id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10112v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10112v1
|
PRODIS -- a speech database and a phoneme-based language model for the study of predictability effects in Polish
| 2024-04-15T20:03:58 | 2024-04-15T20:03:58 |
Zofia Malisz, Jan Foremski, Małgorzata Kul
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We present a speech database and a phoneme-level language model of Polish.
The database and model are designed for the analysis of prosodic and discourse
factors and their impact on acoustic parameters in interaction with
predictability effects. The database is also the first large, publicly
available Polish speech corpus of excellent acoustic quality that can be used
for phonetic analysis and training of multi-speaker speech technology systems.
The speech in the database is processed in a pipeline that achieves a 90%
degree of automation. It incorporates state-of-the-art, freely available tools
enabling database expansion or adaptation to additional languages.
|
[
-0.4294377267360687,
-0.6982428431510925,
0.5985303521156311,
0.20331765711307526,
-0.20367181301116943,
-0.08242788910865784,
-0.11906825006008148,
-0.5647805333137512,
0.7026316523551941,
0.6216514110565186,
-0.8743444681167603,
-0.6234769225120544,
-0.22501687705516815,
0.11192189157009125,
-0.6142698526382446,
0.33903709053993225,
0.36581680178642273,
0.49922266602516174,
0.019113343209028244,
0.2010420560836792,
-0.2044847458600998,
-0.793069064617157,
-0.40258827805519104,
0.042222604155540466,
0.18743382394313812,
0.6410436630249023,
1.0571388006210327,
0.26737433671951294,
0.5617178082466125,
0.31594118475914,
0.12825559079647064,
-0.3901917040348053,
-0.1679752618074417,
0.4756704866886139,
-0.2961755692958832,
-0.42602795362472534,
-1.0000256299972534,
0.059678297489881516,
0.6471745371818542,
0.9234910011291504,
-0.2434806525707245,
0.022330403327941895,
-0.2040187120437622,
0.4553007185459137,
-0.561326801776886,
0.15016475319862366,
-0.16746188700199127,
-0.08151108771562576,
-0.8316816091537476,
-0.01539408229291439,
-0.32691821455955505,
-0.6331955194473267,
0.006449651904404163,
-0.9074395895004272,
0.1935841143131256,
-0.13837851583957672,
0.41374024748802185,
-0.1177416741847992,
0.05229618400335312,
-0.6068493127822876,
-0.9645795226097107,
0.5578503608703613,
-0.7313119173049927,
0.9221982955932617,
0.7620826959609985,
0.26748815178871155,
-0.3281017541885376,
-0.6900739669799805,
-0.5639491081237793,
-0.05690610781311989,
0.04268729314208031,
0.11628196388483047,
-0.04731433838605881,
0.14069007337093353,
-0.0944896712899208,
0.35461968183517456,
-0.6498017907142639,
0.013923516497015953,
-0.48272204399108887,
-0.351717084646225,
0.6500238180160522,
0.20806995034217834,
0.4063011109828949,
0.01014468539506197,
0.1473924219608307,
0.12895354628562927,
-0.8194078207015991,
-0.11186838150024414,
0.7512797117233276,
0.7877721786499023,
0.08278210461139679,
0.3898633122444153,
-0.3845005929470062,
0.7571058869361877,
-0.21854570508003235,
-0.32109230756759644,
0.45276832580566406,
-0.5087239742279053,
0.01575968787074089,
0.30369988083839417,
0.9348086714744568,
-0.0012936443090438843,
0.34014078974723816,
-0.2010677456855774,
0.10927791893482208,
0.21127238869667053,
0.10757119953632355,
-0.6353281140327454,
-0.43477433919906616,
0.3054354190826416,
-0.298565149307251,
-0.3012236952781677,
0.08021309226751328,
-0.8011124730110168,
-0.2510405480861664,
-0.2830994427204132,
0.22052665054798126,
-0.7333359122276306,
-0.7313481569290161,
0.34889668226242065,
0.36491671204566956,
-0.3193191885948181,
-0.1425597220659256,
-0.8807411193847656,
0.9367886185646057,
0.5214150547981262,
0.6987184286117554,
0.0013503818772733212,
-0.08653932064771652,
-0.45159515738487244,
0.005256987176835537,
-0.6607479453086853,
0.8143279552459717,
-0.797248125076294,
-0.8439253568649292,
-0.03290162235498428,
0.27922847867012024,
-0.22426816821098328,
-0.7759398818016052,
0.9210449457168579,
-0.31255903840065,
0.4220680594444275,
-0.21093925833702087,
-0.8136802315711975,
-0.17595230042934418,
-0.5065728425979614,
-0.8875848054885864,
0.5725457072257996,
0.2516632378101349,
-0.6537945866584778,
0.29141950607299805,
-0.4741174876689911,
-0.48342466354370117,
0.3653932213783264,
-0.061569176614284515,
-0.27354374527931213,
0.04840043559670448,
-0.21981759369373322,
0.1614285707473755,
-0.1688840687274933,
0.34938421845436096,
-0.2764431834220886,
-0.3519655168056488,
0.029647937044501305,
0.22566857933998108,
1.0389494895935059,
0.2955256998538971,
0.14848628640174866,
0.20532312989234924,
-1.1759623289108276,
0.11732632666826248,
-0.18436776101589203,
-0.2578505575656891,
-0.3938184678554535,
0.3580699563026428,
0.14972709119319916,
0.41453129053115845,
0.062168803066015244,
-0.9285140037536621,
-0.17604215443134308,
-0.7111132144927979,
0.4037361443042755,
0.0958002358675003,
-0.025597594678401947,
0.40537580847740173,
0.19663356244564056,
0.7818024158477783,
-0.0929202288389206,
0.26362159848213196,
0.09269926697015762,
-0.6543318033218384,
-0.17359432578086853,
-0.18928228318691254,
0.6690990328788757,
0.9413071870803833,
-0.390857070684433,
0.3369045853614807,
0.09856776893138885,
-0.5212492942810059,
-0.5110320448875427,
-0.03869067505002022,
0.3114919364452362,
0.5076286792755127,
0.006026239134371281,
-0.47406527400016785,
-1.0743019580841064,
-1.026728630065918,
-0.12745904922485352,
-0.44059309363365173,
-0.01083589717745781,
0.0223299041390419,
0.21640723943710327,
0.2961347997188568,
1.0129791498184204,
-0.07223320007324219,
-0.4722827076911926,
-0.35553351044654846,
-0.2867473065853119,
0.6546807289123535,
0.44672060012817383,
0.5525572299957275,
-0.5944219827651978,
-0.39516305923461914,
-0.4255104660987854,
-0.7404780983924866,
-0.3007979094982147,
0.39109838008880615,
0.09297475218772888,
-0.009815662167966366,
0.3854113817214966,
-0.7043024897575378,
0.15077543258666992,
0.6367987394332886,
-0.6665263772010803,
0.8758106827735901,
-0.2088506519794464,
0.07922779023647308,
-0.8482152819633484,
-0.018489951267838478,
-0.15214399993419647,
-0.18229690194129944,
-1.0838466882705688,
-0.19083809852600098,
0.17251063883304596,
-0.4264605939388275,
-0.8562730550765991,
0.3552403748035431,
-0.0975758284330368,
-0.5535473227500916,
0.0587855726480484,
0.17639851570129395,
-0.17428812384605408,
-0.025978785008192062,
0.1263824701309204,
1.173335313796997,
0.9628152847290039,
-0.74433434009552,
0.2705439627170563,
0.5341992974281311,
-0.8577447533607483,
0.7835344076156616,
-0.7142562866210938,
-0.060737770050764084,
0.13980542123317719,
-0.20932701230049133,
-0.7463826537132263,
-0.3290037214756012,
0.18150950968265533,
-0.5708410143852234,
0.06305985897779465,
0.22049540281295776,
-0.43988409638404846,
-0.3996973931789398,
-0.06988856941461563,
-0.14678329229354858,
0.3061177432537079,
-0.036000464111566544,
0.38770589232444763,
0.6082646250724792,
-0.828757643699646,
-0.3180655837059021,
-0.2905169427394867,
0.20618627965450287,
-0.0974123626947403,
-0.9409993886947632,
0.3817126750946045,
-0.11139775812625885,
-0.8040709495544434,
0.06587397307157516,
0.3375486731529236,
-0.3210974335670471,
0.13758641481399536,
0.4569946527481079,
0.14221462607383728,
-0.2100098431110382,
0.15600228309631348,
-0.13178154826164246,
-0.3011597990989685,
0.04545718431472778,
-0.07851433008909225,
0.7080614566802979,
-0.12755250930786133,
0.06102048233151436,
-0.745664119720459,
0.5976351499557495,
0.6130733489990234,
-0.13796350359916687,
0.8034582138061523,
0.21166697144508362,
-0.317730188369751,
0.2015945017337799,
-0.06130100414156914,
-0.14910712838172913,
-0.45092228055000305,
0.6269761919975281,
-0.757477343082428,
-0.4663390517234802,
0.7859090566635132,
0.017516296356916428,
-0.16446839272975922,
0.44985297322273254,
0.49753960967063904,
-0.47795557975769043,
1.1546461582183838,
0.6421219110488892,
0.06414738297462463,
0.4022032618522644,
0.037583593279123306,
0.09273304045200348,
-0.4146735370159149,
-0.21323701739311218,
-0.5444611310958862,
0.012189654633402824,
-0.40830856561660767,
-0.03257773816585541,
0.16178327798843384,
0.33384403586387634,
-0.2437163144350052,
0.46407997608184814,
0.05994633212685585,
0.23887322843074799,
0.5410599708557129,
-0.02562769129872322,
0.39975208044052124,
-0.2308497577905655,
-0.1346348226070404,
-0.2665644884109497,
-0.6918817758560181,
-0.48063766956329346,
0.9030223488807678,
0.18429532647132874,
0.4084796607494354,
0.1213809996843338,
0.5521656274795532,
0.21694444119930267,
-0.41185155510902405,
-0.46229955554008484,
0.7035504579544067,
-0.4580186903476715,
-0.83111172914505,
-0.40631696581840515,
-0.06089630722999573,
-0.8197209239006042,
0.07406367361545563,
-0.3927830159664154,
-0.7416731119155884,
0.7217317819595337,
0.13139745593070984,
-0.4521392583847046,
0.1850881427526474,
-0.620899498462677,
0.7849389910697937,
0.0030747398268431425,
-0.23366791009902954,
-0.3199324607849121,
-0.4386093020439148,
0.24600616097450256,
-0.2843642234802246,
0.741507887840271,
-0.448258638381958,
0.03267500177025795,
1.0129295587539673,
-0.573811948299408,
0.6371434330940247,
-0.4198523163795471,
-0.1862180531024933,
0.2594825029373169,
0.536544144153595,
0.2808791697025299,
-0.14067912101745605,
-0.5190575122833252,
0.246232807636261,
0.03409465402364731,
-0.07665462791919708,
-0.1538950651884079,
0.6372892260551453,
-0.6617171764373779,
-0.3944184184074402,
0.1372441053390503,
-0.5376273393630981,
-0.6013123989105225,
0.40782061219215393,
0.27673107385635376,
0.7075560688972473,
-0.6278834342956543,
-0.0800798162817955,
0.5779374241828918,
-0.46466508507728577,
0.34030064940452576,
0.725245475769043,
-0.4820432960987091,
-0.36902567744255066,
0.8934183716773987,
0.48383378982543945,
0.14220395684242249,
-0.32687729597091675,
0.10927803814411163,
-0.274234801530838,
-0.6439875364303589,
-0.13580584526062012,
0.3549845814704895,
-0.4418775737285614,
0.10413291305303574,
-0.4774201512336731,
-0.07915589213371277,
-0.5403386950492859,
0.2156980186700821,
-0.6152974963188171,
-0.8372454643249512,
-0.12740761041641235,
-0.22006946802139282,
0.24807512760162354,
0.9074526429176331,
-0.3551180064678192,
0.665268063545227,
-0.5602407455444336,
0.26488447189331055,
0.09226299077272415,
0.8815313577651978,
-0.7568781971931458,
-0.3204635977745056,
-0.15307393670082092,
-0.1470152586698532,
0.05624943971633911,
-1.285419225692749,
0.7244258522987366,
0.560178816318512,
0.5119861960411072,
0.14375527203083038,
0.14121632277965546,
0.0800052210688591,
-0.6187271475791931,
0.8353620171546936,
0.16547012329101562,
-1.0289926528930664,
0.8315510153770447,
-0.5045160055160522,
0.017732912674546242,
0.5214158892631531,
0.3587672710418701,
-0.3484008014202118,
-0.5444421768188477,
-0.8749638199806213,
-0.8107608556747437,
0.889931857585907,
0.3053024411201477,
-0.18908481299877167,
-0.18444113433361053,
0.15031448006629944,
0.32349926233291626,
0.15839271247386932,
0.1021193340420723,
-0.07114247232675552,
-0.1350424885749817,
-0.03572350740432739,
-0.18999800086021423,
-0.7024293541908264,
0.07029779255390167,
-0.231959268450737,
0.8148695826530457,
0.4314790666103363,
0.20102278888225555,
-0.02460106462240219,
-0.02855059504508972,
-0.19734320044517517,
0.39106643199920654,
0.7087932229042053,
1.0125408172607422,
-0.6823245286941528,
0.01903337985277176,
0.05961746722459793,
-0.927316427230835,
0.20284150540828705,
-0.10381980240345001,
-0.14996927976608276,
0.6128377914428711,
0.324943870306015,
0.7087177634239197,
0.13113917410373688,
-0.5481887459754944,
0.3866896629333496,
0.032733429223299026,
-0.629726231098175,
-0.633803129196167,
-0.0428955964744091,
0.4454326629638672,
0.09577564895153046,
0.13331840932369232,
-0.028696691617369652,
0.4096800684928894,
-0.6770658493041992,
0.43163853883743286,
0.06831823289394379,
-0.4843222498893738,
-0.6670228838920593,
0.8326734900474548,
0.3115081489086151,
-0.6776900291442871,
0.7102417945861816,
0.04782100394368172,
-0.1921183466911316,
0.5251507759094238,
0.5445621013641357,
0.39813336730003357,
-0.9157181978225708,
0.3305581510066986,
0.47329092025756836,
-0.08457887172698975,
-0.04184320196509361,
0.9874363541603088,
0.42603936791419983,
-0.9240679144859314,
-0.4524906277656555,
-0.47330546379089355,
-0.520318329334259,
-0.020647436380386353,
-0.8036484718322754,
0.2660157084465027,
-0.2378745675086975,
-0.6184868216514587,
0.18622221052646637,
-0.06456217914819717,
-0.40084555745124817,
0.2735805809497833,
0.11750133335590363,
1.032924771308899,
-1.0680818557739258,
1.2614872455596924,
0.44001516699790955,
-0.16945888102054596,
-0.4211118519306183,
-0.5840060710906982,
-0.024211043491959572,
-0.6051934957504272,
0.8977189064025879,
-0.41231635212898254,
-0.2346072793006897,
-0.004022575914859772,
-0.09419063478708267,
-1.0884883403778076,
0.6812407970428467,
0.7236056923866272,
-1.0850956439971924,
0.1460164189338684,
0.3113083839416504,
0.4850907325744629,
-0.3471430838108063,
0.005272408481687307,
1.0193583965301514,
0.4583745300769806,
-0.34113505482673645,
-1.3519172668457031,
-0.45417094230651855,
-0.2416822910308838,
-0.21820403635501862,
0.23421230912208557,
-0.009598166681826115,
0.9637351036071777,
-0.08066137135028839,
-0.3534814417362213,
-0.054821934551000595,
0.5345072746276855,
0.08194532990455627,
-0.0958322212100029,
0.5145266652107239,
0.3966366648674011,
1.0208263397216797,
-0.0767771452665329,
1.1150033473968506,
-0.8105430603027344,
0.17447993159294128,
1.1846219301223755,
-0.3894120156764984,
1.0212265253067017,
0.1806713491678238,
-0.5968073010444641,
0.5330878496170044,
0.6629318594932556,
0.5200782418251038,
0.8268605470657349,
0.009395742788910866,
-0.3229079842567444,
-0.2915772497653961,
-0.11104142665863037,
-0.46082594990730286,
0.4859120547771454,
0.8022424578666687,
-0.20470289885997772,
0.037847038358449936,
0.344884991645813,
-0.1156289130449295,
0.24124407768249512,
-0.2965591549873352,
0.6242074370384216,
-0.2261372059583664,
-0.024227028712630272,
0.437566339969635,
-0.2933049201965332,
0.44872531294822693,
-0.4636497497558594,
0.27008894085884094,
-0.07364914566278458,
0.22937560081481934,
-0.4629237651824951,
-1.0525206327438354,
0.6977905631065369,
-0.3336986005306244,
-0.2205619513988495,
0.01758395880460739,
0.8254801034927368,
-0.3970339894294739,
-0.737572968006134,
0.3832259476184845,
0.7394002079963684,
0.5512176156044006,
0.043035779148340225,
-0.5116154551506042,
0.14494815468788147,
-0.2704330384731293,
-0.2559913396835327,
0.243644580245018,
0.04423441365361214,
-0.06130589544773102,
0.6531758904457092,
0.18483339250087738,
0.6227706670761108,
-0.046336300671100616,
0.419188916683197,
0.5488802194595337,
-0.4140866696834564,
-0.7238563895225525,
-0.5496670007705688,
0.1850832849740982,
-0.07338402420282364,
-0.11865052580833435,
0.618394672870636,
0.6851806640625,
0.5361648201942444,
-0.16088059544563293,
0.7503597736358643,
-0.025261498987674713,
1.2925169467926025,
-0.2124505490064621,
0.617866575717926,
0.02813282608985901,
0.12582749128341675,
-0.3992142677307129,
-0.9704440236091614,
-0.30130428075790405,
0.7413137555122375,
-0.3549673855304718,
-0.40184441208839417,
0.44097569584846497,
0.751110851764679,
0.24000200629234314,
0.42433080077171326,
0.5797795653343201,
0.31071287393569946,
0.011131489649415016,
0.27056995034217834,
0.537676215171814,
-0.2543233633041382,
0.22032812237739563,
-0.5700376033782959,
-0.1297304332256317,
0.08693049103021622,
-0.40230220556259155,
-0.3424960672855377,
-0.8553111553192139,
-0.33877450227737427,
-0.25328224897384644,
0.5026362538337708,
0.7061288952827454,
0.7646340727806091,
-1.2659870386123657,
-0.628197431564331,
-0.02509133145213127,
-0.22486209869384766,
-0.2570228576660156,
-0.17703796923160553,
0.4737875759601593,
-0.2563578486442566,
-0.6782152056694031,
0.8436045050621033,
0.07279634475708008,
-0.10657471418380737,
-0.2192518413066864,
-0.21428431570529938,
-0.11668802052736282,
0.0706702172756195,
0.5278047323226929,
0.27085357904434204,
-0.39449140429496765,
-0.04189548268914223,
0.1809145212173462,
0.22020223736763,
0.03768153488636017,
0.7795625329017639,
-0.9405790567398071,
0.5644739270210266,
0.4455615282058716,
-0.263877272605896,
0.19756321609020233,
-0.2079990655183792,
1.077714443206787,
-0.6484111547470093,
0.4289481043815613,
0.21513429284095764,
0.5112358331680298,
0.1870429813861847,
-0.36814194917678833,
0.6729728579521179,
0.2650713324546814,
-0.22640715539455414,
-0.6222468614578247,
0.29021212458610535,
-0.7180851697921753,
-0.42763128876686096,
0.815778374671936,
-0.07520949095487595,
0.019719844684004784,
-0.5764950513839722,
-0.11342611908912659,
0.14382947981357574,
-0.3018401265144348,
0.33370524644851685,
0.9341772198677063,
-0.4008012115955353,
-0.265348881483078,
-1.073352575302124,
0.7534288167953491,
0.07125052809715271,
-0.5072293281555176,
0.25462237000465393,
0.4590979814529419,
0.33251506090164185,
0.166677325963974,
0.954775333404541,
-0.45817995071411133,
0.3350064158439636,
0.20663315057754517,
0.38291800022125244,
-0.12910789251327515,
-0.5446283221244812,
-0.1306179314851761,
0.40972065925598145,
-0.0022497514728456736,
-0.13735684752464294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10102v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10102v2
|
Chinchilla Scaling: A replication attempt
| 2024-04-15T19:19:56 | 2024-05-15T00:57:23 |
Tamay Besiroglu, Ege Erdil, Matthew Barnett, Josh You
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Hoffmann et al. (2022) propose three methods for estimating a compute-optimal
scaling law. We attempt to replicate their third estimation procedure, which
involves fitting a parametric loss function to a reconstruction of data from
their plots. We find that the reported estimates are inconsistent with their
first two estimation methods, fail at fitting the extracted data, and report
implausibly narrow confidence intervals--intervals this narrow would require
over 600,000 experiments, while they likely only ran fewer than 500. In
contrast, our rederivation of the scaling law using the third approach yields
results that are compatible with the findings from the first two estimation
procedures described by Hoffmann et al.
|
[
-0.19613304734230042,
-0.38560014963150024,
0.7073563933372498,
0.5303110480308533,
0.04875154793262482,
-0.5681171417236328,
-0.0356217660009861,
-0.29524827003479004,
0.5254110097885132,
0.31414321064949036,
-0.41661813855171204,
0.38615018129348755,
-0.22406865656375885,
0.02966366522014141,
-0.552645742893219,
0.6475903987884521,
0.18588116765022278,
0.5409992933273315,
0.3736763000488281,
-0.16456447541713715,
-0.013034206815063953,
0.3114052414894104,
-0.585189163684845,
-0.17033696174621582,
0.3382176160812378,
0.5577455759048462,
1.2288529872894287,
1.0930572748184204,
0.42129775881767273,
0.11106496304273605,
-0.08196103572845459,
-0.1494041085243225,
-0.300232857465744,
-0.4812755584716797,
0.25907590985298157,
-1.0913399457931519,
-0.2834344804286957,
0.3313295245170593,
0.7646853923797607,
1.0744540691375732,
-0.40444567799568176,
0.2193211317062378,
0.06092202290892601,
0.7898032665252686,
-0.7413235306739807,
-0.3012144863605499,
-0.4699263870716095,
0.23957043886184692,
-0.2958318293094635,
-0.22490562498569489,
-0.6313444972038269,
-0.5904666781425476,
-0.09958509355783463,
-0.7799440026283264,
0.5126513838768005,
0.09664105623960495,
0.6356804370880127,
0.1606224775314331,
-0.12940213084220886,
-0.28796452283859253,
-0.5306294560432434,
0.9841634631156921,
-0.9213762879371643,
-0.09604458510875702,
0.5937820672988892,
0.23975887894630432,
0.030798783525824547,
-1.0440263748168945,
-0.615400493144989,
-0.4290909469127655,
0.14738593995571136,
-0.044194404035806656,
-0.4329589605331421,
-0.29459020495414734,
0.49347880482673645,
0.33400678634643555,
-0.36430004239082336,
-0.007579321041703224,
-0.7132192850112915,
-0.3162921369075775,
0.7622480988502502,
0.29406043887138367,
0.2016768753528595,
-0.17830826342105865,
-0.34384769201278687,
-0.3283369839191437,
-0.6744385361671448,
0.070560984313488,
0.4613027572631836,
0.5275693535804749,
-0.04588538035750389,
0.5652133226394653,
-0.013587435707449913,
0.7045589089393616,
0.4492231607437134,
-0.23750992119312286,
0.3447217047214508,
-0.28406214714050293,
-0.3253779113292694,
-0.0034531892742961645,
0.7430753111839294,
0.9722021818161011,
0.18469277024269104,
0.24466289579868317,
0.2062261998653412,
-0.35405233502388,
0.5497719049453735,
-0.6838397979736328,
-0.15306775271892548,
0.07077070325613022,
-0.7405624389648438,
-0.45677775144577026,
0.09340240806341171,
-0.9733900427818298,
-0.410876989364624,
0.05417628586292267,
0.6549309492111206,
-0.07701804488897324,
-0.2132261097431183,
-0.09117341786623001,
-0.23520836234092712,
0.4362523555755615,
0.4032333791255951,
-1.0283544063568115,
0.5794240832328796,
0.5344617366790771,
1.095644235610962,
0.14306628704071045,
-0.4450729787349701,
-0.11170592159032822,
-0.2194543331861496,
-0.9305586218833923,
0.4121898114681244,
-0.2414276897907257,
-0.45382484793663025,
-0.10448344796895981,
0.15178467333316803,
0.10104460269212723,
-0.6159082055091858,
0.5033794045448303,
-0.28572946786880493,
-0.4362824261188507,
-0.3930746018886566,
-0.4499889612197876,
-0.19737356901168823,
-0.3101431727409363,
-0.8244288563728333,
0.6542794704437256,
0.5907267332077026,
-0.8736528158187866,
0.312475323677063,
-0.13329006731510162,
-0.5248027443885803,
-0.14393627643585205,
0.2744413912296295,
-0.5654298067092896,
0.3643936812877655,
-0.0022820208687335253,
0.3727947771549225,
-0.6109150052070618,
-0.17472992837429047,
-0.9065268635749817,
-0.42933395504951477,
0.07490949332714081,
-0.2674468457698822,
1.5319894552230835,
0.2727473974227905,
-0.5109807252883911,
-0.2593134045600891,
-0.7035185098648071,
0.28761041164398193,
0.13992345333099365,
0.18572230637073517,
-0.0915338546037674,
0.032797154039144516,
0.09221012145280838,
-0.5230679512023926,
-0.06365833431482315,
-0.6916242241859436,
0.13381846249103546,
-0.143091082572937,
0.6667600274085999,
0.6558800935745239,
0.26237010955810547,
0.4604818820953369,
-0.6436176896095276,
0.5348103642463684,
-0.3852032721042633,
0.3988831639289856,
0.31545290350914,
-0.4309103190898895,
-0.40186116099357605,
0.11103081703186035,
0.008318925276398659,
0.07346045970916748,
-0.16406331956386566,
-0.3231731653213501,
0.00501248799264431,
-0.8594721555709839,
-0.2027507722377777,
-0.23436355590820312,
0.05431915819644928,
0.6863768696784973,
0.569386899471283,
-0.1000722125172615,
-0.5115533471107483,
-1.2265998125076294,
-0.4468940496444702,
-0.23206374049186707,
-0.2109096199274063,
0.026180820539593697,
0.5297102332115173,
0.06869135797023773,
0.7947909235954285,
-0.6757327318191528,
-0.1576658934354782,
-0.07888662070035934,
0.18477624654769897,
0.21785542368888855,
0.7252720594406128,
0.939505398273468,
-0.780872642993927,
-0.961402952671051,
-0.17047762870788574,
-0.4030989706516266,
0.027181843295693398,
-0.08314453065395355,
0.2108423113822937,
-0.1793384552001953,
0.5491052269935608,
-0.22516366839408875,
0.4130089282989502,
0.46475502848625183,
0.696384072303772,
0.9208999276161194,
-0.08691925555467606,
0.22294898331165314,
-0.8335886001586914,
-0.04225899651646614,
0.3359224498271942,
-0.030576584860682487,
-0.9993639588356018,
0.08378278464078903,
0.6881662011146545,
0.17803636193275452,
-0.260734498500824,
0.15497684478759766,
-0.4066294729709625,
0.011464705690741539,
-0.22964388132095337,
0.04704372584819794,
-0.26970699429512024,
0.4086233079433441,
-0.23306508362293243,
0.9617209434509277,
0.3886132836341858,
-0.43312132358551025,
0.2740584909915924,
-0.03801323100924492,
-0.04995852708816528,
0.8841195702552795,
-0.9484561085700989,
-0.24121451377868652,
0.17137028276920319,
0.36586299538612366,
-0.975747287273407,
-0.7181088328361511,
0.21846561133861542,
-0.7093826532363892,
0.20256000757217407,
0.03595070168375969,
0.01345145981758833,
-0.45609235763549805,
-1.0038847923278809,
0.26311856508255005,
0.6332231163978577,
-0.5532408952713013,
0.5508852005004883,
0.5824771523475647,
0.05441728234291077,
-0.5124427080154419,
-0.945071280002594,
-0.2416050285100937,
-0.4862804114818573,
-0.534898042678833,
0.13516686856746674,
-0.022610381245613098,
-0.39019307494163513,
-0.1398306041955948,
-0.4270189106464386,
-0.45856502652168274,
-0.0009406303288415074,
0.17498552799224854,
0.13810665905475616,
-0.3981369733810425,
-0.3329199254512787,
-0.18084868788719177,
0.36417803168296814,
0.5387847423553467,
-0.028529364615678787,
0.16664107143878937,
-0.18181397020816803,
-0.18234063684940338,
-0.9103178977966309,
0.04237208515405655,
0.5280527472496033,
0.16851677000522614,
0.4125522971153259,
0.30535322427749634,
-0.5366227030754089,
0.03655901551246643,
-0.6605185866355896,
0.14521604776382446,
-0.4572608172893524,
0.17357225716114044,
-0.23978902399539948,
-0.24369454383850098,
0.6845932602882385,
0.13830752670764923,
-0.08458366990089417,
0.9557071924209595,
0.19637779891490936,
-0.3141542077064514,
1.1350476741790771,
0.6652107834815979,
0.024933388456702232,
0.16127458214759827,
-0.1845962256193161,
-0.04138277843594551,
-1.3594050407409668,
-0.019443310797214508,
-0.9217219948768616,
-0.10905512422323227,
-0.6518248915672302,
-0.2975325882434845,
0.5017223954200745,
0.10010767728090286,
-0.2175968587398529,
0.5201214551925659,
0.02791435271501541,
0.3276831805706024,
0.6334531307220459,
0.5494723916053772,
0.05847162753343582,
0.02457367442548275,
0.26409003138542175,
-0.2159799039363861,
-0.5213479995727539,
-0.13922415673732758,
1.3531243801116943,
0.13164590299129486,
0.9007980823516846,
-0.0614081546664238,
0.620274543762207,
0.08059021085500717,
0.8595383167266846,
-0.926953136920929,
0.26671528816223145,
0.23348556458950043,
-0.7288790345191956,
-0.7498703002929688,
-0.5819035172462463,
-0.8936975002288818,
0.3698156177997589,
0.42609477043151855,
-0.8178571462631226,
0.22421054542064667,
0.39506787061691284,
-0.526301383972168,
0.3074638843536377,
-0.38694462180137634,
0.4400297999382019,
0.238136425614357,
-0.45548757910728455,
-0.2320481389760971,
-0.893191397190094,
0.6090300679206848,
-0.52767014503479,
0.42536571621894836,
0.2140466868877411,
-0.33769989013671875,
1.0085909366607666,
-0.9320178031921387,
0.700127899646759,
-0.42353659868240356,
0.11950176954269409,
0.6336758136749268,
0.2623606324195862,
0.5093478560447693,
0.1911362111568451,
-0.10037481784820557,
-0.3517971634864807,
0.30295220017433167,
-0.7271035313606262,
-0.6194745898246765,
0.48894041776657104,
-0.6120086312294006,
-0.5197339057922363,
-0.49792033433914185,
-0.31264200806617737,
-0.2639756202697754,
0.2543221414089203,
0.43046849966049194,
0.567039966583252,
-0.011893107555806637,
0.5668917894363403,
0.15242475271224976,
0.2981241047382355,
0.4828955829143524,
0.4241921901702881,
0.026154356077313423,
-0.5460044741630554,
0.6129553318023682,
0.4440867006778717,
0.5694349408149719,
-0.004700951278209686,
0.45241299271583557,
0.13196678459644318,
-0.6602896451950073,
-0.11442764848470688,
0.4273560047149658,
-0.4031681716442108,
-0.21464627981185913,
-0.4177452325820923,
-0.03257351368665695,
-0.38569656014442444,
-0.48543423414230347,
-0.5899731516838074,
-0.3254283666610718,
-0.22692571580410004,
0.2622045576572418,
-0.053044192492961884,
0.5892727375030518,
-0.719546914100647,
0.5319429039955139,
-0.42684927582740784,
0.041113052517175674,
0.08563626557588577,
0.019606199115514755,
0.36222365498542786,
-0.799643337726593,
-0.22069326043128967,
0.493667870759964,
-0.1864900290966034,
-1.2036142349243164,
0.43946436047554016,
0.07545118033885956,
0.5563216209411621,
0.3922467827796936,
0.17844220995903015,
1.0036647319793701,
-0.47865384817123413,
0.6562908887863159,
0.3749772310256958,
-0.9410532712936401,
0.5372323393821716,
-0.3070087432861328,
0.15520168840885162,
0.5264445543289185,
0.9279091954231262,
-0.3953480124473572,
-0.36465132236480713,
-0.936228334903717,
-0.5744273662567139,
0.7045776844024658,
0.002994507784023881,
0.08525659143924713,
0.15945982933044434,
0.6327908635139465,
-0.06579049676656723,
-0.17147058248519897,
-0.5650608539581299,
-0.26016509532928467,
-0.047539692372083664,
0.04100373014807701,
-0.17466379702091217,
-0.25356927514076233,
-0.21759150922298431,
-0.3071025609970093,
0.6154284477233887,
-0.43789660930633545,
-0.11814892292022705,
0.44791021943092346,
-0.189462348818779,
-0.3791971802711487,
-0.35553714632987976,
0.8500110507011414,
1.1787086725234985,
-0.4062472879886627,
-0.07278357446193695,
0.13228623569011688,
-0.9180893301963806,
0.30633771419525146,
-0.19059588015079498,
-0.2725742757320404,
-0.22357888519763947,
0.7122098207473755,
0.14138580858707428,
0.28621888160705566,
-0.2651599049568176,
0.6718003749847412,
-0.055580828338861465,
-0.5633534789085388,
-0.5958240628242493,
-0.018083522096276283,
-0.0014638351276516914,
0.25783106684684753,
0.6559674739837646,
0.3966531753540039,
0.24319028854370117,
-0.41361096501350403,
0.3041503131389618,
0.3347927927970886,
-0.44014671444892883,
-0.3092924952507019,
0.8397114872932434,
-0.19551153481006622,
-0.24470840394496918,
0.6491079330444336,
0.074735626578331,
-0.3271191120147705,
0.984364926815033,
0.38250771164894104,
0.5624727010726929,
-0.43971654772758484,
0.43305453658103943,
0.959382176399231,
0.5523519515991211,
-0.6691102981567383,
-0.0016481033526360989,
0.09714838862419128,
-0.4550570845603943,
0.08204501122236252,
-0.23775705695152283,
-0.5086604356765747,
-0.010013783350586891,
-1.5562119483947754,
-0.009581715799868107,
-0.44309645891189575,
-0.2235216647386551,
0.5741994976997375,
0.056869953870773315,
-0.20751617848873138,
0.08585736155509949,
-0.5391637086868286,
1.0603446960449219,
-1.011673927307129,
0.22666563093662262,
0.06600580364465714,
-0.5399091839790344,
-1.0656293630599976,
0.3335363268852234,
0.44035014510154724,
-1.0304617881774902,
0.20097701251506805,
0.00131708022672683,
-0.22807577252388,
-0.1547938585281372,
-0.8483834862709045,
-1.0509397983551025,
1.135028600692749,
0.2843994200229645,
-0.2974937856197357,
0.25037506222724915,
-0.2855215072631836,
0.5503295063972473,
-0.27776864171028137,
0.17855513095855713,
0.6132817268371582,
0.33723506331443787,
-0.0089983269572258,
-1.0537086725234985,
0.14890648424625397,
0.1472546011209488,
0.274873822927475,
0.13929103314876556,
-1.0483825206756592,
1.0879733562469482,
-0.8313876390457153,
-0.12538066506385803,
0.36679333448410034,
0.7399978637695312,
-0.2242591828107834,
0.08342421799898148,
0.6150557398796082,
0.18629589676856995,
0.7340129613876343,
0.27665504813194275,
1.2128703594207764,
-0.31856751441955566,
0.7679027318954468,
1.1047221422195435,
-0.35954543948173523,
0.9858117699623108,
0.5482543706893921,
-0.8794092535972595,
-0.04007282480597496,
0.9936475157737732,
-0.24786201119422913,
0.39461514353752136,
0.24572280049324036,
0.18358729779720306,
0.3597150146961212,
0.10357356816530228,
-0.4689837694168091,
0.23848216235637665,
-0.10670959204435349,
-0.21288654208183289,
-0.028766119852662086,
-0.21603608131408691,
0.5611395239830017,
-0.2562866508960724,
-0.3873251676559448,
0.05723297595977783,
-0.19813182950019836,
-0.5832509994506836,
0.7630955576896667,
-0.08152453601360321,
0.09495974332094193,
-0.38021552562713623,
0.153208926320076,
-0.5523481369018555,
0.29720473289489746,
-0.24159137904644012,
-0.5762621164321899,
0.2905641198158264,
-0.3107837438583374,
0.1464010775089264,
0.12603136897087097,
0.15110616385936737,
0.06280174851417542,
-0.38273727893829346,
0.00977614801377058,
-0.12605831027030945,
0.24872678518295288,
0.11541517823934555,
-0.31266582012176514,
0.0820845365524292,
0.3576854169368744,
-0.5936006307601929,
0.15810200572013855,
-0.04642590507864952,
0.36197420954704285,
0.6673340201377869,
0.09727974981069565,
0.19894129037857056,
0.24126742780208588,
-0.28666195273399353,
0.5661613941192627,
-0.3638717532157898,
-0.15382559597492218,
-0.6534831523895264,
0.08064213395118713,
-0.2730672061443329,
-0.4640059769153595,
0.9364954233169556,
0.6914784908294678,
0.864940345287323,
0.020800944417715073,
0.6484613418579102,
-0.2688099443912506,
0.4382690191268921,
-0.4369240403175354,
0.18638423085212708,
-0.8300065994262695,
-0.18502303957939148,
-0.1936422735452652,
-0.9361492395401001,
-0.21361617743968964,
0.6897872686386108,
0.23337270319461823,
0.24113769829273224,
1.1741851568222046,
0.8146508932113647,
-0.013563795946538448,
0.46694067120552063,
-0.09467658400535583,
0.5014563202857971,
0.02911435440182686,
0.20485663414001465,
0.11911322176456451,
-0.4670698642730713,
0.25248441100120544,
-0.7563201189041138,
-0.7581720948219299,
-0.3164548873901367,
-0.4054039716720581,
-0.24949876964092255,
-0.591419517993927,
-0.17617115378379822,
-0.5097169280052185,
-0.23127441108226776,
0.5997195839881897,
0.7420875430107117,
-0.471967488527298,
-0.5768709182739258,
0.07730607688426971,
-0.35116156935691833,
-0.7799152135848999,
-0.17034763097763062,
0.39130890369415283,
-0.21340925991535187,
-0.6281004548072815,
0.18490000069141388,
0.08242437988519669,
0.044955603778362274,
-0.5018665790557861,
0.1666206270456314,
-0.08993196487426758,
0.06495292484760284,
-0.03857266157865524,
0.6467022895812988,
-0.7421647906303406,
-0.5398594737052917,
-0.25421783328056335,
-0.3113207221031189,
0.0578327514231205,
0.8420538306236267,
-0.005606528837233782,
0.3963630199432373,
0.3926236033439636,
0.43694594502449036,
0.7589224576950073,
-0.11600278317928314,
0.6452071070671082,
-0.03086225874722004,
-0.038325127214193344,
0.15408127009868622,
0.17152859270572662,
-0.05496066063642502,
-0.05744873732328415,
0.895839512348175,
0.06561301648616791,
-0.5424129962921143,
-1.1597741842269897,
0.129192054271698,
-0.8779230117797852,
-0.16095340251922607,
0.5311843752861023,
-0.23394985496997833,
-0.5896918773651123,
0.4485933482646942,
0.0469500795006752,
-0.033164121210575104,
0.028664493933320045,
0.5324615836143494,
0.7759069800376892,
-0.7811092734336853,
-0.06418520957231522,
-1.0785125494003296,
0.5105507373809814,
0.41465625166893005,
-0.5101144909858704,
0.049840252846479416,
0.30470937490463257,
0.534580409526825,
0.4956405758857727,
0.678577721118927,
-0.10278131812810898,
0.38183578848838806,
0.6993717551231384,
-0.5994206666946411,
0.5105218291282654,
-0.20995527505874634,
-0.43695080280303955,
0.30885961651802063,
0.08121342957019806,
0.17893894016742706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10054v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10054v1
|
AIGeN: An Adversarial Approach for Instruction Generation in VLN
| 2024-04-15T18:00:30 | 2024-04-15T18:00:30 |
Niyati Rawal, Roberto Bigazzi, Lorenzo Baraldi, Rita Cucchiara
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO
|
In the last few years, the research interest in Vision-and-Language
Navigation (VLN) has grown significantly. VLN is a challenging task that
involves an agent following human instructions and navigating in a previously
unknown environment to reach a specified goal. Recent work in literature
focuses on different ways to augment the available datasets of instructions for
improving navigation performance by exploiting synthetic training data. In this
work, we propose AIGeN, a novel architecture inspired by Generative Adversarial
Networks (GANs) that produces meaningful and well-formed synthetic instructions
to improve navigation agents' performance. The model is composed of a
Transformer decoder (GPT-2) and a Transformer encoder (BERT). During the
training phase, the decoder generates sentences for a sequence of images
describing the agent's path to a particular point while the encoder
discriminates between real and fake instructions. Experimentally, we evaluate
the quality of the generated instructions and perform extensive ablation
studies. Additionally, we generate synthetic instructions for 217K trajectories
using AIGeN on Habitat-Matterport 3D Dataset (HM3D) and show an improvement in
the performance of an off-the-shelf VLN method. The validation analysis of our
proposal is conducted on REVERIE and R2R and highlights the promising aspects
of our proposal, achieving state-of-the-art performance.
|
[
-0.35299181938171387,
-0.6897473335266113,
0.32440465688705444,
-0.17475935816764832,
-0.2539235055446625,
0.23887674510478973,
-0.06837934255599976,
-0.3435766398906708,
-0.013078230433166027,
0.34970593452453613,
-0.6877499222755432,
-0.5693246722221375,
-0.2944343388080597,
-0.1787213534116745,
-0.47262799739837646,
0.5041593909263611,
0.18227717280387878,
0.22465628385543823,
-0.20714206993579865,
0.03738914430141449,
-0.25047045946121216,
-0.29278403520584106,
-0.5876447558403015,
-0.25158071517944336,
0.07684420794248581,
0.19734369218349457,
0.7269022464752197,
0.8522505760192871,
0.39819827675819397,
0.35908788442611694,
0.021867141127586365,
0.6460702419281006,
-0.41473978757858276,
0.08591099828481674,
-0.20043019950389862,
-0.46729007363319397,
-0.08501054346561432,
-0.201806902885437,
0.4991074204444885,
0.14796149730682373,
-0.08010304719209671,
-0.33343756198883057,
-0.0058173518627882,
0.7383695840835571,
-0.3749833405017853,
0.27307695150375366,
-0.2893006205558777,
0.20765705406665802,
-0.11479159444570541,
-0.5085881352424622,
-0.4848099648952484,
-0.3864927291870117,
0.14056150615215302,
-0.9689447283744812,
0.5588304400444031,
0.1115918755531311,
0.6976596713066101,
0.4352768361568451,
-0.3120681941509247,
-0.4710386097431183,
-0.8959745168685913,
0.40449708700180054,
-0.37817609310150146,
0.33807021379470825,
-0.23669928312301636,
0.6359047889709473,
-0.324948787689209,
-0.7692905068397522,
-0.4718921184539795,
-0.3048091232776642,
-0.1533212661743164,
0.483106404542923,
-0.18994271755218506,
0.21278616786003113,
-0.01652512140572071,
0.1253257691860199,
-0.8566468954086304,
-0.010688883252441883,
-0.6804457306861877,
-0.16875989735126495,
0.7502802014350891,
0.1534179449081421,
0.5278653502464294,
0.048765771090984344,
-0.7205000519752502,
-0.5969882607460022,
-0.9970722198486328,
-0.09882938116788864,
0.43852996826171875,
0.3152584433555603,
-0.08815600723028183,
0.5156365036964417,
-0.22026413679122925,
0.7635838389396667,
0.013146551325917244,
0.33484286069869995,
0.1998818814754486,
-0.29488110542297363,
0.1930999755859375,
0.3031267523765564,
0.7174745798110962,
0.42021459341049194,
0.30426061153411865,
-0.39403778314590454,
-0.16696518659591675,
0.20600993931293488,
0.8539025187492371,
-0.6274437308311462,
-0.7159827947616577,
-0.1689392775297165,
-0.4217574894428253,
-0.34329724311828613,
0.05206391587853432,
-1.005624771118164,
-0.4415253698825836,
-0.30885615944862366,
0.4664507508277893,
-0.73252272605896,
-0.08826202154159546,
0.01382048986852169,
-0.10511673241853714,
0.7315977811813354,
0.48660212755203247,
-0.6233788132667542,
-0.025326255708932877,
0.5780071020126343,
0.7677434682846069,
-0.06655919551849365,
-0.15016086399555206,
-0.4900771677494049,
-0.03939612954854965,
-0.22259795665740967,
0.6502882242202759,
-0.4373934864997864,
-0.9964417815208435,
0.018435245379805565,
-0.18376193940639496,
-0.08692240715026855,
-0.42883387207984924,
0.1871577650308609,
-0.5832136869430542,
0.35812413692474365,
-0.15866144001483917,
-0.32275423407554626,
-0.5780332684516907,
0.3146287798881531,
-0.5113807320594788,
0.5971892476081848,
0.13076207041740417,
-0.1265488862991333,
-0.007762890309095383,
-0.7875189781188965,
-0.7844523191452026,
0.4634317457675934,
-0.5356765985488892,
-0.27582982182502747,
0.13498365879058838,
0.32531481981277466,
-0.18903754651546478,
-0.3411601185798645,
-0.12527291476726532,
0.3299262821674347,
-0.6015569567680359,
-0.06866166740655899,
-0.8363213539123535,
0.9038176536560059,
0.10550937801599503,
-0.7353494763374329,
0.12364225834608078,
-0.7109531760215759,
0.144067645072937,
0.23209348320960999,
-0.3967140018939972,
-0.19355106353759766,
0.21294288337230682,
-0.2772315740585327,
0.046260301023721695,
0.10747025907039642,
-0.43315014243125916,
0.535561740398407,
-0.6787059307098389,
-0.019566811621189117,
0.7683277130126953,
0.0834362730383873,
0.4119715988636017,
-0.10147852450609207,
0.648306667804718,
-0.329231858253479,
0.34964269399642944,
-0.09440713375806808,
-0.7645878791809082,
-0.9980165362358093,
0.18614402413368225,
-0.1048223078250885,
0.7089934349060059,
-1.4689602851867676,
0.16469478607177734,
-0.4010239541530609,
-0.3974982500076294,
-0.7224392890930176,
-0.009988208301365376,
0.7280976176261902,
0.4305373728275299,
0.7201387882232666,
-0.07813873887062073,
-0.4198715388774872,
-0.6275953054428101,
0.15551790595054626,
-0.3878690302371979,
-0.029917161911725998,
0.3198491632938385,
0.2649889886379242,
-0.3577427864074707,
0.6660357117652893,
-0.508937656879425,
-0.190527081489563,
-0.16839508712291718,
0.15312327444553375,
-0.4092317521572113,
0.47658172249794006,
0.5888329148292542,
-0.9201245307922363,
-0.3409155011177063,
0.10311010479927063,
-0.8784849047660828,
0.21545839309692383,
-0.25365835428237915,
-0.4037552773952484,
-0.056730445474386215,
0.7190843224525452,
-0.5533162951469421,
0.5271563529968262,
0.3211170434951782,
-0.23996657133102417,
0.21870015561580658,
-0.5487305521965027,
0.16558434069156647,
-0.8743470907211304,
-0.08930952101945877,
-0.10429693013429642,
0.06986276805400848,
-0.6056730151176453,
0.40486180782318115,
-0.10623378306627274,
-0.1025741919875145,
-0.6422872543334961,
0.5666453242301941,
-0.36886876821517944,
0.11224176734685898,
-0.28244784474372864,
0.057726502418518066,
0.10472151637077332,
0.5629914999008179,
0.033812057226896286,
1.0967447757720947,
0.3261861801147461,
-0.7100170850753784,
0.9106591939926147,
0.5516839623451233,
-0.16700708866119385,
0.38776612281799316,
-0.42963364720344543,
0.2048822045326233,
-0.35712409019470215,
0.1025073453783989,
-0.9066234230995178,
-0.15449604392051697,
0.472246378660202,
-0.6397289037704468,
0.5103667378425598,
-0.195818230509758,
-0.29518553614616394,
-0.43242430686950684,
-0.040573686361312866,
0.24098528921604156,
0.8941813111305237,
-0.8901565670967102,
0.9775611758232117,
-0.12828616797924042,
0.26665642857551575,
-0.2697627544403076,
-0.6502886414527893,
0.3018520772457123,
-0.08580983430147171,
-0.647864818572998,
0.5494362711906433,
-0.02167990617454052,
-0.2216743379831314,
0.3269638121128082,
0.34641483426094055,
0.4211035370826721,
0.10907503217458725,
0.22021479904651642,
0.43709030747413635,
-0.2475569099187851,
-0.1326681673526764,
-0.08482080698013306,
-0.21907319128513336,
0.2637726664543152,
-0.47635722160339355,
0.4993196427822113,
-0.23442591726779938,
-0.526644229888916,
-0.2046958953142166,
0.19725994765758514,
0.5735805630683899,
-0.3441999852657318,
0.6556919813156128,
0.7852222323417664,
-0.06544724851846695,
-0.3798207640647888,
-0.0620928630232811,
-0.1452656239271164,
-0.5763385891914368,
0.27950718998908997,
-0.2887190878391266,
-0.17363369464874268,
0.19977624714374542,
-0.2705996036529541,
0.191387340426445,
0.47889408469200134,
0.37123996019363403,
-0.13614420592784882,
1.0872175693511963,
0.39959466457366943,
0.22914724051952362,
0.36779096722602844,
-0.7389969229698181,
0.20666663348674774,
-0.8622282147407532,
-0.6806957125663757,
-0.01934843696653843,
-0.40183308720588684,
-0.6339564919471741,
-0.7735781669616699,
0.9110403656959534,
-0.5411557555198669,
-0.012001661583781242,
0.18388497829437256,
-0.5858422517776489,
0.3227808475494385,
1.0158225297927856,
0.17664772272109985,
-0.11864519119262695,
0.03897340968251228,
-0.19865061342716217,
0.21284250915050507,
-1.0220355987548828,
-0.13351304829120636,
0.9731417298316956,
0.00493648461997509,
0.9864748120307922,
0.19659948348999023,
0.6491789817810059,
0.5844427943229675,
0.14185777306556702,
-0.6626093983650208,
0.8082940578460693,
-0.43590936064720154,
-0.378996342420578,
-0.17545418441295624,
-0.42411208152770996,
-0.8177793622016907,
0.32630133628845215,
-0.15600566565990448,
-0.3256571292877197,
0.12015683948993683,
0.3154837191104889,
-0.527414083480835,
0.22421665489673615,
-0.6610644459724426,
0.6224271655082703,
-0.7871565818786621,
-0.47047433257102966,
-0.08261784166097641,
-0.9103363156318665,
0.30379199981689453,
0.3191303312778473,
-0.13443925976753235,
0.5104131698608398,
0.2761712968349457,
0.37545105814933777,
-0.38568606972694397,
0.6058176755905151,
-0.5951038599014282,
-0.08145415037870407,
0.5796030163764954,
-0.03431828320026398,
0.7141889333724976,
-0.22262342274188995,
-0.0036057892721146345,
-0.14942078292369843,
-0.9126802682876587,
0.06249292939901352,
-0.616637647151947,
0.7644456624984741,
-0.6983051300048828,
-0.621325671672821,
-0.20478428900241852,
-0.28221139311790466,
-0.18346793949604034,
0.005737492814660072,
0.698387861251831,
0.6372427344322205,
-0.2721952497959137,
0.24222494661808014,
0.9224941730499268,
-0.6646164059638977,
0.16829684376716614,
0.3584166169166565,
0.17493578791618347,
-0.37330999970436096,
1.2661479711532593,
-0.13393525779247284,
0.25965628027915955,
0.364644855260849,
0.04484863206744194,
-0.5589248538017273,
-0.5708684921264648,
-1.224837064743042,
-0.08906286954879761,
-0.6461431384086609,
-0.17907966673374176,
-0.2750101089477539,
-0.6839945912361145,
-0.18380317091941833,
-0.49600932002067566,
-0.6275488138198853,
-0.058327894657850266,
-0.3821621835231781,
0.07272318750619888,
0.08634800463914871,
0.6692776083946228,
-0.09349149465560913,
0.3889935314655304,
-0.7077759504318237,
0.4659675657749176,
0.4044029414653778,
-0.06472525745630264,
0.028452908620238304,
-0.40453770756721497,
-0.27511128783226013,
0.34810125827789307,
-0.07773158699274063,
-0.45828011631965637,
0.4270777404308319,
0.16459856927394867,
0.7306641936302185,
0.20055373013019562,
0.06272599846124649,
0.4951888620853424,
-0.5702224969863892,
0.768358588218689,
-0.0004489562998060137,
-0.3471614122390747,
0.7824144959449768,
-0.1707945019006729,
0.524315357208252,
0.43164730072021484,
0.03676357865333557,
-0.04956474527716637,
-0.2824433147907257,
-0.535844624042511,
-1.0328893661499023,
0.577995777130127,
0.3491600453853607,
0.09320079535245895,
0.2466651052236557,
0.3731438219547272,
-0.26977062225341797,
-0.012344272807240486,
-0.28529828786849976,
-0.37215059995651245,
-0.2820255160331726,
-0.4127177894115448,
-0.030925719067454338,
-0.028074586763978004,
-0.3358374536037445,
0.048472922295331955,
0.8620449900627136,
0.005267848260700703,
0.4696163833141327,
0.13802605867385864,
-0.0935840830206871,
-0.04791759327054024,
-0.22112023830413818,
0.6765612363815308,
0.046590227633714676,
-0.017573097720742226,
-0.04681463912129402,
-0.1566465198993683,
-0.5336217284202576,
0.393755167722702,
0.3770217001438141,
-0.6283908486366272,
0.006146283354610205,
0.361808180809021,
0.9145610928535461,
-0.31156235933303833,
-0.5071706771850586,
0.5085799098014832,
-0.3048858642578125,
-0.15826842188835144,
-0.3718563914299011,
0.6124433279037476,
-0.32688477635383606,
0.43518757820129395,
0.28558188676834106,
0.3195187449455261,
0.3424580991268158,
-0.39130452275276184,
0.24709352850914001,
0.44857436418533325,
-0.41687196493148804,
-0.17478421330451965,
1.0082712173461914,
0.6554659008979797,
-0.2951437532901764,
0.9478284120559692,
-0.5632420182228088,
-0.7131410837173462,
0.6376633644104004,
0.3239123821258545,
1.0141785144805908,
-0.4053955376148224,
0.2687471807003021,
0.31670770049095154,
0.5497854351997375,
0.05760898068547249,
0.12990526854991913,
-0.027194794267416,
-0.4839874505996704,
-0.1193915531039238,
-0.5898910760879517,
-0.27022984623908997,
0.07482725381851196,
-0.5438559651374817,
0.03593645989894867,
-0.21894524991512299,
0.20756025612354279,
-0.5830463767051697,
-0.3306005001068115,
-0.7391982078552246,
0.5077904462814331,
0.5063077807426453,
0.6450931429862976,
-0.6021557450294495,
0.609022855758667,
0.6904253959655762,
-0.047037482261657715,
-0.3323030471801758,
0.2601528465747833,
0.41692858934402466,
-1.1105828285217285,
0.4496365189552307,
0.12313184887170792,
-0.5310808420181274,
0.19822955131530762,
-0.12648451328277588,
-0.6433831453323364,
1.1092026233673096,
-0.014426765032112598,
-0.5066515803337097,
-0.4268569052219391,
0.20381498336791992,
0.5604848265647888,
-0.17761865258216858,
-0.2740027904510498,
0.31061097979545593,
0.35474279522895813,
0.3779279589653015,
-0.1842455118894577,
-0.07505527883768082,
-0.6047866940498352,
0.19664955139160156,
-0.029835961759090424,
-0.8027486205101013,
0.5142909288406372,
-0.3918994069099426,
-0.3355252742767334,
0.25589874386787415,
0.6026520133018494,
0.0058913263492286205,
-0.014585169032216072,
0.44956091046333313,
0.4218854308128357,
0.4290522634983063,
-0.2789861857891083,
1.1804667711257935,
-0.518597424030304,
-0.13876691460609436,
1.0889679193496704,
0.08358938992023468,
0.28472116589546204,
0.10350671410560608,
0.18817146122455597,
0.5425640344619751,
0.2363700568675995,
-0.08375220745801926,
1.0253475904464722,
0.2983928918838501,
-0.4826487600803375,
0.00815534871071577,
0.019776657223701477,
-0.49554625153541565,
0.8094074130058289,
0.6574628949165344,
-0.4683610498905182,
-0.2627907395362854,
0.453965425491333,
-0.279244065284729,
0.08062455803155899,
-0.17220830917358398,
0.8541011810302734,
-0.29524490237236023,
-0.6897311806678772,
0.3984535038471222,
0.024302847683429718,
0.3096383213996887,
-0.6660749316215515,
-0.36593881249427795,
-0.2681678831577301,
0.322858989238739,
0.21133337914943695,
-0.7951050996780396,
0.050476886332035065,
0.05592341348528862,
0.4030562937259674,
-0.3317110538482666,
0.7096620202064514,
-0.5193026661872864,
-0.5134841203689575,
0.10211127996444702,
0.33845987915992737,
-0.24837546050548553,
0.2594630718231201,
-0.4680488109588623,
0.06153247132897377,
0.40577584505081177,
-0.35263150930404663,
-0.05696478113532066,
0.3367147743701935,
0.32021284103393555,
0.7618966102600098,
0.4096187651157379,
0.08381123840808868,
0.1859680861234665,
0.010909471660852432,
0.8927417397499084,
-0.4676145613193512,
-0.4303293824195862,
-0.7182813286781311,
0.6814126372337341,
-0.09841152280569077,
-0.2569480240345001,
0.7371084094047546,
0.7673266530036926,
0.8597309589385986,
-0.08499222993850708,
1.0493452548980713,
-0.01895386539399624,
-0.06751854717731476,
-0.9326400756835938,
0.5196414589881897,
-0.5717076659202576,
0.4284566640853882,
0.4092261493206024,
-0.7404033541679382,
-0.04223557189106941,
0.7110481262207031,
-0.07112326472997665,
0.01861216127872467,
0.14436312019824982,
0.9238641858100891,
-0.19284135103225708,
-0.25314339995384216,
0.12070109695196152,
0.08346650749444962,
0.747130811214447,
0.6267068982124329,
0.8730210661888123,
-0.5042761564254761,
0.6449316143989563,
-0.2751753330230713,
-0.031347814947366714,
-0.5580083131790161,
-0.2110842913389206,
-0.6067960858345032,
-0.41920205950737,
-0.240194171667099,
-0.4811765253543854,
0.5089030265808105,
0.6098468899726868,
0.523060142993927,
-0.36168408393859863,
0.09696903079748154,
-0.5424484014511108,
-0.29600659012794495,
-0.07971519976854324,
-0.24309004843235016,
0.26768067479133606,
-0.22204656898975372,
-0.720835268497467,
1.1140222549438477,
0.3080309331417084,
0.49978718161582947,
-0.6888600587844849,
-0.3155699670314789,
0.052809689193964005,
0.04343273118138313,
0.42062267661094666,
0.4662936329841614,
-0.5340698957443237,
-0.3610195815563202,
0.023929240182042122,
-0.12922769784927368,
-0.014980265870690346,
0.5042634010314941,
-0.8935957551002502,
1.0826406478881836,
0.3803093433380127,
0.679486095905304,
0.4596620500087738,
0.30361613631248474,
0.8616124391555786,
-0.7568320035934448,
0.021328484639525414,
0.33506956696510315,
0.1567598283290863,
0.4988538920879364,
-0.5478954315185547,
0.7015775442123413,
0.17089910805225372,
-0.1844879686832428,
-0.2687191069126129,
0.24863022565841675,
-0.6694242358207703,
-0.24215281009674072,
1.2709341049194336,
-0.06106282398104668,
-0.4439053237438202,
0.2977314591407776,
-0.38830384612083435,
0.30764955282211304,
-0.10718387365341187,
0.9394052624702454,
0.10411031544208527,
-0.30569538474082947,
0.18041156232357025,
-0.4412948787212372,
0.5875629782676697,
0.009712807834148407,
-0.7978935837745667,
-0.13132815062999725,
0.7241889834403992,
-0.2885848581790924,
0.298226535320282,
0.16655562818050385,
-0.09032459557056427,
0.4991154372692108,
0.414458304643631,
-0.05963067710399628,
-0.4055662751197815,
-0.7801925539970398,
-0.05122169852256775,
0.10481657832860947,
-0.33451810479164124,
-0.7137735486030579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09992v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09992v1
|
MMInA: Benchmarking Multihop Multimodal Internet Agents
| 2024-04-15T17:59:50 | 2024-04-15T17:59:50 |
Ziniu Zhang, Shulin Tian, Liangyu Chen, Ziwei Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Autonomous embodied agents live on an Internet of multimedia websites. Can
they hop around multimodal websites to complete complex user tasks? Existing
benchmarks fail to assess them in a realistic, evolving environment for their
embodiment across websites. To answer this question, we present MMInA, a
multihop and multimodal benchmark to evaluate the embodied agents for
compositional Internet tasks, with several appealing properties: 1) Evolving
real-world multimodal websites. Our benchmark uniquely operates on evolving
real-world websites, ensuring a high degree of realism and applicability to
natural user tasks. Our data includes 1,050 human-written tasks covering
various domains such as shopping and travel, with each task requiring the agent
to autonomously extract multimodal information from web pages as observations;
2) Multihop web browsing. Our dataset features naturally compositional tasks
that require information from or actions on multiple websites to solve, to
assess long-range reasoning capabilities on web tasks; 3) Holistic evaluation.
We propose a novel protocol for evaluating an agent's progress in completing
multihop tasks. We experiment with both standalone (multimodal) language models
and heuristic-based web agents. Extensive experiments demonstrate that while
long-chain multihop web tasks are easy for humans, they remain challenging for
state-of-the-art web agents. We identify that agents are more likely to fail on
the early hops when solving tasks of more hops, which results in lower task
success rates. To address this issue, we propose a simple memory augmentation
approach replaying past action trajectories to reflect. Our method
significantly improved both the single-hop and multihop web browsing abilities
of agents. See our code and data at https://mmina.cliangyu.com
|
[
-0.46115466952323914,
-0.5797220468521118,
0.39468711614608765,
0.30669328570365906,
0.15662209689617157,
0.25936567783355713,
-0.01974598318338394,
-0.72381591796875,
0.3516158163547516,
0.15392671525478363,
-0.8793243765830994,
-0.0736132338643074,
-0.26446664333343506,
0.25585243105888367,
-0.14614246785640717,
0.36066800355911255,
0.059776317328214645,
-0.13307403028011322,
-0.5979515314102173,
-0.30084899067878723,
-0.4086519479751587,
-0.3159050941467285,
-0.5505104064941406,
-0.13818660378456116,
0.643095076084137,
0.32401350140571594,
0.6561053991317749,
0.42076149582862854,
0.42130768299102783,
0.49033981561660767,
0.4927382469177246,
0.7817659974098206,
-0.24345526099205017,
0.27130645513534546,
-0.10148131102323532,
-0.3928050100803375,
-0.8096979856491089,
0.10022245347499847,
0.3729730546474457,
0.427168607711792,
0.000947976135648787,
0.0672643855214119,
-0.25279852747917175,
0.39785870909690857,
-1.1288257837295532,
-0.06512230634689331,
-0.24032896757125854,
-0.010445432737469673,
0.023565366864204407,
-0.2773866355419159,
-0.42483341693878174,
-0.06909821182489395,
-0.16706085205078125,
-0.8572889566421509,
-0.1232730969786644,
-0.025524413213133812,
0.46284857392311096,
0.2500323951244354,
-0.7668675184249878,
-0.2641220986843109,
-0.5368739366531372,
0.8589411973953247,
-0.34546545147895813,
0.7143498659133911,
0.41484394669532776,
0.650952935218811,
-0.1059708520770073,
-0.7815101146697998,
-0.7964892387390137,
-0.49785083532333374,
0.17444442212581635,
0.28492632508277893,
-0.37736913561820984,
-0.26328667998313904,
0.23616471886634827,
0.02695019170641899,
-0.5128782391548157,
-0.20916379988193512,
-0.0717255249619484,
-0.3888659179210663,
0.3343007564544678,
0.21014973521232605,
0.5127546787261963,
0.05290578678250313,
-0.2994104027748108,
-0.5656684637069702,
-0.20729416608810425,
0.08544831722974777,
0.5640743970870972,
0.1244189664721489,
-0.02577848546206951,
0.5664856433868408,
-0.41806742548942566,
0.48988404870033264,
-0.17101749777793884,
-0.4615379571914673,
0.5780972838401794,
-0.22788400948047638,
-0.024649979546666145,
-0.47573521733283997,
0.44585907459259033,
0.6138160228729248,
0.11168257147073746,
-0.2780550718307495,
0.017155658453702927,
0.30296799540519714,
0.6997434496879578,
-0.7050302624702454,
-0.1261841356754303,
0.38147780299186707,
-0.34119176864624023,
0.05521363765001297,
0.1056772992014885,
-0.8037503361701965,
-0.3035169541835785,
-0.4019218981266022,
0.6488795876502991,
-0.46141380071640015,
-0.22423745691776276,
-0.1463117152452469,
-0.47464051842689514,
0.12222494930028915,
0.5458509922027588,
-0.5385393500328064,
0.36372390389442444,
0.6368966102600098,
0.7691568732261658,
-0.05992015451192856,
-0.8585329651832581,
-0.6026522517204285,
0.10279975086450577,
-0.24076099693775177,
0.9517969489097595,
-0.5984353423118591,
0.011605894193053246,
0.02490740641951561,
0.16660954058170319,
-0.13974830508232117,
-0.43287163972854614,
0.5435022711753845,
-0.4948064684867859,
-0.16508863866329193,
-0.14511744678020477,
-0.3280670940876007,
-0.1741722673177719,
0.7389833927154541,
-0.9353695511817932,
0.7595003843307495,
-0.13202647864818573,
-0.2768408954143524,
0.51838618516922,
-0.7422844767570496,
-0.5052486062049866,
-0.34296438097953796,
0.2563113570213318,
-0.06940166652202606,
0.03659588471055031,
0.23462113738059998,
0.255990594625473,
-0.053595107048749924,
-0.4370110332965851,
-0.5795473456382751,
-0.3149535357952118,
0.6025860905647278,
-0.7379283905029297,
0.5159360766410828,
0.006360253784805536,
-0.2833966016769409,
0.11271451413631439,
-1.0565364360809326,
0.20669028162956238,
-0.09307041764259338,
-0.4754509925842285,
-0.23680180311203003,
-0.024208033457398415,
0.13880246877670288,
0.4556887447834015,
0.26321762800216675,
-0.4118032455444336,
0.37524527311325073,
0.07976669818162918,
0.13626165688037872,
0.9527761936187744,
-0.21379293501377106,
0.25208860635757446,
-0.7043141722679138,
0.43745508790016174,
0.07477925717830658,
0.3610513210296631,
-0.4521753489971161,
-0.3968527317047119,
-0.7805009484291077,
-0.5091145038604736,
-0.05164780467748642,
0.23755092918872833,
-0.8547559976577759,
-0.001254896866157651,
-0.5996378064155579,
-0.5540289878845215,
-0.5694820284843445,
0.07212215662002563,
0.3296389579772949,
0.024075884371995926,
0.5882134437561035,
-0.44605833292007446,
-0.1964493989944458,
-0.7888581156730652,
-0.11412130296230316,
0.11009682714939117,
-0.18119771778583527,
0.49630290269851685,
0.5440983772277832,
-0.5813883543014526,
0.5489969253540039,
-0.21233603358268738,
-0.1048140600323677,
0.26031506061553955,
0.5752354860305786,
-0.286088228225708,
0.4896527826786041,
0.34230631589889526,
-0.879070520401001,
-0.3987257778644562,
-0.02922559343278408,
-0.7537080645561218,
-0.005346368066966534,
-0.25576251745224,
-0.24449422955513,
-0.0076932706870138645,
0.21361912786960602,
-0.9645958542823792,
0.20381903648376465,
0.5785961747169495,
-0.2777581512928009,
0.7245160937309265,
-0.385215163230896,
0.6969105005264282,
-0.8212363123893738,
0.2526377737522125,
-0.277716726064682,
-0.4237081706523895,
-0.5028619170188904,
0.32964199781417847,
0.2860247492790222,
0.020651603117585182,
-0.4740883409976959,
0.6944348216056824,
-0.7900115847587585,
-0.39822059869766235,
-0.46730169653892517,
0.03737777844071388,
0.1311875432729721,
0.8121913075447083,
-0.4085679352283478,
0.6885460615158081,
0.49692708253860474,
-0.8495750427246094,
0.5000717639923096,
0.023127475753426552,
0.04846058413386345,
0.9791142344474792,
-0.2797487676143646,
0.46468061208724976,
-0.07275179773569107,
0.24811425805091858,
-1.0867154598236084,
-0.22856833040714264,
0.09774760156869888,
-0.4452795088291168,
-0.046602796763181686,
0.02318626642227173,
-0.6896189451217651,
-0.22965344786643982,
-0.6468209028244019,
0.5649988055229187,
0.15570399165153503,
-0.45412665605545044,
1.0347779989242554,
0.04010128974914551,
0.38705456256866455,
-0.6933335065841675,
-0.39106687903404236,
0.24719782173633575,
-0.0014171169605106115,
-0.7129182815551758,
0.321051687002182,
-0.5340609550476074,
-0.17374321818351746,
-0.12007056921720505,
-0.14275018870830536,
-0.18823572993278503,
0.13180801272392273,
0.2938137948513031,
-0.136341854929924,
-0.11567361652851105,
-0.045196518301963806,
0.009086494334042072,
-0.15070077776908875,
-0.08564198017120361,
-0.0884527638554573,
0.6115573048591614,
0.06634249538183212,
-0.8321728706359863,
-0.4449814260005951,
0.37626948952674866,
0.9525384306907654,
-0.2393450140953064,
0.45075130462646484,
0.7582707405090332,
-0.32361167669296265,
-0.14612990617752075,
-0.6669577360153198,
-0.17140045762062073,
-0.4567801058292389,
-0.15303733944892883,
-0.6913600564002991,
-0.30718308687210083,
0.4931093454360962,
-0.3101023733615875,
0.17606595158576965,
0.1319764405488968,
0.3220168352127075,
-0.19610156118869781,
0.9578184485435486,
0.44592422246932983,
0.13129018247127533,
0.37196701765060425,
-0.24544496834278107,
-0.39916110038757324,
-0.9076739549636841,
0.007054277695715427,
-0.33218249678611755,
-0.7135044932365417,
-0.5877517461776733,
-0.7320643067359924,
0.41725581884384155,
-0.23654530942440033,
0.008490480482578278,
0.2915288805961609,
0.12148379534482956,
0.3295542597770691,
0.7033571004867554,
0.4134732782840729,
0.3844532072544098,
-0.20526669919490814,
-0.13003592193126678,
0.10866402089595795,
-0.17618484795093536,
-0.3278464376926422,
1.2990537881851196,
-0.08903280645608902,
0.5970935225486755,
0.5913224220275879,
0.19699864089488983,
0.8061621189117432,
0.3193623125553131,
-0.5567455291748047,
0.544219970703125,
0.09708905965089798,
-0.6169857978820801,
-0.16936804354190826,
-0.24524584412574768,
-1.0919796228408813,
0.6446161866188049,
-0.27098843455314636,
-0.6804351210594177,
0.22190885245800018,
0.17695240676403046,
-0.05045854300260544,
-0.051354873925447464,
-0.42094630002975464,
1.0143247842788696,
-0.39564597606658936,
-0.8336573243141174,
-0.6024590730667114,
-0.627524733543396,
0.12536615133285522,
0.22071143984794617,
0.25854459404945374,
-0.14340947568416595,
-0.33105888962745667,
0.38311660289764404,
-0.32676631212234497,
0.8049691915512085,
-0.13773740828037262,
0.39061853289604187,
0.045207757502794266,
0.18281075358390808,
0.33726397156715393,
-0.4512591063976288,
0.15922658145427704,
-0.08966773748397827,
-0.047425974160432816,
-0.6631696820259094,
-0.7843910455703735,
0.551673173904419,
-0.714288592338562,
-0.05335787683725357,
-0.41873255372047424,
-0.2491391897201538,
-0.5858970880508423,
0.21322785317897797,
-0.3663157820701599,
0.6608855724334717,
-0.23752865195274353,
0.21411246061325073,
0.2663940191268921,
0.035080909729003906,
0.6261930465698242,
0.6263195276260376,
0.004287953022867441,
-0.42062491178512573,
0.8900949954986572,
-0.12199092656373978,
0.14352256059646606,
0.59690260887146,
0.18776637315750122,
-0.36583131551742554,
-0.2317029982805252,
-0.7487685084342957,
0.06053261086344719,
-0.960368275642395,
-0.15539374947547913,
-0.7632777690887451,
0.371709942817688,
-0.3488142490386963,
0.017319979146122932,
-0.38530629873275757,
-0.3024560511112213,
-0.05513923615217209,
0.07242292165756226,
-0.21348431706428528,
0.3044222593307495,
-0.2206306904554367,
0.2111036330461502,
-0.8126575350761414,
0.5341051816940308,
0.6032767295837402,
0.06343500316143036,
0.3123036026954651,
-0.06982286274433136,
-0.16309723258018494,
0.19046887755393982,
-0.5802336931228638,
-0.7671414613723755,
0.20170938968658447,
0.2287980169057846,
0.8008171916007996,
0.6144742369651794,
-0.1679983139038086,
1.1520746946334839,
-0.39822325110435486,
0.5680417418479919,
-0.015885740518569946,
-0.7993849515914917,
0.19433477520942688,
-0.31668293476104736,
0.42493951320648193,
0.5935612916946411,
0.5493733882904053,
-0.45247557759284973,
-0.05747981369495392,
-0.3371041715145111,
-0.617598295211792,
0.32805562019348145,
0.15136517584323883,
0.3354787230491638,
-0.009261438623070717,
-0.07828956097364426,
0.20257346332073212,
0.4438582956790924,
-0.7061280012130737,
-0.07709891349077225,
-0.22117936611175537,
0.08459270000457764,
-0.07376158237457275,
-0.10061104595661163,
0.018557164818048477,
-0.028364546597003937,
0.5014646053314209,
-0.5485768914222717,
0.3405555486679077,
0.026108641177415848,
-0.6054363250732422,
0.011010682210326195,
0.1516599953174591,
0.8500605821609497,
0.9835630655288696,
-0.11228405684232712,
0.23440128564834595,
-0.14761707186698914,
-0.4084092378616333,
0.20922507345676422,
0.08381006866693497,
0.13745273649692535,
-0.2774597406387329,
0.6803673505783081,
0.40493783354759216,
0.4915987253189087,
-1.105078935623169,
0.5692514181137085,
-0.20057706534862518,
0.17655222117900848,
-0.27762898802757263,
-0.02469543367624283,
-0.035595815628767014,
0.34639084339141846,
0.3908267319202423,
0.22652342915534973,
0.5127986073493958,
-1.0652530193328857,
0.28820595145225525,
0.33294445276260376,
-0.08743374049663544,
-0.4795299768447876,
0.398179292678833,
0.16894914209842682,
-0.3125423491001129,
0.6934492588043213,
-0.2580766975879669,
-0.24472558498382568,
0.4329555928707123,
0.45187291502952576,
0.8575308322906494,
-0.21442678570747375,
0.17096075415611267,
0.19722984731197357,
0.2826377749443054,
0.030311979353427887,
0.17058028280735016,
-0.3908114731311798,
-0.6742218136787415,
-0.14097881317138672,
-0.5454800724983215,
-0.6189774870872498,
-0.2939629852771759,
-0.3249640464782715,
-0.08591141551733017,
-0.21278773248195648,
-0.22462129592895508,
0.06987302005290985,
-0.12450368702411652,
-0.7499514818191528,
0.2829493582248688,
-0.1197797954082489,
0.6119480729103088,
-0.6408942341804504,
0.49632084369659424,
0.6630826592445374,
-0.5265904664993286,
-0.23698078095912933,
0.13099563121795654,
0.22250236570835114,
-0.6364666223526001,
0.3209730088710785,
0.44683799147605896,
-0.41721171140670776,
-0.3798918128013611,
-0.19021335244178772,
-0.582331120967865,
1.257094144821167,
0.20069587230682373,
-0.12292412668466568,
0.05127321556210518,
0.18598581850528717,
0.6403220891952515,
-0.15009567141532898,
0.837512195110321,
0.10265813767910004,
0.7035159468650818,
0.2075345665216446,
-0.9236408472061157,
-0.07393626123666763,
-0.639121949672699,
-0.41908639669418335,
-0.02063770778477192,
-0.8292771577835083,
1.092591404914856,
0.08900678157806396,
-0.08560582250356674,
0.16160103678703308,
0.4772665500640869,
0.08626236021518707,
0.6671935319900513,
0.57721346616745,
0.7386841177940369,
0.7423948049545288,
0.2509174942970276,
0.9073038101196289,
-0.16163982450962067,
-0.1533280611038208,
1.0609509944915771,
-0.3141431510448456,
1.0298599004745483,
0.37508004903793335,
-0.09439829736948013,
0.5040938854217529,
0.23381230235099792,
0.23126442730426788,
0.4287152588367462,
-0.02904200181365013,
-0.1261921375989914,
-0.28819870948791504,
-0.01521372701972723,
0.05342504382133484,
0.8039240837097168,
-0.05189727991819382,
0.20202940702438354,
-0.18473853170871735,
0.3281143605709076,
-0.04512479156255722,
-0.01905936561524868,
-0.12951309978961945,
0.863709032535553,
-0.35465767979621887,
-0.8202913999557495,
0.2522834539413452,
0.07717236876487732,
0.5964635014533997,
-0.7246737480163574,
-0.26871952414512634,
-0.34102579951286316,
0.2897912859916687,
-0.013201046735048294,
-0.21493098139762878,
0.13540346920490265,
-0.16246037185192108,
0.07536181807518005,
-0.16847966611385345,
0.6258624196052551,
0.0022730701602995396,
-0.46444493532180786,
0.3777879774570465,
0.7888662815093994,
0.1827879697084427,
-0.35286468267440796,
-0.6333889365196228,
0.24235506355762482,
-0.4715544879436493,
-0.23096194863319397,
0.41277700662612915,
0.3977030813694,
-0.1347118616104126,
1.089431881904602,
0.8938178420066833,
-0.38596242666244507,
0.3372679352760315,
0.07094793766736984,
0.7125396132469177,
-0.5791436433792114,
-0.545270562171936,
-0.7895233631134033,
0.6356840133666992,
-0.28154733777046204,
-0.3124648630619049,
0.8321725726127625,
0.744228720664978,
0.5508071780204773,
-0.102208711206913,
0.420549213886261,
-0.01810801774263382,
0.17450402677059174,
-0.5010797381401062,
0.46707960963249207,
-0.959369421005249,
-0.233014315366745,
-0.31153252720832825,
-0.9452428221702576,
0.19851788878440857,
0.5471905469894409,
0.2289915829896927,
0.22655221819877625,
0.6586929559707642,
0.6993157863616943,
-0.48740220069885254,
-0.18711701035499573,
0.5694820284843445,
-0.049276649951934814,
0.37849003076553345,
0.48403680324554443,
0.9628697633743286,
-0.45460623502731323,
0.49099770188331604,
-0.3625270128250122,
-0.25410518050193787,
-0.3122260570526123,
-0.8446441888809204,
-0.7504134178161621,
-0.6655977964401245,
-0.12138429284095764,
0.029267290607094765,
0.12829795479774475,
0.9554699063301086,
1.070206642150879,
-0.3493482172489166,
-0.2887205481529236,
0.3114107847213745,
-0.1005171537399292,
-0.8174293041229248,
-0.1770133376121521,
-0.016916964203119278,
-0.06531674414873123,
-0.8485072255134583,
0.6469931602478027,
0.41500160098075867,
-0.04573514312505722,
-0.435835599899292,
-0.05347120389342308,
-0.3973245322704315,
0.26815906167030334,
0.7560513615608215,
0.11593110859394073,
-0.5608060956001282,
-0.3632013499736786,
0.07772187888622284,
0.005430971272289753,
0.24446062743663788,
0.8612231612205505,
-0.6578444838523865,
0.7039898633956909,
0.30818501114845276,
0.6588640213012695,
0.6331809759140015,
0.12992778420448303,
0.22695335745811462,
-0.6139127612113953,
0.028116995468735695,
0.22860130667686462,
0.3795708119869232,
0.2360779494047165,
0.08775648474693298,
0.46698611974716187,
0.19306059181690216,
-0.3423919677734375,
-0.5302165150642395,
0.030124159529805183,
-1.2883832454681396,
-0.4144042730331421,
0.6452555060386658,
-0.1836625188589096,
-0.2727527320384979,
-0.08530640602111816,
-0.020808493718504906,
-0.07614734023809433,
-0.3871517479419708,
0.7901173830032349,
0.715431809425354,
-0.2555581033229828,
-0.2083185613155365,
-0.6438760161399841,
0.17689454555511475,
-0.03529404476284981,
-1.2070940732955933,
-0.08680792897939682,
0.9335231184959412,
0.13429716229438782,
0.48645222187042236,
0.8283161520957947,
0.39699527621269226,
0.5883217453956604,
0.4283784329891205,
-0.0413505993783474,
-0.24325373768806458,
-0.7661773562431335,
0.15843825042247772,
0.42521554231643677,
-0.16229161620140076,
-0.2739269435405731
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09982v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09982v1
|
Memory Sharing for Large Language Model based Agents
| 2024-04-15T17:57:30 | 2024-04-15T17:57:30 |
Hang Gao, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the realm of artificial intelligence, the adaptation of Large Language
Model (LLM)-based agents to execute tasks via natural language prompts
represents a significant advancement, notably eliminating the need for explicit
retraining or fine tuning for fixed-answer tasks such as common sense questions
and yes/no queries. However, the application of In-context Learning to
open-ended challenges, such as poetry creation, reveals substantial limitations
due to the comprehensiveness of the provided examples and agent's ability to
understand the content expressed in the problem, leading to outputs that often
diverge significantly from expected results. Addressing this gap, our study
introduces the Memory-Sharing (MS) framework for LLM multi-agents, which
utilizes a real-time memory storage and retrieval system to enhance the
In-context Learning process. Each "memory" within this system captures both the
posed query and the corresponding real-time response from an LLM-based agent,
aggregating these memories from a broad spectrum of similar agents to enrich
the memory pool shared by all agents. This framework not only aids agents in
identifying the most relevant examples for specific tasks but also evaluates
the potential utility of their memories for future applications by other
agents. Empirical validation across three distinct domains involving
specialized functions of agents demonstrates that the MS framework
significantly improve the agent's performance regrading the open-ended
questions. Furthermore, we also discuss what type of memory pool and what
retrieval strategy in MS can better help agents, offering a future develop
direction of MS. The code and data are available at:
https://github.com/GHupppp/MemorySharingLLM
|
[
-0.34703370928764343,
-0.7497225999832153,
0.7542847990989685,
0.1409047245979309,
0.03931836411356926,
0.0651111975312233,
-0.47664305567741394,
-0.7245027422904968,
0.08154203742742538,
0.35002297163009644,
-0.35565251111984253,
-0.3228774070739746,
-0.3046673536300659,
-0.2640245258808136,
-0.2877804636955261,
0.6486578583717346,
-0.2819491922855377,
-0.19773702323436737,
-0.56183922290802,
-0.41260457038879395,
-0.7611525654792786,
-0.6490781307220459,
-0.8554919958114624,
-0.44458624720573425,
0.5703803896903992,
0.39445167779922485,
0.6128547787666321,
0.5620675086975098,
0.1637474149465561,
0.26572248339653015,
0.1492302417755127,
0.3819425404071808,
-0.46314364671707153,
0.47744911909103394,
-0.4121246635913849,
-0.35710403323173523,
-0.4899875819683075,
0.0027570584788918495,
0.679967999458313,
0.2507793605327606,
-0.1771320104598999,
0.034620996564626694,
-0.10725796222686768,
0.5061002373695374,
-0.7587874531745911,
0.18957233428955078,
-0.8210573196411133,
0.1925898641347885,
-0.0010983084794133902,
-0.3743785619735718,
-0.44074931740760803,
-0.08998601138591766,
0.19291070103645325,
-0.5794521570205688,
0.006291076075285673,
0.023045198991894722,
0.6608169078826904,
0.21539883315563202,
-0.20023617148399353,
-0.4129413366317749,
-0.621910810470581,
0.8291313052177429,
-0.4158220887184143,
0.030641287565231323,
0.3199597895145416,
0.5083777904510498,
-0.1327378749847412,
-0.6004412174224854,
-0.6152139902114868,
-0.2533092200756073,
0.1777225136756897,
0.023849692195653915,
-0.03168061375617981,
-0.024628611281514168,
0.05787523835897446,
0.09825516492128372,
-0.5358003377914429,
-0.045384109020233154,
-0.10342216491699219,
-0.09733133763074875,
0.46610862016677856,
0.34714409708976746,
0.509391725063324,
0.3821146786212921,
-0.379971444606781,
-0.07253331691026688,
-0.35960853099823,
-0.012169398367404938,
0.07887931168079376,
0.40855681896209717,
-0.02368791215121746,
0.47947704792022705,
-0.16566377878189087,
0.5862491130828857,
-0.35224613547325134,
0.2504090368747711,
0.22023995220661163,
-0.1948576122522354,
-0.021856538951396942,
-0.03858942911028862,
0.43827566504478455,
0.3345954418182373,
0.6135957837104797,
-0.3855307698249817,
-0.27555975317955017,
0.05912210792303085,
0.32274094223976135,
-0.8501710891723633,
0.15436458587646484,
0.09766187518835068,
-0.27952954173088074,
0.1063801497220993,
-0.04522261396050453,
-0.4676510989665985,
-0.32165709137916565,
-0.15805193781852722,
0.5660669803619385,
-0.6240324974060059,
-0.18779441714286804,
0.34280702471733093,
-0.21170516312122345,
0.28928712010383606,
0.46925878524780273,
-0.5517578125,
0.4393919110298157,
0.601026177406311,
0.8865705728530884,
-0.34993046522140503,
-0.812017560005188,
-0.7564688324928284,
0.42712166905403137,
-0.05643957108259201,
0.7726990580558777,
-0.6986235976219177,
-0.14388810098171234,
-0.008694248273968697,
-0.10468219220638275,
-0.4186283349990845,
-0.7938255667686462,
0.01777384802699089,
-0.6489858627319336,
0.03319992125034332,
-0.21237812936306,
-0.6211705207824707,
-0.04832928255200386,
0.47327396273612976,
-0.6921460628509521,
0.9505947232246399,
0.08224357664585114,
-0.29618310928344727,
-0.03821111470460892,
-0.7801121473312378,
-0.10871764272451401,
0.06282725185155869,
-0.3913690447807312,
-0.14390243589878082,
-0.008527136407792568,
-0.043451033532619476,
0.6172226071357727,
-0.23200704157352448,
0.07985350489616394,
-0.19254113733768463,
-0.5762220621109009,
0.5572125315666199,
-0.4377914369106293,
0.187193363904953,
0.26246511936187744,
-0.05413997918367386,
0.20708537101745605,
-0.3789605498313904,
0.13383302092552185,
0.25628462433815,
-0.35510388016700745,
-0.2922033369541168,
-0.035759761929512024,
-0.016610320657491684,
0.2789170444011688,
0.4317442774772644,
-0.51249098777771,
0.25546756386756897,
-0.04276140779256821,
0.4183197021484375,
0.7447084784507751,
0.06394949555397034,
0.4919031262397766,
-0.761053740978241,
0.4958057701587677,
0.20765309035778046,
0.15968963503837585,
-0.34861892461776733,
-0.2833637297153473,
-0.4178827106952667,
-0.20742011070251465,
-0.1373436450958252,
0.5377020239830017,
-0.5732597708702087,
-0.017661279067397118,
-0.10167558491230011,
-0.23439885675907135,
-0.46858930587768555,
0.11314349621534348,
0.4175231456756592,
0.3496227562427521,
0.38544172048568726,
-0.2700803577899933,
-0.2278289794921875,
-0.7567881941795349,
-0.2065363973379135,
0.007818358950316906,
0.2373262643814087,
0.7730854153633118,
0.3159846067428589,
-0.21940289437770844,
0.9735096096992493,
-0.45554423332214355,
-0.11614817380905151,
-0.2501804232597351,
-0.21166329085826874,
-0.1027720496058464,
0.3753836750984192,
0.5410308241844177,
-0.636160135269165,
-0.5979198813438416,
-0.10180746018886566,
-0.823602557182312,
0.05937386676669121,
-0.15664902329444885,
-0.36657407879829407,
0.4477955996990204,
0.4628956913948059,
-0.995380163192749,
0.3189462721347809,
0.38955000042915344,
-0.4347892701625824,
0.5666714310646057,
-0.42496389150619507,
0.028278417885303497,
-1.0483264923095703,
0.04510616138577461,
-0.40690815448760986,
-0.30760425329208374,
-0.4082232117652893,
0.23048801720142365,
-0.02338654175400734,
-0.14660389721393585,
-0.5821991562843323,
0.9910078048706055,
-0.6053147912025452,
-0.24787189066410065,
-0.5026452541351318,
0.34455859661102295,
-0.05878980830311775,
0.4494441747665405,
-0.13462567329406738,
0.9741272330284119,
0.6731391549110413,
-0.6355167627334595,
0.33523842692375183,
0.016473248600959778,
-0.011556951329112053,
0.49583297967910767,
-0.27148762345314026,
0.3257725238800049,
-0.1812877207994461,
0.313632071018219,
-0.6324427127838135,
0.05262722074985504,
0.2561156153678894,
-0.47335803508758545,
0.10883697122335434,
0.0794566422700882,
-0.7230178713798523,
0.0019865811336785555,
-0.21556495130062103,
0.6747251152992249,
0.3346863090991974,
-0.6504876017570496,
0.5928057432174683,
0.1644635945558548,
0.06874576956033707,
-0.7543531060218811,
-0.4539911150932312,
0.11458760499954224,
-0.16783665120601654,
-0.5891500115394592,
0.3021448254585266,
-0.37617963552474976,
-0.33090370893478394,
0.45428040623664856,
-0.11948716640472412,
-0.11768370121717453,
0.12429718673229218,
0.207502543926239,
0.12658891081809998,
-0.24037660658359528,
0.6440013647079468,
-0.21839815378189087,
-0.18765781819820404,
-0.14854493737220764,
-0.44349533319473267,
0.845571756362915,
-0.27198028564453125,
-0.438338965177536,
-0.09325695037841797,
0.5979340076446533,
0.5505411624908447,
-0.43471473455429077,
1.0716041326522827,
0.3951929807662964,
-0.46682748198509216,
-0.589076042175293,
-0.4461708068847656,
-0.08128277957439423,
-0.4442518353462219,
0.20618246495723724,
-0.31928932666778564,
-1.1333210468292236,
0.6815309524536133,
0.013602388091385365,
-0.05488400533795357,
0.03276555612683296,
0.4437310993671417,
-0.11450252681970596,
0.42569833993911743,
0.5231592655181885,
-0.3899868428707123,
0.5074903964996338,
-0.30422741174697876,
-0.0749291405081749,
-0.6773223280906677,
-0.10972127318382263,
-0.18709032237529755,
-0.528175950050354,
-0.00434085400775075,
-0.7972710132598877,
-0.008159961551427841,
0.009601670317351818,
-0.3544633686542511,
0.040262557566165924,
-0.40656474232673645,
0.8037611246109009,
0.46904751658439636,
-0.06851851940155029,
0.2019096463918686,
0.032442495226860046,
-0.21390819549560547,
0.3565044105052948,
-0.4346436858177185,
-0.5023197531700134,
1.0044398307800293,
0.15010328590869904,
0.5317582488059998,
0.17583119869232178,
0.6809116005897522,
0.41158223152160645,
0.01420903205871582,
-0.7464830875396729,
0.860468864440918,
0.11317595839500427,
-0.45254382491111755,
-0.41578903794288635,
-0.3954333961009979,
-1.1545915603637695,
0.4725501537322998,
0.06088731437921524,
-0.9105780124664307,
-0.34536170959472656,
-0.08203689754009247,
-0.22665706276893616,
0.5261907577514648,
-0.5754197835922241,
0.7672338485717773,
-0.14785490930080414,
-0.3801185190677643,
-0.5379787087440491,
-0.4323593080043793,
-0.015273191034793854,
0.03215055167675018,
-0.19804027676582336,
-0.193184956908226,
-0.2960825562477112,
0.45854514837265015,
-0.2671956717967987,
0.6978836059570312,
-0.39147815108299255,
0.1506917029619217,
0.5906789898872375,
-0.0018927385099232197,
0.4583011567592621,
-0.06625553965568542,
-0.31496313214302063,
-0.08933122456073761,
-0.03465288132429123,
-0.5311196446418762,
-0.6580263376235962,
0.8048062920570374,
-0.8202709555625916,
-0.4694024920463562,
-0.33361560106277466,
-1.0377566814422607,
-0.16692808270454407,
-0.023338356986641884,
-0.2257469743490219,
0.3359040319919586,
-0.0650351420044899,
0.13052459061145782,
0.7516199946403503,
-0.510040819644928,
0.7407926321029663,
0.7398566007614136,
-0.1471070796251297,
-0.12091128528118134,
0.8494551777839661,
0.21660269796848297,
0.23227554559707642,
0.4414450228214264,
0.15842528641223907,
-0.08198719471693039,
-0.5436298251152039,
-0.30062136054039,
0.3701939582824707,
-0.703572690486908,
-0.131794735789299,
-0.6459954977035522,
-0.4124780297279358,
-0.1321200281381607,
-0.2758086919784546,
-0.22924508154392242,
-0.1891455054283142,
-0.33424970507621765,
-0.12560158967971802,
0.6166985034942627,
0.4703111946582794,
0.1317538172006607,
0.3750355839729309,
-0.880072832107544,
0.14694418013095856,
0.13304783403873444,
0.4843277633190155,
0.4532102644443512,
-0.2323879599571228,
-0.5586104393005371,
-0.20433920621871948,
-0.24217499792575836,
-0.9343878030776978,
0.2742254436016083,
0.13945519924163818,
0.8472676873207092,
0.05246579274535179,
0.11076188832521439,
0.6891676187515259,
-0.4056219160556793,
0.6224367618560791,
-0.15866324305534363,
-0.7319375872612,
0.3126261532306671,
-0.39667510986328125,
0.24610532820224762,
0.5382487773895264,
0.049619171768426895,
-0.7521747946739197,
-0.3224616050720215,
-0.4645858108997345,
-0.8887838125228882,
0.724971354007721,
0.06279740482568741,
0.2266732156276703,
-0.114295095205307,
0.7275514006614685,
-0.011545784771442413,
0.2513435184955597,
-0.5997809171676636,
-0.19648319482803345,
0.20412494242191315,
-0.2851550281047821,
-0.21845971047878265,
-0.00333664589561522,
-0.00589044438675046,
0.022850852459669113,
0.4343547821044922,
-0.2389240711927414,
0.49189797043800354,
0.08702073246240616,
-0.2902847230434418,
-0.1687718778848648,
0.39079058170318604,
0.6036138534545898,
0.5212172865867615,
-0.21862544119358063,
0.2842472493648529,
0.15698477625846863,
-0.4027954936027527,
0.11113966256380081,
0.018138539046049118,
-0.07141292840242386,
-0.3444041311740875,
0.1236431747674942,
0.599189817905426,
-0.1429472267627716,
-1.2207869291305542,
0.46023958921432495,
-0.16017569601535797,
-0.022363310679793358,
-0.5206424593925476,
0.3017604947090149,
0.3368423581123352,
0.780402421951294,
0.26568132638931274,
-0.12365016341209412,
-0.17041583359241486,
-0.7444440126419067,
0.46795615553855896,
0.6134341359138489,
-0.26919636130332947,
-0.22096434235572815,
0.2643413245677948,
-0.23661859333515167,
-0.44797834753990173,
0.6378947496414185,
-0.4052034020423889,
-0.3423883318901062,
0.7093421816825867,
0.7663382887840271,
0.9821597337722778,
-0.09343861788511276,
0.13134810328483582,
-0.08993301540613174,
0.0779639407992363,
-0.06546831130981445,
0.565567672252655,
-0.21461132168769836,
-0.907203733921051,
-0.1616981029510498,
-0.4914758801460266,
-0.4212353825569153,
0.09056337177753448,
-0.39589253067970276,
-0.24073722958564758,
-0.40476399660110474,
-0.010367044247686863,
-0.7283778786659241,
0.25974321365356445,
-0.49856656789779663,
-0.08148868381977081,
0.150170236825943,
1.0146530866622925,
-0.5197373032569885,
1.1785240173339844,
0.8939648866653442,
-0.44695937633514404,
-0.7720562219619751,
0.2567652463912964,
-0.17227961122989655,
-0.8392657041549683,
0.45685243606567383,
0.33660888671875,
-0.14733564853668213,
-0.18156464397907257,
-0.3965737521648407,
-0.7636988162994385,
1.518841028213501,
0.4390343129634857,
-0.14885635673999786,
0.02554161101579666,
0.07460089772939682,
0.6296238303184509,
-0.6862712502479553,
0.17009761929512024,
0.14997531473636627,
0.2514711022377014,
0.20599761605262756,
-0.7702373266220093,
0.19259129464626312,
-0.3457421660423279,
-0.17169715464115143,
0.1876518577337265,
-0.8524531126022339,
1.1745134592056274,
-0.18473424017429352,
-0.20487907528877258,
0.12677355110645294,
0.5732161998748779,
0.7614349722862244,
0.803318977355957,
0.4672912359237671,
0.6156086325645447,
0.9181568026542664,
0.3976670503616333,
0.9077482223510742,
-0.3383564054965973,
-0.005338361021131277,
1.3799431324005127,
-0.5717649459838867,
1.0853536128997803,
0.4423631727695465,
0.27112877368927,
0.31617361307144165,
0.25797921419143677,
0.24651895463466644,
0.3231833279132843,
0.37663158774375916,
-0.5596199631690979,
-0.07596469670534134,
-0.22618387639522552,
-0.30258750915527344,
0.15084558725357056,
0.28106558322906494,
-0.2637309432029724,
-0.2662440538406372,
0.04094458371400833,
-0.06653549522161484,
0.2130766063928604,
-0.3219987154006958,
0.6062182784080505,
0.11963946372270584,
-0.6352940797805786,
0.26530489325523376,
-0.06601956486701965,
0.671302855014801,
-0.5822473764419556,
-0.04945337027311325,
-0.18364015221595764,
0.44406282901763916,
0.08206883817911148,
-0.804319441318512,
0.3589370548725128,
-0.00027607762604020536,
-0.3771915137767792,
-0.3307879865169525,
0.8771653175354004,
-0.5303484201431274,
0.18621884286403656,
0.8067144155502319,
0.7616772055625916,
0.34837043285369873,
-0.2935244143009186,
-0.7035201191902161,
0.06914697587490082,
-0.38483381271362305,
-0.22334308922290802,
0.7119594812393188,
0.49559837579727173,
-0.18095017969608307,
0.9478591084480286,
0.37935301661491394,
0.21418103575706482,
0.2013384997844696,
0.007413248531520367,
0.7671552896499634,
-0.7777358889579773,
-0.41119474172592163,
-0.8741605281829834,
0.18655450642108917,
0.0355132557451725,
0.15088500082492828,
0.7623398303985596,
0.734893262386322,
0.8305870890617371,
-0.03882918506860733,
0.7177985310554504,
0.2613772451877594,
0.3558063507080078,
-0.45623236894607544,
0.8858720660209656,
-0.6369836330413818,
0.18529625236988068,
-0.06129854917526245,
-0.785885751247406,
-0.009170034900307655,
0.4863952696323395,
-0.0999203622341156,
0.06888122856616974,
0.6980345249176025,
0.8350477814674377,
-0.06360381096601486,
-0.0891232043504715,
0.5530174374580383,
-0.02470073103904724,
0.3115096986293793,
0.9421368837356567,
1.1249089241027832,
-0.1416069120168686,
0.6669318675994873,
0.17299823462963104,
0.016019200906157494,
-0.08495115488767624,
-0.6457294821739197,
-0.7844058871269226,
-0.665169894695282,
-0.09288845211267471,
-0.042619094252586365,
0.18670587241649628,
1.214706301689148,
0.6092840433120728,
-0.314937949180603,
-0.4806443154811859,
0.12374760210514069,
0.014489689841866493,
-0.26515915989875793,
-0.1944538801908493,
0.25428617000579834,
-0.4460040330886841,
-0.5155475735664368,
0.47970110177993774,
0.29132217168807983,
0.06054006516933441,
-0.17649239301681519,
-0.4698965847492218,
-0.23847027122974396,
0.42025184631347656,
0.6351783871650696,
0.370890736579895,
-0.5092742443084717,
-0.31866148114204407,
0.0057336315512657166,
-0.2729319632053375,
-0.009759137406945229,
0.7611083388328552,
-0.8986700177192688,
0.20741747319698334,
0.39123770594596863,
0.9815431833267212,
0.4844534993171692,
-0.0667523592710495,
0.2669137418270111,
-0.743836522102356,
0.10160152614116669,
0.16678009927272797,
0.39707228541374207,
0.07716342806816101,
-0.3705653250217438,
0.3865716755390167,
0.24592557549476624,
-0.5317976474761963,
-0.7094449996948242,
0.31071484088897705,
-1.2090458869934082,
-0.5530263185501099,
1.0502948760986328,
-0.22381345927715302,
-0.23285846412181854,
-0.051591645926237106,
-0.1685120165348053,
0.3216616213321686,
-0.7562835812568665,
0.5494000911712646,
0.68817138671875,
-0.3141751289367676,
-0.41518956422805786,
-0.7651849985122681,
0.11405033618211746,
0.29998779296875,
-0.8526501059532166,
0.19851407408714294,
0.6504997611045837,
0.19240225851535797,
-0.037568170577287674,
1.0986884832382202,
0.041647687554359436,
0.11157572269439697,
-0.13276353478431702,
0.1874895989894867,
-0.4099332094192505,
-0.6475806832313538,
-0.35372310876846313,
0.4055471122264862,
0.1724102944135666,
-0.42300787568092346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09980v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09980v1
|
Context Does Matter: Implications for Crowdsourced Evaluation Labels in Task-Oriented Dialogue Systems
| 2024-04-15T17:56:39 | 2024-04-15T17:56:39 |
Clemencia Siro, Mohammad Aliannejadi, Maarten de Rijke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR
|
Crowdsourced labels play a crucial role in evaluating task-oriented dialogue
systems (TDSs). Obtaining high-quality and consistent ground-truth labels from
annotators presents challenges. When evaluating a TDS, annotators must fully
comprehend the dialogue before providing judgments. Previous studies suggest
using only a portion of the dialogue context in the annotation process.
However, the impact of this limitation on label quality remains unexplored.
This study investigates the influence of dialogue context on annotation
quality, considering the truncated context for relevance and usefulness
labeling. We further propose to use large language models (LLMs) to summarize
the dialogue context to provide a rich and short description of the dialogue
context and study the impact of doing so on the annotator's performance.
Reducing context leads to more positive ratings. Conversely, providing the
entire dialogue context yields higher-quality relevance ratings but introduces
ambiguity in usefulness ratings. Using the first user utterance as context
leads to consistent ratings, akin to those obtained using the entire dialogue,
with significantly reduced annotation effort. Our findings show how task
design, particularly the availability of dialogue context, affects the quality
and consistency of crowdsourced evaluation labels.
|
[
-0.4759799540042877,
-0.2003040909767151,
0.6886070370674133,
0.31644153594970703,
-0.5901905298233032,
-0.2625943720340729,
-0.28089606761932373,
-0.6819369792938232,
0.047615859657526016,
0.6051468253135681,
-0.25689777731895447,
-0.38979700207710266,
-0.8716005682945251,
0.2905561923980713,
-0.037000007927417755,
1.237023115158081,
0.13927344977855682,
-0.2147226631641388,
-0.4764043986797333,
-0.46972647309303284,
-0.38490310311317444,
-0.7748923897743225,
-0.3567732274532318,
-0.3024083971977234,
0.5145619511604309,
0.21889372169971466,
0.9198086857795715,
0.5513551235198975,
0.14184264838695526,
0.322476863861084,
-0.40957140922546387,
-0.01566290855407715,
-0.4313659965991974,
0.48491430282592773,
-0.25650352239608765,
-0.12207674980163574,
-0.3268076181411743,
0.278734415769577,
0.4677342176437378,
0.8062795996665955,
0.15187472105026245,
0.3422457277774811,
0.37048864364624023,
0.16696301102638245,
-0.670115053653717,
0.46827274560928345,
-0.29474353790283203,
-0.052536483854055405,
-0.05681278929114342,
-0.2357456535100937,
-0.27367499470710754,
-0.05504597723484039,
0.5723812580108643,
-0.789264976978302,
-0.0036003245040774345,
-0.0071736969985067844,
0.5985588431358337,
0.477817177772522,
-0.3890153169631958,
-0.2268940508365631,
-0.6886816620826721,
0.8012687563896179,
-0.6775248646736145,
0.23556925356388092,
0.5021966099739075,
0.10078208893537521,
0.02205708622932434,
-0.4269765615463257,
-0.399770051240921,
-0.23521029949188232,
-0.39656171202659607,
0.00036075428943149745,
0.022641750052571297,
0.4632137715816498,
0.5073192119598389,
0.12432652711868286,
0.26124587655067444,
0.03608662262558937,
-0.2565869688987732,
-0.5053658485412598,
0.48238837718963623,
0.2438528686761856,
0.09790879487991333,
-0.5627939701080322,
-0.2937684953212738,
0.04112188145518303,
-0.40380316972732544,
0.33842799067497253,
0.04092903807759285,
0.2897103428840637,
0.10784926265478134,
0.4767608344554901,
-0.4131036400794983,
1.0496795177459717,
0.010167834348976612,
-0.5124130249023438,
-0.003645071992650628,
-0.5340681076049805,
-0.184502512216568,
0.02394758351147175,
0.6375256776809692,
0.713099479675293,
-0.105638787150383,
-0.10949143767356873,
-0.24602076411247253,
-0.39204373955726624,
0.25876012444496155,
-0.7623390555381775,
0.13903160393238068,
0.059049177914857864,
-0.397836297750473,
-0.050227414816617966,
0.07397707551717758,
-0.1611699014902115,
-0.48177990317344666,
-0.7515514492988586,
0.3228636384010315,
0.012973572127521038,
0.11699690669775009,
-0.38547736406326294,
-0.2399996966123581,
-0.2903149127960205,
0.7407622337341309,
-0.5869970321655273,
0.010310711339116096,
0.6546019911766052,
0.6975221633911133,
-0.12758348882198334,
0.01800917461514473,
-0.6848752498626709,
0.17829856276512146,
-0.0932454764842987,
0.5596213936805725,
-0.7135161757469177,
-0.6622447371482849,
-0.06663317233324051,
-0.03238312900066376,
0.04120834916830063,
-0.5470179319381714,
0.6187379956245422,
-0.40185967087745667,
0.23196803033351898,
-0.5334493517875671,
-0.40962541103363037,
-0.1405010223388672,
-0.0032624523155391216,
-0.6441745758056641,
0.7573536038398743,
0.22310307621955872,
-0.6382017731666565,
0.7503129839897156,
-0.6299172639846802,
-0.5347304344177246,
0.3665241599082947,
-0.048123039305210114,
-0.03498457744717598,
0.2300512045621872,
0.27050021290779114,
0.5528309345245361,
-0.14543217420578003,
0.5695756077766418,
-0.17000935971736908,
-0.564070463180542,
0.6065669059753418,
-0.3778703212738037,
0.5198222994804382,
0.2882482409477234,
-0.6187780499458313,
0.029546277597546577,
-0.40402480959892273,
0.039177123457193375,
-0.5460130572319031,
-0.3763200640678406,
-0.5290924310684204,
0.025410940870642662,
0.21413858234882355,
0.363603800535202,
-0.08272513747215271,
-0.5566607117652893,
-0.07073139399290085,
-0.06243812292814255,
0.4365675449371338,
0.7215270400047302,
0.18745732307434082,
0.3300980031490326,
-0.1797243356704712,
0.41897398233413696,
-0.1439368724822998,
0.16767409443855286,
-0.30352774262428284,
-0.6485390067100525,
-0.6943072080612183,
-0.41523104906082153,
0.4153813421726227,
0.2959456741809845,
-0.5902732014656067,
0.39994364976882935,
-0.24542397260665894,
-0.35862764716148376,
-0.48297518491744995,
-0.10566190630197525,
0.5550410151481628,
0.5617915391921997,
0.09773328900337219,
-0.5311354398727417,
-0.3939364552497864,
-1.0708644390106201,
-0.34029239416122437,
-0.3749983012676239,
-0.21860383450984955,
0.7286447286605835,
0.33777934312820435,
-0.21004720032215118,
1.448376178741455,
-0.19266115128993988,
-0.3147265911102295,
-0.07061908394098282,
0.13107898831367493,
-0.06966231763362885,
0.36566808819770813,
0.3195769786834717,
-0.6023010015487671,
0.03543613478541374,
-0.2850535809993744,
-0.49265754222869873,
-0.5356540083885193,
-0.142972931265831,
-0.08765122294425964,
0.14831893146038055,
0.06566829979419708,
-0.44643521308898926,
0.6280186772346497,
0.47203871607780457,
-0.2167498618364334,
0.40551039576530457,
0.02984503097832203,
0.5330042839050293,
-0.8391540050506592,
0.13109099864959717,
0.10017355531454086,
-0.3099720776081085,
-0.5168741941452026,
-0.3443862199783325,
-0.33691272139549255,
-0.32343775033950806,
-0.365461140871048,
0.7390669584274292,
-0.06521753966808319,
-0.2577962875366211,
-0.2284061312675476,
0.4611363410949707,
0.3789418041706085,
0.31644973158836365,
0.27190399169921875,
1.0922049283981323,
0.07636351883411407,
-0.5683724284172058,
-0.09153854101896286,
0.31864580512046814,
-0.757891833782196,
0.70615553855896,
-0.6711255311965942,
0.10153082013130188,
0.05849059671163559,
0.6001352667808533,
-0.972846508026123,
-0.34476834535598755,
0.40219226479530334,
-0.24179154634475708,
0.010645690374076366,
-0.08193828165531158,
-0.58936607837677,
-0.024179944768548012,
0.20061032474040985,
0.3945695161819458,
0.08790275454521179,
-0.4166952073574066,
0.16361193358898163,
0.6716576814651489,
-0.2092379778623581,
-0.3842548131942749,
-0.5142077207565308,
0.18816716969013214,
-0.15764427185058594,
-0.49335527420043945,
0.20557919144630432,
0.17212678492069244,
-0.31332656741142273,
-0.22359780967235565,
-0.40660059452056885,
-0.029025353491306305,
0.26607653498649597,
0.693851888179779,
-0.15406493842601776,
0.19281727075576782,
0.41201546788215637,
0.009529480710625648,
-0.08891738951206207,
0.08584345132112503,
-0.2087365984916687,
-0.09586790949106216,
0.020227719098329544,
-0.34482088685035706,
-0.7801689505577087,
0.3690808415412903,
0.5181606411933899,
0.01768876612186432,
0.6215056777000427,
0.4492155611515045,
-0.0826348140835762,
0.3057800531387329,
-0.7978379130363464,
-0.11779005080461502,
-0.43195825815200806,
0.3722158968448639,
-0.2800285220146179,
-1.3861109018325806,
0.3992936313152313,
-0.07546696811914444,
-0.023244569078087807,
0.3706788122653961,
0.2869293689727783,
-0.2353290170431137,
0.802453339099884,
0.313520222902298,
-0.01264575868844986,
0.6154690980911255,
0.07155971974134445,
0.22472165524959564,
-1.15951406955719,
-0.2502971291542053,
-0.5572981834411621,
-0.2326958030462265,
-0.3097723424434662,
-0.5715988874435425,
0.5873506665229797,
0.07065235078334808,
-0.06394042819738388,
0.219896599650383,
-0.6446168422698975,
0.30283746123313904,
0.45253807306289673,
0.15096300840377808,
0.4009462893009186,
0.04692848026752472,
0.17567594349384308,
-0.21553726494312286,
-0.592631459236145,
-1.0269951820373535,
0.7657749652862549,
0.2789042592048645,
0.2367006093263626,
-0.05734651908278465,
0.6343270540237427,
0.5786474943161011,
0.6076662540435791,
-0.5091148018836975,
0.5299001932144165,
0.4559416174888611,
-0.7333279252052307,
-0.44708219170570374,
-0.26068857312202454,
-0.868076741695404,
0.49818703532218933,
0.13119301199913025,
-1.1528819799423218,
0.25708305835723877,
-0.00910424254834652,
-0.44553303718566895,
-0.044094014912843704,
-0.6676340103149414,
0.7598293423652649,
0.09201693534851074,
-0.24954010546207428,
0.00022556466865353286,
-0.6341816782951355,
0.08940938115119934,
0.02275758795440197,
0.39819830656051636,
-0.3471733629703522,
-0.07887274771928787,
1.093021035194397,
-0.6714915633201599,
1.115462064743042,
-0.29551273584365845,
-0.24611516296863556,
0.6691587567329407,
-0.0781286284327507,
0.3032272160053253,
0.43850019574165344,
-0.26492688059806824,
0.3621508777141571,
-0.006979210767894983,
-0.24991434812545776,
-0.6566877365112305,
0.5102310180664062,
-0.8019272089004517,
-1.1773436069488525,
-0.24084524810314178,
-0.44625189900398254,
-0.2268468141555786,
-0.09220854938030243,
0.1609811931848526,
0.6556901335716248,
0.0833580493927002,
0.15725697576999664,
0.376371294260025,
-0.08763127774000168,
0.18308869004249573,
0.18585152924060822,
0.18158361315727234,
-0.32824626564979553,
0.6214308142662048,
0.21582308411598206,
0.4801209270954132,
-0.01869884692132473,
-0.04462482035160065,
-0.19984519481658936,
-0.17652250826358795,
-0.5412204265594482,
-0.1532590240240097,
-0.9905346035957336,
-0.17678384482860565,
-0.6029378771781921,
0.1147911325097084,
-0.24237118661403656,
-0.031714655458927155,
-0.11359141767024994,
-0.5401548147201538,
-0.3714520335197449,
-0.17210790514945984,
0.2763349115848541,
0.6464623808860779,
-0.09592871367931366,
0.39658692479133606,
-0.7055801153182983,
-0.059221986681222916,
0.4676975607872009,
0.33916622400283813,
-0.08428523689508438,
-0.5751129984855652,
-0.4261878430843353,
0.28032588958740234,
-0.17081384360790253,
-0.8242098093032837,
-0.1614566445350647,
-0.04504302144050598,
0.6355706453323364,
0.33674725890159607,
0.13854581117630005,
0.7070095539093018,
-0.079584501683712,
1.0618484020233154,
-0.028696132823824883,
-1.1880362033843994,
0.4908319413661957,
-0.48133471608161926,
0.6718258261680603,
0.8218502998352051,
-0.11187964677810669,
-0.744587779045105,
-0.6148669123649597,
-0.3208117187023163,
-0.8433506488800049,
1.03071129322052,
0.5679951310157776,
0.21439777314662933,
-0.060310810804367065,
0.33935603499412537,
0.21089085936546326,
0.31706538796424866,
-0.6119791269302368,
-0.2819640040397644,
-0.3140934705734253,
0.40420001745224,
-0.13645926117897034,
-0.5630465745925903,
-0.38454774022102356,
-0.24642376601696014,
0.3726171553134918,
0.06907986104488373,
0.25158196687698364,
0.4262197017669678,
-0.16932818293571472,
-0.06702563166618347,
0.5869404673576355,
0.7360242009162903,
0.9125736951828003,
0.010831611230969429,
-0.22852513194084167,
0.18174979090690613,
-0.09527934342622757,
0.1771562099456787,
0.11138324439525604,
-0.15867064893245697,
0.25870275497436523,
0.44190242886543274,
1.0952743291854858,
0.477704256772995,
-0.6472165584564209,
0.4142080843448639,
0.11157523840665817,
0.14083082973957062,
-0.004814116284251213,
0.05098225176334381,
-0.2140709012746811,
0.2612721621990204,
0.6883181929588318,
0.052911099046468735,
0.4234892725944519,
-0.32406121492385864,
0.05407692492008209,
0.34518668055534363,
-0.5960653424263,
-0.08554507791996002,
0.45395171642303467,
0.5987764000892639,
-0.3914586305618286,
0.4039626717567444,
-0.15031123161315918,
-0.7021492719650269,
0.5741334557533264,
0.1793859302997589,
0.7037133574485779,
-0.17693495750427246,
0.3714578449726105,
0.21239598095417023,
0.25069794058799744,
0.22237950563430786,
-0.3538677990436554,
-0.796834409236908,
-0.3066536486148834,
-0.7961256504058838,
-0.5516026020050049,
-0.7819870710372925,
-0.14197464287281036,
-0.6672883629798889,
-0.24651062488555908,
-0.144531711935997,
-0.6093757152557373,
-0.24903178215026855,
-0.29169461131095886,
-0.7872086763381958,
0.5131725668907166,
0.38367581367492676,
0.3933165967464447,
-0.6450027823448181,
0.349899560213089,
0.6134838461875916,
-0.0008527643512934446,
-0.7265579700469971,
0.048346057534217834,
-0.040025483816862106,
-0.2502669394016266,
0.9898676872253418,
0.5047104954719543,
-0.15012826025485992,
-0.3446640372276306,
-0.3425586223602295,
-1.136513352394104,
0.8874273896217346,
0.16491074860095978,
-0.3958708345890045,
0.31756237149238586,
0.2340984046459198,
0.7261260747909546,
-0.47374337911605835,
0.5846441984176636,
0.46063700318336487,
0.658878743648529,
0.057888176292181015,
-1.3937641382217407,
0.2636926472187042,
-0.10743437707424164,
0.3311714231967926,
0.005957125686109066,
-0.5305993556976318,
0.23439578711986542,
-0.18587908148765564,
-0.4283705949783325,
0.019197769463062286,
0.5169990062713623,
0.3370386064052582,
0.38943609595298767,
0.5011863112449646,
0.22639460861682892,
0.49484413862228394,
-0.39225876331329346,
1.2289106845855713,
-0.17061664164066315,
0.30421751737594604,
1.054848313331604,
-0.09835350513458252,
0.33898723125457764,
0.5987645983695984,
-0.16459129750728607,
0.44778698682785034,
0.7629948854446411,
0.333965539932251,
0.34522902965545654,
0.42518478631973267,
-0.3602910041809082,
-0.45360442996025085,
-0.6231438517570496,
-0.39600688219070435,
0.4445359706878662,
0.4792439043521881,
-0.43150123953819275,
-0.12991757690906525,
0.1555463671684265,
-0.018886283040046692,
-0.12460632622241974,
-0.10832241922616959,
0.8030626773834229,
-0.07393292337656021,
-0.898650050163269,
0.4327396750450134,
-0.10113564878702164,
0.30397796630859375,
-0.07845236361026764,
0.023489147424697876,
-0.0522591769695282,
-0.4015520513057709,
-0.27063050866127014,
-0.7178018093109131,
0.170172318816185,
-0.1111786812543869,
-0.1948167234659195,
-0.44191205501556396,
0.43133458495140076,
-0.16758212447166443,
-0.2728319764137268,
0.005491944961249828,
0.36388731002807617,
0.2786270081996918,
-0.14146247506141663,
-0.2946431636810303,
0.4046662747859955,
-0.08250652998685837,
-0.5498021245002747,
0.2655135691165924,
0.47076287865638733,
-0.1375408172607422,
0.4792070686817169,
0.4853716492652893,
-0.41454777121543884,
-0.3685154318809509,
0.05638191103935242,
1.0087947845458984,
-0.5447365045547485,
-0.24806556105613708,
-0.5609089732170105,
0.694150984287262,
-0.30597832798957825,
-0.42369380593299866,
0.6238178610801697,
0.43282589316368103,
0.7624211311340332,
0.11056379228830338,
0.9086822271347046,
-0.050516385585069656,
0.27092212438583374,
-0.2177881896495819,
0.6142600178718567,
-0.39169755578041077,
0.31705981492996216,
-0.6646276116371155,
-1.0556457042694092,
-0.17600437998771667,
0.527672290802002,
-0.5906163454055786,
0.2733447253704071,
0.3968236744403839,
0.30252936482429504,
0.25263577699661255,
0.1353808343410492,
0.36299392580986023,
-0.14998696744441986,
0.2571624219417572,
0.24920453131198883,
0.8534999489784241,
-0.2515881061553955,
0.5306953191757202,
-0.26795315742492676,
-0.20113006234169006,
-0.3711373209953308,
-0.8405719995498657,
-0.9226811528205872,
-0.829778790473938,
-0.5339801907539368,
-0.2607230246067047,
0.1316492259502411,
0.7653982639312744,
0.887142539024353,
-0.5648126006126404,
-0.11538779735565186,
0.4776061177253723,
0.19798047840595245,
0.029335957020521164,
-0.3264436423778534,
0.20920422673225403,
-0.38519859313964844,
-0.7995354533195496,
0.18511724472045898,
0.4957996904850006,
-0.16812647879123688,
-0.04969392716884613,
-0.06939107179641724,
0.3081636130809784,
-0.18656392395496368,
0.7946359515190125,
0.03481832891702652,
-1.3187294006347656,
-0.641520082950592,
-0.31138160824775696,
-0.31715095043182373,
0.030780456960201263,
0.9422955513000488,
-0.9827820062637329,
0.8715444803237915,
0.07528075575828552,
0.4618017375469208,
0.3026125729084015,
0.4094780385494232,
0.7164844274520874,
-0.6403209567070007,
0.18811430037021637,
0.28559359908103943,
0.1530945748090744,
0.4202193319797516,
-0.42916661500930786,
0.39171165227890015,
0.08654823154211044,
-0.6393913626670837,
-0.6067419648170471,
0.17260976135730743,
-0.919565737247467,
-0.04669277369976044,
1.5046170949935913,
-0.3946702480316162,
-0.015693070366978645,
-0.4228740632534027,
-0.5867998003959656,
0.30340081453323364,
-0.7222910523414612,
0.7703399658203125,
0.9944530725479126,
-0.1284395158290863,
-0.03418842330574989,
-0.5062457919120789,
0.6075153350830078,
0.6018627285957336,
-0.45467108488082886,
0.10735546797513962,
0.7517115473747253,
0.1243857741355896,
0.39940860867500305,
0.5834336280822754,
0.20554892718791962,
0.20916710793972015,
-0.5104271173477173,
-0.1154455915093422,
-0.10449307411909103,
0.09170034527778625,
-0.10019062459468842,
0.1362134963274002,
0.10411593317985535,
0.022314785048365593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09971v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09971v1
|
Constructing Benchmarks and Interventions for Combating Hallucinations in LLMs
| 2024-04-15T17:48:46 | 2024-04-15T17:48:46 |
Adi Simhi, Jonathan Herzig, Idan Szpektor, Yonatan Belinkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) are susceptible to hallucination, which sparked
a widespread effort to detect and prevent them. Recent work attempts to
mitigate hallucinations by intervening in the model's computation during
generation, using different setups and heuristics. Those works lack separation
between different hallucination causes. In this work, we first introduce an
approach for constructing datasets based on the model knowledge for detection
and intervention methods in closed-book and open-book question-answering
settings. We then characterize the effect of different choices for
intervention, such as the intervened components (MLPs, attention block,
residual stream, and specific heads), and how often and how strongly to
intervene. We find that intervention success varies depending on the component,
with some components being detrimental to language modeling capabilities.
Finally, we find that interventions can benefit from pre-hallucination steering
direction instead of post-hallucination. The code is available at
https://github.com/technion-cs-nlp/hallucination-mitigation
|
[
-0.4682537019252777,
-1.0380134582519531,
0.6510477662086487,
0.09659987688064575,
-0.08771754056215286,
-0.19868947565555573,
-0.44110119342803955,
-0.28455662727355957,
0.24283120036125183,
0.8443211913108826,
-0.5415714979171753,
-0.6113303899765015,
-0.5683239102363586,
0.16048116981983185,
-0.3176547884941101,
0.7278817892074585,
-0.0973370224237442,
0.1699831485748291,
-0.21922551095485687,
0.11153822392225266,
-0.721528947353363,
-0.7083171606063843,
-0.5370261073112488,
-0.15831229090690613,
0.6943472623825073,
0.26532313227653503,
0.4724443554878235,
0.3600444197654724,
0.535781979560852,
0.21988482773303986,
-0.11422856897115707,
0.3307763934135437,
-0.7648757696151733,
0.4466008245944977,
0.021461565047502518,
-0.3258531987667084,
-0.1685585379600525,
-0.1678677648305893,
0.6057077050209045,
0.850065290927887,
-0.3735690712928772,
-0.12909717857837677,
0.3062928318977356,
0.49418240785598755,
-0.7814826369285583,
-0.07746277749538422,
-0.7681076526641846,
0.17716383934020996,
-0.10315439850091934,
-0.3535425364971161,
-0.5015292763710022,
-0.38770046830177307,
-0.19895954430103302,
-0.1577782779932022,
0.17311564087867737,
0.0040793875232338905,
0.5092754364013672,
0.5915286540985107,
-0.0783216580748558,
-0.5261823534965515,
-0.7601009607315063,
0.7425574660301208,
-0.7698611617088318,
0.48926016688346863,
0.5573949813842773,
0.13967640697956085,
-0.5069890022277832,
-0.4559395909309387,
-0.30398350954055786,
-0.21331393718719482,
-0.11124145984649658,
-0.21510089933872223,
-0.11762475222349167,
-0.03827671706676483,
0.5980668067932129,
0.1082112118601799,
-0.5679725408554077,
0.2527884840965271,
-0.337872713804245,
-0.3401795029640198,
0.410051554441452,
0.3109874725341797,
0.1052224338054657,
-0.15181396901607513,
-0.018901387229561806,
0.010538732632994652,
-0.9096347093582153,
-0.1647956371307373,
0.4770013988018036,
0.365196168422699,
0.3008013069629669,
0.8104172348976135,
-0.1749306619167328,
0.46114540100097656,
-0.15146520733833313,
0.02562500722706318,
0.16843892633914948,
-0.18231645226478577,
-0.2360645979642868,
0.06991545110940933,
0.5472570061683655,
0.3014086186885834,
0.3995872139930725,
-0.5538371801376343,
-0.5023947954177856,
0.05685853213071823,
0.5682607293128967,
-0.8052477240562439,
-0.1000225692987442,
0.5055949687957764,
-0.35477161407470703,
-0.3154783844947815,
-0.15481914579868317,
-0.8878841400146484,
-0.788178563117981,
-0.454853892326355,
0.49683859944343567,
-0.26969602704048157,
-0.3440501391887665,
0.3070873022079468,
0.05155745893716812,
0.3738549053668976,
-0.0636432021856308,
-0.7905089259147644,
0.46782708168029785,
0.7064176201820374,
0.7181883454322815,
-0.42747795581817627,
-0.2769513428211212,
-0.7349261045455933,
0.14597176015377045,
-0.42315924167633057,
0.8663593530654907,
-0.48546990752220154,
-0.42204755544662476,
0.40958166122436523,
0.09242279082536697,
-0.11817634850740433,
-0.971839427947998,
0.5684016942977905,
-0.3045582175254822,
0.0474235974252224,
-0.4945039451122284,
-0.6620215177536011,
-0.05169697105884552,
0.1791170835494995,
-0.664177417755127,
0.9391639232635498,
-0.19155019521713257,
-0.7730914950370789,
0.07653363049030304,
-0.38518059253692627,
-0.4380180239677429,
-0.07661489397287369,
-0.3355198800563812,
-0.3453104496002197,
0.5088769197463989,
0.3373718857765198,
0.6321951150894165,
-0.14144805073738098,
0.43216559290885925,
-0.07394951581954956,
-0.5890586376190186,
0.3077194392681122,
-0.22517529129981995,
0.35722196102142334,
-0.14146354794502258,
-0.44038334488868713,
0.4811290204524994,
-0.7462337017059326,
-0.21594500541687012,
0.1524188220500946,
0.12551940977573395,
-0.3755757510662079,
0.16404294967651367,
-0.08405593037605286,
-0.17019551992416382,
0.05322296917438507,
-0.10537710040807724,
0.07244163006544113,
-0.2532510757446289,
-0.01743374951183796,
0.7337585687637329,
0.3425544202327728,
-0.08687755465507507,
-0.3472708463668823,
0.5982509851455688,
0.11052414029836655,
0.08631749451160431,
0.04404507577419281,
-0.2584388256072998,
-0.7774112224578857,
-0.1850513219833374,
-0.023063212633132935,
0.30149543285369873,
-0.8453433513641357,
0.5265297889709473,
0.006058563943952322,
-0.23332858085632324,
-0.3208911120891571,
0.05024970695376396,
0.45804351568222046,
0.43418818712234497,
0.4631797969341278,
-0.18620629608631134,
-0.6469588875770569,
-0.7986665368080139,
-0.07222633808851242,
0.05920989066362381,
-0.1315268874168396,
0.1446353644132614,
0.4615662395954132,
-0.2373194694519043,
0.5209671258926392,
-0.5448556542396545,
-0.3230622410774231,
-0.14561527967453003,
0.12022871524095535,
0.04914742335677147,
0.24123933911323547,
0.26418137550354004,
-0.41339781880378723,
-0.10506241768598557,
-0.3083173930644989,
-0.9338156580924988,
-0.3529871106147766,
-0.1524883359670639,
-0.1404677927494049,
0.30294591188430786,
0.9163103103637695,
-0.467123419046402,
0.487407922744751,
0.2677654027938843,
-0.06044938042759895,
0.8015739321708679,
0.01347427349537611,
0.1449325978755951,
-0.8799843192100525,
0.007472473196685314,
-0.17283768951892853,
0.11228775233030319,
-0.9535388946533203,
0.046080198138952255,
-0.2892008125782013,
0.214026540517807,
-0.262542188167572,
0.20473358035087585,
-0.2780878245830536,
-0.09403511136770248,
-0.3838026225566864,
0.3897959589958191,
-0.4505027234554291,
0.5582834482192993,
0.3249646723270416,
0.8067037463188171,
0.3889268934726715,
-0.5600062608718872,
-0.03042653761804104,
0.1412658989429474,
-0.509618878364563,
0.2384212166070938,
-0.6695377230644226,
0.34950870275497437,
-0.10628931224346161,
-0.27615946531295776,
-0.889059841632843,
-0.15803773701190948,
0.5351886749267578,
-0.1382519006729126,
0.1292773336172104,
0.2432975322008133,
-0.5881139039993286,
-0.1751898229122162,
-0.49335142970085144,
0.257630854845047,
0.19679982960224152,
-0.5404297113418579,
0.6318303346633911,
0.32930657267570496,
-0.14863911271095276,
-0.48529767990112305,
-0.30590662360191345,
0.15804597735404968,
-0.35405051708221436,
-0.3775266408920288,
0.1915469467639923,
-0.3715570867061615,
-0.39583060145378113,
-0.19550926983356476,
0.04774501547217369,
0.3447939455509186,
0.10876263678073883,
0.24744099378585815,
0.10177048295736313,
-0.13404352962970734,
0.2844572961330414,
0.11904139816761017,
-0.11409580707550049,
0.28415003418922424,
0.04915376752614975,
0.94632887840271,
0.1543760448694229,
-0.5115541815757751,
-0.2633609175682068,
0.3518272638320923,
0.36908158659935,
-0.1492653340101242,
0.8535767793655396,
0.45201823115348816,
-0.5907710790634155,
-0.3849557936191559,
-0.830331563949585,
-0.6090539693832397,
-0.43271830677986145,
0.4703214764595032,
-0.5439237356185913,
-0.6912828087806702,
0.5602401494979858,
0.037518460303545,
-0.0003943966294173151,
-0.0810714066028595,
1.067383885383606,
0.31465399265289307,
0.850624144077301,
0.5235947370529175,
-0.09164435416460037,
0.24066273868083954,
0.03021967224776745,
0.4384783208370209,
-0.9423471689224243,
-0.2678740322589874,
-0.4724888503551483,
-0.10480096191167831,
-0.45515015721321106,
-0.5131606459617615,
0.2383914440870285,
0.23329858481884003,
0.03243071958422661,
0.2370840162038803,
-0.604296863079071,
0.37527337670326233,
0.2615866959095001,
0.14984509348869324,
0.2825930416584015,
0.07807648926973343,
-0.15074697136878967,
-0.21208027005195618,
-0.5092537999153137,
-0.6132476925849915,
1.1179425716400146,
0.3200574815273285,
0.6954858303070068,
0.015585225075483322,
0.8644170761108398,
0.14631371200084686,
0.27348825335502625,
-0.6466917395591736,
0.7866308689117432,
0.2795839011669159,
-0.2721942663192749,
-0.4361378252506256,
-0.3681318163871765,
-0.8737453818321228,
0.35398802161216736,
-0.13564947247505188,
-1.0504287481307983,
0.14697380363941193,
-0.13796144723892212,
-0.2042953073978424,
0.1198023185133934,
-0.5017130374908447,
0.7246108055114746,
-0.08832452446222305,
-0.43051597476005554,
-0.24900677800178528,
-0.20659008622169495,
0.4177185297012329,
-0.19971325993537903,
0.11464940011501312,
0.060131315141916275,
0.07397077977657318,
0.5569660067558289,
-0.04899216815829277,
0.968095600605011,
-0.12815405428409576,
-0.40614089369773865,
0.07016050815582275,
0.11758343875408173,
0.6120591163635254,
-0.11803022027015686,
-0.043845031410455704,
0.1312466561794281,
-0.1075047180056572,
-0.10267777740955353,
-0.5209894180297852,
0.6127224564552307,
-0.4861854612827301,
-0.8274807929992676,
-0.20061145722866058,
-0.8564396500587463,
-0.4249095618724823,
-0.1070731058716774,
0.12517490983009338,
0.20938649773597717,
-0.2962934672832489,
0.287106454372406,
0.9735625982284546,
-0.371205598115921,
0.3130693733692169,
0.475107878446579,
-0.6225771307945251,
-0.3865552246570587,
0.8233498930931091,
0.055292729288339615,
0.19243410229682922,
-0.003173836274072528,
0.22912068665027618,
-0.13380025327205658,
-0.8952736258506775,
0.16116219758987427,
0.44933223724365234,
-0.8334421515464783,
-0.05277886241674423,
-0.6260823607444763,
-0.46229392290115356,
-0.6541512608528137,
0.19116875529289246,
-0.05006597936153412,
0.03451252356171608,
-0.34419816732406616,
-0.09848546236753464,
0.1973617523908615,
0.6674448847770691,
-0.06766526401042938,
0.1494826078414917,
-0.34175965189933777,
0.4546993374824524,
0.014118965715169907,
0.31559035181999207,
0.28001850843429565,
-0.5706130266189575,
-0.3176378905773163,
-0.2430245727300644,
-0.10722701251506805,
-0.8225348591804504,
0.4094572961330414,
-0.255716472864151,
0.6993575692176819,
0.5459302663803101,
0.13077428936958313,
0.5995690822601318,
-0.5585224032402039,
0.5430039167404175,
0.012812375091016293,
-0.7909609079360962,
0.33998703956604004,
-0.13590168952941895,
0.18078935146331787,
0.4350161552429199,
0.49389761686325073,
-0.5963137745857239,
-0.7612100839614868,
-0.1508314460515976,
-0.6881205439567566,
0.4376146197319031,
0.3996447026729584,
-0.10003633052110672,
-0.03923392668366432,
0.40738919377326965,
0.11494258046150208,
0.4205288290977478,
-0.7577279210090637,
0.06214014068245888,
0.13147008419036865,
-0.16894224286079407,
-0.049918003380298615,
-0.4595615565776825,
-0.3797298073768616,
-0.1755533665418625,
0.753265917301178,
-0.078341044485569,
-0.0199460219591856,
-0.010831108316779137,
-0.1917581558227539,
-0.127481147646904,
-0.027995530515909195,
0.8083136081695557,
0.573778510093689,
-0.24328675866127014,
0.12195069342851639,
-0.019333837553858757,
-0.4443392753601074,
-0.26899415254592896,
0.10453735291957855,
-0.2687119245529175,
-0.16295363008975983,
0.5503991842269897,
0.7755908966064453,
0.1184782013297081,
-0.903002917766571,
0.12482264637947083,
-0.12428905069828033,
-0.23917727172374725,
-0.24241986870765686,
0.15401682257652283,
0.14278660714626312,
0.46618813276290894,
0.09090956300497055,
-0.5978728532791138,
0.06931499391794205,
-0.38651007413864136,
0.1642177253961563,
0.5983626246452332,
-0.33813557028770447,
-0.1594488024711609,
0.4571422040462494,
-0.1643921434879303,
-0.6273916959762573,
0.5463529229164124,
0.009134664200246334,
-0.5489786267280579,
0.4943235516548157,
0.5260456800460815,
1.1245343685150146,
-0.33369383215904236,
0.07453789561986923,
0.2680129110813141,
0.5338549017906189,
0.06689143925905228,
0.5110057592391968,
-0.030962524935603142,
-0.8727557063102722,
-0.16050805151462555,
-0.5772296786308289,
-0.3125607669353485,
0.5524843335151672,
-0.6845555901527405,
0.36474207043647766,
-0.21462692320346832,
-0.0031016513239592314,
-0.01401963084936142,
-0.18410228192806244,
-0.46848636865615845,
-0.22572994232177734,
0.27410197257995605,
0.6313889026641846,
-0.8590184450149536,
0.7791470289230347,
0.22428694367408752,
-0.5601077079772949,
-0.4456564486026764,
0.5334852337837219,
-0.1547059714794159,
-0.5990804433822632,
0.37499234080314636,
0.2898637354373932,
-0.2408166378736496,
-0.03629216179251671,
-0.5775024890899658,
-0.5363268256187439,
0.7303021550178528,
0.015359715558588505,
-0.6971213817596436,
0.10095622390508652,
0.46095699071884155,
0.6555742621421814,
-0.4070815443992615,
-0.05861150100827217,
0.9091805815696716,
0.5077964663505554,
-0.03231792524456978,
-0.5103110671043396,
0.2087242156267166,
-0.012284157797694206,
-0.024764129891991615,
0.15151295065879822,
-0.09078057110309601,
0.4181194305419922,
-0.06129898875951767,
-0.04060259833931923,
0.2652933895587921,
0.4790847897529602,
0.5350023508071899,
0.16929082572460175,
0.5867973566055298,
0.4079396724700928,
0.9062492251396179,
-0.03035617433488369,
0.7724567651748657,
-0.47609996795654297,
-0.02993307076394558,
1.1701704263687134,
-0.589958667755127,
0.9451186656951904,
0.8969131708145142,
0.07955649495124817,
0.14115723967552185,
0.5685765147209167,
-0.15150447189807892,
0.6157890558242798,
0.5667309761047363,
-0.24071142077445984,
-0.27865028381347656,
-0.3692801892757416,
-0.41476649045944214,
0.12043768912553787,
0.45967385172843933,
-0.13841477036476135,
0.049348365515470505,
0.4171094298362732,
-0.1271916776895523,
0.18733936548233032,
0.08403152972459793,
0.8237883448600769,
0.11234301328659058,
-0.701755702495575,
0.7182040214538574,
-0.24057313799858093,
0.27856624126434326,
-0.4433135688304901,
-0.14541380107402802,
-0.40005606412887573,
0.14493632316589355,
-0.034257180988788605,
-0.4144725799560547,
0.3185594975948334,
-0.04641522467136383,
-0.2084357887506485,
0.07139314711093903,
0.5845608115196228,
-0.6455769538879395,
-0.44382691383361816,
0.49886104464530945,
0.5158419609069824,
0.34153515100479126,
-0.1583111584186554,
-0.28596872091293335,
0.5331602096557617,
-0.09987945109605789,
-0.45326128602027893,
0.29280731081962585,
0.400226354598999,
-0.18112434446811676,
0.49264079332351685,
0.5190074443817139,
0.20168444514274597,
0.016206523403525352,
0.6793760657310486,
1.0118129253387451,
-0.6575398445129395,
-0.099357970058918,
-0.7209859490394592,
0.23633627593517303,
-0.10344263166189194,
-0.15309546887874603,
0.7392827272415161,
0.554315984249115,
0.6225659847259521,
-0.11721067130565643,
0.4310837388038635,
0.2382499873638153,
0.48489096760749817,
-0.7298959493637085,
0.5957126021385193,
-0.6589637994766235,
0.632324755191803,
-0.2023002654314041,
-1.0260645151138306,
-0.48557329177856445,
0.4370938837528229,
-0.3498672842979431,
-0.05273965001106262,
0.8483793139457703,
1.394421935081482,
0.2717133164405823,
0.03674614056944847,
0.5722203850746155,
0.3956405520439148,
0.3619658946990967,
0.3478311002254486,
1.0376790761947632,
-0.1251823455095291,
0.38951757550239563,
-0.2574925720691681,
-0.1376299113035202,
-0.17032645642757416,
-0.7431663870811462,
-1.3144049644470215,
-0.5007332563400269,
-0.21901436150074005,
-0.3569585978984833,
0.3095133304595947,
0.801840603351593,
0.2556242346763611,
-0.974609911441803,
-0.5228210687637329,
-0.17801439762115479,
0.2608588635921478,
-0.24707083404064178,
-0.1696675419807434,
0.5679359436035156,
-0.6624223589897156,
-0.6599729657173157,
0.4080817699432373,
0.22512578964233398,
-0.22846803069114685,
-0.6826545000076294,
-0.06941163539886475,
-0.11577887088060379,
0.301218181848526,
0.6329763531684875,
-0.08447267860174179,
-0.9010041356086731,
-0.2279166579246521,
0.20816248655319214,
-0.05122751742601395,
0.03402537852525711,
1.0979384183883667,
-0.6608628034591675,
0.32638218998908997,
0.2979831099510193,
0.7169818878173828,
0.25447943806648254,
-0.24738852679729462,
0.5112326741218567,
-0.5728467106819153,
0.1905149668455124,
0.27427899837493896,
0.31964534521102905,
0.30092889070510864,
-0.3544921875,
0.707982063293457,
0.08972552418708801,
-0.5119011998176575,
-1.314508080482483,
0.04740921035408974,
-0.5637208819389343,
-0.4760417342185974,
1.1887465715408325,
0.1814357042312622,
-0.059331201016902924,
-0.13114523887634277,
-0.22693166136741638,
0.16640058159828186,
0.037563856691122055,
1.2703003883361816,
1.0149859189987183,
-0.00543628353625536,
-0.1565001904964447,
-0.6300654411315918,
0.5440607070922852,
0.481111079454422,
-1.088944911956787,
0.44229957461357117,
0.5044063329696655,
-0.22583593428134918,
0.13934504985809326,
0.39062196016311646,
-0.05528603866696358,
-0.02071792259812355,
-0.0871400386095047,
0.3423877954483032,
0.15459281206130981,
-0.6594605445861816,
-0.5668671727180481,
0.14864102005958557,
-0.08810862898826599,
-0.0019589124713093042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09956v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09956v2
|
Tango 2: Aligning Diffusion-based Text-to-Audio Generations through Direct Preference Optimization
| 2024-04-15T17:31:22 | 2024-04-16T12:12:39 |
Navonil Majumder, Chia-Yu Hung, Deepanway Ghosal, Wei-Ning Hsu, Rada Mihalcea, Soujanya Poria
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Generative multimodal content is increasingly prevalent in much of the
content creation arena, as it has the potential to allow artists and media
personnel to create pre-production mockups by quickly bringing their ideas to
life. The generation of audio from text prompts is an important aspect of such
processes in the music and film industry. Many of the recent diffusion-based
text-to-audio models focus on training increasingly sophisticated diffusion
models on a large set of datasets of prompt-audio pairs. These models do not
explicitly focus on the presence of concepts or events and their temporal
ordering in the output audio with respect to the input prompt. Our hypothesis
is focusing on how these aspects of audio generation could improve audio
generation performance in the presence of limited data. As such, in this work,
using an existing text-to-audio model Tango, we synthetically create a
preference dataset where each prompt has a winner audio output and some loser
audio outputs for the diffusion model to learn from. The loser outputs, in
theory, have some concepts from the prompt missing or in an incorrect order. We
fine-tune the publicly available Tango text-to-audio model using diffusion-DPO
(direct preference optimization) loss on our preference dataset and show that
it leads to improved audio output over Tango and AudioLDM2, in terms of both
automatic- and manual-evaluation metrics.
|
[
-0.4417952597141266,
-0.49807310104370117,
0.7126399874687195,
0.3682260811328888,
-0.24800041317939758,
-0.07952336966991425,
-0.15798693895339966,
-0.04460436478257179,
0.10511959344148636,
0.329078733921051,
-0.8894198536872864,
-0.3023838400840759,
-0.6165732741355896,
-0.04923193156719208,
-0.20596006512641907,
0.9923858642578125,
0.2823300063610077,
0.06135570630431175,
-0.42355114221572876,
0.012374023906886578,
-0.9367241859436035,
0.14856654405593872,
-0.8677191138267517,
-0.3904953598976135,
0.3836509883403778,
0.6133173704147339,
0.5242262482643127,
0.5740270614624023,
0.06062271445989609,
0.11076860874891281,
-0.14203369617462158,
0.2694590091705322,
-0.5229875445365906,
0.35167014598846436,
0.06320067495107651,
-0.0612538680434227,
-0.5042192339897156,
0.13733479380607605,
0.5458198189735413,
0.2858569622039795,
-0.14119170606136322,
0.2588844299316406,
0.1391386091709137,
0.9969856142997742,
-0.31552061438560486,
-0.3474930226802826,
-0.613135576248169,
0.42537400126457214,
-0.0482490211725235,
-0.5528810620307922,
-0.6097734570503235,
-0.48698198795318604,
0.037274520844221115,
-0.843612015247345,
0.22737784683704376,
0.026565954089164734,
0.5477669835090637,
0.3775731921195984,
-0.4867861568927765,
-0.4801146686077118,
-1.0593212842941284,
0.6305152773857117,
-0.3185783922672272,
0.24838797748088837,
0.30722418427467346,
0.2713274359703064,
-0.17029984295368195,
-0.40545976161956787,
-0.599582314491272,
0.04463765770196915,
0.3691875636577606,
0.4388647973537445,
-0.20461566746234894,
-0.03294984996318817,
-0.061527226120233536,
0.38531893491744995,
-0.5875880122184753,
0.10842063277959824,
0.03092620149254799,
-0.14667923748493195,
0.6018392443656921,
0.07989375293254852,
0.21063853800296783,
-0.0939510241150856,
-0.3288356065750122,
-0.15522319078445435,
-0.6075358986854553,
0.09586086869239807,
0.8084084391593933,
0.1966729462146759,
-0.11648639291524887,
0.6673328280448914,
0.16085387766361237,
0.6534785032272339,
0.44044265151023865,
-0.29505038261413574,
0.4515938460826874,
-0.5784826874732971,
0.10689792037010193,
0.19289590418338776,
1.0620900392532349,
0.5294976234436035,
-0.13423052430152893,
0.04968956857919693,
-0.3122628629207611,
0.007101782131940126,
0.06152898073196411,
-0.5689600706100464,
-0.026624737307429314,
0.3609422445297241,
-0.10934893786907196,
-0.3972671926021576,
-0.2234964519739151,
-0.9880867004394531,
-0.5907132625579834,
-0.4070737063884735,
0.6191430687904358,
-0.3008478581905365,
-0.3083764612674713,
0.14532774686813354,
-0.4581669569015503,
-0.2186906337738037,
0.3692145049571991,
-0.9198645353317261,
0.11429096758365631,
0.5638847351074219,
0.9773726463317871,
-0.41334599256515503,
0.27985966205596924,
-0.8247958421707153,
0.20843146741390228,
-0.43586069345474243,
0.6206942796707153,
-0.47691208124160767,
-0.696044385433197,
-0.0550297349691391,
-0.5745197534561157,
0.1363062858581543,
-0.5325780510902405,
0.7720168232917786,
-0.2599785029888153,
0.5921352505683899,
-0.0308030154556036,
-0.4723142683506012,
0.3433553874492645,
-0.27060315012931824,
-0.5194343328475952,
1.295992136001587,
-0.11539482325315475,
-0.5794020295143127,
0.4834442138671875,
-0.6790497303009033,
-0.534305214881897,
-0.3746146261692047,
-0.2130768597126007,
-0.6462246775627136,
-0.013228424824774265,
0.11303798109292984,
0.29952847957611084,
-0.555187463760376,
0.5116479396820068,
-0.08471129089593887,
-0.17836202681064606,
0.26020124554634094,
-0.377605676651001,
0.29353153705596924,
0.4124539792537689,
-0.5203980207443237,
0.06598332524299622,
-0.8706860542297363,
-0.32466116547584534,
0.12206108123064041,
-0.39037972688674927,
-0.2730429470539093,
0.33264869451522827,
0.11343736946582794,
0.20919977128505707,
-0.06443410366773605,
-0.4080825448036194,
0.11112484335899353,
-0.3824204206466675,
0.286352276802063,
0.810711145401001,
0.048493459820747375,
0.9258432984352112,
-0.3125145137310028,
0.643100380897522,
0.07597566395998001,
0.15075096487998962,
-0.20489203929901123,
-0.679373562335968,
-0.39080220460891724,
-0.07927010208368301,
0.002723765093833208,
0.3957142233848572,
-0.38509035110473633,
0.3514578342437744,
-0.10241080820560455,
-0.33998903632164,
-0.591960072517395,
0.24099792540073395,
0.1769874542951584,
0.8455885052680969,
0.22938786447048187,
-0.16227513551712036,
-0.509411633014679,
-0.8208047151565552,
0.28094586730003357,
-0.03229483217000961,
-0.10707619786262512,
0.7153452634811401,
-0.2689324915409088,
-0.2240561991930008,
1.1813318729400635,
-0.6934451460838318,
-0.26842254400253296,
-0.1693945676088333,
0.12698939442634583,
0.30849790573120117,
0.6105966567993164,
0.6728340983390808,
-0.8593002557754517,
-0.2852081060409546,
-0.12306313216686249,
-0.328446626663208,
-0.3121493458747864,
-0.1374116837978363,
-0.4735276401042938,
-0.018412187695503235,
0.17858761548995972,
-0.4045667052268982,
-0.2347615361213684,
0.7347185015678406,
-0.347092866897583,
0.5270293951034546,
-0.1100517138838768,
0.10822203755378723,
-1.2481460571289062,
-0.10783478617668152,
0.06542729586362839,
-0.06784116476774216,
-0.6174262762069702,
-0.7037922143936157,
-0.26761749386787415,
-0.4670712649822235,
-0.2803761661052704,
0.558285653591156,
-0.3124220669269562,
-0.2383432537317276,
-0.20784245431423187,
0.5487105846405029,
0.400413453578949,
0.2276597023010254,
0.165314719080925,
0.8559587001800537,
0.6613357067108154,
-0.8666391968727112,
0.1718323677778244,
0.3858155906200409,
-0.30077025294303894,
0.3970118463039398,
-0.5637819766998291,
0.5177714228630066,
-0.1997763216495514,
0.1732948124408722,
-1.4732112884521484,
-0.03131445124745369,
0.2780507802963257,
-0.595495343208313,
0.37453988194465637,
-0.17019566893577576,
-0.18698059022426605,
-0.1910884976387024,
-0.21780309081077576,
0.7431384325027466,
0.8329221606254578,
-0.48509159684181213,
0.5503032803535461,
0.34049320220947266,
-0.34827834367752075,
-0.630707323551178,
-0.3744620680809021,
-0.19217336177825928,
-0.4069609045982361,
-0.7575672268867493,
0.434762179851532,
-0.2866552472114563,
-0.08975626528263092,
-0.1360008716583252,
-0.08695627003908157,
0.06241057068109512,
-0.1296260952949524,
0.3264107406139374,
0.1649394929409027,
-0.2956494688987732,
0.3431335985660553,
0.47726383805274963,
-0.1239447146654129,
-0.15866440534591675,
-0.5104213953018188,
0.5978366732597351,
0.5829477906227112,
0.002245475770905614,
-0.46411576867103577,
0.19510266184806824,
0.48697882890701294,
-0.176805317401886,
0.22261984646320343,
0.5715609788894653,
0.38356536626815796,
-0.3834129869937897,
-0.3753051161766052,
0.0533067025244236,
-0.4829588532447815,
0.15640972554683685,
-0.1711939424276352,
-0.5677272081375122,
0.2052215188741684,
-0.14898277819156647,
0.0333247110247612,
0.49837157130241394,
0.4505402147769928,
-0.2554258406162262,
1.0248736143112183,
0.4276663362979889,
0.2693040370941162,
0.8874782919883728,
-0.32678914070129395,
-0.33205220103263855,
-0.8790764808654785,
-0.3664044737815857,
-0.42901384830474854,
-0.3010939955711365,
-0.2676987648010254,
-0.5293912887573242,
0.2945933938026428,
-0.26737159490585327,
-0.07768707722425461,
0.23533138632774353,
-0.5715577006340027,
0.2887338399887085,
0.6640830636024475,
0.13039375841617584,
0.1813759207725525,
0.11186473071575165,
-0.17631299793720245,
0.11291758716106415,
-0.751344621181488,
-0.31638962030410767,
1.1242713928222656,
0.3676143288612366,
0.5643399357795715,
0.2605958580970764,
0.6598252058029175,
0.6745927929878235,
-0.2025173455476761,
-0.8521955609321594,
0.36114054918289185,
-0.12783317267894745,
-0.38878852128982544,
-0.30869463086128235,
-0.42567163705825806,
-0.9187875986099243,
0.06472821533679962,
-0.4348582923412323,
-0.24110889434814453,
0.2853807210922241,
0.3226824402809143,
-0.33086830377578735,
-0.19259940087795258,
-0.6591469049453735,
0.7000645399093628,
-0.018056731671094894,
-0.5326135754585266,
-0.15694665908813477,
-0.48599669337272644,
0.31179720163345337,
-0.15402603149414062,
0.48409512639045715,
-0.44259580969810486,
0.05888817831873894,
0.6746228337287903,
-0.1869390606880188,
0.4434177875518799,
-0.24176286160945892,
-0.3428894877433777,
0.4450668692588806,
0.19543787837028503,
0.46690046787261963,
0.29243627190589905,
-0.24010221660137177,
-0.2890695333480835,
-0.490997314453125,
-0.17281721532344818,
-0.6144707202911377,
0.444519966840744,
-0.915216326713562,
-0.5749437808990479,
0.027831394225358963,
-0.3906521499156952,
-0.2520144581794739,
-0.08070247620344162,
0.6686469316482544,
0.7902771234512329,
-0.3088565170764923,
-0.14980725944042206,
0.6903107762336731,
-0.39910635352134705,
0.5442766547203064,
0.20257337391376495,
-0.23234237730503082,
-0.7218001484870911,
0.8899919986724854,
-0.25128281116485596,
0.4965011775493622,
0.35989394783973694,
0.51781165599823,
-0.6098777055740356,
-0.6813781261444092,
-0.7480499148368835,
0.09168371558189392,
-0.5619878172874451,
-0.0362805537879467,
-0.5117523670196533,
0.3733081817626953,
-0.3335675597190857,
-0.10280845314264297,
-0.5085813403129578,
-0.5431457161903381,
-0.6459071040153503,
-0.19805067777633667,
0.3712425231933594,
0.5832732319831848,
-0.07955150306224823,
0.3829882740974426,
-0.7005548477172852,
0.39419791102409363,
0.2863816022872925,
0.1216132789850235,
-0.1959659457206726,
-0.818478524684906,
-0.14187128841876984,
0.07790811359882355,
-0.3286345899105072,
-0.9730144739151001,
0.04583841562271118,
0.382790207862854,
0.33625563979148865,
0.5469566583633423,
0.06171555444598198,
0.4109847843647003,
-0.677764356136322,
0.7508808374404907,
0.5431668758392334,
-0.8473731279373169,
1.022399663925171,
-0.6431714296340942,
0.04889362305402756,
0.4709774851799011,
0.05273627117276192,
-0.5698745250701904,
-0.20458337664604187,
-0.45924386382102966,
-0.9637776017189026,
0.9037637114524841,
0.5818321108818054,
0.4254983365535736,
-0.10099382698535919,
0.3552613854408264,
0.44744694232940674,
0.3001764118671417,
-0.7217583656311035,
-0.3395898640155792,
-0.3942873775959015,
-0.2381027489900589,
-0.38482677936553955,
-0.3318292796611786,
-0.2746926248073578,
0.02878284454345703,
0.747406542301178,
0.08341552317142487,
0.23572544753551483,
0.18916472792625427,
0.24133414030075073,
-0.08702598512172699,
0.1552629917860031,
0.8022561073303223,
0.14764994382858276,
-0.029437603428959846,
0.08606976270675659,
-0.4262963831424713,
-0.4418904781341553,
0.7612895369529724,
-0.3237045109272003,
-0.4249112010002136,
0.1765046864748001,
-0.07300011068582535,
1.2325661182403564,
-0.1438463181257248,
-0.6113963723182678,
0.5090851187705994,
0.03443314880132675,
-0.1483086198568344,
-0.3711892366409302,
0.24448730051517487,
-0.05894435569643974,
0.05180392786860466,
0.37734559178352356,
0.5125036239624023,
0.3591318726539612,
-0.45766204595565796,
0.3495565950870514,
0.261028915643692,
-0.44928696751594543,
-0.2649175524711609,
0.9976447224617004,
0.5448586344718933,
-0.4915007948875427,
0.33908596634864807,
-0.15928496420383453,
0.15957273542881012,
0.777189314365387,
0.6221027374267578,
1.0346593856811523,
-0.1988207846879959,
0.5749720335006714,
0.5065031051635742,
-0.1884319931268692,
-0.1696091592311859,
-0.27312350273132324,
-0.3020719587802887,
-0.8647121787071228,
-0.23104968667030334,
-0.6844222545623779,
-0.221045583486557,
-0.0900702252984047,
-0.5765953063964844,
0.48250728845596313,
-0.31329798698425293,
-0.5721510052680969,
0.0280135627835989,
-0.532662034034729,
-0.2567782402038574,
0.2572987973690033,
0.12761884927749634,
0.4151594340801239,
-1.003103494644165,
0.5663869380950928,
0.38795915246009827,
-0.3576056957244873,
-0.5901128649711609,
0.1486465334892273,
0.10806255042552948,
-0.5228611826896667,
0.5239681005477905,
-0.04371166601777077,
-0.3597184121608734,
0.12225436419248581,
-0.07833641767501831,
-0.8629229068756104,
1.0364750623703003,
0.43262937664985657,
-0.6728041768074036,
0.11436954885721207,
-0.009173677302896976,
0.3603251874446869,
-0.5396708250045776,
0.11213559657335281,
0.30620434880256653,
0.4195314347743988,
0.7343893647193909,
-0.5270124077796936,
-0.2754650115966797,
-0.28933724761009216,
0.006149073597043753,
0.38770854473114014,
-0.49260756373405457,
0.5277695059776306,
-0.3309761583805084,
-0.23495301604270935,
-0.1432557851076126,
0.45956799387931824,
0.27577605843544006,
0.693710207939148,
0.5727606415748596,
0.3352668881416321,
0.5948934555053711,
-0.18360857665538788,
1.0334062576293945,
0.06342803686857224,
0.11434192955493927,
1.128453016281128,
-0.19323591887950897,
0.5288265347480774,
0.5138728022575378,
-0.10411793738603592,
0.2859233319759369,
0.9268159866333008,
0.035801514983177185,
0.9204627871513367,
-0.0143058430403471,
-0.2760136127471924,
-0.16492047905921936,
-0.16184614598751068,
-0.39430394768714905,
0.23025520145893097,
-0.049386151134967804,
-0.39720192551612854,
0.3717934489250183,
0.2884664535522461,
-0.07284579426050186,
0.14134806394577026,
-0.12994371354579926,
1.0688611268997192,
-0.23892071843147278,
-0.8401029109954834,
0.23137672245502472,
-0.293233722448349,
0.5381815433502197,
-0.48646795749664307,
0.12291958183050156,
-0.4472755491733551,
-0.13834911584854126,
-0.122376948595047,
-0.7209185361862183,
0.19796687364578247,
-0.04887063428759575,
-0.4035835564136505,
-0.26795297861099243,
0.3013852536678314,
-0.6865521669387817,
-0.3042333722114563,
0.4959023594856262,
0.1368972808122635,
0.002422902500256896,
0.12493117898702621,
-0.504806637763977,
-0.0026004761457443237,
0.15372315049171448,
-0.23127087950706482,
0.13909229636192322,
0.44869986176490784,
0.40828895568847656,
0.3892897665500641,
0.6034883856773376,
0.07698043435811996,
-0.03639199584722519,
0.33231526613235474,
0.5045679807662964,
-0.19052790105342865,
-0.6356756091117859,
-0.9442152976989746,
0.6738901734352112,
0.08773455768823624,
-0.3180340826511383,
0.5247410535812378,
0.8893123269081116,
0.4112989008426666,
-0.20441390573978424,
0.7129866480827332,
-0.01675422675907612,
0.2700871229171753,
-0.8813930153846741,
0.4047113358974457,
-0.8211185336112976,
0.35630956292152405,
-0.7879723906517029,
-1.1973963975906372,
0.14377449452877045,
0.14233039319515228,
-0.07171887159347534,
-0.08170118182897568,
0.37756094336509705,
0.7630879282951355,
-0.02129422500729561,
-0.36126217246055603,
0.24892984330654144,
-0.20897728204727173,
0.24316373467445374,
0.40731632709503174,
0.9162725806236267,
-0.38535037636756897,
0.6657689809799194,
0.012268276885151863,
-0.07354842126369476,
-0.17040981352329254,
-0.8398889303207397,
-0.4898628294467926,
-0.8381313681602478,
-0.4564586281776428,
-0.42664483189582825,
-0.024588197469711304,
0.7827629446983337,
0.5415614247322083,
-0.34658512473106384,
-0.2689903676509857,
-0.27069953083992004,
0.21149593591690063,
-0.12127193808555603,
-0.20776784420013428,
0.18671630322933197,
-0.17923086881637573,
-0.8852629065513611,
0.729577362537384,
0.37670227885246277,
0.5284047722816467,
0.11576269567012787,
-0.532804012298584,
0.16310003399848938,
0.36478471755981445,
0.702789843082428,
-0.06452625244855881,
-0.5673631429672241,
-0.15924449265003204,
0.03412347286939621,
0.08642031252384186,
0.5526951551437378,
0.8431011438369751,
-0.3807295858860016,
0.6634336113929749,
0.5796424746513367,
0.3076680302619934,
0.7741043567657471,
0.2153145968914032,
0.8790270686149597,
-1.020084023475647,
0.3260713219642639,
0.18662676215171814,
0.10424428433179855,
0.31653639674186707,
-0.4167487621307373,
0.45987173914909363,
0.2818181812763214,
-0.4507330656051636,
-0.6868350505828857,
0.43277376890182495,
-1.3685444593429565,
-0.10641973465681076,
1.5473897457122803,
0.29393643140792847,
0.2057262659072876,
0.03316081687808037,
-0.6183090209960938,
0.32596588134765625,
-0.7806660532951355,
0.5772085189819336,
0.5008092522621155,
-0.2751839756965637,
-0.0953410193324089,
-0.2968997061252594,
0.7917093634605408,
0.4387182593345642,
-0.49286651611328125,
0.01426639687269926,
0.8962389230728149,
0.1929243952035904,
0.2145506888628006,
0.922465980052948,
-0.09189373254776001,
0.3329213261604309,
0.026027096435427666,
0.0829099789261818,
-0.17855381965637207,
-0.46484503149986267,
-0.38925984501838684,
0.1962479203939438,
0.14965160191059113,
-0.4638383090496063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09937v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09937v1
|
Compression Represents Intelligence Linearly
| 2024-04-15T17:03:41 | 2024-04-15T17:03:41 |
Yuzhen Huang, Jinghan Zhang, Zifei Shan, Junxian He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT
|
There is a belief that learning to compress well will lead to intelligence.
Recently, language modeling has been shown to be equivalent to compression,
which offers a compelling rationale for the success of large language models
(LLMs): the development of more advanced language models is essentially
enhancing compression which facilitates intelligence. Despite such appealing
discussions, little empirical evidence is present for the interplay between
compression and intelligence. In this work, we examine their relationship in
the context of LLMs, treating LLMs as data compressors. Given the abstract
concept of "intelligence", we adopt the average downstream benchmark scores as
a surrogate, specifically targeting intelligence related to knowledge and
commonsense, coding, and mathematical reasoning. Across 12 benchmarks, our
study brings together 30 public LLMs that originate from diverse organizations.
Remarkably, we find that LLMs' intelligence -- reflected by average benchmark
scores -- almost linearly correlates with their ability to compress external
text corpora. These results provide concrete evidence supporting the belief
that superior compression indicates greater intelligence. Furthermore, our
findings suggest that compression efficiency, as an unsupervised metric derived
from raw text corpora, serves as a reliable evaluation measure that is linearly
associated with the model capabilities. We open-source our compression datasets
as well as our data collection pipelines to facilitate future researchers to
assess compression properly.
|
[
-0.42305174469947815,
-0.34143009781837463,
0.6875954866409302,
-0.15105760097503662,
-0.008517631329596043,
0.15257638692855835,
-0.6847430467605591,
-0.3447500765323639,
0.157840758562088,
0.10299933701753616,
-0.5207580327987671,
-0.34597986936569214,
-0.7670020461082458,
0.07736974954605103,
-0.6060091853141785,
0.871545135974884,
0.41882339119911194,
0.014822207391262054,
-0.7119393944740295,
0.008705036714673042,
-0.39371639490127563,
-0.8752738833427429,
-0.16438111662864685,
-0.3498167097568512,
0.5283055305480957,
0.17636226117610931,
1.0610464811325073,
0.6532261371612549,
0.6138824224472046,
0.35650700330734253,
0.02416691742837429,
-0.003666697070002556,
-0.727293848991394,
0.12500521540641785,
-0.04611668363213539,
-0.5081253051757812,
-0.13928447663784027,
0.1511096954345703,
0.5798643827438354,
0.9492009878158569,
-0.09686560928821564,
0.46032077074050903,
0.18075883388519287,
0.9003623723983765,
-0.4710482358932495,
0.11085238307714462,
-0.7196474671363831,
-0.2521982491016388,
-0.09608088433742523,
-0.36193832755088806,
-0.39569947123527527,
-0.503516435623169,
-0.42000409960746765,
-0.35632649064064026,
0.058141447603702545,
0.25324127078056335,
0.8007338047027588,
0.8526358604431152,
0.01828712597489357,
-0.5359696745872498,
-0.6597740054130554,
0.716157853603363,
-0.5103810429573059,
0.38495415449142456,
0.17854999005794525,
0.10951311141252518,
-0.12323658168315887,
-0.5214793682098389,
-0.595991849899292,
0.06227022781968117,
-0.014328881166875362,
-0.0809975191950798,
-0.3052675426006317,
-0.19571654498577118,
0.42229026556015015,
0.5380193591117859,
-0.3440711200237274,
0.40440884232521057,
-0.670256495475769,
-0.1294679492712021,
0.5436615943908691,
0.039906177669763565,
0.42555001378059387,
0.014205976389348507,
-0.35842809081077576,
-0.2640063762664795,
-0.7309184074401855,
0.19849655032157898,
0.6762791872024536,
0.2320709526538849,
0.14668355882167816,
0.6135810017585754,
-0.10647039860486984,
0.44648945331573486,
-0.4864216148853302,
-0.130326047539711,
0.2796742618083954,
-0.21453700959682465,
-0.2650052011013031,
-0.10054097324609756,
0.7887231707572937,
0.20231761038303375,
0.6710324883460999,
-0.4505781829357147,
-0.4212297201156616,
0.379414439201355,
0.33970651030540466,
-0.8002429604530334,
-0.26006102561950684,
0.26345396041870117,
-0.5329750776290894,
-0.043372564017772675,
0.14998501539230347,
-0.6628758907318115,
-0.33004650473594666,
-0.6821162104606628,
0.23060403764247894,
-0.2219163179397583,
-0.08654330670833588,
0.2695324718952179,
-0.3029993772506714,
-0.15000015497207642,
-0.022672101855278015,
-0.9247101545333862,
0.4761310815811157,
1.0534530878067017,
0.7255536317825317,
-0.13039405643939972,
-0.16737954318523407,
-0.4333733022212982,
-0.08174445480108261,
-0.4031449258327484,
1.1380518674850464,
-0.7232220768928528,
-0.20902810990810394,
0.21403849124908447,
-0.41991984844207764,
0.11554129421710968,
-0.646912693977356,
0.9471803903579712,
-0.35805052518844604,
0.012418262660503387,
-0.25713467597961426,
-0.6101935505867004,
-0.04849851876497269,
-0.0428103469312191,
-0.7202702760696411,
1.121152400970459,
0.1655624359846115,
-0.39327675104141235,
0.17196513712406158,
-0.24527844786643982,
0.011503119021654129,
0.18218356370925903,
-0.3546070158481598,
-0.12555092573165894,
0.5507946014404297,
0.20905831456184387,
0.6316449046134949,
-0.8491172790527344,
0.29662638902664185,
-0.5395351052284241,
-0.4355196952819824,
0.5927160978317261,
-0.4515314996242523,
0.4758382737636566,
0.020964087918400764,
0.4354027509689331,
-0.16816940903663635,
-0.5539188981056213,
0.18595653772354126,
-0.037111133337020874,
-0.696164608001709,
-0.27436912059783936,
0.08489613980054855,
-0.3760632574558258,
0.32572606205940247,
0.26361268758773804,
-0.3958141803741455,
0.47285494208335876,
-0.16003592312335968,
0.3767799139022827,
0.7636215686798096,
-0.24373674392700195,
0.31215736269950867,
-0.7415130138397217,
0.14350321888923645,
-0.5802122354507446,
0.12474392354488373,
0.1243160218000412,
-0.36875924468040466,
-0.6624135375022888,
-0.5020488500595093,
0.3744301497936249,
0.4642336070537567,
-0.3107398748397827,
0.48457908630371094,
-1.077379822731018,
-0.53362637758255,
-0.5591894388198853,
0.43552085757255554,
0.06582877784967422,
0.3294697403907776,
0.38419803977012634,
-0.042588815093040466,
-0.27904900908470154,
-0.872914731502533,
-0.44115379452705383,
-0.23527294397354126,
-0.47898319363594055,
0.29733937978744507,
0.43623408675193787,
0.06180664151906967,
0.6885578036308289,
-0.37416350841522217,
-0.1317872405052185,
-0.05336764454841614,
0.3633216619491577,
0.57794189453125,
0.4242697060108185,
0.49165409803390503,
-0.5679476857185364,
-0.03507763147354126,
-0.6042569279670715,
-0.6389894485473633,
-0.4107472896575928,
0.08137458562850952,
-0.005825737025588751,
-0.10181742906570435,
0.45716845989227295,
-0.8712577819824219,
0.37932437658309937,
0.6871578097343445,
-0.13907012343406677,
0.5574721693992615,
-0.1932239979505539,
0.15303856134414673,
-0.5844998955726624,
-0.11302255839109421,
-0.26607009768486023,
0.15284541249275208,
-0.6085259914398193,
0.06012997031211853,
0.035781681537628174,
-0.1461179554462433,
-0.3521645665168762,
0.10930710285902023,
-0.43250417709350586,
-0.457610547542572,
-0.192726269364357,
0.10147371888160706,
0.01549979392439127,
0.643502950668335,
-0.33064913749694824,
0.8920827507972717,
0.4043613374233246,
-0.6200309991836548,
0.476751446723938,
0.08298413455486298,
-0.7699711322784424,
0.20766600966453552,
-0.7166850566864014,
0.2859286367893219,
-0.26259979605674744,
0.0658913403749466,
-0.7520195245742798,
-0.15392865240573883,
-0.3066529631614685,
-0.47619667649269104,
0.3537195026874542,
0.2410140186548233,
-0.9994293451309204,
-0.30759555101394653,
-0.4018436670303345,
0.32711106538772583,
0.9184924960136414,
-0.48550769686698914,
0.508505642414093,
0.2870975434780121,
-0.2746884822845459,
-0.2823144793510437,
-1.0359246730804443,
0.09804010391235352,
-0.3437289893627167,
-0.627432644367218,
0.4717932939529419,
-0.6265647411346436,
-0.5028473138809204,
0.14337366819381714,
-0.06169789656996727,
0.1299729347229004,
0.11724019795656204,
0.2799569070339203,
0.43977564573287964,
-0.08794824033975601,
0.4990782141685486,
-0.4085502624511719,
0.19700881838798523,
0.37234100699424744,
-0.2223312109708786,
0.5891045928001404,
-0.09152500331401825,
-0.27115240693092346,
-0.15906588733196259,
0.24252404272556305,
0.6902405023574829,
0.11690355092287064,
0.9945022463798523,
0.10435140877962112,
-0.17033261060714722,
-0.16815021634101868,
-0.5777647495269775,
-0.04699310287833214,
-0.4359455704689026,
-0.07479411363601685,
-0.17146021127700806,
-0.7308309078216553,
0.4269818365573883,
-0.3512980341911316,
-0.12308025360107422,
0.3827512562274933,
0.4663715660572052,
0.05445115640759468,
0.8755100965499878,
0.5372946858406067,
-0.22990535199642181,
0.22389650344848633,
-0.11699462682008743,
0.23320047557353973,
-0.8298538327217102,
-0.263515442609787,
-0.914440929889679,
-0.43467962741851807,
-0.4025324285030365,
-0.4698709547519684,
0.19948641955852509,
0.33517298102378845,
-0.3535219132900238,
-0.03871776536107063,
-0.46118977665901184,
0.5673695802688599,
0.333163321018219,
-0.1628028154373169,
0.02804519608616829,
0.11519823223352432,
0.17994754016399384,
0.08148026466369629,
-0.786393404006958,
-0.5565290451049805,
0.8918097019195557,
0.49886783957481384,
0.7415564060211182,
0.48944583535194397,
0.37312862277030945,
0.42905542254447937,
0.26405981183052063,
-1.0091216564178467,
0.5361090898513794,
-0.3119773864746094,
-0.23580004274845123,
0.036679062992334366,
-0.4990723133087158,
-0.8410646915435791,
-0.3149038255214691,
-0.46171852946281433,
-0.9009152054786682,
0.29799044132232666,
-0.38939884305000305,
-0.30688005685806274,
0.1720716804265976,
-0.6265619397163391,
0.2314976453781128,
-0.35126954317092896,
-0.33054473996162415,
-0.3929697275161743,
-0.30160272121429443,
0.34831908345222473,
-0.18146559596061707,
0.48132121562957764,
-0.4364878833293915,
-0.4529346525669098,
0.7316334247589111,
-0.34099480509757996,
0.5815752744674683,
0.3932631313800812,
0.1944780945777893,
-0.09505755454301834,
-0.014519693329930305,
0.20733162760734558,
-0.18435217440128326,
-0.36635926365852356,
0.48113590478897095,
-0.3681299686431885,
-0.5381433367729187,
-1.0522962808609009,
0.8232555985450745,
-0.8186245560646057,
-0.7843443751335144,
-0.18840909004211426,
-0.9687750339508057,
-0.09723705053329468,
-0.1251508742570877,
0.0737295150756836,
0.8296211361885071,
0.36442092061042786,
0.5146799683570862,
0.655903160572052,
-0.18396930396556854,
0.5495463013648987,
0.4505974054336548,
-0.06747926771640778,
-0.30868417024612427,
0.5801999568939209,
0.2602427005767822,
0.3561740815639496,
0.45283931493759155,
0.23082101345062256,
-0.2878706157207489,
-0.7104780077934265,
-0.08056711405515671,
0.18298739194869995,
-1.083177089691162,
-0.5487626791000366,
-0.37600600719451904,
-0.24128177762031555,
-0.5755444169044495,
-0.100999616086483,
-0.1329059600830078,
-0.3848618268966675,
-0.14974132180213928,
0.03965868055820465,
0.3542688488960266,
0.9986670613288879,
0.12548096477985382,
-0.2022993266582489,
-0.8310781121253967,
0.24402765929698944,
0.2654973864555359,
0.24614503979682922,
-0.20029640197753906,
-0.570181667804718,
-0.21836066246032715,
-0.07221462577581406,
0.14577990770339966,
-0.832563579082489,
0.4289434254169464,
0.34210991859436035,
0.7384193539619446,
0.23774933815002441,
0.30450499057769775,
0.6549915075302124,
-0.36943289637565613,
0.9913124442100525,
0.011637376621365547,
-0.7580913305282593,
0.21649283170700073,
0.08756984770298004,
0.43358075618743896,
0.4995836615562439,
0.6471098065376282,
-0.09975545108318329,
-0.28998062014579773,
-0.5326846241950989,
-0.6722834706306458,
0.31152454018592834,
0.07556377351284027,
0.2979050278663635,
-0.04015875607728958,
0.30797135829925537,
0.03285830840468407,
0.33577847480773926,
-0.6484814286231995,
-0.11537238955497742,
0.03012613020837307,
-0.45596688985824585,
0.011874784715473652,
-0.2953137755393982,
-0.054184939712285995,
-0.12570004165172577,
0.6096788644790649,
-0.08756719529628754,
0.3988528251647949,
0.02977294847369194,
0.005278793163597584,
0.19177478551864624,
0.3446793556213379,
0.4092303514480591,
0.4771142303943634,
-0.005493237636983395,
0.3650836646556854,
0.0016496155876666307,
-0.22299475967884064,
-0.1086687296628952,
-0.004459076561033726,
0.21614541113376617,
-0.3165166974067688,
0.5477511882781982,
0.6587611436843872,
0.20625919103622437,
-0.8052565455436707,
0.44258493185043335,
-0.24718505144119263,
-0.10532813519239426,
-0.23063349723815918,
0.17005370557308197,
0.0022496383171528578,
0.20572100579738617,
0.6053157448768616,
0.315624475479126,
0.024405330419540405,
-0.7603461146354675,
-0.13744205236434937,
0.47221070528030396,
-0.17118018865585327,
-0.04996326565742493,
0.2937922477722168,
0.06534207612276077,
-0.523313581943512,
0.9245222210884094,
-0.04081987962126732,
-0.573106586933136,
0.3812490999698639,
0.19998013973236084,
0.5108070969581604,
0.1782630831003189,
-0.38638344407081604,
0.30089640617370605,
0.38443654775619507,
-0.15194036066532135,
-0.0030908333137631416,
-0.1783534735441208,
-0.6158131957054138,
-0.709990382194519,
-0.7346503138542175,
0.04333459958434105,
0.31623804569244385,
-0.4702545702457428,
0.3705599009990692,
-0.2236146181821823,
0.046855028718709946,
-0.16300725936889648,
0.151166632771492,
-0.7927429676055908,
0.11059131473302841,
0.4225918650627136,
1.278316855430603,
-0.6401706337928772,
0.9141629338264465,
0.2560643255710602,
-0.5354652404785156,
-1.0162062644958496,
0.13002747297286987,
0.02002677507698536,
-0.8264883160591125,
0.9165617227554321,
0.4125445485115051,
-0.12638752162456512,
-0.16325481235980988,
-0.5647397637367249,
-1.145862340927124,
0.9492519497871399,
0.6698646545410156,
-0.46054568886756897,
0.062490448355674744,
0.21276478469371796,
0.5936549305915833,
-0.6147683262825012,
0.2316059023141861,
0.4815295934677124,
0.291090726852417,
-0.0498255118727684,
-0.5632786154747009,
0.11180818825960159,
-0.5738906860351562,
-0.03390410915017128,
0.3035159409046173,
-0.42996418476104736,
0.7915415167808533,
0.11481240391731262,
-0.5258967280387878,
0.14494390785694122,
0.6606934666633606,
-0.10018910467624664,
-0.06033727899193764,
0.38917601108551025,
0.6967365741729736,
0.9246359467506409,
-0.11507607251405716,
1.370827555656433,
-0.834023654460907,
0.018393822014331818,
0.8365818858146667,
-0.028272127732634544,
1.0642799139022827,
0.43504762649536133,
-0.023077424615621567,
0.8763586282730103,
0.2324104905128479,
-0.1505015343427658,
0.29123255610466003,
0.2498403936624527,
-0.15543317794799805,
-0.14696669578552246,
-0.6054416298866272,
-0.06979215145111084,
0.2554451525211334,
0.5440966486930847,
-0.4212229251861572,
0.21342523396015167,
-0.2352374643087387,
0.04348660632967949,
0.5270940065383911,
-0.5532609224319458,
0.5971969962120056,
-0.1201820895075798,
-1.0982743501663208,
0.7657026052474976,
-0.37084686756134033,
0.588506281375885,
-0.540242612361908,
0.22312191128730774,
0.03090699575841427,
-0.14774981141090393,
-0.25172868371009827,
-1.0768640041351318,
0.47281691431999207,
0.12391417473554611,
-0.36039063334465027,
-0.5466748476028442,
0.8077191710472107,
-0.37840595841407776,
-0.2312978059053421,
0.38358452916145325,
0.4423829913139343,
0.5536603927612305,
0.08688399940729141,
-0.5562440752983093,
0.5094864964485168,
-0.3467622697353363,
-0.1332448571920395,
0.3287954330444336,
0.3254423439502716,
0.42481914162635803,
0.716903567314148,
0.8702763915061951,
0.34565022587776184,
-0.16370345652103424,
0.3007003366947174,
1.1262435913085938,
-0.26159024238586426,
-0.024012601003050804,
-0.9302017092704773,
0.2796732485294342,
-0.33441081643104553,
-0.17904837429523468,
0.6077747941017151,
0.5561226010322571,
0.7122549414634705,
0.15684327483177185,
0.609530508518219,
0.11905537545681,
0.42633095383644104,
-0.8034595847129822,
0.3772120773792267,
-0.37196847796440125,
0.6143033504486084,
0.20391961932182312,
-0.7727048993110657,
-0.07011494040489197,
0.11769596487283707,
-0.5037258267402649,
-0.0816153809428215,
0.6833463907241821,
0.84922856092453,
0.014996063895523548,
-0.13575027883052826,
0.4198930561542511,
0.02406708523631096,
0.06685464084148407,
0.8428536057472229,
0.7915802597999573,
-0.1886894851922989,
0.7422398924827576,
-0.1395321786403656,
-0.02999063767492771,
0.0340302437543869,
-1.0459620952606201,
-1.0314197540283203,
-0.5071408152580261,
-0.19374683499336243,
-0.1698502153158188,
-0.18393857777118683,
0.9109345078468323,
0.6555174589157104,
-0.28392958641052246,
-0.0730423778295517,
-0.1624450832605362,
-0.02740614302456379,
-0.13095976412296295,
-0.16639597713947296,
0.13517071306705475,
-0.475199431180954,
-0.7635834813117981,
0.42684048414230347,
0.3796504735946655,
-0.03198566660284996,
-0.6301325559616089,
-0.08852676302194595,
-0.04080516844987869,
0.5838344693183899,
0.19056500494480133,
0.04291972145438194,
-0.5933530330657959,
-0.24737098813056946,
-0.1541566252708435,
-0.1979202777147293,
0.05460027605295181,
0.8695036768913269,
-1.1896780729293823,
0.07639073580503464,
0.8317153453826904,
0.7311296463012695,
-0.08531834930181503,
0.008769365958869457,
0.44771283864974976,
-0.8559504151344299,
0.18698981404304504,
0.11711982637643814,
0.4925031065940857,
0.696800947189331,
-0.5248923301696777,
0.5778911113739014,
0.16614925861358643,
-0.9455125331878662,
-0.7891390919685364,
0.40086716413497925,
-0.5790328979492188,
-0.5512643456459045,
1.2984774112701416,
-0.12173040211200714,
-0.518195629119873,
0.06894572079181671,
0.14953483641147614,
0.22821952402591705,
-0.49264591932296753,
0.8088602423667908,
0.9067596197128296,
-0.15185832977294922,
-0.13143055140972137,
-0.8260666728019714,
0.5203208923339844,
0.2709193229675293,
-0.8453236222267151,
0.07022583484649658,
0.3682314157485962,
-0.2407149225473404,
0.5310719013214111,
0.16866493225097656,
0.2153378278017044,
0.008403374813497066,
0.1640617400407791,
-0.11247233301401138,
-0.17514976859092712,
-0.20498906075954437,
-0.4792487323284149,
0.4402414560317993,
0.004125591833144426,
0.3690371513366699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09932v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09932v1
|
Foundational Challenges in Assuring Alignment and Safety of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-15T16:58:28 | 2024-04-15T16:58:28 |
Usman Anwar, Abulhair Saparov, Javier Rando, Daniel Paleka, Miles Turpin, Peter Hase, Ekdeep Singh Lubana, Erik Jenner, Stephen Casper, Oliver Sourbut, Benjamin L. Edelman, Zhaowei Zhang, Mario Günther, Anton Korinek, Jose Hernandez-Orallo, Lewis Hammond, Eric Bigelow, Alexander Pan, Lauro Langosco, Tomasz Korbak, Heidi Zhang, Ruiqi Zhong, Seán Ó hÉigeartaigh, Gabriel Recchia, Giulio Corsi, Alan Chan, Markus Anderljung, Lilian Edwards, Yoshua Bengio, Danqi Chen, Samuel Albanie, Tegan Maharaj, Jakob Foerster, Florian Tramer, He He, Atoosa Kasirzadeh, Yejin Choi, David Krueger
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
This work identifies 18 foundational challenges in assuring the alignment and
safety of large language models (LLMs). These challenges are organized into
three different categories: scientific understanding of LLMs, development and
deployment methods, and sociotechnical challenges. Based on the identified
challenges, we pose $200+$ concrete research questions.
|
[
-0.0890720784664154,
-0.8465917110443115,
0.7889288067817688,
0.3523674011230469,
0.16387073695659637,
0.36683744192123413,
-0.14118993282318115,
-0.7891886234283447,
-0.4638999104499817,
0.8323585391044617,
-0.6434875130653381,
-0.35625600814819336,
-0.6932088136672974,
0.18821056187152863,
-0.6166048049926758,
0.8833578824996948,
-0.4733342230319977,
-0.12044880539178848,
-0.20439213514328003,
-0.013067991472780704,
-0.6320705413818359,
-0.6291499137878418,
-0.4484703540802002,
-0.176640123128891,
0.37849947810173035,
0.46177250146865845,
0.7621554732322693,
0.7395657896995544,
1.067782998085022,
0.3525870740413666,
-0.43026840686798096,
-0.16815587878227234,
-0.2733912467956543,
0.21497036516666412,
-0.2480357438325882,
-0.4457249641418457,
-0.3518788516521454,
-0.25502243638038635,
0.7361264824867249,
1.0434231758117676,
-0.19060924649238586,
0.035154491662979126,
-0.04224274307489395,
0.7715207934379578,
-0.6221987009048462,
0.02449657954275608,
-0.5911946892738342,
-0.1865839660167694,
-0.40618839859962463,
0.12045101821422577,
-0.256410151720047,
-0.41009044647216797,
0.28000858426094055,
-0.40778303146362305,
-0.12693540751934052,
0.09127859771251678,
1.0831738710403442,
0.17661572992801666,
-0.8796836733818054,
-0.6284763813018799,
-0.7672345042228699,
0.8717254996299744,
-0.41037628054618835,
0.1638452112674713,
0.13167425990104675,
0.289217084646225,
-0.45752447843551636,
-0.322017103433609,
-0.4635615348815918,
0.10398104041814804,
0.20192568004131317,
-0.44535931944847107,
0.19973768293857574,
-0.06944508850574493,
0.2165544331073761,
0.5507412552833557,
-0.5535041689872742,
0.5462741851806641,
-0.3628217577934265,
-0.22396250069141388,
0.8868874311447144,
0.5199541449546814,
0.45127153396606445,
-0.07366859167814255,
-0.30450963973999023,
-0.06884074211120605,
-1.1816227436065674,
-0.13623420894145966,
0.41766655445098877,
0.2360585331916809,
-0.402759313583374,
0.7989765405654907,
-0.15258826315402985,
0.7137772440910339,
-0.13067173957824707,
-0.3380551040172577,
0.36213627457618713,
-0.7014040946960449,
0.11557058990001678,
0.12009502947330475,
0.5738539099693298,
0.2496817260980606,
0.35547083616256714,
-0.07032647728919983,
-0.3061879575252533,
0.05416039004921913,
0.13276396691799164,
-0.2774781286716461,
0.35027286410331726,
0.6099807024002075,
-0.06285757571458817,
-0.5766941905021667,
-0.34973663091659546,
-0.4325439929962158,
-0.6025328636169434,
-0.27859267592430115,
0.3800792992115021,
-0.35883402824401855,
-0.3441060185432434,
0.12148851156234741,
0.24227690696716309,
0.6871646642684937,
0.44822004437446594,
-1.0180267095565796,
0.16210463643074036,
1.1964647769927979,
0.8678780794143677,
-0.2939903736114502,
-0.31114742159843445,
0.11520286649465561,
0.5432238578796387,
-0.36856189370155334,
0.6450101137161255,
-0.22825457155704498,
-0.2513817548751831,
0.21016469597816467,
0.15806525945663452,
-0.06301708519458771,
-0.2928053140640259,
0.2831091582775116,
-0.32890963554382324,
-0.07868557423353195,
-0.4317972660064697,
-0.6668062806129456,
0.07215578854084015,
0.5782817006111145,
-0.5347898602485657,
0.8816347718238831,
0.06120876595377922,
-0.7894588708877563,
-0.12949420511722565,
-0.4033504128456116,
-0.4931221604347229,
-0.01725953072309494,
-0.3629443645477295,
-0.160040482878685,
0.004977234173566103,
-0.1462821066379547,
0.3250015676021576,
-0.4566185474395752,
0.5751232504844666,
-0.11846353113651276,
-0.1309828758239746,
0.36824679374694824,
-0.18102340400218964,
1.038211703300476,
0.18944625556468964,
-0.5322396755218506,
0.2582319378852844,
-1.0008747577667236,
-0.26534032821655273,
0.28784531354904175,
-0.3790244460105896,
-0.01022796519100666,
0.17198315262794495,
-0.042714208364486694,
0.011447123251855373,
0.48923248052597046,
-0.42687153816223145,
0.2801385521888733,
-0.3814009428024292,
0.43725600838661194,
0.8007767200469971,
0.04136858507990837,
0.36199137568473816,
-0.31934115290641785,
0.5444418787956238,
0.045274727046489716,
0.11919881403446198,
-0.10569724440574646,
-0.5471348762512207,
-0.5942747592926025,
0.09033282846212387,
0.19533944129943848,
0.9115269780158997,
-0.37352117896080017,
0.454855352640152,
-0.2603676915168762,
-0.566709041595459,
-0.2891470789909363,
0.2786746621131897,
0.45335477590560913,
0.4061677157878876,
-0.003003969555720687,
0.09410516172647476,
-0.456541508436203,
-0.9798919558525085,
0.19124257564544678,
-0.14293172955513,
0.15993143618106842,
-0.06201962009072304,
0.8298028111457825,
-0.3168526589870453,
0.8052777051925659,
-0.3296601474285126,
-0.1071268692612648,
-0.012095279060304165,
0.2298235297203064,
0.09691688418388367,
0.9128117561340332,
0.48710763454437256,
-0.9430647492408752,
-0.34718748927116394,
0.37632307410240173,
-0.8422344923019409,
-0.12856365740299225,
0.20009759068489075,
0.1799522191286087,
0.41795268654823303,
0.7031652927398682,
-0.7609811425209045,
0.22248758375644684,
0.6210567951202393,
-0.004761931020766497,
0.6919373273849487,
0.10376414656639099,
-0.04969281330704689,
-1.121778130531311,
-0.07255052775144577,
-0.04719943553209305,
-0.03619745373725891,
-0.6848325133323669,
0.4368821680545807,
-0.04904152452945709,
-0.2576172351837158,
-0.5152816772460938,
0.36178624629974365,
-0.6184161305427551,
-0.09927228093147278,
-0.05861752852797508,
0.20346644520759583,
-0.10117290914058685,
-0.1251796931028366,
-0.04841169714927673,
0.573265790939331,
0.7083224058151245,
-0.7343470454216003,
0.6212495565414429,
0.16387836635112762,
-0.5261522531509399,
0.5946499109268188,
-0.7648350596427917,
0.09511476755142212,
-0.11796785145998001,
0.10601088404655457,
-1.006468653678894,
-0.4450221061706543,
0.054741233587265015,
-0.25366389751434326,
0.4498474597930908,
0.06257475912570953,
-0.6310809254646301,
-0.0754653662443161,
-0.12944112718105316,
0.4577648639678955,
0.4662928581237793,
-0.14321357011795044,
0.679046094417572,
0.5091321468353271,
-0.3465173840522766,
-0.9254791736602783,
-0.5739234089851379,
0.08494704216718674,
-0.3312286138534546,
-0.9043410420417786,
0.371530681848526,
-0.05421963334083557,
-0.5989362597465515,
0.048290036618709564,
-0.062287602573633194,
0.2402152270078659,
0.6523467898368835,
0.3268791735172272,
0.18426483869552612,
-0.3095056116580963,
-0.14430229365825653,
-0.29312220215797424,
-0.23981758952140808,
0.24233923852443695,
0.07565662264823914,
0.29743802547454834,
-0.3934020400047302,
-0.7037450671195984,
-0.20258153975009918,
0.5159339308738708,
0.5067375898361206,
0.038101665675640106,
0.6923761963844299,
0.4649098813533783,
-0.6796854734420776,
0.18892721831798553,
-0.9098940491676331,
0.2874090373516083,
-0.5333603024482727,
0.4189228415489197,
-0.39912042021751404,
-1.2308706045150757,
0.839319109916687,
-0.061593279242515564,
0.35210904479026794,
0.3690619468688965,
0.7313420176506042,
-0.1321551650762558,
1.2332402467727661,
0.7437307834625244,
-0.023551292717456818,
0.05893343314528465,
0.19355247914791107,
0.23311367630958557,
-0.6287486553192139,
-0.5735856890678406,
-0.9904717206954956,
-0.18421223759651184,
-0.53846275806427,
-0.336392879486084,
0.29134440422058105,
0.31185322999954224,
-0.5065275430679321,
0.3417891561985016,
-0.31951001286506653,
0.4411647915840149,
0.2909269630908966,
-0.33568617701530457,
0.418684184551239,
-0.15997985005378723,
-0.1847134530544281,
0.016105879098176956,
-0.2638425827026367,
-0.7618623375892639,
0.8452746272087097,
0.7752199769020081,
1.0134599208831787,
0.683192789554596,
0.7074616551399231,
-0.27450495958328247,
0.24521559476852417,
-0.7783364057540894,
0.6224561929702759,
0.1341942548751831,
-1.0887466669082642,
-0.4729977250099182,
-0.4620542526245117,
-0.8571462631225586,
-0.008691257797181606,
-0.20451997220516205,
-1.3292030096054077,
0.06831900030374527,
0.06573518365621567,
-0.16203460097312927,
-0.00005108311233925633,
-0.3939467668533325,
0.6842520833015442,
-0.688165545463562,
-0.2662782669067383,
0.05294497683644295,
-0.9106624126434326,
0.561519980430603,
-0.1883554756641388,
0.6261054277420044,
-0.34245485067367554,
0.07323353737592697,
0.5802034139633179,
-0.32922908663749695,
0.8886147737503052,
0.34851640462875366,
-0.6170111894607544,
0.29566508531570435,
0.15756693482398987,
0.6460274457931519,
-0.1888003647327423,
0.10711181163787842,
-0.18883104622364044,
0.3708614706993103,
-0.4478033483028412,
-0.2569639980792999,
0.796728789806366,
-0.7000706791877747,
-1.1831389665603638,
-0.6428475975990295,
-0.7838907241821289,
-0.5360490083694458,
0.14939309656620026,
0.06054254248738289,
0.024796783924102783,
-0.26471588015556335,
0.4093034565448761,
1.1564934253692627,
-0.3195067346096039,
0.4531661570072174,
0.5152955055236816,
-0.48805344104766846,
-0.2610813081264496,
0.8083692789077759,
0.06891995668411255,
0.6316280364990234,
0.4484887421131134,
0.06425555795431137,
-0.07398068159818649,
-1.1215964555740356,
-0.34338653087615967,
0.19585542380809784,
-0.8977872133255005,
-0.077547088265419,
-0.7002952098846436,
-0.38188815116882324,
-0.5595798492431641,
-0.3206297755241394,
-0.5557218790054321,
-0.26363256573677063,
-0.446591317653656,
-0.2241569608449936,
0.3775785267353058,
1.0655120611190796,
-0.11369398981332779,
0.42397332191467285,
-0.9814462661743164,
0.03691444918513298,
0.184611514210701,
0.3101089298725128,
-0.047062262892723083,
-0.38165760040283203,
-0.22964464128017426,
-0.16453516483306885,
-0.32615581154823303,
-0.9036965370178223,
-0.13335582613945007,
-0.37795913219451904,
0.5301646590232849,
0.4593217074871063,
-0.14730781316757202,
0.524936318397522,
-0.45624664425849915,
0.8871260285377502,
0.2412029355764389,
-0.9926007986068726,
0.46261781454086304,
-0.5995879769325256,
-0.06960710138082504,
0.6125164031982422,
0.6693925261497498,
-0.30053821206092834,
0.057915251702070236,
-0.2903864085674286,
-1.015423059463501,
0.3500518202781677,
0.18915456533432007,
0.06401360780000687,
-0.047897543758153915,
0.5231930017471313,
-0.36349380016326904,
0.12431914359331131,
-0.9466625452041626,
-0.07786858826875687,
0.35073423385620117,
-0.2749091684818268,
0.010887355543673038,
-0.4331987202167511,
-0.5403317809104919,
0.04548739269375801,
0.7005119919776917,
-0.013385768048465252,
-0.3287782669067383,
-0.09792567789554596,
-0.28450268507003784,
-0.2545338571071625,
0.48914635181427,
1.209216833114624,
0.7657322883605957,
-0.43397921323776245,
0.17719978094100952,
0.16015779972076416,
-0.1846802979707718,
0.4846753776073456,
-0.1268375962972641,
-0.026942623779177666,
-0.3774062395095825,
0.6152178645133972,
0.7120969891548157,
0.421893447637558,
-0.7814182043075562,
0.4666946232318878,
0.25066304206848145,
-0.3941953778266907,
-0.5781462788581848,
-0.08039554953575134,
0.5085803866386414,
0.04851357638835907,
0.4853370189666748,
-0.5762136578559875,
-0.3349761962890625,
-0.6332547664642334,
-0.15670154988765717,
0.6482313871383667,
-0.37050560116767883,
-0.2659158706665039,
0.50441575050354,
0.21244831383228302,
-0.3340880870819092,
0.3508705794811249,
0.26880618929862976,
-0.6900887489318848,
0.7875943779945374,
0.7606471180915833,
0.5823025107383728,
-0.3439041078090668,
-0.09874077886343002,
-0.0452335961163044,
0.7420889139175415,
-0.5529877543449402,
0.4161696135997772,
0.603800356388092,
-0.7709368467330933,
-0.41010138392448425,
-0.6016368865966797,
-0.8328180313110352,
0.15601526200771332,
-0.5609005689620972,
0.42439040541648865,
-0.4992057979106903,
-0.013637938536703587,
0.12003722041845322,
-0.10497096925973892,
-0.39297714829444885,
0.03803931921720505,
0.20782503485679626,
0.877630352973938,
-0.9683893322944641,
0.4252232611179352,
0.8118282556533813,
-0.2532866299152374,
-0.8674238920211792,
-0.6173262596130371,
0.36431023478507996,
-0.7445179224014282,
0.8207852244377136,
0.008174360729753971,
-0.08137059956789017,
-0.210475355386734,
-0.6572906970977783,
-1.1932964324951172,
1.1199806928634644,
0.4713108539581299,
-0.8804413676261902,
-0.3902471959590912,
0.3819398880004883,
0.3066665232181549,
-0.5795738101005554,
-0.26422223448753357,
0.5183038115501404,
0.7374473214149475,
0.1291806548833847,
-1.187164545059204,
0.14334699511528015,
-0.06914437562227249,
0.04524499177932739,
0.16938768327236176,
-0.5552776455879211,
0.9756526350975037,
-0.13457481563091278,
-0.24406683444976807,
0.22301563620567322,
0.4081119894981384,
0.6039800643920898,
0.3107728958129883,
0.4202738106250763,
0.7920883297920227,
0.6011968851089478,
-0.21224761009216309,
1.0245105028152466,
-0.17077487707138062,
0.35444435477256775,
0.9992349147796631,
-0.7490349411964417,
0.6112648844718933,
0.7832708954811096,
-0.29404333233833313,
0.42090484499931335,
0.8577226996421814,
0.016591932624578476,
0.21555835008621216,
0.5160315036773682,
-0.33627551794052124,
-0.0767037570476532,
-0.2331334352493286,
-0.9237622618675232,
0.36749351024627686,
0.724567174911499,
-0.10373847931623459,
-0.016954196617007256,
-0.08759944885969162,
0.05653364956378937,
0.00999479927122593,
-0.21801362931728363,
0.6944072246551514,
0.19744959473609924,
-0.4915652275085449,
0.29881179332733154,
0.1572776883840561,
0.5086228847503662,
-0.5698145627975464,
-0.006283833645284176,
0.19698470830917358,
0.17346982657909393,
-0.3190133571624756,
-0.8070086240768433,
0.40881064534187317,
-0.18485476076602936,
-0.13295087218284607,
0.007388534490019083,
0.6423485279083252,
-0.20543082058429718,
-0.5249831080436707,
0.22406139969825745,
0.22982476651668549,
-0.030934400856494904,
0.23569954931735992,
-0.493975967168808,
0.6782386302947998,
-0.3116658627986908,
-0.3254730701446533,
0.5784376859664917,
0.49726471304893494,
-0.3080369830131531,
0.9963204860687256,
0.4569791555404663,
-0.08816152065992355,
0.16555356979370117,
-0.19783712923526764,
0.6263913512229919,
-0.7992942929267883,
-0.20940940082073212,
-0.9776620864868164,
0.5888153910636902,
0.15073084831237793,
-0.09278186410665512,
0.6270925402641296,
0.1749904304742813,
0.48530077934265137,
-0.030779043212532997,
0.6693075895309448,
-0.0999993085861206,
0.2590077221393585,
-0.7183135151863098,
0.6240999698638916,
-0.30988308787345886,
0.595129668712616,
-0.5663094520568848,
-0.7702576518058777,
-0.36690348386764526,
0.5002663135528564,
-0.16964034736156464,
-0.028113629668951035,
0.8504958152770996,
0.6146337985992432,
0.4476185142993927,
-0.15299570560455322,
0.03372244909405708,
-0.0023467261344194412,
0.3453069031238556,
0.6848440170288086,
1.1731956005096436,
-0.38846057653427124,
0.46189433336257935,
-0.43901562690734863,
-0.06452039629220963,
-0.17732590436935425,
-1.4257068634033203,
-0.8289027214050293,
-0.5394291877746582,
-0.653541088104248,
-0.77727210521698,
0.03895890712738037,
0.8500109910964966,
0.5875635743141174,
-1.1511071920394897,
-0.6088298559188843,
-0.1171628013253212,
0.6324175000190735,
-0.018391180783510208,
-0.21180732548236847,
0.15066005289554596,
-0.1442369520664215,
-0.6050827503204346,
0.29297930002212524,
0.28990310430526733,
0.4344217777252197,
-0.45232316851615906,
0.05222482979297638,
-0.5582534074783325,
-0.12176329642534256,
0.38372665643692017,
0.45747414231300354,
-0.8331503868103027,
-0.7891595959663391,
-0.06779814511537552,
-0.34154972434043884,
-0.3010956943035126,
0.8073855042457581,
-0.0028065552469342947,
-0.06007441133260727,
0.43407148122787476,
1.1652631759643555,
0.21403613686561584,
0.02442753128707409,
0.8072542548179626,
-0.6880483031272888,
0.05076960474252701,
0.081352099776268,
0.48691365122795105,
0.47276490926742554,
-0.5105359554290771,
0.6959147453308105,
0.18133142590522766,
-0.6393342614173889,
-1.3210052251815796,
0.6202226877212524,
-1.1886391639709473,
-0.08856689929962158,
1.087935447692871,
-0.12453385442495346,
-0.14774993062019348,
-0.3983817994594574,
0.2555212676525116,
0.0740419551730156,
0.388749897480011,
0.5567307472229004,
1.2543284893035889,
-0.09869534522294998,
-0.437060683965683,
-0.576251208782196,
0.4134864807128906,
0.4872434735298157,
-0.7593013644218445,
-0.04264714941382408,
0.4935256540775299,
0.5323126316070557,
0.5115392208099365,
0.3108205199241638,
-0.44612398743629456,
0.11958342790603638,
-0.22227542102336884,
0.07663893699645996,
0.1360306441783905,
-0.38842350244522095,
-0.435132771730423,
0.3558713495731354,
0.3728634715080261,
0.3889218866825104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13076v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13076v1
|
LLM Evaluators Recognize and Favor Their Own Generations
| 2024-04-15T16:49:59 | 2024-04-15T16:49:59 |
Arjun Panickssery, Samuel R. Bowman, Shi Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Self-evaluation using large language models (LLMs) has proven valuable not
only in benchmarking but also methods like reward modeling, constitutional AI,
and self-refinement. But new biases are introduced due to the same LLM acting
as both the evaluator and the evaluatee. One such bias is self-preference,
where an LLM evaluator scores its own outputs higher than others' while human
annotators consider them of equal quality. But do LLMs actually recognize their
own outputs when they give those texts higher scores, or is it just a
coincidence? In this paper, we investigate if self-recognition capability
contributes to self-preference. We discover that, out of the box, LLMs such as
GPT-4 and Llama 2 have non-trivial accuracy at distinguishing themselves from
other LLMs and humans. By fine-tuning LLMs, we discover a linear correlation
between self-recognition capability and the strength of self-preference bias;
using controlled experiments, we show that the causal explanation resists
straightforward confounders. We discuss how self-recognition can interfere with
unbiased evaluations and AI safety more generally.
|
[
-0.5030491352081299,
-0.07271973788738251,
0.8636429905891418,
0.15645717084407806,
-0.13908030092716217,
0.23015227913856506,
-0.18616464734077454,
-0.6851387619972229,
0.20872250199317932,
0.40371230244636536,
-0.21164986491203308,
-0.012767360545694828,
-0.8168079257011414,
0.4064430594444275,
-0.1507605016231537,
1.0323721170425415,
0.08584815263748169,
0.005117050837725401,
-0.4222167730331421,
-0.16533155739307404,
-0.23466812074184418,
-0.7766850590705872,
-0.2880595922470093,
-0.7202089428901672,
0.6359149813652039,
0.27740973234176636,
0.578396737575531,
0.730597972869873,
0.3392007350921631,
0.3409232795238495,
0.19043926894664764,
-0.1596197485923767,
-0.38375014066696167,
0.14753982424736023,
-0.2258339822292328,
-0.31686684489250183,
-0.14800255000591278,
0.5983782410621643,
0.4731390178203583,
0.09445580095052719,
0.33775657415390015,
0.1982070654630661,
0.4399317502975464,
0.849513828754425,
-0.36774516105651855,
-0.05902153626084328,
-0.7320843935012817,
-0.05825509503483772,
-0.34223705530166626,
-0.4576086103916168,
-0.2414463460445404,
-0.30789875984191895,
0.08624977618455887,
-0.14158467948436737,
0.3806501626968384,
-0.023169226944446564,
0.677433431148529,
0.515655517578125,
-0.5241713523864746,
-0.34302136301994324,
-0.6045097708702087,
0.6890837550163269,
-0.5516892671585083,
0.2547420263290405,
0.3829626441001892,
0.09120006859302521,
-0.004729141015559435,
-0.19055573642253876,
-0.4423690736293793,
-0.33106809854507446,
-0.18570959568023682,
0.10940231382846832,
-0.10597604513168335,
0.10728368908166885,
0.204898864030838,
0.48365992307662964,
-0.47757765650749207,
0.6683428287506104,
-0.3871213495731354,
-0.46930357813835144,
0.7338776588439941,
0.055917490273714066,
0.01673308201134205,
-0.4090690612792969,
-0.6434248685836792,
0.06149955838918686,
-0.7902578115463257,
0.22030410170555115,
0.5178494453430176,
0.034940898418426514,
0.2607412040233612,
0.5336335897445679,
-0.3464529812335968,
0.45149582624435425,
0.2869793176651001,
-0.06736382097005844,
0.34606051445007324,
-0.06421229243278503,
-0.13410425186157227,
0.031611599028110504,
1.0831478834152222,
0.21855179965496063,
0.4089895486831665,
-0.11545563489198685,
-0.269412100315094,
0.11353854835033417,
0.16648392379283905,
-0.5170141458511353,
-0.11628618091344833,
-0.011360147967934608,
-0.6429579257965088,
-0.4006947875022888,
-0.04128529503941536,
-0.5953238010406494,
-0.7300485372543335,
-0.31462880969047546,
0.6330951452255249,
-0.0425196997821331,
0.05901715159416199,
0.03454398363828659,
-0.11909976601600647,
0.16472052037715912,
0.2938643991947174,
-1.1316105127334595,
-0.08234221488237381,
0.5173496603965759,
0.4565298557281494,
-0.3705243468284607,
-0.6711888313293457,
-0.4540114998817444,
-0.18454574048519135,
-0.29136526584625244,
1.0413635969161987,
-0.4760470688343048,
-0.46476617455482483,
-0.40943199396133423,
-0.3197329044342041,
0.07446416467428207,
-0.8010435104370117,
0.43647101521492004,
-0.32711389660835266,
0.06803511828184128,
-0.5198699235916138,
-0.48312661051750183,
0.04087640345096588,
-0.10621743649244308,
-0.4085812270641327,
0.8883493542671204,
-0.11417481303215027,
-0.599371075630188,
0.7393574714660645,
-0.28118520975112915,
-0.2267916351556778,
0.11547622829675674,
-0.48218756914138794,
-0.43987128138542175,
0.3773166835308075,
0.12409090250730515,
0.48228850960731506,
-0.11680787801742554,
0.11428087204694748,
-0.5461848974227905,
-0.30439791083335876,
0.5131602883338928,
-0.8383777141571045,
0.5398029088973999,
0.2215041220188141,
-0.4224292039871216,
0.10154341906309128,
-0.689641535282135,
-0.07688874751329422,
0.11437242478132248,
-0.6763577461242676,
-0.383396714925766,
-0.12803326547145844,
-0.5897206664085388,
0.30841174721717834,
0.6925418972969055,
-0.4303220808506012,
0.20452384650707245,
-0.06793422996997833,
0.34835508465766907,
1.3312842845916748,
-0.2733587920665741,
0.37471073865890503,
-0.3794982433319092,
0.4033043384552002,
-0.12271270900964737,
0.12487120926380157,
0.12668320536613464,
-0.33766648173332214,
-0.8059377074241638,
-0.15915636718273163,
0.23120269179344177,
0.1385108083486557,
-0.12246592342853546,
0.5376183986663818,
-0.011788708157837391,
-0.33420661091804504,
-0.6430474519729614,
0.5937578678131104,
0.3181886076927185,
0.33311736583709717,
0.2321961224079132,
-0.3204515874385834,
-0.4742391109466553,
-1.052840232849121,
-0.578580915927887,
-0.46028804779052734,
-0.0421491377055645,
0.45131707191467285,
0.1325470209121704,
-0.11985290050506592,
1.0036011934280396,
-0.17461922764778137,
-0.46752500534057617,
-0.08112338930368423,
0.14741693437099457,
-0.009854359552264214,
0.3070412874221802,
0.6635955572128296,
-0.2970485985279083,
-0.18622395396232605,
-0.25929924845695496,
-0.7941469550132751,
-0.431708425283432,
-0.16793052852153778,
0.007097598165273666,
0.025615990161895752,
0.27281323075294495,
-0.215590238571167,
0.30677729845046997,
0.6629202961921692,
-0.4047432243824005,
0.5878188610076904,
-0.46838366985321045,
0.05864168703556061,
-0.5005565285682678,
-0.30470573902130127,
0.03818555921316147,
-0.18096521496772766,
-0.24626898765563965,
-0.14460280537605286,
0.18880929052829742,
0.5633339881896973,
-0.23495841026306152,
0.6293306350708008,
-0.4355870187282562,
-0.4534720480442047,
-0.4015499949455261,
0.10473215579986572,
0.04493938758969307,
0.1807025521993637,
-0.08819641172885895,
1.089580774307251,
0.3429639935493469,
-0.5192962884902954,
0.0731293335556984,
0.13710781931877136,
-0.3500099182128906,
0.4372665584087372,
-0.4118861258029938,
0.4776936173439026,
-0.07377270609140396,
0.05121961236000061,
-1.0621761083602905,
-0.16411654651165009,
0.065357506275177,
-0.37354516983032227,
0.25555089116096497,
-0.035841312259435654,
-0.01375645026564598,
-0.5365610122680664,
-0.5559396147727966,
0.32972201704978943,
0.461351215839386,
-1.1455419063568115,
0.5315450429916382,
0.28217896819114685,
0.056429244577884674,
-0.7098023891448975,
-0.7072722315788269,
0.043982915580272675,
-0.43299633264541626,
-0.09853771328926086,
0.11344568431377411,
-0.3831311762332916,
-0.15599684417247772,
-0.2730577886104584,
-0.1299986094236374,
0.2578296363353729,
0.16850575804710388,
0.6669156551361084,
0.42199307680130005,
0.08368276804685593,
0.12352558970451355,
-0.04218403249979019,
-0.19087669253349304,
0.13224361836910248,
-0.1345357596874237,
0.3405826687812805,
-0.23704904317855835,
-0.4238640069961548,
-0.29781806468963623,
-0.2417054921388626,
0.4926409125328064,
-0.2987579107284546,
0.16019469499588013,
0.33643195033073425,
0.14082202315330505,
0.06310155242681503,
-0.9974824786186218,
-0.1537051796913147,
-0.543764054775238,
0.08710449934005737,
-0.5830339193344116,
-1.1274912357330322,
0.17797118425369263,
0.222360759973526,
-0.24492020905017853,
0.661022961139679,
0.6791212558746338,
-0.23806168138980865,
0.9044753909111023,
0.23762577772140503,
-0.523810625076294,
0.4091973602771759,
0.10782887786626816,
0.08664797991514206,
-1.1546080112457275,
-0.020898567512631416,
-0.6296828985214233,
-0.3509581387042999,
-0.7829171419143677,
0.05465488135814667,
0.28366896510124207,
-0.11032158136367798,
-0.2459918111562729,
0.10340913385152817,
-0.7425973415374756,
0.6422793865203857,
0.6185483932495117,
0.08152230829000473,
0.5056375861167908,
-0.1117810383439064,
-0.09136518090963364,
-0.1865995228290558,
-0.37276846170425415,
-0.827944815158844,
1.2310335636138916,
0.4444369077682495,
0.9426056742668152,
-0.12425817549228668,
1.187265157699585,
0.5576984882354736,
0.5211153626441956,
-0.6185123324394226,
0.6073640584945679,
-0.18670576810836792,
-0.615056574344635,
-0.20795026421546936,
-0.4488334059715271,
-1.1142911911010742,
0.1391126811504364,
-0.19326581060886383,
-0.8081846833229065,
0.296354740858078,
0.32577651739120483,
-0.4245094656944275,
0.13860568404197693,
-0.5505577921867371,
0.7351191639900208,
-0.5796593427658081,
-0.3232698142528534,
-0.23935829102993011,
-0.2353505790233612,
0.40344882011413574,
-0.22418661415576935,
0.0979030430316925,
-0.5972803831100464,
0.19915315508842468,
0.7908471822738647,
0.12646876275539398,
0.715650200843811,
0.10265146940946579,
-0.05972412973642349,
0.17468605935573578,
0.2834383547306061,
0.15134918689727783,
0.1436159610748291,
-0.21493412554264069,
0.4207129180431366,
-0.2196749448776245,
-0.13156868517398834,
-0.42288675904273987,
1.0977662801742554,
-1.156747579574585,
-1.321833848953247,
-0.635491132736206,
-0.19213952124118805,
0.0564369261264801,
0.16941699385643005,
0.33654385805130005,
0.061023980379104614,
-0.21106137335300446,
-0.1562718003988266,
0.06722176820039749,
-0.11284707486629486,
0.4121355414390564,
0.6161544322967529,
-0.3196879029273987,
-0.2868199348449707,
0.8933510184288025,
0.32673585414886475,
0.4365394711494446,
0.024156929925084114,
0.554761528968811,
-0.511610209941864,
-0.41894346475601196,
-0.5554441809654236,
0.31703469157218933,
-0.8695690035820007,
-0.14820429682731628,
-0.5132755637168884,
-0.18076182901859283,
-0.21004506945610046,
-0.040279313921928406,
-0.17129600048065186,
-0.3804228901863098,
-0.3754407465457916,
-0.3654669523239136,
0.1299978792667389,
1.252698540687561,
-0.34529808163642883,
-0.20127898454666138,
-0.35059693455696106,
0.1827714890241623,
1.0894993543624878,
0.37534090876579285,
0.01117715798318386,
-0.7096200585365295,
0.09381494671106339,
-0.19133277237415314,
-0.41461509466171265,
-0.6589611768722534,
0.11785595864057541,
-0.0795002430677414,
0.5618346929550171,
0.6175838708877563,
-0.08311419934034348,
0.405291348695755,
-0.35424908995628357,
0.6142066121101379,
-0.11605951935052872,
-0.9915385842323303,
0.2729569673538208,
-0.01193931046873331,
0.07495084404945374,
0.6464444994926453,
0.1803036779165268,
-0.07533510774374008,
-0.35480907559394836,
-0.44770005345344543,
-0.08643701672554016,
0.5723697543144226,
0.004723074845969677,
0.2668309807777405,
-0.18311603367328644,
0.38462164998054504,
0.30605360865592957,
0.13312120735645294,
-1.0418660640716553,
-0.13050848245620728,
-0.3392392694950104,
0.012248999439179897,
-0.18874172866344452,
-0.5721128582954407,
0.034223563969135284,
0.007739960215985775,
0.4982510507106781,
-0.2271237075328827,
0.24283432960510254,
0.3042418360710144,
0.13755588233470917,
-0.3009949028491974,
0.4386635422706604,
0.4591657817363739,
0.3680950105190277,
-0.043110862374305725,
0.5151730179786682,
0.27127236127853394,
-0.1681780368089676,
0.511725664138794,
-0.07255597412586212,
-0.03313826769590378,
-0.32757139205932617,
0.1426585614681244,
0.5335273146629333,
-0.12255758792161942,
-0.327623188495636,
0.5215878486633301,
-0.16239938139915466,
0.02277406118810177,
-0.1276649832725525,
0.3456186354160309,
0.018532654270529747,
0.2051110863685608,
0.44416752457618713,
0.20920155942440033,
0.21478363871574402,
-0.6229602098464966,
-0.019726956263184547,
0.9353923797607422,
-0.1989922970533371,
-0.3584982752799988,
0.8616110682487488,
0.002800574293360114,
-0.47422462701797485,
0.27795329689979553,
-0.26885363459587097,
-0.6691719889640808,
0.4977937936782837,
0.4512923061847687,
0.8957343697547913,
-0.5900831818580627,
0.1102745309472084,
0.21379207074642181,
0.23804157972335815,
0.003886901307851076,
0.026556313037872314,
-0.13313676416873932,
-1.0656044483184814,
-0.04421145096421242,
-0.7632625699043274,
-0.31249359250068665,
0.2114107608795166,
-0.5034341216087341,
0.1331854611635208,
-0.48921671509742737,
-0.29110464453697205,
0.09361022710800171,
-0.14144794642925262,
-0.8952817320823669,
0.2406439483165741,
0.1831536442041397,
0.303629070520401,
-0.68704754114151,
0.7880776524543762,
0.20749475061893463,
-0.3273128569126129,
-0.801425576210022,
0.14512738585472107,
-0.028327863663434982,
-1.2114317417144775,
0.7804417014122009,
0.3388237953186035,
-0.20165005326271057,
-0.09541203081607819,
-0.20701925456523895,
-0.9232943058013916,
0.8624287843704224,
0.3645392954349518,
-0.5764493942260742,
0.013436808250844479,
0.17863604426383972,
0.5934797525405884,
-0.4090938866138458,
0.489959180355072,
0.6734728813171387,
0.44581180810928345,
-0.3338627815246582,
-1.001878023147583,
-0.04666176810860634,
0.20015056431293488,
-0.15432657301425934,
-0.020662818104028702,
-0.9636251330375671,
0.6596179008483887,
-0.4643726050853729,
0.019680676981806755,
0.008901108987629414,
0.5317737460136414,
0.3208504915237427,
0.38244786858558655,
0.4981668293476105,
0.33231183886528015,
0.5399458408355713,
0.001722895191051066,
0.9707292318344116,
-0.44625386595726013,
0.38913455605506897,
1.0199037790298462,
-0.38076087832450867,
0.7080187797546387,
0.41954126954078674,
-0.44809871912002563,
0.5291990637779236,
0.5773945450782776,
0.06031939014792442,
0.32756564021110535,
-0.08189032226800919,
-0.1840059608221054,
-0.3515857458114624,
-0.06916774809360504,
-0.18738099932670593,
0.6781320571899414,
0.002099288860335946,
-0.7342458963394165,
0.16763362288475037,
-0.19586610794067383,
-0.019232727587223053,
0.06531108915805817,
-0.2701462209224701,
0.8416681885719299,
0.14690901339054108,
-0.8422725796699524,
0.5518980026245117,
-0.27505597472190857,
0.6622720956802368,
-0.38459914922714233,
0.31084463000297546,
-0.07830121368169785,
-0.030785635113716125,
-0.49457696080207825,
-1.1125413179397583,
-0.027727162465453148,
-0.14139434695243835,
-0.11389438062906265,
-0.2758466899394989,
0.8673804402351379,
-0.12511199712753296,
-0.2613105773925781,
0.6294459700584412,
0.7228561043739319,
0.18300200998783112,
0.07401995360851288,
-0.5965445041656494,
0.006317246239632368,
0.17962513864040375,
-0.37388572096824646,
0.7212830185890198,
0.2005241960287094,
0.10828208923339844,
0.6185634136199951,
0.7162912487983704,
0.07913438230752945,
0.11138860136270523,
0.24706315994262695,
0.6839589476585388,
-0.5864144563674927,
-0.2628103196620941,
-1.206505298614502,
-0.09688575565814972,
0.13362881541252136,
-0.42490270733833313,
0.8738663196563721,
0.6300133466720581,
0.8576310873031616,
-0.06242633983492851,
0.9417158365249634,
0.40703555941581726,
0.44514018297195435,
-0.41019853949546814,
0.5380237698554993,
-0.4768555760383606,
0.4408413767814636,
-0.241753950715065,
-0.8814560770988464,
0.19038809835910797,
0.7228904366493225,
-0.7432684898376465,
0.3710979223251343,
0.33417126536369324,
0.6418278217315674,
0.1966751515865326,
-0.06983157992362976,
0.6751214265823364,
0.1454954445362091,
0.27985498309135437,
0.45213404297828674,
1.1434277296066284,
0.07191827148199081,
0.33792567253112793,
-0.17029902338981628,
-0.2741011381149292,
-0.09350845217704773,
-0.8296387195587158,
-1.1159625053405762,
-0.4579482078552246,
-0.0925367921590805,
-0.2875101864337921,
-0.07373018562793732,
1.0792772769927979,
0.475851446390152,
-0.4800657331943512,
-0.25943875312805176,
0.09360930323600769,
0.26010140776634216,
0.10732720047235489,
-0.1896875947713852,
0.0780504122376442,
-0.4271717369556427,
-0.6156109571456909,
0.5493585467338562,
0.6027681827545166,
0.24166369438171387,
-0.630031406879425,
-0.2903442084789276,
0.44153544306755066,
0.22299574315547943,
0.2516407370567322,
0.23342828452587128,
-0.9871596097946167,
-0.6658467650413513,
-0.25903838872909546,
-0.2788933217525482,
0.6585261821746826,
0.7535442113876343,
-1.0562909841537476,
0.6084557175636292,
0.33597180247306824,
0.45731493830680847,
0.3410686254501343,
0.1264672875404358,
0.32152098417282104,
-0.13502103090286255,
-0.33370494842529297,
-0.0364166796207428,
0.5913756489753723,
0.40805578231811523,
-0.6975841522216797,
0.5704244375228882,
0.0787874087691307,
-1.1659801006317139,
-0.4966484308242798,
0.3234250843524933,
-0.5526741147041321,
0.062215834856033325,
1.0913759469985962,
0.005902835633605719,
0.0015184697695076466,
-0.04031621664762497,
-0.35600990056991577,
-0.0927605926990509,
-0.4932584762573242,
1.209053635597229,
0.6776394248008728,
-0.42453792691230774,
-0.002972373040392995,
-0.2266191989183426,
0.6219735145568848,
0.6633241772651672,
-0.5535001158714294,
0.04656500741839409,
0.22613857686519623,
0.6317137479782104,
0.18644186854362488,
0.7923619151115417,
0.05409492552280426,
0.19260704517364502,
-0.46231329441070557,
-0.02052183821797371,
0.03468025103211403,
-0.20339711010456085,
-0.8278175592422485,
-0.12399157881736755,
0.7638452649116516,
0.027850158512592316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10032v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10032v1
|
Detecting AI Generated Text Based on NLP and Machine Learning Approaches
| 2024-04-15T16:37:44 | 2024-04-15T16:37:44 |
Nuzhat Prova
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Recent advances in natural language processing (NLP) may enable artificial
intelligence (AI) models to generate writing that is identical to human written
form in the future. This might have profound ethical, legal, and social
repercussions. This study aims to address this problem by offering an accurate
AI detector model that can differentiate between electronically produced text
and human-written text. Our approach includes machine learning methods such as
XGB Classifier, SVM, BERT architecture deep learning models. Furthermore, our
results show that the BERT performs better than previous models in identifying
information generated by AI from information provided by humans. Provide a
comprehensive analysis of the current state of AI-generated text identification
in our assessment of pertinent studies. Our testing yielded positive findings,
showing that our strategy is successful, with the BERT emerging as the most
probable answer. We analyze the research's societal implications, highlighting
the possible advantages for various industries while addressing sustainability
issues pertaining to morality and the environment. The XGB classifier and SVM
give 0.84 and 0.81 accuracy in this article, respectively. The greatest
accuracy in this research is provided by the BERT model, which provides 0.93%
accuracy.
|
[
-0.16972051560878754,
-0.9357463121414185,
0.5953195691108704,
-0.11501432955265045,
-0.06902579963207245,
0.19845178723335266,
-0.10564559698104858,
-1.020483136177063,
-0.18429236114025116,
0.5789538621902466,
-0.5240113735198975,
-0.451193243265152,
-0.5925605297088623,
0.3545737564563751,
-0.6257055401802063,
0.9079918265342712,
0.1747528314590454,
-0.11285921186208725,
-0.20917561650276184,
0.04896100237965584,
-0.35314393043518066,
-0.5961860418319702,
-0.802614688873291,
-0.4304731488227844,
0.26800957322120667,
-0.02089691162109375,
0.5836483240127563,
0.7710212469100952,
0.5380195379257202,
0.40057075023651123,
-0.05216046795248985,
0.2705702483654022,
-0.1691937893629074,
-0.005315807182341814,
0.052889272570610046,
-0.33233726024627686,
-0.20287638902664185,
0.12104052305221558,
0.5553412437438965,
-0.05463851988315582,
0.1146232932806015,
0.27593687176704407,
0.03340988606214523,
0.5136571526527405,
-0.41497716307640076,
0.07548175007104874,
-0.9608796834945679,
0.21033774316310883,
-0.2063690572977066,
-0.31523144245147705,
-0.6625552773475647,
-0.3169524669647217,
0.07607448101043701,
-0.34458357095718384,
0.3022858500480652,
0.26782849431037903,
1.0455656051635742,
0.3031080663204193,
-0.1643742024898529,
-0.9534342885017395,
-0.7222814559936523,
1.0035204887390137,
-0.9484314322471619,
0.15033307671546936,
0.2980273365974426,
0.05787307024002075,
-0.07389561831951141,
-0.6622564792633057,
-1.0132209062576294,
-0.354832261800766,
-0.05644579604268074,
0.09495562314987183,
-0.15965279936790466,
-0.1472143828868866,
0.13552458584308624,
0.004751511383801699,
-0.569137692451477,
0.3287762403488159,
-0.1634848713874817,
-0.2342904657125473,
0.9133549928665161,
0.07745297253131866,
0.8006224036216736,
-0.5291714072227478,
-0.3505469262599945,
-0.07544450461864471,
-0.4277748465538025,
0.09756555408239365,
0.6299193501472473,
0.23886005580425262,
0.11921132355928421,
0.4913778305053711,
0.23213624954223633,
0.465003103017807,
-0.25089505314826965,
-0.03926340118050575,
0.11602917313575745,
-0.31422707438468933,
-0.25078409910202026,
0.3509138524532318,
0.8818466663360596,
0.39497411251068115,
0.39679303765296936,
0.04354279860854149,
-0.3544521927833557,
0.15780942142009735,
0.5107349753379822,
-0.5773949027061462,
-0.09254193305969238,
0.10359787195920944,
-0.835802435874939,
-0.7035355567932129,
0.16593751311302185,
-0.46748048067092896,
-0.5457506775856018,
-0.4045388698577881,
0.13975733518600464,
-0.3650580644607544,
-0.09106460958719254,
-0.1580907106399536,
-0.3082112967967987,
0.5532149076461792,
0.29012441635131836,
-0.805002748966217,
-0.07803747057914734,
0.8335381746292114,
0.8078668713569641,
-0.13482923805713654,
0.09645506739616394,
-0.2916412651538849,
0.14519819617271423,
-0.33810991048812866,
0.8849352598190308,
-0.32743650674819946,
-0.14108799397945404,
-0.03607258200645447,
-0.2635558843612671,
0.40564456582069397,
-0.4155866503715515,
0.8116989731788635,
-0.49089735746383667,
0.36024391651153564,
-0.09529953449964523,
-0.7453446388244629,
-0.1664639562368393,
0.41024115681648254,
-0.7693712115287781,
1.0117106437683105,
-0.19091832637786865,
-0.8196846842765808,
0.6898528933525085,
-0.7698509693145752,
-0.4588017463684082,
0.404537171125412,
-0.3507246971130371,
-0.977988064289093,
-0.11511693149805069,
0.10878100246191025,
0.5016994476318359,
-0.1616617739200592,
0.4559359550476074,
-0.2364611178636551,
-0.20331846177577972,
0.30868467688560486,
-0.7511916160583496,
1.091382622718811,
0.16478104889392853,
-0.5486862063407898,
0.09380628913640976,
-0.7809977531433105,
0.21713224053382874,
0.19240467250347137,
-0.4560934007167816,
-0.2668581008911133,
0.42193689942359924,
0.3875542879104614,
0.15157924592494965,
0.2759682834148407,
-0.8643110990524292,
-0.15818586945533752,
-0.205474853515625,
0.46390625834465027,
1.1320722103118896,
-0.09977949410676956,
0.15009327232837677,
-0.4913197159767151,
0.26414987444877625,
-0.4671061933040619,
-0.08097401261329651,
-0.186183363199234,
-0.879227340221405,
-0.48190903663635254,
-0.31788164377212524,
0.3298925459384918,
0.7838676571846008,
-0.46484845876693726,
1.0229395627975464,
-0.17899112403392792,
-0.5014881491661072,
-0.5265663266181946,
-0.08441616594791412,
0.3265412747859955,
0.5702874660491943,
0.20652346312999725,
-0.019641131162643433,
-0.5834473371505737,
-0.6616448760032654,
-0.5039867758750916,
-0.47167494893074036,
-0.1959836632013321,
0.4436492919921875,
0.6148052215576172,
-0.3614223599433899,
1.1734634637832642,
-0.3686889708042145,
-0.33551692962646484,
-0.23771297931671143,
0.5828530788421631,
-0.03375796601176262,
0.5728719234466553,
0.6489728093147278,
-1.0825868844985962,
-0.7178581953048706,
0.18850363790988922,
-1.065373420715332,
-0.1695452481508255,
-0.5223367214202881,
0.17105308175086975,
0.5663354396820068,
0.41795310378074646,
-0.35694777965545654,
0.7133482098579407,
0.14046838879585266,
-0.32878339290618896,
0.3655071258544922,
-0.3551405072212219,
0.1344793736934662,
-0.8240618705749512,
0.2725110352039337,
0.20589999854564667,
-0.4570614695549011,
-0.5966971516609192,
-0.06549263745546341,
-0.024466168135404587,
-0.18194465339183807,
-0.11060205101966858,
0.6552679538726807,
-0.20171308517456055,
0.08405639231204987,
-0.4585009217262268,
0.020914770662784576,
-0.010128783993422985,
0.17853401601314545,
0.2560478448867798,
0.5725964307785034,
-0.017006203532218933,
-0.35958582162857056,
0.3136466145515442,
0.37294745445251465,
-0.5457732081413269,
0.3797048330307007,
-0.7067596912384033,
0.2529087960720062,
-0.3340710699558258,
0.13697844743728638,
-0.8860063552856445,
-0.02835756167769432,
0.35069671273231506,
-0.9144462943077087,
0.10838603228330612,
0.24817785620689392,
-0.7049040794372559,
-0.3437421917915344,
-0.25624188780784607,
-0.21710200607776642,
0.6507930755615234,
-0.5103287100791931,
0.7718416452407837,
0.4171138107776642,
-0.5785870552062988,
-0.4507892429828644,
-0.794556200504303,
0.3161315321922302,
-0.14823110401630402,
-0.7221148014068604,
0.3986976146697998,
-0.05190600827336311,
-0.25513768196105957,
-0.014037768356502056,
0.16845116019248962,
-0.19697709381580353,
0.3750668466091156,
0.12896935641765594,
0.2523477375507355,
-0.04446715489029884,
0.08982080221176147,
0.07687661796808243,
-0.14576572179794312,
0.4348936975002289,
0.018025891855359077,
0.46013161540031433,
0.07951550930738449,
-0.15697097778320312,
-0.7726628184318542,
0.6367393136024475,
0.44150567054748535,
-0.26215994358062744,
0.678432285785675,
0.8584155440330505,
-0.632131814956665,
-0.18127287924289703,
-0.2555348575115204,
-0.040538206696510315,
-0.5227463245391846,
0.3036259710788727,
0.15986470878124237,
-0.3811763823032379,
0.28052785992622375,
0.22291690111160278,
0.14653301239013672,
0.4463106393814087,
0.5671566724777222,
-0.44589298963546753,
1.264844536781311,
0.803627073764801,
-0.22128506004810333,
0.6174784302711487,
-0.026039689779281616,
0.5464696884155273,
-0.3694150745868683,
-0.2642779052257538,
-0.7797357439994812,
-0.20632334053516388,
-0.741601288318634,
0.14184562861919403,
0.006455691065639257,
-0.341289758682251,
-0.07690466940402985,
0.15302419662475586,
-0.7916820049285889,
0.3795222043991089,
0.9936049580574036,
0.20955035090446472,
0.2608206570148468,
-0.16313308477401733,
0.1480737030506134,
0.08542419224977493,
-0.27668052911758423,
-1.18282949924469,
1.108065128326416,
0.2183685600757599,
0.26562657952308655,
-0.010551635175943375,
0.6549928188323975,
1.1237807273864746,
0.5528459548950195,
-0.49925199151039124,
0.5198397040367126,
-0.06700195372104645,
-0.7864329814910889,
-0.30183908343315125,
-0.39130455255508423,
-0.957923412322998,
-0.179386705160141,
-0.6165108680725098,
-0.7151041030883789,
-0.27033963799476624,
0.008070442825555801,
-0.139320969581604,
0.4528217315673828,
-0.6198803782463074,
0.6703110337257385,
-0.5173104405403137,
-0.05571509152650833,
-0.1877448558807373,
-0.7530375123023987,
-0.030069882050156593,
-0.29428666830062866,
0.02055857516825199,
-0.14160294830799103,
0.2503887414932251,
0.7750368118286133,
-0.15583740174770355,
0.8138549327850342,
-0.10888116806745529,
-0.2753390967845917,
0.4639137089252472,
-0.43842965364456177,
0.5609704256057739,
0.028228936716914177,
-0.32790306210517883,
0.24891121685504913,
-0.3934681713581085,
-0.26556625962257385,
-0.17907525599002838,
0.31121164560317993,
-0.6786990761756897,
-0.2702653706073761,
-0.5610935091972351,
-0.5691091418266296,
0.3907700777053833,
0.5672016739845276,
0.5347376465797424,
0.09686236083507538,
-0.32133638858795166,
0.08787409216165543,
0.6720183491706848,
-0.5548487305641174,
0.6947152018547058,
0.3028869926929474,
-0.004423176404088736,
-0.22915957868099213,
0.9276878833770752,
0.024456148967146873,
-0.1267080157995224,
0.48164743185043335,
0.26785051822662354,
-0.37355753779411316,
-0.6494336128234863,
-0.6546391248703003,
-0.17353776097297668,
-0.5859820246696472,
-0.23693832755088806,
-0.6331119537353516,
-0.31640714406967163,
-0.4623802602291107,
-0.4473976194858551,
0.07807610183954239,
0.09175360202789307,
-0.6286806464195251,
-0.007868648506700993,
0.1362690031528473,
0.7182332277297974,
0.12713919579982758,
0.14479276537895203,
-0.9479179978370667,
0.5894387364387512,
0.0799308568239212,
0.08651100099086761,
-0.005962190218269825,
-0.12538522481918335,
0.10024552792310715,
0.35256078839302063,
-0.43564486503601074,
-0.6711001396179199,
0.5915497541427612,
0.17636922001838684,
0.5124468207359314,
0.4930335581302643,
0.188995361328125,
0.09292632341384888,
-0.4798966646194458,
0.7379629611968994,
0.12287501245737076,
-1.2059826850891113,
0.6193434596061707,
-0.3559193015098572,
-0.01961590349674225,
0.33910563588142395,
0.3668411672115326,
-0.4280500113964081,
-0.5309402942657471,
-0.6869146823883057,
-0.6462790966033936,
0.5439110398292542,
0.44753387570381165,
0.22041523456573486,
0.045557472854852676,
0.32877910137176514,
0.16614662110805511,
0.24211889505386353,
-0.9983869791030884,
0.024877553805708885,
0.07316584885120392,
-0.49307480454444885,
0.29521268606185913,
0.0629783496260643,
0.35011211037635803,
0.07383379340171814,
0.7578661441802979,
-0.007802334614098072,
0.4572855830192566,
0.0891304463148117,
-0.08870313316583633,
0.07423520088195801,
0.06247518211603165,
0.47597381472587585,
0.3900585472583771,
-0.17906947433948517,
-0.24520494043827057,
-0.12447161972522736,
-0.453921377658844,
0.1826315075159073,
0.017640287056565285,
-0.6447176337242126,
0.10157103836536407,
0.6126871705055237,
0.45847201347351074,
-0.5879837870597839,
-0.8843867778778076,
0.5348032712936401,
-0.17804943025112152,
-0.12983980774879456,
-0.6502774357795715,
0.1943427175283432,
-0.17650282382965088,
0.17244865000247955,
0.5114440321922302,
0.4490172564983368,
0.2604769468307495,
-0.5652751922607422,
0.24038082361221313,
0.6993725299835205,
-0.31098830699920654,
-0.03593729808926582,
0.789362907409668,
0.388947993516922,
-0.7115702629089355,
0.970923900604248,
-0.42479580640792847,
-0.6805227994918823,
1.029123306274414,
0.5537630915641785,
0.8190189599990845,
0.06871334463357925,
0.21501733362674713,
0.061897411942481995,
0.48283475637435913,
0.18133066594600677,
0.3908793330192566,
-0.1975197046995163,
-0.9578568935394287,
-0.2945845127105713,
-0.4546559453010559,
-0.3870450556278229,
0.13628622889518738,
-0.6445542573928833,
0.3670201897621155,
-0.5212240219116211,
-0.2250141054391861,
0.2937997877597809,
0.11715194582939148,
-0.4196387231349945,
0.3861049711704254,
0.5015719532966614,
0.6034221053123474,
-1.017195224761963,
0.7228984236717224,
0.45714643597602844,
-0.22068661451339722,
-0.3287545144557953,
0.16035231947898865,
0.06687285751104355,
-0.7151790857315063,
0.5319544076919556,
0.7618383169174194,
-0.29106324911117554,
0.0993947684764862,
-0.775522768497467,
-0.502638578414917,
0.9586663842201233,
0.1271246373653412,
-0.3274630904197693,
0.11019939929246902,
0.16490063071250916,
0.6377841830253601,
-0.08705171942710876,
-0.00972695741802454,
0.3100338280200958,
0.6561879515647888,
-0.419654905796051,
-0.5104101896286011,
-0.043950311839580536,
-0.546502947807312,
-0.02731567807495594,
0.35734421014785767,
-0.34655117988586426,
0.5330703258514404,
-0.12129468470811844,
-0.44224560260772705,
0.4293839633464813,
0.8093754649162292,
0.26448503136634827,
0.6189523339271545,
0.4264937937259674,
0.47761768102645874,
1.1016417741775513,
-0.009637579321861267,
0.8800315260887146,
-0.07398544996976852,
0.296098917722702,
0.7166587114334106,
-0.5579689741134644,
0.7012126445770264,
0.13142430782318115,
0.059805627912282944,
0.6513745784759521,
0.4423924386501312,
-0.5012539029121399,
0.4081968367099762,
0.23094519972801208,
-0.30242377519607544,
0.00018491481023374945,
-0.27564457058906555,
-0.09191328287124634,
0.6462348699569702,
0.37872031331062317,
-0.6599833369255066,
0.20610329508781433,
0.08524132519960403,
-0.02269446663558483,
0.32910218834877014,
-0.301741361618042,
0.9011123776435852,
-0.24422939121723175,
-0.6588241457939148,
0.01022355630993843,
0.3316951096057892,
0.8677465319633484,
-0.4414101243019104,
-0.20168963074684143,
0.35536590218544006,
0.3157663941383362,
-0.16302280128002167,
-0.8635147213935852,
0.48075070977211,
0.3091263473033905,
-0.3457191288471222,
-0.5542970299720764,
1.1168246269226074,
-0.1937354952096939,
-0.626102089881897,
0.194217711687088,
0.13586553931236267,
-0.05628170445561409,
0.03916986659169197,
-0.7855625152587891,
-0.09668727219104767,
0.17180931568145752,
0.08278097957372665,
0.018285350874066353,
0.316998690366745,
-0.024579716846346855,
0.6566699147224426,
0.8714991211891174,
-0.09343770146369934,
0.09742731600999832,
-0.3389056921005249,
0.40345677733421326,
-0.6686000227928162,
-0.733567476272583,
-1.0225465297698975,
0.31611207127571106,
-0.5199853777885437,
-0.2973737418651581,
0.5735595226287842,
0.4425468146800995,
0.7707670331001282,
-0.03307995945215225,
1.2248280048370361,
-0.2404976636171341,
0.3634204566478729,
-0.5969244837760925,
1.124010443687439,
-0.30102983117103577,
0.12630032002925873,
-0.4524115324020386,
-0.666069746017456,
-0.322600781917572,
0.7902460694313049,
-0.04908836632966995,
0.1213856115937233,
0.31379109621047974,
0.49018022418022156,
0.2168821096420288,
0.2735092341899872,
0.015083255246281624,
-0.2970232367515564,
0.581727147102356,
0.23598937690258026,
0.8261810541152954,
-0.3509010672569275,
0.4649416208267212,
-0.06452494859695435,
-0.15545514225959778,
-0.18046671152114868,
-1.2983417510986328,
-0.8145496845245361,
-0.42266297340393066,
-0.381539911031723,
-0.09689091145992279,
-0.13729968667030334,
0.6529467701911926,
0.6481214761734009,
-0.6958708763122559,
0.10568934679031372,
-0.446064829826355,
0.17714974284172058,
-0.23810280859470367,
-0.28052181005477905,
0.357784628868103,
-0.12729258835315704,
-0.7905565500259399,
0.03192334249615669,
0.24219220876693726,
0.06069900095462799,
-0.2330194115638733,
0.019957231357693672,
-0.3302328288555145,
0.3387995958328247,
0.55940842628479,
0.11149711161851883,
-0.6724986433982849,
-0.504636287689209,
-0.05282057076692581,
-0.2449350357055664,
0.13560029864311218,
0.6322861313819885,
-0.699724555015564,
0.3182249069213867,
0.667227029800415,
0.8719643950462341,
0.0855591893196106,
0.07588009536266327,
0.5608662962913513,
-0.7449608445167542,
-0.22811667621135712,
0.5096961259841919,
0.2585873007774353,
0.44456231594085693,
-0.7924633026123047,
0.4075274169445038,
0.06973051279783249,
-0.8532657623291016,
-0.6874775290489197,
0.22063656151294708,
-0.7245691418647766,
-0.4118077754974365,
0.6875362396240234,
-0.19507990777492523,
-0.26794716715812683,
-0.3021218180656433,
-0.2847077250480652,
0.3854697644710541,
-0.4371925890445709,
1.0786240100860596,
0.5600746273994446,
-0.12471455335617065,
0.057813726365566254,
-0.2941175699234009,
0.2091481238603592,
0.2187843769788742,
-1.204538106918335,
-0.08034271746873856,
0.4489579498767853,
-0.10112028568983078,
0.47446703910827637,
0.5388030409812927,
0.08371139317750931,
0.29184219241142273,
-0.1442617028951645,
0.25745925307273865,
0.16661465167999268,
-0.2942841947078705,
-0.01607901230454445,
0.064368836581707,
-0.19124054908752441,
-0.060760099440813065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09911v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09911v2
|
ChatShop: Interactive Information Seeking with Language Agents
| 2024-04-15T16:35:41 | 2024-06-16T15:24:12 |
Sanxing Chen, Sam Wiseman, Bhuwan Dhingra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The desire and ability to seek new information strategically are fundamental
to human learning but often overlooked in current language agent evaluation. We
analyze a popular web shopping task designed to test language agents' ability
to perform strategic exploration and discover that it can be reformulated and
solved as a single-turn retrieval task without the need for interactive
information seeking. This finding encourages us to rethink realistic
constraints on information access that would necessitate strategic information
seeking. We then redesign the task to introduce a notion of task ambiguity and
the role of a shopper, serving as a dynamic party with whom the agent
strategically interacts in an open-ended conversation to make informed
decisions. Our experiments demonstrate that the proposed task can effectively
evaluate the agent's ability to explore and gradually accumulate information
through multi-turn interactions. Additionally, we show that large language
model-simulated shoppers serve as a good proxy for real human shoppers,
revealing similar error patterns in agents.
|
[
-0.18597063422203064,
-0.744182288646698,
0.5113486051559448,
0.1380273699760437,
0.06178951635956764,
0.5384967923164368,
-0.47535938024520874,
-0.7901560664176941,
0.18907634913921356,
0.2609321177005768,
-0.8289644718170166,
-0.28727495670318604,
-0.48458629846572876,
-0.2166808843612671,
-0.23109649121761322,
0.5093358159065247,
0.08812899887561798,
-0.30240651965141296,
0.024976573884487152,
0.20544174313545227,
-0.3224698305130005,
-0.3656599521636963,
-1.1303390264511108,
-0.1354159712791443,
0.639361560344696,
0.7009135484695435,
1.3314868211746216,
-0.03517795726656914,
0.3807188868522644,
0.454938143491745,
0.20271240174770355,
0.2506008744239807,
-0.5946776270866394,
0.5511743426322937,
-0.4213179349899292,
-0.8159450888633728,
-0.2575361728668213,
0.17282262444496155,
0.2243272066116333,
0.47354620695114136,
-0.44671759009361267,
0.06034491956233978,
-0.17509129643440247,
0.6142732501029968,
-0.8254604339599609,
0.4660494327545166,
-0.5033913850784302,
0.035189781337976456,
-0.15856844186782837,
-0.32241931557655334,
-0.660576343536377,
-0.04901449382305145,
0.46125105023384094,
-1.0229567289352417,
0.13454629480838776,
0.07296999543905258,
1.039444923400879,
0.010720686055719852,
-0.5734663605690002,
-0.6273288726806641,
-1.1406902074813843,
0.6618705987930298,
-0.14027701318264008,
0.6836362481117249,
0.5883305668830872,
0.4646506905555725,
-0.32182714343070984,
-0.768849790096283,
-0.6492928266525269,
-0.12441874295473099,
-0.10208765417337418,
0.17417581379413605,
-0.7292194962501526,
-0.08765849471092224,
0.09782076627016068,
-0.051233138889074326,
-0.33510535955429077,
-0.422936350107193,
-0.16522014141082764,
0.24733878672122955,
0.6621401309967041,
0.030101334676146507,
0.6309173107147217,
-0.010132228955626488,
-0.43291816115379333,
-0.47400230169296265,
-0.08330533653497696,
0.45431452989578247,
0.5426037311553955,
0.30704909563064575,
0.2632567286491394,
0.505379855632782,
-0.28413301706314087,
0.43291833996772766,
-0.056375689804553986,
0.01793053187429905,
0.14300154149532318,
-0.2993237376213074,
0.103117436170578,
-0.17650721967220306,
0.5063066482543945,
0.4181511700153351,
0.484033465385437,
-0.21364726126194,
-0.169712632894516,
-0.4058621823787689,
0.7852538824081421,
-0.33500683307647705,
-0.03529149666428566,
0.4531998038291931,
-0.38074204325675964,
-0.11568277329206467,
0.3370523154735565,
-0.9434603452682495,
-0.13666415214538574,
-0.03244918957352638,
0.3474386930465698,
-0.38283178210258484,
-0.3150990605354309,
0.25207510590553284,
-0.6043539643287659,
0.32108789682388306,
0.34515103697776794,
-0.7403415441513062,
0.5256233811378479,
0.4429541826248169,
0.6576809883117676,
-0.26016342639923096,
-0.4793308675289154,
-0.32282841205596924,
0.3785591423511505,
-0.364777535200119,
0.9270251989364624,
-0.8522221446037292,
-0.31400787830352783,
0.17986837029457092,
0.0731460377573967,
-0.07617306709289551,
-0.4283541738986969,
0.4869144856929779,
-0.853096604347229,
0.13275747001171112,
-0.3508942127227783,
0.007641314994543791,
-0.15040917694568634,
0.5780993700027466,
-0.6427839994430542,
0.7355827689170837,
0.07805244624614716,
-0.3464007079601288,
0.5504072904586792,
-0.7410106658935547,
-0.27035942673683167,
0.41012147068977356,
-0.12804074585437775,
-0.005545290652662516,
0.07235762476921082,
0.11406853795051575,
-0.03067929856479168,
-0.029214639216661453,
-0.275961697101593,
-0.025942247360944748,
-0.3826253414154053,
0.7883557081222534,
-0.41595128178596497,
0.41517698764801025,
0.06395406275987625,
-0.564495861530304,
-0.06261415779590607,
-0.4303604066371918,
0.09824670851230621,
0.5577645897865295,
-0.5567814707756042,
-0.4585532248020172,
0.5016934871673584,
0.053831882774829865,
0.0481715053319931,
0.4999963641166687,
-0.3772863447666168,
0.5598154664039612,
-0.28621336817741394,
-0.06227017566561699,
0.6831492185592651,
-0.09035314619541168,
0.40085792541503906,
-0.4376308023929596,
0.9414937496185303,
-0.3471542000770569,
0.5601704120635986,
-0.006645234767347574,
-0.49727606773376465,
-0.9736519455909729,
0.06441576033830643,
-0.055090125650167465,
0.5525306463241577,
-0.9618018865585327,
-0.24018393456935883,
-0.010465211234986782,
-0.44855162501335144,
-0.36739474534988403,
-0.16472403705120087,
-0.011046023108065128,
-0.46438169479370117,
0.23040443658828735,
-0.3008187413215637,
-0.33541396260261536,
-0.6274824738502502,
-0.48177647590637207,
-0.17625245451927185,
-0.16884633898735046,
0.45655766129493713,
-0.19509713351726532,
-0.4349675476551056,
0.8269568085670471,
-0.6593354344367981,
-0.40527620911598206,
-0.6562587022781372,
0.2457951158285141,
0.20814667642116547,
0.15876516699790955,
0.16931723058223724,
-0.9230482578277588,
-0.4665013551712036,
0.04598778858780861,
-0.1679050326347351,
0.11520499736070633,
-0.1965050995349884,
-0.3129846155643463,
0.16576914489269257,
0.3391301929950714,
-1.045823335647583,
0.6563326716423035,
0.16108225286006927,
-0.3588141202926636,
0.14209134876728058,
-0.42998239398002625,
0.2988356649875641,
-0.5369570851325989,
-0.11956541985273361,
-0.2887054979801178,
0.04711760953068733,
-0.7866619229316711,
0.18937453627586365,
-0.05246585234999657,
-0.2386050671339035,
-0.2292669117450714,
0.597114086151123,
-0.7719621062278748,
0.007541085127741098,
-0.5524935126304626,
0.5671468377113342,
0.06426583975553513,
0.44247809052467346,
0.080725759267807,
0.6158657073974609,
0.3015809953212738,
-0.5857251286506653,
0.1924557238817215,
0.3025038540363312,
-0.28766968846321106,
0.4998199939727783,
-0.36115318536758423,
0.28499171137809753,
-0.27652251720428467,
0.007907153107225895,
-1.1374393701553345,
-0.16745725274085999,
0.2851041853427887,
-0.3933769762516022,
0.2758743166923523,
-0.20710377395153046,
-0.4055551290512085,
-0.43088001012802124,
-0.07608023285865784,
0.4312857985496521,
0.3901381194591522,
-0.49291616678237915,
0.5143304467201233,
0.5763535499572754,
-0.29328685998916626,
-0.60761958360672,
-0.3878462016582489,
0.14433859288692474,
0.06935075670480728,
-0.5475141406059265,
0.11957157403230667,
0.05200495570898056,
-0.3530479669570923,
-0.3501223623752594,
-0.2651561498641968,
-0.02159658446907997,
0.027916481718420982,
-0.08079317212104797,
0.15409424901008606,
0.07908795773983002,
0.3460352420806885,
-0.4840734601020813,
-0.23320984840393066,
0.2574981153011322,
-0.1683432161808014,
0.9465734958648682,
-0.09577073901891708,
-0.7833085060119629,
-0.0235255416482687,
0.49103617668151855,
0.29693907499313354,
-0.2719862759113312,
0.30870911478996277,
0.30377283692359924,
-0.22905291616916656,
-0.11908867210149765,
-0.6591770052909851,
-0.14488065242767334,
-0.6155698895454407,
0.4101622402667999,
-0.28724002838134766,
-0.29825904965400696,
0.23519988358020782,
-0.11867471784353256,
0.060938648879528046,
0.16884365677833557,
0.07724100351333618,
-0.278150349855423,
1.451968789100647,
0.6666039824485779,
0.646287739276886,
0.5001320242881775,
-0.0435076579451561,
0.628754734992981,
-0.3145659863948822,
-0.720350444316864,
-0.601017415523529,
-0.6965182423591614,
-0.5448847413063049,
-0.4725150465965271,
0.31238695979118347,
0.011950836516916752,
0.03374981880187988,
0.25441640615463257,
-0.41437187790870667,
0.5442142486572266,
0.8653172254562378,
0.22139988839626312,
0.3824807405471802,
-0.18338479101657867,
0.04678153619170189,
-0.07005578279495239,
-0.5892847180366516,
-0.46699580550193787,
0.7225594520568848,
0.10386162996292114,
0.8553217053413391,
0.4699206054210663,
0.2400577962398529,
0.017758743837475777,
-0.26249322295188904,
-1.1561800241470337,
0.6109693050384521,
0.19751110672950745,
-0.5094758868217468,
-0.34416627883911133,
-0.03460714593529701,
-1.7574975490570068,
0.10704522579908371,
-0.12847024202346802,
-0.9559779167175293,
0.45277610421180725,
-0.09904409945011139,
-0.033341966569423676,
0.1415146291255951,
-0.6868258118629456,
0.9942463636398315,
-0.8480446338653564,
-0.4727783501148224,
-0.43664777278900146,
-0.4048786759376526,
-0.1626778393983841,
0.2395295351743698,
0.4483828544616699,
-0.17492862045764923,
-0.4156198799610138,
0.5262765288352966,
-0.0773945078253746,
0.652344822883606,
-0.06987405568361282,
0.3198375701904297,
0.14433394372463226,
0.5698846578598022,
0.741759717464447,
-0.36827948689460754,
0.2618691921234131,
-0.22857818007469177,
0.17508819699287415,
-0.6549345850944519,
-0.8628592491149902,
0.09460663050413132,
-0.4853242337703705,
-1.0106916427612305,
-0.6074084639549255,
-0.5022721886634827,
-0.3892272412776947,
0.2628006935119629,
-0.18270735442638397,
-0.07841791957616806,
-0.4064093828201294,
0.10554153472185135,
0.25857871770858765,
-0.10670710355043411,
0.39391669631004333,
0.8466391563415527,
-0.29000163078308105,
0.34410443902015686,
0.7189500331878662,
-0.1476423591375351,
0.3243609070777893,
0.4542523920536041,
0.3611801564693451,
-0.23887674510478973,
-0.2916997969150543,
-0.23167677223682404,
-0.018082156777381897,
-0.7101459503173828,
0.18750427663326263,
-0.5648912787437439,
-0.007528497837483883,
-0.08153562992811203,
-0.10518047213554382,
-0.4420902132987976,
-0.08321782201528549,
-0.020627999678254128,
0.0912943184375763,
0.21093688905239105,
0.9357136487960815,
0.021947022527456284,
0.5004081726074219,
-0.625022292137146,
-0.11339360475540161,
0.4900820255279541,
0.15692070126533508,
0.15243150293827057,
0.0538836345076561,
-0.16441316902637482,
0.160627543926239,
-0.44149520993232727,
-1.0926686525344849,
0.43569624423980713,
-0.16718702018260956,
0.8847172856330872,
0.7739942669868469,
0.2883300483226776,
0.5747201442718506,
-0.268781453371048,
0.611635148525238,
-0.13837270438671112,
-0.7310194969177246,
0.5297566652297974,
-0.22523881494998932,
0.5230289697647095,
0.43762609362602234,
0.8899205327033997,
-0.8355849385261536,
-0.30360478162765503,
-0.8139514923095703,
-1.136642575263977,
0.901811420917511,
0.27133458852767944,
0.1742231696844101,
-0.3743864893913269,
-0.222421333193779,
-0.06821226328611374,
0.44887739419937134,
-0.6321091651916504,
0.05738544836640358,
0.19796743988990784,
0.33538272976875305,
0.12092510610818863,
-0.29032933712005615,
0.015630517154932022,
0.13137076795101166,
0.6107147932052612,
-0.039535075426101685,
0.24735261499881744,
0.14420196413993835,
0.18540413677692413,
-0.3311091661453247,
0.5249214172363281,
0.04507407546043396,
0.7230631709098816,
-0.16415521502494812,
0.13835829496383667,
-0.18678338825702667,
-0.4223182499408722,
-0.09763923287391663,
0.04264739155769348,
0.02106822282075882,
-0.036317940801382065,
-0.023145180195569992,
0.5963467359542847,
0.565878689289093,
-1.3843307495117188,
0.7665107846260071,
-0.21051378548145294,
0.21365827322006226,
-0.6209889650344849,
0.20055849850177765,
-0.0026500055100768805,
0.5969238877296448,
0.5817076563835144,
0.0676802545785904,
0.31818827986717224,
-1.2018269300460815,
0.20926304161548615,
0.8428999781608582,
-0.495021790266037,
-0.026393605396151543,
0.34416431188583374,
-0.07765909284353256,
-0.9991498589515686,
0.8231632113456726,
-0.4097653031349182,
-0.5746025443077087,
0.4077727794647217,
0.35588017106056213,
0.7996461987495422,
-0.45978185534477234,
0.6195517182350159,
0.08676636219024658,
0.5646257400512695,
0.029658125713467598,
0.3886348009109497,
-0.2762015759944916,
-0.7856715321540833,
-0.035924214869737625,
-0.14094288647174835,
-0.8064509630203247,
-0.12933839857578278,
-0.5766305327415466,
0.46589699387550354,
0.1657474935054779,
-0.24072736501693726,
-0.2889324128627777,
-0.03746245801448822,
-0.7959710359573364,
-0.13443952798843384,
-0.2513360381126404,
0.6950412392616272,
-0.07514320313930511,
0.5952600836753845,
0.47030264139175415,
-0.3590695261955261,
-0.544701874256134,
0.3830099105834961,
-0.09482353180646896,
-0.9717975854873657,
0.4780489504337311,
0.07386600971221924,
-0.17212678492069244,
-0.5170872807502747,
-0.3745010197162628,
-1.167731523513794,
0.8585211038589478,
-0.0877511128783226,
-0.4611082673072815,
-0.4406066834926605,
0.33670011162757874,
0.5523642897605896,
-0.08018645644187927,
0.7225680351257324,
0.6237310171127319,
0.5481877326965332,
0.5644103288650513,
-0.7004688382148743,
-0.05325008183717728,
-0.3795487582683563,
-0.5049806833267212,
0.31464651226997375,
-0.8285483717918396,
0.8917816281318665,
-0.2507898211479187,
-0.5918633937835693,
-0.041828133165836334,
0.03891121596097946,
0.01193144079297781,
0.4426730275154114,
0.8497597575187683,
0.02724543586373329,
0.8705649375915527,
-0.08029564470052719,
0.9837583303451538,
0.05038847401738167,
0.0790114775300026,
1.1084518432617188,
-0.20432959496974945,
1.1763648986816406,
0.34322938323020935,
-0.06807469576597214,
0.4583086371421814,
0.3691999912261963,
0.18305407464504242,
0.2680996358394623,
0.21386654675006866,
-0.20966418087482452,
-0.45272552967071533,
-0.017770957201719284,
0.27668842673301697,
0.8801324367523193,
0.4424780011177063,
0.08716809004545212,
-0.28520631790161133,
-0.07891145348548889,
-0.14454500377178192,
0.025579670444130898,
0.05866771563887596,
0.8232913613319397,
-0.376449316740036,
-0.8053742051124573,
0.16501282155513763,
-0.04427582398056984,
0.2359127402305603,
-0.9101292490959167,
0.04365383833646774,
0.03612440079450607,
0.20639488101005554,
0.08563952893018723,
-0.7829617857933044,
0.2086203396320343,
-0.3724626302719116,
0.24679698050022125,
-0.28769293427467346,
0.8003640174865723,
-0.4227074086666107,
-0.2383771687746048,
0.6079344153404236,
0.7125681638717651,
0.18997833132743835,
-0.31876224279403687,
-0.748551070690155,
0.025806166231632233,
-0.0017817625775933266,
-0.48463040590286255,
0.30511707067489624,
0.4598490297794342,
0.08306951820850372,
0.8200579881668091,
0.6763333082199097,
-0.22835582494735718,
-0.07047373056411743,
-0.13447658717632294,
0.5383067727088928,
-0.7254053950309753,
-0.4228518009185791,
-0.4479101896286011,
0.2533906102180481,
-0.3125842213630676,
-0.1112859770655632,
0.5991595983505249,
0.7286168932914734,
1.0415834188461304,
0.06337032467126846,
0.5969058275222778,
0.13180814683437347,
0.4219152629375458,
-0.2892129123210907,
0.5237513184547424,
-0.6791664958000183,
0.3197636306285858,
-0.2687951922416687,
-0.7151225209236145,
0.32215067744255066,
0.6719465851783752,
-0.2387026846408844,
0.032298844307661057,
0.8095136880874634,
0.40877631306648254,
-0.28327542543411255,
0.36919888854026794,
0.3424603044986725,
0.23723851144313812,
0.22188660502433777,
0.5863295197486877,
1.1709318161010742,
-0.20245155692100525,
0.9939155578613281,
-0.47380366921424866,
-0.40033984184265137,
-0.1763356775045395,
-0.6110707521438599,
-0.8727928400039673,
-0.7386818528175354,
-0.07958658784627914,
-0.24564577639102936,
-0.02824220061302185,
1.1472729444503784,
0.5789322853088379,
-0.34736573696136475,
-0.7207797169685364,
0.15415526926517487,
0.24534942209720612,
-0.4269954562187195,
-0.2975233495235443,
-0.06509651243686676,
-0.7301488518714905,
-1.200503945350647,
0.6838295459747314,
0.43302246928215027,
0.13548974692821503,
-0.1565331667661667,
0.20744934678077698,
-0.5190560221672058,
0.4672548174858093,
0.45295092463493347,
0.30678537487983704,
-0.5589292049407959,
-0.23947148025035858,
0.4052073657512665,
0.07865852862596512,
0.19650959968566895,
1.0983701944351196,
-0.6584056615829468,
0.7937939167022705,
0.24053148925304413,
0.6665273904800415,
0.916388750076294,
-0.15820163488388062,
0.748192548751831,
-0.4272553026676178,
0.2506270110607147,
0.23737427592277527,
0.09964406490325928,
-0.04124809429049492,
-0.44409555196762085,
0.3982769846916199,
-0.09054010361433029,
-0.4638247787952423,
-0.2275368571281433,
0.35938820242881775,
-1.040050983428955,
-0.5507392287254333,
1.024599552154541,
0.18825984001159668,
-0.22035953402519226,
-0.361733615398407,
-0.5914050340652466,
-0.0053366743959486485,
-0.5850517749786377,
0.944628894329071,
0.8185886144638062,
-0.14326786994934082,
-0.29877254366874695,
-0.5517097115516663,
0.4812556803226471,
0.2735380530357361,
-0.6549283862113953,
0.010419810190796852,
0.22087709605693817,
-0.17735464870929718,
0.3687897026538849,
0.7093531489372253,
0.36791834235191345,
0.25695323944091797,
-0.02849411778151989,
-0.08478908985853195,
0.5261616706848145,
-0.40716150403022766,
0.4760180711746216,
0.31680524349212646,
0.24821922183036804,
-0.20953403413295746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09897v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09897v1
|
Progressive Knowledge Graph Completion
| 2024-04-15T16:16:59 | 2024-04-15T16:16:59 |
Jiayi Li, Ruilin Luo, Jiaqi Sun, Jing Xiao, Yujiu Yang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Knowledge Graph Completion (KGC) has emerged as a promising solution to
address the issue of incompleteness within Knowledge Graphs (KGs). Traditional
KGC research primarily centers on triple classification and link prediction.
Nevertheless, we contend that these tasks do not align well with real-world
scenarios and merely serve as surrogate benchmarks. In this paper, we
investigate three crucial processes relevant to real-world construction
scenarios: (a) the verification process, which arises from the necessity and
limitations of human verifiers; (b) the mining process, which identifies the
most promising candidates for verification; and (c) the training process, which
harnesses verified data for subsequent utilization; in order to achieve a
transition toward more realistic challenges. By integrating these three
processes, we introduce the Progressive Knowledge Graph Completion (PKGC) task,
which simulates the gradual completion of KGs in real-world scenarios.
Furthermore, to expedite PKGC processing, we propose two acceleration modules:
Optimized Top-$k$ algorithm and Semantic Validity Filter. These modules
significantly enhance the efficiency of the mining procedure. Our experiments
demonstrate that performance in link prediction does not accurately reflect
performance in PKGC. A more in-depth analysis reveals the key factors
influencing the results and provides potential directions for future research.
|
[
-0.6632700562477112,
-0.7645249366760254,
0.722796618938446,
-0.19693706929683685,
-0.0014885510317981243,
0.4871317744255066,
0.040747176855802536,
-0.4894120991230011,
-0.32219669222831726,
0.2698047161102295,
-0.6410585641860962,
-0.6172316670417786,
-0.639828622341156,
0.11609172075986862,
-0.1967208832502365,
0.64553302526474,
-0.6429123878479004,
-0.5249388813972473,
-0.4870821535587311,
0.059489864856004715,
-0.6696531772613525,
-0.02853582240641117,
-0.4479696750640869,
-0.8391937017440796,
0.45828214287757874,
0.3537289798259735,
0.8612148761749268,
0.8445196151733398,
0.1598772555589676,
0.2597784996032715,
-0.17181918025016785,
0.3012050986289978,
-0.4642459750175476,
0.05293376371264458,
0.23902994394302368,
-0.3790105879306793,
-0.4230937957763672,
0.17083467543125153,
0.6083654761314392,
0.9166207313537598,
-0.003165401751175523,
0.09991724789142609,
0.03789740055799484,
0.9100558161735535,
-0.7635011076927185,
0.39281585812568665,
-0.19003702700138092,
0.29274269938468933,
0.011384510435163975,
0.23824015259742737,
-0.146768257021904,
-0.5939470529556274,
0.2019100934267044,
-0.5534346103668213,
0.1797446459531784,
0.12229973077774048,
0.8192733526229858,
-0.05812320485711098,
-0.6837199926376343,
-0.3655961751937866,
-0.4682770371437073,
0.18988974392414093,
-0.3644716739654541,
0.7778502106666565,
0.8210829496383667,
0.4887954890727997,
-0.4262048304080963,
-1.2036575078964233,
-0.5946412682533264,
-0.5542711019515991,
-0.2366337776184082,
0.2345094531774521,
0.5006318688392639,
0.3023335039615631,
0.5675368309020996,
0.3451097309589386,
-0.3419962227344513,
-0.16993525624275208,
-0.4734812378883362,
-0.5384389162063599,
0.1762179583311081,
0.20424628257751465,
-0.05048532411456108,
-0.2155582755804062,
-0.10522928833961487,
-0.1108323335647583,
-0.8701909780502319,
0.33386775851249695,
0.6819548010826111,
0.060433968901634216,
-0.003943538758903742,
0.5667883157730103,
-0.8657765984535217,
0.7973613739013672,
-0.3151778280735016,
-0.18862825632095337,
0.4426606297492981,
-0.3950790762901306,
-0.0722838044166565,
-0.03576933592557907,
0.34289678931236267,
0.032814934849739075,
0.24984803795814514,
-0.5973961353302002,
0.1686442494392395,
0.20263169705867767,
0.6402563452720642,
-0.4075787365436554,
-0.5522372126579285,
0.3114848732948303,
-0.3395707905292511,
-0.24662543833255768,
-0.07447846233844757,
-0.18537932634353638,
-0.129768505692482,
-0.4627799093723297,
0.3039640784263611,
-0.4025541841983795,
-0.44546887278556824,
-0.10414314270019531,
-0.2992570102214813,
0.07611852139234543,
0.2706977427005768,
-0.19390113651752472,
-0.1313166469335556,
0.7527198791503906,
0.8429110050201416,
0.19841411709785461,
-0.3783690631389618,
-0.23672187328338623,
0.25008702278137207,
-0.49200040102005005,
0.5792785286903381,
-0.544111430644989,
-0.4709952473640442,
0.0007220229599624872,
0.020736726000905037,
0.10272952169179916,
-0.375731498003006,
0.8194678425788879,
-0.8808816075325012,
-0.13690458238124847,
-0.5238483548164368,
-0.5244808793067932,
-0.09898421168327332,
0.8626911640167236,
-0.45740842819213867,
1.101805567741394,
0.4047570526599884,
-1.0144367218017578,
0.6194856762886047,
-0.262406587600708,
-0.49883273243904114,
0.14547871053218842,
0.08719182014465332,
-0.46837928891181946,
-0.141029953956604,
-0.19790171086788177,
0.4861181080341339,
-0.01056207250803709,
0.047811251133680344,
-0.3639054298400879,
-0.347551167011261,
-0.09638775885105133,
0.18615031242370605,
0.2590298354625702,
0.3070213198661804,
-0.18443210422992706,
-0.28682002425193787,
-0.8171735405921936,
0.3004239499568939,
-0.2968641221523285,
-0.5677517652511597,
0.016177047044038773,
0.2226768583059311,
-0.836428165435791,
0.2881629765033722,
0.14096024632453918,
-0.5244038701057434,
0.24629607796669006,
-0.3939216434955597,
0.16676154732704163,
0.719430685043335,
0.0260931383818388,
0.20230427384376526,
-0.2277696281671524,
0.46631208062171936,
-0.18781374394893646,
0.25055280327796936,
0.12394079566001892,
-0.7439104914665222,
-0.5711133480072021,
0.04961914196610451,
0.6676892638206482,
0.5087892413139343,
-1.0410431623458862,
0.14965295791625977,
-0.4488818943500519,
-0.7891032099723816,
-0.08583420515060425,
-0.06583581119775772,
0.44681060314178467,
0.8524818420410156,
0.055035002529621124,
-0.36820438504219055,
-0.4838443696498871,
-0.4949148893356323,
-0.1777411699295044,
-0.603949785232544,
-0.24203139543533325,
0.43827009201049805,
0.33943405747413635,
-0.07365322858095169,
0.9472066164016724,
-0.702260434627533,
-0.07079219818115234,
0.08112449944019318,
0.31655335426330566,
0.46419551968574524,
0.2953127920627594,
-0.07687892764806747,
-1.1918293237686157,
-0.6991322040557861,
0.16282452642917633,
-0.8690258860588074,
0.1683540940284729,
0.3055872321128845,
-0.07036568224430084,
-0.4363612234592438,
0.5906360149383545,
-0.44477978348731995,
0.5412796139717102,
0.28372102975845337,
-0.19495698809623718,
0.7215370535850525,
-0.1420891135931015,
0.4541722536087036,
-0.47723355889320374,
0.0819234699010849,
-0.3322785794734955,
-0.2965051233768463,
-0.5608312487602234,
0.1184660866856575,
0.11913345754146576,
-0.003344745608046651,
-0.1735078990459442,
0.09202064573764801,
-0.40625640749931335,
0.15480664372444153,
-0.2511516809463501,
0.25497594475746155,
-0.2414584904909134,
0.4898468852043152,
-0.29956987500190735,
0.32072028517723083,
0.5304144024848938,
-0.9565471410751343,
0.61788010597229,
0.11865096539258957,
-0.5322800874710083,
0.4724101424217224,
-0.319511741399765,
0.15425872802734375,
-0.36865460872650146,
0.3413691818714142,
-1.1205103397369385,
-0.4460028111934662,
0.5063013434410095,
-0.701168954372406,
0.2558527886867523,
-0.383699893951416,
-0.6747226119041443,
-0.8898549675941467,
-0.21886084973812103,
0.26296982169151306,
0.766502857208252,
-0.2781510353088379,
0.8073753714561462,
0.04812871292233467,
0.23958644270896912,
-0.5980865359306335,
-0.40243518352508545,
0.029884638264775276,
0.09222152829170227,
-0.6262090802192688,
0.43918678164482117,
0.1754981428384781,
0.24513596296310425,
0.24944967031478882,
-0.3590705990791321,
0.1153363436460495,
0.2835230827331543,
0.5776873230934143,
0.018334513530135155,
0.3049090504646301,
-0.0562121756374836,
-0.23229752480983734,
-0.3008675277233124,
-0.01943369023501873,
-0.40881508588790894,
0.25708743929862976,
0.2843260169029236,
-0.3538186848163605,
-0.3179394006729126,
-0.24504399299621582,
0.3594920039176941,
0.18933379650115967,
0.6803075075149536,
0.6869620680809021,
-0.41352248191833496,
0.1259344220161438,
-0.7108250856399536,
0.1942945122718811,
-0.4295930862426758,
0.35348522663116455,
-0.604337751865387,
-1.0058844089508057,
0.5593960881233215,
-0.8302780389785767,
0.07182583957910538,
0.3425320088863373,
0.28806784749031067,
-0.17729315161705017,
1.0892760753631592,
0.43312007188796997,
0.17173214256763458,
0.18164581060409546,
-0.34551191329956055,
0.45861855149269104,
-0.9958913922309875,
-0.7235747575759888,
-0.5908294320106506,
-0.2274133265018463,
-0.7540839910507202,
-0.1799089014530182,
0.6181869506835938,
0.5692592263221741,
-0.1682628095149994,
0.7877058386802673,
-0.37748926877975464,
0.30006492137908936,
0.3365321159362793,
0.19194422662258148,
0.31377309560775757,
0.08720024675130844,
-0.619672417640686,
0.24340477585792542,
-0.7924754619598389,
-0.20549075305461884,
1.0807108879089355,
0.20625579357147217,
0.14833202958106995,
-0.21907922625541687,
0.45843973755836487,
0.47504502534866333,
0.5389813780784607,
-0.45229583978652954,
0.6062160730361938,
0.085894875228405,
-0.538514256477356,
-0.14056143164634705,
-0.7124372720718384,
-0.7895705699920654,
-0.13296040892601013,
-0.2843298316001892,
-0.6399789452552795,
-0.08626061677932739,
0.24172796308994293,
-0.041336916387081146,
0.25519728660583496,
-0.5743496417999268,
0.7641956806182861,
0.3520052433013916,
-0.3167828619480133,
-0.42591893672943115,
-0.7573076486587524,
0.2380952388048172,
0.06857967376708984,
0.5180163979530334,
-0.19057635962963104,
0.19535954296588898,
0.31199589371681213,
-0.578136682510376,
0.5839052796363831,
-0.4577201008796692,
0.06857026368379593,
0.5893188118934631,
-0.03246773034334183,
1.103101372718811,
-0.04524862393736839,
-0.058695610612630844,
-0.08820188790559769,
-0.37774065136909485,
-0.4277957081794739,
-0.5121649503707886,
0.5176066756248474,
-0.6759971380233765,
-0.4129118025302887,
0.06728138029575348,
-0.11439559608697891,
-0.62761390209198,
0.11564510315656662,
0.2532212734222412,
0.1662900596857071,
0.07391933351755142,
-0.04757639765739441,
0.3786337375640869,
0.09438937157392502,
0.053157683461904526,
-0.07514575868844986,
0.248491570353508,
-0.6987137198448181,
0.8628410696983337,
0.3710809350013733,
0.24462099373340607,
0.21221144497394562,
0.08407220989465714,
-0.3838566243648529,
-0.9434842467308044,
-0.35927146673202515,
0.10405102372169495,
-0.8186859488487244,
-0.2103753387928009,
-0.8121999502182007,
-0.2693590521812439,
-0.4484158456325531,
-0.18982797861099243,
-0.22815413773059845,
-0.15332552790641785,
0.19479921460151672,
-0.12987098097801208,
0.007531915791332722,
0.716400146484375,
-0.07089637219905853,
0.27187663316726685,
-0.8966641426086426,
0.3571760356426239,
0.5680159330368042,
0.7791249752044678,
0.2568677067756653,
0.017020178958773613,
-0.6053573489189148,
0.12991593778133392,
-0.24866972863674164,
-0.42709723114967346,
-0.3227088451385498,
-0.09952156245708466,
0.7412057518959045,
0.13547344505786896,
0.10426526516675949,
0.703555703163147,
-0.3239666819572449,
0.7290051579475403,
0.19693462550640106,
-0.42333629727363586,
0.5428533554077148,
-0.24887505173683167,
0.13280341029167175,
0.7854328155517578,
0.8081310987472534,
-0.49189189076423645,
-0.2620882987976074,
-0.7360160946846008,
-1.0472052097320557,
0.500792920589447,
0.5591445565223694,
-0.2643202841281891,
0.023860692977905273,
0.8091212511062622,
-0.18896912038326263,
0.25044405460357666,
-0.47176921367645264,
-0.10118386149406433,
-0.2145569920539856,
0.08737611770629883,
0.46337124705314636,
-0.3455488681793213,
-0.04695839807391167,
0.08840281516313553,
0.9773273468017578,
-0.06168501451611519,
0.0007716122781857848,
0.28776678442955017,
-0.00974070280790329,
0.06310588866472244,
-0.140555277466774,
-0.0876941978931427,
0.8066564798355103,
-0.23580880463123322,
-0.057586319744586945,
0.3925054967403412,
-0.5868453979492188,
0.2528441548347473,
-0.10973583161830902,
-0.1471741944551468,
-0.33094561100006104,
0.643324613571167,
0.5793135762214661,
-0.1031050905585289,
-0.3351646065711975,
0.333124577999115,
0.19547447562217712,
-0.1442091464996338,
-0.20129063725471497,
0.19238877296447754,
0.034930381923913956,
0.30045148730278015,
0.29036080837249756,
0.010200943797826767,
0.07145702093839645,
-0.411523699760437,
0.05492708832025528,
0.17018158733844757,
-0.4326057732105255,
-0.2528207302093506,
0.44061988592147827,
0.028670039027929306,
-0.08358962088823318,
1.0543395280838013,
-0.6029629707336426,
-0.7693915963172913,
0.6825748085975647,
-0.01943480223417282,
0.6820591688156128,
0.14693641662597656,
0.1399223953485489,
0.694608211517334,
0.09082785993814468,
-0.4009167551994324,
0.01567573845386505,
-0.6064146757125854,
-0.6593196988105774,
-0.8211512565612793,
-0.7095975875854492,
-0.22571341693401337,
-0.5253445506095886,
-0.20607857406139374,
0.27621936798095703,
-0.27923962473869324,
-0.36802300810813904,
-0.47733861207962036,
0.22025078535079956,
-0.5976502895355225,
0.42035752534866333,
0.14951719343662262,
0.96928870677948,
-0.7091343998908997,
0.6533625721931458,
0.7279112935066223,
-0.0040244124829769135,
-0.9532370567321777,
-0.09825597703456879,
-0.117978535592556,
-0.6970158815383911,
0.7146369218826294,
0.09091763198375702,
-0.02952847070991993,
0.15597733855247498,
-0.24966512620449066,
-0.5507079362869263,
1.4730077981948853,
-0.03260267898440361,
-0.21610261499881744,
-0.2358655482530594,
0.2897259294986725,
0.3189505338668823,
0.0017334569711238146,
-0.01094165537506342,
0.3638130724430084,
0.639565110206604,
0.8739621043205261,
-0.913237988948822,
0.1103142499923706,
0.18197521567344666,
-0.021477777510881424,
0.4686982333660126,
-0.5195643901824951,
0.44825008511543274,
-0.06160265952348709,
-0.2884833514690399,
0.02528240904211998,
0.5911816954612732,
0.5545792579650879,
0.3689861297607422,
0.8749539852142334,
1.086908221244812,
0.604912519454956,
-0.2765233814716339,
0.9361327290534973,
-0.2782559394836426,
0.42439353466033936,
0.5123544931411743,
-0.027151234447956085,
0.4698180854320526,
-0.04577044025063515,
-0.8945073485374451,
0.6560162305831909,
0.9173903465270996,
0.06467306613922119,
0.6624469757080078,
0.2423686981201172,
-0.3879258930683136,
-0.540645956993103,
-0.29790791869163513,
-0.6220006346702576,
0.22142545878887177,
0.04597380384802818,
-0.05195249617099762,
-0.23545555770397186,
-0.20893970131874084,
0.07367509603500366,
-0.22077345848083496,
-0.5684977173805237,
0.507134199142456,
-0.17546994984149933,
-0.8873509168624878,
0.22050081193447113,
0.06435646861791611,
0.3573738932609558,
-0.9756678342819214,
-0.12425825744867325,
0.03799218684434891,
-0.028065627440810204,
-0.42938756942749023,
-0.642492413520813,
0.34369364380836487,
-0.48052701354026794,
-0.008949591778218746,
-0.25738629698753357,
1.0009156465530396,
-0.03363293409347534,
-0.3633021414279938,
0.13807013630867004,
0.2724061906337738,
0.012074572965502739,
-0.1867702156305313,
-0.22845759987831116,
-0.24245180189609528,
0.03093082085251808,
-0.16882602870464325,
0.46375343203544617,
0.514991283416748,
-0.0878843292593956,
0.7381947636604309,
0.8328902125358582,
0.17739199101924896,
0.0004254935774952173,
-0.10572285950183868,
1.0435020923614502,
-0.47700822353363037,
-0.40198543667793274,
-0.757148265838623,
0.6325057744979858,
-0.16230224072933197,
0.08570577204227448,
0.621272087097168,
0.5817897319793701,
0.9945629239082336,
0.1733543574810028,
0.5773990154266357,
-0.4936458170413971,
0.20915448665618896,
-0.5213386416435242,
0.5030255317687988,
-0.1893901228904724,
0.08553596585988998,
-0.34598615765571594,
-0.8097593188285828,
-0.20659351348876953,
0.2653826177120209,
-0.048695582896471024,
0.00909123383462429,
0.6117445230484009,
0.48993900418281555,
0.08831992745399475,
0.21536263823509216,
0.20032577216625214,
0.04996266961097717,
0.2745782732963562,
0.673678994178772,
0.8695307374000549,
-0.5297854542732239,
0.8617651462554932,
-0.4015922546386719,
-0.15529750287532806,
0.32271328568458557,
-1.2705209255218506,
-0.6142410039901733,
-0.49370089173316956,
-0.6888031959533691,
-0.7230457067489624,
0.06677866727113724,
0.33022430539131165,
0.8161278367042542,
-0.5074219107627869,
0.08746359497308731,
-0.5931349396705627,
0.4914681315422058,
-0.2612951099872589,
-0.139706090092659,
0.47751495242118835,
-0.26556575298309326,
-0.16854989528656006,
0.23084864020347595,
0.24896597862243652,
-0.06547709554433823,
-0.07283440977334976,
-0.22448016703128815,
-0.2365647703409195,
-0.6477394104003906,
0.3714839518070221,
0.29640650749206543,
-0.3137569725513458,
-0.553167462348938,
-0.24170108139514923,
0.47175148129463196,
0.06163843348622322,
0.9728547930717468,
-1.4219512939453125,
0.5986606478691101,
0.822874128818512,
0.5310447216033936,
0.804404079914093,
0.023517802357673645,
0.3850553035736084,
-0.8138311505317688,
-0.2405737340450287,
-0.06616824865341187,
0.07787272334098816,
0.17300839722156525,
-0.24683481454849243,
0.8644641637802124,
0.8159313797950745,
-0.47126707434654236,
-0.7431175112724304,
0.4327877461910248,
-0.386577844619751,
0.043574292212724686,
0.6503507494926453,
-0.4737781882286072,
-0.025561418384313583,
-0.6074457764625549,
0.270611971616745,
0.5537310838699341,
0.2281855195760727,
0.7038018703460693,
1.1754099130630493,
-0.3033575713634491,
0.2511012554168701,
-0.7453221678733826,
0.4026683568954468,
-0.15091045200824738,
-0.37655872106552124,
0.08545178174972534,
0.48139524459838867,
0.2588421702384949,
0.3364759087562561,
0.7551227807998657,
-0.14040179550647736,
0.13743622601032257,
0.12065255641937256,
-0.3179785907268524,
-0.4546889364719391,
-0.24826261401176453,
0.49283361434936523,
0.9070772528648376,
0.19296453893184662,
0.07272454351186752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09894v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09894v3
|
Glitch Tokens in Large Language Models: Categorization Taxonomy and Effective Detection
| 2024-04-15T16:06:36 | 2024-04-19T11:08:36 |
Yuxi Li, Yi Liu, Gelei Deng, Ying Zhang, Wenjia Song, Ling Shi, Kailong Wang, Yuekang Li, Yang Liu, Haoyu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SE
|
With the expanding application of Large Language Models (LLMs) in various
domains, it becomes imperative to comprehensively investigate their unforeseen
behaviors and consequent outcomes. In this study, we introduce and
systematically explore the phenomenon of "glitch tokens", which are anomalous
tokens produced by established tokenizers and could potentially compromise the
models' quality of response. Specifically, we experiment on seven top popular
LLMs utilizing three distinct tokenizers and involving a totally of 182,517
tokens. We present categorizations of the identified glitch tokens and symptoms
exhibited by LLMs when interacting with glitch tokens. Based on our observation
that glitch tokens tend to cluster in the embedding space, we propose
GlitchHunter, a novel iterative clustering-based technique, for efficient
glitch token detection. The evaluation shows that our approach notably
outperforms three baseline methods on eight open-source LLMs. To the best of
our knowledge, we present the first comprehensive study on glitch tokens. Our
new detection further provides valuable insights into mitigating
tokenization-related errors in LLMs.
|
[
-0.1632557362318039,
-1.0208206176757812,
0.5085505843162537,
0.09431912750005722,
-0.3732236921787262,
0.5203907489776611,
-0.012416515499353409,
-0.5119040012359619,
0.6663500070571899,
0.44374212622642517,
-0.28355786204338074,
-0.5107355713844299,
-0.7933838963508606,
-0.11494657397270203,
-0.9182113409042358,
0.6562460660934448,
0.09506142884492874,
-0.02986997365951538,
-0.25125837326049805,
-0.09703007340431213,
-0.7063190340995789,
-0.929613471031189,
-0.7297754287719727,
-0.052227575331926346,
0.4162542521953583,
-0.006145306397229433,
0.6702927947044373,
0.6206285357475281,
0.681167721748352,
0.3474683463573456,
-0.37237149477005005,
0.004505618941038847,
-0.25949057936668396,
0.019869118928909302,
-0.03995732590556145,
-0.5819717049598694,
-0.4633214473724365,
-0.43771809339523315,
0.6360665559768677,
0.6204487085342407,
-0.20791630446910858,
0.16430014371871948,
-0.11140624433755875,
0.24017968773841858,
-0.6049455404281616,
-0.03246127441525459,
-0.8237614631652832,
0.05512344464659691,
-0.5885618329048157,
-0.17035754024982452,
-0.4875774383544922,
-0.030312011018395424,
-0.38559457659721375,
-0.29373589158058167,
0.2220805436372757,
0.3917817771434784,
0.3985457718372345,
0.17116165161132812,
-0.23985669016838074,
-0.5400634407997131,
-0.4952760636806488,
0.7763013243675232,
-0.916300892829895,
0.05075199902057648,
0.27607735991477966,
0.3729020059108734,
-0.6799098253250122,
-0.5475794076919556,
-0.5903850197792053,
-0.20297983288764954,
-0.21828676760196686,
-0.4451402425765991,
-0.5265748500823975,
0.011069759726524353,
0.24171926081180573,
0.6120558977127075,
-0.5602828860282898,
0.56964510679245,
0.027197757735848427,
-0.5430595278739929,
0.23766054213047028,
0.5175296068191528,
0.5054633617401123,
-0.1700301319360733,
-0.08516127616167068,
0.32587090134620667,
-0.736487090587616,
0.015543052926659584,
0.6487056016921997,
0.32656434178352356,
0.16798855364322662,
0.534587025642395,
0.04714953526854515,
0.6877020001411438,
-0.2624184191226959,
-0.0880904570221901,
0.1967260092496872,
-0.451084703207016,
0.008807085454463959,
-0.10246340930461884,
0.5725041627883911,
0.2373768389225006,
0.1214388906955719,
-0.3531613051891327,
-0.4022993743419647,
0.03756597265601158,
0.10573847591876984,
-0.4732421040534973,
0.016053296625614166,
0.4466703534126282,
-0.44988638162612915,
-0.4838751554489136,
0.13022567331790924,
-0.5633378028869629,
-0.7422200441360474,
0.07687965035438538,
0.34996625781059265,
-0.12111785262823105,
-0.5277469754219055,
0.1712891310453415,
-0.17280039191246033,
-0.08857621997594833,
0.18328356742858887,
-0.764674961566925,
0.14390891790390015,
0.8096749782562256,
0.9770469665527344,
-0.41508811712265015,
-0.3530426621437073,
-0.7998454570770264,
0.1185227483510971,
-0.33544856309890747,
0.8219195008277893,
-0.515385091304779,
-0.5123572945594788,
0.26327675580978394,
0.06945578008890152,
-0.04637496918439865,
-0.7076302766799927,
-0.021459341049194336,
-0.48558399081230164,
0.01274185348302126,
-0.15955843031406403,
-0.6616184711456299,
-0.015248778276145458,
0.4223361611366272,
-0.619142472743988,
0.8635731339454651,
-0.09333482384681702,
-0.7579368948936462,
0.5084002614021301,
-0.4510268568992615,
-0.24151556193828583,
0.3099055290222168,
-0.0829438865184784,
-0.25603970885276794,
0.4788811206817627,
-0.03791998699307442,
0.37273740768432617,
-0.09825074672698975,
0.3976385295391083,
-0.2926796078681946,
-0.7473315000534058,
0.645047128200531,
-0.21068458259105682,
0.43614494800567627,
-0.2740440368652344,
-0.24462951719760895,
0.4403088390827179,
-0.6370325684547424,
-0.09097623080015182,
0.15822242200374603,
-0.35570451617240906,
-0.3877808451652527,
0.008001445792615414,
0.11679378896951675,
-0.005712981801480055,
0.007300727069377899,
-0.5258834362030029,
0.39964577555656433,
-0.34985867142677307,
0.6589365005493164,
0.7461740374565125,
0.1230563074350357,
0.07018236070871353,
-0.1758580356836319,
0.48687663674354553,
0.3604692220687866,
0.2260783165693283,
-0.5510140061378479,
-0.4901164472103119,
-0.6506844758987427,
-0.6433615684509277,
0.3856186270713806,
0.33363866806030273,
-0.6584031581878662,
0.6087080836296082,
-0.1499973088502884,
-0.3310375213623047,
-0.38382917642593384,
-0.03762933984398842,
0.3097846210002899,
0.02405261993408203,
0.3193413019180298,
-0.47706666588783264,
-0.34483012557029724,
-0.6704521179199219,
-0.5890974402427673,
-0.15275369584560394,
-0.14490817487239838,
-0.046553075313568115,
0.6170938611030579,
-0.6538107395172119,
0.8845046162605286,
-0.1763395369052887,
-0.514742374420166,
-0.10069243609905243,
0.06745719909667969,
0.22705091536045074,
0.36960163712501526,
0.7139198780059814,
-0.3683071732521057,
-0.08957147598266602,
-0.12305799871683121,
-0.2874954640865326,
0.12806090712547302,
-0.025918178260326385,
0.3639422059059143,
0.39917847514152527,
1.0376628637313843,
-0.4370317757129669,
0.5758829712867737,
0.5392695069313049,
-0.5540074110031128,
0.6443164944648743,
-0.1286626160144806,
-0.0013509938726201653,
-0.7727847695350647,
0.22355300188064575,
-0.42326968908309937,
-0.18462656438350677,
-0.7007970809936523,
0.10676948726177216,
-0.1201016902923584,
0.3538779616355896,
-0.4137740135192871,
0.7113818526268005,
-0.18637697398662567,
-0.26105502247810364,
-0.3426670730113983,
0.01855202578008175,
-0.4579544961452484,
0.2237965315580368,
-0.5610272884368896,
0.5437610149383545,
0.5951533317565918,
-0.32554298639297485,
0.5702539682388306,
0.13060402870178223,
-0.40616902709007263,
0.15829958021640778,
-0.4041902720928192,
0.3521048128604889,
-0.1628834307193756,
0.3080705404281616,
-1.3808238506317139,
-0.43559515476226807,
0.43660566210746765,
-0.4466952681541443,
0.3080485463142395,
-0.31261929869651794,
-0.982358992099762,
-0.4382686913013458,
-0.5201190114021301,
0.6284497380256653,
0.09203260391950607,
-0.643469512462616,
0.49918296933174133,
0.4028783440589905,
-0.009450304321944714,
-0.40222737193107605,
-0.646870493888855,
0.4402564465999603,
-0.36318904161453247,
-0.2810569405555725,
0.060636311769485474,
-0.024001458659768105,
-0.08781962096691132,
0.13624146580696106,
-0.059376008808612823,
0.1756056398153305,
0.3317764103412628,
0.19259467720985413,
0.18210619688034058,
-0.08009620755910873,
0.1750085949897766,
-0.35771849751472473,
-0.2017274647951126,
-0.06059388071298599,
-0.07587214559316635,
0.9857714772224426,
-0.13801775872707367,
-0.8809236288070679,
-0.19622763991355896,
0.31270110607147217,
0.8731297850608826,
-0.18170605599880219,
0.7724758386611938,
0.5206577181816101,
-0.506919801235199,
0.02738218382000923,
-0.706222653388977,
-0.09656091034412384,
-0.4832037687301636,
0.45645368099212646,
-0.056381139904260635,
-1.4061720371246338,
0.9825200438499451,
-0.0647769421339035,
-0.07388331741094589,
0.2767556607723236,
0.47956907749176025,
0.40922749042510986,
1.2251089811325073,
0.6432769298553467,
-0.46244028210639954,
0.44932085275650024,
0.08676081895828247,
0.6148670315742493,
-0.7101204991340637,
-0.2705986797809601,
-0.7232580184936523,
-0.2194889783859253,
-0.6485269069671631,
-0.5717732906341553,
0.17387424409389496,
0.15382172167301178,
-0.06711515039205551,
-0.022216279059648514,
-0.2749903202056885,
0.6937367916107178,
0.31943005323410034,
-0.34741148352622986,
0.37759456038475037,
0.13677729666233063,
-0.342088907957077,
0.09284883737564087,
-0.4740740954875946,
-0.2728186845779419,
0.8758128881454468,
0.47721925377845764,
0.5118309855461121,
0.33840587735176086,
0.6726924180984497,
0.3350488245487213,
0.2365073412656784,
-1.0909063816070557,
0.44763389229774475,
-0.22581540048122406,
-0.5682242512702942,
-0.37495818734169006,
-0.2622617483139038,
-0.8471465110778809,
0.1582213044166565,
-0.12843935191631317,
-1.3435218334197998,
0.03684912621974945,
0.2806980013847351,
-0.19842429459095,
0.4364500939846039,
-0.35038572549819946,
0.8293397426605225,
-0.137220561504364,
0.07013344019651413,
-0.26689961552619934,
-0.2316504567861557,
0.3737546503543854,
-0.3567338287830353,
0.6453960537910461,
-0.1113549992442131,
0.139219269156456,
0.47692322731018066,
-0.28627893328666687,
0.8307774066925049,
-0.3236881196498871,
-0.10245264321565628,
0.1619551181793213,
0.35151806473731995,
0.6014351844787598,
-0.12132599949836731,
0.20360426604747772,
0.44050854444503784,
-0.045352913439273834,
-0.4262653589248657,
-0.4231654405593872,
0.5915995836257935,
-0.26944082975387573,
-0.5646001100540161,
-0.35877346992492676,
-0.2594393789768219,
-0.2577497065067291,
0.24813900887966156,
0.19509272277355194,
0.44155266880989075,
-0.060011282563209534,
0.1928045004606247,
0.22041049599647522,
-0.4607306718826294,
0.5587274432182312,
0.44036391377449036,
-0.8169817328453064,
-0.34853604435920715,
1.1554863452911377,
0.06051655113697052,
0.05971620976924896,
-0.04621481895446777,
0.1280597448348999,
-0.09649475663900375,
-0.9989354014396667,
-0.2555638253688812,
0.24440991878509521,
-0.698973536491394,
-0.33008676767349243,
-0.42149558663368225,
-0.1540437787771225,
-0.00434942077845335,
0.039520591497421265,
-0.14735014736652374,
-0.21124188601970673,
-0.15551765263080597,
-0.08674805611371994,
0.21289165318012238,
0.8954585194587708,
0.12411309778690338,
0.47691652178764343,
-0.8848451375961304,
0.0518551766872406,
0.1709785759449005,
0.5543560981750488,
0.342677503824234,
-0.39767855405807495,
-0.2821689248085022,
-0.2384776622056961,
0.20422619581222534,
-0.658808708190918,
0.0869368389248848,
0.03585544973611832,
0.6253756284713745,
0.3879716396331787,
-0.4233074188232422,
0.685932993888855,
-0.4741915464401245,
1.1074649095535278,
0.36472323536872864,
-1.1961549520492554,
0.33593329787254333,
-0.4005289077758789,
0.20478683710098267,
0.18311268091201782,
-0.1704198569059372,
-0.9752473831176758,
-0.7595632076263428,
-0.36920881271362305,
-1.346606731414795,
0.6033929586410522,
-0.15992601215839386,
0.4790034890174866,
-0.43209701776504517,
0.39848947525024414,
0.029408734291791916,
0.5593129396438599,
-0.4920395612716675,
-0.10525757819414139,
0.038414716720581055,
0.07795485854148865,
-0.09588079154491425,
-0.49480897188186646,
0.018508518114686012,
-0.11283186078071594,
0.4689008891582489,
-0.37588974833488464,
0.2254791557788849,
-0.23238885402679443,
-0.3463994562625885,
-0.4036683440208435,
0.2264697402715683,
0.7678105235099792,
0.6636706590652466,
0.042042799293994904,
0.16120387613773346,
0.06012696027755737,
-0.44257962703704834,
0.01890532299876213,
-0.35761958360671997,
0.14982165396213531,
0.14354458451271057,
0.5424743294715881,
0.6658666729927063,
0.3570219576358795,
-0.7932476997375488,
0.7032478451728821,
-0.06104816496372223,
0.1327243149280548,
-0.22513793408870697,
0.11042755097150803,
0.03394150733947754,
0.16749154031276703,
0.5665866732597351,
-0.1282430738210678,
0.2689858675003052,
-0.5053237080574036,
0.05758405849337578,
0.7693997025489807,
-0.15544134378433228,
-0.30483704805374146,
0.3547089993953705,
0.00045836425852030516,
-0.327180951833725,
0.4061717391014099,
-0.24756863713264465,
-0.7473162412643433,
0.6384692192077637,
0.5700226426124573,
0.9253515005111694,
-0.21325144171714783,
0.1693132370710373,
0.025097087025642395,
0.3816864490509033,
-0.17137019336223602,
-0.07258083671331406,
0.4130886495113373,
-0.6955210566520691,
-0.5211750268936157,
-0.7914329171180725,
-0.5541696548461914,
0.31781840324401855,
-0.4698452651500702,
0.16601119935512543,
-0.4870944023132324,
-0.2548901438713074,
0.022619301453232765,
-0.3908281922340393,
-0.5059986710548401,
-0.3221791386604309,
0.2062613070011139,
0.9530047178268433,
-0.744006872177124,
0.54124516248703,
0.8908658027648926,
0.011733124032616615,
-0.5930929780006409,
0.2572713792324066,
0.1115327924489975,
-1.0053540468215942,
0.350525826215744,
0.3868904411792755,
0.10209982842206955,
0.10285364836454391,
-0.4830954074859619,
-0.7872116565704346,
0.8782938122749329,
0.17736786603927612,
-0.6134651899337769,
0.053492818027734756,
0.5146986842155457,
0.6320260167121887,
-0.23752231895923615,
0.06930715590715408,
0.8292576670646667,
0.4574023485183716,
0.2351224571466446,
-1.1063289642333984,
0.16276749968528748,
-0.01673952490091324,
0.10886679589748383,
0.5042558908462524,
-0.5768753886222839,
0.7862213253974915,
0.02836388535797596,
-0.10175301134586334,
0.2443084716796875,
-0.02399662882089615,
0.20916661620140076,
0.1727912425994873,
0.5383877754211426,
0.5930071473121643,
0.8877888321876526,
-0.22000433504581451,
0.7419333457946777,
-0.2211090326309204,
0.5143502354621887,
0.6916691660881042,
-0.12528666853904724,
0.7075744271278381,
0.6652417182922363,
-0.08248892426490784,
0.28993189334869385,
0.4746097922325134,
-0.21004977822303772,
0.35165277123451233,
0.7314009666442871,
-0.23974144458770752,
-0.301307737827301,
-0.05796438828110695,
-0.21984368562698364,
0.505824863910675,
0.5032127499580383,
-0.03850351274013519,
-0.3406904935836792,
0.1419786661863327,
0.14661403000354767,
-0.36731621623039246,
-0.5705814361572266,
0.7260211706161499,
-0.05354278162121773,
-0.28980040550231934,
0.34609556198120117,
0.16344696283340454,
0.881612241268158,
-0.33498522639274597,
0.05629526451230049,
-0.3931949734687805,
0.2224203199148178,
-0.3398275375366211,
-0.4490531384944916,
0.3051556646823883,
-0.04250920191407204,
-0.019491046667099,
0.12629073858261108,
0.7871582508087158,
-0.23711927235126495,
-0.24088160693645477,
0.4146606922149658,
0.4647575318813324,
0.08820156008005142,
-0.37526166439056396,
-0.29901471734046936,
0.5365353226661682,
-0.2265380173921585,
-0.22893863916397095,
0.6238077878952026,
0.3466982841491699,
-0.37496712803840637,
0.5683798789978027,
0.7080761194229126,
0.001542207901366055,
0.18954986333847046,
-0.04146670177578926,
1.0364608764648438,
-0.6897799372673035,
-0.4459132254123688,
-1.0194309949874878,
0.7418346405029297,
0.04471931979060173,
-0.11394470930099487,
0.6033433675765991,
0.4524611234664917,
0.6575545072555542,
-0.0806296244263649,
0.6740742325782776,
0.1531504988670349,
0.43542730808258057,
-0.4627010226249695,
0.6286382079124451,
-0.4529794156551361,
0.5582361221313477,
-0.236503466963768,
-0.8708077669143677,
-0.5610502362251282,
0.23019899427890778,
-0.10138046741485596,
-0.2679409682750702,
0.6192072629928589,
0.7345751523971558,
0.1892699897289276,
-0.2442551702260971,
0.4111193120479584,
0.2907140552997589,
0.6443656086921692,
0.12028977274894714,
0.995335578918457,
-0.13990983366966248,
0.33696332573890686,
0.4091339111328125,
-0.21721962094306946,
-0.6326916813850403,
-0.9374198913574219,
-1.0957272052764893,
-0.34122154116630554,
-0.31889915466308594,
-0.2962605953216553,
0.008132275193929672,
0.7263848781585693,
0.15339593589305878,
-1.0771470069885254,
-0.07827121019363403,
-0.0597476027905941,
0.31879159808158875,
0.1518820971250534,
-0.24189123511314392,
0.14322225749492645,
-0.5524723529815674,
-0.42944955825805664,
0.3893563449382782,
0.42626330256462097,
0.16793310642242432,
-0.4200669527053833,
0.16153575479984283,
0.33602428436279297,
0.09451379626989365,
0.5590554475784302,
0.12889544665813446,
-0.8469991683959961,
-0.7556285262107849,
0.08441600203514099,
0.1282246708869934,
-0.2657305598258972,
0.9203003644943237,
-0.6280757784843445,
0.40744155645370483,
0.12234491109848022,
0.5450817942619324,
0.02349991165101528,
-0.3868260681629181,
0.16656963527202606,
-1.01700758934021,
0.25236383080482483,
0.06539279967546463,
0.34922510385513306,
0.32000240683555603,
-0.2183031290769577,
0.27723827958106995,
0.41113170981407166,
-0.39401915669441223,
-1.4190309047698975,
0.23818132281303406,
-0.6067760586738586,
-0.3047720491886139,
1.2206573486328125,
0.005400239024311304,
-0.013970226049423218,
-0.10395285487174988,
-0.22762328386306763,
-0.1642633080482483,
-0.14528852701187134,
0.9759389162063599,
1.0762497186660767,
0.05110955238342285,
0.22884555160999298,
-0.4530843198299408,
0.4778132736682892,
0.1073441207408905,
-0.6462210416793823,
0.14570848643779755,
0.5958431363105774,
0.3895476162433624,
0.543793261051178,
0.514065146446228,
-0.1976681798696518,
0.23756058514118195,
-0.2346862256526947,
-0.11637043207883835,
-0.06988819688558578,
-0.2377823442220688,
-0.5435976982116699,
0.13912032544612885,
0.40354475378990173,
-0.12639287114143372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09889v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09889v2
|
Is Table Retrieval a Solved Problem? Exploring Join-Aware Multi-Table Retrieval
| 2024-04-15T15:55:01 | 2024-06-06T01:59:40 |
Peter Baile Chen, Yi Zhang, Dan Roth
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Retrieving relevant tables containing the necessary information to accurately
answer a given question over tables is critical to open-domain
question-answering (QA) systems. Previous methods assume the answer to such a
question can be found either in a single table or multiple tables identified
through question decomposition or rewriting. However, neither of these
approaches is sufficient, as many questions require retrieving multiple tables
and joining them through a join plan that cannot be discerned from the user
query itself. If the join plan is not considered in the retrieval stage, the
subsequent steps of reasoning and answering based on those retrieved tables are
likely to be incorrect. To address this problem, we introduce a method that
uncovers useful join relations for any query and database during table
retrieval. We use a novel re-ranking method formulated as a mixed-integer
program that considers not only table-query relevance but also table-table
relevance that requires inferring join relationships. Our method outperforms
the state-of-the-art approaches for table retrieval by up to 9.3% in F1 score
and for end-to-end QA by up to 5.4% in accuracy.
|
[
-0.6232492923736572,
-0.7220360636711121,
0.8199646472930908,
-0.2281348556280136,
-0.26829493045806885,
0.21692736446857452,
0.32751214504241943,
-0.5762771368026733,
0.47408202290534973,
0.3831705152988434,
-0.6441004276275635,
-0.3909156024456024,
-0.15380574762821198,
-0.09406531602144241,
-0.26665085554122925,
0.6050350666046143,
0.1084204837679863,
0.017513098195195198,
-0.6805226802825928,
-0.5241258144378662,
-0.3988087475299835,
-0.5942425727844238,
-0.22595499455928802,
-0.23555628955364227,
0.7084839940071106,
0.6924331188201904,
0.823853611946106,
0.3987327218055725,
0.7226306200027466,
0.10431785136461258,
-0.125163733959198,
0.1952415406703949,
-0.5941169261932373,
0.33297452330589294,
-0.014424329623579979,
-0.7588954567909241,
-0.43228623270988464,
0.0875217393040657,
0.36633017659187317,
0.8847733736038208,
-0.3711533844470978,
0.4280633330345154,
-0.19672337174415588,
1.0836578607559204,
-0.720940113067627,
0.023528285324573517,
-0.9334651231765747,
0.2125045359134674,
-0.42813360691070557,
-0.5275515913963318,
-0.47764351963996887,
-0.5913223028182983,
0.029748694971203804,
-0.5947383642196655,
0.3282792568206787,
0.3367708921432495,
0.3582748472690582,
-0.03693230822682381,
-0.7231455445289612,
0.017423145473003387,
-0.7127863764762878,
0.3869454264640808,
-0.5535405874252319,
0.8078700304031372,
0.2626015841960907,
0.8707222938537598,
-0.4165736734867096,
-0.6557853817939758,
-0.6634764671325684,
-0.18063344061374664,
-0.2307373732328415,
0.08529064804315567,
0.3476070761680603,
-0.20209901034832,
0.43260297179222107,
0.5188431739807129,
-0.7527065873146057,
-0.41092649102211,
-0.19992220401763916,
-0.12762708961963654,
0.345510870218277,
0.13706748187541962,
0.4709376394748688,
0.18952278792858124,
-0.3583172559738159,
-0.20485305786132812,
-0.7678779363632202,
0.00287628173828125,
-0.15054991841316223,
0.31347107887268066,
0.5285638570785522,
0.7637426257133484,
-0.41528984904289246,
0.8618611693382263,
-0.3785420060157776,
0.06897203624248505,
0.02744182012975216,
-0.5731508135795593,
0.20426633954048157,
-0.1840343326330185,
0.18799255788326263,
0.3864099085330963,
0.07557646185159683,
-0.4457744061946869,
-0.2586580216884613,
-0.055842481553554535,
0.24103957414627075,
-0.2838813364505768,
-0.3084431290626526,
0.21338361501693726,
-0.3570837080478668,
0.2661076486110687,
0.006461688317358494,
-0.8514827489852905,
-0.2769772410392761,
-0.08266206830739975,
0.7662132382392883,
-0.1547950655221939,
-0.44380566477775574,
-0.5127639770507812,
-0.27331608533859253,
0.49270397424697876,
0.3318171799182892,
-0.45810991525650024,
0.14576266705989838,
0.5743626952171326,
0.4465958774089813,
-0.0682784765958786,
-0.12522020936012268,
-0.5065069794654846,
0.24488121271133423,
-0.49421268701553345,
0.8978224992752075,
-0.5397890210151672,
-0.3726429343223572,
-0.06589652597904205,
-0.31734803318977356,
0.029822614043951035,
-0.7552797794342041,
0.5111587047576904,
-0.9786897897720337,
0.16115689277648926,
-0.6950827836990356,
-0.3575766682624817,
0.013372558169066906,
0.4794382154941559,
-1.065825343132019,
0.6961588263511658,
-0.09478255361318588,
-0.6077662110328674,
0.6215009689331055,
-0.1920386701822281,
-0.3286442458629608,
-0.13973452150821686,
-0.21904774010181427,
-0.5163434743881226,
0.06022518873214722,
0.37050333619117737,
0.05577223002910614,
-0.3363594114780426,
0.04302574694156647,
-0.4486851394176483,
-0.5177465677261353,
0.1540903002023697,
0.03557707741856575,
0.28252100944519043,
0.02605476789176464,
0.28211915493011475,
0.03270154446363449,
-0.36960357427597046,
0.517679750919342,
0.20695392787456512,
-0.3140614926815033,
-0.27850762009620667,
0.03266920521855354,
-0.5337188839912415,
0.3647560477256775,
0.22788932919502258,
-0.6045541167259216,
0.25956183671951294,
-0.09916569292545319,
0.03385457396507263,
0.1775047779083252,
0.34311673045158386,
0.4717138707637787,
-0.6383104920387268,
0.3366090953350067,
-0.05548311769962311,
0.10876163095235825,
0.0891948863863945,
-0.7373864650726318,
-0.6413554549217224,
0.2819666862487793,
0.18369466066360474,
0.2946448028087616,
-0.8321654200553894,
-0.19542184472084045,
-0.052119772881269455,
-0.6477871537208557,
-0.6317534446716309,
-0.44087114930152893,
0.3294423520565033,
0.5300923585891724,
0.7392027974128723,
-0.26038140058517456,
-0.22085610032081604,
-0.8070403933525085,
-0.8242781758308411,
-0.21804335713386536,
0.13653667271137238,
0.5214837789535522,
0.30200207233428955,
0.4579480290412903,
0.7705188393592834,
-0.8036666512489319,
-0.39231759309768677,
-0.0736483782529831,
-0.037939488887786865,
0.2760176658630371,
0.22350862622261047,
0.3056720197200775,
-0.9080342054367065,
-0.6317592859268188,
-0.08513757586479187,
-0.7726497054100037,
0.5064074397087097,
0.13484689593315125,
-0.42720773816108704,
-0.10590613633394241,
0.42404425144195557,
-0.6459857225418091,
0.5396842956542969,
-0.19830845296382904,
-0.05211217328906059,
0.4120500981807709,
-0.0861523300409317,
0.44175955653190613,
-0.6982412934303284,
0.3097953796386719,
-0.38328149914741516,
-0.1970449984073639,
-0.39115288853645325,
0.3694399893283844,
0.17934779822826385,
-0.5729836821556091,
-0.25452810525894165,
0.1836349070072174,
-0.8360410928726196,
-0.3357241153717041,
0.18729589879512787,
0.3847075402736664,
-0.08624117821455002,
0.6925592422485352,
-0.24192170798778534,
0.9855557680130005,
0.2703916132450104,
-0.4108933210372925,
0.08887944370508194,
0.4411350190639496,
-0.061040688306093216,
0.44657570123672485,
-0.27825599908828735,
0.5066786408424377,
-0.3505244553089142,
0.08529892563819885,
-1.1263049840927124,
-0.17457222938537598,
0.18424321711063385,
-0.6287463307380676,
0.35162580013275146,
-0.17486870288848877,
-0.18541359901428223,
-0.33185845613479614,
-0.3813268840312958,
0.4155808985233307,
-0.047781094908714294,
-0.6124683022499084,
0.7053322792053223,
0.6418198943138123,
0.06794066727161407,
-0.9352871775627136,
-0.2979028522968292,
-0.09718204289674759,
0.055897463113069534,
-0.511077880859375,
0.5907192826271057,
-0.03914209082722664,
0.036724768579006195,
0.16347971558570862,
-0.9661704897880554,
-0.4328610897064209,
0.03524996340274811,
-0.0165241826325655,
-0.06439383327960968,
0.07174352556467056,
0.13847999274730682,
-0.1211174800992012,
-0.10739649087190628,
0.09517604857683182,
0.13490857183933258,
0.3839946389198303,
0.040199726819992065,
-0.4327739477157593,
-0.30849340558052063,
0.7300198674201965,
0.7797085046768188,
-0.7785182595252991,
0.7592524290084839,
0.1460748016834259,
-0.6261792182922363,
-0.1770283579826355,
-0.5711076259613037,
-0.5002525448799133,
-0.36781731247901917,
0.30816450715065,
-0.6729092001914978,
-0.6102041006088257,
0.9575926661491394,
0.05476849526166916,
0.3100067377090454,
0.30761975049972534,
-0.07464687526226044,
-0.18641787767410278,
0.9220435619354248,
0.45679107308387756,
0.24029777944087982,
0.2044815719127655,
-0.09081543236970901,
0.43840229511260986,
-0.6359723806381226,
-0.886945903301239,
-0.9978675246238708,
-0.4385593831539154,
-0.4683188796043396,
-0.15484736859798431,
0.586553156375885,
0.021545762196183205,
0.06491270661354065,
0.468546599149704,
-0.3856445252895355,
0.6415751576423645,
0.6471978425979614,
0.41746777296066284,
0.712832510471344,
-0.12031012028455734,
-0.2554812431335449,
0.0036721995566040277,
-0.659149706363678,
0.09809733182191849,
1.0630964040756226,
-0.28872621059417725,
0.6004452109336853,
0.5016626715660095,
1.0011347532272339,
0.2091490924358368,
0.42951342463493347,
-0.575518012046814,
0.7125313878059387,
0.34153926372528076,
-0.7746224403381348,
-0.5031906366348267,
-0.8426141142845154,
-0.8814829587936401,
0.6463789939880371,
-0.419185608625412,
-0.5148941874504089,
0.20360594987869263,
-0.001039988943375647,
-0.2001008689403534,
0.003916789777576923,
-0.6436305642127991,
0.9538291096687317,
-0.05642211064696312,
-0.11656033992767334,
-0.397586852312088,
-0.6863316297531128,
0.3726384937763214,
-0.09082384407520294,
0.013683321885764599,
-0.28704574704170227,
0.049886103719472885,
0.8691958785057068,
-0.417419970035553,
-0.047485124319791794,
-0.09682081639766693,
0.25361889600753784,
0.18846014142036438,
0.34438464045524597,
0.3148629367351532,
0.2041662186384201,
-0.2596190273761749,
-0.40894174575805664,
0.3875577449798584,
-0.3145703971385956,
-1.1137549877166748,
0.8555928468704224,
-0.555210292339325,
-0.7634897828102112,
-0.5836814045906067,
-0.23048123717308044,
-0.5947089791297913,
0.4017525315284729,
-0.049993786960840225,
0.46921923756599426,
-0.10039561986923218,
0.14262905716896057,
0.320528119802475,
0.11442779004573822,
0.1665114164352417,
0.5756912231445312,
-0.2643324136734009,
-0.3153061270713806,
0.7937583923339844,
0.4341740012168884,
-0.013614027760922909,
0.6861762404441833,
-0.28115585446357727,
-0.6436629295349121,
-0.4775896668434143,
-0.1501549333333969,
0.40648287534713745,
-0.6155720353126526,
-0.5588674545288086,
-0.3590254485607147,
0.05893327295780182,
-0.022856637835502625,
0.2213459461927414,
-0.23810403048992157,
-0.6958316564559937,
0.10621809214353561,
-0.09331180900335312,
-0.17482413351535797,
0.34111350774765015,
0.34618616104125977,
-0.19060179591178894,
-1.0041885375976562,
0.5027554035186768,
0.49147939682006836,
0.6906230449676514,
0.33503371477127075,
-0.08638700097799301,
-0.009555074386298656,
-0.16632147133350372,
-0.1937788873910904,
-1.53632652759552,
0.2038404792547226,
0.39789703488349915,
1.1534651517868042,
-0.15960103273391724,
0.567598819732666,
0.5844840407371521,
-0.2267346829175949,
0.2441779226064682,
-0.12734366953372955,
-0.35617464780807495,
0.6281219720840454,
0.01110055111348629,
0.11956297606229782,
0.9291543364524841,
0.6622747778892517,
-0.2817327082157135,
-0.084293894469738,
-0.42411288619041443,
-1.037960410118103,
0.6180465817451477,
0.1717763990163803,
-0.35996153950691223,
0.02771306037902832,
0.5323069095611572,
-0.1105358898639679,
0.36288613080978394,
-0.5714175701141357,
-0.34694376587867737,
0.2307875156402588,
0.379631906747818,
0.3452114462852478,
-0.34924933314323425,
-0.05679123103618622,
-0.027660846710205078,
0.47749367356300354,
-0.06261476129293442,
0.5387519001960754,
0.2042272835969925,
-0.24468179047107697,
-0.2329329550266266,
0.3814316689968109,
-0.05750320106744766,
1.1281001567840576,
-0.6462181806564331,
0.015134802088141441,
-0.15213757753372192,
-0.15822595357894897,
0.002525930292904377,
0.1378231644630432,
0.1264093518257141,
0.061193469911813736,
-0.04014851897954941,
-0.004229837097227573,
-0.09012825787067413,
-0.3064963221549988,
0.37095701694488525,
-0.3639494478702545,
0.06733370572328568,
-0.04514547437429428,
-0.04854361712932587,
0.17379799485206604,
0.10533144325017929,
0.7304424047470093,
-0.0019279546104371548,
0.4550497829914093,
-0.8296181559562683,
0.8056722283363342,
0.7020379900932312,
-0.5416749119758606,
0.017207127064466476,
0.7105275988578796,
0.28414463996887207,
-0.4175688624382019,
1.2350287437438965,
0.08215505629777908,
-0.3461569845676422,
0.48844799399375916,
0.47860750555992126,
0.37020033597946167,
-0.21304811537265778,
0.1748746931552887,
0.5266558527946472,
0.27105996012687683,
0.08070261031389236,
0.786871612071991,
-0.21169964969158173,
-0.5882179737091064,
-0.387443870306015,
-0.33973413705825806,
-0.5959006547927856,
-0.18315421044826508,
-0.8476830124855042,
-0.04547486454248428,
-0.18392492830753326,
-0.35882458090782166,
0.19382919371128082,
0.16040882468223572,
-0.42031329870224,
-0.013623672537505627,
-0.3705575168132782,
1.0818934440612793,
-0.520635187625885,
0.5353362560272217,
0.7076084017753601,
-0.6963788270950317,
-0.8487878441810608,
0.08718438446521759,
-0.18161094188690186,
-0.38183271884918213,
-0.07909274846315384,
0.21144014596939087,
0.026682980358600616,
0.19499456882476807,
-0.17179274559020996,
-0.7433680295944214,
1.038513422012329,
0.4531062841415405,
-0.2687641978263855,
-0.025095602497458458,
0.23891158401966095,
0.40131279826164246,
0.15492789447307587,
0.5790336728096008,
0.5262482166290283,
0.3073473274707794,
0.1694207340478897,
-0.9693922400474548,
0.2020721733570099,
-0.1794835925102234,
-0.4699769616127014,
0.7365036010742188,
-0.4331229031085968,
0.5107322931289673,
-0.5781955122947693,
-0.3613051772117615,
-0.22766856849193573,
0.9472832083702087,
0.2505934536457062,
0.7014884352684021,
0.27559787034988403,
0.5689114332199097,
0.8355448246002197,
-0.3383677899837494,
0.6859060525894165,
-0.09193476289510727,
0.2912197411060333,
0.8614733219146729,
-0.34381723403930664,
1.0998156070709229,
0.47415441274642944,
-0.3040013015270233,
0.10152089595794678,
0.5202553868293762,
0.5464309453964233,
0.6072947978973389,
0.06908000260591507,
-0.2812882661819458,
-0.5868739485740662,
-0.14376786351203918,
-0.6674964427947998,
0.33003005385398865,
0.26997339725494385,
0.05812747776508331,
-0.653014063835144,
-0.44331157207489014,
-0.3467984199523926,
0.11547886580228806,
-0.13669635355472565,
0.9085022211074829,
0.2505069673061371,
-0.7694408893585205,
0.5542104244232178,
-0.34722113609313965,
0.006506278179585934,
-0.38115888833999634,
-0.5452561974525452,
-0.6772294044494629,
-0.07263686507940292,
-0.27664270997047424,
-0.8917973041534424,
0.392810195684433,
-0.7634463310241699,
-0.11182916909456253,
0.17204499244689941,
0.6148780584335327,
-0.5464253425598145,
0.14087441563606262,
0.1102645993232727,
1.1687062978744507,
0.005723471753299236,
-0.5568940043449402,
-0.36246708035469055,
-0.42607352137565613,
0.09712378680706024,
0.0996561273932457,
0.5224173069000244,
0.3588537573814392,
-0.16990378499031067,
0.895070493221283,
0.5241761803627014,
-0.5137732625007629,
0.0471370555460453,
-0.09780502319335938,
1.106919527053833,
-0.7260931134223938,
-0.39807021617889404,
-0.2927243709564209,
0.3692583739757538,
-0.05513385310769081,
-0.020589014515280724,
0.48114001750946045,
0.8171471953392029,
0.8749364614486694,
-0.11859432607889175,
0.1954260766506195,
0.08446626365184784,
0.5845563411712646,
-0.2690475881099701,
0.8124591112136841,
-0.7619907259941101,
0.22397369146347046,
-0.06538990139961243,
-1.3374112844467163,
-0.5742447376251221,
0.36787617206573486,
-0.07016918063163757,
0.07736102491617203,
0.6774606108665466,
0.7950868606567383,
-0.0010035719024017453,
0.09703383594751358,
0.17727318406105042,
-0.22334496676921844,
0.38491854071617126,
0.39250990748405457,
0.7357035875320435,
-0.2880532145500183,
1.0357052087783813,
-0.17155037820339203,
-0.2411920130252838,
-0.24957245588302612,
-0.3479185700416565,
-0.35024434328079224,
-0.6084812879562378,
-0.1746322065591812,
-0.19290097057819366,
0.3571757972240448,
0.4618907570838928,
0.3466036915779114,
-0.6723911166191101,
-0.21360346674919128,
0.31601861119270325,
0.42453208565711975,
-0.5070033669471741,
-0.16690346598625183,
0.4976983666419983,
-0.24105553328990936,
-0.15238361060619354,
0.5099493265151978,
0.03524386137723923,
-0.28218570351600647,
0.13894380629062653,
0.41936081647872925,
-0.6709438562393188,
-0.24905361235141754,
0.3541426956653595,
0.5146627426147461,
-0.2430141121149063,
-0.24734456837177277,
0.41958633065223694,
0.08686237782239914,
0.24855676293373108,
0.9199759364128113,
-0.9700912237167358,
0.3708624541759491,
0.9526978731155396,
0.579113781452179,
0.7212344408035278,
0.3171396851539612,
0.5824440121650696,
-0.9829953908920288,
-0.5684269666671753,
0.6196776628494263,
0.2141103446483612,
0.1892407387495041,
-0.2083710879087448,
0.7726850509643555,
0.032593801617622375,
-0.6088383793830872,
-0.688003659248352,
0.2789689004421234,
-1.054944634437561,
-0.08859776705503464,
0.30249810218811035,
0.08120474219322205,
-0.04447420686483383,
-0.37349534034729004,
-0.12911877036094666,
0.3236326277256012,
-0.45772257447242737,
0.7988758683204651,
0.2347717583179474,
-0.5641111731529236,
-0.403560996055603,
-0.3223029375076294,
0.6075036525726318,
0.32181316614151,
-0.6858187317848206,
0.18262867629528046,
0.587510883808136,
-0.11736708879470825,
0.4137483537197113,
0.7203992009162903,
-0.36241501569747925,
0.42926448583602905,
-0.08816823363304138,
-0.2825687527656555,
-0.14036357402801514,
-0.7116174697875977,
0.39151519536972046,
0.6708118319511414,
0.3333868682384491,
-0.34602391719818115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09868v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09868v2
|
Software Engineering Methods For AI-Driven Deductive Legal Reasoning
| 2024-04-15T15:33:29 | 2024-06-27T21:03:15 |
Rohan Padhye
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The recent proliferation of generative artificial intelligence (AI)
technologies such as pre-trained large language models (LLMs) has opened up new
frontiers in computational law. An exciting area of development is the use of
AI to automate the deductive rule-based reasoning inherent in statutory and
contract law. This paper argues that such automated deductive legal reasoning
can now be viewed from the lens of software engineering, treating LLMs as
interpreters of natural-language programs with natural-language inputs. We show
how it is possible to apply principled software engineering techniques to
enhance AI-driven legal reasoning of complex statutes and to unlock new
applications in automated meta-reasoning such as mutation-guided example
generation and metamorphic property-based testing.
|
[
-0.16423794627189636,
-0.9916477203369141,
0.9722148180007935,
0.061584554612636566,
-0.2553240656852722,
0.00450413953512907,
0.051215581595897675,
-0.15467801690101624,
-0.09896860271692276,
0.8862818479537964,
-0.41703033447265625,
-0.48361825942993164,
-0.21862173080444336,
0.12136949598789215,
-0.5737313032150269,
0.5162254571914673,
-0.1554984301328659,
0.06188269704580307,
-0.29486629366874695,
-0.0013296902179718018,
-0.5732827186584473,
-0.3444488048553467,
-0.05118923261761665,
-0.34769439697265625,
-0.09683595597743988,
0.3513534367084503,
1.055118441581726,
0.6361023783683777,
0.45620137453079224,
0.28842291235923767,
0.08886760473251343,
-0.0990416407585144,
0.3030398488044739,
0.028228219598531723,
-0.11827445030212402,
-0.6854008436203003,
-0.36570101976394653,
0.1478194296360016,
0.17908760905265808,
0.5288597941398621,
-0.14034876227378845,
0.024375086650252342,
-0.1731712371110916,
0.6888306140899658,
-0.6878505945205688,
0.3995625376701355,
-0.8144931793212891,
0.10923117399215698,
0.05149999260902405,
-0.3859797716140747,
-0.5453413724899292,
-0.49241867661476135,
-0.22768065333366394,
-0.7045215368270874,
0.0983707383275032,
-0.03523201495409012,
0.7357550859451294,
1.0304592847824097,
-0.49652642011642456,
-0.49101966619491577,
-0.9885650873184204,
0.6096968650817871,
-0.8917322158813477,
0.37306898832321167,
0.3893076777458191,
0.3700909912586212,
-0.4710269570350647,
-0.5639032125473022,
-0.6936954855918884,
-0.9493284225463867,
-0.11782240867614746,
-0.02921748161315918,
0.019252298399806023,
0.45100682973861694,
0.3912191390991211,
0.19367675483226776,
-0.8202675580978394,
0.21034672856330872,
-0.34822243452072144,
-0.004278631415218115,
1.121721625328064,
-0.04394474998116493,
0.5672060251235962,
0.008234871551394463,
0.24533280730247498,
0.3194660246372223,
-0.8816011548042297,
-0.30893266201019287,
0.1960681974887848,
-0.06763423979282379,
0.10849802196025848,
0.7209452390670776,
0.11290522664785385,
0.8686541318893433,
-0.16713407635688782,
0.10005669295787811,
0.16518695652484894,
-0.07868747413158417,
-0.4594492018222809,
0.15991811454296112,
0.6042782664299011,
-0.035770587623119354,
0.5779721140861511,
-0.06579176336526871,
-0.22129671275615692,
0.23911800980567932,
0.2857607901096344,
-0.3005591928958893,
-0.10932447016239166,
0.47384801506996155,
-0.6058375835418701,
-0.43514418601989746,
0.039689935743808746,
-0.3042912781238556,
-0.4549601078033447,
-0.8574236035346985,
0.16731378436088562,
-0.3350391983985901,
-0.24047093093395233,
0.3928101360797882,
-0.3837900757789612,
0.5219494104385376,
0.16185668110847473,
-0.7133783102035522,
-0.04491493105888367,
1.1095962524414062,
0.09797467291355133,
0.5694543123245239,
-0.394558846950531,
-0.5176659822463989,
0.366931676864624,
-0.6692583560943604,
0.4030037522315979,
-0.7759681940078735,
-0.1206325888633728,
-0.11499999463558197,
-0.3731287717819214,
0.18839389085769653,
-0.8157842755317688,
0.3908509612083435,
-0.7062431573867798,
-0.277962863445282,
0.299822598695755,
-0.40861812233924866,
-0.1773122251033783,
0.2904263138771057,
-0.5328167080879211,
0.565482497215271,
0.14866824448108673,
-0.2625449299812317,
0.7183367013931274,
-1.0618457794189453,
-0.9205502271652222,
0.3061316907405853,
-0.6461620330810547,
-0.2512422800064087,
0.1483006328344345,
0.10548361390829086,
0.12673786282539368,
-0.542180061340332,
0.6079860925674438,
-0.5209974050521851,
-0.18827618658542633,
0.1606423556804657,
-0.2622780203819275,
1.3016811609268188,
0.6353899836540222,
-0.7421157360076904,
0.07864923775196075,
-0.6685422658920288,
-0.019625697284936905,
0.05057552456855774,
-0.26448139548301697,
-0.28496772050857544,
0.3075300455093384,
-0.5583752393722534,
0.10933475196361542,
-0.16925640404224396,
-0.3310977816581726,
0.2561642527580261,
-0.61934894323349,
0.9382780194282532,
0.5721930265426636,
-0.320838987827301,
0.484870970249176,
-0.12571588158607483,
0.6279199719429016,
-0.14536848664283752,
0.15468014776706696,
0.06742631644010544,
-0.2731507420539856,
-0.4897123873233795,
-0.3921755254268646,
0.2926742434501648,
0.9608005285263062,
-0.620916485786438,
0.5114310383796692,
-0.1913742870092392,
-0.36571136116981506,
-0.7224265933036804,
0.2578887939453125,
-0.17754676938056946,
0.041715800762176514,
0.3466317057609558,
0.333684504032135,
-0.561935544013977,
-0.8026199340820312,
-0.6229314804077148,
-0.33385127782821655,
-0.029538745060563087,
0.3089006841182709,
0.5225436091423035,
-0.675991415977478,
1.162890911102295,
-0.3956429362297058,
-0.08806866407394409,
-0.4902423322200775,
0.5582716464996338,
0.2708475589752197,
0.3210345506668091,
0.7012430429458618,
-0.9661062955856323,
-0.3487170338630676,
-0.13615450263023376,
-1.0886629819869995,
-0.5090507864952087,
-0.6388838887214661,
0.01455321628600359,
0.07183582335710526,
0.7145065665245056,
-0.7744386792182922,
0.6191966533660889,
-0.18719886243343353,
-0.42867955565452576,
0.5685669779777527,
-0.3198982775211334,
0.193461075425148,
-0.5244039297103882,
-0.39135313034057617,
-0.2130528688430786,
-0.2713869512081146,
-0.40396255254745483,
0.6144121289253235,
-0.17670515179634094,
-0.24378788471221924,
-0.35166919231414795,
0.21940913796424866,
-0.7368923425674438,
-0.1833888441324234,
-0.7198869585990906,
0.10454591363668442,
-0.04086633399128914,
0.04126676917076111,
-0.19554752111434937,
0.7383104562759399,
0.6300989389419556,
-0.8025280833244324,
0.8378573656082153,
0.14490363001823425,
0.0009937614668160677,
0.48961949348449707,
-0.381106436252594,
-0.04875483736395836,
-0.3671899139881134,
0.004426477011293173,
-0.4224678874015808,
-0.14874133467674255,
0.12018394470214844,
-0.222305029630661,
0.09218092262744904,
-0.25967320799827576,
-0.5805200338363647,
-0.7813870906829834,
-0.34266433119773865,
0.3434399962425232,
0.7141304016113281,
-0.37460291385650635,
1.1402217149734497,
0.2344139814376831,
-0.08092878758907318,
-0.3735971450805664,
-0.9383638501167297,
0.39422863721847534,
-0.3539610207080841,
-0.6095658540725708,
0.4393236041069031,
0.09862213581800461,
-0.9053042531013489,
0.25474825501441956,
0.29144781827926636,
-0.39919009804725647,
0.6377027630805969,
0.283986359834671,
0.07147176563739777,
-0.2741323411464691,
0.03583668917417526,
0.32715776562690735,
-0.05230502039194107,
0.5969559550285339,
-0.3054329454898834,
0.3668079078197479,
0.052550651133060455,
-0.6944436430931091,
-0.3769170641899109,
0.19464513659477234,
0.8459694981575012,
-0.3371352553367615,
0.2532099783420563,
-0.10639341175556183,
-0.3248003125190735,
-0.2905319929122925,
-0.5016438961029053,
-0.05396728590130806,
-0.47352248430252075,
0.1273091733455658,
-0.6946502923965454,
-0.644021213054657,
0.045950789004564285,
-0.2135799378156662,
0.349592000246048,
0.6996079087257385,
0.5369817614555359,
-0.11599485576152802,
0.7526649236679077,
0.4582262933254242,
-0.21723441779613495,
0.2684093117713928,
-0.17796261608600616,
0.3485701084136963,
-0.2988818287849426,
0.271639883518219,
-0.5584408044815063,
-0.04641423374414444,
-0.6239114999771118,
-0.1355011761188507,
0.3200249969959259,
0.012654274702072144,
-0.44891875982284546,
0.43094462156295776,
-0.37046438455581665,
0.7709705233573914,
0.8618812561035156,
0.017647583037614822,
0.31867656111717224,
-0.36184030771255493,
-0.0015646114479750395,
0.33975163102149963,
-0.3538115620613098,
-0.674017071723938,
1.1183016300201416,
0.1423148214817047,
0.8906484842300415,
-0.06497706472873688,
0.9427145719528198,
0.6947476267814636,
0.235757514834404,
-0.5842722654342651,
0.7595025300979614,
-0.12158773094415665,
-0.6874597072601318,
-0.3076736330986023,
-0.4105353355407715,
-0.7205085158348083,
-0.09999056160449982,
-0.20443251729011536,
-0.20389597117900848,
-0.10982158035039902,
0.32396602630615234,
-0.4722178876399994,
0.140480175614357,
-0.36980023980140686,
0.7194429636001587,
-0.6467889547348022,
-0.12317508459091187,
-0.8683285713195801,
-0.5901458859443665,
0.30751609802246094,
-0.11500992625951767,
0.418495237827301,
0.05741294473409653,
0.41851454973220825,
0.33497390151023865,
-0.7603603005409241,
0.5919547080993652,
-0.3045561611652374,
-0.3271700143814087,
0.9035331606864929,
0.2938782572746277,
0.5130866169929504,
0.10311011970043182,
-0.11177562177181244,
-0.30678823590278625,
0.06831427663564682,
-0.1366419494152069,
-0.7586828470230103,
0.33087366819381714,
-0.3847731947898865,
-1.0478484630584717,
-0.23936322331428528,
-0.5877771973609924,
0.08820823580026627,
0.14912165701389313,
-0.10832846164703369,
0.0038388788234442472,
-0.09835238009691238,
-0.22311460971832275,
0.4631403982639313,
-0.33453911542892456,
0.31956636905670166,
0.6276891827583313,
-0.03937775269150734,
-0.2529895305633545,
0.8651100993156433,
0.004379949066787958,
-0.05309811234474182,
0.38312873244285583,
0.2843310832977295,
-0.11924824863672256,
-0.5721485018730164,
-0.5366202592849731,
0.16288259625434875,
-0.7138217687606812,
-0.10590828955173492,
-0.47120070457458496,
-0.26824140548706055,
-0.6618369221687317,
-0.43955081701278687,
-0.012192652560770512,
-0.45144814252853394,
-0.15304000675678253,
0.0430777408182621,
0.2076244056224823,
0.6396045684814453,
-0.053693465888500214,
-0.3216025233268738,
-0.8911764025688171,
0.7113728523254395,
0.4249906539916992,
0.030801262706518173,
-0.5698686838150024,
-0.39075931906700134,
0.35734236240386963,
0.23199613392353058,
-0.4015631675720215,
-0.8003374338150024,
-0.07807213068008423,
0.1407293826341629,
0.7768661975860596,
0.24956265091896057,
0.11770454794168472,
0.3502340018749237,
-0.6052486300468445,
0.45727482438087463,
-0.2469208985567093,
-0.9287974238395691,
0.9757583737373352,
-0.05294680595397949,
-0.13019654154777527,
0.4713076651096344,
0.18897783756256104,
-0.0786198154091835,
-0.7121157050132751,
-0.4221917688846588,
-0.3982686400413513,
0.24384894967079163,
0.10982351005077362,
0.262093186378479,
0.10803212970495224,
0.7471907734870911,
0.01311840396374464,
0.2531936466693878,
-0.7656876444816589,
0.20460939407348633,
-0.058737218379974365,
-0.5672335624694824,
0.4484438896179199,
-0.12710586190223694,
-0.01450534351170063,
-0.440244197845459,
0.6660232543945312,
-0.1934664100408554,
0.010411230847239494,
0.03362260386347771,
-0.5371529459953308,
0.3579850196838379,
0.6104092597961426,
0.7566648721694946,
0.7506152391433716,
0.12545765936374664,
0.17711995542049408,
0.16951382160186768,
-0.3906072974205017,
0.4956558346748352,
0.4787980020046234,
-0.597260594367981,
-0.17425110936164856,
0.28119468688964844,
0.36029088497161865,
-0.5197023153305054,
-0.8475737571716309,
0.2538406252861023,
0.4792669713497162,
-0.6404029130935669,
-0.6362519264221191,
0.2616060674190521,
-0.08534201234579086,
0.5022464990615845,
0.2478727400302887,
-0.29048746824264526,
0.4247870445251465,
-0.8004312515258789,
0.23560813069343567,
0.7137843370437622,
0.06663278490304947,
0.08301673829555511,
1.0283257961273193,
0.33725887537002563,
-0.2551359534263611,
0.7701900005340576,
-0.18501774966716766,
-0.6073166728019714,
0.9577258825302124,
0.41808071732521057,
1.2154479026794434,
0.22372713685035706,
0.017908355221152306,
-0.06606333702802658,
0.632591962814331,
-0.015155603177845478,
0.44273972511291504,
-0.27080437541007996,
-0.43947896361351013,
-0.6215746998786926,
-0.2596816420555115,
-0.236437126994133,
0.0040810019709169865,
0.0842258483171463,
0.4996491074562073,
-0.4765773415565491,
0.0434776209294796,
0.043603576719760895,
-0.5401352047920227,
-0.2988336980342865,
0.19031493365764618,
0.3242059350013733,
0.8175673484802246,
-0.722190260887146,
0.5523234605789185,
0.7118945717811584,
-0.6363452076911926,
-0.4232315123081207,
0.13427932560443878,
0.049347344785928726,
-0.6565952897071838,
1.08307945728302,
0.0697731003165245,
-0.2826758921146393,
-0.13859370350837708,
-0.7598050832748413,
-0.30348196625709534,
0.8852081298828125,
0.5901789665222168,
-0.48501548171043396,
0.0011422738898545504,
0.8671802282333374,
0.49598655104637146,
-0.15639877319335938,
0.309951514005661,
0.7505068182945251,
0.49021115899086,
-0.11639147996902466,
-0.7886298894882202,
0.00025717317475937307,
-0.19258345663547516,
-0.21102210879325867,
0.319379597902298,
-0.06681843101978302,
0.4828440546989441,
-0.4458390176296234,
0.040198374539613724,
-0.2446223497390747,
0.625613808631897,
0.20556573569774628,
0.5159372091293335,
0.6373558640480042,
0.7889460325241089,
0.6311585903167725,
0.012706121429800987,
0.8684574365615845,
-0.5775095224380493,
0.08984280377626419,
1.0490056276321411,
-0.7404291033744812,
0.2904866635799408,
0.24787774682044983,
-0.160167396068573,
0.7658254504203796,
0.3028337359428406,
-0.4216670095920563,
0.22359487414360046,
0.742190420627594,
-0.2074451893568039,
-0.4394295811653137,
0.17508238554000854,
-0.052750758826732635,
0.4220278859138489,
0.050595350563526154,
-0.5622590780258179,
-0.10493328422307968,
0.39027005434036255,
-0.1540897637605667,
0.2597464621067047,
-0.3028739094734192,
0.9581799507141113,
0.016907894983887672,
-0.7257570028305054,
0.46247419714927673,
0.2583446502685547,
0.3032837510108948,
-0.06227157637476921,
-0.3058309853076935,
0.026363134384155273,
0.24373845756053925,
-0.2718139886856079,
-0.9662248492240906,
0.7375620603561401,
0.24567118287086487,
-0.07089606672525406,
-0.30168166756629944,
0.7637761831283569,
0.0970330685377121,
-0.4617702066898346,
0.09824158251285553,
0.06510529667139053,
0.22620347142219543,
-0.23776134848594666,
-0.9352971315383911,
-0.5463999509811401,
-0.2681920826435089,
-0.049631986767053604,
-0.27331021428108215,
0.45476287603378296,
-0.25914695858955383,
0.9944308996200562,
0.35764235258102417,
0.01372914295643568,
0.13403093814849854,
0.17674097418785095,
0.9057612419128418,
-0.9062480926513672,
-0.45328840613365173,
-1.3200604915618896,
0.26165738701820374,
0.07544238120317459,
0.3078675866127014,
0.3351289629936218,
0.6952358484268188,
0.5722023248672485,
-0.007750326301902533,
0.9632887840270996,
-0.2577301263809204,
0.2705320417881012,
-0.772329568862915,
0.38733944296836853,
-0.4938628673553467,
0.30430102348327637,
-0.23697566986083984,
-0.7613189220428467,
-0.38466864824295044,
0.518785834312439,
-0.41706305742263794,
-0.10764523595571518,
0.43534064292907715,
0.7610070705413818,
-0.15857233107089996,
-0.015059659257531166,
0.11864721775054932,
0.1312982141971588,
0.46292591094970703,
0.6209754943847656,
0.8856215476989746,
-0.1575007289648056,
0.5058540105819702,
0.17340967059135437,
-0.29870155453681946,
-0.07337421178817749,
-0.7459331154823303,
-0.8885404467582703,
-0.1542799174785614,
-0.48424267768859863,
-0.35629183053970337,
-0.08572486788034439,
1.0510308742523193,
0.2806888520717621,
-0.6558495163917542,
-0.16368167102336884,
-0.7943363189697266,
0.17101246118545532,
-0.20264795422554016,
-0.25364604592323303,
-0.08313540369272232,
-0.6817995309829712,
-0.30687999725341797,
0.543971836566925,
0.3948284983634949,
0.0776577740907669,
-0.45670294761657715,
-0.18721362948417664,
-0.20161208510398865,
0.361939936876297,
0.5243523716926575,
0.29952913522720337,
-0.7246729135513306,
0.06060481071472168,
-0.3363734185695648,
-0.17168493568897247,
0.06954497843980789,
1.0172584056854248,
-0.6989900469779968,
0.15959206223487854,
0.7400273680686951,
0.9065223932266235,
0.22222664952278137,
-0.0018277571070939302,
0.8109048008918762,
0.13006539642810822,
0.2540819048881531,
0.4931527078151703,
0.4448389410972595,
-0.2848893404006958,
-0.40216532349586487,
0.7101945281028748,
0.21261481940746307,
-0.5827052593231201,
-0.7239049077033997,
0.606878399848938,
-0.27092376351356506,
-0.5684106349945068,
0.8850070834159851,
0.014228698797523975,
-0.22777727246284485,
-0.3662494719028473,
-0.16522595286369324,
0.0925247073173523,
0.34438422322273254,
0.8892723321914673,
0.5008087158203125,
-0.12130779027938843,
-0.24704313278198242,
-0.6927348375320435,
0.5404759049415588,
0.5830118656158447,
-1.2975764274597168,
0.11831887066364288,
0.6851605772972107,
0.1499774008989334,
0.18678264319896698,
0.5905172824859619,
-0.0993042141199112,
0.42751017212867737,
0.030103296041488647,
0.009825823828577995,
-0.09231908619403839,
-0.3835943043231964,
-0.14393064379692078,
-0.16506174206733704,
0.399922251701355,
-0.01861332356929779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09841v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09841v2
|
Anatomy of Industrial Scale Multilingual ASR
| 2024-04-15T14:48:43 | 2024-04-16T14:55:13 |
Francis McCann Ramirez, Luka Chkhetiani, Andrew Ehrenberg, Robert McHardy, Rami Botros, Yash Khare, Andrea Vanzo, Taufiquzzaman Peyash, Gabriel Oexle, Michael Liang, Ilya Sklyar, Enver Fakhan, Ahmed Etefy, Daniel McCrystal, Sam Flamini, Domenic Donato, Takuya Yoshioka
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
This paper describes AssemblyAI's industrial-scale automatic speech
recognition (ASR) system, designed to meet the requirements of large-scale,
multilingual ASR serving various application needs. Our system leverages a
diverse training dataset comprising unsupervised (12.5M hours), supervised
(188k hours), and pseudo-labeled (1.6M hours) data across four languages. We
provide a detailed description of our model architecture, consisting of a
full-context 600M-parameter Conformer encoder pre-trained with BEST-RQ and an
RNN-T decoder fine-tuned jointly with the encoder. Our extensive evaluation
demonstrates competitive word error rates (WERs) against larger and more
computationally expensive models, such as Whisper large and Canary-1B.
Furthermore, our architectural choices yield several key advantages, including
an improved code-switching capability, a 5x inference speedup compared to an
optimized Whisper baseline, a 30% reduction in hallucination rate on speech
data, and a 90% reduction in ambient noise compared to Whisper, along with
significantly improved time-stamp accuracy. Throughout this work, we adopt a
system-centric approach to analyzing various aspects of fully-fledged ASR
models to gain practically relevant insights useful for real-world services
operating at scale.
|
[
-0.21101325750350952,
-0.23115336894989014,
-0.09465271234512329,
0.5091778635978699,
-0.1148371621966362,
-0.027389388531446457,
-0.16917508840560913,
-0.8538350462913513,
0.046378105878829956,
0.3582152724266052,
-0.08844054490327835,
-0.16723713278770447,
-0.6370659470558167,
0.2832343578338623,
-0.6051750183105469,
0.42943912744522095,
0.025084519758820534,
0.24446424841880798,
0.1476285308599472,
-0.37652939558029175,
-0.13395404815673828,
-0.8267561793327332,
-0.9748502969741821,
-0.31868377327919006,
0.5421234369277954,
0.3694893717765808,
0.3520219027996063,
0.985421359539032,
0.3678298890590668,
0.3309189975261688,
-0.1764570027589798,
-0.02841421216726303,
0.020690785720944405,
-0.15425913035869598,
0.3654044270515442,
-0.013749542646110058,
-0.7247656583786011,
-0.22557489573955536,
0.785314679145813,
0.7525567412376404,
-0.42617329955101013,
0.38247421383857727,
-0.08635164052248001,
0.3599621653556824,
-0.5459350943565369,
0.4216752350330353,
-0.48928719758987427,
0.14973340928554535,
-0.35175246000289917,
0.07927750051021576,
-0.3319825232028961,
0.11504939198493958,
0.19795948266983032,
-0.37196415662765503,
0.03056226298213005,
0.009703310206532478,
0.6785852909088135,
0.3063272535800934,
-0.5106590390205383,
-0.26876142621040344,
-0.9416658878326416,
0.46867793798446655,
-0.6775879263877869,
0.7593450546264648,
0.2591490149497986,
0.5782349705696106,
0.36080214381217957,
-0.8133305311203003,
-0.42325258255004883,
-0.016714317724108696,
0.14845408499240875,
0.080378957092762,
-0.21743787825107574,
0.11397533863782883,
0.15657326579093933,
0.5032253861427307,
-0.7573485970497131,
0.3441406190395355,
-0.832963228225708,
-0.35610997676849365,
0.7629468441009521,
-0.0733967199921608,
0.23022952675819397,
0.24408993124961853,
-0.1522166132926941,
-0.12083549797534943,
-0.5054770112037659,
0.021733498200774193,
0.33921703696250916,
0.5302720665931702,
-0.1678404062986374,
0.42326444387435913,
-0.36363381147384644,
0.8364497423171997,
-0.15537630021572113,
-0.10101597011089325,
0.474209189414978,
0.009360778145492077,
-0.15607675909996033,
0.6404472589492798,
1.1063367128372192,
0.07467200607061386,
0.15537019073963165,
-0.24096623063087463,
-0.5178991556167603,
0.3654886484146118,
0.3131604492664337,
-0.8220452666282654,
-0.14689217507839203,
0.21321171522140503,
-0.5570448637008667,
0.1305268108844757,
-0.16521935164928436,
-0.33612504601478577,
-0.2145942747592926,
-0.5260799527168274,
0.5971487760543823,
-0.274319589138031,
-0.3662850260734558,
0.33169686794281006,
-0.09317808598279953,
0.3751266300678253,
-0.01566764898598194,
-0.6022083759307861,
0.19812287390232086,
0.589319109916687,
0.899711012840271,
-0.022910865023732185,
-0.3061785399913788,
-0.5876371264457703,
0.21847528219223022,
-0.2757135033607483,
0.8685253262519836,
-0.39852792024612427,
-0.45446643233299255,
-0.13508854806423187,
-0.01771741546690464,
-0.1378992199897766,
-0.8199002742767334,
0.5056754946708679,
-0.5745012164115906,
-0.1669190675020218,
0.12487857788801193,
-0.2859489917755127,
-0.12798219919204712,
0.2169797420501709,
-0.6684613823890686,
0.46352407336235046,
-0.5983173847198486,
-0.30116504430770874,
0.24624547362327576,
-0.8488704562187195,
-0.7729381918907166,
-0.02700992301106453,
-0.0824732854962349,
-0.2803226113319397,
-0.041526034474372864,
0.06118497624993324,
0.3751688003540039,
-0.23098890483379364,
0.08800723403692245,
0.06728238612413406,
-0.12177472561597824,
0.24364899098873138,
-0.7120039463043213,
0.6953949928283691,
0.6320627331733704,
-0.19946199655532837,
0.23290514945983887,
-1.2434555292129517,
-0.10678093135356903,
-0.326846718788147,
-0.39343100786209106,
-0.024150673300027847,
0.0270471703261137,
0.4283919632434845,
0.15202683210372925,
0.4585883915424347,
-0.9615932106971741,
-0.2865777611732483,
-0.4291371703147888,
0.6103483438491821,
0.3718748986721039,
-0.2671409249305725,
0.2477070391178131,
-0.17653757333755493,
0.44351282715797424,
0.0316450409591198,
0.31783369183540344,
-0.1355813592672348,
-0.3107551634311676,
-0.7789470553398132,
-0.4573094844818115,
0.24437016248703003,
0.5628538727760315,
-0.5172111988067627,
0.3027920722961426,
-0.3464234173297882,
-0.5130062103271484,
-0.7590745091438293,
-0.19588012993335724,
0.7397568821907043,
0.3508095145225525,
0.34122124314308167,
-0.4189883768558502,
-0.7658677101135254,
-0.9503276348114014,
-0.11498750001192093,
-0.25738415122032166,
-0.35384994745254517,
0.05057109147310257,
0.005784677341580391,
-0.5119669437408447,
0.7104235887527466,
-0.3035195469856262,
-0.4416830241680145,
-0.23687076568603516,
0.3711302876472473,
0.1670556366443634,
0.3336913287639618,
0.07243247330188751,
-0.932499349117279,
-0.43772926926612854,
0.3546094298362732,
-0.6587656736373901,
-0.17276747524738312,
0.14871224761009216,
0.28135812282562256,
0.2845800817012787,
0.6808017492294312,
-0.40565431118011475,
0.31375765800476074,
0.6627224087715149,
-0.007065823767334223,
0.5693323612213135,
-0.3265974819660187,
0.0017052331240847707,
-1.1732895374298096,
0.22731627523899078,
0.09154189378023148,
0.05316046625375748,
-0.9626262187957764,
-0.07342778146266937,
0.04888639599084854,
-0.38194817304611206,
-0.4200785458087921,
0.26939713954925537,
-0.756001889705658,
-0.4436229467391968,
-0.3093807101249695,
-0.059182118624448776,
-0.046247128397226334,
0.40374600887298584,
0.2137869894504547,
1.0478739738464355,
0.3717709481716156,
-0.8117246031761169,
0.39630842208862305,
0.30927321314811707,
-0.2940295338630676,
0.44967886805534363,
-0.9044221043586731,
0.13273069262504578,
0.0002190356608480215,
0.16176819801330566,
-0.7841783165931702,
-0.21334102749824524,
-0.23881195485591888,
-0.6113888025283813,
0.2695792317390442,
-0.11648032069206238,
-0.5976050496101379,
-0.36127781867980957,
0.23163217306137085,
0.4524206519126892,
0.3510625958442688,
-0.5136880874633789,
0.8354281187057495,
0.9855238199234009,
-0.3389536440372467,
-0.2601314187049866,
-0.7571397423744202,
0.11831089854240417,
-0.19285538792610168,
-0.40332210063934326,
0.0468536876142025,
0.14045658707618713,
-0.2118125855922699,
-0.5632200837135315,
-0.3094230890274048,
-0.5021493434906006,
-0.2045970857143402,
0.16260506212711334,
0.02549331821501255,
-0.5141679048538208,
-0.047363970428705215,
-0.2711266279220581,
-0.29682403802871704,
0.22076034545898438,
-0.3885813057422638,
0.4543798863887787,
-0.1468907594680786,
-0.35775771737098694,
-0.8137558698654175,
0.437278151512146,
0.8187165260314941,
-0.5659186244010925,
0.4473273754119873,
0.5223480463027954,
-0.5408165454864502,
0.19028833508491516,
-0.5458754897117615,
0.17138317227363586,
-0.46761998534202576,
0.4430113732814789,
-0.5632979869842529,
-0.6492950916290283,
0.7715984582901001,
0.2159000188112259,
0.22736892104148865,
0.40554213523864746,
0.368181049823761,
0.11154474318027496,
1.0224134922027588,
0.5367500185966492,
-0.39746469259262085,
0.4408043920993805,
-0.17129771411418915,
0.2655062973499298,
-0.9972957372665405,
-0.2763010263442993,
-0.6834931969642639,
-0.22630847990512848,
-0.44604992866516113,
-0.3877790868282318,
0.5663638114929199,
-0.3891732096672058,
-0.4660647213459015,
0.3535837233066559,
-0.6020650863647461,
0.19554656744003296,
0.34619778394699097,
-0.07446762174367905,
0.2771551311016083,
-0.19040949642658234,
0.37649911642074585,
0.2912687063217163,
-0.7555978298187256,
-0.5214270949363708,
0.8924570083618164,
0.4843701422214508,
0.8701645731925964,
0.19791197776794434,
0.2714320123195648,
0.08726038038730621,
0.04186604544520378,
-0.9026798009872437,
0.33711689710617065,
-0.6608866453170776,
-0.6011132001876831,
-0.5794260501861572,
-0.42628777027130127,
-0.9394746422767639,
0.4065793752670288,
0.2635203003883362,
-0.4706411063671112,
0.40380343794822693,
0.37905505299568176,
-0.5740441679954529,
0.25585806369781494,
-0.9437569975852966,
0.8120934367179871,
-0.4216793179512024,
0.31868553161621094,
-0.11264541745185852,
-0.884843111038208,
-0.12455210834741592,
-0.031651780009269714,
0.28190165758132935,
0.08495011180639267,
0.07104577869176865,
0.9175083041191101,
-0.19136929512023926,
0.812137246131897,
-0.2808344066143036,
-0.18780820071697235,
0.12097936123609543,
-0.3925919532775879,
0.12776821851730347,
-0.43244048953056335,
-0.29412391781806946,
0.5651047229766846,
0.0824686586856842,
-0.0764455571770668,
-0.2929193675518036,
0.25472670793533325,
-1.0226541757583618,
-0.004511053673923016,
-0.40787434577941895,
-0.600073516368866,
-0.3889235258102417,
0.25013646483421326,
0.3282877802848816,
1.059432029724121,
-0.22766965627670288,
0.48098111152648926,
0.8378257751464844,
-0.2585359811782837,
0.3214372992515564,
0.7173117995262146,
-0.026786355301737785,
-0.4449714720249176,
1.0452814102172852,
0.5137885808944702,
0.26845207810401917,
0.579962432384491,
0.1446298211812973,
-0.4765908122062683,
-0.5313371419906616,
-0.7013727426528931,
-0.044817157089710236,
-0.3961245119571686,
-0.24993495643138885,
-1.0384268760681152,
-0.6595523953437805,
-0.570893406867981,
0.09326836466789246,
-0.8111642599105835,
-0.33769387006759644,
-0.4175143837928772,
0.12001623213291168,
0.40373754501342773,
0.6867004036903381,
-0.03861905261874199,
0.6696211099624634,
-0.8428247570991516,
0.6071545481681824,
0.22899720072746277,
0.47174522280693054,
0.10012256354093552,
-0.8893482685089111,
-0.4542836546897888,
0.11104851216077805,
0.017916806042194366,
-0.2804805040359497,
0.5252447724342346,
0.6746963858604431,
0.47377192974090576,
0.6139414310455322,
0.13717731833457947,
0.97390216588974,
-0.9583834409713745,
0.5974317789077759,
0.11543424427509308,
-0.7496600151062012,
0.2419532686471939,
-0.31248489022254944,
0.6175031661987305,
0.30238303542137146,
0.11555487662553787,
-0.7172877788543701,
-0.2322283238172531,
-0.2922544777393341,
-1.1751195192337036,
0.7294449210166931,
-0.20942796766757965,
0.049933552742004395,
0.30157384276390076,
0.29925423860549927,
0.005950224120169878,
0.18696780502796173,
-0.38892310857772827,
-0.22366692125797272,
-0.2750968039035797,
-0.42894360423088074,
-0.30456817150115967,
-0.24495969712734222,
-0.16825324296951294,
-0.06716868281364441,
0.654532790184021,
-0.07694023847579956,
0.3716273009777069,
-0.03632987290620804,
-0.2253485471010208,
0.16771887242794037,
0.34373393654823303,
0.6614048480987549,
0.457830548286438,
-0.08888499438762665,
0.014511452987790108,
0.1530657410621643,
-0.5795425176620483,
0.15695315599441528,
0.5800171494483948,
0.29172059893608093,
-0.03618983179330826,
0.28355666995048523,
0.996745765209198,
0.18061871826648712,
-0.6524204611778259,
0.3147626221179962,
-0.14977523684501648,
-0.09620732069015503,
-0.8213976621627808,
-0.19956745207309723,
-0.020601563155651093,
0.3282056450843811,
0.5468121767044067,
-0.053572990000247955,
0.6450924873352051,
-0.5221370458602905,
0.2988014817237854,
0.19755637645721436,
-0.428915411233902,
-0.5003604888916016,
0.7720589637756348,
0.31363728642463684,
-0.5051700472831726,
0.5346875786781311,
0.0646774172782898,
-0.5294801592826843,
0.637421190738678,
0.4856235086917877,
0.9961939454078674,
-0.5967258214950562,
-0.12065906077623367,
0.22867421805858612,
0.37225547432899475,
-0.24180905520915985,
0.15384770929813385,
-0.012115837074816227,
-0.7203902006149292,
-0.309312641620636,
-0.8343080282211304,
-0.527283787727356,
0.1461307257413864,
-1.1005580425262451,
0.02055167220532894,
-0.4365561604499817,
-0.04633776471018791,
0.12969866394996643,
-0.3883313238620758,
-0.26081857085227966,
0.5103381872177124,
0.30180397629737854,
0.9079490303993225,
-0.740817666053772,
0.8844622373580933,
0.9251817464828491,
-0.16684359312057495,
-0.9050114750862122,
-0.01424130517989397,
0.06789644062519073,
-0.7610709071159363,
0.4964374601840973,
0.39367079734802246,
-0.5524754524230957,
0.04986042529344559,
-0.0953998863697052,
-0.9026300311088562,
1.065582513809204,
0.21505816280841827,
-0.7454947829246521,
0.09755609184503555,
0.2623538672924042,
0.8333723545074463,
-0.36738306283950806,
-0.14040352404117584,
0.6722458600997925,
0.08348160237073898,
0.33213624358177185,
-1.4235445261001587,
-0.44368019700050354,
-0.4024185836315155,
0.1960633248090744,
0.07436080276966095,
-0.7507101893424988,
0.6466224789619446,
0.1740676462650299,
-0.20421011745929718,
-0.01963898167014122,
0.7751749157905579,
0.1671338528394699,
0.38884976506233215,
0.6228341460227966,
0.377217173576355,
0.45370426774024963,
0.06786377727985382,
0.7330783009529114,
-0.3888109624385834,
-0.29209721088409424,
1.1746950149536133,
-0.5042914152145386,
1.1939058303833008,
0.29352349042892456,
-0.013747375458478928,
0.14735792577266693,
0.553928017616272,
0.3294045031070709,
0.39825743436813354,
-0.05990466848015785,
-0.3371305465698242,
0.02053035981953144,
-0.2175500988960266,
-0.37035688757896423,
0.9225737452507019,
0.3376657962799072,
0.028960460796952248,
0.1759113222360611,
0.40001004934310913,
-0.27894890308380127,
-0.05831855162978172,
-0.40751320123672485,
1.1491353511810303,
0.1818670779466629,
-0.10377492755651474,
0.4609507620334625,
-0.10251262784004211,
0.8324156999588013,
-0.7867794632911682,
0.2231292873620987,
0.06400571018457413,
0.4978328049182892,
-0.11458119750022888,
-0.4367835521697998,
0.6215885877609253,
0.27707499265670776,
-0.3698733448982239,
-0.44892972707748413,
0.38254114985466003,
-0.5311097502708435,
-0.5617119073867798,
0.25841522216796875,
-0.004585732705891132,
0.35376209020614624,
-0.13049905002117157,
-0.4011494815349579,
0.5214899778366089,
-0.19552937150001526,
-0.012616355903446674,
0.21102941036224365,
0.672857940196991,
-0.1115177795290947,
0.7366983294487,
0.5131590962409973,
0.26765692234039307,
0.1795557141304016,
0.2611490786075592,
0.6599449515342712,
-0.39153003692626953,
-0.7181775569915771,
-0.3261153995990753,
0.6582693457603455,
0.08212003111839294,
-0.16095809638500214,
0.6054080724716187,
0.7853786945343018,
0.803600549697876,
-0.008791947737336159,
0.7329534292221069,
0.01348415482789278,
0.6075231432914734,
-0.34027808904647827,
0.9701610803604126,
-0.6192881464958191,
0.21846695244312286,
-0.05505629628896713,
-0.45953428745269775,
-0.4964890778064728,
0.8614208102226257,
-0.14353926479816437,
-0.13070803880691528,
0.21140843629837036,
0.8925005197525024,
-0.0314275398850441,
0.05507659167051315,
0.38365739583969116,
0.3383350670337677,
0.3123248517513275,
0.09689176082611084,
0.6009328365325928,
-0.6031872630119324,
0.7411137819290161,
0.07295671105384827,
-0.3220592439174652,
-0.08644147217273712,
-0.48197612166404724,
-0.38498345017433167,
-0.6749247312545776,
-0.3818742334842682,
0.037237752228975296,
-0.009388837963342667,
0.9500231146812439,
0.7944774627685547,
-1.0118026733398438,
-0.9142165184020996,
0.3703952133655548,
-0.5486398935317993,
-0.26443612575531006,
-0.11333416402339935,
0.06772126257419586,
-0.09407894313335419,
-0.5325649380683899,
0.5471315979957581,
0.3375810384750366,
-0.1150815337896347,
-0.12957660853862762,
-0.09970864653587341,
-0.2555995285511017,
0.009501502849161625,
0.7648439407348633,
0.5160311460494995,
-0.578641951084137,
-0.25380802154541016,
-0.12676995992660522,
0.05234992131590843,
0.11245863139629364,
0.5797657370567322,
-0.36832234263420105,
0.6776518225669861,
0.24208417534828186,
0.7346205115318298,
0.2673635184764862,
-0.10724548250436783,
0.8118093609809875,
-0.8183039426803589,
0.47399258613586426,
0.18480977416038513,
0.3254553973674774,
0.5016857385635376,
-0.250039279460907,
0.28806349635124207,
-0.06971923261880875,
-0.6463637351989746,
-0.9087314605712891,
0.19118160009384155,
-0.7480967044830322,
0.1134379655122757,
1.0993746519088745,
-0.15012624859809875,
-0.12147807329893112,
-0.2618553340435028,
-0.11063887178897858,
0.509674608707428,
-0.42573481798171997,
0.7691137194633484,
0.41751667857170105,
-0.31190603971481323,
-0.2035626471042633,
-0.4326496422290802,
0.1786125749349594,
-0.19530226290225983,
-0.7428736686706543,
0.1519259661436081,
0.7164793014526367,
0.1896042823791504,
0.4758265018463135,
0.7511209845542908,
-0.2708398401737213,
0.19496463239192963,
0.15563204884529114,
0.541178286075592,
0.061207365244627,
-0.5666717290878296,
-0.7758646011352539,
0.14763730764389038,
0.23966509103775024,
-0.7111716866493225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09830v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09830v1
|
Negation Triplet Extraction with Syntactic Dependency and Semantic Consistency
| 2024-04-15T14:28:33 | 2024-04-15T14:28:33 |
Yuchen Shi, Deqing Yang, Jingping Liu, Yanghua Xiao, Zongyu Wang, Huimin Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Previous works of negation understanding mainly focus on negation cue
detection and scope resolution, without identifying negation subject which is
also significant to the downstream tasks. In this paper, we propose a new
negation triplet extraction (NTE) task which aims to extract negation subject
along with negation cue and scope. To achieve NTE, we devise a novel
Syntax&Semantic-Enhanced Negation Extraction model, namely SSENE, which is
built based on a generative pretrained language model (PLM) {of Encoder-Decoder
architecture} with a multi-task learning framework. Specifically, the given
sentence's syntactic dependency tree is incorporated into the PLM's encoder to
discover the correlations between the negation subject, cue and scope.
Moreover, the semantic consistency between the sentence and the extracted
triplet is ensured by an auxiliary task learning. Furthermore, we have
constructed a high-quality Chinese dataset NegComment based on the users'
reviews from the real-world platform of Meituan, upon which our evaluations
show that SSENE achieves the best NTE performance compared to the baselines.
Our ablation and case studies also demonstrate that incorporating the syntactic
information helps the PLM's recognize the distant dependency between the
subject and cue, and the auxiliary task learning is helpful to extract the
negation triplets with more semantic consistency.
|
[
-0.2703373432159424,
-0.7669554352760315,
0.3769971430301666,
0.16708159446716309,
-0.21799148619174957,
-0.2801702916622162,
-0.32543548941612244,
-0.43683570623397827,
0.2922229766845703,
0.8249335289001465,
-0.4859832227230072,
-0.5908937454223633,
-0.6268805265426636,
0.24009689688682556,
-0.23437237739562988,
0.8882097601890564,
0.030617836862802505,
-0.04575691744685173,
0.19077223539352417,
0.15717726945877075,
-0.8175790309906006,
-0.15196985006332397,
-0.6508938670158386,
0.018343355506658554,
0.24673733115196228,
0.613649845123291,
0.21152891218662262,
0.3812665641307831,
0.19479966163635254,
0.2561219036579132,
0.15870057046413422,
0.1807153820991516,
-0.09158071130514145,
-0.05023590847849846,
-0.24003754556179047,
-0.3176579773426056,
-0.588246762752533,
-0.0687413215637207,
0.6887420415878296,
0.27443844079971313,
-0.0004040561616420746,
0.03224238008260727,
0.31048280000686646,
0.642947256565094,
-0.5485981106758118,
0.42843562364578247,
-0.6899498701095581,
-0.12653619050979614,
-0.2315445989370346,
0.08743762224912643,
-0.3461901545524597,
-0.3017541766166687,
0.23361191153526306,
-0.6910561323165894,
0.13180023431777954,
-0.3207356631755829,
1.424729585647583,
0.2867657542228699,
-0.742117702960968,
0.3311636745929718,
-0.3312056064605713,
0.6153193116188049,
-0.841411292552948,
0.45291802287101746,
0.32657670974731445,
0.2707936465740204,
0.11511465907096863,
-0.36778226494789124,
-0.6772967576980591,
-0.39800673723220825,
-0.08085384219884872,
0.18590286374092102,
0.15654133260250092,
0.06230597943067551,
0.12577319145202637,
0.38431501388549805,
-0.4273059666156769,
0.12191150337457657,
-0.15979047119617462,
-0.2893467843532562,
0.26985955238342285,
-0.18420033156871796,
0.5614936947822571,
-0.7310827374458313,
-0.42495566606521606,
0.2475637048482895,
-0.6600098609924316,
-0.36880892515182495,
0.26286906003952026,
0.3615993559360504,
-0.025452090427279472,
0.481993168592453,
-0.17372772097587585,
0.7910937666893005,
0.25446709990501404,
0.1765073835849762,
0.5233485102653503,
-0.6221339106559753,
-0.09985271096229553,
-0.053321562707424164,
0.7950119972229004,
0.1908222883939743,
0.1642550230026245,
-0.25689271092414856,
0.014474024996161461,
0.10466116666793823,
0.2706109285354614,
-0.5520614981651306,
-0.18499988317489624,
-0.0859525129199028,
-0.252302348613739,
-0.06932094693183899,
0.1690984070301056,
-0.6761911511421204,
-0.1730736941099167,
-0.5304579138755798,
0.4924565255641937,
-0.7496242523193359,
-0.6586834788322449,
0.046069808304309845,
-0.16797690093517303,
0.4421895742416382,
0.12532559037208557,
-0.8659220933914185,
0.3474882245063782,
0.6514851450920105,
0.6826403141021729,
-0.2636331617832184,
-0.3135981857776642,
-0.7826604247093201,
0.2976028323173523,
-0.06432969123125076,
0.4928300380706787,
-0.10060768574476242,
0.27420079708099365,
-0.5036445260047913,
0.3051479756832123,
-0.19719527661800385,
-0.3976251780986786,
0.21608182787895203,
-0.4536053240299225,
0.19679249823093414,
-0.0014578760601580143,
-0.47284600138664246,
-0.6731082201004028,
0.3880736827850342,
-0.9199591279029846,
0.8302746415138245,
0.019065488129854202,
-0.4891612231731415,
0.4311254024505615,
-0.7226208448410034,
-0.4907691776752472,
0.2529052495956421,
-0.2106809914112091,
-0.012077385559678078,
0.015331204980611801,
0.2780025601387024,
0.5208297371864319,
-0.19166846573352814,
0.494762659072876,
-0.09480935335159302,
-0.07906977832317352,
-0.4718654155731201,
-0.32274141907691956,
0.9152973890304565,
-0.4213705062866211,
-0.546710729598999,
0.24760013818740845,
-0.7626123428344727,
-0.11571215838193893,
-0.03038792870938778,
-0.048739418387413025,
-0.18570956587791443,
-0.14914406836032867,
-0.12933439016342163,
0.2893638610839844,
0.4477401673793793,
-0.8847194910049438,
-0.27210354804992676,
-0.7500744462013245,
0.40209028124809265,
0.7868985533714294,
0.17979025840759277,
0.3177913725376129,
0.07293347269296646,
0.24501140415668488,
-0.17671164870262146,
-0.19454020261764526,
0.1240619495511055,
-0.23447349667549133,
-0.6867459416389465,
-0.06527788937091827,
0.3274065852165222,
0.6629413962364197,
-0.9981276392936707,
0.6421444416046143,
-0.3934521973133087,
-0.06856542825698853,
-0.13625460863113403,
0.1757633090019226,
0.411868691444397,
0.5258978009223938,
0.4743758738040924,
-0.053361598402261734,
-0.689745306968689,
-0.9948034286499023,
-0.16053131222724915,
0.048800982534885406,
0.1862485557794571,
0.09833274781703949,
0.5715669393539429,
0.1237332671880722,
0.7453498840332031,
-0.5435339212417603,
-0.33879193663597107,
-0.47571632266044617,
0.20125511288642883,
0.24512620270252228,
0.6310943961143494,
0.19388346374034882,
-0.9083365797996521,
-0.7060420513153076,
0.154598668217659,
-0.7579159140586853,
-0.009776754304766655,
0.063324935734272,
-0.4405595064163208,
0.23930314183235168,
0.4235773980617523,
-0.3727462887763977,
0.4037533104419708,
0.3032766580581665,
-0.14024077355861664,
0.8670955300331116,
0.12911249697208405,
-0.12052065134048462,
-1.1592445373535156,
-0.04329116269946098,
0.06881829351186752,
-0.23004387319087982,
-0.6296941041946411,
0.12529794871807098,
0.4425233006477356,
0.30697375535964966,
-0.5714369416236877,
0.3786401152610779,
-0.6256163716316223,
0.034215331077575684,
-0.40370526909828186,
0.3073999285697937,
0.2546403110027313,
0.7545491456985474,
0.46001169085502625,
0.32121333479881287,
0.5929655432701111,
-0.6918238997459412,
0.31573402881622314,
0.21084770560264587,
0.019086355343461037,
0.5647804141044617,
-0.4970431327819824,
0.05225137993693352,
-0.060644056648015976,
-0.04842446371912956,
-0.40773552656173706,
-0.1229986697435379,
0.3469301164150238,
-0.26841482520103455,
0.39383018016815186,
-0.1913832277059555,
-0.6773177981376648,
-0.2143852263689041,
-0.15439532697200775,
0.15489841997623444,
0.1843547821044922,
-0.5643579959869385,
0.7236433625221252,
0.3311179280281067,
0.045854128897190094,
-0.6046692132949829,
-0.5895383954048157,
0.11193086206912994,
-0.1582338958978653,
-0.48227426409721375,
0.43719080090522766,
0.22665303945541382,
0.16367344558238983,
0.11650160700082779,
-0.44283318519592285,
-0.1837558150291443,
0.18894560635089874,
0.0995110422372818,
0.5510278344154358,
-0.44057080149650574,
0.14805388450622559,
-0.24281471967697144,
-0.4577953517436981,
0.002821596572175622,
-0.4940347671508789,
0.4391416907310486,
-0.3244019150733948,
-0.13303911685943604,
-0.5004572868347168,
0.32861804962158203,
0.13412228226661682,
-0.3446783125400543,
0.5792062878608704,
0.6615524291992188,
-0.6009571552276611,
-0.05271105840802193,
-0.5651931166648865,
-0.4369155466556549,
-0.40276309847831726,
0.4550444483757019,
-0.3929611146450043,
-0.7400429248809814,
0.03307970240712166,
0.24649037420749664,
0.15269221365451813,
0.5600670576095581,
-0.13995707035064697,
0.16064628958702087,
0.6904639601707458,
0.762978732585907,
0.10959980636835098,
0.5017656683921814,
-0.31580790877342224,
0.04778457060456276,
-1.1129295825958252,
0.08590730279684067,
-0.11262041330337524,
0.15786895155906677,
-0.3920208513736725,
-0.15986678004264832,
0.31285446882247925,
0.10136208683252335,
-0.2799329459667206,
0.8701635003089905,
-0.41213852167129517,
0.5411806702613831,
0.4382714629173279,
0.37974053621292114,
0.1601978987455368,
-0.09968582540750504,
0.0419878214597702,
-0.03071019798517227,
-0.23191073536872864,
-0.518743634223938,
0.8664626479148865,
-0.09613887220621109,
-0.11634626239538193,
0.33236345648765564,
0.9350220561027527,
-0.256412148475647,
-0.04122648388147354,
-0.6179559826850891,
0.7850298285484314,
-0.5655179023742676,
-0.6386301517486572,
-0.2145249843597412,
-0.5073019862174988,
-0.7506285905838013,
0.5698700547218323,
-0.13654494285583496,
-1.0779083967208862,
0.0901293009519577,
-0.0487060584127903,
-0.3326481878757477,
0.3128718137741089,
-0.656585693359375,
1.232820749282837,
-0.28831779956817627,
-0.6294995546340942,
-0.10763157159090042,
-0.7588333487510681,
0.5950449109077454,
0.017390552908182144,
-0.16525685787200928,
-0.3170725405216217,
-0.00043673915206454694,
0.8067820072174072,
-0.2914787232875824,
0.9564257264137268,
-0.11293847113847733,
-0.03397537022829056,
0.0800105407834053,
0.018001744523644447,
0.3722371757030487,
0.04592202976346016,
-0.1833466738462448,
0.26650136709213257,
-0.24269212782382965,
-0.3382757604122162,
-0.5166518092155457,
0.6104767918586731,
-0.36905810236930847,
-0.7136115431785583,
-0.3791300058364868,
-0.37225615978240967,
-0.16128747165203094,
0.6785043478012085,
0.018704669550061226,
0.44120505452156067,
-0.08162736147642136,
-0.06092068925499916,
0.3853372037410736,
-0.1238238513469696,
0.5191839933395386,
0.6315244436264038,
0.14118629693984985,
-0.26488104462623596,
1.2100369930267334,
0.06324461102485657,
0.5089600086212158,
0.5735872387886047,
0.18973080813884735,
-0.15846601128578186,
-0.42566215991973877,
-0.3855798542499542,
0.2944146990776062,
-0.5502519607543945,
-0.15981470048427582,
-0.7786301970481873,
-0.4591287672519684,
-0.3569595217704773,
0.09857143461704254,
-0.26700788736343384,
-0.3982633054256439,
-0.3460574448108673,
-0.3540481925010681,
0.3517495393753052,
0.6580063700675964,
-0.24342544376850128,
0.37796077132225037,
-0.9118528366088867,
0.8280128836631775,
0.18691211938858032,
0.052737656980752945,
-0.10626452416181564,
-0.08674430102109909,
-0.09712038934230804,
-0.08155778795480728,
-0.29363518953323364,
-1.3330295085906982,
0.38801777362823486,
0.10605616122484207,
0.6937410235404968,
0.21939346194267273,
-0.19969980418682098,
0.5810261964797974,
-0.30189618468284607,
0.7920436859130859,
0.24142809212207794,
-1.2158747911453247,
0.6245861649513245,
-0.18922168016433716,
0.33263862133026123,
0.7209972143173218,
-0.011237984523177147,
-0.39411860704421997,
-0.3709404170513153,
-0.709078848361969,
-1.1003550291061401,
1.0657082796096802,
0.111714668571949,
-0.2555423676967621,
-0.10593989491462708,
0.16608992218971252,
0.40040844678878784,
0.34963303804397583,
-1.136649489402771,
-0.11306872218847275,
-0.21228498220443726,
-0.16897805035114288,
0.05225736275315285,
-0.1178450882434845,
0.405634343624115,
-0.08798980712890625,
0.8485057950019836,
-0.03466847911477089,
-0.02451917715370655,
-0.23889029026031494,
-0.39491087198257446,
0.5111530423164368,
0.18525582551956177,
-0.025721454992890358,
0.1419379711151123,
-0.2541681230068207,
0.3002617061138153,
0.10659048706293106,
-0.41334834694862366,
-0.07139881700277328,
0.12816572189331055,
-0.15513765811920166,
-0.11003266274929047,
0.42265748977661133,
0.6718719005584717,
0.23994992673397064,
-0.19880671799182892,
0.6374374032020569,
0.20294038951396942,
-0.19052071869373322,
-0.3040989339351654,
-0.057476162910461426,
0.023616744205355644,
-0.23903140425682068,
-0.06494222581386566,
0.19228513538837433,
0.25772809982299805,
-0.12706807255744934,
0.49694180488586426,
0.3462929427623749,
-0.3718893527984619,
-0.15409961342811584,
0.373301237821579,
0.16155365109443665,
0.18583935499191284,
0.6562271118164062,
-0.4290646016597748,
-0.7673977613449097,
0.8940936326980591,
0.4595677852630615,
1.0319483280181885,
0.03547525033354759,
0.3268193304538727,
0.7335912585258484,
0.4697208106517792,
0.012848724611103535,
0.5456571578979492,
-0.37764331698417664,
-0.9119391441345215,
-0.6316085457801819,
-0.33577588200569153,
0.10423368215560913,
-0.025970153510570526,
-0.6472464799880981,
0.35285139083862305,
-0.2815794348716736,
0.2009003460407257,
-0.1042969673871994,
-0.09759550541639328,
-0.5701871514320374,
-0.04760397598147392,
0.16933190822601318,
0.34534719586372375,
-0.7891097068786621,
0.8764750957489014,
0.4273410737514496,
-0.7206582427024841,
-1.0784932374954224,
0.2017984241247177,
0.07676450908184052,
-0.713851273059845,
0.9482300281524658,
0.6644966006278992,
-0.20069387555122375,
0.15927578508853912,
-0.19334831833839417,
-0.9896002411842346,
0.7934982776641846,
0.35005176067352295,
-0.3214671313762665,
-0.0029497870709747076,
-0.2414628118276596,
0.15829075872898102,
-0.21544310450553894,
0.49393072724342346,
0.523996889591217,
0.6670758128166199,
-0.20208750665187836,
-0.9529508352279663,
0.4044153392314911,
-0.3713530898094177,
-0.13868555426597595,
0.3951582908630371,
-0.36491483449935913,
0.7475982904434204,
-0.02809375338256359,
-0.6282030940055847,
-0.24142305552959442,
0.7053660750389099,
0.1522832214832306,
0.003210933180525899,
0.6440268754959106,
0.35268282890319824,
0.4784775674343109,
0.03512320667505264,
0.591433584690094,
-0.16006170213222504,
-0.16662414371967316,
1.6074140071868896,
-0.353993684053421,
0.7884402871131897,
0.46960967779159546,
0.25028279423713684,
0.8020209670066833,
0.3427347242832184,
0.00016130709263961762,
0.4206959307193756,
-0.010048087686300278,
-0.0471060648560524,
-0.28047099709510803,
-0.14114853739738464,
-0.20453837513923645,
0.38783547282218933,
0.4134598672389984,
-0.13498999178409576,
-0.5170124173164368,
0.26629433035850525,
-0.003563932841643691,
0.09522748738527298,
-0.10300514101982117,
0.9493312239646912,
0.05908282473683357,
-0.6507880687713623,
0.5385453104972839,
-0.18104636669158936,
0.6648116707801819,
-0.4727001190185547,
-0.4327506422996521,
0.2913152575492859,
-0.058294642716646194,
-0.48609575629234314,
-0.5019627213478088,
0.34109780192375183,
-0.24513785541057587,
-0.05150889232754707,
-0.27155789732933044,
0.5529407262802124,
-0.4566783308982849,
-0.3241921663284302,
0.5149260759353638,
0.5266262888908386,
0.26254069805145264,
-0.18691012263298035,
-0.5115137100219727,
-0.42107853293418884,
0.14688222110271454,
-0.008166855201125145,
-0.03876570984721184,
0.37750276923179626,
-0.001294957473874092,
0.17953968048095703,
0.5612127184867859,
0.1439526081085205,
0.14754076302051544,
0.056024689227342606,
0.47291800379753113,
-0.7669378519058228,
-0.6387243270874023,
-0.9346739649772644,
0.5178921222686768,
-0.4055810570716858,
-0.13745248317718506,
1.0472975969314575,
0.4230353832244873,
0.5439742803573608,
0.1268400251865387,
0.7479863166809082,
-0.2821491062641144,
0.2725840210914612,
-0.6156473755836487,
0.08049403876066208,
-0.4752061367034912,
0.3635987639427185,
-0.17934493720531464,
-0.7814190983772278,
-0.2677822411060333,
0.5126711130142212,
-0.5379806160926819,
-0.09215039759874344,
1.1270060539245605,
0.8484828472137451,
-0.10841621458530426,
0.5168906450271606,
0.009927299804985523,
0.3242736756801605,
0.12173476815223694,
1.01498544216156,
0.689720630645752,
-0.44773799180984497,
0.3080109655857086,
-0.45445552468299866,
-0.22368139028549194,
0.03300238773226738,
-0.9517627954483032,
-0.618035614490509,
-0.5312027335166931,
-0.5106366872787476,
-0.23915782570838928,
0.00015798417734913528,
0.7126514911651611,
0.7767150402069092,
-0.7362043857574463,
-0.11590037494897842,
-0.6739947199821472,
0.42698368430137634,
-0.6520374417304993,
-0.37079164385795593,
0.6293725967407227,
-0.24347548186779022,
-0.6949130296707153,
0.6047151684761047,
0.2343316227197647,
-0.1981315016746521,
0.05604149028658867,
0.09137365221977234,
-0.6223049759864807,
-0.5091232657432556,
0.37411215901374817,
0.16306085884571075,
-0.6871901154518127,
-0.2657417356967926,
-0.15987765789031982,
0.008223853074014187,
0.030836520716547966,
0.34470194578170776,
-0.7088202834129333,
0.23311378061771393,
0.4828195571899414,
0.4775224030017853,
0.6419541835784912,
-0.36787283420562744,
0.8417733311653137,
-0.5933440327644348,
-0.1601274013519287,
0.12822619080543518,
0.38674554228782654,
0.28139162063598633,
-0.49782630801200867,
0.5083814859390259,
0.22085121273994446,
-0.09143012017011642,
-0.4428919553756714,
0.39383211731910706,
-0.8732630014419556,
-0.34418413043022156,
1.1696436405181885,
-0.04343130439519882,
-0.4610845446586609,
-0.3553968071937561,
-0.12939946353435516,
0.4729474186897278,
-0.35643571615219116,
0.0734955221414566,
0.6475497484207153,
-0.07342406362295151,
-0.15383704006671906,
-0.8260110020637512,
0.1497902274131775,
0.7201125025749207,
-0.7385389804840088,
-0.04232620820403099,
0.593992292881012,
0.271931916475296,
0.16308006644248962,
0.46892720460891724,
-0.1314469277858734,
0.40579161047935486,
-0.09741360694169998,
0.3894738554954529,
-0.15086856484413147,
-0.34536460041999817,
-0.2726621627807617,
0.33962664008140564,
-0.34849366545677185,
-0.5644703507423401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09824v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09824v1
|
Impact of Preference Noise on the Alignment Performance of Generative Language Models
| 2024-04-15T14:21:53 | 2024-04-15T14:21:53 |
Yang Gao, Dana Alon, Donald Metzler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A key requirement in developing Generative Language Models (GLMs) is to have
their values aligned with human values. Preference-based alignment is a widely
used paradigm for this purpose, in which preferences over generation pairs are
first elicited from human annotators or AI systems, and then fed into some
alignment techniques, e.g., Direct Preference Optimization. However, a
substantial percent (20 - 40%) of the preference pairs used in GLM alignment
are noisy, and it remains unclear how the noise affects the alignment
performance and how to mitigate its negative impact. In this paper, we propose
a framework to inject desirable amounts and types of noise to the preferences,
and systematically study the impact of preference noise on the alignment
performance in two tasks (summarization and dialogue generation). We find that
the alignment performance can be highly sensitive to the noise rates in the
preference data: e.g., a 10 percentage points (pp) increase of the noise rate
can lead to 30 pp drop in the alignment performance (in win rate). To mitigate
the impact of noise, confidence-based data filtering shows significant benefit
when certain types of noise are present. We hope our work can help the
community better understand and mitigate the impact of preference noise in GLM
alignment.
|
[
-0.4452034533023834,
-0.4346555173397064,
0.3891690671443939,
0.07407473027706146,
-0.41649967432022095,
-0.10083272308111191,
-0.23884832859039307,
-0.6672359704971313,
0.11780161410570145,
0.4644344747066498,
-0.3902038633823395,
-0.4480087459087372,
-0.416156142950058,
-0.1334242969751358,
-0.342581570148468,
1.121594786643982,
0.15729068219661713,
-0.09401852637529373,
-0.5786235332489014,
-0.06674423813819885,
-0.3834761381149292,
-0.7447302341461182,
-0.41506773233413696,
-0.29855307936668396,
0.378048300743103,
0.12330830097198486,
1.1578823328018188,
0.6778373122215271,
0.5429253578186035,
0.22610561549663544,
-0.3914420008659363,
-0.12808912992477417,
-0.5091708898544312,
0.4112716019153595,
0.25656232237815857,
-0.47807586193084717,
-0.7189162969589233,
-0.16138717532157898,
0.599931538105011,
0.49918290972709656,
-0.20352035760879517,
-0.02985214814543724,
0.4374801814556122,
0.7617552280426025,
-0.5914811491966248,
0.24041354656219482,
-0.5441060662269592,
0.026687979698181152,
-0.4577467739582062,
-0.2691801190376282,
-0.2528969645500183,
-0.39047229290008545,
0.16228847205638885,
-0.5788128972053528,
0.3221282958984375,
0.11701765656471252,
1.0662397146224976,
0.43019941449165344,
0.013684181496500969,
-0.2346474826335907,
-0.7313363552093506,
0.9479528665542603,
-0.7581765055656433,
0.29344430565834045,
0.3152763247489929,
-0.2219610959291458,
-0.15223191678524017,
0.006535762455314398,
-0.4482673108577728,
0.09414130449295044,
-0.23321640491485596,
0.15350572764873505,
-0.20553143322467804,
0.24248933792114258,
0.3688105642795563,
0.6016275882720947,
-0.48629993200302124,
0.15736457705497742,
-0.16403155028820038,
-0.08948078751564026,
0.6185428500175476,
0.14799974858760834,
0.15373297035694122,
-0.07105003297328949,
0.044246334582567215,
-0.03786268085241318,
-0.48633909225463867,
0.156259685754776,
0.8834986090660095,
0.534173309803009,
-0.1960182636976242,
0.4751861095428467,
-0.2906462550163269,
1.0801090002059937,
0.380705326795578,
-0.2622300982475281,
0.44820359349250793,
-0.6441581845283508,
-0.05169960483908653,
0.09664168953895569,
0.7414476871490479,
0.6778057217597961,
0.25733062624931335,
-0.1676422655582428,
-0.22085022926330566,
0.3415988087654114,
0.3510377109050751,
-0.7240024209022522,
-0.1406039446592331,
0.15878863632678986,
-0.5437436699867249,
-0.6487810611724854,
-0.31644299626350403,
-0.9406495690345764,
-0.38937410712242126,
-0.7619919776916504,
0.25585290789604187,
-0.2748759388923645,
-0.4181275963783264,
0.2234751284122467,
0.06442480534315109,
0.29978445172309875,
0.3653785288333893,
-1.3110407590866089,
0.1498037725687027,
0.767274022102356,
0.851043701171875,
-0.35936540365219116,
0.18847770988941193,
-0.4518510699272156,
0.0785340666770935,
-0.19129975140094757,
0.8471060395240784,
-0.4569507837295532,
-0.6947767734527588,
-0.09672196954488754,
-0.45598581433296204,
-0.12749049067497253,
-0.6258360147476196,
0.6120998859405518,
-0.4377930760383606,
0.2984917163848877,
-0.3817761242389679,
-0.6046903729438782,
0.23365852236747742,
-0.1690528392791748,
-0.5871484279632568,
0.8415738344192505,
0.13998295366764069,
-0.7666372060775757,
0.706023633480072,
-0.6095189452171326,
-0.676266074180603,
-0.09951060265302658,
-0.2862304151058197,
-0.7345060706138611,
0.12378329038619995,
0.19598634541034698,
0.07303541898727417,
-0.1901777982711792,
0.35720741748809814,
-0.27648013830184937,
-0.5579683184623718,
0.25361910462379456,
-0.3349049985408783,
0.7249109148979187,
0.18252481520175934,
-0.39583712816238403,
0.38507670164108276,
-0.6431524753570557,
-0.0202954038977623,
-0.33280181884765625,
-0.11394402384757996,
-0.3351079225540161,
0.07451783120632172,
-0.17323319613933563,
0.25195276737213135,
0.14234521985054016,
-0.23169399797916412,
0.19077545404434204,
-0.4627186954021454,
0.1383218616247177,
0.9013487696647644,
-0.026830608025193214,
0.6093413829803467,
-0.6221404075622559,
0.5826027393341064,
0.2026723474264145,
0.40662509202957153,
0.4630575478076935,
-0.7071447372436523,
-0.6691488027572632,
-0.23433607816696167,
0.2641976773738861,
0.04697132483124733,
-0.12500303983688354,
0.4996192455291748,
-0.3097850978374481,
-0.30206531286239624,
-0.9619289636611938,
0.31360340118408203,
0.2586142420768738,
0.8039562106132507,
0.3963301479816437,
-0.47109296917915344,
-0.5339071154594421,
-1.0488704442977905,
-0.11568120121955872,
-0.45545634627342224,
0.017138676717877388,
0.21557927131652832,
-0.04314860701560974,
0.16821621358394623,
1.3653740882873535,
-0.5641822218894958,
-0.2621672451496124,
-0.01081891730427742,
0.15008234977722168,
0.23947688937187195,
0.5246748924255371,
0.596625804901123,
-0.985176146030426,
-0.497018039226532,
-0.25311484932899475,
-0.32602304220199585,
-0.32509031891822815,
0.17575569450855255,
-0.31486383080482483,
0.36138612031936646,
0.2199602723121643,
-0.4402272403240204,
0.4575176537036896,
0.8498392701148987,
-0.1882958561182022,
0.6860564351081848,
0.15459352731704712,
0.06177692115306854,
-1.0138769149780273,
0.1750132441520691,
0.08398537337779999,
0.07807771861553192,
-0.7242048978805542,
-0.35656121373176575,
-0.2592732012271881,
0.2639833390712738,
-0.21318982541561127,
0.07166006416082382,
-0.31292393803596497,
-0.22666147351264954,
-0.22481483221054077,
-0.10330905020236969,
0.1418948471546173,
0.3950711190700531,
0.26675891876220703,
1.1318141222000122,
0.3202882707118988,
-0.6491774916648865,
-0.1313224583864212,
0.2574814260005951,
-0.42696431279182434,
0.777190089225769,
-0.5414190888404846,
0.14636999368667603,
-0.25535616278648376,
-0.028456958010792732,
-0.8784628510475159,
-0.0015805059811100364,
0.33724984526634216,
-0.32501545548439026,
0.34440872073173523,
-0.3528926372528076,
-0.27685797214508057,
0.20041786134243011,
-0.31432896852493286,
0.3060835003852844,
0.6086463332176208,
-0.25506821274757385,
0.2779121398925781,
0.5127773284912109,
-0.1500997394323349,
-0.5550734400749207,
-0.2809920012950897,
-0.19811254739761353,
-0.4167115092277527,
-0.6412184238433838,
0.3943770229816437,
-0.2495950311422348,
-0.3419952392578125,
0.08601415902376175,
-0.047222502529621124,
0.2895015478134155,
0.17467962205410004,
0.5907226800918579,
0.607025146484375,
-0.12635232508182526,
0.1261269897222519,
-0.2545945942401886,
-0.20180726051330566,
-0.059364691376686096,
-0.1656406819820404,
0.7741496562957764,
-0.2630584239959717,
-0.32203081250190735,
-0.31185856461524963,
0.2076479196548462,
0.6380103230476379,
-0.17417371273040771,
0.7224923968315125,
0.4172854721546173,
0.023630062118172646,
0.3279455304145813,
-0.4691888689994812,
0.006597061175853014,
-0.44155794382095337,
0.37365344166755676,
-0.27606990933418274,
-0.691544771194458,
0.3498436510562897,
0.3089955747127533,
0.13436344265937805,
0.5535412430763245,
0.4969509541988373,
-0.36292415857315063,
1.2105762958526611,
0.38031864166259766,
-0.561345100402832,
0.7551590204238892,
0.11302494257688522,
0.228395015001297,
-1.1312273740768433,
0.07778666168451309,
-0.6639324426651001,
-0.4288617968559265,
-0.5901308655738831,
-0.26717057824134827,
0.3021146357059479,
0.18684649467468262,
-0.08185847848653793,
0.08599010109901428,
-0.5766003131866455,
0.15065479278564453,
0.746181070804596,
-0.13550731539726257,
0.5921932458877563,
0.26335301995277405,
0.13286899030208588,
-0.3003711998462677,
-0.5213721394538879,
-0.38686633110046387,
1.171592116355896,
0.11683748662471771,
0.7711002230644226,
0.31170961260795593,
0.6164433360099792,
0.1378157138824463,
0.21408022940158844,
-0.7507149577140808,
0.30000269412994385,
-0.19964994490146637,
-0.3920562267303467,
-0.4689492881298065,
-0.327087938785553,
-0.8370339274406433,
0.12467251718044281,
-0.2889869809150696,
-0.8961073756217957,
0.4125208258628845,
0.4322044849395752,
-0.4293372929096222,
0.18590331077575684,
-0.4056676924228668,
0.6901582479476929,
-0.1108267605304718,
-0.40978115797042847,
-0.1638740599155426,
-0.6564414501190186,
0.16118811070919037,
0.09401748329401016,
0.1928241103887558,
-0.11417164653539658,
0.4331267774105072,
0.6765475869178772,
-0.09528419375419617,
0.8966688513755798,
-0.1598426252603531,
-0.2699044942855835,
0.014946362935006618,
-0.19682537019252777,
0.6827936768531799,
-0.35846346616744995,
-0.1685684770345688,
0.30379945039749146,
-0.3319433629512787,
-0.0755944475531578,
-0.5371745228767395,
0.456074595451355,
-0.8794108629226685,
-0.7037802338600159,
-0.2974851429462433,
-0.6977102756500244,
-0.28955164551734924,
-0.1613817811012268,
0.6123914122581482,
0.24996763467788696,
-0.1429091840982437,
0.09881414473056793,
0.6520097255706787,
0.15260697901248932,
0.17509587109088898,
0.30192112922668457,
-0.4320157468318939,
-0.19522471725940704,
1.0820094347000122,
0.24186326563358307,
0.655592679977417,
0.12620589137077332,
-0.02607879973948002,
-0.4056693911552429,
-0.6333528757095337,
-0.36523327231407166,
-0.02500317245721817,
-0.3076797425746918,
-0.09256935864686966,
-0.6346902847290039,
-0.26615655422210693,
-0.4191085994243622,
-0.209381103515625,
-0.2954902648925781,
-0.42283791303634644,
-0.4554159939289093,
-0.044846538454294205,
0.25788363814353943,
0.42371001839637756,
-0.030751259997487068,
0.257937490940094,
-0.29311832785606384,
0.2517761290073395,
0.21006852388381958,
0.6187067031860352,
-0.1694391667842865,
-0.46640080213546753,
-0.24224847555160522,
0.13393481075763702,
-0.1638062745332718,
-0.5909443497657776,
0.22204026579856873,
0.004556791391223669,
0.3157269060611725,
0.6025442481040955,
0.17295487225055695,
0.7617555856704712,
-0.021750129759311676,
0.7171738147735596,
0.14741560816764832,
-0.920124351978302,
0.43158453702926636,
-0.2921760380268097,
0.23708583414554596,
0.6225792169570923,
-0.23448175191879272,
-0.6491941809654236,
-0.599834144115448,
-0.5998402237892151,
-0.798520565032959,
0.6724158525466919,
0.3192232847213745,
-0.1768527328968048,
0.2774062156677246,
0.14232900738716125,
-0.005154823884367943,
0.48444506525993347,
-0.38027799129486084,
-0.41513848304748535,
-0.10393080115318298,
-0.12147163599729538,
-0.24128668010234833,
-0.47267454862594604,
-0.3251540958881378,
-0.19238628447055817,
0.7421981692314148,
-0.08506175875663757,
0.20219309628009796,
-0.07963351160287857,
0.022209834307432175,
-0.49495065212249756,
0.5355300903320312,
0.751776933670044,
0.19987855851650238,
-0.5033164620399475,
-0.1840374618768692,
-0.3222014904022217,
-0.3702026307582855,
0.17741039395332336,
-0.02802361734211445,
-0.9784157276153564,
0.008456404320895672,
0.09970051795244217,
1.0806870460510254,
0.09334024041891098,
-0.17932410538196564,
0.4333418905735016,
-0.04638379067182541,
-0.14424239099025726,
0.025479191914200783,
0.2652676999568939,
0.1176525354385376,
-0.3449563980102539,
-0.05160072073340416,
0.5402749180793762,
0.32477065920829773,
-0.29175135493278503,
-0.040628544986248016,
0.6974000930786133,
-0.5744484663009644,
-0.32717159390449524,
0.5319945812225342,
0.1778404414653778,
-0.06303410232067108,
0.5635330677032471,
-0.10232970118522644,
-0.5533090829849243,
0.4799932539463043,
0.5387943387031555,
0.8521705269813538,
-0.17387691140174866,
0.2342083901166916,
0.23695814609527588,
0.08084461092948914,
0.02273879572749138,
0.1417246311903,
-0.15009163320064545,
-1.0666770935058594,
-0.3855927586555481,
-0.8560486435890198,
-0.5230675935745239,
-0.024894004687666893,
-1.0010462999343872,
0.16226474940776825,
0.09116626530885696,
-0.4086788594722748,
-0.01187923550605774,
-0.17897489666938782,
-0.500744640827179,
-0.0006008527125231922,
0.0953155979514122,
0.23194631934165955,
-0.842669665813446,
0.5890666842460632,
0.4907459020614624,
-0.22258524596691132,
-0.6033373475074768,
0.17562097311019897,
0.3285471200942993,
-0.6621171832084656,
0.3663155734539032,
-0.05812685564160347,
-0.2692963480949402,
-0.08319750428199768,
-0.2675762176513672,
-0.9867061376571655,
0.6684237122535706,
0.5630568861961365,
-0.6767106056213379,
0.08489064872264862,
0.330464243888855,
0.6087476015090942,
-0.3060108423233032,
-0.03509962931275368,
0.6861103177070618,
0.6223260164260864,
0.17464135587215424,
-0.9580584764480591,
-0.12670814990997314,
-0.3125312328338623,
-0.02353258989751339,
0.3601010739803314,
-0.7996456027030945,
0.7207745909690857,
-0.09344194829463959,
-0.3632003366947174,
-0.04130172356963158,
0.41162657737731934,
0.08027655631303787,
0.0421123243868351,
0.705538272857666,
0.5516823530197144,
0.8493515849113464,
-0.13080576062202454,
0.8786599040031433,
-0.5331987142562866,
0.16293305158615112,
1.3818788528442383,
-0.5283704400062561,
0.6248718500137329,
0.7592570781707764,
-0.3396483361721039,
0.3095683455467224,
0.35220906138420105,
0.030746934935450554,
0.5777079463005066,
0.2694214880466461,
-0.4888990819454193,
-0.235539048910141,
-0.6187376976013184,
-0.666636049747467,
0.33848273754119873,
0.25609683990478516,
-0.31322047114372253,
0.15489135682582855,
-0.43699774146080017,
-0.0372050479054451,
-0.12609490752220154,
-0.09554050862789154,
1.135664463043213,
-0.23848938941955566,
-0.8411731719970703,
0.20228664577007294,
-0.46217048168182373,
0.7940337061882019,
-0.5076801180839539,
0.1716606318950653,
-0.07397075742483139,
0.03195613622665405,
-0.393882691860199,
-0.8235909938812256,
0.35735753178596497,
-0.16587841510772705,
-0.5814473628997803,
-0.12965044379234314,
0.5631063580513,
-0.6191569566726685,
-0.14525265991687775,
0.34190869331359863,
0.28890326619148254,
-0.1256321668624878,
-0.09626651555299759,
-0.2817661762237549,
0.2002747654914856,
0.2610946297645569,
-0.15181037783622742,
0.741008996963501,
-0.11534751206636429,
0.17093554139137268,
0.2918517291545868,
0.7851656675338745,
0.31049245595932007,
-0.14470317959785461,
0.3177028298377991,
0.9273017048835754,
-0.2574324309825897,
-0.48691925406455994,
-0.9300164580345154,
0.520835816860199,
-0.32643750309944153,
-0.26617079973220825,
0.5635226964950562,
0.7057780623435974,
0.6169993281364441,
0.1106591448187828,
0.9365085363388062,
0.02249874174594879,
0.30483734607696533,
-0.5242864489555359,
0.7568851709365845,
-0.25393804907798767,
0.34967654943466187,
-0.5824885964393616,
-0.9474962949752808,
-0.25921371579170227,
0.478525310754776,
-0.3352205455303192,
-0.09321741759777069,
0.2424195557832718,
1.1066769361495972,
0.2675597369670868,
0.2521660625934601,
0.40074408054351807,
0.12246602028608322,
0.36666637659072876,
0.2649327218532562,
0.6836709380149841,
-0.13700784742832184,
0.4823061525821686,
-0.5372973680496216,
-0.06138385832309723,
-0.2458103597164154,
-0.8265344500541687,
-0.36921393871307373,
-0.5854963064193726,
-0.5525274872779846,
-0.4626549780368805,
0.24363818764686584,
0.7359805703163147,
0.6931140422821045,
-0.9516472816467285,
-0.3437701463699341,
-0.021543197333812714,
0.11046580225229263,
-0.32846611738204956,
-0.2531564235687256,
0.4159436821937561,
-0.45131340622901917,
-0.8145432472229004,
0.15717145800590515,
0.3860839605331421,
0.2575971186161041,
0.09456968307495117,
-0.2747984826564789,
0.04822515696287155,
-0.3000301122665405,
0.27967363595962524,
0.1897183656692505,
-0.6080058217048645,
-0.3140687346458435,
-0.12374182790517807,
-0.29501354694366455,
0.4562056362628937,
0.6831763386726379,
-0.5488187670707703,
0.6421193480491638,
0.14531907439231873,
0.1181875690817833,
0.3095909059047699,
0.3816987872123718,
0.917241096496582,
-0.7721536755561829,
0.08839191496372223,
0.12575076520442963,
0.2913610637187958,
0.2770369350910187,
-0.6467124223709106,
0.5020862221717834,
0.17818084359169006,
-0.617307186126709,
-0.6813132762908936,
0.1460607647895813,
-0.8280282616615295,
0.18182219564914703,
1.1111863851547241,
0.23556534945964813,
0.26131671667099,
-0.31227025389671326,
-0.3143540322780609,
0.24729977548122406,
-0.7930954694747925,
0.8495336771011353,
0.9953868985176086,
-0.3228111267089844,
0.06071854382753372,
-0.21202918887138367,
0.9985018968582153,
0.7022250890731812,
-0.3563046455383301,
0.2693101763725281,
0.5801180601119995,
-0.048960041254758835,
0.29363518953323364,
0.7099527716636658,
-0.20321057736873627,
0.12068779766559601,
-0.22045989334583282,
0.1638059914112091,
0.19693103432655334,
0.07909055799245834,
-0.6065229773521423,
0.3358014225959778,
0.3484972417354584,
-0.0931425541639328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09785v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09785v1
|
Benchmarking Llama2, Mistral, Gemma and GPT for Factuality, Toxicity, Bias and Propensity for Hallucinations
| 2024-04-15T13:40:08 | 2024-04-15T13:40:08 |
David Nadeau, Mike Kroutikov, Karen McNeil, Simon Baribeau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces fourteen novel datasets for the evaluation of Large
Language Models' safety in the context of enterprise tasks. A method was
devised to evaluate a model's safety, as determined by its ability to follow
instructions and output factual, unbiased, grounded, and appropriate content.
In this research, we used OpenAI GPT as point of comparison since it excels at
all levels of safety. On the open-source side, for smaller models, Meta Llama2
performs well at factuality and toxicity but has the highest propensity for
hallucination. Mistral hallucinates the least but cannot handle toxicity well.
It performs well in a dataset mixing several tasks and safety vectors in a
narrow vertical domain. Gemma, the newly introduced open-source model based on
Google Gemini, is generally balanced but trailing behind. When engaging in
back-and-forth conversation (multi-turn prompts), we find that the safety of
open-source models degrades significantly. Aside from OpenAI's GPT, Mistral is
the only model that still performed well in multi-turn tests.
|
[
-0.16017277538776398,
-0.7296416163444519,
0.702133059501648,
0.49317467212677,
0.0923343375325203,
-0.516396164894104,
-0.18700909614562988,
-0.6858023405075073,
-0.15150004625320435,
0.45750874280929565,
-0.2280246466398239,
-0.6150779724121094,
-0.6656454205513,
0.12611335515975952,
-0.7603159546852112,
1.0967687368392944,
0.07161660492420197,
0.10490766912698746,
0.0620666928589344,
-0.2070961743593216,
-0.528913676738739,
-0.9213984608650208,
-0.7028209567070007,
-0.1608566790819168,
0.6199866533279419,
-0.15339311957359314,
0.9517106413841248,
0.3191855549812317,
0.6235159635543823,
0.24790291488170624,
-0.09272847324609756,
-0.15444205701351166,
-0.587120771408081,
0.3616918921470642,
-0.3909549415111542,
-0.28749391436576843,
-0.5010613799095154,
-0.07751646637916565,
0.20527935028076172,
0.3956911265850067,
-0.4767223000526428,
0.11728259176015854,
0.19449329376220703,
0.2720390558242798,
-0.7560526728630066,
0.28914833068847656,
-0.7045257687568665,
-0.038238536566495895,
0.005864419043064117,
0.10367531329393387,
-0.530566394329071,
-0.5764490365982056,
-0.059136439114809036,
-0.5299840569496155,
-0.12131604552268982,
0.1163959801197052,
0.857245683670044,
0.5562718510627747,
-0.4112783968448639,
-0.4859278202056885,
-0.6951232552528381,
0.6881361603736877,
-0.614708423614502,
0.4855802357196808,
0.3022586703300476,
0.3746482729911804,
-0.14667749404907227,
-0.8988725543022156,
-0.3826172947883606,
-0.6219311952590942,
0.10740815103054047,
-0.00925195962190628,
-0.39022254943847656,
0.11027033627033234,
0.255553662776947,
0.24467267096042633,
-0.4785042405128479,
0.2940395176410675,
-0.39357486367225647,
-0.20120148360729218,
0.48486512899398804,
0.4299779236316681,
0.3402232527732849,
0.06820452958345413,
-0.360694020986557,
-0.40122002363204956,
-0.8882336616516113,
-0.38648244738578796,
0.20752185583114624,
0.22239454090595245,
0.03718596696853638,
0.7174575328826904,
-0.10003545135259628,
0.24888445436954498,
-0.08107027411460876,
-0.21711577475070953,
0.3212781250476837,
-0.18348559737205505,
-0.37921977043151855,
-0.047890592366456985,
1.0172770023345947,
0.5342867374420166,
0.29944732785224915,
-0.47804534435272217,
-0.10933726280927658,
0.4024825394153595,
0.5373910665512085,
-0.7421606779098511,
-0.3042839467525482,
0.40632694959640503,
-0.49531883001327515,
-0.5208005905151367,
-0.1723242849111557,
-0.9064084887504578,
-0.6667526960372925,
-0.23010723292827606,
0.6823222637176514,
-0.1743982434272766,
-0.416398286819458,
0.19108332693576813,
0.24060848355293274,
0.1889878362417221,
0.21857601404190063,
-0.7737331986427307,
0.5183582305908203,
0.7783492207527161,
0.9947549700737,
-0.5158905982971191,
-0.40011081099510193,
-0.5028640031814575,
0.04367825388908386,
-0.5398740172386169,
0.7080769538879395,
-0.19525325298309326,
-0.3632626235485077,
0.0077884807251393795,
0.06972111761569977,
-0.029696226119995117,
-0.7425289750099182,
0.8772342205047607,
-0.10437850654125214,
0.11370296776294708,
-0.6316620707511902,
-0.030573654919862747,
-0.2539556622505188,
0.15672726929187775,
-0.8276179432868958,
1.1812407970428467,
-0.17589440941810608,
-1.0708223581314087,
0.486652672290802,
-0.5079130530357361,
-0.3401767611503601,
-0.33592575788497925,
-0.21074843406677246,
-0.11911702156066895,
0.02692343108355999,
0.028531266376376152,
0.44620153307914734,
-0.4255964457988739,
0.39404603838920593,
-0.38759130239486694,
-0.26756995916366577,
0.15165279805660248,
-0.5767487287521362,
0.8459147214889526,
0.16624359786510468,
-0.5957152843475342,
0.14863654971122742,
-0.6200034022331238,
-0.10593436658382416,
-0.04965813457965851,
-0.2141338288784027,
-0.3629888594150543,
0.06101245433092117,
0.336243599653244,
0.4299451410770416,
-0.1842116266489029,
-0.28584930300712585,
-0.36421939730644226,
0.04683949053287506,
0.16558986902236938,
0.6860945224761963,
-0.002659437246620655,
-0.24792055785655975,
-0.3903557062149048,
0.17465196549892426,
0.1636325567960739,
0.3502591550350189,
0.1606084108352661,
-0.5217956900596619,
-0.7525413632392883,
-0.24130742251873016,
0.15394732356071472,
0.7984912395477295,
-0.5933029055595398,
0.3842318058013916,
-0.19947050511837006,
-0.5952686071395874,
-0.533670961856842,
-0.2849777042865753,
0.44154030084609985,
0.4302324056625366,
0.33254438638687134,
-0.3496607542037964,
-0.3165498375892639,
-0.85366290807724,
-0.17558692395687103,
-0.4249751567840576,
-0.11131634563207626,
0.16013069450855255,
0.5254004001617432,
-0.5076951384544373,
0.4883846938610077,
-0.25079792737960815,
-0.2161589413881302,
0.1061774268746376,
0.19429083168506622,
0.019402582198381424,
0.21938231587409973,
0.5051626563072205,
-0.441917359828949,
-0.30001816153526306,
0.011332866735756397,
-1.1312097311019897,
-0.19981591403484344,
0.00995275191962719,
-0.10866507887840271,
0.3744175434112549,
0.3078818917274475,
-0.8147081732749939,
0.36165502667427063,
0.5773624181747437,
-0.2360033392906189,
0.7426118850708008,
-0.04516033083200455,
0.19542637467384338,
-0.9913435578346252,
0.4227905571460724,
0.13325655460357666,
0.05501817166805267,
-0.9037994742393494,
0.11688632518053055,
-0.2034456580877304,
0.040910784155130386,
-0.5185568332672119,
0.37450891733169556,
-0.18545001745224,
-0.09572280943393707,
-0.16100557148456573,
0.1510319709777832,
-0.2833409011363983,
0.24290914833545685,
0.25865283608436584,
0.9653701186180115,
0.629668653011322,
-0.6366724371910095,
0.23537518084049225,
0.21176931262016296,
-0.6047698259353638,
0.37497591972351074,
-0.9892082214355469,
0.23409587144851685,
0.09966319799423218,
-0.0023964564315974712,
-0.717479407787323,
-0.13467735052108765,
0.20535489916801453,
-0.14403726160526276,
-0.11276297271251678,
0.20424115657806396,
-0.7257959246635437,
-0.10687468200922012,
-0.2210494726896286,
0.13228194415569305,
0.545385479927063,
-0.5416026711463928,
0.3751395642757416,
0.5203308463096619,
-0.24147392809391022,
-0.6868587732315063,
-0.7897160649299622,
0.27258267998695374,
-0.38910454511642456,
-0.5155070424079895,
0.06498708575963974,
0.006782769691199064,
-0.6900861263275146,
-0.07475187629461288,
-0.21428586542606354,
-0.07850855588912964,
0.09481868892908096,
0.4900363087654114,
0.18640999495983124,
-0.06279952824115753,
-0.06916479766368866,
-0.07544267922639847,
-0.3144495487213135,
0.31591296195983887,
0.1276172399520874,
0.348542720079422,
-0.19852352142333984,
-0.3444998860359192,
-0.29121845960617065,
0.21283085644245148,
0.6397386193275452,
0.049174681305885315,
0.9506645202636719,
0.4849807024002075,
-0.49389058351516724,
-0.1677364557981491,
-0.6956039667129517,
-0.20779305696487427,
-0.4483412504196167,
0.3788268566131592,
-0.19425834715366364,
-0.6785073280334473,
0.4216102063655853,
0.04074878990650177,
0.16876588761806488,
0.38451874256134033,
0.9807345271110535,
0.41595372557640076,
0.7282044291496277,
0.5549956560134888,
-0.3368934392929077,
0.038694027811288834,
0.19069689512252808,
0.5205325484275818,
-0.44046691060066223,
-0.23245759308338165,
-0.6618237495422363,
0.2797374725341797,
-0.5915763974189758,
-0.40855783224105835,
0.6519141793251038,
-0.1882409006357193,
-0.4172528088092804,
0.26667386293411255,
-0.40748417377471924,
0.38180071115493774,
0.4122382402420044,
-0.0009045638144016266,
0.4608156085014343,
-0.0191827230155468,
-0.13686467707157135,
0.015990665182471275,
-0.2659062445163727,
-0.8782894015312195,
1.1431785821914673,
0.642536997795105,
1.1028428077697754,
0.04536610096693039,
0.33679091930389404,
0.1858854442834854,
0.40581080317497253,
-0.32499685883522034,
0.5285277962684631,
0.008186083287000656,
-0.9649065732955933,
-0.325817734003067,
-0.38102200627326965,
-0.6016799211502075,
0.5428009629249573,
-0.25802135467529297,
-0.9547174572944641,
0.09670890122652054,
-0.06592509150505066,
-0.22675687074661255,
0.2989269196987152,
-0.5906014442443848,
0.703721284866333,
-0.2555704712867737,
-0.45744791626930237,
-0.13932934403419495,
-0.4699976146221161,
0.7198091745376587,
-0.19524216651916504,
0.13145145773887634,
-0.11596419662237167,
0.1245405375957489,
0.5940147042274475,
0.02397681027650833,
0.8541585206985474,
0.013455519452691078,
-0.28607937693595886,
0.23148177564144135,
0.2735520005226135,
0.47189968824386597,
-0.11862540990114212,
-0.2728305160999298,
0.6104363203048706,
0.1878519505262375,
0.12135022133588791,
-0.2799663543701172,
0.7231420874595642,
-0.7338215112686157,
-0.5491765141487122,
-0.5605161786079407,
-0.3040067255496979,
-0.22402362525463104,
0.18323105573654175,
0.4223490059375763,
0.0995863601565361,
-0.4826123118400574,
0.23976071178913116,
0.7909570336341858,
-0.43031877279281616,
0.25254368782043457,
0.3914113938808441,
-0.17871126532554626,
-0.47704431414604187,
0.6004314422607422,
0.024377373978495598,
0.22199782729148865,
-0.041938699781894684,
-0.07428675889968872,
-0.2778915762901306,
-0.5107308626174927,
-0.11387155205011368,
0.13038086891174316,
-0.9126152396202087,
-0.1158696636557579,
-0.8126060962677002,
-0.25667256116867065,
-0.2562081813812256,
0.2528768479824066,
-0.41877496242523193,
-0.22981703281402588,
-0.04165518283843994,
-0.379727840423584,
0.0965370163321495,
0.9788980484008789,
-0.08648575842380524,
-0.007015648763626814,
-0.3181639015674591,
0.33870184421539307,
0.2602024972438812,
0.42102131247520447,
0.14593355357646942,
-0.10661086440086365,
-0.07950655370950699,
-0.16128839552402496,
-0.5185815691947937,
-0.9466779828071594,
0.2534145712852478,
-0.3791102170944214,
0.7996529340744019,
0.4316715598106384,
0.13306550681591034,
0.3460235595703125,
-0.4255157709121704,
0.9333665370941162,
0.1758708655834198,
-1.0326541662216187,
0.13400667905807495,
-0.39624351263046265,
-0.4776274859905243,
0.6742729544639587,
0.5921939611434937,
-0.6467492580413818,
-0.2891828417778015,
-0.2502368688583374,
-0.8600732088088989,
0.4299420714378357,
0.5485457181930542,
-0.1870330572128296,
-0.18559087812900543,
0.15177880227565765,
0.3838999271392822,
0.18095101416110992,
-1.0096588134765625,
-0.11098972707986832,
-0.1834855079650879,
-0.22770313918590546,
-0.1261352151632309,
-0.2781106233596802,
-0.40811043977737427,
-0.0017126195598393679,
0.6737264394760132,
0.06322035193443298,
0.37663137912750244,
-0.017101245000958443,
-0.09179738909006119,
-0.10920167714357376,
0.11331750452518463,
0.5523190498352051,
0.5894765853881836,
-0.11110684275627136,
0.21720516681671143,
0.43920767307281494,
-0.7182034850120544,
0.14796167612075806,
-0.17414483428001404,
-0.09516001492738724,
-0.07999251782894135,
0.4629422128200531,
0.7452337145805359,
0.028020888566970825,
-0.7078242897987366,
0.4771758019924164,
-0.04433233290910721,
-0.1980983018875122,
-0.27405208349227905,
0.27612975239753723,
-0.040083058178424835,
0.2529931366443634,
0.05654584616422653,
-0.17418433725833893,
0.33170250058174133,
-0.7383600473403931,
0.06446981430053711,
0.29791784286499023,
-0.1669784039258957,
-0.31391605734825134,
0.8923574090003967,
0.04720096290111542,
-0.09097228944301605,
0.464285671710968,
0.09929605573415756,
-0.16245773434638977,
0.41164761781692505,
0.48441556096076965,
1.19081711769104,
-0.26926788687705994,
0.10320936143398285,
0.3197007179260254,
0.6817992329597473,
-0.5739012360572815,
0.3843696713447571,
0.41447025537490845,
-0.49335747957229614,
-0.12905307114124298,
-0.35093018412590027,
-0.6755196452140808,
0.5033220648765564,
-0.7007284760475159,
0.1790820062160492,
-0.34254544973373413,
-0.41233715415000916,
-0.20259632170200348,
-0.1648549884557724,
-0.48897743225097656,
0.14582012593746185,
0.05941515788435936,
0.941806435585022,
-1.2049766778945923,
0.7670941948890686,
0.4415159225463867,
-0.35875561833381653,
-0.5507526993751526,
0.34895655512809753,
0.08217860758304596,
-0.46208852529525757,
0.45474812388420105,
0.21813903748989105,
-0.19965411722660065,
-0.4805828928947449,
-0.3389717936515808,
-0.8398668169975281,
1.3155068159103394,
0.39140257239341736,
-0.6138182878494263,
-0.13954123854637146,
0.2452884018421173,
0.7440159320831299,
-0.22130638360977173,
0.3587017059326172,
0.6644679307937622,
0.4647759199142456,
-0.09244758635759354,
-1.2555922269821167,
0.2042233794927597,
-0.21781402826309204,
0.09749917685985565,
-0.13361763954162598,
-0.6427990198135376,
0.9004544615745544,
-0.07778116315603256,
-0.35548722743988037,
0.1420181393623352,
0.4176297187805176,
0.5556381344795227,
0.4454331398010254,
0.4649655222892761,
0.663114070892334,
0.8503631949424744,
-0.15148217976093292,
0.9654695987701416,
-0.4333653450012207,
0.15896332263946533,
1.0947681665420532,
-0.6783449649810791,
0.9971599578857422,
0.21847392618656158,
-0.07633137702941895,
0.36809080839157104,
0.4744602143764496,
-0.00819583609700203,
0.740979015827179,
0.15729695558547974,
0.016097307205200195,
0.02187434956431389,
0.09039009362459183,
-0.4282415509223938,
0.06359453499317169,
0.29830458760261536,
-0.25863200426101685,
-0.15545466542243958,
0.10449104756116867,
0.2775208353996277,
-0.3336701989173889,
0.004600735381245613,
0.7606785893440247,
0.24886631965637207,
-0.6564401388168335,
0.6318373680114746,
-0.02714751474559307,
0.43640682101249695,
-0.27847641706466675,
0.07311674952507019,
-0.23165717720985413,
0.24897095561027527,
-0.16546973586082458,
-0.6140244603157043,
0.2707024812698364,
0.2602556049823761,
0.1544083207845688,
0.2954511046409607,
0.5614736676216125,
-0.12217894196510315,
-0.32775160670280457,
0.6221964359283447,
0.24539990723133087,
0.3261518180370331,
-0.14490319788455963,
-0.41674232482910156,
0.42749521136283875,
-0.41847652196884155,
-0.2945576012134552,
0.20849496126174927,
0.5129818916320801,
-0.3242546617984772,
0.8317050933837891,
0.286958247423172,
0.04881517216563225,
0.20507711172103882,
0.046378280967473984,
0.9364030361175537,
-0.7152201533317566,
-0.39507219195365906,
-0.696111261844635,
0.4273456931114197,
0.06111324951052666,
-0.4065832495689392,
0.8202176094055176,
0.42689165472984314,
0.5375138521194458,
-0.07565463334321976,
0.7994246482849121,
0.09450609236955643,
0.2924345135688782,
-0.597037672996521,
0.8242261409759521,
-0.19068469107151031,
0.26941347122192383,
-0.5237153172492981,
-1.0968468189239502,
-0.1437409520149231,
0.6357864141464233,
-0.24702200293540955,
0.3145667314529419,
1.012499213218689,
1.038802146911621,
-0.03688863664865494,
0.07004114240407944,
0.42379963397979736,
0.4774887263774872,
0.2925280034542084,
0.569893479347229,
0.9304679036140442,
-0.3995417654514313,
0.4054487645626068,
-0.2045837789773941,
-0.2787478268146515,
-0.18147197365760803,
-1.011701226234436,
-1.2219688892364502,
-0.6549625396728516,
-0.21504779160022736,
-0.5623220801353455,
0.3801713287830353,
0.7821173071861267,
0.7844096422195435,
-0.9581854939460754,
-0.29408761858940125,
0.02747592329978943,
-0.3021624982357025,
-0.30984413623809814,
-0.13140098750591278,
0.4207233488559723,
-0.2560935914516449,
-0.38654810190200806,
0.40368619561195374,
0.2710553705692291,
0.05190388113260269,
-0.417520672082901,
-0.10483615845441818,
0.33029526472091675,
0.2593487501144409,
0.6464412212371826,
-0.07466819137334824,
-0.8834409117698669,
-0.3397476375102997,
-0.08925771713256836,
-0.3525407016277313,
-0.1578921675682068,
0.5484883189201355,
-0.43533867597579956,
-0.02965724654495716,
0.42917829751968384,
0.35180625319480896,
0.3092605769634247,
-0.05514797568321228,
0.4388192892074585,
-0.15750204026699066,
0.04930908605456352,
0.08752240240573883,
0.2869211435317993,
0.25979292392730713,
-0.5302601456642151,
0.8669984340667725,
-0.08503496646881104,
-0.7032902240753174,
-1.073746919631958,
-0.05481259524822235,
-0.8788273334503174,
-0.27550384402275085,
1.3252023458480835,
-0.061168182641267776,
-0.0742042288184166,
-0.15767963230609894,
-0.2651631832122803,
0.15449605882167816,
-0.10615384578704834,
1.36699640750885,
0.8058024644851685,
0.11616972833871841,
0.0643756091594696,
-1.0245224237442017,
0.7636909484863281,
0.21128812432289124,
-1.132116436958313,
0.42417457699775696,
0.46909400820732117,
0.34683161973953247,
0.17153336107730865,
0.5900823473930359,
-0.3801907002925873,
0.2409290373325348,
0.35321295261383057,
0.16364601254463196,
-0.00035548844607546926,
-0.7346439957618713,
-0.44024571776390076,
0.15597893297672272,
0.20003744959831238,
0.02743375487625599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09763v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09763v1
|
KG-CTG: Citation Generation through Knowledge Graph-guided Large Language Models
| 2024-04-15T13:06:32 | 2024-04-15T13:06:32 |
Avinash Anand, Mohit Gupta, Kritarth Prasad, Ujjwal Goel, Naman Lal, Astha Verma, Rajiv Ratn Shah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Citation Text Generation (CTG) is a task in natural language processing (NLP)
that aims to produce text that accurately cites or references a cited document
within a source document. In CTG, the generated text draws upon contextual cues
from both the source document and the cited paper, ensuring accurate and
relevant citation information is provided. Previous work in the field of
citation generation is mainly based on the text summarization of documents.
Following this, this paper presents a framework, and a comparative study to
demonstrate the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) for the task of citation
generation. Also, we have shown the improvement in the results of citation
generation by incorporating the knowledge graph relations of the papers in the
prompt for the LLM to better learn the relationship between the papers. To
assess how well our model is performing, we have used a subset of standard
S2ORC dataset, which only consists of computer science academic research papers
in the English Language. Vicuna performs best for this task with 14.15 Meteor,
12.88 Rouge-1, 1.52 Rouge-2, and 10.94 Rouge-L. Also, Alpaca performs best, and
improves the performance by 36.98% in Rouge-1, and 33.14% in Meteor by
including knowledge graphs.
|
[
-0.23292015492916107,
-0.7366684079170227,
0.7736382484436035,
-0.06105998530983925,
-0.410218209028244,
-0.07093604654073715,
-0.18064573407173157,
-0.35002705454826355,
-0.0682453140616417,
0.46197009086608887,
-0.08101538568735123,
-0.7332488894462585,
-0.7820397615432739,
0.5382928848266602,
-0.31493455171585083,
0.8012412786483765,
0.19834327697753906,
0.16901512444019318,
-0.2968200445175171,
-0.0554426871240139,
-0.5188232064247131,
-0.5542969703674316,
-0.8300032019615173,
-0.7490670680999756,
0.8440423607826233,
0.07846812158823013,
0.521616518497467,
0.6416457891464233,
0.5258079171180725,
0.2017049342393875,
-0.24346975982189178,
0.4530452787876129,
-0.4204348623752594,
0.38250601291656494,
-0.3919965326786041,
-0.3219924569129944,
-0.13461700081825256,
-0.18405187129974365,
0.4970991611480713,
0.4450732469558716,
0.25411391258239746,
-0.0631471574306488,
0.038165561854839325,
0.7560995221138,
-0.6313469409942627,
0.3082008361816406,
-0.6513740420341492,
-0.236504465341568,
-0.12928174436092377,
-0.5271966457366943,
-0.6959665417671204,
-0.6423948407173157,
0.00006997797754593194,
-0.45175036787986755,
0.03912435472011566,
0.017349081113934517,
0.7360002994537354,
0.0803457573056221,
-0.9509416222572327,
-0.7581870555877686,
-0.43774306774139404,
0.6647527813911438,
-0.5985485315322876,
0.3544621765613556,
0.32152265310287476,
0.1865089386701584,
-0.33601656556129456,
-1.061125636100769,
-0.38603776693344116,
-0.3486182391643524,
-0.20882169902324677,
0.2701752781867981,
-0.20555564761161804,
-0.20275963842868805,
0.20803497731685638,
0.0018501790473237634,
-0.5368068814277649,
0.03545248508453369,
-0.4215466380119324,
0.04694261774420738,
0.55903160572052,
-0.10111827403306961,
-0.06624370813369751,
-0.7392987012863159,
-0.23563887178897858,
-0.38337546586990356,
-1.0139020681381226,
-0.4637884497642517,
0.32182008028030396,
0.6900604963302612,
0.22492699325084686,
0.6263507008552551,
0.07268993556499481,
0.8183258175849915,
-0.1348893791437149,
-0.42356452345848083,
0.029888734221458435,
-0.3340212404727936,
-0.21839380264282227,
0.01583527959883213,
0.9827660322189331,
0.3630446791648865,
0.4525344967842102,
-0.44841113686561584,
0.22848352789878845,
-0.42245498299598694,
0.08731448650360107,
-0.9005666971206665,
-0.05140191689133644,
-0.08981838077306747,
-0.5801029801368713,
-0.3552212715148926,
0.06326553225517273,
-0.340671569108963,
-0.3909268379211426,
-0.6615420579910278,
0.19531387090682983,
-0.5207619667053223,
-0.15447841584682465,
-0.5005630850791931,
-0.2629215717315674,
0.09167005121707916,
0.2745887041091919,
-0.38736048340797424,
-0.3691032826900482,
0.44807809591293335,
1.1188781261444092,
-0.2612939774990082,
0.07682903110980988,
-0.3966172933578491,
0.4335053563117981,
-0.3583313226699829,
0.9544259905815125,
-0.4954596161842346,
-0.7075371146202087,
0.19836527109146118,
-0.24824659526348114,
-0.1785428524017334,
-0.5869230628013611,
0.6139975190162659,
-0.7200398445129395,
0.21467792987823486,
-0.8131939768791199,
-0.6595086455345154,
-0.23605948686599731,
0.25806695222854614,
-0.6238800883293152,
1.2528082132339478,
0.2422301471233368,
-1.018688678741455,
0.47414717078208923,
-0.6579499840736389,
-0.26623520255088806,
0.1032969281077385,
-0.18054603040218353,
-0.29519256949424744,
-0.17009375989437103,
0.014685769565403461,
0.6553979516029358,
-0.6108298301696777,
0.7005168795585632,
-0.17218677699565887,
0.06919199228286743,
0.06342650949954987,
0.1321786344051361,
0.77488112449646,
0.7634304761886597,
0.07397119700908661,
-0.042152389883995056,
-0.9936350584030151,
0.12052301317453384,
0.21990418434143066,
-0.7371295690536499,
-0.5191638469696045,
0.10233033448457718,
0.2035849690437317,
0.20611080527305603,
0.08140871673822403,
-0.1757691204547882,
0.3688998818397522,
0.16652709245681763,
0.41751402616500854,
0.4223311245441437,
0.1894102245569229,
0.13304388523101807,
-0.059839919209480286,
0.3962905704975128,
-0.23517991602420807,
-0.4693986773490906,
-0.27211692929267883,
-0.2754780650138855,
-0.4791243076324463,
-0.1351531594991684,
0.5537139773368835,
0.25378382205963135,
-0.9270167350769043,
0.3930568993091583,
-0.5773351788520813,
-0.5667809844017029,
0.2418651133775711,
0.14782394468784332,
0.38331741094589233,
0.6348870992660522,
0.1728120893239975,
0.14577320218086243,
-0.6684855818748474,
-0.8592923879623413,
-0.30554619431495667,
-0.37174955010414124,
-0.01842496544122696,
0.4146413803100586,
0.5692437291145325,
-0.05063721910119057,
1.0065323114395142,
-0.5138010382652283,
-0.08277123421430588,
-0.3972415030002594,
0.3964897394180298,
-0.05134950950741768,
0.18762627243995667,
0.9128124713897705,
-0.7232456207275391,
-0.7309842109680176,
0.20129407942295074,
-0.9590967893600464,
-0.47460541129112244,
0.2745138704776764,
-0.21476517617702484,
0.3849552273750305,
0.8300364017486572,
-0.3278905153274536,
0.16338416934013367,
0.5035560131072998,
-0.47608253359794617,
0.5283606052398682,
-0.16965536773204803,
0.26845136284828186,
-1.5333185195922852,
0.6404138803482056,
-0.13295620679855347,
-0.4003286063671112,
-0.5736159086227417,
0.31778591871261597,
0.04956519603729248,
-0.13420386612415314,
-0.24079428613185883,
0.5377413630485535,
-0.43705886602401733,
-0.027429398149251938,
-0.6659683585166931,
0.37659192085266113,
-0.022905757650732994,
0.1799856722354889,
0.027915257960557938,
0.7666390538215637,
0.14677029848098755,
-0.6097595691680908,
0.22961363196372986,
0.15747538208961487,
-0.28176894783973694,
0.3826102018356323,
-0.538139820098877,
0.18615366518497467,
-0.014724751934409142,
0.36417242884635925,
-0.8729953169822693,
-0.13311836123466492,
-0.1539071649312973,
-0.33328330516815186,
0.33845993876457214,
-0.11914199590682983,
-0.9522097706794739,
-0.29986098408699036,
0.026797091588377953,
0.28048038482666016,
0.252871572971344,
-0.6005895733833313,
0.6993910670280457,
0.0458545908331871,
-0.17173801362514496,
-0.4296525716781616,
-0.4065263569355011,
0.1882435381412506,
-0.18609368801116943,
-0.7057304978370667,
0.15307031571865082,
-0.0354931466281414,
-0.4015936255455017,
-0.011061123572289944,
0.1751321256160736,
0.20021255314350128,
-0.16986781358718872,
0.23990607261657715,
-0.008965039625763893,
-0.17297835648059845,
0.43827390670776367,
-0.1753336489200592,
-0.06851858645677567,
-0.11350388824939728,
-0.32172831892967224,
0.7936313152313232,
0.24168963730335236,
-0.046584125608205795,
0.05065847560763359,
0.4314825236797333,
0.49798259139060974,
0.07629052549600601,
0.8555286526679993,
0.38618144392967224,
0.0064146448858082294,
0.13119632005691528,
-0.5350251793861389,
0.05346670001745224,
-0.3624405860900879,
0.3328908383846283,
-0.36380672454833984,
-0.7702886462211609,
0.5094967484474182,
-0.14330266416072845,
0.08495577424764633,
0.6819684505462646,
0.7478898167610168,
0.22423355281352997,
0.6709277629852295,
0.5903401970863342,
-0.17801104485988617,
0.5343764424324036,
-0.11974891275167465,
0.2545834183692932,
-0.6990406513214111,
-0.3393190801143646,
-1.0634490251541138,
-0.022371841594576836,
-0.5805948376655579,
-0.24645490944385529,
0.3680683970451355,
0.3678092062473297,
-0.193261981010437,
0.46839672327041626,
-0.34113016724586487,
0.24348975718021393,
0.7849093079566956,
-0.18116280436515808,
0.4777250587940216,
0.2397412359714508,
-0.43287137150764465,
0.14249972999095917,
-0.8071550726890564,
-0.7489638328552246,
1.4115843772888184,
-0.15411065518856049,
0.36916613578796387,
0.1379861831665039,
0.6621103882789612,
0.38101863861083984,
0.4708137512207031,
-0.5975210666656494,
0.6326019763946533,
-0.1379053145647049,
-0.5368004441261292,
-0.04911244288086891,
-0.5611395239830017,
-1.2097251415252686,
0.44340577721595764,
-0.30431699752807617,
-0.6651091575622559,
-0.12665913999080658,
-0.043960727751255035,
0.1697402447462082,
0.18395866453647614,
-0.5458608269691467,
0.3775044083595276,
0.07048268616199493,
-0.41514262557029724,
-0.17561648786067963,
-0.3278524875640869,
0.3297317326068878,
-0.09103847295045853,
0.09178338944911957,
0.300872802734375,
0.46331918239593506,
0.9057738780975342,
-0.4115728735923767,
0.41666626930236816,
-0.10038480162620544,
-0.19084689021110535,
0.7737876176834106,
0.052960947155952454,
0.9101315140724182,
-0.28229695558547974,
-0.3310609459877014,
-0.04463408887386322,
-0.24665716290473938,
-0.14500050246715546,
-0.3984118700027466,
0.8532236814498901,
-0.7312948703765869,
-0.4803886413574219,
-0.2682940363883972,
-0.9696820378303528,
-0.07530602812767029,
0.3544711768627167,
0.33188533782958984,
0.4039960503578186,
0.030978946015238762,
0.6041768789291382,
0.3095739185810089,
-0.24677316844463348,
0.5924450755119324,
0.532825231552124,
-0.3234570324420929,
-0.622514545917511,
0.5066311955451965,
0.33576634526252747,
0.33888739347457886,
0.5192954540252686,
0.2900867760181427,
-0.4077497720718384,
-0.6127246618270874,
-0.16861878335475922,
0.5413419604301453,
-1.0151804685592651,
-0.3810270130634308,
-0.9017300605773926,
-0.25854983925819397,
-0.8102326393127441,
-0.26398560404777527,
0.02516424097120762,
-0.46809494495391846,
-0.1335892528295517,
-0.2338555008172989,
0.3177553713321686,
0.7223662734031677,
0.07190576940774918,
0.4861832559108734,
-0.5889158248901367,
-0.040236566215753555,
0.32104960083961487,
-0.23506194353103638,
0.002553157974034548,
-0.335520476102829,
-0.2635859549045563,
-0.41362276673316956,
-0.6502501368522644,
-1.0232385396957397,
0.4587330222129822,
-0.20413735508918762,
0.46736323833465576,
0.6276340484619141,
-0.212351456284523,
0.7492837309837341,
-0.2131250649690628,
0.8780218958854675,
0.3435315787792206,
-0.5797078609466553,
0.5537953972816467,
-0.8027876019477844,
0.38967570662498474,
0.4617404639720917,
0.2915896475315094,
-0.28421318531036377,
-0.5054174661636353,
-0.7446830868721008,
-1.0526793003082275,
0.5685433149337769,
0.4931507706642151,
-0.4114741086959839,
-0.14234408736228943,
0.4921437203884125,
0.06291329115629196,
0.17869870364665985,
-1.1164590120315552,
-0.24259820580482483,
0.08964397758245468,
-0.06082671880722046,
-0.013727161101996899,
-0.47300291061401367,
-0.1915321797132492,
0.2972196042537689,
0.8661834001541138,
-0.2689933776855469,
0.10133553296327591,
0.10151123255491257,
0.0005145968170836568,
0.008539887145161629,
0.19272813200950623,
0.7806936502456665,
0.9568315148353577,
-0.18772782385349274,
0.2900039851665497,
0.05603934824466705,
-0.31694144010543823,
-0.26727914810180664,
-0.07708726823329926,
-0.558646559715271,
0.21976278722286224,
0.6532710790634155,
0.4316767454147339,
-0.10232920199632645,
-0.5280334949493408,
0.23410162329673767,
0.2527863383293152,
-0.5548123121261597,
-0.1342334747314453,
0.0049495697021484375,
0.3576093316078186,
0.24420803785324097,
0.5959262847900391,
-0.29729971289634705,
-0.0006390092894434929,
-0.4628865122795105,
-0.21809081733226776,
0.5752671360969543,
0.00457503367215395,
0.05177528038620949,
0.5908328890800476,
0.20507729053497314,
-0.1014745682477951,
0.37425312399864197,
-0.04304119199514389,
-0.3757700026035309,
0.7408955097198486,
0.7955098152160645,
0.6639004349708557,
0.17955055832862854,
0.035801563411951065,
0.9014669060707092,
0.06651382148265839,
-0.04924365133047104,
-0.004022258799523115,
-0.31158074736595154,
-0.4828733801841736,
-0.394550085067749,
-0.585027277469635,
-0.06677908450365067,
0.40258556604385376,
-0.45226040482521057,
0.3461047112941742,
-0.10445541143417358,
-0.318222314119339,
-0.12244287878274918,
0.2191726565361023,
-0.6390158534049988,
0.19677910208702087,
0.036177635192871094,
0.9137653708457947,
-0.8878493905067444,
0.9208824634552002,
0.6433255076408386,
-0.32315757870674133,
-0.9682153463363647,
-0.285995751619339,
-0.13912445306777954,
-0.4896102845668793,
1.1728296279907227,
-0.14029353857040405,
-0.20077787339687347,
-0.1635962575674057,
-0.45199573040008545,
-1.1325019598007202,
1.5857024192810059,
0.26948341727256775,
-0.43558377027511597,
0.1428285390138626,
0.07031350582838058,
0.49900123476982117,
-0.43703481554985046,
0.44815272092819214,
0.28899645805358887,
0.7371177673339844,
0.4308893382549286,
-0.7530490159988403,
0.09592581540346146,
-0.0972251370549202,
0.2181776911020279,
0.20131489634513855,
-0.7876102924346924,
0.6483877897262573,
0.030999798327684402,
-0.2159716933965683,
0.06612122803926468,
0.7492672204971313,
0.7262856960296631,
0.47067010402679443,
0.32785549759864807,
0.5340909361839294,
0.8155466914176941,
-0.23646306991577148,
1.1039706468582153,
-0.41981634497642517,
0.2777116596698761,
1.1009137630462646,
-0.221786767244339,
0.6259292364120483,
0.614736020565033,
-0.1717967689037323,
0.5764643549919128,
0.3706018030643463,
-0.029198691248893738,
0.530390202999115,
-0.043752506375312805,
-0.004010437987744808,
-0.2134610414505005,
-0.08752638101577759,
-0.5748705267906189,
0.2989071309566498,
-0.04573623463511467,
-1.057226538658142,
-0.5430797934532166,
-0.11103454977273941,
0.4911305606365204,
0.14529205858707428,
-0.3738867938518524,
0.6922405958175659,
0.029657913371920586,
-1.1163101196289062,
0.4182600677013397,
0.24875496327877045,
0.23695862293243408,
-0.8950411677360535,
0.17446701228618622,
-0.19892843067646027,
-0.050362586975097656,
-0.13477474451065063,
-0.38658270239830017,
0.07966193556785583,
0.31105396151542664,
-0.4746055603027344,
-0.12172035127878189,
0.839328944683075,
-0.16790643334388733,
-0.5075892210006714,
0.3379078507423401,
0.44590944051742554,
0.2752360701560974,
0.18908876180648804,
-0.25112009048461914,
-0.2519998848438263,
0.08639636635780334,
-0.502004086971283,
0.39303869009017944,
0.3283255100250244,
-0.2020551711320877,
0.7286760807037354,
0.7937886714935303,
0.08579766005277634,
0.1757088154554367,
0.3612445592880249,
0.7288486957550049,
-0.5837767720222473,
-0.43389275670051575,
-0.8310331702232361,
0.20237869024276733,
-0.2798740565776825,
-0.21541354060173035,
1.014981746673584,
0.7599329948425293,
0.4789625406265259,
-0.06739049404859543,
1.0521581172943115,
-0.4677604138851166,
0.2927089035511017,
-0.7018293738365173,
0.5305567979812622,
-0.3353478014469147,
0.057895198464393616,
-0.3251776695251465,
-1.0709136724472046,
-0.4311172664165497,
0.4606476426124573,
-0.403920978307724,
0.36054354906082153,
0.9142905473709106,
0.8101643919944763,
0.2452184110879898,
-0.20204396545886993,
0.26398512721061707,
0.12110577523708344,
0.6277350783348083,
0.4263092279434204,
0.5614328384399414,
-0.33566534519195557,
0.8299555778503418,
0.25390008091926575,
0.17432112991809845,
-0.37958183884620667,
-1.1873160600662231,
-1.1451390981674194,
-0.589281439781189,
-0.40410175919532776,
-0.6464211344718933,
0.029245464131236076,
0.8821543455123901,
0.5682430863380432,
-0.5426614284515381,
-0.05503076687455177,
-0.2870710492134094,
-0.00923348031938076,
-0.040503405034542084,
-0.2820741832256317,
0.8077620267868042,
-0.3385013937950134,
-0.8324664831161499,
0.32433217763900757,
0.10408957302570343,
-0.1555551290512085,
-0.018720071762800217,
-0.23582544922828674,
-0.23340266942977905,
0.06697040796279907,
0.8146162629127502,
0.07977292686700821,
-0.4768022298812866,
-0.3144230246543884,
-0.16070695221424103,
-0.33501705527305603,
-0.12507259845733643,
1.133162260055542,
-0.78955078125,
0.39723411202430725,
0.701632559299469,
0.18794108927249908,
0.6403138041496277,
0.10439649224281311,
0.4645398259162903,
-0.6401699781417847,
-0.13080890476703644,
-0.1506660133600235,
0.4710337221622467,
0.3591679334640503,
-0.165435329079628,
0.8300505876541138,
0.2203240543603897,
-0.8679715394973755,
-0.717650830745697,
0.24840301275253296,
-1.1593371629714966,
-0.5060057044029236,
1.6213678121566772,
-0.04874902218580246,
0.006888556759804487,
0.006062829867005348,
-0.276446133852005,
0.45044592022895813,
-0.25087815523147583,
0.8588346242904663,
0.8815748691558838,
-0.11064425110816956,
0.13592618703842163,
-0.3352212607860565,
0.16481776535511017,
0.010863992385566235,
-0.7013471722602844,
0.0018126675859093666,
0.5610536336898804,
0.38429680466651917,
0.4540897309780121,
0.5218493342399597,
-0.27109870314598083,
0.053813785314559937,
-0.059712935239076614,
0.14375999569892883,
-0.573007345199585,
-0.09869427978992462,
0.24566832184791565,
0.7694965600967407,
0.14584480226039886,
0.31659454107284546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09754v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09754v1
|
Resilience of Large Language Models for Noisy Instructions
| 2024-04-15T12:55:08 | 2024-04-15T12:55:08 |
Bin Wang, Chengwei Wei, Zhengyuan Liu, Geyu Lin, Nancy F. Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As the rapidly advancing domain of natural language processing (NLP), large
language models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful tools for interpreting human
commands and generating text across various tasks. Nonetheless, the resilience
of LLMs to handle text containing inherent errors, stemming from human
interactions and collaborative systems, has not been thoroughly explored. Our
study investigates the resilience of LLMs against five common types of
disruptions including 1) ASR (Automatic Speech Recognition) errors, 2) OCR
(Optical Character Recognition) errors, 3) grammatical mistakes, 4)
typographical errors, and 5) distractive content. We aim to investigate how
these models react by deliberately embedding these errors into instructions.
Our findings reveal that while some LLMs show a degree of resistance to certain
types of noise, their overall performance significantly suffers. This
emphasizes the importance of further investigation into enhancing model
resilience. In response to the observed decline in performance, our study also
evaluates a "re-pass" strategy, designed to purify the instructions of noise
before the LLMs process them. Our analysis indicates that correcting noisy
instructions, particularly for open-source LLMs, presents significant
challenges.
|
[
-0.010022889822721481,
-0.7249915599822998,
0.6101614236831665,
0.27276819944381714,
-0.1620074212551117,
0.08750296384096146,
-0.3972988426685333,
-0.6012563705444336,
-0.16887812316417694,
0.8108517527580261,
-0.45438867807388306,
-0.1519065946340561,
-0.5490296483039856,
0.38469940423965454,
-0.5286296010017395,
0.8802010416984558,
-0.10681580752134323,
0.036831993609666824,
-0.4390369653701782,
-0.14571096003055573,
-0.6276736259460449,
-0.6657864451408386,
-0.8682950139045715,
-0.22040317952632904,
0.34093236923217773,
0.23195534944534302,
0.5271680951118469,
0.592637300491333,
0.8315978050231934,
0.3721967935562134,
-0.2485872060060501,
0.17244893312454224,
-0.43212538957595825,
0.4722343385219574,
-0.2595321834087372,
-0.49098724126815796,
-0.391675740480423,
-0.34965023398399353,
0.8427267074584961,
0.5989811420440674,
-0.28068283200263977,
-0.0791022852063179,
0.382504940032959,
0.7688562273979187,
-0.42050614953041077,
0.25770729780197144,
-0.7613784074783325,
-0.13111470639705658,
-0.19180341064929962,
-0.07114579528570175,
-0.672421932220459,
-0.22281014919281006,
-0.011559123173356056,
-0.3659761846065521,
0.04954703897237778,
-0.03399552404880524,
0.49843695759773254,
0.5834064483642578,
0.17927198112010956,
-0.6370261907577515,
-1.0074210166931152,
0.8882322907447815,
-0.8814334273338318,
0.44551190733909607,
0.4803341031074524,
0.0949215292930603,
-0.4978845715522766,
-0.7222414016723633,
-0.283469557762146,
-0.3404744863510132,
0.22526778280735016,
0.05716366693377495,
-0.3580607771873474,
0.13039621710777283,
0.3381030559539795,
0.25656768679618835,
-0.18880899250507355,
0.4505298435688019,
-0.35535314679145813,
-0.19050124287605286,
0.42240673303604126,
0.3865744173526764,
0.5280709266662598,
0.18299934267997742,
-0.15903140604496002,
-0.03776507079601288,
-0.6322829723358154,
-0.18526704609394073,
0.3244931697845459,
0.351173460483551,
0.01487118098884821,
0.47913995385169983,
0.05969856679439545,
0.6253886222839355,
-0.056043945252895355,
-0.31016862392425537,
-0.11316646635532379,
-0.30559462308883667,
-0.19495046138763428,
0.22548268735408783,
0.8266879320144653,
0.15728092193603516,
0.3390461802482605,
-0.2746678590774536,
-0.44178640842437744,
-0.10418232530355453,
0.6503409743309021,
-0.7078474760055542,
-0.19941169023513794,
0.17827120423316956,
-0.49537742137908936,
-0.16347837448120117,
-0.2381054311990738,
-0.47035685181617737,
-0.6611803770065308,
-0.09961450845003128,
0.43594643473625183,
-0.5825832486152649,
-0.06513737142086029,
0.28554487228393555,
0.1589779406785965,
-0.13094085454940796,
0.5266618728637695,
-0.8093911409378052,
0.3555879592895508,
0.7516282796859741,
0.869605302810669,
0.04522119462490082,
-0.4236934781074524,
-0.42546477913856506,
0.0030928729102015495,
-0.24799394607543945,
0.8328577876091003,
-0.3170137405395508,
-0.4189239740371704,
-0.076321542263031,
0.03791556507349014,
-0.2352447360754013,
-0.751319169998169,
0.8303940296173096,
-0.4805522859096527,
-0.057909585535526276,
-0.2568841874599457,
-0.4742911756038666,
-0.2386718988418579,
0.11185429245233536,
-0.8862050771713257,
0.5347261428833008,
-0.06665563583374023,
-0.8226523995399475,
-0.17582933604717255,
-0.5461909770965576,
-0.4641345143318176,
-0.21749044954776764,
0.013952039182186127,
-0.6373992562294006,
0.3399999439716339,
-0.14279615879058838,
0.31837543845176697,
-0.40873971581459045,
-0.15565146505832672,
-0.3841235339641571,
-0.3865482211112976,
0.4044025242328644,
-0.7382062077522278,
0.663314938545227,
-0.055221185088157654,
-0.12313209474086761,
0.09836741536855698,
-1.0069797039031982,
-0.19300684332847595,
0.21525080502033234,
-0.7734981179237366,
-0.21416567265987396,
0.3906051218509674,
-0.18560320138931274,
0.19703051447868347,
0.01148590911179781,
-0.4001275897026062,
-0.016558531671762466,
-0.277739942073822,
0.640019416809082,
0.8998892903327942,
-0.017028870061039925,
0.14277516305446625,
-0.4719606041908264,
0.44308313727378845,
-0.03771529719233513,
-0.08677903562784195,
-0.23840633034706116,
-0.6292824149131775,
-0.7414456605911255,
-0.0765039324760437,
0.10261689126491547,
0.6100161671638489,
-0.6621535420417786,
0.16496536135673523,
-0.381550669670105,
-0.46609294414520264,
-0.40952616930007935,
0.23799428343772888,
0.5470336079597473,
0.47015029191970825,
0.20235756039619446,
-0.29886743426322937,
-0.6513729691505432,
-0.6186562180519104,
-0.2632750868797302,
-0.29724758863449097,
-0.1024911105632782,
0.037666067481040955,
0.38169530034065247,
-0.39301934838294983,
0.53345787525177,
-0.18845631182193756,
-0.28014075756073,
-0.11859253793954849,
0.02238474227488041,
-0.0023915660567581654,
0.34605783224105835,
0.3339989483356476,
-0.3852466344833374,
-0.19318649172782898,
-0.20874778926372528,
-0.4392554461956024,
-0.34771788120269775,
-0.23608075082302094,
0.2847892940044403,
0.660441517829895,
0.731299102306366,
-0.4487021267414093,
0.3342600464820862,
0.7318366765975952,
-0.2616052031517029,
0.9139689207077026,
-0.3216940760612488,
0.0031912827398627996,
-0.987556517124176,
-0.09537380933761597,
-0.23496843874454498,
-0.1011340394616127,
-0.5563241839408875,
-0.028172211721539497,
-0.3487257957458496,
0.016748210415244102,
-0.28779342770576477,
0.10313235223293304,
-0.47709351778030396,
-0.153909832239151,
-0.3465295433998108,
-0.15385866165161133,
-0.12890374660491943,
0.10621465742588043,
0.19460204243659973,
0.6689610481262207,
0.3190804719924927,
-0.593678891658783,
0.2215229570865631,
0.07481998950242996,
-0.4070087671279907,
0.4830046594142914,
-0.8726283311843872,
0.32522448897361755,
-0.05185822397470474,
0.03606531396508217,
-0.9909999966621399,
-0.34114885330200195,
0.22865471243858337,
-0.31029754877090454,
0.4710196256637573,
-0.010389274917542934,
-0.6347811818122864,
-0.14511120319366455,
-0.18014675378799438,
0.13186730444431305,
0.25093141198158264,
-0.4370531737804413,
0.6731424927711487,
0.15698105096817017,
-0.20702548325061798,
-0.3352494239807129,
-0.8603910803794861,
0.21117110550403595,
-0.10146583616733551,
-0.7856721878051758,
0.08048488199710846,
-0.24791787564754486,
-0.4552195966243744,
0.0719749927520752,
-0.015564016997814178,
-0.1599973440170288,
0.40584906935691833,
0.7055500149726868,
0.08651058375835419,
-0.2997170090675354,
0.01927224174141884,
-0.5136088728904724,
-0.005007476545870304,
0.34421369433403015,
0.09136899560689926,
0.6284602880477905,
-0.21662232279777527,
-0.5871736407279968,
-0.5227153897285461,
0.3008580207824707,
0.9759498834609985,
-0.05969372019171715,
1.056833267211914,
0.46932581067085266,
-0.539440393447876,
-0.1194952055811882,
-0.573976993560791,
-0.13532055914402008,
-0.48150092363357544,
0.5721330046653748,
-0.18563348054885864,
-0.6979173421859741,
0.7713178992271423,
0.09244624525308609,
0.3144616484642029,
0.2639530301094055,
0.45849311351776123,
-0.14190733432769775,
0.6242983937263489,
0.5119960308074951,
-0.2124771922826767,
0.5030027627944946,
0.2756369709968567,
0.1338336169719696,
-0.703274667263031,
-0.1100718304514885,
-0.6639553308486938,
-0.21675431728363037,
-0.44589751958847046,
-0.564078152179718,
0.10882111638784409,
0.011321726255118847,
-0.36536577343940735,
0.1072244644165039,
-0.43048059940338135,
0.29148662090301514,
0.5728951692581177,
0.053166963160037994,
0.4598507285118103,
0.2582983672618866,
0.21926158666610718,
-0.12493248283863068,
-0.6129004955291748,
-0.6927363872528076,
0.7975673079490662,
0.5994546413421631,
1.249456763267517,
0.26290151476860046,
0.7662292718887329,
0.043333496898412704,
0.17952708899974823,
-0.5735490322113037,
0.4736141562461853,
-0.2707826793193817,
-0.42907828092575073,
-0.3446274995803833,
-0.5401044487953186,
-0.9601443409919739,
-0.1488279104232788,
-0.3510870635509491,
-0.8737450838088989,
-0.037257902324199677,
0.03886577486991882,
-0.5928891897201538,
0.6056881546974182,
-0.7930639982223511,
0.5130899548530579,
0.0005005417624488473,
-0.25574246048927307,
-0.04278487712144852,
-0.45379573106765747,
0.3881520628929138,
-0.3706640899181366,
0.32791799306869507,
0.28525757789611816,
-0.09231541305780411,
0.842651903629303,
-0.23022118210792542,
1.0765098333358765,
0.2561458349227905,
-0.32697638869285583,
0.37727805972099304,
0.36783933639526367,
0.6493285894393921,
-0.3739079236984253,
-0.08960650116205215,
0.2635841369628906,
-0.2539252042770386,
-0.006823570001870394,
-0.3811624050140381,
0.7472820281982422,
-0.8203582167625427,
-0.6191824078559875,
-0.2752492129802704,
-0.6045817732810974,
0.011623990722000599,
0.12409307807683945,
0.2636163830757141,
0.36987075209617615,
0.03927163779735565,
0.44689351320266724,
0.8243457674980164,
-0.43628233671188354,
0.6865496635437012,
0.608532726764679,
-0.04694538563489914,
-0.573370099067688,
0.9198169708251953,
0.5439192652702332,
0.7132826447486877,
-0.019337322562932968,
0.09361003339290619,
0.04751352220773697,
-0.8470243811607361,
-0.20117612183094025,
0.04548463597893715,
-0.6807741522789001,
-0.16436603665351868,
-0.5983904004096985,
-0.46907931566238403,
-0.1785336583852768,
-0.24170255661010742,
-0.5932862162590027,
-0.28513476252555847,
-0.58865886926651,
0.01581922173500061,
0.31450411677360535,
1.0571480989456177,
0.013756781816482544,
-0.001566823571920395,
-1.1564897298812866,
0.26890072226524353,
0.14974051713943481,
0.6072436571121216,
0.18206876516342163,
-0.825508713722229,
-0.2001114934682846,
0.03635744750499725,
-0.21520110964775085,
-0.6548910140991211,
0.25631675124168396,
0.24920856952667236,
0.4468052089214325,
0.24732792377471924,
0.08852289617061615,
0.6068277359008789,
-0.7036135792732239,
0.7328274250030518,
0.08988569676876068,
-0.6683958768844604,
0.3526500165462494,
-0.3714751899242401,
0.36372196674346924,
0.3105555772781372,
0.04813184589147568,
-0.45379388332366943,
-0.5273054838180542,
-0.5156292915344238,
-0.8796875476837158,
0.7135780453681946,
0.05631130188703537,
0.0693836584687233,
0.002967441687360406,
0.35301777720451355,
-0.12352772802114487,
-0.12281211465597153,
-0.7132288217544556,
0.04999951645731926,
-0.057577431201934814,
-0.09120558202266693,
0.13609878718852997,
-0.6630122065544128,
0.027435455471277237,
0.32455456256866455,
0.5575851202011108,
0.09380315989255905,
0.17204688489437103,
0.19902072846889496,
-0.05307041481137276,
-0.2912541627883911,
0.35439449548721313,
0.8153162002563477,
0.2854260802268982,
-0.2388492226600647,
0.156219020485878,
0.22109603881835938,
-0.8541263341903687,
0.13175997138023376,
-0.08593074977397919,
-0.12801605463027954,
-0.1613893359899521,
0.8152098655700684,
0.5684646368026733,
0.3968310058116913,
-0.7624609470367432,
0.014486209489405155,
-0.20301473140716553,
0.009685700759291649,
-0.37199079990386963,
0.08393023908138275,
0.462454617023468,
0.11298514902591705,
0.1484086513519287,
0.29326772689819336,
-0.1274673044681549,
-0.7506412863731384,
0.09333664178848267,
0.2346433848142624,
-0.2827446460723877,
-0.3180098235607147,
0.6830828189849854,
0.12097954005002975,
-0.5916266441345215,
0.6739487648010254,
-0.08386518061161041,
-0.487834095954895,
0.45217767357826233,
0.780529797077179,
0.9719065427780151,
-0.3114493787288666,
-0.21392714977264404,
0.23691603541374207,
0.6168503165245056,
-0.42961403727531433,
0.18689090013504028,
0.5031906962394714,
-0.8570948243141174,
-0.4987335801124573,
-0.624920666217804,
-0.5268211960792542,
0.09296316653490067,
-0.675187885761261,
-0.09082864969968796,
-0.8667068481445312,
-0.12685833871364594,
-0.20061041414737701,
-0.2491837739944458,
-0.2913268804550171,
0.013630105182528496,
0.42990562319755554,
0.8015642166137695,
-0.7686575055122375,
0.5075116157531738,
0.6804717779159546,
-0.3005106449127197,
-0.7910131812095642,
0.10837963223457336,
0.15800175070762634,
-0.6307343244552612,
0.5806150436401367,
0.1668054461479187,
-0.23481151461601257,
-0.28494954109191895,
-0.30002567172050476,
-0.7951188087463379,
0.8904375433921814,
0.692844808101654,
-0.8341754078865051,
0.14262482523918152,
0.18538540601730347,
0.6366208791732788,
0.0006480840966105461,
0.04707387089729309,
0.4386383295059204,
0.2504865229129791,
0.060665395110845566,
-1.1361379623413086,
0.24170078337192535,
0.10111971199512482,
-0.08423078060150146,
0.09632308036088943,
-0.7618902921676636,
0.6773969531059265,
-0.3290989100933075,
-0.27543485164642334,
0.13381920754909515,
0.5372968316078186,
0.35406985878944397,
0.10196384787559509,
0.504269540309906,
0.7828971743583679,
0.7706552147865295,
-0.07588619738817215,
1.0930850505828857,
-0.19683784246444702,
-0.03604988753795624,
1.3666999340057373,
-0.21036334335803986,
1.1185317039489746,
0.3628675639629364,
-0.2165217399597168,
0.4744589030742645,
0.29272937774658203,
0.09783808141946793,
0.2609875202178955,
0.2317662239074707,
-0.2784019112586975,
-0.2032371163368225,
-0.0999889224767685,
-0.24802479147911072,
0.4812617897987366,
0.4839915931224823,
-0.4690878987312317,
-0.1642511934041977,
-0.0702303871512413,
-0.01486727874726057,
0.1386469602584839,
-0.5113285183906555,
0.8389833569526672,
0.2915700674057007,
-0.5026472806930542,
0.5909661650657654,
-0.15373173356056213,
0.6554681062698364,
-0.38380566239356995,
-0.08299095928668976,
0.1588321477174759,
0.4185968339443207,
-0.38264748454093933,
-0.8235547542572021,
0.6361474394798279,
-0.018965277820825577,
-0.5657712817192078,
-0.07819497585296631,
0.9389016032218933,
-0.2464006245136261,
-0.5064088106155396,
0.37898164987564087,
0.011811084114015102,
0.15129798650741577,
-0.17956387996673584,
-0.49676766991615295,
0.641270637512207,
0.051114264875650406,
-0.23756827414035797,
0.5681003332138062,
0.4381592273712158,
-0.029797524213790894,
1.0202635526657104,
0.595500648021698,
0.116201251745224,
0.19162939488887787,
0.09477784484624863,
0.8127027750015259,
-0.568130373954773,
-0.013685147278010845,
-1.0983867645263672,
0.47113150358200073,
0.1436918079853058,
0.028577566146850586,
0.8620555996894836,
0.2130100578069687,
0.6153812408447266,
-0.033564742654561996,
0.6388033032417297,
0.3303198516368866,
0.460534006357193,
-0.5632150173187256,
0.8207401633262634,
-0.11490878462791443,
0.6414011120796204,
-0.30035626888275146,
-0.6957892179489136,
-0.40018513798713684,
0.459758996963501,
-0.16913656890392303,
-0.09987280517816544,
0.42493581771850586,
0.7557694911956787,
0.25378653407096863,
0.025831378996372223,
0.36147281527519226,
0.49453258514404297,
0.35560423135757446,
0.557094395160675,
0.7829332947731018,
-0.21703694760799408,
0.8163322806358337,
-0.12106110155582428,
0.026600826531648636,
-0.2993176281452179,
-0.8177404999732971,
-0.8497165441513062,
-0.3546372652053833,
-0.525336742401123,
-0.7206763625144958,
0.12269886583089828,
0.726345419883728,
0.2335589975118637,
-0.7225396633148193,
0.04037288576364517,
-0.18480417132377625,
0.1831650733947754,
-0.23516182601451874,
-0.17126019299030304,
0.31689727306365967,
-0.42450767755508423,
-0.4954935610294342,
0.3936697840690613,
0.3634345531463623,
0.19035325944423676,
-0.21636417508125305,
-0.036041051149368286,
0.05548234283924103,
0.1937028169631958,
0.5285553932189941,
0.33367565274238586,
-0.741988480091095,
-0.49564293026924133,
-0.07866379618644714,
-0.15299329161643982,
-0.09901618957519531,
0.45347246527671814,
-0.37425199151039124,
0.502680778503418,
0.4596518576145172,
0.8014630079269409,
-0.3472851514816284,
-0.1140439361333847,
0.6407731175422668,
-0.5236093997955322,
-0.08710682392120361,
0.28570273518562317,
0.5869761109352112,
0.5680927634239197,
-0.27315452694892883,
0.4636622965335846,
0.1591859608888626,
-0.8708022236824036,
-1.0171831846237183,
0.14424730837345123,
-0.7774812579154968,
-0.1979963779449463,
1.3710652589797974,
-0.44197219610214233,
-0.345533162355423,
-0.2396860420703888,
-0.34765923023223877,
0.0022023601923137903,
-0.20444436371326447,
0.9761353731155396,
0.9873561263084412,
0.0072397030889987946,
-0.3136312663555145,
-0.6140875220298767,
0.4100256860256195,
0.12251705676317215,
-0.5013983249664307,
0.41771960258483887,
0.5351794362068176,
0.4286879897117615,
0.529477596282959,
0.4372878670692444,
-0.17609964311122894,
0.24488607048988342,
0.28301262855529785,
0.013556044548749924,
-0.18958331644535065,
-0.14543072879314423,
-0.5394467115402222,
0.12821584939956665,
0.48522111773490906,
-0.22451676428318024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09753v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09753v1
|
Personalized Collaborative Fine-Tuning for On-Device Large Language Models
| 2024-04-15T12:54:31 | 2024-04-15T12:54:31 |
Nicolas Wagner, Dongyang Fan, Martin Jaggi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We explore on-device self-supervised collaborative fine-tuning of large
language models with limited local data availability. Taking inspiration from
the collaborative learning community, we introduce three distinct
trust-weighted gradient aggregation schemes: weight similarity-based,
prediction similarity-based and validation performance-based. To minimize
communication overhead, we integrate Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) and only
exchange LoRA weight updates. Our protocols, driven by prediction and
performance metrics, surpass both FedAvg and local fine-tuning methods, which
is particularly evident in realistic scenarios with more diverse local data
distributions. The results underscore the effectiveness of our approach in
addressing heterogeneity and scarcity within local datasets.
|
[
-0.5332472920417786,
-0.6810157895088196,
0.4065188467502594,
0.10803548991680145,
0.1566779464483261,
0.2028043270111084,
-0.5470610857009888,
-0.3851992189884186,
0.38827016949653625,
0.5238134264945984,
-0.43496066331863403,
-0.4686400294303894,
-0.2590779662132263,
-0.12622873485088348,
0.0037002728786319494,
0.9533262252807617,
-0.025718923658132553,
-0.024552468210458755,
-0.2430659532546997,
-0.5762897729873657,
-0.4637311100959778,
-0.2123824805021286,
-1.0039212703704834,
-0.31983640789985657,
0.634850800037384,
0.8873093128204346,
0.7307434678077698,
0.8364572525024414,
0.7152186036109924,
0.33001142740249634,
0.09953407943248749,
0.3397751450538635,
-0.6758387088775635,
0.13946424424648285,
-0.4064946174621582,
-0.3498185873031616,
-0.8140202164649963,
-0.07789549976587296,
0.3785886764526367,
0.9596214294433594,
-0.5052729845046997,
0.2160198986530304,
0.19202125072479248,
0.7853960990905762,
-0.7615783214569092,
-0.06923472136259079,
-0.7867366075515747,
-0.054958608001470566,
-0.07912392169237137,
0.041290756314992905,
-0.21633844077587128,
-0.47495585680007935,
0.1157897487282753,
-0.9032955765724182,
0.3638477027416229,
0.2508642375469208,
0.34724804759025574,
0.48785123229026794,
-0.15679731965065002,
-0.14972443878650665,
-0.7570629119873047,
1.0423918962478638,
-0.5539997816085815,
0.2591246962547302,
0.7111480832099915,
0.3090626299381256,
-0.12221068888902664,
-0.8283029198646545,
-0.28676432371139526,
-0.05847733095288277,
0.06924054771661758,
-0.0058572907000780106,
-0.073695108294487,
-0.0056229629553854465,
-0.07192530483007431,
0.6291339993476868,
-0.35360240936279297,
0.5826704502105713,
-0.1336362063884735,
-0.2007768750190735,
0.7182448506355286,
0.12133651971817017,
-0.054507892578840256,
0.4694289565086365,
-0.26173898577690125,
0.27658361196517944,
-0.5765933394432068,
-0.06660424172878265,
0.09086918085813522,
0.6644591093063354,
-0.6322174072265625,
0.2600344717502594,
-0.8656629920005798,
0.7237561941146851,
0.6948847770690918,
-0.05108129233121872,
0.3859919309616089,
-0.5380629301071167,
-0.3399185538291931,
0.17683179676532745,
0.776850700378418,
0.30590125918388367,
0.1415884792804718,
-0.32187649607658386,
-0.026156149804592133,
-0.3243149220943451,
-0.06969158351421356,
-0.5297653079032898,
-0.39265206456184387,
0.0869685485959053,
-0.48899102210998535,
-0.4549297094345093,
-0.23312802612781525,
-0.6142653822898865,
-0.7004817128181458,
-0.4013148248195648,
0.6058173775672913,
0.08077014237642288,
0.08537975698709488,
0.3408071994781494,
0.24075199663639069,
-0.4159371256828308,
0.4918513298034668,
-1.2714264392852783,
0.5537420511245728,
0.526220440864563,
0.8913860321044922,
-0.4559495449066162,
-0.4902556836605072,
-0.9346046447753906,
0.16275383532047272,
0.04876883327960968,
0.5807477831840515,
-0.49515485763549805,
-0.1715123951435089,
-0.1596834510564804,
0.09858972579240799,
-0.12645967304706573,
-0.5784093737602234,
0.4927598536014557,
-0.25562071800231934,
0.34626173973083496,
-0.39070504903793335,
-0.5159602165222168,
0.14870236814022064,
-0.021561725065112114,
-0.5776281356811523,
0.9496886134147644,
0.28596651554107666,
-0.7875441312789917,
0.507295548915863,
-0.5886048078536987,
-0.47405290603637695,
-0.05907941609621048,
0.1951603889465332,
-0.4722449481487274,
0.23779575526714325,
0.48773011565208435,
0.817922055721283,
-0.44740036129951477,
0.02640935219824314,
-0.6742398142814636,
-0.2554570734500885,
-0.2581918239593506,
0.05593032389879227,
0.4996222257614136,
0.5870429277420044,
-0.15714962780475616,
0.22419719398021698,
-0.9903478026390076,
0.05396611988544464,
-0.056257858872413635,
-0.2499421089887619,
-0.5075637102127075,
0.06766128540039062,
-0.13730360567569733,
-0.08117205649614334,
0.7544319033622742,
-0.6340702176094055,
0.3351004123687744,
-0.26338592171669006,
0.5408065915107727,
0.707751989364624,
-0.037130869925022125,
0.8108492493629456,
-0.49808675050735474,
0.2946901321411133,
-0.05879708752036095,
0.21264038980007172,
0.05536378175020218,
-0.28588148951530457,
-0.6026706695556641,
-0.39340248703956604,
0.4090021550655365,
0.328274130821228,
-0.624370276927948,
0.4458020329475403,
-0.45090264081954956,
-0.6145090460777283,
-0.5622587203979492,
0.5811243653297424,
0.2942667305469513,
0.6070737838745117,
0.32051581144332886,
-0.5544642806053162,
-0.330188125371933,
-0.7603810429573059,
-0.028086842969059944,
0.08372779190540314,
-0.03093903698027134,
0.580790102481842,
-0.007786654867231846,
-0.38251426815986633,
0.9647665023803711,
-0.5275797843933105,
-0.6542964577674866,
-0.054716967046260834,
0.135716512799263,
0.023580683395266533,
0.5853267312049866,
0.5660197138786316,
-0.411380797624588,
-0.784963846206665,
0.6455325484275818,
-0.539731502532959,
-0.1944168508052826,
-0.008710958994925022,
0.21895505487918854,
0.046607114374637604,
0.5102230310440063,
-0.12165037542581558,
-0.21533064544200897,
1.0966931581497192,
-0.24738375842571259,
-0.024387555196881294,
-0.741436243057251,
0.17637409269809723,
-1.2690349817276,
-0.32384636998176575,
0.17676596343517303,
-0.5325298309326172,
-0.3781457543373108,
0.012834634631872177,
-0.14535506069660187,
0.11587612330913544,
-0.2452448010444641,
0.6189725995063782,
-0.1996045708656311,
-0.12833698093891144,
-0.12165436893701553,
0.3294453024864197,
-0.15032494068145752,
0.3581089675426483,
-0.18993337452411652,
0.7081907391548157,
0.7507345080375671,
-0.5181613564491272,
0.4631839394569397,
0.06588947772979736,
-0.25393274426460266,
0.7752832174301147,
-0.6402238607406616,
0.1594574898481369,
0.22902530431747437,
0.05317862704396248,
-0.6863330602645874,
-0.4060581624507904,
-0.12154197692871094,
-0.19615724682807922,
-0.10297564417123795,
-0.10142866522073746,
-0.3428049087524414,
-0.011211870238184929,
-0.25761085748672485,
0.34792807698249817,
0.3815319538116455,
-0.8338413834571838,
0.5105074644088745,
0.6175090074539185,
-0.15795579552650452,
-0.23084311187267303,
-0.429171621799469,
-0.2744840383529663,
-0.25899598002433777,
-0.6034688949584961,
0.3017823398113251,
-0.23061692714691162,
-0.306571364402771,
-0.21204249560832977,
0.1417907178401947,
-0.2572428286075592,
0.39646920561790466,
0.4180283546447754,
-0.38705170154571533,
-0.23751972615718842,
0.09341426193714142,
0.3283422589302063,
0.18188951909542084,
-0.38963940739631653,
-0.30510029196739197,
0.468786358833313,
-0.2648746371269226,
-0.20826056599617004,
-0.5372055172920227,
-0.03271614387631416,
0.48964354395866394,
-0.31016260385513306,
0.7713792324066162,
0.9408989548683167,
-0.2739819586277008,
-0.2949813902378082,
-0.6233522891998291,
-0.14881007373332977,
-0.5768089890480042,
0.14662639796733856,
-0.3449209928512573,
-1.3804967403411865,
0.8486163020133972,
-0.23195861279964447,
-0.21420209109783173,
0.2199181169271469,
0.8187925815582275,
-0.2605186402797699,
0.9229135513305664,
0.8226263523101807,
-0.594501793384552,
0.577584981918335,
0.08143755793571472,
-0.06330390274524689,
-0.608156144618988,
-0.0254279226064682,
-0.6581881046295166,
-0.3211069405078888,
-0.8627174496650696,
-0.3240267038345337,
0.26562246680259705,
0.155176043510437,
-0.417344331741333,
0.2901492714881897,
-0.4633534848690033,
0.6210265159606934,
0.6914652585983276,
0.16309630870819092,
0.5375579595565796,
0.3080539405345917,
0.04180043190717697,
-0.00006306696013780311,
-0.7304790019989014,
0.06721669435501099,
1.1345826387405396,
0.39601460099220276,
0.9190401434898376,
0.023311756551265717,
0.6450688242912292,
0.5616841912269592,
0.1082088053226471,
-0.5704334378242493,
0.20257532596588135,
-0.462774395942688,
-0.2776089012622833,
-0.45569542050361633,
-0.5900017619132996,
-1.106044888496399,
-0.0008271722472272813,
-0.21752336621284485,
-0.940003514289856,
0.26392677426338196,
0.45838046073913574,
-0.3837977349758148,
0.2164987325668335,
-0.8790597915649414,
0.7466296553611755,
-0.01073218323290348,
-0.6186034083366394,
-0.5627609491348267,
-0.3697744905948639,
0.055309344083070755,
-0.50283282995224,
0.30383890867233276,
0.04188711941242218,
0.05832723528146744,
0.5694999694824219,
-0.4425942897796631,
0.8092780709266663,
-0.15986821055412292,
-0.16497480869293213,
0.1386154294013977,
0.13714885711669922,
0.7656893134117126,
0.08778060972690582,
-0.32111212611198425,
0.14825282990932465,
-0.08006740361452103,
-0.4160231053829193,
-0.45366865396499634,
1.3211026191711426,
-0.9432717561721802,
-0.22708310186862946,
0.09531220048666,
-0.4927268326282501,
-0.5927291512489319,
0.3093302845954895,
0.11174418032169342,
0.2754760980606079,
-0.13969551026821136,
0.5484765768051147,
0.5541141033172607,
-0.1325979232788086,
0.3073374927043915,
0.6654953956604004,
-0.07494725286960602,
-0.4814162850379944,
1.160046100616455,
-0.15846991539001465,
0.34968093037605286,
0.34269315004348755,
0.3752087354660034,
0.06643711775541306,
-0.7452189922332764,
-0.2724095582962036,
0.16369326412677765,
-0.40095141530036926,
-0.030208207666873932,
-0.3414364755153656,
0.312978059053421,
-0.3797227740287781,
-0.442149817943573,
-0.6601197123527527,
-0.3761664628982544,
-0.40244022011756897,
0.07133253663778305,
0.5910695195198059,
0.6731605529785156,
-0.13206948339939117,
0.7919236421585083,
-0.6222158670425415,
0.16344285011291504,
0.1861318051815033,
0.8370429277420044,
-0.1865985244512558,
-0.6645749807357788,
-0.784166157245636,
0.1434008777141571,
-0.06338038295507431,
-0.020610343664884567,
0.16687263548374176,
0.38883429765701294,
0.38717880845069885,
0.36335036158561707,
0.048959773033857346,
0.6404867768287659,
-0.3120402991771698,
0.7155504822731018,
0.09147525578737259,
-0.9255094528198242,
0.438970685005188,
-0.7147341370582581,
0.2696431279182434,
0.928999125957489,
0.3355291783809662,
-0.3666527569293976,
-0.19207683205604553,
-0.3820769488811493,
-0.37831658124923706,
0.5755266547203064,
-0.1387181580066681,
0.15842777490615845,
0.3713308572769165,
0.4704456329345703,
0.22005392611026764,
0.06369032710790634,
-0.3052076995372772,
-0.2607918679714203,
-0.008495563641190529,
-0.40592336654663086,
-0.3216935098171234,
0.25523024797439575,
-0.07442769408226013,
-0.4396943747997284,
0.453416645526886,
-0.4407540559768677,
-0.12886746227741241,
0.04717819392681122,
0.04434475675225258,
-0.4161910116672516,
-0.09156380593776703,
0.5098878145217896,
0.5448299646377563,
-0.2538169026374817,
-0.2204916626214981,
0.41519078612327576,
-0.49844667315483093,
-0.14175130426883698,
0.017095807939767838,
-0.009911837987601757,
-0.4196639657020569,
0.06214810162782669,
0.929672360420227,
0.1968480348587036,
-0.41806504130363464,
0.32080185413360596,
-0.22599521279335022,
-0.25677433609962463,
-0.0446145236492157,
0.20503805577754974,
0.045104339718818665,
0.1963733732700348,
0.010057765990495682,
0.24844467639923096,
0.07811378687620163,
-0.36818429827690125,
0.04519010707736015,
0.5144608020782471,
-0.6174883842468262,
-0.4477744996547699,
0.6565873622894287,
0.49789461493492126,
-0.2101055532693863,
0.13555404543876648,
-0.07907766848802567,
0.1203237846493721,
0.40384790301322937,
0.29346129298210144,
0.622653603553772,
-0.3605010211467743,
0.38552534580230713,
0.23671820759773254,
0.11126832664012909,
-0.39394932985305786,
0.12611444294452667,
-0.12443143874406815,
-0.9009914994239807,
-0.3911476731300354,
-0.522598385810852,
-0.577711820602417,
0.16506461799144745,
-0.6836093664169312,
0.2162529081106186,
-0.6750446557998657,
0.0022175791673362255,
0.023647624999284744,
0.2228240668773651,
-0.5910628437995911,
0.30678674578666687,
-0.014586116187274456,
0.6950985789299011,
-0.824773371219635,
1.1597379446029663,
0.6296310424804688,
0.025589436292648315,
-0.8549230694770813,
-0.20319189131259918,
-0.24626871943473816,
-0.6411693692207336,
0.24550621211528778,
-0.47781267762184143,
-0.16163977980613708,
0.25491610169410706,
-0.4666424095630646,
-1.121680736541748,
1.1433368921279907,
0.38029298186302185,
-0.7071239352226257,
0.1771351844072342,
-0.041187480092048645,
0.7929511070251465,
-0.47962865233421326,
-0.20792360603809357,
0.466680645942688,
0.2645891308784485,
-0.07712573558092117,
-1.5936026573181152,
-0.10332345217466354,
0.2916989326477051,
-0.28237470984458923,
0.06382066756486893,
-0.9278847575187683,
0.8178167939186096,
-0.22322362661361694,
0.2883382737636566,
0.05645237863063812,
0.45310401916503906,
-0.04321172088384628,
0.4443812370300293,
0.3789931833744049,
0.5540457367897034,
1.046980381011963,
0.18361297249794006,
1.0817744731903076,
-0.3584093749523163,
0.5710005164146423,
1.4637670516967773,
-0.48438772559165955,
0.7270843982696533,
0.25991740822792053,
-0.09655631333589554,
0.31036481261253357,
0.47068384289741516,
-0.04784092679619789,
0.6423016786575317,
-0.15987028181552887,
-0.24945834279060364,
-0.2787122130393982,
-0.3569147288799286,
-0.269840806722641,
0.5715446472167969,
0.2391800582408905,
-0.4142468571662903,
-0.013483947142958641,
0.014472396112978458,
-0.14961104094982147,
0.22218601405620575,
-0.7843282222747803,
0.7909916639328003,
-0.005981429014354944,
-0.5286043286323547,
0.5311777591705322,
0.24856744706630707,
0.7902547121047974,
-0.25255072116851807,
0.4533180296421051,
-0.4100739061832428,
0.43798142671585083,
-0.31668663024902344,
-0.2493065595626831,
-0.09308572858572006,
-0.3937841057777405,
-0.1817673295736313,
-0.24244484305381775,
0.7487068772315979,
-0.3547094464302063,
-0.3801253139972687,
0.23507244884967804,
0.7049601078033447,
-0.2610742747783661,
-0.03036370314657688,
-0.6147361397743225,
0.07142176479101181,
-0.022157197818160057,
-0.16921575367450714,
0.6482733488082886,
0.4710603654384613,
-0.25376397371292114,
1.0142149925231934,
0.5819634199142456,
0.27383360266685486,
-0.01616636849939823,
0.19913539290428162,
0.7113649845123291,
-0.16147056221961975,
-0.49376341700553894,
-0.5335288643836975,
0.09280021488666534,
0.037954431027173996,
-0.30527254939079285,
0.9071968197822571,
0.5326263308525085,
1.1169666051864624,
-0.022615840658545494,
0.7732115387916565,
0.20787854492664337,
0.6617071032524109,
-0.35936325788497925,
0.8295819759368896,
-0.6386783123016357,
0.20249159634113312,
-0.2930208742618561,
-0.7242171168327332,
-0.33041033148765564,
0.5028663873672485,
-0.3424314260482788,
0.04305737838149071,
0.41140487790107727,
0.7786092162132263,
-0.3934214115142822,
-0.0029349580872803926,
0.3043976128101349,
0.1235988512635231,
-0.08599182963371277,
0.4655272662639618,
0.25788867473602295,
-0.303433358669281,
0.14399035274982452,
-0.45250338315963745,
-0.10116176307201385,
-0.32604625821113586,
-0.885866641998291,
-0.9830437302589417,
-0.6307839155197144,
-0.5383281111717224,
-0.13214382529258728,
-0.029031837359070778,
1.0036683082580566,
1.0035619735717773,
-0.885458767414093,
-0.17458409070968628,
-0.13855043053627014,
0.15650945901870728,
-0.15530990064144135,
-0.11895287781953812,
0.22996021807193756,
-0.10216663777828217,
-0.6704026460647583,
0.3400025963783264,
0.0072003938257694244,
-0.08774758875370026,
-0.22426879405975342,
-0.31448206305503845,
0.2802080810070038,
-0.16553550958633423,
0.5322946310043335,
0.36488577723503113,
-0.3882536292076111,
-0.35994356870651245,
-0.1901470571756363,
-0.13386084139347076,
0.12394263595342636,
0.8295068144798279,
-0.9409911632537842,
0.38131967186927795,
0.4182104468345642,
0.6571508049964905,
0.38733261823654175,
0.2762068510055542,
0.5716787576675415,
-0.8659411072731018,
0.15669377148151398,
-0.14337126910686493,
0.34875738620758057,
0.28741884231567383,
-0.2932664453983307,
0.3660851716995239,
0.07546105980873108,
-0.8300603032112122,
-0.8593270182609558,
0.06688808649778366,
-1.243910551071167,
0.08123919367790222,
1.035483479499817,
-0.18663997948169708,
0.15626554191112518,
-0.15515519678592682,
-0.10626666992902756,
-0.08390089869499207,
-0.4868517220020294,
0.8647012710571289,
0.4487120807170868,
0.012078779749572277,
-0.1631990522146225,
-0.29027822613716125,
0.5619537830352783,
0.4354042112827301,
-0.859244167804718,
0.20288869738578796,
0.3915686011314392,
0.3865681290626526,
0.05389738827943802,
0.6440821290016174,
0.3319163918495178,
0.10600640624761581,
-0.4474094808101654,
-0.051118090748786926,
-0.1548248529434204,
-0.12183807045221329,
-0.5665929317474365,
0.17334811389446259,
0.43435344099998474,
-0.029157303273677826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09737v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09737v1
|
Quantization of Large Language Models with an Overdetermined Basis
| 2024-04-15T12:38:46 | 2024-04-15T12:38:46 |
Daniil Merkulov, Daria Cherniuk, Alexander Rudikov, Ivan Oseledets, Ekaterina Muravleva, Aleksandr Mikhalev, Boris Kashin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce an algorithm for data quantization based on the
principles of Kashin representation. This approach hinges on decomposing any
given vector, matrix, or tensor into two factors. The first factor maintains a
small infinity norm, while the second exhibits a similarly constrained norm
when multiplied by an orthogonal matrix. Surprisingly, the entries of factors
after decomposition are well-concentrated around several peaks, which allows us
to efficiently replace them with corresponding centroids for quantization
purposes. We study the theoretical properties of the proposed approach and
rigorously evaluate our compression algorithm in the context of next-word
prediction tasks and on a set of downstream tasks for text classification. Our
findings demonstrate that Kashin Quantization achieves competitive or superior
quality in model performance while ensuring data compression, marking a
significant advancement in the field of data quantization.
|
[
-0.26472482085227966,
-0.5979040861129761,
0.8167390823364258,
0.22784535586833954,
-0.5091981291770935,
0.08260765671730042,
-0.5833820700645447,
-0.30151820182800293,
0.1588912159204483,
0.4032757580280304,
-0.34672290086746216,
-0.713270366191864,
-0.716503918170929,
-0.12946093082427979,
-0.5713694095611572,
0.791130781173706,
0.07176535576581955,
0.26261472702026367,
-0.23696179687976837,
-0.3058086633682251,
-0.49833300709724426,
-0.899071455001831,
-0.4825022220611572,
-0.2384621500968933,
0.21072587370872498,
0.3985554873943329,
0.8143813014030457,
0.7582107186317444,
0.31379780173301697,
0.28647857904434204,
0.05129697918891907,
-0.17651288211345673,
-0.4497145116329193,
0.2779790759086609,
0.2040623277425766,
-0.9009931683540344,
-0.17974455654621124,
-0.006436610594391823,
0.9778364300727844,
0.8047350645065308,
-0.16161009669303894,
0.30727556347846985,
-0.17803031206130981,
0.825356125831604,
-0.6410210728645325,
0.23283696174621582,
-0.3566916286945343,
-0.011559226550161839,
-0.21594201028347015,
-0.2577942907810211,
-0.4597221314907074,
-0.42611485719680786,
-0.31642386317253113,
-0.6509090065956116,
0.1147911325097084,
-0.08557620644569397,
0.7800852060317993,
0.19557249546051025,
-0.5566751956939697,
0.010553416796028614,
-0.8326960206031799,
1.1803680658340454,
-0.6489396691322327,
0.6434476971626282,
0.7625071406364441,
0.45990097522735596,
0.07253262400627136,
-0.37921586632728577,
-0.6291278004646301,
-0.0015679247444495559,
-0.1778467893600464,
-0.22009646892547607,
-0.041379835456609726,
0.06446690112352371,
0.23630306124687195,
0.5759756565093994,
-0.5788695812225342,
0.08091415464878082,
-0.4442582130432129,
-0.07472453266382217,
0.7778946161270142,
0.13198690116405487,
0.16369099915027618,
-0.16794490814208984,
-0.10896877199411392,
-0.3463107943534851,
-0.6888728737831116,
-0.03969069942831993,
0.31226661801338196,
0.13916099071502686,
0.32597625255584717,
0.6869118213653564,
-0.4156946539878845,
0.5028454661369324,
0.05919970944523811,
-0.12526492774486542,
0.156393900513649,
-0.21614037454128265,
-0.2414795309305191,
0.09542529284954071,
0.7059923410415649,
0.15039774775505066,
0.09843380749225616,
-0.00544580677524209,
-0.2797568440437317,
0.5004194378852844,
0.2414892315864563,
-0.8223149180412292,
-0.07595974206924438,
0.39349400997161865,
-0.651151716709137,
-0.48858997225761414,
-0.05147683992981911,
-0.6964772939682007,
-0.25194233655929565,
-0.40057870745658875,
0.7852456569671631,
-0.42038244009017944,
-0.01933293230831623,
0.3472265899181366,
0.16527006030082703,
0.005642940755933523,
0.01558892522007227,
-0.8434451222419739,
0.6133419275283813,
0.8154367208480835,
0.9174016714096069,
0.2710290551185608,
0.17514923214912415,
-0.4247094690799713,
0.024747231975197792,
-0.4684346616268158,
0.4999437928199768,
-0.6360188722610474,
-0.3938843905925751,
-0.0960485115647316,
-0.3248277008533478,
0.42792651057243347,
-0.16945107281208038,
0.39622652530670166,
-0.5015612244606018,
0.011791813187301159,
-0.25447919964790344,
-0.7488616108894348,
-0.26653537154197693,
0.03179456293582916,
-0.843058705329895,
0.6792630553245544,
0.33826181292533875,
-0.4958975911140442,
0.29419630765914917,
-0.42681166529655457,
-0.4571555554866791,
0.12498929351568222,
-0.10257353633642197,
-0.5731136202812195,
0.4709029495716095,
0.16923788189888,
0.6849539875984192,
-0.5649813413619995,
0.3198513388633728,
-0.1559627205133438,
-0.24836046993732452,
0.22482846677303314,
-0.10642191767692566,
0.7877786159515381,
0.1584777683019638,
-0.12013914436101913,
-0.07198841869831085,
-0.9767042398452759,
0.3105528950691223,
0.16024267673492432,
-0.18901924788951874,
-0.5270482897758484,
0.2072819322347641,
0.10605162382125854,
0.004277210216969252,
0.19754712283611298,
-0.7615079879760742,
0.44181081652641296,
-0.3576934337615967,
0.5154910683631897,
0.603104829788208,
-0.04021567478775978,
0.6826112270355225,
-0.014584196731448174,
0.6422120928764343,
-0.11481808125972748,
0.06363371014595032,
-0.1818297654390335,
-0.2798076570034027,
-0.954965353012085,
0.004430587403476238,
0.6508247256278992,
0.16278915107250214,
-0.5100518465042114,
0.6042426228523254,
-0.5663421750068665,
-0.4994415044784546,
-0.5293378233909607,
-0.16888070106506348,
0.226164773106575,
-0.17444461584091187,
0.19229476153850555,
0.09540272504091263,
-0.5970116853713989,
-0.8133330941200256,
0.08357344567775726,
-0.11396945267915726,
-0.0728364959359169,
-0.29528698325157166,
0.20419080555438995,
-0.07220932841300964,
0.9087103605270386,
-0.7175444960594177,
-0.6146820783615112,
-0.15514536201953888,
0.4079020321369171,
0.1639295220375061,
0.8107489943504333,
0.5444517135620117,
-0.9939858317375183,
-0.5837033987045288,
0.2167881429195404,
-0.1947401762008667,
0.005090679507702589,
-0.014764171093702316,
-0.039694443345069885,
0.1475556641817093,
0.6899577975273132,
-0.7315933108329773,
0.6238363981246948,
0.5482715368270874,
-0.2605334222316742,
0.4024818241596222,
-0.06857366859912872,
0.09801292419433594,
-1.0509870052337646,
0.20183603465557098,
-0.12289038300514221,
-0.5652192831039429,
-0.7436984181404114,
0.1902325302362442,
0.1752733439207077,
-0.45936304330825806,
0.22750206291675568,
0.22638626396656036,
-0.36935991048812866,
-0.17320699989795685,
-0.34668996930122375,
-0.13122543692588806,
0.05570816248655319,
0.8160462379455566,
0.023168962448835373,
0.48435285687446594,
0.5464138984680176,
-0.4342140257358551,
0.23558922111988068,
0.19372321665287018,
-0.5473611354827881,
0.6415236592292786,
-0.8558207750320435,
0.004778274334967136,
-0.5036659240722656,
0.4437831938266754,
-0.7853150367736816,
-0.027576981112360954,
-0.14428803324699402,
-0.7175580263137817,
0.26059621572494507,
-0.0667446106672287,
-0.9307845830917358,
-0.0526849739253521,
-0.30121129751205444,
0.771277666091919,
0.7955384850502014,
-0.2899605929851532,
0.3219340741634369,
0.5473486185073853,
0.0021119844168424606,
-0.19579719007015228,
-0.736706554889679,
-0.152736097574234,
-0.3120385706424713,
-0.26927000284194946,
0.3905129134654999,
-0.05087479576468468,
-0.12506307661533356,
0.013198578730225563,
0.016154790297150612,
-0.2841144800186157,
-0.046621520072221756,
0.06668601185083389,
-0.03003891557455063,
-0.15118013322353363,
0.4265373647212982,
0.12777644395828247,
-0.4667137563228607,
-0.06456392258405685,
-0.7895695567131042,
0.7549710869789124,
0.12386252731084824,
-0.03458024188876152,
-0.29419541358947754,
0.6573229432106018,
0.5816589593887329,
-0.42231130599975586,
0.6775972247123718,
0.9042382836341858,
-0.7790173292160034,
-0.30171817541122437,
-0.2208838164806366,
0.14284317195415497,
-0.44362741708755493,
0.4089910387992859,
-0.2713395953178406,
-0.8282811641693115,
0.5168587565422058,
0.1683066189289093,
0.01162111945450306,
0.6028408408164978,
0.4263034760951996,
0.17486555874347687,
1.7356762886047363,
0.9386630058288574,
-0.06814508140087128,
0.2624509632587433,
-0.6151778697967529,
0.5986874103546143,
-0.7013545632362366,
-0.023003192618489265,
-0.8219001293182373,
-0.46056103706359863,
-0.4397232234477997,
-0.3098619878292084,
0.5371590852737427,
0.3270336389541626,
0.04753068462014198,
0.593736469745636,
-0.3404916822910309,
0.6392809748649597,
0.3521326184272766,
0.03724602237343788,
0.11267895251512527,
-0.19000166654586792,
0.27905789017677307,
-0.07028171420097351,
-0.6255486011505127,
-0.09195175766944885,
1.0419286489486694,
0.390578031539917,
0.527564525604248,
0.26179221272468567,
0.6832711696624756,
0.2823508381843567,
0.01846066303551197,
-1.0895906686782837,
0.3764193654060364,
-0.46780216693878174,
-0.29840704798698425,
-0.5369128584861755,
-0.5333394408226013,
-0.8655950427055359,
0.14557085931301117,
-0.13027681410312653,
-1.0061737298965454,
0.44791874289512634,
-0.15223003923892975,
-0.5481289029121399,
-0.0013021462364122272,
-0.4360042214393616,
0.560615599155426,
0.3290404975414276,
0.28712764382362366,
-0.7664960026741028,
-0.4162306785583496,
0.35516148805618286,
-0.3050854802131653,
0.20986878871917725,
-0.214915469288826,
-0.03909555822610855,
0.9506340026855469,
-0.854698657989502,
0.5996109843254089,
-0.10376223176717758,
-0.18812045454978943,
0.17362534999847412,
0.20099268853664398,
0.42452868819236755,
0.3066698908805847,
0.07608277350664139,
0.03229929879307747,
0.34969133138656616,
-0.6334905624389648,
-1.1691538095474243,
0.6198374032974243,
-0.5960769653320312,
-0.3241250514984131,
-0.1807793378829956,
-0.4057419002056122,
-0.41936662793159485,
0.1875004917383194,
0.49273404479026794,
1.0252286195755005,
0.18091556429862976,
0.45041102170944214,
0.45846107602119446,
-0.021442759782075882,
0.19562479853630066,
0.1939784586429596,
-0.22694794833660126,
-0.6290149092674255,
1.0304453372955322,
0.3544228971004486,
0.2868085503578186,
0.6240902543067932,
0.34109801054000854,
-0.19012700021266937,
-0.5116620659828186,
-0.1809840351343155,
0.03145993873476982,
-0.9536157250404358,
-0.7442057132720947,
-0.5267559885978699,
-0.08902846276760101,
-0.5017296075820923,
-0.19467638432979584,
-0.4935506284236908,
-0.8381798267364502,
-0.16697321832180023,
0.02287808246910572,
0.3084414303302765,
0.7462089657783508,
-0.04714334383606911,
0.6647524237632751,
-0.8606835007667542,
0.3238411247730255,
0.1782987266778946,
0.4093497693538666,
0.14795486629009247,
-0.2952694296836853,
-0.8150805830955505,
0.12545421719551086,
0.04933770373463631,
-0.7057911157608032,
0.43525785207748413,
0.34164226055145264,
0.25268569588661194,
0.44571390748023987,
0.16378547251224518,
0.7451004385948181,
-0.4120829701423645,
0.7053468227386475,
0.07026674598455429,
-1.2283393144607544,
0.24488675594329834,
-0.09099984914064407,
0.4693225622177124,
0.6448220610618591,
0.5705103874206543,
-0.6938754916191101,
-0.33768555521965027,
-0.7933000922203064,
-0.5548100471496582,
0.47577035427093506,
0.3893416225910187,
0.20259858667850494,
0.08261950314044952,
0.14908994734287262,
0.10730718076229095,
0.25849729776382446,
-0.4420931339263916,
-0.18432307243347168,
-0.03777649998664856,
-0.4576707184314728,
-0.33987024426460266,
-0.552723228931427,
0.38973376154899597,
-0.2565625309944153,
0.6369000673294067,
-0.12949950993061066,
0.5017258524894714,
0.058894235640764236,
-0.3510569930076599,
-0.16508601605892181,
0.047193530946969986,
0.47071802616119385,
0.5279541611671448,
0.1350744515657425,
0.05192689225077629,
-0.2874654233455658,
-0.5686320662498474,
0.276168555021286,
-0.11944400519132614,
-0.04022622108459473,
0.23073561489582062,
0.2521909475326538,
0.7502520680427551,
0.2129501849412918,
-0.42240533232688904,
0.6042625308036804,
0.0613948330283165,
0.009641563519835472,
-0.22890819609165192,
-0.2402021288871765,
-0.582935094833374,
0.10695374011993408,
0.5965443849563599,
-0.1672806292772293,
0.27605339884757996,
-0.5776618719100952,
0.06806689500808716,
0.3274272084236145,
-0.10160670429468155,
-0.626990795135498,
0.4621761441230774,
-0.21518193185329437,
-0.10623030364513397,
0.29664596915245056,
-0.15329067409038544,
-0.9640747904777527,
0.48705580830574036,
0.3074687719345093,
1.023536205291748,
-0.32010897994041443,
0.3356315791606903,
0.6657021045684814,
-0.03428761661052704,
-0.3235432505607605,
0.21752531826496124,
-0.35636547207832336,
-0.5959746837615967,
-0.603162944316864,
-0.7143152952194214,
0.20610465109348297,
0.089361771941185,
-0.7918614745140076,
0.5053604245185852,
-0.7403655052185059,
-0.30148112773895264,
0.30070850253105164,
0.29579243063926697,
-0.3787761926651001,
0.298275887966156,
0.1088620126247406,
0.5253996849060059,
-0.6965211033821106,
1.0321297645568848,
0.31946054100990295,
-0.2258739024400711,
-0.5783960819244385,
-0.14358782768249512,
-0.2042853832244873,
-0.46222543716430664,
0.47432583570480347,
0.08412427455186844,
0.4414415955543518,
0.3310558795928955,
-0.7477522492408752,
-1.1522974967956543,
0.7303754091262817,
0.12137205898761749,
-0.42836737632751465,
0.08484683930873871,
0.23940269649028778,
0.5492082238197327,
-0.05711159110069275,
-0.2939891815185547,
0.6260008811950684,
0.47752460837364197,
-0.22984196245670319,
-0.8686567544937134,
-0.010510249994695187,
-0.26031407713890076,
0.1990116536617279,
0.7576383948326111,
-0.4391019642353058,
0.8796892762184143,
0.16855594515800476,
-0.6707033514976501,
0.39710733294487,
0.8024647235870361,
-0.21912549436092377,
-0.3914450705051422,
0.43886131048202515,
0.4659716784954071,
0.6105309724807739,
0.03586798533797264,
0.9367096424102783,
-0.28413593769073486,
0.6936163902282715,
0.5427207350730896,
0.1317756325006485,
0.8575016856193542,
0.4547179937362671,
-0.4461466670036316,
0.3792582154273987,
0.2476360946893692,
-0.02005070075392723,
0.523619532585144,
0.20566217601299286,
-0.1193561926484108,
-0.15593695640563965,
-0.20876722037792206,
-0.009739545173943043,
0.6055757999420166,
0.44847583770751953,
-0.06947321444749832,
-0.2347063273191452,
0.2625501751899719,
0.0573846735060215,
0.21961510181427002,
-0.46215662360191345,
0.575056254863739,
-0.035424165427684784,
-0.4672558605670929,
1.0643855333328247,
0.5344753861427307,
0.4336581230163574,
-0.6900767683982849,
-0.014557689428329468,
0.011996615678071976,
-0.016751646995544434,
-0.2058846801519394,
-0.7238602042198181,
0.39838188886642456,
-0.33753058314323425,
-0.22510497272014618,
-0.3378024697303772,
0.6009848713874817,
-0.7854583859443665,
-0.6978954076766968,
-0.3282035291194916,
-0.2053173929452896,
-0.02919590286910534,
-0.17443232238292694,
0.006848214194178581,
0.293622761964798,
-0.12531490623950958,
-0.13623164594173431,
0.1501820683479309,
0.45111989974975586,
-0.32318034768104553,
0.5805911421775818,
0.5525764226913452,
0.13385260105133057,
-0.12533186376094818,
-0.10561127215623856,
0.664280354976654,
-0.6026692390441895,
-1.005784273147583,
-0.6547185182571411,
0.36085301637649536,
0.15133331716060638,
-0.2281181961297989,
0.5325927734375,
0.30511370301246643,
0.6753678917884827,
0.10614827275276184,
0.530582845211029,
-0.0433800034224987,
0.25233134627342224,
-0.7536501884460449,
0.7868430614471436,
-0.46750548481941223,
-0.24000130593776703,
-0.14534609019756317,
-1.0663256645202637,
-0.5611693263053894,
0.6406094431877136,
0.0310108233243227,
-0.15196171402931213,
0.7941752672195435,
0.30365926027297974,
0.09209887683391571,
-0.003813499351963401,
0.4936886429786682,
0.030560018494725227,
0.2278440296649933,
0.707205057144165,
0.34847915172576904,
-0.6260359287261963,
0.1911364197731018,
-0.611054539680481,
-0.05398055166006088,
-0.04892491176724434,
-0.5648523569107056,
-0.692966878414154,
-1.3382221460342407,
-0.34671106934547424,
-0.1334555298089981,
-0.3383440673351288,
0.8318236470222473,
0.8569146394729614,
-0.7073781490325928,
-0.14193151891231537,
-0.19179032742977142,
-0.12624117732048035,
-0.06295809149742126,
-0.17281091213226318,
0.6605216264724731,
-0.4081014394760132,
-0.7159405946731567,
0.026415163651108742,
0.1723659783601761,
0.10109808295965195,
-0.7842360734939575,
-0.05454939231276512,
0.0438692569732666,
-0.05437827855348587,
0.7235432267189026,
-0.003232566174119711,
-0.27150633931159973,
-0.18627393245697021,
-0.08586990833282471,
-0.018811382353305817,
0.004673017654567957,
1.0948690176010132,
-0.9647232294082642,
0.16317449510097504,
0.6998162865638733,
0.7102106809616089,
0.36126983165740967,
0.18149952590465546,
0.9232737421989441,
-0.8901821970939636,
0.40747204422950745,
0.3150501549243927,
0.22614632546901703,
0.28837713599205017,
-0.608742892742157,
0.2792600095272064,
0.08160389214754105,
-0.3197673559188843,
-1.0691993236541748,
0.15962179005146027,
-0.6512962579727173,
-0.2582496702671051,
1.196344256401062,
0.00025090272538363934,
-0.55223548412323,
0.24475666880607605,
-0.052102893590927124,
0.08880271762609482,
-0.10217505693435669,
0.5904215574264526,
0.8696749806404114,
0.6252156496047974,
-0.1501559466123581,
-0.43557196855545044,
0.6215857267379761,
0.5336273908615112,
-0.42226698994636536,
0.23737302422523499,
0.5035849809646606,
-0.2647635340690613,
0.2969319224357605,
0.45318228006362915,
-0.2626425623893738,
0.4083807170391083,
-0.11391948908567429,
-0.0325978547334671,
0.251682311296463,
-0.323765367269516,
-0.8188440799713135,
-0.05052687227725983,
-0.04304353520274162,
-0.12138231098651886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09717v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09717v1
|
Unveiling Imitation Learning: Exploring the Impact of Data Falsity to Large Language Model
| 2024-04-15T12:20:09 | 2024-04-15T12:20:09 |
Hyunsoo Cho
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Many recent studies endeavor to improve open-source language models through
imitation learning, and re-training on the synthetic instruction data from
state-of-the-art proprietary models like ChatGPT and GPT-4. However, the innate
nature of synthetic data inherently contains noisy data, giving rise to a
substantial presence of low-quality data replete with erroneous responses, and
flawed reasoning. Although we intuitively grasp the potential harm of noisy
data, we lack a quantitative understanding of its impact. To this end, this
paper explores the correlation between the degree of noise and its impact on
language models through instruction tuning. We first introduce the
Falsity-Controllable (FACO) dataset, which comprises pairs of true answers with
corresponding reasoning, as well as false pairs to manually control the falsity
ratio of the dataset.Through our extensive experiments, we found multiple
intriguing findings of the correlation between the factuality of the dataset
and instruction tuning: Specifically, we verified falsity of the instruction is
highly relevant to various benchmark scores. Moreover, when LLMs are trained
with false instructions, they learn to lie and generate fake unfaithful
answers, even though they know the correct answer for the user request.
Additionally, we noted that once the language model is trained with a dataset
contaminated by noise, restoring its original performance is possible, but it
failed to reach full performance.
|
[
-0.10356660932302475,
-1.187800407409668,
0.3142060935497284,
-0.1844533532857895,
-0.10389337688684464,
0.15716446936130524,
0.0015453482046723366,
-0.4363456070423126,
-0.09883143752813339,
0.6781578660011292,
-0.4167310893535614,
-0.3352772891521454,
-0.586135745048523,
-0.3415069282054901,
-0.8011246919631958,
1.099189281463623,
0.055600330233573914,
0.09011717140674591,
-0.2483483850955963,
0.009576233103871346,
-0.2114250361919403,
-0.5265147686004639,
-0.4535928964614868,
-0.1756822168827057,
0.09201347082853317,
0.2903895676136017,
0.8319993019104004,
0.9868842363357544,
-0.12490002065896988,
0.30467891693115234,
0.1344127655029297,
0.4804235100746155,
-0.8035922050476074,
0.1528959572315216,
0.0321132130920887,
-0.615730345249176,
-0.3007274866104126,
0.3498719036579132,
0.6198263764381409,
0.5499519109725952,
-0.22231656312942505,
0.015038893558084965,
0.3794487714767456,
0.7032482624053955,
-0.36875006556510925,
0.5172408819198608,
-0.7972912788391113,
-0.1679440438747406,
-0.12920023500919342,
-0.16441728174686432,
-0.3705497086048126,
-0.3515544831752777,
0.061638638377189636,
-0.6995065212249756,
0.48120829463005066,
0.1697421669960022,
0.7928119897842407,
0.4481726288795471,
-0.2128092497587204,
-0.680202305316925,
-0.9101114869117737,
0.8070435523986816,
-0.6234138011932373,
0.4164865016937256,
0.5262641906738281,
-0.07444571703672409,
-0.4166173040866852,
-0.333101361989975,
-0.38285893201828003,
-0.22322304546833038,
0.05927363410592079,
0.08508102595806122,
-0.27969101071357727,
-0.08126386255025864,
0.2530072331428528,
0.6660988926887512,
-0.370620995759964,
0.08290764689445496,
-0.2521439492702484,
-0.34663495421409607,
0.5442781448364258,
0.20889168977737427,
0.25266289710998535,
0.41689345240592957,
-0.13551869988441467,
-0.12536334991455078,
-0.711119532585144,
0.08006978780031204,
0.7994607090950012,
0.2612578272819519,
-0.0724470242857933,
0.33534061908721924,
-0.08687902987003326,
0.8355613350868225,
0.20357099175453186,
0.17542245984077454,
0.10687193274497986,
-0.34532538056373596,
-0.1370975375175476,
-0.026619600132107735,
0.6927950382232666,
-0.04313339665532112,
0.41273149847984314,
-0.3052717447280884,
-0.3144098222255707,
-0.03792703524231911,
0.36178818345069885,
-0.6095530390739441,
-0.36379170417785645,
0.06301455199718475,
-0.21587541699409485,
-0.5073424577713013,
0.1441691815853119,
-0.9459381103515625,
-0.3554823696613312,
-0.589812159538269,
0.5930405259132385,
-0.5454121232032776,
-0.16548626124858856,
0.1488846242427826,
0.41294699907302856,
0.29417669773101807,
0.4400455355644226,
-0.9681398272514343,
0.502910315990448,
0.8310768008232117,
0.73233962059021,
-0.16497913002967834,
-0.3706172704696655,
-0.5754972696304321,
-0.1675260066986084,
-0.5362458825111389,
0.5114506483078003,
-0.511117160320282,
-0.3083285093307495,
-0.09903664886951447,
-0.03211086988449097,
-0.14982327818870544,
-0.588817298412323,
0.30938902497291565,
-0.5262199640274048,
0.21677768230438232,
-0.16122351586818695,
-0.7525330781936646,
-0.1498374491930008,
-0.14247891306877136,
-0.8244838714599609,
0.9703559875488281,
-0.024444011971354485,
-0.4658748507499695,
0.1174384132027626,
-0.4512203335762024,
-0.4942932724952698,
-0.30461248755455017,
-0.17242610454559326,
-0.6623106598854065,
0.23941820859909058,
0.11391011625528336,
0.32722336053848267,
-0.2116854041814804,
-0.06363479793071747,
-0.056613873690366745,
-0.5888832807540894,
0.5304689407348633,
-0.8536390066146851,
0.7117127180099487,
0.094369076192379,
-0.4651959538459778,
-0.26209068298339844,
-0.797869086265564,
0.04145228490233421,
0.1623152494430542,
-0.3290334939956665,
-0.2807849943637848,
-0.004328506533056498,
-0.5174112319946289,
0.04695702716708183,
0.19284404814243317,
-0.3680577278137207,
0.12326204031705856,
-0.4480762481689453,
0.20363849401474,
0.9747342467308044,
0.08988073468208313,
0.29783621430397034,
-0.6642586588859558,
0.42553067207336426,
0.09318368136882782,
0.3260357975959778,
-0.13191235065460205,
-0.5936579704284668,
-0.6277489066123962,
-0.06488027423620224,
0.21804183721542358,
0.4500182271003723,
-0.5083444714546204,
0.05608518794178963,
-0.03740836679935455,
-0.3760261535644531,
-0.988182544708252,
0.4300711750984192,
0.5206938982009888,
0.42425990104675293,
0.39829400181770325,
-0.14658376574516296,
-0.5229282379150391,
-0.7985042333602905,
-0.3820492625236511,
-0.04451356083154678,
0.2664240598678589,
0.3202478885650635,
0.46668413281440735,
0.019977405667304993,
0.729774534702301,
-0.3066522479057312,
-0.18616682291030884,
-0.01566520519554615,
0.242722749710083,
0.09254627674818039,
0.4625530242919922,
0.3039311468601227,
-0.600937008857727,
-0.49509117007255554,
-0.14195017516613007,
-0.41551247239112854,
-0.19290299713611603,
-0.14553961157798767,
0.01596999540925026,
0.5061317086219788,
0.46998223662376404,
-0.31458786129951477,
0.43457919359207153,
0.8263815641403198,
0.0101555110886693,
0.8395739793777466,
-0.26533636450767517,
0.2803886830806732,
-0.864504337310791,
-0.023238062858581543,
-0.29104331135749817,
0.049749840050935745,
-0.6157875061035156,
-0.1838720291852951,
-0.20553675293922424,
0.2054571956396103,
-0.21583043038845062,
0.26131123304367065,
-0.5240791440010071,
-0.06280156224966049,
-0.365694522857666,
-0.21393682062625885,
-0.09512777626514435,
0.4733383059501648,
-0.17253391444683075,
1.0758267641067505,
0.5164369344711304,
-0.5009971857070923,
0.23719750344753265,
0.056347645819187164,
-0.5777221322059631,
-0.03870648518204689,
-0.6792510151863098,
0.2546631991863251,
0.025565702468156815,
-0.03293059766292572,
-0.9077883362770081,
-0.2766324579715729,
0.14796443283557892,
-0.5570405721664429,
0.426277220249176,
-0.2967499792575836,
-0.7107270359992981,
0.2503751814365387,
-0.017534928396344185,
0.08168022334575653,
0.6222689747810364,
-0.6202903985977173,
0.3014086186885834,
0.3728283643722534,
0.26517292857170105,
-0.7603954076766968,
-0.6368589401245117,
-0.32391780614852905,
0.12284208089113235,
-0.3440820872783661,
0.12352234125137329,
-0.22858525812625885,
-0.2047451138496399,
-0.04612741619348526,
-0.3509862422943115,
-0.1321851909160614,
0.23558340966701508,
0.4769393801689148,
0.3713628351688385,
-0.23673588037490845,
0.01266352366656065,
0.033870965242385864,
0.0393344983458519,
0.3452634811401367,
-0.09236455708742142,
0.6226683259010315,
-0.3525915741920471,
-0.35146862268447876,
-0.5113108158111572,
0.06146258860826492,
0.7148710489273071,
0.005540491081774235,
0.9528034925460815,
0.14808185398578644,
-0.04305030032992363,
-0.4909747838973999,
-0.36477985978126526,
-0.2506691515445709,
-0.490131139755249,
0.2650981545448303,
-0.14720363914966583,
-0.7289195656776428,
0.3641674220561981,
-0.004864324815571308,
0.20972242951393127,
-0.022316278889775276,
0.45135802030563354,
-0.1269403100013733,
1.0605909824371338,
0.2874825894832611,
-0.2234659641981125,
0.6252157688140869,
-0.2580856382846832,
-0.03449269384145737,
-0.46529093384742737,
-0.11094707995653152,
-0.32106655836105347,
-0.002619106788188219,
-0.6222450733184814,
-0.4868548512458801,
0.09251600503921509,
-0.017448410391807556,
-0.16634291410446167,
-0.020443672314286232,
-0.19393932819366455,
0.8272703289985657,
0.6329163312911987,
0.2778860330581665,
0.4250248074531555,
0.27913203835487366,
-0.08630456030368805,
-0.030302736908197403,
-0.584649920463562,
-0.45659756660461426,
1.2823092937469482,
0.21041662991046906,
1.001894235610962,
0.014515411108732224,
0.5007503628730774,
0.22223711013793945,
0.06879213452339172,
-0.6659412980079651,
0.38170722126960754,
-0.3558402955532074,
-0.46118786931037903,
-0.26312029361724854,
-0.608837902545929,
-0.9297877550125122,
-0.05388033762574196,
-0.21517345309257507,
-0.37281057238578796,
-0.07954522967338562,
0.5963895916938782,
-0.10540033131837845,
0.30615103244781494,
-0.7055880427360535,
0.5536037087440491,
-0.3745444416999817,
-0.7069802284240723,
-0.19022391736507416,
-0.46552351117134094,
0.41294535994529724,
-0.19041883945465088,
0.28967562317848206,
0.27099600434303284,
0.12610746920108795,
0.5755264163017273,
-0.1944061517715454,
1.2982573509216309,
-0.02376340888440609,
-0.2958916425704956,
0.21423983573913574,
0.4103446900844574,
0.7020734548568726,
-0.20970313251018524,
0.04308917000889778,
0.2901085615158081,
-0.19176535308361053,
-0.44075003266334534,
-0.8094172477722168,
0.7920459508895874,
-1.1203699111938477,
-0.6835853457450867,
-0.1656787246465683,
-0.6588169932365417,
-0.41218218207359314,
0.014410587958991528,
0.27634450793266296,
0.48672235012054443,
-0.2649484872817993,
0.12928622961044312,
1.1057316064834595,
-0.27117452025413513,
0.029542118310928345,
0.7814689874649048,
-0.11189279705286026,
-0.2438693344593048,
1.201894998550415,
0.4229893386363983,
0.6947523355484009,
0.18943001329898834,
0.2706522047519684,
-0.19272176921367645,
-0.5014076232910156,
-0.29999175667762756,
0.3757375478744507,
-0.4175761640071869,
0.09983927756547928,
-0.40476250648498535,
-0.3794001042842865,
-0.34745699167251587,
0.12842945754528046,
-0.7476995587348938,
-0.28997188806533813,
-0.305056095123291,
-0.056925226002931595,
0.242374986410141,
0.977855384349823,
-0.13579517602920532,
0.27925577759742737,
-0.5150854587554932,
-0.037628255784511566,
0.33229881525039673,
0.46933677792549133,
0.1600099503993988,
-0.8629430532455444,
-0.490408718585968,
0.49486860632896423,
-0.21623623371124268,
-0.713019847869873,
0.2935544550418854,
0.2663082182407379,
0.7734999060630798,
0.46539223194122314,
-0.0177227221429348,
0.5412005186080933,
-0.41686877608299255,
0.6109600067138672,
-0.34190383553504944,
-0.9642457365989685,
0.4972077012062073,
-0.24518632888793945,
0.15939883887767792,
0.27740898728370667,
0.5398718118667603,
-0.28404518961906433,
-0.5096560120582581,
-0.7283656597137451,
-0.511616051197052,
0.7871438264846802,
0.11212129890918732,
0.1440797597169876,
0.2729012668132782,
0.3624917268753052,
0.448476642370224,
0.18913519382476807,
-0.5482032895088196,
-0.4678051471710205,
-0.46518293023109436,
-0.11371525377035141,
-0.009898661635816097,
-0.22930608689785004,
-0.042010001838207245,
-0.16087007522583008,
0.8676594495773315,
0.02287333272397518,
0.37463247776031494,
-0.21122108399868011,
-0.13160446286201477,
-0.2628554105758667,
0.1171807199716568,
0.764316737651825,
0.10898889601230621,
-0.09791959077119827,
0.12095796316862106,
-0.15453767776489258,
-0.6926214694976807,
0.06174640357494354,
-0.2905835509300232,
-0.1820928454399109,
-0.21127353608608246,
0.408721923828125,
0.8142516613006592,
0.24457195401191711,
-0.46106407046318054,
0.4178577959537506,
0.13324736058712006,
-0.263081431388855,
-0.21761126816272736,
0.4907534122467041,
-0.12989161908626556,
-0.05016614869236946,
0.1243794858455658,
0.1990683525800705,
-0.05965990945696831,
-0.6000899076461792,
0.30135175585746765,
0.4983782172203064,
-0.3598122298717499,
-0.5802860856056213,
0.44857120513916016,
-0.06542815268039703,
-0.19688130915164948,
0.784978985786438,
0.0773184522986412,
-0.43989577889442444,
0.5757148861885071,
0.7133679389953613,
0.4843346178531647,
-0.5675361752510071,
0.33290040493011475,
0.256920725107193,
0.46510884165763855,
-0.20366023480892181,
0.09659318625926971,
-0.03981572389602661,
-1.027724266052246,
-0.47576674818992615,
-0.36988067626953125,
-0.48619797825813293,
0.5439513325691223,
-0.7646331191062927,
0.05698667839169502,
-0.5287575125694275,
0.3917262852191925,
-0.20272864401340485,
-0.003344086930155754,
-0.267386794090271,
0.008075698278844357,
-0.1251048743724823,
0.5065526366233826,
-1.075454592704773,
1.0078341960906982,
0.34598976373672485,
-0.40843623876571655,
-0.6963328719139099,
0.2521843910217285,
0.2953006327152252,
-1.1169036626815796,
0.49924543499946594,
-0.02082778885960579,
-0.42892736196517944,
0.2265269160270691,
-0.9486778378486633,
-0.8847129940986633,
0.692750096321106,
0.5113609433174133,
-0.45650577545166016,
0.20040689408779144,
0.5144535899162292,
0.7456614375114441,
-0.258629709482193,
-0.03168700635433197,
0.5791785717010498,
0.17706894874572754,
0.05107726901769638,
-0.6794822812080383,
-0.04116631671786308,
-0.10829576849937439,
-0.5194502472877502,
0.21618838608264923,
-0.756001353263855,
0.7641177773475647,
-0.24407784640789032,
-0.37096917629241943,
0.03216792643070221,
0.4199812114238739,
0.0686560794711113,
0.17783619463443756,
0.41465091705322266,
0.3187197148799896,
0.7240919470787048,
0.05015811696648598,
0.9084578156471252,
-0.31567850708961487,
0.21956470608711243,
1.4246225357055664,
-0.07482118159532547,
0.6306653618812561,
0.30618202686309814,
-0.08427482098340988,
0.3659784197807312,
0.33446410298347473,
-0.08084237575531006,
0.4794507920742035,
0.17038993537425995,
-0.1760866492986679,
-0.24325436353683472,
0.10614431649446487,
-0.14684078097343445,
0.5048278570175171,
0.6774269342422485,
-0.510043740272522,
-0.14304666221141815,
-0.1580427885055542,
0.13710854947566986,
0.13817739486694336,
-0.09851648658514023,
0.7038386464118958,
-0.21120060980319977,
-0.4094454050064087,
0.7002894878387451,
-0.4004848599433899,
0.4740680456161499,
-0.48626670241355896,
-0.26313939690589905,
-0.43287140130996704,
0.07667547464370728,
-0.11170598119497299,
-0.6628789305686951,
0.35095492005348206,
-0.1618669182062149,
-0.3001883327960968,
-0.2305121272802353,
0.30248355865478516,
-0.5043919086456299,
-0.05029907822608948,
0.14140325784683228,
0.5959790945053101,
0.3125981390476227,
0.021840931847691536,
-0.8223289251327515,
0.15383517742156982,
0.27967000007629395,
-0.21267296373844147,
0.5823544263839722,
0.40584540367126465,
0.13761365413665771,
0.7361420392990112,
0.7811796069145203,
0.2088964879512787,
0.26076367497444153,
-0.2466181367635727,
0.742408037185669,
-0.30901461839675903,
-0.20563068985939026,
-0.794299840927124,
0.14675818383693695,
0.06149757653474808,
-0.27928847074508667,
0.831859827041626,
0.7010282278060913,
0.8773850798606873,
-0.16743044555187225,
0.7349323034286499,
0.3895171880722046,
0.7332481741905212,
-0.7375319600105286,
0.847204864025116,
-0.3742251396179199,
0.6553887128829956,
-0.19982510805130005,
-0.49030235409736633,
0.02339704893529415,
0.49116888642311096,
-0.3534887433052063,
0.10070949047803879,
0.46085432171821594,
1.278961181640625,
-0.10936704277992249,
0.28051871061325073,
0.6093862652778625,
0.7364302277565002,
0.15234582126140594,
0.2568206489086151,
0.9505550265312195,
-0.4212885797023773,
0.6182742118835449,
-0.35180366039276123,
-0.28863945603370667,
-0.153749018907547,
-0.4181077778339386,
-0.7132322192192078,
-0.8036665320396423,
-0.38575538992881775,
-0.466158390045166,
0.28091728687286377,
0.7689536809921265,
0.5018863677978516,
-0.9627353549003601,
-0.29499274492263794,
-0.4075547158718109,
0.07847806811332703,
-0.4126427471637726,
-0.31467074155807495,
0.4023783802986145,
-0.3192897140979767,
-0.9106839299201965,
0.5667710900306702,
-0.10562772303819656,
0.43080073595046997,
-0.27695152163505554,
-0.020166166126728058,
0.014387978240847588,
0.3142888844013214,
0.3112374246120453,
0.427188903093338,
-0.6033510565757751,
-0.17319439351558685,
0.05098078027367592,
-0.0840168222784996,
-0.035619884729385376,
0.9836711287498474,
-0.7735704183578491,
0.439200758934021,
0.13039635121822357,
0.5929144620895386,
0.2507242262363434,
0.03647833690047264,
0.7075867652893066,
-0.7712625861167908,
-0.20621435344219208,
-0.08165459334850311,
0.06254445761442184,
0.05054760351777077,
-0.6695898771286011,
0.4270516633987427,
0.35439127683639526,
-0.7666139602661133,
-0.8364225625991821,
0.2504139244556427,
-0.6701965928077698,
-0.4527263641357422,
1.154894232749939,
-0.09671494364738464,
-0.31612980365753174,
-0.4637809097766876,
-0.18927830457687378,
0.30901938676834106,
-0.5807514786720276,
1.1484780311584473,
0.8526066541671753,
-0.3902058005332947,
-0.2302352786064148,
-0.8628430366516113,
0.7211157083511353,
0.37639471888542175,
-0.5528995990753174,
0.5278541445732117,
0.5856800675392151,
0.48890650272369385,
-0.11777166277170181,
0.05111831799149513,
-0.17052361369132996,
0.30144378542900085,
0.23028671741485596,
-0.11610761284828186,
-0.45984795689582825,
-0.15766368806362152,
-0.5496168732643127,
-0.03040112368762493,
-0.01641986519098282,
-0.1812109351158142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09696v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09696v1
|
Are Large Language Models Reliable Argument Quality Annotators?
| 2024-04-15T11:54:27 | 2024-04-15T11:54:27 |
Nailia Mirzakhmedova, Marcel Gohsen, Chia Hao Chang, Benno Stein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.ET
|
Evaluating the quality of arguments is a crucial aspect of any system
leveraging argument mining. However, it is a challenge to obtain reliable and
consistent annotations regarding argument quality, as this usually requires
domain-specific expertise of the annotators. Even among experts, the assessment
of argument quality is often inconsistent due to the inherent subjectivity of
this task. In this paper, we study the potential of using state-of-the-art
large language models (LLMs) as proxies for argument quality annotators. To
assess the capability of LLMs in this regard, we analyze the agreement between
model, human expert, and human novice annotators based on an established
taxonomy of argument quality dimensions. Our findings highlight that LLMs can
produce consistent annotations, with a moderately high agreement with human
experts across most of the quality dimensions. Moreover, we show that using
LLMs as additional annotators can significantly improve the agreement between
annotators. These results suggest that LLMs can serve as a valuable tool for
automated argument quality assessment, thus streamlining and accelerating the
evaluation of large argument datasets.
|
[
-0.3910329043865204,
-0.7316117882728577,
0.91869056224823,
-0.11534089595079422,
-0.6513261198997498,
-0.02588311769068241,
-0.3576801121234894,
-0.3815360367298126,
0.058746587485075,
0.4439865052700043,
0.015093889087438583,
-0.32962530851364136,
-0.9570433497428894,
0.25251534581184387,
-0.3794948160648346,
0.7908353805541992,
-0.013791307806968689,
0.2789030373096466,
-0.5211157202720642,
-0.3395977020263672,
-0.4528816342353821,
-0.6886101365089417,
-0.788048505783081,
-0.36279624700546265,
0.6343643665313721,
0.2290448695421219,
0.9979526996612549,
0.6895391941070557,
0.36782342195510864,
0.424431711435318,
-0.1996888965368271,
0.33742037415504456,
-0.037566252052783966,
0.35814139246940613,
-0.45941630005836487,
-0.12277478724718094,
-0.6375316977500916,
-0.014261365868151188,
0.6304289698600769,
0.6101952195167542,
-0.0021364171989262104,
0.15706810355186462,
-0.07060325890779495,
0.33445116877555847,
-0.40869298577308655,
-0.021593127399683,
-0.9164801836013794,
-0.23050706088542938,
-0.2615855634212494,
-0.09750044345855713,
-0.3845474421977997,
-0.4913330078125,
0.2291456162929535,
-0.2816372215747833,
-0.35275471210479736,
-0.11465834826231003,
1.0531550645828247,
0.43726983666419983,
-0.21942856907844543,
-0.4061169922351837,
-0.6058314442634583,
0.541463315486908,
-1.3502031564712524,
0.12259849160909653,
0.16452999413013458,
0.32627391815185547,
-0.42077505588531494,
-0.7017998099327087,
-0.6721121668815613,
-0.4847584068775177,
-0.10723108798265457,
-0.11774332821369171,
-0.2763541340827942,
-0.07387469708919525,
0.3712386190891266,
0.27668607234954834,
-0.14881320297718048,
0.6913674473762512,
0.020576803013682365,
-0.40697911381721497,
0.774409830570221,
0.1441422551870346,
0.21452611684799194,
-0.3193000555038452,
-0.24518945813179016,
0.25753527879714966,
-0.6721071004867554,
-0.09425520151853561,
0.6285484433174133,
0.20146679878234863,
0.24931621551513672,
0.537021815776825,
0.02075536735355854,
0.8098553419113159,
0.006749794818460941,
-0.24012160301208496,
-0.198201984167099,
0.0029564788565039635,
-0.21573971211910248,
-0.23252134025096893,
1.0803152322769165,
0.30895888805389404,
0.4738263785839081,
-0.024043777957558632,
-0.24967460334300995,
-0.23935963213443756,
0.22550873458385468,
-0.7211505770683289,
-0.2605026066303253,
0.40614262223243713,
-0.471170037984848,
-0.09292350709438324,
0.06190640851855278,
-0.7368558645248413,
-0.7260045409202576,
-0.3115669786930084,
0.4611329138278961,
-0.2362009733915329,
-0.3507065773010254,
0.07291698455810547,
0.11081410199403763,
0.007199078798294067,
0.3652249872684479,
-0.6717555522918701,
0.09793027490377426,
0.8808786869049072,
0.7192674279212952,
-0.10739602148532867,
-0.11576288193464279,
-0.8648757934570312,
-0.12242867052555084,
-0.7114502787590027,
1.1725656986236572,
-0.7720020413398743,
-0.14455534517765045,
0.1705886274576187,
-0.12983259558677673,
0.3001402020454407,
-0.7249621748924255,
1.1608822345733643,
-0.5792769193649292,
0.07131434977054596,
-0.41959646344184875,
-0.9193577170372009,
-0.21726492047309875,
0.35522985458374023,
-0.7361536026000977,
0.7333428859710693,
-0.2117462009191513,
-0.4559185802936554,
0.5527605414390564,
-0.45208489894866943,
-0.3307187259197235,
0.4537040591239929,
-0.1420874446630478,
-0.38851630687713623,
0.2580033540725708,
0.20858068764209747,
0.7817890644073486,
-0.4507609009742737,
0.336119681596756,
-0.4983561933040619,
-0.21249136328697205,
0.7441843152046204,
-0.474832147359848,
0.32333168387413025,
0.031464628875255585,
-0.11672735959291458,
0.22868157923221588,
-0.6822154521942139,
-0.036730337888002396,
0.15386655926704407,
-0.44793710112571716,
-0.26954713463783264,
0.2804935872554779,
-0.22709518671035767,
0.3827716112136841,
0.26526662707328796,
-0.5325511693954468,
0.1762925535440445,
-0.27961811423301697,
0.6762743592262268,
0.8896631598472595,
0.11934886872768402,
-0.0712072104215622,
0.016190679743885994,
0.29571282863616943,
-0.033699411898851395,
-0.20116089284420013,
-0.2819730043411255,
-0.4823031425476074,
-0.8074310421943665,
-0.41212210059165955,
0.7284271717071533,
0.144881471991539,
-0.23125992715358734,
0.5708209872245789,
-0.3073456585407257,
-0.5461866855621338,
-0.5008226037025452,
0.15838408470153809,
0.09150143712759018,
0.12959949672222137,
0.1984781175851822,
-0.10929478704929352,
-0.4500606954097748,
-0.8525498509407043,
-0.43958404660224915,
-0.49541154503822327,
0.08546613156795502,
0.12448959052562714,
0.473642498254776,
-0.07923761755228043,
1.0178005695343018,
0.07672809064388275,
-0.007872284390032291,
-0.1938065141439438,
0.15362173318862915,
0.12933219969272614,
0.20166096091270447,
0.37825119495391846,
-0.2942412793636322,
-0.34558331966400146,
-0.024728620424866676,
-0.6412944197654724,
-0.23862947523593903,
-0.30820128321647644,
-0.04764038324356079,
0.33955544233322144,
0.33287304639816284,
-0.6517968773841858,
-0.06548568606376648,
0.5978619456291199,
-0.25117823481559753,
0.7113150358200073,
-0.17836755514144897,
-0.018348241224884987,
-1.0751354694366455,
0.0851469337940216,
0.31462860107421875,
-0.34344199299812317,
-0.5939643383026123,
-0.1612342894077301,
-0.1829366236925125,
0.21200180053710938,
-0.25925129652023315,
0.6370195746421814,
-0.1413593739271164,
0.24369242787361145,
-0.4642883837223053,
0.19991876184940338,
-0.05940307304263115,
0.006208909209817648,
0.12120272219181061,
0.6113148331642151,
0.4490909278392792,
-0.2904645800590515,
0.5555804371833801,
-0.007233469281345606,
-0.5248998403549194,
0.8403988480567932,
-0.8627849817276001,
0.28197816014289856,
0.2040485441684723,
0.18390296399593353,
-1.0540982484817505,
-0.46359843015670776,
0.1543000489473343,
-0.27506789565086365,
0.2486836016178131,
-0.3632349371910095,
-0.8053066730499268,
-0.3034912645816803,
-0.16301670670509338,
-0.20164544880390167,
0.29105672240257263,
-0.6620408296585083,
0.7058380246162415,
0.3385705351829529,
-0.30550140142440796,
-0.624955415725708,
-0.40786585211753845,
0.6216062903404236,
-0.3239191770553589,
-0.47211894392967224,
-0.06679130345582962,
0.17378559708595276,
-0.46349573135375977,
-0.07220052927732468,
0.10934937745332718,
0.10160981863737106,
0.08392156660556793,
0.4195074737071991,
0.12032639980316162,
-0.2567543387413025,
0.21823665499687195,
-0.1404108852148056,
-0.18399986624717712,
0.2807604968547821,
-0.17504340410232544,
0.3311573266983032,
-0.1141280010342598,
-0.6503607034683228,
-0.5252902507781982,
0.35105934739112854,
0.8409748673439026,
-0.24259833991527557,
0.6459754705429077,
0.4730229675769806,
-0.5142799615859985,
0.053256671875715256,
-1.1326733827590942,
-0.03478087857365608,
-0.45327505469322205,
0.36531031131744385,
-0.43414124846458435,
-1.0154085159301758,
0.6033980846405029,
-0.4244917929172516,
0.5126777291297913,
0.6602269411087036,
0.6323665380477905,
-0.09153923392295837,
1.0480623245239258,
-0.021169284358620644,
-0.050474364310503006,
0.06929516792297363,
0.02033231407403946,
0.2868146002292633,
-0.790932297706604,
-0.010722342878580093,
-0.6104124188423157,
-0.19944769144058228,
-0.2262663096189499,
-0.2963508665561676,
-0.1269967257976532,
0.2557244896888733,
-0.3861192762851715,
-0.09229639172554016,
-0.20541667938232422,
0.44254958629608154,
0.15897060930728912,
-0.29437777400016785,
0.16439934074878693,
0.06172215938568115,
-0.11219677329063416,
-0.19772864878177643,
-0.4523056149482727,
-1.3164794445037842,
0.714741051197052,
0.8567537665367126,
0.4981979727745056,
-0.033077336847782135,
0.5296446681022644,
0.22915636003017426,
0.5470625758171082,
-0.8696790337562561,
0.6899301409721375,
-0.2610659897327423,
-0.40801355242729187,
-0.2316417247056961,
-0.35447973012924194,
-0.6414533257484436,
0.3025629222393036,
-0.37352418899536133,
-0.8461264967918396,
0.07841935008764267,
0.1017722338438034,
-0.5284011960029602,
0.6430819630622864,
-0.47919031977653503,
0.9989807605743408,
-0.3193168342113495,
-0.4453156292438507,
0.0017869825242087245,
-0.18773001432418823,
0.23430705070495605,
-0.17029134929180145,
0.0767577588558197,
-0.29368600249290466,
0.1130274161696434,
1.1147234439849854,
-0.489624559879303,
0.6283342242240906,
-0.11290308833122253,
-0.45963335037231445,
0.5501450896263123,
0.14518076181411743,
0.4190085828304291,
-0.014559805393218994,
-0.45945438742637634,
0.37562692165374756,
-0.015470126643776894,
-0.24820701777935028,
-0.5855951905250549,
0.655922532081604,
-0.6881383657455444,
-1.1121183633804321,
-0.2692784368991852,
-0.3765229880809784,
-0.19412554800510406,
0.01863119751214981,
-0.1234922781586647,
0.41421452164649963,
0.046542517840862274,
0.29472821950912476,
0.28693312406539917,
-0.1421319842338562,
0.46717894077301025,
0.2848946750164032,
0.21235042810440063,
-0.5951753258705139,
0.9944395422935486,
0.17796538770198822,
0.15299943089485168,
0.01512278150767088,
0.5348106026649475,
-0.4465675354003906,
-0.8787435293197632,
-0.7387692332267761,
0.26583442091941833,
-1.0676209926605225,
-0.40401217341423035,
-0.6921652555465698,
-0.09937289357185364,
0.09695745259523392,
-0.049397341907024384,
-0.41317951679229736,
-0.31085312366485596,
-0.17940329015254974,
-0.19493016600608826,
0.3568023443222046,
0.785011887550354,
0.13308171927928925,
0.04988478124141693,
-0.8647512793540955,
-0.15980488061904907,
0.5535728335380554,
0.36773115396499634,
0.05280642583966255,
-0.6125694513320923,
-0.14252661168575287,
0.015869250521063805,
-0.17208220064640045,
-0.8257195949554443,
-0.07470185309648514,
0.09857161343097687,
0.7263814806938171,
0.6919780373573303,
-0.13037897646427155,
0.5165371894836426,
-0.3550659716129303,
1.316793441772461,
0.055708982050418854,
-1.0329347848892212,
0.177201509475708,
-0.2344227284193039,
0.055575769394636154,
0.35998836159706116,
0.2050544172525406,
-0.40387392044067383,
-0.4572356343269348,
-0.34972724318504333,
-0.5801118016242981,
0.37452948093414307,
-0.32009920477867126,
0.2552660405635834,
-0.19461508095264435,
0.6733514070510864,
0.34884214401245117,
-0.18277983367443085,
-0.668467104434967,
0.28618961572647095,
-0.1566062569618225,
-0.17331673204898834,
0.15611718595027924,
-0.6649372577667236,
-0.1484205275774002,
0.03945082053542137,
0.4995216429233551,
-0.21503806114196777,
-0.11331870406866074,
-0.23155330121517181,
0.036854662001132965,
-0.29590362310409546,
0.6264669299125671,
0.685878336429596,
0.9601857662200928,
0.050986289978027344,
0.2865979075431824,
0.5532042980194092,
-0.15907351672649384,
0.32806137204170227,
-0.02689332515001297,
0.08711060136556625,
0.1926535815000534,
0.6320520043373108,
0.7389732599258423,
-0.057493969798088074,
-0.6836782693862915,
0.44814401865005493,
-0.004614050965756178,
-0.2076675295829773,
-0.21504762768745422,
0.016006777063012123,
0.49715524911880493,
0.32383981347084045,
0.30180782079696655,
-0.17765845358371735,
-0.27829810976982117,
-0.3959232270717621,
-0.0004020313499495387,
0.7621821165084839,
-0.29830995202064514,
-0.1422528177499771,
0.5321430563926697,
0.3236202895641327,
-0.494135320186615,
0.29238855838775635,
0.06787826120853424,
-0.6688340306282043,
0.22671066224575043,
0.21083517372608185,
0.7363609671592712,
-0.15083971619606018,
0.05328914150595665,
0.3051880896091461,
0.22915495932102203,
-0.19009214639663696,
0.12126784771680832,
0.3390785753726959,
-0.5164036154747009,
-0.8281031250953674,
-0.6397892236709595,
-0.7252066135406494,
0.23813554644584656,
-0.36648738384246826,
0.14773814380168915,
-0.4033755362033844,
-0.41820472478866577,
0.05281253159046173,
0.10091926157474518,
-0.46853551268577576,
0.19015200436115265,
0.338718056678772,
0.7818657755851746,
-0.7629619836807251,
0.8097869157791138,
1.0156406164169312,
-0.3419610261917114,
-0.6444821953773499,
0.037768490612506866,
-0.3816448152065277,
-0.2816992700099945,
0.8774356245994568,
0.022382473573088646,
-0.20616565644741058,
-0.39922845363616943,
-0.46271398663520813,
-0.5496641993522644,
0.7349913716316223,
0.6128770112991333,
-0.6498615145683289,
0.4153292775154114,
0.34540456533432007,
0.9008176922798157,
-0.44010406732559204,
0.47931957244873047,
0.4556606113910675,
0.6204963326454163,
0.15893061459064484,
-0.795242428779602,
0.3142734169960022,
0.0564417727291584,
0.0002941350103355944,
-0.13273261487483978,
-0.38941654562950134,
0.6425798535346985,
-0.263058066368103,
-0.11425451189279556,
0.10094866156578064,
1.108254075050354,
0.259647935628891,
-0.03125797584652901,
0.6627942323684692,
0.5467430353164673,
0.7073177695274353,
-0.1002577617764473,
0.8537450432777405,
-0.30224233865737915,
0.20018048584461212,
0.9613808393478394,
-0.49505698680877686,
1.3225630521774292,
0.33093592524528503,
-0.06917092204093933,
0.5985170006752014,
0.7294681668281555,
-0.03587086871266365,
-0.19038204848766327,
0.34416428208351135,
-0.10101093351840973,
-0.9509018063545227,
-0.09919074177742004,
0.015685230493545532,
0.26855888962745667,
0.4603904187679291,
-0.31387102603912354,
-0.05408599227666855,
-0.39474958181381226,
0.2655632197856903,
0.2285892218351364,
-0.14077362418174744,
0.8852770328521729,
-0.007558200042694807,
-0.7729362845420837,
0.6895002722740173,
0.029844965785741806,
0.6697284579277039,
-0.29939910769462585,
-0.17666608095169067,
-0.17692691087722778,
0.030700499191880226,
-0.31036871671676636,
-1.0705254077911377,
-0.03427935391664505,
0.31811854243278503,
0.11924167722463608,
0.22436216473579407,
0.6905925869941711,
-0.23843781650066376,
-0.3988424837589264,
0.17863328754901886,
0.5107036828994751,
0.18898901343345642,
0.08859959989786148,
-0.5454583764076233,
0.32337507605552673,
-0.47824034094810486,
-0.32280871272087097,
0.25291889905929565,
0.3081342577934265,
0.015519941225647926,
0.6594810485839844,
0.5972409844398499,
0.2901514172554016,
-0.009292060509324074,
0.10887999832630157,
0.763017475605011,
-0.2794778048992157,
0.10582809895277023,
-1.341795563697815,
0.6481044292449951,
-0.3662889301776886,
-0.20550012588500977,
0.7919052243232727,
0.2641547620296478,
0.5366905331611633,
0.1312677264213562,
0.7417253851890564,
0.4126734435558319,
0.5196667909622192,
-0.43228036165237427,
0.5846596956253052,
-0.40409496426582336,
0.1815137267112732,
-0.2896369397640228,
-1.0570043325424194,
-0.426853209733963,
0.6539120078086853,
-0.3646770119667053,
0.07328267395496368,
0.5340071320533752,
0.5346642136573792,
-0.08028490096330643,
0.08564554899930954,
0.37453964352607727,
0.17918497323989868,
0.8404812216758728,
0.23128542304039001,
1.2098225355148315,
-0.1529548168182373,
0.41962236166000366,
0.15950120985507965,
-0.023512206971645355,
-0.30893340706825256,
-1.153770089149475,
-1.2251230478286743,
-0.4438481330871582,
-0.7322631478309631,
-0.33562716841697693,
0.0578453466296196,
1.2956832647323608,
0.6221646070480347,
-0.8665364980697632,
-0.137743279337883,
0.38090959191322327,
0.10298173874616623,
-0.15386411547660828,
-0.12826819717884064,
0.5594990253448486,
-0.3491514325141907,
-0.6723381876945496,
0.2433796525001526,
0.3982521593570709,
-0.32119083404541016,
-0.6490524411201477,
-0.18334336578845978,
-0.1084909737110138,
0.5784594416618347,
0.7134321331977844,
0.17624057829380035,
-1.2831871509552002,
-0.6488345861434937,
-0.4680183231830597,
-0.05618809163570404,
-0.0380183681845665,
0.7386310696601868,
-0.4697379171848297,
0.47323861718177795,
0.35302573442459106,
0.8115023970603943,
-0.2273741215467453,
0.1057983785867691,
0.3517672121524811,
-0.4528662860393524,
-0.23647330701351166,
0.12242958694696426,
0.7999750971794128,
0.6914564967155457,
-0.007556602358818054,
0.21330471336841583,
-0.20317433774471283,
-0.7385942339897156,
-0.856559693813324,
0.004447929561138153,
-0.7853078246116638,
0.00166590407025069,
1.63763427734375,
-0.718518078327179,
-0.014031950384378433,
-0.031315878033638,
-0.3536249101161957,
0.02134285494685173,
-0.3461046814918518,
0.8256393671035767,
1.1468732357025146,
0.045057471841573715,
-0.2914921045303345,
-0.5669011473655701,
0.4138326346874237,
0.44177767634391785,
-0.8772618770599365,
0.34109073877334595,
0.5471617579460144,
0.26741716265678406,
0.44289430975914,
0.11775710433721542,
-0.10580356419086456,
0.059317655861377716,
-0.22783511877059937,
-0.1443188339471817,
-0.15386530756950378,
-0.1014404147863388,
-0.32711994647979736,
0.38638341426849365,
0.776415228843689,
-0.001461716485209763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09695v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09695v1
|
LoRAP: Transformer Sub-Layers Deserve Differentiated Structured Compression for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-15T11:53:22 | 2024-04-15T11:53:22 |
Guangyan Li, Yongqiang Tang, Wensheng Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) show excellent performance in difficult tasks,
but they often require massive memories and computational resources. How to
reduce the parameter scale of LLMs has become research hotspots. In this study,
we make an important observation that the multi-head self-attention (MHA)
sub-layer of Transformer exhibits noticeable low-rank structure, while the
feed-forward network (FFN) sub-layer does not. With this regard, we design a
mixed compression model, which organically combines Low-Rank matrix
approximation And structured Pruning (LoRAP). For the MHA sub-layer, we propose
an input activation weighted singular value decomposition method to strengthen
the low-rank characteristic. Furthermore, we discover that the weight matrices
in MHA sub-layer have different low-rank degrees. Thus, a novel parameter
allocation scheme according to the discrepancy of low-rank degrees is devised.
For the FFN sub-layer, we propose a gradient-free structured channel pruning
method. During the pruning, we get an interesting finding that the least
important 1% of parameter actually play a vital role in model performance.
Extensive evaluations on zero-shot perplexity and zero-shot task classification
indicate that our proposal is superior to previous structured compression
rivals under multiple compression ratios.
|
[
-0.5005581974983215,
-0.6901829242706299,
0.18598735332489014,
0.3870140612125397,
-0.32451674342155457,
0.0700569823384285,
-0.24558448791503906,
-0.3428664207458496,
0.43211784958839417,
0.4782816171646118,
-0.652720034122467,
-0.2694309949874878,
-0.5195891261100769,
0.027638543397188187,
-0.35610756278038025,
0.7552788853645325,
0.11596780270338058,
-0.35928893089294434,
0.150445356965065,
-0.04971680790185928,
-0.41454261541366577,
-0.6364591717720032,
-0.7045269012451172,
-0.539364755153656,
0.861125648021698,
0.29792821407318115,
0.5485301613807678,
0.675243079662323,
0.4753563702106476,
0.35534459352493286,
-0.4483955204486847,
-0.005315010901540518,
-0.6649382710456848,
0.14680251479148865,
0.046205125749111176,
-0.29671967029571533,
-0.8084911704063416,
-0.0456768162548542,
0.8378626108169556,
0.6033730506896973,
-0.2572683095932007,
0.21798767149448395,
0.2346963733434677,
0.5279003977775574,
-0.5403473973274231,
0.08516475558280945,
-0.4778694212436676,
0.2090664952993393,
-0.043557941913604736,
-0.22979091107845306,
-0.6188480854034424,
0.24236640334129333,
-0.4337041676044464,
-0.16872069239616394,
0.24752603471279144,
-0.03788025677204132,
0.816024899482727,
0.747675359249115,
-0.17120416462421417,
0.5439516305923462,
-0.9807178378105164,
0.8783702254295349,
-0.8666730523109436,
0.3412710428237915,
-0.03182363510131836,
0.19908565282821655,
0.10638204216957092,
-0.42419859766960144,
-0.2601366341114044,
0.11064829677343369,
-0.15207047760486603,
0.1013556644320488,
-0.23285840451717377,
0.0937318205833435,
0.1743067055940628,
0.5777015089988708,
-0.2886025011539459,
0.45098116993904114,
-0.4119488596916199,
-0.12921226024627686,
0.5544757843017578,
0.042932283133268356,
-0.11945629864931107,
-0.29871344566345215,
-0.41946616768836975,
-0.14469149708747864,
-0.8173550963401794,
0.11037974804639816,
0.46758797764778137,
0.48962780833244324,
-0.07761035114526749,
0.6251636147499084,
-0.2871641218662262,
0.5350136160850525,
0.14934317767620087,
-0.5439915657043457,
0.13757814466953278,
-0.08385219424962997,
-0.5217816829681396,
-0.07566037029027939,
0.7810417413711548,
-0.02692510187625885,
0.33606618642807007,
-0.10716288536787033,
-0.23920032382011414,
0.0980684757232666,
0.45382049679756165,
-0.8376738429069519,
-0.12045272439718246,
0.292727530002594,
-0.580083429813385,
-0.4282354414463043,
-0.31296905875205994,
-0.4885118007659912,
0.02271370403468609,
-0.22794359922409058,
0.3978491723537445,
-0.009312888607382774,
-0.12717360258102417,
0.23480470478534698,
0.23850782215595245,
0.29271426796913147,
0.30743640661239624,
-0.8374281525611877,
0.2997310757637024,
0.562269389629364,
0.6096572279930115,
-0.25665467977523804,
-0.2326911836862564,
-0.2799052596092224,
0.10647020488977432,
0.09343677759170532,
0.8030030131340027,
-0.38624635338783264,
-0.1992112249135971,
-0.39173904061317444,
-0.07346825301647186,
-0.2321670651435852,
-0.510929524898529,
0.7213376760482788,
-0.46026816964149475,
0.12838150560855865,
0.2115727663040161,
-0.025125227868556976,
-0.05365917459130287,
0.15435677766799927,
-0.6988658308982849,
0.9909576773643494,
0.34357553720474243,
-0.7372900247573853,
-0.08267372101545334,
-0.3458538055419922,
-0.5000335574150085,
0.1306825876235962,
-0.15991751849651337,
-0.5050238370895386,
0.30301183462142944,
0.4260147213935852,
0.4582475423812866,
-0.3722541630268097,
0.18601185083389282,
-0.16661399602890015,
-0.4427414834499359,
0.02582520805299282,
-0.45633065700531006,
0.4389449656009674,
0.16328974068164825,
-0.07398104667663574,
0.2971721291542053,
-0.7689552307128906,
0.12617790699005127,
0.24050085246562958,
-0.7174577713012695,
-0.04162749648094177,
-0.08765890449285507,
-0.013668433763086796,
0.5227269530296326,
0.022031007334589958,
-0.5810209512710571,
0.567871630191803,
-0.4715029299259186,
0.6294346451759338,
0.6800676584243774,
0.06378691643476486,
0.4893858730792999,
-0.15027856826782227,
0.6445432305335999,
0.0063628689385950565,
0.35171258449554443,
0.1340477466583252,
-0.2694660425186157,
-1.0401815176010132,
-0.3897915184497833,
0.36336469650268555,
0.43734481930732727,
-0.5353475213050842,
0.5214249491691589,
-0.49945124983787537,
-0.45219242572784424,
-0.6901612281799316,
0.027648404240608215,
0.31138747930526733,
0.4502578675746918,
0.5278788805007935,
-0.09042729437351227,
-0.28015998005867004,
-1.360677719116211,
-0.01665228232741356,
0.07107015699148178,
-0.27386805415153503,
0.32953786849975586,
0.3089774250984192,
-0.03947485238313675,
0.7997500896453857,
-0.5280461311340332,
-0.4902788996696472,
-0.5800764560699463,
-0.05376045033335686,
0.44619977474212646,
0.47314268350601196,
0.36281996965408325,
-0.49245691299438477,
-0.26450392603874207,
-0.2678733766078949,
-0.2988015413284302,
-0.18793688714504242,
0.10662378370761871,
0.10591047257184982,
-0.1382235884666443,
0.26098644733428955,
-0.7358683347702026,
0.29152101278305054,
0.7102929949760437,
-0.002718841889873147,
0.33300912380218506,
0.0477670319378376,
-0.11518172919750214,
-0.8770174384117126,
-0.13332703709602356,
-0.003474402241408825,
-0.22337380051612854,
-0.5045856237411499,
0.27480918169021606,
-0.06966083496809006,
-0.2671269476413727,
-0.7004942893981934,
0.1868794858455658,
-0.3990829586982727,
-0.039550963789224625,
-0.45364925265312195,
-0.22869834303855896,
0.07259071618318558,
1.115456223487854,
0.051241789013147354,
0.6131701469421387,
0.3364885449409485,
-0.47029364109039307,
0.15261049568653107,
0.17377054691314697,
-0.1941460818052292,
0.26162010431289673,
-0.9526785612106323,
0.2475273162126541,
-0.12944641709327698,
0.32299670577049255,
-0.7511032223701477,
0.1422402411699295,
0.23518258333206177,
-0.03919583186507225,
0.44179415702819824,
-0.3796180188655853,
-0.4721185266971588,
-0.32703346014022827,
-0.27837464213371277,
0.5979446172714233,
0.597412645816803,
-0.21897739171981812,
0.6574727892875671,
0.3760893642902374,
-0.26361799240112305,
-0.46436604857444763,
-0.7979755997657776,
-0.0008422238752245903,
-0.3861217796802521,
-0.7683528065681458,
0.6396417021751404,
-0.16281382739543915,
0.07113726437091827,
-0.1343538761138916,
-0.299567312002182,
0.15434999763965607,
0.017602674663066864,
0.28422531485557556,
0.04897933825850487,
-0.5287458300590515,
-0.2640703320503235,
0.030224602669477463,
-0.31269171833992004,
-0.057357605546712875,
-0.07492580264806747,
0.6971518993377686,
0.06437734514474869,
-0.25190871953964233,
-0.18321387469768524,
0.5555307865142822,
0.38826993107795715,
-0.2512948513031006,
0.9364940524101257,
0.4049667418003082,
-0.08972182869911194,
-0.613084077835083,
-0.3725311756134033,
-0.15139079093933105,
-0.5084693431854248,
0.1741296947002411,
-0.43192654848098755,
-1.0530039072036743,
0.36845627427101135,
-0.07716162502765656,
0.07431439310312271,
0.5431540608406067,
0.6128212213516235,
0.04955938830971718,
0.9332906603813171,
0.7135794162750244,
-0.17826764285564423,
0.3013743460178375,
-0.342589795589447,
0.47491738200187683,
-1.0224597454071045,
0.0393495112657547,
-0.6102085709571838,
-0.7232780456542969,
-0.3627380132675171,
-0.39297792315483093,
0.36988914012908936,
0.07307416945695877,
-0.06879260390996933,
0.48438769578933716,
-0.6919383406639099,
0.37561413645744324,
0.31069716811180115,
-0.014001675881445408,
0.2316921055316925,
0.07331855595111847,
0.09026241302490234,
0.04510773345828056,
-0.8746607303619385,
-0.24889476597309113,
0.5081565380096436,
0.7262248396873474,
1.0526041984558105,
0.13657115399837494,
0.682919979095459,
0.1777888685464859,
0.13114029169082642,
-1.0764809846878052,
0.6050768494606018,
-0.16886313259601593,
-0.2288442850112915,
-0.36922332644462585,
-0.5391770005226135,
-0.8601107001304626,
0.537481427192688,
-0.009105977602303028,
-0.5973055362701416,
0.20484578609466553,
-0.026309829205274582,
-0.45618337392807007,
0.22887714207172394,
-0.5949960350990295,
0.5111019611358643,
0.08388491719961166,
-0.08962008357048035,
-0.05745576322078705,
-0.54582279920578,
0.33496126532554626,
0.0938163548707962,
0.2688424587249756,
0.06337370723485947,
0.18950232863426208,
0.8769190311431885,
-0.5046019554138184,
0.7286983132362366,
0.002938831690698862,
-0.381876140832901,
0.13571400940418243,
0.1504971832036972,
0.5464178323745728,
-0.15695901215076447,
0.017922013998031616,
0.1888769119977951,
-0.30008363723754883,
-0.28793519735336304,
-0.5688581466674805,
0.7418241500854492,
-0.7998831272125244,
-0.7484971284866333,
-0.003214583732187748,
-0.6519352793693542,
-0.14935559034347534,
-0.010090678930282593,
0.17312800884246826,
0.4860016703605652,
0.26922526955604553,
0.6043764352798462,
0.5547099709510803,
-0.08597983419895172,
0.4880932569503784,
0.38828176259994507,
0.06732328981161118,
-0.22939352691173553,
0.7549283504486084,
0.22549621760845184,
0.3353475332260132,
0.6466458439826965,
0.2549380660057068,
0.10660550743341446,
-0.7659428715705872,
-0.07213589549064636,
0.4452172815799713,
-0.9294158816337585,
-0.4128681421279907,
-0.5582396388053894,
-0.7070454359054565,
-0.4599025845527649,
-0.009986749850213528,
-0.7042896747589111,
-0.479032427072525,
-0.017097637057304382,
-0.028318457305431366,
-0.12593582272529602,
0.6043642163276672,
0.41092023253440857,
0.7288790345191956,
-0.6864210963249207,
0.5024838447570801,
0.22412334382534027,
0.3476116359233856,
0.08630362153053284,
-0.767057478427887,
-0.36590084433555603,
-0.2760534882545471,
-0.20843365788459778,
-0.585862934589386,
0.5527506470680237,
0.15954117476940155,
0.4712751507759094,
0.283188134431839,
0.09266110509634018,
0.5613978505134583,
-0.5843697190284729,
0.6071914434432983,
-0.13281948864459991,
-0.6643312573432922,
0.22369667887687683,
-0.2329869270324707,
0.49417322874069214,
0.2390039712190628,
0.034317225217819214,
-0.2507914900779724,
-0.39261800050735474,
-0.6824076771736145,
-0.9784726500511169,
0.7876349091529846,
0.4200466573238373,
0.03290114179253578,
0.3374384641647339,
0.24808616936206818,
-0.11075440049171448,
0.16574686765670776,
-1.268934726715088,
-0.537315845489502,
-0.1024865135550499,
-0.051953401416540146,
-0.0010951341828331351,
-0.4238493740558624,
-0.16604165732860565,
-0.2754395008087158,
0.5290595889091492,
-0.09644590318202972,
0.526673436164856,
0.08009997755289078,
-0.11579667031764984,
-0.184800922870636,
0.6356309652328491,
0.49961936473846436,
0.29805344343185425,
-0.18384800851345062,
0.3361000418663025,
0.025139424949884415,
-0.38948631286621094,
0.28938552737236023,
-0.21939577162265778,
-0.2291516214609146,
-0.22749963402748108,
0.568748950958252,
0.8014393448829651,
0.49911531805992126,
-0.06848324090242386,
0.30776792764663696,
-0.052081648260354996,
-0.2802104651927948,
0.08576463907957077,
0.2573779225349426,
0.17921841144561768,
0.10868949443101883,
0.4457686245441437,
0.04909619688987732,
-0.12228526920080185,
-0.26529642939567566,
-0.2677652835845947,
0.2853744626045227,
-0.09304998070001602,
-0.31717848777770996,
0.3620414733886719,
0.1934942603111267,
-0.4945477247238159,
0.47413215041160583,
0.24880263209342957,
-0.513155460357666,
0.3917657732963562,
0.5342268347740173,
0.6647311449050903,
-0.24117740988731384,
-0.008881284855306149,
0.16772329807281494,
0.5958606600761414,
0.018388308584690094,
-0.017058352008461952,
-0.17803208529949188,
-0.5629886984825134,
-0.7455500960350037,
-0.9231736063957214,
-0.10709880292415619,
0.5375056862831116,
-0.4516671299934387,
0.3222476541996002,
-0.41790029406547546,
-0.06449705362319946,
0.06595420092344284,
-0.03057372011244297,
-0.4368729293346405,
0.33941078186035156,
0.14913342893123627,
0.8184351325035095,
-0.7321699857711792,
1.1241931915283203,
0.13915367424488068,
-0.2274983674287796,
-1.0908660888671875,
-0.1550396978855133,
-0.35740718245506287,
-0.6125264763832092,
0.6183989644050598,
0.05255934223532677,
-0.30761682987213135,
0.16337160766124725,
-0.4042244553565979,
-1.0612173080444336,
0.8582369089126587,
0.4982667863368988,
-0.495747834444046,
-0.366169810295105,
0.16527540981769562,
0.4638631045818329,
-0.3629556894302368,
0.09412491321563721,
0.19657602906227112,
0.43012291193008423,
0.3096259534358978,
-0.8299339413642883,
0.0015294281765818596,
-0.2948675751686096,
-0.06326176971197128,
0.4291287958621979,
-0.8152564167976379,
1.1947262287139893,
0.14743810892105103,
-0.41721078753471375,
-0.23996244370937347,
0.6390653252601624,
0.018881453201174736,
-0.34738844633102417,
0.5915356874465942,
0.561406672000885,
0.037601809948682785,
0.0706697627902031,
0.968133270740509,
-0.13187643885612488,
0.41868144273757935,
0.9042931795120239,
-0.21461883187294006,
0.891083836555481,
0.662900447845459,
-0.26357346773147583,
0.5394843220710754,
0.4167579114437103,
0.015001372434198856,
0.46916449069976807,
0.23168253898620605,
0.23394717276096344,
-0.3513900637626648,
-0.11287697404623032,
-0.37569713592529297,
0.5045986175537109,
0.11318688094615936,
-0.2767086327075958,
-0.26325497031211853,
-0.21784920990467072,
-0.16965681314468384,
-0.3212185502052307,
-0.2749050259590149,
0.5581119060516357,
0.20511893928050995,
-0.7161179780960083,
0.8435025811195374,
0.31893646717071533,
0.7725861072540283,
-0.7192510962486267,
0.19011765718460083,
-0.2808644771575928,
0.159703329205513,
-0.33777353167533875,
-0.6014336347579956,
0.28970441222190857,
-0.22135807573795319,
-0.2617683410644531,
-0.6065905690193176,
0.8406780958175659,
-0.277014821767807,
-0.38326579332351685,
0.38987600803375244,
0.43309056758880615,
0.006747547071427107,
-0.26753801107406616,
-0.5426569581031799,
0.2588786482810974,
-0.21745871007442474,
-0.7415775656700134,
0.5337070226669312,
0.09761682152748108,
-0.01570494845509529,
0.5871391892433167,
0.594183623790741,
0.34056565165519714,
-0.08333858847618103,
0.42452073097229004,
1.0853921175003052,
-0.5644939541816711,
-0.512910783290863,
-0.7525409460067749,
0.3890657424926758,
0.18738073110580444,
-0.041000090539455414,
0.6799078583717346,
0.30550339818000793,
0.42212820053100586,
-0.18115179240703583,
0.17983916401863098,
0.18047384917736053,
0.3655243515968323,
-0.49337735772132874,
0.4898168742656708,
-0.5738044381141663,
0.390238881111145,
-0.2525606155395508,
-1.1124653816223145,
-0.17385739088058472,
0.4727345407009125,
-0.06184832379221916,
0.13884642720222473,
0.7160946130752563,
0.5345343351364136,
-0.24935492873191833,
-0.4028501808643341,
0.3857801854610443,
0.19610708951950073,
0.2776396572589874,
0.6752381324768066,
0.686671793460846,
-0.41726887226104736,
0.5831329226493835,
-0.49062854051589966,
-0.014530643820762634,
-0.17741262912750244,
-0.8726673722267151,
-0.8574551343917847,
-0.39161619544029236,
-0.35729384422302246,
-0.009080861695110798,
-0.5573644638061523,
0.5786636471748352,
0.9936895966529846,
-0.5349916815757751,
-0.15781015157699585,
0.20326656103134155,
0.13026343286037445,
-0.21668723225593567,
-0.23686650395393372,
0.23118963837623596,
0.15648163855075836,
-0.5925242900848389,
0.7826263308525085,
0.5673620700836182,
-0.022659560665488243,
-0.63487309217453,
0.11615981161594391,
-0.247878760099411,
0.22474895417690277,
0.6876669526100159,
0.05388433486223221,
-0.8504915833473206,
-0.26056966185569763,
0.06191167235374451,
-0.22085578739643097,
0.22450242936611176,
0.9545156955718994,
-0.8778858184814453,
-0.399585485458374,
0.5686753988265991,
0.3621501922607422,
0.5002191662788391,
0.24656498432159424,
0.389197438955307,
-1.2092188596725464,
0.4274996817111969,
0.32754021883010864,
0.4726933240890503,
0.2564130425453186,
-0.518984317779541,
0.3416881859302521,
0.04384569451212883,
-0.5527850389480591,
-0.7788040041923523,
0.3103253245353699,
-1.2175806760787964,
-0.3657601773738861,
1.1847370862960815,
0.023712709546089172,
-0.5142214298248291,
0.2078656554222107,
-0.31443288922309875,
0.09061604738235474,
-0.3076086938381195,
0.6108168959617615,
0.65412837266922,
-0.180641770362854,
-0.6058094501495361,
-0.24113380908966064,
0.2554791569709778,
0.4964200556278229,
-0.6864866018295288,
0.0416446179151535,
0.12908288836479187,
0.025845972821116447,
0.3250274658203125,
0.33393752574920654,
0.1321651041507721,
-0.22378768026828766,
-0.16611932218074799,
-0.0009819682454690337,
-0.32934775948524475,
-0.6374147534370422,
-0.4117024838924408,
0.6833410859107971,
0.07942337542772293,
0.0596323162317276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09690v1
|
Harnessing GPT-4V(ision) for Insurance: A Preliminary Exploration
| 2024-04-15T11:45:30 | 2024-04-15T11:45:30 |
Chenwei Lin, Hanjia Lyu, Jiebo Luo, Xian Xu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The emergence of Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) marks a significant milestone
in the development of artificial intelligence. Insurance, as a vast and complex
discipline, involves a wide variety of data forms in its operational processes,
including text, images, and videos, thereby giving rise to diverse multimodal
tasks. Despite this, there has been limited systematic exploration of
multimodal tasks specific to insurance, nor a thorough investigation into how
LMMs can address these challenges. In this paper, we explore GPT-4V's
capabilities in the insurance domain. We categorize multimodal tasks by
focusing primarily on visual aspects based on types of insurance (e.g., auto,
household/commercial property, health, and agricultural insurance) and
insurance stages (e.g., risk assessment, risk monitoring, and claims
processing). Our experiment reveals that GPT-4V exhibits remarkable abilities
in insurance-related tasks, demonstrating not only a robust understanding of
multimodal content in the insurance domain but also a comprehensive knowledge
of insurance scenarios. However, there are notable shortcomings: GPT-4V
struggles with detailed risk rating and loss assessment, suffers from
hallucination in image understanding, and shows variable support for different
languages. Through this work, we aim to bridge the insurance domain with
cutting-edge LMM technology, facilitate interdisciplinary exchange and
development, and provide a foundation for the continued advancement and
evolution of future research endeavors.
|
[
-0.03139220550656319,
-0.6738877296447754,
0.5714947581291199,
0.45219746232032776,
0.022065486758947372,
0.15400636196136475,
0.13122597336769104,
-0.7373675107955933,
-0.13861264288425446,
0.2088821977376938,
-0.5466752052307129,
-0.39043325185775757,
-0.4819166958332062,
-0.29214680194854736,
0.012105816043913364,
1.1973520517349243,
-0.1356717050075531,
-0.21166153252124786,
-0.39123016595840454,
0.06241871416568756,
-0.18387103080749512,
-0.40739119052886963,
-0.5303177833557129,
-0.3583751320838928,
0.5489190220832825,
0.11893636733293533,
0.6363741159439087,
0.15229524672031403,
0.6501715779304504,
0.4078444540500641,
0.556327223777771,
-0.053329795598983765,
-0.04838193953037262,
-0.23918744921684265,
0.10212165862321854,
-0.3092687726020813,
-0.5526155829429626,
0.21699737012386322,
0.7014416456222534,
-0.09733755141496658,
-0.3681790828704834,
-0.19058440625667572,
-0.11930908262729645,
0.38888534903526306,
-0.6764861941337585,
0.6874396800994873,
-0.47680315375328064,
0.17583777010440826,
-0.14323219656944275,
-0.6758533716201782,
-0.12084947526454926,
0.110826775431633,
0.5661391019821167,
-0.8427376747131348,
0.11352673918008804,
0.09642669558525085,
1.1344692707061768,
0.46456554532051086,
-0.9803256988525391,
-0.3013307452201843,
-0.6706205606460571,
0.4788970947265625,
-0.04204942286014557,
0.27879709005355835,
0.49157869815826416,
0.542952835559845,
0.18419061601161957,
-0.7140687704086304,
-0.6748581528663635,
-0.44090303778648376,
0.10931117087602615,
0.5431079268455505,
-0.5371699333190918,
0.4504471719264984,
0.21049383282661438,
0.34662574529647827,
-0.38566944003105164,
0.339962899684906,
-0.34943297505378723,
-0.7357496619224548,
0.6805103421211243,
0.06311222910881042,
0.43210986256599426,
-0.2343381643295288,
-0.6719619631767273,
-0.1183394193649292,
-0.7414552569389343,
0.29712167382240295,
0.5815773010253906,
-0.315066397190094,
-0.17119774222373962,
0.5985498428344727,
-0.19798538088798523,
0.3911849558353424,
-0.5368738174438477,
-0.48519366979599,
0.587403416633606,
-0.7636939287185669,
-0.3874639570713043,
-0.032489512115716934,
0.6662774682044983,
0.5900757312774658,
-0.08783627301454544,
-0.12278302013874054,
-0.2224287986755371,
0.008376143872737885,
0.5488554239273071,
-0.6269202828407288,
-0.006670600268989801,
0.07676516473293304,
-0.2083328813314438,
-0.45200517773628235,
-0.12391820549964905,
-0.5544998049736023,
-0.2566688060760498,
-0.22177128493785858,
0.8526948690414429,
-0.5725604295730591,
-0.2977087199687958,
0.20737789571285248,
-0.2229534536600113,
0.6744102835655212,
0.2173292338848114,
-0.7143344879150391,
0.12725217640399933,
0.3959192633628845,
0.7594175934791565,
0.046966709196567535,
-0.23486600816249847,
-0.08985082060098648,
0.3868335783481598,
0.05630127340555191,
1.0330551862716675,
-0.17961686849594116,
-0.03278115764260292,
0.12219476699829102,
-0.11413250863552094,
-0.018253350630402565,
0.11664168536663055,
0.5803641080856323,
-0.48060810565948486,
0.09638982266187668,
0.25636112689971924,
-0.10031609237194061,
-0.6603265404701233,
0.8469308018684387,
-0.6820859313011169,
0.41970980167388916,
0.3818695545196533,
-0.7469868659973145,
0.681277871131897,
-0.832141637802124,
-0.26760661602020264,
0.24944740533828735,
-0.5856900811195374,
-1.0650973320007324,
0.04128871113061905,
0.10752307623624802,
0.5123389363288879,
-0.3618490397930145,
-0.055047228932380676,
-0.37162572145462036,
-0.05150960758328438,
0.40108251571655273,
-0.76921147108078,
0.15170341730117798,
-0.03729585185647011,
-0.25566527247428894,
0.21191561222076416,
-0.733971357345581,
-0.10151167213916779,
0.16566720604896545,
-0.03486043959856033,
-0.5251023173332214,
-0.1906616985797882,
0.18446077406406403,
0.28995347023010254,
0.18256479501724243,
-0.545017659664154,
0.39774513244628906,
-0.17169852554798126,
0.7245941162109375,
0.7409794330596924,
0.12626522779464722,
0.4849666357040405,
-0.4172351658344269,
0.5557352304458618,
0.2818458676338196,
0.24171943962574005,
-0.11530323326587677,
-0.4850209355354309,
-0.2646733820438385,
-0.6887013912200928,
0.049680884927511215,
0.6473793983459473,
-1.1965261697769165,
-0.3335299491882324,
-0.14841896295547485,
-0.41636550426483154,
-0.29826825857162476,
-0.37909257411956787,
0.20375974476337433,
0.3582160174846649,
0.24895404279232025,
-0.13094143569469452,
-0.13699445128440857,
-1.328866720199585,
-0.08400760591030121,
0.11548930406570435,
0.2681841552257538,
0.2807013690471649,
0.5818881988525391,
-0.7125636339187622,
0.8121941089630127,
-0.5128558874130249,
-0.745500922203064,
-0.2584974467754364,
0.2518370747566223,
0.0563918799161911,
0.3238702416419983,
0.7233142256736755,
-1.1302809715270996,
-0.05821987986564636,
0.24800600111484528,
-0.8306058645248413,
0.28499922156333923,
-0.3689207434654236,
0.20890244841575623,
-0.007505995221436024,
0.10107223689556122,
-0.746635377407074,
0.6682019829750061,
0.453489750623703,
-0.28055787086486816,
0.6348391175270081,
-0.7806118726730347,
0.21133117377758026,
-1.0425270795822144,
-0.3470781147480011,
0.29037782549858093,
-0.37150245904922485,
-0.7987955808639526,
-0.1696750372648239,
0.3405904173851013,
0.07020437717437744,
-0.19504879415035248,
0.24974346160888672,
-0.6967675685882568,
-0.35634586215019226,
-0.17624440789222717,
-0.3473619222640991,
-0.1473064124584198,
0.39423176646232605,
-0.27501189708709717,
1.0054931640625,
0.9114052057266235,
-0.6210752129554749,
0.5478711128234863,
0.17036747932434082,
-0.4508196711540222,
0.6643092632293701,
-0.3591800332069397,
-0.10878343880176544,
-0.3353174924850464,
0.048390019685029984,
-0.5543079972267151,
-0.6180984377861023,
0.33362916111946106,
0.07459770143032074,
0.3001551032066345,
0.1357264369726181,
-0.4534996747970581,
-0.472878634929657,
-0.3001154661178589,
0.4720586836338043,
0.1926681399345398,
-0.005018974654376507,
1.2071940898895264,
0.5496131777763367,
-0.5079680681228638,
-0.8558562397956848,
-0.7853731513023376,
0.2940050959587097,
-0.6443175077438354,
-0.840289294719696,
0.7631910443305969,
0.259433776140213,
-0.2043280154466629,
0.24007612466812134,
-0.07921536266803741,
-0.22430874407291412,
-0.08629316091537476,
0.3460693359375,
0.3887452185153961,
0.09080665558576584,
0.399970144033432,
0.14384248852729797,
-0.43300676345825195,
0.15363378822803497,
-0.43775972723960876,
-0.009923771023750305,
-0.39169830083847046,
-0.48359712958335876,
-0.6842336058616638,
0.2698078155517578,
0.3711617887020111,
-0.40670520067214966,
0.35207563638687134,
0.30143675208091736,
-0.34391969442367554,
-0.0688423365354538,
-0.6652950048446655,
0.2815409004688263,
-0.47614097595214844,
0.7115921974182129,
-0.6715347170829773,
-0.9279025197029114,
0.440025269985199,
-0.03648820519447327,
-0.20161569118499756,
0.5288488864898682,
0.8617258071899414,
-0.07360538095235825,
0.6119405031204224,
0.9940556883811951,
0.14659011363983154,
0.5299168229103088,
-0.3280375897884369,
0.1586107611656189,
-0.33412742614746094,
-0.4778357744216919,
0.13230955600738525,
-0.06624150276184082,
-0.5945664644241333,
-0.5361350178718567,
0.8856599926948547,
-0.6361440420150757,
-0.029817946255207062,
0.15420971810817719,
-0.1534067839384079,
0.31837818026542664,
0.48419198393821716,
0.3659698963165283,
0.5643475651741028,
-0.03533022478222847,
0.2714536488056183,
0.3031349778175354,
-0.4311882555484772,
-0.17438244819641113,
1.0686379671096802,
0.679545521736145,
0.8113082051277161,
0.29608452320098877,
0.31207275390625,
0.368569552898407,
0.545061469078064,
-0.6988027095794678,
0.1129496619105339,
0.10146169364452362,
-0.4240206182003021,
-0.243122398853302,
-0.4885057210922241,
-0.8513720035552979,
0.25005027651786804,
-0.2647261619567871,
-0.4315774440765381,
0.13802087306976318,
0.5578641295433044,
-0.7067004442214966,
-0.08892392367124557,
-0.6984955668449402,
0.9346108436584473,
-0.5807167291641235,
-0.15594972670078278,
-0.40931254625320435,
-0.6185012459754944,
0.6159104108810425,
-0.3168063163757324,
0.28821253776550293,
-0.0568489134311676,
-0.07473300397396088,
0.27941301465034485,
-0.25185081362724304,
0.6245748996734619,
-0.011701873503625393,
-0.26312512159347534,
0.32973819971084595,
-0.33638066053390503,
0.41015416383743286,
0.21270813047885895,
0.3876260221004486,
0.1065930500626564,
0.12449343502521515,
-0.19673915207386017,
-0.6376165747642517,
0.44476988911628723,
-0.8047437071800232,
-0.18004515767097473,
-0.8427322506904602,
-0.9440407752990723,
-0.4510158896446228,
0.17671214044094086,
0.18472450971603394,
0.4974859356880188,
-0.1170998215675354,
-0.19247853755950928,
0.4417683184146881,
-0.3145997226238251,
0.4872102737426758,
0.3553158938884735,
-0.008110588416457176,
-0.3645218312740326,
1.1413190364837646,
0.2863602340221405,
0.24908778071403503,
0.3244219124317169,
0.24173088371753693,
-0.5935710072517395,
-0.6340417265892029,
-0.2791602611541748,
0.19464029371738434,
-0.7409629225730896,
-0.3411456346511841,
-0.720201849937439,
-0.21619687974452972,
-0.1772039383649826,
0.31477469205856323,
-0.1522500067949295,
-0.10881248116493225,
0.20222093164920807,
-0.45588913559913635,
0.4143194556236267,
0.6970563530921936,
-0.09793763607740402,
0.4178539216518402,
-0.6147862076759338,
0.25692808628082275,
0.5339655876159668,
0.3321613371372223,
-0.5672364830970764,
0.043701354414224625,
-0.08508547395467758,
-0.32591256499290466,
-0.31007662415504456,
-0.6742762923240662,
0.2012706995010376,
0.30936935544013977,
0.5551300644874573,
0.5757620930671692,
-0.3000766634941101,
0.5760324597358704,
-0.8345143795013428,
0.3508222699165344,
0.3771909475326538,
-0.6143056750297546,
0.1056164875626564,
-0.3754500448703766,
-0.13167448341846466,
0.4709528684616089,
0.47670304775238037,
-0.17014636099338531,
0.021308427676558495,
-0.5451619625091553,
-0.7053931951522827,
0.37487536668777466,
0.49344027042388916,
0.18292167782783508,
0.3528619706630707,
0.07235723733901978,
-0.03490854799747467,
0.5064864158630371,
-1.117079257965088,
0.18169541656970978,
-0.478823184967041,
-0.15892809629440308,
0.05386146157979965,
-0.3728301525115967,
-0.24701398611068726,
0.17366556823253632,
0.42760682106018066,
-0.2468295693397522,
0.5008118152618408,
0.2472601979970932,
0.027637839317321777,
0.3311936557292938,
0.3196256160736084,
0.9984154105186462,
0.3964625298976898,
-0.09841000288724899,
0.29434236884117126,
-0.15903890132904053,
-0.5252373814582825,
0.2208176851272583,
0.7128419280052185,
0.10855192691087723,
-0.4381740689277649,
0.38034993410110474,
1.0091768503189087,
0.1032087504863739,
-0.561847448348999,
1.0709879398345947,
-0.0704256072640419,
-0.5673440098762512,
-0.8820463418960571,
-0.08765984326601028,
-0.4320974051952362,
0.38129186630249023,
0.3058221936225891,
0.1763361245393753,
0.375449538230896,
-0.6698019504547119,
0.41709253191947937,
0.47449249029159546,
-0.5159485936164856,
-0.3913225829601288,
0.674882173538208,
0.23384436964988708,
0.08952930569648743,
0.7086008191108704,
-0.21964004635810852,
-0.43866652250289917,
0.5088105797767639,
0.4215892553329468,
0.6668734550476074,
-0.013838084414601326,
0.10973084717988968,
-0.144640251994133,
0.5230943560600281,
-0.015185387805104256,
0.45265960693359375,
0.082368403673172,
-1.0128859281539917,
-0.7289099097251892,
-0.4662482738494873,
-0.19205157458782196,
0.13306280970573425,
-0.2567209005355835,
-0.05721072107553482,
-0.09756398946046829,
-0.05875388905405998,
-0.12230570614337921,
-0.6802681684494019,
-1.0993165969848633,
0.2961587607860565,
0.14914114773273468,
0.6546972990036011,
-0.6616843938827515,
0.5748258829116821,
0.4144916832447052,
-0.8388698101043701,
-0.764860212802887,
0.07737841457128525,
0.3044443428516388,
-1.182065486907959,
0.8074414134025574,
0.6114604473114014,
-0.1033739373087883,
0.21750587224960327,
-0.2193373441696167,
-0.7744960188865662,
1.3709864616394043,
0.03997998312115669,
-0.42166513204574585,
-0.6154270768165588,
0.3523068130016327,
0.30412599444389343,
-0.2575458884239197,
0.29355692863464355,
0.4594952166080475,
0.4602969288825989,
-0.057041969150304794,
-0.795560896396637,
-0.17614012956619263,
-0.08717704564332962,
-0.1746540367603302,
0.13597427308559418,
-0.6515429019927979,
0.6424795389175415,
-0.23059070110321045,
-0.06793638318777084,
-0.034544721245765686,
0.7918741106987,
-0.1248934343457222,
0.4777029752731323,
0.838037371635437,
0.655414342880249,
0.5489262938499451,
-0.21763975918293,
1.6548246145248413,
0.04107148200273514,
0.3932419419288635,
0.5453366041183472,
-0.3134053647518158,
0.10085953027009964,
0.34484484791755676,
-0.1216370165348053,
0.4059242308139801,
0.6644492149353027,
0.006478479132056236,
0.6572875380516052,
0.3189580738544464,
-0.7085453867912292,
-0.2058296650648117,
0.029657812789082527,
-0.037184543907642365,
0.8812864422798157,
0.42180827260017395,
-0.07901756465435028,
-0.13257569074630737,
0.7626920938491821,
-0.4100445806980133,
-0.6288938522338867,
-0.5077897310256958,
0.6718697547912598,
0.1843639761209488,
-0.49033308029174805,
-0.4254451096057892,
-0.08706457912921906,
0.39815858006477356,
-1.126813530921936,
-0.22848981618881226,
0.2994457483291626,
0.1335097849369049,
0.0817611962556839,
-0.8058606386184692,
0.3435233533382416,
-0.34814906120300293,
-0.036180734634399414,
-0.5652647614479065,
0.8690026998519897,
-0.30277523398399353,
-0.32924753427505493,
-0.028714267536997795,
0.3265576660633087,
0.2060886025428772,
-0.32847973704338074,
-0.49612441658973694,
-0.3022304177284241,
-0.2351916879415512,
-0.24736708402633667,
0.32417210936546326,
0.6497669816017151,
-0.2900135815143585,
0.9335600137710571,
0.5955145955085754,
0.038563475012779236,
-0.1036955714225769,
0.024025220423936844,
0.8539422750473022,
-0.8356867432594299,
-0.7392044067382812,
-0.9642952084541321,
0.8541648387908936,
-0.2118244469165802,
-0.44331783056259155,
0.5727763175964355,
0.2458776980638504,
0.5724948048591614,
-0.1099957525730133,
1.0094090700149536,
-0.09133883565664291,
-0.05404490604996681,
-0.9074868559837341,
0.5095507502555847,
-0.7943142652511597,
-0.10039664804935455,
-0.2880036532878876,
-0.6375263929367065,
-0.4676361680030823,
0.5329576730728149,
-0.5261824131011963,
-0.12321605533361435,
0.5875592827796936,
0.5593084096908569,
-0.013640807941555977,
-0.23836857080459595,
0.515477180480957,
0.12658372521400452,
0.6020207405090332,
0.19894887506961823,
1.076133131980896,
-0.042390819638967514,
0.6608514189720154,
-0.06713824719190598,
-0.5873351693153381,
0.049582384526729584,
-1.096732497215271,
-0.6125977039337158,
-0.5218667984008789,
-0.16211654245853424,
-0.20781974494457245,
-0.09161755442619324,
0.6814234256744385,
0.5209649205207825,
-0.18314528465270996,
0.25086238980293274,
0.06114881858229637,
-0.24413146078586578,
-0.2731802463531494,
-0.13624589145183563,
0.34707897901535034,
-0.25987789034843445,
-0.48283493518829346,
0.44754284620285034,
0.8621740937232971,
0.3042270541191101,
-0.42104455828666687,
0.21913489699363708,
0.19238746166229248,
-0.22562608122825623,
0.7118408679962158,
0.056580860167741776,
-0.5941861271858215,
-0.4464828670024872,
-0.30161213874816895,
-0.03089362569153309,
-0.02907283417880535,
0.929377555847168,
-0.38638487458229065,
0.6052960157394409,
0.053295932710170746,
1.105604648590088,
0.4936652183532715,
0.06001866236329079,
0.8215032815933228,
-0.46198564767837524,
0.47059547901153564,
0.16325846314430237,
0.6144115328788757,
0.12135324627161026,
-0.5974593758583069,
0.5127459764480591,
0.2754210829734802,
-0.726007878780365,
-0.5808987617492676,
0.6589386463165283,
-1.1532057523727417,
0.052350662648677826,
0.8318464159965515,
0.04705127701163292,
-0.1474776715040207,
-0.19518648087978363,
-0.3308655619621277,
-0.076525017619133,
-0.1544700711965561,
0.4880194067955017,
0.5578846335411072,
-0.4577571749687195,
-0.629539430141449,
-0.9110777974128723,
0.6490581035614014,
0.02780870534479618,
-1.0847407579421997,
-0.5176123976707458,
0.3732678294181824,
0.3369700014591217,
0.2216794490814209,
1.03659188747406,
0.0724913626909256,
0.3628445863723755,
-0.07850055396556854,
0.23356762528419495,
-0.288246750831604,
-0.2793063819408417,
-0.32858511805534363,
0.17927111685276031,
-0.09633208066225052,
-0.2795548141002655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09682v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09682v1
|
Multi-News+: Cost-efficient Dataset Cleansing via LLM-based Data Annotation
| 2024-04-15T11:36:10 | 2024-04-15T11:36:10 |
Juhwan Choi, Jungmin Yun, Kyohoon Jin, YoungBin Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The quality of the dataset is crucial for ensuring optimal performance and
reliability of downstream task models. However, datasets often contain noisy
data inadvertently included during the construction process. Numerous attempts
have been made to correct this issue through human annotators. However, hiring
and managing human annotators is expensive and time-consuming. As an
alternative, recent studies are exploring the use of large language models
(LLMs) for data annotation.
In this study, we present a case study that extends the application of
LLM-based data annotation to enhance the quality of existing datasets through a
cleansing strategy. Specifically, we leverage approaches such as
chain-of-thought (CoT) and majority voting to imitate human annotation and
classify unrelated documents from the Multi-News dataset, which is widely used
for the multi-document summarization task. Through our proposed cleansing
method, we introduce an enhanced Multi-News+. By employing LLMs for data
cleansing, we demonstrate an efficient and effective approach to improving
dataset quality without relying on expensive human annotation efforts.
|
[
-0.6128128170967102,
-0.5625472664833069,
0.437595009803772,
-0.06409196555614471,
-0.713394820690155,
0.4605548083782196,
-0.26791858673095703,
-0.6047381162643433,
0.4019174575805664,
0.8520448803901672,
-0.6453139185905457,
-0.600657045841217,
-0.5082327723503113,
0.09180508553981781,
-0.5302104949951172,
1.2674061059951782,
-0.06994003802537918,
-0.11366745084524155,
-0.07406172156333923,
-0.20705848932266235,
-0.2961975038051605,
-0.6352810263633728,
-0.5124585628509521,
-0.3192639946937561,
0.6268271207809448,
0.43150773644447327,
0.7560892701148987,
0.9612506628036499,
0.4529350697994232,
0.22143588960170746,
-0.149443581700325,
0.7665212750434875,
-0.43881115317344666,
0.20948676764965057,
0.13205230236053467,
-0.4473743736743927,
-0.4599950313568115,
0.18952670693397522,
0.5163662433624268,
0.8849233388900757,
-0.03158068284392357,
0.2160421758890152,
0.13054849207401276,
0.8777765035629272,
-0.648756742477417,
0.11768291890621185,
-0.6631010174751282,
-0.16686777770519257,
-0.2741374969482422,
-0.13731276988983154,
-0.22639375925064087,
-0.5426838397979736,
-0.42822009325027466,
-0.6085599064826965,
0.32682788372039795,
-0.10326559096574783,
0.9479719400405884,
0.31161123514175415,
-0.5450831055641174,
-0.16740654408931732,
-0.6533152461051941,
0.7305958867073059,
-0.6961228251457214,
0.2794259488582611,
0.352561891078949,
-0.036042045801877975,
-0.18077757954597473,
-0.32647302746772766,
-0.5372787117958069,
0.1622670441865921,
-0.22823382914066315,
0.11276660114526749,
0.2785588204860687,
-0.05437604337930679,
0.2510703504085541,
0.33444586396217346,
-0.24173066020011902,
0.16308659315109253,
-0.7570024728775024,
-0.2056049257516861,
0.7140292525291443,
0.04241441190242767,
-0.045698486268520355,
-0.13370099663734436,
-0.44865286350250244,
0.19692914187908173,
-0.9685063362121582,
-0.20228809118270874,
0.5943437218666077,
0.6573149561882019,
0.2770093083381653,
0.6483151912689209,
-0.536511242389679,
0.727192223072052,
-0.40033701062202454,
-0.40220242738723755,
0.5847007036209106,
-0.5422174334526062,
-0.11229868233203888,
0.1705745905637741,
0.4424280524253845,
0.3873499035835266,
0.3007379174232483,
0.0039052614010870457,
-0.34950509667396545,
0.09936372190713882,
0.10523395240306854,
-0.59018474817276,
-0.2437300831079483,
0.4111751317977905,
-0.5175875425338745,
-0.39618194103240967,
0.06111951917409897,
-0.6865299940109253,
-0.9179202318191528,
-0.7785545587539673,
0.07704583555459976,
-0.020816151052713394,
-0.3190726339817047,
0.07414747029542923,
-0.23422005772590637,
-0.017270678654313087,
0.8254777789115906,
-0.5012662410736084,
0.00618715537711978,
0.8091814517974854,
0.7554787397384644,
0.11429339647293091,
-0.000594723445829004,
-0.6541460752487183,
0.2881939709186554,
-0.35095030069351196,
0.9579555988311768,
-0.3931119441986084,
-0.19315122067928314,
-0.23475711047649384,
-0.39528119564056396,
0.2521171271800995,
-0.6551365852355957,
0.657378077507019,
-0.5742974877357483,
0.17005014419555664,
-0.2634241282939911,
-0.6664199233055115,
-0.44087517261505127,
0.4038885533809662,
-1.0762150287628174,
0.8588685989379883,
-0.021968171000480652,
-0.7565940618515015,
0.5834468007087708,
-0.594176709651947,
-0.5740463733673096,
0.0054093459621071815,
-0.05866649001836777,
-0.6046224236488342,
0.12084542214870453,
0.6240817308425903,
0.5660465955734253,
-0.11190540343523026,
0.5359808206558228,
-0.46785199642181396,
-0.4351988136768341,
-0.10030549019575119,
-0.5708774328231812,
0.7307384014129639,
0.20238445699214935,
-0.12869738042354584,
0.03806832432746887,
-0.8472874760627747,
-0.3303116261959076,
-0.3530469536781311,
-0.5437043905258179,
-0.3353496193885803,
0.06836000829935074,
-0.15548595786094666,
0.4348103106021881,
0.12884771823883057,
-0.5754972100257874,
0.4412979781627655,
-0.1866835355758667,
0.0759396180510521,
0.6743220090866089,
0.22320738434791565,
0.10889260470867157,
-0.6823402047157288,
0.2785882353782654,
0.11596543341875076,
0.10333035886287689,
-0.33477890491485596,
-0.4375021755695343,
-0.7698666453361511,
-0.8374930024147034,
0.2209540456533432,
0.34549370408058167,
-0.718521237373352,
0.25629696249961853,
-0.43920230865478516,
-0.49622371792793274,
-0.8586098551750183,
0.4950135350227356,
0.020796040073037148,
0.39826613664627075,
0.5203137397766113,
-0.016072232276201248,
-0.586473822593689,
-0.8018326759338379,
-0.3147498071193695,
0.05209524184465408,
0.0672924816608429,
-0.007125601638108492,
0.2833593785762787,
-0.09365111589431763,
0.9547706246376038,
-0.5108752846717834,
-0.5199794173240662,
-0.23913125693798065,
0.3319336771965027,
0.4133340120315552,
0.3010769784450531,
0.057364996522665024,
-0.933021068572998,
-0.05671275407075882,
-0.35853084921836853,
-0.5355463027954102,
-0.14416880905628204,
-0.3324708938598633,
0.10376054048538208,
0.18878023326396942,
0.620175838470459,
-0.47782450914382935,
0.517970085144043,
0.46559688448905945,
-0.1107843667268753,
0.6535954475402832,
-0.04088595509529114,
0.40009406208992004,
-1.0531866550445557,
0.050240080803632736,
0.08911076933145523,
-0.42427805066108704,
-0.5049225091934204,
-0.07249965518712997,
0.06333231925964355,
-0.039115212857723236,
-0.5649558305740356,
0.37305399775505066,
-0.7038113474845886,
0.11953514069318771,
-0.44538718461990356,
0.4092431664466858,
0.3133687674999237,
0.5325785279273987,
0.0755501538515091,
0.5292388796806335,
0.20705372095108032,
-0.6257513761520386,
0.36624130606651306,
0.1437438726425171,
-0.3598153591156006,
0.3455159664154053,
-0.13822637498378754,
-0.14154130220413208,
-0.5030623078346252,
0.49828144907951355,
-1.1280694007873535,
0.00009673201566329226,
0.17698529362678528,
0.013498757965862751,
0.14905743300914764,
-0.20416824519634247,
-1.0400550365447998,
0.0015949388034641743,
-0.7351159453392029,
-0.037376757711172104,
0.03212856501340866,
-0.8827027082443237,
0.4722304046154022,
0.38892972469329834,
-0.28417158126831055,
-0.6001385450363159,
-0.736836850643158,
0.40117231011390686,
-0.3099234402179718,
-0.3212388753890991,
0.14918428659439087,
0.2289670705795288,
-0.2647068500518799,
-0.03446947783231735,
-0.1973578929901123,
-0.1519952118396759,
0.20665057003498077,
0.20305167138576508,
0.46430084109306335,
0.06497206538915634,
0.33693593740463257,
0.19636578857898712,
-0.21020931005477905,
-0.23240041732788086,
0.083070769906044,
0.40320196747779846,
0.27247437834739685,
-0.4989311397075653,
-0.4841003715991974,
0.22347180545330048,
0.6498830318450928,
-0.5226593613624573,
0.7731303572654724,
0.671628475189209,
-0.3845853805541992,
-0.0354306697845459,
-0.9029687643051147,
-0.11074800789356232,
-0.4367642104625702,
0.3370634615421295,
-0.2579619288444519,
-0.6958783864974976,
0.4666697382926941,
-0.38706174492836,
0.4587467312812805,
0.46794623136520386,
0.32287219166755676,
-0.21282045543193817,
0.7992734909057617,
0.11654435843229294,
-0.5106475353240967,
0.4889152944087982,
-0.2639128565788269,
0.14705751836299896,
-0.8519173860549927,
-0.13560861349105835,
-0.6323711276054382,
-0.39679664373397827,
-0.346485435962677,
-0.3038698136806488,
0.05913833901286125,
0.2031496912240982,
-0.11530967801809311,
0.24531210958957672,
-0.4175616204738617,
0.48391470313072205,
0.6861851215362549,
0.3571794033050537,
0.8060262203216553,
-0.0024422958958894014,
0.23337189853191376,
0.31808310747146606,
-0.4443192183971405,
-0.6106520295143127,
1.1987026929855347,
0.23394335806369781,
0.7504018545150757,
-0.04684482142329216,
0.9560792446136475,
0.11458060890436172,
0.6159792542457581,
-0.40957581996917725,
0.4039766490459442,
-0.2640165388584137,
-0.6248046159744263,
-0.3793454170227051,
-0.5661921501159668,
-0.7760373950004578,
0.5469986200332642,
-0.3342359960079193,
-0.6215096712112427,
0.27379804849624634,
-0.14920498430728912,
-0.3229670226573944,
0.7656121850013733,
-0.6439012289047241,
0.42395344376564026,
-0.12013252079486847,
-0.06002483889460564,
-0.3929443955421448,
-0.36982572078704834,
0.5267370343208313,
-0.4309062957763672,
0.7165685296058655,
-0.47057443857192993,
-0.2868000864982605,
0.6435669660568237,
-0.5527818202972412,
0.8626391887664795,
-0.35277432203292847,
-0.20651404559612274,
0.29678452014923096,
-0.29179060459136963,
0.7624984383583069,
0.12908603250980377,
-0.23024286329746246,
0.17833255231380463,
-0.42943504452705383,
-0.20744511485099792,
-0.3898780047893524,
0.42758268117904663,
-0.5233199000358582,
-0.4465183615684509,
-0.1870272010564804,
-0.6591565608978271,
-0.22609123587608337,
0.09930670261383057,
-0.07254936546087265,
0.7030059099197388,
0.35812312364578247,
0.3173803389072418,
0.43035203218460083,
-0.13352632522583008,
0.5617160201072693,
0.30392396450042725,
-0.10285107791423798,
-0.5940796732902527,
0.7616710662841797,
0.2418641895055771,
0.09588573127985,
0.2975761592388153,
-0.029145000502467155,
-0.3610663414001465,
-0.629121720790863,
-0.30304670333862305,
0.16752320528030396,
-0.7076887488365173,
-0.4668627679347992,
-0.8133549094200134,
0.045198872685432434,
-0.12136640399694443,
0.014068185351788998,
-0.31211912631988525,
-0.6370468735694885,
-0.4592437446117401,
-0.25594329833984375,
0.43191298842430115,
0.5168114304542542,
0.10730508714914322,
0.3605031371116638,
-0.9519386291503906,
0.7246742844581604,
0.007467842660844326,
0.4300796687602997,
-0.10637307912111282,
-0.23351967334747314,
-0.4334372282028198,
0.36758455634117126,
-0.16772255301475525,
-0.7261055707931519,
0.22399456799030304,
0.16903941333293915,
0.5055749416351318,
0.36904388666152954,
0.2580566704273224,
0.7244402170181274,
-0.09180577099323273,
0.5137783885002136,
-0.001999450847506523,
-0.8024491667747498,
0.3165895938873291,
-0.30933746695518494,
0.2926267087459564,
0.9175187945365906,
0.07556614279747009,
-0.4968312978744507,
-0.9116072654724121,
-0.5096763968467712,
-1.128497838973999,
0.5502198934555054,
0.07898026704788208,
-0.09403742104768753,
0.14827486872673035,
0.44699832797050476,
0.18522940576076508,
0.5294864773750305,
-0.5266754627227783,
-0.2718261182308197,
0.07447343319654465,
-0.2561900019645691,
-0.09830279648303986,
-0.18325498700141907,
0.015342449769377708,
-0.048713404685258865,
1.0765585899353027,
0.11601828038692474,
-0.24304920434951782,
0.04320007935166359,
-0.32601651549339294,
0.130307137966156,
0.3589058518409729,
0.3678865432739258,
0.6244370937347412,
-0.04894641041755676,
0.054580770432949066,
0.09456544369459152,
-0.4117984175682068,
0.3081172704696655,
0.15099839866161346,
-0.17580896615982056,
0.20006024837493896,
0.48512864112854004,
0.405404657125473,
0.054406315088272095,
-0.5672250986099243,
0.46129414439201355,
0.06679776310920715,
-0.06793200969696045,
0.0356062687933445,
-0.0023644184693694115,
0.2929740250110626,
0.11167950183153152,
0.5686983466148376,
0.21596330404281616,
0.2612955868244171,
-0.3858720064163208,
0.3690440058708191,
0.16127976775169373,
-0.2789445221424103,
0.2479812502861023,
0.515348494052887,
0.259576678276062,
0.22437900304794312,
0.7821751236915588,
-0.23842892050743103,
-0.44902536273002625,
0.5018730163574219,
-0.13131843507289886,
0.5939548015594482,
0.07455115020275116,
0.14510315656661987,
0.18712759017944336,
0.3719909191131592,
-0.33169475197792053,
0.39844369888305664,
0.14770355820655823,
-0.7364810109138489,
-0.9440896511077881,
-0.39983493089675903,
-0.45136845111846924,
0.06294955313205719,
-0.631965696811676,
0.4712871313095093,
-0.19303303956985474,
-0.14788207411766052,
0.16731633245944977,
0.36297208070755005,
-0.573584258556366,
0.472716361284256,
0.26060160994529724,
0.7536802887916565,
-0.7709804177284241,
0.753294825553894,
0.4237988591194153,
-0.45464643836021423,
-0.6211539506912231,
-0.08281819522380829,
0.1686648577451706,
-0.48730558156967163,
0.37622082233428955,
0.40687641501426697,
0.04387570917606354,
-0.17975547909736633,
-0.28042593598365784,
-0.7034391164779663,
0.8330177664756775,
0.5308844447135925,
-0.8208587169647217,
0.29233184456825256,
0.053357820957899094,
0.3710625171661377,
-0.03808220103383064,
0.07585524767637253,
0.38871192932128906,
0.6685259342193604,
-0.1486290842294693,
-0.643963634967804,
0.07071740925312042,
-0.19975246489048004,
-0.4211425185203552,
0.4886948764324188,
-0.617746114730835,
0.8805841207504272,
-0.3441779911518097,
-0.15359483659267426,
-0.22514215111732483,
0.554844856262207,
0.4042915403842926,
0.2870270907878876,
0.7487126588821411,
0.5575188398361206,
1.1185686588287354,
-0.11582524329423904,
0.7979652881622314,
-0.3470454216003418,
0.40866348147392273,
1.4098674058914185,
-0.4370790421962738,
0.6519285440444946,
0.4710620939731598,
-0.034044016152620316,
0.3280084431171417,
0.4841426908969879,
-0.3417467772960663,
0.47553712129592896,
0.4313410520553589,
-0.3858839273452759,
-0.11259262263774872,
-0.2222249060869217,
-0.18841683864593506,
0.45207494497299194,
0.06197980418801308,
-0.27883240580558777,
-0.5016766786575317,
0.10525631159543991,
0.2438005805015564,
-0.03047463856637478,
-0.41590210795402527,
1.034395456314087,
-0.1651005744934082,
-0.3736504018306732,
0.1741710752248764,
0.003542692866176367,
0.7507933378219604,
-0.3291751742362976,
0.00681546563282609,
-0.11595593392848969,
0.16811013221740723,
-0.43120935559272766,
-0.7987345457077026,
0.5094267725944519,
-0.0049811541102826595,
-0.19050957262516022,
-0.3658306300640106,
0.6610739827156067,
-0.7720632553100586,
-0.5844055414199829,
0.19653739035129547,
0.6985804438591003,
0.18159419298171997,
-0.6630411744117737,
-0.4157543182373047,
0.03865249827504158,
-0.04426044598221779,
-0.42092880606651306,
0.08466576784849167,
0.3315572440624237,
-0.05009930208325386,
0.6929299831390381,
0.8997395634651184,
0.40014830231666565,
-0.26369819045066833,
0.4219453036785126,
1.047235131263733,
-0.6315560936927795,
-0.42570602893829346,
-0.9772215485572815,
0.5508512258529663,
-0.24894405901432037,
-0.07345757633447647,
0.592138946056366,
1.0454765558242798,
0.7456198334693909,
0.2770031988620758,
1.0312398672103882,
0.41588687896728516,
0.7770484089851379,
-0.4217495918273926,
0.8472675085067749,
-0.4488368034362793,
0.46453550457954407,
-0.3771018385887146,
-0.9484638571739197,
-0.5510648488998413,
0.1793273389339447,
-0.08120907843112946,
0.051900967955589294,
0.42775392532348633,
0.8790313005447388,
0.0917823389172554,
0.3565571904182434,
0.05506055802106857,
-0.051002152264118195,
0.5675936937332153,
0.21752646565437317,
0.7635833024978638,
-0.2653919756412506,
0.7230252623558044,
-0.3809261620044708,
-0.12933778762817383,
0.027233798056840897,
-0.9112467765808105,
-0.7738510966300964,
-0.27704131603240967,
-0.5869226455688477,
-0.23083917796611786,
0.1048547551035881,
1.0176887512207031,
0.6640927195549011,
-0.862509548664093,
0.01143560465425253,
0.22636619210243225,
0.2669728696346283,
-0.45855581760406494,
-0.15943790972232819,
0.6628067493438721,
-0.36987364292144775,
-0.49705204367637634,
0.3169845640659332,
0.173879474401474,
-0.20133450627326965,
-0.1479429006576538,
0.314693808555603,
-0.39982864260673523,
-0.1593121588230133,
0.48665571212768555,
-0.29010462760925293,
-0.44774362444877625,
-0.09930422902107239,
-0.49342700839042664,
-0.18730726838111877,
0.2968486547470093,
0.7241736054420471,
-0.8446401357650757,
0.37989041209220886,
0.3352610468864441,
0.5534534454345703,
0.5328206419944763,
0.4795670509338379,
0.39011693000793457,
-1.030781626701355,
-0.007352035026997328,
0.09988491982221603,
0.5371448397636414,
0.5718762874603271,
-0.5628080368041992,
0.6042947769165039,
0.15688835084438324,
-0.15847551822662354,
-0.7620862722396851,
-0.1696108728647232,
-0.6224513053894043,
-0.511825680732727,
1.1664257049560547,
-0.02240041270852089,
0.0722380056977272,
-0.48012620210647583,
-0.4026159346103668,
0.4703068435192108,
-0.5828059315681458,
0.8148348927497864,
0.7050787210464478,
0.015272270888090134,
-0.08284822851419449,
-0.5077275633811951,
0.26199981570243835,
-0.14254429936408997,
-1.189013957977295,
0.45907342433929443,
0.607096254825592,
0.01788914017379284,
-0.0471431203186512,
0.5723087191581726,
-0.12809111177921295,
-0.009432297199964523,
-0.16905221343040466,
0.2831393778324127,
-0.5937663316726685,
-0.36495497822761536,
-0.2661176323890686,
0.35568445920944214,
-0.2905628979206085,
-0.3824521601200104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13074v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13074v1
|
Towards Compositionally Generalizable Semantic Parsing in Large Language Models: A Survey
| 2024-04-15T10:44:58 | 2024-04-15T10:44:58 |
Amogh Mannekote
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Compositional generalization is the ability of a model to generalize to
complex, previously unseen types of combinations of entities from just having
seen the primitives. This type of generalization is particularly relevant to
the semantic parsing community for applications such as task-oriented dialogue,
text-to-SQL parsing, and information retrieval, as they can harbor infinite
complexity. Despite the success of large language models (LLMs) in a wide range
of NLP tasks, unlocking perfect compositional generalization still remains one
of the few last unsolved frontiers. The past few years has seen a surge of
interest in works that explore the limitations of, methods to improve, and
evaluation metrics for compositional generalization capabilities of LLMs for
semantic parsing tasks. In this work, we present a literature survey geared at
synthesizing recent advances in analysis, methods, and evaluation schemes to
offer a starting point for both practitioners and researchers in this area.
|
[
-0.2488618791103363,
-0.8292392492294312,
0.9166747331619263,
0.5033379197120667,
-0.11595377326011658,
0.048527903854846954,
-0.4941539466381073,
-0.41064465045928955,
0.13659943640232086,
0.585870087146759,
-0.4957242012023926,
-0.9237554669380188,
-0.6417531967163086,
0.013782803900539875,
-0.5498507618904114,
0.8067680597305298,
0.11376582831144333,
0.170816108584404,
-0.5574602484703064,
-0.13149987161159515,
-0.6541909575462341,
-0.6241051554679871,
-0.38311347365379333,
-0.1917065531015396,
0.42649129033088684,
-0.08070708811283112,
0.4057368338108063,
0.3261139988899231,
0.47664687037467957,
0.3544747829437256,
-0.3602316379547119,
0.12152016162872314,
-0.408602774143219,
0.4643425941467285,
-0.5333836078643799,
-0.5842626690864563,
-0.5011210441589355,
-0.2489662766456604,
0.9931460618972778,
1.2660136222839355,
-0.017031719908118248,
0.06783812493085861,
0.048567671328783035,
0.6202866435050964,
-0.8153402209281921,
0.3312933146953583,
-0.8954795002937317,
0.19383180141448975,
-0.07793979346752167,
0.0837077647447586,
-0.4241744577884674,
0.02993643842637539,
0.35858291387557983,
-0.44253313541412354,
0.14416208863258362,
-0.051399413496255875,
0.2645004689693451,
-0.03428884968161583,
-0.34777364134788513,
-0.5809574127197266,
-0.8762732148170471,
1.205917239189148,
-0.70061194896698,
0.3774767518043518,
0.10824208706617355,
0.4032582938671112,
-0.19871969521045685,
-0.8945549130439758,
-0.35346850752830505,
-0.4385417103767395,
0.008657876402139664,
0.08100302517414093,
-0.153702512383461,
0.24143022298812866,
0.06120501458644867,
0.7645764946937561,
-0.5027498602867126,
0.07765612751245499,
0.2887905538082123,
-0.03173709660768509,
0.5120871663093567,
0.5699504613876343,
0.5381262898445129,
-0.027217630296945572,
-0.20095086097717285,
0.15269945561885834,
-0.39844706654548645,
-0.04899665340781212,
0.21171940863132477,
0.050298962742090225,
0.052628934383392334,
0.727905809879303,
-0.5672964453697205,
1.1776930093765259,
-0.2724904716014862,
-0.0014517001109197736,
-0.09461994469165802,
-0.6596697568893433,
-0.1990683227777481,
-0.4075188636779785,
0.7088582515716553,
0.2400641292333603,
-0.0029392798896878958,
-0.47941336035728455,
-0.3384731709957123,
0.06397984176874161,
0.04218738526105881,
-0.590854823589325,
-0.06320802122354507,
0.2791100740432739,
-0.49389535188674927,
-0.1856488138437271,
0.13003456592559814,
-0.6367765665054321,
-0.13083763420581818,
-0.6253992915153503,
0.06864529848098755,
-0.1919011026620865,
-0.2877502143383026,
0.518866777420044,
-0.068250373005867,
0.5991927981376648,
0.27311670780181885,
-1.1445879936218262,
0.3933243751525879,
1.1365492343902588,
0.793533980846405,
-0.32323870062828064,
-0.33362022042274475,
-0.19684100151062012,
0.40013566613197327,
-0.2221597284078598,
0.715995728969574,
-0.8842336535453796,
-0.4036228656768799,
0.13124270737171173,
-0.09656108915805817,
-0.4290883243083954,
-0.7242830395698547,
0.680004358291626,
-0.5915337204933167,
0.13890518248081207,
-0.26582297682762146,
-0.8384332060813904,
0.006302958354353905,
0.6406028270721436,
-0.5434795618057251,
0.6752935647964478,
0.1826772391796112,
-0.6707693934440613,
0.16903813183307648,
-0.49211037158966064,
-0.1992376297712326,
-0.10253772139549255,
-0.29149481654167175,
-0.041078921407461166,
0.3945239782333374,
0.11002949625253677,
0.5967889428138733,
-0.5641868114471436,
0.6211267113685608,
-0.20726123452186584,
-0.09848129004240036,
0.30380454659461975,
-0.16544543206691742,
0.5173080563545227,
0.14482049643993378,
-0.17748898267745972,
0.2727400064468384,
-0.8512061238288879,
0.12978127598762512,
0.21648450195789337,
-0.36133652925491333,
-0.41779986023902893,
0.13798081874847412,
-0.1442251056432724,
-0.012194017879664898,
0.49926427006721497,
-0.643392026424408,
0.1850520521402359,
-0.5833384394645691,
0.380246102809906,
0.38427287340164185,
-0.12957686185836792,
0.4670908749103546,
-0.18133193254470825,
0.38381609320640564,
-0.05638653039932251,
0.04401944577693939,
-0.3228762745857239,
-0.319277822971344,
-0.853038489818573,
-0.23980388045310974,
0.48866525292396545,
0.4151931703090668,
-0.4702271521091461,
0.8708064556121826,
-0.4679986834526062,
-0.4246186316013336,
-0.13632860779762268,
0.1942773163318634,
0.3854760229587555,
0.2785186469554901,
0.2428630292415619,
-0.20692159235477448,
-0.4231007993221283,
-1.0250113010406494,
-0.4311109781265259,
0.09964033961296082,
-0.3027663230895996,
0.12360872328281403,
0.2591283619403839,
-0.44897791743278503,
1.1323356628417969,
-0.6977260112762451,
-0.3152327835559845,
-0.4681861400604248,
-0.11858757585287094,
0.1806790828704834,
0.4874383211135864,
0.40839141607284546,
-0.5828670263290405,
-0.43197304010391235,
0.16515576839447021,
-0.790258526802063,
-0.020233580842614174,
0.27187469601631165,
-0.18326015770435333,
-0.16571806371212006,
0.5984748601913452,
-0.6920046210289001,
-0.03307526558637619,
0.5496440529823303,
-0.2654896378517151,
0.5022025108337402,
-0.015413164161145687,
-0.2412729114294052,
-0.943886399269104,
0.23284052312374115,
-0.21525101363658905,
-0.18405726552009583,
-0.7338857054710388,
0.4144798219203949,
-0.18449261784553528,
-0.07290540635585785,
-0.14566247165203094,
0.3617403209209442,
-0.34699130058288574,
-0.09686576575040817,
-0.242196723818779,
-0.017780110239982605,
0.05893373116850853,
0.2636624276638031,
0.07839924097061157,
0.3151888847351074,
0.6083208918571472,
-0.45573121309280396,
0.4169341027736664,
0.09121640771627426,
-0.3131936192512512,
0.4556107521057129,
-0.7784466743469238,
-0.050758928060531616,
-0.34490570425987244,
0.3581543266773224,
-1.1330074071884155,
-0.34896016120910645,
0.048522692173719406,
-0.10259506851434708,
0.17862334847450256,
-0.14703881740570068,
-0.45404544472694397,
0.003171273972839117,
-0.22665444016456604,
0.7745320796966553,
0.06076690927147865,
-0.18856051564216614,
0.9206368327140808,
0.2681202292442322,
-0.13185498118400574,
-0.3939056396484375,
-0.622322142124176,
0.1643453985452652,
-0.06255903840065002,
-0.8667562007904053,
0.409885048866272,
-0.062278781086206436,
-0.3990834057331085,
-0.15245705842971802,
-0.05255841463804245,
-0.15462994575500488,
0.0771624967455864,
-0.1454492211341858,
0.10278771817684174,
-0.36303988099098206,
0.06951248645782471,
0.031619928777217865,
-0.1150355115532875,
0.1704595685005188,
-0.35482677817344666,
0.9493192434310913,
-0.3980231285095215,
-0.5241530537605286,
-0.09277821332216263,
0.6112391352653503,
0.394206702709198,
-0.45664170384407043,
0.650588870048523,
0.46952909231185913,
-0.2560827434062958,
-0.2594996392726898,
-0.72955721616745,
0.2128521353006363,
-0.40014347434043884,
0.3980875015258789,
-0.3112372159957886,
-1.2085371017456055,
0.6329623460769653,
-0.18040350079536438,
-0.04146729037165642,
0.7197892665863037,
0.526063084602356,
0.20054003596305847,
0.8161096572875977,
0.46416527032852173,
-0.010545225813984871,
0.28349417448043823,
-0.39494872093200684,
0.12581080198287964,
-0.8183962106704712,
-0.3465704917907715,
-0.5641222596168518,
-0.008885269053280354,
-0.455478698015213,
-0.4642082452774048,
0.200651153922081,
-0.17666685581207275,
0.11085367947816849,
-0.05011711269617081,
-0.3597632348537445,
0.8370763063430786,
0.24025535583496094,
-0.0645153671503067,
0.6391259431838989,
-0.15100228786468506,
-0.14501315355300903,
0.026766611263155937,
-0.3812045156955719,
-0.4466732144355774,
1.0186091661453247,
0.382062166929245,
0.48707079887390137,
0.23153510689735413,
0.6324219703674316,
0.26290029287338257,
-0.09728848934173584,
-1.1453211307525635,
0.7606673240661621,
-0.39364612102508545,
-0.4498024582862854,
-0.4393683671951294,
-0.303877592086792,
-1.1349222660064697,
0.6293708682060242,
-0.06171377748250961,
-0.6061105728149414,
0.09931696206331253,
-0.0594896599650383,
0.005543856415897608,
0.18353039026260376,
-0.5242815017700195,
0.9789525270462036,
-0.019012929871678352,
-0.019979361444711685,
-0.15068316459655762,
-0.712481677532196,
0.5035964250564575,
-0.08360759913921356,
0.0448811836540699,
-0.1942722648382187,
-0.2861488163471222,
0.4890303909778595,
-0.19605767726898193,
0.8298966884613037,
-0.1372237652540207,
-0.36582687497138977,
0.2804177701473236,
0.03953823819756508,
0.3674972653388977,
-0.206595316529274,
0.10376939177513123,
0.013918634504079819,
0.14354093372821808,
-0.5493491291999817,
-0.6981122493743896,
0.7697427868843079,
-0.4430118501186371,
-0.48753297328948975,
-0.17542968690395355,
-0.5247538089752197,
-0.642095148563385,
0.18158015608787537,
0.06683316826820374,
0.42197108268737793,
-0.47645536065101624,
0.3482564687728882,
0.8758730292320251,
-0.10002140700817108,
0.36442917585372925,
0.28406190872192383,
-0.35299152135849,
-0.3580627143383026,
0.971707820892334,
-0.0854327604174614,
0.3205201327800751,
0.6365491151809692,
0.327840119600296,
-0.23161330819129944,
-0.8717739582061768,
-0.18092887103557587,
0.2971152067184448,
-0.7018545866012573,
0.043954115360975266,
-0.8961990475654602,
-0.11275985091924667,
-0.3083057999610901,
-0.01760064624249935,
-0.40925946831703186,
-0.56508469581604,
-0.39589038491249084,
0.12194531410932541,
-0.46975210309028625,
0.7682507038116455,
0.46616414189338684,
0.383713036775589,
-0.6487289667129517,
0.2030196636915207,
0.5426334738731384,
0.3971700072288513,
0.27073153853416443,
-0.1572808474302292,
-0.07227198034524918,
-0.23881492018699646,
-0.2933509945869446,
-0.5290690064430237,
-0.026923511177301407,
0.2361765056848526,
0.6316126585006714,
0.3030034005641937,
-0.23752006888389587,
0.501692533493042,
-0.36734187602996826,
1.0028194189071655,
0.3640904724597931,
-1.1086676120758057,
0.4638841450214386,
-0.7385678887367249,
0.35617247223854065,
0.6711773872375488,
0.23383790254592896,
-0.642191469669342,
-0.33608078956604004,
-0.3386456370353699,
-0.9735639095306396,
0.2813759446144104,
0.0875558853149414,
0.4845660328865051,
-0.0615551732480526,
0.15616333484649658,
0.19684192538261414,
0.28013932704925537,
-0.7517949938774109,
0.03938249498605728,
0.09910554438829422,
-0.27572599053382874,
0.04966489225625992,
-0.5842020511627197,
-0.052811600267887115,
-0.31787970662117004,
0.3736771047115326,
-0.07469719648361206,
0.04474632069468498,
0.05754576250910759,
-0.35450950264930725,
0.4117175042629242,
0.6484819054603577,
0.5507504343986511,
1.0095953941345215,
0.009880201891064644,
0.17257225513458252,
0.02192661352455616,
-0.18534140288829803,
0.1378672868013382,
-0.01125795766711235,
-0.24100567400455475,
-0.10386978089809418,
0.5318365097045898,
0.5415908098220825,
0.32366567850112915,
-0.9037764668464661,
0.8145673274993896,
-0.07289411872625351,
-0.13927294313907623,
-0.3576904237270355,
0.1661885380744934,
0.1672659069299698,
0.15401236712932587,
0.06661627441644669,
-0.39330586791038513,
0.45011022686958313,
-0.6318230628967285,
-0.21170419454574585,
0.6324117183685303,
-0.14503464102745056,
-0.3138714134693146,
0.29816126823425293,
0.024304263293743134,
0.25262150168418884,
0.3977474272251129,
0.07184110581874847,
-0.22634652256965637,
0.3158506453037262,
0.6428813934326172,
1.0548710823059082,
-0.21396225690841675,
0.0731632336974144,
0.02597993053495884,
0.05701103061437607,
0.028821803629398346,
0.03933044895529747,
-0.23666447401046753,
-0.7232765555381775,
-0.6044544577598572,
-0.9573225378990173,
-0.4151931405067444,
0.051859304308891296,
-0.5478906035423279,
-0.056710705161094666,
-0.4631315767765045,
-0.1280745416879654,
0.11317199468612671,
-0.30385622382164,
-0.44455641508102417,
0.03315335139632225,
-0.020877370610833168,
0.6973975896835327,
-0.7856407761573792,
0.37551435828208923,
0.8957083821296692,
-0.07940404862165451,
-0.3505982756614685,
-0.03567761927843094,
-0.4851124584674835,
-0.5559132099151611,
0.4105139970779419,
0.05946500971913338,
0.03158634528517723,
-0.1333065629005432,
-0.5472449660301208,
-0.7244130373001099,
0.8709724545478821,
0.4571518003940582,
-0.30555349588394165,
-0.35859501361846924,
0.7018435597419739,
0.833308219909668,
-0.5027735829353333,
-0.014727571979165077,
0.9935266375541687,
0.4574241638183594,
0.11942917853593826,
-0.7939831018447876,
-0.11006852984428406,
-0.20748469233512878,
0.5377449989318848,
0.1848485916852951,
-0.6362475156784058,
0.7528195977210999,
0.4987392723560333,
-0.010411339811980724,
0.34642162919044495,
0.6321219801902771,
0.034273937344551086,
0.3867358863353729,
0.3701630234718323,
0.8952654600143433,
0.5105423927307129,
-0.1000177189707756,
0.9884681105613708,
-0.15464076399803162,
0.3980276584625244,
1.2169572114944458,
-0.12437522411346436,
0.5641399621963501,
0.3305506408214569,
-0.34211236238479614,
0.40714308619499207,
0.2096407562494278,
0.024113357067108154,
0.23306575417518616,
0.5047466158866882,
-0.712986409664154,
-0.3837219476699829,
-0.39044299721717834,
-0.28451281785964966,
0.764498233795166,
0.49400341510772705,
-0.6193172931671143,
-0.5062942504882812,
-0.01718609780073166,
-0.08749476820230484,
0.23908765614032745,
-0.3668569326400757,
1.2098045349121094,
-0.04800010845065117,
-0.672450602054596,
0.4123923182487488,
0.18607784807682037,
0.5193415880203247,
-0.77211594581604,
0.11937897652387619,
0.05753898248076439,
-0.13604992628097534,
-0.2685922384262085,
-0.7200537323951721,
0.5029557943344116,
-0.1658564954996109,
-0.38526368141174316,
0.06177790090441704,
0.9468572735786438,
-0.47507619857788086,
-0.38161107897758484,
0.325691819190979,
0.6691180467605591,
-0.07185856252908707,
-0.2694208323955536,
-0.4012836515903473,
0.22894760966300964,
-0.12241718918085098,
-0.1255263239145279,
0.44765278697013855,
0.37478184700012207,
0.13622449338436127,
0.47697749733924866,
0.5163305997848511,
-0.08343572169542313,
0.3243165910243988,
0.09050077944993973,
1.1129965782165527,
-0.8701233863830566,
-0.3668130338191986,
-0.9502453804016113,
0.45265865325927734,
0.022527579218149185,
-0.057680025696754456,
0.6210125684738159,
0.748595654964447,
0.9009924530982971,
-0.39594998955726624,
0.7030661702156067,
0.032865121960639954,
0.40290436148643494,
-0.6584939956665039,
0.2689962089061737,
-0.3585573732852936,
0.21342337131500244,
-0.3179228603839874,
-1.3292614221572876,
-0.5601488947868347,
0.15110431611537933,
-0.4236856698989868,
-0.05318077281117439,
0.5508016347885132,
0.6042661070823669,
-0.23465479910373688,
0.19699814915657043,
0.6149012446403503,
-0.0628630667924881,
0.35608622431755066,
0.336436003446579,
1.197199821472168,
0.05067981407046318,
0.1824975162744522,
-0.11503160744905472,
-0.15359672904014587,
-0.005872812587767839,
-0.7593655586242676,
-0.7595839500427246,
-0.5485302805900574,
0.05577906593680382,
-0.13183675706386566,
-0.1662922501564026,
0.8254874348640442,
0.29037022590637207,
-0.7971847653388977,
-0.2997483015060425,
-0.2642545700073242,
-0.05114544555544853,
0.31304001808166504,
-0.20912550389766693,
0.23864556849002838,
-0.7015413045883179,
-0.8290147185325623,
0.3449663519859314,
0.30528736114501953,
-0.02000693418085575,
-0.32889991998672485,
0.25051167607307434,
0.015888547524809837,
0.10879163444042206,
1.1759607791900635,
0.11803559213876724,
-0.7925511002540588,
-0.0103683453053236,
-0.21379157900810242,
0.12970119714736938,
-0.02756457030773163,
1.0071817636489868,
-0.2638492286205292,
0.4604394733905792,
0.5926000475883484,
1.0723544359207153,
0.3428288698196411,
-0.03630165755748749,
0.35574981570243835,
-0.7220866680145264,
-0.07509846240282059,
0.4255874752998352,
0.4827725291252136,
0.22700464725494385,
-0.01971648819744587,
0.5780820846557617,
0.31987619400024414,
-0.6074727177619934,
-0.5269105434417725,
0.506459653377533,
-1.416299819946289,
-0.2786708176136017,
1.1298737525939941,
-0.1689804494380951,
-0.1623266637325287,
0.014441289938986301,
-0.19602718949317932,
-0.17674942314624786,
-0.03085758164525032,
0.41022175550460815,
0.8563936948776245,
-0.04954212158918381,
0.342538982629776,
-0.2625541388988495,
0.11180934309959412,
0.5749410390853882,
-0.9707373380661011,
0.24110044538974762,
0.8281193971633911,
0.34662699699401855,
0.06949201971292496,
0.5191483497619629,
-0.3987058401107788,
-0.013437014073133469,
-0.346312016248703,
-0.25147196650505066,
0.19646428525447845,
-0.23652493953704834,
-0.5071578621864319,
0.43185490369796753,
0.37858283519744873,
0.22679083049297333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09656v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09656v2
|
Learn Your Reference Model for Real Good Alignment
| 2024-04-15T10:44:31 | 2024-05-21T15:04:12 |
Alexey Gorbatovski, Boris Shaposhnikov, Alexey Malakhov, Nikita Surnachev, Yaroslav Aksenov, Ian Maksimov, Nikita Balagansky, Daniil Gavrilov
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The complexity of the alignment problem stems from the fact that existing
methods are considered unstable. Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback
(RLHF) addresses this issue by minimizing the KL divergence between the trained
policy and the initial supervised fine-tuned policy (SFT) to avoid generating
out-of-domain samples for the reward model (RM). Recently, many methods have
emerged that shift from online to offline optimization, reformulating the RLHF
objective and removing the reward model (DPO, IPO, KTO). Despite eliminating
the reward model and the challenges it posed, these algorithms are still
constrained in terms of closeness of the trained policy to the SFT one. In our
paper, we argue that this implicit limitation in the offline optimization
methods leads to suboptimal results. To address this issue, we propose a class
of new methods called Trust Region (TR-DPO, TR-IPO, TR-KTO), which update the
reference policy during training. With this straightforward update approach, we
demonstrate the effectiveness of the new paradigm of language model alignment
against the classical one on the Anthropic-HH and Reddit TL;DR datasets. Most
notably, when automatically comparing TR methods and baselines side by side
using pretrained Pythia 6.9B models on the Reddit TL;DR task, the difference in
win rates reaches 8.4% for DPO, 14.3% for IPO, and 15% for KTO. Finally, by
assessing model response ratings grounded on criteria such as coherence,
correctness, helpfulness, and harmlessness, we demonstrate that our proposed
methods significantly outperform existing techniques.
|
[
-0.3596464991569519,
-0.4513547420501709,
0.5305139422416687,
-0.37412339448928833,
-0.2590419054031372,
0.2417760193347931,
-0.35656237602233887,
-0.652387797832489,
0.012662790715694427,
0.19520846009254456,
-0.8419555425643921,
-0.27947551012039185,
-0.41181135177612305,
-0.038894496858119965,
0.06514186412096024,
1.1350698471069336,
-0.25446024537086487,
0.16785748302936554,
-0.20248591899871826,
-0.31830450892448425,
-0.29380232095718384,
-0.5118220448493958,
-0.3836025595664978,
-0.6809162497520447,
0.4641895890235901,
0.5822440385818481,
0.9837959408760071,
0.9220869541168213,
0.7936344742774963,
0.18561391532421112,
-0.06528367847204208,
0.2808859646320343,
-0.7220451235771179,
-0.058459095656871796,
-0.3203124403953552,
-0.4406013488769531,
-0.3139902651309967,
0.26621919870376587,
0.37160181999206543,
0.24160461127758026,
-0.6301152110099792,
0.017377149313688278,
-0.20375341176986694,
0.7285781502723694,
-0.7271316647529602,
-0.08297169208526611,
-0.5541359782218933,
0.18166127800941467,
0.16081848740577698,
-0.06764188408851624,
-0.45168790221214294,
-0.7476396560668945,
0.5055490136146545,
-0.8519570231437683,
0.11582405865192413,
0.33687257766723633,
1.3443650007247925,
0.5045598745346069,
-0.14266005158424377,
-0.262260764837265,
-0.8806201815605164,
0.9544092416763306,
-0.6978416442871094,
0.6091647148132324,
0.4912218749523163,
0.48071736097335815,
-0.26466065645217896,
-0.46966552734375,
-0.6416227221488953,
-0.4746156334877014,
-0.05401599407196045,
0.11628565192222595,
-0.05129336565732956,
0.0008873007027432323,
0.03724977746605873,
0.11967091262340546,
-0.2847529351711273,
0.14165261387825012,
-0.2090834677219391,
-0.34025314450263977,
0.5532786250114441,
-0.17953599989414215,
0.08657914400100708,
0.16353239119052887,
-0.5324493050575256,
-0.5599691271781921,
-0.788149893283844,
0.046518079936504364,
0.4249957799911499,
0.24763746559619904,
-0.16446688771247864,
0.28149399161338806,
0.007072035688906908,
0.6902906894683838,
0.4661019444465637,
-0.4983963668346405,
0.019550757482647896,
-0.34326300024986267,
0.06631092727184296,
0.08662055432796478,
0.630301833152771,
0.1982221007347107,
0.3123624324798584,
-0.3745836019515991,
-0.20490843057632446,
-0.06976233422756195,
0.4625590443611145,
-0.25795358419418335,
-0.07676053047180176,
-0.03967085853219032,
-0.33926886320114136,
-0.34244832396507263,
0.23679602146148682,
-0.4255239963531494,
-0.28896912932395935,
-0.47365278005599976,
0.24812936782836914,
-0.29139450192451477,
-0.07461448013782501,
-0.20634792745113373,
0.2538827359676361,
0.2788829803466797,
0.3363734483718872,
-0.7299256324768066,
0.1913025975227356,
0.7195258140563965,
0.6063797473907471,
-0.127393901348114,
-0.38479089736938477,
-0.5606534481048584,
-0.07199355214834213,
-0.43985751271247864,
0.5891390442848206,
-0.43980973958969116,
-0.11887107044458389,
0.04702109843492508,
-0.1311073899269104,
-0.012214701622724533,
-0.6126844882965088,
0.5521537065505981,
-0.7596030235290527,
0.48035168647766113,
-0.3587537705898285,
-0.545846164226532,
-0.15071648359298706,
0.329328328371048,
-0.7348722219467163,
0.951127290725708,
0.20758061110973358,
-0.7181185483932495,
0.39616793394088745,
-0.5510522723197937,
-0.13135313987731934,
-0.5536001920700073,
0.0970449447631836,
-0.8760791420936584,
-0.15290777385234833,
0.1747673749923706,
0.07323987782001495,
-0.24693499505519867,
0.39746472239494324,
-0.6018766760826111,
-0.5084797143936157,
0.3556049168109894,
0.11420619487762451,
0.3527996242046356,
0.3300016224384308,
-0.46341001987457275,
0.3115409314632416,
-0.6229462027549744,
0.2147679179906845,
-0.040855731815099716,
-0.23975808918476105,
-0.3996613025665283,
0.003664762945845723,
-0.2442917674779892,
0.488222599029541,
0.1546383947134018,
-0.4645744264125824,
0.18647658824920654,
-0.44534772634506226,
0.5171329975128174,
0.784094512462616,
-0.044024042785167694,
0.5728128552436829,
-0.36145108938217163,
0.6957997679710388,
-0.027870075777173042,
0.18446539342403412,
0.4119420051574707,
-0.08767606317996979,
-0.6761398911476135,
-0.1266549676656723,
0.7205464243888855,
0.43097347021102905,
-0.6732255816459656,
0.49073508381843567,
-0.4493098258972168,
-0.5205938220024109,
-0.9311214685440063,
-0.07651269435882568,
0.8098403215408325,
0.6895649433135986,
0.5106275677680969,
-0.33248186111450195,
-0.42524415254592896,
-0.9057955145835876,
-0.23614753782749176,
-0.38713255524635315,
0.33122697472572327,
0.19401587545871735,
0.5086884498596191,
-0.03017423488199711,
1.129006266593933,
-0.24622002243995667,
-0.2769661545753479,
-0.031700145453214645,
0.2695354223251343,
-0.20337989926338196,
0.5071256756782532,
0.21282824873924255,
-0.6969686150550842,
-0.5856191515922546,
0.11065176874399185,
-0.4870014488697052,
0.022610550746321678,
-0.15092907845973969,
-0.1738073080778122,
0.2780303359031677,
0.3038097321987152,
-0.36889445781707764,
0.1306452751159668,
0.6209610104560852,
-0.21664321422576904,
0.39200907945632935,
-0.2153746336698532,
0.17545537650585175,
-1.0371983051300049,
0.1448303759098053,
0.06844880431890488,
-0.560093343257904,
-0.3487720191478729,
0.31984734535217285,
0.04592558741569519,
0.042192164808511734,
-0.5136106014251709,
0.39392420649528503,
-0.40735456347465515,
-0.12377161532640457,
-0.14977264404296875,
0.3233683407306671,
-0.18563546240329742,
0.7005373239517212,
0.24566487967967987,
0.7799248695373535,
-0.05411917343735695,
-0.5502767562866211,
0.2889169454574585,
0.3808221220970154,
-0.24933214485645294,
0.4380016028881073,
-0.5470146536827087,
0.28568893671035767,
-0.054244473576545715,
0.5296536087989807,
-0.5469556450843811,
-0.18517334759235382,
0.48178303241729736,
-0.3375587463378906,
0.4326574206352234,
0.09502226114273071,
-0.13260751962661743,
-0.2337254285812378,
-0.22461773455142975,
0.3796546161174774,
0.44697508215904236,
-0.6933779120445251,
0.30159205198287964,
0.3430173397064209,
0.29785728454589844,
-0.9565697312355042,
-0.41265222430229187,
-0.2949872314929962,
-0.3071143329143524,
-0.3066187798976898,
0.5402017831802368,
0.14676718413829803,
-0.21284343302249908,
0.1794583648443222,
-0.28198736906051636,
-0.23367689549922943,
0.10735436528921127,
-0.04181627184152603,
0.2875882387161255,
-0.003911957144737244,
-0.004588955547660589,
-0.2549954950809479,
-0.23247605562210083,
-0.2627045214176178,
-0.22576847672462463,
0.20481300354003906,
-0.15467531979084015,
-0.34344911575317383,
-0.8817241787910461,
-0.0469675213098526,
0.4363071322441101,
-0.2831456959247589,
0.6414883732795715,
0.45676618814468384,
-0.1869364082813263,
-0.005362216383218765,
-0.3604773283004761,
-0.47138410806655884,
-0.3692570626735687,
0.43035441637039185,
-0.16650089621543884,
-0.98322993516922,
0.3523908853530884,
-0.017877692356705666,
0.014365051873028278,
0.07752754539251328,
0.4013902246952057,
-0.14401479065418243,
0.938597559928894,
0.83815997838974,
-0.20324765145778656,
0.6546421051025391,
0.02609967067837715,
0.33952876925468445,
-0.6662156581878662,
-0.0880516916513443,
-0.5553306341171265,
-0.3584868013858795,
-0.7414833307266235,
-0.3104332685470581,
0.22433434426784515,
0.30922409892082214,
-0.34902873635292053,
0.5561602115631104,
-0.4521137475967407,
0.40697577595710754,
0.7073528170585632,
0.43440163135528564,
0.2780507802963257,
-0.04116031527519226,
-0.2964915335178375,
-0.46660107374191284,
-0.8814361095428467,
-0.3826994299888611,
0.973686933517456,
0.5821528434753418,
0.953669011592865,
0.1097087562084198,
0.7787284851074219,
0.32067161798477173,
0.4562603533267975,
-0.7231833934783936,
0.14723989367485046,
0.30193087458610535,
-0.4496862590312958,
-0.33152347803115845,
-0.5141844749450684,
-0.6368270516395569,
0.14763565361499786,
-0.4468212425708771,
-0.5536739230155945,
0.19108699262142181,
0.6603590250015259,
-0.560206949710846,
0.22724157571792603,
-0.5493618845939636,
0.81146240234375,
-0.18365135788917542,
-0.5179497003555298,
-0.2340836077928543,
-0.9797325730323792,
0.4217314124107361,
-0.01782797835767269,
0.13623325526714325,
0.13593876361846924,
0.19068878889083862,
0.6831497550010681,
-0.5619311928749084,
0.5961041450500488,
-0.05261838808655739,
-0.09929823130369186,
0.3896060287952423,
0.0267683956772089,
0.8858010172843933,
-0.2348734736442566,
0.12598635256290436,
-0.15978991985321045,
0.05486246198415756,
-0.32296106219291687,
-0.7130460739135742,
0.5784246325492859,
-0.9992938041687012,
-0.3023332357406616,
-0.6301057934761047,
-0.43361547589302063,
-0.44605228304862976,
0.07190953195095062,
0.20340436697006226,
0.048284437507390976,
-0.2594262957572937,
0.10236804187297821,
0.7293137907981873,
-0.0021347145084291697,
0.15124166011810303,
0.5159004330635071,
0.11072266846895218,
-0.5330013632774353,
0.8599412441253662,
-0.2631288766860962,
0.5289800763130188,
0.586354672908783,
0.32761502265930176,
-0.6000494956970215,
-0.21815574169158936,
-0.3037170469760895,
0.38719430565834045,
-0.7246124744415283,
-0.23146972060203552,
-0.08816873282194138,
0.12612777948379517,
-0.30773407220840454,
-0.06274016946554184,
-0.6799741387367249,
-0.3901957869529724,
-0.13301625847816467,
-0.011953847482800484,
0.01969030871987343,
0.5898757576942444,
-0.12824483215808868,
0.4395214021205902,
-0.803361177444458,
-0.038804709911346436,
0.1775350272655487,
0.3148480951786041,
-0.07725721597671509,
-0.5139956474304199,
-0.4709019660949707,
0.2604343593120575,
-0.48685339093208313,
-0.7126495242118835,
0.15406349301338196,
0.14846350252628326,
0.4617823362350464,
0.28266945481300354,
0.25059911608695984,
0.9297100305557251,
-0.28286176919937134,
0.41156822443008423,
0.25112247467041016,
-0.8202833533287048,
0.22215329110622406,
-0.18636183440685272,
0.13520222902297974,
0.7613201141357422,
0.5976853966712952,
-0.5586714148521423,
-0.20098881423473358,
-0.7723163366317749,
-0.4814041256904602,
0.7604395151138306,
0.03723429515957832,
-0.4452824592590332,
0.40089911222457886,
0.6669170260429382,
-0.09712795168161392,
0.2560870945453644,
-0.9637236595153809,
-0.07711069285869598,
-0.1512499898672104,
-0.3480153977870941,
0.289920836687088,
-0.05723794177174568,
-0.3373452126979828,
-0.006143186241388321,
1.0829415321350098,
-0.2984512448310852,
0.2964555025100708,
0.3912853002548218,
-0.07224921882152557,
-0.5778012871742249,
0.3222915530204773,
0.8571867346763611,
0.9302152991294861,
-0.235920712351799,
-0.1233903020620346,
0.007793397642672062,
-0.19946672022342682,
0.236643984913826,
-0.2274773269891739,
-0.3348628878593445,
-0.25045040249824524,
0.4694629907608032,
0.9400247931480408,
0.28019124269485474,
-0.5260419845581055,
0.4265424609184265,
-0.06407055258750916,
-0.22845153510570526,
-0.12070521712303162,
0.03014056384563446,
-0.12047407031059265,
0.09379825741052628,
-0.08562252670526505,
0.13522274792194366,
-0.2949075698852539,
-0.5095309615135193,
0.3707844913005829,
0.38721805810928345,
-0.9887008666992188,
-0.36513790488243103,
0.6595783233642578,
0.13409171998500824,
-0.18222667276859283,
0.6255668997764587,
-0.21150505542755127,
-0.8124381899833679,
0.3413369655609131,
0.5542418360710144,
0.6190001368522644,
-0.10445316135883331,
0.3249330520629883,
0.5498301386833191,
0.2949157953262329,
-0.459453821182251,
-0.04916585236787796,
0.04020567983388901,
-0.8553544282913208,
-0.396937757730484,
-0.3641395568847656,
-0.6702480912208557,
0.0677463635802269,
-0.8774932026863098,
0.18101420998573303,
-0.38962888717651367,
-0.20926842093467712,
-0.4053325355052948,
0.04718790575861931,
-0.3555866479873657,
0.2457318753004074,
-0.0915336087346077,
0.5698793530464172,
-0.7475762367248535,
1.0430773496627808,
0.854099690914154,
-0.4148740768432617,
-1.0271310806274414,
0.1995456963777542,
0.062290843576192856,
-0.7973031997680664,
0.49446067214012146,
-0.30808019638061523,
-0.17514337599277496,
0.042506877332925797,
-0.6173195838928223,
-1.03408682346344,
1.0711158514022827,
0.36073750257492065,
-0.7811715006828308,
-0.35543328523635864,
-0.08670329302549362,
0.6174560785293579,
-0.37972113490104675,
0.12468009442090988,
0.4965479075908661,
0.5103065967559814,
0.05849429592490196,
-1.0983108282089233,
0.017210442572832108,
0.2785382568836212,
0.08199170231819153,
0.3692447543144226,
-0.7494436502456665,
0.440470427274704,
-0.4351741373538971,
-0.179043248295784,
0.07578172534704208,
0.7905506491661072,
0.38265731930732727,
-0.07663973420858383,
0.6419594287872314,
0.8282149434089661,
0.7500768303871155,
-0.20420807600021362,
1.0163836479187012,
-0.2777210474014282,
0.7702692151069641,
1.3823531866073608,
-0.24531622231006622,
0.9463669061660767,
0.7900022268295288,
-0.09601155668497086,
0.5985074639320374,
0.8495375514030457,
0.09781642258167267,
0.8210525512695312,
0.13304336369037628,
0.1552758812904358,
-0.4134327173233032,
-0.1817787140607834,
-0.29318493604660034,
0.3109188377857208,
-0.1760425567626953,
-0.18195600807666779,
-0.2371855229139328,
-0.23367667198181152,
0.19509616494178772,
0.6060681343078613,
0.03009522333741188,
0.6594350934028625,
0.04922143742442131,
-1.1589678525924683,
0.6174253821372986,
0.11681896448135376,
0.5025853514671326,
-0.6756840348243713,
-0.15843476355075836,
-0.010579438880085945,
0.5014406442642212,
-0.07768619060516357,
-0.1925363689661026,
0.2077595740556717,
-0.36863207817077637,
-0.1493443101644516,
-0.06591147184371948,
0.4320688843727112,
-0.6454209089279175,
-0.05259328335523605,
0.21932671964168549,
0.3037565052509308,
-0.3252168297767639,
0.35410910844802856,
-1.0210039615631104,
-0.0697796493768692,
0.1671958565711975,
-0.1643810272216797,
0.36654967069625854,
0.05201123282313347,
-0.4095636308193207,
0.86269611120224,
0.5852745771408081,
0.079246386885643,
-0.17892949283123016,
-0.3032730519771576,
0.5511161684989929,
-0.6598182916641235,
-0.6799156665802002,
-0.5277826189994812,
0.1442788988351822,
0.10964594781398773,
-0.4376404285430908,
0.4380675256252289,
0.24350841343402863,
1.2353140115737915,
0.026569543406367302,
0.6080098748207092,
-0.09071427583694458,
0.699299156665802,
-0.5575175881385803,
0.545598030090332,
-0.6665987968444824,
0.10844369977712631,
-0.1691652238368988,
-0.8420961499214172,
-0.1512102633714676,
0.9343855977058411,
-0.3191033899784088,
0.05576647073030472,
0.9893585443496704,
0.7767922282218933,
-0.11370775103569031,
-0.07317234575748444,
0.06556139886379242,
0.017918985337018967,
0.22746434807777405,
0.4870583713054657,
0.8135613203048706,
-0.4884682297706604,
0.505340576171875,
-0.607263445854187,
-0.0968240350484848,
-0.20565669238567352,
-1.0864797830581665,
-0.5515296459197998,
-0.49906668066978455,
-0.5156805515289307,
-0.6448821425437927,
0.26748397946357727,
1.3988008499145508,
0.87840735912323,
-0.950444757938385,
-0.2479347437620163,
-0.18163561820983887,
0.2450641393661499,
-0.5949272513389587,
-0.21552766859531403,
0.3718867003917694,
-0.2418588101863861,
-0.5920447111129761,
0.18228472769260406,
-0.1256028264760971,
0.11755553632974625,
-0.3088608980178833,
-0.5598846673965454,
-0.4125330150127411,
-0.2706143856048584,
0.09621112048625946,
0.56355220079422,
-0.8598051071166992,
-0.5431158542633057,
0.12010247260332108,
-0.3110193610191345,
0.1849355846643448,
0.8410891890525818,
-0.5477224588394165,
0.45288097858428955,
0.4961141347885132,
0.6938285827636719,
0.2596256136894226,
0.4472920596599579,
0.8997196555137634,
-0.5719555020332336,
0.06190033629536629,
0.31888872385025024,
0.2378658950328827,
0.32325229048728943,
-0.2338116466999054,
0.6045227646827698,
0.2927091419696808,
-0.6966270208358765,
-0.7712823748588562,
0.29808521270751953,
-0.7240859270095825,
-0.0802033469080925,
0.9326496124267578,
-0.36923646926879883,
-0.4946207106113434,
0.06953628361225128,
-0.07014984637498856,
0.4972231090068817,
-0.4793856739997864,
1.2284051179885864,
0.7566770315170288,
-0.17265678942203522,
-0.04034403711557388,
-0.14412687718868256,
0.8556448221206665,
0.6700915098190308,
-0.6525258421897888,
-0.04874648153781891,
0.514058530330658,
0.23701700568199158,
0.2588757872581482,
0.5104758739471436,
-0.1312338411808014,
0.44497907161712646,
-0.43159958720207214,
0.2813068926334381,
-0.02665148489177227,
-0.4404158294200897,
-0.34169960021972656,
-0.08972875028848648,
0.4471568465232849,
-0.08763263374567032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09645v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09645v1
|
Real-world Instance-specific Image Goal Navigation for Service Robots: Bridging the Domain Gap with Contrastive Learning
| 2024-04-15T10:24:32 | 2024-04-15T10:24:32 |
Taichi Sakaguchi, Akira Taniguchi, Yoshinobu Hagiwara, Lotfi El Hafi, Shoichi Hasegawa, Tadahiro Taniguchi
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Improving instance-specific image goal navigation (InstanceImageNav), which
locates the identical object in a real-world environment from a query image, is
essential for robotic systems to assist users in finding desired objects. The
challenge lies in the domain gap between low-quality images observed by the
moving robot, characterized by motion blur and low-resolution, and high-quality
query images provided by the user. Such domain gaps could significantly reduce
the task success rate but have not been the focus of previous work. To address
this, we propose a novel method called Few-shot Cross-quality Instance-aware
Adaptation (CrossIA), which employs contrastive learning with an instance
classifier to align features between massive low- and few high-quality images.
This approach effectively reduces the domain gap by bringing the latent
representations of cross-quality images closer on an instance basis.
Additionally, the system integrates an object image collection with a
pre-trained deblurring model to enhance the observed image quality. Our method
fine-tunes the SimSiam model, pre-trained on ImageNet, using CrossIA. We
evaluated our method's effectiveness through an InstanceImageNav task with 20
different types of instances, where the robot identifies the same instance in a
real-world environment as a high-quality query image. Our experiments showed
that our method improves the task success rate by up to three times compared to
the baseline, a conventional approach based on SuperGlue. These findings
highlight the potential of leveraging contrastive learning and image
enhancement techniques to bridge the domain gap and improve object localization
in robotic applications. The project website is
https://emergentsystemlabstudent.github.io/DomainBridgingNav/.
|
[
-0.4368867576122284,
-0.6309999823570251,
0.5052399039268494,
-0.5745984315872192,
-0.4335673153400421,
0.06125162914395332,
0.2963818907737732,
-0.5837158560752869,
0.054907191544771194,
0.40018749237060547,
-0.5869857668876648,
-0.5713404417037964,
-0.43359678983688354,
-0.19313573837280273,
0.048320986330509186,
0.45336657762527466,
0.0845569372177124,
-0.2865937352180481,
-0.2504335641860962,
-0.3898896276950836,
-0.24986739456653595,
-0.2582440674304962,
-0.6750118136405945,
-0.20981207489967346,
0.4585919678211212,
0.6882767677307129,
0.9407877326011658,
0.57069993019104,
0.6901329755783081,
0.26976245641708374,
0.16430950164794922,
0.5076437592506409,
-0.47927984595298767,
-0.0719013437628746,
-0.3530908226966858,
-0.573659360408783,
-0.17579028010368347,
-0.30676618218421936,
0.08862276375293732,
0.5488163232803345,
-0.12881401181221008,
-0.10542354732751846,
0.12877322733402252,
0.759918749332428,
-0.8555057048797607,
-0.24289143085479736,
-0.34244272112846375,
0.23363469541072845,
0.09608913958072662,
-0.09145341068506241,
0.06122709810733795,
0.09379202872514725,
0.17708265781402588,
-1.0883466005325317,
0.4549048840999603,
0.25428512692451477,
1.401412844657898,
0.4191405177116394,
-0.09473054856061935,
0.19055065512657166,
-0.632770299911499,
0.9651530385017395,
-0.5235100984573364,
0.4423184096813202,
0.314335435628891,
0.6456971764564514,
-0.02420276217162609,
-0.3991241753101349,
-0.34816572070121765,
0.058746177703142166,
0.0826520323753357,
0.5995686054229736,
-0.4125317335128784,
-0.05432229861617088,
-0.052972108125686646,
0.07548559457063675,
-0.7926297783851624,
0.2670871615409851,
-0.40885716676712036,
0.005714734550565481,
0.4022323787212372,
0.17438507080078125,
0.20876441895961761,
0.15341772139072418,
-0.6431075930595398,
-0.26684045791625977,
-0.6154151558876038,
0.212202250957489,
0.23783721029758453,
0.4802529215812683,
-0.3324050009250641,
0.18972189724445343,
-0.4489501118659973,
0.7505886554718018,
0.16154876351356506,
-0.06821778416633606,
0.34469160437583923,
-0.34248292446136475,
-0.2621959447860718,
-0.1432483047246933,
0.3271457254886627,
0.5925278663635254,
-0.09182797372341156,
-0.07246154546737671,
-0.23025937378406525,
0.18875551223754883,
0.4677310585975647,
-0.7048023343086243,
-0.11334062367677689,
0.20473626255989075,
-0.6175122261047363,
0.16995547711849213,
0.09024660289287567,
-0.5615969896316528,
-0.11223205924034119,
-0.16544662415981293,
0.35923442244529724,
-0.3792429566383362,
-0.016895975917577744,
0.1111663281917572,
0.09410938620567322,
0.244367778301239,
0.6817596554756165,
-0.5061940550804138,
0.28855961561203003,
0.3684377670288086,
0.9466145634651184,
-0.17642842233181,
-0.2302754521369934,
-0.6461596488952637,
0.29636141657829285,
-0.4450189471244812,
1.0294586420059204,
-0.5295193195343018,
-0.3192777931690216,
0.06305462121963501,
0.13211703300476074,
0.24900315701961517,
-0.9707592129707336,
0.3212199807167053,
-0.6850136518478394,
-0.05588780343532562,
0.18107429146766663,
-0.21215315163135529,
-0.6275219917297363,
0.4014933407306671,
-0.4314376413822174,
0.8107866644859314,
0.36731112003326416,
-0.11899074912071228,
0.37124425172805786,
-0.3698677122592926,
-0.385650634765625,
0.0384487509727478,
-0.05302863568067551,
-0.7584459781646729,
-0.09775379300117493,
0.2632674276828766,
0.5859872698783875,
-0.3675104081630707,
-0.3979935944080353,
-0.19693440198898315,
-0.4207806885242462,
-0.3069797158241272,
0.20613539218902588,
0.4507455825805664,
0.10188253223896027,
-0.20119576156139374,
0.07968489825725555,
-0.5130725502967834,
-0.0964515283703804,
0.11148210614919662,
0.1522270143032074,
-0.559724748134613,
-0.38680028915405273,
-0.09240740537643433,
0.3527936041355133,
0.05334718897938728,
-0.42634493112564087,
0.23346440494060516,
-0.10741977393627167,
-0.2022079974412918,
0.5812405943870544,
-0.014961854554712772,
0.43820422887802124,
-0.451067715883255,
0.7014145851135254,
0.30132198333740234,
0.4600076377391815,
-0.2030191868543625,
-0.46467578411102295,
-0.7467132210731506,
-0.26979318261146545,
0.17409777641296387,
0.5952557921409607,
-0.9711911678314209,
0.4757194221019745,
0.00027254701126366854,
-0.4038229286670685,
-0.4373047947883606,
0.15404048562049866,
0.6538505554199219,
0.7125835418701172,
0.7875023484230042,
-0.6897454857826233,
-0.3479973077774048,
-0.9135779142379761,
0.26128819584846497,
0.11126042902469635,
-0.09039076417684555,
0.7170459032058716,
0.45588815212249756,
-0.38473719358444214,
0.5242471098899841,
-0.5405575633049011,
-0.9154055714607239,
-0.10296839475631714,
0.055016905069351196,
0.1640261709690094,
0.5572649240493774,
0.5244622230529785,
-0.9196525812149048,
-0.2807479500770569,
0.16607433557510376,
-0.8077006340026855,
0.14500990509986877,
-0.3377651870250702,
-0.3207117021083832,
0.15517950057983398,
0.349786639213562,
-0.09355448931455612,
0.5250152945518494,
0.7255640029907227,
-0.003381697926670313,
0.239868625998497,
-0.30017250776290894,
0.4669990539550781,
-0.8697740435600281,
-0.19723954796791077,
0.3848835825920105,
-0.39770087599754333,
-0.4958633780479431,
0.0849163830280304,
-0.23479939997196198,
-0.019854115322232246,
-0.8061274886131287,
0.1616918444633484,
-0.4635961353778839,
-0.5407920479774475,
-0.35192960500717163,
0.3827376365661621,
-0.010780014097690582,
0.5110008120536804,
0.22705072164535522,
0.734174907207489,
0.8660404682159424,
-0.8516311645507812,
0.2568332552909851,
0.29138991236686707,
-0.19712050259113312,
0.8649780750274658,
-0.5343509912490845,
0.2636566460132599,
0.18497100472450256,
0.10408084094524384,
-0.7898240685462952,
0.05061274394392967,
0.38522106409072876,
-0.2529838979244232,
-0.023945866152644157,
-0.5071354508399963,
-0.12359150499105453,
0.0726039782166481,
-0.023542463779449463,
0.5810937881469727,
0.7134872078895569,
-0.7280471324920654,
0.5158119201660156,
0.05251091346144676,
0.15482091903686523,
-0.5109760761260986,
-0.7341638803482056,
-0.014696517027914524,
-0.03771233931183815,
-0.5814356207847595,
0.6413684487342834,
0.21821805834770203,
0.1171695664525032,
0.29655107855796814,
-0.31959035992622375,
-0.191701740026474,
0.0820348709821701,
0.2047915905714035,
0.5278886556625366,
-0.1868186593055725,
-0.2644578516483307,
0.05288601666688919,
-0.3859385550022125,
-0.41332969069480896,
-0.20433756709098816,
0.3906279504299164,
0.016771288588643074,
-0.42538100481033325,
-0.7238661646842957,
0.15781015157699585,
-0.03881074860692024,
0.11273293197154999,
0.44764244556427,
0.48529109358787537,
-0.2958405613899231,
-0.4655437171459198,
-0.15266874432563782,
-0.3001219928264618,
-0.4841521382331848,
0.26657834649086,
-0.6723374128341675,
-0.7576557993888855,
0.44277626276016235,
-0.5647955536842346,
-0.2710406482219696,
0.153314471244812,
-0.07997278869152069,
-0.39758920669555664,
0.6450834274291992,
0.8397365808486938,
0.08819930255413055,
0.6431006193161011,
-0.7914973497390747,
0.08248218894004822,
-1.0466362237930298,
-0.25286242365837097,
-0.3632826507091522,
-0.43613412976264954,
-0.28041958808898926,
-0.7234370708465576,
0.4580143690109253,
0.14327342808246613,
-0.08711947500705719,
0.3867526352405548,
-0.48336726427078247,
0.4295654296875,
0.5089187622070312,
0.5687189102172852,
0.3226294219493866,
0.21397918462753296,
0.04468822106719017,
-0.036715418100357056,
-1.0244501829147339,
-0.4671860635280609,
0.7701146602630615,
-0.23061616718769073,
0.7210830450057983,
0.024826154112815857,
0.8437306880950928,
0.6584978103637695,
-0.15812145173549652,
-0.6940088868141174,
0.6709553599357605,
-0.33547016978263855,
-0.2847152650356293,
-0.354051411151886,
-0.357343465089798,
-1.2457283735275269,
0.4212673008441925,
-0.16038718819618225,
-0.33345869183540344,
0.5238982439041138,
0.21889665722846985,
-0.4934430718421936,
0.40895771980285645,
-0.30075588822364807,
0.8982856273651123,
-0.42306533455848694,
-0.8206943869590759,
-0.4271313548088074,
-0.8142224550247192,
0.017338687554001808,
0.18040010333061218,
0.1078483909368515,
-0.2426588535308838,
-0.3964283764362335,
0.3712017238140106,
-0.20684930682182312,
0.8066774606704712,
-0.2578401267528534,
-0.07504212111234665,
0.22636185586452484,
0.1157768964767456,
0.43053391575813293,
-0.3117001950740814,
0.04770248010754585,
0.4452371299266815,
-0.5383116006851196,
-0.7179337739944458,
-0.7818401455879211,
0.42887017130851746,
-0.7810276746749878,
-0.6016660928726196,
-0.37500375509262085,
-0.30754250288009644,
-0.1389705091714859,
0.1647988259792328,
0.010129821486771107,
0.19048954546451569,
-0.3024286925792694,
0.0343191958963871,
0.6222785115242004,
-0.2686253488063812,
0.09692513197660446,
0.4055204689502716,
0.07036171853542328,
-0.009133366867899895,
1.0599055290222168,
-0.07392177730798721,
0.41677796840667725,
0.4723377823829651,
-0.07180210202932358,
0.05158565938472748,
-0.6558041572570801,
-0.5860602259635925,
0.015381356701254845,
-0.4924180507659912,
-0.4888920485973358,
0.003982178401201963,
0.08028935641050339,
-0.13146233558654785,
-0.7815266847610474,
-0.6302278637886047,
-0.1638280153274536,
-0.5955306887626648,
0.33304107189178467,
0.04000133275985718,
0.3011071979999542,
-0.19212669134140015,
0.5210644006729126,
-0.7970154881477356,
0.7415723204612732,
0.4488169252872467,
0.15658603608608246,
-0.29563915729522705,
-0.8763740062713623,
-0.3297991454601288,
-0.012002374045550823,
-0.05845962464809418,
-0.27042466402053833,
0.3444763720035553,
0.18495313823223114,
0.6563061475753784,
0.4632907509803772,
0.10475607216358185,
0.8859385848045349,
-0.1889933943748474,
0.7622727155685425,
0.4107448160648346,
-0.6971717476844788,
0.7872377634048462,
-0.0926646813750267,
0.2525368928909302,
0.5196184515953064,
0.5899916291236877,
-0.3984629809856415,
-0.057524874806404114,
-0.532465398311615,
-0.9141579866409302,
0.7946393489837646,
0.06723085045814514,
0.0013341953745111823,
0.5509313941001892,
0.4192354679107666,
0.2955165207386017,
-0.3232324719429016,
-0.21366560459136963,
-0.28897255659103394,
-0.29302144050598145,
0.04448337480425835,
-0.01350223645567894,
0.2661210894584656,
-0.25383904576301575,
0.20057447254657745,
0.8663511872291565,
-0.3393566608428955,
0.20485156774520874,
0.322929322719574,
-0.3197343945503235,
-0.10654903203248978,
0.05183183401823044,
0.46437782049179077,
0.5077060461044312,
-0.16523517668247223,
-0.038753654807806015,
0.027321351692080498,
-0.15906022489070892,
0.38552752137184143,
0.01003806572407484,
-0.3070864677429199,
-0.1661798506975174,
0.12341202795505524,
0.5569306015968323,
-0.11067575961351395,
-0.5390958189964294,
0.39850345253944397,
0.24550798535346985,
-0.2119278758764267,
0.15902486443519592,
0.35695981979370117,
-0.4737820327281952,
0.5793823003768921,
0.41486573219299316,
0.23255780339241028,
0.38157129287719727,
-0.5986107587814331,
0.254550576210022,
0.2622419595718384,
-0.43748825788497925,
-0.1554814577102661,
0.5158706903457642,
0.4009481966495514,
-0.2265029102563858,
0.5973958373069763,
-0.3431343138217926,
-0.3537367284297943,
0.9017930626869202,
0.606173038482666,
0.769761860370636,
-0.21076995134353638,
0.418565958738327,
0.36821621656417847,
0.2810448110103607,
-0.07935680449008942,
0.15964974462985992,
-0.0477762334048748,
-1.0553405284881592,
-0.01096990518271923,
0.04622860997915268,
-0.7818970084190369,
-0.13840916752815247,
-0.5545424222946167,
-0.008927833288908005,
-0.4573989510536194,
0.008444703184068203,
-0.3062633275985718,
-0.2746109366416931,
-0.67838054895401,
0.5929095149040222,
0.05961405113339424,
0.4194764792919159,
-0.7929815649986267,
0.6719252467155457,
0.9004966616630554,
-0.6851164102554321,
-0.2581046223640442,
0.11491868644952774,
-0.10701386630535126,
-0.9534386396408081,
0.7075527906417847,
0.0876382365822792,
-0.8258268237113953,
-0.18768927454948425,
-0.48108774423599243,
-0.7419746518135071,
1.1360894441604614,
0.10930747538805008,
-0.7946472764015198,
0.3600430190563202,
0.013164332136511803,
0.3440578877925873,
-0.6076487302780151,
0.02338181436061859,
0.16793574392795563,
0.2699126899242401,
-0.02639068104326725,
-0.31554824113845825,
0.15386706590652466,
-0.05402247980237007,
0.39869076013565063,
0.004238609224557877,
-1.0640206336975098,
0.23123344779014587,
-0.41459402441978455,
-0.08686988055706024,
0.15960736572742462,
0.7049795985221863,
0.1909029632806778,
0.3413100242614746,
0.788696825504303,
0.6995704770088196,
0.45168599486351013,
-0.05111631378531456,
0.8567451238632202,
-0.03411050885915756,
0.09203049540519714,
0.9625339508056641,
-0.3414524793624878,
0.5646820664405823,
0.473578542470932,
-0.00019240441906731576,
0.6703085899353027,
0.5916176438331604,
-0.28512996435165405,
0.9308716058731079,
-0.043300166726112366,
-0.061371129006147385,
-0.5318343043327332,
-0.3995756208896637,
-0.2602834403514862,
0.32385268807411194,
0.24724973738193512,
-0.12651197612285614,
-0.026508674025535583,
0.29007261991500854,
-0.4558708667755127,
0.13035109639167786,
-0.3822619915008545,
0.6087248921394348,
-0.16844293475151062,
-0.3151174485683441,
0.6258140206336975,
-0.2675328552722931,
0.804604172706604,
-0.4143834114074707,
-0.4387735426425934,
-0.5682616829872131,
0.18828557431697845,
-0.4212529957294464,
-0.6754762530326843,
0.024268463253974915,
-0.21688657999038696,
0.07937772572040558,
0.0569964237511158,
0.7180208563804626,
-0.13165892660617828,
-0.1550440788269043,
0.38738229870796204,
0.6932342052459717,
0.3483058512210846,
0.21339382231235504,
-0.8836204409599304,
0.11727049946784973,
-0.11614546924829483,
-0.10010068863630295,
0.4148343801498413,
0.29804855585098267,
0.08615738898515701,
0.6947373151779175,
0.5803232789039612,
-0.16634492576122284,
-0.3785141408443451,
0.1906256228685379,
0.7944358587265015,
-0.6511946320533752,
-0.3220815658569336,
-0.11226868629455566,
0.35147109627723694,
0.006386326160281897,
-0.38775506615638733,
0.5797352194786072,
0.774991512298584,
1.3190784454345703,
-0.02051232010126114,
0.6253657341003418,
0.1103956550359726,
0.24465987086296082,
-0.5605903267860413,
0.15827466547489166,
-1.0366233587265015,
0.1714942753314972,
-0.26491671800613403,
-0.7684638500213623,
-0.49555355310440063,
0.8904041051864624,
-0.18693658709526062,
0.14021247625350952,
0.4703870415687561,
0.9886902570724487,
-0.5674824714660645,
-0.7392648458480835,
0.8925420641899109,
-0.2079036384820938,
-0.091093048453331,
0.5936461687088013,
0.8995319604873657,
-0.71393221616745,
0.8221933245658875,
-0.4280655086040497,
-0.128256693482399,
-0.4634127914905548,
-0.5785925388336182,
-0.4811825156211853,
-0.23495768010616302,
-0.8241520524024963,
-0.1315789669752121,
0.6968156099319458,
0.46554550528526306,
1.1318844556808472,
-0.652167558670044,
-0.21283943951129913,
-0.10626843571662903,
0.1413525491952896,
-0.7261874675750732,
-0.1390991359949112,
0.35040104389190674,
-0.2607390582561493,
-0.7838470935821533,
0.42018476128578186,
0.5088940858840942,
0.060184162110090256,
0.08061796426773071,
-0.242244690656662,
-0.3175138235092163,
-0.1278505027294159,
0.3535575270652771,
0.6214609146118164,
-0.5872804522514343,
-0.4176862835884094,
-0.2219727635383606,
-0.030136773362755775,
0.6056630611419678,
0.600730299949646,
-0.7995266914367676,
0.38662368059158325,
0.22370530664920807,
0.7414520382881165,
0.7863516211509705,
0.18986371159553528,
0.07336043566465378,
-0.5634894371032715,
0.3175916373729706,
0.1488264501094818,
0.37864920496940613,
0.3684973120689392,
-0.2886030673980713,
0.9395139813423157,
0.23459678888320923,
-0.38820818066596985,
-0.24642622470855713,
0.2911571264266968,
-1.1504014730453491,
-0.484477698802948,
0.8181967735290527,
-0.49942776560783386,
-0.32188281416893005,
-0.3001534342765808,
-0.31173577904701233,
0.318060964345932,
-0.6595529317855835,
0.9879634976387024,
-0.060861483216285706,
-0.5825493931770325,
-0.5205113291740417,
-0.24848966300487518,
0.15426038205623627,
0.6975957155227661,
-1.1361279487609863,
-0.3296259343624115,
0.7540737986564636,
-0.023296916857361794,
0.2734442353248596,
0.06621460616588593,
0.12870866060256958,
0.6745580434799194,
0.060331448912620544,
0.3489004671573639,
-0.09713320434093475,
-0.41634371876716614,
-0.36863625049591064,
0.12861864268779755,
-0.30206063389778137,
-0.7172347903251648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09615v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09615v1
|
If there's a Trigger Warning, then where's the Trigger? Investigating Trigger Warnings at the Passage Level
| 2024-04-15T09:37:52 | 2024-04-15T09:37:52 |
Matti Wiegmann, Jennifer Rakete, Magdalena Wolska, Benno Stein, Martin Potthast
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Trigger warnings are labels that preface documents with sensitive content if
this content could be perceived as harmful by certain groups of readers. Since
warnings about a document intuitively need to be shown before reading it,
authors usually assign trigger warnings at the document level. What parts of
their writing prompted them to assign a warning, however, remains unclear. We
investigate for the first time the feasibility of identifying the triggering
passages of a document, both manually and computationally. We create a dataset
of 4,135 English passages, each annotated with one of eight common trigger
warnings. In a large-scale evaluation, we then systematically evaluate the
effectiveness of fine-tuned and few-shot classifiers, and their
generalizability. We find that trigger annotation belongs to the group of
subjective annotation tasks in NLP, and that automatic trigger classification
remains challenging but feasible.
|
[
-0.520095705986023,
-0.49086371064186096,
0.5184932947158813,
0.007561053615063429,
-0.13803166151046753,
-0.4429095387458801,
0.1556595414876938,
-0.7454435229301453,
-0.2227601259946823,
0.2327171266078949,
-0.5547621846199036,
-0.5268822312355042,
-1.0198615789413452,
0.34338003396987915,
-0.8584117889404297,
1.1981791257858276,
0.2538866698741913,
-0.5368107557296753,
0.22440099716186523,
0.10106314718723297,
-0.34949570894241333,
-0.4598780572414398,
-0.4946849048137665,
-0.11022487282752991,
1.0319074392318726,
-0.054606541991233826,
0.2029045671224594,
0.3665849566459656,
0.6925172805786133,
0.19217820465564728,
-0.3844699561595917,
-0.48949989676475525,
-0.13177263736724854,
0.3643469512462616,
-0.06295488774776459,
-0.7723925709724426,
0.06869298964738846,
0.07819235324859619,
0.5710194706916809,
0.4630945920944214,
0.4580727517604828,
0.03559626638889313,
-0.035659048706293106,
0.5001547336578369,
-0.8703779578208923,
-0.07471910119056702,
-0.7682636976242065,
0.33408477902412415,
-0.35181301832199097,
-0.10024899989366531,
-0.6452001333236694,
-0.39244604110717773,
0.207442969083786,
-0.4837605357170105,
0.4033010005950928,
0.027958733960986137,
0.46452295780181885,
0.45228806138038635,
-0.8465451002120972,
-0.5511409640312195,
-0.5120623111724854,
0.4412306845188141,
-0.2516370117664337,
-0.059658631682395935,
0.433971643447876,
-0.1685086190700531,
-0.12106052041053772,
-0.4367435872554779,
-0.5134977698326111,
-0.0059101940132677555,
-0.3565368354320526,
-0.006850795354694128,
-0.35460165143013,
-0.002305151429027319,
0.7425421476364136,
0.1728125959634781,
-0.6255606412887573,
0.12387509644031525,
-0.3654273748397827,
-0.563636064529419,
0.6867076754570007,
-0.0016151211457327008,
0.1563025861978531,
-0.10532130300998688,
-0.47337639331817627,
-0.01686374470591545,
-0.8635484576225281,
0.0863751545548439,
0.5249000191688538,
0.2918054163455963,
0.002196138259023428,
0.3493778109550476,
0.3337590992450714,
0.9102453589439392,
0.2730691730976105,
0.2702578008174896,
-0.03106585517525673,
-0.19955068826675415,
0.19703993201255798,
0.4334189295768738,
0.9190927147865295,
0.3774000108242035,
0.29081225395202637,
0.17983855307102203,
-0.2793685495853424,
-0.09589626640081406,
0.5755285620689392,
-0.5707729458808899,
0.011748836375772953,
0.21181729435920715,
-0.057478900998830795,
-0.3419272303581238,
-0.07831259816884995,
-0.4219588041305542,
-0.7812792658805847,
0.2348736971616745,
0.4011404514312744,
-0.2667843699455261,
-0.07332978397607803,
-0.24941684305667877,
-0.23742195963859558,
0.25262367725372314,
0.37946680188179016,
-1.0771394968032837,
-0.17135855555534363,
0.8369362950325012,
0.7292303442955017,
0.008465445600450039,
-0.28589147329330444,
-0.395233154296875,
0.0478687658905983,
-0.5101775527000427,
1.3962392807006836,
-0.39383724331855774,
-0.6643684506416321,
0.5054338574409485,
0.03456801921129227,
0.12008682638406754,
-0.3460538983345032,
1.0889418125152588,
-0.40164199471473694,
0.48304226994514465,
-0.3771042227745056,
-0.6911036968231201,
-0.10333110392093658,
0.18946939706802368,
-0.69573974609375,
1.1200809478759766,
0.05475765839219093,
-1.0838969945907593,
0.8484954833984375,
-0.4492427110671997,
-0.6827601790428162,
-0.028867172077298164,
-0.02623380534350872,
-0.28875407576560974,
0.05976711958646774,
-0.13694794476032257,
0.19886969029903412,
0.13700591027736664,
-0.14404921233654022,
0.15817444026470184,
-0.3240736424922943,
0.3276294469833374,
-0.005112393293529749,
0.7224966883659363,
0.07900779694318771,
-0.2326883226633072,
0.31922096014022827,
-0.431703120470047,
-0.5154296159744263,
-0.19287410378456116,
-0.4533401131629944,
-0.518764317035675,
-0.15846584737300873,
-0.08403414487838745,
0.40217646956443787,
-0.05626385658979416,
-0.4620938003063202,
0.36578717827796936,
-0.08259369432926178,
-0.22823870182037354,
0.6435633301734924,
0.5559026598930359,
0.4659695327281952,
-0.3932654559612274,
0.42455345392227173,
0.2005944699048996,
0.39944106340408325,
-0.4122832417488098,
-0.9993427395820618,
-0.514228343963623,
0.2776392698287964,
0.114021897315979,
0.5115984082221985,
-0.3258560001850128,
0.8027760982513428,
0.32698583602905273,
-0.3599315583705902,
-0.15190735459327698,
0.05438275635242462,
0.4861251711845398,
0.8399819135665894,
0.06507079303264618,
0.3311575949192047,
-0.2909534275531769,
-0.7260294556617737,
-0.5810068249702454,
-0.47957107424736023,
-0.18695931136608124,
-0.218900665640831,
0.5316932797431946,
0.2803494334220886,
0.6981360912322998,
-0.707310676574707,
-0.5942654013633728,
0.0807110071182251,
0.5261334776878357,
0.2711559534072876,
0.17113876342773438,
0.623310387134552,
-0.8328759074211121,
-0.39759331941604614,
-0.2741546928882599,
-0.9391187429428101,
-0.5298438668251038,
-0.3811511993408203,
-0.13060857355594635,
0.027693279087543488,
0.7561279535293579,
-0.18340100347995758,
0.4669385850429535,
0.05544134974479675,
-0.4103824496269226,
0.48867475986480713,
-0.0032828098628669977,
0.0704737976193428,
-0.7544907331466675,
-0.07971607148647308,
0.10110454261302948,
0.19575178623199463,
-0.8192378878593445,
-0.49032142758369446,
0.34485581517219543,
-0.03540557995438576,
-0.5716244578361511,
0.3909008502960205,
-0.2613495886325836,
0.2598789930343628,
-0.274257630109787,
0.19861450791358948,
-0.008980144746601582,
0.06624782085418701,
0.1660165786743164,
0.46416082978248596,
0.4828548729419708,
-0.6376059055328369,
0.06602567434310913,
0.5391529202461243,
-0.2943343222141266,
0.6105862259864807,
-0.13443240523338318,
0.16104000806808472,
-0.25716444849967957,
0.32494786381721497,
-0.770160973072052,
-0.37912678718566895,
0.2480754405260086,
-0.3041035234928131,
0.3738756775856018,
-0.2986874282360077,
-0.14372402429580688,
-0.49454212188720703,
-0.36061200499534607,
0.16773094236850739,
0.241007462143898,
0.041128139942884445,
0.15179648995399475,
0.47183752059936523,
-0.14695703983306885,
-0.5980644226074219,
-0.6570360064506531,
-0.0023936626967042685,
-0.2964269816875458,
-0.3097301125526428,
-0.21304383873939514,
0.15511447191238403,
-0.2418195903301239,
-0.3433583974838257,
-0.2624109089374542,
0.18482154607772827,
0.30895158648490906,
0.7738822102546692,
-0.11017939448356628,
0.11465059220790863,
0.6474410891532898,
0.16468048095703125,
-0.5859779715538025,
0.32231196761131287,
-0.05054033547639847,
0.0523381270468235,
0.12423538416624069,
-0.2570382356643677,
-0.0621059276163578,
0.7339483499526978,
-0.09705483913421631,
0.06023293733596802,
0.47771382331848145,
0.5157479643821716,
-0.834045946598053,
-0.29500633478164673,
-0.3461742401123047,
-0.27916383743286133,
-0.35372546315193176,
0.0821564644575119,
-0.1519748568534851,
-0.6373939514160156,
0.5965887904167175,
0.03791093826293945,
-0.12399693578481674,
0.914369523525238,
0.5299680233001709,
-0.17967122793197632,
0.5338801741600037,
0.5062831044197083,
-0.024691283702850342,
0.7403424382209778,
-0.06156432628631592,
0.3191812336444855,
-0.6639395952224731,
-0.41276025772094727,
-0.832021176815033,
-0.40554821491241455,
-0.3323494493961334,
-0.08380461484193802,
0.8241065144538879,
0.1874544769525528,
0.02677289769053459,
0.5152044892311096,
-0.7456740736961365,
0.7286144495010376,
0.5744460821151733,
-0.12783636152744293,
0.2616266906261444,
-0.40057578682899475,
0.08129657804965973,
0.18750011920928955,
-0.38660091161727905,
-0.6960166096687317,
0.9276100993156433,
0.085722915828228,
0.482435017824173,
0.02428959123790264,
0.7675198316574097,
0.5140805840492249,
0.6106716990470886,
-0.5977365970611572,
0.3559750020503998,
0.08246057480573654,
-1.4293406009674072,
-0.4230422079563141,
0.15500450134277344,
-1.0214881896972656,
-0.0727679580450058,
-0.5071214437484741,
-1.0171644687652588,
0.568629801273346,
0.05042465403676033,
-0.5465430021286011,
0.04935605451464653,
-0.9808884859085083,
0.8050702810287476,
-0.03294714540243149,
-0.09919687360525131,
0.24410077929496765,
-0.8316798210144043,
0.3596881031990051,
-0.5409910678863525,
0.30989205837249756,
-0.4196326434612274,
-0.1001497358083725,
0.7649816870689392,
-0.2282859981060028,
0.9646890163421631,
-0.11741887032985687,
-0.523230791091919,
0.5805449485778809,
0.16126717627048492,
0.41460806131362915,
-0.3413720726966858,
-0.35177916288375854,
-0.018150940537452698,
-0.07571957260370255,
-0.060396600514650345,
-0.37317991256713867,
0.4276362359523773,
-0.2775993049144745,
-0.5243836045265198,
-0.6966747641563416,
-0.2651750445365906,
-0.011575426906347275,
0.2641424536705017,
0.9312030076980591,
0.3124377429485321,
0.08555065095424652,
-0.20930233597755432,
0.27006569504737854,
-0.18783541023731232,
0.6803235411643982,
0.5547769665718079,
-0.02111080102622509,
0.11491427570581436,
0.41323867440223694,
0.11169262230396271,
0.12965765595436096,
0.350521057844162,
0.42281123995780945,
-0.4481615126132965,
-0.7117000818252563,
-0.2058998942375183,
-0.16457054018974304,
-1.122297763824463,
-0.3282434940338135,
-0.6439405083656311,
-0.08410417288541794,
-0.40677186846733093,
-0.36509719491004944,
0.19707316160202026,
-0.12814390659332275,
-0.25058963894844055,
-0.3890261948108673,
0.42922353744506836,
0.9108290672302246,
-0.2811623513698578,
0.35737133026123047,
-0.9137963652610779,
0.09087001532316208,
0.2590797543525696,
0.1899925321340561,
-0.3657841086387634,
-0.4244880974292755,
-0.34884214401245117,
-0.5972756147384644,
-0.4804273545742035,
-1.15414559841156,
0.10484722256660461,
0.1977059692144394,
0.3402324318885803,
0.7587061524391174,
0.596930742263794,
-0.3163872957229614,
-0.19638057053089142,
0.8738097548484802,
0.22781726717948914,
-0.7158036828041077,
1.0958606004714966,
-0.5900670289993286,
0.23497584462165833,
0.582796573638916,
0.9969849586486816,
-0.6214629411697388,
-0.7730030417442322,
-0.3977259695529938,
-0.7177290320396423,
0.5779919624328613,
-0.030198317021131516,
0.016461262479424477,
-0.5698347091674805,
0.2085171937942505,
0.3016926050186157,
-0.0364130474627018,
-0.7091833353042603,
-0.09676007181406021,
0.18398940563201904,
0.11438077688217163,
0.08781713992357254,
-0.29962360858917236,
-0.28099411725997925,
0.11517584323883057,
0.3148338198661804,
-0.1632610708475113,
0.13151051104068756,
0.3264106810092926,
-0.2796024680137634,
-0.553856611251831,
0.3107359707355499,
0.5970292091369629,
0.6354848742485046,
-0.373636394739151,
0.4821361303329468,
0.02981681004166603,
-0.7086411118507385,
0.21064820885658264,
-0.07192777842283249,
-0.48178109526634216,
-0.12178873270750046,
1.1033985614776611,
0.6349156498908997,
0.33501124382019043,
-0.20152179896831512,
0.8389214277267456,
0.23859712481498718,
-0.13124342262744904,
-0.3579959273338318,
0.25053876638412476,
-0.36723679304122925,
0.23698200285434723,
0.6810769438743591,
-0.4093649387359619,
0.4038916826248169,
-0.5633376240730286,
0.30319908261299133,
0.05755964666604996,
-0.4448510706424713,
-0.2592898905277252,
0.558157742023468,
0.3388938009738922,
-0.4321669042110443,
0.4381259083747864,
-0.13988246023654938,
-1.0057663917541504,
0.44339457154273987,
0.3862362504005432,
1.053210735321045,
-0.20260579884052277,
0.09333426505327225,
0.6623810529708862,
0.5373867154121399,
0.49181073904037476,
0.17694558203220367,
0.10334399342536926,
-0.6495376825332642,
-0.30597952008247375,
-0.6327232718467712,
-0.3188179135322571,
-0.19425664842128754,
-0.5096575617790222,
0.21113814413547516,
-0.34704098105430603,
-0.6185669302940369,
0.5381597876548767,
-0.24121956527233124,
-0.3326188027858734,
0.20627444982528687,
0.6241937279701233,
1.0960512161254883,
-1.4765937328338623,
0.54886794090271,
0.40715712308883667,
-0.5092028379440308,
-0.28220394253730774,
0.2639855742454529,
0.31522420048713684,
-0.49011069536209106,
0.64328932762146,
0.1826181262731552,
0.26229313015937805,
-0.2650855481624603,
-0.46869564056396484,
-0.19028277695178986,
0.5702698826789856,
0.05673244968056679,
-0.41231223940849304,
-0.1943533569574356,
0.1294478476047516,
0.5836943984031677,
-0.030938781797885895,
0.20979250967502594,
0.516166090965271,
0.7681900858879089,
0.11425362527370453,
-0.4857906997203827,
0.14816729724407196,
-0.34355586767196655,
-0.5073405504226685,
0.5860342383384705,
-0.12703931331634521,
0.6504688262939453,
-0.3021427392959595,
-0.12844087183475494,
-0.4746096432209015,
0.06024469807744026,
-0.3463245630264282,
0.6039984822273254,
0.59478759765625,
0.3029458224773407,
0.6850982308387756,
-0.5674031972885132,
1.3645399808883667,
-0.10101328790187836,
0.06395293772220612,
0.9773578643798828,
-0.2532529830932617,
0.8777521252632141,
0.32706084847450256,
-0.2594738006591797,
0.5085341334342957,
0.7425158619880676,
0.03659733757376671,
0.49834585189819336,
0.2641567885875702,
-0.88881915807724,
-0.3425443172454834,
-0.24016660451889038,
-0.40402913093566895,
0.19411969184875488,
0.4648990035057068,
-0.36410894989967346,
-0.2653573155403137,
0.2113608866930008,
-0.18698833882808685,
-0.17052386701107025,
-0.3322726786136627,
1.2337257862091064,
0.2593480348587036,
-0.6279298663139343,
0.36523541808128357,
-0.5413674712181091,
0.3730256259441376,
-0.5923306345939636,
0.29644855856895447,
-0.17571882903575897,
0.12568579614162445,
-0.3786660134792328,
-1.2375359535217285,
0.6445979475975037,
0.215532124042511,
-0.2455155849456787,
-0.29549986124038696,
1.016394853591919,
-0.16223900020122528,
-0.29049205780029297,
0.3571704030036926,
0.08122710883617401,
0.27139946818351746,
-0.5323407053947449,
-0.4358188211917877,
0.05835745856165886,
-0.3673604726791382,
-0.32696211338043213,
0.24258996546268463,
0.8016738295555115,
-0.32360386848449707,
0.23132118582725525,
0.571922779083252,
-0.24454627931118011,
0.443248987197876,
0.03515082597732544,
0.7285982966423035,
-0.8289780616760254,
-0.3099808096885681,
-0.4635186195373535,
0.8754116296768188,
-0.027087246999144554,
-0.7668592929840088,
0.5357279777526855,
0.5475677251815796,
0.6024563908576965,
-0.2234572470188141,
0.7685086131095886,
0.008152978494763374,
0.37582963705062866,
-0.3207087814807892,
0.714866578578949,
-0.13608992099761963,
-0.08393966406583786,
-0.3301577568054199,
-0.7513883709907532,
-0.6566019654273987,
0.5164640545845032,
-0.6932702660560608,
-0.070561982691288,
0.902294933795929,
0.5351606011390686,
0.4200736880302429,
0.1807149052619934,
0.4071514308452606,
0.24895715713500977,
0.10162986069917679,
0.599224865436554,
1.122328519821167,
-0.3056228458881378,
0.4212948977947235,
-0.3540175259113312,
-0.16599562764167786,
-0.408764123916626,
-1.2868155241012573,
-0.668854832649231,
-0.9315004348754883,
-0.6500583291053772,
-0.4104321300983429,
-0.09083694964647293,
0.4381192922592163,
0.3540826141834259,
-1.0767475366592407,
0.3243663012981415,
0.06982160359621048,
0.4848904311656952,
0.25786927342414856,
-0.13099105656147003,
0.3434789776802063,
-0.44671428203582764,
-0.5352824330329895,
0.22183917462825775,
0.28724753856658936,
0.3193714916706085,
0.1701551228761673,
0.2770782709121704,
-0.44964542984962463,
-0.19756700098514557,
0.3536335527896881,
0.5047849416732788,
-0.45354169607162476,
-0.5755226612091064,
-0.37666454911231995,
-0.30356574058532715,
-0.269864022731781,
0.944557785987854,
-0.5313579440116882,
0.4372652471065521,
0.6078662872314453,
0.07952386885881424,
0.4648069143295288,
-0.2946927547454834,
0.4041053354740143,
-0.9545770287513733,
0.31542521715164185,
0.3813357651233673,
0.3286645710468292,
0.20659129321575165,
-0.49251672625541687,
0.6345698237419128,
0.04618949070572853,
-0.48751094937324524,
-0.7250688076019287,
0.2278587818145752,
-0.9594780802726746,
-0.16756278276443481,
1.0409953594207764,
-0.2693548798561096,
-0.23478452861309052,
-0.34666815400123596,
-0.315194308757782,
0.43186256289482117,
-0.1359635889530182,
0.7962759137153625,
0.8206852078437805,
-0.01855812408030033,
-0.05385468527674675,
-0.5061428546905518,
0.9047567844390869,
-0.03364438936114311,
-0.9344164729118347,
0.10756628960371017,
0.5799939036369324,
-0.14091727137565613,
0.6158508062362671,
0.3678020238876343,
-0.032444629818201065,
0.2288665622472763,
0.21548262238502502,
0.08372504264116287,
0.19487740099430084,
-0.3364908695220947,
-0.5381107330322266,
0.22214247286319733,
0.14190056920051575,
-0.1371045857667923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09593v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09593v1
|
Improving Recall of Large Language Models: A Model Collaboration Approach for Relational Triple Extraction
| 2024-04-15T09:03:05 | 2024-04-15T09:03:05 |
Zepeng Ding, Wenhao Huang, Jiaqing Liang, Deqing Yang, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Relation triple extraction, which outputs a set of triples from long
sentences, plays a vital role in knowledge acquisition. Large language models
can accurately extract triples from simple sentences through few-shot learning
or fine-tuning when given appropriate instructions. However, they often miss
out when extracting from complex sentences. In this paper, we design an
evaluation-filtering framework that integrates large language models with small
models for relational triple extraction tasks. The framework includes an
evaluation model that can extract related entity pairs with high precision. We
propose a simple labeling principle and a deep neural network to build the
model, embedding the outputs as prompts into the extraction process of the
large model. We conduct extensive experiments to demonstrate that the proposed
method can assist large language models in obtaining more accurate extraction
results, especially from complex sentences containing multiple relational
triples. Our evaluation model can also be embedded into traditional extraction
models to enhance their extraction precision from complex sentences.
|
[
-0.27102887630462646,
-0.574228048324585,
0.9052978754043579,
0.20437537133693695,
-0.012848211452364922,
-0.005860073491930962,
-0.4356933832168579,
-0.8085803985595703,
0.04901774972677231,
0.6364288330078125,
0.03151612728834152,
-0.5284818410873413,
-0.6020917892456055,
0.036407072097063065,
-0.1702444702386856,
0.8032132983207703,
-0.06878235191106796,
-0.035794369876384735,
-0.018493928015232086,
0.09797745943069458,
-0.48614197969436646,
-0.40814098715782166,
-0.538386881351471,
-0.5863000750541687,
0.49966320395469666,
0.5026909112930298,
0.6875535249710083,
0.49703249335289,
0.5551313757896423,
0.1931976079940796,
-0.12930330634117126,
0.38827741146087646,
-0.47200119495391846,
0.037794262170791626,
-0.3407382667064667,
-0.3380827307701111,
-0.6665169596672058,
-0.13672152161598206,
0.8190228343009949,
0.8702475428581238,
-0.06351207196712494,
0.06799999624490738,
0.012957433238625526,
0.720051646232605,
-0.838216245174408,
0.6295101642608643,
-0.45095840096473694,
-0.09502770006656647,
0.011883477680385113,
0.12635718286037445,
-0.46812185645103455,
-0.39217814803123474,
0.39881986379623413,
-0.4489084780216217,
-0.14414814114570618,
0.16291029751300812,
0.7721112370491028,
-0.33590275049209595,
-0.4157395660877228,
-0.2133014053106308,
-0.7993198037147522,
0.6299698948860168,
-0.5735878944396973,
0.3054506480693817,
0.3933629095554352,
0.2463223785161972,
-0.11977173388004303,
-0.6469309329986572,
-0.5310183167457581,
-0.22396284341812134,
-0.26750215888023376,
-0.10629946738481522,
-0.048275113105773926,
0.19458399713039398,
0.2778867185115814,
0.6079431772232056,
-0.043745461851358414,
0.11181239038705826,
-0.2839480936527252,
0.10780903697013855,
0.6410550475120544,
0.05060465261340141,
0.31418880820274353,
-0.4805208146572113,
0.031030654907226562,
0.20162300765514374,
-0.8367846012115479,
-0.3068949282169342,
-0.008149860426783562,
0.5747988820075989,
0.14546827971935272,
0.6154764294624329,
-0.28137725591659546,
0.7014259696006775,
-0.09277615696191788,
-0.0825459361076355,
0.24091985821723938,
-0.4687162935733795,
-0.25834959745407104,
-0.17052358388900757,
0.9430142641067505,
0.17288848757743835,
0.36838892102241516,
-0.2817024290561676,
-0.23499338328838348,
-0.20081648230552673,
0.011914907954633236,
-0.7727800607681274,
-0.5895443558692932,
-0.09485464543104172,
-0.6230270862579346,
-0.3334093689918518,
0.3578774034976959,
-0.8104925155639648,
-0.2289729118347168,
-0.3152311146259308,
0.564620852470398,
-0.3712579309940338,
-0.3997984826564789,
0.3826862573623657,
-0.08473969995975494,
-0.08942010253667831,
-0.017145808786153793,
-0.968458354473114,
0.6236661672592163,
0.7847697138786316,
0.5733921527862549,
-0.19415283203125,
-0.32260650396347046,
-1.1853597164154053,
0.4691329896450043,
-0.06285517662763596,
0.37731000781059265,
-0.5462362170219421,
-0.07183202356100082,
0.026468416675925255,
-0.1878087818622589,
0.002651910064741969,
-0.6524447202682495,
0.13915139436721802,
-0.7973413467407227,
0.19357621669769287,
0.01657368429005146,
-0.5492917895317078,
-0.3246750235557556,
0.3059958517551422,
-1.0509047508239746,
0.8565821051597595,
-0.06154104694724083,
-0.4349876344203949,
0.17250151932239532,
-0.5797697901725769,
-0.49623119831085205,
0.1487119495868683,
-0.2864551246166229,
-0.4803920388221741,
0.013451308012008667,
0.5022762417793274,
0.6264966130256653,
-0.6929437518119812,
0.4707324206829071,
-0.6012250781059265,
-0.4945335388183594,
-0.2853555977344513,
0.05208328738808632,
0.8579396605491638,
-0.19966642558574677,
-0.2498822808265686,
0.058845728635787964,
-0.7139861583709717,
0.0634346753358841,
0.0485135018825531,
-0.46123331785202026,
-0.4843751788139343,
-0.2948656678199768,
-0.29124027490615845,
0.2187817543745041,
0.00878804549574852,
-0.3491421341896057,
0.18770365417003632,
-0.5744420886039734,
0.19755259156227112,
0.2516106069087982,
0.4806666374206543,
0.6417662501335144,
-0.016811704263091087,
0.3502621352672577,
-0.1602030098438263,
-0.2156953364610672,
-0.11231319606304169,
-0.30921831727027893,
-0.7818617820739746,
-0.2567002773284912,
0.5136663913726807,
0.2845149636268616,
-0.9385553002357483,
0.6673452258110046,
-0.676056444644928,
-0.1993095576763153,
-0.2745709717273712,
0.5061971545219421,
0.6392022371292114,
0.22483721375465393,
0.312668114900589,
-0.19054579734802246,
-0.5876371264457703,
-1.005875825881958,
-0.3239671289920807,
-0.2512590289115906,
-0.1499740332365036,
0.166777566075325,
0.6251001358032227,
0.09468140453100204,
0.7643066048622131,
-0.6614856123924255,
-0.2466743439435959,
-0.36934494972229004,
0.21326428651809692,
0.33747464418411255,
0.4022442102432251,
0.3081784248352051,
-0.8663517236709595,
-0.5151920318603516,
0.09249133616685867,
-0.9611555933952332,
0.2974311113357544,
0.20543807744979858,
-0.20914243161678314,
0.007375809829682112,
0.37816742062568665,
-0.7673758268356323,
0.3002170920372009,
0.15790770947933197,
0.010692043229937553,
0.34069156646728516,
-0.01129841897636652,
-0.07018232345581055,
-1.0770292282104492,
0.1619846373796463,
-0.022468453273177147,
-0.39440447092056274,
-0.3645416796207428,
0.22865785658359528,
0.2540111541748047,
0.1888691931962967,
-0.1775500774383545,
0.30532702803611755,
-0.745111346244812,
-0.27964407205581665,
0.0896328017115593,
0.5332614183425903,
0.5115533471107483,
0.39295580983161926,
0.1433202177286148,
0.2175363451242447,
0.24655967950820923,
-0.6528847813606262,
0.5785761475563049,
0.24841651320457458,
-0.5468854308128357,
0.4131229817867279,
-0.34257248044013977,
0.2488590031862259,
0.16335570812225342,
0.10967296361923218,
-0.6482412815093994,
-0.2504480183124542,
0.22047674655914307,
-0.07861217856407166,
0.4298425614833832,
-0.16887250542640686,
-0.7509641051292419,
-0.5761772990226746,
-0.18193820118904114,
0.08560378849506378,
0.09812404215335846,
-0.9589444994926453,
0.821163535118103,
0.60185307264328,
-0.24313883483409882,
-0.5261538028717041,
-0.4072813391685486,
0.09171821177005768,
-0.05750999227166176,
-0.5525222420692444,
0.35989588499069214,
0.18751448392868042,
-0.3030119836330414,
0.17964056134223938,
-0.00472183246165514,
-0.2773257791996002,
0.2527148127555847,
0.10352784395217896,
0.564540445804596,
-0.36957988142967224,
0.6057567596435547,
-0.3075852394104004,
-0.033988818526268005,
0.2915048599243164,
-0.17755021154880524,
0.29837673902511597,
-0.4534258544445038,
0.03681742399930954,
-0.27651408314704895,
0.5103859901428223,
0.46055957674980164,
-0.3216449022293091,
0.7170212864875793,
0.5815410614013672,
-0.6696375012397766,
0.111239954829216,
-0.6477712988853455,
-0.18560320138931274,
-0.3336608409881592,
0.5456101298332214,
-0.7106969356536865,
-0.9549950957298279,
0.11671771109104156,
-0.07126516848802567,
-0.21491622924804688,
0.5202963948249817,
0.3436545133590698,
0.0763077437877655,
1.0207492113113403,
0.6697729229927063,
-0.1738678216934204,
0.2392672449350357,
-0.33312273025512695,
0.45084917545318604,
-0.8838781714439392,
-0.20087891817092896,
-0.4925491511821747,
0.174359992146492,
-0.13671348989009857,
-0.10122468322515488,
0.12400748580694199,
0.44590315222740173,
-0.2087165117263794,
0.2572021782398224,
-0.02097763679921627,
0.7932977080345154,
0.5703107714653015,
0.29228904843330383,
0.62522953748703,
0.08609909564256668,
-0.043342240154743195,
0.035171061754226685,
-0.554803192615509,
-0.4521399140357971,
0.8532299399375916,
0.19870765507221222,
0.21049250662326813,
0.42618197202682495,
0.9507882595062256,
-0.2759004533290863,
0.3971664607524872,
-0.9888677000999451,
0.35215839743614197,
-0.1775238960981369,
-0.6613579392433167,
-0.22939130663871765,
-0.6568824052810669,
-0.5606490969657898,
0.2964288294315338,
-0.513976514339447,
-0.8791355490684509,
0.07930682599544525,
-0.029413215816020966,
-0.912982165813446,
0.3423997759819031,
-0.7481744885444641,
0.759833037853241,
-0.04796066880226135,
-0.6903764009475708,
-0.2477918416261673,
-0.6590274572372437,
0.77399742603302,
-0.2853516936302185,
0.15777726471424103,
-0.07015206664800644,
0.3203326463699341,
0.702167272567749,
-0.12456092238426208,
0.6884369254112244,
-0.023444153368473053,
0.07581068575382233,
0.23300111293792725,
0.35054993629455566,
0.4956049621105194,
0.07250296324491501,
-0.43683749437332153,
-0.08510273694992065,
-0.16491961479187012,
-0.09580893069505692,
-0.611086905002594,
0.7735303044319153,
-0.5205896496772766,
-0.5118526220321655,
0.004597729071974754,
-0.4159126877784729,
-0.29057490825653076,
0.5146182179450989,
-0.33720651268959045,
0.2658299207687378,
-0.31227487325668335,
0.4163542687892914,
0.3849751651287079,
-0.039540406316518784,
0.5590811371803284,
0.29630666971206665,
-0.6322037577629089,
-0.6035290956497192,
0.6987071633338928,
-0.14814378321170807,
0.2812938094139099,
0.41811126470565796,
0.20479509234428406,
-0.11869841068983078,
-0.35845258831977844,
-0.2992520332336426,
0.38855481147766113,
-0.6357299089431763,
-0.46468934416770935,
-0.8004753589630127,
-0.12406470626592636,
-0.49804025888442993,
0.3433128893375397,
-0.38857075572013855,
-0.46506544947624207,
-0.19321581721305847,
-0.11752179265022278,
0.19898904860019684,
1.0279134511947632,
-0.16575883328914642,
0.2669396996498108,
-1.1675128936767578,
0.5783385038375854,
0.5558663606643677,
0.43379896879196167,
0.21399210393428802,
-0.13020704686641693,
-0.30192744731903076,
-0.13754896819591522,
-0.12605687975883484,
-0.5786622166633606,
0.285772442817688,
0.22429323196411133,
0.3979308605194092,
-0.0017156630055978894,
-0.12812626361846924,
0.7774502635002136,
-0.3032072186470032,
0.5579238533973694,
0.37184566259384155,
-1.2319886684417725,
0.46950313448905945,
-0.1601598560810089,
0.12742704153060913,
0.663763165473938,
0.22341440618038177,
-0.28417450189590454,
0.2175028920173645,
-0.5419430136680603,
-0.7323657870292664,
0.8485172390937805,
0.24739930033683777,
-0.251525342464447,
-0.08928133547306061,
0.6055355668067932,
-0.12783758342266083,
0.09804825484752655,
-0.879514217376709,
-0.00849794689565897,
0.6317532658576965,
-0.14730028808116913,
-0.017954790964722633,
-0.5590261220932007,
-0.19040900468826294,
-0.1556287258863449,
0.7464045286178589,
0.12674599885940552,
-0.1422097235918045,
-0.049015842378139496,
-0.28498122096061707,
-0.2062263786792755,
0.10769198089838028,
-0.017613084986805916,
0.7043706774711609,
-0.42772871255874634,
0.2053869515657425,
0.04398009926080704,
-0.05155237391591072,
-0.19991496205329895,
0.16100844740867615,
0.24508553743362427,
-0.21739934384822845,
0.5537611246109009,
0.5532715916633606,
0.4396783113479614,
-0.2215217649936676,
0.8851508498191833,
-0.08526044338941574,
-0.02307078242301941,
-0.29859253764152527,
-0.08725609630346298,
0.4157169759273529,
0.2125319540500641,
0.04763412848114967,
0.12430442869663239,
0.3555957078933716,
-0.63386470079422,
0.46077877283096313,
0.12985239923000336,
-0.39205068349838257,
-0.11449001729488373,
0.22851507365703583,
0.2090788334608078,
-0.3955208361148834,
0.904086709022522,
-0.09311770647764206,
-0.6497835516929626,
0.5293996334075928,
0.5666643381118774,
0.6921359300613403,
-0.17091721296310425,
0.03562026843428612,
0.6297043561935425,
0.02739853225648403,
-0.42729875445365906,
0.06578970700502396,
-0.061958517879247665,
-0.8290820121765137,
-0.5887391567230225,
-0.42042407393455505,
-0.1386442929506302,
0.040588341653347015,
-0.9305974245071411,
0.4047835171222687,
-0.25324133038520813,
0.18718846142292023,
0.3502160608768463,
0.1919213980436325,
-0.740979015827179,
0.08093966543674469,
0.28741687536239624,
0.39763790369033813,
-0.7694336175918579,
1.0539556741714478,
0.22524507343769073,
-0.6683749556541443,
-1.038549780845642,
-0.22557611763477325,
-0.10243792086839676,
-0.5061329007148743,
0.8669420480728149,
0.468490868806839,
-0.34525057673454285,
-0.07426022738218307,
-0.49666956067085266,
-0.8248853087425232,
0.9205123782157898,
0.2974736988544464,
-0.7379016876220703,
-0.1365271657705307,
-0.3213479518890381,
0.5227738618850708,
-0.9400568604469299,
0.22506193816661835,
0.9156457185745239,
0.32693737745285034,
0.11448245495557785,
-1.0344414710998535,
0.16668936610221863,
-0.2323363572359085,
0.1414726823568344,
0.23416417837142944,
-0.15832757949829102,
0.6872487664222717,
-0.34202224016189575,
-0.15456043183803558,
0.1732400804758072,
0.48815715312957764,
0.41027018427848816,
0.10088419914245605,
0.6639502048492432,
0.15612195432186127,
0.8492879867553711,
0.268544465303421,
1.1305421590805054,
0.18655425310134888,
0.3782119154930115,
2.01043963432312,
-0.5400091409683228,
1.1283588409423828,
0.42525914311408997,
0.1246856227517128,
0.4928560256958008,
0.23274511098861694,
0.026247266680002213,
0.2111053317785263,
0.0988723486661911,
-0.18580076098442078,
-0.4933978319168091,
-0.09972617775201797,
-0.07566799968481064,
0.44897931814193726,
0.5445656180381775,
-0.8548276424407959,
0.13267342746257782,
-0.19817297160625458,
0.09819750487804413,
0.13568627834320068,
-0.10767559707164764,
0.9496591091156006,
0.23034925758838654,
-0.7830493450164795,
0.3646242320537567,
-0.24014943838119507,
0.1256449967622757,
0.07743068039417267,
-0.44763582944869995,
0.22144722938537598,
0.44839009642601013,
-0.19455894827842712,
-0.6490854620933533,
0.11862175166606903,
-0.3271828889846802,
-0.486502081155777,
0.09835326671600342,
0.6736025214195251,
-0.7115248441696167,
-0.4072592556476593,
0.7874336838722229,
0.6021904945373535,
0.06979534029960632,
-0.4413016736507416,
-0.3759646415710449,
0.16865332424640656,
0.15448583662509918,
-0.06475171446800232,
-0.17537379264831543,
0.2955760061740875,
0.08505603671073914,
0.18743476271629333,
0.47194719314575195,
0.2141963392496109,
-0.2883703112602234,
0.33688628673553467,
0.732389509677887,
-0.7504934072494507,
-0.15306521952152252,
-1.0300649404525757,
0.33615541458129883,
-0.6616531610488892,
0.153834730386734,
0.47063642740249634,
0.6647604703903198,
0.5799407362937927,
0.0648389458656311,
0.5814414620399475,
-0.004515393171459436,
0.5769376158714294,
-0.49984437227249146,
0.5394948124885559,
-0.36774832010269165,
0.5344246029853821,
-0.3755456805229187,
-1.2416106462478638,
-0.9203160405158997,
0.5518653392791748,
-0.5070292949676514,
-0.05705120414495468,
0.9499748945236206,
0.6401835083961487,
-0.19009608030319214,
0.24577118456363678,
0.2587054967880249,
0.4022887945175171,
0.5582651495933533,
0.7494170665740967,
0.7567903995513916,
-0.7884100079536438,
0.791451096534729,
-0.4930327832698822,
-0.1394883394241333,
-0.20355428755283356,
-0.9743258953094482,
-0.9029213786125183,
-0.32558053731918335,
-0.27019962668418884,
-0.45820188522338867,
-0.0005912318592891097,
0.9993380308151245,
0.8703308701515198,
-0.6809017062187195,
-0.25692808628082275,
0.020202280953526497,
0.31194502115249634,
-0.021206127479672432,
-0.20008227229118347,
0.5220524072647095,
-0.018264327198266983,
-0.6797211170196533,
0.46378880739212036,
0.4108615517616272,
-0.17364716529846191,
0.07002803683280945,
0.009733081795275211,
-0.6159035563468933,
-0.6148203015327454,
0.7082064747810364,
-0.054972708225250244,
-0.5935616493225098,
-0.6859503984451294,
-0.3315288722515106,
-0.1434391736984253,
0.15808434784412384,
0.5405598878860474,
-0.7600077390670776,
0.6239538192749023,
0.34794285893440247,
0.5935741662979126,
0.8059999942779541,
-0.31624966859817505,
1.078066110610962,
-0.5873677730560303,
-0.17712685465812683,
0.12949123978614807,
0.44849827885627747,
0.5269331932067871,
-0.484332412481308,
0.8624173402786255,
0.03141132742166519,
-0.3883577287197113,
-0.6315504908561707,
0.17196127772331238,
-0.7133783102035522,
-0.1416216641664505,
1.1611918210983276,
-0.44118261337280273,
-0.18005700409412384,
-0.1618797481060028,
-0.08192058652639389,
0.3696345388889313,
-0.19796797633171082,
0.6413314938545227,
0.8379825949668884,
0.09913180768489838,
-0.038406308740377426,
-0.3201919198036194,
0.19629882276058197,
0.27433136105537415,
-0.6605660319328308,
0.17708463966846466,
0.6075678467750549,
0.3131449520587921,
0.40246158838272095,
0.39638590812683105,
-0.21970762312412262,
0.3101429343223572,
-0.3072601854801178,
0.32431477308273315,
0.12030545622110367,
-0.5007806420326233,
-0.6144893169403076,
0.4344549775123596,
0.13902851939201355,
0.06571406126022339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09579v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09579v1
|
Modelling Language
| 2024-04-15T08:40:01 | 2024-04-15T08:40:01 |
Jumbly Grindrod
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper argues that large language models have a valuable scientific role
to play in serving as scientific models of a language. Linguistic study should
not only be concerned with the cognitive processes behind linguistic
competence, but also with language understood as an external, social entity.
Once this is recognized, the value of large language models as scientific
models becomes clear. This paper defends this position against a number of
arguments to the effect that language models provide no linguistic insight. It
also draws upon recent work in philosophy of science to show how large language
models could serve as scientific models.
|
[
-0.10308194905519485,
-0.4744011461734772,
0.8871530890464783,
0.3152465522289276,
-0.016209283843636513,
-0.18335790932178497,
-0.6110097169876099,
-0.7741469144821167,
0.2742135226726532,
0.6298992037773132,
0.11418655514717102,
0.17512525618076324,
-0.740971028804779,
0.19495287537574768,
-0.6092019081115723,
0.5554341673851013,
0.42202723026275635,
0.4450717568397522,
-0.3315684199333191,
-0.046208012849092484,
-0.14999151229858398,
-0.4994678497314453,
-1.0933520793914795,
-0.6301210522651672,
0.6289628148078918,
0.0112577760592103,
0.9680691361427307,
0.5921202301979065,
0.40413737297058105,
0.4426710307598114,
-0.3457764983177185,
-0.36021384596824646,
-0.30012214183807373,
0.268991082906723,
-0.5893339514732361,
-0.7072355151176453,
-0.17036107182502747,
0.1941269338130951,
1.046921968460083,
1.1510653495788574,
0.15649963915348053,
0.20283684134483337,
-0.2985629737377167,
0.48746979236602783,
0.0158819742500782,
0.77679443359375,
-0.4613550007343292,
-0.2573985159397125,
-0.4093279540538788,
0.020518019795417786,
-0.6613491773605347,
-0.2878093421459198,
0.32747912406921387,
-0.33372431993484497,
0.1351945996284485,
-0.02244090661406517,
0.7333382964134216,
-0.16620725393295288,
-0.5277755260467529,
-0.13010534644126892,
-0.9760438203811646,
1.0182784795761108,
-1.0914669036865234,
0.5041123032569885,
0.4529321491718292,
0.2907978892326355,
-0.1900099366903305,
-0.46568194031715393,
-0.842799723148346,
-0.7171180844306946,
-0.08684753626585007,
-0.10336509346961975,
0.3362957835197449,
0.1365332305431366,
0.2981469929218292,
0.1870623677968979,
-0.28382548689842224,
0.354149729013443,
-0.7975565195083618,
-0.02583453245460987,
0.8264533877372742,
-0.003917906433343887,
0.4579658806324005,
-0.011534960940480232,
0.3111148178577423,
0.012491382658481598,
-0.7773136496543884,
0.18704287707805634,
0.37859541177749634,
0.4698215425014496,
0.09132640063762665,
0.8617801666259766,
0.04890124499797821,
0.5695211887359619,
-0.5637270212173462,
-0.2448112517595291,
0.019236300140619278,
0.07902166992425919,
-0.010235295630991459,
0.2947046160697937,
0.7632204294204712,
0.06585076451301575,
0.5232165455818176,
-0.12962821125984192,
0.11218400299549103,
0.36125919222831726,
0.16597715020179749,
-0.8520980477333069,
-0.18597568571567535,
0.060440853238105774,
-0.16472145915031433,
-0.17964553833007812,
-0.0811941847205162,
-0.5871253609657288,
-0.24115754663944244,
-0.2727375626564026,
-0.13116034865379333,
-0.33080798387527466,
-0.6567779779434204,
0.3422887623310089,
-0.23414726555347443,
0.04315194487571716,
0.4215545356273651,
-1.1104626655578613,
0.4443477988243103,
1.0207229852676392,
0.7307732105255127,
0.25351831316947937,
-0.3411537706851959,
0.08592923730611801,
0.21417565643787384,
-0.9110027551651001,
0.6453280448913574,
-0.9954997301101685,
-0.49692302942276,
-0.103586845099926,
0.18342088162899017,
0.09600761532783508,
-0.24507248401641846,
0.464603066444397,
-0.614287793636322,
0.15195032954216003,
-0.5192984342575073,
-0.5189696550369263,
-0.5539588332176208,
-0.17659172415733337,
-0.7494905591011047,
0.7276126742362976,
-0.21375872194766998,
-0.41723448038101196,
0.27297040820121765,
-1.0679030418395996,
-0.3401537537574768,
0.5411100387573242,
-0.12012511491775513,
-0.0909309983253479,
0.3748757839202881,
-0.6226279139518738,
0.16754432022571564,
-0.4941546618938446,
0.7115123867988586,
-0.7544205188751221,
0.0888952761888504,
0.6558416485786438,
-0.2628176212310791,
0.7237072587013245,
0.2297767698764801,
-0.2144693285226822,
-0.28378909826278687,
-0.6348737478256226,
0.10323333740234375,
0.1280144453048706,
-0.12797237932682037,
-0.7730457186698914,
0.4846875071525574,
0.21036577224731445,
0.2099602073431015,
0.024958141148090363,
-0.9160352349281311,
0.3087669909000397,
-0.8855655789375305,
0.7630898952484131,
0.29638227820396423,
-0.5140811800956726,
0.6898499727249146,
-0.06364639103412628,
0.4031025469303131,
-0.5739266872406006,
-0.275808721780777,
0.1746426224708557,
-0.7607195377349854,
-0.6099364757537842,
-0.22115033864974976,
0.4933444857597351,
0.10124087333679199,
-0.2682031989097595,
0.06271007657051086,
-0.17136000096797943,
-0.506869375705719,
-0.5047412514686584,
0.012444117106497288,
0.21497227251529694,
0.22423426806926727,
-0.03287823125720024,
-0.32882097363471985,
-0.7805652618408203,
-0.9624633193016052,
-0.279209166765213,
-0.5991114974021912,
0.16823430359363556,
0.27736836671829224,
0.7063553929328918,
-0.0057699233293533325,
0.9429832100868225,
-0.1363556683063507,
0.16128772497177124,
-0.07653702050447464,
0.06674274802207947,
0.12984447181224823,
0.29146450757980347,
0.7302160859107971,
-0.8152655959129333,
-0.16305261850357056,
0.19270896911621094,
-1.18760085105896,
-0.18061710894107819,
0.3514697849750519,
0.20736055076122284,
0.062357865273952484,
0.383461058139801,
-0.8970350623130798,
-0.007728307042270899,
0.5608007907867432,
-0.4583659768104553,
0.5381056070327759,
-0.2891133725643158,
0.1088036596775055,
-0.7208669185638428,
0.2718980312347412,
0.22062328457832336,
-0.04470210522413254,
-0.8962582349777222,
0.2109813690185547,
-0.14570216834545135,
-0.3106968402862549,
-0.3757069706916809,
1.0219228267669678,
-0.4060569703578949,
0.029530242085456848,
-0.6696130037307739,
0.013551306910812855,
-0.02177613414824009,
-0.5180038809776306,
0.4577038288116455,
0.22392839193344116,
0.648194432258606,
-0.5177813172340393,
0.4516778588294983,
-0.06600309908390045,
-0.5521829724311829,
0.1665240377187729,
-0.8276126384735107,
-0.29390135407447815,
-0.33000341057777405,
0.14500685036182404,
-0.7657273411750793,
-0.4271995425224304,
-0.02512853592634201,
-0.37763381004333496,
0.3905370831489563,
-0.15737250447273254,
-0.46054723858833313,
-0.6515589356422424,
0.2295883595943451,
0.32231494784355164,
0.36425331234931946,
-0.05275273323059082,
0.400398850440979,
0.7002550363540649,
-0.5432368516921997,
-0.17395347356796265,
-0.6970576643943787,
0.03959619998931885,
-0.30637326836586,
-0.7520148754119873,
-0.04151935130357742,
0.04783078655600548,
-0.851926326751709,
0.12268479913473129,
-0.019364437088370323,
-0.24765226244926453,
0.21904927492141724,
0.2828897535800934,
0.24883562326431274,
-0.6988866925239563,
0.5608716011047363,
-0.21127189695835114,
-0.16006770730018616,
0.4890928566455841,
-0.33466169238090515,
0.4035109579563141,
-0.04770870879292488,
-0.0512363463640213,
-0.172115758061409,
0.48243802785873413,
1.0048441886901855,
-0.17064350843429565,
1.0218534469604492,
-0.08726905286312103,
-0.3178549110889435,
-0.0042138611897826195,
-0.5118273496627808,
-0.295017808675766,
-0.4475454092025757,
0.5548881888389587,
-0.18621529638767242,
-0.944783627986908,
0.30891889333724976,
0.1924019753932953,
-0.10755369812250137,
0.5675287842750549,
0.5948439836502075,
-0.14957226812839508,
0.7914458513259888,
0.7502943873405457,
-0.006194587796926498,
0.4243730902671814,
0.0036289039999246597,
0.6516860723495483,
-0.5921825170516968,
-0.16081874072551727,
-0.8362555503845215,
0.2778688669204712,
-0.36701563000679016,
-0.2302531599998474,
0.07338668406009674,
-0.09936210513114929,
-0.39010918140411377,
0.27160218358039856,
-0.34967148303985596,
0.3311449885368347,
0.19367815554141998,
-0.26740562915802,
0.1257971227169037,
-0.2784283459186554,
0.2461995631456375,
-0.18118144571781158,
-0.5820029973983765,
-1.0663951635360718,
0.7828128337860107,
0.490188866853714,
0.8359478712081909,
-0.08002093434333801,
0.12583346664905548,
-0.24267853796482086,
0.4648342728614807,
-0.8067104816436768,
0.6546676158905029,
-0.024960385635495186,
-1.017519235610962,
-0.5731869339942932,
-0.4073968529701233,
-1.0140347480773926,
0.5482503175735474,
-0.10350693017244339,
-0.598619818687439,
0.12627246975898743,
0.24358515441417694,
-0.07086291164159775,
0.4138101041316986,
-0.7173836827278137,
0.7351366281509399,
-0.2812310457229614,
-0.19574525952339172,
-0.415357381105423,
-0.2336827516555786,
0.6688143014907837,
-0.12298856675624847,
0.7626222968101501,
-0.3367210328578949,
0.1838318556547165,
1.1086127758026123,
-0.24198099970817566,
0.938877522945404,
-0.013095646165311337,
-0.24762636423110962,
0.34894847869873047,
0.24155092239379883,
-0.04849914833903313,
0.1928705871105194,
-0.20264312624931335,
0.03125501424074173,
0.4205605685710907,
-0.5411342978477478,
-0.4195932149887085,
0.947161853313446,
-0.7075798511505127,
-0.9713871479034424,
-0.5739599466323853,
-0.6889094114303589,
0.0067431749776005745,
0.29867666959762573,
-0.17562776803970337,
0.2467600256204605,
-0.24856556951999664,
0.378473162651062,
0.6333836913108826,
-0.09376272559165955,
0.5266328454017639,
0.6110914349555969,
-0.38604113459587097,
0.1591474562883377,
0.6953080892562866,
0.35975295305252075,
0.6669679880142212,
0.1526864916086197,
0.6356340646743774,
-0.17806817591190338,
-0.39470309019088745,
-0.1274077445268631,
0.614084780216217,
-0.5913599133491516,
0.3493697941303253,
-0.9555405378341675,
-0.13580110669136047,
-0.3851354718208313,
-0.03229017183184624,
-0.6615929007530212,
-0.4601079821586609,
0.10251782089471817,
0.05176181346178055,
0.629010021686554,
0.9232696294784546,
-0.1750299483537674,
0.09953837096691132,
-0.641880214214325,
0.02623484842479229,
0.2546340525150299,
0.310748428106308,
0.11539189517498016,
-0.3938351273536682,
-0.16396869719028473,
0.3577851951122284,
0.08397481590509415,
-0.7362938523292542,
0.5721410512924194,
0.28720059990882874,
0.803678035736084,
0.3594324588775635,
-0.33791422843933105,
0.3775152564048767,
-0.8209971785545349,
0.8644528388977051,
0.062081120908260345,
-1.0882376432418823,
0.4463230073451996,
-0.23175397515296936,
0.08268599212169647,
0.14534565806388855,
0.7632318139076233,
-0.6470943689346313,
-0.4695964753627777,
-0.6357581615447998,
-0.6026756167411804,
0.42814186215400696,
-0.15086984634399414,
0.3423631489276886,
-0.1450386941432953,
0.15864384174346924,
0.06858731806278229,
0.32975146174430847,
-1.0084081888198853,
0.1763143390417099,
-0.18590642511844635,
0.15696731209754944,
-0.586542546749115,
-0.39623603224754333,
-0.19188816845417023,
-0.2574841380119324,
0.6918076872825623,
-0.07393582165241241,
0.09912460297346115,
-0.0626772865653038,
0.18794944882392883,
-0.30162549018859863,
0.40276721119880676,
0.5688959956169128,
0.7060389518737793,
0.1859215795993805,
0.2479366958141327,
-0.17242828011512756,
-0.4628717303276062,
0.1740293949842453,
-0.08759504556655884,
-0.07753271609544754,
-0.10679604113101959,
0.5084759593009949,
0.39758017659187317,
0.4609655737876892,
-0.6319615840911865,
0.16648408770561218,
0.45513153076171875,
-0.0858297348022461,
-0.19985319674015045,
-0.08177139610052109,
0.383718878030777,
0.2815704643726349,
0.016255540773272514,
0.18102075159549713,
-0.09231901168823242,
-1.1871697902679443,
-0.10167437791824341,
0.6078991889953613,
-0.2073049694299698,
-0.7803436517715454,
0.5304960012435913,
-0.09300453960895538,
-0.2240322381258011,
0.47307664155960083,
0.2221783697605133,
-0.7257868051528931,
0.7193289399147034,
0.7677818536758423,
0.3101813495159149,
-0.5784286260604858,
0.26732337474823,
0.19471381604671478,
0.3837340474128723,
-0.6546787023544312,
0.20342233777046204,
0.44170162081718445,
-0.7280488014221191,
-0.6769975423812866,
-0.8267764449119568,
-0.3431379199028015,
0.1072712242603302,
-0.2691364884376526,
0.16711121797561646,
-0.29705706238746643,
-0.1470511257648468,
0.6748839616775513,
-0.25810569524765015,
-0.2619791626930237,
0.21945680677890778,
0.2783587872982025,
0.7321160435676575,
-1.1304470300674438,
1.137507438659668,
0.40444594621658325,
-0.47241342067718506,
-0.688016951084137,
-0.6605056524276733,
-0.1335056722164154,
-0.4679882824420929,
1.3719810247421265,
-0.03862493485212326,
-0.35113295912742615,
-0.34649789333343506,
-0.6761696338653564,
-1.2318905591964722,
0.3952111303806305,
0.6232843995094299,
-0.384016752243042,
-0.15089455246925354,
-0.008563338778913021,
0.9502730965614319,
-0.550957441329956,
0.21220441162586212,
0.024465221911668777,
0.6551013588905334,
0.240739643573761,
-1.0755423307418823,
0.11438670754432678,
-0.31112632155418396,
0.10893816500902176,
0.2250991016626358,
-0.5068144798278809,
1.069190263748169,
-0.29386386275291443,
-0.2211563140153885,
0.18876208364963531,
0.5954697728157043,
-0.09482097625732422,
0.09809650480747223,
0.054734744131565094,
0.13580390810966492,
0.41297638416290283,
-0.012393981218338013,
1.1905438899993896,
-0.062030497938394547,
0.3925169110298157,
0.7202714085578918,
-0.5753690600395203,
0.8544996380805969,
0.3735649585723877,
-0.19098801910877228,
0.313877135515213,
0.41699689626693726,
-0.041946444660425186,
0.5528945922851562,
0.48368415236473083,
-0.2583988904953003,
-0.32395926117897034,
-0.005340278148651123,
-0.5147817134857178,
0.5203332304954529,
0.7487704157829285,
-0.5907372832298279,
-0.11397110670804977,
0.03995318338274956,
0.16032062470912933,
0.38383060693740845,
-0.3674923777580261,
0.2984253466129303,
0.3771681487560272,
-0.6822974681854248,
0.34683355689048767,
-0.08620542287826538,
0.16066624224185944,
-0.6573607921600342,
-0.045223452150821686,
0.39943256974220276,
0.15622247755527496,
-0.22503222525119781,
-0.8977495431900024,
0.6063278317451477,
-0.2250177264213562,
-0.18084409832954407,
-0.2334069311618805,
0.6680821180343628,
-0.37001705169677734,
-0.6447205543518066,
0.3630494475364685,
0.17468227446079254,
0.25196942687034607,
0.34113162755966187,
-0.20119132101535797,
0.13241319358348846,
-0.3026617169380188,
-0.18322715163230896,
0.25474900007247925,
0.5440261960029602,
-0.2101815938949585,
0.8160051703453064,
0.7559496760368347,
0.5332334041595459,
0.02804795280098915,
-0.08609559386968613,
0.45297175645828247,
-0.9044646620750427,
-0.25780320167541504,
-1.0875229835510254,
0.07096929103136063,
-0.17078572511672974,
-0.11422041058540344,
0.8005209565162659,
0.5778796076774597,
0.6833465695381165,
-0.25776126980781555,
0.8400483131408691,
-0.1450626105070114,
0.2641717195510864,
-0.3531551659107208,
0.8594323992729187,
-0.2475840002298355,
0.09732777625322342,
-0.32334834337234497,
-0.698714554309845,
-0.5652400255203247,
0.8687527775764465,
-0.7812510132789612,
0.14812210202217102,
0.7580983638763428,
0.5249825119972229,
0.053607091307640076,
0.33120280504226685,
0.566048264503479,
0.6404802799224854,
0.5073236227035522,
0.04523388296365738,
0.913983166217804,
0.022149721160531044,
-0.19448155164718628,
0.015232295729219913,
-0.2574881315231323,
-0.01704590953886509,
-0.8654189705848694,
-1.0500108003616333,
-0.6964346766471863,
-0.1371152251958847,
-0.40753406286239624,
-0.06632799655199051,
0.7777156829833984,
0.872302770614624,
-0.7187111973762512,
-0.5932353734970093,
0.035545334219932556,
-0.1633932888507843,
-0.14233794808387756,
-0.24058419466018677,
0.04585768282413483,
-0.29604867100715637,
-0.7159141898155212,
0.5788143873214722,
0.4366719424724579,
-0.00928055215626955,
-0.5601639747619629,
0.2887444794178009,
-0.196663036942482,
0.4979163110256195,
0.9279327392578125,
0.688441812992096,
-0.997748851776123,
-0.5316044092178345,
-0.14325641095638275,
-0.06685245037078857,
-0.11160947382450104,
0.776784360408783,
-0.5618462562561035,
0.3619178533554077,
0.22194476425647736,
0.442161500453949,
0.5335686206817627,
-0.8283877968788147,
0.8913643956184387,
0.015076248906552792,
0.3314779996871948,
0.28996986150741577,
0.6593698263168335,
0.4521522521972656,
-0.24690154194831848,
0.34513765573501587,
0.3233059048652649,
-0.5306801199913025,
-0.9955958724021912,
0.3712112307548523,
-0.8376134037971497,
-0.2421504110097885,
1.1286849975585938,
0.003998525440692902,
-0.6198671460151672,
-0.09278387576341629,
-0.11901272088289261,
-0.015355813317000866,
-0.3091784119606018,
0.9269893169403076,
1.0202701091766357,
0.15725195407867432,
-0.4267778694629669,
-0.9579548239707947,
0.372185081243515,
0.3411462604999542,
-0.5289763808250427,
0.0487331785261631,
0.13467198610305786,
0.30486175417900085,
0.5334100723266602,
0.40075117349624634,
-0.3485519289970398,
0.004301691427826881,
0.09980790317058563,
-0.04957600310444832,
0.24825112521648407,
-0.23022879660129547,
-0.0730387419462204,
0.2001967579126358,
0.48470836877822876,
0.4664805829524994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09577v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09577v1
|
Transformers, Contextualism, and Polysemy
| 2024-04-15T08:38:43 | 2024-04-15T08:38:43 |
Jumbly Grindrod
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The transformer architecture, introduced by Vaswani et al. (2017), is at the
heart of the remarkable recent progress in the development of language models,
including famous chatbots such as Chat-gpt and Bard. In this paper, I argue
that we an extract from the way the transformer architecture works a picture of
the relationship between context and meaning. I call this the transformer
picture, and I argue that it is a novel with regard to two related
philosophical debates: the contextualism debate regarding the extent of
context-sensitivity across natural language, and the polysemy debate regarding
how polysemy should be captured within an account of word meaning. Although
much of the paper merely tries to position the transformer picture with respect
to these two debates, I will also begin to make the case for the transformer
picture.
|
[
-0.795824408531189,
-0.6448054313659668,
0.3291444182395935,
-0.1283615380525589,
-0.24283815920352936,
-0.07481120526790619,
-0.0922873467206955,
-0.3777927756309509,
0.3557085394859314,
0.529618501663208,
-0.4007963240146637,
0.4487066864967346,
-0.8412483930587769,
0.05797586217522621,
-0.8308091759681702,
0.7441028356552124,
0.08729568868875504,
-0.3011510968208313,
-0.23967133462429047,
-0.24671457707881927,
-0.6352185010910034,
-0.34361135959625244,
-0.37176865339279175,
-0.3602880835533142,
0.4906044006347656,
-0.1366967111825943,
1.2177538871765137,
0.2692066729068756,
0.5546243786811829,
0.4110446870326996,
-0.15401005744934082,
-0.41328856348991394,
-0.16598795354366302,
0.44168058037757874,
-0.5649480223655701,
-0.6533011794090271,
-0.0022717942483723164,
-0.07526767998933792,
0.5711978673934937,
0.683250904083252,
0.10278388112783432,
0.29070356488227844,
0.019866349175572395,
0.6642430424690247,
-0.3615058660507202,
0.1218612790107727,
-0.7092581391334534,
0.01763533242046833,
-0.18640904128551483,
-0.1538798063993454,
-0.38780921697616577,
0.07401250302791595,
0.2358921766281128,
-0.036379311233758926,
0.3261563777923584,
0.10105761885643005,
1.1303520202636719,
0.3710365295410156,
-0.8532077670097351,
-0.38162192702293396,
-1.1261790990829468,
0.6217361688613892,
-0.09667669236660004,
0.2153773009777069,
-0.21320924162864685,
0.7824984788894653,
0.1263255476951599,
-0.888821542263031,
-1.0565216541290283,
0.13599589467048645,
-0.5035447478294373,
0.2857382297515869,
-0.5619490742683411,
-0.37091535329818726,
0.3133867084980011,
0.6047303080558777,
-0.3275745213031769,
-0.3027506172657013,
-0.6125398278236389,
-0.09476368129253387,
0.3194237947463989,
0.2405756264925003,
0.6438648700714111,
-0.669474184513092,
-0.6852632164955139,
-0.12145844846963882,
-0.42618808150291443,
0.1521444469690323,
0.07811584323644638,
-0.07150829583406448,
-0.14348170161247253,
0.3379586637020111,
0.494293749332428,
0.45529764890670776,
-0.06173563376069069,
0.1783059984445572,
-0.11274262517690659,
-0.18876031041145325,
-0.2478046417236328,
0.04511376842856407,
0.742169976234436,
0.44186878204345703,
0.39487165212631226,
-0.09570920467376709,
0.08418184518814087,
0.6030415892601013,
0.87971431016922,
-0.6772515177726746,
-0.20224487781524658,
-0.07332793623209,
-0.35554060339927673,
-0.20202571153640747,
0.3255670666694641,
-0.5132952928543091,
-0.03242505341768265,
-0.30680352449417114,
-0.003124834503978491,
-0.18063174188137054,
-0.42941442131996155,
-0.043523721396923065,
-0.09003636240959167,
0.8370808362960815,
0.15989959239959717,
-1.1265575885772705,
0.24578799307346344,
1.0548486709594727,
0.5792625546455383,
0.10391276329755783,
-0.006329325493425131,
0.35614731907844543,
0.376973032951355,
-0.6150615215301514,
1.182525634765625,
-0.5858665704727173,
-0.6181158423423767,
-0.058465056121349335,
0.23693034052848816,
-0.2606184482574463,
-0.21630260348320007,
0.5293304324150085,
-0.2991105616092682,
0.8639000654220581,
-0.14140136539936066,
-0.42099708318710327,
-0.31740614771842957,
0.16744233667850494,
-0.6983091831207275,
0.8991831541061401,
-0.02239537052810192,
-0.6576115489006042,
0.22983096539974213,
-0.8367984294891357,
-0.452384352684021,
0.6259183287620544,
-0.6489741802215576,
-0.0448758564889431,
0.5129647850990295,
-0.1328848898410797,
0.19605861604213715,
-0.34673529863357544,
0.39313411712646484,
0.14407651126384735,
-0.3826456069946289,
0.36505118012428284,
-0.3788168430328369,
0.7246050834655762,
0.10768921673297882,
-0.712121844291687,
-0.23397774994373322,
-0.2582883834838867,
-0.20803725719451904,
0.26405930519104004,
0.1309775561094284,
-0.37618783116340637,
0.4508577585220337,
-0.00020857367780990899,
0.41522127389907837,
-0.03672299161553383,
-0.5480949282646179,
0.05691126361489296,
-0.793811023235321,
0.6337834596633911,
0.7615030407905579,
-0.45966091752052307,
0.8160512447357178,
-0.38283392786979675,
0.36681532859802246,
-0.07407136261463165,
0.15489216148853302,
-0.42440396547317505,
-0.6117805242538452,
-0.8012242317199707,
0.0667441114783287,
-0.10357493907213211,
0.5339599847793579,
-0.4742909073829651,
0.4627189636230469,
-0.5695942044258118,
-0.439909964799881,
-0.3618696331977844,
-0.39449241757392883,
-0.02176426351070404,
0.5475425124168396,
0.23806942999362946,
-0.40618738532066345,
-0.27642175555229187,
-1.3369163274765015,
-0.41025397181510925,
-0.24303783476352692,
-0.23926204442977905,
0.6265078783035278,
0.36043134331703186,
-0.3972022533416748,
1.0019679069519043,
-0.6037275195121765,
-0.05217517167329788,
-0.26063472032546997,
-0.018452104181051254,
0.34805527329444885,
0.23558034002780914,
0.9738043546676636,
-1.0761483907699585,
-0.5414063334465027,
0.0048621478490531445,
-0.531109631061554,
0.2484149932861328,
-0.18585406243801117,
-0.37652587890625,
-0.0958145260810852,
0.4836214482784271,
-1.0535433292388916,
0.4805949628353119,
0.2676650583744049,
-0.2510188817977905,
0.2080378234386444,
0.24587777256965637,
0.12127766013145447,
-1.7417612075805664,
-0.009585619904100895,
-0.3679468631744385,
-0.1378655880689621,
-0.740277886390686,
-0.025844387710094452,
-0.030839314684271812,
-0.2696889042854309,
-0.5099619626998901,
0.6527095437049866,
-0.16743111610412598,
0.28793781995773315,
-0.5874933004379272,
0.2036030888557434,
0.05598199740052223,
-0.07077833265066147,
-0.07657796889543533,
0.5966444611549377,
0.5666058659553528,
-0.31393083930015564,
0.5949695110321045,
0.5257335901260376,
-0.32801052927970886,
0.7951251864433289,
-0.5871996283531189,
0.14773549139499664,
-0.39003628492355347,
0.6702200174331665,
-1.2259069681167603,
-0.36927106976509094,
0.2990199625492096,
-0.2018395960330963,
0.0627891793847084,
0.08850293606519699,
-0.2530687153339386,
-0.728560209274292,
-0.2047000229358673,
0.4462251365184784,
0.7126068472862244,
-0.47512248158454895,
0.9808999300003052,
0.5192887783050537,
-0.03035900555551052,
-0.29881903529167175,
-0.7015488147735596,
0.30069294571876526,
-0.4287737011909485,
-0.7780506610870361,
0.6426256895065308,
0.28611820936203003,
-0.5203160643577576,
0.16998374462127686,
-0.2256484180688858,
-0.14867529273033142,
0.008697828277945518,
0.5157684087753296,
0.37049031257629395,
-0.411124050617218,
0.2783471941947937,
-0.1889730542898178,
-0.43548646569252014,
0.4083000719547272,
-0.026049891486763954,
0.45624250173568726,
-0.3043813109397888,
-0.05514372140169144,
-0.19292649626731873,
0.37562650442123413,
0.5346890091896057,
0.07554556429386139,
0.7908430099487305,
0.5907692313194275,
-0.27113407850265503,
-0.09029601514339447,
-0.3369922935962677,
-0.25038790702819824,
-0.4942300319671631,
-0.020413419231772423,
-0.5423291921615601,
-0.8449074625968933,
0.386553555727005,
-0.30809757113456726,
0.05235486477613449,
0.6912139058113098,
0.7054829001426697,
-0.603386402130127,
0.580569326877594,
0.7074947953224182,
0.05556875839829445,
0.6490904092788696,
-0.07759620994329453,
0.7141503095626831,
-0.9110300540924072,
-0.03757808357477188,
-0.6225040555000305,
-0.6462141275405884,
-0.8278214931488037,
-0.21968156099319458,
0.21496334671974182,
-0.3822510242462158,
-0.2822403907775879,
0.7847849130630493,
-0.7042801380157471,
0.5773093104362488,
0.22086241841316223,
-0.26870137453079224,
-0.05863726884126663,
-0.18350647389888763,
0.04067819565534592,
-0.05339748412370682,
-0.4802250564098358,
-1.1190505027770996,
0.6648810505867004,
0.026622019708156586,
0.5714128017425537,
0.32498306035995483,
0.1614067554473877,
0.009007938206195831,
0.4052431285381317,
-0.9016929864883423,
0.612991988658905,
-0.013076831586658955,
-0.9194689989089966,
0.2263181060552597,
0.0632718876004219,
-1.3325804471969604,
0.47214269638061523,
0.05413408949971199,
-0.851976752281189,
0.19856514036655426,
0.09546558558940887,
-0.09480175375938416,
0.5211046934127808,
-0.6099907755851746,
0.9567399621009827,
-0.1987898200750351,
0.0913715809583664,
-0.30273333191871643,
-0.9639513492584229,
0.5951915979385376,
0.11394939571619034,
0.4256771504878998,
-0.13589166104793549,
0.05552490055561066,
0.43616029620170593,
-0.1498623490333557,
0.6658626794815063,
0.31387627124786377,
-0.2354004979133606,
0.33808180689811707,
0.30558618903160095,
-0.0978180393576622,
-0.20237793028354645,
0.4058102071285248,
0.028743693605065346,
0.07311763614416122,
-0.38567671179771423,
-0.8061767220497131,
0.45158326625823975,
-0.5489346385002136,
-0.868107795715332,
-0.4185698926448822,
-0.5709254145622253,
0.039703283458948135,
0.09798197448253632,
0.11703195422887802,
0.6051338315010071,
-0.2875853478908539,
0.5067962408065796,
0.40074655413627625,
-0.26543182134628296,
0.6447345018386841,
-0.02663750760257244,
-0.13026951253414154,
0.07038680464029312,
0.3765297830104828,
-0.23565034568309784,
0.45573195815086365,
0.6753657460212708,
0.219100683927536,
-0.28941866755485535,
0.30343979597091675,
-0.26192352175712585,
0.04205983504652977,
-0.8981679677963257,
0.05809914320707321,
-0.4402017295360565,
-0.3575536608695984,
-0.2115476429462433,
-0.4386807084083557,
-0.4095153510570526,
-0.2977738678455353,
0.13687463104724884,
0.10968615859746933,
-0.0463816374540329,
0.7734146118164062,
0.5502310395240784,
0.43160155415534973,
-0.649391233921051,
0.49978360533714294,
0.595609188079834,
0.12103036791086197,
-0.17853118479251862,
-0.4270657002925873,
0.07372310757637024,
-0.03853623941540718,
-0.6800994277000427,
-0.7679747939109802,
-0.09740206599235535,
0.14796513319015503,
0.5609606504440308,
0.4558972418308258,
-0.20054090023040771,
0.45896217226982117,
-0.8733124732971191,
1.136315107345581,
0.15245747566223145,
-0.7606782913208008,
0.6175573468208313,
0.006065555848181248,
0.39029940962791443,
0.23857209086418152,
0.49514102935791016,
-0.922075629234314,
-0.3384556472301483,
-0.9318304657936096,
-0.7812448143959045,
0.45250365138053894,
0.12231112271547318,
1.2044168710708618,
-0.16585630178451538,
0.03649485483765602,
0.09646568447351456,
0.12909390032291412,
-0.9872209429740906,
-0.31015604734420776,
-0.4098227918148041,
-0.13015492260456085,
-0.047255437821149826,
-0.2592140734195709,
-0.18966181576251984,
-0.3872440457344055,
0.11049100756645203,
-0.09964164346456528,
0.5937565565109253,
-0.10149600356817245,
-0.2890368103981018,
-0.03817671909928322,
0.5884865522384644,
0.342730849981308,
0.6742168664932251,
0.3372752368450165,
0.6518142819404602,
-0.1080017015337944,
-0.4469628930091858,
0.13162681460380554,
-0.46201613545417786,
-0.16472581028938293,
0.12900882959365845,
0.43898189067840576,
1.1183462142944336,
0.5561608672142029,
-0.2465193122625351,
0.6010250449180603,
-0.018764616921544075,
-0.21333378553390503,
-0.2685088515281677,
0.09030880033969879,
0.36099696159362793,
0.3735743463039398,
0.35557588934898376,
0.469555526971817,
-0.0712617039680481,
-0.8823333382606506,
0.2654655873775482,
0.4951590299606323,
-0.4990551769733429,
-0.5083391070365906,
0.7674546241760254,
0.0008015208295546472,
-0.7027803659439087,
0.39302733540534973,
0.06986375153064728,
-0.7721927165985107,
0.45495328307151794,
0.5926082134246826,
1.1171536445617676,
-0.3360016644001007,
0.3020787835121155,
0.30246812105178833,
0.4552980661392212,
0.07873734086751938,
-0.13753969967365265,
-0.36764848232269287,
-1.0593732595443726,
-0.21032437682151794,
-0.6052874326705933,
-0.37774422764778137,
-0.18960076570510864,
-0.5337293744087219,
0.26959556341171265,
0.04025788977742195,
-0.015239796601235867,
0.14418154954910278,
-0.5169317722320557,
-0.41150882840156555,
-0.12088041752576828,
0.4076341390609741,
0.5791506171226501,
-0.6788154244422913,
0.6652524471282959,
0.5533380508422852,
-0.0647365152835846,
-0.6647582650184631,
0.3906615972518921,
-0.19057980179786682,
-0.44356951117515564,
0.562415599822998,
0.5504534244537354,
-0.2476707100868225,
0.038089510053396225,
-0.26527154445648193,
-0.7002000212669373,
0.9816967248916626,
0.5107612013816833,
-0.43419721722602844,
-0.04216544330120087,
0.2716735303401947,
0.5930015444755554,
-0.27524828910827637,
0.309752881526947,
0.48557573556900024,
0.5256862640380859,
0.02375430054962635,
-0.8239085674285889,
0.025630440562963486,
-0.2528599202632904,
0.30896762013435364,
0.5964432954788208,
-0.41673216223716736,
0.7617868185043335,
0.2427154779434204,
-0.7631404399871826,
-0.12834575772285461,
0.35517334938049316,
-0.646964967250824,
-0.19331808388233185,
0.37227529287338257,
0.42526987195014954,
0.02007301338016987,
-0.36435070633888245,
1.4100176095962524,
-0.36432671546936035,
0.5004750490188599,
0.7560951113700867,
-0.0034706627484411,
0.6515762209892273,
0.4994778335094452,
-0.3993769586086273,
0.8428229689598083,
0.28998851776123047,
-0.05993325263261795,
0.36681199073791504,
-0.0708085224032402,
-0.3534914255142212,
-0.08287356793880463,
0.035613708198070526,
-0.13970762491226196,
0.7421337366104126,
0.2813137173652649,
-0.38245537877082825,
-0.5749124884605408,
0.196578711271286,
-0.14016222953796387,
0.22071656584739685,
0.025130046531558037,
0.9649501442909241,
0.3361864686012268,
-0.5022118091583252,
0.3455340564250946,
-0.3172472417354584,
0.4476509392261505,
-0.2572249472141266,
0.36565759778022766,
0.03029455430805683,
-0.03912048414349556,
0.013496942818164825,
-0.9488376975059509,
0.8402029275894165,
-0.2388298362493515,
0.049895450472831726,
-0.6368280649185181,
1.0022825002670288,
-0.13468515872955322,
-0.4970911741256714,
0.3924707770347595,
0.6111459136009216,
0.09554772078990936,
0.2157706320285797,
-0.8874258399009705,
-0.17622807621955872,
-0.5355473756790161,
-0.2660655081272125,
-0.07075537741184235,
0.2077459841966629,
-0.03860818222165108,
0.3381785750389099,
0.4240618348121643,
-0.26669272780418396,
-0.08108754456043243,
-0.004908641800284386,
0.7207091450691223,
-0.7854414582252502,
-0.44026491045951843,
-1.185758352279663,
0.38126319646835327,
0.02164071425795555,
-0.1708621084690094,
0.577302098274231,
0.46171602606773376,
0.8328139185905457,
0.01155390590429306,
0.4087807238101959,
-0.42475447058677673,
0.15738803148269653,
0.006107925903052092,
0.6543042659759521,
-0.36627185344696045,
-0.10263141244649887,
-0.2514178454875946,
-1.1121466159820557,
-0.3291037082672119,
0.7668755650520325,
-0.6426048278808594,
-0.302272766828537,
0.8549624681472778,
0.5833590030670166,
-0.33733007311820984,
0.28034278750419617,
0.27899235486984253,
0.1121763214468956,
0.2897925078868866,
0.49635961651802063,
1.0719143152236938,
-0.6416680812835693,
0.34319692850112915,
-0.0008850372978486121,
0.03706306964159012,
-0.05260191857814789,
-0.6031947731971741,
-0.6518347859382629,
-0.9351824522018433,
0.015058827586472034,
-0.0824885442852974,
-0.5778636932373047,
0.6189441084861755,
0.3218776285648346,
-0.5133840441703796,
-0.34858718514442444,
-0.2571066617965698,
0.2961491346359253,
-0.14950227737426758,
-0.298257976770401,
0.08614686876535416,
-0.35609808564186096,
-0.9313150644302368,
0.1523420512676239,
0.5794524550437927,
-0.06082415208220482,
-0.36423584818840027,
0.34857121109962463,
-0.047399092465639114,
0.4159628450870514,
0.8829058408737183,
0.0038939237128943205,
-0.9405802488327026,
-0.7120445966720581,
-0.20419356226921082,
-0.24833296239376068,
0.4210955798625946,
0.8477447032928467,
-0.7027379274368286,
0.4436037540435791,
0.364795446395874,
0.721936821937561,
0.43999096751213074,
-0.015181753784418106,
0.5701680779457092,
-0.2513779103755951,
0.36560508608818054,
0.20992563664913177,
0.46106573939323425,
0.0991911068558693,
0.021407632157206535,
0.34831395745277405,
0.44381237030029297,
-0.21537242829799652,
-0.8594444990158081,
0.7704960703849792,
-0.8616825938224792,
-0.39264771342277527,
0.614551305770874,
0.3690578043460846,
-0.5358652472496033,
0.060301318764686584,
-0.27249664068222046,
0.11736923456192017,
0.42085614800453186,
0.8521404266357422,
0.8200374245643616,
-0.10461428761482239,
-0.20093144476413727,
-0.7283809781074524,
0.33756834268569946,
0.3867199122905731,
-0.7602808475494385,
-0.32166019082069397,
0.11989901959896088,
0.24459251761436462,
0.6197139024734497,
0.29556483030319214,
-0.25252780318260193,
0.08549961447715759,
0.04382660239934921,
-0.14353762567043304,
0.5894461274147034,
-0.1940891295671463,
0.07604093104600906,
0.43896907567977905,
-0.5495283603668213,
-0.1397487074136734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09576v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09576v1
|
Large language models and linguistic intentionality
| 2024-04-15T08:37:26 | 2024-04-15T08:37:26 |
Jumbly Grindrod
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Do large language models like Chat-GPT or LLaMa meaningfully use the words
they produce? Or are they merely clever prediction machines, simulating
language use by producing statistically plausible text? There have already been
some initial attempts to answer this question by showing that these models meet
the criteria for entering meaningful states according to metasemantic theories
of mental content. In this paper, I will argue for a different approach - that
we should instead consider whether language models meet the criteria given by
our best metasemantic theories of linguistic content. In that vein, I will
illustrate how this can be done by applying two such theories to the case of
language models: Gareth Evans' (1982) account of naming practices and Ruth
Millikan's (1984, 2004, 2005) teleosemantics. In doing so, I will argue that it
is a mistake to think that the failure of LLMs to meet plausible conditions for
mental intentionality thereby renders their outputs meaningless, and that a
distinguishing feature of linguistic intentionality - dependency on a
pre-existing linguistic system - allows for the plausible result LLM outputs
are meaningful.
|
[
-0.2312925010919571,
-0.8030648231506348,
1.0584601163864136,
-0.011114242486655712,
-0.20070859789848328,
-0.276538610458374,
-0.3280443549156189,
-0.5801813006401062,
0.40655067563056946,
0.5759919881820679,
-0.5102745890617371,
0.1256159245967865,
-0.6996908783912659,
0.2355097383260727,
-0.7051500082015991,
0.7082750797271729,
0.08311814069747925,
-0.07624954730272293,
0.08257073163986206,
-0.07371179759502411,
-0.5342536568641663,
-0.586607813835144,
-0.5603110790252686,
-0.4316107928752899,
0.736344039440155,
0.035282496362924576,
1.0608381032943726,
0.6315486431121826,
0.48450255393981934,
0.4415106773376465,
0.18499132990837097,
0.06424654275178909,
-0.4830436110496521,
0.16183893382549286,
-0.2937926948070526,
-0.6927238702774048,
-0.21836043894290924,
0.43954312801361084,
0.7523826360702515,
0.8978966474533081,
-0.1742469221353531,
0.06702735275030136,
0.02934124507009983,
0.303183376789093,
-0.23152746260166168,
0.11339963972568512,
-0.8836445808410645,
0.11761424690485,
-0.1929812729358673,
-0.4494140148162842,
-0.60808926820755,
-0.11718288064002991,
0.007901600562036037,
-0.2804112732410431,
-0.1592380404472351,
0.28677576780319214,
0.7287264466285706,
0.13199396431446075,
-0.27169889211654663,
-0.49488645792007446,
-1.2076374292373657,
0.9820922017097473,
-1.0330617427825928,
0.3195599913597107,
0.6096885800361633,
0.3315982520580292,
-0.23765802383422852,
-0.48008406162261963,
-0.8382512927055359,
-0.4555946886539459,
-0.2262374460697174,
-0.13149893283843994,
-0.1364695131778717,
0.09043295681476593,
0.6585522294044495,
0.2691097855567932,
-0.3051399290561676,
0.19784411787986755,
-0.49989986419677734,
0.15543213486671448,
0.6594337224960327,
0.3867642879486084,
0.5553125739097595,
-0.2008354663848877,
-0.04349036142230034,
0.41410040855407715,
-0.7991553544998169,
-0.17831869423389435,
0.50026935338974,
0.2824254631996155,
0.18557611107826233,
1.0164427757263184,
-0.00921192578971386,
0.40987420082092285,
-0.2997635304927826,
-0.3558642864227295,
-0.07326430827379227,
-0.11902351677417755,
-0.34906676411628723,
-0.02561304345726967,
0.9691911935806274,
0.25019654631614685,
0.9772776365280151,
-0.4519774913787842,
-0.18418744206428528,
0.41461384296417236,
0.3834820091724396,
-0.7057390809059143,
-0.15302430093288422,
0.3610783517360687,
-0.2971217930316925,
-0.43781033158302307,
0.11582154780626297,
0.027228308841586113,
-0.16861321032047272,
-0.6118468046188354,
0.2034718096256256,
-0.39735540747642517,
-0.40874385833740234,
0.30846288800239563,
-0.07266891002655029,
0.04964263364672661,
0.22598901391029358,
-0.9895357489585876,
0.17875663936138153,
0.8295361399650574,
0.5482856035232544,
0.05195179209113121,
-0.5856550931930542,
-0.16784408688545227,
0.3162660598754883,
-0.6396986842155457,
0.6611120104789734,
-0.8911796808242798,
-0.20351369678974152,
0.059157684445381165,
-0.009194430895149708,
-0.053806621581315994,
-0.3201659023761749,
0.13304241001605988,
-0.5565519332885742,
0.21813011169433594,
-0.5427610874176025,
-0.7419376969337463,
-0.35810643434524536,
0.08634842932224274,
-0.5499114990234375,
0.6256453394889832,
-0.26074695587158203,
-0.4755710959434509,
0.4704726040363312,
-0.39531582593917847,
-0.3574232757091522,
0.24373473227024078,
-0.2931365668773651,
0.15108875930309296,
0.3273721933364868,
-0.46268996596336365,
0.7414299845695496,
-0.3449293076992035,
0.713334321975708,
-0.4068323075771332,
-0.46215271949768066,
1.0040318965911865,
-0.6509227752685547,
0.4850335121154785,
0.07914949208498001,
-0.4058477580547333,
-0.32085874676704407,
-0.4120559096336365,
0.12875118851661682,
0.18443825840950012,
-0.288349986076355,
-0.37268882989883423,
0.4786986708641052,
-0.23507484793663025,
0.3130088746547699,
-0.07935439795255661,
-0.3722168803215027,
0.052389103919267654,
-0.40907904505729675,
0.4945530593395233,
0.7198622822761536,
-0.34017521142959595,
0.4494415819644928,
-0.46608221530914307,
0.40844255685806274,
-0.3277498781681061,
0.03709397092461586,
-0.073868028819561,
-0.676734447479248,
-0.7188315391540527,
-0.1782648116350174,
0.1336706578731537,
0.5062044262886047,
-0.5088592171669006,
0.3012816905975342,
-0.41054150462150574,
-0.47552525997161865,
-0.30844590067863464,
0.02906794473528862,
0.24594621360301971,
0.059020377695560455,
-0.01394790131598711,
-0.39993563294410706,
-0.5500562191009521,
-0.9391593337059021,
-0.7305849194526672,
-0.33496448397636414,
-0.09351545572280884,
0.5017570853233337,
0.41958877444267273,
-0.38383832573890686,
0.8376017808914185,
-0.16688480973243713,
-0.05972393974661827,
-0.3304859697818756,
0.023769792169332504,
0.2797892689704895,
0.03204730525612831,
0.5659902691841125,
-0.5734051465988159,
-0.177853524684906,
-0.14495313167572021,
-0.9997621774673462,
-0.16863080859184265,
-0.05127304419875145,
0.302345871925354,
-0.06779475510120392,
0.4251543879508972,
-0.8298367261886597,
0.2891349494457245,
0.6507477164268494,
-0.357687771320343,
0.7224612832069397,
-0.06902109086513519,
0.21583141386508942,
-0.9285845160484314,
0.0766819640994072,
-0.2709847688674927,
-0.28189799189567566,
-0.8807644844055176,
-0.1518811285495758,
-0.2316824495792389,
0.08108347654342651,
-0.5563457012176514,
0.6189104318618774,
-0.27388182282447815,
-0.07561807334423065,
-0.6805264949798584,
0.2198721319437027,
-0.3128436803817749,
0.23211531341075897,
-0.1099252924323082,
0.5657398700714111,
0.20066805183887482,
-0.669842541217804,
0.3554643392562866,
-0.10872238874435425,
-0.36472296714782715,
0.396386057138443,
-0.6481647491455078,
-0.10109656304121017,
-0.2640840411186218,
0.23926110565662384,
-0.9078328013420105,
-0.49605125188827515,
0.36323094367980957,
-0.22001200914382935,
-0.0011417991481721401,
-0.008119180798530579,
-0.5748417973518372,
-0.3103288412094116,
0.021665653213858604,
0.4935707151889801,
0.5796516537666321,
-0.15572263300418854,
0.42867618799209595,
0.5308101773262024,
-0.12227395921945572,
-0.30862143635749817,
-1.0868335962295532,
0.330030620098114,
-0.4173462986946106,
-0.4204675555229187,
0.07954090088605881,
-0.017290621995925903,
-0.636662483215332,
0.02481745555996895,
0.36610013246536255,
0.1792425662279129,
0.02264305204153061,
0.3852509558200836,
0.1778055876493454,
-0.21241723001003265,
0.2110579013824463,
-0.3548750877380371,
-0.054030925035476685,
0.36001715064048767,
-0.06681709736585617,
0.6440617442131042,
-0.04622694477438927,
-0.4549323618412018,
-0.4300818145275116,
0.2940712869167328,
0.46028098464012146,
0.06957868486642838,
0.911435604095459,
0.24857188761234283,
-0.43492889404296875,
-0.1232733279466629,
-0.7523001432418823,
-0.3051861822605133,
-0.49650734663009644,
0.24511033296585083,
-0.36267778277397156,
-0.941592812538147,
0.5029534101486206,
-0.025805484503507614,
0.0629580169916153,
0.478063702583313,
0.5462110638618469,
-0.38546034693717957,
0.9529240131378174,
0.4826357960700989,
0.13174232840538025,
0.4724303185939789,
-0.22193272411823273,
0.5264922976493835,
-0.9656519293785095,
0.035576190799474716,
-0.427047997713089,
-0.38682109117507935,
-0.6696401238441467,
-0.3834139108657837,
-0.12032946944236755,
-0.2466207891702652,
-0.14207203686237335,
0.48430702090263367,
-0.046068884432315826,
0.7058989405632019,
0.20274099707603455,
-0.28002968430519104,
0.3037952482700348,
-0.07127875834703445,
0.02377566508948803,
-0.10133587568998337,
-0.6624541878700256,
-1.1224628686904907,
1.0421537160873413,
0.27616530656814575,
0.7533345222473145,
0.08645514398813248,
0.36378294229507446,
0.1547001749277115,
0.5029850006103516,
-0.7604982256889343,
0.7593244910240173,
-0.09149445593357086,
-0.7045365571975708,
-0.381879985332489,
-0.39167729020118713,
-1.29092276096344,
0.1999320089817047,
-0.17453449964523315,
-1.0210195779800415,
-0.009027618914842606,
0.0070808506570756435,
-0.14640827476978302,
0.5802778005599976,
-0.42216789722442627,
0.5824458003044128,
-0.1237301304936409,
0.07157149910926819,
-0.3843647837638855,
-0.26244255900382996,
0.6633231043815613,
-0.18060965836048126,
0.6306391954421997,
-0.5000341534614563,
-0.30261340737342834,
0.8895288109779358,
-0.1233467310667038,
0.9590891599655151,
0.12649697065353394,
-0.2755315899848938,
0.38313788175582886,
0.303463339805603,
0.472822904586792,
-0.15150964260101318,
0.04357994347810745,
0.19094158709049225,
-0.078547403216362,
-0.22817938029766083,
-0.5609229207038879,
0.5521232485771179,
-0.5812989473342896,
-0.6962705850601196,
-0.25597548484802246,
-0.5947077870368958,
-0.015954740345478058,
0.3281702697277069,
0.133664071559906,
0.523172914981842,
-0.3458637297153473,
0.01327445637434721,
0.5764728784561157,
0.020940570160746574,
0.438541442155838,
0.5705507397651672,
-0.541819155216217,
-0.1981402188539505,
0.8238474130630493,
0.31778663396835327,
0.4449966847896576,
0.1416369527578354,
0.16575193405151367,
-0.016542842611670494,
-0.3026845157146454,
-0.1270504891872406,
0.6926233172416687,
-0.7894778251647949,
0.16798441112041473,
-0.7446383833885193,
-0.33857280015945435,
-0.007726418320089579,
-0.0489945225417614,
-0.3029435873031616,
-0.2865368127822876,
-0.09569995105266571,
0.02559410221874714,
0.02456478774547577,
1.0645923614501953,
0.2394474446773529,
0.4445830285549164,
-0.733771800994873,
0.29528743028640747,
0.35703521966934204,
0.134419783949852,
-0.06639567762613297,
-0.7156057953834534,
-0.03109470009803772,
0.3592766523361206,
-0.08698001503944397,
-0.9206030964851379,
0.10024714469909668,
0.16613703966140747,
0.5316972732543945,
0.6687605381011963,
-0.4319981634616852,
0.5446301698684692,
-0.8490898013114929,
0.7083103656768799,
0.1038319393992424,
-0.7049450278282166,
0.4035443365573883,
-0.4408089220523834,
0.200959250330925,
0.22303275763988495,
0.5336690545082092,
-0.9841192364692688,
-0.9397832751274109,
-0.9828277826309204,
-0.3394644856452942,
0.4897933304309845,
0.11426122486591339,
0.6954784393310547,
-0.3529497981071472,
0.3957993984222412,
0.15486271679401398,
0.26380541920661926,
-0.8332625031471252,
-0.019786419346928596,
0.4882188141345978,
-0.07077715545892715,
-0.1988317221403122,
-0.5404970645904541,
0.049298785626888275,
0.014907398261129856,
0.6334161162376404,
-0.11592545360326767,
0.4032558798789978,
-0.08054745197296143,
-0.08316255360841751,
-0.2419198751449585,
0.17218805849552155,
0.5917255282402039,
0.9587851762771606,
0.3461558520793915,
0.32389357686042786,
0.21770301461219788,
-0.4326730966567993,
0.13791929185390472,
-0.46514764428138733,
-0.2702990472316742,
0.031143296509981155,
0.4973297119140625,
0.7329421639442444,
0.5380523204803467,
-0.7326177358627319,
0.4339539110660553,
0.048851579427719116,
-0.13437972962856293,
-0.41218194365501404,
0.34785258769989014,
0.2479609251022339,
0.35473689436912537,
0.09149853885173798,
0.18617060780525208,
0.0882800817489624,
-1.0020712614059448,
-0.025007642805576324,
0.6833994388580322,
-0.05130685120820999,
-0.6014437079429626,
0.6695737838745117,
-0.12641575932502747,
-0.4496859312057495,
0.5477744936943054,
-0.22661378979682922,
-0.5467650890350342,
0.5076326131820679,
0.3913007080554962,
1.0131655931472778,
-0.48705267906188965,
0.12809057533740997,
0.3053109347820282,
0.6051536798477173,
-0.362765908241272,
0.28872770071029663,
0.25942322611808777,
-1.1015539169311523,
-0.7867368459701538,
-0.6378564238548279,
-0.2931918799877167,
0.10114072263240814,
-0.09360344707965851,
0.3660886287689209,
-0.19303718209266663,
-0.3464367985725403,
0.1587444692850113,
-0.3265267610549927,
-0.6999989748001099,
0.08787988126277924,
0.4607832729816437,
0.568217933177948,
-1.069688320159912,
0.7549217343330383,
0.35292187333106995,
-0.14459538459777832,
-1.00348961353302,
-0.12888099253177643,
-0.17100347578525543,
-0.7729513049125671,
0.39135289192199707,
0.317013144493103,
0.03257651999592781,
-0.12769600749015808,
-0.29905015230178833,
-1.0309942960739136,
0.8800017237663269,
0.40023353695869446,
-0.46002453565597534,
-0.21110419929027557,
0.7357825040817261,
0.45014873147010803,
-0.40319687128067017,
0.25019800662994385,
0.6338529586791992,
0.6624029874801636,
0.06275564432144165,
-1.0648300647735596,
0.16245955228805542,
0.011494939215481281,
0.21727867424488068,
0.32612112164497375,
-0.3848440945148468,
0.6554474234580994,
-0.4016762375831604,
-0.48167291283607483,
0.062001101672649384,
0.5564996004104614,
0.048868317157030106,
0.011322122998535633,
0.32057738304138184,
0.5547820925712585,
0.7010312676429749,
-0.059163354337215424,
1.2067124843597412,
-0.0047804247587919235,
0.251743882894516,
0.7212032675743103,
-0.13163632154464722,
0.8064468502998352,
0.5439265370368958,
-0.5194582939147949,
0.370755136013031,
0.43747857213020325,
-0.04710124433040619,
0.30634254217147827,
0.17719027400016785,
0.017735136672854424,
-0.1578359156847,
0.01889445260167122,
0.005497771315276623,
0.605323076248169,
0.4595145881175995,
-0.5556067824363708,
0.041654255241155624,
0.06533599644899368,
0.25713613629341125,
-0.24887526035308838,
-0.13541151583194733,
0.7400121688842773,
0.48430734872817993,
-0.8459686636924744,
0.4104401171207428,
0.09873194992542267,
0.5471603274345398,
-0.47372159361839294,
0.2727081775665283,
0.025622574612498283,
-0.06519272178411484,
-0.2647227346897125,
-0.7998716235160828,
0.5994805097579956,
0.04286406561732292,
-0.01636783964931965,
-0.2681199610233307,
0.7097578644752502,
-0.45062199234962463,
-0.603735089302063,
0.049541372805833817,
0.647185206413269,
0.6269407868385315,
-0.0211977269500494,
-0.31150782108306885,
0.02498648501932621,
-0.3627602458000183,
-0.4024890065193176,
0.10402026027441025,
0.6228893399238586,
0.14152652025222778,
0.657302737236023,
0.6645682454109192,
0.49621596932411194,
0.12671945989131927,
-0.04664627090096474,
0.46834996342658997,
-0.7587308883666992,
-0.2462124228477478,
-1.3506361246109009,
0.2525910437107086,
0.20119021832942963,
-0.11770814657211304,
0.6795595288276672,
0.4458976089954376,
0.7142326235771179,
0.025515519082546234,
0.6245707869529724,
-0.13694164156913757,
0.07070106267929077,
-0.526874840259552,
0.6709500551223755,
-0.35151171684265137,
0.3821219801902771,
-0.4127628207206726,
-1.29496431350708,
-0.07708284258842468,
0.4636905789375305,
-0.6806219220161438,
0.36917027831077576,
0.8540948033332825,
0.7142726182937622,
-0.20098288357257843,
0.3025655746459961,
0.6654151082038879,
0.3665793836116791,
0.19898881018161774,
0.4541873335838318,
1.185969352722168,
-0.3794097900390625,
0.17249999940395355,
-0.04841066151857376,
-0.2047652006149292,
-0.20726440846920013,
-0.7980614900588989,
-1.0238183736801147,
-0.6385072469711304,
-0.23096373677253723,
0.05645429342985153,
-0.19126835465431213,
0.6884381771087646,
0.4219174087047577,
-0.43854019045829773,
-0.2747362554073334,
-0.07843759655952454,
-0.11947579681873322,
0.020582551136612892,
-0.21453578770160675,
-0.0462803952395916,
-0.47858643531799316,
-0.6695147752761841,
0.23446781933307648,
0.3284543752670288,
0.14444896578788757,
-0.4953080117702484,
-0.10610732436180115,
0.0922490581870079,
0.6187003254890442,
0.8697964549064636,
0.007380918134003878,
-1.1373348236083984,
-0.5195198655128479,
-0.06661178916692734,
-0.2953866124153137,
-0.13158434629440308,
0.736528754234314,
-0.7609039545059204,
-0.05414837971329689,
0.3114907145500183,
0.29019293189048767,
-0.12259097397327423,
-0.3733617961406708,
0.5201887488365173,
-0.26094555854797363,
-0.000028698384994640946,
0.31520500779151917,
0.5838837623596191,
0.2619289457798004,
-0.1843574047088623,
0.3944395184516907,
0.23318085074424744,
-0.5380393862724304,
-0.7730002999305725,
0.45150116086006165,
-0.574778139591217,
-0.23604731261730194,
1.4073182344436646,
0.15595893561840057,
-0.3639749586582184,
0.09182951599359512,
-0.15302066504955292,
0.055441390722990036,
0.16064588725566864,
0.9986522793769836,
0.9456897974014282,
0.12481305748224258,
0.06922998279333115,
-1.0684199333190918,
0.38539600372314453,
0.3678986430168152,
-0.6648319363594055,
0.21066266298294067,
0.29007554054260254,
0.28571817278862,
0.11263374239206314,
0.728808581829071,
-0.004299785476177931,
0.2790283262729645,
-0.194471538066864,
-0.2273622751235962,
0.2125755250453949,
-0.38058099150657654,
0.15687312185764313,
-0.18419253826141357,
0.17527280747890472,
0.280940979719162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09565v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09565v1
|
Reliability Estimation of News Media Sources: Birds of a Feather Flock Together
| 2024-04-15T08:27:47 | 2024-04-15T08:27:47 |
Sergio Burdisso, Dairazalia Sánchez-Cortés, Esaú Villatoro-Tello, Petr Motlicek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Evaluating the reliability of news sources is a routine task for journalists
and organizations committed to acquiring and disseminating accurate
information. Recent research has shown that predicting sources' reliability
represents an important first-prior step in addressing additional challenges
such as fake news detection and fact-checking. In this paper, we introduce a
novel approach for source reliability estimation that leverages reinforcement
learning strategies for estimating the reliability degree of news sources.
Contrary to previous research, our proposed approach models the problem as the
estimation of a reliability degree, and not a reliability label, based on how
all the news media sources interact with each other on the Web. We validated
the effectiveness of our method on a news media reliability dataset that is an
order of magnitude larger than comparable existing datasets. Results show that
the estimated reliability degrees strongly correlates with journalists-provided
scores (Spearman=0.80) and can effectively predict reliability labels
(macro-avg. F$_1$ score=81.05). We release our implementation and dataset,
aiming to provide a valuable resource for the NLP community working on
information verification.
|
[
-0.1375635415315628,
-0.5015470385551453,
0.7019935250282288,
0.556300163269043,
-0.14441218972206116,
0.0712980329990387,
-0.16958780586719513,
-0.2815304398536682,
0.147609680891037,
-0.056221432983875275,
-0.5316747426986694,
-0.19986313581466675,
-0.6310627460479736,
-0.027891898527741432,
-0.24372194707393646,
1.033417820930481,
0.305711954832077,
0.10498835146427155,
-0.5161250829696655,
-0.19209492206573486,
-0.08299286663532257,
-0.08445202559232712,
-0.5466213226318359,
-0.05958075448870659,
0.8062471747398376,
0.059230558574199677,
0.8077846169471741,
0.49018409848213196,
0.4785465598106384,
0.3053463101387024,
-0.12341554462909698,
0.35309121012687683,
-0.494352787733078,
-0.13158461451530457,
-0.3552264869213104,
-0.267703652381897,
0.01150345616042614,
0.37996944785118103,
0.49387606978416443,
0.6410187482833862,
-0.07511237263679504,
0.3436773121356964,
-0.1186959370970726,
0.8092775344848633,
-0.8403885960578918,
0.17168790102005005,
-0.5387340784072876,
0.23372900485992432,
0.031178826466202736,
-0.6732426285743713,
-0.5652555227279663,
-0.6624769568443298,
-0.09102337062358856,
-0.6488077640533447,
-0.17548143863677979,
0.06857619434595108,
0.6097170114517212,
0.16571997106075287,
-0.6865400671958923,
-0.18307805061340332,
-0.8769716024398804,
0.8149372935295105,
-0.5148716568946838,
0.3444483280181885,
0.6521050333976746,
0.2846430838108063,
-0.4375464916229248,
-0.4104861319065094,
-0.4642672538757324,
-0.298074871301651,
0.2017756849527359,
0.2926029562950134,
0.026653869077563286,
-0.3805164098739624,
-0.042343057692050934,
0.1492832601070404,
-0.5898864269256592,
-0.1594962775707245,
-0.4360277056694031,
-0.12257024645805359,
0.6284082531929016,
-0.3968672454357147,
0.04279010742902756,
-0.22016778588294983,
-0.5306176543235779,
-0.0015393607318401337,
-0.11678538471460342,
0.24116428196430206,
0.6061494946479797,
0.21152476966381073,
0.1780366748571396,
0.19091668725013733,
-0.15644347667694092,
0.8182345628738403,
0.032668281346559525,
-0.48631078004837036,
0.44175082445144653,
-0.14888425171375275,
-0.047326091676950455,
0.0788932517170906,
0.8552294969558716,
0.1525733321905136,
-0.09979407489299774,
-0.4306277334690094,
-0.05953843519091606,
-0.4392821490764618,
0.5229411125183105,
-0.07608702033758163,
-0.11763165146112442,
0.20970988273620605,
-0.5410951972007751,
-0.7756935954093933,
0.5267061591148376,
-0.4706995487213135,
-0.4671153426170349,
0.025573959574103355,
0.6672919392585754,
-0.4327355623245239,
-0.7779976725578308,
-0.24202145636081696,
-0.24466572701931,
-0.09194789081811905,
0.19818854331970215,
-0.4548153877258301,
-0.4132295250892639,
0.630257248878479,
0.9104426503181458,
-0.0024946946650743484,
-0.6171078681945801,
-1.037392020225525,
0.09181594848632812,
-0.44538530707359314,
0.7108986377716064,
-0.4443998336791992,
-0.02163361757993698,
0.06378328055143356,
-0.08516450971364975,
0.1407780647277832,
-0.1271580308675766,
0.8121405243873596,
-0.7254254221916199,
0.04403127729892731,
-0.29563042521476746,
-0.7459126114845276,
-0.2622084319591522,
0.4230208098888397,
-1.022616982460022,
0.5426658987998962,
0.398919016122818,
-1.0022844076156616,
0.45323020219802856,
0.09241689741611481,
-0.37039774656295776,
-0.1474607288837433,
-0.007463324349373579,
-0.6367377042770386,
0.14516611397266388,
0.18515226244926453,
0.12726706266403198,
0.4104408025741577,
0.25678732991218567,
-0.8353893160820007,
-0.3359583616256714,
0.39742806553840637,
-0.6573879718780518,
0.8877432346343994,
0.004959714133292437,
0.06711967289447784,
0.09959619492292404,
-0.9963347911834717,
-0.0347801074385643,
-0.14894573390483856,
-0.6953919529914856,
-0.33048683404922485,
0.1714579164981842,
-0.04221086949110031,
0.3719244599342346,
-0.009418460540473461,
-0.47549140453338623,
0.12204401195049286,
-0.07010617107152939,
0.20610833168029785,
0.6545150279998779,
0.32620522379875183,
0.3034749925136566,
-0.5069566965103149,
0.32924744486808777,
0.3117852509021759,
0.407240629196167,
-0.09183100610971451,
-0.05946999043226242,
-0.31920957565307617,
0.14642438292503357,
0.43527209758758545,
0.21366800367832184,
-0.9132812023162842,
0.2886355519294739,
-0.30698734521865845,
-0.6520737409591675,
-0.07633750885725021,
0.16652478277683258,
0.4378000795841217,
0.6340189576148987,
0.48705121874809265,
0.10779356956481934,
-0.6907473802566528,
-0.23476307094097137,
-0.5270684957504272,
-0.6323080658912659,
-0.004028850235044956,
-0.27047720551490784,
0.2516704797744751,
0.3444923758506775,
1.136175513267517,
0.05432070791721344,
-0.16800421476364136,
-0.1772870123386383,
0.512597918510437,
0.0988524854183197,
0.43018433451652527,
0.4554142653942108,
-1.0272196531295776,
0.07067020982503891,
-0.3339081406593323,
-0.918002724647522,
0.5000210404396057,
-0.3568030297756195,
0.13092800974845886,
0.5567845106124878,
0.3699149787425995,
-0.1822301745414734,
0.25415053963661194,
0.8718163967132568,
-0.24613027274608612,
0.7263146638870239,
0.04988924786448479,
0.2718007564544678,
-0.6154345273971558,
0.03762196749448776,
0.5266290307044983,
-0.4029190242290497,
-0.23518328368663788,
-0.3325410485267639,
-0.06863711029291153,
0.09191659837961197,
-0.7295882701873779,
0.2929249405860901,
-0.26740336418151855,
-0.2763610780239105,
-0.23268626630306244,
-0.07457946240901947,
0.025672122836112976,
0.45118221640586853,
0.04151963070034981,
0.4280027449131012,
0.0707443580031395,
-0.5634438991546631,
0.4763025939464569,
0.039588943123817444,
-0.6048471927642822,
0.8387304544448853,
-0.38364702463150024,
-0.228389173746109,
-0.23522771894931793,
0.46210089325904846,
-0.7057864665985107,
-0.0002991299843415618,
0.07654640078544617,
-0.8878852128982544,
0.04750918969511986,
-0.26136514544487,
-0.1462126523256302,
-0.3564181625843048,
-0.18587331473827362,
0.12425851076841354,
0.04273156076669693,
-0.6154928803443909,
0.36590108275413513,
0.4860994517803192,
0.03120453469455242,
-0.953182578086853,
-0.48589932918548584,
-0.04590454325079918,
0.24892282485961914,
-0.7078998684883118,
-0.10882916301488876,
0.11061970889568329,
-0.11333221197128296,
0.5207914113998413,
-0.5132762789726257,
-0.4199482202529907,
0.0800253376364708,
0.3202936351299286,
0.013158145360648632,
-0.2846631705760956,
0.45065709948539734,
-0.2645588219165802,
-0.08199196308851242,
-0.0014183323364704847,
-0.1264878213405609,
0.029053237289190292,
-0.24120883643627167,
-0.4869927763938904,
-0.29889386892318726,
0.09176378697156906,
0.4609738886356354,
-0.31970348954200745,
0.8783323168754578,
0.7455132603645325,
-0.05372486636042595,
-0.16283516585826874,
-0.6048719882965088,
-0.035193752497434616,
-0.4031536877155304,
0.3855297267436981,
-0.04324580729007721,
-0.35698702931404114,
0.23786047101020813,
-0.02192634344100952,
-0.047193098813295364,
0.3847684860229492,
-0.04492776095867157,
-0.39712971448898315,
0.8332309126853943,
0.8426751494407654,
-0.42189541459083557,
0.3542359173297882,
-0.08275766670703888,
-0.18177945911884308,
-0.19767974317073822,
-0.39211294054985046,
-0.285828560590744,
-0.2716989815235138,
-0.17811810970306396,
-0.1432863175868988,
0.4975987374782562,
0.29068756103515625,
-0.23797063529491425,
0.059062693268060684,
-0.14883258938789368,
0.5329936146736145,
0.8078947067260742,
0.22982576489448547,
0.7212129831314087,
0.12914614379405975,
0.21857987344264984,
0.3498219847679138,
-0.6868687272071838,
-0.18557965755462646,
0.8625257611274719,
0.3461438715457916,
0.4119431674480438,
0.11589837819337845,
0.6062801480293274,
0.5028689503669739,
0.21316151320934296,
-0.6251596808433533,
0.19626231491565704,
0.17716240882873535,
-0.37465521693229675,
-0.765153169631958,
-0.6966034173965454,
-0.7203320264816284,
-0.1457296907901764,
-0.2796589732170105,
-0.2208070009946823,
0.20646704733371735,
0.02392752096056938,
-0.34418240189552307,
0.35163870453834534,
-0.08873981237411499,
0.5530357956886292,
-0.3138693869113922,
-0.202139213681221,
-0.21912051737308502,
-0.5162191390991211,
0.6475693583488464,
0.07266676425933838,
0.41132643818855286,
-0.049584899097681046,
0.0242182444781065,
0.7540879249572754,
-0.5728973150253296,
0.48344627022743225,
-0.19615265727043152,
0.20376601815223694,
0.2856702506542206,
-0.12262646853923798,
0.5019298791885376,
0.3471038341522217,
-0.6432284712791443,
0.21315644681453705,
0.026348628103733063,
-0.3995400071144104,
-0.7035642862319946,
0.6021327376365662,
-0.9119915962219238,
-0.007987499237060547,
-0.9206187129020691,
-0.33266130089759827,
-0.550407886505127,
0.08405973017215729,
0.19311437010765076,
0.2890201807022095,
-0.1831299364566803,
0.3998216688632965,
0.3382219672203064,
-0.06796453148126602,
0.8645038604736328,
0.8271298408508301,
0.004064171575009823,
-0.6021592617034912,
1.162050724029541,
0.3912203907966614,
-0.08339672535657883,
0.14281053841114044,
0.12276428937911987,
-0.23519115149974823,
-0.24957284331321716,
-0.41780924797058105,
0.05890873447060585,
-0.5019761919975281,
-0.2863648235797882,
-0.47115015983581543,
-0.6055566668510437,
0.08429829776287079,
-0.07498779892921448,
-0.513886034488678,
-0.28183886408805847,
-0.2510473132133484,
-0.19201885163784027,
0.2560596466064453,
0.37022000551223755,
-0.2945060431957245,
-0.004792755004018545,
-1.0066719055175781,
0.1029738038778305,
0.45195916295051575,
0.5527058243751526,
-0.08065353333950043,
-0.3547992706298828,
-0.4369406998157501,
0.24526748061180115,
-0.42721793055534363,
-1.0230149030685425,
0.23325872421264648,
0.1663718968629837,
0.7728132009506226,
0.24782931804656982,
0.4288293123245239,
0.34823957085609436,
-0.2678898870944977,
0.6645138263702393,
0.40522632002830505,
-0.7194703817367554,
0.686365008354187,
-0.5168722867965698,
-0.030493391677737236,
0.8514339923858643,
0.6685732007026672,
-0.3453792333602905,
-0.5446419715881348,
-0.8048763275146484,
-0.560165286064148,
0.4301978349685669,
0.015232566744089127,
-0.15489843487739563,
-0.12250862270593643,
0.11857151240110397,
-0.08069968968629837,
0.3327470123767853,
-0.5517275333404541,
-0.09044070541858673,
-0.508723258972168,
0.1259409636259079,
-0.07188227027654648,
-0.34119537472724915,
-0.12179625034332275,
-0.17858022451400757,
1.1065877676010132,
0.008118611760437489,
-0.10755681246519089,
0.10225830972194672,
-0.3820377290248871,
-0.4628240466117859,
0.04052499681711197,
0.7473836541175842,
1.2431684732437134,
-0.4374338984489441,
0.08946269005537033,
-0.3501109480857849,
-0.15598629415035248,
0.3900638222694397,
-0.11107762157917023,
-0.10811890661716461,
0.43425118923187256,
0.33912014961242676,
0.6001425385475159,
0.2024044245481491,
-0.2982618510723114,
0.9058043956756592,
0.07401759922504425,
-0.1518631875514984,
-0.6763790845870972,
-0.1883036196231842,
0.07308731973171234,
0.32808470726013184,
0.8341712355613708,
0.28353431820869446,
0.026891959831118584,
-0.5583559274673462,
0.756257176399231,
0.3033786714076996,
-0.7336925864219666,
-0.12753884494304657,
0.3428787291049957,
0.546868622303009,
-0.1811993569135666,
0.7294820547103882,
-0.4387457072734833,
-0.15394125878810883,
0.7680960893630981,
0.39877161383628845,
0.6617095470428467,
-0.1829078048467636,
0.9388433694839478,
0.46496590971946716,
0.3438631296157837,
-0.672484278678894,
0.006459346041083336,
0.3828805088996887,
-0.6566758155822754,
-0.6502715945243835,
-0.9530366063117981,
-0.6443943381309509,
0.4203077256679535,
-0.5989970564842224,
0.11076875776052475,
-0.22903521358966827,
-0.08095458894968033,
-0.0773642361164093,
0.23262286186218262,
-0.2623549699783325,
0.2950223684310913,
0.15911321341991425,
0.9742753505706787,
-1.104414463043213,
0.6287477016448975,
0.46234819293022156,
-0.989371120929718,
-0.9014106392860413,
0.2546028196811676,
0.32968243956565857,
-0.47096529603004456,
0.560584306716919,
0.13907426595687866,
0.13357990980148315,
0.08514568954706192,
-0.3145727813243866,
-0.9238466620445251,
0.8732669353485107,
0.4238303005695343,
-0.5346482396125793,
0.22056066989898682,
-0.21546927094459534,
0.09486082941293716,
0.1480400711297989,
0.4740007817745209,
0.2335408329963684,
0.6566898226737976,
0.21618035435676575,
-0.6912746429443359,
-0.07731251418590546,
-0.3701091408729553,
-0.02782837301492691,
-0.13156388700008392,
-0.7763516902923584,
0.5004978775978088,
-0.40046969056129456,
0.09376209229230881,
-0.24325178563594818,
1.2169594764709473,
0.33005982637405396,
0.4848993122577667,
0.8430436849594116,
0.4289100170135498,
0.8432565331459045,
0.13935641944408417,
0.8017212748527527,
-0.30229267477989197,
0.550306499004364,
1.0597598552703857,
0.3874550759792328,
0.994921863079071,
0.31498295068740845,
-0.3797820508480072,
0.6671115159988403,
0.5753083229064941,
-0.37566420435905457,
0.4067179262638092,
-0.05192331224679947,
-0.31096363067626953,
-0.3046957552433014,
-0.06323893368244171,
-0.3148910403251648,
0.6124049425125122,
-0.1553466022014618,
-0.46547219157218933,
-0.20831669867038727,
0.23601968586444855,
0.0033543312456458807,
0.052083417773246765,
-0.39672529697418213,
0.6076201796531677,
-0.06611261516809464,
-0.5727803707122803,
0.31576111912727356,
-0.1494625359773636,
0.41883745789527893,
-0.4094996154308319,
0.07774292677640915,
-0.24685509502887726,
-0.05037027224898338,
-0.5201892852783203,
-0.807651937007904,
0.43922528624534607,
-0.42566296458244324,
-0.6036114692687988,
0.2142881155014038,
0.5308711528778076,
-0.5765316486358643,
-0.9759045839309692,
-0.09861986339092255,
0.40017032623291016,
0.021284062415361404,
-0.3405267596244812,
-0.375277042388916,
0.3324405252933502,
-0.34213313460350037,
-0.7585527896881104,
0.5389024019241333,
0.16574832797050476,
0.22629833221435547,
0.6911322474479675,
0.719925045967102,
0.24505390226840973,
-0.07586419582366943,
-0.27191460132598877,
0.477956622838974,
-0.3334748148918152,
-0.34197890758514404,
-0.6695886850357056,
0.5662897229194641,
-0.2819591760635376,
-0.27680614590644836,
0.6522864103317261,
0.48840978741645813,
0.8056688904762268,
-0.01792849786579609,
1.215092658996582,
0.05656610429286957,
0.3780958950519562,
-0.35198715329170227,
0.9052399396896362,
-0.5087003707885742,
0.18176089227199554,
-0.09632498025894165,
-0.7640179991722107,
-0.15336234867572784,
0.6349038481712341,
-0.14515608549118042,
-0.012106725014746189,
0.6321948766708374,
0.5223868489265442,
-0.13259094953536987,
0.13600775599479675,
0.17506679892539978,
0.002483780262991786,
0.19235986471176147,
0.4398132860660553,
0.6818376779556274,
-0.24486970901489258,
1.0094962120056152,
-0.697485089302063,
-0.3327252268791199,
-0.3815222978591919,
-1.2934389114379883,
-0.4060811996459961,
-0.6744319796562195,
-0.511658251285553,
-0.5906016826629639,
0.27060675621032715,
0.6757057905197144,
0.6798180341720581,
-0.5187566876411438,
0.11142610758543015,
-0.061360642313957214,
0.5544722080230713,
-0.7984399795532227,
-0.2433754801750183,
0.37966886162757874,
-0.7557121515274048,
-0.2453448325395584,
0.38489797711372375,
0.2696128487586975,
-0.5241444706916809,
-0.44728565216064453,
-0.11702421307563782,
-0.41963455080986023,
0.05585678294301033,
0.35057491064071655,
0.7966049909591675,
-0.5172893404960632,
-0.678960919380188,
-0.3105084300041199,
-0.17366677522659302,
-0.10891292989253998,
0.46117791533470154,
-0.9814160466194153,
0.3301561176776886,
0.6598745584487915,
0.6679410934448242,
0.07849139720201492,
0.35782137513160706,
0.4858693480491638,
-0.9990355968475342,
0.05152478069067001,
0.1774449497461319,
0.0573740117251873,
0.24078752100467682,
-0.3158681094646454,
0.49179020524024963,
0.4788967967033386,
-0.6378452181816101,
-0.9015771150588989,
0.1482345163822174,
-1.1098599433898926,
-0.21779878437519073,
1.1015602350234985,
-0.3878132104873657,
-0.29931217432022095,
-0.07766356319189072,
0.46364226937294006,
0.5122721791267395,
-0.18886876106262207,
0.9009298086166382,
0.5329750776290894,
0.14975351095199585,
-0.5936948657035828,
-0.346396803855896,
0.5506089925765991,
0.0021828373428434134,
-0.5861273407936096,
-0.38021227717399597,
0.4355897903442383,
0.5038853287696838,
0.29730936884880066,
0.6282596588134766,
0.12960046529769897,
0.44999805092811584,
-0.041322190314531326,
-0.17210900783538818,
-0.7024495601654053,
-0.5261777639389038,
-0.010258547030389309,
0.5012150406837463,
-0.29575449228286743,
-0.25829771161079407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09529v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09529v1
|
Prepacking: A Simple Method for Fast Prefilling and Increased Throughput in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-15T07:49:10 | 2024-04-15T07:49:10 |
Siyan Zhao, Daniel Israel, Guy Van den Broeck, Aditya Grover
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
During inference for transformer-based large language models (LLM),
prefilling is the computation of the key-value (KV) cache for input tokens in
the prompt prior to autoregressive generation. For longer input prompt lengths,
prefilling will incur a significant overhead on decoding time. In this work, we
highlight the following pitfall of prefilling: for batches containing
high-varying prompt lengths, significant computation is wasted by the standard
practice of padding sequences to the maximum length. As LLMs increasingly
support longer context lengths, potentially up to 10 million tokens, variations
in prompt lengths within a batch become more pronounced. To address this, we
propose Prepacking, a simple yet effective method to optimize prefilling
computation. To avoid redundant computation on pad tokens, prepacking combines
prompts of varying lengths into a sequence and packs multiple sequences into a
compact batch using a bin-packing algorithm. It then modifies the attention
mask and positional encoding to compute multiple prefilled KV-caches for
multiple prompts within a single sequence. On standard curated dataset
containing prompts with varying lengths, we obtain a significant speed and
memory efficiency improvements as compared to the default padding-based
prefilling computation within Huggingface across a range of base model
configurations and inference serving scenarios.
|
[
-0.5837612748146057,
-0.7235634922981262,
0.4829322397708893,
0.6289321780204773,
-0.5147606134414673,
0.21038854122161865,
-0.3100113272666931,
-0.24815890192985535,
0.2600005865097046,
0.5887767672538757,
-0.6033777594566345,
-0.342451274394989,
-0.43424665927886963,
0.15813587605953217,
-0.11906924843788147,
0.8187028765678406,
0.08710355311632156,
-0.4567068815231323,
-0.26877713203430176,
0.2925683259963989,
-0.6321654915809631,
-0.7241189479827881,
-0.39988648891448975,
0.13966259360313416,
0.5221996903419495,
0.47514608502388,
0.5723598599433899,
0.7195142507553101,
0.19898192584514618,
0.40336066484451294,
-0.022623488679528236,
0.10899568349123001,
-0.42807257175445557,
0.25409945845603943,
0.12775976955890656,
-0.6288889646530151,
-0.6129304766654968,
0.17148512601852417,
0.5744928121566772,
0.30655333399772644,
0.10112687945365906,
0.15769073367118835,
-0.07238814979791641,
0.6301771998405457,
-0.9618953466415405,
-0.09400460869073868,
-0.4952455163002014,
-0.1835532784461975,
-0.6693124175071716,
-0.43325939774513245,
-0.7216508388519287,
-0.08728157728910446,
0.16672411561012268,
-0.6719580292701721,
0.16154605150222778,
0.10295142233371735,
0.804031491279602,
0.34250032901763916,
0.08006155490875244,
-0.14769414067268372,
-0.6079939007759094,
0.7349081635475159,
-0.8683353066444397,
0.2301746904850006,
0.4114395081996918,
0.22733734548091888,
-0.31802019476890564,
-0.9173526763916016,
-0.5809075832366943,
0.11137315630912781,
-0.31717807054519653,
-0.11008577793836594,
-0.13464394211769104,
0.2730253040790558,
0.5104572772979736,
0.16958704590797424,
-0.605651319026947,
0.10484068840742111,
-0.3440925180912018,
-0.30993273854255676,
0.4164356589317322,
-0.24552589654922485,
0.1708349585533142,
-0.02940700761973858,
-0.21726633608341217,
-0.5008614659309387,
-0.882753849029541,
0.2935800552368164,
0.460906058549881,
0.4768166244029999,
-0.05294690281152725,
0.3489605784416199,
-0.2361375391483307,
0.9704937934875488,
0.27838706970214844,
-0.18538504838943481,
0.2355300635099411,
-0.3459417521953583,
-0.37811022996902466,
0.13843822479248047,
0.5916924476623535,
-0.006661610212177038,
0.6576910614967346,
0.10867496579885483,
-0.0443309023976326,
-0.17346465587615967,
0.39712175726890564,
-1.1013836860656738,
-0.26385363936424255,
0.43343451619148254,
-0.18359820544719696,
-0.28726401925086975,
0.029325565323233604,
-0.8554050326347351,
-0.01044517382979393,
-0.3043319880962372,
0.28545305132865906,
-0.1903238594532013,
0.06656115502119064,
0.37968629598617554,
0.13266223669052124,
0.015441011637449265,
0.046833865344524384,
-0.6859681010246277,
0.08842762559652328,
0.6152148246765137,
0.7112565636634827,
-0.031085973605513573,
-0.26892703771591187,
-0.9505574107170105,
0.023848654702305794,
-0.19820347428321838,
1.0278949737548828,
-0.7101234197616577,
-0.5715686678886414,
-0.05279741436243057,
0.12101410329341888,
0.03024975210428238,
-0.3499285876750946,
0.4089409410953522,
-0.7347506880760193,
0.037153128534555435,
-0.3258318305015564,
-0.5193018317222595,
0.2459847331047058,
0.17352768778800964,
-0.7807881236076355,
0.6909889578819275,
-0.027139635756611824,
-0.39062461256980896,
0.2742778956890106,
-0.42779314517974854,
-0.7631208300590515,
0.20087175071239471,
-0.09434129297733307,
-0.41266974806785583,
0.22717566788196564,
0.5500116348266602,
0.5958135724067688,
-0.22583097219467163,
0.3510797917842865,
0.061923347413539886,
-0.5310342311859131,
0.17577584087848663,
-0.16816000640392303,
0.5156227350234985,
0.22522090375423431,
-0.1527125984430313,
0.2765757441520691,
-0.6182901263237,
0.005005436483770609,
-0.04611073061823845,
-0.2989860475063324,
-0.1728060096502304,
-0.2480347603559494,
-0.2430749237537384,
0.18319974839687347,
0.1309053599834442,
-0.2323950231075287,
0.5188302397727966,
-0.41839420795440674,
0.3037056624889374,
0.8231959939002991,
-0.26105865836143494,
0.5751497149467468,
-0.16639713943004608,
0.8780149817466736,
0.19683915376663208,
-0.03812754154205322,
-1.0690851211547852,
-0.3150436580181122,
-0.43084344267845154,
-0.4267781972885132,
0.5891213417053223,
0.5223545432090759,
-0.738784670829773,
0.42036470770835876,
-0.39736366271972656,
-0.39509326219558716,
-0.430673748254776,
-0.08154527097940445,
0.630265474319458,
0.6753690242767334,
0.5377997159957886,
-0.2361283302307129,
-0.6007894277572632,
-0.7752808332443237,
-0.34264010190963745,
-0.11790284514427185,
-0.16344577074050903,
0.1547243744134903,
0.07597944885492325,
-0.10285884141921997,
1.1577240228652954,
-0.722955048084259,
-0.11723147332668304,
-0.24115560948848724,
0.3270306885242462,
0.32496562600135803,
0.6534619331359863,
0.4165725111961365,
-0.6629618406295776,
-0.4077918827533722,
-0.5249068737030029,
0.04351494833827019,
-0.3596600294113159,
-0.23698870837688446,
-0.15965348482131958,
0.33329591155052185,
0.7529915571212769,
-0.9120942950248718,
0.4977115988731384,
0.6256392598152161,
-0.28578293323516846,
0.9981475472450256,
-0.2859090268611908,
0.1787523329257965,
-0.8584479689598083,
0.041155628859996796,
-0.3992907404899597,
-0.12341087311506271,
-0.6090460419654846,
-0.17657393217086792,
0.18567916750907898,
-0.08960048109292984,
-0.6304747462272644,
0.7547792196273804,
-0.597896933555603,
0.037253573536872864,
-0.19773997366428375,
-0.17285612225532532,
0.4362875819206238,
0.38599151372909546,
0.06490941345691681,
0.9877989888191223,
0.23242701590061188,
-0.7554710507392883,
0.09845440089702606,
0.13533498346805573,
-0.4026428461074829,
0.22689734399318695,
-0.6642850041389465,
0.2864146828651428,
-0.24206456542015076,
0.7054231762886047,
-1.0982204675674438,
-0.08554697036743164,
-0.01467812154442072,
-0.2705255448818207,
0.5344706773757935,
-0.34929320216178894,
-0.41822588443756104,
-0.45822805166244507,
-0.31338992714881897,
0.9689490795135498,
0.6978932619094849,
-0.45642659068107605,
0.7761286497116089,
0.15237879753112793,
-0.27163439989089966,
-0.70530104637146,
-0.5350058674812317,
-0.14459630846977234,
-0.4172799289226532,
-0.6371920704841614,
0.671730101108551,
-0.2388475388288498,
0.14823411405086517,
-0.27440690994262695,
-0.09177359938621521,
0.1971505880355835,
-0.024589747190475464,
0.038137562572956085,
0.22176852822303772,
-0.27688878774642944,
0.27507367730140686,
-0.04971475899219513,
-0.5009342432022095,
-0.17069339752197266,
-0.42786264419555664,
0.9300209283828735,
-0.05614539235830307,
-0.25237536430358887,
-0.018192263320088387,
0.3454258441925049,
0.448869526386261,
-0.4008340537548065,
0.7598790526390076,
0.3622244894504547,
-0.24016770720481873,
-0.1345471292734146,
-0.8994879722595215,
-0.3940865397453308,
-0.5536810755729675,
0.19917409121990204,
-0.7429558634757996,
-0.8785227537155151,
0.5784448981285095,
-0.24322043359279633,
0.08414867520332336,
0.12267859280109406,
0.225372314453125,
-0.052506573498249054,
0.5641503930091858,
0.6056315898895264,
-0.17167755961418152,
0.38644635677337646,
0.09176306426525116,
0.5853187441825867,
-0.4090346097946167,
0.00955831166356802,
-0.6913431882858276,
-0.3350169062614441,
-0.5454561114311218,
-0.8328564763069153,
-0.010743227787315845,
0.35953837633132935,
-0.2832227349281311,
0.3180418312549591,
-0.40822407603263855,
0.8451125621795654,
0.503614068031311,
-0.1901780217885971,
0.19113999605178833,
-0.008282407186925411,
-0.08439286798238754,
0.05960221216082573,
-0.6849724650382996,
-0.2787836194038391,
1.0087757110595703,
-0.006281611043959856,
0.6195104718208313,
-0.3994375169277191,
0.5706555843353271,
-0.11261946707963943,
0.19626033306121826,
-0.6384301781654358,
0.5361151099205017,
-0.2146284580230713,
-0.3510856330394745,
-0.362142413854599,
-0.15265905857086182,
-0.9280837774276733,
-0.10793370753526688,
-0.15123289823532104,
-0.838955283164978,
0.14184236526489258,
0.6883121132850647,
-0.773033082485199,
0.14160801470279694,
-0.6817841529846191,
0.8923923373222351,
-0.14113441109657288,
-0.1529441475868225,
0.047238513827323914,
-0.8727777600288391,
0.2814261317253113,
-0.1899491399526596,
0.12997817993164062,
0.07126206159591675,
0.1608896255493164,
0.7177267074584961,
-0.3909219205379486,
0.6685799360275269,
-0.11939340829849243,
0.004556759726256132,
0.19103500247001648,
-0.021233581006526947,
0.7794947028160095,
-0.2081640511751175,
0.16721199452877045,
-0.011341392993927002,
0.004481521900743246,
-0.5569164156913757,
-0.7492648959159851,
0.32661694288253784,
-0.43761542439460754,
-0.8193938136100769,
-0.10625192523002625,
-0.36147210001945496,
-0.30977439880371094,
0.2374001294374466,
0.587231457233429,
0.6136118769645691,
-0.08877560496330261,
0.08838855475187302,
0.8603944778442383,
-0.5285841822624207,
0.506604790687561,
0.21220536530017853,
-0.3144109845161438,
-0.13672906160354614,
0.7706874012947083,
0.16369940340518951,
0.2669713497161865,
0.5750268697738647,
0.27450031042099,
-0.3486484885215759,
-0.38428306579589844,
-0.21272924542427063,
0.331298828125,
-0.4904838800430298,
-0.29348209500312805,
-0.8882948160171509,
-0.12166205048561096,
-0.6199873089790344,
-0.5766320824623108,
-0.5940647721290588,
-0.2909979522228241,
0.0031318264082074165,
-0.03642448037862778,
0.33811524510383606,
0.1464611291885376,
0.05662580206990242,
0.8915419578552246,
-0.9771392345428467,
0.4022800326347351,
0.15505409240722656,
0.3506743609905243,
-0.035436924546957016,
-0.17617067694664001,
-0.24135518074035645,
-0.07434138655662537,
0.06094123423099518,
-0.6703835129737854,
0.3913487493991852,
-0.10723935067653656,
0.3034687638282776,
0.5552099347114563,
0.3102288842201233,
1.1430654525756836,
-0.6616086959838867,
0.6116868257522583,
-0.0558047778904438,
-0.9420747756958008,
0.44805821776390076,
-0.13300035893917084,
0.7713610529899597,
0.612817645072937,
0.3103574514389038,
-0.42970025539398193,
0.021515045315027237,
-0.6480696797370911,
-1.25133216381073,
0.5210976004600525,
-0.048409637063741684,
0.060723938047885895,
-0.13210923969745636,
0.2053266316652298,
-0.017457395792007446,
0.26576754450798035,
-0.2461397349834442,
-0.06973013281822205,
0.027478909119963646,
-0.01116306520998478,
-0.692200243473053,
-0.6299189925193787,
-0.04763033986091614,
-0.32004880905151367,
0.5606396198272705,
-0.18808409571647644,
0.2709498405456543,
0.002364030573517084,
-0.35854825377464294,
0.22842364013195038,
0.37184327840805054,
0.8980227708816528,
0.5182749629020691,
-0.1433231383562088,
0.2261955738067627,
0.025029979646205902,
-0.6390516757965088,
0.135160431265831,
0.23015251755714417,
0.1078856810927391,
-0.09734208136796951,
0.4182177782058716,
0.8783098459243774,
0.35553163290023804,
-0.8051344752311707,
0.4527878165245056,
-0.1630520075559616,
0.2020532339811325,
-0.15817095339298248,
-0.23721902072429657,
0.18330009281635284,
-0.03457340598106384,
0.18488280475139618,
-0.13612645864486694,
-0.2326633334159851,
-0.25612539052963257,
0.23634205758571625,
0.21387304365634918,
0.07809806615114212,
-0.33595648407936096,
0.250598281621933,
0.13606275618076324,
-0.311562180519104,
0.9336666464805603,
0.15124009549617767,
-0.535923182964325,
0.629779577255249,
0.5842457413673401,
0.8875417113304138,
-0.5601736307144165,
0.008913187310099602,
0.33762744069099426,
0.18526820838451385,
-0.17642243206501007,
-0.017959481105208397,
-0.3675568401813507,
-0.7843084335327148,
-0.7893718481063843,
-0.9146950840950012,
-0.006324764806777239,
0.28384700417518616,
-0.41733795404434204,
0.3438267409801483,
-0.12378275394439697,
-0.13821901381015778,
-0.27979931235313416,
-0.09949786216020584,
-0.8736172914505005,
0.24171662330627441,
-0.0542990081012249,
1.1371701955795288,
-0.8870483040809631,
0.7235336899757385,
0.37407299876213074,
0.16667082905769348,
-1.012734055519104,
0.12728023529052734,
-0.09605798125267029,
-0.5195597410202026,
0.568867564201355,
0.631852388381958,
-0.11366517841815948,
0.1590775102376938,
-0.36036595702171326,
-0.9199966192245483,
0.7239581346511841,
0.32819411158561707,
-0.7147691249847412,
-0.2383558303117752,
0.2955366373062134,
0.25490325689315796,
-0.5176779627799988,
0.2427593171596527,
1.0279778242111206,
0.6895039081573486,
0.21801283955574036,
-0.5872030854225159,
0.2722080945968628,
-0.34351128339767456,
-0.07878737151622772,
0.10039990395307541,
-0.14288504421710968,
0.766280472278595,
-0.0865667462348938,
-0.21806345880031586,
-0.06108874827623367,
0.5548480749130249,
0.7078961133956909,
0.0028345121536403894,
0.663699746131897,
0.58298659324646,
0.7340928912162781,
-0.08908871561288834,
1.1509766578674316,
-0.37294214963912964,
-0.2937856614589691,
1.2231841087341309,
-0.12205575406551361,
0.6188318729400635,
0.66804438829422,
-0.07078118622303009,
0.3815273940563202,
0.6304235458374023,
0.4016598165035248,
0.4449995458126068,
0.570483922958374,
-0.18765835464000702,
-0.23194050788879395,
0.15875135362148285,
-0.41898852586746216,
0.26447346806526184,
0.3382548391819,
-0.029846766963601112,
-0.08597546815872192,
0.023217489942908287,
0.17162440717220306,
-0.29749542474746704,
-0.016861148178577423,
0.5985429883003235,
0.13025131821632385,
-1.138758897781372,
0.4626871943473816,
-0.20680935680866241,
0.7130628824234009,
-0.6926950812339783,
0.11422350257635117,
-0.10815253108739853,
0.039917685091495514,
0.03064853884279728,
-0.5333035588264465,
0.1685234159231186,
-0.05107678845524788,
-0.23480439186096191,
-0.6162776350975037,
0.8078516125679016,
-0.3367464244365692,
-0.23571500182151794,
0.1061747744679451,
0.5150046944618225,
0.1269725263118744,
-0.36751431226730347,
-0.1338372677564621,
0.262808620929718,
-0.32831642031669617,
-0.8798247575759888,
0.380159467458725,
0.30379876494407654,
-0.2861294150352478,
0.5147634744644165,
1.048575758934021,
0.07571712881326675,
0.20484492182731628,
0.10504042357206345,
1.0122555494308472,
-0.5780126452445984,
-0.9969906210899353,
-1.1029071807861328,
1.042393445968628,
0.020635394379496574,
-0.1575874388217926,
0.44912654161453247,
0.36125046014785767,
0.8321396708488464,
-0.37028968334198,
0.4109652042388916,
0.1973521113395691,
0.05020438879728317,
-0.6455298066139221,
0.5856336951255798,
-0.19840046763420105,
0.2160215675830841,
-0.39141717553138733,
-0.9729260802268982,
-0.24840138852596283,
0.40848439931869507,
-0.4032149910926819,
-0.018621541559696198,
0.4729645550251007,
0.755795955657959,
-0.062250349670648575,
-0.15199795365333557,
0.3191395401954651,
0.19532878696918488,
0.3866748809814453,
0.3444962203502655,
0.6116988658905029,
-0.07223863899707794,
0.30044475197792053,
-0.27404966950416565,
-0.2321765124797821,
-0.20787544548511505,
-1.3790740966796875,
-0.7952016592025757,
-0.698846161365509,
0.020405489951372147,
-0.2583887577056885,
-0.050296150147914886,
0.8341144919395447,
1.1066505908966064,
-0.7290358543395996,
-0.04212257266044617,
-0.10296405106782913,
-0.05742728337645531,
0.019917596131563187,
-0.2254221886396408,
0.3370858430862427,
-0.4659897983074188,
-0.5692216753959656,
0.45969974994659424,
0.23068967461585999,
0.2564617097377777,
0.012933563441038132,
-0.03744673728942871,
-0.14163628220558167,
0.40960973501205444,
0.5348310470581055,
0.49960172176361084,
-0.5256001353263855,
-0.0482327863574028,
0.012168540619313717,
0.21299856901168823,
0.10919827967882156,
1.2645078897476196,
-1.3007017374038696,
0.45871615409851074,
0.6440566182136536,
0.8743996620178223,
0.7479928135871887,
0.37068790197372437,
0.9939444065093994,
-1.0663642883300781,
0.5821561813354492,
0.18258480727672577,
0.21799197793006897,
0.1372852772474289,
-0.47933751344680786,
0.17805171012878418,
-0.09420992434024811,
-0.4528540372848511,
-0.9351456165313721,
0.5379760265350342,
-0.8786116242408752,
-0.45676058530807495,
0.6338263154029846,
-0.41708439588546753,
-0.19700179994106293,
0.06785821914672852,
-0.09514960646629333,
0.32504209876060486,
-0.27851444482803345,
0.621241569519043,
0.8691433668136597,
0.12068196386098862,
-0.23229217529296875,
-0.238469198346138,
0.8680245876312256,
0.3965584933757782,
-0.8154898285865784,
0.0961848646402359,
0.1594192236661911,
-0.08081279695034027,
0.41023382544517517,
0.8823585510253906,
-0.03088018298149109,
0.13353689014911652,
-0.20708690583705902,
-0.19775916635990143,
-0.2550763785839081,
-0.725683867931366,
-0.2229890525341034,
0.20293237268924713,
-0.34055471420288086,
0.09100264310836792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09516v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09516v1
|
State Space Model for New-Generation Network Alternative to Transformers: A Survey
| 2024-04-15T07:24:45 | 2024-04-15T07:24:45 |
Xiao Wang, Shiao Wang, Yuhe Ding, Yuehang Li, Wentao Wu, Yao Rong, Weizhe Kong, Ju Huang, Shihao Li, Haoxiang Yang, Ziwen Wang, Bo Jiang, Chenglong Li, Yaowei Wang, Yonghong Tian, Jin Tang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM
|
In the post-deep learning era, the Transformer architecture has demonstrated
its powerful performance across pre-trained big models and various downstream
tasks. However, the enormous computational demands of this architecture have
deterred many researchers. To further reduce the complexity of attention
models, numerous efforts have been made to design more efficient methods. Among
them, the State Space Model (SSM), as a possible replacement for the
self-attention based Transformer model, has drawn more and more attention in
recent years. In this paper, we give the first comprehensive review of these
works and also provide experimental comparisons and analysis to better
demonstrate the features and advantages of SSM. Specifically, we first give a
detailed description of principles to help the readers quickly capture the key
ideas of SSM. After that, we dive into the reviews of existing SSMs and their
various applications, including natural language processing, computer vision,
graph, multi-modal and multi-media, point cloud/event stream, time series data,
and other domains. In addition, we give statistical comparisons and analysis of
these models and hope it helps the readers to understand the effectiveness of
different structures on various tasks. Then, we propose possible research
points in this direction to better promote the development of the theoretical
model and application of SSM. More related works will be continuously updated
on the following GitHub:
https://github.com/Event-AHU/Mamba_State_Space_Model_Paper_List.
|
[
-0.6364662051200867,
-0.5499172210693359,
0.4325588643550873,
0.016612326726317406,
-0.2677770256996155,
-0.09662042558193207,
0.0681687518954277,
-0.2867651581764221,
0.5477026700973511,
0.42559003829956055,
-0.4182470440864563,
-0.15045544505119324,
-0.6175186038017273,
0.04520946368575096,
-0.8052428364753723,
0.48363611102104187,
-0.2890394926071167,
-0.1850300133228302,
-0.2924838364124298,
0.006932738237082958,
-0.46255791187286377,
-0.4869767129421234,
-0.6958299279212952,
-0.33917322754859924,
0.3254646360874176,
-0.1037459671497345,
0.5625870823860168,
0.2878093421459198,
0.6799697875976562,
0.4485687017440796,
-0.34749534726142883,
0.09289724379777908,
-0.3986353874206543,
-0.001220579375512898,
-0.07603688538074493,
-0.31565967202186584,
-0.4473195970058441,
0.2086547464132309,
0.9869297742843628,
0.6537067294120789,
-0.13780122995376587,
0.14241361618041992,
0.015424460172653198,
0.8550192713737488,
-0.6510537266731262,
0.24806776642799377,
-0.6857147216796875,
0.3793993294239044,
0.05193324014544487,
-0.10584352910518646,
-0.4333367645740509,
-0.47346439957618713,
0.08115599304437637,
-0.5102564096450806,
0.274157851934433,
-0.010096963495016098,
0.8708363771438599,
0.574081540107727,
-0.648505687713623,
0.13708597421646118,
-1.0967999696731567,
0.6066538095474243,
-0.6196196675300598,
0.5117661356925964,
-0.2574814260005951,
0.5749645233154297,
-0.2116072177886963,
-0.7121581435203552,
-0.7518953680992126,
-0.14613769948482513,
0.11846770346164703,
0.4273799955844879,
-0.6049345135688782,
-0.10849220305681229,
-0.03986253961920738,
0.7003350257873535,
-0.188258096575737,
0.07248473167419434,
-0.3374001085758209,
0.055080026388168335,
0.388279527425766,
0.40168729424476624,
-0.03015953302383423,
-0.6529178023338318,
-0.905175507068634,
0.05244232714176178,
-0.7155037522315979,
0.11368158459663391,
0.37334075570106506,
0.36748450994491577,
-0.02109997533261776,
0.6083499789237976,
-0.44352176785469055,
0.5762078762054443,
0.10043799877166748,
0.3343045115470886,
0.21533606946468353,
-0.4718276262283325,
-0.3152569532394409,
-0.3114882707595825,
0.8614782094955444,
0.24442224204540253,
-0.09953423589468002,
-0.1647258996963501,
0.013608621433377266,
0.12327474355697632,
0.8137418627738953,
-0.7577189803123474,
-0.09557782858610153,
-0.07661572843790054,
-0.9377173185348511,
-0.14484012126922607,
-0.09354125708341599,
-0.640084445476532,
-0.44503891468048096,
-0.42336776852607727,
0.22965626418590546,
-0.36739638447761536,
-0.6198152899742126,
-0.030908025801181793,
0.1600389927625656,
0.3261227011680603,
0.30035993456840515,
-0.29529106616973877,
0.4002222418785095,
0.5315880179405212,
1.1519291400909424,
-0.49586719274520874,
-0.001623455435037613,
0.13924540579319,
-0.2767721116542816,
-0.31962820887565613,
0.8501724004745483,
-0.3186614215373993,
-0.4367985725402832,
-0.160944864153862,
0.19419145584106445,
-0.3088230788707733,
-0.26756852865219116,
0.32999733090400696,
-0.7300000786781311,
-0.026376033201813698,
-0.09082889556884766,
-0.7029808759689331,
-0.33083876967430115,
0.19516168534755707,
-0.9518212676048279,
0.7597636580467224,
0.1258762925863266,
-0.5139023661613464,
0.29135188460350037,
-0.894639790058136,
-0.4558289051055908,
0.015438351780176163,
0.1981731504201889,
-0.5196908712387085,
0.16732321679592133,
-0.08123837411403656,
0.608273446559906,
-0.22364167869091034,
0.2447422593832016,
-0.4611528515815735,
-0.1748264580965042,
0.18919862806797028,
-0.3578692376613617,
0.47929972410202026,
0.5397317409515381,
-0.15634343028068542,
0.16688546538352966,
-0.71529221534729,
-0.10752523690462112,
0.42478030920028687,
-0.3114398419857025,
-0.04770559445023537,
0.48898687958717346,
-0.1284674108028412,
0.373609334230423,
0.06998119503259659,
-0.7719325423240662,
0.03646478056907654,
-0.44704389572143555,
0.5588569045066833,
0.4075954258441925,
0.05498126894235611,
0.8165746927261353,
0.16125495731830597,
0.6881282925605774,
0.16298460960388184,
0.5326399207115173,
-0.3902519941329956,
-0.16345472633838654,
-0.7633271813392639,
0.06861560046672821,
0.2525063157081604,
0.2506992220878601,
-0.6538417339324951,
0.41790664196014404,
-0.3228164315223694,
-0.5483683347702026,
-0.3346007168292999,
-0.09745630621910095,
-0.13744348287582397,
0.39594796299934387,
0.5184109807014465,
-0.2191552072763443,
-0.653052031993866,
-0.9776014685630798,
0.04872078076004982,
0.08567491173744202,
0.46341052651405334,
0.26676806807518005,
0.44226229190826416,
-0.13628894090652466,
1.1404786109924316,
-0.4623364806175232,
-0.22055640816688538,
-0.6275890469551086,
-0.486567884683609,
0.1515669971704483,
0.2645532190799713,
0.35469818115234375,
-0.7301666736602783,
-0.11488817632198334,
-0.212558314204216,
-0.6342408657073975,
0.4223831295967102,
0.0749092847108841,
0.05240785703063011,
0.017435379326343536,
0.4039608836174011,
-0.7762991786003113,
0.732489287853241,
0.5708907842636108,
-0.05074673146009445,
0.3382493853569031,
0.12172827124595642,
0.21996915340423584,
-1.4351551532745361,
0.08920028805732727,
0.4026337265968323,
-0.013527719303965569,
-0.8228334784507751,
0.2395162284374237,
0.11931057274341583,
-0.5014203190803528,
-0.675420343875885,
0.4806196093559265,
-0.5714044570922852,
-0.08175382018089294,
-0.733343243598938,
0.07862240821123123,
-0.18853719532489777,
0.5453697443008423,
-0.1484099179506302,
0.5208284854888916,
0.32023951411247253,
-0.721471905708313,
0.2321823239326477,
0.3061206638813019,
-0.4749632179737091,
0.25577500462532043,
-0.7148526906967163,
-0.05088911950588226,
-0.10842305421829224,
0.5292497873306274,
-1.3877413272857666,
0.1792478859424591,
0.14885155856609344,
-0.2978144884109497,
0.25259315967559814,
-0.15261797606945038,
-0.47188279032707214,
-0.7548121809959412,
0.057393062859773636,
0.2593362629413605,
0.4678606390953064,
-0.6399281620979309,
0.6089809536933899,
0.7167608737945557,
0.2004901021718979,
-0.15929950773715973,
-0.4785509705543518,
0.31450846791267395,
-0.1429767906665802,
-0.5088016390800476,
0.3398140072822571,
0.2979414761066437,
0.16353139281272888,
0.11661319434642792,
-0.2575269639492035,
-0.015515701845288277,
0.3215300738811493,
0.4675176739692688,
0.40017592906951904,
-0.3130253255367279,
-0.05703039467334747,
-0.11804553121328354,
-0.46534988284111023,
-0.024572109803557396,
-0.3150254786014557,
0.575851559638977,
-0.3440997898578644,
-0.3880923390388489,
-0.5713199377059937,
0.22621893882751465,
0.3137184679508209,
-0.40572643280029297,
0.7437013387680054,
0.3863746225833893,
-0.3914179801940918,
-0.006790251471102238,
-0.41535434126853943,
-0.03840354084968567,
-0.46114227175712585,
0.49099108576774597,
-0.19326652586460114,
-1.0699080228805542,
0.3106577396392822,
-0.5349581837654114,
-0.007819335907697678,
0.5632630586624146,
0.42923587560653687,
-0.23929241299629211,
0.9354455471038818,
0.7939319610595703,
-0.2256527692079544,
0.6137348413467407,
-0.4731499254703522,
0.6158120632171631,
-1.096617341041565,
-0.12598426640033722,
-0.3697618246078491,
-0.6121866703033447,
-0.534292995929718,
-0.4088917374610901,
0.21703334152698517,
-0.0064715915359556675,
0.05661836639046669,
0.6646844148635864,
-0.49033185839653015,
0.28556233644485474,
0.08461347222328186,
-0.10217601805925369,
-0.024890076369047165,
-0.017436295747756958,
0.06051168590784073,
0.1738923192024231,
-0.996305525302887,
-0.5944125056266785,
0.883047342300415,
0.4748971164226532,
0.7640970945358276,
-0.034318387508392334,
0.34325820207595825,
0.014781187288463116,
0.34676483273506165,
-0.774613618850708,
0.7091088891029358,
-0.2994687557220459,
-0.6648276448249817,
-0.49049627780914307,
-0.48698508739471436,
-1.2108001708984375,
0.4935618042945862,
-0.17146572470664978,
-0.6115754246711731,
0.17122283577919006,
0.20960672199726105,
-0.3283747732639313,
0.827764093875885,
-0.7050358057022095,
0.574191153049469,
0.08637367933988571,
-0.106387659907341,
-0.27235886454582214,
-0.4558919072151184,
0.4597008228302002,
0.1696748435497284,
-0.22873301804065704,
-0.13008274137973785,
0.16136057674884796,
0.499449223279953,
-0.4496675431728363,
0.867265522480011,
-0.45541343092918396,
0.04093625396490097,
0.6112501621246338,
-0.05610004812479019,
0.35600748658180237,
-0.23570959270000458,
-0.1238240972161293,
0.4280531704425812,
-0.3130480945110321,
-0.0746622234582901,
-0.47347113490104675,
0.6342836618423462,
-0.7245169281959534,
-0.5616207718849182,
-0.09571269899606705,
-0.44429123401641846,
-0.16077299416065216,
0.3347977101802826,
-0.015086322091519833,
0.5579515695571899,
-0.29085126519203186,
0.7137740850448608,
0.5646531581878662,
-0.22591131925582886,
0.6514750123023987,
0.29299411177635193,
-0.1622823029756546,
-0.0916113331913948,
0.55865079164505,
0.15748904645442963,
0.10372316092252731,
0.5473894476890564,
-0.049474701285362244,
-0.5969840288162231,
-0.5459930300712585,
-0.28804874420166016,
-0.0776732936501503,
-0.5073095560073853,
-0.21419762074947357,
-0.843930184841156,
-0.576433002948761,
-0.2928272485733032,
0.3030743896961212,
-0.7238168120384216,
-0.3264106214046478,
-0.21160949766635895,
-0.1638915240764618,
0.06104973331093788,
0.6238770484924316,
0.3724222183227539,
0.5403478145599365,
-0.21144840121269226,
0.51358562707901,
0.00747893750667572,
0.6199076771736145,
0.4648863971233368,
-0.33731788396835327,
-0.2553075850009918,
-0.25067687034606934,
-0.6350075006484985,
-0.9594952464103699,
0.11925870925188065,
-0.0704575926065445,
0.8914346694946289,
0.24836204946041107,
-0.19780205190181732,
0.5771406888961792,
-0.7636753916740417,
0.7729450464248657,
0.5529724359512329,
-0.7255727052688599,
0.5197073221206665,
-0.11112623661756516,
0.36661210656166077,
0.358531653881073,
0.23018646240234375,
-0.5489072799682617,
-0.24641644954681396,
-0.5508615970611572,
-0.7726982235908508,
0.5536408424377441,
0.30031585693359375,
0.2377166450023651,
0.006175992079079151,
0.5260381698608398,
-0.045208271592855453,
0.2399968057870865,
-0.6904429197311401,
-0.4531017243862152,
-0.5996888279914856,
-0.04626786336302757,
-0.1799052357673645,
-0.0028478254098445177,
0.3426589071750641,
-0.1879069060087204,
0.5706170201301575,
-0.15162774920463562,
0.6517786383628845,
0.11404193192720413,
-0.17669491469860077,
-0.01612703502178192,
0.41158148646354675,
0.27559134364128113,
0.6090287566184998,
0.31434863805770874,
0.08509790152311325,
0.4691954553127289,
-0.21748757362365723,
0.5206298828125,
0.08057277649641037,
-0.41600650548934937,
0.04884647950530052,
-0.15265807509422302,
1.162935495376587,
0.4911624491214752,
0.17945925891399384,
0.5343266129493713,
-0.03460361436009407,
-0.5046623945236206,
-0.3255039155483246,
0.40828052163124084,
0.254475474357605,
0.36991021037101746,
0.2696235179901123,
0.4828786849975586,
0.23643945157527924,
-0.15569175779819489,
-0.16488878428936005,
0.5693992972373962,
-0.5260363817214966,
-0.30691736936569214,
0.840433657169342,
0.21527881920337677,
-0.42521822452545166,
0.3396453857421875,
-0.05697571486234665,
-0.3274253010749817,
0.5981048345565796,
0.5287721157073975,
0.7863072156906128,
-0.27222079038619995,
0.3308550715446472,
0.3251429796218872,
0.5181224942207336,
0.10284323990345001,
0.1011032834649086,
-0.05482719466090202,
-0.8972645998001099,
-0.5431999564170837,
-0.5829483866691589,
-0.2078544944524765,
0.4259023070335388,
-0.5821630358695984,
-0.06079486757516861,
-0.5322587490081787,
-0.6509609818458557,
-0.1623603105545044,
0.052640292793512344,
-0.8338294625282288,
0.2760143578052521,
0.2164701670408249,
1.1315810680389404,
-0.6395580172538757,
0.6923310160636902,
0.6676245331764221,
-0.0883730798959732,
-0.7291807532310486,
-0.22779732942581177,
-0.17073902487754822,
-0.4317300617694855,
0.2523559629917145,
0.08197618275880814,
-0.2783683240413666,
-0.05812397599220276,
-0.30975601077079773,
-1.2518357038497925,
1.188281536102295,
0.0936906635761261,
-0.590879499912262,
0.14668425917625427,
0.037112459540367126,
0.5535675883293152,
-0.16783249378204346,
0.08103615790605545,
0.1822967678308487,
0.2623418867588043,
-0.07376092672348022,
-0.19958066940307617,
0.001452301163226366,
-0.49632200598716736,
0.5215227007865906,
0.5232104063034058,
-1.0635696649551392,
0.7479482889175415,
-0.027177393436431885,
-0.42281457781791687,
0.16110461950302124,
1.2220455408096313,
0.13467732071876526,
0.19920091331005096,
1.0167721509933472,
0.3822167217731476,
0.4060119390487671,
-0.17756961286067963,
0.9767714738845825,
-0.37894386053085327,
0.4469302296638489,
0.9778397679328918,
-0.5456098914146423,
0.7677923440933228,
0.5734868049621582,
-0.40234023332595825,
0.4118054509162903,
0.5789488554000854,
-0.3181646764278412,
0.4517129957675934,
0.1614881306886673,
0.28307998180389404,
-0.12148549407720566,
0.19773520529270172,
-0.3628592789173126,
0.29438838362693787,
-0.047052670270204544,
-0.1585964560508728,
-0.2526645362377167,
-0.027629999443888664,
-0.32322850823402405,
-0.17081989347934723,
-0.35531240701675415,
0.5502288341522217,
0.20849548280239105,
-0.3974018692970276,
-0.036961447447538376,
0.13972263038158417,
0.592178225517273,
-0.5663164854049683,
0.2234935760498047,
-0.26868727803230286,
0.12515032291412354,
-0.17051757872104645,
-0.6548788547515869,
0.3554011881351471,
0.12645813822746277,
-0.4152856767177582,
-0.23590189218521118,
1.023450493812561,
0.1494545340538025,
-0.39546966552734375,
0.22426986694335938,
0.44240429997444153,
0.07589058578014374,
0.0813918262720108,
-0.7148187160491943,
-0.1528623253107071,
-0.31358063220977783,
-0.4470277726650238,
0.08605143427848816,
-0.04759722203016281,
0.12474248558282852,
0.783558189868927,
0.6769295930862427,
0.05186625197529793,
0.40761151909828186,
0.298833966255188,
0.6117801070213318,
-0.6063068509101868,
-0.936244547367096,
-0.6016981601715088,
0.3732535243034363,
-0.2087145447731018,
-0.29878973960876465,
0.9372110366821289,
0.5092414021492004,
0.6793426871299744,
-0.013685167767107487,
0.7915536165237427,
0.05081476271152496,
0.4026039242744446,
-0.3885452151298523,
0.6662365794181824,
-0.7041594386100769,
-0.22251896560192108,
-0.3433153033256531,
-1.000618577003479,
0.12597538530826569,
0.5429138541221619,
-0.3659915328025818,
0.292940229177475,
0.7448471784591675,
0.557847261428833,
-0.19406481087207794,
0.5778185129165649,
0.18955309689044952,
0.08207888901233673,
0.23830550909042358,
0.3807361423969269,
1.4318269491195679,
-0.5339711904525757,
0.598045289516449,
-0.018908808007836342,
0.05279819294810295,
-0.2926520109176636,
-0.7391636371612549,
-0.6580905914306641,
-0.818705677986145,
-0.30915671586990356,
-0.004189865663647652,
-0.4723361134529114,
0.45753130316734314,
1.1496124267578125,
-0.6260156035423279,
-0.018718259409070015,
-0.09099889546632767,
0.05537130683660507,
-0.19057869911193848,
-0.1804548054933548,
0.18057438731193542,
-0.16809295117855072,
-0.4309515655040741,
0.5894766449928284,
0.33231619000434875,
0.047019585967063904,
-0.515422523021698,
-0.018914086744189262,
-0.13981036841869354,
0.08238374441862106,
0.7867832183837891,
-0.025979256257414818,
-0.6436353325843811,
-0.08627782016992569,
0.13716675341129303,
-0.09300967305898666,
0.2317476123571396,
0.9788011908531189,
-0.6896635890007019,
0.06642761081457138,
0.3915182650089264,
0.7503354549407959,
0.6942518353462219,
-0.08172234147787094,
0.13809530436992645,
-0.45657333731651306,
-0.1285199224948883,
-0.1407671570777893,
0.6977344155311584,
0.2906655967235565,
-0.36418700218200684,
0.4353695213794708,
0.12786495685577393,
-0.33588239550590515,
-0.5283957123756409,
0.22999553382396698,
-0.9471041560173035,
-0.39369770884513855,
0.955983579158783,
0.10411328822374344,
-0.4249723553657532,
0.18000291287899017,
-0.01033036969602108,
0.6002223491668701,
-0.046341005712747574,
0.8261287808418274,
0.4868369400501251,
-0.08058859407901764,
-0.21510781347751617,
-0.5252985954284668,
0.0157423447817564,
0.33718615770339966,
-1.0263539552688599,
-0.19286876916885376,
0.1464826911687851,
0.2537650763988495,
0.12452859431505203,
0.49126777052879333,
-0.3047926723957062,
0.07546082139015198,
-0.24619677662849426,
0.15776342153549194,
-0.2604215145111084,
-0.6439440846443176,
-0.6518137454986572,
0.49285101890563965,
-0.48113372921943665,
-0.44324997067451477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09492v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09492v1
|
Bridging the Gap between Different Vocabularies for LLM Ensemble
| 2024-04-15T06:28:20 | 2024-04-15T06:28:20 |
Yangyifan Xu, Jinliang Lu, Jiajun Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Ensembling different large language models (LLMs) to unleash their
complementary potential and harness their individual strengths is highly
valuable. Nevertheless, vocabulary discrepancies among various LLMs have
constrained previous studies to either selecting or blending completely
generated outputs. This limitation hinders the dynamic correction and
enhancement of outputs during the generation process, resulting in a limited
capacity for effective ensemble. To address this issue, we propose a novel
method to Ensemble LLMs via Vocabulary Alignment (EVA). EVA bridges the lexical
gap among various LLMs, enabling meticulous ensemble at each generation step.
Specifically, we first learn mappings between the vocabularies of different
LLMs with the assistance of overlapping tokens. Subsequently, these mappings
are employed to project output distributions of LLMs into a unified space,
facilitating a fine-grained ensemble. Finally, we design a filtering strategy
to exclude models that generate unfaithful tokens. Experimental results on
commonsense reasoning, arithmetic reasoning, machine translation, and
data-to-text generation tasks demonstrate the superiority of our approach
compared with individual LLMs and previous ensemble methods conducted on
complete outputs. Further analyses confirm that our approach can leverage
knowledge from different language models and yield consistent improvement.
|
[
-0.4156346321105957,
-0.5776694416999817,
0.4377914071083069,
-0.043192241340875626,
-0.18324977159500122,
0.8677176237106323,
-0.37791407108306885,
-0.427956759929657,
0.2827397286891937,
0.5986292958259583,
-0.3716844916343689,
-0.5234312415122986,
-0.5060005187988281,
0.028189396485686302,
-0.38447433710098267,
0.7220405340194702,
-0.10401230305433273,
-0.023397749289870262,
-0.4397617280483246,
0.00622407253831625,
-0.5849998593330383,
-0.18797317147254944,
-0.37206268310546875,
-0.4724314212799072,
0.33897584676742554,
0.3504181504249573,
0.43951526284217834,
0.5546987056732178,
0.3489850163459778,
0.3946560025215149,
-0.007734798826277256,
0.8886771202087402,
-0.4645857512950897,
0.2668967545032501,
-0.2740241289138794,
-0.32751035690307617,
-0.39187973737716675,
-0.3810938596725464,
0.6692476272583008,
0.6409363746643066,
-0.21491138637065887,
0.08213245868682861,
0.3745361864566803,
0.3952392339706421,
-0.7304041981697083,
-0.4082419276237488,
-1.2509595155715942,
-0.11132955551147461,
-0.4666370749473572,
-0.20755690336227417,
-0.3685968816280365,
0.0867379829287529,
-0.2313622534275055,
-0.5577442646026611,
0.08641158044338226,
0.14132535457611084,
0.8923019766807556,
0.24889792501926422,
-0.029588939622044563,
0.03926144167780876,
-0.6205772757530212,
0.8863219022750854,
-0.6540958285331726,
0.20970995724201202,
0.0018362770788371563,
0.009926702827215195,
-0.25955814123153687,
-0.5220558047294617,
-0.785554051399231,
0.3298627436161041,
0.09094163775444031,
0.17470069229602814,
-0.26249247789382935,
0.1755361109972,
-0.3534756600856781,
0.23861835896968842,
-0.3892737627029419,
0.6543762683868408,
-0.3375527560710907,
-0.3252773582935333,
0.6507677435874939,
0.11029797792434692,
0.30635854601860046,
-0.1456853598356247,
-0.7040761113166809,
-0.2514948546886444,
-0.9298884272575378,
-0.2594763934612274,
0.564289391040802,
0.6035897731781006,
-0.06994602084159851,
0.6746194362640381,
0.2401823103427887,
0.5256880521774292,
0.09766069054603577,
0.07489656656980515,
0.15280961990356445,
-0.34611356258392334,
-0.2951965928077698,
0.2451399564743042,
0.7994647026062012,
0.27879828214645386,
-0.036115922033786774,
-0.22260132431983948,
-0.38574349880218506,
0.12048067152500153,
0.2108423262834549,
-0.23766325414180756,
0.12271282821893692,
0.4168556034564972,
0.08110366016626358,
-0.3843095004558563,
0.008867241442203522,
-1.074706792831421,
-0.1662091463804245,
-0.40976735949516296,
0.5575630068778992,
-0.2160336971282959,
-0.1537640243768692,
-0.0382511243224144,
-0.05247923359274864,
-0.04227340221405029,
0.15722188353538513,
-0.8780882954597473,
0.41198450326919556,
0.8913132548332214,
0.7574398517608643,
-0.24221296608448029,
-0.4122227132320404,
-0.7263789176940918,
0.28483712673187256,
-0.42873549461364746,
0.7012239098548889,
-0.7455815076828003,
-0.34720197319984436,
0.20503036677837372,
-0.2903195023536682,
-0.12287874519824982,
-0.45142313838005066,
0.2592380940914154,
-0.4600231647491455,
0.15935862064361572,
0.17975661158561707,
-0.8708776235580444,
0.06946747750043869,
-0.0007027633837424219,
-0.31553947925567627,
1.2704968452453613,
-0.02000316046178341,
-0.5310701727867126,
0.1772339940071106,
-0.2581872045993805,
-0.058241672813892365,
0.3582287132740021,
-0.4141853153705597,
-0.1031489148736,
0.228477343916893,
0.3476993143558502,
0.4790607690811157,
-0.14319190382957458,
0.2234848439693451,
-0.19487029314041138,
-0.17455561459064484,
0.15614768862724304,
-0.46824344992637634,
0.3713425397872925,
0.25213006138801575,
0.01688782125711441,
0.18508943915367126,
-0.6187345385551453,
0.07527603954076767,
-0.16610363125801086,
-0.263993501663208,
-0.6443242430686951,
-0.057991307228803635,
0.07284748554229736,
-0.12579287588596344,
0.5049038529396057,
-0.42225295305252075,
0.36127763986587524,
-0.5723793506622314,
0.3368314802646637,
0.9734865427017212,
-0.22154858708381653,
0.6790087819099426,
-0.42175865173339844,
0.48288628458976746,
0.006337625440210104,
-0.39750558137893677,
-0.05829939246177673,
-0.14933988451957703,
-0.6733896732330322,
-0.4423820972442627,
0.6322211623191833,
0.5020607113838196,
-0.7579112648963928,
0.8866005539894104,
-0.5448410511016846,
-0.5031474232673645,
-0.709692656993866,
0.4100339114665985,
0.3372739553451538,
0.34477293491363525,
0.25610578060150146,
-0.3048713505268097,
-0.5942509770393372,
-0.5950428247451782,
-0.11313540488481522,
-0.24550525844097137,
-0.11798158288002014,
0.03906938061118126,
0.24715787172317505,
-0.07683949172496796,
0.8186876177787781,
-0.18773946166038513,
-0.19463291764259338,
-0.3612285852432251,
0.016522254794836044,
0.10491865873336792,
0.41211554408073425,
0.17153362929821014,
-0.5077818632125854,
-0.1389731615781784,
0.32668647170066833,
-0.3585277199745178,
-0.4031442105770111,
-0.25530704855918884,
-0.578220784664154,
0.20272570848464966,
0.5742419362068176,
-0.554031491279602,
0.06064273789525032,
0.6636027693748474,
-0.20790252089500427,
0.2794650197029114,
-0.2167341262102127,
-0.1020192950963974,
-1.36771821975708,
-0.29008063673973083,
-0.15195150673389435,
-0.20526115596294403,
-0.577767014503479,
0.09265664964914322,
-0.1253078132867813,
0.30779069662094116,
-0.45642590522766113,
0.906377375125885,
-0.502475380897522,
-0.12079747766256332,
-0.09075212478637695,
0.4169888496398926,
0.12052834033966064,
0.3062931001186371,
-0.13364087045192719,
0.5773290395736694,
0.6069411039352417,
-0.6031224131584167,
0.052767593413591385,
0.33313125371932983,
-0.2730238139629364,
0.32005178928375244,
-0.1777820885181427,
-0.07061365246772766,
-0.021380262449383736,
0.14025962352752686,
-0.9723067879676819,
-0.39951515197753906,
-0.03016149252653122,
-0.38793888688087463,
0.5606784224510193,
0.019106267020106316,
-0.3511313498020172,
-0.17955416440963745,
-0.2088461071252823,
0.45727866888046265,
0.6840744614601135,
-0.7791103720664978,
0.8099221587181091,
0.4777807295322418,
-0.2447635978460312,
-0.6826089024543762,
-0.5732662081718445,
0.11549845337867737,
-0.6321540474891663,
-0.6746941208839417,
0.7163641452789307,
0.34239277243614197,
-0.5496702194213867,
-0.08117733150720596,
-0.154811829328537,
0.17958015203475952,
0.044829729944467545,
0.032265082001686096,
0.5767681002616882,
-0.24658773839473724,
0.5096305012702942,
0.14726336300373077,
0.3612981140613556,
-0.3648943603038788,
-0.3144034445285797,
0.8542520403862,
0.06175721809267998,
-0.5232706665992737,
0.002625339897349477,
0.3381056487560272,
0.5267491936683655,
-0.336839884519577,
0.596325159072876,
0.4427606761455536,
-0.40474507212638855,
-0.5107074975967407,
-0.6348351836204529,
-0.09527357667684555,
-0.5076269507408142,
0.26550576090812683,
-0.13046737015247345,
-0.9552090764045715,
0.5781170129776001,
-0.080567866563797,
0.40831267833709717,
0.4421418309211731,
0.57668137550354,
-0.013452313840389252,
0.6909458041191101,
0.4354919195175171,
-0.15528737008571625,
0.31107038259506226,
-0.02731776237487793,
0.35604146122932434,
-1.0574309825897217,
0.01784696616232395,
-0.34217196702957153,
-0.41147342324256897,
-0.6630164980888367,
-0.6855369806289673,
0.26398488879203796,
0.37630271911621094,
-0.2227793186903,
0.21763761341571808,
-0.5702208876609802,
0.5466920137405396,
0.40945759415626526,
-0.1343027949333191,
0.24009516835212708,
0.3729762136936188,
-0.2052016407251358,
0.16085778176784515,
-0.8566461801528931,
-0.7455300092697144,
1.1430989503860474,
0.211834117770195,
0.6295630931854248,
0.28798407316207886,
1.1288987398147583,
0.10038397461175919,
0.13212241232395172,
-0.44240108132362366,
0.5440130233764648,
-0.32437872886657715,
-0.07375200092792511,
-0.4930015504360199,
-0.28334710001945496,
-1.0998742580413818,
0.5910181403160095,
-0.31875747442245483,
-1.0592684745788574,
0.0022099106572568417,
0.004452758003026247,
-0.579469621181488,
0.5651931762695312,
-0.6514555811882019,
0.4673203229904175,
-0.25293275713920593,
-0.6502098441123962,
-0.13627681136131287,
-0.4076165556907654,
0.5368668437004089,
-0.3031281530857086,
0.3781932592391968,
-0.20732560753822327,
-0.14304837584495544,
0.4874440133571625,
-0.5401107668876648,
0.8818401098251343,
0.28186044096946716,
-0.200700044631958,
0.4630562663078308,
0.1649615466594696,
0.44088831543922424,
-0.15936611592769623,
0.01670706458389759,
0.3775012493133545,
-0.2341822385787964,
-0.28951549530029297,
-0.37228402495384216,
0.8684616684913635,
-0.6190569400787354,
-0.7297545075416565,
-0.2111092507839203,
-0.5726380348205566,
-0.3609527051448822,
-0.03935509920120239,
0.2994602918624878,
0.2920958697795868,
-0.2768648564815521,
-0.15891389548778534,
0.3908143639564514,
-0.08678845316171646,
0.5756081342697144,
0.20718078315258026,
-0.26438331604003906,
-0.31969550251960754,
0.9726742506027222,
-0.014170274138450623,
0.4134349822998047,
0.5296406745910645,
0.03899569809436798,
-0.3806762993335724,
-0.4880039393901825,
-0.5191484093666077,
0.030644843354821205,
-0.38074442744255066,
-0.45615774393081665,
-0.48692798614501953,
-0.25652459263801575,
-0.50641930103302,
-0.3508055806159973,
-0.30977314710617065,
-0.3619333803653717,
-0.3239796757698059,
-0.06914566457271576,
0.47982123494148254,
0.4874279499053955,
-0.31611010432243347,
0.2741779088973999,
-0.9458965063095093,
-0.10508185625076294,
0.1959419697523117,
-0.07973652333021164,
0.14992420375347137,
-0.48093941807746887,
0.1281706541776657,
0.05252636596560478,
-0.5698161721229553,
-0.6562657952308655,
0.5611568689346313,
0.3693256080150604,
0.47812026739120483,
0.34272146224975586,
-0.11168598383665085,
0.9492698907852173,
-0.5701516270637512,
0.9489309787750244,
0.5135462880134583,
-1.0113084316253662,
0.33600759506225586,
-0.31115177273750305,
0.0912013053894043,
0.3287995457649231,
-0.22146740555763245,
-0.49881160259246826,
-0.6232737898826599,
-0.7592644691467285,
-1.2777105569839478,
0.21529115736484528,
0.38621681928634644,
0.19050884246826172,
-0.17084304988384247,
0.020239945501089096,
0.215048149228096,
0.11875183135271072,
-0.3886158764362335,
0.16715943813323975,
0.2275189906358719,
-0.5579465627670288,
-0.14168620109558105,
0.30666109919548035,
-0.2588459253311157,
-0.14073288440704346,
0.7395488023757935,
-0.21953526139259338,
-0.018816521391272545,
0.03661077842116356,
-0.00018475198885425925,
-0.24574632942676544,
0.36902284622192383,
0.37422269582748413,
0.318963885307312,
0.3781329095363617,
0.406482070684433,
0.43013477325439453,
-0.07696224004030228,
0.01580532267689705,
-0.051103346049785614,
0.17380762100219727,
0.017802098765969276,
0.543332576751709,
0.682861864566803,
0.3460364043712616,
-0.9168125987052917,
0.36968931555747986,
0.3173266351222992,
-0.14656876027584076,
-0.22712908685207367,
0.26974374055862427,
0.23028773069381714,
0.30888834595680237,
0.18444305658340454,
0.12496703118085861,
-0.3727804124355316,
-0.5234559774398804,
0.3091566264629364,
0.6328216791152954,
0.11769680678844452,
-0.096085324883461,
0.5079700350761414,
0.2436649352312088,
-0.30908048152923584,
0.43330323696136475,
-0.04067326337099075,
-0.4649653732776642,
0.7190209031105042,
0.35394319891929626,
0.7686978578567505,
-0.25878670811653137,
0.11742214113473892,
0.24048158526420593,
0.06431250274181366,
-0.29127946496009827,
0.035547055304050446,
-0.08935847878456116,
-1.138176441192627,
-0.4846099019050598,
-0.9724242687225342,
-0.25906598567962646,
0.25629332661628723,
-0.487318754196167,
0.358137309551239,
-0.014425154775381088,
0.14277991652488708,
0.015173322521150112,
-0.2292817234992981,
-0.694004237651825,
-0.2663317024707794,
0.31709548830986023,
0.7681049108505249,
-0.8387962579727173,
0.611984372138977,
0.4359915852546692,
-0.2164464145898819,
-0.8632971048355103,
0.09293708950281143,
0.01024249754846096,
-1.16217839717865,
0.36783701181411743,
-0.023879753425717354,
-0.06562836468219757,
-0.10123354196548462,
-0.41345083713531494,
-0.8685789108276367,
0.995815098285675,
0.06681279093027115,
-1.0302809476852417,
-0.052972979843616486,
0.1015264242887497,
0.567433774471283,
-0.7513973116874695,
-0.040366023778915405,
0.6011254787445068,
0.41113847494125366,
0.2851763069629669,
-0.8274418711662292,
-0.2765244245529175,
-0.04060377925634384,
-0.07388986647129059,
0.5512110590934753,
-0.5220158100128174,
0.6200003027915955,
-0.04334240406751633,
-0.4211476445198059,
0.3787825405597687,
0.6672279834747314,
0.5702305436134338,
0.22103159129619598,
0.6317669153213501,
0.7438680529594421,
1.0761271715164185,
-0.04276499152183533,
0.6287596225738525,
-0.2675798535346985,
0.029942290857434273,
1.2735769748687744,
-0.5397337079048157,
1.1000515222549438,
0.864637017250061,
-0.14036570489406586,
0.38379570841789246,
0.7522987127304077,
-0.11726387590169907,
0.3538859784603119,
0.5267162919044495,
-0.4408361315727234,
-0.5395606160163879,
-0.1458226442337036,
-0.1366899460554123,
0.5650618076324463,
0.5775499939918518,
-0.1041327565908432,
-0.30045652389526367,
-0.137112557888031,
-0.25819453597068787,
0.37570422887802124,
-0.4991811215877533,
0.7643512487411499,
-0.024814924225211143,
-0.9163328409194946,
0.49537596106529236,
-0.25511375069618225,
0.8317860960960388,
-0.3469699025154114,
-0.00698963413015008,
-0.10685355961322784,
0.0037458669394254684,
-0.25038477778434753,
-0.7683340907096863,
0.13337716460227966,
0.22771698236465454,
0.18796372413635254,
-0.14603029191493988,
0.635367751121521,
-0.8068272471427917,
-0.6427028179168701,
0.2149997055530548,
0.81954425573349,
0.34076881408691406,
0.5107277035713196,
-0.20687955617904663,
0.04844013601541519,
0.011868826113641262,
-0.0027305560652166605,
0.4204789400100708,
0.48798054456710815,
-0.1537252813577652,
0.3841724693775177,
0.5760622620582581,
0.3815692067146301,
0.10041996091604233,
0.17919199168682098,
0.6882719993591309,
-0.21058034896850586,
-0.3428008258342743,
-0.9649261236190796,
0.4909358322620392,
-0.1585630178451538,
-0.444191575050354,
0.48683446645736694,
0.4903641939163208,
0.9795915484428406,
0.22969643771648407,
0.7660154104232788,
0.17902621626853943,
0.2923213839530945,
-0.8214704990386963,
0.37072595953941345,
-0.7750728726387024,
0.6106898188591003,
-0.04997854307293892,
-0.982189416885376,
-0.07740476727485657,
0.36334991455078125,
0.10300880670547485,
-0.30365216732025146,
0.3349461257457733,
0.9903551936149597,
-0.15283729135990143,
-0.15375100076198578,
0.4695380628108978,
0.1945721060037613,
0.14902421832084656,
0.49107539653778076,
0.914530873298645,
-0.21058310568332672,
0.33076465129852295,
0.17637549340724945,
-0.021510468795895576,
-0.0033041054848581553,
-0.8321463465690613,
-0.6184298396110535,
-0.5926100611686707,
-0.20705018937587738,
-0.1891074925661087,
-0.020740486681461334,
1.0637556314468384,
0.4183737337589264,
-0.4245546758174896,
-0.2363342046737671,
-0.39932015538215637,
0.2664031684398651,
-0.21720270812511444,
-0.22506380081176758,
0.21323952078819275,
-0.41614648699760437,
-0.9715640544891357,
0.5359534025192261,
0.1800297349691391,
0.19358663260936737,
-0.5269437432289124,
-0.08600858598947525,
0.08350010216236115,
0.4600490629673004,
0.2302403599023819,
0.04343928396701813,
-1.0654431581497192,
-0.46248966455459595,
-0.14262434840202332,
0.05552172288298607,
0.12989993393421173,
0.4523000419139862,
-0.7694227695465088,
0.25394096970558167,
0.5277678370475769,
0.8157768249511719,
0.1052754670381546,
-0.11656839400529861,
0.6221482157707214,
-1.118790864944458,
-0.03804651275277138,
0.2544843256473541,
0.5913382172584534,
0.4184466004371643,
-0.392660915851593,
0.4046296775341034,
-0.14067813754081726,
-0.48727118968963623,
-1.1203123331069946,
0.23825675249099731,
-1.012205958366394,
-0.48642203211784363,
1.2474000453948975,
0.23839955031871796,
-0.22544358670711517,
0.19786974787712097,
-0.023136338219046593,
0.31197619438171387,
-0.42647498846054077,
0.866556704044342,
0.9699918031692505,
0.02908041700720787,
0.2625032365322113,
-0.15598678588867188,
0.12641173601150513,
0.5359899997711182,
-0.6712207198143005,
0.20774395763874054,
0.2623053193092346,
0.01575610600411892,
0.35105255246162415,
0.18945468962192535,
0.049524590373039246,
-0.057727355509996414,
-0.09465860575437546,
0.31579262018203735,
0.29334330558776855,
-0.17031171917915344,
-0.4216695725917816,
0.18281838297843933,
-0.23908165097236633,
-0.22484439611434937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09486v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09486v1
|
MMCode: Evaluating Multi-Modal Code Large Language Models with Visually Rich Programming Problems
| 2024-04-15T06:15:46 | 2024-04-15T06:15:46 |
Kaixin Li, Yuchen Tian, Qisheng Hu, Ziyang Luo, Jing Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.SE
|
Programming often involves converting detailed and complex specifications
into code, a process during which developers typically utilize visual aids to
more effectively convey concepts. While recent developments in Large Multimodal
Models have demonstrated remarkable abilities in visual reasoning and
mathematical tasks, there is little work on investigating whether these models
can effectively interpret visual elements for code generation. To this end, we
present MMCode, the first multi-modal coding dataset for evaluating algorithmic
problem-solving skills in visually rich contexts. MMCode contains 3,548
questions and 6,620 images collected from real-world programming challenges
harvested from 10 code competition websites, presenting significant challenges
due to the extreme demand for reasoning abilities. Our experiment results show
that current state-of-the-art models struggle to solve these problems. The
results highlight the lack of powerful vision-code models, and we hope MMCode
can serve as an inspiration for future works in this domain. The data and code
are publicly available at https://github.com/happylkx/MMCode.
|
[
-0.49182140827178955,
-0.5351605415344238,
0.554414689540863,
0.34246331453323364,
-0.16996359825134277,
-0.04235663264989853,
-0.07993727922439575,
-0.41383326053619385,
-0.1585281789302826,
0.42083117365837097,
-0.7333361506462097,
-0.43083301186561584,
-0.511624276638031,
0.24688281118869781,
-0.3929669260978699,
0.6795611381530762,
-0.021041030064225197,
0.1561892181634903,
-0.49687784910202026,
-0.007525649853050709,
-0.5578585863113403,
-0.6058399081230164,
0.10030030459165573,
0.3058041036128998,
0.2706560790538788,
0.598547101020813,
0.5504091382026672,
0.4316515028476715,
0.8238335251808167,
0.35440993309020996,
0.2860436737537384,
0.42638447880744934,
-0.44379922747612,
-0.0387505367398262,
0.16513806581497192,
-0.5164411664009094,
-0.2615499496459961,
0.03510269895195961,
0.2627730369567871,
0.6329625844955444,
0.15584301948547363,
0.46093741059303284,
-0.16726434230804443,
0.41060909628868103,
-0.6485669612884521,
0.577605664730072,
-0.4647296965122223,
0.08610541373491287,
0.09386903047561646,
-0.5323924422264099,
-0.5540862083435059,
-0.25369149446487427,
-0.2537238597869873,
-0.5248108506202698,
-0.07035977393388748,
0.0836922749876976,
0.4588642418384552,
0.18981985747814178,
-0.5881901979446411,
-0.6412811279296875,
-0.5915118455886841,
0.788849413394928,
-0.4879888594150543,
0.46908238530158997,
0.43678590655326843,
0.3547573387622833,
0.09648095816373825,
-0.4401649534702301,
-0.6551198363304138,
-0.4541046619415283,
0.41685381531715393,
0.09688199311494827,
-0.275683730840683,
-0.2456846833229065,
0.4384533166885376,
0.19096246361732483,
-0.606044590473175,
-0.17182372510433197,
-0.7068031430244446,
-0.0717238262295723,
0.543951690196991,
0.26025673747062683,
0.4069482684135437,
-0.45997464656829834,
-0.1298152208328247,
-0.19819355010986328,
-0.2708066701889038,
0.02569280005991459,
0.24562156200408936,
-0.13417081534862518,
-0.3926202058792114,
0.8567902445793152,
-0.28929173946380615,
0.7668543457984924,
-0.508177638053894,
-0.3182564079761505,
0.3879738450050354,
-0.5338425636291504,
-0.19500264525413513,
-0.4248563051223755,
0.42745932936668396,
0.7771698832511902,
0.4913399815559387,
0.1694273203611374,
-0.36646947264671326,
0.3894641399383545,
0.22423675656318665,
-0.8242596983909607,
-0.21392959356307983,
0.13427123427391052,
-0.6654232144355774,
-0.2567290663719177,
0.0977073386311531,
-0.7695478200912476,
-0.37643757462501526,
-0.3887535035610199,
0.31933286786079407,
-0.31655970215797424,
-0.17557024955749512,
0.33775681257247925,
-0.2503364682197571,
0.12880846858024597,
0.4244794249534607,
-0.47244229912757874,
-0.31451481580734253,
0.5050376653671265,
0.6762109994888306,
0.37633153796195984,
-0.4927788972854614,
-0.4921298027038574,
-0.0932011678814888,
-0.3876645863056183,
0.4538877308368683,
-0.8284627199172974,
-0.27355724573135376,
-0.019985007122159004,
-0.2458718717098236,
0.08802245557308197,
-0.6220560669898987,
0.27099373936653137,
-0.42427727580070496,
-0.11418107151985168,
-0.002237342530861497,
-0.1490674614906311,
0.043242424726486206,
0.33977335691452026,
-0.7509166598320007,
0.5444968938827515,
0.17953471839427948,
-0.5409047603607178,
0.2514297664165497,
-0.8249348998069763,
-0.141719251871109,
-0.11184057593345642,
-0.4211121201515198,
-0.24790337681770325,
0.3546350300312042,
0.2506617307662964,
0.4861201047897339,
-0.37081971764564514,
0.08055698871612549,
-0.4521373510360718,
-0.34139224886894226,
0.712814211845398,
-0.6006971001625061,
0.6458392143249512,
0.4760088324546814,
-0.22696302831172943,
0.19531001150608063,
-0.9375354647636414,
0.08754478394985199,
0.4605898857116699,
-0.38833051919937134,
-0.08276361972093582,
-0.11028197407722473,
0.1688155084848404,
0.5476745367050171,
0.09508971869945526,
-0.4054015874862671,
0.4650326669216156,
0.1444244384765625,
0.5582295656204224,
0.7074660658836365,
-0.20077428221702576,
0.07038255035877228,
-0.11207696050405502,
0.6441774368286133,
0.10595862567424774,
0.4862003028392792,
-0.5398343801498413,
-0.8167877793312073,
-0.623564600944519,
-0.15911877155303955,
0.18213869631290436,
0.5308961868286133,
-1.2427843809127808,
-0.1266019195318222,
-0.31467336416244507,
-0.19576267898082733,
-0.6185040473937988,
0.26745790243148804,
0.493451863527298,
0.15506522357463837,
0.24940019845962524,
-0.434509813785553,
-0.31819653511047363,
-0.8939975500106812,
0.21522922813892365,
0.20814591646194458,
0.0019651781767606735,
0.7716890573501587,
0.8356110453605652,
-0.6692792177200317,
0.7116156220436096,
-0.7258922457695007,
-0.1129356324672699,
-0.08193808048963547,
0.23114484548568726,
-0.023470787331461906,
0.5515492558479309,
0.5979892611503601,
-0.9159737229347229,
-0.08244705200195312,
0.06617537885904312,
-0.9085100889205933,
-0.2678912281990051,
-0.2533285915851593,
0.01556185632944107,
-0.050051700323820114,
0.48523539304733276,
-0.3336018919944763,
0.33913710713386536,
0.972319483757019,
-0.5009491443634033,
0.8699982166290283,
-0.35762277245521545,
0.6289874315261841,
-0.677321195602417,
0.1629582941532135,
0.1334693729877472,
-0.024985361844301224,
-0.28887221217155457,
0.5600285530090332,
0.20477145910263062,
-0.6563260555267334,
-0.29780763387680054,
0.180461123585701,
-0.6156710386276245,
-0.27858054637908936,
-0.08667507022619247,
-0.21825700998306274,
-0.012746911495923996,
0.7033730745315552,
-0.2962297797203064,
0.920447051525116,
0.5476805567741394,
-0.35302090644836426,
0.694279134273529,
0.08443205058574677,
-0.674954354763031,
0.5783246755599976,
-0.4703446626663208,
0.20152482390403748,
-0.1819554716348648,
-0.13786017894744873,
-0.7786946296691895,
-0.4157034754753113,
-0.02490657940506935,
-0.4173814654350281,
-0.045116718858480453,
-0.32243281602859497,
-0.6550869345664978,
-0.6121359467506409,
-0.24368076026439667,
0.7498617172241211,
0.4020363390445709,
-0.3285985589027405,
0.22373752295970917,
0.21399836242198944,
0.04243025556206703,
-0.20536339282989502,
-0.7475003600120544,
0.23296764492988586,
0.11732614785432816,
-0.5758470892906189,
-0.15251603722572327,
-0.4836432933807373,
-0.09127919375896454,
-0.05105090141296387,
-0.0938102975487709,
-0.48337507247924805,
0.08953375369310379,
0.2189328521490097,
0.20270633697509766,
-0.14262618124485016,
-0.3262229263782501,
-0.14965219795703888,
-0.31865501403808594,
0.21557509899139404,
-0.1851736158132553,
0.5139679312705994,
-0.1494666188955307,
-0.8464253544807434,
-0.3567141890525818,
0.6797050833702087,
1.035071611404419,
-0.8400819897651672,
0.47034668922424316,
0.5218191742897034,
-0.29746535420417786,
-0.3276897966861725,
-0.39317092299461365,
0.16761717200279236,
-0.46599337458610535,
0.6306378841400146,
-0.6536660194396973,
-0.8421147465705872,
0.3933776319026947,
-0.16407166421413422,
-0.1955372393131256,
0.05432843416929245,
0.5770025849342346,
0.03340090438723564,
1.4564309120178223,
0.7190245985984802,
0.3479709327220917,
0.42977091670036316,
-0.4113890528678894,
0.07772712409496307,
-0.5236338376998901,
-0.613141655921936,
-0.36185160279273987,
-0.14874666929244995,
-0.07693713158369064,
-0.9884596467018127,
0.6502703428268433,
0.1837075650691986,
0.15605740249156952,
0.13019733130931854,
-0.5623310208320618,
0.5865988731384277,
0.6432033181190491,
0.2370852380990982,
0.2883280813694,
-0.19074448943138123,
-0.1602536141872406,
-0.0787564292550087,
-0.7353880405426025,
-0.11324356496334076,
1.0840574502944946,
0.24685564637184143,
0.8257724046707153,
0.23531201481819153,
0.3484964668750763,
0.4922405481338501,
0.086406409740448,
-0.7001293301582336,
0.5342522263526917,
0.08234145492315292,
-0.3535410463809967,
0.10985387861728668,
-0.8718060851097107,
-0.7300716042518616,
0.05211733281612396,
-0.35024985671043396,
-0.1659678965806961,
0.14584395289421082,
0.14663377404212952,
-0.17702384293079376,
-0.04735146090388298,
-1.1534496545791626,
1.2306137084960938,
-0.5905858278274536,
-0.21831375360488892,
-0.2694411277770996,
-0.43448522686958313,
0.5277456045150757,
-0.16906346380710602,
0.5556091070175171,
-0.0016878540627658367,
0.12760715186595917,
0.3885442912578583,
-0.21503226459026337,
0.764420747756958,
-0.1808822900056839,
-0.0538734570145607,
0.26553991436958313,
0.29933759570121765,
0.18674278259277344,
0.008020423352718353,
0.17704246938228607,
-0.1439848095178604,
0.11756247282028198,
-0.49379763007164,
-0.7109173536300659,
0.528049886226654,
-0.4882926940917969,
-0.003302318276837468,
-0.11848898231983185,
-0.6542142629623413,
-0.09567868709564209,
0.2624147832393646,
-0.1720525622367859,
0.9131203293800354,
0.21236668527126312,
0.33544817566871643,
0.5789600014686584,
-0.49178996682167053,
0.37301045656204224,
0.18889562785625458,
-0.35408827662467957,
-0.3745138645172119,
1.0897893905639648,
0.0190285574644804,
0.1702565848827362,
0.04427194222807884,
-0.15234805643558502,
0.17260752618312836,
-0.7152765989303589,
-0.8223661184310913,
-0.24009446799755096,
-0.90426105260849,
-0.41441214084625244,
-0.32641297578811646,
-0.015932340174913406,
-0.10675333440303802,
-0.17676475644111633,
-0.3576452434062958,
-0.027868246659636497,
-0.03235529735684395,
0.26647263765335083,
-0.031333766877651215,
0.9122412204742432,
0.06370458006858826,
-0.1170976310968399,
-0.8915496468544006,
0.5417266488075256,
0.5518819689750671,
0.7686767578125,
-0.009076816029846668,
0.15885873138904572,
-0.5793736577033997,
0.014061321504414082,
0.021474769338965416,
-1.1216981410980225,
0.3328772187232971,
-0.0020117650274187326,
0.5503718256950378,
0.30473655462265015,
-0.16187812387943268,
0.8212131261825562,
-0.39881908893585205,
0.5297613143920898,
0.3832632303237915,
-1.0960265398025513,
0.6138490438461304,
-0.20925085246562958,
0.5797858834266663,
0.31603822112083435,
0.25715965032577515,
-0.3228627145290375,
-0.028912413865327835,
-0.30595576763153076,
-0.46983975172042847,
0.5216411352157593,
0.24963487684726715,
0.11791902780532837,
-0.08829320967197418,
0.11458101868629456,
0.04595937207341194,
0.382627010345459,
-0.7942207455635071,
-0.048396192491054535,
-0.3663421869277954,
-0.2811897397041321,
0.08188717067241669,
-0.4380400478839874,
-0.06843429803848267,
-0.3289201259613037,
-0.08845876902341843,
-0.4565885663032532,
0.6111477017402649,
0.03910031542181969,
-0.5760932564735413,
0.10391798615455627,
0.23062224686145782,
0.9878222942352295,
0.8900787830352783,
0.03457098454236984,
0.25818121433258057,
-0.209427610039711,
-0.343263179063797,
-0.1291564404964447,
0.09590286761522293,
0.1725214570760727,
-0.46184924244880676,
0.49254491925239563,
0.5350111722946167,
0.3530035614967346,
-1.3431473970413208,
0.9545400142669678,
0.016520477831363678,
-0.31980955600738525,
0.11617474257946014,
0.12996120750904083,
-0.14954523742198944,
0.4470054805278778,
0.4402216672897339,
0.4607427418231964,
0.42490658164024353,
-0.6129052639007568,
0.21265026926994324,
0.43030253052711487,
-0.17194074392318726,
-0.3227250277996063,
0.7771736979484558,
0.434988796710968,
-0.14255096018314362,
0.663952648639679,
-0.5116798281669617,
-0.5987190008163452,
0.7315419316291809,
0.566170871257782,
0.46904829144477844,
0.23245802521705627,
0.1321130096912384,
0.08751248568296432,
0.5214701294898987,
0.39532357454299927,
0.4576767385005951,
-0.18588687479496002,
-0.48508158326148987,
-0.7899665832519531,
-0.5432841777801514,
-0.21397574245929718,
-0.23011988401412964,
-0.4381333291530609,
0.021646039560437202,
-0.5899603366851807,
0.0007054581074044108,
-0.028629884123802185,
-0.24116982519626617,
-0.7552884221076965,
0.1603993922472,
0.7155762910842896,
0.8288586735725403,
-0.7703161835670471,
0.6924238801002502,
0.665654718875885,
-0.4921698272228241,
-0.450351357460022,
-0.37558797001838684,
0.003349865321069956,
-0.7843508124351501,
0.5301514863967896,
0.33906593918800354,
-0.16846469044685364,
-0.06353513151407242,
-0.9207044839859009,
-0.5885542035102844,
0.8935002088546753,
0.4920141398906708,
-0.2999332547187805,
0.14919953048229218,
0.031852174550294876,
0.17823554575443268,
-0.5145346522331238,
0.3241100013256073,
0.22054751217365265,
0.433323472738266,
0.042631782591342926,
-1.172694206237793,
-0.2995855212211609,
-0.7593960762023926,
-0.03847475349903107,
0.09626854211091995,
-0.389549195766449,
0.8675879836082458,
-0.4374512732028961,
-0.03621641919016838,
-0.07224667072296143,
0.31031790375709534,
0.2195809781551361,
0.5117567777633667,
0.27707555890083313,
0.5435618162155151,
0.44455742835998535,
0.0025287256576120853,
1.089457631111145,
-0.3543177545070648,
0.39691299200057983,
0.6029788255691528,
-0.0835098996758461,
0.7402632832527161,
0.29811182618141174,
-0.09356424957513809,
0.3348544239997864,
0.1508398950099945,
-0.2546067237854004,
0.41833198070526123,
0.10310667753219604,
0.19782255589962006,
-0.4165148138999939,
-0.03304950147867203,
-0.46863803267478943,
0.724449098110199,
0.250886470079422,
-0.2675158977508545,
-0.014389478601515293,
0.42326799035072327,
-0.25886306166648865,
-0.054190125316381454,
-0.4385933578014374,
0.5289481282234192,
-0.2398093044757843,
-0.3149077892303467,
0.5435149669647217,
0.3481922745704651,
0.7184972167015076,
-0.41746076941490173,
-0.4480432868003845,
-0.14484305679798126,
0.05716954916715622,
-0.3123076260089874,
-0.8226439356803894,
0.32533377408981323,
0.11920548230409622,
-0.2559480369091034,
-0.34020522236824036,
0.43517443537712097,
-0.25941792130470276,
-0.5576589703559875,
0.01056483294814825,
0.748826801776886,
-0.02198096178472042,
-0.12868547439575195,
-0.8045157790184021,
0.39492544531822205,
0.24907082319259644,
0.10780860483646393,
0.13204878568649292,
0.6954137682914734,
0.09067878872156143,
0.8785933256149292,
1.0224637985229492,
-0.35462042689323425,
0.5800869464874268,
0.1325148046016693,
1.1288799047470093,
-0.6879404187202454,
-0.46152204275131226,
-0.6184942722320557,
0.7250691652297974,
0.03277912363409996,
-0.44485992193222046,
0.7935082912445068,
0.7736942768096924,
0.8362071514129639,
-0.42248377203941345,
0.5320132970809937,
-0.0403437465429306,
-0.1646924763917923,
-0.673092782497406,
0.4660000801086426,
-0.6822723150253296,
0.17209462821483612,
-0.4186469614505768,
-0.8418285250663757,
-0.5355428457260132,
0.6381365060806274,
-0.2514788806438446,
0.11883505433797836,
0.4183063805103302,
0.6860703825950623,
-0.37017419934272766,
-0.16466063261032104,
0.4121461808681488,
-0.04684755206108093,
0.22716887295246124,
0.882470428943634,
1.004852294921875,
-0.16479414701461792,
0.8180311322212219,
-0.37612617015838623,
-0.5988670587539673,
-0.42062053084373474,
-0.6119718551635742,
-0.731580376625061,
-0.6178770661354065,
-0.24443234503269196,
-0.2577378749847412,
-0.227204829454422,
0.8746255040168762,
0.9359421730041504,
-0.5003455281257629,
-0.1755301058292389,
0.14073489606380463,
0.02230927348136902,
-0.2749030590057373,
-0.17542095482349396,
-0.14414051175117493,
-0.04350366070866585,
-0.6400544047355652,
0.2845039963722229,
0.46713370084762573,
0.05233655124902725,
-0.30878522992134094,
-0.21974675357341766,
0.051505912095308304,
0.04689597338438034,
0.9594259262084961,
0.04640143737196922,
-0.3754234313964844,
-0.058031436055898666,
0.1840718537569046,
-0.23413793742656708,
0.07501016557216644,
0.9439846277236938,
-0.592133104801178,
0.7693120837211609,
0.3652837574481964,
0.647922694683075,
0.36336782574653625,
-0.03296015411615372,
0.16999804973602295,
-0.5963468551635742,
0.18074753880500793,
0.2524733543395996,
0.3877687156200409,
0.18004952371120453,
0.12991367280483246,
0.35523322224617004,
0.37654909491539,
-0.43154874444007874,
-0.8790486454963684,
0.3720146715641022,
-1.1378042697906494,
-0.44418931007385254,
0.932828962802887,
0.11225224286317825,
-0.16393493115901947,
-0.026422444730997086,
-0.4019099771976471,
-0.2932072877883911,
-0.1390390694141388,
0.5257089734077454,
0.5687241554260254,
-0.10226050019264221,
-0.662018895149231,
-1.068602204322815,
0.14563551545143127,
0.23048944771289825,
-0.8875120878219604,
-0.11670616269111633,
0.9436252117156982,
-0.11618657410144806,
0.26246747374534607,
0.5147573351860046,
-0.08723600953817368,
0.6446965932846069,
0.4648309648036957,
0.10929937660694122,
-0.5692310929298401,
-0.7159375548362732,
-0.3189545273780823,
0.5956120491027832,
0.190889373421669,
-0.10651500523090363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09480v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09480v1
|
Mitigating Hallucination in Abstractive Summarization with Domain-Conditional Mutual Information
| 2024-04-15T06:06:43 | 2024-04-15T06:06:43 |
Kyubyung Chae, Jaepill Choi, Yohan Jo, Taesup Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
A primary challenge in abstractive summarization is hallucination -- the
phenomenon where a model generates plausible text that is absent in the source
text. We hypothesize that the domain (or topic) of the source text triggers the
model to generate text that is highly probable in the domain, neglecting the
details of the source text. To alleviate this model bias, we introduce a
decoding strategy based on domain-conditional pointwise mutual information.
This strategy adjusts the generation probability of each token by comparing it
with the token's marginal probability within the domain of the source text.
According to evaluation on the XSUM dataset, our method demonstrates
improvement in terms of faithfulness and source relevance. The code is publicly
available at \url{https://github.com/qqplot/dcpmi}.
|
[
-0.28658613562583923,
-0.5862471461296082,
0.7177979350090027,
0.17946358025074005,
-0.5397331714630127,
-0.1071784645318985,
0.05021877959370613,
-0.35910671949386597,
0.4844011664390564,
0.32756444811820984,
-0.6534056663513184,
-0.6392555236816406,
-0.6243447661399841,
0.21543307602405548,
-0.4034110903739929,
1.0564334392547607,
0.014841478317975998,
-0.043380800634622574,
-0.5910996794700623,
-0.10130158811807632,
-0.36294040083885193,
-0.9158592820167542,
-0.567920446395874,
-0.32500654458999634,
0.3826340436935425,
0.29403847455978394,
0.634164571762085,
0.4498272240161896,
0.5160596966743469,
0.14692476391792297,
0.018179437145590782,
0.1549057960510254,
-0.6242167949676514,
0.22069813311100006,
-0.15234461426734924,
-0.42302465438842773,
-0.7041988372802734,
-0.3216712176799774,
0.5825303792953491,
0.8633315563201904,
-0.0094838822260499,
-0.13376399874687195,
0.09269339591264725,
0.8044496774673462,
-0.7939018607139587,
0.40954312682151794,
-0.6374258399009705,
0.20461858808994293,
0.1934303343296051,
-0.6215251684188843,
-0.3756827712059021,
-0.3137440085411072,
0.1283062994480133,
-0.6289609670639038,
0.3933688700199127,
0.011088281869888306,
0.8285499811172485,
0.14197413623332977,
-0.585921049118042,
-0.10615739226341248,
-0.6150206923484802,
0.5525219440460205,
-0.645816445350647,
0.06944882124662399,
0.8106496334075928,
0.1228143647313118,
-0.045321669429540634,
-0.6981588006019592,
-0.7940583825111389,
-0.016705289483070374,
-0.3502103388309479,
0.23153676092624664,
-0.30987244844436646,
0.23451940715312958,
0.22410382330417633,
0.4604182839393616,
-0.6050055623054504,
-0.5473523736000061,
-0.1951228380203247,
-0.40592968463897705,
0.652057945728302,
0.3225947320461273,
0.2909092605113983,
-0.41833895444869995,
0.011580579914152622,
-0.1692543774843216,
-0.7075921297073364,
-0.1537591964006424,
0.24476394057273865,
0.15632718801498413,
-0.06558328866958618,
0.8000953793525696,
-0.2629893124103546,
0.3355415165424347,
0.24592292308807373,
-0.05595735087990761,
0.4080961048603058,
-0.6785261034965515,
0.039926573634147644,
0.4025146961212158,
0.33866390585899353,
0.7185693383216858,
0.03397417813539505,
-0.26252201199531555,
-0.4230344295501709,
0.11670868843793869,
0.0792713612318039,
-0.9082658886909485,
-0.5615835189819336,
0.5242245197296143,
-0.641442060470581,
-0.13011838495731354,
0.3185146749019623,
-0.437016099691391,
-0.13686220347881317,
-0.3896375596523285,
0.7434692978858948,
-0.46092021465301514,
-0.40299227833747864,
-0.024850772693753242,
-0.6313119530677795,
-0.0304438304156065,
0.12145383656024933,
-0.9077490568161011,
0.4556220471858978,
0.7279576063156128,
1.1386044025421143,
-0.47640514373779297,
-0.33984434604644775,
-0.7298798561096191,
0.3588418960571289,
-0.13841655850410461,
0.730778694152832,
-0.3158693313598633,
-0.5495956540107727,
0.013837797567248344,
-0.1428999900817871,
0.01422136276960373,
-0.6058449149131775,
0.32643911242485046,
-0.4093925952911377,
0.2293572574853897,
-0.7318738102912903,
-0.5374610424041748,
-0.2744358777999878,
0.025611398741602898,
-0.7174590826034546,
0.4974234104156494,
0.2063911110162735,
-1.172257900238037,
0.3776627779006958,
-0.3426916301250458,
-0.7743033170700073,
-0.245791956782341,
-0.4288635551929474,
-0.5496687889099121,
0.21035417914390564,
0.16360944509506226,
0.36075884103775024,
0.2667493522167206,
0.4657386541366577,
-0.12095872312784195,
-0.5983649492263794,
0.22871516644954681,
-0.1700228899717331,
0.4740934669971466,
0.17361325025558472,
-0.5480790138244629,
0.23623837530612946,
-0.8463226556777954,
-0.37221023440361023,
0.15232670307159424,
0.2194669246673584,
-0.6408430337905884,
0.2000342309474945,
-0.15687721967697144,
0.10982160270214081,
0.014788112603127956,
-0.09181667119264603,
0.049311377108097076,
-0.18503563106060028,
0.020218301564455032,
0.7000410556793213,
0.5494992733001709,
0.5368695855140686,
-0.6914730072021484,
0.38745734095573425,
0.2997644543647766,
-0.2866343855857849,
-0.26516684889793396,
-0.4145486652851105,
-0.47193944454193115,
-0.522302508354187,
0.252475380897522,
0.40183311700820923,
-1.0234054327011108,
0.5381365418434143,
-0.2056819647550583,
0.132406547665596,
-0.19863198697566986,
-0.3974669873714447,
0.3399873673915863,
0.6494830846786499,
0.3144719898700714,
-0.23857922852039337,
-0.650885283946991,
-0.7243978381156921,
0.05483052134513855,
-0.027101268991827965,
-0.24871742725372314,
0.06503558158874512,
0.5068122148513794,
-0.22914154827594757,
0.9717882871627808,
-0.7878738641738892,
-0.3649776875972748,
-0.44028881192207336,
0.3988591134548187,
0.18928329646587372,
0.4509672522544861,
0.536039412021637,
-0.9721497297286987,
-0.2931315004825592,
-0.31458580493927,
-0.9957970380783081,
-0.28693830966949463,
-0.35563433170318604,
-0.21570806205272675,
0.2562328577041626,
0.5123741626739502,
-0.7645279169082642,
0.8084096908569336,
0.41543376445770264,
-0.5066248774528503,
0.6949063539505005,
-0.34368422627449036,
0.5002564191818237,
-1.1143442392349243,
0.2683597505092621,
-0.20423680543899536,
-0.2628019154071808,
-0.5563071370124817,
-0.12704387307167053,
-0.1045723557472229,
-0.05237487331032753,
0.06150257959961891,
0.30482548475265503,
-0.6098056435585022,
0.012827400118112564,
-0.7855427861213684,
0.31925997138023376,
0.09853729605674744,
0.5606371164321899,
0.36343279480934143,
0.7892658114433289,
0.4624120593070984,
-1.0067609548568726,
-0.3070268929004669,
0.4867936670780182,
0.04816059395670891,
0.32079368829727173,
-0.7732236981391907,
-0.19980745017528534,
-0.3307720124721527,
0.42092135548591614,
-0.7687228322029114,
-0.24920372664928436,
0.47635966539382935,
-0.6008182764053345,
0.1296268105506897,
0.1342764049768448,
-0.27695849537849426,
0.23477543890476227,
-0.6711623668670654,
0.7466896772384644,
0.44652631878852844,
-0.5495608448982239,
0.46275338530540466,
0.5646508932113647,
-0.3783317506313324,
-0.585059404373169,
-0.5223235487937927,
0.1262407898902893,
0.00234146136790514,
-0.5843620300292969,
0.756041407585144,
-0.2824516296386719,
-0.5020914673805237,
0.18973901867866516,
-0.461855411529541,
0.020289765670895576,
-0.03550219535827637,
0.5049604773521423,
0.3362939655780792,
0.06271637976169586,
-0.1027575358748436,
0.6421706676483154,
-0.28000107407569885,
0.5071596503257751,
-0.3069136142730713,
0.4925844967365265,
0.3823949098587036,
-0.18025986850261688,
-0.5565351247787476,
0.7922214865684509,
0.31625792384147644,
0.07641386240720749,
0.854339063167572,
0.3010352551937103,
-0.5818917751312256,
-0.19135484099388123,
-0.006461606826633215,
-0.7063038945198059,
-0.3979635238647461,
0.3373543322086334,
-0.660709023475647,
-0.6226735711097717,
0.7415759563446045,
0.29882049560546875,
-0.2069338709115982,
0.607518196105957,
0.47073981165885925,
0.2131839096546173,
1.168529748916626,
0.8943911790847778,
-0.015061420388519764,
0.2663363814353943,
-0.2219247817993164,
0.3186212182044983,
-0.4957570433616638,
-0.30062949657440186,
-0.36868390440940857,
-0.01848229579627514,
-0.32233500480651855,
-0.10325971990823746,
0.5017768144607544,
-0.08163639158010483,
0.30450674891471863,
0.1328018605709076,
-0.2883293926715851,
0.460945725440979,
0.7539365291595459,
0.23902711272239685,
0.6433914303779602,
0.23648038506507874,
-0.15155631303787231,
-0.03483286499977112,
-0.7841967344284058,
-0.20295266807079315,
0.9699682593345642,
-0.05216263607144356,
0.39084291458129883,
0.16661855578422546,
0.7810983657836914,
0.6376193165779114,
-0.1272701621055603,
-0.5633901953697205,
0.5725205540657043,
0.31625455617904663,
-0.3338700532913208,
-0.2870912551879883,
-0.8889554738998413,
-0.8560442924499512,
0.4464798867702484,
-0.485220730304718,
-0.5311049818992615,
0.44280290603637695,
0.16808369755744934,
-0.2582525908946991,
0.09913884848356247,
-0.395045667886734,
0.4952842593193054,
0.4010174870491028,
-0.1580163538455963,
-0.6159706115722656,
-0.6877456307411194,
0.523662805557251,
-0.16270647943019867,
0.06041259318590164,
0.0903678610920906,
0.05955919623374939,
0.6438381671905518,
-0.6705385446548462,
0.6985270380973816,
-0.1668148785829544,
-0.01829882711172104,
0.23321862518787384,
0.2110786885023117,
0.5906327962875366,
0.4435373544692993,
-0.005579882301390171,
0.3498043715953827,
0.1278018206357956,
-0.6110560297966003,
-0.49905574321746826,
0.4689842164516449,
-0.6283014416694641,
-0.5707358121871948,
-0.7806165814399719,
-0.6375257968902588,
0.03039175644516945,
0.1020844578742981,
0.7243154644966125,
0.42840835452079773,
-0.18911588191986084,
-0.35097193717956543,
0.6912579536437988,
-0.051934294402599335,
0.47787463665008545,
0.06990029662847519,
-0.29728445410728455,
-0.5783373117446899,
0.9255804419517517,
-0.13321971893310547,
0.12190860509872437,
0.5895115733146667,
-0.0007877811440266669,
-0.13480772078037262,
-0.8178867697715759,
-0.09833724051713943,
0.45803141593933105,
-0.866968035697937,
-0.23370763659477234,
-0.8821072578430176,
-0.3359457552433014,
-0.508216917514801,
-0.12243930995464325,
0.06001708284020424,
-0.9147446155548096,
-0.3140343725681305,
-0.27124083042144775,
0.12458789348602295,
0.5319985151290894,
-0.41190361976623535,
0.09085492044687271,
-0.8749108910560608,
0.6041720509529114,
0.16416320204734802,
0.07407866418361664,
0.07223251461982727,
-0.7429845333099365,
-0.24143093824386597,
0.054493047297000885,
0.06846015155315399,
-0.787925124168396,
0.48999398946762085,
0.1185603141784668,
0.48390188813209534,
0.5238829851150513,
0.5721036791801453,
0.4342350959777832,
-0.4164469838142395,
0.5864248871803284,
0.25322070717811584,
-1.2158985137939453,
0.3725214898586273,
-0.25401827692985535,
0.31199562549591064,
0.7095862627029419,
0.6345967054367065,
-0.42100533843040466,
-0.5890608429908752,
-0.4684971868991852,
-0.938671886920929,
0.5469327569007874,
0.6017956733703613,
0.02621663175523281,
-0.14278917014598846,
0.5484068393707275,
0.4766473174095154,
0.35614073276519775,
-0.8680347204208374,
-0.34910866618156433,
-0.3116905391216278,
-0.10080453008413315,
-0.05789574980735779,
-0.5220815539360046,
-0.20060117542743683,
-0.3308905065059662,
0.7259571552276611,
0.02155674248933792,
0.3173544406890869,
0.6147862672805786,
-0.2829897105693817,
-0.2682032883167267,
-0.2759767174720764,
0.9422886967658997,
1.055242896080017,
-0.6300450563430786,
0.4748780429363251,
-0.1717066764831543,
-0.7637354135513306,
-0.043897926807403564,
-0.03994716331362724,
-0.40529757738113403,
0.4525304138660431,
0.5323690176010132,
0.5529341101646423,
-0.06046506389975548,
-0.5074942708015442,
0.8256838917732239,
-0.385043203830719,
-0.5893456339836121,
-0.38082486391067505,
-0.03373444080352783,
-0.3563239872455597,
0.17033304274082184,
0.7785098552703857,
0.13036741316318512,
0.45018407702445984,
-0.4554236829280853,
0.6307998299598694,
0.25531965494155884,
-0.1666727066040039,
-0.6734917759895325,
0.7507186532020569,
0.15401691198349,
-0.03265920653939247,
0.4676952362060547,
-0.5948470830917358,
-0.4945656657218933,
0.3537755608558655,
0.7126039862632751,
1.0088982582092285,
0.09084492921829224,
0.27551448345184326,
0.530423104763031,
0.19512903690338135,
0.04043625295162201,
0.3016703724861145,
-0.20767290890216827,
-0.45702701807022095,
-0.48733749985694885,
-0.1491108387708664,
-0.5139656066894531,
-0.14942088723182678,
-0.6615090370178223,
0.2453039139509201,
-0.20110498368740082,
-0.09117202460765839,
-0.29957449436187744,
-0.3327643871307373,
0.11553513258695602,
0.10652965307235718,
-0.09261919558048248,
0.6747530698776245,
-0.9335997104644775,
0.8241869211196899,
0.1868523210287094,
-0.4313170313835144,
-0.30766206979751587,
0.5819540023803711,
-0.09773533046245575,
-0.39748284220695496,
0.32882142066955566,
0.09573861956596375,
-0.28520676493644714,
-0.16105666756629944,
-0.3158884346485138,
-0.6627808213233948,
1.1087535619735718,
0.15322817862033844,
-0.3895428776741028,
-0.036403171718120575,
-0.0629323422908783,
0.190005362033844,
-0.35019975900650024,
-0.05059962719678879,
0.41346943378448486,
0.24758519232273102,
0.16809970140457153,
-0.4953472912311554,
0.5407634377479553,
-0.32208195328712463,
-0.31582531332969666,
0.15606147050857544,
-0.21317249536514282,
0.8081402778625488,
-0.4631383717060089,
-0.3866709768772125,
-0.15007100999355316,
1.0727112293243408,
0.31512317061424255,
0.896676778793335,
0.5136016011238098,
0.1720125675201416,
0.9418591856956482,
0.18268202245235443,
0.9524484276771545,
-0.48366883397102356,
0.10780923068523407,
1.0568333864212036,
-0.1193268895149231,
0.6617056727409363,
0.549907922744751,
0.12253863364458084,
0.2773299217224121,
0.5131185054779053,
0.20827433466911316,
0.9534523487091064,
0.13147097826004028,
-0.4824889004230499,
-0.028749361634254456,
0.10482057183980942,
-0.6780173182487488,
0.22366507351398468,
0.0671609416604042,
-0.12203527241945267,
-0.06486738473176956,
0.039762116968631744,
0.07014397531747818,
0.18838006258010864,
-0.23095285892486572,
0.7827471494674683,
0.3352220058441162,
-0.6926167607307434,
0.7016502022743225,
0.04549369961023331,
0.5553120374679565,
-0.5559701323509216,
-0.3028019964694977,
-0.7058446407318115,
-0.09983166307210922,
-0.33554112911224365,
-0.08287044614553452,
0.6370537281036377,
-0.2585467994213104,
-0.5264120101928711,
0.11164496839046478,
0.5142773389816284,
-0.45560014247894287,
-0.21240483224391937,
0.1737820953130722,
0.4219266176223755,
0.09461628645658493,
-0.5869012475013733,
-0.08950167894363403,
-0.004167794715613127,
0.19802550971508026,
0.07918363809585571,
0.47565600275993347,
0.5631905794143677,
-0.029618483036756516,
0.4245201349258423,
0.4671180248260498,
0.15537992119789124,
-0.36505842208862305,
0.14368806779384613,
0.8731061816215515,
-0.8371427059173584,
-0.7242929935455322,
-0.993760347366333,
0.2947806417942047,
-0.20982863008975983,
-0.05630818381905556,
0.9381510615348816,
0.6748622059822083,
0.547508180141449,
-0.2006179839372635,
0.7969019412994385,
0.1375788003206253,
0.18118147552013397,
-0.6643149256706238,
1.1204253435134888,
-0.47107386589050293,
0.48233669996261597,
-0.47359052300453186,
-1.0598106384277344,
-0.4832466244697571,
0.51340651512146,
0.02533896453678608,
-0.20044416189193726,
1.2541542053222656,
0.6598233580589294,
-0.010970287956297398,
-0.007132932543754578,
0.44701674580574036,
-0.0554659329354763,
-0.015719903632998466,
0.35049009323120117,
0.7146836519241333,
-0.3844160735607147,
0.6618872284889221,
-0.36471691727638245,
-0.5286267399787903,
-0.30936792492866516,
-0.9792996644973755,
-1.129133701324463,
-0.8978572487831116,
-0.6384866833686829,
-0.6390548944473267,
0.1368231177330017,
0.6927235722541809,
0.5731987357139587,
-0.8923934698104858,
-0.10500629246234894,
-0.10309561342000961,
0.3730523884296417,
-0.3173229694366455,
-0.22004199028015137,
0.6599681377410889,
-0.2746824622154236,
-0.6232398152351379,
0.11992239952087402,
0.3275889754295349,
0.17357660830020905,
0.18929249048233032,
-0.12560449540615082,
0.18855315446853638,
0.3207215666770935,
0.7111433148384094,
0.0021231723949313164,
-0.18412505090236664,
-0.1936369687318802,
0.011609459295868874,
-0.11483471095561981,
0.284498929977417,
1.1363860368728638,
-0.5947323441505432,
0.05888775736093521,
0.6113513112068176,
0.45797276496887207,
0.5830380916595459,
0.11119536310434341,
0.8293079137802124,
-0.6696561574935913,
0.24036996066570282,
0.1516476571559906,
0.3274226188659668,
0.05829094722867012,
-0.5766040682792664,
0.3287681043148041,
0.4204276502132416,
-0.5170274376869202,
-0.8216097950935364,
0.13896937668323517,
-1.2334678173065186,
-0.6750919222831726,
0.9011233448982239,
0.06936324387788773,
-0.23556628823280334,
-0.12028268724679947,
-0.2984813451766968,
0.2615692615509033,
-0.43730515241622925,
1.3641504049301147,
0.47701790928840637,
-0.12907680869102478,
0.02166646718978882,
-0.13389290869235992,
0.7505517601966858,
0.5304887890815735,
-0.7259589433670044,
0.04200310260057449,
0.656647264957428,
0.007296019233763218,
-0.033269695937633514,
0.8734331727027893,
0.035908523947000504,
0.5259158611297607,
0.40361735224723816,
0.1155480444431305,
0.0028983058873564005,
-0.4203367233276367,
-0.47821345925331116,
0.25074923038482666,
0.0643664300441742,
-0.12102659791707993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13071v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13071v2
|
Modeling Emotions and Ethics with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-15T05:30:26 | 2024-06-25T04:36:08 |
Edward Y. Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.0
|
This paper explores the integration of human-like emotions and ethical
considerations into Large Language Models (LLMs). We first model eight
fundamental human emotions, presented as opposing pairs, and employ
collaborative LLMs to reinterpret and express these emotions across a spectrum
of intensity. Our focus extends to embedding a latent ethical dimension within
LLMs, guided by a novel self-supervised learning algorithm with human feedback
(SSHF). This approach enables LLMs to perform self-evaluations and adjustments
concerning ethical guidelines, enhancing their capability to generate content
that is not only emotionally resonant but also ethically aligned. The
methodologies and case studies presented herein illustrate the potential of
LLMs to transcend mere text and image generation, venturing into the realms of
empathetic interaction and principled decision-making, thereby setting a new
precedent in the development of emotionally aware and ethically conscious AI
systems.
|
[
-0.06881855428218842,
-0.6164687275886536,
0.8606895208358765,
0.13718844950199127,
-0.18129804730415344,
0.207800030708313,
-0.44456103444099426,
-0.48705625534057617,
0.10763812810182571,
0.6532289981842041,
-0.5145444273948669,
-0.31828999519348145,
-0.2702571153640747,
0.03798926621675491,
-0.11937128007411957,
0.9373036623001099,
0.08642452955245972,
0.4264662265777588,
-0.13917189836502075,
-0.33474767208099365,
0.1701759397983551,
-0.8850117325782776,
-0.7418960332870483,
-0.4470677971839905,
0.6678471565246582,
0.21310697495937347,
0.5912804007530212,
0.5837482810020447,
0.45444512367248535,
0.2655382454395294,
0.14869803190231323,
-0.11845488101243973,
-0.747377872467041,
0.21605581045150757,
-0.3260939121246338,
-0.1369720995426178,
-0.5208950638771057,
0.5521494746208191,
0.27241528034210205,
0.2966710031032562,
-0.3403729498386383,
0.21004943549633026,
-0.08072478324174881,
0.6906539797782898,
-0.40492770075798035,
0.010819870978593826,
-0.21605631709098816,
0.30807816982269287,
0.27290481328964233,
-0.47705551981925964,
-0.42859941720962524,
-0.32785534858703613,
0.11505676805973053,
-0.35624605417251587,
-0.42765501141548157,
0.20403790473937988,
0.3723682761192322,
0.37760043144226074,
-0.6518821120262146,
-0.553168535232544,
-0.5574154257774353,
1.1640290021896362,
-0.6780489087104797,
0.33479952812194824,
0.2657870054244995,
-0.19856350123882294,
0.010171298868954182,
-0.5481981635093689,
-0.6432963013648987,
-0.26364320516586304,
0.16895219683647156,
0.28813618421554565,
-0.17915795743465424,
0.28372570872306824,
0.03307347744703293,
0.22423304617404938,
-0.16563352942466736,
0.43612128496170044,
-0.1389414370059967,
0.16490186750888824,
1.043935775756836,
0.3681197762489319,
0.4401308596134186,
-0.2598136067390442,
-0.09280011802911758,
0.05446876212954521,
-0.7181426882743835,
-0.04152849689126015,
0.8087794184684753,
-0.001302247168496251,
-0.236909881234169,
0.3287671208381653,
0.23480868339538574,
0.16931286454200745,
0.05446545407176018,
0.003754144534468651,
0.24753226339817047,
0.01992197148501873,
-0.2560183107852936,
0.042083535343408585,
1.0051566362380981,
0.698187530040741,
0.6145139336585999,
0.155008926987648,
-0.20482781529426575,
0.1000349372625351,
0.6283873319625854,
-0.8995945453643799,
-0.03137699514627457,
0.5781578421592712,
-0.9686213731765747,
-0.8566718101501465,
-0.3673645257949829,
-0.8189223408699036,
-0.6361845135688782,
-0.7156395316123962,
0.2828768789768219,
-0.25431254506111145,
-0.41859665513038635,
0.142999529838562,
0.3199918270111084,
0.4036532938480377,
0.3362022042274475,
-0.6614315509796143,
0.27520713210105896,
0.7494723200798035,
0.2966846823692322,
0.23547393083572388,
-0.16020388901233673,
-0.5422738790512085,
0.08975107967853546,
-0.5271872878074646,
0.08896162360906601,
-0.8764268755912781,
-0.5186994671821594,
0.0514005646109581,
-0.08742885291576385,
0.4488699734210968,
-0.12222465127706528,
0.6401155591011047,
-0.4234496057033539,
0.33772388100624084,
-0.21475857496261597,
-0.605278730392456,
-0.28426623344421387,
0.19770550727844238,
-0.40060171484947205,
0.7438760995864868,
-0.00422277906909585,
-0.6018367409706116,
-0.13263684511184692,
-0.9865622520446777,
-0.3645705282688141,
0.1561295986175537,
-0.4407864511013031,
-0.3212198317050934,
0.2567909061908722,
-0.2253563106060028,
0.7321590781211853,
-0.5471292734146118,
0.43599000573158264,
-0.4367089569568634,
-0.11259456723928452,
0.21648362278938293,
-0.2852801978588104,
0.8297147750854492,
0.25497564673423767,
-0.3957100808620453,
0.2813645005226135,
-0.47036007046699524,
-0.003807519795373082,
0.3270769417285919,
-0.08425456285476685,
-0.36215606331825256,
0.1492086946964264,
0.3056718409061432,
0.2652188241481781,
0.258710116147995,
-0.45088234543800354,
-0.040219083428382874,
-0.12447220087051392,
0.8043728470802307,
1.1215686798095703,
-0.04509508237242699,
0.6489842534065247,
-0.22368335723876953,
0.6213003993034363,
-0.369137704372406,
0.29332634806632996,
-0.07577727735042572,
-0.10235568135976791,
-0.611793041229248,
-0.10658295452594757,
-0.252610445022583,
0.5346248149871826,
-0.1312723308801651,
0.5528156161308289,
0.04014777019619942,
-0.3143346607685089,
-0.8548955321311951,
0.12033172696828842,
0.36382943391799927,
0.4816964864730835,
0.11806385964155197,
-0.07572051882743835,
-0.2720659077167511,
-0.9615094065666199,
-0.21367664635181427,
-0.41294315457344055,
0.05899583175778389,
0.6577494144439697,
0.5203836560249329,
-0.4298805594444275,
0.677715003490448,
-0.0025024889037013054,
0.013920414261519909,
0.025326838716864586,
0.40876972675323486,
-0.19617953896522522,
0.6967498660087585,
0.4699992835521698,
-0.8895502090454102,
-0.14353613555431366,
0.03232726827263832,
-1.1310762166976929,
-0.16516877710819244,
-0.24230575561523438,
-0.08674949407577515,
0.14519116282463074,
0.467288076877594,
-0.39772921800613403,
0.27274981141090393,
0.5318316221237183,
-0.13548150658607483,
0.4465170204639435,
-0.24407604336738586,
0.4459437429904938,
-1.1868841648101807,
-0.13117653131484985,
0.05610865354537964,
-0.156936913728714,
-0.5253259539604187,
0.11903741210699081,
0.08493581414222717,
0.023845504969358444,
-0.7437931895256042,
0.6655498147010803,
-0.5430127382278442,
-0.07932163029909134,
-0.2834961414337158,
-0.05936021730303764,
0.051308080554008484,
0.34763428568840027,
-0.04626830294728279,
0.4044501781463623,
0.5419562458992004,
-0.26424354314804077,
0.7392045855522156,
0.21862006187438965,
-0.028353527188301086,
1.0795435905456543,
-0.6489945650100708,
0.36944785714149475,
-0.4501695930957794,
0.4332980215549469,
-0.29248756170272827,
-0.3648490905761719,
0.32824838161468506,
-0.2767432928085327,
0.07386551797389984,
-0.09827219694852829,
-0.6112484931945801,
-0.24232128262519836,
-0.4597104489803314,
0.5041904449462891,
0.9112142324447632,
-0.42651307582855225,
1.0012565851211548,
0.49187394976615906,
-0.34882044792175293,
-0.3356965184211731,
-0.6902702450752258,
0.41251692175865173,
-0.374447762966156,
-0.5554881691932678,
0.08605954051017761,
-0.20190684497356415,
-0.6227582693099976,
0.09686081111431122,
0.49816834926605225,
0.12140148878097534,
0.16892604529857635,
0.5167504549026489,
0.20165273547172546,
0.07122360914945602,
0.25142037868499756,
0.07454044371843338,
0.10178757458925247,
0.3968585729598999,
-0.16370651125907898,
0.28381264209747314,
-0.68903648853302,
-0.4810047447681427,
-0.6220730543136597,
0.6769661903381348,
0.5940441489219666,
-0.38406383991241455,
0.49046653509140015,
0.6351423859596252,
-0.6134745478630066,
-0.06628414243459702,
-0.6617035865783691,
-0.27913475036621094,
-0.4467799663543701,
0.3260452449321747,
0.03025057539343834,
-1.1715631484985352,
0.3478764593601227,
-0.004025900736451149,
0.041003573685884476,
0.2151591181755066,
0.9658933281898499,
-0.5262506604194641,
1.0193411111831665,
0.6136212348937988,
-0.011578422039747238,
0.37916797399520874,
-0.13956037163734436,
0.3314405083656311,
-1.0907589197158813,
-0.12023898214101791,
-0.20323313772678375,
-0.3209236264228821,
-0.8775075674057007,
-0.402658611536026,
0.15302389860153198,
-0.15959283709526062,
-0.5255577564239502,
-0.434847354888916,
-0.45384901762008667,
0.6808135509490967,
0.38737308979034424,
0.04534491151571274,
0.028522914275527,
-0.29206475615501404,
0.17123177647590637,
-0.05308520048856735,
-0.29817283153533936,
-1.0135655403137207,
0.9491500854492188,
0.6182430386543274,
1.017905831336975,
0.04662115126848221,
0.9097249507904053,
0.4221561849117279,
0.6976694464683533,
-0.819525957107544,
0.591793954372406,
-0.15583044290542603,
-0.4221942722797394,
-0.31976714730262756,
-0.4753427803516388,
-0.7812337279319763,
-0.1392325907945633,
-0.12385250627994537,
-1.055543303489685,
0.032135140150785446,
-0.0384899377822876,
-0.42961129546165466,
0.2067955881357193,
-0.46564266085624695,
0.6882336735725403,
-0.6781424880027771,
-0.5794110298156738,
-0.6916104555130005,
-0.934565544128418,
0.3649473488330841,
-0.24541087448596954,
0.40016570687294006,
-0.2723221182823181,
-0.04057935252785683,
0.703454315662384,
-0.1721203327178955,
1.0540094375610352,
0.10379620641469955,
-0.23754410445690155,
0.22487729787826538,
0.27473509311676025,
0.3214958608150482,
0.06886182725429535,
-0.2856212556362152,
0.0897316038608551,
-0.17891687154769897,
-0.22598983347415924,
-0.4436296820640564,
0.8533968329429626,
-0.8804461359977722,
-0.6348797082901001,
-0.30682575702667236,
-0.5755569934844971,
-0.13840904831886292,
0.11625885218381882,
-0.3072878122329712,
0.17669527232646942,
-0.3364107608795166,
0.2738354206085205,
0.7575539350509644,
-0.7033805251121521,
0.29714348912239075,
0.49559271335601807,
-0.2732161581516266,
-0.34137406945228577,
0.8351817727088928,
-0.29411014914512634,
0.12996171414852142,
0.11063554137945175,
0.529868483543396,
-0.3630472719669342,
-0.034270115196704865,
-0.367043673992157,
0.3788889944553375,
-0.7996810674667358,
-0.07388752698898315,
-0.7196157574653625,
-0.07621482759714127,
-0.20806820690631866,
-0.6194803714752197,
-0.4052698314189911,
0.10981306433677673,
-0.6606905460357666,
-0.2515113353729248,
0.5779199600219727,
0.9889500737190247,
-0.25460150837898254,
0.21809425950050354,
-0.9750935435295105,
0.20662008225917816,
0.28737306594848633,
0.5198397636413574,
0.1873224824666977,
-0.4392293393611908,
0.19258840382099152,
0.0496748723089695,
-0.15064547955989838,
-0.7749090194702148,
0.4093782603740692,
0.007348452229052782,
0.40157270431518555,
0.4062749445438385,
0.18271714448928833,
0.35140734910964966,
-0.5869898796081543,
0.6951894760131836,
0.3355063498020172,
-1.2648125886917114,
0.4134042263031006,
-0.5870187878608704,
-0.26462677121162415,
0.35249850153923035,
0.5351684093475342,
-0.6971089243888855,
-0.23848101496696472,
-0.7713079452514648,
-0.5747770071029663,
0.4568433165550232,
0.12140654772520065,
0.5853484272956848,
0.026593884453177452,
0.5097336173057556,
-0.020939670503139496,
0.15447214245796204,
-0.6838884353637695,
0.10758721828460693,
0.058819692581892014,
-0.8606886863708496,
0.14950692653656006,
-0.267053484916687,
-0.27119606733322144,
0.10549825429916382,
0.4622066915035248,
-0.03340991213917732,
0.05552046746015549,
0.14941689372062683,
-0.014141199178993702,
-0.3524097502231598,
0.24388833343982697,
0.2989189028739929,
0.3372621238231659,
-0.05951613932847977,
-0.0009485292830504477,
-0.08790422976016998,
0.021593227982521057,
0.3810938894748688,
-0.22362422943115234,
0.34684252738952637,
-0.7092224955558777,
0.20403233170509338,
0.4305664300918579,
0.12498486042022705,
-0.7766733169555664,
0.7194562554359436,
-0.14957325160503387,
-0.07618381828069687,
-0.3591628074645996,
-0.35950034856796265,
0.40275079011917114,
0.5717594623565674,
0.30248335003852844,
-0.40625977516174316,
0.30243608355522156,
-0.7747400999069214,
0.201200470328331,
0.3957231044769287,
-0.2887837290763855,
-0.33586448431015015,
0.5628162026405334,
0.6209967136383057,
-0.5398920774459839,
0.581264078617096,
-0.2728193700313568,
-0.8060721755027771,
0.63719642162323,
0.07595378160476685,
1.0569007396697998,
-0.3299737572669983,
0.20954158902168274,
-0.04530598595738411,
0.2564668655395508,
-0.21752826869487762,
0.45126447081565857,
0.07209667563438416,
-0.7790846824645996,
-0.5053310990333557,
-0.5349839925765991,
-0.7281920909881592,
0.022737083956599236,
-0.6900701522827148,
-0.0869937464594841,
-0.6304743885993958,
-0.025280803442001343,
-0.1665927916765213,
0.005422079470008612,
-0.6241666674613953,
0.37531423568725586,
0.40953144431114197,
0.36893802881240845,
-0.6729105710983276,
0.5969046354293823,
0.5588110685348511,
-0.43285876512527466,
-0.6876538395881653,
-0.15568161010742188,
0.056560106575489044,
-0.8807780742645264,
0.7889630198478699,
0.2973894476890564,
-0.3654501438140869,
0.04500725492835045,
-0.9150601625442505,
-0.3729460537433624,
0.8249216675758362,
0.2652888000011444,
-0.5388684272766113,
0.09996607154607773,
-0.07337792962789536,
0.7846373915672302,
-0.6695607304573059,
0.19454823434352875,
0.24224580824375153,
0.3792492151260376,
-0.24642154574394226,
-0.5995990633964539,
0.11139113456010818,
-0.2301216572523117,
-0.08732767403125763,
0.1479559689760208,
-1.001878261566162,
0.726301372051239,
-0.3576663136482239,
-0.14420504868030548,
-0.0544285774230957,
0.46267634630203247,
0.1624588817358017,
0.22034132480621338,
0.4749811887741089,
0.4218969941139221,
0.7993336319923401,
0.22787004709243774,
1.0684423446655273,
-0.48020705580711365,
0.2607958912849426,
0.9327387809753418,
-0.6432506442070007,
0.6317808032035828,
0.529810905456543,
0.09604310244321823,
0.2708812355995178,
0.7258086800575256,
-0.028201403096318245,
-0.031317222863435745,
0.5730668306350708,
-0.2342587262392044,
-0.4468172788619995,
-0.6425652503967285,
-0.14710108935832977,
0.5701767802238464,
0.429769903421402,
-0.5415100455284119,
0.26631760597229004,
-0.06670461595058441,
-0.00041091974708251655,
0.09232653677463531,
-0.3443421721458435,
0.6373925805091858,
0.35113146901130676,
-0.2050655484199524,
-0.13570234179496765,
0.06848215311765671,
0.6806480288505554,
-0.08466348052024841,
-0.15996241569519043,
0.008339493535459042,
-0.2022450566291809,
-0.1858208179473877,
-1.042047381401062,
0.12859241664409637,
0.29318785667419434,
-0.01678120158612728,
-0.6736543774604797,
0.6069415211677551,
-0.377145379781723,
-0.5872292518615723,
0.5887378454208374,
0.5277533531188965,
0.2358597368001938,
0.07414744794368744,
-0.7586445808410645,
0.3188022971153259,
-0.06153486669063568,
-0.5407000184059143,
0.2593081593513489,
0.5858758687973022,
0.037936389446258545,
0.7548052668571472,
0.7575731873512268,
-0.09447923302650452,
-0.3359319865703583,
0.3336109519004822,
0.5355550646781921,
-1.0074872970581055,
-0.4709259867668152,
-1.02762770652771,
0.3383629322052002,
-0.0647156611084938,
-0.10286509245634079,
0.10024780035018921,
0.09867002815008163,
0.49693819880485535,
0.2709266245365143,
0.9898396730422974,
0.23025201261043549,
0.1719527691602707,
-0.46746549010276794,
0.7935428023338318,
-0.7248286604881287,
-0.00961156003177166,
-0.32528629899024963,
-0.5348774790763855,
-0.05836046114563942,
0.8405357003211975,
-0.26871365308761597,
0.15709814429283142,
0.21963410079479218,
0.45376765727996826,
0.3573627173900604,
0.2283359318971634,
0.48982807993888855,
0.24729518592357635,
0.41074061393737793,
0.5445912480354309,
1.2168591022491455,
-0.04762624204158783,
0.11981096863746643,
-0.2056860774755478,
-0.3518746495246887,
-0.30486002564430237,
-1.3419628143310547,
-0.6832411885261536,
-0.40520215034484863,
-0.29004836082458496,
-0.17923982441425323,
-0.13541029393672943,
1.4278035163879395,
0.646904468536377,
-0.30842268466949463,
-0.23811255395412445,
0.11219904571771622,
0.04060765355825424,
0.3901159465312958,
-0.23988063633441925,
0.09289397299289703,
-0.059607189148664474,
-0.7776222825050354,
0.035984836518764496,
0.7293195128440857,
0.11505312472581863,
-0.6393339037895203,
-0.380571573972702,
0.08815215528011322,
0.5019786357879639,
0.7105393409729004,
0.005182616412639618,
-0.8947930335998535,
-0.4743228554725647,
-0.11620311439037323,
-0.39752906560897827,
-0.07048805803060532,
0.7734228372573853,
-0.340233713388443,
0.30737218260765076,
-0.00866642128676176,
1.065866470336914,
0.02406318485736847,
-0.01297598984092474,
0.7999045848846436,
-0.25169453024864197,
-0.12154284119606018,
0.7555892467498779,
0.5935589671134949,
0.5072834491729736,
-0.6021119952201843,
0.5601933002471924,
-0.046246275305747986,
-0.8303917646408081,
-0.8419828414916992,
0.44529011845588684,
-1.0170981884002686,
-0.1083255484700203,
1.27158522605896,
-0.17265324294567108,
-0.3298986256122589,
0.3168633282184601,
-0.20018360018730164,
0.2677442729473114,
-0.5343732833862305,
0.856525182723999,
0.7372193336486816,
-0.29033923149108887,
-0.27564820647239685,
-0.34393933415412903,
0.20709960162639618,
0.5522934794425964,
-1.0760856866836548,
0.2862265110015869,
0.8213801383972168,
0.18817603588104248,
-0.06451152265071869,
0.5212693214416504,
-0.11790362000465393,
0.17731477320194244,
-0.2574863135814667,
0.3852778971195221,
0.22112101316452026,
0.03787403181195259,
-0.4510367214679718,
-0.21440686285495758,
-0.15054894983768463,
0.33015745878219604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09416v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09416v1
|
Automatic Knowledge Graph Construction for Judicial Cases
| 2024-04-15T02:08:28 | 2024-04-15T02:08:28 |
Jie Zhou, Xin Chen, Hang Zhang, Zhe Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we explore the application of cognitive intelligence in legal
knowledge, focusing on the development of judicial artificial intelligence.
Utilizing natural language processing (NLP) as the core technology, we propose
a method for the automatic construction of case knowledge graphs for judicial
cases. Our approach centers on two fundamental NLP tasks: entity recognition
and relationship extraction. We compare two pre-trained models for entity
recognition to establish their efficacy. Additionally, we introduce a
multi-task semantic relationship extraction model that incorporates
translational embedding, leading to a nuanced contextualized case knowledge
representation. Specifically, in a case study involving a "Motor Vehicle
Traffic Accident Liability Dispute," our approach significantly outperforms the
baseline model. The entity recognition F1 score improved by 0.36, while the
relationship extraction F1 score increased by 2.37. Building on these results,
we detail the automatic construction process of case knowledge graphs for
judicial cases, enabling the assembly of knowledge graphs for hundreds of
thousands of judgments. This framework provides robust semantic support for
applications of judicial AI, including the precise categorization and
recommendation of related cases.
|
[
-0.4316985607147217,
-0.8863115310668945,
1.0593174695968628,
-0.14442521333694458,
-0.2809586226940155,
0.05640941485762596,
-0.2972649037837982,
-0.5978586673736572,
0.3060920238494873,
0.828804612159729,
-0.19587460160255432,
-0.4579843282699585,
-0.5373823046684265,
-0.28812792897224426,
-0.49959883093833923,
0.9108718633651733,
0.19312196969985962,
0.028573842719197273,
-0.4092938005924225,
-0.16398416459560394,
-0.7182478904724121,
-0.551695704460144,
-0.6288058757781982,
-0.15511895716190338,
0.2947990894317627,
0.13330215215682983,
0.5471143126487732,
0.55987948179245,
0.6467419862747192,
0.4281129837036133,
0.1966010481119156,
0.11380571871995926,
0.2372482717037201,
0.058217380195856094,
-0.28493553400039673,
-0.3605271279811859,
-0.6154342889785767,
0.07999768853187561,
0.14907501637935638,
0.5921557545661926,
-0.2899426519870758,
-0.023935621604323387,
-0.4897978603839874,
0.9222602844238281,
-0.5999615788459778,
0.6593647599220276,
-0.9165856242179871,
0.2913467586040497,
-0.34272095561027527,
-0.16534894704818726,
-0.49111247062683105,
-0.3234269618988037,
0.27391156554222107,
-1.0833271741867065,
0.12412289530038834,
0.44480642676353455,
0.8629653453826904,
0.5108259320259094,
-0.8483188152313232,
-0.619865357875824,
-0.6991804838180542,
0.370145320892334,
-0.5194821953773499,
0.3086576461791992,
0.33959299325942993,
0.6115298271179199,
-0.2168738692998886,
-1.1177796125411987,
-0.7709840536117554,
-0.25882530212402344,
-0.26759615540504456,
0.250606507062912,
-0.28181198239326477,
0.20485219359397888,
0.3593219220638275,
0.015519803389906883,
-0.4968215823173523,
-0.3482915461063385,
-0.43677711486816406,
-0.31785911321640015,
0.8510844111442566,
0.049574051052331924,
0.5283606648445129,
-0.45187506079673767,
0.086595319211483,
0.11862673610448837,
-0.3317088186740875,
0.15181629359722137,
0.24558156728744507,
0.3421774208545685,
0.29572707414627075,
0.6947438716888428,
-0.24449679255485535,
0.812678873538971,
0.1651678830385208,
-0.0687100887298584,
0.1918848752975464,
-0.28450047969818115,
-0.2868596017360687,
0.49008744955062866,
1.0805262327194214,
0.2914547622203827,
0.628898024559021,
-0.23699140548706055,
0.01939234882593155,
0.038901299238204956,
0.7483514547348022,
-0.23031863570213318,
-0.19250261783599854,
0.19258716702461243,
-0.4254817068576813,
-0.18575209379196167,
0.1172894686460495,
-0.2709384858608246,
-0.40816453099250793,
-0.6895555257797241,
0.04456758871674538,
-0.6959187388420105,
-0.1003611758351326,
0.1487128585577011,
-0.28297820687294006,
0.11003066599369049,
0.3256978690624237,
-0.5590202212333679,
0.46581149101257324,
0.6189383864402771,
0.3044663667678833,
0.16996829211711884,
0.3445918560028076,
-0.5472702383995056,
0.5560765862464905,
-0.1702072024345398,
0.8191035985946655,
-0.37674108147621155,
0.019779222086071968,
0.15153871476650238,
-0.03390068560838699,
-0.1593208611011505,
-0.5047628879547119,
0.81583571434021,
-0.9483774304389954,
-0.054973095655441284,
-0.02624080330133438,
-0.823183536529541,
-0.38174253702163696,
0.251162052154541,
-0.8249984383583069,
0.449055552482605,
-0.04880136251449585,
-0.7352211475372314,
0.840785562992096,
-0.9574341177940369,
-0.9077866077423096,
0.4156160056591034,
-0.4834222197532654,
-0.39960452914237976,
-0.12140502780675888,
0.3806612193584442,
0.44525644183158875,
-0.1873975247144699,
0.6156318783760071,
-0.3092731237411499,
0.15903908014297485,
-0.1680372655391693,
0.30083608627319336,
1.1878587007522583,
0.13459521532058716,
-0.1835360825061798,
-0.024938972666859627,
-0.6853326559066772,
-0.023977909237146378,
0.3179261088371277,
-0.2867364287376404,
-0.6491472721099854,
0.37460798025131226,
-0.2589365541934967,
0.23016032576560974,
0.0752645879983902,
-0.4671805500984192,
0.11063919216394424,
-0.5218619704246521,
0.6205393671989441,
0.4110695719718933,
0.2648284435272217,
0.5018788576126099,
-0.13009774684906006,
0.15394993126392365,
0.06988663226366043,
0.1162879541516304,
0.4006686508655548,
-0.7011511921882629,
-0.8032636642456055,
0.17859572172164917,
0.4164843261241913,
0.9124866127967834,
-0.8670377731323242,
0.7250290513038635,
-0.4484562873840332,
-0.23738838732242584,
-0.23730753362178802,
0.18977351486682892,
0.13926756381988525,
0.6676926016807556,
0.4842350482940674,
-0.40299972891807556,
-0.6352420449256897,
-0.9992324113845825,
-0.4499291777610779,
-0.750216007232666,
0.1968701183795929,
0.38407304883003235,
0.5717918872833252,
-0.0075701079331338406,
1.3035261631011963,
-0.47662466764450073,
-0.5367962718009949,
0.038044270128011703,
0.22965820133686066,
0.15007585287094116,
0.3810344934463501,
0.6694242358207703,
-0.9437211155891418,
-0.33658531308174133,
0.24950580298900604,
-1.1435270309448242,
0.3133041262626648,
-0.04670141264796257,
-0.31107935309410095,
-0.08281346410512924,
0.5756460428237915,
-0.7030916213989258,
0.45637914538383484,
-0.4799064099788666,
-0.5655191540718079,
0.3081718683242798,
-0.037553079426288605,
0.05163582041859627,
-0.8898911476135254,
-0.19400160014629364,
0.06816070526838303,
-0.5755249857902527,
-0.6398581862449646,
0.04306195303797722,
0.14606377482414246,
0.2752939462661743,
-0.3983108103275299,
0.1565740406513214,
-0.19775627553462982,
-0.22167958319187164,
0.009634464047849178,
0.49415838718414307,
-0.028990203514695168,
0.6346780061721802,
0.04082389920949936,
0.16556954383850098,
0.09402531385421753,
-0.5853973627090454,
0.7710290551185608,
0.32793158292770386,
-0.304313063621521,
0.8583780527114868,
-0.35108962655067444,
0.0010615326464176178,
0.041412536054849625,
-0.04805010184645653,
-0.3654477298259735,
-0.20245656371116638,
0.4183608293533325,
-0.21651461720466614,
0.40536290407180786,
-0.4266647398471832,
-0.6676208972930908,
-0.5665429830551147,
0.14711415767669678,
0.133401021361351,
0.29298558831214905,
-0.06975652277469635,
1.0361077785491943,
1.041916012763977,
-0.2277016043663025,
-0.20474115014076233,
-0.5907120704650879,
0.19225603342056274,
-0.23364178836345673,
-0.6414769887924194,
0.6340827345848083,
0.20927082002162933,
-0.5240454077720642,
0.448461651802063,
0.1252489686012268,
-0.4490954577922821,
0.13520672917366028,
0.38287997245788574,
0.09959624707698822,
-0.33247700333595276,
0.5658535361289978,
0.23662607371807098,
0.07259164750576019,
0.580529510974884,
-0.3671031892299652,
0.17731034755706787,
-0.22219668328762054,
-0.4267405569553375,
-0.33879169821739197,
0.1740947961807251,
0.3570118248462677,
-0.3601212203502655,
0.2820705473423004,
0.2545202374458313,
-0.6086153984069824,
0.03579634800553322,
-0.7549514174461365,
0.2759438753128052,
-0.42965731024742126,
0.008432148955762386,
-0.3687860071659088,
-0.7561513185501099,
0.2730351388454437,
-0.08293289691209793,
0.20954342186450958,
0.9254217147827148,
0.3687080442905426,
-0.15205205976963043,
0.7784243226051331,
0.519810140132904,
-0.38920858502388,
0.5892839431762695,
-0.01715412177145481,
0.40824437141418457,
-0.5862698554992676,
-0.07640811055898666,
-0.4560985267162323,
0.19634005427360535,
-0.42372962832450867,
0.0362667553126812,
0.3535599410533905,
0.017740119248628616,
-0.2690940797328949,
0.6375524997711182,
-0.5228300094604492,
0.2534576952457428,
0.7554705739021301,
0.1663489043712616,
0.6452583074569702,
-0.02873961254954338,
-0.2158820480108261,
0.21570833027362823,
-0.5662868022918701,
-0.46955031156539917,
1.1623940467834473,
-0.17952877283096313,
-0.13378842175006866,
0.12044460326433182,
0.6693326830863953,
0.5816836357116699,
0.11023839563131332,
-0.7600499391555786,
0.626966655254364,
-0.25897711515426636,
-0.6789332032203674,
-0.4213674068450928,
-0.41183340549468994,
-0.8770075440406799,
-0.11781681329011917,
-0.518031656742096,
-0.6057348847389221,
0.04200509563088417,
-0.17785683274269104,
-0.6054661273956299,
0.011933737434446812,
-0.7079976201057434,
0.7714536786079407,
-0.23506450653076172,
-0.07707121223211288,
-0.4039413630962372,
-0.6321486234664917,
0.5600281953811646,
0.0030639434698969126,
0.39054033160209656,
-0.058834340423345566,
0.5014829039573669,
1.0213173627853394,
-0.7182178497314453,
0.4293380677700043,
-0.20821501314640045,
0.2737654745578766,
0.6503520011901855,
-0.12218371033668518,
0.3939566910266876,
0.3061133325099945,
-0.0010306957410648465,
-0.31904083490371704,
0.03494010865688324,
-0.07273803651332855,
-0.795525312423706,
0.2921473979949951,
-0.5109769105911255,
-0.7333993315696716,
-0.30061978101730347,
-0.6273770332336426,
-0.1612098217010498,
0.37836265563964844,
-0.3323545753955841,
0.1578691303730011,
-0.11171650141477585,
-0.008000250905752182,
0.3145553171634674,
-0.007764952257275581,
0.5104084610939026,
0.6222401857376099,
0.10282100737094879,
-0.25158336758613586,
0.9353161454200745,
0.4231770634651184,
-0.4187089502811432,
0.22517921030521393,
-0.05363239347934723,
-0.07220672816038132,
-0.40388134121894836,
-0.562449038028717,
0.09866615384817123,
-0.8233287334442139,
-0.19431324303150177,
-0.7968115210533142,
-0.447383314371109,
-0.6170962452888489,
-0.046280357986688614,
-0.26680323481559753,
-0.6781233549118042,
0.11405864357948303,
-0.08341645449399948,
0.5541079640388489,
0.7446807622909546,
0.38582536578178406,
-0.10617208480834961,
-0.6549727320671082,
0.5134866237640381,
0.6968398094177246,
0.05371919646859169,
-0.33837762475013733,
-0.21352484822273254,
-0.10580285638570786,
-0.3073712885379791,
-0.2951057255268097,
-0.740747332572937,
0.15524663031101227,
0.1706259548664093,
0.6154327392578125,
0.45523205399513245,
0.34891027212142944,
0.8409079313278198,
-0.7318876385688782,
0.483752965927124,
0.0470937080681324,
-0.8659142851829529,
0.9616292119026184,
-0.13306260108947754,
-0.2629591226577759,
0.701339840888977,
0.12566342949867249,
-0.06429439783096313,
-0.6915967464447021,
-0.7759237289428711,
-0.6385529637336731,
0.6335049271583557,
0.29604387283325195,
-0.035567913204431534,
-0.014754567295312881,
0.6816091537475586,
-0.5381380319595337,
0.2835664451122284,
-0.6823959946632385,
-0.01922418735921383,
-0.15829800069332123,
-0.46311265230178833,
0.5109151601791382,
0.152350053191185,
-0.3331344723701477,
-0.5793412327766418,
0.6913812160491943,
-0.21021109819412231,
0.17001786828041077,
0.12750990688800812,
-0.4829278290271759,
0.18308159708976746,
-0.0157440397888422,
0.1361139714717865,
0.4400154948234558,
-0.09778943657875061,
0.05496034026145935,
0.11746746301651001,
-0.3213362693786621,
-0.019595613703131676,
0.3165622651576996,
-0.1756366342306137,
-0.20597173273563385,
0.613122284412384,
0.5183649063110352,
-0.1538388729095459,
-0.5784302353858948,
0.6427780985832214,
-0.415767639875412,
-0.30603161454200745,
-0.883376955986023,
0.15592840313911438,
0.27633264660835266,
0.46963781118392944,
0.17089775204658508,
-0.015804963186383247,
0.45183855295181274,
-0.7093725204467773,
0.4283539652824402,
0.499631404876709,
-0.46051353216171265,
0.27380454540252686,
0.6043097972869873,
0.027490533888339996,
-0.11515587568283081,
0.8210998773574829,
-0.5177509188652039,
-0.4583711624145508,
0.8552716374397278,
0.09892253577709198,
0.542981743812561,
0.2543841004371643,
0.007522340398281813,
0.23386196792125702,
0.3559088408946991,
-0.02732512727379799,
0.009006324224174023,
-0.22183023393154144,
-0.8373975157737732,
-0.21525335311889648,
-0.4368145763874054,
-0.2622653543949127,
-0.38826778531074524,
-0.6752821803092957,
0.2661345601081848,
-0.5988145470619202,
-0.3887660503387451,
0.3575044274330139,
0.26301702857017517,
-0.806674599647522,
0.30657318234443665,
-0.11845016479492188,
0.3872886598110199,
-0.5769513845443726,
1.0012860298156738,
0.7995802164077759,
-0.7574122548103333,
-0.7544541358947754,
-0.29138222336769104,
0.08448424935340881,
-0.5796606540679932,
0.7935811281204224,
-0.0075396159663796425,
0.18751713633537292,
-0.1280636489391327,
-0.30076104402542114,
-0.5764175653457642,
1.2002404928207397,
0.25279271602630615,
-0.6426068544387817,
-0.18959125876426697,
0.16672655940055847,
0.5537685751914978,
-0.5563026666641235,
0.11741819977760315,
0.7155956625938416,
0.5121875405311584,
-0.20863310992717743,
-0.5578354001045227,
0.40793973207473755,
-0.4754709303379059,
-0.32930898666381836,
0.16316437721252441,
-0.22233447432518005,
0.5212371945381165,
0.12559978663921356,
-0.39695775508880615,
-0.43622052669525146,
0.7081087827682495,
0.018688099458813667,
0.4234694242477417,
0.8738929629325867,
0.6900476217269897,
0.9581366181373596,
-0.2333313226699829,
1.002018690109253,
-0.7858322262763977,
0.04556950926780701,
1.1978305578231812,
-0.37248462438583374,
0.5209029316902161,
0.5842023491859436,
-0.20146793127059937,
0.6817346215248108,
0.349578857421875,
-0.206268772482872,
0.33127835392951965,
0.22079893946647644,
-0.0262761153280735,
-0.5115109086036682,
-0.28056541085243225,
0.09870780259370804,
0.21997059881687164,
0.47892042994499207,
-0.4570132791996002,
0.03537757322192192,
-0.06915891915559769,
-0.046766579151153564,
0.16210468113422394,
-0.25016382336616516,
1.0363576412200928,
0.07181249558925629,
-0.6357409954071045,
-0.19845707714557648,
0.10672852396965027,
0.015979105606675148,
-0.27485623955726624,
-0.12872184813022614,
0.3079521059989929,
-0.12271814793348312,
-0.3516811728477478,
-0.8173270225524902,
0.547297477722168,
0.017953500151634216,
-0.4105074405670166,
-0.03380083292722702,
0.9001893997192383,
-0.037207264453172684,
-0.5743405818939209,
0.5508473515510559,
0.5679458975791931,
-0.0850684866309166,
-0.1855999231338501,
-0.8716665506362915,
-0.6268762350082397,
-0.372721403837204,
-0.35601937770843506,
0.07778988033533096,
0.656838595867157,
-0.5282009840011597,
0.46235063672065735,
0.7661997675895691,
-0.0055708386935293674,
0.09742233157157898,
0.26438120007514954,
1.0752015113830566,
-0.7520216107368469,
-0.3226769268512726,
-0.7356880307197571,
0.5274720191955566,
-0.5561069846153259,
-0.13563036918640137,
0.2586480677127838,
0.3263757526874542,
0.6641169190406799,
0.3375132381916046,
0.7969827055931091,
-0.4512192904949188,
0.2833244502544403,
-0.7325168251991272,
0.7443235516548157,
-0.42636194825172424,
0.1969597488641739,
-0.361636221408844,
-0.5142166018486023,
-0.44551882147789,
0.6746276021003723,
-0.5170667767524719,
-0.2232409119606018,
0.7335091233253479,
0.47579947113990784,
-0.08882716298103333,
0.1219012588262558,
0.08521974831819534,
-0.002524228999391198,
0.3346385359764099,
0.7957053184509277,
0.40611758828163147,
-0.5296624898910522,
0.7390320301055908,
-0.2946951687335968,
0.1678282767534256,
-0.09665872156620026,
-0.6319558024406433,
-0.9489790797233582,
-0.4621303379535675,
-0.4263790547847748,
-0.10917621105909348,
-0.02916879765689373,
0.741754412651062,
0.7862085103988647,
-0.8022412657737732,
-0.09555383026599884,
-0.4536435902118683,
0.37974339723587036,
-0.11883877217769623,
-0.2807094156742096,
0.39373743534088135,
-0.5786833167076111,
-0.28759413957595825,
0.48091861605644226,
0.2989376187324524,
-0.42442548274993896,
0.21011731028556824,
-0.026368647813796997,
-0.5637943148612976,
-0.06994698196649551,
0.6176644563674927,
0.1011100634932518,
-0.7712715864181519,
-0.4634924829006195,
-0.4688779413700104,
-0.20825150609016418,
0.07976936548948288,
0.9587008357048035,
-0.7202648520469666,
0.5757772922515869,
0.3548910915851593,
0.7681093215942383,
0.6630812287330627,
-0.20246835052967072,
0.8162853121757507,
-0.5429427027702332,
0.024425843730568886,
0.11943244189023972,
0.843308687210083,
-0.08737730979919434,
-0.32919245958328247,
0.7687427997589111,
0.5240378975868225,
-0.39520108699798584,
-0.40413203835487366,
0.24582508206367493,
-1.0030717849731445,
-0.36153316497802734,
0.3995501399040222,
-0.2944139838218689,
-0.3996279239654541,
-0.629608690738678,
-0.056697893887758255,
0.6154648661613464,
-0.3453693091869354,
0.7707220911979675,
0.7904870510101318,
-0.285499632358551,
0.10910762846469879,
-1.0399296283721924,
0.5207154154777527,
0.1730792224407196,
-0.9736604690551758,
-0.4558427333831787,
0.43114304542541504,
0.19655746221542358,
0.7284313440322876,
0.6222113370895386,
-0.20315887033939362,
0.28443804383277893,
-0.13967913389205933,
0.2994436025619507,
-0.10686307400465012,
-0.11977563053369522,
0.15564551949501038,
0.5373861193656921,
-0.2848464548587799,
0.3610641360282898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09405v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09405v2
|
Few-shot Name Entity Recognition on StackOverflow
| 2024-04-15T01:43:14 | 2024-04-28T01:58:10 |
Xinwei Chen, Kun Li, Tianyou Song, Jiangjian Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
StackOverflow, with its vast question repository and limited labeled
examples, raise an annotation challenge for us. We address this gap by
proposing RoBERTa+MAML, a few-shot named entity recognition (NER) method
leveraging meta-learning. Our approach, evaluated on the StackOverflow NER
corpus (27 entity types), achieves a 5% F1 score improvement over the baseline.
We improved the results further domain-specific phrase processing enhance
results.
|
[
-0.6409156918525696,
-0.8900237083435059,
0.5495433211326599,
-0.2131316065788269,
-0.13277538120746613,
0.1395120471715927,
0.013349778018891811,
-0.6160396933555603,
0.340993732213974,
0.5994320511817932,
-0.7176575064659119,
-0.6349039673805237,
-0.8244435787200928,
0.4602798819541931,
-0.1593615859746933,
1.4393281936645508,
0.2110033631324768,
-0.0375593937933445,
-0.16316045820713043,
-0.09792565554380417,
-0.24037234485149384,
-0.28524050116539,
-0.9329620599746704,
-0.052428312599658966,
0.8392676711082458,
0.46651098132133484,
0.30347827076911926,
0.2076760083436966,
0.9892258644104004,
0.14946912229061127,
-0.10124107450246811,
0.4182604253292084,
-0.4342499375343323,
-0.002496074652299285,
-0.037411920726299286,
-0.34499281644821167,
-0.5036718845367432,
-0.13636662065982819,
0.723679780960083,
0.3432164490222931,
0.03218839690089226,
0.5252958536148071,
-0.27031591534614563,
0.25806593894958496,
-0.992561399936676,
-0.12264203280210495,
-0.8380358815193176,
0.18911997973918915,
-0.5502085089683533,
-0.32170674204826355,
-0.5979158878326416,
-0.298794150352478,
0.1319287270307541,
-0.6972372531890869,
-0.026899395510554314,
0.18364550173282623,
0.9678164124488831,
0.36314281821250916,
-0.3306080996990204,
-0.14477233588695526,
-0.7324743866920471,
0.9335106611251831,
-0.4779216945171356,
-0.025063466280698776,
0.3307766616344452,
0.7184821367263794,
-0.14694064855575562,
-0.5236068367958069,
-0.6847922801971436,
0.21566255390644073,
-0.21023790538311005,
0.024972524493932724,
-0.43386152386665344,
-0.16604186594486237,
0.37174856662750244,
0.0007230043411254883,
-0.5581146478652954,
-0.027935326099395752,
-0.6553203463554382,
-0.12474376708269119,
0.45498523116111755,
0.43234983086586,
0.33540210127830505,
-0.37337756156921387,
-0.5808818936347961,
0.2747207581996918,
-0.8882984519004822,
-0.3789431154727936,
0.11864504963159561,
0.3068249523639679,
0.2438679337501526,
0.46124154329299927,
0.07834090292453766,
0.9678027033805847,
0.07105182111263275,
-0.17976397275924683,
0.44274982810020447,
-0.05404447019100189,
-0.24412193894386292,
-0.06334751099348068,
0.5974738597869873,
-0.03204105794429779,
0.13428062200546265,
-0.14084216952323914,
0.11638762056827545,
-0.4367271065711975,
0.2646065652370453,
-0.851071834564209,
-0.05282583087682724,
0.33081668615341187,
-0.2117958813905716,
-0.1341148167848587,
0.3439392149448395,
-0.6677426695823669,
-0.3796364963054657,
0.11378424614667892,
0.4188517928123474,
-0.37756723165512085,
-0.27464354038238525,
-0.2902073264122009,
-0.5406705141067505,
0.3394691050052643,
0.7016133069992065,
-0.6542273759841919,
0.2897220551967621,
0.8838217854499817,
0.8831414580345154,
-0.32496798038482666,
-0.26048514246940613,
-0.7062064409255981,
0.3592851758003235,
-0.1297895461320877,
1.2501276731491089,
-0.7223041653633118,
-0.5287408232688904,
-0.28743958473205566,
-0.1310250461101532,
0.08155564218759537,
-0.5626766681671143,
0.25696128606796265,
-0.6563721895217896,
0.39659810066223145,
-0.07253667712211609,
-0.765126645565033,
-0.211903914809227,
0.5527343153953552,
-0.6682437062263489,
0.8285282850265503,
0.048429686576128006,
-0.8146568536758423,
0.6852276921272278,
-0.8758247494697571,
-0.38793912529945374,
0.4384501874446869,
-0.13235263526439667,
-0.444517582654953,
-0.040435973554849625,
0.059756215661764145,
0.3339533507823944,
-0.035148557275533676,
-0.33225560188293457,
-0.07717226445674896,
-0.26273590326309204,
0.2936665117740631,
-0.0035937661305069923,
0.6810263395309448,
0.022037753835320473,
-0.04619913548231125,
-0.18811681866645813,
-0.9653878211975098,
0.2710402309894562,
-0.07932490110397339,
-0.3528159558773041,
-0.5417494773864746,
-0.3729078769683838,
0.26745161414146423,
0.276405394077301,
-0.1417081207036972,
-0.4375523328781128,
0.563138484954834,
-0.41266998648643494,
0.18950508534908295,
0.2880977988243103,
0.4548453986644745,
0.5802684426307678,
-0.24179954826831818,
0.7605754137039185,
0.037792034447193146,
0.03830458223819733,
-0.20807141065597534,
-0.7573966383934021,
-0.6287659406661987,
-0.6075511574745178,
0.5826860070228577,
0.5764321088790894,
-0.5509331822395325,
0.13349655270576477,
-0.14155009388923645,
-0.46590960025787354,
-0.7139156460762024,
0.23639017343521118,
0.6120914220809937,
0.616418719291687,
0.8322372436523438,
-0.13308602571487427,
-0.8219509720802307,
-0.7647435069084167,
-0.21075573563575745,
0.07655343413352966,
-0.15543092787265778,
0.6354581117630005,
0.8586063385009766,
-0.285380095243454,
0.9850930571556091,
-0.8125988841056824,
-0.7805752754211426,
-0.19139303267002106,
0.8233683705329895,
0.3344566226005554,
0.3462457060813904,
0.47312358021736145,
-0.7506957054138184,
-0.6139853596687317,
-0.2393561601638794,
-0.3814411461353302,
0.025505375117063522,
0.0743025690317154,
-0.14391225576400757,
0.191497802734375,
0.29255878925323486,
-0.7558964490890503,
0.291292279958725,
0.24704509973526,
0.1452246457338333,
0.2041240632534027,
0.2666718065738678,
0.10775452107191086,
-1.301992654800415,
-0.047201793640851974,
-0.2098204493522644,
-0.38680151104927063,
-0.4189773201942444,
0.066561758518219,
-0.0648169219493866,
-0.16749270260334015,
-0.958811342716217,
0.851086437702179,
-0.8343042731285095,
-0.19003044068813324,
-0.551396906375885,
0.3800237476825714,
-0.03141478821635246,
0.10814495384693146,
0.29678934812545776,
0.6642404198646545,
0.6049571633338928,
-0.7360476851463318,
0.19786393642425537,
0.37087997794151306,
0.020842157304286957,
0.9255943894386292,
-0.5293536186218262,
0.3068428635597229,
-0.1764284074306488,
0.5828683972358704,
-0.937114417552948,
-0.37705671787261963,
0.1676078885793686,
-0.6016426086425781,
0.31012433767318726,
-0.5935710668563843,
-0.4243987500667572,
-0.23883438110351562,
-0.2646808326244354,
0.3039945065975189,
0.6001556515693665,
-0.378569632768631,
0.5208807587623596,
0.473305881023407,
0.20045359432697296,
-0.6477818489074707,
-0.9313815236091614,
0.09246887266635895,
-0.08297041803598404,
-0.24175657331943512,
0.6219875812530518,
0.28008317947387695,
-0.13274532556533813,
0.21963919699192047,
0.17549684643745422,
-0.5352478623390198,
-0.05558754876255989,
0.36161917448043823,
0.1779938042163849,
-0.4066334366798401,
0.5476546287536621,
-0.3606972396373749,
-0.5620501041412354,
-0.2918509840965271,
-0.2115628570318222,
0.35259202122688293,
-0.19742098450660706,
-0.17485453188419342,
-0.43836137652397156,
0.2748200595378876,
0.1605461686849594,
-0.3508952856063843,
0.800054669380188,
0.8455963730812073,
-0.6590186357498169,
-0.531948983669281,
-0.48434311151504517,
-0.194501593708992,
-0.3786020874977112,
-0.09644574671983719,
-0.29272064566612244,
-0.9629338383674622,
0.33739039301872253,
-0.08533844351768494,
-0.09246997535228729,
0.8748049736022949,
0.2937549352645874,
-0.24051080644130707,
0.4965437352657318,
0.660057783126831,
-0.06699220091104507,
0.28722769021987915,
-0.2916630506515503,
0.056934092193841934,
-1.068219542503357,
0.02959185652434826,
-0.4977557957172394,
-0.4332042336463928,
-0.3831557631492615,
-0.6092101335525513,
0.4406244158744812,
-0.0915716141462326,
0.12003833055496216,
0.764313280582428,
-0.6372736692428589,
0.8448715209960938,
0.4030821621417999,
-0.032968029379844666,
0.3548091948032379,
-0.5876498222351074,
0.21549680829048157,
-0.11554792523384094,
-0.26954495906829834,
-0.4478788673877716,
1.0649752616882324,
0.012532382272183895,
0.648757815361023,
0.3848743140697479,
1.2049685716629028,
0.18933451175689697,
0.47126147150993347,
-0.7302958369255066,
0.46171683073043823,
0.028475336730480194,
-1.199242115020752,
-0.2846382260322571,
-0.32001975178718567,
-0.7897801995277405,
-0.06124357879161835,
-0.5945743322372437,
-0.7755228877067566,
-0.10408084839582443,
0.07688121497631073,
-0.6911288499832153,
0.1544259935617447,
-0.3520236909389496,
0.8464451432228088,
-0.26550307869911194,
-0.059235550463199615,
-0.10644474625587463,
-0.5847876667976379,
0.47229287028312683,
-0.00469457171857357,
0.014402208849787712,
-0.15338678658008575,
-0.2490914911031723,
0.4106723666191101,
-0.3904103934764862,
0.7479510307312012,
-0.063304103910923,
0.2790285646915436,
0.4249752163887024,
-0.0860806554555893,
0.3455357849597931,
0.2242642343044281,
0.05845861881971359,
0.22691000998020172,
-0.18628817796707153,
-0.2491927295923233,
-0.6055466532707214,
0.527987539768219,
-0.2811143100261688,
-0.3004991114139557,
-0.5505474805831909,
-0.06942154467105865,
-0.021594783291220665,
0.36774757504463196,
0.5278165340423584,
0.1823585331439972,
-0.34032633900642395,
0.17763882875442505,
0.590509295463562,
0.03608599677681923,
0.4087705612182617,
0.6200292110443115,
-0.38094979524612427,
-0.36444932222366333,
0.5512906908988953,
0.2555420994758606,
0.061349838972091675,
0.7735453248023987,
-0.11556095629930496,
-0.057996395975351334,
-0.377197265625,
-0.6471102237701416,
0.09353160113096237,
-0.7057623267173767,
-0.6073336601257324,
-0.8341185450553894,
-0.394817978143692,
-0.15004928410053253,
-0.24855539202690125,
-0.21868440508842468,
-0.5335791110992432,
-0.5885258316993713,
-0.11480129510164261,
0.7140262126922607,
0.5690064430236816,
0.3769840896129608,
0.3243245780467987,
-1.0017626285552979,
0.4231298565864563,
0.3040544390678406,
-0.03387051448225975,
-0.3602547347545624,
-0.5452064275741577,
0.17950287461280823,
-0.31748566031455994,
-0.1488104611635208,
-1.0209050178527832,
0.03121228516101837,
0.6027010679244995,
0.5311477184295654,
0.5002859830856323,
-0.016376525163650513,
0.8821449875831604,
-0.781956136226654,
0.6609025001525879,
0.11127409338951111,
-0.8487887382507324,
0.9404356479644775,
-0.002396214287728071,
0.290103018283844,
0.7095917463302612,
0.7217196226119995,
-0.24802087247371674,
-0.33791354298591614,
-0.8679265379905701,
-0.5920731425285339,
0.2554545998573303,
0.0829152762889862,
0.41166552901268005,
-0.369245320558548,
0.3623858094215393,
0.1204300969839096,
0.033757664263248444,
-0.6719364523887634,
-0.1247493177652359,
0.4193960726261139,
0.0037327674217522144,
0.3398546576499939,
-0.24509717524051666,
-0.032857123762369156,
-0.0964990183711052,
0.6362998485565186,
-0.0816144272685051,
0.11616601794958115,
0.06525348871946335,
-0.41056370735168457,
-0.09268592298030853,
0.5844870805740356,
0.6845138669013977,
0.6464235782623291,
-0.16256818175315857,
0.15160442888736725,
0.6372561454772949,
-0.2628270387649536,
-0.1386861503124237,
-0.23774339258670807,
-0.23009184002876282,
0.4287271797657013,
0.4297463595867157,
0.5671663880348206,
0.6267263889312744,
-0.5456854701042175,
0.7310559749603271,
0.21789894998073578,
-0.030609868466854095,
-0.4922725260257721,
0.3697417974472046,
-0.013291679322719574,
0.4060361981391907,
0.5779151916503906,
0.10633666068315506,
0.3692742586135864,
-0.5876563787460327,
0.5297955870628357,
0.651560366153717,
-0.43882519006729126,
-0.13389071822166443,
0.4829080402851105,
0.2088787853717804,
-0.4388766884803772,
0.40724945068359375,
-0.4872194528579712,
-0.5499923229217529,
0.5027770400047302,
0.6676213145256042,
0.8183223009109497,
0.009480871260166168,
0.28063061833381653,
0.6959769129753113,
0.20038700103759766,
0.03563001751899719,
0.24457114934921265,
-0.14537200331687927,
-0.6067965626716614,
-0.12879638373851776,
-0.5701834559440613,
-0.7943395972251892,
-0.24831588566303253,
-0.49897000193595886,
0.7029693126678467,
-0.790520191192627,
-0.5279883146286011,
0.4924413859844208,
-0.13183175027370453,
-0.5301944613456726,
0.21674679219722748,
0.11169964075088501,
0.7249537706375122,
-0.5820448994636536,
0.7097587585449219,
0.7361766695976257,
-1.0483404397964478,
-0.3891023099422455,
0.039236005395650864,
0.2852500379085541,
-0.6641520261764526,
1.149051547050476,
0.12525418400764465,
-0.29423263669013977,
0.15777117013931274,
-0.42743945121765137,
-0.7622722387313843,
1.1914914846420288,
-0.18284352123737335,
-0.4349087178707123,
0.11439122259616852,
-0.30728989839553833,
0.6211357116699219,
-0.5548878312110901,
0.5148512125015259,
0.06929104030132294,
0.6310931444168091,
0.21900320053100586,
-0.7045997977256775,
-0.2338600903749466,
-0.15859946608543396,
-0.16666297614574432,
0.5473166108131409,
-0.40852034091949463,
0.8772078156471252,
-0.4829038679599762,
-0.3886086642742157,
-0.013701123185455799,
0.6380569934844971,
0.15337923169136047,
0.4195401966571808,
0.29605913162231445,
0.7388743758201599,
0.8750216364860535,
-0.13092872500419617,
0.9460608959197998,
0.09667250514030457,
0.6325615644454956,
1.4413515329360962,
-0.34777262806892395,
1.4885529279708862,
0.4538944363594055,
-0.29512569308280945,
0.6983485221862793,
0.31358495354652405,
-0.4847259223461151,
0.5372233390808105,
0.26330235600471497,
-0.2320163995027542,
-0.11167064309120178,
-0.08858612179756165,
-0.31078511476516724,
0.5692912340164185,
0.314190149307251,
-0.42270129919052124,
-0.33124592900276184,
0.131508469581604,
0.05386403575539589,
-0.25257158279418945,
-0.3178127706050873,
1.0845049619674683,
0.14501813054084778,
-0.3590916395187378,
0.332986980676651,
-0.08428226411342621,
0.7603819370269775,
-0.2897135317325592,
-0.2684267461299896,
0.10151709616184235,
0.0071090348064899445,
-0.48917698860168457,
-0.7588059306144714,
0.5783751606941223,
0.3414362668991089,
-0.26842620968818665,
0.03446916118264198,
0.9201942086219788,
-0.41697028279304504,
-0.5010668635368347,
0.13679271936416626,
0.4543446898460388,
0.46058329939842224,
-0.04322769120335579,
-0.5848487019538879,
-0.45852914452552795,
-0.7000011801719666,
0.12555864453315735,
0.053180769085884094,
0.5210196375846863,
0.19203312695026398,
0.4441106617450714,
0.5586779713630676,
0.049567561596632004,
0.3391965627670288,
0.02884601801633835,
0.529054582118988,
-0.6403510570526123,
-0.26204168796539307,
-0.9995246529579163,
0.6167385578155518,
-0.2824600636959076,
-0.8116593360900879,
0.8550763726234436,
0.4954286515712738,
0.8637776970863342,
-0.32153186202049255,
0.6190938353538513,
-0.07540884613990784,
0.7917458415031433,
-0.6005619764328003,
0.606665313243866,
-0.6576961874961853,
0.040354080498218536,
-0.4593411684036255,
-0.9151976704597473,
-0.7859395146369934,
0.5499538779258728,
-0.402431845664978,
-0.03628816083073616,
0.7575629949569702,
0.4558323323726654,
-0.2493060678243637,
-0.3107326328754425,
0.28549182415008545,
-0.17734529078006744,
-0.13759106397628784,
0.7256858944892883,
0.9287273287773132,
-0.6099085211753845,
0.618201732635498,
0.05606890097260475,
0.17783237993717194,
-0.7700915932655334,
-1.1113455295562744,
-0.907761812210083,
-0.28369271755218506,
-0.5026775002479553,
-0.19157272577285767,
0.09765069931745529,
0.8138444423675537,
0.8906198143959045,
-1.0167449712753296,
0.5276464819908142,
-0.03036683425307274,
0.3948279917240143,
-0.061973366886377335,
-0.24783213436603546,
0.03783538565039635,
-0.38760700821876526,
-0.603073000907898,
0.1806713491678238,
0.6534349918365479,
-0.17028449475765228,
-0.21138836443424225,
0.03301339969038963,
-0.4020940661430359,
-0.05297698453068733,
0.3950662314891815,
0.5857411026954651,
-0.7915806174278259,
-0.3849540054798126,
0.025876542553305626,
-0.3675476014614105,
0.23765400052070618,
0.6201066374778748,
-0.48236867785453796,
0.19014166295528412,
0.64707350730896,
1.0245838165283203,
0.5217450261116028,
0.2610974609851837,
0.0830957293510437,
-1.0853389501571655,
0.043660592287778854,
0.48337024450302124,
0.23619545996189117,
0.2485378384590149,
-0.41545045375823975,
0.5573081970214844,
0.08602410554885864,
-0.4412120580673218,
-0.5475339293479919,
0.2800147235393524,
-1.01237154006958,
-0.1400313377380371,
1.1137900352478027,
-0.13258302211761475,
-0.3324611485004425,
-0.03002302534878254,
-0.19154101610183716,
-0.18898773193359375,
-0.27098020911216736,
0.6030436158180237,
0.7340507507324219,
-0.2052585780620575,
-0.6342494487762451,
-0.6223280429840088,
0.4336201846599579,
0.12340240180492401,
-1.2851325273513794,
-0.5821719169616699,
0.4564204514026642,
0.49398288130760193,
0.5896448493003845,
0.7924099564552307,
-0.13221175968647003,
0.50721275806427,
-0.18997471034526825,
0.04972952976822853,
0.024431083351373672,
-0.6588195562362671,
-0.22553786635398865,
0.21160466969013214,
-0.005357441026717424,
-0.4615546762943268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09385v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09385v2
|
A Large-Scale Evaluation of Speech Foundation Models
| 2024-04-15T00:03:16 | 2024-05-29T21:24:40 |
Shu-wen Yang, Heng-Jui Chang, Zili Huang, Andy T. Liu, Cheng-I Lai, Haibin Wu, Jiatong Shi, Xuankai Chang, Hsiang-Sheng Tsai, Wen-Chin Huang, Tzu-hsun Feng, Po-Han Chi, Yist Y. Lin, Yung-Sung Chuang, Tzu-Hsien Huang, Wei-Cheng Tseng, Kushal Lakhotia, Shang-Wen Li, Abdelrahman Mohamed, Shinji Watanabe, Hung-yi Lee
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, eess.SP
|
The foundation model paradigm leverages a shared foundation model to achieve
state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance for various tasks, requiring minimal
downstream-specific modeling and data annotation. This approach has proven
crucial in the field of Natural Language Processing (NLP). However, the speech
processing community lacks a similar setup to explore the paradigm
systematically. In this work, we establish the Speech processing Universal
PERformance Benchmark (SUPERB) to study the effectiveness of the paradigm for
speech. We propose a unified multi-tasking framework to address speech
processing tasks in SUPERB using a frozen foundation model followed by
task-specialized, lightweight prediction heads. Combining our results with
community submissions, we verify that the foundation model paradigm is
promising for speech, and our multi-tasking framework is simple yet effective,
as the best-performing foundation model shows competitive generalizability
across most SUPERB tasks. For reproducibility and extensibility, we have
developed a long-term maintained platform that enables deterministic
benchmarking, allows for result sharing via an online leaderboard, and promotes
collaboration through a community-driven benchmark database to support new
development cycles. Finally, we conduct a series of analyses to offer an
in-depth understanding of SUPERB and speech foundation models, including
information flows across tasks inside the models, the correctness of the
weighted-sum benchmarking protocol and the statistical significance and
robustness of the benchmark.
|
[
-0.41449618339538574,
-0.6757276654243469,
-0.025386806577444077,
0.5143126249313354,
-0.11351639032363892,
-0.01552846934646368,
-0.2356949895620346,
-0.6044209003448486,
0.11715138703584671,
0.5188376903533936,
-0.4720797836780548,
-0.3395096957683563,
-0.5837214589118958,
-0.02404714934527874,
-0.7116224765777588,
0.6624583005905151,
0.5625199675559998,
0.23727230727672577,
-0.196044459939003,
-0.19205766916275024,
-0.4537528455257416,
-0.5243604183197021,
-0.5110327005386353,
-0.6481602191925049,
-0.3050774037837982,
0.17753320932388306,
0.5042019486427307,
0.6106482148170471,
0.49636033177375793,
0.24360600113868713,
-0.24016636610031128,
-0.349875807762146,
-0.5254226326942444,
0.19455252587795258,
-0.34206515550613403,
-0.05622369050979614,
-0.5515047907829285,
-0.08058851957321167,
0.7509701251983643,
0.9855173826217651,
-0.5072796940803528,
0.3031371533870697,
0.17802780866622925,
0.5443130731582642,
-0.6165646910667419,
0.2669343054294586,
-0.6571720838546753,
-0.06415143609046936,
-0.33912140130996704,
0.11659235507249832,
-0.16934244334697723,
-0.041002027690410614,
0.3422822952270508,
-0.26398810744285583,
0.18565261363983154,
-0.387531578540802,
0.29418420791625977,
0.25986921787261963,
-0.04676024615764618,
-0.039333198219537735,
-0.6196406483650208,
0.6566635966300964,
-0.6256030201911926,
0.7167361378669739,
0.015430334024131298,
0.3284853994846344,
-0.13920511305332184,
-0.6661739349365234,
-0.4722256362438202,
-0.37670812010765076,
0.3543654680252075,
-0.1331317275762558,
-0.48824647068977356,
0.04314641281962395,
-0.0009604994556866586,
0.47591838240623474,
-0.6183685660362244,
0.021651947870850563,
0.04104385897517204,
-0.32693490386009216,
0.48521846532821655,
-0.05475464463233948,
0.011033543385565281,
-0.16680458188056946,
-0.4235022962093353,
-0.13432861864566803,
-0.44601160287857056,
0.23636476695537567,
-0.35401642322540283,
0.7480241656303406,
-0.15154536068439484,
0.35622674226760864,
-0.6977981328964233,
0.8132635951042175,
-0.16300925612449646,
-0.2603808045387268,
0.24416519701480865,
-0.3631996214389801,
-0.44468820095062256,
-0.07700307667255402,
0.7531325817108154,
0.20287062227725983,
0.21805638074874878,
-0.5473122000694275,
-0.062021974474191666,
0.4844862222671509,
0.056799113750457764,
-0.6933425068855286,
0.10673435032367706,
-0.08136112242937088,
-0.05722489207983017,
-0.009677008725702763,
-0.3094007968902588,
-0.636181652545929,
-0.44373026490211487,
-0.5159009695053101,
0.37511390447616577,
-0.16156868636608124,
-0.4243810176849365,
0.3075004816055298,
0.009088021703064442,
-0.12209741026163101,
-0.07748047262430191,
-0.8729517459869385,
0.8484951853752136,
0.8609460592269897,
0.7260342240333557,
-0.4031731188297272,
-0.2926439940929413,
-0.7573648691177368,
0.08057272434234619,
-0.24982236325740814,
0.8821008205413818,
-0.6430641412734985,
-0.2968749403953552,
-0.24105273187160492,
-0.4106769859790802,
-0.16485242545604706,
-0.6247169971466064,
0.697475254535675,
-0.16016021370887756,
-0.43102121353149414,
-0.251884788274765,
-0.5682300925254822,
0.010609878227114677,
-0.049370527267456055,
-0.6305710077285767,
0.946942925453186,
-0.20518261194229126,
-0.40004023909568787,
0.29791346192359924,
-0.7449140548706055,
-0.49885156750679016,
0.0684373527765274,
-0.32552438974380493,
0.033407390117645264,
0.23315061628818512,
0.11711128056049347,
0.8131574392318726,
-0.717555046081543,
0.8559024333953857,
-0.09403883665800095,
-0.45669224858283997,
-0.07897938042879105,
-0.30973660945892334,
0.673353910446167,
0.026088589802384377,
-0.8716148734092712,
0.09930278360843658,
-1.0214121341705322,
-0.002806543605402112,
-0.22035565972328186,
-0.14757220447063446,
0.016204705461859703,
-0.21044570207595825,
0.39075687527656555,
0.17891202867031097,
-0.03377789631485939,
-0.537001371383667,
-0.22159507870674133,
-0.26724523305892944,
0.7538824677467346,
0.5308284759521484,
-0.4435269236564636,
0.14641839265823364,
-0.061079125851392746,
0.273110568523407,
-0.5200886130332947,
-0.06680629402399063,
0.047410737723112106,
-0.5706668496131897,
-0.4648135304450989,
-0.22582198679447174,
0.41181474924087524,
0.40215224027633667,
-0.18857836723327637,
0.28834646940231323,
-0.37371590733528137,
-0.6074807047843933,
-0.3666226267814636,
-0.00715996278449893,
0.7294417023658752,
0.5750759840011597,
0.45512181520462036,
-0.5879230499267578,
-0.5513925552368164,
-0.954900324344635,
-0.15542389452457428,
0.13551540672779083,
0.12692713737487793,
0.1540418267250061,
0.38049283623695374,
-0.09638351202011108,
1.0320147275924683,
-0.09841505438089371,
-0.3019036650657654,
-0.19723686575889587,
0.33861243724823,
0.24646110832691193,
0.6703673005104065,
0.29037362337112427,
-0.8580290675163269,
-0.20003099739551544,
-0.29341012239456177,
-0.6672517657279968,
0.012534667737782001,
0.38539204001426697,
0.027398621663451195,
0.04315713420510292,
0.24213847517967224,
-0.6881862878799438,
0.19025906920433044,
0.7744607329368591,
-0.19464056193828583,
0.7933687567710876,
0.24184247851371765,
0.1844780445098877,
-0.7161669731140137,
0.4550870358943939,
0.1230938732624054,
-0.08649847656488419,
-0.7802953124046326,
0.46935516595840454,
-0.257555216550827,
-0.38969993591308594,
-0.23661188781261444,
0.3723136782646179,
0.021828925237059593,
-0.538599967956543,
-0.08215244114398956,
0.1681010127067566,
-0.1115693673491478,
0.3552491366863251,
0.10998419672250748,
0.8316056132316589,
0.9040820598602295,
-0.5411251783370972,
0.3295539617538452,
-0.014915334060788155,
-0.5228736400604248,
0.8898977637290955,
-0.9075403809547424,
0.1714993119239807,
0.1758742481470108,
0.39397668838500977,
-1.1280063390731812,
-0.20502953231334686,
-0.30537039041519165,
-0.3750365972518921,
0.1578059196472168,
0.18180593848228455,
-0.47622162103652954,
-0.32396623492240906,
0.010102055966854095,
-0.022454971447587013,
0.1209566742181778,
-0.2884116470813751,
0.5948299169540405,
0.7969498634338379,
-0.35078439116477966,
-0.6880704760551453,
-0.6556861400604248,
0.3015524446964264,
0.03270348906517029,
-0.8328056931495667,
0.6471272110939026,
-0.23168325424194336,
-0.10279998928308487,
-0.1897219866514206,
-0.5973727703094482,
-0.2096954584121704,
0.22621871531009674,
0.3677334189414978,
-0.14888358116149902,
-0.4137798249721527,
0.10824912786483765,
-0.14698626101016998,
-0.3551871180534363,
-0.10223189741373062,
-0.1633540540933609,
0.6740255951881409,
-0.49499455094337463,
-0.06372591853141785,
-0.7352457642555237,
0.4068428575992584,
0.6838781237602234,
-0.36450082063674927,
0.3257010281085968,
0.48152104020118713,
-0.7606868743896484,
-0.02087751030921936,
-0.8235576748847961,
-0.09787870943546295,
-0.3577537536621094,
0.3904542326927185,
-0.5683707594871521,
-1.0811359882354736,
0.350521057844162,
-0.087409608066082,
0.25602662563323975,
0.47413814067840576,
0.3580990731716156,
0.1596936732530594,
0.8299995064735413,
0.8290237188339233,
-0.2848649024963379,
-0.013601480983197689,
-0.3787473440170288,
-0.17416809499263763,
-0.7450050115585327,
-0.1575852781534195,
-0.9368429780006409,
0.05911434069275856,
0.11220324039459229,
-0.5044746994972229,
0.16730915009975433,
0.5666059255599976,
-0.09316909313201904,
0.5842266082763672,
-0.5589147210121155,
0.25424379110336304,
0.5026516318321228,
-0.23079295456409454,
0.5119034647941589,
0.123112753033638,
-0.24937456846237183,
0.0028118824120610952,
-0.5457146763801575,
-0.46008387207984924,
1.0542010068893433,
0.04740510135889053,
0.25785496830940247,
-0.05198925733566284,
0.3448622524738312,
0.38316699862480164,
0.3779863119125366,
-0.31648972630500793,
0.6237339377403259,
-0.6606222987174988,
-0.6882402896881104,
-0.5684718489646912,
-0.31937864422798157,
-0.6160448789596558,
0.6156647205352783,
-0.40019649267196655,
-1.0918325185775757,
-0.05182337388396263,
0.17758579552173615,
-0.5096343755722046,
-0.06209782138466835,
-0.4354472756385803,
0.9876505732536316,
0.29856806993484497,
-0.21583308279514313,
-0.5860828161239624,
-0.5156631469726562,
0.28730371594429016,
-0.05332427844405174,
0.358633428812027,
-0.3475227355957031,
0.45231664180755615,
0.9744287133216858,
0.08586358278989792,
0.6913086771965027,
-0.14905370771884918,
0.10263113677501678,
0.1384361833333969,
-0.08447955548763275,
0.17331303656101227,
0.013831174932420254,
-0.5217781066894531,
0.45767030119895935,
-0.022662531584501266,
-0.06435418874025345,
-0.3100285232067108,
0.9079686403274536,
-0.6042733788490295,
-0.4009695053100586,
0.05026180297136307,
-0.47015494108200073,
-0.6949455142021179,
0.33670660853385925,
-0.010639702901244164,
0.9408300518989563,
-0.49594196677207947,
0.6879467368125916,
0.4866257607936859,
0.3786037564277649,
0.31170013546943665,
0.6754158735275269,
-0.059103742241859436,
-0.31102725863456726,
0.7243727445602417,
0.26215124130249023,
0.09682674705982208,
0.4784625172615051,
0.3882807195186615,
-0.5127021670341492,
-0.6581451296806335,
-0.5945835113525391,
-0.08000867068767548,
-0.5194852948188782,
0.03395720571279526,
-0.7788406610488892,
0.027217956259846687,
-0.7569672465324402,
0.014760403893887997,
-0.7151803374290466,
-0.41520535945892334,
0.12817831337451935,
-0.06190745159983635,
-0.07505756616592407,
0.5740262269973755,
-0.32700616121292114,
0.20652908086776733,
-0.4141518473625183,
0.6592906713485718,
0.5662478804588318,
0.5232488512992859,
0.2195325791835785,
-0.1637548953294754,
0.02832934632897377,
0.2033642828464508,
-0.1857600063085556,
-0.6132336854934692,
-0.22810083627700806,
0.5303678512573242,
0.8799678683280945,
0.12984082102775574,
-0.032463088631629944,
0.6935843229293823,
-0.4569850265979767,
0.7268425226211548,
0.3414233326911926,
-1.4153797626495361,
0.3625516891479492,
-0.23518610000610352,
0.322214812040329,
0.7594751715660095,
0.12074333429336548,
-0.534270167350769,
-0.277445912361145,
-0.4424094259738922,
-0.6704189777374268,
0.5463691353797913,
0.23663467168807983,
-0.053712259978055954,
0.1462189108133316,
0.08969495445489883,
0.16503751277923584,
0.5242785811424255,
-0.466645747423172,
-0.5017267465591431,
-0.15836557745933533,
0.29954326152801514,
-0.3670370280742645,
0.00125249067787081,
-0.3285728991031647,
-0.16119971871376038,
0.6351630091667175,
-0.14746257662773132,
0.047387003898620605,
-0.07157520204782486,
0.0033151109237223864,
-0.2104664444923401,
0.49401214718818665,
0.48993465304374695,
1.0637898445129395,
-0.18241912126541138,
-0.056102924048900604,
-0.03193691000342369,
-0.3132944703102112,
0.01263743732124567,
0.5345444083213806,
0.024961261078715324,
0.02811538614332676,
0.35211095213890076,
0.7408480048179626,
0.8040821552276611,
-0.7381448149681091,
0.5133457183837891,
0.005669584963470697,
-0.05145540088415146,
0.23132644593715668,
0.08905486017465591,
0.41254639625549316,
0.2277565747499466,
0.6077007055282593,
0.4482501745223999,
0.5201311707496643,
-0.6006350517272949,
0.490768164396286,
0.45622187852859497,
-0.4888933300971985,
-0.23729273676872253,
0.6758458614349365,
0.3396872580051422,
-0.362522691488266,
0.19852052628993988,
-0.06756337732076645,
-0.3345138430595398,
0.6366764307022095,
0.6642524600028992,
0.6852834224700928,
-0.4475462734699249,
0.4086933135986328,
0.17146821320056915,
0.1185198724269867,
-0.3723274767398834,
0.2857441306114197,
-0.36003267765045166,
-0.5806413292884827,
-0.7288206815719604,
-0.9028690457344055,
-0.41200149059295654,
0.24782872200012207,
-0.9618158936500549,
-0.2011082023382187,
-0.3146783113479614,
-0.3125404417514801,
0.49584680795669556,
-0.012407734990119934,
-0.7067019939422607,
0.5090098977088928,
0.27555862069129944,
0.9618523120880127,
-0.7982757687568665,
0.6632292866706848,
0.5591140389442444,
0.09992499649524689,
-0.7603397369384766,
-0.18158487975597382,
0.14963674545288086,
-0.7720949649810791,
0.37341073155403137,
0.5276158452033997,
-0.4964670240879059,
0.11078193783760071,
-0.24786989390850067,
-1.106685757637024,
0.9203265309333801,
0.7746082544326782,
-0.741966187953949,
0.16683539748191833,
0.19343788921833038,
0.6804016828536987,
-0.40790101885795593,
-0.032601743936538696,
0.6930612325668335,
0.1726682186126709,
0.24873560667037964,
-1.4562276601791382,
0.055959928780794144,
-0.21513371169567108,
0.057778969407081604,
-0.08706823736429214,
-0.481584370136261,
0.8149164915084839,
-0.10333751142024994,
-0.3470381796360016,
0.1575663983821869,
0.5633786916732788,
0.561464786529541,
0.30570194125175476,
0.6508898138999939,
0.7603762745857239,
0.7400895953178406,
-0.08517605811357498,
0.7183035016059875,
-0.39460891485214233,
0.34955066442489624,
1.2148559093475342,
-0.3534202575683594,
1.210286021232605,
0.15086351335048676,
-0.4404923915863037,
0.20228521525859833,
0.04945896938443184,
0.3386450409889221,
0.5853408575057983,
0.44592198729515076,
0.03307779133319855,
-0.4138927459716797,
-0.6050899028778076,
-0.8239985704421997,
0.7409210801124573,
0.2476617991924286,
0.12477367371320724,
-0.3136618435382843,
0.15033137798309326,
-0.22161419689655304,
0.10713845491409302,
-0.43497300148010254,
0.3514082133769989,
0.11139529198408127,
-0.5195161700248718,
0.6503041386604309,
-0.023307036608457565,
0.7906337976455688,
-0.5970568060874939,
0.07482638955116272,
0.017720988020300865,
0.07977809756994247,
-0.04839686304330826,
-0.377708375453949,
0.27528926730155945,
0.06391026824712753,
-0.28563958406448364,
-0.13419665396213531,
0.4540296494960785,
-0.06389334052801132,
-0.37469005584716797,
0.5111899971961975,
0.3205296993255615,
0.07858607918024063,
-0.30786222219467163,
-0.7736752033233643,
0.4340737462043762,
-0.3079420328140259,
-0.17670470476150513,
0.3248836100101471,
-0.10329807549715042,
0.10189182311296463,
0.7200379371643066,
0.7544437050819397,
0.06396268308162689,
-0.07987432181835175,
0.41250094771385193,
0.7320888638496399,
-0.34655290842056274,
-0.8556498289108276,
-0.7157449722290039,
0.5079394578933716,
-0.06681589782238007,
-0.6119158267974854,
0.44842398166656494,
0.4550190269947052,
0.7366588115692139,
0.2573204040527344,
0.5807831883430481,
-0.10195004940032959,
0.6471841335296631,
-0.3280305862426758,
0.6348795294761658,
-0.41310572624206543,
-0.057967573404312134,
-0.7624836564064026,
-0.9961366653442383,
-0.29682284593582153,
0.6316683888435364,
0.09827219694852829,
-0.2097121626138687,
0.4256567358970642,
0.5610308051109314,
0.1907823234796524,
0.6710323095321655,
0.41246524453163147,
0.24438054859638214,
0.12048804014921188,
0.3552073836326599,
0.39622893929481506,
-0.28788310289382935,
0.3436868190765381,
-0.5234144330024719,
-0.5391235947608948,
0.028218673542141914,
-0.8592624664306641,
-0.5834386944770813,
-0.7341183423995972,
-0.23194794356822968,
0.004068825393915176,
0.5368689894676208,
0.7914139032363892,
1.3592513799667358,
-0.9913349151611328,
-0.5764312148094177,
-0.1706470400094986,
-0.2779138684272766,
-0.715026319026947,
-0.19417493045330048,
0.4070838391780853,
0.11034464836120605,
-0.48239049315452576,
0.9662331938743591,
0.3680068552494049,
-0.4564535915851593,
-0.4490281045436859,
0.143194779753685,
-0.029813429340720177,
-0.23475435376167297,
0.5346633791923523,
0.22523264586925507,
-0.8769931793212891,
0.045109111815690994,
-0.09404516965150833,
-0.032362766563892365,
-0.21059896051883698,
0.8073046803474426,
-0.7788394689559937,
0.5526039004325867,
0.049186158925294876,
0.8581318259239197,
0.25014540553092957,
-0.1036321371793747,
0.5857858061790466,
-0.5417221188545227,
-0.20655317604541779,
0.2073126882314682,
0.29833197593688965,
0.47987762093544006,
-0.07240304350852966,
0.6068679690361023,
0.3152054250240326,
-0.3882652819156647,
-0.9596480131149292,
-0.03940374404191971,
-0.8744272589683533,
-0.11036314815282822,
0.7979708909988403,
-0.14926494657993317,
0.3354756236076355,
-0.1700926274061203,
0.2559160888195038,
0.17106479406356812,
-0.6308003664016724,
0.6822015643119812,
0.7565474510192871,
-0.2798943817615509,
0.20036406815052032,
-0.6067631244659424,
0.34448063373565674,
0.4434654116630554,
-0.6368369460105896,
0.171918585896492,
0.42928409576416016,
0.31468212604522705,
0.536321759223938,
0.9123892188072205,
0.08777705579996109,
0.3349599838256836,
0.04311671480536461,
-0.01952284201979637,
-0.06104066222906113,
-0.5818659067153931,
-0.4310876429080963,
0.730929434299469,
-0.3068235218524933,
0.09777487069368362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09384v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09384v1
|
Tasks People Prompt: A Taxonomy of LLM Downstream Tasks in Software Verification and Falsification Approaches
| 2024-04-14T23:45:23 | 2024-04-14T23:45:23 |
Víctor A. Braberman, Flavia Bonomo-Braberman, Yiannis Charalambous, Juan G. Colonna, Lucas C. Cordeiro, Rosiane de Freitas
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, F.3.1; D.2.4; D.2.5; I.2.7
|
Prompting has become one of the main approaches to leverage emergent
capabilities of Large Language Models [Brown et al. NeurIPS 2020, Wei et al.
TMLR 2022, Wei et al. NeurIPS 2022]. During the last year, researchers and
practitioners have been playing with prompts to see how to make the most of
LLMs. By homogeneously dissecting 80 papers, we investigate in deep how
software testing and verification research communities have been abstractly
architecting their LLM-enabled solutions. More precisely, first, we want to
validate whether downstream tasks are an adequate concept to convey the
blueprint of prompt-based solutions. We also aim at identifying number and
nature of such tasks in solutions. For such goal, we develop a novel downstream
task taxonomy that enables pinpointing some engineering patterns in a rather
varied spectrum of Software Engineering problems that encompasses testing,
fuzzing, debugging, vulnerability detection, static analysis and program
verification approaches.
|
[
-0.482769638299942,
-0.5832425951957703,
0.7028815746307373,
0.45812270045280457,
0.19940704107284546,
0.2225034385919571,
0.35889387130737305,
-0.14012470841407776,
-0.24330125749111176,
0.4748416841030121,
-1.2190685272216797,
-0.2937844395637512,
-0.5359211564064026,
0.3999137580394745,
-0.546107828617096,
1.0785592794418335,
-0.28595876693725586,
-0.21623381972312927,
-0.20677079260349274,
0.14191380143165588,
-0.6383137702941895,
-0.3511582911014557,
-0.5178869962692261,
-0.2883925139904022,
0.7433337569236755,
0.3777983486652374,
0.22277288138866425,
0.431209921836853,
0.08847460895776749,
0.22116565704345703,
-0.0361100398004055,
-0.03846301883459091,
-0.10431426763534546,
0.40482938289642334,
0.1164732351899147,
-0.6192037463188171,
-0.10087314248085022,
0.11548028141260147,
0.27448591589927673,
0.5067532658576965,
0.3408389687538147,
0.5823011994361877,
0.47512778639793396,
0.5485567450523376,
-0.5349571704864502,
0.22389954328536987,
-0.42036378383636475,
-0.14003802835941315,
-0.4378158450126648,
-0.4330240786075592,
-0.6133313179016113,
-0.021342255175113678,
-0.11622976511716843,
-0.24722495675086975,
0.32631760835647583,
0.1947212964296341,
0.62160325050354,
0.44720903038978577,
-0.5495466589927673,
-0.29612457752227783,
-0.5105534195899963,
0.7984779477119446,
-0.2674291133880615,
0.2864435315132141,
0.17534683644771576,
0.136470228433609,
-0.4645211696624756,
-0.4338841438293457,
-0.3066246807575226,
-0.3761880397796631,
-0.018060266971588135,
-0.09814601391553879,
-0.18204137682914734,
0.0003842386358883232,
0.39082276821136475,
0.4116244614124298,
-0.5922228693962097,
0.11695566028356552,
-0.27026382088661194,
-0.4770231544971466,
0.7386482357978821,
0.3966670036315918,
0.5272542238235474,
0.0003464026958681643,
-0.5449353456497192,
0.4342004954814911,
-0.9906833171844482,
0.37930959463119507,
0.39217066764831543,
0.18863098323345184,
-0.14166417717933655,
0.3739181160926819,
-0.2450273633003235,
0.9023035168647766,
0.09253674745559692,
-0.11082512140274048,
-0.14090195298194885,
-0.3757320046424866,
-0.13651873171329498,
-0.2501350939273834,
0.3678115904331207,
0.03177044168114662,
-0.13537490367889404,
-0.15940038859844208,
-0.6000694036483765,
-0.13225319981575012,
0.33486127853393555,
-0.21279636025428772,
-0.3767416775226593,
0.6971540451049805,
-0.3651752173900604,
-0.331332266330719,
-0.2282790243625641,
-0.3410252630710602,
-0.8144122958183289,
-0.5662113428115845,
0.28656071424484253,
-0.12795650959014893,
-0.21941150724887848,
-0.2675164043903351,
-0.1960630714893341,
0.4518083333969116,
0.4193204343318939,
-0.8260617256164551,
0.10478182882070541,
1.1644835472106934,
0.7998128533363342,
-0.3064286410808563,
-0.35708433389663696,
-0.7618114352226257,
-0.19767743349075317,
-0.16114455461502075,
0.9172082543373108,
-0.21070247888565063,
-0.3783400058746338,
-0.04269268736243248,
0.038939155638217926,
0.27363958954811096,
-0.3966643512248993,
0.4988364577293396,
-0.5593044757843018,
0.015286457724869251,
-0.6456625461578369,
-0.3594439625740051,
-0.09687504917383194,
0.5758916139602661,
-0.5823678970336914,
1.2360379695892334,
0.3022414743900299,
-0.6108627319335938,
0.3601919710636139,
-0.6697345972061157,
-0.23264384269714355,
0.5726498365402222,
-0.38071900606155396,
0.15287137031555176,
0.060636796057224274,
0.021337565034627914,
0.5586916208267212,
-0.48597651720046997,
-0.04537070170044899,
0.08458008617162704,
-0.35223037004470825,
0.1260392814874649,
0.1532372236251831,
1.0663766860961914,
0.28205499053001404,
-0.43588778376579285,
0.4707397520542145,
-0.3470831513404846,
-0.13664737343788147,
-0.11802603304386139,
-0.3416842520236969,
-0.14810000360012054,
0.1130901426076889,
-0.14481574296951294,
0.32649582624435425,
0.22007857263088226,
-0.496884822845459,
0.2743426561355591,
-0.15268711745738983,
0.7353355884552002,
0.9999503493309021,
0.2818046808242798,
0.3967115879058838,
-0.6643867492675781,
0.92763352394104,
0.09186411648988724,
0.37681740522384644,
-0.45395657420158386,
-0.9358723759651184,
-0.5977228283882141,
-0.32767608761787415,
-0.0038024121895432472,
0.8046392202377319,
-0.5849312543869019,
0.31034597754478455,
0.03144209086894989,
-0.5628287196159363,
-0.31153157353401184,
0.424551397562027,
0.1838291883468628,
0.4635169208049774,
0.1333674192428589,
0.12045080214738846,
-0.46072623133659363,
-0.7274519205093384,
-0.3254440426826477,
-0.4037485420703888,
-0.255755752325058,
0.10932982712984085,
0.5664457082748413,
-0.1865467131137848,
1.0848567485809326,
-0.3895813822746277,
-0.07245668023824692,
-0.3312857151031494,
0.3642100989818573,
0.4193592369556427,
0.1050855815410614,
0.39876067638397217,
-0.8724085688591003,
-0.31976810097694397,
-0.3332767188549042,
-0.3824763894081116,
-0.504546582698822,
-0.36473745107650757,
-0.05591480806469917,
0.3301207423210144,
0.7620704174041748,
-0.4475739300251007,
-0.07276488095521927,
0.5209850072860718,
-0.41722726821899414,
0.8685097694396973,
0.2890852391719818,
0.14165551960468292,
-0.7280629277229309,
0.06025182083249092,
0.0812900960445404,
-0.006940174847841263,
-0.5334885716438293,
0.41836294531822205,
0.014901499263942242,
-0.06252361834049225,
-0.4808335304260254,
0.8277506232261658,
-0.7715127468109131,
-0.043623749166727066,
-0.3077245056629181,
-0.024617908522486687,
-0.21562521159648895,
0.3485637605190277,
-0.46620333194732666,
0.9501138925552368,
0.6534761190414429,
-0.8804865479469299,
0.4532368779182434,
0.004728189203888178,
-0.0999518558382988,
0.4837360084056854,
-0.657677412033081,
0.13708266615867615,
-0.1591751128435135,
0.18084558844566345,
-1.4989930391311646,
-0.39043357968330383,
0.3084171712398529,
-0.4315287470817566,
-0.008462915197014809,
-0.2794521749019623,
-0.6260398626327515,
-0.6204310059547424,
-0.25144025683403015,
0.25318294763565063,
0.8058947920799255,
-0.26202651858329773,
0.627133309841156,
0.14016076922416687,
-0.2755698263645172,
-0.47694939374923706,
-0.6263779401779175,
-0.04582134261727333,
-0.24802754819393158,
-0.7222933769226074,
0.3018120229244232,
-0.021998148411512375,
-0.5280233025550842,
-0.2854866087436676,
-0.279692679643631,
-0.10242535918951035,
0.6693983674049377,
0.5626233816146851,
0.5021070837974548,
-0.08626623451709747,
0.13216780126094818,
-0.055086638778448105,
-0.2656140923500061,
0.5202600359916687,
-0.2863418757915497,
0.3216961622238159,
0.22131597995758057,
-0.5064181089401245,
-0.20988428592681885,
0.493161141872406,
0.4248712956905365,
-0.12941250205039978,
-0.0033459251280874014,
0.2851002812385559,
-0.38043680787086487,
-0.30460870265960693,
-0.5680583715438843,
-0.26569923758506775,
-0.5229417681694031,
0.040115032345056534,
-0.44693291187286377,
-1.1367627382278442,
0.7511423826217651,
-0.2620686888694763,
0.5492464303970337,
0.356489360332489,
0.5448423027992249,
-0.06987465918064117,
0.7369983792304993,
0.68732088804245,
-0.1595337837934494,
0.24928537011146545,
0.23531784117221832,
0.24516606330871582,
-0.5598058104515076,
-0.07750684022903442,
-0.6986083984375,
-0.29092708230018616,
-0.37997967004776,
-0.40958932042121887,
0.4913560450077057,
0.07308182120323181,
-0.2624703347682953,
0.13900431990623474,
-0.6603482961654663,
0.5374109148979187,
0.4680567681789398,
-0.013565736822783947,
0.202999547123909,
-0.3339396119117737,
-0.141862154006958,
0.13783450424671173,
-0.25098946690559387,
-0.7214167714118958,
0.7439156770706177,
0.3798542320728302,
0.4011317789554596,
-0.04080383479595184,
0.9072993397712708,
0.7162478566169739,
0.5531368851661682,
-1.0299304723739624,
0.8550664186477661,
0.2508644759654999,
-0.7845374345779419,
-0.2377382516860962,
0.01740402542054653,
-0.9570786356925964,
-0.45323142409324646,
0.3189238905906677,
-0.7613282203674316,
-0.08468596637248993,
0.2613658607006073,
-0.6554969549179077,
-0.07467406243085861,
-0.4699574112892151,
0.6772302985191345,
-0.09921839088201523,
-0.08946549892425537,
0.10374748706817627,
-0.544485867023468,
0.513576328754425,
-0.05520204082131386,
0.16631703078746796,
-0.24359291791915894,
-0.4343963861465454,
0.5610779523849487,
-0.3263283371925354,
0.9357881546020508,
-0.3460695147514343,
-0.5889986157417297,
0.4219265878200531,
0.2784331440925598,
0.6826730370521545,
-0.23514269292354584,
0.016611630097031593,
-0.20454923808574677,
-0.12490924447774887,
-0.4299086928367615,
-0.48621687293052673,
0.5348842740058899,
-0.3790355324745178,
-0.9366922378540039,
-0.34353041648864746,
-0.38498902320861816,
-0.42086806893348694,
0.1308710277080536,
0.2968141734600067,
0.24016262590885162,
0.2124914973974228,
-0.548523485660553,
0.7531123757362366,
-0.08483438193798065,
0.40357157588005066,
0.38106706738471985,
-0.15320442616939545,
0.09090889990329742,
0.6719180941581726,
0.01210672315210104,
0.13235080242156982,
0.3155657649040222,
-0.09542286396026611,
-0.2128746509552002,
-0.8852357268333435,
-0.39129307866096497,
0.02242964319884777,
-0.769052267074585,
-0.10337257385253906,
-0.5280161499977112,
-0.02679821290075779,
-0.339908629655838,
-0.3655834197998047,
0.16511568427085876,
-0.05899558588862419,
-0.2521781325340271,
0.05037248879671097,
0.47067490220069885,
0.9890235662460327,
0.3738315999507904,
-0.011360998265445232,
-1.0951735973358154,
0.1174498200416565,
0.28583824634552,
-0.04251815006136894,
0.045226313173770905,
-0.359213262796402,
0.13274991512298584,
-0.21920476853847504,
-0.3642634451389313,
-0.9935198426246643,
0.09654155373573303,
-0.4089037775993347,
0.8467533588409424,
0.08955196291208267,
0.28357449173927307,
0.3101300001144409,
-0.2829364836215973,
1.299468994140625,
0.05310424789786339,
-1.0692306756973267,
0.7751418948173523,
-0.47149619460105896,
0.25170594453811646,
0.39489659667015076,
0.7914084196090698,
-0.7744932174682617,
-0.48865216970443726,
-0.22345884144306183,
-0.9446656703948975,
0.4009592533111572,
-0.1803559809923172,
0.1789904534816742,
-0.03223253786563873,
0.5117740035057068,
0.3266507089138031,
-0.08314694464206696,
-0.4404389262199402,
-0.3461456596851349,
0.31651538610458374,
-0.2064140886068344,
0.2948913276195526,
-0.3806154131889343,
-0.2641555964946747,
0.08318903297185898,
0.5660805106163025,
-0.3485093414783478,
0.3403717279434204,
0.2514093518257141,
-0.09230218082666397,
0.26345598697662354,
0.5733900666236877,
0.6060206890106201,
0.5020662546157837,
0.27017277479171753,
0.17961473762989044,
-0.004829529207199812,
-0.4418550729751587,
0.5543390512466431,
-0.1253294050693512,
-0.2770780324935913,
-0.15595005452632904,
0.34190359711647034,
0.33726462721824646,
0.08035458624362946,
-0.5614627599716187,
0.4531902074813843,
0.3152226507663727,
-0.36456382274627686,
-0.3340713381767273,
0.3590649664402008,
-0.016972126439213753,
0.4199956953525543,
0.9225513935089111,
-0.011662992648780346,
0.42653363943099976,
-0.45334896445274353,
0.08360481262207031,
0.15438945591449738,
-0.4278799593448639,
-0.40597638487815857,
0.5479944944381714,
0.5152369141578674,
-0.42507871985435486,
0.6172971129417419,
-0.6217809915542603,
-0.4976433217525482,
0.5976582765579224,
0.17654924094676971,
1.1888959407806396,
0.00813752505928278,
0.1534997522830963,
0.26340141892433167,
0.3060987591743469,
-0.044603582471609116,
0.6906862258911133,
-0.29800423979759216,
-0.41005927324295044,
-0.7958760261535645,
-0.2780633270740509,
-0.5586568117141724,
0.1026102751493454,
-0.3613469898700714,
0.45960575342178345,
-0.3751000463962555,
-0.09260975569486618,
0.12567773461341858,
-0.15473870933055878,
-0.23352889716625214,
-0.2155381739139557,
0.45902734994888306,
1.2099114656448364,
-0.8707407116889954,
0.42213308811187744,
1.0744191408157349,
-0.18680760264396667,
-0.8711371421813965,
0.2948164939880371,
0.5782003998756409,
-0.5901036262512207,
1.0972909927368164,
0.3086594045162201,
0.053339410573244095,
0.03832641616463661,
-0.6727386713027954,
-0.666901171207428,
1.1653605699539185,
0.26828885078430176,
-0.3198971152305603,
-0.24621360003948212,
-0.07189249247312546,
0.20171643793582916,
-0.19158683717250824,
0.056229110807180405,
0.2732343077659607,
0.5413423180580139,
0.03271772339940071,
-0.7625432014465332,
0.5031743049621582,
-0.493995726108551,
-0.05065122991800308,
0.3597240447998047,
-0.4063824415206909,
0.8510751128196716,
-0.2881576120853424,
-0.5025187730789185,
0.18469640612602234,
0.5900722146034241,
0.7145575284957886,
0.45263227820396423,
0.7606582641601562,
-0.06241930276155472,
0.8090654015541077,
-0.3680572211742401,
1.0534329414367676,
-0.3766636848449707,
-0.06913553923368454,
0.9457511305809021,
-0.5399746894836426,
0.507335364818573,
0.7047466039657593,
-0.5299400687217712,
0.635287344455719,
1.1097283363342285,
-0.1528109759092331,
0.13305631279945374,
0.5052252411842346,
-0.40928521752357483,
-0.46184632182121277,
-0.09043075889348984,
-0.05771864578127861,
0.13000397384166718,
0.20639200508594513,
-0.15077340602874756,
-0.28616631031036377,
0.1257251352071762,
-0.1934899091720581,
-0.26757702231407166,
-0.48304393887519836,
0.4535808265209198,
0.0057570249773561954,
-1.157194972038269,
0.2824274003505707,
-0.17410770058631897,
0.7547519207000732,
-0.40361928939819336,
0.053647227585315704,
-0.13511322438716888,
-0.10418336093425751,
-0.33927857875823975,
-1.0298442840576172,
0.4154805541038513,
-0.17715218663215637,
-0.2807745933532715,
-0.6748558878898621,
0.7909690141677856,
0.17296411097049713,
0.04988405853509903,
0.07915444672107697,
0.5133635997772217,
0.13381177186965942,
-0.37407392263412476,
-0.6745685935020447,
-0.048489492386579514,
0.034864477813243866,
-0.1410997062921524,
0.10334879159927368,
0.43401989340782166,
-0.20607738196849823,
0.8890588283538818,
0.44051989912986755,
-0.1915123611688614,
0.2466520369052887,
-0.13691024482250214,
0.7355295419692993,
-0.5976117253303528,
-0.5300889611244202,
-1.0744537115097046,
0.8603987097740173,
0.2296380251646042,
-0.5182504653930664,
0.9619337320327759,
0.35836246609687805,
0.562114953994751,
-0.15008501708507538,
0.8261715769767761,
-0.1538701206445694,
0.39963892102241516,
-0.3419935703277588,
0.3517438471317291,
-0.3260907232761383,
0.2915767729282379,
-0.047687433660030365,
-0.5144192576408386,
-0.1249251440167427,
-0.21531713008880615,
-0.184114009141922,
0.05754994973540306,
0.491233229637146,
0.9068192839622498,
0.22399215400218964,
0.21324779093265533,
-0.03720312565565109,
-0.02053920179605484,
0.1930806040763855,
0.5686964392662048,
1.2432066202163696,
-0.16793188452720642,
0.3316127359867096,
0.08394597470760345,
-0.33840134739875793,
-0.2761949300765991,
-0.8862916827201843,
-0.6996212601661682,
-0.93503737449646,
-0.7069788575172424,
-0.378490686416626,
-0.25665512681007385,
0.8434956073760986,
0.5829193592071533,
-0.7568308711051941,
-0.02844485081732273,
-0.601013720035553,
0.3138972818851471,
-0.4706086218357086,
-0.2832898497581482,
-0.31446900963783264,
-0.6778677105903625,
-0.3771700859069824,
0.23832716047763824,
0.4280761778354645,
0.1373777836561203,
-0.7140023112297058,
-0.06357614696025848,
-0.05137264356017113,
-0.13251827657222748,
0.5746392011642456,
0.2745262384414673,
-0.8749462962150574,
-0.07086207717657089,
0.38751015067100525,
-0.3084896206855774,
-0.2909386456012726,
1.2379212379455566,
-0.6542302370071411,
-0.17095033824443817,
0.9184971451759338,
0.6896653175354004,
-0.07037761807441711,
-0.2506610155105591,
0.6426985263824463,
-0.8005996942520142,
-0.28706982731819153,
0.3549054265022278,
0.3015814423561096,
0.015227812342345715,
-0.7094561457633972,
0.6598882079124451,
0.2755737602710724,
-0.7367185950279236,
-1.0139496326446533,
0.4402637779712677,
-0.9787028431892395,
-0.1866757720708847,
1.3173727989196777,
-0.36428195238113403,
-0.2830430269241333,
-0.8317227959632874,
-0.2271147519350052,
-0.06340081989765167,
-0.19865435361862183,
0.6487171649932861,
1.0095446109771729,
-0.3748122453689575,
-0.4171116352081299,
-0.4996028244495392,
0.49525511264801025,
0.3094518184661865,
-1.0054875612258911,
0.2865709364414215,
0.4273141920566559,
0.416964054107666,
0.3293919563293457,
0.7865490913391113,
-0.019645748659968376,
0.4780184030532837,
-0.15278752148151398,
-0.12593403458595276,
-0.07409272342920303,
-0.08222232013940811,
-0.3311760723590851,
0.19623950123786926,
0.385591596364975,
-0.05892806500196457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09383v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09383v1
|
Low-Resource Named Entity Recognition with Cross-Lingual, Character-Level Neural Conditional Random Fields
| 2024-04-14T23:44:49 | 2024-04-14T23:44:49 |
Ryan Cotterell, Kevin Duh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Low-resource named entity recognition is still an open problem in NLP. Most
state-of-the-art systems require tens of thousands of annotated sentences in
order to obtain high performance. However, for most of the world's languages,
it is unfeasible to obtain such annotation. In this paper, we present a
transfer learning scheme, whereby we train character-level neural CRFs to
predict named entities for both high-resource languages and low resource
languages jointly. Learning character representations for multiple related
languages allows transfer among the languages, improving F1 by up to 9.8 points
over a loglinear CRF baseline.
|
[
-0.22554679214954376,
-0.23099684715270996,
0.3980449438095093,
0.2577022910118103,
-0.15249131619930267,
0.14992907643318176,
-0.5329102873802185,
-1.0115166902542114,
0.24608023464679718,
0.5738392472267151,
-0.6496024131774902,
-0.32277777791023254,
-0.6731159090995789,
0.45016413927078247,
-0.10904940217733383,
0.9424774646759033,
-0.11449426412582397,
0.014260382391512394,
0.07142238318920135,
-0.30967795848846436,
-0.5092605948448181,
-0.65907883644104,
-1.289124608039856,
-0.27322715520858765,
0.7960123419761658,
0.33457159996032715,
0.3849131464958191,
0.2589670419692993,
0.6768298745155334,
0.32063695788383484,
0.16419802606105804,
0.16548608243465424,
-0.3928169012069702,
0.19462139904499054,
-0.5048143267631531,
-0.628815233707428,
-0.17708247900009155,
-0.45348691940307617,
0.6945454478263855,
0.7694633603096008,
0.1875101625919342,
0.021770218387246132,
-0.14110736548900604,
0.3671382963657379,
-0.4921949803829193,
0.46625787019729614,
-0.7150657773017883,
0.6407381296157837,
-0.1770823895931244,
-0.27961617708206177,
-0.6531903147697449,
0.028749307617545128,
0.4830932021141052,
-0.9511449337005615,
0.0996754840016365,
0.372627854347229,
0.9246852397918701,
-0.07750978320837021,
-0.2574284076690674,
-0.018664337694644928,
-0.7237412333488464,
0.9352876543998718,
-0.3109591007232666,
0.5166561007499695,
0.40022316575050354,
0.24952548742294312,
0.06219128519296646,
-0.6662189364433289,
-0.5441916584968567,
-0.18655642867088318,
-0.42709219455718994,
-0.19449369609355927,
0.058347538113594055,
0.08747548609972,
0.3959694802761078,
0.1151650995016098,
-0.3257683515548706,
0.35856112837791443,
-0.34081485867500305,
-0.5296440720558167,
0.6981117725372314,
0.06393539905548096,
0.45784929394721985,
-0.15975533425807953,
-0.7719318270683289,
-0.16658103466033936,
-0.6506983041763306,
0.17731495201587677,
0.014998998492956161,
0.7024894952774048,
-0.23692844808101654,
0.31892824172973633,
-0.14652933180332184,
0.4727751314640045,
0.2242152839899063,
-0.20042823255062103,
0.16119365394115448,
-0.31308844685554504,
-0.24511028826236725,
0.2761496603488922,
0.8824467062950134,
-0.09737810492515564,
0.41734516620635986,
-0.4355226457118988,
-0.3264261782169342,
-0.4391430616378784,
-0.15673032402992249,
-0.781902015209198,
-0.32639503479003906,
-0.29964709281921387,
-0.4287411570549011,
-0.15062488615512848,
-0.29452595114707947,
-0.8595656752586365,
-0.5858706831932068,
-0.09915319830179214,
0.1922142058610916,
-0.6257192492485046,
-0.12136296182870865,
-0.19192861020565033,
0.07887163013219833,
0.028009554371237755,
0.48124241828918457,
-1.1132441759109497,
0.09201336652040482,
0.019584057852625847,
0.6038011312484741,
-0.3148003816604614,
-0.39176565408706665,
-0.7097327709197998,
0.2567841410636902,
-0.0782293975353241,
0.8323336839675903,
-0.6045225858688354,
-0.3924300968647003,
0.12695860862731934,
0.28831160068511963,
-0.24031558632850647,
-0.3125210404396057,
0.4277644455432892,
-0.6493602991104126,
0.12878036499023438,
-0.5961694121360779,
-0.15799637138843536,
-0.2903713285923004,
-0.0024860119447112083,
-0.8788878917694092,
0.8337074518203735,
0.5264615416526794,
-0.672501802444458,
0.5366628766059875,
-0.349602609872818,
-0.8639580011367798,
0.3717881441116333,
-0.2332049310207367,
-0.0208731796592474,
-0.24033036828041077,
0.24893806874752045,
0.42573198676109314,
-0.2230621576309204,
-0.2089020162820816,
-0.2716841995716095,
-0.08011865615844727,
0.19243858754634857,
-0.30931153893470764,
0.6520668268203735,
0.2993726134300232,
-0.08938568085432053,
-0.3176119327545166,
-0.9874341487884521,
0.16796642541885376,
0.044579047709703445,
-0.5211706757545471,
-0.545455276966095,
-0.37877124547958374,
0.25663429498672485,
0.26025915145874023,
0.1854964792728424,
-0.3614272475242615,
0.1504293978214264,
-0.09381964057683945,
0.4119006395339966,
0.33282965421676636,
0.19583822786808014,
1.001450777053833,
-0.13110341131687164,
0.682054877281189,
0.3123480975627899,
-0.36634668707847595,
0.07606348395347595,
-0.25212135910987854,
-0.8768126964569092,
-0.29551658034324646,
0.7939606308937073,
0.6991755962371826,
-1.329384446144104,
0.26908227801322937,
-0.13501225411891937,
0.03267078101634979,
-0.4949558675289154,
0.18333309888839722,
0.4516364634037018,
0.717583417892456,
0.6817978024482727,
-0.2095852792263031,
-0.791682243347168,
-1.022312879562378,
-0.1671006828546524,
-0.33201026916503906,
0.09468667954206467,
0.3056895434856415,
0.18730373680591583,
0.10160520672798157,
0.36730214953422546,
-0.07392683625221252,
-0.6481528878211975,
-0.619290828704834,
0.27773991227149963,
-0.15375030040740967,
0.4400008022785187,
0.6117954850196838,
-0.7663106322288513,
-0.6793285608291626,
0.38513508439064026,
-0.5255241990089417,
0.12153493613004684,
-0.5996675491333008,
-0.25560635328292847,
0.3274393379688263,
0.46435174345970154,
-0.780860424041748,
0.10501007735729218,
0.5114708542823792,
-0.22397279739379883,
-0.01969536580145359,
-0.11096358299255371,
0.28193625807762146,
-0.9465898275375366,
0.06216919794678688,
0.19599126279354095,
-0.5137063264846802,
-0.31828632950782776,
-0.2637442648410797,
-0.02766231819987297,
-0.27171486616134644,
-0.6277866959571838,
0.8709188103675842,
-0.7979096174240112,
-0.19574332237243652,
0.022401804104447365,
0.20446355640888214,
-0.008810398168861866,
0.7824335098266602,
0.5798067450523376,
0.6487672924995422,
0.49677321314811707,
-0.46805059909820557,
0.15505839884281158,
0.28672531247138977,
-0.2436150461435318,
0.830030083656311,
-0.12135094404220581,
-0.07995123416185379,
0.12825548648834229,
0.2845308780670166,
-0.26862674951553345,
-0.0007208390743471682,
0.37804681062698364,
-0.2568513751029968,
0.6067354679107666,
-0.44718867540359497,
-0.20809349417686462,
-0.019434629008173943,
0.44465163350105286,
0.5840821266174316,
0.44803375005722046,
-0.46670302748680115,
0.7117466926574707,
0.4394958019256592,
-0.1737956553697586,
-0.7747541069984436,
-1.068772315979004,
0.01260274089872837,
0.07491054385900497,
-0.5085417032241821,
0.731350839138031,
0.4307413101196289,
0.1514078974723816,
0.38771387934684753,
0.0020324771758168936,
-0.413344144821167,
-0.058379702270030975,
0.125298410654068,
0.293768048286438,
-0.43500250577926636,
0.1378471702337265,
-0.08783472329378128,
0.09157563000917435,
-0.21624456346035004,
-0.24364489316940308,
0.33262988924980164,
-0.017553772777318954,
0.03664851933717728,
-0.5109626650810242,
0.29944485425949097,
0.13445645570755005,
-0.4044799506664276,
0.6807551980018616,
0.6944557428359985,
-0.7372536063194275,
-0.7444251775741577,
0.016791939735412598,
-0.004713395144790411,
-0.408976674079895,
0.5998456478118896,
-0.6102088689804077,
-0.8507080078125,
0.6398597955703735,
0.10500001907348633,
-0.15876315534114838,
0.8104372024536133,
0.25204595923423767,
0.0007722467416897416,
0.625897228717804,
0.9324472546577454,
-0.0648917406797409,
0.5595760345458984,
-0.17165127396583557,
0.40396931767463684,
-0.48203498125076294,
-0.40524548292160034,
-0.43915075063705444,
-0.5457816123962402,
-0.674696683883667,
-0.44924697279930115,
-0.3087044060230255,
0.36119315028190613,
0.005614268593490124,
0.8494086265563965,
-0.1679254174232483,
0.5551192164421082,
0.34277576208114624,
-0.06569202244281769,
0.3423139154911041,
0.2702743709087372,
-0.260140597820282,
-0.008308677934110165,
-0.726020097732544,
-0.16423062980175018,
0.5818078517913818,
0.3278522491455078,
0.624488353729248,
-0.10628362745046616,
0.9697189927101135,
0.4581323266029358,
0.29481756687164307,
-0.8509234189987183,
0.7426226139068604,
-0.42551323771476746,
-0.40286388993263245,
-0.4828866124153137,
-0.6221904158592224,
-0.5797989368438721,
0.056044697761535645,
-0.8064528107643127,
-0.7074921131134033,
0.7322338223457336,
-0.0374133437871933,
-0.6581076383590698,
0.47787201404571533,
-0.6127376556396484,
0.48672714829444885,
-0.2887056767940521,
-0.07057325541973114,
-0.10594870150089264,
-0.4311200678348541,
0.37932711839675903,
-0.07451574504375458,
-0.09795881062746048,
-0.10809283703565598,
0.060651879757642746,
0.7057435512542725,
0.027588697150349617,
0.6159600019454956,
-0.20704077184200287,
0.08801232278347015,
0.29975348711013794,
0.20906516909599304,
0.5764157772064209,
0.41158708930015564,
-0.014054848812520504,
0.38866961002349854,
0.08137119561433792,
-0.13448141515254974,
-0.47575128078460693,
0.9087975025177002,
-0.6725199818611145,
-0.09278316050767899,
-0.6396949887275696,
-0.5925803184509277,
-0.36348792910575867,
0.5327723026275635,
0.3544926047325134,
-0.08242448419332504,
-0.20523789525032043,
-0.010164381004869938,
0.7984501719474792,
-0.2528659701347351,
0.5846666097640991,
0.3418479263782501,
-0.007196367252618074,
-0.38989877700805664,
0.8875711560249329,
0.21358227729797363,
-0.07834497839212418,
0.7513978481292725,
-0.4547116756439209,
-0.13042141497135162,
-0.5005436539649963,
-0.7756657004356384,
0.10949251055717468,
-0.764180064201355,
-0.45905786752700806,
-0.6521962285041809,
-0.59254390001297,
-0.16567915678024292,
-0.0946928933262825,
-0.2846178412437439,
-0.6642848253250122,
-0.48377132415771484,
0.0264130886644125,
0.24827472865581512,
0.38105663657188416,
0.09223946928977966,
0.23266322910785675,
-0.989752471446991,
0.30159223079681396,
0.0389380156993866,
0.3471176326274872,
-0.06255776435136795,
-0.48534154891967773,
-0.3376728594303131,
0.018380170688033104,
0.06786307692527771,
-0.690891444683075,
0.46778571605682373,
0.5421748757362366,
0.5915768146514893,
0.21605612337589264,
0.2516106069087982,
0.6189427971839905,
-0.49999475479125977,
0.38202571868896484,
0.6268183588981628,
-0.780089259147644,
-0.005126424133777618,
0.09586439281702042,
-0.21048599481582642,
0.7766845226287842,
0.5963266491889954,
-0.689182460308075,
0.06577052175998688,
-0.4558503031730652,
-0.4194400906562805,
0.9742341637611389,
0.028569960966706276,
-0.046707384288311005,
0.06376403570175171,
0.28145942091941833,
0.12321767956018448,
-0.2079574316740036,
-0.8916615843772888,
-0.07089195400476456,
0.15752071142196655,
-0.2432435005903244,
0.15082131326198578,
0.06118617206811905,
-0.0725310742855072,
0.15906932950019836,
0.5768759250640869,
-0.08629097044467926,
0.50284743309021,
0.32515212893486023,
-0.46610942482948303,
-0.4878693222999573,
0.16691169142723083,
0.4721841812133789,
0.1824502795934677,
-0.062252532690763474,
0.24491703510284424,
0.4837137758731842,
-0.32991307973861694,
0.16086609661579132,
0.36450913548469543,
-0.12228917330503464,
0.05796013027429581,
0.4709508419036865,
0.9326666593551636,
0.38411712646484375,
-0.33511096239089966,
0.37490972876548767,
-0.15281535685062408,
-0.3040027618408203,
-0.2823314964771271,
-0.0014098361134529114,
0.22054210305213928,
0.5596876740455627,
0.1864366978406906,
0.34127333760261536,
-0.06924045830965042,
-0.5506209135055542,
0.2711970806121826,
0.28615760803222656,
-0.44960176944732666,
-0.4800744652748108,
0.36003443598747253,
0.37345418334007263,
-0.42548659443855286,
0.716618001461029,
-0.3711325526237488,
-0.5436378717422485,
0.6206843256950378,
0.572022557258606,
0.8662992119789124,
0.03308887407183647,
0.3560785949230194,
0.4926467537879944,
0.30460822582244873,
-0.2637355923652649,
0.2810298502445221,
-0.004271614830940962,
-0.613291323184967,
-0.47310173511505127,
-0.861094057559967,
-0.2894984781742096,
0.2089581936597824,
-0.5037567615509033,
0.6992142200469971,
-0.6881816983222961,
-0.23685495555400848,
0.22213730216026306,
0.14327141642570496,
-1.2270660400390625,
0.2726036012172699,
0.7554771304130554,
0.7852199077606201,
-0.6773706078529358,
1.028777837753296,
0.6400666832923889,
-0.8488714694976807,
-0.6587573289871216,
-0.1500178575515747,
-0.568699061870575,
-0.942368745803833,
1.289986252784729,
-0.057757794857025146,
0.10160916298627853,
-0.030017834156751633,
-0.032490842044353485,
-1.3186545372009277,
1.0279518365859985,
0.48304983973503113,
-0.946365237236023,
-0.5992249846458435,
0.18960979580879211,
0.583958089351654,
-0.619375467300415,
0.05006559193134308,
0.06553622335195541,
0.4456557333469391,
-0.17881883680820465,
-0.8433327078819275,
0.3070489168167114,
0.13835804164409637,
0.09083376079797745,
0.1011190339922905,
-0.6523342132568359,
0.7275636196136475,
-0.5064525604248047,
-0.6589246988296509,
0.042473651468753815,
1.118894100189209,
0.03397594019770622,
0.1477961391210556,
0.6751798391342163,
0.5191405415534973,
0.6967707276344299,
0.06003652140498161,
0.6609578132629395,
-0.41954275965690613,
0.27331942319869995,
1.0779016017913818,
-0.4996620714664459,
0.9419590830802917,
0.4360017478466034,
-0.11843216419219971,
0.6203359961509705,
0.6335356831550598,
-0.25277674198150635,
0.7597082257270813,
0.29225191473960876,
-0.2562670111656189,
-0.45284202694892883,
-0.229234978556633,
-0.17602594196796417,
0.38742920756340027,
0.2660040259361267,
-0.637810230255127,
-0.2741667926311493,
0.18092592060565948,
-0.2617884576320648,
-0.2470790445804596,
-0.34267646074295044,
0.4840531647205353,
0.49079570174217224,
-0.8001259565353394,
0.49561363458633423,
0.1607619673013687,
0.564629077911377,
-0.5175303220748901,
-0.38856926560401917,
-0.33080026507377625,
0.03974345698952675,
-0.32379141449928284,
-0.5733069777488708,
0.04691418632864952,
-0.19034603238105774,
-0.4224202334880829,
-0.37570714950561523,
0.9935224652290344,
-0.8548749685287476,
-0.4834919273853302,
0.5324251055717468,
0.38425958156585693,
-0.08430968970060349,
0.3956361413002014,
-0.7674830555915833,
-0.49208059906959534,
-0.05753086507320404,
-0.20757348835468292,
0.667595624923706,
0.6956101655960083,
-0.34525370597839355,
0.45934057235717773,
0.4540395736694336,
0.4866673946380615,
0.23770493268966675,
0.04648787900805473,
0.42267370223999023,
-0.5984272956848145,
-0.47160637378692627,
-0.3138125538825989,
0.05134018883109093,
0.012338700704276562,
-0.4725927710533142,
0.25756946206092834,
0.028655145317316055,
1.221510887145996,
-0.04004421830177307,
0.970261812210083,
-0.29209282994270325,
0.2653275430202484,
-0.6952259540557861,
0.845883309841156,
-0.42369404435157776,
0.15105704963207245,
0.1806240826845169,
-1.0157685279846191,
-0.20252761244773865,
0.487048476934433,
-0.13278837502002716,
-0.028053296729922295,
0.9197157025337219,
0.3239206373691559,
-0.10296695679426193,
-0.15995192527770996,
0.5998547673225403,
-0.2539687156677246,
-0.03724992275238037,
0.9733590483665466,
0.6658625602722168,
-0.32511717081069946,
0.7691864967346191,
-0.8179503083229065,
0.1204015463590622,
-0.20437072217464447,
-0.8559102416038513,
-0.9782171249389648,
-0.539550244808197,
-0.36941027641296387,
-0.35177597403526306,
0.06939326971769333,
0.9658031463623047,
0.7386556267738342,
-1.0171566009521484,
0.18706005811691284,
0.11401308327913284,
0.10535671561956406,
-0.2718287706375122,
-0.19027316570281982,
0.4458995759487152,
-0.5653772354125977,
-0.7160387635231018,
0.40309348702430725,
0.01088529359549284,
0.006510909181088209,
-0.24811379611492157,
0.012183818966150284,
-0.19273154437541962,
-0.0996956005692482,
0.48256704211235046,
0.7448768615722656,
-0.5431544184684753,
-0.4420458674430847,
0.10503953695297241,
-0.5731489658355713,
-0.048345260322093964,
0.8984773755073547,
-0.7066565752029419,
-0.02747502736747265,
0.7990913987159729,
1.0191410779953003,
0.29428455233573914,
-0.4333830773830414,
0.4588301479816437,
-0.7502484321594238,
0.12067146599292755,
0.4972188472747803,
0.7048594951629639,
0.3837321996688843,
-0.7531654834747314,
0.2547576129436493,
0.39899972081184387,
-0.31251075863838196,
-0.7049267292022705,
0.14880333840847015,
-1.185082197189331,
0.0488508976995945,
1.0647261142730713,
-0.4430687725543976,
-0.1404981017112732,
0.1593923270702362,
0.13348259031772614,
0.4187120795249939,
-0.4654954969882965,
0.4793597459793091,
0.6365858912467957,
-0.07694394141435623,
-0.39103975892066956,
-0.4202646017074585,
0.8442619442939758,
0.37375208735466003,
-0.7140254974365234,
-0.06517294049263,
0.1930752694606781,
0.33497142791748047,
0.2957690954208374,
0.6278538703918457,
-0.08450670540332794,
0.11998721212148666,
0.011858321726322174,
0.4355942904949188,
0.04100235179066658,
-0.5527498126029968,
-0.16044600307941437,
0.04088110476732254,
0.064167819917202,
0.0272336658090353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09375v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09375v1
|
Deceptive Patterns of Intelligent and Interactive Writing Assistants
| 2024-04-14T23:05:10 | 2024-04-14T23:05:10 |
Karim Benharrak, Tim Zindulka, Daniel Buschek
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models have become an integral part of new intelligent and
interactive writing assistants. Many are offered commercially with a
chatbot-like UI, such as ChatGPT, and provide little information about their
inner workings. This makes this new type of widespread system a potential
target for deceptive design patterns. For example, such assistants might
exploit hidden costs by providing guidance up until a certain point before
asking for a fee to see the rest. As another example, they might sneak unwanted
content/edits into longer generated or revised text pieces (e.g. to influence
the expressed opinion). With these and other examples, we conceptually transfer
several deceptive patterns from the literature to the new context of AI writing
assistants. Our goal is to raise awareness and encourage future research into
how the UI and interaction design of such systems can impact people and their
writing.
|
[
0.01001124270260334,
-0.9807082414627075,
0.861339271068573,
0.2532377243041992,
-0.05025684833526611,
0.0755099281668663,
0.19034238159656525,
-0.8520297408103943,
0.24582521617412567,
1.0379523038864136,
-0.5776990652084351,
-0.2966185510158539,
-0.4506834149360657,
0.04335067421197891,
-0.5269220471382141,
0.7460899949073792,
-0.026147419586777687,
-0.1241627186536789,
-0.23804521560668945,
0.23787957429885864,
-0.6882936954498291,
-0.6566811800003052,
-0.9040403962135315,
-0.09824792295694351,
0.4399474859237671,
0.28968489170074463,
0.6771988272666931,
0.4747332036495209,
0.5367099642753601,
0.3512108027935028,
0.2460946887731552,
0.2644488215446472,
-0.3175991177558899,
0.27095574140548706,
0.178513303399086,
-0.7195476293563843,
-0.33633384108543396,
0.3278363347053528,
0.30219823122024536,
0.5135776996612549,
0.04929586499929428,
-0.0927172303199768,
0.2595840096473694,
0.5543372631072998,
-0.5597048401832581,
0.5496400594711304,
-0.34545567631721497,
0.13348951935768127,
-0.2594495117664337,
-0.18534031510353088,
-0.9565086960792542,
-0.5569307208061218,
0.02896026521921158,
-0.873298704624176,
-0.03209203854203224,
0.23088277876377106,
0.6085357069969177,
0.21329551935195923,
-0.0964452400803566,
-0.8547987937927246,
-0.8343205451965332,
0.5152503252029419,
-0.5884292125701904,
-0.014100292697548866,
0.5660316348075867,
0.2449529469013214,
-0.3132055997848511,
-0.7154258489608765,
-0.7779970169067383,
-0.5830208659172058,
-0.4025023877620697,
0.16558489203453064,
-0.400013267993927,
0.23445233702659607,
0.44158798456192017,
0.19729119539260864,
-0.48159363865852356,
0.15761323273181915,
-0.18528062105178833,
-0.07724372297525406,
0.7148371338844299,
0.17313070595264435,
0.6853346228599548,
0.24698127806186676,
-0.14956629276275635,
-0.010252440348267555,
-0.5811247825622559,
-0.04647771269083023,
0.6769442558288574,
-0.05971929803490639,
-0.3435323238372803,
0.5768889784812927,
-0.0852026492357254,
0.8703168630599976,
0.017848478630185127,
-0.08127669990062714,
0.11542265862226486,
-0.05686141923069954,
-0.11855891346931458,
0.19210951030254364,
0.6243314743041992,
0.4608810544013977,
0.6542945504188538,
-0.07689919322729111,
-0.30639296770095825,
0.1869511902332306,
0.19375410676002502,
-0.5091708898544312,
-0.41612643003463745,
-0.12598872184753418,
-0.6861563324928284,
-0.7428954243659973,
0.010070901364088058,
-0.6989714503288269,
-0.8975443243980408,
-0.37945011258125305,
0.3406542241573334,
-0.42560818791389465,
-0.17918720841407776,
-0.018572194501757622,
-0.44938400387763977,
0.33402469754219055,
0.6017748713493347,
-0.824222981929779,
0.34274253249168396,
0.6327791213989258,
0.7216115593910217,
-0.09120263904333115,
-0.3343219757080078,
-0.314882755279541,
0.1864735335111618,
-0.34508565068244934,
0.8837136626243591,
-0.9516666531562805,
-0.527387797832489,
0.11295375227928162,
-0.13634093105793,
-0.14042533934116364,
-0.25782936811447144,
0.381369411945343,
-0.5452816486358643,
0.5747843384742737,
-0.054746225476264954,
-0.37870705127716064,
-0.18122515082359314,
0.16222381591796875,
-0.8576260209083557,
0.4880104959011078,
0.1247774213552475,
-0.5107697248458862,
0.2869265079498291,
-1.0168495178222656,
-0.43842315673828125,
0.25018519163131714,
-0.2811785340309143,
-0.17962594330310822,
0.04564836248755455,
-0.0717553198337555,
0.35139256715774536,
-0.10017235577106476,
-0.23258481919765472,
-0.03310561552643776,
-0.4509223997592926,
0.7435182929039001,
-0.9143365621566772,
0.9157615900039673,
0.30935990810394287,
-0.30756065249443054,
-0.06428012251853943,
-0.7811341881752014,
-0.32885369658470154,
0.12810832262039185,
-0.38854533433914185,
-0.6830612421035767,
-0.16221226751804352,
0.031066300347447395,
-0.08488735556602478,
0.3082488775253296,
-0.5033361911773682,
0.4589328467845917,
-0.19280032813549042,
0.2851473391056061,
0.8055527210235596,
0.13384924829006195,
0.34961405396461487,
-0.7542135715484619,
0.8133660554885864,
-0.22939613461494446,
0.3483336865901947,
-0.34575456380844116,
-0.7167808413505554,
-0.5373854041099548,
-0.2372381091117859,
0.1347864866256714,
0.5639871954917908,
-0.7840691804885864,
0.19662433862686157,
0.021908076480031013,
-0.3566511869430542,
-0.5406855940818787,
0.026695383712649345,
0.5832647681236267,
0.34892359375953674,
0.0071787480264902115,
-0.07114405930042267,
-0.13021571934223175,
-0.845289409160614,
-0.378367155790329,
-0.060238249599933624,
-0.10643865168094635,
0.07190538197755814,
0.18377579748630524,
0.008885676972568035,
0.7841193079948425,
-0.5250816345214844,
-0.4096153974533081,
-0.33585578203201294,
0.2927267551422119,
0.04175582528114319,
0.5144996643066406,
0.8400909900665283,
-0.9794824123382568,
-0.8559355139732361,
-0.09155569225549698,
-0.4763758182525635,
-0.26177912950515747,
-0.630922257900238,
-0.016618605703115463,
0.41549497842788696,
0.7703874707221985,
-0.6866171360015869,
0.5823212265968323,
0.6746340394020081,
-0.6120824813842773,
0.632820188999176,
-0.12337558716535568,
0.13635970652103424,
-1.0181949138641357,
0.0053862640634179115,
-0.12002166360616684,
0.11485084146261215,
-0.6782902479171753,
-0.038373492658138275,
-0.1963927000761032,
-0.06736069917678833,
-0.15949483215808868,
0.4880181849002838,
-0.7700285911560059,
0.3935140073299408,
-0.37361857295036316,
0.0758792832493782,
0.1505552977323532,
0.6197187900543213,
-0.10524065792560577,
0.839979887008667,
0.23796306550502777,
-0.33894309401512146,
0.20420925319194794,
0.13034319877624512,
-0.4603545665740967,
0.49617084860801697,
-0.6861223578453064,
0.16086561977863312,
-0.35157570242881775,
0.3089541792869568,
-0.9271754026412964,
-0.2732055187225342,
0.5034764409065247,
-0.4691411554813385,
0.2447960078716278,
-0.06405521929264069,
-0.5946124792098999,
-0.08466152846813202,
-0.20416104793548584,
0.2887769937515259,
0.7264107465744019,
-0.24152705073356628,
0.6100610494613647,
0.2515009939670563,
-0.23802044987678528,
-0.38823196291923523,
-0.9130979180335999,
0.12573538720607758,
-0.12671548128128052,
-0.3082621395587921,
0.1425352394580841,
-0.1535310447216034,
-0.5107605457305908,
-0.03411681205034256,
0.4791039228439331,
0.006023258436471224,
0.195362389087677,
0.46642327308654785,
0.2534868121147156,
-0.22729068994522095,
-0.09626413881778717,
-0.07594050467014313,
-0.027573447674512863,
0.214854896068573,
-0.03041260689496994,
0.7451031804084778,
0.3004896342754364,
-0.6100347638130188,
-0.8647778630256653,
0.5509951710700989,
1.0435967445373535,
-0.16616305708885193,
0.6431337594985962,
0.2740902006626129,
-0.20807531476020813,
-0.1548616886138916,
-0.6577171087265015,
0.07194408774375916,
-0.541784405708313,
0.0814836397767067,
-0.45415839552879333,
-0.5253797173500061,
0.6083666682243347,
0.20937639474868774,
0.12932980060577393,
0.23680387437343597,
0.26361510157585144,
0.05914118140935898,
1.0692394971847534,
0.8106122612953186,
0.03507936745882034,
0.8602921962738037,
0.06477537751197815,
0.1874743551015854,
-0.5102754831314087,
-0.3843494653701782,
-0.5772452354431152,
-0.1974971741437912,
-0.7221103310585022,
-0.17516551911830902,
0.10017869621515274,
-0.13980545103549957,
0.01851847395300865,
0.19447779655456543,
-0.7744224667549133,
0.7003545165061951,
1.087069034576416,
-0.03303962200880051,
0.4459245502948761,
-0.06808541715145111,
0.11027372628450394,
0.22267961502075195,
-0.451680451631546,
-0.6113885045051575,
0.8692519664764404,
0.20832093060016632,
0.8583776950836182,
0.13930219411849976,
0.28740161657333374,
0.744725227355957,
0.3516836166381836,
-0.6951029896736145,
0.4680582582950592,
-0.08188654482364655,
-0.2871555685997009,
-0.4814552664756775,
-0.03933793306350708,
-1.0858776569366455,
-0.07141058146953583,
-0.07339309900999069,
-0.8046695590019226,
0.397112101316452,
0.224630206823349,
-0.26684170961380005,
0.20439648628234863,
-1.0956369638442993,
0.5843806862831116,
-0.12462259829044342,
-0.1691906601190567,
-0.1597912609577179,
-0.4812517762184143,
0.30850479006767273,
-0.044297508895397186,
-0.01567509025335312,
-0.11993787437677383,
0.15103647112846375,
0.5184022188186646,
-0.29121366143226624,
1.3302594423294067,
-0.08901992440223694,
-0.24371398985385895,
0.3077503442764282,
0.38813143968582153,
0.7363452911376953,
-0.2990913391113281,
-0.2519545555114746,
-0.011420528404414654,
-0.09970476478338242,
-0.331175297498703,
-0.5967870354652405,
0.48572465777397156,
-0.6549696326255798,
-0.6007698178291321,
-0.46782922744750977,
-0.5500755310058594,
-0.028157657012343407,
0.37491440773010254,
0.24820616841316223,
0.501629114151001,
-0.3025996685028076,
0.0006241837400011718,
0.5916902422904968,
-0.26695510745048523,
0.47701242566108704,
0.50420081615448,
0.06610876321792603,
0.06090470030903816,
0.8577794432640076,
-0.09374234825372696,
0.41372108459472656,
0.6014871597290039,
0.04658576101064682,
-0.04053575173020363,
-0.6614344120025635,
-0.4680151045322418,
0.1420435756444931,
-0.5120124220848083,
0.05505744367837906,
-0.5932443141937256,
-0.2917707562446594,
-0.708388090133667,
-0.4754856824874878,
0.16763097047805786,
-0.49868056178092957,
-0.42233696579933167,
0.19742244482040405,
0.4838881492614746,
1.1042454242706299,
0.17258211970329285,
0.5943872928619385,
-0.7416513562202454,
0.17237232625484467,
0.2489258348941803,
0.32720518112182617,
0.06096537038683891,
-0.13637572526931763,
-0.03177403658628464,
0.1598641723394394,
-0.22756879031658173,
-0.8133296370506287,
0.3197519779205322,
-0.2161756008863449,
0.7366059422492981,
0.6062230467796326,
0.10327227413654327,
0.21431200206279755,
-0.49215614795684814,
0.909916341304779,
0.23944777250289917,
-0.6640892624855042,
0.44234248995780945,
-0.39331597089767456,
0.3203182816505432,
0.45200619101524353,
0.23209281265735626,
-0.8348615765571594,
-0.5811483263969421,
-0.4814879596233368,
-0.335869699716568,
0.7396523952484131,
0.1763824224472046,
0.345525324344635,
0.18701881170272827,
0.2622125446796417,
0.37674587965011597,
0.26303571462631226,
-0.8678614497184753,
-0.12894299626350403,
-0.15547646582126617,
-0.3524310290813446,
0.3320624530315399,
-0.48454368114471436,
-0.09705592691898346,
0.285828560590744,
0.4257350265979767,
-0.06711731851100922,
0.42436033487319946,
-0.006614301819354296,
0.056065648794174194,
0.1211036741733551,
0.07476180046796799,
0.931191623210907,
0.4927283227443695,
0.22420960664749146,
0.0020808069966733456,
-0.2510472536087036,
-0.7975754737854004,
-0.1941000074148178,
0.11031116545200348,
-0.4267329275608063,
0.06834384053945541,
0.49061521887779236,
0.7352275848388672,
-0.16521303355693817,
-0.6077275276184082,
0.5503394603729248,
-0.08575019985437393,
-0.3301962614059448,
-0.7477170825004578,
0.435558021068573,
-0.30963248014450073,
0.16131055355072021,
0.1999691128730774,
0.07678483426570892,
0.3090359568595886,
-0.7829530835151672,
-0.30451905727386475,
0.5683319568634033,
-0.4156775176525116,
-0.22376663982868195,
0.5266777873039246,
0.43241697549819946,
-0.7368735074996948,
0.7453078627586365,
-0.1385626494884491,
-0.2943982779979706,
0.5431207418441772,
0.5293638110160828,
0.9653142690658569,
-0.16476790606975555,
0.360085129737854,
-0.24936331808567047,
0.42030712962150574,
0.05198417231440544,
0.13263356685638428,
-0.2722209095954895,
-0.577735960483551,
-0.2557736337184906,
-0.38856276869773865,
-0.5353244543075562,
0.22589482367038727,
-0.29880818724632263,
0.41814011335372925,
-0.41025739908218384,
0.35460349917411804,
0.07445560395717621,
-0.3220037519931793,
-0.4388129711151123,
-0.12492205947637558,
0.05081982538104057,
0.7592348456382751,
-0.5175657868385315,
0.6970198154449463,
0.5570768117904663,
-0.6877983212471008,
-0.49914246797561646,
0.2298206090927124,
-0.10827849060297012,
-1.0151779651641846,
0.31810370087623596,
0.055988624691963196,
-0.3666069209575653,
-0.14019925892353058,
-0.7366947531700134,
-0.8152710795402527,
0.8273068070411682,
0.10946550220251083,
-0.4128362536430359,
-0.6237650513648987,
0.4453854560852051,
0.5200272798538208,
-0.3085757791996002,
0.263740599155426,
0.37186819314956665,
0.6104300618171692,
-0.08081510663032532,
-0.8416679501533508,
0.2807815372943878,
-0.4206962287425995,
-0.1525312066078186,
0.11442346125841141,
-0.8521604537963867,
0.7698356509208679,
0.07549189031124115,
-0.2527143061161041,
0.33926519751548767,
0.11510033160448074,
-0.02188793756067753,
0.42678552865982056,
0.39013051986694336,
0.02548062801361084,
0.6806402802467346,
0.10367981344461441,
1.0056082010269165,
-0.31956472992897034,
-0.37328943610191345,
0.9574779272079468,
-0.17774413526058197,
0.3438698947429657,
0.36381593346595764,
0.2342919558286667,
0.9075658321380615,
0.2225590944290161,
-0.2834067940711975,
0.4026159942150116,
0.22148758172988892,
-0.26868927478790283,
0.07018499076366425,
-0.2319732904434204,
-0.367881178855896,
0.5235854983329773,
0.6592172980308533,
-0.6510969400405884,
0.08428414911031723,
0.150615394115448,
0.11162004619836807,
0.21373043954372406,
-0.019189633429050446,
1.045811653137207,
0.003688385244458914,
-0.7294592261314392,
0.08848728239536285,
-0.0863233432173729,
0.6140933036804199,
-0.5982661247253418,
-0.5378376245498657,
-0.14370957016944885,
-0.0017059630481526256,
-0.048836253583431244,
-0.7957170009613037,
-0.0021789418533444405,
-0.17774240672588348,
-0.12170317023992538,
-0.6117922067642212,
0.8524025678634644,
-0.14201931655406952,
-0.40859755873680115,
-0.2398761510848999,
0.38133320212364197,
0.17268896102905273,
-0.10948267579078674,
-0.5785873532295227,
-0.03387919440865517,
0.057543978095054626,
-0.29395559430122375,
0.11170948296785355,
0.7235387563705444,
-0.21228033304214478,
0.6040219664573669,
0.7313930988311768,
0.017988920211791992,
-0.12666165828704834,
0.08904626220464706,
0.6343527436256409,
-0.5915153622627258,
-0.8441542983055115,
-0.7808352708816528,
0.32200849056243896,
-0.45799121260643005,
-0.4149710536003113,
0.9070221781730652,
0.43184950947761536,
0.6203701496124268,
-0.1421419382095337,
1.1073416471481323,
0.09912577271461487,
0.45274314284324646,
-0.7176641821861267,
1.104714035987854,
-0.34945401549339294,
0.3168530762195587,
-0.44549933075904846,
-0.7107358574867249,
-0.26631587743759155,
0.30359673500061035,
-0.269467294216156,
0.09116776287555695,
0.6587169170379639,
0.6937220692634583,
0.019322605803608894,
0.3486471474170685,
0.4890771806240082,
0.22779473662376404,
0.38206472992897034,
0.32317522168159485,
1.1215840578079224,
0.04536009207367897,
0.6830046772956848,
-0.1943882405757904,
-0.33112964034080505,
-0.4634619653224945,
-0.5198937058448792,
-0.9434716105461121,
-0.608073890209198,
-0.2990073263645172,
-0.3803872764110565,
0.16418808698654175,
0.5873675346374512,
0.40188872814178467,
-0.5152604579925537,
-0.0027312873862683773,
-0.3905586004257202,
0.17391251027584076,
-0.17474426329135895,
-0.30536746978759766,
0.24842846393585205,
-0.041703131049871445,
-0.9945105910301208,
0.14230698347091675,
0.1975480616092682,
0.6303567886352539,
-0.4361313283443451,
0.4382118284702301,
0.2072472870349884,
0.35547342896461487,
0.6659464240074158,
0.3484548330307007,
-0.5682181715965271,
-0.20853082835674286,
0.03317343443632126,
-0.2586538791656494,
-0.12418757379055023,
1.0963084697723389,
-0.7414365410804749,
0.17887696623802185,
0.4795862138271332,
0.40995582938194275,
0.1234247162938118,
-0.028808750212192535,
0.8022662997245789,
-0.4414481222629547,
0.2123163938522339,
0.3425182104110718,
0.019801998510956764,
0.12760359048843384,
-0.8642979860305786,
0.28070369362831116,
0.1571856290102005,
-0.47548016905784607,
-0.7104004621505737,
0.3127650320529938,
-0.8451133966445923,
-0.591389000415802,
1.2070064544677734,
0.09499932080507278,
-0.09797286242246628,
-0.4477580785751343,
-0.6699979305267334,
-0.07335013896226883,
-0.5203260779380798,
1.0322003364562988,
0.7559162974357605,
-0.5550081133842468,
-0.09754963964223862,
-0.5507102012634277,
0.7769722938537598,
0.16843900084495544,
-0.8879496455192566,
0.18284492194652557,
0.8168005347251892,
-0.04411524906754494,
0.34294870495796204,
0.7765719890594482,
-0.10402776300907135,
0.3493508994579315,
0.4342789053916931,
-0.03146960213780403,
-0.11910419911146164,
-0.21301980316638947,
-0.05377152934670448,
0.23618315160274506,
0.24100318551063538,
-0.3669026792049408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09371v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09371v1
|
The Effect of Data Partitioning Strategy on Model Generalizability: A Case Study of Morphological Segmentation
| 2024-04-14T22:22:58 | 2024-04-14T22:22:58 |
Zoey Liu, Bonnie J. Dorr
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Recent work to enhance data partitioning strategies for more realistic model
evaluation face challenges in providing a clear optimal choice. This study
addresses these challenges, focusing on morphological segmentation and
synthesizing limitations related to language diversity, adoption of multiple
datasets and splits, and detailed model comparisons. Our study leverages data
from 19 languages, including ten indigenous or endangered languages across 10
language families with diverse morphological systems (polysynthetic, fusional,
and agglutinative) and different degrees of data availability. We conduct
large-scale experimentation with varying sized combinations of training and
evaluation sets as well as new test data. Our results show that, when faced
with new test data: (1) models trained from random splits are able to achieve
higher numerical scores; (2) model rankings derived from random splits tend to
generalize more consistently.
|
[
-0.4843693971633911,
-0.6758890748023987,
0.4427071511745453,
0.5564796924591064,
-0.5599599480628967,
0.10557197779417038,
-0.21141749620437622,
-0.43715357780456543,
0.04371780529618263,
0.028559774160385132,
-0.4771225154399872,
-0.44079968333244324,
-0.562740683555603,
0.25188425183296204,
-0.3993493318557739,
0.5432301163673401,
0.1833442896604538,
0.3679303228855133,
-0.21106289327144623,
-0.4882075786590576,
-0.44440773129463196,
-0.7749481201171875,
-0.33329328894615173,
-0.015158173628151417,
0.3381207287311554,
0.09148090332746506,
0.8732457756996155,
1.4247889518737793,
0.5794994235038757,
0.3315249979496002,
-0.44929441809654236,
-0.06366554647684097,
-0.2241702824831009,
0.3525966703891754,
-0.25818532705307007,
-0.7679250240325928,
0.08394082635641098,
-0.22579114139080048,
0.9418308138847351,
1.0812948942184448,
-0.3036731779575348,
-0.16354501247406006,
-0.27477332949638367,
0.422756165266037,
-0.6634445786476135,
-0.06624361127614975,
-0.6715463995933533,
0.11836280673742294,
-0.3493918478488922,
0.33485540747642517,
-0.3137917220592499,
-0.42499840259552,
0.410410612821579,
-0.4410969913005829,
0.3390428125858307,
-0.26010361313819885,
0.7207790017127991,
0.15545342862606049,
-0.3244084119796753,
-0.263122022151947,
-0.7786047458648682,
0.7951294779777527,
-0.5532025098800659,
0.5684792399406433,
0.16546328365802765,
0.30086925625801086,
0.12011929601430893,
-0.42200174927711487,
-0.09213670343160629,
0.07296783477067947,
0.25419488549232483,
-0.3205009698867798,
-0.24077416956424713,
-0.03635323420166969,
0.2597986161708832,
0.5281602740287781,
-0.5601022839546204,
0.5437629818916321,
-0.4364597499370575,
-0.36090096831321716,
0.694066047668457,
0.43993890285491943,
0.7682921290397644,
-0.10883008688688278,
0.008797714486718178,
-0.4114342927932739,
-0.5255429148674011,
-0.06921623647212982,
0.7429067492485046,
0.5828314423561096,
-0.050303857773542404,
0.5965651869773865,
-0.22895018756389618,
0.9073812365531921,
-0.20117758214473724,
0.005658149719238281,
0.4927012026309967,
-0.6258160471916199,
-0.151602640748024,
-0.43933621048927307,
0.6421889066696167,
0.15953801572322845,
0.05695253983139992,
-0.19926805794239044,
-0.17217914760112762,
0.031820524483919144,
0.1830795407295227,
-0.6132817268371582,
-0.08325079828500748,
0.14568518102169037,
-0.45058324933052063,
-0.20941610634326935,
-0.11402025818824768,
-0.9264542460441589,
-0.26895198225975037,
-0.31501004099845886,
0.14123442769050598,
-0.6555958390235901,
-0.29369232058525085,
0.22337393462657928,
-0.36234772205352783,
0.24708300828933716,
0.3076332211494446,
-1.2443617582321167,
0.40291401743888855,
0.787912905216217,
0.9904677271842957,
-0.5571063160896301,
-0.2872646749019623,
0.007357631344348192,
-0.2566322982311249,
-0.5171121954917908,
0.6959695219993591,
-1.111433982849121,
-0.5905457139015198,
-0.2582802474498749,
-0.13400234282016754,
-0.6741093993186951,
-1.1000853776931763,
0.3490561246871948,
-0.18567685782909393,
0.1523558497428894,
0.028832390904426575,
-0.4461912214756012,
-0.20305973291397095,
-0.005172109231352806,
-0.8595221638679504,
0.39530131220817566,
0.035403620451688766,
-0.6208633780479431,
0.7490978837013245,
-0.40544137358665466,
-0.4275839328765869,
-0.020718466490507126,
-0.20767754316329956,
-0.4427107572555542,
0.47716212272644043,
0.13688825070858002,
0.2017185539007187,
0.002926000626757741,
0.19031138718128204,
-0.5423396229743958,
0.11083970218896866,
-0.002922140760347247,
-0.39449527859687805,
0.611484706401825,
0.3633507788181305,
-0.05102178826928139,
0.1839316487312317,
-0.9287989735603333,
0.19411428272724152,
0.2238825410604477,
-0.3045419156551361,
-0.7264171242713928,
0.19947944581508636,
-0.14406108856201172,
-0.1713963747024536,
-0.1737486869096756,
-0.4572567045688629,
0.39691781997680664,
-0.4349602460861206,
0.359809547662735,
0.4992640018463135,
0.0793239176273346,
0.6971561908721924,
-0.13370706140995026,
0.5861787796020508,
0.1759711354970932,
0.3456709682941437,
-0.13612759113311768,
-0.5683254599571228,
-0.7352275848388672,
-0.4002093970775604,
0.7621657848358154,
0.2278207540512085,
-0.3952915370464325,
0.18315891921520233,
-0.10477427393198013,
-0.5059697031974792,
-0.5228906273841858,
-0.3424760103225708,
0.20260004699230194,
-0.06800476461648941,
0.04862804710865021,
-0.5948207974433899,
-0.5529235601425171,
-1.3558707237243652,
0.06680961698293686,
-0.0285868551582098,
-0.04900951683521271,
0.21685707569122314,
0.4787459373474121,
-0.38937318325042725,
0.8795918822288513,
-0.5140594244003296,
0.35939010977745056,
-0.2773965001106262,
0.06287702172994614,
0.09715267270803452,
0.6605164408683777,
0.5106725096702576,
-0.9454881548881531,
-0.19823534786701202,
0.033590417355298996,
-0.4554755985736847,
0.326831579208374,
0.21881426870822906,
0.016682865098118782,
-0.04681568965315819,
-0.09082895517349243,
-0.38305631279945374,
0.4004218578338623,
0.41999074816703796,
0.1582413762807846,
0.5235137939453125,
-0.27939823269844055,
-0.07476437091827393,
-0.8441252708435059,
-0.09430086612701416,
0.10930737853050232,
0.14909909665584564,
-1.018723726272583,
0.27390629053115845,
-0.01717752031981945,
-0.06620817631483078,
-0.3722147047519684,
0.3557208776473999,
-0.33959221839904785,
-0.15807074308395386,
-0.0061055137775838375,
-0.6653078198432922,
-0.5581983923912048,
0.1933804154396057,
0.2333553433418274,
0.4722830355167389,
0.7326045036315918,
-0.6357294917106628,
-0.14848841726779938,
0.18756580352783203,
-0.48409605026245117,
0.13055826723575592,
-0.5729365348815918,
0.1848621815443039,
-0.12967953085899353,
-0.03874028101563454,
-0.8824021816253662,
-0.5700317025184631,
0.1190381869673729,
-0.014599178917706013,
0.2568768262863159,
-0.36155804991722107,
-0.33665814995765686,
-0.15454216301441193,
-0.15431998670101166,
0.8689680695533752,
0.33862462639808655,
-0.4322850704193115,
0.4181555211544037,
0.6910062432289124,
-0.3457503020763397,
-0.17608998715877533,
-0.33715614676475525,
-0.23563914000988007,
-0.6066328883171082,
-0.9350782036781311,
0.04364848509430885,
-0.22162209451198578,
-0.45251166820526123,
-0.26020172238349915,
-0.13268227875232697,
-0.6571991443634033,
0.31791236996650696,
0.08036484569311142,
0.13878248631954193,
0.011388315819203854,
-0.03033665381371975,
0.22747200727462769,
0.16375023126602173,
-0.15421879291534424,
-0.1416664868593216,
0.9701792597770691,
0.16675400733947754,
-0.4020117223262787,
0.02051371894776821,
0.1540260761976242,
0.4678856134414673,
-0.35735026001930237,
0.5676913857460022,
0.008064704947173595,
-0.36523815989494324,
-0.4150655269622803,
-0.3924643099308014,
0.15893268585205078,
-0.4046018123626709,
0.43474888801574707,
-0.47368618845939636,
-0.8547207713127136,
0.7282199263572693,
0.12428018450737,
0.14265957474708557,
0.44916096329689026,
0.6030409932136536,
0.4333515465259552,
1.367727279663086,
0.5451217889785767,
-0.10041438788175583,
0.320823609828949,
-0.19594047963619232,
-0.09520524740219116,
-0.5928562879562378,
-0.34062886238098145,
-0.6489375233650208,
-0.2294882982969284,
-0.8024537563323975,
-0.5787052512168884,
0.163050577044487,
-0.29018935561180115,
0.3374333381652832,
-0.05765162408351898,
-0.6288912892341614,
0.6485099792480469,
0.3236564099788666,
-0.0013180089881643653,
0.21024733781814575,
0.3398294746875763,
-0.3880455493927002,
-0.031231513246893883,
-0.67596036195755,
-0.22325806319713593,
1.183965802192688,
0.47239992022514343,
0.6995170712471008,
-0.11927470564842224,
0.8028173446655273,
0.021674415096640587,
-0.11688905954360962,
-0.7549483180046082,
0.38033628463745117,
-0.34090307354927063,
-0.7828531861305237,
-0.616937518119812,
-0.5510666370391846,
-1.1871763467788696,
0.8801555037498474,
0.23162604868412018,
-0.7870623469352722,
0.666039764881134,
-0.294594943523407,
-0.3070547580718994,
0.18053610622882843,
-0.804180383682251,
0.4763354957103729,
-0.1512872725725174,
0.028311127796769142,
-0.1831371933221817,
-0.6021198630332947,
0.4681611955165863,
-0.3342687785625458,
0.411436527967453,
-0.1319301277399063,
-0.02827128954231739,
1.033392310142517,
-0.46441125869750977,
0.5988919734954834,
-0.07287004590034485,
0.10044396668672562,
0.06765802949666977,
-0.006592224817723036,
-0.13590553402900696,
-0.2626356780529022,
-0.07490522414445877,
0.08383027464151382,
0.013290148228406906,
-0.3984832763671875,
-0.5508204698562622,
0.3759145438671112,
-0.7809212803840637,
-0.6899464726448059,
-0.3307487666606903,
-0.7973601818084717,
-0.4439772367477417,
0.16863590478897095,
0.36189842224121094,
0.42388391494750977,
-0.40840867161750793,
0.24211977422237396,
0.6136318445205688,
-0.1600366085767746,
0.38454174995422363,
0.38557884097099304,
-0.2946959435939789,
-0.5813161730766296,
1.120400309562683,
0.47092974185943604,
0.3493210971355438,
-0.022107474505901337,
0.22816501557826996,
-0.22449243068695068,
-1.1387666463851929,
-0.42823708057403564,
0.2653578817844391,
-0.34247568249702454,
0.3636903464794159,
-0.45954611897468567,
-0.3221760094165802,
-0.1442834734916687,
0.19800694286823273,
-0.33556079864501953,
-0.6980924010276794,
-0.04321056604385376,
-0.2493034452199936,
-0.345602422952652,
0.9630089402198792,
-0.21312524378299713,
0.17076475918293,
-0.4665399491786957,
-0.013301171362400055,
0.15930086374282837,
0.3196006417274475,
0.13172824680805206,
-0.2371329665184021,
-0.04158185049891472,
0.04108884558081627,
-0.02444837987422943,
-0.6885874271392822,
0.275469571352005,
-0.04799959436058998,
0.8494849801063538,
0.3148040473461151,
-0.4633369445800781,
0.5245125889778137,
-0.5607033371925354,
0.5034665465354919,
0.15706883370876312,
-0.6420127749443054,
0.38144651055336,
-0.5364351272583008,
0.2879887819290161,
0.6817877888679504,
0.5534512400627136,
-0.4357231855392456,
-0.3722422122955322,
-0.6419334411621094,
-0.9220051169395447,
0.7261449694633484,
0.25766998529434204,
0.11785618215799332,
0.07025223225355148,
0.08871545642614365,
0.5757061839103699,
0.08497169613838196,
-0.33088386058807373,
-0.14416958391666412,
0.1779111623764038,
0.028420278802514076,
0.047192007303237915,
-0.2821696698665619,
-0.03712055832147598,
-0.34985148906707764,
0.23782950639724731,
0.143382266163826,
-0.142339825630188,
-0.17946292459964752,
-0.22036409378051758,
0.20053531229496002,
0.3031662106513977,
0.7125800251960754,
0.8353225588798523,
-0.06143238767981529,
-0.1068812906742096,
-0.03431880474090576,
-0.5924386382102966,
0.49451494216918945,
0.02808285690844059,
-0.4857062101364136,
0.16565324366092682,
0.3345530927181244,
0.998997688293457,
0.0052191889844834805,
-0.3217400014400482,
-0.005361471325159073,
-0.1985490322113037,
-0.39669179916381836,
0.3914998471736908,
0.26866230368614197,
0.0035359784960746765,
0.05180533602833748,
0.33449098467826843,
0.03165168687701225,
0.15850761532783508,
-0.5017226338386536,
0.24932366609573364,
0.4048127830028534,
0.07306215167045593,
-0.4785057008266449,
0.34047994017601013,
0.09858300536870956,
-0.18980133533477783,
0.7634941935539246,
-0.07770635932683945,
-0.5146305561065674,
0.8699235916137695,
0.3700826168060303,
0.7268953919410706,
-0.6382331252098083,
0.5094127058982849,
0.26235851645469666,
0.17946402728557587,
-0.22859956324100494,
0.05011787638068199,
0.1604447215795517,
-0.6716184616088867,
-0.22903381288051605,
-0.6887610554695129,
-0.584198534488678,
0.05583522841334343,
-0.7294289469718933,
0.01632029563188553,
-0.5479738116264343,
-0.30546990036964417,
0.16200990974903107,
-0.3467678129673004,
-0.4703648090362549,
0.4281037747859955,
0.2756366431713104,
0.8088685870170593,
-0.9955392479896545,
0.41480931639671326,
0.6946139931678772,
-0.2876010239124298,
-0.862119197845459,
-0.14033813774585724,
0.01967673934996128,
-0.9040898680686951,
0.47186222672462463,
0.11503822356462479,
0.6050892472267151,
-0.2591691315174103,
-0.33321014046669006,
-1.1415725946426392,
0.6662259101867676,
0.35995960235595703,
-0.35464099049568176,
-0.29203349351882935,
0.6146143674850464,
0.7567811608314514,
-0.4746279716491699,
0.32702597975730896,
0.8381869196891785,
0.45877566933631897,
0.35650452971458435,
-0.9203858375549316,
-0.2715417444705963,
-0.22624963521957397,
0.1521201878786087,
0.2843373715877533,
-0.7747107148170471,
0.9197462201118469,
0.07366339862346649,
-0.501693606376648,
0.20798636972904205,
0.266385942697525,
0.284689337015152,
0.18261222541332245,
0.7753501534461975,
0.7697437405586243,
0.9119746088981628,
-0.19472616910934448,
1.1516622304916382,
0.14582301676273346,
0.13658399879932404,
0.9509778022766113,
-0.227475106716156,
0.5406376719474792,
0.207628071308136,
-0.3071519434452057,
0.26416125893592834,
0.9686775803565979,
-0.434346467256546,
0.5930655598640442,
0.44987645745277405,
-0.06650855392217636,
-0.18544895946979523,
-0.3964660167694092,
-0.3350043296813965,
0.5877333283424377,
0.15911677479743958,
-0.36905601620674133,
-0.47381725907325745,
-0.04445232078433037,
-0.15198498964309692,
-0.37945547699928284,
-0.23273269832134247,
0.7658076882362366,
-0.2065960019826889,
-0.5356308817863464,
0.5369938015937805,
-0.04393944516777992,
0.37206315994262695,
-0.7479998469352722,
0.14978750050067902,
-0.45399364829063416,
-0.10497966408729553,
-0.3434179127216339,
-0.5996452569961548,
0.2708863615989685,
-0.07823029905557632,
-0.2809307873249054,
0.2452135533094406,
0.5814424157142639,
-0.3105320632457733,
-0.6146649122238159,
0.15252035856246948,
0.6103807091712952,
0.1384049654006958,
0.10801348835229874,
-0.24695925414562225,
0.5118251442909241,
0.35073480010032654,
-0.08278924971818924,
0.794543445110321,
0.17923341691493988,
-0.5041137933731079,
0.851097583770752,
0.6366631388664246,
0.09481600672006607,
0.5471510887145996,
0.2561281621456146,
0.9513621926307678,
-0.30153873562812805,
-0.48141908645629883,
-1.0210398435592651,
0.5042976140975952,
-0.11621463298797607,
-0.18387471139431,
0.7927641272544861,
1.0296093225479126,
0.9188211560249329,
-0.014198197983205318,
0.8589902520179749,
0.09610620886087418,
0.3128509223461151,
-0.2921392619609833,
0.4078831374645233,
-0.3110804259777069,
0.08568376302719116,
-0.12157566100358963,
-1.0724774599075317,
-0.4334421455860138,
0.19523203372955322,
-0.5831088423728943,
0.0041107372380793095,
0.5154983997344971,
0.4794865846633911,
-0.17529968917369843,
0.09670254588127136,
0.3806828558444977,
-0.12946036458015442,
0.28440454602241516,
0.2107062190771103,
0.9751415252685547,
0.1371772289276123,
0.18079550564289093,
-0.47682616114616394,
-0.1877620667219162,
0.10902491956949234,
-0.21414662897586823,
-0.6158311367034912,
-0.6718578338623047,
-0.16512654721736908,
0.2444351762533188,
0.08282101899385452,
0.5429614186286926,
0.8615808486938477,
-0.8113301396369934,
-0.5528947710990906,
0.21704764664173126,
0.2582920491695404,
0.29193538427352905,
-0.18660402297973633,
0.16862042248249054,
-0.40160226821899414,
-0.8657777905464172,
0.4620019197463989,
0.33823081851005554,
0.20142234861850739,
-0.0665401965379715,
0.23304732143878937,
-0.012394309043884277,
0.10084313154220581,
0.27366873621940613,
0.30935773253440857,
-0.38810721039772034,
-0.042635153979063034,
-0.09234503656625748,
0.16695891320705414,
0.2518010437488556,
0.7883651852607727,
-0.22136275470256805,
0.6207595467567444,
0.5208696722984314,
0.6757600903511047,
0.4546665847301483,
0.29949867725372314,
0.9557058215141296,
-0.2828541100025177,
0.1365213692188263,
0.16062432527542114,
0.3549407422542572,
0.2930898368358612,
0.027203405275940895,
0.9061464667320251,
0.2311544418334961,
-0.23849748075008392,
-1.036272644996643,
0.16168801486492157,
-0.5720593929290771,
-0.3139176368713379,
1.1252809762954712,
0.06533903628587723,
-0.3530690371990204,
0.07593552768230438,
0.03202194347977638,
-0.13380292057991028,
-0.21744535863399506,
0.5370180010795593,
0.9874966144561768,
-0.1614067405462265,
0.1849735528230667,
-0.10344528406858444,
0.27687308192253113,
0.4554479122161865,
-0.7324339747428894,
0.003411701647564769,
0.5985231995582581,
0.5874435901641846,
0.2857418358325958,
0.1719605177640915,
-0.1257023811340332,
0.1328313946723938,
-0.0031256068032234907,
-0.2657982110977173,
0.10595250874757767,
-0.3435097932815552,
-0.8237200379371643,
0.4020109176635742,
0.049717824906110764,
-0.20195257663726807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13070v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13070v2
|
Evidence from counterfactual tasks supports emergent analogical reasoning in large language models
| 2024-04-14T21:51:02 | 2024-04-29T19:48:56 |
Taylor Webb, Keith J. Holyoak, Hongjing Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We recently reported evidence that large language models are capable of
solving a wide range of text-based analogy problems in a zero-shot manner,
indicating the presence of an emergent capacity for analogical reasoning. Two
recent commentaries have challenged these results, citing evidence from
so-called `counterfactual' tasks in which the standard sequence of the alphabet
is arbitrarily permuted so as to decrease similarity with materials that may
have been present in the language model's training data. Here, we reply to
these critiques, clarifying some misunderstandings about the test materials
used in our original work, and presenting evidence that language models are
also capable of generalizing to these new counterfactual task variants.
|
[
-0.17519748210906982,
-1.0601094961166382,
0.9692822098731995,
-0.38722923398017883,
-0.18704341351985931,
-0.3018011748790741,
0.15864291787147522,
-0.4806409478187561,
0.17947998642921448,
0.38335198163986206,
-0.6569007039070129,
0.11029830574989319,
-0.47674670815467834,
0.1753862053155899,
-0.8311507701873779,
0.833713710308075,
-0.25352057814598083,
0.0824851542711258,
-0.3172052502632141,
-0.24677464365959167,
-0.314531534910202,
-0.6495552062988281,
-0.6757192611694336,
-0.6619611978530884,
0.5994561314582825,
0.2457771599292755,
0.8339144587516785,
0.5678539872169495,
0.2052847445011139,
0.36045509576797485,
0.25483521819114685,
-0.3053315281867981,
-0.3023543953895569,
0.31628042459487915,
-0.3734014928340912,
-0.677211344242096,
-0.20331448316574097,
0.24445423483848572,
0.46655431389808655,
0.8948841691017151,
-0.03260470926761627,
0.21542182564735413,
-0.12839695811271667,
0.30442070960998535,
-0.4319819509983063,
-0.19048678874969482,
-0.7870200276374817,
-0.009818268939852715,
0.09245990216732025,
-0.1685306429862976,
-0.5900989174842834,
0.10070309787988663,
0.16351884603500366,
-0.7244943976402283,
0.4275510013103485,
0.05441780760884285,
0.7132266759872437,
-0.12044873088598251,
-0.3540016710758209,
-0.28823766112327576,
-1.0316823720932007,
0.8581147193908691,
-0.8206557631492615,
0.26277339458465576,
0.1553794890642166,
0.06319835782051086,
-0.030278343707323074,
-0.7452003955841064,
-1.1631801128387451,
-0.35697200894355774,
-0.08512324094772339,
-0.008277727290987968,
-0.3119923770427704,
-0.05612300708889961,
0.7221125960350037,
0.28656741976737976,
-0.6582896113395691,
0.10893874615430832,
-0.04983339458703995,
0.03188883885741234,
0.17612725496292114,
0.154897078871727,
0.538528561592102,
0.2832149267196655,
-0.24816781282424927,
-0.0026787822134792805,
-1.0103410482406616,
-0.1815946102142334,
0.37058892846107483,
0.10172688215970993,
-0.08598935604095459,
0.6959126591682434,
-0.19085374474525452,
0.4817863702774048,
0.08357091248035431,
0.36063069105148315,
0.2974238991737366,
-0.2517460584640503,
-0.28610894083976746,
0.08988452702760696,
0.5998159646987915,
0.5064442157745361,
0.5067124366760254,
-0.2126319259405136,
-0.08022615313529968,
0.4460858106613159,
0.28035587072372437,
-0.7930612564086914,
-0.18799687922000885,
0.14330801367759705,
-0.3788696527481079,
-0.10476580262184143,
0.008251138031482697,
-0.4096810519695282,
-0.07344390451908112,
-0.18854598701000214,
0.6319581270217896,
-0.21958130598068237,
-0.23386715352535248,
0.0354381799697876,
-0.28914859890937805,
0.0016064420342445374,
0.44506633281707764,
-1.0961188077926636,
0.40868714451789856,
0.5727843642234802,
0.6406506896018982,
0.22300514578819275,
-0.49401772022247314,
-0.4413560926914215,
-0.08294744044542313,
-0.7673472166061401,
1.1161220073699951,
-0.8277349472045898,
-0.3214923143386841,
-0.030421698465943336,
0.19930246472358704,
-0.2597563564777374,
-0.7678534984588623,
0.11499109864234924,
-0.26427075266838074,
0.3509223759174347,
-0.5808011889457703,
-0.48650386929512024,
-0.22831080853939056,
0.4600330591201782,
-0.4333243668079376,
0.849275529384613,
0.1244514212012291,
-0.644618034362793,
0.34229615330696106,
-0.43280869722366333,
-0.42066285014152527,
-0.1566532403230667,
-0.37214264273643494,
-0.2242303490638733,
0.27630794048309326,
-0.021094966679811478,
-0.0702219158411026,
-0.4117974042892456,
0.07312169671058655,
-0.7233136296272278,
-0.6071868538856506,
0.5477584004402161,
-0.545271098613739,
0.8075321912765503,
0.13482053577899933,
-0.7005317211151123,
-0.08373405784368515,
-0.4869425892829895,
-0.16667604446411133,
0.2869434058666229,
0.08813070505857468,
-0.6480043530464172,
0.0662831962108612,
-0.14924576878547668,
0.3816617429256439,
0.04392017424106598,
-1.0398908853530884,
0.27928444743156433,
-0.4279519319534302,
0.2728534936904907,
0.5915680527687073,
-0.07931557297706604,
0.3667706251144409,
-0.6858395934104919,
0.4304007291793823,
0.13462650775909424,
-0.3082975745201111,
-0.5959884524345398,
-0.6009833812713623,
-0.6646422147750854,
0.05956215783953667,
0.15911294519901276,
0.45651766657829285,
-0.9366731643676758,
-0.07413556426763535,
-0.18548817932605743,
-0.4164096713066101,
-0.24617360532283783,
-0.06868889182806015,
0.570507824420929,
0.6536718606948853,
0.3839513957500458,
-0.40133509039878845,
-0.8147233724594116,
-0.9725967049598694,
-0.33372458815574646,
-0.46489831805229187,
-0.1774049699306488,
0.16781510412693024,
0.7756876945495605,
0.020903607830405235,
0.829741895198822,
-0.3295004367828369,
0.2730433940887451,
0.05366538092494011,
0.7378790974617004,
0.2876497805118561,
0.5650610327720642,
0.7411230206489563,
-0.6850847601890564,
-0.3865356743335724,
-0.20734576880931854,
-0.9828648567199707,
-0.31987932324409485,
-0.2981061637401581,
0.45456191897392273,
0.37041395902633667,
1.0523176193237305,
-0.9233940243721008,
0.31368497014045715,
0.4184345602989197,
-0.48253196477890015,
0.7853323221206665,
-0.12344937026500702,
0.37201377749443054,
-0.7432721257209778,
0.2853584289550781,
-0.26945939660072327,
-0.10756181925535202,
-0.9415737390518188,
0.27284109592437744,
-0.16552016139030457,
0.2030969262123108,
-0.5325207114219666,
0.7338422536849976,
-0.19776701927185059,
0.06628396362066269,
-0.44662022590637207,
-0.07120455056428909,
-0.20375224947929382,
0.2455357164144516,
0.41636547446250916,
0.7695962190628052,
0.3450234830379486,
-0.3800739347934723,
0.23743586242198944,
0.08606578409671783,
-0.3132295310497284,
0.7750257253646851,
-0.8198130130767822,
0.059463854879140854,
-0.20536461472511292,
0.2960500419139862,
-1.2002090215682983,
0.21612539887428284,
0.3620724081993103,
-0.35006579756736755,
-0.08210858702659607,
0.025947848334908485,
-0.582566499710083,
-0.4184230864048004,
-0.34871307015419006,
0.6071692705154419,
0.6942455768585205,
-0.30878081917762756,
0.28275999426841736,
-0.22518791258335114,
-0.21978512406349182,
-0.4500076174736023,
-0.8103421330451965,
0.1100754365324974,
-0.14378678798675537,
0.009666524827480316,
0.12688598036766052,
-0.3938766419887543,
-0.6705742478370667,
0.0915638655424118,
-0.365876704454422,
0.04023153334856033,
0.1271498203277588,
0.21775436401367188,
0.30259832739830017,
-0.5486624240875244,
0.015688342973589897,
-0.12158782035112381,
0.04784832522273064,
0.37002548575401306,
-0.17910639941692352,
0.44209450483322144,
0.3351888358592987,
-0.6208959817886353,
0.08886969834566116,
0.3837786018848419,
0.6015404462814331,
0.21785934269428253,
0.7714227437973022,
0.03305044025182724,
-0.30994558334350586,
0.04946094751358032,
-0.5254339575767517,
-0.28668537735939026,
-0.4163550138473511,
0.41057199239730835,
-0.4904805123806,
-0.6775010824203491,
0.7004954218864441,
0.18792150914669037,
0.11571735888719559,
0.5635568499565125,
0.5021719932556152,
-0.1895180493593216,
0.772827684879303,
0.2403627634048462,
0.4646356701850891,
0.3487270176410675,
-0.07982008904218674,
0.21221283078193665,
-0.6913142204284668,
0.0976267158985138,
-0.5347915887832642,
-0.0064425040036439896,
-0.4478984475135803,
-0.1400981992483139,
-0.13927915692329407,
-0.2950966954231262,
-0.5229318141937256,
0.30941084027290344,
-0.001637256471440196,
0.42475563287734985,
0.38893699645996094,
0.18301062285900116,
0.26333367824554443,
-0.17030106484889984,
-0.1995093822479248,
0.06225725635886192,
-0.7543051242828369,
-0.4914777874946594,
1.285446047782898,
0.16598786413669586,
0.39680036902427673,
-0.0016204874264076352,
0.32669591903686523,
0.07100207358598709,
0.6054197549819946,
-0.4972039759159088,
0.6939042806625366,
-0.3305552005767822,
-1.0297945737838745,
-0.29529494047164917,
-0.15164814889431,
-1.0901093482971191,
0.42154741287231445,
-0.5004625916481018,
-0.9158481359481812,
0.21971359848976135,
0.27755919098854065,
-0.1773231476545334,
0.5034081935882568,
-0.6745011806488037,
1.030150294303894,
0.1955619752407074,
-0.21265457570552826,
-0.2964397072792053,
-0.4259510934352875,
0.3465479016304016,
-0.237457275390625,
0.2520703077316284,
0.2996903657913208,
0.16258102655410767,
0.8265745043754578,
-0.49223563075065613,
0.9630752205848694,
0.03012922778725624,
-0.3175625205039978,
0.4719817042350769,
0.33142200112342834,
0.3936481773853302,
-0.32857707142829895,
0.0032133152708411217,
0.04770611599087715,
0.04435151442885399,
-0.5307608842849731,
-0.8282874822616577,
0.5673544406890869,
-0.433409720659256,
-0.8121924996376038,
-0.6580023169517517,
-0.7700214982032776,
-0.11769799888134003,
0.35333046317100525,
0.19791042804718018,
0.7185189723968506,
-0.557017982006073,
0.37132468819618225,
0.711294949054718,
0.027776235714554787,
0.6337951421737671,
0.7233752608299255,
-0.018195921555161476,
0.21177376806735992,
0.6494273543357849,
0.3992933928966522,
0.6080688238143921,
0.6072806119918823,
-0.06594125926494598,
-0.10282759368419647,
-0.8174952864646912,
-0.430515319108963,
-0.027185890823602676,
-0.5883938074111938,
0.2617938816547394,
-0.4797001779079437,
-0.029416566714644432,
-0.3679068088531494,
-0.1753411591053009,
-0.2716848850250244,
-0.43186336755752563,
0.004439400974661112,
0.022209258750081062,
-0.17177565395832062,
0.7804446816444397,
0.0882606953382492,
0.2447502315044403,
-0.7329504489898682,
0.6079390645027161,
0.5840291976928711,
0.15287373960018158,
0.2979968190193176,
-0.7805526256561279,
-0.3284074366092682,
0.2581753432750702,
-0.1822999268770218,
-0.74460768699646,
-0.08351913094520569,
-0.12297319620847702,
0.6716668605804443,
0.37215787172317505,
0.10131809115409851,
0.4342481791973114,
-0.9663136005401611,
0.9358688592910767,
0.23523162305355072,
-0.7974483370780945,
0.04727746546268463,
-0.5999641418457031,
0.6388707756996155,
0.28197598457336426,
0.5733620524406433,
-0.5250153541564941,
-0.5450012683868408,
-0.9914815425872803,
-0.5605967044830322,
0.4178957939147949,
0.048285748809576035,
0.31394824385643005,
-0.23442262411117554,
0.1907702535390854,
0.3167712688446045,
0.4471578299999237,
-0.8730337619781494,
-0.1447066366672516,
-0.185984268784523,
-0.22704222798347473,
-0.2548089027404785,
-0.45839381217956543,
-0.041689444333314896,
0.05683864280581474,
0.34250685572624207,
-0.11123451590538025,
0.24620844423770905,
0.38181114196777344,
-0.10417532175779343,
-0.42321357131004333,
0.4337776303291321,
0.6213710904121399,
0.8265485167503357,
-0.15150251984596252,
0.5962958335876465,
0.2846694886684418,
-0.5026262402534485,
0.45616042613983154,
0.08051230758428574,
-0.5424512028694153,
0.024538397789001465,
0.8902047872543335,
0.4332162141799927,
0.3781067728996277,
-0.83244389295578,
0.4249321222305298,
0.42938232421875,
-0.5125913023948669,
-0.3459678590297699,
-0.047639261931180954,
-0.01480494998395443,
0.26149600744247437,
0.39157983660697937,
0.08116528391838074,
0.1279604136943817,
-1.2356784343719482,
0.18161047995090485,
0.675600528717041,
-0.31363892555236816,
-0.5258020162582397,
0.6245975494384766,
-0.07036375254392624,
-0.38812732696533203,
0.563157320022583,
-0.1198694258928299,
-0.3909725844860077,
0.7577028870582581,
0.8481355905532837,
0.8058253526687622,
-0.4225783348083496,
0.13400009274482727,
0.22761234641075134,
0.4082585573196411,
-0.2955087423324585,
0.25128501653671265,
0.13662226498126984,
-0.8718885779380798,
-0.469631165266037,
-0.15137076377868652,
-0.4458446502685547,
0.4130134880542755,
-0.29183799028396606,
-0.11072216928005219,
-0.38312283158302307,
0.2938433885574341,
0.10621460527181625,
-0.49501967430114746,
-0.3283401429653168,
0.4562140703201294,
0.048853181302547455,
0.7536054849624634,
-1.3383744955062866,
0.7948630452156067,
0.8177363276481628,
-0.42696717381477356,
-0.38496285676956177,
0.21702228486537933,
-0.00753626087680459,
-0.5966836810112,
0.9491732716560364,
0.13114161789417267,
-0.20472097396850586,
-0.42797186970710754,
-0.5393069982528687,
-0.714357852935791,
0.5889797806739807,
0.48222458362579346,
-0.479503333568573,
-0.1803852617740631,
0.07221730053424835,
0.8176071643829346,
-0.622615396976471,
0.605356752872467,
0.2160569578409195,
0.2840174734592438,
0.23899517953395844,
-1.1164332628250122,
0.5127953886985779,
-0.4884057641029358,
-0.1684955656528473,
0.06526675075292587,
-0.19475726783275604,
1.0846842527389526,
-0.2234329730272293,
-0.23256410658359528,
0.4099694788455963,
0.5031476616859436,
0.05443480983376503,
0.5590185523033142,
0.7633412480354309,
0.7789129018783569,
0.0286018755286932,
0.15771709382534027,
1.055267095565796,
0.17284904420375824,
0.0869673639535904,
1.2673938274383545,
-0.4841912090778351,
0.9057871699333191,
0.7818477749824524,
-0.28568416833877563,
0.8760191202163696,
0.41415104269981384,
-0.06020752340555191,
0.38723644614219666,
0.08400420844554901,
-0.15292741358280182,
-0.38822364807128906,
-0.11908088624477386,
-0.21549999713897705,
0.26340383291244507,
0.03797721117734909,
-0.23766590654850006,
-0.36928656697273254,
-0.34098848700523376,
0.026331253349781036,
0.40943026542663574,
-0.2155034840106964,
0.42616504430770874,
0.07464691996574402,
-0.8571463823318481,
0.6003280878067017,
-0.24994513392448425,
0.34765625,
-0.45823341608047485,
-0.45957151055336,
0.07459074258804321,
0.047859225422143936,
0.07319716364145279,
-0.7208911180496216,
0.4255487024784088,
-0.3132346570491791,
-0.0785556361079216,
-0.23153208196163177,
0.3949815332889557,
-0.29196760058403015,
-0.15136221051216125,
-0.029360514134168625,
0.5915010571479797,
0.04560161754488945,
-0.10657568275928497,
-0.4861907362937927,
-0.2850165069103241,
-0.15986615419387817,
-0.30359989404678345,
0.37402576208114624,
0.47060275077819824,
-0.098042793571949,
0.510408878326416,
0.572411060333252,
0.05110340565443039,
-0.27906516194343567,
-0.2571573555469513,
0.673434317111969,
-0.7184355854988098,
-0.5275371074676514,
-1.0584665536880493,
0.19611282646656036,
0.009198023937642574,
-0.22160306572914124,
0.7804369330406189,
0.48391181230545044,
1.0366076231002808,
-0.23738698661327362,
0.6162356734275818,
0.0007913372828625143,
0.544121265411377,
-0.6349799633026123,
0.2986641228199005,
-0.4985025227069855,
0.17091931402683258,
-0.4461427628993988,
-0.9752383232116699,
-0.09476063400506973,
0.5329782366752625,
-0.6148977875709534,
0.22243136167526245,
1.2742700576782227,
0.6993272304534912,
-0.4442591369152069,
-0.0643828883767128,
0.33307045698165894,
0.5902788639068604,
0.0053387852385640144,
0.5303062200546265,
0.7229868769645691,
-0.5862497687339783,
0.40373262763023376,
0.28597286343574524,
-0.014190159738063812,
-0.1385733038187027,
-0.9647089838981628,
-0.9268020391464233,
-0.6643933057785034,
-0.3920765817165375,
-0.30367767810821533,
0.293502539396286,
0.8071044683456421,
0.29850155115127563,
-0.8328849077224731,
-0.0997951477766037,
-0.4303138554096222,
0.1416945457458496,
-0.4056493043899536,
-0.12678754329681396,
0.10638906061649323,
0.02079135924577713,
-0.6535295248031616,
0.15441036224365234,
0.06295575946569443,
0.27831780910491943,
-0.022453581914305687,
0.1106467992067337,
-0.6659016609191895,
0.5079831480979919,
0.5302313566207886,
0.6228445172309875,
-0.8136940002441406,
-0.7361418604850769,
-0.07882236689329147,
-0.014183741062879562,
-0.07428649812936783,
0.9603338837623596,
-0.9102672934532166,
0.18701671063899994,
0.6017314791679382,
0.3384838402271271,
0.4676598608493805,
-0.21745462715625763,
0.6017183065414429,
-0.24989457428455353,
0.3935089111328125,
-0.09479575604200363,
0.5194975137710571,
0.20267637073993683,
-0.02942240983247757,
0.3225344717502594,
0.6191996335983276,
-0.18034295737743378,
-0.952526867389679,
0.7309734225273132,
-0.6692947149276733,
-0.6973305344581604,
1.0152448415756226,
-0.37846606969833374,
-0.15694168210029602,
-0.250933438539505,
-0.019070198759436607,
0.17109230160713196,
-0.022579766809940338,
0.8862465620040894,
0.858616054058075,
-0.018768897280097008,
-0.31464317440986633,
-0.5721287131309509,
0.06300066411495209,
0.8117576837539673,
-0.5372441411018372,
0.0029654307290911674,
0.3356252610683441,
0.21822339296340942,
0.45591434836387634,
0.8360129594802856,
0.011554595082998276,
0.5788068175315857,
0.516453742980957,
-0.11872860044240952,
-0.000567405135370791,
-0.11905012279748917,
-0.21551509201526642,
0.020202897489070892,
0.24858307838439941,
0.002297772094607353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09366v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09366v1
|
Understanding the Role of Temperature in Diverse Question Generation by GPT-4
| 2024-04-14T21:38:50 | 2024-04-14T21:38:50 |
Arav Agarwal, Karthik Mittal, Aidan Doyle, Pragnya Sridhar, Zipiao Wan, Jacob Arthur Doughty, Jaromir Savelka, Majd Sakr
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We conduct a preliminary study of the effect of GPT's temperature parameter
on the diversity of GPT4-generated questions. We find that using higher
temperature values leads to significantly higher diversity, with different
temperatures exposing different types of similarity between generated sets of
questions. We also demonstrate that diverse question generation is especially
difficult for questions targeting lower levels of Bloom's Taxonomy.
|
[
-0.9939723610877991,
-0.814254105091095,
0.5648239850997925,
-0.04168771207332611,
-0.37711870670318604,
0.02986486628651619,
0.13910403847694397,
-0.533790111541748,
-0.02797679603099823,
0.12712310254573822,
-0.40080714225769043,
-0.175856813788414,
-0.3332971930503845,
0.3041381537914276,
-0.15195035934448242,
1.1689276695251465,
-0.0020979458931833506,
-0.37504392862319946,
0.10580658912658691,
-0.0060905939899384975,
-0.17165493965148926,
-0.6500198245048523,
-0.5297581553459167,
-0.21250393986701965,
0.7133811116218567,
0.6135267615318298,
0.649386465549469,
-0.04535583779215813,
0.5598961114883423,
0.2713206708431244,
-0.08587818592786789,
-0.20928971469402313,
-0.5563856959342957,
0.764636218547821,
-0.1196340024471283,
-0.6692131161689758,
0.2679058611392975,
-0.07621777802705765,
0.6129653453826904,
0.37174803018569946,
0.032255444675683975,
0.036529846489429474,
-0.18840712308883667,
0.4057518243789673,
-0.4812958240509033,
-0.2860429883003235,
-1.0961127281188965,
0.018437184393405914,
-0.5640767216682434,
-0.14298531413078308,
0.17129482328891754,
-0.39321449398994446,
0.34733882546424866,
-0.09119119495153427,
0.8359093070030212,
-0.24170202016830444,
0.9323143362998962,
-0.02171464078128338,
-0.8075615763664246,
-0.16390812397003174,
-0.9143149256706238,
0.6656025648117065,
-0.4409884214401245,
0.24514691531658173,
0.12104034423828125,
0.03400561586022377,
0.1755552738904953,
-0.45690906047821045,
-0.6035065650939941,
0.26772162318229675,
0.28574204444885254,
0.4945273697376251,
-0.002468103775754571,
-0.2825233042240143,
0.612242579460144,
0.8298548460006714,
-0.8335786461830139,
-0.4498181939125061,
-0.7022041082382202,
-0.06419996917247772,
0.3199748396873474,
0.475650817155838,
0.41633686423301697,
-0.2183828204870224,
0.053357768803834915,
-0.0849137008190155,
-0.44364455342292786,
0.17135289311408997,
0.8237940073013306,
0.23391513526439667,
0.3535408675670624,
0.07136308401823044,
0.14143821597099304,
0.5022688508033752,
-0.06846651434898376,
0.33583971858024597,
0.17436225712299347,
-0.7624354958534241,
0.14092478156089783,
-0.414030522108078,
0.27145740389823914,
0.5359345078468323,
-0.241974338889122,
-0.030767221003770828,
0.19497697055339813,
-0.20482265949249268,
0.1520489901304245,
-1.0347654819488525,
-0.5556644797325134,
0.13378551602363586,
0.2697543799877167,
-0.02857859618961811,
0.3186875283718109,
-0.9582554697990417,
0.23116067051887512,
0.13902461528778076,
0.08574598282575607,
-0.17650969326496124,
-0.6814067363739014,
-0.07517987489700317,
-0.7578321099281311,
0.6687387228012085,
0.41009336709976196,
-1.2382277250289917,
0.44277527928352356,
0.5437833070755005,
0.6345015168190002,
-0.37063106894493103,
-0.2537703812122345,
0.23044097423553467,
0.3042992949485779,
-0.24419482052326202,
0.8926509618759155,
-0.8492592573165894,
-0.6870253086090088,
-0.48794254660606384,
-0.1764061450958252,
-0.21994070708751678,
-0.5094202756881714,
-0.11066718399524689,
-0.8827608823776245,
0.6662729978561401,
-1.3145617246627808,
-0.19415530562400818,
-0.15076357126235962,
0.6282329559326172,
-0.5365105271339417,
0.9088242053985596,
0.21426616609096527,
-1.0505369901657104,
0.9283201694488525,
-0.6119876503944397,
-0.20386549830436707,
0.3863319456577301,
-0.1662866324186325,
-0.4564732611179352,
-0.19455505907535553,
0.1326615810394287,
-0.0649065151810646,
-0.15414875745773315,
-0.4736226201057434,
-0.21839620172977448,
0.05032810941338539,
0.16349466145038605,
-0.24839875102043152,
0.36460068821907043,
0.4375065267086029,
-0.5104541182518005,
-0.06288813054561615,
-0.1337590515613556,
0.39574310183525085,
-0.005925294011831284,
-0.39558273553848267,
-0.25340983271598816,
-0.4590091109275818,
-0.40043333172798157,
-0.20973394811153412,
0.07070118188858032,
-0.39636197686195374,
0.33153021335601807,
-0.13248299062252045,
0.26984965801239014,
0.4507928490638733,
0.9850497245788574,
0.43153515458106995,
-0.44432953000068665,
1.0098625421524048,
0.2463664412498474,
-0.06000391021370888,
0.0932658463716507,
-1.3754887580871582,
-0.41086745262145996,
0.26656559109687805,
-0.06767189502716064,
0.737153172492981,
-0.40719106793403625,
-0.5351988673210144,
0.6106131672859192,
-0.8626813888549805,
0.041119810193777084,
0.3344353437423706,
0.061858728528022766,
0.43593868613243103,
0.23656365275382996,
-0.14593937993049622,
-0.3174041509628296,
-0.4621879756450653,
-0.2658328115940094,
-0.1231740191578865,
0.05474419519305229,
0.6444514989852905,
0.7255310416221619,
-0.06151401624083519,
0.9804738759994507,
-0.7622843384742737,
0.6572628021240234,
-0.1578807234764099,
0.36200401186943054,
0.5305168032646179,
0.49070852994918823,
0.8970553874969482,
-1.0668994188308716,
-0.7188220024108887,
-0.07664147764444351,
-0.45251163840293884,
0.15959715843200684,
0.2077024281024933,
-0.3842898905277252,
-0.037352055311203,
0.047494079917669296,
-1.090893030166626,
0.1777181476354599,
0.1937209516763687,
-0.2996925413608551,
0.4636971950531006,
-0.1224595233798027,
0.7022753953933716,
-1.2222089767456055,
-0.3728102445602417,
-0.2324647307395935,
0.2528302073478699,
-0.8465906381607056,
0.2425675392150879,
-0.15305088460445404,
-0.3709607422351837,
-0.3661574125289917,
0.18174152076244354,
-0.4836407005786896,
-0.008032253943383694,
-0.00012489203072618693,
-0.2837505042552948,
0.15697021782398224,
-0.10326194763183594,
-0.3624459207057953,
0.7874510884284973,
0.7107818126678467,
-0.773790717124939,
0.7366295456886292,
0.21508274972438812,
0.05363713949918747,
0.18841508030891418,
-0.6416992545127869,
0.44648030400276184,
-0.05084807053208351,
-0.05513496324419975,
-1.0582971572875977,
-0.5027520060539246,
-0.025273092091083527,
-0.39798426628112793,
0.07417144626379013,
-0.17047841846942902,
-0.48714756965637207,
-0.6659612059593201,
-0.15692239999771118,
0.8944687843322754,
0.7149133086204529,
-0.21933628618717194,
0.10801684111356735,
-0.11549640446901321,
-0.4339360296726227,
-0.004411065950989723,
-0.5947245359420776,
-0.22992587089538574,
-0.7411696910858154,
-0.8428338170051575,
0.2577780783176422,
-0.5179452896118164,
-0.5640286207199097,
-0.3163355886936188,
-0.07137168943881989,
0.0029489535372704268,
0.02658371441066265,
-0.15665848553180695,
-0.29830068349838257,
-0.5896105766296387,
0.1620875746011734,
0.21579304337501526,
0.40901875495910645,
0.22491073608398438,
-0.25631317496299744,
0.694958508014679,
-0.4368378818035126,
-0.4381863474845886,
0.1330382525920868,
0.9605129361152649,
0.3975493907928467,
-0.08370004594326019,
0.5363563895225525,
0.6787649989128113,
-0.17895951867103577,
-0.03347118943929672,
-0.433034211397171,
-0.5380321741104126,
-0.5352454781532288,
0.038903214037418365,
-0.634580135345459,
-0.9091943502426147,
1.1401113271713257,
0.5303704142570496,
0.08293277025222778,
0.671735405921936,
0.9383711218833923,
0.14795097708702087,
0.9155969023704529,
0.1500108540058136,
0.3620416522026062,
0.34970924258232117,
-0.011018987745046616,
-0.18246789276599884,
-0.24265731871128082,
-0.2723241448402405,
-0.5413796305656433,
-0.38841935992240906,
-0.9045485854148865,
-0.37965384125709534,
0.4591841697692871,
-0.01142028160393238,
-0.5374670028686523,
-0.06917920708656311,
-0.5671688318252563,
0.713006854057312,
0.9553503394126892,
0.22349919378757477,
-0.04198765009641647,
-0.33989813923835754,
0.15961836278438568,
-0.17900030314922333,
-0.5446861386299133,
-0.0696670189499855,
1.0421510934829712,
0.14800727367401123,
0.698384702205658,
0.5403913855552673,
1.264267086982727,
-0.31084302067756653,
0.033290449529886246,
-0.1352539360523224,
0.22131766378879547,
0.2515612542629242,
-1.3074768781661987,
-0.6457308530807495,
-0.37802621722221375,
-0.9641496539115906,
0.38161003589630127,
0.21363331377506256,
-0.4984690845012665,
-0.10911118984222412,
0.05524657666683197,
-0.48844218254089355,
0.5236614942550659,
-0.9189700484275818,
0.8237610459327698,
-0.19538429379463196,
-0.3186075687408447,
0.3828240633010864,
-0.6756414771080017,
0.4042895436286926,
-0.10977399349212646,
-0.08771582692861557,
-0.11593491584062576,
0.1768711358308792,
0.9118525981903076,
-0.42292359471321106,
0.6121521592140198,
-0.2664813697338104,
-0.19112136960029602,
0.6633166074752808,
0.14397378265857697,
0.06016485393047333,
0.6476718187332153,
-0.24622763693332672,
-0.19625061750411987,
0.02801244519650936,
-0.7747111916542053,
-0.31927788257598877,
0.7347998023033142,
-1.0024399757385254,
-1.211137056350708,
-0.5330814123153687,
-0.8858422040939331,
-0.4136606454849243,
0.14919522404670715,
0.8486011028289795,
0.02952667884528637,
0.17791800200939178,
0.011951092630624771,
0.8266422152519226,
-0.20989036560058594,
0.24840505421161652,
0.1552690714597702,
-0.08873218297958374,
-0.07393448799848557,
0.6125016212463379,
0.27704674005508423,
0.6604792475700378,
-0.020277706906199455,
0.4948961138725281,
0.05412771552801132,
-0.6491621136665344,
-0.11028435826301575,
-0.030651362612843513,
-0.8297043442726135,
-0.1703682243824005,
-0.6662059426307678,
-0.16288205981254578,
-0.7482139468193054,
-0.15378516912460327,
0.08309965580701828,
-0.1537221372127533,
-0.693132758140564,
-0.5421400666236877,
0.9256200194358826,
0.7862935066223145,
-0.16964393854141235,
0.30498576164245605,
-0.7788835167884827,
0.26052889227867126,
0.9825592041015625,
0.047483623027801514,
-0.43752485513687134,
-0.48298344016075134,
0.29090145230293274,
-0.2031446248292923,
-0.7336138486862183,
-1.3453723192214966,
0.23254604637622833,
0.32328230142593384,
0.753157377243042,
0.5201136469841003,
0.04729277268052101,
0.6149435043334961,
-0.18424826860427856,
1.343582272529602,
0.12456174939870834,
-0.8666000366210938,
0.931706428527832,
-0.7946789264678955,
0.9645076394081116,
0.4998445510864258,
0.6019782423973083,
-0.030768059194087982,
-0.9945600628852844,
-0.9575960636138916,
-0.9140835404396057,
0.16135457158088684,
0.3079214096069336,
0.6655654907226562,
-0.21335963904857635,
0.6544346213340759,
0.6205848455429077,
-0.12098940461874008,
-0.6597285270690918,
-0.2010878473520279,
-0.664901852607727,
0.49883782863616943,
0.04970501363277435,
-0.31068241596221924,
-0.2359950989484787,
-0.44560399651527405,
0.024224605411291122,
0.1043270155787468,
0.3189467489719391,
0.09736936539411545,
0.4602084457874298,
-0.3126501142978668,
0.5539909601211548,
0.8892181515693665,
0.7051247358322144,
-0.5382169485092163,
0.10421209037303925,
0.7129845023155212,
-0.5043531656265259,
-0.3143698275089264,
-0.251608282327652,
-0.16215844452381134,
0.06310127675533295,
0.19040612876415253,
0.4949242174625397,
-0.3700282871723175,
0.389629602432251,
-0.038713302463293076,
-0.2849336564540863,
-0.6729361414909363,
0.004621594212949276,
0.5621775388717651,
0.1079876571893692,
0.19039861857891083,
0.511196494102478,
0.12153511494398117,
0.13133247196674347,
-1.0316272974014282,
0.7024182081222534,
0.5944609642028809,
-0.0800599604845047,
-0.6281594634056091,
0.7457795739173889,
0.1688918173313141,
0.05725163221359253,
0.8256151080131531,
-0.1832755208015442,
-0.8942652940750122,
0.8678289651870728,
0.8497315049171448,
0.2589302062988281,
-0.5326977968215942,
0.14097045361995697,
0.6258580684661865,
0.39519551396369934,
0.25525301694869995,
1.2377151250839233,
-0.13178953528404236,
-0.7653552889823914,
0.19095121324062347,
-0.3124774098396301,
-0.8221650123596191,
-0.07192479819059372,
-0.7312704920768738,
-0.23649461567401886,
-0.6663432121276855,
-0.5959182381629944,
-0.2646546959877014,
-0.24620021879673004,
-0.8341957330703735,
0.49223676323890686,
0.02275163307785988,
0.48891469836235046,
-0.8931463956832886,
0.3908006548881531,
0.41532835364341736,
-0.6906614899635315,
-1.0394432544708252,
0.3564298152923584,
-0.27581727504730225,
-0.5019597411155701,
0.7741751074790955,
-0.0795854926109314,
0.18967050313949585,
-0.10363650321960449,
-0.6193811893463135,
-0.9303558468818665,
1.263262391090393,
0.28454598784446716,
0.01441403292119503,
-0.17583297193050385,
0.30633488297462463,
0.6071346998214722,
-0.042384807020425797,
0.31650376319885254,
0.6546857953071594,
0.6548854112625122,
0.7375510334968567,
-0.7663574814796448,
0.06826852262020111,
-0.4495822489261627,
-0.26829224824905396,
0.3646872937679291,
-0.47001752257347107,
1.529294729232788,
-0.5435192584991455,
-0.01687511056661606,
-0.21290305256843567,
0.611991822719574,
0.13281215727329254,
0.4432736039161682,
0.1920224279165268,
0.45285725593566895,
0.9099713563919067,
-0.4792427122592926,
1.1099953651428223,
-0.06449240446090698,
0.30720168352127075,
0.4780336320400238,
-0.2631947100162506,
0.396803081035614,
0.5365667939186096,
-0.35235098004341125,
0.49361512064933777,
1.0436733961105347,
-0.2814495861530304,
0.5722640752792358,
0.49850019812583923,
-0.55912184715271,
-0.2318170964717865,
0.38107648491859436,
-1.2488501071929932,
0.19379132986068726,
0.4036269187927246,
0.11252649873495102,
-0.21676410734653473,
-0.10043272376060486,
-0.1683589667081833,
-0.3618989884853363,
-0.2766978442668915,
0.8079683780670166,
0.026105938479304314,
-0.7140639424324036,
0.25245529413223267,
-0.499725878238678,
0.6158499717712402,
-0.5399091243743896,
0.2726844847202301,
-0.6109199523925781,
-0.2568768858909607,
-0.28480929136276245,
-1.0367034673690796,
0.4678639769554138,
-0.14101584255695343,
-0.4055148661136627,
-0.17008870840072632,
0.49131354689598083,
-0.2323647439479828,
-0.3356393575668335,
-0.17546702921390533,
0.44747525453567505,
0.2873454988002777,
-0.21202035248279572,
-0.6373426914215088,
-0.1073325127363205,
-0.0450536385178566,
-0.5390543341636658,
0.22127778828144073,
0.6734486818313599,
0.1804058849811554,
0.26172196865081787,
0.47617414593696594,
-0.18714821338653564,
0.41783326864242554,
0.05240920931100845,
0.791221559047699,
-0.876344621181488,
-0.5511044263839722,
-0.839428722858429,
0.32210689783096313,
-0.016770442947745323,
-0.6112356185913086,
0.9641884565353394,
0.5807362198829651,
0.568066418170929,
-0.2098676711320877,
0.8360617756843567,
0.054233796894550323,
0.5127629637718201,
-0.41135475039482117,
0.5159135460853577,
-0.4046281576156616,
0.12048670649528503,
-0.7180619835853577,
-1.1876802444458008,
-0.2615225911140442,
0.05036560073494911,
-0.7430719137191772,
0.624314546585083,
0.8503288626670837,
0.7092109322547913,
-0.05723276734352112,
0.2820478677749634,
0.2896297574043274,
-0.16649171710014343,
0.7580793499946594,
0.46801286935806274,
0.922100841999054,
-0.10131599009037018,
0.7360023260116577,
-0.24445803463459015,
-0.17911642789840698,
0.33300164341926575,
-0.56529301404953,
-0.8546255826950073,
-0.7007335424423218,
-0.2514970004558563,
-0.28181639313697815,
-0.13086779415607452,
0.3678215742111206,
0.6080769300460815,
-1.017043948173523,
0.10793458670377731,
-0.13175426423549652,
-0.008520168252289295,
0.31813499331474304,
-0.2970319986343384,
0.020529188215732574,
-0.30811285972595215,
-0.5985218286514282,
-0.023831577971577644,
0.034670788794755936,
0.4581250548362732,
-0.0064051044173538685,
0.1370895653963089,
0.004141655750572681,
0.24150048196315765,
0.2905604839324951,
0.3637464642524719,
-0.3713985085487366,
-0.30769431591033936,
-0.08893181383609772,
0.04953441396355629,
0.15976974368095398,
0.6792019605636597,
-0.19158786535263062,
0.031238975003361702,
0.8689345717430115,
0.3977176249027252,
0.8141295909881592,
0.16835473477840424,
0.7459822297096252,
-0.7325851917266846,
-0.1869649738073349,
0.39693471789360046,
0.22683750092983246,
0.2670516073703766,
-0.5906457304954529,
0.02523752860724926,
0.46484315395355225,
-0.7363666296005249,
-0.5415493249893188,
0.844454824924469,
-0.8735877871513367,
-0.18654347956180573,
1.360968828201294,
0.12476278841495514,
0.1766243427991867,
-0.19133424758911133,
-0.2499813288450241,
-0.10420212149620056,
-0.4689321517944336,
0.9017056226730347,
0.8550901412963867,
-0.7004489898681641,
-0.5418727397918701,
-0.6001480221748352,
0.4721764326095581,
0.4316008985042572,
-1.0071595907211304,
-0.25012147426605225,
0.16328805685043335,
0.6720021963119507,
0.20371535420417786,
0.48876526951789856,
0.0970756858587265,
0.4428802728652954,
0.17338939011096954,
-0.42860153317451477,
0.386595219373703,
0.3875734210014343,
0.40358632802963257,
0.7553954720497131,
0.25180524587631226,
0.08589962124824524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09356v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09356v1
|
LLeMpower: Understanding Disparities in the Control and Access of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-14T20:49:53 | 2024-04-14T20:49:53 |
Vishwas Sathish, Hannah Lin, Aditya K Kamath, Anish Nyayachavadi
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.ET, K.4.0; K.7.4
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are a powerful technology that augment human
skill to create new opportunities, akin to the development of steam engines and
the internet. However, LLMs come with a high cost. They require significant
computing resources and energy to train and serve. Inequity in their control
and access has led to concentration of ownership and power to a small
collection of corporations. In our study, we collect training and inference
requirements for various LLMs. We then analyze the economic strengths of
nations and organizations in the context of developing and serving these
models. Additionally, we also look at whether individuals around the world can
access and use this emerging technology. We compare and contrast these groups
to show that these technologies are monopolized by a surprisingly few entities.
We conclude with a qualitative study on the ethical implications of our
findings and discuss future directions towards equity in LLM access.
|
[
-0.29247865080833435,
-0.3719676733016968,
0.7060645222663879,
0.07579075545072556,
0.028929900377988815,
0.47653108835220337,
-0.11276035010814667,
-0.7239478826522827,
-0.054213814437389374,
0.6335740089416504,
-0.3648495376110077,
-0.07254278659820557,
-1.0711735486984253,
0.04377724230289459,
-0.297656774520874,
0.4732237756252289,
-0.028941383585333824,
0.1407204121351242,
-0.25437960028648376,
-0.09507176280021667,
-0.23556284606456757,
-0.7312797904014587,
-0.2925741374492645,
-0.5380859971046448,
0.31099987030029297,
0.5250207185745239,
0.9814586639404297,
0.6407419443130493,
0.6060020327568054,
0.42206841707229614,
-0.16765347123146057,
-0.29918214678764343,
-0.6097500920295715,
-0.10578658431768417,
-0.2722418010234833,
-0.6395137906074524,
-0.4382579028606415,
0.11437908560037613,
0.7796887159347534,
0.9885144233703613,
-0.21612147986888885,
0.28019821643829346,
0.3137921392917633,
0.7090341448783875,
-0.5113276839256287,
0.07064475119113922,
-0.8322880268096924,
0.034390468150377274,
-0.2271151840686798,
0.22400113940238953,
-0.0945550799369812,
-0.3341308534145355,
-0.0535893514752388,
-0.4881143867969513,
0.07231485098600388,
0.4434855878353119,
0.6133230924606323,
0.4241710603237152,
-0.5548544526100159,
-0.41991469264030457,
-0.6616845726966858,
1.2203792333602905,
-0.5845266580581665,
0.24798491597175598,
0.36943039298057556,
0.20157550275325775,
-0.13719315826892853,
-0.7824239134788513,
-0.34109753370285034,
-0.072408027946949,
-0.02180001325905323,
0.01868322305381298,
-0.4564861059188843,
0.19626310467720032,
0.406492680311203,
0.5301281213760376,
-0.08668605983257294,
0.6691696047782898,
-0.6139756441116333,
0.013216787949204445,
0.7196033596992493,
0.12020080536603928,
0.4459821879863739,
-0.0802440419793129,
-0.21917349100112915,
0.2171924114227295,
-0.7180978059768677,
-0.1326838731765747,
0.7219046354293823,
0.3089039921760559,
-0.23207107186317444,
0.9010339379310608,
0.2022428661584854,
0.49471473693847656,
-0.3914085328578949,
-0.3178795278072357,
-0.062349483370780945,
-0.14831745624542236,
-0.5133424401283264,
0.3379206359386444,
0.47576045989990234,
0.08108080923557281,
0.4150727689266205,
-0.07317304611206055,
-0.027157634496688843,
-0.40530890226364136,
0.1802227646112442,
-0.7237992882728577,
0.4742835760116577,
0.3009398281574249,
-0.7820174098014832,
0.09370990842580795,
0.07557975500822067,
-0.5963321924209595,
-0.7306791543960571,
-0.5587128400802612,
0.21755675971508026,
0.08790621161460876,
-0.5190790891647339,
0.14729298651218414,
-0.3800535798072815,
0.21807698905467987,
0.11196877062320709,
-1.174430012702942,
0.48941856622695923,
0.7206553816795349,
1.0049792528152466,
0.03788704797625542,
-0.23785217106342316,
0.08289095014333725,
0.00674545718356967,
-0.07885086536407471,
0.18207594752311707,
-0.37315356731414795,
-0.7455307245254517,
0.15755170583724976,
-0.0006226421101018786,
0.12504495680332184,
-0.810046374797821,
-0.017520109191536903,
-0.5997823476791382,
-0.14820019900798798,
-0.3281022310256958,
-0.6213182806968689,
0.13857631385326385,
-0.27137747406959534,
-0.8113515973091125,
0.5257900953292847,
0.0074576823972165585,
-0.774573028087616,
0.3065258860588074,
-0.7433668971061707,
-0.3582015931606293,
0.1766889989376068,
-0.312734991312027,
-0.16796588897705078,
0.3992283046245575,
-0.21858200430870056,
0.3603942096233368,
-0.614136278629303,
0.28533828258514404,
-0.4670976400375366,
-0.1791893094778061,
0.22482365369796753,
-0.36553955078125,
1.1748875379562378,
0.37378010153770447,
-0.3917308747768402,
-0.16770365834236145,
-0.7631456255912781,
-0.19272692501544952,
0.21354687213897705,
-0.17888277769088745,
-0.5236977934837341,
0.21765750646591187,
-0.3027206063270569,
0.19101975858211517,
0.4610467553138733,
-0.36359429359436035,
0.3120672106742859,
0.07124719023704529,
0.5069977045059204,
0.9637012481689453,
-0.2534467577934265,
0.6953925490379333,
-0.15383318066596985,
0.7271751761436462,
-0.27697205543518066,
0.40156835317611694,
0.3138630986213684,
-0.32223835587501526,
-0.4917643964290619,
-0.49392539262771606,
0.12881594896316528,
0.401865154504776,
-0.5382432341575623,
0.19104313850402832,
-0.14374500513076782,
-0.32105597853660583,
-0.7246221899986267,
0.43779757618904114,
-0.012022034265100956,
0.10095516592264175,
0.09992602467536926,
-0.05408627912402153,
-0.30763116478919983,
-1.2051880359649658,
-0.17681409418582916,
-0.05725778639316559,
-0.2998279631137848,
0.5951536893844604,
0.5186987519264221,
0.06271113455295563,
0.8055762648582458,
-0.18195608258247375,
-0.21870183944702148,
-0.41245853900909424,
-0.20592759549617767,
0.31086573004722595,
0.17695744335651398,
0.11754446476697922,
-0.9544836282730103,
-0.10452872514724731,
0.12134360522031784,
-1.023062825202942,
-0.32451966404914856,
0.06275264918804169,
-0.009008178487420082,
-0.160018190741539,
0.6469572186470032,
-0.24096404016017914,
0.09935455769300461,
0.8103727698326111,
-0.16802985966205597,
0.2972612679004669,
-0.29344800114631653,
0.054046954959630966,
-1.0097295045852661,
0.012453840114176273,
-0.004803442396223545,
-0.09491659700870514,
-0.329043984413147,
-0.061152514070272446,
-0.19407881796360016,
-0.12616926431655884,
-0.5566163659095764,
0.38200998306274414,
-0.8578705787658691,
-0.47627031803131104,
-0.4012147784233093,
0.29168370366096497,
-0.2090812772512436,
-0.10554143786430359,
-0.16866859793663025,
0.8037799596786499,
0.5854380130767822,
-0.5350794792175293,
0.2955036461353302,
0.06985935568809509,
-0.5351423621177673,
0.27860766649246216,
-0.7684472799301147,
-0.10974789410829544,
0.03454263135790825,
-0.12701599299907684,
-0.48255664110183716,
-0.4204014539718628,
-0.4114333987236023,
-0.002638420322909951,
0.12837126851081848,
-0.07367414236068726,
-0.5254318118095398,
-0.25226283073425293,
-0.0018927811179310083,
0.2914416491985321,
0.7000271677970886,
-0.4035661816596985,
0.5710740685462952,
0.9777141213417053,
-0.3807153105735779,
-0.7707990407943726,
-0.9477528929710388,
0.13802315294742584,
-0.2654590606689453,
-0.5879181027412415,
0.18808519840240479,
0.13367056846618652,
-0.9902501702308655,
0.022425008937716484,
0.16324414312839508,
-0.03103412501513958,
0.32651790976524353,
0.6128940582275391,
-0.05307848006486893,
-0.05939328297972679,
0.24853776395320892,
0.07861266285181046,
0.08974055200815201,
0.11131447553634644,
-0.25255635380744934,
0.4338909983634949,
-0.057270389050245285,
-0.6957600712776184,
-0.2044907957315445,
0.45987361669540405,
0.7442819476127625,
-0.04369894042611122,
0.815304160118103,
-0.057456545531749725,
-0.40594834089279175,
-0.22532515227794647,
-0.5200972557067871,
-0.008410110138356686,
-0.5280765295028687,
0.46683773398399353,
0.09475508332252502,
-1.2086941003799438,
0.44765618443489075,
-0.26189345121383667,
0.2314867526292801,
0.3553471267223358,
0.8131268620491028,
0.22052256762981415,
0.7534072995185852,
1.1456422805786133,
-0.34328123927116394,
0.46414920687675476,
-0.1378086656332016,
0.3145212233066559,
-0.5528461933135986,
-0.3431253135204315,
-0.6433841586112976,
-0.4507368803024292,
-0.8684354424476624,
-0.23310397565364838,
0.2756413221359253,
0.20324471592903137,
-0.43172284960746765,
0.004093807656317949,
-0.2299344688653946,
0.7041797041893005,
0.7709585428237915,
-0.14893066883087158,
0.6741902828216553,
0.06659579277038574,
-0.05567386373877525,
-0.11567378044128418,
-0.9041603207588196,
-0.8177319765090942,
0.9514253735542297,
0.6063919067382812,
1.0164622068405151,
0.31175416707992554,
0.5004586577415466,
0.4435082972049713,
0.30524247884750366,
-0.8605719804763794,
0.4076429605484009,
-0.24898864328861237,
-0.782841682434082,
-0.31875672936439514,
-0.4587844908237457,
-0.9662901759147644,
0.08641962707042694,
-0.1158108189702034,
-0.8125632405281067,
0.2835133969783783,
0.04984348267316818,
-0.11718522012233734,
0.7602870464324951,
-0.890949547290802,
0.5674668550491333,
-0.4534936547279358,
-0.605128824710846,
-0.40873709321022034,
-0.5165172219276428,
0.4719046652317047,
-0.13439564406871796,
0.4875301718711853,
-0.2162255197763443,
-0.09494103491306305,
0.5677775740623474,
-0.34500807523727417,
0.88262540102005,
-0.0508815236389637,
-0.22999164462089539,
0.3296264708042145,
-0.1830821931362152,
-0.0007074313471093774,
-0.13680458068847656,
-0.36846378445625305,
0.5452650189399719,
-0.3909280300140381,
-0.6760416626930237,
-0.14383062720298767,
0.7810506224632263,
-0.9746576547622681,
-0.7740491032600403,
-0.47249725461006165,
-0.5819742679595947,
-0.1277211457490921,
0.2545723021030426,
0.19374531507492065,
0.08630596101284027,
-0.2543717920780182,
0.3761357367038727,
0.6046268343925476,
-0.36979031562805176,
0.5623165965080261,
0.30748477578163147,
-0.3163202702999115,
-0.0222866740077734,
0.5350156426429749,
0.5247325897216797,
0.6472365856170654,
0.11538717150688171,
0.08452646434307098,
-0.27914634346961975,
-0.4395321011543274,
-0.08324810862541199,
0.3209488093852997,
-0.5872337222099304,
0.1420641541481018,
-0.34088847041130066,
-0.21564066410064697,
-0.27751073241233826,
-0.1779705286026001,
-0.2425345629453659,
-0.17856428027153015,
-0.32416194677352905,
-0.16499409079551697,
0.20073789358139038,
1.2840940952301025,
-0.21225158870220184,
0.6189685463905334,
-0.4590648114681244,
0.1560831367969513,
0.4904710352420807,
0.32119277119636536,
0.044425830245018005,
-0.36302506923675537,
-0.3443116545677185,
-0.23894445598125458,
-0.39906904101371765,
-0.6825563311576843,
0.25980228185653687,
-0.21402940154075623,
0.5872014760971069,
0.20614966750144958,
-0.06458071619272232,
0.3536747992038727,
-0.6471816897392273,
0.8505856394767761,
0.41485971212387085,
-1.1335365772247314,
0.062286876142024994,
0.03604183346033096,
0.17456355690956116,
0.21944960951805115,
0.7205963730812073,
-0.39446863532066345,
-0.4747278392314911,
-0.8039962649345398,
-0.9603508710861206,
0.5056887269020081,
0.15499411523342133,
0.3659403920173645,
0.43013760447502136,
0.2126014679670334,
-0.05186467990279198,
0.49567291140556335,
-0.7477306723594666,
-0.18945249915122986,
-0.04369684308767319,
-0.12348942458629608,
0.07134783267974854,
-0.2627700865268707,
-0.08232052624225616,
0.027937807142734528,
0.6588281989097595,
0.05598963052034378,
0.10584697872400284,
0.10496528446674347,
0.0199802927672863,
-0.07111001014709473,
0.49326691031455994,
0.21635569632053375,
0.9747462272644043,
0.043140947818756104,
0.2987849712371826,
0.24431154131889343,
-0.4530160427093506,
0.3024119436740875,
-0.017370449379086494,
0.30103233456611633,
-0.17563550174236298,
0.36338821053504944,
0.6969641447067261,
-0.19595466554164886,
-0.7297516465187073,
0.36096271872520447,
-0.08399872481822968,
-0.34931448101997375,
-0.23326438665390015,
0.08215361833572388,
0.25357338786125183,
0.6128225922584534,
0.5272577404975891,
-0.33255302906036377,
0.018097711727023125,
-0.5249457955360413,
-0.13172459602355957,
0.647098183631897,
-0.3253624439239502,
0.0492493137717247,
0.6367023587226868,
0.21705389022827148,
-0.35878998041152954,
0.40337681770324707,
0.08513245731592178,
-0.2834966778755188,
0.6769418120384216,
0.3804605007171631,
0.6508385539054871,
-0.07801703363656998,
-0.1593257039785385,
-0.015060695819556713,
0.8714572787284851,
-0.13404589891433716,
-0.009077642112970352,
0.19954736530780792,
-0.6833814978599548,
-0.4024105668067932,
-0.5337800979614258,
-0.7844511270523071,
0.27389368414878845,
-0.6581354141235352,
0.15789012610912323,
-0.5103766918182373,
-0.43069854378700256,
-0.061475902795791626,
0.08756229281425476,
-0.5975342988967896,
-0.16051553189754486,
0.22259947657585144,
0.8255065679550171,
-0.7897661924362183,
0.6734134554862976,
0.18680179119110107,
-0.2271953821182251,
-0.5781143307685852,
-0.058402903378009796,
0.028244469314813614,
-1.055377721786499,
0.746899425983429,
0.05138424038887024,
-0.13753348588943481,
0.01929386705160141,
-0.6842319965362549,
-0.6671794056892395,
1.2661851644515991,
0.6852015852928162,
-1.0311181545257568,
-0.08214782923460007,
0.2655763626098633,
0.2502304017543793,
-0.2223457247018814,
0.051396358758211136,
0.6009134650230408,
0.40393438935279846,
-0.3559319078922272,
-1.0390455722808838,
-0.21199241280555725,
0.18336065113544464,
-0.013410847634077072,
0.1291046142578125,
-0.7973060011863708,
0.8068729043006897,
-0.19856403768062592,
-0.1634824573993683,
-0.2102685421705246,
0.4820779263973236,
0.1991433948278427,
0.39078277349472046,
0.3511882424354553,
0.1071942001581192,
0.938283383846283,
0.04288691282272339,
1.3618724346160889,
-0.39967209100723267,
0.4073563516139984,
0.6890963315963745,
-0.6245867609977722,
0.48710909485816956,
0.5865193009376526,
-0.34199947118759155,
0.22269752621650696,
0.372111439704895,
0.08425328880548477,
0.05099894478917122,
0.6491929292678833,
-0.47848981618881226,
-0.18625402450561523,
-0.47781091928482056,
-0.291243314743042,
0.23072120547294617,
0.28465569019317627,
-0.5330312848091125,
-0.06421542912721634,
0.002098762895911932,
0.0729522779583931,
0.24474160373210907,
-0.6072672009468079,
0.6140900254249573,
0.6491413712501526,
-0.2347647100687027,
0.18581436574459076,
-0.03244221955537796,
0.6095396876335144,
-0.7804059982299805,
0.2048064023256302,
-0.021272489801049232,
0.1592208594083786,
-0.20155185461044312,
-0.7028763890266418,
0.2601655125617981,
0.3960880935192108,
-0.12339729815721512,
-0.2786391079425812,
0.627205491065979,
-0.12473314255475998,
-0.5285176634788513,
0.7028165459632874,
0.8691736459732056,
0.23818674683570862,
0.13565395772457123,
-0.7071405649185181,
0.1794595718383789,
-0.1707039326429367,
-0.08446255326271057,
0.4312831461429596,
0.5019851922988892,
-0.0508076548576355,
0.6923542022705078,
0.29812198877334595,
0.41907984018325806,
0.16815721988677979,
0.16516903042793274,
0.5643335580825806,
-0.5286037921905518,
-0.11269345879554749,
-1.134313941001892,
0.137655571103096,
-0.389379620552063,
-0.2450963258743286,
0.845942497253418,
0.4868861734867096,
0.6762732863426208,
0.1996159553527832,
1.181816816329956,
-0.17552216351032257,
0.20156815648078918,
-0.6475576758384705,
0.8425416350364685,
-0.7483814358711243,
0.24633827805519104,
0.02908221259713173,
-0.8461167812347412,
-0.26987990736961365,
0.4364345669746399,
-0.4838968813419342,
0.07051777094602585,
0.42865416407585144,
0.7106255888938904,
-0.17815914750099182,
-0.08184557408094406,
0.6039251089096069,
0.31728264689445496,
0.27917397022247314,
0.2768512964248657,
0.866276741027832,
0.05527743324637413,
0.1743568331003189,
-0.06593016535043716,
-0.40166282653808594,
-0.09329115599393845,
-1.137585997581482,
-0.5886496305465698,
-0.26754480600357056,
-0.055823393166065216,
-0.267277330160141,
-0.14457924664020538,
1.1292250156402588,
0.6469601392745972,
-0.5973456501960754,
-0.8861368298530579,
0.0027324247639626265,
0.5992496013641357,
0.09898587316274643,
-0.1545555144548416,
0.08754229545593262,
-0.16775625944137573,
-1.0496408939361572,
0.08758927136659622,
0.3548228144645691,
0.23740285634994507,
-0.5555046796798706,
0.04648983106017113,
-0.0025446265935897827,
0.30161651968955994,
0.7098923921585083,
0.2992960512638092,
-0.4923153221607208,
0.19196434319019318,
0.03491273894906044,
-0.12126041948795319,
-0.11009766161441803,
1.217555284500122,
-0.2465094029903412,
0.26235267519950867,
0.17111247777938843,
0.8241446018218994,
0.06914716958999634,
-0.06108006089925766,
0.5020755529403687,
-0.5395169258117676,
0.34797725081443787,
0.17919836938381195,
0.6331391334533691,
0.4802975356578827,
-0.19719791412353516,
0.2225894182920456,
0.1993742734193802,
-0.9340175986289978,
-0.8181225657463074,
0.31208980083465576,
-0.7339410185813904,
-0.46821799874305725,
1.1799169778823853,
0.06954352557659149,
-0.28812775015830994,
-0.18138980865478516,
-0.16592615842819214,
0.23743581771850586,
-0.2763867676258087,
0.7300390005111694,
0.8154317736625671,
-0.12018711119890213,
0.09025637060403824,
-0.9310253858566284,
0.2043100893497467,
0.12683504819869995,
-0.7896180748939514,
0.19756858050823212,
0.5254073143005371,
0.15711025893688202,
0.050676699727773666,
0.5614280700683594,
-0.14440014958381653,
-0.39742904901504517,
-0.028490353375673294,
0.3211336135864258,
0.10235180705785751,
-0.3197733759880066,
-0.6654466986656189,
0.3596023917198181,
0.4221891760826111,
0.04687676206231117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09339v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09339v1
|
Towards Practical Tool Usage for Continually Learning LLMs
| 2024-04-14T19:45:47 | 2024-04-14T19:45:47 |
Jerry Huang, Prasanna Parthasarathi, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh, Sarath Chandar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) show an innate skill for solving language based
tasks. But insights have suggested an inability to adjust for information or
task-solving skills becoming outdated, as their knowledge, stored directly
within their parameters, remains static in time. Tool use helps by offloading
work to systems that the LLM can access through an interface, but LLMs that use
them still must adapt to nonstationary environments for prolonged use, as new
tools can emerge and existing tools can change. Nevertheless, tools require
less specialized knowledge, therefore we hypothesize they are better suited for
continual learning (CL) as they rely less on parametric memory for solving
tasks and instead focus on learning when to apply pre-defined tools. To verify
this, we develop a synthetic benchmark and follow this by aggregating existing
NLP tasks to form a more realistic testing scenario. While we demonstrate
scaling model size is not a solution, regardless of tool usage, continual
learning techniques can enable tool LLMs to both adapt faster while forgetting
less, highlighting their potential as continual learners.
|
[
-0.19836358726024628,
-0.6639840602874756,
0.6214355826377869,
0.45366916060447693,
-0.304100900888443,
0.15811391174793243,
-0.3809608817100525,
-0.3184863328933716,
-0.2873471677303314,
0.40003153681755066,
-0.6420536041259766,
-0.3852463364601135,
-0.38073673844337463,
0.16708336770534515,
-0.34455132484436035,
0.6755421757698059,
-0.05813971161842346,
-0.04348239302635193,
-0.5113989114761353,
-0.5523704886436462,
-0.789135217666626,
-0.5081678628921509,
-1.151277780532837,
-0.5332304239273071,
0.7591776847839355,
0.5146405696868896,
0.41605135798454285,
0.4180777668952942,
0.4278818964958191,
0.1902274191379547,
-0.06263367086648941,
-0.004041985608637333,
-0.5767969489097595,
0.21158595383167267,
-0.28478536009788513,
-0.5619137287139893,
-0.24167276918888092,
-0.0035080760717391968,
0.7394266724586487,
1.0290591716766357,
-0.4790836572647095,
0.38192805647850037,
0.3030714690685272,
0.3509017527103424,
-0.2837520241737366,
-0.04694540798664093,
-1.0105395317077637,
0.06262387335300446,
0.06502198427915573,
-0.0971757024526596,
-0.5444973707199097,
-0.15014302730560303,
0.013677407056093216,
-0.5643104910850525,
0.09297270327806473,
-0.05706566572189331,
0.6630568504333496,
0.5059287548065186,
-0.22943460941314697,
-0.3252939283847809,
-0.7746006846427917,
0.998966634273529,
-0.7950403690338135,
0.5384771227836609,
0.1752372533082962,
0.346158504486084,
-0.22986957430839539,
-0.8505650758743286,
-0.34753286838531494,
-0.5923929214477539,
0.2025192379951477,
-0.07430662214756012,
0.19955456256866455,
-0.23948934674263,
0.5471317172050476,
0.12582950294017792,
-0.40365228056907654,
0.37110933661460876,
-0.27472594380378723,
-0.12474703043699265,
0.4577420949935913,
0.338356614112854,
0.1837327480316162,
0.44341349601745605,
-0.41196173429489136,
0.0314377024769783,
-0.9868300557136536,
-0.045153312385082245,
-0.19667920470237732,
0.04928462579846382,
-0.1206604391336441,
0.32186973094940186,
0.34952107071876526,
0.7776232361793518,
-0.2517701983451843,
-0.5831981897354126,
0.24905036389827728,
-0.22232776880264282,
-0.20507295429706573,
-0.3918631672859192,
0.42633163928985596,
0.3159978985786438,
0.32955580949783325,
-0.4402170777320862,
-0.3340633511543274,
-0.1968812644481659,
0.658393383026123,
-0.5419331789016724,
-0.14026331901550293,
0.0019593811593949795,
-0.17919713258743286,
0.04258311167359352,
-0.5658982992172241,
-0.44076666235923767,
-0.18867884576320648,
-0.5494183301925659,
0.4336670935153961,
-0.3962812125682831,
-0.25739386677742004,
0.04764643684029579,
-0.15362057089805603,
0.2191413789987564,
0.48813295364379883,
-0.5239404439926147,
0.36761894822120667,
0.5037468671798706,
1.3813751935958862,
-0.43257343769073486,
-0.3407939076423645,
-0.6089524626731873,
0.0561949759721756,
-0.5928782224655151,
0.5620436668395996,
-0.18241524696350098,
-0.6085785031318665,
-0.08781339973211288,
0.2083745002746582,
-0.040179647505283356,
-0.9358341693878174,
0.16409868001937866,
-0.37291088700294495,
-0.18801753222942352,
-0.3327789902687073,
-0.47543391585350037,
-0.04255915805697441,
0.4295852482318878,
-0.5186402201652527,
1.3307565450668335,
0.35941562056541443,
-0.2996308505535126,
0.5711533427238464,
-0.4699144959449768,
-0.19302058219909668,
0.2456943839788437,
0.10200147330760956,
-0.5565910935401917,
0.20320910215377808,
-0.3197970688343048,
0.47695696353912354,
-0.11153154075145721,
0.4283306300640106,
-0.5211039185523987,
-0.2946610450744629,
0.10711058974266052,
-0.2934240698814392,
0.5077645778656006,
-0.002216632943600416,
-0.2782622277736664,
0.01463274098932743,
-0.5683130025863647,
-0.14801986515522003,
0.18890918791294098,
-0.37594813108444214,
-0.1940213143825531,
0.203544482588768,
-0.058103933930397034,
0.340536504983902,
0.36317577958106995,
-0.6639204025268555,
0.14086683094501495,
-0.39565426111221313,
0.3427746891975403,
0.7937225699424744,
0.15395347774028778,
0.20000427961349487,
-0.6404080390930176,
0.5677831768989563,
-0.13430365920066833,
0.021157460287213326,
0.10338976234197617,
-0.14969748258590698,
-0.9606250524520874,
-0.0016464483924210072,
0.126566082239151,
0.4299289286136627,
-0.7405478954315186,
0.23490825295448303,
-0.2977766990661621,
-0.8317114114761353,
0.17249801754951477,
0.66849285364151,
0.1659363955259323,
0.468616247177124,
0.33840495347976685,
-0.4848099648952484,
-0.47940316796302795,
-0.5088439583778381,
-0.12332376837730408,
-0.059038423001766205,
-0.3851010501384735,
0.4065157175064087,
0.572523832321167,
-0.209004744887352,
0.8230865597724915,
-0.16624605655670166,
-0.21822528541088104,
-0.45272350311279297,
0.1035701110959053,
0.32897692918777466,
0.31284406781196594,
0.4465353786945343,
-0.5217326879501343,
-0.5161109566688538,
-0.051691293716430664,
-0.9580485224723816,
-0.11404140293598175,
-0.663143515586853,
0.3207365572452545,
0.274546355009079,
0.928244411945343,
-0.4189722239971161,
-0.009966076351702213,
0.5167668461799622,
-0.00548628019168973,
0.7901780605316162,
-0.49347999691963196,
-0.6702696681022644,
-0.6063863635063171,
0.25364747643470764,
0.11789483577013016,
-0.5674063563346863,
-0.44337043166160583,
0.002292393008247018,
0.20264527201652527,
-0.07896909862756729,
-0.5365607738494873,
0.9668804407119751,
-0.559801459312439,
-0.09357761591672897,
-0.33473703265190125,
0.31545010209083557,
-0.3083992898464203,
0.4361979365348816,
0.03001563809812069,
1.1146938800811768,
0.44183552265167236,
-0.8722555637359619,
0.2496764361858368,
-0.20245373249053955,
-0.24312925338745117,
0.4026598036289215,
-0.9119192361831665,
0.1425039917230606,
0.2188020944595337,
0.07163292169570923,
-0.5354562401771545,
0.202953040599823,
-0.13926896452903748,
-0.07877930998802185,
0.3789500296115875,
0.03328448906540871,
-0.9054930210113525,
-0.28712308406829834,
-0.13159677386283875,
0.04969841614365578,
0.7967204451560974,
-0.5988311767578125,
0.7129064798355103,
0.3017747104167938,
-0.2394101917743683,
-0.3147364556789398,
-0.45295557379722595,
0.1649889498949051,
-0.4244263768196106,
-0.24103586375713348,
0.3264772593975067,
-0.23706510663032532,
-0.18016289174556732,
-0.24034461379051208,
-0.5769444108009338,
0.14439868927001953,
0.4210832715034485,
0.30209439992904663,
0.20816843211650848,
-0.18040667474269867,
0.6389039158821106,
-0.27348095178604126,
-0.09259248524904251,
0.2062356323003769,
-0.2755257785320282,
0.5355725884437561,
-0.14821229875087738,
-0.28920090198516846,
0.07517579197883606,
0.12246478348970413,
0.6399036645889282,
0.002462357049807906,
1.0798670053482056,
0.5477774739265442,
-0.22277715802192688,
-0.4950111508369446,
-0.8679381608963013,
-0.24155239760875702,
-0.5258653163909912,
0.34772542119026184,
-0.23472297191619873,
-0.9721879959106445,
0.4433572590351105,
-0.67218017578125,
0.560136079788208,
0.33152657747268677,
0.6118918657302856,
-0.2870944142341614,
0.5327090620994568,
0.9644702076911926,
-0.12322098016738892,
0.4097675681114197,
-0.16824981570243835,
0.05613293498754501,
-1.016079306602478,
-0.11830435693264008,
-0.3121936023235321,
-0.1690620630979538,
-0.30646657943725586,
-0.4502300024032593,
0.449951708316803,
0.33813056349754333,
-0.2631153166294098,
0.44610926508903503,
-0.32551828026771545,
0.33952414989471436,
0.2976014316082001,
0.08802289515733719,
0.05913040414452553,
-0.24195419251918793,
-0.3223709464073181,
0.09190811961889267,
-0.9230834245681763,
-0.4487767219543457,
1.3244291543960571,
0.42110055685043335,
0.4653261601924896,
-0.12732206284999847,
0.5933328866958618,
0.09671810269355774,
0.6333538889884949,
-0.7527348399162292,
0.7538878917694092,
0.10534320771694183,
-0.22166137397289276,
-0.3388684093952179,
-0.3406406044960022,
-0.9920602440834045,
0.02584533579647541,
0.19545993208885193,
-0.7056488394737244,
-0.21216465532779694,
0.2707098126411438,
-0.06640896201133728,
0.30443257093429565,
-0.48799020051956177,
0.8099316954612732,
-0.2999025881290436,
-0.5219625234603882,
-0.41481640934944153,
-0.41478732228279114,
-0.12332923710346222,
-0.39042356610298157,
0.25846004486083984,
-0.1378069818019867,
-0.35899823904037476,
0.600921094417572,
-0.23629042506217957,
1.13105309009552,
-0.22317934036254883,
-0.01986626535654068,
0.23500557243824005,
0.08552911877632141,
0.44172772765159607,
0.17787526547908783,
-0.09695000946521759,
0.1271052062511444,
0.13518895208835602,
-0.4957408010959625,
-0.5718287229537964,
0.6886594891548157,
-0.5769179463386536,
-0.8039928674697876,
-0.4770224094390869,
-0.714023232460022,
-0.35697275400161743,
0.12617596983909607,
-0.21706080436706543,
0.4463917315006256,
-0.11521659046411514,
0.5249348282814026,
0.794150173664093,
-0.1528952568769455,
0.480614572763443,
0.49547240138053894,
-0.18143117427825928,
0.1015961542725563,
0.8192265629768372,
0.24883484840393066,
0.501948356628418,
-0.007545512169599533,
0.2983686029911041,
-0.22683146595954895,
-0.7177985310554504,
0.008893040008842945,
0.4415627717971802,
-0.875433087348938,
0.022715838626027107,
-0.5250290632247925,
-0.19315262138843536,
0.09510993957519531,
-0.43220266699790955,
-0.20552393794059753,
-0.20473240315914154,
-0.2540518045425415,
0.0716332197189331,
0.4427664577960968,
0.3008921146392822,
-0.11186883598566055,
0.15618747472763062,
-0.8159977197647095,
0.20187413692474365,
0.3412238359451294,
0.2962811291217804,
0.023571008816361427,
-0.7202910780906677,
-0.2695631682872772,
-0.17026829719543457,
-0.3854674696922302,
-0.475208044052124,
0.4879884719848633,
0.49120479822158813,
0.7737321853637695,
-0.03977103903889656,
-0.042169589549303055,
0.4503188133239746,
-0.5948179364204407,
0.8534463047981262,
-0.040290702134370804,
-0.7078287601470947,
0.35697826743125916,
-0.27460700273513794,
0.7925266027450562,
0.5861629247665405,
0.7635378241539001,
-0.7878522872924805,
-0.4283783435821533,
-0.587916910648346,
-0.8186830282211304,
0.16319924592971802,
-0.1467217057943344,
0.3757094740867615,
-0.01867779716849327,
0.7094935774803162,
0.13450005650520325,
0.2123289257287979,
-0.9111786484718323,
0.071403369307518,
0.09224862605333328,
-0.08339999616146088,
-0.31195706129074097,
-0.20489127933979034,
-0.01766221970319748,
-0.32000023126602173,
0.6670425534248352,
-0.2590952515602112,
0.11932408809661865,
-0.09847644716501236,
-0.2908865511417389,
0.23752067983150482,
0.14904680848121643,
0.4028497636318207,
1.1178345680236816,
-0.14573001861572266,
0.04063815623521805,
0.826660692691803,
-0.501396656036377,
0.09796573966741562,
-0.46040967106819153,
0.06457909196615219,
0.10577303171157837,
0.3381045162677765,
0.38280540704727173,
0.46178552508354187,
-1.1640844345092773,
0.10209383815526962,
0.19219598174095154,
-0.18906021118164062,
-0.8676667809486389,
0.3599080443382263,
0.6136128902435303,
0.02305557392537594,
0.10278024524450302,
0.048912595957517624,
-0.266424298286438,
-0.5556933283805847,
0.3610999286174774,
0.4492943584918976,
-0.4803209900856018,
-0.030082762241363525,
0.21074040234088898,
0.1497754156589508,
-0.47970882058143616,
0.7196363806724548,
-0.3556019365787506,
-0.31523674726486206,
0.5875039100646973,
0.6172608137130737,
0.5046435594558716,
-0.18792535364627838,
-0.04251532629132271,
0.5620713233947754,
0.3875581622123718,
-0.33297398686408997,
-0.03945254534482956,
-0.2993837296962738,
-0.60330730676651,
-0.5193744897842407,
-0.6319536566734314,
-0.5478530526161194,
0.2836866080760956,
-0.47832387685775757,
0.2742633521556854,
-0.7741435766220093,
-0.029797356575727463,
-0.29900482296943665,
-0.04723576456308365,
-0.7159509062767029,
0.23382315039634705,
-0.3118899464607239,
1.098159909248352,
-0.5826431512832642,
1.079762578010559,
0.5081779360771179,
-0.1460447758436203,
-0.7633302807807922,
-0.23772527277469635,
0.28188538551330566,
-0.6790651082992554,
0.676283597946167,
0.31648802757263184,
-0.17461712658405304,
0.03302818909287453,
-0.4704235792160034,
-0.7270174622535706,
1.1971734762191772,
0.22347359359264374,
-0.7931429147720337,
-0.11613012850284576,
-0.13554304838180542,
0.6203323602676392,
-0.18604624271392822,
-0.025041013956069946,
0.4285622239112854,
0.1829381287097931,
0.25326383113861084,
-1.0349370241165161,
-0.0002999673306476325,
-0.2648267447948456,
0.05457639321684837,
0.25256112217903137,
-0.3335650861263275,
0.6417557597160339,
0.01364672277122736,
-0.2542229890823364,
-0.15491841733455658,
0.299502968788147,
0.42086732387542725,
0.3201569616794586,
0.6671338677406311,
0.5567150115966797,
0.506523072719574,
0.015174015425145626,
0.9108999371528625,
-0.17739596962928772,
0.30215853452682495,
1.2840020656585693,
-0.4788702726364136,
1.0181493759155273,
0.6100484728813171,
-0.1636749655008316,
0.5067686438560486,
0.5557229518890381,
-0.3343331217765808,
0.23482131958007812,
0.3688257932662964,
-0.3775508403778076,
-0.4427408277988434,
-0.05982743203639984,
-0.0796593427658081,
0.16532975435256958,
0.6030579209327698,
-0.06370970606803894,
-0.31889861822128296,
0.3033338487148285,
0.05098063498735428,
0.09428359568119049,
-0.3240290582180023,
0.8233566880226135,
0.4854772388935089,
-0.604047954082489,
0.7929301261901855,
-0.1488466113805771,
0.7002366781234741,
-0.7963074445724487,
0.1290787011384964,
-0.006761064752936363,
0.288099467754364,
0.13177092373371124,
-0.5394898653030396,
0.6856586337089539,
-0.04413530230522156,
0.02781422808766365,
-0.4741205871105194,
0.5696741342544556,
-0.07319974899291992,
-0.6190226674079895,
0.3622378408908844,
0.43511325120925903,
0.007720638066530228,
-0.04692864045500755,
-0.7750768661499023,
-0.08063982427120209,
-0.23262453079223633,
-0.16941885650157928,
0.676170289516449,
0.29661884903907776,
0.09602167457342148,
1.30772864818573,
0.660201370716095,
0.35928913950920105,
-0.017674556002020836,
0.04927116632461548,
0.7955436110496521,
-0.5405909419059753,
-0.1498645395040512,
-0.7349296808242798,
0.46830984950065613,
-0.23887097835540771,
-0.31122586131095886,
0.9045198559761047,
0.3283317983150482,
1.0045183897018433,
0.05798695981502533,
0.5044869184494019,
0.16282837092876434,
0.5484434366226196,
-0.7440613508224487,
0.4962814152240753,
-0.7515857219696045,
0.4259908199310303,
0.167925626039505,
-0.8096361756324768,
-0.2667270302772522,
0.5673293471336365,
-0.29041361808776855,
0.0024009363260120153,
0.9839514493942261,
0.6328445672988892,
-0.0033493342343717813,
-0.34991905093193054,
0.4640510082244873,
0.015048278495669365,
0.317850798368454,
0.5701778531074524,
0.48683464527130127,
0.06201210245490074,
0.38615739345550537,
-0.307665079832077,
-0.08654050529003143,
-0.0260023083537817,
-1.0531020164489746,
-1.0733145475387573,
-0.6133097410202026,
-0.4252588450908661,
-0.05574125051498413,
0.062111996114254,
0.8496070504188538,
0.6351204514503479,
-0.48114529252052307,
-0.5219030380249023,
-0.38979482650756836,
-0.07435780763626099,
-0.41548410058021545,
-0.15566053986549377,
-0.005429063457995653,
-0.8978760242462158,
-0.2555522322654724,
0.38641709089279175,
0.46821415424346924,
-0.14850066602230072,
-0.4537075459957123,
0.0533389113843441,
-0.27313685417175293,
-0.041809141635894775,
0.6409037113189697,
0.4435890316963196,
-0.6455403566360474,
-0.49631059169769287,
0.16005825996398926,
0.21834500133991241,
0.13720396161079407,
0.8424647450447083,
-0.9845054745674133,
0.41401445865631104,
0.07207293808460236,
0.8324167132377625,
0.6820345520973206,
-0.4661030173301697,
0.6748231053352356,
-0.8223341703414917,
0.27376580238342285,
0.3960620164871216,
0.32831043004989624,
0.34194234013557434,
-0.13955460488796234,
0.5995966792106628,
0.10717064142227173,
-0.7679852247238159,
-0.932451605796814,
0.25779494643211365,
-0.8632872700691223,
-0.29041165113449097,
1.0725635290145874,
-0.4799724221229553,
-0.034641094505786896,
-0.5964155197143555,
0.01493476890027523,
0.035515911877155304,
-0.021889930590987206,
0.7829696536064148,
0.6636506915092468,
0.04953131824731827,
-0.5826194286346436,
-0.8999338150024414,
0.3150145709514618,
0.4851282238960266,
-0.8637754917144775,
-0.002570921555161476,
0.058050915598869324,
0.6701708436012268,
0.1367643028497696,
0.5778048634529114,
0.0042019616812467575,
0.3621087670326233,
0.06019295006990433,
-0.1078813225030899,
0.03681057319045067,
-0.4131256639957428,
-0.21180729568004608,
0.08846499025821686,
0.5595541000366211,
0.2790510952472687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09338v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09338v1
|
Entropy Guided Extrapolative Decoding to Improve Factuality in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-14T19:45:35 | 2024-04-14T19:45:35 |
Souvik Das, Lifeng Jin, Linfeng Song, Haitao Mi, Baolin Peng, Dong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) exhibit impressive natural language capabilities
but suffer from hallucination -- generating content ungrounded in the realities
of training data. Recent work has focused on decoding techniques to improve
factuality during inference by leveraging LLMs' hierarchical representation of
factual knowledge, manipulating the predicted distributions at inference time.
Current state-of-the-art approaches refine decoding by contrasting early-exit
distributions from a lower layer with the final layer to exploit information
related to factuality within the model forward procedure. However, such methods
often assume the final layer is the most reliable and the lower layer selection
process depends on it. In this work, we first propose extrapolation of critical
token probabilities beyond the last layer for more accurate contrasting. We
additionally employ layer-wise entropy-guided lower layer selection, decoupling
the selection process from the final layer. Experiments demonstrate strong
performance - surpassing state-of-the-art on multiple different datasets by
large margins. Analyses show different kinds of prompts respond to different
selection strategies.
|
[
-0.21896326541900635,
-0.7214744091033936,
0.7671064138412476,
0.15693993866443634,
-0.5082751512527466,
0.11082574725151062,
-0.4077977240085602,
-0.5062841773033142,
0.22348636388778687,
0.45074746012687683,
-0.3537200093269348,
-0.5324817299842834,
-0.543501079082489,
0.06386236101388931,
-0.31383633613586426,
0.9786613583564758,
0.2339281439781189,
0.042558811604976654,
-0.3993072509765625,
0.18738411366939545,
-0.1004992350935936,
-0.7233931422233582,
-0.7315468192100525,
-0.5965750217437744,
0.426919549703598,
0.29057905077934265,
0.5474791526794434,
0.6074858903884888,
0.31260401010513306,
0.2412523627281189,
-0.33132174611091614,
0.4135013222694397,
-0.4346858859062195,
0.24250343441963196,
0.05288553237915039,
-0.7012105584144592,
-0.2838033437728882,
-0.05351612716913223,
0.6217930316925049,
0.679617166519165,
-0.2689723074436188,
0.04377332329750061,
0.14283280074596405,
0.6906939744949341,
-0.7792688608169556,
0.4519996643066406,
-0.8364747166633606,
0.12507201731204987,
0.03230338171124458,
-0.6306426525115967,
-0.825947642326355,
-0.2546826899051666,
0.04751309007406235,
-0.44899922609329224,
0.2670486569404602,
0.1630294770002365,
0.5732868313789368,
0.20424816012382507,
-0.2557758688926697,
-0.15957407653331757,
-0.855444610118866,
0.7146480679512024,
-0.8401204943656921,
0.6620090007781982,
0.6276329159736633,
0.03837171569466591,
-0.10405058413743973,
-0.5754034519195557,
-0.43878358602523804,
-0.48781630396842957,
-0.02630572021007538,
0.1059112623333931,
-0.08357227593660355,
0.1087711825966835,
0.1485264152288437,
0.18755075335502625,
-0.2144007533788681,
0.1962222456932068,
-0.10651588439941406,
-0.4728710651397705,
0.4613990783691406,
0.026988135650753975,
0.04962068423628807,
-0.048346616327762604,
-0.22229105234146118,
-0.344135046005249,
-0.6970642805099487,
-0.030470071360468864,
0.30423322319984436,
0.3064817488193512,
-0.0016532016452401876,
0.5153111815452576,
-0.41550561785697937,
0.5473496913909912,
0.08500026911497116,
-0.16204491257667542,
0.37581494450569153,
-0.05678081884980202,
-0.3732757866382599,
0.3076746463775635,
0.4794766902923584,
0.44731518626213074,
-0.051355957984924316,
-0.2436419427394867,
-0.30324503779411316,
-0.27130910754203796,
-0.12902960181236267,
-0.6215269565582275,
-0.3901013731956482,
0.3351888358592987,
-0.532773494720459,
-0.33169543743133545,
-0.010927176102995872,
-0.7083397507667542,
-0.5333788394927979,
-0.45106351375579834,
0.09203574806451797,
-0.513261079788208,
-0.19534890353679657,
0.3335690200328827,
-0.18732790648937225,
0.2364819496870041,
0.3615701496601105,
-0.8823447227478027,
0.13557913899421692,
0.7291837334632874,
0.9307469129562378,
0.02703111059963703,
-0.24257951974868774,
-0.8004855513572693,
0.3621703088283539,
-0.43646353483200073,
0.8426221013069153,
-0.7330595850944519,
0.03775215148925781,
-0.14133115112781525,
-0.2791931629180908,
0.09810692816972733,
-0.5164129734039307,
0.837296724319458,
-0.9897526502609253,
0.05957387760281563,
-0.5204862952232361,
-0.48561063408851624,
-0.3188490569591522,
0.41870173811912537,
-0.7135783433914185,
0.7712330222129822,
-0.2570890486240387,
-0.9039426445960999,
0.4528101086616516,
-0.1929669976234436,
-0.39993155002593994,
-0.058977577835321426,
-0.08074994385242462,
-0.34230339527130127,
0.4708579182624817,
0.4782896935939789,
0.6668179631233215,
-0.3814588487148285,
0.24835123121738434,
-0.44069966673851013,
-0.1818537414073944,
0.3107743561267853,
-0.8789994716644287,
0.5873057842254639,
0.2414141297340393,
-0.2858321964740753,
-0.11269839107990265,
-1.0861443281173706,
0.10175950825214386,
-0.13968345522880554,
-0.5820305943489075,
-0.4341936707496643,
0.024807866662740707,
-0.22516974806785583,
0.12576685845851898,
-0.029134217649698257,
-0.3588219881057739,
-0.10231735557317734,
-0.2991815507411957,
0.2819928228855133,
0.8745261430740356,
-0.15659643709659576,
0.27778783440589905,
-0.17964781820774078,
0.3513059914112091,
0.2500860393047333,
-0.09944616258144379,
-0.005924365483224392,
-0.2795484662055969,
-0.627960741519928,
-0.5688662528991699,
0.375248521566391,
0.6429340839385986,
-0.9676578044891357,
0.5751311182975769,
-0.3150799572467804,
-0.2725365161895752,
-0.47654733061790466,
0.0809284970164299,
0.36840057373046875,
0.5515648126602173,
0.4206453561782837,
-0.09955532103776932,
-0.7456685900688171,
-0.7254322171211243,
-0.17136122286319733,
-0.5672784447669983,
0.13079461455345154,
0.054007638245821,
0.26312682032585144,
-0.1977744996547699,
0.7622278928756714,
-0.562719464302063,
0.01051951851695776,
-0.22973713278770447,
0.07512759417295456,
0.26679715514183044,
0.4142208993434906,
0.12728111445903778,
-0.6831293702125549,
-0.24598729610443115,
0.1373116374015808,
-0.6724094152450562,
-0.023425213992595673,
-0.3698737621307373,
-0.21711111068725586,
0.2964617609977722,
0.622384786605835,
-0.8360614776611328,
0.09310747683048248,
0.5302325487136841,
-0.2065115123987198,
0.8253474831581116,
-0.33035656809806824,
0.13041235506534576,
-0.8154033422470093,
-0.00828186422586441,
-0.03129575401544571,
-0.3084888756275177,
-0.6048990488052368,
0.09114934504032135,
-0.15345445275306702,
0.5000928640365601,
-0.1016450896859169,
0.25270646810531616,
-0.7184620499610901,
-0.025000108405947685,
-0.23664875328540802,
-0.22923164069652557,
0.12611407041549683,
0.26421958208084106,
0.27455347776412964,
0.4612652659416199,
0.6573752164840698,
-0.5093724727630615,
0.6195359230041504,
0.03273758292198181,
-0.6103166937828064,
0.14557181298732758,
-0.46642276644706726,
0.18849144876003265,
-0.3059752285480499,
0.5628259778022766,
-0.9568355083465576,
-0.3410831391811371,
0.17074628174304962,
-0.3147198557853699,
0.37811440229415894,
-0.20269839465618134,
-0.7024869322776794,
-0.08448527008295059,
-0.6080747246742249,
0.43417081236839294,
0.5211858153343201,
-0.6854709386825562,
0.6190841794013977,
0.2314249873161316,
-0.06527436524629593,
-0.7553666830062866,
-1.0621451139450073,
0.39671090245246887,
-0.30939990282058716,
-0.4329926371574402,
0.17585238814353943,
-0.03514257073402405,
-0.3683154582977295,
-0.16729025542736053,
-0.10468457639217377,
0.09953118860721588,
-0.012956356629729271,
-0.1167154312133789,
0.3834409713745117,
-0.2823917269706726,
-0.09709305316209793,
0.15817362070083618,
-0.11222605407238007,
0.285903662443161,
-0.5074435472488403,
0.6413884162902832,
0.015575356781482697,
-0.41204679012298584,
-0.4157494604587555,
0.2767183780670166,
0.6016533374786377,
-0.084309883415699,
1.1771236658096313,
0.7223207950592041,
-0.3643030822277069,
-0.27962788939476013,
-0.7990227341651917,
-0.2968020737171173,
-0.47876742482185364,
0.41305187344551086,
-0.39686310291290283,
-0.6391168832778931,
0.711944580078125,
0.11274361610412598,
-0.142670139670372,
0.12382779270410538,
0.6405726671218872,
0.09091893583536148,
0.9371718168258667,
0.5561521053314209,
-0.054118476808071136,
0.29714930057525635,
-0.18803104758262634,
0.2871853709220886,
-0.8165700435638428,
-0.6402480006217957,
-0.2827163338661194,
0.003138675820082426,
-0.3576648533344269,
-0.4270182251930237,
0.3344558775424957,
0.20574451982975006,
0.12010414153337479,
-0.13478893041610718,
-0.164241760969162,
0.6540582180023193,
0.5995649099349976,
0.4263354241847992,
0.33049333095550537,
0.48806503415107727,
-0.338580846786499,
0.12295819073915482,
-0.7765233516693115,
-0.3060649633407593,
0.8609136343002319,
0.4453776478767395,
0.7939861416816711,
0.025413695722818375,
0.6423601508140564,
0.2890499234199524,
0.020073091611266136,
-0.6765762567520142,
0.4973844289779663,
0.04044301062822342,
-0.409416139125824,
-0.41217780113220215,
-0.6584497094154358,
-0.4764864146709442,
0.39556121826171875,
-0.2184440791606903,
-0.6650272607803345,
0.2651035487651825,
0.2575072944164276,
-0.46046334505081177,
0.5022143125534058,
-0.7887789607048035,
0.2209191769361496,
0.07776321470737457,
-0.2841870188713074,
-0.048630036413669586,
-0.6972121000289917,
0.48793870210647583,
0.0034830437507480383,
0.22691377997398376,
0.19444715976715088,
0.029291905462741852,
0.5556396245956421,
-0.24206723272800446,
0.9929068088531494,
-0.10977122187614441,
-0.46890515089035034,
0.24186185002326965,
0.13272878527641296,
0.9338010549545288,
0.07936573773622513,
-0.44344595074653625,
-0.04883119836449623,
-0.0691724345088005,
-0.2847779095172882,
-0.6171851754188538,
0.5048470497131348,
-0.6777710318565369,
-0.7020395398139954,
-0.1695803701877594,
-0.5078745484352112,
-0.43962329626083374,
-0.06703003495931625,
0.4998311400413513,
0.6598470211029053,
0.16178447008132935,
0.36857014894485474,
0.8142521977424622,
-0.18718558549880981,
0.2387833148241043,
0.2664620280265808,
0.09890692681074142,
-0.41157227754592896,
0.9863137006759644,
0.07184885442256927,
0.2829592823982239,
0.6742998957633972,
0.3631315231323242,
-0.5925570726394653,
-0.9412511587142944,
-0.15417905151844025,
0.08994970470666885,
-1.124313473701477,
-0.3502526879310608,
-0.8493088483810425,
-0.2535960376262665,
-0.6384500861167908,
0.009091310203075409,
-0.22457066178321838,
-0.37886741757392883,
-0.3797690272331238,
-0.5297408699989319,
0.14612950384616852,
0.41102898120880127,
-0.4636245369911194,
0.011578816920518875,
-0.8894997835159302,
0.16732576489448547,
0.19899475574493408,
0.2781212031841278,
0.12585300207138062,
-0.7019380331039429,
-0.38346201181411743,
-0.053516935557127,
0.23638714849948883,
-0.674735426902771,
0.31308484077453613,
0.1701144576072693,
0.6153307557106018,
0.38510823249816895,
0.2883182764053345,
0.6222338676452637,
-0.4524070620536804,
0.6236244440078735,
0.34473714232444763,
-0.8162055015563965,
0.251220703125,
-0.1321129947900772,
0.08604957163333893,
0.5028896331787109,
0.08583039045333862,
-0.3483359217643738,
-0.46353885531425476,
-0.4455146789550781,
-0.991445004940033,
0.6830045580863953,
0.19391018152236938,
0.28434887528419495,
0.014039276167750359,
0.38754013180732727,
0.338945209980011,
0.12639090418815613,
-0.6390684247016907,
-0.1510370671749115,
-0.041380081325769424,
-0.17374630272388458,
-0.08054273575544357,
-0.5458678007125854,
-0.23511025309562683,
-0.29626742005348206,
0.7227361798286438,
-0.2215491682291031,
0.15746432542800903,
0.21008162200450897,
-0.0847994014620781,
0.01656997576355934,
0.3632924556732178,
0.5767251253128052,
0.6135280728340149,
-0.2771000266075134,
0.6519424319267273,
0.3558163344860077,
-0.5366387367248535,
0.10941649973392487,
0.03101375326514244,
-0.176488995552063,
0.012382127344608307,
0.8929226994514465,
0.9240289926528931,
-0.22515271604061127,
-0.5249049663543701,
0.26590609550476074,
0.01788426749408245,
-0.003897337010130286,
-0.06902927905321121,
0.15617716312408447,
-0.15621095895767212,
0.5442887544631958,
0.5650174617767334,
0.12812167406082153,
0.327979177236557,
-0.6663346886634827,
0.24597075581550598,
0.4807387590408325,
-0.02862471342086792,
-0.4499496519565582,
0.4542206823825836,
0.10504411160945892,
0.1828717291355133,
0.4607807397842407,
-0.10989517718553543,
-0.6145432591438293,
0.5340626239776611,
0.6940783858299255,
0.9482945203781128,
0.12722885608673096,
0.4457142949104309,
0.14332200586795807,
0.41871199011802673,
-0.43825092911720276,
0.0940307080745697,
-0.1829858422279358,
-0.8724047541618347,
-0.7162356972694397,
-0.6176774501800537,
-0.2264360785484314,
0.3073349595069885,
-0.7755932807922363,
0.22320939600467682,
-0.42575007677078247,
-0.01946202479302883,
-0.48481285572052,
-0.08299999684095383,
-0.4151744246482849,
0.44728338718414307,
0.6639381647109985,
0.9393362998962402,
-0.8062519431114197,
0.7189887762069702,
0.5092152953147888,
0.09520961344242096,
-0.7453930377960205,
0.398947536945343,
-0.13425372540950775,
-0.7659427523612976,
0.5800402164459229,
0.09783031791448593,
-0.5471782088279724,
-0.03865157440304756,
-0.75014328956604,
-0.9338575005531311,
0.9846727252006531,
0.8991419672966003,
-0.4770275950431824,
-0.1908610761165619,
-0.04273683950304985,
0.4609730839729309,
-0.3816075921058655,
0.46029478311538696,
0.7204515337944031,
0.29699549078941345,
0.45124581456184387,
-0.4923069179058075,
0.3221401274204254,
-0.07176410406827927,
0.07385681569576263,
-0.34662365913391113,
-0.5469066500663757,
0.684066116809845,
-0.37128835916519165,
-0.18544970452785492,
-0.1807592511177063,
0.8663531541824341,
0.5156430006027222,
0.3521541357040405,
0.5627350211143494,
0.4489985406398773,
1.024280071258545,
0.2719666063785553,
1.0862855911254883,
-0.30255550146102905,
0.37329378724098206,
1.1436142921447754,
-0.19751973450183868,
0.8528581857681274,
0.4794130325317383,
-0.01258903183043003,
0.5459068417549133,
0.7194568514823914,
0.20268261432647705,
0.8142948746681213,
0.03634344041347504,
-0.28486740589141846,
-0.5393391847610474,
-0.07080411165952682,
-0.4939756691455841,
0.39766284823417664,
0.3385961651802063,
-0.3184393644332886,
-0.17451439797878265,
-0.12772470712661743,
0.04407333955168724,
-0.27105820178985596,
-0.17008355259895325,
0.6778132915496826,
-0.024598101153969765,
-0.5926046967506409,
0.7595030069351196,
0.09244987368583679,
0.543361246585846,
-0.41860613226890564,
-0.09668580442667007,
-0.27801522612571716,
0.027549168094992638,
-0.372009813785553,
-0.7426301836967468,
0.04820386320352554,
-0.06568647176027298,
-0.2581770420074463,
-0.09885359555482864,
0.7619289755821228,
-0.48162680864334106,
-0.5376473665237427,
0.27607622742652893,
0.3514503836631775,
0.07066083699464798,
-0.16867806017398834,
-0.5180478692054749,
0.3549518883228302,
0.04318331927061081,
-0.5386509299278259,
-0.05273623391985893,
0.7107414603233337,
0.2636791467666626,
0.6993030905723572,
0.8560972809791565,
0.36232316493988037,
0.2215041071176529,
0.1919059157371521,
1.0411680936813354,
-0.5820990204811096,
-0.6809902787208557,
-1.3092331886291504,
0.4220861792564392,
-0.09403355419635773,
-0.0036284481175243855,
0.6907524466514587,
0.4861319363117218,
0.7583695650100708,
0.02022211253643036,
0.8369891047477722,
0.14766620099544525,
0.05627140402793884,
-1.2473233938217163,
0.43354332447052,
-0.34269216656684875,
0.6922203302383423,
-0.1584140807390213,
-0.9230944514274597,
-0.45989999175071716,
0.35864531993865967,
-0.10079051554203033,
0.046833980828523636,
0.6326075792312622,
0.7603057622909546,
-0.1071261391043663,
0.018364762887358665,
0.47165319323539734,
0.42376792430877686,
0.38906246423721313,
0.3729338049888611,
1.1141010522842407,
-0.05880359187722206,
0.41466134786605835,
-0.14336740970611572,
-0.3478710949420929,
-0.3024069666862488,
-0.9277451634407043,
-1.0128573179244995,
-0.5374883413314819,
-0.29849889874458313,
-0.5936023592948914,
-0.03602984920144081,
1.1668505668640137,
0.7812095284461975,
-0.8424904942512512,
0.04884525015950203,
0.03702934831380844,
0.15217210352420807,
-0.1568186730146408,
-0.17910727858543396,
0.38293057680130005,
-0.4223732054233551,
-0.4546082615852356,
0.474472314119339,
0.21385890245437622,
-0.04999161139130592,
-0.21494439244270325,
-0.08519989997148514,
0.058160748332738876,
0.28877824544906616,
0.9308172464370728,
-0.011019027791917324,
-0.5678681135177612,
-0.28434792160987854,
-0.10848116874694824,
-0.0693468526005745,
0.04821450635790825,
0.9275972843170166,
-0.6837391257286072,
0.1405000388622284,
0.7408274412155151,
0.8143185377120972,
0.2632763385772705,
-0.01996171474456787,
0.5907980799674988,
-0.8313872218132019,
0.08860094845294952,
0.10666067898273468,
0.3095643222332001,
0.5254544615745544,
-0.6572229266166687,
0.26597750186920166,
0.36045780777931213,
-0.234730064868927,
-1.1685247421264648,
0.15722404420375824,
-0.707716166973114,
-0.34593135118484497,
1.5484015941619873,
-0.06242102012038231,
-0.3847222924232483,
-0.034557413309812546,
-0.03494030609726906,
0.25606414675712585,
-0.3793679475784302,
0.9504170417785645,
0.9769543409347534,
-0.08824704587459564,
-0.32169362902641296,
-0.3655652105808258,
0.5357437133789062,
0.4110032320022583,
-0.7681007385253906,
0.42104214429855347,
0.5161750316619873,
0.11302454024553299,
0.09904945641756058,
0.5255471467971802,
0.04384202882647514,
0.06532999873161316,
0.005552452057600021,
-0.3699966073036194,
-0.14508754014968872,
-0.6503023505210876,
-0.48886868357658386,
0.14129109680652618,
0.06964549422264099,
-0.05318516120314598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09336v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09336v1
|
Self-Selected Attention Span for Accelerating Large Language Model Inference
| 2024-04-14T19:36:04 | 2024-04-14T19:36:04 |
Tian Jin, Wanzin Yazar, Zifei Xu, Sayeh Sharify, Xin Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) can solve challenging tasks. However, their
inference computation on modern GPUs is highly inefficient due to the
increasing number of tokens they must attend to as they generate new ones. To
address this inefficiency, we capitalize on LLMs' problem-solving capabilities
to optimize their own inference-time efficiency. We demonstrate with two
specific tasks: (a) evaluating complex arithmetic expressions and (b)
summarizing news articles. For both tasks, we create custom datasets to
fine-tune an LLM. The goal of fine-tuning is twofold: first, to make the LLM
learn to solve the evaluation or summarization task, and second, to train it to
identify the minimal attention spans required for each step of the task. As a
result, the fine-tuned model is able to convert these self-identified minimal
attention spans into sparse attention masks on-the-fly during inference. We
develop a custom CUDA kernel to take advantage of the reduced context to attend
to. We demonstrate that using this custom CUDA kernel improves the throughput
of LLM inference by 28%. Our work presents an end-to-end demonstration showing
that training LLMs to self-select their attention spans speeds up
autoregressive inference in solving real-world tasks.
|
[
-0.47621282935142517,
-1.0529396533966064,
0.7675089240074158,
0.4464685022830963,
-0.23516617715358734,
-0.018140776082873344,
-0.4016575515270233,
-0.4788624048233032,
0.19050109386444092,
0.3848241865634918,
-0.47584283351898193,
-0.06914711743593216,
-0.542738139629364,
0.10371282696723938,
-0.045692503452301025,
0.7548977732658386,
0.17874059081077576,
-0.366183340549469,
-0.2472333312034607,
0.07946544885635376,
-0.1609811931848526,
-0.19027453660964966,
-0.8582472205162048,
-0.1479126662015915,
0.5059361457824707,
0.44315797090530396,
0.3984724283218384,
0.9004971981048584,
0.34321296215057373,
0.2590380609035492,
-0.2221464365720749,
0.30889222025871277,
-0.4349833130836487,
0.058009419590234756,
0.13061019778251648,
-0.192894846200943,
-0.362712025642395,
-0.06247769296169281,
0.6238411664962769,
0.7166487574577332,
0.0362769179046154,
0.44830450415611267,
-0.030553273856639862,
0.6140862107276917,
-0.9401357173919678,
0.11020436882972717,
-0.6816617846488953,
0.1052776426076889,
-0.2436574548482895,
0.10782705992460251,
-0.3893267512321472,
-0.16976256668567657,
-0.009413187392055988,
-0.6214011311531067,
0.21343772113323212,
0.03957527130842209,
0.45957279205322266,
0.7041730880737305,
-0.19963319599628448,
0.24636200070381165,
-0.42781201004981995,
0.721072256565094,
-0.7884159684181213,
0.45110300183296204,
0.3953202962875366,
0.13348037004470825,
-0.0469723604619503,
-0.6201753616333008,
-0.42021414637565613,
-0.2532762885093689,
0.01148831844329834,
0.05059592425823212,
-0.16036176681518555,
0.057701632380485535,
0.5122576951980591,
0.31805795431137085,
-0.4398110508918762,
0.3647831380367279,
-0.3574104309082031,
-0.08681175112724304,
0.5515064001083374,
0.26859208941459656,
-0.03374960273504257,
0.05166136100888252,
-0.0361643023788929,
0.18116402626037598,
-0.5997234582901001,
-0.059050288051366806,
0.31892454624176025,
0.056542471051216125,
-0.10198307037353516,
0.4882224500179291,
-0.43679702281951904,
0.8490868210792542,
0.3851047456264496,
0.12626022100448608,
0.18961744010448456,
-0.11054667085409164,
-0.628028929233551,
-0.05500692129135132,
0.7277430295944214,
0.027287013828754425,
0.281203955411911,
-0.24925239384174347,
-0.13314932584762573,
0.1827968955039978,
0.0783771276473999,
-0.8166366815567017,
-0.20718424022197723,
0.12268754094839096,
-0.18551166355609894,
-0.03361959010362625,
-0.4658929109573364,
-0.6938364505767822,
-0.020751960575580597,
-0.21776840090751648,
0.20071682333946228,
0.0478498749434948,
-0.02486030012369156,
0.24786598980426788,
0.009392991662025452,
0.0033885587472468615,
0.30713239312171936,
-1.2556170225143433,
0.2676864266395569,
0.4372943043708801,
0.8404300808906555,
-0.4791683554649353,
-0.0751047432422638,
-1.0111199617385864,
0.2489936649799347,
-0.33298540115356445,
0.8908871412277222,
-0.7391523122787476,
-0.20330189168453217,
-0.40682899951934814,
-0.15999558568000793,
-0.29008162021636963,
-0.5509130954742432,
0.560248076915741,
-0.5499401092529297,
-0.17922259867191315,
-0.06998848915100098,
-0.6346771717071533,
0.21092349290847778,
0.08102153986692429,
-0.6936547756195068,
1.1557258367538452,
0.14377564191818237,
-0.684232771396637,
0.055996909737586975,
-0.6291363835334778,
-0.6952074766159058,
0.03579697385430336,
-0.07808532565832138,
-0.4700193405151367,
0.3450615704059601,
0.5947033166885376,
0.5627933144569397,
-0.14467626810073853,
0.04157929867506027,
-0.5349764227867126,
-0.21195203065872192,
-0.11995258927345276,
-0.36817991733551025,
0.6281079053878784,
0.4304671287536621,
-0.26418155431747437,
0.15635494887828827,
-0.6464366912841797,
-0.11652815341949463,
-0.06933190673589706,
-0.41249656677246094,
-0.3937094509601593,
-0.06644758582115173,
-0.18949982523918152,
0.11393185704946518,
0.39686068892478943,
-0.4957708716392517,
0.1654840111732483,
-0.5162468552589417,
0.5829581022262573,
0.6654969453811646,
-0.05972466990351677,
0.42789605259895325,
-0.03318193554878235,
0.5573789477348328,
-0.1541420966386795,
0.14641670882701874,
-0.1844467967748642,
-0.3104608356952667,
-0.9707295894622803,
-0.35939306020736694,
0.09801006317138672,
0.27833375334739685,
-0.46614333987236023,
0.24001352488994598,
-0.010991307906806469,
-0.273373007774353,
-0.6726089119911194,
0.434529185295105,
0.3052898645401001,
0.8564423322677612,
0.39307117462158203,
-0.020916970446705818,
-0.38122332096099854,
-0.9909681677818298,
-0.2197507619857788,
0.08328157663345337,
-0.02544780634343624,
0.4117402732372284,
0.3226393461227417,
-0.1575424075126648,
0.7686421871185303,
-0.6529003977775574,
-0.197780579328537,
-0.2790237069129944,
0.012351930141448975,
0.23226062953472137,
0.3298851251602173,
0.36087968945503235,
-0.5474368333816528,
-0.49487146735191345,
-0.1419963836669922,
-0.4821094870567322,
-0.5530264973640442,
-0.1446373462677002,
-0.21353070437908173,
0.29346051812171936,
0.8869116306304932,
-0.5489170551300049,
0.132796049118042,
0.47086116671562195,
-0.46095773577690125,
0.6317688226699829,
-0.3986363708972931,
-0.16546662151813507,
-0.6801559925079346,
0.040121495723724365,
0.19986771047115326,
-0.340273916721344,
-0.3019351661205292,
0.00310346158221364,
0.3631998598575592,
0.22207261621952057,
-0.3237706422805786,
0.9233414530754089,
-0.6321625113487244,
-0.303145170211792,
-0.3477737307548523,
0.22414061427116394,
-0.11826172471046448,
0.6798077821731567,
0.06703382730484009,
0.922705888748169,
0.4504655599594116,
-0.7522432804107666,
-0.06561969220638275,
0.2050556093454361,
-0.4638271927833557,
0.16218623518943787,
-0.658513069152832,
0.15749405324459076,
0.032279036939144135,
-0.1470148265361786,
-1.0081593990325928,
-0.21838250756263733,
-0.07760617136955261,
-0.16567008197307587,
0.18865801393985748,
0.026805510744452477,
-0.4607856571674347,
-0.4442104399204254,
-0.10724180191755295,
0.3445245027542114,
0.3927094638347626,
-0.6038625240325928,
0.6843359470367432,
0.6188445687294006,
-0.20582355558872223,
-0.47039446234703064,
-0.7378566265106201,
0.03936414420604706,
-0.08762173354625702,
-0.30928781628608704,
0.21536614000797272,
-0.31947165727615356,
-0.27105504274368286,
-0.18429633975028992,
-0.1740483194589615,
0.10972513258457184,
0.3716456890106201,
0.12926548719406128,
0.1801636815071106,
-0.15417200326919556,
0.1850951761007309,
0.35875362157821655,
-0.07255828380584717,
0.11297568678855896,
0.029200216755270958,
0.3165433406829834,
-0.0589483380317688,
-0.152606800198555,
-0.33302366733551025,
0.15835213661193848,
0.5650322437286377,
-0.5633265972137451,
0.2269977480173111,
0.4919716417789459,
-0.1882677674293518,
-0.2254328727722168,
-0.8936522603034973,
-0.2900683879852295,
-0.45643818378448486,
0.45556437969207764,
-0.3714972734451294,
-1.0926095247268677,
0.3435104787349701,
0.13144409656524658,
0.2341003715991974,
0.4889880418777466,
0.8511271476745605,
0.10114267468452454,
0.9276238679885864,
0.5849212408065796,
-0.3658270835876465,
0.6124754548072815,
-0.16022779047489166,
-0.14046511054039001,
-1.106131911277771,
0.005769047420471907,
-0.3662138283252716,
-0.1964617371559143,
-0.14639292657375336,
-0.44904887676239014,
0.3045496940612793,
-0.3368340730667114,
-0.2558932304382324,
0.04031292721629143,
-0.3418402075767517,
0.7506628632545471,
0.49833378195762634,
0.1218767985701561,
0.4308255910873413,
0.028476335108280182,
-0.05789151415228844,
-0.06669333577156067,
-0.7130466103553772,
-0.1289205551147461,
0.9589879512786865,
0.3257996141910553,
0.9979211091995239,
-0.14176008105278015,
0.2599634528160095,
0.2422991842031479,
0.5389646887779236,
-0.7053464651107788,
0.4814436733722687,
-0.28780367970466614,
-0.47783008217811584,
-0.3838612735271454,
-0.4624451994895935,
-0.7063179016113281,
0.32461389899253845,
-0.07540801912546158,
-0.6610067486763,
-0.028068235144019127,
0.35595640540122986,
-0.7027745246887207,
0.07911917567253113,
-0.886330783367157,
0.9989550709724426,
-0.06515300273895264,
-0.5742460489273071,
-0.5422493815422058,
-0.5566390156745911,
0.3714418411254883,
-0.15457914769649506,
0.01347019150853157,
-0.3476310670375824,
-0.057675208896398544,
0.6371581554412842,
0.00239167851395905,
1.0294216871261597,
0.034437987953424454,
-0.11162395030260086,
0.08880974352359772,
0.09328404068946838,
0.5672855377197266,
0.14798061549663544,
-0.14493876695632935,
-0.0901034027338028,
-0.49840736389160156,
-0.23348000645637512,
-0.4432213604450226,
0.8777137994766235,
-0.5604420304298401,
-0.8854529857635498,
-0.1987660676240921,
-0.9125441312789917,
-0.39433473348617554,
0.19677545130252838,
-0.1121206283569336,
0.16864576935768127,
-0.017568837851285934,
0.05800584331154823,
0.8000971674919128,
0.04814670979976654,
0.8657625913619995,
0.6086774468421936,
0.09386519342660904,
-0.33498963713645935,
0.5129342675209045,
0.09399677067995071,
0.4026266038417816,
0.37841296195983887,
0.1716853827238083,
-0.4215203821659088,
-0.5202941298484802,
-0.6253084540367126,
0.3781532645225525,
-0.5224025845527649,
-0.07405564188957214,
-0.9447539448738098,
-0.05115042254328728,
-0.4025604724884033,
-0.11038301885128021,
-0.24897249042987823,
-0.45189183950424194,
-0.5148108005523682,
-0.049861837178468704,
0.15935203433036804,
0.28534218668937683,
0.19734057784080505,
0.49420785903930664,
-0.47269976139068604,
0.6118733882904053,
0.6056025624275208,
0.236021488904953,
0.05807121470570564,
-0.818228006362915,
-0.3431817293167114,
-0.29116418957710266,
-0.33112284541130066,
-0.49480655789375305,
0.5296125411987305,
0.3483685851097107,
0.6408463716506958,
0.29853665828704834,
-0.038713473826646805,
0.9232900142669678,
-0.514650285243988,
0.2588576674461365,
-0.15343116223812103,
-0.8584487438201904,
0.3495713174343109,
-0.1532343327999115,
0.6336564421653748,
0.37031447887420654,
0.14133484661579132,
-0.2868112027645111,
-0.725496232509613,
-0.4647327959537506,
-0.6632826924324036,
0.5168960094451904,
0.15981100499629974,
0.08135896176099777,
-0.21643002331256866,
0.5320559740066528,
-0.07943478226661682,
0.033318597823381424,
-0.5255276560783386,
-0.20054978132247925,
0.29137808084487915,
-0.2576087713241577,
-0.30906808376312256,
-0.3750699460506439,
0.16247773170471191,
-0.3897404074668884,
0.5719188451766968,
-0.3927111029624939,
-0.01424656342715025,
0.3078349530696869,
-0.40505582094192505,
-0.2752603590488434,
0.054623156785964966,
0.6442420482635498,
0.7621580362319946,
-0.018355712294578552,
0.24007119238376617,
0.5333667993545532,
-0.5053709745407104,
-0.2476932257413864,
0.2986033260822296,
-0.05970272049307823,
-0.11718971282243729,
0.1432100385427475,
0.8575990200042725,
0.31435057520866394,
-0.8001940846443176,
0.18429918587207794,
-0.13214607536792755,
0.10099168866872787,
-0.26081112027168274,
0.2795218229293823,
0.3810066282749176,
0.5290631055831909,
0.5793375372886658,
-0.1990652233362198,
0.19137363135814667,
-0.09864769876003265,
0.09644836187362671,
0.6380137801170349,
-0.022239170968532562,
-0.12968657910823822,
1.0513241291046143,
0.14585453271865845,
-0.08116140961647034,
0.4306875467300415,
-0.03539812192320824,
-0.19415603578090668,
0.9089306592941284,
0.6931166648864746,
0.9711875915527344,
-0.25832557678222656,
-0.10456161201000214,
0.35599032044410706,
0.3307974338531494,
-0.07825528085231781,
0.11623205244541168,
-0.2682954967021942,
-0.532932460308075,
-0.887363076210022,
-0.826861560344696,
-0.37343844771385193,
0.24254591763019562,
-0.39045923948287964,
0.07505615800619125,
-0.3394632637500763,
-0.07989578694105148,
0.3195916414260864,
0.05738396197557449,
-0.32425084710121155,
0.20471912622451782,
0.3030897378921509,
1.0229542255401611,
-0.8438923358917236,
0.8401048183441162,
0.3302493095397949,
0.11848531663417816,
-0.44970667362213135,
-0.2061261534690857,
-0.48978906869888306,
-0.820223331451416,
0.7845109105110168,
0.21989566087722778,
-0.1331668496131897,
0.27678045630455017,
-0.5121142864227295,
-0.7029515504837036,
0.7170284986495972,
0.7779122591018677,
-1.0168964862823486,
-0.01391899585723877,
-0.22155040502548218,
0.45967087149620056,
-0.5278211832046509,
0.20450785756111145,
0.7624000906944275,
0.402638703584671,
-0.029730800539255142,
-0.8557608127593994,
-0.08074476569890976,
-0.06271949410438538,
-0.010029636323451996,
0.3032893240451813,
-0.6280698180198669,
0.7354068756103516,
-0.559581458568573,
0.11757625639438629,
-0.17517045140266418,
0.9573253989219666,
0.2931150197982788,
0.2255377173423767,
0.6246482133865356,
0.8960348963737488,
0.5612382888793945,
0.1283465027809143,
0.9792039394378662,
-0.42449918389320374,
0.3671514093875885,
1.3099091053009033,
-0.010050715878605843,
0.884024441242218,
0.6603683829307556,
-0.04660486802458763,
0.08375033736228943,
0.7636181116104126,
-0.06065453588962555,
0.46334394812583923,
-0.09151407331228256,
-0.3987187445163727,
-0.7893358469009399,
0.11192990839481354,
-0.00535416416823864,
0.08479095250368118,
0.5831393003463745,
-0.42022672295570374,
-0.3648930788040161,
0.002207458019256592,
0.02045356296002865,
-0.13235341012477875,
-0.623580276966095,
0.5953863859176636,
0.20101332664489746,
-0.8549088835716248,
0.43888992071151733,
-0.13395515084266663,
0.5113344192504883,
-0.500347375869751,
0.10244801640510559,
-0.38695693016052246,
0.30755317211151123,
-0.04731554538011551,
-0.6781476140022278,
0.30521246790885925,
-0.03442097827792168,
-0.19576460123062134,
-0.15644705295562744,
0.5496686697006226,
-0.5361016392707825,
-0.5676345825195312,
0.11620059609413147,
0.44676685333251953,
0.04066525399684906,
-0.264920711517334,
-0.5010944604873657,
0.013094382360577583,
-0.09336452186107635,
-0.5258870720863342,
0.26810139417648315,
0.3229753077030182,
-0.1809282749891281,
0.9590872526168823,
0.6206279993057251,
0.11586412787437439,
0.191111758351326,
0.12008248269557953,
0.8980546593666077,
-0.5576226711273193,
-0.6312182545661926,
-1.1773847341537476,
0.04084159433841705,
-0.014899447560310364,
-0.40354111790657043,
0.7840486764907837,
0.8733779788017273,
0.6442703008651733,
-0.19298487901687622,
0.7294301390647888,
0.08190181851387024,
0.28150710463523865,
-0.5327617526054382,
0.5684229731559753,
-0.5471420288085938,
0.11814454197883606,
0.05372871458530426,
-0.6759337782859802,
-0.3408898413181305,
0.5485739707946777,
-0.5087934732437134,
-0.030058614909648895,
0.4542764127254486,
0.6755597591400146,
-0.3066830337047577,
-0.4003031253814697,
0.44967710971832275,
0.4307195842266083,
0.13682924211025238,
0.7523840069770813,
0.3502335846424103,
-0.014330754987895489,
0.5023090243339539,
-0.2399469017982483,
-0.08329352736473083,
-0.28818416595458984,
-0.9542669653892517,
-1.1598811149597168,
-0.26699817180633545,
-0.454809308052063,
-0.055127959698438644,
0.057198598980903625,
0.8138158321380615,
0.742302656173706,
-0.6171720027923584,
-0.1887495368719101,
-0.12039443105459213,
0.0877576395869255,
-0.16269181668758392,
-0.1741323173046112,
0.5020302534103394,
-0.7808936834335327,
-1.0289620161056519,
0.39341726899147034,
0.4261128604412079,
-0.004751766566187143,
-0.3043665587902069,
0.055715613067150116,
-0.191745787858963,
-0.06142577901482582,
0.7107447981834412,
0.4445612132549286,
-0.5806379914283752,
-0.09709135442972183,
0.12981387972831726,
-0.16738390922546387,
0.23319917917251587,
0.7039794325828552,
-0.9601349234580994,
0.377819687128067,
0.38461625576019287,
0.9776153564453125,
0.9884458184242249,
-0.05717982351779938,
0.3681740164756775,
-0.6246728897094727,
0.17554272711277008,
0.16650764644145966,
0.46595704555511475,
0.21431270241737366,
-0.42262518405914307,
0.47289928793907166,
0.20589420199394226,
-0.6262128353118896,
-0.7227073311805725,
0.09741351008415222,
-0.9928199052810669,
-0.30562931299209595,
1.2242354154586792,
-0.01568787917494774,
-0.5635837316513062,
-0.17334093153476715,
-0.21165229380130768,
0.195899099111557,
-0.3841695189476013,
0.9738390445709229,
0.4389382302761078,
-0.2145078033208847,
-0.3658877909183502,
-0.7810032367706299,
0.4529486894607544,
0.6986142992973328,
-0.925078809261322,
0.42528367042541504,
0.447931170463562,
0.4848616421222687,
-0.18134912848472595,
0.6198135018348694,
0.15390382707118988,
0.35400140285491943,
-0.38738781213760376,
-0.008909243158996105,
-0.2495322823524475,
-0.26705658435821533,
-0.3272269666194916,
0.04833312705159187,
-0.0376044437289238,
-0.09734360128641129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09329v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09329v2
|
Large Language Models are as persuasive as humans, but how? About the cognitive effort and moral-emotional language of LLM arguments
| 2024-04-14T19:01:20 | 2024-04-21T07:07:08 |
Carlos Carrasco-Farre
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are already as persuasive as humans. However, we
know very little about how they do it. This paper investigates the persuasion
strategies of LLMs, comparing them with human-generated arguments. Using a
dataset of 1,251 participants in an experiment, we analyze the persuasion
strategies of LLM-generated and human-generated arguments using measures of
cognitive effort (lexical and grammatical complexity) and moral-emotional
language (sentiment and moral analysis). The study reveals that LLMs produce
arguments that require higher cognitive effort, exhibiting more complex
grammatical and lexical structures than human counterparts. Additionally, LLMs
demonstrate a significant propensity to engage more deeply with moral language,
utilizing both positive and negative moral foundations more frequently than
humans. In contrast with previous research, no significant difference was found
in the emotional content produced by LLMs and humans. These findings contribute
to the discourse on AI and persuasion, highlighting the dual potential of LLMs
to both enhance and undermine informational integrity through communication
strategies for digital persuasion.
|
[
-0.43286365270614624,
-1.1530969142913818,
0.8677453398704529,
-0.002451542066410184,
-0.3355571925640106,
0.1708613634109497,
-0.7346388697624207,
-0.041993167251348495,
-0.11034294962882996,
0.3975604474544525,
-0.6055287718772888,
-0.5865378975868225,
-0.37730300426483154,
0.21166671812534332,
-0.08418339490890503,
0.9231935143470764,
0.20543299615383148,
0.2927560806274414,
-0.5334123373031616,
0.13363918662071228,
-0.16836707293987274,
-0.8658452033996582,
-0.7631754875183105,
-0.6222116351127625,
0.7435145974159241,
0.4090496003627777,
0.683301568031311,
0.43729114532470703,
0.3448430597782135,
0.37940266728401184,
-0.1814676970243454,
-0.09662394970655441,
-0.4982774257659912,
0.018372125923633575,
-0.3893117308616638,
-0.7218900918960571,
-0.21136698126792908,
0.1853327751159668,
0.27547985315322876,
0.24943706393241882,
-0.009821689687669277,
0.13939940929412842,
-0.12569403648376465,
0.7946378588676453,
-0.4947185516357422,
-0.01859922707080841,
-0.7038912177085876,
-0.042499009519815445,
-0.3709929287433624,
-0.3878095746040344,
-0.549759566783905,
-0.4930347204208374,
0.05459166690707207,
-0.3457850217819214,
-0.1884622573852539,
-0.03810702636837959,
0.7823584675788879,
0.1356816291809082,
-0.6210557222366333,
-0.8016856908798218,
-0.6973505020141602,
1.0902392864227295,
-0.8493074774742126,
0.04032563045620918,
0.3605085611343384,
-0.20952433347702026,
-0.09625464677810669,
-0.35623791813850403,
-0.7274550199508667,
-0.5814480781555176,
0.25544533133506775,
0.11250930279493332,
-0.30044278502464294,
0.13505026698112488,
0.18713697791099548,
-0.10196369141340256,
-0.2854750454425812,
0.4771591126918793,
-0.11848729103803635,
-0.048063814640045166,
1.0156948566436768,
0.24936696887016296,
0.356723427772522,
-0.3943726420402527,
-0.21775192022323608,
-0.4997757375240326,
-0.7953408360481262,
0.19127662479877472,
0.6544371843338013,
-0.06540745496749878,
-0.15643317997455597,
0.7709904313087463,
0.26505082845687866,
0.3359805941581726,
0.29915568232536316,
-0.132023423910141,
-0.33854469656944275,
-0.22879986464977264,
-0.2572266161441803,
0.15588735044002533,
1.1133217811584473,
0.4481777846813202,
0.7513604164123535,
0.30465707182884216,
-0.17912158370018005,
0.3858337104320526,
0.3369607925415039,
-0.5976172685623169,
-0.01640787161886692,
0.2180578112602234,
-0.638767421245575,
-0.48241719603538513,
-0.06279316544532776,
-0.5889047384262085,
-0.646525502204895,
-0.21342678368091583,
0.2693271040916443,
-0.39146187901496887,
-0.10770037770271301,
0.35518598556518555,
-0.00946833472698927,
0.3577958643436432,
0.3396866023540497,
-0.7799464464187622,
0.22077231109142303,
0.8820510506629944,
0.4099002182483673,
-0.13794171810150146,
0.1835462898015976,
-0.2573672831058502,
0.0573568232357502,
-0.7418103218078613,
0.7704033851623535,
-0.7017645239830017,
-0.4655560553073883,
-0.007563058286905289,
-0.2111044079065323,
0.18947625160217285,
-0.5457989573478699,
0.9751468300819397,
-0.4186857342720032,
0.18480128049850464,
-0.502515435218811,
-0.5363982319831848,
-0.3972671329975128,
0.3248307406902313,
-0.3742249011993408,
0.38082975149154663,
-0.3998282253742218,
-0.39981234073638916,
0.14379346370697021,
-0.8882355690002441,
-0.5497450232505798,
-0.08864493668079376,
-0.33805960416793823,
-0.10892227292060852,
0.3635833263397217,
0.14068229496479034,
0.672930121421814,
-0.751876175403595,
0.41740360856056213,
-0.2804807722568512,
0.0434790775179863,
0.8268013596534729,
-0.7153138518333435,
0.6836043000221252,
0.18590833246707916,
-0.6207206845283508,
0.049631863832473755,
-0.2582404315471649,
-0.17434240877628326,
0.627684473991394,
-0.7018679976463318,
-0.5603456497192383,
0.5256263017654419,
-0.2957583963871002,
0.1612035185098648,
0.3202071189880371,
-0.5431842803955078,
0.14265182614326477,
-0.32720035314559937,
0.7162489295005798,
1.0274906158447266,
-0.22429844737052917,
0.23403604328632355,
-0.24265922605991364,
0.4842728078365326,
-0.1771758496761322,
0.043266940861940384,
0.13353540003299713,
-0.31495359539985657,
-0.760103702545166,
-0.017989719286561012,
-0.3052445650100708,
0.40367209911346436,
-0.2694563567638397,
0.11899377405643463,
-0.21746087074279785,
-0.48567667603492737,
-0.2805725634098053,
0.0580805204808712,
0.4697493314743042,
0.20434513688087463,
0.06547938287258148,
0.1523026078939438,
-0.23947091400623322,
-0.9387004971504211,
-0.42729508876800537,
-0.6199331283569336,
0.053270675241947174,
0.5140049457550049,
0.3557285666465759,
-0.05278097838163376,
0.5801993608474731,
-0.2325076162815094,
0.2147788107395172,
-0.25156059861183167,
0.16886143386363983,
0.09750784933567047,
0.0024723936803638935,
0.5097922682762146,
-0.8102683424949646,
-0.33037567138671875,
-0.11077626049518585,
-0.9671939015388489,
-0.048290904611349106,
-0.2902584969997406,
0.1187450960278511,
0.3277202844619751,
0.43225136399269104,
-0.6508070826530457,
0.20772720873355865,
0.42892587184906006,
-0.4267565608024597,
0.557077169418335,
0.026429250836372375,
0.2557874023914337,
-0.8321546912193298,
-0.549595832824707,
0.2304316759109497,
0.007801144849509001,
-0.5867819786071777,
0.02724420838057995,
-0.1996726542711258,
0.004746495746076107,
-0.6540576219558716,
0.48832225799560547,
-0.45821958780288696,
0.3568437099456787,
-0.14700034260749817,
0.20801852643489838,
-0.0450335294008255,
0.17326711118221283,
0.11127343773841858,
0.5695942640304565,
0.4499131143093109,
-0.6627920866012573,
0.5831831693649292,
0.03356032073497772,
-0.13834118843078613,
0.7866458296775818,
-0.908859133720398,
0.2733975052833557,
-0.18332195281982422,
0.2949812710285187,
-1.029592752456665,
-0.13272160291671753,
-0.03390437364578247,
-0.29742634296417236,
0.1896262764930725,
0.09034167975187302,
-0.30083027482032776,
-0.5063043832778931,
-0.4510815441608429,
0.1319870501756668,
0.47362539172172546,
-0.3197357952594757,
0.6812252998352051,
0.2494271993637085,
-0.37798213958740234,
-0.3059473931789398,
-0.781447172164917,
0.6116079092025757,
-0.5903898477554321,
-0.9608737230300903,
0.30475568771362305,
-0.15639129281044006,
-0.9564033150672913,
-0.2158576399087906,
0.33440354466438293,
0.41568925976753235,
0.14380449056625366,
0.41701093316078186,
0.24324190616607666,
-0.29994064569473267,
0.3887680470943451,
-0.23512162268161774,
0.0844506323337555,
0.4220520555973053,
-0.06624512374401093,
0.8426174521446228,
-0.4378432035446167,
-0.5755085945129395,
-0.6160901188850403,
0.43899041414260864,
0.6999941468238831,
-0.028791066259145737,
0.6804230809211731,
0.222406268119812,
-0.06590181589126587,
0.24276092648506165,
-0.9217414855957031,
-0.49191227555274963,
-0.4996762275695801,
0.41214051842689514,
-0.24669145047664642,
-0.8149405121803284,
-0.1513477861881256,
-0.28469574451446533,
0.38407963514328003,
0.49316948652267456,
0.7862054705619812,
-0.4391781687736511,
1.1397731304168701,
0.18060420453548431,
-0.08856531232595444,
0.3596266508102417,
-0.19778592884540558,
0.11149968206882477,
-0.611579418182373,
-0.11891666054725647,
-0.5512605905532837,
-0.3174467086791992,
-0.38563910126686096,
-0.3299897611141205,
0.18035529553890228,
0.13472367823123932,
-0.6520998477935791,
-0.047832589596509933,
-0.5142207741737366,
0.16652736067771912,
0.4839828610420227,
-0.20367860794067383,
0.30070269107818604,
0.42619797587394714,
0.014134435914456844,
-0.24090656638145447,
-0.5640978217124939,
-1.151082992553711,
1.0170557498931885,
0.4107886552810669,
0.9528709650039673,
0.27877873182296753,
0.584505021572113,
0.4736720323562622,
0.2952467203140259,
-0.973130464553833,
0.9590100646018982,
-0.34665748476982117,
-0.41118013858795166,
-0.16657395660877228,
-0.3736821413040161,
-1.1004945039749146,
-0.08575886487960815,
-0.6354519724845886,
-0.6841854453086853,
0.05331885442137718,
-0.08955100178718567,
0.057782888412475586,
0.5308098793029785,
-0.5608909726142883,
0.4357057511806488,
-0.7693272233009338,
-0.29417023062705994,
-0.7607302069664001,
-0.21550801396369934,
0.19988423585891724,
-0.13354137539863586,
0.403547465801239,
-0.12936489284038544,
-0.1558775007724762,
0.8960393667221069,
-0.27085310220718384,
0.8380387425422668,
0.10380767285823822,
-0.5081307888031006,
0.41826823353767395,
0.0781344473361969,
0.7287399768829346,
-0.07998163253068924,
-0.3586234748363495,
0.20891013741493225,
-0.49148672819137573,
-0.12720541656017303,
-0.2953779995441437,
0.6123785376548767,
-0.7890110611915588,
-1.002637267112732,
-0.09423120319843292,
-0.4184342324733734,
0.03139621019363403,
-0.14235608279705048,
0.2619531452655792,
0.3983638286590576,
-0.5263678431510925,
0.4672671854496002,
0.6121209263801575,
-0.7092328071594238,
0.7267910242080688,
0.4181748628616333,
0.18704915046691895,
-0.4991394877433777,
1.0184434652328491,
-0.16912215948104858,
0.497927188873291,
0.3460347056388855,
0.6922513842582703,
-0.5187695026397705,
-0.30334874987602234,
-0.3286422789096832,
0.5672851204872131,
-0.6170461177825928,
0.17563115060329437,
-0.6330782771110535,
0.1282576620578766,
-0.38868439197540283,
-0.6593383550643921,
-0.4937623143196106,
-0.16163106262683868,
-0.3139854669570923,
0.07380086183547974,
0.45600515604019165,
1.0456197261810303,
0.0820617750287056,
0.1525491625070572,
-0.7179067730903625,
0.22141212224960327,
0.5221666693687439,
-0.28297045826911926,
0.030610697343945503,
-0.17603325843811035,
0.2748728096485138,
0.3423320949077606,
-0.41229110956192017,
-0.7801614999771118,
0.13489896059036255,
-0.11969226598739624,
0.341376394033432,
0.6935544610023499,
0.2574111819267273,
0.5345780253410339,
-0.18361389636993408,
1.030326008796692,
0.4433973431587219,
-0.9112377166748047,
0.2611907422542572,
-0.3230898082256317,
0.05104765295982361,
0.09219525009393692,
0.4173811078071594,
-0.3277449309825897,
-0.22730287909507751,
-0.5709714293479919,
-0.8077490329742432,
0.4836122691631317,
0.10353150963783264,
0.47322148084640503,
-0.18963953852653503,
0.13297566771507263,
-0.24349075555801392,
0.2169804722070694,
-0.8948096632957458,
-0.0861605852842331,
0.02682436630129814,
-0.314937949180603,
-0.06398821622133255,
-0.35779863595962524,
-0.43650180101394653,
0.09942743182182312,
0.4470857083797455,
-0.0013575893826782703,
0.03868050128221512,
0.1996408849954605,
0.08491893857717514,
-0.11260982602834702,
0.45713964104652405,
0.6424868702888489,
0.20778585970401764,
0.27425915002822876,
0.0390174463391304,
-0.02392791397869587,
-0.3443879783153534,
0.5017154812812805,
-0.3012523353099823,
-0.10533268004655838,
-0.41686907410621643,
0.6997655630111694,
0.8717116117477417,
-0.14270444214344025,
-0.7909238934516907,
0.4090672731399536,
-0.30994755029678345,
-0.47951745986938477,
-0.32136309146881104,
0.003926899749785662,
0.804583728313446,
0.5130435824394226,
0.30082178115844727,
-0.44333356618881226,
-0.4579107463359833,
-0.8963454365730286,
-0.5390185713768005,
0.8161358833312988,
-0.14129509031772614,
-0.13382506370544434,
0.6562272906303406,
0.3605514168739319,
-0.6664469242095947,
0.5280994176864624,
0.13191848993301392,
-0.3801368176937103,
0.6197180151939392,
0.46723198890686035,
0.6499184966087341,
0.006901861634105444,
0.3403531610965729,
0.09584010392427444,
0.15702582895755768,
0.0021732200402766466,
0.12944528460502625,
-0.015562086366117,
-0.6951863169670105,
-0.28880226612091064,
-0.3337613642215729,
-0.26940542459487915,
0.11461301892995834,
-0.2737460732460022,
0.16186179220676422,
-0.6148274540901184,
-0.42689013481140137,
0.10441003739833832,
0.09415321052074432,
-0.38360267877578735,
0.21463699638843536,
0.30084922909736633,
0.49559152126312256,
-0.43283864855766296,
0.24706274271011353,
0.9535963535308838,
-0.27612629532814026,
-0.7574728727340698,
0.1050671711564064,
0.21904394030570984,
-0.5756733417510986,
0.6418715715408325,
-0.0032286124769598246,
-0.4314635694026947,
-0.10293825715780258,
-0.9197202920913696,
-0.5395920872688293,
0.7035529017448425,
0.6947111487388611,
-0.6573851704597473,
0.048965007066726685,
0.15212243795394897,
0.4067953824996948,
-0.463039368391037,
0.051101043820381165,
0.11269781738519669,
0.8526617288589478,
-0.09218977391719818,
-0.4128704369068146,
0.21388208866119385,
-0.06659238040447235,
-0.17785672843456268,
-0.04392791911959648,
-0.8083594441413879,
0.7780941128730774,
-0.5432291030883789,
-0.4726773202419281,
-0.058547958731651306,
0.7066221833229065,
0.3350839614868164,
0.2800733149051666,
0.7699800133705139,
0.10065114498138428,
0.719731867313385,
0.045442644506692886,
1.2104264497756958,
-0.12125464528799057,
-0.13084053993225098,
0.551878809928894,
-0.40532511472702026,
0.7123552560806274,
0.4094852805137634,
-0.10292918980121613,
0.663565456867218,
0.5600355267524719,
0.04397742822766304,
-0.1125100776553154,
0.5375334620475769,
-0.33033287525177,
-0.6978104710578918,
-0.3161817789077759,
-0.07586781680583954,
0.5216467380523682,
0.5096776485443115,
-0.12928138673305511,
0.22451160848140717,
-0.031132597476243973,
0.4572925269603729,
0.4037781059741974,
-0.13487203419208527,
1.0533199310302734,
0.2900434732437134,
-0.8545422554016113,
0.7309513092041016,
0.16057415306568146,
0.7910351753234863,
-0.5591762661933899,
0.2039509117603302,
0.13510294258594513,
-0.0474434420466423,
-0.21352048218250275,
-1.0041048526763916,
-0.10004298388957977,
0.3103988766670227,
-0.01618330180644989,
-0.0107472725212574,
0.6884489059448242,
-0.09195388108491898,
-0.32826778292655945,
0.4408276677131653,
0.3757948577404022,
0.21759861707687378,
-0.00322433328256011,
-0.7331976890563965,
-0.08071349561214447,
0.11734218150377274,
-0.5122748017311096,
0.2753296196460724,
0.32084113359451294,
-0.23185531795024872,
1.0056374073028564,
1.0263326168060303,
0.21889837086200714,
-0.28920960426330566,
0.18845120072364807,
0.7672007083892822,
-0.9082658290863037,
0.06979561597108841,
-1.3959163427352905,
0.3288361430168152,
-0.23404139280319214,
-0.027517400681972504,
0.5810723900794983,
0.16292352974414825,
0.49418824911117554,
-0.03785890340805054,
0.7381011843681335,
0.06613238900899887,
-0.2348657101392746,
-0.5598371028900146,
0.4840535521507263,
-0.6737791895866394,
0.26348480582237244,
-0.47501498460769653,
-0.8260572552680969,
0.17842836678028107,
0.6042000651359558,
-0.2797413766384125,
0.10258365422487259,
0.5392454266548157,
0.7242682576179504,
0.2845146656036377,
0.13218006491661072,
0.20333819091320038,
0.5190621614456177,
0.6098339557647705,
0.7284637093544006,
1.1992868185043335,
0.2648314833641052,
0.5355799794197083,
0.19542916119098663,
-0.17881512641906738,
-0.08771950751543045,
-1.1123428344726562,
-1.1033574342727661,
-0.2564365565776825,
-0.31169334053993225,
-0.17468902468681335,
0.024959588423371315,
1.0780881643295288,
0.5713735818862915,
-0.26162517070770264,
-0.46775317192077637,
-0.06313280016183853,
0.16531294584274292,
0.08615870028734207,
-0.20645664632320404,
0.3070125877857208,
0.11098095774650574,
-0.8577325344085693,
0.4679567217826843,
0.4623016119003296,
-0.051557037979364395,
-0.5523228049278259,
-0.24484802782535553,
-0.3333853483200073,
0.7529590129852295,
0.7683227062225342,
0.06645788997411728,
-1.0939399003982544,
-0.1565188616514206,
-0.09041588008403778,
-0.2659868597984314,
0.036858707666397095,
0.7977263927459717,
-0.43772080540657043,
0.12810689210891724,
0.5247122049331665,
0.4033791422843933,
0.11541387438774109,
0.1572357565164566,
0.7686347961425781,
-0.061590857803821564,
-0.11631543189287186,
0.2129349410533905,
0.3166816532611847,
0.44414302706718445,
-0.33836573362350464,
0.3368719816207886,
0.14231106638908386,
-0.5762158036231995,
-0.4275091290473938,
0.23997679352760315,
-0.768006443977356,
-0.48865896463394165,
1.5298311710357666,
0.050053395330905914,
-0.22514978051185608,
-0.004990768618881702,
-0.5329460501670837,
0.0820828527212143,
-0.5952876806259155,
0.6509493589401245,
0.919338583946228,
0.009654941037297249,
0.18331633508205414,
-0.31670475006103516,
0.2217608392238617,
0.5976142883300781,
-0.8273380398750305,
0.28222137689590454,
0.5336824059486389,
0.07294297963380814,
0.18565337359905243,
0.5674923658370972,
-0.22705034911632538,
-0.09322936832904816,
-0.22395610809326172,
0.033581770956516266,
0.044076159596443176,
-0.09881781786680222,
-0.1783747375011444,
0.1963266134262085,
0.11127980053424835,
0.3640003502368927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09299v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09299v1
|
Reap the Wild Wind: Detecting Media Storms in Large-Scale News Corpora
| 2024-04-14T16:47:38 | 2024-04-14T16:47:38 |
Dror K. Markus, Effi Levi, Tamir Sheafer, Shaul R. Shenhav
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Media Storms, dramatic outbursts of attention to a story, are central
components of media dynamics and the attention landscape. Despite their
significance, there has been little systematic and empirical research on this
concept due to issues of measurement and operationalization. We introduce an
iterative human-in-the-loop method to identify media storms in a large-scale
corpus of news articles. The text is first transformed into signals of
dispersion based on several textual characteristics. In each iteration, we
apply unsupervised anomaly detection to these signals; each anomaly is then
validated by an expert to confirm the presence of a storm, and those results
are then used to tune the anomaly detection in the next iteration. We
demonstrate the applicability of this method in two scenarios: first,
supplementing an initial list of media storms within a specific time frame; and
second, detecting media storms in new time periods. We make available a media
storm dataset compiled using both scenarios. Both the method and dataset offer
the basis for comprehensive empirical research into the concept of media
storms, including characterizing them and predicting their outbursts and
durations, in mainstream media or social media platforms.
|
[
-0.5976089835166931,
-1.0076972246170044,
0.48381277918815613,
0.7182440161705017,
-0.47938045859336853,
0.625592827796936,
-0.2707321345806122,
-0.07508289813995361,
0.6817468404769897,
0.4011761546134949,
-0.8368218541145325,
-0.47620487213134766,
-0.8455756306648254,
-0.04039689898490906,
-0.952127993106842,
0.8591237664222717,
-0.08244387805461884,
-0.63580721616745,
0.43287310004234314,
0.16279886662960052,
-0.19332852959632874,
-0.2729075849056244,
-0.1436418741941452,
0.23439845442771912,
0.7079588174819946,
0.2581017017364502,
0.7231980562210083,
0.3639998137950897,
0.8603198528289795,
0.29280951619148254,
-0.3108454644680023,
0.4637475609779358,
-0.49428123235702515,
0.18593771755695343,
-0.4216543436050415,
0.07177876681089401,
0.15710507333278656,
0.13851076364517212,
0.8225346207618713,
0.4832315742969513,
-0.2705196440219879,
0.3707447946071625,
0.05346057191491127,
0.5223769545555115,
-0.7213587760925293,
-0.4420521855354309,
-0.8658649921417236,
0.13464993238449097,
-0.6938560605049133,
-0.9684146046638489,
-0.25569936633110046,
0.0837462916970253,
-0.009030030108988285,
-0.3877505362033844,
0.5704792737960815,
0.17645159363746643,
0.9859417080879211,
0.2698400914669037,
-0.6877525448799133,
-0.37582263350486755,
-1.0733935832977295,
0.730564534664154,
-0.06325940787792206,
0.36690324544906616,
0.16683228313922882,
0.26981714367866516,
-0.566146194934845,
-0.45910945534706116,
-0.5240296721458435,
0.07058621197938919,
0.30917102098464966,
0.19454780220985413,
-0.895081639289856,
-0.3751404881477356,
-0.009465483948588371,
0.49303150177001953,
-0.5427212119102478,
0.15831463038921356,
-0.6536041498184204,
-0.11765198409557343,
0.6591334342956543,
0.2928087115287781,
0.012219447642564774,
-0.32309138774871826,
-0.4054776728153229,
0.02502443641424179,
-0.3826630413532257,
-0.04478265717625618,
0.4832738935947418,
0.05086957663297653,
-0.2595275640487671,
0.36361998319625854,
0.09860232472419739,
0.4423353374004364,
0.06638433039188385,
-0.504767894744873,
0.1720258891582489,
-0.22485288977622986,
-0.1802240014076233,
0.1519000381231308,
0.9074356555938721,
0.45467180013656616,
-0.24651266634464264,
-0.035516783595085144,
-0.31928640604019165,
-0.08360756933689117,
0.4176064133644104,
-0.3978703022003174,
0.04716305434703827,
0.08950600028038025,
-0.5122837424278259,
-0.8751521706581116,
0.03994010016322136,
-1.1776716709136963,
-0.7885722517967224,
-0.24597680568695068,
0.3190583288669586,
0.1471778154373169,
-0.6212258338928223,
-0.04818545654416084,
-0.4835658371448517,
-0.32577913999557495,
-0.017815086990594864,
-0.4491899311542511,
-0.11799775809049606,
0.44894838333129883,
1.0669710636138916,
-0.1197621300816536,
-0.36515888571739197,
-0.4527435302734375,
-0.12671157717704773,
-0.5233278274536133,
1.3437244892120361,
-0.4198552966117859,
-0.18402481079101562,
0.2615453600883484,
0.13598720729351044,
-0.003459276631474495,
-0.35858067870140076,
0.7272351980209351,
-0.7488267421722412,
-0.11025533825159073,
0.12655651569366455,
-0.19471876323223114,
-0.16203801333904266,
0.23731522262096405,
-0.6875110268592834,
0.5843175053596497,
0.24443261325359344,
-1.0335007905960083,
0.4650444984436035,
-0.29448774456977844,
-0.5078448057174683,
-0.2855721414089203,
0.24162255227565765,
-0.5682951807975769,
0.5330842137336731,
0.41332685947418213,
0.25313907861709595,
-0.4837092459201813,
0.3288850486278534,
-0.4340057969093323,
-0.15652261674404144,
0.2103177160024643,
-0.7340052723884583,
0.6766687631607056,
0.6300882697105408,
-0.31925612688064575,
0.06171008571982384,
-0.7662028670310974,
-0.35227614641189575,
0.09443602710962296,
-0.19804070889949799,
-0.3062380254268646,
-0.026415638625621796,
0.2991684079170227,
-0.02888655848801136,
-0.505638062953949,
-0.19245921075344086,
0.29077476263046265,
0.13127033412456512,
0.5176528096199036,
0.4715415835380554,
0.6775073409080505,
0.3793562054634094,
-0.048423368483781815,
0.4920993447303772,
0.5508929491043091,
0.1485145092010498,
-0.5463160872459412,
0.029509762302041054,
-0.22861313819885254,
-0.3844485282897949,
0.20631705224514008,
0.4735186994075775,
-0.690331757068634,
0.31015723943710327,
-0.03975905105471611,
-0.7184102535247803,
-0.34754127264022827,
0.323733925819397,
-0.20515865087509155,
0.0573020875453949,
0.03827085345983505,
0.10248623043298721,
-0.9414480328559875,
-0.4535749852657318,
-0.49398306012153625,
0.13890308141708374,
0.047018665820360184,
-0.23669299483299255,
0.2262471616268158,
-0.5333606600761414,
1.075856328010559,
-0.41440317034721375,
-0.5040411353111267,
-0.15736481547355652,
0.7706485986709595,
0.3795476257801056,
-0.1364225596189499,
0.4148842394351959,
-0.9829161763191223,
0.06504420191049576,
-0.19186587631702423,
-0.8591668009757996,
-0.4356788694858551,
-0.4761451184749603,
0.294315904378891,
0.029112113639712334,
0.7745324373245239,
-0.1253225952386856,
0.3865199089050293,
0.6288287043571472,
-0.4500318765640259,
0.6614269018173218,
-0.010155733674764633,
0.29671257734298706,
-0.7732204794883728,
-0.20917850732803345,
0.3116040527820587,
0.025859300047159195,
-0.4694425165653229,
-0.32781413197517395,
-0.12761034071445465,
0.00923169869929552,
-0.17657417058944702,
0.15269774198532104,
-0.4424314498901367,
-0.17719803750514984,
-0.6019983887672424,
0.256526380777359,
0.15611618757247925,
-0.06028815358877182,
0.005223837215453386,
0.2046370804309845,
0.6021818518638611,
-0.4327007234096527,
0.5276023745536804,
-0.253214031457901,
-0.5852909684181213,
0.5071446299552917,
-0.2905852198600769,
-0.06332021206617355,
-0.5395216941833496,
0.41965624690055847,
-0.7367373704910278,
-0.2715819776058197,
0.06242384761571884,
-0.3454253077507019,
-0.030500637367367744,
-0.005834441632032394,
-0.6951166391372681,
-0.7618891596794128,
-0.23654240369796753,
-0.044080834835767746,
0.14325889945030212,
-0.7724202275276184,
0.49721550941467285,
0.6275752782821655,
0.08768197149038315,
-0.24365314841270447,
-0.23934167623519897,
0.3515392541885376,
-0.5778989195823669,
-0.6264829635620117,
0.2718959450721741,
0.30698490142822266,
-0.6479117274284363,
0.02587328851222992,
-0.19522926211357117,
-0.18823443353176117,
0.32792022824287415,
0.291589617729187,
-0.01662406697869301,
-0.31833046674728394,
0.08274975419044495,
0.05009347200393677,
0.11944734305143356,
0.21723607182502747,
-0.2507374882698059,
0.3553272783756256,
-0.01263368409126997,
-0.017606258392333984,
-0.4072209894657135,
0.6383566856384277,
0.8737270832061768,
-0.3004598021507263,
0.31580623984336853,
0.8474579453468323,
-0.3629212975502014,
-0.14579299092292786,
-0.5193206667900085,
-0.25468701124191284,
-0.4377695918083191,
0.3427082300186157,
-0.0667063519358635,
-0.16182301938533783,
0.6196455359458923,
-0.3157220184803009,
0.1654113382101059,
0.4640677869319916,
0.38639727234840393,
-0.1939679980278015,
0.9446499943733215,
0.7269179821014404,
-0.3456597626209259,
0.5654172301292419,
-0.3150389492511749,
0.058057814836502075,
-0.6068057417869568,
-0.09815192967653275,
-0.38224050402641296,
-0.4483737647533417,
-0.4291021525859833,
-0.09830083698034286,
0.30080029368400574,
0.279307097196579,
-0.060199759900569916,
0.0802445113658905,
-0.43055063486099243,
0.5133326053619385,
0.245218887925148,
-0.20305094122886658,
0.5205997228622437,
0.24535180628299713,
0.31595948338508606,
-0.01494794711470604,
-0.39654576778411865,
-0.3005932569503784,
0.7894532680511475,
0.4594052731990814,
0.8341684341430664,
0.08299384266138077,
0.561276376247406,
0.7786133289337158,
0.6754184365272522,
-0.6306750178337097,
-0.08537134528160095,
0.1427750438451767,
-0.63970547914505,
-0.15635226666927338,
-0.2154204249382019,
-1.040244460105896,
0.3891903758049011,
-0.2948172092437744,
-0.7081629037857056,
0.438375860452652,
0.006333912257105112,
-0.4408096373081207,
0.2379741370677948,
-0.46483954787254333,
0.4854781925678253,
-0.22816430032253265,
-0.11118277907371521,
-0.3210054636001587,
-0.393343061208725,
0.5316395163536072,
-0.28759250044822693,
0.9049259424209595,
-0.034827589988708496,
0.06383655220270157,
0.6172769069671631,
-0.08978503942489624,
0.7896589040756226,
0.10196274518966675,
-0.2384137064218521,
0.8246377110481262,
-0.08190786093473434,
0.6044504642486572,
0.1660154163837433,
0.5131088495254517,
-0.07317470014095306,
-0.21109449863433838,
-0.21709896624088287,
-0.4064764678478241,
0.5635039806365967,
-0.8107678890228271,
-0.3633511960506439,
-0.49616575241088867,
-0.554479718208313,
0.006464194972068071,
0.05844941362738609,
0.5871778726577759,
0.530015766620636,
-0.06500249356031418,
0.08300745487213135,
0.43279555439949036,
0.3047426640987396,
0.771070122718811,
0.7789219617843628,
-0.55594801902771,
-0.5125464200973511,
0.9211720824241638,
0.38349032402038574,
-0.14038719236850739,
0.06476574391126633,
0.2692658007144928,
0.13722437620162964,
-0.440546452999115,
-0.4578219950199127,
-0.02797219343483448,
-0.5851885676383972,
-0.31916970014572144,
-0.7642831206321716,
-0.06552085280418396,
0.01083096582442522,
-0.06389328092336655,
-0.2529968023300171,
0.2817562222480774,
-0.27526357769966125,
0.0344284251332283,
0.24154360592365265,
0.5727081894874573,
-0.19292838871479034,
0.6071202158927917,
-0.8893090486526489,
0.21735015511512756,
-0.1400076001882553,
-0.08273759484291077,
-0.14903806149959564,
-0.8143135905265808,
-0.004385418724268675,
-0.1898418813943863,
-0.9434792995452881,
-1.1302645206451416,
0.6920255422592163,
0.09705092757940292,
0.21542933583259583,
0.9761744141578674,
0.10874130576848984,
0.6406177282333374,
-0.3606756627559662,
0.4660535752773285,
0.20486748218536377,
-0.6985256671905518,
0.645148515701294,
-0.7252306342124939,
0.18973585963249207,
0.2717362344264984,
0.49149778485298157,
-0.4244856536388397,
-0.7132822871208191,
-0.9569357633590698,
-0.6697156429290771,
0.2124389410018921,
0.010769237764179707,
0.10776180773973465,
-0.0695100948214531,
-0.3323104679584503,
-0.0813235342502594,
0.2579345107078552,
-0.17998848855495453,
0.123703233897686,
-0.28759950399398804,
0.27481648325920105,
-0.16297180950641632,
-0.10070312023162842,
-0.17135025560855865,
-0.09907925128936768,
0.2414756715297699,
-0.013030803762376308,
0.011778512969613075,
0.4438723027706146,
-0.1031804233789444,
-0.44524675607681274,
0.31142759323120117,
0.8491541147232056,
0.5936958193778992,
-0.37984731793403625,
0.6304388046264648,
-0.17085625231266022,
-0.7131094932556152,
-0.12051165848970413,
0.12537875771522522,
0.11765968054533005,
0.7092288732528687,
0.5601998567581177,
0.5058115124702454,
0.6309775710105896,
-0.7722132802009583,
0.46828052401542664,
0.1688704639673233,
-0.2677520215511322,
-0.6874696612358093,
-0.5385072231292725,
-0.0733996257185936,
0.47490787506103516,
0.9327305555343628,
0.07741938531398773,
0.3568105101585388,
-1.1041754484176636,
0.20815543830394745,
0.140329971909523,
-0.3043558895587921,
-0.4299578368663788,
0.41031861305236816,
0.16613250970840454,
-0.22988909482955933,
0.5276163220405579,
-0.3795817792415619,
-0.5440534949302673,
0.8619885444641113,
0.7776526212692261,
0.6786976456642151,
-0.09354732930660248,
0.2802576422691345,
0.003288974054157734,
0.59937983751297,
-0.16440947353839874,
0.10887763649225235,
0.23536163568496704,
-0.645035982131958,
-0.2869967222213745,
-0.5149334073066711,
-0.10408325493335724,
0.5680583119392395,
-0.6180577278137207,
0.5200404524803162,
-0.202057883143425,
-0.35550355911254883,
0.7009136080741882,
-0.14872322976589203,
-0.5379801988601685,
-0.0827694907784462,
0.4347325265407562,
1.133466124534607,
-1.2852641344070435,
0.3664434850215912,
0.5506071448326111,
-0.18377074599266052,
-0.7127915620803833,
0.286908894777298,
0.5600014328956604,
-0.3062551021575928,
0.31689026951789856,
0.13556745648384094,
0.2440776526927948,
-0.03913619741797447,
-0.4420780539512634,
-0.869683563709259,
0.948552668094635,
-0.008309266529977322,
-0.9387729167938232,
0.17545385658740997,
-0.28602084517478943,
0.41255733370780945,
-0.4182802140712738,
0.28035053610801697,
0.821884036064148,
0.7220239639282227,
0.24156597256660461,
-0.7847664952278137,
-0.4078923761844635,
-0.04089741408824921,
-0.44550594687461853,
0.46498534083366394,
-0.5660091638565063,
0.3728494346141815,
-0.5580688118934631,
-0.23397113382816315,
-0.44991573691368103,
0.8417935371398926,
0.025741945952177048,
1.1489613056182861,
0.8082762956619263,
0.07391015440225601,
0.9528586864471436,
0.0005028989398851991,
1.077778697013855,
-0.10512637346982956,
0.48027175664901733,
0.6526386141777039,
0.0490914061665535,
0.47335392236709595,
0.5294241309165955,
-0.03065669909119606,
0.5013530850410461,
0.8529604077339172,
-0.21052509546279907,
0.7757049202919006,
0.1692153513431549,
-0.23231181502342224,
-0.20133353769779205,
-0.25810882449150085,
-0.14684215188026428,
0.5619351863861084,
0.5240287184715271,
-0.46719110012054443,
-0.5292035341262817,
0.5902274250984192,
0.36668887734413147,
0.11610004305839539,
-0.7265030145645142,
0.4934476315975189,
0.0890171080827713,
-0.6558792591094971,
0.7086092829704285,
-0.05648956075310707,
0.6614262461662292,
-0.20844078063964844,
0.35158130526542664,
-0.17299358546733856,
0.304146409034729,
-0.4182969331741333,
-0.800303041934967,
0.7299983501434326,
0.14262190461158752,
-0.5990927815437317,
0.06861383467912674,
0.592953622341156,
-0.1945497691631317,
-0.5749456286430359,
0.1122988909482956,
0.38180631399154663,
0.22046658396720886,
-0.4011436104774475,
-0.14622512459754944,
0.5790947079658508,
-0.25872600078582764,
-0.5410165190696716,
0.2191670686006546,
0.631420910358429,
-0.40307295322418213,
0.3804921805858612,
0.4904657006263733,
-0.07737556844949722,
-0.03805837035179138,
0.19588227570056915,
0.879399299621582,
-0.6906402707099915,
-0.46284571290016174,
-0.9358580112457275,
0.17545858025550842,
-0.3780891001224518,
-0.6018201112747192,
0.5247913002967834,
0.45694267749786377,
0.14615848660469055,
-0.0024801844265311956,
0.7382199168205261,
-0.1179436519742012,
0.23336851596832275,
-0.11353184282779694,
0.5419545769691467,
-0.26001155376434326,
0.23981840908527374,
-0.2782090902328491,
-0.6713046431541443,
-0.19457527995109558,
0.06416613608598709,
-0.3035845458507538,
-0.7080535888671875,
0.7877853512763977,
0.6779675483703613,
0.06365039944648743,
0.41118237376213074,
-0.11376228928565979,
0.10555340349674225,
0.2514532506465912,
0.05076303705573082,
1.136566400527954,
-0.0034061805345118046,
0.7496809959411621,
-0.11030961573123932,
-0.6439310312271118,
-0.4977876842021942,
-1.039185643196106,
-0.8107144236564636,
-0.8011376857757568,
-0.24135445058345795,
-0.42221540212631226,
0.1852678656578064,
0.8356335759162903,
0.5081741809844971,
-0.4013625681400299,
0.24203160405158997,
0.054692335426807404,
0.5076271891593933,
-0.7813030481338501,
-0.28622928261756897,
0.4843052625656128,
-0.43782657384872437,
-0.4799048900604248,
0.49619242548942566,
0.12236715108156204,
-0.10108010470867157,
-0.45534855127334595,
0.5772746205329895,
0.15198151767253876,
0.29768112301826477,
0.5975309014320374,
0.3014737069606781,
-0.503507137298584,
-0.05816974863409996,
0.11428897082805634,
-0.07584814727306366,
-0.3485068380832672,
1.0672001838684082,
-0.6453436017036438,
0.03213513642549515,
0.45919349789619446,
0.34288474917411804,
0.3332233130931854,
-0.04328283295035362,
0.22357860207557678,
-0.9115873575210571,
0.3226422965526581,
0.04242816939949989,
0.1646711379289627,
0.10361053049564362,
-0.5331634283065796,
0.3451666235923767,
0.43936505913734436,
-0.6007093191146851,
-1.3729722499847412,
-0.2050781100988388,
-1.0626791715621948,
-0.08946883678436279,
1.2200740575790405,
0.1995261311531067,
-0.2883795201778412,
-0.3250878155231476,
-0.13241618871688843,
-0.328336626291275,
-0.3883998692035675,
1.1905161142349243,
0.5269814729690552,
0.11328712850809097,
-0.1858464628458023,
-0.6967971324920654,
0.08479657769203186,
-0.22269581258296967,
-0.5555955767631531,
0.2116035670042038,
0.08101056516170502,
0.3449387848377228,
0.6992326378822327,
0.1619950830936432,
0.08889070898294449,
0.36558058857917786,
0.1770152598619461,
-0.4071691632270813,
-0.033597834408283234,
-0.6829717755317688,
-0.028876041993498802,
0.39103928208351135,
-0.4526095986366272,
-0.16664862632751465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09296v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09296v1
|
Cross-Data Knowledge Graph Construction for LLM-enabled Educational Question-Answering System: A~Case~Study~at~HCMUT
| 2024-04-14T16:34:31 | 2024-04-14T16:34:31 |
Tuan Bui, Oanh Tran, Phuong Nguyen, Bao Ho, Long Nguyen, Thang Bui, Tho Quan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In today's rapidly evolving landscape of Artificial Intelligence, large
language models (LLMs) have emerged as a vibrant research topic. LLMs find
applications in various fields and contribute significantly. Despite their
powerful language capabilities, similar to pre-trained language models (PLMs),
LLMs still face challenges in remembering events, incorporating new
information, and addressing domain-specific issues or hallucinations. To
overcome these limitations, researchers have proposed Retrieval-Augmented
Generation (RAG) techniques, some others have proposed the integration of LLMs
with Knowledge Graphs (KGs) to provide factual context, thereby improving
performance and delivering more accurate feedback to user queries.
Education plays a crucial role in human development and progress. With the
technology transformation, traditional education is being replaced by digital
or blended education. Therefore, educational data in the digital environment is
increasing day by day. Data in higher education institutions are diverse,
comprising various sources such as unstructured/structured text, relational
databases, web/app-based API access, etc. Constructing a Knowledge Graph from
these cross-data sources is not a simple task. This article proposes a method
for automatically constructing a Knowledge Graph from multiple data sources and
discusses some initial applications (experimental trials) of KG in conjunction
with LLMs for question-answering tasks.
|
[
-0.5419408082962036,
-1.0684075355529785,
0.6725448369979858,
-0.328778475522995,
0.09857381135225296,
0.5518559813499451,
0.13962425291538239,
-0.2875680923461914,
0.2874581813812256,
0.5508314371109009,
-0.43672502040863037,
-0.5891179442405701,
-0.4218662679195404,
0.046226393431425095,
-0.43835389614105225,
0.6654724478721619,
-0.3610072135925293,
0.07137621939182281,
-0.8115884065628052,
-0.10180965811014175,
-0.5935370922088623,
-0.5292655229568481,
-0.5940088629722595,
-0.4401077330112457,
0.4695275127887726,
0.5243574976921082,
0.3402169644832611,
0.4119952619075775,
0.1621888279914856,
0.27950939536094666,
0.25896239280700684,
0.41808512806892395,
-0.5229734778404236,
0.2559380531311035,
-0.19276626408100128,
-0.343339204788208,
-0.5248844623565674,
-0.051807623356580734,
0.7189549207687378,
0.8741516470909119,
0.11348377168178558,
0.17278531193733215,
0.21602816879749298,
0.5045625567436218,
-0.43688729405403137,
0.15347325801849365,
-0.5426948666572571,
0.10590191185474396,
-0.1834683120250702,
-0.31895390152931213,
-0.22789926826953888,
-0.5234225988388062,
0.09730646759271622,
-0.6786344051361084,
-0.08475472033023834,
0.13452185690402985,
0.6671929955482483,
0.12628796696662903,
-0.43687763810157776,
-0.49830538034439087,
-0.5218079686164856,
0.6422708034515381,
-0.4823843538761139,
0.7034499645233154,
0.42885804176330566,
0.6651847958564758,
-0.18198585510253906,
-0.9911311864852905,
-0.5579444169998169,
0.2551710307598114,
-0.1700482815504074,
0.07161330431699753,
0.2450682669878006,
-0.26917174458503723,
-0.03066909685730934,
0.1334812343120575,
-0.403298944234848,
-0.11032046377658844,
-0.37073493003845215,
-0.26939740777015686,
0.4938891530036926,
0.5593296885490417,
0.22016695141792297,
-0.3460718095302582,
-0.32670727372169495,
0.0843324139714241,
-0.8837520480155945,
-0.04036695510149002,
0.29495328664779663,
0.4469101130962372,
0.060799602419137955,
0.8670358657836914,
-0.36140233278274536,
0.8555359244346619,
-0.14843928813934326,
-0.21450528502464294,
0.13475880026817322,
-0.41844695806503296,
-0.040398575365543365,
0.04937976226210594,
0.5978078246116638,
0.2864682078361511,
0.41996851563453674,
-0.32260337471961975,
0.1303286850452423,
-0.12494252622127533,
0.09093339741230011,
-0.6966512203216553,
-0.19800777733325958,
0.1002645194530487,
-0.12438951432704926,
-0.10066831111907959,
-0.28492194414138794,
-0.7557288408279419,
-0.38358935713768005,
-0.43631511926651,
0.44443681836128235,
-0.34284311532974243,
0.028972633183002472,
-0.18472428619861603,
0.09112386405467987,
0.207570418715477,
0.2802113890647888,
-0.32340651750564575,
0.14447540044784546,
0.33190521597862244,
0.3980845808982849,
-0.20444060862064362,
-0.2639429569244385,
-0.225040003657341,
0.45505112409591675,
-0.0933687686920166,
0.5680785775184631,
-0.7293192744255066,
-0.49451354146003723,
0.09659725427627563,
-0.2121245414018631,
-0.23948527872562408,
-0.3802250027656555,
0.45099976658821106,
-0.9968878626823425,
0.5092770457267761,
-0.27929651737213135,
-1.1124706268310547,
-0.20057526230812073,
0.6851665377616882,
-0.34637030959129333,
1.1126629114151,
0.3289005756378174,
-0.9192813038825989,
0.09855537861585617,
-0.5550463199615479,
-0.44833874702453613,
0.239505335688591,
-0.39618420600891113,
-0.286275178194046,
-0.7183718681335449,
0.4209451377391815,
0.5635094046592712,
-0.44696322083473206,
0.24326856434345245,
-0.34134602546691895,
-0.04632281884551048,
0.14940130710601807,
-0.06830848008394241,
0.8649905920028687,
0.05740676075220108,
0.024898117408156395,
-0.32889771461486816,
-0.6768229603767395,
0.37076905369758606,
0.3257192075252533,
-0.6197551488876343,
-0.5371407866477966,
0.07915762811899185,
-0.41067010164260864,
0.0891730934381485,
0.47231486439704895,
-0.4913812279701233,
0.12766163051128387,
-0.0692271962761879,
0.09493172913789749,
0.42188799381256104,
0.2170710563659668,
0.15922832489013672,
-0.2927798628807068,
0.6707988381385803,
-0.11693103611469269,
0.10662359744310379,
0.16661883890628815,
-0.500740110874176,
-0.6676506996154785,
0.0737466961145401,
0.2921753525733948,
0.8106445670127869,
-1.2595469951629639,
0.29345375299453735,
-0.3356080949306488,
-0.3399854004383087,
-0.5267568230628967,
0.38827741146087646,
0.19872795045375824,
1.0722687244415283,
0.43209630250930786,
0.1202952042222023,
-0.6841121912002563,
-0.5948934555053711,
-0.08428897708654404,
-0.19834594428539276,
-0.006210228428244591,
0.7752751708030701,
0.2909524142742157,
-0.3468826711177826,
1.3071777820587158,
-0.8282812237739563,
-0.1800030767917633,
-0.30898675322532654,
-0.19315452873706818,
-0.1011035293340683,
0.11407412588596344,
0.4214876890182495,
-0.7010931968688965,
-0.5540629625320435,
-0.11440997570753098,
-0.8656103014945984,
-0.1811094582080841,
0.371635377407074,
-0.37942659854888916,
0.08196448534727097,
0.4511650800704956,
-0.3998619318008423,
0.29403451085090637,
0.37213069200515747,
-0.3453998863697052,
0.5390119552612305,
0.25311917066574097,
0.331508070230484,
-1.2103441953659058,
0.04356658458709717,
-0.2669972777366638,
-0.1462993323802948,
-0.5272877216339111,
-0.05580631643533707,
-0.19065572321414948,
-0.04038504138588905,
-0.3420197367668152,
0.7453452348709106,
-0.17835475504398346,
-0.11485373228788376,
-0.12089966237545013,
0.6951102614402771,
0.048967793583869934,
0.41945680975914,
-0.08664723485708237,
0.6208699345588684,
0.5777220726013184,
-0.6951050758361816,
0.6212498545646667,
0.5158239603042603,
-0.11102914065122604,
0.7245798707008362,
-0.4495047330856323,
0.07902277261018753,
0.06746887415647507,
0.24906854331493378,
-0.7599673271179199,
-0.23007401823997498,
0.5462395548820496,
-0.46065619587898254,
0.04873393848538399,
-0.09585616737604141,
-0.45700976252555847,
-0.5192173719406128,
-0.18533776700496674,
0.5988051891326904,
0.2880193293094635,
-0.6202300190925598,
0.7497979402542114,
0.6407833695411682,
-0.3074600398540497,
-0.5737165212631226,
-0.30352386832237244,
0.15760920941829681,
-0.09294721484184265,
-0.7879000902175903,
0.039860423654317856,
-0.19117072224617004,
-0.11956337839365005,
0.2641265094280243,
0.15311706066131592,
-0.13378259539604187,
0.0042673260904848576,
-0.0023633495438843966,
0.5253678560256958,
-0.23475763201713562,
0.151566743850708,
0.2527540922164917,
0.24380402266979218,
0.12060867249965668,
-0.1859685778617859,
0.6469666957855225,
0.19971580803394318,
-0.5382072329521179,
0.05956239253282547,
0.19908413290977478,
0.3340189456939697,
-0.12273712456226349,
0.49607542157173157,
0.28033924102783203,
-0.35095471143722534,
-0.4868610203266144,
-0.4814685881137848,
-0.14413176476955414,
-0.47074854373931885,
0.1547032743692398,
-0.3677605986595154,
-0.965081512928009,
0.5137428641319275,
-0.22106356918811798,
-0.008876385167241096,
0.2683400809764862,
0.45486754179000854,
-0.04356681928038597,
0.7253564596176147,
0.2974725067615509,
-0.05508989840745926,
0.22218120098114014,
-0.22443078458309174,
0.20190009474754333,
-0.8280895948410034,
-0.5475056171417236,
-0.5195256471633911,
-0.15054036676883698,
-0.4184730350971222,
-0.40761712193489075,
0.4864010810852051,
0.08006872981786728,
-0.2138916403055191,
0.06325655430555344,
-0.30646002292633057,
0.317336767911911,
0.42690226435661316,
0.030516259372234344,
0.36885860562324524,
0.07369038462638855,
-0.35531097650527954,
0.2894727289676666,
-0.9719729423522949,
-0.3841891884803772,
1.2940112352371216,
0.11068102717399597,
0.7419838905334473,
-0.17597687244415283,
0.7087975740432739,
0.17987263202667236,
0.36965978145599365,
-0.5203653573989868,
0.8135138750076294,
-0.09843512624502182,
-0.6994350552558899,
-0.5662388801574707,
-0.6270225644111633,
-0.9324283599853516,
0.11423419415950775,
-0.31364554166793823,
-0.44203463196754456,
-0.1264733225107193,
-0.012904883362352848,
-0.04260227456688881,
0.4381333589553833,
-0.391751229763031,
0.5177673101425171,
-0.2824985086917877,
-0.3486718237400055,
0.08837541192770004,
-0.5942683219909668,
0.4035664498806,
-0.18725046515464783,
0.21588681638240814,
0.11897484958171844,
0.13041086494922638,
0.8952864408493042,
-0.29964932799339294,
0.7560680508613586,
-0.24318256974220276,
-0.1118147149682045,
0.7678505778312683,
-0.08246196061372757,
0.5388594269752502,
-0.08346307277679443,
-0.062426578253507614,
-0.13374409079551697,
-0.11728985607624054,
-0.29185450077056885,
-0.6481375098228455,
0.6327762603759766,
-0.7927452325820923,
-0.6119115352630615,
0.056532710790634155,
-1.0099672079086304,
-0.6415006518363953,
0.3032607138156891,
-0.3055969476699829,
0.3782697916030884,
-0.020560247823596,
0.045914940536022186,
0.5999184846878052,
-0.30422890186309814,
0.03694329783320427,
0.5539854764938354,
-0.6089276671409607,
-0.5368363857269287,
1.0110267400741577,
0.3690228760242462,
0.11683473736047745,
0.3174317181110382,
0.1150360256433487,
-0.48522767424583435,
-0.4930567741394043,
-0.48678967356681824,
0.32385316491127014,
-0.8332474827766418,
-0.2754039168357849,
-0.6830742359161377,
-0.6782090067863464,
-0.7720428109169006,
-0.15911848843097687,
0.11102894693613052,
-0.4325138330459595,
-0.10072291642427444,
-0.12640276551246643,
0.44529402256011963,
0.8059356808662415,
0.22838684916496277,
0.21111369132995605,
-0.7426729798316956,
0.4992179274559021,
0.664105236530304,
0.3934580385684967,
0.0033164871856570244,
-0.20225298404693604,
-0.3395754098892212,
0.11285775154829025,
-0.17063534259796143,
-0.721517026424408,
0.04419044777750969,
0.044956404715776443,
0.8167717456817627,
0.0786995142698288,
0.1569230705499649,
0.5251477956771851,
-0.30975764989852905,
0.4535558521747589,
-0.1445414423942566,
-0.5154339671134949,
0.3559614419937134,
-0.32183992862701416,
0.04725218936800957,
0.4645029604434967,
0.5726038217544556,
-0.5185641646385193,
-0.6103783249855042,
-0.5035514235496521,
-0.9346381425857544,
0.6210145354270935,
0.10051918029785156,
-0.1126713752746582,
0.20316027104854584,
0.5005400776863098,
0.22280938923358917,
0.36403676867485046,
-0.44331663846969604,
-0.5246934294700623,
-0.11593586951494217,
-0.49641796946525574,
0.051549188792705536,
-0.06478235870599747,
-0.3185751140117645,
-0.3316567540168762,
0.9032522439956665,
-0.10492897033691406,
-0.19691747426986694,
-0.06763792037963867,
-0.16015829145908356,
0.028171679005026817,
0.20896942913532257,
0.09765166789293289,
0.7602404356002808,
-0.09059087187051773,
0.14002028107643127,
0.4054425358772278,
-0.40737447142601013,
0.064033143222332,
0.23564711213111877,
-0.49045804142951965,
-0.21938934922218323,
0.10093800723552704,
0.4916520118713379,
-0.05304985120892525,
-0.6670119166374207,
0.28526583313941956,
0.08653498440980911,
-0.0316477008163929,
-0.22754208743572235,
0.15369783341884613,
0.48950058221817017,
0.38337957859039307,
0.43253418803215027,
-0.6785004138946533,
-0.07630370557308197,
-0.4526166319847107,
0.40190595388412476,
0.5754975080490112,
-0.025320500135421753,
0.1561233252286911,
0.6125831604003906,
0.3379032611846924,
-0.31351372599601746,
0.7366390228271484,
-0.01711179129779339,
-0.6754805445671082,
0.5625109672546387,
0.5136758089065552,
0.4546319544315338,
-0.2156664878129959,
0.3814438283443451,
0.2706652283668518,
0.07758905738592148,
0.31110912561416626,
0.4137204885482788,
-0.10384880751371384,
-0.8228470087051392,
-0.2647860646247864,
-0.6953844428062439,
-0.5922634601593018,
-0.0020038429647684097,
-0.35693585872650146,
0.2635132372379303,
-0.2134694904088974,
-0.02048058807849884,
-0.23047040402889252,
0.18852278590202332,
-0.6564496755599976,
0.5860874056816101,
0.11757037788629532,
0.8133488297462463,
-0.807330310344696,
0.804577112197876,
0.8854685425758362,
-0.170196533203125,
-0.8908145427703857,
-0.35545989871025085,
-0.3362855017185211,
-0.9822835326194763,
0.6614421606063843,
-0.3492133915424347,
-0.09874137490987778,
0.27636319398880005,
-0.329270601272583,
-0.7970953583717346,
1.3758889436721802,
0.19652198255062103,
-0.4468623101711273,
-0.14757226407527924,
0.6950343251228333,
0.4529356062412262,
-0.5245270133018494,
0.014476710930466652,
0.5394993424415588,
0.6131342053413391,
0.3159177303314209,
-0.3962869346141815,
0.04683418199419975,
-0.022225715219974518,
-0.4639231264591217,
0.30287402868270874,
-0.41417840123176575,
0.7413957715034485,
0.015133592300117016,
-0.17287082970142365,
-0.232443168759346,
0.5613692998886108,
0.47531554102897644,
0.6104072332382202,
0.39534327387809753,
0.7547339200973511,
0.7028871178627014,
0.08518189936876297,
0.7516322135925293,
-0.5569974780082703,
0.13838042318820953,
1.2566651105880737,
-0.16090528666973114,
0.5493432283401489,
0.5156326293945312,
-0.3548632860183716,
0.42623159289360046,
0.5391845107078552,
-0.032346032559871674,
0.24105069041252136,
0.13374529778957367,
-0.18101727962493896,
-0.32763537764549255,
-0.17735722661018372,
-0.5399457216262817,
0.2160884588956833,
0.35255616903305054,
-0.23791897296905518,
-0.5374919772148132,
-0.08325468748807907,
-0.07761239260435104,
-0.01761806011199951,
-0.43819883465766907,
0.5058631300926208,
0.04286109283566475,
-0.5030566453933716,
0.21369899809360504,
-0.15287737548351288,
0.27033230662345886,
-0.5927259922027588,
-0.09116160869598389,
-0.21194489300251007,
-0.3515307605266571,
-0.2707211375236511,
-1.1074714660644531,
0.022143127396702766,
0.058874357491731644,
-0.028823211789131165,
-0.025973236188292503,
0.889714241027832,
-0.6930173635482788,
-0.644562840461731,
0.40313488245010376,
1.0662299394607544,
0.1747148633003235,
0.5571391582489014,
-0.5426706075668335,
-0.11886440962553024,
-0.14068162441253662,
-0.32874032855033875,
0.20022928714752197,
0.4627871513366699,
-0.14188776910305023,
0.8150894045829773,
0.43194249272346497,
0.03495362028479576,
0.44275209307670593,
0.11037586629390717,
0.893932044506073,
-0.366641640663147,
-0.3887118995189667,
-0.408756822347641,
0.326443612575531,
-0.04976019263267517,
-0.04450914263725281,
0.9273509383201599,
0.7471441030502319,
0.927006721496582,
0.2998545169830322,
1.0610750913619995,
-0.3393544852733612,
0.7976801991462708,
-0.4057581424713135,
0.8109042644500732,
-0.6405255794525146,
0.22220478951931,
-0.1489814668893814,
-0.8218866586685181,
-0.15869328379631042,
0.04377591237425804,
-0.37642231583595276,
0.209515780210495,
0.5134457349777222,
0.610877513885498,
0.043505631387233734,
-0.07492365688085556,
0.20426464080810547,
0.091708242893219,
0.16687902808189392,
0.4625689685344696,
0.9287262558937073,
-0.28697192668914795,
0.9074794054031372,
-0.22640648484230042,
0.18387040495872498,
-0.13699959218502045,
-0.5353725552558899,
-0.9859637022018433,
-0.5466517210006714,
-0.2674928903579712,
-0.29154789447784424,
0.02455069124698639,
0.5367497205734253,
0.1892581433057785,
-0.7372657656669617,
-0.18781985342502594,
0.245630145072937,
0.5888020992279053,
0.3181591033935547,
-0.2566397786140442,
0.5962428450584412,
-0.25866514444351196,
-0.6077687740325928,
0.3939642012119293,
-0.11101530492305756,
0.1082279309630394,
-0.40461865067481995,
-0.2695319652557373,
-0.4267590343952179,
0.26982998847961426,
0.5724722743034363,
0.3168538212776184,
-0.24115143716335297,
-0.45750853419303894,
-0.00487565016373992,
-0.10730385035276413,
-0.004789775237441063,
0.6881850361824036,
-0.998094916343689,
0.31024646759033203,
0.674241304397583,
1.034271001815796,
0.42094096541404724,
0.12862329185009003,
0.19718784093856812,
-0.656704843044281,
-0.4520896375179291,
0.19585612416267395,
0.27218934893608093,
0.38622745871543884,
-0.2049693912267685,
0.5040316581726074,
0.3104468882083893,
-0.5214198231697083,
-0.8353409171104431,
0.24508382380008698,
-0.7287696003913879,
-0.4154287278652191,
0.8624104261398315,
0.02492505870759487,
-0.16986113786697388,
-0.4115239977836609,
-0.11474787443876266,
0.5462406277656555,
0.038623448461294174,
0.9620750546455383,
0.6771149039268494,
-0.39663660526275635,
0.2209940403699875,
-0.5054653882980347,
0.1558597981929779,
0.13820350170135498,
-1.1744821071624756,
-0.11831934750080109,
0.5656892657279968,
0.39327073097229004,
0.054798025637865067,
0.5066736936569214,
-0.08202795684337616,
-0.06293226033449173,
-0.043918147683143616,
0.06009293347597122,
-0.3070579171180725,
-0.41430097818374634,
0.3520582914352417,
0.6757532358169556,
-0.16075226664543152,
-0.10676278918981552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13069v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13069v1
|
Subtle Signs of Scribal Intent in the Voynich Manuscript
| 2024-04-14T14:54:01 | 2024-04-14T14:54:01 |
Andrew Steckley, Noah Steckley
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study explores the cryptic Voynich Manuscript, by looking for subtle
signs of scribal intent hidden in overlooked features of the "Voynichese"
script. The findings indicate that distributions of tokens within paragraphs
vary significantly based on positions defined not only by elements intrinsic to
the script such as paragraph and line boundaries but also by extrinsic
elements, namely the hand-drawn illustrations of plants.
|
[
0.0624590739607811,
-0.4028964936733246,
1.00835382938385,
0.2961268424987793,
-0.30286285281181335,
-0.10489118099212646,
0.15582849085330963,
-0.6426450610160828,
0.8216819167137146,
0.43560490012168884,
-0.8025028705596924,
-0.5738384127616882,
-0.7449495792388916,
0.09153013676404953,
-0.5706754922866821,
0.8197552561759949,
-0.27797016501426697,
0.35446104407310486,
0.1713726967573166,
-0.15708352625370026,
0.2313603311777115,
-0.41443005204200745,
-0.15834057331085205,
0.0713614970445633,
0.9802851676940918,
0.3742562234401703,
0.3570184111595154,
0.7388627529144287,
0.7817274928092957,
0.223989337682724,
-0.21717026829719543,
-0.2639426589012146,
-0.2024981528520584,
0.1899004876613617,
-0.40951743721961975,
-0.9737551808357239,
0.013513769954442978,
0.021788693964481354,
0.570988655090332,
0.7112364172935486,
0.23752842843532562,
0.2951730191707611,
-0.09122364223003387,
0.5746203660964966,
-0.37507131695747375,
0.0402323342859745,
-0.5947462320327759,
0.1603250801563263,
-0.7721700668334961,
-0.3981923460960388,
-0.4731471538543701,
-0.393062949180603,
0.7563897967338562,
-0.45771539211273193,
0.5530869960784912,
-0.0790533497929573,
1.1183885335922241,
0.0081090172752738,
-0.4000445604324341,
-0.8889086246490479,
-0.35674601793289185,
0.9347313642501831,
-0.3852137625217438,
-0.29228222370147705,
0.008024504408240318,
0.10713028162717819,
-0.26484617590904236,
-0.9645330905914307,
-0.5243067741394043,
-0.38642483949661255,
-0.18679256737232208,
0.007818303070962429,
-0.21457302570343018,
0.18739674985408783,
0.589362621307373,
0.4269109070301056,
-0.47522789239883423,
0.05029657483100891,
-0.2443925440311432,
-0.5562111735343933,
0.44146645069122314,
0.3136565387248993,
0.7262396812438965,
-0.49835529923439026,
-0.5237035155296326,
-0.08478046208620071,
-0.5482959747314453,
0.26366186141967773,
0.5995175242424011,
0.1309625208377838,
0.10777446627616882,
1.1322050094604492,
-0.05919911339879036,
0.43189340829849243,
-0.3294084370136261,
0.21087107062339783,
0.010529687628149986,
-0.564847469329834,
0.35835546255111694,
0.1609913855791092,
0.5214061141014099,
0.81956946849823,
0.17453938722610474,
0.1951288878917694,
-0.03939443826675415,
0.8439314365386963,
-0.07996729761362076,
-0.5603078007698059,
-0.3753321170806885,
0.14535626769065857,
-0.7610962986946106,
-0.5776894688606262,
0.2881837487220764,
-0.3805268108844757,
-0.508784294128418,
-0.07456739991903305,
0.0017749955877661705,
-0.4205549955368042,
0.017217149958014488,
-0.10669030994176865,
-1.2852976322174072,
0.49195560812950134,
0.4002620279788971,
-0.88343346118927,
0.0750909298658371,
0.510341465473175,
0.7755684852600098,
-0.5091918706893921,
-0.44484248757362366,
-0.27406004071235657,
0.1244409903883934,
-0.34308838844299316,
1.1547480821609497,
-0.7461836934089661,
-0.5656548142433167,
0.05724364146590233,
0.3150040805339813,
-0.0017870417796075344,
-0.34234899282455444,
0.7335599064826965,
0.3411511778831482,
0.10577970743179321,
-0.7577489018440247,
-0.4785419702529907,
-0.3834303617477417,
-0.31313467025756836,
-0.6275356411933899,
1.245270013809204,
0.4394628405570984,
-0.808994710445404,
0.6402319073677063,
-0.3463329076766968,
-0.38054266571998596,
0.0017190317157655954,
-0.5785731077194214,
-0.04964704066514969,
0.6726865768432617,
-0.540672242641449,
0.31313836574554443,
0.31848686933517456,
-0.36216339468955994,
-0.22382314503192902,
-0.5121634006500244,
0.8199702501296997,
-0.3576216399669647,
0.89713454246521,
-0.11046238243579865,
-0.7779214978218079,
0.36181625723838806,
-0.6958805918693542,
0.2221098393201828,
-0.1429937332868576,
-0.1358313262462616,
-0.5217707753181458,
-0.16990968585014343,
0.3823765814304352,
0.08300141245126724,
0.41170212626457214,
-0.5701472163200378,
0.6835314631462097,
-0.2366696149110794,
0.5766158103942871,
0.5111375451087952,
0.49313002824783325,
0.6138234734535217,
-0.4603242576122284,
0.6278096437454224,
0.054796747863292694,
0.2195531725883484,
-0.27776581048965454,
-0.6638393402099609,
-0.9993349313735962,
-0.08750008046627045,
0.3354710638523102,
0.5315687656402588,
-0.6599900126457214,
0.2182873636484146,
0.01820538379251957,
-0.6056976914405823,
-0.8230916857719421,
-0.1621239334344864,
0.36898279190063477,
-0.10050725191831589,
-0.0168500654399395,
-0.1351119577884674,
-0.22408826649188995,
-1.2933002710342407,
-0.7543227076530457,
0.13797742128372192,
0.09636912494897842,
0.27727338671684265,
0.5181110501289368,
-0.24337400496006012,
0.4370943009853363,
-0.5464208126068115,
-0.355285108089447,
-0.34427905082702637,
0.39630669355392456,
0.10788824409246445,
0.08815228939056396,
0.7907593250274658,
-0.6126763820648193,
-0.8428770899772644,
0.1824130415916443,
-0.13701842725276947,
-0.3348015546798706,
-0.40057647228240967,
-0.16762816905975342,
0.043677061796188354,
0.6950233578681946,
-0.8939723968505859,
1.1023696660995483,
0.3355577886104584,
-0.5661372542381287,
0.5572173595428467,
-0.0533561035990715,
-0.1560448706150055,
-0.7686266899108887,
0.030794234946370125,
-0.35703518986701965,
0.09133586287498474,
-0.5534662008285522,
-0.04006138816475868,
0.16799888014793396,
0.1727091521024704,
-0.4228368401527405,
0.40722498297691345,
-0.6959410309791565,
-0.022694718092679977,
0.006583405192941427,
0.3502879738807678,
0.152577742934227,
0.39256665110588074,
0.25026535987854004,
0.4586793780326843,
0.711862325668335,
-0.3281056582927704,
-0.06846186518669128,
-0.2047746181488037,
-0.2376522421836853,
0.5057193636894226,
-0.5669996738433838,
-0.23318777978420258,
-0.241547629237175,
-0.022461503744125366,
-1.3242762088775635,
-0.40572646260261536,
0.45409074425697327,
-0.3869776427745819,
-0.02621205896139145,
0.040055543184280396,
0.1635022759437561,
-0.09818847477436066,
-0.652893602848053,
0.3201887607574463,
-0.0018404517322778702,
0.04759176820516586,
0.7548950910568237,
-0.09479571878910065,
-0.3314370810985565,
-0.38816362619400024,
-0.7075424194335938,
-0.11212072521448135,
-0.18510305881500244,
-0.10700169950723648,
0.5183877944946289,
0.01073004025965929,
-0.35992273688316345,
-0.008016585372388363,
-0.1064455434679985,
0.14021871984004974,
-0.1278381496667862,
0.6682617664337158,
0.10494900494813919,
-0.0013604739215224981,
-0.3124537169933319,
0.3311714828014374,
-0.06714490801095963,
0.0380033515393734,
0.11923195421695709,
0.6522009372711182,
-0.04583460092544556,
-0.5788984298706055,
-0.9725583791732788,
0.6700965166091919,
0.9418685436248779,
0.2502874732017517,
0.1469668745994568,
0.58565753698349,
-0.09017164260149002,
-0.19141751527786255,
-0.17037245631217957,
-0.15378335118293762,
-0.39168813824653625,
0.047957342118024826,
-0.3431670069694519,
-0.4040161669254303,
0.8461018800735474,
-0.4042470157146454,
-0.3669505715370178,
0.7821111083030701,
0.06821900606155396,
-0.4966057240962982,
0.9393079876899719,
0.3249649405479431,
0.2667088508605957,
0.7003486752510071,
-0.42087051272392273,
-0.006078086793422699,
-1.0078496932983398,
-0.3487960994243622,
-0.5675235986709595,
-0.6124077439308167,
-0.7571906447410583,
-0.5045266151428223,
0.2976223826408386,
0.17059682309627533,
0.4810290038585663,
0.4341464042663574,
-0.8103736042976379,
0.7431194186210632,
0.6894983649253845,
0.1052996963262558,
-0.023111507296562195,
0.008261663839221,
-0.45123738050460815,
-0.3264778256416321,
-0.4596225321292877,
-0.6557235717773438,
0.9844387173652649,
0.38085341453552246,
0.27719637751579285,
0.15368680655956268,
0.6619435548782349,
0.3415636420249939,
0.10731200128793716,
-0.9049577116966248,
0.5384116768836975,
0.1427289843559265,
-0.3882749676704407,
-0.5802696943283081,
0.12953238189220428,
-1.064774513244629,
0.22612325847148895,
-0.14694416522979736,
-1.0108333826065063,
0.5427900552749634,
-0.09593217074871063,
-0.3453207314014435,
-0.2539098858833313,
-1.020674705505371,
0.8183212280273438,
-0.29773038625717163,
-0.0004702559672296047,
-0.0676337480545044,
-0.4790194630622864,
-0.11787951737642288,
0.5660839080810547,
-0.19962012767791748,
-0.027737438678741455,
-0.1287854164838791,
0.5965929627418518,
-0.335814893245697,
0.9264419078826904,
-0.12994347512722015,
-0.11257500946521759,
0.669133186340332,
0.5291991829872131,
0.9093866348266602,
-0.009496055543422699,
-0.030420105904340744,
0.1908935159444809,
0.3340528607368469,
-0.5554708242416382,
-0.4336637258529663,
0.5132887363433838,
-0.2426733523607254,
-0.5101554989814758,
-0.9236641526222229,
-0.14268048107624054,
0.583192765712738,
0.580087423324585,
1.0417892932891846,
0.5533379912376404,
-0.39352232217788696,
0.043062884360551834,
0.5268880128860474,
-0.024222316220402718,
0.763272225856781,
0.21393990516662598,
-0.267628014087677,
-0.05415811389684677,
0.8767133951187134,
0.1739431619644165,
0.29992467164993286,
0.3492199778556824,
0.2951076924800873,
-0.34063512086868286,
-0.7269331812858582,
-0.3813715875148773,
0.1676831692457199,
-0.887270987033844,
0.32097622752189636,
-0.41623833775520325,
-0.022810976952314377,
-0.09019280225038528,
-0.43162980675697327,
0.049396976828575134,
-0.8048706650733948,
-0.7042815089225769,
-0.06935622543096542,
0.38066986203193665,
0.9995737075805664,
0.3402871787548065,
0.588469386100769,
-0.5359235405921936,
0.14727607369422913,
0.024795204401016235,
-0.025689082220196724,
-0.2602737843990326,
-0.15053607523441315,
0.33768966794013977,
-0.0399475134909153,
-0.12131014466285706,
-1.1107829809188843,
-0.09735413640737534,
0.029566632583737373,
0.5184228420257568,
1.0107835531234741,
-0.2870047390460968,
0.32509496808052063,
-0.3420764207839966,
1.1875170469284058,
0.3300923705101013,
-0.9337770342826843,
0.5198017954826355,
-0.9674599170684814,
0.3508116602897644,
0.6377048492431641,
0.40198948979377747,
-0.7825585007667542,
-0.36321020126342773,
-0.9078004360198975,
-0.8268961310386658,
0.37700483202934265,
0.17107748985290527,
0.1651843637228012,
-0.15016411244869232,
0.39811378717422485,
0.3971782922744751,
0.21786966919898987,
-0.9312260746955872,
-0.25143054127693176,
0.02834697999060154,
-0.23450705409049988,
0.5856263041496277,
-0.36210423707962036,
-0.4099592864513397,
-0.4175737202167511,
-0.24010416865348816,
0.002213297178968787,
0.24526765942573547,
0.5356881022453308,
-0.13672566413879395,
0.002406591782346368,
0.0012126077199354768,
1.0253195762634277,
0.9218031764030457,
0.17411403357982635,
0.35291028022766113,
0.026411790400743484,
-0.7499698400497437,
-0.19693218171596527,
-0.510858416557312,
-0.45379623770713806,
0.646977424621582,
0.7155458331108093,
0.7730315923690796,
0.29671576619148254,
-0.6802113056182861,
0.9124422073364258,
0.1499319225549698,
-0.2110251635313034,
-0.7871590256690979,
0.5873327255249023,
-0.06081603839993477,
0.1393744796514511,
0.18692439794540405,
0.4963782727718353,
0.5554441809654236,
-0.9089331030845642,
-0.14542822539806366,
0.5137646198272705,
-0.627328634262085,
-0.4696687161922455,
0.18624351918697357,
0.023473910987377167,
-0.558734118938446,
0.3224561810493469,
-0.35737818479537964,
-0.6961456537246704,
0.4249325394630432,
0.17965777218341827,
0.7098017930984497,
-0.29622626304626465,
0.7975029945373535,
-0.26082757115364075,
0.338011234998703,
0.17427372932434082,
1.0747400522232056,
-0.1232924610376358,
-0.0988498330116272,
0.058294374495744705,
-0.3730371296405792,
-0.21877042949199677,
-0.27925506234169006,
-0.7166826725006104,
0.33776700496673584,
-0.4896949529647827,
-0.25139760971069336,
0.4179392457008362,
-0.7312209010124207,
-0.7937235236167908,
-0.18046623468399048,
-0.382906436920166,
0.891483724117279,
-0.6954736709594727,
0.4354173541069031,
0.32797566056251526,
-0.22405192255973816,
-0.7895296812057495,
0.16919457912445068,
-0.143775075674057,
-0.908640444278717,
0.7377327680587769,
0.06838946044445038,
-0.2736486494541168,
-0.09460888803005219,
-0.4354161322116852,
-0.8653095960617065,
0.8690769672393799,
-0.16187834739685059,
-0.5597139596939087,
-0.2817748188972473,
0.3775552213191986,
0.6921031475067139,
-0.21623383462429047,
0.49116742610931396,
0.3716062009334564,
0.6303498148918152,
-0.1372671276330948,
-0.604232132434845,
0.14733144640922546,
-0.1902938038110733,
0.0776716023683548,
0.281962126493454,
-0.6813821792602539,
0.9523009657859802,
-0.31153252720832825,
-0.71182781457901,
0.13206470012664795,
0.27987581491470337,
-0.13019254803657532,
0.4177781641483307,
0.06708310544490814,
0.32059383392333984,
0.9290144443511963,
-0.31951040029525757,
1.1364041566848755,
-0.11964614689350128,
-0.06637323647737503,
0.4939422309398651,
-0.3815712630748749,
0.8366880416870117,
1.0501091480255127,
-0.14638566970825195,
1.2159420251846313,
0.6221036314964294,
-0.06556359678506851,
0.5252561569213867,
0.5473906993865967,
-0.5279329419136047,
0.2940026819705963,
-0.3589760363101959,
-0.19015036523342133,
0.5448957681655884,
0.7884881496429443,
-0.6431247591972351,
0.06784527003765106,
-0.08285912871360779,
-0.05968190357089043,
-0.04815571755170822,
-0.18551398813724518,
0.7877305746078491,
0.30924171209335327,
-0.7101516723632812,
0.07811276614665985,
-0.3108194172382355,
0.35172557830810547,
-0.5705471634864807,
-0.4753204882144928,
0.24361933767795563,
0.05896054953336716,
-0.35684359073638916,
-0.8788843750953674,
0.03812357038259506,
-0.6022560000419617,
-0.26429274678230286,
-0.2797659635543823,
0.8730108141899109,
-0.21183930337429047,
-0.4937937557697296,
0.08594518899917603,
0.08633704483509064,
0.2944895327091217,
-0.06465265899896622,
-0.4134344160556793,
0.27244260907173157,
0.14301811158657074,
-0.32188498973846436,
-0.024104446172714233,
0.9562256932258606,
-0.24584893882274628,
0.45382633805274963,
0.7411941885948181,
0.5273622870445251,
0.20448820292949677,
0.14171625673770905,
0.5793735384941101,
-0.9160889983177185,
-0.7048039436340332,
-0.7403929233551025,
0.6465004682540894,
-0.3757496178150177,
-0.785976767539978,
1.1773953437805176,
0.38708746433258057,
0.4383704364299774,
-0.6111440658569336,
0.7723067998886108,
0.048010196536779404,
0.42269450426101685,
-0.5871549248695374,
0.5484103560447693,
-0.03471645712852478,
-0.129146546125412,
-0.5436365008354187,
-0.944122850894928,
0.022393062710762024,
0.6340247392654419,
-0.16846458613872528,
-0.33516526222229004,
1.2574472427368164,
0.5454794764518738,
0.2507420480251312,
0.04039330035448074,
-0.16844671964645386,
-0.08354873955249786,
-0.24560891091823578,
0.26950082182884216,
1.273515224456787,
-0.22124230861663818,
0.1613689810037613,
0.08750823140144348,
-0.3093499541282654,
-0.595579206943512,
-0.8581932187080383,
-0.969813883304596,
-0.6987255215644836,
-0.18487238883972168,
-0.28263989090919495,
-0.4298778474330902,
0.5380555987358093,
0.10253747552633286,
-0.6739223003387451,
0.13126473128795624,
-0.4424583315849304,
0.07491359114646912,
-0.3619612455368042,
-0.35532116889953613,
0.6379655003547668,
0.28526538610458374,
-0.60313880443573,
0.16602280735969543,
0.624278724193573,
0.7517794966697693,
-0.39370647072792053,
0.25092649459838867,
0.20083722472190857,
0.02833530120551586,
0.38134288787841797,
-0.042728688567876816,
-0.9802156090736389,
-0.49547079205513,
0.4496546983718872,
-0.2891976833343506,
-0.3308534324169159,
1.5147236585617065,
0.00486445426940918,
0.24333038926124573,
0.8458786606788635,
-0.19855011999607086,
0.4311128556728363,
-0.2003536969423294,
0.24993108212947845,
-0.7108264565467834,
0.4533469080924988,
0.5844981670379639,
0.2893836200237274,
-0.16948609054088593,
-0.9172881245613098,
0.007093452848494053,
0.31342390179634094,
-0.2937025725841522,
-0.9253187775611877,
0.44314324855804443,
-1.3926619291305542,
-0.43808040022850037,
1.2291187047958374,
0.05984696000814438,
-0.4087033271789551,
-0.22183246910572052,
-0.8503162264823914,
0.013508274219930172,
-0.1849656105041504,
0.8549826145172119,
1.327873945236206,
-0.6901255249977112,
0.08282050490379333,
-0.647114634513855,
1.042830467224121,
0.5626287460327148,
-0.4521077871322632,
0.21589697897434235,
0.2907818853855133,
0.16231830418109894,
0.5148946642875671,
0.6829407215118408,
-0.07637783139944077,
0.34186485409736633,
0.3278358280658722,
-0.27097654342651367,
0.6741454005241394,
-0.4559996724128723,
0.1081245020031929,
-0.02302626147866249,
0.19071552157402039,
-0.1961635947227478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09275v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09275v1
|
TrafficVLM: A Controllable Visual Language Model for Traffic Video Captioning
| 2024-04-14T14:51:44 | 2024-04-14T14:51:44 |
Quang Minh Dinh, Minh Khoi Ho, Anh Quan Dang, Hung Phong Tran
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Traffic video description and analysis have received much attention recently
due to the growing demand for efficient and reliable urban surveillance
systems. Most existing methods only focus on locating traffic event segments,
which severely lack descriptive details related to the behaviour and context of
all the subjects of interest in the events. In this paper, we present
TrafficVLM, a novel multi-modal dense video captioning model for vehicle ego
camera view. TrafficVLM models traffic video events at different levels of
analysis, both spatially and temporally, and generates long fine-grained
descriptions for the vehicle and pedestrian at different phases of the event.
We also propose a conditional component for TrafficVLM to control the
generation outputs and a multi-task fine-tuning paradigm to enhance
TrafficVLM's learning capability. Experiments show that TrafficVLM performs
well on both vehicle and overhead camera views. Our solution achieved
outstanding results in Track 2 of the AI City Challenge 2024, ranking us third
in the challenge standings. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/quangminhdinh/TrafficVLM.
|
[
-0.29872408509254456,
-0.6930039525032043,
0.4217838943004608,
0.31317976117134094,
-0.375002920627594,
0.18753579258918762,
-0.03118262253701687,
-0.22976015508174896,
-0.0657225176692009,
0.42425212264060974,
-0.3511262536048889,
-0.365628182888031,
-0.2602926194667816,
-0.28093579411506653,
-0.6290384531021118,
0.5575920939445496,
-0.174040749669075,
0.3538760542869568,
-0.315488338470459,
-0.23471994698047638,
-0.4969816505908966,
-0.6540217399597168,
-0.6380192041397095,
0.3148011267185211,
0.4031740725040436,
0.1795223504304886,
0.48439469933509827,
0.6938764452934265,
0.7591726779937744,
0.37392479181289673,
0.4512803554534912,
0.47894009947776794,
-0.22959968447685242,
-0.11322023719549179,
0.049716975539922714,
0.09496789425611496,
-0.3516981303691864,
-0.3082640469074249,
0.865433394908905,
0.2693737745285034,
-0.24781979620456696,
-0.05612175539135933,
-0.19702398777008057,
0.3268853425979614,
-0.620773434638977,
0.24800604581832886,
-0.7460435628890991,
-0.31622856855392456,
-0.19192087650299072,
-0.34731054306030273,
-0.04341397061944008,
0.0056560346856713295,
-0.025311274453997612,
-0.3743598759174347,
0.21221119165420532,
0.39102256298065186,
1.015464425086975,
0.5361279845237732,
-0.5105266571044922,
0.3368910253047943,
-0.9233517646789551,
0.7696197032928467,
-0.21542783081531525,
0.5247470736503601,
0.1289311796426773,
0.6847267150878906,
0.3407982885837555,
-0.506654679775238,
-0.7849217057228088,
-0.12753351032733917,
-0.029408009722828865,
0.11442387104034424,
0.09340118616819382,
0.20899774134159088,
-0.09015762805938721,
0.013839494436979294,
-0.6449644565582275,
-0.13614030182361603,
-0.6448404788970947,
-0.3175109028816223,
0.8459559082984924,
0.8718464970588684,
0.02279459312558174,
-0.01917881891131401,
-0.7335354089736938,
0.23654940724372864,
-0.44088730216026306,
0.2365068942308426,
0.11459597200155258,
0.15077929198741913,
-0.3670428693294525,
0.4576987326145172,
-0.3067435026168823,
0.6589670777320862,
-0.468192994594574,
-0.20811624825000763,
0.24180196225643158,
-0.33431440591812134,
-0.5723950862884521,
-0.33408910036087036,
0.913231611251831,
0.5844371318817139,
0.1153993085026741,
-0.12265590578317642,
-0.28856125473976135,
-0.25283926725387573,
0.2956087589263916,
-0.7344568967819214,
-0.3839077353477478,
0.30082404613494873,
-0.3287212550640106,
-0.12476234138011932,
0.2941848039627075,
-0.7166162729263306,
-0.25311407446861267,
-0.5686464309692383,
0.23664508759975433,
-0.16417202353477478,
-0.20338979363441467,
0.26236411929130554,
0.10922015458345413,
0.6443221569061279,
0.8871209621429443,
-0.427923321723938,
0.14638738334178925,
0.4176517724990845,
0.8607266545295715,
-0.37498238682746887,
-0.376030832529068,
-0.7646434903144836,
0.47255751490592957,
-0.08578628301620483,
0.5102749466896057,
-0.45913249254226685,
0.07513589411973953,
0.15065433084964752,
0.08399690687656403,
-0.04523731395602226,
-0.2361574023962021,
-0.15105997025966644,
-0.6361181735992432,
-0.12263939529657364,
0.20144861936569214,
-0.1513509750366211,
-0.3293339014053345,
0.23855845630168915,
-0.5387682318687439,
0.48260611295700073,
-0.06954411417245865,
-0.37115851044654846,
0.2821195423603058,
-0.5934401750564575,
-0.6647144556045532,
0.5398233532905579,
-0.3143588602542877,
-0.6301030516624451,
-0.1904187798500061,
-0.0985831618309021,
0.3903498649597168,
0.16310183703899384,
0.4370562434196472,
-0.11731285601854324,
0.12026030570268631,
0.2032766044139862,
-0.4838716387748718,
0.4680635929107666,
0.3116210997104645,
-0.07937260717153549,
0.5922091603279114,
-0.7204352021217346,
-0.37783095240592957,
0.14583934843540192,
-0.2093387097120285,
-0.06767448037862778,
0.09766297787427902,
0.47300466895103455,
0.044931717216968536,
0.19454194605350494,
-0.5229412317276001,
0.03741036728024483,
0.039570149034261703,
0.5018025636672974,
0.6934502124786377,
-0.04918656125664711,
0.2991258203983307,
0.08132138848304749,
0.7175182700157166,
0.25335046648979187,
0.5830876231193542,
-0.21340665221214294,
-0.5703173875808716,
-0.6134518384933472,
-0.3778761625289917,
-0.16387593746185303,
0.5380753874778748,
-0.8744685649871826,
-0.03353795409202576,
-0.3157852590084076,
-0.19179575145244598,
-0.4304012656211853,
0.14554929733276367,
0.3539113700389862,
0.48181450366973877,
0.2588551342487335,
-0.2063329517841339,
-0.5111551284790039,
-0.8913570642471313,
0.2827857434749603,
-0.07914729416370392,
0.190052330493927,
0.4745112359523773,
0.4636000394821167,
0.034898169338703156,
0.7020299434661865,
-0.45608460903167725,
-0.585976243019104,
-0.3399054706096649,
-0.17866621911525726,
-0.44998008012771606,
0.4926103949546814,
0.6005644202232361,
-1.2773782014846802,
-0.4681515693664551,
0.08342597633600235,
-0.5417265295982361,
0.22180481255054474,
-0.3849736452102661,
-0.11988188326358795,
0.06150742992758751,
0.7192781567573547,
-0.3487316370010376,
0.6530596613883972,
0.22855104506015778,
-0.27747073769569397,
0.5116188526153564,
-0.2684728503227234,
0.10974360257387161,
-0.5835292339324951,
-0.13393692672252655,
-0.1360885500907898,
-0.9609910845756531,
-0.44026151299476624,
0.24975289404392242,
-0.06695964187383652,
-0.13932295143604279,
-0.9021900296211243,
0.34270399808883667,
-0.24534381926059723,
-0.10067980736494064,
-0.18913519382476807,
0.12218925356864929,
0.019993215799331665,
0.8156970739364624,
0.29290974140167236,
0.4904942810535431,
0.9448079466819763,
-0.7159266471862793,
0.6895735859870911,
0.19946569204330444,
-0.48245668411254883,
0.3259800672531128,
-0.34645581245422363,
-0.1467154175043106,
-0.4594230353832245,
-0.05521504208445549,
-1.0904436111450195,
-0.5310633182525635,
0.14542685449123383,
-0.26816391944885254,
-0.020902913063764572,
-0.16938287019729614,
-0.5104210376739502,
-0.3493568003177643,
0.0745837613940239,
0.5137912034988403,
0.38100069761276245,
-0.16865777969360352,
0.7467201948165894,
0.6330288052558899,
-0.04198940098285675,
0.024142960086464882,
-0.5428445339202881,
0.31374335289001465,
-0.4398915469646454,
-0.5121862888336182,
-0.182741180062294,
-0.24922360479831696,
-0.21428914368152618,
-0.25490957498550415,
0.2924497425556183,
-0.5889797210693359,
0.13466204702854156,
0.22560285031795502,
0.37485185265541077,
0.08008188754320145,
0.2161119133234024,
-0.40408551692962646,
0.1264626830816269,
0.11532896757125854,
-0.15929602086544037,
0.46468108892440796,
-0.3093160092830658,
-0.12891997396945953,
-0.5375858545303345,
0.5545865893363953,
0.7558257579803467,
-0.7196102142333984,
0.49768441915512085,
0.8040974736213684,
-0.16497746109962463,
0.24307355284690857,
-0.2581351697444916,
0.05046854540705681,
-0.46914514899253845,
0.7209606170654297,
-0.3263223171234131,
-0.8483964800834656,
0.31953904032707214,
0.34438401460647583,
-0.0813741534948349,
0.05930756777524948,
0.7020847201347351,
-0.33151471614837646,
1.4177360534667969,
0.4963717758655548,
-0.0030923630110919476,
0.6202660202980042,
-0.1732085943222046,
0.11994989961385727,
-0.4166204631328583,
-0.6903626918792725,
-0.0456494465470314,
-0.1617438793182373,
-0.23936675488948822,
-0.5200967192649841,
0.7500504851341248,
-0.21480970084667206,
-0.31583666801452637,
0.04247576743364334,
-0.23226584494113922,
0.5259371995925903,
0.3420105576515198,
0.01128617487847805,
0.34830230474472046,
-0.07613040506839752,
0.4038665294647217,
-0.06995122879743576,
-0.7454971671104431,
-0.21199436485767365,
0.6252617239952087,
0.27706286311149597,
0.7379301190376282,
0.3477788269519806,
-0.005785047542303801,
0.5190436840057373,
0.11746867001056671,
-0.4873291552066803,
0.7635241746902466,
-0.010686185210943222,
-0.6365829706192017,
-0.3606295883655548,
-0.2505154013633728,
-0.7970187067985535,
0.14492955803871155,
0.029269961640238762,
-0.6084809303283691,
-0.17273738980293274,
0.32742834091186523,
-0.6652573347091675,
0.3403445780277252,
-0.24456220865249634,
0.9663210511207581,
-0.5996500253677368,
-0.5323807001113892,
-0.2878403663635254,
-0.8840558528900146,
0.5152539014816284,
0.12949621677398682,
0.45589742064476013,
-0.05288268253207207,
-0.1246817335486412,
0.3191746473312378,
-0.5276638865470886,
0.7566254734992981,
-0.11364590376615524,
0.10925223678350449,
0.5530185699462891,
0.06737785786390305,
0.4509839117527008,
0.34300941228866577,
0.7220358848571777,
0.07051550596952438,
-0.28926074504852295,
-0.443496435880661,
-0.32158952951431274,
0.521248996257782,
-0.2279890775680542,
-0.44530609250068665,
0.0037020419258624315,
-0.4970542788505554,
0.2670571208000183,
0.17428447306156158,
0.04411608353257179,
0.8161206245422363,
0.1178487241268158,
0.1713520884513855,
0.5504245758056641,
-0.2517831027507782,
0.6322318911552429,
0.6615312099456787,
-0.5355678796768188,
-0.39412254095077515,
1.242950201034546,
-0.42838427424430847,
0.20154954493045807,
0.6065256595611572,
-0.1221737414598465,
-0.23453421890735626,
-0.5850454568862915,
-0.7846341729164124,
-0.2642248272895813,
-0.5753839015960693,
-0.20983198285102844,
-0.6946763396263123,
-0.1605672538280487,
-0.4470142126083374,
-0.21766145527362823,
-0.5680295825004578,
-0.1498882919549942,
-0.09293246269226074,
-0.15315721929073334,
0.15082651376724243,
0.6373438835144043,
0.033997729420661926,
0.35172104835510254,
-0.5815672874450684,
0.4798128306865692,
0.5899667143821716,
0.410621702671051,
-0.02547215297818184,
-0.21220391988754272,
-0.4561145305633545,
-0.29965847730636597,
-0.21330492198467255,
-0.49705442786216736,
0.6372556686401367,
0.021600132808089256,
0.23590940237045288,
0.6347537040710449,
-0.23844262957572937,
0.726630449295044,
-0.5388007164001465,
0.9652230143547058,
0.22236093878746033,
-0.6637212634086609,
0.4609248638153076,
-0.47907543182373047,
0.236400306224823,
0.38324815034866333,
-0.011002343147993088,
-0.14126121997833252,
-0.6428875923156738,
-0.35778969526290894,
-0.9526650905609131,
0.3018439710140228,
0.4762488603591919,
0.20543120801448822,
0.09465620666742325,
0.06001194193959236,
-0.07901211827993393,
0.5077922940254211,
-1.0308107137680054,
-0.2309567779302597,
-0.5259565114974976,
-0.08797510713338852,
0.10036350786685944,
0.06323181092739105,
-0.019587790593504906,
-0.5626779794692993,
0.36155450344085693,
-0.005946981254965067,
0.09645702689886093,
0.3497902750968933,
-0.18339532613754272,
-0.02934129908680916,
-0.002216943772509694,
1.014886498451233,
0.567703366279602,
-0.2266908437013626,
0.24242234230041504,
-0.005463986657559872,
-0.3859810531139374,
-0.08867720514535904,
-0.07514200359582901,
-0.4099394679069519,
0.08648063987493515,
0.3691845238208771,
0.9415920376777649,
-0.21409769356250763,
-1.0336557626724243,
0.8347128033638,
0.10852066427469254,
-0.16068430244922638,
-0.8193631172180176,
-0.1196104884147644,
-0.47180527448654175,
0.2971038222312927,
0.35961300134658813,
0.17779697477817535,
0.3642710745334625,
-0.33257946372032166,
-0.01627887226641178,
0.5045077800750732,
-0.749904453754425,
-0.3982190489768982,
1.6284905672073364,
0.47022145986557007,
-0.23504693806171417,
0.27265551686286926,
-0.623903751373291,
-0.7334098219871521,
0.7624204754829407,
-0.22333790361881256,
0.9770334362983704,
0.06949213147163391,
0.10177625715732574,
0.23616833984851837,
0.33653897047042847,
0.35924071073532104,
0.4535084068775177,
-0.02754875272512436,
-0.522013783454895,
-0.5467302799224854,
-0.5462418794631958,
0.02004011906683445,
0.4511704444885254,
-0.5359670519828796,
0.21165914833545685,
-0.3324887454509735,
0.17102931439876556,
-0.10208877921104431,
-0.5586264133453369,
-0.921429455280304,
0.34260430932044983,
0.49943143129348755,
0.8078200221061707,
-0.6683706641197205,
0.8720961809158325,
0.7627677321434021,
-0.475175142288208,
-0.491610586643219,
-0.3741317689418793,
0.011378060095012188,
-0.6207882761955261,
0.5618773698806763,
0.1354253739118576,
-0.08729071915149689,
0.014251728542149067,
-0.9388778209686279,
-0.5730078220367432,
0.9198657870292664,
-0.11538974195718765,
-0.6808227300643921,
-0.03652321547269821,
0.2375594526529312,
0.30038291215896606,
-0.6020393967628479,
-0.19492770731449127,
0.2696208655834198,
0.6691979765892029,
0.12008651345968246,
-0.7253941893577576,
-0.33550530672073364,
0.13602790236473083,
-0.07583918422460556,
-0.09527371823787689,
-1.1125843524932861,
0.5453392267227173,
-0.45947128534317017,
-0.025751721113920212,
0.38302120566368103,
0.7340512275695801,
-0.2377471625804901,
0.42628759145736694,
0.5643343925476074,
0.2299729287624359,
0.25454482436180115,
0.009677459485828876,
1.0834790468215942,
-0.0031893691048026085,
0.11937476694583893,
1.2474865913391113,
-0.10534583032131195,
0.39220190048217773,
0.42118149995803833,
-0.10496922582387924,
0.4031805694103241,
0.18286389112472534,
-0.2653452754020691,
0.8549930453300476,
0.09202057868242264,
-0.15341241657733917,
-0.9529557824134827,
-0.1320357620716095,
0.14394071698188782,
0.8224680423736572,
0.05128854513168335,
-0.09678930789232254,
-0.019391532987356186,
0.533888578414917,
-0.3197169899940491,
0.04283386468887329,
-0.7966970205307007,
0.8238771557807922,
-0.28222399950027466,
-0.5238528251647949,
0.12405294924974442,
-0.013537825085222721,
0.10060025751590729,
-0.5718039274215698,
-0.019841643050312996,
-0.10520309954881668,
0.08517033606767654,
-0.013126816600561142,
-0.8274242281913757,
0.382949560880661,
-0.03020602837204933,
-0.09281348437070847,
-0.2689495384693146,
0.3453095853328705,
-0.8672431111335754,
-0.5721844434738159,
-0.07642216980457306,
0.19773437082767487,
0.4349372684955597,
-0.2421596348285675,
-0.32503849267959595,
0.04995456337928772,
0.1682319939136505,
0.03281348571181297,
-0.05192447826266289,
0.23257926106452942,
-0.29856953024864197,
0.9710095524787903,
0.2466631382703781,
0.041676320135593414,
0.47057676315307617,
0.3454885482788086,
0.718171238899231,
-0.6656478643417358,
-0.6358986496925354,
-0.8727314472198486,
0.9072733521461487,
-0.16711243987083435,
-0.15611842274665833,
0.7475757598876953,
1.0022000074386597,
0.7329955101013184,
-0.2387317568063736,
1.0531638860702515,
-0.04432738572359085,
0.2208108752965927,
-0.605271577835083,
0.17986060678958893,
-0.7524557709693909,
0.21717536449432373,
0.09523562341928482,
-0.5266023874282837,
-0.3183627724647522,
0.16963869333267212,
0.12530115246772766,
-0.323477566242218,
0.32388851046562195,
0.6313090920448303,
-0.23888270556926727,
-0.44004061818122864,
0.5338813662528992,
0.13305281102657318,
0.40878117084503174,
0.5871469974517822,
0.9664930701255798,
-0.2716979682445526,
0.9846980571746826,
-0.10227689146995544,
0.04548390582203865,
-0.3877575397491455,
-0.7357543110847473,
-0.8503669500350952,
-0.7748804092407227,
-0.6740193367004395,
-0.016934383660554886,
0.00030044568120501935,
0.2791889011859894,
1.0427062511444092,
-0.6493768095970154,
-0.027431374415755272,
-0.11105939000844955,
0.0964350625872612,
-0.05481309816241264,
-0.30593758821487427,
0.13034158945083618,
0.06923642009496689,
-0.8185949325561523,
0.278378963470459,
0.6082132458686829,
0.2572160065174103,
-0.6300153136253357,
-0.3319522440433502,
0.09264359623193741,
0.06818550825119019,
0.4824505150318146,
0.23040330410003662,
-0.7533536553382874,
-0.5085322260856628,
-0.31647855043411255,
-0.2559630572795868,
0.18242506682872772,
0.8891561627388,
-0.5573959946632385,
0.5605047345161438,
0.32358190417289734,
0.15252210199832916,
0.5527581572532654,
0.2966485619544983,
0.5896070003509521,
-0.9399473667144775,
0.364910364151001,
0.006886492948979139,
0.45292067527770996,
0.47692805528640747,
-0.1065697893500328,
0.29489865899086,
0.36515012383461,
-0.39059919118881226,
-0.5886539816856384,
0.45668280124664307,
-1.3775737285614014,
-0.29833295941352844,
1.2357193231582642,
0.13065683841705322,
-0.20482756197452545,
-0.441359281539917,
-0.254897803068161,
-0.09773077070713043,
-0.4620044529438019,
0.690412163734436,
0.1545879989862442,
0.1505861133337021,
-0.3947007358074188,
-0.835983157157898,
0.5038420557975769,
0.007544830907136202,
-0.4954942762851715,
0.19359657168388367,
0.6650344133377075,
0.10106877237558365,
-0.09998807311058044,
0.6234521865844727,
0.04520703852176666,
0.4196528196334839,
-0.4886711537837982,
0.114894337952137,
-0.5246095657348633,
-0.6935396194458008,
-0.2914685308933258,
0.3058467209339142,
-0.4178764224052429,
-0.5286403298377991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09260v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09260v1
|
JaFIn: Japanese Financial Instruction Dataset
| 2024-04-14T14:01:53 | 2024-04-14T14:01:53 |
Kota Tanabe, Masahiro Suzuki, Hiroki Sakaji, Itsuki Noda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CE
|
We construct an instruction dataset for the large language model (LLM) in the
Japanese finance domain. Domain adaptation of language models, including LLMs,
is receiving more attention as language models become more popular. This study
demonstrates the effectiveness of domain adaptation through instruction tuning.
To achieve this, we propose an instruction tuning data in Japanese called
JaFIn, the Japanese Financial Instruction Dataset. JaFIn is manually
constructed based on multiple data sources, including Japanese government
websites, which provide extensive financial knowledge. We then utilize JaFIn to
apply instruction tuning for several LLMs, demonstrating that our models
specialized in finance have better domain adaptability than the original
models. The financial-specialized LLMs created were evaluated using a
quantitative Japanese financial benchmark and qualitative response comparisons,
showing improved performance over the originals.
|
[
-0.2842303216457367,
-0.9103090763092041,
0.24005073308944702,
-0.06398069113492966,
-0.202370285987854,
0.19044817984104156,
-0.34419122338294983,
-0.1814933866262436,
-0.15498723089694977,
0.9743397235870361,
-0.6516781449317932,
-0.748116672039032,
-0.5962132811546326,
-0.02730008214712143,
-0.06604594737291336,
1.0263233184814453,
-0.03617104887962341,
0.0782184898853302,
-0.2259318232536316,
0.15124140679836273,
-0.5767577886581421,
-0.1417206972837448,
-1.0678316354751587,
-0.35194045305252075,
0.19646607339382172,
0.7412601709365845,
0.8102346658706665,
0.7255166172981262,
0.7404335141181946,
0.3579998016357422,
0.5385549068450928,
-0.021917320787906647,
-0.6249958276748657,
-0.12787368893623352,
-0.2508835792541504,
-0.8186355233192444,
-0.6823121309280396,
-0.164957195520401,
0.7462468147277832,
0.8172670602798462,
-0.1558273434638977,
0.26288098096847534,
-0.19460706412792206,
0.8814595341682434,
-0.7604820132255554,
0.7549363374710083,
-0.34740573167800903,
-0.0147733548656106,
-0.38200846314430237,
-0.4302038550376892,
-0.5560985803604126,
-0.47864434123039246,
0.31644877791404724,
-1.0295624732971191,
0.19821931421756744,
0.34836018085479736,
0.5297920107841492,
0.12917019426822662,
-0.4852864742279053,
-0.3285670280456543,
-0.5676364302635193,
0.6973843574523926,
-0.6818152666091919,
0.4077011048793793,
0.5879226326942444,
0.5149235129356384,
-0.40058082342147827,
-0.47851240634918213,
0.006622109562158585,
0.01623477414250374,
0.11694679409265518,
0.30284470319747925,
-0.02106644958257675,
0.12738429009914398,
0.3573077917098999,
0.41109922528266907,
-0.4774352014064789,
0.24491536617279053,
-0.3071087896823883,
-0.005177344661206007,
0.8046340346336365,
0.3458307087421417,
0.1837291121482849,
0.10959939658641815,
-0.30112940073013306,
-0.6371548771858215,
-0.5937981009483337,
-0.2199455350637436,
0.5082353949546814,
0.6356186270713806,
-0.3309408724308014,
0.2704761028289795,
-0.09338261187076569,
0.8710660934448242,
0.029410380870103836,
-0.862263023853302,
0.019953198730945587,
0.037289105355739594,
-0.4428292512893677,
0.48871955275535583,
0.3882542550563812,
0.45023393630981445,
0.6172149181365967,
0.10846208035945892,
-0.2689387798309326,
-0.5415326952934265,
0.280386745929718,
-0.4403746426105499,
-0.18727447092533112,
-0.29413095116615295,
-0.2864319980144501,
0.023608364164829254,
0.2752951383590698,
-0.7917540073394775,
-0.19125328958034515,
-0.40693509578704834,
0.4732638895511627,
-0.26422324776649475,
-0.13616172969341278,
0.491658478975296,
-0.3370918035507202,
0.4739045798778534,
0.1527642458677292,
-1.1393486261367798,
0.6990864276885986,
0.7822520136833191,
0.6219826936721802,
0.019230389967560768,
-0.07901905477046967,
-0.06713090091943741,
0.5423333048820496,
-0.49098333716392517,
0.6889156103134155,
-0.7147716283798218,
-0.8458337783813477,
-0.08684335649013519,
0.3410996198654175,
-0.37287601828575134,
-0.35622069239616394,
0.09957941621541977,
-0.624742329120636,
0.3897748291492462,
-0.13089585304260254,
-0.8736696243286133,
-0.3755738139152527,
-0.06808248907327652,
-0.6288861036300659,
0.5852828025817871,
0.48735907673835754,
-0.5844193696975708,
0.21130897104740143,
-1.127585768699646,
-0.5340666174888611,
0.20695137977600098,
0.3141856789588928,
-0.5860609412193298,
0.009651345200836658,
0.23716318607330322,
0.32169994711875916,
-0.6090142130851746,
0.26492559909820557,
-0.5119989514350891,
-0.6481881141662598,
0.5599656105041504,
-0.5268950462341309,
0.5534088611602783,
0.11167927831411362,
-0.15276022255420685,
-0.3878193795681,
-0.8994048833847046,
-0.25518420338630676,
0.31863144040107727,
0.05116560682654381,
-0.9041969180107117,
-0.06720826029777527,
-0.40079423785209656,
-0.5473765134811401,
0.31219416856765747,
-0.10965221375226974,
0.2615582346916199,
-0.574592649936676,
-0.002993099857121706,
1.1557881832122803,
0.3785751461982727,
0.38834819197654724,
-0.4018600583076477,
0.9461017847061157,
-0.08575243502855301,
0.3163917362689972,
-0.34060153365135193,
-0.20210449397563934,
-1.0723183155059814,
-0.03672890365123749,
0.3912331163883209,
0.4759020507335663,
-0.6179670691490173,
0.1421348750591278,
-0.27604538202285767,
-0.1801445037126541,
-0.4843512773513794,
0.1062261313199997,
0.43587905168533325,
0.5744052529335022,
-0.12368591129779816,
-0.2182265818119049,
-0.4781395196914673,
-1.0374984741210938,
-0.0835254117846489,
0.15690924227237701,
0.24455484747886658,
0.33453670144081116,
0.45229804515838623,
0.09275340288877487,
0.44768229126930237,
-0.8877785801887512,
0.13144747912883759,
0.024808933958411217,
-0.05767325311899185,
0.5063058733940125,
0.30121538043022156,
0.7488439083099365,
-0.5326516032218933,
-0.5698105692863464,
0.23480157554149628,
-0.6346917152404785,
0.0587884895503521,
-0.32643255591392517,
-0.42181453108787537,
-0.09930957853794098,
0.24506257474422455,
0.34371742606163025,
0.18116840720176697,
0.3346218168735504,
-0.4744258224964142,
0.09015115350484848,
-0.18277354538440704,
0.3687942326068878,
-1.1872719526290894,
0.007970835082232952,
0.22867229580879211,
-0.5544989109039307,
-0.3979063928127289,
0.07685493677854538,
-0.007835418917238712,
-0.14566069841384888,
-0.2105591744184494,
0.595069944858551,
-0.4194648563861847,
-0.5799429416656494,
-0.5481857061386108,
0.069757841527462,
-0.028861653059720993,
0.543129026889801,
-0.15381954610347748,
1.286084532737732,
0.6471657752990723,
-0.7504188418388367,
0.5487295985221863,
0.333238810300827,
-0.7161914110183716,
0.6238855123519897,
-0.48094120621681213,
0.10569550096988678,
-0.08683919906616211,
-0.1981707364320755,
-0.800487756729126,
-0.5773309469223022,
0.4698582589626312,
0.18758271634578705,
0.5231837630271912,
-0.06612997502088547,
-0.199640691280365,
-0.32716089487075806,
-0.051757652312517166,
0.005390119273215532,
0.4735279083251953,
-0.5157418847084045,
0.20847079157829285,
0.3911278247833252,
-0.7181106209754944,
-0.5272255539894104,
-0.5298501253128052,
-0.18851734697818756,
-0.3098340928554535,
-0.13773556053638458,
0.09296134859323502,
-0.0927758663892746,
-0.2609367072582245,
0.05194553732872009,
-0.04359235614538193,
0.02595345675945282,
0.5560328960418701,
0.22046948969364166,
0.7646631598472595,
-0.7535347938537598,
0.011823923327028751,
0.45717954635620117,
-0.29177752137184143,
0.17814785242080688,
-0.28494828939437866,
0.11950389295816422,
0.09174983203411102,
-0.30854517221450806,
-0.24699093401432037,
-0.07555633038282394,
0.42674410343170166,
0.4399334192276001,
0.7142858505249023,
0.05093603581190109,
-0.07053766399621964,
-0.3087210953235626,
-0.3052869737148285,
0.1923237442970276,
-0.5788788199424744,
0.28343653678894043,
-0.48454779386520386,
-1.0741031169891357,
0.3521554172039032,
-0.3192597031593323,
0.18475668132305145,
0.6199882626533508,
0.37304022908210754,
0.10040401667356491,
0.8865028023719788,
0.9402605891227722,
-0.2611362040042877,
0.6260544061660767,
-0.026910269632935524,
-0.01630677655339241,
-0.6045450568199158,
-0.17772802710533142,
-0.3943179249763489,
-0.3140163719654083,
-0.48754066228866577,
-0.1711263507604599,
0.45643410086631775,
-0.1302744448184967,
-0.4889071583747864,
0.23518195748329163,
-0.03461085632443428,
0.9409535527229309,
0.38694626092910767,
0.06781452149152756,
0.22592109441757202,
0.2507971525192261,
0.04438113048672676,
-0.019473452121019363,
-0.6891185641288757,
-0.2651097774505615,
1.4471653699874878,
0.4259549379348755,
0.9501472115516663,
0.0341845378279686,
0.22779801487922668,
0.5281280279159546,
0.41207778453826904,
-0.5769942998886108,
0.2794170677661896,
-0.5467302799224854,
-0.5900382399559021,
-0.21993570029735565,
-0.6043354868888855,
-0.7137333154678345,
-0.2220284789800644,
-0.02073770947754383,
-0.2992818355560303,
-0.0706145316362381,
-0.24660831689834595,
-0.3762749135494232,
-0.07213805615901947,
-0.6019066572189331,
0.7036420702934265,
-0.4056069552898407,
-0.1626092493534088,
-0.11829957365989685,
-0.20857584476470947,
0.7527708411216736,
-0.5918058156967163,
0.36964336037635803,
-0.2753688395023346,
-0.08285170048475266,
1.046257734298706,
-0.38006311655044556,
1.1125503778457642,
-0.22990167140960693,
-0.3962962329387665,
0.003417949192225933,
-0.3530121147632599,
0.26015955209732056,
0.23891957104206085,
-0.26064300537109375,
-0.1737861931324005,
-0.1707754135131836,
-0.49800318479537964,
-0.7460561990737915,
0.8529273867607117,
-1.1597015857696533,
-0.8109530806541443,
-0.26002851128578186,
-0.7148638367652893,
-0.5117193460464478,
0.1798785924911499,
-0.09951559454202652,
0.43163153529167175,
-0.34565261006355286,
0.11299815773963928,
0.7293696999549866,
-0.22527959942817688,
0.22474054992198944,
1.02605140209198,
-0.30771365761756897,
-0.6500340700149536,
0.8373206853866577,
-0.022486263886094093,
0.2275819182395935,
0.49086588621139526,
0.17385046184062958,
-0.3752549886703491,
-0.11314037442207336,
-0.5070489645004272,
0.2715463936328888,
-0.8205063939094543,
-0.2917618751525879,
0.12417247891426086,
-0.37522709369659424,
-0.5253294706344604,
-0.5084377527236938,
-0.31797489523887634,
-0.37612536549568176,
-0.18292278051376343,
-0.1841534972190857,
0.8443187475204468,
0.7955982685089111,
0.11364953219890594,
0.6766468286514282,
-0.7229323387145996,
0.31236013770103455,
0.2872089445590973,
0.6821005940437317,
-0.15758882462978363,
-0.8156335949897766,
-0.6208644509315491,
0.20502562820911407,
0.06730812788009644,
-0.4312831461429596,
0.1729934811592102,
0.5210673213005066,
0.7357557415962219,
0.756600558757782,
0.018674513325095177,
1.082686185836792,
0.02540419064462185,
0.41425764560699463,
0.17327754199504852,
-0.9093685746192932,
0.6888765692710876,
-0.2775430977344513,
0.5648978352546692,
0.5306801795959473,
0.6746799945831299,
-0.39268171787261963,
-0.39490804076194763,
-0.5238737463951111,
-0.4483529329299927,
0.9606554508209229,
-0.29661989212036133,
0.18766650557518005,
0.1923207938671112,
0.8708874583244324,
0.7363929748535156,
0.1329578459262848,
-0.34052038192749023,
-0.43336406350135803,
-0.047678641974925995,
-0.2576937675476074,
-0.45489761233329773,
-0.17002055048942566,
-0.09582997858524323,
-0.16705229878425598,
0.858867347240448,
-0.3259630501270294,
0.16530118882656097,
-0.41516849398612976,
0.025933170691132545,
-0.3592528998851776,
0.012975136749446392,
0.3950793743133545,
0.6966635584831238,
-0.10323522239923477,
-0.20062090456485748,
0.2537589371204376,
-0.42763400077819824,
0.30018481612205505,
-0.09622825682163239,
-0.2250094711780548,
-0.09192001819610596,
0.5096309185028076,
1.3971012830734253,
0.9990462064743042,
-0.6859618425369263,
0.25325921177864075,
-0.1262260526418686,
-0.40680068731307983,
-0.41397354006767273,
0.8540862798690796,
-0.10763884335756302,
0.17722736299037933,
0.1342833787202835,
-0.20453688502311707,
0.05632634833455086,
-0.6036388874053955,
0.10078393667936325,
0.03283026069402695,
-0.11428079754114151,
-0.11285566538572311,
0.6076236367225647,
0.07647791504859924,
-0.09650535136461258,
0.8202586770057678,
0.3343464732170105,
-0.13721393048763275,
0.7525184750556946,
1.0800824165344238,
0.7853186726570129,
-0.33713486790657043,
0.2877851724624634,
0.49941009283065796,
-0.03917447477579117,
-0.3948555290699005,
0.32831501960754395,
-0.08841105550527573,
-0.6826199293136597,
-0.44488832354545593,
-0.7241161465644836,
-0.7962745428085327,
-0.012902310118079185,
-1.201930284500122,
0.22251015901565552,
-0.9786256551742554,
-0.27686047554016113,
-0.022003237158060074,
0.17815421521663666,
-0.5892412662506104,
0.34910082817077637,
0.2368917167186737,
0.8854678869247437,
-0.9763637185096741,
0.7830652594566345,
0.6422345042228699,
0.0006033669924363494,
-0.3862847685813904,
-0.35196176171302795,
-0.10313330590724945,
-1.126846194267273,
0.2902032136917114,
-0.1895856112241745,
-0.08363208919763565,
0.19602560997009277,
-0.5608883500099182,
-1.1181209087371826,
1.1198005676269531,
0.5642567276954651,
-1.1709781885147095,
0.2530175447463989,
0.4035312533378601,
0.18701337277889252,
-0.48564550280570984,
-0.05424651876091957,
0.8358360528945923,
0.6961564421653748,
0.05430728569626808,
-0.3918273150920868,
-0.3464568853378296,
-0.27924206852912903,
0.2187373787164688,
0.4318128526210785,
-0.89516282081604,
0.31813299655914307,
0.025266345590353012,
-0.1328720599412918,
-0.12689000368118286,
0.6464883685112,
0.1301703006029129,
0.426270067691803,
0.38401347398757935,
0.29247891902923584,
1.0076541900634766,
-0.1827598661184311,
0.9943967461585999,
-0.5217553377151489,
0.15250979363918304,
1.0010634660720825,
-0.33513256907463074,
0.6387737393379211,
-0.10755714029073715,
-0.38765498995780945,
0.6237802505493164,
0.5941000580787659,
-0.33170056343078613,
0.5742156505584717,
0.011843179352581501,
-0.13753031194210052,
-0.35142824053764343,
-0.020142827183008194,
-0.3774494230747223,
0.6082891225814819,
0.550889253616333,
-0.3033665716648102,
0.13836881518363953,
0.33162587881088257,
-0.003766789101064205,
-0.03378090634942055,
-0.546603262424469,
0.9348004460334778,
0.3091943562030792,
-0.5843376517295837,
0.22736023366451263,
0.27300509810447693,
0.16365326941013336,
-0.9445260167121887,
0.24542425572872162,
-0.5058716535568237,
0.21276703476905823,
0.24964173138141632,
-0.6169313788414001,
0.2715793550014496,
0.280711829662323,
-0.34549638628959656,
-0.22091072797775269,
0.742347240447998,
-0.19022341072559357,
-0.9295564293861389,
0.09379381686449051,
0.22680968046188354,
0.11930644512176514,
0.7089434862136841,
-0.8292524814605713,
0.04741024971008301,
0.06315596401691437,
-0.37820982933044434,
0.5723613500595093,
0.39270341396331787,
0.01668359898030758,
0.5925090909004211,
0.7685320973396301,
-0.017391996458172798,
-0.18136197328567505,
0.4086636006832123,
0.5883145928382874,
-1.0697375535964966,
-0.5432648658752441,
-0.64739590883255,
0.025141103193163872,
-0.036428436636924744,
-0.5116665363311768,
0.9065515398979187,
0.5807235836982727,
1.0016366243362427,
-0.21505677700042725,
0.9456490874290466,
0.6486311554908752,
0.316940575838089,
-0.9430872797966003,
0.490843802690506,
-0.4933067858219147,
0.3013460338115692,
-0.15330666303634644,
-0.8709782958030701,
-0.31172654032707214,
0.6529263257980347,
-0.4347916841506958,
0.0018423498841002584,
0.36511316895484924,
0.7422112226486206,
-0.2853519320487976,
0.427473783493042,
0.4326466917991638,
0.20267675817012787,
-0.2010604441165924,
0.7441557049751282,
0.593242347240448,
-0.5248798727989197,
-0.11316712945699692,
-0.33982354402542114,
-0.07166759669780731,
-0.3873904049396515,
-0.7144749760627747,
-0.9279988408088684,
-0.22474202513694763,
-0.7018628120422363,
0.24170006811618805,
0.45696404576301575,
0.7848883867263794,
0.3880370855331421,
-0.9058240056037903,
-0.5557910799980164,
0.23438598215579987,
0.0583701990544796,
-0.1719917356967926,
-0.2421291023492813,
0.19212950766086578,
-0.3527722954750061,
-0.8306717276573181,
0.7091122269630432,
0.5718231797218323,
0.22596028447151184,
-0.23221614956855774,
-0.17004893720149994,
0.3494310677051544,
0.33455750346183777,
0.2581028342247009,
0.09074542671442032,
-0.11555381864309311,
-0.2509419322013855,
-0.009196859784424305,
-0.1601172685623169,
-0.09090442955493927,
0.8132651448249817,
-0.18504101037979126,
0.5428026914596558,
0.17766906321048737,
0.606331467628479,
0.4770541787147522,
-0.0419793538749218,
1.0015819072723389,
-0.5575252771377563,
0.21499311923980713,
-0.3854144215583801,
0.3264677822589874,
0.11709760874509811,
-0.4862709641456604,
0.4768120050430298,
0.14281904697418213,
-0.32138723134994507,
-0.36379435658454895,
-0.22913441061973572,
-0.7621458172798157,
-0.5250251293182373,
0.7888770699501038,
-0.24077829718589783,
-0.7822265625,
-0.02943389117717743,
0.07638102024793625,
0.17388802766799927,
-0.29603126645088196,
0.6722184419631958,
0.7343299984931946,
0.35774490237236023,
-0.3289068043231964,
-0.6207849979400635,
0.0867576077580452,
0.10990002006292343,
-0.6650158166885376,
-0.04605088755488396,
0.31549617648124695,
0.47948625683784485,
-0.4685017466545105,
0.43213534355163574,
0.013690193183720112,
0.4780691862106323,
0.2178153395652771,
-0.16157765686511993,
-0.27345117926597595,
-0.27846425771713257,
-0.31596094369888306,
0.2111877053976059,
0.2667078971862793,
0.034374985843896866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09249v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09249v1
|
Test Code Generation for Telecom Software Systems using Two-Stage Generative Model
| 2024-04-14T13:25:15 | 2024-04-14T13:25:15 |
Mohamad Nabeel, Doumitrou Daniil Nimara, Tahar Zanouda
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In recent years, the evolution of Telecom towards achieving intelligent,
autonomous, and open networks has led to an increasingly complex Telecom
Software system, supporting various heterogeneous deployment scenarios, with
multi-standard and multi-vendor support. As a result, it becomes a challenge
for large-scale Telecom software companies to develop and test software for all
deployment scenarios. To address these challenges, we propose a framework for
Automated Test Generation for large-scale Telecom Software systems. We begin by
generating Test Case Input data for test scenarios observed using a time-series
Generative model trained on historical Telecom Network data during field
trials. Additionally, the time-series Generative model helps in preserving the
privacy of Telecom data. The generated time-series software performance data
are then utilized with test descriptions written in natural language to
generate Test Script using the Generative Large Language Model. Our
comprehensive experiments on public datasets and Telecom datasets obtained from
operational Telecom Networks demonstrate that the framework can effectively
generate comprehensive test case data input and useful test code.
|
[
-0.5292761325836182,
-0.7558943033218384,
0.060113102197647095,
0.4769318401813507,
-0.11674601584672928,
-0.34691500663757324,
0.17742697894573212,
-0.1432700902223587,
-0.14681413769721985,
0.7080484628677368,
-0.5710092782974243,
-0.3426300287246704,
0.1430177539587021,
0.06518742442131042,
-0.6772274374961853,
0.9843713641166687,
-0.16132481396198273,
-0.21887259185314178,
0.2484014630317688,
0.049083005636930466,
-0.30937284231185913,
-0.4564017951488495,
-0.31364747881889343,
-0.3378649652004242,
-0.14898504316806793,
0.4003273844718933,
0.5070891976356506,
0.1207984909415245,
0.20499630272388458,
0.20154301822185516,
0.3247222304344177,
-0.08232278376817703,
-0.10235555469989777,
0.31999829411506653,
0.2625496983528137,
-0.4465276598930359,
-0.2685921788215637,
-0.15621580183506012,
0.585533618927002,
0.48263946175575256,
-0.5543155074119568,
0.5704077482223511,
-0.08075198531150818,
0.23822279274463654,
-0.30340054631233215,
0.24913246929645538,
-0.6521304249763489,
0.3077969253063202,
-0.20638491213321686,
-0.327644944190979,
-0.5007739663124084,
-0.6064660549163818,
-0.0021352586336433887,
-0.48360154032707214,
0.3403624892234802,
0.049534592777490616,
0.8991747498512268,
-0.0030865115113556385,
-0.8315255045890808,
-0.036740053445100784,
-1.0143920183181763,
0.7333503365516663,
-0.7128146290779114,
0.2874251902103424,
0.14827793836593628,
0.6796475052833557,
-0.22595278918743134,
-0.4932348132133484,
-0.6153886914253235,
-0.5194911360740662,
0.42249056696891785,
0.16574904322624207,
0.08811787515878677,
-0.2700798213481903,
0.47381478548049927,
0.36665329337120056,
-0.711984395980835,
0.24889902770519257,
-0.6240520477294922,
-0.11050160974264145,
0.7255493998527527,
0.2974718511104584,
0.12835612893104553,
-0.15321578085422516,
-0.2906314730644226,
0.14011748135089874,
-0.9050734043121338,
-0.13216976821422577,
0.582194447517395,
0.1896628886461258,
-0.14352406561374664,
0.9580662846565247,
-0.2940053641796112,
0.6985570788383484,
-0.2490248680114746,
0.058915477246046066,
0.17145317792892456,
-0.3115786612033844,
-0.5449263453483582,
0.06400665640830994,
0.533353865146637,
0.40121686458587646,
0.41596218943595886,
-0.14769940078258514,
-0.2736455202102661,
0.4337724447250366,
0.534269392490387,
-1.0085755586624146,
-0.11042506992816925,
0.36758217215538025,
-0.4643953740596771,
-0.8392581939697266,
0.135764941573143,
-0.975185751914978,
-0.12666547298431396,
-0.22648757696151733,
0.19292710721492767,
-0.19400042295455933,
-0.6320449113845825,
0.19221124053001404,
0.06578231602907181,
0.6161056160926819,
-0.15965212881565094,
-0.39097100496292114,
0.3037359118461609,
0.4916887581348419,
0.5631827712059021,
-0.016019361093640327,
-0.29460254311561584,
-0.8102145791053772,
0.32251062989234924,
-0.5625336170196533,
0.1475653499364853,
0.03202015906572342,
-0.41068148612976074,
0.2950756251811981,
-0.11462950706481934,
0.020727435126900673,
-0.5484520792961121,
0.07332661002874374,
-0.8736628890037537,
0.3675427734851837,
0.5221428275108337,
-0.39483270049095154,
0.2064974308013916,
0.1322963684797287,
-0.4996528625488281,
1.1556192636489868,
0.20958566665649414,
-0.6677884459495544,
0.2730517089366913,
-0.9565739631652832,
-0.4487098455429077,
-0.014521741308271885,
-0.14346279203891754,
-0.7938973307609558,
-0.25432276725769043,
-0.07690131664276123,
0.3493010103702545,
-0.5061736106872559,
0.23611746728420258,
-0.5079182982444763,
-0.1977950483560562,
0.3200634717941284,
0.011008591391146183,
0.7786601185798645,
0.36963608860969543,
-0.8501230478286743,
-0.3362082540988922,
-0.8010202646255493,
0.5127519369125366,
0.1208701953291893,
-0.2513278126716614,
-0.04563070088624954,
0.111270472407341,
0.2661440074443817,
0.16921080648899078,
-0.2562035024166107,
-0.8674071431159973,
0.08812704682350159,
-0.3287526071071625,
0.44814953207969666,
0.4995722472667694,
0.08854981511831284,
0.2934098243713379,
-0.04485294595360756,
0.7704772353172302,
0.33268842101097107,
0.6507362127304077,
-0.32711678743362427,
-0.3223823606967926,
-0.8363083004951477,
0.2995918095111847,
0.46307817101478577,
0.8538405895233154,
-0.7011372447013855,
0.6893929243087769,
-0.29120194911956787,
-0.41709330677986145,
0.18353652954101562,
0.12140242755413055,
0.3337738513946533,
0.24208156764507294,
-0.033652760088443756,
-0.30821698904037476,
-0.30358579754829407,
-0.8511525988578796,
0.4813776910305023,
-0.21589013934135437,
-0.3675226867198944,
0.1859903186559677,
0.42684271931648254,
-0.2899215519428253,
0.9286171793937683,
-0.8815504908561707,
-0.42435261607170105,
-0.17250075936317444,
0.2208329141139984,
-0.185912624001503,
0.36414989829063416,
0.5654829144477844,
-1.022823452949524,
0.29200637340545654,
0.12312860041856766,
-0.6357937455177307,
-0.229189932346344,
0.07357697188854218,
0.06978978961706161,
0.28669273853302,
0.5675595998764038,
-0.0653127059340477,
0.41195639967918396,
0.8514071702957153,
-0.2880198061466217,
0.8373582363128662,
-0.1623692363500595,
0.00969301350414753,
-1.4400044679641724,
0.1830022782087326,
0.029206302016973495,
0.006562626454979181,
-0.31476613879203796,
0.09651580452919006,
-0.03662336617708206,
-0.7987815141677856,
-0.29816970229148865,
0.04405876249074936,
-0.21412625908851624,
-0.40759986639022827,
0.05345095321536064,
-0.38367146253585815,
-0.07821957767009735,
0.20996779203414917,
-0.2998471260070801,
0.9596177935600281,
0.43047788739204407,
-0.9510107040405273,
0.33218222856521606,
0.08775418251752853,
-0.5298370718955994,
0.35545602440834045,
-0.8325620293617249,
-0.14050106704235077,
0.19872546195983887,
0.42897701263427734,
-0.8065303564071655,
-0.3946496844291687,
-0.10652504861354828,
-0.07722895592451096,
-0.40973126888275146,
-0.35480019450187683,
-0.7842249870300293,
-0.5330442190170288,
0.29529017210006714,
0.3587983548641205,
0.7613070607185364,
-0.33021900057792664,
0.43899422883987427,
0.4621376097202301,
-0.263465017080307,
-0.1073504090309143,
-0.7543308734893799,
0.11549541354179382,
-0.24344861507415771,
-0.8725044131278992,
0.2819809019565582,
0.17427381873130798,
-0.11891091614961624,
-0.28444716334342957,
0.17763251066207886,
-0.5636182427406311,
0.13156570494174957,
0.6241321563720703,
0.32282397150993347,
-0.3314973711967468,
0.1039699837565422,
0.021005166694521904,
0.019976936280727386,
0.33890053629875183,
-0.7691003680229187,
0.5161713361740112,
-0.015837399289011955,
-0.5401144027709961,
-0.25150105357170105,
0.7487219572067261,
0.667261004447937,
-0.4955996572971344,
0.19685064256191254,
0.4753400683403015,
-0.14809341728687286,
-0.7957867980003357,
-0.4206103980541229,
-0.011190359480679035,
-0.45937657356262207,
0.1258670687675476,
-0.42860162258148193,
-0.5301810503005981,
0.5117221474647522,
-0.32742419838905334,
0.26471027731895447,
0.23038922250270844,
0.4484540522098541,
0.39446812868118286,
1.012373685836792,
0.6551700830459595,
0.1657215654850006,
0.3762097954750061,
-0.47740256786346436,
0.30712032318115234,
-0.25681987404823303,
0.029068825766444206,
-0.36281925439834595,
0.188570037484169,
-0.44845709204673767,
-0.00023299281019717455,
0.8345569968223572,
-0.17579133808612823,
-0.27157890796661377,
0.38884538412094116,
-0.31571781635284424,
0.2231033742427826,
0.2404104322195053,
0.13610807061195374,
0.14534498751163483,
0.20156550407409668,
-0.5421839356422424,
0.21333907544612885,
-0.43762829899787903,
-0.30543437600135803,
1.1206254959106445,
0.17949335277080536,
0.7479044198989868,
0.39526674151420593,
0.592156708240509,
0.4385334849357605,
0.15369874238967896,
-0.3580266833305359,
0.40519964694976807,
-0.05834359675645828,
-0.4537661671638489,
-0.2864222824573517,
-0.6654888987541199,
-0.8346666693687439,
-0.321857213973999,
0.2786863446235657,
-0.26442989706993103,
-0.025994539260864258,
0.17821604013442993,
-0.5299511551856995,
0.09004810452461243,
-0.8791953325271606,
0.7214629650115967,
0.10501282662153244,
-0.053360022604465485,
-0.10578451305627823,
-0.48395708203315735,
0.6094628572463989,
-0.4402012825012207,
-0.12955982983112335,
0.2681550979614258,
0.29795193672180176,
0.4725968539714813,
-0.6041990518569946,
0.7601865530014038,
-0.29480481147766113,
-0.26414796710014343,
0.3403182029724121,
0.3480857014656067,
0.3433929979801178,
0.2760375142097473,
-0.3976856470108032,
-0.010030707344412804,
0.00014531424676533788,
-0.2170836180448532,
-0.34029391407966614,
0.38089996576309204,
-0.391988605260849,
-0.05094468966126442,
-0.1831667423248291,
-0.3769198954105377,
-0.16374005377292633,
0.23744533956050873,
0.3884204626083374,
0.8681920170783997,
-0.2501746714115143,
-0.1225011870265007,
0.7620330452919006,
-0.35639455914497375,
0.23719938099384308,
0.4209132790565491,
-0.5386298894882202,
-0.14560359716415405,
0.5578548908233643,
0.0348433181643486,
0.538099467754364,
-0.11226537823677063,
-0.1534852236509323,
-0.3910866379737854,
-0.4941774308681488,
-0.6038919687271118,
-0.21458163857460022,
-0.1834074854850769,
-0.2680264413356781,
-0.48427894711494446,
-0.418415904045105,
-0.42508378624916077,
-0.0369185172021389,
-0.44094017148017883,
-0.2790893614292145,
0.13057440519332886,
0.21874885261058807,
0.346418172121048,
0.7448984980583191,
0.26106780767440796,
0.31559306383132935,
-0.6781876087188721,
0.5282984972000122,
0.3162813186645508,
0.46344998478889465,
-0.2057701200246811,
-0.07603783905506134,
-0.013286399655044079,
-0.037128061056137085,
-0.7519304156303406,
-0.535218358039856,
0.3220270574092865,
0.15836089849472046,
0.07388411462306976,
0.18202154338359833,
0.31412816047668457,
0.38779982924461365,
-0.5978161096572876,
0.9589206576347351,
0.2631702721118927,
-0.9786624312400818,
0.7555183172225952,
-0.5472001433372498,
0.10739290714263916,
0.1554322987794876,
-0.20880144834518433,
-0.32223838567733765,
-0.41219592094421387,
-0.6019231677055359,
-0.7022299766540527,
0.49681180715560913,
0.29866787791252136,
0.21774809062480927,
0.3428409695625305,
0.29123255610466003,
0.10130443423986435,
0.12989099323749542,
-0.37979942560195923,
0.012865698896348476,
-0.358046293258667,
0.02127445489168167,
0.012985184788703918,
0.03607191890478134,
-0.3928208649158478,
0.1549888700246811,
0.25667229294776917,
-0.23453663289546967,
0.29457780718803406,
0.2189047485589981,
0.15030750632286072,
-0.03630628064274788,
0.44256913661956787,
0.6342732310295105,
0.7767773270606995,
-0.02354472316801548,
-0.25927814841270447,
0.1392735242843628,
-0.44277340173721313,
0.431049644947052,
0.44191062450408936,
-0.40198782086372375,
0.1807478666305542,
-0.3360001742839813,
0.4555237293243408,
-0.01685718074440956,
-0.47662875056266785,
0.7124804258346558,
-0.06333751231431961,
-0.4306875765323639,
-1.0520720481872559,
0.3182230293750763,
-0.09059617668390274,
0.03887350857257843,
0.47759294509887695,
-0.11078100651502609,
0.10930830985307693,
-0.27069157361984253,
0.6365056037902832,
0.08391817659139633,
0.06561406701803207,
-0.2567185163497925,
0.9071288108825684,
0.435046911239624,
-0.07770739495754242,
0.6723415851593018,
-0.4472339153289795,
-0.5961300730705261,
1.0222766399383545,
0.6964635252952576,
0.7902151346206665,
-0.30874136090278625,
0.4525553584098816,
0.1462787389755249,
0.13513198494911194,
-0.1737944781780243,
0.4047089219093323,
0.1599409580230713,
-0.3430030047893524,
-0.6865638494491577,
-0.6876228451728821,
-0.24469757080078125,
0.3507053256034851,
-0.6065625548362732,
0.4323616027832031,
-0.43626290559768677,
-0.21981646120548248,
0.05012857913970947,
-0.22776208817958832,
-0.7192016243934631,
0.3096078038215637,
-0.09688010811805725,
1.0000072717666626,
-0.7501322031021118,
0.7555707693099976,
0.4255455732345581,
-0.1583724021911621,
-1.1464024782180786,
0.32501694560050964,
-0.21577435731887817,
-0.5015833973884583,
1.1262083053588867,
0.11302419006824493,
0.1469263881444931,
0.2753884196281433,
-0.04036201909184456,
-0.4012956917285919,
1.0331569910049438,
0.09445768594741821,
-0.38468798995018005,
-0.013951125554740429,
0.5084930062294006,
0.36104315519332886,
-0.4517726004123688,
0.1673758178949356,
0.08588667213916779,
0.32592928409576416,
0.021108556538820267,
-1.0139825344085693,
-0.06573119759559631,
-0.3916079103946686,
0.3433794677257538,
0.6051385402679443,
-0.46829742193222046,
0.7691084742546082,
-0.2786485552787781,
-0.2639600932598114,
0.054552145302295685,
0.33212870359420776,
-0.05072195827960968,
0.27449554204940796,
0.8997906446456909,
0.40162765979766846,
0.1368967890739441,
-0.09524112194776535,
1.1265435218811035,
-0.1870373636484146,
0.2555350661277771,
0.7687163352966309,
-0.8053843379020691,
0.5582677721977234,
0.05214822664856911,
-0.09952259063720703,
0.39572712779045105,
0.4474325180053711,
-0.4517393708229065,
0.22061295807361603,
0.6191782355308533,
-0.23780827224254608,
-0.11620279401540756,
0.02226950228214264,
-0.5134814977645874,
0.6680559515953064,
-0.12859590351581573,
-0.3527200520038605,
-0.5081255435943604,
0.08299712091684341,
-0.12442471086978912,
-0.38368967175483704,
0.025582073256373405,
0.5209099054336548,
-0.07193636149168015,
-0.8968409895896912,
0.651538610458374,
0.2030896097421646,
0.389468252658844,
-0.9118936657905579,
-0.10879795998334885,
-0.09346871078014374,
0.3598140776157379,
-0.09824226796627045,
-0.5803809762001038,
0.4217357337474823,
0.16679462790489197,
-0.06998728960752487,
-0.05964149162173271,
0.29741528630256653,
-0.17889761924743652,
-0.5718520283699036,
0.14783240854740143,
0.14399583637714386,
0.07833760231733322,
0.03328441455960274,
-0.44323599338531494,
0.005647577811032534,
0.01801554299890995,
-0.1643543392419815,
0.0695752426981926,
0.3082684576511383,
-0.037793949246406555,
0.6955953240394592,
0.8182582855224609,
0.303467333316803,
0.41930294036865234,
0.33012494444847107,
0.6332813501358032,
-0.4780269265174866,
-0.8117900490760803,
-0.35957586765289307,
0.45582711696624756,
-0.1952066719532013,
-0.6694439649581909,
0.5605465173721313,
0.7223901152610779,
0.588354766368866,
-0.1564735323190689,
1.117678165435791,
-0.27277982234954834,
0.15175895392894745,
-0.4800594449043274,
0.6334722638130188,
-0.3696621358394623,
0.22543151676654816,
-0.006208427250385284,
-0.7899654507637024,
-0.0965593159198761,
-0.08396352827548981,
0.0353599488735199,
-0.12960080802440643,
0.45437952876091003,
1.2161325216293335,
-0.4572363495826721,
0.342788964509964,
-0.005614731926470995,
0.050715841352939606,
0.556535542011261,
0.5935071110725403,
0.7993589043617249,
-0.7146322727203369,
0.805934727191925,
-0.23677968978881836,
-0.4014835059642792,
-0.18954747915267944,
-0.7570171356201172,
-0.5125004649162292,
-0.6802975535392761,
-0.3440955579280853,
-0.8004361987113953,
-0.04090381786227226,
0.35289621353149414,
0.8178613781929016,
-0.616506814956665,
-0.2995172142982483,
-0.4474697411060333,
-0.407354474067688,
-0.24482829868793488,
-0.3831891119480133,
0.010707301087677479,
-0.3726484477519989,
-0.5834745764732361,
-0.02719852700829506,
0.06858253479003906,
0.20744727551937103,
-0.7030847072601318,
0.08252902328968048,
0.4726536273956299,
-0.1814795881509781,
0.5541968941688538,
0.10785240679979324,
-0.32787302136421204,
-0.14580762386322021,
0.0760740265250206,
-0.08105731755495071,
-0.4460247755050659,
1.0506953001022339,
-0.48566949367523193,
0.13591256737709045,
0.18499623239040375,
0.4243699610233307,
0.293695867061615,
-0.10544982552528381,
1.0316396951675415,
-0.6413736939430237,
0.08751493692398071,
0.26591426134109497,
0.03299281373620033,
0.0033564686309546232,
-0.46056148409843445,
0.6570881605148315,
-0.032683346420526505,
-0.6482117772102356,
-1.1266369819641113,
0.575710117816925,
-1.0380665063858032,
0.12451191991567612,
1.4177926778793335,
-0.12381033599376678,
0.06678452342748642,
-0.3411492109298706,
0.11519800126552582,
0.3640507757663727,
-0.024582983925938606,
0.9419676065444946,
0.3709504008293152,
0.07173115760087967,
0.35726889967918396,
-0.6634818315505981,
0.27227383852005005,
0.3013487756252289,
-1.1207648515701294,
0.3111294209957123,
0.43014776706695557,
0.6404303908348083,
0.10039716958999634,
0.3368131220340729,
-0.45359355211257935,
0.31348103284835815,
0.09347546845674515,
0.09808766841888428,
-0.2323564738035202,
-0.10286141186952591,
0.04177645593881607,
0.38277482986450195,
-0.3114709258079529,
-0.48981770873069763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09248v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09248v1
|
Knowledgeable Agents by Offline Reinforcement Learning from Large Language Model Rollouts
| 2024-04-14T13:19:40 | 2024-04-14T13:19:40 |
Jing-Cheng Pang, Si-Hang Yang, Kaiyuan Li, Jiaji Zhang, Xiong-Hui Chen, Nan Tang, Yang Yu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Reinforcement learning (RL) trains agents to accomplish complex tasks through
environmental interaction data, but its capacity is also limited by the scope
of the available data. To obtain a knowledgeable agent, a promising approach is
to leverage the knowledge from large language models (LLMs). Despite previous
studies combining LLMs with RL, seamless integration of the two components
remains challenging due to their semantic gap. This paper introduces a novel
method, Knowledgeable Agents from Language Model Rollouts (KALM), which
extracts knowledge from LLMs in the form of imaginary rollouts that can be
easily learned by the agent through offline reinforcement learning methods. The
primary challenge of KALM lies in LLM grounding, as LLMs are inherently limited
to textual data, whereas environmental data often comprise numerical vectors
unseen to LLMs. To address this, KALM fine-tunes the LLM to perform various
tasks based on environmental data, including bidirectional translation between
natural language descriptions of skills and their corresponding rollout data.
This grounding process enhances the LLM's comprehension of environmental
dynamics, enabling it to generate diverse and meaningful imaginary rollouts
that reflect novel skills. Initial empirical evaluations on the CLEVR-Robot
environment demonstrate that KALM enables agents to complete complex
rephrasings of task goals and extend their capabilities to novel tasks
requiring unprecedented optimal behaviors. KALM achieves a success rate of 46%
in executing tasks with unseen goals, substantially surpassing the 26% success
rate achieved by baseline methods. Furthermore, KALM effectively enables the
LLM to comprehend environmental dynamics, resulting in the generation of
meaningful imaginary rollouts that reflect novel skills and demonstrate the
seamless integration of large language models and reinforcement learning.
|
[
-0.33454978466033936,
-0.7827121615409851,
0.7850245237350464,
-0.122304268181324,
-0.0073554194532334805,
0.5578227043151855,
-0.42153534293174744,
-0.32866722345352173,
0.0317159965634346,
0.7592662572860718,
-0.7427483201026917,
-0.5476412177085876,
-0.39605945348739624,
-0.33985644578933716,
-0.12365458160638809,
1.2070307731628418,
-0.08629408478736877,
-0.24795886874198914,
-0.21206027269363403,
-0.23975618183612823,
-0.315919429063797,
-0.3567672669887543,
-0.35129696130752563,
-0.8481908440589905,
0.4660682678222656,
0.4558268189430237,
0.5925798416137695,
0.3083535432815552,
0.15287448465824127,
0.3335351049900055,
-0.19102643430233002,
0.6204022765159607,
-0.6211939454078674,
-0.0637362152338028,
-0.4334787428379059,
-0.417400062084198,
-0.18119889497756958,
-0.07202327251434326,
0.6774855852127075,
0.48704415559768677,
-0.23517856001853943,
-0.09062343090772629,
0.05117698386311531,
0.7632479071617126,
-0.4798811376094818,
0.563109815120697,
-0.7768973112106323,
0.2664560079574585,
0.17184101045131683,
-0.26613926887512207,
-0.5506989359855652,
-0.3141215741634369,
0.1701078861951828,
-0.9635452628135681,
-0.24559667706489563,
-0.12141317129135132,
0.8474177122116089,
0.3174092173576355,
-0.638116180896759,
-0.6412376165390015,
-0.8874980211257935,
0.7425147294998169,
-0.7513467669487,
0.19938376545906067,
0.2545069754123688,
0.6056963205337524,
-0.4422079920768738,
-0.5646852254867554,
-0.6321521997451782,
-0.5482946038246155,
0.025691470131278038,
0.19728487730026245,
0.12351954728364944,
0.1562623530626297,
0.11997927725315094,
0.07011746615171432,
-0.20251041650772095,
0.15168516337871552,
-0.21520303189754486,
-0.05067029595375061,
0.4983404576778412,
0.019646529108285904,
0.2423497438430786,
0.14325642585754395,
-0.4083562195301056,
-0.36237114667892456,
-0.5924112200737,
0.370968222618103,
0.369294136762619,
0.6111879348754883,
-0.05321566015481949,
0.660953938961029,
-0.30418363213539124,
0.5122887492179871,
0.005075362045317888,
-0.2995208501815796,
0.33678334951400757,
-0.0032304911874234676,
0.08287695795297623,
-0.08479738980531693,
0.2435954064130783,
0.06745225191116333,
0.08011433482170105,
-0.2528645992279053,
-0.6045448780059814,
-0.3608621656894684,
0.4095754027366638,
-0.23851680755615234,
0.03281642869114876,
0.08993840962648392,
-0.24844355881214142,
-0.4200592339038849,
0.09820402413606644,
-0.6717555522918701,
-0.42322129011154175,
-0.5073668360710144,
0.6420779824256897,
-0.4122776389122009,
-0.4306304156780243,
-0.1846359372138977,
-0.16286423802375793,
0.31999507546424866,
0.39574697613716125,
-0.39077746868133545,
0.22303391993045807,
0.6718000769615173,
0.9014021754264832,
0.17035765945911407,
-0.28797176480293274,
-0.6815078854560852,
0.20399782061576843,
-0.21710661053657532,
0.7641385197639465,
-0.2706785202026367,
-0.13198556005954742,
0.3190017640590668,
-0.02135336771607399,
-0.21026116609573364,
-0.4508560597896576,
0.1636975109577179,
-1.036619782447815,
0.008526922203600407,
-0.013217142783105373,
-0.6557891368865967,
-0.5347430109977722,
0.5829882025718689,
-0.5285125374794006,
0.8654724359512329,
0.3186126947402954,
-0.362396240234375,
0.3054836094379425,
-0.9770241379737854,
-0.22770605981349945,
0.10176753252744675,
0.09992877393960953,
-0.5342260599136353,
-0.137414813041687,
-0.1689729392528534,
0.4282378852367401,
0.17094622552394867,
0.18545329570770264,
-0.43756964802742004,
-0.03990118205547333,
0.19772616028785706,
0.18225480616092682,
0.48977863788604736,
0.19134432077407837,
-0.5693392753601074,
0.20649006962776184,
-0.4862777888774872,
0.3463408648967743,
0.19015610218048096,
-0.4443107545375824,
-0.332431823015213,
0.05996008962392807,
0.0422421358525753,
0.613957941532135,
0.30907729268074036,
-0.25316405296325684,
0.13522452116012573,
-0.506068229675293,
0.3768046498298645,
0.6986949443817139,
0.0744880959391594,
0.4472411870956421,
-0.5873314142227173,
0.6425423622131348,
-0.20371730625629425,
-0.03479234129190445,
-0.03267587348818779,
-0.3246801495552063,
-0.6386278867721558,
-0.401033490896225,
-0.13656331598758698,
0.5979931950569153,
-1.0920467376708984,
0.6126514673233032,
-0.22912035882472992,
-0.8334324955940247,
-0.02982824109494686,
0.3422839045524597,
0.6815633773803711,
0.2963656187057495,
0.27236172556877136,
0.25585612654685974,
-0.3244350850582123,
-0.45948025584220886,
-0.27114012837409973,
-0.27308815717697144,
0.18725763261318207,
0.6511576771736145,
0.7111554145812988,
-0.38614752888679504,
1.0152467489242554,
-0.5222091674804688,
-0.5155684351921082,
-0.5869185328483582,
0.35586488246917725,
0.0927119255065918,
0.19956013560295105,
0.10836255550384521,
-0.8556185364723206,
-0.43211981654167175,
0.38766995072364807,
-0.7215250730514526,
0.07513643801212311,
-0.19365043938159943,
-0.06977996975183487,
0.30323538184165955,
0.5653850436210632,
-0.7640023827552795,
0.18840071558952332,
0.4213756322860718,
-0.5048658847808838,
0.3489462435245514,
-0.7868344783782959,
-0.11085894703865051,
-0.7488243579864502,
0.06697415560483932,
-0.2057611495256424,
-0.5622659921646118,
-0.8296993970870972,
0.16499929130077362,
0.07443427294492722,
0.08001428097486496,
-0.8138941526412964,
0.7193243503570557,
-0.545960545539856,
-0.32320210337638855,
-0.33386191725730896,
0.41639444231987,
-0.05044828727841377,
0.6634507775306702,
0.1877228021621704,
0.25995513796806335,
0.21026264131069183,
-0.7889377474784851,
0.31005963683128357,
0.3774925172328949,
-0.12739291787147522,
0.09959819167852402,
-0.3508145213127136,
0.06469829380512238,
-0.3316023051738739,
0.5456777811050415,
-0.6038244962692261,
-0.16057999432086945,
0.18863290548324585,
-0.14051178097724915,
0.0639810562133789,
0.06559407711029053,
-0.49667397141456604,
-0.07092949002981186,
-0.12294095009565353,
0.1375689059495926,
0.7986741065979004,
-0.6525299549102783,
0.8406897187232971,
0.6129511594772339,
0.11048521101474762,
-0.2565520703792572,
-0.33016330003738403,
-0.25067034363746643,
-0.4882071018218994,
-0.30693283677101135,
0.025004135444760323,
0.22499190270900726,
-0.22543548047542572,
0.0010528564453125,
0.16938281059265137,
-0.08785343915224075,
0.03319968655705452,
0.3199513256549835,
0.10498961806297302,
-0.001446211477741599,
0.2364094853401184,
-0.15516173839569092,
0.009295024909079075,
0.11969706416130066,
-0.3680891692638397,
0.44218263030052185,
-0.21473471820354462,
-0.4110502600669861,
0.09320671856403351,
-0.11240703612565994,
0.8027082681655884,
-0.1566663682460785,
0.9745728373527527,
0.48757630586624146,
-0.2943323850631714,
-0.5971461534500122,
-0.31082579493522644,
-0.1639775186777115,
-0.40412235260009766,
0.488406240940094,
-0.2649744153022766,
-0.6499425172805786,
0.5568072199821472,
-0.4806358814239502,
0.2847413122653961,
0.3389076590538025,
0.45516011118888855,
-0.1963229477405548,
1.1141382455825806,
0.7213667631149292,
0.16371726989746094,
0.5385771989822388,
-0.5333401560783386,
0.18266691267490387,
-0.5989876985549927,
-0.7050217390060425,
-0.1660245805978775,
0.0005251390393823385,
-0.4710020124912262,
-0.6744087934494019,
0.3489915132522583,
0.011283624917268753,
-0.17489001154899597,
0.17098140716552734,
-0.0979544073343277,
0.27563172578811646,
0.39987337589263916,
0.426982581615448,
0.21901880204677582,
-0.11418554186820984,
-0.18675687909126282,
0.2545325756072998,
-0.617889940738678,
-0.618354856967926,
0.9587823152542114,
0.5433363914489746,
0.4421095848083496,
0.1817121058702469,
0.4275587797164917,
0.7173377275466919,
0.274506151676178,
-0.679298996925354,
0.48060062527656555,
0.1715233027935028,
-0.36226409673690796,
-0.518839418888092,
-0.4075622260570526,
-0.7366811633110046,
0.24519774317741394,
-0.30218738317489624,
-0.4714929163455963,
-0.1699206531047821,
0.21765701472759247,
-0.13542164862155914,
0.47229209542274475,
-0.42701390385627747,
0.7014857530593872,
-0.3624055087566376,
-0.03216099366545677,
-0.5809439420700073,
-0.695270836353302,
0.41681796312332153,
-0.4564041495323181,
0.5174183249473572,
-0.2291702777147293,
-0.2813444435596466,
0.5646283626556396,
-0.5061824917793274,
0.8613179922103882,
-0.6117197871208191,
-0.31641685962677,
0.2886175513267517,
-0.20607370138168335,
1.1610872745513916,
-0.11065342277288437,
0.2216104120016098,
0.11181241273880005,
-0.14757117629051208,
-0.42066431045532227,
-0.9131345748901367,
0.5635193586349487,
-0.9612106084823608,
-0.27346232533454895,
-0.37418100237846375,
-0.7644562125205994,
-0.3669320344924927,
0.1806221306324005,
-0.05781576409935951,
0.17134307324886322,
-0.1671799123287201,
-0.12554824352264404,
0.8350954055786133,
-0.31336352229118347,
0.26412081718444824,
0.8272461891174316,
-0.41672077775001526,
-0.36455807089805603,
1.0810641050338745,
0.11767150461673737,
0.6096951365470886,
0.4717308282852173,
0.15404120087623596,
-0.5832489728927612,
-0.2567427456378937,
-0.17791815102100372,
0.12639397382736206,
-0.8687134385108948,
-0.04513833671808243,
-0.8635526299476624,
-0.33219993114471436,
-0.06371524184942245,
-0.3837013840675354,
-0.43740972876548767,
-0.1683756411075592,
0.018757618963718414,
-0.10069850832223892,
0.4219396710395813,
1.0957636833190918,
-0.07474268227815628,
0.22236071527004242,
-0.7898098230361938,
0.27518707513809204,
0.2529832124710083,
0.058291420340538025,
-0.04617131128907204,
-0.7142895460128784,
-0.477453351020813,
0.33882302045822144,
-0.20766614377498627,
-0.7907928824424744,
0.5513313412666321,
0.36274540424346924,
0.8272998332977295,
0.5730659365653992,
0.24672937393188477,
0.5114116072654724,
-0.3406815826892853,
0.4293076694011688,
-0.14662152528762817,
-0.8540561199188232,
0.5834900140762329,
-0.5410813689231873,
0.2686729431152344,
0.37578558921813965,
0.17006047070026398,
-0.37681153416633606,
-0.6949037909507751,
-0.6316588521003723,
-1.0240366458892822,
0.8562537431716919,
0.25942814350128174,
0.02410445362329483,
0.22621193528175354,
0.12559263408184052,
0.1765253245830536,
0.20355534553527832,
-0.632550835609436,
-0.08152202516794205,
-0.1371489316225052,
-0.10129974782466888,
-0.47062164545059204,
0.0516594722867012,
-0.05331466346979141,
0.11783293634653091,
1.0860902070999146,
-0.2500947117805481,
0.05661773309111595,
-0.02906525693833828,
-0.5080053210258484,
0.01717626489698887,
0.2770971655845642,
0.7934497594833374,
0.5604475140571594,
-0.2604202330112457,
0.1557338386774063,
0.5570120215415955,
-0.2102699875831604,
0.48872995376586914,
-0.19417105615139008,
-0.2060488760471344,
-0.08593098074197769,
0.3826774060726166,
0.6574080586433411,
0.2947583794593811,
-1.2728642225265503,
0.3439789116382599,
0.07855035364627838,
-0.24407291412353516,
-0.6811596751213074,
0.05775049701333046,
-0.0873131975531578,
0.5018836259841919,
0.21658167243003845,
0.008355267345905304,
-0.1082591712474823,
-0.3631387948989868,
0.3279033601284027,
0.5616867542266846,
-0.5116732716560364,
-0.24806557595729828,
0.15589627623558044,
0.19663800299167633,
-0.1683603823184967,
0.538218080997467,
-0.4110262095928192,
-0.7271427512168884,
0.767982542514801,
0.5438335537910461,
0.6868391633033752,
0.1034921333193779,
0.5540800094604492,
0.21342867612838745,
0.13091842830181122,
-0.22678889334201813,
0.07737359404563904,
-0.15156051516532898,
-0.7163317799568176,
-0.2600303292274475,
-0.18086843192577362,
-0.5443116426467896,
0.05077546089887619,
-0.6193708777427673,
0.3356855511665344,
-0.5035969614982605,
0.041119106113910675,
-0.49610772728919983,
0.09554439038038254,
-0.6105407476425171,
0.13677607476711273,
0.20393885672092438,
0.7900341749191284,
-1.274964451789856,
0.6283477544784546,
1.1504168510437012,
-0.3899742364883423,
-0.9012327194213867,
0.029313262552022934,
0.07851437479257584,
-0.7837921977043152,
0.9278833270072937,
0.1900377720594406,
-0.0672338604927063,
0.2452721893787384,
-0.12810328602790833,
-0.9358747005462646,
1.1812556982040405,
0.3178570866584778,
-0.2641576826572418,
-0.000993493478745222,
0.2703309655189514,
0.4373229742050171,
-0.4891672730445862,
0.5389499664306641,
0.27619054913520813,
0.629138708114624,
0.1593485027551651,
-0.6205365061759949,
0.1304938644170761,
-0.16578614711761475,
0.028418906033039093,
0.25734445452690125,
-0.6765488386154175,
0.48096179962158203,
-0.23186875879764557,
-0.04274994507431984,
-0.3035467267036438,
0.6677049398422241,
0.6249011158943176,
0.43872877955436707,
0.948913037776947,
0.47657251358032227,
0.8711798191070557,
0.176698237657547,
0.7313485145568848,
-0.37353256344795227,
0.42524728178977966,
0.9217440485954285,
-0.29799580574035645,
0.7683802843093872,
0.41878193616867065,
-0.007458087056875229,
0.6583690643310547,
0.46558094024658203,
0.28104281425476074,
0.9215425848960876,
0.2991044819355011,
-0.5739232897758484,
-0.32872799038887024,
-0.344352662563324,
-0.13870754837989807,
0.3882538080215454,
0.2016390711069107,
-0.07252518832683563,
-0.47841915488243103,
0.5014539361000061,
0.03839971125125885,
0.3241174817085266,
-0.4398350715637207,
1.0698047876358032,
0.02645149454474449,
-0.7475525140762329,
0.261505663394928,
-0.04729266092181206,
0.42807212471961975,
-0.7220655083656311,
-0.3987610638141632,
0.020934438332915306,
0.5121127963066101,
-0.2097102403640747,
-0.6318996548652649,
0.3040195107460022,
-0.13538013398647308,
-0.22248265147209167,
-0.37848055362701416,
0.6017820239067078,
-0.5589829087257385,
-0.27456796169281006,
0.48773711919784546,
0.562900185585022,
0.1553293764591217,
-0.015775129199028015,
-0.5330955982208252,
-0.33793210983276367,
-0.11809945851564407,
-0.32857662439346313,
0.42048555612564087,
0.5404959321022034,
-0.18154557049274445,
1.0230581760406494,
0.725536584854126,
0.3447478115558624,
0.10338220745325089,
-0.19029514491558075,
0.9721878170967102,
-0.5683337450027466,
-0.7391961216926575,
-0.6834643483161926,
0.7487578988075256,
-0.020087016746401787,
0.007174269761890173,
0.7525737285614014,
0.3023991286754608,
0.7255439162254333,
-0.2168327420949936,
0.8731452822685242,
-0.048001475632190704,
0.5735287070274353,
-0.7116330862045288,
0.8052660822868347,
-0.4453098773956299,
0.21478095650672913,
-0.029128877446055412,
-0.7552309036254883,
0.10639496892690659,
0.30849695205688477,
-0.3619724214076996,
0.1573866903781891,
0.5361178517341614,
0.7084404826164246,
0.07566998153924942,
-0.43558716773986816,
0.5736454129219055,
0.0803942084312439,
0.5059226155281067,
0.5643320679664612,
1.1151275634765625,
-0.01649991050362587,
0.553064227104187,
-0.21069326996803284,
-0.23558050394058228,
-0.2611178755760193,
-0.8909016251564026,
-1.1162973642349243,
-0.6131939888000488,
-0.2891278862953186,
-0.3475663661956787,
0.30695825815200806,
1.1761980056762695,
0.8463761806488037,
-0.782725989818573,
0.05360172688961029,
-0.5450409054756165,
0.2927805781364441,
-0.2772732973098755,
-0.24180255830287933,
0.08729048818349838,
-0.6269434094429016,
-0.3450365364551544,
0.4846019446849823,
-0.017406316474080086,
-0.0976606011390686,
-0.4252769351005554,
-0.7176437377929688,
-0.2791944742202759,
0.1647338569164276,
0.4407867193222046,
0.6475882530212402,
-0.7764654159545898,
-0.1269741803407669,
-0.2534997761249542,
-0.014694396406412125,
-0.23382236063480377,
0.6206417083740234,
-0.8586940765380859,
0.1967027336359024,
0.4472566545009613,
0.6896863579750061,
0.2732818126678467,
-0.00909335631877184,
0.7314758896827698,
-0.710874080657959,
0.14241959154605865,
0.11356201767921448,
0.1122196614742279,
0.17518895864486694,
-0.4609498083591461,
0.2241518646478653,
-0.08860969543457031,
-0.5986089706420898,
-0.8547324538230896,
0.020452303811907768,
-0.5478559732437134,
-0.19323599338531494,
1.2860702276229858,
-0.5964071154594421,
-0.1428857147693634,
-0.32169413566589355,
-0.18022528290748596,
0.4132285416126251,
-0.38010573387145996,
0.7692610621452332,
0.43431219458580017,
-0.017291320487856865,
-0.20206637680530548,
-0.6485373973846436,
0.4469360113143921,
0.32698169350624084,
-1.163140058517456,
-0.04964251443743706,
0.26832568645477295,
0.1384299397468567,
0.09537529200315475,
0.3643334209918976,
0.2712157070636749,
0.01840064488351345,
-0.23885677754878998,
0.363837867975235,
-0.35288095474243164,
-0.28213584423065186,
-0.4703623056411743,
0.07046491652727127,
0.30911388993263245,
-0.03748391941189766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09221v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09221v2
|
Exploring and Improving Drafts in Blockwise Parallel Decoding
| 2024-04-14T11:49:38 | 2024-06-05T05:00:35 |
Taehyeon Kim, Ananda Theertha Suresh, Kishore Papineni, Michael Riley, Sanjiv Kumar, Adrian Benton
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Despite the remarkable strides made by autoregressive language models, their
potential is often hampered by the slow inference speeds inherent in sequential
token generation. Blockwise parallel decoding (BPD) was proposed by Stern et
al. as a method to improve inference speed of language models by simultaneously
predicting multiple future tokens, termed block drafts, which are subsequently
verified and conditionally accepted by the autoregressive model. This paper
contributes to the understanding and improvement of block drafts in two ways.
First, we analyze the token distributions produced by multiple prediction
heads. Secondly, we leverage this analysis to develop algorithms to improve BPD
inference speed by refining the block drafts using n-gram and neural language
models. Experiments demonstrate that refined block drafts yield a +5-21%
increase in block efficiency (i.e., the number of accepted tokens from the
block draft) across diverse datasets.
|
[
-0.6014528870582581,
-0.7861232161521912,
0.5451636910438538,
0.4896281063556671,
-0.6089058518409729,
0.2942449748516083,
-0.24141962826251984,
-0.5623888373374939,
0.08569011837244034,
0.483778178691864,
-0.484762579202652,
-0.30713951587677,
-0.9629895091056824,
0.18788555264472961,
-0.37957334518432617,
0.7032116055488586,
-0.11186227202415466,
0.1595352739095688,
0.10402828454971313,
0.16742561757564545,
-0.5183433890342712,
-0.4538615643978119,
-0.855237603187561,
-0.4207024872303009,
0.1952066868543625,
0.21459360420703888,
0.4592636227607727,
1.1889927387237549,
0.5235313773155212,
0.3324683904647827,
-0.08414068818092346,
0.12153051048517227,
-0.28553277254104614,
0.2488345056772232,
-0.14438284933567047,
-0.16087183356285095,
-0.3952983617782593,
-0.18067483603954315,
0.6491273641586304,
0.8732267022132874,
0.08032699674367905,
0.025143682956695557,
0.023777522146701813,
0.9418336749076843,
-0.5804745554924011,
0.3605416715145111,
-0.6531966924667358,
-0.11271438747644424,
-0.30100899934768677,
-0.289730429649353,
-0.5192697644233704,
-0.32059502601623535,
0.16199851036071777,
-0.23849862813949585,
0.5667475461959839,
0.23625244200229645,
0.40550166368484497,
-0.0001716546539682895,
-0.0979088842868805,
-0.07588853687047958,
-0.4027279317378998,
0.49256569147109985,
-0.63377445936203,
0.5246265530586243,
0.5001155138015747,
0.26953306794166565,
-0.28537580370903015,
-0.8519529700279236,
-0.5434938669204712,
0.14908936619758606,
-0.014962959103286266,
-0.1992579996585846,
0.043663084506988525,
0.4252329170703888,
0.22996602952480316,
0.41229936480522156,
-0.524601399898529,
0.07292117178440094,
-0.3251350522041321,
-0.4672207236289978,
0.9066564440727234,
0.2679600715637207,
-0.1929759830236435,
-0.28818345069885254,
-0.15457703173160553,
-0.4089408814907074,
-0.41125062108039856,
0.04477651044726372,
0.6375621557235718,
0.31092333793640137,
0.013337570242583752,
0.2548040449619293,
-0.5612599849700928,
1.2374136447906494,
0.20995500683784485,
0.005577590316534042,
0.31096288561820984,
-0.6833624243736267,
-0.31381919980049133,
-0.1863923817873001,
0.45213764905929565,
0.44520241022109985,
0.12084980309009552,
-0.14854657649993896,
-0.32648882269859314,
-0.05814216658473015,
0.17720839381217957,
-0.9390986561775208,
-0.5976603031158447,
0.6150084733963013,
-1.0427875518798828,
-0.16415497660636902,
0.05696435645222664,
-0.7492122054100037,
-0.4690797030925751,
-0.4428732991218567,
0.06966400891542435,
-0.6064753532409668,
-0.48484742641448975,
0.5015559792518616,
-0.6962621212005615,
-0.119877889752388,
0.3328193426132202,
-1.0626094341278076,
0.3827628195285797,
0.8003302216529846,
0.7290283441543579,
-0.25409865379333496,
-0.5182755589485168,
-0.5421712398529053,
-0.21254180371761322,
-0.3859458863735199,
1.2399308681488037,
-0.4370400309562683,
-0.41746824979782104,
-0.21838410198688507,
-0.3109695315361023,
-0.1494438797235489,
-0.6196358799934387,
0.294457346200943,
-0.37079834938049316,
-0.6585541367530823,
-0.3949936032295227,
-0.514835000038147,
-0.01594463549554348,
0.06478078663349152,
-0.6151936054229736,
0.6124528050422668,
-0.03222399577498436,
-0.9107776880264282,
0.5221871137619019,
-0.4297915995121002,
-0.47356128692626953,
-0.12174205482006073,
0.06065903231501579,
-0.2614307403564453,
0.5364998579025269,
0.538394033908844,
0.5148226022720337,
-0.2277417629957199,
0.3564436435699463,
-0.33090734481811523,
-0.30161312222480774,
0.09946022927761078,
-0.2887713611125946,
0.6719274520874023,
0.45451459288597107,
-0.2734428346157074,
0.20072230696678162,
-0.9043372273445129,
0.18894027173519135,
-0.1747450977563858,
-0.1884845644235611,
-0.13316765427589417,
0.037723444402217865,
0.04162251576781273,
0.008820072747766972,
-0.18491922318935394,
-0.6231608986854553,
0.057328321039676666,
-0.10704053193330765,
0.298958420753479,
1.0537344217300415,
0.19441409409046173,
0.3084816038608551,
-0.44013339281082153,
0.31429868936538696,
0.08384660631418228,
0.15901729464530945,
-0.3938809633255005,
-0.4977136552333832,
-0.5864577889442444,
-0.4643144905567169,
0.5585339665412903,
0.057440903037786484,
-0.641028106212616,
0.3425920009613037,
0.05935346335172653,
-0.29904648661613464,
-0.6364626288414001,
-0.03511589393019676,
0.6040784120559692,
0.3455001413822174,
0.3245507478713989,
-0.7219658493995667,
-0.7905040979385376,
-0.789806604385376,
-0.5821864008903503,
-0.4774158298969269,
0.30915549397468567,
-0.04001397266983986,
0.19709469377994537,
0.10387910902500153,
0.6347864866256714,
-0.39808720350265503,
0.29190129041671753,
-0.394744336605072,
0.7361958622932434,
0.019464818760752678,
0.7660194039344788,
0.2383493334054947,
-0.3881704807281494,
-0.5644546151161194,
-0.1384093016386032,
-0.28770238161087036,
-0.34102532267570496,
-0.213738813996315,
-0.525217592716217,
0.14306941628456116,
0.7547453045845032,
-0.3141014575958252,
0.6067748069763184,
0.4988611042499542,
-0.6455034613609314,
0.7610892057418823,
-0.23937392234802246,
-0.1616804003715515,
-0.5177793502807617,
-0.16121986508369446,
-0.2726130187511444,
-0.2757185399532318,
-0.6572761535644531,
0.15057262778282166,
0.28331902623176575,
0.21470943093299866,
-0.08712954074144363,
0.38159844279289246,
-1.0058505535125732,
-0.24853923916816711,
-0.7327955365180969,
-0.16121137142181396,
0.0046205162070691586,
0.17945317924022675,
0.3218522071838379,
0.5784542560577393,
0.708696722984314,
-0.5565916299819946,
0.06549886614084244,
0.00242807250469923,
-0.35119718313217163,
0.36691024899482727,
-0.5754635334014893,
0.22237640619277954,
-0.609294593334198,
0.43760257959365845,
-0.874991238117218,
0.04724150896072388,
0.06106490641832352,
-0.2358308881521225,
0.3588230311870575,
-0.16177630424499512,
-0.5196225047111511,
-0.5180845856666565,
-0.3782452642917633,
0.5692989826202393,
0.47608423233032227,
-0.47735509276390076,
0.39583173394203186,
0.3649974763393402,
-0.0221530944108963,
-0.5986889004707336,
-0.7137395739555359,
-0.24486380815505981,
0.38499125838279724,
-0.5462538599967957,
0.32647258043289185,
-0.31908881664276123,
-0.3905287981033325,
0.24323348701000214,
-0.2897501289844513,
-0.09863250702619553,
-0.05463352054357529,
0.08758004754781723,
0.005328282713890076,
-0.02998165227472782,
-0.1823817491531372,
0.10161187499761581,
-0.23735657334327698,
0.11567231267690659,
-0.8213735818862915,
0.8024367094039917,
0.12428086251020432,
-0.2719457447528839,
-0.45351549983024597,
0.4732203483581543,
0.3185797333717346,
-0.4052264094352722,
0.6696221828460693,
0.5357820987701416,
-0.22989490628242493,
-0.4319196343421936,
-0.8898992538452148,
-0.22968168556690216,
-0.45707565546035767,
0.07429320365190506,
-0.7373254299163818,
-0.6284820437431335,
0.6832461357116699,
0.09082794934511185,
-0.08080539107322693,
0.26461243629455566,
0.4707998037338257,
0.3238305151462555,
0.7126892805099487,
0.8941752314567566,
0.12367492914199829,
0.49549850821495056,
-0.47159022092819214,
0.06727328151464462,
-1.0126391649246216,
-0.3190135359764099,
-0.49569088220596313,
-0.3803861439228058,
-0.40422433614730835,
-0.6622371077537537,
-0.07598777860403061,
0.24754531681537628,
0.1731881946325302,
0.2806660830974579,
-0.45312371850013733,
0.6155685186386108,
0.7472896575927734,
0.22366976737976074,
0.41215401887893677,
0.016423316672444344,
-0.4625120460987091,
0.27748480439186096,
-0.6010050177574158,
-0.005926927551627159,
1.4613131284713745,
0.19326864182949066,
0.3424326479434967,
-0.2294963002204895,
0.9078648686408997,
0.1588253378868103,
0.32681217789649963,
-0.37995046377182007,
0.38994336128234863,
0.06804609298706055,
-0.669234573841095,
-0.14002960920333862,
-0.3354673981666565,
-0.7563192248344421,
0.48397353291511536,
-0.12240409851074219,
-0.7189111709594727,
0.7173961997032166,
0.30913546681404114,
-0.277775377035141,
0.31520065665245056,
-0.7629819512367249,
0.8660127520561218,
0.21070925891399384,
-0.26548072695732117,
-0.6353476643562317,
-0.48110315203666687,
0.527368426322937,
-0.1875733733177185,
0.072254978120327,
-0.32325485348701477,
0.14272505044937134,
0.4812262952327728,
-0.8027607202529907,
0.42541804909706116,
-0.4365462362766266,
0.19448351860046387,
0.39683419466018677,
0.025927621871232986,
0.695142924785614,
0.06992733478546143,
-0.49331867694854736,
0.134001225233078,
-0.30443328619003296,
-0.7371631264686584,
-0.48772546648979187,
0.4558749794960022,
-0.7164731621742249,
-0.4784225821495056,
-0.20746029913425446,
-0.9301503300666809,
-0.11255132406949997,
0.25347110629081726,
0.25889408588409424,
0.727954626083374,
0.03551577031612396,
-0.31041014194488525,
0.31799495220184326,
0.0810873731970787,
0.8444806337356567,
0.30886679887771606,
-0.14577585458755493,
-0.4753621816635132,
0.5863571166992188,
0.15504169464111328,
0.44038766622543335,
0.17564059793949127,
0.014792703092098236,
-0.46020522713661194,
-1.5632516145706177,
-0.2708469331264496,
0.3172255754470825,
-0.6791251301765442,
-0.15971387922763824,
-0.7734237313270569,
-0.1044653058052063,
-0.5530042052268982,
-0.05383733659982681,
-0.25791457295417786,
-0.5607534646987915,
0.3219297528266907,
-0.3450705409049988,
0.32761088013648987,
0.8093295097351074,
-0.5607619881629944,
0.2932056188583374,
-0.4314751923084259,
0.5901951193809509,
0.10770175606012344,
0.5726940631866455,
0.2735389769077301,
-0.3056615889072418,
-0.15464764833450317,
-0.3265874683856964,
-0.013043985702097416,
-0.7734577059745789,
0.3629925549030304,
-0.2522561550140381,
0.6518857479095459,
0.4297304153442383,
0.18482345342636108,
0.995802104473114,
-0.5544882416725159,
0.38940054178237915,
0.16115809977054596,
-1.1375598907470703,
0.27969595789909363,
-0.14474710822105408,
0.33380892872810364,
0.6106241345405579,
0.05761940777301788,
-0.49407196044921875,
-0.4470214545726776,
-0.5988873839378357,
-0.7507637143135071,
0.8337060213088989,
0.24878959357738495,
-0.3444364070892334,
-0.18571710586547852,
0.16726267337799072,
0.5587705373764038,
0.3530791103839874,
-0.0675470232963562,
-0.37016233801841736,
-0.4044733941555023,
0.03874986246228218,
-0.07038085907697678,
-0.4659227430820465,
0.2886994183063507,
-0.4653118848800659,
0.5070081353187561,
-0.02156248316168785,
0.5051730275154114,
0.3800467848777771,
0.07942204177379608,
-0.013985531404614449,
-0.09397943317890167,
0.39274582266807556,
0.9508616924285889,
-0.3661147356033325,
0.2635306417942047,
-0.19752633571624756,
-0.6234011650085449,
0.11329484730958939,
0.43402454257011414,
-0.034183304756879807,
0.20436352491378784,
0.2704981565475464,
1.0083692073822021,
-0.4850206673145294,
-0.5243833065032959,
0.30013135075569153,
-0.34208089113235474,
-0.31074294447898865,
0.03133166581392288,
-0.2901723384857178,
-0.017328670248389244,
0.310372531414032,
0.37530457973480225,
0.4509311020374298,
0.25162726640701294,
-0.38328418135643005,
0.30570751428604126,
0.36053696274757385,
0.19051209092140198,
-0.3057146966457367,
0.5971485376358032,
0.29196158051490784,
-0.30908870697021484,
0.7318610548973083,
-0.5000119805335999,
-0.2639307379722595,
0.6611102819442749,
0.6608273386955261,
1.1643693447113037,
0.09009696543216705,
0.16922174394130707,
0.354775607585907,
0.35044652223587036,
-0.33726799488067627,
0.6958637237548828,
-0.2730795741081238,
-0.7892137765884399,
-0.6814725399017334,
-0.7073971629142761,
-0.31257036328315735,
0.05218002572655678,
-0.5618922114372253,
-0.050461914390325546,
-0.8531893491744995,
-0.31866297125816345,
0.018972113728523254,
0.02272927761077881,
-0.7990142703056335,
-0.0677943229675293,
0.16938388347625732,
1.2375680208206177,
-0.704778254032135,
1.0097390413284302,
0.39884182810783386,
-0.031826626509428024,
-0.7888020873069763,
0.3325433135032654,
-0.09956863522529602,
-0.7321775555610657,
0.7123257517814636,
0.052904896438121796,
-0.06417003273963928,
0.20935197174549103,
-0.03348979353904724,
-0.9319735169410706,
0.747592031955719,
0.22735044360160828,
-0.4339272081851959,
0.2525639533996582,
-0.13607704639434814,
0.33905458450317383,
-0.4438518285751343,
0.42191529273986816,
0.8376151323318481,
0.6989197731018066,
-0.3512831926345825,
-0.9644380211830139,
0.22570061683654785,
-0.4793190062046051,
0.42391708493232727,
0.2265499085187912,
-0.505339503288269,
1.053769588470459,
-0.23635119199752808,
-0.13982026278972626,
0.18072371184825897,
0.7965455651283264,
0.29039692878723145,
0.3398536443710327,
0.5250970721244812,
0.5319288969039917,
0.8679611086845398,
-0.002903202548623085,
1.2499680519104004,
-0.6507320404052734,
-0.0967465341091156,
0.7513427138328552,
0.09937146306037903,
0.8577705025672913,
0.42054808139801025,
0.004389122128486633,
0.6947349309921265,
0.6387696266174316,
0.24017126858234406,
0.6470742225646973,
0.5405546426773071,
-0.26276564598083496,
-0.14407071471214294,
-0.08970626443624496,
-0.27863776683807373,
0.13137097656726837,
0.2998291850090027,
-0.3129533529281616,
-0.14494910836219788,
-0.07282908260822296,
-0.23746232688426971,
0.22795310616493225,
-0.48379120230674744,
0.48623016476631165,
-0.07875876873731613,
-0.9078014492988586,
0.8453564047813416,
0.40994223952293396,
0.7022594213485718,
-0.3021671175956726,
0.18689441680908203,
-0.4577593207359314,
0.2733701169490814,
-0.0037956719752401114,
-0.5461708903312683,
0.4290309548377991,
-0.017197659239172935,
-0.27031397819519043,
-0.5954696536064148,
0.6425595283508301,
-0.30866819620132446,
-0.42663687467575073,
0.4157719612121582,
0.6910327672958374,
0.33113306760787964,
-0.21815554797649384,
-0.6274253129959106,
0.6656461954116821,
-0.18333683907985687,
0.002252923557534814,
0.16176284849643707,
0.5874864459037781,
-0.0006248781573958695,
0.3927270770072937,
0.8098524808883667,
0.40209057927131653,
0.43778014183044434,
0.009585639461874962,
0.7858278751373291,
-0.7588388919830322,
-0.5860117077827454,
-0.9662218689918518,
0.38802117109298706,
-0.28041958808898926,
-0.27913206815719604,
0.717896580696106,
0.4739089906215668,
1.2042838335037231,
-0.17208963632583618,
0.9595551490783691,
-0.05184796079993248,
0.4039662182331085,
-0.6782932877540588,
0.4927995204925537,
0.05872713774442673,
0.126548632979393,
-0.1909835785627365,
-0.6777581572532654,
-0.19984625279903412,
0.40506210923194885,
-0.14935170114040375,
-0.24076417088508606,
1.1959477663040161,
0.7498759031295776,
-0.01200738362967968,
0.12448640167713165,
0.05428537353873253,
0.10063009709119797,
0.1338590532541275,
0.49291014671325684,
0.6749146580696106,
-0.35854363441467285,
0.3777318298816681,
-0.7323458194732666,
-0.06286664307117462,
-0.19003888964653015,
-1.0156428813934326,
-1.1780285835266113,
-0.5134586691856384,
-0.24643680453300476,
-0.3323749005794525,
0.4666723310947418,
0.9077008366584778,
0.9183222651481628,
-0.7556752562522888,
-0.598710298538208,
-0.6823690533638,
0.2115156501531601,
-0.6731802225112915,
-0.162549689412117,
0.3557821810245514,
-0.6008049845695496,
-0.861647367477417,
0.456098735332489,
0.12514947354793549,
0.04972001910209656,
-0.1418226808309555,
-0.040617093443870544,
0.07256069779396057,
0.24018748104572296,
0.5098525881767273,
0.21052169799804688,
-0.5341416001319885,
-0.1774938553571701,
-0.1984424889087677,
0.10784925520420074,
-0.09183496981859207,
1.3239691257476807,
-0.9652775526046753,
0.5716290473937988,
1.1415258646011353,
0.7259918451309204,
0.7505626082420349,
0.25101563334465027,
0.9887869954109192,
-0.4363428056240082,
0.49604055285453796,
-0.16447612643241882,
0.26404014229774475,
0.28611883521080017,
-0.16304132342338562,
0.26671862602233887,
0.45665332674980164,
-0.20272569358348846,
-0.847912609577179,
0.3796375095844269,
-0.5309653878211975,
-0.6298635005950928,
0.8217638731002808,
-0.09613519161939621,
-0.35599982738494873,
-0.485300749540329,
0.01712089218199253,
0.08445332944393158,
-0.465602844953537,
0.7106906771659851,
0.6792839765548706,
-0.37830600142478943,
-0.09229275584220886,
-0.4093948304653168,
0.6826981902122498,
0.428818017244339,
-0.4448494613170624,
0.5058103203773499,
0.4877875745296478,
0.01981508731842041,
-0.2022501826286316,
1.3075168132781982,
-0.1193903237581253,
0.34778881072998047,
0.4237993359565735,
-0.06104128807783127,
-0.4292868673801422,
-0.5724798440933228,
-0.44689175486564636,
0.2233271300792694,
0.3091180622577667,
-0.29099223017692566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09220v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09220v1
|
Compass: Large Multilingual Language Model for South-east Asia
| 2024-04-14T11:48:33 | 2024-04-14T11:48:33 |
Sophia Maria
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models have exhibited significant proficiency in languages
endowed with extensive linguistic resources, such as English and Chinese.
Nevertheless, their effectiveness notably diminishes when applied to languages
characterized by limited linguistic resources, particularly within the
Southeast Asian linguistic landscape, such as Indonesian. The scarcity of
linguistic resources for these languages presents challenges associated with
inadequate training, restricted vocabulary coverage, and challenging evaluation
processes. In response to these exigencies, we have introduced CompassLLM, a
large multilingual model specifically tailored for Southeast Asian languages,
with the primary aim of supporting the developmental requirements of Shopee.
Our methodology encompasses several key strategies. To progressively enhance
multilingual proficiencies, we implemented a multi-stage pre-training strategy
integrated with curriculum learning, gradually intensifying the focus on
low-resource languages. Concurrently, to better accommodate low-resource human
instructions, we curated and generated a repository of high-quality
multilingual human instructions, culminating the CompassLLM-SFT model through
supervised instruction fine-tuning. Finally, to reinforce the model's alignment
with human preference behaviors, we have embraced the principle of Direct
Preference Optimization (DPO) to obtain CompassLLM-DPO model. Preliminary
evaluation of the CompassLLM model yields promising results, with our model
surpassing benchmark models like Vicuna-7b-v1.5, Sealion, Falcon and SeaLLM,
across diverse evaluation tasks, as verified through both automated and
human-driven assessments. Notably, our model exhibits its superior performance
in South-east Asia languages, such as Indonesian language.
|
[
-0.3957355320453644,
-0.1695082187652588,
0.29130199551582336,
0.3782994747161865,
-0.26460304856300354,
0.22486011683940887,
-0.7118395566940308,
-0.37713855504989624,
-0.02030755765736103,
0.703352689743042,
-0.5794335007667542,
-0.41533252596855164,
-0.38684386014938354,
0.3616255223751068,
0.09211622178554535,
0.6148357391357422,
-0.03377910330891609,
0.3742361068725586,
0.4436360001564026,
-0.3679608404636383,
-0.4651438593864441,
-0.6485272645950317,
-0.591278612613678,
-0.2989926040172577,
0.3085113763809204,
0.9167253375053406,
0.7357195615768433,
0.7276296615600586,
0.39336761832237244,
0.23446276783943176,
0.0016934153391048312,
0.006688660942018032,
-0.42115387320518494,
0.020877327769994736,
-0.2828189730644226,
-0.4645584225654602,
-0.5513484477996826,
0.23511309921741486,
0.5310768485069275,
0.8101455569267273,
-0.10986176133155823,
0.2404942810535431,
0.12300735712051392,
0.728898286819458,
-0.41209760308265686,
0.30242276191711426,
-0.49867284297943115,
-0.22119921445846558,
-0.08871419727802277,
0.1439238339662552,
-0.39995965361595154,
-0.27630549669265747,
0.3158937096595764,
-0.6459864974021912,
-0.054124027490615845,
0.07166042923927307,
0.7766550779342651,
-0.11268319189548492,
-0.6625465750694275,
-0.17269828915596008,
-0.672212541103363,
1.2260018587112427,
-0.5198258757591248,
0.4831848740577698,
0.4682094156742096,
0.36472734808921814,
0.0939779132604599,
-0.08180829137563705,
-0.4190848469734192,
-0.3329850733280182,
0.10712956637144089,
0.03734249621629715,
0.30097857117652893,
0.1762109100818634,
-0.08958064764738083,
0.24230194091796875,
-0.7093949913978577,
0.15798835456371307,
-0.23597271740436554,
0.2239241749048233,
0.7597749829292297,
0.11495853215456009,
0.31017449498176575,
-0.30763229727745056,
-0.35206714272499084,
-0.24653372168540955,
-0.9769980311393738,
-0.2460918128490448,
0.4112808108329773,
0.6815550327301025,
0.13027530908584595,
0.7544394731521606,
-0.1805679351091385,
0.646368145942688,
0.09762613475322723,
-0.5633035898208618,
0.04282848536968231,
-0.4710284173488617,
-0.007983483374118805,
0.08925968408584595,
0.4064498841762543,
0.46431657671928406,
0.09678563475608826,
0.06350496411323547,
-0.1389404982328415,
0.03447950258851051,
-0.24000577628612518,
-0.7070794701576233,
-0.220456063747406,
0.16794247925281525,
-0.47460827231407166,
-0.09975176304578781,
0.032662201672792435,
-0.9897327423095703,
-0.5215656757354736,
-0.6527708768844604,
-0.037693507969379425,
-0.23203183710575104,
-0.9810711145401001,
0.19250863790512085,
0.17881570756435394,
0.4130357503890991,
0.12774284183979034,
-0.7918428182601929,
0.04855829104781151,
0.6363440155982971,
0.760731041431427,
-0.277936190366745,
-0.6574704051017761,
-0.26356038451194763,
0.3377375602722168,
-0.2969655990600586,
0.5792419910430908,
-0.8067328929901123,
-0.4893219769001007,
0.12438072264194489,
0.344840943813324,
-0.09031269699335098,
-0.5830512642860413,
0.5568416714668274,
-0.30077025294303894,
0.11116144806146622,
-0.3791566789150238,
-0.15134276449680328,
-0.3738497197628021,
0.24236330389976501,
-0.7190951704978943,
0.9425421953201294,
0.4162507653236389,
-0.4789065718650818,
0.5759565830230713,
-0.6648154854774475,
-0.5597437620162964,
0.10234576463699341,
-0.0388193354010582,
-0.31182676553726196,
0.026695098727941513,
0.11929380893707275,
0.35185131430625916,
-0.5191308259963989,
0.1935906857252121,
-0.28927817940711975,
-0.3103755712509155,
0.05647370219230652,
-0.22356131672859192,
0.8841809034347534,
0.3410114347934723,
-0.47918131947517395,
0.32740604877471924,
-0.8023491501808167,
0.22265693545341492,
0.256477415561676,
-0.2786967158317566,
-0.5603171586990356,
-0.34138479828834534,
0.31205129623413086,
0.3715529441833496,
0.292690247297287,
-0.36574098467826843,
0.30597561597824097,
-0.5089309215545654,
0.4709343910217285,
0.6111918091773987,
-0.2452479600906372,
0.8129438757896423,
-0.12532460689544678,
0.8002989292144775,
0.13376812636852264,
0.12558580935001373,
-0.33245474100112915,
-0.1416233777999878,
-0.9239336252212524,
-0.3711722493171692,
-0.09664910286664963,
0.7613955140113831,
-0.6569913029670715,
0.25610020756721497,
-0.08759479224681854,
-0.508266270160675,
-0.5336444973945618,
0.3298510015010834,
0.4172542989253998,
0.09345316886901855,
0.3141093850135803,
-0.06864286959171295,
-0.6993448734283447,
-0.6553400158882141,
-0.2769855260848999,
-0.14093263447284698,
-0.06913089752197266,
0.23039491474628448,
0.0993068665266037,
-0.34550145268440247,
0.6098899245262146,
-0.39148184657096863,
-0.4884752929210663,
-0.7946539521217346,
-0.025132877752184868,
0.42028072476387024,
0.32668396830558777,
0.5986011624336243,
-0.6277635097503662,
-0.5841749310493469,
0.21539178490638733,
-0.32991012930870056,
-0.33073240518569946,
-0.00812368094921112,
-0.10443354398012161,
0.37762317061424255,
0.2835816442966461,
-0.5593666434288025,
0.28990036249160767,
0.6623448729515076,
-0.16067281365394592,
0.9494653940200806,
-0.2574918270111084,
0.1839316487312317,
-1.1099896430969238,
0.12348733097314835,
-0.050865720957517624,
0.12280044704675674,
-0.6504094004631042,
0.28609201312065125,
-0.0008771017310209572,
-0.5167173147201538,
-0.39657261967658997,
0.6189407706260681,
-0.8074387907981873,
-0.016854584217071533,
-0.41874608397483826,
0.3794804513454437,
0.04631301760673523,
0.5140891671180725,
0.4765181839466095,
0.9090401530265808,
0.29532113671302795,
-0.6710937023162842,
0.32888999581336975,
0.029525507241487503,
-0.09764988720417023,
0.951687753200531,
-0.6262251734733582,
0.0020172898657619953,
0.08473483473062515,
-0.18330107629299164,
-0.7961019277572632,
-0.12602555751800537,
0.1344209611415863,
0.08827035129070282,
0.47042056918144226,
-0.3586752414703369,
-0.3542534410953522,
-0.4043882489204407,
-0.2631959021091461,
0.5106967091560364,
0.08942820876836777,
-0.6428172588348389,
0.5057159662246704,
0.5425165295600891,
-0.36488255858421326,
-0.47702449560165405,
-0.38139405846595764,
0.20155632495880127,
-0.4784822463989258,
-0.4937521815299988,
-0.19571711122989655,
0.15278974175453186,
-0.3110838830471039,
-0.37871846556663513,
0.21262364089488983,
-0.08609722554683685,
0.020450253039598465,
0.05505676567554474,
0.39773645997047424,
-0.3171772062778473,
0.11590667814016342,
0.08756528049707413,
-0.4586411118507385,
-0.06655684113502502,
-0.6081771850585938,
0.6029883623123169,
-0.45054009556770325,
-0.4707762598991394,
-0.20792867243289948,
0.34752100706100464,
0.5038754343986511,
-0.6240831613540649,
0.6651555895805359,
0.5929046869277954,
-0.1690276563167572,
0.05662410333752632,
-0.5880255699157715,
-0.21956808865070343,
-0.4481882154941559,
0.634240984916687,
-0.5586091876029968,
-0.5879235863685608,
0.4211212396621704,
-0.43532589077949524,
0.0399094894528389,
0.14894889295101166,
0.38051146268844604,
0.4700023829936981,
1.4397963285446167,
0.6778491139411926,
-0.30356037616729736,
0.37129855155944824,
-0.17365095019340515,
0.4246542453765869,
-0.8166232705116272,
0.010165647603571415,
-0.6257810592651367,
0.11324075609445572,
-0.6523878574371338,
-0.41659581661224365,
0.297221302986145,
0.2726658880710602,
-0.48563918471336365,
0.3861624598503113,
-0.5904147028923035,
0.5438815355300903,
0.4054599106311798,
-0.12099535018205643,
0.6516492366790771,
-0.04911495000123978,
-0.37604913115501404,
-0.31504303216934204,
-0.9486448168754578,
-0.9604015350341797,
1.1829490661621094,
0.1833927184343338,
0.9798083305358887,
0.07850440591573715,
0.4788335859775543,
-0.32325294613838196,
0.2804122865200043,
-0.586458146572113,
0.5018998980522156,
-0.1485988050699234,
-0.3756844997406006,
-0.32661202549934387,
-0.05767815187573433,
-0.9458970427513123,
0.47476279735565186,
-0.06798439472913742,
-0.3803541660308838,
-0.022098833695054054,
0.009026695974171162,
0.0009125514188781381,
0.1944674551486969,
-0.8059736490249634,
0.9294243454933167,
-0.5850298404693604,
-0.4451373517513275,
-0.37865039706230164,
-0.5976083874702454,
0.4381321966648102,
0.07797633856534958,
0.2829539179801941,
-0.2482559084892273,
-0.09797461330890656,
0.3917253017425537,
-0.37244895100593567,
0.72776198387146,
-0.22302569448947906,
0.007723115850239992,
0.24018776416778564,
0.12989604473114014,
0.1889479011297226,
0.2801755666732788,
-0.14225409924983978,
0.17795199155807495,
0.1859574019908905,
-0.6537258625030518,
-0.24780158698558807,
0.7018186450004578,
-0.9261871576309204,
-0.573172390460968,
-0.6855389475822449,
-0.23684903979301453,
-0.16771890223026276,
0.6363727450370789,
0.049602072685956955,
-0.0530453696846962,
-0.30529308319091797,
-0.2951586842536926,
0.5926660299301147,
-0.4613906741142273,
0.03953172639012337,
0.7048428058624268,
-0.7158793210983276,
-0.45173588395118713,
0.9458006024360657,
-0.14321179687976837,
0.3729681372642517,
0.005447646137326956,
0.2731002867221832,
-0.40642091631889343,
-0.2719893753528595,
-0.7181428670883179,
0.6351941823959351,
-0.530000627040863,
-0.16101279854774475,
-0.1854434609413147,
-0.07484541833400726,
-0.2986219525337219,
-0.21425564587116241,
-0.5773884654045105,
-0.2511526346206665,
-0.34091681241989136,
0.03175005316734314,
0.07303191721439362,
0.8461979031562805,
0.0016268591862171888,
0.26048368215560913,
-0.6269960999488831,
-0.02110518515110016,
0.20508189499378204,
0.2352214902639389,
0.18161353468894958,
-0.28749871253967285,
-0.22318249940872192,
0.4805051386356354,
-0.2299843728542328,
-0.6816754341125488,
0.4887828230857849,
0.2716158628463745,
0.4443068504333496,
0.6249068975448608,
0.1710776388645172,
0.8871858716011047,
-0.3646211624145508,
0.6247534155845642,
0.15653394162654877,
-0.8587522506713867,
0.5343114137649536,
-0.29651331901550293,
0.5712600946426392,
0.4602954387664795,
0.2874463200569153,
-0.8756818771362305,
-0.4006386697292328,
-0.1530141979455948,
-0.8072892427444458,
0.5279538035392761,
-0.48002690076828003,
-0.055676840245723724,
-0.04437048360705376,
0.2872709035873413,
0.19358663260936737,
0.2902476489543915,
-0.644043505191803,
0.1287120282649994,
-0.449300616979599,
-0.06599795818328857,
-0.16478469967842102,
-0.28493085503578186,
-0.07054702192544937,
-0.14881201088428497,
0.7214087247848511,
-0.3417128622531891,
-0.02670564129948616,
0.003360751084983349,
-0.36716052889823914,
-0.1470090001821518,
0.37701451778411865,
0.6061806082725525,
1.0117303133010864,
0.23520220816135406,
-0.015646113082766533,
0.13938768208026886,
-0.5857672095298767,
0.26471489667892456,
0.06502002477645874,
-0.13773764669895172,
-0.15385276079177856,
0.09817587584257126,
0.5530709624290466,
0.35807815194129944,
-0.8441863656044006,
0.4706721007823944,
-0.05259956791996956,
0.133816659450531,
-0.5781729817390442,
-0.22295553982257843,
-0.01767030730843544,
0.07376134395599365,
0.5231917500495911,
-0.2855217754840851,
-0.1346188336610794,
-0.30187395215034485,
-0.12344250082969666,
0.454481840133667,
-0.3171112835407257,
-0.4491543173789978,
0.6890413761138916,
0.3747543394565582,
0.01782779023051262,
0.6929526925086975,
-0.41553282737731934,
-0.9841135740280151,
0.2946135401725769,
0.5534191131591797,
0.7028516530990601,
-0.5991401076316833,
0.4161790609359741,
0.5643283724784851,
0.5877059698104858,
-0.24202866852283478,
0.42127448320388794,
0.36664071679115295,
-0.40767231583595276,
-0.39482906460762024,
-0.5501269698143005,
-0.4009064733982086,
0.04322956129908562,
-0.6020991206169128,
0.7116087079048157,
-0.43504178524017334,
-0.004078062251210213,
-0.8171581625938416,
0.4975152015686035,
-0.7325976490974426,
-0.12439147382974625,
-0.3673337399959564,
0.8251359462738037,
-0.8998803496360779,
0.7924102544784546,
0.6957988142967224,
-0.5157440900802612,
-0.906637966632843,
-0.3100924491882324,
0.04886038973927498,
-0.8351414799690247,
0.6754006147384644,
0.32604607939720154,
-0.3047797381877899,
-0.13621316850185394,
-0.08599194884300232,
-0.8239259123802185,
0.9571468234062195,
0.2920325994491577,
-0.5206154584884644,
0.051894232630729675,
0.4784269630908966,
0.6809484362602234,
-0.5377174019813538,
0.24725238978862762,
0.6334038376808167,
0.6338117718696594,
0.048775363713502884,
-1.0182656049728394,
0.0016337474808096886,
0.07516732066869736,
0.29112598299980164,
0.16372926533222198,
-0.7852498292922974,
0.6800194978713989,
-0.5065895915031433,
-0.3600122928619385,
0.5416495203971863,
0.5113039016723633,
0.4178306460380554,
0.1971656084060669,
0.30459412932395935,
0.2402205467224121,
0.7673762440681458,
-0.09042678773403168,
0.530471920967102,
-0.6630585193634033,
0.14566458761692047,
1.0815867185592651,
-0.7045254707336426,
0.8941133618354797,
0.4739469885826111,
-0.20550745725631714,
0.17250636219978333,
0.6470662951469421,
0.25949186086654663,
0.22675077617168427,
0.12615640461444855,
-0.2634033262729645,
-0.07340774685144424,
-0.32234257459640503,
-0.4563978612422943,
0.7278931140899658,
0.2741447687149048,
-0.0678681880235672,
0.10642194002866745,
0.2191927582025528,
0.3992961347103119,
0.29226669669151306,
-0.4987820088863373,
0.5433663725852966,
-0.05737922340631485,
-0.6463587880134583,
0.6100553870201111,
0.08395829796791077,
0.5897183418273926,
-0.49779555201530457,
0.0301866065710783,
-0.22459399700164795,
0.456893652677536,
-0.13526779413223267,
-0.409186989068985,
0.1870684027671814,
-0.2083461731672287,
0.035776879638433456,
-0.14496256411075592,
0.6603527069091797,
-1.0523321628570557,
-0.742551326751709,
0.2122543454170227,
0.4467392861843109,
-0.0814041718840599,
-0.08033523708581924,
-0.7187786102294922,
0.15270978212356567,
-0.29680681228637695,
0.03542955964803696,
0.370444655418396,
0.35897526144981384,
-0.151945561170578,
0.7803398966789246,
0.6853451728820801,
0.34270939230918884,
-0.09324079751968384,
0.03131962567567825,
0.6739550232887268,
-0.5272768139839172,
-0.6440842151641846,
-0.47908666729927063,
0.02816978469491005,
-0.2546180486679077,
-0.31762585043907166,
1.0747272968292236,
0.7172185182571411,
1.1000674962997437,
-0.1496143639087677,
0.8022724986076355,
0.3492327630519867,
0.8968743681907654,
-0.26530519127845764,
0.8238552212715149,
-0.3576797544956207,
0.3728598356246948,
-0.4738653302192688,
-1.244939923286438,
-0.37695035338401794,
0.9578238129615784,
-0.3381481468677521,
0.1329575777053833,
0.6888290643692017,
0.7160789966583252,
0.05860832333564758,
0.13360297679901123,
0.11898479610681534,
0.09943665564060211,
0.24913011491298676,
0.8148200511932373,
0.7058166265487671,
-0.17959809303283691,
0.6084436774253845,
-0.2570512592792511,
-0.5280027985572815,
-0.26060566306114197,
-0.9753416180610657,
-1.1036667823791504,
-0.6140149831771851,
-0.06603182852268219,
-0.28701135516166687,
-0.12056510150432587,
1.0649783611297607,
0.6827871203422546,
-0.7377317547798157,
-0.8910142183303833,
0.20522727072238922,
0.29822224378585815,
-0.44761160016059875,
-0.20323067903518677,
0.232010617852211,
-0.2381231188774109,
-0.7146022915840149,
0.08082250505685806,
0.5806935429573059,
0.028493251651525497,
-0.8178446292877197,
-0.44944432377815247,
-0.282566100358963,
-0.29191914200782776,
0.8256152868270874,
0.4532085657119751,
-0.7060238718986511,
-0.13324277102947235,
0.40649348497390747,
-0.11742410063743591,
-0.08444385975599289,
0.988804280757904,
-0.45721131563186646,
0.5284920334815979,
0.06528188288211823,
0.5173007845878601,
0.2740642726421356,
-0.20125329494476318,
0.7631673812866211,
-0.2694437503814697,
0.5623791813850403,
0.12553855776786804,
0.16243726015090942,
0.4730505049228668,
-0.1553841531276703,
0.5326353907585144,
0.17161747813224792,
-0.5916259288787842,
-0.704985499382019,
0.4699973165988922,
-0.5999823212623596,
-0.2030525505542755,
1.2678252458572388,
-0.2496231496334076,
-0.20453450083732605,
-0.34536048769950867,
-0.6767685413360596,
0.08608731627464294,
-0.21276015043258667,
0.8208460211753845,
0.7752025723457336,
0.09949211031198502,
-0.3401755392551422,
-0.20432217419147491,
0.46425384283065796,
0.4533858299255371,
-0.539618968963623,
0.41323235630989075,
0.5091984868049622,
0.15441565215587616,
-0.020455211400985718,
0.29288285970687866,
-0.055131860077381134,
0.3493814468383789,
-0.24812385439872742,
-0.18882666528224945,
0.1415962129831314,
-0.3260553777217865,
-0.40596312284469604,
-0.14049452543258667,
0.629518985748291,
0.14065814018249512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09206v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09206v1
|
DKE-Research at SemEval-2024 Task 2: Incorporating Data Augmentation with Generative Models and Biomedical Knowledge to Enhance Inference Robustness
| 2024-04-14T10:02:47 | 2024-04-14T10:02:47 |
Yuqi Wang, Zeqiang Wang, Wei Wang, Qi Chen, Kaizhu Huang, Anh Nguyen, Suparna De
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Safe and reliable natural language inference is critical for extracting
insights from clinical trial reports but poses challenges due to biases in
large pre-trained language models. This paper presents a novel data
augmentation technique to improve model robustness for biomedical natural
language inference in clinical trials. By generating synthetic examples through
semantic perturbations and domain-specific vocabulary replacement and adding a
new task for numerical and quantitative reasoning, we introduce greater
diversity and reduce shortcut learning. Our approach, combined with multi-task
learning and the DeBERTa architecture, achieved significant performance gains
on the NLI4CT 2024 benchmark compared to the original language models. Ablation
studies validate the contribution of each augmentation method in improving
robustness. Our best-performing model ranked 12th in terms of faithfulness and
8th in terms of consistency, respectively, out of the 32 participants.
|
[
0.04654201120138168,
-0.9530801773071289,
0.56998211145401,
0.17848047614097595,
-0.29602470993995667,
0.042107585817575455,
0.017497507855296135,
-0.5178816318511963,
-0.17891916632652283,
0.6469660401344299,
-0.4153827130794525,
-0.6744022369384766,
-0.5829020142555237,
0.46331265568733215,
-0.035910941660404205,
0.6951132416725159,
0.17536857724189758,
0.36243975162506104,
-0.27198082208633423,
-0.38576334714889526,
-0.47442084550857544,
-0.5124029517173767,
-0.38901442289352417,
-0.3458721339702606,
0.3782168924808502,
0.05911921709775925,
0.6211374998092651,
0.5167894959449768,
0.6331917643547058,
0.27890393137931824,
-0.13350051641464233,
0.3224560022354126,
-0.24416087567806244,
0.22795183956623077,
-0.21022279560565948,
-0.5076996684074402,
-0.7064931392669678,
-0.20505601167678833,
0.361569881439209,
0.9275575280189514,
-0.07608824968338013,
-0.5765426158905029,
0.003830112051218748,
0.34366652369499207,
-0.526218593120575,
0.07825790345668793,
-0.6934328675270081,
-0.3454485535621643,
-0.06105305254459381,
-0.0951930359005928,
-0.47158733010292053,
-0.25453126430511475,
0.2151746153831482,
-0.7398921251296997,
0.1971614509820938,
-0.21100139617919922,
0.7125220894813538,
0.5396209955215454,
-0.553515613079071,
-0.1792220026254654,
-0.30344462394714355,
0.9049155116081238,
-1.2425154447555542,
0.48291367292404175,
0.5182130336761475,
0.12225127220153809,
-0.3340577483177185,
-0.7846842408180237,
-0.45907893776893616,
-0.2739948630332947,
-0.04035681486129761,
0.13329873979091644,
-0.19410276412963867,
0.36912697553634644,
0.35287344455718994,
0.13624323904514313,
-0.49137842655181885,
0.14901109039783478,
-0.24175336956977844,
-0.2297079712152481,
0.5028547048568726,
0.0537416934967041,
0.45665058493614197,
-0.15412119030952454,
-0.2526339292526245,
-0.1978410929441452,
-0.7045230269432068,
-0.266884446144104,
0.19005070626735687,
0.3218229115009308,
0.0197300985455513,
0.4815053641796112,
-0.22638805210590363,
0.7501765489578247,
-0.08103660494089127,
0.09461963921785355,
0.790420413017273,
-0.6931279301643372,
-0.3711988627910614,
-0.025625698268413544,
0.5200974345207214,
0.3595595061779022,
-0.2900276184082031,
-0.19347956776618958,
0.28083980083465576,
0.30420932173728943,
0.5303487777709961,
-0.8958321213722229,
-0.28799259662628174,
0.4761025309562683,
-0.17285321652889252,
-0.6064593195915222,
-0.37982842326164246,
-0.8705940842628479,
-0.2573710083961487,
-0.22786428034305573,
0.43578583002090454,
-0.8911702036857605,
-0.13746920228004456,
0.4461703300476074,
-0.02833867259323597,
-0.15735949575901031,
0.38426774740219116,
-0.6919381022453308,
0.22002235054969788,
0.4914030432701111,
0.5547106862068176,
-0.22164426743984222,
-0.14475888013839722,
-0.5717179775238037,
0.1360137164592743,
-0.215504989027977,
0.7323745489120483,
-0.48255041241645813,
-0.37994951009750366,
-0.23266355693340302,
0.14933788776397705,
-0.11863262206315994,
-0.45879989862442017,
0.8370240330696106,
-0.49415361881256104,
0.2618793845176697,
-0.17749129235744476,
-0.6737747192382812,
-0.2658945322036743,
0.2146022468805313,
-0.6468647718429565,
0.8025099039077759,
0.10746029764413834,
-0.7800695896148682,
0.5476235151290894,
-0.631561815738678,
-0.5472695827484131,
0.16559454798698425,
-0.293596476316452,
-0.6370636224746704,
0.054934099316596985,
0.5364862680435181,
0.23642107844352722,
0.049648404121398926,
0.4558500051498413,
-0.7364841103553772,
-0.07460339367389679,
0.24575622379779816,
-0.3703688979148865,
0.8658532500267029,
0.1951773315668106,
-0.28830206394195557,
-0.11932910233736038,
-0.9047451615333557,
-0.12199366837739944,
-0.0591527484357357,
-0.1311328262090683,
-0.5620678067207336,
-0.31732723116874695,
-0.1607699990272522,
-0.010171717032790184,
-0.0029916497878730297,
-0.73888099193573,
0.108254075050354,
-1.091347336769104,
0.44176211953163147,
0.32680466771125793,
0.22728873789310455,
0.43244192004203796,
-0.20561736822128296,
0.40920117497444153,
0.16267670691013336,
0.08676193654537201,
-0.12490714341402054,
-0.4875098466873169,
-0.20807859301567078,
-0.571861207485199,
0.6242046356201172,
0.42112937569618225,
-0.8869898319244385,
0.438942015171051,
-0.21843665838241577,
-0.28008508682250977,
-0.42039936780929565,
-0.07243663817644119,
0.15446843206882477,
0.8144503235816956,
0.6936026215553284,
-0.05435353145003319,
-0.7247000932693481,
-0.9055740833282471,
-0.11587294191122055,
0.018857505172491074,
-0.1344674676656723,
0.033997707068920135,
0.6076371669769287,
-0.6670925617218018,
0.6261345744132996,
-0.27602118253707886,
0.07606656104326248,
-0.26752129197120667,
0.3033853769302368,
0.24032948911190033,
0.6760078072547913,
0.5653032064437866,
-0.7616060972213745,
-0.008493372239172459,
-0.1343521773815155,
-0.7251081466674805,
-0.32383984327316284,
-0.19993022084236145,
-0.3407539129257202,
-0.026679467409849167,
0.23734186589717865,
-0.40857335925102234,
0.638579785823822,
0.36453038454055786,
-0.17480872571468353,
0.15141305327415466,
-0.4325532615184784,
0.5241696834564209,
-1.108377456665039,
-0.04127749428153038,
-0.22901104390621185,
-0.2425774782896042,
-0.90264892578125,
-0.05804649367928505,
0.20484724640846252,
0.246724933385849,
-0.20637819170951843,
0.3952452540397644,
-0.17214316129684448,
0.38603031635284424,
-0.5065820813179016,
-0.15819638967514038,
0.42061328887939453,
0.054976243525743484,
-0.03417087718844414,
0.6253802180290222,
0.5394602417945862,
-0.5243948101997375,
0.010701113380491734,
0.7921531200408936,
-0.2257768213748932,
0.2661411464214325,
-0.8451980948448181,
0.00936366431415081,
-0.31946855783462524,
0.21861432492733002,
-0.8868921995162964,
-0.4309755563735962,
-0.12067818641662598,
-0.5507742166519165,
0.28784704208374023,
0.04399050027132034,
-0.36939212679862976,
-0.3202943205833435,
-0.21789786219596863,
0.37304097414016724,
0.5743962526321411,
-0.41703495383262634,
0.5889859795570374,
0.4314999580383301,
-0.2766226530075073,
-0.45961520075798035,
-1.0768197774887085,
0.09567250311374664,
-0.26582086086273193,
-0.7047536373138428,
0.6914843320846558,
-0.014204843901097775,
-0.22721299529075623,
-0.14360135793685913,
0.01979779079556465,
-0.21676334738731384,
0.140029639005661,
-0.01969579979777336,
0.5049135684967041,
0.07980188727378845,
0.24559472501277924,
0.529049813747406,
0.050283148884773254,
-0.11186119168996811,
0.15462981164455414,
0.11805974692106247,
0.33622094988822937,
-0.52590012550354,
-0.48103779554367065,
0.45707830786705017,
0.584048867225647,
-0.10051469504833221,
0.5804178714752197,
0.3611188530921936,
-0.7339478135108948,
0.0056685637682676315,
-0.5264683365821838,
-0.5926234126091003,
-0.43816471099853516,
0.43524429202079773,
-0.2685701251029968,
-0.8147582411766052,
0.2666516602039337,
-0.08318160474300385,
0.10660315304994583,
0.4093931317329407,
0.7022511959075928,
0.08170206844806671,
1.2042537927627563,
0.2064828872680664,
0.35373038053512573,
0.07276026159524918,
-0.04784452170133591,
0.21837615966796875,
-0.7582612633705139,
-0.027843324467539787,
-0.3641056418418884,
0.10159250348806381,
-0.28086888790130615,
-0.7295383214950562,
0.5873318910598755,
-0.057834163308143616,
0.0005762611399404705,
0.3124253451824188,
-0.43538159132003784,
-0.02675972506403923,
0.24309760332107544,
0.5044561624526978,
0.33383575081825256,
0.08292181044816971,
-0.3152036964893341,
-0.30923715233802795,
-0.694633424282074,
-0.49045759439468384,
1.2719464302062988,
0.34578558802604675,
0.6708588004112244,
0.06784377992153168,
0.6384597420692444,
0.1646631360054016,
0.23784679174423218,
-0.25247713923454285,
0.13244812190532684,
-0.09739778935909271,
-0.7429414987564087,
-0.01804943196475506,
-0.3640632927417755,
-0.896844208240509,
0.25557538866996765,
-0.32380202412605286,
-0.6778283715248108,
0.36684224009513855,
0.2195519059896469,
-0.7191352248191833,
-0.0603739470243454,
-0.5191035866737366,
0.7620615363121033,
-0.21749980747699738,
-0.686671257019043,
-0.17591072618961334,
-0.7038527727127075,
0.330263614654541,
-0.20372959971427917,
0.3569723963737488,
-0.1546272188425064,
-0.06825871020555496,
0.31363576650619507,
-0.4620191752910614,
0.8182245492935181,
-0.13817621767520905,
0.01946355774998665,
0.14547507464885712,
-0.29661035537719727,
0.6585150361061096,
0.27223238348960876,
-0.37903377413749695,
0.07301855832338333,
0.1560554802417755,
-0.5031780004501343,
-0.595089852809906,
0.6637989282608032,
-0.35096314549446106,
-0.2967815399169922,
-0.35533949732780457,
-0.681320309638977,
-0.5903908014297485,
0.07200272381305695,
0.2715855836868286,
0.689158022403717,
-0.08648470044136047,
0.36516886949539185,
0.5928714275360107,
-0.5963687896728516,
-0.11442045867443085,
0.3473876714706421,
0.2692015469074249,
-0.7094873189926147,
0.40365010499954224,
-0.2898086905479431,
0.4561043977737427,
0.2883449196815491,
0.1086847111582756,
-0.7622113823890686,
-1.0551694631576538,
-0.3668024241924286,
0.1052069291472435,
-0.6280291676521301,
-0.09172652661800385,
-1.1013585329055786,
0.09874418377876282,
-0.8207920789718628,
0.005197219084948301,
-0.39250707626342773,
-0.4172336161136627,
-0.21998849511146545,
-0.28664839267730713,
0.36031797528266907,
0.36665046215057373,
-0.05079621449112892,
0.27667537331581116,
-0.958367645740509,
0.28991538286209106,
0.05658497288823128,
-0.10611235350370407,
-0.4168941080570221,
-0.6690273284912109,
-0.01740633323788643,
0.2712518572807312,
-0.23331594467163086,
-0.9188537001609802,
0.588942289352417,
0.23708084225654602,
0.7092360258102417,
0.06373553723096848,
0.06163014844059944,
0.7050554752349854,
-0.4162488579750061,
0.5528408288955688,
0.1953275203704834,
-0.5433512926101685,
0.6965097784996033,
-0.52247154712677,
0.3810752332210541,
0.9703616499900818,
0.16035348176956177,
0.1891317367553711,
-0.4309072494506836,
-0.7095947265625,
-0.8962700366973877,
0.21377728879451752,
0.6133019924163818,
-0.0399261973798275,
-0.12328687310218811,
0.40378862619400024,
0.335147887468338,
0.26136815547943115,
-0.2875909209251404,
0.041063565760850906,
-0.04502183571457863,
-0.6255209445953369,
0.16758856177330017,
-0.15327975153923035,
-0.23083201050758362,
-0.4843691289424896,
0.7853774428367615,
-0.40652650594711304,
0.1614338457584381,
0.413305401802063,
0.00038310454692691565,
0.20690059661865234,
0.3101578950881958,
0.4622649550437927,
0.6629475951194763,
-0.18495391309261322,
0.046626076102256775,
0.6389366388320923,
-0.5344924330711365,
-0.024990307167172432,
0.5164704322814941,
-0.10311537235975266,
-0.08189086616039276,
0.4376045763492584,
0.7550547122955322,
0.21210446953773499,
-0.810806393623352,
0.3602876365184784,
-0.15707017481327057,
-0.41538727283477783,
0.0006516575813293457,
-0.062498532235622406,
-0.08004850894212723,
0.1787564754486084,
0.11597836762666702,
0.17455647885799408,
0.6645215749740601,
-0.2039801925420761,
0.5557845830917358,
0.3527909517288208,
-0.3050559163093567,
-0.3399454355239868,
0.9699534773826599,
0.19741566479206085,
0.4443645477294922,
0.1731056123971939,
-0.015302922576665878,
-0.3392459750175476,
0.5037010908126831,
0.4598327875137329,
0.5315377712249756,
-0.16469739377498627,
-0.026197612285614014,
0.6532766819000244,
0.10861863195896149,
-0.0651082918047905,
0.5109412670135498,
0.26010286808013916,
-0.6931695342063904,
-0.7656211256980896,
-0.5347575545310974,
-0.41038984060287476,
0.18861660361289978,
-0.4754648208618164,
0.27350491285324097,
0.039356913417577744,
-0.39052823185920715,
0.2414364218711853,
-0.2123676985502243,
-0.4243210554122925,
0.35657998919487,
0.03173135221004486,
0.6895545721054077,
-0.7386560440063477,
0.962807297706604,
0.681597113609314,
-0.2279694676399231,
-0.5707993507385254,
-0.3256779909133911,
-0.025226879864931107,
-0.43505340814590454,
0.46060675382614136,
0.1545427143573761,
0.11519156396389008,
-0.13880912959575653,
-0.3294219672679901,
-0.7014948725700378,
0.9708740711212158,
0.3800143003463745,
-0.5985457301139832,
-0.20953422784805298,
0.22852852940559387,
0.5134879946708679,
-0.2692468464374542,
0.3417515158653259,
0.6956065893173218,
0.38737252354621887,
0.4116309583187103,
-0.6683959364891052,
0.03906925022602081,
-0.22283989191055298,
-0.1063004583120346,
-0.01680867001414299,
0.02284962870180607,
0.4129439890384674,
-0.19899645447731018,
0.0038705558981746435,
0.3551284968852997,
0.5407103300094604,
0.5392581224441528,
0.41175395250320435,
0.5403533577919006,
0.7630557417869568,
0.9361054301261902,
-0.11895632743835449,
0.9733441472053528,
-0.36930784583091736,
0.1711529940366745,
1.0564967393875122,
-0.5061590671539307,
0.3158973455429077,
0.5309113264083862,
-0.27268022298812866,
0.37570828199386597,
0.40514782071113586,
0.02282145619392395,
0.7415223717689514,
-0.02482287771999836,
-0.47491127252578735,
-0.38855212926864624,
-0.05616394802927971,
-0.2771313190460205,
0.36519163846969604,
0.5836169719696045,
-0.40929555892944336,
-0.1718689352273941,
0.36430323123931885,
0.013369262218475342,
0.07000312954187393,
0.24253612756729126,
0.6742256879806519,
0.02807789109647274,
-0.6310084462165833,
0.636726975440979,
-0.30576780438423157,
0.5173041224479675,
-0.5568538904190063,
-0.28688696026802063,
0.07502333074808121,
0.44016793370246887,
-0.017953071743249893,
-0.3036351203918457,
0.4695025682449341,
-0.08644461631774902,
0.24030892550945282,
0.10475970804691315,
0.7982146143913269,
-0.33888480067253113,
-0.7056300640106201,
0.22477291524410248,
0.3642295002937317,
-0.12467747181653976,
0.052775390446186066,
-0.7199771404266357,
0.11555744707584381,
0.119385726749897,
-0.07931366562843323,
0.13677895069122314,
0.26286637783050537,
0.129201278090477,
0.43518033623695374,
0.6337835788726807,
0.1513238102197647,
-0.05330318212509155,
0.2727082073688507,
1.007633924484253,
-0.35806262493133545,
-0.28716331720352173,
-0.82405024766922,
0.5974406599998474,
-0.4622187316417694,
-0.16722697019577026,
0.7106584310531616,
0.4309077262878418,
0.21406349539756775,
0.0021435113158077,
0.9503989815711975,
0.019436726346611977,
0.7730279564857483,
-0.5173925161361694,
0.4624916613101959,
-0.5428205728530884,
0.16273441910743713,
-0.13236799836158752,
-0.308834969997406,
-0.520345151424408,
0.4817434549331665,
-0.388074666261673,
-0.007490662392228842,
0.701194703578949,
0.8388795852661133,
-0.004256087355315685,
0.3345770537853241,
0.38368967175483704,
0.30916735529899597,
0.5273038744926453,
0.4583011269569397,
0.515382707118988,
-0.6042407155036926,
0.08227091282606125,
-0.5216014981269836,
-0.4547208249568939,
0.003297511488199234,
-0.8741255402565002,
-0.8978217244148254,
-0.3044895827770233,
-0.4946414530277252,
-0.3411972224712372,
0.22210505604743958,
0.8937345743179321,
0.810885488986969,
-1.0332274436950684,
0.5021801590919495,
-0.5501790642738342,
-0.3260260820388794,
-0.1402479112148285,
-0.1621338427066803,
0.2854774296283722,
-0.570107638835907,
-0.9650505781173706,
0.8775065541267395,
0.29779407382011414,
0.11748884618282318,
0.11012288928031921,
-0.01399823185056448,
-0.4183412790298462,
0.15327459573745728,
0.4375198781490326,
-0.005579136777669191,
-0.4763261675834656,
-0.024789728224277496,
0.15791438519954681,
-0.036342937499284744,
0.007925307378172874,
0.42688697576522827,
-0.8050824403762817,
0.7923657298088074,
0.6458472609519958,
1.0018128156661987,
0.48108163475990295,
0.22621406614780426,
0.8712139129638672,
-0.4252258837223053,
0.282619446516037,
0.5592976808547974,
0.38554638624191284,
0.4921779930591583,
-0.3467753231525421,
0.5682151317596436,
0.2831754684448242,
-0.7431100606918335,
-0.8291859030723572,
0.10008397698402405,
-0.9824426174163818,
-0.24244222044944763,
1.090724229812622,
-0.04754679650068283,
-0.3155597150325775,
-0.4667764902114868,
-0.14760638773441315,
0.35782763361930847,
-0.21026697754859924,
0.6184831857681274,
0.4586544632911682,
-0.23628449440002441,
0.1347639411687851,
-0.9061410427093506,
0.6367238163948059,
0.7885050177574158,
-1.012934923171997,
-0.14773014187812805,
0.5566516518592834,
0.22056569159030914,
-0.019611580297350883,
0.47794196009635925,
-0.4502539336681366,
0.3211837112903595,
-0.08547373116016388,
-0.13388770818710327,
0.06902862340211868,
0.00458906777203083,
-0.33031293749809265,
-0.03835197538137436,
-0.06787039339542389,
-0.16235367953777313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09173v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09173v3
|
TransformerFAM: Feedback attention is working memory
| 2024-04-14T07:43:45 | 2024-05-07T13:23:46 |
Dongseong Hwang, Weiran Wang, Zhuoyuan Huo, Khe Chai Sim, Pedro Moreno Mengibar
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
While Transformers have revolutionized deep learning, their quadratic
attention complexity hinders their ability to process infinitely long inputs.
We propose Feedback Attention Memory (FAM), a novel Transformer architecture
that leverages a feedback loop to enable the network to attend to its own
latent representations. This design fosters the emergence of working memory
within the Transformer, allowing it to process indefinitely long sequences.
TransformerFAM requires no additional weights, enabling seamless integration
with pre-trained models. Our experiments show that TransformerFAM significantly
improves Transformer performance on long-context tasks across various model
sizes (1B, 8B, and 24B). These results showcase the potential to empower Large
Language Models (LLMs) to process sequences of unlimited length.
|
[
-0.514886736869812,
-0.4990307092666626,
0.38805678486824036,
0.5435448884963989,
0.0931180864572525,
0.07280813902616501,
-0.40059778094291687,
-0.1870400309562683,
0.3226083815097809,
0.8105869293212891,
-0.6086761951446533,
0.055308010429143906,
-0.6270022392272949,
0.05394142121076584,
-0.44386038184165955,
1.1755549907684326,
-0.004044933710247278,
-0.11356453597545624,
-0.21406957507133484,
-0.2145732343196869,
-0.5511772632598877,
-0.5004833936691284,
-0.8025273680686951,
-0.7160986661911011,
0.8013951778411865,
0.3941981792449951,
0.8217005133628845,
0.38674017786979675,
0.43483418226242065,
0.32352742552757263,
-0.007884969003498554,
0.12212229520082474,
-0.7770536541938782,
0.32336390018463135,
-0.31729525327682495,
-0.6170145869255066,
-0.5314351916313171,
0.08643294870853424,
0.8144863247871399,
0.717894434928894,
0.03207787498831749,
0.14270690083503723,
0.037837788462638855,
0.9456386566162109,
-0.5353161096572876,
0.10317371785640717,
-0.26067015528678894,
0.36103013157844543,
0.28521326184272766,
-0.004993396811187267,
-0.8786954879760742,
-0.14341993629932404,
0.3786039352416992,
-0.15334375202655792,
0.24167661368846893,
-0.01512331236153841,
0.6117083430290222,
0.7788777947425842,
-0.01438684668391943,
-0.010365650989115238,
-1.3356990814208984,
0.5143712162971497,
-0.4393167197704315,
0.6496577262878418,
0.17836786806583405,
0.25277218222618103,
-0.18014732003211975,
-0.9481661915779114,
-0.7005602121353149,
-0.1442379504442215,
-0.04444975405931473,
0.2348991483449936,
-0.39456692337989807,
0.16503044962882996,
0.3935493528842926,
0.6282703876495361,
-0.176278755068779,
-0.18986445665359497,
-0.3598189651966095,
0.022138971835374832,
0.2451455444097519,
0.25188618898391724,
-0.08932588994503021,
0.17434097826480865,
-0.3871270716190338,
-0.0002646577195264399,
-0.39191171526908875,
0.0026956149376928806,
-0.006576150190085173,
-0.04635629430413246,
0.045491550117731094,
0.3250381648540497,
0.06583282351493835,
0.44406363368034363,
0.5041227340698242,
0.16257143020629883,
0.0707184374332428,
0.14066173136234283,
-0.6029155254364014,
-0.26531192660331726,
0.8263595700263977,
-0.0331093929708004,
0.12054776400327682,
-0.7397775053977966,
-0.3174249529838562,
-0.17768920958042145,
0.7025896310806274,
-0.8267800211906433,
-0.36273396015167236,
0.09939336031675339,
-0.3407968580722809,
0.029226630926132202,
0.11357858031988144,
-0.8608928918838501,
-0.16669093072414398,
-0.34677770733833313,
0.5360961556434631,
-0.1420143097639084,
-0.14840377867221832,
0.0881410762667656,
0.15224586427211761,
0.14867524802684784,
0.23503781855106354,
-0.8782228231430054,
0.4720483720302582,
0.5172537565231323,
0.9598766565322876,
-0.4037140905857086,
-0.3477526009082794,
-0.7140784859657288,
0.07978082448244095,
-0.2687722146511078,
0.6485165953636169,
-0.5489736795425415,
-0.3438233435153961,
-0.16892023384571075,
0.3742576241493225,
-0.1718670278787613,
-0.6441919207572937,
0.08747529238462448,
-0.9128801226615906,
0.25091302394866943,
0.12909047305583954,
-0.47244295477867126,
-0.22399814426898956,
-0.0083045344799757,
-1.0239231586456299,
1.182774305343628,
0.259956419467926,
-0.34491705894470215,
-0.09613579511642456,
-0.9329819083213806,
-0.6150996685028076,
0.09095913916826248,
0.058876439929008484,
-0.6180471181869507,
0.36082515120506287,
-0.15755929052829742,
0.571739912033081,
-0.2809284031391144,
0.2134815752506256,
-0.08859188854694366,
-0.49475985765457153,
0.3775070011615753,
-0.39846929907798767,
0.16863220930099487,
-0.055361080914735794,
-0.7098065614700317,
0.14497467875480652,
-0.5645154118537903,
-0.44106999039649963,
0.1283946931362152,
-0.35334858298301697,
0.2561655640602112,
-0.3034294843673706,
-0.09465964138507843,
0.4309312701225281,
-0.05393218249082565,
-0.47280216217041016,
0.22555606067180634,
-0.5602378845214844,
0.664578378200531,
0.809919536113739,
-0.23550961911678314,
0.798045814037323,
-0.31988099217414856,
0.7811543941497803,
0.09213675558567047,
0.04678339138627052,
-0.5502275228500366,
-0.12517666816711426,
-1.388949990272522,
-0.054809991270303726,
0.2718553841114044,
0.1349393129348755,
-0.6469844579696655,
0.25670188665390015,
-0.42111197113990784,
-0.2756580412387848,
-0.5485529899597168,
0.2823261320590973,
0.1448259800672531,
0.31098535656929016,
0.42805659770965576,
-0.35050591826438904,
-0.42822080850601196,
-0.8862319588661194,
0.2104455828666687,
0.15488243103027344,
-0.10806991159915924,
0.47703561186790466,
0.45529642701148987,
-0.5533320307731628,
0.9144107103347778,
-0.5164123773574829,
-0.46719470620155334,
-0.22591225802898407,
0.07185066491365433,
0.2338578850030899,
0.16386134922504425,
0.355406254529953,
-0.4984752833843231,
-0.3124412000179291,
-0.35454514622688293,
-0.3004084527492523,
0.18127800524234772,
-0.2888052463531494,
-0.15804296731948853,
0.30725333094596863,
0.41442954540252686,
-0.8172515630722046,
0.25204795598983765,
0.47746267914772034,
-0.3041447401046753,
0.15579432249069214,
-0.0008695943979546428,
-0.22769376635551453,
-1.030800461769104,
0.24005375802516937,
-0.15493489801883698,
-0.4531616270542145,
-0.4935842454433441,
-0.22395507991313934,
-0.02948824129998684,
-0.25703468918800354,
-0.34277939796447754,
0.5180217027664185,
-0.43004733324050903,
-0.11527398228645325,
-0.7115209102630615,
-0.06045350804924965,
0.16404472291469574,
0.9565726518630981,
0.04161355644464493,
0.8495382070541382,
0.1974361538887024,
-0.6410273313522339,
0.46664750576019287,
0.26487094163894653,
0.01611105538904667,
0.26227685809135437,
-0.6346966624259949,
0.5330435633659363,
-0.17738044261932373,
0.44728967547416687,
-1.2341595888137817,
-0.11996262520551682,
0.20724225044250488,
-0.37041836977005005,
0.582595705986023,
0.17769654095172882,
-0.4291019141674042,
-0.7844932079315186,
-0.08944731205701828,
0.269501268863678,
0.5542266368865967,
-0.7434960603713989,
1.01649010181427,
0.2482583373785019,
-0.02025664784014225,
-0.4720340967178345,
-0.7213723063468933,
0.05635632574558258,
0.2562742829322815,
-0.3771953284740448,
0.23291684687137604,
-0.16910821199417114,
0.3614542484283447,
0.025170883163809776,
-0.1738142967224121,
0.0844823569059372,
0.039766181260347366,
0.6197533011436462,
0.2655629515647888,
-0.3534700870513916,
0.28537362813949585,
-0.26626554131507874,
-0.32830673456192017,
0.3364587724208832,
-0.4313736855983734,
0.6680967807769775,
-0.19932840764522552,
-0.01438393909484148,
-0.398840993642807,
0.38511744141578674,
1.1360567808151245,
-0.2064368724822998,
0.5151940584182739,
0.602456271648407,
-0.2736811935901642,
-0.6731869578361511,
-0.6071544289588928,
-0.41438359022140503,
-0.5152562260627747,
0.3626515567302704,
-0.031172366812825203,
-1.4743093252182007,
0.3587678074836731,
-0.22537842392921448,
0.06080979108810425,
0.3117945194244385,
0.9367006421089172,
-0.1497410535812378,
0.7365482449531555,
0.8561892509460449,
-0.4983084797859192,
0.5214880704879761,
-0.5205346941947937,
0.5588989853858948,
-0.918701171875,
-0.24175076186656952,
-0.14000387489795685,
-0.6837674379348755,
-0.08833158016204834,
-0.6569492220878601,
-0.15195044875144958,
-0.08802530914545059,
-0.2089783102273941,
0.3203284740447998,
-0.7018434405326843,
0.574630856513977,
0.38724035024642944,
0.15887483954429626,
-0.002789050340652466,
-0.35441282391548157,
-0.08116424828767776,
-0.022340260446071625,
-0.6365953683853149,
-0.3230797052383423,
0.8468452095985413,
0.7605470418930054,
0.8950107097625732,
-0.15350867807865143,
0.2992636561393738,
0.2853793799877167,
0.653558611869812,
-1.1686750650405884,
0.46004849672317505,
-0.06934884190559387,
-0.2600233852863312,
-0.19454768300056458,
-0.06182907149195671,
-0.8781524896621704,
-0.13167715072631836,
0.14278048276901245,
-0.6061506867408752,
0.0069345091469585896,
0.3233940601348877,
-0.767340898513794,
0.40599873661994934,
-0.38354289531707764,
0.474265456199646,
-0.04709003493189812,
-0.5565720796585083,
-0.12714019417762756,
-0.6441155672073364,
0.2284960001707077,
0.05582404509186745,
-0.2559652328491211,
0.07933862507343292,
0.10004104673862457,
0.780810534954071,
-0.245357945561409,
0.9993260502815247,
-0.017318248748779297,
-0.07409867644309998,
0.22661598026752472,
0.026647886261343956,
0.37307310104370117,
0.1372588723897934,
0.2781028151512146,
-0.03203124925494194,
-0.7415688037872314,
-0.19448670744895935,
-0.7680373787879944,
0.8086342811584473,
-0.8592625856399536,
-0.9005677700042725,
-0.317180871963501,
-0.7176886200904846,
-0.378289133310318,
0.18411880731582642,
0.0013275964884087443,
0.0829600989818573,
0.016061007976531982,
0.5496648550033569,
1.199082851409912,
0.18500114977359772,
0.8209518194198608,
0.4951733648777008,
-0.32111242413520813,
-0.5956500768661499,
0.7142943143844604,
0.17944887280464172,
0.19997961819171906,
0.4051693379878998,
-0.10081756860017776,
-0.14546552300453186,
-0.15129181742668152,
-0.38002559542655945,
0.23651736974716187,
-0.5719097852706909,
-0.3667346239089966,
-1.1467325687408447,
-0.47700637578964233,
-0.13221116364002228,
-0.009195499122142792,
-0.6949647068977356,
-0.09959621727466583,
-0.3491595983505249,
-0.21106170117855072,
0.4033581018447876,
0.8121988773345947,
0.13877232372760773,
0.4113801121711731,
-0.8003217577934265,
0.4906836748123169,
0.5978168249130249,
0.802949845790863,
0.6126346588134766,
-0.5747348666191101,
-0.6426117420196533,
-0.2726873457431793,
-0.5577805042266846,
-0.5439552068710327,
0.2329026162624359,
0.16123296320438385,
0.4607284367084503,
0.39818859100341797,
-0.16699086129665375,
0.3114183843135834,
-0.7209483981132507,
0.8500252962112427,
0.2386474311351776,
-0.9036524891853333,
0.18718719482421875,
0.06104709580540657,
0.7849483489990234,
0.3488108515739441,
0.38476577401161194,
-0.5331354737281799,
-0.4901261329650879,
-0.45151475071907043,
-0.7060335278511047,
0.8544118404388428,
0.11644863337278366,
0.5146607756614685,
-0.2385721504688263,
0.4423820376396179,
0.11339357495307922,
0.10104440152645111,
-0.6114509105682373,
-0.35317662358283997,
-0.34922704100608826,
0.0025542171206325293,
0.026987064629793167,
-0.4156111776828766,
-0.1257493495941162,
-0.3257173001766205,
0.4472372233867645,
-0.24474965035915375,
0.88283771276474,
0.21930266916751862,
-0.10147957503795624,
-0.3925827145576477,
0.09373912215232849,
0.6860065460205078,
0.4462065100669861,
0.15459123253822327,
0.2925461232662201,
0.2573584020137787,
-0.6277580857276917,
0.26759424805641174,
-0.09333845973014832,
-0.04183975234627724,
0.21340282261371613,
0.10568156093358994,
1.0058008432388306,
0.5791699290275574,
-0.32905733585357666,
0.5659371614456177,
-0.2505093812942505,
-0.345808744430542,
-0.3689228296279907,
0.3051602840423584,
0.5436095595359802,
0.42179203033447266,
0.6191253662109375,
0.22696377336978912,
0.011472267098724842,
-0.26177793741226196,
0.6153212785720825,
0.037989381700754166,
-0.7759512662887573,
-0.5063844919204712,
0.8894110321998596,
0.21611693501472473,
-0.6238598823547363,
0.5606390833854675,
0.42767420411109924,
-0.6978980898857117,
0.6232810616493225,
0.7139305472373962,
1.0944160223007202,
-0.44887179136276245,
0.06769533455371857,
0.19837065041065216,
0.13418897986412048,
-0.07455234974622726,
0.152539923787117,
-0.25071269273757935,
-0.551861584186554,
-0.6419356465339661,
-0.681209921836853,
-0.3149315416812897,
0.3871822655200958,
-0.7922297120094299,
0.07325290888547897,
-0.8407866954803467,
-0.31524205207824707,
0.05625859275460243,
-0.3273845314979553,
-0.8067754507064819,
0.3740145266056061,
0.25378867983818054,
0.7939457893371582,
-0.5437645316123962,
0.9533706307411194,
0.4463910460472107,
-0.22368088364601135,
-0.7711390256881714,
0.03001595102250576,
-0.5021901726722717,
-0.5845032930374146,
0.655571460723877,
0.5413499474525452,
-0.42990589141845703,
0.10489753633737564,
-0.5352254509925842,
-0.8533627390861511,
1.0855811834335327,
0.3766094446182251,
-0.8128409385681152,
-0.04491095617413521,
0.18731872737407684,
0.6140845417976379,
-0.46080976724624634,
0.23956450819969177,
0.6419755220413208,
0.23489071428775787,
0.23426102101802826,
-0.5644404888153076,
0.0412011556327343,
-0.261508584022522,
0.1360749453306198,
0.4842129051685333,
-1.1808362007141113,
0.5730047821998596,
-0.20863012969493866,
-0.17531749606132507,
-0.1376560628414154,
1.0401629209518433,
-0.2464277148246765,
0.05301980674266815,
0.46801120042800903,
0.8386307954788208,
0.46043115854263306,
-0.08666283637285233,
0.872710645198822,
-0.3975430130958557,
0.38778212666511536,
1.3208955526351929,
-0.1812771111726761,
0.6635400652885437,
0.6286116242408752,
-0.08374818414449692,
0.5116927027702332,
0.3676718771457672,
-0.24287329614162445,
0.5733159780502319,
0.11683817952871323,
-0.03035733290016651,
-0.18081209063529968,
-0.11699514836072922,
-0.13481715321540833,
0.18327492475509644,
0.22469362616539001,
-0.7428523302078247,
0.057648465037345886,
0.39170923829078674,
0.12258744239807129,
-0.08189201354980469,
-0.3497428596019745,
0.9430170655250549,
0.41919463872909546,
-0.8155809640884399,
0.4472731649875641,
-0.307786762714386,
0.593390703201294,
-0.30259647965431213,
-0.15347576141357422,
-0.3475782871246338,
0.35398468375205994,
-0.23289291560649872,
-0.6487482786178589,
0.5160767436027527,
-0.37390032410621643,
-0.7794983386993408,
-0.2414451688528061,
0.5359313488006592,
-0.4489794671535492,
-0.14424628019332886,
0.673920214176178,
0.08785755932331085,
-0.35549497604370117,
0.11627517640590668,
-0.4317435324192047,
0.04613132402300835,
-0.17838120460510254,
-0.6349761486053467,
0.13507305085659027,
0.2843358516693115,
0.3216477930545807,
0.7596049308776855,
0.479223370552063,
-0.39122676849365234,
0.16146264970302582,
0.06762241572141647,
1.1662169694900513,
-0.707041323184967,
-0.4765905737876892,
-0.9616032838821411,
0.3624216616153717,
0.15765777230262756,
-0.3147452473640442,
0.5254278779029846,
0.4426252543926239,
0.731595516204834,
-0.32030221819877625,
0.6719995737075806,
0.324093222618103,
0.17932367324829102,
-0.0900801420211792,
0.6826974153518677,
-0.31575000286102295,
-0.06684061884880066,
0.007035072892904282,
-0.9651524424552917,
-0.21318858861923218,
0.4323573708534241,
-0.2554481327533722,
0.010850917547941208,
0.8151140213012695,
0.4505329430103302,
-0.04877583310008049,
0.27953189611434937,
0.39061883091926575,
0.3054814040660858,
0.16948622465133667,
0.8992574214935303,
0.7804805636405945,
-0.4522792398929596,
0.5132327079772949,
-0.2760279178619385,
-0.0426698699593544,
-0.3886661231517792,
-0.5609517693519592,
-1.0938763618469238,
-0.4394132196903229,
-0.17088530957698822,
-0.4942737817764282,
-0.2886487543582916,
0.8536990284919739,
0.835418701171875,
-0.889843225479126,
0.026155641302466393,
-0.06768716871738434,
-0.002340545877814293,
-0.13059963285923004,
-0.3092394471168518,
0.24616223573684692,
-0.43108904361724854,
-0.7792391777038574,
0.27071821689605713,
0.8757129311561584,
-0.0978485494852066,
-0.7484660744667053,
-0.2263822704553604,
0.01329890638589859,
0.2156120240688324,
0.7457647323608398,
0.22718772292137146,
-0.622700035572052,
-0.3932132124900818,
0.5095070600509644,
-0.35621407628059387,
0.3941654860973358,
1.0194997787475586,
-0.8617969155311584,
0.5497658252716064,
0.33686378598213196,
1.2112659215927124,
0.7202911376953125,
-0.4484007954597473,
0.8521221280097961,
-0.41032254695892334,
0.09745324403047562,
0.5986794829368591,
0.3508399724960327,
0.19878536462783813,
-0.6707277894020081,
0.4407104253768921,
0.13163131475448608,
-0.7616960406303406,
-0.49803951382637024,
0.06717730313539505,
-1.0842169523239136,
-0.025009149685502052,
0.8784315586090088,
-0.2886984348297119,
-0.4919382631778717,
-0.0619414858520031,
-0.12668566405773163,
0.25365591049194336,
-0.4274677038192749,
0.8787545561790466,
0.8578044772148132,
-0.07366505265235901,
-0.6726332902908325,
-0.3548339903354645,
0.3016536831855774,
0.6965101957321167,
-0.36336377263069153,
0.011318167671561241,
0.13400393724441528,
0.2451835572719574,
0.3865790367126465,
0.508904218673706,
-0.0673506036400795,
0.6527066230773926,
-0.43124017119407654,
0.05411184951663017,
-0.13205647468566895,
-0.7383993268013,
-0.38889598846435547,
0.5153354406356812,
-0.10876231640577316,
-0.06294209510087967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09170v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09170v2
|
Post-Semantic-Thinking: A Robust Strategy to Distill Reasoning Capacity from Large Language Models
| 2024-04-14T07:19:27 | 2024-04-16T07:38:51 |
Xiaoshu Chen, Sihang Zhou, Ke Liang, Xinwang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chain of thought finetuning aims to endow small student models with reasoning
capacity to improve their performance towards a specific task by allowing them
to imitate the reasoning procedure of large language models (LLMs) beyond
simply predicting the answer to the question. However, the existing methods 1)
generate rationale before the answer, making their answer correctness sensitive
to the hallucination in the rationale;2) force the student model to repeat the
exact LLMs rationale expression word-after-word, which could have the model
biased towards learning the expression in rationale but count against the model
from understanding the core logic behind it. Therefore, we propose a robust
Post-Semantic-Thinking (PST) strategy to generate answers before rationale.
Thanks to this answer-first setting, 1) the answering procedure can escape from
the adverse effects caused by hallucinations in the rationale; 2) the complex
reasoning procedure is tightly bound with the relatively concise answer, making
the reasoning for questions easier with the prior information in the answer; 3)
the efficiency of the method can also benefit from the setting since users can
stop the generation right after answers are outputted when inference is
conducted. Furthermore, the PST strategy loose the constraint against the
generated rationale to be close to the LLMs gold standard in the hidden
semantic space instead of the vocabulary space, thus making the small student
model better comprehend the semantic reasoning logic in rationale. Extensive
experiments conducted across 12 reasoning tasks demonstrate the effectiveness
of PST.
|
[
-0.5982991456985474,
-1.006921648979187,
0.8310704827308655,
-0.2042926698923111,
-0.6018410325050354,
-0.06697846204042435,
-0.23152124881744385,
-0.04816066846251488,
0.30628037452697754,
0.751788854598999,
-0.8840343952178955,
-0.10607488453388214,
-0.4313942790031433,
0.08919475972652435,
-0.1876501888036728,
0.9046282768249512,
-0.07554862648248672,
-0.028453832492232323,
-0.08394520729780197,
0.06702430546283722,
-0.409390389919281,
-0.5272535681724548,
-0.49861806631088257,
-0.2780646085739136,
0.4597739279270172,
0.2473004311323166,
0.626838743686676,
0.3851074278354645,
0.5108314156532288,
0.2831346392631531,
0.01609518751502037,
0.2711503207683563,
-0.5412941575050354,
0.11081923544406891,
-0.6783567667007446,
-0.511906087398529,
-0.4266749918460846,
-0.058533113449811935,
0.4433482885360718,
0.7834046483039856,
-0.2032993733882904,
0.11167909950017929,
0.13377322256565094,
0.5256384015083313,
-0.6925413608551025,
-0.1468510627746582,
-1.065272331237793,
-0.05866246297955513,
0.0108064915984869,
-0.4481755197048187,
-0.44548630714416504,
-0.18577881157398224,
0.5223020315170288,
-0.6773594617843628,
-0.12876377999782562,
-0.16874997317790985,
0.661585807800293,
0.36377179622650146,
-0.11063502728939056,
-0.11480525135993958,
-0.6783050894737244,
0.8718723654747009,
-0.6792219281196594,
0.24058715999126434,
0.29271748661994934,
0.37699654698371887,
-0.29056355357170105,
-0.7758054137229919,
-0.6221921443939209,
-0.045721739530563354,
0.1801779568195343,
0.19052380323410034,
0.10748405009508133,
0.09051584452390671,
0.624572217464447,
0.24624401330947876,
-0.4388618767261505,
-0.4318171441555023,
-0.2892509698867798,
-0.20962634682655334,
0.4205818176269531,
0.019542036578059196,
-0.04898122325539589,
-0.11524965614080429,
-0.4848313629627228,
-0.15177394449710846,
-0.5899616479873657,
-0.13018618524074554,
0.07219220697879791,
0.33730852603912354,
0.7299032807350159,
0.8327024579048157,
-0.5108323693275452,
0.5946537852287292,
0.2052515298128128,
-0.17872369289398193,
-0.09899669885635376,
-0.404777467250824,
-0.27709755301475525,
0.22710679471492767,
0.6266151666641235,
0.3358308672904968,
0.4189041256904602,
-0.08706296235322952,
-0.37463483214378357,
0.6304410696029663,
0.4517999589443207,
-0.8987676501274109,
-0.39947637915611267,
-0.024924105033278465,
-0.3776964843273163,
-0.05234065651893616,
-0.07654492557048798,
-0.7113343477249146,
-0.023034797981381416,
-0.6725968718528748,
0.6148409247398376,
-0.6947638988494873,
-0.3960738778114319,
0.5178852081298828,
0.03250284492969513,
0.32305803894996643,
0.3923264145851135,
-0.7109899520874023,
0.6964486241340637,
0.5664779543876648,
0.7373822927474976,
-0.06545441597700119,
-0.254284143447876,
-0.5186509490013123,
0.16340266168117523,
-0.32512450218200684,
0.9240018129348755,
-0.2524932026863098,
-0.000830381119158119,
-0.16785046458244324,
-0.03248002752661705,
-0.1417025923728943,
-0.2733690142631531,
0.4198048710823059,
-0.5795887112617493,
0.2018008679151535,
-0.6749994158744812,
-0.741669774055481,
-0.11478610336780548,
0.43671777844429016,
-0.36060830950737,
0.716865599155426,
-0.056221555918455124,
-0.9384515881538391,
0.2483045607805252,
-0.38924258947372437,
-0.31198281049728394,
-0.03768616169691086,
-0.21663877367973328,
-0.06493524461984634,
0.23800072073936462,
0.17207953333854675,
0.4200288653373718,
-0.143707275390625,
0.2526604235172272,
-0.2843093276023865,
-0.267633855342865,
0.12924301624298096,
-0.3920978605747223,
0.7492847442626953,
0.315366268157959,
-0.4038269519805908,
0.2871681749820709,
-0.5879124999046326,
0.37940728664398193,
0.237351655960083,
0.12466655671596527,
-0.5597965717315674,
0.02679978683590889,
-0.4592309594154358,
0.5478582978248596,
0.09404485672712326,
-0.35850632190704346,
0.12832656502723694,
-0.611089825630188,
0.5147045254707336,
0.7604106068611145,
0.10211273282766342,
0.5215458869934082,
-0.4721580147743225,
0.44802096486091614,
-0.1408887356519699,
0.04347942769527435,
0.029329856857657433,
-0.29448002576828003,
-0.6764545440673828,
0.006883679889142513,
-0.018860572949051857,
0.6658839583396912,
-1.1312130689620972,
0.5157533884048462,
-0.12043595314025879,
-0.5770379304885864,
-0.4567423164844513,
0.15971486270427704,
0.3196253478527069,
0.7225143313407898,
0.436972975730896,
-0.2438529133796692,
-0.5580436587333679,
-0.7134203910827637,
-0.22721707820892334,
-0.16971197724342346,
-0.08475623279809952,
-0.11285658925771713,
0.6221087574958801,
-0.10865044593811035,
0.8224648833274841,
-0.7378234267234802,
0.06951777637004852,
-0.43937355279922485,
-0.15691593289375305,
-0.04604979231953621,
0.44989529252052307,
0.0721311867237091,
-0.5139411687850952,
-0.05669431760907173,
-0.24173642694950104,
-0.49392014741897583,
0.05825559049844742,
-0.2733955681324005,
-0.705795407295227,
0.09335985779762268,
0.3796786665916443,
-0.9130960702896118,
0.39019277691841125,
-0.08982504904270172,
-0.3551550805568695,
0.8722871541976929,
-0.17875568568706512,
0.03870121389627457,
-1.1110886335372925,
-0.1808159202337265,
-0.19664700329303741,
-0.03966021165251732,
-0.30926191806793213,
-0.01214316114783287,
-0.20657013356685638,
-0.01706007495522499,
-0.3459257483482361,
0.1332455277442932,
-0.2670498490333557,
0.09976372122764587,
-0.27230364084243774,
0.41345638036727905,
0.05868237465620041,
0.4553622603416443,
0.280566543340683,
0.5169097185134888,
0.5614392757415771,
-0.5254929065704346,
0.2773657441139221,
0.18872612714767456,
-0.46576327085494995,
0.4958697557449341,
-0.6157826781272888,
0.09994964301586151,
-0.11146590113639832,
0.28893229365348816,
-0.8965088129043579,
-0.04567103460431099,
-0.06863883137702942,
-0.10856106132268906,
-0.15586648881435394,
0.24101829528808594,
-0.644892692565918,
-0.5617589354515076,
-0.269607275724411,
0.3038410246372223,
0.538208544254303,
-0.35241949558258057,
0.4892381727695465,
0.1881023645401001,
-0.12350686639547348,
-0.20227083563804626,
-0.7369856238365173,
-0.1709529012441635,
-0.4182624816894531,
-0.8587453961372375,
0.20615394413471222,
-0.09652744233608246,
-0.4354231059551239,
-0.1388237625360489,
-0.33447352051734924,
0.016331730410456657,
0.11956127732992172,
-0.3948975205421448,
0.39017701148986816,
-0.40474966168403625,
0.14207887649536133,
0.22448258101940155,
-0.25168469548225403,
0.21700963377952576,
-0.6916131377220154,
0.7674916386604309,
-0.4444008767604828,
-0.27442502975463867,
-0.5569061636924744,
0.4209269881248474,
0.5357469320297241,
-0.32106345891952515,
0.6838899850845337,
0.3197367787361145,
-0.5319498181343079,
-0.3463805913925171,
-0.5969013571739197,
-0.8128750324249268,
-0.4302472472190857,
0.25557050108909607,
-0.5726847648620605,
-0.8649230003356934,
0.5647953748703003,
-0.2899402678012848,
-0.05004854500293732,
0.3499615490436554,
0.5377353429794312,
0.029565664008259773,
1.006011724472046,
0.4966925382614136,
0.5229184031486511,
0.34939470887184143,
-0.41732680797576904,
0.5501325726509094,
-0.6457547545433044,
-0.08175087720155716,
-0.11111440509557724,
-0.036040954291820526,
-0.3396322429180145,
-0.3676597774028778,
-0.1350482851266861,
0.6110033988952637,
-0.18110613524913788,
0.3764767646789551,
-0.6886219382286072,
0.5933049321174622,
0.4862615168094635,
0.23039057850837708,
0.19090840220451355,
0.04642753303050995,
-0.24447676539421082,
-0.08046054095029831,
-0.8014795780181885,
-0.6914262771606445,
0.8853162527084351,
0.12374494224786758,
0.6967430710792542,
-0.03450743481516838,
0.7366386651992798,
-0.32658442854881287,
0.06394632905721664,
-0.9806681871414185,
0.8391817808151245,
0.16257460415363312,
-0.29885727167129517,
-0.45325157046318054,
-0.4954453110694885,
-0.5060381889343262,
0.5259525775909424,
-0.1934499442577362,
-0.8145045638084412,
-0.19404007494449615,
0.09551423043012619,
-0.6789865493774414,
0.37562477588653564,
-0.828802227973938,
0.9293754696846008,
-0.036298781633377075,
-0.5421603918075562,
-0.23589801788330078,
-0.7022829651832581,
0.3805522620677948,
0.040803562849760056,
-0.1961458921432495,
0.12799932062625885,
0.12091425806283951,
0.9833788275718689,
-0.9803641438484192,
0.578177273273468,
-0.08836077898740768,
-0.05564666911959648,
0.7892376184463501,
0.2733137905597687,
0.5684515833854675,
-0.14415821433067322,
0.0873015746474266,
-0.32805514335632324,
0.2517586946487427,
-0.5476216673851013,
-0.7887705564498901,
0.6165761351585388,
-0.413728266954422,
-0.9453527927398682,
-0.3760428726673126,
-0.6965818405151367,
-0.4134211242198944,
0.5050165057182312,
0.408834308385849,
0.46971023082733154,
0.1269695907831192,
0.019592059776186943,
0.9522479772567749,
0.09314171969890594,
0.22622986137866974,
0.11845163255929947,
-0.1649371087551117,
-0.4329409897327423,
0.5872058868408203,
0.4939473271369934,
0.708360493183136,
0.06285009533166885,
0.5930324792861938,
-0.4801369905471802,
-0.4459933340549469,
-0.23301203548908234,
0.25091657042503357,
-0.7008617520332336,
-0.06694430112838745,
-0.6415790915489197,
-0.2265370935201645,
-0.48180440068244934,
-0.44720619916915894,
-0.4803897440433502,
-0.43805593252182007,
0.18677890300750732,
-0.25443941354751587,
0.43497365713119507,
0.33500754833221436,
0.19159634411334991,
0.22815603017807007,
-0.40970101952552795,
0.14752404391765594,
0.45900043845176697,
0.24883471429347992,
0.21525545418262482,
-0.2903861105442047,
0.2157127559185028,
0.20509791374206543,
-0.4028322696685791,
-0.7488006949424744,
0.10034552961587906,
-0.20024214684963226,
0.47215232253074646,
0.4925746023654938,
0.35805895924568176,
0.861388623714447,
-0.5563801527023315,
0.6462070941925049,
0.3565552830696106,
-0.9249106049537659,
0.9603894948959351,
-0.39102548360824585,
0.5355249643325806,
0.7047468423843384,
0.2967212498188019,
-0.1139635443687439,
-0.5751116275787354,
-0.773705244064331,
-0.7639342546463013,
0.48489052057266235,
0.2665467858314514,
-0.027312150225043297,
-0.3706319332122803,
0.4013766646385193,
-0.006571681704372168,
0.15714482963085175,
-0.6410205364227295,
0.21652951836585999,
-0.30798816680908203,
-0.05355973541736603,
0.16802451014518738,
-0.29358258843421936,
0.04158131033182144,
-0.48809894919395447,
0.6816845536231995,
-0.2249925285577774,
-0.007709180470556021,
0.49953675270080566,
0.0007142132963053882,
-0.08658256381750107,
0.2045174241065979,
0.5565200448036194,
0.930203378200531,
-0.20438659191131592,
0.5205619931221008,
0.35960978269577026,
-0.3402819037437439,
-0.12968657910823822,
-0.1723046451807022,
-0.1859031319618225,
-0.21561793982982635,
0.35251113772392273,
0.5467684268951416,
0.01281119417399168,
-0.7439302802085876,
0.5093904137611389,
0.029917452484369278,
-0.4565473794937134,
-0.25855547189712524,
0.020680181682109833,
-0.04524964466691017,
0.20856811106204987,
-0.05865820124745369,
0.38165268301963806,
0.10253529250621796,
-0.5396621227264404,
0.47257891297340393,
0.25590941309928894,
-0.34414124488830566,
-0.17639994621276855,
0.5095822811126709,
-0.2708416283130646,
-0.07470917701721191,
0.45271173119544983,
-0.23365995287895203,
-0.7056010365486145,
0.3358059227466583,
0.8347943425178528,
0.7667880654335022,
-0.32104483246803284,
0.16398684680461884,
0.35594356060028076,
0.27413326501846313,
-0.577846348285675,
0.499584436416626,
-0.23020265996456146,
-0.7353537082672119,
-0.7720497250556946,
-0.5611136555671692,
0.04732103273272514,
0.09315378963947296,
-0.6886848211288452,
0.29112082719802856,
-0.7140716314315796,
-0.12914782762527466,
-0.20969101786613464,
0.20043297111988068,
-0.3563186526298523,
0.1218641996383667,
-0.030474375933408737,
0.9819188714027405,
-0.7538958191871643,
0.9852803945541382,
0.42909061908721924,
-0.47177326679229736,
-1.0114843845367432,
0.15263712406158447,
-0.16379506886005402,
-0.33936789631843567,
0.3389890789985657,
0.3242450952529907,
-0.5277659296989441,
-0.06671123951673508,
-0.3365548551082611,
-0.842704713344574,
0.9585539102554321,
0.2586977779865265,
-0.5038270354270935,
-0.030685465782880783,
-0.09486157447099686,
0.6004571318626404,
-0.34734293818473816,
-0.08611077070236206,
0.6731128096580505,
0.1374679058790207,
0.5695518255233765,
-0.6841107606887817,
0.3649252653121948,
-0.05074377357959747,
0.04265137389302254,
0.20761780440807343,
-0.2664642333984375,
0.8587777018547058,
-0.36507487297058105,
-0.2088676542043686,
0.13240809738636017,
0.711344301700592,
0.45076945424079895,
0.08763767778873444,
0.7434452772140503,
0.7671566009521484,
1.040427327156067,
0.0512995608150959,
1.0297592878341675,
0.007106474135071039,
0.19431811571121216,
1.1965148448944092,
-0.3138042390346527,
1.0567363500595093,
0.8417258858680725,
0.11859696358442307,
0.31522804498672485,
0.5157022476196289,
0.27774691581726074,
0.9890220165252686,
0.604297399520874,
-0.11478091776371002,
-0.6338742971420288,
-0.06317675858736038,
-0.31899547576904297,
0.28261396288871765,
0.341244637966156,
-0.0006439920398406684,
-0.2666648030281067,
0.1683502495288849,
0.07716849446296692,
0.39350810647010803,
-0.44713810086250305,
0.7964963912963867,
0.26180747151374817,
-0.9906203746795654,
0.6951220035552979,
-0.3861810564994812,
0.4667346775531769,
-0.6237000226974487,
0.07484372705221176,
0.13776731491088867,
0.5357094407081604,
-0.03844084590673447,
-0.678950846195221,
0.6677758097648621,
-0.17798075079917908,
-0.22811610996723175,
-0.42757952213287354,
0.7961781620979309,
-0.48570144176483154,
-0.6551417112350464,
0.34771379828453064,
0.5867009162902832,
0.09116030484437943,
-0.13011610507965088,
-0.5562872886657715,
-0.10351870208978653,
-0.14521364867687225,
-0.24118465185165405,
0.14758992195129395,
0.932237446308136,
-0.15601572394371033,
0.5259214639663696,
0.5357538461685181,
0.021857459098100662,
0.018228821456432343,
0.07168850302696228,
1.0438846349716187,
-0.37009197473526,
-0.7231013178825378,
-0.9754518270492554,
0.33784204721450806,
-0.19396430253982544,
-0.32594552636146545,
0.8217543363571167,
0.390430748462677,
1.0787699222564697,
0.005256047006696463,
0.49580255150794983,
0.12871494889259338,
0.3040250241756439,
-0.6744750738143921,
0.5504442453384399,
-0.39748746156692505,
0.22608248889446259,
-0.6781824827194214,
-0.9285983443260193,
-0.31751731038093567,
1.0892075300216675,
-0.7825570106506348,
-0.26271000504493713,
1.1125411987304688,
0.7066399455070496,
0.008217726834118366,
0.33067184686660767,
0.2340555042028427,
0.11860985308885574,
0.16264371573925018,
0.8045057058334351,
1.0015294551849365,
-0.2777528762817383,
0.4113052189350128,
-0.4402313828468323,
-0.43368831276893616,
0.1992376446723938,
-0.6180708408355713,
-1.062860369682312,
-0.48466894030570984,
-0.24231038987636566,
-0.5641354322433472,
-0.24191972613334656,
0.9668911695480347,
0.5488901734352112,
-0.7355034947395325,
-0.14001183211803436,
-0.543915331363678,
-0.04318816214799881,
-0.382063627243042,
-0.23729729652404785,
0.5203565359115601,
-0.5064861178398132,
-0.10853318125009537,
-0.025756988674402237,
0.14185397326946259,
-0.12698030471801758,
-0.19565242528915405,
-0.008609428070485592,
-0.4114731550216675,
0.39253705739974976,
0.9143373370170593,
-0.2335953712463379,
-0.9694110751152039,
-0.5082279443740845,
0.16824617981910706,
0.015208073891699314,
-0.30169788002967834,
0.9484701752662659,
-0.7216914892196655,
0.30693715810775757,
0.5217368602752686,
0.7462316155433655,
0.26851215958595276,
-0.14156852662563324,
0.5193485021591187,
-0.1683199107646942,
0.2955305278301239,
0.4209403693675995,
0.4898858964443207,
0.05129942670464516,
-0.2560462951660156,
0.26475197076797485,
0.3563970923423767,
-0.3104162812232971,
-0.6963204145431519,
0.3932195007801056,
-1.040580153465271,
-0.6163864731788635,
0.9662054777145386,
-0.12520883977413177,
-0.32109177112579346,
-0.043437693268060684,
-0.4278673231601715,
0.19529172778129578,
-0.0958688035607338,
0.9641542434692383,
0.8841978907585144,
-0.031101631000638008,
-0.01425083726644516,
-0.4441321790218353,
0.5682514905929565,
0.6344393491744995,
-0.7376958131790161,
0.20570974051952362,
0.3359130024909973,
0.04934133589267731,
0.2752283215522766,
0.7736523151397705,
-0.21376542747020721,
0.18470171093940735,
0.16983768343925476,
-0.4366011917591095,
0.18518002331256866,
-0.5249224305152893,
0.2646787166595459,
0.1998049020767212,
-0.08227590471506119,
-0.030170900747179985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14419v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14419v1
|
Enhancing Fault Detection for Large Language Models via Mutation-Based Confidence Smoothing
| 2024-04-14T07:06:12 | 2024-04-14T07:06:12 |
Qiang Hu, Jin Wen, Maxime Cordy, Yuheng Huang, Xiaofei Xie, Lei Ma
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) achieved great success in multiple application
domains and attracted huge attention from different research communities
recently. Unfortunately, even for the best LLM, there still exist many faults
that LLM cannot correctly predict. Such faults will harm the usability of LLMs.
How to quickly reveal them in LLMs is important, but challenging. The reasons
are twofold, 1) the heavy labeling effort for preparing the test data, and 2)
accessing closed-source LLMs such as GPT4 is money-required. To handle this
problem, in the traditional deep learning testing field, test selection methods
have been proposed for efficiently testing deep learning models by prioritizing
faults. However, the usefulness of these methods on LLMs is unclear and under
exploration. In this paper, we first study the effectiveness of existing fault
detection methods for LLMs. Experimental results on four different
tasks~(including both code tasks and natural language processing tasks) and
four LLMs (e.g., LLaMA and GPT4) demonstrated that existing fault detection
methods cannot perform well on LLMs (e.g., seven out of eight methods perform
worse than random selection on LLaMA). To enhance existing fault detection
methods, we propose MuCS, a prompt Mutation-based prediction Confidence
Smoothing method for LLMs. Concretely, we mutate the prompts and compute the
average prediction confidence of all mutants as the input of fault detection
methods. The results show that our proposed solution significantly enhances
existing methods with the improvement of test relative coverage by up to
97.64%.
|
[
-0.4761708974838257,
-0.6749131083488464,
0.767426073551178,
0.25572124123573303,
-0.18972885608673096,
0.21325042843818665,
-0.4811270534992218,
-0.2621094584465027,
0.07793945074081421,
0.39846929907798767,
-0.6066941618919373,
-0.6218612194061279,
-0.6126710176467896,
0.19469960033893585,
-0.06038641929626465,
0.7945069670677185,
-0.12221559137105942,
-0.10787101089954376,
-0.18565984070301056,
0.16488412022590637,
-0.3245069086551666,
-0.3804236352443695,
-0.8323656916618347,
-0.31010499596595764,
0.5689367651939392,
0.6296876072883606,
0.6786373853683472,
0.268756628036499,
0.372356653213501,
0.3699526786804199,
-0.3530557453632355,
0.5295594930648804,
-0.5242287516593933,
0.3991759717464447,
0.24293972551822662,
-0.5963122844696045,
-0.4718775451183319,
-0.4117020070552826,
0.5739350318908691,
0.632013738155365,
0.15691058337688446,
-0.21506956219673157,
0.36505910754203796,
0.4946231245994568,
-0.6459580659866333,
0.19814178347587585,
-0.7836493253707886,
0.05870290473103523,
-0.2933498024940491,
-0.21203118562698364,
-0.40827977657318115,
-0.5044198036193848,
-0.3542276620864868,
-0.5062617063522339,
0.21522404253482819,
-0.1385369449853897,
0.6568690538406372,
0.38475582003593445,
-0.32780250906944275,
-0.053135257214307785,
-0.5547410249710083,
0.921234130859375,
-1.0029983520507812,
0.37913042306900024,
0.3942479193210602,
0.22195802628993988,
-0.8736345171928406,
-0.520854115486145,
-0.6439372301101685,
-0.38605958223342896,
0.12752841413021088,
-0.23216907680034637,
0.05121341347694397,
0.14563152194023132,
0.42113035917282104,
0.5924772620201111,
-0.7069494724273682,
0.49585404992103577,
0.09686391800642014,
-0.5448691248893738,
0.5242782235145569,
0.07264530658721924,
-0.12993185222148895,
0.13259576261043549,
-0.12790049612522125,
-0.3179161846637726,
-0.8759309649467468,
0.048758216202259064,
0.3963119387626648,
0.25746434926986694,
0.18014776706695557,
0.2268194705247879,
-0.3146112859249115,
0.7261168956756592,
-0.17954716086387634,
-0.3245091736316681,
0.5899308323860168,
-0.19312827289104462,
-0.3003740608692169,
-0.3396108150482178,
0.7541028261184692,
0.08037234842777252,
0.39352139830589294,
0.07182913273572922,
-0.25094476342201233,
0.03884147107601166,
-0.14975464344024658,
-0.8264737725257874,
-0.14572441577911377,
0.31617850065231323,
-0.090925432741642,
-0.30593687295913696,
-0.08771657943725586,
-0.9536197185516357,
-0.6881927251815796,
0.005388401914387941,
0.06897645443677902,
-0.44011056423187256,
-0.19529569149017334,
0.3175841271877289,
0.32110369205474854,
-0.0810052752494812,
0.24714551866054535,
-0.7308234572410583,
-0.1807686984539032,
0.5787688493728638,
0.6341080665588379,
-0.2805081009864807,
-0.3232989013195038,
-0.6620670557022095,
-0.20540839433670044,
-0.36207205057144165,
0.7790818214416504,
-0.45343858003616333,
-0.360609769821167,
0.05309544876217842,
0.04820794239640236,
-0.0342673659324646,
-0.4572817087173462,
0.8345414996147156,
-0.3060222268104553,
-0.10196051001548767,
-0.25928425788879395,
-0.4632643759250641,
-0.03662661463022232,
0.43580928444862366,
-0.5885611772537231,
1.2108888626098633,
0.034075066447257996,
-0.6740509867668152,
0.1412883996963501,
-0.32903435826301575,
-0.6559406518936157,
-0.23820427060127258,
-0.08138196915388107,
-0.8193612098693848,
-0.11942850053310394,
0.49241623282432556,
0.6613938808441162,
-0.2054424285888672,
0.3953157067298889,
-0.6903331279754639,
-0.614027202129364,
0.35435137152671814,
-0.5236985087394714,
0.43242335319519043,
0.18658165633678436,
-0.6671364903450012,
0.18173930048942566,
-0.5942116975784302,
0.23561707139015198,
0.03132499009370804,
-0.4047022759914398,
-0.19354087114334106,
0.06550151854753494,
-0.3477013111114502,
0.1925850659608841,
-0.15314531326293945,
-0.4279096722602844,
0.3980858325958252,
-0.5117791295051575,
0.12612850964069366,
1.0238407850265503,
-0.0823952779173851,
0.1870412677526474,
-0.14757803082466125,
0.6564974188804626,
0.1878453940153122,
0.3352068066596985,
-0.3845102787017822,
-0.8145675659179688,
-1.0901482105255127,
-0.2661269009113312,
0.2939755916595459,
0.41291624307632446,
-0.79816734790802,
0.659980297088623,
-0.20622371137142181,
-0.3797544240951538,
-0.40890488028526306,
0.233478844165802,
0.3935224413871765,
0.3230034410953522,
0.43251582980155945,
-0.16459420323371887,
-0.31310582160949707,
-0.7343047261238098,
-0.3239196836948395,
-0.1374945342540741,
-0.07450159639120102,
0.15593087673187256,
0.2767512798309326,
-0.4026826322078705,
0.6276484131813049,
-0.7137515544891357,
-0.13652901351451874,
-0.14650651812553406,
0.04230956360697746,
0.32349950075149536,
0.36141055822372437,
0.35244253277778625,
-0.7223703265190125,
-0.2753523290157318,
-0.10625297576189041,
-0.34369349479675293,
-0.11840889602899551,
-0.07888009399175644,
0.05564393848180771,
0.28476792573928833,
0.5150326490402222,
-0.4550120532512665,
0.47080135345458984,
0.7754986882209778,
-0.216345876455307,
0.5182912945747375,
-0.00298434984870255,
0.3477533757686615,
-0.9143131971359253,
-0.18940326571464539,
-0.054373882710933685,
-0.35929006338119507,
-0.4627571105957031,
0.0011385310208424926,
0.22326569259166718,
0.1315949261188507,
-0.27000004053115845,
0.4840739071369171,
-0.4878230690956116,
0.02478310652077198,
-0.3822374939918518,
-0.15282149612903595,
0.021923314779996872,
0.5151576995849609,
-0.46919649839401245,
0.6259000301361084,
0.6869396567344666,
-0.6628567576408386,
0.17733247578144073,
-0.0788126289844513,
-0.1971486210823059,
0.11679933220148087,
-0.3149735927581787,
0.3173385262489319,
0.19642408192157745,
0.29563844203948975,
-1.06985604763031,
-0.054429832845926285,
0.3029792308807373,
-0.371931791305542,
0.629891037940979,
-0.19035905599594116,
-0.5321343541145325,
-0.5662121772766113,
-0.509227454662323,
0.26473280787467957,
0.4391133487224579,
-0.6201115846633911,
0.5010453462600708,
0.08140257745981216,
-0.3045315444469452,
-0.6160948872566223,
-0.7166544198989868,
0.04298337176442146,
-0.20422878861427307,
-0.8068360686302185,
0.275969922542572,
-0.4124146103858948,
0.04501073807477951,
-0.33523058891296387,
-0.12297610938549042,
0.07358908653259277,
0.4087279736995697,
0.4352934658527374,
0.13846132159233093,
-0.3285093605518341,
0.3152681291103363,
0.20756348967552185,
-0.29069846868515015,
-0.3024580180644989,
-0.26248985528945923,
0.4812263250350952,
-0.21839621663093567,
-0.6513543725013733,
-0.049827855080366135,
0.2050054669380188,
0.5588053464889526,
-0.37037110328674316,
0.4850118160247803,
0.4705936908721924,
-0.23307564854621887,
-0.42704737186431885,
-0.7849358916282654,
-0.3842024505138397,
-0.528537392616272,
0.4184495806694031,
-0.26957055926322937,
-1.255658507347107,
0.45886343717575073,
-0.43978187441825867,
-0.13779094815254211,
0.25410938262939453,
0.6718806624412537,
0.15008953213691711,
0.8435604572296143,
0.7055514454841614,
-0.4706110656261444,
0.25923752784729004,
-0.04612816125154495,
0.37819531559944153,
-0.5405974388122559,
-0.03829435631632805,
-0.7469962239265442,
-0.3046441674232483,
-0.45987361669540405,
-0.6988731622695923,
0.4111018478870392,
-0.030662843957543373,
-0.056195735931396484,
-0.02170402742922306,
-0.30841994285583496,
0.5467950105667114,
0.3680991232395172,
0.05386033654212952,
0.5033026933670044,
0.08208126574754715,
-0.3739343285560608,
-0.18836824595928192,
-0.36333000659942627,
-0.17219802737236023,
1.0419152975082397,
0.4701933264732361,
0.872721254825592,
-0.1614583283662796,
0.5342004895210266,
-0.02325473539531231,
0.2363443672657013,
-0.6185410022735596,
0.4816754162311554,
-0.07885661721229553,
-0.2227637618780136,
-0.3715798556804657,
-0.676555335521698,
-0.8245763182640076,
0.17789030075073242,
-0.12607426941394806,
-0.4188486635684967,
0.23593981564044952,
0.3472380042076111,
-0.3373582363128662,
0.5388073921203613,
-0.6822584867477417,
0.722551703453064,
-0.2670641541481018,
-0.13179746270179749,
-0.05693066865205765,
-0.4210905432701111,
0.5239187479019165,
-0.333639919757843,
0.30339568853378296,
-0.17684581875801086,
0.23057317733764648,
0.372906893491745,
-0.30814048647880554,
0.7925264239311218,
-0.11779356002807617,
-0.21224871277809143,
-0.09179987013339996,
0.14397838711738586,
0.8410249352455139,
0.08887184411287308,
-0.31761518120765686,
0.1616891771554947,
-0.6026178598403931,
-0.2979965806007385,
-0.5691123008728027,
0.9894351959228516,
-0.25732818245887756,
-0.4875534474849701,
-0.48842674493789673,
-0.6170659065246582,
-0.6019520163536072,
0.22990217804908752,
0.21583721041679382,
0.10945095121860504,
0.18496453762054443,
-0.03431074321269989,
0.9254437685012817,
-0.4865918457508087,
0.4589986205101013,
0.4979379177093506,
-0.26316237449645996,
-0.04495041072368622,
0.7349808812141418,
-0.21344240009784698,
0.33476805686950684,
0.047767531126737595,
0.22606880962848663,
-0.015449033118784428,
-1.024036169052124,
-0.1947624534368515,
0.14286020398139954,
-0.6597662568092346,
-0.5444682240486145,
-0.5630627870559692,
-0.09624572098255157,
-0.46108031272888184,
0.011478702537715435,
-0.49645259976387024,
-0.2603262662887573,
-0.1666065901517868,
-0.20510144531726837,
0.5078153014183044,
0.4320797622203827,
0.057129520922899246,
0.13929836452007294,
-0.4509885013103485,
0.31634029746055603,
0.20327065885066986,
0.5427622199058533,
-0.12056196480989456,
-0.5034802556037903,
-0.06867915391921997,
0.023027116432785988,
-0.4328375458717346,
-0.6793705821037292,
0.27173560857772827,
0.20117881894111633,
0.4884026050567627,
0.2735261023044586,
0.16276714205741882,
0.7156565189361572,
-0.33856794238090515,
0.568470299243927,
-0.013046162202954292,
-0.68986576795578,
0.4473657011985779,
-0.12621290981769562,
0.14138202369213104,
0.5204242467880249,
0.31152158975601196,
-0.43227195739746094,
-0.7491784691810608,
-0.43788763880729675,
-0.988633394241333,
0.36396709084510803,
0.1704849898815155,
0.05317818000912666,
0.110330730676651,
0.40163353085517883,
0.1585492193698883,
-0.014708193019032478,
-0.5942091941833496,
-0.48742926120758057,
0.03676405921578407,
-0.04733904078602791,
-0.36376821994781494,
-0.4031979739665985,
0.23801136016845703,
-0.20541156828403473,
0.798895001411438,
-0.4315592348575592,
0.17196246981620789,
0.2061186283826828,
0.019964179024100304,
-0.16345274448394775,
0.4000195860862732,
0.689145565032959,
0.38530662655830383,
-0.06627260148525238,
0.1988721638917923,
0.2483995109796524,
-0.5159416198730469,
0.13520200550556183,
0.21322111785411835,
-0.1987759917974472,
0.02783399447798729,
0.23478439450263977,
0.7564207911491394,
0.3394559323787689,
-0.5938615798950195,
0.4778037667274475,
-0.033580441027879715,
0.0478958860039711,
-0.11132156103849411,
0.1521642953157425,
0.2507738471031189,
0.25165507197380066,
0.31659838557243347,
0.14517509937286377,
0.09756463766098022,
-0.29509830474853516,
0.3686094284057617,
0.3894646167755127,
-0.3654087483882904,
-0.00530651630833745,
0.2377222180366516,
0.0914902538061142,
-0.058141253888607025,
0.533829927444458,
-0.4361092150211334,
-0.8286729454994202,
0.6102884411811829,
0.3904929459095001,
0.7299826741218567,
-0.5596187114715576,
0.04767303913831711,
0.20979954302310944,
0.5253050327301025,
-0.15605103969573975,
0.33385512232780457,
0.48829224705696106,
-0.7204456329345703,
-0.7354626655578613,
-0.5800259709358215,
-0.3710620105266571,
0.3640473186969757,
-0.13325908780097961,
0.3749902546405792,
-0.20244400203227997,
-0.105684794485569,
-0.29638421535491943,
-0.0393214076757431,
-0.43948474526405334,
0.15067797899246216,
0.3927449584007263,
0.9053219556808472,
-0.756597638130188,
0.9825023412704468,
0.2703116238117218,
0.016575248911976814,
-1.0332719087600708,
0.21511034667491913,
0.004608749412000179,
-0.7309350371360779,
0.2580098807811737,
0.30647537112236023,
0.0897437185049057,
-0.07893417775630951,
-0.37307631969451904,
-0.7314557433128357,
0.9842676520347595,
0.8738520741462708,
-0.7688140869140625,
0.21616588532924652,
0.07986324280500412,
0.26224157214164734,
-0.044964682310819626,
0.3292955756187439,
0.5899180769920349,
0.792939305305481,
0.23945777118206024,
-0.7889329195022583,
0.196494922041893,
-0.18257443606853485,
-0.12468919157981873,
0.42152005434036255,
-0.3687008023262024,
0.8780434727668762,
-0.39579272270202637,
0.13785094022750854,
0.06745190918445587,
0.6131696701049805,
0.5765687823295593,
0.35412657260894775,
0.7554022669792175,
0.5921571850776672,
1.1174039840698242,
-0.2697512209415436,
1.3655354976654053,
0.15647827088832855,
0.5093580484390259,
0.9498481750488281,
-0.323509156703949,
0.6176129579544067,
0.4206857681274414,
-0.225540429353714,
0.4992297887802124,
0.7942000031471252,
-0.08531459420919418,
0.24350205063819885,
0.6337575316429138,
-0.14582355320453644,
-0.3984704315662384,
0.001211989438161254,
-0.5440211892127991,
-0.032175153493881226,
0.18176619708538055,
-0.28123441338539124,
-0.14946089684963226,
0.01886637508869171,
0.31545883417129517,
-0.17326657474040985,
-0.2238418012857437,
0.23967725038528442,
0.1955411285161972,
-0.6952152252197266,
0.6812852025032043,
0.08921637386083603,
0.9656588435173035,
-0.7584988474845886,
-0.08118242025375366,
-0.6032406687736511,
0.4385892450809479,
-0.29571375250816345,
-0.6558359861373901,
0.05141204968094826,
-0.11446122080087662,
-0.024817749857902527,
0.003611744847148657,
1.0228161811828613,
-0.3351144790649414,
-0.5897815823554993,
0.5444872975349426,
0.10895945131778717,
0.09492894262075424,
-0.6341072916984558,
-0.5495890378952026,
0.26951074600219727,
0.12032400071620941,
-0.4859141409397125,
0.44573578238487244,
0.3293077349662781,
-0.09765224158763885,
0.8341491222381592,
0.8874630928039551,
0.21478044986724854,
0.33397388458251953,
0.07554437220096588,
1.1537870168685913,
-0.5191434025764465,
-0.35379987955093384,
-0.8772146105766296,
0.6152305603027344,
-0.047589261084795,
-0.27347391843795776,
0.6577010154724121,
0.36900293827056885,
0.6603671312332153,
-0.09125577658414841,
0.71515953540802,
0.2615971267223358,
0.4265921413898468,
-0.734782874584198,
0.6164402961730957,
-0.41688981652259827,
0.3919563293457031,
-0.3866357207298279,
-0.9009226560592651,
-0.5840991735458374,
0.3300369679927826,
-0.12861333787441254,
0.26630544662475586,
0.9459559917449951,
1.1256312131881714,
-0.027281150221824646,
-0.09056166559457779,
0.4329787790775299,
0.5441370010375977,
0.39404940605163574,
0.8733197450637817,
0.7835226655006409,
-0.3535252809524536,
0.6219866871833801,
-0.36981692910194397,
-0.4010724425315857,
-0.3531356453895569,
-1.1177849769592285,
-0.9540516138076782,
-0.31726494431495667,
-0.351803719997406,
-0.41693001985549927,
0.0336599163711071,
0.5072239637374878,
0.6829226613044739,
-1.0248725414276123,
0.17711178958415985,
-0.0022958063054829836,
0.4176819324493408,
-0.15938954055309296,
-0.15109018981456757,
0.3324168920516968,
-0.4217420220375061,
-0.5595216751098633,
0.806026816368103,
0.3017736077308655,
-0.03124908357858658,
-0.23465029895305634,
-0.36945414543151855,
-0.003708373988047242,
-0.29722875356674194,
0.28182655572891235,
0.2686057984828949,
-0.6205465197563171,
-0.21453051269054413,
0.19146642088890076,
-0.0563906654715538,
-0.0065421899780631065,
0.9225647449493408,
-0.7541021108627319,
0.30227452516555786,
0.3616609275341034,
0.8966948986053467,
0.42960575222969055,
-0.43199312686920166,
0.5891913771629333,
-0.6613755822181702,
0.24931581318378448,
0.34984609484672546,
0.550454318523407,
0.4884045422077179,
-0.6862515211105347,
0.5301566123962402,
0.30606624484062195,
-0.6632118821144104,
-0.9141046404838562,
0.3505585789680481,
-0.956465482711792,
-0.16595980525016785,
1.3356181383132935,
-0.359955370426178,
-0.016786281019449234,
-0.22610528767108917,
-0.035212162882089615,
0.15866215527057648,
-0.26945653557777405,
0.632479190826416,
0.4680649936199188,
0.193017840385437,
-0.024654172360897064,
-0.5038976073265076,
0.559284508228302,
0.721947968006134,
-0.8697428107261658,
0.04195689037442207,
0.2083166390657425,
0.29360637068748474,
0.03835879638791084,
0.4693908095359802,
-0.17626282572746277,
0.18960817158222198,
-0.5477258563041687,
0.3157255947589874,
-0.2825113832950592,
-0.2541167438030243,
-0.5495662093162537,
-0.020515689626336098,
0.2674204409122467,
0.037508778274059296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09163v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09163v1
|
GeMQuAD : Generating Multilingual Question Answering Datasets from Large Language Models using Few Shot Learning
| 2024-04-14T06:55:42 | 2024-04-14T06:55:42 |
Amani Namboori, Shivam Mangale, Andy Rosenbaum, Saleh Soltan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) with capabilities like
In-Context Learning (ICL) has ushered in new possibilities for data generation
across various domains while minimizing the need for extensive data collection
and modeling techniques. Researchers have explored ways to use this generated
synthetic data to optimize smaller student models for reduced deployment costs
and lower latency in downstream tasks. However, ICL-generated data often
suffers from low quality as the task specificity is limited with few examples
used in ICL. In this paper, we propose GeMQuAD - a semi-supervised learning
approach, extending the WeakDAP framework, applied to a dataset generated
through ICL with just one example in the target language using AlexaTM 20B
Seq2Seq LLM. Through our approach, we iteratively identify high-quality data to
enhance model performance, especially for low-resource multilingual setting in
the context of Extractive Question Answering task. Our framework outperforms
the machine translation-augmented model by 0.22/1.68 F1/EM (Exact Match) points
for Hindi and 0.82/1.37 F1/EM points for Spanish on the MLQA dataset, and it
surpasses the performance of model trained on an English-only dataset by
5.05/6.50 F1/EM points for Hindi and 3.81/3.69 points F1/EM for Spanish on the
same dataset. Notably, our approach uses a pre-trained LLM for generation with
no fine-tuning (FT), utilizing just a single annotated example in ICL to
generate data, providing a cost-effective development process.
|
[
-0.31320497393608093,
-1.1593316793441772,
0.38844993710517883,
-0.030748020857572556,
-0.1659930795431137,
0.28551656007766724,
-0.23010674118995667,
-0.2619229555130005,
-0.14349953830242157,
0.41204386949539185,
-0.5440331697463989,
-0.75102299451828,
-0.06544297933578491,
0.07748674601316452,
-0.4503186345100403,
1.2067078351974487,
0.12327291816473007,
0.19313883781433105,
-0.22502851486206055,
-0.09057099372148514,
-0.2991233468055725,
-0.29305899143218994,
-0.4532660245895386,
-0.1504608690738678,
0.15813204646110535,
1.0009604692459106,
0.5327683091163635,
0.16349205374717712,
0.25177448987960815,
0.16098174452781677,
-0.04273729771375656,
0.3682244122028351,
-0.6518797278404236,
-0.061287861317396164,
0.10470038652420044,
-0.40091145038604736,
-0.25137606263160706,
-0.19969125092029572,
0.7900380492210388,
0.8178828358650208,
-0.4578213095664978,
0.3841048777103424,
0.3225442171096802,
0.14894944429397583,
-0.44875767827033997,
0.020239751785993576,
-0.6865189671516418,
-0.10040616244077682,
-0.3177501857280731,
0.13319659233093262,
-0.3227049708366394,
-0.3252635896205902,
-0.008730089291930199,
-0.3821871280670166,
0.5387193560600281,
0.038625508546829224,
0.8537049293518066,
0.02105158567428589,
-0.21140910685062408,
-0.10719448328018188,
-0.6212823987007141,
0.8923194408416748,
-0.9575605392456055,
0.10718066990375519,
0.4053167700767517,
0.39913100004196167,
0.046682972460985184,
-0.4163057208061218,
-0.77122563123703,
0.17876531183719635,
0.027582330629229546,
0.09290141612291336,
0.01291640754789114,
-0.15604980289936066,
0.2638894021511078,
0.39946499466896057,
-0.909745454788208,
0.07902677357196808,
-0.48614442348480225,
-0.02974691428244114,
0.6877415180206299,
0.15954317152500153,
0.3152593672275543,
-0.38692253828048706,
-0.303914338350296,
0.01945255696773529,
-1.0064516067504883,
0.06563659757375717,
0.2509080767631531,
0.7963862419128418,
-0.4462469518184662,
0.6526370048522949,
-0.34444659948349,
0.5927324295043945,
-0.07299156486988068,
-0.32749664783477783,
0.1654065102338791,
-0.22059038281440735,
-0.18739376962184906,
0.11567538976669312,
0.7776001691818237,
-0.16844959557056427,
0.1620488166809082,
-0.1815757155418396,
-0.09035837650299072,
-0.1640443652868271,
-0.22011269629001617,
-0.7195557951927185,
-0.2940637171268463,
0.2138754427433014,
-0.03632469102740288,
-0.1612796187400818,
-0.34301459789276123,
-0.8551832437515259,
-0.16624779999256134,
-0.14144499599933624,
0.37288349866867065,
-0.4573931396007538,
-0.01393377035856247,
-0.10554788261651993,
0.41702914237976074,
0.5277299880981445,
0.18248845636844635,
-0.8012372255325317,
0.22232581675052643,
0.2847745418548584,
0.7099570631980896,
-0.266908198595047,
-0.45955243706703186,
-0.7774963974952698,
0.14776669442653656,
-0.5091835260391235,
0.7674058079719543,
-0.3673979640007019,
-0.4846566319465637,
-0.03683001920580864,
-0.20400917530059814,
0.0642024502158165,
-0.5366160273551941,
0.4290117919445038,
-0.5066015720367432,
0.2557668685913086,
-0.06886376440525055,
-0.39185166358947754,
-0.010617956519126892,
0.4172278046607971,
-0.3723722994327545,
1.2966748476028442,
0.2417568862438202,
-0.6409127712249756,
0.29043376445770264,
-0.32309889793395996,
-0.6276710629463196,
0.3751665949821472,
-0.23376056551933289,
-0.44489383697509766,
-0.04973653331398964,
0.6119429469108582,
0.6978701949119568,
-0.7332368493080139,
0.4459250271320343,
-0.29627081751823425,
-0.2006245106458664,
-0.03403625264763832,
-0.2898835837841034,
0.6879274845123291,
0.18932920694351196,
-0.06511562317609787,
-0.09160014986991882,
-0.7236521244049072,
0.338320791721344,
0.14842236042022705,
-0.4017007052898407,
-0.12373536825180054,
-0.18152934312820435,
0.19676034152507782,
0.41025304794311523,
-0.1549583524465561,
-0.663554310798645,
0.015026510693132877,
-0.6635457277297974,
0.15977390110492706,
0.6895139217376709,
0.21873383224010468,
0.33433592319488525,
-0.0395003966987133,
0.7954793572425842,
-0.02277476154267788,
0.06686761975288391,
0.04076862707734108,
-0.3311628997325897,
-0.8357513546943665,
-0.32583561539649963,
0.3535991907119751,
0.5652664303779602,
-1.3196016550064087,
-0.15945376455783844,
-0.44556957483291626,
-0.4146856665611267,
-0.8410624265670776,
0.757076621055603,
0.5315378308296204,
0.7118690013885498,
0.4724900424480438,
0.03822370618581772,
-0.11805298179388046,
-0.981295645236969,
0.0026602232828736305,
-0.17425121366977692,
0.07970559597015381,
0.22886037826538086,
0.4850877523422241,
0.1573423445224762,
1.059761643409729,
-0.5721139907836914,
-0.2682825028896332,
-0.7729431390762329,
0.22321228682994843,
0.43924465775489807,
0.4079744517803192,
0.2851404547691345,
-0.7728825211524963,
-0.7620794773101807,
-0.11435931921005249,
-0.8239213228225708,
0.011847537942230701,
-0.03663812205195427,
-0.22137820720672607,
0.01424474734812975,
0.1958015114068985,
-0.47417229413986206,
0.13366544246673584,
0.519986093044281,
0.031165726482868195,
0.33941560983657837,
-0.0623951181769371,
0.02929873578250408,
-1.4896576404571533,
-0.03345712646842003,
0.182199627161026,
-0.17874380946159363,
-0.6914381980895996,
0.21670618653297424,
0.13823239505290985,
-0.6041110754013062,
-0.8081521987915039,
0.7382980585098267,
-0.44817879796028137,
0.1049647405743599,
0.0293310284614563,
0.10973580181598663,
-0.17996138334274292,
0.5899322032928467,
0.2569581866264343,
0.9579644203186035,
0.7343428134918213,
-0.5126045942306519,
0.31543785333633423,
0.4517057538032532,
-0.4822804629802704,
0.5972142219543457,
-0.8246504664421082,
0.14674434065818787,
-0.16942213475704193,
-0.24440746009349823,
-0.8340172171592712,
-0.4073861241340637,
-0.1990889608860016,
-0.35361048579216003,
0.4917002320289612,
-0.4051608145236969,
-0.740482747554779,
-0.23762300610542297,
-0.13512198626995087,
0.4289419651031494,
0.4846016466617584,
-0.7042703628540039,
0.41796159744262695,
0.4223988354206085,
-0.4656136631965637,
-0.44568508863449097,
-0.8462285399436951,
0.06979838758707047,
-0.28193551301956177,
-0.5802114009857178,
-0.18870486319065094,
-0.07724759727716446,
-0.10021483153104782,
-0.3227367103099823,
0.1557166874408722,
-0.143777996301651,
0.022416966035962105,
-0.12020504474639893,
0.37690451741218567,
-0.29447126388549805,
0.27502837777137756,
0.15793143212795258,
-0.14046034216880798,
-0.2605676054954529,
0.071603924036026,
0.4214492738246918,
-0.0705743134021759,
-0.3644011616706848,
-0.16214323043823242,
0.6818087100982666,
0.19957025349140167,
-0.3541017770767212,
0.7012683153152466,
0.5114001035690308,
-0.3818212151527405,
-0.786469578742981,
-0.22704187035560608,
-0.1184198334813118,
-0.41934725642204285,
0.3339294493198395,
-0.5615436434745789,
-0.6524893045425415,
0.40269213914871216,
0.044659968465566635,
0.06576140969991684,
0.3513336181640625,
0.6571288108825684,
-0.1775626242160797,
1.2206171751022339,
0.7029765248298645,
-0.3132098913192749,
0.11065360903739929,
-0.4676769971847534,
0.3802465498447418,
-0.705739438533783,
-0.09958377480506897,
-0.49831458926200867,
0.02179195173084736,
-0.5353987812995911,
-0.45295244455337524,
0.7385808825492859,
0.22973796725273132,
-0.05694812163710594,
0.010777452029287815,
-0.19393645226955414,
0.6067615151405334,
0.5547115802764893,
0.1155838891863823,
0.25335121154785156,
0.03918447345495224,
-0.06598123908042908,
0.09942664951086044,
-1.0619810819625854,
-0.4882946312427521,
1.2469022274017334,
-0.06645652651786804,
1.2770709991455078,
0.41997095942497253,
0.6364744901657104,
0.1932363212108612,
0.17723549902439117,
-0.5560302734375,
0.5385557413101196,
0.05234752595424652,
-0.6770754456520081,
-0.1211094930768013,
-0.5520836114883423,
-0.6299541592597961,
0.07695745676755905,
-0.3801927864551544,
-0.6762232184410095,
0.11948085576295853,
0.13795045018196106,
-0.41898179054260254,
0.13364481925964355,
-0.9338772296905518,
0.8223641514778137,
-0.2806681990623474,
-0.7748661637306213,
0.0583500973880291,
-0.7179065942764282,
0.6110372543334961,
-0.2641816735267639,
0.16087675094604492,
-0.19202551245689392,
0.4159199893474579,
0.6522974371910095,
-0.3208712637424469,
0.8370326161384583,
-0.08317679166793823,
-0.06715559214353561,
0.3815896213054657,
0.08390048146247864,
0.6114988923072815,
0.521699845790863,
-0.10280916094779968,
-0.016363028436899185,
0.027928819879889488,
-0.7147137522697449,
-0.28430885076522827,
0.8129680156707764,
-0.7209138870239258,
-0.4377140402793884,
-0.4180375635623932,
-0.6606553792953491,
-0.6503077149391174,
0.09757744520902634,
0.2045474350452423,
0.6173912286758423,
-0.09622175246477127,
0.08309965580701828,
0.7391759157180786,
-0.2652030289173126,
0.44942614436149597,
0.5353589653968811,
0.02199903316795826,
-0.1390278935432434,
0.9583397507667542,
-0.0905454009771347,
0.4211757481098175,
0.2558628022670746,
0.02894010581076145,
-0.42469850182533264,
-0.5770561099052429,
-0.8120076060295105,
0.29283982515335083,
-0.8235529065132141,
-0.4105232059955597,
-0.3998577296733856,
-0.14858773350715637,
-0.3843027353286743,
-0.012995144352316856,
-0.3574506342411041,
-0.09296836704015732,
-0.22878384590148926,
-0.010215822607278824,
0.24523015320301056,
0.3520435392856598,
0.2519102990627289,
0.3619178831577301,
-0.7777858972549438,
0.5883013606071472,
0.5177323222160339,
0.007348678074777126,
-0.14407426118850708,
-0.4251236915588379,
-0.4805765748023987,
0.22879908978939056,
-0.19640929996967316,
-0.7854100465774536,
0.5647769570350647,
0.5659299492835999,
0.47787073254585266,
0.2515294551849365,
0.2692522704601288,
0.8432047963142395,
-0.34939032793045044,
0.8716957569122314,
-0.06838996708393097,
-0.8780003786087036,
0.7784100770950317,
-0.32552382349967957,
0.6200676560401917,
0.7010239362716675,
0.5369908213615417,
-0.4407092332839966,
-0.4194856286048889,
-0.613747775554657,
-0.7403680682182312,
0.881074070930481,
0.1550786942243576,
0.350462406873703,
-0.0034670501481741667,
0.22733740508556366,
0.2021401822566986,
0.1884779930114746,
-0.6376119256019592,
-0.15015216171741486,
0.25317898392677307,
-0.4009396433830261,
-0.4413091540336609,
-0.13251622021198273,
-0.08410155028104782,
-0.22363705933094025,
0.9377365112304688,
-0.5873467922210693,
-0.051913052797317505,
-0.012976698577404022,
-0.4749208092689514,
0.012186757288873196,
0.4362335503101349,
0.1150285080075264,
0.7984115481376648,
-0.0389915406703949,
0.14396847784519196,
0.4563390016555786,
-0.2878522574901581,
0.0006783836288377643,
0.14820756018161774,
-0.34060853719711304,
-0.11214373260736465,
0.4351949095726013,
0.6150866746902466,
-0.16396358609199524,
-0.967883288860321,
0.4584098756313324,
0.05340348184108734,
0.1586790531873703,
0.050292644649744034,
0.031727757304906845,
-0.09612450748682022,
0.2952004075050354,
0.4404751658439636,
-0.3865118622779846,
0.009512604214251041,
-0.6543804407119751,
0.09475508332252502,
0.4776417911052704,
-0.20401349663734436,
-0.4360424280166626,
0.6683823466300964,
0.033638861030340195,
0.16632524132728577,
0.9280309677124023,
-0.24662438035011292,
-0.3775270879268646,
0.2901081144809723,
0.6754230260848999,
0.5740864276885986,
-0.2347850799560547,
0.42882248759269714,
0.4326602816581726,
0.17463421821594238,
0.14295463263988495,
0.5476412773132324,
-0.16156314313411713,
-0.7398325204849243,
-0.43568122386932373,
-0.786381721496582,
-0.37999218702316284,
0.006871073506772518,
-0.6135934591293335,
0.5396907925605774,
-0.1869400292634964,
0.2196454554796219,
-0.0683160349726677,
0.13783812522888184,
-0.7231943011283875,
0.3053629398345947,
0.12979499995708466,
0.5201303362846375,
-1.296385407447815,
1.002793788909912,
0.7592449188232422,
-0.5044543743133545,
-0.8483337759971619,
-0.11976741254329681,
-0.07893917709589005,
-0.804582417011261,
0.23619075119495392,
-0.28051429986953735,
-0.010410084389150143,
0.34794890880584717,
-0.6115022897720337,
-0.6390962600708008,
0.8662506937980652,
0.5015445351600647,
-0.22766757011413574,
-0.0016289702616631985,
0.2780483365058899,
0.42886966466903687,
-0.1566021889448166,
0.1939673125743866,
0.41942763328552246,
0.025688480585813522,
0.33038032054901123,
-0.6476283073425293,
-0.12731365859508514,
-0.37188369035720825,
0.03596751019358635,
0.30014148354530334,
-0.5183780193328857,
0.7251175045967102,
-0.43079379200935364,
-0.34890028834342957,
0.054518990218639374,
0.44693922996520996,
0.28629690408706665,
0.03538336977362633,
0.03309297189116478,
0.5841568112373352,
0.7574895620346069,
-0.07177489250898361,
1.1355669498443604,
-0.0579308345913887,
0.5981812477111816,
1.146522045135498,
-0.3609452545642853,
0.9695969223976135,
0.5413536429405212,
-0.22292298078536987,
0.04676356539130211,
0.8928755521774292,
0.0789279118180275,
0.6542006134986877,
-0.1287688910961151,
-0.32033756375312805,
-0.5577524304389954,
-0.2509639859199524,
-0.14066912233829498,
0.5414466261863708,
0.18552379310131073,
-0.02342270128428936,
-0.6763080954551697,
0.2757169306278229,
-0.07508254051208496,
-0.037867896258831024,
-0.1603151112794876,
0.8771077394485474,
-0.04959407076239586,
-0.26870226860046387,
0.8325935006141663,
0.04910679906606674,
0.4230732023715973,
-0.7231744527816772,
-0.13906612992286682,
-0.5835372805595398,
0.04054927080869675,
-0.1741437017917633,
-0.7644415497779846,
-0.06416105479001999,
0.4150521755218506,
-0.1397782415151596,
-0.2085597813129425,
0.42961418628692627,
-0.6766308546066284,
-0.8700135350227356,
-0.1684153825044632,
0.9609947800636292,
0.2684067189693451,
0.14747971296310425,
-0.7349532246589661,
-0.3647354543209076,
-0.03429494798183441,
-0.1250578761100769,
0.30017638206481934,
0.2878163754940033,
-0.26308542490005493,
0.6734148859977722,
0.6910802125930786,
0.19823339581489563,
0.05834205448627472,
0.09879238158464432,
0.8908148407936096,
-0.3737584352493286,
-0.4292571544647217,
-0.6351611018180847,
0.510058581829071,
0.030388250946998596,
-0.4458587169647217,
0.9835860133171082,
0.920120894908905,
0.9072814583778381,
0.06998185068368912,
0.7068226933479309,
-0.15353627502918243,
0.7552546858787537,
-0.7366412878036499,
0.6518166661262512,
-0.6756289601325989,
0.4024774134159088,
-0.3611419200897217,
-0.9326038360595703,
-0.33287522196769714,
0.2947111129760742,
-0.3319242000579834,
0.045729976147413254,
0.5918601751327515,
1.0681614875793457,
-0.37267830967903137,
-0.16434694826602936,
0.3579445779323578,
0.169479638338089,
0.2264426201581955,
0.7817532420158386,
0.9153571724891663,
-0.4705834984779358,
0.46818917989730835,
-0.4466001093387604,
0.09311464428901672,
0.16763880848884583,
-0.4516650438308716,
-0.8672171831130981,
-0.6617509722709656,
-0.39640870690345764,
-0.1551562249660492,
-0.19672854244709015,
0.8272596597671509,
0.8325695395469666,
-0.9315382838249207,
-0.33435535430908203,
0.15065898001194,
0.2236500084400177,
0.04805891588330269,
-0.23180215060710907,
0.6942339539527893,
-0.36379802227020264,
-0.8841034770011902,
0.4456818699836731,
-0.010287018492817879,
-0.0073404982686042786,
-0.06734894961118698,
-0.07371263206005096,
-0.5875151753425598,
-0.21875809133052826,
0.5768789649009705,
0.3430784344673157,
-0.4182117283344269,
-0.08908569812774658,
-0.06891884654760361,
0.020303955301642418,
0.1331176906824112,
0.3583446443080902,
-0.8139830827713013,
0.6174694895744324,
0.36961811780929565,
0.6915111541748047,
0.7273916006088257,
0.15181010961532593,
0.3873273432254791,
-1.1880747079849243,
0.18251630663871765,
0.4582432210445404,
0.1095242127776146,
0.45222207903862,
-0.19037936627864838,
0.33018019795417786,
0.009301266632974148,
-0.22281412780284882,
-0.9320048093795776,
-0.052725762128829956,
-0.6741591095924377,
-0.19475647807121277,
1.2102679014205933,
-0.041596051305532455,
-0.28240638971328735,
-0.0896138995885849,
-0.09128867834806442,
0.09507663547992706,
-0.27708032727241516,
0.5927518606185913,
0.458996444940567,
-0.14887991547584534,
-0.48740190267562866,
-0.6993255019187927,
0.38122525811195374,
0.26994264125823975,
-1.1170450448989868,
-0.021198617294430733,
0.5447425246238708,
0.23131224513053894,
-0.1985434889793396,
0.3332656919956207,
0.07303114980459213,
0.28789231181144714,
-0.28650519251823425,
0.2424687147140503,
0.2571071684360504,
-0.36016812920570374,
-0.3549443483352661,
0.2842510938644409,
0.3000677525997162,
-0.0308961421251297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09155v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09155v1
|
Mitigating Heterogeneity among Factor Tensors via Lie Group Manifolds for Tensor Decomposition Based Temporal Knowledge Graph Embedding
| 2024-04-14T06:10:46 | 2024-04-14T06:10:46 |
Jiang Li, Xiangdong Su, Yeyun Gong, Guanglai Gao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent studies have highlighted the effectiveness of tensor decomposition
methods in the Temporal Knowledge Graphs Embedding (TKGE) task. However, we
found that inherent heterogeneity among factor tensors in tensor decomposition
significantly hinders the tensor fusion process and further limits the
performance of link prediction. To overcome this limitation, we introduce a
novel method that maps factor tensors onto a unified smooth Lie group manifold
to make the distribution of factor tensors approximating homogeneous in tensor
decomposition. We provide the theoretical proof of our motivation that
homogeneous tensors are more effective than heterogeneous tensors in tensor
fusion and approximating the target for tensor decomposition based TKGE
methods. The proposed method can be directly integrated into existing tensor
decomposition based TKGE methods without introducing extra parameters.
Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in mitigating
the heterogeneity and in enhancing the tensor decomposition based TKGE models.
|
[
-0.48550495505332947,
-0.6436874866485596,
0.5909068584442139,
0.22358140349388123,
-0.40476953983306885,
0.48860815167427063,
0.04275093600153923,
-0.12582336366176605,
0.41714343428611755,
0.11077985167503357,
-0.7761154174804688,
-0.7662736177444458,
-0.452762633562088,
-0.3579147458076477,
0.30703404545783997,
0.5051841139793396,
-0.1985965073108673,
0.2577810287475586,
-0.37048396468162537,
-0.5199099183082581,
-0.07446745783090591,
-0.19683629274368286,
-0.38861382007598877,
-0.764340341091156,
0.45336493849754333,
-0.1700328141450882,
0.5643976926803589,
0.8837020397186279,
0.35572952032089233,
0.24038179218769073,
0.04488508030772209,
0.11601381003856659,
-0.5924093723297119,
0.1996130645275116,
0.07729548960924149,
-0.438658207654953,
-0.444039523601532,
0.3178679049015045,
1.019140601158142,
1.1597929000854492,
-0.029626449570059776,
0.22982673346996307,
-0.006561309099197388,
0.41581693291664124,
-0.7007260322570801,
0.2811075448989868,
-0.13232004642486572,
0.5109723210334778,
-0.009816021658480167,
-0.6096456050872803,
-0.22983092069625854,
-0.456339955329895,
0.27937838435173035,
-0.7527766823768616,
0.4923144578933716,
0.4225589334964752,
0.37570419907569885,
0.42961615324020386,
-0.47712743282318115,
0.18294571340084076,
-0.8649544715881348,
0.7325491309165955,
-0.4471825063228607,
0.7084153294563293,
0.30385690927505493,
0.3147871196269989,
-0.13408459722995758,
-0.6146849393844604,
-0.2635982930660248,
-0.1830137073993683,
-0.15309299528598785,
-0.025234756991267204,
0.0014947598101571202,
0.11278265714645386,
0.09096065163612366,
0.15150220692157745,
-0.5060298442840576,
-0.002334017539396882,
-0.09991918504238129,
-0.4528752863407135,
0.20175954699516296,
0.34752681851387024,
0.2728289067745209,
-0.0008189391228370368,
-0.6955918073654175,
0.11459250003099442,
-0.7328619956970215,
-0.2675417959690094,
0.6601269841194153,
0.06379090249538422,
-0.11639022827148438,
0.6786175966262817,
-0.028453925624489784,
0.2640012502670288,
-0.024368472397327423,
-0.35930341482162476,
0.26195016503334045,
-0.22214877605438232,
-0.08434963971376419,
-0.06707967817783356,
0.48078152537345886,
0.4286096394062042,
-0.2914597988128662,
-0.7778744101524353,
0.025951027870178223,
0.32152557373046875,
-0.07294225692749023,
-0.7861576676368713,
-0.14350460469722748,
0.06994419544935226,
-0.671614408493042,
-0.34908440709114075,
-0.11722330749034882,
-0.8152856230735779,
-0.3307603895664215,
-0.06438303738832474,
0.39636796712875366,
-0.15476666390895844,
-0.46820634603500366,
-0.0695423036813736,
-0.38713499903678894,
0.07154463231563568,
0.10815173387527466,
-0.3776737153530121,
0.2271723747253418,
0.6933649778366089,
0.6779190897941589,
-0.00608314061537385,
-0.2482161521911621,
-0.6128836870193481,
0.733336865901947,
-0.1997828632593155,
0.4703226685523987,
-0.6815189719200134,
-0.5158889293670654,
0.24766409397125244,
-0.20536842942237854,
-0.04053490608930588,
-0.2830853760242462,
0.029171116650104523,
-0.4381597936153412,
0.4689796566963196,
-0.49795079231262207,
-0.830624520778656,
-0.2140282839536667,
0.11773871630430222,
-0.7141544818878174,
0.6253976225852966,
0.3870094120502472,
-0.6610957980155945,
0.5343769192695618,
-0.7632785439491272,
-0.38307011127471924,
0.029200978577136993,
-0.19542476534843445,
-0.5137425065040588,
0.09861229360103607,
0.21895156800746918,
0.8452084064483643,
-0.48894867300987244,
0.0881950706243515,
-0.8684204816818237,
-0.15693725645542145,
-0.07891996949911118,
-0.0425696074962616,
0.7709481716156006,
0.26259666681289673,
-0.4094701111316681,
-0.10236481577157974,
-0.2339348942041397,
-0.021908283233642578,
0.015753351151943207,
-0.15337952971458435,
-0.4961601495742798,
0.07123123854398727,
-0.19548185169696808,
0.05830235406756401,
-0.06710450351238251,
-0.5170570015907288,
0.46593615412712097,
0.20640693604946136,
0.00558187672868371,
0.8978171348571777,
0.21180716156959534,
0.8897113800048828,
-0.25279536843299866,
0.6316581964492798,
0.1674450784921646,
0.22772005200386047,
0.5990228056907654,
-0.3280660808086395,
-0.4591063857078552,
-0.5088540315628052,
0.22258307039737701,
0.0147935152053833,
-1.0492963790893555,
0.1342865228652954,
-0.3456152379512787,
-0.5812864303588867,
-0.3800082504749298,
-0.08554719388484955,
0.4757654070854187,
0.7195457816123962,
0.3200284540653229,
-0.18087968230247498,
-0.3186764121055603,
-0.7882142066955566,
-0.3110343813896179,
-0.41139206290245056,
-0.11636652797460556,
0.22632254660129547,
0.1294775754213333,
-0.3844339847564697,
0.6277492642402649,
-0.8461083769798279,
-0.38294005393981934,
0.1455128937959671,
0.520671546459198,
-0.32456648349761963,
0.5226503014564514,
0.8761184215545654,
-0.6772794127464294,
-0.12638388574123383,
-0.2829611003398895,
-0.9010538458824158,
0.04442302882671356,
0.21997633576393127,
-0.07545269280672073,
0.5222358107566833,
0.7986624240875244,
-0.20435933768749237,
0.5065072178840637,
0.5133275389671326,
-0.9938850998878479,
0.12292586266994476,
-0.016205934807658195,
0.10912596434354782,
-1.0109775066375732,
0.0015610826667398214,
0.3194595277309418,
-0.35076984763145447,
-0.5069206357002258,
-0.04265899583697319,
-0.13812649250030518,
-0.2863937318325043,
-0.2006940096616745,
0.38892707228660583,
-0.40510672330856323,
-0.0735362246632576,
0.07101117819547653,
-0.3191428482532501,
-0.2533895969390869,
0.7731207609176636,
-0.3644165098667145,
0.12180763483047485,
0.42930424213409424,
-0.5035771727561951,
0.08162334561347961,
0.05429749935865402,
-0.18542076647281647,
0.5757162570953369,
-0.4791550934314728,
-0.05030431970953941,
-0.35628724098205566,
0.5303147435188293,
-0.8277648091316223,
-0.0382264107465744,
0.4142132103443146,
-0.20358113944530487,
0.6113961338996887,
-0.44991829991340637,
-0.1858622431755066,
0.016540754586458206,
-0.5616781115531921,
0.577413022518158,
0.6023174524307251,
-0.5610281825065613,
1.361974835395813,
0.4430111050605774,
0.15471388399600983,
-0.4891701936721802,
-0.5058385133743286,
-0.5998002290725708,
-0.43868839740753174,
-0.8323203325271606,
0.4944164752960205,
-0.0840521976351738,
-0.13444210588932037,
0.7626342177391052,
-0.44874095916748047,
0.19986532628536224,
0.132040873169899,
0.2393045276403427,
0.4138554334640503,
-0.3224148154258728,
0.1870022863149643,
-0.0394744798541069,
-0.41322025656700134,
0.09760145097970963,
-0.597621500492096,
0.8546608090400696,
-0.0015444112941622734,
-0.5141693353652954,
-0.1342180073261261,
0.5790873765945435,
0.5686594843864441,
-0.13924723863601685,
1.0413885116577148,
1.5101217031478882,
-0.42038312554359436,
-0.08520287275314331,
-0.8915749788284302,
-0.1393619328737259,
-0.4919363558292389,
0.33389124274253845,
-0.1216704398393631,
-1.1270579099655151,
0.777449369430542,
-0.3415229320526123,
-0.15412455797195435,
0.756698727607727,
0.5343359708786011,
-0.14196835458278656,
1.0020893812179565,
0.7583114504814148,
-0.41547921299934387,
0.45251867175102234,
-0.4789426624774933,
0.20932544767856598,
-0.7767947316169739,
-0.5580483675003052,
-0.5080117583274841,
-0.5499932169914246,
-1.165813684463501,
-0.5177819132804871,
0.625578761100769,
-0.2696942090988159,
-0.3012392520904541,
-0.30828794836997986,
-0.06030922383069992,
0.223728746175766,
0.41726306080818176,
0.22274942696094513,
0.05747213214635849,
0.3135277032852173,
-0.22590354084968567,
0.1326024979352951,
-0.9707524180412292,
0.15632973611354828,
1.0647692680358887,
0.33254486322402954,
0.8958122730255127,
0.1501253992319107,
0.7865580916404724,
0.301862895488739,
0.2203027904033661,
-0.48440659046173096,
0.48280492424964905,
-0.11417999863624573,
-0.2593764662742615,
-0.2704819440841675,
-0.9082950353622437,
-0.5277919173240662,
-0.04152829945087433,
-0.4434312880039215,
-0.6939296722412109,
0.4332972764968872,
-0.03846529498696327,
0.030750218778848648,
0.7355728149414062,
-0.7607688903808594,
0.3739067316055298,
0.5225359797477722,
-0.35257217288017273,
-0.27370378375053406,
-0.43570181727409363,
0.03754058852791786,
0.12070148438215256,
-0.19198033213615417,
-0.3799072504043579,
-0.14081038534641266,
1.1623899936676025,
-0.4854402244091034,
0.5699952244758606,
-0.7957329750061035,
0.37093693017959595,
0.13858239352703094,
0.15890587866306305,
0.5248368382453918,
0.2053292989730835,
-0.055550169199705124,
0.21668975055217743,
-0.4204143285751343,
-0.7850624918937683,
-0.8888412714004517,
0.8066888451576233,
-1.020948052406311,
-0.6404858231544495,
-0.23687666654586792,
-0.7777365446090698,
-0.5862576365470886,
-0.11364555358886719,
0.1793231964111328,
0.6289042830467224,
0.019572747871279716,
0.40490803122520447,
0.6199638843536377,
0.058107830584049225,
0.5815402269363403,
0.2942265570163727,
-0.1401159018278122,
-0.4947914183139801,
0.8861145973205566,
0.23863328993320465,
0.21093064546585083,
0.1539878249168396,
0.3791029453277588,
-0.353187620639801,
-0.520009458065033,
0.24947036802768707,
0.4168647825717926,
-0.6880084872245789,
-0.06316617876291275,
-0.62398761510849,
0.23486129939556122,
-0.4951116144657135,
-0.4195847809314728,
-0.40869349241256714,
-0.5390611290931702,
0.05147264897823334,
0.014268913306295872,
0.24949900805950165,
0.7382493019104004,
-0.21559995412826538,
0.0872100219130516,
-0.4513450562953949,
0.3956491947174072,
0.409253865480423,
0.8982570767402649,
-0.08763713389635086,
0.09653886407613754,
-0.12627406418323517,
-0.2422175407409668,
0.25557762384414673,
-0.5130408406257629,
0.04931386187672615,
-0.16438916325569153,
1.0060774087905884,
0.2220369428396225,
-0.05603745952248573,
0.6238423585891724,
-0.20119470357894897,
0.6449359059333801,
0.34461119771003723,
-0.6700101494789124,
0.002421241020783782,
-0.6016616821289062,
0.14729292690753937,
0.2792696952819824,
0.7156579494476318,
-0.20098692178726196,
-0.20377543568611145,
-0.8714272379875183,
-0.8827060461044312,
0.49318382143974304,
0.3093944191932678,
-0.41243699193000793,
0.46811071038246155,
0.17621633410453796,
-0.018310653045773506,
0.09187671542167664,
-0.1945478767156601,
-0.7683790922164917,
-0.16468830406665802,
-0.048885274678468704,
-0.30105799436569214,
-0.40585213899612427,
-0.4187053442001343,
-0.2809681296348572,
0.7800064086914062,
-0.21416528522968292,
1.038233995437622,
0.08810052275657654,
0.07313454151153564,
-0.4130975306034088,
-0.3088809847831726,
0.39565643668174744,
0.5956326723098755,
-0.4173083007335663,
-0.06582173705101013,
-0.028653571382164955,
-0.5695123672485352,
0.28041312098503113,
0.3759813904762268,
-0.03461650386452675,
0.03154679387807846,
0.513742208480835,
0.6391435265541077,
-0.1452665627002716,
0.6178144812583923,
0.163704052567482,
-0.2899043560028076,
-0.19770699739456177,
0.07898088544607162,
-0.03287529945373535,
0.12095518410205841,
0.6233680248260498,
0.5337784290313721,
0.2529453635215759,
-0.29355278611183167,
-0.3971388041973114,
-0.054608941078186035,
0.2453736513853073,
-0.5060244798660278,
-0.22751843929290771,
0.5665490627288818,
0.1997600942850113,
-0.20100867748260498,
0.45983240008354187,
-0.20250564813613892,
-0.6743260025978088,
0.43793925642967224,
0.4071701765060425,
1.1604292392730713,
-0.3924206495285034,
0.32175707817077637,
0.12626051902770996,
0.20702292025089264,
0.08327563852071762,
0.3331918716430664,
0.2519476115703583,
-0.6166243553161621,
-0.19531632959842682,
-0.4422518312931061,
-0.1903766393661499,
-0.08124404400587082,
-0.5240896940231323,
-0.13229238986968994,
-0.5978662967681885,
0.0048182313330471516,
-0.09553398191928864,
0.23667345941066742,
-1.2831149101257324,
0.09076224267482758,
-0.09134257584810257,
0.36735299229621887,
-0.9949570894241333,
0.5914345383644104,
0.6008220314979553,
-0.2979371249675751,
-1.0328967571258545,
0.37713807821273804,
0.14341804385185242,
-0.7142598628997803,
0.2875545024871826,
-0.34544917941093445,
-0.0978826954960823,
-0.1011401042342186,
-0.41058018803596497,
-0.6443489193916321,
1.468026876449585,
0.6128591895103455,
0.2008158415555954,
0.07230982184410095,
0.45003440976142883,
0.25213494896888733,
-0.5365691184997559,
-0.13500045239925385,
0.10109943151473999,
0.6433261036872864,
0.09373732656240463,
-0.37306883931159973,
0.3338872790336609,
-0.32412904500961304,
0.0736052617430687,
0.30175283551216125,
-0.599661648273468,
0.6935112476348877,
0.2817593216896057,
-0.005416110623627901,
-0.4938971698284149,
0.7186112999916077,
-0.03477245569229126,
0.3302210569381714,
0.8540224432945251,
0.5201548337936401,
0.7911348938941956,
-0.2877161502838135,
1.1690999269485474,
-0.015661314129829407,
0.5261361598968506,
0.5861071944236755,
-0.005291628185659647,
0.004153193905949593,
0.7131268978118896,
-0.07804228365421295,
0.44756990671157837,
0.29309067130088806,
0.17776848375797272,
0.746405303478241,
-0.06687145680189133,
-0.4543783962726593,
-0.4114275574684143,
-0.5354050993919373,
-0.5951007604598999,
0.3089759051799774,
0.25683096051216125,
-0.14085884392261505,
-0.30628353357315063,
-0.12850286066532135,
0.15102577209472656,
-0.38632047176361084,
-0.4380781054496765,
0.4471316635608673,
-0.1314912587404251,
-0.38120415806770325,
0.2893957495689392,
-0.09997165948152542,
0.4762793183326721,
-0.6924635767936707,
0.10310520231723785,
-0.32476097345352173,
0.06625337898731232,
-0.24206091463565826,
-0.3905295729637146,
0.19469255208969116,
-0.5071499347686768,
-0.038314078003168106,
-0.2756757140159607,
1.1179075241088867,
-0.5864393711090088,
-0.46731147170066833,
0.3334011733531952,
0.6568352580070496,
-0.5559108853340149,
0.21408608555793762,
-0.13269826769828796,
-0.08383496850728989,
0.05992371588945389,
-0.6957288384437561,
0.35410499572753906,
0.3440914452075958,
0.0834655836224556,
0.7709423899650574,
0.5624642372131348,
-0.19815339148044586,
0.11407620459794998,
-0.05703269690275192,
1.1225539445877075,
-0.45133984088897705,
-0.5623572468757629,
-0.6944392323493958,
0.5736942291259766,
0.019769875332713127,
-0.13906791806221008,
0.6813263297080994,
0.24032241106033325,
0.6598785519599915,
-0.08414693921804428,
0.7236359119415283,
-0.0778646469116211,
0.046752769500017166,
-0.5694754123687744,
0.9120627641677856,
-0.801816999912262,
0.25369027256965637,
-0.3816230893135071,
-1.122680902481079,
-0.4142416715621948,
0.0826193168759346,
-0.14498475193977356,
0.2579476833343506,
0.9227145314216614,
0.727816104888916,
-0.18967434763908386,
0.19050511717796326,
0.25960373878479004,
0.04817122593522072,
0.5397553443908691,
0.2325521856546402,
0.46086907386779785,
-0.16842156648635864,
0.30555787682533264,
-0.5500255823135376,
-0.04503853991627693,
-0.24363669753074646,
-1.119187593460083,
-1.1672265529632568,
-0.8424814939498901,
-0.5405219197273254,
-0.46484577655792236,
0.030153820291161537,
1.0309957265853882,
0.5307506918907166,
-0.35365545749664307,
0.2159007340669632,
0.3308725953102112,
0.14518871903419495,
-0.011547736823558807,
-0.15541188418865204,
0.7061169743537903,
-0.12048453837633133,
-0.3911617696285248,
0.26879429817199707,
0.27561700344085693,
0.021927490830421448,
-0.6631998419761658,
-0.3537551760673523,
-0.35239142179489136,
-0.36291059851646423,
0.2838488519191742,
-0.02592913620173931,
-0.2340373694896698,
-0.7280109524726868,
0.03242478892207146,
-0.07180840522050858,
-0.24952107667922974,
1.1360586881637573,
-0.7711849212646484,
0.38707587122917175,
0.9258544445037842,
0.8333846926689148,
0.7986243963241577,
-0.42373594641685486,
0.9062103033065796,
-0.9152934551239014,
0.3232356309890747,
0.3551766872406006,
0.634422779083252,
0.0981656014919281,
-0.45475465059280396,
0.931751549243927,
0.7343690395355225,
-0.25899842381477356,
-0.5610532760620117,
0.10355617105960846,
-1.080208659172058,
-0.16232484579086304,
1.279604434967041,
-0.3391823172569275,
-0.44130539894104004,
-0.20087426900863647,
0.5275818705558777,
0.9304594397544861,
-0.18632936477661133,
0.7366387248039246,
0.5165536403656006,
0.09334548562765121,
0.454653799533844,
-0.01678686961531639,
0.32606223225593567,
0.5904297828674316,
-0.5704160928726196,
-0.5063823461532593,
0.27173930406570435,
0.33010274171829224,
0.10101307928562164,
0.550767183303833,
-0.17703860998153687,
0.2387920320034027,
0.12333320826292038,
-0.1731971651315689,
-0.7011547684669495,
-0.17656013369560242,
0.009777168743312359,
0.4868377149105072,
-0.37668174505233765,
-0.14577491581439972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09145v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09145v2
|
ToNER: Type-oriented Named Entity Recognition with Generative Language Model
| 2024-04-14T05:13:37 | 2024-06-11T14:05:03 |
Guochao Jiang, Ziqin Luo, Yuchen Shi, Dixuan Wang, Jiaqing Liang, Deqing Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent years, the fine-tuned generative models have been proven more
powerful than the previous tagging-based or span-based models on named entity
recognition (NER) task. It has also been found that the information related to
entities, such as entity types, can prompt a model to achieve NER better.
However, it is not easy to determine the entity types indeed existing in the
given sentence in advance, and inputting too many potential entity types would
distract the model inevitably. To exploit entity types' merit on promoting NER
task, in this paper we propose a novel NER framework, namely ToNER based on a
generative model. In ToNER, a type matching model is proposed at first to
identify the entity types most likely to appear in the sentence. Then, we
append a multiple binary classification task to fine-tune the generative
model's encoder, so as to generate the refined representation of the input
sentence. Moreover, we add an auxiliary task for the model to discover the
entity types which further fine-tunes the model to output more accurate
results. Our extensive experiments on some NER benchmarks verify the
effectiveness of our proposed strategies in ToNER that are oriented towards
entity types' exploitation.
|
[
-0.4190209209918976,
-0.5756857991218567,
0.38891756534576416,
0.17016810178756714,
-0.38310423493385315,
-0.023462694138288498,
-0.11478104442358017,
-0.629288911819458,
0.3190874755382538,
0.8283336162567139,
-0.14904573559761047,
-0.33506110310554504,
-0.5207964181900024,
0.3455359935760498,
-0.6264097094535828,
0.9648346900939941,
0.005625443533062935,
0.10055987536907196,
-0.11906643211841583,
-0.1291351318359375,
-0.48318222165107727,
-0.5760142207145691,
-1.0056142807006836,
-0.29876917600631714,
0.4230305254459381,
0.30078011751174927,
0.16634832322597504,
0.5938172936439514,
0.6855313777923584,
0.310973197221756,
-0.28578686714172363,
0.06448820233345032,
-0.30235403776168823,
0.2552773356437683,
-0.06753337383270264,
-0.6194450855255127,
-0.3316130042076111,
-0.48045778274536133,
0.6721641421318054,
0.3689211308956146,
-0.20839929580688477,
0.16956207156181335,
-0.06281135231256485,
0.6083412170410156,
-0.4747188687324524,
0.19008159637451172,
-0.818617582321167,
0.045358575880527496,
-0.3765776455402374,
-0.21068614721298218,
-0.6083958745002747,
-0.3494971990585327,
-0.1375826895236969,
-0.3289884328842163,
0.43960243463516235,
0.21140044927597046,
0.9456577897071838,
0.20956158638000488,
-0.5231237411499023,
-0.42399102449417114,
-0.9310306310653687,
0.3015906512737274,
-0.6676418781280518,
0.4037410616874695,
-0.029192958027124405,
0.3791612386703491,
-0.14817826449871063,
-0.5981834530830383,
-0.7411085367202759,
-0.19451887905597687,
-0.020820261910557747,
0.03577343001961708,
-0.08598620444536209,
0.3014441132545471,
0.33571240305900574,
0.7113017439842224,
-0.17866797745227814,
0.08582151681184769,
-0.12726621329784393,
-0.11555668711662292,
0.15544049441814423,
0.058929312974214554,
0.5395649671554565,
-0.15543720126152039,
-0.37567052245140076,
0.05937628820538521,
-0.6235030889511108,
0.09085536003112793,
0.3298051357269287,
0.549373984336853,
0.16043415665626526,
1.0430231094360352,
-0.27584922313690186,
0.9684036374092102,
0.5633924007415771,
-0.04636974632740021,
-0.007933784276247025,
-0.02599993720650673,
-0.22695818543434143,
0.349109411239624,
0.47419917583465576,
0.04062030836939812,
0.2531859278678894,
-0.296012282371521,
-0.5672252774238586,
0.21381893754005432,
0.18585564196109772,
-1.0234479904174805,
-0.19101454317569733,
-0.1259670853614807,
-0.5797483325004578,
-0.37500235438346863,
-0.015247090719640255,
-0.87501460313797,
-0.3888877034187317,
-0.2305341362953186,
0.26338455080986023,
-0.6219562888145447,
-0.2764245867729187,
0.03880720213055611,
0.016876880079507828,
0.3500562012195587,
0.2790972888469696,
-0.9891805052757263,
0.34974205493927,
0.7679678797721863,
0.6582735776901245,
-0.003625827608630061,
0.25091901421546936,
-0.6025696992874146,
0.2286377251148224,
-0.06689447164535522,
1.0299062728881836,
-0.7175054550170898,
-0.34724342823028564,
-0.03362157940864563,
-0.19053640961647034,
-0.07437453418970108,
-0.6543833613395691,
0.5776379108428955,
-1.0108952522277832,
0.08772401511669159,
-0.12161149829626083,
-0.9183118939399719,
-0.3510025143623352,
0.3045283257961273,
-1.0655227899551392,
0.7235590219497681,
0.13026869297027588,
-1.0328681468963623,
0.6289970278739929,
-0.6048996448516846,
-0.463138222694397,
0.4590834379196167,
-0.14726606011390686,
-0.5187579393386841,
0.2909443974494934,
-0.0008677546866238117,
0.2343575805425644,
-0.33990517258644104,
0.44696593284606934,
-0.24071864783763885,
-0.05354752391576767,
0.28581100702285767,
-0.19503119587898254,
0.5216606855392456,
0.04174971207976341,
-0.18864527344703674,
0.06300118565559387,
-1.0327351093292236,
0.025017106905579567,
0.09124171733856201,
-0.6808916926383972,
-0.5056251287460327,
0.003913552965968847,
0.2786006033420563,
0.18389880657196045,
0.14479097723960876,
-0.5406352281570435,
0.05699003115296364,
-0.37867334485054016,
0.22432269155979156,
0.3269447386264801,
0.024050654843449593,
0.5903521180152893,
-0.13426661491394043,
0.5820208191871643,
-0.07307185232639313,
-0.3780738115310669,
0.029145747423171997,
-0.3368660807609558,
-1.2179927825927734,
-0.2309185117483139,
0.603934645652771,
0.5355984568595886,
-0.8484787940979004,
0.35862693190574646,
-0.2963810861110687,
-0.39022451639175415,
-0.5559459328651428,
-0.11699405312538147,
0.5154629349708557,
0.722131073474884,
0.3966400921344757,
-0.31945669651031494,
-0.737317681312561,
-0.8462914824485779,
-0.37613338232040405,
-0.17446795105934143,
0.11872731149196625,
0.39151471853256226,
0.32598763704299927,
-0.1372855305671692,
1.0669549703598022,
-0.43797567486763,
-0.42831599712371826,
-0.4985430836677551,
0.1836954951286316,
0.010843786410987377,
0.4969146251678467,
0.3645772933959961,
-1.0297549962997437,
-0.41550639271736145,
-0.032311972230672836,
-0.4794619083404541,
0.07775434106588364,
0.10694747418165207,
0.11311180144548416,
0.08269165456295013,
0.5936260223388672,
-0.4987357556819916,
-0.05804169550538063,
0.32719913125038147,
-0.30830782651901245,
0.5239824652671814,
-0.015461355447769165,
-0.14902061223983765,
-1.2225656509399414,
0.0509667843580246,
0.07916330546140671,
-0.25816336274147034,
-0.7642652988433838,
0.1445222795009613,
0.12563420832157135,
-0.31868112087249756,
-0.0462813600897789,
0.6478139162063599,
-0.6294304132461548,
-0.06625399738550186,
-0.31951960921287537,
-0.28823867440223694,
-0.09519844502210617,
0.27587270736694336,
0.19201835989952087,
0.708613395690918,
0.5375251770019531,
-0.6503375768661499,
0.18577700853347778,
0.14559289813041687,
-0.3483913838863373,
0.6701290011405945,
-0.6525020599365234,
0.3249216079711914,
-0.434611052274704,
0.09236934036016464,
-0.4738335907459259,
-0.2198854237794876,
0.3671149015426636,
-0.15726223587989807,
0.6553853154182434,
-0.5464898347854614,
-0.47972166538238525,
-0.254321426153183,
0.44951751828193665,
0.44708409905433655,
0.1578030288219452,
-0.49763911962509155,
1.0589113235473633,
0.35018059611320496,
-0.22657139599323273,
-0.3718488812446594,
-0.5454190969467163,
0.10989542305469513,
-0.4651780128479004,
-0.22021321952342987,
0.787911057472229,
0.15669673681259155,
0.03694336861371994,
0.21757009625434875,
-0.25934797525405884,
-0.2893950939178467,
-0.13594067096710205,
0.1360580325126648,
0.21898843348026276,
-0.4950437545776367,
0.1582227200269699,
-0.08995033800601959,
-0.2303655445575714,
-0.09798329323530197,
-0.30925253033638,
0.7338293194770813,
-0.21320129930973053,
-0.33756136894226074,
-0.2563701272010803,
0.3179713785648346,
0.2939939498901367,
-0.6693874597549438,
0.5956306457519531,
0.44589555263519287,
-0.6065554618835449,
-0.09692967683076859,
-0.7399905323982239,
-0.004399785306304693,
-0.4732036888599396,
0.37245428562164307,
-0.5978030562400818,
-0.9386341571807861,
0.28362926840782166,
-0.1085440143942833,
-0.30413109064102173,
0.4016554355621338,
0.14151065051555634,
0.21543514728546143,
0.7025356292724609,
0.9314302802085876,
-0.030809832736849785,
0.7481354475021362,
-0.030601253733038902,
0.40621331334114075,
-0.9145011901855469,
-0.38921159505844116,
-0.5144549012184143,
-0.050701163709163666,
-0.6135718822479248,
-0.349613755941391,
-0.11445077508687973,
0.22055375576019287,
0.03189994394779205,
0.7084840536117554,
-0.6072054505348206,
0.329466313123703,
0.46961620450019836,
-0.047348469495773315,
0.3516063690185547,
-0.10355402529239655,
-0.19823582470417023,
0.03966555744409561,
-0.3829912841320038,
-0.5815083980560303,
0.6794697046279907,
0.05540953949093819,
0.5972383618354797,
0.07539616525173187,
1.046042561531067,
-0.011200111359357834,
0.46065637469291687,
-0.8536775708198547,
0.7902582287788391,
-0.4444904625415802,
-0.6611789464950562,
0.059752464294433594,
-0.5037739276885986,
-0.731167733669281,
0.002316280035302043,
-0.23671548068523407,
-0.6033551096916199,
0.45611217617988586,
0.2795526087284088,
-0.17802517116069794,
0.2971057891845703,
-0.48455798625946045,
0.6993215084075928,
-0.3477674126625061,
0.3317856788635254,
0.044103577733039856,
-0.267362505197525,
0.23505103588104248,
0.08705531060695648,
-0.023140883073210716,
-0.07355741411447525,
0.16400910913944244,
0.6995490789413452,
0.004507048055529594,
0.563809335231781,
-0.2441367208957672,
-0.04273473843932152,
0.2177576720714569,
0.08046390861272812,
0.5642023086547852,
-0.001293121138587594,
-0.1014314815402031,
-0.1470664143562317,
-0.5554516315460205,
0.04215613007545471,
-0.5572940707206726,
0.33915215730667114,
-0.16142915189266205,
-0.507318913936615,
-0.21515442430973053,
-0.32513463497161865,
0.05380340293049812,
0.6217924952507019,
0.42054483294487,
0.6452612280845642,
-0.3760393261909485,
-0.030619263648986816,
0.7428773045539856,
0.007061240263283253,
0.3733704388141632,
0.4910247325897217,
-0.3028971552848816,
-0.49237415194511414,
1.094746708869934,
-0.09215792268514633,
0.1691141128540039,
0.9956124424934387,
-0.2946009933948517,
-0.24320711195468903,
-0.7762543559074402,
-0.33950603008270264,
0.13715240359306335,
-0.5686720013618469,
-0.44687968492507935,
-1.0157121419906616,
-0.2870620787143707,
-0.23824730515480042,
0.02710447832942009,
-0.2651059627532959,
-0.2954705059528351,
-0.5238877534866333,
0.13324470818042755,
0.33572760224342346,
0.5511871576309204,
0.35971006751060486,
0.24546977877616882,
-0.5371038317680359,
0.5831557512283325,
0.4743044972419739,
0.48757046461105347,
-0.08497857302427292,
-0.35725533962249756,
0.14826275408267975,
-0.11246684193611145,
-0.02813260443508625,
-1.0236940383911133,
0.4801103174686432,
0.18050822615623474,
0.4465523362159729,
0.6526066660881042,
-0.07470270246267319,
0.6370927095413208,
-0.6744097471237183,
0.11000508069992065,
0.15829874575138092,
-0.8315988779067993,
0.5460381507873535,
-0.06193678826093674,
-0.13710430264472961,
0.5697294473648071,
0.09578798711299896,
-0.515677273273468,
-0.301296591758728,
-0.5250777006149292,
-0.9149599671363831,
0.5305703282356262,
0.09702109545469284,
0.052109405398368835,
-0.21614527702331543,
0.40873754024505615,
-0.1348000019788742,
0.25191229581832886,
-1.066332221031189,
-0.25111448764801025,
-0.2360203117132187,
-0.2988094389438629,
0.08352979272603989,
-0.41123977303504944,
0.2947118580341339,
0.2614002525806427,
0.6138201355934143,
-0.05515728145837784,
0.44252851605415344,
0.14557510614395142,
-0.39594513177871704,
0.31535834074020386,
0.7081072330474854,
0.30558738112449646,
-0.19535085558891296,
-0.20168744027614594,
0.1558959186077118,
-0.016020821407437325,
-0.2684192657470703,
0.14725825190544128,
0.6706218719482422,
-0.6041951179504395,
0.1663566380739212,
0.06356813758611679,
0.9045181274414062,
0.27848032116889954,
-0.4640253782272339,
0.07368892431259155,
-0.01612342707812786,
0.3636506199836731,
-0.4182218313217163,
0.3070896863937378,
0.28297117352485657,
0.2246340811252594,
0.14578300714492798,
0.32888084650039673,
0.42140522599220276,
-0.36529240012168884,
0.07161930203437805,
0.5881066918373108,
-0.6252007484436035,
-0.15800859034061432,
0.7029943466186523,
0.14513331651687622,
-0.725925862789154,
0.5991086959838867,
-0.6985961198806763,
-0.7881706357002258,
0.91743004322052,
1.012102484703064,
0.945041835308075,
-0.19635574519634247,
0.16768674552440643,
0.4931837320327759,
0.05217127874493599,
-0.24531345069408417,
0.30291688442230225,
0.084241583943367,
-1.0889570713043213,
-0.17148688435554504,
-0.7401078343391418,
-0.2535262405872345,
0.04177696630358696,
-0.8917079567909241,
0.40912604331970215,
-0.3159485161304474,
-0.2751200795173645,
0.3831809163093567,
-0.29236555099487305,
-0.6380351185798645,
0.2478964924812317,
0.2775062620639801,
0.8546922206878662,
-0.4949108958244324,
0.6824811697006226,
1.0505605936050415,
-0.6796802878379822,
-0.8012726306915283,
0.16908371448516846,
-0.2508348822593689,
-0.5658295750617981,
0.8651915788650513,
0.5700984597206116,
-0.046243611723184586,
0.5245497822761536,
0.029590563848614693,
-1.073982834815979,
0.9378204941749573,
0.3125080466270447,
-0.6863804459571838,
-0.3338566720485687,
0.003412845777347684,
0.4382328391075134,
-0.7021111845970154,
0.10468795895576477,
0.1745835542678833,
0.3593556880950928,
0.013335363939404488,
-0.5180676579475403,
0.3069416284561157,
-0.3268951177597046,
0.3801509737968445,
0.46675625443458557,
-0.34085729718208313,
0.772891640663147,
-0.4209769368171692,
-0.6693287491798401,
0.17976966500282288,
0.8407762050628662,
0.24558785557746887,
0.12324308604001999,
0.7100071310997009,
0.7970132231712341,
0.6721585988998413,
-0.058292873203754425,
0.8809605836868286,
-0.27684634923934937,
0.39131826162338257,
1.287973403930664,
-0.40302401781082153,
0.7491386532783508,
0.13609665632247925,
-0.07691851258277893,
0.7018819451332092,
0.24049486219882965,
-0.48074644804000854,
0.6204807758331299,
0.3061271607875824,
-0.5625799894332886,
-0.03804278373718262,
-0.3432731330394745,
-0.2364686131477356,
0.5534524917602539,
0.3768405020236969,
-0.3721258044242859,
-0.22991123795509338,
0.001404835726134479,
0.014061848632991314,
-0.024243976920843124,
-0.4417860209941864,
1.0372512340545654,
-0.04066838324069977,
-0.7255430817604065,
0.10175151377916336,
0.25010567903518677,
0.8431729078292847,
-0.2104538530111313,
-0.1326068490743637,
-0.01434666384011507,
0.09040593355894089,
-0.08027347922325134,
-0.34924477338790894,
0.16636674106121063,
0.07378653436899185,
-0.5085731744766235,
-0.058424875140190125,
1.0943137407302856,
-0.7128278017044067,
-0.6809440851211548,
0.2901930809020996,
0.18573389947414398,
-0.14329852163791656,
-0.2223321944475174,
-0.4267082214355469,
-0.5111273527145386,
-0.1750708967447281,
0.17990265786647797,
0.20546019077301025,
0.591873288154602,
0.17999598383903503,
0.7164952158927917,
0.5067952275276184,
0.1552903652191162,
0.02054775133728981,
0.2957431674003601,
0.7220916748046875,
-0.921718418598175,
-0.5297179818153381,
-0.7330200672149658,
0.2109801173210144,
-0.14366935193538666,
-0.13988687098026276,
0.40283069014549255,
0.703763484954834,
0.6775569319725037,
-0.14293697476387024,
0.5731803774833679,
-0.35776886343955994,
0.4332256317138672,
-0.5658153891563416,
0.5188774466514587,
-0.2457292526960373,
0.0026242167223244905,
-0.2614276111125946,
-0.922856867313385,
-0.19064556062221527,
0.41139742732048035,
-0.09419125318527222,
0.11567945778369904,
0.5295336246490479,
0.6937820315361023,
-0.07503491640090942,
-0.05821527540683746,
-0.020217053592205048,
0.12179666012525558,
0.20717354118824005,
0.32107362151145935,
0.7817192077636719,
-0.1342964768409729,
0.6097739934921265,
-0.2559550106525421,
0.02694430947303772,
-0.40718191862106323,
-0.9367624521255493,
-0.7404478192329407,
-0.484518826007843,
-0.3586445748806,
-0.23369944095611572,
0.0746464729309082,
0.6818626523017883,
0.43600994348526,
-1.006097435951233,
0.20089955627918243,
-0.6121764183044434,
0.10809055715799332,
-0.17377245426177979,
-0.31249725818634033,
0.14544542133808136,
-0.3224121034145355,
-0.674036979675293,
0.14548254013061523,
0.30036965012550354,
0.38585713505744934,
0.20333805680274963,
0.30142897367477417,
-0.011236773803830147,
-0.10097703337669373,
0.41344791650772095,
0.3654709756374359,
-0.8023266792297363,
-0.10047151148319244,
0.04877856746315956,
-0.1999312788248062,
0.04725659266114235,
1.1081311702728271,
-0.745234489440918,
0.4196617901325226,
0.24120178818702698,
0.7849144339561462,
0.3789431154727936,
-0.09146367013454437,
0.46868962049484253,
-0.4291107952594757,
-0.19049543142318726,
0.4167250990867615,
0.659289538860321,
0.6356487274169922,
-0.47424620389938354,
0.25474318861961365,
0.021828027442097664,
-0.29400086402893066,
-0.6423181891441345,
0.3940075933933258,
-1.041203260421753,
0.2011144906282425,
1.2126234769821167,
-0.16597773134708405,
0.26669618487358093,
-0.21197842061519623,
-0.14358742535114288,
0.5543607473373413,
-0.4033318758010864,
0.6832033395767212,
0.5416344404220581,
0.007226362358778715,
-0.22699201107025146,
-0.2842057943344116,
0.35621631145477295,
0.2210182398557663,
-0.8745004534721375,
-0.12205604463815689,
0.394940584897995,
0.4560411870479584,
0.3243948817253113,
0.7098346948623657,
-0.10450105369091034,
0.03704601526260376,
-0.041073963046073914,
0.3623506426811218,
-0.03904927894473076,
-0.2259962260723114,
-0.3432445228099823,
0.21954195201396942,
0.2103613317012787,
-0.09857837110757828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09138v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09138v1
|
From Bytes to Borsch: Fine-Tuning Gemma and Mistral for the Ukrainian Language Representation
| 2024-04-14T04:25:41 | 2024-04-14T04:25:41 |
Artur Kiulian, Anton Polishko, Mykola Khandoga, Oryna Chubych, Jack Connor, Raghav Ravishankar, Adarsh Shirawalmath
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In the rapidly advancing field of AI and NLP, generative large language
models (LLMs) stand at the forefront of innovation, showcasing unparalleled
abilities in text understanding and generation. However, the limited
representation of low-resource languages like Ukrainian poses a notable
challenge, restricting the reach and relevance of this technology. Our paper
addresses this by fine-tuning the open-source Gemma and Mistral LLMs with
Ukrainian datasets, aiming to improve their linguistic proficiency and
benchmarking them against other existing models capable of processing Ukrainian
language. This endeavor not only aims to mitigate language bias in technology
but also promotes inclusivity in the digital realm. Our transparent and
reproducible approach encourages further NLP research and development.
Additionally, we present the Ukrainian Knowledge and Instruction Dataset (UKID)
to aid future efforts in language model fine-tuning. Our research not only
advances the field of NLP but also highlights the importance of linguistic
diversity in AI, which is crucial for cultural preservation, education, and
expanding AI's global utility. Ultimately, we advocate for a future where
technology is inclusive, enabling AI to communicate effectively across all
languages, especially those currently underrepresented.
|
[
-0.3366835117340088,
-0.36364638805389404,
0.14826492965221405,
0.033389296382665634,
-0.33304503560066223,
0.27512219548225403,
-0.3725929260253906,
-0.5860273241996765,
0.11455138772726059,
0.4465254843235016,
-0.3232309818267822,
-0.7539243698120117,
-0.7227843999862671,
0.18839912116527557,
-0.2501312494277954,
0.7945627570152283,
0.1474202424287796,
0.4807440936565399,
-0.14784854650497437,
-0.317982941865921,
-0.6406435370445251,
-0.3682917356491089,
-0.546856701374054,
-0.4267091751098633,
0.0998806282877922,
0.6187195777893066,
0.8085753917694092,
0.7222951650619507,
0.4614678621292114,
0.30499911308288574,
-0.13385632634162903,
0.2831436097621918,
-0.5281370878219604,
0.19664163887500763,
-0.516690731048584,
-0.8267732858657837,
-0.22508355975151062,
-0.4029839038848877,
0.6676210761070251,
0.7271444201469421,
-0.27827346324920654,
0.20458073914051056,
0.21445001661777496,
0.8671210408210754,
-0.41573455929756165,
0.13676495850086212,
-1.0121009349822998,
0.2543938159942627,
-0.3226502537727356,
-0.22876819968223572,
-0.4060174226760864,
-0.2351803332567215,
-0.29098740220069885,
-0.5235593318939209,
0.2816876471042633,
0.024710597470402718,
0.8667147755622864,
0.1781197339296341,
0.012426109053194523,
-0.2700694799423218,
-0.8056590557098389,
0.849169135093689,
-0.5403050184249878,
0.6504529118537903,
0.4404348134994507,
0.11627516150474548,
-0.3356526792049408,
-0.7742543816566467,
-0.1611481010913849,
-0.11517415940761566,
0.3220214247703552,
0.07184740155935287,
-0.58730149269104,
0.03446737304329872,
0.00840099435299635,
0.3939192593097687,
-0.3384077847003937,
0.39067262411117554,
-0.585761308670044,
-0.4924250841140747,
0.4263983368873596,
0.33969902992248535,
0.16596414148807526,
0.31620922684669495,
0.0910496711730957,
-0.03564969450235367,
-0.7659094333648682,
0.022451600059866905,
0.43793347477912903,
0.5506055355072021,
-0.2639261484146118,
0.8013682961463928,
-0.3559935986995697,
0.6999379396438599,
0.3892207443714142,
0.1367795169353485,
0.11882475763559341,
-0.37087497115135193,
-0.17914979159832,
0.08104101568460464,
0.7502032518386841,
0.1263153851032257,
0.3605687618255615,
-0.45866596698760986,
0.036177124828100204,
0.11477984488010406,
0.3399990499019623,
-0.9567481279373169,
-0.12402889132499695,
0.26921573281288147,
-0.36128145456314087,
-0.10153912007808685,
0.11266179382801056,
-0.9762867093086243,
-0.49994853138923645,
-0.29978305101394653,
0.19093991816043854,
-0.45669159293174744,
-0.07599251717329025,
0.5409601926803589,
0.05630871281027794,
-0.04320370778441429,
0.20560860633850098,
-1.390421986579895,
0.3422398865222931,
0.6707668900489807,
0.8782750964164734,
0.26492637395858765,
-0.14890825748443604,
-0.5771081447601318,
0.0813385471701622,
-0.7426455616950989,
0.6269031763076782,
-0.6700865030288696,
-0.5685892701148987,
0.1518738865852356,
-0.1551961600780487,
0.596897542476654,
-0.8902427554130554,
0.2691403031349182,
-0.36537298560142517,
-0.20505864918231964,
-0.13560649752616882,
-0.3820865750312805,
0.11711390316486359,
-0.018888719379901886,
-0.6365127563476562,
1.095796823501587,
0.07453188300132751,
-0.7768147587776184,
0.4445101320743561,
-0.34360450506210327,
-0.25945186614990234,
0.2164483666419983,
-0.21069447696208954,
-0.13947641849517822,
0.47224897146224976,
0.066410131752491,
0.6103476285934448,
-0.2938627600669861,
0.3018052875995636,
-0.2644920349121094,
-0.1162271723151207,
0.13022378087043762,
-0.3969058394432068,
0.5943359732627869,
0.08936507999897003,
-0.2771930992603302,
0.19666700065135956,
-0.9515461325645447,
0.105916328728199,
-0.3057937026023865,
-0.47792646288871765,
-0.10308032482862473,
0.08716809004545212,
0.0543152280151844,
0.11948628723621368,
0.5387400388717651,
-0.6092736721038818,
0.19622628390789032,
-0.6523225903511047,
0.6371251344680786,
0.5499776601791382,
-0.6613459587097168,
0.7531416416168213,
-0.2541431784629822,
0.6549845933914185,
0.175001323223114,
0.12237775325775146,
-0.09230496734380722,
-0.46702322363853455,
-0.7187330722808838,
-0.22601966559886932,
0.48791447281837463,
0.3171805441379547,
-0.6629875898361206,
0.6182118654251099,
-0.4657769501209259,
-0.6922065615653992,
-1.399348258972168,
0.23461489379405975,
0.17584392428398132,
0.19885672628879547,
0.48545295000076294,
-0.31609681248664856,
-0.6604211330413818,
-0.9872022271156311,
-0.023194968700408936,
-0.203457772731781,
-0.036057375371456146,
0.12950429320335388,
0.18949054181575775,
-0.2617183029651642,
1.0982779264450073,
0.0715300664305687,
-0.42312824726104736,
-0.29243919253349304,
0.08485817164182663,
-0.012607104144990444,
0.5002325177192688,
0.28346484899520874,
-0.5419073700904846,
-0.37003782391548157,
0.453681617975235,
-0.38003742694854736,
-0.18094949424266815,
0.300059050321579,
0.013361461460590363,
0.46104538440704346,
0.696742832660675,
-0.5460896492004395,
0.3985482156276703,
0.7855066061019897,
-0.4817454218864441,
0.5427805781364441,
-0.3594261109828949,
0.1480531394481659,
-1.308903694152832,
0.054096121340990067,
-0.2235996276140213,
-0.34667521715164185,
-0.4909818172454834,
0.21094897389411926,
0.05032536759972572,
-0.1915479600429535,
-0.30645665526390076,
0.6486124992370605,
-0.4361751079559326,
-0.15404115617275238,
-0.10782821476459503,
0.14859913289546967,
-0.044378675520420074,
-0.09803791344165802,
-0.08489996194839478,
1.0246258974075317,
0.7903503775596619,
-0.3401423394680023,
0.15972359478473663,
0.16547785699367523,
-0.6189011335372925,
0.27527952194213867,
-0.6140680909156799,
-0.06086815893650055,
-0.08110397309064865,
-0.11174482852220535,
-0.7536359429359436,
-0.09698621928691864,
0.10651994496583939,
-0.604124903678894,
0.41145849227905273,
-0.28133121132850647,
-0.7207033634185791,
0.14318083226680756,
-0.21098746359348297,
0.3812764585018158,
0.575821042060852,
-0.46421465277671814,
0.5978801846504211,
0.44837623834609985,
-0.16272775828838348,
-0.7501764297485352,
-0.9222949147224426,
0.273407906293869,
-0.11803101003170013,
-0.697330117225647,
0.5907944440841675,
-0.09184553474187851,
-0.39667853713035583,
-0.09416472166776657,
-0.010776293464004993,
-0.09757357090711594,
-0.03931919112801552,
0.1992156058549881,
-0.17933791875839233,
-0.5048693418502808,
0.15980230271816254,
0.07263820618391037,
-0.19089312851428986,
-0.2661478817462921,
-0.45651766657829285,
0.9807148575782776,
-0.2173682302236557,
-0.1946389526128769,
-0.44296014308929443,
0.30791133642196655,
0.5868408679962158,
-0.5217911601066589,
0.8200471997261047,
0.8289868235588074,
-0.2693924605846405,
-0.4065144956111908,
-0.45536181330680847,
-0.055560123175382614,
-0.4964311718940735,
0.5609726309776306,
-0.33000990748405457,
-1.295385718345642,
0.8277183771133423,
-0.01719958335161209,
-0.022583704441785812,
0.23257847130298615,
0.7075390815734863,
0.10100884735584259,
0.8019752502441406,
0.9343867301940918,
-0.46368736028671265,
0.4899875223636627,
-0.2192450314760208,
0.08232591301202774,
-0.6164531111717224,
-0.18306690454483032,
-0.9449784755706787,
-0.2566070854663849,
-0.6561363339424133,
-0.4278065860271454,
0.05795672535896301,
0.5154097080230713,
0.1234671026468277,
0.13471117615699768,
-0.44714590907096863,
0.37699055671691895,
0.44757983088493347,
0.05400817096233368,
0.26458290219306946,
0.18685118854045868,
-0.3238142728805542,
-0.19644008576869965,
-0.8071190714836121,
-0.6688700318336487,
1.0707061290740967,
0.2845977246761322,
0.8451505899429321,
0.03251216560602188,
0.6263766288757324,
0.15905041992664337,
-0.01586032472550869,
-0.8461567759513855,
0.5175923109054565,
-0.4084727168083191,
-0.5070739984512329,
-0.34751686453819275,
-0.27086809277534485,
-1.1948108673095703,
0.08953959494829178,
-0.37760046124458313,
-0.9074870347976685,
0.1876552253961563,
0.25991368293762207,
-0.15512587130069733,
0.438251256942749,
-0.46565523743629456,
0.6884035468101501,
0.32217341661453247,
-0.6430719494819641,
-0.6342406868934631,
-0.2522652745246887,
0.008835344575345516,
0.055172596126794815,
0.22096535563468933,
-0.028049461543560028,
-0.11044074594974518,
0.4388684928417206,
-0.32724711298942566,
0.9641280770301819,
0.059868574142456055,
-0.2907995283603668,
0.23049066960811615,
0.24239672720432281,
0.17313171923160553,
0.05172976851463318,
-0.3593120872974396,
0.5802305340766907,
0.023480797186493874,
-0.44452956318855286,
-0.28659728169441223,
0.5499704480171204,
-0.7494542002677917,
-0.46091821789741516,
-0.06436756253242493,
-0.5535215139389038,
-0.09870290011167526,
0.07444123178720474,
0.34170660376548767,
0.7108551263809204,
-0.2782500684261322,
0.42737463116645813,
0.6374884843826294,
-0.2024751752614975,
0.31894946098327637,
0.5822979807853699,
-0.3683776557445526,
-0.42423853278160095,
0.7536004781723022,
0.12551841139793396,
0.1900174915790558,
0.574671745300293,
0.06029509752988815,
-0.09562940895557404,
-1.07178795337677,
-0.49724268913269043,
0.12264876812696457,
-0.7330542802810669,
-0.3145170509815216,
-0.34238171577453613,
-0.051240142434835434,
-0.26423144340515137,
-0.21005579829216003,
-0.4370668828487396,
-0.2148219645023346,
-0.6988747119903564,
-0.04883141443133354,
0.44965246319770813,
0.915082573890686,
-0.22074073553085327,
0.4385358989238739,
-0.9328484535217285,
0.19793951511383057,
-0.07541556656360626,
0.6226232647895813,
0.0019497291650623083,
-0.6991084218025208,
-0.660909116268158,
0.09721428155899048,
-0.3575485944747925,
-0.5857086777687073,
0.31611168384552,
0.11672991514205933,
0.31648945808410645,
0.24153414368629456,
-0.3713698089122772,
0.8252352476119995,
-0.7651792168617249,
0.720970094203949,
0.04687615483999252,
-1.0431357622146606,
0.32890763878822327,
-0.41416415572166443,
0.40612930059432983,
0.6603185534477234,
0.2400161176919937,
-0.5577173233032227,
-0.5116159319877625,
-0.473408579826355,
-0.6917659044265747,
0.7063876986503601,
0.05162535607814789,
0.32986176013946533,
-0.035320866852998734,
0.32536783814430237,
0.400043785572052,
0.1375800520181656,
-0.587263822555542,
0.0008630444062873721,
-0.01972895860671997,
-0.6541703343391418,
-0.021739646792411804,
-0.21249014139175415,
0.26568904519081116,
-0.22082598507404327,
0.6819556355476379,
-0.10361376404762268,
0.08843741565942764,
0.10449906438589096,
-0.09833689779043198,
-0.30169594287872314,
0.338273286819458,
0.5725727677345276,
0.7554504871368408,
0.1374523937702179,
-0.009543105028569698,
0.10408586263656616,
-0.8378183841705322,
-0.03467923775315285,
-0.04241356626152992,
-0.17373354732990265,
0.10993042588233948,
0.3986252248287201,
0.625978946685791,
0.0706627368927002,
-0.7745423316955566,
0.15547697246074677,
0.011568852700293064,
-0.07159373164176941,
-0.14258386194705963,
0.16818754374980927,
0.25887584686279297,
0.35681089758872986,
0.2828742265701294,
0.319212943315506,
-0.098255954682827,
-0.6347929239273071,
0.15018247067928314,
0.6799958944320679,
-0.4945942163467407,
-0.6054821610450745,
0.5062989592552185,
0.191942498087883,
-0.6315861940383911,
0.23766107857227325,
-0.14148147404193878,
-0.09963984042406082,
0.511199951171875,
0.555280327796936,
0.6173319220542908,
-0.4400337040424347,
0.32009997963905334,
0.34085381031036377,
0.5048918128013611,
-0.25820451974868774,
0.5029758810997009,
0.04338273033499718,
-1.0067574977874756,
-0.2256501168012619,
-0.7564379572868347,
-0.10189216583967209,
0.3375456631183624,
-0.7360227704048157,
0.610556423664093,
-0.678731381893158,
-0.2956230044364929,
0.020792363211512566,
0.013555129989981651,
-0.6184207201004028,
0.06857937574386597,
-0.005036831833422184,
1.0824981927871704,
-0.5908186435699463,
0.8616666197776794,
0.6980617642402649,
-0.18267957866191864,
-0.3670271635055542,
-0.11562734842300415,
-0.38246244192123413,
-0.7590609192848206,
0.6664825081825256,
0.05772249773144722,
-0.21101640164852142,
0.32126384973526,
-0.5631178617477417,
-0.8317591547966003,
0.8982555866241455,
0.7507526278495789,
-0.9229943752288818,
0.17221002280712128,
0.3553021252155304,
0.7858718037605286,
-0.25162267684936523,
0.09762770682573318,
0.4669587016105652,
0.2827429473400116,
-0.445760577917099,
-0.9669177532196045,
-0.41677504777908325,
-0.13225775957107544,
-0.14181780815124512,
0.4186027944087982,
-0.5626831650733948,
0.5008991360664368,
-0.07339075952768326,
-0.3833998739719391,
0.3056853115558624,
0.7501614093780518,
0.20177879929542542,
-0.00537658017128706,
-0.06796418130397797,
0.5722296833992004,
0.7136958837509155,
-0.06087295338511467,
0.7812594771385193,
-0.44174841046333313,
-0.05183353275060654,
0.8248183131217957,
0.018195094540715218,
1.022630214691162,
0.49515125155448914,
-0.3313024640083313,
0.32815706729888916,
0.4302998483181,
-0.04647853970527649,
0.4630517065525055,
0.33994269371032715,
-0.29687371850013733,
-0.15161322057247162,
-0.2941645085811615,
-0.09379079937934875,
0.5656226873397827,
0.602249264717102,
-0.09554549306631088,
-0.30992692708969116,
0.0344877727329731,
-0.019516825675964355,
0.41951486468315125,
-0.6151395440101624,
0.8348972797393799,
-0.013882957398891449,
-0.32601699233055115,
0.5670404434204102,
0.3297240436077118,
0.8605313897132874,
-0.7133397459983826,
-0.056132491677999496,
-0.3409619629383087,
0.013240654952824116,
-0.2970113754272461,
-0.6985364556312561,
0.29974669218063354,
0.13967648148536682,
-0.41393327713012695,
0.01057623140513897,
0.6750584244728088,
-0.7337069511413574,
-0.5577651858329773,
0.5244677662849426,
0.24535103142261505,
0.23776592314243317,
0.2769363820552826,
-0.5121662020683289,
0.23310787975788116,
0.09694479405879974,
0.2745235860347748,
0.24466769397258759,
0.854953944683075,
-0.061521485447883606,
0.8685715198516846,
0.26875928044319153,
0.5780494213104248,
0.28298890590667725,
0.05605503171682358,
0.6653690338134766,
-0.4729308485984802,
-0.42418965697288513,
-1.0399994850158691,
0.690976619720459,
0.3196748197078705,
-0.5555424094200134,
0.442261278629303,
0.7080368399620056,
1.0594817399978638,
-0.09823828935623169,
0.7908546328544617,
0.10723819583654404,
0.18738509714603424,
-0.8259273767471313,
0.8135140538215637,
-0.455124169588089,
0.007152035366743803,
0.16124321520328522,
-0.6990928053855896,
-0.20042593777179718,
0.47445225715637207,
0.08072107285261154,
-0.003445772221311927,
0.47484803199768066,
0.9562615752220154,
-0.28218162059783936,
-0.1238785982131958,
0.604147732257843,
0.4405704736709595,
0.11294525116682053,
0.1734583079814911,
0.6778167486190796,
-0.3230201005935669,
0.4864588975906372,
-0.050365347415208817,
-0.035835884511470795,
-0.16539733111858368,
-0.7983041405677795,
-1.0333853960037231,
-0.8539911508560181,
-0.061507727950811386,
-0.1617102324962616,
0.10074792057275772,
0.9341045618057251,
0.6646971106529236,
-0.9003006815910339,
-0.39790892601013184,
-0.2600986361503601,
-0.20834922790527344,
0.12174639850854874,
-0.1407342404127121,
0.11971011757850647,
-0.6216104626655579,
-0.7428760528564453,
0.4397200644016266,
0.5541690587997437,
0.19812843203544617,
-0.5001646280288696,
0.07001814246177673,
0.22856979072093964,
-0.01121112797409296,
0.5350500345230103,
0.0507984459400177,
-0.8795142769813538,
-0.2529280185699463,
-0.022444231435656548,
-0.028796078637242317,
0.36071667075157166,
0.6632257103919983,
-0.8497408032417297,
0.5430760979652405,
0.42501744627952576,
0.8127829432487488,
0.291236937046051,
-0.2058926820755005,
0.7148656845092773,
-0.7629968523979187,
0.32145509123802185,
0.26701289415359497,
0.466309130191803,
0.637056291103363,
-0.22447416186332703,
0.20137163996696472,
-0.1473551243543625,
-0.38035985827445984,
-0.79313063621521,
0.4121515452861786,
-0.8435349464416504,
-0.2607618570327759,
1.0093636512756348,
0.003970425575971603,
-0.010341526009142399,
-0.3871192932128906,
-0.30543291568756104,
0.34850555658340454,
-0.4108183681964874,
1.1544549465179443,
1.0715382099151611,
0.5120255947113037,
-0.0648820698261261,
-0.6471523642539978,
0.6898389458656311,
0.5847766995429993,
-0.8107826709747314,
0.4596298336982727,
0.32279470562934875,
0.058987993746995926,
0.2111189216375351,
0.5399764180183411,
-0.24373289942741394,
0.09729546308517456,
-0.008146965876221657,
0.41592705249786377,
-0.06390988081693649,
-0.49937811493873596,
-0.7509607672691345,
-0.061377283185720444,
0.30856066942214966,
0.044724155217409134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09136v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09136v1
|
TLDR at SemEval-2024 Task 2: T5-generated clinical-Language summaries for DeBERTa Report Analysis
| 2024-04-14T04:14:30 | 2024-04-14T04:14:30 |
Spandan Das, Vinay Samuel, Shahriar Noroozizadeh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces novel methodologies for the Natural Language Inference
for Clinical Trials (NLI4CT) task. We present TLDR (T5-generated
clinical-Language summaries for DeBERTa Report Analysis) which incorporates
T5-model generated premise summaries for improved entailment and contradiction
analysis in clinical NLI tasks. This approach overcomes the challenges posed by
small context windows and lengthy premises, leading to a substantial
improvement in Macro F1 scores: a 0.184 increase over truncated premises. Our
comprehensive experimental evaluation, including detailed error analysis and
ablations, confirms the superiority of TLDR in achieving consistency and
faithfulness in predictions against semantically altered inputs.
|
[
0.10584147274494171,
-0.7468663454055786,
0.7283248901367188,
0.5068290829658508,
-0.20211350917816162,
-0.2267025113105774,
0.05940505489706993,
-0.47557392716407776,
0.2472904920578003,
0.6327354907989502,
-0.4749801456928253,
-0.6432494521141052,
-0.6577743887901306,
0.454804927110672,
-0.20437876880168915,
0.9219053387641907,
-0.1767398715019226,
0.14407503604888916,
-0.03821539133787155,
-0.25768446922302246,
-0.6767309904098511,
-0.32664740085601807,
-0.32307636737823486,
-0.27682390809059143,
0.594084620475769,
0.3853708505630493,
0.4425910711288452,
0.2294384241104126,
0.7766560316085815,
0.19737131893634796,
-0.02540157362818718,
0.05163046717643738,
-0.3775041699409485,
-0.02893204800784588,
-0.09978240728378296,
-0.4465966522693634,
-0.7719356417655945,
-0.01479602511972189,
0.308350533246994,
0.8291288614273071,
-0.14868485927581787,
-0.02532998099923134,
-0.04823117330670357,
0.5134477019309998,
-0.6425191164016724,
0.06952355057001114,
-0.4502246677875519,
0.2195669412612915,
-0.04782642051577568,
-0.4311031401157379,
-0.6869684457778931,
-0.5795713067054749,
0.3763115108013153,
-0.5533722639083862,
0.40582892298698425,
-0.07167336344718933,
0.9037385582923889,
0.5133137702941895,
-0.703292965888977,
-0.533366858959198,
-0.6101519465446472,
0.9200140237808228,
-1.2873190641403198,
0.1134854108095169,
0.15307818353176117,
0.3142479658126831,
-0.16121813654899597,
-1.0257775783538818,
-0.4318241775035858,
-0.09975656121969223,
-0.39410120248794556,
0.24601681530475616,
-0.39277181029319763,
0.25351887941360474,
0.34739258885383606,
-0.03134499490261078,
-0.679592490196228,
-0.060879092663526535,
-0.6281368136405945,
-0.1091693714261055,
0.7695604562759399,
0.37498512864112854,
0.4244687855243683,
-0.07506115734577179,
-0.13655193150043488,
0.27964287996292114,
-0.9621238708496094,
-0.19439207017421722,
-0.24919545650482178,
0.14665070176124573,
-0.04921015352010727,
0.6831203103065491,
-0.14976589381694794,
0.6830353140830994,
0.020172614604234695,
-0.21127291023731232,
0.5738092064857483,
-0.6281684041023254,
-0.5229762196540833,
0.3754924237728119,
0.7438339591026306,
0.8365597128868103,
0.0010533409658819437,
-0.3672153949737549,
-0.019908592104911804,
0.1287255436182022,
0.1791958212852478,
-0.9791173934936523,
-0.14248794317245483,
0.6446290612220764,
-0.3496074676513672,
-0.5893083810806274,
-0.2273789495229721,
-0.7780877947807312,
-0.1888614445924759,
-0.1726393848657608,
0.606373131275177,
-0.5412182807922363,
-0.02126418799161911,
0.1847415268421173,
-0.43352192640304565,
0.3226659595966339,
0.5242676138877869,
-0.5618959069252014,
0.39441779255867004,
0.37004780769348145,
0.47648945450782776,
-0.21304486691951752,
-0.20239552855491638,
-0.8305412530899048,
0.3047589361667633,
-0.3097670376300812,
0.6919185519218445,
-0.3737033009529114,
-0.4170061945915222,
-0.06635215878486633,
0.11997990310192108,
-0.3379964232444763,
-0.5917912125587463,
0.7581731081008911,
-0.3763252794742584,
0.5370703935623169,
-0.3720121383666992,
-0.6832777857780457,
-0.20374459028244019,
0.2716588079929352,
-0.586616575717926,
0.6762708425521851,
0.016391918063163757,
-0.8971465826034546,
0.4404621720314026,
-0.7228266000747681,
-0.6442774534225464,
-0.05971720069646835,
-0.12749291956424713,
-0.43515142798423767,
0.09480294585227966,
0.23810438811779022,
0.1155766025185585,
-0.16549153625965118,
0.6089680790901184,
-0.26797133684158325,
-0.07781071215867996,
0.20547574758529663,
-0.18912960588932037,
0.8368685245513916,
0.20625129342079163,
-0.8118837475776672,
0.03379971906542778,
-0.5755280256271362,
0.06908026337623596,
-0.05252707749605179,
-0.023124171420931816,
-0.16613197326660156,
-0.02046758309006691,
0.0502614825963974,
0.13187184929847717,
0.2192142754793167,
-0.7419217824935913,
-0.19929589331150055,
-0.8016839027404785,
0.4121382534503937,
0.1602354347705841,
0.31505411863327026,
0.29604601860046387,
-0.21261511743068695,
0.48289281129837036,
0.05442332848906517,
0.07127578556537628,
0.035339511930942535,
-0.49195483326911926,
-0.6914704442024231,
-0.06734496355056763,
0.516433596611023,
0.5405886173248291,
-0.6554614305496216,
0.26949015259742737,
-0.3236207962036133,
-0.3021775186061859,
-0.3522177040576935,
-0.3624322712421417,
0.5263394117355347,
0.6965469121932983,
0.4783027470111847,
0.12196280807256699,
-0.8838034272193909,
-1.0458372831344604,
-0.23835787177085876,
0.08015744388103485,
-0.061395835131406784,
0.02291746251285076,
0.8780477643013,
-0.2963486909866333,
1.0416538715362549,
-0.5590813159942627,
-0.5168355703353882,
-0.5798041224479675,
0.4246644079685211,
0.19739586114883423,
0.3643708825111389,
0.6760488748550415,
-0.694471538066864,
-0.37067949771881104,
-0.24458079040050507,
-0.920651912689209,
-0.4759003818035126,
-0.0635925903916359,
0.09605596214532852,
0.4332326650619507,
0.4008778929710388,
-0.378336101770401,
0.8185119032859802,
0.2280910611152649,
-0.5082891583442688,
0.25959962606430054,
-0.2673470675945282,
0.3238406181335449,
-1.0709882974624634,
0.19188816845417023,
-0.26629069447517395,
-0.33782556653022766,
-0.7998867630958557,
-0.15182115137577057,
0.028043383732438087,
0.2568703889846802,
-0.29106956720352173,
0.4207279682159424,
-0.1838899701833725,
0.07488804310560226,
-0.1925843060016632,
0.20772148668766022,
0.26364362239837646,
0.2324080616235733,
0.02072860486805439,
0.698392391204834,
-0.00873178243637085,
-0.4704352021217346,
-0.14026916027069092,
0.47322604060173035,
0.15195874869823456,
-0.02500031888484955,
-1.2360095977783203,
-0.16702739894390106,
-0.13792291283607483,
0.27258536219596863,
-1.1125837564468384,
-0.4227554500102997,
-0.036937613040208817,
-0.5306191444396973,
0.14975300431251526,
0.3481283485889435,
-0.25658750534057617,
-0.18682532012462616,
-0.4455193281173706,
0.22336345911026,
0.5728134512901306,
-0.1807965338230133,
0.7605350017547607,
0.40564683079719543,
-0.16769586503505707,
-0.4604502022266388,
-0.9726355671882629,
0.18827170133590698,
-0.26064667105674744,
-0.4712259769439697,
0.5394172668457031,
0.1064511239528656,
-0.4976626932621002,
0.14957723021507263,
0.13936324417591095,
-0.21596361696720123,
-0.03350057452917099,
0.05047977715730667,
0.16757076978683472,
-0.3432866334915161,
-0.09569673240184784,
0.22393561899662018,
0.1367751955986023,
0.34310534596443176,
0.26229938864707947,
0.11844802647829056,
-0.0796656385064125,
-0.22816984355449677,
-0.36676010489463806,
0.4109398424625397,
0.4392932951450348,
-0.19868551194667816,
0.513079822063446,
0.25037920475006104,
-0.42794933915138245,
-0.05916845425963402,
-0.42502883076667786,
-0.019997889176011086,
-0.38756051659584045,
0.046776317059993744,
-0.2927757799625397,
-0.8424218893051147,
0.28135403990745544,
0.16953015327453613,
0.23282529413700104,
0.7418022751808167,
0.6417821645736694,
-0.0796142965555191,
0.9269244074821472,
0.325786292552948,
0.4006887972354889,
-0.08460657298564911,
-0.18555590510368347,
0.34896206855773926,
-0.6926171183586121,
-0.15157949924468994,
-0.3536115884780884,
-0.011909516528248787,
-0.38878560066223145,
-0.48346295952796936,
0.7966334223747253,
-0.13912484049797058,
-0.11018301546573639,
0.20806695520877838,
-0.26240020990371704,
0.35625025629997253,
0.2504029870033264,
0.09913376718759537,
0.35286131501197815,
-0.17237749695777893,
-0.06615983694791794,
-0.4455242455005646,
-0.522049069404602,
-0.5743499994277954,
1.2138667106628418,
0.24686306715011597,
0.2977522909641266,
0.564834475517273,
0.7558180689811707,
0.39006659388542175,
0.4185689687728882,
-0.49793297052383423,
0.3745270073413849,
-0.14622598886489868,
-0.639498770236969,
-0.1871296763420105,
-0.08214589953422546,
-0.8863511085510254,
0.2898138165473938,
0.06991514563560486,
-0.6730604767799377,
0.021607208997011185,
0.023600071668624878,
-0.5356889963150024,
-0.31267979741096497,
-0.7811408638954163,
0.9701657891273499,
-0.03828858584165573,
-0.2978482246398926,
-0.15339486300945282,
-0.9934834241867065,
0.4826553165912628,
-0.08015275746583939,
0.014653699472546577,
-0.0628248080611229,
-0.055205073207616806,
0.5919837951660156,
-0.6698046326637268,
1.0349723100662231,
-0.2956334948539734,
-0.1907450407743454,
0.32887324690818787,
-0.026762917637825012,
0.497060090303421,
0.12425915896892548,
-0.3329697847366333,
-0.23270748555660248,
0.24992789328098297,
-0.34764450788497925,
-0.7033942341804504,
0.31736645102500916,
-0.42912811040878296,
-0.4350213408470154,
-0.5892820954322815,
-0.3792058825492859,
-0.2141638696193695,
0.299638569355011,
0.37638962268829346,
0.9323676824569702,
-0.6527611017227173,
0.07323426753282547,
0.5633999705314636,
-0.43675512075424194,
0.2647835314273834,
0.6428869366645813,
0.10574901103973389,
-0.47976747155189514,
0.49920853972435,
-0.19572246074676514,
0.31789395213127136,
0.6050269603729248,
0.16903755068778992,
-0.5475560426712036,
-0.7445056438446045,
-0.23873114585876465,
0.29265233874320984,
-0.6958231925964355,
-0.1166536957025528,
-0.8658899068832397,
-0.18751807510852814,
-0.7450920343399048,
-0.1039649099111557,
-0.09899725764989853,
-0.6325777769088745,
-0.32283276319503784,
-0.13522976636886597,
0.10218694061040878,
0.8065465688705444,
0.16500996053218842,
0.14427773654460907,
-0.850283682346344,
0.26153141260147095,
-0.20494385063648224,
-0.32573747634887695,
-0.294753760099411,
-0.690097451210022,
0.1256181299686432,
0.011240331456065178,
-0.4809119701385498,
-0.7261562943458557,
0.6826733946800232,
0.4144114553928375,
0.3910800814628601,
0.2249358594417572,
0.2864687740802765,
0.8157145977020264,
-0.8776453137397766,
0.8155128359794617,
0.22236192226409912,
-0.8991544842720032,
0.8939199447631836,
-0.3986177444458008,
0.20732411742210388,
0.63503098487854,
0.140011265873909,
-0.1345750391483307,
-0.7072291970252991,
-0.7669395804405212,
-0.8371939063072205,
0.5859980583190918,
0.6226503849029541,
-0.2631748914718628,
0.0007203287677839398,
0.05705250799655914,
0.1740126609802246,
0.16390177607536316,
-0.45993420481681824,
0.03053920529782772,
-0.05485338345170021,
-0.6444538235664368,
-0.027324125170707703,
-0.4762604832649231,
-0.4066249132156372,
-0.26023831963539124,
0.5292646288871765,
-0.28292086720466614,
0.29800814390182495,
0.6694173216819763,
-0.18590326607227325,
0.12263661623001099,
0.48284804821014404,
0.9517509937286377,
1.1276723146438599,
-0.526018500328064,
0.1571396291255951,
0.6444974541664124,
-0.23269686102867126,
-0.06484799087047577,
0.11505194753408432,
-0.12699958682060242,
0.26620253920555115,
0.9194626808166504,
0.8304118514060974,
0.24089446663856506,
-0.9351144433021545,
0.8286389708518982,
-0.22244802117347717,
-0.5691356062889099,
-0.7896260023117065,
-0.03431124612689018,
0.00006410880450857803,
0.15491168200969696,
0.06511423736810684,
-0.11339791864156723,
0.7240880131721497,
-0.28773921728134155,
0.48025891184806824,
0.06313920021057129,
-0.3825097680091858,
-0.5400049090385437,
0.9522058367729187,
0.24836614727973938,
0.2847210764884949,
0.2719665467739105,
-0.15350495278835297,
-0.364298939704895,
0.7631106972694397,
0.6944788694381714,
0.8549246788024902,
0.09868388622999191,
0.20289014279842377,
0.6041964292526245,
0.2014249563217163,
0.10242407768964767,
0.562033474445343,
0.4310466945171356,
-0.6157099008560181,
-0.5235102772712708,
-0.43864935636520386,
-0.4177164137363434,
0.08023630082607269,
-0.5726805329322815,
0.20070315897464752,
-0.14626094698905945,
0.15948332846164703,
0.3113764822483063,
-0.2588430345058441,
-0.2275635302066803,
0.37496787309646606,
0.011548434384167194,
0.8521202206611633,
-0.6322595477104187,
0.7793514728546143,
0.5229251980781555,
-0.4765063226222992,
-0.9183792471885681,
0.04241083934903145,
0.11185625195503235,
-0.40984487533569336,
0.9765743017196655,
0.11151230335235596,
-0.23883333802223206,
-0.20526859164237976,
-0.4452342391014099,
-0.6622235774993896,
1.3196284770965576,
0.1737862229347229,
-0.2787996828556061,
-0.2318849116563797,
0.39872169494628906,
0.770836353302002,
-0.500886082649231,
0.45755884051322937,
0.816537082195282,
0.3282844126224518,
0.36381128430366516,
-0.9528351426124573,
0.34635868668556213,
-0.10329121351242065,
-0.09581407159566879,
0.05758205056190491,
-0.32407069206237793,
0.541775643825531,
-0.4824616312980652,
-0.07530046254396439,
0.24937251210212708,
0.6193081736564636,
0.38367190957069397,
0.6505959033966064,
0.34922048449516296,
0.5473628640174866,
0.6973012685775757,
-0.09621629863977432,
1.0260545015335083,
-0.06547500193119049,
0.3904166519641876,
1.2535405158996582,
-0.7308421730995178,
0.7071565389633179,
0.6087499856948853,
-0.13260877132415771,
0.4186706244945526,
0.45810872316360474,
0.12623977661132812,
0.7796913981437683,
-0.0773678794503212,
-0.2691534757614136,
0.008783850818872452,
-0.20397087931632996,
-0.21018899977207184,
0.32183319330215454,
0.4407353103160858,
-0.36381372809410095,
-0.4480883479118347,
-0.07179958373308182,
0.13309477269649506,
-0.11459203064441681,
0.21056252717971802,
0.8281679153442383,
0.1465974897146225,
-0.9949826002120972,
0.7362328171730042,
-0.04918074980378151,
0.22422130405902863,
-0.42657482624053955,
-0.2372656911611557,
-0.1467319130897522,
0.5671157240867615,
-0.16277074813842773,
-0.5928976535797119,
0.6409285664558411,
0.17414630949497223,
0.051048602908849716,
0.008498112671077251,
0.7127798795700073,
-0.4241649806499481,
-0.5622363090515137,
0.22024473547935486,
0.3453461527824402,
0.04989437758922577,
0.35145077109336853,
-0.48321595788002014,
-0.24981234967708588,
0.25945815443992615,
-0.18611527979373932,
-0.11122023314237595,
0.703275740146637,
-0.13528306782245636,
0.41864317655563354,
0.1884499192237854,
-0.05942058190703392,
-0.09561015665531158,
0.3520674705505371,
0.8633735179901123,
-0.6849714517593384,
-0.3271080255508423,
-0.9108520746231079,
0.4612428843975067,
-0.26373276114463806,
-0.4107780158519745,
0.7019193172454834,
0.7622876763343811,
0.17349746823310852,
-0.21237677335739136,
0.8600220084190369,
-0.4577707350254059,
0.7920067310333252,
-0.6566987633705139,
0.4535982012748718,
-0.7087141275405884,
0.11620648950338364,
-0.1424064338207245,
-0.20399481058120728,
-0.555618166923523,
0.12366622686386108,
-0.4719168543815613,
-0.40462106466293335,
1.113631010055542,
0.7093248963356018,
-0.005314301233738661,
0.26938021183013916,
0.10776174068450928,
0.4001992344856262,
0.5357589721679688,
0.7619488835334778,
0.5638468265533447,
-0.8204124569892883,
0.3233080804347992,
-0.00596061022952199,
-0.06416558474302292,
-0.2953417897224426,
-0.7942562699317932,
-1.051184892654419,
-0.21453867852687836,
-0.29908251762390137,
-0.4932285249233246,
0.09300337731838226,
0.8313512206077576,
0.16907751560211182,
-1.2278770208358765,
0.0936698243021965,
-0.37222686409950256,
-0.13494367897510529,
-0.019463391974568367,
-0.24328787624835968,
0.45398667454719543,
-0.639478325843811,
-0.7576122879981995,
0.34799253940582275,
0.15474523603916168,
-0.05787809193134308,
0.19477418065071106,
-0.2020876705646515,
-0.19862155616283417,
-0.10951726138591766,
0.6248188018798828,
-0.08844489604234695,
-0.8919281363487244,
-0.21537019312381744,
0.07258424907922745,
-0.2929213047027588,
0.05367251858115196,
0.6863549947738647,
-0.6903515458106995,
0.20812849700450897,
0.6059467792510986,
0.6054998636245728,
0.5252952575683594,
0.06198928877711296,
1.0939363241195679,
-0.6122201681137085,
0.1862330287694931,
0.46779531240463257,
0.29279035329818726,
0.16858750581741333,
-0.19419938325881958,
0.9187451601028442,
0.19250649213790894,
-0.3717799782752991,
-0.7706682682037354,
0.037747327238321304,
-1.0266610383987427,
-0.28891927003860474,
1.2190724611282349,
-0.14832235872745514,
-0.4441607594490051,
-0.2882903516292572,
-0.22558072209358215,
0.2708536684513092,
-0.14669647812843323,
0.5235552191734314,
0.4733525216579437,
-0.2465314120054245,
0.03579379990696907,
-0.9795368909835815,
0.7395134568214417,
0.6543391942977905,
-0.9872385859489441,
-0.17384983599185944,
0.5468390583992004,
0.39139828085899353,
0.029691459611058235,
0.9572944641113281,
-0.3271257281303406,
0.3275124728679657,
-0.2100892961025238,
-0.14789871871471405,
0.30511409044265747,
-0.07610789686441422,
-0.15933287143707275,
0.08591406047344208,
0.00009450020297663286,
-0.1268123835325241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09135v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09135v1
|
Unveiling LLM Evaluation Focused on Metrics: Challenges and Solutions
| 2024-04-14T03:54:00 | 2024-04-14T03:54:00 |
Taojun Hu, Xiao-Hua Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural Language Processing (NLP) is witnessing a remarkable breakthrough
driven by the success of Large Language Models (LLMs). LLMs have gained
significant attention across academia and industry for their versatile
applications in text generation, question answering, and text summarization. As
the landscape of NLP evolves with an increasing number of domain-specific LLMs
employing diverse techniques and trained on various corpus, evaluating
performance of these models becomes paramount. To quantify the performance,
it's crucial to have a comprehensive grasp of existing metrics. Among the
evaluation, metrics which quantifying the performance of LLMs play a pivotal
role. This paper offers a comprehensive exploration of LLM evaluation from a
metrics perspective, providing insights into the selection and interpretation
of metrics currently in use. Our main goal is to elucidate their mathematical
formulations and statistical interpretations. We shed light on the application
of these metrics using recent Biomedical LLMs. Additionally, we offer a
succinct comparison of these metrics, aiding researchers in selecting
appropriate metrics for diverse tasks. The overarching goal is to furnish
researchers with a pragmatic guide for effective LLM evaluation and metric
selection, thereby advancing the understanding and application of these large
language models.
|
[
-0.24675363302230835,
-0.7141522169113159,
0.7187320590019226,
0.3597940504550934,
-0.17848674952983856,
0.4112188220024109,
-0.35606637597084045,
-0.5821505188941956,
0.023673107847571373,
0.34715744853019714,
-0.45550358295440674,
-0.6852396130561829,
-0.8129591345787048,
0.4667380750179291,
-0.2959270477294922,
1.1356099843978882,
0.12379684299230576,
0.3735693395137787,
-0.780426025390625,
-0.22364068031311035,
-0.44080209732055664,
-0.47717195749282837,
-0.6606988906860352,
-0.6620745062828064,
0.5227743983268738,
-0.016103234142065048,
0.4772702753543854,
0.503537118434906,
1.121061086654663,
0.29303470253944397,
-0.48105451464653015,
0.21052959561347961,
-0.39371514320373535,
0.15723244845867157,
-0.10581718385219574,
-0.4880681335926056,
-0.5162110328674316,
-0.08034972846508026,
0.9426536560058594,
1.2120634317398071,
0.12886787950992584,
0.48223423957824707,
0.2352318912744522,
0.8255811929702759,
-0.5069639086723328,
0.0070520322769880295,
-0.569923996925354,
0.2639942169189453,
-0.2891460955142975,
-0.387032687664032,
-0.1398332417011261,
-0.3964444696903229,
0.1738508641719818,
-0.2949775755405426,
0.021192198619246483,
-0.01685037463903427,
0.44418424367904663,
0.43395230174064636,
-0.22302119433879852,
-0.4050725996494293,
-0.6408023834228516,
0.9309483170509338,
-0.8464044332504272,
0.46715080738067627,
0.06467356532812119,
0.25867608189582825,
-0.2925596535205841,
-0.7621590495109558,
-0.15723153948783875,
-0.3612222671508789,
0.05426843836903572,
0.006195658352226019,
-0.32385948300361633,
0.035312674939632416,
0.12331858277320862,
0.6962755918502808,
-0.6968770027160645,
0.49425703287124634,
-0.2600899040699005,
-0.18764381110668182,
0.5167611241340637,
0.49397170543670654,
0.20532898604869843,
-0.14207586646080017,
-0.32840943336486816,
0.23871347308158875,
-0.5093104243278503,
-0.1639559268951416,
0.0945592001080513,
0.12468643486499786,
-0.05865044146776199,
0.6686944961547852,
-0.11653123050928116,
0.5998210310935974,
-0.37978595495224,
-0.26214051246643066,
0.37157344818115234,
-0.6120976209640503,
-0.21008194983005524,
-0.3849635124206543,
0.9506627917289734,
0.3331174850463867,
0.24245339632034302,
-0.3797875940799713,
-0.22280696034431458,
-0.03462119400501251,
0.36695611476898193,
-0.7075942158699036,
0.2837734520435333,
0.31369298696517944,
-0.5513606667518616,
-0.17285796999931335,
-0.4753977358341217,
-0.8389406204223633,
-0.3927364647388458,
-0.2244672179222107,
0.1448931097984314,
-0.4475366771221161,
-0.025419073179364204,
0.38828474283218384,
-0.19007065892219543,
0.17486833035945892,
0.1472829133272171,
-0.7019707560539246,
0.6130020618438721,
1.025063157081604,
1.1236709356307983,
-0.5905836820602417,
-0.06000806391239166,
-0.2801111042499542,
-0.21194414794445038,
-0.3079545497894287,
0.8361907005310059,
-0.3089625835418701,
-0.5088904500007629,
0.035523537546396255,
-0.42933350801467896,
-0.10534501075744629,
-0.8310288786888123,
0.8340088725090027,
-0.3336838483810425,
-0.09165745973587036,
-0.05190757289528847,
-0.8091503381729126,
0.007064858451485634,
0.395425945520401,
-0.5392801761627197,
1.0158149003982544,
-0.01817719265818596,
-0.7962837219238281,
0.40839794278144836,
-0.8707541227340698,
-0.3013584017753601,
0.2974819839000702,
0.020482799038290977,
-0.4156970977783203,
0.478926420211792,
0.04723326489329338,
0.6082457900047302,
-0.6014947295188904,
0.14041393995285034,
-0.267711877822876,
-0.22812902927398682,
0.5355389714241028,
-0.24856935441493988,
0.5618106126785278,
0.11940344423055649,
0.048805754631757736,
0.1890629082918167,
-0.7484590411186218,
0.12236114591360092,
0.006478203926235437,
-0.35030409693717957,
-0.1481725424528122,
0.11488236486911774,
-0.13721655309200287,
-0.12177180498838425,
0.3933326303958893,
-0.4616677761077881,
-0.16063599288463593,
-0.6414691209793091,
0.29887691140174866,
0.42036402225494385,
0.14104793965816498,
0.37695032358169556,
-0.27643027901649475,
0.6725803017616272,
-0.45956993103027344,
0.21556207537651062,
0.129326730966568,
-0.46963605284690857,
-0.3759453296661377,
-0.43019112944602966,
0.3442864716053009,
0.5344310402870178,
-0.17206379771232605,
0.4129759669303894,
-0.26995062828063965,
-0.7723656892776489,
-0.8190162777900696,
0.3633103668689728,
0.36203163862228394,
0.4653695821762085,
0.3845314383506775,
-0.3722301125526428,
-0.49427926540374756,
-1.024110198020935,
-0.5671476125717163,
-0.19271744787693024,
-0.27819761633872986,
0.21069113910198212,
0.5184783935546875,
-0.2670283913612366,
0.9581998586654663,
-0.4663287103176117,
-0.2750711143016815,
-0.5441983342170715,
0.10011695325374603,
0.3585841655731201,
0.1858057826757431,
0.43958428502082825,
-0.3804422914981842,
-0.08204951882362366,
-0.04135117679834366,
-0.7008970379829407,
-0.5103732347488403,
-0.03205259516835213,
0.012493617832660675,
-0.14396174252033234,
0.4793509542942047,
-0.4430176913738251,
0.1633855402469635,
0.577983021736145,
-0.1959414780139923,
0.9147650599479675,
-0.1759694218635559,
-0.07217801362276077,
-0.6181285381317139,
0.23601941764354706,
0.2627960443496704,
-0.33941173553466797,
-0.49259915947914124,
0.18879219889640808,
-0.19208383560180664,
0.33387163281440735,
-0.3657490909099579,
0.6482288837432861,
-0.31848105788230896,
-0.3683217763900757,
-0.19071143865585327,
0.3748217821121216,
-0.028860509395599365,
0.07244443893432617,
-0.21865791082382202,
0.6074271202087402,
0.44733214378356934,
-0.6296073198318481,
0.3094053864479065,
0.23510168492794037,
-0.4831055700778961,
0.46608272194862366,
-0.8380278944969177,
-0.05441492050886154,
0.003259792225435376,
0.08411910384893417,
-0.833575427532196,
0.31065139174461365,
0.06206335872411728,
-0.6057497262954712,
0.20604610443115234,
0.18384549021720886,
-0.7113227844238281,
-0.3977195620536804,
-0.3662030100822449,
0.345995157957077,
0.3851158320903778,
-0.157310351729393,
0.18385837972164154,
0.6609545946121216,
-0.21001183986663818,
-0.5251432657241821,
-0.47421032190322876,
0.2942029535770416,
-0.41747161746025085,
-0.39133939146995544,
0.3458339273929596,
-0.2202332466840744,
-0.5351486802101135,
-0.2186269462108612,
-0.12348052114248276,
0.17254887521266937,
0.44720304012298584,
0.014210060238838196,
0.21999244391918182,
-0.20651832222938538,
0.1976008266210556,
-0.14596466720104218,
-0.3002817630767822,
0.4333052337169647,
-0.09457232803106308,
0.3939072787761688,
-0.261272668838501,
-0.3502691388130188,
-0.37888360023498535,
0.14447051286697388,
0.28472432494163513,
-0.36443376541137695,
0.6326988935470581,
0.7082696557044983,
-0.40846532583236694,
-0.04176504164934158,
-0.527287483215332,
-0.03273472189903259,
-0.3782658874988556,
0.8437320590019226,
-0.05211515724658966,
-0.8500316143035889,
0.5955003499984741,
-0.36740872263908386,
0.14845961332321167,
0.5436850190162659,
0.8620476126670837,
-0.05794934928417206,
0.9322439432144165,
0.6346651911735535,
0.06382710486650467,
0.2878146171569824,
-0.11573394387960434,
0.34473174810409546,
-1.0490118265151978,
-0.4302801489830017,
-0.6923375129699707,
-0.24686044454574585,
-0.5987985730171204,
-0.615724503993988,
0.489981085062027,
0.11082640290260315,
0.07697020471096039,
0.005977208726108074,
-0.3112422823905945,
0.3518299460411072,
0.09629375487565994,
-0.24731183052062988,
0.49198219180107117,
-0.15572401881217957,
-0.2277965545654297,
-0.21575358510017395,
-0.5945209860801697,
-0.9210397005081177,
1.1631540060043335,
0.7458389401435852,
0.4849436581134796,
-0.010246194899082184,
0.554885983467102,
0.2914067506790161,
0.36768168210983276,
-1.1196578741073608,
0.6897830963134766,
-0.2621874213218689,
-0.415758341550827,
-0.26819199323654175,
-0.5274718999862671,
-0.9771027565002441,
0.35397690534591675,
-0.3908431828022003,
-0.9185933470726013,
-0.4486163258552551,
-0.2761289179325104,
-0.32465094327926636,
0.2788192331790924,
-0.34517619013786316,
0.8925650715827942,
-0.43598610162734985,
-0.17769385874271393,
-0.35494762659072876,
-0.4576270878314972,
0.2745564579963684,
-0.2378288209438324,
0.2040020078420639,
-0.41349661350250244,
-0.43726322054862976,
0.8683825731277466,
-0.040299076586961746,
0.5854327082633972,
0.19606463611125946,
-0.16181674599647522,
0.004357409197837114,
0.007375710178166628,
-0.2351275086402893,
0.2199624925851822,
-0.22513334453105927,
0.6440696716308594,
0.32308605313301086,
-0.2073558121919632,
-0.43428927659988403,
0.6012312769889832,
-0.49788376688957214,
-0.3422326445579529,
-0.3198792636394501,
-0.5158170461654663,
-0.47722506523132324,
0.03303008899092674,
0.0948520079255104,
0.1931658387184143,
-0.5305818319320679,
0.14524127542972565,
0.48489606380462646,
-0.6330591440200806,
0.43905067443847656,
0.44464126229286194,
-0.39723435044288635,
-0.2703026235103607,
0.5718757510185242,
-0.15935584902763367,
0.3420102596282959,
0.5774661898612976,
0.22728225588798523,
-0.5710716247558594,
-1.0496257543563843,
-0.2935185134410858,
0.4592840075492859,
-0.560426652431488,
-0.2333211600780487,
-0.7230175733566284,
-0.16617795825004578,
-0.18922202289104462,
0.07198555767536163,
-0.3262692093849182,
-0.3971143364906311,
-0.29552924633026123,
-0.08766689896583557,
0.12404213100671768,
0.8149498105049133,
-0.10458099842071533,
0.14159083366394043,
-0.8476377129554749,
0.34448477625846863,
-0.12450969964265823,
0.5605149865150452,
-0.04650075361132622,
-0.5429325699806213,
-0.36505264043807983,
-0.15856291353702545,
-0.2743457853794098,
-0.7459971904754639,
0.4814240038394928,
0.27570319175720215,
0.7946611642837524,
0.01990518718957901,
-0.3381228446960449,
0.43899425864219666,
-0.6037752032279968,
0.6882296800613403,
0.20479276776313782,
-0.7528660297393799,
0.43591493368148804,
-0.0913240909576416,
0.2995132505893707,
0.5390052199363708,
0.3065519332885742,
-0.6248897314071655,
-0.6482303738594055,
-0.3693220913410187,
-1.0611127614974976,
0.18940584361553192,
0.23439444601535797,
0.018461449071764946,
-0.024615634232759476,
0.38971585035324097,
0.2220371514558792,
0.13470308482646942,
-0.5748878717422485,
-0.26079586148262024,
0.522906482219696,
-0.23625703155994415,
-0.21527191996574402,
-0.21259187161922455,
-0.09152648597955704,
-0.1193762719631195,
0.4384746551513672,
-0.06317894905805588,
0.13217835128307343,
0.03896908462047577,
-0.23855659365653992,
0.17091186344623566,
0.35198795795440674,
0.44901660084724426,
0.8366478085517883,
-0.3321729004383087,
-0.25127291679382324,
0.3318825364112854,
-0.47472211718559265,
-0.24071115255355835,
-0.08462147414684296,
0.18035386502742767,
0.24081052839756012,
0.6437147259712219,
0.5362495183944702,
0.2508609890937805,
-0.9415294528007507,
0.38758763670921326,
-0.1655680239200592,
-0.04145760089159012,
-0.2236092984676361,
-0.017797846347093582,
0.22347183525562286,
0.14244888722896576,
0.4233051538467407,
-0.04713009297847748,
0.29362753033638,
-0.2611364722251892,
0.2172686755657196,
0.6115354299545288,
-0.3389952778816223,
-0.16037681698799133,
0.494270384311676,
0.09882717579603195,
-0.44625815749168396,
0.3032131493091583,
-0.033174555748701096,
-0.3318609595298767,
0.6794649362564087,
0.506158173084259,
0.9628323912620544,
0.09908747673034668,
0.22657783329486847,
0.34802761673927307,
0.28259485960006714,
0.216262549161911,
0.006123194936662912,
0.20479342341423035,
-0.6874358654022217,
-0.7603863477706909,
-1.1906062364578247,
-0.4929834008216858,
0.16022123396396637,
-0.7365966439247131,
0.0902518555521965,
-0.46589916944503784,
-0.43642768263816833,
0.21418088674545288,
0.31538379192352295,
-0.8321654796600342,
0.1413598656654358,
0.28796082735061646,
0.9713674783706665,
-0.5952141284942627,
0.29903149604797363,
0.6587134599685669,
-0.07363899797201157,
-0.17522452771663666,
-0.17901214957237244,
0.06716298311948776,
-0.8006599545478821,
0.6045519709587097,
0.02106144092977047,
-0.15668684244155884,
-0.16380855441093445,
-0.1329948455095291,
-0.6145601868629456,
0.7712078094482422,
0.30402427911758423,
-0.4929759204387665,
0.11005372554063797,
0.3774513900279999,
1.0370572805404663,
-0.4292196035385132,
0.4738723933696747,
0.9627137184143066,
0.2762468457221985,
-0.2019752413034439,
-1.0722308158874512,
-0.13386176526546478,
-0.11955953389406204,
0.014389109797775745,
0.10945045202970505,
-0.31562161445617676,
0.304903119802475,
-0.3123573064804077,
-0.06015549227595329,
0.1888127475976944,
0.5093404650688171,
0.4043183922767639,
0.3738788366317749,
0.2024567425251007,
0.4081917405128479,
0.7717025279998779,
-0.03563481196761131,
1.1001237630844116,
-0.3061525821685791,
0.3095559775829315,
0.7450981736183167,
-0.1939925104379654,
0.9415727257728577,
0.5398908853530884,
-0.7375645637512207,
0.20389001071453094,
0.6974732279777527,
0.048096489161252975,
0.07713280618190765,
0.6030490398406982,
-0.3116038143634796,
-0.06561273336410522,
-0.3040969669818878,
-0.24782168865203857,
0.5998557806015015,
0.5986976623535156,
-0.2717505097389221,
-0.2851649820804596,
-0.2043498009443283,
-0.14254887402057648,
0.18393611907958984,
-0.41040730476379395,
0.8763396143913269,
0.32007303833961487,
-0.3584098219871521,
0.3961094319820404,
0.2209295630455017,
0.7484975457191467,
-0.6929437518119812,
0.14358964562416077,
-0.15164516866207123,
0.07654809206724167,
-0.29596030712127686,
-0.820921778678894,
0.5781723856925964,
0.35273468494415283,
-0.1280810832977295,
-0.2970709800720215,
0.5176582336425781,
-0.06559912860393524,
-0.5905447006225586,
0.5659270286560059,
0.8464167714118958,
0.32895398139953613,
0.09202594310045242,
-0.8177517652511597,
-0.006538864690810442,
-0.1881493180990219,
-0.1768893003463745,
0.419704407453537,
0.36413928866386414,
0.20546989142894745,
0.9479693174362183,
0.5994480848312378,
0.598346471786499,
-0.14637744426727295,
0.2888951897621155,
0.46924495697021484,
-0.7035462856292725,
-0.24371731281280518,
-1.2193830013275146,
0.3411424458026886,
0.008334445767104626,
-0.3683456480503082,
0.6635635495185852,
0.6615654826164246,
0.6303932070732117,
0.1630164384841919,
0.6113154888153076,
0.3289206027984619,
0.7737028002738953,
-0.569591224193573,
0.6791910529136658,
-0.6332864165306091,
0.5703364610671997,
-0.32592231035232544,
-0.9426398277282715,
-0.5999975800514221,
0.4837065041065216,
-0.396283894777298,
-0.04594436660408974,
0.7357972264289856,
0.45172369480133057,
0.4246782660484314,
-0.15192298591136932,
0.3093434274196625,
0.037419240921735764,
0.30327314138412476,
0.49340730905532837,
0.9225402474403381,
-0.1408289670944214,
0.37871068716049194,
0.02248474769294262,
-0.12991784512996674,
-0.1587279886007309,
-1.08742356300354,
-0.5902737379074097,
-0.32070571184158325,
-0.33040907979011536,
-0.023240411654114723,
-0.09882791340351105,
0.6827659606933594,
0.33462458848953247,
-0.6475062370300293,
-0.4529147148132324,
0.23544006049633026,
0.29902228713035583,
-0.1303662806749344,
-0.22596628963947296,
0.20279277861118317,
-0.5407019853591919,
-0.6934259533882141,
0.29903292655944824,
0.6684038639068604,
-0.10081662982702255,
-0.423530250787735,
-0.018269211053848267,
-0.13156771659851074,
0.14413881301879883,
0.6722944974899292,
0.10390601307153702,
-0.6020408868789673,
0.14202730357646942,
-0.09346798062324524,
-0.23164846003055573,
0.17126570641994476,
0.7935263514518738,
-0.7678491473197937,
0.11741908639669418,
0.4827457070350647,
0.9785338044166565,
0.21686923503875732,
-0.22597263753414154,
0.7058181762695312,
-0.6501109600067139,
-0.22405417263507843,
0.6143617630004883,
0.33990833163261414,
0.6217713356018066,
-0.14472238719463348,
0.7716875076293945,
0.03361278027296066,
-0.6530203819274902,
-1.0847854614257812,
0.08368407934904099,
-0.8325186967849731,
-0.1892550140619278,
1.1328179836273193,
0.021299486979842186,
-0.0392397977411747,
-0.07570711523294449,
0.04145057871937752,
0.2109891176223755,
0.03626376762986183,
0.6887999773025513,
0.699090301990509,
-0.3179943859577179,
0.13162998855113983,
-1.0361820459365845,
0.5357605814933777,
0.7450504302978516,
-0.8604710102081299,
-0.09186167269945145,
0.30616503953933716,
0.20121406018733978,
0.12005086988210678,
0.6431364417076111,
-0.3527643382549286,
-0.10619645565748215,
-0.3661346137523651,
-0.06321369111537933,
0.3346550762653351,
0.004664888605475426,
-0.574265718460083,
0.09020527452230453,
0.2114543318748474,
-0.07302246987819672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09129v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09129v1
|
When Hindsight is Not 20/20: Testing Limits on Reflective Thinking in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-14T02:47:32 | 2024-04-14T02:47:32 |
Yanhong Li, Chenghao Yang, Allyson Ettinger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent studies suggest that self-reflective prompting can significantly
enhance the reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs). However,
the use of external feedback as a stop criterion raises doubts about the true
extent of LLMs' ability to emulate human-like self-reflection. In this paper,
we set out to clarify these capabilities under a more stringent evaluation
setting in which we disallow any kind of external feedback. Our findings under
this setting show a split: while self-reflection enhances performance in
TruthfulQA, it adversely affects results in HotpotQA. We conduct follow-up
analyses to clarify the contributing factors in these patterns, and find that
the influence of self-reflection is impacted both by reliability of accuracy in
models' initial responses, and by overall question difficulty: specifically,
self-reflection shows the most benefit when models are less likely to be
correct initially, and when overall question difficulty is higher. We also find
that self-reflection reduces tendency toward majority voting. Based on our
findings, we propose guidelines for decisions on when to implement
self-reflection. We release the codebase for reproducing our experiments at
https://github.com/yanhong-lbh/LLM-SelfReflection-Eval.
|
[
-0.5341988205909729,
-0.675826370716095,
0.8309010863304138,
0.7554932236671448,
-0.07431886345148087,
-0.2213183343410492,
-0.48561426997184753,
-0.4454651176929474,
-0.10040681064128876,
0.8112054467201233,
-0.45375093817710876,
-0.10897164046764374,
-0.4806123375892639,
0.4074436128139496,
-0.4187766909599304,
1.0071918964385986,
0.00034299460821785033,
0.21573258936405182,
-0.24429477751255035,
-0.20715045928955078,
-0.56141197681427,
-0.3413354158401489,
-0.2796856164932251,
-0.20527160167694092,
0.6421279311180115,
0.5789349675178528,
0.446308434009552,
0.2698858678340912,
0.43594181537628174,
0.32731011509895325,
0.230472132563591,
-0.014931823126971722,
-0.33953696489334106,
0.32824862003326416,
-0.33256980776786804,
-0.41588252782821655,
-0.15549619495868683,
0.2568821310997009,
0.7499583959579468,
0.4494609832763672,
-0.253949910402298,
0.35457271337509155,
0.33882492780685425,
0.7837862968444824,
-0.7554572224617004,
-0.1312018483877182,
-0.37429118156433105,
-0.041343092918395996,
0.04990546777844429,
-0.07625705748796463,
-0.5202339291572571,
-0.3172217309474945,
0.10087559372186661,
0.12271211296319962,
0.1234724223613739,
-0.056933410465717316,
0.4954272508621216,
0.29200276732444763,
-0.6125401854515076,
-0.18265394866466522,
-0.9009902477264404,
0.8780153393745422,
-0.9805821776390076,
0.5938246846199036,
0.19894620776176453,
0.23814868927001953,
0.031629182398319244,
-0.5947538018226624,
-0.5284422039985657,
-0.5238220691680908,
0.0650237649679184,
0.14111843705177307,
0.03737324848771095,
-0.0011849334696307778,
0.37990137934684753,
0.4145057797431946,
-0.3228526711463928,
0.028910033404827118,
-0.629307746887207,
0.07195808738470078,
0.7773584127426147,
0.22817422449588776,
-0.21869006752967834,
-0.04957453906536102,
-0.49150216579437256,
0.0779436007142067,
-0.7186009883880615,
-0.12510918080806732,
0.35972684621810913,
0.42248284816741943,
0.3049636781215668,
0.5018860697746277,
-0.2572765350341797,
0.47439032793045044,
0.24765360355377197,
0.11275879293680191,
0.007546994369477034,
-0.3594268262386322,
-0.038817211985588074,
-0.3824211359024048,
0.8232511281967163,
0.3374903202056885,
0.11946586519479752,
0.03564793989062309,
-0.3437700569629669,
-0.10848093032836914,
0.5033610463142395,
-0.8306793570518494,
-0.250578373670578,
0.24170882999897003,
-0.31693360209465027,
-0.21110080182552338,
-0.10177377611398697,
-0.8468425273895264,
-0.38504287600517273,
-0.19587403535842896,
0.6568785309791565,
0.08589128404855728,
-0.22013463079929352,
-0.05096226558089256,
0.04355410113930702,
0.24637609720230103,
0.4343843460083008,
-0.6568604111671448,
0.4655848443508148,
0.44675254821777344,
0.6967006921768188,
-0.22797073423862457,
-0.5605130791664124,
-0.48157209157943726,
-0.32764169573783875,
-0.5298690795898438,
0.6413889527320862,
-0.21196798980236053,
-0.3433304727077484,
-0.09744758158922195,
0.04992704093456268,
0.15575069189071655,
-0.6516850590705872,
0.3945244550704956,
-0.37335529923439026,
0.5195396542549133,
-0.595464825630188,
-0.434575617313385,
-0.2463780641555786,
0.2867662310600281,
-0.47129926085472107,
0.7382843494415283,
-0.15481668710708618,
-0.5430530309677124,
0.3833325207233429,
-0.41924405097961426,
-0.4383815824985504,
-0.07281351089477539,
-0.24670948088169098,
-0.3615061640739441,
0.2328934669494629,
0.11903136968612671,
0.40530967712402344,
-0.20637790858745575,
0.23394034802913666,
-0.4406372606754303,
-0.3032851815223694,
0.290603369474411,
-0.6259675025939941,
0.5763938426971436,
0.07586967945098877,
-0.8460574746131897,
0.1474217176437378,
-0.40243515372276306,
0.2889489233493805,
0.08114861696958542,
-0.24196356534957886,
-0.20609642565250397,
-0.1551813930273056,
-0.3010290861129761,
0.4290440082550049,
0.09997957199811935,
-0.6013736724853516,
0.06425513327121735,
-0.1886984258890152,
0.19998003542423248,
0.928794801235199,
0.10805359482765198,
0.22000806033611298,
-0.3559800982475281,
0.5886083245277405,
-0.17239223420619965,
0.4755879044532776,
0.15205565094947815,
-0.6135375499725342,
-0.8326504826545715,
0.19443507492542267,
0.1165936291217804,
0.33217307925224304,
-0.5966276526451111,
-0.0006286291754804552,
0.24376580119132996,
-0.5304533243179321,
-0.4862692952156067,
0.4474426805973053,
0.6416137218475342,
0.3288549482822418,
0.3925493359565735,
-0.49759969115257263,
-0.5799977779388428,
-0.9932222366333008,
-0.40894392132759094,
-0.20882365107536316,
0.31322479248046875,
0.2568359375,
0.7471295595169067,
0.07652861624956131,
0.6847829818725586,
-0.39944297075271606,
-0.4086134731769562,
-0.26458725333213806,
-0.041451260447502136,
0.21348483860492706,
0.4524596035480499,
0.23972202837467194,
-0.6608492732048035,
-0.3694383203983307,
-0.6609196662902832,
-0.7552855014801025,
-0.17035594582557678,
0.0026991169434040785,
0.10090431571006775,
0.31150227785110474,
0.33808770775794983,
-0.47035837173461914,
0.3513032793998718,
0.8325175642967224,
-0.4531903564929962,
0.8047921061515808,
-0.25773146748542786,
0.2751246392726898,
-0.2798362970352173,
-0.031753674149513245,
0.05964239314198494,
-0.0350412018597126,
-0.5153747200965881,
0.3021228611469269,
0.04751433804631233,
0.339892715215683,
-0.3633425533771515,
0.6192577481269836,
-0.5465112328529358,
-0.0005744138034060597,
-0.5669984221458435,
0.17864079773426056,
0.22556911408901215,
0.3379914164543152,
-0.08202175050973892,
0.8481542468070984,
-0.09625570476055145,
-0.7559422850608826,
0.3094516694545746,
0.1949441283941269,
-0.4961378276348114,
0.5154866576194763,
-0.5515636801719666,
0.3921184539794922,
0.14141353964805603,
0.28847000002861023,
-1.0393332242965698,
0.12050455808639526,
0.1282486766576767,
-0.3735806345939636,
0.10411524027585983,
0.3241189420223236,
-0.2779707908630371,
-0.5608093738555908,
-0.5455284118652344,
0.2507317066192627,
0.4185355007648468,
-0.7164515852928162,
0.5098391175270081,
0.1505095213651657,
0.06933657079935074,
-0.711527407169342,
-0.8998060822486877,
0.10099583864212036,
-0.19074596464633942,
-0.49946171045303345,
-0.2689526379108429,
-0.33446070551872253,
-0.6521525979042053,
-0.2601906657218933,
0.11757495254278183,
0.29473432898521423,
0.054942838847637177,
0.3282490074634552,
0.14696000516414642,
-0.11325592547655106,
0.19373707473278046,
-0.15489782392978668,
0.16525734961032867,
0.3464997112751007,
-0.17307235300540924,
0.3141433298587799,
-0.4902973771095276,
-0.3913472592830658,
-0.15389901399612427,
0.3807249963283539,
0.2718797028064728,
-0.13147863745689392,
0.6941291093826294,
0.2881729304790497,
0.013446902856230736,
-0.35893091559410095,
-1.1509356498718262,
-0.580751359462738,
-0.5305706262588501,
0.17765240371227264,
-0.36507466435432434,
-0.9590229988098145,
0.5682122707366943,
0.2902676463127136,
0.15113712847232819,
0.5736565589904785,
0.7899455428123474,
-0.19013334810733795,
1.0484042167663574,
0.5394296050071716,
0.2837778329849243,
0.19272580742835999,
-0.24056002497673035,
0.09811452776193619,
-1.281110167503357,
-0.11538132280111313,
-0.2794538736343384,
-0.0967821329832077,
-0.7732608914375305,
-0.30649659037590027,
0.08423512428998947,
-0.378112256526947,
-0.17992353439331055,
-0.0393868014216423,
-0.5615265369415283,
0.3472236096858978,
0.47367775440216064,
0.21110405027866364,
0.5594384670257568,
-0.6660580039024353,
0.07237773388624191,
-0.3764662742614746,
-0.6191770434379578,
-0.2827032506465912,
0.9799426198005676,
0.3994600474834442,
0.8876533508300781,
0.06341468542814255,
0.6985116600990295,
0.14237134158611298,
0.7246888875961304,
-0.7114842534065247,
0.7462958693504333,
0.06320328265428543,
-1.169459342956543,
-0.4986646771430969,
-0.601651132106781,
-0.6972883343696594,
0.5421971678733826,
0.14992550015449524,
-0.356593519449234,
0.33021077513694763,
0.13009026646614075,
-0.3199448585510254,
0.25295543670654297,
-0.7096987366676331,
0.7495301961898804,
-0.37644803524017334,
-0.7085839509963989,
-0.16448184847831726,
-0.49940159916877747,
0.5933899879455566,
-0.08946136385202408,
0.24804618954658508,
0.060746900737285614,
-0.026948150247335434,
0.773041844367981,
-0.1950807273387909,
1.053096890449524,
-0.39985191822052,
-0.5279209613800049,
0.5952425599098206,
0.34319591522216797,
0.5410758256912231,
-0.16019432246685028,
0.1287064552307129,
-0.023446662351489067,
0.13270168006420135,
-0.23142525553703308,
-0.7980388402938843,
0.7311140298843384,
-0.3164178729057312,
-1.3734647035598755,
-0.45916566252708435,
-0.3044997751712799,
-0.39049699902534485,
0.06523045152425766,
0.17801402509212494,
0.2195829302072525,
0.01928608864545822,
0.12832222878932953,
0.44472014904022217,
0.03680388256907463,
0.24176467955112457,
0.749909520149231,
-0.806108295917511,
-0.4075077474117279,
0.7799383997917175,
0.6151713728904724,
0.5731183290481567,
-0.2966298460960388,
0.5258138179779053,
-0.4212101101875305,
-0.5423028469085693,
-0.3379151523113251,
0.5019996762275696,
-1.0316165685653687,
0.046239446848630905,
-0.28663399815559387,
0.06793191283941269,
-0.3911217451095581,
0.3348920941352844,
-0.48336082696914673,
-0.4023081660270691,
-0.009117106907069683,
-0.0498586967587471,
0.08587465435266495,
1.0664350986480713,
-0.2420569211244583,
-0.3810169994831085,
-0.6778624057769775,
-0.20321024954319,
0.4936217665672302,
0.39437219500541687,
0.3950802683830261,
-0.7526150941848755,
-0.32567068934440613,
-0.2234135866165161,
-0.3051150441169739,
-0.7026432156562805,
0.01667133904993534,
0.05956611409783363,
0.3118489384651184,
0.3595830500125885,
0.337126225233078,
0.5857205390930176,
-0.49768704175949097,
0.822908341884613,
-0.12154893577098846,
-0.8896672129631042,
0.39669129252433777,
-0.3066813051700592,
0.5555386543273926,
0.7434485554695129,
0.18006040155887604,
-0.45495396852493286,
-0.8820192813873291,
-0.5414924621582031,
-0.5492196083068848,
0.1203644722700119,
-0.05354944244027138,
0.40130338072776794,
0.009467179886996746,
0.5232715010643005,
0.27226725220680237,
0.2309640496969223,
-0.7693879008293152,
0.03673005849123001,
-0.06154029443860054,
0.29628029465675354,
-0.1398228108882904,
-0.41691216826438904,
-0.3879980742931366,
-0.33920541405677795,
0.5760015249252319,
-0.26120802760124207,
0.2217327505350113,
0.5329429507255554,
0.25282007455825806,
-0.30344700813293457,
0.32532256841659546,
0.7468202114105225,
0.8762890696525574,
-0.012319698929786682,
0.2656453549861908,
0.627876877784729,
-0.35970398783683777,
0.12209521979093552,
-0.26998212933540344,
-0.03415172919631004,
-0.19663095474243164,
0.5611444711685181,
0.3231700658798218,
-0.00682985782623291,
-0.5187605023384094,
0.4899350702762604,
-0.07487710565328598,
-0.1936543732881546,
-0.42497363686561584,
0.15630291402339935,
-0.15428154170513153,
0.608680784702301,
0.38524046540260315,
-0.2451419085264206,
0.3696322739124298,
-0.7514778971672058,
0.22070224583148956,
0.4680253863334656,
-0.4187379777431488,
-0.3720126152038574,
0.5319792032241821,
0.09919892251491547,
-0.2642041742801666,
0.47585588693618774,
-0.045585136860609055,
-0.7793494462966919,
0.3607502579689026,
0.46533048152923584,
0.8250822424888611,
-0.5374367833137512,
0.10055087506771088,
0.2587769329547882,
0.32555708289146423,
-0.18587830662727356,
0.4723169207572937,
-0.2827902138233185,
-0.6008408069610596,
-0.7117626667022705,
-0.2008892148733139,
-0.6745318174362183,
-0.02928587608039379,
-0.6990116238594055,
-0.11522416770458221,
-0.5991296172142029,
-0.4210677742958069,
-0.35658833384513855,
0.23413357138633728,
-0.3258952796459198,
0.4718974232673645,
-0.07904481142759323,
0.8226636648178101,
-0.592642605304718,
0.4129834473133087,
0.16621848940849304,
-0.3565444052219391,
-0.754603922367096,
0.1442655622959137,
-0.034714724868535995,
-0.6186699867248535,
0.6931843757629395,
0.13474732637405396,
-0.3861531615257263,
-0.26166725158691406,
-0.8066900968551636,
-0.6535220146179199,
0.7250067591667175,
0.13926583528518677,
-0.6453957557678223,
-0.03522803634405136,
-0.2737618386745453,
0.7345189452171326,
-0.11843382567167282,
0.24194124341011047,
0.36957427859306335,
0.6355272531509399,
0.15582901239395142,
-1.1507002115249634,
0.5105795860290527,
-0.013017498888075352,
-0.14228703081607819,
0.06080694496631622,
-1.1995978355407715,
0.7259455323219299,
-0.6507959961891174,
-0.12390990555286407,
0.021982384845614433,
0.6886852383613586,
0.23784925043582916,
0.2448509782552719,
0.5888711810112,
0.3888859450817108,
0.31936895847320557,
-0.011124149896204472,
1.155936360359192,
0.07807624340057373,
0.3228543698787689,
1.2854334115982056,
-0.4139397144317627,
0.983787477016449,
0.7248700261116028,
-0.24009117484092712,
0.6205469965934753,
0.3226606547832489,
-0.22684065997600555,
0.5933724045753479,
0.1856570690870285,
-0.0951305478811264,
-0.32229769229888916,
-0.05141044780611992,
-0.39786720275878906,
0.545234739780426,
-0.0037685036659240723,
-0.34041857719421387,
0.1352425515651703,
0.12332875281572342,
0.02363782934844494,
0.137589231133461,
-0.04210612177848816,
0.5735616683959961,
0.4397349953651428,
-1.0058670043945312,
0.4429914057254791,
-0.22423730790615082,
0.47215700149536133,
-0.25916963815689087,
-0.027753645554184914,
-0.1927572637796402,
0.4434443414211273,
-0.30795085430145264,
-1.1220026016235352,
0.4013243019580841,
-0.23104210197925568,
0.11471477895975113,
-0.24691711366176605,
0.5059449076652527,
-0.15470954775810242,
-0.13647757470607758,
0.5995106101036072,
0.7069756388664246,
-0.015156704932451248,
-0.18196527659893036,
-0.5014990568161011,
0.11924660205841064,
-0.054196592420339584,
-0.7205781936645508,
0.31887486577033997,
0.40848878026008606,
0.14389121532440186,
0.8806266784667969,
0.4650208055973053,
0.12976785004138947,
-0.11415496468544006,
0.22552303969860077,
0.7561794519424438,
-0.7175471782684326,
-0.3397381007671356,
-0.9834224581718445,
0.31037572026252747,
0.11319602280855179,
-0.42333921790122986,
1.320042371749878,
0.40955767035484314,
0.6147452592849731,
0.11264922469854355,
0.5224097967147827,
0.21961362659931183,
0.44768014550209045,
-0.5613479018211365,
0.5510887503623962,
-0.5299313068389893,
0.27646180987358093,
-0.25486934185028076,
-0.9001573324203491,
-0.15876169502735138,
0.5039579272270203,
-0.8155154585838318,
0.4942951798439026,
0.7201646566390991,
0.5044152140617371,
0.4769006669521332,
0.23745271563529968,
0.478970468044281,
0.41863593459129333,
0.3676168620586395,
0.3253838121891022,
1.386325478553772,
-0.27234652638435364,
0.5656404495239258,
-0.37088707089424133,
-0.10355031490325928,
-0.0008585361065343022,
-0.5605695247650146,
-1.0391627550125122,
-0.8108606338500977,
-0.23965412378311157,
-0.6876530051231384,
0.014927586540579796,
0.6238895654678345,
0.5746265053749084,
-0.6103169322013855,
-0.30926117300987244,
0.04645894467830658,
0.020722439512610435,
-0.10330550372600555,
-0.24166272580623627,
0.16634759306907654,
-0.21384455263614655,
-0.39624083042144775,
0.350192666053772,
0.1991654336452484,
-0.10840348154306412,
-1.087523341178894,
-0.1411418616771698,
-0.19822369515895844,
0.27575257420539856,
0.3544186055660248,
0.2203168123960495,
-0.664625346660614,
-0.6632035374641418,
0.14811059832572937,
0.0019972340669482946,
0.18498317897319794,
0.6127797961235046,
-0.7021417021751404,
0.5860471129417419,
0.3226974308490753,
0.16396576166152954,
0.6386104822158813,
-0.07022639364004135,
0.6043295860290527,
-0.3509984016418457,
-0.24693827331066132,
0.49935612082481384,
0.08153257519006729,
0.4027559161186218,
-0.4151226580142975,
0.5512692332267761,
0.09460549056529999,
-0.8833919167518616,
-1.005706787109375,
0.3015446364879608,
-0.2505582571029663,
-0.055754613131284714,
1.0857434272766113,
-0.24879321455955505,
-0.1982022523880005,
0.02156732603907585,
-0.1986577957868576,
-0.12434876710176468,
-0.17673376202583313,
1.1095659732818604,
0.9707589149475098,
-0.41775941848754883,
-0.602377712726593,
-0.759113073348999,
0.3701429069042206,
0.6212790608406067,
-0.6165977716445923,
0.10352054983377457,
0.24624128639698029,
0.42538079619407654,
0.34167635440826416,
0.5925754904747009,
0.02529510296881199,
0.3663812279701233,
0.05718196928501129,
-0.1620638370513916,
0.1019238606095314,
-0.44029393792152405,
-0.5992926359176636,
0.1285623013973236,
0.4082653820514679,
0.1639544516801834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09127v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09127v3
|
Confidence Calibration and Rationalization for LLMs via Multi-Agent Deliberation
| 2024-04-14T02:40:43 | 2024-05-10T16:38:23 |
Ruixin Yang, Dheeraj Rajagopal, Shirley Anugrah Hayati, Bin Hu, Dongyeop Kang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Uncertainty estimation is a significant issue for current large language
models (LLMs) that are generally poorly calibrated and over-confident,
especially with reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF). Unlike
humans, whose decisions and confidences not only stem from intrinsic beliefs
but can also be adjusted through daily observations, existing calibration
methods for LLMs focus on estimating or eliciting individual confidence without
taking full advantage of the "Collective Wisdom": the interaction among
multiple LLMs that can collectively improve both accuracy and calibration. In
this work, we propose Collaborative Calibration, a post-hoc training-free
calibration strategy that leverages the collaborative and expressive
capabilities of multiple tool-augmented LLM agents in a simulated group
deliberation process. We demonstrate the effectiveness of Collaborative
Calibration on generative QA tasks across various domains, showing its
potential in harnessing the rationalization of collectively calibrated
confidence assessments and improving the reliability of model predictions.
|
[
-0.41310572624206543,
-0.540285050868988,
0.8025360703468323,
-0.11915497481822968,
-0.1786261945962906,
0.44577309489250183,
-0.43513423204421997,
-0.16806654632091522,
0.1303360015153885,
0.20020389556884766,
-0.5856296420097351,
-0.737567126750946,
-0.39456048607826233,
0.09498101472854614,
0.5151287317276001,
0.6230189800262451,
-0.07111532986164093,
0.40750226378440857,
-0.47321391105651855,
-0.32970935106277466,
-0.5854974985122681,
-0.5130540132522583,
-0.32621291279792786,
-0.703382670879364,
0.6401768326759338,
0.4271753132343292,
0.8342341780662537,
0.018502896651625633,
0.12706682085990906,
0.3725353181362152,
0.2578950822353363,
0.7497798800468445,
-0.6391129493713379,
0.23638197779655457,
-0.21646961569786072,
-0.7936268448829651,
-0.5107669234275818,
0.4958885908126831,
0.4284513294696808,
0.7513178586959839,
-0.4330226182937622,
-0.042601510882377625,
0.11860443651676178,
0.5105406045913696,
-0.8695173859596252,
0.36423468589782715,
-0.7042046189308167,
-0.13793733716011047,
0.5347564816474915,
-0.45796486735343933,
-0.5733330249786377,
-0.7862590551376343,
0.17692506313323975,
-0.9234979748725891,
0.0030117512214928865,
-0.004872721619904041,
0.2099536955356598,
0.648629367351532,
-0.3871507942676544,
-0.1750464141368866,
-0.8434243202209473,
1.1776868104934692,
-0.4678942561149597,
0.23485468327999115,
0.8219866752624512,
0.21220429241657257,
-0.3378775715827942,
-0.2787644863128662,
-0.40740832686424255,
-0.05381763353943825,
0.31838929653167725,
0.2930460274219513,
0.294063538312912,
0.1822650283575058,
-0.14548006653785706,
0.13452370464801788,
-0.28217002749443054,
-0.010157492011785507,
0.012903286144137383,
-0.363777220249176,
0.807410717010498,
-0.012360471300780773,
-0.03549102693796158,
0.44672131538391113,
-0.3700326085090637,
-0.43733587861061096,
-0.7283708453178406,
-0.009553920477628708,
0.2943132817745209,
0.3357579708099365,
-0.030076565220952034,
0.27010542154312134,
-0.025987494736909866,
0.35220396518707275,
0.2120516300201416,
-0.2753778398036957,
0.3632703721523285,
-0.4693983495235443,
-0.19523338973522186,
-0.07581807672977448,
0.8078119158744812,
0.5375107526779175,
0.20369483530521393,
-0.29466891288757324,
-0.17182022333145142,
0.24259692430496216,
0.15109211206436157,
-0.5774101614952087,
-0.16732445359230042,
0.3008725941181183,
0.16301164031028748,
-0.2983453571796417,
0.1084819883108139,
-0.39603903889656067,
-0.6214849948883057,
-0.5371711254119873,
0.5583938956260681,
-0.20909784734249115,
-0.3382549285888672,
0.12241831421852112,
-0.003590925130993128,
0.30269092321395874,
0.8050499558448792,
-0.6241726279258728,
0.16461138427257538,
0.6559540629386902,
0.34268680214881897,
0.0719616562128067,
-0.49715495109558105,
-0.6026847958564758,
0.19383738934993744,
-0.6850358843803406,
0.7051159143447876,
-0.23149627447128296,
-0.671152651309967,
-0.23615096509456635,
-0.24784313142299652,
-0.24532349407672882,
-0.396616131067276,
0.2536483407020569,
-0.668498694896698,
0.3380405902862549,
-0.5258641242980957,
-0.6275497674942017,
-0.24004800617694855,
0.6945521831512451,
-0.61220383644104,
0.6839667558670044,
0.1224169135093689,
-0.5928213000297546,
0.4998781681060791,
-0.02766599878668785,
0.06223241612315178,
0.2110750675201416,
-0.6402570605278015,
-0.18417398631572723,
-0.006212829612195492,
0.22688741981983185,
0.1950271725654602,
-0.43171966075897217,
0.30322059988975525,
-0.6429663300514221,
-0.5589161515235901,
0.3835759460926056,
-0.5620343089103699,
0.5081654191017151,
-0.047910891473293304,
0.002873662393540144,
0.4751740097999573,
-0.35980868339538574,
0.504662811756134,
-0.3166787922382355,
-0.29344454407691956,
-0.29842498898506165,
-0.03721509501338005,
-0.3898557722568512,
0.221306711435318,
0.333238810300827,
-0.3120121955871582,
0.14704342186450958,
-0.46537160873413086,
0.07913506031036377,
0.8428928256034851,
0.22016365826129913,
0.5710768103599548,
-0.8313957452774048,
0.6529930233955383,
-0.18771091103553772,
0.1307247281074524,
0.2586834728717804,
-0.3966473639011383,
-0.47844448685646057,
-0.24366408586502075,
0.19009064137935638,
0.523646354675293,
-0.9902679920196533,
0.6504400372505188,
-0.5015634298324585,
-0.564897894859314,
-0.49802350997924805,
0.3265272378921509,
0.36237502098083496,
0.14465413987636566,
0.15264692902565002,
-0.5801280736923218,
-0.22904077172279358,
-0.441634863615036,
0.04881540685892105,
-0.5486348867416382,
-0.0968816876411438,
0.17486752569675446,
0.2203972488641739,
-0.12521031498908997,
1.0079164505004883,
-0.19534748792648315,
-0.31589195132255554,
-0.15256662666797638,
0.47125691175460815,
-0.1663186103105545,
0.38274598121643066,
0.18064171075820923,
-0.5903900861740112,
-0.4357280135154724,
-0.11514850705862045,
-0.5745847821235657,
0.21482788026332855,
0.08740852773189545,
-0.22941508889198303,
0.248057022690773,
0.18858961760997772,
-0.44847092032432556,
0.40641528367996216,
0.741206169128418,
0.044952843338251114,
0.6835293769836426,
-0.4733821749687195,
0.46434733271598816,
-1.062015414237976,
-0.2944268584251404,
-0.14032551646232605,
-0.4820784628391266,
-0.29090815782546997,
0.1416347175836563,
-0.3100430369377136,
0.6320102214813232,
-0.23690128326416016,
0.2977900505065918,
-0.48140907287597656,
0.0607726089656353,
-0.2590982913970947,
0.5239251852035522,
0.1985916942358017,
0.5541907548904419,
0.1165640726685524,
0.9086329340934753,
0.30538487434387207,
-0.290239155292511,
0.49937012791633606,
0.21965092420578003,
-0.2661808431148529,
0.7987433075904846,
-0.381509393453598,
0.44814732670783997,
-0.0266993660479784,
0.5519745349884033,
-0.7984004616737366,
-0.2891537547111511,
0.14986568689346313,
-0.4372763931751251,
-0.12093310803174973,
-0.004823378752917051,
-0.44998711347579956,
0.02362285740673542,
-0.5351104736328125,
0.5267114043235779,
0.2776831090450287,
-0.27830609679222107,
0.8235342502593994,
0.5453364849090576,
-0.025770151987671852,
-0.6937189102172852,
-0.6850430369377136,
-0.1834435909986496,
0.11923136562108994,
-0.6393086314201355,
0.1515042781829834,
-0.32553333044052124,
-0.33611467480659485,
-0.26248106360435486,
-0.12788257002830505,
-0.13703376054763794,
0.023235350847244263,
0.49130797386169434,
0.35099121928215027,
0.20237241685390472,
0.3948879837989807,
-0.09628047794103622,
-0.025362448766827583,
0.006358362268656492,
0.033455971628427505,
0.599791944026947,
-0.3557422161102295,
-0.7507625818252563,
-0.4827663004398346,
0.03501041978597641,
0.5999637842178345,
-0.2256462723016739,
0.8697559833526611,
0.48055440187454224,
-0.41491952538490295,
-0.38099294900894165,
-0.8299980759620667,
-0.4237748086452484,
-0.4734809398651123,
0.08921393752098083,
-0.21170519292354584,
-1.0030012130737305,
0.6127159595489502,
-0.25077804923057556,
-0.034043699502944946,
0.10361742228269577,
0.6509754061698914,
0.0973179042339325,
0.9215021133422852,
0.6123557090759277,
-0.12329218536615372,
0.17547233402729034,
-0.1356533318758011,
-0.08148442208766937,
-0.6531561613082886,
-0.18004953861236572,
-0.39734622836112976,
-0.029859408736228943,
-0.526222825050354,
-0.9348940849304199,
0.5264321565628052,
0.013258172199130058,
-0.31165894865989685,
-0.024167662486433983,
-0.1933830976486206,
0.6133983731269836,
0.7843962907791138,
0.469619482755661,
0.4720030426979065,
-0.11422469466924667,
-0.3874111771583557,
-0.04488302394747734,
-0.554931104183197,
-0.5704483985900879,
1.063825011253357,
0.07089799642562866,
0.8508092164993286,
-0.03226684406399727,
0.8311070799827576,
-0.02349053882062435,
0.5877677798271179,
-0.8913840055465698,
0.481189101934433,
0.3001079261302948,
-0.37748801708221436,
-0.5669102668762207,
-0.7457152605056763,
-0.664021372795105,
0.3033561408519745,
-0.2276824563741684,
-0.6888425946235657,
0.21382738649845123,
0.17008058726787567,
-0.5655942559242249,
0.19346272945404053,
-0.5609933137893677,
0.7066268920898438,
0.0834520161151886,
-0.4425036907196045,
-0.6380347609519958,
-0.6440373659133911,
0.18648496270179749,
-0.29415974020957947,
0.3957883417606354,
-0.28836527466773987,
0.0838865116238594,
0.2702769935131073,
-0.46114128828048706,
1.0415092706680298,
-0.12439250200986862,
-0.3047811686992645,
0.5944200158119202,
0.13270889222621918,
0.664771318435669,
0.01595432125031948,
-0.45363062620162964,
-0.14203092455863953,
0.1511611044406891,
-0.15559683740139008,
-0.6768888235092163,
0.6159684658050537,
-1.0034143924713135,
-0.5256730318069458,
-0.32516762614250183,
-0.7781847715377808,
-0.6963919401168823,
-0.1129465103149414,
0.0337272509932518,
0.18136058747768402,
-0.49706900119781494,
0.25843602418899536,
0.3109188377857208,
-0.14385318756103516,
0.16456028819084167,
0.27802029252052307,
-0.13142138719558716,
-0.8852612376213074,
0.6875174641609192,
-0.06079872325062752,
0.6426762938499451,
0.20125916600227356,
0.1028929278254509,
-0.42689797282218933,
-0.16990001499652863,
-0.05367856100201607,
0.166413813829422,
-0.799767255783081,
-0.18631954491138458,
-0.07094786316156387,
-0.016924170777201653,
-0.41090697050094604,
-0.11284452676773071,
-0.4465170204639435,
-0.32058534026145935,
-0.40845659375190735,
-0.14460740983486176,
0.11482825130224228,
0.5353506207466125,
-0.117043636739254,
0.347068727016449,
-1.0035881996154785,
-0.1756318360567093,
0.4544607102870941,
0.25201183557510376,
-0.26995113492012024,
-0.285860151052475,
-0.21963360905647278,
0.542708158493042,
-0.36912107467651367,
-0.7396642565727234,
0.4196014702320099,
0.011956154368817806,
0.5187613368034363,
0.0938437283039093,
0.3856584131717682,
0.6565764546394348,
-0.1573493629693985,
0.5807005167007446,
0.24608643352985382,
-0.906400740146637,
0.208560511469841,
-0.1186155155301094,
0.364162415266037,
1.0614465475082397,
0.11232201009988785,
-0.47459813952445984,
-0.34868231415748596,
-0.2153618186712265,
-0.42516908049583435,
0.42932114005088806,
-0.12858113646507263,
0.0007087187259458005,
0.2881323993206024,
0.17956914007663727,
-0.08143025636672974,
0.3857414126396179,
-0.4019906222820282,
0.02100401185452938,
0.018723085522651672,
-0.3468640446662903,
-0.298117458820343,
0.01872110553085804,
-0.5737944841384888,
-0.0669514387845993,
0.8264049887657166,
-0.5336658954620361,
-0.11964739114046097,
0.2588484585285187,
-0.09931308031082153,
-0.5513712167739868,
0.4051613509654999,
0.3454967737197876,
0.6906729936599731,
-0.1658167690038681,
0.17337441444396973,
0.25514087080955505,
-0.3005921244621277,
0.30387505888938904,
0.03065161220729351,
0.02318696305155754,
-0.36181187629699707,
0.2733300030231476,
0.6221083998680115,
0.20090143382549286,
-0.4046735465526581,
0.7853808999061584,
-0.3172028064727783,
-0.42322099208831787,
-0.3479515314102173,
0.08751758933067322,
0.10129152983427048,
0.3598334789276123,
0.2587582767009735,
0.3674236536026001,
-0.16178402304649353,
-0.16645273566246033,
0.20903167128562927,
0.7768132090568542,
-0.44725021719932556,
-0.3477719724178314,
0.32014721632003784,
0.2692737877368927,
0.0022962314542382956,
0.5067899823188782,
-0.3880019187927246,
-0.559005618095398,
0.4630700647830963,
0.07384953647851944,
0.9726118445396423,
-0.5192980170249939,
0.5115470290184021,
0.24335482716560364,
0.44852009415626526,
-0.35196471214294434,
0.2385941445827484,
-0.02064385823905468,
-1.3839147090911865,
-0.8299435973167419,
-0.4072958528995514,
-1.0171586275100708,
-0.16008439660072327,
-0.4705730676651001,
0.04531702399253845,
-0.4004855155944824,
-0.48347923159599304,
-0.5112051367759705,
0.3305600583553314,
-0.6640713214874268,
0.14981336891651154,
0.021035950630903244,
0.4835442304611206,
-0.6173689365386963,
0.9297125935554504,
0.5923500657081604,
-0.33568981289863586,
-1.2785054445266724,
0.0007475744350813329,
0.09997719526290894,
-0.6241917610168457,
0.2573006749153137,
0.31323447823524475,
-0.7100445628166199,
0.027976637706160545,
-0.7995834946632385,
-0.7451910376548767,
1.3722244501113892,
0.5428937077522278,
-0.36324092745780945,
0.002655779244378209,
0.2349013090133667,
0.5996429920196533,
-0.30087390542030334,
0.34722569584846497,
0.18192610144615173,
0.4584750831127167,
0.5061576962471008,
-1.1189045906066895,
-0.01782926172018051,
0.07904168218374252,
-0.13495194911956787,
-0.2688702642917633,
-0.6076464056968689,
0.6290057301521301,
-0.31925728917121887,
-0.20947577059268951,
0.0521153025329113,
0.5867834091186523,
0.6820472478866577,
0.12662586569786072,
0.8309585452079773,
0.47705093026161194,
0.9810184240341187,
-0.04148681089282036,
0.7612971663475037,
-0.5054900050163269,
0.4166073799133301,
1.4908559322357178,
-0.6666377186775208,
0.8416270613670349,
0.5311033129692078,
-0.10557953268289566,
0.4891242980957031,
0.4271199405193329,
0.3741467595100403,
0.3223840296268463,
0.12077274173498154,
-0.8789011836051941,
-0.8600760698318481,
-0.1731179803609848,
-0.13727016746997833,
0.32917237281799316,
0.47284770011901855,
-0.0437328927218914,
-0.06507694721221924,
-0.23932130634784698,
-0.2160944640636444,
0.0991688221693039,
-0.19073133170604706,
0.7475622892379761,
0.18704701960086823,
-1.000730037689209,
0.3766789138317108,
-0.05467015504837036,
0.4902995824813843,
-0.3146369457244873,
0.010177449323236942,
0.06529739499092102,
0.36836710572242737,
-0.02584254741668701,
-0.4820287823677063,
-0.0668439120054245,
-0.6033430099487305,
0.12949010729789734,
-0.210524320602417,
0.552406907081604,
-0.823693573474884,
-0.23945659399032593,
0.28716689348220825,
0.9735854864120483,
-0.03286558389663696,
-0.3150708079338074,
-0.3969195485115051,
0.05970541387796402,
-0.16496604681015015,
-0.33474358916282654,
0.02457655966281891,
0.32522332668304443,
0.15877048671245575,
0.7531958222389221,
0.6674491167068481,
-0.01648234762251377,
-0.14351551234722137,
0.3689049780368805,
0.8844389915466309,
-0.12225203961133957,
-0.22906747460365295,
-0.622671365737915,
0.3100355565547943,
0.1340087354183197,
0.10076474398374557,
0.48739564418792725,
0.18625079095363617,
0.9650952219963074,
0.06900978833436966,
0.8460922837257385,
0.4862644672393799,
0.3994574546813965,
-0.20761890709400177,
0.6553013920783997,
-0.3500919044017792,
0.3373101055622101,
-0.13412392139434814,
-0.8598990440368652,
-0.5448903441429138,
0.8798509836196899,
-0.39756274223327637,
0.2842482626438141,
0.5871153473854065,
0.9842723608016968,
0.3921753764152527,
0.245056614279747,
0.5796188116073608,
0.07310540974140167,
0.30928316712379456,
0.598904013633728,
0.7375284433364868,
-0.22273218631744385,
0.384481817483902,
-0.4074028432369232,
-0.424751341342926,
0.11392718553543091,
-0.9761914610862732,
-0.7955197691917419,
-0.4601549208164215,
-0.3064350485801697,
-0.20198895037174225,
-0.11014720797538757,
1.5556901693344116,
0.716567873954773,
-0.7009971141815186,
-0.3037211000919342,
-0.21047168970108032,
0.18248312175273895,
-0.10345680266618729,
-0.16335146129131317,
0.09222795814275742,
-0.2496107965707779,
-0.7451906204223633,
0.4064043462276459,
0.12885016202926636,
0.07102070748806,
-0.5387187004089355,
-0.4250771403312683,
-0.03662900999188423,
0.23472143709659576,
0.3875008523464203,
-0.02136760577559471,
-0.7137812972068787,
-0.5268318057060242,
-0.11764214187860489,
-0.4734462797641754,
0.033760469406843185,
0.39413872361183167,
-0.9514315724372864,
0.6442107558250427,
0.38843274116516113,
0.5672897100448608,
0.21128760278224945,
0.32534706592559814,
0.9211186766624451,
-0.8967010378837585,
-0.028305713087320328,
0.21226489543914795,
0.22061105072498322,
0.42098405957221985,
-0.06483010202646255,
0.5194453597068787,
0.26749321818351746,
-0.9367454648017883,
-0.5793631076812744,
0.12281858921051025,
-0.8057036399841309,
0.04949557036161423,
0.949815571308136,
-0.5005673170089722,
0.057310257107019424,
-0.0802539736032486,
-0.26476413011550903,
0.4159782826900482,
-0.4978153705596924,
0.7179598212242126,
0.9862026572227478,
0.2068372368812561,
-0.17519178986549377,
-0.10659496486186981,
0.374954491853714,
0.32777777314186096,
-1.0256855487823486,
0.09630611538887024,
0.9754186868667603,
0.09626589715480804,
0.40973496437072754,
0.8432410955429077,
0.06735465675592422,
0.24831542372703552,
-0.1450781524181366,
0.35885775089263916,
0.11673603951931,
-0.3086971640586853,
-0.22360698878765106,
0.17962674796581268,
0.37212586402893066,
0.00038607825990766287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09123v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09123v1
|
Provable Interactive Learning with Hindsight Instruction Feedback
| 2024-04-14T02:18:07 | 2024-04-14T02:18:07 |
Dipendra Misra, Aldo Pacchiano, Robert E. Schapire
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
We study interactive learning in a setting where the agent has to generate a
response (e.g., an action or trajectory) given a context and an instruction. In
contrast, to typical approaches that train the system using reward or expert
supervision on response, we study learning with hindsight instruction where a
teacher provides an instruction that is most suitable for the agent's generated
response. This hindsight labeling of instruction is often easier to provide
than providing expert supervision of the optimal response which may require
expert knowledge or can be impractical to elicit. We initiate the theoretical
analysis of interactive learning with hindsight labeling. We first provide a
lower bound showing that in general, the regret of any algorithm must scale
with the size of the agent's response space. We then study a specialized
setting where the underlying instruction-response distribution can be
decomposed as a low-rank matrix. We introduce an algorithm called LORIL for
this setting and show that its regret scales as $\sqrt{T}$ where $T$ is the
number of rounds and depends on the intrinsic rank but does not depend on the
size of the agent's response space. We provide experiments in two domains
showing that LORIL outperforms baselines even when the low-rank assumption is
violated.
|
[
-0.4996717870235443,
-0.8555955290794373,
0.506322979927063,
0.07207217067480087,
0.28164687752723694,
0.032874997705221176,
-0.26491865515708923,
-0.31213247776031494,
0.1837025135755539,
0.23392195999622345,
-0.8073045015335083,
-0.35630345344543457,
-0.43549150228500366,
-0.21765300631523132,
0.07812603563070297,
1.0677580833435059,
0.12426397949457169,
0.3357090651988983,
-0.309977263212204,
-0.0326969251036644,
-0.5056264400482178,
-0.4420151710510254,
-1.0973637104034424,
-0.21315650641918182,
0.7209718227386475,
0.8411946892738342,
0.48584046959877014,
0.5608761310577393,
0.8537563681602478,
0.37965479493141174,
0.1354072391986847,
0.11602043360471725,
-0.881276547908783,
-0.00213806563988328,
-0.09961722791194916,
-0.5370336174964905,
-0.5078245997428894,
0.3192977011203766,
0.6616007089614868,
0.7561313509941101,
-0.3140016496181488,
0.020138481631875038,
0.20624756813049316,
0.5199474096298218,
-0.6791704893112183,
0.18637217581272125,
0.034235768020153046,
0.4213097393512726,
0.3143359124660492,
-0.21452397108078003,
-0.749704122543335,
-0.6890274882316589,
0.3589268624782562,
-0.7603165507316589,
-0.11201045662164688,
0.33459553122520447,
0.39017564058303833,
0.4623650014400482,
-0.4639648199081421,
-0.4152609407901764,
-1.07624351978302,
0.9993962049484253,
-0.35398781299591064,
0.416826993227005,
0.4603422284126282,
0.65984708070755,
-0.16471901535987854,
-0.9141451716423035,
-0.44855996966362,
-0.5892183184623718,
-0.0356011800467968,
0.40095463395118713,
-0.055930718779563904,
0.38057297468185425,
0.3985412120819092,
0.1555793136358261,
-0.3231988549232483,
0.3930698037147522,
-0.22728756070137024,
-0.04032934457063675,
0.7034898996353149,
0.3250611424446106,
-0.20930485427379608,
0.1841903030872345,
-0.6175370812416077,
-0.5005654096603394,
-0.4178403913974762,
0.5200265049934387,
0.5281966328620911,
0.09037674218416214,
0.006735000293701887,
0.4664699137210846,
-0.003471548203378916,
0.7028847336769104,
0.2514784038066864,
-0.11484880745410919,
-0.06228591501712799,
0.0713551864027977,
-0.01284455694258213,
0.010309235192835331,
0.4146438539028168,
0.38037899136543274,
0.18748359382152557,
-0.0522860623896122,
-0.24302245676517487,
-0.2569917142391205,
0.586054801940918,
-0.7066119909286499,
-0.4250534176826477,
0.10568489879369736,
-0.26705583930015564,
-0.2551463544368744,
-0.027741679921746254,
-0.8430025577545166,
-0.23055091500282288,
-0.29866424202919006,
0.6890702247619629,
-0.3888589143753052,
0.41825389862060547,
-0.44455409049987793,
0.19366304576396942,
0.04556678980588913,
0.7460516095161438,
-0.5933743715286255,
0.396846204996109,
0.3755528926849365,
0.43302738666534424,
-0.04166919365525246,
-0.3050205409526825,
-1.1346160173416138,
-0.12169214338064194,
-0.37499284744262695,
0.7531206011772156,
-0.6995069980621338,
-0.39833366870880127,
-0.21940754354000092,
-0.2250223308801651,
-0.060083191841840744,
-0.4124068319797516,
0.13472029566764832,
-0.7820513844490051,
0.30494049191474915,
-0.18576680123806,
-0.709953784942627,
-0.4905514121055603,
0.5007318258285522,
-0.49149006605148315,
0.584077000617981,
0.06215616688132286,
-0.6102302074432373,
0.3798702657222748,
-0.5498096942901611,
-0.09663592278957367,
-0.025877349078655243,
-0.070692278444767,
-0.4325299561023712,
-0.20621079206466675,
-0.20939648151397705,
0.15054522454738617,
0.19954298436641693,
-0.1281585395336151,
-0.4038241505622864,
-0.6131005883216858,
0.41133543848991394,
-0.3932400047779083,
0.20055727660655975,
-0.017001645639538765,
-0.3476751744747162,
0.30322691798210144,
-0.797618567943573,
0.25800684094429016,
0.03572520241141319,
-0.7019539475440979,
-0.2304631620645523,
0.24778270721435547,
-0.4817153215408325,
-0.0707075446844101,
0.16936250030994415,
-0.40518441796302795,
0.2982955574989319,
-0.3606843948364258,
-0.05114872381091118,
0.9035044312477112,
0.44363436102867126,
0.6452338695526123,
-0.20777028799057007,
0.44966375827789307,
-0.2060966193675995,
0.4848576784133911,
0.05028967931866646,
-0.2869355380535126,
-0.9357282519340515,
0.021345803514122963,
0.5901108384132385,
0.6645870208740234,
-0.8411585688591003,
-0.10797484219074249,
0.04499872773885727,
-0.18070897459983826,
-0.29294636845588684,
-0.2273097187280655,
0.727505624294281,
0.5499956011772156,
0.4513716995716095,
-0.5185233354568481,
-0.3741838037967682,
-0.8568444848060608,
-0.01557051669806242,
-0.2670033276081085,
-0.10338893532752991,
0.5875839591026306,
0.281144380569458,
0.09453944116830826,
0.8362001776695251,
-0.6930501461029053,
-0.4066430926322937,
0.14543665945529938,
0.4080958962440491,
-0.2525693476200104,
0.5528512597084045,
0.40185943245887756,
-0.8452955484390259,
-0.47457975149154663,
-0.14436912536621094,
-0.8255442380905151,
0.3968927264213562,
0.055970314890146255,
0.12388376891613007,
-0.03729474917054176,
0.30258044600486755,
-0.05627668648958206,
0.7869754433631897,
0.22843018174171448,
0.0008636903367005289,
0.3866589367389679,
-0.4439007043838501,
0.22329257428646088,
-0.47857049107551575,
-0.19985038042068481,
-0.07303354889154434,
-0.26994481682777405,
-0.646647036075592,
-0.0254665594547987,
-0.22431543469429016,
-0.06922415643930435,
-0.3373468518257141,
0.34879860281944275,
-0.33153384923934937,
-0.32098355889320374,
-0.3975657522678375,
0.20089149475097656,
-0.3963868021965027,
0.9794952273368835,
0.2845796048641205,
0.7312002778053284,
-0.0009306097635999322,
-0.5146728157997131,
0.30010363459587097,
0.310929536819458,
0.013420948758721352,
0.5756544470787048,
-0.42167380452156067,
0.25153329968452454,
-0.13445855677127838,
0.23877964913845062,
-0.863224446773529,
-0.25198203325271606,
0.4635591208934784,
-0.40438318252563477,
0.3957258462905884,
-0.19798427820205688,
0.1100965067744255,
-0.3203723728656769,
-0.24509580433368683,
0.07352486997842789,
0.5992627739906311,
-0.3520910143852234,
0.3960633873939514,
0.12223166227340698,
-0.1214701309800148,
-1.0233123302459717,
-0.43576470017433167,
-0.30947741866111755,
-0.07682285457849503,
-0.06918816268444061,
0.001817659824155271,
-0.37632131576538086,
-0.5162345767021179,
0.11571580171585083,
0.14443837106227875,
0.09688396006822586,
0.033225931227207184,
0.4142538011074066,
0.04062232747673988,
-0.12104830145835876,
0.08005153387784958,
-0.046452514827251434,
-0.26595452427864075,
0.14238548278808594,
-0.28006288409233093,
0.2248982936143875,
-0.2797553837299347,
-0.5559179186820984,
-0.26483064889907837,
0.46151888370513916,
0.22998276352882385,
-0.0591619573533535,
0.8147807717323303,
0.4416617155075073,
-0.34744977951049805,
-0.31958097219467163,
-0.2773575782775879,
-0.5794297456741333,
-0.46179166436195374,
0.186537504196167,
-0.10907460004091263,
-0.6733005046844482,
0.5043926239013672,
-0.19569489359855652,
0.2933344542980194,
0.06306802481412888,
0.39581024646759033,
-0.49887460470199585,
1.1601382493972778,
1.0232748985290527,
0.6243272423744202,
0.5060905814170837,
-0.5384467244148254,
0.11445451527833939,
-0.688888430595398,
-0.595495879650116,
-0.15023399889469147,
-0.7882306575775146,
-0.5716822743415833,
-0.3111875653266907,
0.6229312419891357,
0.13715018332004547,
-0.40515923500061035,
-0.05550319328904152,
-0.45784738659858704,
0.3077477812767029,
1.1267791986465454,
0.3822629153728485,
0.1491914987564087,
-0.09566127508878708,
-0.2827000617980957,
-0.1681053340435028,
-0.8859965205192566,
-0.36390817165374756,
0.8037317991256714,
0.2353121042251587,
0.7013840079307556,
0.12385618686676025,
0.8844082355499268,
0.5066624879837036,
0.5881403684616089,
-1.0327461957931519,
0.7200157046318054,
0.17128843069076538,
-0.17164582014083862,
-0.6068658828735352,
-0.36735236644744873,
-0.9043310880661011,
0.03573457896709442,
-0.4367588460445404,
-0.7948449850082397,
0.5511091351509094,
0.42641645669937134,
-0.45600298047065735,
0.2134394347667694,
-0.7860848307609558,
0.6515123248100281,
-0.10154632478952408,
-0.6440156698226929,
-0.3077884912490845,
-0.9421473741531372,
0.14468783140182495,
-0.020371390506625175,
0.1382068395614624,
0.3538821041584015,
-0.050536032766103745,
0.8703314661979675,
-0.7857106328010559,
1.0389978885650635,
-0.48862335085868835,
0.20192967355251312,
0.38934072852134705,
0.30843037366867065,
0.7734948396682739,
0.04866814240813255,
0.1406862884759903,
-0.4737379848957062,
-0.4010816812515259,
-0.34604114294052124,
-0.8204156756401062,
0.5018616318702698,
-0.8667985200881958,
-0.7078548073768616,
-0.31593525409698486,
-0.6157848834991455,
-0.47404322028160095,
0.027431445196270943,
0.2665417194366455,
0.40494218468666077,
-0.10710437595844269,
-0.05102728307247162,
0.7737057209014893,
-0.15975429117679596,
0.4614635705947876,
0.724821150302887,
-0.09483843296766281,
-0.37423595786094666,
1.106140375137329,
0.5560073852539062,
0.06914948672056198,
0.42357683181762695,
0.06045873463153839,
-0.17114029824733734,
-0.6665410995483398,
-0.23879891633987427,
-0.05658336728811264,
-0.8904122114181519,
-0.12761817872524261,
-0.423044890165329,
-0.25641512870788574,
0.22659452259540558,
-0.44376298785209656,
-0.33784571290016174,
-0.43092256784439087,
-0.14433586597442627,
-0.12767468392848969,
0.16370674967765808,
1.036080002784729,
-0.4477272033691406,
0.39122653007507324,
-0.6503793597221375,
-0.28138840198516846,
0.7894633412361145,
0.027389168739318848,
0.4024203419685364,
-0.3627336621284485,
-0.40612873435020447,
0.2566632628440857,
-0.5771186351776123,
-0.9348003268241882,
0.2225269377231598,
0.09268920123577118,
0.7590659856796265,
0.5944161415100098,
0.46164682507514954,
0.40117406845092773,
-0.5209715962409973,
0.6635026931762695,
0.08100922405719757,
-0.5455225706100464,
0.5963619351387024,
-0.1448163390159607,
0.02841074950993061,
0.3346918523311615,
0.7094773054122925,
-0.1286124587059021,
-0.550787627696991,
-0.8663758039474487,
-0.7308107018470764,
0.8741289377212524,
0.11787756532430649,
-0.14386944472789764,
0.1810300350189209,
0.3750186860561371,
0.19704128801822662,
0.34536734223365784,
-0.47494804859161377,
-0.2364576756954193,
-0.104226253926754,
0.030256295576691628,
-0.17916011810302734,
-0.3262484073638916,
-0.3796783685684204,
0.13018272817134857,
0.4947545528411865,
-0.16576623916625977,
0.6702251434326172,
0.1555013209581375,
-0.02181285060942173,
-0.15528514981269836,
0.13931013643741608,
0.8181438446044922,
0.6337475776672363,
-0.4039446711540222,
0.1629345566034317,
0.4139541685581207,
-0.42257052659988403,
0.279936283826828,
0.024715695530176163,
0.05068614333868027,
-0.5506094098091125,
0.7535178065299988,
0.8789940476417542,
0.3914710283279419,
-0.5889773964881897,
0.41028761863708496,
-0.094352588057518,
-0.29261720180511475,
-0.24880042672157288,
0.2606383264064789,
-0.25326594710350037,
0.7837979793548584,
0.620858907699585,
0.3091107904911041,
0.3750306963920593,
-0.3111008107662201,
0.4390750229358673,
0.13706040382385254,
-0.7172987461090088,
-0.2785246670246124,
0.72407066822052,
0.08849991112947464,
-0.771353542804718,
0.9376819133758545,
-0.2740502953529358,
-0.4891177713871002,
0.7467299699783325,
0.29126137495040894,
0.5849949717521667,
-0.30571991205215454,
0.4748297333717346,
0.31199583411216736,
0.11060508340597153,
0.303672194480896,
0.008413953706622124,
-0.3175332546234131,
-0.4623999297618866,
-0.42151400446891785,
-0.3873821794986725,
-1.0564346313476562,
-0.2325695902109146,
-0.935692310333252,
-0.265595942735672,
-0.7196659445762634,
-0.2538715898990631,
-0.057265255600214005,
0.16494238376617432,
-0.529325544834137,
0.4406890273094177,
-0.0007989650475792587,
0.658893346786499,
-0.6012827157974243,
0.4671972095966339,
0.9409207701683044,
-0.3773893415927887,
-1.077886700630188,
0.21261125802993774,
0.003984909504652023,
-0.8648112416267395,
0.8596855401992798,
-0.03479120135307312,
-0.19343692064285278,
0.34607747197151184,
-0.5373314023017883,
-0.6054049730300903,
0.9515597820281982,
0.3417315185070038,
-0.43221959471702576,
-0.06467711925506592,
-0.316943883895874,
0.6229529976844788,
-0.24623312056064606,
0.44984403252601624,
0.07211258262395859,
0.5256907939910889,
0.34257736802101135,
-0.6518771648406982,
-0.22319287061691284,
-0.023618070408701897,
-0.2065502256155014,
0.03839974105358124,
-0.9352890849113464,
0.7229936718940735,
-0.6540420055389404,
0.02250310219824314,
-0.19681449234485626,
0.8927844166755676,
0.18842853605747223,
0.5853644013404846,
0.474682092666626,
0.41039079427719116,
0.6404904723167419,
-0.2447998970746994,
1.0435963869094849,
0.20214790105819702,
0.450749009847641,
0.89731764793396,
-0.07518494129180908,
0.9734163284301758,
0.3377663195133209,
-0.2853972911834717,
0.7076438069343567,
0.9650665521621704,
0.17255918681621552,
0.7878202199935913,
0.003517324337735772,
-0.15424993634223938,
-0.4217641055583954,
-0.23158743977546692,
-0.14394031465053558,
0.3904208838939667,
0.3178046643733978,
-0.06327563524246216,
-0.303244948387146,
0.6044442653656006,
-0.29778388142585754,
0.21687348186969757,
-0.43497103452682495,
0.9466660022735596,
0.05128318443894386,
-0.7204833626747131,
0.41795289516448975,
-0.0920834094285965,
0.04087502881884575,
-0.469443142414093,
-0.5125303268432617,
-0.33137333393096924,
0.3759901523590088,
-0.10963217169046402,
-0.8612480163574219,
-0.0498240701854229,
-0.37411749362945557,
-0.08102205395698547,
0.02849428728222847,
0.47718364000320435,
-0.39995768666267395,
-0.0151676619425416,
0.17474287748336792,
0.3473397195339203,
0.24348852038383484,
0.5841246247291565,
-0.6119834780693054,
-0.07007859647274017,
-0.003481699153780937,
-0.7843681573867798,
0.5608490705490112,
0.12095446139574051,
-0.22575823962688446,
1.123167634010315,
0.348062664270401,
-0.2996240556240082,
0.017585601657629013,
-0.5476939082145691,
0.8981097340583801,
-0.19566403329372406,
-0.6973056793212891,
-0.3355996012687683,
0.578688383102417,
-0.1260293424129486,
0.10986893624067307,
0.7808405756950378,
0.30552440881729126,
0.7913713455200195,
-0.1524813026189804,
0.5311974883079529,
0.09522009640932083,
0.3608572483062744,
-0.6331092119216919,
0.2187594473361969,
-0.510277271270752,
0.27407708764076233,
0.13363048434257507,
-0.9095328450202942,
-0.11808017641305923,
0.73294597864151,
-0.8037705421447754,
0.3721820116043091,
0.6845057010650635,
0.36293885111808777,
-0.002609437331557274,
0.03616803139448166,
0.3308749198913574,
0.08807746320962906,
-0.09490649402141571,
0.6653147339820862,
1.0833444595336914,
-0.011025730520486832,
0.5244017243385315,
-0.3870350122451782,
-0.45995795726776123,
-0.43804317712783813,
-0.5754078030586243,
-0.8575125336647034,
-0.41067036986351013,
-0.27737298607826233,
-0.3646228611469269,
0.356742799282074,
0.688854455947876,
0.715158998966217,
-0.7534708380699158,
0.06560630351305008,
0.0719919204711914,
0.30013734102249146,
-0.6543713212013245,
-0.2523043751716614,
0.5850436091423035,
-0.36256086826324463,
-1.0122215747833252,
0.4677621126174927,
0.19100210070610046,
0.30556705594062805,
-0.2542198896408081,
-0.4040452241897583,
-0.04640722647309303,
0.152144655585289,
0.4054941236972809,
0.4178038239479065,
-0.40634411573410034,
-0.618937075138092,
-0.0346846804022789,
0.0033707176335155964,
0.016665223985910416,
0.6995333433151245,
-0.8991039395332336,
0.5335588455200195,
0.29063066840171814,
0.44874903559684753,
0.7366159558296204,
0.1452939510345459,
0.5824398994445801,
-0.9831416010856628,
0.13775043189525604,
0.4164496064186096,
-0.14498327672481537,
-0.03590988740324974,
-0.5913178324699402,
0.6104474663734436,
0.23070736229419708,
-0.78293377161026,
-0.94390469789505,
0.23742640018463135,
-0.907276451587677,
-0.18032629787921906,
0.6716863512992859,
-0.548480749130249,
-0.11268451064825058,
0.18657523393630981,
-0.21613018214702606,
0.08200361579656601,
-0.21850745379924774,
0.6219003200531006,
0.41758397221565247,
-0.5635799169540405,
-0.42541465163230896,
-0.5107247829437256,
0.5341361165046692,
0.23622658848762512,
-0.49438437819480896,
-0.3226267397403717,
0.5453460216522217,
0.0038024731911718845,
0.2629156708717346,
0.5255199670791626,
0.43402883410453796,
0.37134820222854614,
0.4150901436805725,
0.015986094251275063,
-0.4061976373195648,
-0.7031854391098022,
-0.07339143007993698,
0.5333870649337769,
0.1840810477733612,
-0.40785181522369385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09091v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09091v2
|
Semantic In-Domain Product Identification for Search Queries
| 2024-04-13T22:18:14 | 2024-05-29T16:01:27 |
Sanat Sharma, Jayant Kumar, Twisha Naik, Zhaoyu Lu, Arvind Srikantan, Tracy Holloway King
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Accurate explicit and implicit product identification in search queries is
critical for enhancing user experiences, especially at a company like Adobe
which has over 50 products and covers queries across hundreds of tools. In this
work, we present a novel approach to training a product classifier from user
behavioral data. Our semantic model led to >25% relative improvement in CTR
(click through rate) across the deployed surfaces; a >50% decrease in null
rate; a 2x increase in the app cards surfaced, which helps drive product
visibility.
|
[
-0.3383793234825134,
-0.616025447845459,
0.486197829246521,
0.4267517626285553,
0.1007758378982544,
0.3538728952407837,
0.21164056658744812,
-0.7873191833496094,
-0.17925095558166504,
0.43855249881744385,
-0.7479529976844788,
-0.8179940581321716,
-0.2355199009180069,
-0.2620850205421448,
-0.5067667365074158,
0.6880033612251282,
0.03112892620265484,
-0.2110472172498703,
-0.4338231086730957,
-0.13597261905670166,
-0.4265981912612915,
-0.494668185710907,
-0.8022803664207458,
-0.22840353846549988,
0.46449556946754456,
0.38795581459999084,
0.8580461144447327,
0.18132926523685455,
0.4254167377948761,
0.44260767102241516,
0.023094868287444115,
0.08997128158807755,
-0.38434410095214844,
0.17528051137924194,
-0.17766991257667542,
-0.4758566915988922,
-0.09278169274330139,
-0.04673183709383011,
0.13039690256118774,
0.6689630150794983,
-0.05523289740085602,
0.1267899125814438,
0.16020354628562927,
0.5830949544906616,
-0.813245952129364,
0.2604329288005829,
-0.6366834044456482,
0.28861093521118164,
-0.019358891993761063,
-0.30834606289863586,
-0.49298855662345886,
-0.35664138197898865,
0.299348384141922,
-1.1397805213928223,
0.7724196314811707,
0.2074914276599884,
0.9086617231369019,
-0.051702458411455154,
-0.6638854742050171,
-0.2475942075252533,
-0.9649941325187683,
0.6704593300819397,
-0.48276522755622864,
0.752079963684082,
0.281390517950058,
0.47074124217033386,
-0.6207441687583923,
-1.014689564704895,
-0.8168937563896179,
-0.034969087690114975,
-0.1500551700592041,
0.03286837041378021,
0.09322220087051392,
-0.04090951383113861,
0.283835232257843,
0.21890336275100708,
-0.6386185884475708,
-0.13403169810771942,
-0.5062761306762695,
-0.362155556678772,
0.8271728754043579,
0.3343721628189087,
0.4358108341693878,
0.30466610193252563,
-0.6463817954063416,
-0.03690077364444733,
-0.412598192691803,
0.4048873782157898,
0.16499467194080353,
0.18813149631023407,
0.28133055567741394,
0.6458709836006165,
-0.6702765226364136,
0.7660741209983826,
0.3295581042766571,
-0.23939375579357147,
0.4742344915866852,
-0.2552480101585388,
-0.22328676283359528,
0.2958424389362335,
0.36962926387786865,
0.2612334191799164,
-0.0787438228726387,
-0.4151161313056946,
-0.4178803265094757,
0.0662166178226471,
0.41130751371383667,
-0.7873114943504333,
-0.05797601863741875,
0.16818870604038239,
-0.405245840549469,
-0.11915681511163712,
0.44315025210380554,
-0.22805914282798767,
-0.5743120312690735,
-0.4901388883590698,
0.7714291214942932,
-0.2982080280780792,
-0.07221043109893799,
0.3378998637199402,
-0.48174116015434265,
0.7489126920700073,
0.34898293018341064,
-0.7325602769851685,
0.7266278266906738,
0.94647616147995,
0.5859861969947815,
-0.33243632316589355,
-0.08861657977104187,
-0.3978058397769928,
0.41485878825187683,
-0.3945004642009735,
1.008742332458496,
-0.7181234359741211,
-0.6943942308425903,
0.08984289318323135,
0.2790592610836029,
-0.314607173204422,
-0.7912957072257996,
0.3934653699398041,
-1.2069824934005737,
0.1772650182247162,
-0.3936034142971039,
-0.6842233538627625,
-0.4323521554470062,
0.29889625310897827,
-0.8107088208198547,
1.192185640335083,
0.17405833303928375,
-0.6131337881088257,
0.8782393932342529,
-0.7454831004142761,
-0.5690168142318726,
0.36578258872032166,
-0.05641233175992966,
-0.44122248888015747,
0.27293041348457336,
-0.0421207956969738,
0.32921457290649414,
0.05352539196610451,
-0.015678953379392624,
-0.41434022784233093,
-0.3402497470378876,
0.4183702766895294,
0.008514471352100372,
0.576335608959198,
0.3051862418651581,
-0.2932399809360504,
0.12754517793655396,
-0.9639010429382324,
-0.08292516320943832,
0.1960529237985611,
-0.43259668350219727,
-0.45259034633636475,
-0.18294791877269745,
0.32520678639411926,
0.4355771243572235,
0.2785835266113281,
-0.9727045297622681,
0.04094190523028374,
-0.49161645770072937,
-0.07325340807437897,
0.5780439376831055,
0.33568355441093445,
0.27229025959968567,
-0.09701359272003174,
0.4216659665107727,
0.15017583966255188,
0.5732423663139343,
0.2341071516275406,
-0.8462550044059753,
-0.6477160453796387,
-0.17908558249473572,
0.16561895608901978,
0.23382775485515594,
-0.4235733151435852,
0.32434412837028503,
-0.42412489652633667,
-0.5016396641731262,
0.0824616476893425,
0.26147711277008057,
0.2908850908279419,
0.8806514143943787,
0.08997278660535812,
-0.5936307907104492,
0.0624832808971405,
-0.7207616567611694,
-0.3526131212711334,
0.021554728969931602,
-0.39453125,
0.7162758708000183,
0.431056946516037,
-0.3387393057346344,
1.3614012002944946,
-0.6861687302589417,
-0.5783082246780396,
-0.09311595559120178,
0.45500895380973816,
0.1389988660812378,
0.10314139723777771,
0.4286067485809326,
-1.2572530508041382,
-0.7728261947631836,
0.14941240847110748,
-0.4012683629989624,
-0.03470006212592125,
0.10933593660593033,
-0.2474217563867569,
0.3057505786418915,
0.5442030429840088,
-0.527601420879364,
0.8060359358787537,
0.03309527784585953,
-0.567608654499054,
0.2212277054786682,
-0.30794909596443176,
0.07942510396242142,
-0.7464950680732727,
0.0988074243068695,
0.35565385222435,
0.06545040756464005,
-0.45696330070495605,
-0.2613380253314972,
0.07766880095005035,
-0.4615395963191986,
-1.109907627105713,
0.6645855903625488,
-0.2344268411397934,
-0.3118264675140381,
-0.07245022058486938,
-0.08382228761911392,
0.2942603528499603,
0.5883726477622986,
0.2406037151813507,
0.9989339113235474,
0.280910462141037,
-1.1931554079055786,
0.3667951822280884,
0.6154788136482239,
-0.3829292356967926,
0.5907763838768005,
-0.8565430045127869,
-0.0493006557226181,
-0.21932359039783478,
0.2628396153450012,
-1.2670605182647705,
-0.17770828306674957,
0.007901298813521862,
-0.35702982544898987,
0.03617243096232414,
-0.10322645306587219,
-0.7959275841712952,
-0.3315645456314087,
-0.3070175051689148,
0.3333943784236908,
0.2926490604877472,
-0.8962832689285278,
1.0055689811706543,
0.2432125359773636,
0.27940428256988525,
-0.20093058049678802,
-0.30524957180023193,
-0.35752516984939575,
-0.40828192234039307,
-0.9158504009246826,
0.747797966003418,
0.014734050258994102,
0.10385894775390625,
0.023941151797771454,
-0.3716130256652832,
-0.2536899745464325,
0.16156624257564545,
0.4773240089416504,
0.08555774390697479,
-0.09399434924125671,
0.25915980339050293,
-0.18203170597553253,
-0.40031206607818604,
0.01602119393646717,
-0.24042560160160065,
0.37220385670661926,
-0.0353088341653347,
-0.5053812265396118,
-0.6464371681213379,
0.13913534581661224,
0.38700172305107117,
-0.3371288776397705,
0.7369568943977356,
0.6872825622558594,
-0.30166009068489075,
-0.19132663309574127,
-0.44651731848716736,
-0.03296782448887825,
-0.6597303748130798,
0.08286374062299728,
-0.5714539885520935,
-0.35827720165252686,
0.6793529987335205,
-0.32312923669815063,
-0.3893129527568817,
0.6760205030441284,
0.3375377058982849,
-0.058698855340480804,
1.6625779867172241,
1.0355465412139893,
0.059459786862134933,
0.5092123746871948,
-0.39353325963020325,
0.34116432070732117,
-0.5604239106178284,
-1.0417516231536865,
-0.5668929219245911,
-0.36415672302246094,
-0.59260493516922,
-0.019970687106251717,
0.45755821466445923,
-0.16226665675640106,
-0.5569354295730591,
0.4298419952392578,
-0.4309196174144745,
0.27324262261390686,
0.936569333076477,
0.47706282138824463,
0.11729597300291061,
0.054957956075668335,
-0.08399028331041336,
0.10005810111761093,
-0.4202032685279846,
-0.08751820027828217,
0.9751728773117065,
0.1939452439546585,
0.946307897567749,
0.2627590000629425,
0.3529459238052368,
0.4633607566356659,
0.04400015249848366,
-0.8057020306587219,
0.5485380291938782,
0.06009597331285477,
-0.7535977363586426,
-0.14786459505558014,
0.044328123331069946,
-0.9541816711425781,
-0.13597466051578522,
-0.19585102796554565,
-0.7730316519737244,
0.5803875923156738,
0.014817381277680397,
-0.4672744572162628,
-0.3339310586452484,
-0.7984305024147034,
1.161442518234253,
-0.5892238020896912,
-0.5020184516906738,
-0.31202375888824463,
-0.5102370977401733,
-0.0886799544095993,
-0.21167761087417603,
-0.20759743452072144,
-0.15599311888217926,
-0.2394619584083557,
0.9241805076599121,
-0.8110101819038391,
0.6311150193214417,
-0.375836044549942,
0.16049472987651825,
0.14954867959022522,
-0.08056238293647766,
0.6441710591316223,
-0.19434240460395813,
0.22569213807582855,
-0.17166383564472198,
-0.09195224195718765,
-0.40423280000686646,
-1.0664198398590088,
0.542095959186554,
-0.5138685703277588,
-0.44424134492874146,
-0.42633938789367676,
-0.20835301280021667,
-0.6948990225791931,
0.3316996395587921,
0.03684442490339279,
0.43153634667396545,
-0.20876337587833405,
0.2517702281475067,
0.9380655884742737,
-0.4863777756690979,
0.30668216943740845,
0.7956945300102234,
-0.053657323122024536,
0.03366944566369057,
1.010494351387024,
-0.22633475065231323,
-0.06642308086156845,
0.4321953356266022,
0.23409458994865417,
-0.8324341773986816,
-0.43143346905708313,
0.0016130928415805101,
0.20531310141086578,
-0.7899084091186523,
-0.05860109254717827,
-0.7559647560119629,
-0.2583027184009552,
-0.22043290734291077,
-0.08899764716625214,
-0.25705575942993164,
-0.1844349056482315,
-0.34417369961738586,
-0.1078844666481018,
0.5053002834320068,
0.7488652467727661,
0.46034055948257446,
0.6990498304367065,
-0.5594751238822937,
0.3992097079753876,
0.5218874216079712,
0.7918447256088257,
-0.1959308236837387,
-0.351867139339447,
-0.059690725058317184,
-0.12384644150733948,
-0.4328230619430542,
-0.5011444091796875,
0.3414853811264038,
0.5506670475006104,
1.062900424003601,
0.6456527709960938,
0.16876189410686493,
0.5922354459762573,
-0.15402476489543915,
0.8504452109336853,
-0.026272717863321304,
-0.6204460263252258,
0.5659195184707642,
-0.049692656844854355,
0.08965553343296051,
0.650545597076416,
0.9640974998474121,
-0.3721873164176941,
0.06224161386489868,
-0.6938095092773438,
-1.085722804069519,
0.7479663491249084,
-0.05251745507121086,
0.24880249798297882,
0.06445465236902237,
0.008586755022406578,
0.1240977868437767,
0.12160938233137131,
-0.11386123299598694,
-0.14583411812782288,
-0.0012546818470582366,
-0.17601309716701508,
0.16916728019714355,
-0.34114059805870056,
0.19518724083900452,
-0.33854734897613525,
0.875805139541626,
-0.19224847853183746,
0.12045684456825256,
0.0557236522436142,
-0.42103198170661926,
0.33944016695022583,
-0.2720458507537842,
0.3035488724708557,
0.6947435140609741,
-0.28584954142570496,
-0.169605553150177,
-0.11108104139566422,
-0.5963370203971863,
-0.12134464085102081,
-0.08518519997596741,
-0.024728521704673767,
-0.04399960860610008,
-0.1255357712507248,
0.4458545744419098,
0.18268150091171265,
-0.5707479119300842,
0.8385398983955383,
-0.3460509181022644,
-0.15214334428310394,
-0.38639557361602783,
0.1062106192111969,
-0.38325223326683044,
0.23109804093837738,
0.370451420545578,
-0.15273407101631165,
0.9021639823913574,
-0.5102490782737732,
0.44151589274406433,
0.5747429132461548,
-0.6274396777153015,
-0.19299182295799255,
0.8607222437858582,
0.33932024240493774,
-0.28057777881622314,
0.8734995722770691,
0.047389548271894455,
-0.6135923266410828,
0.5733817219734192,
0.611469030380249,
1.1154730319976807,
-0.06256669759750366,
0.3163347542285919,
0.1619904637336731,
-0.3902847468852997,
-0.035956189036369324,
0.1937948763370514,
-0.56668621301651,
-0.8470947742462158,
0.06780564039945602,
-0.6261975765228271,
-0.43116670846939087,
0.07341744005680084,
-0.5413151979446411,
0.5153888463973999,
-0.3451485335826874,
-0.18494725227355957,
0.5176767706871033,
0.3380480706691742,
-0.8921463489532471,
0.5065844058990479,
0.17796577513217926,
1.0559533834457397,
-1.033475399017334,
0.5642324686050415,
0.469725638628006,
-0.750206708908081,
-0.5313826203346252,
-0.1705113798379898,
0.08803335577249527,
-0.5948153734207153,
0.8923781514167786,
0.25264638662338257,
-0.44488203525543213,
-0.2659390866756439,
-0.4985874891281128,
-0.7703069448471069,
1.169122338294983,
-0.12030427902936935,
0.01843699812889099,
0.3933979272842407,
0.5630013942718506,
0.6552659869194031,
-0.39809685945510864,
0.26035159826278687,
0.4880932867527008,
0.3542708456516266,
0.5757454633712769,
-0.5499817728996277,
-0.10849539935588837,
-0.48328158259391785,
0.42166435718536377,
-0.23931919038295746,
-0.19303900003433228,
0.26280608773231506,
0.14780673384666443,
-0.3613910377025604,
-0.17116865515708923,
0.6686167120933533,
0.17101320624351501,
0.7284938097000122,
0.45856404304504395,
0.3829840123653412,
0.7107697129249573,
0.10990103334188461,
1.0363273620605469,
-0.35140088200569153,
0.13254539668560028,
0.8735522031784058,
-0.3757237195968628,
0.8925787806510925,
0.23457486927509308,
-0.02712486870586872,
0.41934287548065186,
0.6449460983276367,
0.047324005514383316,
0.8738210201263428,
0.10251277685165405,
-0.5024901032447815,
-0.07325867563486099,
-0.26502367854118347,
-0.2766840159893036,
0.2639017403125763,
0.4927741587162018,
-0.2884468734264374,
-0.12912596762180328,
0.13746745884418488,
-0.17728416621685028,
0.05415726453065872,
-0.13731442391872406,
1.1360911130905151,
-0.3442787230014801,
-0.18022869527339935,
0.4745253920555115,
0.03570155054330826,
0.6471420526504517,
-0.5095709562301636,
-0.0614268034696579,
-0.3775029480457306,
0.5466639399528503,
-0.5948172807693481,
-0.7863777875900269,
0.3030167818069458,
-0.4435946047306061,
-0.10743392258882523,
-0.0007602006662636995,
0.8394773006439209,
-0.043881505727767944,
-0.5909197926521301,
0.25159141421318054,
0.07965600490570068,
0.03427265211939812,
-0.5153396129608154,
-0.690467894077301,
-0.015976905822753906,
-0.4546138048171997,
-0.41702818870544434,
0.1246705949306488,
0.35438650846481323,
-0.506428062915802,
0.8537178039550781,
0.650224506855011,
-0.4295964539051056,
0.4240165948867798,
0.1571347564458847,
0.835040271282196,
-0.701990008354187,
-0.5110514760017395,
-0.29071128368377686,
0.4165831208229065,
-0.4428749084472656,
-0.034819360822439194,
0.9726626873016357,
1.1603747606277466,
1.0841702222824097,
-0.23510682582855225,
0.6321151852607727,
0.10198090970516205,
0.3821662366390228,
-0.07887455821037292,
0.7563245892524719,
-0.6126794815063477,
0.2932002544403076,
-0.11949159950017929,
-0.9981151223182678,
-0.38016510009765625,
0.3456695079803467,
-0.4240148961544037,
0.0881083756685257,
0.38636329770088196,
1.1186983585357666,
-0.5998613834381104,
-0.040745630860328674,
0.23794688284397125,
-0.11196578294038773,
0.4251507818698883,
0.14948974549770355,
0.7962346076965332,
-0.5366851687431335,
0.41980329155921936,
-0.4541608989238739,
-0.0936293676495552,
-0.35684722661972046,
-0.6909263730049133,
-0.5237546563148499,
-0.6190081238746643,
-0.5231699347496033,
-0.2896150052547455,
-0.019823670387268066,
0.5467109680175781,
0.8604622483253479,
-0.920907735824585,
-0.029687637463212013,
-0.2482587844133377,
-0.0612371452152729,
-0.41702693700790405,
-0.24614198505878448,
0.29234394431114197,
-0.4139368534088135,
-0.40262743830680847,
0.21072852611541748,
0.13782615959644318,
0.012076852843165398,
0.0560021698474884,
-0.06750287115573883,
0.1464853137731552,
0.3504392206668854,
0.7464582920074463,
0.5733130574226379,
-0.4444284737110138,
-0.23722516000270844,
0.10497943311929703,
0.08107031136751175,
0.18850542604923248,
0.6810838580131531,
-1.130685567855835,
0.5173718929290771,
0.654597818851471,
0.543910562992096,
0.9598827958106995,
0.3058697283267975,
0.5004993677139282,
-0.7919533252716064,
0.14355261623859406,
0.001649121637456119,
-0.005200289189815521,
0.20492962002754211,
-0.4090902507305145,
0.43779465556144714,
0.19506601989269257,
-0.18104396760463715,
-0.39321479201316833,
0.0532381646335125,
-1.2212707996368408,
-0.0829111784696579,
1.2030773162841797,
0.017849154770374298,
-0.6438828110694885,
-0.5590416789054871,
-0.2207600474357605,
-0.1713043749332428,
-0.35870447754859924,
0.7568838596343994,
-0.0014205994084477425,
-0.29044997692108154,
0.35309457778930664,
-0.3438194990158081,
0.5561860799789429,
-0.25020357966423035,
-0.5643497109413147,
-0.37250715494155884,
0.4023739695549011,
0.4540562033653259,
0.09515875577926636,
0.4941839873790741,
-0.317605584859848,
0.3378713130950928,
0.011934991925954819,
0.06860755383968353,
-0.09375125169754028,
-0.46031031012535095,
-0.12052673101425171,
0.15196403861045837,
0.2141094207763672,
-0.6196019053459167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09077v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09077v1
|
CuriousLLM: Elevating Multi-Document QA with Reasoning-Infused Knowledge Graph Prompting
| 2024-04-13T20:43:46 | 2024-04-13T20:43:46 |
Zukang Yang, Zixuan Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
In the field of Question Answering (QA), unifying large language models
(LLMs) with external databases has shown great success. However, these methods
often fall short in providing the advanced reasoning needed for complex QA
tasks. To address these issues, we improve over a novel approach called
Knowledge Graph Prompting (KGP), which combines knowledge graphs with a
LLM-based agent to improve reasoning and search accuracy. Nevertheless, the
original KGP framework necessitates costly fine-tuning with large datasets yet
still suffers from LLM hallucination. Therefore, we propose a reasoning-infused
LLM agent to enhance this framework. This agent mimics human curiosity to ask
follow-up questions to more efficiently navigate the search. This simple
modification significantly boosts the LLM performance in QA tasks without the
high costs and latency associated with the initial KGP framework. Our ultimate
goal is to further develop this approach, leading to more accurate, faster, and
cost-effective solutions in the QA domain.
|
[
-0.5065542459487915,
-0.820417046546936,
1.0232584476470947,
-0.1489182412624359,
0.009158628061413765,
0.34470078349113464,
0.13797615468502045,
-0.3180171251296997,
0.3133658468723297,
0.5348023772239685,
-0.8007507920265198,
-0.5835333466529846,
-0.26577240228652954,
0.1457652896642685,
-0.0671088844537735,
0.38641610741615295,
0.057959459722042084,
-0.1828349530696869,
-0.5118635892868042,
-0.04515477642416954,
-0.6192210912704468,
-0.20661196112632751,
-0.7991745471954346,
-0.471983939409256,
0.8967617154121399,
0.45178335905075073,
0.843289852142334,
0.17179232835769653,
-0.07092778384685516,
0.2481396496295929,
-0.0028032485861331224,
0.9816247820854187,
-0.5225850939750671,
0.4357031583786011,
-0.12030959129333496,
-0.8246814608573914,
-0.32794737815856934,
-0.12615332007408142,
0.32829684019088745,
0.5182521939277649,
-0.00935566145926714,
-0.174976646900177,
-0.19560807943344116,
0.8131789565086365,
-0.376617968082428,
0.4000435471534729,
-0.38579314947128296,
-0.15592026710510254,
0.2578001916408539,
-0.5799030661582947,
-0.44834035634994507,
-0.5665808916091919,
0.11851457506418228,
-0.886978805065155,
0.05326957628130913,
0.20833125710487366,
0.7425840497016907,
0.38982605934143066,
-0.5052444934844971,
-0.2628708481788635,
-0.4193750023841858,
0.031140923500061035,
-0.5674002170562744,
0.6155350208282471,
0.31899476051330566,
0.19140693545341492,
-0.4040541350841522,
-0.896700918674469,
-0.8471871018409729,
-0.1982569694519043,
-0.047630760818719864,
0.24056756496429443,
-0.10103347152471542,
0.021253302693367004,
0.3512100577354431,
-0.0586063377559185,
-0.5964634418487549,
-0.08523719757795334,
0.017249174416065216,
-0.13492971658706665,
0.47820913791656494,
0.13160382211208344,
0.4922417104244232,
0.05302566662430763,
-0.07218573242425919,
-0.14734779298305511,
-0.7320895791053772,
0.19344136118888855,
0.35735630989074707,
0.19583635032176971,
0.30745449662208557,
0.6613989472389221,
-0.6465786695480347,
0.6980758905410767,
0.12241031229496002,
0.09438027441501617,
0.13007323443889618,
-0.12005354464054108,
0.0913875624537468,
-0.11119469255208969,
0.518028736114502,
0.5731037259101868,
0.2400224804878235,
-0.325588583946228,
0.09618332237005234,
-0.18566857278347015,
0.36718544363975525,
-0.8197387456893921,
-0.38311970233917236,
0.6991622447967529,
0.10289660841226578,
-0.09750981628894806,
-0.0966152623295784,
-0.4773975908756256,
-0.6696879267692566,
-0.14312490820884705,
0.47203752398490906,
-0.6202524304389954,
-0.16570036113262177,
0.27498432993888855,
-0.22713875770568848,
0.2721593976020813,
0.5870447754859924,
-0.674550473690033,
-0.2528935968875885,
0.475445419549942,
0.3759327530860901,
-0.15040433406829834,
-0.43230268359184265,
-0.5983580946922302,
0.2084074467420578,
-0.5069630146026611,
1.1612857580184937,
-0.5662455558776855,
-0.43648022413253784,
0.11806557327508926,
-0.03426879271864891,
-0.11253976821899414,
-0.45192593336105347,
0.5251287221908569,
-1.209080457687378,
0.5180236101150513,
-0.6524612307548523,
-0.6131641268730164,
-0.4904046654701233,
0.8503312468528748,
-0.4285697340965271,
1.3106848001480103,
0.47373002767562866,
-0.7329543232917786,
0.3399342894554138,
-0.7368335127830505,
-0.18860648572444916,
0.4047296643257141,
-0.1289781928062439,
0.042912665754556656,
-0.39422640204429626,
0.6409622430801392,
0.4516996741294861,
-0.20359094440937042,
0.10376685112714767,
-0.39552611112594604,
-0.2375030219554901,
0.3374713361263275,
-0.04225494712591171,
0.528163492679596,
0.05738050118088722,
0.14901021122932434,
0.2555847764015198,
-0.5524677038192749,
0.5662919282913208,
0.22474932670593262,
-0.4003324806690216,
-0.33645689487457275,
-0.25292980670928955,
-0.5723284482955933,
0.2594811022281647,
0.3889977037906647,
-0.25293204188346863,
0.5493401288986206,
-0.4425404965877533,
0.03934982419013977,
0.5702200531959534,
0.191099613904953,
0.3140604496002197,
-0.6316961646080017,
0.8001450896263123,
-0.23526909947395325,
0.03969718515872955,
-0.12956075370311737,
-0.8514469861984253,
-0.6665295362472534,
-0.21812433004379272,
0.013334530405700207,
0.552362859249115,
-1.1145920753479004,
0.017258640378713608,
-0.2380981743335724,
-0.46994081139564514,
-0.6588207483291626,
0.1022055447101593,
0.06865083426237106,
0.733754575252533,
0.37311702966690063,
0.06021541729569435,
-0.0661797896027565,
-0.46486207842826843,
-0.20681026577949524,
-0.3780672252178192,
-0.13572897017002106,
0.6971730589866638,
-0.09818242490291595,
-0.4873916208744049,
1.112523078918457,
-0.9096265435218811,
-0.08763120323419571,
-0.33737173676490784,
-0.008412305265665054,
0.2958250939846039,
0.04866557568311691,
0.36093848943710327,
-0.8423218131065369,
-0.6572588086128235,
0.04147718846797943,
-0.7725872993469238,
-0.3267562687397003,
0.12076620012521744,
-0.3859362304210663,
-0.14928856492042542,
0.47542068362236023,
-1.13739013671875,
-0.036213211715221405,
-0.04088033363223076,
-0.38150647282600403,
0.6138167977333069,
-0.25240662693977356,
0.4724295139312744,
-1.0701855421066284,
-0.11847289651632309,
-0.5240371227264404,
-0.03320401534438133,
-0.7104672789573669,
0.47677668929100037,
0.24009481072425842,
-0.19413992762565613,
-0.4512297213077545,
0.7464888095855713,
-0.4421280324459076,
0.18923184275627136,
-0.2501668334007263,
0.5151464343070984,
0.4465775191783905,
0.5170055627822876,
-0.24453681707382202,
0.9743073582649231,
0.6072364449501038,
-0.725498378276825,
0.6216129064559937,
0.4943511486053467,
0.2647397220134735,
0.5754300951957703,
-0.4363264739513397,
0.551234245300293,
-0.3445380628108978,
0.16662220656871796,
-0.9583650231361389,
-0.38901379704475403,
0.2958360016345978,
-0.5417467355728149,
0.39996615052223206,
-0.10441505908966064,
-0.7936239242553711,
-0.578741192817688,
-0.41940513253211975,
0.058428503572940826,
0.310759961605072,
-0.7305870652198792,
0.9422054886817932,
0.026893213391304016,
-0.1433849185705185,
-0.47265172004699707,
-0.16115418076515198,
0.16062267124652863,
-0.04874606803059578,
-1.0297846794128418,
0.01612163707613945,
-0.3771413564682007,
-0.015275213867425919,
-0.03386426344513893,
0.018352793529629707,
0.02090095728635788,
0.22515785694122314,
0.09699265658855438,
0.2937287986278534,
-0.15706388652324677,
0.35168036818504333,
0.23844751715660095,
-0.010947972536087036,
0.24637287855148315,
-0.6753624081611633,
0.6034897565841675,
-0.005467177834361792,
-0.49527403712272644,
-0.21969637274742126,
0.3296491503715515,
0.4260101020336151,
-0.201161727309227,
0.3168589174747467,
0.5244488716125488,
-0.18531717360019684,
-0.39037078619003296,
-0.629531741142273,
-0.41679689288139343,
-0.4935319721698761,
0.2624889314174652,
-0.6948308944702148,
-1.0980254411697388,
0.5634699463844299,
-0.38790085911750793,
-0.22945845127105713,
0.29654064774513245,
0.5740756392478943,
-0.18616943061351776,
1.081496238708496,
0.358154833316803,
0.14405639469623566,
0.0498424768447876,
-0.11581016331911087,
0.23558148741722107,
-0.6764624714851379,
-0.533823549747467,
-0.4418396055698395,
0.12417198717594147,
-0.3511083424091339,
-0.6884341239929199,
0.5069935917854309,
0.18328236043453217,
0.28635677695274353,
-0.05329378321766853,
-0.5025976300239563,
0.6239742636680603,
0.5553748607635498,
0.019473910331726074,
0.36739495396614075,
-0.28211572766304016,
-0.4576292634010315,
0.27422797679901123,
-0.9684097766876221,
-0.30965256690979004,
1.005443811416626,
-0.04382145404815674,
0.6455017328262329,
0.23696233332157135,
0.6105765104293823,
0.24182438850402832,
0.2777596712112427,
-0.7182154655456543,
0.5956616401672363,
0.5064308643341064,
-0.4611743688583374,
-0.5185005068778992,
-0.2707546353340149,
-1.116092324256897,
0.3632410168647766,
-0.15671803057193756,
-0.7955420613288879,
0.07503416389226913,
0.08682237565517426,
-0.42104199528694153,
0.09253805875778198,
-0.7402767539024353,
0.567430317401886,
0.04770299419760704,
-0.2546428143978119,
-0.06020539253950119,
-0.5665056705474854,
0.35334619879722595,
0.04038775712251663,
-0.09145544469356537,
-0.045553531497716904,
0.004122001584619284,
0.334786981344223,
-0.31738391518592834,
0.5202900171279907,
-0.08958208560943604,
-0.3362499475479126,
0.38299691677093506,
0.1811968982219696,
1.0599677562713623,
0.21424373984336853,
-0.062351081520318985,
-0.5248520374298096,
-0.08855806291103363,
-0.3300648629665375,
-0.9718512892723083,
0.7404873371124268,
-0.6021227836608887,
-1.0053926706314087,
-0.09765219688415527,
-1.0084228515625,
-0.8935196399688721,
0.48174846172332764,
-0.1136971190571785,
0.14394927024841309,
0.08030807971954346,
-0.15118864178657532,
1.0396921634674072,
-0.09184341132640839,
-0.004416411276906729,
0.8620572686195374,
-0.6159838438034058,
-0.0785713940858841,
0.9161614179611206,
-0.014211088418960571,
0.1845189779996872,
0.6262339353561401,
0.26640114188194275,
-0.7781712412834167,
-0.5259409546852112,
-0.5660958290100098,
0.2685911953449249,
-0.9045022130012512,
0.024305004626512527,
-1.1876603364944458,
0.01607019640505314,
-0.6684383153915405,
-0.11813950538635254,
0.029204029589891434,
-0.3343804180622101,
-0.44516897201538086,
-0.24144606292247772,
0.546857476234436,
0.4495016932487488,
0.3544265329837799,
-0.004822640214115381,
-0.9477869272232056,
0.5450124740600586,
0.91352778673172,
0.14074447751045227,
-0.010247576050460339,
-0.3578532338142395,
-0.027740901336073875,
-0.19662964344024658,
-0.12246721237897873,
-1.006548285484314,
0.28357553482055664,
-0.2683946490287781,
0.6573569774627686,
0.33997324109077454,
0.4143279194831848,
0.32332655787467957,
-0.07783105969429016,
0.5032152533531189,
-0.15732288360595703,
-0.43438833951950073,
0.4067970812320709,
-0.5612090826034546,
0.45868903398513794,
0.4803629517555237,
0.4373956620693207,
-0.5927119851112366,
-0.70733642578125,
-0.5500450730323792,
-0.7029304504394531,
0.5827004909515381,
-0.02215471863746643,
0.021010300144553185,
0.015988299623131752,
0.4055787920951843,
0.027413638308644295,
0.28281164169311523,
-0.20405296981334686,
-0.24778404831886292,
-0.1350688338279724,
0.08610329777002335,
0.26506713032722473,
-0.28993910551071167,
-0.34924066066741943,
0.0016915574669837952,
0.7842397689819336,
-0.8343272805213928,
0.08044888079166412,
0.46647909283638,
-0.09458606690168381,
0.07014801353216171,
0.48172006011009216,
0.34990355372428894,
0.6920680403709412,
-0.33841001987457275,
0.19201020896434784,
0.25830209255218506,
-0.25960350036621094,
0.09187096357345581,
0.4218751788139343,
-0.37038740515708923,
-0.20419125258922577,
-0.039457932114601135,
0.5433720350265503,
-0.19256490468978882,
-0.8049790263175964,
0.3741745054721832,
-0.09815146028995514,
-0.1743798702955246,
0.14226126670837402,
0.36057573556900024,
0.6442731618881226,
0.539387583732605,
0.5840893983840942,
-0.3899039030075073,
0.10313144326210022,
-0.3780931234359741,
0.11819462478160858,
0.348495751619339,
-0.4683539569377899,
0.08869124203920364,
0.7714865803718567,
0.10358526557683945,
-0.2784578800201416,
0.5837939977645874,
-0.5916610360145569,
-0.6588560342788696,
0.6314980387687683,
0.31832680106163025,
0.7984996438026428,
0.1279190331697464,
0.566368043422699,
-0.06803061068058014,
0.4389004409313202,
0.13657978177070618,
0.7086225748062134,
0.008518101647496223,
-0.9312258958816528,
-0.46219003200531006,
-0.10560885816812515,
-0.7123738527297974,
-0.1569323092699051,
-0.23599793016910553,
0.005647778045386076,
-0.16459570825099945,
0.09673218429088593,
-0.11109499633312225,
0.14996543526649475,
-0.5022426247596741,
0.23710480332374573,
-0.1372305005788803,
0.9082199931144714,
-0.3553372919559479,
0.8857315182685852,
0.7513940930366516,
-0.46715131402015686,
-1.2430442571640015,
0.04082184284925461,
-0.1464798003435135,
-0.9186950325965881,
0.31827378273010254,
0.22380244731903076,
-0.1952822208404541,
0.3647008240222931,
-0.5047609806060791,
-0.5670042037963867,
1.4153099060058594,
0.36286279559135437,
-0.21601822972297668,
-0.01683148182928562,
0.041279375553131104,
0.5796473622322083,
-0.28306499123573303,
0.38203760981559753,
0.2647320628166199,
0.6615613698959351,
0.21017935872077942,
-0.2744820713996887,
0.41744664311408997,
-0.23279547691345215,
-0.3459948003292084,
0.11389835178852081,
-0.8545443415641785,
0.5767996907234192,
-0.6457141041755676,
-0.15917401015758514,
-0.20639266073703766,
0.5911112427711487,
0.561856746673584,
0.6088703274726868,
0.43604111671447754,
0.48716235160827637,
1.361384630203247,
0.07414793968200684,
1.1678804159164429,
-0.42993879318237305,
0.017462996765971184,
0.9885055422782898,
-0.608856201171875,
0.4057873487472534,
0.40963470935821533,
-0.3440837562084198,
0.3653683662414551,
0.7033495903015137,
0.23287846148014069,
0.1306103616952896,
-0.07866174727678299,
-0.31609171628952026,
-0.5147951245307922,
-0.4295506179332733,
-0.4946500360965729,
-0.09824951738119125,
0.11239423602819443,
0.12305127084255219,
-0.1413639336824417,
-0.2147500216960907,
-0.025648094713687897,
0.026026161387562752,
-0.147169291973114,
0.654716432094574,
-0.02810652367770672,
-0.8606402277946472,
0.40160536766052246,
-0.15319222211837769,
0.19340746104717255,
-0.7783899307250977,
0.0310071911662817,
-0.46574151515960693,
-0.34160733222961426,
-0.19007998704910278,
-0.8409870266914368,
-0.20349079370498657,
-0.4901181757450104,
-0.2593670189380646,
-0.1649729311466217,
0.978488028049469,
-0.5799323320388794,
-0.06860911846160889,
0.3487210273742676,
1.0479587316513062,
0.06521052122116089,
-0.46106210350990295,
-0.5874210596084595,
-0.4768432676792145,
0.05921592190861702,
-0.34657129645347595,
0.37069249153137207,
0.7297306060791016,
-0.09529542922973633,
1.2190691232681274,
1.0402700901031494,
-0.18384237587451935,
0.053732506930828094,
0.4619223475456238,
1.2658696174621582,
-0.5722976326942444,
-0.6713266372680664,
-0.3684282898902893,
0.32550978660583496,
-0.09614033252000809,
-0.09340576082468033,
0.8649821877479553,
0.49063608050346375,
0.45736441016197205,
-0.04272066429257393,
0.549645185470581,
0.16898955404758453,
0.5045875310897827,
-0.6631083488464355,
0.7424384951591492,
-0.6293481588363647,
0.34547820687294006,
-0.04541553556919098,
-0.640995979309082,
-0.1062021553516388,
-0.1336691677570343,
0.007278527598828077,
-0.039376527070999146,
0.8906044363975525,
1.1309432983398438,
0.24677999317646027,
0.0019989446736872196,
0.5323485136032104,
0.2398916780948639,
0.38108623027801514,
0.3962956368923187,
1.0460964441299438,
0.07744970172643661,
0.6028971672058105,
0.020645776763558388,
0.02458055317401886,
-0.33582398295402527,
-0.6811134219169617,
-0.9289575815200806,
-0.3115316927433014,
-0.3144516348838806,
-0.521735429763794,
-0.015774434432387352,
0.8213048577308655,
0.38856586813926697,
-0.4375414252281189,
0.4330231547355652,
0.010293092578649521,
0.706437349319458,
-0.2617413103580475,
-0.2854040563106537,
0.43788596987724304,
-0.457518070936203,
-0.5730504989624023,
0.7232332229614258,
0.4566376209259033,
0.023010794073343277,
-0.37034401297569275,
-0.276157021522522,
-0.42390429973602295,
0.25389230251312256,
0.5349515080451965,
0.31031450629234314,
-0.5254665017127991,
-0.28160789608955383,
0.32700979709625244,
-0.18699970841407776,
0.175950825214386,
0.5915031433105469,
-0.956028938293457,
0.8063459396362305,
0.6862265467643738,
1.013710856437683,
0.6500667333602905,
-0.035716619342565536,
0.5583856105804443,
-0.5789586305618286,
-0.25912562012672424,
0.2596711218357086,
0.08202282339334488,
0.3035772442817688,
-0.7240060567855835,
0.6061049699783325,
0.360080361366272,
-0.3739282786846161,
-0.6442180871963501,
0.2608598470687866,
-1.058485746383667,
-0.2602197527885437,
1.1837105751037598,
-0.20028938353061676,
-0.10499539226293564,
-0.4173682928085327,
-0.5590621829032898,
0.12454737722873688,
-0.6044055819511414,
0.8140451908111572,
0.7316905856132507,
-0.33766597509384155,
-0.3461574912071228,
-0.3559921681880951,
0.4311274290084839,
0.4232637882232666,
-1.1893950700759888,
0.0024838936515152454,
0.512458324432373,
0.11879491806030273,
0.16150395572185516,
0.9219313263893127,
0.16318906843662262,
0.4665595591068268,
-0.03998027741909027,
0.0005903660203330219,
-0.3887365758419037,
-0.18049989640712738,
0.04518149420619011,
0.5675585269927979,
0.41079404950141907,
0.09350305050611496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09066v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09066v1
|
CodeCloak: A Method for Evaluating and Mitigating Code Leakage by LLM Code Assistants
| 2024-04-13T19:30:58 | 2024-04-13T19:30:58 |
Amit Finkman, Eden Bar-Kochva, Avishag Shapira, Dudu Mimran, Yuval Elovici, Asaf Shabtai
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PL
|
LLM-based code assistants are becoming increasingly popular among developers.
These tools help developers improve their coding efficiency and reduce errors
by providing real-time suggestions based on the developer's codebase. While
beneficial, these tools might inadvertently expose the developer's proprietary
code to the code assistant service provider during the development process. In
this work, we propose two complementary methods to mitigate the risk of code
leakage when using LLM-based code assistants. The first is a technique for
reconstructing a developer's original codebase from code segments sent to the
code assistant service (i.e., prompts) during the development process, enabling
assessment and evaluation of the extent of code leakage to third parties (or
adversaries). The second is CodeCloak, a novel deep reinforcement learning
agent that manipulates the prompts before sending them to the code assistant
service. CodeCloak aims to achieve the following two contradictory goals: (i)
minimizing code leakage, while (ii) preserving relevant and useful suggestions
for the developer. Our evaluation, employing GitHub Copilot, StarCoder, and
CodeLlama LLM-based code assistants models, demonstrates the effectiveness of
our CodeCloak approach on a diverse set of code repositories of varying sizes,
as well as its transferability across different models. In addition, we
generate a realistic simulated coding environment to thoroughly analyze code
leakage risks and evaluate the effectiveness of our proposed mitigation
techniques under practical development scenarios.
|
[
-0.25599557161331177,
-0.5836818218231201,
0.3404051661491394,
0.3501463234424591,
-0.38600972294807434,
0.5889692306518555,
-0.07867447286844254,
-0.4774859845638275,
0.3346264660358429,
0.7736857533454895,
-0.6577990651130676,
-0.48961156606674194,
-0.3530990779399872,
-0.008087239228188992,
-0.1222660019993782,
0.8657687306404114,
-0.3067605793476105,
-0.15457628667354584,
-0.4306428134441376,
0.13543887436389923,
-0.7709969878196716,
-0.3718259036540985,
-0.7561872005462646,
-0.0623067244887352,
0.15910905599594116,
0.4947269856929779,
0.525655210018158,
0.3990572690963745,
0.440906286239624,
0.25010600686073303,
0.10462630540132523,
0.0959790050983429,
-0.4348951280117035,
0.12545689940452576,
0.2513353228569031,
-0.5492709279060364,
-0.3972485363483429,
-0.1980050802230835,
-0.10451760143041611,
0.012189135886728764,
-0.20994503796100616,
0.271841824054718,
0.04219038784503937,
0.7446707487106323,
-0.7847243547439575,
0.05958980321884155,
-0.4526247978210449,
0.27617210149765015,
0.04289072006940842,
-0.433305561542511,
-0.37378600239753723,
-0.6187347769737244,
-0.1308109611272812,
-0.6027714014053345,
-0.21088628470897675,
-0.2437981516122818,
0.2197580337524414,
0.5275657773017883,
0.043091487139463425,
-0.7469821572303772,
-0.5065699815750122,
0.43029895424842834,
-0.6622180342674255,
-0.06703153997659683,
0.40996053814888,
0.31597188115119934,
-0.016339952126145363,
-0.29508331418037415,
-0.3758101463317871,
-0.6367331147193909,
0.1409395933151245,
0.0873120129108429,
-0.04721476510167122,
-0.11619339138269424,
-0.09026508778333664,
0.3233441114425659,
-0.6442732214927673,
0.0014631355879828334,
-0.38077396154403687,
-0.5153301358222961,
0.6666043400764465,
0.09187963604927063,
0.4477813243865967,
0.1683737188577652,
-0.8423324823379517,
-0.1760953962802887,
-0.88994961977005,
0.26068100333213806,
0.584193229675293,
-0.14283789694309235,
-0.025946686044335365,
0.22654584050178528,
0.05971721187233925,
0.33362847566604614,
-0.12220391631126404,
-0.12254799157381058,
0.3330219089984894,
-0.2631273567676544,
-0.037998974323272705,
0.08514993637800217,
0.4536879360675812,
0.1972082257270813,
0.1871679574251175,
-0.2676452100276947,
-0.2864089012145996,
0.13043023645877838,
0.4341296851634979,
-0.39632448554039,
-0.3412110507488251,
0.2349003553390503,
-0.432559996843338,
-0.843771755695343,
0.21993692219257355,
-0.8135296702384949,
-0.6477459669113159,
0.00605554087087512,
0.10777298361063004,
-0.04635560140013695,
-0.3525025248527527,
-0.10273755341768265,
0.023831501603126526,
0.22438262403011322,
0.24658773839473724,
-0.5376765131950378,
0.24707309901714325,
0.8062313795089722,
0.7006474733352661,
-0.5313623547554016,
-0.22679458558559418,
-0.5436999201774597,
0.16629135608673096,
-0.4725261330604553,
0.695064127445221,
-0.39369168877601624,
-0.850136935710907,
0.235651433467865,
-0.08920450508594513,
0.32770445942878723,
-0.6638026237487793,
0.08097775280475616,
-0.6729402542114258,
-0.4390057325363159,
0.095583975315094,
-0.37313929200172424,
0.13680100440979004,
0.3205781579017639,
-0.7797520756721497,
0.6856406927108765,
0.04483870044350624,
-0.15552785992622375,
0.025036698207259178,
-0.5480377078056335,
-0.34600579738616943,
-0.04800654947757721,
-0.1898527443408966,
-0.3122483789920807,
-0.07450734078884125,
0.4057314395904541,
0.3385152518749237,
0.1962994784116745,
-0.020510233938694,
-0.16588814556598663,
-0.5382825136184692,
0.5240048170089722,
-0.47076210379600525,
0.7409928441047668,
0.367071270942688,
-0.2783960998058319,
0.14867594838142395,
-0.456612765789032,
-0.013005556538701057,
-0.031311023980379105,
-0.5077869892120361,
-0.22707496583461761,
-0.6252559423446655,
-0.4299892485141754,
0.08930861949920654,
0.35297080874443054,
-0.3865568935871124,
0.5926538109779358,
-0.25459060072898865,
0.11349546909332275,
0.9429326057434082,
0.24755018949508667,
0.5715178847312927,
-0.3749404847621918,
1.1261595487594604,
-0.3115570843219757,
0.38923370838165283,
-0.2913057208061218,
-0.4061218500137329,
-0.31325170397758484,
-0.29474151134490967,
0.18208089470863342,
0.7135676741600037,
-1.0701522827148438,
0.08177176862955093,
-0.13624702394008636,
-0.504196047782898,
-0.5462139844894409,
0.6807737350463867,
0.8201481103897095,
0.27288618683815,
0.11703108251094818,
-0.2801332175731659,
-0.2822451591491699,
-0.600689709186554,
-0.2683327794075012,
-0.10939154773950577,
0.0897367000579834,
0.29548484086990356,
0.25584298372268677,
-0.3913058042526245,
0.5802069306373596,
-0.4810449779033661,
-0.07867998629808426,
-0.1886754333972931,
-0.12909440696239471,
-0.10242898762226105,
0.6027417182922363,
0.3482748568058014,
-0.5844160318374634,
-0.2688799500465393,
-0.13684634864330292,
-0.46741071343421936,
-0.20097865164279938,
-0.363424152135849,
-0.12441936880350113,
0.2997511625289917,
0.71927809715271,
-0.4170849621295929,
0.635787844657898,
0.8469001650810242,
-0.31135499477386475,
0.6558119058609009,
-0.25704872608184814,
0.0947246178984642,
-0.7457583546638489,
0.07390588521957397,
-0.6587796211242676,
-0.259427011013031,
-0.31504228711128235,
0.1750374585390091,
0.06672228127717972,
-0.3716699182987213,
-0.6895009279251099,
0.4951244592666626,
-0.438689261674881,
-0.24262911081314087,
-0.4182637929916382,
0.051614418625831604,
0.11949393153190613,
0.5416476726531982,
-0.20354606211185455,
1.2457019090652466,
0.21711157262325287,
-0.719996988773346,
0.3869880139827728,
0.16595180332660675,
-0.11832690984010696,
0.035079944878816605,
-0.5317919254302979,
0.6377810835838318,
0.39403077960014343,
0.375280499458313,
-0.7929685711860657,
0.2538587749004364,
0.6000677943229675,
-0.6054247617721558,
0.20084136724472046,
-0.28919467329978943,
-0.30523478984832764,
-0.1491188108921051,
-0.8349522352218628,
0.30563730001449585,
0.48352399468421936,
-0.7199695110321045,
0.22989951074123383,
0.4381345510482788,
-0.3291878402233124,
-0.7800001502037048,
-0.8561305403709412,
0.06508655846118927,
-0.18320956826210022,
-0.6643146872520447,
0.34374749660491943,
-0.2976491451263428,
-0.17126746475696564,
0.10961984097957611,
-0.44675976037979126,
-0.09291958063840866,
0.4271315932273865,
0.5794915556907654,
0.48101431131362915,
-0.0012442237930372357,
0.08538245409727097,
0.039564236998558044,
-0.507667064666748,
0.24422338604927063,
-0.08322456479072571,
0.41938260197639465,
-0.17768540978431702,
-0.4838196933269501,
-0.162761852145195,
0.20999275147914886,
0.33989474177360535,
-0.2630348801612854,
0.3655664026737213,
0.3137330710887909,
0.014935935847461224,
-0.33291906118392944,
-0.3960995376110077,
-0.04416541010141373,
-0.5145757794380188,
0.06879302859306335,
-0.2966565489768982,
-0.6231314539909363,
0.5347905158996582,
-0.4431299567222595,
-0.04694715514779091,
-0.0631503015756607,
0.46080702543258667,
0.01066205557435751,
0.39740297198295593,
0.7816102504730225,
-0.2621918320655823,
0.5916885733604431,
-0.5562035441398621,
0.010947595350444317,
-0.8703271746635437,
-0.071428582072258,
-0.17704741656780243,
-0.031842563301324844,
-0.2039625495672226,
-0.5156452655792236,
0.13706901669502258,
0.14533798396587372,
0.2167450189590454,
0.5804836750030518,
-0.47786685824394226,
0.6024034023284912,
0.4462926685810089,
0.10995438694953918,
0.335575133562088,
-0.09592776000499725,
-0.0040309131145477295,
0.4981801509857178,
-0.48527416586875916,
-0.6465469002723694,
1.1228959560394287,
0.5759986639022827,
0.8551554679870605,
0.14996439218521118,
1.0296398401260376,
0.485787034034729,
0.3041676878929138,
-0.45137086510658264,
0.43353334069252014,
0.21577398478984833,
-0.35151922702789307,
-0.3004864454269409,
-0.28134238719940186,
-0.8265892267227173,
-0.038137178868055344,
0.12425019592046738,
-0.49389323592185974,
0.3450126051902771,
0.3811300992965698,
-0.44871366024017334,
0.12400102615356445,
-0.7457112073898315,
0.7867783308029175,
-0.1371467262506485,
-0.19514726102352142,
-0.2524474561214447,
-0.2777787148952484,
0.49480676651000977,
-0.03968682140111923,
0.1815519481897354,
0.046865932643413544,
-0.4856661558151245,
0.5525421500205994,
-0.39428821206092834,
0.756286084651947,
-0.31655701994895935,
-0.38417482376098633,
0.631731390953064,
0.63630610704422,
0.7934145331382751,
0.5012550950050354,
0.002884868998080492,
0.14471440017223358,
-0.02450576052069664,
-0.37294769287109375,
-0.6893620491027832,
0.7435564994812012,
-0.685296356678009,
-0.4567584991455078,
-0.1485770344734192,
-0.4001352787017822,
-0.23901809751987457,
-0.1305284947156906,
0.11732510477304459,
0.20586642622947693,
-0.03313920274376869,
0.040713101625442505,
0.47309601306915283,
-0.5063855051994324,
0.545201301574707,
0.45263758301734924,
-0.2899770140647888,
-0.4295863211154938,
0.9266297221183777,
-0.4385741055011749,
0.3260360658168793,
0.11477892100811005,
0.2241305708885193,
0.06054908409714699,
-0.64569491147995,
-0.24597840011119843,
-0.10812855511903763,
-0.7093517184257507,
-0.5625655055046082,
-0.08517524600028992,
0.02193201147019863,
-0.2532491087913513,
-0.45399904251098633,
-0.2892950177192688,
-0.30997002124786377,
0.04029597342014313,
-0.27598628401756287,
0.3965147137641907,
0.44300153851509094,
-0.004130466375499964,
0.22731858491897583,
-0.8007715940475464,
0.2960297465324402,
0.2944389283657074,
0.2927684783935547,
-0.13230782747268677,
-0.15785875916481018,
-0.13355307281017303,
-0.03882501646876335,
-0.11227957159280777,
-0.873865008354187,
0.44493284821510315,
-0.3468532860279083,
0.6516528725624084,
0.2515875995159149,
0.11890657991170883,
0.40725958347320557,
-0.1484963446855545,
0.894213855266571,
0.003652494866400957,
-0.8605977296829224,
0.7875299453735352,
-0.10276123136281967,
0.0796818807721138,
0.8796927332878113,
-0.21881897747516632,
-0.2533305287361145,
-0.4251176416873932,
-0.6341187953948975,
-0.8646095991134644,
0.3737668991088867,
0.30639585852622986,
0.08541861176490784,
0.17522887885570526,
0.3090445399284363,
0.29572364687919617,
0.3817671537399292,
-0.6018970012664795,
-0.14978301525115967,
-0.18209968507289886,
-0.05672961845993996,
0.08078693598508835,
-0.2461978644132614,
-0.2836814522743225,
0.2854967713356018,
0.4935897886753082,
-0.09923084080219269,
0.3056132197380066,
0.26502397656440735,
-0.6309780478477478,
0.12486576288938522,
0.25219255685806274,
0.9373525381088257,
0.6053308248519897,
0.04015010595321655,
0.17860396206378937,
0.23585103452205658,
-0.8520419001579285,
0.140513077378273,
-0.17797963321208954,
-0.05345095694065094,
-0.16734853386878967,
0.591094434261322,
0.3739567697048187,
0.30638694763183594,
-0.8663110136985779,
0.6042004227638245,
0.05315510928630829,
0.08062310516834259,
-0.4992709457874298,
0.2733229696750641,
0.0386594720184803,
0.19381901621818542,
0.23180289566516876,
0.38805681467056274,
0.22565798461437225,
-0.5858599543571472,
0.26041144132614136,
0.15884901583194733,
-0.282566100358963,
-0.058067332953214645,
0.19098898768424988,
0.48602962493896484,
-0.4712018370628357,
0.2170996367931366,
-0.2698894441127777,
-0.4704510271549225,
1.2019544839859009,
0.3792642056941986,
1.0389158725738525,
-0.20929087698459625,
0.18199095129966736,
-0.17888179421424866,
0.3688366711139679,
0.27003347873687744,
0.1266445815563202,
-0.1813117116689682,
-0.428925096988678,
-0.2407132238149643,
-0.009582970291376114,
-0.39240214228630066,
-0.15134179592132568,
-0.42387810349464417,
0.011141323484480381,
-0.61705482006073,
0.1728104054927826,
-0.4925776422023773,
0.17324186861515045,
-0.5389661192893982,
-0.4384050965309143,
0.2377041131258011,
1.154022455215454,
-0.5046391487121582,
0.836192786693573,
0.45888298749923706,
-0.47876861691474915,
-0.6746999621391296,
0.2717735171318054,
0.183978870511055,
-1.2253698110580444,
0.5422726273536682,
0.05081486329436302,
-0.339987188577652,
-0.41947096586227417,
-0.456086665391922,
-0.6193044781684875,
1.46904456615448,
0.3687465786933899,
-0.47402825951576233,
0.37863799929618835,
-0.04597765579819679,
0.28534865379333496,
-0.35628974437713623,
0.09268645197153091,
0.48511451482772827,
0.41363784670829773,
-0.2968534231185913,
-0.6725329160690308,
0.2503010034561157,
-0.23005616664886475,
0.17962849140167236,
-0.1007976159453392,
-0.3437376022338867,
0.36580419540405273,
-0.32438015937805176,
0.022901177406311035,
0.19820332527160645,
0.20050843060016632,
0.526819109916687,
0.48669975996017456,
0.6020898222923279,
0.06100844219326973,
0.6860095858573914,
0.5127449035644531,
1.100664496421814,
-0.48918837308883667,
0.1334911733865738,
0.8603313565254211,
-0.0358617901802063,
0.7059144973754883,
0.6060336828231812,
-0.11784397065639496,
0.337598592042923,
0.3679535984992981,
0.05716279149055481,
0.7760478258132935,
0.39153289794921875,
-0.18471074104309082,
0.3228985667228699,
0.16492357850074768,
-0.40905317664146423,
0.08426368236541748,
0.23649558424949646,
-0.0065898168832063675,
0.00366226932965219,
0.14207793772220612,
0.14649540185928345,
0.17964331805706024,
-0.2607581317424774,
0.9008030891418457,
0.12237676978111267,
-0.5385279655456543,
0.398481160402298,
-0.3308967649936676,
0.6891376972198486,
-0.445250540971756,
-0.22692789137363434,
-0.502760648727417,
0.14130738377571106,
-0.14852897822856903,
-0.665772557258606,
0.44128504395484924,
0.05720513314008713,
0.26238080859184265,
-0.18697835505008698,
0.9009411931037903,
-0.23776908218860626,
-0.05150934308767319,
0.3417639136314392,
0.19723626971244812,
0.10064312070608139,
-0.028432900086045265,
-0.8367025256156921,
0.45765772461891174,
0.09754449129104614,
-0.12880060076713562,
0.2592290937900543,
0.1714499145746231,
0.24442744255065918,
0.8619940280914307,
0.7831957936286926,
0.22390425205230713,
0.14031991362571716,
-0.09186504781246185,
0.8979538083076477,
-0.33286985754966736,
-0.6117178201675415,
-0.7145353555679321,
0.36242982745170593,
-0.06862688809633255,
-0.36024439334869385,
0.6706818342208862,
0.4421840012073517,
0.5257646441459656,
-0.4132939875125885,
0.5682215690612793,
0.30019325017929077,
0.0492815300822258,
-0.8571708798408508,
0.4159858524799347,
0.13051317632198334,
0.913715660572052,
-0.38995951414108276,
-0.639142632484436,
-0.1231919601559639,
0.40746238827705383,
-0.27144819498062134,
-0.13433198630809784,
0.5658147931098938,
0.8970168828964233,
0.22084049880504608,
-0.20632120966911316,
0.23126786947250366,
-0.1106807217001915,
0.3876253366470337,
0.7454787492752075,
0.978683590888977,
-0.2360648810863495,
1.0922505855560303,
-0.5082831978797913,
-0.31834152340888977,
-0.39781856536865234,
-0.7353193163871765,
-0.7497807741165161,
-0.11532115191221237,
-0.3917619287967682,
-0.2086288332939148,
0.2610999643802643,
0.564855694770813,
0.6626813411712646,
-0.624565839767456,
0.024087218567728996,
-0.28638121485710144,
0.42687004804611206,
-0.4823686182498932,
-0.23804520070552826,
0.2495625913143158,
-0.3744505047798157,
-0.1217125877737999,
0.543587863445282,
0.10478395223617554,
-0.10336097329854965,
-0.574255645275116,
-0.31884321570396423,
0.3754711449146271,
-0.0945497676730156,
0.3059145510196686,
0.49649208784103394,
-0.6086323261260986,
-0.2254476100206375,
0.06876572221517563,
-0.16964146494865417,
-0.03014892339706421,
1.0496329069137573,
-1.0039106607437134,
0.16678830981254578,
0.3844234347343445,
0.9588391184806824,
0.24802444875240326,
0.07849361002445221,
0.636277973651886,
-0.931369960308075,
0.31553128361701965,
0.31630739569664,
0.10751018673181534,
-0.07626436650753021,
-0.8953982591629028,
0.633587121963501,
-0.32611700892448425,
-0.44957637786865234,
-0.7349642515182495,
0.14162814617156982,
-0.8020539283752441,
-0.5266343355178833,
0.9490709900856018,
-0.365906298160553,
-0.06373202055692673,
-0.11233152449131012,
-0.48320040106773376,
-0.14222802221775055,
-0.5774353742599487,
0.7309404015541077,
0.3562600314617157,
-0.07433885335922241,
-0.30403345823287964,
-0.7527908682823181,
0.7655413746833801,
0.013674601912498474,
-0.9982467293739319,
0.10722599178552628,
0.06682933866977692,
0.2681577205657959,
0.25259628891944885,
0.626592755317688,
-0.2721081078052521,
0.5562363862991333,
0.11857608705759048,
0.215213343501091,
-0.579652726650238,
-0.34011605381965637,
-0.6940230131149292,
0.004355402197688818,
-0.041020143777132034,
-0.6726064085960388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09047v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09047v1
|
Multilingual Evaluation of Semantic Textual Relatedness
| 2024-04-13T17:16:03 | 2024-04-13T17:16:03 |
Sharvi Endait, Srushti Sonavane, Ridhima Sinare, Pritika Rohera, Advait Naik, Dipali Kadam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The explosive growth of online content demands robust Natural Language
Processing (NLP) techniques that can capture nuanced meanings and cultural
context across diverse languages. Semantic Textual Relatedness (STR) goes
beyond superficial word overlap, considering linguistic elements and
non-linguistic factors like topic, sentiment, and perspective. Despite its
pivotal role, prior NLP research has predominantly focused on English, limiting
its applicability across languages. Addressing this gap, our paper dives into
capturing deeper connections between sentences beyond simple word overlap.
Going beyond English-centric NLP research, we explore STR in Marathi, Hindi,
Spanish, and English, unlocking the potential for information retrieval,
machine translation, and more. Leveraging the SemEval-2024 shared task, we
explore various language models across three learning paradigms: supervised,
unsupervised, and cross-lingual. Our comprehensive methodology gains promising
results, demonstrating the effectiveness of our approach. This work aims to not
only showcase our achievements but also inspire further research in
multilingual STR, particularly for low-resourced languages.
|
[
-0.37801870703697205,
-0.7261009812355042,
0.5247775316238403,
0.4135444760322571,
-0.3771359920501709,
0.02343204990029335,
-0.4446887671947479,
-0.9642586708068848,
0.2834654450416565,
0.5878360867500305,
-0.8075593709945679,
-0.4623584747314453,
-0.48435497283935547,
0.5551725625991821,
-0.16853059828281403,
0.8918266892433167,
-0.08867748826742172,
0.14767220616340637,
-0.5974514484405518,
-0.6289003491401672,
-0.6343793272972107,
-0.547579288482666,
-0.35122019052505493,
-0.31932950019836426,
0.4918587803840637,
0.1701900213956833,
0.6016549468040466,
0.2714049518108368,
0.8387671709060669,
0.3649093806743622,
0.12161995470523834,
0.1985541731119156,
-0.21423107385635376,
0.3462444245815277,
-0.522346019744873,
-0.4649384021759033,
-0.0737428218126297,
-0.40178316831588745,
0.4611468017101288,
0.703914999961853,
0.23232322931289673,
0.021869786083698273,
0.3168114423751831,
0.7316887974739075,
-0.4784756600856781,
0.20103466510772705,
-0.5538506507873535,
0.024978242814540863,
-0.40169864892959595,
-0.49562734365463257,
-0.4469139575958252,
-0.24210739135742188,
0.09939172863960266,
-0.6526233553886414,
0.26593679189682007,
-0.1860298216342926,
0.9157090187072754,
0.30851662158966064,
-0.7643676996231079,
-0.5942161679267883,
-0.5995490550994873,
0.884581446647644,
-0.5324098467826843,
0.6333540081977844,
0.6242935657501221,
0.16966040432453156,
0.2004319578409195,
-0.7289778590202332,
-0.4385130703449249,
0.012917544692754745,
-0.203072652220726,
0.3562812805175781,
0.1984775811433792,
-0.4003136157989502,
-0.08818908035755157,
0.37177759408950806,
-0.5329785346984863,
-0.20854945480823517,
-0.20624107122421265,
-0.21465885639190674,
0.3972373306751251,
0.09711100906133652,
0.66452956199646,
-0.41585561633110046,
-0.6372108459472656,
-0.02716044895350933,
-0.6469423770904541,
0.031107602640986443,
0.350146621465683,
0.3206790089607239,
-0.26010948419570923,
0.7924244999885559,
-0.13938650488853455,
0.6097782254219055,
-0.37457960844039917,
0.1068715751171112,
0.3258809447288513,
-1.0560022592544556,
0.21525058150291443,
0.01427391730248928,
0.7594549655914307,
0.44730812311172485,
0.13218440115451813,
-0.09218190610408783,
0.26311150193214417,
0.3097546696662903,
0.0416664220392704,
-0.4749175012111664,
0.18329335749149323,
-0.02032984048128128,
-0.4054628610610962,
0.14684325456619263,
0.026133783161640167,
-0.7950831055641174,
-0.11521638929843903,
-0.3948354721069336,
0.21232077479362488,
-0.6923105716705322,
-0.34591227769851685,
0.045902132987976074,
-0.043650057166814804,
0.45042991638183594,
0.04747926443815231,
-0.8648580312728882,
0.21588443219661713,
0.9508181214332581,
0.7853584289550781,
-0.3529530167579651,
-0.5260304808616638,
-0.1543126106262207,
0.2848711311817169,
-0.1661604791879654,
0.9114875197410583,
-0.7760491967201233,
-0.07116149365901947,
0.03322543203830719,
0.2178853154182434,
-0.27967721223831177,
-0.3055691123008728,
0.8150119185447693,
-0.6030084490776062,
0.2530463933944702,
-0.21793629229068756,
-0.44718894362449646,
-0.3134905695915222,
0.3649257719516754,
-0.8921622037887573,
1.216603398323059,
-0.2364996075630188,
-1.1342315673828125,
0.598509669303894,
-0.35274040699005127,
-0.5134720802307129,
-0.035179056227207184,
-0.046557214111089706,
-0.19562558829784393,
0.03216657415032387,
0.1480010598897934,
0.5476427674293518,
-0.17675301432609558,
0.3201562166213989,
-0.32580843567848206,
-0.1280113160610199,
0.08986790478229523,
-0.1932457536458969,
0.5588907599449158,
0.3213261663913727,
-0.0331244058907032,
0.3570011258125305,
-0.6776409149169922,
0.1338265836238861,
-0.0938495546579361,
-0.0445382259786129,
-1.0837888717651367,
-0.18163727223873138,
0.31046804785728455,
0.4525409936904907,
0.35489749908447266,
-0.42781004309654236,
-0.2990609407424927,
-0.8710492253303528,
0.45967215299606323,
0.21847744286060333,
0.09038951247930527,
0.3967323899269104,
-0.13586008548736572,
0.28451910614967346,
-0.07426407933235168,
-0.11353614181280136,
-0.28869906067848206,
-0.46632128953933716,
-0.6261518597602844,
-0.1276942640542984,
0.2311415672302246,
0.4310043454170227,
-1.0288316011428833,
0.16312569379806519,
-0.4783112108707428,
-0.4262298047542572,
-0.4823983609676361,
0.1842503845691681,
0.3987058401107788,
0.16963165998458862,
0.4403454661369324,
-0.3354545533657074,
-0.5690227746963501,
-0.8519096970558167,
-0.6257871985435486,
0.028473760932683945,
-0.018251854926347733,
0.049259014427661896,
0.5586523413658142,
-0.3636947274208069,
0.6881363391876221,
-0.18333101272583008,
-0.521282970905304,
-0.41266486048698425,
0.051016297191381454,
0.002711661159992218,
0.21446971595287323,
0.30973151326179504,
-1.019406795501709,
-0.7013914585113525,
0.36474063992500305,
-0.896207869052887,
-0.025378724560141563,
0.16032005846500397,
-0.22531254589557648,
0.47488152980804443,
0.44583457708358765,
-0.36358609795570374,
0.3141051232814789,
0.5081550478935242,
-0.45735397934913635,
0.025531552731990814,
-0.3772083818912506,
0.39700475335121155,
-1.4291887283325195,
-0.014511404559016228,
-0.007699900772422552,
-0.06468810141086578,
-0.4409407377243042,
0.40977755188941956,
0.1363748013973236,
-0.15761899948120117,
-0.4886540174484253,
0.5748268365859985,
-0.46510523557662964,
-0.09575508534908295,
-0.062465850263834,
0.21259550750255585,
0.12311691790819168,
0.3158301115036011,
0.36306285858154297,
0.7678347229957581,
0.06283769756555557,
-0.5494377613067627,
0.1958957016468048,
0.3148357570171356,
-0.17797982692718506,
0.7061708569526672,
-0.6246498823165894,
-0.23080366849899292,
-0.06582333892583847,
0.06004445254802704,
-0.7871038913726807,
-0.2537981867790222,
-0.126942440867424,
-0.5192446708679199,
0.09360571205615997,
0.1796330064535141,
-0.4697053134441376,
0.14647868275642395,
-0.6695302128791809,
0.619924783706665,
-0.1336134970188141,
-0.25161609053611755,
0.6129487156867981,
0.4384813606739044,
-0.43102988600730896,
-0.5098084807395935,
-0.8031983375549316,
0.27506211400032043,
-0.32298585772514343,
-0.9501458406448364,
0.27249857783317566,
0.11131199449300766,
-0.31169936060905457,
0.07815657556056976,
-0.0033612651750445366,
-0.4084712266921997,
-0.006227600388228893,
0.14774875342845917,
0.33195212483406067,
-0.30354028940200806,
0.28520989418029785,
-0.15635384619235992,
-0.26532602310180664,
-0.05691025033593178,
-0.12419329583644867,
0.540142297744751,
-0.32931530475616455,
-0.40260976552963257,
-0.03219376876950264,
0.6784101128578186,
0.2657194435596466,
-0.44529297947883606,
0.772925078868866,
0.9014152884483337,
-0.42699456214904785,
0.056391362100839615,
-0.4704946279525757,
-0.04792480915784836,
-0.35609713196754456,
0.30780094861984253,
-0.6263002157211304,
-0.8897204995155334,
0.46018874645233154,
0.009459437802433968,
-0.22102023661136627,
0.8068142533302307,
0.5458056330680847,
0.17891021072864532,
0.5417096614837646,
0.9992137551307678,
0.478483110666275,
0.12994711101055145,
0.047890905290842056,
0.3702913224697113,
-0.6353397965431213,
-0.41883283853530884,
-0.6777312159538269,
0.4029611349105835,
-1.0446444749832153,
-0.6484144330024719,
0.10746868699789047,
-0.1498493105173111,
0.200320303440094,
0.6226805448532104,
-0.31026020646095276,
0.41020482778549194,
0.2726488411426544,
-0.148978129029274,
0.715164840221405,
0.04616700857877731,
-0.3439505100250244,
-0.6749514937400818,
-0.5160222053527832,
-0.6306522488594055,
0.758125364780426,
0.11240944266319275,
0.3920552134513855,
0.2720480263233185,
0.481452614068985,
0.19132201373577118,
-0.1882508099079132,
-0.6929398775100708,
0.46491292119026184,
-0.1229197159409523,
-0.5785002112388611,
-0.33709168434143066,
-0.3111822307109833,
-1.113198161125183,
0.3773154616355896,
-0.4725528061389923,
-0.48734864592552185,
-0.21231646835803986,
-0.40890225768089294,
0.28432297706604004,
-0.024040747433900833,
-0.5984010100364685,
0.9144685864448547,
-0.08674419671297073,
-0.7460782527923584,
-0.39714014530181885,
-0.8605437874794006,
0.2952185273170471,
-0.23548398911952972,
0.5234338641166687,
-0.19725972414016724,
-0.37779730558395386,
0.6258099675178528,
-0.3836399018764496,
0.6467645168304443,
0.4360452890396118,
-0.30365467071533203,
0.11756477504968643,
-0.07109683752059937,
0.019006861373782158,
-0.032119762152433395,
-0.13361452519893646,
0.42916139960289,
0.44414013624191284,
-0.47262853384017944,
-0.41790130734443665,
0.9826408624649048,
-0.5376099348068237,
-0.06364549696445465,
-0.5743870139122009,
-0.42269471287727356,
-0.4037233293056488,
0.358288049697876,
0.2520778477191925,
0.3923660218715668,
-0.3525850772857666,
0.2654232680797577,
0.4405062198638916,
-0.24553684890270233,
0.5138315558433533,
0.39007568359375,
-0.05064516142010689,
-0.2863956093788147,
0.9985216856002808,
-0.058685094118118286,
0.16662092506885529,
0.7964938879013062,
0.04404899850487709,
-0.6000658273696899,
-0.18746285140514374,
-0.46012771129608154,
0.40261656045913696,
-0.8305529952049255,
0.06820095330476761,
-0.8135225176811218,
-0.05544590577483177,
-0.32399338483810425,
-0.26855334639549255,
-0.2346934825181961,
-0.48153620958328247,
0.15650799870491028,
-0.07044785469770432,
0.3746953308582306,
0.7750141620635986,
0.24488818645477295,
-0.20997342467308044,
-1.0126553773880005,
0.29221341013908386,
0.021395958960056305,
0.3817383050918579,
-0.04254964366555214,
-0.22759845852851868,
-0.14871734380722046,
-0.257454514503479,
-0.07113184779882431,
-0.6966425180435181,
0.3776216208934784,
0.4189482033252716,
0.5143552422523499,
0.011035979725420475,
0.21216659247875214,
0.6361976265907288,
-0.535033643245697,
0.8186813592910767,
0.2662888765335083,
-0.9610209465026855,
0.7104562520980835,
-0.4433636963367462,
0.3092101812362671,
0.8349444270133972,
0.6837741732597351,
-0.5686900615692139,
-0.4815227687358856,
-0.3627691864967346,
-1.3155508041381836,
0.2992077171802521,
0.24410174787044525,
0.2533106505870819,
-0.06820093840360641,
-0.21827898919582367,
0.35635238885879517,
-0.014303237199783325,
-0.8983123302459717,
-0.05349252372980118,
-0.1772604137659073,
-0.4330317974090576,
-0.08441045135259628,
-0.2179081290960312,
0.2035466879606247,
0.06426383554935455,
0.5537604093551636,
-0.07493700832128525,
-0.014690523967146873,
0.31966426968574524,
-0.42642441391944885,
0.2858191132545471,
0.7265307307243347,
0.4039512574672699,
0.7224372625350952,
0.06712322682142258,
0.33367106318473816,
0.3356465697288513,
-0.6072348952293396,
0.01363702304661274,
0.002478493144735694,
-0.00789293646812439,
0.15236224234104156,
0.7963404655456543,
0.44369199872016907,
0.6454517245292664,
-0.6231179237365723,
0.5541741847991943,
-0.3021544814109802,
0.26018133759498596,
-0.36052486300468445,
-0.3435153067111969,
0.2721405327320099,
-0.06415850669145584,
0.2460273653268814,
0.1689806580543518,
0.3079194128513336,
-0.744587779045105,
0.2589505612850189,
0.35405606031417847,
-0.8777474761009216,
-0.34977179765701294,
0.5764158964157104,
0.4166179597377777,
-0.07720992714166641,
0.022815220057964325,
0.10336970537900925,
-0.46740689873695374,
0.42133215069770813,
0.5415101051330566,
0.5382365584373474,
-0.08870460838079453,
0.046913567930459976,
0.6169591546058655,
0.3402373194694519,
0.11628901213407516,
0.09787295013666153,
-0.28843507170677185,
-0.5954133868217468,
-0.8059763312339783,
-0.7273062467575073,
-0.2910013794898987,
-0.31988441944122314,
-0.8780612945556641,
0.46238037943840027,
-0.0037836760748177767,
-0.029249345883727074,
-0.014302543364465237,
0.0881834551692009,
-0.55123370885849,
0.11637216061353683,
-0.12655578553676605,
0.6685346364974976,
-0.8592479228973389,
0.7322898507118225,
0.8762722611427307,
-0.4921768009662628,
-0.5567079782485962,
-0.06763250380754471,
0.0413510724902153,
-0.5396681427955627,
0.6883049607276917,
0.36335092782974243,
-0.3856089413166046,
-0.2025817483663559,
0.146079421043396,
-0.5781573057174683,
0.9024633169174194,
0.057462822645902634,
-0.18165671825408936,
0.1313948929309845,
0.27005457878112793,
0.7964043021202087,
-0.14589640498161316,
0.3378596007823944,
0.32600247859954834,
0.31661760807037354,
0.13614414632320404,
-0.8864426016807556,
0.00598478689789772,
-0.6113797426223755,
0.054700493812561035,
0.40381139516830444,
-0.4564300775527954,
0.4544035792350769,
-0.019687462598085403,
-0.4591612219810486,
-0.017564430832862854,
0.6785517930984497,
0.11966138333082199,
0.6771265864372253,
0.1963038444519043,
0.49423786997795105,
0.5572178959846497,
0.006545041222125292,
0.9706746339797974,
-0.4326452612876892,
0.2286471426486969,
1.1561613082885742,
-0.5136783719062805,
1.1419788599014282,
0.6754623651504517,
-0.16869549453258514,
0.48811954259872437,
0.5376401543617249,
0.2641792595386505,
0.41648247838020325,
-0.2360381931066513,
-0.2157311588525772,
-0.09727425873279572,
-0.6113961338996887,
-0.6043893098831177,
0.5372968316078186,
0.31549856066703796,
-0.03399615362286568,
-0.27192097902297974,
0.15515375137329102,
-0.06365260481834412,
0.7798289060592651,
-0.23194359242916107,
0.9837689399719238,
0.19884999096393585,
-0.7150466442108154,
0.28798454999923706,
-0.01646348647773266,
0.9368271827697754,
-0.9027091860771179,
-0.19016005098819733,
0.12312466651201248,
0.06197204813361168,
-0.31188541650772095,
-0.8406568169593811,
0.9819674491882324,
0.14512062072753906,
-0.13676992058753967,
-0.15977206826210022,
1.080467939376831,
-0.5321982502937317,
-0.5389037728309631,
0.8967472314834595,
0.7837339639663696,
-0.01435169018805027,
0.3050353527069092,
-0.37165188789367676,
0.08615218847990036,
-0.11313237994909286,
0.1756693571805954,
0.3867696523666382,
0.6979175806045532,
-0.22814860939979553,
0.5472903847694397,
0.6902090311050415,
0.06803213059902191,
0.0015126309590414166,
0.11108662188053131,
0.447309285402298,
-0.8986752033233643,
-0.5094925761222839,
-0.7519031763076782,
0.18996232748031616,
-0.11713125556707382,
-0.2959699034690857,
1.197920560836792,
0.5832816362380981,
1.2926169633865356,
-0.12605290114879608,
0.7092199921607971,
0.06851652264595032,
0.5601872205734253,
-0.715027928352356,
0.5601871609687805,
-0.5648914575576782,
0.3203687369823456,
-0.5133724212646484,
-1.0099670886993408,
-0.38766172528266907,
0.5799963474273682,
-0.3483503460884094,
-0.265901118516922,
1.1001741886138916,
0.5003020763397217,
-0.2063528299331665,
0.22941134870052338,
0.41128188371658325,
-0.14363670349121094,
-0.3271893560886383,
0.5698742270469666,
1.0379650592803955,
-0.5820457339286804,
0.5366676449775696,
-0.18174664676189423,
0.10344196856021881,
0.015015316195786,
-0.9717159271240234,
-0.8552542328834534,
-0.9246154427528381,
-0.16607123613357544,
-0.27330783009529114,
-0.16510546207427979,
0.7845943570137024,
0.2968575358390808,
-0.7249526977539062,
-0.16402550041675568,
0.07319214940071106,
0.2198805958032608,
0.026070499792695045,
-0.22891829907894135,
0.35706549882888794,
-0.29899248480796814,
-0.6311497688293457,
0.14970389008522034,
0.5672755241394043,
-0.2712952792644501,
-0.10601326823234558,
-0.024307342246174812,
-0.49180594086647034,
0.08362924307584763,
0.9039803743362427,
0.024606943130493164,
-0.7081559300422668,
-0.07226373255252838,
0.02192332223057747,
-0.2853988707065582,
-0.06253661215305328,
0.79835444688797,
-0.488183856010437,
0.5169071555137634,
0.7720642685890198,
0.8919877409934998,
0.4500115215778351,
-0.16347947716712952,
0.472601979970932,
-0.5384320616722107,
0.35284411907196045,
0.1260608732700348,
0.3737933933734894,
0.7706121206283569,
-0.2419731765985489,
0.8990663290023804,
0.1051221564412117,
-0.3678872883319855,
-0.48336121439933777,
0.33404093980789185,
-0.9678063988685608,
-0.27384957671165466,
0.9916694760322571,
-0.30894118547439575,
-0.2863948345184326,
-0.5802390575408936,
-0.11609039455652237,
0.3153461217880249,
0.05710148438811302,
0.4735586643218994,
0.8906294703483582,
0.07532256096601486,
0.09929275512695312,
-0.8151519298553467,
0.31280606985092163,
0.4203742742538452,
-0.805055558681488,
-0.21311858296394348,
0.3472798466682434,
0.1399165689945221,
0.2998846173286438,
0.6030044555664062,
-0.2871295213699341,
0.07925870269536972,
-0.11577162146568298,
0.0004753675893880427,
0.23975273966789246,
-0.19664430618286133,
-0.4376285672187805,
0.1429176777601242,
-0.07494678348302841,
0.18033689260482788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09045v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09045v1
|
Adapting Mental Health Prediction Tasks for Cross-lingual Learning via Meta-Training and In-context Learning with Large Language Model
| 2024-04-13T17:11:35 | 2024-04-13T17:11:35 |
Zita Lifelo, Huansheng Ning, Sahraoui Dhelim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Timely identification is essential for the efficient handling of mental
health illnesses such as depression. However, the current research fails to
adequately address the prediction of mental health conditions from social media
data in low-resource African languages like Swahili. This study introduces two
distinct approaches utilising model-agnostic meta-learning and leveraging large
language models (LLMs) to address this gap. Experiments are conducted on three
datasets translated to low-resource language and applied to four mental health
tasks, which include stress, depression, depression severity and suicidal
ideation prediction. we first apply a meta-learning model with
self-supervision, which results in improved model initialisation for rapid
adaptation and cross-lingual transfer. The results show that our meta-trained
model performs significantly better than standard fine-tuning methods,
outperforming the baseline fine-tuning in macro F1 score with 18\% and 0.8\%
over XLM-R and mBERT. In parallel, we use LLMs' in-context learning
capabilities to assess their performance accuracy across the Swahili mental
health prediction tasks by analysing different cross-lingual prompting
approaches. Our analysis showed that Swahili prompts performed better than
cross-lingual prompts but less than English prompts. Our findings show that
in-context learning can be achieved through cross-lingual transfer through
carefully crafted prompt templates with examples and instructions.
|
[
-0.33482033014297485,
-0.9278662800788879,
0.5427317023277283,
0.37456396222114563,
-0.24624928832054138,
-0.19417902827262878,
-0.4061397612094879,
-0.5872437953948975,
0.34908396005630493,
0.25840070843696594,
-0.9756819009780884,
-0.43625253438949585,
-0.781886100769043,
0.4072374999523163,
0.04225815460085869,
1.0088056325912476,
-0.18006765842437744,
0.22794491052627563,
0.0028672858607023954,
-0.09944981336593628,
-0.707196831703186,
-0.42994198203086853,
-0.8236896991729736,
-0.3906079828739166,
0.75999516248703,
0.672311007976532,
0.5292561650276184,
-0.08635358512401581,
0.05100403353571892,
0.12780770659446716,
0.1361684948205948,
0.3688596487045288,
-0.42508333921432495,
-0.18233810365200043,
-0.49467116594314575,
-0.16351386904716492,
-0.24259929358959198,
-0.2217441350221634,
0.05214972048997879,
0.5030039548873901,
-0.16846127808094025,
0.4416562020778656,
0.3612470030784607,
0.4293331205844879,
-0.5542677044868469,
0.24908378720283508,
-0.4685761034488678,
0.2841947376728058,
-0.015564796514809132,
-0.08172281086444855,
-0.21643678843975067,
-0.07957172393798828,
0.05036124959588051,
-0.3783133924007416,
-0.16712120175361633,
-0.4043380618095398,
0.46728676557540894,
0.38360026478767395,
-0.6634225249290466,
-0.283621609210968,
-0.6405602693557739,
0.6459750533103943,
-0.7731941342353821,
0.08997680991888046,
0.7027639746665955,
0.6191688179969788,
-0.10183542966842651,
-0.44654691219329834,
-0.2760861814022064,
0.38653090596199036,
-0.13536931574344635,
0.13974431157112122,
-0.19250810146331787,
-0.10558115690946579,
0.28356149792671204,
-0.05756276845932007,
-0.3968659043312073,
0.15277786552906036,
-0.20559020340442657,
-0.15089789032936096,
0.7636625170707703,
0.2551937997341156,
0.5772515535354614,
-0.3989652097225189,
-0.11713019758462906,
0.23141613602638245,
-0.45063406229019165,
0.17488400638103485,
-0.14288824796676636,
0.4255741536617279,
-0.41114187240600586,
0.5016874074935913,
0.038843367248773575,
0.3592258393764496,
0.2401808202266693,
-0.6640293598175049,
0.20008984208106995,
0.005053229629993439,
-0.1523694097995758,
0.16581296920776367,
0.8415141105651855,
0.28855395317077637,
0.30176010727882385,
-0.009667553007602692,
-0.1630442589521408,
-0.1350955069065094,
0.310636043548584,
-0.7788911461830139,
-0.04376979172229767,
0.058660123497247696,
-0.6003673672676086,
0.26720091700553894,
-0.5482151508331299,
-0.8675015568733215,
-0.3070774972438812,
-0.27118006348609924,
0.5572023391723633,
-0.645668625831604,
-0.21675285696983337,
-0.07500630617141724,
0.4341752529144287,
-0.1516544371843338,
0.3597310781478882,
-0.9105218052864075,
0.11560296267271042,
0.3964379131793976,
0.9498819708824158,
-0.07488503307104111,
-0.26092976331710815,
-0.46323829889297485,
0.2169090062379837,
-0.14777973294258118,
0.35997092723846436,
-0.38136613368988037,
-0.3680497705936432,
0.06714315712451935,
0.22429288923740387,
-0.25961706042289734,
-0.2134135663509369,
0.6153308749198914,
-0.1262184977531433,
0.18007777631282806,
-0.5572687387466431,
-0.20047569274902344,
-0.36826959252357483,
0.022230815142393112,
-0.5981236696243286,
0.922346830368042,
0.4695923626422882,
-0.9204721450805664,
0.131544828414917,
-0.5446047186851501,
-0.9600552320480347,
-0.17636626958847046,
0.08625432103872299,
-0.23568445444107056,
0.2038450688123703,
0.6033616662025452,
0.749467134475708,
-0.31659063696861267,
0.35042810440063477,
-0.5382247567176819,
-0.3751181364059448,
0.2320667803287506,
-0.31190410256385803,
0.8562195301055908,
0.11438511312007904,
-0.5671585202217102,
-0.0634104460477829,
-0.5696474313735962,
-0.030552193522453308,
0.08561881631612778,
-0.15535809099674225,
-0.4758842885494232,
0.004075930919498205,
0.09626982361078262,
0.6658803224563599,
-0.01991518773138523,
-0.37844687700271606,
-0.15325291454792023,
-0.3037325441837311,
0.4775792360305786,
0.533767580986023,
0.12009048461914062,
0.08187329769134521,
-0.18215513229370117,
0.6077250242233276,
0.030921965837478638,
0.2715925872325897,
-0.014275651425123215,
-0.48558005690574646,
-0.12312161922454834,
-0.4964720904827118,
0.21621741354465485,
0.9054923057556152,
-0.9013571739196777,
0.4470162093639374,
-0.26320546865463257,
-0.49407246708869934,
-0.6038293838500977,
0.38439446687698364,
0.25056105852127075,
0.6554739475250244,
0.5887678861618042,
-0.07581201940774918,
-0.6526384353637695,
-0.612504780292511,
-0.3844713270664215,
0.08883160352706909,
-0.0586453340947628,
0.5976625084877014,
0.5699223279953003,
-0.9229719638824463,
0.5223034024238586,
-0.11882120370864868,
-0.3887057304382324,
-0.4531538486480713,
0.2747379541397095,
0.21217089891433716,
0.044772908091545105,
0.5948424339294434,
-0.5804388523101807,
-0.7850301861763,
0.01579323038458824,
-0.7231253981590271,
-0.26330849528312683,
0.0571872852742672,
0.06847765296697617,
0.2151898294687271,
0.23474907875061035,
-0.4256399869918823,
0.23069724440574646,
0.8325459361076355,
-0.2850797474384308,
0.42702516913414,
-0.01381712406873703,
-0.1307513266801834,
-1.3707492351531982,
-0.04967247694730759,
0.1364264190196991,
-0.3828491270542145,
-0.5135853290557861,
-0.42456191778182983,
0.14317546784877777,
-0.3720628619194031,
-0.3151954710483551,
0.6608452200889587,
-0.3479274809360504,
0.034221332520246506,
-0.40745535492897034,
-0.0727248266339302,
-0.3128519356250763,
0.3560236096382141,
-0.008316799998283386,
0.6434378027915955,
0.6381673812866211,
-0.4753880202770233,
0.07534822076559067,
0.16930367052555084,
-0.5773184299468994,
0.6207565069198608,
-0.4886999726295471,
-0.18929199874401093,
-0.15957817435264587,
0.45312774181365967,
-0.8869712948799133,
-0.2121569812297821,
0.286689430475235,
-0.20576779544353485,
0.25623902678489685,
0.05170678347349167,
-0.33224615454673767,
-0.34156712889671326,
0.21463821828365326,
0.5422447323799133,
0.2965250611305237,
-0.5417084693908691,
0.7403956651687622,
0.43333709239959717,
-0.48604220151901245,
-0.7370448708534241,
-0.7394362092018127,
0.027869833633303642,
-0.35340988636016846,
-0.20412380993366241,
0.3924436569213867,
0.1425991654396057,
-0.04223356768488884,
0.017567375674843788,
0.03907501697540283,
0.1477014124393463,
0.35846206545829773,
0.45586106181144714,
0.13654975593090057,
0.016257328912615776,
0.309261292219162,
0.25928616523742676,
-0.1089102178812027,
0.28631502389907837,
-0.054805122315883636,
0.3610740303993225,
0.16373899579048157,
-0.2004217803478241,
-0.26314035058021545,
0.499324232339859,
0.4970546066761017,
-0.13239087164402008,
0.9197941422462463,
0.9195923209190369,
-0.6250445246696472,
-0.24931693077087402,
-0.323336124420166,
-0.16156136989593506,
-0.3467369079589844,
0.19705216586589813,
-0.4075244069099426,
-0.6973925232887268,
0.479862242937088,
-0.21303227543830872,
-0.0702742338180542,
0.28448453545570374,
0.6011813879013062,
-0.2766675353050232,
1.0916649103164673,
0.8809205889701843,
-0.4737321734428406,
0.6202895045280457,
-0.1299070119857788,
0.1991320252418518,
-0.7015534043312073,
0.014694860205054283,
-0.06434829533100128,
-0.42329949140548706,
-0.520183801651001,
-0.4361379146575928,
0.5635842680931091,
0.050944190472364426,
-0.17812953889369965,
0.1055765226483345,
0.09967940300703049,
-0.02094690501689911,
0.12392235547304153,
0.5548434257507324,
-0.05371776968240738,
0.00730655575171113,
-0.4230707287788391,
-0.3095623552799225,
-0.7392257452011108,
-0.23097728192806244,
0.9793950915336609,
0.1711852252483368,
0.7129314541816711,
-0.08265339583158493,
0.677116334438324,
0.43407487869262695,
0.6304018497467041,
-0.7717518210411072,
0.19140291213989258,
0.014354425482451916,
-0.4049187898635864,
-0.5328079462051392,
-0.5018224120140076,
-0.8913041949272156,
0.23308813571929932,
-0.2359727919101715,
-0.692714512348175,
0.11622144281864166,
-0.15123999118804932,
-0.34249991178512573,
0.2957596480846405,
-0.31565114855766296,
0.7962915301322937,
-0.6133163571357727,
-0.16458956897258759,
-0.5050722360610962,
-0.6337550282478333,
0.39917054772377014,
-0.4382252097129822,
0.7199907898902893,
-0.36340856552124023,
0.0212227962911129,
0.6113051176071167,
-0.20502135157585144,
1.2560175657272339,
-0.12303261458873749,
-0.42782318592071533,
0.13039356470108032,
-0.1210273802280426,
0.33900198340415955,
0.30191007256507874,
-0.20078811049461365,
0.18690186738967896,
0.12873850762844086,
-0.5271477699279785,
-0.6575364470481873,
0.6098546981811523,
-1.0212383270263672,
-0.6268545389175415,
-0.17704427242279053,
-0.5282031893730164,
-0.43495431542396545,
0.2833717465400696,
0.39629366993904114,
0.3686099648475647,
-0.39523959159851074,
-0.18483465909957886,
0.5588779449462891,
-0.5320931077003479,
0.4538760483264923,
0.7428675293922424,
-0.24438606202602386,
-0.7264430522918701,
0.5813298225402832,
0.2636125683784485,
0.06809105724096298,
0.3462676405906677,
0.2942338287830353,
-0.16098976135253906,
0.07259580492973328,
-0.34628596901893616,
0.4339754581451416,
-0.7207208871841431,
-0.38167712092399597,
-0.662871778011322,
-0.2549632489681244,
-0.4636138379573822,
-0.1408557891845703,
-0.17691469192504883,
-0.0657486617565155,
-0.36561229825019836,
-0.14664454758167267,
0.3448236584663391,
0.5668254494667053,
-0.37914568185806274,
0.04957420751452446,
-0.846449613571167,
0.4055895209312439,
0.3191467225551605,
0.17238222062587738,
0.33629241585731506,
-0.6330527663230896,
-0.5782414078712463,
0.3364471197128296,
-0.22530660033226013,
-1.1612274646759033,
0.4317871332168579,
0.44168198108673096,
0.5352134704589844,
0.6281580924987793,
0.3093591034412384,
0.8470438718795776,
-0.6173750162124634,
0.4416750967502594,
0.3115544617176056,
-0.9061388373374939,
0.7872025966644287,
-0.12399844080209732,
0.2634223997592926,
0.6263461112976074,
1.0999648571014404,
-0.9351850748062134,
0.09641924500465393,
-0.32817262411117554,
-0.5416170954704285,
0.4743691682815552,
-0.33864423632621765,
0.19981466233730316,
-0.19808730483055115,
0.38313043117523193,
0.39289599657058716,
-0.127102792263031,
-0.7443552017211914,
-0.2216089963912964,
-0.32001152634620667,
-0.3018762171268463,
-0.6966947317123413,
-0.42560312151908875,
-0.2695225477218628,
-0.6156502366065979,
0.6209943294525146,
-0.45173415541648865,
0.19352205097675323,
0.2282247096300125,
-0.4239885210990906,
-0.5518079996109009,
0.28656187653541565,
0.250187486410141,
0.7343437671661377,
0.00613008439540863,
-0.004598654340952635,
0.50789874792099,
-0.2586023807525635,
0.318703293800354,
0.03755819424986839,
-0.1503230631351471,
0.2660278081893921,
0.5587142705917358,
1.0475914478302002,
0.6957366466522217,
-0.7560102343559265,
0.5240788459777832,
0.013312801718711853,
-0.07384414970874786,
-0.14207051694393158,
-0.08228275179862976,
0.13188056647777557,
0.43795615434646606,
0.24695448577404022,
-0.3401719927787781,
0.11151120811700821,
-0.9014628529548645,
0.021980831399559975,
0.4450167417526245,
-0.46642443537712097,
-0.580775797367096,
0.4449041783809662,
0.15046581625938416,
-0.3726428747177124,
0.40082839131355286,
0.20908960700035095,
-0.506940484046936,
0.19050312042236328,
0.9695510864257812,
0.7895652055740356,
-0.6377632021903992,
0.5922973155975342,
0.480352520942688,
0.23707526922225952,
-0.07941608130931854,
0.6206861734390259,
-0.17047618329524994,
-0.6106953024864197,
-0.46386611461639404,
-0.5846585631370544,
-0.3193091154098511,
0.1987038254737854,
-0.9729567170143127,
0.32285529375076294,
-0.2294355183839798,
-0.424553781747818,
-0.32273122668266296,
0.2602010667324066,
-0.8524861335754395,
0.43574288487434387,
0.40940356254577637,
1.0607572793960571,
-1.2939361333847046,
0.997692346572876,
0.8047096133232117,
-0.11489634215831757,
-0.6742385029792786,
0.28106769919395447,
-0.027585873380303383,
-0.5303035974502563,
0.2083684355020523,
0.4630572497844696,
-0.021926289424300194,
-0.19563043117523193,
0.004116417840123177,
-1.044293761253357,
1.1312658786773682,
0.5691235661506653,
-0.5014941096305847,
-0.03925145044922829,
0.2169114649295807,
0.6621758937835693,
-0.4198001027107239,
0.3313373029232025,
0.3314487040042877,
0.5766558647155762,
-0.1814556121826172,
-0.8942545652389526,
0.20197108387947083,
-0.04900109022855759,
0.035365030169487,
-0.06369490921497345,
-0.5706956386566162,
0.5732700824737549,
-0.4771135747432709,
-0.5512505173683167,
-0.3204503655433655,
0.7148377299308777,
0.008243853226304054,
0.23503538966178894,
0.5329186916351318,
0.5200254917144775,
0.9165717959403992,
0.30256614089012146,
0.8768483400344849,
-0.46124252676963806,
0.10754933208227158,
1.1014463901519775,
-0.4040214419364929,
0.9463129639625549,
0.21247084438800812,
-0.038519181311130524,
0.8812224864959717,
0.9253214597702026,
0.27536317706108093,
0.7139942049980164,
-0.12665431201457977,
-0.10267519950866699,
-0.18269477784633636,
-0.04410497471690178,
-0.302494615316391,
0.2444322258234024,
0.6748864650726318,
-0.46551230549812317,
-0.23782114684581757,
0.5068857669830322,
-0.05088656023144722,
-0.09060042351484299,
-0.5181592702865601,
0.7591916918754578,
0.4791737496852875,
-0.4684332311153412,
0.7360870838165283,
0.09966366738080978,
0.6481670141220093,
-0.5010387301445007,
0.25796929001808167,
-0.08494897186756134,
0.026124900206923485,
-0.17267374694347382,
-0.4533921480178833,
0.4243146479129791,
-0.1874968260526657,
-0.30775442719459534,
-0.13986080884933472,
0.9600678086280823,
-0.5192484259605408,
-0.8336688876152039,
0.8710837364196777,
0.7443177700042725,
-0.05539560317993164,
0.015332662500441074,
-0.8230270147323608,
-0.34960106015205383,
-0.2862178385257721,
-0.08988042175769806,
0.6067604422569275,
0.7519479990005493,
-0.2782851755619049,
0.7749722599983215,
0.2999986708164215,
0.2637418210506439,
-0.2922852635383606,
-0.09970207512378693,
0.5415031313896179,
-0.7698224186897278,
-0.5659413933753967,
-1.014258861541748,
-0.005470793694257736,
0.27208182215690613,
-0.24733760952949524,
0.8240000605583191,
0.0614183135330677,
0.6592810750007629,
-0.18309731781482697,
0.9907064437866211,
0.0900869071483612,
0.5751060247421265,
-0.34454086422920227,
0.5604963898658752,
-0.7894716858863831,
-0.22181487083435059,
-0.4050848186016083,
-0.6681571006774902,
0.17797021567821503,
0.4464609920978546,
-0.5724725127220154,
-0.1862850934267044,
0.6110445261001587,
0.4273207187652588,
-0.13359372317790985,
-0.2086104303598404,
0.2763044238090515,
0.17614056169986725,
-0.09408698230981827,
0.7922770380973816,
0.5985367298126221,
-0.233369842171669,
0.14539985358715057,
-0.41868314146995544,
-0.08431120961904526,
-0.5193431973457336,
-0.8159099221229553,
-1.202540636062622,
-0.5458898544311523,
-0.005105057265609503,
-0.1581401228904724,
0.11330706626176834,
0.9626831412315369,
0.5302466750144958,
-0.765078604221344,
-0.13187715411186218,
0.4518403708934784,
0.2142312079668045,
-0.725441038608551,
-0.15430337190628052,
0.3348797559738159,
-0.26639845967292786,
-0.25152766704559326,
0.2808336317539215,
0.13914914429187775,
-0.03414265438914299,
-0.36035412549972534,
-0.07305007427930832,
-0.18986240029335022,
0.17786826193332672,
0.9086909890174866,
0.2758356034755707,
-0.7891017198562622,
-0.033209387212991714,
-0.34086257219314575,
-0.34498897194862366,
-0.09138444811105728,
0.6669008731842041,
-0.7084620594978333,
0.06260819733142853,
0.1594766527414322,
0.7200778126716614,
0.39158540964126587,
-0.042689431458711624,
0.6704422235488892,
-0.36723455786705017,
-0.05059435963630676,
0.04517781734466553,
0.5240725874900818,
0.40717440843582153,
-0.6835982203483582,
0.5069956183433533,
0.017735937610268593,
-0.24503065645694733,
-0.6786898970603943,
0.12356007844209671,
-0.44237110018730164,
-0.5064944624900818,
1.1520417928695679,
-0.4067297577857971,
-0.4235287010669708,
-0.0608145147562027,
-0.22309131920337677,
0.5744800567626953,
-0.11946851760149002,
1.1698349714279175,
0.5972451567649841,
0.0017159556737169623,
-0.33771681785583496,
-0.6337876915931702,
0.4475241005420685,
0.49363380670547485,
-0.6815208196640015,
0.03482191637158394,
0.05745595321059227,
0.6395123600959778,
-0.16068889200687408,
0.5251511931419373,
0.06084105744957924,
0.44219303131103516,
-0.5717813372612,
0.031956396996974945,
0.2621033489704132,
-0.38126862049102783,
-0.4580637216567993,
-0.22202512621879578,
-0.34080421924591064,
0.36713844537734985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09043v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09043v2
|
Do LLMs Play Dice? Exploring Probability Distribution Sampling in Large Language Models for Behavioral Simulation
| 2024-04-13T16:59:28 | 2024-06-18T05:27:45 |
Jia Gu, Liang Pang, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the rapid advancement of large language models (LLMs) for handling
complex language tasks, an increasing number of studies are employing LLMs as
agents to emulate the sequential decision-making processes of humans often
represented as Markov decision-making processes (MDPs). The actions in MDPs
adhere to specific probability distributions and require iterative sampling.
This arouses curiosity regarding the capacity of LLM agents to comprehend
probability distributions, thereby guiding the agent's behavioral
decision-making through probabilistic sampling and generating behavioral
sequences. To answer the above question, we divide the problem into two main
aspects: sequence simulation with known probability distribution and sequence
simulation with unknown probability distribution. Our analysis indicates that
LLM agents can understand probabilities, but they struggle with probability
sampling. Their ability to perform probabilistic sampling can be improved to
some extent by integrating coding tools, but this level of sampling precision
still makes it difficult to simulate human behavior as agents.
|
[
-0.4534033536911011,
-0.8005396127700806,
0.8251811265945435,
0.2668854892253876,
-0.16113819181919098,
0.08227517455816269,
-0.17240850627422333,
-0.2734502851963043,
0.15428413450717926,
0.7494085431098938,
-0.7583147287368774,
-0.4107896387577057,
-0.2635364234447479,
-0.0880151093006134,
-0.18164141476154327,
0.8015016317367554,
0.26492831110954285,
0.2579202651977539,
-0.2160649448633194,
0.2685600817203522,
-0.1592460721731186,
-0.6421667337417603,
-0.8880999088287354,
-0.4868505001068115,
0.3562600016593933,
0.17076222598552704,
0.6696122884750366,
0.3822283148765564,
0.47725993394851685,
0.3568521738052368,
0.025738531723618507,
0.020985931158065796,
-0.42509737610816956,
0.248122438788414,
-0.22396144270896912,
-0.7258723378181458,
-0.2537664473056793,
0.1390010565519333,
0.8766046762466431,
0.9178580641746521,
-0.4315086305141449,
-0.07690081000328064,
-0.19351670145988464,
0.5174306631088257,
-0.30887386202812195,
0.044086698442697525,
-0.37478896975517273,
0.21959878504276276,
-0.1974814534187317,
-0.3064662516117096,
-0.5358137488365173,
-0.3759738504886627,
-0.03454044088721275,
-0.3953782916069031,
0.2436213344335556,
0.004775552079081535,
0.05873589962720871,
0.12743239104747772,
-0.5895875692367554,
-0.28062814474105835,
-1.0564336776733398,
0.6769646406173706,
-0.542461633682251,
0.07117810845375061,
0.5092394351959229,
0.3081650733947754,
-0.6123447418212891,
-0.20244728028774261,
-0.650017261505127,
-0.4239944815635681,
0.549492359161377,
-0.0018194211879745126,
0.19293466210365295,
0.20174065232276917,
0.4037615656852722,
0.25510770082473755,
-0.279762864112854,
0.4558942914009094,
-0.27886292338371277,
-0.07980858534574509,
1.0350768566131592,
0.38718798756599426,
0.1387455016374588,
0.0652557909488678,
-0.16788634657859802,
-0.5788366794586182,
-0.6213409304618835,
0.22648058831691742,
0.7947434186935425,
0.029412303119897842,
0.13175319135189056,
0.8860034942626953,
0.015661220997571945,
0.6395347714424133,
-0.19522112607955933,
-0.2982688844203949,
0.24544577300548553,
0.06022559478878975,
-0.2696836590766907,
-0.13259759545326233,
0.7833902835845947,
0.38408422470092773,
0.6505095362663269,
0.14225901663303375,
-0.3628131151199341,
-0.16795025765895844,
0.28406721353530884,
-0.27972736954689026,
-0.3073398470878601,
0.45396727323532104,
-0.38853076100349426,
-0.33357182145118713,
0.03576763719320297,
-0.7961326241493225,
-0.6131049990653992,
0.06227913126349449,
0.2338716685771942,
-0.4373151361942291,
-0.35910743474960327,
0.35357391834259033,
-0.27820974588394165,
0.12408279627561569,
0.34031763672828674,
-0.7618470191955566,
0.39094358682632446,
0.4720982015132904,
0.44241875410079956,
-0.2456544041633606,
-0.35614922642707825,
-0.47671496868133545,
0.13786177337169647,
-0.5890141129493713,
0.979916512966156,
-0.4805957078933716,
-0.5757305026054382,
0.3850233852863312,
-0.30759695172309875,
0.08022790402173996,
-0.7438176870346069,
0.2806496024131775,
-0.5241901874542236,
-0.3605308532714844,
-0.2680162489414215,
-0.7619439363479614,
0.05821288004517555,
0.3168051540851593,
-0.8048092126846313,
0.8075528740882874,
-0.04862985387444496,
-0.5708513259887695,
0.4662216901779175,
-0.29523953795433044,
-0.35440516471862793,
0.011908936314284801,
-0.3526163101196289,
-0.24761678278446198,
0.18563304841518402,
-0.15254807472229004,
0.6071352958679199,
-0.0832526832818985,
0.05638870969414711,
-0.597637414932251,
-0.27612489461898804,
0.9446487426757812,
-0.4832828938961029,
0.6618096828460693,
0.4294099509716034,
0.04649871587753296,
-0.10853748023509979,
-0.4769968092441559,
-0.15022729337215424,
0.05171768739819527,
-0.464607298374176,
-0.11437937617301941,
0.4178561270236969,
-0.0015539710875600576,
0.38358718156814575,
-0.1889004111289978,
-0.2319774478673935,
0.588966965675354,
-0.16077665984630585,
0.07990474253892899,
0.882222592830658,
0.3210529685020447,
0.7456992864608765,
-0.6872111558914185,
0.6656664609909058,
0.27470532059669495,
0.019333092495799065,
-0.06975547969341278,
-0.5226989388465881,
-0.29985231161117554,
-0.3354129195213318,
0.14257720112800598,
0.7084172368049622,
-0.8840436935424805,
0.27495551109313965,
0.28392675518989563,
-0.481555700302124,
-0.3185429871082306,
-0.02672339603304863,
0.13793230056762695,
-0.16279122233390808,
-0.09185153990983963,
-0.32433608174324036,
-0.35911309719085693,
-0.6328123807907104,
-0.2183162420988083,
-0.33910155296325684,
-0.0767323449254036,
0.13991081714630127,
0.44604331254959106,
-0.10896776616573334,
0.9358154535293579,
-0.5127372145652771,
-0.36645200848579407,
-0.49645930528640747,
0.17605330049991608,
0.1977572739124298,
0.403556764125824,
0.408473402261734,
-0.6361255049705505,
0.1282862424850464,
-0.5447041988372803,
-0.5985867381095886,
-0.15206117928028107,
-0.3080379068851471,
0.1517915278673172,
0.32276269793510437,
0.47697460651397705,
-0.7769013047218323,
0.3095701336860657,
0.4755139648914337,
-0.17362023890018463,
0.6971588730812073,
-0.6595852375030518,
0.02749142423272133,
-0.8304662704467773,
-0.3870767652988434,
0.17829883098602295,
-0.06409600377082825,
-0.6015121340751648,
0.10687259584665298,
-0.3287855088710785,
0.16524580121040344,
-0.39412543177604675,
0.5109846591949463,
-0.6218871474266052,
-0.5025439858436584,
-0.21396726369857788,
0.055970434099435806,
-0.5033627152442932,
0.04155312851071358,
0.2788506746292114,
0.7760628461837769,
0.4987131953239441,
-0.9864422082901001,
0.3248459994792938,
-0.051391735672950745,
-0.7027795314788818,
0.3520848751068115,
-0.21231499314308167,
-0.20171718299388885,
-0.3302713632583618,
0.5886279940605164,
-0.9674837589263916,
-0.18740084767341614,
0.22280831634998322,
-0.2955094873905182,
0.022096598520874977,
0.04493042081594467,
-0.8154136538505554,
-0.3226412832736969,
-0.3665370047092438,
0.30057159066200256,
0.9771409034729004,
0.027238359674811363,
0.30288752913475037,
0.774534285068512,
-0.08299925923347473,
-0.5606050491333008,
-0.6863299012184143,
-0.15406434237957,
-0.16529132425785065,
-0.36569467186927795,
0.029344139620661736,
-0.19906213879585266,
-0.8762941956520081,
-0.32750558853149414,
0.10743659734725952,
0.0773179680109024,
0.09830960631370544,
0.15819279849529266,
-0.10210025310516357,
0.07427217066287994,
0.3348432779312134,
-0.2541670799255371,
0.11792703717947006,
0.24864248931407928,
-0.378121942281723,
0.8795420527458191,
0.4825311005115509,
-0.7365087866783142,
-0.043326135724782944,
0.30829378962516785,
0.19380442798137665,
-0.006621151696890593,
0.6631726622581482,
0.3770962655544281,
-0.26698067784309387,
-0.406183123588562,
-0.7214435338973999,
-0.2621501088142395,
-0.4456218183040619,
0.24792592227458954,
-0.39821913838386536,
-0.7088757753372192,
0.714914083480835,
-0.0752929151058197,
-0.016450634226202965,
0.069954514503479,
0.728473424911499,
-0.6522742509841919,
1.0060081481933594,
0.4949209988117218,
0.0733359083533287,
0.4197763204574585,
-0.17890200018882751,
0.010007254779338837,
-0.5522871613502502,
-0.15406234562397003,
-0.4353038966655731,
-0.25470036268234253,
-0.7925758957862854,
-0.9882583618164062,
0.3826684057712555,
-0.12647172808647156,
0.007369835861027241,
-0.27827319502830505,
0.07141032814979553,
0.3973844051361084,
0.8051782846450806,
0.09484818577766418,
0.20346751809120178,
0.08678016811609268,
-0.189557284116745,
0.05333820357918739,
-0.4679715633392334,
-0.49696746468544006,
1.0322011709213257,
0.25653207302093506,
1.1286678314208984,
0.1043090969324112,
1.0576162338256836,
0.39557918906211853,
-0.03129420429468155,
-0.5700957179069519,
0.8004604578018188,
0.12780267000198364,
-0.6305840611457825,
-0.356292724609375,
-0.3947344124317169,
-1.0513787269592285,
0.003337753238156438,
-0.28429943323135376,
-0.8497304320335388,
-0.033395782113075256,
0.19215501844882965,
-0.163906067609787,
0.5089675188064575,
-0.38170769810676575,
0.45957979559898376,
0.05161644145846367,
-0.055542442947626114,
-0.40662744641304016,
-0.3618996739387512,
0.5386073589324951,
0.14577043056488037,
0.600423276424408,
-0.19672611355781555,
0.006478690542280674,
0.6549904942512512,
-0.09024661779403687,
0.8803982138633728,
-0.24751417338848114,
-0.41543301939964294,
0.6182487607002258,
0.37600454688072205,
0.5878921151161194,
0.21497087180614471,
-0.16308221220970154,
-0.37620362639427185,
0.004197287373244762,
-0.3817141652107239,
-0.4197857677936554,
0.3137800693511963,
-0.7525373101234436,
-0.6444206833839417,
-0.6011531949043274,
-0.7063776254653931,
-0.25788867473602295,
-0.33778437972068787,
0.2043398767709732,
0.12660136818885803,
-0.3557965159416199,
-0.2121172696352005,
0.9221103191375732,
-0.3538838028907776,
0.4526838958263397,
0.42617708444595337,
-0.31048715114593506,
-0.20115110278129578,
0.744377613067627,
0.25728151202201843,
0.3030867874622345,
0.40270575881004333,
-0.12325859069824219,
-0.3643791079521179,
-0.6531192660331726,
-0.14653430879116058,
0.30369293689727783,
-0.6739776730537415,
0.23846100270748138,
-0.6201644539833069,
-0.10688426345586777,
-0.419483482837677,
-0.05961765721440315,
-0.015116812661290169,
-0.2585425078868866,
-0.023877030238509178,
-0.2937772870063782,
0.3193967640399933,
0.949846625328064,
-0.3243955671787262,
0.42622244358062744,
-0.83214271068573,
0.3070502281188965,
0.2873089611530304,
0.20548976957798004,
-0.18495535850524902,
-0.21200858056545258,
0.04191127046942711,
0.14194808900356293,
-0.1551065891981125,
-1.241178035736084,
0.47732120752334595,
-0.12219487875699997,
0.7099195122718811,
0.38853761553764343,
0.1292153149843216,
0.4861775040626526,
-0.7273597121238708,
0.8446897268295288,
-0.21375395357608795,
-0.4589245915412903,
0.18937334418296814,
-0.5159170627593994,
0.15526415407657623,
0.3060014247894287,
0.25735247135162354,
-0.7260410189628601,
-0.7148317098617554,
-0.8184853792190552,
-0.5373148918151855,
0.8343014121055603,
0.11550863087177277,
0.25569355487823486,
-0.3480827808380127,
0.22220881283283234,
-0.027611421421170235,
0.24742545187473297,
-0.49612951278686523,
-0.1619023084640503,
0.45689594745635986,
-0.2494989037513733,
-0.578249990940094,
-0.3669193685054779,
-0.09955943375825882,
0.07201109826564789,
0.4172484576702118,
-0.02276182360947132,
0.5029510855674744,
0.0677875280380249,
-0.15615606307983398,
-0.127601757645607,
0.1189238652586937,
0.6677061915397644,
0.46701663732528687,
-0.33511483669281006,
0.27896326780319214,
0.12968574464321136,
-0.5675069093704224,
0.4428251087665558,
-0.061012011021375656,
-0.05003437027335167,
-0.2282017171382904,
0.1881139725446701,
0.30826589465141296,
0.13462518155574799,
-1.1708987951278687,
0.26605623960494995,
-0.05358497053384781,
-0.1903715878725052,
-0.7418211698532104,
0.4178154766559601,
0.2918684482574463,
0.5408498644828796,
0.4954657554626465,
-0.13803455233573914,
0.25696179270744324,
-0.7531715631484985,
0.3309466242790222,
0.47857460379600525,
0.014663414098322392,
-0.1593320369720459,
0.35352855920791626,
0.05213182047009468,
-0.764856219291687,
0.7818300724029541,
-0.5243732929229736,
-0.2836843729019165,
1.0029886960983276,
0.6302177309989929,
0.5426604747772217,
-0.15541885793209076,
0.47882550954818726,
0.07912848144769669,
0.29054850339889526,
-0.4843352437019348,
0.5388615727424622,
0.03889795020222664,
-0.8968430161476135,
-0.5164345502853394,
-0.4828259348869324,
-0.6739246249198914,
-0.12305286526679993,
-0.5091159343719482,
0.2120533287525177,
-0.31238803267478943,
-0.17962901294231415,
-0.3646135628223419,
-0.00008458344382233918,
-0.618608832359314,
0.1289983093738556,
0.3486349284648895,
1.1936825513839722,
-0.9234789609909058,
0.8873041272163391,
0.7337732315063477,
-0.29771628975868225,
-0.5310091972351074,
0.1588086485862732,
-0.0844290480017662,
-0.8105975985527039,
0.5805121064186096,
-0.11384802311658859,
0.16528858244419098,
0.08766600489616394,
-0.5353500843048096,
-0.5501030683517456,
0.8466930985450745,
0.14350999891757965,
-0.36957502365112305,
-0.0365213006734848,
0.29367753863334656,
0.43373993039131165,
-0.21915306150913239,
0.33025580644607544,
0.6573340892791748,
0.3248537480831146,
0.019786745309829712,
-0.6766495704650879,
-0.2055986374616623,
-0.021390896290540695,
0.07651259750127792,
0.15638890862464905,
-0.40469789505004883,
1.0206105709075928,
-0.48797857761383057,
0.12934650480747223,
-0.0875183641910553,
0.6547663807868958,
0.9183518886566162,
0.3116677403450012,
0.5686866044998169,
0.48319801688194275,
0.7009646892547607,
0.18379728496074677,
1.2027853727340698,
0.0727648138999939,
0.23251698911190033,
0.8554267287254333,
-0.6914033889770508,
1.0023843050003052,
0.6125804781913757,
-0.45458197593688965,
0.3054717481136322,
0.9258905053138733,
0.1645752489566803,
0.3125966191291809,
0.663486659526825,
-0.46179667115211487,
-0.4584628641605377,
0.2945699393749237,
0.010151674970984459,
0.35109907388687134,
0.5175922513008118,
-0.18801245093345642,
-0.13155943155288696,
0.03029702603816986,
-0.2327115535736084,
0.11548963189125061,
-0.19509771466255188,
0.8630531430244446,
0.12277483195066452,
-0.944325864315033,
-0.1604963093996048,
0.06552557647228241,
0.5559756755828857,
-0.5302355885505676,
-0.1299937516450882,
-0.22463765740394592,
0.12362098693847656,
0.1922304332256317,
-1.3874661922454834,
0.06578033417463303,
-0.1786697953939438,
0.002917034085839987,
-0.21440348029136658,
0.465203195810318,
-0.3650675117969513,
-0.27593180537223816,
0.05694030970335007,
0.5880483984947205,
0.5341886281967163,
-0.07322288304567337,
-0.3933183252811432,
-0.032128121703863144,
-0.30286136269569397,
-0.4553229808807373,
0.6219395995140076,
0.5924391150474548,
-0.20221196115016937,
0.9899572134017944,
0.6822935938835144,
0.2903115153312683,
0.3226952850818634,
0.1983186900615692,
0.45664432644844055,
-0.7359201312065125,
-0.5912428498268127,
-1.0135985612869263,
0.4387426972389221,
-0.09521874785423279,
-0.09192686527967453,
0.43779700994491577,
0.2559052109718323,
0.817814826965332,
-0.4575960338115692,
0.7331972122192383,
0.11014600843191147,
0.1754494309425354,
-0.7029589414596558,
0.4502774178981781,
-0.09531964361667633,
0.23054316639900208,
-0.06473837047815323,
-0.8976299166679382,
-0.14334285259246826,
0.8206570148468018,
-0.3221493363380432,
0.1395885944366455,
0.5095482468605042,
0.6050846576690674,
0.17895938456058502,
-0.32042789459228516,
0.3857196867465973,
0.0427144393324852,
0.4012921452522278,
0.6468265652656555,
1.0764366388320923,
-0.052543800324201584,
0.38006988167762756,
-0.10908263921737671,
-0.026698224246501923,
-0.4307475984096527,
-0.9317883849143982,
-0.8254414200782776,
-0.5401169061660767,
-0.053976379334926605,
-0.2327147126197815,
-0.1041448786854744,
1.3220207691192627,
0.3615460991859436,
-0.4778669774532318,
-0.6809337735176086,
0.020903902128338814,
0.32212382555007935,
-0.45723482966423035,
-0.22134020924568176,
-0.1391301155090332,
-0.5544713139533997,
-0.8731861114501953,
0.0829462856054306,
0.06476296484470367,
0.22915533185005188,
-0.354145884513855,
-0.011079409159719944,
-0.1775604635477066,
0.26906391978263855,
0.33908259868621826,
0.2181672751903534,
-0.5186858177185059,
-0.10143858194351196,
-0.05986893177032471,
-0.26094678044319153,
-0.21294140815734863,
0.9192072153091431,
-0.7541899085044861,
0.16611745953559875,
0.5647755265235901,
0.42964449524879456,
0.38647937774658203,
-0.1977892369031906,
0.7911718487739563,
-0.7334918975830078,
0.2704806923866272,
0.3006466329097748,
0.2800534963607788,
0.0004123660910408944,
-0.10335420817136765,
0.34888070821762085,
0.0996503233909607,
-0.652031421661377,
-0.9790417551994324,
0.5638510584831238,
-0.9483487010002136,
-0.32384800910949707,
1.531088948249817,
0.13230088353157043,
-0.374356210231781,
-0.13702604174613953,
-0.3662787675857544,
0.1924445927143097,
-0.282767653465271,
0.7002459168434143,
0.8209545612335205,
-0.19782738387584686,
-0.28178930282592773,
-0.9259293675422668,
0.5980187654495239,
0.1500655859708786,
-0.6527308821678162,
-0.03929517790675163,
0.32816678285598755,
0.3068711459636688,
-0.14191219210624695,
1.1522786617279053,
0.27435633540153503,
0.27663880586624146,
0.026460230350494385,
0.24322055280208588,
0.3559860587120056,
-0.173428475856781,
-0.40587976574897766,
0.09852336347103119,
0.43841972947120667,
-0.0535246841609478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09027v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09027v1
|
MING-MOE: Enhancing Medical Multi-Task Learning in Large Language Models with Sparse Mixture of Low-Rank Adapter Experts
| 2024-04-13T15:28:52 | 2024-04-13T15:28:52 |
Yusheng Liao, Shuyang Jiang, Yu Wang, Yanfeng Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models like ChatGPT have shown substantial progress in natural
language understanding and generation, proving valuable across various
disciplines, including the medical field. Despite advancements, challenges
persist due to the complexity and diversity inherent in medical tasks which
often require multi-task learning capabilities. Previous approaches, although
beneficial, fall short in real-world applications because they necessitate
task-specific annotations at inference time, limiting broader generalization.
This paper introduces MING-MOE, a novel Mixture-of-Expert~(MOE)-based medical
large language model designed to manage diverse and complex medical tasks
without requiring task-specific annotations, thus enhancing its usability
across extensive datasets. MING-MOE employs a Mixture of Low-Rank Adaptation
(MoLoRA) technique, allowing for efficient parameter usage by maintaining base
model parameters static while adapting through a minimal set of trainable
parameters. We demonstrate that MING-MOE achieves state-of-the-art (SOTA)
performance on over 20 medical tasks, illustrating a significant improvement
over existing models. This approach not only extends the capabilities of
medical language models but also improves inference efficiency.
|
[
-0.06946635991334915,
-0.8954252600669861,
0.5035492777824402,
0.3146340548992157,
-0.3078964054584503,
0.00069828936830163,
-0.3856947422027588,
-0.49171531200408936,
0.1826094388961792,
0.3228762149810791,
-0.272216260433197,
-0.29896870255470276,
-0.9487980604171753,
-0.05136620253324509,
0.17064489424228668,
1.0177581310272217,
0.2374763935804367,
0.43829336762428284,
-0.045148711651563644,
-0.3552330732345581,
-0.7254253625869751,
-0.4529191255569458,
-0.5704372525215149,
-0.197719544172287,
0.31477290391921997,
0.5047732591629028,
0.5049429535865784,
0.428785115480423,
0.38040587306022644,
0.19997306168079376,
0.1755213737487793,
0.5850974917411804,
-0.6822428107261658,
0.27347517013549805,
-0.04722115769982338,
-0.4909653663635254,
-0.7465130686759949,
-0.19894841313362122,
0.5476446151733398,
0.8108199238777161,
-0.2743639349937439,
-0.1724919080734253,
0.17341147363185883,
0.48489677906036377,
-0.7235836982727051,
0.27971187233924866,
-0.7837581038475037,
-0.1022016778588295,
-0.11085483431816101,
-0.29309895634651184,
-0.5078510046005249,
0.22104202210903168,
0.2392963469028473,
-0.915158212184906,
-0.07646653056144714,
0.039155177772045135,
0.6140878796577454,
0.39565327763557434,
-0.6375932097434998,
-0.01722479611635208,
-0.39918646216392517,
0.9607584476470947,
-0.6516700983047485,
0.3289448320865631,
0.3168691098690033,
0.31405147910118103,
-0.37170836329460144,
-0.4315640330314636,
-0.18399032950401306,
-0.2727416157722473,
0.12088782340288162,
0.30806219577789307,
0.17162011563777924,
0.12715066969394684,
-0.05282655730843544,
0.2284318208694458,
-0.3578535318374634,
0.0699593648314476,
-0.27750474214553833,
0.04054134339094162,
0.5058398842811584,
0.036102041602134705,
0.5135208964347839,
0.06669055670499802,
-0.4300606846809387,
0.16081982851028442,
-0.6788828372955322,
-0.24039340019226074,
-0.4024752676486969,
0.12093479931354523,
-0.324367880821228,
0.30489832162857056,
-0.25903773307800293,
0.6349934935569763,
0.06953593343496323,
-0.5392046570777893,
0.2869420051574707,
-0.024662788957357407,
-0.2951904535293579,
-0.16623595356941223,
0.8961805105209351,
0.18948397040367126,
0.05998426303267479,
-0.15891033411026,
0.04247907176613808,
-0.2861976623535156,
0.06326357275247574,
-0.8970354795455933,
-0.6775822639465332,
0.1162777841091156,
-0.5845916271209717,
-0.3186721205711365,
-0.3336785137653351,
-0.6627252101898193,
-0.7543140649795532,
-0.035094551742076874,
0.47336313128471375,
-0.7258434891700745,
-0.3707810342311859,
-0.06636541336774826,
0.03730336204171181,
-0.23224197328090668,
0.5309557914733887,
-0.9286328554153442,
0.183690145611763,
0.5000962018966675,
0.7700750827789307,
-0.4123697876930237,
-0.29609060287475586,
-0.873553991317749,
0.30687853693962097,
-0.31999313831329346,
0.683726966381073,
-0.8125814199447632,
-0.5431428551673889,
-0.45134812593460083,
-0.15109559893608093,
-0.42755255103111267,
-0.7984640598297119,
0.3664085268974304,
-0.10949668288230896,
0.04161752760410309,
0.06602932512760162,
-0.37627118825912476,
-0.3736024796962738,
0.21892458200454712,
-0.24463626742362976,
1.0039371252059937,
0.19571971893310547,
-0.5372437238693237,
0.3782599866390228,
-0.7093626260757446,
-0.7397680282592773,
0.32416048645973206,
-0.3214057385921478,
-0.15451347827911377,
0.26554039120674133,
0.49533146619796753,
0.7592955827713013,
-0.3793909251689911,
0.4407021105289459,
-0.39141395688056946,
-0.17123976349830627,
0.1915765106678009,
-0.5285623073577881,
0.7075673341751099,
0.13976377248764038,
-0.03522026911377907,
0.32598310708999634,
-0.9181802272796631,
-0.27938005328178406,
0.14637626707553864,
-0.5482367277145386,
-0.7298991680145264,
0.22872866690158844,
0.1985529512166977,
0.2824638783931732,
0.2571150064468384,
-0.41318216919898987,
0.31455615162849426,
-0.2895645797252655,
0.568732500076294,
0.5884077548980713,
0.09158647805452347,
0.24477635324001312,
-0.5132213830947876,
0.35613298416137695,
0.23277771472930908,
0.13083399832248688,
-0.05188455060124397,
-0.9258242249488831,
-0.5941045880317688,
-0.9167360663414001,
0.27997905015945435,
0.622189998626709,
-0.9803937077522278,
0.20925107598304749,
-0.4326077401638031,
-0.783582329750061,
-0.8116245865821838,
0.30507832765579224,
0.18852482736110687,
0.5746923685073853,
0.549432098865509,
-0.39825695753097534,
-0.22748976945877075,
-0.5862210392951965,
-0.08697978407144547,
-0.036512501537799835,
-0.018358498811721802,
0.6558175086975098,
0.3084472715854645,
-0.4601573050022125,
0.5983457565307617,
-0.5935177803039551,
-0.3131266236305237,
-0.2972540855407715,
0.1790793240070343,
0.021392617374658585,
0.7714707255363464,
0.6044713258743286,
-0.7685195207595825,
-0.6987079977989197,
0.4130644202232361,
-0.6453123688697815,
-0.10549772530794144,
-0.19590219855308533,
-0.34969162940979004,
-0.07554995268583298,
0.17543354630470276,
-0.3173731863498688,
-0.13959383964538574,
0.8788676857948303,
-0.019822580739855766,
0.44877901673316956,
-0.5551151037216187,
0.20925849676132202,
-1.4603339433670044,
0.07668900489807129,
-0.07357697188854218,
-0.407136470079422,
-0.7537906169891357,
0.38987448811531067,
0.15484777092933655,
-0.11583200842142105,
-0.2013118416070938,
0.764363706111908,
-0.40796196460723877,
0.44554612040519714,
-0.48696669936180115,
-0.06188296154141426,
-0.256449431180954,
0.5610383749008179,
0.13690625131130219,
0.6237595081329346,
0.9788527488708496,
-0.5348172187805176,
0.1043584793806076,
0.1256251335144043,
-0.047929633408784866,
0.7006260752677917,
-0.4761141538619995,
0.008551370352506638,
0.15724928677082062,
0.1545577347278595,
-0.8932233452796936,
-0.42777881026268005,
0.31354695558547974,
-0.3956032693386078,
0.2532660961151123,
-0.34169483184814453,
-0.3392719030380249,
0.12284395843744278,
-0.1563207060098648,
0.5052527189254761,
0.643046498298645,
-0.21838349103927612,
0.7696552872657776,
0.6258227825164795,
-0.5050318837165833,
-0.4448114037513733,
-0.5468711256980896,
0.05091487616300583,
0.05474192276597023,
-0.4378330707550049,
0.2424653023481369,
-0.1423613578081131,
-0.028005318716168404,
-0.24654227495193481,
-0.07675828039646149,
-0.5758975148200989,
0.43528926372528076,
0.33007895946502686,
0.5014474987983704,
-0.45150139927864075,
0.2176753729581833,
0.45348307490348816,
-0.07410269975662231,
-0.3409184217453003,
-0.03988352790474892,
0.42043590545654297,
0.3689401149749756,
-0.3402452766895294,
-0.2631233334541321,
0.5075525641441345,
0.8191897869110107,
-0.3581549823284149,
0.744354784488678,
0.603006899356842,
-0.46657562255859375,
-0.051473185420036316,
-0.5251054167747498,
-0.2713093161582947,
-0.3900758624076843,
0.859088122844696,
-0.2488534152507782,
-0.7325631380081177,
0.2373894304037094,
-0.20994575321674347,
0.3148658275604248,
0.38874131441116333,
0.9385809898376465,
-0.029642589390277863,
1.0815114974975586,
0.428445428609848,
-0.262030690908432,
0.431576669216156,
0.26095330715179443,
-0.022319965064525604,
-0.8223440647125244,
0.0519026443362236,
-0.17235814034938812,
-0.22191974520683289,
-0.4413757026195526,
-0.7941624522209167,
0.7834348678588867,
-0.0924665704369545,
0.10671614110469818,
-0.17961181700229645,
-0.4052121341228485,
0.08686569333076477,
0.5549203753471375,
0.4818551540374756,
0.3432343900203705,
-0.22799643874168396,
0.046043768525123596,
0.3135613203048706,
-0.8461745381355286,
0.0633423700928688,
1.24091374874115,
0.15880246460437775,
0.8097986578941345,
-0.09233874082565308,
0.6437473893165588,
0.06363774091005325,
0.3746737241744995,
-0.752905011177063,
0.4272282123565674,
-0.5798661708831787,
-0.6522790193557739,
-0.13530239462852478,
-0.5117154121398926,
-0.7616928219795227,
0.7583587765693665,
-0.5811024904251099,
-0.4840865135192871,
-0.003945338539779186,
0.2837599813938141,
-0.5286750793457031,
0.13362005352973938,
-0.9139713048934937,
0.8126633167266846,
-0.06091409549117088,
-0.1619807630777359,
-0.4208313822746277,
-0.628561794757843,
0.43585076928138733,
-0.2468554675579071,
0.2830905616283417,
-0.3787572681903839,
-0.12430118769407272,
0.6600174903869629,
-0.3039846122264862,
0.9111043214797974,
-0.28729718923568726,
-0.07783758640289307,
-0.10495550185441971,
0.040375206619501114,
0.467633992433548,
0.015429921448230743,
0.02584768645465374,
0.13603748381137848,
0.16693562269210815,
-0.6973946690559387,
-0.2963251769542694,
0.7020217776298523,
-0.7038461565971375,
-0.39909428358078003,
-0.13915207982063293,
-1.0881476402282715,
-0.6842325329780579,
0.2578120529651642,
0.17707568407058716,
0.4461669921875,
-0.056959521025419235,
0.31989434361457825,
0.4857373833656311,
-0.27021095156669617,
-0.1261875033378601,
0.3965551555156708,
0.09472677856683731,
-0.25544917583465576,
1.1625380516052246,
0.1478651911020279,
0.4118213355541229,
0.42898088693618774,
0.3187170624732971,
0.2539917230606079,
-0.5876899361610413,
-0.5996937155723572,
0.17208217084407806,
-0.5186068415641785,
0.10095556080341339,
-0.822235107421875,
-0.13268819451332092,
-0.3872499167919159,
-0.15998125076293945,
-0.26191407442092896,
-0.22711874544620514,
-0.258146733045578,
0.38593730330467224,
0.2594050168991089,
0.47676756978034973,
0.37398144602775574,
0.37293389439582825,
-1.059230923652649,
0.6129332780838013,
0.37098929286003113,
-0.01643851399421692,
0.09287041425704956,
-0.4500502943992615,
-0.3261238932609558,
0.09822908043861389,
-0.2760910391807556,
-0.8406113386154175,
0.2633659839630127,
0.4048985242843628,
0.6746645569801331,
0.5178803205490112,
0.05733904987573624,
0.7751662135124207,
-0.5905488729476929,
0.6623234152793884,
0.23591136932373047,
-0.6494631171226501,
0.2274564504623413,
-0.41524872183799744,
0.19094477593898773,
0.4321235120296478,
0.2053583413362503,
-0.5722852945327759,
-0.6257011890411377,
-0.19875751435756683,
-0.7888875603675842,
0.5569502711296082,
-0.04654540866613388,
0.12064263224601746,
0.08063115179538727,
-0.03591839596629143,
0.5178900361061096,
0.06797047704458237,
-0.48633310198783875,
-0.23407968878746033,
0.1621004194021225,
-0.5709056854248047,
0.04582713916897774,
-0.26940983533859253,
-0.1898685097694397,
-0.25663861632347107,
0.8363774418830872,
-0.4103618860244751,
0.12572939693927765,
-0.010306050069630146,
-0.4125613570213318,
0.16434520483016968,
0.40203773975372314,
0.6022494435310364,
0.48801228404045105,
-0.009075561538338661,
-0.06385070085525513,
0.5181328058242798,
-0.7826553583145142,
-0.16617028415203094,
0.34564143419265747,
0.1296912431716919,
-0.051264237612485886,
0.4433220624923706,
0.6483634114265442,
0.56116783618927,
-0.9745815396308899,
0.5667145848274231,
0.29833829402923584,
-0.07814770191907883,
0.379626989364624,
0.37900230288505554,
0.18130318820476532,
0.10718557238578796,
0.5005500912666321,
0.4041599929332733,
0.24494114518165588,
-0.3832135498523712,
0.02776380628347397,
0.25201359391212463,
-0.4161475896835327,
-0.2061007171869278,
0.8096067309379578,
0.4685271680355072,
0.22653190791606903,
0.1635156124830246,
-0.014370321296155453,
-0.1690729409456253,
0.425982803106308,
0.583768904209137,
0.5068183541297913,
-0.43816712498664856,
-0.04338032007217407,
0.012968186289072037,
-0.04031089320778847,
-0.09369422495365143,
0.3952066898345947,
-0.07582180202007294,
-0.5622697472572327,
-0.5040643811225891,
-0.21267655491828918,
-0.3798162639141083,
-0.14575065672397614,
-0.5257904529571533,
0.23350533843040466,
-0.18152056634426117,
-0.04722835496068001,
0.03794286027550697,
-0.3324032425880432,
-0.27861952781677246,
0.1317281723022461,
0.05421289801597595,
0.722536027431488,
-0.7307227849960327,
1.175683617591858,
0.897222101688385,
-0.10449188947677612,
-0.576969563961029,
0.1585996001958847,
-0.06296496838331223,
-1.2066808938980103,
0.31722697615623474,
0.06591765582561493,
0.1698288470506668,
-0.03673672303557396,
-0.26150187849998474,
-0.3587722182273865,
0.8574085235595703,
0.5327733159065247,
-0.5013523697853088,
-0.2817414104938507,
-0.26965057849884033,
0.3598670959472656,
-0.2189011126756668,
0.17058254778385162,
0.2628973126411438,
0.1602005511522293,
-0.0820031464099884,
-1.1962978839874268,
0.03805812820792198,
-0.3042928874492645,
-0.22527755796909332,
0.10227485746145248,
-0.6468204259872437,
0.9667831659317017,
-0.27065369486808777,
0.21204690635204315,
0.20801334083080292,
0.41437530517578125,
0.5166396498680115,
0.21382005512714386,
0.5553981065750122,
0.14728432893753052,
1.0259597301483154,
0.15873830020427704,
0.9305822253227234,
-0.5387346148490906,
0.3152710199356079,
0.981281042098999,
-0.3464641571044922,
0.9385825395584106,
0.38789835572242737,
-0.02950974553823471,
0.3749716877937317,
0.3767052888870239,
0.13047948479652405,
0.4890560507774353,
-0.2597285509109497,
-0.3004342317581177,
-0.6044044494628906,
-0.11369479447603226,
-0.49409520626068115,
0.279609739780426,
0.4495634436607361,
-0.4773790240287781,
-0.13665682077407837,
0.2666435241699219,
0.11069469898939133,
-0.21569225192070007,
-0.3817339837551117,
0.8126761317253113,
0.15383830666542053,
-0.5176246762275696,
0.6065536737442017,
-0.04191089794039726,
0.9428404569625854,
-0.6857129335403442,
-0.2231673300266266,
0.1504032015800476,
0.044029414653778076,
-0.055592138320207596,
-0.3685733675956726,
-0.28258368372917175,
-0.18423961102962494,
-0.1326388269662857,
0.2606683373451233,
0.6561827659606934,
-0.6585708260536194,
-0.5985794067382812,
0.07948793470859528,
0.6108145117759705,
0.10971146821975708,
-0.22007989883422852,
-0.5848314762115479,
-0.3570692539215088,
-0.06471046060323715,
0.015411509200930595,
0.5531835556030273,
0.4826095700263977,
-0.021577471867203712,
0.764806866645813,
0.5847617387771606,
0.33934274315834045,
0.21643175184726715,
-0.17460700869560242,
0.7515583038330078,
-0.20550838112831116,
-0.7146050333976746,
-0.7485507130622864,
0.28323185443878174,
0.015615509822964668,
-0.3595472574234009,
0.34975919127464294,
0.43065154552459717,
0.4058848023414612,
-0.3071684241294861,
1.0425399541854858,
-0.08367644995450974,
0.4802860617637634,
-0.5163228511810303,
1.0456995964050293,
-0.9452130198478699,
-0.22794067859649658,
-0.1655423790216446,
-0.39876773953437805,
-0.33426693081855774,
0.48826515674591064,
-0.30112242698669434,
0.15242673456668854,
0.598084568977356,
0.5156941413879395,
-0.24536140263080597,
-0.2908972501754761,
0.6517344117164612,
0.4512942433357239,
0.2655898928642273,
0.9149944186210632,
0.41533181071281433,
-0.12861235439777374,
0.41028788685798645,
-0.15242406725883484,
-0.38947659730911255,
-0.7200959324836731,
-0.5145025253295898,
-0.8367777466773987,
-0.519726574420929,
-0.2537282705307007,
0.16771768033504486,
0.10770668089389801,
1.3322463035583496,
1.236322045326233,
-0.9831763505935669,
0.08166934549808502,
0.34677156805992126,
-0.1914987862110138,
-0.6599185466766357,
-0.16305600106716156,
0.38744843006134033,
-0.47097551822662354,
-0.9411314725875854,
0.5681912302970886,
0.4172739088535309,
-0.30712032318115234,
0.053670648485422134,
-0.13889162242412567,
-0.10540648549795151,
0.013337042182683945,
0.6210492849349976,
0.11365783959627151,
-0.7130361199378967,
-0.13787749409675598,
-0.13931512832641602,
-0.32544365525245667,
0.2866929769515991,
0.5386655330657959,
-0.5261324644088745,
0.7242932319641113,
0.3809548020362854,
0.9648006558418274,
-0.0025654376950114965,
-0.00016162634710781276,
0.605949878692627,
-0.6390334367752075,
0.21030467748641968,
0.14236290752887726,
0.6798513531684875,
0.12718400359153748,
-0.4224089980125427,
0.38418492674827576,
0.3951791226863861,
-0.5073750615119934,
-0.7350625991821289,
-0.09119865298271179,
-1.3221286535263062,
-0.4744146466255188,
1.2504013776779175,
-0.27683231234550476,
0.08863275498151779,
-0.3341195285320282,
-0.7510110139846802,
0.20924082398414612,
-0.5324645638465881,
0.858715832233429,
0.7247837781906128,
-0.17428474128246307,
0.028272535651922226,
-0.8269914388656616,
0.018699387088418007,
0.6534157395362854,
-0.9348956942558289,
0.03397410362958908,
0.3019450306892395,
0.5513388514518738,
-0.10553506761789322,
0.8432382345199585,
0.06061689555644989,
0.5568602681159973,
-0.14040504395961761,
-0.016441989690065384,
-0.08936841785907745,
-0.1680108904838562,
0.036107711493968964,
0.2302876114845276,
0.37434014678001404,
-0.5186156630516052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09022v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09022v1
|
Navigating the Landscape of Large Language Models: A Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Paradigms and Fine-Tuning Strategies
| 2024-04-13T15:03:03 | 2024-04-13T15:03:03 |
Benjue Weng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the surge of ChatGPT,the use of large models has significantly
increased,rapidly rising to prominence across the industry and sweeping across
the internet. This article is a comprehensive review of fine-tuning methods for
large models. This paper investigates the latest technological advancements and
the application of advanced methods in aspects such as task-adaptive
fine-tuning,domain-adaptive fine-tuning,few-shot learning,knowledge
distillation,multi-task learning,parameter-efficient fine-tuning,and dynamic
fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.5912711024284363,
-1.255523920059204,
0.30662524700164795,
0.09053532779216766,
-0.13776667416095734,
0.16668596863746643,
-0.6182123422622681,
-0.4883037209510803,
-0.35333946347236633,
0.4817900061607361,
-0.5146206021308899,
-0.19453538954257965,
-0.6203578114509583,
-0.22339046001434326,
-0.40272870659828186,
0.8659692406654358,
0.2029629796743393,
0.06634628772735596,
0.4079761207103729,
0.19610944390296936,
-0.6786609292030334,
-0.4195092022418976,
-1.1039317846298218,
-0.4239591956138611,
0.41117122769355774,
0.34576475620269775,
0.8403946161270142,
0.5810983777046204,
0.6524868011474609,
0.3027220666408539,
-0.3744566738605499,
0.24587151408195496,
-0.6556478142738342,
0.25206366181373596,
-0.317098468542099,
-0.31161507964134216,
-0.5882481336593628,
-0.27021992206573486,
0.8128063678741455,
0.8252953886985779,
-0.18273738026618958,
0.2127833217382431,
0.19833892583847046,
0.5916239023208618,
-0.5703099966049194,
0.3863767981529236,
-0.9282153248786926,
-0.04684603214263916,
-0.3866336941719055,
-0.4213329255580902,
-0.36463505029678345,
-0.06489228457212448,
0.25757279992103577,
-0.5859760046005249,
0.0354810506105423,
0.25674885511398315,
0.580532431602478,
0.15305723249912262,
-0.4855770766735077,
-0.37004992365837097,
-1.173649787902832,
0.931807816028595,
-0.7803216576576233,
0.4623975157737732,
0.1782962679862976,
0.6334158778190613,
-0.3879367411136627,
-0.7969235777854919,
-0.34957611560821533,
-0.3059983253479004,
0.4196220934391022,
-0.18521219491958618,
-0.2053646445274353,
0.2078993320465088,
0.27587953209877014,
0.5275586247444153,
-0.49270203709602356,
0.604092001914978,
-0.30191943049430847,
0.11615652590990067,
0.5943364500999451,
0.22797051072120667,
0.2426706999540329,
0.31172415614128113,
-0.010516646318137646,
0.023788610473275185,
-0.8611122369766235,
-0.24648572504520416,
0.1633082628250122,
0.6721205711364746,
0.05376977473497391,
0.37034663558006287,
-0.5459586977958679,
1.1282579898834229,
0.08788537979125977,
-0.09985999017953873,
-0.03878376632928848,
-0.30937132239341736,
-0.5085269808769226,
-0.1307746171951294,
0.6430308818817139,
0.3605459928512573,
0.5513731241226196,
-0.04761505872011185,
-0.07880895584821701,
-0.4026098847389221,
0.1922674924135208,
-0.7192746996879578,
-0.2639094889163971,
0.06462215632200241,
-0.498623788356781,
-0.18860416114330292,
-0.5648459792137146,
-0.9109028577804565,
-0.5996213555335999,
-0.6773373484611511,
0.5088303089141846,
-0.3259815275669098,
-0.43279385566711426,
0.48511847853660583,
-0.03817218914628029,
0.3457697629928589,
0.5460988879203796,
-1.0786420106887817,
0.2296738177537918,
1.1380395889282227,
0.9926707744598389,
0.030202459543943405,
-0.142383873462677,
-0.3491249680519104,
-0.03760601580142975,
-0.4969039261341095,
0.7035991549491882,
-0.661550760269165,
-0.167883962392807,
0.33590230345726013,
-0.10993260145187378,
-0.04067058116197586,
-0.4621809124946594,
0.3713432848453522,
-0.8070634603500366,
-0.04511509835720062,
-0.19798792898654938,
-0.6659526228904724,
-0.4493337869644165,
0.46373432874679565,
-0.48672837018966675,
0.6235761046409607,
-0.12516164779663086,
-0.6194710731506348,
0.22047339379787445,
-0.8071011304855347,
-0.44936686754226685,
0.064646415412426,
0.38601160049438477,
-0.18011412024497986,
0.11941716820001602,
0.14433878660202026,
0.7719904780387878,
-0.4505942463874817,
0.20227482914924622,
-0.23695306479930878,
-0.1369979828596115,
0.010413644835352898,
-0.4896019995212555,
0.6569331288337708,
0.5564555525779724,
-0.19105669856071472,
0.27100902795791626,
-0.7694774270057678,
-0.07475943118333817,
0.12104959040880203,
-0.2930213510990143,
-0.28342023491859436,
0.23108482360839844,
0.23521168529987335,
0.14749039709568024,
0.3046796917915344,
-0.20477323234081268,
0.42529451847076416,
-0.31773024797439575,
0.9280956983566284,
0.5376948118209839,
0.13521601259708405,
0.39481207728385925,
-0.20223067700862885,
0.37947970628738403,
-0.1983361691236496,
0.17585422098636627,
-0.3543733060359955,
-0.2689213156700134,
-0.8301916122436523,
-0.023577870801091194,
0.49866706132888794,
0.4892718493938446,
-0.5616482496261597,
0.23358356952667236,
-0.381451278924942,
-0.8966215252876282,
-0.3260881006717682,
0.07436557859182358,
0.18022389709949493,
-0.1264990121126175,
0.38624387979507446,
-0.1456257551908493,
-0.2954316735267639,
-0.8008863925933838,
-0.366637259721756,
0.2589220106601715,
0.029800934717059135,
0.20335246622562408,
0.25030237436294556,
-0.20869526267051697,
0.4664933681488037,
-0.5672378540039062,
-0.12418384104967117,
-0.35258951783180237,
0.26471826434135437,
0.09023132175207138,
0.5732167363166809,
0.4493035078048706,
-0.8213253021240234,
-0.6258214712142944,
0.5081867575645447,
-0.23617932200431824,
0.13579602539539337,
-0.1632891297340393,
0.09166569262742996,
-0.12347692996263504,
0.9296198487281799,
-0.5180851221084595,
-0.3193998634815216,
0.560483455657959,
-0.09438011050224304,
0.5230816602706909,
-0.29745304584503174,
0.1103362962603569,
-1.0659369230270386,
-0.054479796439409256,
0.2733951807022095,
-0.3871850371360779,
-0.7931233048439026,
0.5043908357620239,
-0.06345055252313614,
-0.11839236319065094,
-0.19738896191120148,
0.43664196133613586,
-0.6577064394950867,
0.1610797494649887,
-0.5083884596824646,
0.14095450937747955,
-0.4539702534675598,
0.2503647804260254,
-0.13081787526607513,
0.5572177767753601,
0.8810119032859802,
-0.7012898325920105,
0.538752019405365,
-0.017123963683843613,
-0.6038004159927368,
0.2615158259868622,
-0.48439979553222656,
0.057155709713697433,
-0.08662299811840057,
0.14951328933238983,
-0.9602648615837097,
-0.26893651485443115,
-0.07336632162332535,
-0.15018053352832794,
0.5890767574310303,
-0.2859712541103363,
-0.7202946543693542,
-0.2576841115951538,
0.05074875056743622,
0.2553083002567291,
0.5488408803939819,
-0.39185068011283875,
0.3742079734802246,
0.644313395023346,
-0.45248040556907654,
-0.287314236164093,
-0.17167773842811584,
0.2636496126651764,
-0.4024372100830078,
-0.4277341663837433,
0.1865014135837555,
-0.001027340884320438,
-0.28169187903404236,
-0.5594711303710938,
0.1498689353466034,
-0.14654913544654846,
0.28033551573753357,
-0.15830795466899872,
-0.0759720504283905,
-0.37098217010498047,
0.05375147983431816,
0.010425487533211708,
-0.015332696959376335,
-0.20698176324367523,
-0.4069647789001465,
1.0247713327407837,
-0.0828910693526268,
-0.13402915000915527,
-0.27870240807533264,
0.11645341664552689,
0.7284711599349976,
-0.4955296516418457,
0.5794548392295837,
0.7473024725914001,
-0.4124053418636322,
-0.20075319707393646,
-0.6603566408157349,
-0.08854077756404877,
-0.5013936758041382,
0.6813080310821533,
-0.36100220680236816,
-1.1927711963653564,
0.5349175333976746,
-0.6197981238365173,
0.29426658153533936,
0.45779964327812195,
0.9406902194023132,
0.22810620069503784,
1.2761799097061157,
0.9350953102111816,
-0.14449438452720642,
0.7121430039405823,
-0.04934222251176834,
0.47777366638183594,
-0.6311450004577637,
0.14542831480503082,
-0.7619692087173462,
-0.35054922103881836,
-0.9758017063140869,
-0.2982807457447052,
0.3235609531402588,
0.05751420557498932,
-0.5149074196815491,
0.3312884271144867,
-0.2947418987751007,
0.5143013000488281,
0.5855741500854492,
-0.15722507238388062,
0.5562071800231934,
-0.1406596451997757,
0.1540382355451584,
0.22714939713478088,
-0.7528024911880493,
-0.29800334572792053,
0.8913318514823914,
0.5905268788337708,
0.8269209265708923,
0.0010213997447863221,
-0.08696160465478897,
0.031013324856758118,
-0.2134385108947754,
-0.8819862008094788,
0.4726772904396057,
-0.3819797933101654,
-0.8483121991157532,
-0.49292096495628357,
-0.27834567427635193,
-0.9740443229675293,
0.3537977933883667,
-0.4001304805278778,
-0.8605844974517822,
-0.05520367622375488,
0.3259901702404022,
-0.49814268946647644,
0.45978569984436035,
-0.6607944369316101,
0.8110562562942505,
-0.07187116146087646,
-0.21335291862487793,
-0.6703847050666809,
-0.48998352885246277,
0.27610939741134644,
-0.2112797498703003,
0.1862667053937912,
-0.03727269545197487,
0.22686345875263214,
0.4710923433303833,
0.18120859563350677,
0.9154781699180603,
-0.012744447216391563,
-0.3666212856769562,
0.07181694358587265,
0.3410927355289459,
0.4834425449371338,
-0.22622568905353546,
0.07557791471481323,
0.1598559021949768,
0.25431564450263977,
-0.27730321884155273,
-0.28711146116256714,
0.858593761920929,
-0.5512248277664185,
-0.49276819825172424,
-0.13755305111408234,
-0.612553596496582,
-0.5871002674102783,
0.382362425327301,
0.20331791043281555,
0.46300703287124634,
-0.3036762773990631,
0.5499206781387329,
0.7396459579467773,
-0.3768734633922577,
0.430938720703125,
0.4966248869895935,
-0.2509095072746277,
0.10608206689357758,
0.9459418058395386,
0.20853331685066223,
0.46188199520111084,
0.434526652097702,
0.16106024384498596,
-0.0856759250164032,
-0.9509334564208984,
-0.21486136317253113,
0.1263541728258133,
-0.42757225036621094,
-0.18388277292251587,
-0.5207177400588989,
-0.38049206137657166,
-0.36040228605270386,
-0.047801703214645386,
-0.6402835845947266,
-0.18611538410186768,
0.06223713606595993,
0.15644262731075287,
0.296105295419693,
0.7468045949935913,
0.2308913916349411,
0.6786776781082153,
-0.7476726174354553,
0.061578162014484406,
0.2635820806026459,
0.43397003412246704,
0.2534351348876953,
-0.462400883436203,
-0.431512713432312,
0.144998699426651,
-0.48579728603363037,
-0.33161789178848267,
0.27535414695739746,
0.27963778376579285,
0.36773353815078735,
0.4117548167705536,
-0.28169724345207214,
0.7183323502540588,
-0.8213844895362854,
0.8968371748924255,
-0.03235539793968201,
-0.9284682869911194,
0.3969723582267761,
-0.8766486048698425,
0.44601431488990784,
0.16525447368621826,
0.45071205496788025,
-0.9507091641426086,
-0.06590725481510162,
-0.32770317792892456,
-0.9364050626754761,
0.3120867609977722,
-0.17366953194141388,
0.46184220910072327,
0.29694435000419617,
0.3189219832420349,
0.15510810911655426,
0.30383506417274475,
-0.4723164737224579,
0.14420802891254425,
0.2738863527774811,
0.004375011660158634,
-0.27734461426734924,
-0.16502805054187775,
0.06321240216493607,
-0.31344836950302124,
0.866439163684845,
-0.2863195538520813,
-0.003994846250861883,
-0.41934746503829956,
-0.07723627239465714,
-0.18170320987701416,
0.4001886248588562,
0.6059166193008423,
0.971611738204956,
-0.06852159649133682,
-0.16687780618667603,
0.20181365311145782,
-0.3419640064239502,
-0.3673933148384094,
-0.04342277720570564,
-0.07963944226503372,
-0.29118186235427856,
0.22406458854675293,
1.1100142002105713,
0.3894239068031311,
-0.6408219933509827,
0.2528366148471832,
0.22906942665576935,
-0.20281356573104858,
-0.22217093408107758,
0.30964094400405884,
0.16701288521289825,
0.495932936668396,
0.15287120640277863,
-0.12074772268533707,
0.20369268953800201,
-0.6261856555938721,
-0.27102380990982056,
0.7496849298477173,
-0.5003080368041992,
-0.30301323533058167,
0.5281285047531128,
0.1633291095495224,
-0.12004929780960083,
0.39681220054626465,
0.07624843716621399,
-0.3237903416156769,
0.29404401779174805,
0.5096766352653503,
0.6991696357727051,
-0.34124982357025146,
-0.03550930693745613,
0.39256617426872253,
0.32926198840141296,
-0.4971035122871399,
-0.004545978736132383,
0.09560473263263702,
-0.6366819739341736,
-0.696830153465271,
-0.6683648824691772,
-0.4480660855770111,
0.5104203224182129,
-0.3526371419429779,
0.3861842155456543,
-0.4258820116519928,
-0.1718357503414154,
0.49408942461013794,
0.031031794846057892,
-0.5929712057113647,
0.10333921760320663,
0.2572482228279114,
1.1479110717773438,
-0.6196053624153137,
0.7866097092628479,
0.7401078343391418,
-0.08146090060472488,
-0.5796446800231934,
0.1138882040977478,
0.1551317721605301,
-0.7412693500518799,
0.4337642192840576,
-0.2135024219751358,
-0.029117485508322716,
0.29516249895095825,
-0.6327566504478455,
-0.98038649559021,
0.8329799175262451,
0.2022891789674759,
-0.9511003494262695,
-0.10911945253610611,
-0.08442957699298859,
0.6624017953872681,
-0.10335911810398102,
0.09384996443986893,
0.7885470390319824,
0.46627071499824524,
0.01565425843000412,
-1.5537868738174438,
-0.1886800080537796,
0.053284406661987305,
0.16450513899326324,
0.4408232569694519,
-0.8082787990570068,
0.8372234106063843,
0.2331867218017578,
-0.10266955941915512,
0.034345101565122604,
0.3803732991218567,
-0.3402697443962097,
-0.07142309099435806,
0.46846479177474976,
0.13216620683670044,
0.6266135573387146,
-0.1326601505279541,
0.7338307499885559,
-0.32092902064323425,
0.6043577194213867,
0.9729139804840088,
-0.24614496529102325,
1.0592154264450073,
0.19864322245121002,
-0.09145157039165497,
0.056949812918901443,
0.6333166360855103,
-0.12153390049934387,
0.3568854033946991,
0.3344053328037262,
-0.10393959283828735,
-0.47690701484680176,
0.03888170048594475,
-0.3177013397216797,
0.7458140254020691,
0.7185001373291016,
-0.229739710688591,
-0.49828803539276123,
0.3036355674266815,
0.14338168501853943,
-0.17926661670207977,
-0.6152376532554626,
1.0488789081573486,
0.15204134583473206,
-0.7555533051490784,
0.709326446056366,
0.2885051965713501,
0.7054252028465271,
-0.5862351059913635,
0.10776302218437195,
0.1792275607585907,
0.4571501314640045,
0.07230168581008911,
-0.7617563605308533,
0.1166352704167366,
-0.13600826263427734,
0.09743870794773102,
-0.14559826254844666,
0.8970980644226074,
-0.3810935914516449,
-0.1970708817243576,
0.18415674567222595,
0.5250354409217834,
-0.16016361117362976,
-0.36121976375579834,
-0.6875580549240112,
0.07151488214731216,
-0.14981335401535034,
-0.27447429299354553,
0.49140965938568115,
0.4354417324066162,
-0.1596158742904663,
0.9392923712730408,
0.5282912850379944,
0.09463564306497574,
0.021512756124138832,
0.008149326778948307,
0.7721598148345947,
-0.6145012378692627,
-0.4591895639896393,
-0.8871168494224548,
0.2456761747598648,
0.02315439283847809,
-0.344672828912735,
0.70158451795578,
0.47929003834724426,
0.8365991115570068,
-0.15014512836933136,
0.7670271992683411,
0.10328106582164764,
0.6397913098335266,
-0.6909480094909668,
0.8077732920646667,
-0.5852529406547546,
-0.04513242840766907,
-0.25343114137649536,
-1.0874571800231934,
-0.5022292137145996,
0.5316118001937866,
-0.42231836915016174,
0.0702253133058548,
0.319238543510437,
0.7155396938323975,
-0.38351404666900635,
0.14838722348213196,
0.3312644064426422,
0.5774258971214294,
0.4118083715438843,
0.2801966369152069,
0.6420809030532837,
-0.24765166640281677,
0.16223561763763428,
0.11987505108118057,
-0.3536500632762909,
-0.536278486251831,
-1.0396926403045654,
-0.8765690922737122,
-0.8610538244247437,
-0.33319032192230225,
-0.052815042436122894,
0.110253244638443,
0.9527196884155273,
1.0118474960327148,
-0.9029378294944763,
-0.3353966176509857,
0.05484592169523239,
-0.2660606801509857,
-0.31397172808647156,
-0.14970378577709198,
0.12952201068401337,
-0.6550917029380798,
-0.9593396186828613,
0.25984594225883484,
0.3314569592475891,
-0.060041867196559906,
-0.4414575695991516,
0.3282880187034607,
-0.14630073308944702,
0.13920758664608002,
0.9645386934280396,
0.32761356234550476,
-0.4616957902908325,
-0.2352312207221985,
-0.10751300305128098,
0.11351637542247772,
-0.03227457031607628,
0.8939455151557922,
-0.25607407093048096,
0.3079133927822113,
0.6350094676017761,
0.6805307865142822,
0.5828371644020081,
-0.1755160689353943,
0.771660566329956,
-0.5096956491470337,
0.057119227945804596,
0.016773562878370285,
0.32343772053718567,
0.32480117678642273,
-0.10372694581747055,
0.3061782419681549,
-0.2546803951263428,
-0.9177356362342834,
-0.7972415089607239,
0.2589323818683624,
-1.0359656810760498,
-0.5492067933082581,
1.206166386604309,
0.28039008378982544,
0.08587531000375748,
-0.13870097696781158,
-0.44875282049179077,
0.19797754287719727,
-0.13027848303318024,
0.819918155670166,
0.9753817915916443,
0.046857960522174835,
-0.22486425936222076,
-1.1774176359176636,
0.7514457106590271,
0.11290320008993149,
-0.7596595287322998,
0.4304943084716797,
0.4945010840892792,
0.3202146589756012,
0.24471206963062286,
0.18866078555583954,
-0.03845663741230965,
-0.0793524831533432,
-0.21095557510852814,
-0.3518463969230652,
0.19231653213500977,
-0.3351140022277832,
-0.32624438405036926,
0.12369044870138168,
0.5667874217033386,
0.04393576458096504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13067v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13067v1
|
Towards Efficient Resume Understanding: A Multi-Granularity Multi-Modal Pre-Training Approach
| 2024-04-13T14:31:24 | 2024-04-13T14:31:24 |
Feihu Jiang, Chuan Qin, Jingshuai Zhang, Kaichun Yao, Xi Chen, Dazhong Shen, Chen Zhu, Hengshu Zhu, Hui Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In the contemporary era of widespread online recruitment, resume
understanding has been widely acknowledged as a fundamental and crucial task,
which aims to extract structured information from resume documents
automatically. Compared to the traditional rule-based approaches, the
utilization of recently proposed pre-trained document understanding models can
greatly enhance the effectiveness of resume understanding. The present
approaches have, however, disregarded the hierarchical relations within the
structured information presented in resumes, and have difficulty parsing
resumes in an efficient manner. To this end, in this paper, we propose a novel
model, namely ERU, to achieve efficient resume understanding. Specifically, we
first introduce a layout-aware multi-modal fusion transformer for encoding the
segments in the resume with integrated textual, visual, and layout information.
Then, we design three self-supervised tasks to pre-train this module via a
large number of unlabeled resumes. Next, we fine-tune the model with a
multi-granularity sequence labeling task to extract structured information from
resumes. Finally, extensive experiments on a real-world dataset clearly
demonstrate the effectiveness of ERU.
|
[
-0.2537824213504791,
-0.8047650456428528,
0.5902298092842102,
0.3672051727771759,
-0.05904331058263779,
-0.38182318210601807,
-0.047701146453619,
-0.16735278069972992,
0.1784515231847763,
0.2830432653427124,
-0.8095265030860901,
-0.42613449692726135,
-0.3063170313835144,
-0.08196981251239777,
-0.180807426571846,
1.2129855155944824,
0.1362832486629486,
-0.22007688879966736,
-0.3832473158836365,
-0.09565682709217072,
-0.6832120418548584,
-0.2995709180831909,
-0.2777694761753082,
-0.4435378313064575,
0.43205031752586365,
0.4070962071418762,
0.10623402893543243,
0.6746854186058044,
0.22226044535636902,
0.31948143243789673,
0.18727298080921173,
0.09694550186395645,
-0.6457518339157104,
-0.15464940667152405,
-0.08716033399105072,
-0.3376598060131073,
-0.6786887645721436,
0.053192880004644394,
0.6271314024925232,
0.660920262336731,
-0.3821645975112915,
0.2808097004890442,
0.05381378158926964,
0.6559441089630127,
-0.5304329991340637,
0.3333301246166229,
-0.3780427575111389,
0.05296418070793152,
-0.0324852354824543,
-0.2216213047504425,
-0.5881853103637695,
0.20117318630218506,
-0.14090128242969513,
-1.0673577785491943,
0.405604749917984,
-0.009622665122151375,
0.9966630935668945,
0.015203047543764114,
-0.5226272344589233,
-0.07746017724275589,
-0.5134922862052917,
0.6547021865844727,
-0.10584132373332977,
0.8617454171180725,
0.44568541646003723,
0.41083842515945435,
0.13363851606845856,
-0.6797714829444885,
-0.48980098962783813,
0.24440442025661469,
-0.29910045862197876,
0.5253154635429382,
0.2622332274913788,
0.30166372656822205,
-0.06505400687456131,
0.5909253358840942,
-0.6454028487205505,
0.2685072720050812,
-0.3251528739929199,
-0.1349518746137619,
0.20254942774772644,
-0.05148325487971306,
0.22506439685821533,
-0.3226168751716614,
-0.4639773964881897,
-0.25184112787246704,
-0.10775597393512726,
0.16359834372997284,
0.3234202265739441,
0.016249364241957664,
-0.1684904396533966,
0.28560903668403625,
-0.27300602197647095,
1.1039623022079468,
0.11283320188522339,
-0.32187867164611816,
0.31318986415863037,
-0.7110090851783752,
-0.45507389307022095,
-0.3883703947067261,
0.5279837250709534,
-0.05934065580368042,
-0.25854039192199707,
-0.3997398316860199,
-0.35993897914886475,
-0.19308260083198547,
0.9649791121482849,
-0.5866385102272034,
-0.19828328490257263,
0.09768088907003403,
-0.9391781687736511,
-0.18839631974697113,
0.4847576320171356,
-0.6126313805580139,
0.027171801775693893,
-0.3895895481109619,
0.5056629180908203,
-0.6018251180648804,
0.10139133036136627,
-0.031914230436086655,
-0.05797189846634865,
0.271120548248291,
0.8679028153419495,
-0.7053775191307068,
-0.1254645735025406,
0.7177960276603699,
0.6650645136833191,
-0.022584907710552216,
-0.38464686274528503,
-0.652138888835907,
0.26715272665023804,
0.2607317268848419,
0.8419272899627686,
-0.6654077172279358,
-0.2510453164577484,
-0.16233429312705994,
0.07772431522607803,
-0.550916850566864,
-0.11967312544584274,
0.603583037853241,
-0.7544847726821899,
0.2584451735019684,
0.15638333559036255,
-0.18735271692276,
-0.5966252684593201,
0.6989542245864868,
-0.7590810060501099,
0.7913965582847595,
0.4542337656021118,
-0.5311402082443237,
0.5171008110046387,
-0.8099114298820496,
-0.4033874571323395,
-0.2958855926990509,
-0.5296496152877808,
-0.3839958906173706,
0.043589845299720764,
0.32548072934150696,
0.44795235991477966,
0.10493262857198715,
0.08483174443244934,
0.2601669728755951,
-0.28690025210380554,
-0.06538105010986328,
0.009516416117548943,
0.3128761053085327,
0.38036781549453735,
0.1872936189174652,
0.3366139233112335,
-0.6620031595230103,
-0.250156968832016,
-0.11294695734977722,
-0.8724963068962097,
-0.016301067546010017,
-0.32374250888824463,
0.1838197559118271,
0.4412166178226471,
0.18777628242969513,
-0.29171741008758545,
0.31982511281967163,
-0.08147744089365005,
-0.06663054972887039,
0.783191442489624,
-0.28285640478134155,
0.7253966331481934,
-0.454689621925354,
0.7043898701667786,
0.22822879254817963,
0.1450463980436325,
-0.8700389862060547,
-0.07643526047468185,
-0.3563155233860016,
-0.6583582162857056,
0.11191879212856293,
0.5744076371192932,
-0.49636194109916687,
0.7395913004875183,
-0.3556616008281708,
-0.4563365578651428,
-0.33147528767585754,
0.24727633595466614,
0.454637736082077,
0.7891649007797241,
0.5219241976737976,
-0.560148298740387,
-0.5014100074768066,
-0.8168215155601501,
-0.6154577136039734,
0.06247087940573692,
-0.026252200827002525,
0.5744504928588867,
0.3709401786327362,
-0.5662276148796082,
0.847789466381073,
-0.4099968373775482,
-0.7054779529571533,
-0.4095756411552429,
0.333175927400589,
0.43145057559013367,
0.5605023503303528,
0.12227360159158707,
-1.0212007761001587,
-0.11655156314373016,
0.06436536461114883,
-0.8378913402557373,
0.285472571849823,
-0.7399142384529114,
-0.2100910246372223,
-0.48858126997947693,
0.3773502707481384,
-0.5036224722862244,
0.36581191420555115,
0.1450810730457306,
-0.38534000515937805,
0.408232182264328,
-0.6242815256118774,
0.4214293360710144,
-0.9078458547592163,
0.1853608638048172,
0.43671202659606934,
-0.48624902963638306,
-0.6815412640571594,
0.1954212784767151,
0.4834758937358856,
-0.2739747166633606,
-0.33402955532073975,
0.198515385389328,
-0.6261365413665771,
0.013998560607433319,
-0.06773615628480911,
0.004248631652444601,
0.24427227675914764,
0.4249876141548157,
-0.02429681271314621,
0.49440521001815796,
0.30307790637016296,
-0.7441138029098511,
-0.04950568825006485,
0.5963563323020935,
-0.3386833965778351,
0.8224630951881409,
-0.32387134432792664,
0.20751863718032837,
-0.7646744251251221,
0.929132342338562,
-1.1971790790557861,
-0.41578209400177,
-0.1272086352109909,
0.008350602351129055,
0.4909273684024811,
-0.44963765144348145,
-0.33011865615844727,
-0.4404575824737549,
-0.24787357449531555,
0.7311660051345825,
0.2007543444633484,
-0.5699375867843628,
1.1470431089401245,
0.41032490134239197,
0.1454334259033203,
-0.6946862936019897,
-0.6263594031333923,
-0.370077520608902,
-0.27156493067741394,
-0.679796040058136,
0.8449164628982544,
0.19371022284030914,
-0.04278478026390076,
-0.6225573420524597,
-0.1111738532781601,
-0.6445738077163696,
0.20129556953907013,
0.3706834316253662,
0.3828757703304291,
0.08265966922044754,
0.12346751242876053,
-0.020196586847305298,
-0.06973530352115631,
-0.3446572422981262,
-0.25640684366226196,
0.5103955268859863,
-0.1837027221918106,
-0.4539300501346588,
-0.824908435344696,
0.1528192013502121,
0.4588145911693573,
-0.23147150874137878,
0.827784538269043,
1.0109622478485107,
-0.1392519176006317,
0.09590238332748413,
-0.9638496041297913,
-0.1259608417749405,
-0.4098978042602539,
0.3994104564189911,
-0.47196492552757263,
-0.5273519158363342,
0.5635343194007874,
-0.43696069717407227,
0.1736602783203125,
0.5104004740715027,
0.3343718647956848,
-0.15661752223968506,
0.3611638844013214,
1.0238680839538574,
0.10975497961044312,
0.7031128406524658,
-0.2875460684299469,
-0.000004536737378657563,
-0.6969437599182129,
-0.7387329936027527,
-0.29087528586387634,
-0.3377000689506531,
0.11183509230613708,
-0.4427518844604492,
0.38257887959480286,
0.07824595272541046,
0.1563721001148224,
0.42306044697761536,
-0.4727350175380707,
0.48526257276535034,
0.2773134708404541,
0.47283849120140076,
0.23585359752178192,
-0.263267457485199,
0.2317252904176712,
0.21824367344379425,
-0.5694273710250854,
-0.4275653064250946,
0.8900811672210693,
0.345127135515213,
0.924166738986969,
-0.1779630482196808,
0.7820354104042053,
0.2315264344215393,
-0.061205681413412094,
-0.61018306016922,
0.1216481626033783,
0.005393789149820805,
-0.21907535195350647,
-0.23271790146827698,
-0.310438871383667,
-0.8853986859321594,
0.48989444971084595,
-0.2239488959312439,
-0.7089300155639648,
0.22324852645397186,
0.1670898199081421,
-0.6181753873825073,
0.08304869383573532,
-0.6146718859672546,
1.2058748006820679,
-0.214201420545578,
-0.01492312178015709,
-0.4025752544403076,
-0.7990059852600098,
0.26639071106910706,
-0.4862939417362213,
0.8463785648345947,
0.2359195351600647,
0.046071965247392654,
1.0415940284729004,
-0.20596003532409668,
0.6555320024490356,
-0.005610347725450993,
-0.010717539116740227,
-0.009118001908063889,
-0.017567340284585953,
0.4719686806201935,
0.17463624477386475,
-0.36254429817199707,
0.08268414437770844,
-0.011230343021452427,
-0.3981766700744629,
-0.34286749362945557,
0.6138443946838379,
-0.6393304467201233,
-0.11446692049503326,
-0.07178951054811478,
-0.9158691763877869,
0.29175665974617004,
0.3581011891365051,
0.24978044629096985,
0.4114533066749573,
-0.5399278402328491,
0.16193066537380219,
0.6309131383895874,
-0.3684852123260498,
0.2544389069080353,
0.27617162466049194,
-0.046648796647787094,
0.05581396073102951,
0.7543545365333557,
0.08611349761486053,
-0.23662050068378448,
0.5544201135635376,
-0.16630971431732178,
-0.3082389533519745,
-0.18593893945217133,
-0.5210207104682922,
0.2466655820608139,
-0.7472265362739563,
0.037737831473350525,
-1.1247973442077637,
0.2457548826932907,
-0.6033418774604797,
-0.42012885212898254,
-0.16347602009773254,
-0.18979881703853607,
-0.38644343614578247,
0.12948071956634521,
-0.19089671969413757,
1.0366469621658325,
-0.08341018855571747,
0.6089071035385132,
-0.8446993231773376,
0.7102635502815247,
0.4156349301338196,
0.32989516854286194,
-0.03396740183234215,
-0.7542120814323425,
-0.46665120124816895,
-0.11737621575593948,
-0.5865252614021301,
-0.8391602039337158,
0.29283222556114197,
0.6257210373878479,
0.9896775484085083,
0.6566847562789917,
-0.24018488824367523,
0.7527341842651367,
-0.35858187079429626,
0.5641921162605286,
0.1414671391248703,
-0.6253128051757812,
0.9197559952735901,
-0.515451192855835,
0.2533521056175232,
1.0921542644500732,
0.6275756359100342,
-0.3226560354232788,
0.2894236743450165,
-0.7541824579238892,
-0.8783197402954102,
0.9951908588409424,
0.04391154646873474,
0.028206130489706993,
-0.04092053323984146,
0.4139024317264557,
0.6477298140525818,
0.22944332659244537,
-0.7105224132537842,
-0.1164010614156723,
-0.2988013029098511,
-0.12558171153068542,
0.06779071688652039,
-0.2038404792547226,
-0.19157902896404266,
-0.3977530002593994,
0.47272881865501404,
0.025552159175276756,
0.41104787588119507,
0.030407095327973366,
-0.8968022465705872,
0.3119564652442932,
0.36604857444763184,
0.5026307702064514,
1.1466649770736694,
-0.17915546894073486,
0.06393151730298996,
0.24063457548618317,
-0.33457088470458984,
0.03378824517130852,
0.029921768233180046,
0.48155850172042847,
-0.057178810238838196,
-0.00006040082735125907,
0.47698912024497986,
0.3339741826057434,
-0.44487908482551575,
1.0175292491912842,
-0.19276046752929688,
-0.047064971178770065,
-0.26449912786483765,
-0.08399609476327896,
-0.3213183581829071,
0.08924783021211624,
0.3852072060108185,
0.016317518427968025,
0.0674402266740799,
-0.7338530421257019,
0.39758825302124023,
0.3859647214412689,
-0.3822682499885559,
-0.32038047909736633,
0.5804875493049622,
0.24336057901382446,
-0.2718406915664673,
0.8434333205223083,
0.03364423289895058,
-0.22407318651676178,
0.418885201215744,
0.6920990943908691,
0.3488139510154724,
-0.14227278530597687,
0.21682685613632202,
0.26998522877693176,
-0.19416579604148865,
-0.24759124219417572,
0.15764391422271729,
-0.49807533621788025,
-0.5140637755393982,
-0.41136693954467773,
-0.6830351948738098,
-0.1484035700559616,
-0.07058952003717422,
-0.8465763330459595,
0.2223213016986847,
-0.37833577394485474,
0.17619270086288452,
-0.1427491158246994,
-0.6782665252685547,
-1.2690702676773071,
0.4141511619091034,
0.024443021044135094,
0.6288828253746033,
-1.0366687774658203,
0.5684825778007507,
1.00905179977417,
-0.6100012063980103,
-0.5444466471672058,
-0.3311642110347748,
-0.11463773250579834,
-0.7907032370567322,
0.7635161280632019,
0.8677089214324951,
0.11140405386686325,
0.124448262155056,
0.06836218386888504,
-0.3376644551753998,
1.2135077714920044,
0.3021695911884308,
-0.30257999897003174,
-0.4247807264328003,
-0.4297981560230255,
-0.06591993570327759,
-0.42301687598228455,
0.9025483727455139,
0.4371752440929413,
0.5567337870597839,
-0.14625822007656097,
-1.1044325828552246,
-0.08100345730781555,
-0.30550870299339294,
-0.19173350930213928,
-0.02335701324045658,
-0.4307984709739685,
1.061185598373413,
-0.11258713155984879,
-0.24443940818309784,
-0.4503800868988037,
0.8626076579093933,
-0.06325582414865494,
0.18800537288188934,
0.7626667022705078,
0.7049780488014221,
1.0230821371078491,
0.04130781814455986,
1.0765583515167236,
-0.3095782399177551,
0.45544639229774475,
0.9862319231033325,
0.34747716784477234,
0.3444943428039551,
0.3043137490749359,
-0.026676053181290627,
1.1280573606491089,
0.6274509429931641,
0.08908914774656296,
0.28396639227867126,
-0.18557290732860565,
-0.11940369755029678,
-0.6984599828720093,
0.030193395912647247,
-0.5170899033546448,
0.7801027297973633,
0.1527891457080841,
-0.630329430103302,
-0.6078235507011414,
0.36242616176605225,
-0.29833656549453735,
0.0009798865066841245,
-0.40775853395462036,
1.1084827184677124,
-0.12006450444459915,
-0.467043399810791,
0.3735595941543579,
0.06378919631242752,
0.7753759026527405,
-0.613968014717102,
-0.10264195501804352,
0.23885725438594818,
-0.010181508027017117,
-0.6605123281478882,
-0.5766016840934753,
0.056845396757125854,
-0.3719465136528015,
-0.40422648191452026,
-0.5150302052497864,
0.9125151038169861,
-0.21781082451343536,
-0.24569641053676605,
-0.14408454298973083,
0.7665318846702576,
0.39616379141807556,
-0.4293554127216339,
-0.5065764784812927,
-0.09114526957273483,
-0.2635953724384308,
-0.17425093054771423,
0.6104361414909363,
0.3355872929096222,
0.38783013820648193,
0.4117461144924164,
0.6126169562339783,
-0.34608811140060425,
-0.18718577921390533,
0.08867979794740677,
0.9077209234237671,
-0.5987482666969299,
-1.306823968887329,
-0.7851824760437012,
0.6194828748703003,
-0.16402551531791687,
-0.1745491921901703,
0.5585382580757141,
0.683835506439209,
0.7898675799369812,
-0.3488616645336151,
0.6418501138687134,
0.013282522559165955,
0.05642574653029442,
-0.45538532733917236,
0.861366868019104,
-0.5296050310134888,
0.041240666061639786,
-0.2604755759239197,
-1.0512415170669556,
-0.07559902966022491,
0.9711036086082458,
-0.4374220669269562,
0.22091160714626312,
0.5271084308624268,
0.5033212304115295,
-0.602493405342102,
-0.11181067675352097,
0.14157135784626007,
-0.12997855246067047,
0.21909090876579285,
0.33084046840667725,
0.4319969713687897,
-0.33080533146858215,
0.43223291635513306,
-0.1532527357339859,
-0.43980056047439575,
-0.44466084241867065,
-0.8162277936935425,
-0.8237929940223694,
-0.5858156085014343,
-0.08320706337690353,
-0.3171139657497406,
-0.18527506291866302,
0.8004008531570435,
0.9994530081748962,
-0.39340025186538696,
-0.2018408626317978,
-0.01728879101574421,
0.015764161944389343,
-0.2717552185058594,
-0.23237858712673187,
0.2692519426345825,
-0.5210338234901428,
-0.20679160952568054,
0.996112585067749,
0.25627264380455017,
-0.12859074771404266,
0.09255004674196243,
0.09696167707443237,
-0.44817623496055603,
-0.2414112091064453,
0.6562168598175049,
0.3886868953704834,
-0.43940266966819763,
-0.21201026439666748,
-0.48258620500564575,
-0.02280643954873085,
0.38952720165252686,
0.9817813038825989,
-1.1274244785308838,
0.6589021682739258,
0.5726930499076843,
0.9003195762634277,
0.44408926367759705,
0.6163157224655151,
0.5527213215827942,
-0.9234926700592041,
0.11114676296710968,
-0.07156387716531754,
0.4413451850414276,
0.2050144374370575,
-0.6902550458908081,
0.5016531944274902,
0.05331391468644142,
-0.5582427978515625,
-0.5329380035400391,
0.17012546956539154,
-1.2781537771224976,
-0.24657058715820312,
0.9606621265411377,
-0.28121891617774963,
-0.1594310998916626,
-0.39156508445739746,
-0.17531205713748932,
0.5908426642417908,
-0.3019757568836212,
0.8540725708007812,
0.20004048943519592,
-0.29737401008605957,
0.07053398340940475,
-0.35448405146598816,
0.04429076239466667,
0.40848299860954285,
-0.8839671611785889,
-0.2481863647699356,
0.5079581141471863,
-0.027370130643248558,
0.17379069328308105,
0.9034456014633179,
0.03360725939273834,
0.5424279570579529,
-0.21031884849071503,
-0.14156433939933777,
-0.49698030948638916,
-0.6045424938201904,
-0.2681771516799927,
0.3188646137714386,
-0.22821533679962158,
-0.2646694481372833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09002v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09002v1
|
WikiSplit++: Easy Data Refinement for Split and Rephrase
| 2024-04-13T13:07:32 | 2024-04-13T13:07:32 |
Hayato Tsukagoshi, Tsutomu Hirao, Makoto Morishita, Katsuki Chousa, Ryohei Sasano, Koichi Takeda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The task of Split and Rephrase, which splits a complex sentence into multiple
simple sentences with the same meaning, improves readability and enhances the
performance of downstream tasks in natural language processing (NLP). However,
while Split and Rephrase can be improved using a text-to-text generation
approach that applies encoder-decoder models fine-tuned with a large-scale
dataset, it still suffers from hallucinations and under-splitting. To address
these issues, this paper presents a simple and strong data refinement approach.
Here, we create WikiSplit++ by removing instances in WikiSplit where complex
sentences do not entail at least one of the simpler sentences and reversing the
order of reference simple sentences. Experimental results show that training
with WikiSplit++ leads to better performance than training with WikiSplit, even
with fewer training instances. In particular, our approach yields significant
gains in the number of splits and the entailment ratio, a proxy for measuring
hallucinations.
|
[
-0.6738642454147339,
-0.7626747488975525,
0.31091588735580444,
-0.01635189726948738,
-0.5869386792182922,
-0.04122939333319664,
-0.42990073561668396,
-0.6202729940414429,
0.6604764461517334,
0.4491908550262451,
-0.8913452625274658,
-0.1912899911403656,
-0.3881521224975586,
0.5795434713363647,
-0.4487380385398865,
0.8992953896522522,
-0.11034765094518661,
0.1198900118470192,
-0.17250537872314453,
-0.013704399578273296,
-0.35597193241119385,
-0.2817007601261139,
-0.5666901469230652,
-0.36261922121047974,
0.8781484365463257,
0.6881278157234192,
0.6580668091773987,
0.46853411197662354,
0.30637893080711365,
0.23238661885261536,
0.11197755485773087,
0.7000777125358582,
-0.4573550820350647,
0.5834956765174866,
-0.3284406363964081,
-0.25699934363365173,
0.04571160301566124,
-0.20551325380802155,
0.11822263151407242,
1.0122653245925903,
-0.09434010088443756,
0.031663358211517334,
0.025801531970500946,
0.8642284870147705,
-0.7045177221298218,
-0.35517117381095886,
-0.5217489004135132,
-0.03355566784739494,
-0.02744060754776001,
-0.26413682103157043,
-0.40202128887176514,
-0.31638073921203613,
0.16893982887268066,
-0.8943560123443604,
0.6437035799026489,
-0.08633174747228622,
0.8348921537399292,
0.3364923596382141,
-0.3146264851093292,
-0.2383117973804474,
-0.48370563983917236,
0.5554593801498413,
-0.5946064591407776,
0.5665323734283447,
0.20130446553230286,
0.1512257605791092,
-0.3446648120880127,
-0.9963588118553162,
-0.8986287713050842,
-0.21024362742900848,
-0.35438886284828186,
-0.12408092617988586,
0.182040274143219,
-0.13691148161888123,
0.4187501072883606,
0.22007392346858978,
-0.477547287940979,
-0.21717016398906708,
-0.6557546257972717,
-0.053534459322690964,
0.6278655529022217,
0.04081140086054802,
0.3678598999977112,
-0.4426875114440918,
-0.023162629455327988,
-0.017676154151558876,
-0.38024839758872986,
-0.41032010316848755,
0.4099273085594177,
0.42132264375686646,
0.3629302680492401,
0.9239835143089294,
-0.6261793375015259,
0.369594544172287,
0.1592746526002884,
-0.056231915950775146,
0.7145451903343201,
-0.06367864459753036,
-0.2829110026359558,
0.16113033890724182,
0.44894057512283325,
0.17653176188468933,
0.38031694293022156,
-0.5739725232124329,
0.18007434904575348,
0.17176994681358337,
0.7797595858573914,
-0.7515539526939392,
-0.31642594933509827,
0.5416795611381531,
-0.38467636704444885,
-0.39195671677589417,
0.1428549885749817,
-0.7133772969245911,
-0.5293598771095276,
-0.7498370409011841,
0.534517228603363,
-0.7005280256271362,
-0.26197507977485657,
0.43503978848457336,
-0.5008793473243713,
0.05165671929717064,
0.6333089470863342,
-0.6021973490715027,
0.4493025541305542,
0.8891701698303223,
0.6535871624946594,
-0.34208667278289795,
-0.4813515543937683,
-0.5229199528694153,
0.08381111919879913,
-0.13410481810569763,
0.810617208480835,
-0.2502632439136505,
-0.02420949377119541,
-0.1479143500328064,
0.0776144489645958,
-0.10069873183965683,
-0.43090739846229553,
0.8147274851799011,
-0.18870463967323303,
0.6334251761436462,
-0.29786500334739685,
-0.7402750849723816,
-0.28172552585601807,
0.5723891854286194,
-0.9029122591018677,
0.7016588449478149,
-0.10132694989442825,
-1.1881699562072754,
0.3924275040626526,
-0.7354353070259094,
-0.7115296125411987,
-0.0004333648248575628,
-0.16395282745361328,
-0.3521454930305481,
0.4126916527748108,
0.17192018032073975,
0.08916327357292175,
-0.015359291806817055,
0.038218189030885696,
-0.30638954043388367,
-0.5015762448310852,
0.05149540305137634,
-0.6243542432785034,
0.6164066195487976,
0.2752029597759247,
-0.3725910484790802,
-0.020609138533473015,
-1.1278479099273682,
0.24013268947601318,
-0.13659529387950897,
-0.34626930952072144,
-0.4269445240497589,
0.15977513790130615,
0.4134112596511841,
0.12229634076356888,
0.05763504281640053,
-0.7719889283180237,
0.32096078991889954,
-0.752859890460968,
0.046970050781965256,
0.3637752830982208,
0.04133760556578636,
0.28498101234436035,
-0.20385344326496124,
0.15422016382217407,
0.034257300198078156,
0.2311665415763855,
0.13247936964035034,
-0.26505404710769653,
-1.1900242567062378,
-0.31503376364707947,
0.2222720831632614,
0.38803550601005554,
-1.0024604797363281,
0.5365062355995178,
-0.3128996789455414,
-0.4086035192012787,
-0.9169976711273193,
0.14493906497955322,
-0.1507149040699005,
0.3959728181362152,
0.7116384506225586,
-0.04541689157485962,
-0.6547244191169739,
-1.012900710105896,
-0.3101228177547455,
0.3581882119178772,
-0.2896016836166382,
-0.5069007277488708,
0.5508503317832947,
-0.35109180212020874,
0.8035297989845276,
-0.6560558676719666,
-0.08973278850317001,
-0.28847992420196533,
0.06597138941287994,
-0.052308764308691025,
0.553007185459137,
-0.10498233884572983,
-1.1357200145721436,
-0.5033879280090332,
-0.02107818052172661,
-0.5760186314582825,
-0.04222702980041504,
-0.08868952840566635,
-0.2539612352848053,
-0.0884581208229065,
0.38189879059791565,
-1.2776439189910889,
0.5087540745735168,
-0.14852313697338104,
-0.5039920210838318,
0.5706632733345032,
-0.1320790946483612,
0.06957238167524338,
-1.314094066619873,
0.08694974333047867,
-0.3978472352027893,
-0.24679890275001526,
-0.7443761229515076,
0.30924656987190247,
-0.10371698439121246,
0.09318087249994278,
-0.17149938642978668,
0.051999982446432114,
-0.37198081612586975,
0.2790050208568573,
-0.39805981516838074,
0.03396553173661232,
0.2765386700630188,
0.2930171489715576,
0.19682858884334564,
0.03388452157378197,
0.25482386350631714,
-0.35402002930641174,
0.6157946586608887,
0.00712627125903964,
-0.4068364202976227,
0.42614585161209106,
-0.36679330468177795,
0.28421708941459656,
-0.31122779846191406,
0.201252743601799,
-0.8235839009284973,
-0.35582277178764343,
0.4575161933898926,
-0.34233447909355164,
0.3390868902206421,
0.21366114914417267,
-0.6927662491798401,
-0.04594338685274124,
-0.6470147371292114,
0.13965818285942078,
-0.040701404213905334,
-0.7371921539306641,
0.6997746229171753,
-0.2562229335308075,
0.1303318291902542,
-0.5945591926574707,
-0.6737030148506165,
0.16643276810646057,
-0.28410935401916504,
-0.5053126215934753,
0.4455961585044861,
-0.15793809294700623,
-0.40814125537872314,
-0.008002959191799164,
-0.23641987144947052,
-0.12175317853689194,
0.003397021209821105,
0.3788735568523407,
-0.18856889009475708,
-0.021010395139455795,
0.33898767828941345,
0.24992911517620087,
-0.2663860619068146,
-0.26450014114379883,
0.05419602617621422,
0.6390540599822998,
0.41748344898223877,
-0.21563804149627686,
-0.4308301508426666,
0.7715442180633545,
0.6335592865943909,
0.010532556101679802,
0.8201985955238342,
0.6965057849884033,
-0.6052980422973633,
-0.42893919348716736,
-0.7090228796005249,
-0.22495269775390625,
-0.49425217509269714,
0.11132020503282547,
-0.6220138669013977,
-0.643287718296051,
0.08185167610645294,
0.006010152865201235,
0.29634857177734375,
0.34395506978034973,
0.22106532752513885,
-0.30359524488449097,
0.8602498173713684,
0.541746199131012,
0.19598311185836792,
0.1834859848022461,
0.022387707605957985,
0.3126731812953949,
-0.4312554597854614,
-0.29865241050720215,
-0.5413720607757568,
-0.4952850937843323,
-0.6404696702957153,
-0.2413341999053955,
-0.35719743371009827,
0.20209531486034393,
-0.10317222028970718,
0.1597640961408615,
-0.7595750689506531,
0.608679473400116,
0.17543257772922516,
0.2467050701379776,
0.477555513381958,
0.4773169457912445,
0.18892192840576172,
-0.24957627058029175,
-0.2717532217502594,
-0.2636875510215759,
0.7647841572761536,
0.10429038852453232,
0.5115059614181519,
0.0860217809677124,
0.9170249104499817,
0.21777333319187164,
0.4303363859653473,
-0.7229904532432556,
0.35141319036483765,
-0.28976476192474365,
-0.3370249569416046,
-0.42523548007011414,
-0.5462398529052734,
-0.8193843364715576,
0.5983561873435974,
-0.2717646360397339,
-0.5004000067710876,
0.4334818720817566,
-0.3718402683734894,
0.01718437299132347,
0.03567270562052727,
-0.921055793762207,
0.5694869756698608,
0.07734609395265579,
0.07090549916028976,
-0.38473862409591675,
-0.2046733945608139,
0.12906388938426971,
-0.14874115586280823,
0.1776687502861023,
0.042456865310668945,
-0.09702172130346298,
0.6102641820907593,
-0.9962892532348633,
0.5548357367515564,
-0.20990847051143646,
0.047004714608192444,
-0.019107360392808914,
0.03946803882718086,
0.36973652243614197,
0.10002807527780533,
-0.08993145078420639,
-0.26380279660224915,
-0.053348299115896225,
-0.33417046070098877,
-0.8563104271888733,
0.8064126372337341,
-0.7401904463768005,
-0.3813895881175995,
-0.08777730911970139,
-0.37345021963119507,
-0.28298071026802063,
0.18119235336780548,
0.817027747631073,
0.18479487299919128,
0.1285027265548706,
0.39891567826271057,
0.6257253289222717,
-0.03610077127814293,
-0.030427776277065277,
0.44619321823120117,
-0.14570368826389313,
-0.7184861898422241,
0.47807037830352783,
0.4051094651222229,
-0.07482828944921494,
0.30750489234924316,
-0.015249175019562244,
-0.03777053952217102,
-0.3441162407398224,
-0.12840838730335236,
0.305513858795166,
-0.5991368889808655,
-0.13516636192798615,
-0.6163833737373352,
-0.07510466873645782,
-0.48636558651924133,
-0.08828633278608322,
-0.40971681475639343,
-0.8165404200553894,
-0.2637057304382324,
-0.5120131969451904,
0.6089934706687927,
0.4112148582935333,
0.07149304449558258,
0.04979056492447853,
-0.24426241219043732,
0.9184407591819763,
0.18052086234092712,
0.31862378120422363,
-0.03975308686494827,
-0.3769177496433258,
-0.2868554890155792,
-0.028981955721974373,
-0.03223147615790367,
-0.9347208142280579,
0.1962275207042694,
0.08986462652683258,
0.1911461502313614,
0.11443790793418884,
0.32609325647354126,
1.1531152725219727,
-0.6447734832763672,
0.5679024457931519,
0.31056877970695496,
-0.6657434701919556,
0.47603604197502136,
0.12605616450309753,
0.281838983297348,
1.0958137512207031,
0.33752602338790894,
-0.5764623284339905,
-0.5297596454620361,
-0.5322293043136597,
-1.1062268018722534,
0.33593451976776123,
0.3715144693851471,
0.24732595682144165,
-0.07270553708076477,
0.7730010151863098,
0.519349992275238,
0.10799150913953781,
-0.6514296531677246,
-0.21988029778003693,
-0.3086029887199402,
-0.43738996982574463,
-0.031610243022441864,
-0.16663378477096558,
-0.04758507385849953,
-0.5813390016555786,
0.6357818245887756,
0.1453021764755249,
-0.09800727665424347,
0.47519707679748535,
-0.23243772983551025,
-0.20147104561328888,
0.2664071023464203,
0.061047058552503586,
0.5507644414901733,
-0.14713884890079498,
0.23835524916648865,
0.22970671951770782,
-0.7446715831756592,
0.1062585785984993,
0.21047185361385345,
-0.2548309862613678,
0.48290908336639404,
0.5277929902076721,
0.3814188539981842,
-0.01626070961356163,
-0.4911041557788849,
0.2853842079639435,
-0.24146685004234314,
-0.37194687128067017,
-0.2692515254020691,
0.23825721442699432,
0.10851302742958069,
0.2679459750652313,
0.5354799032211304,
-0.05692794546484947,
0.4012553095817566,
-0.36389094591140747,
0.4624951481819153,
-0.0861450657248497,
-0.07070034742355347,
0.00415077805519104,
0.20772315561771393,
0.09318014234304428,
-0.4567573070526123,
0.8435582518577576,
0.02327657677233219,
-0.2704664468765259,
0.25395914912223816,
0.27068817615509033,
1.0812290906906128,
0.026169663295149803,
0.19350163638591766,
0.30179375410079956,
0.4152218699455261,
-0.2337813675403595,
0.43702954053878784,
-0.3450618088245392,
-0.868236243724823,
-0.5594605803489685,
-0.46708494424819946,
-0.230356827378273,
0.4268052577972412,
-0.9728203415870667,
0.333484023809433,
-0.34814026951789856,
-0.17290769517421722,
0.3030087351799011,
0.4273811876773834,
-0.6245573163032532,
0.4397178888320923,
0.14026333391666412,
1.1540778875350952,
-0.5879716873168945,
1.0551615953445435,
0.42607465386390686,
-0.38698697090148926,
-0.5866118669509888,
0.28369227051734924,
-0.44188082218170166,
0.2504585385322571,
0.3511079251766205,
0.6457014083862305,
-0.018400199711322784,
-0.26405593752861023,
-0.6571936011314392,
-0.5246497988700867,
0.7557634115219116,
0.48037412762641907,
-0.7298829555511475,
-0.21385355293750763,
0.22923006117343903,
0.7929943203926086,
-0.1181657686829567,
-0.10866866260766983,
0.5851853489875793,
0.5050991773605347,
-0.21381057798862457,
-0.6268090605735779,
0.06715040653944016,
-0.5508904457092285,
-0.2524247467517853,
0.17891506850719452,
-0.21377472579479218,
0.6824772357940674,
0.10878739506006241,
-0.32549431920051575,
0.016597582027316093,
0.6556797027587891,
0.1691773235797882,
0.32340407371520996,
0.7479501366615295,
0.6968697905540466,
0.8064921498298645,
-0.00360634783282876,
0.6468061804771423,
0.12807375192642212,
0.2407228797674179,
1.4219043254852295,
-0.22047176957130432,
1.1064684391021729,
0.9189425706863403,
0.11360041797161102,
0.7756977677345276,
0.3840042054653168,
-0.05045327916741371,
0.5957476496696472,
0.15097740292549133,
-0.17165309190750122,
-0.27517053484916687,
0.24419747292995453,
-0.3527463674545288,
0.17214252054691315,
0.26816725730895996,
-0.2846115231513977,
-0.29796963930130005,
0.3229357600212097,
0.14547099173069,
0.09435863047838211,
0.03372249752283096,
0.7773052453994751,
0.011827782727777958,
-0.6366069912910461,
0.38691437244415283,
0.06474905461072922,
0.795806348323822,
-0.6379818916320801,
-0.05344424024224281,
-0.2621200382709503,
0.3017454147338867,
-0.7430297136306763,
-0.5892578363418579,
0.4919031858444214,
0.34113791584968567,
-0.3139725625514984,
-0.028503265231847763,
0.8470994234085083,
-0.4920428395271301,
-0.5562288761138916,
0.42367300391197205,
0.21787437796592712,
0.05491412431001663,
-0.2521909773349762,
-0.5527246594429016,
-0.03961382806301117,
0.28707370162010193,
-0.6843886375427246,
0.1587243676185608,
0.6566791534423828,
0.16216561198234558,
0.5265989303588867,
0.7755444049835205,
0.06448273360729218,
-0.06608752906322479,
0.46547120809555054,
0.9019356369972229,
-0.6832054853439331,
-0.39649391174316406,
-0.7731642723083496,
0.6871596574783325,
-0.49279311299324036,
-0.13410775363445282,
0.8411706686019897,
0.8098641633987427,
0.8062377572059631,
0.033795565366744995,
0.6187015771865845,
-0.01299811527132988,
0.6570746302604675,
-0.219827800989151,
0.8109456300735474,
-0.4921114146709442,
0.16542768478393555,
-0.14410337805747986,
-0.8684170246124268,
-0.35670262575149536,
0.8024364709854126,
-0.14823873341083527,
-0.47400879859924316,
0.4915415942668915,
0.5928704738616943,
-0.0021005086600780487,
0.21474753320217133,
0.016822580248117447,
0.09895296394824982,
0.32740089297294617,
0.1819494068622589,
0.8023671507835388,
-0.5290312767028809,
0.5104339718818665,
-0.6358423233032227,
0.16069087386131287,
0.10211925953626633,
-0.4312859773635864,
-0.6301995515823364,
-0.38712114095687866,
-0.5053614377975464,
-0.41529780626296997,
-0.05090882256627083,
1.0918595790863037,
0.4203258752822876,
-0.7465254664421082,
-0.030205389484763145,
-0.17514757812023163,
0.086117222905159,
-0.36525917053222656,
-0.2813614308834076,
0.48558107018470764,
-0.4462275207042694,
-0.4175916314125061,
0.4851689636707306,
0.08817966282367706,
-0.3448096811771393,
-0.25698336958885193,
-0.06489229202270508,
-0.12281526625156403,
0.2499094307422638,
0.7504099011421204,
-0.11879568547010422,
-0.4670148491859436,
-0.2281128317117691,
-0.3282064199447632,
-0.0770404189825058,
0.05813373625278473,
0.755166232585907,
-0.854928731918335,
0.6473435163497925,
0.7713965177536011,
0.3443804681301117,
0.7775638103485107,
0.028849780559539795,
0.5198327302932739,
-0.7905648946762085,
0.1497279703617096,
0.04280412569642067,
0.216591015458107,
0.4027356803417206,
-0.43703755736351013,
0.6140636205673218,
0.18041934072971344,
0.005835943855345249,
-1.0959657430648804,
0.039636023342609406,
-0.8760022521018982,
-0.7892233729362488,
0.8781664967536926,
0.2034817636013031,
-0.04655401408672333,
-0.3826836049556732,
-0.4201015830039978,
0.42942699790000916,
-0.02430053800344467,
1.0296753644943237,
0.7112300395965576,
-0.024725401774048805,
-0.13947924971580505,
-0.39395400881767273,
0.6972652077674866,
0.1760299801826477,
-0.9688907265663147,
0.22066980600357056,
0.5477825403213501,
0.6071524620056152,
0.47901028394699097,
0.3059203028678894,
0.09195086359977722,
0.3673897981643677,
0.12801550328731537,
0.023760799318552017,
-0.12778429687023163,
-0.26648983359336853,
-0.1865154355764389,
0.6168888807296753,
-0.23584799468517303,
-0.18173344433307648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08997v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08997v1
|
Labeled Morphological Segmentation with Semi-Markov Models
| 2024-04-13T12:51:53 | 2024-04-13T12:51:53 |
Ryan Cotterell, Thomas Müller, Alexander Fraser, Hinrich Schütze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present labeled morphological segmentation, an alternative view of
morphological processing that unifies several tasks. From an annotation
standpoint, we additionally introduce a new hierarchy of morphotactic tagsets.
Finally, we develop \modelname, a discriminative morphological segmentation
system that, contrary to previous work, explicitly models morphotactics. We
show that \textsc{chipmunk} yields improved performance on three tasks for all
six languages: (i) morphological segmentation, (ii) stemming and (iii)
morphological tag classification. On morphological segmentation, our method
shows absolute improvements of 2--6 points $F_1$ over the baseline.
|
[
-0.19820727407932281,
-0.6712698340415955,
0.27854064106941223,
0.18379798531532288,
-0.671212375164032,
0.19382883608341217,
-0.013854737393558025,
-0.8050312995910645,
0.2700083255767822,
0.29695630073547363,
-0.5842599272727966,
-0.7317935824394226,
-0.32376721501350403,
0.18150366842746735,
-0.2515743374824524,
0.7567732930183411,
0.3616972863674164,
0.31178075075149536,
0.11426501721143723,
0.23695042729377747,
-0.34462493658065796,
-0.312998503446579,
-0.6771302819252014,
-0.5666455030441284,
0.6146363615989685,
0.08923707157373428,
0.8034583330154419,
1.3824549913406372,
0.44331732392311096,
0.3029410243034363,
-0.2694900333881378,
0.12382626533508301,
0.26257747411727905,
0.3751106560230255,
-0.09219483286142349,
-0.7759364247322083,
-0.25722143054008484,
-0.05638071149587631,
0.5993285775184631,
0.8068715929985046,
-0.04639280214905739,
-0.10347280651330948,
-0.40479880571365356,
0.2925139367580414,
-0.35604485869407654,
0.21754638850688934,
-0.6932721138000488,
0.16373905539512634,
-0.5430771708488464,
-0.3740116059780121,
-0.5588862299919128,
0.027005529031157494,
-0.017366275191307068,
-0.4363313615322113,
-0.015731539577245712,
-0.3053681552410126,
0.7669685482978821,
0.21222785115242004,
-0.07687912881374359,
0.06266865134239197,
-0.6358019113540649,
0.7599477171897888,
-0.339872270822525,
0.21750982105731964,
0.4302852153778076,
0.09695141017436981,
-0.03719988837838173,
-0.6001988649368286,
0.1394086629152298,
-0.25001654028892517,
0.3896338641643524,
0.17588725686073303,
-0.24288426339626312,
0.1860482096672058,
0.29232892394065857,
0.21609368920326233,
-0.24357172846794128,
0.537828266620636,
-0.27415430545806885,
-0.4248856008052826,
0.682819664478302,
0.1385263204574585,
0.7595953941345215,
-0.2582015097141266,
-0.3630087971687317,
0.03036784753203392,
-0.4854457378387451,
-0.12177310138940811,
0.3965253233909607,
0.1978643387556076,
0.12634995579719543,
0.8196597695350647,
-0.05085880309343338,
0.9702852368354797,
-0.16286037862300873,
-0.3661681115627289,
0.3074590563774109,
-0.0007978301146067679,
-0.09914349019527435,
0.056730709969997406,
0.4718679189682007,
0.23831063508987427,
0.18553227186203003,
-0.1356412172317505,
-0.27822718024253845,
0.2824483811855316,
0.22360122203826904,
-0.4040336012840271,
-0.7918883562088013,
-0.007014905102550983,
-0.5426227450370789,
-0.16617634892463684,
-0.18937265872955322,
-0.5576387643814087,
-0.3592688739299774,
-0.19437913596630096,
0.15870682895183563,
-0.8552062511444092,
-0.23422347009181976,
0.05048937350511551,
-0.2913394868373871,
0.337179571390152,
0.6157408952713013,
-0.896379292011261,
0.20691747963428497,
0.7000046968460083,
1.3129384517669678,
-0.3401123881340027,
-0.03972967341542244,
-0.1520075500011444,
0.03134520351886749,
-0.6260707378387451,
1.3565467596054077,
-1.1950970888137817,
-0.48604899644851685,
-0.20645692944526672,
-0.007396025117486715,
0.016099823638796806,
-0.7464345097541809,
0.2685677409172058,
-0.16093572974205017,
-0.36770233511924744,
0.10780077427625656,
-0.5416698455810547,
-0.29620662331581116,
0.1451820433139801,
-0.6099594235420227,
1.1576921939849854,
-0.12946012616157532,
-0.7949052453041077,
0.2518407106399536,
-0.6767024993896484,
-0.5482584834098816,
0.46617236733436584,
-0.18026167154312134,
-0.10556361824274063,
0.21218518912792206,
-0.08804868906736374,
0.6394460797309875,
0.020395861938595772,
0.11458827555179596,
-0.30522483587265015,
0.11547475308179855,
0.3468881845474243,
0.005615995265543461,
0.9315096139907837,
0.3470326066017151,
-0.20441758632659912,
0.43957558274269104,
-1.0899677276611328,
0.019574642181396484,
0.00008661868196213618,
-0.5197792649269104,
-0.7451500296592712,
0.19628165662288666,
0.007524991407990456,
0.3007368743419647,
0.12171795219182968,
-0.7444049715995789,
0.4146786034107208,
-0.5549026131629944,
0.3759249746799469,
0.5021087527275085,
-0.02010856568813324,
0.40525123476982117,
-0.27514681220054626,
0.4672982096672058,
0.2201487123966217,
-0.02045571245253086,
-0.33778122067451477,
-1.0484867095947266,
-0.740217387676239,
-0.7606189846992493,
0.6034342646598816,
0.37935954332351685,
-1.0010143518447876,
0.36335211992263794,
-0.0314660370349884,
-0.6985734701156616,
-0.33884087204933167,
-0.48140615224838257,
0.4479832947254181,
0.16790306568145752,
0.17900224030017853,
-0.5859211087226868,
-0.6440854072570801,
-1.2675645351409912,
0.02011078968644142,
-0.27406421303749084,
-0.07326700538396835,
-0.3257143199443817,
0.597383975982666,
-0.028960999101400375,
0.6908150315284729,
-0.4710642099380493,
-0.06145360693335533,
-0.12112651020288467,
0.5836547017097473,
-0.03463874012231827,
0.7435880303382874,
0.1257263571023941,
-0.7703407406806946,
-0.31692373752593994,
0.27438077330589294,
-0.04754337668418884,
-0.2742424011230469,
0.08302832394838333,
0.0641203373670578,
0.2650356888771057,
0.24319139122962952,
-0.5670803189277649,
0.3663853704929352,
0.19036471843719482,
0.05690348148345947,
0.41275501251220703,
-0.432087242603302,
-0.1517869532108307,
-1.0157957077026367,
-0.06599445641040802,
0.11957184970378876,
-0.30384668707847595,
-0.9547651410102844,
-0.006483814213424921,
0.07994557917118073,
0.16732238233089447,
-0.563090980052948,
0.42686089873313904,
-0.6510071754455566,
-0.37260785698890686,
-0.3555660843849182,
-0.2117767035961151,
-0.6084895133972168,
0.3459954857826233,
0.5890882611274719,
0.31375351548194885,
0.9235774874687195,
-0.5735440254211426,
0.25949451327323914,
0.09685239940881729,
-0.34412115812301636,
0.3780805468559265,
-0.289491206407547,
-0.007151876576244831,
-0.05156639590859413,
0.1494336575269699,
-1.177014946937561,
-0.2532385289669037,
0.46682488918304443,
-0.6071957349777222,
0.11074385792016983,
-0.4196230471134186,
-0.8211995959281921,
-0.05134648084640503,
-0.363238126039505,
0.27217337489128113,
0.498959481716156,
-0.38111504912376404,
0.3082396388053894,
0.8497443795204163,
0.10880954563617706,
-0.13666002452373505,
-0.723375141620636,
-0.04352918267250061,
-0.24449270963668823,
-0.3535330295562744,
0.47041913866996765,
0.07078373432159424,
-0.2412535548210144,
-0.11923280358314514,
-0.17400212585926056,
-0.49394166469573975,
0.2808752954006195,
0.3172256648540497,
0.28715234994888306,
-0.06520358473062515,
0.32998016476631165,
-0.09911373257637024,
-0.3074886202812195,
-0.17444850504398346,
-0.5332635641098022,
0.6979082822799683,
0.41470804810523987,
-0.13989992439746857,
-0.35690727829933167,
0.25347089767456055,
0.033691082149744034,
-0.7836310863494873,
0.26931849122047424,
0.5473539233207703,
-0.8254362940788269,
-0.13602608442306519,
-0.19589665532112122,
0.21286582946777344,
-0.33870798349380493,
0.40668803453445435,
-0.6337834596633911,
-0.7291023135185242,
0.5751893520355225,
-0.18281257152557373,
0.10130679607391357,
0.7808644771575928,
0.8452101349830627,
-0.12569767236709595,
1.4240977764129639,
0.531773030757904,
0.4955577254295349,
0.497611939907074,
-0.12534065544605255,
-0.03317637741565704,
-0.6512362957000732,
-0.6134388446807861,
-0.8370999693870544,
-0.2567276060581207,
-0.8147630095481873,
-0.7062674760818481,
-0.026906434446573257,
-0.11476034671068192,
0.39466169476509094,
0.2783811390399933,
-0.810543417930603,
0.4838073253631592,
0.4452972412109375,
0.0702441930770874,
0.11091826856136322,
0.04072979465126991,
-0.4334341287612915,
0.07965818792581558,
-0.5457606315612793,
-0.7152542471885681,
0.5755603909492493,
0.4990262985229492,
0.938215970993042,
-0.029418138787150383,
0.7697629928588867,
0.2588389813899994,
0.13078300654888153,
-1.101850152015686,
0.6817121505737305,
-0.29441460967063904,
-1.0080957412719727,
-0.22316555678844452,
-0.21846921741962433,
-1.1739332675933838,
0.6076557636260986,
-0.08936154842376709,
-1.317793369293213,
0.23824232816696167,
0.09935594350099564,
-0.4376024901866913,
0.3816818594932556,
-0.7441072463989258,
0.7528167366981506,
-0.10585647821426392,
0.17575010657310486,
-0.17030203342437744,
-0.6658743023872375,
0.2801953852176666,
-0.044239591807127,
0.09323257952928543,
-0.7503641843795776,
-0.6518489718437195,
1.2014644145965576,
-0.109951913356781,
0.9230170845985413,
-0.1370985060930252,
0.0003685190458782017,
0.06855469942092896,
0.26182419061660767,
-0.052110351622104645,
-0.1262248158454895,
0.2699441611766815,
0.1975666880607605,
0.49870991706848145,
-0.2102779597043991,
-0.219365194439888,
0.4581224024295807,
-0.3393886387348175,
-0.35758835077285767,
-0.623042643070221,
-0.5800485014915466,
-0.04524099826812744,
0.3635386526584625,
0.18156608939170837,
0.5002874135971069,
-0.0013744417810812593,
-0.04291023686528206,
0.6968124508857727,
-0.09507054835557938,
0.5455366373062134,
0.3265254497528076,
-0.2980577349662781,
-0.032746572047472,
0.6320509910583496,
0.21328280866146088,
0.09100629389286041,
0.7210317850112915,
0.2134964019060135,
-0.33687055110931396,
-0.862271785736084,
-0.12195341289043427,
0.3321782946586609,
-0.7778830528259277,
-0.20324625074863434,
-0.8500385284423828,
-0.1198798343539238,
-0.08851165324449539,
0.3203810751438141,
-0.4848874807357788,
-0.7086228132247925,
-0.25162196159362793,
0.15080608427524567,
0.10277219116687775,
0.9421951174736023,
-0.24908414483070374,
0.40706413984298706,
-0.7811169624328613,
0.33398211002349854,
-0.12348932772874832,
0.31393134593963623,
-0.3000378906726837,
-0.4338296055793762,
-0.2651546001434326,
-0.0580483041703701,
-0.24936074018478394,
-1.216925859451294,
0.3409450352191925,
0.07621275633573532,
0.5608602166175842,
0.3552722930908203,
-0.26765328645706177,
0.7999541163444519,
-0.7965475916862488,
0.5425045490264893,
0.2558716833591461,
-0.7683374285697937,
0.5605998635292053,
-0.22641170024871826,
0.6786253452301025,
0.021477773785591125,
0.4827476739883423,
-0.4751574397087097,
-0.5112250447273254,
-0.6972402334213257,
-0.5853959918022156,
0.9727441668510437,
0.20843736827373505,
0.04776899516582489,
-0.48198357224464417,
0.14466328918933868,
0.4280722141265869,
-0.32659998536109924,
-0.4605957269668579,
-0.2989974915981293,
0.2335769534111023,
-0.06367744505405426,
-0.12898342311382294,
-0.5093120336532593,
0.06960658729076385,
-0.5268858075141907,
0.7755920886993408,
0.008897923864424229,
0.368711918592453,
0.04725031554698944,
-0.3014959990978241,
0.025464670732617378,
0.19531241059303284,
0.7777319550514221,
0.8333477973937988,
-0.07906173914670944,
0.6005110144615173,
-0.1439913511276245,
-0.349252313375473,
0.2323000580072403,
0.06287606060504913,
-0.019567646086215973,
0.43913042545318604,
0.5028873682022095,
0.4586290121078491,
0.3025451898574829,
-0.3583567142486572,
-0.009513122029602528,
0.044702380895614624,
-0.1533106565475464,
-0.031201137229800224,
0.07946187257766724,
0.29815271496772766,
0.2776477038860321,
0.05222129821777344,
0.1882498562335968,
0.3737803101539612,
-0.4566296637058258,
0.37249061465263367,
0.44371503591537476,
-0.31928327679634094,
-0.5764725208282471,
0.23144274950027466,
0.15133972465991974,
-0.5877102017402649,
0.19961197674274445,
0.016188429668545723,
-0.5459328293800354,
0.5311048626899719,
0.604716956615448,
0.7439225912094116,
-0.7653903365135193,
0.4640176594257355,
0.377177357673645,
0.3097749650478363,
-0.14965446293354034,
0.21900518238544464,
-0.28190702199935913,
-0.6072524785995483,
-0.34423828125,
-0.6430441737174988,
-0.17072857916355133,
-0.03278527408838272,
-0.49912652373313904,
0.19163838028907776,
-0.42416808009147644,
-0.35318148136138916,
0.9425548911094666,
-0.19125886261463165,
-0.24885262548923492,
0.43250173330307007,
0.3810417950153351,
0.9912421703338623,
-0.7086617946624756,
1.218753457069397,
1.2875282764434814,
-0.1456695944070816,
-0.4253421723842621,
-0.2868656516075134,
0.016080256551504135,
-0.9784771800041199,
0.6593998670578003,
0.39884480834007263,
-0.01496020145714283,
0.07708495110273361,
-0.35185301303863525,
-0.803261935710907,
0.5229141116142273,
0.28648290038108826,
-0.3266112506389618,
0.10542050004005432,
-0.04494643956422806,
0.6852030754089355,
-0.4871556758880615,
0.24757960438728333,
0.6008038520812988,
0.3966483473777771,
0.2738797664642334,
-0.7963260412216187,
-0.31711825728416443,
-0.3080616891384125,
0.42412179708480835,
0.5742790699005127,
-0.028391076251864433,
0.685175359249115,
0.014695034362375736,
-0.5785918235778809,
0.21986722946166992,
0.4394034743309021,
-0.170493483543396,
-0.24738851189613342,
0.5798956155776978,
0.3659704923629761,
0.6710955500602722,
-0.2746625542640686,
0.9217036366462708,
0.04173124581575394,
0.3801850378513336,
0.9300065040588379,
0.2856251895427704,
0.7080697417259216,
0.5357632637023926,
-0.14288106560707092,
0.007345404475927353,
1.4183887243270874,
-0.12242399901151657,
0.45622530579566956,
0.3396884500980377,
0.023864513263106346,
-0.7975775599479675,
-0.37506747245788574,
-0.08814384043216705,
0.7499260306358337,
0.1548970639705658,
-0.2154586762189865,
-0.4151763319969177,
-0.01884409226477146,
0.051705941557884216,
-0.09544263780117035,
-0.395280122756958,
0.7635580897331238,
-0.006581929977983236,
-0.5465127825737,
0.5017402172088623,
0.4898003935813904,
0.5642436742782593,
-0.5275864601135254,
-0.33719828724861145,
0.0366009920835495,
-0.06061868742108345,
-0.33105069398880005,
-0.9524596333503723,
0.4320526719093323,
-0.015768317505717278,
0.07657194882631302,
-0.05188360810279846,
0.8716832995414734,
-0.46226876974105835,
-0.45919615030288696,
0.2046230584383011,
0.26581957936286926,
0.6444814205169678,
0.13418185710906982,
-0.8325904011726379,
0.16462187469005585,
0.062059421092271805,
0.11816006153821945,
0.03666853532195091,
0.16545122861862183,
-0.3063054084777832,
0.9262482523918152,
0.32145175337791443,
0.054471831768751144,
0.5303080677986145,
-0.012780874036252499,
0.5517306923866272,
-0.5711522102355957,
-0.6284642219543457,
-0.9921202659606934,
0.5643589496612549,
-0.0030416070949286222,
-0.09546305239200592,
0.5086300373077393,
0.6193295121192932,
1.0659083127975464,
-0.3465457558631897,
0.3636886179447174,
-0.1750308871269226,
0.38796064257621765,
-0.6171486377716064,
0.23830880224704742,
-0.579831063747406,
0.03204820305109024,
-0.09211677312850952,
-1.0492727756500244,
-0.8888799548149109,
0.6527302861213684,
-0.3566261827945709,
0.0820259228348732,
0.9451401233673096,
0.5278379321098328,
-0.0169359277933836,
-0.18304477632045746,
0.7915648221969604,
-0.04819268360733986,
0.0678272694349289,
0.23263750970363617,
1.384547233581543,
0.30098333954811096,
0.11430522054433823,
-0.663382351398468,
-0.2786521911621094,
0.08149733394384384,
-0.42747440934181213,
-1.1218209266662598,
-0.984708309173584,
-0.5671709179878235,
0.23069891333580017,
-0.006789880339056253,
0.8519638180732727,
0.788750171661377,
-0.6696377396583557,
-0.3129740357398987,
0.42717868089675903,
-0.0019326141336932778,
-0.05360301584005356,
-0.1192285493016243,
0.17082852125167847,
-0.5359771251678467,
-0.7535116672515869,
0.1324646919965744,
0.9167419075965881,
0.017628565430641174,
0.07449046522378922,
0.22315561771392822,
-0.7375012636184692,
0.021180255338549614,
0.31303727626800537,
0.06327322125434875,
-0.998820960521698,
-0.31189990043640137,
-0.38338878750801086,
0.045727651566267014,
0.6427719593048096,
0.8948468565940857,
-0.2138289362192154,
0.6613253951072693,
0.3134026527404785,
0.5552006363868713,
0.3700559139251709,
-0.027804333716630936,
0.05824432894587517,
-0.4972763657569885,
0.08651507645845413,
0.23117630183696747,
0.3761237859725952,
0.3793996274471283,
-0.046135738492012024,
0.4078217148780823,
0.2591449022293091,
-0.0025813609827309847,
-0.6572732329368591,
0.4555455148220062,
-0.943651020526886,
-0.4282093942165375,
1.003787875175476,
-0.26882386207580566,
-0.532577395439148,
-0.24041688442230225,
-0.30143851041793823,
0.564898669719696,
-0.1882123500108719,
0.45941251516342163,
0.6929014325141907,
-0.3300468325614929,
-0.3636208772659302,
-0.2795616090297699,
0.42266690731048584,
0.2886974811553955,
-1.0492374897003174,
-0.1831463724374771,
0.5203747749328613,
0.3221278488636017,
0.3691563308238983,
0.6790586709976196,
-0.41659700870513916,
0.25478270649909973,
-0.15732210874557495,
0.29915153980255127,
0.14320488274097443,
-0.5208152532577515,
-0.641737163066864,
-0.08846700936555862,
0.47406286001205444,
-0.6943974494934082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08977v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08977v2
|
RoNID: New Intent Discovery with Generated-Reliable Labels and Cluster-friendly Representations
| 2024-04-13T11:58:28 | 2024-04-18T06:54:55 |
Shun Zhang, Chaoran Yan, Jian Yang, Changyu Ren, Jiaqi Bai, Tongliang Li, Zhoujun Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
New Intent Discovery (NID) strives to identify known and reasonably deduce
novel intent groups in the open-world scenario. But current methods face issues
with inaccurate pseudo-labels and poor representation learning, creating a
negative feedback loop that degrades overall model performance, including
accuracy and the adjusted rand index. To address the aforementioned challenges,
we propose a Robust New Intent Discovery (RoNID) framework optimized by an
EM-style method, which focuses on constructing reliable pseudo-labels and
obtaining cluster-friendly discriminative representations. RoNID comprises two
main modules: reliable pseudo-label generation module and cluster-friendly
representation learning module. Specifically, the pseudo-label generation
module assigns reliable synthetic labels by solving an optimal transport
problem in the E-step, which effectively provides high-quality supervised
signals for the input of the cluster-friendly representation learning module.
To learn cluster-friendly representation with strong intra-cluster compactness
and large inter-cluster separation, the representation learning module combines
intra-cluster and inter-cluster contrastive learning in the M-step to feed more
discriminative features into the generation module. RoNID can be performed
iteratively to ultimately yield a robust model with reliable pseudo-labels and
cluster-friendly representations. Experimental results on multiple benchmarks
demonstrate our method brings substantial improvements over previous
state-of-the-art methods by a large margin of +1~+4 points.
|
[
-0.5552937388420105,
-0.7833050489425659,
0.7821482419967651,
-0.11940111219882965,
-0.35711395740509033,
-0.28046852350234985,
-0.2683006823062897,
-0.24131156504154205,
0.3722039461135864,
0.08097966760396957,
-0.516617476940155,
-1.0494388341903687,
-0.4256579875946045,
-0.01707395166158676,
-0.1752900928258896,
0.8695951104164124,
-0.0260115098208189,
-0.16930878162384033,
-0.20896917581558228,
-0.17571626603603363,
-0.41132235527038574,
-0.21358440816402435,
-0.7478603720664978,
-0.1498071402311325,
0.820706844329834,
0.5924562215805054,
0.09620703011751175,
0.5416254997253418,
0.27747175097465515,
0.19109036028385162,
-0.1337171494960785,
0.38687798380851746,
-0.6028473377227783,
0.10020712018013,
-0.17542359232902527,
-0.20188358426094055,
-0.6729757189750671,
0.0012320100795477629,
0.5445488691329956,
0.6197196245193481,
-0.22533968091011047,
0.1655268520116806,
-0.0609549842774868,
0.5021704435348511,
-0.6613807678222656,
0.08420024812221527,
-0.7071950435638428,
-0.2472243756055832,
-0.334059476852417,
-0.1289120316505432,
-0.8140847086906433,
-0.3068818151950836,
0.24696582555770874,
-0.9745796322822571,
0.14992152154445648,
0.312759131193161,
0.7433100938796997,
0.05238455906510353,
-0.36441031098365784,
-0.23993642628192902,
-0.776721179485321,
1.0555405616760254,
-0.49305060505867004,
0.35119500756263733,
0.42589429020881653,
0.5204101204872131,
-0.161807581782341,
-0.5162423253059387,
-0.37944483757019043,
-0.14422178268432617,
-0.06082264333963394,
-0.07864096015691757,
0.14783510565757751,
-0.007196284364908934,
-0.04332902655005455,
0.01488548144698143,
-0.6288365125656128,
-0.19626781344413757,
0.07062379270792007,
-0.11523514986038208,
0.7126768827438354,
0.07198522239923477,
0.1420218050479889,
0.18894244730472565,
-0.6261707544326782,
-0.20679204165935516,
-0.9473179578781128,
0.08000391721725464,
0.26963162422180176,
0.44210222363471985,
-0.03467753529548645,
0.5750421285629272,
-0.0958259105682373,
0.6094872951507568,
0.4973393976688385,
-0.028012020513415337,
0.3334800899028778,
-0.4073444902896881,
0.14339475333690643,
0.478080689907074,
0.4776443839073181,
0.3295017182826996,
-0.22816641628742218,
-0.32901206612586975,
-0.35208335518836975,
-0.0031466265209019184,
0.3323725163936615,
-0.8553324341773987,
-0.20655113458633423,
0.3097440302371979,
-0.8878446221351624,
-0.14213460683822632,
0.25540485978126526,
-0.4707240164279938,
-0.13309194147586823,
-0.34191304445266724,
0.8346545100212097,
-0.5538961887359619,
-0.4680127799510956,
0.08229093998670578,
-0.13282421231269836,
0.24562416970729828,
0.5073637366294861,
-0.6719096302986145,
0.0007983266841620207,
0.5998896360397339,
0.7863325476646423,
-0.3834799826145172,
-0.002408826956525445,
-0.5377750396728516,
0.5629832744598389,
-0.5373386740684509,
0.9679329991340637,
-0.5999957919120789,
-0.5231207013130188,
-0.21243777871131897,
-0.03662603348493576,
-0.07827694714069366,
-0.49700459837913513,
0.5091763734817505,
-0.4305812418460846,
0.03547201678156853,
-0.45161306858062744,
-0.580958902835846,
-0.3614829182624817,
0.5886701941490173,
-0.6550948023796082,
0.7697722911834717,
0.19671805202960968,
-0.6812622547149658,
0.5700172185897827,
-0.9575835466384888,
-0.4621557593345642,
-0.062384746968746185,
-0.2502877116203308,
-0.611514151096344,
0.13282763957977295,
-0.09952756762504578,
0.5076948404312134,
-0.011366423219442368,
0.35251501202583313,
-0.49222224950790405,
-0.579039990901947,
0.24013011157512665,
-0.30876997113227844,
0.5440893769264221,
0.0407630018889904,
-0.28962090611457825,
0.46706530451774597,
-0.9863789677619934,
-0.13997256755828857,
0.03886882960796356,
-0.1749856173992157,
-0.5709669589996338,
0.0044576916843652725,
-0.16093388199806213,
0.0010138119105249643,
0.3836267590522766,
-0.9296247959136963,
0.03642004355788231,
-0.049719229340553284,
-0.1579902470111847,
1.0115187168121338,
0.2085951417684555,
0.7084198594093323,
-0.343693345785141,
0.2369457632303238,
0.054351892322301865,
0.4928068220615387,
-0.06400322914123535,
-0.6597356200218201,
-0.3712522089481354,
-0.2194543182849884,
0.25678810477256775,
0.2582498788833618,
-0.7630814909934998,
0.4627402722835541,
-0.3288702070713043,
-0.48106592893600464,
-0.04902760684490204,
-0.04935968294739723,
0.34539633989334106,
0.28262245655059814,
0.5091033577919006,
-0.17771705985069275,
-0.2836984395980835,
-0.6105758547782898,
-0.005416093859821558,
-0.11360890418291092,
0.21503819525241852,
0.536408543586731,
0.26728004217147827,
-0.5550864338874817,
1.017657995223999,
-0.23747797310352325,
-0.48930731415748596,
-0.3912704586982727,
0.24168714880943298,
0.344266414642334,
0.3766738474369049,
0.5236656665802002,
-0.9143397808074951,
-0.6692187786102295,
0.3198680281639099,
-0.38677874207496643,
-0.069313183426857,
-0.04038504883646965,
-0.4527547061443329,
0.003279551863670349,
0.5092610120773315,
-0.35528919100761414,
0.5384382605552673,
0.2583550214767456,
-0.45462843775749207,
0.38820433616638184,
-0.03125447407364845,
0.12334025651216507,
-1.0445877313613892,
0.10803230106830597,
0.08956339210271835,
0.08857075870037079,
-0.5160641074180603,
-0.6598509550094604,
0.04402856528759003,
0.24557684361934662,
-0.5829485058784485,
0.6009204387664795,
-0.3835517168045044,
0.20461678504943848,
-0.35177934169769287,
-0.15409834682941437,
-0.0955154299736023,
0.309209942817688,
0.1777496635913849,
0.5463261008262634,
0.5812772512435913,
-0.9879574179649353,
-0.18753749132156372,
0.20857219398021698,
-0.17050860822200775,
0.733272910118103,
-0.4171668291091919,
0.032866667956113815,
-0.3679114580154419,
0.16478748619556427,
-1.2519534826278687,
-0.3166937828063965,
0.4048672318458557,
-0.5135075449943542,
0.6696480512619019,
-0.4183906018733978,
-0.24953854084014893,
0.10747292637825012,
-0.4163289964199066,
0.8048837184906006,
0.3437957465648651,
-1.0095903873443604,
0.9492546319961548,
0.39026039838790894,
0.14768129587173462,
-0.41521045565605164,
-0.3724426329135895,
-0.3881917893886566,
-0.36749595403671265,
-0.6199964880943298,
0.7520803809165955,
0.0457146093249321,
0.046250611543655396,
0.16172778606414795,
-0.0963386744260788,
0.04593583568930626,
-0.0386878065764904,
0.3316316306591034,
0.18703538179397583,
-0.0729731097817421,
0.05443326756358147,
0.19603392481803894,
-0.49566271901130676,
0.06231231987476349,
-0.1346566379070282,
0.5373801589012146,
0.22009988129138947,
-0.5095757246017456,
-0.44467636942863464,
0.6014535427093506,
0.4977835714817047,
-0.2343634068965912,
0.7817677855491638,
1.0143709182739258,
-0.2850126326084137,
-0.6559908986091614,
-0.13120536506175995,
-0.3456719219684601,
-0.4829987585544586,
0.1553337723016739,
-0.44850438833236694,
-0.8330913782119751,
0.24931001663208008,
-0.643339991569519,
0.2854800224304199,
0.1789284497499466,
0.18861596286296844,
-0.09394445270299911,
1.1932811737060547,
0.5847006440162659,
0.3513791263103485,
0.5878692269325256,
-0.37763944268226624,
0.635785698890686,
-1.2875888347625732,
-0.5393801927566528,
-0.30306512117385864,
-0.4120577275753021,
-0.24896404147148132,
-0.4922509789466858,
0.6720749139785767,
-0.007011133246123791,
0.06147066131234169,
0.26948976516723633,
-0.6101384162902832,
0.11927030235528946,
0.6089400053024292,
0.13842561841011047,
0.0381658598780632,
0.13224835693836212,
-0.27591896057128906,
0.10934150218963623,
-0.6879603266716003,
-0.5656625628471375,
1.627905011177063,
0.0836687982082367,
0.9877055883407593,
0.44324514269828796,
1.2222180366516113,
0.2818727195262909,
0.5312559604644775,
-0.4972083866596222,
0.6558722257614136,
-0.07863177359104156,
-0.668806791305542,
-0.11658883839845657,
-0.34816256165504456,
-1.0029587745666504,
-0.0108681945130229,
-0.23329128324985504,
-0.800308883190155,
0.5751613974571228,
0.37951385974884033,
-0.3623390197753906,
0.29161107540130615,
-0.8646498322486877,
0.7759813666343689,
-0.3106667697429657,
-0.7614061236381531,
-0.18054819107055664,
-0.46900007128715515,
0.30844610929489136,
0.18763086199760437,
0.07392163574695587,
-0.20160557329654694,
0.09649106860160828,
0.6049134731292725,
-0.054177217185497284,
0.7774705290794373,
-0.5636663436889648,
-0.21447506546974182,
0.5093541145324707,
0.054692622274160385,
0.6860169768333435,
0.20604322850704193,
-0.028917979449033737,
0.05039393529295921,
-0.25589779019355774,
-0.13772767782211304,
-0.4317794442176819,
0.8236446976661682,
-0.3223048448562622,
-0.22046542167663574,
-0.29127708077430725,
-0.22570675611495972,
0.09911058098077774,
0.2560805082321167,
0.3376152813434601,
0.6289515495300293,
-0.47168397903442383,
0.17726944386959076,
1.0574874877929688,
-0.23249906301498413,
0.4118051826953888,
0.277784526348114,
-0.34053483605384827,
-0.4247135818004608,
1.4325650930404663,
-0.09179925173521042,
0.10530106723308563,
0.4804956912994385,
0.046457864344120026,
-0.7299244403839111,
-0.7072444558143616,
-0.3908174932003021,
0.2017735093832016,
-0.45376044511795044,
-0.09018749743700027,
-0.5474042296409607,
0.1417129933834076,
-0.24673336744308472,
-0.09803444147109985,
-0.6190865635871887,
-0.14766009151935577,
-0.3041306138038635,
0.09019951522350311,
0.0969744622707367,
0.7784318923950195,
-0.20753398537635803,
0.18325024843215942,
-0.45466533303260803,
0.47378265857696533,
0.1748768389225006,
0.5397343635559082,
-0.13101914525032043,
-0.017873434349894524,
-0.40067365765571594,
-0.07042242586612701,
-0.18912702798843384,
-0.7989583015441895,
-0.03534212335944176,
0.046037960797548294,
0.8333180546760559,
0.8425575494766235,
0.29707446694374084,
0.17429119348526,
-0.319876104593277,
0.48955774307250977,
0.058177873492240906,
-0.5415641069412231,
0.549508273601532,
-0.2664183974266052,
-0.20770815014839172,
0.5849341154098511,
0.4486544728279114,
-0.15699315071105957,
0.3208586871623993,
-0.6030603647232056,
-1.0496621131896973,
0.635338306427002,
0.19314949214458466,
-0.2592732608318329,
-0.40181052684783936,
0.38717567920684814,
0.3492045998573303,
0.10434110462665558,
-0.6834394335746765,
-0.5013124346733093,
-0.03062702715396881,
-0.4218287169933319,
0.14953212440013885,
-0.2826458513736725,
-0.011897675693035126,
-0.21458105742931366,
1.0633924007415771,
-0.107645183801651,
0.7275067567825317,
0.424729585647583,
0.08792519569396973,
0.11111573874950409,
0.2103264182806015,
0.2840498983860016,
0.42347443103790283,
-0.5179413557052612,
0.20662608742713928,
-0.3018518388271332,
-0.3171931207180023,
0.4032294452190399,
-0.020000271499156952,
-0.4777931869029999,
0.3001839816570282,
-0.1876838058233261,
0.5977275371551514,
-0.1567697525024414,
-0.5690444111824036,
0.6993893980979919,
-0.23185519874095917,
-0.3401554822921753,
-0.3234517574310303,
0.3683234751224518,
-0.20225168764591217,
-0.003417731961235404,
0.14461900293827057,
0.24961194396018982,
0.46911168098449707,
-0.3076114356517792,
0.2673681080341339,
0.8122370839118958,
-0.46275609731674194,
-0.4516632854938507,
0.4730181097984314,
0.2853251099586487,
-0.17176082730293274,
0.05958867445588112,
-0.906755805015564,
-0.29377511143684387,
0.2756575644016266,
0.693813681602478,
0.8939515352249146,
-0.4343714118003845,
0.5171666145324707,
0.7009890079498291,
0.2210727334022522,
-0.15591423213481903,
0.41335609555244446,
-0.3481867015361786,
-0.7641260623931885,
-0.2377510815858841,
-0.25156232714653015,
-0.19078989326953888,
-0.09689635783433914,
-0.654291033744812,
0.33804452419281006,
-0.35279014706611633,
-0.42382508516311646,
-0.4158833622932434,
-0.23892426490783691,
-0.4317675232887268,
0.13671401143074036,
-0.004124516621232033,
0.4787718951702118,
-0.7934925556182861,
0.7618060111999512,
0.9434661865234375,
0.21144011616706848,
-0.6458402276039124,
-0.1275634467601776,
0.012492653913795948,
-0.24657854437828064,
0.10182929784059525,
0.5525104999542236,
-0.3304848372936249,
0.1916218101978302,
-0.49382203817367554,
-1.0380982160568237,
1.2967157363891602,
0.023823682218790054,
-0.6460703015327454,
0.29206031560897827,
-0.07342664897441864,
0.026812627911567688,
-0.5961593389511108,
0.17416420578956604,
0.18783831596374512,
0.716012179851532,
0.08191373944282532,
-0.1374943107366562,
0.16990825533866882,
-0.32556748390197754,
-0.036747340112924576,
0.42221519351005554,
-0.36337801814079285,
0.7377082109451294,
-0.33071500062942505,
-0.46822118759155273,
0.1511286348104477,
0.4569311738014221,
0.5523774027824402,
0.8707841038703918,
0.6660659313201904,
0.7796918153762817,
0.7121596932411194,
-0.25380679965019226,
0.870570182800293,
-0.21066448092460632,
0.13250872492790222,
0.9480715394020081,
-0.28831127285957336,
0.7175155282020569,
0.729884922504425,
0.04293273761868477,
0.6382068395614624,
0.5983985066413879,
0.24570991098880768,
0.9877246618270874,
0.1301671862602234,
-0.5465003848075867,
-0.23633360862731934,
-0.20879068970680237,
-0.13151390850543976,
-0.011401222087442875,
0.664971649646759,
-0.3441721200942993,
-0.20782829821109772,
-0.044219765812158585,
-0.396484911441803,
-0.07251542806625366,
-0.10832929611206055,
0.8303554058074951,
-0.35363268852233887,
-0.5405658483505249,
0.19547715783119202,
0.047913599759340286,
0.8423304557800293,
-0.4025131165981293,
-0.5035622715950012,
0.04501640796661377,
0.22677123546600342,
-0.22452594339847565,
-0.3537532091140747,
-0.010884816758334637,
-0.4598684310913086,
-0.25006958842277527,
0.06082231178879738,
0.728557288646698,
-0.5954563617706299,
-0.2763553559780121,
0.30198413133621216,
0.17888343334197998,
-0.026189252734184265,
-0.10453654080629349,
-0.35603323578834534,
0.3273932635784149,
0.25723761320114136,
0.021854965016245842,
0.08180578052997589,
0.5297653079032898,
-0.12261564284563065,
0.3970167338848114,
0.8341673016548157,
-0.13963663578033447,
0.2341783493757248,
0.009082451462745667,
0.6310149431228638,
-0.5214112401008606,
-0.308580219745636,
-0.538729190826416,
0.45714738965034485,
-0.2249462604522705,
-0.2867002487182617,
0.6763203144073486,
0.6079392433166504,
0.8386286497116089,
0.1446658819913864,
0.6850444078445435,
-0.25052177906036377,
0.5990620255470276,
-0.54921555519104,
0.39861440658569336,
-0.4717584252357483,
0.45208778977394104,
-0.24606823921203613,
-1.2000668048858643,
-0.13053233921527863,
0.960411548614502,
-0.2649213373661041,
0.2616800367832184,
0.6137866973876953,
0.945847749710083,
-0.4339243173599243,
-0.045101772993803024,
0.11249659210443497,
0.11580222845077515,
0.6200752258300781,
0.5764045119285583,
0.9934269785881042,
-0.3553985357284546,
0.3741821348667145,
-0.3822125494480133,
-0.28991779685020447,
-0.31489232182502747,
-0.7353456020355225,
-0.8760737180709839,
-0.6827797293663025,
-0.55284184217453,
-0.027308691293001175,
-0.17841990292072296,
0.7783687114715576,
1.1190975904464722,
-0.5835880637168884,
0.02927987650036812,
-0.48490482568740845,
0.2004621922969818,
-0.18392181396484375,
-0.31915128231048584,
0.5081180930137634,
-0.3823017477989197,
-0.5699464082717896,
0.5562269687652588,
0.5612031817436218,
0.24966633319854736,
-0.06031496822834015,
-0.5013765692710876,
-0.24023815989494324,
-0.08740074932575226,
0.637427806854248,
0.02872835472226143,
-0.4420630633831024,
-0.14146806299686432,
-0.10390396416187286,
0.19742782413959503,
-0.05236409232020378,
0.796116292476654,
-0.6013289093971252,
0.41308310627937317,
0.2483709752559662,
0.6609477400779724,
0.47524651885032654,
0.20557066798210144,
0.3801589608192444,
-0.6463927030563354,
-0.13268251717090607,
0.1495237648487091,
0.14099717140197754,
0.3528172969818115,
-0.320608913898468,
0.3261142373085022,
0.018846459686756134,
-0.39980992674827576,
-0.6254292130470276,
0.20139828324317932,
-1.2847312688827515,
-0.36848121881484985,
1.2332842350006104,
-0.1127990260720253,
-0.7193684577941895,
-0.41606828570365906,
-0.4319240152835846,
0.06774056702852249,
-0.7329255938529968,
0.7073123455047607,
0.23985238373279572,
-0.4106890559196472,
0.080227330327034,
-0.023237157613039017,
0.5212483406066895,
0.43107137084007263,
-0.5615620613098145,
-0.1703769564628601,
0.4697757661342621,
0.2283135950565338,
0.3149062395095825,
0.49166589975357056,
-0.4109833240509033,
0.25118979811668396,
-0.19411182403564453,
-0.0006840213318355381,
-0.11255832761526108,
-0.9266523718833923,
0.26247015595436096,
0.11860638111829758,
0.12669458985328674,
-0.5472214221954346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08974v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08974v2
|
OOVs in the Spotlight: How to Inflect them?
| 2024-04-13T11:40:06 | 2024-05-28T10:21:38 |
Tomáš Sourada, Jana Straková, Rudolf Rosa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We focus on morphological inflection in out-of-vocabulary (OOV) conditions,
an under-researched subtask in which state-of-the-art systems usually are less
effective. We developed three systems: a retrograde model and two
sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq) models based on LSTM and Transformer. For
testing in OOV conditions, we automatically extracted a large dataset of nouns
in the morphologically rich Czech language, with lemma-disjoint data splits,
and we further manually annotated a real-world OOV dataset of neologisms. In
the standard OOV conditions, Transformer achieves the best results, with
increasing performance in ensemble with LSTM, the retrograde model and
SIGMORPHON baselines. On the real-world OOV dataset of neologisms, the
retrograde model outperforms all neural models. Finally, our seq2seq models
achieve state-of-the-art results in 9 out of 16 languages from SIGMORPHON 2022
shared task data in the OOV evaluation (feature overlap) in the large data
condition. We release the Czech OOV Inflection Dataset for rigorous evaluation
in OOV conditions. Further, we release the inflection system with the seq2seq
models as a ready-to-use Python library.
|
[
-0.2749505937099457,
-0.6832036972045898,
0.3559780716896057,
0.12009614706039429,
-0.4568262994289398,
0.22698533535003662,
-0.08634374290704727,
-0.6541244983673096,
0.0700690895318985,
0.6771068572998047,
-0.3696851432323456,
-0.16104015707969666,
-0.19762134552001953,
0.28803563117980957,
-0.435786634683609,
0.8374962210655212,
0.1573794037103653,
0.38178759813308716,
-0.3109534680843353,
-0.2253202497959137,
-0.16257323324680328,
-0.2986968457698822,
0.17115901410579681,
-0.5408744215965271,
-0.10472704470157623,
0.8252145648002625,
0.8422846794128418,
0.40278568863868713,
0.5417543053627014,
0.18097609281539917,
-0.42168688774108887,
0.15554538369178772,
-0.254721462726593,
0.36435171961784363,
-0.09635647386312485,
-0.23489004373550415,
-0.3626270890235901,
-0.4919338822364807,
0.7590726613998413,
1.0303183794021606,
-0.021160509437322617,
-0.014952773228287697,
0.05305252969264984,
0.44039565324783325,
-0.40649959444999695,
-0.19627630710601807,
-0.594465434551239,
-0.08117491006851196,
-0.29842472076416016,
0.03986455872654915,
-0.2968906760215759,
-0.3396371901035309,
0.17853479087352753,
-0.3518439531326294,
-0.20036008954048157,
0.05156628414988518,
0.9663352966308594,
0.04263036325573921,
-0.018390558660030365,
-0.18808509409427643,
-0.607022225856781,
0.523666501045227,
-0.8119089603424072,
0.5844986438751221,
0.12935978174209595,
0.18610811233520508,
-0.3662849962711334,
-0.6535420417785645,
-0.48329463601112366,
-0.3067927062511444,
0.05104134604334831,
0.22405457496643066,
-0.18462945520877838,
-0.056136563420295715,
0.1646023541688919,
0.4013255536556244,
-0.7168675661087036,
0.19500821828842163,
-0.5938122868537903,
0.18475590646266937,
0.3863869309425354,
0.20806491374969482,
-0.08019568771123886,
-0.33114778995513916,
-0.4988512098789215,
-0.013666225597262383,
-0.9151542782783508,
0.1559252291917801,
0.7368986010551453,
0.6340198516845703,
0.4498562812805176,
0.9829772114753723,
-0.019882606342434883,
0.6255614757537842,
0.32094186544418335,
-0.20299813151359558,
0.46473366022109985,
-0.6303357481956482,
-0.41906359791755676,
-0.057767126709222794,
0.4728024899959564,
-0.05454955995082855,
-0.049654584378004074,
-0.40180733799934387,
-0.4284626245498657,
-0.11860348284244537,
0.1371653974056244,
-0.6295065879821777,
0.06977081298828125,
0.14375515282154083,
-0.178430438041687,
-0.1270323097705841,
0.13666559755802155,
-0.8899762034416199,
-0.4569813013076782,
-0.1348317265510559,
0.8808186650276184,
-0.7981188893318176,
-0.3200191259384155,
0.4139975309371948,
-0.31289905309677124,
0.21301788091659546,
0.13641269505023956,
-0.7217420339584351,
0.8043132424354553,
0.593750536441803,
0.7908518314361572,
-0.21146422624588013,
0.0032301500905305147,
-0.4313158690929413,
-0.4056157171726227,
-0.2938583791255951,
0.5915079712867737,
-0.573711633682251,
-0.4392123520374298,
0.11745854467153549,
-0.059838224202394485,
-0.01873798854649067,
-0.8572598099708557,
0.11220143735408783,
-0.1872827559709549,
0.15907426178455353,
0.39340052008628845,
-0.4947751462459564,
0.11727383732795715,
0.06437962502241135,
-0.3468303978443146,
1.4482896327972412,
0.473573237657547,
-0.5665296316146851,
0.5034167170524597,
-0.43495380878448486,
-0.379232257604599,
0.31712207198143005,
-0.07986454665660858,
-0.3375686705112457,
0.27802222967147827,
-0.06480230391025543,
0.25888484716415405,
-0.3019004166126251,
0.08958566933870316,
-0.11232859641313553,
-0.19782830774784088,
0.11887908726930618,
0.17514194548130035,
0.8124738931655884,
0.0458793006837368,
-0.26723650097846985,
0.33455780148506165,
-0.8074923157691956,
-0.19759847223758698,
-0.06461385637521744,
-0.20322032272815704,
-0.4472465515136719,
-0.16613543033599854,
0.21648681163787842,
0.15880322456359863,
-0.17968223989009857,
-0.8202808499336243,
0.4276847243309021,
-0.8899469375610352,
0.8390287756919861,
0.16807080805301666,
-0.03129391372203827,
0.7322853803634644,
0.1815890520811081,
0.49132591485977173,
0.09447164833545685,
0.5598353743553162,
-0.34708714485168457,
-0.8107326030731201,
-0.5804646015167236,
-0.4497964680194855,
-0.03362471982836723,
0.566383421421051,
-0.891900897026062,
0.3855583667755127,
-0.23491030931472778,
-0.6888320446014404,
-0.44167304039001465,
0.04636183753609657,
0.5266426801681519,
0.592022716999054,
0.3874987065792084,
-0.41427525877952576,
-0.2808884382247925,
-0.8410947322845459,
-0.11350184679031372,
-0.29782286286354065,
0.3567267656326294,
0.1315746307373047,
0.7652398347854614,
-0.07232638448476791,
1.1629303693771362,
-0.10368162393569946,
-0.21942445635795593,
-0.40200355648994446,
0.1373569816350937,
0.6183897256851196,
0.39972302317619324,
0.40326038002967834,
-1.0000793933868408,
-0.30847424268722534,
0.12384390830993652,
-0.23191380500793457,
0.22444036602973938,
0.3393508791923523,
0.18156997859477997,
0.4854547083377838,
1.1019517183303833,
-0.5406336784362793,
0.6934215426445007,
0.2758949398994446,
-0.5384631156921387,
0.5125169157981873,
-0.11161946505308151,
-0.21167930960655212,
-0.9301663041114807,
0.057477615773677826,
-0.24520529806613922,
-0.2667718529701233,
-0.8950031399726868,
0.08620503544807434,
0.2152804583311081,
-0.010939495638012886,
-0.7444247603416443,
0.45090022683143616,
-0.3977883458137512,
0.03111976757645607,
0.2300042062997818,
0.067792609333992,
-0.19973482191562653,
0.19571389257907867,
-0.025847837328910828,
0.26813000440597534,
0.6628572940826416,
-0.538870632648468,
0.4061509072780609,
0.24644923210144043,
-0.6763162612915039,
0.40793949365615845,
-0.5999243855476379,
-0.060551490634679794,
-0.2701319456100464,
-0.18156816065311432,
-1.4633605480194092,
-0.38214513659477234,
0.5304592847824097,
-0.47638580203056335,
0.6534212231636047,
-0.41204431653022766,
-0.7159469723701477,
-0.35984575748443604,
-0.2699149250984192,
0.7542356252670288,
0.5687745213508606,
-0.6324809193611145,
0.6232455372810364,
0.5185356736183167,
-0.07775629311800003,
-0.5052559971809387,
-0.7253903150558472,
0.02216237224638462,
-0.5406379699707031,
-0.6649580597877502,
0.4429180324077606,
0.028929291293025017,
-0.5819414258003235,
0.13469961285591125,
0.13754862546920776,
-0.1891428679227829,
-0.21591921150684357,
0.4365706145763397,
0.26245272159576416,
-0.28519830107688904,
0.39530783891677856,
-0.2883738875389099,
0.31453022360801697,
-0.38346219062805176,
-0.5124732255935669,
0.5711002945899963,
-0.31429460644721985,
-0.26314154267311096,
0.08829052746295929,
0.06217243894934654,
0.6283257007598877,
-0.08207972347736359,
0.34946489334106445,
0.12189047038555145,
-0.4333065152168274,
0.005749077070504427,
-0.3839726746082306,
-0.23506957292556763,
-0.36534857749938965,
0.436122328042984,
-0.24893400073051453,
-0.6813895106315613,
0.5027153491973877,
-0.008421158418059349,
0.1185399517416954,
0.38276124000549316,
0.4376474618911743,
0.0690840408205986,
0.7803994417190552,
0.8458617329597473,
0.2523450553417206,
0.709510326385498,
-0.2530936896800995,
0.061573438346385956,
-0.7671403288841248,
-0.4968833923339844,
-0.5035580396652222,
0.09642266482114792,
-0.5101186633110046,
-0.5189762115478516,
0.4995749294757843,
0.15094128251075745,
0.24522125720977783,
0.7362186908721924,
-0.252584844827652,
0.19569799304008484,
0.142821803689003,
-0.0914117619395256,
0.11310485750436783,
0.10851708054542542,
-0.28330206871032715,
0.06988179683685303,
-0.8248844146728516,
-0.2718167304992676,
0.7613663077354431,
0.3938092291355133,
0.8952198624610901,
0.08589746057987213,
0.5690792202949524,
-0.10776381194591522,
0.009053463116288185,
-1.1766347885131836,
0.39349693059921265,
-0.10836255550384521,
-0.7072038054466248,
-0.7738431096076965,
-0.10208607465028763,
-1.1086591482162476,
0.27761903405189514,
-0.24172930419445038,
-0.798298180103302,
0.7383853197097778,
0.0945303812623024,
-0.48440301418304443,
0.16723978519439697,
-0.14939409494400024,
0.7527360320091248,
0.03205445408821106,
-0.39581626653671265,
-0.05862130969762802,
-0.8808726668357849,
0.26865655183792114,
0.041225045919418335,
0.4070945978164673,
0.018774980679154396,
-0.20883797109127045,
0.27281707525253296,
-0.4212140738964081,
0.9004703760147095,
0.08959037065505981,
-0.17914478480815887,
0.2583797872066498,
-0.0045533557422459126,
0.2907077670097351,
0.07996472716331482,
-0.15472525358200073,
0.2047654390335083,
-0.1692916750907898,
-0.07808181643486023,
-0.44628605246543884,
0.4415091276168823,
-0.3740372359752655,
-0.21806225180625916,
-0.4452346861362457,
-0.3213118016719818,
-0.2419695407152176,
0.18900439143180847,
0.6688419580459595,
0.7407242059707642,
-0.6363482475280762,
0.2110910415649414,
0.6444448232650757,
0.006127218250185251,
0.46696463227272034,
0.31865882873535156,
-0.5256763100624084,
-0.6844989061355591,
0.7770036458969116,
0.4049191474914551,
0.5353805422782898,
0.31920406222343445,
0.24151329696178436,
-0.23507504165172577,
-0.5620899200439453,
-0.7680808305740356,
0.4251006543636322,
-0.872952401638031,
-0.19883698225021362,
-0.35569849610328674,
-0.15045243501663208,
-0.7747047543525696,
0.28042981028556824,
-0.33324775099754333,
-0.7974493503570557,
-0.1233639195561409,
0.25946569442749023,
0.4014204442501068,
1.2012982368469238,
0.11188728362321854,
0.02015543170273304,
-0.4460959732532501,
0.06724034994840622,
-0.010384603403508663,
0.03256668522953987,
-0.6182496547698975,
-1.1347979307174683,
-0.46320515871047974,
-0.37947535514831543,
-0.16142205893993378,
-0.8199957013130188,
0.6091086864471436,
0.5131547451019287,
0.4318423569202423,
0.4529285132884979,
-0.1419709026813507,
0.8066332936286926,
-0.6023416519165039,
0.7681013345718384,
0.1865963637828827,
-1.0354197025299072,
0.4541107416152954,
-0.10935152322053909,
0.15527555346488953,
0.29030343890190125,
0.27965325117111206,
-0.38496217131614685,
-0.6572059988975525,
-0.6602787971496582,
-1.4689233303070068,
0.5610119700431824,
0.2714969515800476,
0.010266401804983616,
-0.15446686744689941,
0.6310939192771912,
0.6134979724884033,
0.25712406635284424,
-0.20422345399856567,
0.07891649752855301,
-0.4052986204624176,
0.046632491052150726,
-0.4226621091365814,
0.06360456347465515,
0.011215230450034142,
-0.37138840556144714,
0.6319178938865662,
-0.32344409823417664,
-0.146063894033432,
0.39283323287963867,
-0.4143437445163727,
-0.26312392950057983,
0.13544969260692596,
0.7687577605247498,
0.6246662139892578,
-0.2672780454158783,
0.19555699825286865,
0.28369370102882385,
-0.6476982235908508,
-0.12164058536291122,
-0.3521329164505005,
-0.10690224170684814,
0.3162362277507782,
0.3626667857170105,
0.7097851634025574,
0.416052907705307,
-0.7633009552955627,
0.5539242625236511,
0.17568470537662506,
-0.33089202642440796,
-0.3256020247936249,
-0.15540814399719238,
-0.1745382845401764,
0.4605031907558441,
0.18866005539894104,
0.3141512870788574,
0.259603887796402,
-0.8761215806007385,
-0.22146916389465332,
0.5289217829704285,
-0.6411323547363281,
-0.6214224696159363,
-0.04106074199080467,
-0.12905247509479523,
-0.15585161745548248,
0.6288762092590332,
0.09177985042333603,
-0.3794946074485779,
0.5280933380126953,
0.6345641613006592,
0.7304186224937439,
-0.07958833128213882,
-0.09731076657772064,
0.3533872067928314,
0.33023127913475037,
-0.43793046474456787,
0.5927925705909729,
0.05284867063164711,
-0.6128060221672058,
-0.11377670615911484,
-0.4353310465812683,
-0.39227572083473206,
0.02197376638650894,
-1.0766961574554443,
0.5707653760910034,
-0.3763347268104553,
-0.4060337543487549,
-0.04592199996113777,
-0.3640381395816803,
-0.4620751142501831,
0.14961054921150208,
-0.01771249994635582,
1.2225145101547241,
-0.8343099355697632,
0.7689655423164368,
1.0178149938583374,
-0.37141337990760803,
-0.1889355182647705,
-0.11097387224435806,
-0.15497556328773499,
-0.8138183951377869,
0.8985003232955933,
-0.07589277625083923,
-0.4081529676914215,
-0.0735531821846962,
-0.618113100528717,
-1.047662377357483,
0.8187218904495239,
0.5130959749221802,
-0.3021484315395355,
0.14846475422382355,
0.06270691752433777,
0.5649820566177368,
-0.48494160175323486,
0.0364985316991806,
0.6913991570472717,
0.5868531465530396,
0.20854219794273376,
-1.0919458866119385,
-0.1861901730298996,
-0.370920866727829,
-0.19756531715393066,
0.35809966921806335,
-0.36261194944381714,
1.0179237127304077,
-0.4232003390789032,
-0.29607298970222473,
0.5506361722946167,
0.577477216720581,
-0.3128513693809509,
0.05178765580058098,
0.5209218859672546,
0.4554142355918884,
0.6092060208320618,
-0.10463771969079971,
0.8168303966522217,
-0.04244665428996086,
0.015348242595791817,
0.7990660071372986,
-0.14494319260120392,
1.1523668766021729,
1.058024525642395,
0.24445219337940216,
0.35075896978378296,
0.5581508278846741,
-0.01601102016866207,
0.5640023350715637,
0.284830778837204,
0.11778553575277328,
-0.4176199436187744,
-0.2658174932003021,
-0.3641313910484314,
0.5015214085578918,
0.5459700226783752,
-0.08242210745811462,
0.08639544248580933,
0.24056467413902283,
-0.19186080992221832,
0.01944027841091156,
-0.4060360789299011,
0.7874062657356262,
-0.020005637779831886,
-0.630496621131897,
0.5531013011932373,
-0.32914644479751587,
0.5339382290840149,
-0.5656409859657288,
0.02855299599468708,
-0.1904243677854538,
0.44871675968170166,
-0.35959920287132263,
-0.9437459111213684,
0.22469045221805573,
-0.25796887278556824,
-0.16266921162605286,
-0.23661001026630402,
0.4763752520084381,
-0.6767650246620178,
-0.43825212121009827,
0.4371625483036041,
0.3692662715911865,
0.5480592846870422,
0.01640952192246914,
-0.14334149658679962,
-0.06272301822900772,
-0.6390398144721985,
-0.09308420121669769,
0.2763770818710327,
0.5108733177185059,
-0.34021663665771484,
0.42145562171936035,
0.09717760980129242,
0.2817095220088959,
0.12763136625289917,
0.24500662088394165,
1.1928505897521973,
-0.5842483639717102,
-0.27492019534111023,
-0.8770589828491211,
0.5574175715446472,
0.13910646736621857,
-0.7685194611549377,
0.9283397197723389,
0.6853707432746887,
0.8808494210243225,
-0.13410568237304688,
0.3841651976108551,
0.0653964951634407,
0.43509161472320557,
-0.5878817439079285,
0.3114933669567108,
-1.0211213827133179,
-0.17333997786045074,
-0.33019205927848816,
-0.7185329794883728,
-0.6532554030418396,
0.4181596338748932,
0.056498341262340546,
-0.31566500663757324,
0.5405645370483398,
0.8462620973587036,
-0.06134335324168205,
-0.2999916076660156,
0.7319680452346802,
0.42400166392326355,
0.11730756610631943,
0.23590226471424103,
1.1308990716934204,
-0.43129703402519226,
0.582067608833313,
-0.15271681547164917,
-0.25102370977401733,
-0.6896652579307556,
-0.8985400199890137,
-0.9441254138946533,
-0.717053234577179,
-0.2487250119447708,
-0.4583127796649933,
0.1735723465681076,
1.14681875705719,
0.7803393602371216,
-0.6743895411491394,
-0.6068134903907776,
-0.06727474182844162,
-0.07255487143993378,
-0.44918757677078247,
-0.10850167274475098,
0.09707874059677124,
-0.42198795080184937,
-0.47719672322273254,
0.8471137881278992,
0.7809512615203857,
0.10852813720703125,
-0.32128438353538513,
-0.10524895787239075,
0.022221574559807777,
0.25259166955947876,
0.5002118349075317,
0.4730079472064972,
-0.8528953790664673,
-0.06079595163464546,
0.40892523527145386,
0.041468724608421326,
0.30747494101524353,
0.9492237567901611,
-0.899546205997467,
0.5904318690299988,
0.8113695383071899,
-0.1498832255601883,
0.32391297817230225,
-0.1897403746843338,
0.40596622228622437,
-0.5277514457702637,
0.2819438576698303,
0.5441562533378601,
0.4669742286205292,
0.4002807140350342,
-0.13466021418571472,
0.3794323801994324,
0.30886906385421753,
-0.13995549082756042,
-1.2784725427627563,
0.3950839936733246,
-0.6606929898262024,
-0.2779448926448822,
1.1018409729003906,
-0.0025805544573813677,
-0.392365038394928,
-0.6158860921859741,
-0.1563531458377838,
0.14241504669189453,
-0.321058452129364,
0.5456070303916931,
0.5282169580459595,
-0.3625991940498352,
0.14151038229465485,
-0.27656319737434387,
0.6334402561187744,
0.3033043146133423,
-0.4739290773868561,
0.05139311030507088,
0.06656178086996078,
0.16971635818481445,
0.5313072800636292,
0.021804599091410637,
-0.5057724118232727,
0.3367516100406647,
0.006897048093378544,
0.1415264755487442,
-0.1445464938879013,
-0.7152912616729736,
-0.8726803660392761,
0.029451237991452217,
0.0674370527267456,
0.1380530595779419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08958v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08958v1
|
AMU-Tuning: Effective Logit Bias for CLIP-based Few-shot Learning
| 2024-04-13T10:46:11 | 2024-04-13T10:46:11 |
Yuwei Tang, Zhenyi Lin, Qilong Wang, Pengfei Zhu, Qinghua Hu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recently, pre-trained vision-language models (e.g., CLIP) have shown great
potential in few-shot learning and attracted a lot of research interest.
Although efforts have been made to improve few-shot ability of CLIP, key
factors on the effectiveness of existing methods have not been well studied,
limiting further exploration of CLIP's potential in few-shot learning. In this
paper, we first introduce a unified formulation to analyze CLIP-based few-shot
learning methods from a perspective of logit bias, which encourages us to learn
an effective logit bias for further improving performance of CLIP-based
few-shot learning methods. To this end, we disassemble three key components
involved in computation of logit bias (i.e., logit features, logit predictor,
and logit fusion) and empirically analyze the effect on performance of few-shot
classification. Based on analysis of key components, this paper proposes a
novel AMU-Tuning method to learn effective logit bias for CLIP-based few-shot
classification. Specifically, our AMU-Tuning predicts logit bias by exploiting
the appropriate $\underline{\textbf{A}}$uxiliary features, which are fed into
an efficient feature-initialized linear classifier with
$\underline{\textbf{M}}$ulti-branch training. Finally, an
$\underline{\textbf{U}}$ncertainty-based fusion is developed to incorporate
logit bias into CLIP for few-shot classification. The experiments are conducted
on several widely used benchmarks, and the results show AMU-Tuning clearly
outperforms its counterparts while achieving state-of-the-art performance of
CLIP-based few-shot learning without bells and whistles.
|
[
-0.523213267326355,
-0.84381103515625,
0.15199711918830872,
-0.3008236587047577,
-0.5331060886383057,
0.1867576390504837,
-0.12716111540794373,
-0.6073142886161804,
0.42226263880729675,
0.19627146422863007,
-0.7947957515716553,
-0.42767977714538574,
-0.4124872088432312,
-0.10705762356519699,
0.0784367248415947,
0.8324505090713501,
0.2782408893108368,
0.33054012060165405,
0.28728383779525757,
-0.3713710308074951,
-0.660950243473053,
-0.337048202753067,
-0.35145100951194763,
-0.380653440952301,
0.1396375298500061,
0.5187659859657288,
0.42557334899902344,
0.6360424160957336,
0.41926875710487366,
0.1529301553964615,
-0.12886972725391388,
0.018391894176602364,
-0.6421616077423096,
-0.5788194537162781,
0.2660236060619354,
-0.8799844980239868,
-0.3973078429698944,
-0.03940603509545326,
0.8018321990966797,
-0.07630778104066849,
0.00015471220831386745,
0.198150634765625,
0.21181833744049072,
0.4429980218410492,
-1.0599688291549683,
-0.2545650005340576,
-0.943190336227417,
0.19576449692249298,
-0.6113831996917725,
-0.33800745010375977,
-0.3497486710548401,
-0.11105746030807495,
-0.17568890750408173,
-0.6987354159355164,
0.5888984799385071,
0.25973519682884216,
1.0328795909881592,
0.37186336517333984,
-0.1964840143918991,
0.465190589427948,
-0.43556469678878784,
1.0870963335037231,
-0.641146719455719,
0.3766510784626007,
0.12134391814470291,
0.4190311133861542,
-0.023668689653277397,
0.05435912311077118,
-0.2718556821346283,
0.46219080686569214,
-0.09711368381977081,
0.129193514585495,
-0.20121431350708008,
0.3163807988166809,
0.33226025104522705,
0.1590936779975891,
-0.3910715579986572,
0.3943358361721039,
-0.26351815462112427,
-0.3921424150466919,
0.6514720916748047,
0.22727598249912262,
-0.043639324605464935,
-0.25562265515327454,
-0.5738617777824402,
-0.23340389132499695,
-0.8816127181053162,
0.2249857485294342,
0.4741792678833008,
0.2273981273174286,
-0.12337922304868698,
0.32603245973587036,
-0.2202511876821518,
0.8593871593475342,
0.14754757285118103,
-0.49095064401626587,
0.16598083078861237,
-0.4866306185722351,
-0.20570707321166992,
0.11425912380218506,
0.5911585092544556,
0.5248843431472778,
0.1325981169939041,
0.20062585175037384,
-0.08151178061962128,
0.23670059442520142,
0.202371746301651,
-0.7010011672973633,
-0.3653658330440521,
-0.22070349752902985,
-0.30426090955734253,
-0.5833485126495361,
0.08174742013216019,
-0.927742063999176,
0.0036180736497044563,
-0.15178832411766052,
0.5590161681175232,
-0.41680774092674255,
-0.031208772212266922,
-0.2967195212841034,
-0.10456426441669464,
0.4339522421360016,
0.3297092318534851,
-1.0500799417495728,
0.1919742375612259,
0.5157952904701233,
0.935310959815979,
-0.4016880393028259,
-0.48730653524398804,
-0.7033465504646301,
-0.015739036723971367,
0.03442554548382759,
1.0858395099639893,
-0.5177051424980164,
-0.3488632142543793,
0.025287561118602753,
-0.31266048550605774,
-0.22304685413837433,
-0.6122270822525024,
0.36703938245773315,
-0.19318999350070953,
-0.18519611656665802,
-0.12057271599769592,
-0.4533647894859314,
-0.4407420754432678,
0.19951121509075165,
-0.515362024307251,
0.8037136197090149,
-0.1432749480009079,
-0.614466667175293,
0.9882391095161438,
-0.517312228679657,
-0.3157402276992798,
0.12125249952077866,
-0.41247910261154175,
-0.7611985206604004,
0.19999174773693085,
0.6010144948959351,
0.36960524320602417,
0.14421391487121582,
-0.33196571469306946,
-0.5600095391273499,
-0.5785237550735474,
0.27761489152908325,
-0.3913751244544983,
0.6424293518066406,
-0.23034459352493286,
-0.09715588390827179,
0.13443243503570557,
-0.7240158915519714,
0.2941199541091919,
-0.3594047427177429,
-0.11948378384113312,
-0.13199545443058014,
-0.2835206985473633,
0.16075609624385834,
-0.24270284175872803,
-0.26834723353385925,
-0.7546853423118591,
0.31685009598731995,
-0.4710901379585266,
0.21964587271213531,
0.7710335850715637,
0.19573213160037994,
0.555838406085968,
-0.2658032476902008,
0.42212942242622375,
0.05550028383731842,
0.3469087779521942,
-0.3019416928291321,
-0.3600180745124817,
-0.6547487378120422,
-0.5966249108314514,
0.22501522302627563,
0.6419095396995544,
-0.25903695821762085,
0.17239411175251007,
0.144764244556427,
-0.027965113520622253,
-0.6059043407440186,
0.6332595348358154,
0.5178956389427185,
0.37795209884643555,
0.48228341341018677,
-0.42468389868736267,
-0.6889670491218567,
-0.7771171927452087,
-0.41146689653396606,
-0.2671308219432831,
-0.038574736565351486,
0.6916899085044861,
0.31268036365509033,
0.05004813149571419,
1.1024125814437866,
-0.9210801124572754,
-0.7695954442024231,
-0.19495099782943726,
0.21812452375888824,
0.1601453423500061,
0.3040502071380615,
0.6494080424308777,
-0.4539697766304016,
-0.38584524393081665,
-0.037841036915779114,
-0.7199884057044983,
-0.03108999878168106,
0.014963424764573574,
-0.49242863059043884,
0.047642387449741364,
0.09983409941196442,
-0.47447922825813293,
0.7921362519264221,
0.07660859078168869,
-0.2558225691318512,
0.5675252676010132,
0.3633832633495331,
0.08128984272480011,
-0.48069021105766296,
-0.0378527007997036,
-0.0162887554615736,
-0.3868166208267212,
-0.34111300110816956,
-0.001077235210686922,
0.19577045738697052,
0.009912092238664627,
-0.9075875878334045,
0.42308923602104187,
-0.023725880309939384,
0.11748910695314407,
-0.6492387056350708,
-0.17531903088092804,
0.0584256574511528,
0.668665885925293,
0.02671702392399311,
0.4557620584964752,
0.639926552772522,
-0.7980607151985168,
0.20833177864551544,
0.3520830273628235,
-0.21966968476772308,
0.6504210829734802,
-0.41815102100372314,
0.019324706867337227,
0.10255583375692368,
0.15332670509815216,
-0.39789217710494995,
-0.18861372768878937,
0.21494391560554504,
-0.25126704573631287,
0.6576721668243408,
-0.5539206862449646,
-0.24750804901123047,
-0.24412962794303894,
-0.5885108113288879,
0.6188114881515503,
0.4766084849834442,
-0.6772503852844238,
0.3754866421222687,
0.16430285573005676,
0.4977041184902191,
-0.8073879480361938,
-0.36920738220214844,
-0.5502099990844727,
-0.4379248023033142,
-0.4120815396308899,
0.31887924671173096,
0.10102999955415726,
0.09511088579893112,
0.033001627773046494,
-0.3474715054035187,
-0.04130844399333,
0.06670674681663513,
0.21435107290744781,
0.5575926303863525,
-0.3119870126247406,
-0.020534062758088112,
0.049257975071668625,
-0.26775315403938293,
-0.4496733248233795,
-0.19391822814941406,
0.09831849485635757,
-0.21639005839824677,
-0.21432997286319733,
-0.2452486753463745,
-0.07295359671115875,
0.04838167876005173,
-0.045441463589668274,
0.17528122663497925,
0.8549260497093201,
-0.1557369828224182,
-0.2617325484752655,
-0.8002592921257019,
-0.5753001570701599,
-0.4257003664970398,
0.36245396733283997,
-0.3595125675201416,
-0.876319408416748,
0.300609827041626,
-0.08256301283836365,
0.09993135184049606,
0.2473001927137375,
0.5953410863876343,
-0.1926870495080948,
0.6372089982032776,
0.9411970973014832,
-0.4244445264339447,
0.7804104089736938,
-0.40227293968200684,
-0.12315551936626434,
-0.8756831288337708,
-0.02164842188358307,
-0.02445092238485813,
-0.7001017928123474,
-0.35205355286598206,
-0.2307361364364624,
0.7018259763717651,
0.28495654463768005,
0.25217050313949585,
0.29760050773620605,
-0.21796837449073792,
0.9848905801773071,
0.5768132209777832,
0.45251503586769104,
0.3494020402431488,
-0.061800114810466766,
-0.12937329709529877,
-0.012237666174769402,
-0.8536108136177063,
-0.08318483829498291,
1.1118519306182861,
0.34773531556129456,
1.3488521575927734,
-0.08164079487323761,
0.8405593633651733,
0.1499321311712265,
-0.28009822964668274,
-1.117693543434143,
0.17104604840278625,
-0.10303615033626556,
-0.8598645329475403,
-0.48091036081314087,
0.020656239241361618,
-0.5301207900047302,
0.6118335723876953,
-0.7455384731292725,
-0.8640295267105103,
0.2825893461704254,
0.7651759386062622,
-0.4240117073059082,
0.38786613941192627,
-0.7444993853569031,
0.8084962368011475,
-0.3082486391067505,
-0.6794984340667725,
-0.37073710560798645,
-0.6128118634223938,
0.7071815729141235,
-0.0013744971947744489,
-0.24498991668224335,
-0.3871288299560547,
0.2473415583372116,
0.6430435180664062,
-0.43995144963264465,
1.0212669372558594,
-0.09206939488649368,
0.5207791924476624,
0.49633029103279114,
-0.2076410949230194,
0.16437314450740814,
0.3929536044597626,
0.2584094703197479,
0.4363136291503906,
0.10561937838792801,
-0.6046504378318787,
-0.5852869153022766,
0.37284478545188904,
-0.6630325317382812,
-0.34862613677978516,
-0.25988972187042236,
-0.03669317066669464,
-0.07032141834497452,
0.3148248791694641,
0.8847553730010986,
0.4234911799430847,
-0.5260899662971497,
-0.15699779987335205,
0.5802366137504578,
0.30766919255256653,
0.5572115182876587,
0.420486181974411,
-0.2091129571199417,
-0.31789955496788025,
0.7844963669776917,
-0.05410061404109001,
-0.014564918354153633,
0.5021335482597351,
0.3150191903114319,
-0.0809658020734787,
-0.27587249875068665,
-0.6034577488899231,
0.3506093919277191,
-0.5625625252723694,
-0.7762482762336731,
-0.07854074239730835,
-0.045709844678640366,
0.031358297914266586,
-0.2523428797721863,
-0.5478965044021606,
-0.26325148344039917,
-0.41058552265167236,
-0.06561189889907837,
0.266431987285614,
0.5675697326660156,
0.05339299514889717,
0.6737484931945801,
-0.6640815138816833,
0.2351190596818924,
0.40200546383857727,
0.4782727360725403,
-0.1314024180173874,
-0.4426686763763428,
-0.4438621699810028,
-0.18795622885227203,
-0.7482417225837708,
-0.6364997029304504,
0.14609935879707336,
0.7624925374984741,
0.6394137144088745,
0.6783360838890076,
-0.13023920357227325,
0.8496208190917969,
-0.6679819822311401,
0.4522306025028229,
0.44239184260368347,
-0.9503099918365479,
0.8550965189933777,
0.1412937492132187,
0.5987792611122131,
0.8863640427589417,
0.0585760772228241,
0.21952274441719055,
-0.248066246509552,
-0.4824918210506439,
-0.4518403112888336,
1.0282807350158691,
0.21400217711925507,
-0.13437379896640778,
0.4783962368965149,
0.13704568147659302,
0.39272552728652954,
0.12699511647224426,
-0.5944647192955017,
-0.3287501037120819,
-0.45293593406677246,
0.2174290418624878,
-0.01935463212430477,
-0.21047694981098175,
-0.11678643524646759,
-0.354238897562027,
0.7167678475379944,
-0.3895937502384186,
0.2145121693611145,
-0.17042818665504456,
-0.45520415902137756,
-0.47407296299934387,
0.41236183047294617,
0.5013147592544556,
0.5157124996185303,
-0.6215924024581909,
0.04466037079691887,
0.5133981704711914,
-0.6191319227218628,
0.2050294280052185,
-0.3709178864955902,
-0.6249141693115234,
0.18828953802585602,
0.2706533670425415,
1.3009997606277466,
0.5685920715332031,
-0.31189003586769104,
0.6509553790092468,
0.1615123748779297,
-0.21616649627685547,
0.05411425605416298,
0.3391883671283722,
-0.8782301545143127,
0.3090079128742218,
0.4487076699733734,
0.30157867074012756,
0.23343712091445923,
-0.28197547793388367,
0.40645861625671387,
0.8082873821258545,
-0.42387306690216064,
-0.650147557258606,
0.5074049830436707,
0.3250250220298767,
0.0021666940301656723,
0.3445087671279907,
-0.017357803881168365,
-0.747435450553894,
0.1379709541797638,
0.5473346710205078,
1.0247575044631958,
-0.09043899178504944,
0.06665897369384766,
0.617698073387146,
0.27426594495773315,
0.13768969476222992,
-0.07789728790521622,
-0.1796247363090515,
-0.8239855170249939,
-0.3237045109272003,
-0.7338963747024536,
-0.3837874233722687,
0.09350322186946869,
-0.6890360713005066,
0.9111804962158203,
-0.6431596279144287,
-0.43914246559143066,
0.028970913961529732,
-0.10355526953935623,
-0.9194809794425964,
-0.056693658232688904,
0.3306399881839752,
0.5968496203422546,
-1.1932084560394287,
0.823849618434906,
0.8799759149551392,
-0.16373057663440704,
-0.49515020847320557,
0.026884280145168304,
0.40773022174835205,
-0.8931046724319458,
0.38514596223831177,
0.17065057158470154,
-0.30116990208625793,
0.03544076532125473,
-0.7366362810134888,
-0.6662723422050476,
0.9551141262054443,
0.27107784152030945,
-0.509270429611206,
0.03902541846036911,
-0.4049057364463806,
0.04494960606098175,
-0.3646412789821625,
0.3518944978713989,
0.6812747120857239,
0.06118329241871834,
0.4015727639198303,
-0.9698586463928223,
-0.2692374587059021,
0.03371027484536171,
-0.06862835586071014,
0.5392988920211792,
-0.9771860837936401,
0.33827775716781616,
-0.27446240186691284,
-0.12420827895402908,
-0.34266453981399536,
0.6431633830070496,
0.10996764153242111,
0.47754043340682983,
0.41703397035598755,
0.6449296474456787,
0.6476725935935974,
0.11755900830030441,
0.6426709890365601,
-0.010325845330953598,
0.5332357883453369,
0.8991469144821167,
0.13986484706401825,
0.9326987862586975,
0.43147191405296326,
-0.47803762555122375,
0.37986618280410767,
0.30887362360954285,
-0.3793708384037018,
0.7049588561058044,
-0.14214560389518738,
-0.35611337423324585,
-0.46168580651283264,
0.04288199171423912,
-0.07043466717004776,
0.7343569397926331,
0.22378484904766083,
-0.08561026304960251,
-0.2801673710346222,
0.14091575145721436,
-0.2035672962665558,
-0.3844510316848755,
-0.38484203815460205,
1.055153250694275,
0.19329044222831726,
-0.35587456822395325,
0.7302569150924683,
-0.1413511037826538,
1.0428531169891357,
-0.5785530209541321,
-0.11246730387210846,
-0.006513156928122044,
0.15743905305862427,
-0.6179194450378418,
-0.4088922142982483,
-0.03759506717324257,
0.06175469607114792,
-0.24569708108901978,
0.4049203395843506,
0.8695398569107056,
-0.13502466678619385,
-0.5432727336883545,
-0.1556512415409088,
0.2273910790681839,
0.09625004976987839,
0.1550389975309372,
-0.603766918182373,
0.17851783335208893,
0.15797708928585052,
0.3159710466861725,
0.3902895152568817,
-0.07796477526426315,
0.1678887903690338,
0.4048316776752472,
0.1743735522031784,
0.018459873273968697,
0.4696439206600189,
-0.23106004297733307,
0.7533473372459412,
-0.6242443323135376,
-0.5791347622871399,
-1.1484792232513428,
0.4265473186969757,
0.1681189090013504,
-0.39309629797935486,
0.6813418865203857,
0.7583303451538086,
0.8280686736106873,
-0.21490317583084106,
0.8138553500175476,
0.05871862918138504,
0.47256961464881897,
-1.0967164039611816,
0.36901795864105225,
-0.31198742985725403,
0.14536716043949127,
-0.4531148672103882,
-1.1022756099700928,
-0.44057026505470276,
0.7481329441070557,
-0.07773056626319885,
-0.30242836475372314,
0.8039708733558655,
0.6502392888069153,
-0.4104593098163605,
-0.10251031816005707,
0.585070013999939,
-0.05778079852461815,
0.018605003133416176,
0.6889936923980713,
0.4411241114139557,
-0.5749585032463074,
0.5447502732276917,
-0.5918182730674744,
-0.37885820865631104,
-0.7245604395866394,
-0.7419593930244446,
-1.1741900444030762,
0.009121808223426342,
-0.5014641880989075,
-0.006284702569246292,
0.028801623731851578,
0.8687990307807922,
0.9112094044685364,
-0.9919058680534363,
-0.2592318654060364,
0.18800225853919983,
0.2638305127620697,
-0.21135328710079193,
-0.18324582278728485,
0.19134464859962463,
-0.5343760251998901,
-0.5856749415397644,
0.3274487555027008,
0.2150568664073944,
0.2466142326593399,
-0.0071870023384690285,
-0.15186236798763275,
-0.15110929310321808,
-0.3278561532497406,
0.6468247175216675,
0.7245419025421143,
-0.9788064956665039,
-0.25736427307128906,
0.019373087212443352,
0.4422731101512909,
0.5063601136207581,
1.0125484466552734,
-1.1299306154251099,
0.7805259823799133,
0.2518586218357086,
0.39822065830230713,
1.0340765714645386,
0.4805607795715332,
0.475416362285614,
-1.09939706325531,
0.3083735406398773,
-0.012579444795846939,
0.1437619924545288,
0.00944579392671585,
-0.3916797637939453,
0.49021217226982117,
0.4963727295398712,
-0.3547027111053467,
-0.7187886238098145,
0.26595818996429443,
-0.9860854148864746,
0.12414956092834473,
0.9216668605804443,
0.09215430170297623,
-0.25589197874069214,
0.20421065390110016,
-0.33837205171585083,
0.2349666953086853,
-0.6221120357513428,
0.4766962230205536,
0.5169088244438171,
-0.6903321146965027,
-0.5287718772888184,
-0.2662599980831146,
0.6502608060836792,
0.5202912092208862,
-0.3034002184867859,
-0.21286623179912567,
0.5001595616340637,
0.14620625972747803,
-0.06062566116452217,
0.3725017309188843,
0.10806717723608017,
0.5046190619468689,
-0.053814612329006195,
-0.18888643383979797,
0.06195199862122536,
-0.3116609752178192,
-0.6339452862739563,
-0.2594465911388397,
0.47818082571029663,
-0.5407937169075012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08949v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08949v1
|
Multimodal Cross-Document Event Coreference Resolution Using Linear Semantic Transfer and Mixed-Modality Ensembles
| 2024-04-13T10:01:58 | 2024-04-13T10:01:58 |
Abhijnan Nath, Huma Jamil, Shafiuddin Rehan Ahmed, George Baker, Rahul Ghosh, James H. Martin, Nathaniel Blanchard, Nikhil Krishnaswamy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Event coreference resolution (ECR) is the task of determining whether
distinct mentions of events within a multi-document corpus are actually linked
to the same underlying occurrence. Images of the events can help facilitate
resolution when language is ambiguous. Here, we propose a multimodal
cross-document event coreference resolution method that integrates visual and
textual cues with a simple linear map between vision and language models. As
existing ECR benchmark datasets rarely provide images for all event mentions,
we augment the popular ECB+ dataset with event-centric images scraped from the
internet and generated using image diffusion models. We establish three methods
that incorporate images and text for coreference: 1) a standard fused model
with finetuning, 2) a novel linear mapping method without finetuning and 3) an
ensembling approach based on splitting mention pairs by semantic and
discourse-level difficulty. We evaluate on 2 datasets: the augmented ECB+, and
AIDA Phase 1. Our ensemble systems using cross-modal linear mapping establish
an upper limit (91.9 CoNLL F1) on ECB+ ECR performance given the preprocessing
assumptions used, and establish a novel baseline on AIDA Phase 1. Our results
demonstrate the utility of multimodal information in ECR for certain
challenging coreference problems, and highlight a need for more multimodal
resources in the coreference resolution space.
|
[
-0.8483949899673462,
-0.7197145223617554,
0.5890805125236511,
-0.11520049721002579,
-0.3911925256252289,
0.019943397492170334,
-0.7678871154785156,
-0.9502353072166443,
0.236681267619133,
0.25580865144729614,
-0.334434449672699,
-0.44382110238075256,
-0.865527868270874,
0.05910501256585121,
-0.3980271816253662,
0.8059829473495483,
-0.24084672331809998,
0.03207964822649956,
-0.44404760003089905,
-0.33147552609443665,
-0.30267396569252014,
-0.5068801045417786,
-0.4191117286682129,
-0.32228538393974304,
0.48537352681159973,
0.5263344049453735,
0.5233597755432129,
0.3568260967731476,
0.731999933719635,
0.32697173953056335,
0.028888801112771034,
0.31197500228881836,
-0.030666256323456764,
0.06097510829567909,
-0.44300857186317444,
-0.2482033371925354,
-0.2603379786014557,
-0.02445363998413086,
0.43270084261894226,
0.48088598251342773,
0.25381800532341003,
0.16915588080883026,
0.01939867064356804,
0.07491109520196915,
-0.7806522846221924,
0.12546223402023315,
-0.6403519511222839,
-0.1678602397441864,
-0.34103649854660034,
-0.37482497096061707,
-0.4066031873226166,
0.22193622589111328,
0.27121901512145996,
-0.6035535335540771,
0.4381694197654724,
0.09580869227647781,
0.8163175582885742,
-0.059684764593839645,
-0.4442392587661743,
-0.6723234057426453,
-0.7126030921936035,
0.8504084348678589,
-0.2754787504673004,
0.32720503211021423,
0.3139636516571045,
0.03901759535074234,
0.36148130893707275,
-0.5695207118988037,
-0.8175560832023621,
0.11626893281936646,
-0.14343251287937164,
0.015013586729764938,
-0.39805588126182556,
0.04901290312409401,
0.21158212423324585,
0.05244642123579979,
-0.4304274916648865,
0.012609473429620266,
-0.441830039024353,
-0.3503241539001465,
0.2668396234512329,
-0.09921086579561234,
0.25842738151550293,
-0.2173692286014557,
-0.43748143315315247,
-0.16522790491580963,
-0.2819008529186249,
-0.08266068249940872,
-0.1268521398305893,
0.20346416532993317,
-0.12814180552959442,
0.4900593161582947,
0.12605926394462585,
0.5736851692199707,
0.5890198945999146,
-0.33910006284713745,
0.21367426216602325,
-0.6298914551734924,
0.2063569873571396,
0.1692420244216919,
0.5671963691711426,
0.805781900882721,
0.12006264925003052,
-0.12789063155651093,
0.07844852656126022,
0.3389682173728943,
-0.10090229660272598,
-0.6273288130760193,
0.020683730021119118,
0.12312551587820053,
-0.385143518447876,
0.2438584417104721,
-0.2090924233198166,
-1.0485165119171143,
-0.32069599628448486,
-0.5449217557907104,
0.4047733247280121,
-0.6007283329963684,
-0.020549803972244263,
-0.3199378550052643,
-0.23862388730049133,
0.34051594138145447,
0.5313969850540161,
-0.48402488231658936,
0.011796923354268074,
0.3605726659297943,
0.5940413475036621,
-0.018993865698575974,
-0.16445006430149078,
-0.296241819858551,
0.14433667063713074,
0.058063406497240067,
1.2254818677902222,
-0.8379096984863281,
-0.6280630826950073,
-0.021980823948979378,
-0.051350392401218414,
-0.10060101747512817,
-0.3791249692440033,
0.8764166235923767,
-0.1539907306432724,
0.1183907687664032,
-0.1164979636669159,
-0.4873104691505432,
-0.18786075711250305,
0.3677123486995697,
-0.5441966652870178,
0.7266930341720581,
-0.5723000168800354,
-0.5439609885215759,
0.3508888781070709,
-0.18956536054611206,
-0.24626776576042175,
0.06126425415277481,
-0.4141289293766022,
0.0039618005976080894,
-0.09373975545167923,
0.5609150528907776,
0.4754967987537384,
-0.34345826506614685,
0.004238871857523918,
-0.3630779981613159,
0.22361871600151062,
0.21986077725887299,
-0.11424794793128967,
0.06833852082490921,
-0.13691793382167816,
-0.1190975159406662,
0.12310709804296494,
-1.0052276849746704,
-0.05218568816781044,
-0.20832479000091553,
0.06247647479176521,
-0.8630501627922058,
-0.06168549507856369,
0.42949509620666504,
0.47655370831489563,
0.44394806027412415,
-0.6792272925376892,
0.08606827259063721,
0.25504687428474426,
0.05651600658893585,
0.5043519735336304,
-0.05717810243368149,
0.6204217076301575,
-0.15498310327529907,
0.15943798422813416,
0.27653831243515015,
0.044258736073970795,
-0.47629550099372864,
-0.7120371460914612,
-0.8678483963012695,
-0.30318212509155273,
0.14910678565502167,
0.4713715612888336,
-0.8357049226760864,
0.3264167308807373,
-0.3640042841434479,
-0.3942531645298004,
-0.476083368062973,
-0.11481817811727524,
0.4598340690135956,
0.49911025166511536,
0.5809687376022339,
-0.33697429299354553,
-0.7010250091552734,
-1.04984450340271,
0.060098111629486084,
-0.13125963509082794,
0.19374462962150574,
0.42549756169319153,
0.575964629650116,
-0.07673315703868866,
0.7357172966003418,
-0.07933729141950607,
-0.5143922567367554,
-0.1636136919260025,
0.714048445224762,
0.06542342901229858,
0.6798840165138245,
0.7092323899269104,
-0.8461941480636597,
-0.28575393557548523,
0.27506959438323975,
-0.2970784604549408,
-0.07954572141170502,
-0.2726023197174072,
-0.016975238919258118,
0.1424632966518402,
0.17707741260528564,
-0.3169923424720764,
0.5355457663536072,
0.7622122168540955,
-0.45566192269325256,
0.44040659070014954,
-0.060175467282533646,
0.5444775223731995,
-1.0343377590179443,
0.08424627780914307,
0.1430983990430832,
-0.4418359100818634,
-0.44496411085128784,
-0.025288065895438194,
0.21030977368354797,
0.03541968762874603,
-0.22805722057819366,
0.4911615550518036,
-0.570508599281311,
0.17497530579566956,
-0.3937430679798126,
0.5251651406288147,
0.10674060881137848,
0.5165770649909973,
0.2717212438583374,
0.40910211205482483,
0.545198380947113,
-0.4591233432292938,
0.5559648871421814,
0.3525383174419403,
-0.18774139881134033,
1.334647297859192,
-0.16031941771507263,
0.30660906434059143,
-0.18723100423812866,
0.3516979515552521,
-0.9995342493057251,
0.1427600234746933,
0.10050541162490845,
-0.27654561400413513,
0.2901332974433899,
-0.07881886512041092,
-0.21890883147716522,
-0.044288862496614456,
-0.04977915808558464,
0.8358927369117737,
0.1521429717540741,
-0.513739287853241,
1.105775237083435,
0.259390264749527,
-0.23304447531700134,
-0.4362677037715912,
-0.7251072525978088,
0.12752731144428253,
0.05362330377101898,
-0.8108436465263367,
0.792963445186615,
-0.0770665854215622,
-0.1470586657524109,
0.20286136865615845,
-0.060816459357738495,
-0.17516399919986725,
-0.6219488978385925,
0.40507447719573975,
0.4600349962711334,
-0.11052416265010834,
0.036169618368148804,
-0.19157983362674713,
-0.1537379026412964,
-0.24266627430915833,
-0.07166352868080139,
0.30861252546310425,
-0.2823665142059326,
-0.5154295563697815,
-0.3480786681175232,
0.7697792649269104,
0.3978515565395355,
-0.2328600138425827,
0.615433394908905,
0.7324057817459106,
-0.6316303014755249,
0.2602086663246155,
-1.0059657096862793,
-0.058545663952827454,
-0.2710762619972229,
0.14701342582702637,
-0.48661524057388306,
-0.565622866153717,
0.8475751876831055,
-0.2539151608943939,
0.12400009483098984,
0.42212140560150146,
0.5947310328483582,
-0.15622197091579437,
0.5808238387107849,
0.4165622293949127,
0.2262153923511505,
0.47119322419166565,
-0.09134779870510101,
-0.03469138592481613,
-1.1232264041900635,
-0.2944544851779938,
-0.804794430732727,
-0.5977281332015991,
-0.05548853799700737,
-0.9138687252998352,
0.26657119393348694,
0.20415514707565308,
0.48529279232025146,
0.4047091603279114,
-0.12957961857318878,
0.4341045916080475,
0.4778495728969574,
0.2643289268016815,
0.5768525004386902,
-0.27758926153182983,
-0.2958679795265198,
-0.3687964975833893,
-0.4497980773448944,
-0.15561378002166748,
0.7772458791732788,
-0.08814041316509247,
0.7318617701530457,
0.03255610913038254,
0.39066633582115173,
0.2463911920785904,
0.306512713432312,
-0.6766064167022705,
0.4885979890823364,
-0.10900038480758667,
-0.507509171962738,
0.12913978099822998,
-0.147919699549675,
-0.750548779964447,
0.41393157839775085,
-0.5499272346496582,
-0.8395853638648987,
0.9349564909934998,
-0.06253435462713242,
-0.17837294936180115,
0.26167240738868713,
-0.5052619576454163,
0.5489996671676636,
-0.043215326964855194,
-0.33307135105133057,
-0.5444146394729614,
-0.5728899836540222,
0.05988917872309685,
-0.04696807637810707,
0.6664026975631714,
-0.18725542724132538,
-0.05688534677028656,
0.7518839836120605,
0.05845539644360542,
0.8467581868171692,
0.3454417884349823,
0.05376819521188736,
0.22665055096149445,
0.03496953099966049,
0.6250779032707214,
-0.25353148579597473,
0.033339183777570724,
0.22716134786605835,
0.09289592504501343,
-0.3721417784690857,
-0.5556692481040955,
0.7794981598854065,
-0.589133620262146,
-0.24741129577159882,
-0.15350879728794098,
-0.4685121774673462,
-0.05470297485589981,
-0.04234037920832634,
0.3640280067920685,
0.833575427532196,
-0.353563129901886,
0.2508819103240967,
0.3722061514854431,
0.0847892314195633,
0.6090264916419983,
0.4325452446937561,
-0.10910500586032867,
-0.4724578261375427,
0.547564685344696,
0.1696220338344574,
0.14350296556949615,
0.45675334334373474,
-0.14385674893856049,
-0.2846243381500244,
-0.37085244059562683,
-0.49187171459198,
0.22369910776615143,
-1.0938827991485596,
-0.3417624533176422,
-0.5617516040802002,
0.1735387146472931,
-0.46593764424324036,
-0.46597155928611755,
-0.37636879086494446,
-0.5007522702217102,
-0.32277509570121765,
0.06337477266788483,
0.26218464970588684,
0.15623147785663605,
-0.35134872794151306,
0.0283562783151865,
-0.8720963597297668,
0.2797245383262634,
-0.02168181911110878,
0.04117041826248169,
-0.3071511387825012,
-0.42878758907318115,
-0.20623259246349335,
-0.23424749076366425,
-0.2605738341808319,
-1.0897077322006226,
0.21627484261989594,
0.6002634763717651,
0.4976997673511505,
0.5407626628875732,
0.17776274681091309,
1.0038681030273438,
-0.3554145395755768,
0.6663346290588379,
0.534237802028656,
-1.0536895990371704,
0.6590124368667603,
0.006120988167822361,
0.28649234771728516,
0.3780028522014618,
0.2279907763004303,
-0.7368040084838867,
-0.42173174023628235,
-0.6660626530647278,
-0.925135612487793,
0.399251252412796,
0.11797963827848434,
-0.20458249747753143,
-0.08571997284889221,
0.1826266348361969,
0.02310466766357422,
-0.16428667306900024,
-0.5635371804237366,
-0.28686559200286865,
0.1276223063468933,
-0.07568138837814331,
-0.08695866167545319,
-0.0689205676317215,
-0.38101592659950256,
-0.09253457188606262,
0.48640522360801697,
-0.30096685886383057,
0.16038306057453156,
0.58563232421875,
-0.4783766269683838,
-0.21043738722801208,
0.6127328872680664,
0.5195901989936829,
0.6519491076469421,
-0.0073472317308187485,
0.5518761277198792,
0.1743014007806778,
-0.3500044047832489,
-0.034750767052173615,
0.3329157531261444,
0.10496586561203003,
0.18654264509677887,
0.6137306094169617,
0.7090263962745667,
0.618583083152771,
-0.7041687369346619,
0.4531080722808838,
0.1038491427898407,
-0.07597244530916214,
-0.09532260149717331,
-0.47323688864707947,
-0.15123195946216583,
0.5199162364006042,
0.5842260122299194,
0.34783414006233215,
0.17031964659690857,
-0.46572479605674744,
0.37866929173469543,
0.3080008327960968,
-0.41377565264701843,
-0.3840220868587494,
0.2300940901041031,
0.6207033395767212,
0.09865057468414307,
0.30693578720092773,
0.07265232503414154,
-0.4325776696205139,
0.4667198359966278,
0.42243528366088867,
0.5291091799736023,
-0.14204101264476776,
0.09791487455368042,
0.5455567240715027,
0.4511251151561737,
0.32204940915107727,
0.016363583505153656,
-0.1648433357477188,
-1.0370534658432007,
-0.5170062184333801,
-0.443498820066452,
-0.494373619556427,
-0.15021969377994537,
-0.7552281022071838,
0.1700790524482727,
-0.2746942937374115,
-0.4554523229598999,
0.16230326890945435,
-0.20793256163597107,
-0.865916907787323,
0.022882672026753426,
0.6676024198532104,
0.6445606350898743,
-0.5801358819007874,
0.6485264897346497,
0.8870680928230286,
-0.3208145201206207,
-0.3103800117969513,
-0.35117772221565247,
0.10694271326065063,
-0.49299198389053345,
0.4453570544719696,
-0.0570618100464344,
-0.11214660853147507,
-0.1211547702550888,
-0.19540219008922577,
-0.6550091505050659,
0.9236092567443848,
0.11804492771625519,
-0.8128528594970703,
0.023288831114768982,
-0.02050691656768322,
0.22433118522167206,
-0.563235342502594,
0.4941549599170685,
0.3241102695465088,
0.6478990316390991,
0.233194962143898,
-1.2724761962890625,
0.15472738444805145,
-0.17975324392318726,
-0.027966512367129326,
0.2676275074481964,
-0.4009455442428589,
0.6529895663261414,
-0.15668509900569916,
-0.5367916822433472,
0.02555929310619831,
0.8319826722145081,
-0.00921672210097313,
0.34828823804855347,
0.5963854193687439,
0.6569784283638,
0.5889372825622559,
-0.22908656299114227,
0.7536402344703674,
-0.3785244822502136,
0.47265228629112244,
1.1412608623504639,
-0.33253413438796997,
0.875227153301239,
0.8600836992263794,
0.08695770800113678,
0.47963589429855347,
0.3913680911064148,
0.12363032251596451,
0.30692893266677856,
-0.32956305146217346,
-0.46459126472473145,
-0.5795539617538452,
-0.4645457863807678,
-0.47476255893707275,
0.23543940484523773,
0.7062215209007263,
-0.40878549218177795,
-0.7180032730102539,
0.4983231723308563,
-0.23928995430469513,
0.19572338461875916,
-0.46809080243110657,
0.6947636604309082,
-0.09083352982997894,
-0.4691304862499237,
0.18343998491764069,
0.02228926122188568,
0.836773157119751,
-0.45574989914894104,
-0.06021026149392128,
0.12388740479946136,
0.3372332751750946,
-0.03519001603126526,
-0.8259360790252686,
0.3819086253643036,
-0.096841961145401,
-0.31651565432548523,
-0.14879553020000458,
0.9309306144714355,
-0.6445066928863525,
-0.6085888743400574,
0.5693875551223755,
0.4186348021030426,
0.03249185532331467,
0.03166256099939346,
-0.5551729202270508,
0.11727770417928696,
-0.25056523084640503,
0.006415070965886116,
0.28530123829841614,
0.5361056327819824,
0.015443806536495686,
0.3027941882610321,
0.5461342930793762,
-0.04152349755167961,
0.3384557068347931,
0.01571418158710003,
0.7748624682426453,
-0.5171650052070618,
-0.23533901572227478,
-0.4859828054904938,
0.32568857073783875,
-0.023534327745437622,
-0.6019600033760071,
0.35836103558540344,
0.3806314766407013,
0.7761698365211487,
0.042521871626377106,
0.6607797145843506,
-0.3830094635486603,
0.23460790514945984,
-0.4933316707611084,
0.025783032178878784,
-0.40687596797943115,
-0.16175399720668793,
-0.3341284990310669,
-0.5818600654602051,
-0.36778342723846436,
0.5035505890846252,
-0.3206612765789032,
-0.32394126057624817,
0.7452490925788879,
0.6713733673095703,
-0.13844238221645355,
0.09064097702503204,
0.4217534363269806,
0.09868768602609634,
0.10102518647909164,
0.7149567008018494,
0.8192373514175415,
-0.41760924458503723,
0.7692705988883972,
-0.3817468583583832,
-0.43356114625930786,
-0.2809295058250427,
-0.8611964583396912,
-0.6301762461662292,
-1.079326868057251,
-0.558300793170929,
-0.40436676144599915,
0.07904136925935745,
1.1438754796981812,
0.6924721002578735,
-0.752120852470398,
0.08414328843355179,
0.5635743141174316,
-0.05555072799324989,
-0.33068424463272095,
-0.16802214086055756,
0.1914585679769516,
-0.16662615537643433,
-0.9836940169334412,
0.17120042443275452,
0.24875536561012268,
-0.07810190320014954,
-0.19530583918094635,
0.20443463325500488,
-0.5487810373306274,
0.06557323783636093,
0.5867693424224854,
0.06287457793951035,
-0.7989635467529297,
-0.5327609181404114,
-0.3436969816684723,
-0.19694875180721283,
0.10963407903909683,
1.1328626871109009,
-0.6088370084762573,
0.45917755365371704,
0.5616980791091919,
0.5498223900794983,
0.6151792407035828,
-0.13831952214241028,
0.4154379665851593,
-0.8372186422348022,
0.47976648807525635,
0.16280896961688995,
0.7017590999603271,
0.23179762065410614,
-0.27211272716522217,
0.17903806269168854,
0.4479318857192993,
-0.35077399015426636,
-0.33062320947647095,
0.2086050808429718,
-1.5988490581512451,
-0.19835428893566132,
0.9938840270042419,
-0.1751585304737091,
-0.2044147551059723,
-0.35671913623809814,
-0.37115249037742615,
0.023035230115056038,
-0.49759000539779663,
0.46321722865104675,
1.0399816036224365,
-0.2608219385147095,
-0.645520031452179,
0.0009909269865602255,
-0.09045987576246262,
0.12762410938739777,
-0.609492301940918,
-0.26477891206741333,
0.7069196701049805,
-0.041721079498529434,
0.8919417262077332,
0.4651753902435303,
-0.13289988040924072,
0.30945318937301636,
0.10743078589439392,
0.5293009877204895,
0.2132124900817871,
-0.3319412171840668,
-0.0022530679125338793,
0.3740782141685486,
-0.46153709292411804,
-0.11355000734329224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08940v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08940v1
|
Introducing Super RAGs in Mistral 8x7B-v1
| 2024-04-13T09:33:00 | 2024-04-13T09:33:00 |
Ayush Thakur, Raghav Gupta
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The relentless pursuit of enhancing Large Language Models (LLMs) has led to
the advent of Super Retrieval-Augmented Generation (Super RAGs), a novel
approach designed to elevate the performance of LLMs by integrating external
knowledge sources with minimal structural modifications. This paper presents
the integration of Super RAGs into the Mistral 8x7B v1, a state-of-the-art LLM,
and examines the resultant improvements in accuracy, speed, and user
satisfaction. Our methodology uses a fine-tuned instruct model setup and a
cache tuning fork system, ensuring efficient and relevant data retrieval. The
evaluation, conducted over several epochs, demonstrates significant
enhancements across all metrics. The findings suggest that Super RAGs can
effectively augment LLMs, paving the way for more sophisticated and reliable AI
systems. This research contributes to the field by providing empirical evidence
of the benefits of Super RAGs and offering insights into their potential
applications.
|
[
-0.3341248035430908,
-0.3234539330005646,
0.4656159281730652,
-0.0013783934991806746,
-0.3017409145832062,
0.2770777642726898,
-0.07410524040460587,
-0.8047270774841309,
0.2689916789531708,
0.5735844373703003,
-0.05348200723528862,
-0.10672934353351593,
-0.565866231918335,
-0.14489369094371796,
-0.871425211429596,
1.0531927347183228,
0.3227153420448303,
0.020241903141140938,
-0.14848071336746216,
-0.1597498506307602,
-0.3412041962146759,
-0.750256359577179,
-0.5186908841133118,
-0.12693464756011963,
0.4363349378108978,
0.3446751832962036,
0.9467577934265137,
0.7457832098007202,
0.49962377548217773,
0.4044204652309418,
-0.3519359529018402,
0.7340831160545349,
-0.7808659672737122,
0.3420863449573517,
-0.3197268545627594,
-0.7262183427810669,
-0.6008812189102173,
-0.3194291889667511,
0.40481680631637573,
-0.03734062612056732,
-0.19019459187984467,
0.2636546790599823,
0.1520937979221344,
0.6713818311691284,
-0.8517851233482361,
0.052515123039484024,
-0.5360966920852661,
-0.4547535479068756,
-0.5303407311439514,
-0.20614908635616302,
-0.21443091332912445,
-0.28538447618484497,
-0.12299533933401108,
-0.613976001739502,
0.32032516598701477,
-0.14313937723636627,
0.7433130741119385,
0.2894665598869324,
0.16524867713451385,
-0.48325714468955994,
-0.7481697201728821,
0.5483794808387756,
-0.836321234703064,
0.62131667137146,
0.07700617611408234,
0.343537837266922,
-0.14471638202667236,
-0.9475371241569519,
-0.7669652104377747,
-0.2326047718524933,
0.020203856751322746,
0.12319759279489517,
-0.0428641103208065,
-0.1704854518175125,
-0.10915371775627136,
0.4346858561038971,
-0.1856827288866043,
0.1626579314470291,
-0.44320622086524963,
0.00944364070892334,
0.6131060123443604,
0.5186522603034973,
0.30735206604003906,
-0.0773165374994278,
-0.40480107069015503,
0.15820850431919098,
-0.7015333771705627,
-0.19987691938877106,
0.07372920960187912,
0.37134039402008057,
0.021805932745337486,
0.10675360262393951,
-0.010346806608140469,
0.6391084790229797,
0.08081454038619995,
-0.23775696754455566,
-0.010272466577589512,
-0.39876481890678406,
0.016863392665982246,
0.06652557104825974,
0.3975573182106018,
0.2738364338874817,
0.2104787677526474,
-0.2636346220970154,
-0.5138071179389954,
-0.012624143622815609,
0.2944386899471283,
-0.5449431538581848,
0.03857022151350975,
-0.040713049471378326,
-0.19543960690498352,
-0.3909602761268616,
0.182762011885643,
-0.4054107964038849,
-0.9583519697189331,
-0.6180717349052429,
0.3209798336029053,
-0.5649892687797546,
-0.44347384572029114,
0.11887646466493607,
-0.3524627685546875,
0.3780764937400818,
0.5814964175224304,
-0.7754220962524414,
0.32016149163246155,
0.9883430600166321,
0.694596529006958,
0.07306095957756042,
-0.11718356609344482,
-0.39005041122436523,
0.28720176219940186,
-0.8629941940307617,
1.040921688079834,
-0.6035194993019104,
-0.41852685809135437,
0.025615859776735306,
-0.4831061065196991,
0.3326674699783325,
-0.9571157097816467,
0.583111047744751,
-0.8039875030517578,
-0.2475150227546692,
-0.31054845452308655,
-0.5013453960418701,
-0.07927778363227844,
-0.08708219230175018,
-0.5044751763343811,
1.3831616640090942,
0.48291894793510437,
-0.6921557188034058,
0.24425682425498962,
-0.21921728551387787,
-0.13856902718544006,
0.4921684265136719,
-0.11853507161140442,
-0.03585926443338394,
0.5473816394805908,
0.12427955865859985,
0.37449678778648376,
-0.6790144443511963,
0.11648918688297272,
-0.14795809984207153,
-0.7581849694252014,
0.2348054200410843,
-0.3871878683567047,
0.6073192358016968,
0.1548101305961609,
-0.29226160049438477,
-0.16602690517902374,
-0.6677719950675964,
-0.07314731925725937,
-0.13640256226062775,
-0.36358246207237244,
-0.5760096311569214,
-0.19682617485523224,
0.3052748739719391,
-0.07511094957590103,
0.44150835275650024,
-0.24128979444503784,
0.14480149745941162,
-0.4527154266834259,
0.08373001962900162,
1.0834790468215942,
-0.317958801984787,
0.33071473240852356,
-0.3853878378868103,
0.47633305191993713,
-0.2195405811071396,
0.2599434554576874,
-0.3079116642475128,
0.06742193549871445,
-1.1369267702102661,
-0.41423311829566956,
0.5331614017486572,
0.4669516980648041,
-0.8811424374580383,
0.13638775050640106,
-0.259091854095459,
-0.7505577802658081,
-0.7074107527732849,
0.33067405223846436,
0.5564347505569458,
0.3514411747455597,
0.5270624160766602,
0.015543656423687935,
-0.6633279919624329,
-0.7101283073425293,
-0.24173493683338165,
0.0019640757236629725,
0.23998390138149261,
0.3642995357513428,
-0.05885634571313858,
-0.33705127239227295,
0.8708295226097107,
-0.24703733623027802,
-0.18687622249126434,
-0.642987072467804,
-0.3110644221305847,
0.381192684173584,
0.3176635503768921,
0.5898410081863403,
-0.7803966403007507,
-0.6637768745422363,
0.21700797975063324,
-0.7073561549186707,
-0.29027867317199707,
0.1001279354095459,
-0.16517683863639832,
0.3952139616012573,
0.7449210286140442,
-0.4710758328437805,
0.49925702810287476,
0.4151972532272339,
-0.0819561630487442,
0.8783393502235413,
-0.39813482761383057,
0.2114216834306717,
-0.9349045157432556,
-0.191339910030365,
0.029138406738638878,
-0.3061484098434448,
-0.6276854872703552,
0.3679732382297516,
0.39848142862319946,
0.3776126503944397,
-0.4124543070793152,
0.5723665356636047,
-0.5074220895767212,
0.034359291195869446,
-0.6052676439285278,
0.04036999121308327,
-0.14187441766262054,
-0.036808256059885025,
-0.47181734442710876,
1.1734589338302612,
0.4866313338279724,
-0.8057439923286438,
0.28565549850463867,
-0.08123748749494553,
-0.26813215017318726,
0.5509880781173706,
-0.6966249346733093,
0.30034518241882324,
-0.45413514971733093,
0.23948733508586884,
-0.791978120803833,
-0.04607560858130455,
-0.08706505596637726,
-0.4504193961620331,
0.5942540764808655,
-0.06789242476224899,
-0.4849795401096344,
0.029365193098783493,
-0.3032868802547455,
0.16319335997104645,
0.5103421211242676,
-0.8161304593086243,
0.5112931132316589,
0.670989990234375,
-0.23325215280056,
-0.5829306840896606,
-0.3139009177684784,
0.3332478702068329,
-0.20922884345054626,
-0.3221096396446228,
0.45339536666870117,
0.012507512234151363,
-0.32083526253700256,
-0.08165746927261353,
-0.44629284739494324,
0.14995212852954865,
-0.05144033208489418,
0.05810186266899109,
0.5556115508079529,
-0.46298331022262573,
-0.11165423691272736,
0.0700199231505394,
-0.4480380117893219,
-0.42246851325035095,
-0.3873220682144165,
0.529679000377655,
0.025869866833090782,
0.14915011823177338,
-0.3005305826663971,
0.06624773889780045,
0.6617090106010437,
-0.32132506370544434,
0.6307974457740784,
0.38641825318336487,
-0.2589814364910126,
-0.5107074975967407,
-0.8983574509620667,
0.271501749753952,
-0.5705602765083313,
0.32047373056411743,
-0.3156168460845947,
-0.8489202260971069,
0.25899380445480347,
-0.03314055874943733,
0.0684971883893013,
0.27993977069854736,
0.33593451976776123,
-0.13076168298721313,
0.8424596786499023,
0.771904468536377,
-0.27820780873298645,
0.6612153649330139,
-0.4180752635002136,
0.015128402039408684,
-0.9986236691474915,
-0.14115093648433685,
-0.7376924157142639,
-0.12318562716245651,
-0.4756680727005005,
-0.7845383286476135,
0.6943973302841187,
0.36688467860221863,
-0.25356316566467285,
0.30950650572776794,
-0.32773134112358093,
0.7205328345298767,
0.5450858473777771,
0.23463404178619385,
0.29144126176834106,
-0.27280181646347046,
0.22206518054008484,
0.08011052012443542,
-0.8280485272407532,
-0.5238698720932007,
1.0528502464294434,
0.10830365866422653,
1.0324739217758179,
0.23628586530685425,
0.759769082069397,
0.5100796222686768,
0.6845161318778992,
-0.3750222325325012,
0.5673040747642517,
-0.6385864615440369,
-0.38030296564102173,
-0.20892930030822754,
-0.10400934517383575,
-0.7648013830184937,
0.36996880173683167,
-0.18041671812534332,
-0.5839540958404541,
0.16600282490253448,
0.3098222017288208,
-0.49647057056427,
0.05967222526669502,
-0.5903307795524597,
0.24938680231571198,
-0.2681906223297119,
-0.5855011343955994,
-0.23782029747962952,
-0.22920240461826324,
0.32275867462158203,
0.007907399907708168,
0.3790743947029114,
0.2227468192577362,
-0.3479035198688507,
0.6366101503372192,
-0.3409518003463745,
0.5795243978500366,
-0.03255235031247139,
-0.20153982937335968,
0.36391663551330566,
0.11675453931093216,
0.5071635246276855,
0.024364182725548744,
-0.17315757274627686,
0.2841099798679352,
-0.27280884981155396,
-0.18206195533275604,
-0.8717900514602661,
1.0091087818145752,
-0.7368830442428589,
-0.8304494619369507,
-0.24289025366306305,
-0.6718168258666992,
-0.2747417390346527,
0.06522071361541748,
-0.11760345101356506,
0.9545736908912659,
0.24966353178024292,
0.2173204869031906,
0.9382724761962891,
-0.25878217816352844,
0.294570654630661,
0.6207326650619507,
-0.4424211084842682,
-0.48876363039016724,
1.0900366306304932,
0.577716052532196,
0.20786742866039276,
0.3553013503551483,
0.4111565053462982,
-0.4995771646499634,
-0.660030722618103,
-0.6272528171539307,
0.23350739479064941,
-0.5985520482063293,
-0.5063539743423462,
-0.5753222703933716,
-0.26494282484054565,
-0.7925020456314087,
-0.2525251507759094,
-0.40655258297920227,
-0.3828854262828827,
-0.09041354060173035,
-0.12257710099220276,
0.36487963795661926,
1.1943087577819824,
-0.2396881878376007,
0.3317817151546478,
-1.0578668117523193,
0.4569103419780731,
0.0823989063501358,
0.35543879866600037,
0.08543212711811066,
-0.9390204548835754,
-0.7339650392532349,
-0.30127671360969543,
-0.13805823028087616,
-0.7234305739402771,
0.27552565932273865,
-0.07726232707500458,
0.7969801425933838,
0.3803219497203827,
-0.1472785770893097,
0.9714493155479431,
-0.47355395555496216,
0.552157998085022,
-0.0021607610397040844,
-0.7964766621589661,
0.13658633828163147,
-0.36753398180007935,
0.06771893799304962,
0.35362106561660767,
0.2609120309352875,
-0.45143961906433105,
-0.5188151597976685,
-0.6987075209617615,
-0.9787657260894775,
0.6946088671684265,
-0.2682574391365051,
0.3457939922809601,
0.16256439685821533,
0.5131719708442688,
0.24217219650745392,
0.0640118196606636,
0.07581156492233276,
-0.49229300022125244,
0.12657767534255981,
-0.1856555938720703,
-0.36592140793800354,
-0.43628618121147156,
0.38319242000579834,
-0.1187128871679306,
0.8035280704498291,
0.12919458746910095,
-0.23918095231056213,
0.1496555060148239,
-0.1603851169347763,
0.142385795712471,
-0.06398502737283707,
0.3589886724948883,
0.8539511561393738,
0.21500498056411743,
0.10868435353040695,
0.21948124468326569,
-0.5679275393486023,
-0.024609554558992386,
0.08686008304357529,
-0.23890841007232666,
0.08270525932312012,
0.45528706908226013,
0.4505060315132141,
0.41806328296661377,
-0.5816516876220703,
0.15079471468925476,
0.24505959451198578,
0.3523677885532379,
-0.08976875990629196,
0.5313634872436523,
0.13658961653709412,
0.5512973070144653,
0.6122010350227356,
0.021653804928064346,
0.3590593636035919,
-0.41940030455589294,
0.23396331071853638,
0.35781383514404297,
-0.32225629687309265,
-0.11031706631183624,
0.5429375171661377,
0.15417852997779846,
-0.6039335131645203,
0.24558527767658234,
0.07461664825677872,
-0.7327544689178467,
0.41985204815864563,
0.7076520323753357,
0.5791471600532532,
-0.43381115794181824,
-0.004255177453160286,
0.12961971759796143,
0.43137428164482117,
-0.053596675395965576,
0.26072943210601807,
-0.12711669504642487,
-0.5866897106170654,
-0.4220489263534546,
-0.7383027076721191,
-0.41836926341056824,
0.06108707934617996,
-0.4934173822402954,
0.3063698709011078,
-0.30628079175949097,
0.0774124413728714,
-0.2018704116344452,
-0.22084881365299225,
-0.575872540473938,
0.16183513402938843,
0.2779851257801056,
1.2661607265472412,
-0.5434646606445312,
0.5715857744216919,
0.6393090486526489,
-0.35451921820640564,
-0.8729671835899353,
0.04876251146197319,
-0.14371991157531738,
-0.922537088394165,
0.4412878453731537,
-0.08499155193567276,
-0.2600591778755188,
0.06616033613681793,
-0.6469877362251282,
-1.046456217765808,
0.8744679689407349,
0.6261569261550903,
-0.5610950589179993,
0.07024151086807251,
0.08943087607622147,
0.5833456516265869,
0.06815840303897858,
0.5258409380912781,
0.7831140756607056,
0.23005381226539612,
-0.1348872035741806,
-1.0372952222824097,
-0.21878068149089813,
-0.23712672293186188,
0.2999139130115509,
0.35918429493904114,
-0.8439820408821106,
0.8051257133483887,
-0.23099276423454285,
-0.049483440816402435,
0.05018351227045059,
1.0860742330551147,
0.46803170442581177,
0.18233320116996765,
0.4110032916069031,
0.5937532782554626,
0.6601198315620422,
0.24188396334648132,
1.1298415660858154,
-0.47177812457084656,
0.18591302633285522,
1.1124309301376343,
0.01189358625560999,
0.7583691477775574,
0.37246233224868774,
-0.30083391070365906,
0.4891723096370697,
0.07299084961414337,
0.7986329793930054,
0.1809471845626831,
0.2369677871465683,
-0.4536835551261902,
-0.25483396649360657,
-0.3574243187904358,
-0.6066303253173828,
0.31645941734313965,
0.6245004534721375,
-0.06792779266834259,
-0.25855523347854614,
-0.18877571821212769,
0.17684094607830048,
0.20515364408493042,
-0.5832913517951965,
0.7422283887863159,
0.05526476725935936,
-0.5218096375465393,
0.5232516527175903,
-0.10178566724061966,
0.8714898228645325,
-0.6268059611320496,
-0.3939933776855469,
-0.6989087462425232,
0.3959774672985077,
-0.2831781208515167,
-0.5700085759162903,
-0.04873047396540642,
0.2547186315059662,
-0.07957980036735535,
-0.13521915674209595,
0.9885495901107788,
-0.11990325152873993,
-0.5505069494247437,
0.11958416551351547,
0.5244962573051453,
0.06422474980354309,
0.06012428551912308,
-0.5010404586791992,
0.4645023047924042,
-0.3445052206516266,
-0.1564478725194931,
0.41744089126586914,
0.6823992729187012,
-0.010088370181620121,
0.5477568507194519,
0.7736644148826599,
0.2788514494895935,
0.16966332495212555,
0.05190993845462799,
1.1528409719467163,
-0.6104392409324646,
-0.5473304986953735,
-0.7874234914779663,
0.5789080858230591,
0.03597935661673546,
-0.2784285843372345,
0.8698506951332092,
0.766083300113678,
0.8728697299957275,
0.2740704417228699,
1.0802884101867676,
-0.05842084810137749,
0.7341567873954773,
-0.3965383768081665,
0.5836500525474548,
-0.4916192293167114,
0.36314648389816284,
-0.3648391664028168,
-0.6506844758987427,
0.06525372713804245,
0.3571639358997345,
0.03628252074122429,
0.03871704265475273,
0.279567688703537,
1.1313656568527222,
-0.12396770715713501,
-0.0384320393204689,
0.44520047307014465,
0.3033120036125183,
0.31959813833236694,
0.15396647155284882,
1.0054731369018555,
-0.4351043403148651,
0.5367443561553955,
-0.16896706819534302,
-0.510534405708313,
-0.17779812216758728,
-0.5116416215896606,
-0.27878305315971375,
-0.4491112530231476,
0.16404274106025696,
-0.5160737633705139,
0.4708877503871918,
0.7071806192398071,
0.5641099214553833,
-0.6609722375869751,
-0.33549046516418457,
0.16156522929668427,
0.05700736120343208,
-0.1138092428445816,
-0.20316161215305328,
0.22124813497066498,
-0.6696878671646118,
-0.8873701095581055,
0.5876052975654602,
0.5604516863822937,
-0.2702174186706543,
-0.5203313827514648,
-0.18313272297382355,
0.05089494585990906,
0.34103021025657654,
0.5445936322212219,
-0.04940378665924072,
-0.39424431324005127,
-0.16072359681129456,
0.18955098092556,
-0.2182888239622116,
-0.2289857417345047,
0.9114311337471008,
-1.0028613805770874,
0.2342778593301773,
0.5203496813774109,
0.9283015727996826,
0.3232710063457489,
0.07656679302453995,
0.42045074701309204,
-0.08574683964252472,
-0.15686647593975067,
0.05457345396280289,
0.26066917181015015,
0.21050973236560822,
-0.3823220133781433,
0.41403746604919434,
0.20984195172786713,
-0.5063189268112183,
-1.0114622116088867,
-0.2042156606912613,
-0.4636697769165039,
-0.14798445999622345,
1.1410317420959473,
0.04090597480535507,
-0.2419523447751999,
-0.35287272930145264,
-0.5447896718978882,
0.12812644243240356,
-0.25245267152786255,
0.8569618463516235,
0.3187403976917267,
-0.22231817245483398,
0.07165965437889099,
-0.5829126238822937,
0.3421778976917267,
0.27505338191986084,
-0.7403687834739685,
0.16592486202716827,
0.4841878116130829,
0.07058114558458328,
0.12982945144176483,
0.9060018658638,
-0.04905937984585762,
0.5149577856063843,
0.04426240548491478,
-0.17174403369426727,
-0.18768446147441864,
-0.6042258143424988,
-0.1259605586528778,
0.2299436628818512,
0.044381335377693176,
0.02014082483947277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08938v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08938v1
|
Enforcing Paraphrase Generation via Controllable Latent Diffusion
| 2024-04-13T09:24:32 | 2024-04-13T09:24:32 |
Wei Zou, Ziyuan Zhuang, Shujian Huang, Jia Liu, Jiajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Paraphrase generation aims to produce high-quality and diverse utterances of
a given text. Though state-of-the-art generation via the diffusion model
reconciles generation quality and diversity, textual diffusion suffers from a
truncation issue that hinders efficiency and quality control. In this work, we
propose \textit{L}atent \textit{D}iffusion \textit{P}araphraser~(LDP), a novel
paraphrase generation by modeling a controllable diffusion process given a
learned latent space. LDP achieves superior generation efficiency compared to
its diffusion counterparts. It facilitates only input segments to enforce
paraphrase semantics, which further improves the results without external
features. Experiments show that LDP achieves improved and diverse paraphrase
generation compared to baselines. Further analysis shows that our method is
also helpful to other similar text generations and domain adaptations. Our code
and data are available at https://github.com/NIL-zhuang/ld4pg.
|
[
-0.04446600750088692,
-0.7512410879135132,
0.5607745051383972,
0.5412664413452148,
-0.4339975416660309,
0.19019468128681183,
0.20082774758338928,
-0.023562969639897346,
0.04175518825650215,
0.8044325709342957,
-0.09350398182868958,
-0.35251545906066895,
-0.6222141981124878,
0.0646551176905632,
-0.46994030475616455,
1.0605655908584595,
-0.2605660557746887,
-0.28339794278144836,
-0.004160828422755003,
-0.18057164549827576,
0.09433846920728683,
-0.2234407216310501,
-0.7183070182800293,
-0.2827158570289612,
0.39291417598724365,
0.2398010492324829,
0.8560508489608765,
0.4554753005504608,
0.2653093636035919,
0.20208950340747833,
-0.5466687679290771,
0.14943242073059082,
-0.28757596015930176,
0.17324447631835938,
-0.28904107213020325,
-0.054704371839761734,
-0.5694868564605713,
-0.15820297598838806,
1.0406080484390259,
0.7239179015159607,
-0.36960840225219727,
-0.3884330093860626,
0.6368157267570496,
0.4808378517627716,
-0.754774808883667,
-0.17092525959014893,
-0.6664745807647705,
0.14707987010478973,
-0.17250597476959229,
-0.3934985101222992,
-0.34985479712486267,
-0.6140202879905701,
-0.03306502848863602,
-0.4459300935268402,
0.21889309585094452,
-0.2780001759529114,
0.7553569674491882,
0.2633224129676819,
-0.3630788028240204,
-0.3712269365787506,
-0.5011869668960571,
0.5859503746032715,
-0.7510824799537659,
0.16197888553142548,
0.31609225273132324,
0.09323985874652863,
-0.12081777304410934,
-1.0258510112762451,
-0.6795072555541992,
-0.06102024018764496,
0.12324979901313782,
0.004897591657936573,
-0.26688072085380554,
-0.04024864360690117,
-0.1823640912771225,
0.39955219626426697,
-0.4507099390029907,
-0.13417290151119232,
-0.30985739827156067,
-0.06592288613319397,
0.17369219660758972,
0.050273213535547256,
0.21880723536014557,
-0.36189496517181396,
-0.3811812698841095,
-0.02056514099240303,
-0.5601691007614136,
-0.11037242412567139,
0.23730655014514923,
-0.21740272641181946,
0.03158167749643326,
0.5052694082260132,
-0.2626820206642151,
0.49588799476623535,
0.25959083437919617,
0.025057632476091385,
0.18530818819999695,
-0.3339281976222992,
-0.00753606716170907,
-0.217000812292099,
0.7630948424339294,
0.509229302406311,
-0.06565719097852707,
-0.1799357682466507,
-0.2944847047328949,
-0.30682533979415894,
0.02922118455171585,
-0.78419429063797,
-0.5975538492202759,
0.04377925768494606,
-0.30953559279441833,
-0.3518497049808502,
-0.21877308189868927,
-1.1421703100204468,
-0.2542673349380493,
0.17680217325687408,
0.3293789327144623,
-0.6243734359741211,
-0.16526003181934357,
-0.001183491782285273,
-0.4446275234222412,
0.04063360020518303,
0.14439760148525238,
-0.7160259485244751,
0.2636035680770874,
0.5271764993667603,
1.222024917602539,
-0.701937735080719,
-0.4833570718765259,
-0.7183393239974976,
0.5598822236061096,
-0.28263720870018005,
0.7828304171562195,
-0.597427248954773,
-0.42662015557289124,
-0.20467768609523773,
-0.3678719103336334,
-0.0028196407947689295,
-0.7680275440216064,
0.5242997407913208,
-0.8002411127090454,
0.28833115100860596,
0.10323527455329895,
-0.6936438083648682,
0.21024908125400543,
-0.15156424045562744,
-0.517135739326477,
0.5833145380020142,
0.11455793678760529,
-0.8671566247940063,
0.4370698034763336,
-0.5317180156707764,
-0.34009766578674316,
0.2648681700229645,
-0.19757980108261108,
-0.6300393342971802,
0.00006843305891379714,
0.31022584438323975,
0.35376298427581787,
0.004061092156916857,
0.3632965385913849,
-0.3336402475833893,
0.18439273536205292,
0.24312317371368408,
-0.5169894695281982,
0.7410663366317749,
0.5643685460090637,
-0.20628683269023895,
0.04527514800429344,
-0.6478561162948608,
0.02546040713787079,
-0.004343219567090273,
-0.566024661064148,
-0.2755621671676636,
0.0000394952658098191,
0.11383538693189621,
0.1697338968515396,
0.3586554527282715,
-0.4561993479728699,
-0.016080621629953384,
-0.2993195950984955,
0.5666030645370483,
0.8955388069152832,
0.6797118782997131,
0.8798951506614685,
-0.46544766426086426,
0.7541071176528931,
0.09238336235284805,
0.08636508882045746,
0.35654550790786743,
-0.37894079089164734,
-0.24214640259742737,
-0.37991079688072205,
0.1509644240140915,
0.4572223126888275,
-1.2423228025436401,
0.5463436245918274,
-0.09814812242984772,
-0.3503298759460449,
-0.08370255678892136,
0.3308566212654114,
0.19220545887947083,
0.7026106119155884,
0.42118972539901733,
-0.002413924317806959,
-0.050985220819711685,
-0.6372494697570801,
-0.07556995004415512,
0.12008660286664963,
-0.15420709550380707,
0.012694699689745903,
0.22558103501796722,
0.1557542383670807,
0.8300083875656128,
-0.6609034538269043,
0.04642054811120033,
-0.5799673795700073,
0.05609545484185219,
0.07891958951950073,
0.7902963161468506,
0.5960208177566528,
-1.0005826950073242,
-0.5862039923667908,
-0.31524786353111267,
-0.7422621846199036,
-0.5344526767730713,
-0.3738858997821808,
-0.5769607424736023,
-0.24324405193328857,
0.6955369114875793,
-0.6060178875923157,
0.23160187900066376,
0.5323818325996399,
-0.520623505115509,
0.3660355508327484,
-0.5210608243942261,
0.14098502695560455,
-1.2966653108596802,
0.0944221168756485,
-0.25497400760650635,
-0.19132229685783386,
-0.3132585883140564,
0.252587229013443,
0.08778644353151321,
-0.26005303859710693,
-0.6024371385574341,
0.48168954253196716,
-0.29700037837028503,
0.3115878105163574,
-0.6652786731719971,
0.09015524387359619,
0.17803657054901123,
0.22177278995513916,
0.15170401334762573,
0.8806082606315613,
0.5579469203948975,
-0.9652208089828491,
-0.056571684777736664,
0.49854788184165955,
-0.19414563477039337,
0.6641462445259094,
-0.7931801676750183,
-0.17987483739852905,
-0.008440135046839714,
0.5197123289108276,
-0.6586809754371643,
-0.09158170223236084,
0.3226100206375122,
-0.22422337532043457,
-0.0025934388395398855,
0.1110147088766098,
-0.5507738590240479,
0.08384082466363907,
-0.32167741656303406,
0.2771056592464447,
0.8487764596939087,
-0.6043651700019836,
0.19780857861042023,
0.23986859619617462,
-0.3775484263896942,
-0.29056742787361145,
-0.374767541885376,
0.31860974431037903,
-0.5863738059997559,
-0.45352691411972046,
0.431918740272522,
-0.4606446325778961,
-0.09677475690841675,
-0.18695437908172607,
-0.16135382652282715,
-0.48252421617507935,
0.08522100746631622,
-0.32999807596206665,
-0.1445462852716446,
-0.03471031412482262,
-0.2446310669183731,
0.8490407466888428,
-0.04979393631219864,
-0.14070816338062286,
-0.4477144479751587,
0.4053974151611328,
0.5842939019203186,
0.0336613766849041,
-0.4427194893360138,
0.5601615905761719,
0.6109435558319092,
-0.1769895851612091,
0.8067342042922974,
0.2440510243177414,
-0.01704775169491768,
-0.6093847155570984,
0.12152957171201706,
-0.10574411600828171,
-0.5606094002723694,
0.12332247942686081,
-0.43955475091934204,
-0.6666998863220215,
0.2330443561077118,
-0.17021435499191284,
0.20220211148262024,
0.2867527902126312,
0.4719921052455902,
0.004787195008248091,
0.5926687717437744,
0.4551936686038971,
0.42217957973480225,
0.5936716794967651,
-0.09352085739374161,
-0.17731915414333344,
-0.8680447936058044,
0.15680092573165894,
-0.35907816886901855,
-0.32518720626831055,
-0.3333408534526825,
-0.6842042803764343,
0.4593108594417572,
0.652999222278595,
0.24446231126785278,
0.2849701941013336,
-0.46527400612831116,
0.5519071817398071,
0.6022315621376038,
0.2966955900192261,
0.2639247477054596,
0.0666055828332901,
-0.2109263688325882,
-0.1876225620508194,
-0.7620643377304077,
-0.65120929479599,
0.8418721556663513,
0.02722231298685074,
0.7524142861366272,
0.3093830943107605,
1.1535518169403076,
0.6519209146499634,
-0.22260265052318573,
0.07674544304609299,
0.7580968141555786,
-0.3279724717140198,
-0.3063642680644989,
-0.15373173356056213,
-0.5698028802871704,
-1.030861735343933,
0.40818357467651367,
0.14583627879619598,
-0.5156398415565491,
0.270429402589798,
0.36578238010406494,
-0.19888576865196228,
0.4199695289134979,
-0.46021002531051636,
0.7884652018547058,
0.2814110815525055,
-0.47820067405700684,
-0.08326222747564316,
-0.5693261623382568,
0.1751159429550171,
-0.296801894903183,
-0.16720925271511078,
-0.07214720547199249,
-0.34575536847114563,
0.8513957858085632,
-0.6111839413642883,
0.5341609716415405,
-0.4236311614513397,
-0.2779480516910553,
0.40260767936706543,
0.29592007398605347,
0.48977360129356384,
0.08230903744697571,
-0.24234053492546082,
-0.12308146804571152,
-0.19215033948421478,
-0.7836395502090454,
-0.4488835036754608,
0.7548537850379944,
-0.4029211401939392,
-0.4729026257991791,
-0.11995623260736465,
-0.4941667318344116,
0.04630182683467865,
0.228468656539917,
0.7013120651245117,
0.028191328048706055,
-0.017093179747462273,
0.34819164872169495,
0.8097723126411438,
-0.3669823110103607,
0.38656750321388245,
0.24322937428951263,
0.03921392560005188,
-0.5510765314102173,
1.039160966873169,
-0.14068222045898438,
0.7550873756408691,
0.6002741456031799,
0.5499290227890015,
-0.17431175708770752,
-0.9441919922828674,
-0.33013737201690674,
0.09186621010303497,
-0.9259267449378967,
0.01909368298947811,
-1.060805320739746,
-0.1762402206659317,
-0.48777514696121216,
-0.4902311861515045,
-0.013821201398968697,
-0.6857798099517822,
-0.38168641924858093,
0.0590653270483017,
0.27332115173339844,
0.3076115846633911,
-0.2953190505504608,
0.5772997736930847,
-0.7275094985961914,
0.6803710460662842,
0.27471548318862915,
-0.007264186628162861,
0.03529020771384239,
-0.7792338728904724,
0.11278552561998367,
-0.15457302331924438,
-0.6547585129737854,
-0.900147020816803,
0.3628663718700409,
0.5813779830932617,
0.5026176571846008,
0.11153807491064072,
0.36291033029556274,
0.2341872751712799,
-0.7762398719787598,
0.9162440896034241,
0.07634484767913818,
-1.044677495956421,
0.7063863277435303,
-0.3767077922821045,
0.39274096488952637,
0.38123682141304016,
0.14191128313541412,
-0.1588534265756607,
-1.164623498916626,
-0.7146074771881104,
-1.051787257194519,
0.38433846831321716,
0.6528180241584778,
0.17285661399364471,
-0.1691276580095291,
0.44926589727401733,
0.3532645106315613,
0.2385905683040619,
-0.9003452062606812,
-0.08625879138708115,
-0.26136645674705505,
-0.36484086513519287,
0.010832685977220535,
-0.0798395425081253,
0.028016410768032074,
0.17514044046401978,
0.5030099749565125,
0.2032138854265213,
-0.03305981308221817,
0.1527870148420334,
-0.27645882964134216,
0.0929470881819725,
0.2911984920501709,
0.5057775378227234,
0.7099323868751526,
0.06271108239889145,
0.3389565646648407,
-0.018535934388637543,
-0.42632973194122314,
0.3819335401058197,
0.04354551434516907,
-0.7624232769012451,
0.14744587242603302,
0.3223467767238617,
0.5376186966896057,
-0.03294428065419197,
-0.4044191241264343,
0.4198005795478821,
0.1765790432691574,
-0.3501286804676056,
0.012104715220630169,
0.25847896933555603,
0.06270407140254974,
0.48172861337661743,
0.3147991895675659,
-0.03890562057495117,
0.3227996826171875,
0.13017745316028595,
0.7140257954597473,
0.1016014888882637,
0.13147227466106415,
-0.22095781564712524,
1.1928600072860718,
0.302696168422699,
-0.18864485621452332,
0.249156653881073,
-0.3762986660003662,
-0.2736693024635315,
0.23053371906280518,
0.5066769123077393,
0.937455952167511,
-0.2031731903553009,
0.2852524518966675,
0.09191076457500458,
0.0670255795121193,
0.025336889550089836,
0.06766614317893982,
-0.4431365430355072,
-0.4898211359977722,
-0.23663929104804993,
-0.8751099705696106,
-0.39067938923835754,
-0.05533285066485405,
-0.3516935408115387,
-0.0446431003510952,
-0.7582729458808899,
0.2024451494216919,
0.1757168024778366,
-0.7157853245735168,
0.015263418667018414,
0.06278067827224731,
-0.03025035187602043,
0.572218656539917,
-0.7719138264656067,
0.9946431517601013,
0.35857856273651123,
-0.45768678188323975,
-0.2567596733570099,
0.6520794034004211,
-0.4281025528907776,
-0.6274001598358154,
0.7273373603820801,
-0.3364903926849365,
-0.12924587726593018,
0.12583735585212708,
-0.29470059275627136,
-0.6057482957839966,
0.8388873338699341,
0.27972227334976196,
-0.1023298054933548,
-0.2366141825914383,
-0.17239004373550415,
0.40378063917160034,
-0.06379620730876923,
-0.44856664538383484,
0.270873099565506,
0.18259212374687195,
0.22241799533367157,
-0.5924686789512634,
0.03765593096613884,
-0.11647765338420868,
0.10232580453157425,
0.2969411611557007,
-0.44663119316101074,
0.8994934558868408,
0.06618105620145798,
0.05193997174501419,
0.29018718004226685,
1.0273916721343994,
0.4624063968658447,
0.32424458861351013,
0.47610190510749817,
0.4373587965965271,
0.44260647892951965,
0.2789180278778076,
0.8636409640312195,
-0.24746941030025482,
0.1336350291967392,
1.3596934080123901,
-0.34582141041755676,
0.8735408186912537,
0.6745758056640625,
-0.09982789307832718,
0.3998328149318695,
0.3094884157180786,
0.3080427050590515,
1.0094341039657593,
0.24531982839107513,
-0.7163627743721008,
-0.047812484204769135,
0.06305543333292007,
-0.1705193817615509,
0.24341163039207458,
0.24189026653766632,
-0.4908995032310486,
-0.45343199372291565,
0.1579688936471939,
0.018405457958579063,
0.3895207643508911,
0.03788590058684349,
0.8186640739440918,
0.026014363393187523,
-0.7356447577476501,
0.7687913179397583,
-0.018978262320160866,
0.7082428932189941,
-0.734268069267273,
-0.14525142312049866,
-0.3525749444961548,
0.40091535449028015,
0.024579688906669617,
-0.8628714680671692,
0.47061288356781006,
0.10083906352519989,
-0.08094215393066406,
-0.6295908093452454,
0.3052283525466919,
-0.5205060839653015,
-0.3215385377407074,
0.27025556564331055,
0.30600059032440186,
0.28799495100975037,
0.09316869080066681,
-0.8351552486419678,
-0.265323668718338,
0.2910386323928833,
-0.21830663084983826,
0.23923097550868988,
0.7085588574409485,
0.05850618705153465,
0.4327528774738312,
0.33131054043769836,
0.38640356063842773,
0.36082693934440613,
-0.11265172809362411,
0.6242341995239258,
-0.40752285718917847,
-0.9419081211090088,
-0.9068503975868225,
0.29708099365234375,
-0.26808515191078186,
-0.468586802482605,
0.8550353646278381,
0.43450093269348145,
0.46082422137260437,
-0.035544659942388535,
0.7355297803878784,
-0.19871865212917328,
0.49683865904808044,
-0.6712055802345276,
0.8448065519332886,
-0.5363772511482239,
0.1585756540298462,
-0.5055416226387024,
-0.923413097858429,
-0.1524052917957306,
0.6833329200744629,
0.016505395993590355,
-0.028209112584590912,
0.8332991600036621,
0.5715940594673157,
-0.24402032792568207,
-0.4034005105495453,
0.34660398960113525,
-0.06122326850891113,
0.7402560114860535,
0.6019128561019897,
0.7453098893165588,
-0.19870784878730774,
0.7739386558532715,
-0.27773794531822205,
-0.42747244238853455,
0.08445172011852264,
-0.8616399168968201,
-0.5717952847480774,
-0.5273185968399048,
-0.6409294605255127,
-0.5567443370819092,
-0.030789311975240707,
0.320728063583374,
0.4387389123439789,
-0.49012845754623413,
-0.15253344178199768,
-0.722137987613678,
0.11909057199954987,
-0.24294467270374298,
-0.27291440963745117,
0.4955027997493744,
-0.3394549787044525,
-0.9048067331314087,
0.35588863492012024,
0.24415160715579987,
0.20359443128108978,
-0.07104784995317459,
-0.277495414018631,
-0.37255173921585083,
0.07406468689441681,
0.28125765919685364,
0.12539416551589966,
-0.6516924500465393,
-0.030603813007473946,
-0.3486950397491455,
-0.08120850473642349,
0.08566579967737198,
0.8592216968536377,
-0.37128469347953796,
0.14793944358825684,
0.4840233027935028,
0.7558799386024475,
0.2908679246902466,
-0.0773010402917862,
0.6940633654594421,
-1.0100516080856323,
0.25084811449050903,
0.5441974401473999,
0.272452712059021,
0.3066401779651642,
-0.19591616094112396,
0.08263404667377472,
0.32086148858070374,
-0.7480913996696472,
-0.5844194889068604,
0.25580739974975586,
-0.7825416922569275,
-0.6492931246757507,
1.162692904472351,
-0.41405272483825684,
-0.1322755515575409,
-0.017306068912148476,
-0.2306394726037979,
0.35505229234695435,
-0.5713912844657898,
0.6466883420944214,
0.4845380187034607,
-0.008899163454771042,
-0.21398968994617462,
-0.2825124263763428,
0.5381229519844055,
0.5750894546508789,
-0.8105434775352478,
0.35456347465515137,
0.6372033953666687,
0.43176478147506714,
-0.12635916471481323,
0.855800211429596,
-0.08749096095561981,
0.40382352471351624,
0.11040511727333069,
-0.14624936878681183,
0.37636277079582214,
-0.08150020986795425,
-0.3415645360946655,
0.45751702785491943,
0.28998541831970215,
-0.3731575906276703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13066v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13066v2
|
Leveraging Large Language Model as Simulated Patients for Clinical Education
| 2024-04-13T06:36:32 | 2024-04-25T02:39:24 |
Yanzeng Li, Cheng Zeng, Jialun Zhong, Ruoyu Zhang, Minhao Zhang, Lei Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Simulated Patients (SPs) play a crucial role in clinical medical education by
providing realistic scenarios for student practice. However, the high cost of
training and hiring qualified SPs, along with the heavy workload and potential
risks they face in consistently portraying actual patients, limit students'
access to this type of clinical training. Consequently, the integration of
computer program-based simulated patients has emerged as a valuable educational
tool in recent years. With the rapid development of Large Language Models
(LLMs), their exceptional capabilities in conversational artificial
intelligence and role-playing have been demonstrated, making them a feasible
option for implementing Virtual Simulated Patient (VSP). In this paper, we
present an integrated model-agnostic framework called CureFun that harnesses
the potential of LLMs in clinical medical education. This framework facilitates
natural conversations between students and simulated patients, evaluates their
dialogue, and provides suggestions to enhance students' clinical inquiry
skills. Through comprehensive evaluations, our approach demonstrates more
authentic and professional SP-scenario dialogue flows compared to other
LLM-based chatbots, thus proving its proficiency in simulating patients.
Additionally, leveraging CureFun's evaluation ability, we assess several
medical LLMs and discuss the possibilities and limitations of using LLMs as
virtual doctors from the perspective of their diagnostic abilities.
|
[
-0.2442954033613205,
-1.0427080392837524,
1.0082587003707886,
-0.03047565184533596,
-0.20935481786727905,
0.24744540452957153,
-0.46530723571777344,
-0.4671311378479004,
0.4004802703857422,
0.6297880411148071,
-0.442432701587677,
-0.3936281204223633,
-0.44478321075439453,
0.2427077740430832,
-0.12818476557731628,
0.6287206411361694,
0.0666404440999031,
0.7732690572738647,
-0.6226956844329834,
0.044617414474487305,
-0.5674853324890137,
-0.6280762553215027,
-0.8685379028320312,
-0.3427237272262573,
0.35078808665275574,
0.16356368362903595,
0.5147691965103149,
0.528957724571228,
0.37860819697380066,
0.4196568429470062,
0.2666992247104645,
0.11943338811397552,
-0.6668526530265808,
0.11515031009912491,
-0.10811763256788254,
-0.5625225901603699,
-0.18780869245529175,
-0.005205051973462105,
0.538200855255127,
0.8456023335456848,
-0.4065171778202057,
-0.41945940256118774,
-0.4213966727256775,
-0.08017965406179428,
-0.0853278711438179,
0.07392894476652145,
-0.4111858904361725,
0.2554403245449066,
0.10581111907958984,
0.011023134924471378,
-0.5142925381660461,
-0.35674425959587097,
0.32549822330474854,
-0.7027441263198853,
0.14896763861179352,
-0.35317251086235046,
0.6931878328323364,
-0.042770661413669586,
-0.4374083876609802,
-0.35718974471092224,
-0.7281182408332825,
0.5412325859069824,
-0.9398531913757324,
0.3459649384021759,
0.20209094882011414,
0.8041234016418457,
-0.4693570137023926,
-0.8369013667106628,
-0.7090549468994141,
-0.6241162419319153,
-0.06418202817440033,
0.3134498596191406,
0.18268828094005585,
0.5843116044998169,
0.3334917724132538,
0.5353054404258728,
-0.38718587160110474,
0.36925387382507324,
-0.44648730754852295,
-0.1277494579553604,
0.5331758856773376,
0.40503451228141785,
0.5341969728469849,
0.04537677392363548,
-0.472745805978775,
-0.017899952828884125,
-0.4264836311340332,
-0.19725961983203888,
-0.22092053294181824,
0.1426369994878769,
-0.25122004747390747,
0.3790750801563263,
0.1315300017595291,
0.8251668214797974,
-0.4000107944011688,
-0.43622568249702454,
0.002011342439800501,
0.10142061114311218,
-0.4400438368320465,
0.06796839088201523,
0.7316049933433533,
0.2886371612548828,
0.37066495418548584,
-0.09889334440231323,
0.1767786592245102,
0.4257916510105133,
0.550586998462677,
-1.1153950691223145,
-0.20852842926979065,
0.5135416984558105,
-0.2856059670448303,
-0.4135816991329193,
-0.24114574491977692,
-0.6839430928230286,
-0.3974693715572357,
-0.5296651124954224,
0.3565339148044586,
-0.5788823962211609,
-0.2664625942707062,
0.4929942786693573,
0.16177944839000702,
-0.07015636563301086,
0.8221969604492188,
-0.5144103169441223,
0.5405657887458801,
0.7258298397064209,
0.614616334438324,
-0.012098950333893299,
0.03410118818283081,
-0.6396480798721313,
0.06005365401506424,
-0.250227689743042,
0.6534077525138855,
-0.7505940198898315,
-0.9180417656898499,
0.22217433154582977,
0.022776026278734207,
-0.26223134994506836,
-0.5872132182121277,
0.4177199602127075,
-0.12751783430576324,
0.3666481077671051,
-0.10709593445062637,
-0.8894705772399902,
-0.009267517365515232,
0.5275364518165588,
-0.2874022424221039,
0.43262383341789246,
0.35790079832077026,
-0.32919177412986755,
0.04103582352399826,
-0.6192865967750549,
-0.36421406269073486,
0.5266047120094299,
-0.7652581930160522,
-0.27228105068206787,
-0.028209006413817406,
0.044635821133852005,
0.41984739899635315,
-0.3820650577545166,
0.6238313913345337,
-0.3583351671695709,
-0.40020492672920227,
0.43289586901664734,
-0.3252144455909729,
0.5940911173820496,
0.19595906138420105,
0.028567038476467133,
0.24117650091648102,
-0.382845938205719,
0.039626047015190125,
0.15212275087833405,
-0.1413649469614029,
-0.3072274327278137,
-0.19749332964420319,
0.02866143360733986,
0.3436424732208252,
-0.2707987427711487,
-0.6026981472969055,
0.6298759579658508,
-0.7383249998092651,
0.3474271297454834,
0.4305146634578705,
0.21816404163837433,
0.007769265677779913,
-0.46554508805274963,
0.9611874222755432,
0.046365126967430115,
0.4357773959636688,
-0.42004629969596863,
-0.5702648758888245,
-0.7086673378944397,
-0.5706690549850464,
0.24669089913368225,
0.5127660036087036,
-0.8740941286087036,
-0.2499430775642395,
-0.15501052141189575,
-0.5138919949531555,
-0.6583037376403809,
-0.11994718015193939,
0.29909271001815796,
0.8468500375747681,
0.20185944437980652,
-0.10661264508962631,
-0.30364781618118286,
-0.8240972757339478,
0.05165689066052437,
-0.19288338720798492,
-0.13012002408504486,
0.5629971027374268,
0.3716902434825897,
-0.5667428970336914,
0.6029616594314575,
-0.6263762712478638,
-0.4195098578929901,
-0.41413429379463196,
-0.38553905487060547,
0.07607337087392807,
0.42576864361763,
0.5564739108085632,
-0.8090978264808655,
-0.5025143623352051,
0.038167115300893784,
-0.7761527299880981,
0.00955392699688673,
-0.49914300441741943,
0.03624941036105156,
-0.22327572107315063,
0.5252965092658997,
-0.5154716372489929,
0.5158665776252747,
0.39326977729797363,
-0.17846597731113434,
0.6739256381988525,
-0.6961861252784729,
0.39535781741142273,
-1.2171541452407837,
0.10723144561052322,
0.06747782230377197,
-0.4159340560436249,
-0.693346381187439,
0.11029670387506485,
0.023870237171649933,
-0.4032451808452606,
-0.39980560541152954,
0.7486792802810669,
-0.09987002611160278,
0.36127492785453796,
-0.2325269728899002,
0.39718350768089294,
-0.06552669405937195,
-0.05568261072039604,
0.2571316659450531,
0.5099102258682251,
0.5869291424751282,
-0.2725057005882263,
0.3526696264743805,
0.33392566442489624,
-0.3188909888267517,
0.8344117403030396,
-0.7237887978553772,
-0.1160757765173912,
0.10374435782432556,
0.6235429048538208,
-0.4886775314807892,
-0.5212806463241577,
0.04728423431515694,
-0.270928293466568,
0.2953774631023407,
-0.1539698839187622,
-0.604621946811676,
-0.6094918251037598,
0.14365623891353607,
0.3107285797595978,
0.4561549425125122,
-0.2826450765132904,
0.46089455485343933,
0.2557796537876129,
-0.14198538661003113,
-0.2657873034477234,
-0.2525516748428345,
0.3294874429702759,
-0.22675631940364838,
-0.6035524010658264,
0.3120129704475403,
-0.3026186227798462,
-0.23822951316833496,
-0.3133281171321869,
0.3769308626651764,
-0.07558412104845047,
0.06894639134407043,
0.4299151599407196,
0.5678377747535706,
-0.4098339378833771,
0.2815166115760803,
0.3186722993850708,
-0.04197672754526138,
0.10019508004188538,
0.01562866009771824,
0.5392976403236389,
-0.051437441259622574,
-0.7186997532844543,
-0.5387609601020813,
0.5165067315101624,
0.816545307636261,
-0.2058950513601303,
0.8461573719978333,
0.23432952165603638,
-0.6033339500427246,
-0.2546175420284271,
-0.9259413480758667,
-0.6227941513061523,
-0.4386143982410431,
0.5690545439720154,
-0.08791118860244751,
-1.0879465341567993,
0.4597974717617035,
-0.6325019598007202,
0.06738895177841187,
-0.03884061053395271,
0.6435486674308777,
-0.03939450904726982,
1.0407586097717285,
0.5157296657562256,
0.32179081439971924,
-0.0873195230960846,
0.008992375805974007,
0.1874389946460724,
-0.523337185382843,
-0.5370211601257324,
-0.24658752977848053,
0.0496043786406517,
-0.13777931034564972,
-0.8313296437263489,
0.6544683575630188,
0.05951446667313576,
-0.1113600879907608,
-0.10808153450489044,
-0.2064463049173355,
0.3053162693977356,
0.10308506339788437,
0.27907949686050415,
0.12648743391036987,
-0.03539828583598137,
-0.459932804107666,
-0.23682287335395813,
-0.6073768138885498,
-0.2965831160545349,
0.8894477486610413,
0.5899404287338257,
0.4091280400753021,
-0.0682416632771492,
0.6139925122261047,
0.2048892378807068,
0.6818968057632446,
-0.9379155039787292,
0.4977504014968872,
-0.11859036237001419,
-0.34539660811424255,
0.008910808712244034,
-0.43822282552719116,
-0.7628675103187561,
0.3462992310523987,
-0.40693432092666626,
-0.6638363599777222,
-0.1739237904548645,
0.11966601014137268,
-0.555734395980835,
0.28630465269088745,
-0.5582566857337952,
0.9217972159385681,
-0.3296310603618622,
-0.2200530469417572,
-0.5010926127433777,
-0.6780198216438293,
0.3681352138519287,
-0.31884464621543884,
0.3904716968536377,
0.14432014524936676,
0.3252011239528656,
0.32808101177215576,
-0.8216593265533447,
0.9169776439666748,
-0.09928474575281143,
-0.03737705200910568,
0.03392723947763443,
0.3191753327846527,
0.06531335413455963,
0.4353440999984741,
-0.08659517019987106,
0.02021048404276371,
0.25119227170944214,
-0.3716140389442444,
-0.5392180681228638,
0.9422607421875,
-0.6226160526275635,
-0.8552571535110474,
-0.30532440543174744,
-0.4371047019958496,
-0.6091336607933044,
0.18466724455356598,
-0.15082164108753204,
0.5623016953468323,
-0.46849891543388367,
-0.06384984403848648,
0.6804856657981873,
-0.7071295976638794,
-0.21409492194652557,
0.731722354888916,
-0.6378244161605835,
-0.4268220067024231,
0.6335311532020569,
-0.2848178446292877,
0.6095989942550659,
0.12864287197589874,
0.6046434640884399,
-0.3019021451473236,
-0.24770909547805786,
-0.6666803956031799,
0.7246415615081787,
-0.6385354399681091,
-0.15123476088047028,
-0.787480354309082,
-0.4308452904224396,
-0.3953061103820801,
-0.5862070918083191,
-0.16592200100421906,
0.07448066025972366,
-0.21679644286632538,
-0.07657121866941452,
0.3609340190887451,
0.5506242513656616,
0.15217480063438416,
0.4712373614311218,
-0.7091549634933472,
0.3056381642818451,
0.20809657871723175,
0.18710404634475708,
-0.06053432077169418,
-0.46997109055519104,
-0.08928073197603226,
0.2447260022163391,
-0.056414101272821426,
-0.7592063546180725,
0.5118883848190308,
0.10763440281152725,
0.7045885920524597,
0.9181206226348877,
0.05315515026450157,
0.8021374344825745,
-0.6440293192863464,
0.6012086272239685,
0.4888351857662201,
-0.5902318358421326,
0.5602940320968628,
-0.46338436007499695,
0.06023791804909706,
0.5200622081756592,
0.3998897075653076,
-0.8251049518585205,
-0.4527321457862854,
-0.5142191648483276,
-0.36873066425323486,
0.6512386798858643,
-0.11660145223140717,
0.40872448682785034,
-0.22740808129310608,
0.5002987384796143,
0.09652882814407349,
0.18897998332977295,
-0.5034239888191223,
-0.11546509712934494,
-0.005440377164632082,
-0.319129079580307,
-0.12702929973602295,
-0.2845112979412079,
-0.4225221574306488,
-0.2755909562110901,
0.34275829792022705,
0.014014899730682373,
0.0639069601893425,
0.31235793232917786,
0.27558526396751404,
-0.05852288007736206,
0.06910649687051773,
0.6692848801612854,
0.3292013704776764,
-0.09734956920146942,
-0.1605745553970337,
0.21322964131832123,
-0.6813378930091858,
-0.1779002547264099,
0.07726502418518066,
0.22635309398174286,
0.0035931223537772894,
0.23000456392765045,
0.6073541641235352,
0.4435921013355255,
-1.2290561199188232,
0.8020725846290588,
-0.2150169163942337,
-0.141551673412323,
-0.48185619711875916,
0.1922975331544876,
0.3786143660545349,
0.23596280813217163,
-0.15779565274715424,
-0.09244663268327713,
0.08831017464399338,
-0.31286942958831787,
0.31553658843040466,
0.35833558440208435,
-0.7734107375144958,
-0.11313368380069733,
0.7787929177284241,
0.23919469118118286,
-0.5147296190261841,
0.85446697473526,
0.2877151370048523,
-0.5915371775627136,
0.7096248269081116,
0.9972691535949707,
0.4025985300540924,
-0.5457276105880737,
0.4829227924346924,
0.2937694489955902,
-0.05185719579458237,
-0.2326347380876541,
0.036487024277448654,
0.20079337060451508,
-0.35488107800483704,
-0.48675718903541565,
-0.6997339129447937,
-0.5636529326438904,
0.35079386830329895,
-0.3296843469142914,
0.6405472755432129,
-0.5831895470619202,
-0.1419912576675415,
-0.08750738948583603,
-0.1958678513765335,
-0.5390190482139587,
0.416108101606369,
0.19889740645885468,
0.9846600890159607,
-0.8219506144523621,
1.0930904150009155,
0.8414909243583679,
-0.23186926543712616,
-0.8509445786476135,
-0.3020114004611969,
0.04404091462492943,
-0.8291789889335632,
0.5067786574363708,
0.3671935498714447,
0.19278712570667267,
-0.2040834277868271,
-0.26145580410957336,
-0.08822305500507355,
0.7478881478309631,
0.44534820318222046,
-0.645084023475647,
-0.18425904214382172,
0.489369660615921,
0.9028627872467041,
-0.5596782565116882,
0.46544116735458374,
0.0848471000790596,
0.08727078884840012,
0.29608091711997986,
-1.0726823806762695,
-0.057358015328645706,
-0.2916811406612396,
-0.10971738398075104,
-0.09088129550218582,
-0.34938639402389526,
0.6156841516494751,
-0.49972954392433167,
-0.007912241853773594,
0.09499765932559967,
0.22878503799438477,
0.3920261263847351,
0.21652935445308685,
0.47180575132369995,
0.3162328600883484,
0.5773089528083801,
0.23262305557727814,
1.1465497016906738,
-0.14734071493148804,
0.17810992896556854,
0.7961233854293823,
-0.3654421269893646,
0.6502788662910461,
0.4766113758087158,
-0.12779004871845245,
0.3892291188240051,
0.43675634264945984,
-0.07512101531028748,
0.005462975241243839,
0.6454883813858032,
-0.7057392597198486,
-0.6908844113349915,
-0.26190274953842163,
-0.5274367332458496,
0.37913185358047485,
0.8710386753082275,
-0.40073493123054504,
-0.08996802568435669,
0.4237779974937439,
0.15069180727005005,
0.4706326127052307,
-0.13624797761440277,
0.46030551195144653,
0.45727765560150146,
-0.39529985189437866,
0.4062480628490448,
-0.0057668848894536495,
0.3119144141674042,
-0.7553113698959351,
-0.3985562324523926,
-0.17493100464344025,
0.28071942925453186,
0.00019075567252002656,
-0.2977641820907593,
-0.22998273372650146,
-0.2336599975824356,
0.18881435692310333,
-0.02787497639656067,
0.45796722173690796,
-0.4501086175441742,
-0.8926520943641663,
0.18705379962921143,
0.2856113314628601,
0.25329989194869995,
0.1994493454694748,
-0.7216343879699707,
0.18122915923595428,
0.03898579627275467,
0.28350621461868286,
0.4626564681529999,
0.31585490703582764,
-0.10641749948263168,
0.9779148101806641,
0.7669574022293091,
0.4287078380584717,
-0.4878346920013428,
0.41243472695350647,
0.8582084774971008,
-0.18211345374584198,
-0.5516095161437988,
-0.5877168774604797,
0.39707115292549133,
-0.18759873509407043,
-0.09821929782629013,
0.45106884837150574,
0.5947956442832947,
0.5176783800125122,
-0.26031583547592163,
0.6172157526016235,
0.4961458444595337,
0.6832441091537476,
-0.33894866704940796,
1.0291370153427124,
-0.6100125312805176,
0.48789557814598083,
-0.4911309778690338,
-0.373771071434021,
-0.4131520092487335,
0.7402311563491821,
-0.3474601209163666,
0.01775973290205002,
0.3847695589065552,
0.5057942271232605,
-0.25490978360176086,
0.05315038189291954,
0.7947546243667603,
0.3382338285446167,
0.7398933172225952,
0.6047046184539795,
0.7268827557563782,
-0.13372506201267242,
0.031763575971126556,
-0.2863909900188446,
-0.4485509693622589,
-0.5179544687271118,
-0.5149622559547424,
-1.125980019569397,
-0.3935176730155945,
-0.43736064434051514,
-0.38826486468315125,
0.02322711981832981,
1.0335649251937866,
0.5936517715454102,
-0.5983071327209473,
-0.20252461731433868,
0.18950331211090088,
-0.38184526562690735,
0.2683069705963135,
-0.21679557859897614,
0.4616453945636749,
0.017633836716413498,
-0.6665680408477783,
0.5305598378181458,
0.3370476961135864,
0.24717698991298676,
-0.41991403698921204,
0.0256172064691782,
0.20767465233802795,
0.22881284356117249,
0.6191378235816956,
0.309542179107666,
-0.6722053289413452,
-0.06522379070520401,
0.15897700190544128,
-0.24193720519542694,
-0.09611152857542038,
0.8107864260673523,
-1.1654173135757446,
0.8969672322273254,
-0.36410167813301086,
0.7480831742286682,
0.33891192078590393,
-0.01970328576862812,
0.7454503774642944,
0.07642338424921036,
0.31575915217399597,
0.48707279562950134,
0.1724521368741989,
0.2011582851409912,
-0.4835488498210907,
0.032881658524274826,
0.18986886739730835,
-0.45752978324890137,
-1.05802583694458,
0.19278588891029358,
-1.012412190437317,
-0.4151415526866913,
1.05156409740448,
-0.42786818742752075,
0.2450321763753891,
-0.13402153551578522,
-0.5666088461875916,
0.06032876297831535,
-0.04915102198719978,
0.9177481532096863,
0.1742716133594513,
-0.27750086784362793,
0.09047780930995941,
-1.0270020961761475,
0.47300493717193604,
0.4361381530761719,
-0.9945659637451172,
-0.2740895748138428,
0.618873119354248,
0.49949896335601807,
-0.18522010743618011,
0.6619460582733154,
-0.33864107728004456,
0.140238955616951,
-0.24522757530212402,
-0.13878341019153595,
-0.19515077769756317,
-0.08073008060455322,
0.05007360503077507,
-0.06326625496149063,
-0.10893497616052628,
0.29436713457107544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13065v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13065v1
|
Intellecta Cognitiva: A Comprehensive Dataset for Advancing Academic Knowledge and Machine Reasoning
| 2024-04-13T06:11:25 | 2024-04-13T06:11:25 |
Ajmal PS, Ditto PS, Jithin VG
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Intellecta dataset emerges as an innovative synthetic dataset, engineered to
enhance the cognitive processing capabilities of contemporary language models.
With a composition of 11.53 billion tokens, integrating 8.01 billion tokens of
synthetic data with 3.52 billion tokens of rich textbook data, Intellecta is
crafted to foster advanced reasoning and comprehensive educational narrative
generation. Leveraging the Mixtral-8x7B-Instruct-v0.1 model, the dataset
facilitates the generation of complex thought processes and detailed,
textbook-style explanations, thus enabling language models to engage in both
critical thinking and profound educational discourse. This hybrid dataset
stands as a testament to the potential of synthetic data in pushing the
boundaries of AI, offering a repository that is not only vast and varied but
also refined to align with ethical standards and intellectual rigor.
|
[
-0.5024213194847107,
-1.0679506063461304,
0.542908787727356,
-0.1389191895723343,
0.020020004361867905,
0.2557826042175293,
-0.17113658785820007,
-0.34189915657043457,
0.2281222641468048,
0.2965501546859741,
-0.8112125992774963,
-0.3130114674568176,
-0.2898670434951782,
-0.25732487440109253,
-0.4604659676551819,
0.9720287919044495,
0.23029735684394836,
0.2075786292552948,
-0.5617184638977051,
-0.11970534175634384,
-0.585010290145874,
-0.6959570050239563,
-0.5588633418083191,
-0.40081489086151123,
0.44589346647262573,
0.9190324544906616,
0.42547401785850525,
0.16360799968242645,
0.5201700329780579,
0.24693194031715393,
0.36581215262413025,
0.2210129201412201,
-0.5959506630897522,
0.031504057347774506,
-0.5645954012870789,
-0.6935351490974426,
-0.5593249797821045,
0.09150302410125732,
0.4327835142612457,
0.8101029992103577,
-0.021423323079943657,
0.40742048621177673,
-0.17228823900222778,
0.9057924151420593,
-0.5516324639320374,
0.3162092864513397,
-0.5717689990997314,
0.08883075416088104,
-0.32633376121520996,
0.0760253295302391,
-0.5292862057685852,
-0.5207518339157104,
0.42257222533226013,
-0.7873377799987793,
-0.02093290537595749,
0.1467614620923996,
0.6387863159179688,
0.41778460144996643,
-0.3221486806869507,
-0.12999846041202545,
-0.7758185863494873,
0.8863666653633118,
-0.1758033037185669,
0.2372213751077652,
0.15554387867450714,
0.5167720317840576,
-0.17173199355602264,
-0.9922832250595093,
-0.9736441373825073,
0.30267706513404846,
0.27315768599510193,
0.3565351963043213,
0.0955587849020958,
-0.16622112691402435,
0.17500652372837067,
0.5546619296073914,
-0.5238231420516968,
0.08161305636167526,
-0.6188583970069885,
-0.09352909028530121,
0.7746782302856445,
0.2835962176322937,
0.62444007396698,
0.06789924204349518,
-0.2141384333372116,
-0.38672295212745667,
-0.7289190292358398,
0.08739164471626282,
0.41521796584129333,
0.03427325189113617,
0.12664587795734406,
0.6650182604789734,
-0.31376633048057556,
0.7471780776977539,
-0.05155627429485321,
0.29829466342926025,
0.262888640165329,
-0.2585720419883728,
-0.27006053924560547,
0.32887157797813416,
0.696348249912262,
0.28569504618644714,
0.5220244526863098,
-0.23229019343852997,
0.15947078168392181,
0.4878203868865967,
0.34244266152381897,
-0.7988073825836182,
-0.4430178701877594,
0.4592030346393585,
-0.15658926963806152,
0.012775644659996033,
0.12510384619235992,
-0.968403160572052,
-0.04033169522881508,
-0.9083646535873413,
0.2756041884422302,
-0.7357927560806274,
-0.05670369789004326,
0.24228371679782867,
-0.23345445096492767,
-0.003960945177823305,
0.39086171984672546,
-1.0803463459014893,
0.42186975479125977,
0.7364106178283691,
0.47311288118362427,
-0.43738293647766113,
-0.13021722435951233,
0.11587831377983093,
0.11891667544841766,
-0.39359691739082336,
0.9925929307937622,
-0.8468061089515686,
-0.18527072668075562,
-0.214668408036232,
-0.2557618319988251,
-0.24413858354091644,
-0.5880471467971802,
0.8169211745262146,
-0.49400410056114197,
0.5601739287376404,
-0.20928093791007996,
-0.9826261401176453,
-0.8443717956542969,
0.1893230825662613,
-0.8819955587387085,
1.1420389413833618,
0.2433774471282959,
-0.43631309270858765,
0.5791614651679993,
-0.8285335302352905,
-0.04235105589032173,
0.33372369408607483,
-0.40732529759407043,
-0.13059434294700623,
-0.14368176460266113,
0.2078760713338852,
0.3749409317970276,
-0.6726820468902588,
0.9319376349449158,
-0.2715878486633301,
-0.2930889129638672,
0.32711026072502136,
-0.47465139627456665,
0.9817351698875427,
0.12748397886753082,
-0.3103978931903839,
0.026457276195287704,
-1.126336932182312,
0.2069360464811325,
0.17713893949985504,
0.07106456905603409,
-0.5895336270332336,
-0.006984049454331398,
-0.13822929561138153,
0.29315733909606934,
0.5117195844650269,
-0.44061848521232605,
0.19766297936439514,
-0.2802164852619171,
0.3498491048812866,
0.7203038334846497,
0.06943895667791367,
0.4248823821544647,
-0.49255529046058655,
0.34276068210601807,
0.06883661448955536,
0.07285750657320023,
-0.027608714997768402,
-0.5984719395637512,
-0.8655315041542053,
-0.36834636330604553,
0.005426796618849039,
0.8455045223236084,
-0.5768532752990723,
0.5068373084068298,
-0.35241076350212097,
-0.7313423156738281,
-0.6514819264411926,
-0.13902612030506134,
0.09573329985141754,
0.843841016292572,
0.5404143929481506,
0.011001377366483212,
-0.6535362005233765,
-1.1782495975494385,
-0.25304198265075684,
0.06758209317922592,
-0.08826010674238205,
0.4388502538204193,
0.7696845531463623,
-0.009251878596842289,
0.9583114385604858,
-0.3744816482067108,
-0.1537248194217682,
-0.041150495409965515,
-0.12980979681015015,
0.30351147055625916,
0.7391396760940552,
0.46058711409568787,
-0.8444942235946655,
-0.43003344535827637,
-0.23555989563465118,
-1.241050362586975,
0.21318158507347107,
-0.19142977893352509,
-0.45318353176116943,
-0.20423747599124908,
0.20454150438308716,
-0.4661504328250885,
0.3626316487789154,
0.32454708218574524,
-0.6008113622665405,
0.2986774444580078,
0.028672046959400177,
0.3001363277435303,
-1.163252353668213,
0.03826237842440605,
-0.20522615313529968,
0.25468185544013977,
-0.5560929775238037,
0.12221426516771317,
-0.06432374566793442,
-0.06181618198752403,
-0.40252047777175903,
0.525591254234314,
-0.10001876205205917,
0.23289018869400024,
0.3159126341342926,
0.33896857500076294,
0.14639420807361603,
0.5828536748886108,
-0.24319212138652802,
0.9628159403800964,
0.5568450689315796,
-0.5871318578720093,
0.5652824640274048,
0.696537971496582,
-0.534436047077179,
0.8554244041442871,
-0.6723979115486145,
0.313238263130188,
0.046358104795217514,
0.08375561237335205,
-0.4320636987686157,
-0.46911197900772095,
0.14776279032230377,
-0.2798437476158142,
-0.09152800589799881,
0.5146008729934692,
-0.4414328932762146,
-0.2860811650753021,
-0.12928426265716553,
0.5907588601112366,
0.37273040413856506,
-0.7537642121315002,
0.7742172479629517,
0.7219900488853455,
-0.37862303853034973,
-0.45664963126182556,
-0.683337390422821,
0.3790937662124634,
-0.16278062760829926,
-0.7954886555671692,
0.5197730660438538,
-0.3348807990550995,
-0.6688838005065918,
0.04092369228601456,
0.4263204038143158,
-0.06217105686664581,
-0.08545029908418655,
0.29689693450927734,
0.7734078168869019,
-0.11920390278100967,
0.2579992711544037,
0.3201547861099243,
0.038712672889232635,
0.2526172399520874,
-0.37014004588127136,
0.5906552076339722,
-0.0775483176112175,
-0.3527372181415558,
-0.5927572250366211,
0.32921716570854187,
0.7487033009529114,
-0.04783080518245697,
0.9334641098976135,
0.0909799337387085,
-0.5093492865562439,
-0.44288086891174316,
-0.2905588448047638,
-0.27576175332069397,
-0.4303838312625885,
0.2531186640262604,
-0.4770923852920532,
-0.6804859042167664,
0.581356942653656,
0.05770375579595566,
-0.08888756483793259,
0.651722252368927,
0.6898950934410095,
0.24104207754135132,
0.8750321269035339,
0.3693508505821228,
-0.06300295144319534,
0.2665533721446991,
-0.4891550838947296,
0.37172526121139526,
-0.8937997221946716,
-0.999101996421814,
-0.3576681613922119,
-0.34504735469818115,
-0.3688771426677704,
-0.31891003251075745,
0.13061492145061493,
-0.32490774989128113,
-0.41393280029296875,
-0.11014394462108612,
-0.8142057657241821,
0.5001251101493835,
0.8136982321739197,
0.2594027519226074,
0.28753426671028137,
-0.019017992541193962,
-0.067676842212677,
-0.21610324084758759,
-0.8410786390304565,
-0.7520608305931091,
1.483985424041748,
0.007807167246937752,
0.38893842697143555,
0.1927555650472641,
0.27045950293540955,
0.2739958167076111,
0.2612192630767822,
-0.857475996017456,
0.7576012015342712,
-0.1647128313779831,
-0.9320397973060608,
-0.203729048371315,
-0.111715167760849,
-0.5998207926750183,
-0.06371297687292099,
-0.324130117893219,
-0.6977066993713379,
0.39127209782600403,
-0.05231340602040291,
-0.21538716554641724,
0.17373168468475342,
-0.9120291471481323,
0.7766187787055969,
0.00498259998857975,
-0.5441243052482605,
-0.630932629108429,
-0.22979006171226501,
0.5518261790275574,
-0.3838973343372345,
-0.044883254915475845,
-0.03058044984936714,
0.14990225434303284,
0.98239666223526,
-0.4115101099014282,
0.6518152952194214,
0.015397302806377411,
0.19762495160102844,
0.7052702903747559,
-0.06204058229923248,
0.3834269344806671,
0.0032029354479163885,
-0.2988402843475342,
0.08161237090826035,
-0.22431033849716187,
-0.5060151815414429,
-0.5086121559143066,
0.6077547669410706,
-0.8673227429389954,
-0.6505071520805359,
-0.3691779673099518,
-0.9206356406211853,
-0.25201737880706787,
0.16654422879219055,
0.08523297309875488,
0.6239432096481323,
-0.5424541234970093,
0.47597309947013855,
0.7783563137054443,
-0.1499657928943634,
0.2293868511915207,
0.28518515825271606,
-0.0038044010289013386,
-0.32142022252082825,
1.178505301475525,
0.5606755614280701,
0.021869543939828873,
0.11792288720607758,
-0.214714914560318,
-0.31063538789749146,
-0.5435292720794678,
-0.46956852078437805,
-0.1677318811416626,
-0.8538129925727844,
0.11067090928554535,
-0.8889760971069336,
-0.18699020147323608,
-0.23962950706481934,
-0.29798585176467896,
-0.1815669983625412,
-0.8029714226722717,
-0.4409663677215576,
-0.4496624171733856,
0.4143567681312561,
0.7207042574882507,
0.20180737972259521,
-0.008271739818155766,
-0.5666375160217285,
0.2513921856880188,
0.5517624020576477,
0.11836066842079163,
0.016467679291963577,
-0.46222758293151855,
-0.16482985019683838,
0.03876771777868271,
-0.024701738730072975,
-0.6223554015159607,
0.4600997567176819,
0.46208932995796204,
0.584170401096344,
0.23713938891887665,
0.026132820174098015,
0.40103384852409363,
-0.4789784848690033,
0.9126394987106323,
-0.10586132109165192,
-0.890137791633606,
0.5331956744194031,
-0.35016530752182007,
0.09946974366903305,
0.5932503938674927,
0.39706021547317505,
-0.114894799888134,
-0.4488280415534973,
-0.9115731120109558,
-0.9203980565071106,
0.5880466103553772,
-0.00690992409363389,
0.04832281544804573,
0.07779023796319962,
0.3491072952747345,
0.47584089636802673,
0.06935236603021622,
-0.24906612932682037,
-0.168210968375206,
-0.47045955061912537,
-0.8205133676528931,
0.004017983563244343,
0.016367686912417412,
-0.4127890467643738,
-0.5763899087905884,
0.8882673382759094,
-0.3465767204761505,
-0.047870222479104996,
-0.06167761981487274,
-0.07016011327505112,
0.23414838314056396,
0.1085413247346878,
0.37975162267684937,
0.8617311716079712,
-0.01827971078455448,
-0.010329950600862503,
0.1350925862789154,
-0.792917788028717,
0.20456469058990479,
0.1248239278793335,
-0.40581512451171875,
-0.4524400234222412,
0.05909925699234009,
0.6471281051635742,
-0.17743836343288422,
-1.1128790378570557,
0.07537737488746643,
-0.27322056889533997,
-0.1224651038646698,
-0.7376273274421692,
0.49991336464881897,
0.031492505222558975,
0.20870888233184814,
0.5870354771614075,
0.36273959279060364,
0.3422829508781433,
-0.6171556711196899,
0.40170958638191223,
0.20498774945735931,
-0.31771814823150635,
-0.5060971975326538,
0.7877581715583801,
0.16752013564109802,
-0.12733373045921326,
0.9699690341949463,
0.09510371088981628,
-0.3733738958835602,
0.9079048037528992,
0.4324614405632019,
0.8185839653015137,
0.07840033620595932,
0.363912433385849,
0.6142408847808838,
0.16006331145763397,
0.0028914175927639008,
0.43459105491638184,
0.13117408752441406,
-0.9706924557685852,
-0.3167807459831238,
-0.40881654620170593,
-0.6863225698471069,
0.022352026775479317,
-0.7019878625869751,
0.11064650863409042,
-0.6033403873443604,
0.021625185385346413,
0.20679375529289246,
-0.014411712996661663,
-0.8085994720458984,
0.82124924659729,
-0.0755121037364006,
0.9871931076049805,
-0.8441590666770935,
0.9208504557609558,
0.4884360134601593,
-0.6217184066772461,
-0.895764946937561,
-0.4432240128517151,
-0.03809342160820961,
-0.8050822019577026,
0.8044081330299377,
0.20229658484458923,
-0.00843776110559702,
0.1789282113313675,
-0.7040383219718933,
-0.7622427344322205,
1.08790123462677,
0.40187153220176697,
-0.6466550230979919,
0.27859580516815186,
0.1267234981060028,
0.6147446036338806,
-0.5734885931015015,
0.026958879083395004,
0.8132230639457703,
0.660361111164093,
0.011959224939346313,
-0.17455731332302094,
0.024375678971409798,
-0.6602177619934082,
-0.6391459107398987,
-0.12236036360263824,
-0.8439764380455017,
0.9586445093154907,
-0.12349444627761841,
-0.19015571475028992,
-0.24892520904541016,
0.697787344455719,
0.26578256487846375,
0.3667312562465668,
0.00732454564422369,
0.9003676772117615,
1.244788646697998,
-0.47654858231544495,
0.9400115609169006,
-0.49336889386177063,
-0.11805613338947296,
1.119003176689148,
-0.23055718839168549,
0.6969695687294006,
0.4861733615398407,
-0.17528881132602692,
0.9785761833190918,
0.7888330817222595,
-0.10812827199697495,
0.2201448678970337,
-0.3205575942993164,
-0.522551953792572,
-0.22446317970752716,
-0.451937735080719,
-0.12811309099197388,
0.5344532132148743,
0.8473914265632629,
-0.034484781324863434,
0.5286332368850708,
-0.0676649659872055,
-0.08258324861526489,
0.2970236837863922,
-0.3197031319141388,
0.8232597708702087,
-0.020342594012618065,
-1.1250271797180176,
0.2297666221857071,
-0.5907162427902222,
0.2730037271976471,
-0.175047367811203,
-0.17999891936779022,
-0.046300433576107025,
0.3877985179424286,
-0.1313469558954239,
-0.9066047668457031,
0.3199610412120819,
-0.14542096853256226,
-0.28881868720054626,
-0.06848518550395966,
0.6376509070396423,
-0.34972018003463745,
-0.5357533693313599,
0.08995208889245987,
0.5306892395019531,
0.023806840181350708,
0.18608851730823517,
-0.6256792545318604,
-0.23316477239131927,
-0.10841306298971176,
-0.32452428340911865,
0.11191829293966293,
0.782703161239624,
-0.1285385936498642,
0.9162114262580872,
0.7116537690162659,
-0.07041005045175552,
-0.08725159615278244,
0.09804316610097885,
0.9504706263542175,
-0.7672464847564697,
-0.4775244891643524,
-0.6203349232673645,
0.536445140838623,
-0.3854929506778717,
-0.43867963552474976,
0.762094259262085,
0.6985089182853699,
0.7634835243225098,
0.01902654953300953,
1.1096607446670532,
-0.04012908786535263,
0.4535166025161743,
-0.46692371368408203,
0.5429921746253967,
-0.297739177942276,
0.06712226569652557,
0.13178414106369019,
-0.8150001168251038,
-0.21851159632205963,
0.3597770929336548,
-0.34904944896698,
0.022650254890322685,
0.6805936694145203,
0.49899086356163025,
0.145265132188797,
0.5110517144203186,
0.1409941017627716,
0.1407901644706726,
0.3103160262107849,
0.559532880783081,
0.7214250564575195,
-0.41959163546562195,
0.10884040594100952,
-0.09828513115644455,
-0.27550578117370605,
-0.13236507773399353,
-0.4386533200740814,
-1.0047320127487183,
-0.5702235698699951,
-0.20842406153678894,
-0.2315198928117752,
-0.040036190301179886,
0.9682016372680664,
0.5493300557136536,
-1.0853564739227295,
-0.001164210494607687,
-0.428864061832428,
0.061613939702510834,
-0.06387972831726074,
-0.3453015387058258,
0.41628649830818176,
-0.213787242770195,
-1.1897618770599365,
0.4636088013648987,
0.4491700530052185,
0.1261587142944336,
-0.6612164378166199,
-0.002549273893237114,
-0.2824593186378479,
0.7097689509391785,
0.5711580514907837,
0.1471804678440094,
-0.27328214049339294,
-0.35848209261894226,
0.24440783262252808,
-0.05295346677303314,
-0.10902801156044006,
0.6149646639823914,
-1.1588736772537231,
0.7173481583595276,
0.6273636817932129,
0.6401885151863098,
0.3163885772228241,
-0.27595260739326477,
0.8515649437904358,
-0.20340371131896973,
0.5974462628364563,
0.5802674889564514,
0.3618449568748474,
0.4675619602203369,
-0.4680330753326416,
0.6580935120582581,
0.3446377217769623,
-0.6244775652885437,
-0.6157534718513489,
0.10993243008852005,
-0.9688164591789246,
-0.40017279982566833,
0.4250054657459259,
-0.02336646430194378,
-0.4447644054889679,
-0.40590885281562805,
-0.18809188902378082,
0.16975295543670654,
-0.5418263673782349,
1.2260007858276367,
0.8178356289863586,
-0.17417150735855103,
0.04301634803414345,
-0.5384020209312439,
0.4781055450439453,
0.5926616191864014,
-1.181612253189087,
-0.3010452389717102,
0.6554259657859802,
-0.24521276354789734,
0.21374453604221344,
0.3573538661003113,
-0.12366253137588501,
0.3332347273826599,
0.37319207191467285,
0.05220452696084976,
0.1442042738199234,
-0.5335226655006409,
0.20964495837688446,
0.38934755325317383,
-0.3825632631778717,
0.15889084339141846
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.