,
1.0010854005813599,
-0.40691861510276794,
-0.07166126370429993,
-0.1765216737985611,
-0.20216597616672516,
-0.6076112985610962,
-0.3710622787475586,
0.837218165397644,
0.5468855500221252,
-0.13934502005577087,
0.1273031234741211,
-0.1385156512260437,
0.6764882802963257,
-0.7201008200645447,
0.4617294371128082,
-0.6840528249740601,
0.18898864090442657,
-0.22706612944602966,
-0.1851649284362793,
-0.35770758986473083,
-0.38899633288383484,
-0.18498417735099792,
-0.5709003806114197,
0.6737369894981384,
0.08554635941982269,
1.0573194026947021,
0.22597771883010864,
-0.20227350294589996,
-0.5225042104721069,
-0.6311010122299194,
0.25417017936706543,
-0.9613158702850342,
0.3419302999973297,
0.14544665813446045,
0.08146549761295319,
-0.29151666164398193,
-0.5519936680793762,
-1.0052180290222168,
-0.20413243770599365,
-0.2604351341724396,
0.12216982245445251,
-0.07652167230844498,
-0.05734122917056084,
0.25839629769325256,
0.6931453347206116,
-0.4874390661716461,
-0.17277756333351135,
-0.2380421757698059,
-0.4435969293117523,
0.5263938903808594,
0.2956554591655731,
0.4758166968822479,
-0.02597193233668804,
-0.093076191842556,
0.15046881139278412,
-0.3700758218765259,
-0.1646629273891449,
0.04062773287296295,
0.36093392968177795,
-0.4990003705024719,
0.5335270762443542,
-0.5731990933418274,
0.19543543457984924,
0.4470928907394409,
-0.46705782413482666,
0.33220186829566956,
-0.6557129621505737,
-0.12984204292297363,
0.20661011338233948,
0.37545645236968994,
0.3705053925514221,
0.09066073596477509,
-0.0371071957051754,
-0.11548259854316711,
-0.18943734467029572,
0.0763702392578125,
-0.8145897388458252,
-0.2768111526966095,
0.2651030123233795,
-0.36952900886535645,
-0.1615443229675293,
0.13450948894023895,
-0.5491746068000793,
-0.41419005393981934,
-0.12708547711372375,
0.6653876900672913,
-0.48105719685554504,
-0.20029151439666748,
0.018692992627620697,
-0.1692599654197693,
-0.39051154255867004,
0.5632150769233704,
-1.0237079858779907,
0.2531096339225769,
0.8159887790679932,
1.016908884048462,
0.0018417026149109006,
-0.24110178649425507,
-0.5707820057868958,
-0.06682337075471878,
-0.45325642824172974,
1.1199167966842651,
-0.22424300014972687,
-0.2271670550107956,
0.05087963119149208,
-0.04946945607662201,
0.11125272512435913,
-0.8127896189689636,
0.5774271488189697,
-0.4773304760456085,
-0.16074852645397186,
-0.18853510916233063,
-0.8143681287765503,
-0.3122329115867615,
0.47575220465660095,
-0.41737258434295654,
0.7340179681777954,
0.11595983058214188,
-0.821042001247406,
0.6484182476997375,
-0.6244753003120422,
-0.22832517325878143,
0.05628473684191704,
-0.16655544936656952,
-0.6710940599441528,
0.31710678339004517,
0.07838855683803558,
0.14155341684818268,
0.20882168412208557,
0.3221528232097626,
-0.3137054443359375,
-0.5441495180130005,
0.29358023405075073,
-0.5967289805412292,
0.3422795236110687,
0.1581522524356842,
-0.21299795806407928,
0.10266061127185822,
-0.8750005960464478,
-0.2683308720588684,
-0.22807274758815765,
-0.5773401260375977,
0.11890542507171631,
0.14374716579914093,
-0.32842743396759033,
-0.1308644860982895,
0.3555939793586731,
-0.41142183542251587,
0.07948735356330872,
-0.24359238147735596,
-0.13217708468437195,
0.3655501902103424,
0.23956707119941711,
0.30547454953193665,
-0.4214819371700287,
-0.02295053005218506,
0.2143816351890564,
-0.06428657472133636,
-0.5860562324523926,
-0.18742048740386963,
-0.9576794505119324,
-0.43631917238235474,
0.3175686299800873,
0.44733017683029175,
-0.5910392999649048,
0.5656524300575256,
-0.6767526865005493,
-0.412647008895874,
0.09981460124254227,
-0.02527148835361004,
0.19446711242198944,
0.7827303409576416,
0.4552237093448639,
-0.20845168828964233,
-0.2647981345653534,
-0.715987503528595,
-0.3295150399208069,
-0.23211409151554108,
0.07940032333135605,
-0.10209168493747711,
0.6387543082237244,
-0.3342438042163849,
0.9910013675689697,
-0.5348355770111084,
-0.1288323551416397,
0.08856955170631409,
0.5266850590705872,
0.14461016654968262,
0.5188779234886169,
0.12053211033344269,
-0.6707242131233215,
-0.4281826913356781,
0.1680895835161209,
-0.7418220043182373,
-0.07299260795116425,
-0.26789888739585876,
0.23018580675125122,
0.3897934556007385,
0.6203081607818604,
-0.618127703666687,
0.7335314154624939,
0.04653547331690788,
-0.3095969259738922,
0.8485962748527527,
-0.595600962638855,
0.39572980999946594,
-0.37400972843170166,
-0.05923275649547577,
-0.3274262845516205,
-0.6425774097442627,
-0.5242220759391785,
0.0679277554154396,
0.34094440937042236,
0.09485886245965958,
-0.13092489540576935,
0.18860185146331787,
-0.25839465856552124,
-0.0013586949789896607,
-0.5230711102485657,
0.268551766872406,
0.013384891673922539,
0.33544009923934937,
-0.01873156614601612,
0.8661803603172302,
0.12278082221746445,
-0.7674055695533752,
0.0947098657488823,
0.4365546405315399,
-0.4578477442264557,
0.7367038726806641,
-0.18825869262218475,
-0.2736367881298065,
-0.11135808378458023,
0.41541895270347595,
-1.2390291690826416,
-0.5297523736953735,
0.2918471693992615,
-0.6346107125282288,
0.39134520292282104,
-0.01834721863269806,
-0.5649311542510986,
0.179602712392807,
-0.4780988395214081,
0.26700830459594727,
0.09039867669343948,
-0.47490036487579346,
0.6379244327545166,
0.2329246699810028,
-0.28163155913352966,
-0.3946027457714081,
-0.40048739314079285,
0.0003827273612841964,
0.16561302542686462,
-0.6506944298744202,
0.03740378096699715,
-0.1295580416917801,
-0.46804079413414,
0.09537975490093231,
-0.5810466408729553,
-0.4062028229236603,
0.0036986907944083214,
0.18893153965473175,
0.20375992357730865,
-0.38873884081840515,
0.35407376289367676,
0.11761052161455154,
-0.1600397527217865,
-0.08287905156612396,
0.17393869161605835,
0.18755434453487396,
-0.25885722041130066,
-0.2788136899471283,
-0.6123911142349243,
0.13654188811779022,
0.859154224395752,
0.1274862140417099,
0.5033164620399475,
0.5525813102722168,
-0.38529929518699646,
0.1148511990904808,
-0.5548866391181946,
-0.049863968044519424,
-0.44069525599479675,
0.3742242753505707,
-0.17760194838047028,
-0.6715291142463684,
0.5038816332817078,
-0.2598784267902374,
0.053031712770462036,
0.6312803030014038,
0.4990646541118622,
-0.08566038310527802,
0.6541344523429871,
0.5582316517829895,
0.11682431399822235,
0.13068783283233643,
-0.054575495421886444,
0.3045385777950287,
-0.5683954358100891,
-0.1366133689880371,
-0.39251992106437683,
-0.0037696899380534887,
-0.31755128502845764,
-0.31098058819770813,
0.7047469019889832,
0.002404106082394719,
-0.36122390627861023,
-0.2399154007434845,
0.06133393943309784,
0.6496159434318542,
0.061371609568595886,
0.05058278515934944,
0.6906337141990662,
0.07690553367137909,
-0.112165667116642,
0.06876236200332642,
-0.5344918966293335,
-0.35880425572395325,
0.6034249663352966,
0.2951407730579376,
0.3245182931423187,
0.3563205599784851,
0.2497374564409256,
0.7377740144729614,
0.3398808538913727,
-0.7980037331581116,
0.24130703508853912,
-0.058356426656246185,
-0.9072980880737305,
-0.4019972085952759,
-0.3841876685619354,
-0.22970706224441528,
0.4994230568408966,
-0.6270421743392944,
-0.6317656636238098,
0.2228170931339264,
0.045206159353256226,
-0.5697489380836487,
0.4305410087108612,
-0.6315096616744995,
0.6106629371643066,
0.2771134078502655,
-0.08778148889541626,
-0.4457962214946747,
-0.49836599826812744,
0.5272746086120605,
-0.1730440855026245,
0.6388131976127625,
-0.257167786359787,
0.008695618249475956,
0.32769501209259033,
-1.104387640953064,
0.5038829445838928,
0.038097530603408813,
-0.16346772015094757,
0.1926548182964325,
0.2935568392276764,
0.4860348403453827,
0.43877431750297546,
-0.05295952409505844,
0.3114318251609802,
-0.18912597000598907,
-0.2410999983549118,
-0.6378675103187561,
0.3929694890975952,
-0.39138221740722656,
-0.45471101999282837,
-0.5851752758026123,
-0.8285121917724609,
-0.15951505303382874,
0.2860560715198517,
0.3965759873390198,
0.8273336291313171,
-0.0324183851480484,
-0.002910678507760167,
0.6171333193778992,
0.2950439155101776,
0.4220203459262848,
0.8887050151824951,
-0.13861264288425446,
-0.310848206281662,
0.8402497172355652,
0.30949124693870544,
0.21388745307922363,
0.32008180022239685,
0.06828431040048599,
-0.1105189174413681,
-0.7451207041740417,
-0.6591811776161194,
0.2018233984708786,
-0.7094929218292236,
-0.39300039410591125,
-0.5383689403533936,
-0.16178147494792938,
-0.3991221487522125,
-0.2591324746608734,
-0.45147183537483215,
-0.43222761154174805,
-0.10628503561019897,
0.10204433649778366,
0.21031971275806427,
0.7291598916053772,
-0.47154146432876587,
0.2926812469959259,
-1.1014013290405273,
0.4687928259372711,
0.05629105493426323,
0.20207135379314423,
-0.009898701682686806,
-0.8249773979187012,
-0.5796695947647095,
0.018003523349761963,
-0.4545682966709137,
-0.6012843251228333,
0.015367514453828335,
0.2929215431213379,
0.032037340104579926,
0.7799066305160522,
0.06466798484325409,
0.848116397857666,
-0.5222864151000977,
0.7770660519599915,
0.03507259860634804,
-1.3332716226577759,
0.22154048085212708,
-0.21092639863491058,
0.2958538830280304,
0.8992485404014587,
0.20057053864002228,
-0.44312620162963867,
-0.3962912857532501,
-0.8168944716453552,
-0.7810502648353577,
0.762759804725647,
0.11986701935529709,
-0.10796897858381271,
0.05746890977025032,
0.4228106439113617,
0.26158127188682556,
0.17782911658287048,
-0.1339297741651535,
-0.34096506237983704,
0.21414220333099365,
-0.10702583193778992,
0.02860700711607933,
-0.49863582849502563,
-0.031007355079054832,
-0.08448230475187302,
0.8881464004516602,
-0.17662104964256287,
-0.23310217261314392,
0.41326943039894104,
-0.21028365194797516,
-0.17485201358795166,
0.1708381325006485,
0.8465743660926819,
0.975105345249176,
-0.44880586862564087,
0.20151852071285248,
0.6408436894416809,
-0.7308878898620605,
0.036810606718063354,
-0.2305418998003006,
-0.4130908250808716,
0.41606006026268005,
0.6637591123580933,
0.292808473110199,
0.5464205741882324,
-0.7491874694824219,
0.6199502944946289,
-0.12905801832675934,
0.06572996824979782,
-0.22474664449691772,
0.2043064683675766,
-0.2205076962709427,
0.17222648859024048,
0.2901821434497833,
0.5730699896812439,
0.5059735774993896,
-0.7592714428901672,
0.4068801701068878,
0.2420499473810196,
-0.23413896560668945,
-0.1709960401058197,
0.20541362464427948,
0.15870098769664764,
-0.09244907647371292,
0.43700629472732544,
-0.5808213353157043,
-0.5704492330551147,
0.45849186182022095,
0.2912448048591614,
0.5029042959213257,
0.0990033894777298,
0.3006516098976135,
0.3370664715766907,
0.22419129312038422,
-0.07589499652385712,
0.1034170612692833,
-0.4568973779678345,
-0.9125141501426697,
-0.1844317466020584,
-0.07822473347187042,
-0.7594825625419617,
-0.003605789737775922,
-0.5294750332832336,
0.24205933511257172,
-0.4319751262664795,
0.15484461188316345,
0.22883647680282593,
0.1743156611919403,
-0.09610803425312042,
0.4061897099018097,
0.10546185076236725,
0.9291145205497742,
-0.829181969165802,
0.36939024925231934,
0.49769580364227295,
-0.36125126481056213,
-0.5427637100219727,
0.4380147159099579,
0.43753525614738464,
-0.4246097505092621,
0.5393943786621094,
0.002035134471952915,
-0.39249587059020996,
-0.4699048697948456,
-0.4195878207683563,
-0.7869552969932556,
0.8002637028694153,
0.28029611706733704,
-0.132050022482872,
0.457724392414093,
-0.10199781507253647,
0.18611222505569458,
-0.17169301211833954,
0.5882622003555298,
0.8340600728988647,
0.6548645496368408,
0.05935204401612282,
-1.049865961074829,
-0.11081095039844513,
-0.08026683330535889,
-0.44096627831459045,
0.22899217903614044,
-0.7544649839401245,
0.8962491154670715,
-0.32776832580566406,
-0.5701157450675964,
0.05609513074159622,
0.9974137544631958,
0.15707869827747345,
0.8265241980552673,
0.4476594924926758,
0.5984757542610168,
1.2706935405731201,
-0.1286323219537735,
0.7240570187568665,
-0.21159720420837402,
0.7426344156265259,
1.2794973850250244,
-0.16799674928188324,
0.7663900852203369,
0.04590913653373718,
-0.23335561156272888,
0.6282833218574524,
0.29095253348350525,
0.08491606265306473,
0.22840073704719543,
-0.22999021410942078,
-0.5157375335693359,
-0.29594066739082336,
-0.05895966663956642,
-0.39138489961624146,
0.5764508247375488,
0.45859774947166443,
0.29748791456222534,
-0.6772620677947998,
-0.4714522659778595,
0.41386058926582336,
0.2079581320285797,
-0.4359559416770935,
0.6626009345054626,
-0.4413015842437744,
-0.315884530544281,
0.5990239381790161,
-0.0046465895138680935,
0.6861867308616638,
-0.46808913350105286,
-0.18251000344753265,
-0.302924782037735,
0.309315949678421,
-0.6830824613571167,
-0.6379026174545288,
0.41373395919799805,
0.1808737963438034,
-0.45297154784202576,
0.6367954015731812,
0.7349406480789185,
-0.3709072470664978,
-0.2939998507499695,
-0.4496268630027771,
0.1927269995212555,
0.26408037543296814,
0.03316438943147659,
-0.11257445812225342,
0.33907583355903625,
-0.07653222978115082,
0.35204142332077026,
-0.010992861352860928,
0.7840477228164673,
0.17043234407901764,
0.5827044248580933,
0.6020833253860474,
0.03082359954714775,
-0.276203453540802,
-0.3486475944519043,
0.6631679534912109,
-0.3588104248046875,
-0.680632472038269,
-0.9758293628692627,
0.5370847582817078,
-0.34871745109558105,
-0.28522539138793945,
0.9903303384780884,
0.8865499496459961,
0.6073512434959412,
-0.14659370481967926,
0.7268767952919006,
0.05923859030008316,
0.4655713737010956,
-0.5620219707489014,
0.7317366003990173,
-0.3615266680717468,
0.223796084523201,
0.0733024924993515,
-0.5369113683700562,
-0.37181010842323303,
0.41877609491348267,
-0.14655925333499908,
-0.23340676724910736,
0.8709455132484436,
0.7714247703552246,
-0.20726251602172852,
0.2703288197517395,
0.24371139705181122,
0.5225871801376343,
0.2604503631591797,
-0.04500982165336609,
0.7021745443344116,
-0.5037112236022949,
0.18628519773483276,
0.03976671025156975,
-0.360177606344223,
-0.8192691206932068,
-0.9943118691444397,
-0.318482905626297,
-0.4005579650402069,
-0.7082349061965942,
-0.34607088565826416,
-0.24069249629974365,
0.8239652514457703,
0.6969215273857117,
-1.071797251701355,
0.056033406406641006,
-0.023955412209033966,
0.4802248179912567,
-0.03621980547904968,
-0.2827613949775696,
0.3646441400051117,
-0.8180975317955017,
-0.5030667781829834,
0.30539944767951965,
0.6984321475028992,
-0.17501746118068695,
0.08658697456121445,
0.09327751398086548,
-0.1389315128326416,
0.5137757658958435,
0.4624774754047394,
0.43764686584472656,
-0.4574136734008789,
-0.5691657066345215,
-0.6489126682281494,
0.17072421312332153,
0.30663198232650757,
0.6591656804084778,
-0.3950687348842621,
0.7162161469459534,
0.5802041292190552,
0.5059597492218018,
0.19702675938606262,
0.32669079303741455,
-0.04948483780026436,
-0.4762054979801178,
0.06549380719661713,
-0.26661819219589233,
0.3456794321537018,
0.2489165961742401,
-0.5813966989517212,
0.42171332240104675,
0.30531057715415955,
-0.6932793855667114,
-0.7350499033927917,
-0.013623191975057125,
-1.025507926940918,
-0.14676329493522644,
0.7973337769508362,
-0.26634126901626587,
-0.16759292781352997,
-0.38223379850387573,
-0.2607307732105255,
0.2758198380470276,
-0.4167029857635498,
0.9820988178253174,
0.856364905834198,
-0.47003769874572754,
0.45238471031188965,
-0.2894931733608246,
0.4851510226726532,
0.22057071328163147,
-0.7568793296813965,
0.21583157777786255,
0.7398695349693298,
0.43425261974334717,
0.6749641299247742,
0.650292694568634,
-0.18416844308376312,
0.5739633440971375,
0.26520493626594543,
-0.23743711411952972,
-0.22892338037490845,
-0.35712409019470215,
-0.38096344470977783,
0.16719412803649902,
-0.05630190670490265,
-0.16010181605815887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11141v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11141v1
|
Context-Aware Siamese Networks for Efficient Emotion Recognition in Conversation
| 2024-04-17T07:36:40 | 2024-04-17T07:36:40 |
Barbara Gendron, Gaël Guibon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The advent of deep learning models has made a considerable contribution to
the achievement of Emotion Recognition in Conversation (ERC). However, this
task still remains an important challenge due to the plurality and subjectivity
of human emotions. Previous work on ERC provides predictive models using mostly
graph-based conversation representations. In this work, we propose a way to
model the conversational context that we incorporate into a metric learning
training strategy, with a two-step process. This allows us to perform ERC in a
flexible classification scenario and to end up with a lightweight yet efficient
model. Using metric learning through a Siamese Network architecture, we achieve
57.71 in macro F1 score for emotion classification in conversation on
DailyDialog dataset, which outperforms the related work. This state-of-the-art
result is promising regarding the use of metric learning for emotion
recognition, yet perfectible compared to the microF1 score obtained.
|
[
-0.47996941208839417,
-0.4558830261230469,
0.3172392249107361,
0.16212508082389832,
-0.3522375524044037,
-0.10857278108596802,
-0.19130615890026093,
-0.4478321969509125,
0.5009780526161194,
0.13466589152812958,
-0.7276763916015625,
-0.7112305760383606,
-0.378677099943161,
0.09846196323633194,
0.02116602286696434,
0.9758609533309937,
-0.26007768511772156,
0.1227225512266159,
0.0849972516298294,
-0.6984975337982178,
-0.32871145009994507,
-0.6007239818572998,
-0.9316832423210144,
-0.2700357735157013,
0.5772119164466858,
0.7553779482841492,
0.0007491070427931845,
0.08537551015615463,
0.37984928488731384,
0.3120119571685791,
-0.15201249718666077,
0.25194376707077026,
-0.6325538754463196,
0.22923877835273743,
0.4621765613555908,
-0.5236973762512207,
-0.6785001158714294,
0.03668275848031044,
0.4334772825241089,
0.35148632526397705,
-0.246555894613266,
-0.13913901150226593,
0.07461127638816833,
0.7704584002494812,
-0.5353155136108398,
0.3646419942378998,
-0.5587501525878906,
0.7054808735847473,
0.2676486670970917,
-0.2907414138317108,
-0.37278831005096436,
-0.20369119942188263,
0.24985159933567047,
-0.21799573302268982,
-0.09277640283107758,
0.09853822737932205,
0.43354490399360657,
0.04091301187872887,
-0.659197211265564,
-0.2605884075164795,
-0.5421715378761292,
0.43191391229629517,
-0.43520575761795044,
0.4438443183898926,
0.11660154163837433,
0.4753876030445099,
0.24353407323360443,
-0.4359871745109558,
-0.4533882141113281,
-0.004668612498790026,
0.05176396295428276,
0.3707255423069,
-0.14642159640789032,
0.11988777667284012,
0.23580528795719147,
0.05307420715689659,
-0.47543278336524963,
0.2509707808494568,
-0.1769491583108902,
0.048458922654390335,
0.3928728699684143,
0.6255833506584167,
-0.06015291437506676,
-0.30555182695388794,
-0.3743361234664917,
-0.023460624739527702,
-0.4952743947505951,
0.12269610911607742,
0.08891197293996811,
0.2771531641483307,
-0.19707031548023224,
0.08735013008117676,
-0.37833330035209656,
0.07205688953399658,
-0.19178731739521027,
0.24270550906658173,
0.21753354370594025,
-0.1199098452925682,
-0.21427279710769653,
0.21421292424201965,
0.8550952672958374,
0.4319952130317688,
0.32172396779060364,
0.18815265595912933,
-0.0815892368555069,
-0.09720917791128159,
0.27860116958618164,
-1.0774803161621094,
-0.07546672970056534,
0.15173734724521637,
-0.2652312219142914,
-0.39877673983573914,
0.038634758442640305,
-0.9112260937690735,
-0.2589845657348633,
-0.21144647896289825,
0.10533485561609268,
-0.1612057387828827,
-0.2903411388397217,
-0.005025722086429596,
0.35246407985687256,
-0.08681663870811462,
0.5647923946380615,
-0.5867481827735901,
0.4541093409061432,
0.5637999773025513,
1.1523633003234863,
0.17698459327220917,
0.2045053392648697,
-0.3675558567047119,
-0.3891409635543823,
-0.39128702878952026,
0.4657684564590454,
-0.4345687925815582,
-0.5728359818458557,
-0.003192601725459099,
-0.060269638895988464,
-0.059427063912153244,
-0.3500668406486511,
0.5431211590766907,
-0.3900347650051117,
0.1950227916240692,
0.07353302091360092,
-0.3036549687385559,
-0.34306037425994873,
0.403103768825531,
-0.5285698771476746,
0.7251417636871338,
-0.10553249716758728,
-1.0348156690597534,
0.15154540538787842,
-0.8284581303596497,
-0.39466696977615356,
-0.11138418316841125,
0.12126339972019196,
-0.5459679365158081,
0.22185353934764862,
0.0142874326556921,
0.9030100107192993,
0.02653496526181698,
0.06010998785495758,
-0.7179124355316162,
-0.22397266328334808,
0.32039040327072144,
-0.31510400772094727,
0.3589054048061371,
0.33841943740844727,
-0.45429766178131104,
-0.15070794522762299,
-0.7074121236801147,
-0.01826471835374832,
-0.03499327227473259,
-0.1535516232252121,
-0.34703442454338074,
-0.12209419161081314,
-0.1913866251707077,
0.33282020688056946,
-0.2198120504617691,
-0.5960214138031006,
-0.17288008332252502,
-0.22697849571704865,
0.31990310549736023,
0.8761158585548401,
-0.09249760955572128,
0.4256630837917328,
0.34232836961746216,
0.35521194338798523,
0.5406885147094727,
-0.20198877155780792,
-0.06380565464496613,
-0.15852829813957214,
-1.2011233568191528,
-0.11319627612829208,
0.17600834369659424,
0.633622407913208,
-0.35720500349998474,
0.5831655859947205,
-0.33697494864463806,
-0.545315146446228,
-0.3353224992752075,
-0.09418191760778427,
0.2961053252220154,
0.7713345289230347,
0.04503188654780388,
-0.44004473090171814,
-0.618285596370697,
-0.599571943283081,
0.07626847177743912,
-0.2556796371936798,
0.03447437286376953,
1.1467176675796509,
0.41643577814102173,
-0.21110060811042786,
0.8506330251693726,
-0.5251154899597168,
-0.27303534746170044,
-0.2358303964138031,
0.6307883262634277,
-0.17440380156040192,
0.570030689239502,
0.28659096360206604,
-0.8593376278877258,
-0.653791606426239,
0.23947374522686005,
-0.783164918422699,
-0.06335318088531494,
0.2118745744228363,
-0.15227992832660675,
0.2839072644710541,
0.4404068887233734,
-0.17144188284873962,
0.5339518785476685,
0.22919915616512299,
-0.049266960471868515,
0.23717950284481049,
0.009127653203904629,
0.22170224785804749,
-1.091424584388733,
-0.027414245530962944,
0.38737952709198,
-0.6248506307601929,
-0.860194981098175,
-0.7450202703475952,
0.012269645929336548,
-0.4073795974254608,
-0.5310129523277283,
0.5619619488716125,
-0.09245602786540985,
-0.07646150141954422,
0.05820772051811218,
0.1175508052110672,
-0.15880869328975677,
0.8334188461303711,
0.39838871359825134,
0.3237461447715759,
0.4270590841770172,
-0.6917046308517456,
0.31966131925582886,
0.1285274624824524,
-0.4088146984577179,
0.9764270782470703,
-0.42898857593536377,
0.3956213891506195,
-0.25522544980049133,
0.7248602509498596,
-0.916041910648346,
-0.21486549079418182,
0.2835162281990051,
-0.45152366161346436,
0.3192020356655121,
0.23309528827667236,
-0.20551951229572296,
-0.11237689107656479,
0.032258737832307816,
0.3096042573451996,
0.38277387619018555,
-0.669796347618103,
0.6922508478164673,
0.2962490916252136,
-0.22221636772155762,
-0.10509438067674637,
-0.625427782535553,
-0.07196889072656631,
-0.5560962557792664,
-0.3768673539161682,
-0.23938360810279846,
0.07856319099664688,
0.17082616686820984,
-0.3285188674926758,
-0.10620997101068497,
-0.19313472509384155,
0.2822595536708832,
0.4606989622116089,
-0.036752454936504364,
-0.15755492448806763,
0.4189051687717438,
-0.19510594010353088,
-0.28942567110061646,
0.10415909439325333,
-0.06963471323251724,
0.34307554364204407,
-0.36993494629859924,
-0.06008533015847206,
-0.8922328948974609,
0.5045525431632996,
0.5869703888893127,
-0.2199372798204422,
0.6187620162963867,
0.9032239317893982,
-0.5844860672950745,
-0.08605177700519562,
-0.3068091869354248,
-0.25517722964286804,
-0.385564923286438,
0.7550771236419678,
-0.5304610729217529,
-0.9980982542037964,
0.6627782583236694,
-0.5017222166061401,
-0.12142754346132278,
0.19055378437042236,
0.3689211905002594,
-0.1575148105621338,
1.501589298248291,
0.6110979318618774,
-0.22007539868354797,
0.7649389505386353,
-0.24847999215126038,
0.46875324845314026,
-0.992431104183197,
-0.2879651188850403,
-0.6453192830085754,
-0.5223797559738159,
-0.44536009430885315,
-0.3717012405395508,
0.5900212526321411,
-0.1527179479598999,
-0.47215381264686584,
0.2197558730840683,
-0.03561766445636749,
0.30810481309890747,
-0.12071051448583603,
0.3408385217189789,
-0.09854476153850555,
-0.018201984465122223,
-0.1142999529838562,
-0.23954463005065918,
-0.716465175151825,
-0.42387548089027405,
0.7157159447669983,
0.6864736080169678,
0.6249503493309021,
-0.06242292746901512,
0.7761366367340088,
-0.07794982939958572,
0.6347301006317139,
-0.8544110655784607,
0.7517343759536743,
-0.10664049535989761,
-0.41006481647491455,
-0.09759107977151871,
-1.0038954019546509,
-0.43337324261665344,
0.10580799728631973,
-0.09596016258001328,
-1.4154633283615112,
0.05775296315550804,
-0.06848947703838348,
-0.23785850405693054,
0.3049871325492859,
-0.6812779903411865,
1.1278940439224243,
-0.16592265665531158,
-0.062170278280973434,
-0.4635236859321594,
-0.7176200151443481,
0.19197115302085876,
0.18311581015586853,
-0.046796899288892746,
-0.449480265378952,
0.12688323855400085,
0.7764165997505188,
-0.2790164053440094,
0.9172280430793762,
-0.2677995562553406,
0.2750394344329834,
0.1982797086238861,
0.34270861744880676,
0.4234902262687683,
0.3388085663318634,
-0.08072362840175629,
0.13792629539966583,
-0.6253153085708618,
-0.039076853543519974,
-0.9145817756652832,
0.3651820123195648,
-0.509425699710846,
-0.17434129118919373,
-0.09895913302898407,
-0.1349576860666275,
-0.3102372884750366,
-0.21735058724880219,
-0.017762016505002975,
0.6977542042732239,
-0.6427628993988037,
0.3837677240371704,
0.6973989605903625,
0.047038037329912186,
0.1831190437078476,
0.48475226759910583,
0.1753281056880951,
-0.34159284830093384,
0.911543071269989,
-0.1632058024406433,
0.20641204714775085,
0.4860239326953888,
0.14620327949523926,
-0.2626859247684479,
0.2285533994436264,
-0.24073255062103271,
-0.17994238436222076,
-0.8240680694580078,
-0.420573353767395,
-0.9634750485420227,
-0.08825075626373291,
-0.20445504784584045,
-0.11700605601072311,
-0.518584668636322,
-0.1835823953151703,
-0.7777791023254395,
-0.2719117999076843,
0.22662833333015442,
0.5849939584732056,
0.02728213183581829,
0.21426010131835938,
-0.6376590728759766,
-0.18104781210422516,
0.579857349395752,
0.5934811234474182,
0.2735866904258728,
-0.33470776677131653,
-0.2058010846376419,
0.15670424699783325,
-0.2512636184692383,
-0.8130955696105957,
0.3649832010269165,
0.6199688911437988,
-0.11130349338054657,
0.8031784892082214,
0.2405185103416443,
0.7490253448486328,
-0.5557491779327393,
0.34104636311531067,
0.4940395653247833,
-1.057414174079895,
0.4699859321117401,
0.14491797983646393,
0.08552885800600052,
0.6083014607429504,
0.6650103330612183,
-0.8865386843681335,
-0.07112053781747818,
-0.6923767924308777,
-0.6369365453720093,
0.8239877820014954,
0.03194129467010498,
0.31305772066116333,
0.12382442504167557,
0.22123125195503235,
-0.1840280443429947,
0.16695183515548706,
-0.5451735854148865,
0.18101240694522858,
-0.11613067984580994,
-0.6087562441825867,
-0.19747745990753174,
-0.19694973528385162,
-0.0744737908244133,
-0.17982497811317444,
0.40766075253486633,
-0.5708502531051636,
0.536168098449707,
0.25603172183036804,
-0.04417261853814125,
0.0194663368165493,
0.1938471645116806,
0.44736966490745544,
-0.21612532436847687,
-0.36812105774879456,
-0.027742715552449226,
0.5772100687026978,
0.011558661237359047,
0.10146329551935196,
-0.221635103225708,
0.5212203860282898,
-0.03035990707576275,
-0.08868291229009628,
1.5164616107940674,
0.5924283862113953,
-0.5513641238212585,
0.5508180856704712,
-0.4025532901287079,
-0.10020813345909119,
-0.1339913010597229,
-0.03215827792882919,
0.07583928108215332,
0.47755900025367737,
-0.12946635484695435,
0.04515137895941734,
0.3427247405052185,
-0.5462977290153503,
0.12995098531246185,
0.3713264465332031,
-0.9615046381950378,
-0.38402289152145386,
0.3250727951526642,
0.518267810344696,
-0.37271150946617126,
0.5758572816848755,
-0.42332398891448975,
-1.2868255376815796,
0.6582345366477966,
0.3090335428714752,
1.1861720085144043,
-0.16403143107891083,
0.32098644971847534,
0.5615302920341492,
-0.3378197252750397,
0.13761180639266968,
0.04980945959687233,
-0.49491074681282043,
-0.7211513519287109,
0.3549681603908539,
-0.47276782989501953,
-0.7587689161300659,
-0.4451468586921692,
-0.5520986914634705,
0.22130995988845825,
-0.5566404461860657,
-0.11688762158155441,
-0.15184444189071655,
0.12524379789829254,
-0.9270836710929871,
0.4280262589454651,
0.4241740107536316,
0.7642242312431335,
-0.9612104296684265,
0.49109750986099243,
0.6085500717163086,
0.11974332481622696,
-0.8627309799194336,
-0.23717667162418365,
0.15250501036643982,
-0.35676220059394836,
0.7031767964363098,
0.9584862589836121,
-0.20309005677700043,
-0.044930350035429,
-0.43048039078712463,
-0.19280491769313812,
1.0463050603866577,
-0.016147831454873085,
-0.3171364367008209,
0.32681339979171753,
-0.11138851940631866,
0.7620781064033508,
-1.0846271514892578,
0.686214804649353,
0.40569236874580383,
0.06863077729940414,
0.222432479262352,
-0.586252748966217,
-0.17810292541980743,
-0.3168151378631592,
0.118033766746521,
0.10935843735933304,
-0.8333889245986938,
0.41733935475349426,
-0.030842076987028122,
-0.46903181076049805,
-0.2656170129776001,
0.8162387013435364,
-0.05990922078490257,
0.4429469108581543,
0.8704701066017151,
0.5500675439834595,
0.8235227465629578,
-0.21696533262729645,
0.5975798964500427,
-0.08335991948843002,
0.5455039143562317,
0.6965262293815613,
-0.4762290418148041,
1.0213350057601929,
-0.026301216334104538,
0.013374879024922848,
0.6140086650848389,
0.9450129866600037,
0.5458504557609558,
0.2889077961444855,
0.20933830738067627,
-0.451010137796402,
-0.2985149025917053,
-0.35277995467185974,
0.10306117683649063,
0.6355453133583069,
0.5080054402351379,
-0.08436403423547745,
-0.06143956258893013,
0.1131000816822052,
0.20163565874099731,
-0.45837879180908203,
-0.440421462059021,
1.2111485004425049,
0.31539222598075867,
-0.4074629843235016,
0.2965880334377289,
-0.2875363230705261,
0.6403814554214478,
-0.418429434299469,
0.15211619436740875,
-0.34231436252593994,
0.20578862726688385,
-0.2879037857055664,
-0.4863559901714325,
0.14769107103347778,
0.39836108684539795,
0.12280245125293732,
-0.1947883516550064,
0.5857101082801819,
-0.6967122554779053,
-0.3407153785228729,
0.27408385276794434,
0.10231006890535355,
0.37291839718818665,
-0.0923357680439949,
-0.5103438496589661,
-0.17906345427036285,
-0.2047901153564453,
-0.4244157075881958,
0.2178076058626175,
0.8456879258155823,
0.24874086678028107,
0.6941294074058533,
0.12567102909088135,
-0.2560821771621704,
-0.2788115441799164,
0.10249579697847366,
0.6753373742103577,
-0.5853183269500732,
-0.9785333871841431,
-0.502998411655426,
0.6982280015945435,
-0.2073206901550293,
-0.3756257891654968,
-0.059452302753925323,
0.10183422267436981,
0.5404765009880066,
0.2692810595035553,
0.3695327341556549,
0.04899154230952263,
0.34704580903053284,
-0.36774611473083496,
0.5320523977279663,
-0.9624869227409363,
-0.1285582184791565,
-0.3394836485385895,
-0.5872336626052856,
-0.3275262713432312,
0.8030685782432556,
-0.009565058164298534,
0.15955404937267303,
0.6675513982772827,
0.6905368566513062,
-0.1777457594871521,
0.5359477400779724,
0.18147526681423187,
0.05661540478467941,
0.32097578048706055,
1.011979103088379,
0.4237661361694336,
-0.19369950890541077,
0.3220589756965637,
-0.3625071346759796,
-0.18850241601467133,
-0.6173607110977173,
-0.9917675256729126,
-0.7189779877662659,
-0.7012327313423157,
-0.3553721308708191,
-0.22789715230464935,
-0.10157493501901627,
1.053507685661316,
0.7984978556632996,
-0.7176703214645386,
-0.06818126887083054,
-0.177604541182518,
0.09511507302522659,
0.15503747761249542,
-0.2080366611480713,
0.06375329196453094,
-0.32164904475212097,
-0.7555869221687317,
-0.08531689643859863,
0.5958413481712341,
0.14903025329113007,
-0.1908348798751831,
-0.34881553053855896,
0.07862263172864914,
-0.024706073105335236,
0.3678925037384033,
0.23742301762104034,
-0.2362954169511795,
-0.43697530031204224,
-0.2222844809293747,
-0.3486606776714325,
0.37698641419410706,
1.0166088342666626,
-0.5352886915206909,
0.6576670408248901,
0.4171990156173706,
0.7544722557067871,
0.49317577481269836,
-0.008483241312205791,
0.6071912050247192,
-0.9367661476135254,
0.32664602994918823,
0.4011787474155426,
0.5249387621879578,
0.5511000752449036,
-0.3094015419483185,
0.5197507739067078,
0.15485255420207977,
-0.5428943634033203,
-0.8276273608207703,
0.36542457342147827,
-0.8934141993522644,
0.3136042356491089,
0.8292020559310913,
-0.6223785281181335,
-0.29406464099884033,
0.3860493302345276,
-0.2232624590396881,
0.37907370924949646,
-0.48980218172073364,
0.6604032516479492,
0.604939341545105,
-0.13641144335269928,
-0.2782612442970276,
-0.35780975222587585,
0.19710130989551544,
0.5977399349212646,
-0.9828737378120422,
0.08025869727134705,
0.3168330192565918,
0.027420232072472572,
0.07036533951759338,
0.7086467742919922,
0.1313207894563675,
0.13899339735507965,
-0.0496789924800396,
-0.1318662017583847,
0.18966461718082428,
-0.6914458870887756,
-0.5990893840789795,
0.08243055641651154,
-0.4029662013053894,
-0.18521617352962494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11132v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11132v1
|
A Novel ICD Coding Framework Based on Associated and Hierarchical Code Description Distillation
| 2024-04-17T07:26:23 | 2024-04-17T07:26:23 |
Bin Zhang, Junli Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
ICD(International Classification of Diseases) coding involves assigning ICD
codes to patients visit based on their medical notes. ICD coding is a
challenging multilabel text classification problem due to noisy medical
document inputs. Recent advancements in automated ICD coding have enhanced
performance by integrating additional data and knowledge bases with the
encoding of medical notes and codes. However, most of them ignore the code
hierarchy, leading to improper code assignments. To address these problems, we
propose a novel framework based on associated and hierarchical code description
distillation (AHDD) for better code representation learning and avoidance of
improper code assignment.we utilize the code description and the hierarchical
structure inherent to the ICD codes. Therefore, in this paper, we leverage the
code description and the hierarchical structure inherent to the ICD codes. The
code description is also applied to aware the attention layer and output layer.
Experimental results on the benchmark dataset show the superiority of the
proposed framework over several state-of-the-art baselines.
|
[
-0.25152388215065,
-0.3003953993320465,
0.40880829095840454,
0.18191178143024445,
-0.3553440570831299,
0.4245753884315491,
0.20882445573806763,
-0.4137706160545349,
-0.018791336566209793,
0.02188587188720703,
-0.31070953607559204,
-0.6728863716125488,
-0.6387048363685608,
-0.1116747185587883,
-0.09752777218818665,
1.2073665857315063,
-0.2590722441673279,
0.16657176613807678,
-0.22676388919353485,
-0.17729324102401733,
-0.2865467071533203,
-0.9012539982795715,
-0.4905051290988922,
-0.4006688594818115,
0.18510326743125916,
0.2972610890865326,
0.3129945695400238,
0.8660064935684204,
0.9048454165458679,
0.2301824986934662,
-0.06153823062777519,
0.1773393154144287,
-0.005586730781942606,
-0.248449444770813,
0.03240359202027321,
-0.024699335917830467,
-0.8929187059402466,
-0.45384883880615234,
0.3754783272743225,
0.6176803112030029,
-0.5728568434715271,
0.1731823831796646,
0.23559090495109558,
0.6677600145339966,
-0.5496385097503662,
0.4948135316371918,
-0.21554754674434662,
0.23489542305469513,
0.02104574255645275,
-0.570523738861084,
-0.31839892268180847,
-0.09242545068264008,
-0.03813311085104942,
-0.4033142924308777,
-0.08496109396219254,
0.06748960167169571,
0.5106685757637024,
0.5299661159515381,
-0.38370904326438904,
-0.49509772658348083,
-0.5983076691627502,
0.10829903185367584,
-0.4854530096054077,
0.08505003154277802,
0.30348366498947144,
0.4273456931114197,
0.22347456216812134,
-0.6934894323348999,
-0.41987693309783936,
0.19737105071544647,
-0.1806076169013977,
0.12687593698501587,
-0.11133307963609695,
0.34612759947776794,
0.11310764402151108,
0.7490400075912476,
-0.31565773487091064,
0.005017272662371397,
-0.32470703125,
-0.031173136085271835,
0.24384437501430511,
-0.03012361377477646,
0.4141356945037842,
-0.13308042287826538,
-0.5936347842216492,
0.3273705542087555,
-0.3131464719772339,
-0.14823970198631287,
-0.22950930893421173,
0.038314949721097946,
-0.6166048645973206,
0.1540161371231079,
-0.03217743709683418,
0.251043438911438,
0.658569872379303,
-0.6233589053153992,
0.6771060228347778,
-0.01075847540050745,
-0.45169538259506226,
0.5650832653045654,
0.30722787976264954,
0.4819536805152893,
0.008173227310180664,
-0.14193369448184967,
-0.13942480087280273,
0.05576945096254349,
0.532184362411499,
-0.6020183563232422,
-0.5398189425468445,
0.2007201761007309,
-0.9521127343177795,
-0.4154288172721863,
-0.18253162503242493,
-0.9018864035606384,
-0.3361050486564636,
-0.31852850317955017,
-0.0005214990815147758,
-0.34009337425231934,
-0.1363040953874588,
0.2920517027378082,
0.13007201254367828,
-0.3389890491962433,
0.2826178967952728,
-1.0034782886505127,
0.6972494721412659,
0.2081233561038971,
0.5656142830848694,
-0.20959869027137756,
-0.08407972007989883,
-0.38172647356987,
0.5159211158752441,
-0.08672836422920227,
0.4741826355457306,
-0.2430536299943924,
-0.2751857042312622,
-0.1765412837266922,
-0.383938193321228,
0.1782555729150772,
-0.6843960285186768,
0.5662530660629272,
-0.4399743676185608,
-0.42730894684791565,
0.3707345426082611,
-0.1734301745891571,
-0.050997015088796616,
0.17996612191200256,
-0.797429084777832,
0.6790754199028015,
0.4301641881465912,
-1.0183849334716797,
0.31881627440452576,
-0.47215014696121216,
-0.6317939758300781,
0.2506355941295624,
-0.4587714672088623,
-0.5053598284721375,
-0.0032370868138968945,
0.46407610177993774,
0.21679484844207764,
-0.23462438583374023,
0.4563736021518707,
0.1519056260585785,
-0.2058398723602295,
-0.10552620887756348,
-0.2817333936691284,
0.7738195657730103,
0.4317796528339386,
-0.4409804940223694,
-0.013736598193645477,
-1.1474840641021729,
0.024649037048220634,
-0.2719196081161499,
-0.6262868642807007,
-0.3865385055541992,
-0.07790076732635498,
0.011474035680294037,
0.304329514503479,
0.023799464106559753,
-0.22411976754665375,
0.30649712681770325,
-0.03666705638170242,
0.3093891143798828,
0.66884446144104,
0.43753135204315186,
0.4292476177215576,
-0.37776944041252136,
0.5266815423965454,
0.5514616966247559,
0.20536388456821442,
-0.2735004127025604,
-0.31732308864593506,
-0.32936859130859375,
-0.36638832092285156,
0.29128608107566833,
0.5192812085151672,
-0.8576655983924866,
0.5245907306671143,
-0.2532959282398224,
-0.09019986540079117,
-0.5994881391525269,
0.1276269257068634,
0.6825109124183655,
0.8116297125816345,
0.5655902028083801,
-0.2549968659877777,
-0.5530381202697754,
-0.6570596694946289,
0.6096699833869934,
-0.6565308570861816,
0.13419698178768158,
0.1579820066690445,
0.24976229667663574,
-0.472587525844574,
0.4668411612510681,
-0.4945039749145508,
-0.6993876099586487,
-0.15510591864585876,
0.11947878450155258,
-0.029300564900040627,
0.8236510753631592,
0.5937761664390564,
-0.7823827266693115,
-0.4108729064464569,
0.391203910112381,
-0.3931470513343811,
0.04104992374777794,
-0.32738903164863586,
-0.161861851811409,
-0.038648512214422226,
0.46341001987457275,
-0.09767065942287445,
0.6402989625930786,
0.293193519115448,
0.017177142202854156,
0.32868891954421997,
-0.7274883389472961,
0.351545512676239,
-1.0512025356292725,
0.18255186080932617,
0.06320590525865555,
-0.022003844380378723,
-0.3140692114830017,
0.18942362070083618,
0.5796296000480652,
0.1732027530670166,
-0.2513478994369507,
-0.029261689633131027,
-0.43805956840515137,
0.204240083694458,
-0.0675411969423294,
-0.38427555561065674,
0.15871399641036987,
0.7838780879974365,
0.022747259587049484,
0.2380460500717163,
0.8051313757896423,
-0.639840304851532,
0.48185229301452637,
0.1629132330417633,
-0.3761051893234253,
0.7443451285362244,
-0.43388140201568604,
-0.20557492971420288,
-0.2224447876214981,
0.3874080777168274,
-0.7837937474250793,
-0.09360162913799286,
0.15493232011795044,
-0.2625358998775482,
0.6481118202209473,
-0.3623219132423401,
-0.6027966737747192,
-0.7833292484283447,
0.009407274425029755,
0.8976747393608093,
0.7982858419418335,
-0.7833935618400574,
0.34840312600135803,
0.660030722618103,
0.016614926978945732,
-0.4186670780181885,
-0.8534010052680969,
-0.002086443128064275,
-0.3894302546977997,
-0.07703973352909088,
0.7200503349304199,
-0.09225013107061386,
-0.12001287192106247,
-0.08101548999547958,
-0.4915129244327545,
-0.43300920724868774,
-0.015761200338602066,
0.2469940185546875,
0.36638200283050537,
-0.23434767127037048,
0.2718126177787781,
0.16309736669063568,
-0.19665774703025818,
0.0807814821600914,
-0.3804173469543457,
0.22273264825344086,
0.3472098708152771,
-0.4736188054084778,
-0.7239816188812256,
0.568699061870575,
0.8128994703292847,
-0.35714948177337646,
0.16119404137134552,
0.2826531231403351,
-0.9299128651618958,
-0.34134265780448914,
-0.0666930228471756,
0.20622731745243073,
-0.4694148600101471,
0.5666276216506958,
-0.3031666576862335,
-0.351371169090271,
0.6504380702972412,
-0.13518066704273224,
-0.1623835563659668,
0.20319563150405884,
0.39544108510017395,
0.004465594422072172,
1.3117989301681519,
0.8024117946624756,
-0.25559914112091064,
-0.141204833984375,
0.00010314246901543811,
0.32547545433044434,
-1.0473682880401611,
-0.5502523183822632,
-0.7621407508850098,
-0.16504982113838196,
-0.22828708589076996,
-0.3957294225692749,
0.5301571488380432,
0.307728111743927,
-0.1263635754585266,
-0.21890737116336823,
-0.9172657132148743,
0.31562912464141846,
0.18944163620471954,
0.1748735010623932,
0.3551783859729767,
0.2545776665210724,
-0.3913661539554596,
-0.047798287123441696,
-0.7982850074768066,
-0.21482403576374054,
0.8342394828796387,
0.5842527747154236,
1.2034029960632324,
0.019949039444327354,
0.8726380467414856,
0.46042343974113464,
0.09982481598854065,
-0.632524847984314,
0.024503285065293312,
-0.3319544792175293,
-0.29993411898612976,
0.32469022274017334,
-0.3182057738304138,
-0.44276711344718933,
-0.11281100660562515,
0.23621150851249695,
-0.8333248496055603,
0.5758352875709534,
0.37043535709381104,
-0.8033686876296997,
0.36980125308036804,
-0.8910586833953857,
0.7245103716850281,
-0.41933688521385193,
-0.002253427868708968,
-0.07546418905258179,
-0.6906739473342896,
0.23927779495716095,
-0.16289585828781128,
0.5160462260246277,
0.31512486934661865,
0.1757856011390686,
0.539497435092926,
-0.4423339366912842,
0.7767211198806763,
-0.05312616005539894,
-0.45178601145744324,
0.17303459346294403,
-0.21339550614356995,
0.20036260783672333,
0.4097052812576294,
0.10036643594503403,
-0.02699621394276619,
0.053371865302324295,
-0.2804156243801117,
-0.46517887711524963,
0.7961029410362244,
-0.6046267747879028,
-0.16545158624649048,
-0.36616164445877075,
-0.24636472761631012,
-0.20238430798053741,
0.2630295157432556,
0.23426149785518646,
1.0967077016830444,
0.020538408309221268,
-0.25078096985816956,
0.7803550362586975,
-0.2067253291606903,
0.1946241408586502,
-0.03644314035773277,
0.036347709596157074,
-0.3675355613231659,
0.7269477248191833,
-0.1100926548242569,
0.2343583106994629,
0.6317394971847534,
-0.17938098311424255,
-0.15677814185619354,
-0.8584356307983398,
-0.8308477401733398,
-0.23844976723194122,
-1.0051634311676025,
-0.5309010148048401,
-0.6851058006286621,
-0.37524867057800293,
-0.6075889468193054,
-0.23295094072818756,
-0.02354240044951439,
-0.11561878025531769,
-0.34100478887557983,
-0.15385885536670685,
0.17533046007156372,
0.8085605502128601,
-0.035349879413843155,
0.19750924408435822,
-0.8311073184013367,
0.9890110492706299,
0.014271303080022335,
0.793514609336853,
0.35778504610061646,
-0.0341290645301342,
-0.632970929145813,
0.19065706431865692,
-0.2707306444644928,
-0.7861580848693848,
0.19423164427280426,
0.18919941782951355,
0.8190745115280151,
0.5470707416534424,
0.5567266941070557,
1.0339151620864868,
-0.7812604308128357,
0.380927175283432,
0.5247999429702759,
-0.900427520275116,
0.5446272492408752,
0.14418089389801025,
0.4747529923915863,
0.46933263540267944,
0.25563228130340576,
-0.4117165207862854,
-0.2509911060333252,
-0.48777148127555847,
-0.9864441752433777,
0.9132850766181946,
-0.12453459948301315,
-0.16311147809028625,
-0.22728729248046875,
0.5638473629951477,
0.14948007464408875,
0.17384718358516693,
-0.531074047088623,
-0.6452147960662842,
-0.0898665115237236,
-0.6553770899772644,
0.20214638113975525,
-0.19359207153320312,
-0.24711103737354279,
-0.38185015320777893,
0.1939401775598526,
-0.12682567536830902,
0.4898145794868469,
0.3949826657772064,
-0.013054686598479748,
-0.3810805380344391,
0.16381420195102692,
0.06205875054001808,
0.5807808637619019,
-0.15822888910770416,
0.5287178158760071,
-0.29607507586479187,
-0.6940764784812927,
0.1642913818359375,
0.27147176861763,
0.20351286232471466,
-0.16369280219078064,
0.2142738252878189,
0.5351393818855286,
0.11298558861017227,
-0.5278806090354919,
0.3838234841823578,
-0.07760461419820786,
-0.21103382110595703,
-0.0037468099035322666,
0.036665741354227066,
0.012566438876092434,
-0.03175364434719086,
0.5753412246704102,
0.6000818014144897,
0.5160275101661682,
-0.5362739562988281,
0.6163084506988525,
-0.09761397540569305,
-0.2960019111633301,
-0.0951741486787796,
0.7006466388702393,
0.4749673008918762,
-0.11451679468154907,
0.4292607605457306,
-0.22517560422420502,
-0.5688176155090332,
0.9425519704818726,
0.6402696371078491,
0.5735064148902893,
-0.19693882763385773,
0.141822949051857,
0.26206594705581665,
0.007164682261645794,
0.22754372656345367,
0.13749045133590698,
-0.5751979351043701,
-0.2943038046360016,
-0.37816759943962097,
-0.571542501449585,
0.16351889073848724,
0.1453525274991989,
-1.1392312049865723,
0.2969626188278198,
-0.6796438694000244,
0.09735754132270813,
0.14295557141304016,
-0.18377771973609924,
-0.09140340983867645,
0.3168264627456665,
0.3243028521537781,
0.7616049647331238,
-0.2633872330188751,
0.9757675528526306,
1.0577430725097656,
-0.12096603214740753,
-0.6420331001281738,
0.2790593206882477,
0.18288591504096985,
-0.5288495421409607,
0.4954070746898651,
0.1397821307182312,
-0.12733834981918335,
0.0970349982380867,
0.006268512923270464,
-0.6939026117324829,
0.8358913660049438,
0.026546983048319817,
-0.4882151186466217,
-0.3666098415851593,
-0.22680623829364777,
0.646630585193634,
-0.6806523203849792,
-0.26088380813598633,
0.4726414680480957,
-0.02380736730992794,
0.2676003873348236,
-1.2151237726211548,
0.06589202582836151,
-0.7498022317886353,
-0.2653249204158783,
0.04107202962040901,
-0.3011603355407715,
0.5584700107574463,
-0.6153901815414429,
-0.24769769608974457,
0.0005482985288836062,
0.11129023879766464,
0.14932341873645782,
0.42646947503089905,
0.11862047016620636,
0.39953848719596863,
0.6210481524467468,
0.026459449902176857,
0.9186480045318604,
-0.40794938802719116,
0.1900622546672821,
1.1639370918273926,
-0.40458205342292786,
0.39170923829078674,
0.3619297742843628,
-0.23914773762226105,
0.4186168909072876,
0.5780424475669861,
0.30620163679122925,
0.974928617477417,
0.31482020020484924,
-0.11805135756731033,
0.14772041141986847,
0.2183108925819397,
-0.703814685344696,
0.07334514707326889,
0.4419292211532593,
-0.3742321729660034,
-0.4703161120414734,
0.2465689480304718,
-0.3708958327770233,
0.20215101540088654,
-0.5388385057449341,
1.1064306497573853,
-0.028197171166539192,
-0.5316177010536194,
0.9084899425506592,
0.22167928516864777,
0.566284716129303,
-0.2794259488582611,
-0.3242754340171814,
0.13467180728912354,
0.5723289847373962,
-0.3540686070919037,
-0.33569926023483276,
0.21820393204689026,
-0.045327093452215195,
-0.36733585596084595,
-0.4481312036514282,
0.23927229642868042,
-0.5641635656356812,
-0.27101969718933105,
0.10234272480010986,
0.06647001951932907,
-0.22077447175979614,
0.43424248695373535,
-0.7286800146102905,
-0.029246242716908455,
0.18729247152805328,
0.47380152344703674,
0.3040536344051361,
0.8648082613945007,
0.04749879613518715,
0.5246461629867554,
0.09065928310155869,
0.15281647443771362,
-0.006403075996786356,
0.2558351159095764,
0.9640244841575623,
-0.23449568450450897,
-1.2155178785324097,
-0.49601465463638306,
0.5375488996505737,
0.08714330941438675,
-0.2500591576099396,
0.2679384648799896,
0.4156002998352051,
0.7625864148139954,
0.04158546030521393,
0.8895916938781738,
-0.15270106494426727,
0.29648327827453613,
-0.4444642961025238,
0.8041202425956726,
-0.4135395586490631,
0.5722830891609192,
-0.4723432958126068,
-0.4954737722873688,
-0.5548116564750671,
0.700963020324707,
0.33527228236198425,
0.10981759428977966,
0.9237287044525146,
0.09426743537187576,
-0.15691296756267548,
-0.18852517008781433,
-0.06446901708841324,
0.1464899480342865,
0.2698137164115906,
0.7257628440856934,
0.5474039316177368,
-0.3135322332382202,
0.3533443212509155,
-0.624139666557312,
-0.4894593060016632,
-0.2903459072113037,
-0.6242728233337402,
-0.727527379989624,
-0.6425347924232483,
-0.8507302403450012,
-0.24004177749156952,
0.1410738229751587,
0.7325233221054077,
0.9274635314941406,
-0.7468196749687195,
0.05269424617290497,
-0.1813274472951889,
0.1043948233127594,
-0.46411246061325073,
-0.10463490337133408,
0.7833288311958313,
-0.20895323157310486,
-0.5625459551811218,
-0.3368166983127594,
0.5545974373817444,
0.41190800070762634,
0.0875423327088356,
-0.29163622856140137,
-0.06042126566171646,
-0.5236472487449646,
0.38972342014312744,
-0.03350607305765152,
-0.3838372826576233,
0.05235862731933594,
-0.2621437907218933,
-0.369816392660141,
0.41257917881011963,
0.9055948257446289,
-0.6935954093933105,
0.35557183623313904,
0.06560228765010834,
0.5088458061218262,
-0.0007976320339366794,
0.2407807856798172,
0.23824112117290497,
-0.7915377616882324,
0.13746428489685059,
0.35897237062454224,
0.2251499593257904,
0.12243695557117462,
-0.665776252746582,
-0.025950660929083824,
-0.10521980375051498,
-0.312073677778244,
-0.8907784819602966,
0.026982402428984642,
-1.043245553970337,
-0.3327710032463074,
0.998472273349762,
-0.29982268810272217,
-0.1669861525297165,
-0.7138522267341614,
-0.5302643775939941,
0.12800464034080505,
-0.4103487730026245,
1.0319781303405762,
0.5104579329490662,
-0.2247428447008133,
-0.11094830185174942,
-0.15466490387916565,
0.7832431793212891,
-0.0036041110288351774,
-0.7108835577964783,
0.22385726869106293,
0.769209086894989,
-0.18935713171958923,
0.27463430166244507,
0.929871141910553,
-0.7017909288406372,
0.5144649744033813,
-0.10864381492137909,
0.17662015557289124,
0.001084267278201878,
-0.5299193263053894,
-0.36103981733322144,
0.26167577505111694,
0.17382168769836426,
-0.37919217348098755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11124v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11124v1
|
What's under the hood: Investigating Automatic Metrics on Meeting Summarization
| 2024-04-17T07:15:07 | 2024-04-17T07:15:07 |
Frederic Kirstein, Jan Philip Wahle, Terry Ruas, Bela Gipp
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Meeting summarization has become a critical task considering the increase in
online interactions. While new techniques are introduced regularly, their
evaluation uses metrics not designed to capture meeting-specific errors,
undermining effective evaluation. This paper investigates what the frequently
used automatic metrics capture and which errors they mask by correlating
automatic metric scores with human evaluations across a broad error taxonomy.
We commence with a comprehensive literature review on English meeting
summarization to define key challenges like speaker dynamics and contextual
turn-taking and error types such as missing information and linguistic
inaccuracy, concepts previously loosely defined in the field. We examine the
relationship between characteristic challenges and errors by using annotated
transcripts and summaries from Transformer-based sequence-to-sequence and
autoregressive models from the general summary QMSum dataset. Through
experimental validation, we find that different model architectures respond
variably to challenges in meeting transcripts, resulting in different
pronounced links between challenges and errors. Current default-used metrics
struggle to capture observable errors, showing weak to mid-correlations, while
a third of the correlations show trends of error masking. Only a subset reacts
accurately to specific errors, while most correlations show either
unresponsiveness or failure to reflect the error's impact on summary quality.
|
[
-0.3650200068950653,
-0.22304341197013855,
0.4396574795246124,
0.15102197229862213,
0.29384756088256836,
0.4663652777671814,
0.14194968342781067,
-0.5390998721122742,
0.36385419964790344,
-0.10428477823734283,
-0.6613014340400696,
-0.18298879265785217,
-0.6411169171333313,
0.453204482793808,
-0.547295868396759,
1.0756001472473145,
-0.2985914945602417,
-0.06879542022943497,
-0.44188353419303894,
-0.28383126854896545,
-0.5484578609466553,
-0.8217565417289734,
-0.32498690485954285,
-0.10147380083799362,
0.27564048767089844,
0.4529883563518524,
0.6626381874084473,
0.3950144648551941,
0.8710054755210876,
0.22975152730941772,
0.009511187672615051,
0.5771647095680237,
-0.1911136507987976,
-0.2907331585884094,
0.17880326509475708,
-0.46376222372055054,
-1.0816106796264648,
0.3998103439807892,
0.7921380400657654,
1.044374942779541,
-0.17276643216609955,
0.488922119140625,
0.23677469789981842,
0.6642429232597351,
-0.42621567845344543,
0.25293412804603577,
-0.5246292948722839,
0.17389772832393646,
0.038754742592573166,
-0.20097889006137848,
0.3065713942050934,
-0.10430741310119629,
0.0563405342400074,
-0.5819063186645508,
0.4197286367416382,
0.18515288829803467,
1.090315818786621,
0.3561306595802307,
-0.25676730275154114,
-0.370891273021698,
-0.7326605916023254,
0.5730279088020325,
-0.7221555709838867,
-0.03550376743078232,
0.5950642228126526,
0.4920119047164917,
-0.07892540097236633,
-0.49970048666000366,
-0.288417786359787,
0.1368669867515564,
-0.5187178254127502,
0.3288287818431854,
-0.36307501792907715,
-0.03185969591140747,
0.24818480014801025,
0.5689758062362671,
-0.37094366550445557,
0.11668390780687332,
-0.5318000316619873,
-0.23442578315734863,
0.7149471640586853,
0.7264840006828308,
0.3571246564388275,
-0.31212058663368225,
0.0619724839925766,
0.09727299213409424,
-0.21862640976905823,
0.05578482151031494,
0.05580948665738106,
0.16272087395191193,
-0.3249390721321106,
0.4468209147453308,
-0.24000908434391022,
0.1562959998846054,
0.028602341189980507,
0.07127458602190018,
0.17027917504310608,
-0.718802809715271,
-0.014790847897529602,
-0.3417789936065674,
0.7701084017753601,
0.9971839785575867,
0.12380042672157288,
-0.23171697556972504,
-0.46893876791000366,
-0.07120443135499954,
-0.07396050542593002,
-0.39471256732940674,
-0.5425201058387756,
0.5943104028701782,
-0.12000691890716553,
-0.031830817461013794,
0.30953800678253174,
-0.6049558520317078,
0.004802307114005089,
-0.3307339549064636,
0.7229989767074585,
0.18391111493110657,
0.009502722881734371,
-0.19706925749778748,
-0.4485539197921753,
0.05490632355213165,
0.6533913016319275,
-0.41837236285209656,
0.6432979702949524,
0.45679911971092224,
1.1643685102462769,
-0.30785730481147766,
-0.4572446644306183,
-0.6099685430526733,
-0.044810689985752106,
-0.3851882815361023,
0.7925500273704529,
0.3205895721912384,
-0.5681101679801941,
-0.2280845046043396,
0.04348481073975563,
-0.4412975609302521,
-0.7100896239280701,
0.07263665646314621,
0.11995500326156616,
0.54491126537323,
-0.2560941278934479,
-0.44896528124809265,
0.24731869995594025,
0.14435142278671265,
-0.4155925214290619,
0.8163054585456848,
0.14548958837985992,
-0.57889324426651,
0.34012168645858765,
-0.9259824156761169,
-0.12391497194766998,
0.03642294183373451,
-0.2587377727031708,
-0.5421860814094543,
0.2429019659757614,
0.34607264399528503,
0.27167439460754395,
0.08431808650493622,
0.012046732939779758,
0.23849138617515564,
-0.44101765751838684,
0.5461391806602478,
0.20517165958881378,
0.4770803153514862,
-0.14567264914512634,
-0.2775900065898895,
0.1936711221933365,
-0.987338662147522,
-0.039170343428850174,
0.21296852827072144,
-0.11681060492992401,
-0.0446794219315052,
0.23102672398090363,
-0.3039594292640686,
0.16529229283332825,
0.1696872115135193,
-0.1251073032617569,
-0.2767282724380493,
-0.032551657408475876,
0.30009275674819946,
0.31525060534477234,
0.41832438111305237,
0.252109169960022,
-0.8215768933296204,
0.4720918834209442,
-0.005318413954228163,
0.26750117540359497,
-0.6010490655899048,
-0.45994600653648376,
-0.624909520149231,
-0.3172607719898224,
0.036478880792856216,
0.755492091178894,
-0.23306457698345184,
0.39212891459465027,
-0.40255022048950195,
-0.6929681301116943,
-0.5977039337158203,
0.05041706934571266,
0.4280763566493988,
0.10671647638082504,
0.21920213103294373,
-0.49629175662994385,
-0.6103065013885498,
-0.6217854022979736,
-0.5532866716384888,
-0.32606542110443115,
-0.5870544910430908,
0.09956425428390503,
0.5521646738052368,
-0.10349570214748383,
1.0770303010940552,
-0.33041512966156006,
-0.7493542432785034,
-0.10066983848810196,
0.5008462071418762,
-0.0015173269202932715,
0.45949918031692505,
0.43966007232666016,
-0.3613373935222626,
-0.17595839500427246,
-0.33849528431892395,
-0.7077853679656982,
-0.5396961569786072,
-0.179298996925354,
0.4270201325416565,
0.37527820467948914,
0.4474679231643677,
-0.39767953753471375,
0.5696666240692139,
0.28029534220695496,
-0.19058355689048767,
0.718006432056427,
-0.24141386151313782,
0.5362414121627808,
-0.6280185580253601,
-0.054626282304525375,
-0.20416902005672455,
-0.3176964819431305,
-0.3792657256126404,
-0.04717476665973663,
-0.03348216786980629,
-0.005093482788652182,
-0.2516939043998718,
0.09557291120290756,
-0.7169365882873535,
-0.3599485754966736,
-0.2217787355184555,
0.5013289451599121,
0.4254463315010071,
0.5807392597198486,
-0.3968587815761566,
0.678402841091156,
0.05888617783784866,
-0.8886568546295166,
0.30054518580436707,
0.562321126461029,
-0.030565913766622543,
0.7134190797805786,
-0.6828019618988037,
0.02125849761068821,
-0.16323137283325195,
0.18602395057678223,
-1.3034011125564575,
-0.716985821723938,
0.05684018135070801,
-0.958045244216919,
0.20664207637310028,
0.17419923841953278,
-0.5084318518638611,
-0.15667244791984558,
-0.7199321985244751,
0.28902143239974976,
0.3799050450325012,
-0.12879307568073273,
0.6203517913818359,
0.6530952453613281,
-0.04442908242344856,
-0.07916629314422607,
-0.9200725555419922,
0.45440322160720825,
-0.32781633734703064,
-0.19354407489299774,
-0.004239784553647041,
0.0011882733087986708,
-0.604338526725769,
-0.18375761806964874,
-0.19518163800239563,
0.045837368816137314,
0.23428797721862793,
0.33146488666534424,
0.19151292741298676,
0.01836821623146534,
-0.10731470584869385,
-0.4987384080886841,
-0.039982520043849945,
0.4123881757259369,
0.05171613767743111,
-0.029954517260193825,
-0.32709088921546936,
-0.3519473671913147,
-0.8778895139694214,
0.6811574101448059,
0.7790592312812805,
-0.03784506395459175,
0.5985545516014099,
0.3184185028076172,
-0.5676527619361877,
0.3419559895992279,
-0.5220571160316467,
-0.07909861952066422,
-0.30220627784729004,
0.6488170027732849,
-0.1362800896167755,
-0.32368773221969604,
1.1125091314315796,
0.22438018023967743,
0.5477322936058044,
0.8314965963363647,
0.18709029257297516,
-0.5195449590682983,
1.0260167121887207,
0.5455687642097473,
0.23161344230175018,
0.12549683451652527,
0.026707246899604797,
0.15575584769248962,
-0.775303840637207,
-0.16821599006652832,
-0.8738727569580078,
-0.1775946170091629,
-0.5165433883666992,
-0.3018593490123749,
0.6104339361190796,
0.027393965050578117,
0.09547705203294754,
0.4366499185562134,
-0.1496592015028,
0.36822372674942017,
0.331791490316391,
-0.5591809749603271,
0.6084449291229248,
-0.2807137072086334,
0.35294678807258606,
-0.4574924111366272,
-0.8720430135726929,
-0.660717785358429,
0.5270326733589172,
0.3797011375427246,
0.5668599009513855,
0.18528622388839722,
0.4429575204849243,
0.27920854091644287,
0.30631566047668457,
-0.7320991158485413,
0.438576340675354,
0.2756333351135254,
-0.4474791884422302,
-0.35004153847694397,
-0.686598002910614,
-0.5527974963188171,
0.2669023275375366,
-0.16000232100486755,
-0.8289634585380554,
0.1456584930419922,
0.37381091713905334,
-0.3929575979709625,
0.4252169132232666,
-0.839949369430542,
0.723413348197937,
-0.05125737190246582,
0.25867798924446106,
0.1529494673013687,
-0.8239666819572449,
0.25017738342285156,
-0.24470001459121704,
0.7270651459693909,
-0.33590221405029297,
-0.08294495195150375,
1.0500805377960205,
-0.2849148213863373,
0.8335272669792175,
0.15804074704647064,
-0.03043431043624878,
0.14507542550563812,
0.24864406883716583,
0.3907199203968048,
-0.2924749255180359,
0.4603837728500366,
0.38121137022972107,
0.4301103949546814,
-0.3401341140270233,
-0.6559135913848877,
0.1336783766746521,
-0.6254062056541443,
-0.516266942024231,
-0.3853354752063751,
-0.3220328092575073,
-0.3646780848503113,
-0.38846901059150696,
0.5117954611778259,
0.7499886751174927,
-0.26466140151023865,
-0.3794824779033661,
0.019884653389453888,
-0.15879034996032715,
0.5352494120597839,
0.5604801774024963,
-0.3330652713775635,
-0.5889406204223633,
0.8004478812217712,
0.5347477197647095,
0.702135443687439,
0.10865307599306107,
0.012067981995642185,
0.15922419726848602,
-0.5030620098114014,
-0.2873252332210541,
0.23349423706531525,
-0.8185524940490723,
-0.3069494366645813,
-0.8612272143363953,
-0.3231511414051056,
-0.3574464023113251,
0.06284265965223312,
-0.3145504593849182,
-0.9192586541175842,
-0.2617771625518799,
-0.09479617327451706,
-0.048337433487176895,
0.7240977883338928,
-0.18658801913261414,
0.450440913438797,
-1.1871801614761353,
0.19009077548980713,
-0.03322469815611839,
0.10354682803153992,
0.01948370411992073,
-0.6224047541618347,
-0.526500403881073,
-0.06892647594213486,
-0.3205718994140625,
-0.8784623742103577,
0.2811683714389801,
0.5519315004348755,
0.4215060770511627,
0.034980833530426025,
0.164210706949234,
0.8811181783676147,
-0.26162227988243103,
1.0628308057785034,
0.19435866177082062,
-0.9338167309761047,
0.6507035493850708,
-0.28462541103363037,
0.6757785677909851,
0.39998430013656616,
0.25128746032714844,
-0.726151704788208,
-1.1146929264068604,
-0.7051302194595337,
-1.0913888216018677,
0.6255208253860474,
0.4246485233306885,
-0.10438940674066544,
-0.12084964662790298,
0.3291492164134979,
-0.08166027814149857,
0.33743536472320557,
-0.5818080902099609,
-0.28439635038375854,
0.044398561120033264,
0.06813603639602661,
-0.07294780761003494,
-0.2414730340242386,
-0.28186869621276855,
-0.14419062435626984,
0.6881982088088989,
-0.08703509718179703,
0.14107699692249298,
0.7285197377204895,
-0.2989559769630432,
-0.43805864453315735,
0.16200819611549377,
0.7328489422798157,
1.094300389289856,
-0.46763816475868225,
0.02581506222486496,
0.5054720044136047,
-0.2880494296550751,
-0.24699905514717102,
-0.20498260855674744,
0.24282026290893555,
0.5053411722183228,
0.6264510154724121,
0.4280260503292084,
0.21086667478084564,
-0.63862144947052,
0.5842888951301575,
-0.34308525919914246,
-0.2766881287097931,
-0.5652860403060913,
-0.16116374731063843,
-0.3261977434158325,
-0.06779523193836212,
0.8665521740913391,
0.05428803339600563,
0.25356587767601013,
-0.5411516427993774,
0.14418482780456543,
0.26949843764305115,
-0.4988671839237213,
-0.6002054810523987,
0.7707711458206177,
0.21487785875797272,
-0.551069438457489,
0.04475971683859825,
-0.29317277669906616,
-0.6415716409683228,
0.5028121471405029,
-0.11912161856889725,
0.8885642886161804,
-0.18824650347232819,
-0.15126200020313263,
0.47379070520401,
0.5543613433837891,
0.3943255841732025,
-0.2096276581287384,
-0.1032896414399147,
-0.2699158489704132,
-0.47116345167160034,
-0.27725017070770264,
-0.8193243145942688,
-0.04334500432014465,
-0.6768028140068054,
0.11174631118774414,
-0.28265196084976196,
-0.31881529092788696,
-0.04437774047255516,
-0.02131989598274231,
-0.4222181439399719,
-0.010423210449516773,
-0.2642538249492645,
0.6496075987815857,
-0.714733898639679,
-0.3459407687187195,
0.6743896007537842,
-0.31322240829467773,
-0.6198230385780334,
-0.041726261377334595,
0.4775703549385071,
-0.30116304755210876,
0.1246044784784317,
0.11987661570310593,
-0.21214042603969574,
-0.374976247549057,
-0.08090189099311829,
-0.5823788642883301,
0.904009222984314,
-0.16657979786396027,
-0.3705343008041382,
-0.4142758548259735,
0.14072217047214508,
0.45132729411125183,
-0.3918647766113281,
0.338278204202652,
0.6493057012557983,
0.16032972931861877,
-0.04377643018960953,
-1.622977375984192,
-0.05352149158716202,
-0.10453063249588013,
-0.3669103682041168,
0.23278483748435974,
-0.5446545481681824,
0.39730626344680786,
-0.3118322193622589,
-0.60902339220047,
0.03328496962785721,
0.4481470584869385,
-0.31704363226890564,
0.5995816588401794,
0.334613174200058,
0.18552589416503906,
0.6775583028793335,
-0.28889405727386475,
0.8287877440452576,
0.06772195547819138,
0.270631343126297,
1.319342017173767,
-0.10247820615768433,
0.5942291617393494,
0.3881193995475769,
-0.48637840151786804,
0.05394383892416954,
0.3914480209350586,
-0.005097724962979555,
0.027671197429299355,
0.12973657250404358,
0.06218282878398895,
0.14999336004257202,
0.10792092233896255,
-0.13677236437797546,
0.442298024892807,
0.46119505167007446,
0.05179237574338913,
-0.4406697452068329,
-0.1170136108994484,
0.04687580466270447,
0.09613553434610367,
-0.43368440866470337,
1.1988118886947632,
0.19360396265983582,
-0.7527600526809692,
0.3004441261291504,
-0.009248904883861542,
0.47766128182411194,
-0.37148964405059814,
0.15435054898262024,
-0.450903981924057,
0.09689196944236755,
-0.5193132758140564,
-0.3375522494316101,
0.778990626335144,
0.03778708726167679,
-0.11693379282951355,
0.07651415467262268,
0.09178679436445236,
-0.30032414197921753,
-0.12846042215824127,
-0.0021272762678563595,
0.826870858669281,
0.4377909302711487,
-0.1096004843711853,
-0.12534253299236298,
-0.12681205570697784,
-0.35824987292289734,
0.11799304187297821,
0.17058634757995605,
0.44780492782592773,
-0.18110094964504242,
0.4380451738834381,
0.23796643316745758,
0.018193943426012993,
0.019024699926376343,
0.16167515516281128,
0.4218529760837555,
-0.6487241387367249,
-0.7034313082695007,
-0.708827018737793,
0.605036735534668,
-0.135088711977005,
-0.27447509765625,
0.7733566164970398,
0.5190001130104065,
0.49974116683006287,
0.13049866259098053,
0.42779672145843506,
0.35471466183662415,
0.8762828707695007,
-0.20984625816345215,
0.7857895493507385,
-0.6072402596473694,
0.4487551748752594,
-0.2751484811306,
-0.7026585340499878,
-0.3257209360599518,
0.16317930817604065,
0.07017191499471664,
-0.03747687488794327,
0.7675765752792358,
0.5043439269065857,
0.21150994300842285,
-0.19352492690086365,
0.3811940848827362,
0.1361929476261139,
0.45470964908599854,
0.5509825944900513,
0.9260244369506836,
-0.6798094511032104,
0.504241943359375,
0.15457989275455475,
-0.545622706413269,
-0.3889184892177582,
-0.7936468720436096,
-0.7113574147224426,
-0.9387689232826233,
-1.0010546445846558,
-0.5146327018737793,
-0.05533422902226448,
0.9847976565361023,
0.46775153279304504,
-0.7991209626197815,
-0.24490784108638763,
0.27523520588874817,
-0.13647249341011047,
-0.22863727807998657,
-0.31232979893684387,
0.25703638792037964,
-0.5903872847557068,
-0.5946884751319885,
-0.11597511917352676,
0.3262767493724823,
0.5505573749542236,
-0.04407341405749321,
0.15900534391403198,
0.1582496166229248,
0.32231882214546204,
0.2034560590982437,
0.35954442620277405,
-0.46480679512023926,
-0.23114652931690216,
-0.2347317934036255,
-0.1452941596508026,
0.2011437714099884,
0.6266979575157166,
-0.5171858072280884,
0.11033347249031067,
0.08087915927171707,
0.31887906789779663,
0.09242959320545197,
-0.005040962714701891,
0.7719756960868835,
-0.9255443215370178,
-0.3341934382915497,
0.03466597944498062,
0.41403257846832275,
0.6477492451667786,
-0.3760443925857544,
0.4339110851287842,
0.3639258146286011,
-0.5514582395553589,
-1.037704348564148,
0.09156061708927155,
-0.7809861898422241,
0.07641050964593887,
0.5890867114067078,
-0.21835856139659882,
-0.1881507933139801,
-0.26352712512016296,
-0.05285702273249626,
0.17207740247249603,
0.2659280002117157,
1.1434845924377441,
1.074210524559021,
-0.26865583658218384,
-0.004323131870478392,
-0.6927635073661804,
0.9005045294761658,
0.29328393936157227,
-0.8156099319458008,
0.10684319585561752,
0.6173402667045593,
0.22833490371704102,
0.4857328236103058,
0.6341416239738464,
-0.39422714710235596,
0.7490925192832947,
-0.22471418976783752,
-0.2516147196292877,
-0.04029972106218338,
-0.23152011632919312,
-0.5184258222579956,
0.03452428802847862,
0.021150434389710426,
-0.3886250853538513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11109v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11109v1
|
Consistency Training by Synthetic Question Generation for Conversational Question Answering
| 2024-04-17T06:49:14 | 2024-04-17T06:49:14 |
Hamed Hematian Hemati, Hamid Beigy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Efficiently modeling historical information is a critical component in
addressing user queries within a conversational question-answering (QA)
context, as historical context plays a vital role in clarifying the user's
questions. However, irrelevant history induces noise in the reasoning process,
especially for those questions with a considerable historical context. In our
novel model-agnostic approach, referred to as CoTaH (Consistency-Trained
augmented History), we augment the historical information with synthetic
questions and subsequently employ consistency training to train a model that
utilizes both real and augmented historical data to implicitly make the
reasoning robust to irrelevant history. To the best of our knowledge, this is
the first instance of research using question generation as a form of data
augmentation to model conversational QA settings. By citing a common modeling
error prevalent in previous research, we introduce a new baseline model and
compare our model's performance against it, demonstrating an improvement in
results, particularly when dealing with questions that include a substantial
amount of historical context. The source code can be found on our GitHub page.
|
[
-0.4253184199333191,
-1.2868863344192505,
0.658706545829773,
-0.31443044543266296,
-0.026416318491101265,
0.0012490510707721114,
0.07383468747138977,
-0.4421493113040924,
0.06509333103895187,
0.5921655297279358,
-0.6638715863227844,
-0.33791685104370117,
-0.09531616419553757,
-0.1254040151834488,
-0.5089328289031982,
0.8314379453659058,
-0.15419848263263702,
0.1373957097530365,
-0.5144208669662476,
-0.47391656041145325,
-0.8104325532913208,
-0.858460009098053,
-0.6240057349205017,
-0.2487453669309616,
0.1243775337934494,
0.3158681392669678,
0.8881838321685791,
0.47710299491882324,
-0.036614805459976196,
0.216534823179245,
-0.14829300343990326,
0.44989606738090515,
-0.5903691649436951,
0.36396533250808716,
-0.11472271382808685,
-0.5512583255767822,
-0.21820394694805145,
-0.23571127653121948,
0.5684483647346497,
0.7908893823623657,
-0.1992195099592209,
0.16851133108139038,
-0.14939114451408386,
0.3938421607017517,
-0.7418270707130432,
-0.07440429925918579,
-0.9488797187805176,
-0.11415533721446991,
0.4552500247955322,
-0.498252272605896,
-0.429290235042572,
-0.6970073580741882,
0.22322289645671844,
-0.5818679332733154,
0.6590259075164795,
-0.10994336009025574,
1.0308363437652588,
0.06237538531422615,
-0.5189927220344543,
-0.09928334504365921,
-1.0276131629943848,
0.4825100898742676,
-0.6267176270484924,
0.37469813227653503,
0.6160876154899597,
0.44878193736076355,
-0.21066580712795258,
-0.716310441493988,
-0.8070915341377258,
-0.31518298387527466,
0.06452929973602295,
0.011996942572295666,
0.06041426956653595,
-0.06831009685993195,
0.3352915346622467,
0.37484824657440186,
-0.5709559321403503,
-0.40338563919067383,
-0.4137856662273407,
-0.2243470698595047,
0.4790223240852356,
0.31895363330841064,
0.3480410575866699,
-0.043541207909584045,
-0.399352490901947,
-0.13241221010684967,
-0.7656874060630798,
0.23870088160037994,
0.3600008189678192,
0.06877030432224274,
0.08958138525485992,
0.4735281765460968,
-0.4642980694770813,
0.8263041377067566,
0.2988135814666748,
0.16392116248607635,
-0.13071145117282867,
-0.4407026171684265,
0.02603331208229065,
0.13618193566799164,
0.3664236068725586,
0.3407219350337982,
0.10514088720083237,
-0.16716770827770233,
0.059912096709012985,
0.22154544293880463,
0.6398753523826599,
-0.665325403213501,
-0.2457287758588791,
0.2908991873264313,
-0.03571994975209236,
-0.10438162088394165,
-0.03133765980601311,
-0.34006619453430176,
-0.1271536648273468,
-0.5369758605957031,
0.47721871733665466,
-0.5432319045066833,
-0.2956232726573944,
-0.155368372797966,
-0.0700841024518013,
0.47984614968299866,
0.4785851240158081,
-1.0564653873443604,
0.3918350338935852,
0.7353745698928833,
0.5448431372642517,
0.07069521397352219,
-0.16995251178741455,
-0.4882420003414154,
0.13331927359104156,
-0.6643369197845459,
0.7432100176811218,
-0.43088385462760925,
-0.7040427923202515,
0.08414072543382645,
0.06039178743958473,
0.08965183794498444,
-0.6886901259422302,
0.3921830952167511,
-0.7030075788497925,
0.3397100567817688,
-0.3651954233646393,
-0.7241678237915039,
-0.12673716247081757,
0.6843914985656738,
-0.4572250247001648,
0.9588664174079895,
0.28130167722702026,
-0.39150404930114746,
0.36496034264564514,
-0.19728033244609833,
-0.01940230093896389,
-0.03915980085730553,
-0.43744683265686035,
-0.46464961767196655,
-0.16097933053970337,
0.13086974620819092,
-0.2025788277387619,
-0.08753953129053116,
0.6088363528251648,
-0.14887504279613495,
-0.4674970209598541,
0.2531772553920746,
-0.6330292224884033,
0.6733977794647217,
0.12131901830434799,
-0.27312394976615906,
-0.0173330195248127,
-0.6788625121116638,
0.4192979037761688,
0.04929347336292267,
-0.13088731467723846,
-0.18838848173618317,
-0.057672493159770966,
-0.22973833978176117,
0.005835873074829578,
0.33654531836509705,
-0.512538731098175,
0.17347055673599243,
-0.4359327554702759,
0.05733024328947067,
0.5722973942756653,
0.40098121762275696,
0.20787394046783447,
-0.7033754587173462,
0.435209721326828,
-0.004308115690946579,
0.14830662310123444,
-0.29417625069618225,
-0.5790829658508301,
-0.711911678314209,
0.3735247850418091,
0.21101586520671844,
0.33674511313438416,
-0.4755297899246216,
0.2866198420524597,
-0.23584017157554626,
-0.4165595471858978,
-0.17617149651050568,
0.08143941313028336,
0.27033692598342896,
0.9467342495918274,
0.40633660554885864,
-0.2735951244831085,
-0.9787840247154236,
-0.6722091436386108,
-0.11993025243282318,
-0.6196376085281372,
0.15842100977897644,
0.2709618806838989,
0.27138110995292664,
-0.08712080866098404,
1.3085963726043701,
-0.42354777455329895,
0.4495931565761566,
-0.08617173880338669,
0.2065192610025406,
-0.16560585796833038,
0.7133004665374756,
0.34874749183654785,
-1.0027999877929688,
-0.43260467052459717,
-0.08696335554122925,
-0.7588117718696594,
0.2332531362771988,
-0.09337592869997025,
-0.4008018374443054,
0.2484496682882309,
0.35637012124061584,
-0.558863639831543,
0.48203837871551514,
0.5794830322265625,
-0.1772516667842865,
0.6977416276931763,
-0.07162825018167496,
0.574019193649292,
-1.3942910432815552,
0.16980543732643127,
-0.3954533040523529,
-0.2828879654407501,
-0.8472036719322205,
-0.207559272646904,
0.039717283099889755,
-0.37238579988479614,
-0.3321857750415802,
0.5832882523536682,
-0.13456708192825317,
0.3299665153026581,
-0.3670441210269928,
0.04085666313767433,
0.31592053174972534,
0.4698686897754669,
0.1720082312822342,
0.9263349175453186,
0.22634604573249817,
-0.6898819208145142,
0.12152085453271866,
0.6222439408302307,
0.11678659915924072,
0.6779977679252625,
-0.7870794534683228,
0.37463077902793884,
0.012441569939255714,
0.3652936518192291,
-1.1320741176605225,
-0.34877219796180725,
0.12645575404167175,
-0.6479582190513611,
0.16425621509552002,
-0.2648386061191559,
-0.2033371925354004,
-0.03882915899157524,
-0.017866168171167374,
0.5951222777366638,
0.6370182633399963,
-0.6745971441268921,
0.5457193851470947,
0.12546606361865997,
-0.08919797092676163,
-0.4997955560684204,
-0.2522350549697876,
-0.11993442475795746,
0.023588752374053,
-0.7381036877632141,
0.269850492477417,
-0.21872854232788086,
-0.23503410816192627,
-0.12494229525327682,
-0.5520383715629578,
-0.5746642351150513,
-0.016743499785661697,
0.16262471675872803,
0.49535492062568665,
-0.3950172960758209,
0.22819073498249054,
-0.015444718301296234,
0.06960755586624146,
0.06333541125059128,
-0.13954174518585205,
0.7931933999061584,
-0.09419886022806168,
-0.49076709151268005,
-0.7154222726821899,
0.3142596185207367,
0.31311866641044617,
0.0480051152408123,
0.9262060523033142,
0.22193458676338196,
-0.28749287128448486,
0.09345903247594833,
-0.835478663444519,
-0.4890466630458832,
-0.41632747650146484,
0.07589173316955566,
-0.2207239866256714,
-0.8185383081436157,
0.6578697562217712,
-0.023615732789039612,
0.1527034193277359,
0.41360917687416077,
0.39518654346466064,
-0.05804400518536568,
1.3002909421920776,
0.3541277050971985,
0.15555952489376068,
0.48041006922721863,
-0.2777155935764313,
-0.053975917398929596,
-0.49484574794769287,
-0.16370587050914764,
-0.43908587098121643,
0.1497444212436676,
-0.4812844395637512,
-0.07791091501712799,
0.3934992253780365,
0.17416490614414215,
-0.5213297009468079,
0.09642675518989563,
-0.2895430624485016,
0.37115854024887085,
0.5976840257644653,
0.2500317096710205,
0.4154217541217804,
-0.24188508093357086,
0.3735763430595398,
0.268023818731308,
-0.7423302531242371,
-0.7797287106513977,
1.265424370765686,
-0.04189273342490196,
0.5604973435401917,
-0.037476979196071625,
0.737491250038147,
0.2261345535516739,
0.1260116845369339,
-0.39395076036453247,
0.2709856331348419,
0.5128951668739319,
-0.876153826713562,
-0.4184785783290863,
-0.40448713302612305,
-1.1073590517044067,
0.08054169267416,
-0.1217433363199234,
-0.6988431811332703,
0.19911247491836548,
0.6857141852378845,
-0.5279930830001831,
0.3092648386955261,
-0.7655028104782104,
0.9186305999755859,
0.011401007883250713,
-0.3753476142883301,
0.08024027198553085,
-0.8485947847366333,
0.3601449131965637,
0.24275249242782593,
-0.3259159326553345,
0.03468022868037224,
0.3791668713092804,
0.3414042294025421,
-0.6850438714027405,
0.777844250202179,
-0.15719716250896454,
-0.030103646218776703,
0.6745712161064148,
0.24388782680034637,
0.7303803563117981,
0.23396725952625275,
0.15017324686050415,
0.0037814483512192965,
0.5361036062240601,
-0.6897322535514832,
-0.9447776079177856,
0.5324900150299072,
-0.8904949426651001,
-0.8157403469085693,
-0.20028991997241974,
-0.7656444311141968,
-0.5099905729293823,
-0.16898107528686523,
0.14555853605270386,
0.6210777163505554,
-0.519645631313324,
0.24821488559246063,
0.9207169413566589,
0.15342716872692108,
-0.019189463928341866,
0.3303200900554657,
-0.00012012149818474427,
-0.19662518799304962,
0.5192886590957642,
0.014961379580199718,
0.6649838089942932,
0.2506406307220459,
0.04187487065792084,
-0.4781799018383026,
-0.4484776258468628,
-0.6462736129760742,
-0.16859713196754456,
-0.6534990668296814,
-0.02397991716861725,
-0.6557258367538452,
-0.3217831254005432,
-0.5250741243362427,
-0.1623741090297699,
-0.4500362277030945,
-0.49832791090011597,
-0.203473761677742,
0.02625848352909088,
0.2621128559112549,
0.423711895942688,
0.33524009585380554,
0.22281086444854736,
-0.7272491455078125,
0.6150137186050415,
0.5569745898246765,
0.1282123178243637,
-0.08677582442760468,
-0.5449612736701965,
-0.04809471219778061,
0.5590819716453552,
-0.6023511290550232,
-0.868878960609436,
0.10821553319692612,
0.06377475708723068,
0.6984469294548035,
0.22743074595928192,
0.234882190823555,
0.7107788324356079,
-0.3240867555141449,
1.010951280593872,
-0.008646496571600437,
-0.8102654218673706,
0.7983812689781189,
-0.3856585919857025,
0.44113069772720337,
0.8112845420837402,
0.3320083022117615,
-0.4904950261116028,
-0.412576824426651,
-1.0015313625335693,
-0.6649185419082642,
0.4343625605106354,
0.20297765731811523,
0.338826060295105,
-0.24433983862400055,
0.4717051088809967,
0.40401366353034973,
0.12797921895980835,
-0.4124540686607361,
-0.20685039460659027,
-0.4646280109882355,
-0.18561048805713654,
0.09919562935829163,
-0.2706450819969177,
-0.39673593640327454,
-0.21851858496665955,
0.7783298492431641,
-0.28612393140792847,
0.053296785801649094,
0.32756465673446655,
-0.1888803094625473,
-0.1386842131614685,
0.3595399260520935,
0.6086311936378479,
1.1114537715911865,
-0.3046001195907593,
-0.02419777773320675,
0.5011532306671143,
-0.35479792952537537,
0.4144849479198456,
0.031124085187911987,
-0.4803386926651001,
0.020529743283987045,
-0.010476158000528812,
0.7011899948120117,
0.06440690159797668,
-0.7210980653762817,
0.24203045666217804,
-0.060828808695077896,
-0.25382000207901,
-0.5903627872467041,
0.29409563541412354,
-0.156498983502388,
0.13518176972866058,
0.37915337085723877,
-0.0862564966082573,
0.01772242784500122,
-0.8725908398628235,
0.2739179730415344,
0.4423002600669861,
-0.4215877950191498,
-0.048103298991918564,
0.7386281490325928,
-0.10688429325819016,
-0.311463326215744,
0.5673723816871643,
0.15804417431354523,
-0.2782735824584961,
0.6120259761810303,
0.575861394405365,
0.5701414942741394,
-0.19473659992218018,
0.39931270480155945,
0.507561206817627,
-0.11622271686792374,
-0.13772810995578766,
0.4637778699398041,
-0.33504197001457214,
-0.6925188899040222,
-0.1947270929813385,
-0.3769092857837677,
-0.8042214512825012,
0.06655346602201462,
-0.8037903308868408,
0.0666692852973938,
-0.5424001216888428,
-0.14349590241909027,
-0.27153244614601135,
-0.04223672300577164,
-0.5420608520507812,
0.450334757566452,
-0.21221299469470978,
0.5326477885246277,
-0.5314071178436279,
0.5091007947921753,
0.5390137434005737,
-0.5426334142684937,
-0.9138786792755127,
0.26686927676200867,
-0.17061686515808105,
-0.5701690912246704,
0.2963641285896301,
-0.038269493728876114,
-0.13299468159675598,
0.020837882533669472,
-0.7686480283737183,
-0.7403361201286316,
1.1086069345474243,
0.47623977065086365,
-0.3499593436717987,
0.01881149597465992,
0.1927977353334427,
0.702578604221344,
-0.23303456604480743,
0.1416168212890625,
0.4974645674228668,
0.09327135980129242,
0.3745657205581665,
-0.7464286088943481,
0.039126381278038025,
-0.2439606934785843,
0.033541835844516754,
0.12388793379068375,
-0.4151422679424286,
0.6258094310760498,
-0.05951078608632088,
-0.343912810087204,
0.6120805740356445,
0.8557160496711731,
0.5238060355186462,
0.5404086709022522,
0.34042346477508545,
0.42245784401893616,
0.9224741458892822,
-0.282248854637146,
1.1314364671707153,
-0.42769861221313477,
0.21586231887340546,
1.3676385879516602,
-0.18601711094379425,
0.694621741771698,
0.45528697967529297,
-0.05014387145638466,
0.7298814654350281,
0.5692263245582581,
0.23847156763076782,
0.2346106469631195,
-0.10104060173034668,
-0.4710666835308075,
-0.30831828713417053,
-0.12013270705938339,
-0.7511773109436035,
0.4088910222053528,
-0.1468828171491623,
-0.25816306471824646,
-0.07471887022256851,
-0.2702813148498535,
-0.06011039763689041,
0.3524309992790222,
-0.13759514689445496,
1.0063618421554565,
-0.3968829810619354,
-0.9203789234161377,
1.1307764053344727,
-0.45445671677589417,
0.09399040043354034,
-0.7739457488059998,
-0.2552991807460785,
-0.43482911586761475,
-0.1598018854856491,
0.1204029992222786,
-0.4781695306301117,
0.31214526295661926,
-0.24394723773002625,
-0.3415786325931549,
0.23974105715751648,
0.36603859066963196,
-0.5463662147521973,
-0.2705792188644409,
-0.41121914982795715,
0.6735963225364685,
-0.03004111349582672,
-0.0338250994682312,
-0.3985694348812103,
-0.15385675430297852,
-0.147744819521904,
-0.013973972760140896,
0.12096249312162399,
0.25456175208091736,
-0.17264845967292786,
0.549187183380127,
0.6381353735923767,
-0.1568390280008316,
0.07692968100309372,
0.08900786936283112,
0.721888542175293,
-0.7126646041870117,
-0.5117430090904236,
-0.5730797648429871,
0.4630450904369354,
-0.20477765798568726,
-0.33391711115837097,
0.6568787097930908,
0.7660356760025024,
0.8407444953918457,
0.12767978012561798,
0.7528498768806458,
0.12224407494068146,
0.5319240689277649,
-0.5504275560379028,
0.4473161995410919,
-0.404399037361145,
0.13761934638023376,
-0.05203137919306755,
-0.8824874758720398,
0.17591118812561035,
0.24101729691028595,
-0.16835488379001617,
0.19006040692329407,
0.5066941380500793,
0.9154821634292603,
0.09388425946235657,
0.5505324602127075,
0.41789862513542175,
0.017161471769213676,
0.3221895694732666,
0.2479574978351593,
1.1340166330337524,
-0.5331899523735046,
0.5470570921897888,
-0.3057781457901001,
0.14656999707221985,
-0.10433381050825119,
-0.40977421402931213,
-0.5554877519607544,
-0.7906425595283508,
-0.19877970218658447,
-0.710834264755249,
0.49827975034713745,
0.9952940940856934,
0.720396101474762,
-1.0491912364959717,
-0.07442539185285568,
-0.39709416031837463,
-0.036672260612249374,
-0.19958984851837158,
-0.2408628612756729,
0.34238481521606445,
-0.52425217628479,
-0.6975864171981812,
0.3442012667655945,
-0.14815238118171692,
0.36085811257362366,
-0.30263403058052063,
-0.15008382499217987,
-0.3708372116088867,
0.2749391198158264,
0.35852673649787903,
0.7694910168647766,
-0.606253445148468,
-0.5843897461891174,
-0.032581575214862823,
0.03260398656129837,
0.5207366943359375,
0.781716525554657,
-0.8760706186294556,
0.7470008730888367,
0.3708658218383789,
0.7377310991287231,
0.6410416960716248,
0.5988105535507202,
0.8630669713020325,
-0.8831536173820496,
0.039313603192567825,
0.39931467175483704,
0.09045308083295822,
0.42772752046585083,
-0.4704701006412506,
0.4070616066455841,
0.14888736605644226,
-0.6439756155014038,
-0.8181064128875732,
0.2508965730667114,
-1.0286316871643066,
-0.2182028442621231,
0.9741834402084351,
-0.028129836544394493,
-0.07517446577548981,
-0.4157341420650482,
-0.5512398481369019,
0.402597039937973,
-0.1343115121126175,
1.2112263441085815,
0.4811473488807678,
-0.29290443658828735,
-0.0958847850561142,
-0.5937874913215637,
0.5124858021736145,
0.6211344003677368,
-0.8467513918876648,
-0.037133585661649704,
0.7640817761421204,
0.2944415807723999,
0.08461140841245651,
0.7497316598892212,
-0.01596624217927456,
0.7744368314743042,
0.2818683385848999,
-0.07321195304393768,
0.061946090310811996,
-0.17580671608448029,
0.0377027653157711,
0.3807861804962158,
0.1690026968717575,
-0.13914430141448975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11095v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11095v1
|
Inductive-Deductive Strategy Reuse for Multi-Turn Instructional Dialogues
| 2024-04-17T06:26:32 | 2024-04-17T06:26:32 |
Jiao Ou, Jiayu Wu, Che Liu, Fuzheng Zhang, Di Zhang, Kun Gai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Aligning large language models (LLMs) with human expectations requires
high-quality instructional dialogues, which can be achieved by raising diverse,
in-depth, and insightful instructions that deepen interactions. Existing
methods target instructions from real instruction dialogues as a learning goal
and fine-tune a user simulator for posing instructions. However, the user
simulator struggles to implicitly model complex dialogue flows and pose
high-quality instructions. In this paper, we take inspiration from the
cognitive abilities inherent in human learning and propose the explicit
modeling of complex dialogue flows through instructional strategy reuse.
Specifically, we first induce high-level strategies from various real
instruction dialogues. These strategies are applied to new dialogue scenarios
deductively, where the instructional strategies facilitate high-quality
instructions. Experimental results show that our method can generate diverse,
in-depth, and insightful instructions for a given dialogue history. The
constructed multi-turn instructional dialogues can outperform competitive
baselines on the downstream chat model.
|
[
-0.23676247894763947,
-0.9903867244720459,
0.5845380425453186,
0.16025464236736298,
-0.2953503727912903,
0.36119604110717773,
-0.4226246476173401,
0.05163288116455078,
0.051057279109954834,
0.6794239282608032,
-0.7369858622550964,
-0.5050382614135742,
-0.2854486107826233,
-0.17110614478588104,
-0.38930460810661316,
0.7393004894256592,
0.06332173943519592,
0.14327123761177063,
-0.2367413341999054,
0.17443294823169708,
-0.5056628584861755,
-0.585281252861023,
-0.40728557109832764,
-0.3262069523334503,
0.46751296520233154,
0.9442803859710693,
0.5492532253265381,
0.37004178762435913,
0.18827293813228607,
0.2893197536468506,
0.18740274012088776,
0.388614684343338,
-0.5962920784950256,
0.3363818824291229,
-0.15307343006134033,
-0.39919939637184143,
-0.2583228051662445,
0.23760268092155457,
0.6702151894569397,
0.5355989933013916,
-0.6778865456581116,
-0.029098404571413994,
0.25038790702819824,
0.16675488650798798,
-0.4388733506202698,
0.07486560940742493,
-0.6271098256111145,
-0.08386930078268051,
0.23665334284305573,
-0.3532802164554596,
-0.6811733841896057,
-0.49905925989151,
0.3899608850479126,
-0.7041356563568115,
0.04489012062549591,
-0.32892757654190063,
0.5184057950973511,
0.12295828014612198,
-0.2025979459285736,
-0.38831791281700134,
-1.1833709478378296,
0.9589383602142334,
-1.0270463228225708,
0.07732279598712921,
0.002912659663707018,
0.4457840323448181,
-0.28642112016677856,
-0.587117075920105,
-0.5010842084884644,
-0.2549770772457123,
0.1255747228860855,
0.180825337767601,
0.008726590313017368,
0.09017329663038254,
0.2410832643508911,
-0.0008718694443814456,
-0.05814283713698387,
0.4439624845981598,
-0.27580031752586365,
0.13767436146736145,
0.7619622945785522,
0.609481930732727,
0.2617533504962921,
0.11451781541109085,
-0.6096375584602356,
-0.18822051584720612,
-0.7522739768028259,
0.21604661643505096,
0.2511354386806488,
0.408184289932251,
-0.10661239176988602,
0.5238863825798035,
-0.2517075538635254,
0.4896352291107178,
0.24273106455802917,
-0.5734359622001648,
0.10813076794147491,
-0.1894989311695099,
-0.06185252219438553,
0.2865321934223175,
0.6135774254798889,
0.3381531238555908,
0.2819577157497406,
-0.13567234575748444,
-0.021803518757224083,
-0.16437625885009766,
0.5635559558868408,
-0.902312159538269,
-0.04057900980114937,
0.1592051237821579,
-0.2681877911090851,
-0.3043355345726013,
-0.26755210757255554,
-0.9940885305404663,
-0.1787695586681366,
-0.734130859375,
0.31021973490715027,
-0.5652602314949036,
-0.27524372935295105,
0.17304342985153198,
0.051895949989557266,
0.5125709176063538,
0.5236079096794128,
-0.8663350939750671,
0.27463191747665405,
0.7081210017204285,
0.4514957070350647,
-0.11065100878477097,
-0.3460613489151001,
-0.6109825968742371,
0.4132991433143616,
-0.20950055122375488,
0.623877227306366,
-0.8230456709861755,
-0.5423228144645691,
0.3381849229335785,
-0.2967919707298279,
-0.06809283047914505,
-0.5205912590026855,
0.661090612411499,
-0.07765267044305801,
0.3806811273097992,
-0.1250103861093521,
-0.7292096614837646,
-0.22813332080841064,
0.3433780372142792,
-0.41475412249565125,
0.4937502443790436,
-0.07794839888811111,
-0.3213578760623932,
0.004239235073328018,
-0.7274057865142822,
-0.6446507573127747,
0.07888586819171906,
-0.21345235407352448,
-0.21360161900520325,
0.06309417635202408,
0.1634228527545929,
0.41267967224121094,
-0.5517066121101379,
0.3090537190437317,
-0.09533800184726715,
-0.4925070106983185,
0.5069863796234131,
-0.8152130246162415,
0.7490736842155457,
0.05821707099676132,
-0.41213202476501465,
-0.0025369320064783096,
-0.5235997438430786,
0.2542765736579895,
0.09558475017547607,
-0.528989851474762,
-0.23418007791042328,
0.10748042911291122,
-0.5776885151863098,
0.1214984804391861,
-0.11478552967309952,
-0.3878747820854187,
0.39022526144981384,
-0.3840312659740448,
0.5505818724632263,
0.5070582628250122,
0.2662027180194855,
0.46020084619522095,
-0.24246813356876373,
0.5939217209815979,
0.08213652670383453,
0.34121978282928467,
-0.3576287031173706,
-0.2394719421863556,
-0.8147271871566772,
-0.5704611539840698,
-0.14059853553771973,
0.7878168225288391,
-0.5779386162757874,
0.07785259187221527,
-0.17652682960033417,
-0.5205996632575989,
-0.6481223106384277,
0.215758815407753,
0.43800851702690125,
0.2623751759529114,
0.5251240134239197,
-0.06760048121213913,
-0.18092438578605652,
-0.7940481901168823,
-0.16950662434101105,
-0.0958794355392456,
0.13783906400203705,
0.3296864330768585,
0.18960677087306976,
-0.23296277225017548,
0.697016716003418,
-0.43589526414871216,
0.12111589312553406,
-0.5600826144218445,
0.3910176157951355,
-0.1797972470521927,
0.5442580580711365,
0.08086860179901123,
-0.4898083508014679,
-0.32880935072898865,
-0.527650773525238,
-0.9055502414703369,
0.1471964567899704,
-0.5261949300765991,
-0.4977262318134308,
0.02959340251982212,
0.4589676856994629,
-0.6898807287216187,
0.40161147713661194,
0.07055159658193588,
0.1886407732963562,
0.49660786986351013,
-0.13480651378631592,
0.24061015248298645,
-1.062856674194336,
-0.6048728823661804,
-0.01029016263782978,
0.231930673122406,
-0.646084189414978,
-0.061033397912979126,
-0.26056790351867676,
-0.1781587451696396,
-0.5534897446632385,
0.3523280918598175,
-0.40142321586608887,
0.21540430188179016,
0.013399279676377773,
0.38008397817611694,
0.23334474861621857,
0.785580039024353,
0.05150913819670677,
0.5199888944625854,
0.211149662733078,
-0.6384515762329102,
0.6283599138259888,
0.2924465537071228,
-0.5875096321105957,
0.6619377732276917,
-0.736851155757904,
0.10060495138168335,
0.02337854541838169,
0.27847978472709656,
-1.1256576776504517,
0.0011222019093111157,
0.24798274040222168,
-0.12172897905111313,
0.5009937882423401,
-0.20082800090312958,
-0.38982921838760376,
-0.10322556644678116,
-0.2723759710788727,
0.19849532842636108,
0.604663074016571,
-0.6575664281845093,
0.8192676901817322,
0.21145249903202057,
-0.2923111617565155,
-0.5838763117790222,
-0.37251216173171997,
0.11041354387998581,
-0.4953555762767792,
-0.4902222156524658,
0.4861254394054413,
0.04338100552558899,
-0.20617017149925232,
-0.14882171154022217,
0.14305046200752258,
0.10529769212007523,
0.2850552201271057,
0.26057925820350647,
0.327250599861145,
-0.15128421783447266,
0.05468235909938812,
0.2847485840320587,
0.07256686687469482,
0.2180391103029251,
-0.27081823348999023,
0.5132686495780945,
0.2282726764678955,
-0.5902131199836731,
-0.7516382336616516,
0.7441139221191406,
0.7560272812843323,
-0.3486010730266571,
0.5796282887458801,
0.4592011570930481,
-0.15468136966228485,
-0.2382204532623291,
-0.7597503066062927,
-0.5643668174743652,
-0.40394142270088196,
0.39496904611587524,
-0.25359630584716797,
-0.603234589099884,
0.29312044382095337,
-0.43897196650505066,
0.5711122155189514,
-0.21049591898918152,
0.5447644591331482,
-0.4210776090621948,
1.116607666015625,
0.3317275047302246,
0.33251848816871643,
0.4541126787662506,
-0.5341829061508179,
0.46593889594078064,
-0.912022590637207,
-0.5698940753936768,
-0.3645516037940979,
-0.4905239939689636,
-0.1812717467546463,
-0.4435376822948456,
-0.022545889019966125,
0.26061350107192993,
-0.5723173022270203,
0.1416429728269577,
-0.31342318654060364,
0.2832789421081543,
0.9220063090324402,
0.03897637873888016,
0.4072748124599457,
0.25593820214271545,
-0.24692925810813904,
-0.1799824982881546,
-0.8120806813240051,
-0.7074597477912903,
0.8099033236503601,
0.33412498235702515,
1.3249090909957886,
0.20220784842967987,
1.0586771965026855,
-0.0012273237807676196,
0.3614210784435272,
-0.78667151927948,
0.6949557065963745,
-0.004963832441717386,
-0.40293532609939575,
-0.4828387498855591,
-0.4371313154697418,
-0.7755644917488098,
0.2176901251077652,
-0.34933552145957947,
-0.6009706258773804,
-0.10413806885480881,
0.15935839712619781,
-0.459109902381897,
0.21383030712604523,
-0.7680268883705139,
0.9837188124656677,
-0.5802907943725586,
-0.42727503180503845,
-0.45935723185539246,
-0.34794753789901733,
0.30937573313713074,
0.43567460775375366,
-0.014020388945937157,
-0.0183480903506279,
0.18349918723106384,
0.5922713279724121,
-0.3191137909889221,
1.175934076309204,
-0.25763168931007385,
-0.3139018714427948,
0.8183432817459106,
0.21242591738700867,
0.4499686360359192,
0.014166703447699547,
0.36054179072380066,
-0.20473888516426086,
-0.1904703825712204,
-0.19849932193756104,
-0.9000167846679688,
0.6970025300979614,
-0.9350700378417969,
-1.1359951496124268,
-0.005475581623613834,
-0.3321716785430908,
-0.07665728032588959,
-0.19084765017032623,
0.15023258328437805,
0.801079273223877,
-0.4858095049858093,
0.03329388052225113,
0.7203383445739746,
-0.3335856795310974,
0.18207408487796783,
0.580227792263031,
0.1849968433380127,
-0.2659919261932373,
1.077095866203308,
0.012261354364454746,
0.6552873253822327,
0.4004369080066681,
0.18910352885723114,
-0.2979826331138611,
-0.2609633207321167,
-0.5120782256126404,
0.26625484228134155,
-0.7164279222488403,
-0.2478504776954651,
-0.5462961792945862,
-0.24764598906040192,
-0.08366113156080246,
-0.14894530177116394,
-0.3084295988082886,
-0.38887399435043335,
-0.27832329273223877,
-0.10034237056970596,
0.20861348509788513,
0.33479738235473633,
0.12435571104288101,
0.35706135630607605,
-0.8520296812057495,
0.11168140918016434,
0.7289325594902039,
-0.02575199492275715,
0.3612346351146698,
-0.7178303003311157,
-0.28664249181747437,
0.49637138843536377,
-0.6620335578918457,
-0.7648176550865173,
0.20481927692890167,
0.08786813169717789,
1.0541598796844482,
0.33535873889923096,
0.21903888881206512,
0.550748884677887,
-0.49214670062065125,
0.6190799474716187,
0.18745240569114685,
-0.7678708434104919,
0.47281789779663086,
0.041128501296043396,
0.2196003943681717,
0.4590331017971039,
0.46714290976524353,
-0.4088206887245178,
-0.4648331105709076,
-0.4683948755264282,
-0.8143852949142456,
0.5545157790184021,
-0.16484753787517548,
0.5111315846443176,
-0.12294158339500427,
0.43357083201408386,
-0.009925036691129208,
0.06208486109972,
-0.2615397870540619,
0.013913236558437347,
-0.4233435094356537,
-0.31947702169418335,
0.2845178246498108,
-0.3518090546131134,
-0.42421722412109375,
-0.14588294923305511,
0.5359158515930176,
-0.040592364966869354,
0.2517731189727783,
-0.03238598629832268,
-0.13417094945907593,
0.2025938779115677,
0.5412272214889526,
0.5529730319976807,
0.48365315794944763,
-0.10699311643838882,
-0.08388789743185043,
0.11566295474767685,
-0.23578575253486633,
0.37337517738342285,
-0.1995926946401596,
-0.02970266155898571,
-0.18899746239185333,
0.39944401383399963,
0.6485793590545654,
0.6156994104385376,
-0.82923424243927,
0.25173312425613403,
-0.08047263324260712,
-0.13059590756893158,
-0.44836458563804626,
0.3838825225830078,
0.316585898399353,
0.44545620679855347,
0.18622176349163055,
-0.33125248551368713,
-0.03902040794491768,
-0.8350384831428528,
-0.0014108000323176384,
0.5579942464828491,
-0.3247467875480652,
-0.02180679328739643,
0.34530481696128845,
0.771657407283783,
-0.5145536661148071,
1.1182490587234497,
-0.168580561876297,
-0.6185391545295715,
0.21398237347602844,
0.6526905298233032,
0.8938643932342529,
-0.17347103357315063,
0.5456023812294006,
0.5388347506523132,
0.01956629380583763,
-0.15077359974384308,
-0.041361771523952484,
0.013382219709455967,
-0.7476407885551453,
-0.7250400185585022,
-0.112630195915699,
-0.6303635239601135,
0.042457688599824905,
-0.6916225552558899,
0.20573824644088745,
-0.45682138204574585,
0.059782445430755615,
0.06082270294427872,
-0.16228632628917694,
-0.47478270530700684,
-0.14729005098342896,
0.24739615619182587,
0.729982852935791,
-0.5320627093315125,
0.6426405906677246,
0.2908796966075897,
-0.578550398349762,
-0.759699285030365,
-0.05622013285756111,
0.013741862960159779,
-0.6592172384262085,
0.7735751867294312,
0.07823636382818222,
-0.5241764187812805,
-0.16189800202846527,
-0.8025320768356323,
-0.38316333293914795,
1.1168274879455566,
0.14893442392349243,
-0.5290709733963013,
-0.2840568423271179,
0.0011834547622129321,
0.2924390733242035,
-0.8807331323623657,
0.19616462290287018,
0.49411243200302124,
-0.022683486342430115,
0.34030383825302124,
-0.33457061648368835,
-0.002980957506224513,
0.02408766746520996,
-0.03062736988067627,
-0.0412420853972435,
-0.4566556513309479,
0.7655063271522522,
-0.6920168995857239,
-0.41164782643318176,
0.09402575343847275,
0.5686957240104675,
0.27271199226379395,
0.11149241775274277,
0.5063693523406982,
0.5015185475349426,
0.5027029514312744,
0.10117145627737045,
0.7826694250106812,
-0.09878528118133545,
0.06775709986686707,
1.4270521402359009,
-0.4467903971672058,
0.8452237844467163,
0.25525104999542236,
0.1854315549135208,
0.9063310623168945,
0.10775566101074219,
0.13650164008140564,
0.5249366164207458,
0.3968597650527954,
-0.3671979606151581,
-0.6377356648445129,
-0.05756688117980957,
-0.16490770876407623,
0.6189956068992615,
0.6498991250991821,
-0.09365921467542648,
-0.1796468198299408,
-0.0167021956294775,
0.20128802955150604,
0.3598795235157013,
0.00855330191552639,
1.0760637521743774,
-0.12022808194160461,
-0.937613308429718,
0.8206157088279724,
-0.11232219636440277,
0.5445862412452698,
-0.37525734305381775,
-0.5099336504936218,
-0.2934992015361786,
0.31820204854011536,
0.0424482598900795,
-0.8009270429611206,
-0.22972343862056732,
0.10274045914411545,
-0.09768655151128769,
-0.08304049074649811,
0.20175205171108246,
-0.7558351755142212,
-0.46015697717666626,
0.18321071565151215,
0.5256737470626831,
0.07879717648029327,
0.21756573021411896,
-0.5888171792030334,
-0.06933281570672989,
0.17017604410648346,
0.002158080693334341,
0.2979561388492584,
0.6437059640884399,
-0.04530981183052063,
0.95258629322052,
0.46504563093185425,
-0.353759229183197,
-0.030590618029236794,
0.43616387248039246,
0.8264416456222534,
-0.6827442049980164,
-0.02860124409198761,
-0.8131541609764099,
0.6394744515419006,
-0.2990424633026123,
-0.29241999983787537,
0.5399733781814575,
0.3705839514732361,
0.875810444355011,
0.006365285255014896,
0.7295262813568115,
0.4619559645652771,
0.6077570915222168,
-0.5053151845932007,
0.0956728532910347,
-0.32883432507514954,
0.45709940791130066,
-0.29563307762145996,
-0.8849554061889648,
0.13492326438426971,
0.8464706540107727,
-0.018131697550415993,
-0.0812465026974678,
0.38959047198295593,
0.7098603248596191,
-0.07419645041227341,
0.2275208830833435,
0.09471888840198517,
0.10599938780069351,
0.6440929770469666,
0.7770088911056519,
1.321435570716858,
-0.009840443730354309,
0.8317070603370667,
-0.23040206730365753,
-0.43026453256607056,
-0.569761335849762,
-0.754037082195282,
-1.114937663078308,
-0.48336485028266907,
-0.5692421197891235,
-0.3770671486854553,
-0.16440936923027039,
1.1595178842544556,
0.549376368522644,
-0.3951488733291626,
-0.4182637333869934,
0.2755131721496582,
0.2985731363296509,
-0.5297302603721619,
-0.22047139704227448,
-0.028473053127527237,
-0.5956766605377197,
-0.6798900365829468,
0.35816994309425354,
0.22485291957855225,
0.21383772790431976,
-0.5240809321403503,
-0.22514164447784424,
-0.36759424209594727,
0.39437323808670044,
0.777925968170166,
0.3066713213920593,
-0.9301230907440186,
-0.2054925113916397,
0.16517944633960724,
-0.2777116894721985,
-0.1836242377758026,
1.1379598379135132,
-0.6955588459968567,
0.40047773718833923,
0.2744620740413666,
0.6616210341453552,
0.5404289960861206,
0.1610584855079651,
0.8258293867111206,
-0.44247502088546753,
-0.04368766397237778,
0.3733900785446167,
0.06113386154174805,
0.44128280878067017,
-0.1303717941045761,
0.2809390723705292,
-0.236475870013237,
-0.33241891860961914,
-0.7286047339439392,
0.34950166940689087,
-0.9251657128334045,
-0.34009817242622375,
1.0929784774780273,
-0.42500168085098267,
0.21533887088298798,
0.03968217596411705,
-0.40476348996162415,
0.2396785020828247,
-0.5125377178192139,
0.9496464133262634,
0.6371615529060364,
-0.13431847095489502,
-0.2515285611152649,
-0.4097783863544464,
0.3280033469200134,
0.27408307790756226,
-0.8189670443534851,
0.42842936515808105,
0.4177955687046051,
0.10614470392465591,
0.3012274205684662,
0.2623097002506256,
-0.14722569286823273,
0.0715009793639183,
-0.06574808806180954,
-0.07389143109321594,
-0.1510467529296875,
-0.6914145350456238,
0.13574276864528656,
-0.16639716923236847,
0.07512776553630829,
-0.23936092853546143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11086v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11086v2
|
ViLLM-Eval: A Comprehensive Evaluation Suite for Vietnamese Large Language Models
| 2024-04-17T05:57:17 | 2024-04-18T07:41:23 |
Trong-Hieu Nguyen, Anh-Cuong Le, Viet-Cuong Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid advancement of large language models (LLMs) necessitates the
development of new benchmarks to accurately assess their capabilities. To
address this need for Vietnamese, this work aims to introduce ViLLM-Eval, the
comprehensive evaluation suite designed to measure the advanced knowledge and
reasoning abilities of foundation models within a Vietnamese context.
ViLLM-Eval consists of multiple-choice questions and predict next word tasks
spanning various difficulty levels and diverse disciplines, ranging from
humanities to science and engineering. A thorough evaluation of the most
advanced LLMs on ViLLM-Eval revealed that even the best performing models have
significant room for improvement in understanding and responding to Vietnamese
language tasks. ViLLM-Eval is believed to be instrumental in identifying key
strengths and weaknesses of foundation models, ultimately promoting their
development and enhancing their performance for Vietnamese users. This paper
provides a thorough overview of ViLLM-Eval as part of the Vietnamese Large
Language Model shared task, held within the 10th International Workshop on
Vietnamese Language and Speech Processing (VLSP 2023).
|
[
-0.3025103509426117,
-1.1702467203140259,
0.6754355430603027,
0.3265601694583893,
-0.0190940760076046,
0.4178829491138458,
-0.3761844038963318,
-0.2187362164258957,
-0.23895765841007233,
0.8459262251853943,
-0.25239142775535583,
-0.7549709677696228,
-0.5181455016136169,
0.07996585965156555,
-0.6498034000396729,
0.6513810753822327,
-0.2588355839252472,
0.0794702097773552,
-0.5326343774795532,
-0.16587629914283752,
-0.5745729804039001,
-0.4705316424369812,
-0.30963727831840515,
-0.39034560322761536,
0.12094426155090332,
0.24330350756645203,
0.340284526348114,
0.2822553515434265,
0.6266425848007202,
0.3279292583465576,
-0.12390195578336716,
0.11959515511989594,
-0.6688709855079651,
0.2655513286590576,
-0.23877428472042084,
-0.4099569022655487,
-0.7274523377418518,
-0.23158419132232666,
0.8163745403289795,
0.4445129334926605,
-0.02753644622862339,
0.30661728978157043,
0.05676111578941345,
0.646724283695221,
-0.7284479141235352,
0.10528671741485596,
-0.665810763835907,
-0.27032458782196045,
0.2060493379831314,
-0.10661371797323227,
-0.4309459328651428,
-0.2958593964576721,
0.3464662730693817,
-0.09596144407987595,
-0.25151318311691284,
-0.44360125064849854,
0.6687678098678589,
0.23043353855609894,
-0.465316504240036,
0.17612551152706146,
-0.6180052757263184,
0.9195743799209595,
-0.3065791726112366,
0.4783633351325989,
0.14158612489700317,
0.4128110706806183,
0.1372041553258896,
-0.6773739457130432,
-0.2854686975479126,
-0.4524877667427063,
0.22687757015228271,
0.1902112066745758,
-0.3024199306964874,
0.3110147714614868,
0.03579317033290863,
0.2906220257282257,
-0.8022550940513611,
-0.046817149966955185,
-0.5008007884025574,
-0.07648774981498718,
0.8452944755554199,
0.31263187527656555,
0.15097816288471222,
0.022705256938934326,
-0.7109507918357849,
0.104177325963974,
-0.6401277184486389,
-0.12374208867549896,
-0.1299600452184677,
0.07593029737472534,
-0.13476413488388062,
0.6827085614204407,
-0.368608683347702,
0.9740434288978577,
-0.6338168382644653,
-0.12530796229839325,
0.2672432065010071,
-0.45215901732444763,
-0.49780693650245667,
-0.13978512585163116,
0.5296213030815125,
0.25343775749206543,
0.4395759403705597,
0.28699567914009094,
-0.6500930190086365,
0.17547398805618286,
0.1677810251712799,
-0.45323798060417175,
0.1651623398065567,
0.39898428320884705,
-0.33130574226379395,
-0.26153984665870667,
0.17610113322734833,
-0.5946834683418274,
-0.18749429285526276,
-0.6095204949378967,
0.7823488712310791,
-0.2650938034057617,
-0.511087954044342,
0.36649489402770996,
-0.12582673132419586,
0.3707638382911682,
0.5172645449638367,
-0.06242102012038231,
0.3477800488471985,
0.9634518027305603,
0.8694489598274231,
-0.6746048331260681,
-0.5272908210754395,
-0.9023740887641907,
-0.2308107316493988,
-0.10765349119901657,
0.7096204161643982,
-0.7804740071296692,
-0.700359582901001,
0.20089749991893768,
-0.10643841326236725,
-0.2851419448852539,
-0.6767362952232361,
0.47105538845062256,
-0.3264017403125763,
-0.14829370379447937,
0.08129028230905533,
-0.7117347717285156,
-0.1835232675075531,
0.36013394594192505,
-0.6108717918395996,
1.0029114484786987,
0.5734162926673889,
-0.4018614590167999,
-0.11711243540048599,
-0.5811886787414551,
-0.14062467217445374,
0.39262545108795166,
-0.0915428102016449,
-0.16640490293502808,
0.25540855526924133,
-0.021152229979634285,
0.539445161819458,
-0.4248262047767639,
0.4491526484489441,
-0.21945717930793762,
-0.4363194406032562,
0.27482548356056213,
-0.5037757158279419,
0.719645619392395,
0.19287429749965668,
-0.30337145924568176,
0.5959950685501099,
-0.8256866335868835,
0.3585178256034851,
-0.13485532999038696,
-0.48510482907295227,
-0.1942605972290039,
-0.46636274456977844,
0.37097012996673584,
0.1358194649219513,
0.560004472732544,
0.008650128729641438,
0.13749252259731293,
-0.12193261831998825,
0.2015831619501114,
0.751061201095581,
-0.1837274730205536,
0.08374461531639099,
-0.05130232125520706,
0.9311743378639221,
-0.44287335872650146,
0.08695400506258011,
-0.4201110005378723,
-0.4010314643383026,
-0.9225396513938904,
-0.3220508098602295,
0.20467522740364075,
0.7363645434379578,
-0.5379908680915833,
0.44520673155784607,
-0.2180977165699005,
-0.7626118659973145,
-0.6914013624191284,
0.26244914531707764,
0.6729145646095276,
0.19827690720558167,
0.3322656452655792,
0.0008804813260212541,
-0.6357499957084656,
-0.861729621887207,
-0.21908557415008545,
-0.44585660099983215,
0.17593006789684296,
0.18310165405273438,
0.6977760195732117,
-0.5459591150283813,
0.7980624437332153,
-0.4674423933029175,
-0.048682283610105515,
-0.5921750664710999,
0.01154314074665308,
0.028242526575922966,
0.10753786563873291,
0.3694835901260376,
-0.8990287184715271,
-0.41959524154663086,
0.2942264974117279,
-0.6663105487823486,
-0.4332658350467682,
0.3310188353061676,
-0.0821867361664772,
0.22038298845291138,
0.39831069111824036,
-0.5230557322502136,
0.2874513864517212,
0.607321560382843,
-0.5149186849594116,
0.9994707107543945,
-0.13282372057437897,
0.03218571096658707,
-0.5963324904441833,
0.06780685484409332,
-0.01940971612930298,
-0.2838797867298126,
-0.5197681188583374,
0.4237261712551117,
0.03440501168370247,
0.014943897724151611,
-0.6230519413948059,
0.9810197949409485,
-0.23247018456459045,
-0.0893995612859726,
-0.2665387690067291,
0.09056199342012405,
0.1877490133047104,
-0.11230534315109253,
0.33661630749702454,
0.7457732558250427,
0.6630341410636902,
-0.47570833563804626,
0.5711382627487183,
-0.15946030616760254,
-0.23581412434577942,
0.701852560043335,
-0.649285078048706,
0.03179609030485153,
0.23863434791564941,
-0.16475775837898254,
-0.7876449227333069,
-0.09132542461156845,
-0.5537715554237366,
-0.25195249915122986,
0.12848855555057526,
0.1292245090007782,
0.10136640071868896,
-0.44074854254722595,
-0.3262547552585602,
0.24126964807510376,
0.4416104853153229,
-0.3646114766597748,
0.6717078685760498,
0.4690120220184326,
-0.10476923733949661,
-0.6089045405387878,
-0.27112939953804016,
0.13698148727416992,
-0.5122783184051514,
-0.7638101577758789,
0.003883425146341324,
-0.2206251621246338,
-0.83135586977005,
-0.15000185370445251,
0.12890321016311646,
-0.2522852420806885,
0.25574660301208496,
0.03502430394291878,
0.28315094113349915,
-0.7534120678901672,
0.17318905889987946,
-0.29929378628730774,
-0.1459813117980957,
0.1634659767150879,
-0.3481065332889557,
0.6294490694999695,
-0.8506379723548889,
-0.31565678119659424,
-0.04982766881585121,
0.22962839901447296,
0.6613234281539917,
-0.5407124757766724,
0.29037871956825256,
0.7016128897666931,
-0.4305768609046936,
-0.19381748139858246,
-0.8644635677337646,
0.2313290238380432,
-0.4024908244609833,
0.8647089004516602,
-0.43320655822753906,
-1.0671361684799194,
0.16736356914043427,
-0.0570426881313324,
-0.09025003015995026,
0.475827157497406,
0.8788031935691833,
0.353468656539917,
0.7978911995887756,
0.7266128659248352,
-0.17395570874214172,
0.1401853859424591,
-0.3465728461742401,
-0.1845685988664627,
-0.7296397686004639,
-0.2186906337738037,
-0.46032607555389404,
0.2908823788166046,
-0.1756010800600052,
-0.9157608151435852,
0.16471436619758606,
0.12083640694618225,
-0.19552528858184814,
0.32777297496795654,
-0.3405473828315735,
0.41548317670822144,
0.21802620589733124,
-0.315145343542099,
0.4048612415790558,
-0.11324844509363174,
-0.02817339263856411,
0.19314150512218475,
-0.2879810929298401,
-0.8404508233070374,
1.128447413444519,
0.3156552016735077,
0.6965533494949341,
-0.2723657488822937,
0.6601693630218506,
0.2972751259803772,
0.1709669530391693,
-0.7574261426925659,
0.6694136261940002,
-0.042810630053281784,
-0.11945082247257233,
-0.3650476932525635,
-0.2376605123281479,
-0.7825127243995667,
0.4406093955039978,
0.06510521471500397,
-0.8395851254463196,
-0.3538830876350403,
-0.13385850191116333,
-0.23686498403549194,
-0.019768258556723595,
-0.7399420142173767,
0.9443039894104004,
-0.6656420826911926,
-0.25707703828811646,
-0.40293875336647034,
-0.3053781986236572,
0.6367434859275818,
-0.25266867876052856,
0.11614713817834854,
-0.1049480140209198,
-0.15002310276031494,
0.5034467577934265,
-0.11596713215112686,
0.24137748777866364,
0.008511791005730629,
-0.17211365699768066,
0.6033732891082764,
-0.02875061146914959,
0.13880270719528198,
0.3158388137817383,
-0.299625426530838,
0.14540910720825195,
-0.04805225506424904,
-0.08704941719770432,
-0.45075732469558716,
0.8790917992591858,
-0.7399218082427979,
-0.762576162815094,
-0.14505250751972198,
-0.22447550296783447,
-0.14372041821479797,
0.11440486460924149,
-0.0560377836227417,
0.2063324749469757,
-0.623052179813385,
0.3390551805496216,
0.7725083231925964,
-0.48786503076553345,
0.07354142516851425,
0.6147566437721252,
-0.7510414123535156,
-0.3925431966781616,
1.0691523551940918,
0.008656328544020653,
0.4486760199069977,
0.6612871885299683,
0.2601194977760315,
-0.330596387386322,
-0.4485643804073334,
-0.18203701078891754,
0.03750694543123245,
-0.7606247067451477,
-0.09245658665895462,
-0.9368535876274109,
-0.6277662515640259,
-0.17525959014892578,
-0.22420893609523773,
-0.4214393198490143,
-0.2466903179883957,
-0.04876941815018654,
-0.37853479385375977,
0.19060875475406647,
0.8854090571403503,
0.15776705741882324,
0.07698608934879303,
-0.7152175307273865,
0.33619099855422974,
0.46425914764404297,
0.008046875707805157,
-0.23445060849189758,
-0.3020090162754059,
-0.2172887921333313,
-0.2101152241230011,
-0.21248501539230347,
-0.6615400314331055,
0.31591343879699707,
0.20745134353637695,
0.7001802921295166,
0.36666181683540344,
-0.22424621880054474,
0.5311867594718933,
-0.1913289576768875,
0.9274917244911194,
0.0037872842513024807,
-1.106099009513855,
0.7668092846870422,
-0.22661562263965607,
0.3748708665370941,
0.3346889317035675,
-0.01558006927371025,
-0.4319232702255249,
-0.31554126739501953,
-0.5705529451370239,
-0.896733820438385,
0.2655985951423645,
0.15140478312969208,
0.027887625619769096,
0.1243489608168602,
-0.021464888006448746,
0.19846725463867188,
0.29817524552345276,
-0.6159882545471191,
0.007254809141159058,
0.14996129274368286,
0.07792776823043823,
-0.07259051501750946,
-0.4628072679042816,
0.047415591776371,
-0.3643256723880768,
0.5309470891952515,
-0.20576727390289307,
0.09256786853075027,
0.009638173505663872,
-0.31751787662506104,
0.08083807677030563,
0.36230218410491943,
0.7067659497261047,
1.1086920499801636,
-0.09176819771528244,
0.23123812675476074,
0.5028625130653381,
-0.37520453333854675,
0.1753751039505005,
0.06625761836767197,
0.19380007684230804,
0.10756415128707886,
0.7953767776489258,
0.8953114151954651,
0.04303228110074997,
-1.1937391757965088,
0.6725441813468933,
-0.13250911235809326,
0.03730625659227371,
-0.3614341616630554,
0.35008612275123596,
0.21357524394989014,
0.23239754140377045,
0.32565146684646606,
-0.279116690158844,
0.12679776549339294,
-0.3675508201122284,
0.3922116160392761,
0.4224860370159149,
-0.6723847389221191,
-0.2845469117164612,
0.4061466157436371,
0.21988928318023682,
-0.4365190863609314,
0.414371520280838,
0.19084878265857697,
-0.8484810590744019,
0.9148969054222107,
0.2976894974708557,
1.1132878065109253,
-0.7124308347702026,
0.32390522956848145,
0.3193953335285187,
0.31050974130630493,
-0.10674334317445755,
0.5876690745353699,
0.10588283091783524,
-0.4346146583557129,
-0.3921677768230438,
-1.0193514823913574,
-0.15089580416679382,
0.44994375109672546,
-0.5936785936355591,
0.7947988510131836,
-0.01409289799630642,
0.05637970194220543,
-0.507489800453186,
-0.012289625592529774,
-0.9524654150009155,
0.37355732917785645,
0.1589563935995102,
1.0563284158706665,
-0.5916429162025452,
0.742737889289856,
0.8209646940231323,
-0.09027361869812012,
-0.5046197175979614,
-0.2652681767940521,
0.14756304025650024,
-0.9563723206520081,
0.7121530175209045,
0.3990737795829773,
-0.16677521169185638,
-0.2040718048810959,
-0.2734772264957428,
-0.6756340265274048,
0.9044395685195923,
0.5497324466705322,
-0.557263970375061,
0.17953860759735107,
0.31999269127845764,
0.6580089926719666,
-0.5905542373657227,
0.5231840014457703,
0.9011616706848145,
0.7468916773796082,
-0.2960127890110016,
-1.153273105621338,
-0.28068533539772034,
-0.3342546224594116,
0.1103237196803093,
-0.1657588630914688,
-0.6597440242767334,
0.8235968351364136,
-0.27612099051475525,
0.06554751098155975,
0.2606128454208374,
0.608687162399292,
0.5706570744514465,
0.30052900314331055,
0.4717693626880646,
0.23925629258155823,
0.7042561769485474,
-0.13733959197998047,
0.983577311038971,
-0.3173463046550751,
0.36417171359062195,
0.9639501571655273,
-0.3586408495903015,
1.0182560682296753,
0.31835517287254333,
-0.27324679493904114,
-0.04677743464708328,
0.43517428636550903,
0.15412959456443787,
0.11106571555137634,
0.4374234974384308,
-0.3339467942714691,
-0.5788552165031433,
-0.26468396186828613,
-0.5513316988945007,
0.7338224053382874,
0.5771756172180176,
-0.14283688366413116,
-0.06109992042183876,
0.09449854493141174,
-0.2773424983024597,
0.10853969305753708,
-0.3173711597919464,
0.5678629279136658,
0.4615885615348816,
-0.6912826895713806,
0.584901750087738,
-0.04603035748004913,
0.44727838039398193,
-0.7070678472518921,
-0.26885536313056946,
0.014583776704967022,
0.19993214309215546,
-0.10410821437835693,
-1.0171622037887573,
0.1655440628528595,
0.04406849667429924,
0.0008258859161287546,
-0.10870496928691864,
0.9792598485946655,
-0.5599619746208191,
-0.6537728905677795,
0.816863477230072,
0.8351653218269348,
0.06803864985704422,
-0.3214935064315796,
-0.7784804701805115,
0.3992483913898468,
-0.12435717135667801,
-0.43655309081077576,
0.09084481000900269,
0.39396971464157104,
-0.23809508979320526,
0.7806456089019775,
0.30636441707611084,
0.1243206262588501,
-0.09983740746974945,
0.2000519037246704,
0.6323432326316833,
-0.6013787388801575,
-0.4173128604888916,
-1.0742541551589966,
0.7507413029670715,
-0.009020429104566574,
-0.48577430844306946,
0.6760733723640442,
0.8112246990203857,
0.8291319012641907,
-0.09504075348377228,
1.1283857822418213,
0.30548855662345886,
0.2064916491508484,
-0.6094511151313782,
0.6951945424079895,
-0.6473610401153564,
0.36817511916160583,
-0.5358771681785583,
-1.1967180967330933,
-0.05980948358774185,
0.5703622102737427,
-0.010329988785088062,
0.09091465920209885,
0.673384964466095,
0.5486736297607422,
0.22553367912769318,
-0.08017337322235107,
0.7579963803291321,
0.35127708315849304,
0.34245070815086365,
0.6051875948905945,
1.2166707515716553,
-0.0881383866071701,
0.3442677855491638,
0.0013816438149660826,
-0.1362808644771576,
-0.3467147648334503,
-0.5873525142669678,
-0.8815791010856628,
-0.6790019869804382,
-0.4220801293849945,
-0.3059728145599365,
0.23958328366279602,
0.883515477180481,
0.4685685336589813,
-0.6686903238296509,
-0.7189773917198181,
0.17864157259464264,
0.45340120792388916,
-0.15101711452007294,
-0.29050856828689575,
0.4197254776954651,
-0.1539408564567566,
-0.7402369976043701,
0.6659591794013977,
0.7685995697975159,
-0.2200327068567276,
-0.7228481769561768,
-0.3941882252693176,
-0.05580559000372887,
-0.03268101066350937,
0.9541720151901245,
-0.08618206530809402,
-0.8805598020553589,
-0.20891955494880676,
0.18244700133800507,
-0.020644672214984894,
-0.08809121698141098,
0.7231990098953247,
-0.942021369934082,
0.7487339377403259,
0.6645719408988953,
0.7272666692733765,
0.15096314251422882,
-0.21639220416545868,
0.8912354111671448,
-0.31896284222602844,
-0.1176600530743599,
0.24993067979812622,
0.6166077852249146,
0.3173190951347351,
-0.2557055354118347,
0.8149179220199585,
0.015702737495303154,
-0.4962317943572998,
-1.1962374448776245,
0.043325453996658325,
-0.9738079905509949,
-0.1364484280347824,
1.512184977531433,
-0.20702365040779114,
-0.19975265860557556,
-0.22205869853496552,
-0.4225400388240814,
-0.02967073582112789,
-0.12028137594461441,
0.4586425721645355,
0.9142374396324158,
0.15593822300434113,
-0.18848612904548645,
-0.7147159576416016,
0.27970966696739197,
0.20157206058502197,
-0.9297129511833191,
0.01807733252644539,
0.322923481464386,
0.10869097709655762,
-0.001798840588890016,
0.6428694725036621,
0.05365685001015663,
0.46382108330726624,
-0.36666637659072876,
-0.21819980442523956,
0.2102256566286087,
-0.5329399108886719,
-0.5567000508308411,
0.16579307615756989,
0.18270719051361084,
0.378713458776474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13082v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13082v1
|
TREACLE: Thrifty Reasoning via Context-Aware LLM and Prompt Selection
| 2024-04-17T05:56:49 | 2024-04-17T05:56:49 |
Xuechen Zhang, Zijian Huang, Ege Onur Taga, Carlee Joe-Wong, Samet Oymak, Jiasi Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent successes in natural language processing have led to the proliferation
of large language models (LLMs) by multiple providers. Each LLM offering has
different inference accuracy, monetary cost, and latency, and their accuracy
further depends on the exact wording of the question (i.e., the specific
prompt). At the same time, users often have a limit on monetary budget and
latency to answer all their questions, and they do not know which LLMs to
choose for each question to meet their accuracy and long-term budget
requirements. To navigate this rich design space, we propose TREACLE (Thrifty
Reasoning via Context-Aware LLM and Prompt Selection), a reinforcement learning
policy that jointly selects the model and prompting scheme while respecting the
user's monetary cost and latency constraints. TREACLE uses the problem context,
including question text embeddings (reflecting the type or difficulty of a
query) and the response history (reflecting the consistency of previous
responses) to make smart decisions. Our evaluations on standard reasoning
datasets (GSM8K, CSQA, and LLC ) with various LLMs and prompts show that
TREACLE enables cost savings of up to 85% compared to baselines while
maintaining high accuracy. Importantly, it provides the user with the ability
to gracefully trade off accuracy for cost.
|
[
-0.4446050524711609,
-0.7285274267196655,
0.8489817976951599,
0.5076269507408142,
-0.23060642182826996,
0.0874151960015297,
-0.2604858875274658,
-0.2189277857542038,
0.1487065851688385,
0.7433310151100159,
-0.5797335505485535,
-0.16275328397750854,
0.07229028642177582,
0.12718090415000916,
0.2027735412120819,
0.6292933225631714,
0.01336764357984066,
-0.3915110230445862,
-0.14830097556114197,
-0.39402779936790466,
-1.1412800550460815,
-0.056960973888635635,
-1.0798145532608032,
-0.16377735137939453,
0.6129229068756104,
0.7847832441329956,
0.5545003414154053,
0.5232239365577698,
-0.10118497908115387,
0.3416406214237213,
-0.09662510454654694,
0.37431904673576355,
-0.06828588247299194,
0.33698317408561707,
-0.7245972156524658,
-0.40248575806617737,
-0.23835265636444092,
-0.08002247661352158,
0.11889996379613876,
0.43430304527282715,
-0.18089178204536438,
0.09328969568014145,
-0.097859688103199,
0.6986433267593384,
-0.7650941610336304,
0.0551857091486454,
-0.5557729601860046,
-0.0708022341132164,
-0.08363588154315948,
-0.29597705602645874,
-0.4543929696083069,
-0.4501882493495941,
0.4087562561035156,
-0.7985343337059021,
-0.18882009387016296,
0.3411524295806885,
0.64169842004776,
0.50102698802948,
-0.4433403015136719,
-0.2906394898891449,
-0.4527412950992584,
1.0156407356262207,
-0.33771827816963196,
0.40801864862442017,
0.5169670581817627,
0.44825005531311035,
-0.003001615172252059,
-0.787265956401825,
-0.42375317215919495,
-0.4400010108947754,
0.06840339303016663,
0.15028202533721924,
-0.08794531971216202,
-0.07084948569536209,
0.1983838826417923,
0.16122233867645264,
-0.6460307836532593,
-0.06505756825208664,
-0.16852611303329468,
-0.1945929080247879,
0.500043511390686,
0.1604195386171341,
0.006825244519859552,
-0.31229689717292786,
-0.43100664019584656,
-0.008308734744787216,
-0.6642939448356628,
0.16986602544784546,
-0.0147936400026083,
0.2600612938404083,
-0.020672086626291275,
0.5686358213424683,
-0.20120403170585632,
0.7762079834938049,
0.28683939576148987,
0.012430161237716675,
-0.06405383348464966,
-0.19086763262748718,
-0.1335720270872116,
0.20065467059612274,
0.46154555678367615,
0.37034744024276733,
0.39028263092041016,
0.020035985857248306,
-0.37887561321258545,
-0.08687927573919296,
0.5208685994148254,
-0.3097343444824219,
-0.019367463886737823,
0.4307011663913727,
-0.20196838676929474,
-0.34796473383903503,
-0.4825091063976288,
-0.6034829020500183,
-0.3506232798099518,
-0.26932844519615173,
0.4374777376651764,
-0.19070018827915192,
-0.08157471567392349,
0.21507146954536438,
-0.2433834820985794,
-0.17440982162952423,
0.36736804246902466,
-0.6979485154151917,
0.05989807844161987,
0.37083694338798523,
0.8116699457168579,
-0.02105850540101528,
-0.053806692361831665,
-0.9259278774261475,
0.42636770009994507,
-0.263787180185318,
0.8983455300331116,
-0.527533769607544,
-0.5386661291122437,
0.041419319808483124,
-0.14364679157733917,
0.08802127838134766,
-0.32350173592567444,
0.5935957431793213,
-0.7245622873306274,
0.45166701078414917,
-0.5025966167449951,
-0.3668590784072876,
-0.06218837946653366,
0.5294011235237122,
-0.9118161201477051,
0.8189911246299744,
0.29176387190818787,
-0.8370851278305054,
0.5888494849205017,
-0.5830448269844055,
-0.49190089106559753,
0.31499290466308594,
0.14076940715312958,
-0.2029285728931427,
0.07655714452266693,
0.32216155529022217,
0.2586316466331482,
-0.39118126034736633,
0.7138642072677612,
-0.43644335865974426,
-0.4591257870197296,
0.10661330819129944,
-0.43761131167411804,
0.7675109505653381,
0.47558268904685974,
-0.3464789092540741,
0.12369699776172638,
-0.4202480614185333,
-0.1414676308631897,
0.12931010127067566,
-0.6405421495437622,
-0.5743297338485718,
-0.10418389737606049,
-0.10282431542873383,
0.05455135554075241,
0.13499528169631958,
-0.13896289467811584,
0.33901888132095337,
-0.32475894689559937,
0.7903510332107544,
0.8680514097213745,
-0.010936993174254894,
0.7216534614562988,
-0.5757853984832764,
0.335586816072464,
-0.27523380517959595,
0.1325194388628006,
-0.09054464101791382,
-0.2920690178871155,
-0.5538855791091919,
-0.0974116325378418,
-0.015053863637149334,
0.6521421074867249,
-1.2110114097595215,
0.06551158428192139,
0.009286687709391117,
-0.18223072588443756,
-0.03759877383708954,
-0.18389266729354858,
0.18094447255134583,
0.8815699219703674,
0.5102185010910034,
0.15617692470550537,
-0.32124465703964233,
-0.7000651955604553,
-0.5673803091049194,
-0.4759794771671295,
-0.05644427612423897,
0.7619650363922119,
0.2693548798561096,
0.01823202334344387,
1.0750473737716675,
-0.5199798941612244,
-0.030871793627738953,
-0.6595616936683655,
0.20041099190711975,
0.243742436170578,
0.4541158080101013,
0.33611735701560974,
-0.9799678921699524,
-0.09644622355699539,
-0.40060707926750183,
-0.23209646344184875,
-0.5092554688453674,
-0.5600663423538208,
-0.11141493171453476,
0.33206576108932495,
0.2995868921279907,
-0.7138304710388184,
0.19651520252227783,
0.21230308711528778,
-0.5294089913368225,
0.6447644233703613,
-0.38507553935050964,
0.11340377479791641,
-1.2309900522232056,
0.09940990805625916,
0.2637307047843933,
-0.297228068113327,
-0.2392295002937317,
-0.11474436521530151,
0.2864921987056732,
0.12544207274913788,
-0.33084192872047424,
1.0718985795974731,
-0.10824595391750336,
0.01270407997071743,
-0.015472575090825558,
0.18872395157814026,
0.3391399383544922,
0.5771030187606812,
0.2894328236579895,
1.2112817764282227,
-0.004539813846349716,
-0.9836766123771667,
0.30727511644363403,
0.249410018324852,
-0.14951542019844055,
0.9342669248580933,
-1.0098294019699097,
-0.16843847930431366,
0.1352969855070114,
0.4104404151439667,
-0.8215179443359375,
-0.174881249666214,
0.2925548553466797,
-0.24378949403762817,
0.19790862500667572,
-0.09088250249624252,
-0.21396879851818085,
-0.46047940850257874,
-0.3853820264339447,
0.48355787992477417,
0.14867296814918518,
-0.7859004139900208,
0.7550816535949707,
0.455230176448822,
-0.2552359104156494,
-0.770176887512207,
-0.6505091786384583,
0.17773565649986267,
-0.49478042125701904,
-0.4352514445781708,
0.31167009472846985,
-0.2489892542362213,
-0.20917850732803345,
-0.029443202540278435,
-0.3215598464012146,
0.035378288477659225,
0.32160428166389465,
-0.08609052002429962,
0.5234823226928711,
0.010532969608902931,
0.5937561988830566,
0.13874997198581696,
-0.3647718131542206,
-0.015594934113323689,
-1.1332948207855225,
0.5676737427711487,
-0.23941358923912048,
-0.11132729053497314,
0.04589568451046944,
0.15610691905021667,
0.3516618013381958,
-0.33112165331840515,
0.36164942383766174,
0.2698860764503479,
-0.1829611212015152,
-0.34231114387512207,
-0.8864498138427734,
-0.02015266939997673,
-0.5249062776565552,
-0.02192201092839241,
-0.4708757996559143,
-1.1802747249603271,
0.2080659568309784,
-0.20317764580249786,
0.24768558144569397,
0.1485525518655777,
0.29310739040374756,
-0.07629330456256866,
0.8243855834007263,
0.28596368432044983,
-0.07563421875238419,
0.5310004949569702,
0.0278713870793581,
0.005270507652312517,
-0.5792800784111023,
-0.23367764055728912,
-0.5998463034629822,
-0.11853822320699692,
-0.5872348546981812,
-0.3632364869117737,
0.5033977031707764,
-0.1385187804698944,
-0.7358360290527344,
0.3932514786720276,
-0.2901158928871155,
0.53270423412323,
0.956036388874054,
0.17250226438045502,
0.2537778317928314,
-0.1701156049966812,
-0.42031458020210266,
0.05884206295013428,
-0.7536077499389648,
-0.5044423937797546,
0.7445189356803894,
-0.0033019124530255795,
0.6446018815040588,
0.07092764228582382,
0.45395785570144653,
0.44892144203186035,
0.18754664063453674,
-0.6612098813056946,
0.6244333386421204,
0.20176686346530914,
-0.5952900052070618,
-0.44456684589385986,
-0.775023341178894,
-0.8073652386665344,
0.1333898901939392,
-0.05963582172989845,
-0.7658622860908508,
0.013533291406929493,
0.421362042427063,
-0.35331887006759644,
0.25736019015312195,
-0.3314131200313568,
0.9286528825759888,
-0.34305137395858765,
-0.8922207355499268,
-0.3439493477344513,
-0.5948183536529541,
0.40474972128868103,
0.11843353509902954,
0.06616125255823135,
0.09185025840997696,
-0.2853001356124878,
0.46794384717941284,
-0.30960386991500854,
0.5038978457450867,
-0.14758147299289703,
0.07309462130069733,
0.2511539161205292,
0.3869413435459137,
0.7052589058876038,
0.5834400653839111,
0.03652137145400047,
-0.17734920978546143,
-0.271994411945343,
-0.38094842433929443,
-0.3746459484100342,
0.7302538752555847,
-0.22640058398246765,
-0.8431383371353149,
-0.4313983917236328,
-0.5766846537590027,
-0.592634379863739,
0.2243078649044037,
0.20270004868507385,
0.5597763061523438,
0.02436496876180172,
0.05010980740189552,
0.9788222908973694,
-0.6770675778388977,
0.5161628723144531,
0.2760980725288391,
0.011433525010943413,
-0.6487069725990295,
0.7062215209007263,
-0.1383601725101471,
0.19658678770065308,
0.45981988310813904,
0.6033298373222351,
-0.8183726668357849,
-0.15423503518104553,
-0.623419463634491,
0.3221946954727173,
-0.49717774987220764,
-0.14601975679397583,
-0.7264573574066162,
0.37418073415756226,
-0.07764863222837448,
-0.5848963856697083,
-0.27861472964286804,
-0.6607058048248291,
-0.10532381385564804,
-0.1937999278306961,
0.2220541536808014,
0.23419779539108276,
-0.1502838283777237,
0.16757024824619293,
-0.8684116005897522,
0.1638481616973877,
0.6607974171638489,
0.41638830304145813,
0.04424624890089035,
-0.40419238805770874,
-0.03381474316120148,
-0.2635762095451355,
-0.20330026745796204,
-0.7833889722824097,
0.25462618470191956,
-0.25430673360824585,
0.48179274797439575,
0.42166414856910706,
0.4364831745624542,
0.6079413890838623,
-0.30226653814315796,
0.7457559704780579,
0.18410685658454895,
-1.0565149784088135,
0.6280442476272583,
-0.2743844985961914,
0.5950450301170349,
0.7115775942802429,
0.07771114259958267,
-0.8804750442504883,
-0.29567569494247437,
-0.5614286661148071,
-0.8483383059501648,
0.5738734602928162,
-0.058153968304395676,
0.03520532697439194,
-0.22208361327648163,
0.03387441113591194,
-0.011277209036052227,
0.2914923429489136,
-0.48531901836395264,
0.05513724684715271,
-0.2901585102081299,
-0.02687458135187626,
0.04390687495470047,
-0.3075988292694092,
0.07035153359174728,
0.03482505679130554,
0.5690816044807434,
-0.2571425437927246,
-0.006519237998872995,
0.10831496119499207,
-0.14357773959636688,
0.022782180458307266,
0.42061957716941833,
0.628199577331543,
0.49333876371383667,
-0.0010271869832649827,
0.2623288333415985,
0.3702610433101654,
-0.18857444822788239,
0.09514633566141129,
-0.11515285819768906,
-0.18454168736934662,
-0.11788254231214523,
0.22625921666622162,
0.6075554490089417,
0.5414575934410095,
-0.9563484787940979,
0.4130547344684601,
-0.32455897331237793,
-0.039597608149051666,
-0.2673775553703308,
0.12507255375385284,
0.2371678650379181,
0.6443682312965393,
0.19538861513137817,
0.0604054257273674,
0.20380128920078278,
-0.14164330065250397,
0.05833229050040245,
0.34643861651420593,
-0.1493353396654129,
0.059176959097385406,
0.858906626701355,
0.26825955510139465,
-0.2768327295780182,
0.6806443929672241,
-0.18160979449748993,
-0.5050395727157593,
0.5033026933670044,
0.422903835773468,
0.9972227811813354,
-0.08394891768693924,
0.6088240742683411,
0.4811421036720276,
0.2228665053844452,
-0.4543522298336029,
0.42255663871765137,
-0.5144792795181274,
-0.5231746435165405,
-0.3538892865180969,
-0.26520100235939026,
-0.5892878174781799,
0.01726604998111725,
-0.45077887177467346,
0.08952289819717407,
-0.5328654050827026,
-0.20627523958683014,
-0.5329179763793945,
0.1695568710565567,
-0.5238460302352905,
0.17454801499843597,
0.02065851539373398,
1.2404981851577759,
-0.4111454486846924,
0.4108699858188629,
0.7108315825462341,
-0.4565359652042389,
-0.9709444046020508,
-0.14352992177009583,
0.07679271697998047,
-0.7052339315414429,
0.5559719800949097,
0.31501439213752747,
-0.22210034728050232,
-0.2389218509197235,
-0.7163004279136658,
-0.666284441947937,
1.1303147077560425,
0.15051865577697754,
-0.5523040294647217,
-0.03333393856883049,
-0.15144355595111847,
0.06356765329837799,
-0.1455875188112259,
0.28760507702827454,
0.48759153485298157,
0.6993176341056824,
0.47439607977867126,
-0.8005006313323975,
0.21297916769981384,
0.03758866712450981,
0.11280614137649536,
0.2104903757572174,
-0.6021202802658081,
0.8423585295677185,
-0.4970977008342743,
-0.30078619718551636,
-0.17676003277301788,
0.4678173065185547,
0.9773625731468201,
0.7927234172821045,
0.7378805875778198,
0.5177884101867676,
0.9637772440910339,
-0.0477728545665741,
0.8754127025604248,
-0.2102329134941101,
0.1140696331858635,
0.9821090698242188,
-0.32149451971054077,
0.47191330790519714,
0.6979131102561951,
0.1352979987859726,
0.2983817458152771,
0.8393830060958862,
0.3587838113307953,
0.6441171169281006,
0.1806202083826065,
-0.3438057601451874,
-0.5717496275901794,
-0.3256368637084961,
-0.1057196855545044,
0.07137935608625412,
0.33665168285369873,
0.14959827065467834,
-0.26180219650268555,
-0.0525960698723793,
0.15428854525089264,
-0.04898884892463684,
-0.3278774917125702,
0.6922520399093628,
0.21165181696414948,
-0.9121366739273071,
0.31811922788619995,
-0.07908731698989868,
0.5209587216377258,
-0.42628341913223267,
-0.026584554463624954,
-0.6319738626480103,
0.017052432522177696,
0.15183371305465698,
-0.8211713433265686,
0.05953419953584671,
0.08311182260513306,
0.05623085796833038,
-0.44089475274086,
0.8605372905731201,
-0.1570364087820053,
-0.02813337929546833,
0.00595365185290575,
0.6087794303894043,
-0.22541692852973938,
-0.08177980035543442,
-0.6371397376060486,
-0.19588051736354828,
-0.22929561138153076,
-0.6105326414108276,
0.0008153383969329298,
0.6215270161628723,
-0.3247290849685669,
1.1970436573028564,
0.6406291723251343,
0.21797162294387817,
-0.5295450687408447,
-0.050235822796821594,
0.8631323575973511,
-0.7891983985900879,
-1.1099090576171875,
-0.6836632490158081,
0.48942098021507263,
-0.37578877806663513,
-0.38647666573524475,
0.3331393599510193,
0.21364612877368927,
0.8932991623878479,
0.012820256873965263,
0.775042712688446,
0.14037805795669556,
0.31547027826309204,
-0.6486682295799255,
0.32257330417633057,
-0.7842448949813843,
0.6120355725288391,
-0.2095358669757843,
-0.8232784867286682,
-0.10570799559354782,
0.6963270902633667,
-0.5909733772277832,
-0.01189999096095562,
0.5900216698646545,
0.5427810549736023,
-0.04947073012590408,
0.21622693538665771,
0.10752666741609573,
-0.31806087493896484,
0.337555468082428,
0.8656730055809021,
1.0749471187591553,
0.2924831509590149,
0.5368484258651733,
0.03943051025271416,
-0.06936799734830856,
-0.4682128131389618,
-1.0039417743682861,
-0.9077499508857727,
-0.46435993909835815,
-0.042249880731105804,
-0.3247767984867096,
0.060713473707437515,
1.262168049812317,
0.52224200963974,
-0.5397299528121948,
-0.21777041256427765,
-0.2643052935600281,
0.5408433675765991,
-0.2364717572927475,
-0.23612263798713684,
0.22966773808002472,
-0.5630756616592407,
-0.35955315828323364,
0.3290298879146576,
0.5397971272468567,
-0.11604826152324677,
0.030035460367798805,
-0.3085714280605316,
0.013189384713768959,
0.388893723487854,
0.4135183095932007,
0.3823184669017792,
-0.4625239968299866,
-0.4498575031757355,
0.05085998401045799,
-0.2647956311702728,
-0.12947247922420502,
0.9988300204277039,
-1.0461344718933105,
0.3194425702095032,
0.5344897508621216,
0.869255542755127,
0.3033866286277771,
-0.09479065984487534,
0.5576474666595459,
-0.47047707438468933,
-0.09138473868370056,
0.3579825162887573,
0.3923526406288147,
0.10664033144712448,
-0.2685360312461853,
0.520717203617096,
0.20045046508312225,
-0.6038557291030884,
-0.7034909129142761,
0.4141733944416046,
-0.8884412050247192,
-0.5525955557823181,
0.8971824645996094,
0.04347947984933853,
-0.14004985988140106,
-0.3949630558490753,
-0.3882054388523102,
0.21610204875469208,
-0.673503041267395,
0.8502559065818787,
0.4494408369064331,
0.19684050977230072,
-0.4692595601081848,
-0.5778747200965881,
0.4808591604232788,
0.5248571038246155,
-0.7158161401748657,
0.1017448753118515,
0.7106184959411621,
0.198018416762352,
-0.07366196066141129,
0.6021727323532104,
0.35419178009033203,
0.3597610890865326,
-0.20999467372894287,
-0.3979429304599762,
-0.42363208532333374,
-0.5113860368728638,
-0.01545149739831686,
0.3151822090148926,
-0.041387829929590225,
-0.11888748407363892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11061v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11061v1
|
Unified Examination of Entity Linking in Absence of Candidate Sets
| 2024-04-17T04:37:58 | 2024-04-17T04:37:58 |
Nicolas Ong, Hassan Shavarani, Anoop Sarkar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite remarkable strides made in the development of entity linking systems
in recent years, a comprehensive comparative analysis of these systems using a
unified framework is notably absent. This paper addresses this oversight by
introducing a new black-box benchmark and conducting a comprehensive evaluation
of all state-of-the-art entity linking methods. We use an ablation study to
investigate the impact of candidate sets on the performance of entity linking.
Our findings uncover exactly how much such entity linking systems depend on
candidate sets, and how much this limits the general applicability of each
system. We present an alternative approach to candidate sets, demonstrating
that leveraging the entire in-domain candidate set can serve as a viable
substitute for certain models. We show the trade-off between less restrictive
candidate sets, increased inference time and memory footprint for some models.
|
[
-0.8361935019493103,
-0.3689587712287903,
0.3216163218021393,
-0.34773242473602295,
-0.35319840908050537,
-0.09311936050653458,
-0.01694590598344803,
-0.7409632205963135,
0.15331777930259705,
0.5530755519866943,
-0.4198927879333496,
-0.25158923864364624,
0.05270427465438843,
0.3373965620994568,
-0.567497193813324,
0.8155548572540283,
0.13750696182250977,
-0.3811784088611603,
-0.5463084578514099,
-0.35144785046577454,
-0.3187597692012787,
-0.06527876108884811,
-0.48718374967575073,
-0.6721300482749939,
0.3663882315158844,
0.1039036437869072,
0.6916922926902771,
0.8488143682479858,
0.6112074255943298,
0.19922541081905365,
-0.0807148888707161,
-0.0772925540804863,
-0.26187366247177124,
0.08262187987565994,
-0.7073778510093689,
0.09934453666210175,
-0.1188126802444458,
-0.08528989553451538,
0.9791132211685181,
1.0706689357757568,
-0.008616629987955093,
0.4147099554538727,
-0.26243850588798523,
0.7350021600723267,
-1.2342393398284912,
-0.16371913254261017,
-1.168709397315979,
-0.1889571100473404,
-0.4726562201976776,
-0.11067159473896027,
-0.32736077904701233,
-0.2642515301704407,
0.2759039103984833,
-0.32814693450927734,
0.6072142124176025,
0.24492083489894867,
0.803860604763031,
0.4335865080356598,
-0.7177670001983643,
-0.3053828477859497,
-0.8279032111167908,
0.5022285580635071,
-0.40832969546318054,
0.6879424452781677,
-0.19295907020568848,
0.016931187361478806,
0.040493760257959366,
-0.6885871887207031,
-0.31714314222335815,
-0.2486644685268402,
0.0671275407075882,
-0.09825484454631805,
-0.278383731842041,
0.3741708993911743,
0.30460020899772644,
0.6205306649208069,
-0.3452248275279999,
0.07982364296913147,
-0.5210886597633362,
-0.04947589337825775,
0.4807800054550171,
0.016054227948188782,
0.058108851313591,
-0.060770999640226364,
-0.5648975968360901,
-0.11371085047721863,
-1.2791121006011963,
-0.32798081636428833,
0.5090229511260986,
0.26330626010894775,
0.29965147376060486,
0.6488247513771057,
-0.07989707589149475,
0.7499034404754639,
0.03238223120570183,
0.3357023000717163,
-0.08767206966876984,
-0.3235885500907898,
-0.5359640717506409,
0.1840302050113678,
0.6150341629981995,
0.21370883285999298,
0.10984163731336594,
-0.5338414907455444,
-0.22255180776119232,
0.3498587906360626,
0.5332613587379456,
-0.8388670086860657,
-0.3652559518814087,
0.28404268622398376,
-0.26563790440559387,
0.054577842354774475,
0.20742636919021606,
-0.6808041334152222,
-0.09548404067754745,
-0.12767083942890167,
0.4018413722515106,
-0.11857996135950089,
-0.33710017800331116,
-0.005887408275157213,
-0.25670650601387024,
0.059228841215372086,
-0.06885971873998642,
-0.7773020267486572,
0.28249073028564453,
0.591711163520813,
0.3717416822910309,
-0.2573772072792053,
-0.10969789326190948,
-0.4397502839565277,
0.3372586667537689,
-0.5517707467079163,
1.0342272520065308,
-0.947689414024353,
-0.6605184078216553,
0.21199750900268555,
-0.006649078335613012,
0.10827791690826416,
-0.930523693561554,
0.4985986649990082,
-0.7750318646430969,
-0.2664405107498169,
-0.4509204626083374,
-0.796133279800415,
-0.038408976048231125,
-0.2377607822418213,
-0.8222009539604187,
1.0098583698272705,
-0.07935232669115067,
-0.43959981203079224,
0.5877126455307007,
-0.6284175515174866,
-0.4963649809360504,
0.09526068717241287,
-0.12917226552963257,
-0.44842034578323364,
0.2526545524597168,
-0.13757900893688202,
0.20244814455509186,
-0.47999125719070435,
0.11826083064079285,
-0.7352601885795593,
-0.8041549921035767,
-0.0028327361214905977,
-0.16179126501083374,
0.9255632758140564,
0.11125805974006653,
-0.4578506350517273,
-0.45991480350494385,
-0.9213849902153015,
0.043822210282087326,
-0.0482824333012104,
-0.26338788866996765,
-0.5161922574043274,
-0.1411534696817398,
-0.37479352951049805,
-0.03275379166007042,
0.046670377254486084,
-0.49264147877693176,
0.32531487941741943,
-0.3063679039478302,
-0.26513785123825073,
0.6983215808868408,
0.23680271208286285,
0.5672038793563843,
0.04999072477221489,
0.238666832447052,
-0.07001183927059174,
-0.2359052300453186,
0.015828937292099,
-0.3393639624118805,
-0.9829185009002686,
0.1678534597158432,
0.5083503723144531,
0.06015263497829437,
-0.6849423050880432,
0.23188257217407227,
-0.11735069006681442,
-0.5427137017250061,
-0.6019474267959595,
0.16438855230808258,
0.8346180319786072,
0.39094287157058716,
0.37042123079299927,
-0.3749532997608185,
-0.5502753853797913,
-1.1289079189300537,
-0.46615543961524963,
-0.3753194808959961,
-0.10275910049676895,
0.17522357404232025,
0.8535852432250977,
0.10566280037164688,
0.5251765847206116,
-0.2613500952720642,
0.022637009620666504,
0.36102744936943054,
-0.31448766589164734,
0.10578283667564392,
0.553501307964325,
0.4462393820285797,
-0.6324707269668579,
-0.20802773535251617,
-0.021653519943356514,
-0.738105833530426,
0.09550728648900986,
-0.027493346482515335,
-0.05793355777859688,
0.15803998708724976,
0.4848771393299103,
-0.3475266695022583,
0.45077192783355713,
0.43295085430145264,
-0.2945452034473419,
0.6728845834732056,
-0.024806248024106026,
0.19529666006565094,
-0.47805100679397583,
0.5241344571113586,
0.36766737699508667,
0.3842633068561554,
-0.7267665266990662,
0.1940964311361313,
0.20017170906066895,
-0.11751282215118408,
-0.3662053346633911,
0.8127655386924744,
-0.7559615969657898,
-0.707155168056488,
-0.06946417689323425,
0.1809815615415573,
0.20909881591796875,
0.17533816397190094,
-0.16340452432632446,
0.8109307885169983,
0.3193162679672241,
-0.8414924144744873,
0.2218698412179947,
0.5441031455993652,
-0.06099182367324829,
0.9962778687477112,
-0.5325194001197815,
0.1947888880968094,
-0.046745117753744125,
0.04375291243195534,
-0.7170645594596863,
-0.02351672761142254,
0.15036199986934662,
-0.23240117728710175,
0.4726850688457489,
-0.4429464340209961,
-0.2969256341457367,
-0.35378298163414,
-0.1344449669122696,
0.11793611198663712,
0.3995513617992401,
-0.7505279183387756,
0.29775089025497437,
0.14277859032154083,
0.27791622281074524,
-0.816903829574585,
-0.40594446659088135,
0.05438932403922081,
-0.2869313061237335,
-0.2480299472808838,
0.585893988609314,
0.009253340773284435,
-0.5660655498504639,
0.2979249060153961,
-0.6053938865661621,
-0.17966189980506897,
0.315978467464447,
0.15317939221858978,
0.3829706907272339,
-0.3990289866924286,
0.4022449553012848,
0.18847781419754028,
-0.18821440637111664,
0.09257175773382187,
-0.26222941279411316,
-0.05954724922776222,
-0.02062588557600975,
-0.666156530380249,
-0.4536794424057007,
0.3958546817302704,
0.28598806262016296,
-0.5191478729248047,
0.7175765037536621,
0.26717379689216614,
-0.562936544418335,
-0.06931979209184647,
-0.8453237414360046,
-0.13089710474014282,
-0.47093865275382996,
0.1220889762043953,
-0.5172954201698303,
-0.5966307520866394,
0.40468817949295044,
-0.10606817901134491,
0.38098275661468506,
0.6373026371002197,
0.3024756610393524,
0.22708763182163239,
0.4537109136581421,
0.5611202716827393,
0.2578267455101013,
0.35077863931655884,
-0.009771531447768211,
0.1887795478105545,
-1.0223848819732666,
-0.2626814544200897,
-1.041243314743042,
0.034730423241853714,
-0.7605470418930054,
0.10329708456993103,
0.16647416353225708,
0.20490451157093048,
-0.44119319319725037,
0.5694370865821838,
-0.5941008925437927,
0.6674990057945251,
0.5441807508468628,
-0.057671401649713516,
0.5413062572479248,
0.02635113149881363,
-0.25756514072418213,
0.1597738116979599,
-0.4874429702758789,
-0.5263282060623169,
1.3464984893798828,
-0.2644050419330597,
0.4431021511554718,
0.023624110966920853,
0.7210316061973572,
0.22067895531654358,
0.6510704755783081,
-0.08235418051481247,
0.47436800599098206,
-0.07542180269956589,
-1.2200506925582886,
-0.34536316990852356,
-0.3024366497993469,
-1.1517161130905151,
0.495421439409256,
-0.43364641070365906,
-0.8410652279853821,
0.35955289006233215,
0.12676414847373962,
-0.09925408661365509,
0.7639607787132263,
-0.6298117637634277,
0.8274890780448914,
0.22685307264328003,
-0.5777345895767212,
0.002810073085129261,
-0.3230152428150177,
0.34214627742767334,
-0.1527312695980072,
-0.25356975197792053,
-0.1897042840719223,
-0.1333211213350296,
0.5300344824790955,
-0.0068550934083759785,
0.32569676637649536,
-0.06957575678825378,
-0.022072816267609596,
0.2841798663139343,
0.09276057034730911,
0.41776326298713684,
0.026477478444576263,
-0.5074114203453064,
0.19033874571323395,
-0.0555206798017025,
-0.4898361265659332,
-0.2614574730396271,
0.8727954626083374,
-0.2494940608739853,
-0.5057297945022583,
-0.20461522042751312,
0.07576628029346466,
-0.26097026467323303,
0.3916056752204895,
0.06497753411531448,
0.5652951598167419,
-0.5675296783447266,
0.2528649866580963,
0.9066221714019775,
0.07762151211500168,
0.4040620028972626,
0.3209586441516876,
0.2452070713043213,
-0.09513941407203674,
0.5282837152481079,
-0.18249210715293884,
0.3042548894882202,
0.030881039798259735,
-0.42469099164009094,
-0.6461805105209351,
-0.7631881237030029,
-0.6805356740951538,
0.46299517154693604,
-0.8192660808563232,
-0.3023628294467926,
-0.5891785025596619,
0.21209749579429626,
-0.45162761211395264,
-0.30994337797164917,
-0.5519299507141113,
0.14944559335708618,
-0.31099027395248413,
0.07590237259864807,
-0.09241262078285217,
0.710454523563385,
0.16351233422756195,
0.0283046904951334,
-0.5362564325332642,
0.31888100504875183,
0.14943961799144745,
0.9277539849281311,
0.16277532279491425,
0.09493811428546906,
-0.23074235022068024,
-0.2355731576681137,
-0.42624470591545105,
-0.9841665029525757,
-0.3315422534942627,
0.2978123128414154,
0.9078482985496521,
0.7195711731910706,
0.23039093613624573,
0.6752393245697021,
-0.512235701084137,
0.5651588439941406,
0.22190028429031372,
-0.8091486096382141,
0.4664217233657837,
-0.06773548573255539,
0.04363314062356949,
0.7400084137916565,
0.4603143036365509,
-0.20575885474681854,
-0.194481760263443,
-0.9583544135093689,
-0.49673527479171753,
0.14945286512374878,
0.32163044810295105,
-0.40062281489372253,
-0.200077623128891,
0.6833038330078125,
0.010181058198213577,
0.2663056552410126,
-0.41960594058036804,
-0.8111560940742493,
0.44916993379592896,
0.41862353682518005,
-0.06599119305610657,
0.028553210198879242,
-0.09821470081806183,
0.10677517205476761,
0.8404650092124939,
-0.13851052522659302,
0.27914783358573914,
0.11462806910276413,
-0.10408981144428253,
-0.3347218632698059,
0.31090956926345825,
-0.0923234149813652,
0.7524387836456299,
-0.2521974742412567,
-0.08497507125139236,
0.25331810116767883,
0.0309598445892334,
0.30898362398147583,
0.33775588870048523,
-0.19371037185192108,
0.3492290675640106,
0.1338023543357849,
0.4560158848762512,
0.6292858719825745,
-0.41655266284942627,
0.11640596389770508,
0.3533337414264679,
-0.08391568809747696,
-0.11440526694059372,
0.19827565550804138,
0.3477705121040344,
0.25136926770210266,
0.27218130230903625,
0.028207074850797653,
0.36761996150016785,
-0.647222638130188,
0.25506386160850525,
0.738096296787262,
-0.6830282807350159,
-0.1937168687582016,
0.8647687435150146,
0.2807137072086334,
-0.16515959799289703,
0.5702069997787476,
-0.07910811901092529,
0.01026997622102499,
0.5739855170249939,
0.3945234417915344,
0.7894534468650818,
-0.3375038802623749,
-0.09312289208173752,
0.4177341163158417,
0.46797725558280945,
0.03929219767451286,
-0.2080828696489334,
-0.04098043590784073,
-0.4296017587184906,
-0.29003822803497314,
-0.44622156023979187,
-0.6969128251075745,
0.025545038282871246,
-0.9321283102035522,
0.22790800034999847,
-0.30165937542915344,
0.012395638972520828,
0.3088243305683136,
0.35104382038116455,
-0.8215553164482117,
0.3515275716781616,
-0.13594989478588104,
0.8932247161865234,
-0.817037045955658,
0.4003884494304657,
1.0218466520309448,
-0.5048567056655884,
-0.07977094501256943,
-0.2552032768726349,
0.03644579276442528,
-0.3289220631122589,
-0.1105765774846077,
-0.012183747254312038,
-0.00757644884288311,
-0.059982236474752426,
-0.1207355484366417,
-0.7219799160957336,
0.9034545421600342,
0.4345850944519043,
-0.29655295610427856,
-0.2891070544719696,
-0.0782075822353363,
0.4925002157688141,
-0.308062344789505,
0.16664709150791168,
0.7500461935997009,
0.4053695797920227,
0.09279203414916992,
-0.8904730081558228,
0.2688024044036865,
-0.0400255061686039,
-0.06362617015838623,
0.7282648086547852,
-0.4338943362236023,
0.6093940138816833,
-0.1567966341972351,
-0.503617525100708,
0.04505004733800888,
0.5505886673927307,
0.1965700089931488,
0.4353623688220978,
0.5044825077056885,
0.6156625151634216,
0.6282477974891663,
-0.052031341940164566,
0.8943229913711548,
-0.11891018599271774,
0.43066874146461487,
0.8866921067237854,
-0.5881378650665283,
0.696380078792572,
0.48317211866378784,
-0.31961315870285034,
0.18983741104602814,
0.5576651692390442,
-0.2656664550304413,
0.13747607171535492,
0.2192862182855606,
-0.5098749399185181,
-0.44622886180877686,
-0.10672109574079514,
-0.6081408858299255,
0.1559748649597168,
0.2970980405807495,
-0.1947554051876068,
-0.5104210376739502,
-0.6145619750022888,
-0.1673806607723236,
-0.013873223215341568,
-0.21938587725162506,
0.621168315410614,
0.009324879385530949,
-0.8876772522926331,
0.5047551989555359,
-0.44666388630867004,
0.501485288143158,
-0.37544935941696167,
-0.15775658190250397,
-0.21391411125659943,
0.1093486100435257,
-0.16275425255298615,
-0.41282081604003906,
0.23750418424606323,
-0.11818602681159973,
0.06511111557483673,
0.17468473315238953,
0.8280937075614929,
-0.17826901376247406,
-0.16270384192466736,
0.3200644254684448,
0.645832359790802,
0.29088738560676575,
-0.11938834190368652,
-0.7290763854980469,
-0.01929629221558571,
0.030181407928466797,
-0.2707054316997528,
0.4166492223739624,
0.3038524091243744,
0.04801162704825401,
0.5695167183876038,
0.8717231750488281,
0.08521933108568192,
-0.2881811559200287,
-0.35774725675582886,
0.8714223504066467,
-0.7619497179985046,
0.0029864690732210875,
-0.5791496634483337,
0.32347843050956726,
-0.13445231318473816,
-0.47022512555122375,
0.524946928024292,
0.7429823279380798,
1.0464280843734741,
0.239683136343956,
0.7007150650024414,
0.11155489087104797,
0.2855633795261383,
-0.3863676190376282,
0.47847387194633484,
-0.9423342347145081,
0.3987348675727844,
-0.6685031652450562,
-1.4369616508483887,
-0.23795771598815918,
0.1395360231399536,
0.1408596634864807,
0.16084875166416168,
0.8714086413383484,
0.6754982471466064,
-0.20757856965065002,
-0.006443156395107508,
0.4566243886947632,
-0.20300999283790588,
0.16999028623104095,
0.2791997790336609,
0.5882031321525574,
-0.4891919791698456,
0.7127685546875,
-0.24452275037765503,
0.08073258399963379,
-0.4036065936088562,
-0.9876665472984314,
-1.0353175401687622,
-0.6649512052536011,
-0.5010919570922852,
-0.6045691967010498,
0.3756285607814789,
0.5433029532432556,
0.32661256194114685,
-0.620938241481781,
0.002818300388753414,
0.45813655853271484,
0.29121044278144836,
-0.08066566288471222,
-0.06352592259645462,
0.3647208511829376,
0.10994214564561844,
-0.6547049283981323,
0.36592236161231995,
0.4787929356098175,
0.024862755089998245,
-0.31323540210723877,
0.30743658542633057,
-0.3084355592727661,
0.07741253077983856,
0.08311451226472855,
0.597672700881958,
-0.6348401308059692,
-0.34121283888816833,
-0.11274244636297226,
0.17965255677700043,
0.2571698725223541,
0.8165587782859802,
-0.5862599611282349,
0.2718175947666168,
0.027838431298732758,
0.6947313547134399,
0.5320072770118713,
-0.14967159926891327,
0.3273754417896271,
-0.5021576285362244,
0.04422435536980629,
0.1336917281150818,
0.5085847973823547,
0.23023325204849243,
-0.18014273047447205,
0.8051734566688538,
0.1727982759475708,
-0.3780856430530548,
-0.8498979806900024,
0.23485708236694336,
-0.6816315054893494,
-0.19900640845298767,
0.945556640625,
-0.057413555681705475,
-0.2644769847393036,
-0.301947683095932,
0.35436782240867615,
0.24730873107910156,
-0.2877839505672455,
0.6498642563819885,
0.47741013765335083,
-0.08029363304376602,
0.23211559653282166,
-0.4398108422756195,
0.18314792215824127,
0.21034546196460724,
-0.8224756717681885,
-0.06320919096469879,
0.7561034560203552,
0.3557448089122772,
0.21103492379188538,
0.6776171922683716,
-0.11308655142784119,
0.6297072768211365,
0.41875895857810974,
0.3553057014942169,
0.04179997742176056,
-0.35698413848876953,
-0.35709598660469055,
0.20357877016067505,
-0.09210017323493958,
0.0891559049487114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11055v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11055v1
|
On the Causal Nature of Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-04-17T04:04:34 | 2024-04-17T04:04:34 |
Zhiheng Lyu, Zhijing Jin, Fernando Gonzalez, Rada Mihalcea, Bernhard Schoelkopf, Mrinmaya Sachan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sentiment analysis (SA) aims to identify the sentiment expressed in a text,
such as a product review. Given a review and the sentiment associated with it,
this paper formulates SA as a combination of two tasks: (1) a causal discovery
task that distinguishes whether a review "primes" the sentiment (Causal
Hypothesis C1), or the sentiment "primes" the review (Causal Hypothesis C2);
and (2) the traditional prediction task to model the sentiment using the review
as input. Using the peak-end rule in psychology, we classify a sample as C1 if
its overall sentiment score approximates an average of all the sentence-level
sentiments in the review, and C2 if the overall sentiment score approximates an
average of the peak and end sentiments. For the prediction task, we use the
discovered causal mechanisms behind the samples to improve the performance of
LLMs by proposing causal prompts that give the models an inductive bias of the
underlying causal graph, leading to substantial improvements by up to 32.13 F1
points on zero-shot five-class SA. Our code is at
https://github.com/cogito233/causal-sa
|
[
-0.39152511954307556,
-0.7412431240081787,
0.6202912926673889,
0.6787451505661011,
-0.32779446244239807,
-0.2807459533214569,
-0.1256987750530243,
-0.5042412877082825,
0.3208405375480652,
0.2818306088447571,
-0.8958307504653931,
-0.5363198518753052,
-0.7922385334968567,
0.11697504669427872,
-0.16865228116512299,
1.225360631942749,
0.31802836060523987,
0.328081339597702,
-0.17727252840995789,
-0.11336532235145569,
-0.550834596157074,
-0.37843137979507446,
-0.7404360175132751,
-0.20618027448654175,
0.8949894905090332,
0.21674159169197083,
0.40652427077293396,
-0.07503101229667664,
0.650748610496521,
0.15753622353076935,
-0.2939882278442383,
0.046464841812849045,
-0.7672719359397888,
0.3745882213115692,
-0.1022629365324974,
-0.6709944009780884,
-0.26902905106544495,
0.29267171025276184,
0.1986273229122162,
0.7557669281959534,
0.2574775218963623,
0.269418865442276,
0.26432549953460693,
1.0332117080688477,
-0.6716352701187134,
0.4897210896015167,
-0.3168509006500244,
-0.13324330747127533,
0.038374774158000946,
-0.48246052861213684,
-0.5790308713912964,
-0.3452414274215698,
0.1124931052327156,
-0.2585170269012451,
0.4897477924823761,
0.11553797125816345,
0.79679936170578,
0.2945961356163025,
-0.6188109517097473,
-0.2089117467403412,
-0.8848931193351746,
0.8022602796554565,
-0.5408315062522888,
0.12399878352880478,
0.016272014006972313,
0.11863517761230469,
-0.16677983105182648,
-0.10744217783212662,
-0.5504840612411499,
-0.17451366782188416,
-0.11349483579397202,
0.4632771611213684,
-0.3125656545162201,
0.18670004606246948,
0.47193944454193115,
0.4211912453174591,
-0.3085758090019226,
-0.012753741815686226,
-0.41002410650253296,
-0.14068879187107086,
0.8064199090003967,
0.45594435930252075,
0.2524445056915283,
-0.5033959150314331,
-0.5272943377494812,
0.3011956810951233,
-0.8729689121246338,
0.3938761353492737,
0.22697383165359497,
0.5487472414970398,
-0.01980631984770298,
0.6257312893867493,
-0.20197342336177826,
0.6347351670265198,
0.23110613226890564,
-0.0721539855003357,
0.1773436963558197,
-0.3899984359741211,
-0.43132397532463074,
0.20656214654445648,
0.768403947353363,
0.5950383543968201,
-0.0502256378531456,
0.16250012814998627,
-0.13400746881961823,
0.4642154574394226,
0.30046117305755615,
-0.5452589392662048,
0.07253479957580566,
0.2777957320213318,
-0.6903870701789856,
-0.5974127650260925,
0.14534741640090942,
-0.731513261795044,
-0.678469181060791,
-0.6509270668029785,
0.6041164398193359,
0.18152257800102234,
-0.15218909084796906,
0.06108466908335686,
-0.43100807070732117,
0.34247392416000366,
0.23777414858341217,
-0.482184499502182,
0.20590351521968842,
0.5590870380401611,
0.6785010099411011,
-0.13856054842472076,
-0.1438441276550293,
-0.4067133963108063,
-0.17505362629890442,
-0.4431383013725281,
1.0855610370635986,
-0.255037784576416,
-0.6141480803489685,
0.022490039467811584,
-0.00702153192833066,
-0.17814935743808746,
-0.25244349241256714,
0.7932320237159729,
-0.6041631102561951,
0.22795096039772034,
-1.05868399143219,
-0.43168342113494873,
-0.47566869854927063,
0.2951802909374237,
-0.6824489831924438,
0.9466820359230042,
-0.12839776277542114,
-0.8776833415031433,
0.657742440700531,
-0.596496045589447,
-0.6901222467422485,
-0.4523448944091797,
0.16216082870960236,
-0.4182305932044983,
0.4581981897354126,
0.19665569067001343,
0.5690025091171265,
-0.8481776714324951,
0.4215208888053894,
-0.5081036686897278,
-0.47386252880096436,
0.399042546749115,
-0.25401437282562256,
0.9839017391204834,
0.2103695571422577,
-0.6671683192253113,
0.20007063448429108,
-0.6760457158088684,
-0.6253291368484497,
0.0015726141864433885,
0.030017388984560966,
-0.44488897919654846,
0.1624467521905899,
-0.07911577820777893,
0.21541520953178406,
0.033676113933324814,
-0.650896430015564,
0.15374988317489624,
-0.28798073530197144,
-0.13140088319778442,
0.8804451823234558,
0.5985225439071655,
0.2715185582637787,
-0.12996244430541992,
0.4072181284427643,
0.14535529911518097,
0.5598861575126648,
-0.027716124430298805,
-0.470714271068573,
-0.9358389377593994,
-0.24959059059619904,
-0.14225031435489655,
0.4083753824234009,
-0.09653938561677933,
0.3932429254055023,
-0.07058218121528625,
-0.5017273426055908,
-0.12184621393680573,
-0.002267258707433939,
0.2817946672439575,
0.6391868591308594,
0.33013615012168884,
-0.1947793960571289,
-0.55247962474823,
-0.7725332975387573,
-0.597901463508606,
-0.3901008665561676,
0.35969823598861694,
0.0586334727704525,
0.20707497000694275,
-0.19018276035785675,
0.867648184299469,
-0.8989479541778564,
-0.4688915014266968,
-0.2568286061286926,
0.4696367084980011,
0.4996187388896942,
0.057950228452682495,
0.42179426550865173,
-0.6356448531150818,
-0.2789488136768341,
-0.42365381121635437,
-1.0613458156585693,
-0.519798755645752,
-0.20240242779254913,
-0.09483973681926727,
0.07282429933547974,
0.6701961159706116,
-0.5355662107467651,
0.3905835747718811,
-0.012611922807991505,
-0.3918640613555908,
0.7687538266181946,
0.3603135943412781,
0.19449803233146667,
-0.698062539100647,
0.1211116835474968,
0.5204415917396545,
0.5484265089035034,
-0.6480215787887573,
-0.1853763908147812,
-0.3621748983860016,
-0.13347025215625763,
-0.3150078356266022,
0.22428454458713531,
-0.34768083691596985,
0.0596858449280262,
-0.46475788950920105,
-0.07027556002140045,
-0.054314374923706055,
0.5425622463226318,
-0.33093300461769104,
0.4792388379573822,
0.6582602262496948,
-0.6396008729934692,
0.0688343346118927,
-0.1355397254228592,
0.00035174383083358407,
0.7829194068908691,
-0.7479475140571594,
-0.267773300409317,
-0.527099609375,
0.1948394626379013,
-1.472342848777771,
0.02412986010313034,
0.3360374867916107,
-0.5672764778137207,
0.11930554360151291,
0.13164740800857544,
-0.4220370352268219,
-0.25489524006843567,
-0.44588595628738403,
0.05435889586806297,
0.4913245737552643,
-0.6193256974220276,
0.6809664964675903,
0.22895345091819763,
0.04584725201129913,
-0.5768336057662964,
-0.32065701484680176,
-0.10369228571653366,
-0.33511975407600403,
-0.36608973145484924,
-0.009979434311389923,
0.14830929040908813,
-0.5504686236381531,
-0.0037148890551179647,
-0.2326529175043106,
0.46295955777168274,
0.030819188803434372,
0.5496974587440491,
0.35871681571006775,
0.010583358816802502,
0.2975577414035797,
0.2032332569360733,
-0.46458205580711365,
0.7498003244400024,
0.029154755175113678,
0.25505346059799194,
0.07893698662519455,
-0.049521785229444504,
-0.3839620053768158,
0.20799465477466583,
0.7541636228561401,
0.011246992275118828,
0.5390265583992004,
0.5685365796089172,
-0.06324559450149536,
-0.17427635192871094,
-0.5497462749481201,
-0.08906514197587967,
-0.3753688633441925,
-0.11455447971820831,
-0.2590137720108032,
-0.5436847805976868,
0.3928956091403961,
-0.07465928047895432,
-0.22679008543491364,
0.9005652070045471,
0.5169029235839844,
-0.15054486691951752,
1.265198826789856,
0.8281705975532532,
-0.5201083421707153,
0.3801584243774414,
-0.13225306570529938,
0.6877155303955078,
-0.7995001077651978,
-0.4377308487892151,
-0.5532498955726624,
-0.28941118717193604,
-0.5589239597320557,
-0.025559909641742706,
0.6902087330818176,
0.17848671972751617,
-0.4154353737831116,
0.037643298506736755,
-0.3921476900577545,
0.19902345538139343,
0.7184988856315613,
0.2827279567718506,
0.12313982844352722,
-0.07590509951114655,
-0.08925772458314896,
0.02041846513748169,
-0.4558950364589691,
-0.18425139784812927,
1.050308346748352,
0.28998324275016785,
0.676398754119873,
-0.07434285432100296,
0.6389522552490234,
0.3567776083946228,
0.48077645897865295,
-0.9160138964653015,
0.739582359790802,
0.04880582541227341,
-0.6577725410461426,
-0.043141137808561325,
-0.10367295145988464,
-0.6492844820022583,
0.2394796907901764,
-0.38613519072532654,
-0.4520869553089142,
0.5153291821479797,
-0.0372517853975296,
-0.07700420171022415,
-0.16930538415908813,
-0.5424965023994446,
0.6184404492378235,
-0.0530560165643692,
-0.6565310955047607,
-0.5206879377365112,
-0.6787860989570618,
0.699859082698822,
0.18641357123851776,
0.22175189852714539,
-0.27495884895324707,
0.3853270709514618,
0.9176780581474304,
-0.3594765365123749,
1.3409194946289062,
-0.5432301163673401,
0.039452433586120605,
0.5651481747627258,
-0.02142682857811451,
0.29580989480018616,
-0.13208571076393127,
0.08409314602613449,
0.05564161390066147,
-0.2852262556552887,
-0.37748444080352783,
-0.8962193727493286,
0.6279957294464111,
-0.6827811598777771,
-0.8095040917396545,
-0.6091082096099854,
-0.23611924052238464,
-0.2261323630809784,
-0.03572060540318489,
0.2749350666999817,
0.3686831593513489,
-0.2034064680337906,
-0.18165358901023865,
0.418574720621109,
-0.11950653791427612,
0.33076611161231995,
0.4172219932079315,
-0.08349652588367462,
-0.30286186933517456,
0.7909150123596191,
-0.01988837867975235,
0.04628871753811836,
0.315756618976593,
0.6300424933433533,
-0.3487384021282196,
-0.2891828417778015,
0.04198792949318886,
0.340186208486557,
-0.8933016657829285,
-0.2211543321609497,
-0.5201795697212219,
0.16459478437900543,
-0.3336564302444458,
-0.0214178916066885,
0.040192194283008575,
-0.10653543472290039,
-0.34026774764060974,
-0.3739846348762512,
0.3855169117450714,
0.8327261805534363,
-0.26083919405937195,
0.23974557220935822,
-0.5513871312141418,
0.2591172456741333,
0.19917882978916168,
0.03866036981344223,
0.2975206673145294,
-0.19065769016742706,
-0.12540729343891144,
-0.3558581471443176,
-0.2321271449327469,
-1.1094447374343872,
0.30843067169189453,
-0.2081996649503708,
0.4546838104724884,
0.8223744630813599,
0.13435935974121094,
0.6557121276855469,
-0.10648005455732346,
1.0060571432113647,
0.463544636964798,
-0.8466095924377441,
0.7030749320983887,
-0.4210836887359619,
-0.015673067420721054,
0.46655526757240295,
0.7963401079177856,
-0.3509290814399719,
-0.41740065813064575,
-0.4975520670413971,
-0.7452906370162964,
0.14471961557865143,
-0.14746777713298798,
-0.06831111758947372,
-0.4028782546520233,
0.43406617641448975,
0.08414649218320847,
0.1277797967195511,
-0.6699317693710327,
-0.335896760225296,
-0.015565166249871254,
-0.1455390602350235,
-0.3878490924835205,
-0.6039714217185974,
-0.18196293711662292,
-0.2901342511177063,
0.6667568683624268,
-0.07004702836275101,
0.4593973755836487,
0.44670888781547546,
-0.009237924590706825,
-0.46890583634376526,
0.14469166100025177,
0.3749430179595947,
0.3563331365585327,
-0.23948952555656433,
0.21753698587417603,
-0.07666797190904617,
-0.2086936980485916,
0.06762736290693283,
-0.13563548028469086,
-0.37013378739356995,
-0.18467062711715698,
0.5235307216644287,
0.6534205079078674,
0.2832375764846802,
-0.30319705605506897,
0.6152243614196777,
0.2055722326040268,
-0.015389060601592064,
-0.1925714910030365,
-0.052323125302791595,
-0.30666255950927734,
0.24673019349575043,
0.53486168384552,
0.20590908825397491,
0.6406439542770386,
-0.7325910925865173,
0.00866073090583086,
0.5894157886505127,
-0.700307309627533,
-0.49373096227645874,
0.6509004831314087,
0.08940739184617996,
0.07392629981040955,
0.4473857879638672,
-0.26517561078071594,
-0.8177472949028015,
0.5615349411964417,
0.42564353346824646,
1.111009120941162,
0.11929916590452194,
0.233924999833107,
0.7303909659385681,
0.22100113332271576,
0.021252794191241264,
0.47234517335891724,
0.10129160434007645,
-0.6301642060279846,
-0.4994833171367645,
-0.640178918838501,
-0.26636794209480286,
-0.2922822833061218,
-0.8889477252960205,
0.4515385925769806,
-0.2423645704984665,
-0.20617704093456268,
0.04896777123212814,
0.019185861572623253,
-0.32944998145103455,
0.7108250856399536,
-0.1590714454650879,
0.627708375453949,
-1.381547212600708,
0.19011767208576202,
0.16092897951602936,
-0.8449134230613708,
-0.7525658011436462,
0.050551097840070724,
0.3648878037929535,
-0.5673515796661377,
0.9696502089500427,
0.26043960452079773,
-0.39818647503852844,
-0.3558741807937622,
-0.7561693787574768,
-0.7154126167297363,
0.8239250779151917,
-0.17410652339458466,
-0.2629346251487732,
0.3627466857433319,
-0.20648297667503357,
0.7609236240386963,
-0.21411128342151642,
0.0411137230694294,
0.587638795375824,
0.37356165051460266,
-0.022282756865024567,
-0.36028599739074707,
0.3704652786254883,
-0.4505351185798645,
-0.22430798411369324,
0.18450190126895905,
-0.5537397861480713,
0.7203708291053772,
-0.4126242995262146,
-0.10688181221485138,
-0.28669273853302,
0.7105947732925415,
0.24521993100643158,
0.6050500273704529,
0.6103979349136353,
0.4162503182888031,
0.639910876750946,
-0.12302163988351822,
1.2502566576004028,
-0.3769606053829193,
0.42573603987693787,
0.6269791126251221,
-0.37056058645248413,
0.7292416095733643,
0.5791659951210022,
-0.2779516279697418,
0.7074877619743347,
0.715310275554657,
-0.17111775279045105,
0.5559324026107788,
0.22631631791591644,
-0.36815178394317627,
-0.11686130613088608,
-0.2647874653339386,
-0.10913711041212082,
0.24763625860214233,
0.31947022676467896,
-0.32997286319732666,
-0.0386582650244236,
-0.09198348224163055,
0.04880344867706299,
-0.10569692403078079,
-0.6727388501167297,
0.7528278827667236,
0.16905473172664642,
-0.7832103371620178,
0.2578223645687103,
-0.1224379613995552,
0.5234408378601074,
-0.32808396220207214,
0.18728157877922058,
-0.2597028911113739,
0.19617959856987,
-0.37878796458244324,
-0.48606598377227783,
0.4809424877166748,
-0.27593445777893066,
-0.33130478858947754,
0.011304999701678753,
0.9634751081466675,
0.12526342272758484,
-0.5249221324920654,
0.4653753936290741,
0.4877370297908783,
-0.10898210853338242,
-0.07209066301584244,
-0.4304409325122833,
0.10182523727416992,
-0.1963811218738556,
-0.34975549578666687,
0.21052470803260803,
0.11612432450056076,
-0.09525797516107559,
0.3259991705417633,
0.9144530296325684,
-0.06327488273382187,
-0.11524948477745056,
0.35438480973243713,
0.7424848675727844,
-0.9846624732017517,
-0.6066312193870544,
-1.023569107055664,
0.3625926077365875,
-0.02738313563168049,
-0.3698784410953522,
0.9883508086204529,
0.43508586287498474,
0.32539552450180054,
-0.2715494930744171,
0.7299639582633972,
0.10204996168613434,
0.48549818992614746,
-0.5147553086280823,
0.5341213345527649,
-0.4626672565937042,
0.22937501966953278,
-0.5386145114898682,
-0.941547691822052,
-0.7405254244804382,
0.3186776638031006,
-0.6991405487060547,
-0.112788125872612,
1.0059256553649902,
0.8499294519424438,
0.41356223821640015,
0.37919214367866516,
-0.018449954688549042,
0.30998221039772034,
0.20332936942577362,
0.18191887438297272,
0.9603399634361267,
-0.3554050028324127,
0.1198730617761612,
-0.14396008849143982,
-0.3021295666694641,
-0.11540960520505905,
-0.7618020176887512,
-0.9168355464935303,
-0.36771443486213684,
-0.32962194085121155,
-0.6352006196975708,
-0.0362110435962677,
0.7567858099937439,
0.21946045756340027,
-0.6730968356132507,
-0.36801809072494507,
-0.3745219111442566,
0.22127674520015717,
-0.571725070476532,
-0.2853432893753052,
0.4908059537410736,
-0.8909119963645935,
-0.35571029782295227,
0.18505601584911346,
0.43371808528900146,
-0.3655337691307068,
-0.232718825340271,
0.2566765546798706,
0.02014625258743763,
0.3259471356868744,
0.9821175336837769,
0.13618437945842743,
-0.657153844833374,
-0.22364701330661774,
0.22925513982772827,
0.08663229644298553,
-0.09605316817760468,
1.2287518978118896,
-0.5809962153434753,
0.3832704722881317,
0.6456598043441772,
0.36257508397102356,
0.38180261850357056,
-0.06465090066194534,
0.6090706586837769,
-0.39513665437698364,
-0.16200491786003113,
-0.1544455736875534,
0.41824132204055786,
0.028277629986405373,
-0.5552066564559937,
0.46880993247032166,
0.5719022154808044,
-0.36976778507232666,
-0.8009053468704224,
0.2862401604652405,
-1.3495111465454102,
-0.4042613208293915,
1.1547867059707642,
0.11216531693935394,
-0.3251025378704071,
0.004109404515475035,
-0.42158272862434387,
0.18803346157073975,
-0.14799213409423828,
0.9561190605163574,
0.3969411849975586,
-0.5480622053146362,
0.04841426759958267,
-0.14372728765010834,
0.31989791989326477,
0.3642927408218384,
-0.6552940607070923,
-0.040818892419338226,
0.5973819494247437,
0.2094217985868454,
0.25678005814552307,
0.6925893425941467,
-0.2119007110595703,
0.35211142897605896,
-0.04372566193342209,
-0.04859241098165512,
0.2855234146118164,
-0.4237920045852661,
-0.561306893825531,
0.47269928455352783,
0.013047873973846436,
-0.09215694665908813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11049v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11049v2
|
Stepwise Alignment for Constrained Language Model Policy Optimization
| 2024-04-17T03:44:58 | 2024-05-23T01:13:41 |
Akifumi Wachi, Thien Q. Tran, Rei Sato, Takumi Tanabe, Youhei Akimoto
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Safety and trustworthiness are indispensable requirements for real-world
applications of AI systems using large language models (LLMs). This paper
formulates human value alignment as an optimization problem of the language
model policy to maximize reward under a safety constraint, and then proposes an
algorithm, Stepwise Alignment for Constrained Policy Optimization (SACPO). One
key idea behind SACPO, supported by theory, is that the optimal policy
incorporating reward and safety can be directly obtained from a reward-aligned
policy. Building on this key idea, SACPO aligns LLMs step-wise with each metric
while leveraging simple yet powerful alignment algorithms such as direct
preference optimization (DPO). SACPO offers several advantages, including
simplicity, stability, computational efficiency, and flexibility of algorithms
and datasets. Under mild assumptions, our theoretical analysis provides the
upper bounds on optimality and safety constraint violation. Our experimental
results show that SACPO can fine-tune Alpaca-7B better than the
state-of-the-art method in terms of both helpfulness and harmlessness.
|
[
-0.010382317006587982,
-0.09515636414289474,
0.6759357452392578,
0.2799914479255676,
-0.15191826224327087,
0.24066242575645447,
-0.005442803259938955,
-0.540252685546875,
-0.09082674235105515,
0.6362615823745728,
-0.716249406337738,
-0.39118337631225586,
-0.6120581030845642,
-0.09327542781829834,
0.08655830472707748,
0.800202488899231,
-0.1245298758149147,
-0.1341227889060974,
-0.08732356876134872,
-0.08780036121606827,
-0.590601921081543,
-0.22105960547924042,
-0.6781244277954102,
-0.4553561508655548,
0.3990006744861603,
0.45533671975135803,
1.0112007856369019,
1.1835390329360962,
0.5386806726455688,
0.31141823530197144,
-0.19884981215000153,
0.2112722396850586,
-0.30592721700668335,
-0.08021418005228043,
-0.27227452397346497,
-0.3378284275531769,
-0.5319765210151672,
0.06435386836528778,
0.42908111214637756,
0.35073143243789673,
-0.26126399636268616,
-0.2629733681678772,
0.057668473571538925,
0.664417028427124,
-0.7666915655136108,
-0.09789934754371643,
-0.5649583339691162,
-0.11903207004070282,
0.19548484683036804,
-0.1908547282218933,
-0.2820323705673218,
-0.8680079579353333,
0.073171466588974,
-0.6183170676231384,
-0.46473148465156555,
0.18572700023651123,
1.0775800943374634,
0.7699282169342041,
-0.40819019079208374,
-0.2877088785171509,
-0.5155342221260071,
1.0725960731506348,
-0.564777672290802,
0.4089234173297882,
0.3663768172264099,
0.07228030264377594,
-0.47771981358528137,
0.2197856307029724,
-0.7077028155326843,
-0.3107450008392334,
-0.06448587775230408,
-0.2674699127674103,
-0.025496462360024452,
0.24518732726573944,
-0.07484180480241776,
-0.013334786519408226,
-0.401419997215271,
0.49637970328330994,
-0.18487659096717834,
-0.48006466031074524,
0.7699685096740723,
0.19005268812179565,
0.251425176858902,
-0.1031636968255043,
-0.735944926738739,
-0.3795401453971863,
-0.7983428835868835,
0.3822771906852722,
0.6247557997703552,
0.5121791958808899,
0.024490537121891975,
0.3750825524330139,
-0.2178283929824829,
0.7285179495811462,
-0.031828124076128006,
-0.5914191603660583,
0.3503425717353821,
-0.34975409507751465,
0.02802407741546631,
0.3476323187351227,
0.8382079005241394,
0.4461429715156555,
0.3098965883255005,
-0.0503118634223938,
-0.158225417137146,
0.0023499520029872656,
0.4815444350242615,
-0.4064478874206543,
0.46563178300857544,
0.28658807277679443,
-0.1691664457321167,
-0.9647402763366699,
-0.12660741806030273,
-0.6651695966720581,
-0.41928136348724365,
-0.4275205433368683,
0.2869022786617279,
-0.3939809799194336,
-0.026572635397315025,
0.15614743530750275,
0.31303876638412476,
0.4698695242404938,
0.1161801889538765,
-1.1840198040008545,
0.22493082284927368,
0.9849603176116943,
0.7192720770835876,
-0.4281051456928253,
-0.5385671854019165,
-0.7389894723892212,
0.38357338309288025,
-0.5378823280334473,
0.4537366032600403,
-0.520539402961731,
-0.3383830487728119,
0.05805731192231178,
-0.045235924422740936,
-0.02518792822957039,
-0.30311912298202515,
0.9988941550254822,
-0.41166016459465027,
-0.31365737318992615,
-0.255464643239975,
-0.35163021087646484,
0.07180698961019516,
0.43302759528160095,
-0.5240541100502014,
0.9252496361732483,
-0.06339816749095917,
-0.40129759907722473,
0.4871620237827301,
-0.5763623714447021,
-0.5242539048194885,
-0.3892649710178375,
-0.1886710673570633,
-0.34280896186828613,
-0.16437910497188568,
0.13122911751270294,
0.21349726617336273,
-0.23956802487373352,
0.37004920840263367,
-0.20308387279510498,
-0.33055004477500916,
0.2310042679309845,
-0.23204927146434784,
0.7951918244361877,
0.20788289606571198,
-0.3161734938621521,
0.34591424465179443,
-0.7251492738723755,
0.05965796858072281,
0.10873785614967346,
-0.5039389133453369,
-0.6279779672622681,
0.20270800590515137,
-0.4415605664253235,
0.29385849833488464,
0.5255640745162964,
-0.5540174245834351,
0.3692474365234375,
-0.3975101411342621,
0.38599270582199097,
1.2204277515411377,
-0.3286585211753845,
0.7380014061927795,
-0.10323826968669891,
0.4867502748966217,
-0.14315590262413025,
0.6228359341621399,
0.41279637813568115,
-0.06428772956132889,
-0.3573927879333496,
-0.23992279171943665,
0.27579379081726074,
0.8574572801589966,
-0.14727568626403809,
0.9964011907577515,
-0.17960113286972046,
-0.18210051953792572,
-0.8469880223274231,
0.0962301716208458,
0.5283778309822083,
0.7625192403793335,
0.3802046775817871,
-0.0798560082912445,
-0.2809513211250305,
-1.247983694076538,
-0.10023234784603119,
-0.43620240688323975,
0.18909308314323425,
0.1553535908460617,
0.11258357018232346,
-0.2751990258693695,
0.7860789895057678,
-0.6422721743583679,
-0.07532811164855957,
0.11051590740680695,
-0.07883306592702866,
-0.06874285638332367,
0.8213270306587219,
0.3187832832336426,
-0.7751062512397766,
-0.1485922932624817,
0.026315215975046158,
-0.22545947134494781,
-0.24693989753723145,
-0.05900650843977928,
-0.5385404229164124,
0.4108227789402008,
0.2535567283630371,
-0.37995293736457825,
0.2507348656654358,
0.7583007216453552,
-0.15984681248664856,
0.27410173416137695,
-0.14946691691875458,
0.2955778241157532,
-1.0307589769363403,
-0.047907207161188126,
-0.20974509418010712,
-0.2765224277973175,
-0.6192532181739807,
-0.026347342878580093,
0.151395782828331,
-0.06713021546602249,
-0.37588733434677124,
0.3852514326572418,
-0.2244536280632019,
0.057880476117134094,
-0.5267279148101807,
0.15371152758598328,
-0.15400511026382446,
0.454397588968277,
0.26286476850509644,
0.7262860536575317,
0.32395461201667786,
-0.6262878179550171,
-0.058470841497182846,
0.39419087767601013,
-0.1342441737651825,
0.659574031829834,
-0.48990511894226074,
0.17877821624279022,
0.2131151407957077,
0.18511031568050385,
-0.6240676045417786,
-0.14388024806976318,
0.23635578155517578,
-0.1921614557504654,
0.3417801558971405,
-0.05870916694402695,
-0.05468370020389557,
-0.08337809145450592,
-0.40802305936813354,
0.51043301820755,
0.4982580542564392,
-0.6065738201141357,
0.32501012086868286,
0.6575353741645813,
0.027444828301668167,
-1.2268235683441162,
-0.21982356905937195,
-0.16649574041366577,
-0.30278635025024414,
-0.42627325654029846,
0.49471235275268555,
0.015448536723852158,
-0.10667385905981064,
-0.1483246088027954,
-0.3253145217895508,
0.20343376696109772,
0.013390769250690937,
0.22940798103809357,
0.6075275540351868,
0.3488951325416565,
-0.07489282637834549,
0.3067988157272339,
-0.4763913154602051,
-0.17228347063064575,
-0.0386526957154274,
0.6399565935134888,
-0.2638160288333893,
-0.2407086342573166,
-0.45369672775268555,
0.31062808632850647,
0.5167357325553894,
0.004295309539884329,
0.45606401562690735,
0.1586577594280243,
-0.3366497755050659,
0.07021323591470718,
-0.42867740988731384,
0.1774991899728775,
-0.5220624208450317,
0.21767227351665497,
-0.2867511212825775,
-0.8183066248893738,
0.10461688786745071,
-0.16574408113956451,
0.17939747869968414,
0.3357899785041809,
0.3415258526802063,
0.07775381952524185,
1.1623740196228027,
0.8258020281791687,
-0.46268799901008606,
0.340720534324646,
0.2957569360733032,
0.12944859266281128,
-0.8139508962631226,
-0.39700770378112793,
-0.8714323043823242,
-0.25119152665138245,
-0.6978772282600403,
-0.289022296667099,
0.11930976808071136,
0.12698543071746826,
-0.5757015347480774,
0.718226432800293,
-0.7644241452217102,
0.5700029134750366,
0.5637863874435425,
0.10836704075336456,
0.24041905999183655,
-0.40945717692375183,
0.016043851152062416,
0.08580297976732254,
-0.4114922881126404,
-0.7444046139717102,
0.6898027062416077,
0.34007176756858826,
0.9213590025901794,
0.017373979091644287,
1.011080026626587,
0.128004789352417,
-0.03451574593782425,
-0.8609519004821777,
0.6312451362609863,
0.07515374571084976,
-0.3315579295158386,
-0.6215928792953491,
-0.25958961248397827,
-0.8767358660697937,
-0.04386679828166962,
-0.28839895129203796,
-0.9602968096733093,
0.4498639404773712,
0.5033981204032898,
-0.38643598556518555,
-0.06401339173316956,
-0.3722027838230133,
0.8509311676025391,
-0.6534592509269714,
-0.21396972239017487,
-0.3066374361515045,
-0.970379114151001,
0.29492291808128357,
0.06919799000024796,
0.12382999807596207,
-0.459075003862381,
-0.43448588252067566,
0.515299379825592,
-0.6185584664344788,
0.586425244808197,
-0.01905113272368908,
-0.31581175327301025,
0.04280485585331917,
0.06403101980686188,
0.8993129134178162,
-0.3987334668636322,
-0.10134321451187134,
0.15618614852428436,
0.17723321914672852,
-0.5042123794555664,
-0.3280640244483948,
0.8308301568031311,
-0.8437471985816956,
-0.7289852499961853,
-0.5544417500495911,
-0.6532379388809204,
-0.5558909773826599,
0.26371559500694275,
0.027602992951869965,
-0.2212805151939392,
-0.2208489179611206,
-0.17907613515853882,
0.6451382040977478,
-0.12399957329034805,
0.4359610080718994,
0.32615163922309875,
0.06548971682786942,
-0.36094212532043457,
0.8365296125411987,
-0.24929840862751007,
0.5372376441955566,
0.46314671635627747,
0.45492926239967346,
-0.3875589966773987,
-0.4012526571750641,
-0.5930185914039612,
0.17476388812065125,
-0.48927566409111023,
-0.25409266352653503,
-0.1207885891199112,
-0.11242237687110901,
-0.34742671251296997,
-0.6718099117279053,
-0.6005271077156067,
-0.40639036893844604,
-0.05683371424674988,
-0.13891838490962982,
0.15795168280601501,
0.3380396068096161,
-0.29744160175323486,
0.03739626705646515,
-0.7392807602882385,
0.03988828510046005,
0.2546917796134949,
0.3550525903701782,
-0.2524973452091217,
-0.19220781326293945,
-0.08474072813987732,
-0.08867132663726807,
-0.3342032730579376,
-0.752093493938446,
0.06185787916183472,
-0.3002113997936249,
0.48901277780532837,
0.5707021951675415,
0.18126416206359863,
0.7922849655151367,
-0.5568179488182068,
0.3702920079231262,
0.3729953467845917,
-1.085317611694336,
0.6901963949203491,
-0.19453087449073792,
-0.09803878515958786,
1.081132411956787,
0.5193015933036804,
-0.45201677083969116,
-0.027224598452448845,
-0.3956775665283203,
-0.6955124735832214,
0.625740647315979,
0.17483831942081451,
0.05711207911372185,
0.12975220382213593,
0.32615458965301514,
0.12500566244125366,
0.12058199197053909,
-0.543986439704895,
0.14466360211372375,
0.06300868093967438,
-0.4270385801792145,
0.18294265866279602,
-0.11258640885353088,
-0.5751205682754517,
-0.014583670534193516,
0.9935128092765808,
-0.3105711340904236,
-0.07243455201387405,
-0.02074042335152626,
0.14140178263187408,
-0.2629624605178833,
0.35904690623283386,
1.0041255950927734,
0.6163148880004883,
-0.20896968245506287,
-0.04080168530344963,
0.04536459967494011,
-0.417915403842926,
0.6413335204124451,
-0.01631065644323826,
-0.3581838011741638,
-0.6412046551704407,
0.08649542182683945,
0.7847720384597778,
0.20152907073497772,
-0.769761860370636,
0.5325617790222168,
0.23096045851707458,
-0.02247445099055767,
-0.03540539741516113,
0.5127125978469849,
-0.08098532259464264,
0.3384757339954376,
0.14575371146202087,
0.029581177979707718,
-0.07242954522371292,
-0.451016902923584,
-0.023928022012114525,
0.6867945194244385,
-0.5065304040908813,
0.02011442743241787,
0.6542721390724182,
0.3049355149269104,
-0.7458128929138184,
0.3015104830265045,
0.10275708138942719,
-0.5537087321281433,
0.5704089403152466,
0.6465076208114624,
0.9199249148368835,
-0.28738290071487427,
0.20534780621528625,
0.274269700050354,
0.6139459609985352,
-0.3787146508693695,
0.06439269334077835,
-0.05865753814578056,
-1.140263557434082,
-0.2898850440979004,
-0.7587270736694336,
-0.7649695873260498,
-0.10375990718603134,
-0.6438815593719482,
0.3235795199871063,
-0.35263389348983765,
0.04357532411813736,
-0.26030200719833374,
-0.11038285493850708,
-0.27511849999427795,
0.28125619888305664,
0.022876860573887825,
0.6509203910827637,
-0.879635214805603,
0.8856769800186157,
0.3010531961917877,
-0.2896577715873718,
-1.132422924041748,
0.21184571087360382,
0.10188975930213928,
-1.1431502103805542,
0.26795896887779236,
0.014742360450327396,
-0.527969479560852,
-0.29573854804039,
-0.5400335192680359,
-1.1313202381134033,
1.1758337020874023,
0.4931199848651886,
-0.7473054528236389,
-0.0847766250371933,
0.16546939313411713,
0.28484010696411133,
-0.5181191563606262,
-0.5451062917709351,
0.8544853329658508,
0.6289655566215515,
0.30073755979537964,
-0.8954011797904968,
0.3968442678451538,
0.23409931361675262,
0.14316920936107635,
0.6000179052352905,
-0.9667966365814209,
0.09898094087839127,
-0.23657186329364777,
0.22893671691417694,
0.0002622729225549847,
0.5834054946899414,
0.7098765969276428,
0.18895408511161804,
0.9702819585800171,
0.6500645279884338,
0.8754208087921143,
-0.018916016444563866,
0.8693474531173706,
-0.20812878012657166,
0.17109373211860657,
0.9689965844154358,
-0.3567808270454407,
0.8039059042930603,
0.7669596672058105,
-0.2708386182785034,
0.3933814465999603,
0.9040747880935669,
0.40463757514953613,
0.7210567593574524,
0.018419252708554268,
-0.09869708865880966,
-0.2749364674091339,
-0.06640297919511795,
-0.14323142170906067,
0.6076807379722595,
-0.12408910691738129,
-0.28472617268562317,
0.24014408886432648,
-0.3751649558544159,
0.29874929785728455,
-0.025635624304413795,
-0.3368518054485321,
0.6924340128898621,
-0.11026666313409805,
-1.006160855293274,
0.633355438709259,
-0.12530766427516937,
0.5018645524978638,
-0.6359545588493347,
0.08573991060256958,
0.016120750457048416,
0.17179124057292938,
-0.25427335500717163,
-0.6223477125167847,
0.353247731924057,
-0.10624851286411285,
0.007119087968021631,
-0.16305603086948395,
0.6164501309394836,
-0.36136940121650696,
-0.28605249524116516,
0.2007659524679184,
-0.12901422381401062,
-0.027637669816613197,
0.4918721318244934,
-0.7389649748802185,
0.2564855217933655,
0.038200221955776215,
-0.23259811103343964,
0.5082733631134033,
-0.03987118601799011,
-0.317290723323822,
0.667394757270813,
0.46633538603782654,
0.21273985505104065,
-0.26486578583717346,
-0.23720736801624298,
0.6249548196792603,
-0.6195366382598877,
-0.6570231914520264,
-0.9784709215164185,
0.4671357572078705,
-0.19879280030727386,
-0.28909048438072205,
0.18735532462596893,
0.45580074191093445,
0.661096453666687,
0.31397154927253723,
0.6562703251838684,
0.0009554197895340621,
0.17517833411693573,
-0.7087476849555969,
0.4837345778942108,
-0.5800871849060059,
0.15078964829444885,
-0.5089359879493713,
-0.8370387554168701,
-0.248038649559021,
0.7500491142272949,
-0.1814093142747879,
-0.2869683504104614,
0.5697331428527832,
0.9575135111808777,
0.1568855494260788,
-0.19309309124946594,
0.19887332618236542,
-0.2538880705833435,
0.20260176062583923,
0.5760311484336853,
0.5220825672149658,
-0.07823357731103897,
0.6088583469390869,
-0.3732392489910126,
-0.45489829778671265,
-0.07340344041585922,
-1.3888978958129883,
-0.3766367435455322,
-0.6004418134689331,
-0.24653513729572296,
-0.4423939287662506,
0.055414311587810516,
1.261146903038025,
0.6993575692176819,
-0.7821382284164429,
-0.2932155430316925,
-0.10737054795026779,
0.44880014657974243,
-0.44694414734840393,
-0.16872411966323853,
0.42037782073020935,
-0.22005757689476013,
-0.949230968952179,
0.609824538230896,
0.5146629214286804,
0.11329231411218643,
-0.1882762759923935,
-0.5338095426559448,
-0.30444273352622986,
0.526085615158081,
0.31514638662338257,
0.5658555626869202,
-0.691245436668396,
-0.8166273832321167,
-0.16847099363803864,
-0.3282313048839569,
0.19369260966777802,
0.7886896729469299,
-0.28192976117134094,
0.2180853933095932,
0.4162599742412567,
0.847562849521637,
0.20918339490890503,
0.44135236740112305,
0.6558573246002197,
-0.43984389305114746,
0.2286626100540161,
0.2834181487560272,
0.3556591868400574,
0.218601793050766,
-0.6634793877601624,
0.7423667311668396,
-0.17682763934135437,
-0.8400508165359497,
-0.9359391331672668,
0.5033276081085205,
-1.2376418113708496,
-0.0250052809715271,
1.0806384086608887,
0.14847776293754578,
-0.3489806056022644,
0.2294786274433136,
-0.2748672366142273,
0.2114820033311844,
-0.5887070298194885,
0.9571046233177185,
0.7053660154342651,
-0.5598231554031372,
0.05270449072122574,
-0.006623477209359407,
0.6650004982948303,
0.46473929286003113,
-0.897524356842041,
0.01025474350899458,
0.5103323459625244,
0.18250827491283417,
0.2607291638851166,
0.7022094130516052,
-0.08922430127859116,
0.1908801943063736,
-0.3529251515865326,
0.13894431293010712,
0.002294651698321104,
-0.3970954716205597,
-0.40442949533462524,
0.06056860834360123,
0.23316887021064758,
-0.5633031725883484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11045v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11045v1
|
Offset Unlearning for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-17T03:39:51 | 2024-04-17T03:39:51 |
James Y. Huang, Wenxuan Zhou, Fei Wang, Fred Morstatter, Sheng Zhang, Hoifung Poon, Muhao Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the strong capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) to acquire
knowledge from their training corpora, the memorization of sensitive
information in the corpora such as copyrighted, harmful, and private content
has led to ethical and legal concerns. In response to these challenges,
unlearning has emerged as a potential remedy for LLMs affected by problematic
training data. However, previous unlearning techniques are either not
applicable to black-box LLMs due to required access to model internal weights,
or violate data protection principles by retaining sensitive data for
inference-time correction. We propose $\delta$-unlearning, an offset unlearning
framework for black-box LLMs. Instead of tuning the black-box LLM itself,
$\delta$-unlearning learns the logit offset needed for unlearning by
contrasting the logits from a pair of smaller models. Experiments demonstrate
that $\delta$-unlearning can effectively unlearn target data while maintaining
similar or even stronger performance on general out-of-forget-scope tasks.
$\delta$-unlearning also effectively incorporates different unlearning
algorithms, making our approach a versatile solution to adapting various
existing unlearning algorithms to black-box LLMs.
|
[
-0.06932990998029709,
-0.5127630829811096,
0.23738758265972137,
0.03067106381058693,
-0.4678409695625305,
0.4085516631603241,
-0.5098453164100647,
-0.38066691160202026,
-0.146154522895813,
0.6845181584358215,
-0.6121203303337097,
-0.39084765315055847,
-0.4087195098400116,
-0.34446054697036743,
-0.28648069500923157,
0.9146291017532349,
0.10198269784450531,
0.27726003527641296,
0.09587094932794571,
-0.3471691906452179,
-0.7445181608200073,
-0.5293276906013489,
-0.439431369304657,
-0.3257390856742859,
0.407330185174942,
0.6571888327598572,
0.4452328383922577,
0.8317205309867859,
-0.0009264980908483267,
0.20800335705280304,
-0.27294665575027466,
0.0901261642575264,
-0.7510281205177307,
0.11563292145729065,
-0.5110124349594116,
-0.5422083139419556,
-0.33610999584198,
-0.47512635588645935,
0.8029821515083313,
1.0103075504302979,
-0.2717345952987671,
0.06024360656738281,
0.12891057133674622,
0.8121261596679688,
-1.054947018623352,
-0.11701656132936478,
-0.7682563662528992,
0.014347784221172333,
-0.19563615322113037,
-0.24132248759269714,
-0.5332568287849426,
0.04160076379776001,
-0.1567612886428833,
-0.6283112168312073,
0.3340719938278198,
-0.17340058088302612,
0.5374502539634705,
0.21405993402004242,
-0.342576265335083,
-0.2562922239303589,
-0.9618340730667114,
1.1439450979232788,
-0.8383054137229919,
0.383878231048584,
0.3034469485282898,
0.3005850911140442,
-0.13351181149482727,
-0.5538655519485474,
-0.34493041038513184,
0.4519607722759247,
0.1616075336933136,
-0.061798568814992905,
-0.4672187268733978,
-0.2490154504776001,
0.2659742832183838,
0.41530290246009827,
-0.3032180964946747,
0.7463350892066956,
-0.6352105140686035,
-0.13343043625354767,
0.5403020977973938,
-0.10900082439184189,
-0.048956938087940216,
0.18351614475250244,
-0.21438995003700256,
-0.14592216908931732,
-1.1844892501831055,
-0.08520202338695526,
0.5897797346115112,
0.4514477849006653,
0.05640367791056633,
0.5529974699020386,
-0.15437321364879608,
0.3692285120487213,
0.25755423307418823,
0.21991926431655884,
0.35240447521209717,
0.10470721870660782,
-0.3084377348423004,
0.08183898776769638,
0.44353872537612915,
0.19169576466083527,
0.273075133562088,
-0.48297736048698425,
-0.3059391379356384,
-0.24760568141937256,
0.4123068153858185,
-0.7473827004432678,
-0.006466174032539129,
0.321857750415802,
-0.13671904802322388,
-0.016775326803326607,
-0.009558194316923618,
-0.9850404858589172,
-0.30620694160461426,
-0.4390336871147156,
0.4131987392902374,
-0.3746279776096344,
-0.20541167259216309,
0.014894485473632812,
0.0043147592805325985,
-0.0010783282341435552,
0.2359178066253662,
-0.8949217796325684,
0.028202764689922333,
0.7990506291389465,
0.6993042826652527,
-0.07931314408779144,
-0.1882036328315735,
-0.7010377049446106,
0.28190022706985474,
-0.32935357093811035,
0.29943475127220154,
-0.5208486914634705,
-0.44463086128234863,
0.2551901936531067,
0.2694753110408783,
0.31283682584762573,
-0.4967099130153656,
0.4024854600429535,
-0.8391457796096802,
0.27319687604904175,
-0.267374724149704,
-0.9040738940238953,
-0.23590238392353058,
-0.30699846148490906,
-0.5974623560905457,
0.8572924137115479,
-0.0029835901223123074,
-0.6608768105506897,
0.38284480571746826,
-0.37508058547973633,
-0.21274849772453308,
0.17439521849155426,
-0.07799755781888962,
-0.7134602069854736,
0.27532267570495605,
0.1718735247850418,
0.3901529908180237,
-0.014688447117805481,
0.14309711754322052,
-0.5649257302284241,
-0.41238030791282654,
0.0834449827671051,
-0.42312344908714294,
1.1920583248138428,
0.20561186969280243,
-0.35423898696899414,
-0.030828673392534256,
-0.7554788589477539,
0.07311134785413742,
0.018208961933851242,
-0.21590881049633026,
-0.8027428388595581,
-0.043349843472242355,
-0.21194438636302948,
0.02981746383011341,
0.16100671887397766,
-0.670025110244751,
0.2382902354001999,
-0.22365747392177582,
0.34699755907058716,
1.0153487920761108,
0.09907977283000946,
0.7917637228965759,
-0.36749640107154846,
0.4540255665779114,
-0.10212118178606033,
-0.2128666192293167,
-0.20487256348133087,
0.03697698563337326,
-0.6658602952957153,
-0.4768085777759552,
0.30649396777153015,
0.38181179761886597,
-0.4395831227302551,
0.6908161044120789,
-0.291189044713974,
-0.37364786863327026,
-0.6687870025634766,
0.5720852017402649,
0.7008857131004333,
0.4620731472969055,
0.46835026144981384,
-0.5256293416023254,
-0.5078721642494202,
-0.6450749635696411,
-0.11722542345523834,
0.2538788616657257,
-0.17330129444599152,
0.0029211773071438074,
0.4737743139266968,
-0.12547196447849274,
0.7689927220344543,
-0.447257399559021,
-0.4082874059677124,
0.1063774898648262,
0.27785709500312805,
-0.09819596260786057,
0.5963770747184753,
0.21523651480674744,
-0.7642998695373535,
-0.19978854060173035,
-0.10543876886367798,
-0.7986211776733398,
-0.09476558119058609,
0.014090687036514282,
-0.27208825945854187,
0.4206729531288147,
0.7768688797950745,
-0.551042377948761,
0.41216567158699036,
0.36588621139526367,
-0.17418153584003448,
0.6259390115737915,
-0.420764297246933,
-0.4005769193172455,
-1.1463432312011719,
0.22641289234161377,
-0.4867474436759949,
-0.17468278110027313,
-0.754931628704071,
0.013477307744324207,
0.47219789028167725,
0.3526113033294678,
-0.464191734790802,
0.6479694843292236,
-0.8775885701179504,
-0.18021881580352783,
-0.5145239233970642,
-0.19262783229351044,
-0.06419458240270615,
0.6657087206840515,
0.12664365768432617,
0.5451643466949463,
0.4101073741912842,
-0.60063636302948,
0.12564553320407867,
0.19565613567829132,
-0.3384263217449188,
0.6552958488464355,
-0.30543097853660583,
0.3727894425392151,
-0.2714708745479584,
0.17466972768306732,
-0.6723731756210327,
0.1115223839879036,
-0.16079972684383392,
-0.3045758306980133,
0.6529889106750488,
-0.4351392388343811,
-0.3842061460018158,
0.011124657467007637,
-0.356496661901474,
0.6583170294761658,
0.6441906094551086,
-0.8284991979598999,
0.24298115074634552,
0.4217868745326996,
-0.18799184262752533,
-1.2415255308151245,
-0.5406097769737244,
-0.19167083501815796,
-0.4132455587387085,
0.008627687580883503,
0.40755516290664673,
-0.09968205541372299,
-0.16393336653709412,
0.0682208240032196,
-0.2237519919872284,
-0.04910224303603172,
0.005551048554480076,
0.347796231508255,
0.25141218304634094,
-0.13485732674598694,
0.328968346118927,
0.12483062595129013,
0.0022578409407287836,
-0.04525049030780792,
-0.5665363669395447,
0.5214759111404419,
0.12011657655239105,
-0.43128979206085205,
0.1630031168460846,
0.3439147174358368,
0.4970196485519409,
-0.2272985875606537,
0.7660633325576782,
0.312019020318985,
-0.7436770796775818,
-0.4971062242984772,
-0.46357038617134094,
-0.12525884807109833,
-0.4592896103858948,
0.3940378725528717,
0.18172766268253326,
-0.8083832859992981,
0.4597241282463074,
-0.06356868892908096,
0.4784720540046692,
0.0995115265250206,
0.8470125794410706,
-0.1690177172422409,
0.4173189699649811,
0.9801477193832397,
-0.3186148405075073,
0.6197220683097839,
-0.18346917629241943,
-0.00197843206115067,
-0.9354316592216492,
-0.07678310573101044,
-0.3864271640777588,
-0.32788556814193726,
-0.4201064109802246,
-0.36292389035224915,
-0.1105552464723587,
0.5907928943634033,
-0.46097496151924133,
0.28416523337364197,
-0.18145565688610077,
0.7192491888999939,
0.6058204174041748,
0.15655440092086792,
0.5835060477256775,
0.32936838269233704,
-0.1530405580997467,
0.0849967747926712,
-0.4420139193534851,
-0.3067023456096649,
1.4740333557128906,
0.2825218439102173,
0.7460646629333496,
0.28931286931037903,
0.5039056539535522,
0.2810090482234955,
0.5116865038871765,
-0.4697105288505554,
0.18562577664852142,
-0.41152068972587585,
-0.7891358137130737,
-0.6495366096496582,
-0.6040284633636475,
-1.0710586309432983,
0.19838957488536835,
0.0036920011043548584,
-1.1183366775512695,
0.43197566270828247,
0.23974718153476715,
-0.13038457930088043,
0.7526616454124451,
-0.6401534080505371,
0.7287192344665527,
-0.14234216511249542,
-0.6755591630935669,
-0.14814113080501556,
-0.5874858498573303,
0.4246571958065033,
-0.6598181128501892,
0.3610219359397888,
-0.03689985349774361,
0.07081081718206406,
0.63333660364151,
-0.406343936920166,
1.2423312664031982,
-0.24648037552833557,
-0.32933589816093445,
-0.0993218719959259,
0.30984583497047424,
0.46821826696395874,
-0.06518450379371643,
0.046553079038858414,
0.196347177028656,
-0.19545666873455048,
-0.592186450958252,
-0.5029622912406921,
0.5822634100914001,
-0.6440043449401855,
-0.4039836823940277,
-0.2195509821176529,
-0.9708447456359863,
-0.28375571966171265,
0.5021765232086182,
0.4290045201778412,
0.08976371586322784,
-0.1684274971485138,
0.21354283392429352,
0.5905683040618896,
-0.11863444745540619,
0.6897030472755432,
1.0051041841506958,
-0.023352045565843582,
-0.23134684562683105,
0.8832040429115295,
0.0762060135602951,
0.46901723742485046,
0.7923644185066223,
-0.0286452267318964,
-0.45594272017478943,
-0.520954430103302,
-0.38473740220069885,
0.35338830947875977,
-0.7507689595222473,
-0.3658490777015686,
-0.24425803124904633,
-0.181240513920784,
-0.1895875632762909,
-0.31600746512413025,
-0.5906016826629639,
-0.47956275939941406,
-0.2611793875694275,
-0.17163655161857605,
0.27348849177360535,
0.4192705750465393,
-0.36092904210090637,
0.4830130338668823,
-0.656201958656311,
0.05584339052438736,
0.1407020390033722,
0.4664403796195984,
0.14546345174312592,
-1.032724380493164,
-0.2809762954711914,
0.34437093138694763,
-0.42518022656440735,
-0.532558262348175,
0.6123345494270325,
0.033372510224580765,
0.4201192557811737,
0.5078107118606567,
0.27429506182670593,
0.7597630620002747,
-0.49387356638908386,
0.12523357570171356,
0.22667525708675385,
-0.9508221745491028,
-0.035850830376148224,
-0.2630053460597992,
0.3847907483577728,
0.4384987950325012,
0.48032715916633606,
-0.6633756160736084,
-0.4857625961303711,
-0.5830209851264954,
-1.0825015306472778,
0.6230446696281433,
0.1272546350955963,
0.11614017933607101,
0.5814866423606873,
0.40736961364746094,
0.38139525055885315,
0.43718966841697693,
-0.6871181130409241,
-0.10884689539670944,
-0.008781245909631252,
-0.21379493176937103,
-0.5490493774414062,
-0.2554880976676941,
-0.1818242371082306,
0.007204926107078791,
0.6901262402534485,
-0.07492227852344513,
0.13772940635681152,
-0.31671321392059326,
-0.487100213766098,
-0.5660156607627869,
0.5445038676261902,
0.301404744386673,
0.8707463145256042,
-0.3987368047237396,
0.13777928054332733,
0.41706064343452454,
-0.3612847924232483,
0.2659168541431427,
0.0022714866790920496,
-0.47317028045654297,
-0.2548988163471222,
0.4276706278324127,
0.49052757024765015,
0.3637771010398865,
-0.7343986630439758,
0.4027431309223175,
0.18638066947460175,
0.023287395015358925,
-0.46257784962654114,
-0.18312640488147736,
0.2249736785888672,
0.21891988813877106,
0.4089416265487671,
-0.2812426686286926,
-0.26813244819641113,
-0.520783007144928,
0.5717963576316833,
0.5628625154495239,
-0.4296518564224243,
-0.2608453333377838,
0.5445857644081116,
-0.20468410849571228,
-0.3474705219268799,
0.738039493560791,
0.0033316772896796465,
-0.26035812497138977,
0.5109371542930603,
0.5825125575065613,
0.7244853377342224,
-0.5413660407066345,
-0.11763881146907806,
0.06020628660917282,
0.2084064930677414,
-0.2854527235031128,
-0.03373437747359276,
0.008695087395608425,
-0.8742477297782898,
-0.5918916463851929,
-0.4741690456867218,
-0.4545900225639343,
0.478879451751709,
-1.0990828275680542,
0.25394487380981445,
-0.4953573942184448,
0.3549067974090576,
0.07757502049207687,
-0.19532698392868042,
-0.574616551399231,
0.02404218167066574,
-0.008418132551014423,
0.8759057521820068,
-0.7689881920814514,
0.9558184146881104,
0.5026116371154785,
-0.27045416831970215,
-0.5094798803329468,
0.0406976081430912,
0.18585334718227386,
-0.9937117099761963,
0.41563037037849426,
0.15324948728084564,
0.08355292677879333,
-0.1265929788351059,
-0.45557552576065063,
-0.6088635921478271,
1.1032673120498657,
0.6878786683082581,
-1.0349537134170532,
-0.06929370015859604,
-0.02340943180024624,
0.5173586010932922,
-0.19903278350830078,
0.16440632939338684,
0.4676111340522766,
-0.12907271087169647,
0.021788744255900383,
-0.6583701968193054,
0.1760481745004654,
-0.07976596057415009,
-0.3035183846950531,
0.40535813570022583,
-0.6292263865470886,
0.7898321747779846,
-0.2377089411020279,
-0.21437174081802368,
-0.04618531093001366,
0.6027075052261353,
0.29016563296318054,
0.1903848946094513,
0.551719069480896,
0.5296886563301086,
1.087820053100586,
0.18462148308753967,
0.7175448536872864,
-0.06307143718004227,
0.3145139217376709,
1.3982809782028198,
-0.29032087326049805,
0.9071617126464844,
0.4351068139076233,
0.11400826275348663,
0.18252085149288177,
0.35600546002388,
0.02743488922715187,
0.580216646194458,
0.2865719497203827,
-0.34827104210853577,
-0.09306571632623672,
0.11373405158519745,
-0.2180771827697754,
0.37905317544937134,
0.39507314562797546,
-0.22086048126220703,
-0.4033786356449127,
-0.10808447748422623,
0.36156368255615234,
0.0036510371137410402,
-0.4107676148414612,
0.5959934592247009,
0.2517838180065155,
-0.6362693905830383,
0.653418779373169,
0.14131894707679749,
0.5614742636680603,
-0.557144045829773,
-0.0017846315167844296,
-0.45634785294532776,
0.6902098059654236,
-0.09141314029693604,
-0.5195066332817078,
0.22270914912223816,
0.20524072647094727,
-0.2556418180465698,
-0.26471319794654846,
0.24877707660198212,
-0.6932851076126099,
-0.5197840332984924,
0.6965402364730835,
0.4201158583164215,
0.044866256415843964,
-0.052368149161338806,
-0.45568007230758667,
-0.2624431252479553,
0.034169476479291916,
-0.06319665163755417,
0.7037363648414612,
0.6017670631408691,
-0.4207976758480072,
0.8214460611343384,
0.742131233215332,
0.15488168597221375,
0.11556847393512726,
-0.024944132193922997,
0.8816981911659241,
-0.6876476407051086,
-0.5768583416938782,
-0.8718936443328857,
0.3605378270149231,
0.12050671875476837,
-0.2535042464733124,
0.6161103248596191,
0.7118750810623169,
1.1281214952468872,
0.09873513132333755,
0.7508001327514648,
0.3552880585193634,
0.6356711387634277,
-0.7921521067619324,
0.591402530670166,
-0.6419512033462524,
0.5874842405319214,
-0.2716045379638672,
-0.8156796097755432,
-0.381621778011322,
0.29419028759002686,
-0.17746461927890778,
0.010616459883749485,
0.5267642736434937,
0.8834707736968994,
-0.3315543830394745,
0.00680152140557766,
0.39110785722732544,
0.20264098048210144,
0.2703235149383545,
0.7812604308128357,
0.6725905537605286,
0.023802926763892174,
0.6995837688446045,
-0.48124656081199646,
-0.30675095319747925,
-0.17770172655582428,
-1.0156687498092651,
-0.8524391055107117,
-0.4417340159416199,
-0.09961206465959549,
-0.2896862328052521,
0.3301990032196045,
0.6074308753013611,
0.7349859476089478,
-1.0236990451812744,
-0.4066707491874695,
-0.1461976021528244,
0.23415161669254303,
-0.39545348286628723,
-0.17131762206554413,
0.5996429920196533,
-0.18566936254501343,
-0.770482063293457,
0.34346553683280945,
-0.008820844814181328,
0.2040918618440628,
-0.19906535744667053,
-0.12299773097038269,
-0.06487290561199188,
-0.19420160353183746,
0.23608148097991943,
0.9040295481681824,
-0.36662977933883667,
-0.11663544923067093,
-0.188384011387825,
0.13493403792381287,
0.04033995047211647,
1.0689020156860352,
-0.4155242145061493,
0.3260791301727295,
-0.02098359353840351,
0.7915672659873962,
0.7097897529602051,
0.15991033613681793,
0.768463671207428,
-1.4388220310211182,
0.36930105090141296,
0.16352465748786926,
0.5801321864128113,
0.3697294592857361,
-0.4567405581474304,
0.30447104573249817,
0.06252655386924744,
-0.39137426018714905,
-1.1598289012908936,
0.17173315584659576,
-0.7872510552406311,
-0.6792461276054382,
1.1729998588562012,
-0.3214406669139862,
-0.14636437594890594,
-0.21350006759166718,
0.11901408433914185,
0.428459107875824,
-0.4352813959121704,
0.9025059342384338,
0.6586717367172241,
0.3539065718650818,
-0.2570776343345642,
-0.5825022459030151,
0.3040401041507721,
0.7498324513435364,
-0.6256312727928162,
0.7783724665641785,
0.48062554001808167,
0.4822949767112732,
0.07779671996831894,
0.4289720058441162,
-0.3049462139606476,
0.20028012990951538,
-0.3525659441947937,
0.3709784746170044,
-0.24066634476184845,
-0.39016520977020264,
-0.8010603785514832,
0.07399989664554596,
-0.07460878789424896,
-0.3694056570529938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11036v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11036v1
|
Cross-Platform Hate Speech Detection with Weakly Supervised Causal Disentanglement
| 2024-04-17T03:25:54 | 2024-04-17T03:25:54 |
Paras Sheth, Tharindu Kumarage, Raha Moraffah, Aman Chadha, Huan Liu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Content moderation faces a challenging task as social media's ability to
spread hate speech contrasts with its role in promoting global connectivity.
With rapidly evolving slang and hate speech, the adaptability of conventional
deep learning to the fluid landscape of online dialogue remains limited. In
response, causality inspired disentanglement has shown promise by segregating
platform specific peculiarities from universal hate indicators. However, its
dependency on available ground truth target labels for discerning these nuances
faces practical hurdles with the incessant evolution of platforms and the
mutable nature of hate speech. Using confidence based reweighting and
contrastive regularization, this study presents HATE WATCH, a novel framework
of weakly supervised causal disentanglement that circumvents the need for
explicit target labeling and effectively disentangles input features into
invariant representations of hate. Empirical validation across platforms two
with target labels and two without positions HATE WATCH as a novel method in
cross platform hate speech detection with superior performance. HATE WATCH
advances scalable content moderation techniques towards developing safer online
communities.
|
[
-0.3745478689670563,
-0.9520794749259949,
0.21353887021541595,
0.02458750084042549,
-0.33707305788993835,
0.33714938163757324,
-0.17380210757255554,
-0.45926573872566223,
0.7575068473815918,
0.20676450431346893,
-0.8972203731536865,
-0.4644264578819275,
-1.0568625926971436,
-0.19698995351791382,
-0.5543236136436462,
1.2484431266784668,
0.3529573380947113,
0.14515221118927002,
0.16928666830062866,
-0.21840591728687286,
-0.11018744856119156,
-0.3964250087738037,
-0.7746328711509705,
-0.3584652245044708,
1.0507725477218628,
0.20285217463970184,
0.7103420495986938,
0.5567343235015869,
0.28892964124679565,
0.2679453194141388,
-0.03755740076303482,
0.14791437983512878,
-0.9176422357559204,
0.2738606035709381,
-0.2879073917865753,
-0.4275602698326111,
-0.1563405841588974,
0.014123395085334778,
0.26959744095802307,
0.34344619512557983,
0.2469874620437622,
0.1853572130203247,
0.2080717533826828,
0.17677859961986542,
-0.6579272150993347,
-0.17493250966072083,
-0.8231489658355713,
0.11049044877290726,
-0.34365132451057434,
-0.07549909502267838,
-0.12453749775886536,
-0.05075812339782715,
-0.11561427265405655,
-0.4164113998413086,
0.3266747295856476,
0.05622659623622894,
0.6516410708427429,
0.6289007067680359,
-0.283903032541275,
-0.20906473696231842,
-0.9177034497261047,
0.9467710256576538,
-0.4953661859035492,
0.5259012579917908,
0.587480366230011,
0.13535729050636292,
0.052459776401519775,
-0.6679841876029968,
-0.49237823486328125,
0.18253536522388458,
0.164748415350914,
-0.026045044884085655,
-0.7437729239463806,
-0.19465893507003784,
0.0543048158288002,
0.09780000895261765,
-0.3620045483112335,
0.6048434972763062,
-0.4303615093231201,
-0.45649391412734985,
0.6298523545265198,
0.0809209793806076,
0.2822352349758148,
-0.03138625621795654,
-0.5200993418693542,
0.27169257402420044,
-0.3797856867313385,
-0.10451015084981918,
0.7503411769866943,
0.5916221141815186,
-0.3249887526035309,
0.1417851746082306,
-0.06587199121713638,
0.26532408595085144,
0.4736262261867523,
-0.32204803824424744,
0.2201595902442932,
0.23285838961601257,
-0.014219427481293678,
0.5435466766357422,
0.8085445761680603,
0.5711088180541992,
-0.0027734264731407166,
-0.4015616476535797,
0.19340543448925018,
0.703009843826294,
0.31627997756004333,
-0.8494436144828796,
-0.27021583914756775,
0.06611580401659012,
-0.3748232126235962,
-0.5440316200256348,
-0.29164937138557434,
-0.8879275321960449,
-0.9274665117263794,
-0.3726573884487152,
0.27228444814682007,
-0.11878063529729843,
-0.3526532053947449,
-0.20373402535915375,
-0.10551316291093826,
0.02202272228896618,
0.06461776793003082,
-0.7873626351356506,
0.293332576751709,
0.7238231897354126,
0.7223640084266663,
-0.6009198427200317,
-0.00412402069196105,
-0.8031783699989319,
0.09786509722471237,
-0.03855506703257561,
0.3847608268260956,
-0.513917863368988,
0.1646529585123062,
-0.19906122982501984,
0.14687645435333252,
0.33884814381599426,
-0.2724774181842804,
0.678187370300293,
-0.7253131866455078,
-0.20873738825321198,
-0.014198447577655315,
-0.38295218348503113,
-0.16170601546764374,
0.2551397383213043,
-0.5168223977088928,
0.5490002632141113,
-0.14111334085464478,
-0.9100021123886108,
0.7584609389305115,
0.0775047019124031,
-0.5477765202522278,
-0.05775194987654686,
-0.1336134523153305,
-0.8073802590370178,
-0.07768372446298599,
0.1446506828069687,
0.2526013255119324,
-0.07769450545310974,
0.38998928666114807,
-1.0569134950637817,
-0.34657835960388184,
-0.038325466215610504,
-0.647311270236969,
0.7971549034118652,
0.3576458990573883,
-1.0281932353973389,
0.215427964925766,
-0.6823304295539856,
-0.2272961139678955,
0.06321565061807632,
0.23161594569683075,
-0.4913701117038727,
0.426163911819458,
0.19085244834423065,
0.31852641701698303,
0.14856195449829102,
-0.7906835079193115,
-0.47480472922325134,
-0.12545810639858246,
0.40322786569595337,
0.8077420592308044,
0.057740505784749985,
0.08303730189800262,
-0.1977073699235916,
0.32144561409950256,
0.28441619873046875,
0.3022056221961975,
0.8130174875259399,
-0.4413881003856659,
-0.6071589589118958,
-0.33974823355674744,
-0.2227095663547516,
0.5704125761985779,
-0.5323581099510193,
0.24520911276340485,
0.13137170672416687,
-0.5020089149475098,
-0.23644372820854187,
0.42814624309539795,
0.47329843044281006,
0.41084960103034973,
0.5233032703399658,
-0.2503316402435303,
-0.9540736675262451,
-1.0407297611236572,
-0.4506966471672058,
-0.18456779420375824,
0.03587674722075462,
0.116814024746418,
0.17057056725025177,
-0.4566737115383148,
0.7789708375930786,
-0.22330501675605774,
-0.30129197239875793,
-0.19032713770866394,
0.3634643852710724,
-0.12446340918540955,
0.41477325558662415,
0.4762897491455078,
-1.277312159538269,
-0.5154948830604553,
-0.3477446436882019,
-0.46679335832595825,
-0.3244892656803131,
0.13398320972919464,
0.06567706167697906,
-0.331849604845047,
0.7652717232704163,
0.28780996799468994,
0.5205144882202148,
0.5769075155258179,
-0.19774290919303894,
0.10401204228401184,
0.4044853150844574,
0.2836396098136902,
-0.9503881931304932,
-0.3014824688434601,
0.16618084907531738,
-0.4128932058811188,
-0.6677025556564331,
-0.3207245469093323,
-0.6178369522094727,
0.05373993143439293,
-0.5935866236686707,
-0.08565402776002884,
0.07952433079481125,
0.2605137825012207,
-0.4082473814487457,
0.3732078969478607,
-0.3380737006664276,
0.5173519253730774,
0.0658893808722496,
0.18575820326805115,
0.48053523898124695,
-0.5600482225418091,
0.41311633586883545,
0.05332832783460617,
-0.07897566258907318,
0.912987470626831,
-0.3784073293209076,
0.010633254423737526,
-0.21587394177913666,
0.21946287155151367,
-0.99945467710495,
-0.12832926213741302,
0.5523239970207214,
-0.549697756767273,
-0.018013227730989456,
-0.5978628396987915,
-0.36433669924736023,
-0.08131223917007446,
-0.18117137253284454,
0.5277092456817627,
0.2722008526325226,
-0.39767590165138245,
0.36028701066970825,
0.7981492877006531,
0.07972263544797897,
-0.42842361330986023,
-0.9696387648582458,
-0.15465788543224335,
-0.7947387099266052,
-0.29061222076416016,
0.42725610733032227,
-0.09483042359352112,
-0.378753125667572,
-0.156915545463562,
-0.283669650554657,
-0.4135226905345917,
0.11545324325561523,
0.684637188911438,
-0.15378984808921814,
-0.09279441088438034,
-0.018305562436580658,
0.20982469618320465,
0.00399307906627655,
0.2383478432893753,
-0.15739667415618896,
0.4101191759109497,
0.2305910885334015,
-0.34112685918807983,
-0.5705534815788269,
0.3424246609210968,
0.6871891617774963,
0.25363245606422424,
0.5593269467353821,
1.3626303672790527,
-0.42597877979278564,
-0.382509708404541,
-0.5069600939750671,
-0.26928120851516724,
-0.4760553538799286,
0.18198420107364655,
0.08605349063873291,
-1.4021755456924438,
0.5624996423721313,
0.11686449497938156,
-0.16192595660686493,
0.3279878497123718,
0.5416514873504639,
0.12995333969593048,
0.9895226955413818,
0.5978356003761292,
-0.4907970726490021,
0.4201299250125885,
0.4037794768810272,
0.2908494770526886,
-0.28926563262939453,
-0.13271859288215637,
-0.3784739077091217,
-0.7917778491973877,
-0.731330394744873,
-0.347665399312973,
0.34164509177207947,
0.20562508702278137,
-0.3835660219192505,
0.3874979615211487,
-0.4537900686264038,
0.3277689218521118,
0.19974631071090698,
0.4282703399658203,
0.2645033597946167,
0.20990535616874695,
-0.03902005776762962,
-0.7413324117660522,
-0.4685359299182892,
-0.021906210109591484,
0.9253354072570801,
0.5221193432807922,
0.7827985882759094,
0.3344404697418213,
0.4998646080493927,
0.7776700258255005,
0.37191104888916016,
-0.6046432256698608,
0.17376971244812012,
-0.4291418492794037,
-0.7170810103416443,
-0.1338517665863037,
-0.46909332275390625,
-0.7219475507736206,
-0.04397192969918251,
-0.2918012738227844,
-0.970504879951477,
0.2614235579967499,
0.33940503001213074,
-0.19237272441387177,
0.738503098487854,
-0.3118070960044861,
0.8107298016548157,
-0.08322915434837341,
-0.8444836139678955,
-0.4421335756778717,
-0.547758162021637,
0.48737844824790955,
-0.025011299178004265,
0.4193190634250641,
-0.19739702343940735,
0.01811198703944683,
0.9558517336845398,
-0.2615133821964264,
1.4237533807754517,
-0.1976563036441803,
-0.06322158873081207,
0.4273613691329956,
0.22915484011173248,
0.3525676429271698,
0.13197124004364014,
0.30729934573173523,
0.20988240838050842,
-0.4474087655544281,
-0.22034695744514465,
-0.2267986238002777,
0.8840161561965942,
-0.5821054577827454,
-0.2390640527009964,
0.032510485500097275,
-0.2391335815191269,
-0.5194275975227356,
0.1977969855070114,
0.2943575084209442,
0.2903769314289093,
-0.2827931344509125,
0.2709116041660309,
1.0118359327316284,
-0.08388719707727432,
0.12883369624614716,
0.6730325222015381,
-0.1530464142560959,
-0.3575746715068817,
1.267778992652893,
-0.31240278482437134,
0.1307859569787979,
0.45439931750297546,
0.26430898904800415,
-0.2778860330581665,
-0.45425763726234436,
-0.11901826411485672,
-0.1670485883951187,
-0.4665141999721527,
-0.08049709349870682,
-0.737523078918457,
0.09280410408973694,
-0.2554450035095215,
-0.2098056524991989,
-0.42092618346214294,
-0.03329067304730415,
-0.2415708750486374,
-0.002323334803804755,
0.4902995228767395,
0.5643576979637146,
-0.6236546039581299,
0.4416230022907257,
-0.09603007882833481,
0.6704874038696289,
0.4425732493400574,
0.4117514491081238,
-0.20051316916942596,
-0.7765805721282959,
-0.08187685161828995,
0.09938199073076248,
-0.2662884593009949,
-0.9468140006065369,
0.2715476155281067,
-0.22345095872879028,
0.306547075510025,
0.626566469669342,
0.3763355016708374,
0.6639050245285034,
-0.4136163294315338,
0.511772096157074,
0.3520183563232422,
-0.8146085739135742,
0.43761780858039856,
-0.3976042568683624,
-0.19910462200641632,
0.6860763430595398,
0.8128098845481873,
-0.46796417236328125,
-0.7657686471939087,
-0.5543188452720642,
-0.7809220552444458,
0.6090217232704163,
0.039288874715566635,
-0.03813603147864342,
-0.1786498725414276,
-0.4559745490550995,
-0.03620738536119461,
0.3282758593559265,
-0.8831596374511719,
-0.7063623070716858,
-0.24718250334262848,
0.046667326241731644,
-0.11072568595409393,
-0.07293213158845901,
-0.3423568904399872,
-0.18702447414398193,
0.6900845766067505,
0.11824460327625275,
-0.05442291870713234,
0.06227175518870354,
-0.2513262927532196,
-0.19197694957256317,
0.17176902294158936,
0.3755006492137909,
0.33984580636024475,
-0.2994726896286011,
0.2378932535648346,
0.04581999406218529,
-0.41784241795539856,
0.0775703638792038,
0.060115981847047806,
-0.2470124065876007,
0.2272486686706543,
0.1310344636440277,
0.6962088346481323,
0.5452951788902283,
-0.32825344800949097,
0.693219006061554,
0.05277467519044876,
-0.2937752902507782,
-0.19182421267032623,
-0.06701504439115524,
-0.018119994550943375,
0.30951520800590515,
0.20532697439193726,
0.11316640675067902,
0.2500458061695099,
-0.16957175731658936,
0.7183578610420227,
0.3005223572254181,
-1.083344578742981,
-0.13605628907680511,
1.0322178602218628,
0.09429506957530975,
0.00045145105104893446,
0.0016363161848857999,
-0.23129305243492126,
-0.6578259468078613,
0.39322569966316223,
0.3602064847946167,
0.9370384812355042,
-0.21693246066570282,
0.4716879725456238,
0.33724382519721985,
0.34856361150741577,
0.48572051525115967,
-0.2823590338230133,
-0.24969612061977386,
-0.7399438619613647,
-0.34953954815864563,
-0.7324458360671997,
-0.38468876481056213,
0.5474336743354797,
-0.7336432933807373,
0.05535711720585823,
-0.8317842483520508,
-0.10152174532413483,
0.2481357902288437,
-0.1963011920452118,
-0.39651259779930115,
0.214591845870018,
0.5681345462799072,
0.28112831711769104,
-1.202893614768982,
0.400842547416687,
0.09274377673864365,
-0.21084418892860413,
-0.6196033954620361,
0.0016850859392434359,
0.6949320435523987,
-0.6485105156898499,
0.7191506028175354,
0.11253892630338669,
-0.6642201542854309,
-0.2817893922328949,
-0.7047227025032043,
-0.5465871095657349,
0.5263967514038086,
0.20531630516052246,
-0.5641747117042542,
0.4682091176509857,
0.22137926518917084,
0.5879305005073547,
-0.26364290714263916,
-0.057009898126125336,
0.24710014462471008,
0.3710193932056427,
0.007659486494958401,
-0.6800646185874939,
0.11148583889007568,
0.07712413370609283,
-0.42429864406585693,
0.09857290983200073,
-0.8257215023040771,
0.7351254224777222,
0.40748170018196106,
-0.2038436383008957,
-0.5034993886947632,
0.688273549079895,
0.01406925544142723,
0.6715002655982971,
0.794145941734314,
0.4810272753238678,
0.3173780143260956,
0.12966668605804443,
0.33414140343666077,
-0.10391835123300552,
0.18663591146469116,
1.2015023231506348,
-0.10986071825027466,
0.4158249795436859,
0.45866894721984863,
-0.17175395786762238,
0.6447778940200806,
0.32215943932533264,
-0.07750901579856873,
0.44108232855796814,
0.5122788548469543,
-0.5403860211372375,
-0.7209716439247131,
-0.43699735403060913,
-0.23839956521987915,
0.5019607543945312,
0.5617731809616089,
-0.34766894578933716,
-0.48695850372314453,
0.06751268357038498,
0.2671217918395996,
0.5307289361953735,
-0.614692747592926,
0.5084394812583923,
-0.0415833480656147,
-0.3089541494846344,
0.4865248501300812,
0.24135757982730865,
1.163470983505249,
-0.7665608525276184,
0.18531112372875214,
0.037141311913728714,
0.31085845828056335,
-0.39281994104385376,
-0.2588764727115631,
0.5138588547706604,
0.2352210432291031,
-0.32938438653945923,
-0.28859201073646545,
0.6584934592247009,
-0.362831175327301,
-0.0859338715672493,
0.7420129179954529,
0.17414376139640808,
0.10084111243486404,
-0.16694489121437073,
-0.9339331984519958,
0.44679492712020874,
0.14301376044750214,
0.22968409955501556,
0.5514495968818665,
0.32180389761924744,
-0.08374819904565811,
0.4797635078430176,
0.5340863466262817,
-0.13978849351406097,
0.3112052381038666,
0.06811536848545074,
0.9408518075942993,
-0.15201136469841003,
-0.7103663682937622,
-0.8794214129447937,
0.2183060348033905,
-0.09193775057792664,
-0.4053947627544403,
0.8596389889717102,
0.6179172396659851,
1.101469874382019,
0.12659431993961334,
0.5035610198974609,
-0.2740176022052765,
0.8190699219703674,
-0.17411187291145325,
0.7752788066864014,
-0.591107189655304,
-0.011747708544135094,
-0.7239078879356384,
-0.5376676321029663,
-0.34173673391342163,
0.2634044885635376,
-0.5138067603111267,
-0.329164981842041,
0.4801572561264038,
0.8338177800178528,
-0.43706706166267395,
-0.01757608726620674,
0.33331888914108276,
0.20571063458919525,
0.23925615847110748,
0.5032326579093933,
0.4406913220882416,
-0.49590352177619934,
0.8820997476577759,
-0.3116178810596466,
-0.24771572649478912,
-0.14101043343544006,
-0.7119757533073425,
-0.947903573513031,
-0.4801427125930786,
-0.6275864243507385,
-0.5457939505577087,
0.06564106047153473,
0.5404193997383118,
0.8253348469734192,
-1.0902290344238281,
-0.017220811918377876,
-0.05206206440925598,
0.44292619824409485,
-0.24318529665470123,
-0.316584050655365,
0.06316874921321869,
-0.07955069839954376,
-0.8145734667778015,
0.706459641456604,
0.2561269700527191,
-0.30144208669662476,
-0.13983109593391418,
-0.1374865472316742,
-0.38792479038238525,
-0.19712436199188232,
0.40239331126213074,
0.6719666123390198,
-0.6322978138923645,
-0.18783822655677795,
-0.6313890218734741,
-0.05345458164811134,
-0.2399957925081253,
0.9443745613098145,
-0.571190595626831,
0.2078426331281662,
0.11877410113811493,
0.9221822023391724,
0.6260915994644165,
0.010173551738262177,
0.15738524496555328,
-0.916693389415741,
0.5576141476631165,
0.22224637866020203,
0.1545717865228653,
0.18348267674446106,
-0.2536270022392273,
0.011158104054629803,
0.7614355087280273,
-0.2930493652820587,
-0.7308008670806885,
0.6248658895492554,
-1.018456220626831,
-0.3183930814266205,
0.8553133010864258,
0.009188973344862461,
-0.16748900711536407,
-0.4703196585178375,
0.12002813071012497,
0.30979979038238525,
-0.4413541853427887,
0.5537033081054688,
0.3446787893772125,
0.018538009375333786,
-0.07454206049442291,
-0.30187100172042847,
0.7226861715316772,
0.44938191771507263,
-0.2846175730228424,
0.020777292549610138,
0.7419739365577698,
0.3166179060935974,
0.2499741166830063,
0.3323591947555542,
0.00578200863674283,
0.07658959925174713,
0.30930018424987793,
-0.3562653362751007,
-0.07751061022281647,
-0.3175831437110901,
-0.20949795842170715,
0.4501923620700836,
-0.5381635427474976,
-0.2605574131011963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11023v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11023v1
|
Advancing Social Intelligence in AI Agents: Technical Challenges and Open Questions
| 2024-04-17T02:57:42 | 2024-04-17T02:57:42 |
Leena Mathur, Paul Pu Liang, Louis-Philippe Morency
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Building socially-intelligent AI agents (Social-AI) is a multidisciplinary,
multimodal research goal that involves creating agents that can sense,
perceive, reason about, learn from, and respond to affect, behavior, and
cognition of other agents (human or artificial). Progress towards Social-AI has
accelerated in the past decade across several computing communities, including
natural language processing, machine learning, robotics, human-machine
interaction, computer vision, and speech. Natural language processing, in
particular, has been prominent in Social-AI research, as language plays a key
role in constructing the social world. In this position paper, we identify a
set of underlying technical challenges and open questions for researchers
across computing communities to advance Social-AI. We anchor our discussion in
the context of social intelligence concepts and prior progress in Social-AI
research.
|
[
-0.4131990671157837,
-1.1802412271499634,
0.6184779405593872,
-0.014918801374733448,
0.3611510097980499,
0.6868717670440674,
-0.3416260778903961,
-0.8753514289855957,
0.18011465668678284,
0.11432462930679321,
-0.5792704820632935,
-0.19917581975460052,
-0.6712124347686768,
0.12305702269077301,
-0.1231408640742302,
0.7260411977767944,
0.23236986994743347,
-0.3518999218940735,
-0.34288254380226135,
-0.25081130862236023,
-0.3959265351295471,
-0.5223125219345093,
-0.9155756235122681,
-0.2019580900669098,
0.6508433818817139,
0.6101424098014832,
1.1119755506515503,
0.3256174921989441,
0.5532182455062866,
0.4696269631385803,
0.17227695882320404,
0.39159706234931946,
-0.2206936776638031,
0.27202650904655457,
-0.07949913293123245,
-0.3482295274734497,
-0.5394567251205444,
0.09598401188850403,
0.5580241680145264,
0.731116533279419,
0.33394655585289,
0.301033079624176,
0.08705273270606995,
0.8807589411735535,
-0.39311671257019043,
0.4852890372276306,
-0.5155900120735168,
-0.18018028140068054,
-0.311189740896225,
0.04625273495912552,
-0.1584075540304184,
-0.45619627833366394,
-0.031643468886613846,
-0.6770143508911133,
0.19653302431106567,
-0.023633882403373718,
0.796022891998291,
0.34120824933052063,
-0.40958988666534424,
-0.16675110161304474,
-1.0053105354309082,
0.5226327776908875,
-0.2674373388290405,
0.2520161271095276,
0.48189976811408997,
0.4145328402519226,
-0.17513033747673035,
-0.6752505898475647,
-0.5474265217781067,
-0.23339499533176422,
0.3533810079097748,
-0.14316724240779877,
-0.036824289709329605,
-0.09986837208271027,
0.14022822678089142,
-0.05872155353426933,
-0.3090975284576416,
-0.09527982771396637,
-0.6847498416900635,
-0.08952731639146805,
1.090839147567749,
0.12404435873031616,
0.31869080662727356,
0.3370935022830963,
0.13723431527614594,
-0.02131796069443226,
-0.42544350028038025,
0.16542288661003113,
0.3740513026714325,
0.3838418424129486,
-0.3182924687862396,
0.4974651038646698,
-0.4562990367412567,
0.2710152566432953,
-0.13926516473293304,
0.42893028259277344,
0.38101810216903687,
-0.5690472722053528,
0.2790582478046417,
-0.07644910365343094,
0.5206765532493591,
0.14060057699680328,
0.7075333595275879,
-0.1505054235458374,
0.09550478309392929,
0.22274786233901978,
0.5324853658676147,
-0.27093133330345154,
0.14607176184654236,
0.38344982266426086,
-0.38875988125801086,
-0.40780267119407654,
0.048556383699178696,
-0.5644015669822693,
-0.639880359172821,
-0.3163515329360962,
0.16443026065826416,
-0.23990342020988464,
-0.5610995292663574,
-0.18867377936840057,
-0.47647225856781006,
0.7766831517219543,
0.5001094341278076,
-0.6052818298339844,
0.30499666929244995,
1.0170722007751465,
0.830901026725769,
0.3638947904109955,
-0.44935673475265503,
-0.346625417470932,
0.10987560451030731,
-0.28553441166877747,
0.9765592813491821,
-0.8088989853858948,
-0.20820316672325134,
0.12763580679893494,
-0.044549111276865005,
-0.14685115218162537,
-0.16961461305618286,
0.0441339947283268,
-0.3792385756969452,
-0.02052442915737629,
-0.3947190046310425,
-0.20544090867042542,
0.05780202895402908,
0.4633379876613617,
-0.381002277135849,
0.8896669745445251,
0.06924834847450256,
-0.5852915048599243,
0.1234397143125534,
-1.190317153930664,
-0.6750023365020752,
0.4673919379711151,
-0.3238486349582672,
0.06068721041083336,
0.18416784703731537,
-0.0402691587805748,
0.31208959221839905,
-0.40927809476852417,
0.2286708503961563,
-0.48514965176582336,
-0.23701654374599457,
0.512516975402832,
-0.257933646440506,
0.7592049837112427,
0.19095171988010406,
-0.5541568398475647,
0.28303471207618713,
-0.5546606183052063,
-0.16341595351696014,
0.26928600668907166,
0.04974289983510971,
-0.22702309489250183,
0.4807520806789398,
-0.30798497796058655,
-0.0926605761051178,
0.5197126865386963,
-0.6679674983024597,
0.025826623663306236,
-0.29371750354766846,
0.7080262899398804,
1.0684196949005127,
-0.1667005866765976,
0.5163700580596924,
-0.6624724268913269,
0.3115389347076416,
-0.34587687253952026,
0.45198801159858704,
0.16134992241859436,
-0.8873566389083862,
-0.493305504322052,
0.051766008138656616,
0.006408661603927612,
0.6023017764091492,
-1.0527477264404297,
0.11967500299215317,
-0.07941808551549911,
-0.6782571077346802,
-0.8614018559455872,
-0.03504602983593941,
0.06713814288377762,
0.24146011471748352,
0.10792335122823715,
0.03343120962381363,
-0.17903803288936615,
-0.7355102300643921,
-0.3491751551628113,
-0.46177470684051514,
0.1832544505596161,
0.3455098867416382,
0.5033248066902161,
-0.36433807015419006,
0.928030788898468,
-0.5425441265106201,
0.021033743396401405,
-0.42911821603775024,
0.11513659358024597,
-0.3510139286518097,
0.44095921516418457,
0.22545966506004333,
-1.103835105895996,
-0.6284888386726379,
0.2539963722229004,
-1.0319360494613647,
0.14075934886932373,
0.23316819965839386,
-0.04144291579723358,
0.19274912774562836,
0.6214640140533447,
-0.8499515056610107,
0.6442344188690186,
-0.018659718334674835,
-0.330204576253891,
0.30150702595710754,
-0.1282414048910141,
0.37920865416526794,
-1.0315624475479126,
0.022836793214082718,
-0.07376090437173843,
0.09245596081018448,
-1.1049726009368896,
0.1936817616224289,
-0.4590223431587219,
-0.3202904462814331,
-0.27846744656562805,
0.727669894695282,
-0.3767584264278412,
-0.008124797604978085,
-0.1619400531053543,
0.4578876793384552,
-0.3386276364326477,
0.337757408618927,
-0.2788616716861725,
0.5711002349853516,
0.7397339940071106,
-0.7635469436645508,
0.48055407404899597,
-0.04270115867257118,
0.08282085508108139,
0.6015944480895996,
-0.9576539993286133,
0.6510191559791565,
-0.4143066108226776,
-0.22784289717674255,
-0.6950055360794067,
-0.35050061345100403,
0.5086817145347595,
-1.0232042074203491,
-0.06859885901212692,
0.4662206768989563,
-0.533578634262085,
-0.5415571928024292,
-0.47341540455818176,
0.6280131936073303,
0.4155562222003937,
0.1087999939918518,
0.7159188985824585,
0.667046308517456,
-0.33861246705055237,
-0.2986711263656616,
-0.3219429850578308,
0.14565834403038025,
0.07970503717660904,
-0.9735512137413025,
0.17391853034496307,
-0.1609928011894226,
-0.9386194348335266,
0.235856831073761,
0.3364330232143402,
-0.15933246910572052,
0.4526507258415222,
0.24467402696609497,
-0.007302573416382074,
-0.14723996818065643,
0.20053665339946747,
0.07301734387874603,
-0.14843471348285675,
0.20565979182720184,
0.06941036880016327,
0.5169274210929871,
-0.4093221426010132,
-0.25455522537231445,
-0.3128885328769684,
0.5892505645751953,
0.5068066716194153,
-0.4869180917739868,
0.6355140209197998,
0.6453786492347717,
-0.691645085811615,
-0.06607110053300858,
-0.5344086289405823,
-0.014463929459452629,
-0.5077875256538391,
0.2807902693748474,
-0.1888088583946228,
-1.1428884267807007,
0.642376184463501,
0.04239066317677498,
0.22119328379631042,
0.309620201587677,
0.4222409725189209,
-0.29829511046409607,
1.1930338144302368,
0.8849018216133118,
-0.08181486278772354,
0.5272762179374695,
0.045876991003751755,
0.33198457956314087,
-0.40040597319602966,
-0.24548989534378052,
-0.9259686470031738,
-0.2924509048461914,
-0.6450480222702026,
-0.3312896192073822,
0.24809770286083221,
-0.6197590231895447,
-0.2661941647529602,
0.15706831216812134,
-0.45002949237823486,
0.17359939217567444,
0.8502510786056519,
0.10564319789409637,
0.03171297162771225,
-0.17753060162067413,
0.5061665177345276,
0.5561502575874329,
-0.4035250246524811,
-0.6343052387237549,
0.7951344847679138,
0.32002684473991394,
0.280987411737442,
0.048398457467556,
0.6659861207008362,
0.7769171595573425,
0.06624595820903778,
-0.5208631157875061,
0.7578516006469727,
0.19474540650844574,
-0.7114318013191223,
-0.616860032081604,
-0.2835886776447296,
-1.122511625289917,
-0.24449467658996582,
-0.14872613549232483,
-0.6627026796340942,
0.04777799919247627,
0.10443265736103058,
-0.2549709975719452,
0.16504691541194916,
-0.6019947528839111,
0.7958989143371582,
-0.21067067980766296,
-0.26934656500816345,
-0.6696643829345703,
-0.9886935949325562,
-0.13869313895702362,
0.2676638960838318,
0.49845564365386963,
-0.43388745188713074,
0.15241128206253052,
0.5265575051307678,
-0.2812334895133972,
0.8715642094612122,
-0.35163038969039917,
0.27008572220802307,
0.6315380334854126,
-0.3737632930278778,
0.11399371176958084,
-0.0717378705739975,
-0.14587971568107605,
0.2236924022436142,
0.061397649347782135,
-0.6667956113815308,
-0.5803900361061096,
0.16104502975940704,
-0.9794471263885498,
-0.8562397956848145,
-0.4335298240184784,
-0.5373265743255615,
-0.12462236732244492,
0.06978002190589905,
-0.23113250732421875,
0.38365721702575684,
-0.5254469513893127,
0.2506360709667206,
0.5730094909667969,
-0.26689431071281433,
0.36854520440101624,
0.2641507089138031,
0.09902723133563995,
-0.13193704187870026,
1.0991805791854858,
0.16274897754192352,
0.3946073353290558,
0.31474772095680237,
0.1942860633134842,
0.11226942390203476,
-0.4385148286819458,
-0.35557821393013,
0.15071147680282593,
-0.4139545261859894,
0.08429905027151108,
-0.5027756094932556,
-0.3947508931159973,
-0.9964178800582886,
-0.2742982804775238,
-0.1868162453174591,
-0.18128123879432678,
-0.3433973491191864,
0.15652531385421753,
0.5177080035209656,
1.0643277168273926,
-0.1471930891275406,
-0.01596357859671116,
-0.8286271095275879,
0.40770918130874634,
0.21092993021011353,
0.1695312261581421,
0.024671005085110664,
-0.04044356569647789,
-0.2810106873512268,
0.3849566876888275,
-0.18864281475543976,
-0.9011926054954529,
-0.05507313460111618,
0.14366737008094788,
0.7226932048797607,
0.15085366368293762,
0.38005495071411133,
0.48774752020835876,
-0.42795491218566895,
0.9432021975517273,
-0.27418720722198486,
-0.6437131762504578,
0.9117891788482666,
-0.22648903727531433,
0.3034306466579437,
0.6715531945228577,
0.38639476895332336,
-0.598447859287262,
-0.6168549656867981,
-0.6531226634979248,
-0.6749674081802368,
0.491360604763031,
0.3090406358242035,
0.2625453770160675,
-0.1239681988954544,
0.4648202061653137,
-0.058935269713401794,
0.20995472371578217,
-0.43743443489074707,
-0.16632071137428284,
-0.16569441556930542,
-0.23076924681663513,
-0.06466910988092422,
0.14501744508743286,
0.09852311760187149,
-0.1802268773317337,
0.5327325463294983,
-0.3870919644832611,
0.38086193799972534,
0.1846347451210022,
-0.010398163460195065,
-0.04358883574604988,
0.3875133991241455,
0.4538259506225586,
0.5944746136665344,
0.022075997665524483,
-0.04789649322628975,
-0.1296725571155548,
-0.3632095754146576,
0.02259867452085018,
0.3739575445652008,
-0.29310503602027893,
-0.5122783184051514,
0.2713966369628906,
0.6345769762992859,
-0.2806922197341919,
-0.6504046320915222,
0.29842427372932434,
-0.3391539454460144,
-0.33534836769104004,
-0.507028341293335,
0.28634852170944214,
-0.07317767292261124,
0.6431770324707031,
0.5636046528816223,
0.04289214685559273,
-0.06712888926267624,
-1.1301997900009155,
-0.08314981311559677,
0.6169968843460083,
-0.5769575238227844,
-0.46932974457740784,
0.5330033898353577,
0.2629201114177704,
-1.0338897705078125,
0.625156819820404,
-0.5145432949066162,
-0.4992583394050598,
0.9413226842880249,
0.33704429864883423,
1.1400859355926514,
0.061259616166353226,
0.4738169014453888,
-0.2826918959617615,
0.6312891840934753,
0.35625019669532776,
0.7073785662651062,
-0.3648723363876343,
-0.9737580418586731,
-0.06893528252840042,
-0.2636711001396179,
-0.7016990184783936,
-0.5439056158065796,
-0.3442442715167999,
0.027987303212285042,
-0.4382683038711548,
-0.2878240942955017,
0.12791846692562103,
-0.012825293466448784,
-0.7163963317871094,
-0.19012024998664856,
0.17695170640945435,
0.7196124792098999,
-0.4994626045227051,
0.6562835574150085,
1.1040745973587036,
-0.45553407073020935,
-0.48483407497406006,
-0.1372896283864975,
-0.052355702966451645,
-0.685396134853363,
0.4398529827594757,
0.2730514407157898,
-0.2583715617656708,
-0.00541932275518775,
-1.06854248046875,
-0.6929046511650085,
0.9734585285186768,
0.10663598775863647,
0.11494795978069305,
-0.32423415780067444,
0.3536228835582733,
0.6856431365013123,
-0.28182604908943176,
0.07050073146820068,
0.3851061165332794,
0.5526959896087646,
-0.24592439830303192,
-0.7942513227462769,
0.05088771507143974,
-0.7391864061355591,
-0.14327630400657654,
0.21635164320468903,
-1.0082876682281494,
0.6557550430297852,
-0.2965359389781952,
-0.2879827618598938,
0.0704474151134491,
0.8964617848396301,
0.142878457903862,
0.8957967162132263,
0.4695751667022705,
0.030838878825306892,
0.8324035406112671,
-0.05273761227726936,
0.7563888430595398,
-0.43756747245788574,
-0.12866616249084473,
0.6326258182525635,
-0.6427468657493591,
0.4659883677959442,
0.02427363581955433,
-0.018459783867001534,
0.5024982690811157,
0.6278752684593201,
0.1647281050682068,
0.0538027286529541,
-0.05765972658991814,
-0.4729805290699005,
-0.11178027093410492,
-0.4350035786628723,
-0.4489630162715912,
0.6059837937355042,
0.48555788397789,
0.14307501912117004,
0.27705761790275574,
0.09172181785106659,
-0.23358099162578583,
0.2849951982498169,
-0.5231778621673584,
0.9246970415115356,
-0.05868218466639519,
-0.6918962597846985,
-0.22982555627822876,
-0.02488677017390728,
0.4134296178817749,
-0.6082048416137695,
-0.2260483354330063,
0.02067406103014946,
0.012970632873475552,
-0.004445936996489763,
-0.5477131009101868,
0.6109718084335327,
0.07754918932914734,
-0.14516505599021912,
-0.16239233314990997,
1.1545991897583008,
-0.07126813381910324,
-0.3212907612323761,
0.30524808168411255,
0.6223376989364624,
0.21550814807415009,
-0.17955045402050018,
-0.8843234777450562,
0.01621408388018608,
-0.32245177030563354,
0.07819747179746628,
0.22239361703395844,
0.7121639847755432,
-0.10334868729114532,
0.8880103826522827,
0.6741136908531189,
-0.061943817883729935,
0.0898047462105751,
0.10841121524572372,
0.9052138328552246,
-0.8988409638404846,
-0.3524330258369446,
-0.8815872073173523,
0.5066771507263184,
-0.26186567544937134,
-0.29213249683380127,
0.5487468242645264,
0.09482061862945557,
0.7109794020652771,
0.4521726071834564,
0.8498085737228394,
-0.6660612225532532,
0.27085697650909424,
-0.017709776759147644,
0.664223313331604,
-0.49016520380973816,
-0.1774381697177887,
-0.3729957640171051,
-0.45043379068374634,
-0.04269351810216904,
0.38793841004371643,
-0.1126750111579895,
0.13562221825122833,
0.4077971279621124,
0.7418079972267151,
0.601863443851471,
0.23932425677776337,
0.22528617084026337,
0.03482144698500633,
0.4741755723953247,
0.2517969608306885,
0.992219090461731,
-0.17322981357574463,
0.37346315383911133,
-0.25561293959617615,
-0.26868849992752075,
0.24511370062828064,
-0.3852132558822632,
-0.8478363752365112,
-0.6651272773742676,
-0.45529893040657043,
-0.3360477685928345,
0.3796963393688202,
1.1569867134094238,
0.40836846828460693,
-0.5716472268104553,
-0.3963639438152313,
0.12152048200368881,
0.7159456014633179,
-0.3511642515659332,
-0.31746456027030945,
-0.13275647163391113,
-0.4883424639701843,
-0.6528998017311096,
0.4150952696800232,
0.5632588863372803,
-0.2412441521883011,
-0.3183068037033081,
-0.2259712815284729,
-0.5666828155517578,
0.18319974839687347,
0.7343788743019104,
0.6296122074127197,
-0.40429630875587463,
-0.7315986156463623,
0.20001322031021118,
0.14855791628360748,
0.0024830412585288286,
0.5758888125419617,
-0.5585680603981018,
0.1517430543899536,
0.41103026270866394,
1.026506781578064,
0.02232404612004757,
0.0009064777405001223,
0.6197114586830139,
-0.4866766333580017,
-0.062241315841674805,
0.23887263238430023,
0.05650603398680687,
0.25792640447616577,
-0.42728370428085327,
0.6310216784477234,
0.5864577293395996,
-0.7483217716217041,
-0.9439981579780579,
0.37539997696876526,
-0.697810173034668,
-0.3293859362602234,
0.9173431396484375,
0.29846030473709106,
-0.2838224768638611,
-0.5652498602867126,
-0.1524079591035843,
0.6073021292686462,
-0.4403398334980011,
0.6825735569000244,
0.46523991227149963,
-0.3356158137321472,
-0.33058664202690125,
-0.4262906312942505,
0.30556967854499817,
0.059157367795705795,
-1.0286258459091187,
0.03190202638506889,
0.4347304403781891,
-0.2340913861989975,
0.3946298062801361,
1.109767198562622,
0.08847193419933319,
0.342907190322876,
0.08580285310745239,
-0.09721410274505615,
0.10058781504631042,
-0.6342887878417969,
-0.05340803414583206,
0.416948527097702,
0.3225238025188446,
-0.0890599712729454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11018v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11018v2
|
Many-Shot In-Context Learning
| 2024-04-17T02:49:26 | 2024-05-22T17:06:10 |
Rishabh Agarwal, Avi Singh, Lei M. Zhang, Bernd Bohnet, Luis Rosias, Stephanie Chan, Biao Zhang, Ankesh Anand, Zaheer Abbas, Azade Nova, John D. Co-Reyes, Eric Chu, Feryal Behbahani, Aleksandra Faust, Hugo Larochelle
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) excel at few-shot in-context learning (ICL) --
learning from a few examples provided in context at inference, without any
weight updates. Newly expanded context windows allow us to investigate ICL with
hundreds or thousands of examples -- the many-shot regime. Going from few-shot
to many-shot, we observe significant performance gains across a wide variety of
generative and discriminative tasks. While promising, many-shot ICL can be
bottlenecked by the available amount of human-generated examples. To mitigate
this limitation, we explore two new settings: Reinforced and Unsupervised ICL.
Reinforced ICL uses model-generated chain-of-thought rationales in place of
human examples. Unsupervised ICL removes rationales from the prompt altogether,
and prompts the model only with domain-specific questions. We find that both
Reinforced and Unsupervised ICL can be quite effective in the many-shot regime,
particularly on complex reasoning tasks. Finally, we demonstrate that, unlike
few-shot learning, many-shot learning is effective at overriding pretraining
biases, can learn high-dimensional functions with numerical inputs, and
performs comparably to fine-tuning. Our analysis also reveals the limitations
of next-token prediction loss as an indicator of downstream ICL performance.
|
[
-0.5487545132637024,
-0.8560834527015686,
0.46227261424064636,
0.01659916341304779,
-0.2293643206357956,
0.04935869574546814,
-0.3710155487060547,
-0.38063278794288635,
-0.5394123196601868,
0.4091780483722687,
-0.5053860545158386,
-0.41852208971977234,
-0.4685448706150055,
0.1815817952156067,
-0.13809731602668762,
1.030228614807129,
-0.05411194637417793,
0.16209599375724792,
-0.19473400712013245,
-0.13182543218135834,
-0.24761006236076355,
-0.6351969838142395,
-0.6970967650413513,
-0.5922566056251526,
0.5311943888664246,
0.4873248338699341,
0.10994063317775726,
0.3378857672214508,
0.21687541902065277,
0.196111798286438,
0.01403818279504776,
0.3978932499885559,
-0.6307960748672485,
-0.008479914627969265,
-0.09977327287197113,
-0.361471951007843,
-0.09183900058269501,
-0.09489458054304123,
0.8773167133331299,
0.8113954663276672,
-0.024655738845467567,
-0.04710698127746582,
0.3895356357097626,
0.5243422985076904,
-1.0461289882659912,
0.13782280683517456,
-0.8416623473167419,
0.03516964241862297,
-0.13639038801193237,
-0.1492099016904831,
-0.709364116191864,
0.23600365221500397,
0.23829810321331024,
-0.4525582790374756,
-0.17453673481941223,
0.09433386474847794,
0.32986634969711304,
0.11660202592611313,
-0.7139925360679626,
-0.05911127105355263,
-0.6038914322853088,
0.9812271595001221,
-0.544713020324707,
0.15684105455875397,
0.2589452862739563,
0.379642516374588,
-0.4593718647956848,
-0.5608963370323181,
-0.42748579382896423,
-0.22948628664016724,
0.07705129683017731,
0.146305650472641,
-0.2290596216917038,
0.21749477088451385,
0.5118659734725952,
-0.24261915683746338,
-0.40683552622795105,
0.31183716654777527,
-0.2770827114582062,
-0.10592777281999588,
0.4810609519481659,
0.11360201239585876,
0.012555343098938465,
0.15366892516613007,
-0.4863172173500061,
-0.11640391498804092,
-1.197884202003479,
0.19358912110328674,
-0.005907735321670771,
0.42474815249443054,
-0.07239381223917007,
0.47457417845726013,
-0.1954658478498459,
0.7335792183876038,
0.0016231016488745809,
-0.40908458828926086,
-0.00008298768807435408,
0.03664516657590866,
-0.15905724465847015,
0.06224500387907028,
0.5205336213111877,
0.1297231763601303,
0.31707799434661865,
0.00481807067990303,
-0.2439098060131073,
-0.17751891911029816,
-0.15416297316551208,
-0.7497458457946777,
0.030767772346735,
-0.09838542342185974,
-0.1811143308877945,
0.08690963685512543,
0.05467568710446358,
-0.3576045036315918,
-0.21761801838874817,
-0.30992668867111206,
0.2842090427875519,
-0.32838237285614014,
0.03320106118917465,
0.0887509360909462,
-0.032294753938913345,
0.4540881812572479,
0.43003523349761963,
-0.7017646431922913,
0.35109761357307434,
0.6053125858306885,
0.7030200362205505,
-0.3660615086555481,
-0.5169318914413452,
-0.7724786996841431,
0.36392897367477417,
-0.47273725271224976,
0.9618070721626282,
-0.5306198000907898,
-0.11826469004154205,
0.14947886765003204,
-0.21508699655532837,
0.08478470891714096,
-0.7080686092376709,
0.05065504088997841,
-0.49220916628837585,
-0.0867069885134697,
-0.23245377838611603,
-0.6084304451942444,
-0.1219523474574089,
0.4274621307849884,
-0.368147611618042,
0.8058069348335266,
-0.037914399057626724,
-0.5539895296096802,
0.5914257764816284,
-0.5936329364776611,
-0.5637630820274353,
0.01724034920334816,
-0.3024088442325592,
-0.26702800393104553,
0.20757436752319336,
0.10305521637201309,
0.6972479820251465,
-0.3283947706222534,
0.29508331418037415,
-0.5303170084953308,
-0.5211597084999084,
0.21980659663677216,
-0.7602582573890686,
0.7274764776229858,
0.18732574582099915,
-0.2257189154624939,
0.051544610410928726,
-0.5536941289901733,
-0.20024119317531586,
-0.15129052102565765,
-0.6282813549041748,
-0.09633908420801163,
-0.14819233119487762,
0.025979280471801758,
0.4793720543384552,
-0.2920057475566864,
-0.4583241045475006,
0.24638304114341736,
-0.3943813443183899,
0.5001000761985779,
0.5724732875823975,
-0.07313834130764008,
0.3855647146701813,
-0.27614453434944153,
0.35904914140701294,
0.48453056812286377,
-0.16421709954738617,
-0.46190038323402405,
-0.13102804124355316,
-0.5897688269615173,
-0.5231720805168152,
-0.03426114469766617,
0.3418008089065552,
-0.9479407668113708,
0.11783896386623383,
0.11210831254720688,
-0.08821536600589752,
-0.11107716709375381,
0.3609275817871094,
0.5989601016044617,
0.5871710181236267,
0.39047572016716003,
-0.12871946394443512,
-0.4169743061065674,
-0.7767359018325806,
-0.11760318279266357,
-0.06897607445716858,
0.0026721095200628042,
0.40067365765571594,
0.7295461297035217,
0.08752191066741943,
0.8499199748039246,
-0.4854886829853058,
-0.17753733694553375,
-0.5172747373580933,
0.30877867341041565,
-0.10498033463954926,
0.47114747762680054,
0.31020665168762207,
-0.4450608193874359,
-0.5311737656593323,
-0.17516586184501648,
-0.703447699546814,
0.11188950389623642,
-0.26086312532424927,
0.09134609997272491,
0.31010931730270386,
0.8201221227645874,
-0.7122515439987183,
0.4052271544933319,
0.21862167119979858,
-0.06626036018133163,
0.6449348330497742,
-0.30596357583999634,
-0.1703040599822998,
-0.9654507637023926,
-0.13065358996391296,
0.15959720313549042,
-0.31768548488616943,
-0.5447522401809692,
0.019787020981311798,
0.02566499076783657,
-0.07566975057125092,
-0.9078022837638855,
0.7006952166557312,
-0.4614126682281494,
-0.29763177037239075,
-0.3679227828979492,
0.18482157588005066,
0.050118617713451385,
0.5831186771392822,
0.042683396488428116,
0.7464756965637207,
0.8351150155067444,
-0.6619795560836792,
0.19641686975955963,
0.016627144068479538,
-0.5829660296440125,
0.4308135509490967,
-0.47415193915367126,
0.084356889128685,
-0.48812201619148254,
0.8042217493057251,
-0.9693154692649841,
-0.3620659410953522,
-0.07362483441829681,
-0.004491278436034918,
0.5589463114738464,
-0.16327930986881256,
-0.46094590425491333,
-0.13084276020526886,
-0.3618379831314087,
0.6240549087524414,
0.3807235062122345,
-0.8384729623794556,
0.3973938226699829,
0.11788076907396317,
0.23587274551391602,
-0.8462867736816406,
-0.7476613521575928,
0.1252819448709488,
-0.3386143445968628,
-0.2705424726009369,
0.3105129599571228,
-0.022810081019997597,
-0.38210809230804443,
-0.31059151887893677,
0.20629854500293732,
-0.23777180910110474,
0.2381897270679474,
0.02335525117814541,
0.16646069288253784,
-0.24120603501796722,
0.44322383403778076,
0.0379241406917572,
-0.11032175272703171,
-0.2511763572692871,
-0.4317883849143982,
0.48229551315307617,
-0.22717316448688507,
-0.5247820615768433,
-0.3444674611091614,
0.4480535686016083,
0.5884333252906799,
-0.09524888545274734,
0.8153659105300903,
0.43635082244873047,
-0.42788487672805786,
-0.37906983494758606,
-0.5537023544311523,
-0.3020271360874176,
-0.3958287537097931,
0.6215371489524841,
-0.5514978766441345,
-1.0676426887512207,
0.33635619282722473,
-0.26158690452575684,
0.10060159862041473,
0.22407928109169006,
0.5614854097366333,
-0.24837784469127655,
1.1312675476074219,
0.43691766262054443,
-0.10948485881090164,
0.35805654525756836,
-0.33053141832351685,
0.13638271391391754,
-0.9329290986061096,
-0.027523571625351906,
-0.11809618771076202,
-0.24447545409202576,
-0.28489935398101807,
-0.2634340226650238,
0.4114053249359131,
0.4738761782646179,
-0.48168063163757324,
0.04712895676493645,
-0.029534153640270233,
0.8547909259796143,
0.532734751701355,
0.15628330409526825,
0.30549195408821106,
-0.05299003794789314,
-0.17477475106716156,
0.20106029510498047,
-0.9104636311531067,
-0.3811049461364746,
1.1457253694534302,
0.1718446910381317,
0.7639385461807251,
0.041260283440351486,
0.5668011903762817,
-0.0694400742650032,
0.3330872654914856,
-0.8595545291900635,
0.3995570242404938,
-0.2265782505273819,
-0.6579124331474304,
-0.27104613184928894,
-0.19151060283184052,
-0.7829496264457703,
0.3860814869403839,
-0.38398754596710205,
-0.7011995315551758,
-0.09897790849208832,
0.4457148313522339,
-0.6243925094604492,
0.4981456696987152,
-0.6819762587547302,
0.6542447209358215,
-0.18382129073143005,
-0.6348552107810974,
-0.3065498471260071,
-0.6420344710350037,
0.51966792345047,
-0.07631132006645203,
-0.19093306362628937,
-0.015583831816911697,
0.07570486515760422,
0.20462702214717865,
-0.1067337617278099,
1.1995980739593506,
-0.06804239749908447,
0.16273996233940125,
0.4532913267612457,
-0.17692235112190247,
0.4065544009208679,
0.027798455208539963,
0.037270624190568924,
-0.008062153123319149,
-0.1356465220451355,
-0.5376754999160767,
-0.5742268562316895,
0.7516348361968994,
-0.6094895601272583,
-0.6064807772636414,
-0.3306291401386261,
-0.6546531915664673,
-0.3007992208003998,
-0.01642725244164467,
0.4370879828929901,
0.812690019607544,
-0.09496226906776428,
0.4269635081291199,
0.6365872621536255,
-0.3957638442516327,
0.6535199880599976,
0.31498804688453674,
0.17054405808448792,
-0.10540861636400223,
0.49190351366996765,
0.1574687957763672,
0.4002791941165924,
0.4807770252227783,
0.22573596239089966,
-0.3712078928947449,
-0.5643349885940552,
-0.4437558948993683,
0.10302474349737167,
-0.8609145283699036,
-0.35759779810905457,
-0.4081009030342102,
-0.1755474954843521,
-0.268425315618515,
-0.3925541341304779,
-0.28554826974868774,
-0.09270387142896652,
-0.40742191672325134,
-0.10293690860271454,
-0.01658586412668228,
0.5858227610588074,
0.09442362189292908,
0.4125688374042511,
-0.49681973457336426,
0.05846690014004707,
0.3905142545700073,
0.22882728278636932,
0.2511865794658661,
-0.5029852986335754,
-0.160663902759552,
-0.037455856800079346,
-0.43673229217529297,
-0.41865062713623047,
0.22571729123592377,
0.36549243330955505,
0.4525521993637085,
0.7017284035682678,
0.07742977142333984,
0.9260575771331787,
-0.7020279169082642,
0.5749727487564087,
0.4112144112586975,
-0.7329149842262268,
0.20348212122917175,
-0.19012081623077393,
0.6649624109268188,
0.5490083694458008,
0.35444706678390503,
-0.3222804665565491,
-0.08909786492586136,
-0.34081321954727173,
-0.4349850118160248,
0.6111733913421631,
-0.2816285789012909,
0.23143579065799713,
-0.3167271912097931,
0.5731438994407654,
0.014333977364003658,
0.02120359241962433,
-0.8731071352958679,
-0.0010320083238184452,
0.10583329200744629,
-0.1426757574081421,
-0.07685037702322006,
-0.37074121832847595,
-0.10169989615678787,
-0.380166620016098,
0.47882017493247986,
-0.5793660879135132,
-0.04390142485499382,
0.15973837673664093,
-0.427211731672287,
-0.02375381998717785,
0.38932138681411743,
0.8444961905479431,
0.7361940145492554,
0.06068108603358269,
0.5129407644271851,
0.649409830570221,
0.09649955481290817,
0.08987003564834595,
-0.33203691244125366,
-0.09663443267345428,
-0.5141371488571167,
0.6855996251106262,
0.9077997803688049,
0.4297419488430023,
-1.0024158954620361,
0.5841384530067444,
0.2832948565483093,
-0.2828882932662964,
-0.33109110593795776,
-0.08909784257411957,
-0.0802059918642044,
0.4640439450740814,
0.33248257637023926,
-0.04706334322690964,
0.03609609603881836,
-0.869173526763916,
0.32932549715042114,
0.7944080829620361,
-0.4915625751018524,
-0.27983808517456055,
0.27289077639579773,
0.013530752621591091,
0.036483313888311386,
0.6865601539611816,
-0.34069928526878357,
-0.5522105693817139,
0.46212416887283325,
0.9589689373970032,
0.7054842710494995,
0.1488613486289978,
0.03740021958947182,
0.3088572919368744,
0.011877898126840591,
-0.29897645115852356,
-0.16275514662265778,
-0.13296154141426086,
-0.9621068239212036,
-0.6644282937049866,
-0.31293606758117676,
-0.2594662606716156,
0.2504539489746094,
-0.4251459240913391,
0.35034388303756714,
-0.6218870878219604,
0.06708304584026337,
-0.19135011732578278,
-0.10030554234981537,
-0.612822413444519,
-0.049135591834783554,
0.24850136041641235,
0.8447526693344116,
-0.8914563059806824,
1.0451502799987793,
0.639045000076294,
-0.25975725054740906,
-0.5422151684761047,
-0.038426175713539124,
0.1723058968782425,
-0.7184275984764099,
0.918003261089325,
0.37377113103866577,
-0.327297568321228,
0.04951602593064308,
-0.8239306807518005,
-0.6147130727767944,
1.1346025466918945,
0.46015504002571106,
-0.43509578704833984,
0.080508753657341,
-0.05026251822710037,
0.37973636388778687,
-0.6914570927619934,
0.2921031415462494,
0.6536797881126404,
0.139095276594162,
0.3446684777736664,
-0.5779325366020203,
-0.21039865911006927,
0.23512734472751617,
-0.10346683859825134,
0.02258172072470188,
-0.615852952003479,
0.8045250773429871,
-0.34781885147094727,
-0.05288221687078476,
-0.12367817759513855,
0.5141160488128662,
0.5629737377166748,
0.38965678215026855,
0.5499796271324158,
0.40710610151290894,
0.5657472610473633,
0.0776991993188858,
1.1179921627044678,
-0.0760510265827179,
0.09742508828639984,
1.2537686824798584,
-0.5232816934585571,
1.0333001613616943,
0.537132203578949,
0.056454144418239594,
0.31699761748313904,
0.430663138628006,
0.17925673723220825,
0.43913936614990234,
0.3016664385795593,
-0.5725504755973816,
-0.5813300013542175,
-0.37494197487831116,
0.23855465650558472,
0.7116889357566833,
0.3514679968357086,
-0.03345043212175369,
-0.3765488564968109,
0.3446710407733917,
-0.053936246782541275,
-0.02645760215818882,
-0.24123768508434296,
0.9076710343360901,
0.3415497839450836,
-0.7563095688819885,
0.5400151014328003,
-0.13515113294124603,
0.7511764764785767,
-0.5748698115348816,
-0.24583707749843597,
-0.10535375028848648,
0.29362666606903076,
-0.0138306375592947,
-0.5793731212615967,
0.13630786538124084,
-0.01554113905876875,
-0.11701582372188568,
-0.10161761939525604,
0.7486891746520996,
-0.5581572651863098,
-0.3177467882633209,
0.22105269134044647,
0.44115665555000305,
0.12728577852249146,
-0.1010303795337677,
-0.6571637988090515,
-0.19198107719421387,
-0.20981444418430328,
-0.13442255556583405,
0.6487054228782654,
0.338158518075943,
-0.2502365708351135,
0.8942172527313232,
0.4948464035987854,
-0.029159214347600937,
-0.03126664087176323,
0.11645940691232681,
0.8327640295028687,
-0.5369857549667358,
-0.09446883201599121,
-1.065894603729248,
0.4308062791824341,
-0.01397909875959158,
-0.530098557472229,
0.48241421580314636,
0.5580506920814514,
1.0625321865081787,
0.05084101855754852,
0.7052187323570251,
0.4168164134025574,
0.15527179837226868,
-0.728037416934967,
0.28208208084106445,
-0.5417665839195251,
0.27701646089553833,
-0.17451678216457367,
-0.8121957778930664,
-0.6692282557487488,
0.6663731336593628,
-0.2953251004219055,
0.006445757579058409,
0.7361908555030823,
0.7620381712913513,
-0.0955297201871872,
-0.3392224907875061,
0.7316912412643433,
0.04591430351138115,
0.377460777759552,
0.8047794699668884,
1.0093263387680054,
-0.15635384619235992,
0.4566287398338318,
-0.14009176194667816,
-0.24265886843204498,
-0.22470150887966156,
-0.949504554271698,
-1.1695961952209473,
-0.4655861258506775,
-0.23233936727046967,
-0.06970933079719543,
-0.007946066558361053,
1.400791883468628,
0.9484357833862305,
-0.8278600573539734,
-0.3731658458709717,
-0.10814552009105682,
0.09460911899805069,
-0.11854425072669983,
-0.148809552192688,
0.3158687949180603,
-0.5061326026916504,
-0.6420526504516602,
0.527701199054718,
0.5572064518928528,
0.08132751286029816,
-0.28314271569252014,
-0.19837725162506104,
-0.35376712679862976,
-0.15175051987171173,
1.072837233543396,
0.4145568013191223,
-0.9200058579444885,
-0.31915587186813354,
-0.15115100145339966,
-0.031042050570249557,
0.028564445674419403,
0.9486408829689026,
-0.8754878640174866,
0.4192148745059967,
0.37310969829559326,
0.7590548396110535,
0.6262077689170837,
-0.022841548547148705,
0.5694417357444763,
-0.9278156757354736,
0.34648582339286804,
0.12973400950431824,
0.5391076803207397,
0.23319435119628906,
-0.03385043889284134,
0.164180725812912,
0.017024442553520203,
-0.32350844144821167,
-0.7043092250823975,
0.470016211271286,
-0.6263499855995178,
-0.6327389478683472,
1.193285584449768,
-0.29256656765937805,
0.007750316057354212,
-0.25952136516571045,
-0.13376888632774353,
0.20960868895053864,
-0.276763379573822,
0.6232287287712097,
0.734408438205719,
-0.3249589800834656,
-0.3544192612171173,
-0.5387387275695801,
0.516218364238739,
0.44525808095932007,
-0.8953049778938293,
0.11556482315063477,
0.6262133717536926,
0.07599814981222153,
-0.24625656008720398,
0.43289464712142944,
0.03160839527845383,
0.2162286937236786,
-0.2390654981136322,
-0.19563110172748566,
-0.009017881937325,
-0.7443508505821228,
-0.4889870882034302,
0.14662854373455048,
0.34128037095069885,
0.16963008046150208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10981v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10981v1
|
A Survey on Retrieval-Augmented Text Generation for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-17T01:27:42 | 2024-04-17T01:27:42 |
Yizheng Huang, Jimmy Huang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) merges retrieval methods with deep
learning advancements to address the static limitations of large language
models (LLMs) by enabling the dynamic integration of up-to-date external
information. This methodology, focusing primarily on the text domain, provides
a cost-effective solution to the generation of plausible but incorrect
responses by LLMs, thereby enhancing the accuracy and reliability of their
outputs through the use of real-world data. As RAG grows in complexity and
incorporates multiple concepts that can influence its performance, this paper
organizes the RAG paradigm into four categories: pre-retrieval, retrieval,
post-retrieval, and generation, offering a detailed perspective from the
retrieval viewpoint. It outlines RAG's evolution and discusses the field's
progression through the analysis of significant studies. Additionally, the
paper introduces evaluation methods for RAG, addressing the challenges faced
and proposing future research directions. By offering an organized framework
and categorization, the study aims to consolidate existing research on RAG,
clarify its technological underpinnings, and highlight its potential to broaden
the adaptability and applications of LLMs.
|
[
-0.4891018569469452,
-0.8164591789245605,
0.6024293899536133,
-0.05084626376628876,
-0.05871659144759178,
0.6094253063201904,
-0.36999791860580444,
-0.5067168474197388,
0.23805706202983856,
0.6404791474342346,
-0.2609039843082428,
-0.03633840009570122,
-0.5772905945777893,
0.20601993799209595,
-0.5001612901687622,
1.0628827810287476,
0.05260012298822403,
-0.1518506407737732,
-0.22420634329319,
0.00561486603692174,
-0.4694819450378418,
-0.6346175074577332,
-0.6521409153938293,
-0.3389413058757782,
0.6483779549598694,
0.23199808597564697,
0.45762982964515686,
0.43813356757164,
0.545703649520874,
0.3090076148509979,
-0.362878680229187,
0.6419989466667175,
-0.5399848818778992,
0.48474693298339844,
-0.2864101231098175,
-0.23422883450984955,
-0.49831900000572205,
-0.05881096422672272,
0.9075755476951599,
0.5481545329093933,
-0.1846289187669754,
0.24904011189937592,
0.10147888213396072,
0.8007152676582336,
-0.829296886920929,
-0.34252914786338806,
-0.8819783926010132,
-0.15976735949516296,
-0.3860258460044861,
-0.4145803153514862,
-0.47950586676597595,
-0.30431050062179565,
0.013617310672998428,
-0.23854981362819672,
0.2920375466346741,
0.10930872708559036,
0.6431396007537842,
0.0911172404885292,
-0.5457710027694702,
-0.5866304636001587,
-0.9895544052124023,
0.8489301204681396,
-0.6239047646522522,
0.43079835176467896,
0.23140184581279755,
0.32288816571235657,
-0.3413325548171997,
-0.8803967833518982,
-0.4941677749156952,
-0.35539141297340393,
0.09590908885002136,
0.10634075850248337,
0.20473609864711761,
-0.22365713119506836,
-0.021603507921099663,
0.6942690014839172,
-0.48167285323143005,
0.21630671620368958,
-0.14982956647872925,
0.19833609461784363,
0.7327314019203186,
0.3120519518852234,
0.23424378037452698,
-0.2569968104362488,
-0.19560028612613678,
0.04310838505625725,
-0.814622700214386,
-0.31096649169921875,
0.23407869040966034,
0.4982372522354126,
0.11780844628810883,
0.6757560968399048,
-0.008844737894833088,
0.6887703537940979,
0.08559609949588776,
-0.20424386858940125,
0.2296656370162964,
-0.32610663771629333,
-0.1560262143611908,
-0.05684279650449753,
0.7693408131599426,
0.030437417328357697,
-0.06473305821418762,
-0.11726197600364685,
-0.4664090871810913,
-0.41472092270851135,
0.4278600513935089,
-0.6970767974853516,
0.22882281243801117,
-0.06996938586235046,
-0.31838372349739075,
-0.4724099934101105,
-0.12691432237625122,
-0.7761734127998352,
-0.7246952652931213,
-0.40067392587661743,
0.11345487833023071,
-0.16443732380867004,
-0.6429521441459656,
-0.05580258369445801,
0.049470461905002594,
0.20542337000370026,
0.17068445682525635,
-0.6215797662734985,
0.2846093773841858,
0.7889150977134705,
0.539540708065033,
-0.33649009466171265,
-0.03135242313146591,
-0.46811774373054504,
0.11459417641162872,
-0.5630291104316711,
0.7563186883926392,
-0.5069727897644043,
-0.46394336223602295,
0.3097355365753174,
-0.189600870013237,
0.29669517278671265,
-0.6539656519889832,
0.6364109516143799,
-0.9928283095359802,
0.2546311020851135,
-0.06200771778821945,
-0.5464789867401123,
-0.03302650898694992,
0.37269049882888794,
-0.5920742750167847,
1.207007646560669,
0.027658941224217415,
-0.7991558313369751,
0.23188616335391998,
-0.23213237524032593,
-0.45207569003105164,
0.36732667684555054,
-0.22225940227508545,
-0.44798651337623596,
0.42599356174468994,
-0.06125206500291824,
0.5117247104644775,
-0.8450456261634827,
0.5404766201972961,
0.03263645991683006,
-0.18687500059604645,
0.33519572019577026,
-0.5043273568153381,
0.3648047149181366,
0.44083672761917114,
-0.1125841960310936,
-0.17644259333610535,
-0.8852573037147522,
0.04369232431054115,
0.3090893030166626,
-0.4449903666973114,
-0.5159180164337158,
0.13919010758399963,
-0.018977943807840347,
0.09352142363786697,
0.3734733760356903,
-0.40369346737861633,
0.23197320103645325,
-0.5014230012893677,
0.06879732757806778,
0.5507866144180298,
0.04198621213436127,
0.5532934665679932,
-0.15126745402812958,
0.5769067406654358,
-0.30388352274894714,
-0.19594106078147888,
-0.2685581147670746,
-0.22353097796440125,
-0.7282431125640869,
-0.05774684622883797,
0.4644872546195984,
0.40073463320732117,
-0.9358199238777161,
0.21647992730140686,
-0.28673937916755676,
-0.6390199661254883,
-0.36141785979270935,
0.0629129484295845,
0.5357069373130798,
0.4502781629562378,
0.33134010434150696,
-0.031510211527347565,
-0.7332449555397034,
-0.6828250885009766,
-0.36013489961624146,
-0.01997469551861286,
0.17433227598667145,
0.5879107117652893,
0.22198544442653656,
-0.44146087765693665,
0.7289913296699524,
-0.4928932785987854,
0.03586960211396217,
-0.30221834778785706,
0.1950814574956894,
0.24744677543640137,
0.23640689253807068,
0.36724621057510376,
-1.0051695108413696,
-0.4943678081035614,
0.3451032042503357,
-0.5105857253074646,
-0.11204750835895538,
0.12327314168214798,
0.15692080557346344,
0.4999241232872009,
0.5491418242454529,
-0.45850810408592224,
0.19461853802204132,
0.7746146321296692,
-0.06702778488397598,
0.7181137800216675,
-0.2172996699810028,
0.2802824378013611,
-1.2971312999725342,
0.15394051373004913,
-0.24028636515140533,
-0.1607726514339447,
-0.6516127586364746,
0.22550594806671143,
-0.03920499235391617,
-0.028048628941178322,
-0.2382754236459732,
0.8618808388710022,
-0.6174948811531067,
-0.17492489516735077,
-0.6415972113609314,
0.24761922657489777,
-0.061087772250175476,
-0.05319620668888092,
-0.17480501532554626,
0.9587035775184631,
0.12680786848068237,
-0.7727600932121277,
0.40965908765792847,
-0.015743816271424294,
-0.3167662024497986,
0.1908450573682785,
-0.36894652247428894,
0.277261346578598,
-0.3020840883255005,
0.2737543284893036,
-0.8425527215003967,
-0.39067038893699646,
0.003309291321784258,
-0.6048287749290466,
0.7602188587188721,
-0.05243410915136337,
-0.5486123561859131,
-0.29570746421813965,
-0.13684001564979553,
0.5674319267272949,
0.627476155757904,
-0.442689448595047,
0.6602329611778259,
0.5104885697364807,
-0.31239020824432373,
-0.8362017273902893,
-0.5206107497215271,
0.27486395835876465,
-0.1369018256664276,
-0.2904002368450165,
0.4182751178741455,
0.024379746988415718,
-0.41799649596214294,
-0.010643969289958477,
0.07366058230400085,
-0.04347488284111023,
-0.10227654874324799,
-0.17610929906368256,
0.1722521185874939,
-0.26251208782196045,
0.3302539587020874,
-0.0881444662809372,
0.1634914129972458,
-0.23340436816215515,
-0.05652747303247452,
0.7646111249923706,
0.09272906184196472,
-0.014956989325582981,
0.1536874771118164,
0.22684140503406525,
0.3714456558227539,
-0.5280014276504517,
0.659370481967926,
0.5118383765220642,
-0.1499737650156021,
-0.42068880796432495,
-0.8056756258010864,
0.18481284379959106,
-0.493897408246994,
0.41443830728530884,
-0.40320900082588196,
-1.1299469470977783,
0.3504035770893097,
-0.33647915720939636,
0.15647639334201813,
0.5858827829360962,
0.7370285391807556,
-0.050435230135917664,
0.8285803198814392,
0.6678196787834167,
0.2578031122684479,
0.3894076645374298,
-0.047697748988866806,
0.13067126274108887,
-1.1030333042144775,
-0.217461958527565,
-0.6736581921577454,
-0.02062007412314415,
-0.9115977883338928,
-0.5800485014915466,
0.19853141903877258,
0.22600312530994415,
-0.32514896988868713,
0.14104704558849335,
-0.5910229086875916,
0.2515780031681061,
0.16740213334560394,
-0.23069876432418823,
0.32946476340293884,
0.0437275655567646,
0.13036270439624786,
-0.02486824244260788,
-0.5687866806983948,
-0.41404759883880615,
1.0501480102539062,
0.2821280062198639,
0.737469494342804,
0.2151271402835846,
0.7395678758621216,
0.24780720472335815,
0.5556861758232117,
-0.7267229557037354,
0.5789511799812317,
-0.5226272344589233,
-0.6962447166442871,
-0.20114532113075256,
-0.6541565656661987,
-1.1622107028961182,
0.13945429027080536,
-0.32333990931510925,
-0.23088636994361877,
-0.06752733886241913,
0.09196417778730392,
-0.014938517473638058,
0.29917746782302856,
-0.43300721049308777,
0.2477305382490158,
-0.3721312880516052,
-0.3282549977302551,
-0.02782541513442993,
-0.3715953230857849,
0.7037217617034912,
-0.46129655838012695,
0.4541093111038208,
0.07616731524467468,
-0.2464177906513214,
0.5110790133476257,
-0.08710876852273941,
0.4077327847480774,
0.03263548016548157,
-0.5250480771064758,
0.5063544511795044,
0.035869598388671875,
0.5624359846115112,
-0.130651593208313,
-0.09130861610174179,
-0.23604486882686615,
-0.3439526855945587,
0.07098696380853653,
-0.5340537428855896,
0.8508265018463135,
-0.47474372386932373,
-0.5081645846366882,
-0.42811617255210876,
-0.6208807826042175,
-0.49562981724739075,
0.33355051279067993,
0.14179733395576477,
0.5104169249534607,
-0.07443058490753174,
0.35192105174064636,
0.8255152702331543,
-0.6932356357574463,
0.29897186160087585,
0.41760507225990295,
-0.7522464394569397,
-0.6379731893539429,
1.143548607826233,
0.14191167056560516,
0.18694426119327545,
0.5057739615440369,
0.19769887626171112,
-0.25644218921661377,
-0.6127474308013916,
-0.3865599036216736,
0.4274818003177643,
-0.38099515438079834,
-0.40899792313575745,
-0.6034320592880249,
-0.4128541648387909,
-0.5333744883537292,
0.01549597829580307,
-0.5051907300949097,
-0.26237353682518005,
-0.3189907968044281,
0.11548790335655212,
0.29954203963279724,
0.9859355688095093,
0.1727229207754135,
0.16356873512268066,
-0.9444339275360107,
0.4638509452342987,
0.2647949755191803,
0.5346609354019165,
0.09894099831581116,
-0.5587203502655029,
-0.3143494725227356,
-0.03529400750994682,
-0.16979087889194489,
-0.5761039853096008,
0.3574206531047821,
0.07160107046365738,
0.42465415596961975,
-0.06350646913051605,
0.028596218675374985,
0.5651467442512512,
-0.9574348330497742,
0.8907999992370605,
0.2206948697566986,
-0.4748312532901764,
0.3223970830440521,
-0.5032204985618591,
0.10737555474042892,
0.3070545196533203,
0.23705469071865082,
-0.3881708085536957,
-0.2556818723678589,
-0.5697673559188843,
-1.0444239377975464,
0.46725791692733765,
-0.037552982568740845,
0.46151673793792725,
-0.09091296046972275,
0.5544759035110474,
-0.003149741794914007,
0.26017624139785767,
-0.38581952452659607,
-0.2762354612350464,
0.33486464619636536,
-0.12470172345638275,
-0.20828494429588318,
-0.5599018931388855,
0.1435234099626541,
0.0660715326666832,
0.7372371554374695,
0.06772913783788681,
0.07308094948530197,
-0.0438697375357151,
-0.049024730920791626,
0.010342552326619625,
0.4102526903152466,
0.6246150135993958,
0.7395203709602356,
-0.10910332947969437,
0.04923626035451889,
0.1724408119916916,
-0.5556312799453735,
0.27670127153396606,
0.08392124623060226,
-0.19642044603824615,
0.09234181046485901,
0.33787208795547485,
0.6726067066192627,
-0.004562912508845329,
-0.7351917624473572,
0.38888242840766907,
0.021860796958208084,
-0.1398555338382721,
-0.4755394756793976,
-0.013374701142311096,
-0.12804651260375977,
0.23742727935314178,
0.7344246506690979,
-0.21189163625240326,
0.22441378235816956,
-0.5082529187202454,
0.23446758091449738,
0.5033562779426575,
-0.10042187571525574,
-0.1197531670331955,
0.45285025238990784,
0.14172671735286713,
-0.4529935121536255,
0.2503369152545929,
-0.17145197093486786,
-0.3770091235637665,
0.33313778042793274,
0.611284077167511,
1.0241385698318481,
-0.39617064595222473,
0.02449796162545681,
0.34977009892463684,
0.2416374683380127,
-0.09526587277650833,
0.10789269208908081,
0.12290634959936142,
-0.6353694200515747,
-0.9860929250717163,
-1.0626473426818848,
-0.3130629062652588,
0.3687536418437958,
-0.48262202739715576,
0.20453977584838867,
-0.2693880796432495,
-0.36844104528427124,
-0.15346097946166992,
0.07013610005378723,
-0.4239218235015869,
0.3941820561885834,
0.29244399070739746,
0.8749087452888489,
-0.30624234676361084,
0.5463971495628357,
0.879256010055542,
-0.1947941929101944,
-0.5963302254676819,
0.12440751492977142,
-0.22582174837589264,
-0.5634947419166565,
0.9114614129066467,
-0.17575961351394653,
-0.3896421492099762,
0.040691085159778595,
-0.5284470319747925,
-0.9798671007156372,
0.7924062609672546,
0.11324476450681686,
-0.3778526782989502,
-0.2388656586408615,
0.024667197838425636,
0.6666578054428101,
-0.21641144156455994,
0.022105544805526733,
0.4363672435283661,
0.2862941026687622,
0.2183544784784317,
-0.9539365172386169,
-0.20557409524917603,
-0.08910085260868073,
0.40508368611335754,
0.47085121273994446,
-0.4941170811653137,
0.834248423576355,
0.16616438329219818,
-0.267959862947464,
0.26806822419166565,
0.7262603640556335,
0.43613702058792114,
0.1981956660747528,
0.32162976264953613,
0.576640784740448,
0.42838138341903687,
0.016633275896310806,
1.102897047996521,
-0.09880229830741882,
0.23209863901138306,
1.2484681606292725,
-0.3245962858200073,
0.9227030873298645,
0.29263415932655334,
-0.20806068181991577,
0.4141509234905243,
0.21985960006713867,
0.24415551126003265,
0.3216657042503357,
0.3187018632888794,
-0.41822656989097595,
0.023330820724368095,
-0.38458946347236633,
-0.469205379486084,
0.4890453517436981,
0.5100419521331787,
-0.4948514997959137,
-0.16636024415493011,
0.12276491522789001,
-0.07458062469959259,
0.2874175012111664,
-0.4413292407989502,
1.0114247798919678,
0.07094839215278625,
-0.7169849276542664,
0.6790034770965576,
0.12520349025726318,
0.7695738673210144,
-0.5130062699317932,
-0.2326846718788147,
-0.19150015711784363,
0.12318143993616104,
-0.14095471799373627,
-0.926766574382782,
0.25798508524894714,
0.3057631850242615,
-0.32468628883361816,
-0.35026323795318604,
1.0004645586013794,
-0.357645720243454,
-0.42885780334472656,
0.1458752304315567,
0.5745555758476257,
0.06762738525867462,
0.1947890967130661,
-0.44227632880210876,
0.3956874907016754,
-0.1601654589176178,
-0.46892985701560974,
0.40792712569236755,
0.7023177742958069,
0.015887167304754257,
0.5204746127128601,
0.5856746435165405,
0.21860834956169128,
0.1466144472360611,
-0.003602013224735856,
0.8300212621688843,
-0.649135172367096,
0.04381468892097473,
-0.634833037853241,
0.5902913808822632,
-0.08687307685613632,
-0.18286128342151642,
0.8000458478927612,
0.5870702862739563,
0.6451461911201477,
0.07829491049051285,
0.7776824235916138,
-0.1806166172027588,
1.1327569484710693,
-0.4376944601535797,
0.7512157559394836,
-0.8555914163589478,
0.1546841412782669,
-0.4479271471500397,
-1.0518505573272705,
-0.30851244926452637,
0.10288894176483154,
-0.09231112897396088,
0.20495624840259552,
0.3590906858444214,
0.4915503263473511,
0.12427230179309845,
-0.38249412178993225,
0.22052770853042603,
0.14293554425239563,
0.378726989030838,
0.10119248181581497,
1.0106513500213623,
-0.3967542052268982,
0.5336800217628479,
0.1481800675392151,
-0.15244978666305542,
-0.22829104959964752,
-0.8389564156532288,
-0.64327073097229,
-0.6854146122932434,
0.0021621922496706247,
-0.3894314765930176,
-0.08302205055952072,
0.6690680384635925,
0.23582766950130463,
-0.5211664438247681,
-0.27950215339660645,
-0.06052650138735771,
-0.09069080650806427,
0.2520042657852173,
-0.2266383320093155,
0.3783057928085327,
-0.7544872164726257,
-0.9554005861282349,
0.44418081641197205,
0.0905325785279274,
-0.07022618502378464,
-0.3420298099517822,
-0.0990687683224678,
-0.3786247670650482,
0.09464941918849945,
1.0474909543991089,
0.3630693852901459,
-0.6331931948661804,
0.014232316985726357,
0.11965882033109665,
-0.2741717994213104,
-0.2897672653198242,
0.743380069732666,
-0.7864071726799011,
0.4024243652820587,
0.5758177638053894,
1.2444958686828613,
0.39980408549308777,
-0.04399807006120682,
0.5081773996353149,
-0.8955603241920471,
0.018638605251908302,
0.47507697343826294,
0.02045208215713501,
0.445904016494751,
-0.1677146852016449,
0.5126442909240723,
0.004593390505760908,
-0.7999734878540039,
-1.2304327487945557,
0.33756276965141296,
-0.57557213306427,
-0.35564011335372925,
1.3168368339538574,
0.25532424449920654,
0.010102775879204273,
0.1026998907327652,
-0.20056381821632385,
0.25626620650291443,
0.02097657509148121,
0.4723866879940033,
0.5381449460983276,
0.021227886900305748,
-0.34545907378196716,
-0.6361125111579895,
0.5756082534790039,
0.1772751808166504,
-0.7597835659980774,
0.21536804735660553,
0.7429479360580444,
-0.04151073843240738,
0.36961469054222107,
0.48239073157310486,
-0.2052241563796997,
-0.03885365277528763,
-0.29500874876976013,
0.11768864095211029,
0.11120985448360443,
-0.37724271416664124,
-0.2481282353401184,
0.13373522460460663,
0.34664466977119446,
0.28722742199897766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13081v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13081v1
|
SuRe: Summarizing Retrievals using Answer Candidates for Open-domain QA of LLMs
| 2024-04-17T01:15:54 | 2024-04-17T01:15:54 |
Jaehyung Kim, Jaehyun Nam, Sangwoo Mo, Jongjin Park, Sang-Woo Lee, Minjoon Seo, Jung-Woo Ha, Jinwoo Shin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have made significant advancements in various
natural language processing tasks, including question answering (QA) tasks.
While incorporating new information with the retrieval of relevant passages is
a promising way to improve QA with LLMs, the existing methods often require
additional fine-tuning which becomes infeasible with recent LLMs. Augmenting
retrieved passages via prompting has the potential to address this limitation,
but this direction has been limitedly explored. To this end, we design a simple
yet effective framework to enhance open-domain QA (ODQA) with LLMs, based on
the summarized retrieval (SuRe). SuRe helps LLMs predict more accurate answers
for a given question, which are well-supported by the summarized retrieval that
could be viewed as an explicit rationale extracted from the retrieved passages.
Specifically, SuRe first constructs summaries of the retrieved passages for
each of the multiple answer candidates. Then, SuRe confirms the most plausible
answer from the candidate set by evaluating the validity and ranking of the
generated summaries. Experimental results on diverse ODQA benchmarks
demonstrate the superiority of SuRe, with improvements of up to 4.6% in exact
match (EM) and 4.0% in F1 score over standard prompting approaches. SuRe also
can be integrated with a broad range of retrieval methods and LLMs. Finally,
the generated summaries from SuRe show additional advantages to measure the
importance of retrieved passages and serve as more preferred rationales by
models and humans.
|
[
-0.5683207511901855,
-0.7447937726974487,
0.8876422643661499,
-0.08825431019067764,
-0.2389908730983734,
-0.09764313697814941,
-0.16640330851078033,
-0.2683526277542114,
0.36234086751937866,
0.5636940002441406,
-0.3249530494213104,
-0.3270243704319,
-0.20923882722854614,
0.362764835357666,
-0.35972559452056885,
1.0359148979187012,
0.104060597717762,
0.11708627641201019,
-0.3590463101863861,
-0.21302469074726105,
-0.5644399523735046,
-0.41648122668266296,
-0.5343254208564758,
0.001106845447793603,
0.4474537670612335,
0.5252494215965271,
0.6481923460960388,
0.36797812581062317,
0.42866769433021545,
0.19651924073696136,
-0.4180371165275574,
0.42446374893188477,
-0.4887506663799286,
0.4054795503616333,
-0.248494490981102,
-0.552697479724884,
-0.7601081728935242,
-0.10193239897489548,
0.600177526473999,
0.7055330872535706,
-0.23120427131652832,
0.16047422587871552,
0.05366574972867966,
0.5525871515274048,
-0.7382650971412659,
0.010442462749779224,
-0.632623016834259,
-0.2623666524887085,
0.09191926568746567,
-0.49592092633247375,
-0.3687029182910919,
-0.7383601665496826,
0.35943934321403503,
-0.6127619743347168,
0.13776274025440216,
-0.034349337220191956,
0.6268935203552246,
0.14980894327163696,
-0.4748501479625702,
-0.3459044396877289,
-0.34035661816596985,
0.744898796081543,
-0.9948170781135559,
0.1764126420021057,
0.16466963291168213,
0.45027321577072144,
-0.031914468854665756,
-0.6859002113342285,
-0.5894548296928406,
-0.17632941901683807,
-0.08610999584197998,
0.45437565445899963,
0.1532197743654251,
0.19025880098342896,
0.10701902210712433,
0.6257641315460205,
-0.39689716696739197,
-0.06036262959241867,
-0.2270497977733612,
-0.1844712197780609,
0.5223724246025085,
0.22356753051280975,
0.29882174730300903,
0.08545825630426407,
-0.43667641282081604,
0.05237885192036629,
-0.917418897151947,
0.24585409462451935,
0.04166342690587044,
0.46833622455596924,
0.2350449562072754,
0.7346788644790649,
-0.6404985189437866,
0.849542498588562,
-0.019999422132968903,
-0.020785851404070854,
0.05494897812604904,
-0.5128597021102905,
-0.11862551420927048,
-0.27355003356933594,
0.4058031141757965,
0.5047151446342468,
0.47681865096092224,
-0.12054720520973206,
-0.2917942404747009,
-0.5666782855987549,
0.12729130685329437,
-0.9036884903907776,
-0.07148054987192154,
0.6846150755882263,
-0.32682204246520996,
0.16013450920581818,
0.32765257358551025,
-0.6218827962875366,
-0.17913323640823364,
-0.4225541353225708,
0.5870486497879028,
-0.3564796447753906,
-0.16726049780845642,
0.4473462402820587,
-0.22713661193847656,
0.41859665513038635,
0.6655464172363281,
-0.622657835483551,
0.04792706295847893,
0.6503434181213379,
0.6920136213302612,
-0.23301737010478973,
-0.06034459173679352,
-1.085243821144104,
-0.15935048460960388,
-0.4033523201942444,
0.7875387668609619,
-0.3908468782901764,
-0.37560778856277466,
0.27953487634658813,
-0.2842068374156952,
0.0065340306609869,
-0.7914155721664429,
0.5972964763641357,
-1.116640567779541,
0.4936945140361786,
-0.36798837780952454,
-0.6407313942909241,
-0.04036211594939232,
0.4166170060634613,
-0.6944385766983032,
0.9172738194465637,
-0.013773081824183464,
-0.6692098379135132,
0.05086224526166916,
-0.611799418926239,
-0.19613023102283478,
0.0716012716293335,
-0.11352891474962234,
-0.19847285747528076,
0.12949223816394806,
0.5580976605415344,
0.5552833676338196,
0.020668992772698402,
0.1886122077703476,
-0.05602278560400009,
-0.4155757427215576,
0.26705288887023926,
-0.04056194797158241,
0.7942745089530945,
0.18029610812664032,
0.1644199639558792,
0.3777523934841156,
-0.3791094422340393,
0.4167923629283905,
-0.07170283049345016,
-0.5899314880371094,
-0.2895010709762573,
-0.19279111921787262,
-0.6086049675941467,
0.005202054046094418,
0.41639944911003113,
-0.39316168427467346,
0.18829989433288574,
-0.6043703556060791,
-0.09283477813005447,
0.5252217650413513,
0.47666946053504944,
0.5646918416023254,
-0.4863610863685608,
0.7947988510131836,
-0.19311195611953735,
-0.07085729390382767,
-0.5073205828666687,
-0.6698689460754395,
-0.3674718737602234,
-0.5586652755737305,
0.29276037216186523,
0.6281422972679138,
-1.0027700662612915,
0.15846846997737885,
-0.21054713428020477,
-0.07323069870471954,
-0.5389407277107239,
0.026878932490944862,
0.43358197808265686,
0.43103542923927307,
0.4610576033592224,
-0.12513166666030884,
-0.47264301776885986,
-0.6319541335105896,
-0.3926074206829071,
-0.27081331610679626,
-0.4306259751319885,
0.18678633868694305,
0.26900818943977356,
0.5446348786354065,
1.311462640762329,
-0.82062828540802,
-0.2817123830318451,
-0.3738338053226471,
-0.2951546907424927,
0.4794149398803711,
-0.05736524239182472,
0.47864633798599243,
-0.824828565120697,
-0.5688554644584656,
-0.3097419738769531,
-0.7159509062767029,
-0.11042126268148422,
0.16760261356830597,
-0.32772403955459595,
-0.4195805490016937,
0.4082081913948059,
-0.6438332796096802,
0.2248755842447281,
-0.025816738605499268,
-0.3081872761249542,
0.8188015222549438,
-0.1747317612171173,
0.2872525751590729,
-1.1188551187515259,
0.018098890781402588,
-0.22133323550224304,
-0.2582626938819885,
-0.6573225259780884,
0.5389437079429626,
0.21859867870807648,
0.15106646716594696,
-0.5642422437667847,
0.6547545194625854,
-0.45270535349845886,
0.12514296174049377,
-0.36634108424186707,
0.5499445199966431,
-0.03631581366062164,
0.2214135080575943,
0.032094914466142654,
1.1251572370529175,
0.4928775727748871,
-0.999187171459198,
0.06995547562837601,
0.5792044997215271,
-0.26870134472846985,
0.6407037973403931,
-0.7531999349594116,
-0.04190681874752045,
-0.5365057587623596,
0.25586485862731934,
-1.0210239887237549,
-0.3586001396179199,
-0.09892512112855911,
-0.7212401032447815,
0.10361537337303162,
0.23384085297584534,
-0.3322980999946594,
-0.13494233787059784,
-0.746823787689209,
0.2339836210012436,
0.42329904437065125,
-0.6683930158615112,
0.5825685858726501,
0.19067077338695526,
-0.5421195030212402,
-0.6163750886917114,
-0.135477676987648,
-0.03341003507375717,
-0.10499156266450882,
-0.5384474396705627,
0.3242422640323639,
-0.45387935638427734,
-0.35723215341567993,
-0.10618586838245392,
-0.16820798814296722,
-0.1588987559080124,
0.20689000189304352,
-0.26489531993865967,
0.43127790093421936,
-0.4851748049259186,
0.17622709274291992,
0.11878971755504608,
0.00634240685030818,
-0.0103464899584651,
-0.26191335916519165,
0.22692741453647614,
-0.1219172403216362,
-0.1240815818309784,
-0.13312676548957825,
0.5165451169013977,
0.27321958541870117,
-0.7935646176338196,
0.6867577433586121,
0.22380530834197998,
-0.39790236949920654,
-0.2503131330013275,
-0.3102940618991852,
-0.5808548927307129,
-0.4186094403266907,
0.21641042828559875,
-0.5249409079551697,
-1.2248225212097168,
0.5879873633384705,
0.10901323705911636,
0.4529479146003723,
0.39855948090553284,
0.4814222455024719,
-0.17247852683067322,
1.0705493688583374,
0.4872872233390808,
0.048874322324991226,
0.34286096692085266,
-0.15490776300430298,
0.15710817277431488,
-0.8925806879997253,
-0.09797926992177963,
-0.7051709890365601,
0.15218661725521088,
-0.05954843387007713,
-0.28916919231414795,
0.6284193992614746,
0.522670328617096,
0.1377563178539276,
-0.0017195187974721193,
-0.1874983310699463,
0.702398955821991,
0.4547197222709656,
0.07643699645996094,
0.5746921896934509,
-0.13413341343402863,
-0.1753651350736618,
0.13358846306800842,
-0.4733472168445587,
-0.6640568375587463,
1.0717178583145142,
0.19262559711933136,
0.5120328664779663,
0.5853883624076843,
0.8912235498428345,
0.20289531350135803,
0.4726364016532898,
-0.7091202139854431,
0.7608086466789246,
0.2100997269153595,
-0.7652491927146912,
-0.41503122448921204,
-0.3861158490180969,
-0.8636775016784668,
0.5072038173675537,
-0.11326266080141068,
-0.7267910838127136,
0.028428031131625175,
0.16762617230415344,
-0.8100247979164124,
-0.026898128911852837,
-0.38846006989479065,
0.4672812521457672,
0.11399839073419571,
-0.10333286970853806,
0.06874218583106995,
-0.6086335778236389,
0.40238243341445923,
0.06857046484947205,
0.05428452789783478,
0.04605899006128311,
-0.42389798164367676,
0.5778424739837646,
-0.4015747904777527,
0.6032753586769104,
-0.26884910464286804,
-0.44153475761413574,
0.5947520136833191,
-0.06755927205085754,
0.5583142042160034,
0.12890151143074036,
-0.31167861819267273,
-0.4920210540294647,
0.2112823724746704,
-0.41690346598625183,
-0.9229914546012878,
0.5842569470405579,
-0.3282792866230011,
-0.7241129875183105,
-0.04239384084939957,
-0.3689471185207367,
-0.5126281380653381,
0.2934475839138031,
-0.1413482427597046,
0.48024412989616394,
0.02177589386701584,
0.18148650228977203,
0.9958580732345581,
-0.09488728642463684,
0.1760490983724594,
0.844715416431427,
-0.44993606209754944,
-0.5746374726295471,
0.8231524229049683,
-0.1398516297340393,
0.38730454444885254,
0.5052520632743835,
0.2754819095134735,
-0.6975472569465637,
-0.878454327583313,
-0.5575982332229614,
0.356353759765625,
-0.8713233470916748,
-0.3337014317512512,
-0.6000036597251892,
-0.038870420306921005,
-0.5114918947219849,
0.10301687568426132,
0.3169851005077362,
-0.4696245491504669,
-0.30504077672958374,
-0.34521135687828064,
0.19020763039588928,
0.5592390298843384,
0.3332560062408447,
0.1828179806470871,
-0.9091837406158447,
0.5283355712890625,
0.43792545795440674,
0.35083824396133423,
0.16399012506008148,
-0.7487648129463196,
-0.2246173620223999,
0.020234551280736923,
-0.27488648891448975,
-1.1845096349716187,
0.1760922372341156,
0.41875967383384705,
0.8590441942214966,
0.2096763700246811,
0.4936612546443939,
0.533688485622406,
-0.34595683217048645,
1.0523583889007568,
-0.10164394974708557,
-0.5531107783317566,
0.5764131546020508,
-0.3468652665615082,
0.4089987874031067,
0.742010235786438,
0.5016931891441345,
-0.10373355448246002,
-0.6699369549751282,
-0.3303855061531067,
-0.8871423602104187,
0.5228219628334045,
0.2016981840133667,
0.17519055306911469,
-0.367727130651474,
0.58176589012146,
0.08535995334386826,
0.24051184952259064,
-0.3351462185382843,
-0.2513982057571411,
0.18042178452014923,
-0.345648854970932,
0.12993396818637848,
-0.3331372141838074,
-0.00042734952876344323,
0.17300809919834137,
0.9219820499420166,
-0.5267418622970581,
-0.00663224421441555,
0.5589279532432556,
-0.1055578738451004,
0.19301606714725494,
0.5700298547744751,
0.3950951099395752,
0.8651394248008728,
-0.47697561979293823,
-0.014968346804380417,
0.25504815578460693,
-0.2641112506389618,
-0.024389946833252907,
-0.03407284617424011,
-0.3847862780094147,
0.03674584627151489,
0.2593561112880707,
0.19531108438968658,
-0.15144680440425873,
-1.0222313404083252,
0.6971709728240967,
-0.16181887686252594,
-0.1861596405506134,
-0.001508231507614255,
0.09435420483350754,
0.19391800463199615,
0.2961394190788269,
0.7514716982841492,
-0.3656483292579651,
0.41141968965530396,
-0.4751928746700287,
0.41531699895858765,
0.45925432443618774,
-0.3499942719936371,
-0.05342528223991394,
0.6710334420204163,
0.24915403127670288,
-0.15087836980819702,
0.29773208498954773,
-0.26048147678375244,
-0.5128670334815979,
0.4990701973438263,
0.519308865070343,
0.7707999348640442,
-0.21498584747314453,
0.11685376614332199,
0.5997335910797119,
-0.0013335880357772112,
-0.16031549870967865,
0.9003146886825562,
-0.27215126156806946,
-0.5144655108451843,
-0.6881527304649353,
-0.5568133592605591,
-0.5910509824752808,
-0.15362386405467987,
-0.8337706327438354,
0.05770452693104744,
-0.15029609203338623,
-0.09478216618299484,
-0.20808109641075134,
-0.12531138956546783,
-0.25308096408843994,
0.39112430810928345,
-0.2643657624721527,
1.176825761795044,
-0.38959357142448425,
0.4964076578617096,
0.8663977980613708,
-0.6308724880218506,
-0.808070719242096,
0.26823994517326355,
-0.2634621858596802,
-0.4534711539745331,
0.26488444209098816,
0.1570100635290146,
-0.19787035882472992,
0.14237619936466217,
-0.43238961696624756,
-0.7332043647766113,
1.1214008331298828,
0.34868040680885315,
-0.22740168869495392,
-0.07756472378969193,
-0.21170710027217865,
0.5369068384170532,
-0.3009025454521179,
0.5461227893829346,
0.3239218294620514,
0.15835829079151154,
0.16518621146678925,
-0.8965938687324524,
0.18715719878673553,
-0.13011521100997925,
-0.28402000665664673,
0.1882774978876114,
-0.34992602467536926,
0.6991177797317505,
-0.7397814989089966,
-0.4226149320602417,
0.5826505422592163,
1.0158360004425049,
0.45127442479133606,
0.43138301372528076,
0.4226696193218231,
0.14117088913917542,
0.9222176671028137,
0.07332386076450348,
1.0566447973251343,
-0.1773698329925537,
0.11813588440418243,
1.2940505743026733,
-0.16650868952274323,
1.2946498394012451,
0.292309045791626,
-0.2851914167404175,
0.24158868193626404,
0.5338211059570312,
0.8129388689994812,
0.4334261417388916,
0.21416619420051575,
-0.5267388224601746,
-0.4115820825099945,
-0.18664953112602234,
-0.434158056974411,
0.07115121930837631,
0.22545795142650604,
-0.27588552236557007,
-0.40959885716438293,
-0.048951320350170135,
-0.18898627161979675,
0.3769984245300293,
-0.3387075960636139,
0.9219321608543396,
0.138556569814682,
-1.0778703689575195,
0.5434460043907166,
0.038532182574272156,
0.5773160457611084,
-0.6058000326156616,
-0.20344090461730957,
-0.4944583773612976,
-0.11289515346288681,
-0.28475242853164673,
-0.9888341426849365,
0.09820196032524109,
-0.021801570430397987,
-0.2620057463645935,
-0.21449364721775055,
0.6374204158782959,
-0.673252284526825,
0.10711033642292023,
-0.057948436588048935,
0.8001749515533447,
0.2380734086036682,
-0.4606883227825165,
-0.21943141520023346,
-0.5089171528816223,
0.17696534097194672,
-0.04646342992782593,
0.2310660481452942,
0.3261067271232605,
-0.19056196510791779,
0.6708253622055054,
0.6517614722251892,
0.0721018984913826,
0.11675058305263519,
0.3306759297847748,
0.8663256168365479,
-0.6681212186813354,
-0.558326780796051,
-0.6197506785392761,
0.6243648529052734,
-0.14582888782024384,
-0.16030418872833252,
0.9112579822540283,
0.7201928496360779,
0.5920072793960571,
-0.08931181579828262,
0.6337197422981262,
0.19798842072486877,
0.9977271556854248,
-0.8099391460418701,
0.3771438002586365,
-0.661637544631958,
0.5487052798271179,
0.08375703543424606,
-0.9548196196556091,
-0.29873496294021606,
0.2511192560195923,
-0.18083757162094116,
0.0885753259062767,
0.5263908505439758,
0.7877506017684937,
0.15912094712257385,
0.16200286149978638,
0.3251585364341736,
0.01835438422858715,
0.4416999816894531,
0.3458687663078308,
0.8988358378410339,
-0.2147173434495926,
0.6083125472068787,
0.27442190051078796,
-0.3615383803844452,
-0.22965264320373535,
-0.7349463105201721,
-0.7787943482398987,
-0.48904821276664734,
-0.29511356353759766,
-0.42341485619544983,
0.09817086905241013,
0.78741055727005,
0.4017794132232666,
-0.8492314219474792,
-0.03335791081190109,
0.3523779511451721,
0.23276278376579285,
-0.2779058516025543,
-0.26745545864105225,
0.33738669753074646,
-0.41849544644355774,
-0.6581704616546631,
0.6040312647819519,
0.11959146708250046,
-0.02450602874159813,
-0.25625327229499817,
-0.14948788285255432,
-0.13013523817062378,
0.3037808835506439,
0.814102292060852,
0.3100590705871582,
-0.6986721754074097,
-0.2691898047924042,
0.4140065312385559,
-0.06515911966562271,
-0.10621561855077744,
0.7189459800720215,
-0.9803978800773621,
0.5335020422935486,
0.6809195876121521,
0.7886502742767334,
0.05001359060406685,
0.4188670814037323,
0.7190337777137756,
-0.8991216421127319,
-0.6506868004798889,
0.511126697063446,
0.24952462315559387,
0.22106990218162537,
-0.14711713790893555,
0.40255483984947205,
-0.28920719027519226,
-0.3722398281097412,
-0.7751856446266174,
0.19749099016189575,
-0.9981088638305664,
-0.18399278819561005,
1.139621615409851,
-0.33202821016311646,
0.014629507437348366,
-0.25904884934425354,
-0.5688704252243042,
-0.15553413331508636,
-0.4321942627429962,
0.5755971670150757,
0.4803268611431122,
-0.1260146200656891,
-0.027445660904049873,
-0.5136232376098633,
0.3726538121700287,
0.5143911242485046,
-0.9623286128044128,
-0.025511447340250015,
0.6701030731201172,
0.21378013491630554,
0.1609867513179779,
1.061239242553711,
-0.2132159173488617,
0.5218610167503357,
-0.6132766604423523,
-0.3992844820022583,
-0.09168794006109238,
-0.3319016695022583,
-0.3707317113876343,
0.5732940435409546,
0.40698811411857605,
-0.35010331869125366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10975v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10975v1
|
Procedural Dilemma Generation for Evaluating Moral Reasoning in Humans and Language Models
| 2024-04-17T01:13:04 | 2024-04-17T01:13:04 |
Jan-Philipp Fränken, Kanishk Gandhi, Tori Qiu, Ayesha Khawaja, Noah D. Goodman, Tobias Gerstenberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As AI systems like language models are increasingly integrated into
decision-making processes affecting people's lives, it's critical to ensure
that these systems have sound moral reasoning. To test whether they do, we need
to develop systematic evaluations. We provide a framework that uses a language
model to translate causal graphs that capture key aspects of moral dilemmas
into prompt templates. With this framework, we procedurally generated a large
and diverse set of moral dilemmas -- the OffTheRails benchmark -- consisting of
50 scenarios and 400 unique test items. We collected moral permissibility and
intention judgments from human participants for a subset of our items and
compared these judgments to those from two language models (GPT-4 and Claude-2)
across eight conditions. We find that moral dilemmas in which the harm is a
necessary means (as compared to a side effect) resulted in lower permissibility
and higher intention ratings for both participants and language models. The
same pattern was observed for evitable versus inevitable harmful outcomes.
However, there was no clear effect of whether the harm resulted from an agent's
action versus from having omitted to act. We discuss limitations of our prompt
generation pipeline and opportunities for improving scenarios to increase the
strength of experimental effects.
|
[
-0.23318463563919067,
-0.9782325625419617,
0.9645920991897583,
0.2854284942150116,
-0.18001633882522583,
-0.27683818340301514,
0.12105952948331833,
-0.10424484312534332,
-0.3514394462108612,
0.548978328704834,
-0.651076078414917,
-0.318987637758255,
-0.2499634474515915,
0.3051309585571289,
-0.1892557144165039,
0.971889078617096,
0.202964648604393,
0.17019173502922058,
-0.15522271394729614,
-0.08447521924972534,
-0.564720094203949,
-0.395237535238266,
-0.9897032976150513,
-0.11413688212633133,
0.4064524173736572,
0.3079206943511963,
0.6211850047111511,
0.4353000819683075,
0.46336841583251953,
0.4497841000556946,
0.005042228847742081,
-0.14680568873882294,
-0.5762583017349243,
0.12772056460380554,
-0.44628679752349854,
-0.29718923568725586,
-0.2525089383125305,
0.31517598032951355,
0.2984025478363037,
0.6167006492614746,
-0.32490235567092896,
0.16788043081760406,
-0.13337484002113342,
0.4515930414199829,
-0.4892704486846924,
0.03420035541057587,
-0.38780948519706726,
0.13172931969165802,
-0.05899270623922348,
-0.12874163687229156,
-0.36055514216423035,
-0.7847073674201965,
0.3035387694835663,
-0.4786958396434784,
0.030112192034721375,
0.33269837498664856,
0.6561802625656128,
0.32310518622398376,
-0.589659571647644,
-0.5491326451301575,
-0.4265054762363434,
0.8504125475883484,
-0.5881651043891907,
0.12980900704860687,
0.5500602722167969,
0.24499398469924927,
-0.3245348632335663,
-0.9602477550506592,
-0.5182502865791321,
-0.49963146448135376,
0.0690893679857254,
0.27295398712158203,
-0.26149243116378784,
0.15279649198055267,
0.5069832801818848,
0.04626122862100601,
-0.3951992988586426,
-0.07858974486589432,
-0.243012472987175,
-0.2705475986003876,
0.7719456553459167,
0.6722171902656555,
0.3501119613647461,
-0.4749877452850342,
-0.16375017166137695,
-0.16885897517204285,
-0.8728576302528381,
0.38783395290374756,
0.9192208647727966,
0.1217753142118454,
0.015295229852199554,
0.5279094576835632,
0.23711523413658142,
0.46881359815597534,
0.19434988498687744,
0.23708811402320862,
-0.1393129676580429,
-0.6476144194602966,
-0.01672138087451458,
0.03519532456994057,
0.9172558784484863,
0.7832985520362854,
0.4174480736255646,
0.2723623514175415,
-0.21054020524024963,
0.14655523002147675,
0.44122815132141113,
-0.801472544670105,
-0.08636270463466644,
0.31230875849723816,
-0.49195611476898193,
-0.5479274392127991,
-0.04051946476101875,
-0.6004513502120972,
-0.6436102390289307,
-0.12009736150503159,
-0.17900864779949188,
-0.47808364033699036,
-0.13716578483581543,
0.3712185025215149,
-0.3806820511817932,
0.2287382036447525,
0.2875555455684662,
-0.40545397996902466,
0.03868545591831207,
0.3697929084300995,
0.5703439712524414,
-0.0014906538417562842,
-0.19320541620254517,
-0.7890373468399048,
-0.1308598816394806,
-0.5105075836181641,
0.9073156118392944,
-0.6519886255264282,
-0.7174646258354187,
0.04907858744263649,
-0.010819593444466591,
0.18487854301929474,
-0.3415899872779846,
0.9157833456993103,
-0.022056639194488525,
0.17033667862415314,
-0.698521614074707,
-0.4292079508304596,
-0.2522437274456024,
0.27997782826423645,
-0.40810054540634155,
0.4432421922683716,
0.16151316463947296,
-0.5180554986000061,
0.30770522356033325,
-0.7291397452354431,
-0.4317344129085541,
0.08567050099372864,
-0.24908281862735748,
-0.28177884221076965,
0.052298445254564285,
-0.20599201321601868,
0.25114747881889343,
-0.851742148399353,
0.5940608978271484,
-0.3826195299625397,
-0.17456068098545074,
0.45548298954963684,
-0.5791441798210144,
1.1758559942245483,
0.25347837805747986,
-0.22586151957511902,
0.22601641714572906,
-0.3668302595615387,
0.09129583835601807,
0.27630937099456787,
-0.18980686366558075,
-0.33887189626693726,
0.2433662712574005,
-0.0427219457924366,
0.46875178813934326,
-0.1270841807126999,
-0.5525786876678467,
-0.04989190772175789,
-0.28087350726127625,
0.6555855870246887,
0.9345061182975769,
0.4389277398586273,
0.20114807784557343,
-0.5616277456283569,
0.6207159757614136,
-0.08194290846586227,
0.5273897647857666,
0.06402774900197983,
-0.7427458167076111,
-0.6544460654258728,
0.22464428842067719,
-0.1481902152299881,
0.5388104319572449,
-0.7293441891670227,
0.33672896027565,
0.2453755885362625,
-0.23214450478553772,
-0.2998361587524414,
-0.46178263425827026,
0.7560965418815613,
0.620827853679657,
0.14889732003211975,
-0.35741522908210754,
-0.23136042058467865,
-0.7256949543952942,
-0.4541241228580475,
-0.5578032732009888,
0.1375095546245575,
0.5571956634521484,
0.4957856237888336,
-0.062499161809682846,
0.9899194240570068,
-0.4987090826034546,
0.07287326455116272,
-0.12214052677154541,
0.3778892457485199,
0.08446736633777618,
0.49127352237701416,
0.5026572942733765,
-0.6184484958648682,
-0.15547260642051697,
-0.1960771679878235,
-0.8145117163658142,
-0.2911686301231384,
-0.3448459208011627,
-0.1808682084083557,
-0.060895420610904694,
0.37607139348983765,
-0.3835790455341339,
0.3984708786010742,
0.09676583111286163,
-0.6313645839691162,
1.042252540588379,
-0.16351839900016785,
0.39903005957603455,
-0.6027893424034119,
0.025600174441933632,
0.03686189651489258,
-0.012173558585345745,
-0.6360150575637817,
-0.06852284073829651,
-0.20296843349933624,
-0.16546647250652313,
-0.7037781476974487,
0.6848157644271851,
-0.13129854202270508,
0.1603422909975052,
0.29727762937545776,
0.2064400613307953,
-0.028785552829504013,
0.28894558548927307,
-0.016445156186819077,
0.7979476451873779,
0.32782885432243347,
-0.5355411171913147,
0.2988104224205017,
0.4855637550354004,
-0.2459004819393158,
0.7847297191619873,
-0.8459809422492981,
0.19718867540359497,
-0.09018100053071976,
0.17821411788463593,
-0.5500985980033875,
-0.12059241533279419,
0.4364487826824188,
-0.20910899341106415,
-0.1485278308391571,
-0.15717700123786926,
-0.1742682307958603,
-0.3588589131832123,
-0.5584825873374939,
0.34886425733566284,
0.7121062874794006,
-0.12933067977428436,
0.17326195538043976,
0.40082091093063354,
-0.3989632725715637,
-0.34271878004074097,
-0.3770103454589844,
0.20488855242729187,
-0.3669644892215729,
-0.6682084202766418,
-0.03814522549510002,
-0.28431957960128784,
-0.6977437138557434,
-0.11141540110111237,
0.15220171213150024,
0.027022670954465866,
-0.0374765619635582,
0.37435880303382874,
0.10024173557758331,
0.08158369362354279,
0.05853472277522087,
0.3892822265625,
-0.2920144498348236,
0.39802810549736023,
-0.256247878074646,
0.4363429546356201,
-0.6326730847358704,
-0.5682082176208496,
-0.22480508685112,
0.4990183711051941,
0.2799857556819916,
-0.31223800778388977,
0.22807356715202332,
-0.029011424630880356,
-0.21462436020374298,
0.17099352180957794,
-0.4580621123313904,
-0.08855327218770981,
-0.5193106532096863,
0.129420667886734,
-0.21419593691825867,
-0.6336690187454224,
0.4372633993625641,
-0.22782383859157562,
0.05808034911751747,
0.40737757086753845,
0.533248245716095,
-0.2046595960855484,
1.2157262563705444,
0.026754850521683693,
0.4244322180747986,
0.41066741943359375,
-0.2567790448665619,
0.20260825753211975,
-0.635176420211792,
0.0696057602763176,
-0.4882507920265198,
0.22057931125164032,
-0.7198347449302673,
-0.3957921266555786,
0.4249226748943329,
0.20979854464530945,
-0.6718230843544006,
0.06966592371463776,
-0.36584585905075073,
0.5518922805786133,
0.33584117889404297,
0.08197421580553055,
0.40459898114204407,
-0.056934308260679245,
-0.334450900554657,
0.04714901000261307,
-0.6462128758430481,
-0.9468613266944885,
0.7929694056510925,
-0.042820610105991364,
0.46894922852516174,
0.11399432271718979,
0.46241873502731323,
0.3357754647731781,
0.3069198727607727,
-0.6225171089172363,
0.6236660480499268,
0.011783030815422535,
-0.6469351649284363,
-0.4370264410972595,
-0.5709720253944397,
-1.195635437965393,
0.0365033820271492,
-0.07908791303634644,
-0.7322850227355957,
0.4387764036655426,
-0.016219783574342728,
-0.5563428401947021,
-0.11258187144994736,
-0.6335850954055786,
0.8112728595733643,
-0.4228042662143707,
-0.5541474223136902,
-0.32721683382987976,
-0.8210906982421875,
0.4856463670730591,
-0.12471083551645279,
0.15027138590812683,
-0.13183529675006866,
0.1627180129289627,
0.5899921655654907,
-0.7042744159698486,
0.7863703370094299,
-0.2064715474843979,
-0.11616041511297226,
0.7279580235481262,
0.2267431765794754,
0.5600904822349548,
0.3290451467037201,
-0.3985673189163208,
0.1475745141506195,
-0.0061750165186822414,
-0.16823597252368927,
-0.4836823046207428,
0.5098097324371338,
-0.5517067313194275,
-0.8243478536605835,
-0.4610902667045593,
-0.3524225652217865,
-0.15320780873298645,
0.312956303358078,
0.34443095326423645,
0.5818542838096619,
-0.5877171754837036,
-0.2243356704711914,
0.2753602862358093,
-0.6640815734863281,
0.43678009510040283,
0.5525686740875244,
-0.04850310832262039,
-0.29493725299835205,
0.9479641318321228,
-0.11654754728078842,
0.306831955909729,
-0.37866052985191345,
0.6138919591903687,
-0.44022390246391296,
-0.5254822373390198,
-0.4717380404472351,
0.19523921608924866,
-0.6986498236656189,
-0.14327892661094666,
-0.3096035122871399,
0.08262123167514801,
-0.07253559678792953,
-0.4842466115951538,
-0.28997671604156494,
-0.22400951385498047,
-0.14338110387325287,
-0.003462798660621047,
0.3570002019405365,
0.96442049741745,
-0.11580182611942291,
0.04514487832784653,
-0.9471999406814575,
0.09207732230424881,
0.29916584491729736,
0.15957830846309662,
-0.17716901004314423,
-0.20643030107021332,
0.3358292579650879,
0.23127543926239014,
-0.45594698190689087,
-0.8565302491188049,
0.164943128824234,
-0.11360100656747818,
0.42943429946899414,
0.6078737378120422,
0.4906559884548187,
0.7035640478134155,
-0.6245695948600769,
0.7454907298088074,
0.4235630929470062,
-1.067604660987854,
0.5440697073936462,
-0.7044743299484253,
0.00108153757173568,
0.5574761629104614,
0.31352871656417847,
-0.6585270762443542,
-0.4284290373325348,
-0.6402445435523987,
-0.5468170046806335,
0.7700559496879578,
0.5486462116241455,
0.061491459608078,
-0.46230408549308777,
0.4886910021305084,
0.13980557024478912,
0.019987503066658974,
-0.333139032125473,
-0.048756714910268784,
-0.3130658268928528,
-0.06338901817798615,
0.09038844704627991,
-0.04547789320349693,
-0.3112103044986725,
-0.22001846134662628,
0.34446823596954346,
0.0032853626180440187,
0.1660597324371338,
0.18959128856658936,
-0.10274560004472733,
-0.4218043386936188,
0.20201227068901062,
0.4589760899543762,
0.6401564478874207,
0.06195981428027153,
-0.26626917719841003,
0.13436971604824066,
-0.3869050145149231,
0.5839880108833313,
0.00033465473097749054,
-0.1885252147912979,
-0.6204867362976074,
0.4519887864589691,
0.6523500084877014,
0.04184544086456299,
-0.8659898042678833,
0.6359929442405701,
-0.4820139408111572,
0.03154745325446129,
-0.21756719052791595,
0.11342042684555054,
-0.0657319724559784,
0.3956277668476105,
-0.17771267890930176,
0.016995294019579887,
0.3910854160785675,
-0.6414818167686462,
0.14971186220645905,
0.2688615322113037,
-0.23114930093288422,
-0.3304881155490875,
0.3984433114528656,
0.511245608329773,
-0.6880151629447937,
0.9866730570793152,
-0.6323785185813904,
-0.4243028163909912,
0.7596570253372192,
0.38404273986816406,
1.045395016670227,
-0.353626549243927,
0.5431667566299438,
0.36477434635162354,
0.2918945848941803,
-0.06914759427309036,
0.5795372724533081,
0.21669672429561615,
-0.7196899652481079,
-0.3049204349517822,
-0.4602196514606476,
-0.48499661684036255,
-0.21323707699775696,
-0.6189717650413513,
0.12898550927639008,
-0.4141513407230377,
-0.32043561339378357,
-0.3099616467952728,
-0.23919402062892914,
-0.5328678488731384,
0.018593138083815575,
-0.36395618319511414,
0.37890034914016724,
-0.5262073874473572,
0.43161049485206604,
0.507841944694519,
-0.6723917722702026,
-0.6687146425247192,
0.1564931869506836,
0.10188887268304825,
-0.6129509806632996,
0.4308381974697113,
0.11855626106262207,
-0.33039966225624084,
0.1393219381570816,
-0.5144156217575073,
-0.4884912967681885,
0.8067094683647156,
0.6140367388725281,
-0.6101681590080261,
0.07498877495527267,
0.18939493596553802,
0.5375434160232544,
-0.15689362585544586,
0.3535858690738678,
0.804779052734375,
0.8380216360092163,
0.030241429805755615,
-0.5331399440765381,
0.2963472306728363,
-0.29890215396881104,
-0.07621456682682037,
0.17074917256832123,
-0.49962496757507324,
0.8750125765800476,
-0.5901935696601868,
-0.5468736290931702,
0.11697609722614288,
0.1148613914847374,
0.41022467613220215,
0.316994309425354,
0.5893428325653076,
0.18047329783439636,
0.7327673435211182,
-0.1579212099313736,
1.5362107753753662,
-0.05351554974913597,
0.3059304654598236,
0.7408097982406616,
-0.4656963050365448,
0.24975304305553436,
0.35525256395339966,
-0.2526782751083374,
0.3361414968967438,
0.7268937230110168,
0.21266695857048035,
0.35342419147491455,
0.49688175320625305,
0.014870686456561089,
-0.5355717539787292,
-0.509659469127655,
-0.29074832797050476,
0.4169560670852661,
0.43789634108543396,
0.006205786485224962,
-0.12909066677093506,
-0.17550693452358246,
-0.10506012290716171,
-0.03814486786723137,
-0.06973125040531158,
0.637966513633728,
0.1654251366853714,
-0.7541908025741577,
0.39148855209350586,
0.02117716707289219,
0.03599943220615387,
-0.5130956768989563,
-0.22222335636615753,
-0.30078253149986267,
-0.06540688127279282,
0.006762509699910879,
-0.9448177218437195,
0.20712897181510925,
0.19228772819042206,
0.2040676325559616,
-0.29393163323402405,
0.5723727941513062,
-0.05460192635655403,
-0.5566087365150452,
0.2560119926929474,
0.7007726430892944,
0.23654642701148987,
0.026269011199474335,
-0.8838292360305786,
-0.1786501556634903,
-0.10150086879730225,
-0.3909241855144501,
0.07254422456026077,
0.5264723896980286,
-0.4194837510585785,
0.6826381087303162,
0.9027394652366638,
-0.1257234811782837,
-0.1627650260925293,
0.2827511131763458,
0.8427530527114868,
-0.8574008941650391,
-0.4456852078437805,
-0.8774335980415344,
0.5963730216026306,
-0.2159043550491333,
-0.5340307354927063,
0.5552462935447693,
0.13135798275470734,
0.3529268503189087,
0.11338707059621811,
0.8701320290565491,
-0.09464713931083679,
-0.1504659801721573,
-0.5609456300735474,
0.6720505952835083,
-0.27693971991539,
0.273151159286499,
-0.5066813826560974,
-0.7008993625640869,
-0.11148421466350555,
0.7728660106658936,
-0.4227652847766876,
0.32517120242118835,
1.0279960632324219,
0.6672435998916626,
0.3960672616958618,
0.18087369203567505,
0.26528850197792053,
0.2612556219100952,
0.4049686789512634,
0.5708914995193481,
1.473187804222107,
-0.17403873801231384,
0.4392493665218353,
0.06909201294183731,
-0.3026071786880493,
0.04072805494070053,
-1.1333460807800293,
-0.9086507558822632,
-0.5435176491737366,
-0.10040591657161713,
-0.2690027058124542,
0.2739373743534088,
0.7711291909217834,
0.2829763889312744,
-0.6514168977737427,
-0.30001023411750793,
-0.47968900203704834,
0.30233851075172424,
-0.16023197770118713,
-0.18641550838947296,
0.3245057165622711,
-0.2974172830581665,
-0.4978073537349701,
0.29837045073509216,
0.44569554924964905,
0.07228682935237885,
-0.23379923403263092,
-0.39278778433799744,
-0.10234502702951431,
0.41137588024139404,
0.6343329548835754,
0.04821600392460823,
-0.7218735218048096,
-0.4968612492084503,
-0.1644313633441925,
-0.012851957231760025,
-0.17338424921035767,
1.2222124338150024,
-0.4775334894657135,
0.43470463156700134,
0.423801451921463,
0.2815324664115906,
0.1473386436700821,
-0.011820166371762753,
0.9313687682151794,
-0.3365614414215088,
-0.0007867270614951849,
0.48594626784324646,
0.5359488129615784,
0.08780251443386078,
-0.4641333520412445,
0.5462839603424072,
0.046666085720062256,
-0.5528360605239868,
-0.7433183193206787,
0.5676027536392212,
-0.49711334705352783,
-0.3513947129249573,
1.2111302614212036,
-0.35393020510673523,
0.11001258343458176,
-0.45403575897216797,
-0.54548579454422,
0.19743098318576813,
-0.549044668674469,
0.7136799693107605,
0.6571891903877258,
-0.30797308683395386,
0.17102943360805511,
-0.4941754639148712,
0.5109185576438904,
0.31431910395622253,
-0.9950708150863647,
0.22255831956863403,
0.816371500492096,
-0.03128977492451668,
-0.03697848692536354,
0.6150307059288025,
-0.06422388553619385,
0.49529874324798584,
0.17105218768119812,
-0.11403942853212357,
-0.12233008444309235,
-0.0963829979300499,
-0.2880781590938568,
-0.07552196085453033,
-0.09344768524169922,
0.36533257365226746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10960v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10960v1
|
Uncertainty-Based Abstention in LLMs Improves Safety and Reduces Hallucinations
| 2024-04-16T23:56:38 | 2024-04-16T23:56:38 |
Christian Tomani, Kamalika Chaudhuri, Ivan Evtimov, Daniel Cremers, Mark Ibrahim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
A major barrier towards the practical deployment of large language models
(LLMs) is their lack of reliability. Three situations where this is
particularly apparent are correctness, hallucinations when given unanswerable
questions, and safety. In all three cases, models should ideally abstain from
responding, much like humans, whose ability to understand uncertainty makes us
refrain from answering questions we don't know. Inspired by analogous
approaches in classification, this study explores the feasibility and efficacy
of abstaining while uncertain in the context of LLMs within the domain of
question-answering. We investigate two kinds of uncertainties, statistical
uncertainty metrics and a distinct verbalized measure, termed as In-Dialogue
Uncertainty (InDU). Using these uncertainty measures combined with models with
and without Reinforcement Learning with Human Feedback (RLHF), we show that in
all three situations, abstention based on the right kind of uncertainty measure
can boost the reliability of LLMs. By sacrificing only a few highly uncertain
samples we can improve correctness by 2% to 8%, avoid 50% hallucinations via
correctly identifying unanswerable questions and increase safety by 70% up to
99% with almost no additional computational overhead.
|
[
-0.37199464440345764,
-1.1584703922271729,
0.8040139079093933,
0.0343468114733696,
-0.2473989725112915,
0.2923320233821869,
-0.36600470542907715,
-0.5415143966674805,
-0.1480952948331833,
0.5922873616218567,
-0.45499947667121887,
-0.33328312635421753,
-0.4469831883907318,
0.08798712491989136,
-0.35857337713241577,
0.6916021108627319,
-0.19240781664848328,
0.016734804958105087,
-0.37011611461639404,
0.036541108042001724,
-0.383221834897995,
-0.5645272135734558,
-0.700050413608551,
-0.42542144656181335,
0.549567461013794,
0.3631404638290405,
0.8463523983955383,
0.4840104579925537,
0.5194685459136963,
0.2966458201408386,
-0.13588576018810272,
0.1823096126317978,
-0.34014496207237244,
0.3090902268886566,
-0.17591702938079834,
-0.8735434412956238,
-0.15015558898448944,
-0.20138590037822723,
0.4755750298500061,
0.8327761292457581,
-0.6091115474700928,
-0.2860027253627777,
0.2145322859287262,
0.48755812644958496,
-0.683377206325531,
-0.03535187616944313,
-0.7029016613960266,
0.07968474179506302,
0.2103922814130783,
-0.13175402581691742,
-0.3401491045951843,
-0.5130495429039001,
0.12425514310598373,
-0.5787538290023804,
-0.03298864886164665,
0.1742040067911148,
0.7381801009178162,
0.6692301034927368,
-0.16762907803058624,
-0.4578307867050171,
-1.034533143043518,
0.6833850145339966,
-0.7816852331161499,
0.4892916679382324,
0.9310590028762817,
0.09553133696317673,
-0.3544958233833313,
-0.37382155656814575,
-0.481757253408432,
-0.2758946716785431,
0.06577066332101822,
0.02965553104877472,
0.014172220602631569,
0.44567346572875977,
0.03147713840007782,
-0.034677404910326004,
-0.34315794706344604,
0.35593268275260925,
-0.26346728205680847,
-0.44992879033088684,
0.4214165508747101,
0.16695863008499146,
-0.010541284456849098,
-0.05777530372142792,
-0.3988388478755951,
-0.07178649306297302,
-0.8267703652381897,
0.0702403113245964,
0.38169264793395996,
0.19894014298915863,
0.049722470343112946,
0.5645685195922852,
-0.10701989382505417,
0.40638667345046997,
-0.09790109843015671,
-0.3152240812778473,
-0.0893118679523468,
0.012469588778913021,
-0.24050191044807434,
-0.13130876421928406,
0.6152810454368591,
0.18435101211071014,
0.21128320693969727,
-0.3032679855823517,
-0.3810303807258606,
0.007689069025218487,
0.47793740034103394,
-0.613305389881134,
-0.08509200066328049,
0.685695230960846,
-0.17197087407112122,
-0.1965906172990799,
-0.056531697511672974,
-0.653343141078949,
-0.41471144556999207,
-0.09502211958169937,
0.5106600522994995,
-0.5920526385307312,
-0.20193800330162048,
0.12972775101661682,
0.20883095264434814,
0.09511936455965042,
0.5286467671394348,
-0.6312171816825867,
0.45783692598342896,
0.5374454855918884,
0.5548804998397827,
-0.14726737141609192,
-0.13880746066570282,
-0.34560829401016235,
0.04308026656508446,
-0.8172304034233093,
0.5805321931838989,
-0.22707484662532806,
-0.5929773449897766,
-0.07764288783073425,
-0.16051051020622253,
-0.07447881996631622,
-0.7277546525001526,
0.5522174835205078,
-0.4345068335533142,
-0.00659174332395196,
-0.14687131345272064,
-0.7873619198799133,
-0.5806468725204468,
0.32583504915237427,
-0.28087180852890015,
0.6219550371170044,
-0.029570933431386948,
-0.511174201965332,
0.24801871180534363,
-0.13465242087841034,
-0.28489160537719727,
-0.03147363290190697,
-0.13845235109329224,
-0.48404979705810547,
0.22854582965373993,
0.09304456412792206,
0.28403663635253906,
-0.08575811237096786,
0.27348384261131287,
-0.3567952811717987,
-0.45457378029823303,
0.801516592502594,
-0.8306645750999451,
0.3866899907588959,
0.3890109956264496,
-0.1708310842514038,
0.011397638358175755,
-0.3772023320198059,
0.24668677151203156,
-0.19183778762817383,
-0.24609024822711945,
-0.30962350964546204,
0.1870054006576538,
-0.26192706823349,
0.22840385138988495,
-0.15017545223236084,
-0.41931840777397156,
-0.3276682198047638,
-0.5691041946411133,
0.1983979344367981,
0.753740131855011,
0.2535938024520874,
0.27197936177253723,
-0.6865555047988892,
0.720678448677063,
-0.14291265606880188,
0.2505030632019043,
0.3433944880962372,
-0.3818299174308777,
-0.8708143830299377,
-0.2263992875814438,
0.15532217919826508,
0.9045979976654053,
-0.9673284292221069,
0.4450628459453583,
0.1437464952468872,
-0.4782290458679199,
-0.4625973701477051,
0.0432773157954216,
0.6958509087562561,
0.5844187140464783,
0.263861745595932,
-0.26849788427352905,
-0.32017895579338074,
-0.5755026936531067,
0.0012242639204487205,
-0.8197917342185974,
-0.050614628940820694,
0.17104196548461914,
0.5029497742652893,
-0.05222802609205246,
0.8047633171081543,
-0.32278868556022644,
0.0268099382519722,
-0.31715360283851624,
0.0931440070271492,
-0.268920361995697,
0.3718354403972626,
0.09954783320426941,
-0.7504529356956482,
-0.0589795857667923,
-0.20064306259155273,
-0.7940695881843567,
0.1656724512577057,
-0.2844212055206299,
0.10206456482410431,
0.544284999370575,
0.40340644121170044,
-0.733372151851654,
0.7037506103515625,
0.21613046526908875,
0.12233692407608032,
0.6546995639801025,
-0.2341725081205368,
0.14980031549930573,
-0.786715030670166,
-0.26079654693603516,
-0.1752394586801529,
-0.18520550429821014,
-0.6670745611190796,
-0.02203374169766903,
0.018179967999458313,
0.2988012731075287,
-0.6892016530036926,
0.41220301389694214,
-0.10894926637411118,
0.10379895567893982,
-0.29893606901168823,
0.20008714497089386,
0.029835136607289314,
0.4386581480503082,
0.3418388366699219,
0.6214421987533569,
0.5386893153190613,
-0.7814286351203918,
0.08754437416791916,
0.2789314091205597,
-0.5054234266281128,
0.5633658766746521,
-0.6413320302963257,
0.07224345952272415,
-0.27197763323783875,
0.04702837020158768,
-0.8470954298973083,
-0.3892459571361542,
0.5178177952766418,
-0.5630711317062378,
0.3800075054168701,
0.09568852931261063,
-0.2841178774833679,
-0.19821634888648987,
-0.20511198043823242,
0.009490220807492733,
0.4597479999065399,
-0.1676388382911682,
0.3990485668182373,
0.08579234778881073,
-0.3939242959022522,
-0.7693057060241699,
-0.853843629360199,
-0.018040798604488373,
-0.40555718541145325,
-0.1577707976102829,
-0.04513292759656906,
-0.3144829571247101,
-0.6879400610923767,
0.008172164671123028,
-0.36178743839263916,
-0.17692162096500397,
0.4928296208381653,
0.43591004610061646,
0.4028277099132538,
0.21646550297737122,
0.6601819396018982,
0.006455875467509031,
0.003688300959765911,
0.15617674589157104,
-0.0760929137468338,
0.39314234256744385,
-0.0207514725625515,
-0.7230777144432068,
-0.6808263063430786,
0.2892184555530548,
0.31989508867263794,
0.09467340260744095,
0.6954591870307922,
0.2024030089378357,
-0.5204108357429504,
-0.22266413271427155,
-0.6179512143135071,
-0.5911083221435547,
-0.506577730178833,
0.36365994811058044,
-0.2795189619064331,
-0.9334290623664856,
0.4750240445137024,
0.06816893070936203,
-0.004690890200436115,
0.08465978503227234,
0.28287601470947266,
-0.5693361759185791,
0.5771706104278564,
0.46180564165115356,
0.08717206865549088,
0.0847153440117836,
0.22045089304447174,
0.358358234167099,
-0.5241715908050537,
-0.24603597819805145,
-0.7075045704841614,
0.1385970413684845,
-0.4836765229701996,
-0.45960870385169983,
0.37691760063171387,
0.30511462688446045,
-0.27418795228004456,
-0.035265058279037476,
-0.3725496828556061,
0.3020850419998169,
0.30291152000427246,
0.33507102727890015,
0.25553229451179504,
-0.12420697510242462,
0.13538110256195068,
-0.05642405524849892,
-0.5538532137870789,
-0.5351380109786987,
0.933111310005188,
0.4646211564540863,
1.190373420715332,
0.0754404217004776,
0.7355331778526306,
0.049927230924367905,
0.19672802090644836,
-0.9204179644584656,
0.49122723937034607,
0.44726961851119995,
-0.6116322875022888,
-0.7651973366737366,
-0.6772262454032898,
-0.6914029121398926,
0.3255530297756195,
-0.3875446617603302,
-0.8435556292533875,
0.19249853491783142,
0.026845896616578102,
-0.6999465823173523,
0.5315170884132385,
-0.5265199542045593,
0.2126743644475937,
-0.5296202898025513,
-0.13092032074928284,
-0.04341844469308853,
-0.7670485973358154,
0.2725291848182678,
-0.4164849817752838,
0.38009148836135864,
-0.12764649093151093,
-0.22208702564239502,
0.6344438791275024,
-0.3465000092983246,
0.9648759961128235,
0.12102854251861572,
-0.14496272802352905,
0.558086097240448,
0.39446887373924255,
0.7602409720420837,
0.14732661843299866,
-0.18071913719177246,
0.08013607561588287,
-0.02274879813194275,
-0.050606295466423035,
-0.7459676861763,
0.2590961158275604,
-0.647657036781311,
-0.7732899785041809,
-0.3876208961009979,
-0.6517605185508728,
-0.5023811459541321,
-0.05717478692531586,
0.424787700176239,
0.02103993110358715,
-0.062460001558065414,
0.16564540565013885,
1.160199761390686,
-0.4613611400127411,
0.4914199709892273,
0.48924708366394043,
-0.2752862274646759,
-0.5171439051628113,
0.5106571912765503,
0.16431576013565063,
0.6861026287078857,
0.3641665577888489,
0.10512065142393112,
-0.6063047647476196,
-0.9103955626487732,
-0.07222571223974228,
0.16841381788253784,
-0.8192310929298401,
-0.1631166785955429,
-0.608174741268158,
-0.3645566999912262,
-0.25320398807525635,
-0.25662949681282043,
-0.38341912627220154,
-0.4170025885105133,
-0.4048141539096832,
-0.6420729756355286,
0.4037388265132904,
0.795161247253418,
-0.14242760837078094,
0.24942153692245483,
-0.4636019468307495,
0.11744313687086105,
0.3523843586444855,
0.30929604172706604,
-0.06307824701070786,
-0.7166904807090759,
-0.03176788613200188,
0.15020041167736053,
-0.1424938589334488,
-0.7526775598526001,
0.48993149399757385,
0.029407385736703873,
0.7120764851570129,
0.4882771670818329,
0.5476222634315491,
0.612476110458374,
-0.055951450020074844,
0.5987569689750671,
0.21150745451450348,
-0.9062291979789734,
0.42075201869010925,
-0.22515983879566193,
0.06400598585605621,
0.7303931713104248,
0.4918399751186371,
-0.5109920501708984,
-0.8049876093864441,
-0.3534471094608307,
-0.8924249410629272,
0.4421025514602661,
0.25624358654022217,
0.0724685937166214,
-0.020027805119752884,
0.4593518078327179,
0.16262848675251007,
0.42594072222709656,
-0.5379144549369812,
-0.17563286423683167,
0.09872541576623917,
-0.008726249448955059,
-0.1470322608947754,
-0.3298909366130829,
-0.31907057762145996,
-0.17090804874897003,
0.8018248081207275,
0.0036743306554853916,
0.13310566544532776,
0.29420018196105957,
-0.18874549865722656,
-0.19240768253803253,
0.47109898924827576,
0.5974013805389404,
0.7039288282394409,
-0.384793758392334,
0.1698051542043686,
0.45558562874794006,
-0.43238335847854614,
0.36956965923309326,
-0.25886669754981995,
-0.2969513237476349,
-0.2512444853782654,
0.3210168778896332,
0.614736795425415,
-0.12841200828552246,
-0.7952431440353394,
0.12790526449680328,
-0.1071915477514267,
-0.25902673602104187,
-0.3866853713989258,
0.08828294277191162,
0.05551337078213692,
0.06128625199198723,
0.27899491786956787,
0.20337118208408356,
-0.10702119767665863,
-0.3439350426197052,
0.4508322477340698,
0.3563162684440613,
-0.7218722105026245,
0.03864708170294762,
0.5720594525337219,
-0.1106833964586258,
-0.3506472110748291,
0.6157376766204834,
-0.1136460155248642,
-0.2337067872285843,
0.6513550281524658,
0.47346147894859314,
0.8439027667045593,
-0.3300447165966034,
0.4410158395767212,
0.15587857365608215,
0.6683565974235535,
-0.21520310640335083,
0.2867419123649597,
0.13891544938087463,
-0.9300552010536194,
-0.24581310153007507,
-0.5080333352088928,
-0.8202027082443237,
-0.049610354006290436,
-0.7497395873069763,
-0.3404581844806671,
-0.5932472348213196,
-0.260701060295105,
-0.4836619198322296,
-0.1449616551399231,
-0.20730963349342346,
0.3185705542564392,
0.03466323763132095,
0.6286331415176392,
-0.6438958644866943,
0.7503068447113037,
0.33006444573402405,
-0.3503480851650238,
-0.9541016221046448,
0.26000356674194336,
0.11813988536596298,
-0.23635920882225037,
0.05875849351286888,
0.040763165801763535,
-0.3554357886314392,
-0.3949723541736603,
-0.6095943450927734,
-0.8803098201751709,
0.8326402306556702,
0.39338430762290955,
-0.5260408520698547,
0.24597620964050293,
0.1882878541946411,
0.3978675603866577,
-0.002635004697367549,
0.15093988180160522,
0.5532066226005554,
0.4990535080432892,
0.285845011472702,
-0.8790722489356995,
-0.04295548424124718,
0.19204099476337433,
0.0013213769998401403,
0.03784839063882828,
-0.5335028171539307,
0.7390515804290771,
-0.4744792580604553,
-0.28735634684562683,
0.3416511118412018,
0.5707381963729858,
0.3650418519973755,
0.231723815202713,
0.5581017732620239,
0.475157767534256,
1.192793369293213,
-0.2981845736503601,
0.9814813137054443,
-0.06054146960377693,
0.06723187863826752,
1.2386507987976074,
-0.46629083156585693,
0.9774001240730286,
0.5993040800094604,
-0.20361508429050446,
0.3213588297367096,
0.7746798396110535,
0.5282543301582336,
0.491984099149704,
0.2652375102043152,
-0.41520142555236816,
-0.5150534510612488,
-0.1809999942779541,
-0.10916029661893845,
0.40081295371055603,
0.7953212261199951,
0.008073688484728336,
0.028380276635289192,
0.27480262517929077,
0.30562376976013184,
0.2228570431470871,
-0.11999666690826416,
0.7977323532104492,
0.33723291754722595,
-0.8291383981704712,
0.7317517399787903,
-0.1554904282093048,
0.5916965007781982,
-0.6983652710914612,
0.18701423704624176,
-0.37585487961769104,
0.10502134263515472,
-0.09213544428348541,
-0.8424190282821655,
0.3843108117580414,
-0.2885324954986572,
0.09552755951881409,
-0.07719116657972336,
0.6071780920028687,
-0.4819090962409973,
-0.5245161056518555,
0.30125853419303894,
0.575433611869812,
0.27832192182540894,
-0.04796500504016876,
-0.5008193254470825,
-0.028274815529584885,
-0.06565634161233902,
-0.18016056716442108,
0.25450682640075684,
0.3433225154876709,
-0.11033895611763,
1.3684563636779785,
0.3771928548812866,
0.2941382825374603,
-0.14019592106342316,
-0.26716339588165283,
0.5996518731117249,
-0.44744256138801575,
-0.24342796206474304,
-0.7260904908180237,
0.3297399878501892,
0.23653465509414673,
-0.18151725828647614,
0.6966208219528198,
0.17014385759830475,
0.7465386986732483,
0.15715745091438293,
1.0243709087371826,
0.15174266695976257,
0.5207113027572632,
-0.5062626004219055,
0.7723901271820068,
-0.4819777011871338,
0.5217982530593872,
-0.3120577037334442,
-0.5580940842628479,
-0.4577852189540863,
0.5049535632133484,
-0.31702709197998047,
0.05914508178830147,
0.6992099285125732,
0.9928393959999084,
0.5947345495223999,
-0.014109065756201744,
0.6591730713844299,
0.00994829647243023,
0.1702963411808014,
0.5108650326728821,
1.0634013414382935,
-0.12518301606178284,
0.6224400401115417,
-0.5356991291046143,
-0.041079163551330566,
-0.006719914264976978,
-0.45308050513267517,
-0.7923882007598877,
-0.3715498149394989,
-0.3001260459423065,
-0.36104294657707214,
0.4139435887336731,
0.9258906245231628,
0.6395775079727173,
-0.8767051100730896,
-0.22569645941257477,
-0.01536762434989214,
0.5670385360717773,
-0.3731120228767395,
-0.12829378247261047,
0.2829754650592804,
-0.39769625663757324,
-0.5062332153320312,
0.42532527446746826,
0.32587766647338867,
0.47373470664024353,
-0.24778766930103302,
-0.2810268700122833,
-0.0564911849796772,
0.5284804701805115,
0.25515326857566833,
0.33653178811073303,
-0.9194387197494507,
-0.5764210820198059,
0.004471901338547468,
-0.12001336365938187,
-0.03900360316038132,
0.3050232529640198,
-0.6002312302589417,
0.3824121654033661,
0.2265602946281433,
0.5452843904495239,
0.15608692169189453,
0.3864816129207611,
0.46827858686447144,
-0.6672507524490356,
0.2565341293811798,
0.5532041192054749,
0.21448107063770294,
0.4246574938297272,
-0.4894997179508209,
0.4978841245174408,
0.01101535465568304,
-0.6027785539627075,
-0.7605637311935425,
0.41531187295913696,
-0.6228706240653992,
-0.566983699798584,
1.1766537427902222,
-0.20789483189582825,
-0.1299871802330017,
-0.7178003191947937,
-0.07533261179924011,
0.09523565322160721,
-0.34890350699424744,
0.9319416880607605,
0.7935356497764587,
-0.2114282101392746,
-0.40814104676246643,
-0.6217286586761475,
0.5571795105934143,
0.4894537627696991,
-0.8425569534301758,
0.09143762290477753,
0.42042168974876404,
0.17973117530345917,
0.02211778424680233,
0.4973960220813751,
0.05639220029115677,
0.1780758798122406,
0.033158134669065475,
0.3062503933906555,
0.17556573450565338,
-0.5140774846076965,
-0.33064568042755127,
0.24359670281410217,
0.3979734480381012,
-0.15137863159179688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10952v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10952v1
|
Can Language Models Solve Olympiad Programming?
| 2024-04-16T23:27:38 | 2024-04-16T23:27:38 |
Quan Shi, Michael Tang, Karthik Narasimhan, Shunyu Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.PL
|
Computing olympiads contain some of the most challenging problems for humans,
requiring complex algorithmic reasoning, puzzle solving, in addition to
generating efficient code. However, it has been understudied as a domain to
evaluate language models (LMs). In this paper, we introduce the USACO benchmark
with 307 problems from the USA Computing Olympiad, along with high-quality unit
tests, reference code, and official analyses for each problem. These resources
enable us to construct and test a range of LM inference methods for competitive
programming for the first time. We find GPT-4 only achieves a 8.7% pass@1
accuracy with zero-shot chain-of-thought prompting, and our best inference
method improves it to 20.2% using a combination of self-reflection and
retrieval over episodic knowledge. However, this is far from solving the
benchmark. To better understand the remaining challenges, we design a novel
human-in-the-loop study and surprisingly find that a small number of targeted
hints enable GPT-4 to solve 13 out of 15 problems previously unsolvable by any
model and method. Our benchmark, baseline methods, quantitative results, and
qualitative analysis serve as an initial step toward LMs with grounded,
creative, and algorithmic reasoning.
|
[
-0.3243395686149597,
-0.5209921002388,
0.7609214186668396,
0.20389758050441742,
-0.02654213085770607,
0.4080926179885864,
-0.28693461418151855,
-0.3299074172973633,
-0.6089653968811035,
0.2619015872478485,
-0.528528094291687,
-0.29236069321632385,
-0.3737744092941284,
0.3061736524105072,
-0.14073076844215393,
0.49798375368118286,
-0.22454889118671417,
0.019970020279288292,
-0.4727162718772888,
0.1585151106119156,
-0.2977823317050934,
-0.6033453941345215,
-0.2474256455898285,
-0.5551230907440186,
-0.09277912974357605,
0.5136944651603699,
0.5464853048324585,
0.4092133939266205,
0.33552125096321106,
0.32839417457580566,
0.01842835545539856,
0.07012142986059189,
-0.4874669909477234,
-0.17863936722278595,
-0.18030840158462524,
-0.4684695601463318,
0.002595967147499323,
0.32237255573272705,
0.32499396800994873,
0.8591780662536621,
-0.3308871388435364,
-0.053065817803144455,
0.042786240577697754,
0.6512802839279175,
-0.41643908619880676,
0.18180763721466064,
-0.8696078658103943,
0.057227760553359985,
-0.1797254979610443,
0.04032037407159805,
-0.300384521484375,
-0.08518441021442413,
-0.2443026304244995,
-0.6657465696334839,
0.2289772480726242,
0.25391602516174316,
0.7302868962287903,
0.22577950358390808,
-0.17786166071891785,
-0.4486789405345917,
-0.6400569677352905,
0.9890227317810059,
-0.5860210657119751,
0.43712088465690613,
0.5438035130500793,
0.25659576058387756,
-0.3524743318557739,
-0.4215099513530731,
-0.5206459760665894,
-0.30305615067481995,
0.6504340171813965,
0.03789219260215759,
-0.1350618600845337,
-0.029842039570212364,
0.2802714407444,
0.16729122400283813,
-0.7628645896911621,
-0.023153547197580338,
-0.6077622771263123,
-0.06755875051021576,
0.7096707224845886,
0.29245004057884216,
0.3826587200164795,
0.12720747292041779,
-0.12824417650699615,
0.10924948006868362,
-0.8143904209136963,
-0.015538327395915985,
0.3545103967189789,
-0.036792315542697906,
0.201293483376503,
0.2500329911708832,
-0.27125972509384155,
0.6064584255218506,
-0.25179335474967957,
0.10078436136245728,
0.035098638385534286,
-0.19954034686088562,
0.00116874894592911,
-0.39415082335472107,
0.7005837559700012,
0.16324900090694427,
0.7473044991493225,
-0.5028666853904724,
-0.18493574857711792,
0.17664779722690582,
0.17227818071842194,
-0.5323554873466492,
-0.3378608226776123,
0.19414132833480835,
-0.14567413926124573,
-0.13154283165931702,
-0.28969693183898926,
-0.5537654161453247,
-0.2990491986274719,
-0.18356749415397644,
0.40845370292663574,
-0.2637456953525543,
-0.1288139373064041,
0.19439281523227692,
0.042589880526065826,
0.056104905903339386,
0.08783908933401108,
-0.8319864869117737,
0.606453001499176,
0.8949913382530212,
0.6316434144973755,
-0.1594146490097046,
-0.5161705613136292,
-0.019081663340330124,
-0.42340195178985596,
-0.4577602446079254,
0.8389054536819458,
-0.5444244146347046,
-0.34489694237709045,
-0.09187888354063034,
-0.4854632616043091,
-0.13279756903648376,
-0.7848368883132935,
0.3181091547012329,
-0.5482061505317688,
-0.06628308445215225,
-0.25262054800987244,
-0.7867931723594666,
0.3811381459236145,
0.25936198234558105,
-0.31930819153785706,
0.9376786351203918,
0.047770917415618896,
-0.47832322120666504,
-0.024772297590970993,
-0.32388070225715637,
0.01813848875463009,
0.007604299113154411,
-0.4132675230503082,
-0.23101375997066498,
0.29365718364715576,
0.2087869942188263,
0.09019142389297485,
-0.779518187046051,
0.4362562894821167,
-0.4109017550945282,
-0.6603193879127502,
0.29311275482177734,
-0.10635267198085785,
0.8422313928604126,
0.589180588722229,
-0.2648211717605591,
-0.3875783383846283,
-0.5632367134094238,
0.29886433482170105,
0.3118152320384979,
-0.1254444569349289,
0.09064998477697372,
0.05405409261584282,
-0.4297391474246979,
0.29666680097579956,
0.020636724308133125,
-0.6547006964683533,
0.36256977915763855,
-0.04187006130814552,
0.4656934440135956,
0.854964017868042,
-0.22088490426540375,
0.24311242997646332,
-0.2709132432937622,
0.870246171951294,
-0.2197401374578476,
0.08615559339523315,
0.09132175147533417,
-0.9326790571212769,
-0.39685457944869995,
-0.002996095223352313,
0.21861395239830017,
0.6435563564300537,
-0.7795600891113281,
-0.022524984553456306,
0.0016363052418455482,
-0.507009744644165,
-0.6027846336364746,
0.1576126366853714,
0.557034969329834,
0.5533108711242676,
0.20736420154571533,
-0.048698581755161285,
-0.5050486326217651,
-0.7354817390441895,
-0.7978568077087402,
-0.14329710602760315,
0.010946114547550678,
0.5253417491912842,
0.8326646685600281,
0.07852862775325775,
0.8980323672294617,
-0.4857499599456787,
0.11098089069128036,
-0.2528127431869507,
0.5372961163520813,
0.3956018388271332,
0.4359317719936371,
0.12044267356395721,
-0.5010595917701721,
-0.6344570517539978,
-0.12651121616363525,
-0.7215843200683594,
-0.5864445567131042,
0.10696034133434296,
0.2552780210971832,
-0.016632437705993652,
0.33433717489242554,
-0.20376716554164886,
0.3396441340446472,
0.4956538677215576,
-0.3513745367527008,
0.8720988035202026,
-0.2900787889957428,
0.21076489984989166,
-0.3721161484718323,
-0.013388830237090588,
-0.21731936931610107,
-0.11352922767400742,
-0.4460490047931671,
0.08219251036643982,
0.13782544434070587,
-0.4684082269668579,
-0.0816367119550705,
0.6990836262702942,
-0.6180649399757385,
-0.12697209417819977,
-0.23433971405029297,
0.11089035123586655,
-0.061285924166440964,
0.5321967005729675,
-0.1037551537156105,
0.8495032787322998,
0.41945695877075195,
-0.22873468697071075,
0.2946316599845886,
-0.17931486666202545,
-0.6993815302848816,
0.33887043595314026,
-0.6158900856971741,
0.5975316166877747,
-0.10284915566444397,
-0.1251445859670639,
-0.8581700921058655,
-0.03255946934223175,
-0.1907844841480255,
-0.5009851455688477,
0.06221861019730568,
-0.04245629161596298,
-0.3946192264556885,
-0.6552445292472839,
-0.24211089313030243,
0.5019347071647644,
0.7767375707626343,
-0.38874754309654236,
-0.07203132659196854,
0.38169729709625244,
-0.14452481269836426,
-0.5353873372077942,
-0.44287431240081787,
0.07810764014720917,
0.01479854341596365,
-0.611544132232666,
0.19300848245620728,
-0.4508388042449951,
-0.37125465273857117,
0.02040291391313076,
-0.1707821935415268,
-0.6321601271629333,
0.40329912304878235,
-0.07234671711921692,
0.030237600207328796,
-0.048186108469963074,
-0.28139302134513855,
-0.408850759267807,
-0.14147497713565826,
-0.030855286866426468,
-0.10720179229974747,
0.17690956592559814,
-0.3735547661781311,
-0.4618547558784485,
-0.6128731369972229,
0.38603243231773376,
0.28715500235557556,
-0.08464952558279037,
0.3679101765155792,
0.03577588126063347,
-0.502446174621582,
-0.26025351881980896,
-0.6510483622550964,
-0.058087579905986786,
-0.4317665994167328,
0.48812657594680786,
-0.7655327320098877,
-0.7685741186141968,
0.5556347370147705,
-0.18954147398471832,
-0.35471341013908386,
0.05756659060716629,
0.47732365131378174,
-0.05097951740026474,
1.3539066314697266,
0.27055856585502625,
-0.23277701437473297,
0.15498867630958557,
-0.3284341096878052,
0.12396485358476639,
-0.8559434413909912,
-0.14491073787212372,
-0.876451313495636,
-0.0806766003370285,
-0.298715204000473,
-0.44981932640075684,
0.3247489333152771,
0.48838335275650024,
-0.5436423420906067,
0.2880905568599701,
-0.43927282094955444,
0.9722242951393127,
0.4161156415939331,
-0.08000968396663666,
0.36819952726364136,
-0.2034999281167984,
-0.5862622261047363,
-0.42746445536613464,
-0.7861576080322266,
-0.3779554069042206,
1.1489689350128174,
0.12299875915050507,
0.8023536801338196,
-0.0757070928812027,
0.8726451992988586,
0.16974620521068573,
0.5941516757011414,
-0.22230397164821625,
0.37067171931266785,
0.18828102946281433,
-1.0070266723632812,
-0.09141609817743301,
-0.6702743768692017,
-0.8281397819519043,
0.34527966380119324,
0.0693555399775505,
-1.2209168672561646,
-0.003976865671575069,
0.20326149463653564,
-0.2173188030719757,
0.14567294716835022,
-0.655001699924469,
1.1205204725265503,
-0.2958112061023712,
-0.6167246699333191,
-0.13635767996311188,
-0.35529428720474243,
0.4279078543186188,
-0.04095744341611862,
0.8293566703796387,
-0.3489351272583008,
0.0885583758354187,
0.5365880727767944,
-0.569631814956665,
0.5329470634460449,
-0.06392619013786316,
0.27141520380973816,
0.556130588054657,
0.21404968202114105,
0.5069318413734436,
-0.15088802576065063,
-0.36600252985954285,
-0.07868895679712296,
-0.007172249723225832,
-0.5227364897727966,
-0.6028450727462769,
0.74991375207901,
-0.8042315244674683,
-0.6604140996932983,
-0.5840365886688232,
-0.5028043389320374,
-0.2927403450012207,
0.10865405946969986,
0.22183600068092346,
0.4532264769077301,
-0.2722787857055664,
-0.0665368065237999,
0.2525474429130554,
0.003070287639275193,
0.2672352194786072,
0.5361962914466858,
-0.15726520121097565,
-0.34327083826065063,
0.9707369208335876,
-0.007381414528936148,
0.15128721296787262,
0.06225194036960602,
0.3961523771286011,
-0.345646470785141,
-0.9317778944969177,
-0.38526129722595215,
0.2807823717594147,
-0.6693468689918518,
-0.1437162309885025,
-0.20308250188827515,
0.058812566101551056,
-0.37679001688957214,
-0.16192299127578735,
-0.6341511607170105,
-0.28755122423171997,
-0.0385756678879261,
0.39340564608573914,
-0.3003518581390381,
0.9983775019645691,
-0.21990267932415009,
-0.02309398725628853,
-0.5675719976425171,
0.20577429234981537,
0.43552497029304504,
0.5335803031921387,
0.021820707246661186,
-0.47765418887138367,
-0.12223249673843384,
-0.08757266402244568,
-0.44281408190727234,
-0.9793587923049927,
0.2995125353336334,
0.1932932734489441,
0.5979688763618469,
0.18765603005886078,
-0.02846149541437626,
0.7004367113113403,
-0.727873682975769,
0.8324941396713257,
-0.0651494637131691,
-1.0965371131896973,
0.15748189389705658,
-0.27321627736091614,
0.2314087152481079,
0.564249575138092,
0.4425301253795624,
-0.5610700845718384,
-0.3321540355682373,
-0.6359118819236755,
-0.38456109166145325,
0.7456755042076111,
0.5231147408485413,
-0.25783658027648926,
-0.26323390007019043,
0.5783179402351379,
-0.13148437440395355,
0.22189021110534668,
-0.7328535318374634,
-0.16371387243270874,
0.01545428205281496,
-0.24390217661857605,
-0.061391059309244156,
-0.11402499675750732,
0.35030388832092285,
-0.20649603009223938,
0.6844509243965149,
0.049713071435689926,
0.11420931667089462,
0.15247923135757446,
-0.3255317211151123,
-0.09724622219800949,
0.25339287519454956,
0.5928255319595337,
0.8913513422012329,
-0.3260890245437622,
0.2076237052679062,
0.060108352452516556,
-0.267608106136322,
0.1341133415699005,
-0.013944171369075775,
0.04639827460050583,
-0.5138818025588989,
0.4203059673309326,
0.33525124192237854,
0.35147178173065186,
-0.9134179949760437,
0.4805068373680115,
-0.1925317794084549,
-0.12873105704784393,
-0.09842508286237717,
0.08132442831993103,
0.29982906579971313,
0.2950427532196045,
0.47932198643684387,
-0.35355135798454285,
0.19753414392471313,
-0.6651346683502197,
0.14366814494132996,
0.6714967489242554,
-0.19068726897239685,
-0.6332442760467529,
1.004888892173767,
0.3937356472015381,
-0.604619026184082,
0.6743239760398865,
-0.623747706413269,
-0.9367676377296448,
0.8503947257995605,
0.8911947011947632,
0.6073150634765625,
-0.3072183132171631,
0.006760942749679089,
0.44731593132019043,
0.3247065246105194,
-0.29533475637435913,
0.5996055603027344,
-0.13689978420734406,
-0.8466928601264954,
-0.3997865617275238,
-0.42599985003471375,
-0.580928385257721,
0.15074600279331207,
-0.3984348773956299,
-0.07307615131139755,
-0.23413881659507751,
0.20134389400482178,
-0.09358461946249008,
0.31874340772628784,
-0.805122971534729,
0.030608678236603737,
0.41642332077026367,
0.8340364694595337,
-0.8932713866233826,
0.7900745868682861,
0.630032479763031,
-0.2010246068239212,
-0.4840082824230194,
-0.4777914583683014,
0.2287389039993286,
-0.8900201916694641,
0.5125956535339355,
0.048653751611709595,
0.060137368738651276,
0.2804831564426422,
-0.7177866697311401,
-0.6842591762542725,
0.7514356970787048,
0.359372079372406,
-0.527561366558075,
0.15807431936264038,
0.2534925937652588,
0.3438740372657776,
-0.49104511737823486,
0.47324880957603455,
0.6877219676971436,
0.3324165344238281,
0.11552005261182785,
-1.1354509592056274,
-0.1663348227739334,
-0.2978963553905487,
0.03079061023890972,
0.12737610936164856,
-0.376492440700531,
1.18612802028656,
-0.3848552703857422,
-0.05597185343503952,
0.4402104318141937,
0.31673142313957214,
0.5126582384109497,
0.388916552066803,
0.3186725974082947,
0.682884931564331,
0.8877200484275818,
0.07257182151079178,
1.3240855932235718,
-0.20378616452217102,
0.8221773505210876,
1.026930809020996,
-0.5208760499954224,
0.6022485494613647,
0.3098222017288208,
-0.6920692324638367,
0.3360801339149475,
0.4962462782859802,
0.35803744196891785,
0.46970024704933167,
0.7305651307106018,
-0.2548411190509796,
-0.5817416310310364,
0.1707877218723297,
-0.35745689272880554,
0.34090352058410645,
0.3186684846878052,
0.20402491092681885,
-0.43795835971832275,
-0.18079420924186707,
0.18848496675491333,
0.35311779379844666,
-0.26052433252334595,
0.2835625410079956,
0.207638680934906,
-0.8839025497436523,
0.8324887752532959,
-0.040136199444532394,
0.3801145851612091,
-0.18250024318695068,
-0.17284078896045685,
-0.39792779088020325,
0.43061184883117676,
0.15228977799415588,
-0.578572690486908,
0.02336028404533863,
0.2852165997028351,
0.13064250349998474,
-0.14014843106269836,
0.5721498131752014,
-0.41054674983024597,
-0.45507556200027466,
-0.01150109339505434,
0.44878706336021423,
0.633647084236145,
-0.3927054703235626,
-0.8476913571357727,
0.31258973479270935,
0.0141152860596776,
-0.25052958726882935,
0.23167166113853455,
0.39217785000801086,
-0.04910514876246452,
0.7940436005592346,
0.3494686782360077,
0.004499915521591902,
0.1408880203962326,
-0.14063124358654022,
0.7204065918922424,
-0.8250078558921814,
-0.3545287847518921,
-0.8260011076927185,
0.34827908873558044,
-0.1081821396946907,
-0.32035917043685913,
0.3769170939922333,
0.6170250773429871,
0.675629734992981,
-0.03718996047973633,
0.8106192350387573,
0.09809211641550064,
0.3838503062725067,
-0.3203417658805847,
0.5864512920379639,
-0.4942156970500946,
0.22973881661891937,
-0.28162798285484314,
-0.7550058364868164,
-0.33296293020248413,
0.7356981039047241,
-0.34520140290260315,
0.12584587931632996,
0.9104762077331543,
0.5678266286849976,
0.016399189829826355,
0.0314197763800621,
0.4988347887992859,
0.2931913733482361,
0.3747186064720154,
1.0933870077133179,
1.0464638471603394,
-0.33450135588645935,
0.5505309104919434,
-0.5136955380439758,
-0.5318884253501892,
-0.25493332743644714,
-1.0926352739334106,
-0.959790050983429,
-0.48439475893974304,
-0.1980539709329605,
-0.13077932596206665,
0.3935041129589081,
0.8813436627388,
0.5815193057060242,
-0.7043042182922363,
-0.4970476031303406,
-0.3276132345199585,
0.43408966064453125,
-0.13520260155200958,
-0.11198528110980988,
0.2364206314086914,
-0.4764740467071533,
-0.7618155479431152,
0.5688945055007935,
-0.03293970972299576,
-0.18366575241088867,
0.0606946237385273,
-0.224954754114151,
-0.2005234956741333,
0.09600399434566498,
0.16071279346942902,
0.6252560019493103,
-0.665386438369751,
-0.33303216099739075,
0.2071419358253479,
0.031323786824941635,
0.053636349737644196,
0.9179326891899109,
-0.8717710375785828,
0.7673810720443726,
0.33845436573028564,
0.48002129793167114,
0.6002811789512634,
0.07088114321231842,
0.5328854322433472,
-0.4811211824417114,
0.28151845932006836,
0.4136582911014557,
0.45615729689598083,
0.1667259782552719,
0.09017526358366013,
0.5153911709785461,
0.5050413012504578,
-0.9715016484260559,
-0.9391536712646484,
0.21637645363807678,
-0.35958966612815857,
-0.3818044066429138,
0.8295555710792542,
-0.20658865571022034,
-0.37346088886260986,
-0.3740232586860657,
0.11198023706674576,
-0.05845894664525986,
-0.13492625951766968,
0.9944018125534058,
1.0598574876785278,
-0.606731653213501,
-0.04835875704884529,
-0.7255551218986511,
0.5620585680007935,
0.4598333239555359,
-0.6697481870651245,
0.006148042157292366,
0.23632952570915222,
0.39354759454727173,
-0.06186433508992195,
1.011075735092163,
-0.014007597230374813,
0.375528484582901,
0.1821998953819275,
0.24539633095264435,
-0.16848255693912506,
-0.3308402895927429,
-0.18574899435043335,
-0.03847125172615051,
0.41054314374923706,
0.015187603421509266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10939v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10939v1
|
More Room for Language: Investigating the Effect of Retrieval on Language Models
| 2024-04-16T22:43:48 | 2024-04-16T22:43:48 |
David Samuel, Lucas Georges Gabriel Charpentier, Sondre Wold
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented language models pose a promising alternative to standard
language modeling. During pretraining, these models search in a corpus of
documents for contextually relevant information that could aid the language
modeling objective. We introduce an 'ideal retrieval' methodology to study
these models in a fully controllable setting. We conduct an extensive
evaluation to examine how retrieval augmentation affects the behavior of the
underlying language model. Among other things, we observe that these models: i)
save substantially less world knowledge in their weights, ii) are better at
understanding local context and inter-word dependencies, but iii) are worse at
comprehending global context.
|
[
-0.3314664661884308,
-0.7501633167266846,
0.5335383415222168,
-0.25188589096069336,
-0.053554169833660126,
-0.11414837837219238,
-0.2244071364402771,
-0.5537697672843933,
0.11891201883554459,
0.6104007363319397,
-0.24585101008415222,
0.036307718604803085,
-0.30768388509750366,
-0.028589460998773575,
-0.674936056137085,
0.43510982394218445,
-0.1617654412984848,
0.17603762447834015,
-0.4890872538089752,
-0.12804418802261353,
-0.7284973859786987,
-0.9996722340583801,
-0.35423293709754944,
-0.5815436840057373,
0.3839370012283325,
0.10561202466487885,
0.8171383142471313,
0.37928712368011475,
0.5278128385543823,
0.3097071945667267,
-0.25758200883865356,
-0.3400641679763794,
-0.4971778094768524,
0.05949665606021881,
-0.07128515839576721,
-0.6481158137321472,
-0.17494261264801025,
0.22988732159137726,
0.8093011379241943,
0.9116009473800659,
-0.34150803089141846,
0.006560328882187605,
-0.21675774455070496,
0.6823912262916565,
-0.9049517512321472,
0.009421516209840775,
-0.576335072517395,
-0.010349803604185581,
-0.08847581595182419,
-0.31327664852142334,
-0.4136236011981964,
-0.13973349332809448,
0.488150954246521,
-0.6187784671783447,
0.3082147240638733,
0.2432190328836441,
0.8192728161811829,
0.06113845854997635,
-0.4407000243663788,
-0.27744388580322266,
-0.7038329839706421,
0.7432814240455627,
-0.45201921463012695,
0.7840012311935425,
0.7134150266647339,
0.15567265450954437,
0.04036876931786537,
-0.8110893964767456,
-0.6208946108818054,
-0.48610952496528625,
-0.39950528740882874,
0.11149962991476059,
-0.01279235165566206,
0.18917766213417053,
0.19198837876319885,
0.45223718881607056,
-0.3980894982814789,
-0.318937212228775,
-0.44575685262680054,
-0.08858831971883774,
0.4610755145549774,
-0.08105255663394928,
0.6217677593231201,
-0.23079606890678406,
-0.0469261109828949,
-0.10323423892259598,
-0.8768694996833801,
-0.11397472769021988,
0.33874988555908203,
0.4743313193321228,
0.32903844118118286,
0.5481921434402466,
-0.27170810103416443,
0.987558126449585,
-0.2727245092391968,
0.27034899592399597,
0.011919854208827019,
-0.2974635660648346,
-0.11122482270002365,
0.09487251937389374,
0.01986122690141201,
0.1399727463722229,
0.12310072779655457,
-0.23683463037014008,
-0.219291552901268,
-0.18187274038791656,
0.3636213541030884,
-0.9065158367156982,
-0.17870038747787476,
-0.14235328137874603,
-0.3818790018558502,
-0.007434073369950056,
0.1781798005104065,
-0.046058714389801025,
-0.18793885409832,
-0.6098700761795044,
0.7073569297790527,
-0.5845367908477783,
-0.2917567491531372,
0.09852135181427002,
-0.43517956137657166,
0.45131397247314453,
0.20280879735946655,
-0.8153960704803467,
0.4469466805458069,
0.47313669323921204,
0.8231179714202881,
-0.03214689716696739,
-0.20384277403354645,
-0.38513505458831787,
0.015211437828838825,
-0.5659406185150146,
0.6942020654678345,
-1.0163371562957764,
-0.6725578904151917,
0.14431749284267426,
0.12495720386505127,
-0.091065913438797,
-0.6289682984352112,
0.3464091420173645,
-1.0030310153961182,
0.5127784013748169,
-0.503379762172699,
-0.7297771573066711,
-0.28697529435157776,
0.14077100157737732,
-0.7830064296722412,
0.9463724493980408,
0.2528930604457855,
-0.4981580972671509,
0.34171247482299805,
-0.6100197434425354,
-0.269692599773407,
0.08442474901676178,
-0.05760112777352333,
0.14855879545211792,
0.5003300309181213,
0.053892407566308975,
0.018581006675958633,
-0.09540632367134094,
0.24347026646137238,
-0.12540310621261597,
-0.6103588342666626,
0.12141799926757812,
-0.3006877601146698,
0.6294563412666321,
0.38061726093292236,
0.16615363955497742,
-0.18524083495140076,
-0.5982192158699036,
0.028393225744366646,
-0.043347086757421494,
-0.49906274676322937,
-0.9800281524658203,
0.07364892214536667,
0.006720689591020346,
0.055521007627248764,
0.27173343300819397,
-0.6010615825653076,
0.21298524737358093,
-0.5403301119804382,
0.053542666137218475,
0.3425823748111725,
-0.1938045769929886,
0.8914461135864258,
-0.2624311149120331,
0.660269558429718,
-0.3527865409851074,
-0.08157321810722351,
-0.22548310458660126,
-0.1024952307343483,
-0.6609236001968384,
0.08942507207393646,
0.5317674279212952,
0.33958181738853455,
-0.7420877814292908,
0.073280468583107,
-0.1490623950958252,
-0.1096017062664032,
-0.5630236864089966,
0.03972452133893967,
0.42611637711524963,
0.3525301218032837,
0.2990856170654297,
-0.371499240398407,
-0.9302762150764465,
-0.6522359251976013,
-0.4456043243408203,
0.020773403346538544,
0.05508941411972046,
0.4444136321544647,
0.49963557720184326,
-0.18007802963256836,
0.9882531762123108,
-0.44858986139297485,
-0.1573377251625061,
-0.3000485599040985,
-0.26346129179000854,
-0.06668974459171295,
0.4718136191368103,
0.7051981687545776,
-0.9078867435455322,
-0.4452924132347107,
-0.05850157514214516,
-0.586444616317749,
-0.10175532847642899,
0.3604724705219269,
-0.1582104116678238,
0.14925776422023773,
0.7563096880912781,
-0.5154959559440613,
0.4963071048259735,
0.45265626907348633,
-0.2500472068786621,
0.4083476960659027,
-0.40274131298065186,
0.19144664704799652,
-0.878672182559967,
0.2662406265735626,
-0.4741288423538208,
-0.15177351236343384,
-0.8402647972106934,
0.5371862649917603,
0.2396484762430191,
-0.3043205738067627,
-0.43418779969215393,
1.100463628768921,
-0.7312300205230713,
-0.1516958475112915,
-0.5404381155967712,
0.44911712408065796,
0.22866623103618622,
-0.03490440919995308,
0.37112024426460266,
0.9984321594238281,
0.3585303723812103,
-0.5902745723724365,
0.08898014575242996,
0.19951020181179047,
-0.6369871497154236,
0.07168301939964294,
-0.4709230661392212,
0.1558654010295868,
-0.412813663482666,
0.26146200299263,
-1.0169322490692139,
-0.32187971472740173,
-0.4963764548301697,
-0.4782494902610779,
0.5012162327766418,
0.035382211208343506,
-0.2959873378276825,
-0.29620152711868286,
-0.2659823000431061,
0.3815895915031433,
0.40339064598083496,
-0.6166226863861084,
0.3001909554004669,
0.4588387906551361,
-0.11516863852739334,
-0.6370160579681396,
-0.6124612092971802,
-0.06648506969213486,
0.003749310038983822,
-0.2922317683696747,
0.5028326511383057,
-0.11501874029636383,
-0.562652587890625,
0.054663121700286865,
-0.20103682577610016,
-0.30298691987991333,
0.2111000120639801,
-0.1313973069190979,
0.16379934549331665,
-0.20476067066192627,
0.5037946701049805,
-0.04524562507867813,
0.017275357618927956,
-0.15620988607406616,
-0.17155566811561584,
0.7144618034362793,
-0.21017539501190186,
-0.33473098278045654,
-0.16113817691802979,
0.39461836218833923,
0.09540814906358719,
-0.3208097219467163,
1.0417147874832153,
0.3323577344417572,
-0.6029433608055115,
0.287093847990036,
-0.6928980946540833,
-0.3303166329860687,
-0.4912947118282318,
0.5405294895172119,
-0.516848087310791,
-1.0244632959365845,
0.5889929533004761,
0.21943695843219757,
-0.24469099938869476,
0.19793635606765747,
0.36648207902908325,
0.00926351547241211,
1.255920171737671,
1.1015177965164185,
-0.02618972398340702,
1.0904213190078735,
-0.24621926248073578,
0.29249876737594604,
-1.0702334642410278,
-0.09500670433044434,
-0.6164377331733704,
0.008796378038823605,
-0.2885379195213318,
-0.41543325781822205,
-0.05878704786300659,
0.512127161026001,
-0.0356440432369709,
0.4162421226501465,
-0.3481992483139038,
0.8268534541130066,
0.39797380566596985,
-0.06829153746366501,
0.3688468337059021,
-0.006629549898207188,
-0.13659964501857758,
-0.09643451869487762,
-0.862585723400116,
-0.45515283942222595,
0.9562456607818604,
-0.07863907516002655,
0.7014020085334778,
0.1956811547279358,
0.5701380372047424,
-0.007259679958224297,
0.6278147101402283,
-0.7089236378669739,
0.20163433253765106,
-0.046511098742485046,
-1.0947126150131226,
-0.35853350162506104,
-0.34853988885879517,
-1.1859036684036255,
0.4525962471961975,
0.00899428315460682,
-0.8494222164154053,
0.2391642928123474,
0.10012571513652802,
-0.42444026470184326,
0.024479979649186134,
-0.8752549290657043,
0.657772958278656,
-0.14050117135047913,
-0.27177536487579346,
-0.35814881324768066,
-0.4289020001888275,
0.32964229583740234,
-0.07283678650856018,
0.28280699253082275,
0.12176317721605301,
-0.03142296522855759,
0.6002604961395264,
-0.4221220016479492,
0.3923121690750122,
-0.25000301003456116,
-0.03102089650928974,
0.4747045338153839,
0.1903637796640396,
0.21094100177288055,
-0.0799950510263443,
-0.6575310230255127,
-0.2833830714225769,
0.2541565001010895,
-0.49485689401626587,
-0.7361161708831787,
0.6850006580352783,
-0.7278711795806885,
-0.6963464021682739,
-0.2609809339046478,
-0.6524567008018494,
-0.1744769960641861,
0.3538254499435425,
0.12587128579616547,
0.6222227811813354,
-0.39674296975135803,
0.4494793713092804,
0.5369831323623657,
-0.5003454685211182,
0.3753679394721985,
0.8494983315467834,
-0.5792674422264099,
0.07977574318647385,
0.6417428255081177,
0.4535699486732483,
0.23482054471969604,
0.6799867153167725,
0.3148227632045746,
-0.6333299875259399,
-0.3630712628364563,
-0.09092361479997635,
0.034023117274045944,
-0.652593731880188,
-0.024943146854639053,
-0.5112612843513489,
-0.22057385742664337,
-0.6715295910835266,
-0.03986423835158348,
-0.2209252268075943,
-0.45586809515953064,
-0.07997920364141464,
-0.20692750811576843,
0.3283906579017639,
0.6858603358268738,
-0.0863775685429573,
0.7042505145072937,
-0.8313320279121399,
-0.02905067428946495,
0.31676027178764343,
0.4753245711326599,
0.023414844647049904,
-0.8954658508300781,
-0.36159029603004456,
0.034692149609327316,
-0.12039048224687576,
-0.8337183594703674,
0.6007605791091919,
0.37650278210639954,
0.7268720865249634,
0.22615578770637512,
0.01985783316195011,
0.8931329250335693,
-0.692510724067688,
0.7323673963546753,
0.017550524324178696,
-0.9356718063354492,
0.6836211085319519,
-0.16475734114646912,
0.4407508373260498,
0.5673769116401672,
0.39076370000839233,
-0.5151544213294983,
-0.06289259344339371,
-0.7127258777618408,
-0.8567001223564148,
0.762338399887085,
0.021472226828336716,
0.7463350296020508,
-0.16175666451454163,
0.7909244298934937,
-0.16122542321681976,
0.4608568549156189,
-0.7631944417953491,
0.02596299536526203,
0.07276776432991028,
0.25915876030921936,
-0.12798425555229187,
-0.46194565296173096,
0.15164095163345337,
-0.5190397500991821,
0.7476606965065002,
0.06605380773544312,
0.21294201910495758,
0.25054776668548584,
-0.4653710126876831,
-0.24654531478881836,
0.2912605106830597,
0.4476853907108307,
0.7876185774803162,
-0.33279675245285034,
-0.008769601583480835,
0.3993269205093384,
-0.2461695671081543,
-0.020907150581479073,
0.11240678280591965,
-0.091204933822155,
0.13525205850601196,
0.36916789412498474,
0.7823626399040222,
0.1639268398284912,
-0.8351904153823853,
0.5338003635406494,
-0.19145356118679047,
-0.04319868981838226,
-0.39290863275527954,
0.11588113754987717,
0.022710461169481277,
0.03417658433318138,
0.33062535524368286,
-0.16456741094589233,
0.3429833948612213,
-1.0338475704193115,
0.38747313618659973,
0.5722876191139221,
-0.6626766324043274,
-0.3002382814884186,
0.48041731119155884,
0.018326934427022934,
-0.5749656558036804,
0.6353055238723755,
-0.12058409303426743,
-0.5182069540023804,
0.3203583359718323,
0.7887312173843384,
0.3965222239494324,
-0.493405818939209,
-0.08836662024259567,
0.36404967308044434,
0.21866482496261597,
-0.18448643386363983,
0.2792051434516907,
-0.10856490582227707,
-0.9637957811355591,
-0.6467640995979309,
-0.7727271318435669,
-0.30477017164230347,
0.21696148812770844,
-0.7522382736206055,
0.07338055968284607,
-0.12437207251787186,
-0.11976485699415207,
-0.3429887294769287,
0.23581372201442719,
-0.5472044944763184,
0.19293059408664703,
0.03381834924221039,
0.9882434010505676,
-0.49332883954048157,
1.147864818572998,
0.9099631905555725,
-0.4556870460510254,
-0.8362812399864197,
-0.13583336770534515,
-0.3610440492630005,
-0.828254759311676,
0.7018022537231445,
0.32178667187690735,
-0.11143308132886887,
0.07442297786474228,
-0.5565270781517029,
-1.1426146030426025,
0.8636090755462646,
0.49011483788490295,
-0.5064019560813904,
-0.2089262306690216,
-0.2688576281070709,
0.7993249893188477,
-0.19468407332897186,
0.39624232053756714,
0.7505466938018799,
0.38725435733795166,
-0.19001077115535736,
-0.8618056774139404,
-0.16315831243991852,
-0.3453693985939026,
0.24620506167411804,
0.2844914495944977,
-0.4621056318283081,
0.9347197413444519,
-0.17621690034866333,
-0.2913276255130768,
0.3469623029232025,
0.5059158205986023,
-0.002477611182257533,
-0.0550314262509346,
0.4077056348323822,
0.4389171600341797,
0.7778111696243286,
0.04529961198568344,
1.644271969795227,
-0.505894660949707,
0.3356556296348572,
1.1192177534103394,
-0.3196299076080322,
1.057782769203186,
0.5435020327568054,
-0.16064850986003876,
0.3082177937030792,
0.5093727111816406,
0.6685974597930908,
0.577017605304718,
0.3137982189655304,
-0.22154970467090607,
-0.20202799141407013,
-0.25008150935173035,
-0.551530122756958,
0.343313068151474,
0.3877469003200531,
-0.16808833181858063,
-0.033675361424684525,
0.14172929525375366,
-0.19151605665683746,
0.2874703109264374,
-0.08878927677869797,
0.616389811038971,
0.18617309629917145,
-0.695661723613739,
0.6037046909332275,
-0.061875343322753906,
0.44137418270111084,
-0.5277659893035889,
-0.04919765517115593,
-0.26231199502944946,
0.24897688627243042,
-0.05462285503745079,
-0.36031338572502136,
0.5136145949363708,
-0.14878898859024048,
-0.16680094599723816,
-0.3116198778152466,
0.8827447891235352,
-0.5760676860809326,
-0.39016193151474,
0.4569690525531769,
0.8820377588272095,
0.2913745939731598,
-0.28493165969848633,
-0.5686858892440796,
-0.047563716769218445,
-0.12030383199453354,
-0.5092728137969971,
0.49138954281806946,
0.3126780688762665,
-0.06740032136440277,
0.5555636286735535,
0.6030614376068115,
0.10580137372016907,
0.13954144716262817,
0.35677120089530945,
0.6162733435630798,
-0.5937185883522034,
-0.31523406505584717,
-0.6809489727020264,
0.058443110436201096,
-0.10421913862228394,
-0.037487711757421494,
0.8516518473625183,
0.6108620166778564,
1.0424081087112427,
0.020460236817598343,
0.6862719058990479,
-0.26206228137016296,
0.5981664061546326,
-0.441192090511322,
0.6962122321128845,
-0.9699017405509949,
0.3339902460575104,
-0.2929702699184418,
-0.971001386642456,
-0.38205686211586,
0.9807723164558411,
-0.5903851985931396,
0.16270190477371216,
0.5773016810417175,
0.89420086145401,
-0.001411502598784864,
-0.090669184923172,
0.5991942286491394,
0.046261221170425415,
0.22536492347717285,
-0.014009288512170315,
1.1674543619155884,
-0.3915463089942932,
0.42588895559310913,
-0.12864886224269867,
-0.07873068749904633,
-0.2343916893005371,
-0.6457082033157349,
-0.6542183756828308,
-0.6538034677505493,
0.1657155156135559,
-0.04197920486330986,
0.26001545786857605,
0.705162763595581,
0.8319647312164307,
-0.7511589527130127,
-0.42744317650794983,
-0.14505784213542938,
0.1757059544324875,
0.10337790846824646,
-0.2607404887676239,
0.3070395886898041,
-0.623997688293457,
-0.7767966389656067,
0.4851442575454712,
-0.057434577494859695,
0.009458254091441631,
-0.07998373359441757,
-0.14484591782093048,
-0.4964256286621094,
0.19432730972766876,
0.9166355133056641,
0.05423448979854584,
-0.5810834765434265,
-0.5521878600120544,
0.21527259051799774,
0.06726764142513275,
-0.03079225867986679,
1.0312190055847168,
-0.9312489628791809,
0.6658943891525269,
0.6941616535186768,
0.584412157535553,
0.555057168006897,
0.036847930401563644,
0.9213243126869202,
-0.9456371665000916,
0.4788364768028259,
0.11370304226875305,
0.4641910791397095,
0.3850058913230896,
-0.26450932025909424,
0.5361960530281067,
0.12530618906021118,
-0.41812634468078613,
-0.9124978184700012,
0.22830738127231598,
-0.3074204623699188,
-0.5453036427497864,
0.9831203818321228,
-0.0062805661000311375,
-0.1620580554008484,
0.052362605929374695,
-0.39110130071640015,
0.3924369513988495,
-0.2687138319015503,
0.733676552772522,
0.9551628828048706,
-0.18577395379543304,
-0.12696868181228638,
-0.9461228251457214,
0.5606350302696228,
0.6964902281761169,
-0.4360138475894928,
-0.022078417241573334,
0.5329695343971252,
0.23187255859375,
0.2484823316335678,
0.8640024662017822,
-0.18820065259933472,
0.1510763168334961,
-0.12862712144851685,
0.07098832726478577,
0.28046953678131104,
-0.3886789083480835,
-0.43307122588157654,
-0.1323850303888321,
0.41015174984931946,
0.2631429433822632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10934v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10934v1
|
Shears: Unstructured Sparsity with Neural Low-rank Adapter Search
| 2024-04-16T22:12:36 | 2024-04-16T22:12:36 |
J. Pablo Muñoz, Jinjie Yuan, Nilesh Jain
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recently, several approaches successfully demonstrated that weight-sharing
Neural Architecture Search (NAS) can effectively explore a search space of
elastic low-rank adapters (LoRA), allowing the parameter-efficient fine-tuning
(PEFT) and compression of large language models. In this paper, we introduce a
novel approach called Shears, demonstrating how the integration of
cost-effective sparsity and a proposed Neural Low-rank adapter Search (NLS)
algorithm can further improve the efficiency of PEFT approaches. Results
demonstrate the benefits of Shears compared to other methods, reaching high
sparsity levels while improving or with little drop in accuracy, utilizing a
single GPU for a pair of hours.
|
[
-0.4022596776485443,
-0.6334394216537476,
0.41776180267333984,
0.38604456186294556,
-0.194793701171875,
0.08538229763507843,
-0.14810606837272644,
-0.1832270622253418,
0.6266270279884338,
0.14368776977062225,
-0.36733415722846985,
-0.16115041077136993,
-0.6415050625801086,
-0.06855334341526031,
-0.43051838874816895,
0.7570717334747314,
0.2512401342391968,
-0.09524323046207428,
0.2330392599105835,
-0.2517452836036682,
-0.001248513930477202,
-0.3193442225456238,
-0.8523141145706177,
-0.11630542576313019,
0.4194590449333191,
0.24960343539714813,
1.116584300994873,
0.5959771871566772,
0.5030258893966675,
0.42677754163742065,
-0.7997044324874878,
0.42096346616744995,
-0.5529966354370117,
-0.113922618329525,
-0.19542096555233002,
0.0007670514169149101,
-0.47034144401550293,
-0.19819588959217072,
1.0387847423553467,
1.0921616554260254,
-0.2872663140296936,
0.058275677263736725,
0.4985087811946869,
1.0731596946716309,
-0.630237340927124,
-0.558038055896759,
-0.5657885670661926,
0.19245047867298126,
-0.26705360412597656,
-0.5458337664604187,
-0.17036238312721252,
-0.008509946055710316,
0.19227711856365204,
-0.5387924313545227,
0.22815725207328796,
-0.24274425208568573,
0.5708954334259033,
0.43319979310035706,
-0.22603444755077362,
0.1380140483379364,
-0.35667431354522705,
0.673639178276062,
-0.7111573815345764,
0.6918452978134155,
-0.10889668762683868,
-0.07770069688558578,
-0.46230849623680115,
-0.6340159177780151,
-0.07690903544425964,
0.17711564898490906,
0.009871200658380985,
-0.1963132619857788,
-0.31516698002815247,
0.07558704167604446,
-0.05497673898935318,
0.46309179067611694,
-0.30826157331466675,
0.23368079960346222,
-0.5133681893348694,
-0.035528093576431274,
0.47076019644737244,
0.012521013617515564,
0.2663160264492035,
-0.06377111375331879,
-0.415205180644989,
-0.06995587050914764,
-0.8231074213981628,
0.6052800416946411,
0.28823310136795044,
0.5878633856773376,
-0.0849686861038208,
0.34469521045684814,
-0.18191684782505035,
0.8547371029853821,
0.023212196305394173,
0.1710292100906372,
-0.023060893639922142,
0.011235417798161507,
-0.04780824854969978,
-0.0940515547990799,
0.6135473847389221,
0.22876402735710144,
-0.25344374775886536,
-0.5216958522796631,
-0.5165868997573853,
-0.3007907271385193,
0.2296663522720337,
-0.7903146147727966,
-0.14537516236305237,
-0.06285497546195984,
-0.8334516286849976,
-0.7582435607910156,
-0.1492834836244583,
-0.8738960027694702,
-0.5017760992050171,
-0.07441528141498566,
0.29721102118492126,
-0.32241567969322205,
-0.1853061020374298,
0.2619914412498474,
-0.49092406034469604,
0.26697853207588196,
0.3209752142429352,
-0.753444254398346,
0.9248733520507812,
0.6503864526748657,
1.3377745151519775,
-0.33732378482818604,
-0.3334052264690399,
-1.1020913124084473,
-0.19530999660491943,
-0.45057258009910583,
1.0314316749572754,
-0.39812740683555603,
-0.31460967659950256,
-0.19638940691947937,
0.03864063322544098,
-0.09000502526760101,
-0.3589809536933899,
0.5308597683906555,
-0.3417060971260071,
-0.2263154685497284,
-0.019933516159653664,
-0.15262044966220856,
-0.1774534285068512,
0.12576086819171906,
-0.6826750040054321,
1.4255928993225098,
0.33843547105789185,
-0.33861082792282104,
-0.08210794627666473,
-0.9014183282852173,
-0.4922800064086914,
0.1346122920513153,
0.08495272696018219,
-0.13377317786216736,
0.587687611579895,
0.15428557991981506,
0.44378000497817993,
-0.41350793838500977,
0.26003092527389526,
-0.3278055787086487,
-0.706693172454834,
0.18023128807544708,
-0.5041571259498596,
0.5129261612892151,
-0.05818300321698189,
-0.3357478082180023,
0.01666668988764286,
-0.6387331485748291,
0.09804533421993256,
0.10035164654254913,
-0.513233482837677,
-0.44351625442504883,
0.2746914327144623,
0.2574135661125183,
0.012119228020310402,
0.2116859406232834,
-0.43676161766052246,
0.24751491844654083,
-0.8037236928939819,
0.7238454222679138,
0.9783252477645874,
-0.4628818929195404,
0.8084124326705933,
-0.33829015493392944,
0.03631895035505295,
-0.012907817959785461,
0.047071874141693115,
0.5185964703559875,
-0.3299665153026581,
-0.5955832600593567,
-0.05598296970129013,
0.5018668174743652,
0.20113322138786316,
-0.5917518734931946,
0.05596721172332764,
-0.15849795937538147,
-0.6974828243255615,
-0.5816127061843872,
0.311710387468338,
0.4415365159511566,
0.3258591294288635,
0.46106696128845215,
-0.3265305459499359,
-0.4083004891872406,
-0.8325446844100952,
-0.46422991156578064,
0.32259151339530945,
-0.16238395869731903,
0.5025235414505005,
-0.1058080792427063,
0.001627061516046524,
0.5064507126808167,
-0.6009039878845215,
-0.4245610237121582,
-0.10454478114843369,
0.12034837901592255,
0.5044084787368774,
0.5922173261642456,
0.9197571873664856,
-0.8190937042236328,
-0.281755656003952,
-0.04379085823893547,
-0.08883063495159149,
0.13817912340164185,
0.2183535397052765,
-0.07086431235074997,
0.31815651059150696,
0.7477796673774719,
-0.2106838971376419,
0.4355694651603699,
0.9104293584823608,
-0.4704955220222473,
0.021240320056676865,
-0.4116320013999939,
-0.15477149188518524,
-0.7441785335540771,
0.061175305396318436,
0.2777784764766693,
-0.21466422080993652,
-0.5331800580024719,
-0.07473444938659668,
-0.14587533473968506,
-0.2424958199262619,
-0.5630349516868591,
0.43206626176834106,
-0.5458458065986633,
-0.26264524459838867,
-0.11632274091243744,
0.28923583030700684,
-0.05841655284166336,
0.7624278664588928,
-0.05806950479745865,
1.2324943542480469,
0.5324369668960571,
-0.8191510438919067,
-0.06096545606851578,
-0.009644930250942707,
-0.13557900488376617,
0.13162383437156677,
-0.9263215065002441,
0.1833672672510147,
-0.23965668678283691,
-0.04528091102838516,
-0.9624152183532715,
0.29277631640434265,
-0.19176700711250305,
-0.28395017981529236,
0.14338462054729462,
-0.4804086685180664,
0.01866062544286251,
-0.021686196327209473,
-0.8390787243843079,
0.5581409931182861,
0.5404408574104309,
-0.8312387466430664,
0.7648366689682007,
0.7998059988021851,
-0.1931736320257187,
-0.7147761583328247,
-0.2986724376678467,
-0.07474187761545181,
0.09747856110334396,
-0.5728024244308472,
0.7593849897384644,
-0.16407959163188934,
0.04118635505437851,
0.1594352275133133,
-0.19497209787368774,
-0.2792004644870758,
0.3880372643470764,
0.026794105768203735,
0.29632189869880676,
-0.7092114686965942,
-0.3135349154472351,
0.34096845984458923,
0.007169653661549091,
-0.23832793533802032,
-0.3117527663707733,
0.7792202830314636,
-0.7002598643302917,
0.033194199204444885,
-0.2582809329032898,
0.2452886551618576,
0.6581028699874878,
0.08967940509319305,
0.6429167985916138,
0.3855960965156555,
-0.35851216316223145,
-0.28339019417762756,
-0.5357710123062134,
0.02670004963874817,
-0.6408992409706116,
0.40629076957702637,
-0.32875239849090576,
-0.7900570631027222,
0.2281995713710785,
-0.5809770822525024,
-0.0424463227391243,
0.49916332960128784,
0.16295234858989716,
-0.29204505681991577,
1.1306979656219482,
0.7112900018692017,
-0.331498384475708,
0.3741644024848938,
-0.31048518419265747,
0.07038488239049911,
-1.1498005390167236,
0.022740663960576057,
-0.6494405269622803,
-0.9731403589248657,
-0.6568937301635742,
-0.4652014374732971,
0.5293047428131104,
0.16312812268733978,
-0.1727009117603302,
0.3051092028617859,
-1.048667311668396,
0.8860201835632324,
0.5469088554382324,
0.23184576630592346,
0.0045179277658462524,
-0.04027646780014038,
-0.07411234080791473,
0.12244037538766861,
-0.9287203550338745,
-0.1976843774318695,
0.7191756963729858,
0.2879117429256439,
0.5864266157150269,
0.4127167761325836,
0.35687318444252014,
0.2877500355243683,
-0.06153237074613571,
-0.954006016254425,
0.5148055553436279,
-0.9063338041305542,
0.07656952738761902,
-0.7144705653190613,
-0.26368337869644165,
-0.8701068162918091,
0.3183130621910095,
-0.45849862694740295,
-0.7325317859649658,
0.5482354164123535,
0.27975764870643616,
-0.5505384206771851,
0.6162499785423279,
-0.3654853403568268,
0.5353332757949829,
-0.18945366144180298,
-0.32602646946907043,
-0.14243213832378387,
-0.3566254675388336,
-0.11098718643188477,
0.34417277574539185,
0.247083380818367,
-0.04728393629193306,
-0.22683747112751007,
0.9997798204421997,
-0.33482131361961365,
0.7300959825515747,
-0.28678008913993835,
0.2967435121536255,
-0.06882809847593307,
0.30932024121284485,
0.616707980632782,
0.16359347105026245,
-0.20055587589740753,
0.39918479323387146,
0.01242046058177948,
-0.2681120038032532,
-0.6531239748001099,
0.7944153547286987,
-0.9168388247489929,
-0.3650122284889221,
-0.3024590015411377,
-0.6554657220840454,
-0.24526818096637726,
0.3636004626750946,
0.10543268918991089,
0.638330340385437,
-0.41709333658218384,
0.500744640827179,
0.8023133277893066,
-0.005363562610000372,
0.48449254035949707,
0.4690914750099182,
0.2095663845539093,
-0.4744112491607666,
0.9793378710746765,
0.16906467080116272,
-0.310604453086853,
0.3827609419822693,
0.43042200803756714,
0.03620387241244316,
-0.7793840169906616,
-0.5929666757583618,
0.1471947729587555,
-0.10099923610687256,
-0.6410028338432312,
-0.38911113142967224,
-0.6106060743331909,
-0.32655230164527893,
-0.6780479550361633,
-0.8200254440307617,
-0.6567809581756592,
-0.27657753229141235,
0.26075297594070435,
0.4086964726448059,
0.9139827489852905,
-0.17707130312919617,
0.4501771330833435,
-0.8500592112541199,
0.281960666179657,
-0.008812939748167992,
0.7777618169784546,
0.09792888164520264,
-0.7798758149147034,
-0.06375279277563095,
0.036784593015909195,
-0.4296465516090393,
-0.43896064162254333,
0.541341245174408,
0.3067753314971924,
0.4738403260707855,
0.35367900133132935,
0.008960885927081108,
0.8155612945556641,
-0.6992366909980774,
0.5096600651741028,
0.18633970618247986,
-1.1616170406341553,
0.22162199020385742,
-0.14348144829273224,
-0.10740160942077637,
0.6660451889038086,
0.31739160418510437,
-0.5682714581489563,
0.16901953518390656,
-0.4746776521205902,
-1.0093181133270264,
0.8079487681388855,
-0.022508369758725166,
0.011708063073456287,
0.27648061513900757,
0.31073102355003357,
-0.21823439002037048,
-0.3275500237941742,
-0.30095186829566956,
-0.0837242528796196,
0.09312944114208221,
-0.07121787965297699,
0.03588744252920151,
-0.5018886923789978,
-0.2287125587463379,
-0.45532673597335815,
0.9257405996322632,
-0.3820074200630188,
0.17937271296977997,
0.3545818328857422,
-0.011468993499875069,
-0.21362784504890442,
0.20442740619182587,
0.6411572098731995,
0.07640894502401352,
-0.18898022174835205,
0.13468314707279205,
0.5789508819580078,
-0.4898327887058258,
-0.021488310769200325,
0.03453093767166138,
-0.19586260616779327,
0.09269130229949951,
-0.25389498472213745,
0.8258534669876099,
0.8059380650520325,
-0.4629735052585602,
0.6392490267753601,
-0.143269345164299,
-0.4773193299770355,
-0.15330831706523895,
-0.046881888061761856,
0.16355587542057037,
0.3375314772129059,
0.1828598976135254,
0.5043855905532837,
0.4296157956123352,
-0.07562946528196335,
0.09938344359397888,
0.7698205709457397,
-0.5097103118896484,
-0.2388991415500641,
0.24907736480236053,
0.4277150630950928,
-0.7673820853233337,
0.5405662655830383,
0.06661923229694366,
-0.4194676876068115,
0.5450310707092285,
0.6186023950576782,
0.5666534304618835,
-0.3528743386268616,
0.06025521829724312,
0.06316550076007843,
0.29716435074806213,
-0.5405547022819519,
0.2093445360660553,
-0.01944076083600521,
-0.7330414056777954,
-0.31120285391807556,
-0.6096155047416687,
-0.6028642058372498,
0.0929328054189682,
-0.7049416303634644,
0.4858711361885071,
-0.5615919828414917,
0.047418221831321716,
0.1172032579779625,
-0.33270353078842163,
-0.43538880348205566,
-0.17039728164672852,
-0.02364352159202099,
1.4386036396026611,
-0.503871738910675,
0.44494614005088806,
0.7068522572517395,
-0.00394165376201272,
-0.8740681409835815,
-0.24300503730773926,
-0.10474661737680435,
-0.8278887867927551,
0.5439759492874146,
-0.13515034317970276,
-0.5770180821418762,
-0.020010247826576233,
-0.42194271087646484,
-1.335684061050415,
1.0218969583511353,
0.395389199256897,
-0.3045675456523895,
-0.4327566623687744,
-0.06354855000972748,
0.1789124310016632,
-0.0378422811627388,
0.03999960049986839,
0.5314720869064331,
0.18262426555156708,
0.050754643976688385,
-0.9312111139297485,
0.061520595103502274,
-0.5728005170822144,
0.15977171063423157,
0.5558575391769409,
-0.7677744626998901,
1.1213687658309937,
0.1391618400812149,
0.12192771583795547,
0.156551793217659,
0.69788658618927,
0.004656173288822174,
0.11042861640453339,
0.7343273162841797,
0.4080694615840912,
0.7486122846603394,
0.12025441974401474,
0.6551473140716553,
-0.5606764554977417,
0.2976495325565338,
0.6348036527633667,
0.0035543800331652164,
1.0385714769363403,
0.6219826936721802,
-0.2187274694442749,
0.6283329725265503,
0.13175544142723083,
0.2791614830493927,
0.5809394121170044,
0.1558602750301361,
-0.0542927160859108,
-0.2624790668487549,
-0.1486474722623825,
-0.24137111008167267,
0.5025986433029175,
0.39736539125442505,
-0.21730661392211914,
-0.47367745637893677,
-0.3140677809715271,
-0.19652113318443298,
0.08043094724416733,
-0.5500256419181824,
0.8661839365959167,
0.0193962249904871,
-0.5414881110191345,
0.8483610153198242,
0.10481848567724228,
1.2107032537460327,
-0.5714236497879028,
-0.17493946850299835,
-0.15272793173789978,
0.3288455903530121,
-0.2946745455265045,
-0.704143762588501,
0.5151934027671814,
-0.1577705442905426,
-0.2887892425060272,
-0.1817874014377594,
1.0215636491775513,
-0.07189308106899261,
-0.5363821387290955,
0.35327473282814026,
0.5890034437179565,
0.1256237030029297,
-0.1481858193874359,
-0.5465338230133057,
-0.041038863360881805,
-0.45185908675193787,
-0.4603692591190338,
0.7927295565605164,
0.4464280605316162,
0.20605146884918213,
0.4108046889305115,
0.8262737989425659,
0.37781819701194763,
-0.24810774624347687,
-0.2656962275505066,
1.371974229812622,
-0.6881332397460938,
-0.5380021929740906,
-0.6675348281860352,
0.16111703217029572,
-0.33052417635917664,
-0.3641548156738281,
0.26770347356796265,
0.7372632622718811,
0.5733308792114258,
0.21666927635669708,
0.4841262400150299,
0.1091718077659607,
0.6413065791130066,
-0.5753217935562134,
1.0128697156906128,
-0.7723246812820435,
0.1597752869129181,
-0.3220630884170532,
-0.5239530801773071,
-0.24974778294563293,
0.9334315061569214,
-0.023488208651542664,
-0.48942670226097107,
0.6314463019371033,
0.8887032270431519,
-0.40159887075424194,
-0.006153368856757879,
0.28296712040901184,
0.11352916061878204,
-0.15413156151771545,
0.4430893063545227,
0.4534384310245514,
-0.6293137669563293,
0.4726894497871399,
-0.41610127687454224,
-0.2825801372528076,
-0.15506041049957275,
-1.0094751119613647,
-0.6622697114944458,
-0.4978867471218109,
0.11656501144170761,
-0.5102447271347046,
0.21004748344421387,
1.1413614749908447,
0.6454591751098633,
-0.5585441589355469,
-0.4293208718299866,
-0.08815906941890717,
0.16117988526821136,
-0.5035240054130554,
-0.19575655460357666,
0.49308711290359497,
-0.46070247888565063,
-0.5807477235794067,
1.0064477920532227,
0.4007870554924011,
-0.07417303323745728,
0.011897759512066841,
-0.13263458013534546,
-0.01976439729332924,
0.27785736322402954,
0.6104065179824829,
0.4013032913208008,
-0.274453341960907,
-0.13347679376602173,
0.3272808790206909,
0.08759669959545135,
0.18538494408130646,
1.0957248210906982,
-0.9771038889884949,
-0.4568900167942047,
0.4495166838169098,
0.9442111253738403,
0.1930834949016571,
-0.0875699520111084,
0.537163496017456,
-0.6030588150024414,
0.43818560242652893,
0.27714815735816956,
0.6181367635726929,
0.08231468498706818,
-0.6542239189147949,
0.6834656596183777,
0.1257334202528,
-0.4627465605735779,
-1.086816430091858,
-0.1696683019399643,
-1.1262457370758057,
-0.485218346118927,
1.1206086874008179,
0.26591789722442627,
-0.5034842491149902,
-0.15132269263267517,
-0.18464478850364685,
-0.1139761209487915,
-0.4669479429721832,
0.764236330986023,
0.2635573446750641,
-0.16594168543815613,
0.16091181337833405,
-0.04512878134846687,
0.7184674143791199,
0.6203206777572632,
-0.3779047131538391,
0.030705884099006653,
0.026185091584920883,
0.29293903708457947,
0.11956161260604858,
0.757099986076355,
-0.05642154812812805,
0.2583391070365906,
-0.1965571790933609,
-0.26015186309814453,
-0.24235662817955017,
-0.39622727036476135,
-0.4413309097290039,
0.27404099702835083,
0.15218505263328552,
0.0523737296462059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10933v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10933v1
|
LLMem: Estimating GPU Memory Usage for Fine-Tuning Pre-Trained LLMs
| 2024-04-16T22:11:35 | 2024-04-16T22:11:35 |
Taeho Kim, Yanming Wang, Vatshank Chaturvedi, Lokesh Gupta, Seyeon Kim, Yongin Kwon, Sangtae Ha
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Fine-tuning pre-trained large language models (LLMs) with limited hardware
presents challenges due to GPU memory constraints. Various distributed
fine-tuning methods have been proposed to alleviate memory constraints on GPU.
However, determining the most effective method for achieving rapid fine-tuning
while preventing GPU out-of-memory issues in a given environment remains
unclear. To address this challenge, we introduce LLMem, a solution that
estimates the GPU memory consumption when applying distributed fine-tuning
methods across multiple GPUs and identifies the optimal method. We conduct GPU
memory usage estimation prior to fine-tuning, leveraging the fundamental
structure of transformer-based decoder models and the memory usage distribution
of each method. Experimental results show that LLMem accurately estimates peak
GPU memory usage on a single GPU, with error rates of up to 1.6%. Additionally,
it shows an average error rate of 3.0% when applying distributed fine-tuning
methods to LLMs with more than a billion parameters on multi-GPU setups.
|
[
-0.7147249579429626,
-0.9600842595100403,
0.7728877663612366,
0.05996013432741165,
-0.41603028774261475,
-0.08281446993350983,
-0.5820754766464233,
0.0593147948384285,
-0.2098688781261444,
0.3184702694416046,
-0.45674625039100647,
-0.45722106099128723,
-0.6700882911682129,
-0.179128497838974,
-0.11955752968788147,
0.41787368059158325,
-0.18403615057468414,
0.05130816623568535,
-0.5025174021720886,
-0.14717338979244232,
-0.5283902287483215,
-0.18453679978847504,
-0.5804247856140137,
-0.3229486048221588,
0.44639483094215393,
0.6145970225334167,
0.5519272685050964,
0.7022994160652161,
0.5794668793678284,
0.2630741000175476,
0.08944349735975266,
0.6915464401245117,
-0.6607941389083862,
-0.09229884296655655,
0.13711704313755035,
-0.45621296763420105,
-0.5855514407157898,
0.03649277240037918,
0.829585075378418,
0.3390471935272217,
-0.37972715497016907,
0.511850118637085,
0.1341962218284607,
0.24796611070632935,
-0.9625498652458191,
0.16347205638885498,
-0.7442404627799988,
0.10184868425130844,
-0.3522661328315735,
-0.4810250401496887,
-0.32774412631988525,
-0.1805042177438736,
-0.4032069444656372,
-0.7378178834915161,
0.278624027967453,
-0.024872727692127228,
0.5975529551506042,
0.7388752698898315,
0.1518966108560562,
0.07364621013402939,
-0.8420509099960327,
0.8328196406364441,
-0.675968587398529,
0.48093506693840027,
0.38384881615638733,
0.3457562029361725,
-0.27221646904945374,
-0.5384685397148132,
-0.43542933464050293,
0.12408174574375153,
0.030648300424218178,
0.14204995334148407,
-0.248516246676445,
0.23023158311843872,
0.495346337556839,
0.4509313404560089,
-0.3220817744731903,
0.26613324880599976,
0.01852009817957878,
0.05249396339058876,
0.36217859387397766,
0.3172496259212494,
0.334479957818985,
0.48436418175697327,
-0.2090958058834076,
0.2428412288427353,
-0.7878941297531128,
-0.6186345815658569,
0.18731914460659027,
0.23917238414287567,
0.06301282346248627,
0.24190402030944824,
0.1763780117034912,
0.6896260976791382,
0.0004109694273211062,
-0.29665058851242065,
-0.13934318721294403,
-0.1537213921546936,
-0.5274040699005127,
-0.17773893475532532,
0.6650608777999878,
0.2406991869211197,
0.2564481198787689,
-0.14673489332199097,
-0.2390061616897583,
0.04900434613227844,
0.2567724287509918,
-1.081811547279358,
-0.2673604488372803,
-0.1626032590866089,
-0.09363069385290146,
0.3075917959213257,
-0.4353954493999481,
-0.7285243272781372,
-0.2929788827896118,
-0.16377638280391693,
0.21192587912082672,
0.0819607600569725,
-0.20859217643737793,
0.11539068073034286,
0.03780125081539154,
0.08545424789190292,
0.16259673237800598,
-1.0928173065185547,
0.48400649428367615,
0.6186807751655579,
0.7080163359642029,
-0.2535727024078369,
-0.33808714151382446,
-0.814128577709198,
0.24261468648910522,
-0.10272176563739777,
0.7267016768455505,
-0.5863401889801025,
-0.4052566885948181,
-0.2188190221786499,
-0.08210733532905579,
-0.2659604847431183,
-0.8173048496246338,
0.41139382123947144,
-0.3958404064178467,
-0.321971595287323,
-0.13876421749591827,
-0.765404999256134,
-0.020199421793222427,
0.26421862840652466,
-0.6025336980819702,
1.1763808727264404,
-0.059943266212940216,
-0.6613504886627197,
0.24283528327941895,
-0.18843255937099457,
-0.23644034564495087,
0.23196567595005035,
-0.27765825390815735,
-0.559368371963501,
0.6084887385368347,
0.5381625294685364,
0.6771591901779175,
-0.5309436917304993,
0.1533121019601822,
-0.27523985505104065,
-0.7328470349311829,
-0.24319061636924744,
-0.5680153965950012,
0.20724865794181824,
0.27118244767189026,
-0.11910491436719894,
0.21837913990020752,
-0.5368264317512512,
-0.14946869015693665,
0.03509238362312317,
-0.3636503517627716,
-0.330405592918396,
0.19490507245063782,
-0.16999675333499908,
-0.276250422000885,
0.547335147857666,
-0.4207783341407776,
0.14226025342941284,
-0.037799008190631866,
0.42534002661705017,
0.7485960721969604,
-0.3539508879184723,
0.3273296058177948,
-0.13006722927093506,
0.44240042567253113,
-0.11013362556695938,
0.367765337228775,
-0.21255353093147278,
-0.2484009861946106,
-0.6429580450057983,
-0.3118042051792145,
-0.15435391664505005,
0.37715795636177063,
-0.08745677024126053,
0.026797369122505188,
-0.19698721170425415,
-0.38217487931251526,
-0.3448697328567505,
0.3613967001438141,
0.13792361319065094,
0.37793248891830444,
0.49921926856040955,
0.16893942654132843,
-0.40042492747306824,
-0.6721580028533936,
-0.3476998209953308,
0.038784705102443695,
0.03707359358668327,
0.7500097155570984,
0.21043801307678223,
-0.5603719353675842,
0.5204277634620667,
-0.696058988571167,
-0.18656928837299347,
-0.1613732874393463,
-0.1689235270023346,
0.14910905063152313,
0.3512938916683197,
0.2535720467567444,
-0.1928768903017044,
-0.48226791620254517,
0.0900360494852066,
-0.3880048990249634,
-0.011459228582680225,
-0.2083197683095932,
-0.010011185891926289,
0.05836612731218338,
0.6634176969528198,
-0.6185684204101562,
0.19012923538684845,
0.7502345442771912,
0.20902101695537567,
0.4432702660560608,
-0.8806379437446594,
0.013511409983038902,
-0.8792611956596375,
-0.1951078325510025,
0.17713820934295654,
-0.3705544173717499,
-0.09983670711517334,
0.1055355966091156,
0.250373899936676,
-0.0027471843641251326,
-0.249711275100708,
0.5148175358772278,
-0.7093111276626587,
-0.1255679428577423,
-0.5034699440002441,
0.16878998279571533,
-0.28171414136886597,
0.3599399924278259,
-0.12209485471248627,
1.1676560640335083,
0.7631217241287231,
-0.5768889784812927,
0.32555195689201355,
-0.09647328406572342,
-0.37048572301864624,
0.4343833029270172,
-0.45345059037208557,
0.17862412333488464,
-0.04625115171074867,
-0.1319284588098526,
-0.99718177318573,
-0.08479347079992294,
0.0741625502705574,
-0.016627613455057144,
0.41235628724098206,
-0.25204363465309143,
-0.5549827218055725,
-0.24202218651771545,
0.2012360543012619,
0.5630775690078735,
0.5663050413131714,
-0.8650162816047668,
0.75599604845047,
0.6006662845611572,
0.06379483640193939,
-0.5026785731315613,
-0.35568350553512573,
-0.10819937288761139,
-0.3064248263835907,
-0.392397940158844,
0.21187898516654968,
-0.15544480085372925,
0.017756644636392593,
-0.1637888252735138,
-0.3911556899547577,
-0.11114126443862915,
0.1764237880706787,
0.3397664725780487,
0.08294357359409332,
-0.3809789717197418,
-0.007367146201431751,
0.04044019430875778,
-0.32809948921203613,
0.07208482176065445,
-0.17238056659698486,
0.6850766539573669,
-0.2637150287628174,
-0.4254913330078125,
-0.2855324447154999,
0.21227672696113586,
0.429584264755249,
-0.11893288046121597,
0.5658588409423828,
0.860013484954834,
-0.4650833010673523,
-0.37424084544181824,
-0.8479771614074707,
-0.13018307089805603,
-0.49898457527160645,
0.6037741899490356,
-0.31525933742523193,
-0.8476368188858032,
0.7446683049201965,
-0.5760100483894348,
0.006435451563447714,
0.2112085372209549,
0.5890113115310669,
-0.19972312450408936,
0.9008241891860962,
0.7565494775772095,
-0.29349470138549805,
0.4713036119937897,
-0.11455745249986649,
-0.04651128873229027,
-0.6794517040252686,
0.03565286099910736,
-0.24319198727607727,
-0.5259978771209717,
-0.47581955790519714,
-0.7194611430168152,
0.1850169599056244,
0.26068878173828125,
-0.26386532187461853,
0.13261494040489197,
-0.3347793519496918,
0.977313756942749,
0.41951775550842285,
0.10006643831729889,
0.22974519431591034,
0.12963569164276123,
-0.07248474657535553,
0.021926647052168846,
-0.7360585331916809,
-0.25954920053482056,
0.8752078413963318,
0.3125309348106384,
1.0718050003051758,
-0.47828391194343567,
0.6081472635269165,
-0.15962830185890198,
0.3844080865383148,
-0.6923590302467346,
0.6078826785087585,
-0.26149219274520874,
-0.32718566060066223,
-0.30340707302093506,
-0.5489353537559509,
-0.7357926964759827,
0.19348399341106415,
0.09509695321321487,
-0.49364033341407776,
-0.27371662855148315,
0.29281291365623474,
-0.49366727471351624,
0.7776435613632202,
-0.32574936747550964,
0.8529199361801147,
-0.18649816513061523,
-0.14354640245437622,
-0.67563396692276,
-0.177313894033432,
0.1847122758626938,
-0.06030810624361038,
-0.027941934764385223,
-0.47986990213394165,
-0.11592330038547516,
0.49998730421066284,
-0.2435426115989685,
0.6159639358520508,
-0.18922536075115204,
-0.03253304958343506,
0.14429324865341187,
-0.2390243113040924,
0.6776466965675354,
0.262513667345047,
0.14598219096660614,
0.48255500197410583,
-0.1515253186225891,
-0.39175307750701904,
-0.3390694856643677,
1.0976817607879639,
-0.9608369469642639,
-0.6749349236488342,
-0.14646270871162415,
-0.7333271503448486,
-0.22696827352046967,
0.2403639554977417,
0.2428160458803177,
0.18949997425079346,
-0.3188454806804657,
-0.06122623011469841,
0.9453652501106262,
-0.42688611149787903,
0.680875837802887,
0.46950122714042664,
0.14703156054019928,
-0.49461865425109863,
0.7008603811264038,
-0.029542161151766777,
0.11187209188938141,
0.3089669942855835,
0.2322206348180771,
-0.0937422662973404,
-0.955713152885437,
-0.5288817882537842,
0.35265931487083435,
-0.49471864104270935,
-0.20056670904159546,
-0.3584001660346985,
-0.15149812400341034,
0.15441739559173584,
-0.02488049864768982,
-0.7743590474128723,
0.17987188696861267,
-0.6175952553749084,
-0.02641790173947811,
0.3489071726799011,
0.33053648471832275,
0.0831824243068695,
0.9316834807395935,
-0.8832756280899048,
0.42589449882507324,
0.163118377327919,
0.7571622133255005,
-0.22158929705619812,
-0.5470982193946838,
-0.41200459003448486,
0.024256037548184395,
-0.18929915130138397,
-0.39191892743110657,
0.4937826991081238,
0.3060910105705261,
0.8717430830001831,
0.3612704575061798,
-0.23672762513160706,
1.2064415216445923,
-0.7119225263595581,
0.3448607921600342,
0.07586050778627396,
-0.5387455224990845,
0.5417762994766235,
-0.1933962106704712,
0.44611701369285583,
0.5019122958183289,
0.24209803342819214,
-0.2918515205383301,
-0.35696128010749817,
-0.314238041639328,
-0.6170695424079895,
0.5178666710853577,
-0.23291127383708954,
0.37615251541137695,
-0.24604924023151398,
0.4766184091567993,
0.057499758899211884,
-0.20348070561885834,
-0.17479965090751648,
-0.5641275644302368,
0.30050382018089294,
-0.09170296043157578,
-0.48609933257102966,
-0.35804682970046997,
-0.09129100292921066,
-0.5009893774986267,
0.511500895023346,
-0.12295731902122498,
0.19169797003269196,
-0.2804950475692749,
-0.397510290145874,
-0.3172849118709564,
0.07551201432943344,
0.7731555104255676,
0.8715246319770813,
-0.26599088311195374,
0.288383811712265,
0.5811453461647034,
-0.78705894947052,
-0.06605510413646698,
0.1590067446231842,
-0.05175381153821945,
0.1327488273382187,
-0.4358048439025879,
0.9776297211647034,
0.169962078332901,
-0.5305629372596741,
0.1902804672718048,
-0.47359633445739746,
-0.13197949528694153,
-0.31252968311309814,
0.12260137498378754,
0.3984038531780243,
0.41988158226013184,
0.11616881191730499,
0.18959951400756836,
-0.37448838353157043,
0.21982848644256592,
0.24195457994937897,
0.8300517201423645,
-0.2546662986278534,
-0.2198973298072815,
0.8477622866630554,
0.09099731594324112,
-0.03736661747097969,
0.928138256072998,
0.08631335943937302,
0.03437059745192528,
0.4761011302471161,
0.6060194373130798,
0.9910720586776733,
-0.34672626852989197,
-0.1332024484872818,
0.5326103568077087,
0.22359958291053772,
-0.43496638536453247,
0.19861926138401031,
-0.07451380044221878,
-0.8617376089096069,
-0.6880283355712891,
-0.76026850938797,
-0.20589704811573029,
0.25835803151130676,
-0.4773213267326355,
0.3346193730831146,
-0.537086546421051,
-0.43638256192207336,
-0.2903144657611847,
0.1096569299697876,
-0.7117205858230591,
0.02092025987803936,
0.5073981285095215,
0.8336209654808044,
-0.7114054560661316,
1.145716905593872,
0.3716910779476166,
0.12412796914577484,
-0.7487749457359314,
-0.3417221009731293,
-0.3654891550540924,
-0.9855450987815857,
0.24888233840465546,
0.07514871656894684,
-0.31884637475013733,
0.241024911403656,
-0.2888619303703308,
-0.7780646085739136,
0.9512699842453003,
0.8229880928993225,
-0.946679413318634,
0.3227804899215698,
0.22789011895656586,
0.029195433482527733,
-0.12559455633163452,
0.34229621291160583,
0.8385130763053894,
0.36147263646125793,
0.1049615815281868,
-0.8077049851417542,
0.054986558854579926,
-0.007125729229301214,
-0.13341179490089417,
0.563042938709259,
-0.5286599397659302,
0.817317008972168,
-0.46795231103897095,
-0.34685540199279785,
-0.22331780195236206,
0.6504840850830078,
0.345451295375824,
0.055161118507385254,
0.42075344920158386,
0.8247944116592407,
1.0247206687927246,
-0.09603556245565414,
0.7721145749092102,
-0.5341691374778748,
0.4564712941646576,
1.18588125705719,
0.1502939909696579,
0.7426479458808899,
0.4947982132434845,
-0.050010740756988525,
-0.16651535034179688,
0.6534674763679504,
-0.09745605289936066,
0.41545355319976807,
0.37834519147872925,
-0.5032515525817871,
-0.5947473645210266,
0.3034200966358185,
-0.38547420501708984,
0.05402299761772156,
0.49188199639320374,
-0.3231269419193268,
-0.4395419657230377,
0.005757693666964769,
-0.05405271053314209,
-0.3660410940647125,
-0.6237353086471558,
0.7003631591796875,
0.30856749415397644,
-0.3995371162891388,
0.8597874045372009,
-0.019885491579771042,
0.6998237371444702,
-0.22265735268592834,
0.2627354562282562,
-0.6010864973068237,
0.7440739870071411,
-0.06227957829833031,
-0.35373741388320923,
0.2909184992313385,
-0.12149880081415176,
-0.21571038663387299,
-0.2860316038131714,
0.6305819749832153,
-0.581633448600769,
-0.5509601831436157,
0.12924233078956604,
0.5011867880821228,
0.2887503206729889,
-0.39868828654289246,
-0.4101383686065674,
0.20539027452468872,
-0.32489311695098877,
-0.12331446260213852,
0.6805136203765869,
0.15933500230312347,
0.22578054666519165,
0.757648766040802,
0.3082146942615509,
0.20333275198936462,
0.45557209849357605,
0.17183032631874084,
0.7614391446113586,
-0.4271487295627594,
-0.20576852560043335,
-1.3557538986206055,
0.0867161974310875,
0.24072906374931335,
-0.11555849015712738,
1.0010907649993896,
0.7997464537620544,
0.8475882411003113,
-0.0817328616976738,
0.7121449708938599,
0.522712767124176,
-0.05710224434733391,
-0.16002488136291504,
0.5529341697692871,
-0.5588268041610718,
0.3554992377758026,
-0.06610453873872757,
-1.1242560148239136,
-0.4014178216457367,
0.5595857501029968,
-0.2790447175502777,
-0.19484367966651917,
0.36367982625961304,
0.885681688785553,
-0.5269097089767456,
0.08430854231119156,
0.49317023158073425,
0.03426764905452728,
0.08277436345815659,
0.7182034254074097,
0.7978013753890991,
-0.3473588526248932,
0.4741384983062744,
-0.1409209966659546,
-0.1383274644613266,
-0.16689245402812958,
-0.9314371943473816,
-0.8486258387565613,
-0.008976414799690247,
-0.5112500786781311,
0.10724937915802002,
-0.1077774167060852,
0.5253887176513672,
0.7730944156646729,
-0.7676635384559631,
-0.4915817081928253,
-0.20032358169555664,
0.07779835909605026,
-0.37720879912376404,
0.012978165410459042,
0.3142433762550354,
-0.5964289903640747,
-0.7866941690444946,
0.3473018407821655,
0.2554556727409363,
-0.11643607169389725,
-0.19409039616584778,
-0.24688343703746796,
0.2685709595680237,
0.1553783267736435,
0.5006392002105713,
0.15799830853939056,
-0.5682339072227478,
-0.12425686419010162,
0.08068245649337769,
-0.09015548974275589,
0.3672915995121002,
0.7353518605232239,
-0.4842674136161804,
0.3363598585128784,
0.5241387486457825,
0.8775415420532227,
0.9861854910850525,
-0.05157029256224632,
0.36938080191612244,
-0.80894535779953,
0.03786708042025566,
0.017796335741877556,
0.4402191638946533,
-0.05033411085605621,
-0.20304720103740692,
0.05595032498240471,
0.1415330022573471,
-0.728028416633606,
-0.7541073560714722,
-0.0934218168258667,
-0.8677672743797302,
-0.20937541127204895,
0.9693996906280518,
-0.16329456865787506,
-0.17125709354877472,
0.1867130547761917,
0.028046268969774246,
0.3871672451496124,
-0.07875804603099823,
0.52458256483078,
0.5125612616539001,
-0.10657297074794769,
-0.6535338759422302,
-0.8899502754211426,
0.5229323506355286,
0.1258390247821808,
-0.7697187066078186,
0.43432480096817017,
0.46255984902381897,
0.43153661489486694,
-0.3173582851886749,
0.5649484395980835,
0.21094059944152832,
-0.09906928241252899,
0.02585645020008087,
0.004970346111804247,
-0.1675383746623993,
-0.4242606461048126,
-0.10384801030158997,
0.0948522686958313,
-0.16524538397789001,
-0.42519518733024597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10924v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10924v1
|
Binder: Hierarchical Concept Representation through Order Embedding of Binary Vectors
| 2024-04-16T21:52:55 | 2024-04-16T21:52:55 |
Croix Gyurek, Niloy Talukder, Mohammad Al Hasan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
For natural language understanding and generation, embedding concepts using
an order-based representation is an essential task. Unlike traditional point
vector based representation, an order-based representation imposes geometric
constraints on the representation vectors for explicitly capturing various
semantic relationships that may exist between a pair of concepts. In existing
literature, several approaches on order-based embedding have been proposed,
mostly focusing on capturing hierarchical relationships; examples include
vectors in Euclidean space, complex, Hyperbolic, order, and Box Embedding. Box
embedding creates region-based rich representation of concepts, but along the
process it sacrifices simplicity, requiring a custom-made optimization scheme
for learning the representation. Hyperbolic embedding improves embedding
quality by exploiting the ever-expanding property of Hyperbolic space, but it
also suffers from the same fate as box embedding as gradient descent like
optimization is not simple in the Hyperbolic space. In this work, we propose
Binder, a novel approach for order-based representation. Binder uses binary
vectors for embedding, so the embedding vectors are compact with an order of
magnitude smaller footprint than other methods. Binder uses a simple and
efficient optimization scheme for learning representation vectors with a linear
time complexity. Our comprehensive experimental results show that Binder is
very accurate, yielding competitive results on the representation task. But
Binder stands out from its competitors on the transitive closure link
prediction task as it can learn concept embeddings just from the direct edges,
whereas all existing order-based approaches rely on the indirect edges.
|
[
-0.44370806217193604,
-0.6994384527206421,
0.26184770464897156,
-0.05421464517712593,
-0.36989733576774597,
0.2770484387874603,
0.055468324571847916,
-0.2334800809621811,
0.5463735461235046,
0.19019636511802673,
-0.28355658054351807,
-0.5136423110961914,
-0.7513779997825623,
-0.21652500331401825,
-0.004434730391949415,
0.7754644751548767,
0.1344432681798935,
-0.0012987229274585843,
-0.2848098874092102,
-0.18573158979415894,
-0.458322674036026,
-0.6025344729423523,
-0.21005159616470337,
-0.5330555438995361,
0.25020867586135864,
0.1723819226026535,
1.1035312414169312,
1.2783278226852417,
0.4919300377368927,
0.33130377531051636,
-0.1712118238210678,
-0.12053989619016647,
-0.7714945077896118,
0.11583753675222397,
-0.22674186527729034,
-0.40641701221466064,
-0.2051200568675995,
-0.07227672636508942,
0.570207417011261,
0.8660984635353088,
-0.3665942847728729,
0.04911022260785103,
-0.26226815581321716,
0.602368950843811,
-0.8192263841629028,
0.2948664128780365,
-0.5529347062110901,
0.3204841613769531,
-0.09623691439628601,
-0.31262457370758057,
-0.37182581424713135,
-0.4257434606552124,
0.3898645043373108,
-0.6983466744422913,
0.24061760306358337,
0.5063339471817017,
0.8901665806770325,
0.3558560013771057,
-0.2144494205713272,
-0.4174945652484894,
-0.7734681367874146,
0.6762080192565918,
-0.09988778829574585,
0.8289062976837158,
0.1196044310927391,
0.4105292856693268,
-0.31628715991973877,
-0.7312780618667603,
-0.4455642104148865,
0.37885501980781555,
0.014862465672194958,
0.2252066284418106,
-0.12133591622114182,
0.04310724884271622,
0.047516778111457825,
0.41209539771080017,
-0.4037899672985077,
0.050747811794281006,
-0.39520972967147827,
-0.025339558720588684,
0.31127938628196716,
-0.004925900604575872,
0.2365618646144867,
-0.4989665150642395,
-0.5553577542304993,
-0.3824208080768585,
-0.5733564496040344,
0.09320627152919769,
0.20609396696090698,
0.26023048162460327,
-0.04632540047168732,
0.5619097948074341,
0.19636590778827667,
0.5257964134216309,
0.4744870662689209,
-0.11307080835103989,
0.19418536126613617,
0.17010733485221863,
-0.2683693766593933,
0.3098197877407074,
0.7784346342086792,
0.2654794752597809,
-0.17159101366996765,
-0.408050537109375,
-0.12071143090724945,
0.09011559933423996,
0.2498488426208496,
-0.9566441774368286,
-0.166533961892128,
0.18951399624347687,
-0.40724578499794006,
-0.22911417484283447,
0.4200943410396576,
-0.6801502108573914,
-0.16524291038513184,
-0.2586820721626282,
0.09270727634429932,
-0.32596251368522644,
0.14438112080097198,
0.20686495304107666,
0.01953745074570179,
0.6061075329780579,
0.15563412010669708,
-0.97055983543396,
0.6969542503356934,
0.8428254127502441,
0.8155038356781006,
-0.1608722060918808,
0.15368321537971497,
-0.6325370073318481,
0.5134671330451965,
-0.5259782075881958,
0.8022357821464539,
-0.7906102538108826,
-0.4541577994823456,
-0.022102735936641693,
-0.33615344762802124,
0.2553526759147644,
-0.4248047471046448,
0.42252489924430847,
-0.756418764591217,
0.3276773691177368,
0.010304252617061138,
-0.7429099678993225,
-0.11615228652954102,
0.010679399594664574,
-0.6197292804718018,
0.9309894442558289,
-0.13987022638320923,
-0.8436675071716309,
0.3425692319869995,
-0.2899562418460846,
-0.19361473619937897,
0.35554391145706177,
-0.6268295645713806,
-0.5059379935264587,
0.12531410157680511,
0.09773935377597809,
0.6451421976089478,
-0.2993413209915161,
0.13626563549041748,
-0.12230844050645828,
-0.2671447992324829,
-0.1682576984167099,
0.20939750969409943,
0.2132600098848343,
-0.08497235924005508,
-0.27363067865371704,
-0.0374608039855957,
-0.6620303392410278,
0.04044175520539284,
0.2159200757741928,
-0.23045948147773743,
-0.4980406165122986,
0.13654370605945587,
-0.13478951156139374,
0.1713862419128418,
0.2244143933057785,
-0.5900543332099915,
0.21283847093582153,
-0.8284751772880554,
0.15904399752616882,
0.8271602392196655,
0.14996474981307983,
0.8794940114021301,
-0.10578471422195435,
0.5042518973350525,
0.030850963667035103,
-0.009693056344985962,
0.31204167008399963,
-0.6419316530227661,
-0.6358909010887146,
-0.0041054049506783485,
0.48835012316703796,
0.44940027594566345,
-0.6501107215881348,
0.6127652525901794,
-0.5482907295227051,
-0.4432544410228729,
-0.3969069719314575,
-0.041652534157037735,
0.4753361642360687,
-0.03646761178970337,
0.2617585361003876,
-0.4635094702243805,
-0.28030169010162354,
-0.775361955165863,
0.0995861291885376,
-0.229391410946846,
0.17448653280735016,
0.0617389902472496,
0.4860154688358307,
-0.33665037155151367,
0.9059974551200867,
-0.9534158110618591,
-0.2966182827949524,
-0.03608324006199837,
0.14237678050994873,
0.27621740102767944,
0.40130412578582764,
0.36112868785858154,
-1.017401099205017,
-0.21653743088245392,
0.17670567333698273,
-0.3782273828983307,
0.5259350538253784,
0.06283911317586899,
-0.49967706203460693,
-0.03877755627036095,
0.5497809648513794,
-0.2933875024318695,
0.3838564157485962,
0.40936920046806335,
-0.1902392953634262,
0.15873272716999054,
-0.38935184478759766,
-0.3923587501049042,
-1.1281661987304688,
-0.34985607862472534,
-0.11613460630178452,
-0.29021063446998596,
-0.4697982966899872,
-0.008601145818829536,
-0.13475681841373444,
-0.35967832803726196,
-0.21725919842720032,
0.2826029062271118,
-0.5609825849533081,
0.04861729219555855,
0.0031813415698707104,
0.19870567321777344,
-0.12026182562112808,
0.6200432181358337,
0.04526437446475029,
0.27129918336868286,
0.4911842346191406,
-0.5031525492668152,
0.17705421149730682,
0.6256115436553955,
0.010748549364507198,
0.5027576684951782,
-0.9714850783348083,
0.26744210720062256,
-0.5751039385795593,
0.017983367666602135,
-0.7960457801818848,
0.006487962324172258,
0.4678473472595215,
-0.361714243888855,
0.474153071641922,
-0.38560640811920166,
-0.6470175385475159,
-0.33899328112602234,
-0.415572851896286,
0.30994242429733276,
0.5158838033676147,
-0.5110693573951721,
0.6116889119148254,
0.556084394454956,
-0.02509346976876259,
-0.6244083046913147,
-0.4325695335865021,
-0.2473028302192688,
0.06339849531650543,
-0.2697984278202057,
0.6737506985664368,
-0.09494230896234512,
0.14748750627040863,
0.1681412309408188,
-0.35581597685813904,
-0.033244166523218155,
-0.2648046314716339,
0.3285086452960968,
0.03257248178124428,
-0.19669751822948456,
0.29121455550193787,
0.2303253412246704,
-0.34822940826416016,
0.061540983617305756,
-0.5419167876243591,
0.3380392789840698,
-0.03842400386929512,
-0.30632269382476807,
0.009927117265760899,
0.38176050782203674,
0.5894680619239807,
-0.2414870709180832,
0.8401193022727966,
0.3670822083950043,
-0.6251305341720581,
-0.38085031509399414,
-0.3975510597229004,
0.06010642275214195,
-0.5037155151367188,
0.12162254005670547,
-0.6115832328796387,
-0.622556746006012,
0.29218533635139465,
-0.23425380885601044,
0.06063086912035942,
0.27196910977363586,
0.4954558312892914,
0.04971752688288689,
0.7417719960212708,
0.921671450138092,
0.0036801034584641457,
0.49566900730133057,
-0.6930391192436218,
0.4886976480484009,
-0.6385790109634399,
-0.47057828307151794,
-0.4054175317287445,
-0.30971240997314453,
-0.9301593899726868,
-0.7404311299324036,
0.24222101271152496,
0.37144041061401367,
-0.2613585591316223,
0.40881043672561646,
-0.8679670095443726,
0.5800472497940063,
0.4497547447681427,
0.1337132453918457,
0.1692202389240265,
0.2323482483625412,
-0.5108324289321899,
-0.11056939512491226,
-0.8980756402015686,
-0.5939039587974548,
0.6637958884239197,
0.28530290722846985,
0.7902302145957947,
0.24899253249168396,
1.1030925512313843,
-0.03394220396876335,
-0.041500456631183624,
-1.247619867324829,
0.2786540687084198,
-0.10328169167041779,
-0.12256713211536407,
-0.2108253836631775,
-0.28890103101730347,
-1.2192388772964478,
0.3357032835483551,
-0.3879081904888153,
-0.6782564520835876,
0.5548402667045593,
-0.07520473748445511,
-0.21940183639526367,
0.35124847292900085,
-0.5909451842308044,
0.6329466700553894,
0.05753765627741814,
-0.34136056900024414,
0.05524585768580437,
-0.8006566166877747,
-0.15232031047344208,
0.17532581090927124,
0.32054510712623596,
0.17099182307720184,
-0.10835620015859604,
1.0569357872009277,
-0.6330242156982422,
0.7045809030532837,
0.07660343497991562,
-0.031129248440265656,
0.2148503214120865,
0.28720876574516296,
0.5122768878936768,
-0.1355474442243576,
-0.013425815850496292,
-0.30390799045562744,
-0.07802972942590714,
-0.49659642577171326,
-1.0653148889541626,
0.474907785654068,
-0.9413254857063293,
-0.5936568975448608,
-0.6325321197509766,
-0.3927764892578125,
-0.056453555822372437,
0.35815712809562683,
0.2745034098625183,
0.9313040971755981,
-0.1875467747449875,
0.06193775311112404,
0.6206662058830261,
-0.07889696210622787,
0.189694344997406,
-0.08855459094047546,
-0.05966039001941681,
-0.701546311378479,
1.0535705089569092,
0.2680700123310089,
0.04032675176858902,
1.0236761569976807,
0.47836002707481384,
-0.42355218529701233,
-0.582980215549469,
-0.2020321935415268,
0.5204393267631531,
-0.8789357542991638,
-0.28463929891586304,
-0.7089971899986267,
-0.05468979850411415,
-0.22519436478614807,
-0.4332573711872101,
-0.4155491590499878,
-0.5120583176612854,
-0.13965585827827454,
-0.16348545253276825,
0.3754277527332306,
1.2943446636199951,
0.02279886044561863,
0.26747339963912964,
-0.5732319355010986,
0.5963166356086731,
0.260087251663208,
0.5631601810455322,
0.07823003828525543,
-0.04703215882182121,
-0.25290149450302124,
-0.24410513043403625,
-0.6441659331321716,
-0.8038884401321411,
0.21382591128349304,
0.08989656716585159,
0.5205504894256592,
0.5588606595993042,
0.22088754177093506,
0.8557651042938232,
-0.8679175972938538,
0.40202054381370544,
0.40201330184936523,
-0.9949924349784851,
0.6670212745666504,
-0.09941733628511429,
0.009553601033985615,
0.16054528951644897,
0.628272533416748,
-0.313323438167572,
-0.3554873764514923,
-0.896693229675293,
-0.8139449954032898,
0.4158134460449219,
0.45708799362182617,
0.05875343084335327,
-0.140763059258461,
0.3284463882446289,
-0.0007214632350951433,
0.13876987993717194,
-0.30183231830596924,
-0.7538338303565979,
-0.2836003601551056,
-0.08323238044977188,
0.02471848390996456,
-0.2036322057247162,
0.1938665509223938,
-0.3269078731536865,
0.3729463815689087,
0.009756652638316154,
0.6563884615898132,
0.243733748793602,
-0.07779587060213089,
-0.06266539543867111,
0.2510853111743927,
0.2849161624908447,
0.6123825907707214,
-0.26414138078689575,
0.17993506789207458,
-0.14960318803787231,
-0.4591209292411804,
0.24335244297981262,
0.14459191262722015,
-0.0536222904920578,
0.19678744673728943,
0.24045541882514954,
0.740985631942749,
0.4519782066345215,
-0.0883903056383133,
0.6070706248283386,
0.07267159968614578,
0.1251286268234253,
0.007400656584650278,
-0.3743167519569397,
0.0771978348493576,
0.08430769294500351,
0.14904868602752686,
0.09998452663421631,
0.31355464458465576,
-0.459084689617157,
0.3578587472438812,
0.18385612964630127,
-0.548254668712616,
-0.27984827756881714,
0.733738124370575,
0.08644301444292068,
-0.30276644229888916,
0.1881837695837021,
-0.4920062720775604,
-0.7112493515014648,
0.2928081452846527,
0.6314412355422974,
0.6593945026397705,
-0.1461223065853119,
0.3541935682296753,
0.36265748739242554,
0.058096740394830704,
0.012736805714666843,
0.27116715908050537,
-0.16687680780887604,
-0.768261194229126,
-0.2290426790714264,
-0.6436530947685242,
-0.7228298187255859,
-0.4884342551231384,
-0.802651047706604,
0.3366784453392029,
-0.7840756773948669,
-0.17749905586242676,
-0.09267758578062057,
0.12174388766288757,
-0.7585976719856262,
-0.05164438113570213,
0.045392513275146484,
0.5972121357917786,
-0.4175208508968353,
0.4157022535800934,
0.9349784851074219,
-0.3271750509738922,
-0.6763330698013306,
-0.04518333449959755,
-0.16120319068431854,
-0.5226808190345764,
0.815409779548645,
0.12153743952512741,
-0.2851301431655884,
0.14698798954486847,
-0.2822635769844055,
-0.809343159198761,
1.045862078666687,
0.25734004378318787,
-0.3684549927711487,
-0.3019586205482483,
-0.0015338310040533543,
0.4752030372619629,
-0.41404810547828674,
0.08286568522453308,
0.14459902048110962,
0.051142171025276184,
0.46394455432891846,
-0.429513156414032,
0.24855200946331024,
-0.23080052435398102,
0.5428154468536377,
0.45766714215278625,
-0.3163524568080902,
0.3978999853134155,
-0.18437913060188293,
-0.5740575790405273,
-0.14819389581680298,
0.9832874536514282,
0.18089677393436432,
-0.21934391558170319,
0.245173841714859,
0.710328996181488,
0.9673470854759216,
0.019090715795755386,
1.2327316999435425,
-0.20084133744239807,
0.5461128354072571,
0.9600939154624939,
0.04616425931453705,
0.9451964497566223,
0.43870142102241516,
-0.034301307052373886,
0.9011021852493286,
0.361429899930954,
0.1204388216137886,
0.679831862449646,
0.605764627456665,
0.14844433963298798,
-0.008459950797259808,
-0.29661065340042114,
-0.3540829122066498,
0.2416132390499115,
0.5022113919258118,
0.03102114610373974,
-0.24775128066539764,
-0.07095365971326828,
-0.1177620068192482,
0.18304967880249023,
-0.1573837399482727,
0.9512782692909241,
0.1695232391357422,
-0.08183035999536514,
0.7928767204284668,
-0.0995233878493309,
0.6617217659950256,
-0.2666032612323761,
-0.26983872056007385,
0.27019059658050537,
0.10039589554071426,
-0.046832650899887085,
-0.6109859943389893,
0.06561070680618286,
-0.44087859988212585,
-0.23062799870967865,
-0.4175195097923279,
0.4917595088481903,
-0.3633548617362976,
-0.5944281220436096,
0.43256062269210815,
0.6148563623428345,
0.06848527491092682,
0.4971262812614441,
-0.6316079497337341,
0.03820774704217911,
-0.5597503185272217,
-0.11312872916460037,
-0.20776498317718506,
0.7767357230186462,
0.14397402107715607,
0.605451226234436,
0.41895878314971924,
0.18735016882419586,
0.14813655614852905,
-0.04344220459461212,
0.8064584136009216,
-0.659330427646637,
-0.7566893696784973,
-0.5226396918296814,
0.2078656256198883,
-0.00693298177793622,
0.0005178721621632576,
0.28048935532569885,
0.5724135637283325,
0.8926511406898499,
-0.049596384167671204,
0.5313363075256348,
-0.06249309703707695,
0.07683172821998596,
-0.4516313076019287,
0.4598102867603302,
-0.24129271507263184,
-0.13145506381988525,
-0.4553678035736084,
-1.010416030883789,
-0.6138003468513489,
0.7707479596138,
-0.3920319378376007,
-0.2606194317340851,
0.9161593914031982,
0.6090941429138184,
-0.36745259165763855,
-0.11649313569068909,
0.49092382192611694,
0.10871714353561401,
0.31067708134651184,
0.5171226859092712,
0.5678370594978333,
-0.8415495753288269,
0.42779871821403503,
-0.4426533579826355,
-0.19699028134346008,
0.015829330310225487,
-0.6995071172714233,
-1.1523444652557373,
-0.7384308576583862,
-0.49942561984062195,
-0.28457844257354736,
0.05284208431839943,
1.32156503200531,
0.7668749690055847,
-0.8288450837135315,
-0.29884323477745056,
-0.026505043730139732,
0.5156002044677734,
-0.06646018475294113,
-0.21564938127994537,
0.6748671531677246,
-0.2335638850927353,
-0.7560474872589111,
-0.12688077986240387,
0.284097284078598,
0.35287317633628845,
0.03238300979137421,
-0.07141157984733582,
-0.13704046607017517,
-0.02623278833925724,
0.773341715335846,
0.09903112798929214,
-0.7587491273880005,
-0.3719741702079773,
-0.07547468692064285,
-0.044377271085977554,
0.35292303562164307,
0.8680576682090759,
-0.8514347076416016,
0.5572459697723389,
0.7254316806793213,
0.9285777807235718,
0.4558088779449463,
-0.025552142411470413,
0.8231698870658875,
-0.7320298552513123,
0.07394125312566757,
0.03928963094949722,
0.4996843934059143,
0.2454223930835724,
-0.42607882618904114,
0.23188920319080353,
0.23329612612724304,
-0.08360231667757034,
-0.42971694469451904,
0.3903074264526367,
-1.162439227104187,
-0.0007114554173313081,
0.843000590801239,
0.09125007688999176,
-0.4309196472167969,
-0.18195195496082306,
-0.10258696973323822,
0.34069889783859253,
-0.6433911919593811,
0.3823583424091339,
0.4576469361782074,
0.05741531401872635,
-0.03992431238293648,
-0.1156744584441185,
0.2813597023487091,
0.04648144915699959,
-0.4372929632663727,
-0.24686726927757263,
0.07753098756074905,
-0.10841405391693115,
0.6209592223167419,
0.2669003903865814,
-0.23198768496513367,
0.03903394937515259,
-0.338547945022583,
-0.11945796757936478,
0.12859795987606049,
-0.29294541478157043,
-0.11876845359802246,
0.39115259051322937,
-0.07596177607774734,
-0.3820100426673889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10922v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10922v1
|
Teaching a Multilingual Large Language Model to Understand Multilingual Speech via Multi-Instructional Training
| 2024-04-16T21:45:59 | 2024-04-16T21:45:59 |
Pavel Denisov, Ngoc Thang Vu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Recent advancements in language modeling have led to the emergence of Large
Language Models (LLMs) capable of various natural language processing tasks.
Despite their success in text-based tasks, applying LLMs to the speech domain
remains limited and challenging. This paper presents BLOOMZMMS, a novel model
that integrates a multilingual LLM with a multilingual speech encoder, aiming
to harness the capabilities of LLMs for speech recognition and beyond.
Utilizing a multi-instructional training approach, we demonstrate the
transferability of linguistic knowledge from the text to the speech modality.
Our experiments, conducted on 1900 hours of transcribed data from 139
languages, establish that a multilingual speech representation can be
effectively learned and aligned with a multilingual LLM. While this learned
representation initially shows limitations in task generalization, we address
this issue by generating synthetic targets in a multi-instructional style. Our
zero-shot evaluation results confirm the robustness of our approach across
multiple tasks, including speech translation and multilingual spoken language
understanding, thereby opening new avenues for applying LLMs in the speech
domain.
|
[
-0.13618142902851105,
-0.6602904200553894,
0.4579378664493561,
0.2159675508737564,
-0.08224257826805115,
0.2727281451225281,
-0.6742632389068604,
-0.1737791746854782,
0.11038906127214432,
0.3542894721031189,
-0.751995861530304,
-0.46691593527793884,
-0.5323148369789124,
-0.06637764722108841,
-0.30043742060661316,
1.0501400232315063,
0.09030663222074509,
0.4503082036972046,
0.06815867871046066,
0.19375374913215637,
-0.4614565074443817,
-0.6746789813041687,
-0.3423694968223572,
-0.4906744360923767,
0.6209311485290527,
0.4935518205165863,
0.28286492824554443,
0.28715819120407104,
0.22786739468574524,
0.23831641674041748,
0.06484180688858032,
0.21326753497123718,
-0.4868645966053009,
0.05919080600142479,
-0.04016897454857826,
-0.5552121996879578,
-0.13381294906139374,
-0.3403933048248291,
1.0294679403305054,
0.8559279441833496,
-0.38850659132003784,
0.15092334151268005,
0.07103270292282104,
0.23508338630199432,
-0.6444291472434998,
0.21550129354000092,
-0.7611719965934753,
0.3312319219112396,
-0.3484659194946289,
-0.11293363571166992,
-0.6985746622085571,
0.07322326302528381,
0.007547745015472174,
-0.3577663004398346,
0.16268792748451233,
-0.5014041662216187,
0.22635093331336975,
-0.07122542709112167,
-0.3784099221229553,
-0.19969262182712555,
-1.0666145086288452,
0.878959059715271,
-0.6498244404792786,
0.7691466808319092,
0.10347267240285873,
0.5145427584648132,
0.12373075634241104,
-0.33969423174858093,
-0.5227792263031006,
-0.17387284338474274,
0.3609431982040405,
0.16638699173927307,
0.04397992417216301,
-0.16992174088954926,
0.021695544943213463,
0.31138846278190613,
-0.6513049006462097,
0.26450875401496887,
-0.2645057439804077,
-0.1972280591726303,
0.43496936559677124,
0.08146071434020996,
0.39127856492996216,
0.13480672240257263,
-0.5066145658493042,
-0.0056200711987912655,
-0.49889808893203735,
-0.1802637130022049,
0.17845746874809265,
0.8803955316543579,
-0.2762485146522522,
0.4740164875984192,
0.23192521929740906,
0.6837178468704224,
-0.3180365562438965,
-0.4459676742553711,
0.35899507999420166,
-0.17326995730400085,
-0.1409730166196823,
0.04560069367289543,
0.6211036443710327,
-0.1934015154838562,
0.33333200216293335,
-0.5105312466621399,
0.07996759563684464,
-0.1197592243552208,
0.28888264298439026,
-0.6523057222366333,
0.24614687263965607,
-0.13350942730903625,
-0.04216533899307251,
0.20381416380405426,
0.006555110681802034,
-0.743643045425415,
-0.05526050180196762,
-0.358962744474411,
0.5482116937637329,
-0.6059268712997437,
-0.32823243737220764,
0.308960884809494,
0.06308086216449738,
0.35147514939308167,
0.11059752851724625,
-1.1872152090072632,
0.1762412041425705,
0.5318741798400879,
1.0038397312164307,
-0.18825805187225342,
-0.7184884548187256,
-0.5657452940940857,
0.6219846606254578,
-0.4058239758014679,
0.5342139601707458,
-0.5127038359642029,
-0.42007309198379517,
0.39871102571487427,
0.0015804829308763146,
-0.4860060513019562,
-0.3343013823032379,
0.3537786900997162,
-0.3941175043582916,
-0.01261255145072937,
0.03726895526051521,
-0.5888567566871643,
-0.24492205679416656,
0.3294748365879059,
-0.28451618552207947,
0.6919412016868591,
-0.04087340831756592,
-0.3287643790245056,
-0.0039133913815021515,
-0.6613548994064331,
-0.614020586013794,
0.14468766748905182,
-0.17163489758968353,
-0.2789228856563568,
0.012815804220736027,
0.1219116672873497,
0.44087398052215576,
0.16648884117603302,
0.0839090645313263,
-0.056787360459566116,
-0.24109072983264923,
0.27630460262298584,
-0.7288652062416077,
0.5431309938430786,
0.1327734887599945,
-0.12395405024290085,
0.22416609525680542,
-0.6235541701316833,
0.1269398182630539,
0.26827192306518555,
-0.586494505405426,
0.057964518666267395,
-0.10169542580842972,
0.20097167789936066,
0.09189523011445999,
0.13672056794166565,
-0.4913621246814728,
0.12738105654716492,
-0.4459165036678314,
0.5274591445922852,
0.4228399395942688,
-0.10057871043682098,
0.534551739692688,
-0.25543829798698425,
0.5725067257881165,
-0.09197472035884857,
-0.0037019888404756784,
-0.7276657819747925,
-0.31664204597473145,
-0.8754801750183105,
-0.35403144359588623,
-0.05279142037034035,
0.6775962114334106,
-0.6241034269332886,
0.07455244660377502,
-0.41015076637268066,
-0.45036235451698303,
-0.2655882239341736,
0.39169156551361084,
0.3710479438304901,
0.18061937391757965,
0.429836630821228,
-0.08070187270641327,
-0.39068788290023804,
-0.7366729974746704,
-0.20935608446598053,
0.34533894062042236,
-0.03385142236948013,
0.02782513201236725,
0.40959033370018005,
-0.3911060094833374,
0.7096914649009705,
-0.406138151884079,
-0.46328938007354736,
-0.6204192638397217,
0.12680919468402863,
0.2310512661933899,
0.4555404782295227,
0.4073121249675751,
-0.4725160598754883,
-0.5274707078933716,
0.07368749380111694,
-0.4562808871269226,
0.3174990117549896,
-0.09703076630830765,
-0.019854817539453506,
-0.09256146103143692,
0.3867388367652893,
-0.5489799380302429,
-0.10860960185527802,
0.5556224584579468,
0.12179213762283325,
0.7251553535461426,
-0.45028603076934814,
-0.014453244395554066,
-1.2013055086135864,
-0.2555294334888458,
-0.11459898203611374,
-0.15493710339069366,
-1.1211453676223755,
0.1145063191652298,
0.07792045921087265,
-0.5482372045516968,
-0.725071370601654,
0.4115196168422699,
-0.5580087900161743,
-0.20707322657108307,
-0.2981598675251007,
0.08547456562519073,
-0.12819474935531616,
0.5414726734161377,
0.10873246937990189,
0.8280143141746521,
0.6574617028236389,
-0.5795918107032776,
0.49061283469200134,
0.35356712341308594,
-0.43095633387565613,
0.5364744067192078,
-0.23632429540157318,
0.3922851085662842,
-0.27562621235847473,
0.08893448859453201,
-0.616433322429657,
-0.4215594232082367,
0.07156607508659363,
-0.33878645300865173,
0.6058740019798279,
-0.2996983528137207,
-0.46762168407440186,
-0.22915935516357422,
-0.026245689019560814,
0.24435798823833466,
0.3220333158969879,
-0.5710815787315369,
0.6067085862159729,
0.30541831254959106,
-0.2527220547199249,
-0.4997050166130066,
-1.066534399986267,
0.16211208701133728,
-0.2859930694103241,
-0.5160463452339172,
0.48767274618148804,
-0.1754537969827652,
0.04811330884695053,
-0.4127137064933777,
0.2097596526145935,
-0.33777156472206116,
-0.06698302924633026,
-0.09099332988262177,
0.10320736467838287,
-0.2994750738143921,
0.4688478708267212,
-0.08223336935043335,
0.04673366621136665,
-0.06920383870601654,
-0.3512885272502899,
0.7894677519798279,
0.019523797556757927,
-0.8170156478881836,
-0.4385205805301666,
0.5635586977005005,
0.6347083449363708,
-0.5337265133857727,
0.8647382855415344,
0.865659236907959,
-0.5088919997215271,
-0.4468592405319214,
-0.4849405586719513,
-0.19299688935279846,
-0.3972555100917816,
0.7223174571990967,
-0.32005834579467773,
-0.8051701188087463,
0.44424062967300415,
-0.009770629927515984,
0.16144055128097534,
0.1396210491657257,
0.7855955362319946,
0.12631341814994812,
0.8158559203147888,
0.7550534605979919,
-0.20802189409732819,
0.7583208084106445,
-0.3222717344760895,
0.12484943121671677,
-0.8230330348014832,
-0.46768173575401306,
-0.38395920395851135,
0.103926882147789,
0.06340478360652924,
-0.8885001540184021,
0.4145429730415344,
-0.04389211907982826,
-0.18709257245063782,
0.14520025253295898,
-0.014389810152351856,
0.5243003368377686,
0.4631814658641815,
0.12602472305297852,
0.16306033730506897,
0.3172760307788849,
-0.03853954002261162,
-0.1507696658372879,
-0.8207575678825378,
-0.4650406837463379,
0.9693611860275269,
0.34164318442344666,
0.670236349105835,
0.33339476585388184,
0.6683894395828247,
0.1678253412246704,
0.1534564346075058,
-1.0560051202774048,
0.1764383167028427,
-0.4066711962223053,
-0.4170026481151581,
-0.3095703423023224,
-0.3627576231956482,
-0.7030083537101746,
0.5800500512123108,
-0.25319987535476685,
-0.7174507975578308,
-0.17178811132907867,
0.014921853318810463,
-0.35281580686569214,
0.41535553336143494,
-0.8061851263046265,
0.8803154230117798,
-0.39461418986320496,
-0.2756940722465515,
-0.3500482439994812,
-0.3357188403606415,
0.24678267538547516,
-0.19520987570285797,
0.8644461035728455,
-0.19817890226840973,
0.16892924904823303,
0.6201013922691345,
-0.07480261474847794,
0.9838981032371521,
-0.09403479844331741,
-0.4080686569213867,
0.15608543157577515,
-0.05502500385046005,
0.17732644081115723,
-0.14651082456111908,
-0.10595551878213882,
0.14059045910835266,
-0.2518251836299896,
-0.22471024096012115,
-0.5576110482215881,
0.5546025037765503,
-0.5731906890869141,
-0.39984384179115295,
-0.22916652262210846,
-0.74620521068573,
-0.5431831479072571,
0.18491020798683167,
0.08644994348287582,
0.5753318667411804,
-0.4379814863204956,
-0.003037361428141594,
0.688947856426239,
-0.23778362572193146,
0.37068867683410645,
0.7346835732460022,
-0.21897225081920624,
-0.344735324382782,
1.120650053024292,
0.1444217562675476,
0.424984872341156,
0.49878382682800293,
0.17205119132995605,
-0.19929641485214233,
-0.5498208999633789,
-0.633246660232544,
0.27664873003959656,
-0.8092878460884094,
-0.014094262383878231,
-0.44214585423469543,
-0.4175279140472412,
-0.4928632080554962,
-0.04953477531671524,
-0.5137804746627808,
0.015835750848054886,
-0.46066799759864807,
0.07489623129367828,
0.034328799694776535,
0.6032068729400635,
-0.2302483469247818,
0.5075771808624268,
-1.097093939781189,
0.15013357996940613,
0.5182364583015442,
0.22888977825641632,
0.12465451657772064,
-0.9394523501396179,
-0.6420515775680542,
0.29717081785202026,
-0.37707144021987915,
-0.9906719923019409,
0.5739057064056396,
0.8732694983482361,
0.8159714937210083,
0.5329546332359314,
-0.3573249876499176,
0.6553257703781128,
-1.1483761072158813,
0.6914674639701843,
0.38623714447021484,
-1.1360610723495483,
0.5169879794120789,
-0.3972989320755005,
0.5804353952407837,
0.00948286522179842,
0.39168310165405273,
-0.899518609046936,
-0.3743652105331421,
-0.04259544983506203,
-0.6649909019470215,
0.7761145234107971,
-0.006982955615967512,
0.7674635052680969,
-0.07262862473726273,
0.29045993089675903,
0.18423637747764587,
0.07132861018180847,
-0.7788862586021423,
-0.1743571013212204,
-0.15112462639808655,
-0.2906186282634735,
-0.48232048749923706,
-0.35606470704078674,
-0.14694508910179138,
0.0003320466785226017,
0.613422155380249,
-0.2764875292778015,
0.28106898069381714,
-0.12050392478704453,
-0.34536314010620117,
0.022164873778820038,
0.6466831564903259,
0.7949524521827698,
0.609433650970459,
0.13090628385543823,
0.3623870015144348,
0.29620203375816345,
-0.4012018144130707,
0.23105615377426147,
0.0993005782365799,
0.04325628653168678,
0.10539235919713974,
0.6602878570556641,
0.8962969183921814,
0.6562970876693726,
-0.7188799381256104,
0.34212619066238403,
0.30702584981918335,
-0.1732395440340042,
-0.27696895599365234,
-0.022285766899585724,
0.35896536707878113,
0.3531258702278137,
0.44696566462516785,
-0.2737692594528198,
0.021569179370999336,
-0.5895045399665833,
0.11913449317216873,
0.6714567542076111,
-0.26855188608169556,
-0.4125121533870697,
0.44272366166114807,
-0.042582906782627106,
-0.5142707824707031,
0.36718565225601196,
0.08877358585596085,
-0.7615301609039307,
0.2983437478542328,
0.8906272649765015,
0.5361801385879517,
-0.6961104273796082,
0.3472382724285126,
0.4158245623111725,
0.24936163425445557,
-0.13691867887973785,
0.0958142802119255,
-0.09069839119911194,
-0.8669167160987854,
-0.5495736002922058,
-0.7273672223091125,
-0.5856943130493164,
0.12829364836215973,
-0.685606062412262,
0.17144587635993958,
-0.10903885215520859,
-0.14437535405158997,
0.19633714854717255,
-0.5282127857208252,
-0.36192479729652405,
-0.10347306728363037,
0.5683997869491577,
0.641435980796814,
-0.8381068110466003,
0.8012136220932007,
0.5029022693634033,
-0.2505795359611511,
-0.5966693162918091,
-0.07313934713602066,
0.018966563045978546,
-0.8610274791717529,
0.6609237790107727,
0.2540687918663025,
-0.19347530603408813,
0.032343678176403046,
-0.21684017777442932,
-0.9331652522087097,
0.6378270983695984,
0.8887665271759033,
-0.6923293471336365,
-0.03021182119846344,
0.35182490944862366,
0.36943918466567993,
-0.3473246693611145,
-0.025391925126314163,
0.2794840335845947,
0.1286659836769104,
0.3316333591938019,
-1.0335922241210938,
-0.640009880065918,
0.11155541986227036,
-0.01945984736084938,
-0.00012846199388150126,
-0.4337593913078308,
0.8456728458404541,
-0.4036409258842468,
-0.25436872243881226,
-0.18029244244098663,
0.5780420899391174,
0.06371244788169861,
0.03660890832543373,
0.2737804353237152,
0.3405129611492157,
0.6974883079528809,
-0.025501267984509468,
0.6896889209747314,
-0.12593679130077362,
0.44674840569496155,
1.3253856897354126,
-0.3110836148262024,
1.128438949584961,
0.3257139027118683,
-0.36028042435646057,
0.4052621126174927,
0.37664875388145447,
-0.042257942259311676,
0.5302132964134216,
0.18288074433803558,
-0.6621529459953308,
-0.436674028635025,
-0.0963805615901947,
-0.3909528851509094,
0.7284485697746277,
0.4879516363143921,
-0.18887636065483093,
-0.3820299208164215,
0.5869143009185791,
-0.05052006244659424,
0.1375083178281784,
-0.42385026812553406,
0.7422062754631042,
0.1278807520866394,
-0.18788987398147583,
0.5658788084983826,
0.09541217982769012,
0.7232649326324463,
-0.9668738842010498,
0.04801446199417114,
0.14560003578662872,
0.39342501759529114,
-0.0541665218770504,
-0.48901182413101196,
0.43157294392585754,
0.1405474990606308,
-0.26926255226135254,
-0.29413220286369324,
0.39569729566574097,
-1.0597732067108154,
-0.7739105820655823,
0.32688605785369873,
0.5354851484298706,
0.21167385578155518,
-0.0077802762389183044,
-0.45320799946784973,
0.14937692880630493,
-0.2792063057422638,
0.15072886645793915,
0.38182151317596436,
0.16159313917160034,
0.3809109926223755,
0.7853395938873291,
0.5984651446342468,
0.16498196125030518,
0.3386612832546234,
0.5775421261787415,
0.61967533826828,
-0.28074198961257935,
-0.5463866591453552,
-0.9764819145202637,
0.17281262576580048,
0.3223235309123993,
0.19712722301483154,
1.0114850997924805,
0.5990424752235413,
0.8854718208312988,
-0.36566221714019775,
0.7711656093597412,
0.49842607975006104,
0.5862720608711243,
-0.7231902480125427,
0.6694046258926392,
-0.46336740255355835,
-0.07588580250740051,
-0.062232766300439835,
-0.8492675423622131,
-0.3402090072631836,
0.7836915850639343,
-0.24839696288108826,
0.1640002578496933,
0.2850188612937927,
0.4327687621116638,
-0.023784389719367027,
-0.13192886114120483,
0.4561053216457367,
-0.0214022658765316,
0.3616511821746826,
0.6384653449058533,
0.8639724254608154,
0.016622906550765038,
0.5337119102478027,
-0.20051786303520203,
-0.23678052425384521,
-0.1374129205942154,
-0.632558286190033,
-0.9502653479576111,
-0.46049022674560547,
-0.1945808380842209,
0.13405773043632507,
0.00621574092656374,
0.858402669429779,
0.9859527349472046,
-0.7608062028884888,
-0.6493213176727295,
0.1526840627193451,
0.029841439798474312,
-0.1623876839876175,
-0.18766970932483673,
0.129311203956604,
-0.7706684470176697,
-1.0032289028167725,
0.8980647325515747,
0.37731245160102844,
0.286013126373291,
-0.5130246877670288,
-0.05235622823238373,
-0.16802175343036652,
0.031017234548926353,
0.7354170680046082,
0.2375423014163971,
-0.6648052334785461,
-0.03688735514879227,
0.023879623040556908,
0.1936182975769043,
0.023088369518518448,
0.9221963882446289,
-0.3337431252002716,
0.5215252637863159,
-0.09035258740186691,
0.6848217844963074,
0.5787575840950012,
-0.5310954451560974,
0.5107678771018982,
-0.9132707715034485,
0.3444436192512512,
0.1565561443567276,
0.35471296310424805,
0.5951159596443176,
-0.14495493471622467,
-0.014535696245729923,
0.11384934931993484,
-0.1955052763223648,
-0.8650451898574829,
0.42528828978538513,
-0.7302659153938293,
-0.24178321659564972,
1.1952283382415771,
-0.2717226445674896,
0.037911009043455124,
0.065398208796978,
-0.09825601428747177,
0.40681159496307373,
-0.10750573128461838,
0.5854917168617249,
0.6705483198165894,
0.07269337028265,
-0.3185935318470001,
-0.6105495691299438,
0.19328820705413818,
0.27356207370758057,
-0.822568416595459,
0.2014450877904892,
0.25764748454093933,
0.37868252396583557,
0.23440103232860565,
0.38595131039619446,
0.096028633415699,
0.07519620656967163,
0.007763080298900604,
0.10322923958301544,
-0.14812998473644257,
-0.38184282183647156,
-0.6082046031951904,
0.16633446514606476,
0.010314017534255981,
-0.34658995270729065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10917v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10917v1
|
Which questions should I answer? Salience Prediction of Inquisitive Questions
| 2024-04-16T21:33:05 | 2024-04-16T21:33:05 |
Yating Wu, Ritika Mangla, Alexandros G. Dimakis, Greg Durrett, Junyi Jessy Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Inquisitive questions -- open-ended, curiosity-driven questions people ask as
they read -- are an integral part of discourse processing (Kehler and Rohde,
2017; Onea, 2016) and comprehension (Prince, 2004). Recent work in NLP has
taken advantage of question generation capabilities of LLMs to enhance a wide
range of applications. But the space of inquisitive questions is vast: many
questions can be evoked from a given context. So which of those should be
prioritized to find answers? Linguistic theories, unfortunately, have not yet
provided an answer to this question. This paper presents QSALIENCE, a salience
predictor of inquisitive questions. QSALIENCE is instruction-tuned over our
dataset of linguist-annotated salience scores of 1,766 (context, question)
pairs. A question scores high on salience if answering it would greatly enhance
the understanding of the text (Van Rooy, 2003). We show that highly salient
questions are empirically more likely to be answered in the same article,
bridging potential questions (Onea, 2016) with Questions Under Discussion
(Roberts, 2012). We further validate our findings by showing that answering
salient questions is an indicator of summarization quality in news.
|
[
-0.5896218419075012,
-0.523135244846344,
0.8363807797431946,
0.19036217033863068,
-0.3297892212867737,
-0.12885664403438568,
0.05368153750896454,
-0.5971734523773193,
0.4303974211215973,
0.4003731906414032,
-0.615175724029541,
-0.1322915405035019,
-0.6751055121421814,
0.14492003619670868,
-0.4763161838054657,
1.0650863647460938,
0.25745701789855957,
-0.21071608364582062,
-0.7070181369781494,
-0.053769551217556,
-0.4257901608943939,
-0.5499381422996521,
-0.38204893469810486,
0.03739750385284424,
0.713646411895752,
0.5682692527770996,
0.7702308893203735,
0.1978398561477661,
0.3761610686779022,
0.3012350797653198,
-0.4440300166606903,
-0.2007388472557068,
-0.3290705680847168,
0.6610428094863892,
-0.12598450481891632,
-0.8916199207305908,
0.18824036419391632,
-0.04811962693929672,
0.27042001485824585,
0.9985639452934265,
0.3142407238483429,
0.5567567348480225,
-0.176805779337883,
0.5748984813690186,
-0.6827900409698486,
-0.3485332429409027,
-0.440528005361557,
0.0831698402762413,
-0.20004507899284363,
-0.4512101411819458,
0.058689456433057785,
-0.6691815853118896,
0.47050347924232483,
-0.3113420903682709,
0.09775813668966293,
0.207899272441864,
0.6405310034751892,
0.5381743907928467,
-0.46213483810424805,
-0.15885314345359802,
-0.22110527753829956,
0.6724973917007446,
-0.6477048993110657,
0.27135035395622253,
0.7209767699241638,
0.06669645756483078,
0.08102943748235703,
-0.5297411680221558,
-0.33035534620285034,
-0.1421964168548584,
-0.5105305910110474,
0.4171393811702728,
-0.16164632141590118,
-0.15771231055259705,
0.2284279614686966,
0.5645580291748047,
-0.8868955373764038,
-0.26201581954956055,
-0.3143616318702698,
0.0014887347351759672,
0.42728450894355774,
0.03499258682131767,
0.1534627079963684,
-0.20235975086688995,
-0.2880091667175293,
0.4140925705432892,
-0.28664442896842957,
0.6425923705101013,
0.36870142817497253,
-0.28756043314933777,
0.21636135876178741,
0.7188243269920349,
-0.3950621783733368,
0.6709261536598206,
0.23162919282913208,
-0.0006749146268703043,
-0.16135859489440918,
-0.4304922819137573,
0.2238372266292572,
0.2035285383462906,
0.3315213620662689,
0.5206139087677002,
0.16807377338409424,
-0.13045065104961395,
-0.05657002702355385,
-0.36395263671875,
0.26534998416900635,
-0.7153638601303101,
-0.03728457912802696,
0.759259819984436,
-0.1947614550590515,
-0.18056586384773254,
0.14694148302078247,
-0.6620960831642151,
-0.17877130210399628,
-0.04594242200255394,
0.05177919194102287,
-0.2536482810974121,
-0.08285456150770187,
0.0859648659825325,
-0.22358913719654083,
0.08997724950313568,
0.40968942642211914,
-1.084096074104309,
0.17609554529190063,
0.5618672966957092,
0.53923100233078,
-0.07000090181827545,
0.030923230573534966,
-0.5607704520225525,
0.08470502495765686,
-0.3293192386627197,
1.0971368551254272,
-0.5296167731285095,
-0.28989896178245544,
-0.029715754091739655,
-0.028714079409837723,
0.053552474826574326,
-0.4290509819984436,
0.7277382612228394,
-0.7391567230224609,
0.7884657979011536,
-0.6052257418632507,
-0.5423922538757324,
-0.3145671784877777,
0.40184780955314636,
-0.5283534526824951,
0.9274807572364807,
0.35590770840644836,
-1.1441104412078857,
0.22410593926906586,
-0.6561639904975891,
-0.2664506137371063,
0.32139503955841064,
0.05142626538872719,
-0.18089699745178223,
0.27474650740623474,
0.3339534401893616,
0.22395139932632446,
-0.3405396640300751,
0.28751397132873535,
0.20131509006023407,
-0.40138116478919983,
0.7571956515312195,
-0.0849960669875145,
0.41226959228515625,
-0.06788475066423416,
-0.21442118287086487,
-0.04837702959775925,
-0.3959138095378876,
0.3912624716758728,
-0.05899641290307045,
-0.39718878269195557,
-0.49356138706207275,
-0.05306161567568779,
-0.3723828196525574,
0.17177914083003998,
0.43862205743789673,
-0.5058545470237732,
-0.18669655919075012,
-0.9228900671005249,
-0.0967593789100647,
0.651246190071106,
0.5327783226966858,
0.39393359422683716,
-0.2811385989189148,
0.753216028213501,
0.1208093985915184,
0.02536056935787201,
-0.22235941886901855,
-0.621230959892273,
-0.5580202341079712,
0.22830402851104736,
0.11515343934297562,
0.411379337310791,
-0.5136950016021729,
0.04998818784952164,
0.035724423825740814,
-0.4150625765323639,
-0.6700823903083801,
-0.3344118893146515,
0.4858191907405853,
0.7467541098594666,
0.46302950382232666,
-0.0625755712389946,
-0.4093172252178192,
-0.916833758354187,
-0.5758135318756104,
-0.4435541033744812,
-0.02054154872894287,
0.36126387119293213,
0.19793035089969635,
0.5160996913909912,
1.1720291376113892,
-0.853740394115448,
0.4463876187801361,
-0.06335882097482681,
-0.01293204352259636,
0.21263045072555542,
0.13757702708244324,
0.5769603848457336,
-1.2876311540603638,
-0.22767572104930878,
-0.3080075681209564,
-0.7239134907722473,
-0.3784063458442688,
0.09313720464706421,
-0.13773798942565918,
-0.26543667912483215,
0.4410344064235687,
-0.5851468443870544,
0.01828557439148426,
0.27670878171920776,
-0.4211576282978058,
0.6334623098373413,
0.2604886591434479,
0.1495516300201416,
-0.8930895328521729,
0.07956982403993607,
0.02461383491754532,
-0.09493004530668259,
-0.6614336967468262,
0.2690799832344055,
-0.19768193364143372,
-0.09695202857255936,
-0.6483414769172668,
0.6785416007041931,
-0.05509495735168457,
-0.16785718500614166,
-0.10975583642721176,
0.26306626200675964,
0.10909667611122131,
0.25331515073776245,
-0.2595820128917694,
1.087708592414856,
0.3176850974559784,
-0.8855913877487183,
0.35016143321990967,
0.3273875415325165,
-0.2951330244541168,
0.23492306470870972,
-0.9380840063095093,
-0.021562660112977028,
-0.556968092918396,
-0.15816070139408112,
-1.3070274591445923,
-0.3755949139595032,
0.26351994276046753,
-0.7372444868087769,
-0.08988812565803528,
0.16211025416851044,
-0.2863045930862427,
-0.47296664118766785,
-0.5110999941825867,
0.4897872805595398,
0.20644675195217133,
-0.43843066692352295,
0.19744953513145447,
0.36825188994407654,
-0.645904004573822,
-0.9060285687446594,
-0.43074285984039307,
-0.26179102063179016,
-0.1671488732099533,
-0.3770843744277954,
0.09182538092136383,
-0.4592267572879791,
-0.4921562373638153,
0.1387549489736557,
-0.23534730076789856,
0.01908835582435131,
0.47854939103126526,
0.4394274353981018,
0.07581471651792526,
-0.2662275433540344,
0.36528411507606506,
0.27501359581947327,
-0.33071547746658325,
0.3057032823562622,
-0.1264108419418335,
0.5424103736877441,
-0.09349893778562546,
-0.3218662738800049,
-0.025517407804727554,
0.5798120498657227,
0.45387721061706543,
-0.49253222346305847,
0.2657562494277954,
0.25355300307273865,
-0.07101021707057953,
0.3301551043987274,
-0.45036160945892334,
-0.3951541781425476,
-0.38777071237564087,
0.36022138595581055,
-0.29565170407295227,
-1.2238678932189941,
0.43907609581947327,
0.0072306618094444275,
0.11267533898353577,
0.4097149968147278,
0.5456475019454956,
-0.5163691639900208,
1.1395152807235718,
0.5987511277198792,
-0.2193010002374649,
0.2683013379573822,
0.0149538554251194,
0.35295599699020386,
-0.46092912554740906,
-0.20054320991039276,
-0.6607404351234436,
-0.4058246314525604,
-0.4490484893321991,
-0.008985976688563824,
0.5626035332679749,
0.04489722102880478,
0.10905151069164276,
0.029949961230158806,
-0.4983549416065216,
0.630133330821991,
0.7145658135414124,
-0.19687612354755402,
0.2847733497619629,
-0.3259003162384033,
0.15106406807899475,
-0.13141092658042908,
-0.641775906085968,
-0.5526083707809448,
0.6773003935813904,
0.20713697373867035,
0.40306535363197327,
0.33044561743736267,
0.682307243347168,
-0.08107390254735947,
0.08816435933113098,
-0.810803234577179,
0.7377380132675171,
0.36393868923187256,
-0.725274920463562,
-0.5104911923408508,
-0.1591925173997879,
-1.003482460975647,
0.42536088824272156,
-0.25210121273994446,
-0.538879930973053,
0.29187965393066406,
0.05432906001806259,
-0.711298942565918,
-0.05127016454935074,
-0.3929084539413452,
0.45325368642807007,
-0.2594945728778839,
-0.31959033012390137,
-0.022895418107509613,
-0.9970672130584717,
0.45819833874702454,
0.04311668872833252,
-0.005741739645600319,
-0.2429380565881729,
-0.2540365159511566,
0.6162952780723572,
-0.002442591590806842,
0.593787670135498,
0.09935697913169861,
-0.12853050231933594,
0.33212605118751526,
-0.026883846148848534,
-0.10354246199131012,
0.6064593195915222,
-0.34258079528808594,
-0.28069159388542175,
0.051957495510578156,
-0.3905167877674103,
-0.8125316500663757,
0.46131545305252075,
-0.5920540690422058,
-1.0647144317626953,
-0.6149193048477173,
-0.549177348613739,
-0.18838490545749664,
0.0830635279417038,
0.45498672127723694,
0.1287928968667984,
-0.15644724667072296,
-0.14828649163246155,
0.8859860897064209,
-0.13869349658489227,
0.6960497498512268,
0.47554031014442444,
-0.10485344380140305,
-0.14433865249156952,
0.5056066513061523,
0.013576257042586803,
0.16472123563289642,
0.6107105016708374,
0.14561253786087036,
-0.4328141212463379,
-0.3454952538013458,
-0.3531340956687927,
0.24926038086414337,
-0.5976004004478455,
-0.4458768963813782,
-0.8424984216690063,
-0.21847234666347504,
-0.23534145951271057,
-0.22126980125904083,
0.06238207221031189,
-0.5261538028717041,
-0.4904029071331024,
-0.2668781280517578,
0.33693447709083557,
0.3066338896751404,
0.30855926871299744,
-0.11205065995454788,
-0.8496080040931702,
0.2602028250694275,
0.738333523273468,
0.12296488881111145,
-0.15798695385456085,
-0.6884910464286804,
-0.3261377811431885,
-0.020938927307724953,
-0.3724272549152374,
-0.8964043259620667,
0.4115409553050995,
0.09496849775314331,
0.5820706486701965,
0.41599491238594055,
0.4164424538612366,
0.32260531187057495,
-0.15221095085144043,
1.022721529006958,
-0.0661093145608902,
-0.6229149699211121,
0.8466484546661377,
-0.04564663767814636,
0.3954082131385803,
0.7153698801994324,
0.9734817147254944,
-0.7305574417114258,
-0.8295015692710876,
-0.7096458673477173,
-0.9033992886543274,
0.2660306692123413,
-0.06295862048864365,
0.2725982964038849,
-0.2529323101043701,
0.50111323595047,
0.33375638723373413,
0.6264162659645081,
-0.6057879328727722,
-0.01623954251408577,
-0.13190841674804688,
0.19935916364192963,
0.05554710701107979,
-0.6265621185302734,
-0.07603058218955994,
-0.12639892101287842,
0.3333229720592499,
-0.22985802590847015,
0.09644044935703278,
0.19663304090499878,
-0.0008339781779795885,
-0.4445797801017761,
0.5122533440589905,
0.6358670592308044,
0.8202866911888123,
-0.40213626623153687,
0.3206455707550049,
0.08540255576372147,
-0.5075820684432983,
0.1438302993774414,
-0.12465926259756088,
-0.3318910300731659,
0.21381281316280365,
0.27996253967285156,
0.403251975774765,
0.25207048654556274,
-0.8641770482063293,
0.6614028215408325,
-0.00840243324637413,
-0.15080516040325165,
-0.19132736325263977,
0.3051433861255646,
0.10388252884149551,
0.3761949837207794,
0.4677745997905731,
-0.08929134160280228,
0.3932294249534607,
-0.7487047910690308,
-0.040639083832502365,
0.2113824188709259,
-0.2715303599834442,
-0.286059707403183,
0.6455783843994141,
-0.028268437832593918,
-0.028364764526486397,
0.42039403319358826,
-0.07813036441802979,
-0.9064164757728577,
0.5008102059364319,
0.3733890652656555,
0.5716603398323059,
-0.2985743582248688,
0.2088702917098999,
0.46413564682006836,
0.019160153344273567,
0.23614461719989777,
0.7770982384681702,
0.09787740558385849,
-0.5014412999153137,
-0.42493686079978943,
-0.645804762840271,
-0.6814313530921936,
-0.059563230723142624,
-0.7246583104133606,
0.0011214276310056448,
-0.21916641294956207,
-0.11100145429372787,
0.026744995266199112,
0.055549319833517075,
-0.0693206638097763,
0.5645149946212769,
-0.12796881794929504,
0.6161298155784607,
-0.7723503708839417,
0.17265895009040833,
0.767898440361023,
-0.7556670308113098,
-0.36050695180892944,
0.5340555310249329,
-0.31099870800971985,
-0.5093542337417603,
0.6427925229072571,
-0.07366819679737091,
0.10893069952726364,
0.1770189255475998,
-0.7725403308868408,
-1.2551612854003906,
0.9988881349563599,
0.3483721613883972,
-0.1918596774339676,
0.11521466076374054,
-0.04976595565676689,
0.3832263946533203,
-0.023357829079031944,
0.4588843882083893,
0.48631927371025085,
0.48369768261909485,
0.15265922248363495,
-0.5799543857574463,
-0.10953569412231445,
-0.37667182087898254,
-0.027586499229073524,
0.21647293865680695,
-0.573888897895813,
0.8236575722694397,
-0.6950104832649231,
-0.1265588253736496,
0.07557900995016098,
0.9127997756004333,
0.3487686514854431,
0.5731743574142456,
0.3910076320171356,
0.3207746148109436,
0.9651160836219788,
-0.2307058423757553,
1.1443270444869995,
-0.4171709418296814,
-0.09660950303077698,
0.8631441593170166,
0.18757279217243195,
0.7425168752670288,
0.6352840065956116,
-0.15061208605766296,
0.2220027595758438,
1.0920170545578003,
0.28373244404792786,
0.689862847328186,
0.19121821224689484,
-0.4199162721633911,
0.0607546903192997,
-0.4553907811641693,
-0.7305150032043457,
0.48812928795814514,
0.23737788200378418,
-0.11236172169446945,
-0.052970513701438904,
0.11184906214475632,
-0.06482923030853271,
0.20294271409511566,
-0.3637963831424713,
0.9017376899719238,
-0.05319296568632126,
-0.8164854645729065,
0.4239327311515808,
-0.06639038026332855,
0.4639560580253601,
-0.31156057119369507,
0.08762860298156738,
-0.5868997573852539,
-0.4876406490802765,
-0.29658639430999756,
-1.3199056386947632,
0.13340222835540771,
-0.20533718168735504,
-0.6314260959625244,
-0.13927966356277466,
0.7760447263717651,
-0.5381555557250977,
-0.12479601055383682,
-0.13339105248451233,
0.8072039484977722,
0.42627254128456116,
-0.2362297922372818,
-0.38672542572021484,
-0.5405837297439575,
-0.17271828651428223,
-0.3407016098499298,
0.4535093605518341,
0.591396689414978,
-0.035741813480854034,
0.7063595652580261,
0.7171772718429565,
0.002711974550038576,
0.06857439875602722,
0.0714913085103035,
1.2388240098953247,
-0.5921271443367004,
-0.6919655799865723,
-0.5017256140708923,
0.6964555978775024,
-0.14757075905799866,
-0.630059003829956,
0.8723825216293335,
0.5834817290306091,
0.5991453528404236,
-0.10169560462236404,
0.7175122499465942,
0.24692367017269135,
0.9234310984611511,
-0.3647349178791046,
0.4574216306209564,
-0.6038402915000916,
0.09956146776676178,
-0.2777194380760193,
-0.871282160282135,
-0.10466822236776352,
0.5700127482414246,
-0.5899982452392578,
0.010341971181333065,
0.7917502522468567,
0.5925915837287903,
0.2593855559825897,
0.32228735089302063,
0.408517062664032,
-0.006086348555982113,
-0.15226377546787262,
0.4642029404640198,
1.0096756219863892,
-0.2709341049194336,
0.18898384273052216,
-0.21531228721141815,
-0.007909594103693962,
-0.5342254042625427,
-0.5789958238601685,
-0.4067656397819519,
-0.6693723201751709,
-0.17558223009109497,
-0.1189916804432869,
0.09388716518878937,
0.8788477182388306,
0.20181122422218323,
-0.703352153301239,
0.05349939689040184,
0.14635111391544342,
0.4334460198879242,
-0.13676705956459045,
-0.18071652948856354,
0.27257317304611206,
-0.5207865238189697,
-0.6898115873336792,
0.12693428993225098,
0.5968670845031738,
0.1687384396791458,
0.05257030203938484,
0.35922887921333313,
-0.3320126533508301,
0.002836894243955612,
0.7061546444892883,
0.40711531043052673,
-0.6250214576721191,
-0.2116212099790573,
0.44357845187187195,
-0.06296835094690323,
-0.0340212918817997,
0.6585480570793152,
-0.693151593208313,
0.21934525668621063,
0.3876587152481079,
0.6839768886566162,
0.2413564771413803,
0.41392073035240173,
0.3497591018676758,
-0.9420716762542725,
0.141389861702919,
0.9983262419700623,
0.11545465141534805,
0.06985440850257874,
-0.6577568650245667,
0.4117153286933899,
0.002479389775544405,
-0.5995358824729919,
-0.6426854729652405,
0.278562068939209,
-0.7288134098052979,
-0.3879413902759552,
0.9435480237007141,
0.07489646971225739,
-0.12760736048221588,
-0.3605108857154846,
-0.45301300287246704,
-0.10541913658380508,
-0.22571061551570892,
0.6486242413520813,
0.6685115694999695,
-0.2874285876750946,
-0.6576014757156372,
-0.6086330413818359,
0.5243867039680481,
0.8176572918891907,
-0.87177973985672,
0.007384998723864555,
0.2108718305826187,
-0.14541415870189667,
0.177409365773201,
0.6843715310096741,
0.15796956419944763,
0.4832044541835785,
-0.40371954441070557,
-0.20936709642410278,
0.21551252901554108,
-0.211996391415596,
0.028340112417936325,
0.5481244921684265,
0.2672928273677826,
-0.159561425447464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10887v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10887v1
|
Search Beyond Queries: Training Smaller Language Models for Web Interactions via Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-04-16T20:15:32 | 2024-04-16T20:15:32 |
Moghis Fereidouni, A. B. Siddique
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Traditional search systems focus on query formulation for effective results
but face challenges in scenarios such as product searches where crucial product
details (e.g., size, color) remain concealed until users visit specific product
pages. This highlights the need for intelligent web navigation agents capable
of formulating queries and navigating web pages according to users' high-level
intents. In response to this need, this work introduces a Grounded Language
Agent for Intelligent Web Interactions, called GLAINTEL. Drawing upon
advancements in language modeling and reinforcement learning, GLAINTEL
investigates the efficacy of transformer-based models in enhancing the search
capabilities of interactive web environments. Given the dynamic action space
for each state in web navigation, GLAINTEL employs the Flan-T5 architecture and
incorporates language modeling and value estimation heads. This work focuses on
training smaller language models as agents across various scenarios,
systematically evaluating the impact of human demonstrations on the training
process. Specifically, we investigate scenarios where no human demonstrations
are available and subsequently assess the effective utilization of such
demonstrations. We also explore unsupervised domain adaptation for situations
where demonstrations are confined to a specific domain. Experimental
evaluations across diverse setups demonstrate the effectiveness of training
agents in unsupervised settings, outperforming in-context learning-based
approaches that employ larger models with up to 540 billion parameters.
Surprisingly, behavioral cloning-based methods that straightforwardly use human
demonstrations do not outperform unsupervised learning-based methods.
Additionally, combining human demonstrations with Reinforcement Learning-based
training yields results comparable to models utilizing GPT-4.
|
[
-0.517768144607544,
-0.6075457334518433,
0.6078956127166748,
-0.03877852484583855,
-0.005566672421991825,
0.12874284386634827,
-0.3835216164588928,
-0.4049117863178253,
0.10057790577411652,
0.24458442628383636,
-0.7246870398521423,
-0.3174375295639038,
-0.29489031434059143,
-0.27089911699295044,
-0.4389708936214447,
0.4861648380756378,
0.21084803342819214,
-0.11728480458259583,
-0.3112058937549591,
-0.03984599933028221,
-0.18099138140678406,
-0.5623766183853149,
-0.8194203972816467,
-0.4364916682243347,
0.4234181046485901,
0.3707582354545593,
0.8321422338485718,
0.09939403086900711,
0.07556044310331345,
0.3830725848674774,
0.2178986370563507,
0.3197063207626343,
-0.5604321956634521,
0.032291803508996964,
-0.6162749528884888,
-0.5022518038749695,
-0.06264597922563553,
0.12485745549201965,
0.39218851923942566,
0.6903287768363953,
-0.258523166179657,
-0.2661608159542084,
-0.0728950947523117,
0.4449705481529236,
-0.6576370000839233,
0.2473505437374115,
-0.626581072807312,
0.006354203447699547,
0.26804086565971375,
-0.11829590797424316,
-0.6489159464836121,
-0.37258514761924744,
0.4259893298149109,
-0.9463393688201904,
0.3339194357395172,
0.2143883854150772,
0.8742058277130127,
0.2437356859445572,
-0.6064861416816711,
-0.30821532011032104,
-0.7174274325370789,
0.9944666624069214,
-0.5781742334365845,
0.6707143187522888,
0.474242627620697,
0.526012659072876,
-0.52483731508255,
-1.0686235427856445,
-0.6786096692085266,
-0.6218529343605042,
-0.2650911509990692,
0.14184360206127167,
-0.3775164783000946,
0.11798004060983658,
0.3155252933502197,
0.014510325156152248,
-0.460685133934021,
0.16488902270793915,
-0.23560971021652222,
-0.16033779084682465,
0.4941715896129608,
0.041853103786706924,
0.49195730686187744,
0.07623694092035294,
-0.14497946202754974,
-0.49236711859703064,
-0.46847763657569885,
0.2763345539569855,
0.16816776990890503,
0.31987425684928894,
0.14550594985485077,
0.24409453570842743,
-0.3733152151107788,
0.5015716552734375,
0.30697524547576904,
0.04565804451704025,
-0.018374165520071983,
0.04829231649637222,
-0.20611871778964996,
-0.18730680644512177,
0.5315662026405334,
0.13657690584659576,
0.22147923707962036,
-0.34857872128486633,
-0.27465134859085083,
-0.03120262362062931,
0.8162375688552856,
-0.9621392488479614,
-0.4048253297805786,
0.03772682324051857,
-0.4673624038696289,
-0.30291441082954407,
0.1349024623632431,
-0.6753697395324707,
-0.4626295268535614,
-0.3694923520088196,
0.6632739901542664,
-0.4366840422153473,
-0.36042317748069763,
0.13523456454277039,
-0.2840224802494049,
0.340181827545166,
0.5170944333076477,
-0.9725219011306763,
0.7239456176757812,
0.4320544898509979,
0.5194779634475708,
-0.22664712369441986,
-0.33694660663604736,
-0.690908670425415,
0.071818508207798,
-0.34494033455848694,
0.550452470779419,
-0.6801042556762695,
-0.5730852484703064,
0.2850393056869507,
0.2757437527179718,
-0.33299922943115234,
-0.6918381452560425,
0.3709764778614044,
-1.0862889289855957,
0.2612864077091217,
-0.04428919404745102,
-0.6069108843803406,
-0.6062932014465332,
0.3382413685321808,
-0.8209535479545593,
0.8289979100227356,
0.12133347988128662,
-0.3119356334209442,
0.24371404945850372,
-0.904332160949707,
-0.6394148468971252,
-0.10720458626747131,
-0.15438297390937805,
-0.19624735414981842,
0.143976628780365,
0.3491438329219818,
0.245191290974617,
-0.17638196051120758,
-0.11461081355810165,
-0.1948857307434082,
-0.4407830238342285,
0.24157612025737762,
-0.3751753568649292,
0.3892444670200348,
-0.2384626567363739,
-0.7103796601295471,
0.2756519615650177,
-0.6085312962532043,
0.24875377118587494,
0.29989108443260193,
-0.36402738094329834,
-0.4386027157306671,
0.18061159551143646,
-0.0537886917591095,
0.29630374908447266,
-0.02767663076519966,
-0.25402647256851196,
0.3932894170284271,
-0.552629828453064,
0.3639693856239319,
0.4246162176132202,
0.15896601974964142,
0.6717880368232727,
-0.2187076061964035,
0.6788080334663391,
-0.21603265404701233,
0.3409399092197418,
0.13528256118297577,
-0.36171093583106995,
-0.9200611114501953,
0.10755614191293716,
0.16838502883911133,
0.3378690481185913,
-1.210814118385315,
-0.1495477259159088,
-0.5056187510490417,
-0.42831555008888245,
-0.22431239485740662,
-0.0010724179446697235,
0.40446069836616516,
0.3111869692802429,
0.7072136998176575,
-0.23745465278625488,
-0.2945043742656708,
-0.7521229982376099,
-0.07953465729951859,
-0.14254842698574066,
-0.18043388426303864,
0.3802243769168854,
0.5442060232162476,
-0.4088420271873474,
1.0650005340576172,
-0.3491199314594269,
-0.26718220114707947,
-0.42226189374923706,
0.2795701324939728,
-0.08142594993114471,
0.400836318731308,
0.5199555158615112,
-1.1361430883407593,
-0.45414865016937256,
0.2480224221944809,
-0.6149558424949646,
0.33615541458129883,
-0.014571674168109894,
-0.0070262192748487,
0.21945810317993164,
0.5517148375511169,
-0.7709167003631592,
0.6668186783790588,
0.31955385208129883,
0.34406715631484985,
0.39387986063957214,
-0.3113436996936798,
0.1818506419658661,
-0.5832741260528564,
-0.0701107382774353,
0.12746594846248627,
-0.31877049803733826,
-0.8445314764976501,
0.2072611004114151,
0.14855852723121643,
-0.17217224836349487,
-0.5948768258094788,
0.901739776134491,
-0.5497403144836426,
-0.22301626205444336,
-0.39136338233947754,
0.2773881256580353,
0.14704465866088867,
0.8177293539047241,
0.17104791104793549,
1.079004168510437,
0.22614644467830658,
-0.8511457443237305,
0.2690106928348541,
0.3059563934803009,
-0.008706235326826572,
0.36579394340515137,
-0.5479148626327515,
0.20766769349575043,
0.2319481372833252,
0.34205520153045654,
-0.6439409255981445,
-0.36648184061050415,
0.05224050581455231,
-0.3253508508205414,
0.2742849290370941,
-0.4611646234989166,
-0.38434553146362305,
-0.44179853796958923,
-0.39876309037208557,
0.17362888157367706,
0.6993768811225891,
-0.8568272590637207,
0.7781002521514893,
0.12477288395166397,
0.05423906072974205,
-0.27757832407951355,
-0.3149099349975586,
0.051301635801792145,
-0.13934217393398285,
-0.5695896744728088,
0.41199639439582825,
0.09572555124759674,
-0.10280928760766983,
-0.10555865615606308,
-0.07282289862632751,
-0.17293958365917206,
0.19776952266693115,
0.23405131697654724,
-0.06178605929017067,
-0.17026884853839874,
0.2942116856575012,
0.08779402822256088,
0.04712023586034775,
0.059056222438812256,
-0.7175351977348328,
0.59182208776474,
-0.25721874833106995,
-0.730678141117096,
-0.4869312345981598,
0.19750651717185974,
0.39797544479370117,
-0.22961701452732086,
0.5994316935539246,
0.5846459865570068,
-0.3662616014480591,
-0.2851521670818329,
-0.4542439579963684,
-0.47053036093711853,
-0.5740338563919067,
0.24007903039455414,
-0.33491286635398865,
-0.7878451943397522,
0.3592308759689331,
-0.4758470058441162,
-0.32274699211120605,
0.25500473380088806,
0.28318795561790466,
-0.14605797827243805,
1.173654556274414,
0.8732589483261108,
0.09926285594701767,
0.5598828196525574,
-0.34549614787101746,
0.16307424008846283,
-0.5985193252563477,
-0.23462820053100586,
-0.2292260378599167,
-0.4052804708480835,
-0.6314281821250916,
-0.49542200565338135,
0.4008289575576782,
0.12416181713342667,
-0.24784131348133087,
0.19874683022499084,
-0.12649832665920258,
0.4105490446090698,
0.9406027793884277,
0.23872916400432587,
0.15593348443508148,
0.16423770785331726,
-0.36575430631637573,
-0.04340842738747597,
-0.7006170153617859,
-0.27585071325302124,
0.7919912934303284,
0.012433141469955444,
0.8116248250007629,
0.3487517833709717,
0.3746494650840759,
0.47436293959617615,
0.3547378480434418,
-0.9377434849739075,
0.5291264653205872,
0.0947045385837555,
-0.46800073981285095,
-0.6293859481811523,
-0.17081697285175323,
-1.0555012226104736,
0.4572778046131134,
0.05584334209561348,
-0.8696441054344177,
0.26207712292671204,
0.157632514834404,
-0.16066256165504456,
0.2237141877412796,
-0.625232994556427,
0.9297574162483215,
-0.4846526086330414,
-0.5884775519371033,
-0.5450187921524048,
-0.5966411232948303,
0.12858013808727264,
0.1664416342973709,
0.04760589078068733,
0.45946258306503296,
0.0018521054880693555,
0.2404356300830841,
-0.5022155046463013,
0.9590119123458862,
-0.4676484167575836,
-0.007066015154123306,
0.11258965730667114,
0.23243758082389832,
0.6801701188087463,
-0.14412112534046173,
0.15229345858097076,
-0.31744909286499023,
-0.25433018803596497,
-0.43774163722991943,
-0.9659616947174072,
0.5176686644554138,
-0.6550055742263794,
-0.7702975273132324,
-0.247966468334198,
-0.026784438639879227,
-0.6036503314971924,
0.19700318574905396,
-0.022754445672035217,
0.46617403626441956,
-0.36569589376449585,
0.2345585823059082,
0.8463418483734131,
-0.47283345460891724,
0.44423186779022217,
0.6294326782226562,
-0.46009311079978943,
-0.19912876188755035,
1.111894130706787,
-0.31163594126701355,
0.33904027938842773,
0.5961158275604248,
0.20176036655902863,
-0.5599309802055359,
-0.41599369049072266,
-0.4995180666446686,
-0.010199672542512417,
-0.8172873854637146,
0.06292768567800522,
-0.5855541229248047,
-0.27920132875442505,
-0.0637085884809494,
-0.12802278995513916,
-0.19833038747310638,
-0.3058093786239624,
-0.24232718348503113,
-0.1096063107252121,
0.24025709927082062,
0.734321653842926,
0.013385101221501827,
0.5084192752838135,
-0.6031769514083862,
0.195308119058609,
0.8841277360916138,
0.12244140356779099,
0.42789605259895325,
-0.38233280181884766,
-0.3631752133369446,
0.11309613287448883,
-0.2826288044452667,
-0.6539022326469421,
0.39389723539352417,
0.2809317708015442,
0.8738672733306885,
0.30303114652633667,
0.05517598241567612,
0.4794403314590454,
-0.538780927658081,
0.8224364519119263,
0.017455600202083588,
-0.9176084399223328,
0.5973443984985352,
-0.5005030035972595,
0.0808749794960022,
0.45278868079185486,
0.6659044623374939,
-0.5215774178504944,
0.03923002630472183,
-0.5458059906959534,
-0.7883561849594116,
0.8101171851158142,
0.1319345235824585,
0.13563060760498047,
0.11653713136911392,
0.20519398152828217,
-0.062156978994607925,
0.41439419984817505,
-0.40204447507858276,
0.07424645125865936,
-0.46323123574256897,
0.07019232213497162,
0.11906580626964569,
0.06334244459867477,
-0.06198538467288017,
-0.24841006100177765,
0.9288524985313416,
-0.5515333414077759,
0.21578100323677063,
-0.0018110891105607152,
-0.713977575302124,
0.14501988887786865,
0.2414007931947708,
0.8007282614707947,
0.5738614201545715,
-0.026109930127859116,
-0.04040662199258804,
0.27431437373161316,
-0.375690758228302,
0.23954209685325623,
0.18966272473335266,
-0.06088969483971596,
-0.13957418501377106,
0.13079163432121277,
0.8807770609855652,
0.5801336765289307,
-0.8211855888366699,
0.7068886160850525,
-0.38155996799468994,
-0.04603300243616104,
-0.4264310300350189,
0.23420082032680511,
0.14573881030082703,
0.4299871325492859,
0.4794481694698334,
-0.22507429122924805,
0.3712862432003021,
-0.47412216663360596,
0.2486417442560196,
0.4546262323856354,
-0.6157065033912659,
-0.4208064675331116,
0.6871310472488403,
0.22714412212371826,
-0.30746638774871826,
0.702338457107544,
-0.4247567653656006,
-0.6932680010795593,
0.5035330653190613,
0.303958535194397,
0.8174717426300049,
-0.15045057237148285,
0.4407517910003662,
-0.01991530880331993,
0.24527765810489655,
-0.23522092401981354,
-0.05459290370345116,
-0.15141458809375763,
-0.5836372375488281,
-0.24250556528568268,
-0.39448440074920654,
-0.7439237833023071,
0.1353384405374527,
-0.6147603392601013,
0.02156549133360386,
-0.423220157623291,
-0.022998329252004623,
-0.09095010906457901,
0.10012781620025635,
-0.8759533166885376,
0.28546959161758423,
-0.07365185022354126,
0.8594228029251099,
-0.4977957606315613,
0.9465712308883667,
0.8696054816246033,
-0.7599599957466125,
-0.7785788774490356,
0.20293721556663513,
-0.008911823853850365,
-0.6788266897201538,
0.750290036201477,
0.17148201167583466,
-0.4019313454627991,
0.1291431039571762,
-0.5713083744049072,
-0.6810215711593628,
1.1463406085968018,
0.2729039788246155,
-0.1711384356021881,
-0.15124225616455078,
0.0990799143910408,
0.7128598093986511,
-0.13061515986919403,
0.4157659709453583,
0.47092774510383606,
0.43727198243141174,
-0.014848530292510986,
-0.8739308714866638,
-0.0536164864897728,
-0.21442990005016327,
0.11477658897638321,
-0.07731922715902328,
-0.7571679353713989,
0.5956097841262817,
0.05135683715343475,
-0.16473795473575592,
0.3096388578414917,
0.5475060939788818,
-0.026692600920796394,
0.08761440962553024,
0.5760283470153809,
0.26773107051849365,
0.8123088479042053,
0.009831169620156288,
1.115496039390564,
0.03473799675703049,
0.27952811121940613,
1.080885410308838,
-0.50504070520401,
0.8777947425842285,
0.3560086190700531,
-0.11730372905731201,
0.7352067828178406,
0.41204261779785156,
0.28498002886772156,
0.6396777629852295,
0.23215563595294952,
-0.34517204761505127,
-0.47309842705726624,
-0.18662986159324646,
-0.08502250164747238,
0.3272021412849426,
0.5147918462753296,
-0.027252839878201485,
-0.27107080817222595,
0.28109386563301086,
-0.1822119504213333,
0.3188510239124298,
-0.19536103308200836,
0.8863874673843384,
-0.023276356980204582,
-0.5676913261413574,
0.5223972797393799,
0.1293191760778427,
0.4943181276321411,
-0.6834346652030945,
-0.12814192473888397,
-0.3826175928115845,
0.2592554986476898,
-0.05403667315840721,
-0.37143364548683167,
-0.21241576969623566,
-0.2898551821708679,
-0.1634192168712616,
-0.21669717133045197,
0.9403918981552124,
-0.17420898377895355,
-0.12171725928783417,
0.548983097076416,
0.667677104473114,
0.011729546822607517,
-0.2709748148918152,
-0.5256032347679138,
-0.15289388597011566,
-0.079827219247818,
-0.4303274154663086,
0.589751660823822,
0.43270644545555115,
-0.42716893553733826,
0.8959121704101562,
0.6339219808578491,
-0.38281410932540894,
0.22356857359409332,
0.3885791003704071,
1.0546960830688477,
-0.6101436614990234,
-0.4935852289199829,
-0.42822396755218506,
0.3982185125350952,
-0.23846082389354706,
0.2606804668903351,
0.5174655318260193,
0.4365958273410797,
0.8622040748596191,
-0.24392084777355194,
0.9794585108757019,
0.26674166321754456,
0.42274904251098633,
-0.6732039451599121,
0.5826758742332458,
-0.7715878486633301,
-0.07948841154575348,
0.011850074864923954,
-0.694356381893158,
0.0017026050481945276,
0.631627082824707,
-0.43702057003974915,
0.2599392533302307,
0.5916765332221985,
0.6956708431243896,
-0.5919439792633057,
0.16673380136489868,
0.5564037561416626,
-0.03737013787031174,
0.6743478178977966,
0.28792262077331543,
1.143720269203186,
-0.22606025636196136,
0.6284047961235046,
-0.07930967211723328,
0.03368067741394043,
-0.5921640992164612,
-0.6921229958534241,
-1.080675482749939,
-0.37724146246910095,
0.05718443915247917,
-0.05864865332841873,
0.2622486352920532,
0.9876437187194824,
0.9386491179466248,
-0.7547305822372437,
-0.1408081352710724,
-0.059652164578437805,
-0.004310054238885641,
-0.3043455481529236,
-0.24877627193927765,
0.19739051163196564,
-0.4603520631790161,
-0.725875198841095,
0.8469855785369873,
0.18315795063972473,
0.11763094365596771,
-0.41825172305107117,
-0.2501817047595978,
-0.25579798221588135,
0.09024127572774887,
0.5783748626708984,
0.6009733080863953,
-0.7999403476715088,
-0.6183921098709106,
0.1618274301290512,
-0.02123452164232731,
0.03612203523516655,
0.7942105531692505,
-1.1690598726272583,
0.30737972259521484,
0.04784757271409035,
1.0135071277618408,
0.8717814087867737,
0.04932297393679619,
0.6262784600257874,
-0.9541101455688477,
0.22497715055942535,
0.18545380234718323,
0.13718627393245697,
0.37784141302108765,
-0.08983223885297775,
0.48534077405929565,
0.06656501442193985,
-0.32992076873779297,
-0.3778671324253082,
0.3452039659023285,
-0.7295759320259094,
-0.24495169520378113,
1.0722239017486572,
-0.0778849646449089,
-0.05284916236996651,
-0.04180486127734184,
-0.22350597381591797,
0.005323110613971949,
-0.47205615043640137,
0.6965835690498352,
0.4628034234046936,
-0.1762859970331192,
-0.15967442095279694,
-0.8773212432861328,
0.6182244420051575,
0.3087177574634552,
-0.8204626441001892,
-0.2891359329223633,
0.44802311062812805,
0.13079974055290222,
0.231203094124794,
0.3841078281402588,
0.4273208975791931,
0.39722079038619995,
-0.1736949384212494,
0.07810519635677338,
0.017769161611795425,
-0.3891545236110687,
-0.3138701021671295,
0.11327867954969406,
0.21636539697647095,
-0.15112778544425964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10877v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10877v2
|
Incubating Text Classifiers Following User Instruction with Nothing but LLM
| 2024-04-16T19:53:35 | 2024-05-20T07:42:53 |
Letian Peng, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we aim to generate text classification data given arbitrary
class definitions (i.e., user instruction), so one can train a small text
classifier without any human annotation or raw corpus. Compared with pioneer
attempts, our proposed Incubator is the first framework that can handle
complicated and even mutually dependent classes (e.g., "TED Talk given by
Educator" and "Other"). Specifically, Incubator is an LLM firstly tuned on the
instruction-to-data mappings that we obtained from classification datasets and
descriptions on HuggingFace together with in-context augmentation by GPT-4. We
then refine Incubator by learning on the cluster centers of semantic textual
embeddings to emphasize the uniformity and semantic diversity in generations.
We compare Incubator on various classification tasks with strong baselines such
as direct LLM-based inference and training data generation by prompt
engineering. Experiments show Incubator is able to (1) perform well on
traditional benchmarks, (2) take label dependency and user preference into
consideration, and (3) enable logical text mining by incubating multiple
classifiers.
|
[
-0.23833630979061127,
-0.4764936864376068,
0.34598055481910706,
0.12742145359516144,
0.024275770410895348,
-0.04326912760734558,
-0.28140491247177124,
-0.40866178274154663,
-0.05683417245745659,
0.2381221204996109,
-0.3931381404399872,
-0.5050236582756042,
-0.4926786720752716,
0.3149557411670685,
-0.5160163640975952,
1.1662018299102783,
0.15890085697174072,
-0.1912844479084015,
-0.46938952803611755,
0.13069577515125275,
-0.30673080682754517,
-0.6235693097114563,
-0.5380752682685852,
-0.32052090764045715,
0.3691716492176056,
0.6507925391197205,
0.28071990609169006,
0.7373170852661133,
-0.007796645630151033,
0.2593342959880829,
0.12402518838644028,
-0.08932214230298996,
-0.3872372508049011,
0.12122291326522827,
0.27238598465919495,
-0.32089027762413025,
0.20104877650737762,
-0.11208934336900711,
0.6050571203231812,
0.7998395562171936,
-0.08128312975168228,
0.02030886523425579,
0.31330037117004395,
0.29884859919548035,
-0.44166550040245056,
0.20998436212539673,
-0.7619484066963196,
0.2866029441356659,
-0.33042314648628235,
-0.3578375577926636,
-0.7123239040374756,
-0.27113160490989685,
0.2048787772655487,
-0.41343554854393005,
0.3705151379108429,
-0.013989623636007309,
0.6428533792495728,
0.25612014532089233,
-0.37241172790527344,
-0.42080190777778625,
-0.5969695448875427,
0.7247181534767151,
-0.2822819650173187,
0.309920072555542,
-0.04318830743432045,
0.16760313510894775,
-0.2765178382396698,
-1.0106087923049927,
-0.6998339295387268,
-0.1433376520872116,
-0.20278461277484894,
0.1362287551164627,
0.09144329279661179,
0.05475102365016937,
0.3043776750564575,
0.1482728272676468,
-0.31623828411102295,
0.2735503613948822,
-0.3651062548160553,
-0.04491649195551872,
0.2960064113140106,
0.02116796188056469,
0.5150541067123413,
-0.12955783307552338,
-0.8681648373603821,
-0.027198726311326027,
-0.5373846292495728,
0.10835602134466171,
0.2977210581302643,
0.34924277663230896,
-0.11952005326747894,
0.5926942229270935,
-0.017102694138884544,
0.5420668125152588,
0.037715405225753784,
-0.042063429951667786,
0.48848262429237366,
0.0017565302550792694,
-0.3089950382709503,
0.4124649465084076,
0.8755366802215576,
-0.13448521494865417,
0.07862440496683121,
-0.3168867826461792,
-0.20137876272201538,
0.2355700433254242,
0.32109618186950684,
-0.9919823408126831,
-0.31150317192077637,
-0.015361502766609192,
-0.21391579508781433,
-0.5712738633155823,
0.1717744618654251,
-0.8622978925704956,
-0.32537487149238586,
-0.17504596710205078,
0.5121403932571411,
-0.34177905321121216,
0.1650373786687851,
-0.0034925267100334167,
-0.01717054471373558,
0.4752020537853241,
0.3074864447116852,
-1.1774934530258179,
0.4474150538444519,
0.6598924994468689,
0.5592292547225952,
-0.33053937554359436,
-0.35968777537345886,
-0.46017828583717346,
0.00436367467045784,
-0.10678330063819885,
0.8906084299087524,
-0.6090822219848633,
-0.4980250597000122,
0.07447241246700287,
-0.31201860308647156,
-0.19958114624023438,
-0.2763391435146332,
0.5111981630325317,
-0.41447973251342773,
0.6135367155075073,
0.06949333101511002,
-1.1098833084106445,
-0.17093542218208313,
0.08664597570896149,
-0.2916922867298126,
1.1669591665267944,
0.1518448293209076,
-1.0195212364196777,
0.6215404272079468,
-0.720538854598999,
-0.517731785774231,
0.45308881998062134,
-0.7246021628379822,
-0.38501033186912537,
-0.24449250102043152,
-0.07692365348339081,
0.6205140352249146,
0.018739812076091766,
0.010973867028951645,
-0.011618304997682571,
-0.4142689108848572,
0.2281232625246048,
-0.17925363779067993,
0.7687737941741943,
-0.10662411898374557,
-0.5644621849060059,
0.05408177152276039,
-0.9105321168899536,
0.02944580465555191,
0.15650862455368042,
-0.6110448837280273,
-0.17472857236862183,
-0.1132241040468216,
0.13511395454406738,
-0.0006052637472748756,
0.19726763665676117,
-0.5984645485877991,
0.37128233909606934,
-0.27172142267227173,
0.46029558777809143,
0.7159044146537781,
0.10881035774946213,
0.44422483444213867,
-0.5438094735145569,
0.44393157958984375,
-0.10245471447706223,
-0.13506360352039337,
-0.45037561655044556,
-0.6210636496543884,
-1.1774147748947144,
-0.38467827439308167,
0.27785706520080566,
0.5403218865394592,
-0.6161866784095764,
0.6634870767593384,
-0.29054877161979675,
-0.3820786774158478,
-0.37017500400543213,
0.321798712015152,
0.2372933030128479,
0.5781844258308411,
0.3160252571105957,
0.2481275200843811,
-0.5872727632522583,
-0.5358927845954895,
0.16764850914478302,
0.01340988464653492,
0.07141148298978806,
0.14917421340942383,
0.325307160615921,
-0.5291078090667725,
0.8422092199325562,
-0.2623556852340698,
-0.08113636076450348,
-0.32095497846603394,
0.11106325685977936,
0.0638413280248642,
0.41795119643211365,
0.4024134874343872,
-0.6914198398590088,
-0.35416179895401,
-0.10256726294755936,
-0.9847162961959839,
-0.04090573638677597,
-0.06881345063447952,
-0.010665316134691238,
0.3089308440685272,
0.7084987759590149,
-0.4138292074203491,
0.40019330382347107,
0.1223694458603859,
-0.023314066231250763,
0.3387302756309509,
-0.11059562861919403,
-0.17366662621498108,
-0.8641002774238586,
-0.32044875621795654,
-0.1524352729320526,
-0.16035011410713196,
-0.7457764148712158,
-0.0590999536216259,
0.13702604174613953,
-0.12178125232458115,
-0.41469961404800415,
0.6633303761482239,
-0.1836339235305786,
0.29048284888267517,
-0.42198437452316284,
0.0018329382874071598,
-0.14155812561511993,
0.2819570004940033,
0.09129004180431366,
0.6672465801239014,
0.36386507749557495,
-0.8525769710540771,
-0.09778691083192825,
0.4172859787940979,
-0.15120525658130646,
0.21733474731445312,
-0.26048851013183594,
0.3219965398311615,
-0.08482933044433594,
0.21724636852741241,
-0.8970179557800293,
-0.4134557247161865,
0.3431069850921631,
-0.4470197558403015,
0.3563019335269928,
0.01987418532371521,
-0.6656419038772583,
-0.3585277199745178,
-0.40287911891937256,
0.12983745336532593,
0.6708351373672485,
-1.000490427017212,
0.35472604632377625,
0.0736810714006424,
-0.05182696133852005,
-0.28095582127571106,
-0.5884870886802673,
-0.16681073606014252,
-0.20488236844539642,
-0.36504247784614563,
0.11774224787950516,
-0.17626312375068665,
0.10114908218383789,
0.08326857537031174,
0.056750405579805374,
-0.04098103567957878,
0.08868100494146347,
0.4938673675060272,
0.3432554006576538,
-0.1776905059814453,
0.6805498600006104,
0.32118162512779236,
-0.3552819490432739,
-0.050158239901065826,
-0.4290858507156372,
0.32465019822120667,
-0.16360719501972198,
-0.17183832824230194,
-0.4386584758758545,
0.03620476275682449,
0.10585781186819077,
0.2464112490415573,
0.6699577569961548,
0.46061572432518005,
-0.4644619822502136,
-0.5563061237335205,
-0.40435314178466797,
-0.21900305151939392,
-0.4903506934642792,
-0.1411210298538208,
-0.3755258023738861,
-1.1005313396453857,
-0.041442953050136566,
-0.004983624443411827,
0.04110568016767502,
0.2776942253112793,
0.5196380615234375,
-0.12339318543672562,
0.3980676531791687,
1.0483003854751587,
0.06507176905870438,
0.30614936351776123,
0.029945870861411095,
0.040281012654304504,
-0.5835950970649719,
-0.3040178418159485,
-0.5518835186958313,
-0.3032209873199463,
-0.6613320708274841,
-0.03351892530918121,
0.21017789840698242,
-0.07795022428035736,
-0.3481622636318207,
0.1644233912229538,
-0.8297655582427979,
0.408464640378952,
0.6855124235153198,
0.09651666134595871,
0.24094974994659424,
0.09347406029701233,
-0.22966967523097992,
-0.1281522512435913,
-0.7815080881118774,
-0.6662397384643555,
1.2292355298995972,
0.0813845843076706,
0.6405538320541382,
-0.34445735812187195,
1.1596754789352417,
0.2057458758354187,
0.6553869247436523,
-0.7643890380859375,
0.4996759295463562,
-0.126023069024086,
-0.3726033568382263,
0.026858076453208923,
-0.5423582196235657,
-0.9709428548812866,
0.2609906792640686,
-0.3359426259994507,
-0.7142336964607239,
0.02354678325355053,
-0.09662976115942001,
-0.35453277826309204,
0.2083982676267624,
-0.9343187212944031,
0.6798242926597595,
-0.3916037678718567,
-0.04806095361709595,
0.44899627566337585,
-0.6451438069343567,
0.38729363679885864,
-0.12440928816795349,
0.24747218191623688,
0.08513618260622025,
-0.2801254391670227,
0.903114378452301,
-0.4351850152015686,
1.0657222270965576,
-0.3645328879356384,
0.19044438004493713,
0.24756325781345367,
-0.10512015223503113,
0.07667316496372223,
-0.09061550348997116,
0.027398731559515,
-0.032304853200912476,
-0.11723646521568298,
-0.3024807274341583,
-0.426278680562973,
0.6846280097961426,
-0.9429470896720886,
-0.3610992729663849,
-0.6412757039070129,
-0.17077569663524628,
-0.21765011548995972,
0.32053306698799133,
0.5423458814620972,
0.16061459481716156,
0.00025111623108386993,
0.2768377661705017,
0.7392690777778625,
-0.3419530689716339,
0.4014751613140106,
0.37549152970314026,
-0.3328458070755005,
-0.39737194776535034,
0.923332929611206,
-0.0038854689337313175,
0.0711076408624649,
0.5233764052391052,
0.4679408669471741,
-0.041920680552721024,
-0.36089736223220825,
-0.5087154507637024,
-0.06191399693489075,
-0.7770692110061646,
-0.41285353899002075,
-0.9594307541847229,
-0.6330299377441406,
0.07185888290405273,
-0.4088340401649475,
-0.06147335469722748,
-0.2994190752506256,
-0.6197255253791809,
-0.323995441198349,
0.5158196091651917,
0.8068251609802246,
0.2294015884399414,
0.6241875886917114,
-0.5539373159408569,
0.1543484330177307,
0.35625752806663513,
0.025677496567368507,
-0.04486219957470894,
-0.40594252943992615,
-0.0021157213486731052,
-0.24547266960144043,
-0.25915443897247314,
-0.4352295398712158,
-0.013407023623585701,
0.32038161158561707,
0.35627830028533936,
0.46541765332221985,
0.08863642066717148,
0.214692160487175,
-0.5356432795524597,
0.6411596536636353,
0.24646693468093872,
-0.7570475935935974,
0.5603699088096619,
-0.06888078153133392,
-0.012751113623380661,
0.6413360238075256,
0.5180719494819641,
-0.24620658159255981,
-0.266137957572937,
-0.7162587642669678,
-0.766292929649353,
0.5827579498291016,
0.21550820767879486,
0.3474499583244324,
-0.10253297537565231,
0.6796796321868896,
0.7337427735328674,
0.33079296350479126,
-0.8583096265792847,
-0.23042455315589905,
-0.18465113639831543,
-0.457360178232193,
0.14858660101890564,
-0.2069447636604309,
0.07027032971382141,
-0.26892533898353577,
0.5143964886665344,
-0.0067411926575005054,
0.3535829782485962,
-0.04417753592133522,
-0.20879873633384705,
0.12272769957780838,
0.3794671893119812,
0.16423146426677704,
0.2711760699748993,
0.01904132403433323,
0.2891824543476105,
0.12291456758975983,
-0.3151151239871979,
0.39844372868537903,
0.17314226925373077,
-0.6143466830253601,
-0.2330055832862854,
0.4695679545402527,
0.5068858861923218,
0.7012786865234375,
-0.5767233967781067,
0.6078939437866211,
-0.2925732135772705,
-0.09361667186021805,
-0.21087504923343658,
0.4611532986164093,
-0.02063305489718914,
0.005982609000056982,
0.2996571362018585,
0.039572250097990036,
0.0911564826965332,
-0.09057211130857468,
0.4855089485645294,
0.2758241295814514,
-0.2763802707195282,
-0.21555297076702118,
0.6414151191711426,
0.12494412064552307,
-0.059672076255083084,
0.3627123236656189,
-0.5264315605163574,
-0.4459770917892456,
0.3808854818344116,
0.7921398282051086,
0.8430120944976807,
-0.029334653168916702,
0.23180799186229706,
0.07058320939540863,
0.29909661412239075,
0.047020986676216125,
0.16265197098255157,
-0.3065422475337982,
-0.8440465331077576,
-0.07548601925373077,
-0.8637948632240295,
-0.6246594786643982,
0.0179019533097744,
-0.5072640776634216,
0.4664454162120819,
-0.7752059102058411,
0.3093041777610779,
0.05926811322569847,
0.084775909781456,
-0.8682323694229126,
0.15580031275749207,
0.08849015086889267,
0.8137505054473877,
-0.6507988572120667,
0.7422306537628174,
0.8311054110527039,
-0.31383296847343445,
-0.49247363209724426,
0.04815034568309784,
-0.08311884850263596,
-0.7645999789237976,
0.5259724855422974,
0.7627718448638916,
-0.08739499002695084,
0.2652098834514618,
-0.6790026426315308,
-0.2973441481590271,
0.948674738407135,
0.09665440768003464,
-0.5642321705818176,
0.2876112759113312,
0.015362512320280075,
0.45245206356048584,
-0.540867030620575,
0.12805847823619843,
0.2977481186389923,
0.33460351824760437,
0.22024522721767426,
-0.22632651031017303,
-0.0032352302223443985,
-0.24296674132347107,
0.08928219228982925,
-0.01998060755431652,
-0.5497339963912964,
0.6607670187950134,
-0.19069670140743256,
-0.38240131735801697,
0.30637308955192566,
0.696617603302002,
0.08992300927639008,
0.45781731605529785,
0.39562466740608215,
0.7585235834121704,
0.9215226769447327,
-0.061190903186798096,
1.035083293914795,
-0.14723370969295502,
0.15984319150447845,
1.2633148431777954,
-0.40526703000068665,
0.9161949753761292,
0.2444685995578766,
-0.1508963704109192,
0.6522319912910461,
0.5367113947868347,
-0.01048285048455,
0.2512950003147125,
0.3140963912010193,
-0.49547070264816284,
0.008314209058880806,
0.08050867915153503,
-0.5226782560348511,
0.3800079822540283,
0.24500784277915955,
-0.08756205439567566,
-0.3907449245452881,
0.40924450755119324,
0.24700023233890533,
0.06528652459383011,
0.09668932110071182,
1.0316420793533325,
0.042459502816200256,
-0.15115396678447723,
0.30849745869636536,
0.049696363508701324,
0.8915820717811584,
-0.5205057263374329,
0.10568920522928238,
-0.13705863058567047,
0.17306014895439148,
-0.3789709806442261,
-0.5605544447898865,
-0.16065919399261475,
0.2796856462955475,
-0.2277645319700241,
-0.17194725573062897,
0.810946524143219,
-0.27071768045425415,
-0.6279828548431396,
0.3325560390949249,
0.42488059401512146,
0.1325191706418991,
0.28021156787872314,
-0.206025630235672,
0.12910793721675873,
-0.245052307844162,
-0.24804455041885376,
0.31987568736076355,
0.8282149434089661,
0.285186767578125,
0.47378456592559814,
0.6733555793762207,
-0.23128631711006165,
0.36405909061431885,
-0.09078508615493774,
0.9864639639854431,
-0.7326550483703613,
-0.29911401867866516,
-0.8661144971847534,
0.24405726790428162,
0.2483394891023636,
-0.2746129333972931,
0.8141294121742249,
0.629503071308136,
0.960377037525177,
-0.03380661457777023,
1.2544608116149902,
-0.18156422674655914,
0.40219220519065857,
-0.5245968103408813,
0.5892078280448914,
-0.22594021260738373,
0.20441126823425293,
0.10633521527051926,
-0.8482915163040161,
-0.4758928120136261,
0.6130098104476929,
-0.2211226224899292,
0.22221635282039642,
0.6808171272277832,
0.40551361441612244,
-0.03652775660157204,
0.42340007424354553,
0.030001014471054077,
0.2527725398540497,
0.42025476694107056,
0.32863426208496094,
0.9646929502487183,
-0.20865724980831146,
0.5179056525230408,
-0.3213672637939453,
-0.5881483554840088,
-0.3667222559452057,
-0.8385940790176392,
-1.158030390739441,
-0.27181777358055115,
-0.20700271427631378,
-0.21695835888385773,
-0.029272280633449554,
1.0586190223693848,
0.5238001942634583,
-0.7131426930427551,
-0.09288295358419418,
-0.3596005439758301,
0.12380286306142807,
-0.0015457607805728912,
-0.27843809127807617,
0.1985350102186203,
-0.9971709251403809,
-0.4319755434989929,
0.3466328978538513,
0.29038897156715393,
0.12297819554805756,
-0.1982019990682602,
-0.001976141706109047,
0.018500961363315582,
-0.09156400710344315,
0.5748700499534607,
0.3395349979400635,
-0.25664687156677246,
-0.40716424584388733,
-0.195791557431221,
-0.12854336202144623,
0.31089645624160767,
0.6034952998161316,
-0.9688870906829834,
0.6120508313179016,
0.08682117611169815,
1.0373517274856567,
0.5597238540649414,
-0.2693363130092621,
-0.020900847390294075,
-0.946636974811554,
0.1699255108833313,
0.21066448092460632,
0.1303660124540329,
0.4409756064414978,
-0.44251903891563416,
0.33215251564979553,
0.2939385771751404,
-0.5566258430480957,
-0.6589086651802063,
0.008480883203446865,
-0.9427011013031006,
0.0680587887763977,
0.8879379034042358,
0.01001479011029005,
-0.22501085698604584,
0.1979280710220337,
-0.24746325612068176,
0.13086973130702972,
-0.4887746274471283,
0.8296815156936646,
0.4709188640117645,
-0.34448543190956116,
-0.08034397661685944,
-0.5242879390716553,
0.3664907217025757,
-0.1174534410238266,
-1.3169666528701782,
-0.39903461933135986,
0.12784287333488464,
0.34432539343833923,
0.1337333619594574,
0.523127555847168,
-0.00005186349153518677,
0.002970181405544281,
0.1947055459022522,
0.18000882863998413,
-0.021286895498633385,
-0.4750748872756958,
-0.18675844371318817,
0.32407665252685547,
-0.13176313042640686,
-0.37629440426826477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10859v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10859v1
|
Forcing Diffuse Distributions out of Language Models
| 2024-04-16T19:17:23 | 2024-04-16T19:17:23 |
Yiming Zhang, Avi Schwarzschild, Nicholas Carlini, Zico Kolter, Daphne Ippolito
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Despite being trained specifically to follow user instructions, today's
language models perform poorly when instructed to produce random outputs. For
example, when prompted to pick a number uniformly between one and ten
Llama-2-13B-chat disproportionately favors the number five, and when tasked
with picking a first name at random, Mistral-7B-Instruct chooses Avery 40 times
more often than we would expect based on the U.S. population. When these
language models are used for real-world tasks where diversity of outputs is
crucial, such as language model assisted dataset construction, their inability
to produce diffuse distributions over valid choices is a major hurdle. In this
work, we propose a fine-tuning method that encourages language models to output
distributions that are diffuse over valid outcomes. The methods we introduce
generalize across a variety of tasks and distributions and make large language
models practical for synthetic dataset generation with little human
intervention.
|
[
-0.368821382522583,
-0.6540202498435974,
0.4868234694004059,
0.5196428894996643,
-0.23050464689731598,
-0.11337724328041077,
-0.3772951066493988,
-0.35712504386901855,
-0.24658514559268951,
0.5936028361320496,
-0.49317437410354614,
-0.3768683969974518,
-0.7270336747169495,
0.0199885256588459,
-0.6082146167755127,
1.1592308282852173,
0.16783495247364044,
-0.03761839494109154,
0.13478951156139374,
-0.0858437791466713,
-0.35816124081611633,
-0.3354746997356415,
-0.8241321444511414,
-0.24487851560115814,
0.5860496759414673,
0.4513731002807617,
0.9410961866378784,
0.5793681144714355,
0.3153020739555359,
0.23597607016563416,
-0.06739399582147598,
0.5094513893127441,
-0.8259562849998474,
0.11517578363418579,
-0.26430511474609375,
-0.45650506019592285,
-0.1586889624595642,
-0.0759706050157547,
0.6613603234291077,
1.039711833000183,
-0.4018074870109558,
0.10441654175519943,
0.07083849608898163,
0.5675482749938965,
-0.7046508193016052,
-0.2236955314874649,
-0.8198336958885193,
-0.2234911322593689,
-0.3966485261917114,
0.19091880321502686,
-0.6726297736167908,
-0.3816484212875366,
0.01100127026438713,
-0.4743407964706421,
0.4023391008377075,
-0.049712467938661575,
0.7007179260253906,
0.06603195518255234,
-0.3120582103729248,
-0.21833452582359314,
-1.1622110605239868,
1.0085628032684326,
-0.575541079044342,
0.3467082679271698,
0.685413122177124,
0.26835745573043823,
-0.17317256331443787,
-0.36349382996559143,
-0.4376959204673767,
-0.21100106835365295,
0.13446059823036194,
-0.2447921186685562,
-0.27629488706588745,
0.019719695672392845,
0.1737932711839676,
-0.07439028471708298,
-0.2940775752067566,
0.23220309615135193,
-0.4825774133205414,
-0.05834275111556053,
0.7427853345870972,
0.28510355949401855,
0.20057767629623413,
0.22358493506908417,
0.18321484327316284,
-0.27937546372413635,
-0.8338847160339355,
-0.2502371370792389,
0.720599353313446,
0.5457561612129211,
-0.004131736699491739,
0.5496828556060791,
-0.2794908583164215,
0.8326137661933899,
0.35370704531669617,
0.125911146402359,
0.24261942505836487,
-0.1081659346818924,
-0.356316477060318,
-0.3873234987258911,
0.6100292801856995,
0.061025600880384445,
0.5581141114234924,
-0.04400815814733505,
-0.319901704788208,
-0.01365190651267767,
0.20560428500175476,
-0.5618441700935364,
-0.27211087942123413,
0.25165635347366333,
-0.28561273217201233,
-0.4741944968700409,
-0.1113913357257843,
-0.5821552872657776,
-0.5067071318626404,
-0.2877714931964874,
0.11031123995780945,
-0.48452720046043396,
-0.33594581484794617,
0.29747840762138367,
-0.2582724988460541,
-0.3487239181995392,
0.4953596591949463,
-1.1591802835464478,
0.3536902964115143,
0.3217836618423462,
0.4571065604686737,
-0.22049272060394287,
-0.2694675624370575,
-0.5075403451919556,
0.25431737303733826,
-0.5081433653831482,
0.8835201263427734,
-0.8401671648025513,
-0.4832054376602173,
-0.07069440931081772,
-0.278028666973114,
0.13107521831989288,
-0.9446825981140137,
0.11082310974597931,
-0.3531290292739868,
0.097312793135643,
-0.10023266822099686,
-0.5265398621559143,
0.19301582872867584,
-0.22938841581344604,
-0.5539100766181946,
0.8047614097595215,
0.2501189708709717,
-0.661520779132843,
0.6071245074272156,
-0.3201739192008972,
-0.4077953100204468,
-0.038162440061569214,
-0.23459234833717346,
-0.38970938324928284,
0.23740613460540771,
0.15045742690563202,
0.5746606588363647,
-0.09080364555120468,
0.4854583740234375,
-0.5138461589813232,
-0.30271080136299133,
0.15187998116016388,
-0.7704979181289673,
0.8211831450462341,
0.4660719335079193,
-0.05686338245868683,
-0.16318565607070923,
-0.878044605255127,
-0.12143966555595398,
-0.04898058995604515,
-0.4114057123661041,
-0.5160603523254395,
0.1203179731965065,
0.1868484616279602,
-0.0707414522767067,
-0.18941639363765717,
-0.2579590082168579,
0.28216221928596497,
-0.43760567903518677,
0.11006662249565125,
0.8855076432228088,
0.023193228989839554,
0.9483516216278076,
-0.4014279842376709,
0.5182126760482788,
0.24151651561260223,
0.19034019112586975,
0.39491310715675354,
-0.5266911387443542,
-0.46979427337646484,
-0.39320001006126404,
0.2872083783149719,
0.4972054958343506,
-0.6587230563163757,
0.34546685218811035,
-0.13163943588733673,
-0.5593225955963135,
-0.5478172302246094,
0.46780529618263245,
0.05364463850855827,
0.2870781421661377,
0.09038963168859482,
-0.028744151815772057,
-0.5716087818145752,
-0.9241237044334412,
-0.22109636664390564,
-0.035069067031145096,
-0.12628184258937836,
0.3032478988170624,
0.12670838832855225,
-0.39386895298957825,
1.0898548364639282,
-0.7009304165840149,
-0.10248187929391861,
-0.5588913559913635,
0.18460142612457275,
0.22801895439624786,
0.4809410870075226,
0.5998173356056213,
-0.8782476782798767,
-0.4161815643310547,
-0.07202424108982086,
-0.24467186629772186,
-0.29433494806289673,
-0.4010023772716522,
-0.4663762152194977,
0.07984452694654465,
0.37564876675605774,
-0.4341292977333069,
0.3657483160495758,
0.5733976364135742,
-0.2520803213119507,
0.38977181911468506,
-0.28722479939460754,
-0.38480469584465027,
-1.0490864515304565,
-0.14095768332481384,
-0.0143305454403162,
-0.20271995663642883,
-0.6517508029937744,
-0.18608158826828003,
-0.022607827559113503,
0.16205473244190216,
-0.46891701221466064,
0.9392232298851013,
-0.33063775300979614,
0.362873911857605,
-0.08677629381418228,
-0.22905658185482025,
-0.2030792087316513,
0.07118069380521774,
0.10456016659736633,
0.4661563038825989,
0.5232309103012085,
-0.7950927019119263,
0.17213955521583557,
0.21746328473091125,
-0.30634254217147827,
0.3499499559402466,
-0.5471802353858948,
-0.22870990633964539,
-0.3901960849761963,
0.3371681272983551,
-0.8716781139373779,
-0.3095923364162445,
0.11259377747774124,
0.013583831489086151,
0.302448570728302,
-0.11611240357160568,
-0.423967182636261,
-0.0033447933383286,
-0.041700731962919235,
0.4737074673175812,
0.6924389600753784,
-0.43782973289489746,
0.2720399796962738,
0.3735550343990326,
-0.0710788443684578,
-0.4821108877658844,
-0.8255590200424194,
-0.2170090228319168,
-0.3285943567752838,
-0.579241156578064,
0.049830809235572815,
-0.3904721736907959,
-0.4959356188774109,
-0.3072148859500885,
0.10837755352258682,
-0.31746819615364075,
0.13053569197654724,
0.1849917769432068,
0.06531098484992981,
0.22731801867485046,
0.2684309184551239,
0.3509043753147125,
0.09303119778633118,
-0.3563927710056305,
-0.15519914031028748,
0.350676953792572,
0.5635345578193665,
-0.5779716968536377,
-0.02423780970275402,
0.5104269981384277,
0.25961071252822876,
0.0512906089425087,
0.8848398327827454,
0.4904879629611969,
-0.18711285293102264,
-0.8477696776390076,
-0.39538300037384033,
-0.22855903208255768,
-0.5178595185279846,
0.47523555159568787,
-0.2786891460418701,
-0.833499014377594,
0.5247063636779785,
-0.15276789665222168,
0.32564792037010193,
0.20716333389282227,
0.7671296000480652,
-0.040469083935022354,
1.2401845455169678,
0.6639820337295532,
0.08020968735218048,
0.7723022699356079,
-0.1940169334411621,
0.165029376745224,
-0.4477006494998932,
0.21256977319717407,
-0.4413849115371704,
-0.24613231420516968,
-0.6024248600006104,
-0.37507203221321106,
0.21572242677211761,
0.04296034947037697,
-0.11099322140216827,
0.09394427388906479,
-0.5555969476699829,
0.5037010312080383,
0.54703289270401,
0.12177066504955292,
0.03615671768784523,
0.30361407995224,
-0.0285382978618145,
0.050553709268569946,
-0.5932503342628479,
-0.3815569579601288,
1.2389856576919556,
0.15599943697452545,
1.2173594236373901,
0.1414591670036316,
1.1293529272079468,
0.42827901244163513,
0.5100119709968567,
-0.22866131365299225,
0.3801468014717102,
-0.5019965171813965,
-0.6429363489151001,
-0.6296806335449219,
-0.5913582444190979,
-1.141607642173767,
0.12864699959754944,
0.07334654033184052,
-0.5937094688415527,
0.5496783256530762,
0.30463114380836487,
-0.42794474959373474,
-0.0012014758540317416,
-0.9279570579528809,
0.5100265741348267,
0.34508827328681946,
-0.09816375374794006,
-0.04773576185107231,
-0.2187451869249344,
0.5450230240821838,
-0.18582196533679962,
0.5783730149269104,
-0.32856494188308716,
0.14229342341423035,
0.341343492269516,
-0.48522481322288513,
1.2069616317749023,
-0.1564803421497345,
-0.42736145853996277,
0.33326655626296997,
0.4132814109325409,
0.6757793426513672,
0.2939450144767761,
-0.376631498336792,
-0.055484067648649216,
-0.2874465882778168,
-0.38416656851768494,
-0.5082805752754211,
0.5915026068687439,
-0.9000611305236816,
-0.4403824210166931,
0.06201345846056938,
-0.5904656052589417,
-0.14461582899093628,
0.014886761084198952,
0.7283071279525757,
0.3784250020980835,
-0.24278029799461365,
-0.16473321616649628,
0.6455976963043213,
-0.16815736889839172,
0.20729787647724152,
0.35464343428611755,
-0.2824413776397705,
-0.30343714356422424,
1.133722186088562,
0.40972527861595154,
0.733425498008728,
0.11102021485567093,
0.07739584147930145,
-0.07255415618419647,
-0.551602303981781,
-0.3650320768356323,
0.17256233096122742,
-0.7428763508796692,
-0.162406325340271,
-0.44653332233428955,
-0.25825369358062744,
-0.3922371566295624,
-0.2759226858615875,
-0.23953008651733398,
-0.6393808126449585,
-0.48120689392089844,
-0.21709361672401428,
0.33438289165496826,
0.9142554402351379,
-0.32935112714767456,
0.35786503553390503,
-0.695393443107605,
0.47945815324783325,
0.49394339323043823,
0.4270689785480499,
-0.049374960362911224,
-0.700203001499176,
-0.15919604897499084,
0.40215739607810974,
-0.2132195681333542,
-0.7787492275238037,
0.4534609317779541,
0.5103991627693176,
0.5020419955253601,
0.3760039806365967,
0.05047281086444855,
0.5932213664054871,
-0.7319886684417725,
0.5136095881462097,
-0.10527818650007248,
-0.6732498407363892,
0.5201963186264038,
-0.4473213255405426,
0.357505202293396,
0.377663254737854,
0.08795236796140671,
-0.5257051587104797,
-1.0897666215896606,
-0.7507994174957275,
-0.8260109424591064,
0.836747944355011,
0.4088078439235687,
0.5862548351287842,
-0.37248724699020386,
0.10042993724346161,
0.38060706853866577,
0.05306177958846092,
-0.6635189056396484,
-0.3390839397907257,
0.06140778586268425,
-0.42196428775787354,
-0.07711479067802429,
-0.32898250222206116,
-0.07394403219223022,
-0.23340696096420288,
0.5382767915725708,
-0.04346068203449249,
-0.012717953883111477,
-0.14723458886146545,
-0.04813963919878006,
-0.32858946919441223,
0.20867054164409637,
0.7566460371017456,
0.6363986730575562,
0.021783124655485153,
0.2970549762248993,
0.11545503884553909,
-0.5326310992240906,
0.22475196421146393,
-0.0028751660138368607,
-0.4820603132247925,
0.06161917746067047,
0.19850072264671326,
0.6875858306884766,
0.04937887564301491,
-0.6495868563652039,
0.1367683708667755,
-0.14707373082637787,
-0.2785055935382843,
-0.1164044588804245,
0.5184227824211121,
0.3344632387161255,
0.04530353471636772,
0.2645457684993744,
0.3528478145599365,
0.15412312746047974,
-0.1376177817583084,
0.23009786009788513,
0.5776728987693787,
0.12313562631607056,
-0.32929036021232605,
0.5192054510116577,
0.16035352647304535,
-0.2399487942457199,
0.7386810779571533,
-0.4735416769981384,
0.06568285822868347,
0.593467652797699,
0.5132436156272888,
0.7936756610870361,
-0.3564016819000244,
0.5623832941055298,
0.20407111942768097,
0.18314437568187714,
-0.6229633688926697,
0.37834298610687256,
0.16893750429153442,
-1.1145033836364746,
-0.27619779109954834,
-0.7889606356620789,
-0.18021279573440552,
-0.011613309383392334,
-0.4294731914997101,
0.30404919385910034,
-0.46360015869140625,
-0.21664074063301086,
0.11984089761972427,
-0.45055660605430603,
-0.8623059988021851,
0.08878963440656662,
0.4223039746284485,
0.7444547414779663,
-1.1520057916641235,
0.9015426635742188,
0.5426575541496277,
-0.28959646821022034,
-0.691886305809021,
-0.22584445774555206,
-0.2216939479112625,
-0.7570309638977051,
0.7701432108879089,
-0.3107624351978302,
0.34424588084220886,
0.07237783074378967,
-0.962083101272583,
-1.007405400276184,
0.6299471259117126,
0.6816220283508301,
-0.6711965799331665,
0.05205425247550011,
0.42255520820617676,
0.4943114221096039,
-0.29632312059402466,
0.20490607619285583,
0.4034934937953949,
0.5203667283058167,
0.1571539044380188,
-0.8548061847686768,
-0.18297521770000458,
0.009770400822162628,
0.2845233678817749,
0.23365962505340576,
-0.4354780912399292,
0.924224853515625,
-0.35519540309906006,
-0.24716392159461975,
-0.18467669188976288,
0.5885082483291626,
0.5998674035072327,
-0.12996788322925568,
0.6505815386772156,
0.3459482491016388,
0.9149293303489685,
0.23769323527812958,
1.0725146532058716,
0.18889476358890533,
0.3176148533821106,
1.2430521249771118,
-0.35468024015426636,
0.7495170831680298,
0.5285101532936096,
-0.312625914812088,
0.4289152920246124,
0.5950631499290466,
-0.03286841884255409,
0.7235515117645264,
0.5059027075767517,
-0.27698832750320435,
-0.46142518520355225,
0.07055183500051498,
0.05408667400479317,
0.19311420619487762,
0.4990570843219757,
-0.29851847887039185,
-0.4477555751800537,
0.16381481289863586,
-0.2004130780696869,
0.08057078719139099,
0.0045996857807040215,
0.6593045592308044,
0.1118999794125557,
-0.45214512944221497,
0.6822046637535095,
-0.11235717684030533,
0.6026102304458618,
-0.5475566983222961,
-0.18399065732955933,
-0.514305830001831,
0.18191057443618774,
-0.1931203454732895,
-0.6964481472969055,
0.39689362049102783,
0.03168991953134537,
-0.5925866365432739,
-0.4299211800098419,
0.3374914526939392,
-0.7192540764808655,
-0.8637107014656067,
0.09032067656517029,
0.5182314515113831,
-0.0029043841641396284,
0.020383041352033615,
-0.500545859336853,
0.016633929684758186,
0.22684967517852783,
-0.5332003235816956,
0.6033859848976135,
0.6951258182525635,
-0.33618590235710144,
0.8622666001319885,
0.633699893951416,
0.3310833275318146,
0.35959017276763916,
0.4401618242263794,
0.6767381429672241,
-0.3132888972759247,
-0.46711358428001404,
-0.9040926098823547,
0.5217486619949341,
-0.021935872733592987,
-0.21845120191574097,
0.46494996547698975,
0.2542068362236023,
0.8304408192634583,
-0.19130496680736542,
1.1423133611679077,
-0.10122380405664444,
0.47582826018333435,
-0.20414210855960846,
0.6461812853813171,
-0.343597948551178,
0.49589335918426514,
-0.09465425461530685,
-0.8233077526092529,
-0.3714251220226288,
0.4721698760986328,
-0.2235937863588333,
0.191120445728302,
0.22005301713943481,
0.7986311912536621,
-0.2505151033401489,
-0.4527928829193115,
0.5446096658706665,
0.33878186345100403,
0.5075166821479797,
0.3318549692630768,
0.6450548768043518,
-0.03578217327594757,
0.6584745049476624,
-0.2966667413711548,
-0.16255968809127808,
-0.1297760009765625,
-0.7405275106430054,
-0.7818570137023926,
-0.46260300278663635,
-0.2806938886642456,
-0.15639600157737732,
-0.0957159548997879,
0.8488284945487976,
0.8419857621192932,
-0.9010595679283142,
-0.27158987522125244,
-0.31049948930740356,
0.2514219582080841,
-0.2572486400604248,
-0.2455221563577652,
0.07742922008037567,
-0.5905823707580566,
-0.8404867649078369,
0.20220278203487396,
-0.05293755233287811,
0.30034124851226807,
-0.2012249231338501,
-0.022918278351426125,
0.10930538922548294,
0.19834205508232117,
0.36573541164398193,
0.09297453612089157,
-0.7270966172218323,
-0.34197086095809937,
-0.1170799508690834,
-0.4118970036506653,
-0.21129077672958374,
0.36194300651550293,
-0.7198907732963562,
0.2636813223361969,
0.4357917904853821,
0.3443359434604645,
0.09013968706130981,
-0.09291008859872818,
0.9868232011795044,
-1.2074705362319946,
0.20381653308868408,
0.23687748610973358,
0.15252256393432617,
0.20205098390579224,
-0.5411504507064819,
0.36285150051116943,
0.01923612877726555,
-0.5273966789245605,
-0.9603549838066101,
0.32078444957733154,
-0.5681762099266052,
-0.38796669244766235,
1.5136195421218872,
0.20878389477729797,
-0.11231722682714462,
-0.23576191067695618,
-0.43333256244659424,
0.004514816217124462,
-0.6073368191719055,
0.8498038649559021,
0.7374645471572876,
-0.061070237308740616,
0.01707872934639454,
-0.3845236599445343,
0.8960821032524109,
0.38006260991096497,
-0.550611138343811,
0.5391590595245361,
0.4618590474128723,
0.5227867364883423,
-0.16351930797100067,
0.773304283618927,
0.36976513266563416,
0.18562155961990356,
-0.16095222532749176,
0.08412645012140274,
0.238276407122612,
-0.12274494767189026,
-0.4479341506958008,
0.009647470898926258,
0.2949787378311157,
0.16694633662700653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10857v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10857v1
|
D3CODE: Disentangling Disagreements in Data across Cultures on Offensiveness Detection and Evaluation
| 2024-04-16T19:12:03 | 2024-04-16T19:12:03 |
Aida Mostafazadeh Davani, Mark Díaz, Dylan Baker, Vinodkumar Prabhakaran
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While human annotations play a crucial role in language technologies,
annotator subjectivity has long been overlooked in data collection. Recent
studies that have critically examined this issue are often situated in the
Western context, and solely document differences across age, gender, or racial
groups. As a result, NLP research on subjectivity have overlooked the fact that
individuals within demographic groups may hold diverse values, which can
influence their perceptions beyond their group norms. To effectively
incorporate these considerations into NLP pipelines, we need datasets with
extensive parallel annotations from various social and cultural groups. In this
paper we introduce the \dataset dataset: a large-scale cross-cultural dataset
of parallel annotations for offensive language in over 4.5K sentences annotated
by a pool of over 4k annotators, balanced across gender and age, from across 21
countries, representing eight geo-cultural regions. The dataset contains
annotators' moral values captured along six moral foundations: care, equality,
proportionality, authority, loyalty, and purity. Our analyses reveal
substantial regional variations in annotators' perceptions that are shaped by
individual moral values, offering crucial insights for building pluralistic,
culturally sensitive NLP models.
|
[
-0.340240478515625,
-0.29996761679649353,
0.2309391349554062,
0.44058704376220703,
-0.21749991178512573,
0.09138579666614532,
-0.22519810497760773,
-0.529808521270752,
-0.1715615689754486,
0.48739445209503174,
-0.28538933396339417,
-0.6870148777961731,
-1.0029100179672241,
0.5284234881401062,
-0.14254221320152283,
1.2333672046661377,
0.06016891822218895,
-0.0816892609000206,
0.03922712430357933,
-0.761603832244873,
-0.15445508062839508,
-0.8253152370452881,
-0.3608423173427582,
-0.09502604603767395,
0.5242379903793335,
0.3935500681400299,
0.7612447738647461,
0.789664089679718,
0.6772368550300598,
0.2509624660015106,
-0.22650355100631714,
-0.009416145272552967,
-0.5815345048904419,
0.03240285813808441,
-0.38432908058166504,
-0.46225160360336304,
-0.36446595191955566,
0.12961842119693756,
0.12706033885478973,
0.4752281904220581,
0.19916877150535583,
0.4824860394001007,
-0.09624459594488144,
0.7799460291862488,
-0.8190016746520996,
0.3119491636753082,
-0.5448939204216003,
0.31058305501937866,
-0.41382384300231934,
0.16041341423988342,
-0.15159018337726593,
-0.4958212375640869,
-0.06627035140991211,
-0.5754321813583374,
0.194496288895607,
-0.2924087643623352,
0.5995600819587708,
0.3617474436759949,
-0.47688058018684387,
-0.28833457827568054,
-0.438193678855896,
0.8594964742660522,
-0.5408331155776978,
0.11697831004858017,
0.7974282503128052,
-0.0009543694322928786,
0.32268404960632324,
-0.5589552521705627,
-0.7191248536109924,
0.36538124084472656,
-0.1872880607843399,
0.08602384477853775,
-0.34953027963638306,
-0.28068625926971436,
0.48984354734420776,
0.43156400322914124,
-0.15380147099494934,
0.3768486976623535,
-0.4551554024219513,
-0.000537496292963624,
0.8685904145240784,
0.18763962388038635,
0.4684056341648102,
-0.33207133412361145,
-0.20455914735794067,
0.045650169253349304,
-0.658307671546936,
0.2700916826725006,
0.779362142086029,
0.26758885383605957,
-0.28317636251449585,
0.432186484336853,
-0.2740798592567444,
0.3436565101146698,
-0.036961544305086136,
0.07213900983333588,
0.47546347975730896,
-0.19911623001098633,
0.08694649487733841,
0.07752031832933426,
0.9936201572418213,
0.9655661582946777,
0.7612187266349792,
0.16238701343536377,
-0.11119101196527481,
0.22649407386779785,
0.31367745995521545,
-0.7582576274871826,
-0.28098559379577637,
0.2724909484386444,
-0.5268033742904663,
-0.3639182448387146,
-0.15758578479290009,
-0.8564744591712952,
-0.811912477016449,
-0.21477577090263367,
-0.3590492904186249,
-0.2781495451927185,
-0.393791526556015,
0.15027034282684326,
-0.2109973281621933,
0.12146015465259552,
0.0414673313498497,
-1.1171987056732178,
0.25725704431533813,
0.8192502856254578,
0.6295437812805176,
-0.12746809422969818,
-0.28589189052581787,
-0.22414132952690125,
-0.13011384010314941,
-0.22647830843925476,
0.2838221490383148,
-0.849648654460907,
-0.14566074311733246,
0.007991917431354523,
-0.06269454210996628,
0.3823312222957611,
-0.5089467763900757,
0.9591599702835083,
-0.4711451232433319,
-0.048716891556978226,
-0.7030799388885498,
-0.004638741724193096,
-0.4780212342739105,
0.19382566213607788,
-0.8068925142288208,
0.7217755317687988,
0.011230596341192722,
-1.1992161273956299,
0.7234079241752625,
-0.6641278266906738,
-0.4637473523616791,
0.28465017676353455,
-0.30096593499183655,
-0.3400733172893524,
0.13053259253501892,
0.5950700640678406,
0.5388821363449097,
-0.3232150077819824,
0.24196414649486542,
-0.46449440717697144,
-0.5164303779602051,
0.23975537717342377,
-0.44152647256851196,
1.1450315713882446,
0.20258057117462158,
-0.4777284562587738,
-0.16469234228134155,
-0.6216245889663696,
-0.4389984607696533,
0.36878344416618347,
-0.15633584558963776,
-0.6642746925354004,
0.08719824999570847,
0.06518951803445816,
0.37760552763938904,
-0.03547723591327667,
-0.8029098510742188,
-0.2057536095380783,
-0.08210781216621399,
0.49102655053138733,
0.7547516822814941,
-0.3351064622402191,
0.14028678834438324,
-0.40255919098854065,
0.49081936478614807,
0.2408994734287262,
0.22136682271957397,
0.10507906973361969,
-0.4344949424266815,
-0.4931587278842926,
-0.21334773302078247,
-0.213148832321167,
0.6019609570503235,
-0.623772144317627,
0.34620359539985657,
-0.4576473534107208,
-0.3307107388973236,
-0.6677917838096619,
0.15720531344413757,
0.38830307126045227,
0.25500231981277466,
0.41985923051834106,
-0.0933002158999443,
-0.4909302890300751,
-1.1017534732818604,
-0.4412611424922943,
-0.6197932362556458,
0.02451903559267521,
0.1950765699148178,
0.3872160017490387,
0.07954484224319458,
0.9356129169464111,
-0.4342529773712158,
-0.4116142690181732,
-0.19085592031478882,
0.1479702591896057,
0.07051803171634674,
0.36718106269836426,
0.7541359663009644,
-0.9767654538154602,
-0.33052122592926025,
0.05282516032457352,
-0.9822990298271179,
-0.2616058588027954,
0.26232388615608215,
0.027544014155864716,
0.13575604557991028,
0.11479225009679794,
0.11973053216934204,
0.49493294954299927,
0.674654483795166,
-0.230676531791687,
0.17349374294281006,
0.34599921107292175,
0.48569685220718384,
-0.8492854833602905,
-0.010599241591989994,
0.16765448451042175,
0.14035262167453766,
-0.43647509813308716,
-0.17735283076763153,
0.00016477440658491105,
0.11365735530853271,
-0.6006437540054321,
0.27480608224868774,
-0.10631629824638367,
0.23291823267936707,
0.09768720716238022,
0.03296780213713646,
0.11548967659473419,
0.36585474014282227,
0.1722842901945114,
0.8039875030517578,
0.28054651618003845,
-0.28236955404281616,
0.42667439579963684,
0.6146430969238281,
-0.16268621385097504,
0.9173874855041504,
-0.5185131430625916,
0.2536178231239319,
-0.43035653233528137,
0.15570864081382751,
-0.653369665145874,
-0.16623260080814362,
0.469059020280838,
-0.3076937198638916,
-0.40284454822540283,
-0.6470375061035156,
-0.5275599956512451,
-0.4424973428249359,
-0.3896811902523041,
0.9184948205947876,
0.3042420446872711,
-0.6199055910110474,
0.24338756501674652,
0.6424995064735413,
-0.35449567437171936,
-1.0290447473526,
-0.8892175555229187,
0.11382350325584412,
-0.7042946219444275,
-0.5300279259681702,
-0.22802646458148956,
0.3072567880153656,
-0.5650119185447693,
-0.2419024407863617,
0.11926908791065216,
-0.23420582711696625,
0.18721677362918854,
0.28469040989875793,
-0.12203074991703033,
-0.007556091528385878,
0.036613743752241135,
-0.09103552997112274,
0.11851336061954498,
0.5181546211242676,
-0.12557445466518402,
0.20639066398143768,
-0.4171905219554901,
-0.28854748606681824,
-0.1865168809890747,
0.499670147895813,
0.5114845037460327,
-0.4822103977203369,
0.44018828868865967,
0.6455425024032593,
-0.3256649672985077,
0.04095817729830742,
-0.519582986831665,
0.14413531124591827,
-0.4352531433105469,
0.34756848216056824,
-0.3238799571990967,
-0.969897449016571,
0.8026891946792603,
0.3552151918411255,
0.15379901230335236,
0.4361794590950012,
0.42068207263946533,
0.05594492703676224,
0.7537592649459839,
0.2843812108039856,
0.020684096962213516,
0.19548657536506653,
-0.0884748175740242,
0.13085730373859406,
-0.7741461992263794,
-0.14258232712745667,
-0.4349447190761566,
-0.5193941593170166,
-0.7958246469497681,
-0.33522945642471313,
0.011538892984390259,
-0.0113902036100626,
-0.39046186208724976,
0.16521036624908447,
-0.5221699476242065,
0.6614273190498352,
0.09559459984302521,
0.0007645066943950951,
0.2836839258670807,
-0.08217734843492508,
0.023774228990077972,
-0.39543095231056213,
-0.3800193667411804,
-0.8288024663925171,
1.0848653316497803,
0.5038924217224121,
0.5480036735534668,
0.41246792674064636,
0.544596254825592,
0.4269338846206665,
0.3514895737171173,
-0.6865095496177673,
0.27209851145744324,
-0.6364012956619263,
-0.8179239630699158,
-0.02548534795641899,
-0.3925269842147827,
-0.8366556763648987,
0.1747729778289795,
0.10753031075000763,
-0.9804467558860779,
0.5607534050941467,
0.09542890638113022,
-0.29389843344688416,
0.6196461319923401,
-0.5761702060699463,
0.8489177227020264,
-0.1711195707321167,
-0.5115209221839905,
0.12902630865573883,
-0.7299821972846985,
0.6350966095924377,
-0.2150493860244751,
0.40707480907440186,
-0.6171202063560486,
0.04875372722744942,
0.7634944319725037,
-0.18502271175384521,
1.093432068824768,
-0.2747114896774292,
-0.3632131814956665,
0.21576307713985443,
0.16925224661827087,
0.09844419360160828,
0.273291677236557,
-0.33717039227485657,
0.6195072531700134,
-0.12414059787988663,
-0.4083510637283325,
-0.17540329694747925,
0.5188404321670532,
-0.737673282623291,
-0.5144637823104858,
-0.33593299984931946,
-0.5806949734687805,
-0.0032617836259305477,
0.052731167525053024,
0.12470340728759766,
0.43329834938049316,
-0.01750597357749939,
0.24995049834251404,
0.3556409180164337,
-0.42058107256889343,
0.4596051275730133,
0.17909914255142212,
0.008360710926353931,
-0.44836971163749695,
0.8868658542633057,
-0.03693027421832085,
0.13332116603851318,
0.06626147776842117,
0.1616443693637848,
-0.3352658152580261,
-0.5044096112251282,
-0.514502227306366,
0.013499156571924686,
-1.071794867515564,
-0.1680109053850174,
-0.8597627878189087,
0.09876547008752823,
-0.11889725923538208,
-0.1862950325012207,
-0.3551498353481293,
-0.239296555519104,
-0.12779319286346436,
-0.23248398303985596,
0.858427882194519,
0.9856514930725098,
-0.25179895758628845,
0.3108591139316559,
-0.8217572569847107,
0.33136650919914246,
0.11620381474494934,
0.5551840662956238,
-0.2828945219516754,
-0.28076422214508057,
-0.03197438642382622,
0.1184166744351387,
-0.11707110702991486,
-0.563664436340332,
0.15851177275180817,
-0.2071271538734436,
0.370281457901001,
0.3587205410003662,
0.48262855410575867,
0.426588237285614,
-0.21288950741291046,
0.8283753991127014,
-0.02500172145664692,
-1.0301347970962524,
0.4550021290779114,
-0.501940906047821,
0.128210186958313,
0.8143954277038574,
0.6453313231468201,
-0.8411630988121033,
-0.5160319805145264,
-0.457840234041214,
-1.000209927558899,
0.985470712184906,
0.3921652138233185,
0.3583405017852783,
-0.3511198163032532,
0.07172659784555435,
0.42231130599975586,
0.03670356422662735,
-0.7577894926071167,
-0.36696943640708923,
-0.4885704517364502,
-0.34850311279296875,
0.09252054244279861,
-0.21570612490177155,
-0.48952770233154297,
0.04345327243208885,
0.09097117185592651,
-0.27007246017456055,
-0.07180513441562653,
0.08347606658935547,
-0.24006353318691254,
0.17525900900363922,
0.19419178366661072,
0.3693426847457886,
0.9977747797966003,
-0.23471498489379883,
0.1547795534133911,
0.21116559207439423,
-0.8115991353988647,
0.3920668363571167,
0.190866619348526,
0.01363931130617857,
-0.22166922688484192,
0.3630501925945282,
0.6929699182510376,
-0.3471762537956238,
-0.2537462115287781,
0.7696371078491211,
-0.3934497833251953,
0.02738400734961033,
-0.17857606709003448,
-0.2702163755893707,
-0.2662009000778198,
0.05883308872580528,
0.24644848704338074,
0.03817401081323624,
0.31710076332092285,
-0.21898730099201202,
0.3397310972213745,
-0.1206362396478653,
-0.6138056516647339,
-0.30054688453674316,
0.6741598844528198,
0.5492539405822754,
-0.054227400571107864,
0.6692584156990051,
-0.1313634067773819,
-0.6836215853691101,
0.5447778701782227,
0.19680997729301453,
0.9090449810028076,
0.12174209207296371,
0.22821277379989624,
0.4433181583881378,
0.5194456577301025,
0.26367828249931335,
0.26868000626564026,
0.007090482860803604,
-0.8715593814849854,
-0.5205180644989014,
-0.5081447958946228,
-0.23319382965564728,
-0.11242026090621948,
-0.9622926115989685,
0.11726813018321991,
-0.5819675326347351,
-0.20811322331428528,
-0.09216760098934174,
-0.24740903079509735,
-0.9108430743217468,
0.3857838809490204,
0.44296425580978394,
0.5800564289093018,
-1.1929389238357544,
0.417062371969223,
0.7291562557220459,
-0.5147210359573364,
-0.3590075969696045,
0.346814900636673,
0.2863185405731201,
-0.9372200965881348,
0.9995396733283997,
0.34015992283821106,
-0.06275957077741623,
-0.25530892610549927,
-0.3157837986946106,
-0.3463461399078369,
0.5606905221939087,
0.22332985699176788,
-0.319429486989975,
0.27148038148880005,
0.41859960556030273,
0.47528019547462463,
-0.23600968718528748,
0.28269362449645996,
0.9591664671897888,
0.30742940306663513,
-0.15004336833953857,
-0.6874606013298035,
0.27618059515953064,
-0.33483538031578064,
0.048873089253902435,
0.10397272557020187,
-0.7098544836044312,
0.5856914520263672,
-0.1351834535598755,
-0.1906774938106537,
-0.5025594830513,
0.3831246495246887,
0.3431451618671417,
0.1397092044353485,
0.6161218285560608,
0.34512895345687866,
0.5445601940155029,
-0.30598002672195435,
1.0701138973236084,
0.003068387508392334,
0.01765379123389721,
1.1798375844955444,
-0.27613675594329834,
0.3777320981025696,
0.19562388956546783,
-0.16680119931697845,
0.21955512464046478,
0.41157498955726624,
-0.0009305827552452683,
0.23202143609523773,
0.4035496413707733,
-0.14008735120296478,
0.04214692860841751,
-0.47398898005485535,
-0.2597868740558624,
0.9813752770423889,
0.4637848436832428,
-0.20645365118980408,
-0.0825873538851738,
-0.1527400016784668,
0.42939841747283936,
0.39052629470825195,
-0.20362944900989532,
0.9178021550178528,
0.007438191678375006,
-0.31486251950263977,
0.596717357635498,
-0.1598108559846878,
0.758653461933136,
-0.2656424045562744,
0.014567474834620953,
-0.44476184248924255,
0.07308226823806763,
-0.44417786598205566,
-1.3616961240768433,
0.5220165252685547,
0.37421485781669617,
-0.08588283509016037,
-0.2937973141670227,
0.22716137766838074,
-0.137832909822464,
-0.3422064781188965,
0.49332395195961,
0.11710796505212784,
0.19799135625362396,
0.017982594668865204,
-0.6375228762626648,
0.3772667348384857,
0.037468355149030685,
0.0766068696975708,
-0.1958383321762085,
0.97993403673172,
-0.33007577061653137,
0.4325435757637024,
0.5989259481430054,
0.04392777010798454,
-0.0742432028055191,
0.2731535732746124,
0.8564068078994751,
-0.6144963502883911,
-0.2525378465652466,
-1.1600332260131836,
0.7366666793823242,
-0.3117048740386963,
-0.6730117201805115,
0.6375443339347839,
0.43871474266052246,
1.172516107559204,
0.18526558578014374,
0.9785977602005005,
-0.18767480552196503,
0.2843282222747803,
-0.33713456988334656,
0.8288008570671082,
-0.23571637272834778,
0.15024326741695404,
-0.5430413484573364,
-0.8170194029808044,
-0.4099992513656616,
0.617143988609314,
-0.4116303026676178,
0.030443625524640083,
0.45246264338493347,
0.35557228326797485,
0.09455972909927368,
0.4525516629219055,
0.1766381859779358,
0.11960560083389282,
0.45386654138565063,
0.3503504991531372,
1.184399962425232,
-0.39045971632003784,
0.4249679744243622,
-0.6102790832519531,
-0.11479596793651581,
0.1201726570725441,
-1.0685628652572632,
-0.895404577255249,
-0.44199737906455994,
-0.38764333724975586,
-0.3047810196876526,
-0.07351972162723541,
0.9423765540122986,
0.4766354262828827,
-1.0231813192367554,
-0.2152663767337799,
0.3029739558696747,
0.0841788798570633,
-0.22318483889102936,
-0.19842936098575592,
0.200738325715065,
-0.029753342270851135,
-0.9844728112220764,
-0.1674056351184845,
0.1300799399614334,
-0.06360483914613724,
-0.0826101303100586,
0.15994179248809814,
-0.12074968218803406,
-0.18831513822078705,
0.6235688924789429,
0.061965975910425186,
-0.8150942921638489,
-0.5046858787536621,
-0.46104153990745544,
0.002418740652501583,
0.10630729794502258,
0.6458470225334167,
-0.38349616527557373,
0.5724599361419678,
0.3092777729034424,
0.7003133893013,
-0.01511683501303196,
0.18777813017368317,
0.8351424932479858,
-0.8438927531242371,
0.3426535427570343,
0.48551666736602783,
0.3291156589984894,
0.7868863344192505,
-0.5078919529914856,
0.6671090126037598,
0.20494967699050903,
-0.46011456847190857,
-0.5355042815208435,
0.29641932249069214,
-0.6527079343795776,
0.023433104157447815,
1.1005373001098633,
-0.5045738220214844,
0.016498317942023277,
-0.4332897663116455,
-0.1984756737947464,
0.14250199496746063,
-0.5211610198020935,
0.7086049318313599,
0.7555718421936035,
0.2060282826423645,
-0.02194627746939659,
-0.6325350999832153,
0.8017250895500183,
0.3519309461116791,
-0.6945801973342896,
0.6674246191978455,
0.562491238117218,
0.17280644178390503,
0.1336788833141327,
0.3644087314605713,
-0.32188883423805237,
0.07030051946640015,
0.0035429876297712326,
0.24915507435798645,
0.01115499809384346,
-0.11190267652273178,
-0.3828658163547516,
0.056306641548871994,
-0.1127377301454544,
-0.28835105895996094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10848v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10848v1
|
A LayoutLMv3-Based Model for Enhanced Relation Extraction in Visually-Rich Documents
| 2024-04-16T18:50:57 | 2024-04-16T18:50:57 |
Wiam Adnan, Joel Tang, Yassine Bel Khayat Zouggari, Seif Edinne Laatiri, Laurent Lam, Fabien Caspani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Document Understanding is an evolving field in Natural Language Processing
(NLP). In particular, visual and spatial features are essential in addition to
the raw text itself and hence, several multimodal models were developed in the
field of Visual Document Understanding (VDU). However, while research is mainly
focused on Key Information Extraction (KIE), Relation Extraction (RE) between
identified entities is still under-studied. For instance, RE is crucial to
regroup entities or obtain a comprehensive hierarchy of data in a document. In
this paper, we present a model that, initialized from LayoutLMv3, can match or
outperform the current state-of-the-art results in RE applied to Visually-Rich
Documents (VRD) on FUNSD and CORD datasets, without any specific pre-training
and with fewer parameters. We also report an extensive ablation study performed
on FUNSD, highlighting the great impact of certain features and modelization
choices on the performances.
|
[
-0.4117225110530853,
-0.7446312308311462,
0.5101457834243774,
0.21906600892543793,
-0.5449090600013733,
-0.30454713106155396,
0.1149526908993721,
-0.567618191242218,
-0.043189700692892075,
0.7791225910186768,
-0.4520725607872009,
-0.6368718147277832,
-0.26044994592666626,
-0.16584254801273346,
-0.2230980396270752,
0.7044371962547302,
-0.061153341084718704,
-0.11753924936056137,
-0.49924391508102417,
-0.24938629567623138,
-0.4607885479927063,
-0.33909881114959717,
-0.025561070069670677,
-0.1533709466457367,
0.5781353116035461,
0.17240016162395477,
0.729008674621582,
0.8644915819168091,
0.7993298172950745,
0.28059515357017517,
-0.32623791694641113,
0.45839163661003113,
-0.32928770780563354,
0.352907657623291,
0.012728748843073845,
-0.27262192964553833,
-0.5817072987556458,
0.020220095291733742,
0.6009315848350525,
0.6808117628097534,
0.0010080364299938083,
-0.10152881592512131,
-0.054912351071834564,
0.5708006620407104,
-0.6797604560852051,
0.297013521194458,
-0.7045950293540955,
0.03855267912149429,
-0.23639249801635742,
-0.38250818848609924,
-0.5299175381660461,
-0.21111495792865753,
0.36593469977378845,
-0.9884874820709229,
0.37417420744895935,
0.25513187050819397,
1.2627568244934082,
0.03469248116016388,
-0.45837849378585815,
-0.22115448117256165,
-0.6252843737602234,
0.4657667577266693,
-0.4516526758670807,
0.9984543323516846,
0.3556763231754303,
0.10195289552211761,
0.024153446778655052,
-0.8233531713485718,
-0.4073907732963562,
0.0023075025528669357,
-0.344852477312088,
0.24364934861660004,
-0.053836170583963394,
-0.1071537509560585,
0.47143131494522095,
0.5031207203865051,
-0.6036862730979919,
-0.03258657082915306,
-0.323542982339859,
-0.00699228048324585,
0.3084345757961273,
0.09793981164693832,
0.36699140071868896,
-0.7583003640174866,
-0.5579039454460144,
-0.08844176679849625,
-0.6212925314903259,
-0.2869455814361572,
0.03922513127326965,
-0.03987870365381241,
-0.25865069031715393,
0.6908360123634338,
0.1417984813451767,
0.9265929460525513,
-0.38547879457473755,
-0.2471926212310791,
0.2754670977592468,
-0.6238217353820801,
-0.651832640171051,
-0.4197385907173157,
0.6838808059692383,
0.3414250910282135,
0.25942569971084595,
-0.23902535438537598,
-0.04389439895749092,
-0.1796574890613556,
0.39150720834732056,
-0.7521783113479614,
-0.49761176109313965,
-0.07245734333992004,
-0.685983419418335,
-0.18332253396511078,
0.023992568254470825,
-0.8196852207183838,
-0.5681034922599792,
-0.42337942123413086,
0.09351027756929398,
-0.9150339961051941,
-0.19826242327690125,
-0.20936767756938934,
-0.34498298168182373,
0.44888901710510254,
0.7008917331695557,
-0.8383632898330688,
0.10753196477890015,
0.6923680305480957,
0.9080978631973267,
-0.29425206780433655,
-0.2404811680316925,
-0.5686612725257874,
0.4548957645893097,
-0.18089205026626587,
0.7514660954475403,
-0.5007737278938293,
-0.4819807708263397,
-0.06368941813707352,
-0.22245603799819946,
-0.013772726058959961,
-0.49074792861938477,
0.6225697994232178,
-0.8705530166625977,
0.29490000009536743,
-0.05342116951942444,
-0.41960108280181885,
-0.15841346979141235,
0.35002952814102173,
-1.0135061740875244,
0.8768607974052429,
0.3146142065525055,
-1.0598443746566772,
0.5334751009941101,
-0.5087131261825562,
-0.3462779223918915,
0.03066237084567547,
-0.2490309625864029,
-0.6668184399604797,
0.17651499807834625,
0.5172352194786072,
0.3338272273540497,
-0.022787174209952354,
-0.00803782045841217,
-0.5346355438232422,
-0.02118712104856968,
-0.017256179824471474,
-0.2576068043708801,
0.7058218717575073,
0.29339855909347534,
0.38066619634628296,
0.38630372285842896,
-1.0273573398590088,
-0.22763864696025848,
0.2566046416759491,
-0.2572251856327057,
-0.8953410983085632,
-0.21329626441001892,
0.11655764281749725,
0.3454837203025818,
0.17795611917972565,
-0.44000720977783203,
0.2885909080505371,
-0.537602961063385,
-0.001982312649488449,
0.3942314386367798,
0.2648653984069824,
0.7944526076316833,
0.09108246862888336,
0.5202397108078003,
0.03492019325494766,
-0.024800602346658707,
-0.6420878767967224,
-0.3536376655101776,
-0.5843590497970581,
-0.6604120135307312,
0.23836879432201385,
0.3403175473213196,
-0.9426369071006775,
0.26003497838974,
-0.3968201279640198,
-0.36694926023483276,
-0.22030597925186157,
0.14755220711231232,
0.3599560558795929,
0.7726582288742065,
0.3570437729358673,
-0.22038640081882477,
-0.5644136667251587,
-0.9482899308204651,
-0.06561951339244843,
-0.022020768374204636,
-0.04956575110554695,
0.5126298069953918,
0.1905936896800995,
-0.12078095972537994,
0.9066108465194702,
-0.7801895141601562,
-0.5856833457946777,
-0.3791271150112152,
0.16282576322555542,
-0.013163767755031586,
0.2850606143474579,
0.5525789260864258,
-1.023085117340088,
-0.28230592608451843,
0.321326345205307,
-0.937498152256012,
0.01941990666091442,
-0.0920582115650177,
-0.5004943609237671,
-0.09162046015262604,
0.3991372287273407,
-0.7972034215927124,
0.7830172181129456,
0.230167955160141,
-0.29048049449920654,
0.27001863718032837,
-0.3548344671726227,
-0.04517634958028793,
-1.042103886604309,
0.021051933988928795,
0.3001295328140259,
-0.18293508887290955,
-0.687197208404541,
0.2131805121898651,
0.5663964152336121,
-0.26441189646720886,
-0.4295397400856018,
0.6986091136932373,
-0.7143863439559937,
-0.5710498094558716,
0.01837809383869171,
0.5284005999565125,
0.5581315159797668,
0.538994312286377,
0.46438726782798767,
0.2896944284439087,
0.19326822459697723,
-0.37363356351852417,
0.1785338819026947,
0.6974704265594482,
-0.2651551365852356,
0.5059213638305664,
-0.27259212732315063,
-0.16456958651542664,
-0.047853339463472366,
0.06623078137636185,
-0.987297773361206,
-0.19137436151504517,
0.060750626027584076,
-0.3058023750782013,
0.29857590794563293,
-0.20222626626491547,
-0.5225756168365479,
-0.12164768576622009,
-0.2799975275993347,
0.3191697597503662,
0.14362765848636627,
-0.6199382543563843,
0.998161256313324,
0.21360467374324799,
-0.03764036297798157,
-0.36039459705352783,
-0.2964077293872833,
-0.16005247831344604,
-0.39466238021850586,
-0.9944411516189575,
0.5731582045555115,
0.3097568452358246,
-0.30933988094329834,
-0.0032190619967877865,
-0.16332367062568665,
-0.30206117033958435,
0.21682950854301453,
0.3264913856983185,
0.5735315084457397,
-0.06855212897062302,
0.040773194283246994,
-0.22452834248542786,
0.0008005595300346613,
-0.09803176671266556,
0.2577771842479706,
0.5092690587043762,
0.25067633390426636,
-0.3828105032444,
-0.4209180474281311,
0.26869305968284607,
0.6368957161903381,
-0.8039067387580872,
0.6624205708503723,
0.7275617122650146,
-0.570580780506134,
-0.0012712356401607394,
-0.42345359921455383,
0.2510819435119629,
-0.39177969098091125,
0.5591040253639221,
-0.5764710307121277,
-0.49057793617248535,
0.618208110332489,
0.031600840389728546,
0.294770747423172,
0.32558223605155945,
0.17348790168762207,
-0.1665613204240799,
0.7774367928504944,
0.7331517934799194,
0.34751445055007935,
0.7933017015457153,
-0.2218186855316162,
0.12180572748184204,
-1.2733622789382935,
-0.7390134334564209,
-0.44841983914375305,
0.08111109584569931,
-0.3588663637638092,
-0.3592781722545624,
0.16383643448352814,
0.2818760573863983,
0.23988963663578033,
0.3469895124435425,
-0.12024621665477753,
0.10905762761831284,
0.33720341324806213,
0.030628396198153496,
0.37547627091407776,
0.11449964344501495,
-0.19991439580917358,
-0.39554402232170105,
-0.4771673083305359,
-0.2615746557712555,
0.8206807374954224,
0.4213596284389496,
0.8231709599494934,
0.3265109360218048,
0.7651249766349792,
-0.09852404147386551,
0.44429904222488403,
-0.6881766319274902,
0.4195668399333954,
-0.04214705899357796,
-0.09264935553073883,
-0.2736392319202423,
-0.40223243832588196,
-1.0985349416732788,
0.6824634075164795,
-0.2528479993343353,
-0.7517463564872742,
0.3669002652168274,
0.03134281188249588,
-0.18460051715373993,
0.03909428045153618,
-0.8962864279747009,
0.9302615523338318,
-0.2411043345928192,
-0.6987107396125793,
0.19145989418029785,
-0.510288655757904,
0.5441762804985046,
0.008253267966210842,
0.24806885421276093,
0.09485730528831482,
0.1387593299150467,
0.6912866234779358,
-0.3195156157016754,
0.15686576068401337,
-0.1519414335489273,
-0.36538931727409363,
-0.10382094234228134,
0.3369798958301544,
0.45737919211387634,
0.13924606144428253,
-0.15437451004981995,
-0.09433837234973907,
-0.22885213792324066,
0.01923767291009426,
-0.9767563343048096,
0.813174843788147,
-0.5603410601615906,
-0.35445263981819153,
-0.1689162254333496,
-0.6481331586837769,
-0.14643587172031403,
0.39561328291893005,
-0.0018534715054556727,
0.6920531392097473,
-0.3125591576099396,
0.30753791332244873,
0.7680264115333557,
-0.3238093852996826,
0.39565491676330566,
0.2872896194458008,
-0.7211300730705261,
-0.46300673484802246,
0.9260455965995789,
-0.1084822416305542,
0.09742216765880585,
0.4673331081867218,
-0.12755322456359863,
-0.5599542856216431,
-0.5142443776130676,
-0.2369167059659958,
0.3548930883407593,
-0.8143106698989868,
-0.1480388641357422,
-0.9772503972053528,
-0.3444858193397522,
-0.43824243545532227,
-0.13866056501865387,
-0.24085408449172974,
-0.20773100852966309,
-0.5742613673210144,
-0.07237359136343002,
-0.03357253223657608,
0.6846933364868164,
0.18287165462970734,
0.15264414250850677,
-0.7773868441581726,
0.8501139879226685,
0.20487886667251587,
0.3459438681602478,
-0.12500153481960297,
-0.4625464677810669,
-0.17832264304161072,
-0.40659981966018677,
-0.4243587553501129,
-0.9569430351257324,
0.7604398727416992,
-0.0015123934717848897,
0.6599530577659607,
0.5109075903892517,
-0.393559068441391,
0.9428061246871948,
-0.4374919533729553,
0.5492205023765564,
0.09252092242240906,
-0.5485537648200989,
0.6705504655838013,
-0.4134889543056488,
0.27702564001083374,
0.16676853597164154,
0.06087910756468773,
-0.3543730080127716,
0.026047293096780777,
-0.8530997633934021,
-0.8923354744911194,
0.6779958605766296,
0.4679449200630188,
-0.3585816025733948,
0.14577849209308624,
0.30146947503089905,
-0.0536557100713253,
0.11605081707239151,
-0.7598909139633179,
-0.035289302468299866,
-0.27760225534439087,
-0.10515442490577698,
0.2203311026096344,
-0.3841910660266876,
0.04832978546619415,
-0.1283358782529831,
0.3171946704387665,
0.1010897234082222,
0.17744147777557373,
0.13937318325042725,
-0.4688638150691986,
0.19422398507595062,
0.10273151099681854,
0.5158862471580505,
0.7390286326408386,
-0.4976832866668701,
0.21071824431419373,
-0.19103525578975677,
-0.32519838213920593,
-0.2641659677028656,
0.36059123277664185,
0.0456489659845829,
0.001422578003257513,
0.7243261933326721,
0.8986643552780151,
0.34188854694366455,
-0.2956942915916443,
0.6113032698631287,
-0.34337317943573,
-0.18567445874214172,
0.018488572910428047,
0.09552846103906631,
0.0072887958958745,
0.09944473206996918,
0.14140933752059937,
0.09308618307113647,
0.15194058418273926,
-0.2975079119205475,
0.4370753765106201,
0.7089250683784485,
-0.4157719016075134,
-0.13653862476348877,
0.7361599802970886,
0.3213149607181549,
-0.4057789444923401,
0.6500852108001709,
-0.02528478018939495,
-0.23362772166728973,
0.49714457988739014,
0.5088397264480591,
0.5329675078392029,
0.07359226793050766,
0.12166623771190643,
0.25600460171699524,
0.24702082574367523,
0.39531853795051575,
0.06531549245119095,
-0.24892228841781616,
-0.7176799774169922,
-0.2719776928424835,
-0.739979088306427,
-0.10528535395860672,
0.32683148980140686,
-0.8200719952583313,
0.4004381597042084,
-0.3008522689342499,
0.2285391390323639,
0.01040598750114441,
-0.011515581980347633,
-0.8131367564201355,
0.2959352433681488,
0.26287513971328735,
0.9343351721763611,
-0.6449717879295349,
0.9540200233459473,
0.53041011095047,
-0.2895643711090088,
-0.5919108390808105,
-0.010972172021865845,
-0.1470264345407486,
-0.5883411169052124,
0.7107530236244202,
0.21807682514190674,
0.05032707378268242,
0.013033488765358925,
-0.24682219326496124,
-0.8920043110847473,
1.1715515851974487,
0.27175596356391907,
-0.309132844209671,
-0.13336776196956635,
-0.31025421619415283,
0.5462431311607361,
-0.4902747869491577,
0.36995652318000793,
0.41611167788505554,
0.24047711491584778,
0.22280551493167877,
-0.4543556869029999,
-0.1673208624124527,
-0.37592756748199463,
0.27268505096435547,
0.18220777809619904,
-0.27614328265190125,
0.5838713049888611,
-0.1101689264178276,
-0.3326337933540344,
0.05328426882624626,
1.012644648551941,
0.48771220445632935,
0.23765242099761963,
0.461860716342926,
0.5449730157852173,
0.7000716328620911,
-0.11229963600635529,
1.0478817224502563,
0.017010429874062538,
0.1800280064344406,
1.433901071548462,
-0.4878968298435211,
0.6245173215866089,
0.5482532382011414,
0.22083504498004913,
0.4090929627418518,
0.6416337490081787,
0.08018813282251358,
0.7886239290237427,
-0.20082084834575653,
0.12501297891139984,
-0.21011757850646973,
-0.004371492192149162,
-0.3658929467201233,
0.43141958117485046,
0.5150905251502991,
-0.6952715516090393,
-0.31789904832839966,
-0.10407096892595291,
-0.15913021564483643,
0.03255758062005043,
-0.07327944040298462,
0.9682164192199707,
-0.06937643885612488,
-0.5783618092536926,
0.15676349401474,
-0.017973365262150764,
0.23400525748729706,
-0.5633673071861267,
-0.28965744376182556,
-0.2523401081562042,
-0.1664496213197708,
-0.17302574217319489,
-0.8300836086273193,
0.16348224878311157,
-0.2215479016304016,
-0.27407094836235046,
-0.2226247489452362,
0.912331759929657,
-0.5178007483482361,
-0.3210820257663727,
0.3058270514011383,
0.5877567529678345,
-0.1693083941936493,
0.0737483948469162,
-0.37507832050323486,
0.31757572293281555,
0.2265697419643402,
-0.2705460786819458,
0.3003781735897064,
0.636914849281311,
-0.09691708534955978,
0.5729825496673584,
0.6943551301956177,
0.05639587715268135,
0.06824644654989243,
0.30020758509635925,
0.9533982872962952,
-0.5549831390380859,
-0.6042760014533997,
-0.8540015816688538,
0.6046768426895142,
-0.6228986978530884,
-0.22079607844352722,
0.8650058507919312,
0.6848750114440918,
0.4051789939403534,
0.0796884149312973,
0.6318045854568481,
0.2340007871389389,
0.14889061450958252,
-0.6857897639274597,
0.5592593550682068,
-0.6515249609947205,
0.37746596336364746,
-0.6747806072235107,
-1.1950331926345825,
-0.6867172718048096,
0.6733620762825012,
-0.28144192695617676,
-0.16601847112178802,
0.7620934844017029,
0.5500697493553162,
-0.331135630607605,
0.04209516569972038,
0.4174063503742218,
-0.015189098194241524,
0.7374520301818848,
0.10938961058855057,
0.765304684638977,
-0.20690244436264038,
0.5887670516967773,
-0.39307963848114014,
-0.11571396142244339,
-0.14035412669181824,
-0.8725060820579529,
-0.9621466398239136,
-0.5577697157859802,
-0.22030799090862274,
-0.1705714464187622,
-0.27525216341018677,
0.3215538561344147,
0.5102970004081726,
-0.08333054184913635,
0.24975423514842987,
0.0656958743929863,
0.4464148283004761,
0.09832131862640381,
-0.19357845187187195,
0.7033675312995911,
0.11431354284286499,
-0.4583587646484375,
0.3693869709968567,
0.6722879409790039,
0.20772242546081543,
-0.2165825217962265,
0.05937308818101883,
-0.43345317244529724,
-0.08592461794614792,
0.6378321051597595,
0.03315921127796173,
-0.6614168286323547,
-0.14772965013980865,
-0.13941161334514618,
-0.1889379769563675,
0.4376372992992401,
0.6903173923492432,
-0.6701368689537048,
0.5985698699951172,
0.6093826293945312,
0.3955138921737671,
0.674460232257843,
0.39089158177375793,
0.4608774781227112,
-0.9601620435714722,
0.3148849904537201,
-0.21816782653331757,
0.6249960660934448,
0.5435028076171875,
-0.40499478578567505,
0.6325100660324097,
0.21135859191417694,
-0.29169216752052307,
-0.753841757774353,
0.34803274273872375,
-1.110599160194397,
-0.05046578496694565,
1.1872259378433228,
-0.25465232133865356,
-0.34565433859825134,
-0.08855348080396652,
-0.5161707401275635,
0.31107664108276367,
-0.21953752636909485,
0.355236291885376,
0.4293074607849121,
-0.3525784909725189,
-0.47003045678138733,
-0.309531569480896,
0.38726821541786194,
0.12913520634174347,
-1.0869097709655762,
0.2842731177806854,
0.6997836828231812,
-0.09328193962574005,
0.35951098799705505,
0.5247777104377747,
-0.19412796199321747,
0.19527095556259155,
-0.11690206080675125,
0.028256211429834366,
-0.22107426822185516,
-0.4786427915096283,
-0.13635721802711487,
0.5773023962974548,
-0.09744899719953537,
-0.05501410365104675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10838v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10838v1
|
Dynamic Self-adaptive Multiscale Distillation from Pre-trained Multimodal Large Model for Efficient Cross-modal Representation Learning
| 2024-04-16T18:22:49 | 2024-04-16T18:22:49 |
Zhengyang Liang, Meiyu Liang, Wei Huang, Yawen Li, Zhe Xue
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
In recent years, pre-trained multimodal large models have attracted
widespread attention due to their outstanding performance in various multimodal
applications. Nonetheless, the extensive computational resources and vast
datasets required for their training present significant hurdles for deployment
in environments with limited computational resources. To address this
challenge, we propose a novel dynamic self-adaptive multiscale distillation
from pre-trained multimodal large model for efficient cross-modal
representation learning for the first time. Unlike existing distillation
methods, our strategy employs a multiscale perspective, enabling the extraction
structural knowledge across from the pre-trained multimodal large model.
Ensuring that the student model inherits a comprehensive and nuanced
understanding of the teacher knowledge. To optimize each distillation loss in a
balanced and efficient manner, we propose a dynamic self-adaptive distillation
loss balancer, a novel component eliminating the need for manual loss weight
adjustments and dynamically balances each loss item during the distillation
process. Our methodology streamlines pre-trained multimodal large models using
only their output features and original image-level information, requiring
minimal computational resources. This efficient approach is suited for various
applications and allows the deployment of advanced multimodal technologies even
in resource-limited settings. Extensive experiments has demonstrated that our
method maintains high performance while significantly reducing model complexity
and training costs. Moreover, our distilled student model utilizes only
image-level information to achieve state-of-the-art performance on cross-modal
retrieval tasks, surpassing previous methods that relied on region-level
information.
|
[
-0.35054996609687805,
-0.5334751009941101,
0.5178670287132263,
0.33824509382247925,
-0.45704782009124756,
0.357633113861084,
-0.07146114110946655,
-0.0056428308598697186,
0.12439548969268799,
0.03146524727344513,
-0.688312828540802,
0.1099720224738121,
-0.7352383732795715,
-0.0011890737805515528,
-0.035959403961896896,
0.9006562232971191,
-0.017614874988794327,
0.28735101222991943,
-0.22559216618537903,
-0.281766414642334,
-0.7622970938682556,
-0.3254036605358124,
-0.3814411759376526,
-0.48889923095703125,
0.6118770241737366,
0.0811857059597969,
0.21023070812225342,
0.3687007427215576,
0.22243882715702057,
0.5066982507705688,
0.046736955642700195,
-0.015592099167406559,
-0.46644243597984314,
0.1663140207529068,
-0.44700556993484497,
-0.2650621235370636,
-0.5226384401321411,
-0.07977961748838425,
0.710972785949707,
0.40822848677635193,
-0.38217002153396606,
0.2511872947216034,
0.41305115818977356,
0.6006467342376709,
-0.9079384803771973,
0.17006050050258636,
-0.7099944353103638,
0.2881970703601837,
-0.025555703788995743,
-0.29310643672943115,
-0.25072312355041504,
0.059180211275815964,
0.16565485298633575,
-0.6503496170043945,
0.06102629378437996,
-0.34061476588249207,
0.322799950838089,
0.491749107837677,
-0.9081901907920837,
-0.14816218614578247,
-0.6603877544403076,
0.8083440065383911,
-0.40434667468070984,
0.4475823938846588,
-0.07435640692710876,
0.7335050106048584,
0.04567909985780716,
-0.9842702746391296,
-0.6199617385864258,
0.05286350101232529,
0.1719321310520172,
0.24159792065620422,
-0.3229512572288513,
-0.178750678896904,
0.08558646589517593,
0.4273499548435211,
-0.36131128668785095,
-0.1543121337890625,
-0.18615278601646423,
-0.16100099682807922,
0.2729777693748474,
0.24319793283939362,
-0.10876832902431488,
-0.0555984266102314,
-0.6719585061073303,
-0.36016666889190674,
0.08748216181993484,
-0.07865238934755325,
0.041978515684604645,
0.1450348049402237,
-0.19308976829051971,
0.1328124850988388,
-0.03322756290435791,
0.36032989621162415,
0.6237436532974243,
-0.4758022129535675,
0.44860124588012695,
-0.54380863904953,
-0.28511911630630493,
0.16920149326324463,
0.5898881554603577,
0.16659705340862274,
-0.1083277240395546,
0.40570300817489624,
-0.18860197067260742,
-0.3171045482158661,
0.3083796203136444,
-1.125840187072754,
-0.4938882887363434,
-0.26936832070350647,
-0.4668130874633789,
-0.2571920156478882,
-0.41359615325927734,
-0.7976346015930176,
-0.48706290125846863,
-0.41907626390457153,
0.9176567792892456,
-0.1848013699054718,
-0.5442303419113159,
-0.2219819873571396,
-0.11359188705682755,
-0.2970171570777893,
0.550470232963562,
-0.7945002317428589,
0.042191434651613235,
-0.1130114495754242,
0.8670172095298767,
-0.04284669831395149,
-0.277647465467453,
-0.20359723269939423,
0.289115309715271,
-0.05380748584866524,
0.19614046812057495,
-0.4303715229034424,
-0.27060940861701965,
-0.5822591781616211,
0.1379394829273224,
0.13201987743377686,
-0.534019410610199,
-0.07480785250663757,
-0.4688622057437897,
0.01327134296298027,
-0.16062462329864502,
-0.09437911957502365,
-0.35808515548706055,
0.3077961802482605,
-0.6974205374717712,
0.8205605745315552,
-0.042468585073947906,
-0.6743848323822021,
0.47468745708465576,
-0.32817941904067993,
-0.33452272415161133,
-0.07400373369455338,
-0.1070747822523117,
-0.5817893147468567,
0.2686731517314911,
0.2470182180404663,
0.41621342301368713,
-0.2641311287879944,
0.3153878152370453,
-0.48113974928855896,
0.1175103411078453,
0.07988491654396057,
-1.059841513633728,
0.5735136866569519,
0.3469971716403961,
-0.4209865927696228,
0.13251356780529022,
-1.0332555770874023,
-0.11379557102918625,
0.19077108800411224,
-0.40248897671699524,
-0.37948548793792725,
-0.15782926976680756,
0.08495475351810455,
0.3774244487285614,
0.43238332867622375,
-0.49923649430274963,
0.19302499294281006,
0.3844376504421234,
0.3906405568122864,
0.904809296131134,
-0.0932982936501503,
0.5303880572319031,
-0.031954675912857056,
0.4559796154499054,
0.2756057679653168,
0.18520420789718628,
-0.41515785455703735,
0.18957193195819855,
-0.3994840383529663,
-0.7292985916137695,
0.1941111534833908,
0.18572865426540375,
-1.0128087997436523,
0.24522000551223755,
-0.13574999570846558,
-0.6439493298530579,
-0.1097077950835228,
0.32005855441093445,
0.1786140650510788,
0.6641212105751038,
0.6450021862983704,
-0.2400542050600052,
-0.4942479133605957,
-0.7034099698066711,
0.1487928032875061,
0.18347665667533875,
0.04631642624735832,
0.12675559520721436,
0.3602340817451477,
-0.09179496020078659,
0.7192987203598022,
-0.5806340575218201,
-0.6392962336540222,
-0.2575415372848511,
0.4210670590400696,
0.08978530019521713,
0.5854992270469666,
0.7912083268165588,
-0.8544469475746155,
-0.5302267074584961,
-0.02358025126159191,
-0.6405776739120483,
-0.19057898223400116,
-0.41142284870147705,
-0.015960339456796646,
-0.1797911375761032,
0.37120822072029114,
-0.1639239490032196,
0.2127588540315628,
0.864881157875061,
-0.3058680295944214,
0.32247194647789,
-0.6368564963340759,
0.19270490109920502,
-1.2880375385284424,
-0.02849419228732586,
0.060256652534008026,
-0.39199769496917725,
-0.18223688006401062,
-0.3558611273765564,
0.3216705620288849,
-0.15852968394756317,
-0.42318323254585266,
0.2853951156139374,
-0.7199458479881287,
0.2139514982700348,
-0.5722077488899231,
-0.29935163259506226,
0.32970428466796875,
0.4998578727245331,
-0.10960082709789276,
0.46297451853752136,
0.5164332985877991,
-0.38816118240356445,
0.6539247035980225,
-0.16521741449832916,
-0.25134122371673584,
0.8786467909812927,
-0.4453449845314026,
-0.2815634608268738,
-0.24296805262565613,
0.6383683085441589,
-0.974986732006073,
0.09725181758403778,
0.06796509027481079,
-0.04058456793427467,
0.541232168674469,
-0.30157923698425293,
0.1107342392206192,
-0.205735445022583,
-0.048372648656368256,
0.8696486949920654,
0.2333955615758896,
-0.6492128968238831,
1.297358751296997,
0.23007141053676605,
-0.2032168209552765,
-0.5580664277076721,
-0.7599449157714844,
-0.06726308912038803,
-0.19292646646499634,
-0.2686556577682495,
0.30765894055366516,
-0.20330122113227844,
0.33391010761260986,
-0.14921502768993378,
-0.5941827297210693,
-0.3670332431793213,
0.12458284944295883,
0.21390923857688904,
0.10265763103961945,
-0.07918918877840042,
0.18076829612255096,
0.21894247829914093,
-0.08043675869703293,
0.0013915770687162876,
-0.17870087921619415,
0.5580935478210449,
0.05063185468316078,
-0.29822108149528503,
-0.7462291717529297,
0.1647450476884842,
0.9754674434661865,
-0.27127256989479065,
0.5718308091163635,
0.7449530959129333,
-0.24757696688175201,
-0.19641220569610596,
-0.6095792055130005,
-0.11165277659893036,
-0.5900274515151978,
0.8249760866165161,
-0.5848984122276306,
-0.4768209457397461,
0.5250059962272644,
-0.20826084911823273,
-0.18430110812187195,
0.29598453640937805,
0.8346354365348816,
-0.09563125669956207,
0.899766743183136,
0.584050714969635,
0.1412927210330963,
0.8605953454971313,
-0.3121042847633362,
-0.0679103434085846,
-0.49616241455078125,
-0.5686343312263489,
-0.13964587450027466,
-0.6954360008239746,
-0.34350812435150146,
-0.5957883596420288,
0.6351979970932007,
-0.15776456892490387,
-0.234019473195076,
0.006595445331186056,
-0.44903048872947693,
0.444550096988678,
0.3882720172405243,
0.3138362765312195,
0.27339085936546326,
-0.10717985779047012,
-0.15782204270362854,
-0.07359067350625992,
-0.6306676268577576,
0.0792090967297554,
0.9117841720581055,
0.3649745285511017,
1.3587393760681152,
-0.037578608840703964,
0.6059423685073853,
0.4211314916610718,
-0.10027854144573212,
-0.5993855595588684,
0.3261639475822449,
-0.03807372599840164,
-0.5814172625541687,
-0.3003270924091339,
-0.7027173042297363,
-0.6371471881866455,
0.6940842270851135,
-0.5430201292037964,
0.047045234590768814,
0.4434550702571869,
0.4865555167198181,
-0.4041808545589447,
0.6041767001152039,
-0.721740186214447,
1.0670455694198608,
-0.7434026002883911,
-0.5181639790534973,
-0.4576668441295624,
-0.5367969870567322,
0.16061845421791077,
-0.5260984897613525,
0.21670891344547272,
-0.06275158375501633,
0.014507511630654335,
0.4072290062904358,
-0.4288616180419922,
0.7588935494422913,
-0.6574485301971436,
-0.24528558552265167,
0.24901871383190155,
0.22265751659870148,
0.2411390095949173,
0.05524272471666336,
0.21464283764362335,
0.18289504945278168,
0.2856312394142151,
-0.3410092294216156,
-0.8226594924926758,
0.6966479420661926,
-0.7853472232818604,
-0.48770076036453247,
-0.6640568375587463,
-0.6685119867324829,
0.19141414761543274,
0.437214195728302,
-0.12213952094316483,
0.3768101632595062,
-0.04205450043082237,
0.5333579182624817,
0.4142005741596222,
-0.0809900090098381,
0.7837021946907043,
0.4279254078865051,
-0.018568428233265877,
-0.6638897061347961,
0.8864219188690186,
0.35063061118125916,
0.35679736733436584,
0.27371981739997864,
0.4027390480041504,
-0.46634361147880554,
-0.44268375635147095,
-0.5095816850662231,
-0.18812015652656555,
-0.559450626373291,
-0.36884674429893494,
-0.6313070058822632,
0.08367596566677094,
-0.21220695972442627,
-0.0424971841275692,
-0.8169212341308594,
-0.27707162499427795,
-0.31238383054733276,
0.16587407886981964,
-0.022577011957764626,
0.47112563252449036,
-0.21186146140098572,
0.37504565715789795,
-0.7940278649330139,
0.4531589150428772,
0.8489720225334167,
0.3146311938762665,
0.2853843569755554,
-0.5439865589141846,
-0.3495197296142578,
0.15480168163776398,
-0.6308497786521912,
-0.7260068655014038,
0.29541635513305664,
0.5321359038352966,
0.5433520674705505,
0.39046475291252136,
0.17182610929012299,
1.0466071367263794,
-0.48972204327583313,
0.4486689567565918,
0.5966265201568604,
-1.0024675130844116,
0.2680545449256897,
-0.02917032316327095,
0.6988279819488525,
0.6135187149047852,
0.6250578761100769,
-0.09801400452852249,
0.20947265625,
-0.08976006507873535,
-0.762959361076355,
0.7057317495346069,
-0.22094231843948364,
0.2751421332359314,
0.3673843443393707,
0.05901927500963211,
0.3242965042591095,
0.16508106887340546,
-1.0710450410842896,
-0.009707622230052948,
-0.7709900736808777,
-0.3730493485927582,
0.03253401443362236,
-0.2109602987766266,
-0.06967485696077347,
-0.5077835321426392,
0.6134684681892395,
-0.4164493680000305,
-0.2044912725687027,
0.058455515652894974,
-0.39008650183677673,
-0.019558729603886604,
0.03715324029326439,
0.37881821393966675,
0.7586464881896973,
-0.11200042814016342,
0.43095293641090393,
0.5488799810409546,
-0.5820741057395935,
0.5717004537582397,
0.13473473489284515,
0.2884407639503479,
-0.33756133913993835,
0.13433828949928284,
0.8059858083724976,
0.3514491617679596,
-0.42763254046440125,
0.6734703779220581,
-0.2526985704898834,
-0.16295850276947021,
-0.2814573049545288,
-0.09731388837099075,
-0.0033838108647614717,
0.9226595759391785,
0.7334479689598083,
0.059630539268255234,
0.015758167952299118,
-0.5734891891479492,
0.21323497593402863,
0.3749525547027588,
-0.1108531653881073,
-0.32250380516052246,
0.8092792630195618,
0.2569634020328522,
0.28806644678115845,
0.44252803921699524,
0.18322283029556274,
-0.25335493683815,
0.3502539396286011,
0.526388943195343,
0.8373587727546692,
-0.5694695115089417,
0.0775846615433693,
0.2547268569469452,
0.04437787085771561,
0.1309259831905365,
0.06406133621931076,
-0.49442175030708313,
-0.4747031033039093,
-0.2965717911720276,
-0.8243312239646912,
-0.0445634089410305,
-0.0971066951751709,
-0.5551272034645081,
0.2294882833957672,
-0.6704962849617004,
-0.37159353494644165,
0.04799417778849602,
-0.21004514396190643,
-0.42574840784072876,
0.3882577121257782,
0.3932413160800934,
0.5263019800186157,
-0.9749977588653564,
0.9316191673278809,
0.5357010364532471,
-0.2104666531085968,
-0.533270001411438,
-0.1789616346359253,
0.08019497245550156,
-0.4323686361312866,
0.8254727721214294,
-0.01802746392786503,
-0.23088601231575012,
-0.08757855743169785,
-0.015336574986577034,
-0.9839629530906677,
1.469394564628601,
0.5758744478225708,
-0.7880143523216248,
-0.19493412971496582,
0.056570228189229965,
0.3526575267314911,
-0.30123814940452576,
0.490579754114151,
-0.0372830294072628,
0.36223605275154114,
0.6603515148162842,
-1.0232486724853516,
0.04249035567045212,
-0.19344401359558105,
0.1893533617258072,
0.0631260871887207,
-0.7518430948257446,
1.1047176122665405,
0.006484920158982277,
0.05013009160757065,
-0.3220385015010834,
0.8361687064170837,
-0.03705857694149017,
0.3055775761604309,
0.8666295409202576,
0.486797034740448,
0.44944754242897034,
0.029993511736392975,
0.47963637113571167,
-0.17594140768051147,
0.4572509825229645,
1.3068689107894897,
-0.18012888729572296,
0.36384499073028564,
0.591154932975769,
-0.01738223433494568,
0.47912004590034485,
0.34093567728996277,
0.014162139967083931,
0.9205650687217712,
0.008007228374481201,
-0.3171488046646118,
-0.4923393130302429,
0.22912545502185822,
-0.44275006651878357,
0.771186351776123,
-0.017946943640708923,
-0.3586856424808502,
-0.5698238015174866,
0.5317804217338562,
-0.41020864248275757,
-0.16953641176223755,
-0.4257514774799347,
0.6915435791015625,
-0.16103868186473846,
-0.31228646636009216,
0.7698202133178711,
-0.23465366661548615,
0.7594662308692932,
-0.7888490557670593,
-0.14468196034431458,
-0.0244576595723629,
0.4837740659713745,
-0.1141849160194397,
-0.4370070993900299,
0.13613134622573853,
-0.3367680609226227,
-0.34022748470306396,
-0.44638755917549133,
0.5048040151596069,
-0.6686232089996338,
-0.6327643394470215,
0.3545496165752411,
0.27239271998405457,
-0.3655907213687897,
-0.1336752474308014,
-0.6507883071899414,
0.2239585816860199,
-0.11669518798589706,
-0.3149090111255646,
0.4488072991371155,
0.7880892753601074,
0.10539987683296204,
0.673222541809082,
0.38290998339653015,
-0.11877813190221786,
0.3984532058238983,
-0.14268556237220764,
1.1562130451202393,
-0.39275622367858887,
-0.5072262287139893,
-0.7983689904212952,
0.590976357460022,
0.041909974068403244,
-0.03569233417510986,
0.5431539416313171,
0.47989025712013245,
0.8837752938270569,
-0.13427773118019104,
0.5229281187057495,
-0.12679308652877808,
0.05587435141205788,
-0.3241741359233856,
0.8677542805671692,
-1.0059818029403687,
-0.015421131625771523,
-0.36241403222084045,
-1.0374013185501099,
0.10621889680624008,
0.7213611006736755,
0.03481902927160263,
0.37194204330444336,
0.4373319745063782,
0.5409712195396423,
-0.4502616226673126,
-0.19662217795848846,
0.3600139021873474,
0.36092668771743774,
0.35643166303634644,
0.38608068227767944,
0.6153776049613953,
-0.2805507481098175,
0.5733345150947571,
-0.43552201986312866,
-0.5120524168014526,
-0.10768318176269531,
-1.0555002689361572,
-0.6952043175697327,
-0.6063138842582703,
-0.28742900490760803,
-0.03692733868956566,
-0.12936581671237946,
1.0302726030349731,
0.8087517619132996,
-0.5615605711936951,
-0.21519380807876587,
0.40399688482284546,
-0.2474336177110672,
-0.19396738708019257,
-0.1872154176235199,
0.0686158761382103,
-0.15572082996368408,
-0.8652767539024353,
0.4927327036857605,
0.1812748908996582,
0.16866126656532288,
-0.37750527262687683,
0.05621321499347687,
-0.5460067987442017,
-0.13810621201992035,
0.7634146809577942,
0.057104382663965225,
-0.3025304675102234,
-0.14572761952877045,
-0.3653438985347748,
0.1038883775472641,
0.060003235936164856,
0.6754888296127319,
-0.879466712474823,
0.8643495440483093,
0.5452881455421448,
0.7328866124153137,
0.8635261058807373,
-0.17016218602657318,
0.40050721168518066,
-0.6922728419303894,
0.2385871261358261,
0.12254648655653,
0.43258222937583923,
0.09495134651660919,
-0.06941509991884232,
0.08006654679775238,
0.44319406151771545,
-0.3881641924381256,
-0.6889152526855469,
0.03602505102753639,
-1.1234045028686523,
-0.539033830165863,
0.3897956609725952,
-0.1878129094839096,
-0.1742219477891922,
0.30171525478363037,
-0.37655943632125854,
0.5490950345993042,
-0.2628141939640045,
0.897114098072052,
0.3685688078403473,
0.05108874663710594,
-0.380199134349823,
0.0991632491350174,
-0.022293565794825554,
0.42041701078414917,
-0.4550381004810333,
0.05896222963929176,
0.6873372793197632,
0.6972449421882629,
0.17187447845935822,
0.2892070710659027,
-0.12538212537765503,
0.0646548792719841,
-0.014585673809051514,
0.2990490198135376,
-0.5398714542388916,
-0.6792461276054382,
-0.35322508215904236,
0.46204957365989685,
-0.2464919239282608,
-0.3141942024230957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10830v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10830v2
|
Fewer Truncations Improve Language Modeling
| 2024-04-16T18:08:29 | 2024-05-02T17:10:44 |
Hantian Ding, Zijian Wang, Giovanni Paolini, Varun Kumar, Anoop Deoras, Dan Roth, Stefano Soatto
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In large language model training, input documents are typically concatenated
together and then split into sequences of equal length to avoid padding tokens.
Despite its efficiency, the concatenation approach compromises data integrity
-- it inevitably breaks many documents into incomplete pieces, leading to
excessive truncations that hinder the model from learning to compose logically
coherent and factually consistent content that is grounded on the complete
context. To address the issue, we propose Best-fit Packing, a scalable and
efficient method that packs documents into training sequences through
length-aware combinatorial optimization. Our method completely eliminates
unnecessary truncations while retaining the same training efficiency as
concatenation. Empirical results from both text and code pre-training show that
our method achieves superior performance (e.g., relatively +4.7% on reading
comprehension; +16.8% in context following; and +9.2% on program synthesis),
and reduces closed-domain hallucination effectively by up to 58.3%.
|
[
-0.4229721426963806,
-0.6371628642082214,
0.3361356258392334,
-0.00655712466686964,
-0.551827609539032,
0.18531611561775208,
-0.34317073225975037,
-0.5455645322799683,
0.016490483656525612,
0.4387262463569641,
-0.4304220974445343,
-0.2720540463924408,
-0.6056178212165833,
-0.012412738986313343,
-0.547720730304718,
0.8116486668586731,
0.10383811593055725,
-0.23865461349487305,
-0.40373021364212036,
-0.01332250889390707,
-0.41011685132980347,
-0.6434855461120605,
-0.34099331498146057,
-0.3186158835887909,
0.25302252173423767,
0.403998464345932,
0.7799544334411621,
1.0725778341293335,
0.4196895360946655,
0.2692374885082245,
-0.20098832249641418,
0.5318130254745483,
-0.6688963174819946,
0.12829285860061646,
0.3293202817440033,
-0.33041879534721375,
-0.29941433668136597,
-0.042452916502952576,
0.706847608089447,
0.78848797082901,
-0.37119942903518677,
0.11493311822414398,
0.2423657327890396,
0.8144619464874268,
-0.5946940183639526,
-0.09524795413017273,
-0.40215304493904114,
-0.013342924416065216,
-0.24457427859306335,
-0.46257033944129944,
-0.7304832935333252,
-0.3139156699180603,
0.16895577311515808,
-0.5831997990608215,
0.2146717756986618,
-0.031835246831178665,
0.6609053611755371,
0.25774019956588745,
-0.15713602304458618,
-0.22703991830348969,
-0.8833848237991333,
0.774046003818512,
-0.8280482292175293,
0.7115619778633118,
0.4782866835594177,
0.13734900951385498,
-0.4229435324668884,
-0.29435616731643677,
-0.43660303950309753,
0.0578797273337841,
-0.19411487877368927,
-0.3195503056049347,
0.11205197870731354,
0.3173913061618805,
0.42678818106651306,
0.2535608112812042,
-1.1228176355361938,
-0.010864753276109695,
-0.8176017999649048,
-0.1617020070552826,
0.7632607221603394,
-0.21491485834121704,
0.36048761010169983,
0.2138921618461609,
0.09021158516407013,
-0.4389649033546448,
-0.7267076373100281,
-0.023020897060632706,
0.5890865921974182,
0.3158693015575409,
0.03743463754653931,
0.4704500138759613,
0.0813526064157486,
0.9960834383964539,
0.07528954744338989,
-0.3217114806175232,
0.1376057118177414,
-0.3065408170223236,
-0.342589408159256,
-0.012137767858803272,
0.5908791422843933,
0.15794631838798523,
0.4023239016532898,
-0.32330429553985596,
-0.011471017263829708,
-0.12547479569911957,
0.3641078472137451,
-0.8809438943862915,
-0.2186252772808075,
0.32474929094314575,
-0.2949460446834564,
-0.33681395649909973,
0.04827682673931122,
-0.5985583066940308,
0.14429445564746857,
-0.3957279622554779,
0.10205677151679993,
-0.7476880550384521,
0.2231297492980957,
0.3482872247695923,
-0.08472718298435211,
0.10332995653152466,
-0.01836678571999073,
-1.1906886100769043,
0.38414615392684937,
0.7762624621391296,
1.0329753160476685,
-0.18249762058258057,
-0.21521727740764618,
-1.0598788261413574,
0.2801571190357208,
-0.41524696350097656,
0.7887681126594543,
-0.6924681663513184,
-0.5067608952522278,
0.060104597359895706,
-0.32088330388069153,
-0.01563325710594654,
-0.4996185898780823,
0.5897974967956543,
-0.15267381072044373,
0.2788068950176239,
0.11005211621522903,
-0.8142185211181641,
0.013604159466922283,
0.16155540943145752,
-0.6844046115875244,
1.103532314300537,
0.11987810581922531,
-0.4375133216381073,
0.19754637777805328,
-0.31972259283065796,
-0.5870252251625061,
0.08231295645236969,
0.05270436406135559,
-0.5679557919502258,
0.2793990671634674,
0.16879796981811523,
0.2610616087913513,
0.10171516239643097,
0.48007816076278687,
-0.215765118598938,
-0.6617299318313599,
-0.049331191927194595,
-0.18638509511947632,
0.5138205885887146,
0.07252059876918793,
-0.08194563537836075,
-0.052703745663166046,
-0.7338378429412842,
0.25953438878059387,
-0.12097527831792831,
-0.6142844557762146,
-0.47457611560821533,
-0.1461302489042282,
0.03199242800474167,
0.2503204643726349,
-0.14441727101802826,
-0.3857892155647278,
0.48804566264152527,
-0.7654622197151184,
0.3298507630825043,
0.6316031217575073,
-0.29669103026390076,
0.7195790410041809,
-0.5906813144683838,
0.5178055167198181,
-0.19934433698654175,
0.20937283337116241,
-0.09103468805551529,
-0.06889127939939499,
-0.7135630249977112,
-0.1775009036064148,
0.4137493968009949,
0.24173638224601746,
-0.5599024295806885,
0.6343919038772583,
-0.3742394745349884,
-0.6884466409683228,
-0.13684263825416565,
0.23343002796173096,
0.45300212502479553,
0.3012697994709015,
0.33015209436416626,
-0.3457983434200287,
-0.6987975835800171,
-0.640429675579071,
-0.33198827505111694,
-0.06850394606590271,
0.1754053235054016,
-0.24212853610515594,
0.4832497239112854,
-0.12622082233428955,
0.8050336837768555,
-0.5813902616500854,
-0.016982706263661385,
-0.4093327522277832,
-0.03289380297064781,
-0.049550045281648636,
0.7414945960044861,
0.5379565954208374,
-0.5623084306716919,
-0.5594252943992615,
-0.2772204279899597,
-0.25792884826660156,
0.113328717648983,
-0.2885113060474396,
-0.28375357389450073,
0.3423008322715759,
0.3433397710323334,
-0.8129859566688538,
0.45236852765083313,
0.657386302947998,
-0.036571674048900604,
0.5643194317817688,
-0.47314903140068054,
-0.303114116191864,
-0.9105790853500366,
0.09826960414648056,
-0.19115330278873444,
-0.38093841075897217,
-0.8332891464233398,
-0.1317560225725174,
0.053457312285900116,
-0.24211007356643677,
-0.35767489671707153,
0.556758463382721,
-0.47939446568489075,
-0.035158853977918625,
-0.175062358379364,
0.11567961424589157,
0.3039200007915497,
0.49258530139923096,
-0.029339764267206192,
0.8825741410255432,
0.25177624821662903,
-0.719879150390625,
-0.05115751922130585,
0.6096055507659912,
-0.48229584097862244,
0.08965006470680237,
-0.42187801003456116,
0.44797563552856445,
-0.30375608801841736,
0.39745786786079407,
-0.5478915572166443,
-0.12157770991325378,
-0.18629105389118195,
-0.272345632314682,
0.6393084526062012,
0.07801426202058792,
-0.5401269197463989,
-0.37302324175834656,
-0.4986526668071747,
0.5669253468513489,
0.48932981491088867,
-0.5420827865600586,
0.31182411313056946,
0.4014611542224884,
-0.007195404730737209,
-0.5906212329864502,
-0.7886281609535217,
-0.19827596843242645,
-0.18901480734348297,
-0.6509380340576172,
0.3923662006855011,
-0.5783535242080688,
0.23991930484771729,
-0.3990238904953003,
-0.3652348518371582,
-0.29902130365371704,
0.05925382673740387,
-0.09518461674451828,
0.22648297250270844,
0.07684233039617538,
0.12719076871871948,
-0.012834680266678333,
-0.10918973386287689,
-0.4020451009273529,
-0.623264729976654,
0.8115326166152954,
-0.011598524637520313,
-0.10918767750263214,
-0.30593058466911316,
0.7356775999069214,
0.64682936668396,
-0.3672087788581848,
1.0293631553649902,
0.26488155126571655,
-0.45477956533432007,
-0.5779284238815308,
-0.44449901580810547,
-0.12302573025226593,
-0.527968168258667,
0.3148452639579773,
-0.28621408343315125,
-1.0229648351669312,
0.20248545706272125,
0.16103480756282806,
0.25383684039115906,
-0.11706282198429108,
0.005411961581557989,
-0.14605356752872467,
0.798105001449585,
1.0369030237197876,
0.07877368479967117,
0.6832554340362549,
-0.34738048911094666,
0.7640734910964966,
-0.7110535502433777,
-0.18885007500648499,
-0.6364754438400269,
-0.17259977757930756,
-0.47704488039016724,
-0.5644049048423767,
0.12276298552751541,
0.14996035397052765,
0.05050012841820717,
0.5962542295455933,
-0.7933914661407471,
0.8615142703056335,
0.5151901841163635,
-0.017287472262978554,
0.11376337707042694,
0.29952380061149597,
-0.07562001794576645,
-0.11108125746250153,
-0.9215856194496155,
-0.4314011037349701,
0.9702779054641724,
0.09921927750110626,
0.5229637026786804,
-0.00034767092438414693,
0.8824751377105713,
-0.011193829588592052,
-0.08504843711853027,
-0.9121888875961304,
0.48778069019317627,
-0.314223974943161,
-0.15878397226333618,
-0.39207711815834045,
-0.4026406705379486,
-0.9049199223518372,
0.17438600957393646,
-0.10863260179758072,
-0.9157422184944153,
0.17142672836780548,
0.32000231742858887,
-0.44623783230781555,
0.3068494200706482,
-0.5169482231140137,
0.7316337823867798,
-0.253195583820343,
-0.14690692722797394,
0.03510671854019165,
-0.4553278088569641,
0.3594897389411926,
-0.3306562006473541,
0.34345898032188416,
0.11553771793842316,
0.19214724004268646,
0.84111487865448,
-0.709362268447876,
0.38431665301322937,
0.2777974605560303,
0.10747556388378143,
0.13633432984352112,
0.27787670493125916,
0.7362020015716553,
-0.6142018437385559,
-0.04619237035512924,
-0.05706775188446045,
0.28730154037475586,
-0.5359546542167664,
-0.8622704148292542,
0.2764420807361603,
-0.5486900210380554,
-0.37432795763015747,
-0.3707132935523987,
-0.8745662569999695,
-0.32357528805732727,
0.19127853214740753,
0.3880910873413086,
0.7407829761505127,
-0.08765965700149536,
0.4036484658718109,
0.8202489018440247,
-0.16106131672859192,
0.6438242197036743,
0.19129294157028198,
0.13152815401554108,
-0.2912496030330658,
0.8089694976806641,
0.3679812550544739,
0.37398070096969604,
0.4366056025028229,
0.2725549638271332,
-0.2740356922149658,
-0.7772586941719055,
-0.0267914067953825,
0.44645601511001587,
-0.6124365329742432,
-0.19620177149772644,
-0.7143778204917908,
-0.3559987545013428,
-0.5755761861801147,
-0.4532860219478607,
-0.5440468192100525,
-0.5001967549324036,
0.14291781187057495,
-0.22625784575939178,
-0.10576402395963669,
0.5445809364318848,
0.03776665776968002,
0.5807207822799683,
-1.172680139541626,
-0.086512990295887,
-0.0073046511970460415,
0.4873063564300537,
-0.07560991495847702,
-0.3999501168727875,
-0.5148755311965942,
-0.19419926404953003,
-0.35164445638656616,
-0.706058144569397,
0.5902185440063477,
0.3762858510017395,
0.4339236915111542,
0.3336212635040283,
0.1605672836303711,
1.148867130279541,
-0.6405350565910339,
0.5197962522506714,
0.1699763983488083,
-1.0070505142211914,
0.5363264083862305,
-0.26569709181785583,
0.41441646218299866,
0.7236056327819824,
0.06639765948057175,
-0.6460105776786804,
-0.4769953787326813,
-0.7523882389068604,
-0.8373263478279114,
0.6341721415519714,
0.39482662081718445,
0.06498651206493378,
0.037500087171792984,
0.335018128156662,
0.1321752369403839,
0.2224874049425125,
-0.593810498714447,
0.036659713834524155,
0.3852303922176361,
-0.4728406071662903,
-0.05396941676735878,
-0.503750205039978,
-0.002534914528951049,
-0.3322998881340027,
0.8202550411224365,
-0.15974833071231842,
0.16412091255187988,
-0.12321443110704422,
-0.3393229842185974,
-0.15554066002368927,
0.1303018182516098,
0.9909135699272156,
0.9103986620903015,
-0.27917802333831787,
0.1898672878742218,
-0.11353924125432968,
-0.6560063362121582,
0.19892536103725433,
-0.12687242031097412,
-0.36261558532714844,
0.29459965229034424,
0.4584261178970337,
0.7064483165740967,
0.10932684689760208,
-0.8818640112876892,
0.3889259994029999,
-0.008810690604150295,
-0.09068725258111954,
-0.04220614582300186,
0.2634964883327484,
-0.21103285253047943,
-0.05257393419742584,
-0.009268938563764095,
0.08225911110639572,
0.08708430826663971,
-0.45921868085861206,
0.4865574240684509,
0.39487767219543457,
-0.025306809693574905,
-0.09019555896520615,
0.2529318034648895,
0.13793911039829254,
-0.45239412784576416,
0.6608469486236572,
0.12082400918006897,
-0.6152328848838806,
0.47060805559158325,
0.709609866142273,
0.7162038683891296,
-0.29696154594421387,
0.3278746008872986,
0.5739936828613281,
0.5081746578216553,
-0.594574511051178,
-0.13365793228149414,
-0.27190834283828735,
-0.4225844740867615,
-0.4857838749885559,
-0.7214467525482178,
-0.3252831995487213,
0.18420735001564026,
-0.543333113193512,
0.30616381764411926,
-0.2579721212387085,
0.14643196761608124,
-0.33055388927459717,
0.25431787967681885,
-0.5568768978118896,
0.10676351189613342,
0.214479461312294,
1.051160216331482,
-0.893938422203064,
1.0073312520980835,
0.2563263773918152,
-0.27991601824760437,
-1.0421196222305298,
-0.020440101623535156,
-0.15779602527618408,
-0.2181415855884552,
0.12308556586503983,
0.5100573301315308,
0.06572605669498444,
-0.21649694442749023,
-0.4896087944507599,
-1.1696984767913818,
0.7015883326530457,
0.6247227191925049,
-0.8977760076522827,
-0.2855772078037262,
0.2999349534511566,
0.3473449945449829,
-0.39565369486808777,
0.21286368370056152,
0.8818182349205017,
0.3116303086280823,
0.28944164514541626,
-0.8516984581947327,
0.004458921495825052,
-0.24129417538642883,
0.22515541315078735,
0.33694085478782654,
-0.5098186731338501,
0.37379977107048035,
0.018703902140259743,
-0.31203925609588623,
-0.01878972351551056,
0.42444726824760437,
0.3470436930656433,
0.0009638842311687768,
0.36235395073890686,
0.6355944275856018,
1.3829374313354492,
0.06643842905759811,
1.175150752067566,
-0.1480170488357544,
0.31487491726875305,
1.4378044605255127,
0.09559740126132965,
0.7523258328437805,
0.5222389698028564,
-0.0014277322916314006,
0.2613716423511505,
0.7518191933631897,
0.18941554427146912,
0.6505414247512817,
0.21318280696868896,
0.0707801878452301,
-0.2303069829940796,
0.0763014629483223,
-0.17027857899665833,
0.31481602787971497,
0.11839472502470016,
0.013286173343658447,
-0.1414502114057541,
0.025698812678456306,
0.21507057547569275,
0.06694618612527847,
0.20860739052295685,
0.6399728655815125,
0.09462203830480576,
-0.812397837638855,
0.9274910688400269,
-0.1660812497138977,
0.5589450001716614,
-0.6257032155990601,
0.1202126294374466,
-0.42767831683158875,
0.046491071581840515,
-0.20432239770889282,
-0.4392974376678467,
0.6529727578163147,
0.05392090976238251,
-0.19676926732063293,
-0.3620947301387787,
0.3922491669654846,
-0.8767066597938538,
-0.4543824791908264,
0.07453715056180954,
0.15090003609657288,
0.22785718739032745,
0.09831896424293518,
-0.35950976610183716,
0.3464372456073761,
-0.008184985257685184,
-0.15360409021377563,
0.3745478689670563,
0.16120292246341705,
-0.04819246008992195,
0.6494588255882263,
0.8006547689437866,
0.14881344139575958,
0.20948322117328644,
-0.14604271948337555,
0.8566145896911621,
-0.3802359104156494,
-0.6666756868362427,
-0.970486044883728,
0.6663008332252502,
-0.25967511534690857,
-0.109480120241642,
0.22625620663166046,
0.856732189655304,
1.0044702291488647,
0.05856354162096977,
0.6078468561172485,
0.19727107882499695,
-0.13680538535118103,
-0.450831800699234,
0.5235874056816101,
-0.4684624969959259,
0.22812534868717194,
-0.2001771330833435,
-1.1798759698867798,
-0.47935178875923157,
0.7572728991508484,
-0.2744278609752655,
-0.23871898651123047,
0.8973609805107117,
0.5701860785484314,
-0.18984152376651764,
-0.24173606932163239,
0.5056177973747253,
-0.06240545213222504,
0.5728582143783569,
0.7224812507629395,
0.31175974011421204,
-0.560053288936615,
0.746668815612793,
-0.3216894268989563,
0.07625676691532135,
-0.21600821614265442,
-0.7616119384765625,
-1.0119549036026,
-0.5418141484260559,
-0.3939976692199707,
-0.39719563722610474,
0.08063536137342453,
1.002535343170166,
1.1430368423461914,
-0.6288638710975647,
-0.25340965390205383,
-0.21744206547737122,
0.1267196387052536,
-0.09609586745500565,
-0.13466483354568481,
0.483206182718277,
-0.3648240566253662,
-0.7714707851409912,
0.39833366870880127,
0.5240992307662964,
0.26181164383888245,
0.09350007772445679,
-0.23721788823604584,
-0.16605548560619354,
0.422221839427948,
0.5238364934921265,
0.2539984881877899,
-0.4717899560928345,
-0.36041876673698425,
-0.1788305789232254,
-0.1833285540342331,
0.2820969223976135,
0.766825258731842,
-0.5392141342163086,
0.6683571338653564,
0.6662933230400085,
0.8644811511039734,
0.695021390914917,
0.19890299439430237,
0.9531916379928589,
-0.9647351503372192,
0.6005492806434631,
0.30763402581214905,
0.21406301856040955,
0.44704532623291016,
-0.5805808305740356,
0.6328761577606201,
-0.04821866378188133,
-0.4287715554237366,
-1.140889286994934,
0.1855388730764389,
-1.080594539642334,
-0.20219597220420837,
0.9016391038894653,
-0.14606142044067383,
-0.48273327946662903,
0.19151614606380463,
0.07766790688037872,
0.4385489225387573,
-0.2859082520008087,
0.6843528151512146,
0.9313274621963501,
-0.13109807670116425,
-0.3364260196685791,
-0.5680647492408752,
0.6866358518600464,
0.4795190393924713,
-0.8157727718353271,
0.015363122336566448,
0.43245798349380493,
0.16014038026332855,
0.0775163471698761,
0.5700798034667969,
0.16826456785202026,
0.1196606233716011,
-0.2180546224117279,
-0.3048860430717468,
-0.19708749651908875,
-0.5635608434677124,
-0.2501678764820099,
0.13501307368278503,
-0.08327778428792953,
-0.15734612941741943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10774v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10774v1
|
MiniCheck: Efficient Fact-Checking of LLMs on Grounding Documents
| 2024-04-16T17:59:10 | 2024-04-16T17:59:10 |
Liyan Tang, Philippe Laban, Greg Durrett
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recognizing if LLM output can be grounded in evidence is central to many
tasks in NLP: retrieval-augmented generation, summarization, document-grounded
dialogue, and more. Current approaches to this kind of "fact-checking" are
based on verifying each piece of a model generation against potential evidence
using an LLM. However, this process can be very computationally expensive,
requiring many calls to LLMs to check a single response. In this work, we show
how to build small models that have GPT-4-level performance but for 400x lower
cost. We do this by constructing synthetic training data with GPT-4, which
involves creating realistic yet challenging instances of factual errors via a
structured generation procedure. Training on this data teaches models to check
each fact in the claim and recognize synthesis of information across sentences.
For evaluation, we unify pre-existing datasets into a benchmark LLM-AggreFact,
collected from recent work on fact-checking and grounding LLM generations. Our
best system MiniCheck-FT5 (770M parameters) outperforms all systems of
comparable size and reaches GPT-4 accuracy. We release LLM-AggreFact, code for
data synthesis, and models.
|
[
-0.23715102672576904,
-0.6234544515609741,
0.9347144365310669,
-0.20559769868850708,
-0.21724483370780945,
0.06551852077245712,
0.10678240656852722,
-0.35893574357032776,
-0.020383544266223907,
0.4200402498245239,
-0.6416287422180176,
-0.6033499836921692,
-0.4504217207431793,
0.18639692664146423,
-0.6822628378868103,
1.0349363088607788,
0.0611238069832325,
-0.13041216135025024,
-0.35767194628715515,
-0.08161425590515137,
-0.015516458079218864,
-0.6226544380187988,
-0.6863551735877991,
-0.6744460463523865,
0.11663085222244263,
0.42585092782974243,
0.4629494845867157,
0.6894814372062683,
0.35227322578430176,
0.3293322026729584,
-0.036795180290937424,
0.5396530628204346,
-0.48124581575393677,
-0.34983277320861816,
-0.17285224795341492,
-0.5897363424301147,
-0.575555145740509,
0.4599802494049072,
0.48312950134277344,
0.2207004278898239,
-0.09717077016830444,
0.23682868480682373,
-0.10947515070438385,
0.6243957877159119,
-0.3324660658836365,
0.22997665405273438,
-0.8502834439277649,
0.034738898277282715,
-0.08178454637527466,
-0.2248764932155609,
-0.4122105538845062,
-0.5946907997131348,
-0.2003733068704605,
-0.3599182069301605,
0.7763057351112366,
0.2248581200838089,
1.0903890132904053,
0.4180699288845062,
-0.4390676021575928,
-0.5018887519836426,
-0.3523049056529999,
0.4513469338417053,
-0.7296375036239624,
0.3653542399406433,
0.500962495803833,
0.0846729502081871,
-0.18308137357234955,
-0.8247936367988586,
-0.6492145657539368,
-0.35344210267066956,
-0.4371378421783447,
0.155268132686615,
-0.07517094165086746,
0.31114670634269714,
0.7255027294158936,
0.5778343677520752,
-0.5486240386962891,
-0.1468539834022522,
-0.12472797930240631,
-0.3869187533855438,
0.21966561675071716,
0.09624867141246796,
0.20386482775211334,
-0.3009895980358124,
-0.155240997672081,
-0.0300401970744133,
-1.0972623825073242,
-0.11680272221565247,
0.386689692735672,
0.006866978481411934,
-0.03265421465039253,
0.8073726296424866,
-0.4589284658432007,
0.5028961300849915,
0.3806608319282532,
-0.4235055446624756,
-0.10046307742595673,
-0.9255576133728027,
-0.4473799467086792,
0.07021144777536392,
0.4641492962837219,
0.34248313307762146,
-0.3207787871360779,
-0.05377424508333206,
-0.41084393858909607,
0.4078504145145416,
0.04569341614842415,
-0.9499849677085876,
-0.5203839540481567,
0.15592136979103088,
-0.1618809998035431,
-0.6140369176864624,
-0.25254887342453003,
-0.5625453591346741,
-0.4306128919124603,
-0.4108283519744873,
0.301563024520874,
-0.3737167418003082,
0.20515814423561096,
0.07244491577148438,
0.04494987428188324,
0.19963885843753815,
0.41298365592956543,
-0.8142005205154419,
0.3753161132335663,
0.6802313923835754,
0.9753873348236084,
0.07072106003761292,
-0.06115414947271347,
-0.9046947360038757,
0.03523413836956024,
-0.46261879801750183,
0.9562825560569763,
-0.06817807257175446,
-0.03951367735862732,
-0.11368276923894882,
-0.14536702632904053,
0.15578755736351013,
-0.6147142648696899,
0.7839284539222717,
-0.46079495549201965,
0.21003207564353943,
-0.39084699749946594,
-0.6533966660499573,
0.03399531915783882,
0.6128026843070984,
-0.5865559577941895,
1.257834792137146,
0.03541635721921921,
-0.9388071298599243,
0.5475977659225464,
-0.48791149258613586,
-0.3004637062549591,
-0.0320824533700943,
-0.5045375823974609,
-0.42258501052856445,
0.06739248335361481,
0.2929117679595947,
0.22359004616737366,
-0.3491785228252411,
0.24051691591739655,
-0.0687156394124031,
-0.30096498131752014,
-0.12863023579120636,
-0.07175113260746002,
0.6222360134124756,
0.019070034846663475,
-0.565071702003479,
0.06287755817174911,
-1.1631464958190918,
0.0011418216163292527,
0.005461875814944506,
-0.7649429440498352,
-0.16949370503425598,
0.06409308314323425,
-0.6045490503311157,
0.1618029773235321,
-0.01043944526463747,
-0.4291025400161743,
0.169979989528656,
-0.4506807327270508,
0.20671670138835907,
0.49781450629234314,
-0.025428559631109238,
0.3259126842021942,
-0.38709190487861633,
0.1487395018339157,
-0.09957294166088104,
-0.134269118309021,
-0.11688544601202011,
-0.35142797231674194,
-1.2925302982330322,
-0.39998409152030945,
0.5103682279586792,
0.46716970205307007,
-0.9781149625778198,
0.5496034026145935,
-0.19404269754886627,
-0.37534722685813904,
-0.32984161376953125,
0.18675169348716736,
0.21793468296527863,
0.7398473024368286,
0.38090798258781433,
0.08234897255897522,
-0.7338452339172363,
-0.8327746391296387,
-0.2601149082183838,
-0.3575160801410675,
-0.18776021897792816,
-0.05638868361711502,
0.5802834630012512,
-0.33925071358680725,
1.0894454717636108,
-0.309998095035553,
-0.1466589719057083,
-0.08749176561832428,
0.3467746376991272,
0.3797871470451355,
0.31347712874412537,
0.41709840297698975,
-0.34575390815734863,
-0.20886822044849396,
-0.2698412835597992,
-0.8192833662033081,
-0.4073515832424164,
-0.3221028447151184,
-0.05323182791471481,
0.06126829981803894,
0.5183297395706177,
-0.8791233897209167,
0.3091042935848236,
0.5328950881958008,
-0.34651774168014526,
0.42075759172439575,
-0.27059152722358704,
0.07989733666181564,
-0.4290463924407959,
-0.06479690223932266,
-0.24158760905265808,
-0.7096102237701416,
-0.45418909192085266,
0.18168063461780548,
0.22980214655399323,
0.08714847266674042,
-0.2702205181121826,
0.16036783158779144,
-0.5095351934432983,
-0.20905952155590057,
-0.44700396060943604,
0.02357466146349907,
0.02016459032893181,
0.27603790163993835,
-0.10166627913713455,
1.029062271118164,
0.07043064385652542,
-0.6119518280029297,
0.3658093214035034,
0.057309579104185104,
-0.4477401077747345,
0.4081250727176666,
-0.5337405204772949,
0.4206768870353699,
0.14232751727104187,
0.4582805335521698,
-0.7679758667945862,
-0.25526708364486694,
0.03584161400794983,
-0.029440922662615776,
0.11208576709032059,
-0.5252665877342224,
-0.8596024513244629,
-0.21676963567733765,
-0.4577085077762604,
-0.006419215351343155,
0.5773467421531677,
-0.8343629240989685,
0.82249516248703,
0.2920348644256592,
-0.06926844269037247,
-0.29341351985931396,
-0.5093021392822266,
0.18958862125873566,
-0.07249753177165985,
-0.6806595921516418,
0.2800029516220093,
-0.03120340406894684,
-0.26562827825546265,
-0.07435501366853714,
-0.376845121383667,
0.2580197751522064,
0.07415460050106049,
0.1055443286895752,
0.09232982248067856,
-0.12534558773040771,
-0.09315363317728043,
0.10758595913648605,
-0.29100966453552246,
0.12172538787126541,
-0.24007374048233032,
0.29680484533309937,
-0.4550262689590454,
-0.5362592339515686,
0.12364665418863297,
0.04447563737630844,
0.45635926723480225,
0.29938578605651855,
0.306076318025589,
0.4335229694843292,
-0.5226387977600098,
-0.3657085597515106,
-0.8330349326133728,
-0.41815635561943054,
-0.5038792490959167,
-0.02613496407866478,
-0.41904953122138977,
-0.7556894421577454,
0.32013723254203796,
-0.3864569067955017,
0.11334417015314102,
0.5749895572662354,
0.7628412842750549,
-0.20346646010875702,
0.6814374923706055,
0.6094120144844055,
0.20729555189609528,
-0.03031577169895172,
-0.2845229208469391,
0.21395254135131836,
-0.35572993755340576,
-0.007430204655975103,
-0.38969191908836365,
0.014050891622900963,
-0.48062247037887573,
-0.6482434868812561,
0.5166168212890625,
-0.037722520530223846,
-0.09146755188703537,
-0.019175320863723755,
-0.18255481123924255,
0.7890672087669373,
0.6721102595329285,
0.03377337008714676,
0.6836479902267456,
0.0006813722429797053,
-0.4468250274658203,
-0.053792115300893784,
-0.7367664575576782,
-0.6438782811164856,
0.9864139556884766,
0.22311389446258545,
0.6054890155792236,
0.07389563322067261,
0.7025049924850464,
0.44993746280670166,
0.5287697911262512,
-0.6218770146369934,
0.7550661563873291,
-0.06490733474493027,
-0.505325973033905,
-0.04568285867571831,
-0.41857191920280457,
-0.31341397762298584,
0.4621575176715851,
-0.35503721237182617,
-0.11155460774898529,
-0.013826576061546803,
0.4552643299102783,
-0.48783373832702637,
0.26058343052864075,
-0.5501872897148132,
0.39215636253356934,
-0.2665773332118988,
-0.4083728790283203,
-0.18333609402179718,
-0.47118255496025085,
0.7885165214538574,
-0.296512246131897,
0.2990981638431549,
-0.18660962581634521,
0.15390661358833313,
0.5932573080062866,
-0.7304955720901489,
0.9431211948394775,
-0.07507232576608658,
-0.09340161085128784,
0.3654436469078064,
0.17893089354038239,
1.0076045989990234,
0.2637929320335388,
0.08312387019395828,
0.14391431212425232,
0.026931259781122208,
-0.06836848706007004,
-0.41197484731674194,
0.6837741732597351,
-0.6403411626815796,
-0.6785922050476074,
-0.6805545687675476,
-0.22573935985565186,
-0.34596946835517883,
0.31948229670524597,
0.43118560314178467,
0.17574380338191986,
-0.15577730536460876,
0.11451935768127441,
0.8237357139587402,
0.10670936107635498,
0.12999942898750305,
0.6979302167892456,
-0.16727903485298157,
-0.2735278904438019,
0.650364875793457,
0.12004873156547546,
-0.031167345121502876,
0.22101478278636932,
0.3547457158565521,
-0.3430944085121155,
-0.7582743763923645,
-0.4857901334762573,
0.2861691117286682,
-0.9232163429260254,
-0.37059569358825684,
-0.82795649766922,
-0.19251668453216553,
-0.1186588779091835,
0.11300979554653168,
-0.5218417048454285,
-0.47142669558525085,
0.009746716357767582,
-0.5383341908454895,
0.14950154721736908,
0.7176386713981628,
-0.41368383169174194,
0.19749906659126282,
-0.6588231325149536,
0.6903996467590332,
0.659246027469635,
0.09468436241149902,
-0.5121150612831116,
-0.50087571144104,
-0.23106157779693604,
-0.06474076211452484,
-0.3115985095500946,
-0.6879798173904419,
0.06676343083381653,
0.1320263147354126,
0.3436332941055298,
0.13809578120708466,
0.06679479777812958,
0.44290855526924133,
-0.8672558665275574,
0.8004206418991089,
0.04901836812496185,
-1.0593326091766357,
0.5212210416793823,
-0.29775217175483704,
-0.16221310198307037,
0.6376619935035706,
0.06673093140125275,
-0.17937371134757996,
-0.3746349811553955,
-0.7722289562225342,
-0.7291065454483032,
0.6108002662658691,
0.3706645965576172,
-0.3154520094394684,
0.15070511400699615,
0.4477699398994446,
-0.0059023224748671055,
0.2322569489479065,
-0.7499704957008362,
-0.1355161964893341,
-0.26451560854911804,
-0.21856075525283813,
0.11230305582284927,
-0.6470972895622253,
-0.7257832288742065,
-0.2499394714832306,
0.7152742147445679,
-0.51482093334198,
0.24613580107688904,
0.19475509226322174,
-0.21469749510288239,
0.08196073025465012,
0.15195707976818085,
0.7734625339508057,
0.45315787196159363,
-0.4590227007865906,
0.7481909990310669,
0.48217302560806274,
-0.267987996339798,
0.5248371362686157,
-0.12612365186214447,
-0.5155869722366333,
0.23626375198364258,
0.3287942111492157,
0.455321341753006,
0.1655419021844864,
-0.3010269105434418,
0.4818592667579651,
-0.007882988080382347,
-0.3167545795440674,
-0.1965402364730835,
0.1975671648979187,
0.20590434968471527,
0.1812138557434082,
0.11038622260093689,
0.08361729979515076,
0.2531900405883789,
-0.5141034722328186,
0.3406532406806946,
0.21896852552890778,
0.35162994265556335,
-0.3120216727256775,
0.49545466899871826,
0.2735559642314911,
0.21371977031230927,
0.5081871151924133,
-0.43482455611228943,
-0.5679746866226196,
0.4666793942451477,
0.4451286792755127,
0.7133389711380005,
0.19947469234466553,
0.019469432532787323,
0.34978917241096497,
0.78136146068573,
-0.32061558961868286,
0.2050146460533142,
0.08932112157344818,
-0.8046839237213135,
-0.5138453841209412,
-0.48008760809898376,
-0.7855589389801025,
0.45004934072494507,
-0.19809509813785553,
0.25228366255760193,
-0.6918271780014038,
-0.16313622891902924,
-0.13276264071464539,
0.08805104345083237,
-0.773004412651062,
0.41792023181915283,
0.07094595581293106,
0.8052567839622498,
-1.011397361755371,
0.8930206298828125,
0.5052478909492493,
-0.24317769706249237,
-0.5748384594917297,
-0.1057850793004036,
0.3051677942276001,
-0.7623000741004944,
0.8689001202583313,
0.020009208470582962,
-0.5486584305763245,
-0.08790260553359985,
-0.7231989502906799,
-0.8408750295639038,
1.0587505102157593,
0.5661681890487671,
-0.5538065433502197,
-0.16311390697956085,
-0.001538240583613515,
0.4604136049747467,
-0.22140729427337646,
0.25748229026794434,
0.8789953589439392,
0.42069634795188904,
0.0024309842847287655,
-0.4605436623096466,
0.2207050919532776,
0.02738010883331299,
-0.3045417368412018,
-0.3122462332248688,
-0.6678789854049683,
0.8619277477264404,
-0.0923779308795929,
-0.4476638436317444,
-0.2027433067560196,
0.6558346748352051,
0.6078988909721375,
0.30876386165618896,
0.6292020082473755,
0.7036436796188354,
1.156712532043457,
-0.24416087567806244,
1.0541982650756836,
-0.3195452094078064,
0.47146129608154297,
1.3040955066680908,
-0.27821460366249084,
0.46446937322616577,
0.3959939479827881,
-0.2485051155090332,
0.38056957721710205,
0.6626831293106079,
-0.125110924243927,
0.5431461334228516,
0.183698371052742,
-0.25991398096084595,
-0.37933066487312317,
0.14277708530426025,
-0.2371807098388672,
0.1884465217590332,
0.33383551239967346,
-0.06588888168334961,
-0.37499168515205383,
-0.49145546555519104,
0.013003145344555378,
-0.21921072900295258,
0.0156759861856699,
0.732075572013855,
0.021980591118335724,
-0.5141682624816895,
0.5921178460121155,
0.298382043838501,
0.6724372506141663,
-0.5858045816421509,
-0.06185963749885559,
-0.5415905117988586,
0.20963910222053528,
-0.3748426139354706,
-0.4201538860797882,
0.23686730861663818,
0.3109688460826874,
-0.303257018327713,
-0.2427499145269394,
1.0445080995559692,
-0.39511388540267944,
-0.36027824878692627,
0.04109452664852142,
0.5861436128616333,
0.052584998309612274,
-0.08562785387039185,
-0.5784409642219543,
0.03299390524625778,
0.09119399636983871,
-0.262326180934906,
0.3037818968296051,
0.4099608361721039,
0.13576257228851318,
0.477642297744751,
1.0150879621505737,
0.29239270091056824,
0.19536331295967102,
-0.004451951012015343,
0.9130396842956543,
-0.5039833784103394,
-0.601353645324707,
-0.90326988697052,
0.244075745344162,
-0.2441723495721817,
0.17252115905284882,
0.7830159664154053,
0.6897522211074829,
0.7558208107948303,
-0.10285168886184692,
0.9730246067047119,
0.19530326128005981,
0.6051247119903564,
-1.0473594665527344,
0.5672741532325745,
-0.27523598074913025,
0.3540847599506378,
0.16914941370487213,
-0.7004282474517822,
-0.11067984998226166,
0.7642912864685059,
-0.11231470853090286,
-0.10072282701730728,
1.0446312427520752,
0.7786105871200562,
-0.3196006119251251,
0.01766657829284668,
0.3938111364841461,
0.21758441627025604,
0.6829938292503357,
0.32796770334243774,
0.9884328246116638,
-0.4310654103755951,
0.3000320792198181,
-0.27435237169265747,
-0.24731439352035522,
-0.21939966082572937,
-1.357741355895996,
-0.93281489610672,
0.005464650224894285,
-0.47112205624580383,
-0.6016292572021484,
-0.1997128278017044,
0.8295634984970093,
0.6822973489761353,
-0.9051594734191895,
0.05284663662314415,
-0.20881709456443787,
0.2070857286453247,
0.061591219156980515,
-0.15385381877422333,
0.5113192200660706,
-0.39730599522590637,
-0.4397163689136505,
0.8610366582870483,
0.3041827082633972,
0.14524126052856445,
-0.041511114686727524,
-0.025545360520482063,
-0.07980614900588989,
0.34988799691200256,
0.6216816902160645,
0.12807822227478027,
-0.7052951455116272,
-0.5556846261024475,
-0.2857157588005066,
-0.2907995581626892,
0.0613187700510025,
1.2148369550704956,
-0.6551090478897095,
0.2978491485118866,
0.543172299861908,
0.9157206416130066,
0.7744021415710449,
0.058026887476444244,
0.3314547836780548,
-0.9541207551956177,
0.04006968438625336,
0.014939946122467518,
0.6541746258735657,
0.4586419463157654,
-0.4655568301677704,
0.9019638895988464,
0.6639823317527771,
-0.5521324276924133,
-0.8769347071647644,
0.1601434201002121,
-0.7998732328414917,
0.16770309209823608,
1.133988380432129,
-0.08437387645244598,
0.0845259577035904,
-0.10405050963163376,
-0.0916316956281662,
0.1252821385860443,
-0.09556679427623749,
0.7122828364372253,
0.9661864042282104,
-0.24523547291755676,
-0.07771354168653488,
-0.5121152997016907,
0.9649478793144226,
0.40574368834495544,
-0.992020308971405,
0.09288274496793747,
0.6638389825820923,
0.5452114939689636,
0.23764874041080475,
0.8964858055114746,
0.06682969629764557,
0.16683495044708252,
0.240631103515625,
-0.014545464888215065,
-0.22222918272018433,
-0.22458811104297638,
-0.11577938497066498,
0.27153974771499634,
0.007608878426253796,
0.024060780182480812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10763v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10763v1
|
LaDiC: Are Diffusion Models Really Inferior to Autoregressive Counterparts for Image-to-Text Generation?
| 2024-04-16T17:47:16 | 2024-04-16T17:47:16 |
Yuchi Wang, Shuhuai Ren, Rundong Gao, Linli Yao, Qingyan Guo, Kaikai An, Jianhong Bai, Xu Sun
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Diffusion models have exhibited remarkable capabilities in text-to-image
generation. However, their performance in image-to-text generation,
specifically image captioning, has lagged behind Auto-Regressive (AR) models,
casting doubt on their applicability for such tasks. In this work, we revisit
diffusion models, highlighting their capacity for holistic context modeling and
parallel decoding. With these benefits, diffusion models can alleviate the
inherent limitations of AR methods, including their slow inference speed, error
propagation, and unidirectional constraints. Furthermore, we identify the prior
underperformance of diffusion models stemming from the absence of an effective
latent space for image-text alignment, and the discrepancy between continuous
diffusion processes and discrete textual data. In response, we introduce a
novel architecture, LaDiC, which utilizes a split BERT to create a dedicated
latent space for captions and integrates a regularization module to manage
varying text lengths. Our framework also includes a diffuser for semantic
image-to-text conversion and a Back&Refine technique to enhance token
interactivity during inference. LaDiC achieves state-of-the-art performance for
diffusion-based methods on the MS COCO dataset with 38.2 BLEU@4 and 126.2
CIDEr, demonstrating exceptional performance without pre-training or ancillary
modules. This indicates strong competitiveness with AR models, revealing the
previously untapped potential of diffusion models in image-to-text generation.
|
[
-0.27969226241111755,
-0.7808417081832886,
0.4711401164531708,
0.34091225266456604,
-0.4919704794883728,
0.07039698958396912,
0.056678012013435364,
-0.2652983069419861,
-0.21797528862953186,
0.3736766576766968,
-0.2610008120536804,
-0.31197991967201233,
-0.921312153339386,
0.05652705207467079,
-0.7416971325874329,
0.8540249466896057,
-0.13220061361789703,
-0.07219710201025009,
-0.45976579189300537,
-0.10496506094932556,
-0.4833366572856903,
-0.03341175243258476,
-0.7760121822357178,
0.004327266942709684,
0.31706127524375916,
0.010729383677244186,
0.6020521521568298,
0.5018186569213867,
0.40654128789901733,
0.25513550639152527,
-0.02239234186708927,
0.2648322880268097,
-0.30680298805236816,
0.15665796399116516,
-0.016217177733778954,
-0.27536290884017944,
-0.34040093421936035,
0.003684688825160265,
0.6340253949165344,
0.45465534925460815,
-0.24821412563323975,
-0.21348686516284943,
-0.04733423888683319,
1.1095386743545532,
-0.5346226096153259,
0.0543932169675827,
-0.6175600290298462,
0.1252231001853943,
0.10318450629711151,
-0.10939205437898636,
-0.5961447358131409,
-0.13634496927261353,
0.15697212517261505,
-0.474421888589859,
0.5705543160438538,
0.3055753707885742,
0.8358518481254578,
0.6322129964828491,
-0.30746883153915405,
-0.40082210302352905,
-0.6456335783004761,
0.6748819947242737,
-0.7205132246017456,
0.1414828896522522,
0.17619635164737701,
0.20925576984882355,
0.1319940835237503,
-0.6638741493225098,
-0.5117170214653015,
-0.12357576191425323,
-0.08850394189357758,
0.37078821659088135,
-0.19339028000831604,
-0.2744370996952057,
-0.22393706440925598,
0.3953978717327118,
-0.3656229078769684,
0.02196173556149006,
-0.2243870198726654,
0.07838614284992218,
0.6569674611091614,
0.10624489188194275,
0.3128419816493988,
-0.06991468369960785,
-0.4841735064983368,
0.010869135148823261,
-0.6020374298095703,
-0.3069731891155243,
0.3283660113811493,
0.017701050266623497,
-0.3414888381958008,
0.38436710834503174,
0.2112792581319809,
0.6593698859214783,
0.23023246228694916,
0.06066972017288208,
-0.12319762259721756,
-0.16838201880455017,
-0.30616846680641174,
-0.2222318947315216,
1.0558661222457886,
0.37881985306739807,
-0.07966261357069016,
-0.3162906765937805,
-0.22564010322093964,
-0.0828954204916954,
0.2561998963356018,
-0.7522901892662048,
-0.5056024193763733,
0.11106160283088684,
-0.5189149975776672,
-0.3758757710456848,
-0.07174412161111832,
-0.8180041909217834,
-0.2576676309108734,
0.0951499491930008,
0.17878444492816925,
-0.233681321144104,
-0.14977110922336578,
-0.17456835508346558,
-0.3414919972419739,
0.17945899069309235,
0.7312828302383423,
-0.6119540929794312,
0.32420775294303894,
0.15545973181724548,
1.303388237953186,
-0.6670873165130615,
-0.06653604656457901,
-0.13354870676994324,
0.24154072999954224,
-0.6308860182762146,
1.131500005722046,
-0.39379948377609253,
-0.6262155771255493,
-0.19558359682559967,
-0.003832147689536214,
-0.2976335287094116,
-0.5670047998428345,
0.2303847372531891,
-0.8707621693611145,
0.21831923723220825,
-0.03371252864599228,
-0.525857150554657,
0.1144663542509079,
-0.18733544647693634,
-0.8153720498085022,
0.6150627732276917,
0.051263246685266495,
-0.9414215087890625,
0.19061437249183655,
-0.9132563471794128,
-0.6019508838653564,
-0.04110150411725044,
-0.14722749590873718,
-0.5325005054473877,
0.10325133055448532,
0.302676796913147,
0.5305200815200806,
-0.4296535849571228,
0.4169500470161438,
-0.16309672594070435,
-0.08627929538488388,
0.09900476038455963,
-0.8354653716087341,
0.5113492012023926,
0.4658496677875519,
-0.2628712058067322,
-0.15507183969020844,
-0.33914002776145935,
-0.5886213779449463,
0.24800528585910797,
-0.20240816473960876,
-0.2621867060661316,
0.25736501812934875,
0.23177765309810638,
0.15422995388507843,
-0.021474236622452736,
-0.3613913655281067,
-0.0497916005551815,
-0.20911331474781036,
0.6565145254135132,
0.7634994387626648,
0.001496623852290213,
0.9934777617454529,
-0.18329867720603943,
0.45046573877334595,
0.42661792039871216,
0.0805233046412468,
-0.40001457929611206,
-0.6752946972846985,
-0.4142812192440033,
-0.5058516263961792,
0.40304863452911377,
0.3999743163585663,
-0.8772336840629578,
0.2322930097579956,
-0.255184143781662,
-0.14729823172092438,
-0.3652985692024231,
0.0926591008901596,
0.0027140076272189617,
0.8038437366485596,
0.2779825031757355,
-0.7140897512435913,
0.14957371354103088,
-0.8691372871398926,
0.3015900254249573,
0.17021425068378448,
0.2873344421386719,
0.3753904700279236,
0.39617037773132324,
-0.3078542947769165,
0.9740232229232788,
-0.4025349020957947,
-0.18195459246635437,
0.019133185967803,
0.39518141746520996,
-0.1602027863264084,
0.6032736897468567,
0.582545816898346,
-1.0551177263259888,
-0.7141278386116028,
-0.017894597724080086,
-0.7593089938163757,
-0.050391875207424164,
-0.1841040700674057,
-0.340064138174057,
0.6772361397743225,
0.5005375146865845,
-0.642198383808136,
0.7717822194099426,
0.60157310962677,
-0.24866844713687897,
0.41556787490844727,
-0.3768627643585205,
0.19585029780864716,
-0.8771049976348877,
0.15040326118469238,
0.0701385885477066,
-0.3148232400417328,
-0.27551624178886414,
-0.034063827246427536,
0.011399930343031883,
0.05809061601758003,
-0.3446294963359833,
0.8624988198280334,
-0.5992510914802551,
-0.1133478432893753,
-0.5331488847732544,
0.10737963765859604,
0.27437931299209595,
0.14239786565303802,
0.5370442271232605,
0.892195463180542,
0.8281868696212769,
-0.6533192992210388,
0.10545410960912704,
0.14984746277332306,
-0.26476773619651794,
0.6688377857208252,
-0.7440198659896851,
-0.2290412038564682,
-0.4621594548225403,
0.5789443850517273,
-1.4060698747634888,
-0.13891011476516724,
0.315885066986084,
-0.25855082273483276,
0.48920905590057373,
-0.11623699963092804,
-0.5939394235610962,
-0.2396857887506485,
-0.12994587421417236,
0.6265132427215576,
0.8428732752799988,
-0.5135628581047058,
0.5558878779411316,
0.08526895195245743,
-0.10353489220142365,
-0.773726761341095,
-0.8384894728660583,
0.09255874902009964,
-0.28388747572898865,
-0.4036182761192322,
0.2864363193511963,
-0.26747894287109375,
-0.061717670410871506,
0.1299777328968048,
-0.006343650631606579,
-0.3286561071872711,
-0.14803439378738403,
0.26541242003440857,
0.3439951539039612,
0.005676513537764549,
-0.03487877547740936,
0.4874826967716217,
0.1039547398686409,
-0.05117463320493698,
-0.1708836555480957,
0.228124737739563,
0.23792177438735962,
-0.0627942904829979,
-0.5887432098388672,
0.4244151711463928,
0.6011033654212952,
-0.04753110930323601,
0.9062371253967285,
0.6260499954223633,
0.04000524803996086,
-0.17117834091186523,
-0.42148634791374207,
0.19272759556770325,
-0.4459281265735626,
-0.022501252591609955,
-0.114918053150177,
-0.5779242515563965,
0.5397505164146423,
-0.20463095605373383,
0.15269669890403748,
0.5615907907485962,
0.5246654748916626,
-0.3924005925655365,
0.7398349046707153,
0.5104433298110962,
0.12096469104290009,
0.4644400477409363,
-0.5609862804412842,
0.11007092893123627,
-0.9284976720809937,
0.004841040354222059,
-0.07470393180847168,
-0.04068264737725258,
-0.1300935000181198,
-0.7297024726867676,
0.13937154412269592,
0.13544227182865143,
0.04375378042459488,
-0.025558017194271088,
-0.5601774454116821,
0.31043511629104614,
0.13195766508579254,
0.03359702229499817,
0.3073844313621521,
0.2650497555732727,
0.04876399412751198,
0.15623648464679718,
-1.0287044048309326,
-0.46592244505882263,
0.9390888214111328,
0.35224539041519165,
0.931869626045227,
0.09793175756931305,
0.5131828784942627,
0.8928261399269104,
0.746791422367096,
-0.48011264204978943,
0.35160189867019653,
-0.39422157406806946,
-0.43638142943382263,
-0.32152000069618225,
-0.30993741750717163,
-0.9537965655326843,
0.2094586193561554,
0.1381915956735611,
-0.18233764171600342,
0.433022141456604,
0.22015877068042755,
-0.2757193446159363,
0.3230953812599182,
-0.7905073761940002,
0.8181235790252686,
0.03895661607384682,
-0.6702051162719727,
-0.05800582841038704,
-0.6860599517822266,
0.47353166341781616,
-0.16927187144756317,
0.6081808805465698,
0.02485428750514984,
-0.22853758931159973,
0.4720397889614105,
-0.5039387941360474,
0.9676805734634399,
-0.18756401538848877,
-0.42140042781829834,
0.5453965663909912,
0.15330877900123596,
0.22151286900043488,
0.09621842205524445,
0.1697015017271042,
0.011956349946558475,
-0.012668810784816742,
-0.6358410716056824,
-0.45654943585395813,
0.8687577843666077,
-0.7200232744216919,
-0.3595373034477234,
-0.21563798189163208,
-0.612206757068634,
0.2104162871837616,
0.04897390678524971,
0.6254674792289734,
0.401277095079422,
-0.18460816144943237,
-0.2537468671798706,
0.735884428024292,
-0.22348006069660187,
0.9461489915847778,
0.09843599796295166,
0.07611244916915894,
-0.4842243790626526,
0.8732274770736694,
-0.10418500006198883,
0.3999708592891693,
0.42952489852905273,
0.05980004370212555,
-0.43814748525619507,
-0.5460708141326904,
-0.7546966671943665,
0.46674662828445435,
-0.8033313155174255,
-0.22846628725528717,
-0.8439110517501831,
-0.04342081770300865,
-0.43801888823509216,
-0.5285376906394958,
-0.5466852784156799,
-0.3593842387199402,
-0.6863456964492798,
0.3210849463939667,
0.1157064214348793,
0.8559525012969971,
-0.11064396053552628,
0.5089250802993774,
-0.5755783915519714,
0.40428096055984497,
0.34068453311920166,
0.2423304319381714,
0.4824034571647644,
-0.6659547686576843,
-0.25627508759498596,
-0.25160083174705505,
-0.18513892590999603,
-0.8816732168197632,
0.6878975629806519,
0.1491452008485794,
0.2617097496986389,
0.32609131932258606,
-0.017753729596734047,
0.6020308136940002,
-0.8126512169837952,
0.8397741913795471,
0.26787200570106506,
-0.8066392540931702,
0.43595582246780396,
-0.22098489105701447,
0.18220014870166779,
0.22838905453681946,
0.38966378569602966,
0.08286882936954498,
-0.3658488988876343,
-0.6917407512664795,
-0.9418153166770935,
0.47992873191833496,
0.2660619914531708,
0.16523827612400055,
-0.16885699331760406,
0.4896317422389984,
0.3086836636066437,
0.44438374042510986,
-0.9247890710830688,
-0.15322473645210266,
-0.34028497338294983,
-0.19906331598758698,
-0.0999281108379364,
-0.2466028481721878,
-0.1565835028886795,
-0.17613521218299866,
0.49959495663642883,
-0.06349466741085052,
0.41489866375923157,
0.5168343782424927,
-0.17983216047286987,
-0.1215125173330307,
-0.008659744635224342,
0.41889306902885437,
0.3500857651233673,
0.09234436601400375,
-0.03489745408296585,
-0.29417186975479126,
-0.2913133203983307,
0.14296534657478333,
0.13510572910308838,
-0.16009937226772308,
0.024941742420196533,
0.4110148847103119,
0.812376081943512,
-0.23266473412513733,
-0.6073461771011353,
0.7089240550994873,
-0.13034096360206604,
-0.28952863812446594,
-0.2207350730895996,
-0.15878407657146454,
-0.09408548474311829,
0.23527765274047852,
0.3693068027496338,
0.3450889587402344,
0.4197731614112854,
-0.30203506350517273,
0.00917716883122921,
0.6511502265930176,
-0.27332058548927307,
-0.1229163259267807,
1.0484849214553833,
0.3115118145942688,
-0.03690721467137337,
0.33631986379623413,
-0.29525405168533325,
0.04299723356962204,
0.7752109169960022,
0.40528905391693115,
0.8838724493980408,
-0.014761961065232754,
0.5595411658287048,
0.11309737712144852,
0.2552812993526459,
-0.3375474512577057,
-0.21882222592830658,
-0.5865604877471924,
-0.5346850752830505,
-0.3432043492794037,
-0.49021604657173157,
-0.0685821995139122,
-0.33500009775161743,
-0.4776242673397064,
-0.22669684886932373,
-0.3155161738395691,
-0.20198452472686768,
-0.037199269980192184,
-0.5314807295799255,
-0.5066487789154053,
0.2910718023777008,
0.04307933151721954,
0.7693337202072144,
-0.9844518303871155,
0.7331852912902832,
0.5814619660377502,
-0.2197725623846054,
-0.13463006913661957,
0.08933623880147934,
-0.5820273160934448,
-0.42695102095603943,
0.7651031613349915,
-0.02450282871723175,
-0.11178090423345566,
-0.011018434539437294,
-0.7651847004890442,
-0.587142825126648,
1.1899663209915161,
-0.0367443785071373,
-0.46657782793045044,
-0.2450445294380188,
-0.20562578737735748,
0.6189659833908081,
-0.7204776406288147,
0.2304980307817459,
0.36689430475234985,
0.1499950885772705,
0.4306010603904724,
-0.45522257685661316,
-0.05829233303666115,
-0.014481711201369762,
0.47819894552230835,
-0.26981788873672485,
-0.8740862011909485,
0.7517212629318237,
-0.3840957283973694,
-0.4202720820903778,
0.3434375524520874,
0.6200505495071411,
0.10288412123918533,
0.5911657810211182,
0.35638895630836487,
0.49769458174705505,
0.22823908925056458,
0.09340909868478775,
1.2036978006362915,
-0.07919716089963913,
0.29909780621528625,
1.0067389011383057,
-0.2567833960056305,
0.9137227535247803,
0.5394807457923889,
-0.07162544131278992,
0.8094680309295654,
0.5956005454063416,
0.2217307686805725,
0.9165264964103699,
-0.19807632267475128,
-0.20020993053913116,
-0.06862393766641617,
0.17603786289691925,
-0.036467354744672775,
-0.13075321912765503,
0.3566161096096039,
-0.689544677734375,
-0.21684545278549194,
0.16386866569519043,
-0.34760749340057373,
0.2742753028869629,
-0.06961506605148315,
0.6572516560554504,
-0.09828194230794907,
-0.3963944911956787,
0.5197938680648804,
-0.06291305273771286,
0.8273124098777771,
-0.18117010593414307,
-0.008782065473496914,
-0.5068319439888,
-0.23426547646522522,
-0.09373688697814941,
-0.6840249300003052,
0.43384501338005066,
-0.11768234521150589,
-0.3036089539527893,
-0.2047758847475052,
0.5525943040847778,
-0.39647793769836426,
-0.3898940086364746,
0.11330775916576385,
0.5146985054016113,
0.07859635353088379,
0.18066295981407166,
-0.9067001342773438,
0.02154250256717205,
-0.12592849135398865,
-0.20938202738761902,
0.02660955861210823,
0.4008534550666809,
0.05259036272764206,
0.5968452095985413,
0.25996023416519165,
-0.13914020359516144,
0.2089015543460846,
0.03400956466794014,
0.6238751411437988,
-0.4279000163078308,
-0.48162543773651123,
-0.8009793162345886,
0.5195492506027222,
-0.05329989641904831,
0.17051108181476593,
0.5768560171127319,
0.5177663564682007,
0.30896854400634766,
-0.30412179231643677,
0.9205904006958008,
-0.13646070659160614,
0.16102592647075653,
-0.5468090772628784,
0.7490024566650391,
-0.7683054208755493,
0.3310483992099762,
-0.28806382417678833,
-0.8076990246772766,
-0.25590017437934875,
0.46628129482269287,
-0.4156612753868103,
0.0839877501130104,
0.617077648639679,
0.5770811438560486,
-0.05762844905257225,
-0.23379766941070557,
0.34325069189071655,
0.11429038643836975,
0.26358047127723694,
0.2766980230808258,
0.9562103748321533,
-0.6459997892379761,
0.23623962700366974,
-0.14429472386837006,
-0.19720517098903656,
0.06287004798650742,
-0.8690987229347229,
-1.0044710636138916,
-0.6860544681549072,
-0.6514514684677124,
-0.10458970069885254,
-0.00150560331530869,
0.12014681100845337,
0.90779709815979,
-0.4553808569908142,
-0.1833200603723526,
-0.6020165085792542,
0.13375671207904816,
0.05668935552239418,
-0.3258720338344574,
0.4632924199104309,
-0.38030409812927246,
-0.9339385628700256,
0.0262627974152565,
0.43100041151046753,
0.5346341133117676,
-0.43404123187065125,
-0.10208632051944733,
-0.21583350002765656,
0.375311017036438,
0.8141842484474182,
0.19994497299194336,
-0.8621148467063904,
0.38091835379600525,
-0.25707268714904785,
-0.07852308452129364,
0.22594515979290009,
0.5561280250549316,
-0.7805886268615723,
0.4233510196208954,
0.20731887221336365,
0.4812632203102112,
0.5240140557289124,
0.27871841192245483,
0.3845564126968384,
-0.6272132396697998,
0.334114670753479,
-0.04923213645815849,
0.1859065145254135,
0.5506001710891724,
-0.417192667722702,
0.35272571444511414,
0.3464094400405884,
-0.6480191349983215,
-0.7613325715065002,
0.07026991248130798,
-0.8626551628112793,
-0.7019447684288025,
1.0100562572479248,
-0.042506083846092224,
-0.5095663666725159,
0.1483772099018097,
-0.29533421993255615,
0.018306437879800797,
-0.5196041464805603,
0.7952534556388855,
0.7593632936477661,
-0.31239283084869385,
-0.6007516980171204,
-0.3787655830383301,
0.5231258869171143,
0.31614840030670166,
-0.7703142166137695,
0.1316101849079132,
0.7775291800498962,
0.2635767161846161,
0.1264706701040268,
0.8515270352363586,
-0.2940838932991028,
0.22768621146678925,
0.11487571150064468,
-0.18587760627269745,
0.2198101133108139,
-0.4571399390697479,
-0.4569808840751648,
0.15466198325157166,
0.09066189080476761,
-0.09681382030248642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10757v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10757v1
|
Deep Learning and LLM-based Methods Applied to Stellar Lightcurve Classification
| 2024-04-16T17:35:25 | 2024-04-16T17:35:25 |
Yu-Yang Li, Yu Bai, Cunshi Wang, Mengwei Qu, Ziteng Lu, Roberto Soria, Jifeng Liu
|
astro-ph.IM
|
astro-ph.IM, astro-ph.SR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Light curves serve as a valuable source of information on stellar formation
and evolution. With the rapid advancement of machine learning techniques, it
can be effectively processed to extract astronomical patterns and information.
In this study, we present a comprehensive evaluation of deep-learning and large
language model (LLM) based models for the automatic classification of variable
star light curves, based on large datasets from the Kepler and K2 missions.
Special emphasis is placed on Cepheids, RR Lyrae, and eclipsing binaries,
examining the influence of observational cadence and phase distribution on
classification precision. Employing AutoDL optimization, we achieve striking
performance with the 1D-Convolution+BiLSTM architecture and the Swin
Transformer, hitting accuracies of 94\% and 99\% correspondingly, with the
latter demonstrating a notable 83\% accuracy in discerning the elusive Type II
Cepheids-comprising merely 0.02\% of the total dataset.We unveil StarWhisper
LightCurve (LC), an innovative Series comprising three LLM-based models: LLM,
multimodal large language model (MLLM), and Large Audio Language Model (LALM).
Each model is fine-tuned with strategic prompt engineering and customized
training methods to explore the emergent abilities of these models for
astronomical data. Remarkably, StarWhisper LC Series exhibit high accuracies
around 90\%, significantly reducing the need for explicit feature engineering,
thereby paving the way for streamlined parallel data processing and the
progression of multifaceted multimodal models in astronomical applications. The
study furnishes two detailed catalogs illustrating the impacts of phase and
sampling intervals on deep learning classification accuracy, showing that a
substantial decrease of up to 14\% in observation duration and 21\% in sampling
points can be realized without compromising accuracy by more than 10\%.
|
[
-0.2040775865316391,
-0.6714512705802917,
0.4722939431667328,
-0.13047847151756287,
-0.01925431378185749,
0.27426621317863464,
-0.4402152895927429,
-0.8678709268569946,
-0.2295890599489212,
0.6056188344955444,
-0.6041739583015442,
-0.611433744430542,
-0.47504153847694397,
-0.09711965918540955,
-0.43804100155830383,
0.8518498539924622,
-0.10140882432460785,
0.3226376473903656,
0.18899327516555786,
-0.10236085951328278,
-0.3017910122871399,
-0.22439885139465332,
-0.25096723437309265,
-0.24105922877788544,
0.7240076065063477,
0.5039457082748413,
0.6950820684432983,
0.682515025138855,
0.9889161586761475,
0.34699124097824097,
-0.10703638195991516,
0.5329669117927551,
-0.41223767399787903,
0.14326703548431396,
0.2656998336315155,
-0.4477231502532959,
-0.09484558552503586,
-0.07876632362604141,
0.41768980026245117,
0.8384944200515747,
0.06679771095514297,
0.3784462809562683,
0.2882094383239746,
0.5173662900924683,
-0.40418824553489685,
0.631138265132904,
-0.4762042462825775,
0.17545165121555328,
-0.2400216907262802,
-0.19768360257148743,
-0.3980816602706909,
-0.4076375365257263,
0.30407121777534485,
-0.6556230187416077,
0.48878344893455505,
0.16039954125881195,
0.5945290923118591,
0.48224544525146484,
-0.3936561346054077,
-0.6855925917625427,
-1.0685548782348633,
0.8706005811691284,
-0.5829481482505798,
0.4972790777683258,
-0.1849558800458908,
0.48363086581230164,
-0.05948817357420921,
-0.8480114936828613,
-0.446761816740036,
-0.4358976483345032,
-0.02615184523165226,
0.02462432160973549,
0.3105827271938324,
0.1448814421892166,
0.15768273174762726,
0.35970911383628845,
-0.48279687762260437,
0.5968984961509705,
-0.46511754393577576,
-0.0840291902422905,
0.6035011410713196,
0.4682562053203583,
-0.35648369789123535,
-0.29289278388023376,
-0.28775110840797424,
-0.4001675248146057,
-0.49637147784233093,
0.42954760789871216,
0.19972741603851318,
0.4269271492958069,
-0.13275018334388733,
0.6166056990623474,
-0.049066223204135895,
0.3679141700267792,
0.16961698234081268,
-0.3201247453689575,
0.09983223676681519,
-0.2965312898159027,
-0.18880616128444672,
-0.2241571694612503,
0.7101157307624817,
0.3017524480819702,
0.04768836125731468,
-0.19614748656749725,
-0.32864290475845337,
0.2542591094970703,
-0.23139646649360657,
-0.8897855281829834,
-0.34650304913520813,
0.07864232361316681,
-0.5283904671669006,
-0.2838588356971741,
0.15282128751277924,
-0.6855820417404175,
-0.5972927212715149,
-0.7881722450256348,
0.23170296847820282,
-0.22853519022464752,
0.08300917595624924,
-0.008581963367760181,
0.284025639295578,
0.23101237416267395,
0.47468653321266174,
-0.9252153038978577,
0.07155919820070267,
0.7751706838607788,
0.6087772250175476,
-0.16821101307868958,
-0.30207720398902893,
-0.10258544236421585,
-0.23622694611549377,
-0.40118318796157837,
0.45233553647994995,
-0.4361785650253296,
-0.37163442373275757,
0.026617487892508507,
0.2639036178588867,
0.027947090566158295,
-0.372672438621521,
0.626705527305603,
-0.6864822506904602,
-0.025548625737428665,
-0.09108234941959381,
-0.995937705039978,
-0.47571486234664917,
-0.20715317130088806,
-0.482352077960968,
0.684458315372467,
0.19567365944385529,
-0.32398295402526855,
0.7917705774307251,
-0.35619595646858215,
-0.12189680337905884,
0.5569536685943604,
-0.3207198977470398,
-0.46807533502578735,
0.12045277655124664,
0.043044563382864,
0.8391093611717224,
-0.22489462792873383,
0.39181968569755554,
-0.34881994128227234,
-0.2936069369316101,
0.17528781294822693,
-0.44041600823402405,
0.3742794990539551,
0.5262058973312378,
-0.5978944897651672,
0.19284160435199738,
-0.5138850808143616,
0.11761025339365005,
-0.051003795117139816,
-0.14972348511219025,
-0.03877398371696472,
0.07091344892978668,
0.6175952553749084,
-0.07915151864290237,
0.14064866304397583,
-0.3955984115600586,
0.3171924650669098,
-0.18386974930763245,
0.35427483916282654,
0.5932488441467285,
-0.12373953312635422,
0.4978586435317993,
0.017453422769904137,
0.14486461877822876,
-0.08950408548116684,
0.5397960543632507,
-0.18085898458957672,
-0.29233574867248535,
-0.9438735246658325,
-0.05631664767861366,
0.0913587212562561,
0.5625672936439514,
-0.549292802810669,
0.7996938824653625,
-0.12592090666294098,
-0.9310650825500488,
-0.3644663095474243,
0.41894975304603577,
0.44674456119537354,
0.5771463513374329,
0.42455288767814636,
0.20399469137191772,
-0.25225311517715454,
-0.5722659230232239,
0.22000430524349213,
0.024201171472668648,
0.1592470407485962,
0.4680060148239136,
0.522838294506073,
-0.5131629705429077,
0.5096778273582458,
-0.28919747471809387,
-0.13991035521030426,
-0.08939379453659058,
0.023357832804322243,
0.2537999153137207,
0.3237585723400116,
0.40011829137802124,
-0.7174848914146423,
-0.39214223623275757,
0.07414940744638443,
-0.896814227104187,
0.04734232276678085,
-0.13854335248470306,
0.19607743620872498,
0.3717614412307739,
0.48860350251197815,
-0.3474685251712799,
0.3345834016799927,
0.48581597208976746,
-0.7704102396965027,
0.3510396480560303,
-0.200274258852005,
0.3450232148170471,
-0.5345746874809265,
-0.02173948474228382,
0.19468463957309723,
-0.09606282413005829,
-0.6592724323272705,
0.11860877275466919,
0.44318392872810364,
0.1880175769329071,
-0.4058126211166382,
0.25496888160705566,
-0.4341309666633606,
-0.2660626471042633,
-0.4583149552345276,
-0.2027585804462433,
-0.270990788936615,
0.2888850271701813,
0.13197839260101318,
0.27469322085380554,
0.5475577116012573,
-0.7799699902534485,
0.5274155139923096,
0.10301272571086884,
-0.695858359336853,
-0.0032346094958484173,
-0.3551408052444458,
0.009918823838233948,
-0.05283437296748161,
0.12931086122989655,
-0.7303928136825562,
-0.02502049133181572,
0.12229707092046738,
-0.22064711153507233,
0.3731355667114258,
-0.05891812592744827,
-0.42074140906333923,
-0.44518494606018066,
0.014178888872265816,
0.21011221408843994,
0.6654994487762451,
-0.6535875797271729,
0.25761938095092773,
0.06942393630743027,
-0.12334772199392319,
-0.46980729699134827,
-0.35385972261428833,
-0.08197227865457535,
-0.17911304533481598,
-0.49197497963905334,
0.3453100919723511,
-0.18296748399734497,
-0.27484631538391113,
-0.22041580080986023,
0.07352951914072037,
0.3431020975112915,
0.037543777376413345,
0.529901385307312,
0.7238820791244507,
-0.3075937032699585,
0.06590277701616287,
-0.267488956451416,
-0.279061496257782,
-0.2553427517414093,
-0.13563400506973267,
0.7334790229797363,
-0.42352843284606934,
-0.4006060063838959,
-0.5908665657043457,
-0.2609235346317291,
0.6115261912345886,
0.05833965912461281,
0.2451993227005005,
0.9792505502700806,
-0.12046949565410614,
-0.2797257602214813,
-0.5882790088653564,
-0.4039088785648346,
-0.4567458927631378,
0.4407413601875305,
-0.07779254019260406,
-0.8805460333824158,
0.4158484935760498,
0.15187519788742065,
0.36340436339378357,
0.5916900634765625,
0.38113290071487427,
-0.2640531361103058,
0.8220120072364807,
0.6365330815315247,
-0.09218616038560867,
0.46685707569122314,
-0.5861108303070068,
-0.1191008985042572,
-0.6445985436439514,
-0.6473223567008972,
-0.37750011682510376,
-0.48153093457221985,
-0.800513505935669,
-0.6633992195129395,
0.1408139169216156,
0.03504849970340729,
-0.33751118183135986,
0.31004050374031067,
-0.6902181506156921,
0.30338606238365173,
0.29367566108703613,
0.3732636570930481,
0.1667374223470688,
-0.13443484902381897,
0.4362015128135681,
-0.20520494878292084,
-0.4408377408981323,
-0.5674247741699219,
1.1878851652145386,
0.5973162651062012,
1.1447755098342896,
-0.3475421369075775,
0.4442538321018219,
0.3422802686691284,
0.2436402589082718,
-0.7720804214477539,
0.33602282404899597,
-0.3658837676048279,
-0.07605660706758499,
-0.49650976061820984,
-0.5538948178291321,
-0.6816586852073669,
0.09830173850059509,
-0.45985904335975647,
-0.14913615584373474,
0.4845900535583496,
0.11814709007740021,
-0.48308855295181274,
0.3174552321434021,
-0.5701878070831299,
0.7515419125556946,
-0.7909500598907471,
-0.13816073536872864,
-0.22336074709892273,
-0.5074657797813416,
0.26126596331596375,
-0.12450998276472092,
0.1959734559059143,
-0.2975369393825531,
-0.1470111906528473,
0.6492764353752136,
-0.18090209364891052,
0.7145715951919556,
-0.3751829266548157,
0.037537604570388794,
0.2207094430923462,
0.08224871754646301,
0.606356143951416,
0.18486608564853668,
0.07534781843423843,
0.213372141122818,
-0.06022880971431732,
-0.17361269891262054,
-0.32723888754844666,
0.7565866708755493,
-1.00521981716156,
-0.15984521806240082,
-0.22791044414043427,
-0.5638549327850342,
0.08203355222940445,
-0.12664730846881866,
0.23704485595226288,
0.4855698049068451,
0.09404001384973526,
0.4784126877784729,
0.5947487354278564,
-0.06960424780845642,
0.7068070769309998,
0.6491069197654724,
-0.468326598405838,
-0.31274303793907166,
0.7079047560691833,
0.06764472275972366,
0.16120260953903198,
0.15970858931541443,
0.1453040987253189,
-0.4233418405056,
-0.9138946533203125,
-0.3894159495830536,
0.09193474799394608,
-0.7820079922676086,
-0.2354803830385208,
-0.49032726883888245,
-0.2425854355096817,
-0.41373735666275024,
-0.4010261595249176,
-0.2378099113702774,
-0.20146842300891876,
-0.30123814940452576,
0.005353363696485758,
0.3597041964530945,
0.8899981379508972,
0.33394235372543335,
0.3809613883495331,
-0.6417610049247742,
0.11296592652797699,
0.07135710120201111,
-0.02637358568608761,
-0.2530194818973541,
-0.6529852151870728,
-0.1848558634519577,
-0.16915658116340637,
-0.17269739508628845,
-0.37270599603652954,
0.5682376027107239,
0.24043351411819458,
0.4251331686973572,
0.4733946919441223,
-0.242384135723114,
0.685279130935669,
-0.2753307819366455,
0.6310306191444397,
0.41657403111457825,
-0.678806722164154,
0.37228095531463623,
-0.05047741159796715,
0.17830610275268555,
0.5438460111618042,
0.13020791113376617,
-0.5015173554420471,
-0.3685440719127655,
-0.4744388461112976,
-0.7543083429336548,
0.611993670463562,
0.06091193109750748,
-0.18495264649391174,
0.4661557674407959,
0.7364343404769897,
0.391206294298172,
0.09327612072229385,
-0.6577503085136414,
-0.3501482307910919,
-0.16956831514835358,
-0.3556039035320282,
-0.6244445443153381,
0.042928941547870636,
0.38596972823143005,
-0.2939038872718811,
0.412950724363327,
-0.24851639568805695,
-0.1395433098077774,
0.16252754628658295,
-0.3168824017047882,
-0.3030777871608734,
0.006502619944512844,
0.35297882556915283,
0.6020202040672302,
-0.18582360446453094,
-0.056322332471609116,
0.30860111117362976,
-0.6140303611755371,
-0.15497536957263947,
0.2961365580558777,
-0.43116986751556396,
0.02687111683189869,
0.47076138854026794,
0.8290805220603943,
0.2803749740123749,
-0.545189619064331,
0.24388784170150757,
0.0430883914232254,
-0.11603456735610962,
-0.6011970043182373,
0.3299815058708191,
-0.04537005349993706,
0.6393597722053528,
0.5510565042495728,
0.34636232256889343,
0.26614707708358765,
-0.33941811323165894,
0.09313080459833145,
0.35086286067962646,
-0.4092506468296051,
-0.17846299707889557,
0.6013310551643372,
0.1710459589958191,
-0.13511201739311218,
0.5956084132194519,
0.0974232405424118,
-0.3856884837150574,
0.9336914420127869,
0.02837577648460865,
0.6836499571800232,
-0.32879653573036194,
0.05935479328036308,
0.37336844205856323,
0.11889471858739853,
-0.08164721727371216,
0.11436782032251358,
-0.0869000032544136,
-0.4780794382095337,
-0.2878727912902832,
-0.8206617832183838,
-0.5214617252349854,
0.07578662037849426,
-0.24056322872638702,
0.6697022914886475,
-0.6059273481369019,
-0.02867521531879902,
0.2379414439201355,
0.35076791048049927,
-1.0263996124267578,
0.07649309188127518,
0.7102620005607605,
0.7507877349853516,
-0.6233224868774414,
0.747161865234375,
0.15337561070919037,
-0.16032548248767853,
-0.7646132707595825,
-0.5226037502288818,
0.05476904287934303,
-0.772214412689209,
0.7422032952308655,
0.3333424925804138,
-0.07641410827636719,
-0.00573219358921051,
-0.4479259252548218,
-0.7309795618057251,
1.494002342224121,
-0.11721431463956833,
-1.355205774307251,
-0.06342203170061111,
0.38191333413124084,
0.5280500650405884,
-0.49190419912338257,
0.46470382809638977,
0.504319429397583,
0.533209502696991,
0.2800810933113098,
-0.8695036768913269,
-0.25316688418388367,
0.21709924936294556,
-0.14305716753005981,
0.2873629033565521,
-0.5410478711128235,
0.782468318939209,
-0.370212584733963,
-0.08905072510242462,
0.11748021841049194,
0.686293363571167,
0.09984862804412842,
0.4152444303035736,
0.6177376508712769,
0.08679123967885971,
0.8515146970748901,
-0.34641480445861816,
0.6368762254714966,
-0.5210508108139038,
0.6108958721160889,
0.5969970226287842,
-0.3357994854450226,
0.7313520908355713,
0.2394070029258728,
-0.15206627547740936,
0.30524560809135437,
0.8860390186309814,
-0.6222412586212158,
0.40977492928504944,
0.10803613811731339,
-0.1367189884185791,
-0.13719823956489563,
0.2405175417661667,
-0.1423713117837906,
0.341741144657135,
0.5654405951499939,
-0.5261228680610657,
0.035634223371744156,
0.2311198115348816,
-0.18639619648456573,
-0.13006162643432617,
-0.5753241181373596,
0.6253054738044739,
0.1198001429438591,
-0.5154373049736023,
0.2614246904850006,
-0.21881254017353058,
1.0536696910858154,
-0.48430952429771423,
0.18356645107269287,
-0.167583629488945,
0.5713494420051575,
-0.4745931327342987,
-0.8378826379776001,
-0.1359456181526184,
-0.015063619241118431,
0.07116453349590302,
-0.1769503951072693,
0.6078574061393738,
-0.5242561101913452,
-0.8632140755653381,
0.32069912552833557,
0.29852059483528137,
0.04057258740067482,
0.25297364592552185,
-0.6488809585571289,
-0.06059334799647331,
0.1303962618112564,
-0.30005717277526855,
-0.07971012592315674,
0.2465488463640213,
0.16905269026756287,
0.660030722618103,
0.7556183934211731,
0.09103628247976303,
0.27920565009117126,
0.21965186297893524,
0.573963463306427,
-1.0267341136932373,
-0.2874618172645569,
-0.7292054295539856,
0.3259091079235077,
0.08469398319721222,
-0.41969186067581177,
0.7319341897964478,
0.6758407950401306,
0.5852991938591003,
-0.16570720076560974,
0.48007020354270935,
-0.06791732460260391,
0.5122727751731873,
-0.5821722745895386,
0.5369020104408264,
-0.21988390386104584,
0.39306876063346863,
-0.07367967814207077,
-1.1229138374328613,
-0.10100369155406952,
0.10096059739589691,
-0.19183450937271118,
0.10190002620220184,
0.561137855052948,
0.7036077976226807,
-0.03977413848042488,
0.08286532759666443,
0.35289114713668823,
0.060637958347797394,
0.4284602105617523,
0.6878543496131897,
1.0433313846588135,
-0.3983398675918579,
0.7278949022293091,
-0.5885362029075623,
-0.22288383543491364,
-0.46335068345069885,
-0.36564648151397705,
-0.6848137974739075,
-0.45682528614997864,
-0.40990379452705383,
-0.13226065039634705,
-0.203358992934227,
0.884562075138092,
0.7077479362487793,
-0.871369481086731,
-0.22338221967220306,
-0.15167108178138733,
-0.34426018595695496,
0.04904342070221901,
-0.25102555751800537,
0.6181594133377075,
-0.6887871623039246,
-0.7134531736373901,
0.4333367645740509,
0.0975116640329361,
0.24094921350479126,
-0.5389783382415771,
-0.5034961700439453,
0.6564548015594482,
-0.4195159375667572,
0.4510534405708313,
0.12206879258155823,
-0.919705867767334,
-0.38511770963668823,
0.37349411845207214,
-0.31586208939552307,
-0.13669954240322113,
0.7960771918296814,
-0.7010506987571716,
0.11193142831325531,
0.2626330256462097,
0.30452439188957214,
0.7095817923545837,
-0.33796459436416626,
0.06602390855550766,
-0.050002001225948334,
0.09017674624919891,
0.5105343461036682,
0.6320924162864685,
0.31609687209129333,
-0.41716012358665466,
0.4385066628456116,
0.24522621929645538,
-1.079749345779419,
-0.6194322109222412,
0.009351196698844433,
-1.1613807678222656,
-0.34782204031944275,
1.1336133480072021,
0.04218944162130356,
-0.21313999593257904,
-0.09809324890375137,
-0.27782371640205383,
0.29041585326194763,
-0.20087593793869019,
0.8019008040428162,
0.23867389559745789,
-0.3684981167316437,
-0.3297159671783447,
-0.7491276264190674,
0.6400132775306702,
0.14489667117595673,
-0.7274239659309387,
0.1981886476278305,
0.6691299080848694,
0.25747692584991455,
0.2614212930202484,
-0.15304361283779144,
-0.05495854839682579,
0.2967413067817688,
-0.13621577620506287,
0.23260344564914703,
-0.07502537220716476,
-0.46490123867988586,
-0.3097951114177704,
0.1390283703804016,
-0.051121968775987625,
0.15980203449726105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10719v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10719v2
|
Is DPO Superior to PPO for LLM Alignment? A Comprehensive Study
| 2024-04-16T16:51:53 | 2024-04-21T11:58:54 |
Shusheng Xu, Wei Fu, Jiaxuan Gao, Wenjie Ye, Weilin Liu, Zhiyu Mei, Guangju Wang, Chao Yu, Yi Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) is currently the most
widely used method to align large language models (LLMs) with human
preferences. Existing RLHF methods can be roughly categorized as either
reward-based or reward-free. Novel applications such as ChatGPT and Claude
leverage reward-based methods that first learn a reward model and apply
actor-critic algorithms, such as Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO). However,
in academic benchmarks, state-of-the-art results are often achieved via
reward-free methods, such as Direct Preference Optimization (DPO). Is DPO truly
superior to PPO? Why does PPO perform poorly on these benchmarks? In this
paper, we first conduct both theoretical and empirical studies on the
algorithmic properties of DPO and show that DPO may have fundamental
limitations. Moreover, we also comprehensively examine PPO and reveal the key
factors for the best performances of PPO in fine-tuning LLMs. Finally, we
benchmark DPO and PPO across a collection of RLHF testbeds, ranging from
dialogue to code generation. Experiment results demonstrate that PPO is able to
surpass other alignment methods in all cases and achieve state-of-the-art
results in challenging code competitions.
|
[
-0.2604396641254425,
-0.36409756541252136,
0.6701769232749939,
0.12316929548978806,
-0.13427680730819702,
0.3050813376903534,
-0.3656403720378876,
-0.4204829931259155,
-0.17388823628425598,
0.3275464177131653,
-0.7502608299255371,
-0.23073171079158783,
-0.42668652534484863,
0.14419375360012054,
0.33212390542030334,
0.9348236918449402,
-0.17836470901966095,
0.0967484712600708,
-0.398762971162796,
0.047021832317113876,
-0.37862643599510193,
-0.6129562258720398,
-0.4841550886631012,
-0.7287235856056213,
0.5824089646339417,
0.5130820274353027,
0.799153745174408,
0.8352510333061218,
0.5735641121864319,
0.3049512505531311,
-0.07665695995092392,
0.38089635968208313,
-0.519451916217804,
0.09693673253059387,
-0.15446361899375916,
-0.2198927253484726,
-0.5177882313728333,
0.08546528220176697,
0.5744644403457642,
0.47694718837738037,
-0.44354355335235596,
-0.24264727532863617,
0.09688939899206161,
1.0823558568954468,
-0.6834335923194885,
0.07164281606674194,
-0.39208877086639404,
0.22853349149227142,
0.056214988231658936,
-0.19701333343982697,
-0.3782324194908142,
-0.6408400535583496,
0.28257808089256287,
-0.772026777267456,
-0.26858997344970703,
0.15479294955730438,
0.8414686918258667,
0.44558462500572205,
-0.3143031895160675,
-0.2727055251598358,
-0.7978585958480835,
0.9899157285690308,
-0.5883450508117676,
0.27484363317489624,
0.2594980299472809,
0.15780609846115112,
-0.46739619970321655,
-0.11857352405786514,
-0.6867953538894653,
-0.5628774762153625,
0.053951114416122437,
0.2595677971839905,
0.0534827783703804,
0.3591834008693695,
0.08120446652173996,
0.5316094756126404,
-0.43426746129989624,
0.5538671016693115,
0.10775437951087952,
-0.2529239356517792,
0.6753634214401245,
-0.021253449842333794,
0.06343881040811539,
-0.16903391480445862,
-0.6268114447593689,
-0.4758813977241516,
-0.6738955974578857,
0.1903793215751648,
0.7197414040565491,
0.13017356395721436,
0.23175868391990662,
0.46683216094970703,
-0.11613623052835464,
0.704509437084198,
0.2977008521556854,
-0.38161516189575195,
0.060955632477998734,
-0.05246717482805252,
0.056108709424734116,
0.14869073033332825,
1.0500917434692383,
0.477725088596344,
0.4388604462146759,
-0.21259614825248718,
-0.29954901337623596,
-0.08116351813077927,
0.32937872409820557,
-0.39526060223579407,
0.025752363726496696,
0.30407747626304626,
-0.2313738763332367,
-0.43569037318229675,
0.030465122312307358,
-0.586532473564148,
-0.5127890110015869,
-0.4359312057495117,
0.16352912783622742,
-0.25962361693382263,
-0.28149130940437317,
-0.05861695110797882,
0.19246989488601685,
0.45610523223876953,
0.36209970712661743,
-1.120726466178894,
0.2646652162075043,
1.1688525676727295,
0.6017402410507202,
-0.6005684733390808,
-0.5376530885696411,
-0.5967288017272949,
-0.10797543823719025,
-0.5595992803573608,
0.7622799277305603,
-0.4225730299949646,
-0.3923824429512024,
0.06062636524438858,
-0.3594861626625061,
-0.07367317378520966,
-0.9458224773406982,
0.6854809522628784,
-0.5331818461418152,
0.29421499371528625,
-0.31722140312194824,
-0.7317221164703369,
0.10384221374988556,
0.16219785809516907,
-0.448603093624115,
0.9239813685417175,
0.11908978223800659,
-0.5539355278015137,
0.4366616904735565,
-0.32931989431381226,
-0.26395896077156067,
-0.26273515820503235,
-0.2761586606502533,
-0.5801598429679871,
0.04774007946252823,
0.05427030101418495,
0.12400045245885849,
-0.2715930640697479,
0.6013292074203491,
-0.5215816497802734,
-0.4767191708087921,
0.7166831493377686,
-0.2390735149383545,
0.23315951228141785,
0.2893851697444916,
-0.4667951464653015,
0.45097240805625916,
-0.5562803745269775,
-0.10579003393650055,
0.15792813897132874,
-0.4828279912471771,
0.004210242070257664,
0.3597923219203949,
-0.2762888967990875,
0.3423415720462799,
0.1548977494239807,
-0.48032355308532715,
0.45122548937797546,
-0.39999374747276306,
0.47518596053123474,
1.2350213527679443,
-0.21538275480270386,
0.6500524878501892,
-0.5128344297409058,
0.5735483169555664,
-0.14151820540428162,
0.2910095453262329,
0.382517546415329,
-0.16675399243831635,
-0.5238590240478516,
-0.19650766253471375,
0.39970746636390686,
0.724913477897644,
-0.36890727281570435,
0.6673219799995422,
-0.15429356694221497,
-0.13850779831409454,
-0.5707442164421082,
0.07151325047016144,
0.653373658657074,
0.8256886005401611,
0.15051589906215668,
-0.3795551359653473,
-0.3473982512950897,
-1.0354390144348145,
-0.00616831798106432,
-0.4357264041900635,
-0.02147991955280304,
0.5143954753875732,
0.09947378188371658,
0.06807836890220642,
0.8854789137840271,
-0.47710639238357544,
-0.18706108629703522,
-0.18427501618862152,
-0.07270344346761703,
0.09775863587856293,
0.4508940279483795,
0.2353878915309906,
-0.6001201272010803,
-0.5916832685470581,
0.03272907808423042,
-0.35031893849372864,
-0.20701251924037933,
-0.049362603574991226,
-0.16240271925926208,
0.46928879618644714,
-0.006545925512909889,
-0.20291553437709808,
-0.11911813169717789,
0.7237458825111389,
-0.11338948458433151,
0.6045248508453369,
-0.39506444334983826,
0.22993317246437073,
-0.6925899982452393,
0.09611126035451889,
-0.15849311649799347,
-0.3498557209968567,
-0.42928093671798706,
-0.2411458045244217,
0.023565925657749176,
-0.11135155707597733,
-0.4935958683490753,
0.3224193751811981,
-0.13170631229877472,
-0.2667451500892639,
-0.418836385011673,
0.24561788141727448,
-0.10775315761566162,
0.8051683306694031,
0.31849053502082825,
0.9301270246505737,
0.26292967796325684,
-0.7492634654045105,
0.3404053747653961,
0.2560441493988037,
-0.35551777482032776,
0.43149641156196594,
-0.657307505607605,
0.40595316886901855,
0.04914950206875801,
0.22488728165626526,
-0.8547759056091309,
-0.06461668759584427,
0.5026560425758362,
-0.2197999358177185,
0.34619659185409546,
-0.07725995033979416,
-0.4003659784793854,
-0.06877096742391586,
-0.4029293358325958,
0.16336201131343842,
0.6754593253135681,
-0.5836465954780579,
0.007133772596716881,
0.35891643166542053,
-0.019121430814266205,
-0.9444486498832703,
-0.22151662409305573,
-0.22329206764698029,
-0.283405065536499,
-0.2978847324848175,
0.6918773055076599,
0.0065465932711958885,
-0.1620589792728424,
-0.23140214383602142,
-0.35466283559799194,
0.2060154527425766,
0.1541312038898468,
0.17544282972812653,
0.38896799087524414,
0.24017350375652313,
0.14442357420921326,
-0.33535048365592957,
-0.39836370944976807,
-0.22826972603797913,
-0.2902992367744446,
0.5406933426856995,
-0.22672486305236816,
-0.31329527497291565,
-0.679100513458252,
0.18271492421627045,
0.397583931684494,
-0.13013480603694916,
0.45395252108573914,
0.10976870357990265,
0.2274526059627533,
-0.08587620407342911,
-0.4842275083065033,
-0.09579890966415405,
-0.4400820732116699,
0.1389177292585373,
-0.207556813955307,
-0.8589826226234436,
0.2611538767814636,
-0.3042438328266144,
-0.06048080325126648,
0.24108441174030304,
0.31087982654571533,
-0.16407930850982666,
1.135968565940857,
0.6581527590751648,
-0.2533860206604004,
0.8405967354774475,
0.08390826731920242,
-0.07623089104890823,
-0.8685830235481262,
-0.11207111179828644,
-0.40083417296409607,
-0.509494960308075,
-0.8472687005996704,
-0.1676548421382904,
0.1508587896823883,
0.36422330141067505,
-0.34953829646110535,
0.20958399772644043,
-0.6208438277244568,
0.4358889162540436,
0.6317645907402039,
0.08030117303133011,
0.3815075159072876,
-0.011150438338518143,
-0.09699495881795883,
-0.1817304790019989,
-0.7504221200942993,
-0.5324013233184814,
1.0154508352279663,
0.4154781103134155,
0.6907449960708618,
0.018251048400998116,
0.9281080961227417,
0.18830129504203796,
0.24717777967453003,
-1.0124682188034058,
0.43552082777023315,
-0.09435901790857315,
-0.15174563229084015,
-0.42029622197151184,
-0.5338937044143677,
-0.9820094108581543,
0.26194724440574646,
-0.2628735303878784,
-0.613679826259613,
0.2517279088497162,
0.5121338367462158,
-0.368536114692688,
0.11507793515920639,
-0.5746762752532959,
0.8456335663795471,
-0.5364807844161987,
-0.5895935893058777,
-0.2598051130771637,
-0.47622549533843994,
0.10752454400062561,
0.2836114168167114,
0.03913815692067146,
-0.2870776355266571,
-0.23487186431884766,
0.6711093187332153,
-0.4588501453399658,
0.4659125804901123,
-0.17625805735588074,
-0.3801988363265991,
0.13772591948509216,
-0.08399249613285065,
0.6439191102981567,
0.003127428935840726,
-0.04644371569156647,
-0.08648058027029037,
-0.13638941943645477,
-0.35662707686424255,
-0.5959292054176331,
0.7422375082969666,
-1.0676132440567017,
-0.6287499666213989,
-0.6844101548194885,
-0.3153497874736786,
-0.4255427420139313,
-0.013277576304972172,
0.038681939244270325,
0.10658126324415207,
-0.11992323398590088,
-0.09916378557682037,
0.7632838487625122,
-0.3570233881473541,
0.3062339127063751,
0.5882896780967712,
-0.2070866972208023,
-0.7387551069259644,
0.8969185948371887,
-0.20778797566890717,
0.3590849041938782,
0.8173433542251587,
0.5612207055091858,
-0.45615488290786743,
-0.5882852673530579,
-0.3122254014015198,
0.3420293927192688,
-0.4595019221305847,
-0.023890655487775803,
-0.1123509407043457,
0.2407023161649704,
-0.3344630300998688,
-0.0743749812245369,
-0.6425407528877258,
-0.32184267044067383,
0.015106135047972202,
0.09754832834005356,
0.04770136624574661,
0.5381730794906616,
-0.059151776134967804,
0.026621714234352112,
-0.5409524440765381,
0.14651435613632202,
0.500361442565918,
0.6461144685745239,
-0.16346488893032074,
-0.21050086617469788,
0.08318454027175903,
-0.07066211104393005,
-0.48186811804771423,
-0.9372619390487671,
0.05227483808994293,
-0.11329804360866547,
0.5400921702384949,
0.33970972895622253,
0.1953856498003006,
0.6163245439529419,
-0.39707067608833313,
0.45812922716140747,
0.17687195539474487,
-0.8226720094680786,
0.6010342240333557,
-0.31735944747924805,
0.09976713359355927,
0.6879336833953857,
0.3557133376598358,
-0.6725590229034424,
0.16088533401489258,
-0.5073509216308594,
-0.7585839033126831,
0.9141010642051697,
-0.1451234072446823,
-0.26343002915382385,
0.12365573644638062,
0.48388969898223877,
0.16497482359409332,
0.299301415681839,
-0.6421318650245667,
-0.05789743736386299,
0.013823323883116245,
-0.0417712926864624,
-0.1546950787305832,
-0.2565214931964874,
-0.2514438331127167,
0.05015277490019798,
0.7006012201309204,
-0.22627684473991394,
0.22083450853824615,
0.3312814235687256,
-0.09439373016357422,
-0.2277614325284958,
0.5239898562431335,
0.850396990776062,
0.7560907602310181,
-0.41988757252693176,
-0.19209465384483337,
-0.07644504308700562,
-0.12471161782741547,
0.3607291579246521,
-0.07228995859622955,
-0.10876516252756119,
-0.4842195212841034,
0.2854181230068207,
1.0123480558395386,
0.22823458909988403,
-0.8414481282234192,
0.5160477757453918,
-0.07062740623950958,
-0.43498075008392334,
-0.1851758062839508,
0.18360893428325653,
-0.1621159464120865,
0.20966532826423645,
0.1463252454996109,
-0.25565195083618164,
-0.13021114468574524,
-0.544579803943634,
-0.014447249472141266,
0.39205148816108704,
-0.521477460861206,
-0.13258765637874603,
0.4358392059803009,
0.3205217719078064,
-0.4211787283420563,
0.7132285237312317,
-0.04033698886632919,
-0.5102440714836121,
0.5154249668121338,
0.33701950311660767,
0.8852982521057129,
-0.02457365393638611,
0.38473495841026306,
0.19135917723178864,
-0.04598177596926689,
-0.1955728828907013,
0.029704943299293518,
-0.45479732751846313,
-0.7864844799041748,
-0.7195088863372803,
-0.6218620538711548,
-0.972752571105957,
0.12214908003807068,
-0.5809491276741028,
-0.06678072363138199,
-0.5536280274391174,
-0.07194050401449203,
-0.23203237354755402,
0.3055485785007477,
-0.2696498930454254,
-0.20979537069797516,
0.20466771721839905,
0.44928306341171265,
-0.5256361961364746,
0.858886182308197,
0.8614711165428162,
-0.18317602574825287,
-0.7445583939552307,
0.16434495151042938,
-0.017210179939866066,
-0.8558343052864075,
0.6439511775970459,
-0.022345390170812607,
-0.13894414901733398,
-0.11662597954273224,
-0.12313266098499298,
-0.7619256377220154,
1.0650835037231445,
0.45908641815185547,
-0.9226791262626648,
0.010112734511494637,
0.04650148004293442,
0.50698322057724,
-0.2047889679670334,
0.17417611181735992,
0.44640272855758667,
0.5066485404968262,
0.1330801546573639,
-1.0759549140930176,
-0.0598018616437912,
0.22647824883460999,
0.21535709500312805,
0.348875492811203,
-0.870071530342102,
0.38988712430000305,
-0.15721340477466583,
-0.23084446787834167,
-0.10937445610761642,
0.4779997169971466,
0.47400787472724915,
0.048232536762952805,
0.6764604449272156,
0.5740191340446472,
0.6322587132453918,
-0.22974689304828644,
1.181264042854309,
-0.2664802670478821,
0.317409873008728,
1.0862096548080444,
-0.6164678931236267,
0.9297381043434143,
0.6729843616485596,
-0.5654684901237488,
0.45954063534736633,
0.8168303966522217,
0.29226920008659363,
0.7031534314155579,
0.48112770915031433,
-0.09251165390014648,
-0.24890199303627014,
-0.08259843289852142,
-0.18904665112495422,
0.2854205071926117,
-0.20610564947128296,
0.05688050389289856,
0.1493939906358719,
-0.24683724343776703,
-0.0050969780422747135,
0.489458292722702,
-0.14167679846286774,
1.3083477020263672,
-0.099381223320961,
-1.3654828071594238,
0.5974752306938171,
-0.1569071263074875,
0.7405778169631958,
-0.713981032371521,
0.08972002565860748,
-0.3880821168422699,
0.6045006513595581,
-0.13787062466144562,
-0.7258402705192566,
0.17728306353092194,
-0.20160922408103943,
-0.0796532854437828,
-0.5804177522659302,
0.5033423900604248,
-0.37907180190086365,
0.26822730898857117,
0.2823198735713959,
0.2095840871334076,
-0.2817053496837616,
0.05516265332698822,
-0.8297134637832642,
0.049448832869529724,
-0.03942877799272537,
-0.34813812375068665,
0.7464146018028259,
0.01818994991481304,
0.11055704206228256,
0.7389317154884338,
0.5310431122779846,
0.15706121921539307,
-0.31367552280426025,
0.03051174432039261,
0.5387734770774841,
-0.5470013618469238,
-0.3642432689666748,
-0.9347359538078308,
0.2522689700126648,
-0.008077097125351429,
-0.29089170694351196,
0.4507150948047638,
0.3742307126522064,
1.059557557106018,
-0.031857091933488846,
0.5834280252456665,
0.19569100439548492,
0.34623250365257263,
-0.619048535823822,
0.14142277836799622,
-0.4243736267089844,
0.17403408885002136,
-0.2636680603027344,
-1.033509612083435,
-0.09460394084453583,
0.6445721387863159,
-0.49890217185020447,
-0.1123570054769516,
0.6162799000740051,
0.7607676982879639,
0.272461861371994,
-0.2160157412290573,
0.17423029243946075,
-0.33981990814208984,
0.3610682785511017,
0.752547562122345,
1.161119818687439,
0.062170401215553284,
0.6386514902114868,
-0.4742662310600281,
-0.4558620750904083,
-0.2489173859357834,
-1.1168192625045776,
-0.48665696382522583,
-0.4159706234931946,
-0.4474373757839203,
-0.20611436665058136,
0.2260637879371643,
1.050532341003418,
0.6383266448974609,
-0.7691648006439209,
-0.486833781003952,
-0.427731454372406,
0.5010477900505066,
-0.699702799320221,
-0.20372077822685242,
0.30520009994506836,
-0.47688615322113037,
-0.9056015610694885,
0.3423464298248291,
0.4303440451622009,
0.03749590739607811,
-0.17426346242427826,
-0.6382831931114197,
-0.13971024751663208,
-0.14127255976200104,
0.3392701745033264,
0.5129109025001526,
-0.7459980845451355,
-0.2829888164997101,
0.11114208400249481,
-0.1809893101453781,
0.2086208164691925,
1.0812113285064697,
-0.5864967703819275,
0.37855640053749084,
0.672764003276825,
0.6921953558921814,
0.24073150753974915,
0.1922374665737152,
0.7843978404998779,
-0.5312989354133606,
-0.09030456840991974,
0.2528238892555237,
0.21482932567596436,
0.22829999029636383,
-0.2970590591430664,
0.40580981969833374,
0.11169377714395523,
-0.9179238677024841,
-0.7153205275535583,
0.5761095881462097,
-0.9503913521766663,
-0.19465631246566772,
1.1064879894256592,
-0.017502374947071075,
-0.19163943827152252,
0.3213883638381958,
-0.36317160725593567,
0.2278498262166977,
-0.6581094264984131,
0.9708794951438904,
0.715303897857666,
-0.6037091016769409,
-0.18730834126472473,
-0.2442379891872406,
0.8068234324455261,
0.7635390758514404,
-0.6227214932441711,
0.22151075303554535,
0.48604413866996765,
0.16032882034778595,
0.03178565949201584,
0.8351564407348633,
-0.16542288661003113,
0.2290312498807907,
-0.4260402023792267,
0.03187210485339165,
-0.22719219326972961,
-0.15569216012954712,
-0.5661422610282898,
-0.001769303809851408,
0.6329814195632935,
-0.2228379249572754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10710v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10710v2
|
Dual Modalities of Text: Visual and Textual Generative Pre-training
| 2024-04-16T16:36:50 | 2024-04-17T08:44:30 |
Yekun Chai, Qingyi Liu, Jingwu Xiao, Shuohuan Wang, Yu Sun, Hua Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Harnessing visual texts represents a burgeoning frontier in the evolution of
language modeling. In this paper, we introduce a novel pre-training framework
for a suite of pixel-based autoregressive language models, pre-training on a
corpus of over 400 million documents rendered as RGB images. Our approach is
characterized by a dual-modality training regimen, engaging both visual data
through next patch prediction with a regression head and textual data via next
token prediction with a classification head. This study is particularly focused
on investigating the synergistic interplay between visual and textual
modalities of language. Our comprehensive evaluation across a diverse array of
benchmarks reveals that the confluence of visual and textual data substantially
augments the efficacy of pixel-based language models. Notably, our findings
show that a unidirectional pixel-based model, devoid of textual data during
training, can match the performance levels of advanced bidirectional
pixel-based models on various language understanding benchmarks. This work
highlights the considerable untapped potential of integrating visual and
textual information for language modeling purposes. We will release our code,
data, and checkpoints to inspire further research advancement.
|
[
-0.2585242688655853,
-0.7512737512588501,
0.4606097340583801,
0.06073208898305893,
-0.503724992275238,
0.14354601502418518,
-0.3617981970310211,
-0.3236609399318695,
-0.05905061960220337,
0.5268804430961609,
-0.519490659236908,
-0.48834481835365295,
-0.5876434445381165,
-0.11870069801807404,
-0.37068259716033936,
0.8411415815353394,
-0.06486685574054718,
0.27249810099601746,
-0.273337185382843,
-0.017193878069519997,
-0.3997708857059479,
-0.6929836869239807,
-0.10331347584724426,
-0.023944055661559105,
0.6299533247947693,
0.20131336152553558,
0.8580536842346191,
0.5899093151092529,
0.3798412084579468,
0.29915106296539307,
0.4861326813697815,
-0.16984125971794128,
-0.34687405824661255,
-0.02750759944319725,
0.06144269183278084,
-0.39495766162872314,
0.000629486283287406,
0.14488616585731506,
0.6213098168373108,
0.4535766541957855,
-0.004887667018920183,
-0.06274166703224182,
-0.03252217918634415,
0.4307977557182312,
-0.5696228742599487,
0.1994844377040863,
-0.65909743309021,
0.029164696112275124,
-0.35220426321029663,
-0.3655768036842346,
-0.3987340033054352,
0.1019044890999794,
0.10769006609916687,
-0.44258493185043335,
0.29258960485458374,
-0.08315590023994446,
0.9700140953063965,
0.3399410545825958,
-0.45357415080070496,
-0.14844587445259094,
-0.45469921827316284,
0.5166011452674866,
-0.41425660252571106,
0.6205272674560547,
0.4812173843383789,
0.09036985784769058,
0.3778998851776123,
-1.0879390239715576,
-0.7612481713294983,
-0.12413111329078674,
-0.25981467962265015,
0.3125569820404053,
-0.11351650208234787,
-0.0009543260093778372,
-0.14580689370632172,
0.44248682260513306,
-0.7162351012229919,
0.2734927237033844,
-0.14210432767868042,
-0.16351957619190216,
0.32910236716270447,
0.032313425093889236,
0.7152079343795776,
-0.21264463663101196,
-0.5924123525619507,
-0.3174923062324524,
-0.4261164963245392,
-0.12772594392299652,
0.4416091740131378,
0.22577084600925446,
-0.4492146372795105,
0.5459765791893005,
0.30586951971054077,
0.8532353043556213,
-0.3835974335670471,
0.272455632686615,
0.06551803648471832,
-0.8750183582305908,
-0.2459154725074768,
-0.4394344687461853,
1.252758264541626,
0.157767653465271,
0.3713282346725464,
-0.18085601925849915,
-0.28358525037765503,
0.3850407302379608,
0.37810519337654114,
-0.8648290038108826,
-0.6522495150566101,
-0.2743166983127594,
-0.45660221576690674,
-0.2967008352279663,
0.008746525272727013,
-0.9645904898643494,
-0.2817697823047638,
-0.551193118095398,
0.5101792812347412,
-0.5571120381355286,
-0.5073800683021545,
0.10333910584449768,
0.05456804856657982,
-0.12014848738908768,
0.3818362057209015,
-1.0618821382522583,
0.024405453354120255,
0.38516271114349365,
0.6073857545852661,
-0.013582750223577023,
-0.5945702195167542,
-0.08650542050600052,
-0.073208287358284,
-0.3888213038444519,
0.8570354580879211,
-0.7618900537490845,
-0.25903359055519104,
0.19328631460666656,
-0.11877316981554031,
-0.27499568462371826,
-0.2081339806318283,
0.3092330992221832,
-0.5164749026298523,
0.5439770221710205,
-0.04956316575407982,
-0.18097807466983795,
-0.028568169102072716,
-0.054767806082963943,
-0.7858943343162537,
1.0143316984176636,
0.10196119546890259,
-1.0426753759384155,
0.6152218580245972,
-0.2538743019104004,
-0.3085019290447235,
0.2693546712398529,
-0.6630679965019226,
-0.4071442484855652,
-0.0033582434989511967,
0.15189260244369507,
0.4932449758052826,
-0.3363249897956848,
0.373975932598114,
-0.27251550555229187,
-0.1925368756055832,
0.18006977438926697,
-0.6484271287918091,
0.5003718733787537,
0.12086249887943268,
-0.27069368958473206,
0.1729794591665268,
-0.663235604763031,
0.11820119619369507,
0.19476501643657684,
-0.17898252606391907,
-0.3243389427661896,
-0.030823593959212303,
0.632720947265625,
0.3653445839881897,
0.29762136936187744,
-0.2985863983631134,
0.005609168671071529,
-0.14462189376354218,
0.327002614736557,
0.5197669863700867,
-0.516182005405426,
0.4993067681789398,
0.016593370586633682,
0.5767794847488403,
0.1422363519668579,
-0.2454836219549179,
-0.7359204292297363,
-0.15098628401756287,
-0.6612693667411804,
-0.4833395481109619,
0.37164613604545593,
0.4335894286632538,
-1.0539963245391846,
0.38488033413887024,
-0.4346005916595459,
-0.3107845187187195,
-0.3660094439983368,
0.08259805291891098,
0.640473484992981,
0.3016107976436615,
0.2732563018798828,
-0.3609805107116699,
-0.49641311168670654,
-0.8269879221916199,
-0.23555892705917358,
-0.35331571102142334,
0.16416318714618683,
0.15125539898872375,
0.36801233887672424,
-0.43969374895095825,
1.0772225856781006,
-0.2251933515071869,
-0.22959035634994507,
-0.40398821234703064,
0.7202358841896057,
-0.1478998064994812,
0.48335757851600647,
0.7211382985115051,
-1.0316187143325806,
-0.4878354072570801,
0.03593007102608681,
-0.6093125343322754,
-0.12764854729175568,
-0.2004162222146988,
-0.07435908913612366,
0.40630602836608887,
0.6708312630653381,
-0.19043684005737305,
0.6341844797134399,
0.8520976901054382,
-0.5730995535850525,
0.4652249217033386,
-0.3267045319080353,
0.26498907804489136,
-1.0949314832687378,
0.09328454732894897,
0.07611510902643204,
-0.25978848338127136,
-0.5776492953300476,
-0.19473788142204285,
0.5084020495414734,
-0.19862614572048187,
-0.19853149354457855,
0.5694170594215393,
-0.6656679511070251,
0.09246502071619034,
-0.340475469827652,
-0.09358344227075577,
-0.052162330597639084,
0.616567850112915,
0.5907204151153564,
1.0295509099960327,
0.5980379581451416,
-0.2802782654762268,
0.22867679595947266,
0.1657596379518509,
-0.47078466415405273,
0.3760087192058563,
-0.4882640242576599,
-0.2142331749200821,
-0.3757883608341217,
0.06383813917636871,
-1.0795719623565674,
-0.09451258927583694,
0.04370086267590523,
-0.40073394775390625,
0.6243794560432434,
-0.13243257999420166,
-0.7912347316741943,
-0.32686516642570496,
-0.08006644994020462,
0.8216023445129395,
0.3800870478153229,
-0.4383508265018463,
0.5383849143981934,
0.38926902413368225,
-0.4360692501068115,
-0.4568310081958771,
-0.8713104724884033,
0.31391003727912903,
0.09746071696281433,
-0.5262669324874878,
0.22554104030132294,
0.0023663716856390238,
0.19999875128269196,
-0.05674683675169945,
0.35030439496040344,
-0.25868910551071167,
-0.21650967001914978,
0.12348644435405731,
0.4743717312812805,
-0.16029956936836243,
0.4026494026184082,
-0.2560410499572754,
-0.20551425218582153,
-0.03513515740633011,
-0.31987127661705017,
0.7244561910629272,
-0.15844514966011047,
-0.4254510998725891,
-0.44523948431015015,
0.3156684339046478,
0.6048035621643066,
-0.5150413513183594,
0.6798874735832214,
0.6808633804321289,
-0.19542238116264343,
-0.012816036120057106,
-0.5899353623390198,
0.029565876349806786,
-0.4020695984363556,
0.8239008784294128,
-0.3175029456615448,
-0.5226025581359863,
0.10483371466398239,
0.1833440512418747,
-0.2860002815723419,
0.13926191627979279,
0.6424028873443604,
-0.06153228506445885,
0.6626920700073242,
1.0050326585769653,
0.17885902523994446,
0.8854153752326965,
-0.09052222967147827,
0.18699300289154053,
-0.4552696943283081,
-0.24052032828330994,
-0.29225093126296997,
0.11629141122102737,
-0.33552736043930054,
-0.6098178625106812,
0.10986827313899994,
0.23738771677017212,
-0.0012941051973029971,
0.46427813172340393,
-0.15604321658611298,
0.24054351449012756,
0.4397342801094055,
0.15313999354839325,
0.18365733325481415,
0.09849319607019424,
-0.3458629250526428,
-0.40394726395606995,
-0.7900224924087524,
-0.5394496321678162,
1.0789397954940796,
0.35067713260650635,
0.9504124522209167,
-0.20748573541641235,
0.2925967872142792,
0.03240516036748886,
0.36835435032844543,
-0.5738075971603394,
0.41350749135017395,
-0.3453822433948517,
-0.2967928349971771,
-0.11384152621030807,
-0.4130167067050934,
-0.8301153182983398,
0.47381699085235596,
-0.4964548647403717,
-0.2983129024505615,
0.18169669806957245,
0.3266410529613495,
0.09572318941354752,
0.21839962899684906,
-1.0427056550979614,
1.331884741783142,
-0.5825427770614624,
-0.5190029144287109,
-0.08588206022977829,
-0.5737190246582031,
0.18014957010746002,
-0.27461791038513184,
0.2369915395975113,
0.0968746691942215,
-0.260802298784256,
0.5016012787818909,
-0.3190326690673828,
0.9537190198898315,
0.155530646443367,
-0.16466008126735687,
0.020019616931676865,
-0.0045495289377868176,
0.22031249105930328,
0.04484272003173828,
0.334928959608078,
0.25994211435317993,
0.0535636767745018,
-0.47540244460105896,
-0.34936702251434326,
0.3041441738605499,
-0.740243673324585,
-0.16182619333267212,
-0.481877863407135,
-0.492729127407074,
-0.2532452940940857,
0.43212926387786865,
0.521193265914917,
0.7811141610145569,
-0.47361472249031067,
0.10544127970933914,
0.3946286141872406,
-0.2951563596725464,
0.7283428311347961,
0.32895687222480774,
-0.2636168599128723,
-0.6373805999755859,
0.7176303863525391,
-0.2098928838968277,
0.3507198393344879,
0.5545695424079895,
-0.053520988672971725,
-0.5049680471420288,
-0.623228907585144,
-0.6258001327514648,
0.37877365946769714,
-0.6276435256004333,
-0.13367298245429993,
-0.9171326756477356,
-0.12608367204666138,
-0.40279442071914673,
-0.06909346580505371,
-0.4553181827068329,
0.05728096887469292,
-0.5512059330940247,
0.18572746217250824,
0.10729818791151047,
0.7466338276863098,
0.1255313754081726,
0.4004533886909485,
-0.6744070053100586,
0.37394043803215027,
0.3461737632751465,
0.5422295928001404,
-0.17747360467910767,
-0.33513641357421875,
-0.3186391592025757,
0.28839051723480225,
0.00400103023275733,
-0.8178397417068481,
0.6775820255279541,
0.04796475172042847,
0.4250361919403076,
0.20239421725273132,
-0.3491770327091217,
0.6636835932731628,
-0.6201984882354736,
0.5668343901634216,
0.6619341969490051,
-0.7718193531036377,
0.4284171164035797,
-0.6859107613563538,
0.49526679515838623,
0.6366110444068909,
0.31182822585105896,
-0.5018179416656494,
-0.22000841796398163,
-0.3394045829772949,
-0.5592421293258667,
0.8182607293128967,
0.13422982394695282,
0.19178378582000732,
0.08131156116724014,
-0.04210613667964935,
0.2480354756116867,
0.4576517939567566,
-1.1212234497070312,
-0.004717106930911541,
-0.6544471383094788,
-0.5777012705802917,
-0.41767317056655884,
-0.45141851902008057,
0.11289684474468231,
-0.2781772017478943,
0.23165342211723328,
-0.3294578194618225,
0.1038220226764679,
-0.043175701051950455,
-0.5747224688529968,
0.17919676005840302,
0.09599073976278305,
0.34701278805732727,
0.5931217670440674,
0.20142869651317596,
0.2472149282693863,
-0.3045533299446106,
-0.7147814631462097,
-0.09279779344797134,
0.2734309136867523,
0.0014932324411347508,
0.0077651930041611195,
0.45043519139289856,
0.9964597821235657,
0.33764660358428955,
-0.7149500250816345,
0.905026376247406,
-0.28873902559280396,
-0.13247573375701904,
-0.03982388228178024,
-0.49181416630744934,
0.05030122771859169,
-0.10669882595539093,
0.15959495306015015,
0.16891948878765106,
-0.2659669816493988,
-0.6821019053459167,
0.2028154879808426,
0.616779088973999,
-0.42546507716178894,
-0.5241044759750366,
0.5778814554214478,
0.3027473986148834,
-0.06249561160802841,
0.35657545924186707,
0.20436114072799683,
-0.5453897714614868,
0.36849963665008545,
0.48298558592796326,
0.7780857086181641,
0.05262325704097748,
0.3969719707965851,
0.24381369352340698,
0.20359623432159424,
0.07708824425935745,
0.08253432810306549,
-0.336182564496994,
-0.6725829839706421,
-0.06508670747280121,
-0.9197317361831665,
0.08311270922422409,
-0.04446494206786156,
-0.3433491885662079,
0.5020164847373962,
-0.13473059237003326,
-0.040770016610622406,
-0.19076672196388245,
-0.2682165503501892,
-0.6486915946006775,
0.3897664546966553,
0.3698355257511139,
0.5818372368812561,
-0.8570888042449951,
0.9671638011932373,
0.7548909187316895,
-0.6584574580192566,
-0.3231928050518036,
0.10506153851747513,
-0.26850536465644836,
-0.8536617159843445,
0.7898234724998474,
0.19945457577705383,
-0.30065101385116577,
0.15581558644771576,
-0.3417278528213501,
-0.7757324576377869,
0.8373428583145142,
0.35278019309043884,
-0.43082940578460693,
-0.06369180977344513,
0.21073143184185028,
0.6800161600112915,
-0.3442640006542206,
0.4644050896167755,
0.15570220351219177,
0.2664916217327118,
0.1324910819530487,
-0.8239662051200867,
-0.270895391702652,
-0.5690463781356812,
0.38160908222198486,
0.26800835132598877,
-0.3347073197364807,
0.8352380990982056,
-0.060695577412843704,
-0.7608717679977417,
0.17895425856113434,
0.7139787077903748,
-0.27470603585243225,
-0.08604685962200165,
0.3809197247028351,
0.5971808433532715,
0.29211339354515076,
-0.20833000540733337,
0.9804551601409912,
-0.36024194955825806,
0.12022797018289566,
1.0293854475021362,
0.029827360063791275,
0.8562674522399902,
0.4649009108543396,
-0.11124084889888763,
0.6376550793647766,
0.6122222542762756,
0.17544634640216827,
0.6255789399147034,
-0.06974529474973679,
-0.31966856122016907,
-0.318724662065506,
0.018324555829167366,
-0.43945443630218506,
0.4281228184700012,
0.18478082120418549,
-0.38580480217933655,
-0.2876271903514862,
0.1767215132713318,
-0.058511797338724136,
0.5641583800315857,
-0.08123460412025452,
0.8678272366523743,
-0.18685658276081085,
-0.6784461736679077,
0.5959579944610596,
-0.16777731478214264,
0.9649975299835205,
-0.7759144902229309,
0.18931686878204346,
0.031852200627326965,
0.10468485206365585,
0.10864441841840744,
-0.6477317810058594,
0.02717275731265545,
-0.07371235638856888,
-0.21993482112884521,
-0.8343115448951721,
0.5525922179222107,
-0.8872864246368408,
-0.588630199432373,
0.33737045526504517,
0.515221118927002,
-0.325204074382782,
-0.044117558747529984,
-0.5948261618614197,
0.14257414638996124,
-0.16195048391819,
-0.03932519629597664,
0.27218279242515564,
0.6664981842041016,
0.15921157598495483,
0.36233046650886536,
0.5541724562644958,
0.042526163160800934,
0.18739953637123108,
0.3068910539150238,
0.9110540747642517,
-0.8150604963302612,
-0.7439581155776978,
-0.7587115168571472,
0.5697103142738342,
0.087259441614151,
-0.30968618392944336,
0.46446919441223145,
0.5945388078689575,
0.82317054271698,
-0.22852902114391327,
0.8175686597824097,
0.15917807817459106,
0.21626706421375275,
-0.7991013526916504,
0.9648259878158569,
-0.6413273811340332,
-0.08414934575557709,
-0.14601221680641174,
-0.7043782472610474,
-0.2478669136762619,
0.2947421073913574,
-0.2813292443752289,
0.24816620349884033,
1.051643967628479,
0.7857875227928162,
-0.10699112713336945,
0.049579184502363205,
0.2926524877548218,
0.1322728395462036,
0.07869874686002731,
0.36466047167778015,
0.9657192230224609,
-0.37773722410202026,
0.5391110777854919,
-0.1578318476676941,
-0.37744563817977905,
0.004158599302172661,
-0.8914065957069397,
-1.1054143905639648,
-0.9742485284805298,
-0.1614682376384735,
0.07812655717134476,
-0.024142451584339142,
0.3841308057308197,
0.7830886244773865,
-0.3653639256954193,
-0.24203519523143768,
-0.5753881335258484,
-0.45875343680381775,
0.39295440912246704,
-0.1514308899641037,
0.11110594868659973,
-0.6939122080802917,
-0.754821240901947,
0.04260677099227905,
0.4597911834716797,
0.5586682558059692,
-0.3678327202796936,
0.021426085382699966,
-0.3695177435874939,
-0.1374252587556839,
0.5173676609992981,
0.18985489010810852,
-0.7438283562660217,
0.17530940473079681,
-0.12330560386180878,
-0.5286093950271606,
0.046204179525375366,
1.065529465675354,
-1.1300265789031982,
0.6468274593353271,
0.5808721780776978,
0.5899814367294312,
0.49821364879608154,
-0.07534932345151901,
0.9170457124710083,
-0.5448034405708313,
0.591633677482605,
0.178911492228508,
0.4027647376060486,
0.48326972126960754,
-0.09767260402441025,
0.2302805632352829,
0.34419962763786316,
-0.18203070759773254,
-0.7719026803970337,
0.403820663690567,
-0.7905250787734985,
-0.4470457136631012,
1.076181173324585,
-0.014866684563457966,
-0.018237633630633354,
-0.0018834446091204882,
-0.3134213089942932,
0.028773171827197075,
0.07390294969081879,
0.41411638259887695,
0.7404409646987915,
0.3719803988933563,
-0.5176231861114502,
-0.24943704903125763,
0.5388091206550598,
0.6934114694595337,
-0.9115620255470276,
0.23474662005901337,
0.7893368005752563,
-0.1586805284023285,
-0.09716484695672989,
0.8198209404945374,
-0.3058326840400696,
0.25277507305145264,
0.2694246172904968,
0.19086506962776184,
-0.12978045642375946,
-0.5141034722328186,
-0.4554057717323303,
-0.10572059452533722,
-0.19236697256565094,
-0.023684563115239143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10706v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10706v1
|
Cross-Language Evolution of Divergent Collective Memory Around the Arab Spring
| 2024-04-16T16:30:27 | 2024-04-16T16:30:27 |
H. Laurie Jones, Brian C. Keegan
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.SI
|
The Arab Spring was a historic set of protests beginning in 2011 that toppled
governments and led to major conflicts. Collective memories of events like
these can vary significantly across social contexts in response to political,
cultural, and linguistic factors. While Wikipedia plays an important role in
documenting both historic and current events, little attention has been given
to how Wikipedia articles, created in the aftermath of major events, continue
to evolve over years or decades. Using the archived content of Arab
Spring-related topics across the Arabic and English Wikipedias between 2011 and
2024, we define and evaluate multilingual measures of event salience,
deliberation, contextualization, and consolidation of collective memory
surrounding the Arab Spring. Our findings about the temporal evolution of the
Wikipedia articles' content similarity across languages has implications for
theorizing about online collective memory processes and evaluating linguistic
models trained on these data.
|
[
-0.9742828011512756,
-0.648446798324585,
0.40880781412124634,
-0.19343456625938416,
-0.20870812237262726,
0.0940423458814621,
-0.2778971195220947,
-0.5730501413345337,
0.5158430337905884,
-0.09388108551502228,
-0.6046833395957947,
-0.21193505823612213,
-0.5052982568740845,
0.24486036598682404,
-1.0442417860031128,
1.4227508306503296,
-0.336813747882843,
-0.22008134424686432,
0.22613529860973358,
-0.5974615812301636,
0.13775843381881714,
-0.23239471018314362,
-0.4248221516609192,
-0.32581499218940735,
0.7898495197296143,
0.022207750007510185,
0.673254668712616,
0.34534603357315063,
-0.04064314067363739,
0.2531198561191559,
-0.1492428183555603,
-0.08670377731323242,
-0.5748733282089233,
0.06286697089672089,
-0.47592324018478394,
0.18568402528762817,
0.2699574828147888,
-0.0341125912964344,
0.870392382144928,
0.40890905261039734,
-0.1908586472272873,
0.26284149289131165,
-0.11344829946756363,
0.8192181587219238,
-0.7549680471420288,
-0.021479407325387,
-0.6675646901130676,
-0.003087152261286974,
-0.09137062728404999,
0.2030060738325119,
0.17001552879810333,
-0.38617274165153503,
0.34198302030563354,
-0.12170015275478363,
0.4162221848964691,
-0.4863770604133606,
1.0091609954833984,
-0.024314118549227715,
-0.254788339138031,
-0.40249061584472656,
-0.6510947346687317,
0.7344196438789368,
-0.30134910345077515,
0.7522098422050476,
0.01335662230849266,
0.07981614023447037,
-0.13113322854042053,
-0.916605532169342,
-0.8376231789588928,
-0.04445897787809372,
0.11230417340993881,
0.1964777559041977,
-0.35390394926071167,
-0.5569055676460266,
-0.12027037143707275,
0.19029320776462555,
-0.4204024374485016,
-0.12040631473064423,
-0.525012731552124,
0.04060737043619156,
0.39655494689941406,
-0.1190963089466095,
0.8194727301597595,
-0.21471591293811798,
-0.4295291304588318,
0.28564226627349854,
-0.9246857762336731,
0.11945537477731705,
0.4544301927089691,
-0.04265131428837776,
-0.5128753781318665,
0.24506708979606628,
-0.14544673264026642,
0.2459501177072525,
-0.07352666556835175,
0.24236546456813812,
0.13736730813980103,
-0.579375684261322,
0.1869414746761322,
0.3100435435771942,
0.7552218437194824,
0.2900204658508301,
0.3939368724822998,
-0.40085703134536743,
0.04467662051320076,
-0.03147829324007034,
0.3665531277656555,
-0.7298858761787415,
-0.36219364404678345,
-0.07218950986862183,
-0.5475484728813171,
0.11128633469343185,
0.3123827874660492,
-0.8157418966293335,
-0.21547234058380127,
-0.20893701910972595,
-0.18320722877979279,
-0.1934245526790619,
-0.5140928626060486,
-0.1310042142868042,
-0.40834906697273254,
0.1910272091627121,
0.3738100826740265,
-0.6842368245124817,
0.22064192593097687,
0.6456853151321411,
1.1155554056167603,
-0.27997085452079773,
-0.7227964997291565,
-0.03339110687375069,
0.22504691779613495,
-0.2600211799144745,
0.8943586945533752,
-0.5646267533302307,
-0.3934693932533264,
0.25605785846710205,
0.10897891968488693,
0.21508435904979706,
-0.1602461338043213,
0.2171294242143631,
-1.0264437198638916,
0.21188244223594666,
-0.6457998156547546,
-0.30437642335891724,
-0.3308291435241699,
0.2930296063423157,
-0.800254762172699,
0.7964628338813782,
-0.09618180245161057,
-0.9327806830406189,
0.6709750294685364,
-0.5792274475097656,
-0.2766142785549164,
-0.16425855457782745,
-0.6214658617973328,
-0.3031608462333679,
0.08693264424800873,
0.01481389719992876,
0.1766587346792221,
-0.21487745642662048,
-0.2005389779806137,
-0.22570942342281342,
-0.20833724737167358,
0.4024210572242737,
-0.08034562319517136,
0.7205199599266052,
-0.15035521984100342,
-0.3054243326187134,
-0.10427096486091614,
-0.642816424369812,
-0.41664132475852966,
0.027709325775504112,
-0.5512191653251648,
-0.43168002367019653,
0.35168513655662537,
0.02723812870681286,
0.37640252709388733,
0.2868224084377289,
-0.27174001932144165,
0.12009057402610779,
-0.4498486816883087,
0.38041263818740845,
0.7322121262550354,
0.6999106407165527,
0.23379825055599213,
-0.4020799994468689,
0.1893080621957779,
0.5667880177497864,
0.054278839379549026,
-0.14843478798866272,
-0.34528467059135437,
-0.5550464987754822,
0.3438310921192169,
-0.27148133516311646,
0.21072520315647125,
-0.33218860626220703,
0.17828726768493652,
-0.2607930600643158,
-0.7032468914985657,
0.029936252161860466,
0.18600749969482422,
0.15032444894313812,
0.16434358060359955,
0.3411989212036133,
-0.5118381381034851,
-0.5097771286964417,
-0.9172766208648682,
-0.24123045802116394,
-0.5497220158576965,
0.4452749490737915,
0.1928834319114685,
0.44980940222740173,
-0.19742178916931152,
0.7470917701721191,
-0.0009901055600494146,
0.18518801033496857,
-0.019383694976568222,
0.5186027884483337,
-0.006219747941941023,
-0.04847022891044617,
0.8214316368103027,
-0.8724969029426575,
-0.4185818135738373,
0.2796470522880554,
-0.32182323932647705,
-0.09653805941343307,
-0.31681129336357117,
-0.012383204884827137,
0.6174709796905518,
0.3876558840274811,
-0.5406496524810791,
0.3196747303009033,
0.533515214920044,
-0.46227559447288513,
0.6276253461837769,
0.1593293398618698,
0.6063737869262695,
-1.2386903762817383,
-0.17672209441661835,
-0.11465181410312653,
0.1812712699174881,
-0.3866475522518158,
-0.08614984899759293,
0.028297774493694305,
0.26814842224121094,
-0.6999587416648865,
0.32839736342430115,
-0.8532644510269165,
-0.32038524746894836,
-0.35786280035972595,
0.1564023643732071,
-0.4814225137233734,
0.03903869912028313,
-0.04265332967042923,
0.8869485259056091,
0.6182997822761536,
-0.7327055931091309,
0.4476582705974579,
0.19009144604206085,
-0.7066049575805664,
0.08884068578481674,
-0.09495649486780167,
0.29023805260658264,
-0.3477192223072052,
0.061971765011548996,
-0.9384859800338745,
0.05546461418271065,
0.14263015985488892,
-0.19713181257247925,
-0.14378564059734344,
-0.15778730809688568,
-0.1738126575946808,
-0.14965753257274628,
-0.3458949625492096,
0.5177267789840698,
0.4598684012889862,
-0.4482541084289551,
0.4327952563762665,
0.5614692568778992,
-0.3943588435649872,
-0.6898053884506226,
-0.517504096031189,
0.19669562578201294,
-0.26079052686691284,
-0.388030081987381,
0.2019328773021698,
0.07251323759555817,
-0.6185316443443298,
0.24056988954544067,
-0.28155580163002014,
-0.21319162845611572,
-0.018655098974704742,
0.27298375964164734,
-0.1815854161977768,
-0.39659199118614197,
0.23765860497951508,
0.17241936922073364,
0.23105275630950928,
0.34027916193008423,
-0.21537768840789795,
0.8660159111022949,
-0.07934652268886566,
-0.37987157702445984,
-0.4375978410243988,
0.5236142873764038,
0.7572613954544067,
-0.22784969210624695,
1.23344087600708,
0.4321117401123047,
-0.2912347912788391,
-0.13349059224128723,
-0.5677341818809509,
-0.21370582282543182,
-0.39281561970710754,
0.41530388593673706,
-0.017751453444361687,
-0.675452470779419,
0.9587776064872742,
-0.11135625094175339,
0.33754876255989075,
0.6773192286491394,
0.930182158946991,
0.06318239122629166,
0.35518792271614075,
0.24681858718395233,
-0.45987144112586975,
0.5866115689277649,
0.018948789685964584,
0.008268581703305244,
-0.39546486735343933,
-0.40313026309013367,
-0.6186594367027283,
-0.7511860728263855,
-0.3368885815143585,
-0.10937317460775375,
0.22071945667266846,
0.14550206065177917,
-0.5337933897972107,
-0.007755503989756107,
0.1401393860578537,
0.7358453273773193,
0.2615492343902588,
-0.04356471449136734,
0.1939714550971985,
0.22358374297618866,
0.27929145097732544,
-0.10900707542896271,
-0.35618215799331665,
-0.49501773715019226,
0.5882566571235657,
-0.1964777112007141,
0.5882957577705383,
0.560599148273468,
0.6355063915252686,
0.7400941252708435,
0.21414826810359955,
-0.34347328543663025,
0.2930183410644531,
0.26110178232192993,
-0.0736616849899292,
-0.26386579871177673,
0.044931553304195404,
-1.080472707748413,
-0.16460338234901428,
0.05209627002477646,
-0.8175930380821228,
0.3056991696357727,
-0.2367381751537323,
-0.0625072494149208,
0.39494001865386963,
-0.31208473443984985,
0.6919137239456177,
-0.0507919006049633,
-0.08365064859390259,
-0.7224559187889099,
-0.4732200503349304,
0.3168717920780182,
-0.2188873291015625,
0.22333668172359467,
-0.20983241498470306,
-0.49413785338401794,
0.8302065134048462,
-0.08943414688110352,
0.7578728199005127,
0.19282077252864838,
-0.16135630011558533,
0.3494771420955658,
0.049820516258478165,
0.28732946515083313,
0.09014230221509933,
0.0955226719379425,
0.3703760504722595,
-0.12790262699127197,
-0.5241897702217102,
-0.4167620837688446,
1.2322864532470703,
-1.3112999200820923,
-0.7132932543754578,
-0.18865182995796204,
-0.28803059458732605,
0.2115488350391388,
-0.008827832527458668,
0.0744095891714096,
0.2084326595067978,
-0.5035336017608643,
-0.15590882301330566,
0.5223524570465088,
-0.01813432015478611,
1.082138180732727,
0.6457396149635315,
-0.39202558994293213,
-0.2547350227832794,
0.47848430275917053,
0.46003514528274536,
0.06710322201251984,
0.005992494523525238,
0.13022105395793915,
-0.12788818776607513,
-0.5435313582420349,
-0.5399163961410522,
0.11508326232433319,
-0.7479628920555115,
-0.06842649728059769,
-0.7300456166267395,
-0.215342715382576,
-0.3453426957130432,
-0.24003246426582336,
-0.40440911054611206,
-0.34642642736434937,
-0.201966792345047,
-0.1508866399526596,
0.6411706805229187,
0.7332816123962402,
-0.06337826699018478,
-0.14476549625396729,
-0.9675021767616272,
0.21086794137954712,
0.07323537021875381,
0.18792276084423065,
0.21213176846504211,
-0.525534451007843,
-0.5771421194076538,
-0.28838813304901123,
-0.2454918920993805,
-1.5496647357940674,
0.08500421792268753,
0.39782851934432983,
0.5596343874931335,
0.8879652619361877,
0.0946795642375946,
0.5937094688415527,
-0.6870014667510986,
1.2420614957809448,
0.21811515092849731,
-0.7496877312660217,
0.5103400945663452,
-0.10801699012517929,
0.41125351190567017,
0.13755357265472412,
0.6720890998840332,
-0.8139491081237793,
-0.5045556426048279,
-0.5429372191429138,
-0.8967865109443665,
0.43813857436180115,
-0.10354067385196686,
0.404073566198349,
-0.333389550447464,
0.48684588074684143,
0.4471295475959778,
-0.04764702171087265,
-0.5302492380142212,
-0.5902179479598999,
-0.24954257905483246,
0.2296624630689621,
0.25813814997673035,
-0.33808839321136475,
-0.28764820098876953,
-0.24324291944503784,
0.5909513235092163,
0.18314650654792786,
-0.09387808293104172,
0.03204727917909622,
-0.07270953059196472,
-0.3368794023990631,
0.5000100135803223,
0.5877618789672852,
1.1228294372558594,
0.48925086855888367,
0.2929506003856659,
0.39606407284736633,
-0.7090153694152832,
0.19729842245578766,
0.12405752390623093,
-0.36449921131134033,
0.2654959559440613,
0.3209769129753113,
0.6593752503395081,
0.5506958961486816,
-0.7445098757743835,
0.21641986072063446,
0.09568177908658981,
0.01557724829763174,
-0.7280793190002441,
0.09649737179279327,
0.11895686388015747,
0.7306593656539917,
0.7718048095703125,
-0.3131578266620636,
-0.009143552742898464,
-0.9979751110076904,
0.40096819400787354,
0.19064325094223022,
-0.1171955019235611,
-0.5991984605789185,
0.2659454643726349,
-0.14591249823570251,
-0.07696962356567383,
0.388883113861084,
0.08885771036148071,
-0.5767861008644104,
0.44524747133255005,
0.38886889815330505,
0.721648633480072,
-0.2948678135871887,
0.21873964369297028,
0.49588310718536377,
0.18424661457538605,
0.2082698792219162,
0.4029386043548584,
-0.2241763323545456,
-0.9377626180648804,
-0.2997911274433136,
-0.5278456807136536,
-0.10689078271389008,
0.16937774419784546,
-0.6010215878486633,
0.09909724444150925,
-0.4665047824382782,
-0.16864871978759766,
-0.18796734511852264,
0.188856840133667,
-0.6614233255386353,
0.031005313619971275,
0.4078167974948883,
0.9360848665237427,
-0.9098967909812927,
0.6353791356086731,
0.9058642387390137,
-0.62221759557724,
-0.10761517286300659,
0.37952783703804016,
0.17064042389392853,
-0.6473747491836548,
0.6635374426841736,
-0.057146694511175156,
-0.13423167169094086,
-0.046505458652973175,
-0.2585306167602539,
-0.9962545037269592,
0.8595337867736816,
0.16583262383937836,
-0.4473159611225128,
-0.04545526206493378,
0.03219950571656227,
0.38645651936531067,
-0.0018609784310683608,
-0.18936856091022491,
0.5078823566436768,
0.36630889773368835,
-0.27667778730392456,
-0.9037448763847351,
-0.06733362376689911,
0.015559409745037556,
-0.22249041497707367,
0.7912454009056091,
-0.9253748059272766,
0.7628379464149475,
0.03818238154053688,
-0.6251701712608337,
-0.054666224867105484,
0.9656449556350708,
0.013578429818153381,
0.22083880007266998,
0.3376138508319855,
0.6109967231750488,
0.6715483665466309,
-0.04577837139368057,
0.8497134447097778,
-0.5091473460197449,
0.06868903338909149,
0.7407363057136536,
-0.12137570232152939,
0.8959754109382629,
0.7103918194770813,
-0.34865283966064453,
0.9332067370414734,
0.4490610361099243,
0.11798106133937836,
0.6036573648452759,
0.057063642889261246,
-0.728043794631958,
0.030547242611646652,
-0.17600636184215546,
-0.5728635191917419,
0.38112762570381165,
0.3305031955242157,
-0.45730355381965637,
-0.7420759201049805,
-0.19030539691448212,
-0.08101650327444077,
0.014055725187063217,
-0.7609521746635437,
0.9886388182640076,
-0.01346853282302618,
-0.4810672402381897,
0.18384256958961487,
-0.20556949079036713,
0.1758270412683487,
-0.35873621702194214,
0.11109451949596405,
-0.4273442327976227,
-0.16829955577850342,
-0.06200672313570976,
-0.8696504831314087,
0.6143930554389954,
0.3448648154735565,
-0.5064119100570679,
0.05255797877907753,
0.435205340385437,
-0.279074490070343,
-0.3000238537788391,
0.4387969672679901,
0.741370439529419,
0.463307648897171,
0.13710232079029083,
-0.6816681623458862,
0.3201000392436981,
-0.3140411376953125,
-0.5178677439689636,
0.40215134620666504,
0.7943828701972961,
-0.08694850653409958,
0.23167084157466888,
0.4793572723865509,
0.0732249915599823,
0.4807693362236023,
0.2356344610452652,
0.9501157999038696,
-0.758935809135437,
-0.40934574604034424,
-1.2871705293655396,
0.2006697654724121,
-0.11197642236948013,
-0.2645316421985626,
0.8365010023117065,
0.7436385154724121,
1.0996171236038208,
0.13640354573726654,
0.8039737343788147,
-0.14316444098949432,
0.30615314841270447,
-0.627459704875946,
1.136904239654541,
-0.5289524793624878,
-0.2482537180185318,
-0.1067051887512207,
-0.6704618334770203,
0.11814592033624649,
0.398800253868103,
-0.06591994315385818,
0.10439645498991013,
0.44739702343940735,
0.5310021638870239,
-0.06434336304664612,
0.10616911947727203,
0.07446160167455673,
0.35978177189826965,
0.021093739196658134,
0.3671157658100128,
1.0568652153015137,
0.10128878057003021,
0.5293125510215759,
0.1297817826271057,
0.2929615378379822,
-0.00676726084202528,
-0.6977874636650085,
-0.7316523194313049,
-1.0509679317474365,
-0.5137685537338257,
-0.43556636571884155,
0.14516910910606384,
1.1485569477081299,
0.22335723042488098,
-1.0470072031021118,
-0.09888912737369537,
-0.00837975088506937,
0.08309771865606308,
-0.25126218795776367,
-0.18587623536586761,
0.6006883978843689,
-0.23945504426956177,
-0.7016464471817017,
0.2177816778421402,
0.32567161321640015,
0.26195624470710754,
-0.5356674790382385,
-0.1674712896347046,
-0.45632967352867126,
0.09810085594654083,
0.36679214239120483,
0.9050765037536621,
-1.0245460271835327,
-0.4901531934738159,
-0.5249119400978088,
-0.08492954075336456,
0.06228586286306381,
0.783821702003479,
-0.8402500152587891,
-0.012581937946379185,
0.4460850954055786,
0.9096817970275879,
0.2531590163707733,
-0.195698544383049,
0.4969901740550995,
-0.6342872977256775,
0.2953599691390991,
-0.13143275678157806,
0.578764796257019,
0.21386970579624176,
0.15766099095344543,
0.1477324515581131,
0.48825252056121826,
-0.46210411190986633,
-0.49132296442985535,
0.2658635973930359,
-0.5959426760673523,
-0.31740692257881165,
0.8283911943435669,
-0.015599518083035946,
-0.06134358048439026,
-0.34351950883865356,
0.051674965769052505,
0.5334798693656921,
-0.5065181851387024,
1.713243007659912,
1.2073974609375,
-0.13841311633586884,
-0.7516379952430725,
-0.2754441201686859,
0.4679955840110779,
0.05219030752778053,
-0.7621421217918396,
-0.16711361706256866,
0.812287449836731,
-0.07713839411735535,
0.1565248817205429,
0.23896704614162445,
0.18648993968963623,
0.6289138197898865,
-0.1856241524219513,
-0.22799968719482422,
0.4384278655052185,
-0.45663124322891235,
-0.029598983004689217,
0.49990251660346985,
-0.16415250301361084,
0.07901996374130249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10704v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10704v1
|
Question Difficulty Ranking for Multiple-Choice Reading Comprehension
| 2024-04-16T16:23:10 | 2024-04-16T16:23:10 |
Vatsal Raina, Mark Gales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Multiple-choice (MC) tests are an efficient method to assess English
learners. It is useful for test creators to rank candidate MC questions by
difficulty during exam curation. Typically, the difficulty is determined by
having human test takers trial the questions in a pretesting stage. However,
this is expensive and not scalable. Therefore, we explore automated approaches
to rank MC questions by difficulty. However, there is limited data for explicit
training of a system for difficulty scores. Hence, we compare task transfer and
zero-shot approaches: task transfer adapts level classification and reading
comprehension systems for difficulty ranking while zero-shot prompting of
instruction finetuned language models contrasts absolute assessment against
comparative. It is found that level classification transfers better than
reading comprehension. Additionally, zero-shot comparative assessment is more
effective at difficulty ranking than the absolute assessment and even the task
transfer approaches at question difficulty ranking with a Spearman's
correlation of 40.4%. Combining the systems is observed to further boost the
correlation.
|
[
-0.5192540287971497,
-0.8430218696594238,
0.6056338548660278,
0.06431328505277634,
0.07903438806533813,
0.1522076427936554,
-0.0333954282104969,
-0.41572749614715576,
-0.2308223992586136,
0.3603648841381073,
-0.31792911887168884,
-0.2062922567129135,
-0.6765891313552856,
0.6305415034294128,
-0.10696788132190704,
0.8476036190986633,
-0.3571472465991974,
0.1388082504272461,
-0.36502736806869507,
-0.043388158082962036,
-0.6376347541809082,
-0.3514828085899353,
-0.8783521056175232,
-0.27422013878822327,
0.7211348414421082,
0.7461025714874268,
0.35233184695243835,
0.29960912466049194,
1.019330620765686,
0.31568753719329834,
0.18944095075130463,
-0.14531125128269196,
-0.17128582298755646,
0.3207857310771942,
-0.37553319334983826,
-0.49260279536247253,
-0.30993080139160156,
0.0191020630300045,
0.21854959428310394,
0.8100536465644836,
0.18038806319236755,
0.20644208788871765,
0.15988796949386597,
0.46260491013526917,
-0.8396351933479309,
-0.03920933976769447,
-0.3488870859146118,
0.08922940492630005,
0.006145460531115532,
-0.5328491926193237,
-0.5453959703445435,
-0.15339326858520508,
0.09231280535459518,
-0.41854092478752136,
0.35266557335853577,
0.33010751008987427,
0.6138795614242554,
0.401163250207901,
-0.8921769261360168,
-0.5125107169151306,
-0.6238023042678833,
0.9499316811561584,
-0.058158501982688904,
0.25291210412979126,
0.6192106008529663,
0.417173832654953,
0.3811095058917999,
-0.1761632263660431,
-0.4843117892742157,
-0.6105896234512329,
0.05755827948451042,
0.36871787905693054,
0.20135444402694702,
0.09330089390277863,
0.0806509479880333,
0.19913259148597717,
-0.8504893183708191,
0.13490717113018036,
-0.5772659778594971,
-0.041229479014873505,
0.7077990174293518,
0.21214905381202698,
0.23431296646595,
-0.38352468609809875,
-0.10577750951051712,
-0.4137396216392517,
-0.14717255532741547,
0.40801945328712463,
0.19695720076560974,
0.33976686000823975,
0.510506272315979,
0.7271629571914673,
-0.34782788157463074,
0.9890211224555969,
0.050732921808958054,
-0.28145426511764526,
0.3142143785953522,
-0.36017465591430664,
-0.06426338106393814,
-0.10290026664733887,
0.6349028944969177,
0.07287979125976562,
0.2716776430606842,
0.04910925775766373,
-0.011660889722406864,
-0.21294483542442322,
0.4618120789527893,
-0.5751603841781616,
-0.09961453080177307,
0.3331679701805115,
-0.07843901216983795,
-0.2678161859512329,
0.011494677513837814,
-0.539664089679718,
-0.1285184770822525,
-0.1565985381603241,
1.0879759788513184,
-0.41009610891342163,
0.12549065053462982,
0.24366207420825958,
-0.2147669792175293,
0.22226762771606445,
0.3410797417163849,
-0.8850283622741699,
0.1421261429786682,
0.3863028883934021,
0.7433145642280579,
-0.6505895853042603,
-0.3859673738479614,
-0.21223895251750946,
0.027593964710831642,
-0.20394179224967957,
1.085086703300476,
-0.42105385661125183,
-0.30144187808036804,
-0.34108367562294006,
0.056224316358566284,
-0.5583807229995728,
-0.35613352060317993,
0.42383843660354614,
-0.34267088770866394,
0.3430575728416443,
-0.1525777131319046,
-0.4972604513168335,
-0.205025315284729,
0.5900757312774658,
-0.3229866325855255,
0.9061799645423889,
0.3142503798007965,
-0.6127992868423462,
0.17422953248023987,
-0.7740494012832642,
-0.5835208296775818,
0.008958759717643261,
0.3182747960090637,
0.06775619834661484,
-0.30745285749435425,
0.31848323345184326,
0.6433790922164917,
0.019992420449852943,
-0.25519540905952454,
-0.15157756209373474,
-0.6035041809082031,
0.08025240153074265,
-0.42042404413223267,
0.6674748659133911,
0.3085559904575348,
-0.5220094919204712,
-0.33128979802131653,
-0.5219512581825256,
0.225677952170372,
0.026037737727165222,
-0.35562002658843994,
-0.3519454300403595,
-0.24556882679462433,
-0.5258373022079468,
0.12037232518196106,
-0.0261855386197567,
-0.37518322467803955,
0.22515937685966492,
-0.11129441857337952,
-0.09647603332996368,
0.48293453454971313,
0.3617154061794281,
0.44737106561660767,
-0.6345357298851013,
0.9130966067314148,
0.10324102640151978,
0.23846769332885742,
-0.033996593207120895,
-0.5798831582069397,
-0.9277259707450867,
0.23548878729343414,
0.41223034262657166,
1.4222524166107178,
-0.8228248953819275,
0.23499354720115662,
0.07899464666843414,
-0.8224360942840576,
-0.7233685255050659,
0.16832603514194489,
0.45878762006759644,
0.6486412286758423,
0.6299331188201904,
-0.13250349462032318,
0.19982130825519562,
-0.5689971446990967,
-0.03300727158784866,
-0.2805696725845337,
-0.1337086260318756,
0.41174766421318054,
0.5246840119361877,
0.29272711277008057,
0.2295638918876648,
-0.622039794921875,
-0.24786758422851562,
-0.20241965353488922,
0.18785353004932404,
0.09503387659788132,
0.5830316543579102,
0.30500248074531555,
-0.6857956647872925,
-0.8477481007575989,
0.05610664188861847,
-0.5707305073738098,
-0.18204888701438904,
-0.03260968253016472,
-0.09912603348493576,
0.1847640872001648,
0.4235522449016571,
-0.2972101867198944,
0.16309933364391327,
0.14102911949157715,
-0.33164796233177185,
0.7063697576522827,
-0.21054856479167938,
0.8160990476608276,
-0.7908347249031067,
0.0027766821440309286,
-0.20603446662425995,
-0.19687531888484955,
-0.4457857608795166,
0.3952470123767853,
0.054793864488601685,
-0.10088317096233368,
-0.6885587573051453,
0.27342692017555237,
-0.4487813413143158,
0.13342918455600739,
0.20763255655765533,
0.2558266222476959,
0.08230416476726532,
0.49435707926750183,
-0.22183114290237427,
0.8321652412414551,
0.5685004591941833,
-0.7525759339332581,
0.4091251790523529,
0.07706649601459503,
0.12445366382598877,
1.0122851133346558,
-0.53495854139328,
0.30988144874572754,
-0.20893295109272003,
-0.16569362580776215,
-1.4236128330230713,
0.19930320978164673,
0.23934508860111237,
-0.32246890664100647,
0.39830631017684937,
0.09278784692287445,
0.07313742488622665,
-0.4608231782913208,
-0.34167125821113586,
0.41407427191734314,
0.38399699330329895,
0.10660329461097717,
0.007615317590534687,
-0.20273634791374207,
-0.5327654480934143,
-0.6562649607658386,
-0.8072636723518372,
-0.24190372228622437,
-0.11444485932588577,
-0.3157116770744324,
0.2045643925666809,
-0.6152576804161072,
-0.18823090195655823,
-0.12149585783481598,
0.05891157314181328,
-0.2838239073753357,
0.04342040792107582,
0.11187390238046646,
0.1475934088230133,
-0.1861400306224823,
0.19354674220085144,
0.20417724549770355,
-0.06347783654928207,
-0.22351084649562836,
0.21585527062416077,
0.12286288291215897,
-0.0019101492362096906,
-0.5004530549049377,
-0.35570821166038513,
0.5292409062385559,
0.4632723033428192,
-0.12693236768245697,
0.42663276195526123,
0.3499358296394348,
0.06450679153203964,
-0.030208474025130272,
-0.4715830385684967,
-0.04929540678858757,
-0.44607385993003845,
0.20799745619297028,
-0.8143218755722046,
-0.8574746251106262,
0.22535651922225952,
0.2707124948501587,
0.21751968562602997,
0.5024587512016296,
0.3001740872859955,
-0.43702951073646545,
1.2678910493850708,
0.19612988829612732,
0.18225958943367004,
0.15620458126068115,
-0.2028798907995224,
0.03947329521179199,
-0.43620622158050537,
-0.1641804277896881,
-0.9529732465744019,
-0.48798954486846924,
-0.3261862099170685,
-0.30095621943473816,
0.28715789318084717,
0.17506645619869232,
-0.35800743103027344,
0.3766886293888092,
-0.6772174835205078,
0.6508186459541321,
0.4958554208278656,
0.11818873137235641,
0.5180657505989075,
-0.0018323458498343825,
-0.33497679233551025,
0.04299648851156235,
-0.5398776531219482,
-0.33194857835769653,
1.2680009603500366,
-0.11653336882591248,
0.45216837525367737,
0.23252399265766144,
0.8557253479957581,
0.3612503707408905,
0.302471786737442,
-0.9472243785858154,
0.5524113774299622,
-0.15523606538772583,
-0.7172625660896301,
-0.8752619624137878,
-0.5075127482414246,
-1.233546495437622,
0.38516783714294434,
-0.35789811611175537,
-0.4180986285209656,
0.04597052186727524,
-0.14771556854248047,
-0.6179309487342834,
0.03696506470441818,
-1.0253020524978638,
0.6497957706451416,
-0.10493097454309464,
-0.08191253989934921,
0.13280516862869263,
-0.507879376411438,
0.29233741760253906,
-0.1505725085735321,
0.307002454996109,
0.051980528980493546,
-0.1237279623746872,
0.7436351776123047,
-0.052545029670000076,
0.08659469336271286,
-0.01024699304252863,
0.24356403946876526,
0.19335158169269562,
0.4556233882904053,
-0.05662845820188522,
-0.11958768218755722,
-0.45905056595802307,
-0.23873670399188995,
0.4002043604850769,
-0.7058053612709045,
-0.7691885828971863,
0.5063354969024658,
-0.7759238481521606,
-0.7905252575874329,
-0.5775899291038513,
-0.6235975623130798,
-0.39203906059265137,
0.22567607462406158,
0.28708669543266296,
0.3420831859111786,
0.07168733328580856,
0.13131478428840637,
0.6010186076164246,
0.15736569464206696,
0.5990370512008667,
0.5367555022239685,
0.06915510445833206,
-0.18443937599658966,
0.9474987387657166,
0.6516377329826355,
0.48949697613716125,
0.5065913796424866,
0.05883549153804779,
-0.4090979993343353,
-0.8012322783470154,
-0.46301716566085815,
0.03613482415676117,
-0.6008109450340271,
-0.3259875774383545,
-0.6377576589584351,
-0.33703935146331787,
-0.514950692653656,
-0.41637349128723145,
0.06465335935354233,
-0.40871745347976685,
-0.3468531668186188,
-0.2604439854621887,
0.09172076731920242,
0.7273138165473938,
0.08723422139883041,
0.19574744999408722,
-0.5353701710700989,
0.4125925302505493,
0.6849923133850098,
0.19954513013362885,
-0.2136198878288269,
-0.6558588743209839,
0.21751715242862701,
-0.24665279686450958,
-0.7731772661209106,
-1.2397058010101318,
0.1554584950208664,
0.17136132717132568,
0.25104740262031555,
0.2044234424829483,
0.3566838204860687,
0.7272506356239319,
-0.33748626708984375,
0.9098957180976868,
0.00432848883792758,
-0.8978607654571533,
0.4537433087825775,
0.078611359000206,
0.29858216643333435,
1.1342318058013916,
0.8607174158096313,
-0.3135102093219757,
-0.5870314240455627,
-0.5298063158988953,
-0.47208908200263977,
0.716181218624115,
0.030271409079432487,
0.08044072985649109,
-0.013260718435049057,
0.4360524117946625,
0.18105268478393555,
-0.13263462483882904,
-0.49246495962142944,
-0.2703624665737152,
-0.06128324195742607,
-0.24554426968097687,
-0.5531412959098816,
0.12123619019985199,
0.29957151412963867,
-0.6525319218635559,
0.574731171131134,
0.03337741643190384,
0.17566080391407013,
0.5967984199523926,
-0.43697622418403625,
-0.041341084986925125,
0.5544523000717163,
0.5073643922805786,
0.6792353391647339,
-0.3685515820980072,
0.33112454414367676,
0.5546352863311768,
-0.5593470931053162,
0.6654645204544067,
-0.05376964434981346,
-0.17275309562683105,
-0.1686398684978485,
0.45995691418647766,
0.5048750638961792,
-0.004674787167459726,
-0.41527438163757324,
0.5954587459564209,
0.03474733978509903,
-0.7464116811752319,
0.11833957582712173,
0.46189847588539124,
-0.17266035079956055,
0.057545728981494904,
0.4179823696613312,
-0.18765541911125183,
0.37420690059661865,
-0.4861917197704315,
0.24799911677837372,
0.07229545712471008,
-0.45734795928001404,
0.11394890397787094,
0.22120784223079681,
0.21925388276576996,
-0.7588635087013245,
0.6153776049613953,
-0.5790436267852783,
-0.34230247139930725,
0.5375114679336548,
0.6122448444366455,
0.23966431617736816,
-0.6416684985160828,
0.6444911956787109,
0.4340454638004303,
0.43425750732421875,
-0.10540357977151871,
0.5872605443000793,
-0.096494659781456,
-0.44273248314857483,
-0.3873685300350189,
-0.4438660740852356,
-0.8677156567573547,
-0.06938351690769196,
-0.6793514490127563,
0.20522278547286987,
-0.34708264470100403,
-0.027888230979442596,
0.06602349877357483,
0.5093121528625488,
-0.7635836601257324,
0.4793305993080139,
-0.18703648447990417,
0.7819910645484924,
-0.8035253882408142,
0.3171597719192505,
0.7225123047828674,
-0.47930896282196045,
-0.8865805864334106,
-0.20955203473567963,
-0.44116222858428955,
-0.6053283214569092,
0.12028469145298004,
0.1824844479560852,
0.24360086023807526,
0.4976573586463928,
-0.12331777811050415,
-0.6440842151641846,
1.069226861000061,
0.33913329243659973,
-0.38258951902389526,
0.15982596576213837,
0.1672869771718979,
0.3854788839817047,
-0.04694423824548721,
0.918117344379425,
0.5242940187454224,
0.6558693647384644,
0.26672154664993286,
-0.9682782888412476,
-0.02047201432287693,
-0.18532370030879974,
-0.4112676680088043,
0.22184215486049652,
-0.40684613585472107,
0.7602543830871582,
-0.2467474639415741,
-0.01624382473528385,
-0.2229069620370865,
0.23854011297225952,
0.23934312164783478,
0.7314141988754272,
0.6702817678451538,
0.27070608735084534,
0.7530601620674133,
0.08422353118658066,
0.9525336027145386,
0.11717606335878372,
0.2835294306278229,
0.6339483857154846,
-0.3337002396583557,
1.2782891988754272,
0.5432368516921997,
-0.4580984115600586,
0.7251062989234924,
0.8447393774986267,
0.15994569659233093,
0.09307265281677246,
0.5133591294288635,
0.047190017998218536,
-0.2968587279319763,
0.04211335629224777,
-0.27998632192611694,
0.6033739447593689,
-0.2077052891254425,
0.09875626116991043,
-0.2633741796016693,
0.3963125944137573,
-0.19767442345619202,
-0.004229487851262093,
-0.4007825255393982,
0.6429017782211304,
-0.04400372877717018,
-1.0141777992248535,
0.7158227562904358,
-0.17135637998580933,
0.5811147093772888,
-0.5799192786216736,
-0.009115181863307953,
-0.3581046760082245,
-0.2929591238498688,
-0.038368307054042816,
-1.0000993013381958,
0.33748185634613037,
-0.05873585119843483,
-0.1465359479188919,
-0.4226371645927429,
0.5671760439872742,
-0.40357205271720886,
-0.6295660138130188,
0.08825067430734634,
0.9085993766784668,
0.7367479801177979,
-0.26185426115989685,
-1.0025039911270142,
-0.42928773164749146,
-0.26162293553352356,
-0.4777037501335144,
0.26828980445861816,
0.1512969583272934,
0.023003319278359413,
0.6674780249595642,
0.5711683630943298,
-0.0892094075679779,
0.11347004771232605,
-0.0032698146533221006,
0.07417981326580048,
-0.8376797437667847,
-0.44842037558555603,
-0.6735793352127075,
0.34161144495010376,
0.11896061897277832,
-0.36779579520225525,
0.5749185681343079,
0.07050060480833054,
0.6121858358383179,
0.007774335332214832,
0.42704546451568604,
-0.034191858023405075,
0.48158881068229675,
-0.2085518091917038,
0.6394741535186768,
-0.8044575452804565,
-0.21002213656902313,
-0.41832083463668823,
-0.970166802406311,
-0.5346168279647827,
0.27363890409469604,
-0.22094058990478516,
0.07307309657335281,
1.3247125148773193,
0.7705404758453369,
-0.05210229009389877,
-0.2662794888019562,
0.5492572784423828,
-0.2617388367652893,
-0.07338656485080719,
0.9788446426391602,
0.5587072372436523,
-0.509270191192627,
0.9508785009384155,
-0.40765252709388733,
-0.3979782462120056,
-0.10388348251581192,
-0.5867550373077393,
-0.8149656653404236,
-0.6973109841346741,
-0.38304316997528076,
-0.03640696778893471,
0.000764513504691422,
0.626031219959259,
0.7332273721694946,
-0.8225985765457153,
-0.27620938420295715,
0.2251582145690918,
0.38635730743408203,
-0.49963727593421936,
-0.29051345586776733,
0.3956175744533539,
-0.531827986240387,
-0.830857515335083,
0.29892876744270325,
0.05005301907658577,
0.22309432923793793,
-0.17923176288604736,
0.023916885256767273,
-0.29399147629737854,
0.3052169382572174,
0.6166504621505737,
0.06916225701570511,
-0.35216501355171204,
-0.44620636105537415,
0.40612903237342834,
-0.28662988543510437,
-0.15897779166698456,
0.5661143064498901,
-0.6125970482826233,
0.5009834170341492,
0.7422642111778259,
0.7585939764976501,
0.28149092197418213,
0.10700514167547226,
0.08604133129119873,
-0.43607816100120544,
-0.17449089884757996,
0.31194210052490234,
-0.09981894493103027,
0.13568277657032013,
-0.5244970917701721,
0.4447186589241028,
0.3009091019630432,
-0.6595699191093445,
-0.8241977095603943,
-0.042443349957466125,
-1.0906431674957275,
-0.38821032643318176,
1.095126986503601,
-0.19258439540863037,
-0.14957483112812042,
-0.5123398900032043,
-0.3573625087738037,
0.2488948106765747,
0.05315567925572395,
0.6447267532348633,
1.0453046560287476,
-0.5116118788719177,
-0.4254598617553711,
-0.7632524967193604,
0.2311440408229828,
0.9760591983795166,
-0.7469093203544617,
-0.5722315311431885,
-0.025029029697179794,
0.2686004340648651,
0.30536648631095886,
0.6327808499336243,
0.1615079641342163,
0.20113225281238556,
-0.16653785109519958,
-0.13207490742206573,
-0.26818010210990906,
-0.38125091791152954,
-0.494587779045105,
0.7209705710411072,
-0.03934023529291153,
-0.3283517360687256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10696v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10696v1
|
Integrating knowledge bases to improve coreference and bridging resolution for the chemical domain
| 2024-04-16T16:15:19 | 2024-04-16T16:15:19 |
Pengcheng Lu, Massimo Poesio
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Resolving coreference and bridging relations in chemical patents is important
for better understanding the precise chemical process, where chemical domain
knowledge is very critical. We proposed an approach incorporating external
knowledge into a multi-task learning model for both coreference and bridging
resolution in the chemical domain. The results show that integrating external
knowledge can benefit both chemical coreference and bridging resolution.
|
[
-0.4557220935821533,
-0.2959443926811218,
1.0232083797454834,
-0.05074260011315346,
0.03904303163290024,
0.34616321325302124,
-0.3500569760799408,
-1.0362036228179932,
-0.0793210119009018,
0.5251469612121582,
-0.28204503655433655,
-0.16784372925758362,
-0.7387449741363525,
-0.18772761523723602,
0.3134973645210266,
0.787269651889801,
-0.2669760584831238,
0.17496010661125183,
-0.5502866506576538,
0.0982716977596283,
-0.5849729180335999,
-0.7762525677680969,
-0.3793778121471405,
-0.7583925127983093,
0.3018432557582855,
0.6128201484680176,
0.30404624342918396,
0.3522980213165283,
0.666959285736084,
0.32328349351882935,
-0.2123088836669922,
0.21837522089481354,
0.02309574745595455,
0.4145912528038025,
-0.8784877061843872,
-0.7022067308425903,
-0.15607944130897522,
0.22495707869529724,
0.13355256617069244,
1.019242763519287,
0.19881029427051544,
0.010390232317149639,
0.14970555901527405,
0.6953778862953186,
-0.6354010105133057,
0.5522043108940125,
-0.35713598132133484,
0.037417009472846985,
-0.12514324486255646,
-0.01716761291027069,
-0.30332115292549133,
0.15298320353031158,
0.5349851250648499,
-0.548735499382019,
0.44465625286102295,
0.23566874861717224,
0.9606953859329224,
0.0068203723058104515,
-0.5520294308662415,
-0.21851295232772827,
-0.8817369937896729,
0.7564634084701538,
-0.3756391704082489,
0.3832384943962097,
0.109467051923275,
0.42698588967323303,
-0.10750067979097366,
-0.9845733046531677,
-0.4089311957359314,
-0.30620667338371277,
-0.09432729333639145,
-0.022861791774630547,
0.01366115640848875,
0.3778334856033325,
0.28798821568489075,
0.444926381111145,
-0.3240090310573578,
-0.300314724445343,
-0.6190782785415649,
-0.39778390526771545,
0.3855597674846649,
-0.1786683350801468,
0.25690045952796936,
0.012689510360360146,
-0.6852043271064758,
0.31712350249290466,
-0.5973430871963501,
0.05613233149051666,
-0.09971301257610321,
0.8539934754371643,
0.21559543907642365,
0.569031298160553,
-0.20171505212783813,
0.4776392877101898,
0.5523108243942261,
-0.16472312808036804,
0.27675166726112366,
-0.4343666732311249,
-0.10678091645240784,
0.35295915603637695,
0.008528062142431736,
0.25591591000556946,
0.15159137547016144,
-0.5300790667533875,
0.07333877682685852,
0.2569349706172943,
0.3271911144256592,
-0.7159150838851929,
-0.23203709721565247,
0.4197060167789459,
-0.35354942083358765,
0.468508780002594,
0.1573353260755539,
-0.4767732620239258,
-0.5295516848564148,
-0.8734756708145142,
0.6722344756126404,
-0.39789387583732605,
-0.283108651638031,
-0.3543941378593445,
-0.9317713975906372,
-0.27792221307754517,
0.34825825691223145,
-0.7048760652542114,
0.2586704194545746,
0.7990483045578003,
0.9454106092453003,
-0.11731219291687012,
-0.23528307676315308,
-0.10560502856969833,
0.5077710747718811,
0.10468852519989014,
1.1467175483703613,
-0.5804885625839233,
-0.7927716970443726,
-0.39679691195487976,
0.12569373846054077,
-0.12506070733070374,
-1.0655791759490967,
0.3167756199836731,
-0.6137122511863708,
-0.1285979151725769,
-0.8124544024467468,
-0.43112438917160034,
-0.33050575852394104,
0.07833154499530792,
-0.6220114827156067,
0.6548477411270142,
0.20380304753780365,
-0.4054490327835083,
0.5448911786079407,
-0.7520859837532043,
-0.4753839075565338,
0.004953307099640369,
0.03899117186665535,
0.16101975739002228,
0.08241420239210129,
-0.023543287068605423,
0.4640912413597107,
-0.41806647181510925,
0.16694405674934387,
-0.38269108533859253,
0.3886462152004242,
0.09968506544828415,
0.6314309239387512,
0.6619223952293396,
0.30561503767967224,
-0.13503287732601166,
0.25138479471206665,
-0.5528323650360107,
-0.23859505355358124,
-0.4129967987537384,
-0.12225131690502167,
-0.6664071679115295,
-0.38616305589675903,
-0.2551213204860687,
0.7058423757553101,
0.4276828467845917,
-0.9133379459381104,
0.1309882253408432,
-0.23633037507534027,
0.17378386855125427,
0.717379093170166,
0.6833859086036682,
0.8252966403961182,
-0.5843252539634705,
0.17977841198444366,
0.4642561376094818,
-0.03149358928203583,
0.1456291675567627,
-0.8697599768638611,
-0.7568132281303406,
-0.10030180215835571,
0.16879649460315704,
0.4510861337184906,
-0.7847853899002075,
0.20689836144447327,
-0.04802088066935539,
-0.7149320244789124,
0.14023970067501068,
0.45526832342147827,
0.37190982699394226,
0.7578280568122864,
0.5490052700042725,
-0.7667633295059204,
-0.5375868678092957,
-0.860472559928894,
-0.33347195386886597,
-0.03471825644373894,
0.1384778916835785,
0.41947609186172485,
0.7633308172225952,
-0.28297340869903564,
1.095004916191101,
-0.45750391483306885,
-0.5175310969352722,
0.05147842690348625,
0.4942764937877655,
0.5359349250793457,
0.6259083151817322,
0.5852097868919373,
-0.7861588597297668,
-0.6426432728767395,
0.35112476348876953,
-0.5950018763542175,
0.04478000849485397,
0.267988920211792,
-0.5159326195716858,
-0.04786469414830208,
0.16779725253582,
-0.8818225860595703,
0.0014236123533919454,
0.12308144569396973,
-0.45410892367362976,
0.6377314925193787,
-0.05482887849211693,
0.4426902234554291,
-1.0683470964431763,
0.1981874704360962,
0.35205888748168945,
0.04498014599084854,
-0.7423498034477234,
0.029937226325273514,
0.07526513934135437,
-0.24527607858181,
-0.5052384734153748,
0.6242848634719849,
-0.7410245537757874,
0.21467868983745575,
-0.19376583397388458,
-0.23210419714450836,
0.23513013124465942,
0.3445918560028076,
0.22105126082897186,
0.7298518419265747,
0.5613460540771484,
-1.0173611640930176,
0.6230580806732178,
0.05279949679970741,
-0.22884105145931244,
1.0433489084243774,
-0.08702229708433151,
-0.14350390434265137,
-0.05683324858546257,
-0.04697844758629799,
-1.020411729812622,
-0.05462256073951721,
-0.07771681994199753,
-0.2250332087278366,
0.5924569368362427,
-0.26531293988227844,
-0.3454373776912689,
-0.35283660888671875,
-0.03465217724442482,
0.01396446768194437,
0.009206626564264297,
-0.703690767288208,
1.1765104532241821,
0.49581992626190186,
-0.4336930811405182,
-0.6022732853889465,
-0.7470065355300903,
-0.2226913422346115,
-0.2324749231338501,
-0.6605104804039001,
1.048535943031311,
0.060124803334474564,
-0.3281850814819336,
0.304252028465271,
-0.42071881890296936,
-0.3932555615901947,
-0.4158543646335602,
0.42659300565719604,
0.08535797894001007,
-0.14571043848991394,
0.330809086561203,
-0.01815745420753956,
-0.3652150332927704,
0.2558964788913727,
-0.17003290355205536,
0.1992110162973404,
0.20882681012153625,
-0.3061186671257019,
-0.13691140711307526,
0.6685441732406616,
0.7184635996818542,
-0.23425085842609406,
0.7509747743606567,
0.12923192977905273,
-0.6643434762954712,
-0.2728695869445801,
-0.6104565262794495,
-0.3395060896873474,
-0.518014132976532,
-0.10678135603666306,
-0.6038583517074585,
-0.6543667912483215,
0.7674325108528137,
-0.716072142124176,
-0.12029684334993362,
0.7678065299987793,
0.5441502332687378,
-0.16646066308021545,
0.32433465123176575,
0.8376607894897461,
0.11353924125432968,
0.45134249329566956,
-0.3248264491558075,
0.5517642498016357,
-1.008564829826355,
-0.5150941014289856,
-0.514719545841217,
-0.20731094479560852,
0.2230479121208191,
-0.6551019549369812,
0.3060920238494873,
0.2900853753089905,
-0.4632421135902405,
0.6803945302963257,
-0.4245207905769348,
0.3163374662399292,
0.8854898810386658,
0.4864131212234497,
0.5160346627235413,
-0.000861757667735219,
-0.7678802609443665,
-0.31841564178466797,
-0.564646303653717,
-0.09052342921495438,
0.9744964838027954,
0.12522514164447784,
0.787533164024353,
0.26154670119285583,
0.6770208477973938,
0.3591061234474182,
0.503071665763855,
-0.8262489438056946,
0.1786101907491684,
0.19002433121204376,
-1.0534271001815796,
0.21035513281822205,
-0.2546713650226593,
-0.4780832529067993,
0.053750328719615936,
-0.11970158666372299,
-0.9196903705596924,
0.901380181312561,
0.1955551952123642,
-0.5690662860870361,
0.19949010014533997,
-1.0156463384628296,
0.8775006532669067,
-0.35358673334121704,
-0.5107882618904114,
-0.5568392872810364,
-0.5783651471138,
0.4188951849937439,
-0.004948067478835583,
0.23362502455711365,
-0.1640385538339615,
0.2020573616027832,
0.8630773425102234,
-0.5013697743415833,
1.118021011352539,
-0.3853724002838135,
-0.15420450270175934,
0.6285936832427979,
-0.10813530534505844,
0.1658237725496292,
-0.37674710154533386,
0.03395794704556465,
-0.0637269988656044,
0.004908484406769276,
-0.1244540587067604,
-0.7163236737251282,
0.9207881689071655,
-0.51859450340271,
-0.7115646600723267,
-0.6272812485694885,
-0.585343062877655,
-0.5481516122817993,
0.13467268645763397,
0.2389126420021057,
-0.08959987014532089,
0.2311946451663971,
-0.1644958257675171,
0.5961878895759583,
0.18157264590263367,
0.2776201665401459,
0.5224180817604065,
0.09265349805355072,
-0.3453541696071625,
0.968152642250061,
0.692047119140625,
0.23414242267608643,
0.344841331243515,
-0.018261777237057686,
-0.44949379563331604,
-0.04025188460946083,
0.006974049843847752,
0.3369784653186798,
-1.2524245977401733,
-0.5408778786659241,
-0.5384967923164368,
-0.27594467997550964,
-0.6967489719390869,
-0.07071075588464737,
-0.4541616439819336,
-0.657123863697052,
-0.3076353669166565,
-0.20658208429813385,
0.5759824514389038,
0.5206146836280823,
-0.5966950058937073,
0.19411394000053406,
-1.1926552057266235,
0.40632614493370056,
0.37726134061813354,
0.3782917261123657,
0.15388371050357819,
-0.5009122490882874,
-0.6430550217628479,
-0.0758773684501648,
-0.6461655497550964,
-1.0586488246917725,
0.05107078701257706,
0.353655070066452,
1.0790214538574219,
0.5366604924201965,
0.12948504090309143,
0.8006479144096375,
-0.5319226980209351,
0.6235847473144531,
0.2540321350097656,
-1.0173921585083008,
0.6821277737617493,
0.017794925719499588,
0.07020704448223114,
0.40102651715278625,
1.0359734296798706,
-0.7175542712211609,
0.024243783205747604,
-0.5610969066619873,
-1.1125712394714355,
0.17170357704162598,
-0.22742630541324615,
-0.21364161372184753,
0.2134498953819275,
0.4387943744659424,
-0.08307202160358429,
0.100064218044281,
-0.3695391118526459,
-0.308668315410614,
0.42760613560676575,
0.17953196167945862,
0.16113446652889252,
-0.01446347963064909,
-0.5978825092315674,
-0.4957980215549469,
0.8685665130615234,
0.2078995704650879,
0.4574487507343292,
0.3012939691543579,
-0.3314744532108307,
-0.17733731865882874,
0.1929696500301361,
0.25631433725357056,
0.7332344651222229,
-0.016571512445807457,
0.32398054003715515,
0.03924771770834923,
-0.3752233386039734,
0.21086664497852325,
0.1557874232530594,
0.6902017593383789,
-0.0956927016377449,
0.42522746324539185,
0.18310199677944183,
-0.09842418879270554,
-0.5977864861488342,
0.00846148282289505,
0.4182925224304199,
-0.252336710691452,
0.18818871676921844,
0.1463138908147812,
0.20981451869010925,
0.7712922096252441,
0.6311879754066467,
0.507412850856781,
0.23423156142234802,
-0.8468693494796753,
0.6755558252334595,
0.3138274848461151,
-0.2798578143119812,
0.02136571705341339,
0.4438033699989319,
0.4305844306945801,
0.20290327072143555,
0.29436206817626953,
0.17140178382396698,
-0.9004520773887634,
0.6483778953552246,
0.5583032965660095,
0.5028363466262817,
-0.7032960057258606,
-0.09954816848039627,
0.5962532162666321,
0.15752889215946198,
0.010112812742590904,
0.3770349621772766,
-0.49493128061294556,
-0.883476972579956,
-0.3639567196369171,
-0.14588265120983124,
-0.8245033621788025,
-0.41435694694519043,
-0.44005101919174194,
-0.1003362238407135,
-0.6836808919906616,
-0.7515363097190857,
0.13631632924079895,
0.19745700061321259,
-0.6252537369728088,
0.18435971438884735,
0.06284768134355545,
0.818540096282959,
-1.2281464338302612,
0.6676056981086731,
0.5947479009628296,
-0.6935633420944214,
-0.5208807587623596,
-0.44593337178230286,
0.1897483468055725,
-0.2889341115951538,
1.2537392377853394,
0.09142645448446274,
-0.14570574462413788,
-0.16535650193691254,
-0.23094646632671356,
-1.1625615358352661,
1.08775794506073,
0.2541026771068573,
-0.27625301480293274,
0.02015080489218235,
-0.01115986704826355,
0.36709627509117126,
-0.362562894821167,
-0.07059301435947418,
0.5599347352981567,
0.6151772737503052,
0.09377066045999527,
-1.323213815689087,
0.3079792261123657,
-0.43049588799476624,
-0.07163504511117935,
0.09859535843133926,
-0.32466310262680054,
0.7652952671051025,
-0.41576579213142395,
-0.5505300164222717,
-0.33060482144355774,
0.7811041474342346,
0.12595316767692566,
0.07037638872861862,
0.09901890903711319,
0.7785311937332153,
0.733944296836853,
-0.35407891869544983,
0.6252889633178711,
-0.5843042135238647,
0.3004772663116455,
1.2280242443084717,
-0.4003511071205139,
0.8692754507064819,
0.7774929404258728,
-0.2553654909133911,
0.6976488828659058,
0.7756108045578003,
0.054237253963947296,
0.6232591271400452,
0.1141611635684967,
-0.8767235279083252,
-0.2392832636833191,
-0.3945445716381073,
-0.7342898845672607,
-0.13972896337509155,
0.885347843170166,
-0.5278866291046143,
-0.3086789548397064,
0.2972967326641083,
-0.15939193964004517,
0.05284704267978668,
-0.19025270640850067,
0.6708117723464966,
0.19326812028884888,
-0.6925265789031982,
-0.002773888409137726,
0.154697448015213,
0.6971451640129089,
-0.3853204846382141,
-0.1891864836215973,
0.24832652509212494,
0.38120919466018677,
-0.49847331643104553,
-0.8942142128944397,
0.4847782254219055,
-0.34273600578308105,
-0.5642449855804443,
-0.07094099372625351,
1.0137896537780762,
-0.3647648096084595,
-0.03536517545580864,
0.6682137250900269,
0.4855691194534302,
-0.28145843744277954,
-0.49507439136505127,
-0.4413374364376068,
-0.5139032006263733,
-0.4667845070362091,
-0.01935545727610588,
0.21153223514556885,
0.41118359565734863,
0.14031998813152313,
0.6464200615882874,
0.8705832958221436,
-0.015411858446896076,
0.2406143993139267,
-0.22822803258895874,
1.1604317426681519,
-0.633574366569519,
-0.259250670671463,
-0.4759163558483124,
0.6134320497512817,
-0.12422254681587219,
0.00876747164875269,
0.7423422336578369,
0.5966442823410034,
0.7669414281845093,
-0.4824913442134857,
1.0354714393615723,
-0.3381572961807251,
0.6700609922409058,
-0.3939834535121918,
0.48346686363220215,
-0.09497654438018799,
-0.0418526716530323,
-0.1858951300382614,
-0.8773708939552307,
-0.5644382238388062,
0.6488258242607117,
-0.4730064272880554,
0.22327350080013275,
1.0803414583206177,
0.7188445925712585,
-0.23706954717636108,
-0.138335719704628,
-0.016688425093889236,
0.07404940575361252,
0.39302292466163635,
0.7228865027427673,
0.6785389184951782,
-0.23246939480304718,
0.10056198388338089,
-0.9008902311325073,
-0.3062186539173126,
-0.08128414303064346,
-0.766621470451355,
-0.8655943274497986,
-0.7838270664215088,
-0.28205400705337524,
-0.5850526094436646,
-0.15138904750347137,
1.0212106704711914,
0.9301960468292236,
-0.9472619295120239,
-0.3642977774143219,
0.1350308507680893,
0.10933950543403625,
-0.4944687783718109,
-0.29885536432266235,
0.1372680813074112,
-0.49628087878227234,
-0.6376899480819702,
0.362900972366333,
0.3747820258140564,
0.0724872574210167,
-0.02565518394112587,
0.0471494160592556,
-0.48922857642173767,
-0.17613455653190613,
0.7749491930007935,
0.6032488346099854,
-0.45461305975914,
-0.24185818433761597,
-0.2920154333114624,
0.059745170176029205,
0.2460760474205017,
1.2868150472640991,
-0.6535797119140625,
0.6258840560913086,
0.756489098072052,
0.680965781211853,
0.6294856667518616,
0.09883143752813339,
0.8381176590919495,
-0.8211469054222107,
-0.008574916049838066,
0.11855857074260712,
0.5765882730484009,
0.16135896742343903,
-0.71262526512146,
0.3876986503601074,
0.5940491557121277,
-0.48719683289527893,
-0.21114829182624817,
0.3063242733478546,
-1.2224920988082886,
-0.41070085763931274,
0.6993059515953064,
-0.37399184703826904,
-0.20340687036514282,
-0.5568886995315552,
-0.32021287083625793,
0.36219221353530884,
-0.5085012316703796,
0.4437240660190582,
0.9953519105911255,
-0.8117402791976929,
-0.25838983058929443,
-0.3054790198802948,
0.33837130665779114,
0.009143751114606857,
-0.9980972409248352,
-0.01589318737387657,
0.42210158705711365,
0.39085453748703003,
0.8808387517929077,
0.24004235863685608,
0.027866795659065247,
0.28134581446647644,
0.14320996403694153,
0.22804796695709229,
0.17563103139400482,
-0.7278419137001038,
0.18996407091617584,
0.28886502981185913,
0.24844904243946075,
-0.012496737763285637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10652v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10652v1
|
ViTextVQA: A Large-Scale Visual Question Answering Dataset for Evaluating Vietnamese Text Comprehension in Images
| 2024-04-16T15:28:30 | 2024-04-16T15:28:30 |
Quan Van Nguyen, Dan Quang Tran, Huy Quang Pham, Thang Kien-Bao Nguyen, Nghia Hieu Nguyen, Kiet Van Nguyen, Ngan Luu-Thuy Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Visual Question Answering (VQA) is a complicated task that requires the
capability of simultaneously processing natural language and images. Initially,
this task was researched, focusing on methods to help machines understand
objects and scene contexts in images. However, some text appearing in the image
that carries explicit information about the full content of the image is not
mentioned. Along with the continuous development of the AI era, there have been
many studies on the reading comprehension ability of VQA models in the world.
As a developing country, conditions are still limited, and this task is still
open in Vietnam. Therefore, we introduce the first large-scale dataset in
Vietnamese specializing in the ability to understand text appearing in images,
we call it ViTextVQA (\textbf{Vi}etnamese \textbf{Text}-based \textbf{V}isual
\textbf{Q}uestion \textbf{A}nswering dataset) which contains \textbf{over
16,000} images and \textbf{over 50,000} questions with answers. Through
meticulous experiments with various state-of-the-art models, we uncover the
significance of the order in which tokens in OCR text are processed and
selected to formulate answers. This finding helped us significantly improve the
performance of the baseline models on the ViTextVQA dataset. Our dataset is
available at this
\href{https://github.com/minhquan6203/ViTextVQA-Dataset}{link} for research
purposes.
|
[
-0.3703627288341522,
-1.008823037147522,
0.7051860690116882,
0.05416432395577431,
-0.6053990721702576,
-0.24289555847644806,
0.1283203810453415,
-0.24956540763378143,
-0.31763532757759094,
0.8888171911239624,
-0.48197141289711,
-0.544379472732544,
-0.5358770489692688,
0.2186257243156433,
-0.47253793478012085,
0.4079381823539734,
-0.22828766703605652,
0.18899434804916382,
-0.6602811813354492,
-0.4991827607154846,
-0.5265684723854065,
-0.2604272961616516,
-0.3802722096443176,
0.30155476927757263,
0.3389163911342621,
0.4500732421875,
0.5197367072105408,
0.7911702394485474,
0.6864843368530273,
0.3593812882900238,
-0.12483670562505722,
0.28899696469306946,
-0.6685089468955994,
0.17464564740657806,
-0.013445409014821053,
-0.42976826429367065,
-0.02166919782757759,
-0.3868745267391205,
0.6315864324569702,
0.07868444174528122,
0.23867537081241608,
0.3818311095237732,
-0.1854643076658249,
0.6436893343925476,
-0.7409547567367554,
0.1215401366353035,
-0.48186707496643066,
-0.0629379153251648,
0.23876865208148956,
-0.18974782526493073,
-0.3289821147918701,
-0.2169145941734314,
0.5330944657325745,
-0.6956436038017273,
-0.038203585892915726,
-0.209078848361969,
1.1223335266113281,
0.5267404913902283,
-0.775727391242981,
-0.04351338371634483,
-0.464896023273468,
0.5724653601646423,
-0.04185093566775322,
0.10046640038490295,
0.30691224336624146,
0.5161049365997314,
0.28666096925735474,
-0.8747225999832153,
-0.8048874735832214,
0.12691360712051392,
0.08751572668552399,
0.4418385326862335,
-0.25586235523223877,
-0.030078448355197906,
0.23496240377426147,
0.3485490381717682,
-0.8514126539230347,
-0.30253323912620544,
-0.6220696568489075,
-0.2228807508945465,
0.28234854340553284,
0.21349959075450897,
0.48911699652671814,
-0.4357282519340515,
-0.6539723873138428,
-0.10595860332250595,
-0.25957190990448,
0.25473421812057495,
-0.38494670391082764,
-0.1357763707637787,
0.045748572796583176,
1.01211416721344,
-0.37669655680656433,
0.858794093132019,
-0.5261714458465576,
0.0006809566402807832,
0.19576725363731384,
-0.6766355037689209,
-0.4723055064678192,
-0.2543051242828369,
0.673561155796051,
0.6269280314445496,
0.6224414110183716,
0.5083209872245789,
-0.14871256053447723,
-0.09617005288600922,
0.23510339856147766,
-0.8141605854034424,
-0.052477557212114334,
0.26248687505722046,
-0.5613766312599182,
-0.06854497641324997,
0.22905823588371277,
-0.5513707399368286,
-0.5584003329277039,
-0.42421671748161316,
0.8966526389122009,
-0.4009236693382263,
-0.11951304972171783,
0.16420820355415344,
-0.41734549403190613,
0.7070314884185791,
0.6526875495910645,
-0.11663629114627838,
-0.10010630637407303,
0.3827435076236725,
0.9765071868896484,
-0.04397476837038994,
-0.13974447548389435,
-0.7536516785621643,
-0.27862751483917236,
-0.18112657964229584,
0.9555956721305847,
-0.4631779193878174,
-0.2882384657859802,
0.24238240718841553,
0.16977167129516602,
-0.011530805379152298,
-0.5826088786125183,
0.5736546516418457,
-0.6167159080505371,
0.16693513095378876,
-0.32191377878189087,
-0.30408725142478943,
-0.23422831296920776,
0.3189164400100708,
-0.9403440356254578,
1.0382024049758911,
0.20093783736228943,
-1.0173660516738892,
0.189678356051445,
-0.23136663436889648,
-0.04166969284415245,
0.1720191240310669,
-0.18403661251068115,
-0.33264368772506714,
0.011739774607121944,
0.848774254322052,
0.3942652940750122,
-0.41359907388687134,
-0.11166640371084213,
0.05055529251694679,
-0.6649504899978638,
0.3621425926685333,
-0.5093183517456055,
0.7649635076522827,
0.06833137571811676,
-0.22048735618591309,
0.1357768476009369,
-0.6127074360847473,
0.1492503434419632,
0.19990123808383942,
-0.12839476764202118,
-0.6260619163513184,
-0.45196443796157837,
0.3209284245967865,
0.2712070941925049,
0.2774062752723694,
-0.547782301902771,
0.29208487272262573,
0.04396634176373482,
0.5239660143852234,
0.6173413395881653,
0.20606915652751923,
0.2928366959095001,
-0.1206846609711647,
0.759878933429718,
0.20826411247253418,
0.3066466450691223,
-0.7676391005516052,
-0.7103946208953857,
-0.7781054377555847,
-0.48106876015663147,
0.21487170457839966,
0.8133941292762756,
-1.5569396018981934,
-0.23424240946769714,
-0.38077232241630554,
-0.49822330474853516,
-0.7919934988021851,
-0.1464504897594452,
0.5268183350563049,
0.6910272836685181,
0.4599362909793854,
-0.08047004044055939,
-0.36277833580970764,
-0.9739275574684143,
-0.17906145751476288,
-0.3857009708881378,
-0.2610975205898285,
0.5340476036071777,
0.6837491989135742,
-0.320032000541687,
0.8592157959938049,
-0.6982538104057312,
-0.2526088058948517,
0.10477948188781738,
0.06400179117918015,
0.11905635893344879,
0.03047730214893818,
0.4054303467273712,
-1.3591196537017822,
-0.34522080421447754,
-0.07679183036088943,
-0.8111737966537476,
-0.05223056301474571,
-0.07587220519781113,
-0.47827112674713135,
0.23909823596477509,
0.8252050280570984,
-0.30246683955192566,
0.6818239092826843,
0.5689900517463684,
-0.48068246245384216,
0.43460652232170105,
-0.2467118799686432,
0.36505886912345886,
-1.0107733011245728,
0.09276406466960907,
0.2168339341878891,
-0.3631063401699066,
-0.3655768930912018,
0.08690156787633896,
0.32043468952178955,
-0.0006859872373752296,
-0.5612884163856506,
0.6012037992477417,
-0.20384372770786285,
0.1686457395553589,
-0.0065355258993804455,
0.053344760090112686,
0.2589852213859558,
0.30206990242004395,
0.25179624557495117,
1.026556134223938,
0.5034388899803162,
-0.29170411825180054,
0.3822420537471771,
0.5506159067153931,
-0.47101810574531555,
0.8940343260765076,
-1.0061285495758057,
0.0240663830190897,
-0.6395376920700073,
-0.019413094967603683,
-1.365540862083435,
-0.15660460293293,
0.14465975761413574,
-0.5119601488113403,
-0.31602662801742554,
-0.2418220341205597,
-0.2029002159833908,
-0.36752068996429443,
-0.04864244908094406,
0.5962750911712646,
0.4175322949886322,
-0.640484094619751,
0.588424026966095,
0.527504026889801,
-0.25793248414993286,
-0.717760443687439,
-0.6241340637207031,
0.20687387883663177,
-0.09240230917930603,
-0.603299081325531,
-0.1458602398633957,
-0.12469898909330368,
-0.23606514930725098,
-0.025222893804311752,
0.013762349262833595,
-0.6324639320373535,
-0.30052584409713745,
0.26335409283638,
0.3937320411205292,
-0.4900515377521515,
0.4042164981365204,
-0.040906306356191635,
-0.06800961494445801,
0.024824365973472595,
-0.5533019304275513,
0.12430307269096375,
-0.22715504467487335,
0.16784782707691193,
-0.404153972864151,
0.3202703893184662,
0.7393941283226013,
-0.6454536318778992,
0.5824407935142517,
0.6323897838592529,
-0.36742040514945984,
-0.005802519619464874,
-0.2707562744617462,
0.2814938426017761,
-0.45201942324638367,
0.547844409942627,
-0.447238028049469,
-0.965362012386322,
0.041595712304115295,
0.17408618330955505,
-0.006863699294626713,
0.5009498000144958,
0.5003404021263123,
-0.2516334056854248,
0.864443838596344,
0.5516214370727539,
0.08138740062713623,
0.5292303562164307,
-0.23961420357227325,
-0.3476197421550751,
-0.44379904866218567,
-0.2498544454574585,
-0.45856788754463196,
0.10646958649158478,
-0.6040940284729004,
-0.9968240261077881,
0.42101582884788513,
-0.41421884298324585,
-0.3719300329685211,
0.024457864463329315,
-0.6354550719261169,
0.6720348000526428,
0.6185463666915894,
0.386251837015152,
0.49515366554260254,
0.1307697892189026,
0.09933830052614212,
-0.07326045632362366,
-0.4434852600097656,
-0.49941110610961914,
1.0241131782531738,
0.0907697007060051,
0.6070156097412109,
-0.18154437839984894,
0.2491806447505951,
0.2531605064868927,
-0.10745586454868317,
-0.8248409628868103,
0.5209459066390991,
-0.17038121819496155,
-0.3360651135444641,
-0.5610170960426331,
-0.5187859535217285,
-0.9818621873855591,
0.37857091426849365,
-0.4077272415161133,
-0.3736099898815155,
0.14398208260536194,
-0.011124840006232262,
-0.011817370541393757,
-0.032152626663446426,
-0.6824240684509277,
0.976161777973175,
-0.14189280569553375,
-0.22072350978851318,
0.2456209510564804,
-0.7108520269393921,
0.35190144181251526,
0.06762800365686417,
0.012455655261874199,
0.2605758309364319,
-0.313554048538208,
0.5193324089050293,
-0.33682921528816223,
0.26886969804763794,
-0.2106931209564209,
-0.12458281219005585,
0.6254568099975586,
-0.2586352825164795,
0.06811670958995819,
0.35895466804504395,
0.06404387205839157,
-0.00394722493365407,
0.3437892198562622,
-0.8132383227348328,
-0.5601855516433716,
0.34090456366539,
-0.802944004535675,
-0.2694668173789978,
-0.3746686279773712,
-0.21899116039276123,
0.12835344672203064,
0.4755306541919708,
0.4354322850704193,
0.5873991847038269,
-0.25729700922966003,
0.4168594479560852,
1.1905736923217773,
-0.5700573921203613,
-0.016813334077596664,
0.12314949929714203,
-0.3125559091567993,
-0.6001373529434204,
0.9749143719673157,
0.07596306502819061,
0.11136200278997421,
0.6536245346069336,
-0.017758090049028397,
-0.31522995233535767,
-0.3704516291618347,
-0.6031389236450195,
0.22247852385044098,
-0.9211734533309937,
-0.02443939447402954,
-0.6916110515594482,
-0.34917399287223816,
0.10648152232170105,
0.15560585260391235,
-0.03678939491510391,
-0.20922642946243286,
-0.21238739788532257,
0.03506888076663017,
0.43996626138687134,
0.7374902963638306,
0.6329595446586609,
0.26873064041137695,
-0.833903431892395,
0.9119114875793457,
0.7050334811210632,
0.19774779677391052,
-0.3774073123931885,
-0.5820949673652649,
-0.26364830136299133,
0.10499584674835205,
0.07683011144399643,
-0.6972700357437134,
0.24186597764492035,
0.22772496938705444,
0.027578555047512054,
0.10407185554504395,
0.14380519092082977,
0.6510671377182007,
-0.2854855954647064,
0.6806861162185669,
-0.24904152750968933,
-0.8397580981254578,
0.4510979652404785,
-0.5053920745849609,
0.9882976412773132,
0.7162362337112427,
0.27341920137405396,
-0.6776963472366333,
-0.14492082595825195,
-0.20154666900634766,
-0.944848358631134,
0.389638215303421,
0.5235345363616943,
0.1802109181880951,
0.5042245388031006,
0.6454777121543884,
0.01330779492855072,
0.3207210898399353,
-0.5042583346366882,
-0.17080330848693848,
-0.3571012616157532,
-0.34430888295173645,
-0.11720874160528183,
-0.1987752765417099,
0.195417582988739,
-0.4133755564689636,
0.26162922382354736,
-0.3178933262825012,
0.37645643949508667,
0.6748934984207153,
-0.5336542725563049,
0.1544981300830841,
-0.2644044756889343,
0.344586580991745,
0.6683439612388611,
0.07254850119352341,
0.07263469696044922,
-0.023215413093566895,
-0.9831811785697937,
-0.0024413205683231354,
-0.09950227290391922,
-0.2284989058971405,
0.11980106681585312,
0.558074414730072,
0.7263045310974121,
-0.4396419823169708,
-1.1499844789505005,
0.7379851937294006,
-0.948608934879303,
-0.37200480699539185,
-0.40326422452926636,
-0.033731117844581604,
-0.07389023154973984,
0.42830973863601685,
0.5182206034660339,
-0.2518129348754883,
0.27102479338645935,
-0.28380152583122253,
0.2999803125858307,
0.11918549239635468,
-0.8008705973625183,
0.23479604721069336,
0.4525872766971588,
0.05468996614217758,
0.012274645268917084,
1.0027059316635132,
0.3435847759246826,
-0.5136774778366089,
1.0248517990112305,
-0.04075133800506592,
0.5776945948600769,
0.13991422951221466,
0.6219630837440491,
0.5221319794654846,
0.6288238763809204,
0.21944020688533783,
0.9086208343505859,
0.07736644148826599,
-0.26986587047576904,
-0.3490491211414337,
-0.43941253423690796,
-0.3980238437652588,
0.1583976149559021,
-0.7165572643280029,
0.21654199063777924,
-0.10311277955770493,
0.0197638887912035,
-0.12421759963035583,
-0.17588631808757782,
-0.9022045135498047,
0.6195839047431946,
0.24997949600219727,
1.0760070085525513,
-0.7277041673660278,
0.5574904084205627,
0.8725951910018921,
-0.2834327220916748,
-0.30259981751441956,
0.19751958549022675,
-0.1262635439634323,
-0.9065540432929993,
0.23767907917499542,
0.506821870803833,
0.15906953811645508,
0.0820290818810463,
-0.9951760768890381,
-0.7392429113388062,
0.9713836908340454,
0.23077356815338135,
-0.3144518733024597,
0.15166719257831573,
0.276732474565506,
0.6703251600265503,
-0.19319331645965576,
0.4275534749031067,
0.5560488104820251,
0.5534235239028931,
0.2073327600955963,
-0.5500492453575134,
0.02684685029089451,
-0.6211386919021606,
0.12841731309890747,
0.016902662813663483,
-0.5154648423194885,
0.707806408405304,
-0.20253607630729675,
-0.07255574315786362,
0.530981719493866,
0.7211204767227173,
0.15834175050258636,
0.36814799904823303,
0.5563925504684448,
0.17861409485340118,
0.7329273819923401,
-0.18392977118492126,
0.9319943785667419,
0.30740225315093994,
0.09340201318264008,
0.9574893712997437,
0.3432948887348175,
0.889889121055603,
0.48444992303848267,
0.21159309148788452,
0.208094522356987,
0.7549166083335876,
-0.04050009325146675,
0.34158921241760254,
0.19121497869491577,
0.012610886245965958,
-0.4264781177043915,
-0.2520863711833954,
-0.16153226792812347,
0.6338502764701843,
0.3365596532821655,
-0.2715558111667633,
0.15348933637142181,
0.280143678188324,
-0.4076349139213562,
0.15693511068820953,
-0.40393951535224915,
0.8039665818214417,
0.019495084881782532,
-0.6174727082252502,
0.7689477205276489,
-0.35215049982070923,
0.15754744410514832,
-0.2958000898361206,
-0.29914751648902893,
-0.13391129672527313,
-0.07404990494251251,
0.07694739103317261,
-1.1417587995529175,
-0.17062623798847198,
0.07456300407648087,
-0.13225823640823364,
0.08078134804964066,
0.46652114391326904,
-0.5282014608383179,
-0.5868676900863647,
-0.03801930323243141,
0.5648526549339294,
-0.033904191106557846,
-0.33894333243370056,
-0.6778370141983032,
0.030108200386166573,
-0.09965074807405472,
-0.2920072376728058,
-0.16115625202655792,
0.9442166686058044,
-0.3000293970108032,
0.4880257844924927,
0.1836383193731308,
-0.4356532394886017,
-0.0033405304420739412,
-0.22666813433170319,
0.8957768082618713,
-0.6838739514350891,
-0.5095285773277283,
-0.5817543268203735,
0.8161644339561462,
-0.16659140586853027,
-0.6899054646492004,
0.5705690979957581,
0.42918649315834045,
0.6807059645652771,
-0.1410500854253769,
1.0016629695892334,
0.23646120727062225,
0.04644784331321716,
-0.5922927856445312,
0.6905511617660522,
-0.9783802032470703,
-0.29786625504493713,
-0.5286006331443787,
-0.8760873079299927,
-0.33658602833747864,
0.34208375215530396,
-0.10565251857042313,
-0.25006940960884094,
0.5856943130493164,
0.6346311569213867,
0.11270228773355484,
-0.020371342077851295,
0.34065285325050354,
0.37500715255737305,
0.11484036594629288,
0.519156813621521,
0.9846487641334534,
-0.6616193056106567,
0.8855822682380676,
0.06214037537574768,
-0.32690683007240295,
-0.22849300503730774,
-0.48561418056488037,
-1.01320481300354,
-1.1058725118637085,
-0.08440632373094559,
-0.4138490855693817,
0.15346792340278625,
0.3630062937736511,
0.29875797033309937,
-0.46851885318756104,
0.060568347573280334,
0.10005524009466171,
0.1387873739004135,
-0.06882277876138687,
-0.15714029967784882,
0.628579318523407,
0.31201034784317017,
-0.7853748202323914,
-0.22299526631832123,
0.3522815704345703,
0.08247212320566177,
-0.10027783364057541,
0.13705983757972717,
-0.2311045080423355,
0.30013424158096313,
0.7089948654174805,
0.2134813666343689,
-0.36136549711227417,
-0.006082172505557537,
0.4638793170452118,
-0.36563387513160706,
0.3070465326309204,
0.5600331425666809,
-0.982315182685852,
1.0825014114379883,
0.977982223033905,
0.8465736508369446,
0.5384243726730347,
0.21788421273231506,
0.5294341444969177,
-0.3005274832248688,
0.0950254574418068,
0.12619982659816742,
0.26082223653793335,
0.26221024990081787,
-0.2728341221809387,
0.3891281485557556,
0.0053771184757351875,
-0.5428988933563232,
-0.6727194786071777,
0.1095520481467247,
-1.0954302549362183,
-0.4380069375038147,
1.1167311668395996,
-0.01969733089208603,
-0.8137101531028748,
-0.25760266184806824,
-1.0270836353302002,
0.20608051121234894,
-0.311740905046463,
0.5520092844963074,
0.5058991312980652,
0.40112385153770447,
-0.4737990200519562,
-0.652716875076294,
0.21118278801441193,
0.21800461411476135,
-0.912137508392334,
-0.09891366213560104,
0.6048214435577393,
-0.19842898845672607,
-0.20332227647304535,
0.5438991189002991,
0.10586132854223251,
0.6917771697044373,
-0.14510484039783478,
-0.25474292039871216,
0.12352602183818817,
-0.43591105937957764,
-0.5647611618041992,
0.11048372834920883,
-0.22527934610843658,
-0.34267958998680115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10642v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10642v2
|
Self-playing Adversarial Language Game Enhances LLM Reasoning
| 2024-04-16T15:16:22 | 2024-05-23T06:38:15 |
Pengyu Cheng, Tianhao Hu, Han Xu, Zhisong Zhang, Yong Dai, Lei Han, Nan Du
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We explore the self-play training procedure of large language models (LLMs)
in a two-player adversarial language game called Adversarial Taboo. In this
game, an attacker and a defender communicate around a target word only visible
to the attacker. The attacker aims to induce the defender to speak the target
word unconsciously, while the defender tries to infer the target word from the
attacker's utterances. To win the game, both players should have sufficient
knowledge about the target word and high-level reasoning ability to infer and
express in this information-reserved conversation. Hence, we are curious about
whether LLMs' reasoning ability can be further enhanced by self-play in this
adversarial language game (SPAG). With this goal, we select several open-source
LLMs and let each act as the attacker and play with a copy of itself as the
defender on an extensive range of target words. Through reinforcement learning
on the game outcomes, we observe that the LLMs' performances uniformly improve
on a broad range of reasoning benchmarks. Furthermore, iteratively adopting
this self-play process can continuously promote LLMs' reasoning abilities. The
code is at https://github.com/Linear95/SPAG.
|
[
-0.15987469255924225,
-0.9359590411186218,
0.5560755729675293,
0.4378262758255005,
-0.17045406997203827,
-0.04669318348169327,
-0.24111606180667877,
-0.30266398191452026,
0.055597398430109024,
0.9633685946464539,
-0.4149029552936554,
-0.5687124133110046,
-0.6128215789794922,
0.020713604986667633,
-0.3102782070636749,
0.8927043080329895,
0.1318078637123108,
0.1685054451227188,
-0.2663435935974121,
-0.10799597948789597,
-0.3008262515068054,
-0.5514309406280518,
-0.809172511100769,
-0.612327516078949,
0.3086357116699219,
0.23052899539470673,
0.6346940398216248,
0.9846756458282471,
0.25282514095306396,
0.3767315149307251,
0.03969166800379753,
0.1254388839006424,
-0.7584401965141296,
0.6451181769371033,
-0.3417978882789612,
-0.615763247013092,
-0.03755749389529228,
0.019488345831632614,
0.5472161769866943,
0.030172742903232574,
-0.11499446630477905,
-0.004814764019101858,
0.09666645526885986,
0.5790197849273682,
-0.48729369044303894,
-0.10333623737096786,
-0.796614944934845,
0.22322654724121094,
-0.17424286901950836,
-0.29599180817604065,
-0.4501867890357971,
0.009371386840939522,
-0.14939168095588684,
-0.7391265034675598,
-0.06532458961009979,
-0.2656387388706207,
0.5032209753990173,
0.6323800086975098,
-0.26384034752845764,
-0.3128156363964081,
-0.6716731786727905,
0.20008277893066406,
-0.6150611042976379,
0.08158104866743088,
0.43405699729919434,
0.0729149803519249,
-0.5019350647926331,
-0.2955375611782074,
-0.2505521774291992,
-0.5480824708938599,
0.16850751638412476,
0.2733754813671112,
-0.4714347720146179,
0.1364077478647232,
0.3835428059101105,
0.09166654944419861,
-0.5722849369049072,
0.21349404752254486,
-0.08441238850355148,
-0.17926396429538727,
0.6718476414680481,
-0.09010181576013565,
0.03351278230547905,
0.15877586603164673,
-0.6639915108680725,
0.19329805672168732,
-0.8957434892654419,
-0.04816311597824097,
0.6097074151039124,
-0.07571125775575638,
0.11476989090442657,
0.5303896069526672,
0.013885109685361385,
0.48845431208610535,
0.16196799278259277,
0.08615577220916748,
-0.06114965304732323,
0.10710329562425613,
-0.053839582949876785,
0.16300150752067566,
0.9062146544456482,
0.16732504963874817,
0.2625087797641754,
-0.319091796875,
-0.15056197345256805,
0.08675277978181839,
0.4538351595401764,
-0.42597779631614685,
-0.44397833943367004,
-0.035527318716049194,
-0.205674946308136,
-0.408239483833313,
-0.4191010594367981,
-0.4401513636112213,
-0.8064322471618652,
0.1453123539686203,
0.5739877820014954,
-0.6655879020690918,
-0.18634097278118134,
0.21199022233486176,
-0.2132667452096939,
0.2534850537776947,
0.2645336389541626,
-0.6537207961082458,
0.4243588447570801,
0.6125312447547913,
0.5669268369674683,
-0.19946721196174622,
-0.34263747930526733,
-0.5717211961746216,
0.3034954071044922,
-0.6014117002487183,
0.7949905395507812,
-0.22874152660369873,
-0.5755801796913147,
-0.13323111832141876,
-0.41068875789642334,
0.1542597860097885,
-0.5212759375572205,
0.5378425717353821,
-0.6554470062255859,
0.161905437707901,
-0.04425433650612831,
-0.6508448719978333,
-0.009820881299674511,
0.6763038039207458,
-0.39424192905426025,
0.9427613615989685,
-0.22784335911273956,
-0.4618040919303894,
0.04381004348397255,
-0.6019795536994934,
-0.6604350209236145,
0.3043704330921173,
-0.3301626443862915,
-0.37666377425193787,
0.060956697911024094,
0.21925196051597595,
0.3087274730205536,
-0.14972750842571259,
-0.13486480712890625,
-0.5843850374221802,
-0.32010596990585327,
0.5781034231185913,
-0.45017507672309875,
0.537080705165863,
0.23313471674919128,
-0.47413170337677,
0.08936818689107895,
-0.33015257120132446,
-0.0008381725638173521,
0.5207371115684509,
-0.239863783121109,
-0.23496149480342865,
0.20557501912117004,
-0.6786677837371826,
0.23184165358543396,
0.2494373917579651,
-0.28181374073028564,
0.2639748454093933,
-0.5680704712867737,
0.24474367499351501,
0.8169758915901184,
0.12638139724731445,
0.47365689277648926,
-0.3423900902271271,
0.5148218274116516,
-0.21426498889923096,
0.3257627487182617,
-0.04357779026031494,
-0.4342010021209717,
-0.7161675095558167,
-0.22945813834667206,
0.1597076952457428,
0.6078423857688904,
-0.8331411480903625,
0.2660093605518341,
0.1648130863904953,
-0.3247079849243164,
-0.4779292941093445,
0.2618659436702728,
0.49926790595054626,
0.2991400361061096,
0.3401642441749573,
-0.08340786397457123,
-0.3740917146205902,
-0.6609998941421509,
-0.41750091314315796,
-0.3690459728240967,
0.25884220004081726,
0.6505752205848694,
0.3397604525089264,
-0.160535529255867,
0.5778801441192627,
-0.3313796818256378,
-0.4482632577419281,
-0.2955634891986847,
-0.031152330338954926,
-0.08449161797761917,
0.268984317779541,
0.5876860618591309,
-0.32748517394065857,
-0.26271235942840576,
-0.2599710524082184,
-0.8611122965812683,
-0.2911999821662903,
-0.1997838169336319,
-0.24410824477672577,
0.12268137186765671,
0.580226719379425,
-0.49933645129203796,
0.18050454556941986,
0.5872889757156372,
-0.465933620929718,
0.6342465877532959,
-0.38305604457855225,
0.1171179860830307,
-0.7618431448936462,
-0.2642509639263153,
-0.11592857539653778,
-0.28222039341926575,
-0.6106091141700745,
0.3410053551197052,
-0.1418607383966446,
0.09559746831655502,
-0.38248661160469055,
0.6191074252128601,
-0.5457628965377808,
-0.1400737166404724,
-0.6397961378097534,
0.4018614888191223,
-0.10134879499673843,
0.3794999420642853,
-0.021611124277114868,
0.8610242605209351,
0.8410064578056335,
-0.7457039952278137,
0.502409815788269,
-0.024699468165636063,
-0.1767057329416275,
0.2626463770866394,
-0.521955132484436,
0.23812012374401093,
0.20847775042057037,
0.10618656873703003,
-0.8343209028244019,
0.09183898568153381,
0.49904513359069824,
-0.7800093293190002,
0.35125941038131714,
-0.3494661748409271,
-0.42624011635780334,
-0.26182255148887634,
-0.03567378595471382,
0.12905627489089966,
0.42194488644599915,
-0.6172184348106384,
0.4642673134803772,
0.6273038983345032,
0.09951229393482208,
-0.7712826728820801,
-0.6524332761764526,
0.3573495149612427,
-0.41057756543159485,
-0.43489813804626465,
0.2127404510974884,
-0.15601956844329834,
-0.24773132801055908,
-0.007053215056657791,
-0.11867044866085052,
0.11907833069562912,
0.526940107345581,
0.141902357339859,
0.04031014442443848,
-0.14859983325004578,
0.2924228608608246,
-0.2384590357542038,
-0.05746592953801155,
0.60221266746521,
-0.6332226395606995,
0.48734840750694275,
-0.25687769055366516,
-0.577672004699707,
0.040733449161052704,
0.21025653183460236,
0.05950940400362015,
-0.08950479328632355,
0.5471230149269104,
0.33369699120521545,
-0.1559610664844513,
-0.4503536522388458,
-0.680108904838562,
-0.1474650502204895,
-0.48905572295188904,
0.33362680673599243,
-0.5422948598861694,
-1.0969558954238892,
0.4706422984600067,
-0.27191612124443054,
-0.27524998784065247,
0.4133283197879791,
0.5911073684692383,
-0.2119452804327011,
1.0380223989486694,
0.23612943291664124,
-0.1956266611814499,
0.1337369680404663,
-0.2751739025115967,
-0.4404680132865906,
-0.5785920023918152,
-0.1826501339673996,
-0.24590922892093658,
-0.10195024311542511,
-0.38192200660705566,
-0.6468794345855713,
0.27162206172943115,
0.15187707543373108,
-0.2914912700653076,
0.21473996341228485,
-0.4267108738422394,
0.7464442849159241,
0.4892728626728058,
0.3567335903644562,
0.13247492909431458,
-0.11630956083536148,
-0.3383151590824127,
0.027279818430542946,
-0.8403533101081848,
-0.2683706283569336,
1.0615390539169312,
0.5263456702232361,
0.8873704075813293,
0.3977831304073334,
1.0524721145629883,
0.4826681911945343,
0.1608285903930664,
-0.6522160768508911,
0.7354868650436401,
-0.05057748034596443,
-0.5387198328971863,
-0.36603328585624695,
-0.6906130909919739,
-0.9753801822662354,
0.12938043475151062,
-0.3024458587169647,
-0.6578612327575684,
-0.3349481523036957,
0.2127346247434616,
-0.355802446603775,
0.2754051387310028,
-0.29498833417892456,
0.811654806137085,
-0.7749963998794556,
-0.6125660538673401,
-0.5138532519340515,
-0.4347759485244751,
0.517558753490448,
0.21586544811725616,
0.12366200983524323,
0.023647863417863846,
-0.11070166528224945,
0.620713472366333,
0.006053104531019926,
0.8039798140525818,
-0.003087463555857539,
-0.201349675655365,
0.4045298397541046,
0.5025528073310852,
0.41530275344848633,
0.2149001806974411,
0.09984026104211807,
0.2307233065366745,
-0.4829375743865967,
-0.3173234164714813,
-0.6620491147041321,
0.8772704005241394,
-0.8897320032119751,
-1.3495978116989136,
-0.7249692678451538,
-0.41947832703590393,
-0.1877254992723465,
0.17290018498897552,
0.10523593425750732,
0.08350886404514313,
-0.6824902296066284,
0.18283048272132874,
1.123245358467102,
-0.1127375066280365,
0.0907508060336113,
0.625416100025177,
-0.17494353652000427,
-0.45793867111206055,
0.6705178022384644,
-0.10540074110031128,
0.32549405097961426,
0.4398990571498871,
0.5010486245155334,
-0.5663594603538513,
-0.5826336741447449,
-0.4759266674518585,
0.25468114018440247,
-0.7950242757797241,
-0.2306799739599228,
-0.5829537510871887,
-0.3378223776817322,
-0.4263075888156891,
0.10258382558822632,
-0.2413712590932846,
-0.3769600987434387,
-0.2532922327518463,
0.05860885605216026,
0.3036271333694458,
0.9680929183959961,
-0.39853817224502563,
0.27537715435028076,
-0.5231993794441223,
0.1741955578327179,
0.38008353114128113,
0.20559264719486237,
-0.46316781640052795,
-0.8229356408119202,
-0.204584002494812,
-0.028024617582559586,
-0.31740495562553406,
-1.284703254699707,
0.20838777720928192,
-0.11671265959739685,
0.9599006772041321,
0.4753377437591553,
0.016447145491838455,
0.4321191608905792,
-0.47770974040031433,
0.597044825553894,
0.1531672179698944,
-0.7526642084121704,
0.47868868708610535,
-0.45241373777389526,
0.3165249526500702,
0.25448358058929443,
0.08088330924510956,
-0.3224048316478729,
-0.5325827598571777,
-0.7640290856361389,
-0.39135879278182983,
0.741347074508667,
0.19352853298187256,
-0.0015250361757352948,
-0.20736099779605865,
0.3818511366844177,
-0.1703743189573288,
-0.07691056281328201,
-0.9225137829780579,
-0.4975113272666931,
-0.24316059052944183,
0.08466578274965286,
-0.21066342294216156,
-0.27055972814559937,
-0.6334165930747986,
0.20278412103652954,
0.80339115858078,
-0.2252838909626007,
0.27329161763191223,
0.07179354876279831,
-0.21908976137638092,
-0.009177309460937977,
0.23498506844043732,
0.529356837272644,
-0.07107663154602051,
0.3153376281261444,
0.45460689067840576,
0.45320841670036316,
-0.22701971232891083,
0.27816084027290344,
0.30961039662361145,
-0.2129063904285431,
-0.4844202697277069,
0.2711179554462433,
0.7115104794502258,
0.23820124566555023,
-0.5435184836387634,
0.5845255851745605,
-0.15339189767837524,
-0.4537144899368286,
-0.31848350167274475,
0.4002959728240967,
0.09324827790260315,
0.622806966304779,
0.05295238643884659,
0.1722833812236786,
0.17927132546901703,
-0.34303542971611023,
0.3126887381076813,
0.7422459721565247,
-0.3034646809101105,
0.1354900598526001,
0.6664134860038757,
0.08532644063234329,
-0.4773196280002594,
0.14644010365009308,
-0.44254159927368164,
-0.9621592164039612,
0.48162275552749634,
0.8647089004516602,
0.8533377647399902,
-0.18026186525821686,
0.27460289001464844,
0.14588549733161926,
0.5252248048782349,
-0.09238287061452866,
0.03565894439816475,
-0.3001236021518707,
-0.8352006673812866,
-0.45011448860168457,
-0.08332739025354385,
-0.35276198387145996,
0.2851809561252594,
-0.15001536905765533,
-0.08774009346961975,
-0.5034187436103821,
-0.10947471112012863,
-0.5067360997200012,
0.17792314291000366,
-0.3860644996166229,
-0.11650410294532776,
0.5933080911636353,
0.8536556959152222,
-0.5158352255821228,
0.744282603263855,
0.5491439700126648,
-0.27286338806152344,
-0.48252198100090027,
0.08099564909934998,
0.042382702231407166,
-0.9242458343505859,
0.5806971788406372,
-0.10802122950553894,
-0.3813237249851227,
-0.0026909811422228813,
-0.5479620695114136,
-0.9687346816062927,
0.9072327613830566,
0.42625367641448975,
-0.2742515206336975,
0.21489550173282623,
0.2472953051328659,
0.5764710307121277,
-0.37849605083465576,
0.24206548929214478,
0.39803749322891235,
0.19813303649425507,
0.28827568888664246,
-0.3703334331512451,
-0.027196770533919334,
-0.10749226063489914,
-0.37620046734809875,
-0.011754351668059826,
-0.6481271386146545,
0.44373300671577454,
-0.37529149651527405,
-0.1925925761461258,
-0.00743516068905592,
1.055655598640442,
0.5299150347709656,
0.11048806458711624,
0.6219967007637024,
0.7540743947029114,
0.5478110313415527,
-0.10290055721998215,
0.7302355766296387,
-0.3865940570831299,
-0.05418955907225609,
1.1540826559066772,
-0.34282660484313965,
0.5421409606933594,
0.040427930653095245,
0.15260626375675201,
0.3077765107154846,
0.38184860348701477,
-0.03429541364312172,
0.34701040387153625,
0.3966926634311676,
-0.34774792194366455,
-0.6109825372695923,
0.1731727570295334,
-0.2600111663341522,
0.6118624806404114,
0.6159555315971375,
-0.22970807552337646,
-0.26163920760154724,
-0.0929160863161087,
0.12566520273685455,
0.4413246810436249,
-0.2943856120109558,
1.0220574140548706,
-0.010120232589542866,
-0.7693616151809692,
0.39863377809524536,
-0.01179357711225748,
0.5278462171554565,
-0.788299024105072,
0.08768249303102493,
-0.14160571992397308,
0.4857884645462036,
0.16066710650920868,
-0.9712739586830139,
-0.0349610298871994,
0.04979900270700455,
0.22825303673744202,
-0.22572387754917145,
1.0661982297897339,
-0.5184150338172913,
-0.05241997167468071,
0.663189172744751,
0.5690011382102966,
0.21971377730369568,
-0.11196952313184738,
-1.1806379556655884,
-0.19752824306488037,
-0.19550353288650513,
-0.24991053342819214,
0.5462743043899536,
0.5689066052436829,
0.22391271591186523,
0.8934537172317505,
0.6204240322113037,
0.33620747923851013,
0.09824911504983902,
0.16213054955005646,
0.8925566077232361,
-0.3939732015132904,
-0.4647291898727417,
-1.077094316482544,
0.02683267742395401,
-0.3249042332172394,
-0.26197224855422974,
0.9396729469299316,
0.7614280581474304,
0.7096059322357178,
0.13632111251354218,
0.8413562178611755,
0.3442789316177368,
0.23319324851036072,
-0.5331401824951172,
0.67349773645401,
-0.34937113523483276,
0.27003857493400574,
-0.02494785189628601,
-0.3712722361087799,
-0.14370015263557434,
0.7195885181427002,
-0.37695297598838806,
-0.17573131620883942,
0.41147443652153015,
0.817777156829834,
0.31081610918045044,
-0.2101401686668396,
0.6960098147392273,
0.28719213604927063,
0.27296650409698486,
0.6863765716552734,
1.173540711402893,
-0.2510606646537781,
0.8661025762557983,
-0.16738606989383698,
-0.4673480689525604,
-0.036662280559539795,
-0.7856738567352295,
-1.2136286497116089,
-0.20825842022895813,
-0.23052868247032166,
-0.7815309762954712,
0.44150686264038086,
0.9239617586135864,
0.38315072655677795,
-0.2907223701477051,
-0.403577595949173,
-0.109580397605896,
0.2449331432580948,
-0.3820875287055969,
-0.20910486578941345,
-0.06376345455646515,
-0.4623073935508728,
-0.2354569286108017,
0.9147464036941528,
0.2689613103866577,
-0.07676195353269577,
-0.4772118628025055,
-0.3353225886821747,
-0.3458516299724579,
0.34197667241096497,
0.36684638261795044,
0.5203763842582703,
-0.5974751710891724,
-0.1589333564043045,
0.27324697375297546,
-0.287227064371109,
-0.12009048461914062,
0.7202515602111816,
-0.7695494294166565,
0.47013378143310547,
0.20421677827835083,
0.775759756565094,
0.5821557641029358,
-0.05484038591384888,
0.5850932598114014,
-0.5431329607963562,
-0.05262516811490059,
0.3107016980648041,
0.40034550428390503,
0.23253852128982544,
-0.5421037077903748,
0.46985113620758057,
0.38141584396362305,
-0.7388187050819397,
-0.492743581533432,
0.45397913455963135,
-0.45817095041275024,
-0.5590459108352661,
1.5457613468170166,
-0.25648829340934753,
-0.20961053669452667,
-0.02945726551115513,
-0.16770444810390472,
0.40419650077819824,
-0.38141483068466187,
0.8627757430076599,
0.573132336139679,
-0.1191222295165062,
-0.247370183467865,
-0.051708053797483444,
0.7796207666397095,
0.40585458278656006,
-0.6221400499343872,
0.13244976103305817,
0.41835224628448486,
0.1992393285036087,
0.12016303092241287,
0.7324334979057312,
0.05717983841896057,
0.4889504313468933,
0.0737529993057251,
-0.02326354943215847,
-0.2868695557117462,
-0.4099743664264679,
-0.4632778763771057,
0.03919031843543053,
0.08983978629112244,
-0.123409204185009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10630v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10630v1
|
HLAT: High-quality Large Language Model Pre-trained on AWS Trainium
| 2024-04-16T15:02:46 | 2024-04-16T15:02:46 |
Haozheng Fan, Hao Zhou, Guangtai Huang, Parameswaran Raman, Xinwei Fu, Gaurav Gupta, Dhananjay Ram, Yida Wang, Jun Huan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Getting large language models (LLMs) to perform well on the downstream tasks
requires pre-training over trillions of tokens. This typically demands a large
number of powerful computational devices in addition to a stable distributed
training framework to accelerate the training. The growing number of
applications leveraging AI/ML had led to a scarcity of the expensive
conventional accelerators (such as GPUs), which begs the need for the
alternative specialized-accelerators that are scalable and cost-efficient. AWS
Trainium is the second-generation machine learning accelerator that has been
purposely built for training large deep learning models. Its corresponding
instance, Amazon EC2 trn1, is an alternative to GPU instances for LLM training.
However, training LLMs with billions of parameters on trn1 is challenging due
to its relatively nascent software ecosystem. In this paper, we showcase HLAT:
a 7 billion parameter decoder-only LLM pre-trained using trn1 instances over
1.8 trillion tokens. The performance of HLAT is benchmarked against popular
open source baseline models including LLaMA and OpenLLaMA, which have been
trained on NVIDIA GPUs and Google TPUs, respectively. On various evaluation
tasks, we show that HLAT achieves model quality on par with the baselines. We
also share the best practice of using the Neuron Distributed Training Library
(NDTL), a customized distributed training library for AWS Trainium to achieve
efficient training. Our work demonstrates that AWS Trainium powered by the NDTL
is able to successfully pre-train state-of-the-art LLM models with high
performance and cost-effectiveness.
|
[
-0.3266054391860962,
-0.5275666117668152,
0.2922084629535675,
0.2588919997215271,
-0.3584919571876526,
0.3898797035217285,
-0.15042833983898163,
-0.32207635045051575,
-0.03304405137896538,
0.39346811175346375,
-0.2498789280653,
-0.5983722805976868,
-0.5144986510276794,
-0.12156300246715546,
-0.5059084296226501,
0.834270179271698,
0.13077649474143982,
0.03144710510969162,
-0.03823550418019295,
-0.04866756871342659,
0.19357997179031372,
-0.6451178193092346,
-0.8439490795135498,
-0.4350135326385498,
0.6056008338928223,
0.3353421092033386,
0.681163489818573,
0.8741501569747925,
0.7043781876564026,
0.19863122701644897,
-0.1060902401804924,
-0.047145191580057144,
-0.4160321056842804,
-0.16201657056808472,
0.1350075900554657,
-0.3627120554447174,
-0.9074525833129883,
-0.203822523355484,
0.6090684533119202,
0.3832351565361023,
-0.3207777142524719,
0.36858341097831726,
0.02684626914560795,
0.516907274723053,
-0.5476862788200378,
-0.23554359376430511,
-0.600691556930542,
0.14075419306755066,
-0.5034118890762329,
-0.04082898795604706,
-0.6165837049484253,
-0.21302422881126404,
0.08846161514520645,
-0.5670725107192993,
0.12225623428821564,
0.22108568251132965,
1.1347525119781494,
0.5004714131355286,
-0.3044358491897583,
0.08125550299882889,
-0.8262645602226257,
0.7316619157791138,
-0.9515268802642822,
0.5501198172569275,
0.23068884015083313,
0.5221771597862244,
-0.16265444457530975,
-0.7419523596763611,
-0.2669794261455536,
-0.38548317551612854,
-0.022184811532497406,
0.04601435363292694,
-0.09424897283315659,
-0.06205779314041138,
0.3760847747325897,
0.18174315989017487,
-0.8389389514923096,
0.6322610378265381,
-0.07522861659526825,
-0.26556336879730225,
0.1791895031929016,
0.08014705777168274,
-0.0916750356554985,
0.03477306291460991,
-0.30020520091056824,
-0.23902031779289246,
-1.075941801071167,
-0.3053252100944519,
0.5411638617515564,
0.17237097024917603,
-0.1978723257780075,
0.012602587230503559,
-0.12405712157487869,
0.6220608949661255,
-0.1842070072889328,
-0.027605772018432617,
0.25135883688926697,
0.03930104523897171,
-0.3241458535194397,
0.12762479484081268,
0.8256602883338928,
-0.43818336725234985,
-0.04973796755075455,
-0.2575220465660095,
-0.056908056139945984,
-0.017740871757268906,
0.38560616970062256,
-1.1638582944869995,
-0.12114443629980087,
0.39983969926834106,
-0.27806347608566284,
-0.07586577534675598,
-0.4029645621776581,
-0.9009429216384888,
-0.1738647222518921,
-0.23324459791183472,
0.04984571412205696,
-0.21600580215454102,
-0.42089417576789856,
-0.006329451221972704,
0.10860193520784378,
0.2556503713130951,
0.47215360403060913,
-0.9344654083251953,
0.22176340222358704,
0.7250781059265137,
0.7468485236167908,
-0.043652888387441635,
-0.4611895978450775,
-0.7002030611038208,
0.057866938412189484,
-0.27409639954566956,
0.5848921537399292,
-0.14654143154621124,
0.14351534843444824,
0.16975846886634827,
-0.2447204440832138,
0.29192066192626953,
-0.656511127948761,
0.6745028495788574,
-0.9377319812774658,
-0.21895843744277954,
0.07833070307970047,
-0.4564710855484009,
0.17592106759548187,
0.45583629608154297,
-0.6902289390563965,
1.0550352334976196,
0.24073363840579987,
-0.5420033931732178,
0.3852762281894684,
-0.5818558931350708,
-0.6330744624137878,
0.3271314799785614,
-0.0038704280741512775,
-0.5393984317779541,
-0.10848014801740646,
0.09210284054279327,
0.34614381194114685,
-0.48112890124320984,
0.17150193452835083,
-0.33486419916152954,
-0.3017180263996124,
-0.07135193794965744,
-0.30681777000427246,
0.696149468421936,
0.3690604567527771,
-0.5613571405410767,
0.3633629381656647,
-0.8002015948295593,
0.17069564759731293,
-0.00878370925784111,
-0.4803941547870636,
-0.007575776427984238,
-0.08531764149665833,
0.038811810314655304,
0.2298344522714615,
0.3335007131099701,
-0.45754754543304443,
-0.07743395864963531,
-0.292044073343277,
0.6860220432281494,
0.650908350944519,
-0.6544299125671387,
0.24637390673160553,
0.10700515657663345,
0.5191105604171753,
0.050059761852025986,
0.25716087222099304,
0.04532055929303169,
0.010889282450079918,
-0.9584101438522339,
-0.2148214727640152,
0.4485139846801758,
0.2680363059043884,
-0.5816016793251038,
0.5240328311920166,
-0.395461767911911,
-0.786368191242218,
-0.702631950378418,
0.3619644343852997,
0.2881379723548889,
0.27983802556991577,
0.341568261384964,
0.04750733822584152,
-0.6688956618309021,
-0.7932934761047363,
0.19849105179309845,
-0.024372786283493042,
-0.11398003250360489,
0.151042178273201,
0.6600134372711182,
-0.3204810619354248,
0.7477917075157166,
-0.03848487138748169,
-0.27328240871429443,
-0.4589947462081909,
0.2658716142177582,
0.25530320405960083,
0.46298617124557495,
0.5066223740577698,
-0.3829330503940582,
-0.5963376760482788,
0.29724523425102234,
-0.7778658866882324,
0.19436590373516083,
0.03545258566737175,
-0.5234063267707825,
0.4185253381729126,
0.5731255412101746,
-0.5898431539535522,
0.20923283696174622,
0.9356832504272461,
0.07119923084974289,
0.6377934813499451,
-0.47133907675743103,
-0.1122424378991127,
-1.0303691625595093,
0.3230329751968384,
-0.12820366024971008,
-0.28392088413238525,
-0.39095813035964966,
0.03815155848860741,
0.21199271082878113,
-0.11690013110637665,
-0.8116151690483093,
0.4648932218551636,
-0.42923703789711,
-0.43344223499298096,
-0.5062573552131653,
0.10212727636098862,
-0.0030747177079319954,
0.5317763686180115,
0.07689741998910904,
0.8014199137687683,
0.6761807203292847,
-0.7825652360916138,
0.4667204022407532,
0.2798527479171753,
-0.5634720325469971,
0.1753268837928772,
-0.7771079540252686,
0.22707462310791016,
0.09399017691612244,
0.24110357463359833,
-0.28223705291748047,
-0.12855054438114166,
-0.09434907883405685,
-0.08868244290351868,
0.09194916486740112,
-0.04972974210977554,
-0.8230257630348206,
-0.6403844952583313,
0.2369053214788437,
0.5187515020370483,
0.774163544178009,
-0.9514085054397583,
0.474637895822525,
0.2603534460067749,
0.27362242341041565,
-0.6348071694374084,
-0.5668975114822388,
0.2486071139574051,
-0.2541194558143616,
-0.3762817084789276,
0.41327595710754395,
0.011438841000199318,
0.12374866008758545,
0.05757176876068115,
0.10060948133468628,
-0.13444319367408752,
0.2958834171295166,
0.17672261595726013,
0.17994621396064758,
-0.41580259799957275,
0.07611405104398727,
-0.1765170693397522,
-0.2487858384847641,
-0.07762579619884491,
-0.3552372455596924,
1.0894081592559814,
-0.42450278997421265,
-0.36953964829444885,
-0.7703670263290405,
-0.1009855791926384,
0.624538242816925,
-0.473249226808548,
0.7880262732505798,
0.7378314733505249,
-0.32397928833961487,
-0.41517090797424316,
-0.26835426688194275,
-0.15249906480312347,
-0.4822362959384918,
0.6174261569976807,
-0.28222140669822693,
-0.8114195466041565,
0.4052777588367462,
-0.18695470690727234,
0.16090594232082367,
0.2201526165008545,
0.6759017705917358,
-0.14479641616344452,
0.8810654282569885,
0.500653862953186,
-0.4606044292449951,
0.678601861000061,
-0.26166459918022156,
0.16482166945934296,
-0.825697124004364,
0.1974574476480484,
-0.6748831272125244,
-0.2581164240837097,
-0.41906800866127014,
-0.1925593763589859,
0.26499679684638977,
-0.10065584629774094,
-0.7967691421508789,
0.6093611717224121,
-0.24555905163288116,
0.45516133308410645,
0.9044798016548157,
0.2203652709722519,
0.2780120372772217,
0.1529078334569931,
0.1376963108778,
0.2025061547756195,
-0.9633411765098572,
-0.6811219453811646,
1.1267224550247192,
0.5366851091384888,
0.8998732566833496,
-0.003038177965208888,
0.7002396583557129,
0.21028482913970947,
0.6097943186759949,
-0.5970608592033386,
0.5885624885559082,
-0.22266143560409546,
-0.8428205251693726,
-0.3112921416759491,
-0.49677929282188416,
-1.0703479051589966,
0.23334237933158875,
-0.1873655617237091,
-0.4074302315711975,
-0.37220028042793274,
0.369454950094223,
-0.41561293601989746,
0.45524725317955017,
-0.2343829721212387,
1.0305850505828857,
-0.722381591796875,
-0.6288105249404907,
-0.4543682336807251,
-0.5143304467201233,
0.07498136907815933,
0.07413280010223389,
-0.07395150512456894,
-0.006311096716672182,
0.3688134253025055,
0.7224298119544983,
-0.42409154772758484,
0.5054472088813782,
-0.04875830188393593,
-0.02738984487950802,
0.21779601275920868,
0.04581119865179062,
0.44643041491508484,
-0.19010445475578308,
-0.2886536717414856,
0.3986763656139374,
-0.45603513717651367,
-0.5706061124801636,
-0.49037131667137146,
0.5892301797866821,
-1.015550136566162,
-0.5444546341896057,
-0.3497054874897003,
-0.4192332625389099,
-0.09934449195861816,
0.4205425977706909,
0.12818443775177002,
0.5072906613349915,
-0.22165200114250183,
0.3975355625152588,
0.45832234621047974,
-0.36048367619514465,
0.5144465565681458,
0.2793256938457489,
-0.028660036623477936,
-0.37903741002082825,
0.7263065576553345,
-0.3365330994129181,
0.4366578459739685,
0.31901803612709045,
0.04688139632344246,
-0.2038811594247818,
-0.646630048751831,
-0.8382676243782043,
0.34110206365585327,
-0.5040496587753296,
-0.10582426190376282,
-0.45829087495803833,
-0.41629862785339355,
-0.3411058187484741,
-0.007146554999053478,
-0.7908284664154053,
0.1509653627872467,
-0.3609329164028168,
-0.14369164407253265,
0.054825376719236374,
0.4229148030281067,
0.10856696218252182,
0.9430932998657227,
-0.9167819023132324,
0.11326182633638382,
0.059543486684560776,
0.425457626581192,
0.1639571338891983,
-0.6378214359283447,
-0.671943187713623,
0.0793478935956955,
-0.32584476470947266,
-0.3985185921192169,
0.6273361444473267,
0.05454149469733238,
0.5555838346481323,
0.5729740262031555,
-0.08551973104476929,
0.6530749201774597,
-0.5394294857978821,
0.38538625836372375,
0.049033135175704956,
-0.8968318700790405,
0.4257591962814331,
-0.26569998264312744,
0.22292548418045044,
0.5894348621368408,
0.4469357132911682,
-0.35358816385269165,
-0.30268552899360657,
-0.538092315196991,
-0.5494083166122437,
0.7811095714569092,
0.0022594351321458817,
-0.013496765866875648,
0.4534291923046112,
0.20339158177375793,
0.03372645750641823,
0.43723264336586,
-0.8756809234619141,
-0.10175967216491699,
-0.26755276322364807,
-0.28263527154922485,
-0.20068155229091644,
-0.046544477343559265,
-0.20755188167095184,
-0.2400510162115097,
0.8675768971443176,
-0.037429485470056534,
0.17840391397476196,
-0.2071233093738556,
-0.37564486265182495,
-0.027265314012765884,
0.2375383973121643,
0.44365057349205017,
0.5262782573699951,
-0.34503376483917236,
0.19520628452301025,
-0.14461131393909454,
-0.3158833682537079,
0.1899455487728119,
-0.13102935254573822,
-0.24203835427761078,
-0.01687159389257431,
0.2707147002220154,
1.1853657960891724,
-0.053838327527046204,
-0.8588183522224426,
0.2336166948080063,
0.0511922687292099,
-0.281495064496994,
-0.32362309098243713,
0.02084723860025406,
0.1222098171710968,
0.12059245258569717,
0.14104850590229034,
-0.18005935847759247,
-0.24481135606765747,
-0.512309193611145,
0.14728128910064697,
0.3654356002807617,
-0.08525451272726059,
-0.3309687077999115,
0.6103906035423279,
0.3286094665527344,
-0.3274708390235901,
1.0979036092758179,
-0.3921896517276764,
-0.8708196878433228,
0.7301731705665588,
0.6073399186134338,
0.7148078083992004,
-0.06343846023082733,
0.38127413392066956,
0.5233350396156311,
0.53080815076828,
-0.15238019824028015,
-0.15442822873592377,
-0.019779037684202194,
-0.7156086564064026,
-0.437678724527359,
-0.7670104503631592,
-0.8019263744354248,
0.23359329998493195,
-0.45344436168670654,
0.20845675468444824,
-0.5963699817657471,
-0.1838645339012146,
-0.45284342765808105,
-0.06316893547773361,
-0.8189443945884705,
0.15561847388744354,
0.21524927020072937,
0.8181669116020203,
-0.6264982223510742,
1.1382189989089966,
0.5241510272026062,
-0.09346260875463486,
-0.7520537972450256,
-0.2442471832036972,
-0.5516840815544128,
-0.6477387547492981,
1.0251238346099854,
0.2445002943277359,
0.11415598541498184,
0.23165735602378845,
-0.39462926983833313,
-0.9973655343055725,
0.9359753131866455,
0.6080588102340698,
-0.6279372572898865,
-0.04042946547269821,
0.6283692717552185,
0.7338072657585144,
-0.13376568257808685,
0.49012619256973267,
0.6210432052612305,
0.46451494097709656,
0.09696169942617416,
-0.7418886423110962,
-0.06830281019210815,
-0.0363985039293766,
-0.3996638059616089,
0.2512844502925873,
-0.7516555786132812,
1.0072004795074463,
-0.18936939537525177,
-0.1889468878507614,
-0.10352043807506561,
0.7422134280204773,
0.3621373176574707,
0.1607181280851364,
0.45883581042289734,
0.7755286693572998,
0.7185789942741394,
-0.08646989613771439,
0.7862555384635925,
-0.4467281699180603,
0.2742231488227844,
1.1375638246536255,
-0.5836561918258667,
1.0731775760650635,
0.34719720482826233,
-0.22266562283039093,
0.6958284974098206,
0.7222995758056641,
-0.06137485429644585,
0.36774149537086487,
0.3437230587005615,
-0.17703211307525635,
-0.5142208337783813,
0.03951398283243179,
-0.29377225041389465,
0.3205503821372986,
0.13766397535800934,
-0.06177322193980217,
-0.37347152829170227,
0.04995381087064743,
-0.18180516362190247,
-0.3084813356399536,
-0.21655263006687164,
0.409964382648468,
0.07258586585521698,
-0.47540342807769775,
0.6674742698669434,
-0.18481440842151642,
0.6762767434120178,
-0.5916352868080139,
0.30707746744155884,
-0.3107011318206787,
0.42293283343315125,
-0.1743093580007553,
-0.13964703679084778,
0.07588227093219757,
0.10216070711612701,
0.18701691925525665,
-0.2843691408634186,
0.32428842782974243,
-0.24848370254039764,
-0.4251631200313568,
0.3778339624404907,
0.5756784081459045,
0.16213564574718475,
-0.08877544105052948,
-0.4891672432422638,
0.17584429681301117,
-0.47136181592941284,
-0.3116442859172821,
0.4825056195259094,
0.1762111783027649,
0.2656092643737793,
0.9971985220909119,
0.6444242000579834,
0.23960226774215698,
0.283364862203598,
0.16662514209747314,
0.5922596454620361,
-0.5826653838157654,
-0.5734976530075073,
-0.7513654828071594,
0.24657535552978516,
-0.09568287432193756,
-0.26416078209877014,
0.7836555242538452,
0.7116845846176147,
0.9448689222335815,
-0.02178201824426651,
0.7061177492141724,
0.08819787204265594,
0.3059242367744446,
-0.33785244822502136,
0.7128223776817322,
-0.7501790523529053,
0.044072240591049194,
0.06910789757966995,
-0.847501277923584,
-0.2960132956504822,
0.57353675365448,
-0.10254120826721191,
-0.05008254945278168,
0.9088677167892456,
0.7287454605102539,
0.04134954512119293,
-0.10742092877626419,
0.34359413385391235,
0.23684293031692505,
0.6500924825668335,
0.7349280714988708,
0.8632451891899109,
-0.48570144176483154,
0.6386424899101257,
-0.23955920338630676,
-0.03445673733949661,
-0.4325839579105377,
-0.8986642956733704,
-0.8169971108436584,
-0.12854057550430298,
-0.36111101508140564,
-0.24965159595012665,
-0.019833644852042198,
0.8725280165672302,
1.0989580154418945,
-0.6515207290649414,
-0.5332025289535522,
-0.3651677370071411,
0.07161667197942734,
-0.23187090456485748,
-0.1334880143404007,
0.49396228790283203,
-0.33246272802352905,
-0.9372215270996094,
0.25986337661743164,
0.01576557382941246,
0.12164366245269775,
-0.5128516554832458,
-0.2867116332054138,
0.09978154301643372,
-0.3990086615085602,
0.5483009815216064,
0.2810373306274414,
-0.3329170346260071,
-0.040570344775915146,
0.07665172964334488,
-0.5179057717323303,
0.3033759593963623,
0.5603228807449341,
-0.7157317996025085,
-0.2301255166530609,
0.3280903995037079,
1.0815675258636475,
0.712062418460846,
-0.056416600942611694,
0.2856918275356293,
-0.27393320202827454,
0.35189372301101685,
0.3486596643924713,
0.37045177817344666,
0.24060174822807312,
-0.025285029783844948,
0.30420348048210144,
-0.09998757392168045,
-0.73744136095047,
-0.9281724095344543,
0.2070128470659256,
-1.0843435525894165,
-0.01798105239868164,
1.1527262926101685,
-0.20404760539531708,
-0.5071485638618469,
0.23476511240005493,
0.00580032030120492,
0.3505098521709442,
-0.2784777581691742,
0.7438911199569702,
0.5117549896240234,
0.08972910791635513,
-0.06702453643083572,
-0.6045665740966797,
0.3357059359550476,
0.7762191891670227,
-1.2849864959716797,
0.06957584619522095,
0.4077857434749603,
-0.031100010499358177,
-0.038982465863227844,
0.36054566502571106,
0.1486053466796875,
0.11884285509586334,
0.18291868269443512,
0.5233938694000244,
-0.1730407476425171,
-0.7080259323120117,
-0.029777852818369865,
0.21862170100212097,
0.19777722656726837,
-0.16802504658699036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10579v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10579v1
|
The application of Augmented Reality (AR) in Remote Work and Education
| 2024-04-16T14:04:46 | 2024-04-16T14:04:46 |
Keqin Li, Peng Xirui, Jintong Song, Bo Hong, Jin Wang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the rapid advancement of technology, Augmented Reality (AR) technology,
known for its ability to deeply integrate virtual information with the real
world, is gradually transforming traditional work modes and teaching methods.
Particularly in the realms of remote work and online education, AR technology
demonstrates a broad spectrum of application prospects. This paper delves into
the application potential and actual effects of AR technology in remote work
and education. Through a systematic literature review, this study outlines the
key features, advantages, and challenges of AR technology. Based on theoretical
analysis, it discusses the scientific basis and technical support that AR
technology provides for enhancing remote work efficiency and promoting
innovation in educational teaching models. Additionally, by designing an
empirical research plan and analyzing experimental data, this article reveals
the specific performance and influencing factors of AR technology in practical
applications. Finally, based on the results of the experiments, this research
summarizes the application value of AR technology in remote work and education,
looks forward to its future development trends, and proposes forward-looking
research directions and strategic suggestions, offering empirical foundation
and theoretical guidance for further promoting the in-depth application of AR
technology in related fields.
|
[
-0.6225576400756836,
-0.8235533237457275,
0.21041546761989594,
-0.30649900436401367,
-0.35461002588272095,
0.36773186922073364,
0.3275863528251648,
-0.8400994539260864,
0.4194760024547577,
0.2704940736293793,
-0.1395900398492813,
-0.06039714068174362,
-0.6528168320655823,
0.2655598223209381,
-0.6269066333770752,
0.30134648084640503,
-0.6244412660598755,
-0.03837471455335617,
0.02124667912721634,
-0.03525741770863533,
-0.6464383006095886,
-0.4160383939743042,
-0.2573726773262024,
0.27928832173347473,
0.4164697229862213,
0.5916337370872498,
0.40158629417419434,
0.4017505943775177,
1.0822522640228271,
0.3378664255142212,
0.2535383701324463,
0.13337330520153046,
0.15673916041851044,
-0.07127697765827179,
-0.12216299772262573,
-0.4694444239139557,
-0.26056334376335144,
-0.003509339177981019,
0.9692810773849487,
0.5888056755065918,
-0.016318753361701965,
0.2234230935573578,
-0.040195733308792114,
0.7241933345794678,
-0.5123670101165771,
-0.537003755569458,
0.20819690823554993,
0.38060620427131653,
0.0932568609714508,
-0.1642099916934967,
0.3394830822944641,
-0.49129194021224976,
0.340430349111557,
-0.42944493889808655,
0.2433292716741562,
0.58807373046875,
0.775704026222229,
-0.06801395863294601,
-0.48734623193740845,
-0.027890361845493317,
-1.1495945453643799,
0.3846011459827423,
-0.5067707300186157,
0.6843101382255554,
0.12569326162338257,
0.5719891786575317,
-0.06752609461545944,
-0.3749583959579468,
-0.5345324873924255,
-0.22035016119480133,
0.3749598264694214,
-0.10193757712841034,
0.3045995235443115,
0.11813131719827652,
0.12431023269891739,
0.726343035697937,
-0.22057053446769714,
-0.22569021582603455,
-0.8306859135627747,
0.38635343313217163,
0.007229146081954241,
-0.19797301292419434,
0.5079560875892639,
0.33168280124664307,
-0.501458466053009,
-0.2913689613342285,
-0.267703115940094,
0.19784732162952423,
0.2712480425834656,
0.18296155333518982,
-0.05244942009449005,
0.9884053468704224,
-0.3967442810535431,
0.8912941813468933,
-0.2730315923690796,
-0.40354007482528687,
-0.13619275391101837,
-0.30416861176490784,
-0.30376338958740234,
-0.04483094438910484,
0.09996586292982101,
0.2078595906496048,
-0.4876687824726105,
0.08695496618747711,
-0.0727841854095459,
-0.15727975964546204,
0.21531252562999725,
-0.351696640253067,
0.33111169934272766,
-0.007276393938809633,
-0.48352381587028503,
-0.19237445294857025,
-0.03274763002991676,
-0.8094103932380676,
-0.5074983239173889,
-0.4193262457847595,
0.4328508973121643,
-0.21067647635936737,
-1.1120892763137817,
-0.03895829990506172,
-0.18565340340137482,
-0.2974681556224823,
0.6109945774078369,
-0.4678909182548523,
0.3877433240413666,
0.5176605582237244,
1.238791584968567,
-0.14144207537174225,
-0.2816728949546814,
-0.2700332701206207,
-0.07636025547981262,
-0.35235634446144104,
0.8454318642616272,
-0.42646199464797974,
-0.3961183726787567,
0.3864673376083374,
-0.23182347416877747,
0.03755810856819153,
-0.5250791311264038,
0.17936907708644867,
-0.7299705743789673,
0.09343542158603668,
-0.25015854835510254,
-0.06575867533683777,
-0.40052035450935364,
0.8399285674095154,
-0.7298248410224915,
0.625300407409668,
0.12624405324459076,
-0.3959638476371765,
0.7197527885437012,
-0.9682871699333191,
-0.380407452583313,
0.039087630808353424,
0.17009936273097992,
-0.3642699420452118,
0.07919637858867645,
-0.17315059900283813,
0.16213762760162354,
-0.04658651724457741,
-0.14680936932563782,
0.2636479139328003,
-0.7158345580101013,
0.11405903100967407,
0.12411192059516907,
0.27117300033569336,
0.29217854142189026,
-0.4876311719417572,
-0.16311334073543549,
-0.3446989357471466,
-0.46396952867507935,
-0.35898053646087646,
-0.11667432636022568,
-0.5402731895446777,
0.016310498118400574,
-0.39633604884147644,
0.32621288299560547,
-0.02555474080145359,
-0.5755888223648071,
0.12105283886194229,
-0.2516617476940155,
-0.15622034668922424,
0.08702199161052704,
-0.024803532287478447,
0.745776355266571,
-0.34366002678871155,
0.9086964726448059,
-0.23111040890216827,
0.3964044749736786,
0.16260135173797607,
-0.3372807204723358,
-0.2096284031867981,
-0.41935989260673523,
0.4973970353603363,
0.5989565849304199,
-0.9571748971939087,
-0.02877337671816349,
0.1404872089624405,
-0.18983052670955658,
-0.487129271030426,
-0.17583253979682922,
0.23350577056407928,
0.738690197467804,
0.06223979592323303,
-0.339742511510849,
-0.7414724826812744,
-0.4074927270412445,
-0.48787811398506165,
0.17380058765411377,
0.10960476100444794,
0.0036062051076442003,
0.3356885313987732,
-0.04749065637588501,
0.7841296792030334,
0.21181125938892365,
-0.6387664675712585,
-0.0482085682451725,
-0.04278988018631935,
0.016111811622977257,
0.41164863109588623,
0.25499558448791504,
-1.1186052560806274,
-0.23397476971149445,
0.14227767288684845,
-0.8345454335212708,
0.6115311980247498,
-0.11396902799606323,
-0.3841893672943115,
0.09610486030578613,
-0.15520034730434418,
-0.29145362973213196,
0.7981038093566895,
0.2789633572101593,
-0.33287712931632996,
0.41876906156539917,
0.0493774339556694,
1.1054201126098633,
-0.4729587137699127,
0.05276121944189072,
0.15627241134643555,
0.018468672409653664,
-0.23586410284042358,
0.15613538026809692,
-0.40852612257003784,
-0.4916079044342041,
-0.559978187084198,
0.4020114243030548,
-0.45612865686416626,
-0.18958669900894165,
-0.4939410984516144,
0.508412778377533,
0.0916166827082634,
-0.07463967055082321,
0.1622948795557022,
0.7047011852264404,
0.5431922674179077,
-0.7848040461540222,
0.6703538298606873,
0.1519177109003067,
-0.37642407417297363,
0.3469223380088806,
-0.24917905032634735,
-0.3071146607398987,
0.40121030807495117,
0.11527984589338303,
-0.5827382206916809,
-0.016839591786265373,
0.6020922064781189,
-0.39621874690055847,
0.2718314230442047,
0.18868325650691986,
-0.6091846227645874,
-0.4586222171783447,
-0.5139561295509338,
0.28648144006729126,
0.3751131594181061,
-0.4391511380672455,
0.8854925036430359,
0.25190868973731995,
0.24858933687210083,
-0.7591628432273865,
-0.607995867729187,
0.19870761036872864,
-0.28578609228134155,
-0.4691290855407715,
0.06632014364004135,
0.4683992266654968,
-0.7482013702392578,
0.2830826938152313,
-0.3942004442214966,
0.10792595893144608,
-0.0626622661948204,
0.22163239121437073,
0.502733588218689,
-0.019947730004787445,
-0.17097283899784088,
0.07892143726348877,
0.03964149206876755,
-0.02070668153464794,
0.062144890427589417,
-0.11032914370298386,
-0.21382850408554077,
-0.47813090682029724,
-0.5822997689247131,
0.5186217427253723,
0.0935528501868248,
0.14376938343048096,
1.0732852220535278,
0.41183680295944214,
-0.41627833247184753,
0.13937802612781525,
-0.7404584288597107,
-0.28116676211357117,
-0.44996702671051025,
0.24855083227157593,
-0.019559402018785477,
-0.5252411365509033,
0.32701539993286133,
-0.9667120575904846,
0.13386641442775726,
0.011628430336713791,
0.09667553752660751,
0.0485101044178009,
0.6999368071556091,
0.7857428193092346,
0.5926182270050049,
1.0666804313659668,
-0.6539880037307739,
0.5940125584602356,
-1.0598827600479126,
-0.5759040713310242,
-0.07966551929712296,
-0.3368150293827057,
0.07803934067487717,
-0.030325593426823616,
0.4384342432022095,
0.2594689130783081,
-0.22592678666114807,
0.06170722469687462,
-0.9864938259124756,
0.14838461577892303,
0.654904305934906,
0.3598538935184479,
0.27035820484161377,
0.2343018651008606,
0.2468464970588684,
0.018487336114048958,
-0.4563082158565521,
-0.7577766180038452,
0.8839753866195679,
0.31689274311065674,
0.22353850305080414,
0.021878177300095558,
0.3326082229614258,
0.7840040922164917,
0.09017021209001541,
-0.2654958665370941,
0.34217390418052673,
0.3793696463108063,
-0.9060356616973877,
-0.40329718589782715,
0.160166397690773,
-0.4992360770702362,
0.250769704580307,
-0.273125559091568,
-0.2831977605819702,
0.45221611857414246,
0.3216082751750946,
-0.4859054386615753,
0.8865757584571838,
-1.286353349685669,
0.42259684205055237,
-0.2858242094516754,
-0.8411219716072083,
-0.2643521726131439,
-0.48534122109413147,
0.5356773138046265,
0.08494864404201508,
0.7181719541549683,
0.10079839825630188,
-0.020428303629159927,
1.1326924562454224,
-0.3671848475933075,
0.666743278503418,
-0.44623422622680664,
-0.07330655306577682,
0.8649080395698547,
0.22110117971897125,
0.4117601215839386,
0.20194673538208008,
-0.2587178647518158,
0.17156393826007843,
0.12449811398983002,
-0.23126311600208282,
-0.43887603282928467,
0.8664690256118774,
-0.748070240020752,
-0.5173982381820679,
-0.9475461840629578,
-0.2527569532394409,
-0.17287421226501465,
0.3889032304286957,
-0.10701946914196014,
0.5243594646453857,
0.30435800552368164,
-0.5746005177497864,
0.5893738865852356,
-0.019587477669119835,
0.21551518142223358,
-0.019053155556321144,
-0.5922513008117676,
-0.31899988651275635,
1.0486009120941162,
0.300146222114563,
0.21125993132591248,
0.4106608033180237,
-0.07180221378803253,
-0.035573773086071014,
-0.41459164023399353,
-0.5254333019256592,
0.14263591170310974,
-0.522927463054657,
-0.26687854528427124,
-0.12961791455745697,
0.25143736600875854,
-0.16273143887519836,
-0.7598304152488708,
-0.23298379778862,
-0.21815870702266693,
-0.358489990234375,
-0.08126259595155716,
0.5619298219680786,
0.7403215169906616,
-0.4703109562397003,
0.04081600904464722,
-0.4656055271625519,
0.6723470091819763,
0.6766857504844666,
0.7809782028198242,
0.15087871253490448,
-0.12919838726520538,
-0.4288514256477356,
0.5384066104888916,
-0.1906205713748932,
-0.09368074685335159,
0.23667268455028534,
0.050290297716856,
0.18949736654758453,
0.27242839336395264,
0.019835306331515312,
0.44199034571647644,
-0.17990632355213165,
1.0151393413543701,
0.28356635570526123,
-0.3826677203178406,
0.4500274658203125,
-0.08335228264331818,
-0.30491310358047485,
0.45969638228416443,
0.27455443143844604,
-0.13869044184684753,
0.30412983894348145,
-0.5209872126579285,
-0.7840876579284668,
0.5946604013442993,
-0.018113214522600174,
0.0006904204492457211,
0.5326098203659058,
0.18735858798027039,
0.42057907581329346,
0.5504601001739502,
-0.28283560276031494,
-0.3153626620769501,
-0.4832766652107239,
0.6498117446899414,
0.541042149066925,
-0.2794218361377716,
-0.3952014148235321,
-0.32065218687057495,
0.5941839218139648,
0.6582229137420654,
0.8497866988182068,
0.2707765996456146,
0.3353458642959595,
-0.5065591335296631,
0.070757195353508,
0.8004884123802185,
0.9361081719398499,
-0.4757594168186188,
0.2564007639884949,
0.41206541657447815,
-0.6373456120491028,
-0.1519022434949875,
-0.11038806289434433,
0.40667253732681274,
0.041697051376104355,
0.3603154420852661,
0.2743116617202759,
-0.24064119160175323,
-0.8387702703475952,
0.38503602147102356,
0.27272287011146545,
-0.24296830594539642,
-0.6946699023246765,
0.03676733747124672,
-0.3270518183708191,
0.5950238108634949,
0.9742040634155273,
0.5127642750740051,
0.3866955637931824,
-0.6133699417114258,
-0.09215795993804932,
0.17120368778705597,
-0.19418606162071228,
-0.07143158465623856,
0.8112009763717651,
0.18448832631111145,
-0.9411871433258057,
0.1531589776277542,
-0.1985006481409073,
-0.3039027452468872,
0.666979193687439,
0.5109636187553406,
0.4427548944950104,
-0.06815878301858902,
0.13878686726093292,
0.03001246601343155,
0.1658385992050171,
-0.2422482967376709,
0.5452700257301331,
-0.26497381925582886,
-0.10170433670282364,
-0.5296667814254761,
-0.05380724370479584,
-0.7523877620697021,
-0.49921897053718567,
-0.3322526514530182,
0.2864891290664673,
-0.35670205950737,
0.010264604352414608,
-0.6135528087615967,
-0.0898170992732048,
-0.452551007270813,
0.44911736249923706,
0.147008016705513,
0.5909934043884277,
-0.41090184450149536,
0.23325496912002563,
0.9641198515892029,
-0.19270993769168854,
-0.4424365162849426,
-0.2936720848083496,
-0.2680028975009918,
-0.5120686888694763,
0.909305214881897,
-0.33253610134124756,
-0.7466443777084351,
-0.06503109633922577,
-0.6260614395141602,
-0.8782772421836853,
0.9718511700630188,
-0.02749486267566681,
-0.6131709218025208,
-0.1278948336839676,
0.0029843230731785297,
0.45931193232536316,
-0.2898496687412262,
0.2777039408683777,
0.06291739642620087,
0.4574320912361145,
0.21058091521263123,
-0.7718551158905029,
-0.23993326723575592,
-0.3157191574573517,
0.13533027470111847,
0.11318080872297287,
-0.3457379937171936,
0.30167537927627563,
-0.10125770419836044,
-0.06991738080978394,
-0.5245700478553772,
0.6885055303573608,
0.302610844373703,
0.7364785671234131,
0.06616110354661942,
0.0126634007319808,
-0.00171106425113976,
0.25668439269065857,
0.9550808072090149,
-0.02554495632648468,
0.03048386238515377,
0.01906009018421173,
0.016138693317770958,
0.5828940868377686,
0.32021602988243103,
-0.24600756168365479,
0.6612310409545898,
0.5579021573066711,
0.2070121467113495,
0.6975417137145996,
-0.09756065905094147,
-0.8079448938369751,
0.2848298251628876,
-0.5912072062492371,
-0.9608340263366699,
-0.18685795366764069,
0.3906499147415161,
-0.05848310887813568,
0.15427161753177643,
0.9827746748924255,
-0.10195578634738922,
0.18463478982448578,
-0.6117531061172485,
0.10754965990781784,
0.02839307114481926,
-0.20743665099143982,
0.4334726929664612,
-0.10258190333843231,
0.7940119504928589,
-0.31333744525909424,
-0.9031223058700562,
0.28821417689323425,
-0.007226769812405109,
-0.5275101065635681,
-0.4144129753112793,
0.35805556178092957,
-0.22088442742824554,
0.238209068775177,
-0.35588714480400085,
0.8667033314704895,
0.2384183555841446,
-0.30115094780921936,
-0.15379898250102997,
0.122954361140728,
-0.059025298804044724,
0.04261252284049988,
-0.15427254140377045,
0.10461404174566269,
-0.29179647564888,
-0.05895581841468811,
0.6493326425552368,
0.6576904058456421,
0.37426644563674927,
0.5306403636932373,
0.30471271276474,
0.16099976003170013,
0.10387320071458817,
-0.628589391708374,
0.8228501081466675,
-0.39572200179100037,
-0.25009846687316895,
-0.23264718055725098,
0.7095813751220703,
-0.18729177117347717,
-0.5410581827163696,
0.8211752772331238,
0.5532378554344177,
0.7486929893493652,
-0.10170041769742966,
0.6985171437263489,
-0.5840962529182434,
0.8437082767486572,
0.061475783586502075,
0.23272152245044708,
-0.380271852016449,
0.2438497096300125,
-0.6271405816078186,
-0.7290962934494019,
-0.6552607417106628,
0.7439332008361816,
-0.6524282693862915,
0.09297171980142593,
0.7942391633987427,
-0.10465913265943527,
0.08461955189704895,
0.01445510983467102,
0.3587121069431305,
-0.8204807043075562,
-0.15787501633167267,
-0.3095605969429016,
0.6393257975578308,
-0.835078239440918,
0.3166983723640442,
-0.9221915602684021,
-0.5769460201263428,
-0.6781604290008545,
-0.5859003067016602,
-0.8536297678947449,
-0.8193256855010986,
-0.5192948579788208,
-0.3537845015525818,
0.28741830587387085,
0.6688023209571838,
0.5442895293235779,
-0.503836452960968,
-0.1489104926586151,
-0.0754351019859314,
0.2766255736351013,
-1.018178939819336,
-0.22650280594825745,
0.6387488842010498,
0.4806591868400574,
-0.4438419044017792,
0.2685855031013489,
0.025741096585989,
-0.09838155657052994,
-0.1856084018945694,
0.18557387590408325,
-0.8285925388336182,
-0.491036981344223,
0.7587048411369324,
0.9884340763092041,
-0.4050731956958771,
-0.29295891523361206,
0.26188963651657104,
0.2842785120010376,
-0.18758969008922577,
0.5551913976669312,
-1.022841215133667,
0.7378427982330322,
0.16192644834518433,
0.3459722697734833,
-0.029641855508089066,
0.3554641008377075,
0.22693820297718048,
-0.12160205096006393,
0.016782231628894806,
0.48900383710861206,
-0.11089714616537094,
0.18222521245479584,
-0.6607241630554199,
0.4872013032436371,
0.20490463078022003,
-0.7371355295181274,
-1.0834052562713623,
-0.19788697361946106,
-0.5716943740844727,
0.013295121490955353,
0.9148396253585815,
0.19482818245887756,
-0.18405979871749878,
-0.3662554621696472,
-0.5423449873924255,
0.5359108448028564,
-0.28386539220809937,
1.1246205568313599,
0.2383504956960678,
-0.5538985729217529,
-0.32856661081314087,
-0.941923201084137,
0.2640695869922638,
0.127016082406044,
-0.37988343834877014,
-0.6955426931381226,
0.050924383103847504,
-0.1664804369211197,
0.3522564172744751,
-0.041420482099056244,
0.0884193703532219,
0.29032620787620544,
0.5588456392288208,
0.29939281940460205,
-0.6721289157867432,
-0.1509612649679184,
-0.12598378956317902,
0.4098733067512512,
0.353292316198349,
-0.7212756872177124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10555v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10555v1
|
Construction of Domain-specified Japanese Large Language Model for Finance through Continual Pre-training
| 2024-04-16T13:26:32 | 2024-04-16T13:26:32 |
Masanori Hirano, Kentaro Imajo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, q-fin.CP
|
Large language models (LLMs) are now widely used in various fields, including
finance. However, Japanese financial-specific LLMs have not been proposed yet.
Hence, this study aims to construct a Japanese financial-specific LLM through
continual pre-training. Before tuning, we constructed Japanese
financial-focused datasets for continual pre-training. As a base model, we
employed a Japanese LLM that achieved state-of-the-art performance on Japanese
financial benchmarks among the 10-billion-class parameter models. After
continual pre-training using the datasets and the base model, the tuned model
performed better than the original model on the Japanese financial benchmarks.
Moreover, the outputs comparison results reveal that the tuned model's outputs
tend to be better than the original model's outputs in terms of the quality and
length of the answers. These findings indicate that domain-specific continual
pre-training is also effective for LLMs. The tuned model is publicly available
on Hugging Face.
|
[
-0.37154608964920044,
-0.8658595085144043,
0.4003574252128601,
0.3032987415790558,
-0.5604733228683472,
0.24010150134563446,
-0.5009898543357849,
-0.48983725905418396,
0.15957646071910858,
0.8941815495491028,
-0.5808863043785095,
-0.5376840829849243,
-0.6265541315078735,
0.06808428466320038,
-0.13146042823791504,
0.9732792973518372,
-0.1582982987165451,
0.041137296706438065,
-0.022183621302247047,
0.20970267057418823,
-0.4118713140487671,
-0.503654956817627,
-0.9964130520820618,
-0.32123860716819763,
0.3978894352912903,
0.08895407617092133,
0.7114770412445068,
0.5303506851196289,
0.5925993323326111,
0.3044510781764984,
0.341808557510376,
-0.06045908480882645,
-0.518497109413147,
-0.1769673228263855,
0.01069734524935484,
-0.5043851137161255,
-0.6859695911407471,
0.3418658375740051,
0.8073137998580933,
0.7506725192070007,
-0.31972944736480713,
0.019734738394618034,
0.14898066222667694,
0.5843799710273743,
-0.4664565920829773,
0.3844822943210602,
-0.5196776986122131,
-0.12622655928134918,
-0.5473322868347168,
-0.24671101570129395,
-0.47314178943634033,
-0.31683430075645447,
0.20450973510742188,
-0.9388306140899658,
-0.12244834005832672,
0.09838224947452545,
1.0801515579223633,
0.10756883025169373,
-0.32974663376808167,
-0.18118040263652802,
-0.508025050163269,
0.5645961165428162,
-0.8489212989807129,
0.48028865456581116,
0.544767439365387,
0.25728198885917664,
-0.20545516908168793,
-0.7828439474105835,
-0.20515526831150055,
-0.48512816429138184,
0.004466896876692772,
0.18551750481128693,
0.26936256885528564,
-0.03906480595469475,
0.2625603973865509,
0.28165102005004883,
-0.395521342754364,
0.32079067826271057,
0.012968902476131916,
-0.1559746265411377,
0.7173091769218445,
0.1365177184343338,
-0.08008074015378952,
0.2072022408246994,
-0.3246074914932251,
-0.15464694797992706,
-0.9428688883781433,
-0.29505160450935364,
0.5648742914199829,
0.5125769972801208,
-0.22350217401981354,
0.19295009970664978,
-0.17301835119724274,
0.5821177363395691,
0.1361626386642456,
-0.7529546618461609,
0.036491721868515015,
-0.15851888060569763,
-0.19231460988521576,
-0.06319699436426163,
0.6476103067398071,
0.010516166687011719,
0.821529746055603,
-0.10166138410568237,
-0.4259323179721832,
-0.15898241102695465,
0.36587634682655334,
-0.6984876990318298,
-0.0864182710647583,
-0.17468230426311493,
-0.41463831067085266,
-0.23617036640644073,
-0.13540633022785187,
-0.4974857568740845,
0.2453310489654541,
-0.6246269941329956,
0.4545908272266388,
-0.21217717230319977,
-0.3274071216583252,
0.27182745933532715,
0.13885055482387543,
0.3477616310119629,
-0.010181782767176628,
-0.7044267058372498,
0.38625597953796387,
0.5887669920921326,
0.6704036593437195,
-0.09180091321468353,
-0.2528744637966156,
-0.43818578124046326,
0.5120291709899902,
-0.49143585562705994,
0.5567352175712585,
-0.7196251749992371,
-0.7637367844581604,
0.101788729429245,
-0.016567954793572426,
-0.06286348402500153,
-0.5494645833969116,
0.08422460407018661,
-0.697731614112854,
0.07106903940439224,
0.014560103416442871,
-0.7537482380867004,
0.24101151525974274,
0.2185431271791458,
-0.2446858435869217,
0.6014952063560486,
0.2526407539844513,
-0.528476357460022,
0.5185909867286682,
-0.646345317363739,
-0.5954373478889465,
0.5331117510795593,
-0.06595861911773682,
-0.7150289416313171,
-0.14562846720218658,
0.012206808663904667,
0.5864223837852478,
-0.32802796363830566,
0.6286202669143677,
-0.6092321872711182,
-0.36664098501205444,
0.47826525568962097,
-0.45542699098587036,
0.1568240076303482,
-0.04164835065603256,
-0.26319077610969543,
-0.18960900604724884,
-0.8454126715660095,
-0.17904804646968842,
0.386656254529953,
-0.030177105218172073,
-0.6755862832069397,
-0.08719534426927567,
0.021971506997942924,
-0.21999940276145935,
0.7064836025238037,
-0.3272503614425659,
0.294405072927475,
-0.6135055422782898,
0.2913641929626465,
0.9152531623840332,
0.08874936401844025,
0.08608425408601761,
-0.3325817584991455,
0.7167654633522034,
-0.10286899656057358,
0.22952331602573395,
-0.32120466232299805,
-0.12305139750242233,
-0.5045350790023804,
-0.3194047510623932,
0.27173781394958496,
0.27693498134613037,
-0.3825376331806183,
0.3754774332046509,
-0.08947985619306564,
-0.4096643030643463,
-0.0002982226142194122,
0.203367680311203,
0.3822977840900421,
0.5118734240531921,
0.05127539113163948,
-0.24669137597084045,
-0.4723398685455322,
-0.9782925248146057,
-0.10185293108224869,
0.07508686184883118,
0.13104276359081268,
0.31081682443618774,
0.48876041173934937,
-0.156669482588768,
0.6194204688072205,
-0.8351783752441406,
-0.009223508648574352,
-0.2622929513454437,
0.01152798067778349,
0.4424418807029724,
0.49813687801361084,
0.6685900688171387,
-0.8211736679077148,
-0.5561168193817139,
0.1432105004787445,
-0.501562237739563,
0.2007494866847992,
-0.32874056696891785,
-0.32973966002464294,
0.014242714270949364,
0.5301613807678223,
-0.42580607533454895,
0.28243717551231384,
0.24544748663902283,
-0.26821258664131165,
0.671936571598053,
-0.2793521583080292,
0.010724787600338459,
-1.2536677122116089,
0.37552234530448914,
0.21884387731552124,
-0.548746645450592,
-0.3847156763076782,
0.08110011368989944,
0.02305913344025612,
-0.258797824382782,
0.057779014110565186,
0.8165294528007507,
-0.30379536747932434,
-0.1393606811761856,
-0.5866029262542725,
0.24311710894107819,
-0.3206048309803009,
0.5127852559089661,
0.21699167788028717,
0.8539595007896423,
0.7254268527030945,
-0.7920497059822083,
0.25397834181785583,
0.10410743951797485,
-0.5729523301124573,
0.581641674041748,
-0.7969581484794617,
-0.06884230673313141,
0.1386633813381195,
0.14114101231098175,
-0.758001983165741,
-0.37710267305374146,
0.1936061531305313,
0.007337004411965609,
0.8198331594467163,
-0.04921504855155945,
-0.23948654532432556,
-0.5163832306861877,
0.3513159453868866,
0.23453037440776825,
0.5966007709503174,
-0.42756354808807373,
0.38540083169937134,
0.3032609522342682,
-0.7586984634399414,
-0.3769294321537018,
-0.3029015064239502,
-0.04569077864289284,
-0.4330165982246399,
-0.40002405643463135,
0.49082544445991516,
-0.20021148025989532,
-0.035680439323186874,
-0.2738337814807892,
-0.19304430484771729,
0.10056570172309875,
0.37455296516418457,
0.10561496019363403,
0.8051297068595886,
-0.38898056745529175,
-0.09896213561296463,
-0.0744619369506836,
-0.4088066816329956,
0.08848762512207031,
-0.48590147495269775,
0.6321631073951721,
0.050804778933525085,
-0.15394474565982819,
-0.43159645795822144,
0.02199213020503521,
0.3751629889011383,
-0.16952097415924072,
0.6993489861488342,
0.0018104055197909474,
-0.08299144357442856,
-0.1930077075958252,
-0.6755272746086121,
0.0992610901594162,
-0.5936445593833923,
0.30528393387794495,
-0.6524315476417542,
-1.2175917625427246,
0.6265228390693665,
-0.40973252058029175,
0.11827623099088669,
0.5578249096870422,
0.5511471629142761,
0.054007548838853836,
0.8078290820121765,
1.0293304920196533,
-0.36017781496047974,
0.6136490702629089,
-0.003250955371186137,
0.05387219414114952,
-0.404863566160202,
-0.23483644425868988,
-0.4445686340332031,
-0.10574822127819061,
-0.4642854630947113,
-0.005610546562820673,
0.3109947144985199,
0.15226972103118896,
-0.5333966612815857,
0.30788010358810425,
0.08044534176588058,
0.6181309819221497,
0.13811108469963074,
-0.10240637511014938,
0.08695191144943237,
-0.1726880520582199,
-0.13608957827091217,
0.09996386617422104,
-0.38208189606666565,
-0.3077639639377594,
1.2395806312561035,
0.5505548715591431,
0.8422296643257141,
-0.332906574010849,
0.6528058052062988,
0.039371833205223083,
0.7116084694862366,
-0.42829573154449463,
0.362631618976593,
-0.37683558464050293,
-0.31143760681152344,
-0.3351995348930359,
-0.8461868166923523,
-0.7176794409751892,
-0.24898244440555573,
0.27764827013015747,
-0.4338129162788391,
-0.2777794301509857,
0.03739738091826439,
-0.32528629899024963,
-0.2008010745048523,
-0.2058878242969513,
0.8555306196212769,
-0.4127867817878723,
-0.2872585356235504,
-0.18620119988918304,
-0.35421767830848694,
0.5792593955993652,
-0.7055096626281738,
0.2667427659034729,
-0.16532565653324127,
-0.06574481725692749,
0.7879539728164673,
-0.607477068901062,
0.8477000594139099,
-0.27292945981025696,
-0.4657437205314636,
0.0016112490557134151,
-0.3493328392505646,
0.64300137758255,
0.4281424880027771,
0.19300901889801025,
0.10793669521808624,
-0.14277388155460358,
-0.5031787753105164,
-0.4184139370918274,
0.7447282671928406,
-0.8852981328964233,
-0.7825252413749695,
-0.09187006205320358,
-0.3835946023464203,
-0.7933527231216431,
0.2980937361717224,
0.1812230497598648,
0.4479162395000458,
-0.24591577053070068,
0.24969631433486938,
0.48177871108055115,
-0.11486182361841202,
0.29799675941467285,
0.8951722979545593,
-0.4878990054130554,
-0.43229782581329346,
0.6658999919891357,
0.015603609383106232,
0.20024488866329193,
0.27537801861763,
0.24001070857048035,
-0.398671954870224,
-0.23814521729946136,
-0.16381528973579407,
0.5298978090286255,
-0.28057941794395447,
-0.23012077808380127,
-0.18865573406219482,
-0.4285432994365692,
-0.4753482937812805,
-0.362849622964859,
-0.5979284048080444,
0.22257016599178314,
-0.029945651069283485,
-0.008766116574406624,
0.4360843300819397,
0.5380714535713196,
0.13222704827785492,
0.5119664072990417,
-0.8094179034233093,
0.4590993821620941,
0.13947032392024994,
0.9084458947181702,
0.06059742718935013,
-0.8555468916893005,
-0.6514570116996765,
0.09704411029815674,
0.11225350201129913,
-0.30926835536956787,
0.369998961687088,
0.18325962126255035,
0.7158092260360718,
0.7056788802146912,
-0.2656324505805969,
1.0000874996185303,
-0.2392904907464981,
0.3616735339164734,
0.29194146394729614,
-0.8811550736427307,
0.6315919756889343,
-0.4511292576789856,
0.46338629722595215,
0.5770567655563354,
0.7636560797691345,
-0.409324586391449,
-0.699514627456665,
-0.4435955882072449,
-0.764277458190918,
0.6002097129821777,
-0.10798704624176025,
0.31618911027908325,
-0.10793939232826233,
0.9666436910629272,
0.3640914261341095,
0.4161601662635803,
-0.6463898420333862,
-0.25484442710876465,
-0.14995108544826508,
0.053672149777412415,
-0.40542787313461304,
-0.04063975438475609,
0.2552616596221924,
-0.0658126249909401,
0.9132580161094666,
-0.21614421904087067,
-0.30265313386917114,
-0.28907310962677,
0.18308383226394653,
-0.09059339761734009,
-0.18490265309810638,
0.3501947820186615,
0.6929523944854736,
-0.11973554641008377,
-0.46788981556892395,
-0.0433032289147377,
-0.542219340801239,
0.12126436084508896,
0.08556613326072693,
-0.052824731916189194,
-0.16261596977710724,
0.18088746070861816,
0.885410726070404,
0.632615864276886,
-0.8456825017929077,
0.3851832449436188,
-0.051276396960020065,
-0.4635257124900818,
-0.6723862886428833,
0.09463195502758026,
0.24879994988441467,
0.10775495320558548,
0.3016350567340851,
-0.2035144865512848,
-0.37825554609298706,
-0.6322261691093445,
0.28367337584495544,
0.39434289932250977,
-0.060557667165994644,
-0.10965876281261444,
0.7444867491722107,
0.16612498462200165,
0.13225802779197693,
0.9108049273490906,
0.1214032843708992,
-0.36020785570144653,
0.5706705451011658,
0.8442015647888184,
0.8126156330108643,
-0.27244657278060913,
0.1494937539100647,
0.3939622938632965,
-0.04146794229745865,
-0.46066150069236755,
0.30908137559890747,
-0.15271200239658356,
-0.7451472878456116,
-0.7012357115745544,
-1.1155015230178833,
-0.5096649527549744,
0.37436211109161377,
-0.9347913861274719,
0.21409818530082703,
-0.8027673959732056,
-0.31563952565193176,
-0.09144607931375504,
0.24269069731235504,
-0.6665830612182617,
0.5303763151168823,
0.08762772381305695,
0.8866676092147827,
-0.5197327136993408,
0.910060465335846,
0.42946332693099976,
-0.36573535203933716,
-0.7591444253921509,
0.0031919425819069147,
-0.36309418082237244,
-0.9240840077400208,
0.6180729269981384,
0.06756114214658737,
-0.05505652353167534,
0.0035149026662111282,
-0.6968474388122559,
-1.2124652862548828,
0.8497392535209656,
0.4164566993713379,
-1.2578141689300537,
-0.048362500965595245,
0.22247159481048584,
0.4173651337623596,
-0.527386486530304,
-0.2668684422969818,
0.5981009602546692,
0.5885170698165894,
0.27330756187438965,
-0.6972060203552246,
-0.35633736848831177,
-0.4388463497161865,
0.0990566611289978,
0.5085317492485046,
-0.9276235699653625,
0.50628262758255,
0.19419215619564056,
-0.029299961403012276,
0.2686081826686859,
0.7818129062652588,
0.38185498118400574,
0.28762415051460266,
0.32519587874412537,
0.474270761013031,
0.8327896595001221,
-0.0864059180021286,
1.057234287261963,
-0.8021186590194702,
0.14806315302848816,
1.1649973392486572,
-0.6548721194267273,
0.9190937876701355,
-0.02132783643901348,
-0.3212791681289673,
0.48717591166496277,
0.626096785068512,
-0.2744755446910858,
0.35547932982444763,
0.32627061009407043,
-0.08338809758424759,
-0.6757476329803467,
0.05860138684511185,
-0.44001197814941406,
0.448742151260376,
0.2599739134311676,
-0.07471034675836563,
0.339335560798645,
0.2856655418872833,
0.0032798859756439924,
-0.07720215618610382,
-0.5242995619773865,
0.7313028573989868,
0.5402045249938965,
-0.6692277789115906,
0.18923009932041168,
0.16258741915225983,
0.8188574910163879,
-1.3610923290252686,
0.6802694201469421,
-0.5601945519447327,
0.0852774828672409,
0.3404926657676697,
-0.35690343379974365,
0.38281604647636414,
0.30592986941337585,
-0.1567210704088211,
-0.33257630467414856,
0.5689476728439331,
-0.37937211990356445,
-0.6333425641059875,
0.12185248732566833,
0.1662416160106659,
0.09965214133262634,
-0.013313143514096737,
-0.385881245136261,
-0.2092456966638565,
-0.17883926630020142,
-0.49068963527679443,
0.722352921962738,
0.29137369990348816,
0.14054416120052338,
0.634735107421875,
0.8880264163017273,
0.13312412798404694,
-0.4317813217639923,
0.48696303367614746,
0.6592487096786499,
-0.9032052755355835,
-0.8034785389900208,
-0.7298396229743958,
0.13567212224006653,
0.036529045552015305,
-0.6434197425842285,
0.6209920644760132,
0.6444482207298279,
1.0362739562988281,
-0.15249788761138916,
0.7195302248001099,
0.7195786833763123,
0.3307968080043793,
-0.8691418766975403,
0.7443287968635559,
-0.8525014519691467,
0.15743693709373474,
-0.33295148611068726,
-0.9705091118812561,
-0.11266782879829407,
0.656207263469696,
-0.39888516068458557,
0.33687102794647217,
0.29241347312927246,
0.6662647128105164,
-0.021612312644720078,
0.07677777111530304,
0.5368872284889221,
0.28789660334587097,
-0.09385422617197037,
0.4082934558391571,
0.6422868967056274,
-0.0959298387169838,
0.2229459136724472,
-0.05962776765227318,
0.15967142581939697,
-0.12039127200841904,
-0.795721173286438,
-0.7633622884750366,
-0.3029126226902008,
-0.6813037395477295,
0.11957905441522598,
-0.13436977565288544,
0.6471251249313354,
0.5670537352561951,
-0.5081568956375122,
-0.4469377100467682,
0.0773216262459755,
-0.4479164779186249,
0.08655189722776413,
-0.20854058861732483,
0.12251381576061249,
-0.4445950984954834,
-0.5512807965278625,
0.5506817698478699,
0.6972970366477966,
0.22933349013328552,
-0.33864039182662964,
-0.20613554120063782,
0.264028400182724,
0.3723148703575134,
0.36305323243141174,
0.049724727869033813,
-0.32323092222213745,
-0.17534340918064117,
-0.11633998155593872,
-0.13209503889083862,
-0.05076265335083008,
0.82976233959198,
-0.357785701751709,
0.08977183699607849,
-0.10664992779493332,
0.6592130661010742,
0.7345227599143982,
0.10319026559591293,
0.9045257568359375,
-0.6602808237075806,
0.1399996429681778,
-0.08085929602384567,
0.47047895193099976,
0.0051536355167627335,
-0.3778629004955292,
0.24556899070739746,
0.24434766173362732,
-0.4381537139415741,
-0.4109814167022705,
0.0336698442697525,
-0.874887228012085,
-0.43876755237579346,
0.8927516341209412,
-0.32584428787231445,
-0.25532376766204834,
0.03511493280529976,
0.08411308377981186,
0.1518174260854721,
-0.1802332103252411,
0.4813757836818695,
0.7175233364105225,
0.41297316551208496,
-0.06588614732027054,
-0.23205512762069702,
0.3309919536113739,
0.3253789246082306,
-0.7840710282325745,
0.06598769873380661,
0.2185095250606537,
0.5451746582984924,
-0.1888817846775055,
0.7964450716972351,
-0.10539019107818604,
0.28433898091316223,
0.1845342069864273,
-0.22532938420772552,
-0.0990479364991188,
-0.42345744371414185,
0.061748381704092026,
0.379027396440506,
0.20385590195655823,
0.4206281900405884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10552v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10552v1
|
Unveiling the Misuse Potential of Base Large Language Models via In-Context Learning
| 2024-04-16T13:22:54 | 2024-04-16T13:22:54 |
Xiao Wang, Tianze Chen, Xianjun Yang, Qi Zhang, Xun Zhao, Dahua Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The open-sourcing of large language models (LLMs) accelerates application
development, innovation, and scientific progress. This includes both base
models, which are pre-trained on extensive datasets without alignment, and
aligned models, deliberately designed to align with ethical standards and human
values. Contrary to the prevalent assumption that the inherent
instruction-following limitations of base LLMs serve as a safeguard against
misuse, our investigation exposes a critical oversight in this belief. By
deploying carefully designed demonstrations, our research demonstrates that
base LLMs could effectively interpret and execute malicious instructions. To
systematically assess these risks, we introduce a novel set of risk evaluation
metrics. Empirical results reveal that the outputs from base LLMs can exhibit
risk levels on par with those of models fine-tuned for malicious purposes. This
vulnerability, requiring neither specialized knowledge nor training, can be
manipulated by almost anyone, highlighting the substantial risk and the
critical need for immediate attention to the base LLMs' security protocols.
|
[
0.041896846145391464,
-0.6427439451217651,
0.48084473609924316,
-0.1743396818637848,
-0.023244962096214294,
-0.08402511477470398,
-0.30650222301483154,
-0.5752155780792236,
-0.46882134675979614,
0.9629353284835815,
-0.3006846010684967,
-0.44271060824394226,
-0.7491937279701233,
-0.27639394998550415,
-0.41895994544029236,
1.0040438175201416,
0.124710813164711,
0.012683603912591934,
-0.3230254650115967,
0.007212341297417879,
-0.5532860159873962,
-0.566131055355072,
-0.33053135871887207,
-0.204722598195076,
0.38396283984184265,
0.5586919188499451,
0.7334586977958679,
0.7202233076095581,
0.5656529664993286,
0.2055482715368271,
0.13330169022083282,
-0.22764767706394196,
-0.8292485475540161,
0.019052766263484955,
-0.39216023683547974,
-0.5864787697792053,
-0.39514419436454773,
0.18022823333740234,
0.6105835437774658,
0.9851759672164917,
-0.03604130446910858,
0.34551137685775757,
0.20374533534049988,
0.700035035610199,
-0.8875417113304138,
-0.09996835142374039,
-0.9192222356796265,
-0.22736383974552155,
-0.33442968130111694,
-0.3697078824043274,
-0.876361072063446,
-0.29707691073417664,
0.34564849734306335,
-0.26086854934692383,
-0.2977847456932068,
-0.13288867473602295,
0.4272848069667816,
0.14744669198989868,
-0.42177242040634155,
-0.39519035816192627,
-0.7690829634666443,
0.9090701341629028,
-0.5246745347976685,
0.27794262766838074,
0.2418789565563202,
0.3682793080806732,
-0.4583038091659546,
-0.558700680732727,
-0.1585157960653305,
-0.4077847898006439,
0.056018806993961334,
-0.3570233881473541,
-0.3784777820110321,
0.06312896311283112,
0.4348854124546051,
0.17414169013500214,
-0.39230942726135254,
0.3542967438697815,
-0.5023794770240784,
-0.10766469687223434,
0.3921973705291748,
0.13434521853923798,
0.6029840111732483,
0.1252526193857193,
-0.43347814679145813,
-0.13836154341697693,
-1.4820464849472046,
0.0592484213411808,
0.4511169493198395,
0.4550144076347351,
-0.218449667096138,
0.6053963899612427,
0.17238633334636688,
0.6125696897506714,
-0.23057986795902252,
0.01142993476241827,
0.16420423984527588,
0.022162852808833122,
-0.5826021432876587,
0.15098464488983154,
0.6319325566291809,
0.21616384387016296,
0.4907631278038025,
-0.29958081245422363,
0.009442109614610672,
-0.22172822058200836,
0.5615472197532654,
-0.7948654294013977,
0.18618424236774445,
0.2116227000951767,
-0.3826344907283783,
-0.5232203006744385,
0.08902961015701294,
-0.6614512801170349,
-0.5685686469078064,
-0.058455757796764374,
0.34057390689849854,
-0.4492909014225006,
-0.2908768355846405,
0.14475557208061218,
0.025235140696167946,
0.309823215007782,
0.08857220411300659,
-0.6896162629127502,
0.2743719816207886,
0.7339917421340942,
0.6354522109031677,
-0.09129595756530762,
-0.3202289640903473,
-0.5313462018966675,
0.3262845575809479,
-0.5249111652374268,
0.14781895279884338,
-0.514846920967102,
-0.6109087467193604,
0.004947782028466463,
-0.09547396749258041,
0.18647536635398865,
-0.5831673741340637,
0.3856239318847656,
-0.6149035096168518,
-0.06371341645717621,
-0.2152053266763687,
-0.28074848651885986,
-0.20743125677108765,
0.04577978327870369,
-0.5458608865737915,
0.7128063440322876,
0.17545846104621887,
-0.7169050574302673,
0.2022222876548767,
-0.6394379138946533,
-0.3968040943145752,
0.07841366529464722,
-0.1447565257549286,
-0.15371787548065186,
0.29011398553848267,
-0.1369991898536682,
0.529175877571106,
-0.24854755401611328,
0.161361426115036,
-0.3339990973472595,
-0.37440189719200134,
0.35139280557632446,
-0.7698507905006409,
1.0814353227615356,
0.16264165937900543,
-0.5382216572761536,
0.07436636835336685,
-0.6669909954071045,
-0.06096838414669037,
0.24869082868099213,
-0.28764641284942627,
-0.7660699486732483,
0.012484594248235226,
-0.49737802147865295,
0.2045476734638214,
0.25290805101394653,
-0.35712629556655884,
-0.03301495686173439,
-0.6341094970703125,
0.25849899649620056,
0.8874855041503906,
-0.01753220707178116,
0.8127641081809998,
-0.12245531380176544,
0.3975287973880768,
-0.1741432547569275,
0.33204689621925354,
-0.3818778395652771,
-0.2294016182422638,
-0.4231421649456024,
-0.17222701013088226,
-0.03713149204850197,
0.5781672596931458,
-0.23149125277996063,
0.22268936038017273,
-0.37252095341682434,
-0.5610520839691162,
-0.27433741092681885,
0.23422883450984955,
0.6098738312721252,
0.5079725384712219,
0.22404323518276215,
-0.10186409950256348,
-0.45311811566352844,
-0.8602638840675354,
-0.47680237889289856,
-0.10776261240243912,
0.027599195018410683,
0.3413732349872589,
0.4761213958263397,
-0.2711850702762604,
0.7114578485488892,
-0.1466471403837204,
0.15055854618549347,
-0.14506953954696655,
-0.18279360234737396,
0.027916420251131058,
0.5637072920799255,
0.6052501797676086,
-0.473484069108963,
-0.3181867003440857,
0.037341490387916565,
-0.9371625185012817,
-0.10259649157524109,
-0.02443896047770977,
-0.31348130106925964,
0.017911601811647415,
0.7245773673057556,
-0.5426992774009705,
0.40615540742874146,
0.5316209197044373,
-0.05131130293011665,
0.6720868349075317,
-0.12120696902275085,
-0.09578189253807068,
-0.9805504679679871,
0.11265584081411362,
-0.15998929738998413,
-0.0851268470287323,
-0.8135382533073425,
0.35788074135780334,
0.3551948368549347,
-0.1510668843984604,
-0.7302737832069397,
0.459027498960495,
-0.6227932572364807,
0.0036034579388797283,
-0.27044564485549927,
-0.09849835932254791,
-0.1583290696144104,
0.02613384649157524,
-0.27509811520576477,
0.7475382685661316,
0.662359893321991,
-0.556012749671936,
0.053417038172483444,
-0.1048932671546936,
-0.5675814151763916,
0.24765798449516296,
-0.48848533630371094,
0.2789364457130432,
0.06521652638912201,
0.11217177659273148,
-0.6893585324287415,
-0.2777528166770935,
0.37851205468177795,
-0.31119510531425476,
0.5462793707847595,
-0.2656741738319397,
-0.3896835148334503,
-0.06785587221384048,
-0.27713191509246826,
0.261248916387558,
0.6123783588409424,
-0.5427031517028809,
0.5685973167419434,
0.43588995933532715,
-0.04334929585456848,
-1.0534123182296753,
-0.8321911692619324,
0.21526773273944855,
-0.41565749049186707,
-0.4845929443836212,
0.08269842714071274,
0.13444122672080994,
-0.5888852477073669,
-0.07065501809120178,
-0.1796337366104126,
0.1934904158115387,
0.5680678486824036,
0.7021740078926086,
0.3028137683868408,
-0.30701377987861633,
-0.07161344587802887,
0.0034500062465667725,
0.010015163570642471,
0.5336209535598755,
-0.2930293381214142,
0.38880693912506104,
-0.10526388883590698,
-0.7359558343887329,
-0.2657874822616577,
0.4514267146587372,
0.7810148596763611,
-0.05413184314966202,
0.8328326344490051,
-0.14382489025592804,
-0.541236937046051,
-0.4189285337924957,
-0.37992626428604126,
-0.0591072142124176,
-0.550024151802063,
0.4738631844520569,
-0.13441097736358643,
-0.815213143825531,
0.29262807965278625,
-0.1820896714925766,
0.18918344378471375,
0.22393029928207397,
0.6164422035217285,
-0.013036753050982952,
0.7705027461051941,
0.8104320168495178,
-0.12673862278461456,
0.46934106945991516,
-0.10632319003343582,
0.18180344998836517,
-0.5999119877815247,
-0.38716697692871094,
-0.5302595496177673,
0.022203519940376282,
-0.3823775053024292,
-0.42137113213539124,
0.3172391951084137,
0.07359424233436584,
-0.4368474781513214,
0.2384665608406067,
-0.2301754206418991,
0.8376168608665466,
0.48859983682632446,
-0.005241760518401861,
0.14444224536418915,
0.07646173983812332,
-0.19286499917507172,
0.21231219172477722,
-0.405656099319458,
-0.9293195009231567,
1.5112099647521973,
0.6881518959999084,
1.142865538597107,
0.20861591398715973,
0.5805981159210205,
0.26198703050613403,
0.5402051210403442,
-0.7066780924797058,
0.5088908672332764,
0.004219669848680496,
-0.6551071405410767,
-0.2330145537853241,
-0.39435771107673645,
-0.843454122543335,
0.10813229531049728,
0.1299312859773636,
-0.8883336186408997,
0.056067053228616714,
0.2751481235027313,
-0.24859683215618134,
0.3661046326160431,
-0.9827921986579895,
0.8934814929962158,
-0.5208988189697266,
-0.336413711309433,
-0.2167477011680603,
-0.7853065729141235,
0.6166327595710754,
-0.08232764899730682,
0.36174774169921875,
0.09575365483760834,
0.07262828946113586,
0.46157529950141907,
-0.22920802235603333,
1.3005647659301758,
-0.2229015976190567,
-0.3581945598125458,
0.24385519325733185,
0.4312903881072998,
0.4921371042728424,
-0.09266822785139084,
0.040958281606435776,
0.2961534261703491,
-0.34345492720603943,
-0.341840922832489,
-0.4636293351650238,
0.8539245128631592,
-0.7038413882255554,
-0.8441298604011536,
-0.3534579873085022,
-0.464899480342865,
-0.4026434123516083,
0.20679381489753723,
0.22319728136062622,
0.3609803020954132,
-0.4301846921443939,
0.3889962434768677,
0.9084503650665283,
-0.4876948595046997,
0.12298646569252014,
0.46900326013565063,
-0.016380056738853455,
-0.0035073095932602882,
0.78763747215271,
-0.19250920414924622,
0.825378954410553,
0.2913954555988312,
0.32920992374420166,
-0.07758091390132904,
-0.7173697352409363,
-0.4577467441558838,
0.1192326620221138,
-0.9788104891777039,
-0.19578252732753754,
-0.4791666567325592,
-0.2802823483943939,
-0.2627696096897125,
-0.32281798124313354,
-0.35628172755241394,
-0.08237988501787186,
-0.40229567885398865,
-0.2984503209590912,
0.07230141013860703,
0.6958943009376526,
0.04290563240647316,
0.3998321294784546,
-0.857719898223877,
-0.1712064892053604,
0.1315210908651352,
0.2946924865245819,
0.19962520897388458,
-0.5957034826278687,
-0.31439343094825745,
0.2194141149520874,
-0.2938883900642395,
-0.9750164747238159,
0.20182915031909943,
0.018143022432923317,
0.981115460395813,
0.6202465295791626,
-0.13419581949710846,
0.3619077503681183,
-0.6645367741584778,
0.730438768863678,
0.1620013415813446,
-0.9702926874160767,
0.5334495306015015,
-0.25779834389686584,
-0.00022792375239077955,
0.3923284709453583,
0.6572796106338501,
-0.346964031457901,
-0.3607290983200073,
-0.47628894448280334,
-0.8193963170051575,
0.7341345548629761,
-0.12659987807273865,
0.4925104081630707,
0.06299062818288803,
0.3137342035770416,
0.18681249022483826,
0.081349216401577,
-0.6883525252342224,
-0.1911979615688324,
-0.06756329536437988,
-0.061622556298971176,
0.09116676449775696,
-0.4118250012397766,
-0.4157119393348694,
0.03411649540066719,
0.5151440501213074,
0.06856220215559006,
0.07238234579563141,
-0.2264929562807083,
-0.5827378034591675,
-0.24930621683597565,
0.399737149477005,
0.5738738179206848,
0.6343310475349426,
-0.13371573388576508,
0.31405434012413025,
0.27670854330062866,
-0.4933381676673889,
0.05682139843702316,
-0.41430896520614624,
0.07558248937129974,
-0.46845531463623047,
0.5609175562858582,
0.624627947807312,
0.3670855164527893,
-1.034335970878601,
0.6101916432380676,
0.3106590807437897,
0.032681655138731,
-0.29153895378112793,
0.236341655254364,
0.09650740027427673,
0.04287806525826454,
0.33852651715278625,
0.1754746288061142,
0.010152045637369156,
-0.783384382724762,
0.2511717677116394,
0.5516858696937561,
-0.41996148228645325,
-0.30697324872016907,
0.30501285195350647,
0.05348750948905945,
-0.14290915429592133,
0.40586698055267334,
0.22471323609352112,
-0.4259580373764038,
0.5999548435211182,
0.7333220839500427,
0.7869102954864502,
-0.44061633944511414,
-0.017317602410912514,
0.053673096001148224,
0.8054443001747131,
-0.06566579639911652,
-0.014744033105671406,
0.1856575608253479,
-0.7179814577102661,
-0.32162055373191833,
-0.40391960740089417,
-0.5273405313491821,
0.48666056990623474,
-0.6039039492607117,
0.25507280230522156,
-0.6176860928535461,
0.21967461705207825,
-0.2153981775045395,
-0.506290853023529,
-0.4913148581981659,
-0.01774255931377411,
0.4097957909107208,
1.054746389389038,
-0.936706006526947,
0.6802907586097717,
0.39316311478614807,
-0.17519766092300415,
-0.6807251572608948,
0.04965103417634964,
0.2176893949508667,
-0.8925163745880127,
0.8221642971038818,
0.26908501982688904,
-0.27593082189559937,
-0.27946925163269043,
-0.7442960143089294,
-0.8226173520088196,
0.7808359861373901,
0.7590064406394958,
-0.3410808742046356,
-0.183216854929924,
0.40557944774627686,
0.3442623019218445,
-0.5019760727882385,
0.06509186327457428,
0.5631369948387146,
0.1660005748271942,
-0.14090798795223236,
-0.7016831040382385,
0.20265749096870422,
-0.04850153997540474,
-0.16745147109031677,
0.16696520149707794,
-0.20711670815944672,
0.8071019649505615,
-0.39781054854393005,
-0.32033082842826843,
-0.269325852394104,
0.2980000972747803,
0.17770721018314362,
0.07935424894094467,
0.3256883919239044,
0.30747413635253906,
0.5822780132293701,
0.2052004486322403,
1.1411628723144531,
-0.14594365656375885,
-0.14907842874526978,
1.1617375612258911,
-0.41318467259407043,
0.8409689664840698,
0.5357223153114319,
0.1822139024734497,
0.4684240520000458,
0.33668383955955505,
0.23048123717308044,
0.5464516878128052,
0.34664133191108704,
-0.20451965928077698,
-0.0788218080997467,
0.13204625248908997,
-0.23115883767604828,
0.46370479464530945,
0.8763899207115173,
-0.7000178694725037,
-0.4079498052597046,
0.05974718555808067,
0.0912555679678917,
0.11490368843078613,
-0.3527046740055084,
0.5875725150108337,
0.3194372057914734,
-0.3544350266456604,
0.5960432887077332,
0.00980552937835455,
0.4878697097301483,
-0.6832994818687439,
-0.0017588370246812701,
0.26777538657188416,
0.11618445813655853,
-0.1171569675207138,
-0.7193160653114319,
0.40969017148017883,
0.332045316696167,
0.015523434616625309,
-0.33599337935447693,
0.7435812950134277,
0.03987512364983559,
-0.11588411033153534,
0.5982116460800171,
0.43603232502937317,
0.11264441907405853,
-0.19088689982891083,
-0.44257858395576477,
0.044970378279685974,
-0.16534008085727692,
-0.3748822808265686,
0.6403101682662964,
0.3869190514087677,
-0.4014583230018616,
0.7896683812141418,
0.7537264823913574,
0.13256333768367767,
0.21490643918514252,
-0.017735116183757782,
0.9332394599914551,
-0.44864317774772644,
-0.2146909087896347,
-1.2757583856582642,
0.4363396167755127,
-0.023837337270379066,
-0.10510201007127762,
0.7102825045585632,
0.5266717076301575,
1.0608309507369995,
-0.13893058896064758,
1.0606507062911987,
0.2500717341899872,
0.31339266896247864,
-0.6127700209617615,
0.8787381052970886,
-0.4087979793548584,
0.5278884172439575,
-0.10929027944803238,
-0.5104818344116211,
-0.1858060657978058,
0.2767002582550049,
-0.4420792758464813,
-0.035180993378162384,
0.6435486078262329,
0.7872536182403564,
-0.21214979887008667,
-0.11770572513341904,
0.45262718200683594,
0.24536101520061493,
0.3608812391757965,
0.5777893662452698,
0.97477787733078,
-0.06100849807262421,
0.5280835032463074,
-0.1807703673839569,
-0.4805614948272705,
-0.36208000779151917,
-1.148465871810913,
-1.084221363067627,
-0.2847680449485779,
0.07622884213924408,
-0.48081067204475403,
0.07432404905557632,
1.017060399055481,
0.5522996187210083,
-0.799151599407196,
-0.39050498604774475,
-0.001915055327117443,
0.02924777753651142,
-0.11237634718418121,
-0.1732819825410843,
0.1423974633216858,
-0.17593476176261902,
-0.4813721179962158,
0.6693917512893677,
0.2884296476840973,
0.10051727294921875,
-0.3995424807071686,
0.04311994090676308,
0.10432551801204681,
0.21776965260505676,
0.5724309086799622,
0.3520973324775696,
-0.6928755640983582,
-0.36366164684295654,
0.01343814842402935,
-0.4636150300502777,
-0.14758053421974182,
0.8238433599472046,
-0.41036802530288696,
0.22382980585098267,
0.4562045633792877,
0.9717380404472351,
-0.15440259873867035,
-0.2307737171649933,
0.805307924747467,
-0.8013548254966736,
0.06706033647060394,
0.2538670003414154,
0.4122292697429657,
0.30232682824134827,
-0.7244343757629395,
0.19190585613250732,
0.07420797646045685,
-0.2942869961261749,
-1.1191129684448242,
0.4428215026855469,
-0.8891940116882324,
-0.369453489780426,
1.2353647947311401,
-0.2646075487136841,
-0.4021393954753876,
-0.02859189361333847,
0.014333630912005901,
0.14298324286937714,
-0.24636748433113098,
0.5976963043212891,
0.6016088128089905,
0.288625031709671,
0.029949011281132698,
-0.9345259666442871,
0.3985705077648163,
0.05501691624522209,
-0.7965481281280518,
0.46393224596977234,
0.4129049479961395,
0.5869266390800476,
0.03309474512934685,
0.31917643547058105,
-0.4794386327266693,
0.2851247787475586,
-0.060746997594833374,
0.0935196802020073,
-0.27847808599472046,
-0.5407713651657104,
-0.5915157794952393,
0.2829517424106598,
0.14415813982486725,
-0.04978039115667343
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10513v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10513v1
|
CoTAR: Chain-of-Thought Attribution Reasoning with Multi-level Granularity
| 2024-04-16T12:37:10 | 2024-04-16T12:37:10 |
Moshe Berchansky, Daniel Fleischer, Moshe Wasserblat, Peter Izsak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
State-of-the-art performance in QA tasks is currently achieved by systems
employing Large Language Models (LLMs), however these models tend to
hallucinate information in their responses. One approach focuses on enhancing
the generation process by incorporating attribution from the given input to the
output. However, the challenge of identifying appropriate attributions and
verifying their accuracy against a source is a complex task that requires
significant improvements in assessing such systems. We introduce an
attribution-oriented Chain-of-Thought reasoning method to enhance the accuracy
of attributions. This approach focuses the reasoning process on generating an
attribution-centric output. Evaluations on two context-enhanced
question-answering datasets using GPT-4 demonstrate improved accuracy and
correctness of attributions. In addition, the combination of our method with
finetuning enhances the response and attribution accuracy of two smaller LLMs,
showing their potential to outperform GPT-4 in some cases.
|
[
-0.4396887719631195,
-0.9788253903388977,
0.8965128064155579,
0.035990189760923386,
-0.26266801357269287,
0.29508376121520996,
-0.16982291638851166,
-0.43380194902420044,
0.04297906905412674,
0.44064250588417053,
-0.27394741773605347,
-0.4464455246925354,
-0.4014715254306793,
-0.054235540330410004,
-0.5713191032409668,
1.025426983833313,
-0.18190421164035797,
-0.2502722144126892,
-0.3421454131603241,
-0.014494093134999275,
-0.3474924564361572,
-0.7885300517082214,
-0.9390088319778442,
-0.46005213260650635,
0.7298845648765564,
0.4014146029949188,
0.6032669544219971,
0.4103398323059082,
0.36834716796875,
0.2582321763038635,
-0.1849442720413208,
0.5311536192893982,
-0.2626912593841553,
0.041735775768756866,
-0.50222247838974,
-0.47538459300994873,
-0.8014662265777588,
-0.35264235734939575,
0.4313133955001831,
0.20752699673175812,
-0.23356753587722778,
0.40319061279296875,
-0.020105822011828423,
0.654204785823822,
-0.9754442572593689,
-0.09902448207139969,
-0.7987855672836304,
-0.20128269493579865,
0.06974349170923233,
-0.40713948011398315,
-0.3400011956691742,
-0.6716125011444092,
-0.08538368344306946,
-0.2761561870574951,
-0.08978672325611115,
-0.06771579384803772,
0.680480420589447,
0.1605876237154007,
-0.5971319675445557,
-0.598006546497345,
-0.7662525773048401,
0.7641682028770447,
-0.7397585511207581,
0.22319304943084717,
0.4875439405441284,
0.13352414965629578,
0.08222372829914093,
-0.6111961603164673,
-0.5482040643692017,
0.04349237680435181,
0.12177789211273193,
0.018969284370541573,
0.05312517657876015,
-0.04511227831244469,
-0.0077460468746721745,
0.5368776321411133,
-0.22267630696296692,
-0.3042273223400116,
-0.11660768836736679,
-0.0027482416480779648,
0.6254005432128906,
0.025014467537403107,
-0.19252343475818634,
-0.1916077733039856,
-0.4824223518371582,
-0.1789516657590866,
-0.5009523630142212,
0.043707072734832764,
0.269634872674942,
0.17515793442726135,
0.38150620460510254,
0.4727277159690857,
-0.18832340836524963,
0.5844648480415344,
0.333564430475235,
-0.04947264865040779,
0.07981588691473007,
-0.6115758419036865,
-0.14954058825969696,
0.1613544225692749,
0.664342999458313,
0.12917910516262054,
0.12174561619758606,
-0.1346069574356079,
-0.36164090037345886,
0.060922905802726746,
0.5176951289176941,
-0.46204522252082825,
-0.05890696123242378,
0.5635870695114136,
-0.15368397533893585,
-0.6317013502120972,
0.041103340685367584,
-0.5262140035629272,
-0.22708439826965332,
-0.25573235750198364,
0.46946993470191956,
-0.3612344563007355,
-0.25419682264328003,
0.17160916328430176,
0.08354265987873077,
0.3429357707500458,
0.25036320090293884,
-0.5168913006782532,
0.5126075148582458,
0.6553032994270325,
0.6805185079574585,
-0.20534241199493408,
-0.2206706553697586,
-0.656745433807373,
0.5582703948020935,
-0.5751861333847046,
1.1126394271850586,
-0.6450763940811157,
0.12754562497138977,
-0.17316055297851562,
-0.42798447608947754,
0.11820877343416214,
-0.6500003933906555,
0.49905848503112793,
-0.5457738041877747,
0.10316846519708633,
-0.5244763493537903,
-0.41518357396125793,
-0.04215915501117706,
0.7332313060760498,
-0.427868127822876,
0.9843876957893372,
0.17925208806991577,
-0.4795309007167816,
0.5267921686172485,
-0.7016333937644958,
-0.27885061502456665,
-0.029318735003471375,
-0.4798597991466522,
-0.26121222972869873,
0.048329755663871765,
0.42799094319343567,
0.21380603313446045,
-0.2567001283168793,
0.39597365260124207,
0.006011118646711111,
-0.11639375984668732,
0.5273600816726685,
-0.5143148303031921,
0.3781844675540924,
0.2532399594783783,
-0.3605499267578125,
0.3161355257034302,
-0.7833629250526428,
0.6054125428199768,
-0.22311431169509888,
-0.4504774212837219,
-0.2837941348552704,
-0.0019064457155764103,
-0.24741452932357788,
0.37722304463386536,
0.12628032267093658,
-0.3276151120662689,
0.19453199207782745,
-0.09130412340164185,
0.24653536081314087,
0.800758421421051,
0.1364351511001587,
0.3955930471420288,
-0.18063370883464813,
0.6751800775527954,
0.12173203378915787,
0.22149385511875153,
0.4295898675918579,
-0.1849825531244278,
-0.5788590312004089,
-0.22132806479930878,
0.16338270902633667,
0.48872047662734985,
-1.0280193090438843,
0.4710025489330292,
-0.07625193148851395,
-0.2964507043361664,
-0.15851294994354248,
0.052906643599271774,
0.6423631906509399,
0.28116554021835327,
0.3693489730358124,
-0.4081554114818573,
-0.30957770347595215,
-0.5590643286705017,
-0.4046051502227783,
-0.30665141344070435,
-0.06376732140779495,
0.27642586827278137,
0.40257689356803894,
-0.18930554389953613,
0.9135356545448303,
-0.7149394750595093,
-0.1580616682767868,
-0.1690298318862915,
0.373548299074173,
0.043450791388750076,
0.4195540249347687,
0.17367878556251526,
-0.510056734085083,
-0.19482865929603577,
0.16674289107322693,
-0.6955741047859192,
-0.04017652943730354,
-0.16379494965076447,
-0.42186495661735535,
-0.05881506949663162,
0.41528522968292236,
-0.39162495732307434,
0.13994723558425903,
0.39339694380760193,
-0.5644243955612183,
0.9028632044792175,
-0.11923719942569733,
0.541196346282959,
-0.9315534830093384,
-0.06965658813714981,
-0.30829599499702454,
-0.48315736651420593,
-0.5104613900184631,
0.20884177088737488,
-0.054418012499809265,
0.09799426794052124,
-0.3570540249347687,
0.23225738108158112,
-0.3935173749923706,
-0.15447376668453217,
-0.39253342151641846,
0.25831136107444763,
0.26556071639060974,
0.4285719692707062,
-0.17516092956066132,
0.9049348831176758,
0.48805299401283264,
-0.6255982518196106,
0.6653480529785156,
0.4231463372707367,
-0.3347761034965515,
0.6974905729293823,
-0.5106827020645142,
0.3748759329319,
0.04483897238969803,
0.563390851020813,
-0.6507769227027893,
-0.25241464376449585,
0.10014443844556808,
-0.2695424258708954,
-0.2631019055843353,
0.06126048415899277,
-0.590090274810791,
-0.4236622452735901,
-0.4245946705341339,
0.981596052646637,
0.1766493171453476,
-0.5249083042144775,
0.6127711534500122,
0.07233524322509766,
-0.1306401491165161,
-0.5037327408790588,
-0.7309919595718384,
0.026724200695753098,
-0.47411051392555237,
-0.588074266910553,
0.2818109691143036,
0.2711331248283386,
-0.30444270372390747,
-0.257934033870697,
-0.40853801369667053,
-0.466254323720932,
-0.2966858446598053,
-0.3108479082584381,
-0.01332284789532423,
-0.18959486484527588,
0.3007848262786865,
0.07583452761173248,
0.012340877205133438,
0.2862512767314911,
-0.31610894203186035,
0.7181782722473145,
-0.6356649398803711,
-0.43056273460388184,
-0.20204617083072662,
0.33458536863327026,
0.3303526043891907,
-0.25428271293640137,
0.5861949324607849,
0.5898999571800232,
-0.3687320947647095,
-0.2812769412994385,
-0.5233308672904968,
-0.2816251814365387,
-0.4965772032737732,
0.14557336270809174,
-0.5554482936859131,
-0.5574013590812683,
0.8872824311256409,
-0.04866233468055725,
-0.36560872197151184,
0.29021841287612915,
0.6377944350242615,
0.14785559475421906,
0.9230859279632568,
0.27421969175338745,
0.22392775118350983,
0.420990526676178,
-0.34026941657066345,
0.494783878326416,
-0.9746158719062805,
-0.2223852425813675,
-0.2568635046482086,
-0.08632592856884003,
-0.26268768310546875,
-0.551681399345398,
0.4783249497413635,
0.29449304938316345,
-0.22597981989383698,
0.20499373972415924,
-0.48136311769485474,
0.7534075379371643,
0.2978525459766388,
0.47073495388031006,
0.6052960753440857,
-0.10002723336219788,
0.2603299021720886,
0.7039995789527893,
-0.7185285687446594,
-0.766211748123169,
0.7469810247421265,
0.2286306917667389,
0.9610264301300049,
0.30275920033454895,
0.5879261493682861,
0.35009661316871643,
-0.034846775233745575,
-0.7056556344032288,
0.3893735110759735,
0.008421365171670914,
-0.5690814852714539,
-0.42777055501937866,
-0.46329694986343384,
-0.6041318774223328,
0.20085714757442474,
0.04665607213973999,
-1.017119288444519,
0.27717530727386475,
0.4090156555175781,
-0.7132596373558044,
0.38339513540267944,
-0.5337936878204346,
0.6312207579612732,
-0.20673339068889618,
-0.4933703541755676,
-0.23699060082435608,
-0.4094368815422058,
0.5259496569633484,
-0.2054179459810257,
0.13404139876365662,
0.09015510231256485,
0.037373002618551254,
0.7524864077568054,
-0.5815310478210449,
0.5462601184844971,
0.13202138245105743,
-0.7607054710388184,
0.7327760457992554,
0.14346590638160706,
0.7955845594406128,
0.2908821403980255,
-0.11727800965309143,
-0.2421361356973648,
0.3536301255226135,
-0.38721033930778503,
-0.8088323473930359,
0.6855054497718811,
-0.3836694061756134,
-0.41428548097610474,
-0.3442557454109192,
-0.7616264224052429,
-0.44802126288414,
-0.07033820450305939,
0.23444311320781708,
0.7342714667320251,
0.24670353531837463,
-0.03418399766087532,
0.4884856939315796,
-0.0804118663072586,
0.04796334728598595,
-0.18140506744384766,
-0.293145090341568,
-0.40142613649368286,
0.9438336491584778,
-0.305372416973114,
0.7857589721679688,
0.02843223325908184,
0.27085503935813904,
-0.3839299976825714,
-0.3563494086265564,
-0.3889530599117279,
-0.04908726364374161,
-1.0695198774337769,
-0.3599746823310852,
-0.4325200021266937,
-0.16636335849761963,
-0.2312532663345337,
-0.33564087748527527,
-0.6201579570770264,
-0.29261159896850586,
0.20831723511219025,
0.10096070915460587,
0.42142927646636963,
0.6974928975105286,
0.11546337604522705,
0.44624435901641846,
-0.6919998526573181,
0.3386271297931671,
0.48875701427459717,
0.5396597385406494,
0.23529735207557678,
-0.26857873797416687,
-0.2397441565990448,
0.21820104122161865,
-0.5356447696685791,
-0.609299898147583,
-0.08834177255630493,
0.0825800970196724,
0.1959899365901947,
0.32482707500457764,
-0.02188362553715706,
0.9082316160202026,
-0.22178372740745544,
0.8862032890319824,
0.25571247935295105,
-1.2787495851516724,
0.5979196429252625,
-0.40529268980026245,
0.4392752945423126,
0.6429001688957214,
0.011904917657375336,
-0.17973409593105316,
-0.6315971612930298,
-0.7856202125549316,
-1.0123451948165894,
0.39644140005111694,
0.42934533953666687,
-0.117655910551548,
-0.17814622819423676,
0.32637301087379456,
0.14260266721248627,
0.2644244134426117,
-0.6609151363372803,
0.10503819584846497,
0.038941122591495514,
-0.18311035633087158,
0.18974335491657257,
-0.13091649115085602,
-0.17592363059520721,
-0.2860669493675232,
0.6194118857383728,
-0.3597012460231781,
0.44118887186050415,
0.25703999400138855,
-0.012548762373626232,
-0.24011118710041046,
0.6436321139335632,
0.4382372796535492,
1.3308436870574951,
-0.19588884711265564,
0.550575852394104,
0.5179837346076965,
-0.19025424122810364,
0.33599913120269775,
-0.47507140040397644,
0.2407524436712265,
-0.18642979860305786,
0.40839457511901855,
0.4648989737033844,
-0.2358522266149521,
-0.5489610433578491,
0.6627675890922546,
0.12777242064476013,
-0.16083279252052307,
-0.10186770558357239,
0.045379795134067535,
-0.17920979857444763,
0.5150504112243652,
0.27751243114471436,
0.024738086387515068,
0.3015166223049164,
-0.8370646834373474,
0.3032120168209076,
0.29765617847442627,
-0.29981887340545654,
0.0064421589486300945,
0.3031200170516968,
0.09106526523828506,
-0.04547150060534477,
0.25574108958244324,
-0.24521870911121368,
-0.6899327635765076,
0.5811412334442139,
0.5569644570350647,
0.8880724310874939,
-0.023577744141221046,
0.4056265354156494,
0.192063108086586,
-0.11963949352502823,
-0.2296806275844574,
0.46490827202796936,
-0.10162636637687683,
-0.7144649624824524,
-0.7747156620025635,
-0.45109009742736816,
-0.35961225628852844,
0.0822533667087555,
-0.7842211127281189,
0.10157641023397446,
-0.39382123947143555,
-0.3322259783744812,
-0.30330774188041687,
-0.3232002854347229,
-0.3496294319629669,
0.32652053236961365,
0.12579715251922607,
0.47887033224105835,
-0.7484332919120789,
0.5896798968315125,
0.565299928188324,
-0.4747903645038605,
-0.8524701595306396,
0.3207959830760956,
-0.3489101231098175,
-0.511577308177948,
0.4417969882488251,
-0.16095028817653656,
-0.5641366839408875,
0.0029564143624156713,
-0.5694870352745056,
-0.957654595375061,
1.174958348274231,
0.12812748551368713,
-0.3644854426383972,
-0.11042922735214233,
0.1100425124168396,
0.4718095660209656,
-0.5667821764945984,
0.25092068314552307,
0.7720822691917419,
0.2049645185470581,
0.24582143127918243,
-0.957605242729187,
0.35326629877090454,
0.1905406415462494,
0.07745348662137985,
0.25934988260269165,
-0.34839022159576416,
0.8439490795135498,
-0.13186755776405334,
0.0010849530808627605,
-0.2566499412059784,
0.6057004928588867,
0.7324501872062683,
0.2065134197473526,
0.6871706247329712,
0.12670102715492249,
0.9975446462631226,
0.02030516043305397,
1.0270804166793823,
0.03888572007417679,
0.45014697313308716,
1.310989260673523,
0.00185663893353194,
0.8493516445159912,
0.7871682047843933,
-0.26766741275787354,
0.9679015874862671,
0.48344099521636963,
0.24878078699111938,
0.5733517408370972,
0.44087472558021545,
-0.37640127539634705,
-0.2193393111228943,
-0.2175474613904953,
-0.19643808901309967,
0.33151334524154663,
0.07085981965065002,
-0.36377832293510437,
-0.1417720764875412,
-0.0021823574788868427,
-0.13296711444854736,
0.06650778651237488,
-0.4807094633579254,
0.8759252429008484,
0.09376697242259979,
-0.5738006234169006,
1.0012685060501099,
-0.21085067093372345,
0.4942418932914734,
-0.3974582552909851,
0.10534492880105972,
0.087345190346241,
0.4555039703845978,
-0.45619016885757446,
-0.85568767786026,
0.5114652514457703,
0.2863317131996155,
-0.22085429728031158,
-0.18970896303653717,
0.6767614483833313,
-0.6073636412620544,
-0.5465754866600037,
0.10982118546962738,
0.6700602173805237,
0.1855849176645279,
-0.4521712362766266,
-0.4930024743080139,
-0.04219277575612068,
-0.0984945073723793,
-0.18737857043743134,
-0.15736599266529083,
0.6008267402648926,
-0.35483282804489136,
0.6564330458641052,
0.40907689929008484,
0.21463431417942047,
-0.0017314163269475102,
0.32329869270324707,
1.0233948230743408,
-0.5974245071411133,
-0.46951356530189514,
-0.8528546690940857,
0.4311555027961731,
-0.2810424268245697,
-0.32823267579078674,
0.3288661539554596,
0.47910380363464355,
0.7704811096191406,
0.017785221338272095,
0.7219805121421814,
-0.2950180768966675,
0.1034451499581337,
-0.6525858640670776,
0.2846023142337799,
-0.45865389704704285,
0.32298359274864197,
-0.5175551176071167,
-1.0373996496200562,
-0.16933609545230865,
0.5351070761680603,
-0.4920782744884491,
0.1596703827381134,
1.2312672138214111,
0.5703484416007996,
-0.29539233446121216,
-0.07305559515953064,
0.13251535594463348,
0.010384752415120602,
0.6593621373176575,
0.7162787914276123,
0.9364191889762878,
-0.5301090478897095,
0.683872640132904,
-0.051032062619924545,
-0.3667251467704773,
0.167831689119339,
-0.9407747983932495,
-0.6248152852058411,
-0.4489143490791321,
-0.35386893153190613,
-0.364867627620697,
0.05557536333799362,
0.8501473069190979,
0.48565614223480225,
-0.8242824077606201,
-0.2920646369457245,
-0.42433157563209534,
-0.06721065938472748,
-0.595782995223999,
-0.2569248378276825,
0.40967604517936707,
-0.5337430238723755,
-0.2191215455532074,
0.0429074764251709,
-0.015428122133016586,
-0.2425033450126648,
-0.26982319355010986,
-0.09951823204755783,
-0.46963539719581604,
0.34895095229148865,
0.9791195392608643,
-0.2966737151145935,
-0.8859437704086304,
-0.6419804096221924,
-0.3975417912006378,
-0.019984882324934006,
0.11332675069570541,
0.8102542757987976,
-0.659862756729126,
0.09207016229629517,
0.548040509223938,
0.4191461205482483,
0.41619908809661865,
0.635093629360199,
0.795867383480072,
-0.8912667632102966,
-0.2797260582447052,
0.28128570318222046,
-0.07236535847187042,
0.23809374868869781,
-0.5760416388511658,
0.47701212763786316,
-0.2928406000137329,
-0.7067191004753113,
-0.6124584078788757,
0.4853839874267578,
-0.9631708264350891,
-0.25325119495391846,
1.454852819442749,
-0.04792071133852005,
-0.21600964665412903,
-0.01338464580476284,
-0.3235679566860199,
0.29034149646759033,
-0.3761911988258362,
0.9783172011375427,
0.8819261789321899,
-0.43048059940338135,
-0.1190439909696579,
-0.19458253681659698,
0.5996266603469849,
0.4242449402809143,
-1.2769701480865479,
0.4405956268310547,
0.3898058235645294,
-0.01227161381393671,
0.37839043140411377,
0.6377341151237488,
-0.12772856652736664,
0.12111226469278336,
-0.06942913681268692,
-0.02653942070901394,
0.19321109354496002,
-0.36309927701950073,
0.025182871147990227,
0.0817265659570694,
0.24613173305988312,
-0.15774835646152496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10508v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10508v3
|
White Men Lead, Black Women Help? Benchmarking Language Agency Social Biases in LLMs
| 2024-04-16T12:27:54 | 2024-06-20T07:44:17 |
Yixin Wan, Kai-Wei Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Language agency is an important aspect of evaluating social biases in texts.
While several studies approached agency-related bias in human-written language,
very limited research has investigated such biases in Large Language Model
(LLM)-generated content. In addition, previous research often relies on
string-matching techniques to identify agentic and communal words within texts,
which fall short of accurately classifying language agency. We introduce the
novel Language Agency Bias Evaluation (LABE) benchmark, which comprehensively
evaluates biases in LLMs by analyzing agency levels attributed to different
demographic groups in model generations. LABE leverages 5,400 template-based
prompts, an accurate agency classifier, and corresponding bias metrics to test
for gender, racial, and intersectional language agency biases in LLMs on 3 text
generation tasks: biographies, professor reviews, and reference letters. To
build better and more accurate automated agency classifiers, we also contribute
and release the Language Agency Classification (LAC) dataset, consisting of
3,724 agentic and communal sentences. Using LABE, we unveil previously
under-explored language agency social biases in 3 recent LLMs: ChatGPT, Llama3,
and Mistral. We observe that: (1) For the same text category, LLM generations
demonstrate higher levels of gender bias than human-written texts; (2) On most
generation tasks, models show remarkably higher levels of intersectional bias
than the other bias aspects. Those who are at the intersection of gender and
racial minority groups -- such as Black females -- are consistently described
by texts with lower levels of agency; (3) Among the 3 LLMs investigated, Llama3
demonstrates greatest overall bias in language agency; (4) Not only does
prompt-based mitigation fail to resolve language agency bias in LLMs, but it
frequently leads to the exacerbation of biases in generated texts.
|
[
-0.19970566034317017,
-0.4521295726299286,
0.47585830092430115,
0.3367628753185272,
0.1530022770166397,
0.5944362282752991,
-0.11308638751506805,
-0.3804241716861725,
0.03284810855984688,
0.44989699125289917,
-0.6143102049827576,
-0.4780086278915405,
-0.6518062949180603,
0.0998087227344513,
-0.4362247586250305,
0.8202040791511536,
-0.018497347831726074,
0.28965017199516296,
-0.1475585699081421,
-0.25733116269111633,
-0.6370254755020142,
-0.4180866479873657,
-0.7487664222717285,
-0.46153828501701355,
0.47391289472579956,
0.3089058995246887,
0.6270403265953064,
0.3957155644893646,
0.12716268002986908,
0.282454252243042,
-0.1164880096912384,
0.19037067890167236,
-0.6963303685188293,
0.06742753088474274,
-0.08859676122665405,
-0.2885802388191223,
-0.35440582036972046,
0.3112633228302002,
0.31263965368270874,
0.7163985371589661,
-0.03337575122714043,
0.4087393581867218,
-0.19258134067058563,
0.7023783326148987,
-0.8875411748886108,
-0.004259434528648853,
-0.6641985177993774,
-0.20067085325717926,
-0.2759166359901428,
-0.13577930629253387,
-0.4693435728549957,
-0.553250253200531,
0.09271442890167236,
-0.13340310752391815,
0.4291449785232544,
0.2635759115219116,
0.5420100688934326,
0.03096013329923153,
-0.7994287610054016,
-0.23156698048114777,
-0.5780942440032959,
0.6821258068084717,
-0.48775583505630493,
0.20645672082901,
0.3992466330528259,
0.2545149624347687,
-0.17733025550842285,
-0.34359994530677795,
-0.6033463478088379,
-0.3540344834327698,
0.006357631646096706,
0.026943949982523918,
-0.053279951214790344,
-0.3081105649471283,
0.24552303552627563,
0.10563813894987106,
-0.33671602606773376,
0.1475004255771637,
-0.39308691024780273,
-0.24994917213916779,
0.7257329821586609,
0.031290680170059204,
0.5729170441627502,
0.013050682842731476,
-0.29891616106033325,
-0.2977339029312134,
-0.8696767091751099,
-0.08356649428606033,
0.811434805393219,
0.23985524475574493,
-0.1345714032649994,
0.4809556305408478,
-0.07911171764135361,
0.2649129331111908,
-0.06726676225662231,
0.23168762028217316,
0.30131813883781433,
-0.2668088674545288,
0.13165265321731567,
0.1229560449719429,
0.88106369972229,
0.6153311133384705,
0.6006094217300415,
-0.14825618267059326,
-0.08337144553661346,
0.28791123628616333,
0.3117711544036865,
-0.42635342478752136,
0.39495471119880676,
-0.17461034655570984,
-0.18512243032455444,
-0.31503117084503174,
-0.04024520143866539,
-0.7966351509094238,
-0.8287276029586792,
0.018337251618504524,
-0.10028421133756638,
-0.12407079339027405,
-0.19458384811878204,
-0.3721955716609955,
-0.22146479785442352,
0.6219475269317627,
0.11001952737569809,
-1.0794310569763184,
0.5054384469985962,
0.7252081632614136,
0.6120745539665222,
-0.2644844353199005,
-0.41274192929267883,
-0.4923524856567383,
0.03549665957689285,
-0.43397533893585205,
0.628901481628418,
-0.5170950293540955,
-0.2884276211261749,
0.3287031650543213,
-0.06567292660474777,
0.06730706244707108,
-0.5854030847549438,
0.5371330380439758,
-0.30012232065200806,
0.03905503451824188,
-0.4384705722332001,
-0.40097111463546753,
0.3724003732204437,
-0.17626026272773743,
-0.5090120434761047,
1.2636370658874512,
0.2065451294183731,
-0.6023988127708435,
0.6873362064361572,
-0.3642756938934326,
-0.2516079545021057,
-0.011779861524701118,
-0.6283886432647705,
-0.2944623529911041,
-0.050467461347579956,
0.08292872458696365,
0.23103898763656616,
-0.6028622984886169,
0.3042215406894684,
-0.3710360527038574,
-0.39554843306541443,
0.4533390700817108,
-0.15983730554580688,
0.8441524505615234,
-0.09765736013650894,
-0.6328130960464478,
0.21322548389434814,
-0.5461896657943726,
-0.41381531953811646,
0.26594454050064087,
-0.11238903552293777,
-0.47137176990509033,
-0.027896355837583542,
-0.05393793806433678,
0.19925156235694885,
0.02583819068968296,
-0.644122838973999,
-0.2136533260345459,
0.05211251601576805,
0.15519431233406067,
1.0888491868972778,
-0.3052363097667694,
0.5268862247467041,
-0.31574562191963196,
0.4188162684440613,
-0.3476784825325012,
-0.06659820675849915,
0.3147183060646057,
-0.45937004685401917,
-0.6178727149963379,
0.00803428515791893,
0.11565282940864563,
0.3744896650314331,
-0.6521228551864624,
0.4868638515472412,
-0.07975388318300247,
-0.3937830924987793,
-0.6942033171653748,
0.22296646237373352,
0.4924769401550293,
0.15203379094600677,
-0.04177692160010338,
-0.3263896703720093,
-0.33235499262809753,
-1.0978913307189941,
-0.417339026927948,
-0.22977235913276672,
-0.04986546188592911,
0.3395313322544098,
0.5039122104644775,
-0.3197151720523834,
0.9293822050094604,
-0.3700474500656128,
-0.1296999454498291,
-0.2678992748260498,
0.3432720899581909,
-0.2583265006542206,
0.17310146987438202,
0.3567450940608978,
-0.4879259765148163,
-0.4222804307937622,
-0.19697792828083038,
-0.5360805988311768,
-0.7548800706863403,
0.16296611726284027,
-0.42129942774772644,
0.09232854098081589,
0.7610755562782288,
-0.20892846584320068,
0.10866720229387283,
0.6445308327674866,
-0.7874103784561157,
0.5306365489959717,
0.021295951679348946,
-0.16024339199066162,
-0.8645394444465637,
-0.082205630838871,
0.25588610768318176,
-0.24013708531856537,
-0.7023372650146484,
-0.08147133141756058,
0.1296413093805313,
0.23635363578796387,
-0.35005688667297363,
0.8613432049751282,
-0.6758044958114624,
-0.3183600902557373,
-0.3387153148651123,
0.4726984202861786,
-0.41089701652526855,
0.36612018942832947,
-0.36714792251586914,
0.8329983353614807,
0.20769238471984863,
-0.33864206075668335,
0.11874696612358093,
0.21694612503051758,
-0.3181321620941162,
0.46123194694519043,
-0.36721473932266235,
0.4923340082168579,
-0.2493380457162857,
0.38668161630630493,
-0.832051694393158,
0.05877626687288284,
-0.03210018575191498,
-0.3631826341152191,
0.0771583691239357,
0.3249479830265045,
-0.4436444342136383,
-0.3151322305202484,
-0.5041759014129639,
0.6063495874404907,
0.3883529603481293,
-0.2996525466442108,
0.39259952306747437,
0.6161626577377319,
-0.15501096844673157,
-0.873517632484436,
-0.5926599502563477,
0.009013050235807896,
0.05679762735962868,
-0.3884422183036804,
0.0718090757727623,
-0.08718523383140564,
-0.5829696655273438,
-0.13439452648162842,
-0.07453741878271103,
0.03132007643580437,
0.16129520535469055,
0.24471443891525269,
0.21336787939071655,
0.15747201442718506,
-0.0640379935503006,
-0.016479413956403732,
0.11903656274080276,
0.08706331998109818,
0.30881959199905396,
0.7835102081298828,
-0.05137987807393074,
-0.21621400117874146,
0.28661268949508667,
0.20275764167308807,
0.4757855534553528,
-0.0507863312959671,
0.7749385833740234,
0.5933908820152283,
-0.2704593241214752,
-0.3069480061531067,
-0.8470186591148376,
-0.14789307117462158,
-0.4219456911087036,
0.1911490112543106,
0.09585250169038773,
-0.9903274178504944,
0.5242840647697449,
0.27583882212638855,
0.10566024482250214,
0.32204851508140564,
0.7204527258872986,
0.2584584951400757,
0.6820782423019409,
0.6466708779335022,
-0.3047223687171936,
0.5985040664672852,
-0.029659252613782883,
0.001775026903487742,
-0.8376718163490295,
0.013127273879945278,
-0.5493335127830505,
-0.10335911810398102,
-0.9387775659561157,
-0.39733827114105225,
0.058904003351926804,
-0.4048181474208832,
-0.11175544559955597,
0.09183471649885178,
-0.17253360152244568,
0.5404418110847473,
0.4930172562599182,
-0.09377344697713852,
0.1047799289226532,
-0.2692245543003082,
-0.23624011874198914,
0.1155652105808258,
-0.4007170498371124,
-0.9009238481521606,
1.3107497692108154,
0.41170090436935425,
0.39032304286956787,
0.08233197778463364,
0.5558795928955078,
0.772872269153595,
0.8113506436347961,
-0.2928621470928192,
0.8364896178245544,
-0.19438999891281128,
-0.7687880396842957,
-0.2592121958732605,
-0.43598005175590515,
-1.046416997909546,
0.4708734452724457,
-0.20756109058856964,
-0.7895329594612122,
0.33486998081207275,
-0.20082256197929382,
0.03740738704800606,
0.037897996604442596,
-0.6436552405357361,
0.7117197513580322,
0.017257045954465866,
-0.4783836007118225,
-0.004224081058055162,
-0.4439680278301239,
0.6775609254837036,
-0.2008773535490036,
0.40487226843833923,
-0.6300583481788635,
-0.06171185150742531,
0.7698142528533936,
-0.4653497636318207,
0.8638240098953247,
-0.026341306045651436,
-0.3596976101398468,
0.03003666363656521,
-0.09244249761104584,
0.405791312456131,
-0.29044193029403687,
-0.12384238094091415,
0.06779170781373978,
-0.37665820121765137,
-0.5641404986381531,
-0.23751288652420044,
0.5934215188026428,
-0.9220352172851562,
-0.4102570712566376,
-0.506966233253479,
-0.6510704755783081,
-0.25753864645957947,
0.1628512442111969,
0.036037083715200424,
0.3561343550682068,
-0.4622701406478882,
-0.011032183654606342,
0.29170742630958557,
-0.2356288582086563,
0.2875247597694397,
0.6952801942825317,
-0.07866544276475906,
-0.3113645017147064,
0.5891628861427307,
-0.044420015066862106,
0.5084906220436096,
0.16123619675636292,
0.07443704456090927,
-0.2741473615169525,
-0.28806623816490173,
-0.31348204612731934,
0.4019988775253296,
-0.6683778762817383,
0.10107555240392685,
-0.5098590850830078,
-0.1520608365535736,
-0.6754801869392395,
-0.1718672662973404,
-0.13781718909740448,
-0.016007903963327408,
0.09958917647600174,
-0.2002956122159958,
0.041760195046663284,
0.7081910371780396,
0.18447816371917725,
0.448440283536911,
-0.17843183875083923,
0.4524814188480377,
0.43814679980278015,
0.13181869685649872,
-0.03606804087758064,
-0.1354694664478302,
-0.025756889954209328,
-0.2524038851261139,
-0.3810971975326538,
-1.0962324142456055,
0.17518262565135956,
-0.2506304085254669,
0.7222704291343689,
0.08205141127109528,
0.005501584615558386,
0.10311105102300644,
-0.5748819708824158,
0.7368825078010559,
0.05867881327867508,
-0.953255832195282,
0.20226383209228516,
-0.43779700994491577,
0.23742350935935974,
0.6848453283309937,
-0.0037475686985999346,
-0.7034739851951599,
-1.0540200471878052,
-0.6002269983291626,
-0.942541778087616,
0.9404727816581726,
0.4534839987754822,
0.06035485863685608,
-0.1498793363571167,
0.26664090156555176,
0.07528818398714066,
0.357269287109375,
-1.0502402782440186,
-0.6550325155258179,
0.3381767272949219,
-0.28145819902420044,
-0.1551211178302765,
-0.4168199896812439,
-0.008614149875938892,
0.236219584941864,
0.677804708480835,
-0.20046496391296387,
0.1209339126944542,
0.119901642203331,
-0.1964733898639679,
-0.38241004943847656,
0.5939790606498718,
0.6836584806442261,
0.7849171757698059,
-0.3050347864627838,
0.16293835639953613,
0.25999268889427185,
-0.5243663191795349,
0.48365315794944763,
0.0915084257721901,
-0.5412938594818115,
-0.10353688150644302,
0.426988810300827,
0.8128993511199951,
0.010042029432952404,
-0.7041212916374207,
0.6285918951034546,
-0.26030850410461426,
-0.23975689709186554,
-0.26710936427116394,
0.05808958783745766,
0.024593312293291092,
0.19289956986904144,
0.6244392395019531,
-0.2731795012950897,
-0.03233948349952698,
-0.852215051651001,
-0.1807500123977661,
0.6304128170013428,
-0.32853686809539795,
-0.037504009902477264,
0.5531401634216309,
0.42110294103622437,
-0.3954152464866638,
0.0037507684901356697,
-0.40200915932655334,
-0.4243720471858978,
0.6586339473724365,
0.34142160415649414,
1.2295750379562378,
-0.19175095856189728,
0.3706256151199341,
0.07489372044801712,
0.6539515852928162,
-0.08870191872119904,
0.1482047140598297,
0.134427011013031,
-0.9990650415420532,
-0.282929927110672,
-0.42570194602012634,
-0.6030746698379517,
0.19306263327598572,
-0.45174509286880493,
0.1648036390542984,
-0.31353023648262024,
-0.1895129680633545,
0.011034452356398106,
0.1140170693397522,
-0.6705326437950134,
-0.12418453395366669,
0.34409070014953613,
0.7825493812561035,
-1.094974398612976,
0.4153693616390228,
0.5966670513153076,
-0.07083594053983688,
-0.4757902920246124,
0.26057061553001404,
0.24322398006916046,
-0.8089908361434937,
0.5614959001541138,
0.22085149586200714,
-0.25044921040534973,
-0.20765076577663422,
-0.4531504213809967,
-0.5503959059715271,
1.0681345462799072,
0.3823060989379883,
-0.5501255393028259,
0.20139971375465393,
0.26113784313201904,
0.6325013637542725,
-0.5416896939277649,
0.6036249399185181,
0.9363290667533875,
0.45883044600486755,
-0.3426065444946289,
-0.9388934373855591,
0.44638291001319885,
-0.13955803215503693,
0.16166077554225922,
0.1299266219139099,
-0.889103889465332,
0.7049291729927063,
0.06239240989089012,
-0.2526167929172516,
-0.08053403347730637,
0.5437428951263428,
0.6338515877723694,
0.5170119404792786,
0.7786614894866943,
0.04375072196125984,
0.8239777088165283,
-0.14048102498054504,
1.0555768013000488,
-0.05235494673252106,
-0.07276970148086548,
1.0215948820114136,
-0.7121598124504089,
0.4182308614253998,
0.2999962270259857,
-0.1671331226825714,
0.48033732175827026,
0.34953370690345764,
0.15189741551876068,
0.22879230976104736,
0.5615165829658508,
-0.29108455777168274,
0.13623042404651642,
-0.4427202045917511,
-0.13475167751312256,
0.23574252426624298,
0.06344341486692429,
-0.3402557671070099,
-0.056827519088983536,
-0.29309824109077454,
0.03996807336807251,
0.352061003446579,
-0.19371511042118073,
0.7388383150100708,
0.10485151410102844,
-0.7817206978797913,
0.2311031073331833,
-0.01568829081952572,
0.6416755318641663,
-0.5933447480201721,
0.3271261155605316,
-0.3999585509300232,
0.14083682000637054,
-0.05301925167441368,
-0.5293996930122375,
-0.20940090715885162,
0.24005353450775146,
-0.1551070511341095,
-0.19951340556144714,
0.7281094789505005,
-0.6474515199661255,
-0.45753952860832214,
0.6198651790618896,
0.747051477432251,
0.009683884680271149,
0.26993370056152344,
-0.5137884020805359,
0.08901403099298477,
-0.04520512744784355,
0.07887470722198486,
0.30377283692359924,
0.40817683935165405,
-0.36842644214630127,
0.7305395603179932,
0.536344587802887,
0.4700452387332916,
0.3485445976257324,
0.5743407607078552,
0.646539568901062,
-0.8011455535888672,
-0.24437099695205688,
-0.9309518337249756,
0.11128870397806168,
-0.34204161167144775,
-0.2733171582221985,
0.8484460711479187,
0.43249431252479553,
0.7711848616600037,
0.17184408009052277,
0.7466917634010315,
0.12921872735023499,
0.457808256149292,
-0.3673304319381714,
0.6050682067871094,
-0.2867467403411865,
0.15448275208473206,
-0.6141239404678345,
-0.974365234375,
0.04617070406675339,
0.2032407522201538,
-0.47920045256614685,
0.2957937717437744,
0.6996870040893555,
0.8314797282218933,
0.2206422984600067,
-0.07980778068304062,
0.18200404942035675,
0.14736929535865784,
0.4623136818408966,
0.22166894376277924,
1.0110946893692017,
-0.2866271734237671,
0.48608243465423584,
0.0374460443854332,
-0.2825593948364258,
-0.19030654430389404,
-0.8561517000198364,
-1.0035074949264526,
-0.25407475233078003,
-0.3191239833831787,
-0.20928539335727692,
0.14518480002880096,
1.1305744647979736,
0.5147936940193176,
-0.5797812938690186,
-0.5706368088722229,
0.0010940153151750565,
0.3650968670845032,
-0.1436455249786377,
-0.2655045688152313,
0.050853729248046875,
-0.22457991540431976,
-0.7486003637313843,
0.28667259216308594,
0.03045858070254326,
-0.09539567679166794,
-0.48207560181617737,
-0.19345076382160187,
-0.36286914348602295,
0.19051244854927063,
0.5545765161514282,
0.08479559421539307,
-0.7068172693252563,
-0.0792367160320282,
-0.31891459226608276,
-0.45227324962615967,
-0.2527616620063782,
1.0500836372375488,
-0.2905224859714508,
0.23580417037010193,
0.23388200998306274,
0.47573205828666687,
0.38670316338539124,
-0.12816256284713745,
0.9216362237930298,
-1.0844017267227173,
-0.1019517108798027,
0.07920683920383453,
0.545716404914856,
0.5959457159042358,
-0.1805969774723053,
0.6804152727127075,
0.13410799205303192,
-0.6510484218597412,
-0.8905994296073914,
0.001428260700777173,
-0.8303213119506836,
-0.17228591442108154,
1.464840054512024,
0.295962929725647,
-0.2865746319293976,
-0.13025183975696564,
-0.3486468493938446,
0.3780207633972168,
-0.7870175838470459,
0.8278552293777466,
0.9242554903030396,
0.24368397891521454,
-0.17810934782028198,
-0.8370642066001892,
0.48286542296409607,
0.5364457368850708,
-0.9110425114631653,
0.34580808877944946,
0.5999045372009277,
0.06957778334617615,
0.1631747931241989,
1.0522701740264893,
0.15601472556591034,
0.26158249378204346,
-0.22243234515190125,
0.21906791627407074,
0.23198765516281128,
0.05713053047657013,
-0.1873897761106491,
-0.07655638456344604,
0.13269925117492676,
0.0720226988196373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10503v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10503v1
|
A Sentiment Analysis of Medical Text Based on Deep Learning
| 2024-04-16T12:20:49 | 2024-04-16T12:20:49 |
Yinan Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The field of natural language processing (NLP) has made significant progress
with the rapid development of deep learning technologies. One of the research
directions in text sentiment analysis is sentiment analysis of medical texts,
which holds great potential for application in clinical diagnosis. However, the
medical field currently lacks sufficient text datasets, and the effectiveness
of sentiment analysis is greatly impacted by different model design approaches,
which presents challenges. Therefore, this paper focuses on the medical domain,
using bidirectional encoder representations from transformers (BERT) as the
basic pre-trained model and experimenting with modules such as convolutional
neural network (CNN), fully connected network (FCN), and graph convolutional
networks (GCN) at the output layer. Experiments and analyses were conducted on
the METS-CoV dataset to explore the training performance after integrating
different deep learning networks. The results indicate that CNN models
outperform other networks when trained on smaller medical text datasets in
combination with pre-trained models like BERT. This study highlights the
significance of model selection in achieving effective sentiment analysis in
the medical domain and provides a reference for future research to develop more
efficient model architectures.
|
[
-0.321095734834671,
-0.4089297652244568,
0.5578794479370117,
0.19633638858795166,
-0.7250699400901794,
-0.01487004105001688,
-0.3030502200126648,
-0.45338115096092224,
0.18471327424049377,
0.2772577106952667,
-0.4274267554283142,
-0.7620152831077576,
-0.9450628161430359,
0.23196491599082947,
-0.06490020453929901,
1.1892733573913574,
0.19202516973018646,
0.7666215896606445,
-0.4951433539390564,
-0.24165721237659454,
-0.31437262892723083,
-0.6568540334701538,
-0.7399911880493164,
-0.5525442957878113,
0.6592543125152588,
0.06559651345014572,
0.7813692092895508,
-0.2628258466720581,
1.0611109733581543,
0.2782210409641266,
-0.1670006662607193,
0.08084742724895477,
-0.015727795660495758,
0.22403931617736816,
0.19253242015838623,
-0.09857615828514099,
-0.4307945668697357,
-0.021077889949083328,
0.2582966089248657,
0.7120789885520935,
0.07765555381774902,
-0.2682918608188629,
0.06447802484035492,
0.7792642116546631,
0.02580585516989231,
0.03267722949385643,
-0.20789361000061035,
0.591572642326355,
0.11342690140008926,
0.08628407120704651,
-0.3594585657119751,
-0.5019361972808838,
0.6558247208595276,
-0.10183294117450714,
0.2932557463645935,
-0.2094363570213318,
1.0199156999588013,
0.3697821795940399,
-0.43459030985832214,
-0.5700878500938416,
-0.4506208896636963,
0.5740950107574463,
-1.0605480670928955,
0.3641325831413269,
-0.22490884363651276,
0.3100118935108185,
0.15769466757774353,
-0.9019165635108948,
-0.40551796555519104,
-0.35624417662620544,
-0.2199683040380478,
0.6150172352790833,
-0.01701071858406067,
0.23662056028842926,
-0.2060081958770752,
0.44849541783332825,
-0.5464369654655457,
0.27582165598869324,
-0.19185100495815277,
0.23139704763889313,
0.5142120122909546,
0.08292093873023987,
0.26636117696762085,
-0.5525842308998108,
-0.5539164543151855,
-0.0812014490365982,
-0.3615807294845581,
0.034330908209085464,
-0.12315387278795242,
0.14395076036453247,
-0.3223828077316284,
0.39561960101127625,
0.18907518684864044,
0.6136206984519958,
-0.14633843302726746,
0.17931251227855682,
0.6240770220756531,
0.002802665112540126,
-0.8993043899536133,
-0.030203325673937798,
1.3771486282348633,
0.32867616415023804,
0.3549657166004181,
-0.017614055424928665,
0.027817578986287117,
0.02110297605395317,
0.7194443941116333,
-0.9274681210517883,
-0.193891242146492,
0.39422622323036194,
-1.0207955837249756,
-0.7976630330085754,
-0.18500477075576782,
-0.8148894906044006,
-0.6371243596076965,
-0.3770517408847809,
0.03720564767718315,
-0.5174787044525146,
-0.17289486527442932,
0.4493747055530548,
0.053899385035037994,
0.041048843413591385,
0.16662627458572388,
-0.5411500930786133,
0.1472870111465454,
0.5917603969573975,
0.57723468542099,
-0.14523987472057343,
0.24774335324764252,
0.08504100143909454,
-0.6036524772644043,
-0.32454511523246765,
0.51971435546875,
-0.530719518661499,
-0.5651893615722656,
0.1336059272289276,
-0.03969690948724747,
-0.18215425312519073,
-0.4653957784175873,
0.8504682183265686,
-0.47463205456733704,
0.3318004012107849,
-0.1100691705942154,
-0.5273571014404297,
-0.3710492253303528,
0.5353153944015503,
-0.5967699885368347,
0.519927978515625,
-0.05725404992699623,
-0.8485403060913086,
0.35469570755958557,
-0.5162079334259033,
-0.8130736947059631,
-0.011187992990016937,
-0.35466089844703674,
-0.9220697283744812,
0.5265531539916992,
0.4521855413913727,
0.9998794198036194,
-0.38100090622901917,
0.545289933681488,
-0.33936455845832825,
-0.13647747039794922,
0.37577754259109497,
-0.39999106526374817,
0.8075045943260193,
0.26035264134407043,
-0.05062336474657059,
-0.04815172776579857,
-0.5361247062683105,
-0.2395046502351761,
0.11300265789031982,
-0.20659372210502625,
-0.27295929193496704,
0.18780101835727692,
-0.07142386585474014,
0.23560035228729248,
0.0282308179885149,
-0.6643441915512085,
0.14235654473304749,
-0.8413642048835754,
0.09598696231842041,
0.2937418520450592,
0.11398619413375854,
0.2635365128517151,
0.04865966737270355,
0.4864584803581238,
0.35667210817337036,
0.3680071532726288,
0.2820996642112732,
-0.5590380430221558,
-0.7083666920661926,
-0.2520507574081421,
0.38653871417045593,
0.42006775736808777,
-0.5573391914367676,
0.46115642786026,
-0.24911338090896606,
-0.3852604627609253,
-0.9464263319969177,
-0.27884870767593384,
0.17240604758262634,
0.848339319229126,
0.3536583185195923,
-0.28664448857307434,
-0.5909453630447388,
-1.1015883684158325,
-0.10312025994062424,
-0.05537509545683861,
0.05987956002354622,
0.575027346611023,
0.33127275109291077,
-0.7867234945297241,
0.5828072428703308,
-0.47935643792152405,
-0.4657870829105377,
-0.2880640923976898,
0.12851324677467346,
0.6415837407112122,
0.2506592869758606,
0.6707000732421875,
-0.7454766631126404,
-0.5300951600074768,
0.2469906210899353,
-0.9929763674736023,
0.25595781207084656,
-0.1109708920121193,
-0.010077395476400852,
-0.0012567894300445914,
0.16113530099391937,
-0.5705351233482361,
0.2561126947402954,
0.7577157020568848,
-0.10510005056858063,
0.22296850383281708,
-0.3792031407356262,
0.05553601309657097,
-1.3133635520935059,
0.091117262840271,
0.2507237493991852,
-0.286050409078598,
-0.5030585527420044,
-0.0572221539914608,
-0.0336826890707016,
-0.17288292944431305,
-0.32467103004455566,
0.0797039046883583,
-0.06665260344743729,
0.407592236995697,
-0.14474251866340637,
-0.06817080080509186,
0.35966190695762634,
0.19937804341316223,
0.15117312967777252,
0.271969199180603,
0.6188544631004333,
-0.2362586259841919,
0.4907625913619995,
0.4230498671531677,
-0.14629854261875153,
0.26889103651046753,
-0.8120877146720886,
0.12291930615901947,
-0.4090472161769867,
0.024831295013427734,
-0.9196801781654358,
-0.02286822348833084,
0.3055812120437622,
-0.714789092540741,
0.6431483626365662,
-0.13451185822486877,
-0.34654706716537476,
-0.6384531855583191,
-0.18308110535144806,
0.13998828828334808,
0.6921473741531372,
-0.44503822922706604,
0.4392577111721039,
0.32811301946640015,
-0.03870968148112297,
-0.544592559337616,
-0.7201122045516968,
0.12474845349788666,
0.07412808388471603,
-0.4862559735774994,
0.3702767789363861,
0.1133015900850296,
0.006722382735460997,
-0.15965639054775238,
0.2526959478855133,
-0.10582761466503143,
0.02053682692348957,
0.35837411880493164,
0.5763444900512695,
-0.32393819093704224,
0.5421651005744934,
0.37643805146217346,
-0.17126253247261047,
0.362638920545578,
0.06880021095275879,
0.49815481901168823,
-0.21014975011348724,
-0.15053881704807281,
-0.5415463447570801,
0.3303164839744568,
0.830257773399353,
-0.2475113570690155,
0.6520587801933289,
0.45656707882881165,
-0.3800429105758667,
0.10821104049682617,
-0.20499809086322784,
0.004726876504719257,
-0.3948971629142761,
0.5693702697753906,
0.08500344306230545,
-0.643236517906189,
0.16621193289756775,
-0.07892949134111404,
-0.24788926541805267,
0.6326496005058289,
0.8576093912124634,
-0.6110021471977234,
1.2233994007110596,
0.3270989656448364,
-0.2482529580593109,
0.00975758209824562,
-0.1737590730190277,
0.43078771233558655,
-0.7402909994125366,
-0.3928403854370117,
-0.3350677490234375,
-0.3513408899307251,
-0.621647834777832,
-0.30799153447151184,
0.5737963914871216,
-0.3313024342060089,
-0.06512755900621414,
-0.16568318009376526,
-0.860716700553894,
-0.06218010559678078,
0.28536176681518555,
0.4252311885356903,
-0.08436547964811325,
0.15332742035388947,
-0.5535601377487183,
-0.15310795605182648,
-0.30474749207496643,
-0.4033212959766388,
0.9758099317550659,
0.7112118005752563,
0.5577414035797119,
-0.3213864862918854,
0.7923888564109802,
0.20994234085083008,
0.42751839756965637,
-1.0663926601409912,
0.25199124217033386,
-1.0152639150619507,
-0.3317454159259796,
0.09145627170801163,
-0.23682348430156708,
-0.8985434174537659,
0.09544499963521957,
-0.2786963880062103,
0.11464987695217133,
0.2764299213886261,
-0.19112266600131989,
-0.7086018323898315,
0.12334202975034714,
-0.535777747631073,
0.8797301650047302,
-0.2893921434879303,
0.18691004812717438,
-0.2578188478946686,
-0.6957076191902161,
0.03813762962818146,
0.23960331082344055,
-0.1009441465139389,
-0.09240391850471497,
0.2672732472419739,
0.6108548045158386,
-0.2514576315879822,
0.9406500458717346,
-0.3364819586277008,
0.010884826071560383,
0.05768512561917305,
-0.08198956400156021,
0.14436353743076324,
0.35982152819633484,
-0.2698725759983063,
0.4144751727581024,
-0.22338782250881195,
0.0024022452998906374,
-0.3089793026447296,
0.6041692495346069,
-0.9300211071968079,
-0.33874234557151794,
-0.35006871819496155,
-0.1284407377243042,
-0.4343711733818054,
0.05433719977736473,
0.42291468381881714,
0.5373097658157349,
-0.3754834532737732,
0.3117320239543915,
0.63847416639328,
-0.6013055443763733,
0.3669223189353943,
-0.025363735854625702,
-0.04197230935096741,
-0.43793943524360657,
0.5182235240936279,
-0.10130710899829865,
-0.17517521977424622,
0.4125581681728363,
0.526483416557312,
-0.1591905653476715,
-0.6192482113838196,
-0.5343574285507202,
0.20744679868221283,
-0.46465182304382324,
-0.44837647676467896,
-0.7512856721878052,
-0.5800836682319641,
-0.24991050362586975,
-0.21441586315631866,
-0.28648653626441956,
0.05102807655930519,
-0.6393401026725769,
-0.06823895871639252,
0.21004962921142578,
0.5587461590766907,
0.48030102252960205,
0.29637983441352844,
-0.992071270942688,
0.46600255370140076,
0.28417089581489563,
0.483462929725647,
0.051097482442855835,
-0.12606240808963776,
-0.12035147845745087,
-0.03895498812198639,
-0.15786822140216827,
-0.9059364795684814,
0.6755469441413879,
0.03199981153011322,
0.24770064651966095,
0.6732950806617737,
-0.12777382135391235,
0.38062793016433716,
-0.48789095878601074,
0.7037688493728638,
0.5561651587486267,
-0.634523868560791,
0.5302335619926453,
-0.1773359626531601,
0.020645182579755783,
0.6556724905967712,
0.45500117540359497,
-0.5283342003822327,
-0.25442084670066833,
-0.3905678689479828,
-0.5023855566978455,
0.2710694670677185,
-0.02796260081231594,
0.3565019965171814,
-0.17519021034240723,
0.42874372005462646,
0.41292688250541687,
0.23611409962177277,
-0.5496382117271423,
-0.19813503324985504,
-0.2257293164730072,
-0.9672183990478516,
0.04527514427900314,
-0.33886533975601196,
0.0951414555311203,
-0.6518061757087708,
0.39853209257125854,
-0.10463054478168488,
0.5596559643745422,
0.540486752986908,
0.02931327000260353,
0.1670544147491455,
0.12936227023601532,
0.27562254667282104,
0.10466960817575455,
-0.232737198472023,
-0.026262130588293076,
0.16633953154087067,
-0.7579138875007629,
-0.20501278340816498,
0.19603805243968964,
0.036557190120220184,
0.31113922595977783,
0.42861515283584595,
0.8268968462944031,
-0.028486603870987892,
-0.45787233114242554,
0.9320371150970459,
-0.2796325385570526,
-0.1216464713215828,
-0.18565386533737183,
-0.1795523464679718,
0.12075413018465042,
0.21159732341766357,
0.06423097103834152,
0.5570752620697021,
0.41489145159721375,
-0.1615331918001175,
0.09034444391727448,
0.5322316288948059,
-1.0750569105148315,
-0.3130102753639221,
0.4246782660484314,
0.3255314826965332,
-0.13791291415691376,
0.9508888721466064,
0.11809732764959335,
-0.61050945520401,
0.7034233808517456,
0.19019797444343567,
1.063359260559082,
0.012967427261173725,
0.4584275782108307,
0.15666136145591736,
-0.015841316431760788,
0.25150105357170105,
0.3573604226112366,
0.3262157440185547,
-0.6583808064460754,
-0.5530927181243896,
-0.7192233800888062,
-0.25270628929138184,
-0.07556872814893723,
-0.6282919049263,
0.28927361965179443,
-0.44681844115257263,
-0.4861246645450592,
-0.026934776455163956,
0.09992897510528564,
-0.977102518081665,
0.9739648699760437,
0.47787541151046753,
0.6340730786323547,
-0.5288883447647095,
0.9175191521644592,
0.6891944408416748,
-0.28779852390289307,
-0.49611231684684753,
-0.047642163932323456,
-0.3731507360935211,
-0.9803339242935181,
0.6672599911689758,
0.3271743953227997,
-0.0017332311253994703,
-0.3583424985408783,
-0.6433049440383911,
-0.1861133724451065,
0.6236717700958252,
-0.008673000149428844,
-0.7424219846725464,
-0.11974354833364487,
0.25986233353614807,
1.1120777130126953,
-0.5459503531455994,
0.09420401602983475,
0.38235121965408325,
0.04211069270968437,
-0.029394712299108505,
-0.5391173362731934,
0.010116606019437313,
-0.2834049463272095,
-0.19984261691570282,
-0.09027589857578278,
-0.5237545371055603,
0.9312762022018433,
-0.12395860254764557,
0.15507285296916962,
-0.1771613508462906,
0.46403199434280396,
-0.12935318052768707,
0.24930138885974884,
0.2888922095298767,
0.5962012410163879,
0.6313228607177734,
-0.0013945747632533312,
1.2108447551727295,
-0.07154890894889832,
0.5381444096565247,
0.5660498738288879,
-0.2350979447364807,
0.7399780750274658,
0.35422101616859436,
-0.2334904968738556,
0.7769991755485535,
0.4710673987865448,
-0.20667041838169098,
0.5745369791984558,
-0.063773512840271,
-0.32185009121894836,
-0.30404290556907654,
0.17606830596923828,
-0.5476340055465698,
0.40950632095336914,
0.3262403607368469,
-1.0358034372329712,
-0.053459443151950836,
0.3660394847393036,
0.09071467071771622,
-0.17997179925441742,
-0.22684821486473083,
0.9777948260307312,
0.41250714659690857,
-0.4120255410671234,
0.2504032850265503,
-0.07750415056943893,
0.6516733169555664,
-0.39309990406036377,
0.20887622237205505,
-0.10495609790086746,
0.41779595613479614,
-0.11865624785423279,
-0.8063864707946777,
0.28393346071243286,
-0.14138983190059662,
-0.18891750276088715,
-0.19074706733226776,
0.916300356388092,
-0.07185998558998108,
-0.9465131759643555,
0.4792715609073639,
0.36476778984069824,
-0.08963716775178909,
-0.012147164903581142,
-0.7924367785453796,
-0.13117164373397827,
0.04493473842740059,
-0.28898710012435913,
0.20714198052883148,
0.49538975954055786,
0.4235548973083496,
0.30881908535957336,
0.5770530104637146,
0.2846265733242035,
-0.3496541380882263,
0.5641899108886719,
0.9822713732719421,
-0.7034459710121155,
-0.32056501507759094,
-1.2062959671020508,
0.5861475467681885,
-0.2905203104019165,
-0.280282586812973,
0.3321278989315033,
0.32142144441604614,
0.2145276516675949,
-0.35108962655067444,
0.7384946346282959,
0.22943668067455292,
0.6122639179229736,
-0.2886212170124054,
1.26016104221344,
-0.5583814978599548,
-0.08278719335794449,
-0.21551252901554108,
-0.14978229999542236,
-0.8199775218963623,
0.5840643644332886,
-0.1079595685005188,
-0.050490602850914,
0.6169212460517883,
0.2341313362121582,
0.13737167418003082,
0.30545809864997864,
0.2565959393978119,
0.2868686318397522,
0.2677062749862671,
0.5066191554069519,
0.5826110243797302,
-0.5339097380638123,
0.11055310815572739,
-0.23262828588485718,
-0.015099974349141121,
-0.48217424750328064,
-0.7443150877952576,
-1.0892000198364258,
-0.2483787089586258,
-0.31974896788597107,
-0.45737409591674805,
-0.14480258524417877,
0.8772518634796143,
0.6845803260803223,
-0.9287129640579224,
0.3164807856082916,
-0.02267332375049591,
-0.04541965201497078,
-0.13314656913280487,
-0.16962125897407532,
0.7271151542663574,
-0.6495150923728943,
-0.4654058814048767,
0.05205836519598961,
0.3201785683631897,
0.06223994866013527,
-0.09922491014003754,
0.057234667241573334,
0.130670964717865,
0.11568554490804672,
0.8818161487579346,
-0.317017525434494,
-0.38823461532592773,
-0.14297813177108765,
0.23582656681537628,
-0.48893144726753235,
0.46186795830726624,
0.846455991268158,
-1.0441828966140747,
0.654283344745636,
0.3867420554161072,
0.7628015279769897,
0.20321644842624664,
-0.2104114294052124,
0.45214229822158813,
-0.5807564854621887,
-0.0755043551325798,
0.7424169778823853,
0.4550822079181671,
0.38309571146965027,
-0.46410953998565674,
0.03838688135147095,
0.0329861119389534,
-0.5054928660392761,
-0.5928270816802979,
-0.08868080377578735,
-1.0835777521133423,
-0.5006062984466553,
0.882870078086853,
0.0955960750579834,
-0.100973941385746,
-0.0028890057001262903,
-0.4527531862258911,
0.5156862735748291,
-0.06228567659854889,
0.8369179368019104,
0.2769581079483032,
-0.24934789538383484,
0.10027601569890976,
-0.4832904636859894,
0.5878496766090393,
0.593529999256134,
-0.6574566960334778,
-0.4080618917942047,
-0.003009906504303217,
0.0383860319852829,
-0.0016609261510893703,
0.3853212893009186,
-0.4108041524887085,
0.007680514361709356,
-0.467080682516098,
0.1638425588607788,
0.04132767394185066,
-0.18185459077358246,
-0.5409405827522278,
0.39190474152565,
-0.21385720372200012,
-0.5134351253509521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10501v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10501v1
|
Self-Supervised Visual Preference Alignment
| 2024-04-16T12:19:54 | 2024-04-16T12:19:54 |
Ke Zhu, Liang Zhao, Zheng Ge, Xiangyu Zhang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper makes the first attempt towards unsupervised preference alignment
in Vision-Language Models (VLMs). We generate chosen and rejected responses
with regard to the original and augmented image pairs, and conduct preference
alignment with direct preference optimization. It is based on a core idea:
properly designed augmentation to the image input will induce VLM to generate
false but hard negative responses, which helps the model to learn from and
produce more robust and powerful answers. The whole pipeline no longer hinges
on supervision from GPT4 or human involvement during alignment, and is highly
efficient with few lines of code. With only 8k randomly sampled unsupervised
data, it achieves 90\% relative score to GPT-4 on complex reasoning in
LLaVA-Bench, and improves LLaVA-7B/13B by 6.7\%/5.6\% score on complex
multi-modal benchmark MM-Vet. Visualizations shows its improved ability to
align with user-intentions. A series of ablations are firmly conducted to
reveal the latent mechanism of the approach, which also indicates its potential
towards further scaling. Code will be available.
|
[
-0.5196282863616943,
-0.38327714800834656,
0.558259904384613,
-0.08794338256120682,
-0.45937827229499817,
-0.25453612208366394,
-0.07029827684164047,
-0.36073726415634155,
0.3381509780883789,
0.7229166626930237,
-0.5579355359077454,
-0.3574331998825073,
-0.27155083417892456,
-0.06382397562265396,
-0.13401003181934357,
0.8270438313484192,
0.022409388795495033,
0.146183580160141,
-0.4247008264064789,
-0.2580585479736328,
-0.4452475905418396,
-0.5330551862716675,
-0.08094534277915955,
-0.09389256685972214,
0.5437389016151428,
0.49651044607162476,
0.5921077728271484,
0.8801976442337036,
0.7008008360862732,
0.3400847315788269,
0.22334085404872894,
0.2691704034805298,
-0.5200783014297485,
0.07800772786140442,
-0.27327385544776917,
-0.23964589834213257,
-0.6288108229637146,
-0.05487852543592453,
0.16533923149108887,
0.2681833505630493,
-0.08173884451389313,
0.26459893584251404,
0.14741787314414978,
1.0210896730422974,
-0.5688907504081726,
-0.06101786717772484,
-0.6439167261123657,
-0.05518361181020737,
-0.26254701614379883,
-0.2509371042251587,
-0.2680678963661194,
-0.052047502249479294,
0.08058405667543411,
-0.6224309802055359,
0.08789270371198654,
0.23429718613624573,
0.7759893536567688,
0.6202578544616699,
-0.4315449893474579,
0.22497642040252686,
-0.44729164242744446,
0.8838404417037964,
-0.4505152106285095,
0.32281991839408875,
0.12411843240261078,
0.3269708752632141,
0.05527670681476593,
-0.5189409852027893,
-0.42243334650993347,
0.0917782187461853,
-0.09448336064815521,
0.3116602301597595,
-0.12761397659778595,
0.1332801878452301,
0.1760362982749939,
0.3278268575668335,
-0.6942725777626038,
0.17945311963558197,
-0.42482027411460876,
-0.2237289994955063,
0.7533023357391357,
0.24028602242469788,
-0.009112095460295677,
-0.17277689278125763,
-0.6579657196998596,
-0.10854116082191467,
-0.49420076608657837,
0.27917882800102234,
0.3986263573169708,
0.15869592130184174,
-0.03596198558807373,
1.0138118267059326,
-0.5182014107704163,
1.044233798980713,
0.5758857131004333,
0.0019317870028316975,
0.5266267657279968,
-0.6114720106124878,
-0.43741101026535034,
0.0721454918384552,
0.8016085624694824,
1.090335488319397,
0.4156716763973236,
0.2597843408584595,
-0.11345898360013962,
0.32128044962882996,
0.5244852304458618,
-0.3748123347759247,
-0.2820933163166046,
0.10779161006212234,
-0.41670557856559753,
-0.5425348281860352,
-0.24834996461868286,
-0.6891642808914185,
-0.3562439978122711,
-0.8873549103736877,
0.28441646695137024,
-0.11517611891031265,
-0.09784460812807083,
0.1158696711063385,
0.15651848912239075,
0.5069867968559265,
0.6797248721122742,
-1.1807984113693237,
0.043819837272167206,
0.4405593276023865,
0.3943338096141815,
-0.6520429849624634,
-0.37752121686935425,
-0.38040632009506226,
0.03789597377181053,
-0.34986504912376404,
0.8234343528747559,
-0.32098013162612915,
-0.21661821007728577,
-0.1417866051197052,
0.015309356153011322,
0.27216726541519165,
-0.29717451333999634,
0.4446808695793152,
-0.26788100600242615,
0.32808545231819153,
-0.4289100170135498,
-0.46163952350616455,
0.04229363426566124,
0.3587985038757324,
-0.28464967012405396,
0.9426335096359253,
0.007083599455654621,
-0.9092168211936951,
0.625498354434967,
-0.5380386114120483,
0.03138089179992676,
-0.018051842227578163,
-0.4644252061843872,
-0.32468172907829285,
0.0962691381573677,
0.7553419470787048,
0.3474724590778351,
0.08593787997961044,
0.24304047226905823,
-0.7093839645385742,
-0.14013980329036713,
0.07699072360992432,
-0.3437415361404419,
0.663408100605011,
0.13830694556236267,
-0.24603070318698883,
0.6274656653404236,
-0.6009001731872559,
0.21848136186599731,
0.21556439995765686,
0.16629287600517273,
-0.4610949754714966,
-0.2335737645626068,
-0.11401606351137161,
0.19867107272148132,
0.743786633014679,
-0.5123872756958008,
0.582006573677063,
-0.397405207157135,
0.0069241574965417385,
1.2095543146133423,
-0.3403047025203705,
0.6909877061843872,
0.1282075196504593,
0.26440751552581787,
0.08585197478532791,
0.7799705862998962,
0.22028349339962006,
-0.3684169352054596,
-0.800443708896637,
-0.137136772274971,
0.09126046299934387,
0.30361267924308777,
-0.5932789444923401,
0.4181865155696869,
-0.09338923543691635,
-0.28275957703590393,
-0.7640323638916016,
0.35014569759368896,
0.4527663290500641,
0.9421312212944031,
0.521828830242157,
-0.47538429498672485,
-0.6074238419532776,
-1.3627653121948242,
0.0048877522349357605,
-0.15980732440948486,
0.28782182931900024,
0.38992610573768616,
0.09729275852441788,
-0.31329917907714844,
1.1404880285263062,
-0.6370944976806641,
-0.32209014892578125,
0.14853616058826447,
-0.29376935958862305,
0.14749303460121155,
0.4737596809864044,
0.7625583410263062,
-0.851584792137146,
-0.4902275800704956,
0.1368178427219391,
-0.9209882020950317,
-0.21803835034370422,
0.4192829132080078,
-0.42293205857276917,
0.3987036645412445,
0.23532910645008087,
-0.13269001245498657,
0.6059108972549438,
0.624582827091217,
-0.2579882740974426,
0.5512998104095459,
-0.31348544359207153,
0.147338405251503,
-0.9316619038581848,
-0.17871949076652527,
0.19882386922836304,
-0.25042444467544556,
-0.47474339604377747,
-0.14934200048446655,
0.1817401945590973,
0.2901357412338257,
-0.520038366317749,
0.628002941608429,
-0.43262410163879395,
-0.3223908543586731,
-0.2568240761756897,
-0.05792532488703728,
-0.12012818455696106,
0.6588284969329834,
0.24274522066116333,
0.7945783138275146,
0.6809064149856567,
-0.28709790110588074,
0.575104832649231,
0.46202564239501953,
-0.12719090282917023,
0.8278435468673706,
-0.5083590745925903,
0.23331621289253235,
-0.08718869835138321,
-0.23308725655078888,
-1.1430034637451172,
-0.11312269419431686,
0.3475586175918579,
-0.38303279876708984,
0.3428042232990265,
-0.2749743163585663,
0.02529427595436573,
-0.4627710282802582,
-0.3198668658733368,
0.4125206172466278,
0.44344863295555115,
-0.8172771334648132,
0.43776214122772217,
0.4511415660381317,
0.15648937225341797,
-0.9345579147338867,
-0.491396427154541,
-0.029150711372494698,
-0.2945803105831146,
-0.6254259943962097,
0.1493852585554123,
-0.29535558819770813,
-0.22025629878044128,
-0.04173767939209938,
-0.14176620543003082,
0.2089516818523407,
-0.2901346683502197,
0.3774005174636841,
0.6655924320220947,
-0.20284175872802734,
-0.09837611019611359,
-0.25445568561553955,
-0.2780405879020691,
-0.32284682989120483,
-0.31512680649757385,
0.40671175718307495,
-0.47679662704467773,
-0.5773091316223145,
-0.28216496109962463,
0.24506649374961853,
0.4659099876880646,
-0.41192352771759033,
0.0266850758343935,
0.6424825191497803,
0.12151675671339035,
0.4063822031021118,
-0.7819399237632751,
-0.03298425301909447,
-0.5145690441131592,
0.11401699483394623,
-0.3995918333530426,
-0.9267346262931824,
0.16407588124275208,
0.24483539164066315,
0.005215722601860762,
0.4024460017681122,
0.7398240566253662,
-0.517400860786438,
1.3738688230514526,
0.7216455936431885,
-0.09785748273134232,
0.5639002919197083,
-0.02510261908173561,
0.20911040902137756,
-0.9511591196060181,
-0.20131346583366394,
0.00787291768938303,
-0.2928037643432617,
-0.7239443063735962,
-0.19175465404987335,
0.3551366925239563,
-0.08428260684013367,
-0.21046185493469238,
0.12275061011314392,
-0.9569186568260193,
0.3632162809371948,
0.8045255541801453,
0.1301966905593872,
0.0859048068523407,
0.24790260195732117,
-0.05182885006070137,
-0.440618634223938,
-0.41566237807273865,
-0.31156402826309204,
1.2341463565826416,
0.14067219197750092,
0.9742613434791565,
-0.037980832159519196,
0.7911763191223145,
0.2487785816192627,
0.18670015037059784,
-0.7479503750801086,
0.5110408067703247,
-0.10867653787136078,
-0.39679157733917236,
-0.5449934005737305,
0.00033135840203613043,
-0.7182419896125793,
0.387588769197464,
-0.3306419253349304,
-0.7880645990371704,
0.29445523023605347,
0.632857620716095,
-0.16093328595161438,
-0.10631001740694046,
-0.8574633598327637,
1.0229560136795044,
-0.7624630928039551,
-0.6795889735221863,
0.22410304844379425,
-0.8827837109565735,
0.41565898060798645,
-0.019017985090613365,
-0.16784988343715668,
0.00877924170345068,
0.12516872584819794,
0.37885549664497375,
-0.3194631040096283,
0.8126513361930847,
-0.16560442745685577,
0.08542917668819427,
0.022309286519885063,
-0.1827879697084427,
0.31783315539360046,
-0.23286744952201843,
0.30817049741744995,
0.15827183425426483,
-0.11538471281528473,
-0.42995765805244446,
-0.789695143699646,
0.749580979347229,
-0.7218047976493835,
-0.943015992641449,
-0.40514400601387024,
-0.36229363083839417,
-0.2688961923122406,
0.2802075147628784,
0.252286821603775,
0.3013503849506378,
0.04804876446723938,
0.10303369909524918,
0.5386872291564941,
0.1919182986021042,
0.24986602365970612,
0.47557464241981506,
-0.7563371658325195,
-0.6623044013977051,
0.8444457054138184,
-0.09477641433477402,
0.2642399072647095,
0.22756722569465637,
0.2720191180706024,
-0.6727722883224487,
-0.59196537733078,
-0.6498783826828003,
0.19772714376449585,
-0.732820451259613,
-0.12094186246395111,
-0.528626561164856,
-0.027477800846099854,
-0.629942774772644,
-0.40378668904304504,
-0.5383896231651306,
-0.15991508960723877,
-0.2772335708141327,
-0.21933098137378693,
0.32553166151046753,
0.6136895418167114,
-0.13684141635894775,
0.08723459392786026,
-0.2944415211677551,
0.2933683395385742,
0.640461802482605,
0.23754434287548065,
-0.524818480014801,
-0.434573769569397,
0.0574173703789711,
-0.009959224611520767,
-0.13089123368263245,
-0.6525855660438538,
0.5113961100578308,
-0.31820014119148254,
0.5844756960868835,
0.6413265466690063,
-0.01786981336772442,
0.9804328083992004,
-0.3703736364841461,
0.8130239248275757,
0.5018313527107239,
-0.6827008724212646,
0.6692277789115906,
-0.3086855113506317,
0.12445519864559174,
0.6358636617660522,
0.03890515863895416,
-0.023063914850354195,
0.01108937244862318,
-0.549957811832428,
-0.7011378407478333,
0.4619015157222748,
0.05891266465187073,
-0.17139706015586853,
0.2945697605609894,
0.2218015193939209,
0.030665630474686623,
0.26801130175590515,
-0.6733499765396118,
-0.47777822613716125,
-0.5749322772026062,
-0.2848581075668335,
-0.35441792011260986,
-0.4245125949382782,
-0.3296331465244293,
-0.6101974844932556,
0.5904962420463562,
-0.5024417042732239,
0.0001423677458660677,
0.28501781821250916,
0.05888687074184418,
-0.15307867527008057,
-0.009418913163244724,
0.8247702717781067,
0.6089745163917542,
-0.3224286735057831,
0.1981976181268692,
-0.04994793236255646,
-0.1494358330965042,
0.15057049691677094,
-0.24881890416145325,
-0.1662156730890274,
-0.42799824476242065,
-0.07431235909461975,
1.0068706274032593,
-0.1305605173110962,
-0.21059101819992065,
0.8375670313835144,
-0.2710632085800171,
-0.26595520973205566,
-0.23857198655605316,
-0.0069089545868337154,
-0.15031211078166962,
0.29539960622787476,
0.05381237715482712,
0.28286612033843994,
0.2549285888671875,
-0.24733465909957886,
0.2632896900177002,
0.8093932271003723,
-0.7156206369400024,
-0.06884518265724182,
0.6480600833892822,
0.12149004638195038,
-0.022101327776908875,
0.3490835428237915,
0.10529354959726334,
-0.4269641935825348,
0.3191862106323242,
0.5202797055244446,
0.6338434815406799,
-0.1490665227174759,
0.17628216743469238,
0.28955933451652527,
0.18551546335220337,
0.038432102650403976,
0.1685652732849121,
-0.09846986085176468,
-0.8935805559158325,
-0.3511853516101837,
-0.5993533730506897,
-0.3152795732021332,
0.011402586475014687,
-0.7442798614501953,
0.282682329416275,
-0.10348125547170639,
-0.1855882853269577,
-0.018902665004134178,
-0.1596943438053131,
-0.6905533671379089,
0.3595731258392334,
0.14548158645629883,
0.41417983174324036,
-0.8608922362327576,
0.8967013359069824,
0.7289733290672302,
-0.3958703279495239,
-0.7184390425682068,
-0.3336086571216583,
0.21454955637454987,
-1.2925777435302734,
0.7461093068122864,
-0.01862763799726963,
-0.2711564004421234,
-0.015444251708686352,
-0.8979344367980957,
-1.0125354528427124,
0.902975857257843,
0.301566481590271,
-0.6543375253677368,
0.19023047387599945,
-0.16671225428581238,
0.5556078553199768,
-0.47611966729164124,
0.1159287616610527,
0.38942453265190125,
0.5210519433021545,
0.2543350160121918,
-0.9655293226242065,
-0.29319310188293457,
-0.3440691828727722,
0.017465533688664436,
0.1777842938899994,
-0.6489711999893188,
0.5381055474281311,
-0.32253298163414,
0.1961314082145691,
-0.17241276800632477,
0.7371916770935059,
0.12195432186126709,
0.27667683362960815,
0.5935912728309631,
0.71224445104599,
0.4620746374130249,
0.032748784869909286,
0.9272865056991577,
-0.20336933434009552,
0.2845948338508606,
1.2041163444519043,
-0.3458980917930603,
0.5728376507759094,
1.0433226823806763,
-0.16002397239208221,
0.001801020698621869,
0.7538305521011353,
-0.05206264182925224,
0.7715949416160583,
-0.235836461186409,
0.18641100823879242,
-0.5736003518104553,
-0.17656803131103516,
-0.47669148445129395,
0.6694719195365906,
0.018686441704630852,
-0.32088354229927063,
0.06611664593219757,
-0.14815887808799744,
-0.4748001992702484,
0.01427196804434061,
-0.3270058035850525,
0.913726806640625,
-0.08171353489160538,
-0.7047626376152039,
0.5774049758911133,
-0.5799798965454102,
0.7357960343360901,
-0.4299274981021881,
0.08390669524669647,
-0.18728071451187134,
0.10179463773965836,
-0.33329516649246216,
-1.1045588254928589,
-0.057345014065504074,
-0.1837271749973297,
-0.21184231340885162,
-0.2526499927043915,
0.8781466484069824,
-0.45837149024009705,
-0.45166927576065063,
0.19563621282577515,
0.5158641338348389,
-0.002917660865932703,
0.07798870652914047,
-0.7325218319892883,
-0.05169350281357765,
0.5005508065223694,
-0.2236751914024353,
0.5070621967315674,
0.09105449169874191,
-0.18528950214385986,
0.4942263066768646,
0.7129137516021729,
-0.010619843378663063,
0.07815248519182205,
0.13904011249542236,
0.861721396446228,
-0.46544110774993896,
-0.3385051488876343,
-0.8650640249252319,
0.5611635446548462,
-0.40789687633514404,
-0.29105788469314575,
0.7446609139442444,
0.5447118282318115,
0.9428257346153259,
-0.25991740822792053,
0.7566589117050171,
0.2971232831478119,
0.18605250120162964,
-0.6169729828834534,
0.1739797592163086,
-0.8217846155166626,
-0.09424743801355362,
-0.39362815022468567,
-0.9849364757537842,
-0.3841775953769684,
0.5675488114356995,
-0.5348581075668335,
-0.20413611829280853,
0.4440929591655731,
0.8692346215248108,
-0.15295353531837463,
-0.37826040387153625,
0.6305631995201111,
-0.21536357700824738,
0.17209511995315552,
0.28659775853157043,
0.8356465101242065,
-0.04906419664621353,
0.2658512592315674,
-0.5335264205932617,
-0.3532007932662964,
-0.4452669620513916,
-0.924278736114502,
-0.6611770391464233,
-0.6625595688819885,
-0.3114987909793854,
-0.2593787610530853,
-0.07315753400325775,
0.8772069215774536,
0.5740630626678467,
-0.5946282148361206,
-0.07265718281269073,
0.07683928310871124,
-0.09076448529958725,
-0.09372062981128693,
-0.15238149464130402,
0.36710870265960693,
-0.11444041132926941,
-0.6060203313827515,
0.25568991899490356,
0.6013323068618774,
0.37176358699798584,
-0.4357001483440399,
-0.28750935196876526,
0.14028958976268768,
-0.20424284040927887,
0.49669578671455383,
0.3288770020008087,
-1.0898231267929077,
-0.48733535408973694,
0.1903146207332611,
-0.2511458098888397,
0.6072134375572205,
0.4640160799026489,
-0.571858823299408,
0.9808278679847717,
0.3753436505794525,
0.37063533067703247,
0.559032142162323,
0.4121299982070923,
0.5488636493682861,
-0.5405978560447693,
0.10160183906555176,
-0.03525249660015106,
0.5896291732788086,
0.46359673142433167,
-0.42315468192100525,
0.6334607601165771,
0.15165865421295166,
-0.6489439010620117,
-0.6338484287261963,
0.42734795808792114,
-1.5110214948654175,
0.13250519335269928,
1.1568750143051147,
0.3100925087928772,
-0.4167775809764862,
0.14397375285625458,
-0.7869117856025696,
0.07590139657258987,
-0.39189231395721436,
0.6191540956497192,
0.3676089644432068,
-0.4919343590736389,
-0.2124864012002945,
-0.19266462326049805,
0.5038221478462219,
0.457758367061615,
-0.5339921712875366,
-0.01431199163198471,
0.7615396976470947,
0.3150634169578552,
0.10484791547060013,
0.9544603824615479,
-0.15094241499900818,
0.14334505796432495,
-0.35913407802581787,
0.5454457402229309,
-0.22846731543540955,
-0.2592200040817261,
-0.48041829466819763,
-0.019767193123698235,
0.17953284084796906,
-0.4694887101650238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10500v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10500v1
|
When Emotional Stimuli meet Prompt Designing: An Auto-Prompt Graphical Paradigm
| 2024-04-16T12:19:08 | 2024-04-16T12:19:08 |
Chenggian Ma, Xiangyu Zhao, Chunhui Zhang, Yanzhao Qin, Wentao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T20, I.2.7
|
With the development of Large Language Models (LLM), numerous prompts have
been proposed, each with a rich set of features and their own merits. This
paper summarizes the prompt words for large language models (LLMs),
categorizing them into stimulating and framework types, and proposes an
Auto-Prompt Graphical Paradigm(APGP) that combines both stimulating and
framework prompts to enhance the problem-solving capabilities of LLMs across
multiple domains, then exemplifies it with a framework that adheres to this
paradigm. The framework involves automated prompt generation and consideration
of emotion-stimulus factors, guiding LLMs in problem abstraction, diversified
solutions generation, comprehensive optimization, and self-verification after
providing answers, ensuring solution accuracy. Compared to traditional stimuli
and framework prompts, this framework integrates the advantages of both by
adopting automated approaches inspired by APE work, overcoming the limitations
of manually designed prompts. Test results on the ruozhiba and BBH datasets
demonstrate that this framework can effectively improve the efficiency and
accuracy of LLMs in problem-solving, paving the way for new applications of
LLMs.
|
[
-0.7342435121536255,
-1.0126789808273315,
0.7493216395378113,
0.7883280515670776,
-0.1088632196187973,
-0.09292466193437576,
-0.20024096965789795,
-0.3514494299888611,
0.06902244687080383,
0.19587291777133942,
-0.840836763381958,
-0.25263863801956177,
-0.4117303192615509,
0.8153205513954163,
-0.11154820770025253,
0.5535241961479187,
-0.30113691091537476,
-0.12632523477077484,
-0.08768410235643387,
0.03570718318223953,
-0.5567741394042969,
-0.4590737521648407,
-0.7491856813430786,
-0.2230774164199829,
0.7149541974067688,
0.33742666244506836,
0.657011091709137,
0.8382088541984558,
0.21843673288822174,
0.38233309984207153,
0.12342304736375809,
0.0897572785615921,
0.055560361593961716,
0.3914044499397278,
0.039603523910045624,
-0.24018603563308716,
-0.458418607711792,
-0.06182359531521797,
0.23659221827983856,
0.5879290699958801,
-0.14413122832775116,
-0.08187578618526459,
0.06061221659183502,
0.6064390540122986,
-0.39395055174827576,
0.4631810188293457,
-0.13624577224254608,
0.23900535702705383,
0.16397301852703094,
-0.3478996455669403,
-0.4974134564399719,
-0.18023952841758728,
0.11375398933887482,
-0.5463489294052124,
-0.16477884352207184,
0.35224348306655884,
0.5472551584243774,
0.3370649218559265,
-0.48182564973831177,
-0.376709908246994,
-0.15840858221054077,
0.40420010685920715,
-0.5939749479293823,
0.06352382898330688,
-0.08604489266872406,
0.08283555507659912,
-0.5072643756866455,
-0.2268458902835846,
-0.5527017712593079,
-0.3419121503829956,
-0.105951227247715,
-0.11786948144435883,
-0.4457490146160126,
0.19905860722064972,
0.4436081051826477,
0.15894047915935516,
-0.724279522895813,
0.37676990032196045,
0.15559762716293335,
-0.07924836128950119,
0.7402342557907104,
0.5673390626907349,
0.6570600271224976,
-0.3261859714984894,
-0.33217373490333557,
-0.036522332578897476,
-0.7556928396224976,
-0.03553898632526398,
0.16593748331069946,
0.4574621915817261,
-0.2644703984260559,
0.4839843809604645,
-0.23185856640338898,
1.0018110275268555,
0.2638569474220276,
-0.01197575218975544,
0.11423224955797195,
0.11848105490207672,
-0.21213524043560028,
-0.09085243195295334,
0.9907820224761963,
0.37181928753852844,
0.3423948585987091,
0.2595261037349701,
-0.465750128030777,
0.17864234745502472,
-0.15787196159362793,
-0.796202540397644,
-0.17718292772769928,
0.3253316879272461,
-0.6107855439186096,
-0.2581177353858948,
-0.5276349782943726,
-0.8472287654876709,
-0.6256078481674194,
-0.6712822318077087,
0.21369148790836334,
-0.318403035402298,
-0.32187730073928833,
0.0774841383099556,
-0.02281072363257408,
0.11134988814592361,
0.5066606998443604,
-0.913560152053833,
-0.12351960688829422,
0.46846136450767517,
0.7927353382110596,
-0.3421930968761444,
-0.15084204077720642,
-0.515853226184845,
-0.14745575189590454,
-0.4827384352684021,
0.9249705076217651,
-0.6705541014671326,
-0.6039652824401855,
0.2964487075805664,
-0.08916153013706207,
0.3581702411174774,
-0.332435667514801,
0.3728410601615906,
-0.2581225037574768,
0.34838101267814636,
-0.49977657198905945,
-0.37283775210380554,
-0.13245104253292084,
0.17549264430999756,
-0.617033064365387,
1.0829514265060425,
0.04523468390107155,
-0.4224873483181,
0.2709077000617981,
-0.898949146270752,
-0.3677217960357666,
0.39052751660346985,
-0.3540368378162384,
0.14915110170841217,
0.22029145061969757,
0.3147110342979431,
0.5613411068916321,
-0.509289562702179,
0.3376820683479309,
-0.33180803060531616,
0.05065588280558586,
0.22542569041252136,
-0.11318445950746536,
0.6799247860908508,
0.38417187333106995,
-0.45508334040641785,
0.4404238760471344,
-0.7181828022003174,
-0.010871275328099728,
0.3286459147930145,
-0.07551954686641693,
-0.1791428029537201,
-0.16202037036418915,
0.00031960205524228513,
0.6254655718803406,
0.26587629318237305,
-0.24538075923919678,
0.35388582944869995,
-0.11869000643491745,
0.44752833247184753,
0.961216151714325,
-0.1018856018781662,
0.334741473197937,
-0.14446544647216797,
0.802690863609314,
-0.03629671037197113,
-0.12380097061395645,
-0.7463155388832092,
-0.3677067756652832,
-0.6682848334312439,
-0.45985403656959534,
-0.18689186871051788,
0.4757959544658661,
-0.6564596891403198,
0.5489059686660767,
0.37258201837539673,
-0.3783451020717621,
-0.2067292481660843,
-0.09389059990644455,
0.1652524471282959,
0.6132855415344238,
0.22299906611442566,
-0.1341034173965454,
-0.46837854385375977,
-0.8374971747398376,
-0.08952195942401886,
-0.22076289355754852,
-0.00914898980408907,
0.5479110479354858,
0.3374873995780945,
-0.18414294719696045,
1.0380440950393677,
-0.5015241503715515,
0.013220718130469322,
-0.10515882074832916,
0.6410940885543823,
0.39541617035865784,
0.3282198905944824,
0.6865186095237732,
-0.6687877774238586,
-0.49646374583244324,
-0.43683138489723206,
-0.8540669679641724,
-0.8468289971351624,
-0.08219388127326965,
-0.035905275493860245,
0.3638264536857605,
0.4536244571208954,
-0.6639708280563354,
0.14046841859817505,
0.21759741008281708,
-0.589171290397644,
0.9238760471343994,
-0.10976094007492065,
0.15555551648139954,
-0.8008731603622437,
0.024152131751179695,
0.32726672291755676,
0.15053148567676544,
-0.3568303883075714,
0.03794393688440323,
-0.010960894636809826,
-0.6233795881271362,
-0.2530604302883148,
1.015584945678711,
-0.6905168294906616,
0.04224788770079613,
-0.607846736907959,
0.21815744042396545,
0.011538189835846424,
0.5110512375831604,
0.32593733072280884,
0.871738612651825,
0.7818759083747864,
-0.6879897713661194,
0.9417523741722107,
0.26337870955467224,
-0.11494392901659012,
0.998988687992096,
-0.8479365706443787,
0.02653373032808304,
-0.45778241753578186,
0.5350088477134705,
-1.1750150918960571,
-0.49659353494644165,
0.21605223417282104,
-0.10175324976444244,
0.26413023471832275,
0.2274751514196396,
-0.6494244933128357,
-0.6733053922653198,
-0.04981003329157829,
0.357241153717041,
0.5557979345321655,
-0.643426775932312,
0.7539610862731934,
0.12301795929670334,
-0.6895880103111267,
-0.3950836658477783,
-0.458405077457428,
0.3443366587162018,
-0.4281541705131531,
-0.7044870853424072,
0.25908324122428894,
-0.20744606852531433,
-0.24851201474666595,
-0.12575297057628632,
0.2739391326904297,
0.3925083875656128,
0.04017152264714241,
0.22834396362304688,
0.6071996092796326,
-0.06916327774524689,
0.3482881188392639,
-0.19327397644519806,
-0.3607073426246643,
0.37046319246292114,
-0.2352602779865265,
0.7667974233627319,
-0.11979397386312485,
-0.222657710313797,
-0.47417277097702026,
0.7822149395942688,
0.41072678565979004,
-0.36309167742729187,
0.2777590751647949,
0.4740195870399475,
-0.35351303219795227,
-0.2716277539730072,
-0.34740161895751953,
-0.10104014724493027,
-0.5747457146644592,
0.3689125180244446,
-0.5001971125602722,
-0.7728862166404724,
0.5338618159294128,
-0.1764046847820282,
0.17721331119537354,
0.10895705968141556,
0.9136542677879333,
0.06131092458963394,
1.5499061346054077,
0.8152015209197998,
-0.09430201351642609,
0.7841442823410034,
0.28830990195274353,
0.18122711777687073,
-0.6888744235038757,
-0.18818430602550507,
-0.5318923592567444,
-0.13952495157718658,
-0.3457900285720825,
-0.10913217067718506,
0.47108107805252075,
-0.06218486651778221,
-0.6072632074356079,
0.12608350813388824,
-0.7093399167060852,
0.24457532167434692,
0.1643603891134262,
-0.32963454723358154,
-0.026242444291710854,
-0.10441833734512329,
-0.387451708316803,
0.11565515398979187,
-0.79366135597229,
-0.5819807052612305,
0.6495006084442139,
0.32267478108406067,
0.8882479667663574,
-0.025555303320288658,
0.4704025685787201,
0.3227223753929138,
0.5680080056190491,
-0.8791199326515198,
0.7975602149963379,
0.33505451679229736,
-0.4492626488208771,
-0.229823499917984,
-0.321056067943573,
-0.8409535884857178,
0.14519621431827545,
-0.11717800050973892,
-0.9623429775238037,
0.3803677558898926,
0.32752230763435364,
-0.42658475041389465,
-0.23359879851341248,
-0.5165387392044067,
0.7190570831298828,
-0.46049603819847107,
-0.2753899395465851,
-0.02815880998969078,
-0.4803542494773865,
0.17539149522781372,
0.012867576442658901,
0.364004909992218,
-0.37697935104370117,
-0.27491194009780884,
0.5251535773277283,
-0.3455555737018585,
0.7130794525146484,
-0.1234319731593132,
-0.7064451575279236,
0.33082014322280884,
0.2913876175880432,
0.7082876563072205,
-0.13100774586200714,
-0.26262885332107544,
-0.501643180847168,
-0.526906430721283,
-0.20930880308151245,
-0.7455207705497742,
0.5482289791107178,
-0.4484124779701233,
-0.7583900094032288,
-0.3390751779079437,
-0.6190093755722046,
-0.32853466272354126,
0.10121580958366394,
0.22893254458904266,
0.7499138116836548,
-0.11937687546014786,
-0.41938021779060364,
0.7037258744239807,
-0.4279399514198303,
0.7024646997451782,
0.5992314219474792,
-0.4902714192867279,
-0.2903707027435303,
0.6591756939888,
-0.3222932815551758,
0.06487095355987549,
-0.054026685655117035,
0.014621163718402386,
-0.5346828103065491,
-0.09871084243059158,
-0.6857321858406067,
0.23444579541683197,
-0.9162580966949463,
-0.33783555030822754,
-0.6655005812644958,
0.15248849987983704,
-0.31996408104896545,
-0.43853268027305603,
0.1629544049501419,
0.010689923539757729,
-0.34176158905029297,
0.010480252094566822,
0.5581555962562561,
0.5078193545341492,
-0.2022886723279953,
0.20124457776546478,
-0.7543357610702515,
0.3230462372303009,
0.3265973627567291,
0.2873818278312683,
0.30286628007888794,
-0.3065921664237976,
0.16998620331287384,
-0.19050247967243195,
-0.11346571892499924,
-1.0428667068481445,
0.599982500076294,
0.05502288416028023,
0.43552061915397644,
0.46368324756622314,
0.09736677259206772,
0.45590025186538696,
-0.6376982927322388,
0.7935011386871338,
0.522128701210022,
-0.944177508354187,
0.5429163575172424,
-0.6652448177337646,
0.23668794333934784,
0.06133786961436272,
0.6014286279678345,
-0.7589545845985413,
-0.1630854606628418,
-0.49205508828163147,
-0.991304874420166,
0.6103803515434265,
-0.25328490138053894,
0.19366982579231262,
-0.29717329144477844,
0.30403581261634827,
0.10463426262140274,
0.25477951765060425,
-0.5544212460517883,
-0.35607069730758667,
-0.08072927594184875,
-0.5280249118804932,
0.10431864112615585,
-0.1811545193195343,
-0.2423464059829712,
-0.08563783764839172,
0.5424875617027283,
-0.4202285408973694,
0.6124008297920227,
0.16850675642490387,
0.025708112865686417,
-0.4542083144187927,
0.356373131275177,
0.16516666114330292,
0.3144480884075165,
0.2871125340461731,
-0.01796286553144455,
0.006658679805696011,
0.23018233478069305,
0.5821536779403687,
0.026464425027370453,
0.036217935383319855,
-0.14535517990589142,
0.23169435560703278,
0.9992274045944214,
-0.10246503353118896,
-0.7669903635978699,
0.26199766993522644,
0.05740031972527504,
0.06004999577999115,
-0.1572786569595337,
0.2980645000934601,
-0.06185790151357651,
0.26145875453948975,
0.6863673329353333,
-0.43707275390625,
0.25859299302101135,
-0.7802785634994507,
0.06178240105509758,
0.403909295797348,
-0.07135287672281265,
-0.10144400596618652,
0.6225773096084595,
0.54206383228302,
-0.5347753167152405,
0.480286180973053,
-0.3307456076145172,
-0.7148609161376953,
0.7617940306663513,
0.8963608145713806,
0.8200258016586304,
-0.29725465178489685,
0.24471770226955414,
0.30520692467689514,
-0.2712678015232086,
-0.12028224766254425,
0.4615360200405121,
-0.11178203672170639,
-0.4978479743003845,
-0.48324155807495117,
-0.49399277567863464,
-0.3178883492946625,
0.06773608922958374,
-0.4881666302680969,
0.4583997428417206,
-0.4537910223007202,
-0.1713283210992813,
0.06715921312570572,
-0.13670849800109863,
-0.5059602856636047,
0.44543007016181946,
0.5551027655601501,
1.0919519662857056,
-0.821593701839447,
0.15520943701267242,
0.8967201113700867,
-0.1694597750902176,
-0.9017137289047241,
-0.25636711716651917,
0.26307210326194763,
-0.7856318354606628,
0.7799718976020813,
0.3154001832008362,
-0.026366455480456352,
0.16987885534763336,
-0.7818611860275269,
-0.8081631064414978,
0.6569821834564209,
0.1650150865316391,
-0.5400595664978027,
-0.08257924020290375,
-0.10643705725669861,
0.48714837431907654,
-0.809708297252655,
0.45672616362571716,
0.4997788071632385,
0.6944410800933838,
0.08673218637704849,
-0.7451127171516418,
0.5031611919403076,
-0.6169232726097107,
0.04632548987865448,
0.2585630714893341,
-0.7922640442848206,
0.7683233618736267,
-0.2347407341003418,
-0.36464667320251465,
0.09893330186605453,
0.7488130927085876,
0.6037788987159729,
-0.07989971339702606,
0.6286208033561707,
0.1839708536863327,
0.6870054006576538,
-0.22844333946704865,
0.8710706233978271,
-0.5322876572608948,
0.08222905546426773,
0.6575008034706116,
-0.38215768337249756,
0.2879701256752014,
0.24243056774139404,
-0.12343708425760269,
0.7163017988204956,
1.0637956857681274,
-0.13489024341106415,
0.21705050766468048,
0.3402383625507355,
-0.2058575600385666,
-0.4581030607223511,
-0.3755472004413605,
-0.4792419373989105,
0.19495327770709991,
0.546667218208313,
-0.14062565565109253,
-0.2546807825565338,
0.2696647047996521,
0.029968004673719406,
-0.10806278884410858,
-0.4431164860725403,
0.6159000992774963,
0.3839937746524811,
-0.7886540293693542,
0.5521444082260132,
0.07805826514959335,
0.661704421043396,
-0.43668892979621887,
0.017890185117721558,
-0.247338205575943,
-0.40825536847114563,
-0.16652798652648926,
-0.7761593461036682,
-0.09370053559541702,
0.1582176238298416,
-0.011477217078208923,
-0.44500187039375305,
0.7036505341529846,
-0.3887200355529785,
-0.19184310734272003,
0.10724105685949326,
0.5195729732513428,
-0.09835238754749298,
0.13001443445682526,
-0.8822035193443298,
0.12200669199228287,
-0.40016794204711914,
-0.4116533696651459,
0.1628008335828781,
0.932326078414917,
-0.03531673178076744,
1.0330307483673096,
0.48719146847724915,
-0.053767308592796326,
-0.3773941099643707,
-0.17570562660694122,
0.8307290077209473,
-0.7553151249885559,
-0.970420241355896,
-0.9586387872695923,
0.4490961730480194,
-0.06061369553208351,
-0.3142293095588684,
0.49156245589256287,
0.007837329991161823,
0.026608075946569443,
-0.009813628159463406,
0.8673538565635681,
-0.2989248037338257,
-0.028235729783773422,
-0.35204339027404785,
0.2630063593387604,
-0.6178199052810669,
0.06523022055625916,
-0.629037618637085,
-0.970851480960846,
-0.16646264493465424,
0.7706863284111023,
-0.3030966520309448,
0.1740458756685257,
0.5226653814315796,
0.6367216110229492,
0.34374725818634033,
0.17242684960365295,
-0.13556647300720215,
0.10632261633872986,
0.3061579763889313,
0.7946028709411621,
1.0835983753204346,
0.23802849650382996,
0.06766030937433243,
0.1666315793991089,
-0.5407719612121582,
-0.5484420657157898,
-1.2147750854492188,
-0.866015613079071,
-0.6391171216964722,
-0.4487884044647217,
-0.21184732019901276,
-0.20672185719013214,
1.4848781824111938,
0.47013911604881287,
-0.5338258743286133,
-0.17686831951141357,
-0.20673315227031708,
-0.017503125593066216,
0.037151820957660675,
-0.2640843093395233,
0.31135308742523193,
-0.6272706985473633,
-0.5798217058181763,
0.3169235587120056,
0.5433065891265869,
0.40362104773521423,
-0.43738630414009094,
0.02452891133725643,
0.3463151752948761,
0.3771617114543915,
0.5471763014793396,
0.30085307359695435,
-0.4470451772212982,
-0.1662633866071701,
0.01889016665518284,
-0.3267419934272766,
0.053448207676410675,
0.9301810264587402,
-0.8742905259132385,
0.21210841834545135,
0.5683130621910095,
0.34652402997016907,
-0.16316473484039307,
0.07875720411539078,
1.0847073793411255,
-0.34438472986221313,
0.34804514050483704,
0.2024877369403839,
0.6626256108283997,
0.30374106764793396,
-0.4943970739841461,
0.30786463618278503,
0.07141664624214172,
-0.45074036717414856,
-0.8883346319198608,
0.7155128121376038,
-0.6846588253974915,
-0.3621222674846649,
1.3353960514068604,
-0.23126064240932465,
-0.333453893661499,
-0.09208734333515167,
-0.5265139937400818,
0.09306135028600693,
-0.6246858239173889,
1.003220558166504,
0.9527081251144409,
-0.554267406463623,
-0.3411756157875061,
-0.06436055153608322,
0.6931861042976379,
0.643505871295929,
-1.0200680494308472,
0.3346737325191498,
0.8694522976875305,
-0.06574423611164093,
0.14502333104610443,
0.5390685796737671,
0.05464484915137291,
0.32406187057495117,
-0.2538706958293915,
0.0590912289917469,
-0.1676614135503769,
-0.40485042333602905,
-0.48224273324012756,
0.17307321727275848,
-0.010925340466201305,
0.40297022461891174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10475v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10475v1
|
Conversations as a Source for Teaching Scientific Concepts at Different Education Levels
| 2024-04-16T11:33:36 | 2024-04-16T11:33:36 |
Donya Rooein, Dirk Hovy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Open conversations are one of the most engaging forms of teaching. However,
creating those conversations in educational software is a complex endeavor,
especially if we want to address the needs of different audiences. While
language models hold great promise for educational applications, there are
substantial challenges in training them to engage in meaningful and effective
conversational teaching, especially when considering the diverse needs of
various audiences. No official data sets exist for this task to facilitate the
training of language models for conversational teaching, considering the
diverse needs of various audiences. This paper presents a novel source for
facilitating conversational teaching of scientific concepts at various
difficulty levels (from preschooler to expert), namely dialogues taken from
video transcripts. We analyse this data source in various ways to show that it
offers a diverse array of examples that can be used to generate contextually
appropriate and natural responses to scientific topics for specific target
audiences. It is a freely available valuable resource for training and
evaluating conversation models, encompassing organically occurring dialogues.
While the raw data is available online, we provide additional metadata for
conversational analysis of dialogues at each level in all available videos.
|
[
-0.29593801498413086,
-0.8487918376922607,
0.31234580278396606,
0.230290025472641,
-0.15434114634990692,
0.31829971075057983,
-0.1855335235595703,
-0.14024898409843445,
-0.056729529052972794,
0.21524353325366974,
-0.4726593494415283,
-0.5250188112258911,
-0.3291267156600952,
-0.08823393285274506,
-0.46484342217445374,
1.0818002223968506,
0.17095181345939636,
0.5844404101371765,
-0.4848954379558563,
-0.17677436769008636,
-0.2553398311138153,
-0.25551366806030273,
-0.4419850707054138,
0.07033370435237885,
0.3363400101661682,
0.5834493041038513,
0.5394036769866943,
0.3051131069660187,
0.6877039670944214,
0.2864570617675781,
-0.025316016748547554,
0.12084566056728363,
-0.5828428268432617,
0.2511170208454132,
-0.33323511481285095,
-0.3549775183200836,
0.20733323693275452,
-0.001211487571708858,
0.9025967121124268,
1.1685270071029663,
-0.3962800204753876,
0.20786738395690918,
0.08605626970529556,
0.353851854801178,
-0.2080180048942566,
0.33223944902420044,
-0.8012780547142029,
0.42185071110725403,
0.10567177832126617,
-0.3124277591705322,
-0.4344058632850647,
-0.4923839867115021,
0.4757540822029114,
-0.8407558798789978,
0.44869253039360046,
-0.24758802354335785,
0.5218294858932495,
0.22043509781360626,
-0.4484299123287201,
-0.6333914399147034,
-0.7933688163757324,
0.6557127833366394,
-0.6246331930160522,
0.36483004689216614,
0.2760489583015442,
0.26760542392730713,
-0.2441154271364212,
-0.6620517373085022,
-0.6129938364028931,
-0.4120770990848541,
0.19610577821731567,
0.07010191679000854,
0.04776863753795624,
0.10843421518802643,
0.08224516361951828,
0.3336423337459564,
-0.20814326405525208,
-0.14868178963661194,
-0.7192667722702026,
0.2062956541776657,
0.28679391741752625,
0.339191734790802,
0.31028950214385986,
-0.30082234740257263,
0.007511069066822529,
-0.27493205666542053,
-0.23227368295192719,
0.09593689441680908,
0.3972247540950775,
0.4240102469921112,
-0.2988026738166809,
0.6488437056541443,
0.10243426263332367,
0.8873358368873596,
-0.15427792072296143,
-0.19995319843292236,
-0.15252189338207245,
-0.3963034749031067,
0.12158400565385818,
-0.11535947024822235,
0.6361424922943115,
0.3598434627056122,
0.10153952240943909,
0.029405852779746056,
0.48618292808532715,
0.07656361162662506,
0.1433628797531128,
-1.0605111122131348,
-0.6490273475646973,
-0.012057425454258919,
0.138595312833786,
-0.3099488914012909,
0.10162832587957382,
-0.7710198163986206,
-0.2858937680721283,
-0.13298951089382172,
-0.23109403252601624,
-0.25719964504241943,
-0.024274185299873352,
0.058846939355134964,
-0.08286815881729126,
-0.07939404249191284,
0.3720758259296417,
-1.121413230895996,
0.49488309025764465,
0.39830052852630615,
1.0217050313949585,
-0.021094495430588722,
0.16213367879390717,
-0.3360110819339752,
0.224790558218956,
-0.3163931369781494,
0.5405625700950623,
-0.7970827221870422,
-0.6218349933624268,
-0.12264015525579453,
-0.19868823885917664,
-0.056384239345788956,
-0.26271095871925354,
0.23473197221755981,
-0.16623130440711975,
0.5860660076141357,
0.17989718914031982,
-0.4727957844734192,
-0.01891128532588482,
0.33269059658050537,
-0.416107177734375,
0.8076756596565247,
0.10299927741289139,
-0.7830039858818054,
0.12617403268814087,
-1.0024912357330322,
-0.05983101949095726,
0.26036256551742554,
-0.5937315821647644,
0.008544405922293663,
-0.26235049962997437,
0.03856430575251579,
0.3558414578437805,
-0.23617865145206451,
0.6706864833831787,
-0.26848191022872925,
0.3881751000881195,
0.4752478003501892,
-0.35949793457984924,
0.3800877034664154,
0.3744342029094696,
-0.08062441647052765,
0.19312120974063873,
-0.7539085745811462,
0.04834462329745293,
-0.01677670143544674,
-0.10643760114908218,
-0.4731196165084839,
0.26212361454963684,
-0.27154991030693054,
-0.0755976065993309,
-0.2514473795890808,
-0.7554431557655334,
0.23270636796951294,
-0.5353677272796631,
0.7612589001655579,
0.3918631672859192,
0.12455901503562927,
0.3898993730545044,
-0.10449840873479843,
0.361274778842926,
0.04228699579834938,
0.06880160421133041,
-0.44770127534866333,
-0.7429448962211609,
-0.7562718987464905,
-0.024192431941628456,
0.033279869705438614,
0.3864220976829529,
-0.5310172438621521,
-0.09139279276132584,
-0.09860928356647491,
-0.8331529498100281,
-0.8026630878448486,
0.3244813084602356,
0.36139971017837524,
0.8351348638534546,
0.2065008580684662,
-0.4020605683326721,
-0.4103797674179077,
-0.6542648077011108,
-0.010126304812729359,
-0.157896488904953,
-0.28831514716148376,
0.7930401563644409,
0.4491789937019348,
0.2571772336959839,
1.13668954372406,
-0.6356601119041443,
0.11194298416376114,
0.1178174614906311,
0.3316730558872223,
-0.017606554552912712,
0.43927597999572754,
0.40374767780303955,
-0.6569197177886963,
-0.5566163659095764,
0.14358888566493988,
-0.9618921279907227,
0.2930682301521301,
-0.04040075093507767,
-0.10755616426467896,
-0.23044921457767487,
0.078016497194767,
-0.5780049562454224,
0.049829985946416855,
0.5474472641944885,
-0.015343666076660156,
0.23451723158359528,
0.07532978802919388,
0.3781348168849945,
-1.1411914825439453,
0.030236776918172836,
0.16740743815898895,
0.03301891312003136,
-0.6828284859657288,
0.068535216152668,
-0.4538401961326599,
-0.5836462378501892,
-0.9569503664970398,
0.4061027467250824,
-0.23854877054691315,
0.06945285201072693,
0.18749955296516418,
0.42360585927963257,
-0.150990828871727,
0.16377364099025726,
0.49306732416152954,
0.7026917934417725,
0.5866852402687073,
-0.5534384250640869,
0.5361580848693848,
0.9334262013435364,
-0.5182744860649109,
0.49539294838905334,
-0.7190505862236023,
0.2588350474834442,
-0.10828358680009842,
0.45883944630622864,
-0.4915190041065216,
-0.5226563215255737,
0.35707738995552063,
-0.4567970335483551,
-0.13729670643806458,
-0.418266624212265,
0.09376006573438644,
-0.19597972929477692,
-0.06606028974056244,
0.2882968783378601,
0.16221503913402557,
-0.3493208885192871,
-0.032212357968091965,
0.430569589138031,
-0.6779179573059082,
-0.5335718989372253,
-0.27861592173576355,
0.15705901384353638,
-0.23298723995685577,
-0.7931969165802002,
-0.0929948017001152,
-0.3709600865840912,
-0.31815460324287415,
0.16515223681926727,
-0.06277836859226227,
-0.3435688018798828,
-0.07291574776172638,
0.21994593739509583,
0.3381265103816986,
-0.34524673223495483,
0.15745499730110168,
0.015592573210597038,
0.2938721477985382,
0.2551274597644806,
-0.2504747211933136,
0.19583339989185333,
-0.2182043045759201,
-0.5745794773101807,
-0.15015408396720886,
0.5408775806427002,
0.26653119921684265,
0.2077549695968628,
0.6687530279159546,
0.43797674775123596,
-0.3124748766422272,
-0.19712692499160767,
-0.12275753170251846,
-0.5978510975837708,
-0.4715852439403534,
0.4540574550628662,
-0.08146083354949951,
-1.0810998678207397,
0.33992159366607666,
0.19540488719940186,
0.2232479453086853,
-0.12539058923721313,
0.43165403604507446,
-0.161236971616745,
1.0377646684646606,
0.32881835103034973,
0.5749598741531372,
0.4118441939353943,
-0.27300986647605896,
0.3570259213447571,
-0.46153154969215393,
-0.7840273976325989,
-0.6461226344108582,
0.21945370733737946,
-0.24167129397392273,
-0.6446213126182556,
0.2704516053199768,
-0.24401472508907318,
-0.34216317534446716,
0.12473192065954208,
-0.667564332485199,
0.574447512626648,
0.4198282063007355,
-0.0034863604232668877,
0.33071473240852356,
0.11353683471679688,
0.11878354847431183,
-0.3747575581073761,
-0.8499398827552795,
-0.8463709950447083,
0.7761713862419128,
0.31871679425239563,
0.9793517589569092,
0.0706724151968956,
0.22235074639320374,
0.13873957097530365,
0.35586902499198914,
-0.7619292140007019,
0.6299011707305908,
0.039510391652584076,
-0.7303469777107239,
-0.486368864774704,
-0.6205212473869324,
-0.8668042421340942,
0.14432336390018463,
-0.23232951760292053,
-0.7153013348579407,
-0.1349937915802002,
0.059200480580329895,
-0.37776708602905273,
0.469015508890152,
-0.6548476219177246,
1.0729782581329346,
-0.22581897675991058,
-0.277861624956131,
-0.21001878380775452,
-0.9116518497467041,
0.49299970269203186,
-0.031169496476650238,
0.21256496012210846,
-0.2025749236345291,
0.37743717432022095,
0.9084635972976685,
-0.3607577085494995,
1.096846580505371,
-0.21452991664409637,
-0.020760297775268555,
0.7668711543083191,
0.13424503803253174,
-0.18440185487270355,
0.3321225047111511,
0.2779827415943146,
-0.04052983969449997,
0.22976647317409515,
-0.3312407433986664,
-0.6527150869369507,
0.7003046274185181,
-1.0119937658309937,
-0.836585521697998,
-0.5275974273681641,
-0.6707580089569092,
-0.35769107937812805,
-0.11923140287399292,
-0.16857288777828217,
0.23576156795024872,
-0.27610403299331665,
0.5855687260627747,
0.7794929146766663,
-0.3179306387901306,
0.012079667299985886,
0.6182959675788879,
0.16101737320423126,
-0.14886581897735596,
1.010226845741272,
-0.20079192519187927,
0.6569991707801819,
0.1822689324617386,
0.25794604420661926,
0.0020726227667182684,
-0.5259753465652466,
-0.32398781180381775,
-0.0776735246181488,
-0.8767730593681335,
-0.23222094774246216,
-0.8611862063407898,
-0.3828710913658142,
-0.440714031457901,
-0.18633727729320526,
-0.1918184608221054,
-0.7039769887924194,
-0.5416638851165771,
-0.45881950855255127,
0.4511003792285919,
0.732392430305481,
0.0021230264101177454,
0.37444886565208435,
-1.0945056676864624,
0.27276039123535156,
0.547681987285614,
0.16702120006084442,
0.005073612090200186,
-0.36111223697662354,
-0.12928922474384308,
0.5232344269752502,
-0.6687257289886475,
-1.0405430793762207,
0.5773486495018005,
0.7314600944519043,
0.6136264204978943,
0.3258405029773712,
-0.03194236010313034,
0.5939794778823853,
-0.2450966238975525,
1.1606042385101318,
0.5743455290794373,
-0.9123572707176208,
0.9170658588409424,
-0.5044253468513489,
-0.18042278289794922,
0.41453248262405396,
0.8315316438674927,
-0.7107186317443848,
-0.4919438362121582,
-0.5272994637489319,
-0.788135290145874,
0.9001999497413635,
0.07282144576311111,
0.4928591549396515,
-0.14500048756599426,
-0.030475953593850136,
0.4623657166957855,
0.43382924795150757,
-0.6546512246131897,
0.16930390894412994,
-0.8900076746940613,
-0.30463072657585144,
0.04313519597053528,
0.24745281040668488,
-0.6275774240493774,
-0.43392494320869446,
0.5425663590431213,
-0.16423489153385162,
-0.008754427544772625,
0.06450112164020538,
-0.04055909812450409,
-0.26650434732437134,
0.3958386480808258,
0.5799667239189148,
0.49121350049972534,
-0.2189841866493225,
0.023942919448018074,
0.07554929703474045,
-0.6465470790863037,
0.0055441283620893955,
-0.1344773918390274,
-0.005999893415719271,
-0.08912767469882965,
0.019693361595273018,
0.9016767144203186,
0.6328701972961426,
-0.8871256113052368,
0.1978110671043396,
0.04485049098730087,
-0.13192076981067657,
-0.15321452915668488,
0.34342530369758606,
0.27533385157585144,
0.038223810493946075,
0.36903607845306396,
-0.12026898562908173,
0.2053256630897522,
-0.6955685019493103,
0.2647501826286316,
0.2688715159893036,
-0.42885106801986694,
-0.40967264771461487,
0.7245753407478333,
0.6466845273971558,
-0.3969958424568176,
0.9261137247085571,
0.01271399762481451,
-0.16073577105998993,
0.5298370122909546,
0.6273167133331299,
0.510399341583252,
-0.27644211053848267,
0.8047058582305908,
0.4745138883590698,
-0.12839123606681824,
0.12486463785171509,
0.06618155539035797,
-0.2755333483219147,
-0.7785770893096924,
-0.2931980788707733,
-0.4442516565322876,
-1.142115831375122,
0.043628890067338943,
-0.564161479473114,
0.09480530768632889,
-0.44596511125564575,
-0.17783868312835693,
0.31051337718963623,
-0.336404949426651,
-0.47197166085243225,
-0.09766608476638794,
0.20510812103748322,
0.7440447211265564,
-0.936973512172699,
0.44345661997795105,
0.7038136124610901,
-0.5204270482063293,
-0.7518747448921204,
-0.7575555443763733,
-0.1323225349187851,
-0.5162416696548462,
0.676522970199585,
-0.15986210107803345,
-0.07421854138374329,
0.011650756001472473,
-0.9917696714401245,
-0.5922641158103943,
0.6471807360649109,
0.5566391944885254,
-0.4446590542793274,
-0.2935156524181366,
0.4219263792037964,
0.6501165628433228,
-0.6826451420783997,
0.3923124074935913,
0.15624424815177917,
0.35465776920318604,
0.6366249918937683,
-0.8282488584518433,
-0.3538516163825989,
-0.6199992299079895,
-0.500206708908081,
-0.16982805728912354,
-0.4122604727745056,
0.6146308779716492,
-0.3261728882789612,
-0.16030773520469666,
0.07624634355306625,
0.6934969425201416,
0.41198545694351196,
0.7529307007789612,
0.16630634665489197,
0.16285386681556702,
0.5634608268737793,
-0.13641543686389923,
0.4235173165798187,
-0.18975861370563507,
0.1629640907049179,
0.9604719281196594,
-0.2007521241903305,
0.6771191358566284,
0.4832301735877991,
-0.3812916874885559,
0.5162484645843506,
0.8623497486114502,
-0.1619182676076889,
0.4171139597892761,
0.4628688395023346,
-0.47323453426361084,
-0.054962318390607834,
-0.3952283263206482,
-0.4516257345676422,
0.2168985903263092,
0.9365228414535522,
0.10016721487045288,
-0.16235268115997314,
0.1419612020254135,
-0.2232716828584671,
0.312214732170105,
-0.10928848385810852,
0.5926191806793213,
0.22256527841091156,
-0.6610971689224243,
0.3471553325653076,
-0.4525384306907654,
0.267342209815979,
-0.62663334608078,
-0.3621322512626648,
-0.10064895451068878,
-0.4078521430492401,
-0.5112155079841614,
-0.9321298599243164,
-0.0038202146533876657,
0.2885863482952118,
0.0872410461306572,
-0.07864593714475632,
0.2791523039340973,
-0.8452950716018677,
-0.2893315255641937,
-0.3348798453807831,
0.35232675075531006,
0.6574847102165222,
0.5676301717758179,
-0.5227690935134888,
-0.1019471064209938,
-0.0995093360543251,
-0.04585275053977966,
0.15927255153656006,
0.2287130206823349,
-0.07880983501672745,
0.9226542115211487,
0.7766082882881165,
-0.026162270456552505,
0.3607795536518097,
0.18911537528038025,
0.8743525147438049,
-0.5194494724273682,
-0.5023894309997559,
-0.017833251506090164,
0.6272803544998169,
-0.20134182274341583,
-0.33496758341789246,
0.7411721348762512,
0.48170801997184753,
0.8387184739112854,
-0.32047125697135925,
0.9334785342216492,
0.04425538703799248,
0.33100882172584534,
-0.2326960414648056,
0.40231651067733765,
0.06754922866821289,
0.1692977249622345,
-0.2496359497308731,
-1.1471164226531982,
-0.1656566858291626,
0.8893190622329712,
-0.0692305937409401,
-0.08016952872276306,
0.6752555966377258,
0.552426815032959,
-0.15617229044437408,
0.6177170872688293,
0.04677336663007736,
0.1703912913799286,
0.6250282526016235,
0.3207978904247284,
1.2301135063171387,
0.11794696748256683,
0.5901131629943848,
-0.20734034478664398,
-0.2975987195968628,
-0.23425611853599548,
-0.8801203370094299,
-0.9513748288154602,
-0.6428232789039612,
-0.5674482583999634,
-0.08229564875364304,
0.3120688199996948,
1.0017964839935303,
0.7826606631278992,
-0.888825535774231,
-0.2753799557685852,
-0.29548773169517517,
-0.27238282561302185,
0.34146860241889954,
-0.21084384620189667,
0.10475190728902817,
-0.18762606382369995,
-0.7673366069793701,
0.7316378355026245,
-0.09145009517669678,
0.23179779946804047,
-0.5374457240104675,
-0.029077010229229927,
0.036205947399139404,
0.43350881338119507,
0.37423041462898254,
0.7650596499443054,
-0.4450693726539612,
-0.4458276927471161,
0.21835771203041077,
0.09390049427747726,
0.03335558995604515,
1.0871446132659912,
-0.5298100709915161,
0.6066811680793762,
0.24911902844905853,
0.5837717652320862,
0.7782098650932312,
-0.0797915831208229,
0.45891085267066956,
-0.7342360019683838,
0.33045002818107605,
0.6622880697250366,
-0.15296100080013275,
0.7674420475959778,
-0.011718956753611565,
0.4959643483161926,
0.32386448979377747,
-0.32972753047943115,
-1.2197209596633911,
0.1400909572839737,
-1.2438205480575562,
-0.07057693600654602,
0.9528360962867737,
-0.3081965148448944,
0.09790731966495514,
-0.04962386563420296,
-0.2464994490146637,
0.3288195729255676,
-0.4625627100467682,
0.9127227067947388,
0.8153067231178284,
-0.09016863256692886,
-0.06051497161388397,
-0.6560394167900085,
0.32599666714668274,
0.213882714509964,
-0.8314608335494995,
-0.08385111391544342,
0.4929460883140564,
0.13415610790252686,
0.20012085139751434,
0.291959285736084,
-0.0773707702755928,
-0.048271555453538895,
0.25552740693092346,
-0.0630510002374649,
-0.06510009616613388,
-0.4616800546646118,
0.18374422192573547,
0.19041527807712555,
0.08388488739728928,
-0.06797422468662262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10464v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10464v2
|
DESTEIN: Navigating Detoxification of Language Models via Universal Steering Pairs and Head-wise Activation Fusion
| 2024-04-16T11:07:48 | 2024-04-23T07:46:54 |
Yu Li, Zhihua Wei, Han Jiang, Chuanyang Gong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the remarkable achievements of language models (LMs) across a broad
spectrum of tasks, their propensity for generating toxic outputs remains a
prevalent concern. Current solutions involving fine-tuning or auxiliary models
usually require extensive memory and computational resources, rendering them
less practical for deployment in large language models (LLMs). In this paper,
we propose DeStein, a novel method that detoxififies LMs by altering their
internal representations in the activation space with lower resource and time
cost. Specifically, we leverage self-induced steering pairs to identify
detoxification vectors through arithmetic operations in the activation space.
During inference, detoxification is achieved by blending the detoxification
vectors with the original representations. Empirical results demonstrate that
our method significantly outperforms previous state-of-the-art approaches on
popular detoxification metrics, while also maintaining satisfactory generation
quality and diversity. Furthermore, we extend our method to multiple LLMs,
demonstrating its practicality and scalability. We open-source our method at
https://github.com/LizLizLi/DeStein . Warning: Some example model outputs
contain highly offensive or disturbing text.
|
[
-0.2922933101654053,
-0.6748153567314148,
0.6174324750900269,
-0.03893335908651352,
-0.24824081361293793,
0.048141393810510635,
-0.17339806258678436,
-0.23577578365802765,
-0.1749691665172577,
0.5514935255050659,
-0.4954244792461395,
-0.6137253642082214,
-0.6698347330093384,
0.06412303447723389,
-0.7251434922218323,
0.7651780843734741,
0.2323574721813202,
-0.05078304931521416,
0.0068788048811256886,
-0.013584832660853863,
-0.44668087363243103,
-0.2109980285167694,
-0.5784837007522583,
-0.6542943120002747,
0.6014650464057922,
0.22396816313266754,
0.7640140652656555,
0.6068983674049377,
0.14257225394248962,
0.39325496554374695,
-0.29145288467407227,
-0.03537821024656296,
-0.7504748702049255,
0.27577394247055054,
-0.35472407937049866,
-0.06710487604141235,
-0.03243786469101906,
-0.024412713944911957,
0.7304694652557373,
0.6877426505088806,
-0.1623656004667282,
-0.22840136289596558,
0.041817620396614075,
0.9236783385276794,
-0.701238214969635,
-0.2888808846473694,
-0.9291653633117676,
-0.025333605706691742,
-0.06782887876033783,
0.03745991364121437,
-0.6112554669380188,
-0.1083986759185791,
0.014232936315238476,
-0.4250474274158478,
-0.3989875912666321,
-0.303182989358902,
0.4317282438278198,
0.6490925550460815,
-0.5597435235977173,
-0.0864642933011055,
-0.9072655439376831,
1.029054880142212,
-0.9693995714187622,
0.669150173664093,
0.15555740892887115,
0.07039391249418259,
-0.3364217281341553,
-0.40488767623901367,
-0.2915326952934265,
-0.29115352034568787,
-0.16962836682796478,
-0.05613674595952034,
-0.42346814274787903,
0.10388420522212982,
0.07373102754354477,
0.016284482553601265,
-0.5533332228660583,
0.3543151021003723,
-0.46271663904190063,
0.015520285815000534,
0.7382972240447998,
0.0719771534204483,
0.7921304106712341,
0.007954071275889874,
-0.4265085458755493,
0.223368838429451,
-0.9835638403892517,
-0.6062657237052917,
0.39573436975479126,
0.27090802788734436,
-0.12150701880455017,
0.2955981194972992,
-0.10475669801235199,
0.4952808618545532,
0.33989793062210083,
0.20640119910240173,
0.3567880690097809,
-0.18173260986804962,
-0.33837589621543884,
0.3021104335784912,
0.8389921188354492,
0.16471625864505768,
0.1336127519607544,
-0.354815810918808,
-0.061145417392253876,
-0.12461166828870773,
0.5146598815917969,
-0.9526909589767456,
-0.2630194127559662,
0.652905285358429,
-0.21659265458583832,
-0.598029613494873,
-0.5926679968833923,
-0.9748684763908386,
-0.44863614439964294,
-0.3442692160606384,
0.4752412438392639,
-0.6562046408653259,
-0.7696882486343384,
0.1387636661529541,
-0.1351376473903656,
0.11825703829526901,
-0.02226918190717697,
-1.0610677003860474,
0.0014020204544067383,
0.6778233647346497,
0.6235288381576538,
-0.3183230757713318,
-0.0047216154634952545,
-0.5167233347892761,
0.321985125541687,
-0.3066730201244354,
0.5787315964698792,
-0.8016112446784973,
-0.3258940875530243,
0.0919228047132492,
-0.3361475467681885,
0.04334268718957901,
-0.7379652261734009,
0.3415718078613281,
-0.7290045022964478,
0.03391899913549423,
0.0001717589475447312,
-0.4423316419124603,
-0.2763329744338989,
0.10727086663246155,
-0.7117365598678589,
0.9151453375816345,
-0.13398265838623047,
-0.8187606334686279,
-0.08135291188955307,
-0.5058522820472717,
-0.3835281729698181,
0.1510651856660843,
-0.13929383456707,
-0.1365918219089508,
0.2565269470214844,
-0.02202962525188923,
0.142927348613739,
-0.29510119557380676,
0.36399900913238525,
-0.2848551571369171,
-0.2738526463508606,
-0.13226523995399475,
-0.40023523569107056,
1.1159663200378418,
0.30931147933006287,
-0.39277276396751404,
0.5095312595367432,
-0.7576963305473328,
-0.013307352550327778,
0.07766783982515335,
-0.2797119915485382,
-0.8281153440475464,
-0.1270819753408432,
-0.20788869261741638,
0.3824286162853241,
0.05924822390079498,
-0.6000805497169495,
-0.012708439491689205,
-0.6582553386688232,
0.43570882081985474,
0.717645525932312,
0.08366958051919937,
0.6681082844734192,
-0.13019677996635437,
0.24838627874851227,
0.3532475233078003,
-0.027669867500662804,
0.05089356377720833,
-0.3073652386665344,
-0.6945326328277588,
-0.3036469519138336,
-0.07746504992246628,
0.3892518877983093,
-0.7411047220230103,
0.5645081400871277,
-0.3193088471889496,
-0.764149010181427,
-0.5602892637252808,
0.40887650847435,
0.5925855040550232,
0.40074968338012695,
0.44491469860076904,
0.10635889321565628,
-0.30353808403015137,
-1.0189924240112305,
-0.3502170741558075,
-0.01908409781754017,
-0.07880335301160812,
-0.21900230646133423,
0.543512761592865,
-0.5837243795394897,
0.6396338939666748,
-0.24409346282482147,
-0.2003111094236374,
-0.32458367943763733,
0.06245861202478409,
0.10509073734283447,
0.47703322768211365,
0.4954393804073334,
-0.711785614490509,
-0.3735472559928894,
-0.22864311933517456,
-0.6498803496360779,
-0.4166988730430603,
-0.19943712651729584,
-0.45390212535858154,
0.051129478961229324,
0.49529317021369934,
-0.30875885486602783,
0.1624056100845337,
0.6982114911079407,
-0.19148468971252441,
0.4766696095466614,
-0.3097657263278961,
-0.04564733803272247,
-0.7587770223617554,
0.17361722886562347,
0.08385371416807175,
-0.05233773589134216,
-1.1381396055221558,
0.16237396001815796,
0.08118594437837601,
0.011699107475578785,
-0.7533788084983826,
0.6992220282554626,
-0.36937886476516724,
0.4051782488822937,
-0.3144255578517914,
0.42932021617889404,
0.07194503396749496,
0.565168559551239,
-0.0194842666387558,
0.3839264214038849,
0.6080625653266907,
-0.6510683298110962,
0.26890772581100464,
0.29658403992652893,
-0.05807945877313614,
0.45602211356163025,
-0.7124683260917664,
0.010302639566361904,
-0.49722808599472046,
0.07956430315971375,
-1.0583587884902954,
0.1338261365890503,
0.5575180053710938,
0.14883212745189667,
0.41030335426330566,
-0.15220151841640472,
-0.4245717525482178,
0.12979941070079803,
-0.21939510107040405,
0.7105382680892944,
0.7076005339622498,
-0.5241718888282776,
0.6484896540641785,
0.6849684119224548,
0.04648537188768387,
-0.13510990142822266,
-0.6771689653396606,
-0.034109536558389664,
-0.7178613543510437,
-0.44926023483276367,
0.4900493919849396,
-0.11805256456136703,
-0.5141937136650085,
-0.05812814459204674,
-0.11637549847364426,
0.036216434091329575,
0.16894690692424774,
0.18893654644489288,
-0.11062676459550858,
0.2924887537956238,
0.4606403708457947,
0.43962299823760986,
-0.5406153202056885,
-0.004195027519017458,
-0.17143036425113678,
0.583106517791748,
0.08486833423376083,
-0.39799976348876953,
-0.508793830871582,
0.6846650242805481,
0.7909349799156189,
-0.4974581003189087,
0.6657519340515137,
0.6460756063461304,
-0.4578878581523895,
-0.19718314707279205,
-0.34268248081207275,
-0.3088444769382477,
-0.5318536758422852,
0.5396870970726013,
-0.2988770008087158,
-0.4271591305732727,
0.2840428352355957,
-0.4332183599472046,
0.3558298349380493,
0.42150723934173584,
0.9049551486968994,
0.3347115218639374,
1.0832457542419434,
0.40436288714408875,
-0.06413083523511887,
0.43489307165145874,
-0.2965790033340454,
0.2830548882484436,
-1.0433874130249023,
-0.05550753325223923,
-0.35584118962287903,
-0.4452820122241974,
-0.3515905737876892,
-0.3851313591003418,
0.60267573595047,
-0.02060917764902115,
-0.5125734210014343,
0.4503939151763916,
-0.5436739325523376,
0.41827183961868286,
0.5557909607887268,
-0.08882029354572296,
0.444007009267807,
0.036045756191015244,
-0.41038909554481506,
-0.10737492889165878,
-0.4965430200099945,
-0.43283626437187195,
0.7353920340538025,
0.4299980700016022,
0.8478037118911743,
0.2085118293762207,
1.0506871938705444,
0.12767718732357025,
0.451934814453125,
-0.45506754517555237,
0.5718369483947754,
-0.30488121509552,
-0.7464920878410339,
-0.40966397523880005,
-0.5713998079299927,
-0.740716278553009,
0.5425876975059509,
-0.06544598191976547,
-0.8544485569000244,
-0.050534456968307495,
0.08062363415956497,
-0.25748586654663086,
0.46811962127685547,
-0.4906131327152252,
1.01256263256073,
-0.49128928780555725,
-0.43646755814552307,
-0.7371623516082764,
-0.4441274106502533,
0.4808264970779419,
-0.3839195668697357,
0.4902586042881012,
-0.6022711396217346,
0.03258485347032547,
0.6215778589248657,
-0.11042454093694687,
0.8959525227546692,
-0.18800568580627441,
-0.7898280024528503,
0.2040385603904724,
0.5146514177322388,
0.4911550283432007,
-0.2792169451713562,
-0.4413343667984009,
0.562587559223175,
-0.06052249297499657,
-0.06450392305850983,
-0.5588943958282471,
1.0046895742416382,
-0.5907543301582336,
-0.5612697005271912,
-0.08435314893722534,
-0.6813721656799316,
-0.1694900244474411,
0.5009795427322388,
0.02275949902832508,
0.536537766456604,
-0.015786636620759964,
-0.1364094763994217,
0.4354211688041687,
-0.5997307896614075,
0.3391864001750946,
0.48359769582748413,
-0.3359692096710205,
-0.3692828416824341,
0.9003621935844421,
-0.24057716131210327,
0.6228140592575073,
0.3736453950405121,
0.39566609263420105,
-0.4471212327480316,
-0.49068987369537354,
-0.5513374209403992,
0.41479212045669556,
-0.628086507320404,
-0.012769744731485844,
-0.5848265886306763,
-0.1454029381275177,
-0.1143428310751915,
0.09601019322872162,
-0.6349642276763916,
-0.344698041677475,
-0.26716625690460205,
0.029578078538179398,
0.25960296392440796,
0.7773616909980774,
-0.42015427350997925,
0.2592737674713135,
-0.8936174511909485,
0.33941665291786194,
0.04010845720767975,
0.28026458621025085,
0.10760301351547241,
-0.6260625123977661,
-0.08074578642845154,
0.47457265853881836,
-0.40401655435562134,
-1.2051180601119995,
0.5367531180381775,
0.19862763583660126,
0.7852193117141724,
0.5672781467437744,
0.3040466904640198,
0.6023305058479309,
-0.679577112197876,
0.42897698283195496,
0.2636052966117859,
-0.8516250252723694,
0.4919683039188385,
-0.13481609523296356,
0.36678096652030945,
0.41796162724494934,
0.5955680012702942,
-0.7910146117210388,
-0.8544601202011108,
-0.26004281640052795,
-1.053403615951538,
0.24296115338802338,
0.10524163395166397,
0.398659348487854,
-0.13370607793331146,
0.18788257241249084,
0.08812384307384491,
0.02848869562149048,
-0.34260040521621704,
-0.3066549003124237,
0.14401233196258545,
-0.41913896799087524,
0.23704765737056732,
-0.4711892008781433,
-0.121715247631073,
-0.21708407998085022,
0.9960703253746033,
0.29324132204055786,
-0.06509076058864594,
-0.023598788306117058,
-0.3396930992603302,
-0.20417818427085876,
0.3407495617866516,
0.3333940804004669,
0.33799949288368225,
0.0178527869284153,
0.46331068873405457,
0.15863190591335297,
0.00010697399557102472,
0.5054545998573303,
-0.2376462072134018,
-0.366324782371521,
-0.10108361393213272,
0.15352152287960052,
0.36841753125190735,
0.6306959390640259,
-0.7982025742530823,
0.19589975476264954,
0.16763776540756226,
0.016173899173736572,
-0.12614184617996216,
0.19276951253414154,
0.21924471855163574,
0.1905847191810608,
0.2109507918357849,
-0.34737831354141235,
0.1392035335302353,
-0.29918035864830017,
0.45764222741127014,
0.6036417484283447,
-0.6262498497962952,
-0.28875571489334106,
0.8549396395683289,
0.663535475730896,
-0.0475323460996151,
0.7434019446372986,
-0.28315913677215576,
-0.33108723163604736,
0.05132098123431206,
0.5845012068748474,
1.3033595085144043,
-0.19247372448444366,
0.17251411080360413,
0.5324138402938843,
0.16547437012195587,
0.3265153169631958,
-0.1649463027715683,
0.15401460230350494,
-0.852168083190918,
-0.4295278489589691,
-0.6853892207145691,
0.1557883620262146,
0.3120560050010681,
-0.33050501346588135,
-0.026788827031850815,
-0.12554892897605896,
-0.041055791079998016,
0.053418904542922974,
-0.35395148396492004,
-0.28033173084259033,
-0.34716662764549255,
0.44789883494377136,
0.7989508509635925,
-1.092822790145874,
0.7687641978263855,
0.5291597247123718,
-0.37663260102272034,
-0.20577062666416168,
-0.15758199989795685,
0.3932729661464691,
-0.6736845374107361,
0.8602249622344971,
0.3728448450565338,
-0.2976073920726776,
0.26202163100242615,
-0.1873428374528885,
-0.7651540637016296,
0.6162527799606323,
0.4320395588874817,
-0.6707335114479065,
-0.13218511641025543,
0.2022942304611206,
0.3442409038543701,
-0.06634695827960968,
0.28539541363716125,
0.7583190202713013,
0.6512684226036072,
0.1549888700246811,
-0.7866181135177612,
0.3034054934978485,
-0.28209230303764343,
0.1351315975189209,
0.2582632303237915,
-0.35351020097732544,
0.36555397510528564,
-0.34861233830451965,
-0.5671815872192383,
-0.024831971153616905,
0.45129063725471497,
0.158578559756279,
-0.4845714867115021,
0.7694213390350342,
0.7534313797950745,
0.5443662405014038,
0.2317732274532318,
0.5634459853172302,
-0.6692438721656799,
0.1526758223772049,
0.9627880454063416,
-0.3283713459968567,
0.550080418586731,
0.6408124566078186,
0.11420673877000809,
0.5702988505363464,
0.07669983059167862,
0.1505437195301056,
0.771796703338623,
0.4928751587867737,
-0.44618579745292664,
-0.6667063236236572,
-0.20945172011852264,
-0.14127032458782196,
0.3658350110054016,
0.3768022060394287,
-0.30909207463264465,
-0.919901967048645,
0.07143539190292358,
0.16367022693157196,
0.14668871462345123,
-0.008847379125654697,
0.7672151923179626,
0.18594440817832947,
-0.479012131690979,
0.8645126819610596,
0.005036693532019854,
0.5546503067016602,
-0.49969807267189026,
-0.18043701350688934,
-0.13868355751037598,
0.508445680141449,
0.022440696135163307,
-0.5813127756118774,
0.5925910472869873,
-0.07583285123109818,
0.13413211703300476,
-0.5824679136276245,
0.7168042659759521,
-0.8998122215270996,
-0.4902784526348114,
0.6684344410896301,
0.48910394310951233,
0.2888762056827545,
-0.24390725791454315,
-0.5961123108863831,
0.4352443516254425,
0.12423897534608841,
-0.1361490786075592,
0.3655407130718231,
0.2081509381532669,
0.19726049900054932,
0.9428972601890564,
0.545721709728241,
0.021844200789928436,
-0.009466131217777729,
0.0979514941573143,
0.8569663763046265,
-0.49410930275917053,
-0.05854159966111183,
-1.2100014686584473,
0.7851340174674988,
0.16079995036125183,
-0.05571595951914787,
0.6396176218986511,
0.4612328112125397,
0.589638888835907,
0.0016550775617361069,
0.6981309652328491,
0.07649848610162735,
0.2464011311531067,
-0.32253146171569824,
0.9044257402420044,
-0.7030187249183655,
0.1499018371105194,
-0.16374817490577698,
-0.5566864013671875,
-0.33906829357147217,
0.4757421314716339,
-0.33740493655204773,
-0.008454722352325916,
0.34071919322013855,
0.9216189384460449,
-0.033259302377700806,
-0.29512596130371094,
0.42944127321243286,
0.5141106843948364,
0.70267254114151,
0.8019384145736694,
0.7093015909194946,
-0.2809608280658722,
0.5429750084877014,
-0.40613552927970886,
-0.37616974115371704,
-0.2944035828113556,
-0.9946336150169373,
-0.9012644290924072,
-0.5968686938285828,
-0.5827398896217346,
-0.10499574989080429,
0.009890319779515266,
0.8633739948272705,
0.7224408388137817,
-0.6541763544082642,
0.04487616568803787,
-0.09386783838272095,
0.3218340277671814,
-0.32633110880851746,
-0.16051115095615387,
0.23117659986019135,
-0.5164462924003601,
-1.0251539945602417,
0.5308416485786438,
0.3771349787712097,
0.01755918748676777,
-0.6817080974578857,
-0.038461338728666306,
-0.19367274641990662,
-0.05342673882842064,
0.5125762820243835,
0.09357846528291702,
-0.7866999506950378,
-0.3854379951953888,
-0.4302516579627991,
-0.166610985994339,
-0.21644507348537445,
0.4111528992652893,
-0.7903119921684265,
0.42883825302124023,
0.7085224390029907,
0.5013715624809265,
0.03598613664507866,
0.021409383043646812,
0.7061899304389954,
-0.6139601469039917,
0.22888685762882233,
0.09653757512569427,
0.2196781039237976,
0.22612030804157257,
-0.03808538243174553,
0.2783280909061432,
-0.10434596240520477,
-0.35214459896087646,
-0.7918766736984253,
0.5980344414710999,
-0.6134173274040222,
-0.301709920167923,
1.4968851804733276,
0.07401996105909348,
-0.2148331105709076,
-0.05861298739910126,
-0.1742708683013916,
0.22639258205890656,
-0.20007403194904327,
0.8729746341705322,
0.26521867513656616,
0.14065691828727722,
0.08667793869972229,
-0.4491473436355591,
0.4354357123374939,
0.298941433429718,
-0.7436666488647461,
0.5517427921295166,
0.4579226076602936,
0.4950554370880127,
0.34053662419319153,
0.38482901453971863,
-0.28186020255088806,
-0.23252463340759277,
-0.11102799326181412,
0.09989480674266815,
-0.18050852417945862,
-0.3781938850879669,
-0.37608546018600464,
-0.297312468290329,
-0.3004583716392517,
-0.0824442207813263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10440v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10440v1
|
Language Proficiency and F0 Entrainment: A Study of L2 English Imitation in Italian, French, and Slovak Speakers
| 2024-04-16T10:10:19 | 2024-04-16T10:10:19 |
Zheng Yuan, Štefan Beňuš, Alessandro D'Ausilio
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
This study explores F0 entrainment in second language (L2) English speech
imitation during an Alternating Reading Task (ART). Participants with Italian,
French, and Slovak native languages imitated English utterances, and their F0
entrainment was quantified using the Dynamic Time Warping (DTW) distance
between the parameterized F0 contours of the imitated utterances and those of
the model utterances. Results indicate a nuanced relationship between L2
English proficiency and entrainment: speakers with higher proficiency generally
exhibit less entrainment in pitch variation and declination. However, within
dyads, the more proficient speakers demonstrate a greater ability to mimic
pitch range, leading to increased entrainment. This suggests that proficiency
influences entrainment differently at individual and dyadic levels,
highlighting the complex interplay between language skill and prosodic
adaptation.
|
[
0.020304081961512566,
-0.8275578618049622,
0.3729167580604553,
0.19491346180438995,
0.17952106893062592,
0.3927006423473358,
-0.13243068754673004,
-0.91428142786026,
0.40839916467666626,
0.1283103972673416,
-0.27628806233406067,
-0.058126553893089294,
-0.6558974385261536,
0.1537497192621231,
-0.3535386323928833,
0.38264912366867065,
-0.2844993472099304,
0.22531087696552277,
-0.06106417998671532,
-0.18587806820869446,
-0.44954317808151245,
-0.1373785436153412,
-1.0017340183258057,
-0.44322916865348816,
0.19817183911800385,
0.6549645662307739,
0.4633399248123169,
0.1811484545469284,
0.07990303635597229,
0.4014244079589844,
0.12066994607448578,
-0.00913914106786251,
-0.4476280212402344,
0.3656778335571289,
-0.0665094181895256,
-0.8576886057853699,
-0.33241742849349976,
0.2900862395763397,
0.8972975611686707,
0.48996880650520325,
-0.037696532905101776,
-0.14038144052028656,
0.2273847907781601,
0.872145414352417,
-0.3015827536582947,
0.18484479188919067,
-0.564179539680481,
0.051049645990133286,
-0.17777851223945618,
-0.02615467831492424,
-0.522855818271637,
-0.18563921749591827,
0.1401064097881317,
-0.863841712474823,
0.1815059930086136,
-0.06749013811349869,
0.6538024544715881,
0.34910234808921814,
-0.22804304957389832,
-0.32617223262786865,
-0.6786521077156067,
0.48341888189315796,
-0.6541414260864258,
0.7277381420135498,
0.46795347332954407,
0.10846337676048279,
0.08786586672067642,
-0.6732507348060608,
-0.8918008208274841,
-0.40555340051651,
-0.2206040471792221,
0.2768080532550812,
0.12467224895954132,
-0.03566008433699608,
0.3213796615600586,
0.2664892375469208,
-0.4552171528339386,
0.1745568960905075,
-0.3572149872779846,
0.02758204936981201,
0.6941681504249573,
-0.0958440825343132,
0.4665786921977997,
0.41722866892814636,
-0.029712380841374397,
-0.17898324131965637,
-0.6169649958610535,
0.49263569712638855,
0.7640213370323181,
-0.03762716054916382,
-0.11304046213626862,
0.45276445150375366,
-0.07295583188533783,
0.6005457639694214,
0.1389971822500229,
-0.2131490856409073,
0.560292661190033,
-0.23684491217136383,
0.25302401185035706,
0.10648592561483383,
0.4255874752998352,
0.4337306618690491,
0.7388836741447449,
-0.26762139797210693,
-0.12434899806976318,
-0.27690479159355164,
0.058127760887145996,
-0.5336099863052368,
0.021100791171193123,
0.0494283065199852,
-0.06856141239404678,
0.01818208210170269,
0.3514186143875122,
-0.7391647100448608,
-0.22195063531398773,
-0.18507790565490723,
0.6724744439125061,
-0.5258620977401733,
-0.4540454149246216,
0.10048896819353104,
-0.44543853402137756,
0.27572065591812134,
0.046168722212314606,
-1.2175854444503784,
0.33959516882896423,
0.599070131778717,
1.0257422924041748,
-0.409824013710022,
-0.6863494515419006,
-0.3631540536880493,
0.17147214710712433,
-0.3673587143421173,
0.46982213854789734,
-0.5268967151641846,
-0.5907615423202515,
0.12646940350532532,
0.4656338095664978,
-0.4364883601665497,
-0.6374598145484924,
-0.05248958617448807,
-0.3879834711551666,
0.07996110618114471,
-0.05218328908085823,
-0.514687180519104,
-0.18645943701267242,
-0.11606098711490631,
-0.5993799567222595,
1.2236924171447754,
0.5447263121604919,
-0.6094303727149963,
0.5605202913284302,
-0.3490292727947235,
-0.4614102244377136,
-0.03278537839651108,
-0.21084079146385193,
-0.1280483454465866,
0.22411786019802094,
-0.29830673336982727,
0.1588296741247177,
0.304494172334671,
-0.5031566619873047,
0.0557856485247612,
-0.7163159847259521,
0.23927487432956696,
-0.22299431264400482,
0.5052660703659058,
-0.16886860132217407,
-0.5851803421974182,
-0.26715290546417236,
-0.7152156829833984,
0.08386252820491791,
0.19642731547355652,
-0.3450571596622467,
-0.4992435872554779,
0.07443635910749435,
-0.12706468999385834,
0.027521375566720963,
0.1843031495809555,
-0.7897457480430603,
0.141630157828331,
-1.121407151222229,
0.5154123306274414,
0.430667906999588,
0.5379942059516907,
0.38522353768348694,
-0.5314580202102661,
0.4382689893245697,
0.15604759752750397,
-0.2701726257801056,
0.0921400710940361,
-0.5306426882743835,
-0.7838115692138672,
0.09855174273252487,
0.11620438098907471,
0.9519473314285278,
-0.9224134683609009,
0.10733126103878021,
-0.21706819534301758,
-0.41339194774627686,
-0.7158533930778503,
0.26824289560317993,
0.5271090269088745,
-0.006946131587028503,
0.28978660702705383,
-0.2916422486305237,
-0.227071613073349,
-0.8597447276115417,
-0.596671998500824,
-0.21980509161949158,
-0.06311208754777908,
-0.09209685027599335,
0.5681127309799194,
0.17623232305049896,
0.5383416414260864,
-0.2270580679178238,
-0.35346052050590515,
-0.2297772765159607,
0.07724012434482574,
0.09796842932701111,
0.7081769108772278,
0.9527768492698669,
-0.3652559816837311,
-0.8961886167526245,
-0.14443448185920715,
-0.2142830640077591,
0.1446920782327652,
-0.2183448225259781,
-0.05052415654063225,
0.5172695517539978,
0.7022749185562134,
-0.11512502282857895,
0.4150594174861908,
0.5339763760566711,
-0.55176842212677,
0.31371185183525085,
-0.3708072304725647,
0.2971569299697876,
-1.0248595476150513,
-0.177016943693161,
-0.3169545531272888,
-0.04341944307088852,
-0.8608114719390869,
-0.1806136965751648,
-0.21578098833560944,
0.3387087285518646,
-0.6066367030143738,
0.5691094398498535,
-0.500913679599762,
-0.06921085715293884,
-0.11451356112957001,
0.08481699973344803,
-0.061704542487859726,
0.23689888417720795,
0.302738219499588,
1.0818402767181396,
0.43207234144210815,
-0.3231509029865265,
0.0313321016728878,
0.21039284765720367,
-0.6452357769012451,
0.4218149483203888,
-0.7555323839187622,
0.3370964229106903,
-0.08723848313093185,
-0.2620280086994171,
-1.3647427558898926,
-0.0665832906961441,
-0.13388481736183167,
-0.5440608859062195,
0.600236177444458,
0.31484663486480713,
-0.38365790247917175,
-0.3686496317386627,
-0.03282855451107025,
0.32552483677864075,
0.6945779323577881,
-0.14719203114509583,
0.13847047090530396,
0.08370690047740936,
-0.25068598985671997,
-0.39886772632598877,
-0.996122419834137,
-0.3590870201587677,
0.061026208102703094,
-0.47074636816978455,
0.5113666653633118,
-0.017275242134928703,
-0.578669548034668,
-0.31307169795036316,
-0.10038713365793228,
0.1255570501089096,
0.0894722267985344,
0.26982685923576355,
-0.40642181038856506,
-0.052611641585826874,
-0.06851441413164139,
0.10853371024131775,
-0.07187590003013611,
-0.06743746995925903,
-0.005845143925398588,
0.5016434192657471,
0.08613475412130356,
-0.5914111137390137,
-0.8785736560821533,
0.5358688235282898,
0.6937682628631592,
-0.03582308441400528,
0.8813667297363281,
0.5037214756011963,
-0.24497602880001068,
-0.10883370041847229,
-0.5023996829986572,
-0.4682455062866211,
-0.5028363466262817,
0.3844141662120819,
-0.7279277443885803,
-0.5824651718139648,
0.46519148349761963,
0.4013154208660126,
0.24129724502563477,
0.24571171402931213,
0.4449669420719147,
-0.48678529262542725,
0.8171889185905457,
0.6011695861816406,
0.09620173275470734,
0.8082548379898071,
-0.5999184846878052,
-0.046339694410562515,
-0.6906383037567139,
-0.1925094872713089,
-0.4319247007369995,
-0.7430112361907959,
-0.47010767459869385,
-0.5077098608016968,
0.3119748830795288,
0.041590504348278046,
-0.12802934646606445,
0.11763396859169006,
-0.04464370757341385,
0.5399209260940552,
0.5891796350479126,
0.37463200092315674,
0.27258527278900146,
0.1936991959810257,
-0.15049749612808228,
-0.5943591594696045,
-0.35130736231803894,
-0.24118344485759735,
0.8440097570419312,
0.2985571622848511,
0.3302861452102661,
0.2822096645832062,
0.6988896131515503,
0.22204820811748505,
-0.08511251956224442,
-0.8715143799781799,
0.3932722806930542,
-0.2778392434120178,
-0.41974830627441406,
-0.565039873123169,
0.2048603594303131,
-0.8189312815666199,
-0.15446311235427856,
-0.08317707479000092,
-0.6951869130134583,
0.34023651480674744,
0.18329685926437378,
-0.21447156369686127,
0.0774741992354393,
-0.5375751852989197,
0.5446674823760986,
-0.06066906824707985,
-0.5386821031570435,
-0.4608475863933563,
-0.4547382593154907,
-0.10906774550676346,
-0.05539077892899513,
0.1740066111087799,
0.00029127643210813403,
-0.3004642724990845,
0.6826409101486206,
-0.13370618224143982,
0.7787986993789673,
-0.5838454365730286,
-0.1900552660226822,
0.2900490164756775,
0.41518720984458923,
0.6455217599868774,
-0.10624921321868896,
-0.4485724866390228,
-0.00432819128036499,
0.06216014176607132,
-0.45451200008392334,
-0.6182528734207153,
0.4468642771244049,
-0.9719117283821106,
-0.8025620579719543,
-0.2681715190410614,
-0.39888426661491394,
-0.5540646314620972,
-0.0036342190578579903,
0.4485005736351013,
0.1728457510471344,
-0.31771448254585266,
0.3026500940322876,
0.4905054271221161,
-0.013218006119132042,
0.69240403175354,
0.8337342739105225,
0.16939738392829895,
-0.4794657528400421,
0.6145860552787781,
0.5239397883415222,
0.8430085778236389,
0.4850071370601654,
-0.15389370918273926,
-0.24586550891399384,
-0.5691254734992981,
-0.30437830090522766,
0.419021874666214,
-0.4518100321292877,
0.38682249188423157,
-0.5362535119056702,
-0.2661822438240051,
-0.4895745515823364,
-0.3959306478500366,
-0.3468364179134369,
-0.6702902913093567,
-0.07065577805042267,
-0.35407593846321106,
0.4009113311767578,
0.8173133134841919,
-0.13832677900791168,
0.3082103431224823,
-0.3906917870044708,
0.01867421716451645,
0.40410149097442627,
0.12108055502176285,
-0.1176246702671051,
-1.103649377822876,
-0.4049132466316223,
0.29016754031181335,
-0.25021564960479736,
-1.065751314163208,
0.10302780568599701,
0.648154616355896,
0.9572627544403076,
0.3890836536884308,
-0.2397526204586029,
0.6321168541908264,
-0.7613317966461182,
1.1774160861968994,
0.11420392990112305,
-0.9706308841705322,
0.4168960452079773,
-0.08439972996711731,
0.2815646231174469,
0.7522050142288208,
0.4779472351074219,
-0.7072693705558777,
-0.8434212803840637,
-0.507750928401947,
-0.7823291420936584,
0.6285589933395386,
0.09743402898311615,
0.29065650701522827,
0.06320329010486603,
0.33294016122817993,
0.16346341371536255,
-0.04737456887960434,
-0.5068391561508179,
-0.08934010565280914,
-0.19923542439937592,
-0.15136297047138214,
-0.5729323029518127,
-0.3508703410625458,
-0.12263087928295135,
-0.7430082559585571,
0.7105951309204102,
-0.06212913244962692,
0.5218481421470642,
0.375474750995636,
-0.2463861107826233,
-0.1911327987909317,
-0.013551324605941772,
0.9699183106422424,
0.4756995737552643,
0.1647205501794815,
0.11726102232933044,
0.5646273493766785,
-0.8289893865585327,
0.5594221949577332,
-0.4448995888233185,
-0.11867596209049225,
0.2897523045539856,
0.7550297379493713,
0.8322279453277588,
0.3524872958660126,
-0.40982478857040405,
0.45371559262275696,
0.3497485816478729,
-0.5950209498405457,
-0.5417355895042419,
0.3812335133552551,
0.17360952496528625,
0.37969905138015747,
0.18361681699752808,
-0.22973738610744476,
-0.2457261085510254,
-0.7026723027229309,
0.34788498282432556,
0.24813216924667358,
-0.40547069907188416,
-0.5266438722610474,
0.8730045557022095,
0.1845712810754776,
-0.569182276725769,
0.5396953821182251,
-0.07086654752492905,
-0.42032262682914734,
0.7098659873008728,
0.7690689563751221,
0.9113366007804871,
-0.5320578217506409,
0.033808376640081406,
0.5619579553604126,
0.3364870250225067,
0.08500339090824127,
0.8470219969749451,
-0.07750622928142548,
-0.8171717524528503,
-0.14515572786331177,
-0.5673739910125732,
-0.41891413927078247,
-0.1123303696513176,
-0.8691479563713074,
0.17562882602214813,
-0.05097042769193649,
-0.007660411763936281,
0.002259250497445464,
-0.038974445313215256,
-0.6167395710945129,
-0.21396200358867645,
-0.039439063519239426,
1.068818211555481,
-0.9853172302246094,
1.1742167472839355,
0.8522999882698059,
-0.42689770460128784,
-0.6899141073226929,
0.3285068869590759,
-0.045428939163684845,
-0.9972573518753052,
0.8675379157066345,
0.09292592108249664,
-0.1437622457742691,
0.47142294049263,
0.07220800220966339,
-0.48647168278694153,
1.2755005359649658,
0.1327800452709198,
-0.6236255168914795,
-0.055171117186546326,
0.5952650904655457,
0.7699435949325562,
-0.38234061002731323,
0.34433823823928833,
0.9493575692176819,
0.5691641569137573,
-0.06831894814968109,
-1.1807277202606201,
-0.2959262728691101,
-0.09126751124858856,
0.10040348023176193,
-0.10309692472219467,
-0.9861894845962524,
0.5664759874343872,
-0.33696967363357544,
-0.03392377495765686,
0.16976794600486755,
0.5678579807281494,
-0.10020951181650162,
0.11008088290691376,
0.7007707357406616,
0.5124598145484924,
0.4789578318595886,
-0.2052733302116394,
0.41118669509887695,
-0.8583675026893616,
-0.1961262971162796,
0.8741835355758667,
-0.253667414188385,
1.3142406940460205,
0.7252724170684814,
-0.3385578691959381,
0.7824809551239014,
0.356190025806427,
0.37137365341186523,
0.4839012324810028,
0.028275391086935997,
-0.3737012445926666,
0.08712629228830338,
0.26003697514533997,
-0.46802276372909546,
0.6573851704597473,
0.5566688776016235,
-0.6168097257614136,
0.34024712443351746,
0.3394280672073364,
0.22714026272296906,
0.2552669048309326,
-0.026002177968621254,
1.0168616771697998,
-0.014127684757113457,
-0.9159558415412903,
0.861595094203949,
-0.3517463505268097,
0.45391228795051575,
-0.4602639973163605,
0.04056241735816002,
-0.44411516189575195,
0.22427985072135925,
-0.1578293740749359,
-1.016300082206726,
0.6034239530563354,
-0.1830851137638092,
-0.2779134511947632,
-0.5905239582061768,
0.10604095458984375,
-0.7876657247543335,
-0.061301715672016144,
0.3802221417427063,
0.4865744411945343,
0.46534278988838196,
0.219602569937706,
-0.5080409049987793,
-0.2220858931541443,
0.156651109457016,
-0.5201871991157532,
0.26750829815864563,
0.23426967859268188,
0.39430347084999084,
0.2309885174036026,
0.26059362292289734,
0.32468950748443604,
0.1955735832452774,
0.1834782510995865,
0.22869957983493805,
-0.3436753451824188,
-0.5023864507675171,
-0.6889773011207581,
0.6994155049324036,
-0.01912660524249077,
-0.32213523983955383,
0.6730746030807495,
0.6479772925376892,
0.9047227501869202,
-0.5193555355072021,
0.5375686287879944,
-0.05232742056250572,
0.6047183275222778,
-0.7436177730560303,
0.847692608833313,
-0.7979264855384827,
-0.25414037704467773,
0.01991761475801468,
-0.9291321635246277,
0.3120553195476532,
0.7770386338233948,
-0.25470414757728577,
-0.3313588500022888,
0.9707890748977661,
1.061977505683899,
0.1974029541015625,
-0.04715067520737648,
0.6457024812698364,
0.3237839937210083,
0.0746193379163742,
0.5399987101554871,
0.6508992910385132,
-0.290393203496933,
-0.08941137045621872,
-0.2307659089565277,
-0.15786337852478027,
-0.09199395775794983,
-0.4555087089538574,
-0.7967077493667603,
-0.9929567575454712,
-0.24909844994544983,
-0.43633729219436646,
0.32114747166633606,
0.824945867061615,
0.45106083154678345,
-0.966410219669342,
-0.4116554856300354,
-0.17697016894817352,
-0.23846742510795593,
-0.6092944741249084,
-0.299533486366272,
-0.0011163187446072698,
-0.38188737630844116,
-1.2693125009536743,
0.7120704650878906,
-0.022688627243041992,
0.6958280801773071,
-0.3706190884113312,
-0.20831584930419922,
-0.25702184438705444,
0.10467220097780228,
0.5038106441497803,
0.40117043256759644,
-0.6046606302261353,
-0.5519437193870544,
-0.001963795628398657,
0.02978086844086647,
-0.00868106260895729,
0.7378308176994324,
-0.423563688993454,
0.552696943283081,
0.7998133897781372,
0.25723347067832947,
0.45080214738845825,
-0.10140668600797653,
0.5721123218536377,
-0.9956364035606384,
0.7919434309005737,
0.19765359163284302,
0.1930394470691681,
0.03676796704530716,
-0.24052336812019348,
0.6018047332763672,
0.6874681711196899,
-0.42809227108955383,
-0.9055014848709106,
0.17586387693881989,
-0.4563247561454773,
0.1385108381509781,
1.348982334136963,
-0.2432868778705597,
0.21779821813106537,
-0.1928640902042389,
-0.2597663998603821,
0.2336525321006775,
-0.19471296668052673,
0.3813461661338806,
1.1535248756408691,
-0.35231268405914307,
-0.149324432015419,
-1.1127560138702393,
0.8278020024299622,
0.5576162338256836,
-0.45747631788253784,
-0.2258206158876419,
0.06992550194263458,
0.5440436601638794,
0.13458313047885895,
0.5987880229949951,
0.14677539467811584,
0.23735672235488892,
0.38740894198417664,
0.028348436579108238,
-0.08420343697071075,
-0.4853343963623047,
-0.08735557645559311,
-0.12014948576688766,
0.27565798163414,
-0.33881646394729614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10419v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10419v1
|
MAD Speech: Measures of Acoustic Diversity of Speech
| 2024-04-16T09:35:27 | 2024-04-16T09:35:27 |
Matthieu Futeral, Andrea Agostinelli, Marco Tagliasacchi, Neil Zeghidour, Eugene Kharitonov
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL
|
Generative spoken language models produce speech in a wide range of voices,
prosody, and recording conditions, seemingly approaching the diversity of
natural speech. However, the extent to which generated speech is acoustically
diverse remains unclear due to a lack of appropriate metrics. We address this
gap by developing lightweight metrics of acoustic diversity, which we
collectively refer to as MAD Speech. We focus on measuring five facets of
acoustic diversity: voice, gender, emotion, accent, and background noise. We
construct the metrics as a composition of specialized, per-facet embedding
models and an aggregation function that measures diversity within the embedding
space. Next, we build a series of datasets with a priori known diversity
preferences for each facet. Using these datasets, we demonstrate that our
proposed metrics achieve a stronger agreement with the ground-truth diversity
than baselines. Finally, we showcase the applicability of our proposed metrics
across several real-life evaluation scenarios. MAD Speech will be made publicly
accessible.
|
[
-0.8262711763381958,
-0.6923402547836304,
0.028643878176808357,
0.39174580574035645,
0.042401332408189774,
0.5128549933433533,
-0.05811731144785881,
-0.3778044283390045,
0.303857684135437,
0.06117736175656319,
-0.44202837347984314,
-0.6978887319564819,
-0.553748607635498,
0.03879699110984802,
-0.6257014870643616,
1.2448772192001343,
0.566152036190033,
0.30438685417175293,
-0.03208087757229805,
-0.3476333022117615,
-0.41097477078437805,
-0.39926427602767944,
-0.4058704972267151,
-0.016077134758234024,
0.591296911239624,
0.2548410892486572,
0.6905336976051331,
0.3488531708717346,
0.1913369596004486,
0.3454735279083252,
-0.41890785098075867,
0.27682557702064514,
-0.574263334274292,
0.21448677778244019,
-0.1113920509815216,
-0.314813494682312,
-0.4180290400981903,
0.05573692545294762,
0.8674566149711609,
0.8023129105567932,
-0.34908556938171387,
-0.09707891196012497,
-0.13177967071533203,
0.4182932376861572,
-0.6795012354850769,
-0.10354011505842209,
-0.48064860701560974,
0.2352546900510788,
-0.2830919921398163,
0.15936577320098877,
0.14792348444461823,
-0.3286237418651581,
0.24679487943649292,
-0.08791499584913254,
0.38791003823280334,
-0.07604757696390152,
0.4390450716018677,
0.08283030986785889,
-0.40332549810409546,
-0.21599754691123962,
-1.0330418348312378,
0.7889353036880493,
-0.7364567518234253,
0.5757864713668823,
0.2285776138305664,
0.5179498195648193,
0.029203055426478386,
-0.4903275966644287,
-0.7040609121322632,
-0.23363026976585388,
0.3316414952278137,
0.3995745778083801,
-0.758145272731781,
0.06766866147518158,
-0.06066509336233139,
0.9393015503883362,
-0.4812016487121582,
-0.020121101289987564,
-0.3132955729961395,
-0.17324014008045197,
0.9400159120559692,
0.4996315538883209,
0.561804473400116,
0.1602589339017868,
0.20349985361099243,
-0.08074068278074265,
-0.1812538206577301,
-0.2260286808013916,
0.9598395824432373,
0.5075693130493164,
-0.49050942063331604,
0.5506717562675476,
-0.3062601089477539,
0.7208935022354126,
-0.1828506886959076,
-0.4114728271961212,
0.3706037402153015,
-0.4044348895549774,
0.055736441165208817,
0.14706316590309143,
0.6384317874908447,
0.10799900442361832,
0.15874578058719635,
-0.3005656898021698,
-0.35129180550575256,
-0.10283748060464859,
0.08033312857151031,
-0.5723735690116882,
-0.2773634195327759,
0.0507492832839489,
-0.1053168773651123,
-0.07679648697376251,
-0.2362210899591446,
-0.6528438925743103,
-0.6839678287506104,
-0.31497907638549805,
0.18783022463321686,
-0.41878995299339294,
-0.5707366466522217,
0.09093095362186432,
-0.500249981880188,
0.028353799134492874,
0.14357192814350128,
-0.6927585601806641,
0.49199768900871277,
0.5931469798088074,
1.188326358795166,
-0.22310610115528107,
-0.19728456437587738,
-0.3321053683757782,
-0.09343772381544113,
-0.3690718710422516,
0.8472104072570801,
-0.6254748702049255,
-0.8179976940155029,
-0.21238116919994354,
-0.4857112467288971,
-0.02375713177025318,
-0.864646852016449,
0.40969863533973694,
0.05446307733654976,
0.13586708903312683,
-0.3610530495643616,
-0.41656559705734253,
-0.31465262174606323,
0.08109069615602493,
-0.48695772886276245,
0.5939565896987915,
0.30232083797454834,
-0.6773934960365295,
0.35497695207595825,
-0.6052829623222351,
-0.46351054310798645,
0.03472999110817909,
-0.18989352881908417,
-0.4087297022342682,
0.2324094921350479,
-0.028514783829450607,
0.1556566059589386,
-0.1812606155872345,
0.15537673234939575,
-0.40940919518470764,
-0.14644251763820648,
0.2012285590171814,
-0.5945180654525757,
0.6699240207672119,
0.5661242604255676,
-0.13869991898536682,
0.15248002111911774,
-0.8524406552314758,
-0.42785316705703735,
-0.15877586603164673,
-0.2230941653251648,
-0.2976733148097992,
0.20333528518676758,
0.18559542298316956,
0.09009464085102081,
-0.15318387746810913,
-0.619763195514679,
-0.17331644892692566,
-0.527608335018158,
0.3220471441745758,
0.4489969313144684,
0.060118284076452255,
-0.09005452692508698,
-0.5074750185012817,
0.5466687679290771,
0.40764468908309937,
-0.2586975693702698,
0.23127558827400208,
-0.6620115637779236,
-0.5421482920646667,
-0.8449808955192566,
0.02154613472521305,
0.6269857287406921,
0.10601575672626495,
0.2699071764945984,
0.17855195701122284,
-0.9896259307861328,
-0.6255794167518616,
-0.13360314071178436,
0.27765244245529175,
0.2984828054904938,
0.09927249699831009,
-0.5855435729026794,
-0.7439587712287903,
-0.9053184390068054,
-0.5014356970787048,
-0.282531201839447,
-0.009461646899580956,
0.6308045983314514,
0.2694174349308014,
-0.16164235770702362,
0.9577317833900452,
-0.31980955600738525,
-0.03517989069223404,
-0.22867794334888458,
0.6453688144683838,
0.11493635922670364,
0.4314880669116974,
0.8052378296852112,
-0.48586151003837585,
-0.10943285375833511,
0.05742236599326134,
-0.40951454639434814,
-0.27339521050453186,
0.36785390973091125,
0.12346822023391724,
-0.201158344745636,
-0.05119332671165466,
-0.46365857124328613,
0.13147516548633575,
0.6331112384796143,
-0.2864961624145508,
0.7281582355499268,
0.3265491724014282,
0.3166728615760803,
-0.9125313758850098,
-0.3006454408168793,
-0.04005540907382965,
-0.32069826126098633,
-0.674201488494873,
-0.25014543533325195,
-0.796972930431366,
-0.4688662588596344,
-0.5916814804077148,
0.18086092174053192,
-0.2453756332397461,
-0.5490428805351257,
-0.2829451262950897,
0.15951956808567047,
-0.34068071842193604,
0.2039862424135208,
-0.26174068450927734,
0.7851511240005493,
0.8260050415992737,
-0.5883296132087708,
0.5161295533180237,
0.08708932995796204,
-0.2616628110408783,
1.034437894821167,
-0.654293954372406,
0.14152801036834717,
-0.16841061413288116,
0.22368773818016052,
-1.1790480613708496,
-0.1257682889699936,
0.02855304814875126,
-0.5145848989486694,
0.09666997939348221,
-0.027479607611894608,
-0.1881093531847,
-0.16838790476322174,
0.23021715879440308,
0.3677690625190735,
0.34658393263816833,
-0.09339568018913269,
0.5477717518806458,
1.0268086194992065,
-0.5380278825759888,
-0.3287394344806671,
-0.3754931092262268,
0.08639350533485413,
-0.3369264006614685,
-0.6342364549636841,
0.0035556862130761147,
-0.19626787304878235,
-0.7537069916725159,
-0.10447406023740768,
-0.08142195641994476,
-0.2070930153131485,
0.11428102850914001,
0.3430715799331665,
-0.3525466024875641,
-0.4685523211956024,
-0.07212023437023163,
0.24401509761810303,
0.4223484992980957,
-0.004960931837558746,
-0.3571961224079132,
0.7327854037284851,
-0.5691584348678589,
-0.3879164755344391,
-0.29929009079933167,
0.8341199159622192,
0.6552237272262573,
-0.2245021015405655,
0.430091917514801,
1.0268452167510986,
-0.42475396394729614,
0.07489929348230362,
-0.29461583495140076,
0.19651836156845093,
-0.40475982427597046,
0.5465373992919922,
-0.28235408663749695,
-1.1184278726577759,
0.8020178079605103,
0.06944908946752548,
0.4142567813396454,
0.3746231496334076,
0.9482492804527283,
-0.045331839472055435,
1.5004403591156006,
0.30603930354118347,
-0.028490416705608368,
0.43860775232315063,
-0.09951722621917725,
0.2472044974565506,
-0.4862927496433258,
-0.2241709977388382,
-0.7397183775901794,
-0.5943196415901184,
-0.8194816708564758,
-0.2704545855522156,
0.23488886654376984,
-0.15555167198181152,
-0.3366832733154297,
-0.20324039459228516,
-0.2603740394115448,
0.2772471010684967,
0.47640249133110046,
-0.12788791954517365,
0.1492575854063034,
-0.12190185487270355,
0.11393444240093231,
-0.0848948135972023,
-0.33679452538490295,
-0.26328858733177185,
0.6218356490135193,
0.348903089761734,
0.5561188459396362,
0.2183174192905426,
0.7827110886573792,
0.44501936435699463,
0.07304596900939941,
-0.8182342052459717,
0.37151026725769043,
-0.4538060128688812,
-0.7358793616294861,
-0.23206734657287598,
-0.5286406874656677,
-0.7371920347213745,
0.43085235357284546,
0.05766898766160011,
-0.5884666442871094,
0.38970431685447693,
0.22659260034561157,
-0.27896109223365784,
0.30947402119636536,
-0.40925133228302,
0.4736751914024353,
0.0313827209174633,
0.2584063410758972,
-0.3590749204158783,
-0.21915562450885773,
0.5455157160758972,
0.15776948630809784,
0.17248646914958954,
-0.43997642397880554,
0.10176485031843185,
1.1347875595092773,
-0.2841084599494934,
0.7562075853347778,
-0.20889122784137726,
-0.20279791951179504,
0.5506686568260193,
0.15462279319763184,
0.02506604790687561,
0.006947663147002459,
0.3013359606266022,
0.6715402007102966,
-0.1976032853126526,
-0.28019681572914124,
-0.37507838010787964,
0.7145262360572815,
-1.1619608402252197,
-0.5374124646186829,
-0.22595985233783722,
-0.8822231888771057,
-0.5912978053092957,
-0.04122941568493843,
0.15802894532680511,
0.2895843982696533,
-0.3756299912929535,
0.3409893214702606,
0.4078212082386017,
-0.26606374979019165,
0.2708049714565277,
0.6427168846130371,
-0.1815449744462967,
-0.5489884614944458,
1.1986080408096313,
0.3844467103481293,
0.24218954145908356,
-0.0036992391105741262,
0.49982935190200806,
-0.14734765887260437,
-0.530367374420166,
-0.11180976778268814,
-0.05845317989587784,
-0.5376389026641846,
0.09890399128198624,
-1.1623950004577637,
-0.20526434481143951,
-0.6064778566360474,
0.05896580219268799,
-0.6835709810256958,
-0.569978654384613,
-0.2364380955696106,
-0.42649826407432556,
0.4013521671295166,
0.8007799983024597,
-0.4941823482513428,
0.42381033301353455,
-0.4827290177345276,
0.4445559084415436,
0.6371968388557434,
0.17986461520195007,
-0.16291850805282593,
-0.5268883109092712,
-0.1595681607723236,
0.19746685028076172,
-0.4787423312664032,
-1.128682255744934,
0.7287386655807495,
0.41584837436676025,
0.6728823781013489,
0.41762760281562805,
-0.12921781837940216,
0.6600359678268433,
-0.26679953932762146,
1.0505307912826538,
0.24835410714149475,
-1.0553146600723267,
0.5652196407318115,
-0.47230294346809387,
0.1310805082321167,
0.26970914006233215,
0.19502989947795868,
-0.5874577164649963,
-1.1503570079803467,
-0.6588127017021179,
-0.9607206583023071,
0.3866595923900604,
0.0919768363237381,
0.3012591004371643,
-0.20318779349327087,
-0.48518267273902893,
0.2822422385215759,
0.36054718494415283,
-0.29158633947372437,
-0.5510790944099426,
-0.6806453466415405,
-0.0417511872947216,
-0.14713454246520996,
0.09323960542678833,
-0.6310837864875793,
-0.3577749729156494,
0.20508185029029846,
0.17749057710170746,
0.29612311720848083,
-0.042686235159635544,
0.1342749297618866,
-0.04650107026100159,
0.3735966384410858,
0.9065067172050476,
0.6305293440818787,
-0.1638888716697693,
0.289556086063385,
0.2644542157649994,
-0.7261295914649963,
0.0659714862704277,
-0.07585026323795319,
0.11090712994337082,
0.5317931771278381,
0.09275224804878235,
1.1457574367523193,
0.09660759568214417,
-0.5938039422035217,
0.20976650714874268,
-0.04461261257529259,
-0.1702689230442047,
-0.2539781630039215,
0.3225950598716736,
0.1831437647342682,
0.28651300072669983,
0.18844246864318848,
0.24480457603931427,
0.6102714538574219,
-0.5366889834403992,
0.3097345232963562,
0.3967391848564148,
-0.6136866807937622,
-0.34070560336112976,
0.5014801025390625,
0.40482133626937866,
-0.5674254298210144,
0.5144338011741638,
-0.16482295095920563,
-0.18263621628284454,
0.470154732465744,
0.7567793130874634,
1.3489623069763184,
-0.28381237387657166,
0.1319330483675003,
0.18826229870319366,
0.2556360065937042,
0.36752212047576904,
0.5699596405029297,
-0.09244157373905182,
-0.6511998176574707,
0.06809286773204803,
-0.7266674637794495,
-0.6175178289413452,
0.07590337097644806,
-0.6890757083892822,
-0.023623401299118996,
-0.5116968154907227,
-0.3211807310581207,
-0.05343703553080559,
-0.18281251192092896,
-0.6118718981742859,
0.1967564970254898,
0.45089587569236755,
0.5090696811676025,
-1.2060848474502563,
0.1499033272266388,
0.5855655670166016,
-0.31514474749565125,
-0.6526808738708496,
-0.07685355097055435,
0.26792842149734497,
-0.7488659024238586,
0.48153039813041687,
-0.06356148421764374,
-0.3780378997325897,
0.05339527875185013,
-0.5657371878623962,
-0.771777868270874,
0.7268746495246887,
0.530994176864624,
-0.7199471592903137,
0.3382079601287842,
0.03775976225733757,
0.4711296558380127,
-0.4355963170528412,
0.340567409992218,
0.7059960961341858,
0.4300377666950226,
0.12881913781166077,
-0.9711766839027405,
-0.6032459139823914,
-0.17549960315227509,
-0.03238144516944885,
-0.12080033123493195,
-0.40897268056869507,
1.021841287612915,
-0.19793395698070526,
-0.422985702753067,
-0.32423439621925354,
0.9544769525527954,
0.5453375577926636,
0.5371667742729187,
0.6474740505218506,
0.8037986159324646,
0.9618737697601318,
-0.18719995021820068,
1.0458401441574097,
0.029691627249121666,
0.15820951759815216,
0.8129180669784546,
-0.17247535288333893,
0.528841495513916,
-0.02169157564640045,
-0.5382645726203918,
0.3971031904220581,
0.5834843516349792,
0.16220645606517792,
0.34909889101982117,
0.4502732753753662,
-0.6510444283485413,
-0.25068768858909607,
-0.4780050814151764,
-0.5913920402526855,
0.871189296245575,
0.3816039264202118,
-0.008251422084867954,
-0.17051859200000763,
0.00034003343898802996,
-0.010223615914583206,
-0.2097744345664978,
-0.4080251157283783,
0.8343440890312195,
0.1323845088481903,
-0.2718120813369751,
0.5074743628501892,
-0.11216314136981964,
0.6633427739143372,
-0.4149934947490692,
0.15758627653121948,
-0.47966235876083374,
-0.360081285238266,
-0.3011960983276367,
-0.8701672554016113,
0.4887681305408478,
0.13904404640197754,
-0.32932528853416443,
0.21365047991275787,
0.2551710307598114,
-0.5672197341918945,
-0.34315547347068787,
-0.042349498718976974,
0.4599330723285675,
0.543407678604126,
-0.013345828279852867,
-0.5049353837966919,
-0.011797912418842316,
-0.19120675325393677,
-0.04800279065966606,
0.30237069725990295,
0.45694297552108765,
0.03734007105231285,
0.6357744932174683,
0.6343522071838379,
0.5469943284988403,
0.46850746870040894,
0.5672626495361328,
0.5036983489990234,
-0.4774250090122223,
-0.8655796051025391,
-0.8579708337783813,
0.48301583528518677,
0.010296394117176533,
-0.8185513615608215,
0.6433188915252686,
0.6680780649185181,
0.7711614966392517,
0.008398455567657948,
0.8751208782196045,
0.11475877463817596,
0.6394047141075134,
-0.06926821917295456,
0.8451333045959473,
-0.4670089781284332,
-0.08096170425415039,
-0.6194416284561157,
-0.858378529548645,
-0.05568660795688629,
0.6580146551132202,
-0.08130767941474915,
0.15580730140209198,
0.15502114593982697,
0.8538608551025391,
0.11174169182777405,
0.32829737663269043,
0.6602223515510559,
0.258545845746994,
0.22469088435173035,
0.09402886778116226,
1.1943740844726562,
0.052367571741342545,
0.3801829218864441,
-0.07561159878969193,
-0.18815277516841888,
-0.13913945853710175,
-0.5673127174377441,
-0.32875731587409973,
-0.645357072353363,
-0.5879724621772766,
-0.10117543488740921,
0.09311605244874954,
0.556431770324707,
0.8503459692001343,
-0.8954837918281555,
-0.5883449912071228,
-0.013401754200458527,
0.17499954998493195,
-0.5924596786499023,
-0.2815822660923004,
-0.2795819938182831,
-0.12517240643501282,
-0.8492162227630615,
0.5662060976028442,
0.5267658233642578,
0.1507798284292221,
-0.4707143306732178,
-0.17428165674209595,
0.08476562052965164,
0.44879668951034546,
0.6020894050598145,
0.43875420093536377,
-0.6891990303993225,
-0.20118504762649536,
-0.3364388644695282,
0.07625589519739151,
-0.05460275709629059,
0.8521559238433838,
-0.4364235997200012,
0.47252893447875977,
0.7283377647399902,
0.5319557785987854,
0.08792012184858322,
-0.1361134946346283,
0.8276638984680176,
-1.0141948461532593,
0.02475040964782238,
0.6873799562454224,
0.43189918994903564,
0.4190037250518799,
0.048179954290390015,
0.10568032413721085,
0.5131918787956238,
-0.4114408791065216,
-1.1263983249664307,
0.3634411692619324,
-1.0312482118606567,
0.0977993980050087,
0.9962122440338135,
-0.06230660155415535,
0.25466063618659973,
-0.3476882576942444,
-0.16558855772018433,
0.4966415464878082,
-0.4769939184188843,
0.6677446961402893,
0.6772122383117676,
-0.4246084690093994,
-0.29374778270721436,
-0.29265251755714417,
0.29587262868881226,
0.1475050151348114,
-0.7043439149856567,
-0.074766606092453,
0.7554762959480286,
0.12012405693531036,
0.4051295816898346,
0.39053064584732056,
-0.24123229086399078,
0.3012767732143402,
0.3904650807380676,
0.043516941368579865,
0.07080376893281937,
-0.3617456555366516,
-0.30394694209098816,
0.31523847579956055,
-0.028359953314065933,
-0.4288938343524933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10384v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10384v1
|
Reasoning on Efficient Knowledge Paths:Knowledge Graph Guides Large Language Model for Domain Question Answering
| 2024-04-16T08:28:16 | 2024-04-16T08:28:16 |
Yuqi Wang, Boran Jiang, Yi Luo, Dawei He, Peng Cheng, Liangcai Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Large language models (LLMs), such as GPT3.5, GPT4 and LLAMA2 perform
surprisingly well and outperform human experts on many tasks. However, in many
domain-specific evaluations, these LLMs often suffer from hallucination
problems due to insufficient training of relevant corpus. Furthermore,
fine-tuning large models may face problems such as the LLMs are not open source
or the construction of high-quality domain instruction is difficult. Therefore,
structured knowledge databases such as knowledge graph can better provide
domain background knowledge for LLMs and make full use of the reasoning and
analysis capabilities of LLMs. In some previous works, LLM was called multiple
times to determine whether the current triplet was suitable for inclusion in
the subgraph when retrieving subgraphs through a question. Especially for the
question that require a multi-hop reasoning path, frequent calls to LLM will
consume a lot of computing power. Moreover, when choosing the reasoning path,
LLM will be called once for each step, and if one of the steps is selected
incorrectly, it will lead to the accumulation of errors in the following steps.
In this paper, we integrated and optimized a pipeline for selecting reasoning
paths from KG based on LLM, which can reduce the dependency on LLM. In
addition, we propose a simple and effective subgraph retrieval method based on
chain of thought (CoT) and page rank which can returns the paths most likely to
contain the answer. We conduct experiments on three datasets: GenMedGPT-5k
[14], WebQuestions [2], and CMCQA [21]. Finally, RoK can demonstrate that using
fewer LLM calls can achieve the same results as previous SOTAs models.
|
[
-0.42617931962013245,
-1.0267573595046997,
1.0093469619750977,
-0.15332651138305664,
-0.1414356529712677,
0.18916520476341248,
-0.020280219614505768,
-0.4784921407699585,
0.015468109399080276,
0.6341122984886169,
-0.6608585715293884,
-0.7013239860534668,
-0.5669329166412354,
0.026076942682266235,
-0.08617492765188217,
0.5944689512252808,
-0.28291118144989014,
0.026663538068532944,
-0.4606512784957886,
-0.13285386562347412,
-0.40750589966773987,
-0.4041062295436859,
-0.7411683201789856,
-0.5187267661094666,
0.6687639951705933,
0.36614999175071716,
0.6676697731018066,
0.413807213306427,
0.5195097923278809,
0.19757525622844696,
-0.14452385902404785,
0.5775302052497864,
-0.4425045847892761,
0.2802901268005371,
-0.141184464097023,
-0.2559264600276947,
-0.45774462819099426,
-0.21045421063899994,
0.3687513768672943,
0.8543302416801453,
0.11138711869716644,
0.08173861354589462,
-0.11226105690002441,
0.7877867221832275,
-0.45333659648895264,
0.14698955416679382,
-0.5726330280303955,
-0.06364528089761734,
-0.2792114317417145,
-0.3171813488006592,
-0.3482356071472168,
-0.4944593906402588,
0.11121530830860138,
-0.5536479353904724,
-0.08175962418317795,
0.17513440549373627,
0.5979206562042236,
0.42470264434814453,
-0.5233358144760132,
-0.33082684874534607,
-0.47826749086380005,
0.5621469616889954,
-0.5474318265914917,
0.7198529243469238,
0.3868488669395447,
0.46023693680763245,
-0.3756835162639618,
-0.740100085735321,
-0.40562698245048523,
-0.07620420306921005,
-0.12745827436447144,
0.0035185953602194786,
-0.08889435976743698,
0.21963301301002502,
0.306344598531723,
-0.07460018247365952,
-0.6895295977592468,
-0.08624295145273209,
-0.13232292234897614,
-0.41253843903541565,
0.46854832768440247,
0.23657271265983582,
0.14687220752239227,
-0.09324419498443604,
-0.24872684478759766,
0.18118005990982056,
-0.9272125363349915,
-0.16078969836235046,
0.45016413927078247,
0.13839347660541534,
0.45833757519721985,
0.5836511254310608,
-0.35212308168411255,
1.0206841230392456,
-0.3394891619682312,
-0.39663997292518616,
0.05422775447368622,
-0.375600129365921,
0.1672322154045105,
-0.15637201070785522,
0.6267439126968384,
0.23728950321674347,
0.48146578669548035,
-0.41743889451026917,
-0.03061552345752716,
-0.2457689791917801,
0.10486983507871628,
-0.6718114614486694,
-0.26427197456359863,
0.2787179946899414,
-0.17046314477920532,
0.19495835900306702,
-0.36725130677223206,
-0.5023133754730225,
-0.4103952646255493,
-0.24538938701152802,
0.23804642260074615,
-0.6950376033782959,
-0.08475776016712189,
0.0822373777627945,
-0.0015097103314474225,
0.16124558448791504,
0.5227901339530945,
-0.6021566390991211,
0.23434969782829285,
0.5399971604347229,
0.6338567137718201,
-0.148416668176651,
-0.20590141415596008,
-0.4371377229690552,
0.20392616093158722,
-0.4006521701812744,
0.8878818154335022,
-0.5358195304870605,
-0.15687213838100433,
-0.250358521938324,
-0.19674387574195862,
-0.23414860665798187,
-0.5517736673355103,
0.4503138065338135,
-0.9783364534378052,
-0.06827626377344131,
-0.48936787247657776,
-0.6651816964149475,
-0.3840150833129883,
0.368893563747406,
-0.42603662610054016,
0.8824650645256042,
0.1726781278848648,
-0.8433218002319336,
0.17611126601696014,
-0.6120986938476562,
-0.5351603627204895,
0.06877487152814865,
-0.17706550657749176,
-0.039624445140361786,
-0.5141180157661438,
0.42802897095680237,
0.5161793828010559,
-0.37430986762046814,
0.08790270239114761,
-0.21478450298309326,
-0.23283885419368744,
-0.1726917326450348,
-0.07509560883045197,
0.8890663385391235,
0.305866003036499,
-0.22436608374118805,
-0.04578719660639763,
-0.5474252700805664,
0.33210423588752747,
0.2639412581920624,
-0.433627724647522,
-0.3676379323005676,
0.08438243716955185,
-0.6661970019340515,
0.08896427601575851,
0.08930861204862595,
-0.3045992851257324,
0.36261722445487976,
-0.1331814080476761,
0.31292614340782166,
0.8105176687240601,
0.19152911007404327,
0.14487439393997192,
-0.0580105297267437,
0.7040732502937317,
-0.10052433609962463,
0.0021393648348748684,
0.2660454213619232,
-0.8083907961845398,
-0.7035852670669556,
-0.062135763466358185,
0.31221678853034973,
0.6241076588630676,
-0.9190720319747925,
0.14006388187408447,
-0.28607508540153503,
-0.43336397409439087,
-0.41440853476524353,
0.2555842995643616,
0.34615257382392883,
0.603232741355896,
0.422187864780426,
-0.01644992083311081,
-0.4365772008895874,
-0.6883937120437622,
-0.3542617857456207,
-0.12650051712989807,
0.24553361535072327,
0.6037053465843201,
0.4810020327568054,
-0.25229379534721375,
1.0510540008544922,
-0.8063228130340576,
0.01738576963543892,
-0.4818764925003052,
-0.10049919784069061,
0.24640217423439026,
-0.0031370411161333323,
0.21119137108325958,
-0.678842306137085,
-0.5320379137992859,
-0.10506046563386917,
-0.8040869832038879,
-0.23422542214393616,
0.1855633407831192,
-0.4577869474887848,
0.08285896480083466,
0.49787601828575134,
-0.7548797726631165,
0.21187464892864227,
0.322803795337677,
-0.2305886596441269,
0.5543534159660339,
0.03683674708008766,
0.011464715003967285,
-0.6665907502174377,
0.04126480966806412,
-0.20261003077030182,
-0.4436052143573761,
-0.44728827476501465,
-0.015155619010329247,
-0.15935280919075012,
0.20747943222522736,
-0.2391921430826187,
0.5710601210594177,
-0.3540492653846741,
-0.2417827993631363,
-0.03700108081102371,
0.43079760670661926,
-0.010456409305334091,
0.6259959936141968,
0.05106008052825928,
0.684689998626709,
0.44371381402015686,
-0.5785248875617981,
0.6267479062080383,
0.2037832885980606,
-0.3288252055644989,
0.2716490924358368,
-0.41439342498779297,
0.6046979427337646,
-0.09418536722660065,
0.42868179082870483,
-0.8232825398445129,
-0.09729820489883423,
0.348023384809494,
-0.31674015522003174,
0.06192900240421295,
-0.2311789095401764,
-0.7449924945831299,
-0.43595772981643677,
0.013017931953072548,
0.32808753848075867,
0.3259281516075134,
-0.5414277911186218,
0.542630672454834,
0.5073772072792053,
0.07092515379190445,
-0.7108436822891235,
-0.21585974097251892,
-0.07450471818447113,
-0.11899013072252274,
-1.0057520866394043,
0.09514985233545303,
-0.11530663073062897,
-0.22440645098686218,
0.17594212293624878,
-0.25781071186065674,
0.07299511879682541,
0.09084458649158478,
0.012713024392724037,
0.09368766099214554,
-0.04883220046758652,
0.2126172035932541,
-0.05785330384969711,
-0.35710930824279785,
0.12645848095417023,
-0.5932949781417847,
0.6033239960670471,
-0.07269033789634705,
-0.5910239219665527,
-0.004491216037422419,
0.2695537209510803,
0.5321415066719055,
-0.03213905170559883,
0.579224705696106,
0.45311108231544495,
-0.32334840297698975,
-0.21406158804893494,
-0.50815749168396,
-0.14054365456104279,
-0.37359070777893066,
0.2788980007171631,
-0.5639953017234802,
-0.9397309422492981,
0.41475072503089905,
-0.3288397490978241,
-0.045122887939214706,
0.35784757137298584,
0.5400547385215759,
0.02530214935541153,
1.1083208322525024,
0.15750752389431,
0.13997136056423187,
-0.06626725941896439,
-0.4635900557041168,
0.5893137454986572,
-0.9057926535606384,
-0.4243992567062378,
-0.32318153977394104,
-0.04593248665332794,
-0.38362401723861694,
-0.5210196375846863,
0.6625263094902039,
0.2574206292629242,
-0.21886156499385834,
0.25214990973472595,
-0.41519156098365784,
0.5578811168670654,
0.6140848994255066,
0.10404171794652939,
0.49869322776794434,
-0.20985868573188782,
-0.5523145198822021,
0.24177393317222595,
-1.0395123958587646,
-0.47481563687324524,
0.9507091641426086,
0.22294571995735168,
0.7427268028259277,
0.15365400910377502,
0.5489571690559387,
-0.028591495007276535,
0.058306850492954254,
-0.8097056746482849,
0.8702855110168457,
0.007327662315219641,
-0.7398243546485901,
-0.4252084195613861,
-0.6488116979598999,
-0.8327085971832275,
0.23299536108970642,
0.02815569005906582,
-0.7351129651069641,
-0.10510493814945221,
0.1553351730108261,
-0.42356038093566895,
0.4446607530117035,
-0.5869928598403931,
0.7867369055747986,
-0.2118837684392929,
-0.3544214367866516,
-0.12736065685749054,
-0.8513941764831543,
0.37568798661231995,
-0.03256708011031151,
0.14350634813308716,
-0.052289530634880066,
0.2576487362384796,
0.7743386030197144,
-0.5418245196342468,
0.6171743273735046,
-0.22221879661083221,
-0.03076624497771263,
0.6277784705162048,
0.09208718687295914,
0.8157469034194946,
-0.21475882828235626,
-0.02366192638874054,
0.13490210473537445,
-0.07404731959104538,
-0.23109203577041626,
-0.749327540397644,
0.5530464053153992,
-0.6911170482635498,
-0.8005734086036682,
-0.1899191290140152,
-0.49144163727760315,
-0.7011138796806335,
0.2606666386127472,
0.23981331288814545,
0.3901049792766571,
0.3099925220012665,
0.09800291061401367,
0.6522412896156311,
-0.23818837106227875,
-0.019961843267083168,
0.1823158711194992,
-0.3302575647830963,
-0.14997614920139313,
0.7345420718193054,
0.38357478380203247,
0.3930678367614746,
0.3930797576904297,
0.28903964161872864,
-0.5797004103660583,
-0.7229148149490356,
-0.4088359773159027,
0.24103060364723206,
-1.169211983680725,
-0.26097604632377625,
-0.9414932727813721,
-0.407188355922699,
-0.5538416504859924,
0.148758664727211,
-0.1655532270669937,
-0.46116602420806885,
0.1505749523639679,
-0.28999999165534973,
0.5620138645172119,
0.7129877805709839,
0.05191965401172638,
-0.016553929075598717,
-0.7342337965965271,
0.4231241047382355,
0.6672853827476501,
0.34596389532089233,
0.11012264341115952,
-0.127727210521698,
-0.21031154692173004,
-0.16525116562843323,
-0.31335893273353577,
-0.8972955942153931,
0.05761515349149704,
-0.1998526155948639,
0.8243127465248108,
0.13845229148864746,
0.09640151262283325,
0.7267476916313171,
-0.5035051107406616,
0.5478941202163696,
-0.04165666550397873,
-0.6874017715454102,
0.5015998482704163,
-0.35471948981285095,
0.01697506383061409,
0.3620785176753998,
0.49156078696250916,
-0.4339357912540436,
-0.25512805581092834,
-0.5995264649391174,
-1.0036265850067139,
0.6319089531898499,
0.24292728304862976,
-0.37368252873420715,
-0.01002416480332613,
0.3737175166606903,
0.022341232746839523,
0.07979624718427658,
-0.4672647714614868,
-0.25982022285461426,
-0.018087636679410934,
0.02666843868792057,
0.25860801339149475,
-0.1998409777879715,
-0.18006975948810577,
-0.33706384897232056,
0.7509667873382568,
-0.26936471462249756,
0.20396363735198975,
0.17009958624839783,
-0.07504361867904663,
-0.10257890820503235,
0.18507303297519684,
0.10637389868497849,
0.8197707533836365,
-0.20288234949111938,
0.5032492876052856,
0.3725115954875946,
-0.2598336338996887,
0.07622943818569183,
-0.2113458663225174,
-0.024539869278669357,
-0.23492243885993958,
0.535341739654541,
0.6889632344245911,
-0.21914084255695343,
-0.7174429297447205,
0.4002757966518402,
0.21502520143985748,
-0.12593843042850494,
-0.13560251891613007,
0.2552645206451416,
0.4251125752925873,
0.3986363410949707,
0.0685640498995781,
-0.037611253559589386,
0.024169225245714188,
-0.39581289887428284,
0.08095069974660873,
0.4684862792491913,
-0.2693420946598053,
0.14069221913814545,
0.43313583731651306,
0.149558424949646,
-0.2851698696613312,
0.8849823474884033,
-0.4083090126514435,
-0.837074875831604,
0.40410855412483215,
0.4050714373588562,
0.615726888179779,
0.13537336885929108,
0.08417483419179916,
0.2421754002571106,
0.28422901034355164,
0.007176752667874098,
0.12996339797973633,
0.10681705921888351,
-0.9689173102378845,
-0.652428388595581,
-0.5111826658248901,
-0.42708584666252136,
0.1318299025297165,
-0.07821512967348099,
0.0673287883400917,
-0.29830166697502136,
-0.05395593121647835,
-0.2511135935783386,
0.11445937305688858,
-0.5504562854766846,
0.11897538602352142,
0.00124446046538651,
0.9832919239997864,
-0.5888411402702332,
0.8646409511566162,
0.5826842188835144,
-0.21057389676570892,
-1.0475972890853882,
-0.038339048624038696,
0.0065696691162884235,
-0.9532240629196167,
0.8049314022064209,
-0.029340270906686783,
-0.46134406328201294,
0.20144802331924438,
-0.49734237790107727,
-0.783906877040863,
1.2226495742797852,
0.4351249933242798,
-0.3002851605415344,
0.04198827967047691,
0.1249043345451355,
0.35243284702301025,
-0.30135631561279297,
0.16371232271194458,
0.6583342552185059,
0.6283791065216064,
0.4989008903503418,
-0.6562709212303162,
0.24796947836875916,
0.02080817148089409,
-0.15995550155639648,
0.1948825865983963,
-0.6478844285011292,
0.6478440761566162,
-0.4432860016822815,
-0.05760953947901726,
-0.17351876199245453,
0.2882820665836334,
0.5550506114959717,
0.24997949600219727,
0.7005563378334045,
0.6315445303916931,
0.9792320728302002,
-0.009454712271690369,
1.1880865097045898,
-0.17703357338905334,
0.28410130739212036,
0.743046224117279,
-0.18636175990104675,
0.4977814853191376,
0.4110592007637024,
-0.36940088868141174,
0.4541950821876526,
0.9139454960823059,
0.44133666157722473,
0.5663371682167053,
0.41994017362594604,
-0.08660468459129333,
-0.7233448624610901,
-0.000020533243514364585,
-0.2224431335926056,
0.3005169928073883,
0.21809905767440796,
-0.019899364560842514,
-0.3259027600288391,
-0.3817191421985626,
0.16789546608924866,
-0.22248435020446777,
-0.11180470883846283,
0.5019115209579468,
0.18158943951129913,
-0.8115420937538147,
0.5117549896240234,
-0.1688498705625534,
0.13241533935070038,
-0.6519179940223694,
-0.21190132200717926,
-0.34201475977897644,
-0.04078126326203346,
-0.3197039067745209,
-0.808399498462677,
0.24982686340808868,
-0.03669624403119087,
0.01816687174141407,
-0.2608411908149719,
0.8464022874832153,
-0.07896830886602402,
-0.2849559187889099,
0.5742255449295044,
0.8385090231895447,
0.3417355418205261,
-0.06801313161849976,
-0.6408616900444031,
-0.21046683192253113,
-0.03701213747262955,
-0.4514572322368622,
0.22516648471355438,
0.5879998207092285,
-0.20766597986221313,
1.0199607610702515,
0.7775779366493225,
0.09954014420509338,
0.06993186473846436,
0.22188840806484222,
0.9201629757881165,
-0.5278995633125305,
-0.28776171803474426,
-0.7848954796791077,
0.2126358300447464,
-0.07374105602502823,
-0.03854164481163025,
0.6921728253364563,
0.4574824571609497,
0.5938265919685364,
0.3072151243686676,
0.8573265075683594,
-0.06170693039894104,
0.6549103260040283,
-0.9152765274047852,
0.3817887008190155,
-0.4851524531841278,
0.6525288224220276,
-0.2937164008617401,
-0.8520750999450684,
-0.38815760612487793,
0.698932945728302,
-0.5756732821464539,
0.27258601784706116,
1.0588319301605225,
0.8212619423866272,
0.03379461541771889,
0.0037083893548697233,
0.1978195607662201,
0.22098706662654877,
0.3193185329437256,
0.7367932200431824,
0.9713540077209473,
-0.05700261890888214,
0.7745815515518188,
-0.09044712036848068,
-0.16108104586601257,
-0.1710105836391449,
-0.8343953490257263,
-0.7142590284347534,
-0.39213719964027405,
-0.2543020248413086,
-0.545385479927063,
0.20245878398418427,
0.7806879878044128,
0.6893100738525391,
-0.553983211517334,
-0.03792329505085945,
-0.22178815305233002,
0.7596825361251831,
-0.2640058696269989,
-0.19029274582862854,
0.6639441847801208,
-0.37546202540397644,
-0.3857438862323761,
0.40124520659446716,
0.26823166012763977,
-0.2747950851917267,
-0.20419014990329742,
-0.2399751842021942,
-0.27179938554763794,
-0.04699846729636192,
0.5853055715560913,
-0.007761660031974316,
-0.6073011755943298,
-0.6029689311981201,
0.2594618797302246,
-0.01616891287267208,
0.08024277538061142,
0.8208333253860474,
-0.7769278883934021,
0.3144139349460602,
0.6642580628395081,
0.6775920987129211,
0.542599618434906,
-0.09306195378303528,
0.40990835428237915,
-0.5668095946311951,
-0.39383578300476074,
0.2867307662963867,
0.44023752212524414,
0.24986785650253296,
-0.44066137075424194,
0.8879716992378235,
0.5443935394287109,
-0.6104702353477478,
-0.45916324853897095,
0.48769035935401917,
-0.8519395589828491,
-0.47227269411087036,
1.5465154647827148,
-0.19386926293373108,
-0.09364034235477448,
-0.5372134447097778,
-0.16886094212532043,
0.19948093593120575,
-0.07901288568973541,
0.4944154918193817,
0.7821155786514282,
-0.8214153051376343,
-0.15628407895565033,
-0.7395797371864319,
0.4482753872871399,
0.14815759658813477,
-0.741527259349823,
0.11371856927871704,
0.3615805208683014,
0.3040921688079834,
0.18304508924484253,
0.9363398551940918,
-0.041370801627635956,
-0.12045621871948242,
-0.023400550708174706,
-0.3207012414932251,
-0.1729268729686737,
-0.42794132232666016,
0.36047452688217163,
0.2972322106361389,
0.17890912294387817,
-0.04921509698033333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10346v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10346v3
|
Self-Explore to Avoid the Pit: Improving the Reasoning Capabilities of Language Models with Fine-grained Rewards
| 2024-04-16T07:30:11 | 2024-05-16T13:47:00 |
Hyeonbin Hwang, Doyoung Kim, Seungone Kim, Seonghyeon Ye, Minjoon Seo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Training on large amounts of rationales (i.e., CoT Fine-tuning) is effective
at improving the reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs).
However, acquiring human-authored rationales or augmenting rationales from
proprietary models is costly and not scalable. In this paper, we study the
problem of whether LLMs could self-improve their reasoning capabilities. To
this end, we propose Self-Explore, where the LLM is tasked to explore the first
wrong step (i.e., the first pit) within the rationale and use such signals as
fine-grained rewards for further improvement. On the GSM8K and MATH test set,
Self-Explore achieves 11.57% and 2.89% improvement on average across three LLMs
compared to supervised fine-tuning (SFT). Our code is available at
https://github.com/hbin0701/Self-Explore.
|
[
-0.5574631690979004,
-0.6484866738319397,
0.8887426257133484,
-0.0009407412144355476,
-0.10738722234964371,
0.0931355357170105,
-0.30912837386131287,
-0.24812771379947662,
-0.14885316789150238,
0.5712504386901855,
-0.634818971157074,
-0.31505289673805237,
-0.7442498803138733,
-0.00793712679296732,
-0.047688961029052734,
0.6687750220298767,
-0.21045061945915222,
-0.2298102080821991,
-0.18970711529254913,
-0.05408278480172157,
-0.5876139998435974,
-0.5041059851646423,
-0.6818066835403442,
-0.20617906749248505,
0.6471993923187256,
0.5883330702781677,
0.45488446950912476,
0.693936288356781,
0.47578033804893494,
0.3269072473049164,
-0.1840706616640091,
0.27964866161346436,
-0.6838610768318176,
0.19814081490039825,
-0.574670672416687,
-0.43558135628700256,
-0.28150099515914917,
0.10494793206453323,
0.22921213507652283,
0.32161733508110046,
-0.08733324706554413,
0.008136012591421604,
0.059041913598775864,
0.8340548276901245,
-0.7744298577308655,
0.25423598289489746,
-0.5963696837425232,
-0.20999276638031006,
-0.2960628569126129,
-0.4632393717765808,
-0.3470019996166229,
-0.04630477353930473,
0.09766651690006256,
-0.487991064786911,
0.045894406735897064,
-0.030521759763360023,
0.45893868803977966,
0.5410769581794739,
-0.12614743411540985,
-0.22073747217655182,
-0.5811922550201416,
0.9628430008888245,
-0.6266220211982727,
0.1408298909664154,
0.523925244808197,
0.42325034737586975,
-0.29720640182495117,
-0.3335554003715515,
-0.1770479679107666,
-0.31894469261169434,
-0.17228016257286072,
-0.11403454095125198,
-0.2289765477180481,
0.06366556882858276,
0.48401570320129395,
0.23127882182598114,
-0.4157218635082245,
0.0796344205737114,
-0.3443680703639984,
-0.26038655638694763,
0.8961362838745117,
0.22349488735198975,
0.3058106303215027,
-0.13215532898902893,
-0.2612927258014679,
-0.12997792661190033,
-0.8118214011192322,
0.3520401120185852,
0.043638091534376144,
0.3005480468273163,
0.20236597955226898,
0.7240205407142639,
-0.5958053469657898,
0.5737118721008301,
0.14812438189983368,
-0.04754595458507538,
-0.018448760733008385,
-0.23516781628131866,
-0.21849006414413452,
0.13149629533290863,
0.4477568566799164,
-0.08547153323888779,
0.40645623207092285,
-0.22523553669452667,
-0.40357086062431335,
0.1262774020433426,
0.4508211016654968,
-0.725802481174469,
-0.2835755944252014,
0.3338797092437744,
-0.14448198676109314,
-0.29543712735176086,
-0.3094787895679474,
-0.528392493724823,
-0.43481048941612244,
-0.4919317662715912,
0.5466184020042419,
-0.632112443447113,
-0.1888851523399353,
0.28807830810546875,
0.06228787824511528,
0.1170433759689331,
0.5700832605361938,
-1.090420126914978,
0.08521296828985214,
0.8801403641700745,
0.6665127873420715,
-0.029290853068232536,
-0.5280165672302246,
-0.7300881743431091,
0.01434955932199955,
-0.4642156660556793,
1.1547925472259521,
-0.46079230308532715,
-0.5081442594528198,
-0.4261505901813507,
-0.18641690909862518,
-0.12898977100849152,
-0.6579476594924927,
0.6126527190208435,
-0.3500280976295471,
0.01964246667921543,
-0.4279140830039978,
-0.5969570279121399,
-0.04310267046093941,
0.52740877866745,
-0.29123568534851074,
0.9904648661613464,
0.2891245484352112,
-0.528745710849762,
-0.002869263058528304,
-0.8233147859573364,
-0.1979987472295761,
-0.08110860735177994,
-0.368733286857605,
-0.021879082545638084,
0.35552066564559937,
0.6164965033531189,
0.2444399893283844,
-0.15688496828079224,
0.34790149331092834,
-0.39161404967308044,
-0.5921863913536072,
0.09659900516271591,
-0.3343214988708496,
0.5288323760032654,
0.3639403283596039,
-0.7403669357299805,
0.12124202400445938,
-0.621056854724884,
0.18354150652885437,
0.2602500319480896,
-0.16218115389347076,
-0.5625223517417908,
0.021991385146975517,
-0.6935714483261108,
0.3094820976257324,
0.13656660914421082,
-0.3701713979244232,
0.4008157551288605,
-0.6911079287528992,
0.17225797474384308,
1.091474175453186,
-0.2899100184440613,
0.6596789360046387,
-0.46137261390686035,
0.7324303388595581,
0.028803639113903046,
0.06577873975038528,
-0.4634486734867096,
-0.20469535887241364,
-0.8581064343452454,
-0.26320093870162964,
0.5453347563743591,
0.2565705180168152,
-0.4944208562374115,
0.2920277416706085,
0.009141759015619755,
-0.46186912059783936,
-0.6622288823127747,
0.24963118135929108,
0.17775459587574005,
0.3162469267845154,
0.5869699120521545,
-0.11287805438041687,
-0.2027893215417862,
-0.6963366270065308,
-0.5912878513336182,
-0.01069248840212822,
-0.07891098409891129,
0.4461025297641754,
0.26210588216781616,
-0.3741284906864166,
1.1482948064804077,
-0.46010613441467285,
-0.19967345893383026,
-0.15127572417259216,
0.358236700296402,
-0.05505431815981865,
0.6718822717666626,
0.28909045457839966,
-0.4339301288127899,
-0.4358946681022644,
0.07180722802877426,
-0.6314713358879089,
-0.3384769856929779,
-0.2077299803495407,
-0.16146138310432434,
0.17318928241729736,
0.6270990967750549,
-0.6072157621383667,
0.4817952513694763,
0.36384308338165283,
-0.43652406334877014,
0.5567384958267212,
-0.2891509532928467,
0.01277977880090475,
-0.468955934047699,
-0.13450361788272858,
-0.07534687966108322,
-0.2276255339384079,
-0.33114326000213623,
0.18092402815818787,
0.169252410531044,
0.02608547732234001,
-0.2577054500579834,
0.936231791973114,
-0.4351601004600525,
0.050935737788677216,
-0.5949431657791138,
0.2608773708343506,
-0.0599161759018898,
0.5147333145141602,
-0.16248342394828796,
1.0792124271392822,
0.7248327732086182,
-0.5873827338218689,
-0.09691301733255386,
-0.05773643031716347,
-0.31922465562820435,
0.11801190674304962,
-0.4492354989051819,
0.09313345700502396,
-0.24040287733078003,
0.03674768656492233,
-0.7478522658348083,
-0.13325312733650208,
0.25731927156448364,
-0.430131196975708,
0.18520331382751465,
-0.12401384860277176,
-0.05006437003612518,
-0.22282688319683075,
-0.3343401551246643,
0.47773781418800354,
0.45780351758003235,
-1.004380702972412,
0.6297577023506165,
0.2608593702316284,
-0.41266778111457825,
-0.6240564584732056,
-0.441800594329834,
-0.0772586315870285,
-0.34294238686561584,
-0.6671209335327148,
0.1285787969827652,
-0.29874739050865173,
-0.29282742738723755,
-0.20834797620773315,
-0.37136316299438477,
0.18120907247066498,
0.35118821263313293,
0.0006739551317878067,
-0.02758893556892872,
-0.21305876970291138,
0.2982640564441681,
0.2020852118730545,
-0.3975089192390442,
0.2947482168674469,
-0.2335786521434784,
0.6499995589256287,
-0.4717695415019989,
-0.4889301061630249,
-0.33192574977874756,
0.17147910594940186,
0.3210255801677704,
-0.32712486386299133,
0.22611497342586517,
0.4013514518737793,
-0.24993857741355896,
-0.18588966131210327,
-0.7222193479537964,
-0.2418927252292633,
-0.5671469569206238,
0.06039572134613991,
-0.6946782469749451,
-1.2505146265029907,
0.3051527440547943,
-0.4625548720359802,
-0.16226603090763092,
0.6872456073760986,
0.42349326610565186,
-0.22694869339466095,
1.2070611715316772,
0.5659737586975098,
-0.03594742715358734,
0.2522844076156616,
-0.2916848659515381,
0.28930532932281494,
-0.96001136302948,
-0.11157247424125671,
-0.5889765024185181,
-0.11366941779851913,
-0.6466887593269348,
-0.5289464592933655,
0.22528180480003357,
0.35231027007102966,
-0.18932291865348816,
0.17276272177696228,
-0.3852320611476898,
0.8505798578262329,
0.5825155377388,
-0.0010316827101632953,
0.33380770683288574,
-0.028281746432185173,
-0.2891820967197418,
-0.09884589165449142,
-0.9651497602462769,
-0.4927635192871094,
0.9727544188499451,
0.5506454706192017,
1.0344854593276978,
0.009025237523019314,
1.103692889213562,
-0.04613356664776802,
0.39025071263313293,
-0.8302278518676758,
0.4560009241104126,
0.060247212648391724,
-0.5305559039115906,
-0.6927180290222168,
-0.7533236145973206,
-1.0530123710632324,
0.3973678648471832,
0.07715170085430145,
-0.8837794661521912,
0.28619295358657837,
0.2956037223339081,
-0.6085934042930603,
0.11250331997871399,
-0.7601631283760071,
1.030512809753418,
-0.6231618523597717,
-0.5055921673774719,
-0.4444383680820465,
-0.22298452258110046,
0.5319483876228333,
-0.19840937852859497,
0.30615347623825073,
-0.22410711646080017,
0.29537108540534973,
0.46876591444015503,
-0.2804299294948578,
0.6880744099617004,
-0.05599188432097435,
-0.1526545137166977,
0.3952881693840027,
0.5345599055290222,
0.6823464035987854,
0.24774737656116486,
0.16804839670658112,
-0.10015938431024551,
-0.05655668303370476,
-0.5984059572219849,
-0.8578468561172485,
0.7796059846878052,
-0.524583101272583,
-1.177045464515686,
-0.6642854809761047,
-0.5460560321807861,
-0.34762856364250183,
0.20343667268753052,
-0.11373394727706909,
0.36643585562705994,
0.012709916569292545,
0.06213534250855446,
0.7216796875,
-0.17849098145961761,
0.3426673114299774,
0.3480091691017151,
-0.2027973234653473,
-0.09528285264968872,
0.8624539971351624,
-0.04210517928004265,
0.3397846519947052,
-0.020206203684210777,
0.7965242266654968,
-0.6275007724761963,
-0.6310017704963684,
-0.4832748472690582,
0.1277082860469818,
-0.5476281642913818,
-0.21207907795906067,
-0.6615232825279236,
-0.1612413078546524,
-0.519527792930603,
-0.21662235260009766,
-0.5797632932662964,
-0.3789655268192291,
-0.23657584190368652,
0.22125062346458435,
0.20018671452999115,
0.6015650629997253,
-0.3214346468448639,
0.49357831478118896,
-0.824776291847229,
0.08410315960645676,
0.4791666269302368,
0.5355014204978943,
0.016552327200770378,
-0.7279755473136902,
-0.27331122756004333,
0.17069709300994873,
-0.42982104420661926,
-0.35360172390937805,
0.44967010617256165,
-0.4480800926685333,
0.6798332929611206,
0.512100100517273,
0.1473613679409027,
0.8868183493614197,
-0.2879047095775604,
0.4266800880432129,
0.07335254549980164,
-1.022491216659546,
0.6535623073577881,
-0.5551378726959229,
0.5405120253562927,
0.7871257662773132,
0.36777275800704956,
-0.2572861313819885,
-0.24488137662410736,
-0.9115843772888184,
-0.5456831455230713,
0.8484593629837036,
0.21004199981689453,
-0.04182165861129761,
0.15337558090686798,
0.43890589475631714,
-0.17169903218746185,
-0.11905447393655777,
-0.9110870957374573,
0.21967355906963348,
0.022569863125681877,
0.009403206408023834,
-0.2521546483039856,
-0.30268481373786926,
-0.2933395802974701,
-0.40008631348609924,
0.740778923034668,
-0.38600584864616394,
0.07801716774702072,
0.40484264492988586,
-0.11016003787517548,
-0.2824975848197937,
0.45620325207710266,
0.5443076491355896,
0.6436457633972168,
-0.23767046630382538,
0.348777711391449,
0.2136470228433609,
0.06815648823976517,
0.06522217392921448,
0.11963198333978653,
0.04052679240703583,
-0.33074480295181274,
0.046975746750831604,
0.6625053286552429,
0.3486161231994629,
-0.9465760588645935,
0.3361192047595978,
-0.07264377176761627,
-0.08050370961427689,
-0.08478939533233643,
0.519737184047699,
0.09188541024923325,
0.43914851546287537,
-0.02037331834435463,
0.007108824327588081,
0.2095629721879959,
-0.6283162832260132,
0.1652255356311798,
0.46579742431640625,
-0.20655608177185059,
0.14941483736038208,
0.3716809153556824,
-0.009564246982336044,
-0.43810397386550903,
0.3781420588493347,
-0.4785573184490204,
-0.600123405456543,
0.576358437538147,
0.5695951581001282,
0.7636730670928955,
-0.3324151337146759,
0.19618725776672363,
0.48605045676231384,
0.5440611839294434,
-0.48314180970191956,
-0.061196137219667435,
-0.11483816802501678,
-0.5813815593719482,
-0.608563244342804,
-0.43672284483909607,
-0.41264188289642334,
0.14746834337711334,
-0.2339111715555191,
0.49214503169059753,
-0.2467411607503891,
0.19083407521247864,
-0.13415168225765228,
0.08116264641284943,
-0.30508267879486084,
0.26548120379447937,
0.10907100886106491,
0.990902841091156,
-0.2554893493652344,
0.934808611869812,
0.37262555956840515,
-0.06230754032731056,
-0.8520082831382751,
-0.026111893355846405,
-0.228870689868927,
-0.6516813635826111,
0.2963377833366394,
0.4089319705963135,
-0.24539059400558472,
0.022780273109674454,
-0.48028334975242615,
-1.2121248245239258,
1.0315574407577515,
0.12560883164405823,
-0.8072749972343445,
0.15581873059272766,
0.14026400446891785,
0.4814395010471344,
-0.4391731917858124,
0.35779112577438354,
0.819075345993042,
0.5258857011795044,
0.1137242540717125,
-0.6272079348564148,
-0.13390375673770905,
0.05497782304883003,
-0.20932967960834503,
0.25446173548698425,
-0.6056860089302063,
0.7763587236404419,
-0.47194305062294006,
-0.2643817961215973,
0.05090825632214546,
0.49741849303245544,
0.6413692831993103,
0.5832191705703735,
0.7905160784721375,
0.4572632908821106,
0.7959353923797607,
0.007626659236848354,
1.1307764053344727,
-0.21466097235679626,
0.6748178601264954,
1.4166582822799683,
-0.03490430861711502,
0.668701708316803,
0.47741463780403137,
0.06663372367620468,
0.28350555896759033,
0.7407611012458801,
0.23113779723644257,
0.5097773671150208,
0.43132004141807556,
-0.11393999308347702,
-0.6185991168022156,
0.31063568592071533,
-0.3298952579498291,
0.6662386059761047,
0.345213919878006,
-0.08044753223657608,
-0.5532251000404358,
-0.25348961353302,
-0.2180931121110916,
0.2250904142856598,
-0.3244907855987549,
0.5025976896286011,
0.0907197967171669,
-0.8908749222755432,
0.7299376130104065,
0.15305963158607483,
0.563071608543396,
-0.5090363621711731,
0.14284422993659973,
-0.4594268202781677,
0.06961830705404282,
0.056308381259441376,
-0.5612589120864868,
0.39545246958732605,
0.09335940331220627,
0.2729797065258026,
-0.26321446895599365,
1.0718190670013428,
-0.2910524606704712,
-0.36575958132743835,
0.49482646584510803,
0.8241569995880127,
0.08361010998487473,
-0.41155806183815,
-0.7696176767349243,
-0.11823850125074387,
-0.011561479419469833,
-0.5131209492683411,
0.6369680166244507,
0.5372440218925476,
-0.08665802329778671,
0.9315159320831299,
0.6863605976104736,
-0.19428662955760956,
0.014231651090085506,
-0.012988042086362839,
1.1201287508010864,
-1.0944287776947021,
-0.556421160697937,
-1.00394606590271,
0.37053969502449036,
0.055505212396383286,
-0.22980418801307678,
0.49939772486686707,
0.6182709336280823,
1.0418554544448853,
0.07956411689519882,
0.7285552024841309,
0.17209690809249878,
0.44731858372688293,
-0.6452105641365051,
0.4586145877838135,
-0.7505013942718506,
0.4427017569541931,
-0.1063283309340477,
-0.6129397749900818,
-0.08196838200092316,
0.9255357384681702,
-0.47748857736587524,
-0.09302106499671936,
0.7526659965515137,
0.8910582661628723,
-0.2476721554994583,
0.2732585668563843,
0.39957287907600403,
0.34474676847457886,
0.29590821266174316,
0.5064734220504761,
1.263513445854187,
-0.1345740258693695,
0.2781257629394531,
-0.5874748229980469,
-0.43725189566612244,
-0.02835603430867195,
-0.734895646572113,
-0.9677347540855408,
-0.083180271089077,
-0.082469642162323,
-0.36711353063583374,
-0.15853504836559296,
1.0432196855545044,
0.5010472536087036,
-0.6980592608451843,
-0.3309601843357086,
-0.3224778473377228,
0.31093931198120117,
-0.07869502902030945,
-0.16720038652420044,
0.1992427110671997,
-1.0697036981582642,
-0.7431260943412781,
0.8449885249137878,
0.32109805941581726,
0.051327385008335114,
-0.45451483130455017,
-0.18187160789966583,
-0.10595232248306274,
0.21593253314495087,
0.6793191432952881,
0.37152695655822754,
-0.7521747946739197,
-0.4432266354560852,
0.24441620707511902,
-0.06592804938554764,
0.280305415391922,
1.038926362991333,
-0.9545707702636719,
0.5365474224090576,
0.2168222963809967,
1.04900062084198,
0.5650476217269897,
0.062010545283555984,
0.4112558662891388,
-0.19815900921821594,
-0.07972366362810135,
0.20507261157035828,
0.3442613482475281,
-0.0842045247554779,
-0.5186475515365601,
0.8071543574333191,
0.08720619976520538,
-0.717583179473877,
-0.8419890403747559,
0.061679452657699585,
-1.107704520225525,
-0.4300134479999542,
1.1526787281036377,
-0.04851236194372177,
-0.3880102336406708,
0.022303970530629158,
-0.3580981492996216,
-0.042381398379802704,
-0.20444348454475403,
1.4194363355636597,
0.8083530068397522,
-0.44449615478515625,
-0.09880097210407257,
-0.45575082302093506,
0.5704949498176575,
0.8890008330345154,
-1.026368260383606,
0.33824682235717773,
0.28805020451545715,
0.3023342788219452,
0.1470658779144287,
0.9633828997612,
-0.19617527723312378,
0.2754061222076416,
-0.23656710982322693,
-0.17195741832256317,
0.011091035790741444,
-0.6751433610916138,
-0.7426995635032654,
-0.033508528023958206,
0.20359380543231964,
0.1564721167087555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13079v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13079v1
|
Relational Graph Convolutional Networks for Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-04-16T07:27:49 | 2024-04-16T07:27:49 |
Asal Khosravi, Zahed Rahmati, Ali Vefghi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
With the growth of textual data across online platforms, sentiment analysis
has become crucial for extracting insights from user-generated content. While
traditional approaches and deep learning models have shown promise, they cannot
often capture complex relationships between entities. In this paper, we propose
leveraging Relational Graph Convolutional Networks (RGCNs) for sentiment
analysis, which offer interpretability and flexibility by capturing
dependencies between data points represented as nodes in a graph. We
demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach by using pre-trained language
models such as BERT and RoBERTa with RGCN architecture on product reviews from
Amazon and Digikala datasets and evaluating the results. Our experiments
highlight the effectiveness of RGCNs in capturing relational information for
sentiment analysis tasks.
|
[
-0.4737379848957062,
-0.9488877654075623,
0.36187171936035156,
0.26866215467453003,
-0.48282361030578613,
0.15760432183742523,
-0.20095740258693695,
-0.6139791011810303,
0.47886666655540466,
0.40229615569114685,
-0.6873307228088379,
-0.8616580367088318,
-0.6938856840133667,
-0.06928710639476776,
-0.10661506652832031,
1.1508992910385132,
0.2095566689968109,
0.00473981536924839,
-0.44486939907073975,
-0.2787671685218811,
-0.09511374682188034,
-0.46284058690071106,
-0.6629214882850647,
-0.4539727568626404,
0.972029447555542,
0.15996620059013367,
1.1547554731369019,
-0.174971342086792,
0.4385121762752533,
0.22049570083618164,
0.031648483127355576,
0.4691433608531952,
-0.5094517469406128,
0.40046700835227966,
0.1222713366150856,
0.059444475919008255,
-0.3456280827522278,
0.11873810738325119,
0.5065444111824036,
0.9508901238441467,
0.1612803339958191,
0.15359169244766235,
0.15086066722869873,
0.7634661793708801,
-0.31464314460754395,
0.6646226048469543,
-0.22444042563438416,
0.45685049891471863,
0.1030711978673935,
0.11632850021123886,
-0.3960340917110443,
-0.6676770448684692,
0.2023230940103531,
-0.6390576958656311,
-0.1497773379087448,
-0.12917141616344452,
0.8919926881790161,
0.028496069833636284,
-0.29698699712753296,
-0.34296736121177673,
-0.6800899505615234,
0.5313353538513184,
-0.6000546216964722,
0.39618173241615295,
-0.07161601632833481,
0.21483579277992249,
-0.03866761922836304,
-1.0563455820083618,
-0.4741854667663574,
-0.12193719297647476,
-0.45486345887184143,
0.422595351934433,
-0.14965462684631348,
-0.16677041351795197,
0.07063949853181839,
0.335689514875412,
-0.4722376763820648,
-0.17695467174053192,
0.014316448010504246,
0.15528781712055206,
0.5727565288543701,
0.09525987505912781,
0.3238789737224579,
-0.49722856283187866,
-0.38459864258766174,
-0.0773606225848198,
-0.5356049537658691,
0.2718181312084198,
0.40197181701660156,
0.6052039861679077,
0.032052915543317795,
0.3634914457798004,
-0.1730933040380478,
0.6754665970802307,
-0.10749249160289764,
0.2875601053237915,
0.3004799783229828,
-0.1741153746843338,
-0.3828524351119995,
-0.2803547978401184,
1.4237064123153687,
0.3776930570602417,
0.6330382823944092,
-0.25365346670150757,
0.06070638447999954,
0.025531526654958725,
0.3046250641345978,
-0.9576119184494019,
-0.6531660556793213,
0.07276926934719086,
-0.9642083048820496,
-0.5633783936500549,
0.24099472165107727,
-0.8067036271095276,
-0.46904614567756653,
-0.43356558680534363,
-0.24528053402900696,
-0.1018320769071579,
-0.6605046391487122,
-0.062203098088502884,
-0.11840035021305084,
0.057098571211099625,
0.0632823184132576,
-0.5123512744903564,
0.4233262836933136,
0.7833335399627686,
0.8768059015274048,
0.14198501408100128,
-0.11728500574827194,
-0.33018532395362854,
-0.40280571579933167,
-0.1659444272518158,
0.761640191078186,
-0.47405847907066345,
-0.39989760518074036,
0.18362782895565033,
0.03501544147729874,
-0.09234140813350677,
-0.25009921193122864,
0.40292540192604065,
-0.9539263844490051,
-0.08759592473506927,
-0.30473318696022034,
-0.6017472743988037,
-0.4086307883262634,
0.802863359451294,
-0.8785865902900696,
0.6740090250968933,
0.23261860013008118,
-0.9972729682922363,
0.23131531476974487,
-0.12765388190746307,
-0.6186069250106812,
0.07195796072483063,
-0.24664676189422607,
-0.9476465582847595,
0.01226790715008974,
0.4702724516391754,
0.7869482040405273,
0.015760503709316254,
0.0950617641210556,
-0.9917492866516113,
-0.08578872680664062,
0.5290801525115967,
-0.10442188382148743,
0.9160434007644653,
0.33596599102020264,
0.16029469668865204,
0.016144907101988792,
-0.5503321290016174,
0.14366522431373596,
0.1469307243824005,
-0.2389194518327713,
-0.18742036819458008,
0.1595078855752945,
0.004002392757683992,
0.20556676387786865,
0.1483246237039566,
-0.44957759976387024,
0.16359515488147736,
-0.1827145218849182,
0.43581539392471313,
0.3232018053531647,
0.35200005769729614,
0.21379691362380981,
0.23216088116168976,
0.7094661593437195,
0.09743958711624146,
0.0889860987663269,
0.24730312824249268,
-0.431843101978302,
-0.3411705791950226,
0.1619270294904709,
0.2374473512172699,
0.38158583641052246,
-0.7387486100196838,
0.37825143337249756,
-0.6190617084503174,
-0.3789414167404175,
-0.16029146313667297,
0.16126306354999542,
0.1731858104467392,
0.6191495656967163,
0.12456526607275009,
-0.4697628319263458,
-0.47381067276000977,
-0.5315051078796387,
-0.42758721113204956,
-0.14263315498828888,
0.15799404680728912,
0.6191067695617676,
0.08955860137939453,
-0.32355210185050964,
0.9535737633705139,
-0.39345282316207886,
-0.3892577588558197,
-0.47663503885269165,
0.2878551483154297,
0.3767642080783844,
-0.020799420773983,
0.4949759244918823,
-0.8502614498138428,
-0.7808092832565308,
0.3094138503074646,
-1.1052355766296387,
0.26793384552001953,
-0.010285634547472,
0.0743536576628685,
-0.2585614323616028,
0.45383623242378235,
-0.7708457708358765,
0.09418436884880066,
0.5331357717514038,
-0.02397036924958229,
0.2515951097011566,
0.24501796066761017,
-0.19753983616828918,
-0.9030381441116333,
0.03863273933529854,
0.26923179626464844,
-0.7070430517196655,
-0.2639889717102051,
-0.27051323652267456,
-0.38900136947631836,
-0.4689458906650543,
-0.33119291067123413,
0.09191207587718964,
-0.45815348625183105,
-0.3503871262073517,
-0.03440205007791519,
0.5056613087654114,
0.3311716616153717,
0.44300171732902527,
0.061932336539030075,
0.1949266493320465,
0.3284819722175598,
-0.24259153008460999,
0.9549596905708313,
0.43484875559806824,
-0.2843928337097168,
0.3137040138244629,
-0.6631187200546265,
0.19176895916461945,
-0.18001192808151245,
0.4519886076450348,
-0.8785107135772705,
-0.036824628710746765,
0.7026141285896301,
-0.6941246390342712,
0.2734854221343994,
-0.35832664370536804,
-0.3438451588153839,
-0.32348671555519104,
-0.24586479365825653,
0.03225427120923996,
-0.024485081434249878,
-0.5706517100334167,
0.8966385722160339,
0.41868704557418823,
-0.02747366949915886,
-0.7458695769309998,
-0.6457157135009766,
0.005243564490228891,
-0.10453329235315323,
-0.6812201142311096,
0.014672682620584965,
0.45569366216659546,
-0.18788109719753265,
0.5212831497192383,
0.3714632987976074,
0.1859743297100067,
0.07865146547555923,
0.4868694841861725,
-0.03990489989519119,
-0.20063133537769318,
0.39849600195884705,
-0.28320926427841187,
-0.3136604130268097,
0.4720032513141632,
-0.39924439787864685,
0.39912840723991394,
-0.31005924940109253,
0.11947744339704514,
-0.4176861345767975,
0.37513846158981323,
0.3990144431591034,
-0.26107922196388245,
0.6754251718521118,
0.6400772929191589,
-0.081120066344738,
-0.4181921184062958,
0.03311176598072052,
0.0803162008523941,
-0.37101075053215027,
0.3737369477748871,
-0.30016404390335083,
-0.7535019516944885,
0.44634729623794556,
-0.3198932111263275,
-0.40338075160980225,
0.25503087043762207,
0.5049312114715576,
-0.3492419123649597,
0.8870519995689392,
0.3226158320903778,
-0.442279189825058,
0.6236494779586792,
-0.41168686747550964,
0.7987585067749023,
-0.6164408326148987,
-0.19506758451461792,
-0.1981775015592575,
-0.43918052315711975,
-0.7293878197669983,
0.23219901323318481,
0.07076291739940643,
0.07432244718074799,
-0.13015276193618774,
0.05288470536470413,
-0.514883816242218,
0.43348637223243713,
0.26927506923675537,
0.5142163038253784,
0.13661126792430878,
0.25889819860458374,
0.10996345430612564,
0.12470415234565735,
-0.45745038986206055,
-0.31869587302207947,
0.7534539699554443,
0.4831683039665222,
0.8100628852844238,
-0.20009928941726685,
0.3326278030872345,
0.3594051003456116,
0.48588797450065613,
-1.1180763244628906,
0.4058774709701538,
-0.5535903573036194,
-0.08625685423612595,
-0.18717172741889954,
-0.5876142978668213,
-0.9183605313301086,
0.07661330699920654,
-0.25084683299064636,
-0.23304559290409088,
0.3390595018863678,
0.020091110840439796,
-0.31642064452171326,
0.1411685198545456,
-0.4296213984489441,
1.1986892223358154,
-0.14019997417926788,
-0.07671072334051132,
-0.07811368256807327,
-0.752956211566925,
0.1569138467311859,
0.7216098308563232,
0.03546928986907005,
0.010782035999000072,
0.6004424095153809,
0.37886378169059753,
-0.3867408335208893,
1.0536335706710815,
-0.30309349298477173,
0.28242215514183044,
0.6852683424949646,
0.11492381989955902,
0.6308403611183167,
0.45538806915283203,
-0.03349979594349861,
0.23735792934894562,
-0.38141554594039917,
-0.134604349732399,
-0.8797853589057922,
0.8633959889411926,
-1.0136950016021729,
-0.008086597546935081,
-0.23519589006900787,
-0.29137885570526123,
-0.43305739760398865,
0.09657533466815948,
0.05939638614654541,
0.43021541833877563,
-0.48468589782714844,
0.2746444046497345,
0.3806864619255066,
0.24772286415100098,
0.3957330882549286,
-0.27515697479248047,
-0.6066132187843323,
-0.6667341589927673,
0.8483839631080627,
0.12771403789520264,
0.011298373341560364,
0.3231379985809326,
0.37514305114746094,
-0.3640175461769104,
-0.3483453094959259,
-0.4342333972454071,
0.2268974632024765,
-0.9168865084648132,
-0.34541457891464233,
-0.8301060199737549,
-0.24919743835926056,
-0.286989688873291,
0.15079531073570251,
-0.15527908504009247,
-0.4172171950340271,
-0.44870635867118835,
-0.49182265996932983,
0.5607244372367859,
0.7960197329521179,
0.21869836747646332,
0.47911810874938965,
-0.8893762826919556,
0.2070314586162567,
0.560924768447876,
0.30901166796684265,
0.24262340366840363,
0.3210081458091736,
-0.29106101393699646,
0.02682371437549591,
-0.2630033493041992,
-0.8808789253234863,
0.43591824173927307,
0.20477283000946045,
-0.019313959404826164,
0.38613635301589966,
-0.11089776456356049,
0.3471609354019165,
0.09491419792175293,
0.6873068809509277,
0.2131166011095047,
-0.7322083711624146,
0.4194074869155884,
-0.47031664848327637,
-0.059644535183906555,
0.48138779401779175,
0.689561128616333,
-0.6144788265228271,
-0.0773577094078064,
-0.37138208746910095,
-0.5222621560096741,
0.34889647364616394,
-0.030478324741125107,
0.30465754866600037,
-0.07924935966730118,
0.5768323540687561,
-0.17819495499134064,
0.2123304009437561,
-0.9792751669883728,
0.01606602966785431,
-0.6786157488822937,
-0.559845507144928,
0.018310952931642532,
-0.09897652268409729,
-0.09712298959493637,
-0.030571941286325455,
0.4520563781261444,
-0.27795350551605225,
-0.010562474839389324,
0.13640311360359192,
-0.19193975627422333,
-0.0068475366570055485,
-0.11401005834341049,
-0.20512132346630096,
0.5387763977050781,
-0.005937535315752029,
0.2066453993320465,
-0.1587096005678177,
-0.23916475474834442,
-0.33669134974479675,
0.18111656606197357,
-0.14052993059158325,
0.0041787088848650455,
0.3574514389038086,
0.7231537699699402,
-0.10971420258283615,
-0.04655295982956886,
0.6040143966674805,
-0.43007272481918335,
0.13626612722873688,
-0.351715624332428,
-0.39521658420562744,
0.5025831460952759,
0.2543703019618988,
-0.31228959560394287,
-0.0334797166287899,
0.12375017255544662,
-0.6741363406181335,
0.1953938752412796,
0.6715810298919678,
-1.0620365142822266,
-0.39315804839134216,
-0.004352528136223555,
0.13192054629325867,
-0.1233937218785286,
1.119611382484436,
-0.20443253219127655,
-0.5766346454620361,
0.5160905718803406,
0.33734026551246643,
0.8715559840202332,
0.09195214509963989,
0.6209002733230591,
0.2776397466659546,
-0.18222130835056305,
0.3907426595687866,
0.21324291825294495,
-0.03824798762798309,
-0.9826944470405579,
-0.3348968029022217,
-0.5086604356765747,
-0.5016648173332214,
-0.2958618700504303,
-0.5013230443000793,
0.11427579820156097,
-0.6531776189804077,
-0.25453293323516846,
0.030835356563329697,
-0.05249381437897682,
-0.6121339797973633,
0.5733859539031982,
0.05400615558028221,
0.23947298526763916,
-0.8483161330223083,
0.6061016321182251,
0.547542929649353,
-0.7128781080245972,
-1.0451539754867554,
-0.39389294385910034,
-0.43682169914245605,
-0.5008643865585327,
0.704251766204834,
0.22407136857509613,
-0.28321129083633423,
-0.1898306906223297,
-0.6153873801231384,
-0.3269404172897339,
0.9151712656021118,
-0.006999061908572912,
-0.3686077892780304,
0.20489773154258728,
0.332483172416687,
0.7643346786499023,
-0.8350107669830322,
0.20712070167064667,
0.3836468756198883,
0.34229668974876404,
-0.0665997788310051,
-0.029200680553913116,
0.018253162503242493,
-0.39830031991004944,
-0.14884977042675018,
0.19493982195854187,
-0.6273040771484375,
0.9441923499107361,
0.27579283714294434,
-0.11708485335111618,
-0.41460222005844116,
0.8866083025932312,
-0.16216354072093964,
0.29752713441848755,
0.5351574420928955,
0.7372788786888123,
0.7152155041694641,
-0.017506074160337448,
1.104817271232605,
-0.11138184368610382,
0.7868121266365051,
1.1127163171768188,
-0.20141515135765076,
0.8313748240470886,
0.1726597249507904,
-0.2649039626121521,
1.0112128257751465,
0.6544482111930847,
-0.05245300009846687,
0.3790665566921234,
0.2171100378036499,
-0.27982988953590393,
-0.4633149802684784,
-0.3045811653137207,
-0.26426294445991516,
0.18749266862869263,
0.506682813167572,
-0.5312726497650146,
-0.20919792354106903,
-0.11343656480312347,
0.20387206971645355,
0.1260957568883896,
-0.28201305866241455,
0.8970702290534973,
0.6796460151672363,
-0.4099486172199249,
-0.06090186536312103,
-0.5595389604568481,
0.08156022429466248,
-0.38795292377471924,
0.03892023116350174,
-0.11794941127300262,
0.3634624481201172,
-0.5916109681129456,
-1.077240228652954,
0.5876211524009705,
-0.30563077330589294,
-0.2864341139793396,
-0.27139905095100403,
1.0550183057785034,
-0.07568264752626419,
-0.8352565765380859,
0.8498319983482361,
0.5419806838035583,
-0.20738311111927032,
-0.25465014576911926,
-0.7409756183624268,
-0.09329641610383987,
-0.24960951507091522,
-0.5429447293281555,
0.17486678063869476,
0.6316470503807068,
0.15459534525871277,
0.43592774868011475,
0.6473383903503418,
-0.06300310045480728,
-0.15618136525154114,
0.5447636842727661,
1.0623027086257935,
-0.4974493086338043,
-0.4567452073097229,
-0.8389267921447754,
0.4303898215293884,
-0.24687588214874268,
-0.04711791127920151,
0.7989540100097656,
0.2617161273956299,
0.660476803779602,
-0.09937696158885956,
0.8167224526405334,
0.07764805108308792,
0.5301213264465332,
-0.30521342158317566,
0.8747583031654358,
-0.16751474142074585,
-0.03508055955171585,
-0.15021981298923492,
-0.9717202186584473,
-0.6858168840408325,
0.5497475266456604,
-0.38672012090682983,
0.08515896648168564,
0.5440561771392822,
0.5117589235305786,
-0.23116229474544525,
0.2790481448173523,
-0.16087700426578522,
0.23794934153556824,
0.46359193325042725,
0.37081968784332275,
1.1070152521133423,
-0.42366814613342285,
0.6189731955528259,
-0.3351447582244873,
0.16139867901802063,
-0.008203000761568546,
-1.0308221578598022,
-1.0701215267181396,
0.03277447447180748,
-0.5057362914085388,
-0.7309873700141907,
0.0034507012460380793,
0.6089605689048767,
0.5519026517868042,
-0.742145836353302,
-0.08670253306627274,
-0.38030117750167847,
0.44093626737594604,
-0.2568831443786621,
-0.23830987513065338,
0.5365246534347534,
-0.46301522850990295,
-0.35595399141311646,
0.12164392322301865,
0.07682450115680695,
-0.32218775153160095,
-0.39914971590042114,
0.015169383957982063,
0.08120205998420715,
-0.23336480557918549,
0.6534114480018616,
0.2683166563510895,
-0.37033528089523315,
-0.40865859389305115,
0.11398333311080933,
-0.01155297551304102,
0.28331419825553894,
0.9516985416412354,
-0.969755232334137,
0.5790241360664368,
0.8928617835044861,
0.643970251083374,
0.6015036702156067,
0.36153706908226013,
0.4021977484226227,
-0.9027887582778931,
-0.059720899909734726,
0.3432140648365021,
0.3848549425601959,
0.5929714441299438,
-0.3707551658153534,
0.18640567362308502,
0.18762747943401337,
-0.6330844163894653,
-0.043811533600091934,
0.3912768065929413,
-1.2079250812530518,
-0.1782035082578659,
0.9603030681610107,
-0.759402334690094,
-0.266731321811676,
-0.13154461979866028,
0.029545757919549942,
0.1725890338420868,
-0.23751822113990784,
0.5330591201782227,
0.5406619310379028,
-0.07638656347990036,
-0.2985222041606903,
-0.019157543778419495,
0.36108991503715515,
-0.05464332550764084,
-0.860225260257721,
-0.056024353951215744,
0.48449471592903137,
0.09701059013605118,
0.13874498009681702,
0.6249455213546753,
-0.1309933066368103,
-0.020455677062273026,
-0.07221389561891556,
-0.14168880879878998,
-0.18100862205028534,
-0.32350021600723267,
-0.20816336572170258,
0.6206483840942383,
0.04799741879105568,
-0.26375052332878113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10315v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10315v1
|
Enhancing Confidence Expression in Large Language Models Through Learning from Past Experience
| 2024-04-16T06:47:49 | 2024-04-16T06:47:49 |
Haixia Han, Tingyun Li, Shisong Chen, Jie Shi, Chengyu Du, Yanghua Xiao, Jiaqing Liang, Xin Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable performance across
various downstream tasks, but they may generate inaccurate or false information
with a confident tone. One of the possible solutions is to empower the LLM
confidence expression capability, in which the confidence expressed can be
well-aligned with the true probability of the generated answer being correct.
However, leveraging the intrinsic ability of LLMs or the signals from the
output logits of answers proves challenging in accurately capturing the
response uncertainty in LLMs. Therefore, drawing inspiration from cognitive
diagnostics, we propose a method of Learning from Past experience (LePe) to
enhance the capability for confidence expression. Specifically, we first
identify three key problems: (1) How to capture the inherent confidence of the
LLM? (2) How to teach the LLM to express confidence? (3) How to evaluate the
confidence expression of the LLM? Then we devise three stages in LePe to deal
with these problems. Besides, to accurately capture the confidence of an LLM
when constructing the training data, we design a complete pipeline including
question preparation and answer sampling. We also conduct experiments using the
Llama family of LLMs to verify the effectiveness of our proposed method on four
datasets.
|
[
-0.1502150297164917,
-0.8270260095596313,
0.9810993075370789,
-0.12929648160934448,
-0.14792490005493164,
0.16897204518318176,
-0.41924789547920227,
-0.37751927971839905,
0.1632591187953949,
0.5040271282196045,
-0.4672367572784424,
-0.574073314666748,
-0.6871045231819153,
-0.09657327085733414,
-0.1512693464756012,
0.6572182178497314,
-0.11876161396503448,
0.006962909363210201,
-0.13419918715953827,
0.41410771012306213,
-0.5344556570053101,
-0.7698613405227661,
-0.9713134765625,
-0.30298903584480286,
0.36081743240356445,
0.49925580620765686,
0.19598613679409027,
0.038194458931684494,
0.12925004959106445,
0.23643948137760162,
0.07302140444517136,
0.3077356815338135,
-0.583636462688446,
0.14436356723308563,
0.015342463739216328,
-0.6185889840126038,
-0.5736550688743591,
0.04943207651376724,
0.7040137648582458,
0.7386937141418457,
-0.4141269624233246,
-0.0709487646818161,
0.3596498966217041,
0.37406420707702637,
-0.7240440249443054,
0.20147857069969177,
-0.8765332698822021,
-0.008953251875936985,
0.06342864781618118,
-0.38528990745544434,
-0.5908944606781006,
-0.22924049198627472,
-0.18932543694972992,
-0.6509936451911926,
-0.18056488037109375,
-0.23699548840522766,
0.7046105861663818,
0.2411307841539383,
-0.21547630429267883,
-0.36032313108444214,
-0.7644309997558594,
0.9559358954429626,
-0.9798821806907654,
0.20349137485027313,
0.3846397399902344,
0.29335251450538635,
-0.3611515760421753,
-0.7925257086753845,
-0.6639750003814697,
-0.10926395654678345,
0.10754024237394333,
0.21552544832229614,
0.15462727844715118,
-0.2781629264354706,
0.2019837349653244,
0.3745928108692169,
-0.3613373637199402,
0.3031204342842102,
-0.15294583141803741,
-0.3875731825828552,
0.7460887432098389,
0.12378157675266266,
-0.29364147782325745,
0.1338348090648651,
-0.22384130954742432,
-0.3575039207935333,
-0.7218287587165833,
0.013312745839357376,
0.1808338165283203,
0.2827509343624115,
0.036076996475458145,
0.4748833179473877,
-0.24875818192958832,
0.533325731754303,
0.09191002696752548,
-0.44326475262641907,
0.4067741632461548,
0.1953510344028473,
-0.31412824988365173,
-0.021968601271510124,
0.5595901608467102,
0.228683739900589,
0.5302833318710327,
0.08008226007223129,
-0.3010424077510834,
-0.0517868846654892,
0.23516298830509186,
-0.6926068067550659,
0.12906743586063385,
0.1968332976102829,
-0.2712317407131195,
-0.20871151983737946,
0.02287815324962139,
-0.9864447712898254,
-0.4103573262691498,
-0.04905622452497482,
0.43022099137306213,
-0.4276721775531769,
-0.37968093156814575,
0.24082249402999878,
0.2092587947845459,
0.5767305493354797,
0.6284036040306091,
-0.721718430519104,
0.49713367223739624,
0.6694267392158508,
0.5387751460075378,
-0.08121414482593536,
-0.09358697384595871,
-0.8298244476318359,
0.07984616607427597,
-0.5458953976631165,
0.2902323007583618,
-0.5054591298103333,
-0.5150694847106934,
0.1141987070441246,
-0.14549283683300018,
-0.11219680309295654,
-0.44192540645599365,
0.47915688157081604,
-0.5102239847183228,
0.3058546483516693,
0.14235173165798187,
-0.9565098881721497,
-0.02676316536962986,
0.348270446062088,
-0.28105536103248596,
1.0695911645889282,
0.25863316655158997,
-0.4570835530757904,
0.0991312712430954,
-0.28869548439979553,
-0.185015469789505,
0.010601358488202095,
-0.5791498422622681,
-0.2626402676105499,
0.3369247019290924,
0.4631044566631317,
0.7515210509300232,
-0.10087959468364716,
-0.01202784851193428,
-0.13647150993347168,
-0.2810521721839905,
0.42048412561416626,
-0.4329811632633209,
0.5123050212860107,
-0.08536887913942337,
-0.31167757511138916,
-0.34726855158805847,
-0.5272261500358582,
0.3005428612232208,
0.13094943761825562,
-0.12231516093015671,
-0.28163668513298035,
-0.153054878115654,
-0.5553309917449951,
0.28672483563423157,
0.46383827924728394,
-0.5364645719528198,
0.2730367183685303,
-0.583163321018219,
0.07053307443857193,
0.8518134951591492,
0.3070215582847595,
0.12675829231739044,
-0.27548161149024963,
0.578497588634491,
-0.10263103246688843,
0.13732779026031494,
-0.04450095817446709,
-0.6572591662406921,
-0.6780640482902527,
-0.11865457147359848,
0.15630857646465302,
0.6241567730903625,
-0.5739189386367798,
0.5054778456687927,
-0.35452112555503845,
-0.39090389013290405,
-0.37880629301071167,
0.5746105909347534,
0.06754537671804428,
0.68381667137146,
0.40481382608413696,
-0.4548768401145935,
-0.3927365243434906,
-0.7838535308837891,
0.11107999831438065,
-0.3861205577850342,
-0.288653701543808,
0.44550594687461853,
0.35082945227622986,
0.11740224063396454,
0.6512154936790466,
-0.7230457663536072,
-0.306253582239151,
-0.15020541846752167,
0.2542697787284851,
0.37032002210617065,
0.497600257396698,
0.19253866374492645,
-0.6543510556221008,
-0.16886219382286072,
0.11349181830883026,
-0.6013659834861755,
-0.019775353372097015,
-0.13178203999996185,
0.03814378380775452,
0.355251669883728,
0.7899424433708191,
-0.6361262798309326,
0.4024795889854431,
0.6744466423988342,
-0.04848172888159752,
0.4861776530742645,
-0.19639790058135986,
0.20476189255714417,
-1.06932532787323,
-0.19715705513954163,
-0.24448832869529724,
-0.3280477523803711,
-0.18206460773944855,
0.013780590146780014,
-0.0027478470001369715,
0.2257937490940094,
-0.4586729109287262,
0.5242842435836792,
-0.41923820972442627,
0.1430334895849228,
-0.16987696290016174,
0.2830018699169159,
-0.11141636222600937,
0.49370571970939636,
0.20963558554649353,
0.4329114258289337,
0.5935383439064026,
-0.5342631340026855,
0.225154310464859,
-0.12674669921398163,
-0.3914104700088501,
0.5540829300880432,
-0.5195448994636536,
0.41230037808418274,
0.0026263410691171885,
0.08068208396434784,
-1.1565003395080566,
-0.1378883570432663,
0.0424836203455925,
-0.5536339282989502,
0.7040678262710571,
-0.09455187618732452,
-0.449774831533432,
-0.36099734902381897,
-0.11255066096782684,
0.032240040600299835,
0.9793980717658997,
-0.39626044034957886,
1.105346918106079,
0.07468563318252563,
-0.42404040694236755,
-0.8719263672828674,
-0.6807982325553894,
0.010151072405278683,
-0.37868762016296387,
-0.37936487793922424,
0.3127661645412445,
-0.12032128870487213,
-0.24903514981269836,
-0.3215581476688385,
-0.13832871615886688,
0.03181065618991852,
0.3595508635044098,
0.2817469835281372,
0.25796961784362793,
-0.18748414516448975,
0.3551826477050781,
-0.02675698883831501,
-0.008668932132422924,
0.01887158304452896,
-0.0738757774233818,
0.7323828935623169,
-0.10623779147863388,
-0.3582950830459595,
-0.3159978687763214,
0.16211922466754913,
0.23983167111873627,
-0.06637744605541229,
0.6270304322242737,
0.5301708579063416,
-0.5093281865119934,
-0.42015039920806885,
-0.769386351108551,
-0.4056825339794159,
-0.4535183906555176,
0.25150781869888306,
-0.25585150718688965,
-1.098324179649353,
0.23904380202293396,
-0.4000578820705414,
0.015731720253825188,
0.24697692692279816,
0.6552316546440125,
-0.27772268652915955,
0.7407328486442566,
0.8874565362930298,
-0.008497054688632488,
0.26644396781921387,
-0.03361247852444649,
-0.09474087506532669,
-0.8411670327186584,
-0.10740166157484055,
-0.25514042377471924,
-0.14233915507793427,
-0.2819991111755371,
-0.6926097869873047,
0.3183669149875641,
0.39657577872276306,
-0.004483056254684925,
-0.25074321031570435,
-0.02715141326189041,
0.21207022666931152,
0.2331954687833786,
0.25883081555366516,
0.2246675044298172,
-0.02132965624332428,
-0.20431292057037354,
-0.1419113278388977,
-0.4963989853858948,
-0.6996769905090332,
1.1997323036193848,
0.518152117729187,
0.8920401930809021,
0.16659682989120483,
0.960841715335846,
0.09323476999998093,
0.6022621989250183,
-0.8528274893760681,
0.5911626219749451,
0.011452033184468746,
-0.15561407804489136,
-0.40794503688812256,
-0.5089880228042603,
-0.8003957867622375,
-0.06402839720249176,
-0.36062824726104736,
-1.0641913414001465,
0.2187155932188034,
0.2513979971408844,
-0.40574613213539124,
-0.030781324952840805,
-0.4867163896560669,
0.5475143790245056,
-0.39409366250038147,
-0.27564510703086853,
-0.31122100353240967,
-0.5636990666389465,
0.42452168464660645,
-0.4143214523792267,
0.2685900628566742,
0.2005927711725235,
-0.2529368996620178,
0.5333409309387207,
-0.2692362070083618,
1.2853816747665405,
-0.11630966514348984,
-0.4637487232685089,
0.1893378049135208,
0.06902852654457092,
0.6510380506515503,
0.058990705758333206,
-0.21883553266525269,
-0.036365628242492676,
-0.26095524430274963,
-0.33466553688049316,
-0.9339939951896667,
0.7248689532279968,
-0.6077037453651428,
-0.8087605237960815,
-0.10771747678518295,
-0.49463725090026855,
-0.5991464257240295,
0.0002709623659029603,
0.1620142012834549,
0.1931687891483307,
-0.32017263770103455,
0.21584656834602356,
0.7055346369743347,
-0.29940828680992126,
0.46440589427948,
0.5129252672195435,
-0.5127609968185425,
-0.19556397199630737,
0.4332502782344818,
0.11236680299043655,
0.5227460861206055,
0.4236772060394287,
0.32313311100006104,
-0.2371564656496048,
-0.5967301726341248,
-0.07146608084440231,
0.2563607394695282,
-0.7468277812004089,
-0.2857986390590668,
-0.3502900004386902,
-0.24154150485992432,
-0.5756245255470276,
-0.045762620866298676,
-0.37117230892181396,
-0.5025811195373535,
-0.14780738949775696,
-0.20707611739635468,
0.3691067099571228,
0.6210827827453613,
-0.16525061428546906,
0.4925508201122284,
-0.5442314743995667,
0.10006556659936905,
0.6442202925682068,
0.042497508227825165,
0.0005528926849365234,
-0.6207232475280762,
-0.24561239778995514,
0.14255362749099731,
-0.30902478098869324,
-0.942642092704773,
0.5703648328781128,
0.2811405658721924,
0.7829709053039551,
0.2588088810443878,
0.053144946694374084,
0.474820077419281,
-0.33331000804901123,
0.9461492896080017,
-0.07098712772130966,
-1.0973124504089355,
0.6998761296272278,
0.12988492846488953,
0.006915668025612831,
0.2769010066986084,
0.6285552382469177,
-0.2096560150384903,
-0.5159379839897156,
-0.8246261477470398,
-0.8581625819206238,
0.005115885753184557,
0.047779083251953125,
0.21052290499210358,
-0.10332152247428894,
0.7208489775657654,
0.05322995036840439,
0.213423490524292,
-0.6329503655433655,
-0.042634639889001846,
-0.08087103813886642,
-0.30445730686187744,
-0.33449074625968933,
-0.2354767769575119,
-0.2190696895122528,
-0.042733944952487946,
0.8549057245254517,
-0.43953195214271545,
0.01902359537780285,
0.5389437675476074,
-0.267376184463501,
0.06441657990217209,
0.4250006675720215,
0.34092220664024353,
0.6808295845985413,
-0.23617316782474518,
0.1439899504184723,
0.4262036681175232,
-0.24132899940013885,
-0.11965933442115784,
0.04891428351402283,
0.18090340495109558,
-0.20510217547416687,
0.5298346281051636,
0.49488186836242676,
-0.10417751222848892,
-0.8179261088371277,
0.7351201176643372,
-0.10892221331596375,
-0.05508951097726822,
-0.5821285843849182,
0.16061735153198242,
0.24158217012882233,
0.2583100497722626,
0.5824655890464783,
-0.4450402557849884,
-0.17083048820495605,
-0.4712521433830261,
0.17439690232276917,
0.4740559756755829,
-0.31822651624679565,
0.09935964643955231,
0.0687420517206192,
-0.16976062953472137,
-0.12773168087005615,
0.7365374565124512,
-0.051228638738393784,
-0.4881135821342468,
0.44174063205718994,
0.6574131846427917,
0.46739891171455383,
-0.6246157884597778,
0.11156997084617615,
0.27359917759895325,
0.4631105661392212,
-0.07109227776527405,
0.3964780867099762,
0.13377059996128082,
-1.1067368984222412,
-0.8775058388710022,
-0.5797926187515259,
-0.47997406125068665,
0.39976516366004944,
-0.8346850872039795,
0.17946979403495789,
-0.566417932510376,
-0.27257877588272095,
-0.4383387863636017,
0.20444507896900177,
-0.8162487149238586,
0.48520398139953613,
0.36607953906059265,
0.9294823408126831,
-0.9496417045593262,
0.89404296875,
0.500243067741394,
-0.3273080289363861,
-1.0800844430923462,
0.07272209227085114,
-0.1954832822084427,
-1.0546693801879883,
0.7781462669372559,
0.09828457981348038,
-0.1695515513420105,
0.11951261013746262,
-0.8087151050567627,
-0.7014915347099304,
1.18227219581604,
0.28152233362197876,
-0.8242161273956299,
0.13697293400764465,
-0.05780733749270439,
0.6222681403160095,
-0.8588930368423462,
0.16436423361301422,
0.4625977575778961,
0.29470589756965637,
-0.03129533305764198,
-0.8828228712081909,
0.15886147320270538,
-0.09565358608961105,
-0.24698461592197418,
-0.10072515159845352,
-0.38270261883735657,
0.9849533438682556,
-0.23939567804336548,
-0.11874441802501678,
0.4066615402698517,
0.8200393915176392,
0.3393494784832001,
-0.04227551817893982,
0.6348184943199158,
0.47575029730796814,
1.1808415651321411,
-0.009182430803775787,
1.305160641670227,
-0.1898118406534195,
0.15394966304302216,
1.451943278312683,
-0.4803619384765625,
1.4338713884353638,
0.742706298828125,
0.20388907194137573,
0.8638061285018921,
0.39897361397743225,
0.2361835539340973,
0.2953215539455414,
0.3756598234176636,
-0.2225547879934311,
-0.6993743181228638,
-0.00443045562133193,
-0.3434930741786957,
0.4702668786048889,
0.9886284470558167,
-0.5342389345169067,
0.09015832841396332,
-0.09867742657661438,
-0.07111991941928864,
0.22979392111301422,
-0.39086079597473145,
0.6247493028640747,
0.3696367144584656,
-0.20910689234733582,
0.5913688540458679,
-0.3339882791042328,
0.6493563055992126,
-0.7262341976165771,
-0.33694642782211304,
-0.17213138937950134,
0.07825103402137756,
-0.0113399438560009,
-0.8407868146896362,
-0.057526275515556335,
-0.29366758465766907,
0.10101332515478134,
-0.08047661185264587,
0.707400381565094,
-0.3022412359714508,
-0.6295033097267151,
0.3578227460384369,
0.8854917287826538,
0.3128766715526581,
0.040022749453783035,
-0.44652336835861206,
0.07255197316408157,
-0.2513516843318939,
-0.3576536476612091,
0.1298726499080658,
0.491313099861145,
0.030300715938210487,
0.6996678709983826,
0.4538913667201996,
0.4668518602848053,
-0.1564318686723709,
0.05193183943629265,
0.7905628085136414,
-0.5225507020950317,
-0.2693624198436737,
-0.75765061378479,
0.3965983986854553,
-0.34765148162841797,
-0.23149371147155762,
0.5025019645690918,
0.2207552045583725,
0.84745192527771,
0.05844057723879814,
0.9248953461647034,
0.24318504333496094,
0.656423807144165,
-0.9878563284873962,
0.3537660539150238,
-0.5865653157234192,
0.4231763482093811,
-0.2591666877269745,
-0.7941094040870667,
-0.2581523358821869,
0.9405634999275208,
-0.44046223163604736,
0.17478817701339722,
0.7796101570129395,
0.8753418922424316,
0.25296783447265625,
-0.2457028478384018,
0.5680301189422607,
0.7122100591659546,
0.1812332719564438,
0.9992796182632446,
1.0533111095428467,
-0.33245933055877686,
0.3617563247680664,
-0.35744601488113403,
-0.4372689723968506,
0.003658236702904105,
-1.3567887544631958,
-0.7624588012695312,
-0.2522643804550171,
-0.3622738718986511,
-0.4217972755432129,
0.11357773840427399,
0.8619241714477539,
0.6680053472518921,
-0.6371907591819763,
-0.23859207332134247,
0.17616987228393555,
-0.008182684890925884,
-0.38457435369491577,
-0.23631422221660614,
0.3067895472049713,
-0.2750157117843628,
-0.7472132444381714,
0.5685033798217773,
0.04176768288016319,
0.2739573121070862,
-0.26053386926651,
-0.19791419804096222,
0.04323071241378784,
0.1380481719970703,
0.5889197587966919,
0.1429259181022644,
-0.4910186529159546,
-0.602199912071228,
-0.12273356318473816,
0.0054731606505811214,
-0.030991746112704277,
0.7761839628219604,
-0.9807471036911011,
0.09972262382507324,
0.034088317304849625,
0.8601177334785461,
0.6041579246520996,
-0.0940370261669159,
1.0033485889434814,
-1.0302215814590454,
0.03280682489275932,
0.3088104724884033,
0.603823184967041,
0.6620992422103882,
-0.5894543528556824,
0.5256005525588989,
-0.04798141121864319,
-0.3905136287212372,
-0.5474681854248047,
0.34242531657218933,
-1.057355523109436,
-0.4021417498588562,
1.1553617715835571,
-0.43544262647628784,
-0.04061039164662361,
-0.08190412074327469,
-0.2446517050266266,
0.21429528295993805,
-0.24696800112724304,
0.7198652625083923,
0.8137154579162598,
-0.16723766922950745,
-0.27927207946777344,
-0.4808011054992676,
0.3454124927520752,
0.5432018041610718,
-0.8298654556274414,
0.0337260365486145,
0.4892062842845917,
0.2507754862308502,
0.26249387860298157,
0.6991442441940308,
-0.20077566802501678,
0.138653963804245,
-0.11828009784221649,
0.12526561319828033,
0.16979648172855377,
-0.26817435026168823,
-0.275360107421875,
0.37388134002685547,
0.3730525076389313,
0.19317390024662018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10306v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10306v4
|
Balancing Speciality and Versatility: a Coarse to Fine Framework for Supervised Fine-tuning Large Language Model
| 2024-04-16T06:27:39 | 2024-06-03T10:42:36 |
Hengyuan Zhang, Yanru Wu, Dawei Li, Sak Yang, Rui Zhao, Yong Jiang, Fei Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aligned Large Language Models (LLMs) showcase remarkable versatility, capable
of handling diverse real-world tasks. Meanwhile, aligned LLMs are also expected
to exhibit speciality, excelling in specific applications. However, fine-tuning
with extra data, a common practice to gain speciality, often leads to
catastrophic forgetting (CF) of previously acquired versatility, hindering the
model's performance across diverse tasks. In response to this challenge, we
propose CoFiTune, a coarse to fine framework in an attempt to strike the
balance between speciality and versatility. At the coarse-grained level, an
empirical tree-search algorithm is utilized to pinpoint and update specific
modules that are crucial for speciality, while keeping other parameters frozen;
at the fine-grained level, a soft-masking mechanism regulates the update to the
LLMs, mitigating the CF issue without harming speciality. In an overall
evaluation of both speciality and versatility, CoFiTune consistently
outperforms baseline methods across diverse tasks and model scales. Compared to
the full-parameter SFT, CoFiTune leads to about 14% versatility improvement and
marginal speciality loss on a 13B model. Lastly, based on further analysis, we
provide a speculative insight into the information forwarding process in LLMs,
which helps explain the effectiveness of the proposed method. The code is
available at https://github.com/rattlesnakey/CoFiTune.
|
[
-0.3792184293270111,
-0.8538029193878174,
0.2999390959739685,
0.07257387042045593,
-0.08615579456090927,
0.005988717079162598,
-0.606008768081665,
-0.22170837223529816,
0.28261038661003113,
0.449256956577301,
-0.717217206954956,
-0.5105543732643127,
-0.5519750714302063,
-0.04542551934719086,
-0.3602340817451477,
1.3515483140945435,
0.11882433295249939,
-0.2124127596616745,
-0.11128653585910797,
-0.508473813533783,
-0.30903732776641846,
-0.22383449971675873,
-0.7058905363082886,
-0.42071548104286194,
0.6986270546913147,
0.5845388770103455,
1.1608344316482544,
0.7687422037124634,
0.6319044828414917,
0.29265254735946655,
-0.2379365712404251,
0.13700968027114868,
-1.0577566623687744,
-0.14034326374530792,
-0.540370762348175,
-0.42335042357444763,
-0.5948318839073181,
-0.24564418196678162,
0.4807499647140503,
0.9913665056228638,
-0.3044038414955139,
0.02936364710330963,
0.1467946618795395,
0.5187668800354004,
-0.4183456003665924,
-0.14299853146076202,
-0.6679542064666748,
-0.025955261662602425,
-0.39922112226486206,
0.040946684777736664,
0.006441438104957342,
-0.004051998257637024,
0.22534775733947754,
-0.6638328433036804,
0.295937180519104,
-0.000959794211667031,
1.055476427078247,
0.4548586905002594,
-0.1987351030111313,
-0.2605569064617157,
-0.7146151661872864,
0.7587987184524536,
-0.6948717832565308,
0.4108227789402008,
0.19407597184181213,
0.2042478322982788,
-0.3362308442592621,
-0.6253513097763062,
-0.3995582163333893,
-0.13901352882385254,
-0.010503873229026794,
-0.0869770273566246,
-0.0005444427370093763,
0.038556575775146484,
-0.06602629274129868,
0.751974880695343,
-0.4286686182022095,
0.4675562083721161,
-0.10404127836227417,
-0.36402150988578796,
0.7842782735824585,
-0.06596194952726364,
0.11046946793794632,
0.3271273076534271,
-0.2741732597351074,
0.14250034093856812,
-0.602043867111206,
0.19822080433368683,
0.6318273544311523,
0.35404258966445923,
-0.1838838905096054,
0.2984817624092102,
-0.36185917258262634,
0.5221803188323975,
0.36197179555892944,
-0.012115822173655033,
0.002511413535103202,
-0.1633676439523697,
-0.21588200330734253,
-0.1525903046131134,
0.716691255569458,
-0.04639098420739174,
0.16848859190940857,
-0.41146719455718994,
-0.342177152633667,
-0.1893284171819687,
0.12323302030563354,
-0.5292525291442871,
-0.39682328701019287,
0.097196064889431,
-0.0568537563085556,
-0.2364630401134491,
-0.05608464404940605,
-0.3325350284576416,
-0.15185591578483582,
-0.39894697070121765,
0.5237219333648682,
-0.3569220304489136,
-0.23190192878246307,
0.25700876116752625,
0.22590473294258118,
-0.1712283492088318,
0.2344120889902115,
-1.0373859405517578,
0.3673175275325775,
0.7743405103683472,
0.5358100533485413,
-0.44894179701805115,
-0.2924714684486389,
-0.6903935670852661,
0.1774241179227829,
-0.08179910480976105,
0.6623438000679016,
-0.7446719408035278,
0.046174950897693634,
-0.31974077224731445,
0.05512120574712753,
0.018026290461421013,
-0.4988577365875244,
0.8344122767448425,
-0.49461430311203003,
-0.17712651193141937,
-0.12451177835464478,
-0.5874497294425964,
-0.33964329957962036,
0.24122610688209534,
-0.8417522311210632,
0.8940212726593018,
0.2503375709056854,
-0.5070911049842834,
0.15387742221355438,
-0.10272934287786484,
-0.44715774059295654,
0.061922505497932434,
-0.3212001621723175,
-0.8078158497810364,
0.26760637760162354,
-0.0367177352309227,
0.6168482303619385,
-0.26323771476745605,
0.9590699076652527,
-0.5879271030426025,
-0.617637038230896,
-0.06107592582702637,
-0.4123515486717224,
0.5647867918014526,
0.15201030671596527,
-0.2992790937423706,
0.1346832513809204,
-0.8862219452857971,
-0.15831485390663147,
-0.036342233419418335,
-0.5683562159538269,
-0.3056897222995758,
-0.0492556057870388,
0.08043821901082993,
0.03222260624170303,
0.27950185537338257,
-0.2466319501399994,
-0.005467724986374378,
-0.5367814898490906,
0.4936114251613617,
0.6911313533782959,
-0.41768836975097656,
0.655536413192749,
-0.4621521532535553,
0.21138639748096466,
0.1037435457110405,
0.015357814729213715,
0.032676149159669876,
-0.23757468163967133,
-0.8920699954032898,
-0.4009501338005066,
0.3537466526031494,
0.44765326380729675,
-0.2553698718547821,
0.6239241361618042,
-0.28673654794692993,
-0.45474472641944885,
-0.5485314726829529,
0.4611869156360626,
0.41345298290252686,
0.3391309976577759,
0.24239131808280945,
-0.42809516191482544,
-0.48475542664527893,
-1.1265290975570679,
-0.5700021386146545,
0.1511618196964264,
0.24535903334617615,
0.3868897557258606,
0.3368194103240967,
-0.4878615736961365,
0.9774528741836548,
-0.27837833762168884,
-0.45361337065696716,
-0.02634025551378727,
-0.03531034663319588,
0.39846867322921753,
0.646237313747406,
0.359442800283432,
-0.835105299949646,
-0.20437762141227722,
0.19579128921031952,
-0.4483928978443146,
-0.2238686978816986,
-0.1569449007511139,
0.011014002375304699,
0.06334798038005829,
0.4814756512641907,
-0.45281654596328735,
0.056777019053697586,
0.8094770908355713,
-0.2572981119155884,
0.2842697501182556,
-0.1551315039396286,
-0.09699701517820358,
-0.9554222226142883,
0.14980578422546387,
-0.09691750258207321,
-0.3567439615726471,
-0.5659166574478149,
0.3774971663951874,
-0.09215345233678818,
0.13775008916854858,
-0.32489925622940063,
0.5535862445831299,
-0.03734568879008293,
0.26030993461608887,
0.18217960000038147,
0.02024703659117222,
0.003885234473273158,
0.5748612880706787,
-0.21771830320358276,
0.5462999939918518,
0.4515373408794403,
-0.602849006652832,
0.25413694977760315,
-0.022560859099030495,
0.09328159689903259,
0.6183794736862183,
-0.3743251860141754,
0.1117045134305954,
-0.10818013548851013,
-0.02713717706501484,
-1.0243366956710815,
-0.390717476606369,
-0.12186583131551743,
-0.12780143320560455,
0.5759839415550232,
-0.17261074483394623,
-0.21238455176353455,
-0.1333523392677307,
-0.21127644181251526,
0.42362648248672485,
0.07832466810941696,
-0.44771215319633484,
0.6239038705825806,
0.3614346385002136,
-0.40086349844932556,
-0.39825645089149475,
-0.6012488007545471,
0.22807784378528595,
-0.1341300755739212,
-0.8263496160507202,
0.5179267525672913,
-0.21381521224975586,
-0.05873093754053116,
-0.0897805467247963,
-0.269221693277359,
-0.08347972482442856,
0.35164114832878113,
-0.06154491379857063,
-0.04665566235780716,
-0.2788335978984833,
0.1678372472524643,
0.279095858335495,
-0.19177599251270294,
-0.3838110566139221,
-0.4547698199748993,
0.3881191313266754,
-0.45661211013793945,
-0.4221342206001282,
-0.3871217370033264,
0.29372137784957886,
0.33323726058006287,
-0.15641449391841888,
0.6285690665245056,
0.7965601086616516,
-0.32926642894744873,
-0.019212624058127403,
-0.7793049812316895,
-0.15886178612709045,
-0.5017181038856506,
0.5623185038566589,
-0.3316420614719391,
-1.3739452362060547,
0.5922701954841614,
-0.18994563817977905,
0.09407627582550049,
0.456661581993103,
0.4515531063079834,
-0.1312955915927887,
0.797905683517456,
0.8509291410446167,
-0.007888691499829292,
0.28366905450820923,
-0.13772952556610107,
0.4810055196285248,
-0.401338130235672,
-0.1684073954820633,
-0.2560397982597351,
-0.5738054513931274,
-0.6145774722099304,
-0.18214577436447144,
0.13004592061042786,
0.42762476205825806,
-0.22367283701896667,
0.2829369306564331,
-0.26610469818115234,
0.34133610129356384,
0.23769886791706085,
0.004000112414360046,
0.5004456043243408,
-0.01207515224814415,
-0.23154625296592712,
-0.09291094541549683,
-0.8600831031799316,
-0.502334475517273,
0.7195619344711304,
0.41746240854263306,
0.9523041844367981,
0.08466450124979019,
0.7906336784362793,
0.008627712726593018,
0.14210879802703857,
-0.8301246762275696,
0.45293721556663513,
-0.548275351524353,
-0.46736079454421997,
-0.38234177231788635,
-0.43601128458976746,
-0.6121043562889099,
-0.0707140639424324,
-0.36841878294944763,
-0.5776212811470032,
0.1394243687391281,
0.5683167576789856,
-0.5664827227592468,
0.2951730489730835,
-0.7620790004730225,
0.7063815593719482,
-0.16234347224235535,
-0.8605036735534668,
-0.3238297402858734,
-0.5066476464271545,
0.2938448488712311,
-0.4217604696750641,
0.3504246771335602,
-0.15302270650863647,
-0.10450413823127747,
0.6721451878547668,
-0.1974378079175949,
0.9903910756111145,
0.16511718928813934,
-0.2929624915122986,
0.03580006957054138,
0.22173801064491272,
0.6578365564346313,
0.3099312484264374,
-0.26966801285743713,
0.31228843331336975,
0.04617374390363693,
-0.45586952567100525,
-0.28399577736854553,
1.0666816234588623,
-0.5897409915924072,
-0.9220718741416931,
-0.024217309430241585,
-0.9427148699760437,
-0.24592255055904388,
0.4778473377227783,
0.12459859997034073,
0.20035922527313232,
-0.39529016613960266,
0.4157446622848511,
0.9511756300926208,
-0.16780221462249756,
0.39029425382614136,
0.4766332805156708,
0.05397374927997589,
-0.2867734134197235,
0.912609338760376,
0.35761332511901855,
0.36657238006591797,
0.47499701380729675,
0.4159904420375824,
0.10368142277002335,
-0.7157866954803467,
-0.2603355646133423,
0.17156998813152313,
-0.3818429708480835,
-0.24433569610118866,
-0.6542815566062927,
-0.3107081949710846,
-0.29193806648254395,
-0.40209344029426575,
-0.7445178627967834,
-0.5178090929985046,
-0.35015255212783813,
0.16361910104751587,
0.48110905289649963,
0.6078176498413086,
-0.007108053658157587,
0.47680139541625977,
-0.674774706363678,
0.12619827687740326,
0.2993762493133545,
0.7398146390914917,
-0.13340798020362854,
-0.6668769717216492,
-0.41575220227241516,
0.14609041810035706,
-0.44436880946159363,
-0.08831696957349777,
-0.021192528307437897,
0.5963181853294373,
0.5100685358047485,
0.40999674797058105,
-0.00597431929782033,
0.8561829924583435,
-0.3766811788082123,
0.3600350022315979,
0.07434768974781036,
-0.8363444209098816,
0.22882957756519318,
-0.578217625617981,
0.4334174692630768,
0.7195480465888977,
0.24068333208560944,
-0.4505038559436798,
-0.6788682341575623,
-0.7117526531219482,
-0.8100855350494385,
0.6291618347167969,
0.1499083787202835,
0.2861447036266327,
0.31137943267822266,
0.4552638530731201,
0.449727863073349,
0.030266229063272476,
-0.5991827249526978,
0.07599371671676636,
0.1865483671426773,
-0.481383353471756,
-0.06040199100971222,
-0.12453088909387589,
-0.2359815090894699,
-0.18891559541225433,
0.6154439449310303,
-0.3258761167526245,
-0.1415952742099762,
0.04831993952393532,
-0.2328188568353653,
-0.18335361778736115,
0.4627825915813446,
0.39174726605415344,
0.5610477328300476,
0.031162580475211143,
0.13576476275920868,
0.4782097339630127,
-0.5006322860717773,
-0.08205258101224899,
0.10717543214559555,
-0.1891767978668213,
-0.29653000831604004,
0.5282963514328003,
0.6583272218704224,
0.6485570669174194,
-0.5740153193473816,
0.4662730097770691,
0.08256491273641586,
-0.2109723687171936,
0.01637416146695614,
0.4463028311729431,
0.41330257058143616,
0.32758402824401855,
0.12178939580917358,
0.5324760675430298,
0.01805896684527397,
-0.5380873680114746,
0.3630315959453583,
0.37731051445007324,
-0.520837128162384,
-0.5004091858863831,
0.5555294156074524,
0.12414557486772537,
-0.4811279773712158,
0.28708377480506897,
-0.13660626113414764,
-0.27496927976608276,
0.4237004518508911,
0.4851481318473816,
0.6177927851676941,
-0.3597550094127655,
-0.11551667749881744,
0.044596992433071136,
0.13416703045368195,
-0.3119029104709625,
0.24297629296779633,
0.08728154748678207,
-0.6422275900840759,
-0.23180651664733887,
-0.7410348057746887,
-0.03382539376616478,
0.14544765651226044,
-0.6171407699584961,
0.5921536087989807,
-0.6245464086532593,
-0.1942942887544632,
-0.14862731099128723,
-0.056769486516714096,
-0.7809983491897583,
0.35616907477378845,
0.09716996550559998,
0.9607899785041809,
-0.9440281391143799,
0.7906366586685181,
0.5848216414451599,
0.015631984919309616,
-0.8242588043212891,
0.032696813344955444,
0.04493201896548271,
-0.6407849192619324,
0.2085396647453308,
0.16104605793952942,
-0.25648266077041626,
0.25369271636009216,
-0.38537245988845825,
-1.0514165163040161,
1.1533641815185547,
0.7773630619049072,
-1.1389607191085815,
-0.07592182606458664,
0.10163338482379913,
0.5992743372917175,
-0.3479614555835724,
-0.028598206117749214,
0.8307803273200989,
0.2934333384037018,
0.3004312813282013,
-1.0710939168930054,
0.029622089117765427,
-0.03214479237794876,
0.007658825255930424,
0.1525958776473999,
-0.9830543398857117,
0.7405332922935486,
-0.2512969970703125,
-0.06281434744596481,
0.11963756382465363,
0.49231258034706116,
0.014377642422914505,
0.2332414984703064,
0.3168887794017792,
1.0420961380004883,
0.97309809923172,
-0.11153803765773773,
0.6233322024345398,
-0.05651240423321724,
0.5020214319229126,
1.1050915718078613,
-0.14540907740592957,
0.7654550671577454,
0.7097572088241577,
0.05108688399195671,
0.23716646432876587,
0.46652787923812866,
0.12034918367862701,
0.4675424098968506,
0.05365012586116791,
-0.08339651674032211,
-0.4243723452091217,
-0.11363905668258667,
-0.06316299736499786,
0.4963671863079071,
0.4379674196243286,
-0.09623818844556808,
-0.3669711947441101,
-0.044877875596284866,
0.12675946950912476,
0.31034693121910095,
-0.37564530968666077,
0.6877886056900024,
0.2914862036705017,
-0.7759451270103455,
0.7895287871360779,
0.039727162569761276,
0.7644909024238586,
-0.5222800970077515,
0.2413780838251114,
-0.2690396010875702,
0.5756019949913025,
-0.6040812730789185,
-0.6662595868110657,
0.5669703483581543,
-0.2703850269317627,
-0.2870495915412903,
-0.18030381202697754,
0.4614839255809784,
-0.5966624021530151,
-0.5421317219734192,
0.37932640314102173,
0.20452967286109924,
-0.2758636474609375,
0.2898552715778351,
-0.6704548597335815,
0.25778433680534363,
-0.07882789522409439,
0.00493529113009572,
0.25884151458740234,
0.5742893815040588,
-0.43155449628829956,
0.5962455868721008,
0.39385828375816345,
0.007039014715701342,
-0.16523221135139465,
0.24287644028663635,
1.0082255601882935,
-0.46270883083343506,
-0.5526067614555359,
-1.0535192489624023,
0.25460317730903625,
0.13227415084838867,
-0.4150948226451874,
0.4138311445713043,
0.6900617480278015,
1.0276210308074951,
0.10941389948129654,
0.5078045725822449,
0.038143858313560486,
0.21059368550777435,
-0.5190371870994568,
0.7784045338630676,
-0.6229997277259827,
0.5451685190200806,
-0.14178121089935303,
-0.7699384093284607,
-0.5803709626197815,
0.40080246329307556,
-0.41471782326698303,
-0.03447277098894119,
0.5676800608634949,
1.3120508193969727,
-0.6214361190795898,
0.15261417627334595,
0.3714403510093689,
0.3988860547542572,
0.24126984179019928,
0.7175224423408508,
0.5417799949645996,
-0.4934183955192566,
0.6143736839294434,
0.03643146902322769,
-0.3512972593307495,
-0.35961881279945374,
-0.954340934753418,
-0.9825038909912109,
-0.38293662667274475,
-0.34142401814460754,
-0.15146999061107635,
0.20855286717414856,
0.9775679707527161,
0.9051530361175537,
-0.9960958361625671,
-0.19649066030979156,
-0.2827674448490143,
0.10535014420747757,
-0.13047148287296295,
-0.12579207122325897,
0.1083594337105751,
-0.4262242615222931,
-0.5674159526824951,
0.011218699626624584,
0.6348583102226257,
-0.07792641222476959,
-0.11690215021371841,
-0.24428845942020416,
-0.3610399067401886,
0.07078453153371811,
0.3574856221675873,
0.1393253207206726,
-0.7316233515739441,
-0.3552563786506653,
-0.13967154920101166,
-0.13137078285217285,
0.16662012040615082,
0.7611258625984192,
-0.5297272801399231,
0.24688933789730072,
0.4384074807167053,
0.9494138360023499,
0.3819099962711334,
-0.41054245829582214,
0.7563357353210449,
-0.821929395198822,
0.16977334022521973,
0.18717989325523376,
0.2742288112640381,
0.5328516960144043,
-0.6219184398651123,
0.14589738845825195,
0.26798585057258606,
-0.42328929901123047,
-0.5012602210044861,
0.33574917912483215,
-0.8184517621994019,
-0.060775723308324814,
0.9776187539100647,
-0.28453803062438965,
-0.19412876665592194,
-0.06705444306135178,
-0.23664657771587372,
0.24772070348262787,
-0.25779208540916443,
0.7919096946716309,
0.7892945408821106,
0.20970506966114044,
-0.01649835705757141,
-0.2434564083814621,
0.4450511336326599,
0.6538260579109192,
-0.4140227138996124,
-0.07631398737430573,
0.03161012753844261,
0.5414255261421204,
-0.01610189862549305,
0.31981992721557617,
0.039604585617780685,
0.11628503352403641,
-0.49031755328178406,
-0.4292248785495758,
-0.11821745336055756,
-0.3036421835422516,
-0.4561913013458252,
0.0034237902145832777,
0.1928340047597885,
0.4807681143283844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06656v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06656v1
|
Exploring Social Media Posts for Depression Identification: A Study on Reddit Dataset
| 2024-04-16T06:25:51 | 2024-04-16T06:25:51 |
Nandigramam Sai Harshit, Nilesh Kumar Sahu, Haroon R. Lone
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Depression is one of the most common mental disorders affecting an
individual's personal and professional life. In this work, we investigated the
possibility of utilizing social media posts to identify depression in
individuals. To achieve this goal, we conducted a preliminary study where we
extracted and analyzed the top Reddit posts made in 2022 from
depression-related forums. The collected data were labeled as depressive and
non-depressive using UMLS Metathesaurus. Further, the pre-processed data were
fed to classical machine learning models, where we achieved an accuracy of
92.28\% in predicting the depressive and non-depressive posts.
|
[
-0.6041179299354553,
-1.1839361190795898,
0.7510262131690979,
0.5532616376876831,
-0.5094501972198486,
0.0862560123205185,
-0.1148780956864357,
-0.5668630599975586,
0.9068487882614136,
-0.05675213783979416,
-0.7967924475669861,
-0.8978822231292725,
-1.0334296226501465,
0.5638353824615479,
-0.4340628385543823,
0.5204241275787354,
0.03987664729356766,
0.21811948716640472,
-0.1564679592847824,
0.10089240968227386,
-0.3933979272842407,
-0.5170888304710388,
-0.8628609776496887,
0.04810279607772827,
0.8194437623023987,
0.26628178358078003,
0.48552098870277405,
-0.149533212184906,
0.6436327695846558,
0.31567442417144775,
-0.31296709179878235,
-0.04295129328966141,
-0.5051462650299072,
-0.23660260438919067,
-0.47134262323379517,
-0.005775269586592913,
-0.1943269670009613,
-0.15083898603916168,
0.021130120381712914,
0.5458346605300903,
0.07637442648410797,
0.5209882259368896,
0.3337745666503906,
0.440167635679245,
-0.6751897931098938,
-0.03250725567340851,
-0.08299688994884491,
0.3784776031970978,
-0.21810072660446167,
-0.2819110155105591,
0.08810778707265854,
-0.8257556557655334,
-0.13782650232315063,
-0.4352715015411377,
0.24965885281562805,
-0.7509889006614685,
0.38293272256851196,
0.28707456588745117,
-0.596520185470581,
-0.4288870096206665,
-0.8067930936813354,
0.6916965842247009,
-0.3566134572029114,
0.17830705642700195,
0.43938758969306946,
0.4352499544620514,
0.12251123040914536,
-0.4716934561729431,
-0.19375263154506683,
0.5688035488128662,
-0.4802832007408142,
-0.0682532787322998,
-0.34451600909233093,
-0.23843438923358917,
0.24947315454483032,
0.3061971962451935,
-0.8373576402664185,
-0.29470744729042053,
-0.42417946457862854,
0.03232428804039955,
0.7031725645065308,
0.28734707832336426,
0.6044666171073914,
-0.5308836698532104,
-0.07956553995609283,
0.3166850805282593,
-0.05353126674890518,
0.17598289251327515,
0.07005301862955093,
0.20495641231536865,
-0.16492146253585815,
0.8886253833770752,
-0.14772319793701172,
0.688858687877655,
-0.02011028304696083,
-0.03148425742983818,
0.06584765762090683,
-0.2097119390964508,
-0.25051239132881165,
-0.14473482966423035,
0.6225281953811646,
0.8920813798904419,
0.3214746117591858,
0.06139973923563957,
-0.1614946722984314,
0.2315259575843811,
0.4875138998031616,
-0.4763679504394531,
-0.28167885541915894,
0.15858621895313263,
-0.8848682045936584,
-0.3359184265136719,
0.08349192142486572,
-1.1832389831542969,
-0.9189519882202148,
-0.3103928565979004,
0.25867512822151184,
-0.21060588955879211,
-0.5361902713775635,
-0.1472090631723404,
-0.21502545475959778,
-0.39338284730911255,
0.2614598870277405,
-0.6412174105644226,
0.25312864780426025,
0.520814061164856,
1.0565041303634644,
0.10965271294116974,
0.062441691756248474,
0.06505671888589859,
-0.19484154880046844,
-0.24261480569839478,
1.0285565853118896,
-0.34979984164237976,
-0.3643530607223511,
0.12574216723442078,
0.44697824120521545,
-0.15764014422893524,
-0.4691116511821747,
0.7308657765388489,
-0.40021318197250366,
-0.12765054404735565,
-0.4903329610824585,
-0.3974584639072418,
-0.09030616283416748,
0.14379769563674927,
-0.9217217564582825,
0.6224253177642822,
0.4146002233028412,
-1.1550856828689575,
0.20901452004909515,
-0.5153008103370667,
-0.3936624526977539,
-0.09936085343360901,
0.050351813435554504,
-0.20074905455112457,
0.4127238988876343,
0.07132330536842346,
0.6961171627044678,
-0.1490447223186493,
0.03973683714866638,
-0.6702762842178345,
-0.4126162827014923,
0.5225780010223389,
0.10002288222312927,
0.8427436351776123,
0.41851675510406494,
-0.08651772886514664,
-0.1015503853559494,
-0.686369776725769,
-0.09553121775388718,
0.2185705006122589,
-0.18766608834266663,
-0.6936100721359253,
0.018090568482875824,
-0.05417913943529129,
0.25732043385505676,
0.22844775021076202,
-0.6089593768119812,
0.007571766618639231,
-0.039607029408216476,
0.6591740250587463,
0.5732870101928711,
0.5223511457443237,
-0.13826924562454224,
-0.0409063883125782,
0.69412761926651,
0.007667552214115858,
0.2392122447490692,
0.47828754782676697,
-0.6775096654891968,
0.14262492954730988,
-0.22561746835708618,
0.4695424437522888,
0.5338080525398254,
-0.0749298706650734,
0.5400997400283813,
0.12198685109615326,
-0.5720231533050537,
-0.48104292154312134,
0.00801781378686428,
0.000883531232830137,
0.37372609972953796,
0.48846325278282166,
0.00009745028364704922,
-0.874248743057251,
-0.6640307307243347,
-0.48562103509902954,
0.3812422454357147,
-0.03320745751261711,
0.12618473172187805,
0.22836528718471527,
-0.6933450698852539,
0.5479156970977783,
-0.6999619007110596,
-0.19929184019565582,
-0.09158825874328613,
0.7366645932197571,
0.27502042055130005,
0.07363399118185043,
0.3796709477901459,
-0.702177882194519,
-0.9862664341926575,
-0.3663707375526428,
-1.0358755588531494,
-0.12961043417453766,
0.08775757253170013,
0.05407117307186127,
-0.01954522542655468,
0.3496655523777008,
-0.9212954044342041,
0.7226274013519287,
0.3482508957386017,
-0.2211098074913025,
0.1699456125497818,
0.13915486633777618,
0.2848377525806427,
-0.7610859870910645,
0.16496756672859192,
0.43086743354797363,
-0.13792294263839722,
-0.3105721175670624,
-0.6621021032333374,
-0.05422092601656914,
-0.45812860131263733,
-0.15705251693725586,
0.0028603863902390003,
-0.20423106849193573,
-0.39935144782066345,
-0.267785906791687,
0.17038965225219727,
-0.27612653374671936,
-0.028080837801098824,
-0.07908445596694946,
0.2804647982120514,
0.909869909286499,
-0.3915315568447113,
0.18593692779541016,
0.17118538916110992,
-0.4445003271102905,
0.5576225519180298,
-0.5790882110595703,
-0.022797979414463043,
-0.46638810634613037,
0.1046994999051094,
-1.48982572555542,
-0.5087315440177917,
0.3056428134441376,
-0.73396897315979,
-0.25067460536956787,
0.26135605573654175,
-0.3443104922771454,
-0.6649738550186157,
-0.16408836841583252,
0.2847979962825775,
0.02317766100168228,
-0.05114118754863739,
0.28640666604042053,
0.48211416602134705,
-0.3688259422779083,
-0.3111720681190491,
-0.5956005454063416,
-0.0000650303263682872,
-0.5061720609664917,
-0.4193646013736725,
0.556657612323761,
-0.004137931391596794,
-0.4825924336910248,
0.36465850472450256,
0.15930505096912384,
-0.24676966667175293,
0.2284090220928192,
0.19403420388698578,
-0.3356279134750366,
0.11118271946907043,
0.21472862362861633,
-0.08672235906124115,
-0.24052421748638153,
0.1609012931585312,
0.7533549666404724,
0.8214725852012634,
0.3394843637943268,
0.002937880577519536,
-1.055351734161377,
0.6284559965133667,
0.5517500638961792,
0.2418692708015442,
0.7904232740402222,
0.3313988447189331,
-0.6841282248497009,
-0.013770340010523796,
-0.07510866224765778,
-0.20077471435070038,
-0.4000110626220703,
-0.10604014992713928,
-0.10925887525081635,
-0.425537109375,
0.427045613527298,
-0.2660159170627594,
-0.25398197770118713,
0.35788288712501526,
0.18483871221542358,
-0.5202866792678833,
1.3901151418685913,
0.6611716151237488,
-0.07908409833908081,
0.3459918200969696,
0.027757180854678154,
0.3005143404006958,
-0.2977982759475708,
0.14474868774414062,
-0.3245803117752075,
-0.7139312028884888,
-0.6635222434997559,
0.10101168602705002,
-0.021013958379626274,
0.230782613158226,
0.01825663633644581,
0.4618726372718811,
-0.7810733318328857,
0.33376386761665344,
0.5015227794647217,
0.3274904489517212,
0.10605424642562866,
-0.1678161770105362,
0.3498937487602234,
-0.3198942542076111,
0.08437882363796234,
-0.6383151412010193,
1.0363984107971191,
0.07749676704406738,
0.7491198182106018,
0.07421674579381943,
0.8690457344055176,
0.9700642824172974,
0.35161805152893066,
-0.5086448192596436,
0.453167587518692,
-0.16453009843826294,
-0.5219751000404358,
-0.3500995337963104,
-0.3854283094406128,
-1.0228960514068604,
-0.28331077098846436,
-0.20077206194400787,
-0.6336691379547119,
0.23098693788051605,
-0.026456888765096664,
-0.6307865977287292,
-0.05772197246551514,
-0.6815590262413025,
0.9289224147796631,
-0.2963511049747467,
0.1468028426170349,
-0.36243951320648193,
-0.8655670881271362,
0.41342124342918396,
-0.3129619359970093,
0.431816965341568,
-0.06961002200841904,
0.4179781675338745,
0.8197149634361267,
0.034449588507413864,
1.0348446369171143,
-0.4747993052005768,
0.15797153115272522,
0.5101895928382874,
-0.26392096281051636,
0.24329784512519836,
0.11530017852783203,
0.07495760917663574,
0.019608469679951668,
0.3199717104434967,
-0.28594186902046204,
-0.5195932984352112,
0.7100362181663513,
-1.1278767585754395,
-0.009413694031536579,
-0.34372445940971375,
0.06166593357920647,
-0.09829440712928772,
0.09868930280208588,
0.33538582921028137,
0.11125107854604721,
-0.5284545421600342,
0.07926127314567566,
0.2674564719200134,
-0.38130077719688416,
0.47365882992744446,
0.30629828572273254,
-0.25624585151672363,
-0.7860842943191528,
0.7261433005332947,
0.45173379778862,
-0.4325929582118988,
0.2809160053730011,
0.22950458526611328,
-0.3475538492202759,
-0.09251480549573898,
0.1786409318447113,
0.6507953405380249,
-0.5370423793792725,
-0.17400850355625153,
-0.5986943244934082,
-0.05935851112008095,
-0.8550214767456055,
-0.1549341231584549,
-0.42594754695892334,
-0.4477035105228424,
-0.7965829372406006,
-0.434402197599411,
0.1216898262500763,
1.0348924398422241,
-0.5799389481544495,
0.35986512899398804,
-0.8648515343666077,
0.6974021196365356,
0.45342743396759033,
0.24862034618854523,
-0.108475461602211,
0.22819185256958008,
-0.04343056306242943,
0.10872300714254379,
-0.5543642044067383,
-1.279228687286377,
0.4032558500766754,
0.010621181689202785,
0.40266096591949463,
0.7838843464851379,
0.2559942305088043,
0.9249110817909241,
0.23060451447963715,
0.6032541990280151,
0.3225955665111542,
-0.5814692974090576,
0.7129132151603699,
-0.20168186724185944,
-0.007898402400314808,
0.7569248676300049,
1.0565956830978394,
-0.8936089277267456,
-0.04556559398770332,
-0.7183877229690552,
-0.509657084941864,
0.5293532013893127,
0.023308727890253067,
-0.048644665628671646,
-0.29763367772102356,
0.47050994634628296,
0.09105321764945984,
0.1741093546152115,
-0.6292146444320679,
-0.1966412514448166,
-0.35730814933776855,
-0.14949634671211243,
-0.2478073686361313,
-0.49589264392852783,
-0.2310248762369156,
-0.4090096056461334,
0.13061465322971344,
0.21885719895362854,
0.760150671005249,
0.17677398025989532,
-0.1444244235754013,
-0.6521538496017456,
-0.1526491492986679,
0.4214872419834137,
0.9627131223678589,
-0.5215178728103638,
0.5526118278503418,
-0.14090478420257568,
0.07123687863349915,
-0.009110819548368454,
0.11615918576717377,
0.12633360922336578,
0.34004223346710205,
0.30152273178100586,
0.2225385308265686,
0.17686262726783752,
-0.5292208194732666,
0.47966188192367554,
-0.3083054721355438,
-0.39374780654907227,
-0.7825531959533691,
-0.0701340064406395,
0.5528993010520935,
0.4709760844707489,
0.22461427748203278,
0.07183713465929031,
0.0760178416967392,
-0.7117820978164673,
0.2917257845401764,
0.3829096257686615,
-0.5264553427696228,
-0.8235488533973694,
0.3827436566352844,
0.24119380116462708,
-0.9041779637336731,
0.6816558241844177,
-0.01939026452600956,
-0.16953513026237488,
0.3457300364971161,
0.2749117612838745,
0.7425715923309326,
-0.37757614254951477,
0.6840670108795166,
0.6917668581008911,
-0.09021329134702682,
-0.12487746775150299,
0.5894021391868591,
-0.11107350885868073,
-0.5826098322868347,
0.06761997193098068,
-0.5992467999458313,
-0.11595560610294342,
0.46666914224624634,
-0.831254780292511,
0.6182317733764648,
-0.38292938470840454,
-0.8150089979171753,
0.12050805985927582,
-0.12787434458732605,
-0.2353045642375946,
0.5776181221008301,
0.3701430857181549,
0.6021090745925903,
-1.2029750347137451,
0.41123518347740173,
0.9087480902671814,
-0.2312624156475067,
-0.1478900909423828,
0.1281105875968933,
0.29465562105178833,
-0.257510781288147,
0.34460580348968506,
0.4743139445781708,
0.043407753109931946,
0.09436109662055969,
-0.4711351990699768,
-0.7818231582641602,
1.0693340301513672,
-0.049275871366262436,
-0.18433590233325958,
-0.00759871955960989,
0.5088329315185547,
0.7155395150184631,
-0.23423610627651215,
0.10554291307926178,
0.25415468215942383,
0.6124172806739807,
-0.07912872731685638,
-0.3375871479511261,
-0.04422852769494057,
-0.3689424693584442,
-0.11500721424818039,
0.19175486266613007,
-0.5942484736442566,
0.9045711159706116,
0.023319803178310394,
-0.752858579158783,
-0.1537291258573532,
0.38876163959503174,
0.26364943385124207,
0.6163215041160583,
0.6042944192886353,
0.9289625883102417,
0.8998252153396606,
0.2887231111526489,
0.592543363571167,
-0.4056248366832733,
0.6716597080230713,
0.6704397797584534,
-0.14156794548034668,
0.5895233154296875,
0.3145877420902252,
-0.16023534536361694,
0.3645898401737213,
1.153926968574524,
-0.04065123200416565,
0.9563791751861572,
-0.11005629599094391,
-0.28657904267311096,
-0.1985245794057846,
0.052669115364551544,
-0.32630234956741333,
0.1424374133348465,
0.3454514741897583,
-0.9468309879302979,
-0.495305597782135,
0.1852913647890091,
-0.08173727244138718,
-0.07300952821969986,
-0.06193721294403076,
0.8914973735809326,
0.10613235831260681,
-0.5257624387741089,
0.5829635262489319,
-0.04326636716723442,
0.3503451645374298,
-0.17102639377117157,
-0.017273595556616783,
-0.15694628655910492,
0.3688790500164032,
-0.2840316891670227,
-0.9374390840530396,
1.2373396158218384,
0.05650830268859863,
-0.08379912376403809,
-0.3915269374847412,
1.1845711469650269,
0.12353906035423279,
-0.570132851600647,
0.700475811958313,
0.6730429530143738,
0.29850226640701294,
-0.4659076929092407,
-0.7852539420127869,
-0.19005197286605835,
-0.08245079964399338,
-0.45884740352630615,
0.347077876329422,
0.6825559139251709,
0.26759785413742065,
0.3191227614879608,
0.0817127525806427,
-0.15381325781345367,
-0.20541389286518097,
-0.12248741090297699,
0.7143609523773193,
-1.1636770963668823,
-0.15468446910381317,
-0.8846908211708069,
0.545295238494873,
-0.26493316888809204,
-0.6101637482643127,
0.8838602304458618,
0.3925994336605072,
0.363894522190094,
-0.17935319244861603,
0.8173865079879761,
-0.5638564825057983,
1.1952447891235352,
0.20851725339889526,
0.5426933765411377,
-0.8025451302528381,
-0.2191518396139145,
-0.48286670446395874,
-0.6241734623908997,
-0.2886640429496765,
0.8520394563674927,
-0.373762309551239,
-0.31672966480255127,
0.7402471303939819,
0.7342612743377686,
-0.09420022368431091,
0.4652537703514099,
0.06457572430372238,
0.13472525775432587,
-0.11373121291399002,
0.10876252502202988,
1.1139487028121948,
-0.04669630527496338,
0.26615312695503235,
-0.7443839907646179,
-0.20835401117801666,
-0.5304231643676758,
-0.28184932470321655,
-1.0081740617752075,
-0.5254480838775635,
-0.47342437505722046,
-0.06637593358755112,
-0.035796988755464554,
0.5422112941741943,
0.06278299540281296,
-0.5171590447425842,
-0.005112234968692064,
-0.5636624693870544,
0.3957540988922119,
-0.41919073462486267,
-0.3084256052970886,
0.21143408119678497,
-0.11169356852769852,
-0.5273411870002747,
0.046597354114055634,
-0.13962218165397644,
-0.09909767657518387,
-0.10979075729846954,
0.39787790179252625,
-0.3725370466709137,
-0.06726786494255066,
0.6061436533927917,
0.015418123453855515,
-0.18394707143306732,
-0.19182027876377106,
0.05492490157485008,
-0.24681298434734344,
0.13159507513046265,
0.8700286746025085,
-0.3101591467857361,
-0.020863601937890053,
0.8548607230186462,
0.09115207940340042,
0.3039061427116394,
0.630782961845398,
0.16591934859752655,
-0.4340321123600006,
-0.49505648016929626,
0.07843248546123505,
0.19409139454364777,
0.3294013738632202,
-0.5703758001327515,
0.6062842011451721,
0.5517533421516418,
-0.751468300819397,
-0.7010574340820312,
-0.15720964968204498,
-0.7964252233505249,
-0.7215033769607544,
0.7851811647415161,
-0.12508848309516907,
-0.20306497812271118,
-0.4120156764984131,
-0.17847074568271637,
0.45686259865760803,
-0.39731165766716003,
1.4193854331970215,
0.8222895264625549,
-0.4923628568649292,
-0.442266583442688,
-0.5306288003921509,
0.32696449756622314,
-0.10602455586194992,
-0.6552214026451111,
-0.06051550805568695,
0.27714210748672485,
0.2613385021686554,
0.2471037656068802,
0.6619815230369568,
-0.03802517428994179,
0.16177958250045776,
-0.3377290964126587,
-0.160361647605896,
0.6588230729103088,
-0.029068738222122192,
-0.032140664756298065,
0.7131854295730591,
-0.4777297377586365,
-0.13890202343463898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10297v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10297v1
|
Future Language Modeling from Temporal Document History
| 2024-04-16T05:45:52 | 2024-04-16T05:45:52 |
Changmao Li, Jeffrey Flanigan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Predicting the future is of great interest across many aspects of human
activity. Businesses are interested in future trends, traders are interested in
future stock prices, and companies are highly interested in future
technological breakthroughs. While there are many automated systems for
predicting future numerical data, such as weather, stock prices, and demand for
products, there is relatively little work in automatically predicting textual
data. Humans are interested in textual data predictions because it is a natural
format for our consumption, and experts routinely make predictions in a textual
format (Christensen et al., 2004; Tetlock & Gardner, 2015; Frick, 2015).
However, there has been relatively little formalization of this general problem
in the machine learning or natural language processing communities. To address
this gap, we introduce the task of future language modeling: probabilistic
modeling of texts in the future based on a temporal history of texts. To our
knowledge, our work is the first work to formalize the task of predicting the
future in this way. We show that it is indeed possible to build future language
models that improve upon strong non-temporal language model baselines, opening
the door to working on this important, and widely applicable problem.
|
[
0.12893293797969818,
-0.863296389579773,
0.778106689453125,
-0.02305254526436329,
-0.07573781162500381,
-0.007971798069775105,
-0.07547013461589813,
-0.8725011944770813,
0.28501462936401367,
0.7729986906051636,
-0.6782293319702148,
-0.5824135541915894,
-0.4076422154903412,
-0.27179187536239624,
-0.8303030729293823,
0.8843168616294861,
0.0686308741569519,
-0.22270983457565308,
-0.1773599535226822,
0.3379008173942566,
-0.38515913486480713,
-0.8519144058227539,
-0.5238659381866455,
-0.5196604132652283,
0.10987944155931473,
0.1900358945131302,
0.9544327259063721,
0.753399133682251,
-0.0037311320193111897,
0.377729207277298,
0.014566509053111076,
-0.4314911663532257,
-0.17697592079639435,
0.4697165787220001,
0.06691420078277588,
-0.3060133457183838,
-0.4790588319301605,
0.25965186953544617,
0.6886757612228394,
0.8611844778060913,
0.07016255706548691,
0.05331790819764137,
-0.0836697369813919,
0.17579907178878784,
-0.1930171549320221,
0.7372696995735168,
-0.6521497368812561,
-0.028715329244732857,
-0.5195819735527039,
-0.5345275402069092,
-0.5215996503829956,
-0.491533488035202,
0.17968225479125977,
-0.4551289975643158,
0.2221125215291977,
0.15957875549793243,
0.8727806210517883,
-0.13896550238132477,
-0.4422339200973511,
-0.2203134000301361,
-0.8948809504508972,
1.036198377609253,
-0.8722638487815857,
0.7842031121253967,
0.7637076377868652,
0.21977265179157257,
-0.5730894207954407,
-0.8426432609558105,
-0.6707836985588074,
-0.425796240568161,
0.06449000537395477,
0.027062389999628067,
0.1055268868803978,
-0.28141751885414124,
-0.17423993349075317,
0.06153588742017746,
-0.6742545366287231,
0.13952594995498657,
-0.13314811885356903,
-0.05326615646481514,
0.44595199823379517,
0.29256635904312134,
0.16201698780059814,
-0.020134465768933296,
-0.3407672941684723,
0.0026313497219234705,
-0.34042081236839294,
-0.12805691361427307,
0.333964079618454,
0.2902396023273468,
-0.08872770518064499,
0.5386546850204468,
-0.14183159172534943,
0.6592281460762024,
-0.24952685832977295,
-0.1733386218547821,
-0.04845356568694115,
-0.2358754724264145,
-0.17191071808338165,
-0.00008331819844897836,
0.6919477581977844,
0.3794480264186859,
0.3983916938304901,
-0.30198660492897034,
-0.16093377768993378,
0.056069742888212204,
0.10821907222270966,
-0.6035527586936951,
-0.41053861379623413,
0.35655197501182556,
-0.4658115804195404,
-0.2549133598804474,
-0.38563475012779236,
-0.8587180376052856,
-0.3511599004268646,
-0.5739238858222961,
-0.07517394423484802,
-0.5892337560653687,
-0.02072356827557087,
0.04109059274196625,
0.04393726959824562,
0.026814384385943413,
0.2812323272228241,
-1.0874478816986084,
0.36812350153923035,
0.6323874592781067,
0.6952797174453735,
0.29370301961898804,
-0.3603454530239105,
-0.4096633195877075,
0.4460471570491791,
-0.6512703895568848,
0.9714530110359192,
-0.7647621035575867,
-0.5548399090766907,
0.01038065180182457,
0.11264805495738983,
0.31841519474983215,
-0.13512195646762848,
0.7066179513931274,
-0.7632691860198975,
0.5295808911323547,
0.3322553038597107,
-0.5802539587020874,
-0.06205189600586891,
0.038252029567956924,
-0.815712571144104,
0.7716165781021118,
-0.10096418857574463,
-0.7215946912765503,
0.4822666645050049,
-0.5633874535560608,
-0.5489015579223633,
0.1962817907333374,
-0.027114050462841988,
-0.5548509955406189,
-0.18481259047985077,
0.27872657775878906,
0.457975834608078,
-0.2334108203649521,
0.8937516212463379,
-0.4667726457118988,
0.0061122155748307705,
0.3736517131328583,
-0.6153402924537659,
0.6157984137535095,
0.14242470264434814,
-0.2113076001405716,
-0.20767554640769958,
-0.7063913345336914,
0.009103205986320972,
0.007129395380616188,
-0.1726527214050293,
-0.3323603868484497,
0.5669031739234924,
0.43806377053260803,
0.18254771828651428,
0.6581886410713196,
-0.3689389228820801,
0.16932392120361328,
-0.48336517810821533,
0.3628130257129669,
0.982223391532898,
0.00430197874084115,
0.747054398059845,
-0.3508073389530182,
0.5671002268791199,
-0.21522819995880127,
0.34530410170555115,
-0.5342363119125366,
-0.6037363409996033,
-0.3196270763874054,
0.2145879864692688,
0.21932612359523773,
0.5866011381149292,
-0.4593408703804016,
0.3343736529350281,
-0.40169066190719604,
-0.6095617413520813,
0.26479145884513855,
-0.3242715299129486,
0.09098181128501892,
0.5362405776977539,
0.24932961165905,
0.029229048639535904,
-1.0629228353500366,
-0.6800733804702759,
-0.2906242311000824,
-0.7780556082725525,
0.15359891951084137,
-0.14164811372756958,
0.13702252507209778,
-0.21621614694595337,
1.3264987468719482,
-0.5302256941795349,
-0.21091923117637634,
-0.20207956433296204,
0.6196265816688538,
0.4281933903694153,
0.3561929166316986,
0.3271966874599457,
-0.9478560090065002,
-0.1844835728406906,
-0.012357629835605621,
-0.7004544734954834,
-0.05953919142484665,
-0.3553057312965393,
0.08619066327810287,
0.5160213708877563,
0.8568115830421448,
-0.39244017004966736,
0.06646072864532471,
0.8346675634384155,
-0.5363065600395203,
0.6767808198928833,
-0.17503073811531067,
0.024074550718069077,
-1.3534221649169922,
0.04561745747923851,
0.2073875069618225,
-0.25423479080200195,
-0.5937696099281311,
-0.519028902053833,
-0.012010821141302586,
-0.34723132848739624,
-0.38143521547317505,
1.170202374458313,
-0.36659422516822815,
0.04765621945261955,
-0.0533221997320652,
-0.23329317569732666,
-0.3070795238018036,
0.07761368155479431,
0.37361279129981995,
0.4127393960952759,
0.27536845207214355,
-0.48564088344573975,
-0.053218331187963486,
0.10217852145433426,
-0.3429182767868042,
0.07291147112846375,
-0.3973276615142822,
-0.15122535824775696,
0.004856100771576166,
0.4659387469291687,
-0.4937282204627991,
-0.1352972537279129,
-0.0642613098025322,
-0.9241619110107422,
0.32442161440849304,
-0.24926906824111938,
-0.6487259268760681,
-0.2235603779554367,
0.13355164229869843,
-0.08371856063604355,
0.5245653390884399,
-0.24613197147846222,
0.8046566843986511,
0.5551151037216187,
-0.6589217185974121,
-0.7134841680526733,
-0.5688339471817017,
0.5896494388580322,
0.04535334184765816,
-0.4919019043445587,
0.4877319633960724,
-0.19234324991703033,
-0.4557303190231323,
0.2287110835313797,
0.0766621008515358,
-0.35730481147766113,
0.22881054878234863,
0.34686893224716187,
0.6583319306373596,
-0.10617020726203918,
0.17721763253211975,
-0.057255469262599945,
-0.47667843103408813,
0.0342811681330204,
-1.0125831365585327,
0.5374215841293335,
0.00830796081572771,
-0.019727086648344994,
-0.30758464336395264,
0.454456627368927,
0.5612042546272278,
-0.2705860137939453,
0.8537508845329285,
0.4294026792049408,
-0.9215015769004822,
0.06022659316658974,
-0.3939218521118164,
-0.09878125786781311,
-0.46888697147369385,
0.4378086030483246,
-0.21194075047969818,
-0.6799665689468384,
0.3286376893520355,
0.09320740401744843,
0.33499741554260254,
0.5315699577331543,
0.5717609524726868,
-0.3912113308906555,
0.739225447177887,
1.1073627471923828,
0.017322467640042305,
0.9293186068534851,
-0.040205538272857666,
0.19405341148376465,
-0.03655045107007027,
-0.3044654130935669,
-0.5151071548461914,
-0.07031144201755524,
-0.7005578875541687,
-0.07749150693416595,
0.056346211582422256,
0.14271439611911774,
0.07289005815982819,
0.624034583568573,
0.14087143540382385,
0.5299341082572937,
0.584025502204895,
-0.40860146284103394,
0.35341858863830566,
-0.1914977729320526,
-0.05632076784968376,
-0.21138164401054382,
-0.1927305907011032,
-1.0924586057662964,
1.1434383392333984,
0.3139924108982086,
0.6766288876533508,
-0.29784896969795227,
0.7309896945953369,
0.48504021763801575,
0.4459831714630127,
-0.2915419340133667,
0.6181313991546631,
-0.4785846471786499,
-0.4959869980812073,
-0.47687870264053345,
-0.10866759717464447,
-1.1118520498275757,
-0.24133391678333282,
-0.3327019214630127,
-0.7475679516792297,
0.1765192151069641,
0.09766418486833572,
-0.014208287931978703,
0.2725948095321655,
-0.6879833340644836,
0.7788841724395752,
-0.16892525553703308,
-0.12198997288942337,
0.029072079807519913,
-0.6609041690826416,
-0.1164514347910881,
-0.36240413784980774,
0.5915672183036804,
-0.3614940345287323,
-0.24964265525341034,
0.7510355710983276,
-0.24215193092823029,
1.0863971710205078,
-0.019217710942029953,
-0.04711945354938507,
0.14114677906036377,
0.18743611872196198,
0.7106294631958008,
0.23142927885055542,
-0.3104979991912842,
0.11114531755447388,
0.1282692700624466,
-0.4035211205482483,
-0.36353230476379395,
0.556953489780426,
-0.48779693245887756,
-0.22802139818668365,
-0.4912981688976288,
-0.4967755675315857,
-0.3035978078842163,
0.35170790553092957,
0.1809326410293579,
0.7733169794082642,
-0.6257156729698181,
-0.18966932594776154,
0.3961729109287262,
-0.15529166162014008,
0.808648407459259,
0.8313999772071838,
-0.00957404263317585,
-0.20949918031692505,
0.7441539168357849,
0.197474405169487,
-0.1849258840084076,
1.0257230997085571,
0.32259246706962585,
-0.6140091419219971,
-0.6306800842285156,
-0.08041294664144516,
-0.028439169749617577,
-0.7052819728851318,
-0.026258796453475952,
-1.0186564922332764,
-0.11512695252895355,
-0.7409770488739014,
-0.41129937767982483,
-0.33223360776901245,
-0.42963090538978577,
-0.6418953537940979,
-0.0035861744545400143,
0.2767145335674286,
0.6323148608207703,
0.05377025529742241,
0.09575944393873215,
-1.0657668113708496,
0.16220372915267944,
0.04287091642618179,
0.3712104260921478,
-0.30822429060935974,
-0.23115788400173187,
-0.4536625146865845,
-0.17903263866901398,
-0.24467028677463531,
-0.8084105253219604,
0.9892524480819702,
0.1740393489599228,
0.6523187160491943,
-0.014586394652724266,
0.05727546662092209,
0.3720596432685852,
-0.7792235016822815,
0.8900992274284363,
0.03275657072663307,
-0.9044336080551147,
0.6999145746231079,
-0.5445946455001831,
0.08746685087680817,
0.1153353825211525,
0.32826173305511475,
-0.968287467956543,
-0.7342879176139832,
-0.8652563095092773,
-0.9521591663360596,
0.3486558496952057,
-0.08790846168994904,
0.2391345351934433,
-0.29543715715408325,
0.10743321478366852,
0.4561143219470978,
-0.06774232536554337,
-0.7467987537384033,
0.1392979770898819,
-0.05383194983005524,
-0.35316187143325806,
-0.5600589513778687,
-0.1678248941898346,
0.4954753816127777,
0.24621036648750305,
0.7352136373519897,
-0.16082118451595306,
0.402713805437088,
-0.3504869341850281,
-0.08054789900779724,
-0.03644005209207535,
0.45080751180648804,
0.5862545967102051,
0.6590467691421509,
-0.3665868043899536,
-0.03558848425745964,
0.1555427759885788,
-0.4543440341949463,
-0.011690877377986908,
0.48168307542800903,
-0.0742373988032341,
0.2982170283794403,
0.5794932246208191,
0.3841756284236908,
0.3725220561027527,
-0.627246618270874,
0.2618124186992645,
-0.04516581818461418,
-0.046065691858530045,
-1.0073482990264893,
-0.5101261138916016,
0.28394627571105957,
0.6417492628097534,
0.580380380153656,
0.024338290095329285,
0.025052634999155998,
-0.7212916612625122,
0.27385327219963074,
0.05114724114537239,
-0.310434490442276,
-0.49478015303611755,
1.1669776439666748,
-0.04168219864368439,
-0.27460500597953796,
0.5202754139900208,
-0.25762102007865906,
-0.4730544686317444,
0.5315472483634949,
0.6620613932609558,
1.0204836130142212,
-0.2085355818271637,
0.07374168187379837,
0.14559607207775116,
0.2386297583580017,
-0.3545616865158081,
0.3539891242980957,
0.38759005069732666,
-0.49503517150878906,
-0.5936211943626404,
-0.9198358654975891,
-0.5336692333221436,
0.0698048397898674,
-0.055410049855709076,
0.5713892579078674,
-0.3231111168861389,
-0.4218463897705078,
-0.11703525483608246,
0.15437942743301392,
-0.5118496417999268,
0.5718963742256165,
0.3041440546512604,
0.7852519154548645,
-1.0094860792160034,
1.2113362550735474,
0.5386738777160645,
-0.21453718841075897,
-0.10385551303625107,
0.280164510011673,
-0.04589032754302025,
-0.444652259349823,
0.8214125037193298,
-0.009062495082616806,
-0.02750333398580551,
-0.1858666092157364,
-0.40796959400177,
-0.9904530048370361,
1.0710177421569824,
0.49330639839172363,
-0.620002269744873,
-0.4272667467594147,
-0.18186309933662415,
0.6367109417915344,
-0.04166543111205101,
0.046476349234580994,
0.17043760418891907,
0.37203875184059143,
0.013027532026171684,
-0.6773514747619629,
-0.33989572525024414,
-0.4877932369709015,
0.054957546293735504,
0.5312196016311646,
-0.13890498876571655,
1.12856125831604,
-0.20372530817985535,
-0.5952140688896179,
0.32745102047920227,
1.2392677068710327,
-0.0734497681260109,
0.5139771699905396,
0.19629718363285065,
0.212550550699234,
0.8526843190193176,
-0.16815268993377686,
1.2066760063171387,
-0.4438287913799286,
-0.006040130276232958,
1.5500658750534058,
-0.1769452840089798,
1.140182614326477,
0.26063013076782227,
-0.12407753616571426,
0.7495240569114685,
0.8905327916145325,
0.2459924966096878,
0.3766920268535614,
-0.21254439651966095,
-0.17409370839595795,
-0.22807030379772186,
-0.21489951014518738,
-0.3496358096599579,
0.308941125869751,
0.3649446666240692,
-0.4897293746471405,
0.04922880604863167,
-0.23989242315292358,
0.13399609923362732,
0.3054667115211487,
0.0046003591269254684,
0.5833666324615479,
-0.12307823449373245,
-0.5275920033454895,
0.11118174344301224,
0.37011176347732544,
0.5417924523353577,
-0.6106088161468506,
0.13446259498596191,
-0.1650725156068802,
0.20760942995548248,
0.2273133099079132,
-0.9705770015716553,
0.45865151286125183,
-0.01443718746304512,
-0.3361944258213043,
-0.7016223073005676,
0.5496484637260437,
-0.5290234684944153,
-0.6692712306976318,
0.27954915165901184,
0.3412613868713379,
0.006884967442601919,
0.07387670874595642,
-0.3766104578971863,
-0.2890419363975525,
-0.3719428479671478,
-0.14459015429019928,
0.232499361038208,
0.4135874807834625,
-0.45359358191490173,
0.8199367523193359,
0.713489830493927,
0.03529238700866699,
0.07465124875307083,
0.04914474114775658,
0.4755171835422516,
-0.8696191310882568,
-0.9627869129180908,
-0.822989821434021,
0.26452207565307617,
0.2041396051645279,
-0.16978612542152405,
0.33539777994155884,
0.6045423746109009,
0.6510587930679321,
0.09790945798158646,
0.8350664377212524,
0.19709159433841705,
0.5123152732849121,
-0.7303867340087891,
0.733138382434845,
-0.4325641691684723,
0.04429143667221069,
-0.16895577311515808,
-0.7273227572441101,
-0.23350615799427032,
0.035087235271930695,
-0.38131868839263916,
0.06770077347755432,
0.8329177498817444,
0.536082923412323,
0.384531170129776,
0.46370595693588257,
0.31008586287498474,
0.14243511855602264,
0.4517543613910675,
0.42683693766593933,
0.6838615536689758,
-0.10414735972881317,
0.7457558512687683,
-0.32963019609451294,
-0.18794341385364532,
-0.2034248411655426,
-1.257881999015808,
-0.6257835626602173,
-1.2935048341751099,
-0.2271740585565567,
-0.18469856679439545,
0.36410224437713623,
0.731096088886261,
0.634653627872467,
-0.7175447940826416,
-0.3838235139846802,
-0.013399691320955753,
-0.1892295777797699,
-0.20139020681381226,
-0.15784703195095062,
0.24886618554592133,
-0.2399103194475174,
-0.8886401057243347,
0.46416908502578735,
0.31732845306396484,
0.5134639143943787,
-0.13745161890983582,
0.016544867306947708,
-0.1349504292011261,
0.11955400556325912,
0.6761506199836731,
0.2912243604660034,
-0.5609521865844727,
-0.1347704827785492,
0.2067987024784088,
-0.14059196412563324,
-0.13769064843654633,
0.7065247297286987,
-0.9943795800209045,
0.3805651068687439,
0.43101418018341064,
0.3500688970088959,
0.48834165930747986,
-0.34712210297584534,
0.9476208090782166,
-0.6753182411193848,
-0.0462600439786911,
0.4481182396411896,
0.47048214077949524,
0.34679079055786133,
-0.2857244908809662,
0.2634466588497162,
0.11294031888246536,
-0.3783178925514221,
-0.32158592343330383,
0.16029682755470276,
-0.7213367223739624,
-0.35790544748306274,
0.8122671246528625,
0.14569896459579468,
-0.277712345123291,
-0.4036172330379486,
0.099857859313488,
0.48773321509361267,
-0.45133811235427856,
0.7412657141685486,
0.6322852969169617,
0.16405610740184784,
-0.09972936660051346,
-0.733386218547821,
0.12196223437786102,
0.08113543689250946,
-0.9261412024497986,
0.3059226870536804,
0.44202542304992676,
-0.12356801331043243,
-0.1660691797733307,
0.8694923520088196,
-0.4518093466758728,
0.03215324878692627,
0.1776900589466095,
-0.11656012386083603,
0.1768432855606079,
-0.41464197635650635,
-0.012619529850780964,
0.12161660194396973,
0.07348843663930893,
0.14722713828086853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13078v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13078v2
|
Empowering Interdisciplinary Research with BERT-Based Models: An Approach Through SciBERT-CNN with Topic Modeling
| 2024-04-16T05:21:47 | 2024-04-23T05:15:18 |
Darya Likhareva, Hamsini Sankaran, Sivakumar Thiyagarajan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Researchers must stay current in their fields by regularly reviewing academic
literature, a task complicated by the daily publication of thousands of papers.
Traditional multi-label text classification methods often ignore semantic
relationships and fail to address the inherent class imbalances. This paper
introduces a novel approach using the SciBERT model and CNNs to systematically
categorize academic abstracts from the Elsevier OA CC-BY corpus. We use a
multi-segment input strategy that processes abstracts, body text, titles, and
keywords obtained via BERT topic modeling through SciBERT. Here, the [CLS]
token embeddings capture the contextual representation of each segment,
concatenated and processed through a CNN. The CNN uses convolution and pooling
to enhance feature extraction and reduce dimensionality, optimizing the data
for classification. Additionally, we incorporate class weights based on label
frequency to address the class imbalance, significantly improving the
classification F1 score and enhancing text classification systems and
literature review efficiency.
|
[
-0.47424542903900146,
-0.4975452721118927,
0.3830532729625702,
0.1816636323928833,
-0.3516022562980652,
0.4113468527793884,
-0.17261312901973724,
-0.4890892207622528,
0.298626571893692,
0.1996048241853714,
-0.08089613169431686,
-0.5451949238777161,
-0.6641969680786133,
0.06718412041664124,
-0.6364473700523376,
1.4289480447769165,
0.16321943700313568,
0.6229737401008606,
-0.5771273970603943,
-0.26702722907066345,
-0.19352011382579803,
-0.610447108745575,
-0.32332858443260193,
-0.43680617213249207,
0.7893362641334534,
0.40622955560684204,
0.2947165369987488,
0.18763814866542816,
0.6692655086517334,
0.24538478255271912,
-0.34085437655448914,
0.015088428743183613,
-0.24705609679222107,
0.08956336230039597,
-0.13455148041248322,
-0.42822784185409546,
-0.13679789006710052,
-0.031659625470638275,
0.7559977769851685,
0.707139790058136,
0.25356149673461914,
-0.10678020864725113,
0.0008335627499036491,
0.26496902108192444,
-0.503356397151947,
-0.09475263208150864,
-0.4945816397666931,
0.1775711625814438,
-0.20652560889720917,
-0.28499090671539307,
-0.552370548248291,
-0.17699673771858215,
0.6110635995864868,
-0.2778761684894562,
0.32868149876594543,
0.09857773035764694,
0.8377420902252197,
0.0212126262485981,
-0.4949081838130951,
-0.34924784302711487,
-0.34388577938079834,
0.8710823655128479,
-0.3602765202522278,
0.21511933207511902,
0.08623019605875015,
-0.20506048202514648,
0.12298817932605743,
-0.838192880153656,
-0.3150763213634491,
-0.2228672206401825,
-0.12396901100873947,
-0.0943201407790184,
0.07089482992887497,
-0.03431909531354904,
-0.22293603420257568,
0.14570219814777374,
-0.41004905104637146,
0.14323782920837402,
-0.8854932188987732,
-0.1832527071237564,
0.6145572066307068,
0.05210895091295242,
0.3574460446834564,
-0.06689000129699707,
-0.6398430466651917,
0.03417104482650757,
-0.5003933906555176,
0.06128891184926033,
0.1670341193675995,
0.1682853102684021,
0.20880450308322906,
0.5607544183731079,
0.051953766494989395,
0.7301812767982483,
-0.1698334962129593,
0.1589740365743637,
0.40432050824165344,
-0.2156360149383545,
-0.09178803116083145,
0.7307060956954956,
0.5358080863952637,
0.3051418364048004,
-0.3020596206188202,
-0.08327319473028183,
0.219171941280365,
-0.3438849449157715,
0.5160626173019409,
-0.8966572880744934,
-0.18839873373508453,
0.43210795521736145,
-0.7092366218566895,
-0.388039767742157,
0.030631069093942642,
-0.6266492009162903,
-0.27807122468948364,
-0.3867352306842804,
0.3502669632434845,
-0.4921930730342865,
0.022265208885073662,
-0.11894828081130981,
-0.2874896824359894,
-0.05974169075489044,
0.5554326176643372,
-0.6141301393508911,
0.0362139493227005,
0.651435911655426,
1.2188715934753418,
-0.4749463200569153,
-0.11745020002126694,
0.009068453684449196,
-0.07017306983470917,
0.08601024001836777,
0.9340009689331055,
-0.5681791305541992,
-0.3688787817955017,
-0.031400807201862335,
0.031094525009393692,
0.08607397973537445,
0.17928995192050934,
0.6271334886550903,
-0.6527308821678162,
0.40578868985176086,
-0.1534704566001892,
-0.7988080382347107,
-0.22353285551071167,
0.43786486983299255,
-0.4592075049877167,
0.6230893731117249,
-0.21810829639434814,
-1.2010366916656494,
0.31372109055519104,
-0.8124234080314636,
-0.24632063508033752,
0.0288960263133049,
-0.16698861122131348,
-0.6725727319717407,
0.09745306521654129,
0.18521259725093842,
0.5650174617767334,
-0.21225781738758087,
0.5419270992279053,
-0.3028484582901001,
-0.37671220302581787,
0.36929845809936523,
-0.17642705142498016,
0.7689633965492249,
0.5315948128700256,
0.2511800229549408,
0.4550216495990753,
-0.4830131530761719,
-0.1785934716463089,
-0.34752559661865234,
-0.2914913296699524,
-0.7935482859611511,
0.2886843681335449,
0.4674213230609894,
0.18331369757652283,
0.2483154684305191,
-0.90456223487854,
0.47884565591812134,
-0.26730358600616455,
0.6172434687614441,
0.37065356969833374,
0.00306836050003767,
0.46182283759117126,
-0.22885574400424957,
-0.0351606085896492,
0.2400835156440735,
-0.23391245305538177,
-0.3546164333820343,
-0.6114683747291565,
-0.6800742745399475,
-0.5146543383598328,
0.8035520315170288,
0.42295393347740173,
-0.5227463245391846,
0.45725446939468384,
-0.18268759548664093,
-0.688383162021637,
-0.4823942184448242,
-0.4254832863807678,
-0.07545723766088486,
0.4767927825450897,
0.5130055546760559,
-0.43582719564437866,
-0.15639863908290863,
-0.9103801846504211,
0.11142024397850037,
0.06699962913990021,
0.03372480347752571,
0.010120372287929058,
0.48057836294174194,
0.006776576861739159,
0.9735118746757507,
-0.6290788650512695,
-0.3590206801891327,
-0.0615440234541893,
0.8899527788162231,
-0.0343887135386467,
0.8522340059280396,
0.5690295696258545,
-0.926345944404602,
-0.224445179104805,
-0.05805043876171112,
-0.6646631956100464,
0.04619695991277695,
-0.05710873007774353,
-0.07050219178199768,
0.10282929241657257,
0.7447100281715393,
-0.1558564454317093,
0.451084703207016,
-0.016605230048298836,
-0.38084638118743896,
0.10543402284383774,
-0.2365303933620453,
0.11531128734350204,
-0.817610502243042,
0.002011525444686413,
0.2610090374946594,
0.15223531424999237,
-0.5745133757591248,
-0.11922809481620789,
0.14468178153038025,
-0.38246339559555054,
-0.5175609588623047,
0.26208433508872986,
-0.2059749811887741,
0.1632022112607956,
-0.5380231738090515,
-0.07420822232961655,
0.11592552065849304,
0.25646084547042847,
0.30002862215042114,
0.4292793571949005,
0.648193359375,
-0.4253724217414856,
-0.02720898948609829,
0.30287230014801025,
-0.3539598882198334,
0.3939514756202698,
-0.7476799488067627,
-0.2970722019672394,
-0.5973467826843262,
0.5472645163536072,
-1.0734375715255737,
-0.012251464650034904,
-0.030463434755802155,
-0.2640298008918762,
0.49404284358024597,
0.08815493434667587,
-0.5079379677772522,
-0.12290498614311218,
-0.5289170742034912,
0.4503069221973419,
0.16590018570423126,
-0.41458064317703247,
0.5848278999328613,
0.3706236779689789,
-0.5233175754547119,
-0.7317275404930115,
-0.5734700560569763,
-0.00252492050640285,
-0.1483454704284668,
-0.5071684718132019,
0.8306173086166382,
0.17940594255924225,
-0.05646625533699989,
0.32800185680389404,
0.14532312750816345,
-0.3974318504333496,
0.10012394934892654,
0.08436092734336853,
0.3282439112663269,
-0.025407440960407257,
0.6867305636405945,
0.39311474561691284,
0.25689002871513367,
0.06755580008029938,
-0.24292202293872833,
0.48818057775497437,
-0.14115598797798157,
-0.20663145184516907,
-0.21113279461860657,
0.6225789189338684,
0.6301957368850708,
-0.4092032313346863,
0.7043170928955078,
0.8388721346855164,
-0.2528030276298523,
0.020849956199526787,
-0.2380393147468567,
-0.3685828447341919,
-0.300855815410614,
0.6025353074073792,
0.028483806177973747,
-0.9147860407829285,
0.3939526379108429,
-0.11549773067235947,
0.2601052224636078,
0.459070086479187,
0.7015148997306824,
-0.3039807379245758,
0.7024832963943481,
0.7108107805252075,
-0.056059982627630234,
0.4118739068508148,
-0.27177807688713074,
0.28299108147621155,
-0.7226978540420532,
-0.5615155696868896,
-0.8425729274749756,
-0.6004459261894226,
-0.5310041904449463,
-0.29892241954803467,
0.5108896493911743,
0.05267804116010666,
-0.07384061068296432,
0.16313856840133667,
-1.0367310047149658,
0.2353925257921219,
0.7843414545059204,
0.416793555021286,
0.15279008448123932,
0.21121659874916077,
-0.093253493309021,
-0.13153253495693207,
-0.7083173990249634,
-0.40460634231567383,
1.155637264251709,
0.5544337630271912,
0.8082813620567322,
-0.1717136651277542,
0.7041416168212891,
0.49675625562667847,
0.8578363060951233,
-0.7503155469894409,
0.20176757872104645,
-0.22498661279678345,
-0.8943666815757751,
-0.2886088788509369,
0.08694076538085938,
-0.804071843624115,
0.7511011362075806,
-0.4755293130874634,
-0.8203288912773132,
0.5080430507659912,
-0.1854095160961151,
-0.218855619430542,
0.3407977819442749,
-0.41084372997283936,
0.5966871976852417,
-0.33476534485816956,
-0.47342509031295776,
-0.34694090485572815,
-0.7613604664802551,
0.4374435544013977,
-0.21412883698940277,
0.10834053158760071,
-0.22845235466957092,
-0.10399413108825684,
0.8082465529441833,
-0.2747722864151001,
0.7646937370300293,
0.07579388469457626,
0.045470889657735825,
0.44702115654945374,
-0.45510199666023254,
-0.19818121194839478,
0.24576149880886078,
-0.12624795734882355,
0.3539683520793915,
-0.031023262068629265,
-0.41274958848953247,
-0.2779819965362549,
0.7576253414154053,
-0.9846543073654175,
-0.4171126186847687,
-0.9794184565544128,
-0.6497310400009155,
0.0008948248578235507,
-0.00329825421795249,
0.29608455300331116,
0.4102790653705597,
-0.10664509236812592,
0.3405110836029053,
0.6544989943504333,
-0.40326425433158875,
0.514352560043335,
0.3537760376930237,
-0.08854208886623383,
-0.370665580034256,
1.0191491842269897,
0.2235819399356842,
-0.13533926010131836,
0.5079714059829712,
0.15102645754814148,
-0.20188495516777039,
-0.5009512305259705,
-0.17587558925151825,
-0.0666545182466507,
-0.8221620321273804,
-0.34099358320236206,
-1.2084468603134155,
-0.4000403583049774,
-0.32839104533195496,
-0.357368528842926,
0.01788054220378399,
-0.5163390636444092,
-0.6112563014030457,
0.10274937748908997,
0.31716373562812805,
0.3280442953109741,
-0.07025349140167236,
0.36869165301322937,
-0.7043166756629944,
0.00022136399638839066,
0.06356342881917953,
0.05508210137486458,
0.16460350155830383,
-0.405430406332016,
-0.21803149580955505,
-0.3822292685508728,
-0.7418270111083984,
-0.7802548408508301,
0.43924805521965027,
0.2084205448627472,
0.4985211491584778,
0.271088570356369,
0.14116846024990082,
0.2140199989080429,
-0.612116813659668,
0.8346409797668457,
0.3499632179737091,
-0.9469348788261414,
0.5278244018554688,
-0.06501328200101852,
0.17513976991176605,
0.5866900086402893,
0.8913002610206604,
-0.16513755917549133,
-0.5290536880493164,
-0.5582391023635864,
-1.2554532289505005,
0.7321203947067261,
0.15618112683296204,
0.16776043176651,
0.04811365529894829,
-0.02998514287173748,
0.08460317552089691,
0.35460343956947327,
-0.7382519245147705,
-0.243633434176445,
-0.5749335885047913,
-0.3267216086387634,
0.3074605166912079,
-0.2324533313512802,
-0.12630002200603485,
-0.549015998840332,
0.6650175452232361,
-0.09622226655483246,
0.5020341873168945,
0.4449273645877838,
-0.007610267028212547,
0.29296258091926575,
0.26482120156288147,
1.0183131694793701,
0.5684121251106262,
-0.47341883182525635,
0.20489977300167084,
0.1080755963921547,
-0.41724416613578796,
0.13745510578155518,
0.26150208711624146,
-0.21302078664302826,
0.3931538164615631,
0.32205459475517273,
0.3933075964450836,
0.23224037885665894,
-0.598888635635376,
0.4414345622062683,
-0.06065238267183304,
-0.19637005031108856,
-0.1566803753376007,
-0.1085558533668518,
0.061462003737688065,
-0.010833252221345901,
0.6305354237556458,
0.2549634575843811,
0.3845343291759491,
-0.36933138966560364,
0.5258042216300964,
0.23221376538276672,
-0.5922227501869202,
0.1586509495973587,
0.5066809058189392,
0.41288796067237854,
0.1710595190525055,
0.5623368620872498,
0.01822592504322529,
-0.6087757349014282,
0.9025612473487854,
0.2850835621356964,
0.5914085507392883,
0.0808262750506401,
0.20772060751914978,
0.5309115648269653,
0.15822307765483856,
-0.058482274413108826,
0.1431526392698288,
0.02980806678533554,
-0.5150699019432068,
-0.47345834970474243,
-0.5019499659538269,
-0.5333232879638672,
0.03871210664510727,
-0.6210439801216125,
0.5192047357559204,
-0.3099299371242523,
-0.1573558896780014,
0.5160684585571289,
-0.22398363053798676,
-0.28127413988113403,
0.1475098878145218,
0.14551123976707458,
0.9632472991943359,
-0.7940118312835693,
1.073255181312561,
0.7937018275260925,
-0.5072317123413086,
-0.13860554993152618,
-0.13845209777355194,
-0.301567405462265,
-0.26989808678627014,
1.1839758157730103,
0.26958638429641724,
0.33208125829696655,
-0.2271289825439453,
-0.864341676235199,
-0.8895524740219116,
0.8300974369049072,
-0.27308014035224915,
-0.5253813862800598,
0.08548985421657562,
-0.3791365921497345,
0.5831198692321777,
-0.5760819315910339,
0.3638962507247925,
-0.04538648575544357,
0.3602375388145447,
0.12213356047868729,
-0.4797712564468384,
-0.46210044622421265,
-0.1656336486339569,
-0.175734281539917,
0.11484982818365097,
-0.6177813410758972,
1.2033885717391968,
0.06359201669692993,
0.2863095700740814,
-0.009000576101243496,
1.0115642547607422,
0.2704346477985382,
0.5863003730773926,
0.16842390596866608,
0.420600026845932,
0.664627730846405,
-0.30306902527809143,
0.7034704089164734,
-0.4427909553050995,
0.6672405004501343,
0.9073368906974792,
-0.3261798620223999,
0.6375748515129089,
0.4917435050010681,
0.1907220482826233,
0.5172721147537231,
0.8164279460906982,
-0.5825597047805786,
0.9279539585113525,
0.589724600315094,
-0.4051605463027954,
-0.055620159953832626,
-0.4202837347984314,
-0.5565598607063293,
0.635332465171814,
0.7522592544555664,
-0.6314697265625,
-0.4816771447658539,
0.5336320400238037,
-0.011913588270545006,
-0.012758539989590645,
-0.5931541323661804,
0.5592337846755981,
-0.039277270436286926,
-0.6597915291786194,
0.16044624149799347,
0.46101757884025574,
0.8591510057449341,
-0.42140331864356995,
-0.07044019550085068,
0.11066864430904388,
-0.018433911725878716,
-0.17557327449321747,
-0.7144402265548706,
0.22855058312416077,
-0.06251128017902374,
-0.23147378861904144,
-0.13316217064857483,
0.9705943465232849,
-0.6969693899154663,
-0.8033311367034912,
-0.163018137216568,
0.192927747964859,
0.16631117463111877,
0.4145350456237793,
-0.6312304735183716,
0.11682630330324173,
-0.24321022629737854,
0.10380856692790985,
0.23662205040454865,
0.3653623163700104,
-0.36024656891822815,
0.4963064193725586,
0.3564560115337372,
-0.20671315491199493,
-0.20340415835380554,
-0.24131299555301666,
0.8630037307739258,
-0.5558391809463501,
-0.5729509592056274,
-0.7626499533653259,
0.4277108907699585,
-0.36593344807624817,
-0.44337862730026245,
0.41854700446128845,
0.49398505687713623,
0.6475873589515686,
-0.20422320067882538,
0.7453569769859314,
-0.1367088258266449,
0.28563031554222107,
-0.31840208172798157,
0.891676664352417,
-0.5586919784545898,
0.00468763941898942,
-0.19779518246650696,
-0.4540766775608063,
-0.500303328037262,
0.7312446236610413,
-0.06308543682098389,
-0.24721406400203705,
0.728510320186615,
0.15086832642555237,
0.023859452456235886,
0.36003732681274414,
0.02844945713877678,
-0.23685882985591888,
0.2846859395503998,
0.31087446212768555,
0.7914909720420837,
-0.2151322364807129,
0.1623755842447281,
-0.1999034881591797,
-0.08339891582727432,
-0.48290741443634033,
-0.940060019493103,
-1.1918773651123047,
-0.585769772529602,
-0.6513563394546509,
-0.1964811384677887,
-0.07854156196117401,
1.028009295463562,
0.8386662602424622,
-1.0506651401519775,
0.027870342135429382,
0.05231766775250435,
0.34819650650024414,
-0.014724924229085445,
-0.23268140852451324,
0.8372316956520081,
-0.6362450122833252,
-0.7438859939575195,
-0.08941739797592163,
0.22546039521694183,
0.07968321442604065,
-0.5669528841972351,
0.5006465315818787,
-0.6243893504142761,
-0.1079491451382637,
0.6695379614830017,
0.07871843129396439,
-0.7181327939033508,
-0.004229577258229256,
-0.12473543733358383,
-0.3101770579814911,
-0.017613640055060387,
1.0024412870407104,
-0.7657642960548401,
0.3369261920452118,
0.5763356685638428,
0.885826587677002,
0.4354929029941559,
-0.07010794430971146,
0.47158199548721313,
-0.8010082840919495,
0.30538859963417053,
0.4408591091632843,
0.47636494040489197,
0.19829054176807404,
-0.40272313356399536,
0.49395325779914856,
0.09657680988311768,
-0.5747854709625244,
-0.8684117197990417,
-0.24296832084655762,
-1.0528286695480347,
-0.8295078277587891,
0.4622466266155243,
-0.23477496206760406,
-0.10100551694631577,
-0.2812581956386566,
-0.3343736231327057,
0.14182142913341522,
-0.5130088329315186,
0.9455763697624207,
0.9415426254272461,
-0.29505977034568787,
-0.024499205872416496,
-0.36681848764419556,
0.20075932145118713,
0.4428822100162506,
-0.749997615814209,
-0.6196445822715759,
0.20005816221237183,
0.11788177490234375,
0.7483136653900146,
0.21913579106330872,
-0.23588471114635468,
0.11134245991706848,
-0.4034801721572876,
0.3197035789489746,
-0.00586990499868989,
-0.41088205575942993,
-0.16197063028812408,
0.6637139320373535,
-0.20819120109081268,
-0.15685395896434784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10271v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10271v2
|
Social Choice Should Guide AI Alignment in Dealing with Diverse Human Feedback
| 2024-04-16T03:59:33 | 2024-06-04T14:34:38 |
Vincent Conitzer, Rachel Freedman, Jobst Heitzig, Wesley H. Holliday, Bob M. Jacobs, Nathan Lambert, Milan Mossé, Eric Pacuit, Stuart Russell, Hailey Schoelkopf, Emanuel Tewolde, William S. Zwicker
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.GT, 68T01, 68T50, 91B14, 91B12, I.2.0; I.2.7; K.4.2; I.2.m; J.4
|
Foundation models such as GPT-4 are fine-tuned to avoid unsafe or otherwise
problematic behavior, such as helping to commit crimes or producing racist
text. One approach to fine-tuning, called reinforcement learning from human
feedback, learns from humans' expressed preferences over multiple outputs.
Another approach is constitutional AI, in which the input from humans is a list
of high-level principles. But how do we deal with potentially diverging input
from humans? How can we aggregate the input into consistent data about
"collective" preferences or otherwise use it to make collective choices about
model behavior? In this paper, we argue that the field of social choice is well
positioned to address these questions, and we discuss ways forward for this
agenda, drawing on discussions in a recent workshop on Social Choice for AI
Ethics and Safety held in Berkeley, CA, USA in December 2023.
|
[
-0.40968766808509827,
-0.46322131156921387,
0.5510562658309937,
-0.1048886775970459,
-0.1603342443704605,
0.45430418848991394,
-0.10039030760526657,
-0.6929122805595398,
-0.022464901208877563,
0.43999242782592773,
-0.5221445560455322,
-0.05202677100896835,
-0.6370247602462769,
-0.07297848910093307,
-0.08700194209814072,
1.2101625204086304,
0.14501234889030457,
0.2571425139904022,
-0.179340198636055,
-0.2951946556568146,
-0.4076034426689148,
-0.5285044312477112,
-1.0944620370864868,
-0.5421293377876282,
0.7385762333869934,
0.5490363240242004,
1.0224908590316772,
0.6958772540092468,
0.2978738248348236,
0.3847198188304901,
-0.037737421691417694,
0.18275894224643707,
-0.6205938458442688,
-0.18688327074050903,
-0.5043124556541443,
-0.42391759157180786,
-0.1198127493262291,
0.4657649099826813,
0.3235558271408081,
0.5155081152915955,
-0.17332938313484192,
-0.09598950296640396,
0.18280287086963654,
0.7001050710678101,
-0.3460325300693512,
-0.15264125168323517,
-0.4203650653362274,
-0.06386756151914597,
-0.042138904333114624,
0.10529929399490356,
-0.21516795456409454,
-0.6378800868988037,
0.207748681306839,
-0.4234505891799927,
0.21558447182178497,
0.015047265216708183,
0.7239488959312439,
0.48951882123947144,
-0.5119245648384094,
0.19480979442596436,
-0.9279087781906128,
0.6595425605773926,
-0.16510619223117828,
0.3924862742424011,
0.6631839871406555,
0.29530516266822815,
-0.2629600167274475,
-0.5014382600784302,
-0.26852652430534363,
0.029101209715008736,
0.15887637436389923,
0.12788096070289612,
0.4027821123600006,
0.2550183832645416,
-0.06742824614048004,
0.019289659336209297,
-0.1693023294210434,
0.21893414855003357,
-0.7751989960670471,
-0.24836263060569763,
1.0800237655639648,
0.1497156023979187,
0.23745404183864594,
0.27505016326904297,
-0.04323742911219597,
-0.008366929367184639,
-0.6172167062759399,
0.42532896995544434,
0.6957090497016907,
0.35194334387779236,
-0.1550876498222351,
0.3352428674697876,
-0.3243007957935333,
0.6129267811775208,
0.5483056306838989,
0.32962939143180847,
-0.0054066963493824005,
-0.40931200981140137,
0.0019052323186770082,
0.166181281208992,
0.6864702105522156,
0.3911662697792053,
0.23640403151512146,
-0.1916906088590622,
-0.09640246629714966,
0.3771655559539795,
0.6493787169456482,
-0.3341310918331146,
-0.12363853305578232,
0.2377932369709015,
-0.49577856063842773,
-0.6090867519378662,
0.1995023638010025,
-0.7499051094055176,
-0.6108233332633972,
-0.8122506737709045,
-0.0444449745118618,
-0.15997213125228882,
-0.03973272442817688,
0.1641935408115387,
-0.3313671350479126,
0.3391053378582001,
0.3958547115325928,
-1.1576859951019287,
0.45852890610694885,
0.803750216960907,
0.5396732091903687,
-0.4113692045211792,
-0.4524942636489868,
-0.6844903826713562,
0.3298659026622772,
-0.3108009994029999,
0.7389227747917175,
-0.7430430054664612,
-0.4529709815979004,
-0.2695711851119995,
-0.16941089928150177,
0.2782222032546997,
-0.25815701484680176,
0.2535869777202606,
-0.38581129908561707,
0.10597037523984909,
-0.5955947637557983,
-0.3336613178253174,
0.026419777423143387,
0.2112298309803009,
-0.6716071367263794,
0.4152490794658661,
-0.028617022559046745,
-0.5727088451385498,
0.9503764510154724,
-0.7806899547576904,
-0.5129609704017639,
0.04538827762007713,
-0.5054624080657959,
-0.41289931535720825,
-0.136257603764534,
0.04387575760483742,
0.13936562836170197,
0.03355471044778824,
0.4777103066444397,
-0.8525791764259338,
-0.4177640378475189,
0.06731195747852325,
-0.395685613155365,
0.9300690293312073,
0.20265765488147736,
-0.43843862414360046,
0.46304842829704285,
-0.36991217732429504,
-0.2804144024848938,
-0.1313929557800293,
-0.47474420070648193,
-0.1829320192337036,
0.434635728597641,
-0.11857476085424423,
0.21407556533813477,
0.0471266508102417,
-0.3911849856376648,
0.1259939819574356,
-0.200775146484375,
0.8102872967720032,
1.374555230140686,
-0.1614476442337036,
0.8329267501831055,
-0.7566755414009094,
0.4063607156276703,
-0.27368655800819397,
0.6142402291297913,
0.9052143096923828,
-0.46731066703796387,
-0.3437815308570862,
0.05085652694106102,
0.3159165680408478,
0.3459850549697876,
-0.38692575693130493,
0.46486884355545044,
0.26667529344558716,
-0.3088691234588623,
-0.3711261451244354,
0.03371414169669151,
0.03115246444940567,
0.0787166878581047,
0.17951200902462006,
-0.35999515652656555,
-0.4506388008594513,
-0.6258032321929932,
-0.39023441076278687,
-0.41142645478248596,
0.3353743851184845,
0.3065396547317505,
0.3168126940727234,
-0.2868267595767975,
1.0409423112869263,
-0.1122749075293541,
0.17301228642463684,
-0.20004257559776306,
0.19500526785850525,
-0.2074137032032013,
0.5444189310073853,
0.5079125165939331,
-1.0673519372940063,
-0.13594871759414673,
0.11811352521181107,
-0.3689779043197632,
0.4773832857608795,
-0.024540165439248085,
-0.5744408369064331,
-0.15626493096351624,
0.21354348957538605,
-0.455373078584671,
0.3615243434906006,
0.11812616139650345,
-0.34731051325798035,
0.3256893455982208,
0.08040483295917511,
0.14167600870132446,
-1.0013468265533447,
-0.18266752362251282,
-0.20302030444145203,
-0.3590603768825531,
-0.36618927121162415,
-0.22365738451480865,
-0.24047726392745972,
0.21757769584655762,
-0.3511340320110321,
0.4451846778392792,
-0.03234124556183815,
-0.2807849645614624,
0.04715341702103615,
-0.09883766621351242,
-0.3877168893814087,
0.3397778272628784,
0.02624155394732952,
0.6359798908233643,
0.10420763492584229,
-0.6839215159416199,
0.42239880561828613,
0.4831140637397766,
-0.03770735114812851,
0.6991446614265442,
-0.6386088728904724,
0.48767730593681335,
-0.22278951108455658,
0.5237565636634827,
-0.6165913939476013,
-0.5684328079223633,
0.24374058842658997,
-0.5417435765266418,
0.04856928810477257,
0.05393912270665169,
0.019970377907156944,
-0.33714786171913147,
-0.31172189116477966,
0.3983285129070282,
0.24384182691574097,
-0.313260018825531,
0.48775577545166016,
0.9001877307891846,
-0.13295720517635345,
-0.8473052382469177,
-0.3448124825954437,
-0.18585018813610077,
-0.2449207752943039,
-0.5072700381278992,
0.2845304608345032,
-0.267057329416275,
-0.3030283451080322,
-0.05554359033703804,
0.0590808279812336,
0.006714924704283476,
0.27431583404541016,
0.34687530994415283,
0.40813422203063965,
0.17249634861946106,
0.03000381775200367,
0.16298766434192657,
-0.0968760997056961,
-0.08824500441551208,
-0.4047219455242157,
0.5202357172966003,
-0.15159372985363007,
-0.2612673342227936,
-0.11717242747545242,
0.41131240129470825,
0.5194998979568481,
-0.381929874420166,
0.17739596962928772,
0.3671838641166687,
-0.3795042037963867,
0.07032892107963562,
-0.27119097113609314,
-0.2968902885913849,
-0.5108786821365356,
0.16749538481235504,
0.21161353588104248,
-1.1936477422714233,
0.3690963387489319,
0.05937576666474342,
0.5846596360206604,
0.16464267671108246,
0.7453253865242004,
-0.3208179175853729,
1.2618718147277832,
0.7305532693862915,
-0.5116909146308899,
0.8339240550994873,
0.026953423395752907,
0.0651034414768219,
-0.22769100964069366,
0.057377107441425323,
-0.47710612416267395,
-0.6661261320114136,
-0.6581625938415527,
0.1878572702407837,
0.10400635004043579,
-0.20649395883083344,
-0.591952383518219,
0.018034854903817177,
-0.6043869853019714,
0.8278127908706665,
0.7931391596794128,
0.3966250717639923,
-0.05823406204581261,
-0.29738494753837585,
-0.02114119753241539,
0.47434455156326294,
-0.409823477268219,
-0.4816693961620331,
0.9401192665100098,
-0.039408598095178604,
0.5160200595855713,
-0.028853941708803177,
1.129506230354309,
0.38201847672462463,
0.364384263753891,
-0.41261202096939087,
0.4036659002304077,
-0.11036179959774017,
-0.8261445760726929,
-0.7290342450141907,
-0.15453819930553436,
-1.1721776723861694,
0.15322937071323395,
-0.1492082178592682,
-0.6940777897834778,
0.4452105760574341,
0.3522229790687561,
-0.9634299874305725,
0.17223599553108215,
-0.4039924740791321,
0.7442685961723328,
-0.3645172417163849,
-0.4051855802536011,
-0.4871070683002472,
-0.9507500529289246,
0.2727435827255249,
0.31549108028411865,
0.044125452637672424,
-0.06197527423501015,
0.2704198360443115,
0.6826189756393433,
-0.1472097635269165,
1.0527055263519287,
-0.09799864888191223,
0.31216666102409363,
0.24040861427783966,
-0.36859002709388733,
0.4191974103450775,
0.3092988133430481,
-0.01833665557205677,
-0.029593871906399727,
0.05870373174548149,
-0.32288461923599243,
-0.2763955891132355,
0.44099995493888855,
-1.3570722341537476,
-0.5847488045692444,
-0.34797024726867676,
-0.37434136867523193,
-0.3215630352497101,
0.12866459786891937,
0.5008677244186401,
0.1318579614162445,
-0.5708693861961365,
0.10865352302789688,
0.5083414316177368,
0.13430701196193695,
0.35276880860328674,
0.17476408183574677,
0.10853228718042374,
-0.5348843932151794,
0.7193076014518738,
0.19916731119155884,
0.1859177201986313,
-0.08934328705072403,
0.30416908860206604,
-0.3885762095451355,
-0.3913663327693939,
-0.45080119371414185,
-0.0032260834705084562,
-0.430562287569046,
-0.170969620347023,
-0.4099104702472687,
-0.07532908022403717,
-0.5516052842140198,
-0.6155406832695007,
-0.17640244960784912,
-0.2766503095626831,
-0.3821353316307068,
-0.622033417224884,
0.1400430053472519,
0.9007648825645447,
-0.29951971769332886,
0.1364758461713791,
-0.6491135358810425,
0.4233214557170868,
0.6763536930084229,
0.5525641441345215,
-0.3360704481601715,
0.06238732114434242,
0.10940899699926376,
0.22445248067378998,
-0.533074676990509,
-0.7787026762962341,
-0.13421063125133514,
-0.17704319953918457,
0.7373992204666138,
0.47458168864250183,
0.29429951310157776,
0.5897438526153564,
-0.4716952443122864,
0.6971878409385681,
0.10038533061742783,
-0.6935635805130005,
0.6660512089729309,
-0.45845216512680054,
-0.11292071640491486,
0.9538487195968628,
0.33281925320625305,
-0.675354540348053,
-0.443194717168808,
-0.8461676239967346,
-0.49862951040267944,
0.6896257996559143,
-0.10621456801891327,
0.17064201831817627,
0.042804814875125885,
0.37377405166625977,
0.21294167637825012,
0.16383413970470428,
-0.7396520972251892,
0.23927219212055206,
-0.235891655087471,
-0.19962827861309052,
-0.05063222721219063,
0.17995087802410126,
-0.5069217681884766,
-0.3463577628135681,
0.34229475259780884,
-0.20796047151088715,
0.10707760602235794,
-0.13341501355171204,
0.17808383703231812,
-0.46855786442756653,
0.16706699132919312,
0.5754104256629944,
0.6480008959770203,
0.15339812636375427,
-0.1279415488243103,
0.023703355342149734,
-0.2640778422355652,
0.5354083776473999,
-0.0725393295288086,
-0.31117403507232666,
-0.6971624493598938,
-0.12373685091733932,
0.6340302228927612,
-0.0691760703921318,
-0.12722526490688324,
0.37497082352638245,
-0.1972762942314148,
-0.498778760433197,
-0.2545185685157776,
0.6174151301383972,
-0.13402493298053741,
0.3893154561519623,
-0.159319207072258,
0.391770601272583,
0.23557184636592865,
-0.5918411016464233,
0.4287905991077423,
0.546441376209259,
-0.5623612999916077,
-0.2492665797472,
0.7347865700721741,
0.5071457028388977,
-0.5525842308998108,
0.6999441981315613,
-0.06830527633428574,
-0.5429790616035461,
0.8089720010757446,
0.1878764033317566,
0.8232828974723816,
-0.2896895408630371,
0.4113123416900635,
-0.016201402992010117,
0.23023125529289246,
-0.4267788827419281,
0.27275076508522034,
-0.16972868144512177,
-1.1520836353302002,
-0.27641603350639343,
-0.25546514987945557,
-0.6349189877510071,
-0.12973126769065857,
-0.5742267966270447,
0.3341066837310791,
-0.8104285597801208,
-0.2182287871837616,
0.07982093840837479,
-0.01966163143515587,
-0.552756130695343,
0.15963870286941528,
0.19901788234710693,
0.35148438811302185,
-0.9322106242179871,
0.6879497170448303,
0.6082889437675476,
-0.4768407940864563,
-0.829816997051239,
-0.12123876810073853,
0.18542642891407013,
-0.6571049690246582,
0.14878834784030914,
0.1043442040681839,
-0.2997569739818573,
-0.2033579796552658,
-1.2888230085372925,
-0.7706063985824585,
0.9196275472640991,
0.4020201861858368,
-0.3309558033943176,
-0.18968482315540314,
-0.07536794990301132,
0.2537968158721924,
-0.17432893812656403,
-0.10555191338062286,
0.8160822987556458,
0.6470887660980225,
-0.005901919677853584,
-0.6192355155944824,
-0.2692700922489166,
-0.1961553990840912,
-0.19116219878196716,
0.2600604295730591,
-1.1109970808029175,
0.609160304069519,
-0.37384259700775146,
-0.018957147374749184,
-0.16238030791282654,
0.6291587352752686,
0.29432740807533264,
0.397151380777359,
0.7663343548774719,
0.13673676550388336,
1.0608175992965698,
-0.06345751881599426,
0.9305326342582703,
-0.042834095656871796,
0.10015495866537094,
1.0161689519882202,
-0.5736185908317566,
0.5013397932052612,
0.3462674915790558,
-0.41900163888931274,
0.3073558509349823,
1.3443766832351685,
0.03899981826543808,
0.6531074047088623,
0.053662464022636414,
-0.06856481730937958,
-0.4166717529296875,
0.14036059379577637,
-0.14875270426273346,
0.6425119042396545,
0.36952635645866394,
-0.013868900947272778,
0.3255920708179474,
-0.33665233850479126,
-0.33436015248298645,
-0.22246114909648895,
-0.2900644540786743,
1.092923641204834,
-0.09101036936044693,
-0.9961088299751282,
-0.0528390109539032,
-0.23665732145309448,
0.5032353401184082,
-0.32683858275413513,
-0.1685386449098587,
-0.16745486855506897,
-0.016527051106095314,
-0.24449671804904938,
-0.6303266882896423,
0.32963457703590393,
-0.40341588854789734,
-0.3562520444393158,
-0.05630997195839882,
0.5590547323226929,
-0.20733347535133362,
-0.18467958271503448,
0.1503993570804596,
0.13445964455604553,
-0.14260739088058472,
0.39007994532585144,
-0.778451144695282,
-0.31150782108306885,
0.027547428384423256,
-0.01369708962738514,
0.47646331787109375,
0.24550722539424896,
-0.4567069113254547,
0.39931705594062805,
0.8396350741386414,
0.06637044250965118,
-0.062149785459041595,
-0.08107233792543411,
0.8029084801673889,
-0.5618903636932373,
-0.9923793077468872,
-0.8140707612037659,
0.49363625049591064,
-0.466465562582016,
-0.556125283241272,
-0.16028882563114166,
0.10335970669984818,
0.9772212505340576,
0.41585859656333923,
1.1547322273254395,
-0.041432056576013565,
0.16729098558425903,
-0.3201664686203003,
0.575141966342926,
-0.30122795701026917,
-0.17582577466964722,
-0.28081798553466797,
-0.6984529495239258,
-0.2356078028678894,
0.7667059302330017,
-0.4442788064479828,
0.1328134834766388,
0.2799743711948395,
0.47309544682502747,
-0.04393213987350464,
0.42631030082702637,
0.1190098449587822,
-0.27029699087142944,
0.35208627581596375,
0.27090588212013245,
1.023220181465149,
0.3201589584350586,
0.4860122501850128,
0.09682497382164001,
-0.2770177721977234,
-0.22602741420269012,
-0.5132421255111694,
-0.5969785451889038,
-0.3468639552593231,
-0.09980332851409912,
-0.1922074556350708,
0.30203256011009216,
1.2730129957199097,
0.8257997632026672,
-0.829984188079834,
-0.30312371253967285,
-0.24181081354618073,
0.42223599553108215,
-0.5184950232505798,
-0.08711957186460495,
-0.0005496676312759519,
-0.46552538871765137,
-0.5621138215065002,
0.16445724666118622,
0.31033360958099365,
-0.033179719001054764,
-0.11636174470186234,
-0.3713590204715729,
-0.15877319872379303,
0.1195700466632843,
0.3403177559375763,
0.4217895567417145,
-0.7965700030326843,
-0.724000096321106,
-0.22509293258190155,
-0.26039519906044006,
0.2097095102071762,
1.0350463390350342,
-0.3865549564361572,
0.14419600367546082,
0.5169910192489624,
1.0265446901321411,
0.17716804146766663,
0.1091141477227211,
1.067636251449585,
-0.4086320400238037,
-0.08958876132965088,
0.3224664032459259,
0.4328744411468506,
0.04061701148748398,
-0.751074492931366,
0.6908944845199585,
0.12233823537826538,
-1.0475471019744873,
-0.3954937160015106,
0.42280444502830505,
-0.5826547145843506,
-0.3062096834182739,
0.9399411678314209,
0.1767185926437378,
-0.11910545080900192,
-0.5639600157737732,
-0.458332896232605,
0.34458401799201965,
-0.6304821372032166,
1.0966466665267944,
0.8839871883392334,
-0.44386669993400574,
-0.2065163105726242,
-0.24250973761081696,
0.7232319712638855,
0.3316759169101715,
-0.863236129283905,
-0.04896963760256767,
0.8188598155975342,
0.12162259966135025,
-0.042833562940359116,
0.9081689715385437,
-0.04680847004055977,
0.7198560237884521,
-0.3951641321182251,
-0.18161821365356445,
0.4591175615787506,
-0.47095492482185364,
-0.35539618134498596,
-0.05621737986803055,
0.13216951489448547,
-0.2037108689546585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10268v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10268v1
|
Modeling Low-Resource Health Coaching Dialogues via Neuro-Symbolic Goal Summarization and Text-Units-Text Generation
| 2024-04-16T03:46:30 | 2024-04-16T03:46:30 |
Yue Zhou, Barbara Di Eugenio, Brian Ziebart, Lisa Sharp, Bing Liu, Nikolaos Agadakos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Health coaching helps patients achieve personalized and lifestyle-related
goals, effectively managing chronic conditions and alleviating mental health
issues. It is particularly beneficial, however cost-prohibitive, for
low-socioeconomic status populations due to its highly personalized and
labor-intensive nature. In this paper, we propose a neuro-symbolic goal
summarizer to support health coaches in keeping track of the goals and a
text-units-text dialogue generation model that converses with patients and
helps them create and accomplish specific goals for physical activities. Our
models outperform previous state-of-the-art while eliminating the need for
predefined schema and corresponding annotation. We also propose a new health
coaching dataset extending previous work and a metric to measure the
unconventionality of the patient's response based on data difficulty,
facilitating potential coach alerts during deployment.
|
[
-0.01881127618253231,
-0.544660210609436,
0.4616898000240326,
0.07663819938898087,
-0.18515630066394806,
-0.01211586594581604,
-0.2544499337673187,
-0.39024579524993896,
0.8790579438209534,
0.323799729347229,
-0.9313433170318604,
-0.5596911907196045,
-0.47612258791923523,
0.17401497066020966,
0.16460467875003815,
1.2268165349960327,
0.1841316819190979,
0.17939290404319763,
-0.14567837119102478,
-0.04574275761842728,
-0.8558703660964966,
-0.25275376439094543,
-0.7997872233390808,
-0.6675929427146912,
0.49515268206596375,
0.49340805411338806,
0.5671494603157043,
0.3311726152896881,
0.5637187361717224,
0.2297992706298828,
-0.10195915400981903,
0.38813912868499756,
-0.453041672706604,
0.5366595387458801,
0.1280074119567871,
-0.3632410168647766,
-0.988092303276062,
-0.13446557521820068,
0.2762455940246582,
1.027335286140442,
-0.288525253534317,
0.4853568375110626,
0.05708688497543335,
0.3816613554954529,
-0.3944031596183777,
0.3575590252876282,
-0.5156998634338379,
0.35315588116645813,
0.31066057085990906,
-0.22633446753025055,
-0.026307396590709686,
-0.23700401186943054,
-0.03134630620479584,
-0.6631205081939697,
0.06787475198507309,
-0.1585112065076828,
0.5013094544410706,
0.7289777994155884,
-0.3011702597141266,
-0.16349446773529053,
-0.7564079165458679,
0.5680256485939026,
-0.8956922888755798,
-0.1386559009552002,
0.8707334399223328,
0.37534722685813904,
-0.19801782071590424,
-0.24725914001464844,
-0.10946907103061676,
0.044543370604515076,
-0.3200185000896454,
0.5005823373794556,
-0.279619961977005,
0.2443452924489975,
0.24857698380947113,
0.09413538873195648,
-0.37719976902008057,
0.07041008770465851,
-0.23805032670497894,
0.14681476354599,
0.7981104254722595,
0.7895126342773438,
0.23827745020389557,
-0.5614871382713318,
0.3584834933280945,
0.562297523021698,
-0.3621014654636383,
-0.1559651494026184,
-0.1037319228053093,
0.5198140144348145,
-0.476894348859787,
0.6833555698394775,
-0.6781178712844849,
0.43275582790374756,
0.09611734002828598,
-0.6601385474205017,
-0.04631275311112404,
-0.4614380896091461,
-0.11478285491466522,
0.26421427726745605,
0.6585062742233276,
0.7945743799209595,
0.043272465467453,
-0.4030856192111969,
-0.23305650055408478,
-0.10509014874696732,
0.32391977310180664,
-1.1200308799743652,
-0.3840174078941345,
0.14141476154327393,
-0.8902771472930908,
-0.33193519711494446,
-0.5742738842964172,
-0.7475379705429077,
-0.45967793464660645,
-0.3804263770580292,
0.07871973514556885,
-0.7268199324607849,
-0.1802109181880951,
-0.0394735150039196,
-0.010853049345314503,
-0.3099648654460907,
0.34356799721717834,
-1.0469646453857422,
0.5683231949806213,
0.3618719279766083,
1.1602137088775635,
0.08728578686714172,
0.3486959934234619,
-0.4836198389530182,
0.29005181789398193,
0.027472075074911118,
0.6245704293251038,
-0.45555487275123596,
-0.8029940724372864,
0.0929316058754921,
-0.11119919270277023,
-0.011755513958632946,
-0.24802227318286896,
0.302742063999176,
0.24290432035923004,
-0.01620800979435444,
-0.2708883285522461,
-0.437513142824173,
0.3127533495426178,
0.4596351385116577,
-0.2913084328174591,
0.9078293442726135,
0.3672823905944824,
-0.46172860264778137,
0.28569865226745605,
-0.771471381187439,
-0.716627299785614,
0.5810214281082153,
-0.29788514971733093,
-0.3242166340351105,
0.5306531190872192,
-0.012920983135700226,
0.4042127728462219,
-0.6903166174888611,
0.006617994513362646,
-0.19440248608589172,
-0.24265065789222717,
0.1271182745695114,
-0.16912177205085754,
0.4156135618686676,
0.01700183004140854,
-0.20895591378211975,
0.03209279105067253,
-0.7236654162406921,
0.26457035541534424,
-0.056317731738090515,
-0.24149635434150696,
-0.4589976370334625,
0.2749234437942505,
-0.14359401166439056,
0.33949732780456543,
0.15310639142990112,
-0.35235610604286194,
0.23088717460632324,
-0.46348118782043457,
0.5326020121574402,
0.3672356605529785,
0.3555498421192169,
0.2571491301059723,
-0.48662298917770386,
0.7733346223831177,
-0.41354528069496155,
0.3996126055717468,
-0.2909778356552124,
-0.6188696622848511,
0.008769490756094456,
-0.446271151304245,
-0.16277389228343964,
0.342229962348938,
-0.9113355875015259,
0.5391216278076172,
-0.5522283911705017,
-0.8393226265907288,
-0.4400947391986847,
-0.02998962253332138,
0.4011407196521759,
1.0364480018615723,
0.5415390729904175,
-0.16644816100597382,
-0.08596419543027878,
-0.612190842628479,
-0.12784124910831451,
-0.2852979004383087,
0.03656269609928131,
0.7253815531730652,
0.6531182527542114,
-0.04678689315915108,
0.715708315372467,
-0.8273072242736816,
-0.5743615031242371,
-0.4935775101184845,
0.17024102807044983,
0.19245289266109467,
0.6151186227798462,
0.6468271017074585,
-0.5600098371505737,
-0.5344700813293457,
-0.1278495490550995,
-0.8491891622543335,
-0.05163086950778961,
-0.05684183910489082,
-0.1016753539443016,
-0.30345168709754944,
0.17714367806911469,
-0.7913546562194824,
0.8332837820053101,
0.4131239652633667,
-0.2879830598831177,
0.5531245470046997,
-0.25186657905578613,
0.24439974129199982,
-1.2855993509292603,
0.14438608288764954,
0.043638668954372406,
-0.04754220321774483,
-0.6866680979728699,
-0.712232768535614,
-0.5748639106750488,
-0.3549010753631592,
-0.13275592029094696,
0.39332371950149536,
-0.23768602311611176,
0.2599543035030365,
-0.47115930914878845,
-0.19670352339744568,
-0.2368096113204956,
0.42292433977127075,
0.1319403350353241,
0.2711741626262665,
0.2975507378578186,
-0.5007171034812927,
0.3984197974205017,
0.4879092276096344,
-0.06950434297323227,
1.0218632221221924,
-1.1612474918365479,
-0.14109571278095245,
-0.1794711947441101,
0.384175568819046,
-0.6923574805259705,
-0.5820118188858032,
0.3288848102092743,
-0.4079638421535492,
0.015006336383521557,
-0.18311071395874023,
-0.37075716257095337,
-0.3352624177932739,
-0.10242483019828796,
0.5948877930641174,
0.559578537940979,
0.18967196345329285,
0.5112830996513367,
0.6198115944862366,
-0.22046011686325073,
-0.09116728603839874,
-0.6927233338356018,
-0.049651820212602615,
-0.2483012080192566,
-0.2652214467525482,
0.6616057753562927,
-0.08572493493556976,
-0.030823273584246635,
0.3033648133277893,
-0.23747628927230835,
-0.07554745674133301,
0.2232038825750351,
0.5589938163757324,
0.4313507378101349,
0.028828345239162445,
0.3238997459411621,
0.2523999810218811,
-0.18834203481674194,
0.28859758377075195,
-0.3988751769065857,
0.43106094002723694,
0.20499595999717712,
-0.197677344083786,
-0.44174930453300476,
0.9190404415130615,
0.17064735293388367,
-0.1623760461807251,
1.0046255588531494,
0.3724474012851715,
-0.926181972026825,
-0.13755132257938385,
-0.03702238202095032,
-0.6005527377128601,
-0.40114039182662964,
0.39499086141586304,
-0.04902755469083786,
-0.551552951335907,
0.20692184567451477,
-0.2908678650856018,
0.08117866516113281,
-0.06274588406085968,
0.7524758577346802,
-0.31933900713920593,
1.3278656005859375,
0.37304890155792236,
0.3343891203403473,
0.4233696758747101,
-0.15168525278568268,
0.21802160143852234,
-0.6700773239135742,
-0.36453670263290405,
-0.42348870635032654,
-0.7439810633659363,
-0.5192037224769592,
-0.05411043390631676,
0.7063611745834351,
-0.17999550700187683,
-0.2468770295381546,
0.43754419684410095,
-1.0087841749191284,
0.094608835875988,
0.3889451026916504,
0.4985117018222809,
-0.028209272772073746,
-0.36700472235679626,
-0.014354418963193893,
-0.5426664352416992,
-0.7794570922851562,
-0.3818594813346863,
0.6226943135261536,
-0.14103087782859802,
0.8282669186592102,
0.22898884117603302,
1.0130740404129028,
0.15829019248485565,
0.5399634838104248,
-1.1254010200500488,
0.4778215289115906,
-0.14408764243125916,
-0.670819103717804,
-0.27111101150512695,
-0.5954617857933044,
-0.7541331648826599,
0.012678028084337711,
-0.6377526521682739,
-1.0406619310379028,
0.017336484044790268,
0.5033376216888428,
-0.7814828157424927,
0.1707819402217865,
-0.5923236012458801,
0.9577863812446594,
-0.40829893946647644,
-0.27805790305137634,
-0.2320100963115692,
-0.7131056189537048,
0.25482892990112305,
-0.03141971677541733,
0.02386978268623352,
-0.5908030867576599,
0.05136475712060928,
0.6208314895629883,
-0.7468558549880981,
1.058731198310852,
-0.23302775621414185,
0.3969813883304596,
0.11030860245227814,
0.019375212490558624,
0.36077186465263367,
0.19936539232730865,
0.06392517685890198,
-0.21606765687465668,
0.18111269176006317,
-0.3748694062232971,
-0.7087754607200623,
0.5226326584815979,
-0.4437447488307953,
-0.4333252012729645,
-0.2834724485874176,
-0.5591282248497009,
-0.48572441935539246,
0.3103560209274292,
0.2905387580394745,
0.3518611788749695,
-0.27390098571777344,
0.1281442940235138,
0.28704074025154114,
-0.3819371163845062,
0.4455602765083313,
0.48410993814468384,
0.3702351152896881,
-0.4274909496307373,
0.803001344203949,
0.33036869764328003,
0.16112184524536133,
0.21556565165519714,
0.2947796881198883,
0.16070492565631866,
-0.3420323431491852,
0.1980108767747879,
0.32186761498451233,
-0.3527768850326538,
-0.538769006729126,
-0.32391875982284546,
-0.12565165758132935,
-0.5245280265808105,
-0.08634503185749054,
-0.3105762302875519,
-0.34632962942123413,
-0.21639864146709442,
-0.07271133363246918,
0.3738071322441101,
0.4266982972621918,
-0.12333157658576965,
0.6155800223350525,
-0.8483664393424988,
0.22260424494743347,
0.017042404040694237,
-0.026497511193156242,
0.05468645691871643,
-0.20334672927856445,
-0.7015963196754456,
0.13180556893348694,
-0.3543667793273926,
-1.2988898754119873,
0.6528332233428955,
0.02313496172428131,
0.24921292066574097,
0.250300794839859,
0.25742900371551514,
0.7227946519851685,
-0.7248298525810242,
0.82087641954422,
0.7646881937980652,
-0.6422273516654968,
0.9649056196212769,
-0.23649421334266663,
0.38083428144454956,
0.7063278555870056,
0.3715203106403351,
-0.7193085551261902,
0.017865939065814018,
-0.5045074820518494,
-0.7918453216552734,
0.6550130844116211,
0.1493023931980133,
0.3531584143638611,
-0.34426555037498474,
0.49216070771217346,
-0.24195708334445953,
0.41394510865211487,
-0.24419786036014557,
-0.2965267598628998,
-0.4851495325565338,
-0.5641498565673828,
0.2807711362838745,
0.09664693474769592,
-0.3594823479652405,
-0.42885076999664307,
0.7858567833900452,
-0.545887291431427,
0.35396909713745117,
0.09588061273097992,
0.33951127529144287,
0.11175261437892914,
0.16142666339874268,
0.5878458023071289,
0.0860542356967926,
-0.07453534007072449,
0.09903296828269958,
0.3337322175502777,
-0.39146989583969116,
0.009922626428306103,
0.03647053241729736,
-0.26961749792099,
0.3374583423137665,
0.33813929557800293,
0.7029476165771484,
0.6516634225845337,
-0.4423544108867645,
0.22071993350982666,
-0.04704925790429115,
-0.22680428624153137,
-0.1450449526309967,
0.2608720362186432,
0.23105669021606445,
-0.02872052788734436,
-0.1264723837375641,
0.18377439677715302,
0.19891910254955292,
-0.20038296282291412,
0.01896561123430729,
0.3783150911331177,
-0.7443864941596985,
-0.5895769000053406,
0.9868737459182739,
0.43900054693222046,
-0.6578416228294373,
0.46122193336486816,
-0.14550592005252838,
-0.0986095741391182,
0.3883174955844879,
0.4602605998516083,
0.757320761680603,
-0.012189332395792007,
0.6403071880340576,
0.38408634066581726,
0.21838068962097168,
0.07857957482337952,
0.2420491725206375,
-0.2920829951763153,
-0.36522531509399414,
-0.36682233214378357,
-0.3692205548286438,
-0.4145011901855469,
-0.12319936603307724,
-0.845005452632904,
0.25065818428993225,
-0.25133731961250305,
-0.9321640133857727,
0.35207709670066833,
0.022854100912809372,
-0.7881361246109009,
0.37234628200531006,
0.13208405673503876,
0.5431909561157227,
-0.6087374687194824,
0.7072127461433411,
0.7878175973892212,
-0.8902913331985474,
-0.9303655624389648,
-0.1181873083114624,
0.27605801820755005,
-0.8070367574691772,
0.6463813185691833,
-0.1004994586110115,
-0.11900090426206589,
-0.30347520112991333,
-0.3010195195674896,
-0.4313548505306244,
1.3371461629867554,
0.7162664532661438,
-0.1153285875916481,
-0.7869047522544861,
0.22012563049793243,
0.6398944854736328,
-0.45131075382232666,
0.343822717666626,
0.2913103699684143,
0.3394128084182739,
0.04762180149555206,
-0.7421508431434631,
0.1444900631904602,
-0.2483292520046234,
0.058365605771541595,
-0.010810532607138157,
-0.8289161324501038,
0.6841608285903931,
-0.3483175039291382,
0.04734749346971512,
0.020122431218624115,
0.3583727180957794,
0.08927842229604721,
0.12310834228992462,
0.360434353351593,
0.24535681307315826,
0.908255934715271,
-0.1706409454345703,
1.1425533294677734,
-0.6759065389633179,
0.18158821761608124,
1.432753324508667,
-0.22881093621253967,
0.2244526445865631,
0.37266311049461365,
0.1773606687784195,
0.23025871813297272,
0.34210124611854553,
0.03249198943376541,
0.47319260239601135,
0.23511724174022675,
-0.6336816549301147,
-0.3989188075065613,
-0.7983559370040894,
-0.0991726964712143,
0.4305623173713684,
0.2577797770500183,
-0.6249416470527649,
-0.2823511064052582,
-0.25014564394950867,
0.37504667043685913,
0.0726800262928009,
-0.16916418075561523,
0.8247587084770203,
0.474816232919693,
-0.7967857122421265,
0.3540489375591278,
-0.07372016459703445,
0.32053470611572266,
-0.5483487844467163,
-0.18534116446971893,
-0.222670778632164,
0.11711002886295319,
-0.48206526041030884,
-0.25784236192703247,
0.3733990490436554,
0.1658681333065033,
-0.3231949806213379,
-0.5490723252296448,
0.6397401690483093,
-0.5035339593887329,
-0.4512919485569,
0.08180730789899826,
0.6432382464408875,
0.19551703333854675,
0.24061033129692078,
-0.8059543371200562,
-0.4163130521774292,
-0.3727359473705292,
-0.08110673725605011,
0.22675448656082153,
0.43423089385032654,
0.050082385540008545,
0.3914654552936554,
0.33471593260765076,
0.5716033577919006,
-0.3442368507385254,
0.14232948422431946,
0.4430290758609772,
-0.5716451406478882,
-0.5165206789970398,
-0.7480781674385071,
0.38732367753982544,
-0.4116753935813904,
-0.7348527908325195,
0.5671485662460327,
0.37284228205680847,
-0.019783347845077515,
0.04998049885034561,
0.8664058446884155,
-0.060310810804367065,
0.24919354915618896,
-0.16165240108966827,
0.9432429075241089,
-0.6573155522346497,
-0.05027160048484802,
-0.23111777007579803,
-0.2881145477294922,
-0.17283396422863007,
0.5405141115188599,
-0.20446226000785828,
0.052074138075113297,
0.5657296180725098,
0.47372618317604065,
0.2949454188346863,
0.08053284138441086,
0.17935174703598022,
-0.15159718692302704,
0.5542944669723511,
0.8513844609260559,
0.44760140776634216,
-0.19855405390262604,
0.4109592139720917,
-0.20481626689434052,
-0.20996524393558502,
-0.09503494203090668,
-0.6852894425392151,
-1.0448635816574097,
-0.3893680274486542,
-0.6180228590965271,
-0.4564582109451294,
-0.040798962116241455,
1.287429690361023,
1.03874933719635,
-0.6034395694732666,
-0.1372479945421219,
0.11470374464988708,
0.007452256046235561,
-0.47855424880981445,
-0.15943355858325958,
0.11240135133266449,
-0.3075290024280548,
-0.5084770321846008,
0.2952515780925751,
0.28486308455467224,
0.1392444521188736,
0.01825336180627346,
-0.1903565227985382,
0.18494099378585815,
0.2074408382177353,
0.46393024921417236,
0.35423675179481506,
-0.2772446572780609,
-0.1553633213043213,
0.15631631016731262,
-0.16433243453502655,
-0.0896502137184143,
0.9413918256759644,
-0.5537546277046204,
0.04214518517255783,
0.006903752218931913,
0.5549948811531067,
0.5771027207374573,
-0.09779883921146393,
0.4604956805706024,
-0.8457576632499695,
0.06574375182390213,
0.5625819563865662,
0.3776841163635254,
0.17164753377437592,
-0.2994683086872101,
0.583774209022522,
0.3484373688697815,
-0.2883792221546173,
-0.9448038339614868,
0.13604582846164703,
-0.7694286704063416,
-0.05583270266652107,
0.9638451933860779,
-0.1496504545211792,
-0.26727229356765747,
0.0707043930888176,
-0.2293144315481186,
0.39187848567962646,
-0.4388238787651062,
0.7812686562538147,
0.5412572622299194,
-0.6334750652313232,
0.2897454500198364,
-0.581554651260376,
0.7687674164772034,
0.4935356676578522,
-1.2390199899673462,
-0.08859431743621826,
0.6613832116127014,
0.02438226155936718,
0.033270463347435,
0.9015921354293823,
0.2257688343524933,
0.22003567218780518,
-0.05508669465780258,
-0.08229375630617142,
-0.08920439332723618,
0.04889935255050659,
0.2918780744075775,
0.044854797422885895,
-0.5120763182640076,
-0.2067607343196869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13077v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13077v1
|
Improving the Capabilities of Large Language Model Based Marketing Analytics Copilots With Semantic Search And Fine-Tuning
| 2024-04-16T03:39:16 | 2024-04-16T03:39:16 |
Yilin Gao, Sai Kumar Arava, Yancheng Li, James W. Snyder Jr
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.1; I.2.7
|
Artificial intelligence (AI) is widely deployed to solve problems related to
marketing attribution and budget optimization. However, AI models can be quite
complex, and it can be difficult to understand model workings and insights
without extensive implementation teams. In principle, recently developed large
language models (LLMs), like GPT-4, can be deployed to provide marketing
insights, reducing the time and effort required to make critical decisions. In
practice, there are substantial challenges that need to be overcome to reliably
use such models. We focus on domain-specific question-answering, SQL generation
needed for data retrieval, and tabular analysis and show how a combination of
semantic search, prompt engineering, and fine-tuning can be applied to
dramatically improve the ability of LLMs to execute these tasks accurately. We
compare both proprietary models, like GPT-4, and open-source models, like
Llama-2-70b, as well as various embedding methods. These models are tested on
sample use cases specific to marketing mix modeling and attribution.
|
[
-0.09916558861732483,
-0.8761335611343384,
0.7551963925361633,
-0.000007254011961776996,
-0.09553588181734085,
0.25024423003196716,
-0.4100160002708435,
-0.5882217884063721,
-0.05199909582734108,
0.6861531138420105,
-0.854130208492279,
-0.5702419877052307,
-0.39847907423973083,
0.15481482446193695,
-0.16922856867313385,
0.8784840703010559,
-0.25668543577194214,
0.15423014760017395,
-0.1180611327290535,
-0.1815636157989502,
-0.6542927026748657,
-0.6407817602157593,
-0.7110412120819092,
-0.13815583288669586,
0.362309068441391,
0.47204768657684326,
0.5839515924453735,
0.31219032406806946,
0.5737946033477783,
0.36357855796813965,
-0.008284421637654305,
0.3661589026451111,
-0.5522527098655701,
0.13483087718486786,
-0.28523582220077515,
-0.4423736035823822,
-0.7827094793319702,
0.17317700386047363,
0.38788318634033203,
0.7576456665992737,
-0.33850643038749695,
0.18321296572685242,
-0.06005508080124855,
0.4776872992515564,
-0.41433876752853394,
0.5607948899269104,
-1.104514479637146,
-0.3328630030155182,
0.10801394283771515,
-0.21698202192783356,
-0.2624940872192383,
-0.3573838770389557,
0.5442225933074951,
-0.9061667323112488,
0.15617208182811737,
0.1964760273694992,
0.8874877691268921,
0.3627847135066986,
-0.4818153977394104,
-0.7233050465583801,
-0.8033689260482788,
0.9728691577911377,
-0.7513291835784912,
0.19713307917118073,
0.40499046444892883,
0.39130836725234985,
-0.1823316365480423,
-0.6383861899375916,
-0.2930736541748047,
-0.33532291650772095,
-0.04244502633810043,
-0.08874405175447464,
-0.2553826570510864,
0.0457959920167923,
0.009148338809609413,
0.20112819969654083,
-0.35169798135757446,
0.1887446641921997,
-0.2911328673362732,
-0.07154849171638489,
0.572084367275238,
0.39989790320396423,
0.06808190047740936,
0.04479866102337837,
0.030914071947336197,
0.14148439466953278,
-0.5616269111633301,
-0.14692793786525726,
0.31302568316459656,
0.4556248188018799,
0.22400762140750885,
0.7694286704063416,
-0.41175276041030884,
0.49621686339378357,
-0.10931990295648575,
0.16249440610408783,
0.004252024460583925,
-0.5652670860290527,
-0.18983784317970276,
-0.16211208701133728,
0.43918314576148987,
0.09489332139492035,
0.41841667890548706,
-0.1960296332836151,
-0.2733437716960907,
-0.0183163583278656,
0.22309818863868713,
-0.7664894461631775,
-0.2401195764541626,
0.27087143063545227,
-0.42051228880882263,
-0.21483241021633148,
-0.10237693786621094,
-0.4790142774581909,
-0.11564535647630692,
-0.5573086142539978,
0.2897394001483917,
-0.29944077134132385,
-0.1773080825805664,
0.10913830995559692,
-0.05052252858877182,
0.4709427058696747,
0.29100751876831055,
-0.8499515056610107,
0.32086682319641113,
1.0630475282669067,
0.7282713055610657,
-0.27977389097213745,
0.025631990283727646,
-0.5271217823028564,
0.20707367360591888,
-0.3422847390174866,
0.887601912021637,
-0.8105571269989014,
-0.15220649540424347,
0.02806372568011284,
-0.0038888209965080023,
-0.19965583086013794,
-0.8802728056907654,
0.40688687562942505,
-0.7034997344017029,
0.05296055227518082,
-0.29835134744644165,
-0.802426815032959,
-0.37328946590423584,
0.6044509410858154,
-0.6007978916168213,
0.6536664962768555,
0.2507438361644745,
-0.21531574428081512,
0.3245958685874939,
-0.825890839099884,
-0.20853492617607117,
0.16032245755195618,
-0.11203298717737198,
-0.718160092830658,
0.23944343626499176,
0.3464660346508026,
0.378997802734375,
-0.37623387575149536,
0.2466379851102829,
-0.2375965714454651,
-0.0915909856557846,
0.2617333233356476,
-0.32385051250457764,
0.4268212616443634,
0.28587135672569275,
-0.3304789364337921,
0.4553047716617584,
-0.676166832447052,
-0.01049948763102293,
0.413006991147995,
-0.4510367214679718,
-0.22508712112903595,
0.035063695162534714,
0.06791269779205322,
-0.16822518408298492,
0.27254530787467957,
-0.2894658148288727,
0.2920300364494324,
-0.4072606563568115,
0.6567836403846741,
0.6403201222419739,
-0.056333888322114944,
0.4829275608062744,
-0.1297796070575714,
0.7693815231323242,
-0.2962464392185211,
0.18854674696922302,
-0.16704915463924408,
-0.5821015238761902,
-0.6022554039955139,
-0.06632930785417557,
0.2992746829986572,
0.4845452904701233,
-0.5758571028709412,
0.2219116985797882,
-0.20569506287574768,
-0.5620940327644348,
-0.327547550201416,
0.3286053240299225,
-0.057606328278779984,
0.33250999450683594,
0.20144318044185638,
-0.18548597395420074,
-0.3134443759918213,
-0.8583332300186157,
-0.31454116106033325,
0.08382348716259003,
-0.12951640784740448,
0.46051666140556335,
0.41556164622306824,
-0.2336193025112152,
0.8769646883010864,
-0.8243780732154846,
-0.4918634295463562,
-0.4872961938381195,
0.04468854144215584,
0.3303695023059845,
0.17060460150241852,
0.424906849861145,
-0.9304163455963135,
-0.5215033888816833,
0.14050932228565216,
-0.40760502219200134,
-0.12623636424541473,
0.20978112518787384,
0.11027252674102783,
0.2813224494457245,
0.31523916125297546,
-0.8316051959991455,
0.36406049132347107,
0.5381162166595459,
-0.2762487232685089,
0.5970035791397095,
-0.3222910463809967,
0.0954882949590683,
-0.7594422698020935,
0.101438008248806,
0.07074973732233047,
-0.20883594453334808,
-0.6977031230926514,
0.04207451641559601,
0.13463912904262543,
-0.5578599572181702,
-0.4628961384296417,
0.3096107542514801,
-0.3464503884315491,
-0.18174225091934204,
-0.3437954783439636,
-0.021474188193678856,
0.23211723566055298,
0.678165853023529,
0.03595289960503578,
0.9142839312553406,
0.2577928304672241,
-0.6982966065406799,
0.38114872574806213,
0.2898436188697815,
-0.6126687526702881,
0.43846777081489563,
-0.8847134709358215,
0.010642828419804573,
0.07076822966337204,
0.34193727374076843,
-0.9554155468940735,
-0.45994046330451965,
0.2840406000614166,
-0.23017343878746033,
0.016044896095991135,
-0.11594534665346146,
-0.7035276889801025,
-0.2343277633190155,
-0.128373384475708,
0.5745494365692139,
0.3209390938282013,
-0.4600541889667511,
0.8129208087921143,
0.3007359802722931,
-0.39323657751083374,
-0.1697903275489807,
-0.2536177933216095,
0.02681364305317402,
-0.4853487014770508,
-0.7297853231430054,
0.2400164008140564,
-0.03367731347680092,
-0.15762220323085785,
-0.1559382826089859,
-0.1049066111445427,
-0.010065391659736633,
0.15844406187534332,
-0.30713945627212524,
0.22365278005599976,
-0.3091775178909302,
0.14045582711696625,
-0.28726163506507874,
-0.25703805685043335,
0.04543044790625572,
-0.4409371614456177,
0.7054458856582642,
-0.0532539002597332,
-0.29288777709007263,
-0.6186662912368774,
0.4484599530696869,
0.580663800239563,
-0.613255500793457,
0.6337795257568359,
0.31328052282333374,
-0.23950828611850739,
-0.1935299038887024,
-0.5974178910255432,
-0.1766633242368698,
-0.5373238921165466,
0.4611474573612213,
-0.29368433356285095,
-0.7596462368965149,
0.7349098324775696,
-0.12169533222913742,
-0.07966343313455582,
0.4002622961997986,
0.736241340637207,
0.018437717109918594,
1.3994218111038208,
0.7506422400474548,
-0.007229895330965519,
0.5664504766464233,
-0.3569793701171875,
0.4092571437358856,
-0.47338467836380005,
-0.29305917024612427,
-0.6793476939201355,
-0.11882487684488297,
-0.5714082717895508,
-0.29044321179389954,
0.49443137645721436,
-0.30978673696517944,
-0.13132035732269287,
0.19137048721313477,
-0.48618102073669434,
0.5793190002441406,
0.5791683793067932,
-0.05114304646849632,
0.37003958225250244,
-0.017437774688005447,
0.4481564164161682,
0.08223825693130493,
-0.542346179485321,
-0.39138489961624146,
1.0410689115524292,
0.4026740789413452,
0.8542730808258057,
0.25035539269447327,
0.08069983124732971,
-0.025882145389914513,
0.17287948727607727,
-1.0455533266067505,
0.38622167706489563,
-0.21551817655563354,
-0.7415423393249512,
-0.15585485100746155,
-0.5069376230239868,
-0.9389168620109558,
0.1730528175830841,
0.0160550307482481,
-0.7466559410095215,
-0.006461277604103088,
0.2113349884748459,
-0.3168199956417084,
0.12909500300884247,
-0.8873584866523743,
1.0513640642166138,
-0.45514920353889465,
-0.11336542665958405,
-0.23398610949516296,
-0.14417468011379242,
0.19293855130672455,
-0.4117449223995209,
0.11088767647743225,
-0.43311992287635803,
-0.11509525030851364,
0.6776237487792969,
-0.698341429233551,
0.7333378791809082,
-0.013838857412338257,
-0.44843435287475586,
0.3376178443431854,
-0.05442523956298828,
0.870550274848938,
-0.2933710813522339,
-0.08795726299285889,
-0.07750964164733887,
-0.023326370865106583,
-0.5149613618850708,
-0.8348844051361084,
0.6371461153030396,
-0.46347159147262573,
-0.6874398589134216,
-0.03387123718857765,
-0.7023743987083435,
-0.38052937388420105,
0.20764131844043732,
-0.05057509243488312,
0.2792244851589203,
-0.11205516755580902,
0.22412942349910736,
0.4520929455757141,
-0.30860817432403564,
0.21364258229732513,
0.4752882719039917,
-0.007625429891049862,
-0.3388338088989258,
0.9289718270301819,
0.031755004078149796,
0.35004284977912903,
0.22757774591445923,
0.3528740108013153,
-0.5196171402931213,
-0.7535132765769958,
-0.18892629444599152,
0.32722896337509155,
-0.7237029671669006,
-0.2850346267223358,
-0.6198397278785706,
0.16836942732334137,
-0.5022950768470764,
-0.015132861211895943,
-0.4782925546169281,
-0.31634625792503357,
-0.25918781757354736,
0.04602295160293579,
0.33021798729896545,
0.7879593968391418,
0.4582311511039734,
0.5685664415359497,
-0.684962272644043,
0.04281145706772804,
0.16093593835830688,
0.4972575306892395,
0.10869864374399185,
-0.10009438544511795,
-0.43937334418296814,
0.062415558844804764,
-0.46752169728279114,
-0.619665265083313,
0.36888495087623596,
-0.0666925385594368,
0.5358983278274536,
0.05824430659413338,
-0.17275184392929077,
0.6212846636772156,
-0.3693857192993164,
0.6289639472961426,
-0.2715838551521301,
-0.9627296328544617,
0.5075816512107849,
-0.7748270630836487,
0.2939724624156952,
0.5204803943634033,
0.496486097574234,
-0.22384583950042725,
-0.16800174117088318,
-0.49526548385620117,
-0.9647302031517029,
0.8378060460090637,
0.2831413149833679,
0.14406584203243256,
0.21029479801654816,
0.3427804708480835,
0.09495564550161362,
0.41564032435417175,
-0.4729136824607849,
0.08108066767454147,
0.11667840927839279,
-0.3784438967704773,
-0.29609495401382446,
-0.10452592372894287,
0.18071496486663818,
-0.3704780638217926,
0.6644735336303711,
-0.26719939708709717,
-0.09163671731948853,
-0.13688187301158905,
-0.013985431753098965,
-0.03786540776491165,
0.1885877102613449,
0.5579902529716492,
0.9699399471282959,
-0.3174192011356354,
-0.4120875298976898,
0.11690422147512436,
-0.08964129537343979,
-0.06757702678442001,
0.17077292501926422,
0.056134358048439026,
-0.18785955011844635,
0.10760018974542618,
0.5494148135185242,
0.10030756145715714,
-1.0075119733810425,
0.4539901614189148,
-0.03401773422956467,
-0.19826819002628326,
-0.5055082440376282,
-0.03349349647760391,
0.1299581229686737,
0.28484195470809937,
0.3821510672569275,
-0.3200330138206482,
0.27598488330841064,
-0.7808058857917786,
0.1568446010351181,
0.7302655577659607,
-0.14195755124092102,
-0.13239836692810059,
0.7482907772064209,
0.24464474618434906,
-0.26929524540901184,
0.6361975073814392,
0.13547919690608978,
-0.685657799243927,
0.867686927318573,
0.42410674691200256,
0.7251855134963989,
-0.12257999926805496,
0.10897397249937057,
-0.08193042874336243,
0.16505327820777893,
0.050399355590343475,
-0.04351144656538963,
-0.012947130016982555,
-0.6100213527679443,
-0.5811347365379333,
-0.3348163664340973,
-0.701417863368988,
0.2025843858718872,
-0.36644744873046875,
0.3662809729576111,
-0.3374868929386139,
-0.036571308970451355,
0.4072108268737793,
0.29814568161964417,
-0.9454888105392456,
-0.03729544207453728,
-0.07759225368499756,
0.8186966776847839,
-0.4099411368370056,
0.6522592902183533,
0.627460777759552,
-0.257224977016449,
-0.9354450702667236,
-0.171697735786438,
0.06623012572526932,
-0.8515390157699585,
0.6443286538124084,
0.23934955894947052,
-0.04595281556248665,
-0.028354978188872337,
-0.5997816324234009,
-0.865324079990387,
1.0346695184707642,
0.07551982253789902,
-0.5132234692573547,
-0.10481613129377365,
0.36040470004081726,
0.5039607882499695,
-0.6942563056945801,
0.10126716643571854,
0.9999902844429016,
0.4782920479774475,
0.20089633762836456,
-0.9344214797019958,
-0.1579858660697937,
0.2012990266084671,
-0.08480207622051239,
0.2932245433330536,
-0.40585458278656006,
0.6892719268798828,
0.03736446425318718,
-0.12237071245908737,
0.3633856177330017,
0.44298362731933594,
0.1972222775220871,
0.5552085041999817,
0.37100473046302795,
0.3580678105354309,
0.7916315793991089,
0.011644793674349785,
1.0198718309402466,
0.04159003496170044,
0.45584848523139954,
1.0331475734710693,
-0.40100744366645813,
0.9023631811141968,
0.24596840143203735,
0.06836302578449249,
0.29895976185798645,
0.6308029294013977,
-0.2820211946964264,
0.5201588869094849,
0.21151147782802582,
-0.09152935445308685,
-0.2054256647825241,
-0.1660812795162201,
0.09116112440824509,
0.6587904095649719,
0.6146875023841858,
-0.2530876696109772,
-0.2521655857563019,
-0.018019510433077812,
0.009432753548026085,
0.03723285719752312,
-0.3388892710208893,
1.0852992534637451,
-0.06888514012098312,
-0.6371649503707886,
0.5822627544403076,
0.06500935554504395,
0.6122736930847168,
-0.7038971185684204,
0.06370890885591507,
-0.1316143423318863,
0.5046097040176392,
0.08819620311260223,
-0.605704128742218,
0.4863557517528534,
0.02228078804910183,
0.029979685321450233,
0.007325579412281513,
0.6555321216583252,
-0.4078141152858734,
-0.5565512776374817,
0.25766417384147644,
0.48162850737571716,
0.028107022866606712,
-0.40223291516304016,
-0.8722139000892639,
0.3739944100379944,
0.001554308575578034,
-0.29993319511413574,
0.005247773602604866,
0.429325133562088,
-0.02970554307103157,
0.803610622882843,
0.6339871287345886,
-0.017504574730992317,
-0.029203936457633972,
0.05114744231104851,
0.8778513669967651,
-0.739964485168457,
-0.3393939733505249,
-0.740969717502594,
0.38689273595809937,
-0.12410307675600052,
0.04014486446976662,
0.6084777116775513,
0.5306557416915894,
0.8013942241668701,
0.05046715959906578,
0.6727633476257324,
0.4370417594909668,
0.46618732810020447,
-0.5775313377380371,
0.5802251100540161,
-0.7670488953590393,
0.4676002264022827,
-0.24993987381458282,
-1.2689318656921387,
-0.42904719710350037,
0.13466179370880127,
-0.6425387859344482,
0.05675399303436279,
0.3314318358898163,
0.865800142288208,
-0.3264527916908264,
0.06604701280593872,
0.24478141963481903,
0.18507221341133118,
0.8596644997596741,
0.4056653678417206,
0.8554549217224121,
-0.29451048374176025,
0.8162602782249451,
0.011011448688805103,
-0.20289047062397003,
-0.334359347820282,
-0.7254955172538757,
-0.8838968873023987,
-0.45852553844451904,
-0.350777268409729,
-0.0896013155579567,
0.018199635669589043,
0.8966077566146851,
0.6940800547599792,
-0.7830610275268555,
-0.2217448502779007,
0.06034386530518532,
0.006763610523194075,
-0.08789567649364471,
-0.25290000438690186,
0.4461832046508789,
-0.5932806730270386,
-0.8691623210906982,
0.34332406520843506,
0.2590131461620331,
0.09235576540231705,
-0.1765425056219101,
0.03180559352040291,
0.04860334470868111,
0.36565783619880676,
0.6422698497772217,
0.02437807433307171,
-0.628659188747406,
-0.10591650009155273,
0.06382476538419724,
0.22345976531505585,
0.08790900558233261,
1.2244973182678223,
-0.35820937156677246,
0.09932618588209152,
0.3524770438671112,
0.8175981640815735,
0.41202011704444885,
0.2192593812942505,
0.8176305890083313,
-0.4921194911003113,
0.056237444281578064,
0.24785681068897247,
0.38357067108154297,
0.4447380602359772,
-0.28814560174942017,
0.46319150924682617,
-0.03475875034928322,
-0.7656412720680237,
-0.4862215220928192,
0.3822094798088074,
-0.9991835951805115,
-0.6468047499656677,
1.0928047895431519,
0.19566595554351807,
-0.29819026589393616,
-0.21991373598575592,
-0.34227845072746277,
-0.0007623398560099304,
-0.4190809726715088,
0.5770004391670227,
0.6933171153068542,
-0.1662573218345642,
-0.005997525993734598,
-0.5875744223594666,
0.531528115272522,
0.5322146415710449,
-0.8137627840042114,
0.3790951669216156,
0.48165589570999146,
0.395183801651001,
0.026289112865924835,
0.4962480068206787,
0.07825127989053726,
-0.05156032368540764,
-0.30633217096328735,
-0.44210734963417053,
-0.08204762637615204,
-0.18693456053733826,
-0.2150357961654663,
0.06431134045124054,
0.21157261729240417,
-0.19062018394470215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10259v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10259v1
|
Uncovering Latent Arguments in Social Media Messaging by Employing LLMs-in-the-Loop Strategy
| 2024-04-16T03:26:43 | 2024-04-16T03:26:43 |
Tunazzina Islam, Dan Goldwasser
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
The widespread use of social media has led to a surge in popularity for
automated methods of analyzing public opinion. Supervised methods are adept at
text categorization, yet the dynamic nature of social media discussions poses a
continual challenge for these techniques due to the constant shifting of the
focus. On the other hand, traditional unsupervised methods for extracting
themes from public discourse, such as topic modeling, often reveal overarching
patterns that might not capture specific nuances. Consequently, a significant
portion of research into social media discourse still depends on
labor-intensive manual coding techniques and a human-in-the-loop approach,
which are both time-consuming and costly. In this work, we study the problem of
discovering arguments associated with a specific theme. We propose a generic
LLMs-in-the-Loop strategy that leverages the advanced capabilities of Large
Language Models (LLMs) to extract latent arguments from social media messaging.
To demonstrate our approach, we apply our framework to contentious topics. We
use two publicly available datasets: (1) the climate campaigns dataset of 14k
Facebook ads with 25 themes and (2) the COVID-19 vaccine campaigns dataset of
9k Facebook ads with 14 themes. Furthermore, we analyze demographic targeting
and the adaptation of messaging based on real-world events.
|
[
-0.4114166498184204,
-1.0538740158081055,
0.6832785606384277,
0.16317974030971527,
-0.9498968720436096,
0.49410393834114075,
-0.33790323138237,
0.22160223126411438,
0.460619181394577,
0.5058125853538513,
-0.5041722655296326,
-0.4501041769981384,
-0.5763798952102661,
-0.1899605691432953,
-0.4526437520980835,
1.0345526933670044,
-0.10294386744499207,
-0.10875698924064636,
-0.3386569023132324,
-0.053826238960027695,
-0.1458914875984192,
-0.5630367398262024,
-0.27392706274986267,
-0.30131208896636963,
0.8027238845825195,
0.730679988861084,
0.2537551522254944,
0.2503863275051117,
0.5599353313446045,
0.18194584548473358,
-0.4199778139591217,
0.2549537122249603,
-0.8095127940177917,
0.2286069095134735,
-0.5157256722450256,
-0.128171905875206,
-0.08116605132818222,
0.2016039937734604,
0.6023011207580566,
0.3689827620983124,
-0.006967292167246342,
0.2924793064594269,
-0.04657909274101257,
0.4969025254249573,
-0.5837244987487793,
-0.28146684169769287,
-1.0991607904434204,
-0.23974110186100006,
-0.36762675642967224,
-0.6356357336044312,
-0.14101198315620422,
-0.45272210240364075,
0.1015269011259079,
-0.1388784646987915,
-0.03366963192820549,
-0.25467991828918457,
1.0375564098358154,
-0.1236134022474289,
-0.46369990706443787,
-0.6843256950378418,
-0.8220021724700928,
0.7969622611999512,
-0.7859624028205872,
-0.10528101027011871,
0.2692793011665344,
0.1963108628988266,
-0.2112690955400467,
-0.4565587639808655,
-0.4345603287220001,
0.13176925480365753,
0.4353391230106354,
0.19949878752231598,
-0.36289575695991516,
-0.30669108033180237,
0.08609770238399506,
0.18079513311386108,
-0.3395031988620758,
0.041878145188093185,
-0.38882195949554443,
-0.04114203527569771,
0.8270992040634155,
0.026501018553972244,
0.04390629008412361,
-0.4505348205566406,
-0.23672448098659515,
0.24393028020858765,
-0.6456718444824219,
0.0881863683462143,
0.6494036316871643,
0.3774622976779938,
-0.44394147396087646,
0.695898711681366,
0.12298883497714996,
0.3721754550933838,
0.33754828572273254,
-0.18116188049316406,
-0.2859973609447479,
-0.09666060656309128,
-0.0025572022423148155,
-0.027950089424848557,
0.8779553771018982,
0.4917965829372406,
0.19405710697174072,
0.07680393755435944,
-0.0669960081577301,
0.36719805002212524,
0.28090205788612366,
-0.6222389340400696,
0.06312020123004913,
0.2019466757774353,
-0.6269770860671997,
-0.3333708643913269,
0.18648898601531982,
-0.9435176849365234,
-0.7286102175712585,
-0.2447102665901184,
-0.02638060785830021,
0.08032321184873581,
-0.2947763502597809,
-0.14758314192295074,
-0.09050673246383667,
0.18602989614009857,
0.29217615723609924,
-0.39875277876853943,
-0.05492627993226051,
0.9999632239341736,
1.0555967092514038,
-0.2410161942243576,
0.4806802570819855,
-0.3909115493297577,
0.09079597145318985,
-0.6763044595718384,
1.1795177459716797,
-1.0996248722076416,
-0.2642890512943268,
0.1432970017194748,
0.12439475953578949,
0.14721959829330444,
-0.5083625316619873,
0.581924557685852,
-0.7887043356895447,
0.13559311628341675,
-0.5065149664878845,
-0.7903740406036377,
0.16954682767391205,
0.16749882698059082,
-0.3764020800590515,
0.8587508201599121,
-0.28077432513237,
-0.9102064967155457,
0.09976040571928024,
-0.747871458530426,
-0.2735574543476105,
-0.03797917068004608,
-0.45663347840309143,
-0.5534255504608154,
0.383463978767395,
0.27304917573928833,
0.7253022789955139,
-0.5261905789375305,
0.5724681615829468,
-0.8669413924217224,
-0.4237584173679352,
0.41349154710769653,
-0.4410153329372406,
0.5945118069648743,
0.4024330973625183,
-0.30621522665023804,
0.1813361644744873,
-0.49872395396232605,
-0.645361065864563,
0.3768308460712433,
-0.29409492015838623,
-0.36453789472579956,
0.2628609836101532,
-0.233301043510437,
0.18933354318141937,
0.008495931513607502,
-0.4666927456855774,
0.12442449480295181,
-0.3164430558681488,
0.6990498900413513,
0.971809446811676,
0.5479370951652527,
0.499161034822464,
-0.29287269711494446,
0.6961327791213989,
0.08495602011680603,
-0.10470758378505707,
-0.23404262959957123,
-0.5842354893684387,
-0.5652357339859009,
0.13232767581939697,
-0.16613587737083435,
0.3727755546569824,
-0.6962736248970032,
0.13254596292972565,
-0.2526637017726898,
-0.5128754377365112,
-0.4826967418193817,
0.22017595171928406,
0.062451377511024475,
0.1823582649230957,
-0.057626452296972275,
0.05964647978544235,
-0.29143357276916504,
-0.6309592127799988,
-0.4834890365600586,
-0.3699429929256439,
0.15167109668254852,
0.5636582970619202,
0.48534929752349854,
-0.31338995695114136,
1.0396233797073364,
-0.5152108669281006,
0.32629793882369995,
-0.18373246490955353,
0.4067436754703522,
0.30324479937553406,
0.0031035507563501596,
0.34045252203941345,
-0.847612202167511,
-0.3979790210723877,
-0.011119523085653782,
-0.7824969291687012,
-0.34677061438560486,
-0.3334297835826874,
-0.18616369366645813,
0.05130802467465401,
0.6564214825630188,
-0.3058495819568634,
0.3666377365589142,
0.5178645253181458,
-0.13382630050182343,
0.2783397138118744,
0.2103809416294098,
-0.003670550649985671,
-1.22000253200531,
-0.26084768772125244,
0.5005045533180237,
-0.04809678718447685,
-0.4095839858055115,
-0.18835103511810303,
-0.16033963859081268,
-0.144510418176651,
-0.4128354489803314,
0.41945400834083557,
-0.20990943908691406,
0.3026578724384308,
-0.46825891733169556,
0.2141675353050232,
-0.055254898965358734,
0.02009832113981247,
-0.12245320528745651,
0.39477550983428955,
0.4787330627441406,
-0.29473021626472473,
0.6055559515953064,
-0.19596822559833527,
-0.2560465931892395,
0.5333317518234253,
-0.5780274868011475,
0.6394538879394531,
-0.4310717284679413,
0.4451322555541992,
-1.1819748878479004,
-0.2918722629547119,
0.39145880937576294,
-0.3635385036468506,
-0.05469777062535286,
-0.44422897696495056,
-0.35842883586883545,
-0.5311118960380554,
-0.47137805819511414,
0.13615797460079193,
0.14323700964450836,
-0.39816564321517944,
0.4134441912174225,
0.842915415763855,
-0.26056915521621704,
-0.22768130898475647,
-0.2554960250854492,
0.3866320550441742,
-0.9054806232452393,
-0.46644023060798645,
0.3558468818664551,
0.039732545614242554,
-0.6136416792869568,
-0.07606007903814316,
-0.13955670595169067,
0.19428351521492004,
0.03914444521069527,
0.27981823682785034,
-0.18436256051063538,
-0.17531441152095795,
0.3302660286426544,
0.04177509993314743,
-0.07396984100341797,
0.1346195638179779,
-0.09626767039299011,
0.5975858569145203,
-0.09285091608762741,
-0.4472624957561493,
-0.258100688457489,
0.6693592667579651,
0.5982972383499146,
0.07612524926662445,
0.4116736948490143,
0.45588418841362,
-0.5015625953674316,
-0.19858253002166748,
-0.7655783295631409,
-0.17865872383117676,
-0.46931731700897217,
0.07016213983297348,
0.13005106151103973,
-0.9288254976272583,
0.4589836895465851,
-0.4666997194290161,
0.13993524014949799,
0.028351793065667152,
0.7889317870140076,
-0.45670953392982483,
0.7430828809738159,
0.3870575726032257,
-0.27989763021469116,
0.6326584219932556,
-0.2613878548145294,
0.372585266828537,
-0.4299250841140747,
0.0952632874250412,
-0.35655951499938965,
-0.05185016244649887,
-0.40503260493278503,
-0.6295803785324097,
0.020634951069951057,
0.22421890497207642,
-0.2649005651473999,
0.1367122083902359,
-0.3254700005054474,
0.24417825043201447,
0.173866868019104,
0.15585565567016602,
-0.04637506976723671,
0.31650087237358093,
0.00835425779223442,
-0.16731509566307068,
-0.6292110681533813,
-1.1953951120376587,
0.865602970123291,
0.5306581258773804,
0.7759215831756592,
-0.05343494936823845,
0.6491000056266785,
0.5494070053100586,
0.745003342628479,
-0.6854574084281921,
0.6923104524612427,
-0.21505527198314667,
-0.48040318489074707,
0.0010310523211956024,
-0.3212844729423523,
-1.0260356664657593,
0.0936722606420517,
-0.322411447763443,
-0.8326545357704163,
0.12484744191169739,
0.02778884582221508,
-0.287295401096344,
0.5619135499000549,
-0.4707469940185547,
0.5838983058929443,
-0.3191657066345215,
-0.4745425283908844,
-0.24918557703495026,
-0.4335978031158447,
0.15294985473155975,
-0.30735617876052856,
0.4725058376789093,
-0.4638271629810333,
0.16649991273880005,
0.917527973651886,
-0.31952184438705444,
1.020400881767273,
-0.05881761759519577,
-0.5498221516609192,
0.5888720154762268,
-0.6236190795898438,
0.5558058023452759,
0.2593003511428833,
0.06653789430856705,
-0.11232228577136993,
-0.4289209842681885,
-0.32824835181236267,
-0.3986469805240631,
0.7021685242652893,
-0.6340755224227905,
-0.7506231665611267,
-0.10962563753128052,
-0.20410732924938202,
-0.01609591394662857,
-0.21155190467834473,
0.0955304503440857,
0.31531837582588196,
-0.31604456901550293,
0.3132670223712921,
0.5259202122688293,
-0.401711106300354,
0.5398654341697693,
0.24927394092082977,
0.026671355590224266,
-0.5697442293167114,
1.0870648622512817,
0.20942439138889313,
0.11228153854608536,
0.11655966937541962,
0.6584917306900024,
-0.2591627240180969,
-0.39412713050842285,
-0.1896471083164215,
0.3054831027984619,
-0.8205975294113159,
-0.361682653427124,
-0.7827629446983337,
0.07463010400533676,
-0.374830961227417,
-0.4598630964756012,
-0.3804478347301483,
0.1838386505842209,
-0.5835428237915039,
0.05847174674272537,
0.43343788385391235,
0.6823090314865112,
0.08428605645895004,
0.6683472394943237,
-0.6100465059280396,
0.47303757071495056,
0.26293492317199707,
0.2269110530614853,
-0.05623646453022957,
-0.4818997383117676,
-0.2234022468328476,
0.2205972671508789,
-0.6424762010574341,
-1.3409234285354614,
0.17925117909908295,
-0.16665144264698029,
0.5204846262931824,
0.8678914308547974,
0.27409887313842773,
0.8468406200408936,
-0.05623626708984375,
0.8401528596878052,
-0.006924744695425034,
-0.7751414179801941,
0.7900986671447754,
-0.6402310729026794,
-0.07760477811098099,
0.18302074074745178,
0.40749049186706543,
-0.4720137417316437,
-0.5442211031913757,
-0.6942455172538757,
-0.9746667146682739,
0.32342496514320374,
0.224129781126976,
0.44095683097839355,
-0.2519363760948181,
0.4544861614704132,
-0.2011602371931076,
0.07135084271430969,
-0.7482593655586243,
0.0007935527246445417,
0.001882811076939106,
0.0737515240907669,
0.0667702928185463,
-0.4132611155509949,
-0.2037905603647232,
-0.23731619119644165,
0.5187240242958069,
-0.18732035160064697,
0.10106196999549866,
-0.12808667123317719,
-0.027133971452713013,
-0.3119773864746094,
0.26393255591392517,
0.568191647529602,
0.6748577952384949,
-0.25600388646125793,
0.010478810407221317,
-0.02677437663078308,
-0.23703633248806,
0.22016803920269012,
-0.05157524347305298,
-0.09841441363096237,
0.18234500288963318,
0.46953895688056946,
0.706447958946228,
0.18835853040218353,
-0.4161638021469116,
0.47013232111930847,
0.007800437044352293,
-0.11579348891973495,
-0.23047411441802979,
-0.313950777053833,
0.7018827795982361,
0.5659516453742981,
0.5658049583435059,
-0.39217618107795715,
-0.29864272475242615,
-0.7457987070083618,
0.23966407775878906,
0.5399526357650757,
-0.4754126965999603,
-0.36352837085723877,
0.4539491832256317,
0.2614160478115082,
-0.4486415982246399,
0.0023307176306843758,
-0.0679706484079361,
-0.3943958878517151,
0.6684630513191223,
0.480243980884552,
0.8915495276451111,
-0.015425609424710274,
0.4645858407020569,
0.07934373617172241,
0.10909203439950943,
-0.057826295495033264,
0.24666254222393036,
0.10808400809764862,
-0.76718670129776,
-0.41119441390037537,
-0.45996522903442383,
-0.3879052400588989,
0.4312692880630493,
-0.621921181678772,
0.3728574812412262,
-0.38662078976631165,
-0.45034176111221313,
0.2651046812534332,
0.15525753796100616,
-0.1502896249294281,
-0.13480521738529205,
0.4411439001560211,
0.5168285965919495,
-1.1868096590042114,
0.6163119673728943,
1.0217795372009277,
0.007758843246847391,
-0.317945659160614,
0.47953125834465027,
0.24966515600681305,
-0.3683687150478363,
0.19100113213062286,
0.07365918159484863,
-0.29665932059288025,
-0.34995362162590027,
-1.0897325277328491,
-0.6293556094169617,
0.8086742758750916,
0.5973635315895081,
-0.5560715198516846,
0.3459055423736572,
0.017517080530524254,
0.481716126203537,
-0.7808114290237427,
0.012779470533132553,
0.31482598185539246,
0.34497520327568054,
0.2703099548816681,
-0.294260174036026,
-0.08788279443979263,
-0.34109631180763245,
0.023560920730233192,
-0.14928090572357178,
-0.6566274762153625,
0.7070754766464233,
-0.14521484076976776,
-0.4953854978084564,
-0.3956161439418793,
0.7954537272453308,
0.5061912536621094,
0.7610083818435669,
0.5329983830451965,
0.11510489881038666,
0.6993886828422546,
0.18324989080429077,
0.7629785537719727,
-0.14875522255897522,
0.6001015901565552,
0.7069655060768127,
-0.28144386410713196,
0.7324782609939575,
0.6037260293960571,
-0.022963188588619232,
0.4090915024280548,
1.0194838047027588,
0.0759730339050293,
0.34784215688705444,
0.6342405676841736,
-0.13680848479270935,
-0.49033093452453613,
-0.29115211963653564,
-0.1789185106754303,
0.44768252968788147,
0.7249294519424438,
-0.24225027859210968,
-0.4174919128417969,
-0.07253659516572952,
0.3426050543785095,
0.45793747901916504,
-0.20057930052280426,
0.8744332194328308,
0.2422952950000763,
-0.5392497181892395,
0.47077593207359314,
-0.06672342121601105,
0.8210596442222595,
-0.2672891616821289,
-0.15360131859779358,
-0.235447496175766,
0.11512133479118347,
-0.060130901634693146,
-0.6508740782737732,
0.34011203050613403,
0.37588927149772644,
0.09494927525520325,
-0.2050207257270813,
1.0730277299880981,
-0.3167067766189575,
-0.7067859768867493,
0.3987389802932739,
0.53972327709198,
0.08794856816530228,
-0.1259140819311142,
-0.9480995535850525,
0.3013257086277008,
-0.0976027101278305,
-0.29630887508392334,
0.06324667483568192,
0.5705093145370483,
-0.3443843424320221,
0.5910094380378723,
0.8086645603179932,
0.04108870029449463,
-0.2134689837694168,
0.18403497338294983,
1.3579217195510864,
-0.739501953125,
-0.35151082277297974,
-1.2818548679351807,
0.2932991683483124,
-0.5043178200721741,
-0.23233246803283691,
0.7968974113464355,
0.5023184418678284,
0.515022873878479,
0.359907865524292,
0.8378982543945312,
0.3609689772129059,
0.612790584564209,
-0.28218644857406616,
0.4762705862522125,
-0.6443012356758118,
0.5776813626289368,
-0.9037861227989197,
-0.5679775476455688,
-0.16553597152233124,
0.7419952154159546,
-0.4771590232849121,
-0.20289117097854614,
0.25646308064460754,
0.7811120748519897,
-0.014557252638041973,
0.1738077998161316,
-0.12981432676315308,
0.059041284024715424,
0.6773521304130554,
0.41248950362205505,
1.379604458808899,
0.08439560979604721,
0.46184831857681274,
-0.07399251312017441,
-0.31051647663116455,
-0.46266064047813416,
-1.2245672941207886,
-1.1930216550827026,
-0.5347787141799927,
-0.4862934350967407,
-0.6681019067764282,
0.1274465024471283,
1.117300271987915,
0.452248215675354,
-0.6710915565490723,
-0.3870925307273865,
0.1610681414604187,
0.48386913537979126,
0.10970962047576904,
-0.19859932363033295,
0.4306531846523285,
-0.17539039254188538,
-0.36209696531295776,
0.1593637466430664,
0.5271006226539612,
-0.10548852384090424,
-0.2996238172054291,
0.07407443970441818,
-0.4628009796142578,
0.5303454995155334,
0.664935827255249,
0.17029722034931183,
-0.8060721755027771,
-0.19249765574932098,
-0.10274840891361237,
0.03130018711090088,
0.09445654600858688,
1.0870565176010132,
-0.42077481746673584,
0.31531548500061035,
0.3908100426197052,
0.6451639533042908,
0.5071069598197937,
0.3791750371456146,
0.47177383303642273,
-0.5277354121208191,
0.0017659292789176106,
0.21880842745304108,
0.24964138865470886,
0.5584001541137695,
-0.20105771720409393,
0.19995521008968353,
0.509274423122406,
-0.3245276212692261,
-1.0023174285888672,
0.19312363862991333,
-0.935661256313324,
-0.5322554707527161,
1.696956753730774,
-0.1975841522216797,
-0.0737517774105072,
-0.42942026257514954,
-0.13419528305530548,
0.26360780000686646,
-0.522009551525116,
1.0434293746948242,
0.7920982837677002,
0.2821785807609558,
-0.24931588768959045,
-0.40197136998176575,
0.1375572681427002,
0.03289855644106865,
-0.7251558899879456,
0.12993909418582916,
0.19012895226478577,
0.0663052350282669,
0.19661152362823486,
0.8350217342376709,
-0.07304417341947556,
-0.2795323431491852,
-0.37231898307800293,
-0.5391752123832703,
0.5651746988296509,
-0.10502877086400986,
-0.27513375878334045,
0.2984648048877716,
-0.3862501084804535,
-0.0031039270106703043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10237v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10237v2
|
Med-MoE: Mixture of Domain-Specific Experts for Lightweight Medical Vision-Language Models
| 2024-04-16T02:35:17 | 2024-06-26T06:04:51 |
Songtao Jiang, Tuo Zheng, Yan Zhang, Yeying Jin, Li Yuan, Zuozhu Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in general-purpose or domain-specific multimodal large
language models (LLMs) have witnessed remarkable progress for medical
decision-making. However, they are designated for specific classification or
generative tasks, and require model training or finetuning on large-scale
datasets with sizeable parameters and tremendous computing, hindering their
clinical utility across diverse resource-constrained scenarios in practice. In
this paper, we propose a novel and lightweight framework Med-MoE
(Mixture-of-Experts) that tackles both discriminative and generative multimodal
medical tasks. The learning of Med-MoE consists of three steps: multimodal
medical alignment, instruction tuning and routing, and domain-specific MoE
tuning. After aligning multimodal medical images with LLM tokens, we then
enable the model for different multimodal medical tasks with instruction
tuning, together with a trainable router tailored for expert selection across
input modalities. Finally, the model is tuned by integrating the router with
multiple domain-specific experts, which are selectively activated and further
empowered by meta expert. Comprehensive experiments on both open- and close-end
medical question answering (Med-VQA) and image classification tasks across
datasets such as VQA-RAD, SLAKE and Path-VQA demonstrate that our model can
achieve performance superior to or on par with state-of-the-art baselines,
while only requiring approximately 30\%-50\% of activated model parameters.
Extensive analysis and ablations corroborate the effectiveness and practical
utility of our method.
|
[
-0.4863452613353729,
-0.9180314540863037,
0.683114767074585,
-0.11461816728115082,
-0.37243252992630005,
-0.057504698634147644,
-0.34133458137512207,
-0.3571019768714905,
0.3274388313293457,
0.4997856616973877,
-0.46994125843048096,
-0.38087978959083557,
-0.7572936415672302,
0.015440652146935463,
0.13804037868976593,
0.7995696663856506,
-0.0078048985451459885,
0.5666707158088684,
-0.4273221790790558,
-0.3712480366230011,
-0.5830740928649902,
-0.10696583986282349,
-0.5226238965988159,
-0.19093182682991028,
0.5527880191802979,
0.37462443113327026,
0.6942355036735535,
0.500417947769165,
0.6149568557739258,
0.320931077003479,
0.3210354745388031,
0.5200498700141907,
-0.204977348446846,
0.12286456674337387,
-0.3410356342792511,
-0.4697285592556,
-0.679226815700531,
-0.20116093754768372,
0.19452153146266937,
0.7094477415084839,
-0.33974379301071167,
-0.02023058757185936,
-0.2644508183002472,
0.3848628103733063,
-0.6479173898696899,
0.023917514830827713,
-0.8870565891265869,
-0.06676489114761353,
-0.11718157678842545,
-0.36381885409355164,
-0.4152955710887909,
0.1951257288455963,
0.16204769909381866,
-0.6590495705604553,
0.20584581792354584,
0.18347695469856262,
0.592262864112854,
0.630755603313446,
-0.6014018058776855,
-0.08001016080379486,
-0.26867949962615967,
0.9404500722885132,
-0.6553289890289307,
0.34463489055633545,
0.454524427652359,
0.41516178846359253,
0.0559781976044178,
-0.5342820882797241,
-0.4863080680370331,
-0.06436938047409058,
0.18720704317092896,
0.3169788420200348,
0.21794281899929047,
0.3205201327800751,
-0.2628524601459503,
0.3205690085887909,
-0.49186816811561584,
0.2645341157913208,
-0.40917766094207764,
0.022145407274365425,
0.504252016544342,
0.3056946098804474,
0.3782655894756317,
0.08538348972797394,
-0.6032251119613647,
0.2770483195781708,
-0.5485076308250427,
-0.25339576601982117,
-0.34939897060394287,
-0.018201148137450218,
-0.23189078271389008,
0.6392772793769836,
-0.22523720562458038,
0.9962382912635803,
0.25400641560554504,
-0.8064447641372681,
0.28486379981040955,
-0.11231081187725067,
-0.22176168859004974,
-0.3270679712295532,
0.7965425252914429,
0.6165317893028259,
0.1929323524236679,
-0.17563119530677795,
-0.25683191418647766,
-0.012084245681762695,
0.38020023703575134,
-0.6798622608184814,
-0.5172849893569946,
0.22747540473937988,
-0.6240943074226379,
-0.40599870681762695,
-0.3920268714427948,
-0.6967201828956604,
-0.4792987108230591,
-0.4226345717906952,
0.6312980651855469,
-0.5211023092269897,
-0.31219491362571716,
0.33104947209358215,
0.14981311559677124,
-0.20197881758213043,
0.45860370993614197,
-0.9721143245697021,
0.11082365363836288,
0.301302433013916,
0.4821532368659973,
-0.3021535277366638,
-0.09408269822597504,
-0.44475165009498596,
0.2865736186504364,
-0.1494593769311905,
0.5749501585960388,
-0.8676382303237915,
-0.3664742410182953,
-0.2339557409286499,
-0.1563234180212021,
-0.4072459936141968,
-0.634746253490448,
0.35344067215919495,
-0.49972259998321533,
0.23621246218681335,
0.1549445390701294,
-0.5807152986526489,
-0.3724081218242645,
0.3282577693462372,
-0.42912349104881287,
0.7105987668037415,
0.1568271368741989,
-0.5939549207687378,
0.5138675570487976,
-0.4247409403324127,
-0.5224615335464478,
0.3038927912712097,
-0.6333839893341064,
-0.3090653717517853,
0.19778582453727722,
0.6092103719711304,
0.9523749351501465,
-0.44187411665916443,
0.548953652381897,
-0.4858051538467407,
0.024133410304784775,
0.30521830916404724,
-0.48180198669433594,
0.5500190854072571,
0.062368202954530716,
-0.164667010307312,
0.1978604942560196,
-0.917087733745575,
-0.008791288360953331,
0.06678759306669235,
-0.4825124442577362,
-0.39516040682792664,
0.0352013073861599,
0.1648462414741516,
0.4100506007671356,
0.2955067753791809,
-0.478819876909256,
0.11226076632738113,
-0.19297054409980774,
0.3394787907600403,
0.7108279466629028,
0.03084351308643818,
0.3550812005996704,
-0.4546087980270386,
0.5228463411331177,
0.26029616594314575,
0.3338121175765991,
-0.10389962047338486,
-0.9389265179634094,
-0.6897232532501221,
-0.9254814982414246,
0.30849504470825195,
0.6002934575080872,
-1.3117233514785767,
0.34154564142227173,
-0.33632779121398926,
-0.43347030878067017,
-0.9163900017738342,
0.33992207050323486,
0.507439374923706,
0.8896953463554382,
0.49603724479675293,
-0.23617780208587646,
-0.13930214941501617,
-1.0418426990509033,
0.24425138533115387,
0.09206788241863251,
0.022389061748981476,
0.6178954839706421,
0.355495423078537,
-0.4665678143501282,
0.7815727591514587,
-0.570444643497467,
-0.41360899806022644,
-0.15139716863632202,
0.007592827547341585,
-0.02628331445157528,
0.5458216071128845,
0.6589191555976868,
-1.1130505800247192,
-0.3717234432697296,
0.1528855860233307,
-0.8051498532295227,
-0.01835637353360653,
-0.020159512758255005,
0.022638360038399696,
-0.10184989124536514,
0.23532430827617645,
-0.6000953316688538,
0.040685977786779404,
0.643478512763977,
-0.05127132683992386,
0.33402198553085327,
-0.4320618510246277,
0.18894822895526886,
-1.386283040046692,
-0.05208505690097809,
0.046085942536592484,
-0.31330233812332153,
-0.5166632533073425,
0.44521477818489075,
0.1408238559961319,
-0.06216059625148773,
-0.39099058508872986,
0.738899827003479,
-0.3160754442214966,
0.4295753538608551,
-0.17761270701885223,
-0.18895073235034943,
-0.028272578492760658,
0.6349583268165588,
0.1641417145729065,
0.5818014144897461,
0.9725924730300903,
-0.5921666622161865,
0.3219102919101715,
0.16968126595020294,
-0.3562605679035187,
0.8429434299468994,
-0.48880457878112793,
-0.038890399038791656,
-0.10443911701440811,
-0.11382779479026794,
-0.8192903399467468,
-0.5609251260757446,
0.232100248336792,
-0.32139280438423157,
0.4300985634326935,
-0.20101560652256012,
-0.41912713646888733,
-0.24876630306243896,
0.07007619738578796,
0.7320239543914795,
0.6142392158508301,
-0.23031331598758698,
1.0876519680023193,
0.5215421319007874,
-0.43868494033813477,
-0.5390211343765259,
-0.5729280710220337,
-0.04301822930574417,
-0.02527325041592121,
-0.7123739719390869,
0.34107089042663574,
-0.20917901396751404,
-0.031145315617322922,
-0.058758895844221115,
0.15106043219566345,
-0.4794943928718567,
0.04821155220270157,
0.2930925190448761,
0.4804540276527405,
-0.2998679578304291,
0.22606565058231354,
0.3330061137676239,
-0.13097630441188812,
-0.26794373989105225,
-0.054068416357040405,
0.2655182182788849,
0.2453261911869049,
-0.6511824727058411,
-0.29297754168510437,
0.5312542915344238,
0.9080997109413147,
-0.4719787836074829,
0.6764635443687439,
0.7922877669334412,
-0.2800750434398651,
-0.027122633531689644,
-0.8694337606430054,
-0.21401454508304596,
-0.449273943901062,
0.6261708736419678,
-0.40008625388145447,
-0.751643717288971,
0.3070965111255646,
-0.19476227462291718,
0.15614768862724304,
0.26083263754844666,
0.947658121585846,
-0.18696875870227814,
1.1949927806854248,
0.5414173007011414,
-0.01645481400191784,
0.1435953825712204,
0.08493142575025558,
-0.12534017860889435,
-0.6046460866928101,
-0.4163108766078949,
0.0252743661403656,
-0.376414954662323,
-0.06648369878530502,
-0.7106093764305115,
0.8115259408950806,
-0.30306363105773926,
0.11762907356023788,
-0.3860335648059845,
-0.3891483545303345,
0.32571423053741455,
0.5148314833641052,
0.6535407304763794,
0.09285573661327362,
0.0005739234038628638,
-0.3672553598880768,
0.012076704762876034,
-0.8711720108985901,
-0.09362313896417618,
1.2948904037475586,
0.23146414756774902,
1.0501636266708374,
-0.2190972864627838,
0.3945075273513794,
0.011692351661622524,
0.26420438289642334,
-0.7773430347442627,
0.6806094646453857,
-0.47613632678985596,
-0.7720436453819275,
0.23847998678684235,
-0.3707709312438965,
-0.5275288820266724,
0.4170231819152832,
-0.6421618461608887,
-0.14522364735603333,
0.15945769846439362,
0.23761318624019623,
-0.5347099900245667,
0.485761433839798,
-0.7009968161582947,
0.5708571076393127,
-0.331940233707428,
-0.1667618602514267,
-0.33773165941238403,
-0.8755119442939758,
0.4796074330806732,
-0.2972751557826996,
0.277801513671875,
-0.15670180320739746,
-0.38071921467781067,
0.4767419099807739,
-0.14233101904392242,
1.0249167680740356,
-0.23966093361377716,
-0.05198948457837105,
-0.0774165540933609,
-0.09866339713335037,
0.09944397956132889,
-0.02094845101237297,
0.2103969007730484,
0.1357540339231491,
-0.263374924659729,
-0.40459108352661133,
-0.4161209166049957,
0.4827958941459656,
-0.6813240051269531,
-0.3658201992511749,
0.1402180790901184,
-0.7434065341949463,
-0.5532739162445068,
0.2478586733341217,
0.39411190152168274,
0.887233316898346,
0.12456264346837997,
0.3762396574020386,
1.0165510177612305,
-0.15003074705600739,
-0.0964616984128952,
0.6589540243148804,
-0.04741392657160759,
-0.5946233868598938,
0.9643617868423462,
-0.1255505532026291,
0.21895749866962433,
0.5945675373077393,
0.033809881657361984,
0.0394723154604435,
-0.8055407404899597,
-0.665835440158844,
0.10400412976741791,
-0.6590650081634521,
-0.35382896661758423,
-0.7733904719352722,
0.038556620478630066,
-0.010674894787371159,
-0.26221126317977905,
-0.3398531675338745,
-0.1941685974597931,
-0.299489825963974,
0.21819154918193817,
0.23310169577598572,
0.4504009485244751,
0.41520512104034424,
0.3235819339752197,
-0.933228611946106,
0.7675386667251587,
0.43183445930480957,
0.32061129808425903,
-0.24886979162693024,
-0.2852424681186676,
-0.2803087830543518,
-0.015751056373119354,
-0.13580431044101715,
-0.7024880051612854,
0.11977341771125793,
0.39059802889823914,
0.694384753704071,
0.7982455492019653,
-0.04590638726949692,
0.648598313331604,
-0.8214790225028992,
0.6099669337272644,
0.5053189396858215,
-0.3681734800338745,
0.33084431290626526,
-0.3098220229148865,
0.011904600076377392,
0.692258358001709,
0.3256612718105316,
0.01743491366505623,
-0.5161991119384766,
-0.13636648654937744,
-0.7027900218963623,
0.28130343556404114,
-0.14147767424583435,
0.0341215506196022,
0.01982131041586399,
0.24942588806152344,
0.49535444378852844,
0.274600088596344,
-0.3639375865459442,
-0.20545826852321625,
0.1688510775566101,
-0.7805846333503723,
0.023870406672358513,
-0.14503194391727448,
-0.4915807843208313,
-0.36238589882850647,
0.4040129780769348,
-0.2838200330734253,
0.15836964547634125,
0.022963065654039383,
-0.2725144624710083,
0.06086120381951332,
0.20073413848876953,
0.6513681411743164,
0.7049972414970398,
-0.09493536502122879,
0.024548247456550598,
0.08080606907606125,
-0.6590389609336853,
0.026290999725461006,
0.0886441022157669,
0.006516247522085905,
-0.02067803591489792,
0.2764071822166443,
0.7185916304588318,
0.47663959860801697,
-0.9492598176002502,
0.660915732383728,
0.07197555899620056,
-0.4465746283531189,
0.1883266419172287,
0.2114269733428955,
-0.07287430018186569,
0.25083187222480774,
0.3762156367301941,
0.7380648851394653,
0.14887164533138275,
-0.10328679531812668,
0.23760059475898743,
0.38467854261398315,
-0.14350518584251404,
-0.22516721487045288,
0.8810186982154846,
0.5579994320869446,
0.23505011200904846,
0.3009470999240875,
0.11461508274078369,
-0.2577274739742279,
0.3456117808818817,
0.20714972913265228,
0.5711901187896729,
-0.26876941323280334,
-0.035476911813020706,
-0.1905333548784256,
0.060725245624780655,
-0.020635660737752914,
0.3645056486129761,
0.08139485865831375,
-0.7857776880264282,
-0.5150995850563049,
-0.34521862864494324,
-0.23810963332653046,
-0.08204979449510574,
-0.7011324763298035,
0.210953950881958,
-0.3458465337753296,
-0.39712753891944885,
0.05442117154598236,
-0.48914971947669983,
-0.7769013047218323,
0.5733697414398193,
0.028997890651226044,
0.8031778335571289,
-0.6880950331687927,
0.8057100176811218,
1.081968069076538,
-0.254940390586853,
-0.5071038603782654,
-0.2000112384557724,
-0.028229009360074997,
-1.1914268732070923,
0.5847951769828796,
-0.07679319381713867,
-0.018671009689569473,
-0.17910757660865784,
-0.4980227053165436,
-0.3181045949459076,
0.9913589954376221,
0.4348105490207672,
-0.46535271406173706,
-0.26083990931510925,
-0.2224133014678955,
0.19202926754951477,
-0.4787330627441406,
0.12078387290239334,
0.0033565149642527103,
0.05945787951350212,
0.04472487047314644,
-1.1451423168182373,
-0.13466951251029968,
-0.3955070972442627,
-0.10164043307304382,
-0.004087766166776419,
-0.5832185745239258,
0.9498367309570312,
-0.3072015643119812,
0.2594670057296753,
0.1089811846613884,
0.3587036430835724,
0.305180162191391,
0.2809857726097107,
0.6119420528411865,
0.6900490522384644,
0.7259026169776917,
0.16064885258674622,
1.0335274934768677,
-0.6648122668266296,
0.12845927476882935,
0.753442108631134,
-0.2564062178134918,
0.8229504823684692,
0.4551965892314911,
0.02645140513777733,
0.339418888092041,
0.4642252027988434,
0.0822150707244873,
0.8036139607429504,
-0.44263455271720886,
-0.509952962398529,
-0.6845472455024719,
0.16810919344425201,
-0.509721040725708,
0.3547402620315552,
0.5387715697288513,
-0.48779430985450745,
-0.0633181780576706,
0.5655834674835205,
-0.09028834849596024,
-0.14402562379837036,
-0.5646538734436035,
0.8379227519035339,
0.11534931510686874,
-0.40561169385910034,
0.4314383566379547,
0.08500122278928757,
1.00167977809906,
-0.6525879502296448,
0.00333253457210958,
0.15841823816299438,
0.21739710867404938,
-0.12077892571687698,
-0.6827036142349243,
-0.26637202501296997,
-0.25957632064819336,
-0.45886728167533875,
0.028804125264286995,
0.6993752121925354,
-0.6078413128852844,
-0.6752387285232544,
-0.08393502980470657,
0.631763219833374,
-0.016751719638705254,
0.10542190819978714,
-0.7986315488815308,
-0.3423273265361786,
-0.1188272088766098,
-0.008217965252697468,
0.3800930678844452,
0.39613285660743713,
0.14698095619678497,
1.0602859258651733,
0.3600821793079376,
0.25096091628074646,
0.1491975486278534,
-0.007427736651152372,
0.9931176900863647,
-0.13217759132385254,
-0.3719201683998108,
-0.6311373114585876,
0.6060079336166382,
0.13681001961231232,
-0.39241379499435425,
0.39020049571990967,
0.36683908104896545,
0.5621864199638367,
-0.4565195143222809,
0.6929706335067749,
0.01354727242141962,
0.4230606257915497,
-0.8788988590240479,
0.828038215637207,
-1.0100452899932861,
-0.15486988425254822,
-0.010700059123337269,
-0.4122336506843567,
-0.31323039531707764,
0.5435429215431213,
-0.25369155406951904,
0.33500513434410095,
0.37838053703308105,
0.7159475088119507,
-0.3869726359844208,
-0.35071974992752075,
0.5833356976509094,
0.08190413564443588,
0.00942106544971466,
0.6172119379043579,
0.48687881231307983,
0.040095556527376175,
0.3042120039463043,
-0.13620644807815552,
-0.34041720628738403,
-0.6381433010101318,
-0.37173715233802795,
-1.0765697956085205,
-0.4822400212287903,
-0.39975205063819885,
0.21142937242984772,
-0.16113516688346863,
1.0924172401428223,
1.2261080741882324,
-0.6002874374389648,
0.40595972537994385,
0.41234061121940613,
-0.2150789350271225,
-0.24047836661338806,
-0.1664915382862091,
0.28168344497680664,
-0.39440953731536865,
-0.648521363735199,
0.4184436500072479,
0.4824882447719574,
-0.10628888010978699,
-0.23865140974521637,
-0.03605953976511955,
0.07792189717292786,
-0.018528535962104797,
0.613886833190918,
-0.10441087931394577,
-0.9260848164558411,
0.15522027015686035,
-0.029549797996878624,
-0.27687665820121765,
0.11540624499320984,
0.6948330998420715,
-0.5854632258415222,
0.8960660099983215,
0.22910667955875397,
0.941986620426178,
-0.03865509852766991,
0.01720123551785946,
0.5661941170692444,
-0.7997266054153442,
0.1943492889404297,
0.40478718280792236,
0.6797304153442383,
0.20830240845680237,
-0.27032962441444397,
0.1652437001466751,
0.302425742149353,
-0.5282024145126343,
-0.5782409310340881,
0.13552632927894592,
-1.2424328327178955,
-0.4285436272621155,
0.9999231100082397,
-0.1485958993434906,
0.06395627558231354,
-0.25130483508110046,
-0.5334050059318542,
-0.10264155268669128,
-0.32114139199256897,
0.5954421162605286,
0.47449183464050293,
-0.08278416842222214,
-0.35730457305908203,
-0.7655379772186279,
0.12385310977697372,
0.5758867263793945,
-0.6974971890449524,
-0.5500599145889282,
0.5037034153938293,
0.5875083804130554,
0.023601844906806946,
0.7620137929916382,
-0.1616886556148529,
0.3963325321674347,
-0.19509153068065643,
0.12014689296483994,
-0.3740141987800598,
-0.42087554931640625,
-0.04592272639274597,
0.24610252678394318,
0.009509534575045109,
-0.4190689027309418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10229v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10229v1
|
Generative Text Steganography with Large Language Model
| 2024-04-16T02:19:28 | 2024-04-16T02:19:28 |
Jiaxuan Wu, Zhengxian Wu, Yiming Xue, Juan Wen, Wanli Peng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have blurred the boundary of
high-quality text generation between humans and machines, which is favorable
for generative text steganography. While, current advanced steganographic
mapping is not suitable for LLMs since most users are restricted to accessing
only the black-box API or user interface of the LLMs, thereby lacking access to
the training vocabulary and its sampling probabilities. In this paper, we
explore a black-box generative text steganographic method based on the user
interfaces of large language models, which is called LLM-Stega. The main goal
of LLM-Stega is that the secure covert communication between Alice (sender) and
Bob (receiver) is conducted by using the user interfaces of LLMs. Specifically,
We first construct a keyword set and design a new encrypted steganographic
mapping to embed secret messages. Furthermore, to guarantee accurate extraction
of secret messages and rich semantics of generated stego texts, an optimization
mechanism based on reject sampling is proposed. Comprehensive experiments
demonstrate that the proposed LLM-Stega outperforms current state-of-the-art
methods.
|
[
-0.2599474787712097,
-1.0860244035720825,
0.5286992192268372,
0.0665760189294815,
-0.6645159125328064,
0.35049864649772644,
-0.33972445130348206,
-0.4278944730758667,
0.31875190138816833,
0.7368434071540833,
-0.4262236952781677,
-1.151674509048462,
-0.7407766580581665,
0.1715797632932663,
-0.4937075078487396,
0.630969762802124,
-0.06033327803015709,
-0.06749676913022995,
-0.006360207684338093,
0.19864356517791748,
-0.2412368506193161,
-0.6628790497779846,
-0.42168745398521423,
-0.02665502205491066,
0.057463388890028,
0.06842674314975739,
0.7081320285797119,
0.46395474672317505,
0.3857891261577606,
0.21980959177017212,
-0.33147957921028137,
0.2360723316669464,
-0.7031157612800598,
0.4211285412311554,
0.01964518614113331,
-0.516473650932312,
-0.32075026631355286,
-0.3071381151676178,
0.7495430707931519,
0.20690196752548218,
-0.12672705948352814,
-0.06759266555309296,
-0.00889173150062561,
0.22220347821712494,
-0.5178524255752563,
0.08981204032897949,
-0.6586657762527466,
0.004128739237785339,
-0.5054914355278015,
-0.2690090239048004,
-0.6280831098556519,
-0.27468371391296387,
-0.3307783007621765,
-0.5538015365600586,
0.2644679546356201,
0.3721170723438263,
0.7969217896461487,
-0.2066020369529724,
-0.1108926385641098,
-0.33965635299682617,
-0.7858819961547852,
0.630225658416748,
-0.7301768064498901,
0.20576223731040955,
0.5569576025009155,
0.2405877262353897,
-0.2492896318435669,
-0.5615248084068298,
-0.6240054368972778,
-0.36186879873275757,
0.16869942843914032,
0.021252496168017387,
-0.3677352964878082,
0.13754944503307343,
0.1936068832874298,
0.4113943576812744,
-0.3566149175167084,
0.2643432021141052,
-0.3651386797428131,
-0.20587877929210663,
0.5887511372566223,
-0.01901525817811489,
0.4153745770454407,
-0.10835584253072739,
-0.635916531085968,
-0.20669272541999817,
-1.0734891891479492,
-0.4931453466415405,
0.5836948752403259,
0.060509100556373596,
-0.20361024141311646,
0.45961880683898926,
0.06358511745929718,
0.4202648401260376,
-0.20453037321567535,
-0.0682147964835167,
0.1018311083316803,
0.014021565206348896,
-0.2978763282299042,
-0.2275729775428772,
1.1986719369888306,
0.13178643584251404,
0.09683860093355179,
-0.44538262486457825,
-0.2565663158893585,
0.013602539896965027,
0.1485651582479477,
-0.8776142001152039,
0.03812958300113678,
-0.19375641644001007,
-0.44422560930252075,
-0.5776695609092712,
-0.08145659416913986,
-1.1244678497314453,
-0.29850220680236816,
0.3220750689506531,
0.374732106924057,
-0.2048991620540619,
-0.025668401271104813,
0.050027381628751755,
0.08857422322034836,
-0.05677894875407219,
0.2465568333864212,
-0.9185140132904053,
0.28567802906036377,
0.5317942500114441,
0.8291246891021729,
-0.0925944596529007,
0.14474767446517944,
-0.530590832233429,
0.47408413887023926,
-0.43031740188598633,
0.4209260940551758,
-0.6685469150543213,
-0.6760016679763794,
0.19315871596336365,
-0.005712124519050121,
0.4839676320552826,
-0.4378451704978943,
0.5353776812553406,
-0.9131782650947571,
0.03146609291434288,
0.04521891474723816,
-0.5319293737411499,
-0.08613326400518417,
-0.02169111743569374,
-0.7408394813537598,
0.5984293222427368,
-0.23217609524726868,
-0.5014046430587769,
0.1917724609375,
-0.2866351008415222,
-0.5682079195976257,
0.5123468041419983,
-0.2989175021648407,
-0.8004462122917175,
0.023834023624658585,
0.2545641362667084,
0.6012657880783081,
-0.32933422923088074,
0.386443555355072,
-0.5438761711120605,
-0.48847681283950806,
0.49929744005203247,
-0.7177690863609314,
0.7900716662406921,
0.3535696268081665,
-0.28719645738601685,
0.09302204102277756,
-0.4259795546531677,
-0.27762845158576965,
0.275907427072525,
-0.3673369288444519,
-0.5220738053321838,
-0.19414839148521423,
0.0569482259452343,
-0.22121526300907135,
0.3160751760005951,
-0.4974352717399597,
0.32126039266586304,
-0.41695964336395264,
0.5410794019699097,
0.7416771054267883,
0.0533229298889637,
0.5202991366386414,
0.05610878765583038,
0.7129311561584473,
-0.2382323294878006,
0.15646551549434662,
0.0004833817947655916,
-0.7692399024963379,
-0.29506996273994446,
-0.4022567570209503,
0.39287155866622925,
0.4092733561992645,
-0.6978532671928406,
0.5039148926734924,
-0.13070377707481384,
-0.16126477718353271,
-0.5314708948135376,
0.5271807312965393,
0.5426983833312988,
0.010417062789201736,
-0.010447701439261436,
-0.447977215051651,
-0.1267123818397522,
-0.845370888710022,
0.005778254009783268,
-0.03171025961637497,
-0.07241421937942505,
0.2636488378047943,
0.4345798194408417,
-0.2196022868156433,
0.24760909378528595,
-0.6494200229644775,
-0.4155145585536957,
-0.18770165741443634,
0.11475606262683868,
-0.12634991109371185,
0.237811878323555,
0.5014375448226929,
-0.595747709274292,
-0.12914252281188965,
-0.20166553556919098,
-0.6743871569633484,
-0.1271764189004898,
-0.06811342388391495,
-0.5868024826049805,
0.1533297896385193,
0.8064484000205994,
-0.5687286853790283,
0.5961810946464539,
0.8380693793296814,
-0.14836376905441284,
0.3767329752445221,
-0.3258795738220215,
0.02235175296664238,
-1.266879677772522,
0.05155836045742035,
-0.10039664059877396,
-0.4058786630630493,
-0.5999895334243774,
0.47596755623817444,
0.24157574772834778,
-0.4489639103412628,
-0.16897428035736084,
0.5382894277572632,
-0.8594282269477844,
0.025380222126841545,
-0.25509604811668396,
0.0589233860373497,
0.0032209851779043674,
0.45851755142211914,
-0.015152729116380215,
0.8188406229019165,
0.6275184154510498,
-0.13581569492816925,
0.36971578001976013,
0.47913822531700134,
-0.3221781551837921,
0.09017839282751083,
-0.38830050826072693,
0.4879840910434723,
-0.19521208107471466,
0.2560749053955078,
-1.0776370763778687,
-0.13913032412528992,
0.5633341073989868,
-0.2862270474433899,
0.5272656679153442,
-0.3562733232975006,
-0.7501966953277588,
-0.163252592086792,
-0.3214659094810486,
0.23035967350006104,
0.8109181523323059,
-0.506905734539032,
0.27474460005760193,
0.35554054379463196,
-0.14753977954387665,
-0.4048970639705658,
-0.6783472299575806,
0.5335242748260498,
-0.21115203201770782,
-0.5956273674964905,
0.5223420262336731,
0.03081737458705902,
-0.01868012361228466,
-0.21125705540180206,
0.10455407202243805,
0.06611756235361099,
0.07256237417459488,
0.45014485716819763,
0.4547789692878723,
0.11347654461860657,
0.1100613996386528,
0.31093084812164307,
0.13555783033370972,
0.10734563320875168,
0.10047006607055664,
0.7380224466323853,
0.08423902094364166,
-0.38654905557632446,
-0.30968451499938965,
0.6279014945030212,
0.3647322654724121,
-0.19174961745738983,
0.977057158946991,
0.5043837428092957,
-0.4329284429550171,
-0.5277398228645325,
-0.41557809710502625,
-0.28977495431900024,
-0.5012044310569763,
0.18125945329666138,
-0.3174014389514923,
-0.8270784616470337,
0.4204729199409485,
-0.03612411767244339,
0.07637385278940201,
-0.01897258870303631,
0.3687339127063751,
-0.04611761495471001,
0.7943031787872314,
0.37594327330589294,
-0.08922766894102097,
0.44294458627700806,
-0.38008561730384827,
0.14893604815006256,
-0.8178663849830627,
-0.2693403959274292,
-0.3464599549770355,
-0.22514140605926514,
-0.1966174691915512,
-0.3903273344039917,
0.3037862479686737,
0.43682026863098145,
0.07672671228647232,
0.24130280315876007,
-0.4213905930519104,
0.1500479280948639,
0.6155979037284851,
0.4218236804008484,
0.483868271112442,
0.6169591546058655,
-0.009243120439350605,
0.04042407497763634,
-0.29148373007774353,
-0.528852641582489,
1.390872836112976,
0.3106131851673126,
1.3381186723709106,
0.13252343237400055,
0.9987431764602661,
0.1960485726594925,
0.5614254474639893,
-0.5295672416687012,
0.8200604319572449,
-0.3692381978034973,
-0.5741888284683228,
-0.18825434148311615,
-0.5678129196166992,
-1.0416539907455444,
0.2367555797100067,
-0.3418866693973541,
-0.45284655690193176,
-0.04022148251533508,
-0.036731597036123276,
0.00743380282074213,
0.4885631799697876,
-0.7112828493118286,
0.40396371483802795,
-0.11043325811624527,
-0.3705490231513977,
-0.08388000726699829,
-0.31473806500434875,
0.46563994884490967,
-0.10341296344995499,
0.22532497346401215,
0.013124456629157066,
-0.14542324841022491,
0.8881002068519592,
-0.17162662744522095,
1.068995714187622,
-0.03413846716284752,
-0.5228766798973083,
0.03899841010570526,
0.4015200138092041,
0.8881385326385498,
0.2489999234676361,
0.10651714354753494,
0.3580450117588043,
-0.6270665526390076,
-0.0903567299246788,
-0.41770732402801514,
0.8400868773460388,
-0.5922722220420837,
-0.891438364982605,
-0.1928415149450302,
-0.21117708086967468,
0.043844763189554214,
0.2317054569721222,
0.43122151494026184,
0.35445016622543335,
-0.130377858877182,
0.1166628897190094,
0.6578657031059265,
-0.430966854095459,
0.22111207246780396,
0.07172775268554688,
-0.2646234631538391,
-0.40603402256965637,
0.7609167695045471,
-0.17057155072689056,
0.45286521315574646,
0.4146714210510254,
0.03013618476688862,
-0.4035695791244507,
-0.8478959798812866,
-0.6053839921951294,
0.4263148009777069,
-0.7370925545692444,
-0.4202609658241272,
-0.355357825756073,
-0.31006860733032227,
-0.3569595217704773,
-0.36623355746269226,
0.09945488721132278,
0.08374305814504623,
-0.7921559810638428,
0.1080341786146164,
0.38962501287460327,
0.3640974164009094,
0.3956439197063446,
0.3795963525772095,
-0.3856271505355835,
0.8177571296691895,
0.39480477571487427,
0.31981295347213745,
-0.08855848014354706,
-0.6302735209465027,
0.23637911677360535,
0.00957060419023037,
-0.31271854043006897,
-1.2461791038513184,
0.7459511160850525,
0.023454783484339714,
0.41343173384666443,
0.5487000346183777,
-0.04550831392407417,
0.3750000596046448,
-0.32050031423568726,
0.45486417412757874,
0.2564062178134918,
-0.8109377026557922,
0.44326838850975037,
-0.35918524861335754,
-0.022742457687854767,
0.1603461652994156,
0.08214791864156723,
-0.2562098205089569,
-0.6502953767776489,
-0.45605310797691345,
-0.8241574168205261,
0.5229543447494507,
0.3723679780960083,
0.4609554409980774,
0.27068647742271423,
0.4026734530925751,
0.16300871968269348,
0.3586514890193939,
-0.9731838703155518,
-0.33925437927246094,
-0.10959023982286453,
-0.2368861734867096,
-0.033816322684288025,
-0.33526766300201416,
-0.42400965094566345,
0.13415087759494781,
0.4229508638381958,
0.04564240947365761,
0.5244942307472229,
-0.21213467419147491,
-0.1759740561246872,
-0.11260730773210526,
0.5820770859718323,
0.5048278570175171,
0.2868189215660095,
-0.07828544080257416,
0.405459463596344,
0.06690992414951324,
-0.6687509417533875,
0.19588765501976013,
0.14662544429302216,
-0.7203192710876465,
-0.015373962931334972,
0.2841576039791107,
0.9145718216896057,
0.0626145750284195,
-0.47480639815330505,
0.6894310116767883,
0.16739366948604584,
-0.43351954221725464,
-0.2101607620716095,
0.1211574375629425,
0.20314259827136993,
0.09191316366195679,
0.4646505117416382,
-0.02455969899892807,
0.023473314940929413,
-0.4282163679599762,
-0.1179288774728775,
0.8297022581100464,
-0.029642051085829735,
-0.1869346797466278,
0.9187588691711426,
0.19660773873329163,
-0.5303897261619568,
0.32277706265449524,
-0.33889394998550415,
-0.4636290371417999,
0.328798770904541,
0.8735378384590149,
0.8503454923629761,
-0.17216041684150696,
0.4573237895965576,
0.0025627014692872763,
0.49369534850120544,
-0.1432076096534729,
0.2802862823009491,
-0.07919836044311523,
-0.47353747487068176,
-0.2536899447441101,
-0.717465341091156,
-0.1361187994480133,
0.6004178524017334,
-0.3405463993549347,
0.22108808159828186,
-0.6474330425262451,
-0.09533083438873291,
-0.25111091136932373,
-0.2623530328273773,
-0.47500675916671753,
-0.15593506395816803,
0.2673302888870239,
0.6094774007797241,
-0.7084840536117554,
0.6173654198646545,
0.28460898995399475,
-0.028317304328083992,
-0.37363073229789734,
-0.004767848178744316,
-0.3127632737159729,
-1.2767198085784912,
0.505672812461853,
-0.10778108239173889,
-0.08197303116321564,
0.06821147352457047,
-0.7846927642822266,
-0.4460233151912689,
0.8620502352714539,
0.44580012559890747,
-0.8880382180213928,
-0.21515744924545288,
-0.010712654329836369,
0.43689391016960144,
-0.11849602311849594,
-0.24933235347270966,
-0.014497572556138039,
0.35314616560935974,
-0.045786913484334946,
-0.2712751030921936,
0.5524946451187134,
-0.10556880384683609,
0.26776787638664246,
0.2413623332977295,
-0.5531449317932129,
0.4751967489719391,
-0.008350261487066746,
-0.6993411183357239,
0.10275827348232269,
0.7217960357666016,
0.43958503007888794,
-0.10789123922586441,
0.2983853220939636,
0.4375036954879761,
0.39063382148742676,
-0.011491344310343266,
0.8775609731674194,
0.06860033422708511,
0.26036348938941956,
0.3607923090457916,
-0.07982701063156128,
0.8285752534866333,
0.4973670244216919,
-0.17974011600017548,
0.3537268042564392,
0.12559077143669128,
-0.35045233368873596,
0.5582318305969238,
0.5870292782783508,
-0.6421492099761963,
-0.29023298621177673,
0.365499347448349,
-0.2758263051509857,
-0.015925541520118713,
0.5226151943206787,
-0.6415234804153442,
-0.17415323853492737,
0.2914590537548065,
0.10775052011013031,
0.15358857810497284,
-0.17356161773204803,
0.6477716565132141,
0.15538683533668518,
-0.3425142765045166,
0.9030560851097107,
0.37259483337402344,
1.0336006879806519,
-0.4609720706939697,
-0.0007985440897755325,
-0.24275808036327362,
-0.15099142491817474,
0.06247016042470932,
-0.8221650123596191,
-0.18049480020999908,
0.1293117254972458,
0.3087858259677887,
-0.4267357587814331,
0.9285849928855896,
-0.7096897959709167,
-0.5745109915733337,
0.2592885494232178,
0.11062999069690704,
0.2554485499858856,
-0.00008562741277273744,
-0.3838336765766144,
0.38317441940307617,
-0.07819507271051407,
-0.1800248622894287,
0.23730413615703583,
0.06771552562713623,
-0.18114276230335236,
0.7691988945007324,
0.8314416408538818,
0.5836897492408752,
0.19022199511528015,
0.3447078466415405,
0.6429345011711121,
-0.5675795674324036,
-0.6058753132820129,
-0.88129061460495,
-0.14394034445285797,
-0.10331231355667114,
-0.05956817790865898,
0.7323286533355713,
0.36637258529663086,
0.45192286372184753,
-0.2170277088880539,
1.0406277179718018,
0.25838762521743774,
0.09156312048435211,
-0.793234646320343,
0.8751534223556519,
-0.4554157257080078,
0.38673636317253113,
-0.38541072607040405,
-0.7947260141372681,
-0.2779466211795807,
0.42032578587532043,
-0.1611502319574356,
-0.02943284995853901,
0.29709315299987793,
1.0100276470184326,
-0.2649751901626587,
-0.15445241332054138,
0.41244634985923767,
0.07392477244138718,
0.47853994369506836,
0.7182599902153015,
0.8059601783752441,
-0.44134068489074707,
0.9031269550323486,
0.0255215372890234,
-0.29373612999916077,
-0.586868166923523,
-0.5520868897438049,
-1.244739055633545,
-0.6703364849090576,
-0.11180083453655243,
-0.34050852060317993,
0.2559761703014374,
0.11461348086595535,
0.5611249208450317,
-0.454563170671463,
-0.002103509148582816,
-0.21915224194526672,
-0.0077222734689712524,
0.10345485806465149,
-0.16083772480487823,
0.4567360281944275,
0.19401752948760986,
-0.6885685920715332,
0.3361780643463135,
0.24890564382076263,
0.6168387532234192,
-0.7096580266952515,
-0.018404794856905937,
0.19829684495925903,
-0.013756992295384407,
0.25282037258148193,
0.17954270541667938,
-0.764299213886261,
-0.09014906734228134,
0.010418355464935303,
-0.3359810411930084,
0.034773971885442734,
0.6491972208023071,
-0.3351576328277588,
0.4072149097919464,
0.49428728222846985,
0.46552377939224243,
0.9917019605636597,
0.06458399444818497,
0.4696357250213623,
-0.8823322653770447,
0.18108321726322174,
-0.021862970665097237,
0.23764751851558685,
0.2777007818222046,
-0.48277363181114197,
-0.1488829255104065,
0.19371332228183746,
-0.22309011220932007,
-0.9574836492538452,
0.23873823881149292,
-1.0148261785507202,
-0.435528427362442,
1.5091735124588013,
-0.08992420136928558,
-0.404375284910202,
-0.10529597848653793,
-0.36214348673820496,
0.2144564688205719,
-0.5760721564292908,
0.8999114036560059,
0.6424261927604675,
0.6535089015960693,
-0.30147868394851685,
-0.4965018630027771,
0.5446490049362183,
0.23754842579364777,
-0.9478398561477661,
0.19538776576519012,
0.3700469732284546,
0.2863001823425293,
0.12755447626113892,
0.6059814095497131,
-0.31770792603492737,
0.016364550217986107,
-0.0026012815069407225,
0.08427932858467102,
-0.36541804671287537,
-0.35799458622932434,
-0.32072606682777405,
0.4218619167804718,
-0.11044500768184662,
-0.30413296818733215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10228v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10228v2
|
Two-Stage Stance Labeling: User-Hashtag Heuristics with Graph Neural Networks
| 2024-04-16T02:18:30 | 2024-05-17T14:07:24 |
Joshua Melton, Shannon Reid, Gabriel Terejanu, Siddharth Krishnan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SI
|
The high volume and rapid evolution of content on social media present major
challenges for studying the stance of social media users. In this work, we
develop a two stage stance labeling method that utilizes the user-hashtag
bipartite graph and the user-user interaction graph. In the first stage, a
simple and efficient heuristic for stance labeling uses the user-hashtag
bipartite graph to iteratively update the stance association of user and
hashtag nodes via a label propagation mechanism. This set of soft labels is
then integrated with the user-user interaction graph to train a graph neural
network (GNN) model using semi-supervised learning. We evaluate this method on
two large-scale datasets containing tweets related to climate change from June
2021 to June 2022 and gun control from January 2022 to January 2023. Our
experiments demonstrate that enriching text-based embeddings of users with
network information from the user interaction graph using our semi-supervised
GNN method outperforms both classifiers trained on user textual embeddings and
zero-shot classification using LLMs such as GPT4. We discuss the need for
integrating nuanced understanding from social science with the scalability of
computational methods to better understand how polarization on social media
occurs for divisive issues such as climate change and gun control.
|
[
-0.23669122159481049,
-0.9144433736801147,
0.5067572593688965,
0.13845479488372803,
-0.3463829457759857,
0.5748729705810547,
-0.287064790725708,
-0.052201781421899796,
0.3830283284187317,
0.0049234312027692795,
-0.21994435787200928,
-0.7778943181037903,
-0.882175862789154,
-0.41820552945137024,
-0.11700448393821716,
1.0077388286590576,
0.06112666428089142,
0.008894503116607666,
0.0783962607383728,
-0.2109002023935318,
-0.11802630871534348,
-0.24634848535060883,
-0.8355265855789185,
-0.5199643969535828,
1.027957797050476,
0.2801240086555481,
0.9458411335945129,
0.4600628614425659,
0.22677695751190186,
0.18796850740909576,
-0.5658622980117798,
-0.29392412304878235,
-0.430556982755661,
-0.04580363631248474,
-0.22860001027584076,
0.1547776311635971,
0.0010808211518451571,
0.1978723406791687,
0.7148776054382324,
0.6862346529960632,
0.05560069903731346,
0.10338535159826279,
0.050175879150629044,
0.23345410823822021,
-0.3389967083930969,
0.19429592788219452,
-0.3875483572483063,
0.031316183507442474,
-0.16018737852573395,
0.08780136704444885,
-0.23293451964855194,
-0.09636190533638,
-0.08688380569219589,
-0.4185974597930908,
0.12882442772388458,
-0.07043488323688507,
0.9504396319389343,
0.03371890261769295,
-0.5476943850517273,
0.13587336242198944,
-0.526009202003479,
0.747235119342804,
-0.7592141628265381,
0.21991264820098877,
0.37162163853645325,
0.10746713727712631,
-0.0724618062376976,
-0.6633583903312683,
-0.7663140296936035,
0.11010332405567169,
0.17863968014717102,
0.08379516750574112,
0.06722848117351532,
-0.03781305253505707,
0.1445462703704834,
-0.1869591623544693,
-0.11688634753227234,
0.32884883880615234,
-0.34777721762657166,
-0.2678643465042114,
0.6694980263710022,
-0.1907443106174469,
0.3703371286392212,
-0.7538388967514038,
-0.7100231647491455,
-0.13986411690711975,
-0.22416770458221436,
0.23463323712348938,
0.6732318997383118,
0.6210601925849915,
-0.20093406736850739,
0.7218259572982788,
0.08296389877796173,
0.328374445438385,
0.1411946713924408,
0.032222624868154526,
0.20123685896396637,
-0.4574606120586395,
-0.0774955004453659,
0.10547510534524918,
1.0826398134231567,
0.610185980796814,
-0.07885049283504486,
-0.08441071212291718,
-0.06670653074979782,
-0.01230061985552311,
0.20713454484939575,
-0.658352792263031,
-0.18155236542224884,
0.2139715999364853,
-0.45070621371269226,
-0.6491682529449463,
-0.016457702964544296,
-0.7393132448196411,
-1.0558509826660156,
-0.36362147331237793,
0.4250410199165344,
-0.0751868486404419,
-0.36990460753440857,
-0.10686106979846954,
-0.37112295627593994,
0.30566975474357605,
0.33060675859451294,
-0.5858445763587952,
0.030125435441732407,
0.9815041422843933,
1.0096279382705688,
0.03478254750370979,
-0.0271752942353487,
-0.27506235241889954,
0.1584184616804123,
-0.37854817509651184,
0.6070833206176758,
-0.7479736804962158,
-0.23103275895118713,
0.0741165354847908,
-0.19051609933376312,
0.1995357871055603,
-0.03932834044098854,
0.2885518968105316,
-0.7360045909881592,
0.0080195851624012,
-0.6041767597198486,
-0.5826258659362793,
-0.23414920270442963,
0.41944414377212524,
-0.5897550582885742,
1.1036653518676758,
0.05654643103480339,
-0.9669848680496216,
0.5471088886260986,
-0.49528768658638,
-0.6135119199752808,
0.023957785218954086,
-0.30939847230911255,
-0.6872323155403137,
-0.19628584384918213,
-0.13799409568309784,
0.6163324117660522,
-0.03646475449204445,
0.439094603061676,
-0.7607042193412781,
-0.1884555071592331,
0.04284469410777092,
0.15753385424613953,
1.1359754800796509,
-0.04736369475722313,
-0.4467659890651703,
0.28160610795021057,
-0.10287461429834366,
-0.2803334891796112,
0.06751038134098053,
-0.4090602993965149,
-0.11728081852197647,
0.1318441778421402,
-0.03883767127990723,
0.37947574257850647,
0.13198548555374146,
-0.5806692838668823,
0.20622994005680084,
-0.016593866050243378,
0.7562611103057861,
0.8924746513366699,
0.23368412256240845,
0.5505579113960266,
0.09795507043600082,
0.2300238013267517,
0.06653542816638947,
0.20453377068042755,
0.24069641530513763,
-0.6145619750022888,
-0.4349108934402466,
0.259011834859848,
0.2630760669708252,
0.5432847142219543,
-0.694873034954071,
0.3583493232727051,
0.027963003143668175,
-0.16897287964820862,
-0.07841187715530396,
0.40547609329223633,
0.21919095516204834,
0.5777573585510254,
0.4280565679073334,
-0.1867762804031372,
-0.3879062533378601,
-0.6934204697608948,
-0.3885115683078766,
-0.5014607310295105,
0.4129990041255951,
0.10170421004295349,
0.4182559549808502,
-0.04221280664205551,
0.7065684795379639,
-0.1914852112531662,
-0.11458037793636322,
-0.21165619790554047,
0.7191607356071472,
-0.08946038037538528,
0.059033386409282684,
0.4257442057132721,
-1.0418422222137451,
-0.5161903500556946,
-0.054666388779878616,
-0.6482946276664734,
0.15444031357765198,
-0.10481669753789902,
-0.253469318151474,
0.277194082736969,
0.6494268774986267,
-0.28484171628952026,
0.6025035977363586,
0.3547416627407074,
-0.4760781526565552,
0.06457897275686264,
0.2581135630607605,
0.05183056369423866,
-1.393962025642395,
-0.2926647365093231,
0.6530912518501282,
-0.29469794034957886,
-0.7305881977081299,
-0.47840872406959534,
-0.20640423893928528,
-0.055387236177921295,
-0.5464468598365784,
0.5261866450309753,
-0.2630082964897156,
-0.2157931625843048,
-0.1838289201259613,
0.08083201199769974,
-0.11870592087507248,
0.24207624793052673,
-0.04154997691512108,
0.29481276869773865,
0.47884801030158997,
-0.15861405432224274,
0.18561577796936035,
0.253968745470047,
-0.013766048476099968,
0.3718738555908203,
-0.5688561201095581,
0.34544727206230164,
-0.3995632827281952,
0.37774696946144104,
-1.4041231870651245,
-0.1918785125017166,
0.7038746476173401,
-0.4550469219684601,
0.5121966600418091,
-0.5930684804916382,
-0.7747286558151245,
-0.6403332948684692,
-0.46584150195121765,
0.21439900994300842,
0.22521339356899261,
-0.306132972240448,
0.4866844713687897,
0.5058489441871643,
-0.04180653393268585,
-0.671035885810852,
-0.46945521235466003,
0.41351351141929626,
-0.2625088393688202,
-0.4679741859436035,
0.22286644577980042,
0.2295161932706833,
-0.23170515894889832,
0.10354240983724594,
-0.10602373629808426,
0.19940218329429626,
0.02615918032824993,
0.17428545653820038,
0.047245848923921585,
0.10678227990865707,
0.19723109900951385,
0.044203680008649826,
-0.13320522010326385,
0.06883662939071655,
-0.4691879451274872,
0.46940985321998596,
-0.18417881429195404,
-0.095609650015831,
-0.5513904094696045,
0.2512059211730957,
0.10770907253026962,
0.13057000935077667,
0.9216572046279907,
0.9741854667663574,
-0.3784293532371521,
-0.06384598463773727,
-0.1708001047372818,
-0.10415913909673691,
-0.37460124492645264,
0.1220499575138092,
0.2460986226797104,
-0.8467137217521667,
0.4335627257823944,
-0.13057076930999756,
0.12137061357498169,
0.3039180338382721,
0.7607786655426025,
-0.592891275882721,
1.0302737951278687,
0.5149129629135132,
-0.08584075421094894,
0.652582049369812,
-0.40177008509635925,
0.4105059802532196,
-0.5551209449768066,
-0.414308100938797,
-0.35904040932655334,
-0.8666924834251404,
-0.4533421993255615,
-0.7152978777885437,
0.1043785884976387,
0.27690020203590393,
-0.4793161451816559,
0.33049654960632324,
-0.47842127084732056,
0.27754491567611694,
0.3089831471443176,
0.3937006890773773,
-0.09552658349275589,
0.19840717315673828,
0.10881250351667404,
0.012700634077191353,
-0.23200638592243195,
-0.49780237674713135,
0.8349549174308777,
0.3364177942276001,
0.48958462476730347,
0.16553302109241486,
0.8079992532730103,
0.7497729659080505,
0.4419409930706024,
-1.1879160404205322,
0.5409355163574219,
-0.11766652762889862,
-0.5866836309432983,
-0.5284096598625183,
-0.24698954820632935,
-0.6639986038208008,
0.10915551334619522,
-0.14621320366859436,
-0.7778407335281372,
0.2206469178199768,
0.2261073887348175,
-0.20542749762535095,
0.46262872219085693,
-0.5573270916938782,
0.8433728218078613,
-0.20371229946613312,
-0.5224842429161072,
-0.08150148391723633,
-1.0020090341567993,
-0.19900278747081757,
0.2998567819595337,
0.11351355910301208,
-0.40880152583122253,
-0.29581424593925476,
1.0912812948226929,
-0.41444137692451477,
1.2972103357315063,
-0.7422294616699219,
-0.05009721964597702,
0.4136592149734497,
-0.2716238796710968,
0.3549962043762207,
0.25520387291908264,
-0.2049831748008728,
0.22650188207626343,
-0.31932759284973145,
-0.6674274802207947,
-0.3284609913825989,
0.41862305998802185,
-0.8519569635391235,
-0.5585755705833435,
-0.32293909788131714,
-0.2480449080467224,
-0.19036291539669037,
0.41724663972854614,
0.19581791758537292,
0.3586687743663788,
-0.1212744265794754,
0.09030702710151672,
0.5787258744239807,
0.08040401339530945,
0.6369631290435791,
-0.088958241045475,
-0.17889246344566345,
-0.5123935341835022,
0.7826571464538574,
0.41897499561309814,
0.06423775106668472,
0.05671136453747749,
0.7101219296455383,
-0.3546868562698364,
-0.5292098522186279,
-0.3260299563407898,
0.18059635162353516,
-0.7535944581031799,
-0.2746269106864929,
-0.5378286838531494,
-0.002802768489345908,
-0.42505836486816406,
-0.30656003952026367,
-0.09090139716863632,
-0.3559376001358032,
-0.3220377564430237,
-0.24309924244880676,
0.40207439661026,
0.6611486673355103,
-0.09361936897039413,
0.6207939386367798,
-0.16720573604106903,
0.43640410900115967,
0.0585344024002552,
0.21416376531124115,
-0.16437099874019623,
-0.3666442930698395,
-0.08206260204315186,
0.09656193852424622,
-0.3888498544692993,
-1.23663330078125,
-0.2160056084394455,
0.007338786497712135,
0.4289149343967438,
0.5202587246894836,
0.14697571098804474,
0.1689368486404419,
-0.14854398369789124,
0.7343716025352478,
0.5193488001823425,
-0.8076381683349609,
0.5424786806106567,
-0.6541528701782227,
-0.05612647905945778,
0.6318851113319397,
0.7172086834907532,
-0.4440976083278656,
-0.12845301628112793,
-0.4891016483306885,
-0.8218608498573303,
0.6970381736755371,
0.03276003897190094,
0.5727674961090088,
-0.004065783228725195,
0.41237184405326843,
-0.21436184644699097,
0.2605355978012085,
-0.45621323585510254,
-0.18170265853405,
-0.4827585518360138,
-0.1701928675174713,
-0.06903281062841415,
-0.0936979278922081,
-0.4912881553173065,
-0.48715561628341675,
0.6017447710037231,
-0.43810442090034485,
0.028754454106092453,
-0.22136302292346954,
0.16110669076442719,
-0.10847346484661102,
0.1657947599887848,
0.15668509900569916,
0.5327661633491516,
-0.09193255752325058,
0.20073750615119934,
-0.05440886318683624,
-0.1424330770969391,
0.16481639444828033,
0.18995033204555511,
-0.4875294268131256,
-0.13405299186706543,
-0.046073343604803085,
0.8276152610778809,
0.2447713166475296,
0.24737142026424408,
0.7711169719696045,
0.18555261194705963,
-0.44416752457618713,
-0.19091753661632538,
-0.33607426285743713,
0.5270608067512512,
0.3078199028968811,
0.17575831711292267,
-0.04657796397805214,
0.13451851904392242,
-0.7082346081733704,
0.1302429586648941,
0.36943545937538147,
-0.6399780511856079,
-0.533306896686554,
0.6381476521492004,
-0.08865245431661606,
-0.3776244521141052,
0.30036479234695435,
-0.3313451111316681,
-0.7568407654762268,
0.605411946773529,
0.4061533510684967,
0.677627444267273,
-0.006710555870085955,
1.0109916925430298,
0.46616971492767334,
0.02517125755548477,
-0.06113462522625923,
0.5211402773857117,
-0.06935165077447891,
-0.8774515986442566,
-0.24829398095607758,
-0.47881752252578735,
-0.28585493564605713,
-0.1511564552783966,
-0.5147779583930969,
0.36540961265563965,
-1.0454192161560059,
-0.7690369486808777,
0.5478179454803467,
0.19655214250087738,
-0.5599010586738586,
0.004832705482840538,
0.32244011759757996,
0.5824181437492371,
-1.1152275800704956,
0.33626845479011536,
1.0781861543655396,
-0.4606249928474426,
-0.7648332715034485,
0.3016209602355957,
0.5705706477165222,
-0.5106410384178162,
0.29096919298171997,
0.192546084523201,
-0.1653137505054474,
-0.00040918466402217746,
-1.089723825454712,
-0.3582738935947418,
1.0685662031173706,
0.15898573398590088,
-0.1470346301794052,
0.14323624968528748,
-0.07115659862756729,
0.5406444072723389,
-0.014934929087758064,
-0.27368903160095215,
0.2912086546421051,
0.6674756407737732,
0.4379520118236542,
-0.12828049063682556,
0.15697090327739716,
-0.06418300420045853,
0.14898043870925903,
0.328535258769989,
-1.066150426864624,
0.5559995770454407,
-0.2780390679836273,
-0.29646003246307373,
-0.4424740672111511,
0.9785869121551514,
-0.07211734354496002,
0.5757406949996948,
0.768101692199707,
0.6304361820220947,
0.7559179663658142,
-0.12105542421340942,
0.7397736310958862,
0.048396360129117966,
0.6172712445259094,
0.7155187129974365,
-0.32803162932395935,
0.8254634141921997,
0.5363487005233765,
-0.03698863461613655,
0.597455620765686,
0.8419910669326782,
-0.13524138927459717,
0.2790991961956024,
0.3086143732070923,
-0.403945654630661,
-0.4977370798587799,
-0.44841912388801575,
0.06315097212791443,
0.2546795606613159,
0.26426011323928833,
-0.23521016538143158,
-0.32183533906936646,
0.014448542147874832,
0.6294806003570557,
0.1569012999534607,
-0.2690073251724243,
0.9985504150390625,
0.22505255043506622,
-0.3028155565261841,
0.06036290153861046,
0.0683685690164566,
0.33881905674934387,
-0.061322394758462906,
0.26427140831947327,
0.030111005529761314,
-0.15387164056301117,
-0.3619407117366791,
-1.3366495370864868,
0.19318242371082306,
-0.007078723981976509,
-0.07852905988693237,
-0.358329713344574,
0.9368875622749329,
-0.254383385181427,
-0.6104423999786377,
0.6036282777786255,
0.22155502438545227,
-0.10207648575305939,
0.29136571288108826,
-0.9323033690452576,
0.13993500173091888,
-0.25141677260398865,
-0.4832465350627899,
0.30620306730270386,
0.22311367094516754,
-0.28484979271888733,
0.15458790957927704,
0.656549334526062,
-0.16784214973449707,
-0.050792817026376724,
0.5821051597595215,
1.1289676427841187,
-0.44598299264907837,
-0.27806660532951355,
-0.796291172504425,
0.464232474565506,
-0.4024169445037842,
-0.17450137436389923,
0.5134815573692322,
0.3171547055244446,
0.5459526777267456,
0.6459493637084961,
1.0326999425888062,
-0.4181288480758667,
0.10574794560670853,
-0.26333215832710266,
0.4281095266342163,
-0.6065973043441772,
-0.07913859933614731,
-0.15513503551483154,
-0.7364149689674377,
-0.45873650908470154,
0.29534295201301575,
-0.4407072067260742,
0.25422725081443787,
0.21258972585201263,
0.6712085604667664,
-0.09509728848934174,
-0.05965990573167801,
-0.08966375887393951,
0.058905135840177536,
0.38008004426956177,
0.008617818355560303,
0.7309200763702393,
-0.11324497312307358,
0.46368408203125,
-0.5066965818405151,
-0.18845710158348083,
-0.2930976450443268,
-0.9119758605957031,
-1.1068893671035767,
-0.6088221669197083,
-0.6688272953033447,
-0.8394149541854858,
0.08695600181818008,
0.7722705006599426,
0.6980176568031311,
-0.7294928431510925,
0.1060343012213707,
0.20319485664367676,
0.2194000482559204,
0.023704608902335167,
-0.23802699148654938,
0.4286086857318878,
-0.26891687512397766,
-0.4802749454975128,
0.08869897574186325,
0.25628989934921265,
-0.1130020022392273,
-0.3281448781490326,
-0.12985534965991974,
-0.5153860449790955,
0.08170516788959503,
0.5676636695861816,
0.47507384419441223,
-0.6881229281425476,
-0.668424665927887,
-0.012943344190716743,
-0.2160346359014511,
0.1931946873664856,
0.7073262929916382,
-0.32342734932899475,
0.5334391593933105,
0.843976616859436,
0.7154554724693298,
0.4996098577976227,
0.5309751629829407,
0.1936294585466385,
-0.9818742275238037,
-0.20369906723499298,
0.0983731672167778,
0.23811064660549164,
0.6709771156311035,
-0.4254414141178131,
0.3099726438522339,
0.44574758410453796,
-0.28982090950012207,
-0.584364116191864,
0.1384580135345459,
-1.267668604850769,
-0.3084874749183655,
1.424080729484558,
0.016554225236177444,
-0.28063496947288513,
-0.2322687953710556,
-0.09880826622247696,
0.784331738948822,
-0.5828837752342224,
0.6184824109077454,
0.6793411374092102,
-0.051064398139715195,
-0.24408826231956482,
-0.5286982655525208,
0.2093251645565033,
0.07060972601175308,
-0.5610039830207825,
-0.13476650416851044,
0.3220311403274536,
0.2222728282213211,
0.2580097019672394,
0.7225005626678467,
0.1366177648305893,
-0.014523464255034924,
-0.12822149693965912,
-0.08913309872150421,
-0.04684130847454071,
-0.5370646119117737,
-0.19071277976036072,
0.07313946634531021,
-0.14183321595191956,
-0.15098583698272705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10226v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10226v1
|
Find The Gap: Knowledge Base Reasoning For Visual Question Answering
| 2024-04-16T02:11:46 | 2024-04-16T02:11:46 |
Elham J. Barezi, Parisa Kordjamshidi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
We analyze knowledge-based visual question answering, for which given a
question, the models need to ground it into the visual modality and retrieve
the relevant knowledge from a given large knowledge base (KB) to be able to
answer. Our analysis has two folds, one based on designing neural architectures
and training them from scratch, and another based on large pre-trained language
models (LLMs). Our research questions are: 1) Can we effectively augment models
by explicit supervised retrieval of the relevant KB information to solve the
KB-VQA problem? 2) How do task-specific and LLM-based models perform in the
integration of visual and external knowledge, and multi-hop reasoning over both
sources of information? 3) Is the implicit knowledge of LLMs sufficient for
KB-VQA and to what extent it can replace the explicit KB? Our results
demonstrate the positive impact of empowering task-specific and LLM models with
supervised external and visual knowledge retrieval models. Our findings show
that though LLMs are stronger in 1-hop reasoning, they suffer in 2-hop
reasoning in comparison with our fine-tuned NN model even if the relevant
information from both modalities is available to the model. Moreover, we
observed that LLM models outperform the NN model for KB-related questions which
confirms the effectiveness of implicit knowledge in LLMs however, they do not
alleviate the need for external KB.
|
[
-0.5344065427780151,
-1.1120206117630005,
1.0243760347366333,
-0.03744446486234665,
0.003193178214132786,
-0.0636870414018631,
0.05770369991660118,
-0.7037138938903809,
-0.12987159192562103,
0.5550135970115662,
-0.6225611567497253,
-0.3495437204837799,
-0.6407361030578613,
-0.047071658074855804,
-0.10000192373991013,
0.09967734664678574,
-0.23104901611804962,
0.34319350123405457,
-0.8144949078559875,
0.013602075167000294,
-0.8127968907356262,
-0.3217223584651947,
-0.35061782598495483,
-0.023663803935050964,
0.6514721512794495,
0.4502253234386444,
0.542970597743988,
0.6036746501922607,
0.6589691042900085,
0.316026896238327,
-0.32347509264945984,
0.181934654712677,
-0.3785043954849243,
0.1478438824415207,
0.0023228980135172606,
-0.6315139532089233,
-0.24572420120239258,
-0.2993675470352173,
0.35637423396110535,
1.0939370393753052,
0.22293518483638763,
0.14785587787628174,
-0.10135731101036072,
0.7288554906845093,
-0.5117908716201782,
0.2386280596256256,
-0.6073700189590454,
-0.08008625358343124,
-0.034621309489011765,
-0.10797982662916183,
-0.23165705800056458,
-0.18377038836479187,
0.4510553479194641,
-0.817492663860321,
0.10412756353616714,
-0.0006672406452707946,
0.8133440017700195,
0.4764614999294281,
-0.7231857180595398,
-0.1194983422756195,
-0.5111867189407349,
0.4820877015590668,
-0.4540005624294281,
0.6650720238685608,
0.33605337142944336,
0.3174252212047577,
-0.0561167411506176,
-0.8101068735122681,
-0.5707995891571045,
-0.2920432984828949,
-0.04602468013763428,
0.14814259111881256,
-0.21091090142726898,
0.13624118268489838,
0.5099887251853943,
0.235419362783432,
-0.7040135860443115,
-0.2668297588825226,
-0.53227299451828,
-0.057063210755586624,
0.36117619276046753,
0.07677282392978668,
0.4549497365951538,
-0.27686700224876404,
-0.44432127475738525,
0.09915386140346527,
-0.7799750566482544,
0.34974008798599243,
0.19005149602890015,
0.11520653963088989,
0.257424533367157,
0.6646427512168884,
-0.4421199560165405,
1.0506569147109985,
-0.15702985227108002,
0.15780705213546753,
-0.05385087430477142,
-0.4157291352748871,
-0.23280614614486694,
-0.4230206310749054,
0.2503663897514343,
0.3915660083293915,
0.493013858795166,
-0.2995259463787079,
0.12479667365550995,
-0.021642042323946953,
0.2552681863307953,
-0.5597974061965942,
-0.227005735039711,
-0.11333519220352173,
-0.5152048468589783,
0.04185469448566437,
-0.019186411052942276,
-0.4670020639896393,
-0.33827152848243713,
-0.5134463310241699,
0.6900501251220703,
-0.2792574167251587,
-0.4300674498081207,
0.042981766164302826,
-0.3801751434803009,
0.38808879256248474,
0.6333887577056885,
-0.46248728036880493,
0.27139532566070557,
0.4757687747478485,
0.580197274684906,
0.04931095615029335,
-0.14052733778953552,
-0.29162535071372986,
-0.01581609807908535,
-0.52321457862854,
0.7730405926704407,
-0.5519363284111023,
-0.031528290361166,
0.007684863638132811,
0.10597966611385345,
-0.21421712636947632,
-0.5656721591949463,
0.07406162470579147,
-1.1468744277954102,
0.17362070083618164,
-0.9187296628952026,
-0.6972740888595581,
-0.49520257115364075,
0.43332570791244507,
-0.7982754111289978,
0.6990349292755127,
0.1467539668083191,
-0.7713742256164551,
0.29361581802368164,
-0.48744210600852966,
-0.22877375781536102,
0.06298523396253586,
-0.34837451577186584,
0.0617135614156723,
-0.07425188273191452,
0.39905160665512085,
0.2942933738231659,
-0.2460068315267563,
0.15583287179470062,
-0.46552133560180664,
-0.39851468801498413,
0.060599084943532944,
-0.09655594080686569,
0.7798330783843994,
0.038817763328552246,
-0.20411323010921478,
0.0877251848578453,
-0.45325759053230286,
0.08312104642391205,
0.20658472180366516,
-0.23840047419071198,
-0.5274308919906616,
-0.12055454403162003,
-0.33850762248039246,
0.2925011217594147,
0.2151486724615097,
-0.4981482923030853,
0.27951622009277344,
-0.19591709971427917,
0.1187649518251419,
0.6948543190956116,
0.22882713377475739,
0.49119481444358826,
-0.018398582935333252,
0.5808534026145935,
0.15138226747512817,
0.17520931363105774,
-0.18656706809997559,
-0.736779510974884,
-0.849941611289978,
0.21618250012397766,
0.3216976821422577,
0.6744521856307983,
-0.9858222603797913,
-0.0724007710814476,
-0.05113798752427101,
-0.2121400535106659,
-0.37356480956077576,
0.28145885467529297,
0.30410826206207275,
0.899225652217865,
0.44700148701667786,
-0.1518317610025406,
-0.4895573854446411,
-0.9829806685447693,
-0.21656298637390137,
-0.17833246290683746,
0.22613251209259033,
0.5475844740867615,
0.5089167356491089,
0.04584246873855591,
0.8347151279449463,
-0.5072078704833984,
0.05935167148709297,
-0.1599671095609665,
-0.1118263378739357,
0.10114500671625137,
0.24364466965198517,
0.31645628809928894,
-1.0719919204711914,
-0.35736018419265747,
-0.22537124156951904,
-1.1298907995224,
-0.11137408018112183,
0.10606332868337631,
-0.2794105112552643,
0.014259720221161842,
0.8498876690864563,
-0.7666522860527039,
0.6636971235275269,
0.13976001739501953,
-0.5009863972663879,
0.3997339606285095,
0.11171245574951172,
0.3315155804157257,
-0.8041405081748962,
-0.0054292092099785805,
-0.040911830961704254,
-0.13038097321987152,
-0.7078034281730652,
0.07405600696802139,
0.14323987066745758,
-0.04876195266842842,
-0.3033679723739624,
0.734525740146637,
-0.6958764791488647,
-0.04002493992447853,
-0.21141153573989868,
0.1431128978729248,
0.10946425050497055,
0.7040470242500305,
0.21948903799057007,
0.5987730622291565,
0.7309140563011169,
-0.593264639377594,
0.4196828603744507,
0.40559321641921997,
-0.4476936459541321,
0.3568423092365265,
-0.7832313179969788,
0.06642194837331772,
-0.43775343894958496,
-0.022740965709090233,
-1.388126015663147,
-0.263173371553421,
0.23088613152503967,
-0.6175754070281982,
0.29599902033805847,
-0.46621012687683105,
-0.306074321269989,
-0.4302327334880829,
0.10268213599920273,
0.6221596002578735,
0.5102654695510864,
-0.5535319447517395,
0.5860837697982788,
0.2425762116909027,
-0.3569281995296478,
-0.8900750875473022,
-0.5846601128578186,
0.06845930218696594,
-0.03717406094074249,
-1.1918500661849976,
0.13347740471363068,
-0.0765010416507721,
-0.3108922839164734,
0.2797800302505493,
-0.2975080907344818,
-0.11789417266845703,
-0.007518052123486996,
0.2207890897989273,
0.3472137153148651,
-0.5279678702354431,
0.35506221652030945,
-0.2769724130630493,
0.0011343654477968812,
0.20764519274234772,
-0.32543569803237915,
0.21793268620967865,
-0.2443237006664276,
-0.6129552721977234,
0.09211467206478119,
0.5400086641311646,
0.4026273787021637,
-0.2077617347240448,
0.5469343066215515,
0.42827239632606506,
-0.4776025414466858,
0.05940590053796768,
-0.7822140455245972,
-0.06216826289892197,
-0.38975784182548523,
0.41477060317993164,
-0.4797399342060089,
-1.0930317640304565,
0.5123481154441833,
0.010919004678726196,
-0.367942214012146,
0.29626861214637756,
0.4046613574028015,
-0.3365047574043274,
1.0529385805130005,
0.968606173992157,
0.4526243209838867,
0.4433603882789612,
-0.3136434257030487,
0.047435443848371506,
-0.7541661858558655,
-0.5225838422775269,
-0.08648312091827393,
-0.22872266173362732,
-0.3517002761363983,
-0.5773585438728333,
0.5462894439697266,
0.4876817762851715,
-0.23712275922298431,
0.11300360411405563,
-0.17948214709758759,
0.45479175448417664,
0.9112139940261841,
0.34632083773612976,
0.3142155706882477,
-0.06828590482473373,
-0.1705419421195984,
-0.04734138399362564,
-1.066284418106079,
-0.171641007065773,
0.9812200665473938,
0.3137936592102051,
0.7787262201309204,
0.025992007926106453,
0.17836318910121918,
-0.060437582433223724,
-0.02022911049425602,
-0.6618533730506897,
0.6351087689399719,
0.16856960952281952,
-0.699025571346283,
-0.3583637475967407,
-0.532479465007782,
-0.7123408913612366,
0.19290664792060852,
-0.08019215613603592,
-0.6634131073951721,
0.2652377784252167,
0.28808853030204773,
-0.12647411227226257,
0.3480701148509979,
-0.8574539422988892,
1.2136212587356567,
-0.3715815246105194,
-0.5615726709365845,
0.062411028891801834,
-1.0014387369155884,
0.6825656890869141,
0.3411930203437805,
-0.1386478841304779,
0.19553710520267487,
0.00983540527522564,
0.7458442449569702,
-0.42721810936927795,
0.7389264702796936,
-0.43357935547828674,
0.1155288964509964,
0.45281746983528137,
0.04564034193754196,
0.30118927359580994,
-0.09133452922105789,
0.37839290499687195,
0.1519623100757599,
-0.13575640320777893,
-0.48365122079849243,
-0.9929200410842896,
0.3914966583251953,
-0.5435494780540466,
-0.9013649225234985,
-0.15852344036102295,
-0.5410470366477966,
-0.5583316683769226,
0.18697881698608398,
0.13939499855041504,
0.41298121213912964,
0.1258559226989746,
0.23690497875213623,
1.0637071132659912,
-0.2442455291748047,
0.11611976474523544,
0.3487592935562134,
-0.23588396608829498,
-0.2551726996898651,
0.5737417340278625,
0.1997208446264267,
0.3087790310382843,
0.5976033806800842,
0.025126885622739792,
-0.457846462726593,
-0.4745524227619171,
-0.6711171269416809,
0.12807528674602509,
-1.100059151649475,
-0.17454630136489868,
-0.751226544380188,
-0.3647036850452423,
-0.43482598662376404,
0.216406911611557,
-0.09627194702625275,
-0.3909514248371124,
0.03552404046058655,
-0.06329093128442764,
0.4585004150867462,
0.790237545967102,
-0.07245484739542007,
0.21650011837482452,
-0.7150188088417053,
0.5787240862846375,
0.7428173422813416,
0.549794614315033,
0.13827216625213623,
-0.5134510397911072,
-0.17681103944778442,
-0.051323503255844116,
-0.0598418153822422,
-1.2516154050827026,
-0.045116450637578964,
-0.2902895212173462,
0.8059720993041992,
0.21400192379951477,
-0.2642630934715271,
0.9235472679138184,
-0.46715983748435974,
0.675578236579895,
0.12860408425331116,
-0.5927013754844666,
0.5325905084609985,
-0.3152783215045929,
0.28646600246429443,
0.3933475613594055,
0.5575045347213745,
-0.44728484749794006,
-0.1027853935956955,
-0.5813792943954468,
-0.840156078338623,
0.5013394951820374,
0.08139266818761826,
-0.18229340016841888,
0.18216146528720856,
0.268233984708786,
-0.07228568941354752,
0.24033772945404053,
-0.8122193217277527,
-0.2224108874797821,
-0.12217404693365097,
-0.07245663553476334,
0.264303594827652,
-0.2499772161245346,
-0.08070796728134155,
-0.4044532775878906,
0.47803404927253723,
-0.057493507862091064,
0.3240458071231842,
0.37537896633148193,
-0.3130442202091217,
-0.24147580564022064,
0.09835033118724823,
0.27031686902046204,
0.9336167573928833,
-0.06491086632013321,
0.21078822016716003,
0.20525658130645752,
-0.11576641350984573,
-0.12744517624378204,
0.12832500040531158,
-0.19450782239437103,
-0.08561261743307114,
0.5761494636535645,
0.8793985843658447,
0.01512076985090971,
-0.7344764471054077,
0.8160919547080994,
-0.11174213141202927,
-0.3331301510334015,
-0.2030428946018219,
-0.00867728516459465,
0.4155401587486267,
0.5823492407798767,
0.3207649290561676,
0.2130374163389206,
0.09115836769342422,
-0.3584847152233124,
0.2911984622478485,
0.7077610492706299,
-0.37420764565467834,
0.0433172844350338,
0.6544066667556763,
0.04249884933233261,
-0.13501715660095215,
0.7027661800384521,
0.08831701427698135,
-0.6207594275474548,
0.7701451182365417,
0.3033194839954376,
0.42535483837127686,
0.12651658058166504,
0.0545237734913826,
0.3777371048927307,
0.5260382294654846,
0.04148050770163536,
0.4619859755039215,
-0.2702007293701172,
-0.6714237928390503,
-0.6783460378646851,
-0.31115105748176575,
-0.2986849248409271,
0.2762833833694458,
-0.4814451038837433,
-0.010715874843299389,
-0.058548443019390106,
0.08805251866579056,
-0.23339544236660004,
-0.21296100318431854,
-0.9679080247879028,
0.26754283905029297,
0.4977976381778717,
1.2391430139541626,
-0.7959135174751282,
0.37503862380981445,
0.6872555613517761,
-0.6565232276916504,
-0.9759368896484375,
-0.09157902747392654,
-0.17438016831874847,
-0.9444611668586731,
0.8733458518981934,
0.13994042575359344,
0.007988039404153824,
-0.11157982051372528,
-0.8804649114608765,
-1.1202691793441772,
1.1286451816558838,
0.30479976534843445,
-0.3683110177516937,
-0.30918043851852417,
-0.005802581086754799,
0.3702195882797241,
-0.14556236565113068,
0.2656613290309906,
0.26845595240592957,
0.5196017026901245,
0.4530135989189148,
-0.7482892870903015,
0.010007314383983612,
-0.5678864121437073,
0.04208217188715935,
0.04788839817047119,
-0.34566977620124817,
0.7198461890220642,
-0.5490806698799133,
-0.10558731108903885,
0.039500460028648376,
0.6027739644050598,
0.311405748128891,
0.37923213839530945,
0.5743566155433655,
0.6753726601600647,
0.6154308319091797,
-0.09110978990793228,
0.9571914672851562,
-0.0690469741821289,
-0.059320252388715744,
0.9125140309333801,
0.03775562718510628,
0.7122194766998291,
0.6910004615783691,
-0.03673546016216278,
0.5816137194633484,
0.8311455249786377,
0.05993924289941788,
0.48590779304504395,
0.201111301779747,
0.0034035551361739635,
-0.6377261281013489,
0.049153849482536316,
-0.5445224046707153,
0.3046990633010864,
0.18419896066188812,
-0.19505080580711365,
-0.20510660111904144,
-0.08724131435155869,
-0.3966764211654663,
-0.13895060122013092,
-0.40596896409988403,
0.856663703918457,
0.17158298194408417,
-0.880938708782196,
0.45397064089775085,
-0.24436698853969574,
0.2396182268857956,
-0.6072299480438232,
-0.32685402035713196,
-0.2381831407546997,
-0.1510411500930786,
-0.10701211541891098,
-0.8304100036621094,
0.08841696381568909,
-0.04356050491333008,
-0.3210960030555725,
-0.12450851500034332,
1.1737637519836426,
-0.6027770042419434,
-0.5773385167121887,
0.3711392879486084,
1.299655556678772,
-0.003024625824764371,
-0.27078214287757874,
-0.5092101693153381,
-0.2895398736000061,
-0.1900479942560196,
-0.4661708474159241,
0.08754505217075348,
0.5518918633460999,
-0.14425808191299438,
0.8033236265182495,
0.583511471748352,
0.031246913596987724,
0.47460412979125977,
0.14568166434764862,
0.8850075006484985,
-0.8175172209739685,
-0.4814048707485199,
-0.5988343358039856,
0.6416041851043701,
-0.170427143573761,
-0.05806165561079979,
0.6904226541519165,
0.3232821822166443,
0.8528187274932861,
-0.31837522983551025,
0.8964259624481201,
-0.10250820964574814,
0.4603678286075592,
-0.7164347767829895,
0.40425562858581543,
-0.914845883846283,
0.1760392040014267,
-0.37013426423072815,
-0.741276204586029,
-0.18102842569351196,
0.47867345809936523,
-0.43523329496383667,
0.19588355720043182,
0.6839108467102051,
0.9612247943878174,
-0.17932569980621338,
-0.08482109755277634,
0.4198487102985382,
0.0559043362736702,
-0.09547951072454453,
0.9124728441238403,
1.3954991102218628,
-0.34287452697753906,
0.821739673614502,
-0.12402345985174179,
-0.23033007979393005,
-0.018261108547449112,
-0.7525397539138794,
-0.7728790640830994,
-0.5903691649436951,
-0.1431722342967987,
-0.19305531680583954,
0.0633944422006607,
0.48005080223083496,
0.8167338371276855,
-0.3862551748752594,
-0.05382274463772774,
-0.3151930570602417,
0.44901448488235474,
-0.13783299922943115,
-0.25287482142448425,
0.2887127101421356,
-0.39852243661880493,
-0.2893012762069702,
0.3697383999824524,
0.2351408153772354,
0.0386553630232811,
-0.1563969999551773,
-0.06694714725017548,
-0.3116738498210907,
-0.15448327362537384,
0.5032274127006531,
0.24279525876045227,
-0.7578723430633545,
-0.2674019932746887,
0.641735315322876,
-0.05778372287750244,
0.21793927252292633,
0.8354198336601257,
-0.8393434882164001,
0.5819600820541382,
0.7787660956382751,
1.0212141275405884,
0.5756022930145264,
0.13791903853416443,
0.582581639289856,
-0.7644533514976501,
-0.24512240290641785,
0.15559524297714233,
0.4656151235103607,
0.32989227771759033,
-0.2679655849933624,
0.4855732321739197,
0.4590728282928467,
-0.4094667434692383,
-0.589730441570282,
0.4738946557044983,
-1.1118167638778687,
-0.5425819158554077,
1.2070318460464478,
0.005401381757110357,
-0.25919896364212036,
-0.20921790599822998,
-0.13013409078121185,
0.32332342863082886,
0.1562630832195282,
0.44474202394485474,
0.7478674054145813,
-0.49427542090415955,
-0.4398747682571411,
-0.7989255785942078,
0.44299739599227905,
0.4155372083187103,
-0.8218780755996704,
-0.054596371948719025,
0.6432640552520752,
0.4309828281402588,
0.15494367480278015,
0.796100378036499,
0.03926560655236244,
0.6151242852210999,
0.17534996569156647,
-0.09407252073287964,
-0.48037993907928467,
-0.6724857091903687,
-0.1829005926847458,
0.2257453203201294,
0.010934176854789257,
-0.22506973147392273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10199v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10199v3
|
CULTURE-GEN: Revealing Global Cultural Perception in Language Models through Natural Language Prompting
| 2024-04-16T00:50:43 | 2024-04-26T18:39:54 |
Huihan Li, Liwei Jiang, Jena D. Huang, Hyunwoo Kim, Sebastin Santy, Taylor Sorensen, Bill Yuchen Lin, Nouha Dziri, Xiang Ren, Yejin Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As the utilization of large language models (LLMs) has proliferated
worldwide, it is crucial for them to have adequate knowledge and fair
representation for diverse global cultures. In this work, we uncover culture
perceptions of three SOTA models on 110 countries and regions on 8
culture-related topics through culture-conditioned generations, and extract
symbols from these generations that are associated to each culture by the LLM.
We discover that culture-conditioned generation consist of linguistic "markers"
that distinguish marginalized cultures apart from default cultures. We also
discover that LLMs have an uneven degree of diversity in the culture symbols,
and that cultures from different geographic regions have different presence in
LLMs' culture-agnostic generation. Our findings promote further research in
studying the knowledge and fairness of global culture perception in LLMs. Code
and Data can be found in: https://github.com/huihanlhh/Culture-Gen/
|
[
-0.5165391564369202,
-0.7196095585823059,
0.5972970128059387,
0.3313850164413452,
-0.04589042812585831,
0.23952610790729523,
-0.40895217657089233,
-0.6744117736816406,
0.1908077746629715,
0.43116191029548645,
-0.887013852596283,
-0.3739379942417145,
-0.37906327843666077,
0.5136129856109619,
-0.07814030349254608,
0.7637122273445129,
0.13179893791675568,
0.4095953106880188,
-0.1997150331735611,
-0.006012332160025835,
-0.2243182361125946,
-0.6086360812187195,
-0.5666804909706116,
-0.505366861820221,
0.08938276767730713,
0.7137002348899841,
0.422272652387619,
0.24717111885547638,
0.14785349369049072,
0.23860734701156616,
-0.21226412057876587,
-0.03809869661927223,
-0.4681262969970703,
0.24217674136161804,
0.0016741938889026642,
-0.5703383088111877,
-0.3316793441772461,
0.12324340641498566,
0.5025917291641235,
0.6224649548530579,
0.08035173267126083,
0.5835908651351929,
0.28702935576438904,
0.519855260848999,
-0.3446262776851654,
0.02881479077041149,
-0.6538500785827637,
0.22986069321632385,
-0.11187634617090225,
-0.4172567129135132,
-0.5141597986221313,
-0.598926842212677,
0.1119861900806427,
-0.5838738679885864,
0.4830488860607147,
0.20912162959575653,
0.629708468914032,
-0.016587447375059128,
-0.7814018726348877,
-0.21813194453716278,
-0.8357691168785095,
0.8747320175170898,
-0.16587308049201965,
0.3070782423019409,
0.3009459376335144,
0.25072744488716125,
-0.3181087076663971,
-0.5237840414047241,
-0.6590437889099121,
-0.1496724635362625,
0.10384470224380493,
0.21483896672725677,
-0.1682804375886917,
-0.2238922268152237,
0.3223000764846802,
0.5217088460922241,
-0.506753146648407,
0.14831358194351196,
-0.2798953056335449,
-0.3301805555820465,
0.41962969303131104,
-0.017612984403967857,
0.734013020992279,
-0.2624133825302124,
-0.5221689343452454,
0.09662937372922897,
-1.2577844858169556,
0.09214220941066742,
0.5000212788581848,
0.3130896985530853,
-0.34224510192871094,
0.018957659602165222,
-0.34401947259902954,
0.6968012452125549,
-0.17374078929424286,
-0.06242651492357254,
0.21684406697750092,
-0.1498485803604126,
-0.06395750492811203,
-0.05625004693865776,
0.7179824709892273,
0.4208236038684845,
0.7534613013267517,
0.05853904038667679,
0.07246584445238113,
0.12238333374261856,
-0.15305963158607483,
-0.7983741760253906,
0.1286199390888214,
-0.14857332408428192,
-0.6554543972015381,
-0.2753901183605194,
-0.011236821301281452,
-0.8772597908973694,
-0.7537853121757507,
-0.09667149931192398,
0.00694327661767602,
-0.05982770398259163,
-0.4145504832267761,
-0.02225683070719242,
-0.289529949426651,
0.2563309073448181,
0.06438880413770676,
-1.1776691675186157,
-0.14744900166988373,
0.4746569097042084,
0.5413804054260254,
0.13038498163223267,
-0.11667508631944656,
-0.024272629991173744,
0.0014682542532682419,
-0.28284239768981934,
0.7550017833709717,
-0.8883252143859863,
-0.5308274030685425,
0.3284175992012024,
0.00933428667485714,
0.2886708378791809,
-0.6501875519752502,
0.6876547932624817,
-0.5493963360786438,
0.2735975384712219,
-0.8733915090560913,
-0.10255644470453262,
-0.2738644778728485,
0.30317437648773193,
-0.6217328906059265,
0.8554345369338989,
0.04786742106080055,
-0.5350568890571594,
0.8386954665184021,
-0.38672444224357605,
-0.2825036644935608,
0.38632363080978394,
-0.46551477909088135,
0.06454039365053177,
0.19927674531936646,
0.4004470407962799,
0.5500771403312683,
-0.43349891901016235,
0.39892372488975525,
-0.3459671437740326,
-0.18122664093971252,
0.15554511547088623,
-0.39884093403816223,
0.9653964638710022,
0.6386409997940063,
-0.18172277510166168,
0.11504820734262466,
-0.7860726714134216,
-0.2601841688156128,
0.5059210062026978,
-0.41730383038520813,
-0.42803096771240234,
-0.08474915474653244,
-0.05995194986462593,
0.27610889077186584,
0.2745390832424164,
-0.5590792894363403,
0.3975406587123871,
-0.2399875521659851,
0.6896894574165344,
0.6387656331062317,
0.018472446128726006,
0.5893213152885437,
-0.23055388033390045,
0.8659183979034424,
-0.06816741824150085,
0.36338523030281067,
-0.07282599806785583,
-0.6586287617683411,
-0.7285861372947693,
-0.12008585780858994,
-0.10736636817455292,
0.36540091037750244,
-0.9227742552757263,
0.1004331111907959,
-0.30536189675331116,
-0.29556187987327576,
-0.5581381916999817,
0.262745201587677,
0.12131525576114655,
0.3742915689945221,
0.038295771926641464,
0.012237239629030228,
-0.9296353459358215,
-0.8143802285194397,
-0.1869327276945114,
-0.25122517347335815,
-0.21755029261112213,
0.10353787243366241,
0.29288479685783386,
-0.04883136600255966,
1.0159180164337158,
-0.24104714393615723,
-0.025089504197239876,
-0.6349145770072937,
0.04788285121321678,
0.13008393347263336,
0.060062434524297714,
0.6629207134246826,
-0.7746087312698364,
-0.4249349534511566,
-0.1146487295627594,
-0.7727029919624329,
-0.31658801436424255,
0.19094817340373993,
-0.04587022587656975,
0.25104057788848877,
0.8291016221046448,
-0.07132937014102936,
0.12526677548885345,
1.0982434749603271,
-0.4664626717567444,
0.318560928106308,
-0.03926756605505943,
0.23467247188091278,
-1.0560872554779053,
0.023712441325187683,
0.0726422369480133,
0.016220109537243843,
-0.8800892233848572,
0.21801379323005676,
0.1982991248369217,
0.0665360689163208,
-0.24192099273204803,
0.6886049509048462,
-0.6118909120559692,
0.13792723417282104,
0.008840333670377731,
0.09373927861452103,
0.11575082689523697,
0.03759279102087021,
0.23460277915000916,
0.8049224615097046,
0.5129076838493347,
-0.6345679759979248,
0.13693863153457642,
0.11411046236753464,
-0.6767351627349854,
0.4557960033416748,
-0.2602238655090332,
0.06003447622060776,
-0.34574756026268005,
0.590650200843811,
-0.6584821939468384,
-0.24785450100898743,
0.15717922151088715,
-0.31649327278137207,
-0.09602352231740952,
-0.3266265392303467,
-0.44447091221809387,
-0.4404650926589966,
-0.013785880990326405,
0.6350101232528687,
0.7488064169883728,
-0.6368231773376465,
0.4252622723579407,
0.23044165968894958,
-0.33388951420783997,
-0.478789359331131,
-0.6016401052474976,
-0.012672306038439274,
-0.517930805683136,
-0.6576427221298218,
0.0374579019844532,
-0.24789321422576904,
-0.438297301530838,
-0.5519067049026489,
-0.01851462945342064,
0.3071786165237427,
0.2996896207332611,
0.3103725016117096,
0.2881019115447998,
-0.18742243945598602,
-0.04624322056770325,
-0.17652061581611633,
0.09834550321102142,
0.2535218894481659,
-0.4469846487045288,
0.8054307103157043,
-0.10057590901851654,
-0.32270973920822144,
0.06628744304180145,
0.21251408755779266,
0.33538728952407837,
-0.25351017713546753,
0.6320016384124756,
0.523577868938446,
-0.34776759147644043,
-0.21800649166107178,
-0.6241538524627686,
-0.336167573928833,
-0.5128157734870911,
0.06154295802116394,
-0.2849647104740143,
-1.124503493309021,
0.8546814918518066,
-0.10599490255117416,
-0.32607269287109375,
0.48819610476493835,
0.7174361348152161,
0.19299128651618958,
1.1262348890304565,
0.7589170932769775,
-0.2325841337442398,
0.3724806606769562,
-0.20407499372959137,
0.3345143795013428,
-0.37763023376464844,
-0.4483638405799866,
-0.6906303763389587,
-0.3213828206062317,
-0.860393226146698,
-0.27611005306243896,
0.4775543808937073,
0.13129249215126038,
-0.25701868534088135,
-0.4971219599246979,
-0.19721460342407227,
0.7096594572067261,
0.6804147958755493,
-0.24618211388587952,
0.49785807728767395,
0.12570996582508087,
-0.4054979979991913,
0.021757712587714195,
-0.6839224696159363,
-0.6772540807723999,
0.7564032673835754,
0.4554281532764435,
0.7246649861335754,
0.10668111592531204,
0.7040528059005737,
0.07369059324264526,
0.3196519911289215,
-0.6975806355476379,
0.6367118954658508,
-0.2580934166908264,
-0.76227205991745,
-0.006453916430473328,
-0.4220965802669525,
-1.0322051048278809,
-0.11762437224388123,
-0.20442654192447662,
-0.832011878490448,
0.32376328110694885,
0.09886681288480759,
-0.458980530500412,
0.07085975259542465,
-0.5703572630882263,
0.5805343389511108,
0.02816314622759819,
0.0646357536315918,
-0.04113805666565895,
-0.558064877986908,
0.5216230154037476,
0.036859117448329926,
0.7093865275382996,
-0.43853849172592163,
0.41793644428253174,
0.5650151371955872,
-0.050949618220329285,
0.8920007348060608,
-0.24371689558029175,
-0.46326449513435364,
0.310334712266922,
0.19776847958564758,
0.16613274812698364,
0.027751559391617775,
-0.2491358369588852,
0.21088969707489014,
-0.23168648779392242,
-0.24306899309158325,
-0.27687060832977295,
0.7318567037582397,
-0.7979264259338379,
-0.6956526637077332,
-0.19116544723510742,
-0.6405901908874512,
-0.2752552926540375,
0.12755616009235382,
0.5493846535682678,
0.3547668755054474,
-0.24023374915122986,
0.1814589947462082,
0.6877297163009644,
-0.5949773788452148,
0.33213189244270325,
0.4445517957210541,
-0.5432455539703369,
0.10588505119085312,
0.7444254159927368,
0.07103931903839111,
0.40198609232902527,
0.17620781064033508,
0.43309152126312256,
-0.2281593531370163,
-0.2762686610221863,
-0.49013155698776245,
-0.07549184560775757,
-0.8806053996086121,
-0.08375023305416107,
-0.3043007552623749,
-0.1001492589712143,
-0.5756129622459412,
-0.21557635068893433,
0.23040619492530823,
-0.1059194952249527,
-0.05924401804804802,
-0.3311675190925598,
0.4536774158477783,
0.9222714304924011,
-0.109441377222538,
0.2960565686225891,
-0.6782988905906677,
0.2447417974472046,
0.39701902866363525,
0.19226296246051788,
-0.1311587393283844,
-0.5750025510787964,
0.0370023176074028,
0.04212753847241402,
-0.005912464577704668,
-0.8959932923316956,
0.4195554852485657,
0.1312326043844223,
0.6978856325149536,
0.7074411511421204,
0.13416387140750885,
0.5356585383415222,
-0.3547978103160858,
0.9519028663635254,
-0.05020442232489586,
-0.8279131054878235,
0.558384358882904,
-0.43155619502067566,
0.5415998697280884,
0.1929825395345688,
0.46650999784469604,
-0.8507447838783264,
-0.8230360150337219,
-0.5258429050445557,
-0.8654533624649048,
0.6449005603790283,
-0.3564222753047943,
0.4731331467628479,
-0.1350029706954956,
0.12418627738952637,
0.322858065366745,
-0.06943626701831818,
-0.9240135550498962,
-0.3328492343425751,
-0.12110698223114014,
-0.10803040117025375,
-0.03898089751601219,
-0.6675229072570801,
-0.1807764619588852,
-0.06579940766096115,
0.5157373547554016,
-0.19205573201179504,
0.05300625413656235,
0.008758798241615295,
-0.18571783602237701,
-0.366375595331192,
0.5564872026443481,
0.6118491888046265,
0.67481929063797,
-0.0778467208147049,
0.28445494174957275,
0.3205646276473999,
-0.5175656080245972,
0.19074827432632446,
-0.3153863251209259,
-0.5013789534568787,
-0.19732899963855743,
0.1967218667268753,
0.8068386912345886,
-0.32989805936813354,
-0.3291442394256592,
0.2344084233045578,
-0.3021271824836731,
-0.004289603792130947,
-0.30621248483657837,
0.006223849952220917,
0.08114698529243469,
0.1915866583585739,
0.7176788449287415,
-0.19131366908550262,
0.11750530451536179,
-0.8590578436851501,
-0.22354969382286072,
0.48368263244628906,
-0.2466425895690918,
-0.24685931205749512,
0.7081278562545776,
0.3921368420124054,
0.09546563029289246,
0.6051132082939148,
-0.4385078549385071,
-0.7027171850204468,
0.4917750954627991,
0.6596283912658691,
0.6719061136245728,
-0.3370186686515808,
0.3973967730998993,
0.4076325297355652,
0.3392643630504608,
-0.07006973028182983,
0.6507051587104797,
0.20506416261196136,
-1.170655369758606,
-0.5167092084884644,
-0.9167220592498779,
-0.17549408972263336,
0.23381254076957703,
-0.7521671056747437,
0.2520984709262848,
-0.40525537729263306,
-0.3027471899986267,
-0.33327630162239075,
-0.12480343133211136,
-1.0008724927902222,
0.3256327211856842,
0.6018180847167969,
1.0182900428771973,
-1.4054272174835205,
0.8834197521209717,
0.6530406475067139,
-0.19019252061843872,
-0.8849025964736938,
0.26275649666786194,
0.29608699679374695,
-1.321197271347046,
0.9004461765289307,
0.22642943263053894,
-0.09199751913547516,
0.04159530997276306,
-0.6413998007774353,
-0.6731973886489868,
0.7196499705314636,
0.48316293954849243,
-0.4306461215019226,
0.27469632029533386,
0.24012039601802826,
0.5689424276351929,
-0.308300644159317,
0.16502420604228973,
0.76865154504776,
0.5176018476486206,
0.1461436152458191,
-0.7192825675010681,
0.18577690422534943,
-0.283802330493927,
0.07562297582626343,
0.011457224376499653,
-0.6110432744026184,
0.6348332166671753,
-0.2891017496585846,
-0.23237714171409607,
0.002383016748353839,
0.7086331248283386,
0.8350715637207031,
0.2959601879119873,
0.5295164585113525,
0.007923337630927563,
0.7256150245666504,
-0.40417155623435974,
0.7740169763565063,
-0.5288336277008057,
0.02102898620069027,
0.5797818303108215,
-0.15951719880104065,
0.658292293548584,
0.520995557308197,
-0.05631917342543602,
0.6688100695610046,
0.7947148084640503,
-0.01887805573642254,
0.20308230817317963,
0.33924755454063416,
-0.41101497411727905,
-0.4041089415550232,
-0.6946998238563538,
-0.6926717162132263,
0.6500536203384399,
0.4414958357810974,
-0.3025473952293396,
0.041759565472602844,
0.09159588813781738,
0.26838183403015137,
0.03889555111527443,
-0.37802961468696594,
0.5187696218490601,
0.247596874833107,
-0.7691051959991455,
0.49594879150390625,
-0.18949545919895172,
0.9153861999511719,
-0.640356719493866,
0.13977910578250885,
-0.6923296451568604,
-0.30851519107818604,
-0.25694429874420166,
-0.6311504244804382,
0.00666554132476449,
0.11281528323888779,
-0.3568573296070099,
-0.7523711919784546,
0.8067291378974915,
-0.28786513209342957,
-0.5636644959449768,
0.3073536157608032,
0.6067908406257629,
0.12032482028007507,
-0.004478678107261658,
-0.1929091066122055,
0.1783960908651352,
0.29899629950523376,
-0.28855639696121216,
0.3034159541130066,
0.6885013580322266,
-0.447115421295166,
0.8506841063499451,
0.4552342891693115,
0.1280238777399063,
0.0876183733344078,
0.5945466756820679,
0.2622371017932892,
-0.5910754203796387,
-0.5191971063613892,
-1.0543535947799683,
0.2979795038700104,
0.06502874940633774,
-0.10936300456523895,
0.8315209150314331,
0.0955561175942421,
0.9751155972480774,
-0.22890394926071167,
1.0432217121124268,
-0.17975008487701416,
0.26700541377067566,
-0.6695598363876343,
0.9194943904876709,
-0.5758487582206726,
0.16062192618846893,
0.001949385041370988,
-0.7902709245681763,
-0.1820669025182724,
0.41387975215911865,
-0.4770132005214691,
0.36869508028030396,
0.42862361669540405,
0.8009420037269592,
0.3167700469493866,
0.28554779291152954,
0.2385931760072708,
0.35335445404052734,
0.1640419065952301,
0.21818025410175323,
1.360162377357483,
0.3115180432796478,
0.592757523059845,
0.027121255174279213,
-0.08679447323083878,
-0.2468263804912567,
-1.0625829696655273,
-0.49068063497543335,
-0.6790669560432434,
-0.21198435127735138,
-0.2931880056858063,
-0.3717104196548462,
0.9810171127319336,
0.5093912482261658,
-0.9911925792694092,
-0.2747991383075714,
0.19620713591575623,
0.029731471091508865,
0.0005593043752014637,
-0.2107764482498169,
-0.1321268081665039,
-0.1597573608160019,
-0.917969286441803,
0.49117639660835266,
0.18460522592067719,
0.25652945041656494,
-0.6066471934318542,
-0.1047578677535057,
0.23269256949424744,
-0.13624083995819092,
0.5635550022125244,
0.24272498488426208,
-0.8311151266098022,
-0.34307214617729187,
-0.03293415531516075,
-0.11174329370260239,
-0.12258900701999664,
0.8626570701599121,
-0.7854028344154358,
0.42559242248535156,
0.8010734915733337,
-0.06664927303791046,
-0.04841672256588936,
-0.188704714179039,
0.9652784466743469,
-1.1657754182815552,
0.36806902289390564,
-0.013146040961146355,
0.5643307566642761,
0.5449363589286804,
-0.17526014149188995,
0.4063396453857422,
0.20568214356899261,
-0.5627335906028748,
-0.6689303517341614,
0.5799834728240967,
-0.5471509099006653,
-0.24394994974136353,
1.5452017784118652,
0.10176445543766022,
0.10892456769943237,
-0.19281312823295593,
-0.09620199352502823,
0.3243255317211151,
-0.3123825490474701,
0.8147178292274475,
0.7104286551475525,
0.2453453242778778,
-0.05120265483856201,
-0.9430012106895447,
0.70381760597229,
0.5481299161911011,
-0.6600252389907837,
-0.12802208960056305,
0.5577321648597717,
0.38943517208099365,
0.03455982357263565,
0.6657962203025818,
0.1836097538471222,
-0.10270179063081741,
-0.3087961971759796,
0.32290810346603394,
0.32276007533073425,
-0.2616468369960785,
-0.3456724286079407,
0.0600583516061306,
0.46775364875793457,
0.1786254644393921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10198v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10198v2
|
ClashEval: Quantifying the tug-of-war between an LLM's internal prior and external evidence
| 2024-04-16T00:43:03 | 2024-06-10T04:44:57 |
Kevin Wu, Eric Wu, James Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval augmented generation (RAG) is frequently used to mitigate
hallucinations and provide up-to-date knowledge for large language models
(LLMs). However, given that document retrieval is an imprecise task and
sometimes results in erroneous or even harmful content being presented in
context, this raises the question of how LLMs handle retrieved information: If
the provided content is incorrect, does the model know to ignore it, or does it
recapitulate the error? Conversely, when the model's initial response is
incorrect, does it always know to use the retrieved information to correct
itself, or does it insist on its wrong prior response? To answer this, we
curate a dataset of over 1200 questions across six domains (e.g., drug dosages,
Olympic records, locations) along with content relevant to answering each
question. We further apply precise perturbations to the answers in the content
that range from subtle to blatant errors. We benchmark six top-performing LLMs,
including GPT-4o, on this dataset and find that LLMs are susceptible to
adopting incorrect retrieved content, overriding their own correct prior
knowledge over 60% of the time. However, the more unrealistic the retrieved
content is (i.e. more deviated from truth), the less likely the model is to
adopt it. Also, the less confident a model is in its initial response (via
measuring token probabilities), the more likely it is to adopt the information
in the retrieved content. We exploit this finding and demonstrate simple
methods for improving model accuracy where there is conflicting retrieved
content. Our results highlight a difficult task and benchmark for LLMs --
namely, their ability to correctly discern when it is wrong in light of correct
retrieved content and to reject cases when the provided content is incorrect.
|
[
-0.3195644021034241,
-0.5423696637153625,
0.6155856847763062,
-0.10749776661396027,
-0.09819638729095459,
0.2503302991390228,
-0.030223442241549492,
-0.6077669858932495,
-0.1464012861251831,
0.5435105562210083,
-0.11109452694654465,
-0.04028945416212082,
-0.910104513168335,
0.10554511845111847,
-0.34354686737060547,
0.9781933426856995,
-0.29289865493774414,
-0.019240256398916245,
-0.2972179651260376,
-0.17636793851852417,
-0.5807710289955139,
-0.5985714197158813,
-0.5489766597747803,
-0.4495559334754944,
0.47031134366989136,
0.18507568538188934,
0.6412678956985474,
0.32034218311309814,
0.7320418357849121,
0.3468649685382843,
-0.28241822123527527,
0.42244601249694824,
-0.8560302257537842,
0.20458999276161194,
-0.5804802775382996,
-0.6062542200088501,
-0.2390683889389038,
0.043438371270895004,
0.5343577861785889,
0.38894781470298767,
-0.20339661836624146,
0.2548708915710449,
0.21457308530807495,
0.6593185067176819,
-0.7618960738182068,
-0.2836320102214813,
-1.1013739109039307,
-0.17275889217853546,
-0.3939683735370636,
-0.4836590588092804,
-0.46477168798446655,
-0.21641723811626434,
0.13473980128765106,
-0.4687906503677368,
0.21678180992603302,
0.24223485589027405,
1.1846835613250732,
0.32635802030563354,
-0.6305215358734131,
-0.734779953956604,
-0.6565219163894653,
0.6130411624908447,
-0.6221418380737305,
0.2873692810535431,
0.4646158218383789,
0.07785714417695999,
-0.4316597282886505,
-0.8896379470825195,
-0.5078426599502563,
-0.2136380970478058,
-0.20411404967308044,
0.2946605086326599,
-0.18095120787620544,
-0.12075354903936386,
0.34765708446502686,
0.5471503734588623,
-0.4656932055950165,
-0.005335464142262936,
-0.3809041976928711,
-0.15767015516757965,
0.6684125661849976,
0.14523589611053467,
0.1894993633031845,
-0.25183460116386414,
-0.6467840075492859,
-0.08045484125614166,
-1.1564693450927734,
0.03578655794262886,
0.54404217004776,
0.24278856813907623,
0.23142419755458832,
0.8695744276046753,
0.182973712682724,
0.4848804771900177,
0.58583003282547,
0.04279421269893646,
0.14693856239318848,
-0.3812432289123535,
-0.2304283231496811,
0.21557177603244781,
0.594512939453125,
0.18005742132663727,
-0.06913614273071289,
0.0033291319850832224,
-0.400954008102417,
-0.3294858932495117,
0.7535337805747986,
-0.5512819886207581,
0.007760150358080864,
0.37009164690971375,
-0.29965633153915405,
-0.07093276083469391,
0.03554007038474083,
-0.6863880753517151,
-0.7228803038597107,
-0.2283729612827301,
0.6734300851821899,
-0.3778526186943054,
-0.306363582611084,
-0.21608500182628632,
-0.1717011034488678,
0.11128619313240051,
0.31245115399360657,
-0.5087189078330994,
0.13946665823459625,
0.6699684262275696,
0.7687084078788757,
-0.32741880416870117,
-0.07072661072015762,
-0.6224559545516968,
0.18451470136642456,
-0.5971300601959229,
0.7913764119148254,
-0.3238335847854614,
-0.5709549188613892,
0.12666942179203033,
-0.04655417427420616,
-0.08597783744335175,
-0.8866915702819824,
0.8093357682228088,
-0.8820640444755554,
0.10300379991531372,
-0.6619996428489685,
-0.8045044541358948,
0.007656665984541178,
0.42178329825401306,
-0.7406899333000183,
0.9963067173957825,
0.058162569999694824,
-1.045437216758728,
0.412842333316803,
-0.055272575467824936,
-0.15968705713748932,
-0.0022638277150690556,
-0.2716117799282074,
-0.26956769824028015,
0.2215401828289032,
-0.0409293957054615,
0.051923006772994995,
-0.26792579889297485,
0.30952972173690796,
-0.20347966253757477,
-0.2751958668231964,
0.289417028427124,
-0.36816832423210144,
0.4324958920478821,
0.3044824004173279,
-0.21101699769496918,
-0.11294279992580414,
-0.4659428000450134,
-0.23898445069789886,
0.2568792402744293,
-0.42398953437805176,
-0.5889621376991272,
0.06613252311944962,
-0.5745967626571655,
0.33861756324768066,
0.4090808928012848,
-0.3912190794944763,
0.24048294126987457,
-0.17785575985908508,
-0.20091964304447174,
0.859452486038208,
0.20618829131126404,
0.19467467069625854,
-0.7872764468193054,
0.30802711844444275,
0.17857028543949127,
-0.15077988803386688,
-0.057427454739809036,
-0.4313536286354065,
-0.5015531778335571,
0.24521608650684357,
0.22298896312713623,
0.43787649273872375,
-0.8862102031707764,
-0.1479080319404602,
-0.2951892614364624,
-0.30661365389823914,
-0.5720979571342468,
0.26263222098350525,
0.38946565985679626,
0.7804798483848572,
0.3925168514251709,
-0.17837533354759216,
-0.6879575252532959,
-0.5451341867446899,
-0.5426256060600281,
-0.4027751684188843,
0.1204352080821991,
0.49484458565711975,
0.44370535016059875,
-0.09227262437343597,
0.6995539665222168,
-0.22817973792552948,
-0.20699948072433472,
-0.0664939284324646,
0.5792132019996643,
0.26922306418418884,
0.29342958331108093,
0.19697453081607819,
-1.1007901430130005,
-0.3371349573135376,
0.09803062677383423,
-0.8240332007408142,
-0.2831612527370453,
-0.19053001701831818,
-0.06979357451200485,
0.4454123377799988,
0.4016650915145874,
-0.5534646511077881,
0.20331130921840668,
0.4863601624965668,
-0.23127587139606476,
0.6879540085792542,
-0.29904404282569885,
0.4845633804798126,
-0.857481062412262,
0.12565605342388153,
-0.11755477637052536,
-0.0025674481876194477,
-0.4059218764305115,
0.21388205885887146,
0.02917235903441906,
0.6301472783088684,
-0.4335474669933319,
0.544898271560669,
-0.657260000705719,
-0.050775110721588135,
-0.24142661690711975,
0.4047248959541321,
-0.03602626174688339,
0.10641808807849884,
0.0248582623898983,
0.9911993741989136,
-0.1041954979300499,
-0.4741601049900055,
0.16146549582481384,
0.2128247171640396,
-0.27376440167427063,
0.8128217458724976,
-0.5091664791107178,
0.2499612271785736,
-0.2548012435436249,
0.06271152198314667,
-1.181230902671814,
-0.32425710558891296,
-0.007232509087771177,
-0.42790743708610535,
0.6820769906044006,
-0.5047560334205627,
-0.4394422471523285,
-0.38356608152389526,
-0.18888044357299805,
0.3052670657634735,
0.35176563262939453,
-0.6509701609611511,
0.6475713849067688,
0.5637163519859314,
-0.3030710220336914,
-0.9468176960945129,
-0.42431753873825073,
0.10928680747747421,
-0.25957080721855164,
-0.5691496729850769,
0.38966548442840576,
-0.16404494643211365,
-0.5502282977104187,
0.020771991461515427,
-0.3700873553752899,
-0.02813017927110195,
-0.3306224048137665,
0.2502792179584503,
0.22109511494636536,
-0.17973586916923523,
0.3874135911464691,
-0.329827219247818,
0.2947545349597931,
0.0751381441950798,
0.06741466373205185,
0.5430805683135986,
0.049805644899606705,
-0.5525504946708679,
0.28304049372673035,
0.14968962967395782,
0.26783040165901184,
-0.11079785227775574,
0.45819956064224243,
0.4538321793079376,
-0.22828039526939392,
0.08486996591091156,
-0.9831491112709045,
0.19442637264728546,
-0.48981329798698425,
0.10953697562217712,
-0.49680790305137634,
-0.5647209882736206,
0.6764301657676697,
-0.11558671295642853,
0.09194864332675934,
0.7142013311386108,
0.6431082487106323,
-0.08861768245697021,
1.000441551208496,
0.3028258979320526,
0.00466552097350359,
0.36584198474884033,
-0.21097470819950104,
-0.12929904460906982,
-1.0169501304626465,
-0.28433147072792053,
-0.44368669390678406,
-0.12413371354341507,
-0.6157485842704773,
-0.4362260699272156,
0.31040582060813904,
0.22415167093276978,
-0.2691275477409363,
0.14924809336662292,
-0.23749269545078278,
0.320263147354126,
0.3414408564567566,
0.03291928768157959,
0.5433762073516846,
-0.3187965154647827,
-0.33761855959892273,
-0.20500300824642181,
-0.6916379332542419,
-0.45342910289764404,
1.254375696182251,
0.18683461844921112,
0.9714746475219727,
0.3673536479473114,
0.7167845368385315,
0.223933607339859,
0.6600396633148193,
-0.4307107925415039,
0.0887191966176033,
0.014600902795791626,
-0.6856609582901001,
0.0742705762386322,
-0.6846275925636292,
-1.184865951538086,
0.3474746644496918,
-0.14951883256435394,
-0.6383056640625,
0.25507068634033203,
0.09790843725204468,
-0.224796324968338,
0.5502995848655701,
-0.6202600598335266,
0.5569149255752563,
-0.37462255358695984,
-0.7161761522293091,
-0.01217749621719122,
-0.5100380182266235,
0.6865137815475464,
-0.21325919032096863,
0.3531687557697296,
0.25773876905441284,
-0.07741271704435349,
0.4762594699859619,
-0.2277977615594864,
0.6402249932289124,
0.07205275446176529,
-0.47228774428367615,
0.5541926026344299,
0.4143288731575012,
0.8725059032440186,
-0.18186220526695251,
-0.0013737393310293555,
-0.15699900686740875,
0.12603135406970978,
-0.13653115928173065,
-0.5708394646644592,
0.7578644156455994,
-0.715987503528595,
-0.8411906361579895,
-0.5214232802391052,
-0.3519454896450043,
-0.16288381814956665,
0.07351046055555344,
0.5783136487007141,
0.3992345333099365,
-0.17416469752788544,
0.005415052175521851,
0.7967008948326111,
-0.10702432692050934,
0.21560132503509521,
0.6661409735679626,
-0.18312877416610718,
-0.23417314887046814,
0.8744745850563049,
0.39321595430374146,
0.4547356963157654,
0.27252352237701416,
0.10968173295259476,
-0.5974513292312622,
-0.6983216404914856,
-0.30128374695777893,
0.2045426219701767,
-0.8632023930549622,
-0.3693205416202545,
-0.5668221712112427,
-0.3745681047439575,
-0.3064456582069397,
0.15329815447330475,
-0.3425925374031067,
0.04681623354554176,
-0.2309856414794922,
0.036025792360305786,
-0.0075095952488482,
1.1734039783477783,
-0.06989795714616776,
0.03346121683716774,
-0.8881336450576782,
0.25910520553588867,
0.22072076797485352,
0.3238912522792816,
-0.1295197457075119,
-1.0654245615005493,
-0.04138150438666344,
0.11140664666891098,
-0.4646656811237335,
-1.0302932262420654,
0.3316473960876465,
-0.10124281793832779,
0.7944086194038391,
0.14735250174999237,
0.1612556427717209,
0.7791921496391296,
-0.49331900477409363,
0.769248366355896,
-0.22618338465690613,
-0.6418430209159851,
0.4919627904891968,
-0.2615891695022583,
0.20808985829353333,
0.4672672748565674,
0.704917848110199,
-0.445166677236557,
-0.5053656697273254,
-0.9838657975196838,
-0.9890791177749634,
0.37934842705726624,
-0.0004911303985863924,
-0.05415778607130051,
-0.1806115061044693,
0.3099355697631836,
-0.04499117657542229,
0.26560071110725403,
-0.5433912873268127,
0.025978274643421173,
0.1395328789949417,
-0.048622503876686096,
0.16799354553222656,
-0.43343690037727356,
-0.299795925617218,
0.21128146350383759,
0.7772150039672852,
-0.0756194218993187,
0.061155784875154495,
0.5054686069488525,
-0.42614832520484924,
-0.4202226996421814,
0.12817592918872833,
0.6442831754684448,
0.7713719010353088,
-0.34945884346961975,
0.29483214020729065,
0.27674412727355957,
-0.44948694109916687,
0.04029841348528862,
0.056797150522470474,
0.007943212985992432,
0.06358276307582855,
0.46313905715942383,
0.28549081087112427,
0.14673425257205963,
-0.8355858325958252,
0.7001909017562866,
-0.019194629043340683,
0.0982138067483902,
-0.36627280712127686,
-0.1888425499200821,
-0.21631047129631042,
0.2972135543823242,
0.6094090938568115,
-0.008640212938189507,
0.18659307062625885,
-0.5578488707542419,
0.475462406873703,
0.49419891834259033,
-0.2377927005290985,
-0.16157333552837372,
0.45767882466316223,
-0.10712914168834686,
-0.15338702499866486,
0.32892242074012756,
-0.23395787179470062,
-0.4887545704841614,
0.5054004788398743,
0.5469136834144592,
0.6053826212882996,
-0.23765933513641357,
0.06300688534975052,
0.48252376914024353,
0.3188531696796417,
-0.2774093449115753,
0.14104662835597992,
0.3062867820262909,
-0.8643037676811218,
-0.48850905895233154,
-0.35725224018096924,
-0.4507926404476166,
0.3406252861022949,
-0.6177954077720642,
-0.04729492962360382,
-0.20930811762809753,
-0.2718369662761688,
-0.1810372918844223,
0.22876965999603271,
-0.6311184763908386,
0.10408851504325867,
0.04928162321448326,
0.8568788170814514,
-0.3129841983318329,
0.46500226855278015,
0.46479153633117676,
-0.730379045009613,
-0.7384310960769653,
0.054015837609767914,
0.3433231711387634,
-0.8773004412651062,
0.7509516477584839,
-0.2779340445995331,
-0.07189220190048218,
-0.3366350531578064,
-0.5870059132575989,
-1.1026723384857178,
0.9243952631950378,
0.1721174269914627,
-0.6387342810630798,
0.0681566521525383,
-0.11378089338541031,
0.606023907661438,
-0.19438225030899048,
0.44400161504745483,
0.4285910725593567,
0.3599648177623749,
0.6078846454620361,
-0.9450299739837646,
0.09994368255138397,
-0.18109872937202454,
-0.21395200490951538,
0.2896600663661957,
-0.5284392833709717,
0.9358625411987305,
-0.40602466464042664,
-0.4963085651397705,
0.10974472761154175,
0.40509024262428284,
0.2070358544588089,
0.2852570414543152,
0.3886331021785736,
0.5177046656608582,
0.9044184684753418,
-0.1733323484659195,
1.2531424760818481,
-0.2370225489139557,
0.2605701982975006,
1.4825119972229004,
-0.44894713163375854,
1.1419453620910645,
0.6754667162895203,
-0.25579288601875305,
0.40538644790649414,
0.5909335017204285,
0.10140668600797653,
0.28806546330451965,
0.25121262669563293,
-0.17086873948574066,
0.10184481739997864,
-0.16392865777015686,
-0.48391932249069214,
0.27819326519966125,
0.49047181010246277,
-0.3998700678348541,
-0.3109148442745209,
-0.45283904671669006,
0.01777719147503376,
0.12075863778591156,
-0.2488851696252823,
1.083006739616394,
0.04788575321435928,
-0.956574559211731,
0.6622069478034973,
-0.2335517555475235,
0.5209035277366638,
-0.5909720659255981,
-0.027837948873639107,
-0.3527275025844574,
0.15019123256206512,
-0.22072798013687134,
-1.1605159044265747,
0.4432993531227112,
-0.05123007670044899,
-0.033530399203300476,
-0.0015535484999418259,
0.8241292238235474,
-0.6163442730903625,
-0.12938719987869263,
0.3001571297645569,
0.6801412105560303,
-0.009232285432517529,
-0.06907741725444794,
-0.5587853789329529,
0.20662663877010345,
-0.1380980759859085,
-0.16978542506694794,
0.40772539377212524,
0.5859618782997131,
-0.01019059494137764,
0.6217498779296875,
0.5774230360984802,
0.41248244047164917,
0.10515491664409637,
-0.028264708817005157,
0.7970836758613586,
-0.43764612078666687,
-0.056270722299814224,
-0.711690366268158,
0.49283865094184875,
-0.3645879924297333,
-0.3895065188407898,
0.8008795976638794,
0.44208672642707825,
0.9348257184028625,
0.42508047819137573,
0.5844324231147766,
0.05163915827870369,
0.6731699705123901,
-0.6124770045280457,
0.405701607465744,
-0.6922733783721924,
0.5636169910430908,
-0.20036183297634125,
-0.5030267834663391,
0.19316783547401428,
0.2001131922006607,
-0.44244030117988586,
0.13269522786140442,
0.5199585556983948,
0.6987849473953247,
0.07934841513633728,
-0.03840915486216545,
0.2030380666255951,
0.516042947769165,
0.2548213601112366,
0.4572227895259857,
1.2042951583862305,
-0.41241347789764404,
0.7171594500541687,
0.10032020509243011,
-0.017147677019238472,
-0.15704244375228882,
-0.8586145639419556,
-0.5519992709159851,
-0.5835288166999817,
-0.07883746176958084,
-0.6140929460525513,
0.26181018352508545,
0.8295702934265137,
0.34665247797966003,
-0.679938793182373,
-0.19631151854991913,
0.15505829453468323,
0.4342764616012573,
0.008679889142513275,
-0.2458629012107849,
0.1582164168357849,
-0.683474600315094,
-0.4585929811000824,
0.23488028347492218,
0.014545495621860027,
0.21991249918937683,
-0.01967884600162506,
-0.08217985928058624,
-0.4889024496078491,
0.3097006380558014,
0.4892509877681732,
0.3528120219707489,
-0.6934828162193298,
-0.3363179862499237,
-0.15949106216430664,
-0.43602514266967773,
0.273020476102829,
0.9507024884223938,
-0.5968444347381592,
0.5920523405075073,
0.536612331867218,
0.8067445158958435,
0.6220541596412659,
0.24772030115127563,
0.6538919806480408,
-0.8955740928649902,
-0.2567763328552246,
0.13699889183044434,
0.4261798858642578,
0.5012570023536682,
-0.5108357667922974,
0.5648764371871948,
0.2024243324995041,
-0.7735629081726074,
-0.8370345234870911,
0.16331899166107178,
-0.5880207419395447,
-0.34048542380332947,
1.0376536846160889,
-0.21109013259410858,
-0.04375714063644409,
-0.1573910117149353,
-0.4131934642791748,
0.125267893075943,
-0.18613435328006744,
0.9455975890159607,
0.9247958660125732,
-0.024130191653966904,
-0.10314194858074188,
-0.7412675619125366,
0.7298930883407593,
0.26395392417907715,
-0.5411756038665771,
0.05293484032154083,
0.4504837691783905,
0.2733098864555359,
0.372627854347229,
0.6151931285858154,
-0.13839191198349,
0.04619884118437767,
0.11699072271585464,
-0.34213095903396606,
0.24958808720111847,
-0.16401837766170502,
-0.2988337278366089,
0.18361525237560272,
0.09803251922130585,
0.1492595374584198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10180v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10180v2
|
Deferred NAM: Low-latency Top-K Context Injection via Deferred Context Encoding for Non-Streaming ASR
| 2024-04-15T23:28:13 | 2024-04-23T13:43:26 |
Zelin Wu, Gan Song, Christopher Li, Pat Rondon, Zhong Meng, Xavier Velez, Weiran Wang, Diamantino Caseiro, Golan Pundak, Tsendsuren Munkhdalai, Angad Chandorkar, Rohit Prabhavalkar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE, eess.AS
|
Contextual biasing enables speech recognizers to transcribe important phrases
in the speaker's context, such as contact names, even if they are rare in, or
absent from, the training data. Attention-based biasing is a leading approach
which allows for full end-to-end cotraining of the recognizer and biasing
system and requires no separate inference-time components. Such biasers
typically consist of a context encoder; followed by a context filter which
narrows down the context to apply, improving per-step inference time; and,
finally, context application via cross attention. Though much work has gone
into optimizing per-frame performance, the context encoder is at least as
important: recognition cannot begin before context encoding ends. Here, we show
the lightweight phrase selection pass can be moved before context encoding,
resulting in a speedup of up to 16.1 times and enabling biasing to scale to 20K
phrases with a maximum pre-decoding delay under 33ms. With the addition of
phrase- and wordpiece-level cross-entropy losses, our technique also achieves
up to a 37.5% relative WER reduction over the baseline without the losses and
lightweight phrase selection pass.
|
[
-0.49061524868011475,
-0.6202389001846313,
0.3791435956954956,
0.1613113284111023,
-0.474505752325058,
-0.22895143926143646,
-0.27330824732780457,
-0.2820926904678345,
0.20182937383651733,
0.5273516178131104,
-0.7454279065132141,
-0.21479211747646332,
-0.7592285871505737,
0.029050543904304504,
-0.442489892244339,
0.7355623841285706,
0.18263870477676392,
0.010851376689970493,
-0.3072070777416229,
0.04624290019273758,
-0.49193763732910156,
-0.5321655869483948,
-0.49216756224632263,
-0.37854793667793274,
0.15871945023536682,
0.3531920313835144,
0.5429469347000122,
0.6318713426589966,
0.20821815729141235,
0.24109071493148804,
-0.4429475963115692,
-0.25670376420021057,
-0.5142692923545837,
0.2252708226442337,
-0.05534769967198372,
-0.4045106768608093,
-0.36044982075691223,
-0.008293778635561466,
0.573411762714386,
0.7484831809997559,
0.17129388451576233,
0.044571198523044586,
-0.13190416991710663,
0.8924039006233215,
-1.1025060415267944,
-0.2928692400455475,
-0.6760827302932739,
0.2207951843738556,
-0.4101998805999756,
-0.3081953823566437,
-0.2845049202442169,
0.05341300368309021,
0.5578673481941223,
-0.4851326644420624,
0.04764401912689209,
-0.20634496212005615,
0.7669435739517212,
0.8867294788360596,
-0.34259656071662903,
-0.045262373983860016,
-0.6267070770263672,
0.7643141150474548,
-0.5568214654922485,
0.6571674346923828,
0.5244249105453491,
0.3349509537220001,
0.08942493051290512,
-0.7801172137260437,
-0.5563061833381653,
0.036872029304504395,
-0.0019784648902714252,
0.18999728560447693,
-0.08311686664819717,
0.3350726068019867,
0.4793738126754761,
0.4035942852497101,
-0.4175071716308594,
-0.23536649346351624,
-0.1507711410522461,
-0.28742945194244385,
0.40099480748176575,
-0.23442722856998444,
-0.027756692841649055,
-0.10187409818172455,
-0.4849216639995575,
0.16286338865756989,
-0.7436211109161377,
-0.16852450370788574,
-0.11854839324951172,
0.23678170144557953,
-0.2488574981689453,
0.4191528260707855,
-0.6737805604934692,
0.8348582983016968,
0.45689213275909424,
-0.17686545848846436,
0.190660297870636,
-0.4075120687484741,
-0.5315201282501221,
0.6104750037193298,
0.43941357731819153,
0.38296833634376526,
0.1897437870502472,
-0.21757051348686218,
-0.19360840320587158,
0.28731051087379456,
0.17057360708713531,
-0.8599520921707153,
0.08224654197692871,
0.31208866834640503,
-0.44531896710395813,
0.028210071846842766,
-0.04023126885294914,
-0.6683276891708374,
-0.06612258404493332,
-0.3742259740829468,
0.43608900904655457,
-0.18134424090385437,
0.006138908211141825,
-0.0008814304601401091,
-0.2740313708782196,
0.4000997841358185,
0.16020303964614868,
-0.4411924183368683,
0.2167189121246338,
0.267343670129776,
1.1079075336456299,
-0.3637092113494873,
0.14657242596149445,
-0.9164709448814392,
0.2766614556312561,
-0.29347124695777893,
0.6557496786117554,
-0.6406078934669495,
-0.4672694504261017,
-0.19216202199459076,
0.007595345377922058,
0.11735476553440094,
-0.4006929099559784,
0.4229460060596466,
-0.7197027206420898,
0.21489101648330688,
-0.4583576023578644,
-0.4329566955566406,
0.031985484063625336,
0.08594247698783875,
-0.2968255579471588,
0.7797632813453674,
0.08337502181529999,
-0.8970292806625366,
0.5904847383499146,
-0.7589371800422668,
-0.7636529207229614,
-0.08157647401094437,
-0.08149109035730362,
-0.09611675143241882,
0.11565285921096802,
0.48075374960899353,
0.2952119708061218,
-0.07758313417434692,
0.18365687131881714,
-0.010617773048579693,
-0.6146482229232788,
0.16101327538490295,
-0.5365063548088074,
0.6145505905151367,
0.3727629482746124,
-0.7329233288764954,
0.2953833341598511,
-0.826105535030365,
-0.04607433080673218,
-0.11607600748538971,
-0.36030110716819763,
-0.559555172920227,
-0.3397650420665741,
0.22579069435596466,
0.4178036153316498,
0.020343976095318794,
-0.5348073840141296,
-0.06058178469538689,
-0.6904798150062561,
0.4034624993801117,
0.5832697749137878,
-0.01979205757379532,
0.6686320900917053,
-0.13575275242328644,
0.4360819458961487,
0.3093402087688446,
-0.10811373591423035,
-0.1403106451034546,
-0.34769731760025024,
-0.7750751376152039,
-0.20843930542469025,
0.4865170121192932,
0.7618038654327393,
-1.2807174921035767,
0.35033345222473145,
-0.32581809163093567,
-0.05128736421465874,
-0.5983442664146423,
-0.05580558627843857,
0.735697329044342,
0.7288147211074829,
0.49034586548805237,
-0.35926732420921326,
-0.6966572403907776,
-0.8675677180290222,
-0.06532569229602814,
0.35267725586891174,
-0.31416401267051697,
0.3197914958000183,
0.033473700284957886,
-0.3445475101470947,
0.8975932002067566,
-0.5570566058158875,
-0.5139416456222534,
-0.07575830072164536,
-0.20265042781829834,
-0.13764116168022156,
0.3845256567001343,
0.27289703488349915,
-0.827165961265564,
-0.508743405342102,
-0.2842094302177429,
-0.5488244295120239,
-0.41125622391700745,
-0.07969113439321518,
-0.2178117334842682,
0.29821744561195374,
0.7706190943717957,
-0.3485237956047058,
0.6460057497024536,
0.27413445711135864,
-0.25043267011642456,
0.07583031803369522,
-0.04528643935918808,
0.049334246665239334,
-0.9648598432540894,
0.14724276959896088,
-0.24698525667190552,
-0.36717137694358826,
-0.9302912354469299,
-0.39886611700057983,
-0.09968164563179016,
-0.01919654756784439,
-0.8555566668510437,
0.663250207901001,
-0.7312173843383789,
-0.37659958004951477,
-0.5493930578231812,
0.3405696153640747,
0.040441934019327164,
0.31043297052383423,
0.35694965720176697,
1.11637282371521,
0.7100182771682739,
-1.0052614212036133,
-0.19116635620594025,
0.32520967721939087,
-0.22202996909618378,
0.8373135924339294,
-0.6719467043876648,
0.3377434015274048,
-0.20546840131282806,
0.48982933163642883,
-0.688179075717926,
0.00037785127642564476,
0.14137999713420868,
-0.390961229801178,
0.4330880343914032,
-0.31415799260139465,
0.027279088273644447,
-0.17971138656139374,
-0.14687781035900116,
0.5415762662887573,
0.38759633898735046,
-0.37206530570983887,
0.23370611667633057,
0.5864346623420715,
0.09494485706090927,
-0.834886908531189,
-1.1340394020080566,
0.20439738035202026,
-0.2269854098558426,
-0.3248721957206726,
0.7236803770065308,
-0.0340813472867012,
-0.0817725658416748,
-0.15014682710170746,
-0.3248833417892456,
-0.06301920115947723,
-0.03428920358419418,
0.14248228073120117,
-0.23444755375385284,
-0.2166164219379425,
-0.17712074518203735,
0.38893359899520874,
-0.4333842396736145,
-0.3271554410457611,
-0.5695380568504333,
0.4205119013786316,
0.21618232131004333,
-0.15974923968315125,
-0.8515943884849548,
0.37732794880867004,
0.6494672298431396,
0.0443897619843483,
0.43178582191467285,
0.7833991050720215,
-0.4557390809059143,
0.23094388842582703,
-0.5303432941436768,
-0.34703585505485535,
-0.49954384565353394,
0.04195941239595413,
-0.5876461267471313,
-0.9018958210945129,
0.3423285186290741,
0.025660503655672073,
-0.29935845732688904,
0.06903938949108124,
0.5753191113471985,
0.4843348562717438,
0.758701503276825,
0.4734785258769989,
-0.2774129807949066,
0.7771574854850769,
-0.25389617681503296,
-0.1423962563276291,
-1.1794482469558716,
0.06866074353456497,
-0.04466686770319939,
-0.5725924372673035,
-0.4412554204463959,
-0.7227807641029358,
0.3082205355167389,
-0.09537301957607269,
-0.012943660840392113,
0.0232369527220726,
-0.7192351818084717,
0.5127276182174683,
0.7348549962043762,
0.023232540115714073,
0.1197948232293129,
-0.18869136273860931,
-0.10338647663593292,
-0.06864335387945175,
-0.6889823079109192,
-0.1362912654876709,
1.0295650959014893,
-0.07631361484527588,
0.5962024331092834,
-0.1001562550663948,
0.5670402646064758,
0.3427697718143463,
-0.039261799305677414,
-0.8231646418571472,
0.5810123085975647,
-0.19007568061351776,
-0.4659897983074188,
-0.20842531323432922,
-0.22779254615306854,
-0.8647945523262024,
0.1979592889547348,
0.12004082649946213,
-0.6819124817848206,
0.4745999574661255,
0.20461790263652802,
-0.5147476196289062,
-0.016038425266742706,
-0.6379129886627197,
0.6201580762863159,
0.055339157581329346,
-0.39197486639022827,
0.08824638277292252,
-1.1451047658920288,
0.22252650558948517,
0.2817586064338684,
-0.04897858574986458,
0.08787193894386292,
-0.29644259810447693,
0.6797481775283813,
-0.3778282403945923,
0.5550870895385742,
-0.7478496432304382,
0.0839376375079155,
0.3067443072795868,
-0.1758253127336502,
0.180703803896904,
0.07953963428735733,
0.06577777862548828,
0.34359246492385864,
0.011739038862287998,
-0.3174636662006378,
-0.594672441482544,
0.7349247932434082,
-0.4909590184688568,
-0.523308515548706,
-0.4367614686489105,
-0.5228466391563416,
-0.19026443362236023,
0.30909040570259094,
0.438904345035553,
0.5247740149497986,
-0.05386766418814659,
0.3167465925216675,
0.8126928210258484,
-0.1655428409576416,
0.5219341516494751,
0.24325324594974518,
0.1122186928987503,
-0.5143110156059265,
0.7083352208137512,
0.2279938906431198,
0.49156129360198975,
0.6197798252105713,
0.18348181247711182,
-0.3789280354976654,
-0.5081381797790527,
-0.6717241406440735,
0.013249170035123825,
-0.6302827596664429,
-0.272759348154068,
-0.9226186275482178,
-0.17057561874389648,
-0.5149048566818237,
-0.4553042948246002,
-0.47511929273605347,
-0.6012668013572693,
-0.1875356137752533,
0.10362216085195541,
0.26579803228378296,
0.2609865069389343,
-0.1814085841178894,
0.8269025087356567,
-0.40692541003227234,
0.6571125984191895,
0.10460031777620316,
0.28575700521469116,
-0.042263880372047424,
-0.5607752203941345,
-0.0692988857626915,
0.07895136624574661,
0.030500119552016258,
-0.770836591720581,
0.42213213443756104,
0.39049750566482544,
0.37094825506210327,
0.7764976024627686,
0.47498032450675964,
0.9629082679748535,
-0.5815777778625488,
0.8418428897857666,
-0.21196529269218445,
-1.1973692178726196,
0.9128431677818298,
0.03368734195828438,
0.9308083653450012,
0.6882107257843018,
0.11203445494174957,
-0.511293351650238,
-0.1525919884443283,
-0.2533358037471771,
-1.0536890029907227,
1.1057438850402832,
0.2703855633735657,
-0.05840928107500076,
-0.06162016838788986,
0.33378198742866516,
0.009914546273648739,
0.41817906498908997,
-0.29429903626441956,
-0.48927435278892517,
-0.49126267433166504,
0.08700565993785858,
-0.13934628665447235,
-0.4131573438644409,
-0.14758427441120148,
-0.2882014811038971,
0.6088290810585022,
-0.23703385889530182,
0.6921783089637756,
0.6885930299758911,
-0.4791029095649719,
0.03312160074710846,
0.3233546316623688,
1.1635841131210327,
0.30574503540992737,
-0.2462247759103775,
0.20843558013439178,
0.26547572016716003,
-0.5288910865783691,
0.12975411117076874,
0.02911730483174324,
-0.5172021985054016,
0.11278179287910461,
-0.0764358639717102,
1.1506779193878174,
0.5386502146720886,
-0.45764076709747314,
0.4467793405056,
-0.14443059265613556,
0.12321885675191879,
-0.14801640808582306,
-0.11327442526817322,
-0.20795086026191711,
0.12353755533695221,
0.3135860860347748,
-0.08479723334312439,
0.40713930130004883,
-0.2352069616317749,
0.6462182402610779,
0.49436938762664795,
-0.5708011984825134,
-0.22071164846420288,
0.8893383145332336,
0.04064516723155975,
-0.1628471165895462,
0.2520327866077423,
-0.08946539461612701,
-0.5698018670082092,
0.22855007648468018,
0.6339119076728821,
1.0038625001907349,
-0.38747715950012207,
-0.09438683092594147,
0.1173761710524559,
0.04331178218126297,
0.07159213721752167,
0.3234947621822357,
-0.5996728539466858,
-0.5219746828079224,
-0.2771289646625519,
-0.6826273798942566,
-0.21767576038837433,
0.055013880133628845,
-0.8692446351051331,
0.12328250706195831,
-0.3159283697605133,
-0.4193825125694275,
-0.22829203307628632,
-0.19387072324752808,
-0.5684541463851929,
0.31414666771888733,
0.1710214465856552,
0.7356332540512085,
-0.5633583664894104,
0.8832072019577026,
0.6215326189994812,
-0.10979687422513962,
-0.022305050864815712,
0.5044851303100586,
0.3040824830532074,
-0.5725963711738586,
0.6382302045822144,
0.4483596086502075,
-0.2078433483839035,
0.2330894023180008,
-0.2177547663450241,
-1.2190159559249878,
1.2086176872253418,
0.3282613158226013,
-0.41615647077560425,
-0.13423378765583038,
-0.12770269811153412,
0.26604214310646057,
-0.35688167810440063,
0.26602810621261597,
0.5336801409721375,
0.32396936416625977,
0.5171359181404114,
-1.0249909162521362,
0.204604834318161,
0.12617921829223633,
0.28956139087677,
-0.026647578924894333,
-0.5334505438804626,
0.49182024598121643,
0.03692935034632683,
-0.41543325781822205,
-0.30514922738075256,
0.8512656092643738,
0.03392812982201576,
0.570339024066925,
0.5666038393974304,
0.4399178922176361,
0.5754611492156982,
-0.012085874564945698,
1.0754657983779907,
-0.44923803210258484,
-0.26653823256492615,
1.076216697692871,
-0.21458661556243896,
0.8220587968826294,
0.6579351425170898,
-0.014175971038639545,
0.3305770456790924,
0.46767258644104004,
0.7149574756622314,
1.1245242357254028,
0.049015071243047714,
-0.18789717555046082,
0.012829841114580631,
-0.3014494776725769,
-0.5211817622184753,
0.6263145208358765,
0.5133854150772095,
-0.1009313240647316,
-0.04797884076833725,
0.4669373333454132,
-0.002507512690499425,
-0.185216024518013,
-0.4162461459636688,
0.9626870155334473,
0.31373685598373413,
-0.6397976279258728,
0.9425856471061707,
-0.19881391525268555,
1.1798605918884277,
-0.48872464895248413,
0.38101333379745483,
-0.12846504151821136,
0.16424044966697693,
-0.008639039471745491,
-0.3893328607082367,
0.7127251625061035,
-0.1188432052731514,
-0.4203035533428192,
-0.32995840907096863,
0.9721897840499878,
-0.5840791463851929,
-0.17863112688064575,
0.31653276085853577,
0.5216068625450134,
0.17391663789749146,
-0.23856334388256073,
-0.5789798498153687,
0.23859421908855438,
-0.25248420238494873,
-0.32013028860092163,
0.542824387550354,
0.3594239056110382,
-0.00870366208255291,
0.625128984451294,
0.6172394752502441,
0.07277919352054596,
0.11258214712142944,
0.20269398391246796,
0.9461719393730164,
-0.4972875714302063,
-0.8300802111625671,
-0.746610164642334,
0.4094439744949341,
-0.11467569321393967,
-0.0834035873413086,
0.5542011260986328,
0.38253724575042725,
0.8981629610061646,
-0.009615898132324219,
0.643939733505249,
0.019541500136256218,
0.28980374336242676,
-0.657622218132019,
0.9025387167930603,
-0.611274003982544,
0.01024516113102436,
-0.5517971515655518,
-0.6482720971107483,
-0.28634974360466003,
0.7978969812393188,
-0.34843018651008606,
0.04374365881085396,
0.5529516935348511,
0.5666665434837341,
-0.01989816688001156,
-0.3066115379333496,
0.6909635663032532,
0.020206281915307045,
0.08500254154205322,
0.49234944581985474,
0.21032637357711792,
-0.5566405653953552,
0.28675806522369385,
-0.2858639359474182,
-0.20537032186985016,
-0.3427439332008362,
-0.7957141399383545,
-0.9078925251960754,
-0.6354082822799683,
-0.39141738414764404,
-0.2412472665309906,
0.1924116462469101,
0.8422549962997437,
0.9961138963699341,
-0.8986668586730957,
0.06525466591119766,
0.0019061298808082938,
0.16319742798805237,
-0.3062904477119446,
-0.2986104488372803,
0.2694765627384186,
-0.20947082340717316,
-0.6598782539367676,
0.763593316078186,
0.4539025127887726,
0.04708602651953697,
-0.15533016622066498,
-0.1375942826271057,
-0.5164493322372437,
0.21386724710464478,
0.8128328919410706,
0.1898985207080841,
-1.032466173171997,
-0.32325479388237,
-0.06220502033829689,
0.1870020180940628,
0.21396087110042572,
0.8281809687614441,
-1.1822776794433594,
0.6455734372138977,
0.4225445091724396,
0.9230936169624329,
0.5637704730033875,
0.2739394009113312,
0.616141676902771,
-1.1271494626998901,
0.6182827353477478,
0.10072921961545944,
0.11408369988203049,
0.47181999683380127,
-0.5273622870445251,
0.27956873178482056,
0.4447420537471771,
-0.542425274848938,
-0.9716881513595581,
0.3177272379398346,
-1.0474567413330078,
-0.1086781695485115,
1.1266522407531738,
0.048368703573942184,
-0.3429267108440399,
-0.397354394197464,
-0.17013095319271088,
0.44482189416885376,
-0.6080396771430969,
0.4827251136302948,
0.4722166657447815,
-0.2394990622997284,
-0.3108123242855072,
-0.6209791302680969,
0.7809385061264038,
0.3177225589752197,
-0.5036375522613525,
0.07143867760896683,
0.5375570058822632,
0.17413222789764404,
0.14246876537799835,
1.0131319761276245,
0.16616190969944,
0.14905205368995667,
0.06383965909481049,
-0.23529526591300964,
-0.0771036148071289,
-0.3803851306438446,
-0.5008280277252197,
0.05822033807635307,
-0.328579306602478,
-0.502335786819458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10174v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10174v1
|
On the Effects of Fine-tuning Language Models for Text-Based Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-04-15T23:05:57 | 2024-04-15T23:05:57 |
Mauricio Gruppi, Soham Dan, Keerthiram Murugesan, Subhajit Chaudhury
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text-based reinforcement learning involves an agent interacting with a
fictional environment using observed text and admissible actions in natural
language to complete a task. Previous works have shown that agents can succeed
in text-based interactive environments even in the complete absence of semantic
understanding or other linguistic capabilities. The success of these agents in
playing such games suggests that semantic understanding may not be important
for the task. This raises an important question about the benefits of LMs in
guiding the agents through the game states. In this work, we show that rich
semantic understanding leads to efficient training of text-based RL agents.
Moreover, we describe the occurrence of semantic degeneration as a consequence
of inappropriate fine-tuning of language models in text-based reinforcement
learning (TBRL). Specifically, we describe the shift in the semantic
representation of words in the LM, as well as how it affects the performance of
the agent in tasks that are semantically similar to the training games. We
believe these results may help develop better strategies to fine-tune agents in
text-based RL scenarios.
|
[
-0.2303217649459839,
-1.0585205554962158,
0.5367639660835266,
-0.06726796180009842,
-0.15321004390716553,
-0.07970046997070312,
-0.4887000620365143,
-0.4623917043209076,
-0.31419482827186584,
0.8726006150245667,
-0.7377748489379883,
-0.41939422488212585,
-0.6353528499603271,
0.20542816817760468,
0.04219984635710716,
1.550926923751831,
-0.102195605635643,
-0.0438593365252018,
0.04785925894975662,
-0.085283562541008,
-0.7216389775276184,
0.017578832805156708,
-0.8341785073280334,
-0.9811319708824158,
0.6602578163146973,
0.4413227438926697,
0.8985725045204163,
0.6652379035949707,
0.283938467502594,
0.42784079909324646,
-0.29610204696655273,
0.4172050654888153,
-0.9632512331008911,
0.43464234471321106,
-0.6868236660957336,
-0.5141703486442566,
-0.0731382891535759,
-0.08213014900684357,
0.6337952613830566,
0.39248785376548767,
0.052075859159231186,
-0.25169333815574646,
0.13250529766082764,
0.8463627696037292,
-0.4508480131626129,
0.3088422417640686,
-0.877242386341095,
0.21585673093795776,
0.37481555342674255,
-0.4504314363002777,
-0.48236215114593506,
0.04481275752186775,
0.23543809354305267,
-0.9576078057289124,
0.1489003449678421,
-0.10675379633903503,
1.1752078533172607,
0.647907555103302,
-0.3651954233646393,
-0.4240056574344635,
-0.8611019253730774,
0.8830362558364868,
-0.4959701895713806,
0.2618910074234009,
0.4864403009414673,
0.2658160626888275,
-0.39744505286216736,
-0.20522046089172363,
-0.46861040592193604,
-0.49206867814064026,
-0.1610674411058426,
0.09059210866689682,
0.16603513062000275,
0.39949938654899597,
0.362466037273407,
0.09151234477758408,
-0.22866351902484894,
0.3859027326107025,
-0.2183040827512741,
-0.08625537157058716,
0.5361589789390564,
0.34375447034835815,
0.3019196391105652,
-0.006823317147791386,
-0.37687841057777405,
-0.37318453192710876,
-0.4311620891094208,
0.16123631596565247,
0.05595628172159195,
0.5786159634590149,
-0.07045242190361023,
0.5456036925315857,
-0.1577414870262146,
0.7987570762634277,
0.020430337637662888,
-0.13594721257686615,
-0.11845260113477707,
-0.18834078311920166,
-0.3689165413379669,
0.0897226482629776,
0.394359827041626,
0.32129696011543274,
0.6778624653816223,
-0.4934706389904022,
-0.4829120337963104,
0.24212078750133514,
0.33820292353630066,
-0.8017666935920715,
-0.0916961207985878,
0.1120377629995346,
-0.39329975843429565,
-0.3609900176525116,
-0.13308945298194885,
-0.3822292983531952,
-0.5620105862617493,
-0.4819132685661316,
0.7847425937652588,
-0.7997491955757141,
-0.14763489365577698,
0.38889414072036743,
-0.5329405665397644,
0.23637008666992188,
0.3249918222427368,
-1.0825376510620117,
0.2783271372318268,
0.6280004382133484,
0.3594793379306793,
-0.0017836584011092782,
-0.5163252949714661,
-0.6529734134674072,
0.2465580850839615,
-0.2897896468639374,
0.7193012237548828,
-0.540702223777771,
-0.3676772713661194,
0.04249129444360733,
0.06461749225854874,
-0.33877551555633545,
-0.5654358863830566,
0.2683148980140686,
-0.5967445969581604,
0.03562897443771362,
0.07590655237436295,
-0.7017803192138672,
-0.1373225748538971,
0.480635404586792,
-0.5152910351753235,
0.6815891861915588,
-0.22750580310821533,
-0.42723938822746277,
0.5418710112571716,
-0.43923336267471313,
-0.5277295708656311,
-0.1669926643371582,
0.10293485224246979,
-0.33994820713996887,
0.22300292551517487,
0.05889467895030975,
0.6004156470298767,
0.13632826507091522,
-0.0801917240023613,
-0.06365199387073517,
-0.594480574131012,
0.5172855257987976,
-0.3660033047199249,
0.1690770834684372,
0.1279410570859909,
-0.3629745841026306,
0.156180739402771,
-0.5529211759567261,
0.2648184895515442,
-0.03411022573709488,
-0.42386531829833984,
-0.7482525706291199,
0.3236044943332672,
-0.0811070054769516,
0.2609069049358368,
0.07174240052700043,
-0.3371276259422302,
-0.03477199375629425,
-0.9609230160713196,
0.174508199095726,
0.6105679869651794,
0.14860408008098602,
0.5713903903961182,
-0.49058297276496887,
0.23525036871433258,
-0.011968309059739113,
-0.05749386548995972,
-0.22109584510326385,
-0.039801545441150665,
-0.7535778880119324,
-0.19100402295589447,
0.23916444182395935,
0.48749762773513794,
-0.9525066018104553,
0.16907276213169098,
-0.07130858302116394,
-0.2877916991710663,
-0.34182488918304443,
0.15897373855113983,
0.6358270645141602,
0.21506500244140625,
0.5122846961021423,
0.07477278262376785,
0.014411813579499722,
-0.6431035399436951,
-0.6516656875610352,
0.025496432557702065,
0.34489789605140686,
0.46022161841392517,
0.6510928869247437,
-0.4212949872016907,
0.809561550617218,
-0.35426241159439087,
-0.4444807767868042,
-0.590957760810852,
0.11868916451931,
-0.32830876111984253,
0.4134371876716614,
0.2031785547733307,
-0.8058198690414429,
-0.32457828521728516,
0.24168120324611664,
-0.42962270975112915,
0.11011792719364166,
-0.31351804733276367,
-0.05768652260303497,
0.45972639322280884,
0.6674691438674927,
-0.47338077425956726,
0.3861706852912903,
0.4124109148979187,
-0.7971835732460022,
0.2504584789276123,
-0.7683519124984741,
0.17633849382400513,
-0.6589266657829285,
-0.2858441472053528,
0.04190340265631676,
-0.3640139698982239,
-0.634553849697113,
0.1410849243402481,
0.037884294986724854,
-0.01856807991862297,
-0.2706131339073181,
0.8046554923057556,
-0.1704905480146408,
0.07523660361766815,
-0.5283672213554382,
0.6249373555183411,
0.055307142436504364,
0.4787081480026245,
0.30614981055259705,
0.605474591255188,
0.21560662984848022,
-1.0474621057510376,
-0.16954036056995392,
0.22544269263744354,
-0.054566752165555954,
0.3049330413341522,
-0.6398445963859558,
-0.2877395451068878,
-0.36247217655181885,
-0.03408992290496826,
-0.6070079207420349,
0.03793647512793541,
-0.005717672873288393,
-0.3513593077659607,
0.3717055022716522,
0.2527371942996979,
-0.3481805920600891,
0.19467346370220184,
-0.1971697360277176,
0.04272296652197838,
0.30926594138145447,
-0.3409433662891388,
0.3184853196144104,
0.25473567843437195,
0.33264851570129395,
-0.49293938279151917,
-0.7643703818321228,
-0.23963502049446106,
-0.18081651628017426,
-0.27808818221092224,
0.47633278369903564,
0.08712586015462875,
-0.35771819949150085,
0.21922460198402405,
0.0010514919413253665,
-0.09021368622779846,
0.4015829861164093,
0.1305086463689804,
-0.11962302029132843,
-0.004071616102010012,
0.6014151573181152,
0.2704089283943176,
-0.2235940545797348,
-0.18152856826782227,
-0.14269672334194183,
0.3404577076435089,
0.04692566767334938,
0.14515173435211182,
-0.36674338579177856,
0.1223381981253624,
0.2942714989185333,
-0.35768193006515503,
1.0702320337295532,
0.40190255641937256,
-0.11973070353269577,
-0.8025972843170166,
-0.08846938610076904,
-0.33474892377853394,
-0.47229382395744324,
0.658536434173584,
-0.35324278473854065,
-1.1517714262008667,
0.500512421131134,
-0.205436110496521,
-0.021853508427739143,
0.5990041494369507,
0.594476580619812,
-0.1749427169561386,
0.949511706829071,
0.8750788569450378,
0.3052287697792053,
0.7335708141326904,
-0.1477620005607605,
-0.25672006607055664,
-0.46033790707588196,
-0.29402127861976624,
-0.6148693561553955,
-0.25374698638916016,
-0.7636948227882385,
-0.3390524089336395,
-0.0821857750415802,
-0.06383497267961502,
-0.5901543498039246,
0.23634782433509827,
-0.2272413820028305,
0.6770591735839844,
0.22868679463863373,
0.39915475249290466,
0.3441595733165741,
-0.017155811190605164,
-0.32012706995010376,
-0.17131727933883667,
-0.7560415267944336,
-0.4820738434791565,
0.5363134145736694,
0.4832611680030823,
0.9420897960662842,
0.05188818275928497,
0.7036741971969604,
0.3500392436981201,
-0.202723428606987,
-0.7916034460067749,
0.44853994250297546,
-0.23541609942913055,
-0.4445144832134247,
-0.6597038507461548,
-0.5205582976341248,
-1.1485778093338013,
0.26048699021339417,
-0.4505075216293335,
-0.5817903280258179,
-0.025806725025177002,
0.10735928267240524,
-0.13486742973327637,
0.09739554673433304,
-0.653078556060791,
1.2074915170669556,
-0.145844966173172,
-0.4356725513935089,
-0.885369598865509,
-0.42531976103782654,
0.10191619396209717,
0.158607617020607,
0.11422908306121826,
-0.11126922816038132,
-0.18708980083465576,
0.4697857201099396,
-0.36368754506111145,
0.8783936500549316,
-0.2518373727798462,
-0.34767189621925354,
0.024015704169869423,
0.16162341833114624,
0.6335863471031189,
0.009696557186543941,
0.03627932816743851,
-0.4536336362361908,
0.1903144270181656,
-0.34579670429229736,
-0.6850406527519226,
0.7060490250587463,
-0.8659403324127197,
-0.29700079560279846,
-0.3477996587753296,
-0.7792982459068298,
-0.4031582772731781,
0.03449593111872673,
-0.06392114609479904,
0.4484960436820984,
-0.4872639775276184,
-0.041113946586847305,
1.1678135395050049,
-0.6846997737884521,
0.1879591941833496,
0.8146262168884277,
-0.1025569811463356,
-0.01935887522995472,
1.042507529258728,
-0.027501467615365982,
0.5983847379684448,
0.6138349771499634,
0.06664126366376877,
-0.2831103503704071,
-0.4463281035423279,
-0.38265514373779297,
0.2161063849925995,
-0.6238337755203247,
-0.09565627574920654,
-0.3435436189174652,
0.04329625144600868,
0.21970170736312866,
-0.08453597873449326,
-0.15728361904621124,
-0.2827724814414978,
-0.3724845051765442,
-0.004266906529664993,
0.6101983189582825,
0.8818768858909607,
0.10528075695037842,
0.3843115270137787,
-0.720737874507904,
0.30101582407951355,
0.08922254294157028,
0.477583646774292,
-0.06932394206523895,
-0.5751521587371826,
-0.6842607855796814,
0.10320284962654114,
-0.11906959861516953,
-0.7104997038841248,
0.10303932428359985,
0.4710029065608978,
0.4567882716655731,
0.08317197114229202,
0.024055639281868935,
0.5965684056282043,
-0.5856849551200867,
0.5181371569633484,
-0.29511162638664246,
-0.7810432314872742,
0.5550230741500854,
-0.4873102307319641,
0.5264899730682373,
0.7316824793815613,
0.02786240354180336,
-0.7140928506851196,
-0.773918092250824,
-0.44248074293136597,
-0.5728927254676819,
1.0682713985443115,
0.0026813813019543886,
0.3389798402786255,
-0.08874139934778214,
0.49255135655403137,
0.16733017563819885,
-0.014794089831411839,
-0.8017430901527405,
-0.12192939966917038,
0.03476971387863159,
-0.186241015791893,
-0.33162763714790344,
-0.2468942403793335,
0.1476016342639923,
-0.08847349882125854,
0.9885561466217041,
-0.03570519760251045,
0.1447843462228775,
0.23575906455516815,
-0.5401588678359985,
-0.15379683673381805,
0.39899393916130066,
0.8214670419692993,
0.18226805329322815,
-0.063734270632267,
-0.03700222820043564,
0.32090339064598083,
-0.173775777220726,
-0.04295735061168671,
0.12501314282417297,
-0.1946292668581009,
-0.2041485607624054,
0.4542080760002136,
1.1165403127670288,
0.5766021609306335,
-1.0494624376296997,
0.14881229400634766,
-0.1946777105331421,
-0.24233825504779816,
0.1012696772813797,
0.485885351896286,
-0.19090045988559723,
0.4295298457145691,
-0.04016375541687012,
0.017888540402054787,
-0.0972973182797432,
-0.6439786553382874,
0.38715630769729614,
0.5498870015144348,
-0.8684607148170471,
0.07014051079750061,
0.40593668818473816,
0.10960202664136887,
-0.29420265555381775,
0.32215526700019836,
-0.3762659430503845,
-0.5900557041168213,
0.5878293514251709,
0.7323309779167175,
0.6753184795379639,
0.13845179975032806,
0.41638749837875366,
0.08566995710134506,
0.3769483268260956,
-0.06439223140478134,
0.09908729791641235,
-0.11341502517461777,
-0.8196948766708374,
-0.6880835294723511,
-0.6078724265098572,
-0.24421550333499908,
-0.13154999911785126,
-0.23933333158493042,
0.20332905650138855,
-0.3245093822479248,
0.10882104188203812,
-0.22844035923480988,
0.2583272159099579,
-0.5501695275306702,
0.41255059838294983,
0.11304253339767456,
0.8685520887374878,
-0.6176586151123047,
0.7316292524337769,
0.7664281725883484,
-0.37833431363105774,
-0.9798877239227295,
0.1345917284488678,
-0.41178950667381287,
-0.532787561416626,
0.8556508421897888,
0.01452894601970911,
-0.3165332078933716,
0.15281015634536743,
-0.1820681095123291,
-0.41489046812057495,
0.8539813756942749,
0.2790319621562958,
-0.288372278213501,
0.09621087461709976,
0.35791563987731934,
0.9261450171470642,
-0.15373988449573517,
0.24800200760364532,
0.44645988941192627,
0.33753469586372375,
-0.3073078393936157,
-0.8970937728881836,
-0.010067138820886612,
0.18843713402748108,
0.14293542504310608,
0.4795703887939453,
-0.5757696032524109,
0.5566127300262451,
-0.19063323736190796,
-0.1739395260810852,
0.07078544050455093,
0.648504912853241,
-0.06672839820384979,
0.19246740639209747,
0.39115577936172485,
0.536811351776123,
0.5961244702339172,
-0.03744225203990936,
1.0605299472808838,
-0.21348486840724945,
0.5917927026748657,
0.6998686790466309,
0.05776660144329071,
0.6840266585350037,
0.25758546590805054,
0.4097255766391754,
0.5970156192779541,
0.42668694257736206,
0.2969057857990265,
0.7463471293449402,
0.2717716097831726,
-0.13176478445529938,
-0.5179408192634583,
-0.1652427464723587,
-0.1593930721282959,
0.4542014002799988,
0.5354524850845337,
-0.3814694881439209,
-0.6795132756233215,
0.33905109763145447,
-0.11369682103395462,
0.7399404048919678,
-0.6934050917625427,
1.0390957593917847,
0.050301071256399155,
-0.570006251335144,
0.5690696239471436,
0.18533633649349213,
0.7342680096626282,
-0.6297545433044434,
-0.16827896237373352,
-0.08649619668722153,
0.6763010025024414,
-0.04696536436676979,
-0.6946882605552673,
0.4651639759540558,
-0.02947647124528885,
-0.23338189721107483,
-0.36347752809524536,
1.054213047027588,
-0.6384262442588806,
-0.122064508497715,
0.4467754662036896,
0.6034542322158813,
0.1217922493815422,
0.0029566860757768154,
-0.9543578028678894,
-0.019033445045351982,
-0.11878303438425064,
-0.23322607576847076,
0.4878038465976715,
0.9640849828720093,
0.02330024354159832,
0.7077150344848633,
0.05224761366844177,
-0.054119110107421875,
-0.35536810755729675,
-0.1623152196407318,
0.6048700213432312,
-0.8961524963378906,
-0.40904173254966736,
-0.959324300289154,
0.4066477417945862,
0.10784675180912018,
-0.32376447319984436,
0.6395214796066284,
0.352140873670578,
0.8140111565589905,
-0.18302814662456512,
0.5540794730186462,
0.05132315307855606,
0.40480291843414307,
-0.8805187940597534,
0.7882999181747437,
-0.7900140285491943,
0.18110615015029907,
-0.21902145445346832,
-0.5802816152572632,
-0.17701150476932526,
0.6493277549743652,
-0.36133819818496704,
0.06572210043668747,
0.6376180052757263,
0.7905845046043396,
0.1448715627193451,
-0.1867363154888153,
0.6154913902282715,
0.29170864820480347,
0.05210825800895691,
0.4916406273841858,
0.8027885556221008,
-0.311601847410202,
0.5019489526748657,
0.09998190402984619,
0.07753157615661621,
-0.1365259736776352,
-0.7302431464195251,
-1.3098857402801514,
-0.5145596861839294,
-0.2126973271369934,
-0.3852817714214325,
0.5834248661994934,
1.043663740158081,
0.12704944610595703,
-0.5623159408569336,
-0.010200127959251404,
-0.3582143187522888,
0.4459928274154663,
-0.3474750220775604,
-0.2171173393726349,
0.1729270964860916,
-0.8597641587257385,
-0.7117769718170166,
0.2950379252433777,
0.16449064016342163,
-0.02699405699968338,
-0.12990529835224152,
-0.42168378829956055,
-0.11011233180761337,
0.17012086510658264,
0.6817330121994019,
0.32017308473587036,
-0.6150022149085999,
-0.5942729711532593,
-0.03575466200709343,
-0.3516893982887268,
-0.2802172303199768,
0.5418946743011475,
-1.1791276931762695,
0.3257902264595032,
0.38012850284576416,
0.7064048647880554,
0.439582496881485,
-0.20351482927799225,
0.718161404132843,
-0.4568941295146942,
0.3104451298713684,
0.1044909879565239,
-0.23155081272125244,
0.19560657441616058,
-0.20093722641468048,
0.20011313259601593,
-0.07203610241413116,
-0.7312756180763245,
-0.5862894058227539,
0.29424190521240234,
-0.6460791230201721,
-0.6417121887207031,
1.2471492290496826,
0.11727394163608551,
-0.22292034327983856,
-0.18717966973781586,
-0.4534567892551422,
0.42702311277389526,
-0.37266796827316284,
0.6484123468399048,
0.6487388610839844,
-0.0038752418477088213,
0.05328473448753357,
-0.6694207787513733,
1.0645476579666138,
0.6447270512580872,
-0.5933998823165894,
0.32991039752960205,
0.40414828062057495,
0.05398928374052048,
-0.22332020103931427,
0.3110872805118561,
0.28335198760032654,
0.2522202432155609,
-0.23320582509040833,
-0.07950079441070557,
-0.06768517196178436,
-0.2713685631752014,
-0.4455496072769165,
-0.31583988666534424,
0.42456480860710144,
0.1656828224658966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10150v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10150v1
|
TabSQLify: Enhancing Reasoning Capabilities of LLMs Through Table Decomposition
| 2024-04-15T21:42:20 | 2024-04-15T21:42:20 |
Md Mahadi Hasan Nahid, Davood Rafiei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.IR
|
Table reasoning is a challenging task that requires understanding both
natural language questions and structured tabular data. Large language models
(LLMs) have shown impressive capabilities in natural language understanding and
generation, but they often struggle with large tables due to their limited
input length. In this paper, we propose TabSQLify, a novel method that
leverages text-to-SQL generation to decompose tables into smaller and relevant
sub-tables, containing only essential information for answering questions or
verifying statements, before performing the reasoning task. In our
comprehensive evaluation on four challenging datasets, our approach
demonstrates comparable or superior performance compared to prevailing methods
reliant on full tables as input. Moreover, our method can reduce the input
context length significantly, making it more scalable and efficient for
large-scale table reasoning applications. Our method performs remarkably well
on the WikiTQ benchmark, achieving an accuracy of 64.7%. Additionally, on the
TabFact benchmark, it achieves a high accuracy of 79.5%. These results surpass
other LLM-based baseline models on gpt-3.5-turbo (chatgpt). TabSQLify can
reduce the table size significantly alleviating the computational load on LLMs
when handling large tables without compromising performance.
|
[
-0.37093353271484375,
-1.0091617107391357,
0.6874609589576721,
0.01944851130247116,
-0.38535767793655396,
0.17138755321502686,
-0.3205565810203552,
-0.06633956730365753,
-0.029531994834542274,
0.7810002565383911,
-0.5630331039428711,
-0.6757359504699707,
0.0365452840924263,
-0.01031674537807703,
-0.4765986204147339,
0.9762282371520996,
0.07840295135974884,
-0.08878524601459503,
-0.7183979153633118,
0.07236050069332123,
-0.4685554504394531,
-0.28165730834007263,
-0.5101693868637085,
-0.42005661129951477,
0.4127322733402252,
0.5624080896377563,
0.6213725209236145,
0.7449046969413757,
0.4483315646648407,
0.23784811794757843,
-0.07531577348709106,
0.6110627055168152,
-0.6085957288742065,
0.3295923173427582,
-0.1631874144077301,
-0.5769473910331726,
-0.5069114565849304,
-0.6235220432281494,
0.631821870803833,
0.5975625514984131,
-0.3292723596096039,
0.5437411665916443,
0.10055521130561829,
0.8073483109474182,
-0.37012797594070435,
0.33479127287864685,
-0.9795870780944824,
0.20046958327293396,
-0.2503531873226166,
-0.17377352714538574,
-0.9461301565170288,
-0.5339494943618774,
-0.4656449258327484,
-0.48710018396377563,
0.16090388596057892,
0.25668519735336304,
0.8089780807495117,
0.4703559875488281,
-0.6369465589523315,
0.34329506754875183,
-0.8875910639762878,
0.35619446635246277,
-0.7851370573043823,
0.746982753276825,
0.06686240434646606,
0.4354173243045807,
-0.7064328193664551,
-0.9240009188652039,
-0.9372885227203369,
-0.37389492988586426,
-0.3484235405921936,
-0.1788046956062317,
-0.009127562865614891,
0.22979280352592468,
0.5929949879646301,
0.34115785360336304,
-1.0922659635543823,
-0.09323068708181381,
-0.1240190640091896,
-0.08393329381942749,
0.3319021761417389,
0.33705344796180725,
0.46554744243621826,
-0.1773330718278885,
-0.12945590913295746,
-0.06857357174158096,
-0.9151496291160583,
0.04060623049736023,
-0.21531982719898224,
0.32371512055397034,
0.45803093910217285,
0.7220529317855835,
-0.2949589490890503,
0.8275158405303955,
-0.11685502529144287,
-0.3334311842918396,
-0.07106795907020569,
-0.2256164699792862,
-0.6693059206008911,
-0.054775726050138474,
0.5951657295227051,
0.41815122961997986,
-0.046992335468530655,
-0.21991734206676483,
0.041870810091495514,
0.18088172376155853,
0.013688245788216591,
-0.5437161326408386,
-0.302334725856781,
0.40802350640296936,
-0.0625842958688736,
0.10867694020271301,
-0.3148292899131775,
-0.7296434640884399,
-0.614051878452301,
-0.1923794150352478,
0.2147429883480072,
-0.18883834779262543,
0.013690276071429253,
-0.12824787199497223,
0.055377233773469925,
0.28179797530174255,
0.46097785234451294,
-0.5891183614730835,
0.31792783737182617,
0.6675276160240173,
0.3870494067668915,
-0.17359678447246552,
0.047793611884117126,
-0.7196149230003357,
0.6000999808311462,
-0.5443527698516846,
0.8801317811012268,
-0.1347953975200653,
-0.21733589470386505,
-0.16246500611305237,
-0.12072445452213287,
0.12194418162107468,
-0.7226634621620178,
0.8002558350563049,
-0.4434700608253479,
-0.13713593780994415,
-0.46911826729774475,
-0.5009467601776123,
0.1340659260749817,
0.5155335664749146,
-0.8420930504798889,
1.1455531120300293,
0.1335030198097229,
-0.38707175850868225,
0.5248392224311829,
-0.7259168028831482,
-0.4684724509716034,
0.328237384557724,
-0.17853033542633057,
-0.40158072113990784,
-0.05386544018983841,
0.6141577959060669,
0.25572285056114197,
-0.49805164337158203,
0.5364435911178589,
-0.1847406029701233,
-0.12285255640745163,
0.3789488971233368,
-0.1178760901093483,
0.410661518573761,
0.1032678633928299,
-0.1229763925075531,
0.23148052394390106,
-0.5745284557342529,
0.3822459876537323,
0.04740458354353905,
-0.46201929450035095,
0.2015533596277237,
0.08519686013460159,
-0.12393645942211151,
0.1947277933359146,
-0.10649790614843369,
-0.5005039572715759,
0.18293286859989166,
-0.38282525539398193,
0.37536904215812683,
0.3981105387210846,
0.24454547464847565,
0.4285140931606293,
-0.1321672946214676,
0.4138571321964264,
-0.08560769259929657,
0.20613430440425873,
0.19342856109142303,
-0.09240398555994034,
-0.992280900478363,
-0.27466386556625366,
0.5523742437362671,
0.6749016642570496,
-1.1941531896591187,
0.21079841256141663,
-0.6254010796546936,
-0.5115235447883606,
-0.09553069621324539,
0.15646439790725708,
0.14141328632831573,
0.7838425636291504,
0.7260333895683289,
0.35540053248405457,
-0.6983036398887634,
-1.1508301496505737,
-0.6135849952697754,
-0.099639892578125,
-0.252206414937973,
0.11798398196697235,
0.3464483320713043,
-0.18086636066436768,
1.0062496662139893,
-0.6756967306137085,
-0.2780945301055908,
-0.7692422270774841,
-0.09755942225456238,
0.03231054171919823,
0.4784388542175293,
0.23207323253154755,
-0.502296507358551,
-0.6830714344978333,
0.2958909571170807,
-0.4984126389026642,
-0.11319655179977417,
-0.1533588021993637,
-0.3940958082675934,
0.17906521260738373,
0.5465878248214722,
-1.0531054735183716,
0.5545507073402405,
-0.006502059753984213,
-0.2470635175704956,
0.429135799407959,
0.1586829423904419,
0.0919790267944336,
-0.6855510473251343,
-0.0909612849354744,
-0.1967519223690033,
-0.5116261839866638,
-0.6322609782218933,
0.08332058042287827,
0.07481471449136734,
-0.2745586335659027,
-0.3276093006134033,
0.4411681890487671,
-0.4820958971977234,
-0.1209620013833046,
0.18223963677883148,
0.19628894329071045,
0.36066102981567383,
0.5086486339569092,
-0.31267049908638,
0.7957869172096252,
-0.047206658869981766,
-0.44525328278541565,
0.4943229556083679,
0.4385526776313782,
-0.2444155216217041,
0.16333460807800293,
-0.39672520756721497,
-0.021029427647590637,
-0.11721856147050858,
0.6857679486274719,
-1.116202712059021,
-0.47155866026878357,
0.13034124672412872,
-0.27225828170776367,
0.24108707904815674,
-0.1380835622549057,
-0.6077097654342651,
-0.5949693918228149,
-0.17979027330875397,
-0.12348920106887817,
0.44261330366134644,
-0.6401824355125427,
1.099249005317688,
0.5298428535461426,
-0.12517495453357697,
-0.6770106554031372,
-0.9616082310676575,
0.21809174120426178,
-0.190777987241745,
-0.6241769194602966,
0.47624945640563965,
0.09003368020057678,
-0.3957935869693756,
-0.04991663247346878,
-0.46208733320236206,
-0.17951269447803497,
-0.2327391654253006,
0.13099175691604614,
0.22778987884521484,
-0.18549083173274994,
0.4769156873226166,
0.4547363221645355,
0.21921667456626892,
0.06793814152479172,
-0.09482725709676743,
0.5989606976509094,
-0.11488520354032516,
-0.1194838285446167,
-0.2221929132938385,
0.27502915263175964,
0.5839186310768127,
-0.4028128683567047,
0.8434681296348572,
0.509956955909729,
-0.4307771325111389,
-0.6707025766372681,
-0.7953347563743591,
-0.22541838884353638,
-0.45692557096481323,
0.28492531180381775,
-0.25500500202178955,
-0.890833854675293,
0.6667772531509399,
-0.17381000518798828,
0.14785297214984894,
0.45146530866622925,
0.40398186445236206,
-0.0412871390581131,
0.8201977610588074,
0.07760030031204224,
0.3702147901058197,
0.18045085668563843,
0.028925593942403793,
0.4068462550640106,
-0.5929452776908875,
-0.37599697709083557,
-0.629152238368988,
-0.06447715312242508,
-0.279185026884079,
-0.8267555236816406,
0.42638444900512695,
-0.4259801208972931,
-0.15509328246116638,
0.0482470765709877,
-0.4972413182258606,
0.9082291722297668,
0.26232850551605225,
0.4496649503707886,
0.4991392493247986,
-0.009629388339817524,
0.003224545158445835,
-0.016300590708851814,
-0.6054260730743408,
-0.3539091646671295,
0.8315994143486023,
0.1096864640712738,
0.5605819821357727,
0.09463801234960556,
0.6186020970344543,
0.41003209352493286,
0.4737831652164459,
-0.6794542670249939,
1.0874141454696655,
-0.1389317810535431,
-0.7271780371665955,
-0.7047889232635498,
-0.738821268081665,
-0.6428105235099792,
0.31237998604774475,
-0.411287784576416,
-0.7536748647689819,
-0.11392898857593536,
0.38561180233955383,
-0.1492142528295517,
0.27413210272789,
-0.8784400224685669,
1.0000699758529663,
-0.0002396450290689245,
-0.5465816855430603,
0.1701526790857315,
-0.317533940076828,
0.6312289237976074,
0.14120398461818695,
0.11864619702100754,
-0.14525166153907776,
0.1990700662136078,
0.639817476272583,
-0.7964550256729126,
0.4510887861251831,
-0.288463830947876,
-0.06115959584712982,
0.5519607663154602,
0.3151250183582306,
0.7533433437347412,
0.2833969295024872,
0.06703880429267883,
-0.4162733554840088,
0.08538884669542313,
-0.1849491149187088,
-1.065726637840271,
0.6064397692680359,
-0.08205194771289825,
-0.708622932434082,
0.04032575711607933,
-0.5263057351112366,
-0.6470950245857239,
0.058333467692136765,
0.07605314254760742,
0.5353349447250366,
0.003976970445364714,
0.4727238416671753,
0.8396651148796082,
-0.2146439403295517,
0.1675029695034027,
0.1250281184911728,
-0.5861149430274963,
-0.3835291266441345,
0.5798037052154541,
0.17182105779647827,
-0.04353465512394905,
0.6696965098381042,
-0.025961503386497498,
-0.7070332765579224,
-0.6177564263343811,
-0.5237423181533813,
0.09993905574083328,
-0.800340473651886,
-0.5878387093544006,
-0.5801524519920349,
0.05512361228466034,
-0.3498876988887787,
0.14552421867847443,
-0.2885213792324066,
-0.6140184998512268,
0.1934918612241745,
-0.3600863814353943,
0.2318456768989563,
0.2732272148132324,
0.27781766653060913,
0.29447659850120544,
-0.8614526987075806,
0.4763375222682953,
0.5861294269561768,
0.26877152919769287,
-0.17558647692203522,
-0.2462567687034607,
-0.11019796878099442,
-0.16118794679641724,
0.0694928765296936,
-1.088334321975708,
0.3091258108615875,
0.24629178643226624,
0.6626430153846741,
-0.25897979736328125,
0.34406983852386475,
0.9996233582496643,
-0.5000122785568237,
0.7800710201263428,
-0.0739189088344574,
-1.1936668157577515,
0.6089910864830017,
-0.4175061881542206,
0.37897324562072754,
0.8566441535949707,
-0.07399314641952515,
-0.09810281544923782,
-0.29918035864830017,
-0.25855252146720886,
-1.060487151145935,
0.31308305263519287,
0.10397655516862869,
-0.2801629602909088,
0.20111089944839478,
0.4929477274417877,
0.011036652140319347,
0.09298235177993774,
-1.2687714099884033,
-0.05491520091891289,
0.07011781632900238,
-0.22354842722415924,
0.21961404383182526,
-0.3631143271923065,
-0.148405984044075,
-0.5702561736106873,
0.6670084595680237,
-0.14460359513759613,
0.23602400720119476,
0.05382239446043968,
-0.42701008915901184,
0.002120732329785824,
0.6203858852386475,
0.4405263662338257,
0.8095517158508301,
-0.04512723907828331,
0.2168082743883133,
0.5540673136711121,
-0.40047362446784973,
0.10491732507944107,
0.04487717151641846,
-0.10167807340621948,
0.11117944121360779,
0.11011821031570435,
0.6044992208480835,
-0.17895743250846863,
-0.8089054822921753,
0.17290812730789185,
-0.37145310640335083,
-0.12389153987169266,
-0.09856708347797394,
0.1677747666835785,
0.1930612176656723,
0.2717239558696747,
0.41844442486763,
-0.48425954580307007,
0.4562440812587738,
-0.36969855427742004,
0.14312943816184998,
0.3124031126499176,
0.06603662669658661,
0.3292868733406067,
0.48120009899139404,
0.03738940507173538,
-0.03577405959367752,
0.5962960720062256,
-0.3333745002746582,
-0.4801148772239685,
0.4535224437713623,
0.5226449966430664,
0.5042392015457153,
-0.12699545919895172,
0.3238344192504883,
0.4594116806983948,
0.5416812896728516,
-0.015567121095955372,
0.3130328059196472,
-0.15287424623966217,
-0.45033255219459534,
-0.7230822443962097,
-0.6230472922325134,
-0.4984753131866455,
0.37849992513656616,
-0.5331595540046692,
-0.04062460735440254,
-0.3542535603046417,
-0.34257999062538147,
-0.008993462659418583,
-0.08932963013648987,
-0.38398751616477966,
0.2775019705295563,
-0.06299613416194916,
0.7561474442481995,
-0.724976658821106,
0.6872579455375671,
0.5076175928115845,
-0.06119870766997337,
-1.2935060262680054,
-0.04247399792075157,
-0.37220919132232666,
-0.07373134046792984,
0.530734658241272,
-0.012517543509602547,
0.135935440659523,
-0.05941173806786537,
-0.6150688529014587,
-0.6188651323318481,
0.8747405409812927,
0.6374203562736511,
-0.48288285732269287,
-0.030284985899925232,
0.6209967136383057,
0.5414431691169739,
-0.022404184564948082,
0.00046524713980033994,
0.9874222874641418,
0.631283164024353,
0.05994149297475815,
-0.8908560276031494,
0.35910484194755554,
-0.20381084084510803,
-0.013026708737015724,
0.501064121723175,
-0.03157244995236397,
0.6148194670677185,
-0.03881083056330681,
-0.22059518098831177,
-0.3863433301448822,
0.6654458045959473,
0.3529873192310333,
0.2672334313392639,
0.4483150541782379,
0.4888339340686798,
0.8439639806747437,
-0.4833899140357971,
0.4840443432331085,
0.19076038897037506,
0.25965070724487305,
1.3773250579833984,
-0.431079626083374,
0.9666906595230103,
0.5326541066169739,
-0.3144511282444,
0.6706351637840271,
0.4019486904144287,
0.07935764640569687,
0.1756654977798462,
0.3781130611896515,
-0.2641434967517853,
-0.505013108253479,
-0.17791388928890228,
-0.3469313383102417,
0.5079610347747803,
0.662635862827301,
-0.1095910593867302,
-0.31732243299484253,
-0.0038958825170993805,
0.03540731593966484,
0.19618190824985504,
-0.3786031901836395,
0.7652950882911682,
-0.24904556572437286,
-0.8300765752792358,
0.6774672865867615,
-0.29987961053848267,
-0.14565691351890564,
-0.35553619265556335,
-0.13356377184391022,
-0.35006481409072876,
0.09784364700317383,
-0.44347530603408813,
-0.8229142427444458,
0.3241440951824188,
-0.06838978081941605,
-0.00786252599209547,
-0.12890015542507172,
0.9582386016845703,
-0.5386580228805542,
-0.1806444674730301,
-0.13280361890792847,
0.67130446434021,
-0.1657390147447586,
-0.1991584300994873,
-0.37592825293540955,
0.10425149649381638,
0.2767597734928131,
-0.2426021546125412,
0.10715922713279724,
0.5149363875389099,
-0.0719253271818161,
0.7654018998146057,
0.7912309765815735,
-0.16171856224536896,
0.0011433213949203491,
0.02086864598095417,
1.1284823417663574,
-0.5385180711746216,
-0.5584007501602173,
-0.9293079376220703,
0.6901482939720154,
-0.33686062693595886,
0.18079032003879547,
0.6553087830543518,
0.7702929377555847,
0.3535466194152832,
-0.46660149097442627,
0.4345102310180664,
0.048456259071826935,
0.5718063116073608,
-0.6156139373779297,
0.6645625829696655,
-0.4271708130836487,
0.4453813433647156,
-0.19526469707489014,
-0.9512613415718079,
-0.6677223443984985,
0.3532021641731262,
-0.34368425607681274,
-0.2611702084541321,
0.7326328158378601,
0.8106037974357605,
0.3334663510322571,
-0.1855333149433136,
0.17303583025932312,
0.27838075160980225,
0.4403790235519409,
0.4584275186061859,
0.8662530779838562,
-0.09697620570659637,
0.9559432864189148,
-0.0023282445035874844,
-0.01305566355586052,
-0.18111839890480042,
-0.7535467147827148,
-1.1574242115020752,
-0.3986622095108032,
-0.2498040795326233,
-0.3987463414669037,
-0.16644355654716492,
0.799165666103363,
0.38080957531929016,
-0.5493596792221069,
-0.055467598140239716,
-0.1760866641998291,
0.3098454177379608,
-0.033519331365823746,
-0.3098289370536804,
0.3855694830417633,
-0.1239619106054306,
-0.24290192127227783,
0.4099711775779724,
0.4203643202781677,
-0.07170290499925613,
-0.07206062227487564,
0.410348504781723,
-0.14255622029304504,
0.19389818608760834,
0.8773045539855957,
0.2064155787229538,
-0.7035803198814392,
-0.09768906235694885,
0.08168855309486389,
-0.020261285826563835,
0.23199595510959625,
0.5307341814041138,
-0.9346334934234619,
0.0402773842215538,
0.7045784592628479,
0.5921108722686768,
0.8688603043556213,
0.17947448790073395,
0.29625260829925537,
-0.738772988319397,
-0.0466754324734211,
0.45232129096984863,
0.3015962243080139,
0.28558608889579773,
-0.5008297562599182,
0.6697750091552734,
-0.21229195594787598,
-0.5365092158317566,
-1.3689415454864502,
0.24114911258220673,
-1.1909821033477783,
-0.1758485734462738,
1.0028254985809326,
0.08102505654096603,
-0.5858431458473206,
-0.14391671121120453,
-0.3849583566188812,
0.2959355115890503,
-0.33558642864227295,
0.5327021479606628,
0.37313592433929443,
-0.3418457508087158,
-0.44189298152923584,
-0.5036354660987854,
0.8270330429077148,
0.19156841933727264,
-1.4363160133361816,
0.48747602105140686,
0.6666385531425476,
0.016741186380386353,
0.17618758976459503,
0.4629644751548767,
-0.06292099505662918,
0.3299857974052429,
0.14716275036334991,
0.10000953823328018,
-0.14603950083255768,
-0.2511402666568756,
0.3694147765636444,
0.44887498021125793,
0.05949496105313301,
0.16620329022407532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10141v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10141v1
|
ANCHOR: LLM-driven News Subject Conditioning for Text-to-Image Synthesis
| 2024-04-15T21:19:10 | 2024-04-15T21:19:10 |
Aashish Anantha Ramakrishnan, Sharon X. Huang, Dongwon Lee
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM, 65D19
|
Text-to-Image (T2I) Synthesis has made tremendous strides in enhancing
synthesized image quality, but current datasets evaluate model performance only
on descriptive, instruction-based prompts. Real-world news image captions take
a more pragmatic approach, providing high-level situational and Named-Entity
(NE) information and limited physical object descriptions, making them
abstractive. To evaluate the ability of T2I models to capture intended subjects
from news captions, we introduce the Abstractive News Captions with High-level
cOntext Representation (ANCHOR) dataset, containing 70K+ samples sourced from 5
different news media organizations. With Large Language Models (LLM) achieving
success in language and commonsense reasoning tasks, we explore the ability of
different LLMs to identify and understand key subjects from abstractive
captions. Our proposed method Subject-Aware Finetuning (SAFE), selects and
enhances the representation of key subjects in synthesized images by leveraging
LLM-generated subject weights. It also adapts to the domain distribution of
news images and captions through custom Domain Fine-tuning, outperforming
current T2I baselines on ANCHOR. By launching the ANCHOR dataset, we hope to
motivate research in furthering the Natural Language Understanding (NLU)
capabilities of T2I models.
|
[
-0.32497477531433105,
-0.636968731880188,
0.7633802890777588,
0.2578328251838684,
-0.4881037175655365,
0.04514612257480621,
-0.3679324984550476,
-0.23913533985614777,
-0.2965558171272278,
0.353706955909729,
-0.5753663182258606,
-0.8078753352165222,
-0.42891374230384827,
0.17234420776367188,
-0.2815147638320923,
1.095970630645752,
-0.07629747688770294,
0.0852334126830101,
-0.36312052607536316,
-0.09698216617107391,
-0.4984092116355896,
-0.17675632238388062,
-0.6599533557891846,
0.007822033017873764,
0.41403454542160034,
0.6164628267288208,
0.6604612469673157,
0.7897016406059265,
0.4745248556137085,
0.11012855172157288,
0.09334270656108856,
0.08431589603424072,
-0.5994745492935181,
-0.12319999188184738,
-0.6303838491439819,
-0.2684049606323242,
-0.2362120896577835,
0.2309514880180359,
0.5743748545646667,
0.5718357563018799,
0.37836503982543945,
0.2327713966369629,
-0.001858615200035274,
0.7258434295654297,
-0.5710132122039795,
0.15019740164279938,
-0.8257954120635986,
0.07422313839197159,
0.16037924587726593,
-0.28687232732772827,
-0.6417208313941956,
-0.1535234898328781,
0.11527320742607117,
-0.7794878482818604,
0.4010082185268402,
0.24913324415683746,
0.9989556074142456,
0.47470200061798096,
-0.5049523711204529,
-0.004986650310456753,
-0.4674880802631378,
0.8653779625892639,
-0.6082525849342346,
0.40952473878860474,
0.39608466625213623,
0.08470961451530457,
-0.06686315685510635,
-0.4917720556259155,
-0.264268159866333,
-0.16159823536872864,
-0.1605512648820877,
0.16977861523628235,
0.08742240071296692,
-0.07419908046722412,
0.0627453625202179,
0.2944696247577667,
-0.3781128525733948,
0.046830758452415466,
-0.6783927083015442,
-0.23347929120063782,
0.6713466644287109,
-0.0864841416478157,
0.22674322128295898,
-0.32942095398902893,
-0.3825646638870239,
0.07171158492565155,
-0.8903003334999084,
-0.022219959646463394,
0.22302484512329102,
0.1607358306646347,
-0.21732838451862335,
0.6478257179260254,
-0.38360223174095154,
0.6074202656745911,
0.3911927044391632,
-0.14625371992588043,
-0.024296237155795097,
-0.2403927892446518,
-0.043588362634181976,
0.29449114203453064,
0.5919215679168701,
1.0291352272033691,
0.3917487859725952,
-0.34076178073883057,
-0.2100023627281189,
0.12986400723457336,
0.17739544808864594,
-0.8440622091293335,
-0.01554519310593605,
0.3252819776535034,
-0.4808051884174347,
-0.5147039890289307,
-0.031197182834148407,
-0.5835723876953125,
-0.3299465477466583,
-0.5181581974029541,
0.24635177850723267,
-0.1983305811882019,
-0.1235976591706276,
-0.14201699197292328,
-0.10583247989416122,
0.4877077639102936,
0.16656158864498138,
-0.4858747124671936,
0.14721518754959106,
0.6230676174163818,
0.6365651488304138,
-0.5498694777488708,
-0.05570230260491371,
-0.6996597647666931,
0.5670735239982605,
-0.45929670333862305,
0.7058834433555603,
-0.4360739290714264,
-0.011290254071354866,
0.03737105801701546,
0.12298989295959473,
0.2373291403055191,
-0.2778005301952362,
0.5195744633674622,
-0.5824555158615112,
0.13503946363925934,
0.03410104289650917,
-0.4369146227836609,
-0.10989698767662048,
0.27672699093818665,
-0.8141958713531494,
0.4482094943523407,
0.026008257642388344,
-0.6622488498687744,
0.1738463044166565,
-0.23333700001239777,
-0.8656942248344421,
-0.46346887946128845,
0.005048071965575218,
-0.4161776900291443,
0.30925944447517395,
0.7486431002616882,
0.6888129115104675,
-0.07403778284788132,
0.5651676058769226,
-0.22314248979091644,
-0.28728538751602173,
0.397414892911911,
-0.38488975167274475,
-0.06677445024251938,
0.21883301436901093,
0.004336777608841658,
0.13457298278808594,
-0.7084877490997314,
-0.12882429361343384,
0.021609483286738396,
-0.24618618190288544,
-0.3071076571941376,
0.048356518149375916,
0.21778348088264465,
0.1847783774137497,
0.04853595048189163,
-0.49412235617637634,
-0.04792380332946777,
-0.36914384365081787,
0.7678093910217285,
0.3524091839790344,
0.5094935297966003,
0.7669504284858704,
-0.1529635339975357,
0.07891245186328888,
0.09511584043502808,
-0.21332529187202454,
-0.41906607151031494,
-0.3219401240348816,
-0.6030188202857971,
-0.034955695271492004,
0.39179420471191406,
0.4867762327194214,
-0.8485901355743408,
0.09837073087692261,
-0.4040500819683075,
-0.019177796319127083,
-0.5112679600715637,
-0.1415739357471466,
0.5276821851730347,
0.582781970500946,
0.34569019079208374,
-0.01925571821630001,
-0.4236716628074646,
-1.1246943473815918,
-0.33275923132896423,
0.3367955684661865,
-0.17516884207725525,
0.10013874620199203,
0.1761571764945984,
0.22610051929950714,
0.9241192936897278,
-0.44610416889190674,
-0.4341685175895691,
-0.31543004512786865,
0.18932682275772095,
0.08771851658821106,
0.7757036685943604,
0.2548404932022095,
-1.022122859954834,
-0.17925378680229187,
-0.18467694520950317,
-0.6656135320663452,
0.09637483954429626,
-0.3983808755874634,
-0.3050495386123657,
0.30153951048851013,
0.7572376132011414,
-0.6131148934364319,
0.4707012176513672,
0.35866737365722656,
-0.21053405106067657,
0.14703884720802307,
0.10233751684427261,
0.2648228704929352,
-1.1352837085723877,
0.06577635556459427,
0.3140159249305725,
-0.44221851229667664,
-0.466524600982666,
0.09641912579536438,
0.11991310119628906,
-0.6233675479888916,
-0.7514150142669678,
0.6991178393363953,
-0.5698744654655457,
-0.25739553570747375,
-0.2692781090736389,
0.14814946055412292,
0.21007953584194183,
0.789016842842102,
0.511321485042572,
0.7933949828147888,
0.584710419178009,
-0.6469897627830505,
-0.06086717173457146,
0.17672739923000336,
-0.39226335287094116,
0.6208583116531372,
-0.8431666493415833,
0.20995652675628662,
-0.46546295285224915,
0.3143409192562103,
-1.0339486598968506,
-0.7694730162620544,
0.2558300793170929,
-0.3992249667644501,
0.4291737973690033,
-0.13148219883441925,
-0.3224239945411682,
-0.12164691090583801,
-0.33998239040374756,
0.579436182975769,
0.4551553726196289,
-0.21288932859897614,
0.4797498285770416,
0.14592373371124268,
-0.1741689145565033,
-0.3575585186481476,
-0.9355212450027466,
0.24263896048069,
-0.08903774619102478,
-0.29555171728134155,
0.47208288311958313,
0.11956601589918137,
0.0263066329061985,
0.3482237160205841,
-0.33725225925445557,
-0.2296842485666275,
-0.043799854815006256,
0.20530714094638824,
0.17401427030563354,
-0.1458224654197693,
0.12694181501865387,
0.5672905445098877,
-0.24632927775382996,
-0.007885836996138096,
-0.36005493998527527,
-0.010289400815963745,
0.04224688559770584,
-0.22339290380477905,
-0.7996268272399902,
0.4856499135494232,
0.6072030067443848,
-0.4885712265968323,
0.46641069650650024,
0.5149978995323181,
-0.5268955230712891,
-0.03553988039493561,
-0.5262207388877869,
-0.347087025642395,
-0.38837772607803345,
0.4531566798686981,
-0.31007063388824463,
-0.7256423234939575,
0.2728666663169861,
-0.02635890431702137,
-0.03733357414603233,
0.34988629817962646,
0.34543368220329285,
-0.14245373010635376,
1.0124460458755493,
0.21651965379714966,
-0.08322826027870178,
0.2423209846019745,
-0.3684910833835602,
-0.0213143490254879,
-0.7559025287628174,
-0.07925081253051758,
0.12003874778747559,
-0.49710309505462646,
-0.4533331096172333,
-0.38125884532928467,
0.38499122858047485,
-0.19229769706726074,
-0.2190689742565155,
0.11108213663101196,
-0.5936100482940674,
0.6373451948165894,
0.5484751462936401,
0.6542515754699707,
0.4717313051223755,
0.20592540502548218,
0.5204070806503296,
-0.08619770407676697,
-0.298761248588562,
-0.5044047832489014,
1.1470645666122437,
0.4104093611240387,
0.8808973431587219,
-0.2563587725162506,
0.43091881275177,
0.27710655331611633,
0.45250001549720764,
-0.9345617294311523,
0.6338558793067932,
-0.29068076610565186,
-0.6655166149139404,
-0.040181905031204224,
-0.10525641590356827,
-0.5555113554000854,
-0.06784950196743011,
-0.20279642939567566,
-0.32278504967689514,
0.20720274746418,
0.1666402667760849,
-0.34296876192092896,
0.029464341700077057,
-0.62889564037323,
0.6881269812583923,
-0.0012203024234622717,
-0.5953825116157532,
-0.30753669142723083,
-0.7356795072555542,
0.4784345030784607,
0.12190564721822739,
0.20370855927467346,
-0.32830265164375305,
-0.2824317514896393,
0.47334349155426025,
0.08555194735527039,
0.9563381671905518,
-0.08328818529844284,
-0.07122091203927994,
0.45067161321640015,
0.027839209884405136,
0.3618098199367523,
0.3810907006263733,
-0.08499470353126526,
0.00948526430875063,
-0.2932407557964325,
-0.30705684423446655,
-0.5930166244506836,
0.8256845474243164,
-0.5934502482414246,
-0.8308159112930298,
-0.020772047340869904,
-0.6909781098365784,
-0.3246123790740967,
0.16039642691612244,
0.48228439688682556,
0.6487419009208679,
-0.04453857243061066,
0.4148373007774353,
0.6859688758850098,
-0.06954827904701233,
0.32921117544174194,
0.31749194860458374,
0.121844083070755,
-0.7415611743927002,
0.9269618988037109,
-0.23800399899482727,
0.2622887194156647,
0.6230667233467102,
-0.049968112260103226,
-0.17056845128536224,
-0.6995436549186707,
-0.5348529815673828,
0.07620395720005035,
-0.7456858158111572,
-0.5709338784217834,
-0.36546075344085693,
-0.149845689535141,
-0.1636682152748108,
-0.26330187916755676,
-0.3076668977737427,
-0.4884108006954193,
-0.5828691720962524,
-0.3228245973587036,
0.2782132923603058,
0.3399437665939331,
0.29094934463500977,
0.2212042510509491,
-0.7810148000717163,
0.7208604216575623,
0.27011436223983765,
0.305666446685791,
-0.13792318105697632,
-0.42597320675849915,
-0.1320781111717224,
0.02278844080865383,
-0.2920636832714081,
-0.9532915949821472,
0.19116851687431335,
0.3114053010940552,
0.35003313422203064,
0.3904913365840912,
0.38829392194747925,
0.2703859508037567,
-0.6545621752738953,
0.695371150970459,
0.05773834511637688,
-0.8879778385162354,
0.8245513439178467,
-0.4814004898071289,
0.1837528795003891,
0.6308754682540894,
0.3264380395412445,
-0.13263626396656036,
-0.7313404679298401,
-0.18635733425617218,
-0.7333908081054688,
0.5864158272743225,
0.3599112927913666,
0.3501838445663452,
0.06107737123966217,
0.687728762626648,
-0.009095443412661552,
0.320140540599823,
-1.0080037117004395,
0.12731334567070007,
-0.4060956835746765,
-0.6287247538566589,
0.19422301650047302,
-0.2863072156906128,
-0.08484768122434616,
-0.2806784212589264,
0.5203931927680969,
-0.29624056816101074,
0.2268964648246765,
0.4415977895259857,
-0.2388082593679428,
-0.14475396275520325,
0.3085463047027588,
0.5401248931884766,
0.5790198445320129,
-0.17494601011276245,
0.22161729633808136,
-0.10995368659496307,
-0.11892774701118469,
0.25473901629447937,
0.20897488296031952,
-0.24245388805866241,
-0.06151221692562103,
0.4028366506099701,
1.0400967597961426,
0.4868113100528717,
-0.5804747343063354,
0.5317939519882202,
0.22311073541641235,
-0.2330130785703659,
0.0009103276534006,
0.05638990178704262,
-0.030478311702609062,
0.10427626967430115,
0.5378069281578064,
0.11357530206441879,
0.26033586263656616,
-0.4852410554885864,
0.2351142019033432,
0.21882447600364685,
-0.3006802797317505,
-0.42937713861465454,
0.9110987782478333,
0.396237313747406,
0.1002717912197113,
0.4866050183773041,
-0.2411472499370575,
-0.24837027490139008,
0.6241056323051453,
0.47780120372772217,
0.8706056475639343,
0.07481648772954941,
0.11941884458065033,
0.5642366409301758,
0.1654980182647705,
-0.042835868895053864,
0.2235972136259079,
0.07763620465993881,
-0.6050480008125305,
-0.6565340757369995,
-0.24342213571071625,
-0.2812882661819458,
0.28085196018218994,
-0.6989637017250061,
0.2598143219947815,
-0.5050713419914246,
-0.012229636311531067,
-0.08467233926057816,
-0.35452812910079956,
-0.5363266468048096,
0.4281176030635834,
0.3101176917552948,
0.8759676814079285,
-0.9076290130615234,
0.5943096280097961,
0.9617382884025574,
-0.3906894624233246,
-0.6810435652732849,
0.4379880726337433,
-0.28486886620521545,
-0.5282878279685974,
0.6094557642936707,
0.58405601978302,
0.35115668177604675,
0.29750755429267883,
-0.9586760401725769,
-0.7856768369674683,
0.9877781271934509,
0.3499950170516968,
-0.5067815780639648,
-0.12974809110164642,
0.24733887612819672,
0.3047240972518921,
-0.5701735019683838,
-0.25717127323150635,
0.35996997356414795,
0.6508800387382507,
0.2797078490257263,
-0.40255776047706604,
0.28854963183403015,
0.04001467674970627,
0.32464203238487244,
-0.25007715821266174,
-0.4172567129135132,
0.3605306148529053,
-0.4763825237751007,
-0.4222250282764435,
0.26305124163627625,
1.0930348634719849,
0.2844926118850708,
0.7885072827339172,
0.37976738810539246,
0.4498148560523987,
0.24903304874897003,
-0.11959673464298248,
1.0905656814575195,
-0.36836519837379456,
0.1765705794095993,
1.1303658485412598,
0.01531772967427969,
0.8768062591552734,
0.6186755299568176,
0.26164761185646057,
0.34942519664764404,
0.6833245754241943,
-0.09622135758399963,
1.1140228509902954,
0.04979240149259567,
-0.03101462870836258,
-0.29335615038871765,
-0.3944028317928314,
0.0013680937699973583,
0.17639897763729095,
0.38397836685180664,
-0.45210325717926025,
-0.26364487409591675,
0.516425371170044,
-0.13253545761108398,
0.33829304575920105,
-0.5712621212005615,
0.7926853895187378,
0.15863102674484253,
-0.9669792652130127,
0.5358287692070007,
0.12018214166164398,
0.46239227056503296,
-0.21151381731033325,
0.010167043656110764,
-0.2665642499923706,
-0.0019588449504226446,
-0.31628575921058655,
-1.157667636871338,
0.29842478036880493,
-0.05273376405239105,
-0.3973523676395416,
-0.15393373370170593,
0.8987447023391724,
-0.8800742030143738,
-0.5738052129745483,
-0.44080880284309387,
0.24235646426677704,
-0.0010953819146379828,
-0.2725750505924225,
-0.24368150532245636,
0.15645185112953186,
-0.023534119129180908,
-0.46095481514930725,
0.03063558228313923,
0.38507550954818726,
-0.3280683755874634,
0.39827802777290344,
0.49747779965400696,
-0.27041861414909363,
-0.455518513917923,
-0.028793295845389366,
0.907745361328125,
-0.5707902908325195,
-0.36943164467811584,
-0.5894835591316223,
0.624466598033905,
-0.025336431339383125,
-0.041758451610803604,
0.3328379988670349,
0.43923431634902954,
0.5618078112602234,
-0.6595274806022644,
0.6800128221511841,
0.16011688113212585,
0.2584962844848633,
-0.9010403752326965,
0.6390140056610107,
-0.49139827489852905,
-0.11347734928131104,
0.03111223317682743,
-0.8782903552055359,
-0.318105548620224,
0.25972265005111694,
-0.3757343888282776,
-0.2897336781024933,
0.566581666469574,
0.7303172945976257,
-0.2660735845565796,
-0.18834005296230316,
0.14364473521709442,
0.037055060267448425,
0.13221222162246704,
0.6551038026809692,
0.8341040015220642,
-0.43652501702308655,
0.5985126495361328,
-0.2776649594306946,
0.019756872206926346,
-0.05002477765083313,
-1.286232590675354,
-1.088050127029419,
-0.5409365892410278,
-0.7163700461387634,
-0.041298773139715195,
0.2877272963523865,
0.7459481358528137,
0.8379109501838684,
-0.988305389881134,
0.3952527642250061,
-0.36577489972114563,
0.22545000910758972,
-0.11013241112232208,
-0.2609004080295563,
0.567224383354187,
-0.346452921628952,
-0.9438250660896301,
0.25847989320755005,
0.026880430057644844,
0.053482525050640106,
-0.1388499140739441,
0.16260787844657898,
0.08714939653873444,
0.009103289805352688,
0.5598040223121643,
0.11187522858381271,
-0.8112643361091614,
-0.35531800985336304,
-0.14210814237594604,
-0.1411004662513733,
0.07855503261089325,
0.8141409158706665,
-0.8716661334037781,
0.06987575441598892,
0.403196781873703,
0.7181262969970703,
0.2851577401161194,
0.32558557391166687,
0.6289232969284058,
-1.2089781761169434,
0.5199178457260132,
-0.040794022381305695,
0.09964409470558167,
0.6910399198532104,
-0.5582072138786316,
0.47953420877456665,
0.13228970766067505,
-0.2095608115196228,
-0.5921164751052856,
0.1483270525932312,
-1.0957797765731812,
-0.35437142848968506,
1.449864149093628,
-0.08318225294351578,
-0.3818093538284302,
0.24849340319633484,
-0.4207576513290405,
0.33104202151298523,
-0.6159442067146301,
0.3964601755142212,
0.3746856153011322,
0.3455873727798462,
-0.46476513147354126,
-0.4424839913845062,
0.48395416140556335,
0.16689863801002502,
-0.7899088263511658,
-0.1108684316277504,
0.6819568872451782,
0.35389089584350586,
0.04263613745570183,
0.1174030676484108,
-0.008086775429546833,
0.3563423752784729,
-0.6370549201965332,
-0.05057605355978012,
-0.46948370337486267,
-0.37145599722862244,
-0.09172143042087555,
0.0821617916226387,
-0.19462014734745026,
-0.49705949425697327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10136v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10136v1
|
Language Model Cascades: Token-level uncertainty and beyond
| 2024-04-15T21:02:48 | 2024-04-15T21:02:48 |
Neha Gupta, Harikrishna Narasimhan, Wittawat Jitkrittum, Ankit Singh Rawat, Aditya Krishna Menon, Sanjiv Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent advances in language models (LMs) have led to significant improvements
in quality on complex NLP tasks, but at the expense of increased inference
costs. Cascading offers a simple strategy to achieve more favorable
cost-quality tradeoffs: here, a small model is invoked for most "easy"
instances, while a few "hard" instances are deferred to the large model. While
the principles underpinning cascading are well-studied for classification tasks
- with deferral based on predicted class uncertainty favored theoretically and
practically - a similar understanding is lacking for generative LM tasks. In
this work, we initiate a systematic study of deferral rules for LM cascades. We
begin by examining the natural extension of predicted class uncertainty to
generative LM tasks, namely, the predicted sequence uncertainty. We show that
this measure suffers from the length bias problem, either over- or
under-emphasizing outputs based on their lengths. This is because LMs produce a
sequence of uncertainty values, one for each output token; and moreover, the
number of output tokens is variable across examples. To mitigate this issue, we
propose to exploit the richer token-level uncertainty information implicit in
generative LMs. We argue that naive predicted sequence uncertainty corresponds
to a simple aggregation of these uncertainties. By contrast, we show that
incorporating token-level uncertainty through learned post-hoc deferral rules
can significantly outperform such simple aggregation strategies, via
experiments on a range of natural language benchmarks with FLAN-T5 models. We
further show that incorporating embeddings from the smaller model and
intermediate layers of the larger model can give an additional boost in the
overall cost-quality tradeoff.
|
[
-0.3484194576740265,
-0.6772143244743347,
0.40524572134017944,
0.009140120819211006,
-0.07434140890836716,
0.031695783138275146,
-0.062465816736221313,
-0.45394957065582275,
-0.1335170567035675,
0.27896416187286377,
-0.4653548002243042,
-0.3207387626171112,
-0.8347415328025818,
-0.15894554555416107,
-0.6042674779891968,
1.1201956272125244,
0.036387115716934204,
-0.10963310301303864,
-0.15596100687980652,
0.18619291484355927,
-0.5340746641159058,
-0.6523931622505188,
-0.8365894556045532,
-0.3439006805419922,
0.6603994369506836,
0.17878812551498413,
0.9386138319969177,
0.6211495399475098,
0.4146953523159027,
0.15169616043567657,
-0.34819507598876953,
-0.10167841613292694,
-0.1472228616476059,
0.25088584423065186,
-0.10100499540567398,
-0.7087929844856262,
-0.4152091145515442,
-0.20764054358005524,
0.5834618210792542,
1.0774006843566895,
-0.21579547226428986,
0.059995777904987335,
0.10851772874593735,
0.684056282043457,
-0.8706511855125427,
0.3195154368877411,
-0.6088181138038635,
0.20751254260540009,
-0.3447750210762024,
0.2092965841293335,
-0.43484407663345337,
-0.1123189628124237,
0.2552226781845093,
-0.33225682377815247,
0.29220497608184814,
0.09836442768573761,
0.7883985638618469,
0.427213579416275,
-0.18400488793849945,
-0.4401356279850006,
-0.9290833473205566,
0.8693835735321045,
-0.877676248550415,
0.28621822595596313,
0.6251320838928223,
-0.01788901537656784,
-0.158377543091774,
-0.9385072588920593,
-0.46187981963157654,
0.022003304213285446,
-0.08353040367364883,
-0.023694690316915512,
-0.2524570822715759,
0.36603784561157227,
0.13137108087539673,
0.6722134351730347,
-0.2530331611633301,
0.25602278113365173,
-0.3766612112522125,
-0.27146926522254944,
0.30563071370124817,
0.13000991940498352,
0.14859718084335327,
-0.14313603937625885,
-0.2877609133720398,
0.049452733248472214,
-0.5438367128372192,
0.13457438349723816,
0.21370290219783783,
0.5531116724014282,
-0.09635140001773834,
0.45266586542129517,
-0.11657744646072388,
0.6045112013816833,
0.08062698692083359,
0.03541385754942894,
-0.14233168959617615,
-0.3885483741760254,
-0.3427722752094269,
0.12372167408466339,
0.5109645128250122,
-0.10293316096067429,
0.17115594446659088,
-0.05599971488118172,
-0.4305483400821686,
0.09153014421463013,
0.23409923911094666,
-0.48407211899757385,
-0.13778163492679596,
0.37756407260894775,
-0.3831717073917389,
-0.34403738379478455,
-0.007835973985493183,
-0.5421077013015747,
-0.09957142174243927,
-0.2488090693950653,
0.5337238311767578,
-0.43580105900764465,
-0.16137750446796417,
0.0404944084584713,
0.12207230180501938,
0.005367551930248737,
0.34585464000701904,
-1.0082567930221558,
0.6362500190734863,
0.9868080019950867,
1.0763671398162842,
-0.057509645819664,
-0.317741721868515,
-0.734650731086731,
-0.05372365191578865,
-0.6188764572143555,
0.30833932757377625,
-0.5149639844894409,
-0.4344111680984497,
0.11948668211698532,
-0.42858535051345825,
-0.04758729040622711,
-0.2101084440946579,
0.6874665021896362,
-0.6282364130020142,
0.4771606922149658,
-0.3950831890106201,
-0.5955020189285278,
-0.02636251412332058,
-0.14542295038700104,
-0.6629139184951782,
1.146040916442871,
0.12278185784816742,
-1.1399924755096436,
0.706384003162384,
-0.3321284353733063,
-0.6596704125404358,
-0.04171176254749298,
0.05749519169330597,
-0.2639782428741455,
0.46772241592407227,
0.12333809584379196,
0.4020465314388275,
-0.27962014079093933,
0.3687659502029419,
-0.057132210582494736,
-0.37306714057922363,
0.16709406673908234,
-0.8086487054824829,
0.434737890958786,
0.2688170075416565,
-0.27496466040611267,
0.06855004280805588,
-0.46275338530540466,
-0.17124292254447937,
-0.47040167450904846,
-0.39176008105278015,
-0.4298447072505951,
0.1600465625524521,
-0.2576656639575958,
0.338542103767395,
-0.027776749804615974,
-0.12259265035390854,
0.11882687360048294,
-0.5296511650085449,
0.42191463708877563,
0.8611982464790344,
-0.23446378111839294,
0.7561638951301575,
-0.32252511382102966,
0.511314332485199,
0.18480059504508972,
0.3457641303539276,
-0.16385142505168915,
-0.5485535860061646,
-1.120782732963562,
-0.16140396893024445,
0.6056742072105408,
0.2683694064617157,
-0.7015965580940247,
0.36376503109931946,
-0.2641618847846985,
-0.205617755651474,
-0.5990773439407349,
-0.11091390997171402,
0.3905479907989502,
0.30487585067749023,
0.4418362081050873,
-0.6321182250976562,
-0.22221967577934265,
-0.5872825384140015,
-0.1309526264667511,
-0.4728746712207794,
-0.020955504849553108,
-0.2542923092842102,
0.4995430111885071,
0.11058696359395981,
0.9497038125991821,
-0.4539380371570587,
-0.31570443511009216,
-0.4133906960487366,
0.5427993535995483,
0.16607554256916046,
0.5039157271385193,
0.26830413937568665,
-0.5527474284172058,
-0.07460666447877884,
-0.31552594900131226,
-0.14357547461986542,
-0.07111659646034241,
-0.34006962180137634,
-0.149167999625206,
0.5613694190979004,
0.411927193403244,
-0.9606446027755737,
0.5723537802696228,
0.4530918002128601,
-0.07401803135871887,
0.5644194483757019,
-0.14382430911064148,
-0.30673229694366455,
-1.146005392074585,
-0.19117020070552826,
-0.1894300878047943,
-0.09714151173830032,
-0.853693962097168,
-0.013935293070971966,
-0.09504636377096176,
0.3979901969432831,
-0.2960716784000397,
0.34565025568008423,
-0.5081396102905273,
-0.33250656723976135,
-0.29891446232795715,
-0.11210265755653381,
0.025002868846058846,
0.3367803692817688,
0.1019328236579895,
0.5119143128395081,
0.7353710532188416,
-0.8571311831474304,
-0.043120384216308594,
-0.1828208565711975,
-0.4351798892021179,
0.3814435303211212,
-0.5534940958023071,
-0.13374970853328705,
-0.26511162519454956,
0.39522793889045715,
-0.76991868019104,
-0.1699886918067932,
0.13335460424423218,
-0.4179360270500183,
0.6939553618431091,
-0.14644989371299744,
-0.3970688581466675,
-0.46098190546035767,
-0.2967112362384796,
0.5076186060905457,
0.623423159122467,
-0.26851195096969604,
0.3811412453651428,
-0.02443414181470871,
-0.167648047208786,
-0.9077391028404236,
-1.0830607414245605,
0.1367085576057434,
-0.12098585814237595,
-0.19051319360733032,
0.6008760333061218,
0.09161997586488724,
-0.20394138991832733,
0.02795735001564026,
-0.40266165137290955,
-0.08527776598930359,
0.19380252063274384,
0.2657454013824463,
-0.0021193160209804773,
-0.25855252146720886,
0.21000735461711884,
0.2532086968421936,
-0.13172060251235962,
0.03731654956936836,
-0.606174111366272,
0.6724909543991089,
-0.0012890653451904655,
-0.5684966444969177,
-0.5528298020362854,
0.11641743034124374,
0.5761677026748657,
-0.06842326372861862,
1.0017904043197632,
0.6173095107078552,
-0.6543874740600586,
-0.33978402614593506,
-0.44240376353263855,
-0.22198979556560516,
-0.39987310767173767,
0.176345556974411,
-0.3859688639640808,
-0.7834419012069702,
0.6068925857543945,
0.3007810413837433,
0.04546318203210831,
0.5662754774093628,
0.38985496759414673,
0.09723883867263794,
0.7808111310005188,
0.4988018572330475,
-0.3468206524848938,
0.3577929139137268,
-0.134987935423851,
0.32515910267829895,
-0.6150400638580322,
-0.12487993389368057,
-0.569398045539856,
-0.2473166584968567,
-0.5547441840171814,
-0.8676891922950745,
-0.015146082267165184,
0.44452303647994995,
-0.3718617260456085,
0.1394863724708557,
-0.18961164355278015,
0.19271214306354523,
0.8079566359519958,
-0.17025476694107056,
0.3115832805633545,
-0.055033884942531586,
-0.0706486776471138,
0.09004811197519302,
-0.975224494934082,
-0.3863741457462311,
0.7059900760650635,
0.4964894652366638,
0.837768018245697,
0.21454694867134094,
0.5566659569740295,
0.41450804471969604,
0.26975223422050476,
-0.8077080845832825,
0.23148055374622345,
-0.15931379795074463,
-0.5954954624176025,
-0.4100417196750641,
-0.4543904662132263,
-0.8003942966461182,
0.19421136379241943,
0.040893491357564926,
-0.656323254108429,
0.32894256711006165,
0.2296486347913742,
-0.4393121898174286,
0.49633365869522095,
-0.2986358106136322,
0.591214120388031,
-0.02059747278690338,
-0.24623076617717743,
-0.0032119492534548044,
-0.9670155048370361,
0.41927018761634827,
-0.2760789692401886,
0.4249476194381714,
-0.04550820589065552,
-0.022522030398249626,
0.4425632059574127,
-0.7471745610237122,
1.0713245868682861,
0.14203929901123047,
-0.2160966843366623,
0.3919854462146759,
0.36752501130104065,
0.49531546235084534,
-0.11641740798950195,
-0.1881941854953766,
0.09733140468597412,
0.06524118781089783,
-0.484045147895813,
-0.42496922612190247,
0.617533266544342,
-0.6099251508712769,
-0.5721437335014343,
-0.579924464225769,
-0.47282978892326355,
0.009545279666781425,
0.047610800713300705,
0.5335902571678162,
0.5030619502067566,
0.09508073329925537,
-0.023776350542902946,
0.484443336725235,
-0.25498414039611816,
0.7328718304634094,
0.013944861479103565,
-0.020418813452124596,
-0.19341780245304108,
0.6255922913551331,
0.2567569613456726,
0.8772896528244019,
0.6886464357376099,
0.2842128276824951,
-0.35451000928878784,
-0.5810685753822327,
-0.2518356740474701,
-0.20453885197639465,
-0.7695327997207642,
-0.3715585470199585,
-0.4174250364303589,
-0.4035276770591736,
-0.3904704749584198,
-0.1002136617898941,
-0.35867834091186523,
-0.6706549525260925,
-0.5677568912506104,
-0.3304111361503601,
0.24852080643177032,
0.8394238948822021,
-0.07669366896152496,
0.32189008593559265,
-0.609894871711731,
-0.07706406712532043,
0.1423901617527008,
0.4627699851989746,
0.40259966254234314,
-0.7790191769599915,
-0.09464961290359497,
0.10550396144390106,
-0.12709146738052368,
-0.5856634378433228,
0.32873040437698364,
0.40587010979652405,
0.387043833732605,
0.6236131191253662,
0.35748589038848877,
0.8529020547866821,
-0.41156959533691406,
1.114805817604065,
0.1894068866968155,
-1.379294753074646,
0.41343897581100464,
-0.0017802715301513672,
0.1884814202785492,
0.4536000192165375,
0.3438371419906616,
-0.7007667422294617,
-0.4937150180339813,
-0.5055827498435974,
-1.081701397895813,
0.885109007358551,
0.5290226936340332,
0.5129408240318298,
-0.2262854278087616,
0.5113022923469543,
0.15851551294326782,
0.28381720185279846,
-0.7912007570266724,
-0.2253858596086502,
-0.15740971267223358,
-0.2765061855316162,
0.0620608851313591,
-0.40004226565361023,
0.16411830484867096,
-0.12000783532857895,
0.43060624599456787,
0.040212031453847885,
0.01218733936548233,
0.12083186954259872,
-0.14326192438602448,
-0.12461575120687485,
0.28265610337257385,
0.7069375514984131,
0.31633052229881287,
-0.07229982316493988,
0.5662258863449097,
0.4085449278354645,
-0.3798079192638397,
-0.017385998740792274,
-0.15279871225357056,
-0.1560782641172409,
0.04879472404718399,
0.7752756476402283,
0.9749852418899536,
0.24665409326553345,
-0.33987659215927124,
0.5129002928733826,
0.1320921778678894,
-0.0711769089102745,
-0.14229735732078552,
-0.1276431679725647,
-0.11631408333778381,
-0.08078640699386597,
0.379468709230423,
0.18533092737197876,
0.1285688579082489,
-0.5563476085662842,
0.2568168640136719,
0.2949654459953308,
-0.5354486703872681,
-0.4945395886898041,
0.8192102909088135,
-0.005271993577480316,
-0.2719345688819885,
0.4147144854068756,
-0.1224348172545433,
-0.4971174895763397,
0.5338207483291626,
0.3385624885559082,
0.831693708896637,
-0.34516236186027527,
0.13735879957675934,
0.08015323430299759,
0.4198492169380188,
-0.5764752626419067,
0.059051141142845154,
-0.16981381177902222,
-0.6118517518043518,
-0.5957515835762024,
-0.9230738282203674,
-0.24239292740821838,
-0.03282468020915985,
-0.843306303024292,
0.22221508622169495,
-0.38851404190063477,
-0.34580448269844055,
-0.4011678993701935,
-0.2826061546802521,
-0.5886895656585693,
0.3101552426815033,
0.21051521599292755,
0.9498566389083862,
-0.7657148838043213,
0.5397156476974487,
0.2641892433166504,
-0.5655845403671265,
-0.7678505778312683,
0.4095502197742462,
-0.1818799376487732,
-0.5126099586486816,
0.7663214206695557,
0.14584070444107056,
-0.05078167840838432,
-0.17296671867370605,
-0.12596341967582703,
-1.1536489725112915,
0.9833431839942932,
0.05982641503214836,
-0.5390681624412537,
-0.35582002997398376,
0.35536712408065796,
0.6639081835746765,
-0.1767936646938324,
0.18574246764183044,
0.6634962558746338,
0.16116487979888916,
0.36907869577407837,
-0.8515618443489075,
0.15360547602176666,
0.2791106402873993,
0.3061540424823761,
0.34099993109703064,
-0.4829644560813904,
0.9940803647041321,
-0.21827702224254608,
-0.3300815224647522,
0.1489744782447815,
0.8257027268409729,
-0.12314216792583466,
0.3696433901786804,
0.40578222274780273,
0.5470135807991028,
0.7647026777267456,
-0.27268078923225403,
1.2434868812561035,
-0.38327670097351074,
0.30522921681404114,
1.1510123014450073,
-0.17276857793331146,
0.9761372804641724,
0.4319742023944855,
-0.4052036702632904,
0.5669705867767334,
1.063988447189331,
0.4826352000236511,
0.4667181968688965,
0.5751850008964539,
-0.40729671716690063,
-0.110515296459198,
-0.2254355251789093,
-0.28198885917663574,
0.17663326859474182,
0.5829871892929077,
-0.5215594172477722,
0.1033041849732399,
-0.21040378510951996,
0.06072069704532623,
-0.2128894180059433,
-0.4089747965335846,
0.7189670205116272,
0.36938148736953735,
-0.7213383913040161,
0.3378060460090637,
0.03831770643591881,
0.8122916221618652,
-0.34158918261528015,
0.3712574541568756,
-0.4655718207359314,
-0.006392883136868477,
-0.1669677048921585,
-0.6089064478874207,
0.4327426850795746,
-0.20622724294662476,
-0.22624051570892334,
-0.20879986882209778,
0.5868337750434875,
-0.4954250752925873,
-0.706849992275238,
0.2035953551530838,
0.4437559247016907,
0.04655354842543602,
0.05444517731666565,
-0.45690152049064636,
-0.0032908644061535597,
-0.4251909852027893,
-0.23017942905426025,
0.17686240375041962,
0.5167378783226013,
-0.22622761130332947,
0.6883184909820557,
0.41998299956321716,
0.31131550669670105,
0.1564485728740692,
0.49196135997772217,
0.6445401310920715,
-0.388016015291214,
-0.2680884003639221,
-1.0476659536361694,
0.5080376267433167,
0.24043403565883636,
-0.26369500160217285,
0.3409777283668518,
0.30746543407440186,
1.0145095586776733,
0.0340874008834362,
0.642657458782196,
0.168258935213089,
0.09028441458940506,
-0.5948273539543152,
0.4679186940193176,
-0.49072468280792236,
0.5436580181121826,
-0.4628077745437622,
-0.7674925327301025,
-0.45680686831474304,
0.4673091173171997,
-0.1971130222082138,
0.24972525238990784,
0.5464614033699036,
0.5163570642471313,
0.030184784904122353,
-0.16276131570339203,
0.35145410895347595,
0.0008887556032277644,
0.2131621092557907,
0.4734196066856384,
0.871882438659668,
-0.3684983253479004,
0.43453818559646606,
-0.2868648171424866,
0.09897774457931519,
-0.18084484338760376,
-0.852556586265564,
-0.6558506488800049,
-0.6790615320205688,
-0.3367956280708313,
-0.3079957067966461,
0.011666698381304741,
0.8300000429153442,
0.798161506652832,
-0.8459291458129883,
-0.003971489146351814,
-0.6025803685188293,
0.3272043466567993,
-0.20760345458984375,
-0.27130770683288574,
0.3605576455593109,
-0.6928074955940247,
-0.8414230346679688,
-0.05547454580664635,
0.19286979734897614,
0.41699159145355225,
-0.28120219707489014,
0.04039188101887703,
0.0028243435081094503,
0.37731021642684937,
0.6167327165603638,
-0.0020569749176502228,
-1.1285983324050903,
-0.32593557238578796,
-0.18149703741073608,
-0.11833050847053528,
-0.2348807156085968,
0.8074299097061157,
-0.5765668153762817,
0.27745962142944336,
0.5291206240653992,
0.5475063920021057,
0.3473893105983734,
0.08689868450164795,
0.7957772016525269,
-1.1644604206085205,
-0.0013928916305303574,
0.21243591606616974,
0.3406751751899719,
0.35355687141418457,
-0.25661224126815796,
0.33661261200904846,
0.07172545045614243,
-0.35800984501838684,
-1.0209819078445435,
0.44824692606925964,
-0.5306563377380371,
-0.47390687465667725,
1.0155779123306274,
-0.0699164867401123,
0.18480247259140015,
-0.10252086818218231,
0.023196350783109665,
0.4273577928543091,
-0.16776300966739655,
0.9003984332084656,
1.0111443996429443,
0.022410091012716293,
-0.20063680410385132,
-0.4354429543018341,
0.8763688802719116,
0.6640101671218872,
-0.5834004878997803,
0.17282751202583313,
0.3196769952774048,
-0.023581163957715034,
0.23075729608535767,
0.4023483395576477,
0.0975005030632019,
0.003573978552594781,
-0.046605437994003296,
-0.022115470841526985,
0.4224815368652344,
-0.4243519604206085,
-0.486439973115921,
0.16715726256370544,
0.521685004234314,
-0.13151870667934418
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.