id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08888v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08888v1
|
Towards Enhancing Health Coaching Dialogue in Low-Resource Settings
| 2024-04-13T03:23:15 | 2024-04-13T03:23:15 |
Yue Zhou, Barbara Di Eugenio, Brian Ziebart, Lisa Sharp, Bing Liu, Ben Gerber, Nikolaos Agadakos, Shweta Yadav
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Health coaching helps patients identify and accomplish lifestyle-related
goals, effectively improving the control of chronic diseases and mitigating
mental health conditions. However, health coaching is cost-prohibitive due to
its highly personalized and labor-intensive nature. In this paper, we propose
to build a dialogue system that converses with the patients, helps them create
and accomplish specific goals, and can address their emotions with empathy.
However, building such a system is challenging since real-world health coaching
datasets are limited and empathy is subtle. Thus, we propose a modularized
health coaching dialogue system with simplified NLU and NLG frameworks combined
with mechanism-conditioned empathetic response generation. Through automatic
and human evaluation, we show that our system generates more empathetic,
fluent, and coherent responses and outperforms the state-of-the-art in NLU
tasks while requiring less annotation. We view our approach as a key step
towards building automated and more accessible health coaching systems.
|
[
-0.24045869708061218,
-0.6791651248931885,
0.5245810747146606,
0.15793903172016144,
-0.1611413061618805,
-0.0011996454559266567,
-0.23536288738250732,
-0.44292983412742615,
0.7814965844154358,
0.07590842992067337,
-0.9712176322937012,
-0.40277254581451416,
-0.4971313178539276,
0.3199268877506256,
0.625368058681488,
0.7881184816360474,
0.2789875566959381,
0.4124222993850708,
0.10244777798652649,
-0.4392053782939911,
-0.5278289914131165,
-0.1716168373823166,
-1.0245485305786133,
-0.43153277039527893,
0.5327883958816528,
0.5279843807220459,
0.6033425331115723,
0.2887541949748993,
0.4639692008495331,
0.2966884970664978,
-0.02921305038034916,
0.5307623744010925,
-0.29610052704811096,
0.47695696353912354,
-0.013449229300022125,
-0.36734917759895325,
-1.0937845706939697,
-0.21385876834392548,
-0.1062973365187645,
0.6290130019187927,
-0.3493266999721527,
0.20244170725345612,
0.18495766818523407,
0.6305985450744629,
-0.3939928114414215,
0.3018031716346741,
-0.31824204325675964,
0.5605802536010742,
0.34494340419769287,
-0.27261921763420105,
-0.027569416910409927,
-0.1348295658826828,
0.06348961591720581,
-0.7404636740684509,
-0.13864286243915558,
0.13810884952545166,
0.2511821389198303,
0.6933902502059937,
-0.22854019701480865,
-0.035539496690034866,
-0.5684736967086792,
0.6293995976448059,
-1.071218490600586,
-0.10050095617771149,
0.7071520090103149,
0.29124853014945984,
-0.09443840384483337,
-0.1310630738735199,
-0.18324074149131775,
0.24371212720870972,
-0.3938356637954712,
0.6592223048210144,
-0.17904283106327057,
0.4366786777973175,
0.35489603877067566,
0.2056412547826767,
-0.41925403475761414,
0.10024750977754593,
0.05893116444349289,
0.2392834573984146,
0.6807109117507935,
0.6593295335769653,
0.2259775996208191,
-0.6158145070075989,
0.4075063169002533,
0.4102586507797241,
-0.05946214869618416,
-0.09285322576761246,
-0.0293887946754694,
0.3717653751373291,
-0.3264020085334778,
0.4032333195209503,
-0.4910995364189148,
0.4927395284175873,
0.27315643429756165,
-0.6280041337013245,
-0.04194642975926399,
-0.12436368316411972,
-0.31607770919799805,
0.2281634509563446,
0.5750179290771484,
0.8212324976921082,
-0.26538708806037903,
-0.2971334457397461,
0.16703684628009796,
-0.08228584378957748,
0.6348280906677246,
-1.0640647411346436,
-0.15477856993675232,
0.5765680074691772,
-0.8080196380615234,
-0.27345016598701477,
-0.4206539988517761,
-0.7856424450874329,
-0.2856450378894806,
-0.28914105892181396,
0.08856644481420517,
-0.43369045853614807,
-0.18243347108364105,
0.044950220733881,
0.00023213350505102426,
0.13459612429141998,
0.3811987340450287,
-0.8703588247299194,
0.3161730468273163,
0.5051756501197815,
0.8835643529891968,
0.18121863901615143,
0.44116654992103577,
-0.5936648845672607,
0.30642223358154297,
0.05377662926912308,
0.6287893652915955,
-0.5244711637496948,
-0.7137737274169922,
0.12791341543197632,
-0.07299088686704636,
0.2202685922384262,
-0.4283910095691681,
0.6464706659317017,
0.30102258920669556,
0.16134217381477356,
-0.3791499137878418,
-0.462947279214859,
0.5103803277015686,
0.6105316877365112,
-0.28922179341316223,
0.5616743564605713,
0.3508547246456146,
-0.7679821848869324,
0.2799065113067627,
-0.8921809196472168,
-0.6721382737159729,
0.45973050594329834,
-0.2630282938480377,
-0.28791528940200806,
0.33149096369743347,
0.3187330663204193,
0.3565302789211273,
-0.5812556743621826,
0.003836953081190586,
-0.4539051949977875,
-0.22991393506526947,
-0.13441932201385498,
-0.12197970598936081,
0.40181416273117065,
0.22309836745262146,
-0.4582754969596863,
0.04628261178731918,
-0.6831783056259155,
0.36184918880462646,
-0.27469202876091003,
-0.36287549138069153,
-0.32049819827079773,
0.04577955976128578,
-0.22812794148921967,
-0.006439963821321726,
-0.31294378638267517,
-0.5268594026565552,
0.26818370819091797,
-0.5562794208526611,
0.6048336625099182,
0.5272824764251709,
0.0036639515310525894,
0.6979858875274658,
-0.33104759454727173,
0.7003463506698608,
-0.24775418639183044,
0.5453287363052368,
-0.2562623918056488,
-0.674589991569519,
-0.3776768743991852,
-0.6155129075050354,
-0.35023677349090576,
0.5473814606666565,
-0.6872761249542236,
0.8678706884384155,
-0.12726882100105286,
-0.43476295471191406,
-1.0420639514923096,
-0.03673502802848816,
0.4341557025909424,
0.9009789824485779,
0.5506337881088257,
-0.41695669293403625,
-0.2280658781528473,
-0.7266910672187805,
-0.24575205147266388,
-0.09537618607282639,
-0.14971895515918732,
0.9673468470573425,
0.21846503019332886,
-0.2583096921443939,
0.6686381101608276,
-0.5568690299987793,
-0.49667254090309143,
-0.3422870635986328,
-0.0032047838903963566,
0.031173918396234512,
0.6237714290618896,
0.27961358428001404,
-0.5183950066566467,
-0.6332194805145264,
-0.02410559356212616,
-0.8310279846191406,
-0.13278315961360931,
0.10899052768945694,
-0.4261089265346527,
-0.1352596879005432,
0.11983156949281693,
-0.5504580736160278,
0.7228794097900391,
0.43980175256729126,
-0.33042991161346436,
0.1886264681816101,
-0.03792596980929375,
0.41619929671287537,
-1.3135435581207275,
0.21021883189678192,
-0.20807503163814545,
-0.18809494376182556,
-0.46615564823150635,
-0.5594907999038696,
-0.5393856763839722,
-0.2936749756336212,
-0.19139957427978516,
0.5666543841362,
-0.02528923936188221,
0.2669818103313446,
-0.16859367489814758,
-0.3024485409259796,
0.06395497918128967,
0.5881425142288208,
-0.0010115221375599504,
0.06425993144512177,
0.41853490471839905,
-0.2305884212255478,
0.6396942138671875,
0.7304368615150452,
-0.1283208429813385,
1.4330239295959473,
-0.7392920255661011,
0.04767715558409691,
0.00642589433118701,
0.8768863081932068,
-0.3889646530151367,
-0.6652379035949707,
0.5516898036003113,
-0.2833636999130249,
0.12924911081790924,
-0.24479974806308746,
-0.08437179774045944,
-0.4154629707336426,
-0.042831968516111374,
0.49507957696914673,
0.6451558470726013,
-0.12088948488235474,
0.6321784257888794,
0.33142033219337463,
-0.31309112906455994,
-0.3607732951641083,
-0.7072063088417053,
-0.0000260202959907474,
-0.24465268850326538,
-0.5592978000640869,
0.2280234694480896,
-0.15109537541866302,
-0.24973836541175842,
0.3107824921607971,
-0.21536342799663544,
-0.19043351709842682,
0.06790594756603241,
0.507604718208313,
-0.057958316057920456,
-0.02868732064962387,
0.3618503510951996,
0.5553942918777466,
-0.174897238612175,
0.07006645202636719,
-0.4848465919494629,
0.23162877559661865,
-0.05140241980552673,
-0.4236597716808319,
-0.8370730876922607,
0.9591171741485596,
0.2775530219078064,
-0.1143668070435524,
0.8860680460929871,
0.7334248423576355,
-0.36370107531547546,
-0.22181953489780426,
-0.3339827358722687,
-0.6220215559005737,
-0.40530505776405334,
0.15004906058311462,
0.0073427134193480015,
-0.8782609105110168,
0.2273765653371811,
-0.18084529042243958,
0.005639806389808655,
-0.17444731295108795,
0.7862189412117004,
-0.19835080206394196,
1.2255719900131226,
0.17085565626621246,
0.22495344281196594,
0.32926711440086365,
-0.14518672227859497,
0.33540573716163635,
-0.9150532484054565,
-0.3113745450973511,
-0.19255253672599792,
-0.6799486875534058,
-0.5238762497901917,
-0.22657646238803864,
0.6647884249687195,
-0.18378129601478577,
-0.3431154489517212,
0.017938939854502678,
-0.8765791058540344,
-0.020457526668906212,
0.41606056690216064,
0.7484577894210815,
0.02198866568505764,
-0.6645947694778442,
-0.1383516490459442,
-0.3057730197906494,
-0.8431001305580139,
-0.2523600161075592,
0.38370245695114136,
0.013223248533904552,
0.8069359064102173,
0.1993933618068695,
0.8792855739593506,
0.1086169108748436,
0.6950386166572571,
-1.3199596405029297,
0.17337769269943237,
-0.01279456540942192,
-0.5755751729011536,
-0.2755691707134247,
-0.47855356335639954,
-0.6735190749168396,
0.1232970654964447,
-0.4436686635017395,
-0.5778206586837769,
0.12163473665714264,
0.5064364075660706,
-1.0007445812225342,
0.2881371080875397,
-0.6036569476127625,
0.8501506447792053,
-0.07102064788341522,
-0.5022727847099304,
-0.20602825284004211,
-0.7957236170768738,
0.1602245420217514,
0.052502572536468506,
0.17465174198150635,
-0.5463446378707886,
0.37024039030075073,
0.4130685329437256,
-0.7391051054000854,
0.9781097173690796,
-0.2957054674625397,
0.19547119736671448,
0.0704115480184555,
0.12267908453941345,
0.14432965219020844,
0.5420669317245483,
-0.15533095598220825,
-0.5541048645973206,
-0.1393563598394394,
-0.6550040245056152,
-0.9311268329620361,
0.5258446931838989,
-0.3824392557144165,
-0.66715008020401,
0.04540054500102997,
-0.42824044823646545,
-0.632545530796051,
-0.002239171415567398,
0.007298563607037067,
0.5426956415176392,
-0.4615360200405121,
0.15811066329479218,
0.3208982050418854,
-0.6449052095413208,
0.24184367060661316,
0.32108554244041443,
0.4041013717651367,
-0.34438833594322205,
0.3941701352596283,
-0.16942301392555237,
0.18335974216461182,
0.18373359739780426,
0.47905147075653076,
0.26300492882728577,
0.2723817229270935,
-0.11099346727132797,
0.08978403359651566,
-0.2954450845718384,
-0.6926732063293457,
-0.5513560175895691,
0.11869389563798904,
-0.6390056610107422,
-0.40888547897338867,
-0.32727134227752686,
-0.20148098468780518,
-0.10824905335903168,
-0.20272865891456604,
0.44912970066070557,
0.5167075395584106,
-0.4035986363887787,
0.3885320723056793,
-1.1475880146026611,
-0.010880669578909874,
0.5434216856956482,
0.22637978196144104,
0.2964540123939514,
-0.19172348082065582,
-0.48489686846733093,
-0.04724303260445595,
-0.31927812099456787,
-0.8690260052680969,
0.6524405479431152,
0.1222643181681633,
0.16826224327087402,
0.6419432163238525,
0.3210219740867615,
0.8125598430633545,
-0.9097368121147156,
0.7236310839653015,
0.5201346278190613,
-0.843471884727478,
0.8463578224182129,
-0.28429925441741943,
0.2721695601940155,
0.6744633316993713,
0.27778416872024536,
-0.5795735120773315,
-0.26819363236427307,
-0.6092793345451355,
-0.7232149243354797,
0.7378097176551819,
-0.0055246357806026936,
0.46555984020233154,
-0.2929706871509552,
0.5153937339782715,
-0.1619604080915451,
0.18713931739330292,
-0.011486083269119263,
-0.06852884590625763,
-0.4508524537086487,
-0.47161242365837097,
0.34080368280410767,
0.09470859169960022,
-0.6608304381370544,
-0.34943050146102905,
0.4324977397918701,
-0.4857329726219177,
0.4901748299598694,
0.45232516527175903,
0.38928455114364624,
-0.2286360263824463,
0.48003971576690674,
0.20237956941127777,
-0.12676170468330383,
-0.12583713233470917,
-0.017578521743416786,
0.3769424855709076,
0.02901330776512623,
-0.04387221112847328,
-0.26601797342300415,
0.41219180822372437,
0.013085086829960346,
0.42457321286201477,
0.8385099768638611,
0.6505460739135742,
-0.4979454278945923,
0.38835445046424866,
-0.16091857850551605,
-0.08895328640937805,
0.15425775945186615,
0.2487242966890335,
0.35919633507728577,
0.3907664120197296,
-0.13813534379005432,
0.02040356583893299,
0.3354630172252655,
-0.45465412735939026,
0.118128702044487,
0.3991444408893585,
-0.7601776719093323,
-0.49933701753616333,
0.6678217053413391,
0.8026824593544006,
-0.7862602472305298,
0.49470219016075134,
-0.0025246411096304655,
-0.48014035820961,
0.21882565319538116,
0.33830025792121887,
0.7548974752426147,
-0.16660647094249725,
0.5327199697494507,
0.35706114768981934,
-0.09586019068956375,
-0.03821926936507225,
0.17215020954608917,
-0.43977779150009155,
-0.5323693156242371,
-0.433006227016449,
-0.5803572535514832,
-0.8294048309326172,
-0.35485419631004333,
-1.1775861978530884,
-0.21855321526527405,
-0.2912985384464264,
-0.5650244951248169,
-0.00576367974281311,
-0.1303573101758957,
-0.8534788489341736,
0.3110024631023407,
0.1075400859117508,
0.5246281623840332,
-0.6754169464111328,
0.5589003562927246,
0.5439854264259338,
-0.43153271079063416,
-0.8723911046981812,
-0.09739481657743454,
0.16008637845516205,
-0.9074132442474365,
0.6149619221687317,
0.09295029193162918,
-0.19931280612945557,
-0.13586707413196564,
-0.5727354884147644,
-0.0929812416434288,
1.2456775903701782,
0.3667667508125305,
-0.12463397532701492,
-0.48326003551483154,
-0.12216690927743912,
0.705852210521698,
-0.4816282391548157,
0.2906874418258667,
0.3930266201496124,
0.5242367386817932,
0.06491103768348694,
-1.0252362489700317,
0.09811906516551971,
-0.14856846630573273,
-0.08530522882938385,
-0.30138853192329407,
-0.9137864708900452,
0.3027959167957306,
-0.38534069061279297,
0.001706332666799426,
0.14435143768787384,
0.19824199378490448,
-0.0643538236618042,
-0.006743553560227156,
0.32563015818595886,
0.5925717353820801,
0.8179980516433716,
-0.023409415036439896,
1.1167967319488525,
-0.5034452080726624,
0.24723117053508759,
1.1625021696090698,
-0.43291497230529785,
0.48236480355262756,
0.4204971194267273,
0.08927042782306671,
0.2334454208612442,
0.3829227387905121,
0.1230073794722557,
0.3255559504032135,
0.1386367380619049,
-0.7740851044654846,
-0.46811598539352417,
-0.7264844179153442,
0.054743967950344086,
0.27246466279029846,
0.20635145902633667,
-0.3683193027973175,
-0.07897584140300751,
0.0782570093870163,
0.26737073063850403,
-0.050623081624507904,
-0.22488538920879364,
1.0064549446105957,
0.6058070063591003,
-0.6107040047645569,
0.13798809051513672,
-0.22385099530220032,
0.5691928863525391,
-0.4553637206554413,
-0.07183810323476791,
-0.3846287727355957,
0.054974183440208435,
-0.5098395347595215,
-0.2715408205986023,
0.4126887321472168,
0.15398919582366943,
-0.09747562557458878,
-0.5983151197433472,
0.46958041191101074,
-0.4980502128601074,
-0.2031569629907608,
0.4522234797477722,
0.8501224517822266,
0.014721290208399296,
0.28842681646347046,
-0.8729151487350464,
-0.21516567468643188,
-0.29486754536628723,
-0.26224663853645325,
0.27502837777137756,
0.6012873649597168,
0.5241856575012207,
0.3610854744911194,
0.3429800868034363,
0.24766987562179565,
-0.40070927143096924,
0.24463047087192535,
0.6751053333282471,
-0.48170503973960876,
-0.37725192308425903,
-0.6182297468185425,
0.5809510946273804,
-0.29533326625823975,
-0.1745063215494156,
0.48403987288475037,
0.025242403149604797,
0.15399843454360962,
0.03718193992972374,
0.9176244139671326,
-0.261456698179245,
0.46961331367492676,
-0.19212882220745087,
0.7484709024429321,
-0.7047520279884338,
-0.2650388479232788,
-0.20590321719646454,
-0.380720853805542,
-0.5562931895256042,
0.8791497945785522,
-0.04758588969707489,
-0.07884035259485245,
0.6119306683540344,
0.6141982674598694,
0.18150515854358673,
-0.043336886912584305,
0.5669728517532349,
0.12157577276229858,
0.5487455129623413,
0.6030151844024658,
0.512748122215271,
-0.02542884647846222,
0.31287917494773865,
0.013333555310964584,
-0.30717048048973083,
-0.12579433619976044,
-0.6467772126197815,
-0.8110048770904541,
-0.18764886260032654,
-0.2255491316318512,
-0.6328307390213013,
0.06613318622112274,
1.3832979202270508,
0.8373808264732361,
-0.5832208395004272,
0.09569577127695084,
0.23338070511817932,
-0.11796694993972778,
-0.09930547326803207,
-0.17630839347839355,
0.2413039356470108,
-0.44688382744789124,
-0.8277785181999207,
0.2835013270378113,
0.5670152902603149,
-0.3097578287124634,
-0.01625020243227482,
-0.2488594949245453,
0.4636732041835785,
0.3317841589450836,
0.5400075316429138,
0.27353134751319885,
-0.41940730810165405,
-0.28008851408958435,
0.014496497809886932,
-0.1441512256860733,
0.3336925208568573,
0.995405375957489,
-0.4064466059207916,
0.41234129667282104,
-0.035951390862464905,
0.7497588396072388,
0.21792937815189362,
0.11087194085121155,
0.5350512862205505,
-0.42869219183921814,
0.16622330248355865,
0.5735715627670288,
0.3559609651565552,
0.2822032868862152,
-0.35443633794784546,
0.4976682960987091,
0.15115654468536377,
-0.5804359912872314,
-0.7239336967468262,
0.4297156035900116,
-0.9552057385444641,
-0.004537553992122412,
1.1501948833465576,
-0.5370427966117859,
-0.23527805507183075,
-0.15576694905757904,
-0.5020937919616699,
0.41089317202568054,
-0.5175778269767761,
0.7648805975914001,
0.369781494140625,
-0.8643612861633301,
0.37054550647735596,
-0.18308566510677338,
0.7714741230010986,
0.501190185546875,
-1.1675188541412354,
-0.1078038290143013,
0.34864118695259094,
0.11038345843553543,
-0.16242572665214539,
0.9198509454727173,
0.1797771006822586,
-0.03389119356870651,
0.019711805507540703,
-0.0953357145190239,
0.21371744573116302,
0.27386075258255005,
0.08525338023900986,
-0.22261127829551697,
-0.438824325799942,
0.13087667524814606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08886v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08886v1
|
EIVEN: Efficient Implicit Attribute Value Extraction using Multimodal LLM
| 2024-04-13T03:15:56 | 2024-04-13T03:15:56 |
Henry Peng Zou, Gavin Heqing Yu, Ziwei Fan, Dan Bu, Han Liu, Peng Dai, Dongmei Jia, Cornelia Caragea
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
In e-commerce, accurately extracting product attribute values from multimodal
data is crucial for improving user experience and operational efficiency of
retailers. However, previous approaches to multimodal attribute value
extraction often struggle with implicit attribute values embedded in images or
text, rely heavily on extensive labeled data, and can easily confuse similar
attribute values. To address these issues, we introduce EIVEN, a data- and
parameter-efficient generative framework that pioneers the use of multimodal
LLM for implicit attribute value extraction. EIVEN leverages the rich inherent
knowledge of a pre-trained LLM and vision encoder to reduce reliance on labeled
data. We also introduce a novel Learning-by-Comparison technique to reduce
model confusion by enforcing attribute value comparison and difference
identification. Additionally, we construct initial open-source datasets for
multimodal implicit attribute value extraction. Our extensive experiments
reveal that EIVEN significantly outperforms existing methods in extracting
implicit attribute values while requiring less labeled data.
|
[
-0.19420021772384644,
-0.5984236001968384,
0.41529354453086853,
0.263575941324234,
-0.275570273399353,
-0.09006094187498093,
0.023363640531897545,
-0.8042789697647095,
-0.09004592895507812,
-0.16498005390167236,
-0.8752683997154236,
-0.5395040512084961,
-0.6283593773841858,
0.08762280642986298,
-0.28296858072280884,
0.9015923142433167,
0.2242993861436844,
-0.04561784490942955,
-0.5185980796813965,
-0.3702499568462372,
0.26290449500083923,
-0.3191671371459961,
-0.7685357928276062,
0.023296717554330826,
0.9532509446144104,
0.02567279152572155,
0.4632114768028259,
0.4897820055484772,
0.48154503107070923,
0.34009966254234314,
0.057815227657556534,
0.5559738278388977,
-0.4458577334880829,
0.28002625703811646,
0.2336081862449646,
-0.18524029850959778,
-0.7798519730567932,
0.1499139964580536,
0.08980313688516617,
0.1952492594718933,
-0.1506628394126892,
0.30240094661712646,
-0.14957523345947266,
0.6214268803596497,
-1.0078474283218384,
0.5874728560447693,
-0.369638592004776,
0.2126268893480301,
-0.1417444944381714,
0.05604429543018341,
-0.32800740003585815,
-0.46337124705314636,
0.038509294390678406,
-1.02333664894104,
0.35040679574012756,
0.14149916172027588,
1.1200319528579712,
0.37135791778564453,
-0.551196813583374,
-0.18637053668498993,
-0.6927726864814758,
0.9062079191207886,
-0.2701663672924042,
0.8543232083320618,
0.17334847152233124,
-0.0013934073504060507,
0.17536701261997223,
-0.957790732383728,
-0.878092348575592,
-0.06705860793590546,
-0.1579543799161911,
0.49200335144996643,
-0.2799696624279022,
0.007753914687782526,
0.28725776076316833,
0.2580311894416809,
-0.40564873814582825,
0.01912841387093067,
-0.21908073127269745,
0.1122172623872757,
0.5769817233085632,
0.05560745671391487,
0.13801032304763794,
-0.26352164149284363,
-0.5699866414070129,
-0.42647117376327515,
-0.8003666400909424,
0.11632779240608215,
0.2789120674133301,
-0.18877267837524414,
0.010275698266923428,
0.4384410083293915,
-0.23908697068691254,
0.5661205053329468,
0.13414694368839264,
-0.6566576957702637,
0.5525509119033813,
-0.2922514081001282,
-0.34903380274772644,
-0.0834178552031517,
0.58777916431427,
0.35584506392478943,
-0.11144202947616577,
-0.1419355422258377,
-0.23335908353328705,
-0.1778600513935089,
0.02765914611518383,
-0.7205408811569214,
-0.3052578568458557,
0.07409767806529999,
-0.6290510892868042,
-0.21481862664222717,
0.16697348654270172,
-0.9187809228897095,
-0.23871807754039764,
-0.42262002825737,
0.28547561168670654,
0.10009632259607315,
-0.2667843997478485,
-0.27167126536369324,
-0.22354748845100403,
0.6498528122901917,
0.7142096161842346,
-0.8252399563789368,
-0.06292599439620972,
0.7337189316749573,
0.8166126012802124,
-0.41837278008461,
0.10906367748975754,
-0.2505037188529968,
0.4696284532546997,
-0.05896390601992607,
0.63686603307724,
-0.5258827209472656,
-0.07511596381664276,
-0.2356940656900406,
0.1793745756149292,
0.21233686804771423,
-0.4610178470611572,
0.24203790724277496,
-0.7995288968086243,
-0.20551691949367523,
0.052165836095809937,
-0.2989957630634308,
-0.1826520562171936,
0.5107473134994507,
-1.2407410144805908,
1.0452135801315308,
-0.03818383812904358,
-0.24376390874385834,
0.8147986531257629,
-0.4995504319667816,
-0.41701412200927734,
0.12076278775930405,
-0.25587454438209534,
-0.7858473062515259,
0.3101227879524231,
0.39282119274139404,
0.6130343675613403,
-0.5135261416435242,
-0.15790145099163055,
-0.4536340832710266,
0.14197103679180145,
0.41108664870262146,
-0.8894723057746887,
0.48845893144607544,
0.4091135263442993,
-0.2801717221736908,
-0.13317053020000458,
-0.8493064045906067,
0.13505898416042328,
0.16465333104133606,
-0.3496813178062439,
-0.3319481313228607,
-0.09663639962673187,
0.28998836874961853,
0.3288414180278778,
0.2771109640598297,
-0.6726897358894348,
0.01647837646305561,
0.12712977826595306,
-0.03426244482398033,
1.1855559349060059,
-0.4422590732574463,
0.39720404148101807,
-0.15340958535671234,
0.5307859778404236,
-0.03659624233841896,
0.409111350774765,
-0.05199320986866951,
-0.4265507161617279,
-0.9794431328773499,
-0.6999252438545227,
0.2096271961927414,
0.304964154958725,
-0.7744201421737671,
0.07799596339464188,
-0.4284704923629761,
-0.24056436121463776,
-0.5396706461906433,
0.26293298602104187,
0.2887316048145294,
0.4727439284324646,
0.2930580973625183,
-0.0011962995631620288,
-0.18359167873859406,
-0.9926363229751587,
-0.05413341894745827,
-0.12492761015892029,
-0.11962178349494934,
0.6667636036872864,
0.4320869743824005,
-0.1354728490114212,
0.7875306010246277,
-0.8244588971138,
-0.39925339818000793,
-0.20263221859931946,
0.5348565578460693,
0.04283980280160904,
0.4507119953632355,
0.007746183779090643,
-1.2148488759994507,
-0.44795510172843933,
0.16733406484127045,
-0.7983250021934509,
-0.12518419325351715,
-0.34883812069892883,
-0.14890146255493164,
0.24635502696037292,
0.22138608992099762,
-0.6110196709632874,
0.5433635711669922,
0.4804643392562866,
-0.13208627700805664,
0.19393661618232727,
-0.325343519449234,
0.3805069625377655,
-0.9076531529426575,
-0.15970595180988312,
0.3137744665145874,
-0.2636106014251709,
-0.39890310168266296,
-0.013364874757826328,
0.37148517370224,
0.13334143161773682,
-0.8678460717201233,
0.36647912859916687,
-0.5765542387962341,
-0.05240999162197113,
0.19494444131851196,
-0.09668970108032227,
0.4438167214393616,
0.5207998156547546,
0.19293631613254547,
0.6235076189041138,
0.062162354588508606,
-0.716781735420227,
0.9003375172615051,
0.23704975843429565,
-0.32829388976097107,
0.9924830198287964,
-0.49215438961982727,
0.2952759265899658,
-0.4879274368286133,
-0.02559472806751728,
-0.790371835231781,
-0.02559754252433777,
0.2993149757385254,
0.030711932107806206,
0.45549097657203674,
-0.26337340474128723,
-0.49717745184898376,
0.0698639526963234,
-0.36765214800834656,
0.7413066029548645,
0.3550291955471039,
-0.8757234811782837,
1.0798730850219727,
0.1630280613899231,
-0.21536928415298462,
-0.5548564195632935,
-0.540519654750824,
-0.18534107506275177,
-0.25255638360977173,
-0.6561264395713806,
0.5870883464813232,
-0.21307681500911713,
0.04174397885799408,
0.009743654169142246,
-0.08077092468738556,
-0.11227349191904068,
0.06521309167146683,
0.2286561280488968,
0.3719804584980011,
0.09523668140172958,
0.43233972787857056,
0.04465079680085182,
-0.41841641068458557,
-0.059833209961652756,
0.011524947360157967,
-0.08234062045812607,
-0.16106650233268738,
-0.6100592017173767,
-0.18071231245994568,
0.4312199056148529,
0.3421974778175354,
-0.11804184317588806,
0.7747942805290222,
0.7585431337356567,
-0.29160910844802856,
-0.18993662297725677,
-0.6644938588142395,
-0.016199875622987747,
-0.48354727029800415,
0.5881094336509705,
-0.46623143553733826,
-0.47016477584838867,
0.14604555070400238,
-0.3373982608318329,
-0.1152368038892746,
0.37732985615730286,
0.21726372838020325,
-0.40892383456230164,
1.4516812562942505,
0.6808056235313416,
0.6000052094459534,
0.34237831830978394,
-0.14612913131713867,
0.09744232147932053,
-0.784996747970581,
-1.0138424634933472,
-0.2351154386997223,
-0.5260166525840759,
-0.36311790347099304,
-0.284869521856308,
0.5800482034683228,
-0.11341379582881927,
-0.21466298401355743,
-0.064829520881176,
-0.2823047935962677,
0.43716058135032654,
0.4365620017051697,
0.6804439425468445,
0.3405971825122833,
0.1758326292037964,
0.27925223112106323,
-0.19708603620529175,
-0.34195882081985474,
-0.06807687133550644,
1.1203486919403076,
0.23306894302368164,
1.2441222667694092,
0.5549729466438293,
0.1100560799241066,
0.2085382640361786,
0.5779573917388916,
-0.9168446660041809,
0.3270529806613922,
-0.3395995795726776,
-0.4825964868068695,
0.014068982563912868,
-0.41298121213912964,
-0.7181146144866943,
0.30303066968917847,
-0.40011799335479736,
-0.3191847801208496,
0.45408645272254944,
0.16815213859081268,
-0.4120137393474579,
0.20308129489421844,
-0.7112604975700378,
0.7939372062683105,
-0.8769295811653137,
-0.7471280694007874,
0.14024297893047333,
-0.4481082856655121,
-0.03479450196027756,
-0.0628792941570282,
-0.05099982023239136,
-0.27888190746307373,
-0.37926629185676575,
0.768957257270813,
-0.2921454608440399,
0.5551337003707886,
0.1264248490333557,
-0.16174112260341644,
-0.17612095177173615,
-0.2068953514099121,
0.5499814748764038,
0.06532292068004608,
0.18704229593276978,
0.21532925963401794,
-0.2614401876926422,
-0.25817281007766724,
-0.8487692475318909,
0.6325322389602661,
-0.7143009901046753,
-0.39142853021621704,
-0.5008059144020081,
-0.36689117550849915,
-0.006654237397015095,
-0.1410195678472519,
0.111688032746315,
0.361952006816864,
-0.14006134867668152,
0.38136011362075806,
0.9770819544792175,
-0.3246877193450928,
0.6476300954818726,
0.33468106389045715,
0.09844858944416046,
-0.5010966062545776,
1.022328495979309,
-0.15731550753116608,
0.36542803049087524,
0.47702404856681824,
0.001235263654962182,
-0.6918515563011169,
0.11369678378105164,
-0.6592403650283813,
-0.08710617572069168,
-1.1117348670959473,
-0.39522290229797363,
-0.6309070587158203,
-0.04174518212676048,
-0.1746031641960144,
-0.10278046131134033,
-0.40739354491233826,
-0.32525041699409485,
-0.3460133969783783,
-0.3491784334182739,
0.6320701241493225,
0.8338057398796082,
-0.13966728746891022,
0.20333924889564514,
-0.6908237934112549,
0.45764660835266113,
0.9456726312637329,
0.18457648158073425,
0.003172258846461773,
0.1111835241317749,
-0.11142020672559738,
-0.04263241961598396,
-0.2264707088470459,
-0.876180112361908,
0.5084205269813538,
0.5356413125991821,
0.7425652742385864,
0.8547176718711853,
-0.14164790511131287,
0.9276111125946045,
-0.13152407109737396,
0.6918829083442688,
0.46975335478782654,
-0.7442352175712585,
0.30675047636032104,
0.26582032442092896,
0.22112759947776794,
0.24269749224185944,
0.6076475381851196,
-0.3305613696575165,
0.2942764163017273,
-0.32213470339775085,
-1.2195844650268555,
0.7067995667457581,
0.16686533391475677,
0.138805091381073,
0.10024607181549072,
0.21912717819213867,
0.37057408690452576,
0.411954790353775,
-1.1365766525268555,
-0.6515164971351624,
-0.35714012384414673,
-0.4670560359954834,
0.002866415772587061,
-0.327005535364151,
-0.15736551582813263,
-0.5836562514305115,
0.32631418108940125,
-0.20233702659606934,
0.4386431574821472,
0.08467557281255722,
-0.682711660861969,
0.439874529838562,
0.27455586194992065,
0.43486472964286804,
0.46845754981040955,
-0.07463279366493225,
0.4037195146083832,
0.22477364540100098,
-0.42389529943466187,
0.35476258397102356,
0.14946630597114563,
-0.14539644122123718,
-0.3717222213745117,
0.03656110540032387,
0.7743419408798218,
0.033892542123794556,
-0.4982340633869171,
0.7177832126617432,
-0.19110603630542755,
-0.0003189754788763821,
-0.5535027384757996,
-0.3033101558685303,
-0.13549359142780304,
0.2139841914176941,
0.3686191737651825,
0.015637751668691635,
0.24685342609882355,
-0.17868909239768982,
0.16140873730182648,
0.3055974543094635,
-0.42042091488838196,
-0.19392645359039307,
0.6976096630096436,
0.35510319471359253,
0.19401657581329346,
0.9575456380844116,
-0.20618388056755066,
-0.21891553699970245,
0.6866481304168701,
0.6243449449539185,
0.946647047996521,
0.05344270542263985,
0.38236305117607117,
0.13785628974437714,
0.24488519132137299,
0.18317051231861115,
0.21673505008220673,
-0.27896445989608765,
-0.7536059617996216,
-0.333241730928421,
-0.5568902492523193,
-0.026802247390151024,
0.018926041200757027,
-0.593725323677063,
0.09307597577571869,
-0.4086250364780426,
-0.13740293681621552,
-0.23561759293079376,
-0.6054925322532654,
-1.0746053457260132,
0.39683958888053894,
0.34488335251808167,
0.23638790845870972,
-0.6541628241539001,
0.34055933356285095,
0.39712923765182495,
-0.6717818379402161,
-0.566638708114624,
-0.5852717161178589,
0.14528577029705048,
-0.6079203486442566,
1.3797352313995361,
0.3785218596458435,
-0.3837338387966156,
-0.09032515436410904,
-0.6954751014709473,
-0.6227135062217712,
1.4504342079162598,
0.31859347224235535,
-0.4103739857673645,
0.153988778591156,
0.2889094650745392,
0.05836864933371544,
-0.559526801109314,
0.8932642936706543,
0.3886021077632904,
0.7296907901763916,
0.44768214225769043,
-0.2841091752052307,
0.00543894711881876,
-0.5214194655418396,
0.23928965628147125,
0.06265311688184738,
-0.4361748993396759,
1.0160789489746094,
-0.06912550330162048,
-0.3374207317829132,
-0.15031369030475616,
0.619878351688385,
-0.07997674494981766,
0.34549447894096375,
0.5330687761306763,
0.8178724050521851,
0.7741712331771851,
-0.37100133299827576,
0.8915842175483704,
0.16250792145729065,
0.26319649815559387,
0.7209178805351257,
-0.24431879818439484,
0.7818085551261902,
0.4318535625934601,
-0.07218409329652786,
0.6172897815704346,
0.5758439898490906,
-0.1487618088722229,
0.7341139912605286,
-0.19318464398384094,
-0.7295880317687988,
-0.5426819324493408,
-0.034093067049980164,
-0.2773439288139343,
0.3775533139705658,
0.36449405550956726,
-0.36900079250335693,
-0.007101007737219334,
0.07799287885427475,
-0.11240871250629425,
-0.4951413571834564,
-0.38870546221733093,
1.1230852603912354,
0.004147858824580908,
-0.011594881303608418,
0.173666849732399,
-0.013324430212378502,
0.7292456030845642,
-0.5494682788848877,
-0.4580432176589966,
-0.1424470841884613,
0.24880379438400269,
-0.38483259081840515,
-0.39186832308769226,
-0.1812165528535843,
-0.10621658712625504,
-0.24677617847919464,
-0.5838656425476074,
0.6353247165679932,
-0.48955631256103516,
-0.7599382996559143,
0.2123207300901413,
0.5906545519828796,
-0.11240784078836441,
0.004635675810277462,
-0.7628041505813599,
-0.15110257267951965,
-0.31808432936668396,
-0.3365919888019562,
0.15084221959114075,
0.25787147879600525,
0.28345218300819397,
0.8148341178894043,
0.8901541829109192,
-0.06302350014448166,
0.23522256314754486,
-0.015788426622748375,
0.7280819416046143,
-0.7201945781707764,
-0.26279759407043457,
-0.9031232595443726,
0.7727814316749573,
-0.48244428634643555,
-0.28129562735557556,
0.6343637108802795,
0.4854302704334259,
0.9516251683235168,
-0.16955432295799255,
0.561286449432373,
-0.08317039906978607,
-0.09082747250795364,
-0.7413720488548279,
0.8367840051651001,
-0.8565962910652161,
0.3604430556297302,
-0.25709718465805054,
-0.9316656589508057,
-0.3219035565853119,
0.7942909598350525,
0.11191429197788239,
0.2924869954586029,
0.7118839621543884,
0.9930906295776367,
-0.21265217661857605,
-0.06624658405780792,
0.36441531777381897,
-0.06865891814231873,
0.3814876973628998,
0.5877677202224731,
0.9481744766235352,
-0.5046402812004089,
0.6865097284317017,
-0.4376888871192932,
-0.32538315653800964,
0.0940394476056099,
-1.3164876699447632,
-0.4252186715602875,
-0.5566025972366333,
-0.5128133296966553,
-0.17955078184604645,
0.06516421586275101,
1.0654685497283936,
0.9650861620903015,
-0.7424526810646057,
0.10237065702676773,
0.24671098589897156,
0.3311035931110382,
-0.4322570264339447,
-0.21272264420986176,
0.37576866149902344,
0.17993372678756714,
-0.9643301963806152,
0.15517912805080414,
0.4210594892501831,
0.25885629653930664,
-0.1678803265094757,
-0.3203217685222626,
-0.06923189014196396,
-0.08738826215267181,
0.8674699664115906,
0.0817139744758606,
-0.5961114168167114,
-0.15475770831108093,
0.03492618352174759,
-0.052615877240896225,
0.15956462919712067,
0.6394835710525513,
-0.7504338026046753,
0.5520524382591248,
0.45767784118652344,
0.5827606320381165,
0.648617148399353,
-0.0452905111014843,
0.5225565433502197,
-0.8323819637298584,
0.15686888992786407,
-0.08419883251190186,
0.17968374490737915,
0.3222845494747162,
-0.31853485107421875,
0.2769175171852112,
0.3291606605052948,
-0.14790694415569305,
-0.2862105965614319,
0.5179175734519958,
-1.0087473392486572,
-0.10748378932476044,
1.1518378257751465,
-0.46106794476509094,
-0.4087173044681549,
-0.17491759359836578,
-0.020176665857434273,
0.048141323029994965,
-0.4399615526199341,
0.6374420523643494,
0.21174316108226776,
-0.07797462493181229,
-0.6894808411598206,
-0.14536744356155396,
0.4802760183811188,
0.17870035767555237,
-1.0363717079162598,
-0.5029330849647522,
0.6111283898353577,
0.03315811976790428,
-0.140238955616951,
0.20341737568378448,
-0.08565615862607956,
0.24638335406780243,
-0.11803069710731506,
0.2845253646373749,
-0.41874006390571594,
-0.45716795325279236,
-0.26991721987724304,
0.30112358927726746,
-0.047751061618328094,
-0.15399768948554993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08885v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08885v1
|
Is Next Token Prediction Sufficient for GPT? Exploration on Code Logic Comprehension
| 2024-04-13T03:11:07 | 2024-04-13T03:11:07 |
Mengnan Qi, Yufan Huang, Yongqiang Yao, Maoquan Wang, Bin Gu, Neel Sundaresan
|
cs.PL
|
cs.PL, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) has experienced exponential growth, they
demonstrate remarkable performance across various tasks. Notwithstanding,
contemporary research primarily centers on enhancing the size and quality of
pretraining data, still utilizing the next token prediction task on
autoregressive transformer model structure. The efficacy of this task in truly
facilitating the model's comprehension of code logic remains questionable, we
speculate that it still interprets code as mere text, while human emphasizes
the underlying logical knowledge. In order to prove it, we introduce a new
task, "Logically Equivalent Code Selection," which necessitates the selection
of logically equivalent code from a candidate set, given a query code. Our
experimental findings indicate that current LLMs underperform in this task,
since they understand code by unordered bag of keywords. To ameliorate their
performance, we propose an advanced pretraining task, "Next Token Prediction+".
This task aims to modify the sentence embedding distribution of the LLM without
sacrificing its generative capabilities. Our experimental results reveal that
following this pretraining, both Code Llama and StarCoder, the prevalent code
domain pretraining models, display significant improvements on our logically
equivalent code selection task and the code completion task.
|
[
-0.15281230211257935,
-0.4863446354866028,
0.6773508191108704,
-0.11344828456640244,
-0.45704561471939087,
0.3328673541545868,
-0.22375181317329407,
-0.4341108202934265,
-0.010145965963602066,
0.3837288022041321,
-0.5178478360176086,
-0.35623395442962646,
-0.7552761435508728,
0.170965313911438,
-0.42975127696990967,
1.063034176826477,
-0.06529474258422852,
0.09857475757598877,
-0.4400738775730133,
0.20480026304721832,
-0.7726675868034363,
-0.884515643119812,
-0.5543176531791687,
-0.5064214468002319,
0.2106408327817917,
-0.0032936299685388803,
0.5950263142585754,
0.5398064255714417,
0.5245103240013123,
0.25167444348335266,
0.02040940150618553,
-0.24611641466617584,
-0.2647719085216522,
-0.16697007417678833,
-0.005112772807478905,
-0.923086941242218,
-0.3602423667907715,
0.07076720148324966,
0.23079447448253632,
0.4797755181789398,
0.07492583990097046,
0.16965217888355255,
-0.06815507262945175,
0.5131110548973083,
-0.3465002179145813,
0.4208764135837555,
-1.2465455532073975,
0.25605931878089905,
0.03657124191522598,
-0.360093891620636,
-0.4492509663105011,
-0.22768983244895935,
-0.04625937342643738,
-0.5591784119606018,
0.18282611668109894,
0.2168223112821579,
0.6519587635993958,
0.4827237129211426,
-0.37467098236083984,
-0.17950940132141113,
-0.43170931935310364,
0.41720935702323914,
-0.536861777305603,
0.3307906687259674,
0.43655186891555786,
0.19200235605239868,
0.09207203984260559,
-1.0089130401611328,
-0.8924175500869751,
-0.4730728566646576,
-0.1509484499692917,
0.11254952847957611,
-0.19069573283195496,
0.17192919552326202,
0.35590454936027527,
0.15204252302646637,
-0.6251857876777649,
0.02121429145336151,
-0.36337801814079285,
-0.4566754400730133,
0.10699240863323212,
0.09823254495859146,
0.2503872215747833,
-0.05931946262717247,
-0.4273633360862732,
0.02376423589885235,
-0.9835713505744934,
-0.0004296304832678288,
0.1297616958618164,
-0.09017910808324814,
0.26792678236961365,
0.619056761264801,
0.0010522800730541348,
0.6491202712059021,
-0.11128595471382141,
0.15062111616134644,
0.46155235171318054,
-0.38294848799705505,
-0.46250224113464355,
-0.03876340389251709,
0.4288090765476227,
0.23533709347248077,
0.6001546382904053,
-0.19965916872024536,
-0.37224945425987244,
0.4963098466396332,
0.4507846534252167,
-0.7782019972801208,
-0.5559051632881165,
-0.03952805697917938,
-0.49777650833129883,
-0.2660275101661682,
0.18477362394332886,
-0.2700258195400238,
-0.1747513711452484,
-0.5987921953201294,
0.3336212635040283,
-0.30470719933509827,
-0.2106003761291504,
0.1842493712902069,
-0.10306809097528458,
0.2510075569152832,
0.07000946253538132,
-0.7654064297676086,
0.16080358624458313,
0.7926355600357056,
0.7695645093917847,
-0.10220473259687424,
-0.42519256472587585,
-0.6309687495231628,
-0.0256270170211792,
-0.39766988158226013,
0.7976009249687195,
-0.8416231274604797,
-0.43250179290771484,
-0.13888975977897644,
-0.09969119727611542,
-0.318904310464859,
-0.491694837808609,
0.5340073704719543,
-0.9161151647567749,
-0.04543796554207802,
-0.3545401096343994,
-0.6569256782531738,
0.017763037234544754,
0.17309273779392242,
-0.43112418055534363,
0.48567211627960205,
0.27649492025375366,
-0.8188835978507996,
0.6491556763648987,
-0.5349030494689941,
-0.4838869869709015,
-0.008604503236711025,
-0.4237560033798218,
-0.2546096444129944,
0.1925925314426422,
0.4043267071247101,
0.49808645248413086,
0.012812823057174683,
0.38551390171051025,
-0.18575464189052582,
-0.7390716075897217,
0.2810722589492798,
-0.39910104870796204,
0.34845778346061707,
0.2633007764816284,
-0.5423970222473145,
0.28778302669525146,
-0.30215126276016235,
0.1880992203950882,
0.009544572792947292,
-0.0939650908112526,
0.16443319618701935,
-0.016589505597949028,
-0.20516696572303772,
0.43940863013267517,
0.11449722945690155,
-0.25980255007743835,
0.3310472369194031,
-0.4090113341808319,
0.613282322883606,
1.1440051794052124,
-0.30282679200172424,
0.5078247785568237,
-0.18298082053661346,
0.9013208746910095,
-0.15150758624076843,
0.11259275674819946,
-0.25266900658607483,
-0.5218870043754578,
-0.5345888733863831,
-0.02933833934366703,
0.28630393743515015,
0.6266933679580688,
-0.9793756008148193,
0.44812291860580444,
-0.5430302619934082,
-0.11479295045137405,
-0.05946531146764755,
0.1733984649181366,
0.5006477236747742,
0.4222714900970459,
0.48308706283569336,
-0.25855740904808044,
-0.7848895788192749,
-0.5093634128570557,
-0.48358017206192017,
-0.49251019954681396,
-0.034670647233724594,
0.025641923770308495,
0.4965381324291229,
-0.4794245660305023,
0.8861852288246155,
-0.605207622051239,
-0.337012380361557,
-0.5151325464248657,
-0.1798916757106781,
0.3968024253845215,
0.37485048174858093,
0.3825085759162903,
-0.7721713781356812,
-0.32832247018814087,
-0.06563667207956314,
-0.4387621581554413,
0.09533803164958954,
-0.038630347698926926,
0.03132327273488045,
0.2312774360179901,
0.9653800129890442,
-0.5536076426506042,
0.3749571442604065,
0.6051455736160278,
-0.5237164497375488,
0.5974106192588806,
-0.20748262107372284,
-0.16657595336437225,
-0.7905772924423218,
0.021381953731179237,
-0.3829977512359619,
-0.2843933701515198,
-0.44349372386932373,
-0.026661107316613197,
0.18155425786972046,
-0.03948674723505974,
-0.20903271436691284,
0.5472815632820129,
-0.39280879497528076,
-0.26002201437950134,
-0.4750783443450928,
-0.14334380626678467,
-0.1853209137916565,
0.5193726420402527,
0.14317509531974792,
1.1382755041122437,
0.6193573474884033,
-0.3664056956768036,
0.12679052352905273,
0.2846527695655823,
-0.5600962042808533,
-0.11951321363449097,
-0.8004198670387268,
0.31980279088020325,
-0.08368153125047684,
0.5172286033630371,
-0.8954320549964905,
0.07430531829595566,
0.10353545099496841,
-0.6199038028717041,
0.2661963403224945,
-0.1186099424958229,
-0.575441300868988,
-0.60443514585495,
-0.08333229273557663,
0.4683597981929779,
0.945686936378479,
-0.5759459733963013,
0.3495977222919464,
0.19210770726203918,
-0.13018053770065308,
-0.6360532641410828,
-0.7053087949752808,
0.09344158321619034,
-0.16066628694534302,
-0.23399542272090912,
0.1827637106180191,
-0.027816908434033394,
0.07682736963033676,
0.011719748377799988,
-0.3357149660587311,
0.15118753910064697,
-0.021048318594694138,
0.14871171116828918,
0.603893518447876,
-0.11657846719026566,
0.22818733751773834,
-0.16701026260852814,
-0.40428903698921204,
0.33430567383766174,
-0.9757835268974304,
0.6688509583473206,
-0.12106732279062271,
-0.5068009495735168,
-0.1707005649805069,
-0.24297653138637543,
0.19941696524620056,
-0.4543715715408325,
0.48290544748306274,
0.818152129650116,
-0.12888337671756744,
-0.07926009595394135,
-0.5202236175537109,
-0.11819202452898026,
-0.503740131855011,
0.6066221594810486,
-0.5606935024261475,
-1.1555534601211548,
0.3724331557750702,
-0.03241272270679474,
-0.24356982111930847,
0.3895378112792969,
0.39499005675315857,
0.20146504044532776,
1.0256247520446777,
0.8052880167961121,
-0.4429330825805664,
0.5314795970916748,
-0.22450870275497437,
0.3109387457370758,
-0.6327297687530518,
-0.29326510429382324,
-0.4209215044975281,
-0.016888665035367012,
-0.29634883999824524,
-0.5940749645233154,
0.24384063482284546,
0.176887646317482,
-0.4127650558948517,
0.3579336106777191,
-0.5011953115463257,
0.7343857288360596,
0.3439640402793884,
-0.03227262943983078,
0.27641940116882324,
0.10407183319330215,
-0.08748471736907959,
0.12007977068424225,
-0.5939374566078186,
-0.2998706102371216,
1.5351108312606812,
0.15377072989940643,
0.48419952392578125,
-0.3704351484775543,
0.6245533227920532,
0.14945633709430695,
0.5745993852615356,
-0.4955729842185974,
0.3838229179382324,
-0.11341975629329681,
-0.3636801838874817,
-0.09539385885000229,
-0.5242586135864258,
-0.785979151725769,
0.2105584442615509,
0.026690244674682617,
-0.81297367811203,
-0.1374010592699051,
0.22335396707057953,
-0.2612836956977844,
0.33810368180274963,
-0.7482760548591614,
0.9340683221817017,
-0.21244952082633972,
0.2240186631679535,
-0.1499452441930771,
-0.6138517260551453,
0.29755422472953796,
-0.34627121686935425,
0.2897079885005951,
0.02815096825361252,
-0.24307814240455627,
0.6282743215560913,
-0.4025801122188568,
0.627257764339447,
-0.27300167083740234,
0.034209106117486954,
0.2321586310863495,
0.01828308217227459,
0.8111746907234192,
0.14877210557460785,
-0.022054769098758698,
-0.14319159090518951,
-0.13998791575431824,
-0.4589346945285797,
-0.8367499709129333,
0.4429595172405243,
-0.692709743976593,
-0.8574946522712708,
-0.16940215229988098,
-0.2750147581100464,
-0.442506343126297,
0.1872515082359314,
0.45150527358055115,
0.41807007789611816,
0.16605938971042633,
-0.09448985010385513,
0.6306037902832031,
0.00585041381418705,
0.36947986483573914,
-0.09478782117366791,
-0.3205145299434662,
-0.39939701557159424,
0.8914810419082642,
-0.3346502482891083,
0.22828000783920288,
0.5062037110328674,
0.0562334805727005,
-0.6116076111793518,
-0.9430411458015442,
-0.2378186583518982,
-0.027707261964678764,
-0.8355181813240051,
-0.43469446897506714,
-0.8455584049224854,
-0.09627814590930939,
-0.28704920411109924,
-0.14651115238666534,
0.04464617744088173,
-0.20390082895755768,
-0.222324937582016,
-0.44405215978622437,
0.24240438640117645,
0.7984437346458435,
0.32200542092323303,
0.17190374433994293,
-0.8231668472290039,
0.24595680832862854,
0.14930500090122223,
0.3726326823234558,
-0.10889994353055954,
-0.7940114140510559,
-0.27285534143447876,
-0.14195843040943146,
-0.050181031227111816,
-0.43011078238487244,
0.27298295497894287,
0.10004141926765442,
0.6708315014839172,
0.243397057056427,
-0.14649192988872528,
0.7839941382408142,
-0.7258538603782654,
0.7094812989234924,
0.43415898084640503,
-1.1380488872528076,
0.4832996428012848,
-0.12599694728851318,
0.1593160331249237,
0.667029082775116,
0.19231687486171722,
-0.2724098563194275,
-0.3957117199897766,
-0.7015401721000671,
-0.5850000381469727,
0.38445091247558594,
0.24821826815605164,
0.4954298138618469,
-0.06259963661432266,
0.5333460569381714,
0.17476516962051392,
0.4403355121612549,
-0.9184370636940002,
-0.04273654893040657,
-0.41444826126098633,
-0.07617910951375961,
-0.5511581301689148,
-0.08702532202005386,
0.41988083720207214,
-0.5471676588058472,
0.3258837163448334,
-0.3137037754058838,
0.6078640818595886,
0.10323775559663773,
-0.1603718101978302,
0.029728835448622704,
0.0293241236358881,
0.22853410243988037,
0.9970387816429138,
0.11345065385103226,
-0.004189063794910908,
0.34201088547706604,
-0.6247819066047668,
0.15555398166179657,
0.07092518359422684,
0.22616071999073029,
-0.17622947692871094,
0.7003499865531921,
0.8228311538696289,
-0.006440001539885998,
-0.8420981764793396,
0.8057196140289307,
-0.06977172195911407,
-0.3735654950141907,
-0.4714263379573822,
0.18563151359558105,
-0.05989616736769676,
0.27547240257263184,
0.45608073472976685,
0.42674121260643005,
0.030299736186861992,
-0.6778005957603455,
0.36263608932495117,
0.43918493390083313,
-0.3330764174461365,
-0.25875937938690186,
0.9454517960548401,
-0.030912982299923897,
0.03198965638875961,
0.6724537014961243,
-0.3344070017337799,
-1.0013799667358398,
0.7286784052848816,
0.6265968680381775,
0.9001049995422363,
0.22060555219650269,
0.03360102325677872,
0.09196452796459198,
0.3029472827911377,
-0.14887169003486633,
0.20532912015914917,
-0.04031047597527504,
-0.7933900952339172,
-0.9090284109115601,
-0.6648774147033691,
0.05838944390416145,
-0.08988570421934128,
-0.3403533101081848,
0.19706587493419647,
-0.38859593868255615,
0.0029472799506038427,
-0.5667650103569031,
0.0700530931353569,
-0.8591416478157043,
0.35697492957115173,
0.13261699676513672,
1.0571866035461426,
-0.5817093253135681,
1.2482446432113647,
0.7413819432258606,
-0.28332293033599854,
-1.0872822999954224,
0.3668612241744995,
-0.3703160583972931,
-1.0980421304702759,
0.8809899687767029,
0.320060670375824,
0.12116435170173645,
0.06757785379886627,
-0.3723915219306946,
-0.8057910203933716,
1.1762633323669434,
0.4884372353553772,
-0.5873679518699646,
-0.2882171869277954,
0.022626014426350594,
0.5181438326835632,
-0.38869598507881165,
0.3554694354534149,
0.6450687050819397,
0.4237760007381439,
0.1532953679561615,
-0.8015517592430115,
0.23022493720054626,
-0.3298266530036926,
0.1929709017276764,
0.08909046649932861,
-0.24987474083900452,
0.9188793301582336,
-0.5017638206481934,
-0.057995740324258804,
0.14666426181793213,
0.7027150392532349,
0.17312021553516388,
0.09944935888051987,
0.7496458888053894,
0.33436599373817444,
0.7844190001487732,
-0.0024197548627853394,
1.255232810974121,
-0.384942889213562,
0.24625879526138306,
0.9734042882919312,
-0.2331654131412506,
0.8407409191131592,
0.37451496720314026,
-0.49228718876838684,
0.4646405577659607,
0.7060276865959167,
0.03390518203377724,
0.5977498888969421,
0.5053954124450684,
-0.0885891392827034,
-0.3505833148956299,
0.36108797788619995,
-0.6330857872962952,
0.3396860957145691,
0.14304219186306,
-0.29510700702667236,
0.20685067772865295,
0.06428799033164978,
-0.22235964238643646,
0.012161142192780972,
-0.4111957550048828,
0.7514139413833618,
0.1542801409959793,
-0.6948451399803162,
0.6037399768829346,
-0.1848859339952469,
0.812463641166687,
-0.5326076745986938,
0.08185579627752304,
-0.24554994702339172,
0.18263007700443268,
-0.1471630334854126,
-0.5143401622772217,
0.36648961901664734,
-0.07262974232435226,
0.12439195066690445,
-0.23633131384849548,
0.8852592706680298,
-0.07350347191095352,
-0.4399510324001312,
0.28766265511512756,
0.6099943518638611,
-0.003596958238631487,
-0.44333693385124207,
-0.641409695148468,
0.03127339109778404,
0.18594393134117126,
-0.17899803817272186,
0.367730975151062,
0.47108498215675354,
0.06906622648239136,
0.7189551591873169,
0.899634599685669,
0.14246781170368195,
0.1308167576789856,
0.18519838154315948,
1.1866117715835571,
-0.6449995040893555,
-0.6865437626838684,
-0.9663360118865967,
0.24422839283943176,
0.1863574981689453,
-0.17112427949905396,
0.4920414388179779,
0.4159330427646637,
1.1463871002197266,
-0.17920038104057312,
0.9612277746200562,
0.18811844289302826,
0.057175032794475555,
-0.882145345211029,
0.5205824375152588,
-0.3610016107559204,
0.47116193175315857,
-0.4204600155353546,
-1.1542307138442993,
-0.2896696627140045,
0.4290946125984192,
-0.46412745118141174,
0.13314899802207947,
1.0657824277877808,
0.6153087019920349,
0.07484158873558044,
0.1809493899345398,
0.3329872786998749,
-0.0878152847290039,
0.35616371035575867,
0.7338614463806152,
0.9783957600593567,
-0.2026047557592392,
0.8837119340896606,
0.17592443525791168,
-0.06643858551979065,
0.09767620265483856,
-0.8119836449623108,
-1.1576834917068481,
-0.5540072917938232,
0.05913914367556572,
-0.25141313672065735,
0.21080778539180756,
0.9407063126564026,
0.5089945793151855,
-0.6148831844329834,
0.12267539650201797,
-0.7015846967697144,
0.05276850610971451,
-0.05122930556535721,
-0.09583864361047745,
0.423887699842453,
-0.7449279427528381,
-0.41994497179985046,
0.12254641205072403,
-0.025942960754036903,
-0.011438002809882164,
0.1130957156419754,
-0.23038825392723083,
0.42123010754585266,
-0.30468809604644775,
0.6980310082435608,
-0.09357451647520065,
-0.7133728265762329,
-0.3896331787109375,
0.11756401509046555,
0.0907832458615303,
0.02931378409266472,
1.2893269062042236,
-1.1752536296844482,
0.11510802060365677,
0.3276561498641968,
0.9688835740089417,
0.3866358995437622,
-0.025612808763980865,
0.6799415349960327,
-0.41448086500167847,
0.1708069145679474,
0.2637680470943451,
0.5570299625396729,
-0.02088066004216671,
-0.38005679845809937,
0.47524508833885193,
0.3130461275577545,
-0.44883406162261963,
-0.5893519520759583,
0.31526118516921997,
-0.5604546666145325,
-0.43573513627052307,
1.213026523590088,
-0.2328004688024521,
-0.07414288818836212,
-0.1520976573228836,
-0.22747181355953217,
0.09949582815170288,
-0.22845050692558289,
0.47683969140052795,
0.4493768811225891,
-0.044556573033332825,
-0.09137248992919922,
-0.5920677185058594,
0.6582317352294922,
0.6206549406051636,
-0.7594283223152161,
0.003096925327554345,
0.26701146364212036,
0.1704992651939392,
-0.13433843851089478,
0.9678258895874023,
-0.10023022443056107,
0.28144705295562744,
-0.016307884827256203,
-0.2632211446762085,
-0.2799648940563202,
-0.38856419920921326,
-0.2717791497707367,
-0.07385488599538803,
0.2806432843208313,
0.0051710959523916245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08877v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08877v1
|
Aligning LLMs for FL-free Program Repair
| 2024-04-13T02:36:40 | 2024-04-13T02:36:40 |
Junjielong Xu, Ying Fu, Shin Hwei Tan, Pinjia He
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved decent results on automated
program repair (APR). However, the next token prediction training objective of
decoder-only LLMs (e.g., GPT-4) is misaligned with the masked span prediction
objective of current infilling-style methods, which impedes LLMs from fully
leveraging pre-trained knowledge for program repair. In addition, while some
LLMs are capable of locating and repairing bugs end-to-end when using the
related artifacts (e.g., test cases) as input, existing methods regard them as
separate tasks and ask LLMs to generate patches at fixed locations. This
restriction hinders LLMs from exploring potential patches beyond the given
locations.
In this paper, we investigate a new approach to adapt LLMs to program repair.
Our core insight is that LLM's APR capability can be greatly improved by simply
aligning the output to their training objective and allowing them to refine the
whole program without first performing fault localization. Based on this
insight, we designed D4C, a straightforward prompting framework for APR. D4C
can repair 180 bugs correctly in Defects4J, with each patch being sampled only
10 times. This surpasses the SOTA APR methods with perfect fault localization
by 10% and reduces the patch sampling number by 90%. Our findings reveal that
(1) objective alignment is crucial for fully exploiting LLM's pre-trained
capability, and (2) replacing the traditional localize-then-repair workflow
with direct debugging is more effective for LLM-based APR methods. Thus, we
believe this paper introduces a new mindset for harnessing LLMs in APR.
|
[
-0.1789238005876541,
-0.346537709236145,
0.7118115425109863,
0.23671671748161316,
-0.030685318633913994,
0.37716278433799744,
-0.171463280916214,
-0.5066779255867004,
0.14966857433319092,
0.37315234541893005,
-0.8423303365707397,
-0.4632347524166107,
-0.3056927025318146,
0.18135519325733185,
0.04340875893831253,
1.1174899339675903,
-0.4977649748325348,
-0.16410128772258759,
-0.25960081815719604,
0.018486876040697098,
-0.7882477045059204,
-0.26251891255378723,
-0.8414255976676941,
-0.11125151813030243,
0.3427642583847046,
0.7156793475151062,
0.39650973677635193,
0.8197566866874695,
0.6204336881637573,
0.3277655839920044,
0.4089958965778351,
0.16339616477489471,
-0.3323568105697632,
-0.041937753558158875,
0.2490091323852539,
-0.7685709595680237,
-0.6330170035362244,
-0.10913447290658951,
0.3856428861618042,
0.23840346932411194,
0.05185406655073166,
-0.15042921900749207,
0.12703664600849152,
0.7937713861465454,
-0.40207451581954956,
0.07482995837926865,
-0.6630610823631287,
-0.007125814910978079,
-0.17142198979854584,
-0.3236536979675293,
-0.10947217047214508,
-0.2996961176395416,
-0.42455726861953735,
-0.7537752985954285,
0.20267175137996674,
0.12040695548057556,
0.7426849007606506,
0.6624603271484375,
-0.22050118446350098,
0.015610380098223686,
-0.4543702304363251,
0.7933982610702515,
-0.9014332890510559,
0.0394921712577343,
0.11369690299034119,
0.27938199043273926,
-0.4163321852684021,
-0.08408097922801971,
-0.358294814825058,
0.1381240338087082,
0.18083760142326355,
0.1070421040058136,
0.005363740958273411,
0.16808776557445526,
0.24385975301265717,
0.4798473119735718,
-0.3819064497947693,
0.4254695773124695,
-0.14227940142154694,
-0.579943835735321,
0.6094995141029358,
0.09673565626144409,
0.2192532867193222,
0.44341742992401123,
-0.7333288192749023,
0.28397950530052185,
-1.0067520141601562,
0.034571003168821335,
0.443783700466156,
0.20008736848831177,
-0.0925295427441597,
0.28291013836860657,
0.05314618721604347,
0.8563344478607178,
0.2167641669511795,
-0.34462353587150574,
0.26983848214149475,
-0.39346539974212646,
-0.07951168715953827,
0.3133580684661865,
0.5282868146896362,
0.3608332574367523,
0.15992671251296997,
-0.04161577299237251,
-0.5754793286323547,
-0.05096748471260071,
0.19938276708126068,
-0.3882998526096344,
-0.07889379560947418,
0.2734317183494568,
0.024760428816080093,
-0.3726542890071869,
0.14919058978557587,
-0.44157642126083374,
-0.46342480182647705,
-0.4179275333881378,
0.2800680696964264,
-0.33795830607414246,
-0.2390691637992859,
0.02127743884921074,
0.19605879485607147,
0.2118157297372818,
0.19382870197296143,
-0.9272483587265015,
-0.06170002371072769,
0.8782039880752563,
0.8047655820846558,
-0.1546906977891922,
-0.30283495783805847,
-0.8050847053527832,
0.2121109962463379,
-0.5272092819213867,
0.945504903793335,
-0.3592519164085388,
-0.0667773187160492,
0.10154474526643753,
-0.005914187524467707,
-0.023128515109419823,
-0.40163302421569824,
0.2675972282886505,
-0.38666990399360657,
-0.06223640590906143,
-0.6139863729476929,
-0.404981791973114,
0.2285199612379074,
0.4623611569404602,
-0.47968342900276184,
1.0117911100387573,
0.2602446377277374,
-0.7855104804039001,
0.2162228524684906,
-0.5704847574234009,
-0.1327468454837799,
-0.4012923240661621,
-0.15026047825813293,
-0.5476953983306885,
-0.057899169623851776,
0.6159500479698181,
0.1681402176618576,
0.09533515572547913,
0.10090586543083191,
-0.29397711157798767,
-0.6846839785575867,
0.21117563545703888,
-0.26243746280670166,
0.5041288733482361,
0.13187551498413086,
-0.6973845958709717,
0.3596206307411194,
-0.5446193218231201,
-0.14985741674900055,
-0.22169709205627441,
-0.3347433805465698,
-0.16391555964946747,
-0.17530162632465363,
-0.6678951382637024,
0.22892597317695618,
0.4310343563556671,
-0.8607274889945984,
0.45914262533187866,
-0.9412855505943298,
0.20427709817886353,
1.16305410861969,
-0.07126219570636749,
0.6338492035865784,
-0.4612976014614105,
0.8389589190483093,
0.15988758206367493,
0.0807609111070633,
-0.2764892876148224,
-0.19896259903907776,
-0.7323449850082397,
-0.5159643888473511,
-0.0903393030166626,
0.41934770345687866,
-0.6020584106445312,
0.3483971357345581,
-0.12500707805156708,
-0.0988074466586113,
-0.43122485280036926,
0.2632327377796173,
0.4167743921279907,
0.8261735439300537,
0.26494431495666504,
-0.08998356759548187,
-0.8013275265693665,
-0.5701091885566711,
-0.2259780466556549,
-0.10147130489349365,
0.06358002871274948,
-0.1473202407360077,
0.025910086929798126,
-0.16152207553386688,
0.9217579960823059,
-0.43407124280929565,
-0.7249312400817871,
-0.2549494504928589,
-0.3253377079963684,
0.37929606437683105,
0.32599514722824097,
0.2270239293575287,
-0.21399597823619843,
-0.6213452219963074,
-0.12706789374351501,
-0.3961613178253174,
-0.45154663920402527,
-0.11308345198631287,
-0.1061190813779831,
0.7391617298126221,
0.7094506621360779,
-0.41537922620773315,
0.34634143114089966,
0.6716763377189636,
-0.3306170105934143,
0.34751349687576294,
-0.16518500447273254,
0.22187328338623047,
-0.9355031251907349,
-0.05195263773202896,
-0.23231270909309387,
-0.2818954288959503,
-0.38750964403152466,
-0.19548924267292023,
0.20695669949054718,
-0.0479484386742115,
-0.297488272190094,
0.5311146974563599,
-0.8262059092521667,
-0.24760589003562927,
-0.5101504325866699,
0.14995281398296356,
0.01718715764582157,
0.41712167859077454,
-0.2638501524925232,
0.8598299026489258,
0.46756812930107117,
-0.2338547706604004,
0.15888188779354095,
0.06460686773061752,
-0.026231102645397186,
0.45206785202026367,
-0.3509558439254761,
0.194203183054924,
-0.09233535081148148,
0.37113505601882935,
-1.1795885562896729,
-0.08346530050039291,
0.33567124605178833,
-0.2754833698272705,
0.5111920833587646,
-0.026901474222540855,
-0.11481130123138428,
-0.32453978061676025,
-0.6147229671478271,
0.4239230453968048,
0.2717638313770294,
-0.6052459478378296,
0.36372458934783936,
0.11947697401046753,
-0.07706838101148605,
-0.8410431146621704,
-0.526415228843689,
-0.10687108337879181,
-0.44092103838920593,
-0.635223388671875,
0.5133506059646606,
-0.1729927659034729,
-0.07077100872993469,
-0.1841965764760971,
-0.7235054969787598,
0.026334932073950768,
0.21572580933570862,
0.39029496908187866,
0.4557499289512634,
-0.3554970324039459,
-0.0029851363506168127,
-0.1753951907157898,
-0.44318249821662903,
-0.18401482701301575,
-0.3419055938720703,
0.43099087476730347,
-0.1994175761938095,
-0.674885630607605,
-0.09448391944169998,
0.06534130871295929,
0.44284921884536743,
-0.5539670586585999,
0.38016772270202637,
0.5618195533752441,
-0.11555375903844833,
-0.03358133137226105,
-0.750173807144165,
-0.19993814826011658,
-0.4828639626502991,
0.21803532540798187,
-0.22680465877056122,
-0.9008901119232178,
0.4781344532966614,
0.08318490535020828,
0.3436757028102875,
0.21070562303066254,
0.2805517315864563,
-0.06036553904414177,
0.9705472588539124,
0.9063476324081421,
-0.4676678478717804,
0.41438397765159607,
0.07776281237602234,
0.6388200521469116,
-0.8723124265670776,
-0.10948079824447632,
-0.4267675578594208,
-0.47945037484169006,
0.14829187095165253,
-0.3055758476257324,
0.2729288935661316,
0.29086652398109436,
-0.3288775384426117,
0.18521462380886078,
-0.6439746618270874,
0.6529829502105713,
0.2893291115760803,
-0.004053589887917042,
0.29679954051971436,
0.020078768953680992,
-0.16562533378601074,
-0.05786624550819397,
-0.5111724138259888,
-0.35422974824905396,
0.9760280847549438,
0.49643200635910034,
0.5240586400032043,
0.01558785792440176,
1.1977900266647339,
-0.16647201776504517,
0.4186333119869232,
-0.6478179693222046,
0.37002652883529663,
0.08894143998622894,
-0.19619612395763397,
-0.3867485821247101,
-0.13365614414215088,
-0.9321913123130798,
-0.26930028200149536,
0.17722082138061523,
-0.5142144560813904,
-0.03973383828997612,
0.5506154298782349,
-0.4776548147201538,
0.37665849924087524,
-0.37381622195243835,
0.8379469513893127,
-0.435437947511673,
-0.051816683262586594,
-0.031061219051480293,
-0.5151544809341431,
0.40536928176879883,
-0.25463172793388367,
0.40980640053749084,
-0.31682074069976807,
-0.2555617392063141,
0.43299400806427,
-0.7707542181015015,
0.8169410824775696,
-0.49813660979270935,
-0.49926984310150146,
0.0780780091881752,
-0.002001738641411066,
0.749116837978363,
-0.024990731850266457,
-0.06219187006354332,
0.02540610544383526,
-0.03905511274933815,
-0.2795826494693756,
-0.5106198787689209,
0.9509125351905823,
-0.6356364488601685,
-0.7525970935821533,
-0.6181975603103638,
-0.7849876284599304,
-0.4154868721961975,
0.1774563044309616,
0.020713768899440765,
0.2282349169254303,
0.2413131147623062,
-0.3838677704334259,
0.6032735705375671,
-0.02480345219373703,
0.6632495522499084,
0.7539685368537903,
-0.183696448802948,
-0.2192850261926651,
0.8725172281265259,
-0.2306496649980545,
0.029640134423971176,
0.4223264455795288,
0.058207981288433075,
-0.18818233907222748,
-0.6266528964042664,
-0.23907466232776642,
0.2939271926879883,
-0.6228068470954895,
-0.7341388463973999,
-0.23902282118797302,
0.0006603799411095679,
-0.27504950761795044,
-0.38010090589523315,
-0.31170564889907837,
-0.21165786683559418,
-0.37349507212638855,
-0.2070218324661255,
0.48147687315940857,
0.36177584528923035,
-0.1399059146642685,
0.22326773405075073,
-0.8444147109985352,
0.16514383256435394,
-0.18118126690387726,
0.6053431630134583,
-0.29538556933403015,
-0.31754517555236816,
-0.2728031277656555,
0.23723168671131134,
-0.3502502143383026,
-0.7503833174705505,
0.23229040205478668,
0.23559078574180603,
0.5365944504737854,
0.243020161986351,
0.08333051204681396,
0.9481660723686218,
-0.5507908463478088,
0.7656726241111755,
0.18981227278709412,
-0.8492511510848999,
0.5404174327850342,
-0.2487463355064392,
0.1614125370979309,
0.5943812727928162,
0.12701572477817535,
-0.32031065225601196,
-0.5806213617324829,
-0.32004159688949585,
-0.7522413730621338,
0.6258256435394287,
-0.2850887179374695,
-0.14697663486003876,
-0.2203795313835144,
0.5159132480621338,
0.046200864017009735,
-0.06420156359672546,
-0.4515549838542938,
0.08331283926963806,
-0.29975253343582153,
-0.6892843246459961,
-0.07471171766519547,
-0.07739601284265518,
-0.15687806904315948,
-0.0805123895406723,
0.8791475892066956,
-0.4704056680202484,
0.43123817443847656,
0.290680855512619,
-0.13195383548736572,
-0.4729541838169098,
0.053953077644109726,
0.7719002366065979,
0.697856605052948,
0.03155627101659775,
0.08719172328710556,
0.11511942744255066,
-0.10149630159139633,
0.2920929789543152,
-0.09830764681100845,
0.1931532919406891,
-0.21825358271598816,
0.35150662064552307,
0.6299718022346497,
0.31555646657943726,
-0.6926674246788025,
0.7312986850738525,
0.14308136701583862,
-0.1408434957265854,
-0.29182109236717224,
0.18981018662452698,
0.061702463775873184,
0.37833723425865173,
0.33799630403518677,
0.2545709013938904,
-0.34145739674568176,
-0.32643723487854004,
0.30392101407051086,
0.7053542733192444,
-0.5245886445045471,
-0.3380086421966553,
0.7236254215240479,
0.16984745860099792,
-0.14558227360248566,
0.7111226320266724,
0.15892401337623596,
-0.5259717106819153,
0.7097127437591553,
0.6978835463523865,
0.7159169316291809,
-0.2811976969242096,
0.09844730794429779,
0.34539079666137695,
0.2368481457233429,
-0.19040659070014954,
0.3029135465621948,
0.1724623441696167,
-0.6671995520591736,
-0.6362683773040771,
-0.6176698207855225,
-0.00668939296156168,
0.055034611374139786,
-0.1333218812942505,
0.5106927752494812,
-0.4633443057537079,
0.12318090349435806,
-0.5386616587638855,
0.019310958683490753,
-0.39652732014656067,
0.03519411385059357,
0.007666253484785557,
0.9592257142066956,
-0.8572968244552612,
0.8031212687492371,
0.5063794255256653,
-0.4041197597980499,
-1.246469497680664,
0.19199880957603455,
0.2431275099515915,
-1.0454984903335571,
0.36298394203186035,
0.43652182817459106,
0.2573651969432831,
0.14278769493103027,
-0.2878433167934418,
-1.1994956731796265,
1.1491557359695435,
0.5759425163269043,
-0.7612512707710266,
-0.0825638696551323,
0.11126051098108292,
0.309314101934433,
-0.3864921033382416,
0.00023442473320756108,
0.4763782024383545,
0.555511474609375,
-0.00046193928574211895,
-0.9165389537811279,
0.3310491740703583,
-0.05474301427602768,
-0.19993256032466888,
0.5302948355674744,
-0.46090617775917053,
0.5448630452156067,
-0.38927093148231506,
-0.022361308336257935,
0.07520289719104767,
0.5110251903533936,
0.4216749966144562,
0.1427554488182068,
0.5712546706199646,
0.6070008873939514,
0.6725646257400513,
-0.25235050916671753,
0.931178629398346,
-0.42788389325141907,
-0.0011481475085020065,
0.9610204696655273,
-0.2130068838596344,
0.41179338097572327,
0.7596882581710815,
-0.15495596826076508,
0.4812448024749756,
0.8315612077713013,
-0.05774467810988426,
0.5758179426193237,
0.24434080719947815,
-0.1554381251335144,
0.029645422473549843,
0.31728169322013855,
-0.26424914598464966,
0.19272328913211823,
-0.0011568359332159162,
-0.030206959694623947,
-0.19424962997436523,
0.006409902125597,
0.0918935164809227,
-0.008867056109011173,
-0.37180960178375244,
0.7943894267082214,
0.09000586718320847,
-0.9238051772117615,
0.7252238392829895,
-0.007403842639178038,
0.6634124517440796,
-0.6087148189544678,
-0.010708189569413662,
-0.5361091494560242,
0.34485766291618347,
-0.6749080419540405,
-0.5156754851341248,
0.7507747411727905,
-0.06580884754657745,
-0.168025940656662,
-0.1346706598997116,
0.6454242467880249,
-0.5038841962814331,
-0.2682800590991974,
-0.05188465490937233,
0.01523390132933855,
0.035072799772024155,
-0.26036933064460754,
-0.451421320438385,
0.3937676250934601,
0.39436841011047363,
-0.11853493005037308,
0.571354329586029,
0.35873931646347046,
-0.38407695293426514,
0.4598100483417511,
0.6132704019546509,
0.26059770584106445,
0.14834599196910858,
-0.04342928156256676,
0.755255401134491,
-0.38095539808273315,
-0.2941674590110779,
-0.9168952107429504,
0.7927938103675842,
0.13423684239387512,
0.04901423305273056,
0.7168306112289429,
0.43611451983451843,
0.5301181077957153,
0.06780318170785904,
0.7524979710578918,
0.14541614055633545,
0.3421771228313446,
-0.5755449533462524,
0.23885329067707062,
-0.41488125920295715,
0.7713407278060913,
-0.24852171540260315,
-1.1642533540725708,
-0.4549795687198639,
0.5712506175041199,
-0.21253657341003418,
-0.15642395615577698,
0.6178776025772095,
1.0766375064849854,
0.0448964461684227,
-0.3236706256866455,
0.06801105290651321,
0.15705080330371857,
0.5690378546714783,
0.6423649787902832,
0.6320599317550659,
-0.18803808093070984,
0.6177479028701782,
-0.16618561744689941,
-0.5022605657577515,
-0.02130870893597603,
-1.1435128450393677,
-0.5896265506744385,
-0.2593213617801666,
-0.4754353165626526,
-0.12328209728002548,
-0.05906837433576584,
0.8065765500068665,
0.2557161748409271,
-0.6933895349502563,
0.144427090883255,
-0.5128330588340759,
0.0794626921415329,
-0.42726999521255493,
-0.19625873863697052,
0.29300713539123535,
-0.8380088806152344,
-0.45812439918518066,
0.7959985733032227,
0.39253899455070496,
-0.04088728874921799,
-0.14274805784225464,
-0.36962655186653137,
0.14539922773838043,
-0.20096871256828308,
0.205706387758255,
0.42658519744873047,
-0.7563403844833374,
-0.6505388617515564,
0.2180432677268982,
0.08502297103404999,
0.32462912797927856,
0.8665207624435425,
-0.7489166855812073,
0.23955820500850677,
0.2709011137485504,
0.8240221738815308,
0.18483030796051025,
0.06814208626747131,
0.9121354818344116,
-1.0786752700805664,
0.05298386886715889,
0.12335333973169327,
0.4554205536842346,
0.41133156418800354,
-0.6349318623542786,
0.3359173834323883,
-0.11218632757663727,
-0.7431530356407166,
-0.8085660934448242,
0.2992536127567291,
-0.6401450037956238,
-0.152491956949234,
1.0516836643218994,
-0.22663278877735138,
-0.03933874890208244,
-0.15348508954048157,
-0.5109450817108154,
0.38618266582489014,
-0.15722614526748657,
0.7637413144111633,
0.4560483992099762,
-0.2558082938194275,
-0.20953123271465302,
-0.14101657271385193,
0.5775808691978455,
0.3996222913265228,
-0.5848091244697571,
0.040559422224760056,
0.5252768397331238,
0.6572468280792236,
-0.06497808545827866,
0.987575113773346,
-0.3294540345668793,
0.09474384784698486,
-0.3875531852245331,
0.1513577103614807,
-0.4882563352584839,
-0.27752235531806946,
-0.5745627284049988,
-0.21469171345233917,
0.36474281549453735,
-0.18412001430988312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08865v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08865v1
|
LLM In-Context Recall is Prompt Dependent
| 2024-04-13T01:13:59 | 2024-04-13T01:13:59 |
Daniel Machlab, Rick Battle
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The proliferation of Large Language Models (LLMs) highlights the critical
importance of conducting thorough evaluations to discern their comparative
advantages, limitations, and optimal use cases. Particularly important is
assessing their capacity to accurately retrieve information included in a given
prompt. A model's ability to do this significantly influences how effectively
it can utilize contextual details, thus impacting its practical efficacy and
dependability in real-world applications.
Our research analyzes the in-context recall performance of various LLMs using
the needle-in-a-haystack method. In this approach, a factoid (the "needle") is
embedded within a block of filler text (the "haystack"), which the model is
asked to retrieve. We assess the recall performance of each model across
various haystack lengths and with varying needle placements to identify
performance patterns. This study demonstrates that an LLM's recall capability
is not only contingent upon the prompt's content but also may be compromised by
biases in its training data. Conversely, adjustments to model architecture,
training strategy, or fine-tuning can improve performance. Our analysis
provides insight into LLM behavior, offering direction for the development of
more effective applications of LLMs.
|
[
-0.07664372026920319,
-0.8025575876235962,
0.7313441038131714,
0.04866693168878555,
-0.13197913765907288,
-0.23429155349731445,
-0.07540973275899887,
-0.5922679901123047,
0.0999099612236023,
0.31182369589805603,
-0.30228206515312195,
-0.3741263449192047,
-0.49054214358329773,
0.4332769811153412,
-0.5943926572799683,
0.5522850751876831,
-0.009001544676721096,
0.040438514202833176,
-0.4623575508594513,
0.05185173824429512,
-1.0371934175491333,
-0.8348885178565979,
-0.4192970395088196,
-0.20710664987564087,
0.5189904570579529,
0.5768020153045654,
0.16362272202968597,
0.7064928412437439,
0.3692943751811981,
0.25422531366348267,
-0.4257661998271942,
0.02256511151790619,
-0.6503803730010986,
0.2624746263027191,
-0.1769554764032364,
-0.5379357933998108,
-0.20255917310714722,
0.031206687912344933,
0.978431761264801,
0.5867401957511902,
-0.2387891709804535,
-0.049105871468782425,
0.16051889955997467,
0.44858577847480774,
-0.698506772518158,
-0.2006026655435562,
-0.9203598499298096,
-0.24568487703800201,
-0.026545802131295204,
-0.3058544397354126,
-0.5610215067863464,
-0.3338024318218231,
0.4252167344093323,
-0.47670048475265503,
0.03012499399483204,
0.08614898473024368,
0.7734773755073547,
0.07445402443408966,
-0.4106822609901428,
-0.5572095513343811,
-0.5464579463005066,
0.5667241215705872,
-0.7315502762794495,
0.06676442921161652,
0.5154645442962646,
0.13988976180553436,
-0.299217164516449,
-0.49681994318962097,
-0.21653102338314056,
-0.295566201210022,
-0.2526334524154663,
-0.11890026181936264,
0.2332056760787964,
-0.13722681999206543,
0.5549297332763672,
0.22935931384563446,
-0.19741714000701904,
0.3156788647174835,
-0.224554181098938,
-0.1319991946220398,
0.18072375655174255,
0.6056309938430786,
0.24844418466091156,
-0.3254067599773407,
-0.49800339341163635,
0.17997710406780243,
-1.0554921627044678,
0.2910735309123993,
-0.14720159769058228,
0.45112934708595276,
-0.019536737352609634,
0.4356447458267212,
-0.1490619033575058,
0.6901859641075134,
0.03383190929889679,
-0.2779920697212219,
0.0038230116479098797,
-0.39592212438583374,
-0.11112609505653381,
0.050703126937150955,
0.4128890633583069,
0.15732990205287933,
0.13060224056243896,
-0.10664253681898117,
-0.6004290580749512,
-0.430019348859787,
0.4516291320323944,
-0.7739417552947998,
0.3220652639865875,
0.04115935042500496,
-0.33164066076278687,
0.12392883002758026,
0.17899447679519653,
-0.27076807618141174,
-0.5565215945243835,
-0.2899031639099121,
0.6654772758483887,
-0.5794565677642822,
0.053487472236156464,
0.03784264251589775,
-0.177776038646698,
0.17033697664737701,
0.3256791830062866,
-0.9030351042747498,
0.07118526101112366,
0.8957444429397583,
1.1139594316482544,
-0.36640968918800354,
-0.3397032618522644,
-0.7107334136962891,
0.26258885860443115,
-0.33246514201164246,
0.7538899779319763,
-0.6156609058380127,
-0.5998937487602234,
0.3320035934448242,
0.13831622898578644,
-0.24683837592601776,
-0.8369393348693848,
0.3756895363330841,
-0.49711281061172485,
0.008021140471100807,
-0.7887018918991089,
-1.0379031896591187,
-0.2803753614425659,
0.24167346954345703,
-0.8163419961929321,
0.9513835906982422,
-0.03828897699713707,
-0.6866534948348999,
0.5144810676574707,
-0.026040751487016678,
-0.3959702253341675,
0.01945181004703045,
-0.23149719834327698,
-0.23599348962306976,
0.3481525480747223,
-0.04321766644716263,
0.6985886096954346,
-0.29238250851631165,
0.27272382378578186,
-0.05785501003265381,
-1.1385829448699951,
0.6033912301063538,
-0.3407030999660492,
0.5046898126602173,
-0.27006861567497253,
0.030790749937295914,
0.051763035356998444,
-0.7788863778114319,
-0.5251926779747009,
-0.012656631879508495,
-0.6401795148849487,
-0.608526885509491,
-0.07976238429546356,
-0.2500858008861542,
0.10838337987661362,
0.1656431257724762,
-0.3750069737434387,
0.08671168237924576,
-0.3342466354370117,
0.27937307953834534,
0.8144236207008362,
0.1987977772951126,
0.3072616159915924,
-0.5547585487365723,
0.499704509973526,
-0.1439896672964096,
-0.11817732453346252,
-0.7737182974815369,
-0.02933957427740097,
-0.7277314066886902,
-0.48344895243644714,
0.16330116987228394,
0.5140054225921631,
-0.4918287694454193,
0.2558313310146332,
0.011061728931963444,
-0.26113253831863403,
-0.028400786221027374,
0.016887642443180084,
0.4185229539871216,
0.7541828155517578,
0.002482810290530324,
-0.2761753797531128,
-0.4571945071220398,
-0.7906975150108337,
-0.36590245366096497,
-0.05063328519463539,
-0.030048662796616554,
0.5572769045829773,
0.3856143057346344,
-0.10260117053985596,
0.9153677225112915,
-0.06817091256380081,
-0.17539165914058685,
-0.24996663630008698,
-0.19618621468544006,
0.6241264343261719,
0.18469293415546417,
0.31905728578567505,
-0.3139731287956238,
-0.27358874678611755,
-0.34205520153045654,
-0.8608891367912292,
-0.10789525508880615,
-0.29027557373046875,
-0.020405393093824387,
0.4060786962509155,
0.6269372701644897,
-0.5473048686981201,
0.3363175690174103,
0.22546587884426117,
-0.4553941786289215,
0.7247985005378723,
-0.3626590073108673,
0.026164811104536057,
-0.6452142596244812,
0.4495463967323303,
-0.27903228998184204,
-0.0762324407696724,
-0.6387883424758911,
-0.2762560248374939,
0.4642763137817383,
0.2923577129840851,
-0.6060585975646973,
0.7595691084861755,
-0.4634374976158142,
-0.15034788846969604,
-0.1722928136587143,
0.14334338903427124,
-0.04177052155137062,
0.1488839089870453,
0.07147036492824554,
1.2594269514083862,
0.4136599898338318,
-1.0702252388000488,
-0.11492995172739029,
0.06420794874429703,
-0.7397342920303345,
0.5697101354598999,
-0.6101163029670715,
0.18783782422542572,
-0.0017972694477066398,
0.13345210254192352,
-1.0682296752929688,
-0.2727998197078705,
-0.06980159878730774,
-0.05919588729739189,
0.39940696954727173,
0.14547684788703918,
-0.555935800075531,
-0.05458735674619675,
-0.19026117026805878,
0.24111922085285187,
0.3985264301300049,
-0.6093001365661621,
0.5820474028587341,
0.33234480023384094,
-0.04302733391523361,
-0.531832218170166,
-0.24111871421337128,
-0.01363569125533104,
-0.585626482963562,
-0.16281315684318542,
0.06600742787122726,
0.09816648066043854,
-0.10140173882246017,
-0.5230771899223328,
-0.16672755777835846,
0.19911067187786102,
0.43334531784057617,
0.3112887740135193,
0.4574069380760193,
0.10196862369775772,
0.5419695973396301,
-0.36580929160118103,
-0.1495940238237381,
0.25873467326164246,
0.07462020218372345,
0.4737779200077057,
0.009725487791001797,
-0.14589166641235352,
-0.4136406481266022,
0.1853601336479187,
0.3931827247142792,
0.17492623627185822,
0.735358476638794,
0.005565683823078871,
-0.35576701164245605,
-0.11190174520015717,
-0.7005848288536072,
-0.3955042064189911,
-0.4424378573894501,
0.49582770466804504,
-0.4499872028827667,
-0.9080080986022949,
0.6218953728675842,
-0.033995840698480606,
-0.06080072000622749,
0.08963906019926071,
0.5542919635772705,
-0.3572375178337097,
0.527511477470398,
0.61310213804245,
-0.09149966388940811,
0.751314640045166,
-0.026067351922392845,
-0.3000693619251251,
-1.0435566902160645,
-0.341220498085022,
-0.3604874312877655,
-0.13734494149684906,
-0.016635870561003685,
-0.2056959569454193,
0.5192010998725891,
0.13764776289463043,
-0.2100505530834198,
0.14878764748573303,
-0.0704871341586113,
0.552175760269165,
0.5736297369003296,
0.0027429694309830666,
0.49091410636901855,
-0.07834780961275101,
-0.38869979977607727,
0.048442114144563675,
-0.8620581030845642,
-0.8384667634963989,
1.0275025367736816,
0.38458287715911865,
0.6332902908325195,
-0.05125664919614792,
0.472302109003067,
-0.1154346689581871,
0.13970933854579926,
-0.8072699308395386,
0.6011603474617004,
0.030464135110378265,
-0.5805001258850098,
-0.31688445806503296,
-0.13462328910827637,
-1.1019476652145386,
0.2998163104057312,
-0.1846006214618683,
-0.7652801871299744,
-0.04891832917928696,
0.1955171525478363,
-0.49251121282577515,
0.0523805133998394,
-0.6239108443260193,
0.5279443860054016,
-0.17468798160552979,
-0.38347530364990234,
-0.16723144054412842,
-0.42387932538986206,
0.363308846950531,
-0.31289395689964294,
0.030250925570726395,
-0.16133049130439758,
-0.2117220163345337,
0.5754048824310303,
-0.15147525072097778,
1.0205397605895996,
0.07083465903997421,
-0.19253501296043396,
0.28495994210243225,
0.24856558442115784,
0.6030866503715515,
-0.010232415981590748,
-0.18937139213085175,
0.23944716155529022,
0.08068526536226273,
-0.08345469832420349,
-0.49593546986579895,
0.5300131440162659,
-0.47725164890289307,
-0.7809305787086487,
-0.3293909728527069,
-0.45814889669418335,
-0.3170393705368042,
-0.005041708238422871,
0.11693334579467773,
0.5758680701255798,
-0.5042933225631714,
0.21149694919586182,
0.8551193475723267,
-0.4458773136138916,
0.6040102243423462,
0.7006343603134155,
-0.232587993144989,
0.008640177547931671,
0.7408897876739502,
0.2889528274536133,
0.3661193549633026,
0.46221697330474854,
0.20661230385303497,
-0.1642911434173584,
-0.39258521795272827,
-0.3291376829147339,
0.39466622471809387,
-0.8255911469459534,
-0.22176989912986755,
-0.5362051129341125,
-0.05540341138839722,
0.11896874755620956,
-0.08337143808603287,
-0.12778013944625854,
-0.2053123116493225,
-0.6142526268959045,
0.010139093734323978,
0.5871288180351257,
0.9449542760848999,
0.17596599459648132,
0.3312965929508209,
-0.6707442998886108,
-0.021408656612038612,
0.3036189377307892,
0.4998469352722168,
0.31695541739463806,
-0.7214844822883606,
-0.44769471883773804,
-0.2834722697734833,
-0.044148802757263184,
-0.7794837951660156,
0.11075177788734436,
0.08286929130554199,
0.7011190056800842,
0.2051807940006256,
-0.26797786355018616,
0.5241204500198364,
-0.5978220105171204,
0.6594551205635071,
-0.0976346954703331,
-0.8779301047325134,
0.4715476334095001,
-0.39838069677352905,
0.6259234547615051,
0.41794079542160034,
0.24534225463867188,
-0.8367293477058411,
-0.2809920012950897,
-0.3420651853084564,
-0.9370364546775818,
0.8580107688903809,
-0.1103777214884758,
0.07030315697193146,
-0.2893349826335907,
0.6945764422416687,
0.26506733894348145,
0.06201975792646408,
-0.29515451192855835,
0.12291724979877472,
0.23777911067008972,
0.03902628645300865,
-0.0033483589068055153,
-0.6391343474388123,
0.010576377622783184,
-0.10535886883735657,
0.4290370047092438,
0.0008353057783097029,
0.11210983246564865,
0.12794385850429535,
-0.31715282797813416,
0.29493534564971924,
0.039560843259096146,
0.5866386890411377,
0.89650559425354,
-0.3544517755508423,
0.06706126779317856,
0.502178430557251,
-0.4448970854282379,
-0.02331722341477871,
-0.5452225804328918,
-0.3074335753917694,
-0.05133640766143799,
0.6077867150306702,
0.6572745442390442,
0.5084399580955505,
-1.064451813697815,
0.5028679966926575,
-0.060977403074502945,
0.29655998945236206,
-0.3325716257095337,
0.3172641396522522,
0.11623406410217285,
0.21731294691562653,
0.35586628317832947,
-0.4302781820297241,
0.24611835181713104,
-0.6287864446640015,
0.19750399887561798,
0.6009300947189331,
-0.3191342353820801,
-0.15345926582813263,
0.23473243415355682,
0.096548892557621,
-0.4289281964302063,
0.6156488060951233,
0.23378781974315643,
-0.3711448609828949,
0.791361927986145,
0.7139772176742554,
0.7161874175071716,
-0.18608656525611877,
-0.1343454271554947,
0.6122987866401672,
0.058683376759290695,
-0.27279773354530334,
0.1804577112197876,
0.16671167314052582,
-0.45297303795814514,
-0.183528333902359,
-0.2391822785139084,
-0.2285357564687729,
0.03920559957623482,
-0.6664128303527832,
0.30636027455329895,
-0.5519390106201172,
-0.30376872420310974,
-0.6053184866905212,
-0.15355148911476135,
-0.6975347995758057,
0.1079440638422966,
-0.0017598271369934082,
1.0404345989227295,
-0.5755726099014282,
0.7874153852462769,
0.33546125888824463,
-0.20786108076572418,
-0.7221813201904297,
-0.05309336259961128,
0.1492432802915573,
-0.9033527374267578,
0.508322536945343,
0.5130074620246887,
-0.23658078908920288,
-0.3194097876548767,
-0.4358067214488983,
-1.2094814777374268,
1.329132080078125,
0.18282251060009003,
-0.7192806601524353,
0.19595126807689667,
-0.2350660264492035,
0.47707656025886536,
-0.5977310538291931,
0.5230493545532227,
0.8763251900672913,
0.06504783034324646,
0.23075732588768005,
-1.0645698308944702,
0.24757608771324158,
0.13098064064979553,
0.39936521649360657,
-0.046442802995443344,
-0.5884556770324707,
0.8288682699203491,
-0.3357407748699188,
-0.5084661245346069,
0.26836490631103516,
0.39271417260169983,
0.7604301571846008,
0.05235866457223892,
0.2912754714488983,
-0.014333571307361126,
1.0782735347747803,
0.17559954524040222,
1.139446496963501,
-0.04228336736559868,
0.071188785135746,
1.1334291696548462,
-0.27886247634887695,
1.1860134601593018,
0.6525993347167969,
0.1604049950838089,
0.4062371551990509,
0.5761876106262207,
0.22822585701942444,
0.39629775285720825,
0.217611163854599,
0.016914600506424904,
-0.21620997786521912,
-0.22060048580169678,
-0.21048498153686523,
0.41444942355155945,
0.5482375621795654,
-0.5021930932998657,
0.11550422012805939,
-0.1043182834982872,
0.03258639946579933,
0.09419212490320206,
-0.2613646984100342,
0.9414633512496948,
0.12730303406715393,
-0.6505894660949707,
0.80472332239151,
-0.22356602549552917,
0.6444504857063293,
-0.4711563289165497,
-0.14427340030670166,
-0.40981408953666687,
0.07347765564918518,
0.17214076220989227,
-0.5657663345336914,
0.07677119225263596,
-0.10212274640798569,
-0.3717481791973114,
-0.04594835638999939,
0.5495221018791199,
-0.25703951716423035,
-0.27695268392562866,
0.31270772218704224,
0.398983895778656,
0.16825370490550995,
0.09273486584424973,
-0.3046361804008484,
0.3732880651950836,
-0.2996887266635895,
-0.2508411705493927,
0.37382808327674866,
0.47778376936912537,
-0.15809862315654755,
0.8878828883171082,
0.2598404884338379,
0.12421344220638275,
-0.03539152443408966,
0.00983976386487484,
0.6771050691604614,
-0.9855033159255981,
-0.3746531307697296,
-1.0056486129760742,
0.3462735116481781,
-0.016610726714134216,
-0.39481112360954285,
0.840305745601654,
0.561296284198761,
0.729652464389801,
-0.0196473877876997,
0.5829442143440247,
0.36704057455062866,
0.9249599575996399,
-0.9286215305328369,
0.5339029431343079,
-0.47075796127319336,
0.6601204872131348,
-0.2006067931652069,
-0.719932496547699,
-0.11632867902517319,
0.6792633533477783,
-0.2393185943365097,
0.13495412468910217,
0.8282096982002258,
0.7669656276702881,
0.25671228766441345,
-0.047636862844228745,
0.4036852717399597,
0.35667431354522705,
0.19296306371688843,
0.8610369563102722,
1.2305879592895508,
-0.29575592279434204,
0.16228407621383667,
0.18926475942134857,
-0.17097707092761993,
-0.555334746837616,
-1.0280145406723022,
-1.086304783821106,
-0.5328922867774963,
0.07046923041343689,
-0.22522245347499847,
-0.03565078228712082,
0.8622686862945557,
0.4651239812374115,
-0.5185273885726929,
-0.6608538031578064,
0.34506070613861084,
0.3010933995246887,
-0.06455105543136597,
-0.13183416426181793,
0.3625900149345398,
-0.5759308934211731,
-0.5067639946937561,
0.3631453216075897,
0.43520891666412354,
0.13918842375278473,
-0.1268654614686966,
-0.05830283835530281,
-0.22954580187797546,
0.2034778594970703,
0.5988803505897522,
0.16955862939357758,
-0.920993447303772,
-0.30952534079551697,
0.14131465554237366,
-0.3443615138530731,
0.06101124733686447,
0.9478346109390259,
-1.1081877946853638,
0.5208772420883179,
0.4019815921783447,
0.5588877201080322,
0.23556260764598846,
0.13460999727249146,
0.6682366728782654,
-0.6095669269561768,
0.09188136458396912,
0.02397412247955799,
0.3329041004180908,
0.36235955357551575,
-0.36815372109413147,
0.24845147132873535,
0.0930626392364502,
-0.5046643614768982,
-0.7210221886634827,
0.02861880138516426,
-0.547374427318573,
-0.5591722130775452,
1.5619165897369385,
-0.012554064393043518,
-0.09695947170257568,
-0.20897044241428375,
-0.355912983417511,
-0.06259182095527649,
-0.3769405484199524,
0.9294087886810303,
0.9642381072044373,
0.0023970259353518486,
-0.05482804775238037,
-0.6545445919036865,
0.5078563690185547,
0.4079412519931793,
-0.47111910581588745,
0.14885160326957703,
0.6378215551376343,
0.4372723698616028,
-0.24352547526359558,
0.8044050335884094,
0.14039331674575806,
0.15793536603450775,
-0.2937626540660858,
-0.2587381601333618,
0.07173583656549454,
-0.5109792351722717,
-0.7263213992118835,
0.09382688999176025,
0.21815042197704315,
0.05518914759159088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08856v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08856v1
|
On Speculative Decoding for Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-04-13T00:02:36 | 2024-04-13T00:02:36 |
Mukul Gagrani, Raghavv Goel, Wonseok Jeon, Junyoung Park, Mingu Lee, Christopher Lott
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Inference with Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) is slow due to their
large-language-model backbone which suffers from memory bandwidth bottleneck
and generates tokens auto-regressively. In this paper, we explore the
application of speculative decoding to enhance the inference efficiency of
MLLMs, specifically the LLaVA 7B model. We show that a language-only model can
serve as a good draft model for speculative decoding with LLaVA 7B, bypassing
the need for image tokens and their associated processing components from the
draft model. Our experiments across three different tasks show that speculative
decoding can achieve a memory-bound speedup of up to 2.37$\times$ using a 115M
parameter language model that we trained from scratch. Additionally, we
introduce a compact LLaVA draft model incorporating an image adapter, which
shows marginal performance gains in image captioning while maintaining
comparable results in other tasks.
|
[
-0.17252139747142792,
-0.616998016834259,
0.6659000515937805,
0.3544895350933075,
-0.5313059687614441,
0.20561547577381134,
-0.1637837290763855,
-0.6855530738830566,
0.39634644985198975,
0.7091256976127625,
-0.32563769817352295,
-0.09645835310220718,
-0.474336713552475,
0.02021840773522854,
-0.3455370366573334,
0.3959704339504242,
0.051876142621040344,
-0.040664345026016235,
-0.15133333206176758,
0.1922423541545868,
-0.1988174170255661,
-0.5243525505065918,
-0.540038526058197,
0.2709744870662689,
0.6513375639915466,
0.1317928284406662,
0.5401864647865295,
0.6301445960998535,
0.3407153785228729,
0.3303825259208679,
-0.06631235778331757,
0.516652524471283,
-0.6904129981994629,
0.37343689799308777,
0.034702118486166,
-0.8419929146766663,
-0.33914878964424133,
-0.3829568922519684,
0.850774347782135,
0.2615973949432373,
0.07594551891088486,
0.07307540625333786,
-0.5226964354515076,
0.5553998351097107,
-0.9809632897377014,
0.3925476372241974,
-0.8396803140640259,
-0.2381083369255066,
-0.4424138069152832,
-0.43792977929115295,
-0.9804660677909851,
0.014805072918534279,
-0.37227174639701843,
-0.694075882434845,
0.25166991353034973,
0.6789584159851074,
0.707300066947937,
0.1278049796819687,
-0.2954503297805786,
-0.020080022513866425,
-0.6339431405067444,
0.7798271179199219,
-0.846655011177063,
0.573889970779419,
0.43809568881988525,
0.38131213188171387,
-0.2778468728065491,
-0.715803861618042,
-0.8751220703125,
-0.24836452305316925,
0.0488465242087841,
0.026406865566968918,
-0.06284533441066742,
0.2048136442899704,
0.38059473037719727,
0.1331084668636322,
-0.323839008808136,
0.05216926708817482,
-0.5134930610656738,
-0.5488951206207275,
0.5073410272598267,
0.324207067489624,
-0.0558183528482914,
-0.20948463678359985,
-0.21937620639801025,
-0.08852825313806534,
-0.5696670413017273,
0.006494847591966391,
0.49598219990730286,
0.06447584182024002,
-0.05599411949515343,
0.5785989165306091,
-0.2163863629102707,
0.6974731683731079,
0.0015803686110302806,
-0.5187948346138,
0.24436233937740326,
-0.16348797082901,
-0.107672318816185,
-0.21957337856292725,
0.42458611726760864,
0.6327080726623535,
-0.10928843170404434,
-0.3762357831001282,
-0.2457900196313858,
0.5565069317817688,
0.09817078709602356,
-0.8328137397766113,
-0.24243977665901184,
0.254911869764328,
-0.7573279738426208,
-0.05568521097302437,
-0.42054399847984314,
-0.6978898644447327,
-0.49046722054481506,
0.018361495807766914,
-0.03862579166889191,
-0.5237469673156738,
-0.3402218222618103,
0.37424731254577637,
-0.3795228600502014,
0.26619523763656616,
0.6070678234100342,
-0.9742070436477661,
-0.06434948742389679,
0.23361168801784515,
0.6500126123428345,
-0.17420850694179535,
-0.3630174994468689,
-0.5246917009353638,
0.34345248341560364,
-0.5727952718734741,
1.3467462062835693,
-0.8111942410469055,
-0.28721433877944946,
-0.22333282232284546,
-0.09929460287094116,
-0.1969437152147293,
-0.07954337447881699,
0.6576562523841858,
-0.9849290251731873,
-0.41715338826179504,
-0.25206679105758667,
-0.6252678632736206,
-0.15188904106616974,
0.21926191449165344,
-0.9015367031097412,
0.5065906047821045,
-0.29645800590515137,
-0.8683921694755554,
0.514376163482666,
-0.29153352975845337,
-0.19996321201324463,
-0.09421056509017944,
-0.021897390484809875,
0.04919663444161415,
0.3094245195388794,
0.5769524574279785,
0.5505509376525879,
-0.34839552640914917,
0.20390291512012482,
-0.6004483699798584,
-0.7730615735054016,
0.32702040672302246,
-0.8869873285293579,
0.22534030675888062,
0.5884845852851868,
0.1983523964881897,
0.011305974796414375,
-0.5928886532783508,
-0.08546341210603714,
0.012740548700094223,
-0.46791765093803406,
-0.244393989443779,
-0.045200783759355545,
0.23451051115989685,
-0.13517703115940094,
0.01067275833338499,
-0.489635705947876,
0.4211823344230652,
-0.2882901728153229,
0.1513882875442505,
0.6436256170272827,
-0.14212580025196075,
0.4008219242095947,
-0.27331075072288513,
0.5253779888153076,
0.20857061445713043,
0.08134870231151581,
-0.6338005661964417,
-0.40572214126586914,
-0.9105826616287231,
-0.585258960723877,
0.3626253008842468,
0.2429817020893097,
-1.4337586164474487,
-0.375605046749115,
-0.26158714294433594,
-0.36659327149391174,
-0.8093668818473816,
0.020670779049396515,
0.28908243775367737,
0.18026681244373322,
0.12551066279411316,
0.019538484513759613,
-0.6288263201713562,
-1.024611473083496,
-0.3029497563838959,
-0.16720770299434662,
0.35772567987442017,
0.24581772089004517,
0.08445549011230469,
-0.17403514683246613,
0.32463181018829346,
-0.33300384879112244,
0.3066074252128601,
-0.5358633995056152,
-0.06932085752487183,
0.2884308695793152,
0.34234821796417236,
0.7692689895629883,
-0.6886405348777771,
-0.24875342845916748,
-0.22977660596370697,
-0.709544837474823,
0.24712100625038147,
-0.25367608666419983,
-0.3207378089427948,
0.48691999912261963,
0.6731842160224915,
-0.9600321650505066,
0.332093745470047,
0.6600028276443481,
-0.37759849429130554,
0.6479516625404358,
-0.28894737362861633,
0.45676010847091675,
-0.9325337409973145,
-0.030219068750739098,
-0.3349322974681854,
-0.13904200494289398,
-0.5818802118301392,
0.3439200520515442,
0.32700952887535095,
0.20705561339855194,
-0.6204727292060852,
0.6601400375366211,
-0.7671965956687927,
0.09028303623199463,
-0.4324592053890228,
-0.17801643908023834,
0.19593657553195953,
0.3172979950904846,
0.2218366116285324,
0.8839136958122253,
0.7628698348999023,
-0.38242077827453613,
0.13276362419128418,
-0.22253136336803436,
-0.41769611835479736,
-0.09016184508800507,
-0.23061026632785797,
0.16170816123485565,
-0.5124363899230957,
0.5247475504875183,
-0.9202220439910889,
-0.40084320306777954,
0.11140430718660355,
-0.0769762173295021,
0.42902714014053345,
-0.2528552711009979,
-0.6952069401741028,
-0.49135148525238037,
-0.31439071893692017,
0.7158963084220886,
0.4653145372867584,
-0.4428439140319824,
0.9107603430747986,
0.20169486105442047,
0.2721838057041168,
-0.8821679949760437,
-0.7251892685890198,
0.2665070593357086,
-0.04643655940890312,
-0.5716580152511597,
0.07244045287370682,
-0.0626215785741806,
-0.08031690120697021,
-0.0533779039978981,
0.1631757915019989,
-0.002554146572947502,
-0.1418159008026123,
0.23317952454090118,
0.4060762822628021,
-0.3478091359138489,
0.10116932541131973,
0.29247990250587463,
-0.04768124222755432,
-0.08427418768405914,
-0.3215484917163849,
0.4950401186943054,
-0.24533674120903015,
-0.3298262059688568,
-0.3232875168323517,
0.44809383153915405,
0.7860172986984253,
0.07357277721166611,
0.7356743812561035,
0.5945833921432495,
-0.0551333986222744,
-0.12668748199939728,
-1.1474190950393677,
-0.07617145031690598,
-0.4954075217247009,
0.30117735266685486,
-0.6430845260620117,
-0.8186982870101929,
0.6671865582466125,
-0.117119200527668,
-0.05379481986165047,
0.40923115611076355,
0.6260302066802979,
0.026466330513358116,
0.5671223402023315,
0.6310638189315796,
0.04216194525361061,
0.279961496591568,
-0.25105026364326477,
0.029440805315971375,
-0.6471304893493652,
-0.2713015079498291,
-0.1237703412771225,
-0.17056457698345184,
-0.30328038334846497,
-1.0560990571975708,
-0.057217225432395935,
0.09516781568527222,
0.28898850083351135,
-0.05521944910287857,
-0.00033517443807795644,
0.7136785984039307,
0.456646591424942,
0.25805366039276123,
0.3852480947971344,
0.21862594783306122,
-0.24787768721580505,
-0.028706485405564308,
-0.9743970036506653,
-0.28544068336486816,
1.1547677516937256,
0.26744595170021057,
1.2341722249984741,
0.08332657068967819,
0.373838871717453,
0.2708558738231659,
0.43283262848854065,
-0.5476737022399902,
0.4876112937927246,
-0.23492562770843506,
-0.7281618118286133,
0.04626253619790077,
-0.1705472767353058,
-0.7192718386650085,
0.5314540266990662,
-0.3942320644855499,
-0.6629744172096252,
0.4512593150138855,
0.5903603434562683,
-0.24830904603004456,
0.659970760345459,
-1.0093756914138794,
0.4161660671234131,
0.02683051861822605,
-0.5784270167350769,
-0.3813301622867584,
-0.3759063184261322,
0.8571859002113342,
-0.03339790925383568,
0.19821682572364807,
-0.12768980860710144,
0.033443041145801544,
0.530832827091217,
0.05895985662937164,
0.9965221285820007,
-0.21687141060829163,
0.02510738931596279,
0.4474491775035858,
0.2330971658229828,
0.6377043128013611,
0.12239980697631836,
-0.3955157399177551,
0.08956064283847809,
0.13539259135723114,
-0.6621568202972412,
-0.6770772933959961,
0.624983012676239,
-0.6376800537109375,
-0.7333077788352966,
-0.14229479432106018,
-1.0010367631912231,
-0.320835143327713,
0.04852813854813576,
0.1642991304397583,
0.4071028232574463,
0.2305569052696228,
0.00045408375444822013,
0.538763701915741,
-0.18832747638225555,
0.6139338612556458,
0.3662284016609192,
-0.30220749974250793,
-0.14271873235702515,
0.9678385257720947,
-0.19214947521686554,
0.3710891604423523,
0.5041528940200806,
-0.10293663293123245,
-0.5103079676628113,
-0.8041172623634338,
-0.6499611139297485,
0.29032033681869507,
-0.9623317122459412,
-0.23590759932994843,
-0.8650568723678589,
0.054803989827632904,
-0.3176254332065582,
-0.15821139514446259,
-0.4210549592971802,
-0.5322034358978271,
-0.13878042995929718,
-0.009711350314319134,
0.5416654944419861,
0.5491576194763184,
0.1445804089307785,
0.3247300684452057,
-0.8591859936714172,
0.39700183272361755,
-0.19462360441684723,
0.21075637638568878,
0.4352644383907318,
-0.6618120670318604,
-0.2740944027900696,
-0.17241740226745605,
0.15570086240768433,
-0.5649727582931519,
0.5081993341445923,
0.02953501231968403,
0.6688607931137085,
0.5532389879226685,
0.08840316534042358,
0.9452379941940308,
-0.4721980094909668,
0.6219562888145447,
0.20281168818473816,
-0.6639172434806824,
0.037194933742284775,
-0.3342190086841583,
0.3682781159877777,
0.304828017950058,
0.12826114892959595,
-0.1241212710738182,
-0.53415447473526,
-0.22654186189174652,
-0.778075098991394,
0.44955146312713623,
0.05636593699455261,
0.3722269535064697,
-0.16137012839317322,
0.38500773906707764,
0.3402472138404846,
0.16920627653598785,
-0.6213706731796265,
-0.1490786373615265,
-0.22225511074066162,
0.18309447169303894,
-0.11690381169319153,
-0.7889769077301025,
0.13207800686359406,
-0.2255544811487198,
0.24460376799106598,
-0.28313982486724854,
0.4499189853668213,
0.10018835961818695,
-0.19774536788463593,
0.014048703946173191,
0.3528403341770172,
0.7374615669250488,
0.39864102005958557,
-0.20906522870063782,
0.33647620677948,
0.15085986256599426,
-0.4771823585033417,
0.13873495161533356,
-0.03740502893924713,
-0.041472356766462326,
-0.027990715578198433,
0.681933581829071,
1.1463496685028076,
0.1719360500574112,
-0.8559455871582031,
0.17027468979358673,
-0.3370436728000641,
-0.21472784876823425,
0.08250641077756882,
0.0018279540818184614,
0.30794909596443176,
0.5181663632392883,
0.389843225479126,
0.418104350566864,
0.30115270614624023,
-0.400372713804245,
0.04181857779622078,
0.30481311678886414,
0.31258076429367065,
-0.2148410528898239,
0.6943631172180176,
0.0869329646229744,
0.3182946741580963,
0.47844797372817993,
-0.22675080597400665,
-0.11179227381944656,
0.4937211573123932,
0.9102609157562256,
0.5011435151100159,
0.20099236071109772,
-0.02696070447564125,
0.14070503413677216,
0.36922720074653625,
-0.12127688527107239,
0.5529176592826843,
0.031158611178398132,
-0.7224733829498291,
-0.9125521779060364,
-0.9085943698883057,
-0.20024777948856354,
-0.15754146873950958,
-0.3421904146671295,
-0.11319725215435028,
-0.43332183361053467,
-0.2273523360490799,
-0.16237932443618774,
-0.49567121267318726,
-0.7387140393257141,
-0.0674603134393692,
0.33323317766189575,
1.0957554578781128,
-0.4855804443359375,
1.0869135856628418,
0.44297391176223755,
0.01457307394593954,
-0.934281587600708,
-0.06887071579694748,
-0.29192304611206055,
-0.7970530986785889,
0.8579769730567932,
0.11599522083997726,
-0.3486673831939697,
-0.21987232565879822,
-0.34335440397262573,
-1.1746538877487183,
0.9184896349906921,
0.73215651512146,
-0.8265938758850098,
-0.1411508470773697,
-0.2990022301673889,
0.4500104486942291,
-0.4572087228298187,
0.4262349307537079,
0.2979550063610077,
0.42299985885620117,
0.3984944820404053,
-0.6927986741065979,
0.2263929843902588,
-0.46145978569984436,
0.17501315474510193,
-0.15875594317913055,
-0.723908543586731,
0.982877254486084,
-0.6505426168441772,
-0.15399205684661865,
0.251996248960495,
0.8935351371765137,
0.36441710591316223,
0.19935789704322815,
0.44130584597587585,
0.32146039605140686,
0.6774196028709412,
0.3188137114048004,
1.4484930038452148,
-0.42855140566825867,
0.024184521287679672,
0.7322546243667603,
-0.2033478170633316,
1.0466583967208862,
0.689365565776825,
0.018352782353758812,
0.3930891752243042,
0.532120406627655,
0.16756664216518402,
0.5773025155067444,
-0.024235984310507774,
-0.2652575969696045,
-0.659902811050415,
-0.0964810773730278,
-0.3210006356239319,
0.3720347583293915,
0.6501778364181519,
-0.4202944040298462,
-0.1540469527244568,
0.15101498365402222,
-0.22147443890571594,
-0.13875308632850647,
-0.404255747795105,
0.2647680640220642,
0.10294411331415176,
-0.5269073843955994,
0.8883070349693298,
0.08936569094657898,
0.7926325798034668,
-0.5214540958404541,
0.0013979849172756076,
-0.12936218082904816,
0.14437511563301086,
0.1347055733203888,
-0.5419497489929199,
0.1750425100326538,
-0.26669517159461975,
-0.3325607180595398,
-0.007926363497972488,
0.8508696556091309,
-0.32216981053352356,
-0.8460508584976196,
0.22891360521316528,
0.47553375363349915,
0.2230611890554428,
0.04336170107126236,
-0.4000469744205475,
0.644005298614502,
-0.08584164828062057,
-0.2645801305770874,
0.19593502581119537,
0.4492414593696594,
-0.189814954996109,
0.9775799512863159,
1.011915922164917,
0.06651809811592102,
0.22623422741889954,
0.1308545470237732,
1.2639319896697998,
-0.6864122748374939,
-0.5365012884140015,
-0.8212543725967407,
0.3841801881790161,
0.12652286887168884,
0.04098965600132942,
0.7389169335365295,
0.3750283122062683,
0.41807320713996887,
-0.5578441023826599,
0.7361374497413635,
0.1004372239112854,
0.02547558769583702,
-1.1110395193099976,
0.6607111096382141,
-0.4348912239074707,
0.37861084938049316,
-0.10111499577760696,
-0.5449590682983398,
-0.2016197144985199,
0.1361009031534195,
-0.2525024116039276,
-0.207188218832016,
0.7374921441078186,
0.9755969047546387,
-0.058393508195877075,
-0.1423400193452835,
0.7280848622322083,
0.43177470564842224,
0.19339370727539062,
0.43080297112464905,
0.99715256690979,
-0.26454994082450867,
0.45396849513053894,
-0.18866980075836182,
0.06309546530246735,
-0.2675996720790863,
-0.917747974395752,
-1.271558403968811,
-0.3204403817653656,
0.2614220380783081,
-0.3960522711277008,
0.3318289816379547,
0.6083462238311768,
0.7488042712211609,
-0.5129968523979187,
-0.12659411132335663,
0.3581526279449463,
-0.043975166976451874,
-0.04166289046406746,
-0.19871437549591064,
0.3729613125324249,
-0.34629660844802856,
-0.5944792032241821,
0.5141216516494751,
0.271519273519516,
0.09619995951652527,
-0.2917283773422241,
0.05642296001315117,
-0.18287834525108337,
0.2947269380092621,
0.8637083172798157,
0.06916523724794388,
-1.172191858291626,
0.03011283278465271,
0.14490100741386414,
0.14928768575191498,
-0.221256822347641,
1.001802682876587,
-0.8812416195869446,
0.5026792287826538,
0.338716596364975,
0.6741834878921509,
0.8158220648765564,
-0.04178917780518532,
0.5896684527397156,
-0.26431819796562195,
0.8703247308731079,
0.07783633470535278,
0.6055540442466736,
0.16216447949409485,
-0.5556887984275818,
-0.15492692589759827,
0.33479467034339905,
-0.16869290173053741,
-0.7721953988075256,
0.07176472246646881,
-1.1084575653076172,
-0.484957218170166,
1.163919448852539,
-0.12460780888795853,
-0.6548553705215454,
-0.09085223078727722,
-0.41344037652015686,
-0.27679556608200073,
-0.7113768458366394,
0.6963775753974915,
0.4840572476387024,
-0.09344404935836792,
-0.6194499731063843,
-0.5167656540870667,
0.34834638237953186,
0.2155601978302002,
-0.5440456867218018,
0.17370523512363434,
0.5791271924972534,
0.001680078450590372,
0.054183851927518845,
0.8317487239837646,
0.13120616972446442,
0.4057327210903168,
0.7560551762580872,
-0.056948546320199966,
-0.2238602340221405,
-0.3576051592826843,
0.22746393084526062,
0.243670254945755,
0.3243950605392456,
0.20440073311328888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08846v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08846v2
|
Experimental Design for Active Transductive Inference in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-12T23:27:46 | 2024-05-31T02:37:10 |
Subhojyoti Mukherjee, Anusha Lalitha, Aniket Deshmukh, Ge Liu, Yifei Ma, Branislav Kveton
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
One emergent ability of large language models (LLMs) is that query-specific
examples can be included in the prompt at inference time. In this work, we use
active learning for adaptive prompt design and call it Active In-context Prompt
Design (AIPD). We design the LLM prompt by adaptively choosing few-shot
examples from a training set to optimize performance on a test set. The
training examples are initially unlabeled and we obtain the label of the most
informative ones, which maximally reduces uncertainty in the LLM prediction. We
propose two algorithms, GO and SAL, which differ in how the few-shot examples
are chosen. We analyze these algorithms in linear models: first GO and then use
its equivalence with SAL. We experiment with many different tasks in small,
medium-sized, and large language models; and show that GO and SAL outperform
other methods for choosing few-shot examples in the LLM prompt at inference
time.
|
[
0.0349418930709362,
-1.1247159242630005,
0.7169790267944336,
0.3518356680870056,
-0.2932211458683014,
-0.1924065798521042,
-0.3354272246360779,
-0.3329979479312897,
-0.14900518953800201,
0.09288448840379715,
-0.5882641673088074,
-0.23502638936042786,
-0.17620055377483368,
0.11350386589765549,
-0.15566964447498322,
0.5479224920272827,
-0.18233893811702728,
0.04031598940491676,
0.2589341700077057,
-0.22731992602348328,
-0.4315040111541748,
0.04627477005124092,
-1.106101632118225,
0.07919429242610931,
0.49504196643829346,
0.3568006455898285,
0.6062494516372681,
0.512827455997467,
0.10332050919532776,
0.24844704568386078,
-0.305376797914505,
0.2667139768600464,
-0.06781068444252014,
0.41897308826446533,
-0.22518038749694824,
-0.6195054054260254,
-0.16162541508674622,
0.02235998399555683,
0.8261017799377441,
0.849258542060852,
0.11472296714782715,
-0.06633652001619339,
-0.0905393660068512,
0.025103455409407616,
-0.6904432773590088,
-0.01673138327896595,
-0.5850533843040466,
0.09199775010347366,
0.20503529906272888,
-0.02380005642771721,
-0.715937077999115,
-0.36687174439430237,
0.10210029780864716,
-0.528972327709198,
0.09712816029787064,
0.33273231983184814,
0.4137667715549469,
0.23855344951152802,
-0.31151244044303894,
-0.2985855042934418,
-0.8558640480041504,
0.8497871160507202,
-0.8759101033210754,
0.3327694237232208,
0.2887399196624756,
0.27265679836273193,
-0.3442234694957733,
-0.7872534990310669,
-0.48926082253456116,
-0.29673123359680176,
-0.04483909532427788,
0.09345564246177673,
-0.3459627628326416,
0.04178449884057045,
0.3642300069332123,
-0.11680366098880768,
-0.6077890396118164,
0.41755443811416626,
-0.17552414536476135,
-0.07637158781290054,
0.45514988899230957,
0.012595436535775661,
0.16440677642822266,
0.013137317262589931,
-0.24709229171276093,
0.016340183094143867,
-0.808556318283081,
0.2664092779159546,
0.0307320524007082,
0.5586503744125366,
-0.08940302580595016,
0.5113753080368042,
-0.0036749301943928003,
1.0863368511199951,
0.20144574344158173,
0.0451824888586998,
0.09054688364267349,
-0.31898802518844604,
-0.2859845757484436,
-0.05282263457775116,
0.8777105808258057,
-0.17725075781345367,
0.1665458083152771,
-0.10546291619539261,
-0.3807717263698578,
-0.3281899690628052,
0.08611474931240082,
-0.46580830216407776,
-0.05194038897752762,
0.22757449746131897,
-0.340362012386322,
-0.016576256603002548,
-0.26318925619125366,
-0.5578802227973938,
-0.2939825654029846,
-0.15155386924743652,
0.6447715759277344,
-0.39263099431991577,
-0.03268195316195488,
-0.15406924486160278,
-0.048129964619874954,
0.22737263143062592,
0.49035048484802246,
-0.7720479965209961,
0.18341758847236633,
0.3462221622467041,
0.8926789164543152,
-0.5252469182014465,
-0.35223808884620667,
-1.0703237056732178,
0.18634635210037231,
-0.5185033082962036,
0.9101668000221252,
-0.909678041934967,
-0.3923936188220978,
0.008316205814480782,
0.14152444899082184,
-0.10111173987388611,
-0.35666751861572266,
0.6430685520172119,
-0.6680548191070557,
0.4284384548664093,
-0.08550054579973221,
-0.4673699736595154,
-0.18955077230930328,
0.03223053365945816,
-0.609413743019104,
1.0320101976394653,
0.14734162390232086,
-0.5561517477035522,
0.4432981014251709,
-0.8665806651115417,
-0.3645266890525818,
0.07432220131158829,
-0.1586538553237915,
-0.39391618967056274,
0.40786558389663696,
0.2358541190624237,
0.36921942234039307,
-0.06492096185684204,
0.022423837333917618,
-0.3641829192638397,
-0.4595254063606262,
0.43434786796569824,
-0.4657019078731537,
0.9629074931144714,
0.22212515771389008,
-0.4328267276287079,
0.4228391647338867,
-0.6640231013298035,
0.16894593834877014,
0.0937155932188034,
-0.4203574061393738,
-0.5647580623626709,
0.04830550774931908,
-0.35238751769065857,
-0.042331404983997345,
-0.23303139209747314,
-0.29354920983314514,
0.4027714729309082,
-0.4056966304779053,
0.2347579002380371,
0.9630316495895386,
0.31946295499801636,
0.6809142231941223,
-0.08325176686048508,
0.7191739082336426,
-0.06404931098222733,
0.08471812307834625,
-0.14548607170581818,
-0.4796251058578491,
-0.8169664740562439,
-0.46411198377609253,
0.5504630208015442,
0.5009264945983887,
-0.7913306355476379,
0.2303229719400406,
0.14872366189956665,
-0.2392396628856659,
-0.43113255500793457,
0.032152097672224045,
0.18458639085292816,
0.41720274090766907,
0.20539350807666779,
0.11878732591867447,
-0.3088380694389343,
-0.785071074962616,
-0.3949752748012543,
-0.5411766171455383,
-0.21969588100910187,
0.38698330521583557,
0.2934314012527466,
0.1551707535982132,
0.9051048755645752,
-0.4444523751735687,
0.47653520107269287,
-0.3779229521751404,
0.24714607000350952,
0.40651601552963257,
0.21764466166496277,
0.6903489232063293,
-0.6092647910118103,
-0.5397538542747498,
-0.4697243273258209,
-0.43978366255760193,
-0.4690040946006775,
-0.27396711707115173,
-0.3083603084087372,
-0.005424112547188997,
0.41237980127334595,
-0.4803351163864136,
0.3260785639286041,
0.1770962029695511,
-0.6077369451522827,
0.32979804277420044,
-0.08211232721805573,
-0.06699070334434509,
-0.879285454750061,
-0.21338163316249847,
-0.061848681420087814,
-0.2805948257446289,
-0.7475039958953857,
0.0980498418211937,
0.27668213844299316,
-0.23434126377105713,
-0.6459398865699768,
1.1936960220336914,
-0.7294986248016357,
-0.15405134856700897,
-0.4332500398159027,
-0.11165615916252136,
-0.07632821798324585,
0.5475358366966248,
0.26634660363197327,
0.952813982963562,
0.7212589383125305,
-1.092262625694275,
0.3939017653465271,
0.10673727840185165,
-0.5749574899673462,
0.1384241282939911,
-0.7954615950584412,
0.2293580025434494,
-0.27038636803627014,
0.28708574175834656,
-1.4575793743133545,
-0.10827959328889847,
0.3438442647457123,
-0.21300911903381348,
0.3563450574874878,
0.016129696741700172,
-0.26850804686546326,
-0.30369260907173157,
-0.22835330665111542,
0.4234713017940521,
0.5720260739326477,
-0.7548285722732544,
0.6744533181190491,
0.026692846789956093,
-0.43516942858695984,
-0.4003432095050812,
-0.6513451337814331,
-0.14478088915348053,
-0.3275294601917267,
-0.30008354783058167,
0.0916355699300766,
-0.31680694222450256,
-0.45205533504486084,
-0.12224472314119339,
0.07269185036420822,
-0.04868505522608757,
0.36428770422935486,
0.06797349452972412,
0.19807878136634827,
-0.16827332973480225,
0.3663499355316162,
0.15962634980678558,
0.09252001345157623,
-0.0941542461514473,
-0.15818682312965393,
0.3848084509372711,
0.1924411505460739,
-0.530215859413147,
-0.35015255212783813,
0.4307115375995636,
0.3450351059436798,
-0.13634970784187317,
0.5371659398078918,
0.2742420732975006,
-0.37332814931869507,
-0.8199588656425476,
-0.28894978761672974,
-0.23591390252113342,
-0.4435899555683136,
0.1548946648836136,
-0.43160828948020935,
-0.5312041640281677,
0.42199093103408813,
-0.06314583867788315,
0.6598202586174011,
0.041758012026548386,
0.7314344644546509,
0.07197501510381699,
0.909509539604187,
0.4994467496871948,
0.2102077305316925,
0.9166264533996582,
-0.09906700253486633,
0.07189767807722092,
-0.6646050214767456,
0.11031743139028549,
-0.5785835981369019,
-0.4120902419090271,
-0.08871030807495117,
-0.6075752377510071,
0.5198604464530945,
0.03094564750790596,
-0.25340232253074646,
0.07762862741947174,
-0.18576616048812866,
0.29930171370506287,
0.7083359956741333,
0.17017820477485657,
0.26355037093162537,
0.07587440311908722,
-0.3790780007839203,
0.1743464171886444,
-0.8627014756202698,
-0.2946509122848511,
0.8666579127311707,
0.28388965129852295,
1.1012955904006958,
0.4300861954689026,
0.2470777928829193,
0.2606874704360962,
0.275320827960968,
-0.9957017302513123,
0.6137824058532715,
0.1779453158378601,
-0.7175388932228088,
-0.3801161050796509,
-0.1617923080921173,
-0.9648877382278442,
0.16643457114696503,
0.008088899776339531,
-0.5213028192520142,
0.3930395841598511,
0.1847873330116272,
-0.6100105047225952,
-0.005188374314457178,
-0.8450935482978821,
0.4855140149593353,
-0.3196384608745575,
-0.6822594404220581,
0.12743999063968658,
-0.4604438543319702,
0.3161594271659851,
-0.12239930778741837,
-0.003027821658179164,
0.13460594415664673,
-0.39272332191467285,
0.6772016286849976,
-0.11747618764638901,
0.9466759562492371,
-0.3517698049545288,
-0.09286246448755264,
0.5744497179985046,
0.20980392396450043,
0.8242465853691101,
0.13571181893348694,
-0.5985198020935059,
-0.5615979433059692,
-0.6590704917907715,
-0.40493300557136536,
-0.6499496102333069,
0.42530596256256104,
-0.6059731841087341,
-0.6734591722488403,
-0.24975807964801788,
-0.5427547097206116,
-0.46357813477516174,
0.047404177486896515,
0.11601429432630539,
0.4798622727394104,
-0.11950430274009705,
-0.010221794247627258,
0.7165646553039551,
-0.3000890016555786,
1.005321979522705,
0.9380814433097839,
-0.0059438226744532585,
-0.036345649510622025,
0.3484158217906952,
-0.039189718663692474,
0.4842406213283539,
0.3469848334789276,
0.3561028838157654,
-0.48527607321739197,
-0.7709696888923645,
-0.6179578900337219,
0.2415742129087448,
-0.7799274325370789,
-0.12902145087718964,
-0.6360835433006287,
-0.06133216992020607,
-0.4471413195133209,
-0.13440576195716858,
-0.1252538114786148,
-0.4080655872821808,
-0.38670215010643005,
-0.11522428691387177,
0.41301190853118896,
0.2624112665653229,
0.01957910694181919,
0.3767419159412384,
-0.5039821267127991,
0.40775609016418457,
0.6010530591011047,
0.15695713460445404,
0.021931741386651993,
-0.9763897061347961,
0.12426505237817764,
-0.0854681208729744,
-0.043623413890600204,
-0.8685208559036255,
0.20194685459136963,
0.3783513903617859,
0.924891471862793,
0.5993754267692566,
0.2642263174057007,
0.39053988456726074,
-0.5723523497581482,
0.8601192831993103,
-0.0987938642501831,
-0.6079899072647095,
0.7244377136230469,
-0.14935915172100067,
0.5248408913612366,
0.5837821364402771,
0.5383674502372742,
-0.35498353838920593,
-0.3034571707248688,
-0.43015775084495544,
-0.43459078669548035,
0.7012653350830078,
0.004330903757363558,
0.08840374648571014,
-0.0918208584189415,
0.3529554307460785,
0.4033750891685486,
-0.11093032360076904,
-0.8562957644462585,
-0.09119829535484314,
0.22293812036514282,
-0.19044560194015503,
0.16263900697231293,
-0.34839925169944763,
-0.2387053668498993,
-0.08633098006248474,
0.8131851553916931,
-0.41392260789871216,
0.4876304268836975,
0.05059622973203659,
-0.13155917823314667,
-0.2093985378742218,
0.32122889161109924,
0.4946317970752716,
0.9194167256355286,
-0.06757276505231857,
0.3469553291797638,
0.3553667962551117,
-0.2133469581604004,
0.4574006497859955,
-0.021541832014918327,
-0.5217412710189819,
0.2519262731075287,
0.5987746715545654,
1.2821389436721802,
0.04492652043700218,
-0.6649228930473328,
0.42770108580589294,
-0.2700507640838623,
-0.01642410084605217,
-0.16690100729465485,
0.4749472141265869,
-0.03700084611773491,
0.4575095772743225,
0.4920557737350464,
-0.4209126830101013,
-0.0022904658690094948,
-0.8083910346031189,
-0.014368331991136074,
0.6101930737495422,
-0.2936074137687683,
-0.32337528467178345,
0.7450647354125977,
0.20148013532161713,
-0.6444223523139954,
0.4345460832118988,
-0.3319946527481079,
-0.3217695951461792,
0.4303051233291626,
0.7823815941810608,
0.8624215722084045,
-0.4843757152557373,
0.1983027160167694,
0.24490836262702942,
0.005102373193949461,
-0.15777407586574554,
0.4420711398124695,
-0.0209023617208004,
-0.6595013737678528,
-0.5381512641906738,
-0.546696662902832,
-0.5210550427436829,
0.2863977253437042,
-0.2144903987646103,
0.515458881855011,
-0.39830282330513,
0.0680031105875969,
-0.0008816696354188025,
-0.028990469872951508,
-0.32880908250808716,
0.17714832723140717,
0.08591926097869873,
1.069556474685669,
-0.9933515787124634,
0.6585968732833862,
0.9554915428161621,
0.03288041055202484,
-0.6788124442100525,
0.10088860988616943,
-0.13646680116653442,
-0.9523741602897644,
0.5404310822486877,
-0.2758540213108063,
0.2502445578575134,
0.012185871601104736,
-0.7308042049407959,
-0.7804837822914124,
0.8695979714393616,
0.2030586153268814,
-0.4492310881614685,
-0.20332008600234985,
-0.37293192744255066,
0.18293245136737823,
-0.3619001507759094,
0.4935002326965332,
0.37750044465065,
0.47860822081565857,
0.35625654458999634,
-0.6376736164093018,
0.10725528746843338,
-0.08400697261095047,
-0.09677913039922714,
0.1760510951280594,
-0.700955331325531,
0.8210821747779846,
-0.35712364315986633,
-0.22818788886070251,
0.08441263437271118,
0.8411495089530945,
0.7051873803138733,
0.23678883910179138,
1.003920316696167,
0.11858715116977692,
0.7273231148719788,
0.10804778337478638,
0.9048140645027161,
-0.0029840818606317043,
-0.05822518840432167,
1.1782951354980469,
-0.20072074234485626,
0.5490496754646301,
0.507361888885498,
-0.272150456905365,
0.17824769020080566,
1.018450140953064,
0.08357644081115723,
0.7691968679428101,
0.1659710854291916,
-0.6079075336456299,
-0.22375774383544922,
-0.0849849283695221,
-0.11909568309783936,
0.380097895860672,
0.3031698763370514,
-0.46415019035339355,
-0.27657172083854675,
0.18384797871112823,
0.02198236621916294,
-0.36863890290260315,
-0.38038092851638794,
0.7718902230262756,
-0.05944612994790077,
-1.0202341079711914,
0.5972489714622498,
0.10924050956964493,
0.426472932100296,
-0.710896909236908,
-0.039525363594293594,
-0.47482073307037354,
0.01891838014125824,
0.17483608424663544,
-0.6200425624847412,
-0.13137920200824738,
0.011307732202112675,
-0.005851190071552992,
-0.2402334362268448,
0.7609517574310303,
-0.39349624514579773,
-0.6874131560325623,
0.008235715329647064,
0.6588131189346313,
0.2611454427242279,
0.2100990116596222,
-0.7449322938919067,
-0.036596138030290604,
0.061175767332315445,
-0.7308157086372375,
0.08648013323545456,
0.6763913035392761,
-0.34163710474967957,
0.6318548917770386,
0.4220031499862671,
0.34642645716667175,
0.3102477788925171,
0.07676484435796738,
0.9274654388427734,
-0.6738191843032837,
-0.5571126937866211,
-0.8394798040390015,
0.4259222447872162,
0.06259734183549881,
-0.2516588568687439,
0.5593016743659973,
0.4299096167087555,
0.27106574177742004,
-0.03267889469861984,
0.8723655343055725,
-0.036341264843940735,
0.6427507996559143,
-0.7980601191520691,
0.08693289756774902,
-0.5686171650886536,
0.357200562953949,
-0.06301094591617584,
-1.0856715440750122,
-0.14567559957504272,
0.6939103603363037,
-0.1414674073457718,
0.05220554396510124,
0.8277400732040405,
0.7756014466285706,
-0.3204127550125122,
-0.132446750998497,
0.09465844184160233,
0.31654244661331177,
0.4880271553993225,
0.6579500436782837,
0.8429898619651794,
-0.10478672385215759,
0.40638405084609985,
-0.12931489944458008,
-0.3485253155231476,
-0.2264387458562851,
-1.0315660238265991,
-0.9895192384719849,
-0.3983810842037201,
-0.21122047305107117,
-0.2313387542963028,
0.0004027370014227927,
0.9151744842529297,
0.5914871096611023,
-0.7001436352729797,
-0.01998128555715084,
-0.07468948513269424,
0.3358929753303528,
-0.26708176732063293,
-0.18612347543239594,
0.4833318591117859,
-0.4389607608318329,
-1.076820731163025,
0.8310112357139587,
0.049674779176712036,
0.26365286111831665,
-0.20581580698490143,
0.11865246295928955,
-0.5553164482116699,
0.11666680127382278,
0.4367721378803253,
0.3332987427711487,
-0.4808283746242523,
-0.46558770537376404,
0.08356396853923798,
0.028867298737168312,
-0.14585866034030914,
0.9154382944107056,
-0.9309270977973938,
0.3340437412261963,
0.7100481390953064,
0.73973548412323,
0.3520592153072357,
0.20157629251480103,
0.7322500348091125,
-0.6864314079284668,
0.470304399728775,
0.36225053668022156,
0.3580875098705292,
0.0012649907730519772,
-0.1495283842086792,
0.7419565916061401,
0.15092940628528595,
-0.31336167454719543,
-1.0317655801773071,
0.2800692915916443,
-0.916412353515625,
-0.6931070685386658,
1.6027296781539917,
-0.30751752853393555,
-0.41822341084480286,
-0.13371038436889648,
-0.10777955502271652,
0.24942705035209656,
-0.3689114451408386,
0.5367146134376526,
0.6536882519721985,
-0.4288245141506195,
-0.30921897292137146,
-0.6374146342277527,
0.3592645227909088,
0.47100257873535156,
-0.787447452545166,
0.22438880801200867,
0.49085965752601624,
0.16100434958934784,
-0.06704417616128922,
0.5805536508560181,
0.3459034562110901,
0.325591504573822,
-0.23145370185375214,
-0.31743431091308594,
-0.08278333395719528,
-0.4165783226490021,
-0.4725385308265686,
0.24861621856689453,
0.28351104259490967,
-0.23625338077545166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08836v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08836v1
|
BERT-LSH: Reducing Absolute Compute For Attention
| 2024-04-12T22:35:00 | 2024-04-12T22:35:00 |
Zezheng Li, Kingston Yip
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This study introduces a novel BERT-LSH model that incorporates Locality
Sensitive Hashing (LSH) to approximate the attention mechanism in the BERT
architecture. We examine the computational efficiency and performance of this
model compared to a standard baseline BERT model. Our findings reveal that
BERT-LSH significantly reduces computational demand for the self-attention
layer while unexpectedly outperforming the baseline model in pretraining and
fine-tuning tasks. These results suggest that the LSH-based attention mechanism
not only offers computational advantages but also may enhance the model's
ability to generalize from its training data. For more information, visit our
GitHub repository: https://github.com/leo4life2/algoml-final
|
[
-0.41932857036590576,
-1.0023738145828247,
0.7689353823661804,
-0.25746020674705505,
-0.10262493789196014,
-0.3692900240421295,
-0.1614132970571518,
-0.8127227425575256,
0.14514805376529694,
0.41179347038269043,
-0.8820393681526184,
-0.3476356863975525,
-0.14923445880413055,
-0.3164115250110626,
-0.5868465900421143,
0.9699985980987549,
0.11160044372081757,
-0.14471888542175293,
-0.16893962025642395,
0.21744030714035034,
0.05241616070270538,
-0.49420854449272156,
-0.644982635974884,
-0.2525227963924408,
0.8788971304893494,
0.2886662781238556,
0.6143489480018616,
0.8135496377944946,
1.1091197729110718,
0.1927371472120285,
0.07548799365758896,
-0.30660510063171387,
-0.7836295962333679,
0.11621294915676117,
-0.0011925899889320135,
-0.3477470874786377,
-0.6331428289413452,
-0.32537025213241577,
0.8559544086456299,
0.6241860389709473,
-0.082426056265831,
0.545124888420105,
-0.16328726708889008,
0.999679684638977,
-1.0578256845474243,
-0.027082296088337898,
-0.8027077317237854,
0.11251673102378845,
-0.31305384635925293,
0.1236170083284378,
-0.38214537501335144,
-0.14783218502998352,
0.25695523619651794,
-0.6654977202415466,
0.6515922546386719,
-0.059273019433021545,
0.8764750957489014,
0.6865447759628296,
0.09890627861022949,
0.10528848320245743,
-0.3897257149219513,
0.8552009463310242,
-0.7569065093994141,
0.36809009313583374,
0.6341145634651184,
0.014935336075723171,
0.2428325116634369,
-0.9049386978149414,
-0.2989186942577362,
-0.05756533518433571,
0.04109783470630646,
0.1687808632850647,
-0.037097856402397156,
0.4989543855190277,
0.29980894923210144,
0.5529289841651917,
-0.2567494213581085,
0.020471401512622833,
-0.2807076573371887,
-0.1847403347492218,
0.2144818902015686,
0.13121068477630615,
-0.0316351018846035,
-0.21495652198791504,
-0.3559226393699646,
0.1226499080657959,
-0.8979784846305847,
0.15380366146564484,
0.11921839416027069,
0.5232701897621155,
-0.00044085949775762856,
0.19680626690387726,
-0.1589650958776474,
0.8227458000183105,
0.33295994997024536,
0.34042179584503174,
0.0019499262562021613,
-0.0609419122338295,
-0.4848652184009552,
0.13955539464950562,
0.40873634815216064,
0.23069633543491364,
-0.10088559240102768,
-0.05036615580320358,
-0.09937187284231186,
-0.15292827785015106,
0.7832121849060059,
-0.9136665463447571,
-0.37924832105636597,
0.5312907695770264,
-0.7953894138336182,
-0.5195984244346619,
-0.22249984741210938,
-0.24379876255989075,
-0.021675147116184235,
-0.13671168684959412,
0.6598978638648987,
-0.513093888759613,
0.19703280925750732,
-0.33488667011260986,
0.23560000956058502,
0.40365153551101685,
0.2706865966320038,
-1.1480265855789185,
0.39031144976615906,
0.6944855451583862,
0.8736205101013184,
-0.22780044376850128,
-0.19629499316215515,
-0.4395759105682373,
0.3605094254016876,
-0.3643098771572113,
0.5455788373947144,
-0.11813119053840637,
-0.18266436457633972,
-0.10371366143226624,
-0.27751630544662476,
0.2229868769645691,
-0.5423315763473511,
0.6390652656555176,
-0.6576464772224426,
-0.1006944477558136,
-0.8359853625297546,
-0.6467514634132385,
-0.15539886057376862,
0.18080610036849976,
-0.9797998070716858,
1.0094610452651978,
0.234731987118721,
-0.8342621326446533,
0.08674748986959457,
-1.1129941940307617,
-0.47363701462745667,
0.20338863134384155,
0.08034251630306244,
-0.5375834107398987,
0.2858239710330963,
0.15054801106452942,
0.44957783818244934,
-0.082537442445755,
-0.10445282608270645,
-0.49265989661216736,
-0.8474798202514648,
-0.0926118865609169,
-0.05131829157471657,
0.6813316941261292,
0.47399234771728516,
-0.4505860507488251,
0.4318011701107025,
-0.44002726674079895,
0.4809858500957489,
0.12605924904346466,
-0.1688389629125595,
-0.27017220854759216,
0.07183278352022171,
0.17251752316951752,
-0.13785400986671448,
0.6540409922599792,
-0.4052642583847046,
0.0747496709227562,
-0.5314680337905884,
0.43043726682662964,
1.1455296277999878,
-0.24625606834888458,
0.4514044225215912,
-0.3243212401866913,
0.044742170721292496,
-0.509924590587616,
0.5180237889289856,
-0.10696391016244888,
-0.2080068290233612,
-0.8345975279808044,
-0.5314041376113892,
0.7507560849189758,
0.33626097440719604,
-0.23417529463768005,
0.5656949281692505,
-0.08054666221141815,
-0.1687011420726776,
-1.2014635801315308,
0.02583486959338188,
0.5325292348861694,
0.5061127543449402,
0.25662025809288025,
-0.5684236884117126,
-0.40576067566871643,
-1.353714942932129,
0.10475452989339828,
-0.17338381707668304,
0.08162149041891098,
0.3855755031108856,
0.16043636202812195,
-0.18156227469444275,
0.8370493054389954,
-0.2997637093067169,
-0.22659030556678772,
-0.02710190787911415,
0.08076422661542892,
0.2299107015132904,
0.3388504385948181,
0.6902067065238953,
-0.5649446249008179,
-0.8536977767944336,
-0.02445848658680916,
-0.6676573753356934,
-0.00427670031785965,
-0.0041295732371509075,
-0.30291691422462463,
0.2781955301761627,
0.3738763928413391,
-0.7547294497489929,
0.6817243695259094,
0.3426175117492676,
0.029858050867915154,
0.5976601243019104,
-0.19469158351421356,
0.31100723147392273,
-0.6259865760803223,
0.5396139621734619,
-0.5601927042007446,
-0.33151015639305115,
-0.791244626045227,
0.8364476561546326,
0.4256241023540497,
-0.06368057429790497,
-0.4669298231601715,
0.4813639223575592,
-0.49230220913887024,
-0.3643880784511566,
-0.2612264156341553,
-0.25867798924446106,
-0.2921660244464874,
0.7385597229003906,
-0.05418197065591812,
0.9742823243141174,
0.5959646105766296,
-0.5340293049812317,
0.3150622546672821,
0.11053550243377686,
-0.5560861825942993,
0.276413232088089,
-0.8422962427139282,
0.3934266269207001,
0.09194327890872955,
-0.0762307196855545,
-0.8608160018920898,
-0.33830320835113525,
0.05055992677807808,
-0.5928531885147095,
0.390421062707901,
0.28130030632019043,
-0.5809774398803711,
-0.4653390347957611,
-0.8642711043357849,
0.4732951819896698,
0.7186890244483948,
-0.5783329010009766,
0.45206207036972046,
0.03889695554971695,
-0.170416459441185,
-0.6532604694366455,
-0.8442316055297852,
-0.12739454209804535,
0.013931280001997948,
-0.3747187852859497,
0.7935265302658081,
-0.3769616186618805,
-0.3594900071620941,
0.27757424116134644,
-0.14983882009983063,
-0.3152240812778473,
0.1584320366382599,
0.09715614467859268,
0.12938183546066284,
-0.06640179455280304,
0.35346370935440063,
-0.05976521596312523,
0.10587598383426666,
0.15679636597633362,
0.045802388340234756,
0.5365577936172485,
-0.044778451323509216,
-0.5053382515907288,
-0.721429705619812,
0.6519723534584045,
0.5935627818107605,
0.003039659233763814,
0.7180473208427429,
0.6541762351989746,
-0.3601921498775482,
-0.0775425136089325,
-0.6415122747421265,
-0.47825396060943604,
-0.5349814891815186,
0.6141781806945801,
-0.29404041171073914,
-0.7069766521453857,
0.8583500981330872,
0.4357392191886902,
0.17484299838542938,
0.4515393078327179,
0.872667670249939,
-0.6209208369255066,
0.7895799875259399,
0.6888095736503601,
-0.4505521059036255,
0.9208294153213501,
-0.044387150555849075,
0.15973857045173645,
-0.9364174604415894,
0.35107800364494324,
-0.20839987695217133,
-0.5613114833831787,
-0.28346875309944153,
-0.33370110392570496,
0.45370417833328247,
-0.22250738739967346,
-0.5943741798400879,
-0.1759444773197174,
-0.8280780911445618,
0.6476263999938965,
0.9669605493545532,
0.5133316516876221,
-0.19627130031585693,
0.08946241438388824,
0.21594323217868805,
-0.17113998532295227,
-0.7501938939094543,
0.12098222970962524,
1.3199328184127808,
0.2222219705581665,
0.5647186040878296,
0.0985841453075409,
0.9164636731147766,
0.7988146543502808,
0.1636059433221817,
-0.8439290523529053,
0.5784199833869934,
-0.09118888527154922,
-0.9979660511016846,
-0.5554247498512268,
-0.5340681076049805,
-0.9396371841430664,
-0.06497835367918015,
0.1319338083267212,
-0.5288820266723633,
-0.2113015502691269,
0.24066311120986938,
-0.6595190763473511,
0.42076873779296875,
-0.9344196319580078,
0.7407884001731873,
-0.20553117990493774,
-0.7193662524223328,
-0.5656062364578247,
-0.9097299575805664,
0.13301129639148712,
-0.3095995783805847,
0.21523551642894745,
-0.031000176444649696,
0.02384910173714161,
0.5857512354850769,
-0.5976324081420898,
0.9295315146446228,
-0.2813883125782013,
-0.15447580814361572,
0.3344630002975464,
-0.013274535536766052,
0.776283860206604,
-0.4440590739250183,
-0.012659337371587753,
0.029908733442425728,
-0.40841788053512573,
-0.8708763718605042,
-0.30231258273124695,
0.9658691883087158,
-0.9551766514778137,
-0.39450252056121826,
-0.08126379549503326,
-0.7598639130592346,
-0.12278863042593002,
0.35839203000068665,
0.31355419754981995,
0.11455591022968292,
-0.1533305048942566,
0.12820827960968018,
0.9919212460517883,
0.1034654825925827,
0.42546817660331726,
0.37564581632614136,
-0.03685475140810013,
-0.26567959785461426,
0.5888329148292542,
0.14980705082416534,
0.5761667490005493,
0.4918045699596405,
-0.14175337553024292,
-0.11698590964078903,
-0.554830014705658,
-0.10449396818876266,
0.21341632306575775,
-0.7943503260612488,
-0.19209426641464233,
-0.24405373632907867,
-0.40595901012420654,
-0.4574061632156372,
-0.387368768453598,
-0.5271593928337097,
-0.3388597369194031,
-0.221086785197258,
0.005453511606901884,
0.3143455982208252,
0.5519181489944458,
-0.20772868394851685,
0.4045332372188568,
-0.47888806462287903,
0.5715172290802002,
0.7763135433197021,
0.7168493270874023,
0.30830898880958557,
-0.6311635971069336,
-0.6375975608825684,
-0.129760280251503,
-0.1356097161769867,
-0.646277904510498,
0.022025618702173233,
0.2616721987724304,
0.7106398344039917,
0.32092270255088806,
0.09600593894720078,
0.8682325482368469,
-0.5306124091148376,
0.6317978501319885,
0.2560209333896637,
-1.2666893005371094,
0.6262145042419434,
-0.6832563877105713,
0.7528319358825684,
0.7927153706550598,
0.03673039376735687,
-0.13609328866004944,
-0.16528145968914032,
-0.6602184772491455,
-1.0445226430892944,
0.8364806175231934,
0.48032280802726746,
-0.06724309921264648,
0.11629228293895721,
0.6573868989944458,
0.01087589468806982,
0.18690700829029083,
-0.9228932857513428,
-0.47368448972702026,
0.2125028669834137,
-0.38833722472190857,
0.31916090846061707,
-0.608962893486023,
-0.12470565736293793,
-0.5056237578392029,
0.736627459526062,
0.15600502490997314,
0.9651656746864319,
0.33499935269355774,
-0.0767010971903801,
-0.45353081822395325,
-0.06492270529270172,
0.37732040882110596,
0.3520166873931885,
-0.7825697660446167,
-0.02135433442890644,
0.3583144545555115,
-0.6279083490371704,
-0.2810676097869873,
-0.024973995983600616,
-0.39157089591026306,
-0.07057911902666092,
0.5842646956443787,
0.6369789242744446,
0.3112667500972748,
-0.4570479094982147,
0.2215161770582199,
0.17409725487232208,
-0.3377557396888733,
-0.022949937731027603,
-0.04360220581293106,
0.015738366171717644,
-0.04550258442759514,
0.3373572528362274,
-0.07157731056213379,
0.574087381362915,
-0.571682333946228,
0.18805409967899323,
0.43681439757347107,
-0.5162754654884338,
-0.07551730424165726,
0.5796839594841003,
0.3493325412273407,
-0.2076939195394516,
0.5808133482933044,
0.030409742146730423,
-0.42898857593536377,
0.8499983549118042,
0.3847149610519409,
0.9214929938316345,
-0.477826863527298,
-0.3251667618751526,
0.32763686776161194,
0.39873892068862915,
0.20314998924732208,
0.3659249246120453,
-0.7057417035102844,
-0.3691422641277313,
-0.5780941247940063,
-0.24643553793430328,
-0.62166827917099,
0.15508604049682617,
-1.0018600225448608,
0.0769096091389656,
-0.6623013615608215,
-0.396224707365036,
0.018376080319285393,
0.09076789766550064,
-0.6175062656402588,
0.14848902821540833,
0.35723716020584106,
0.4777073264122009,
-0.2243833690881729,
1.1120675802230835,
0.6929774284362793,
0.10465817153453827,
-0.35433661937713623,
0.19994796812534332,
-0.26490071415901184,
-0.9614750146865845,
0.2640824317932129,
0.2525758743286133,
-0.2673402726650238,
0.07193155586719513,
-0.8384112119674683,
-1.1488831043243408,
1.0032817125320435,
0.40114665031433105,
-0.9045152068138123,
-0.05575501546263695,
-0.2812436521053314,
0.45845550298690796,
0.22789005935192108,
0.03452424332499504,
0.3417065441608429,
0.41681933403015137,
-0.20789794623851776,
-1.0620262622833252,
-0.1569116711616516,
-0.4128468334674835,
-0.21772587299346924,
0.6219953298568726,
-0.8434857130050659,
1.097730040550232,
-0.4560714066028595,
-0.1469782441854477,
0.16185395419597626,
0.4321193993091583,
0.23021210730075836,
0.0927668958902359,
0.3144274950027466,
0.7635684609413147,
0.8125714063644409,
0.026407698169350624,
1.065819501876831,
-0.5484450459480286,
0.7185087203979492,
1.198543906211853,
-0.3851558566093445,
0.9096564650535583,
0.607638955116272,
-0.5016574859619141,
0.40494194626808167,
0.7002241611480713,
0.2395353615283966,
1.0958404541015625,
0.16545885801315308,
-0.20881149172782898,
-0.34829527139663696,
-0.011329378932714462,
-0.7719302773475647,
0.01277875155210495,
0.16269844770431519,
-0.4332086145877838,
0.05052837356925011,
-0.4258689284324646,
-0.35697099566459656,
-0.24518272280693054,
-0.7518825531005859,
0.7394081950187683,
-0.18103377521038055,
-0.3059858977794647,
0.7193621397018433,
-0.13737574219703674,
0.7654759287834167,
-1.0606391429901123,
0.10256937146186829,
0.00664613489061594,
0.2727440297603607,
-0.024243498221039772,
-0.5014042258262634,
0.28192761540412903,
-0.06946328282356262,
-0.7487934827804565,
-0.11875349283218384,
0.8954693675041199,
-0.11081521213054657,
-0.41740140318870544,
0.3661308288574219,
0.24193626642227173,
0.11137484014034271,
-0.2357308715581894,
-0.8662884831428528,
0.15147508680820465,
0.26193130016326904,
-0.3887998163700104,
0.5520972013473511,
0.31304505467414856,
0.1545531004667282,
0.6553152799606323,
0.7543043494224548,
0.0014713561395183206,
-0.06849995255470276,
0.09666959941387177,
0.747696042060852,
-0.9333760738372803,
-0.7866626381874084,
-0.851751446723938,
0.15182794630527496,
-0.11183091998100281,
0.1105731949210167,
0.5037030577659607,
0.42573466897010803,
0.6109263300895691,
-0.2926315367221832,
0.9161229133605957,
-0.17130552232265472,
0.7040865421295166,
-0.37340158224105835,
0.9760253429412842,
-0.6927886009216309,
0.019058028236031532,
-0.18974469602108002,
-0.7920827269554138,
-0.16393519937992096,
0.7955389022827148,
-0.05632706731557846,
0.31031277775764465,
0.6940353512763977,
0.30699682235717773,
-0.028948357328772545,
-0.2492310106754303,
0.4633823037147522,
0.3348592519760132,
-0.009780279360711575,
0.8657577633857727,
0.44315794110298157,
-0.3485168218612671,
0.17703332006931305,
-0.517333447933197,
-0.09683402627706528,
-0.42967289686203003,
-0.6926948428153992,
-0.9105563759803772,
-0.4487836956977844,
-0.016972623765468597,
0.10070236772298813,
0.4026224911212921,
0.7825934290885925,
1.0077450275421143,
-0.9621022343635559,
-0.07725195586681366,
-0.08615873008966446,
-0.15529493987560272,
-0.3310699462890625,
-0.2062484622001648,
0.6857317090034485,
-0.5744884610176086,
-0.44967570900917053,
0.07634646445512772,
0.17572903633117676,
-0.043247371912002563,
-0.3259525001049042,
0.058340247720479965,
-0.1634901463985443,
0.19515225291252136,
0.5731775760650635,
0.08764971047639847,
-0.9412617683410645,
-0.2592937648296356,
0.011760154739022255,
-0.39224615693092346,
0.05678902566432953,
0.6758849620819092,
-0.7946736812591553,
0.5056182742118835,
0.22279180586338043,
0.5289386510848999,
0.7666938900947571,
0.13087794184684753,
0.26781511306762695,
-0.8546132445335388,
0.2339266985654831,
0.27803975343704224,
0.13388581573963165,
0.2090413123369217,
-0.7761180400848389,
0.5797086954116821,
-0.029547056183218956,
-0.8346666693687439,
-0.9319891333580017,
0.23406559228897095,
-1.129652976989746,
-0.5016250610351562,
0.8579643964767456,
0.023691415786743164,
-0.6166742444038391,
0.0700637474656105,
-0.22262834012508392,
0.03100324235856533,
-0.610030472278595,
1.2035988569259644,
0.8964207768440247,
-0.1662825495004654,
-0.19971977174282074,
-0.6310425996780396,
0.5643255710601807,
0.9696252346038818,
-0.7557193636894226,
0.36336749792099,
0.3804999887943268,
0.10860411077737808,
0.0904056653380394,
0.8849701285362244,
0.19794438779354095,
0.845085620880127,
-0.03857972472906113,
0.6724866032600403,
0.034628815948963165,
-0.31254082918167114,
-0.1686287671327591,
0.1934148520231247,
0.12430032342672348,
-0.2890913188457489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08821v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08821v1
|
Constrained C-Test Generation via Mixed-Integer Programming
| 2024-04-12T21:35:21 | 2024-04-12T21:35:21 |
Ji-Ung Lee, Marc E. Pfetsch, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This work proposes a novel method to generate C-Tests; a deviated form of
cloze tests (a gap filling exercise) where only the last part of a word is
turned into a gap. In contrast to previous works that only consider varying the
gap size or gap placement to achieve locally optimal solutions, we propose a
mixed-integer programming (MIP) approach. This allows us to consider gap size
and placement simultaneously, achieving globally optimal solutions, and to
directly integrate state-of-the-art models for gap difficulty prediction into
the optimization problem. A user study with 40 participants across four C-Test
generation strategies (including GPT-4) shows that our approach (MIP)
significantly outperforms two of the baseline strategies (based on gap
placement and GPT-4); and performs on-par with the third (based on gap size).
Our analysis shows that GPT-4 still struggles to fulfill explicit constraints
during generation and that MIP produces C-Tests that correlate best with the
perceived difficulty. We publish our code, model, and collected data consisting
of 32 English C-Tests with 20 gaps each (totaling 3,200 individual gap
responses) under an open source license.
|
[
-0.8030426502227783,
-0.5648727416992188,
0.5737162828445435,
0.3750840723514557,
-0.13526257872581482,
0.11509955674409866,
-0.21333853900432587,
-0.49698883295059204,
-0.17156165838241577,
0.11356106400489807,
-0.7832989692687988,
-0.31828680634498596,
-0.0776536837220192,
0.30950894951820374,
0.2073270082473755,
0.8006576299667358,
-0.46550098061561584,
0.12824690341949463,
-0.25456705689430237,
0.18122071027755737,
-0.6192265152931213,
-0.2702845633029938,
0.01931149512529373,
-0.03578060492873192,
0.2803492546081543,
0.8035346865653992,
0.5799094438552856,
0.3376672565937042,
0.4822516441345215,
0.13927145302295685,
0.04786593094468117,
0.11622780561447144,
-0.318951278924942,
-0.0716414526104927,
0.10506124049425125,
-0.14349058270454407,
0.173142209649086,
-0.033355940133333206,
0.48256322741508484,
0.8159385919570923,
-0.38006287813186646,
-0.03487900644540787,
-0.01702161133289337,
0.20794111490249634,
-0.8686221241950989,
-0.2263268381357193,
-0.8535874485969543,
0.15027280151844025,
-0.3483729958534241,
0.06719397753477097,
-0.22670739889144897,
-0.5582746267318726,
-0.11886836588382721,
-0.5230973362922668,
0.512969434261322,
0.18067897856235504,
0.7590697407722473,
0.45284807682037354,
-0.310712605714798,
-0.6188589930534363,
-0.43372097611427307,
0.6695592999458313,
-0.7411966323852539,
0.41856756806373596,
0.03377227857708931,
-0.027037085965275764,
-0.4667396545410156,
-0.4882488250732422,
-0.7071859836578369,
-0.6426666378974915,
0.2657473087310791,
0.2693188786506653,
0.41398540139198303,
0.27503907680511475,
0.48474475741386414,
0.6824277639389038,
-0.9408940672874451,
-0.011876414529979229,
-0.807468593120575,
-0.3229842483997345,
0.7386506199836731,
0.14917461574077606,
0.5727681517601013,
0.23582495748996735,
-0.3726504445075989,
0.10769824683666229,
-0.8322234153747559,
0.2564057409763336,
0.5543904900550842,
-0.010941712185740471,
0.10552187263965607,
0.827697217464447,
-0.16175909340381622,
0.7019144892692566,
0.1226554811000824,
-0.03727004677057266,
0.19371351599693298,
-0.21645838022232056,
0.02022748999297619,
-0.14410912990570068,
0.5222761631011963,
0.21832974255084991,
0.16975775361061096,
0.1239769384264946,
-0.2143920212984085,
0.35262832045555115,
0.016987396404147148,
-0.8693431615829468,
-0.21510103344917297,
0.05281013622879982,
0.09202119708061218,
-0.021226441487669945,
-0.03298123553395271,
-0.7344740033149719,
0.011747369542717934,
-0.12701351940631866,
0.04270213842391968,
-0.42444536089897156,
0.025037188082933426,
0.33134910464286804,
-0.14262987673282623,
0.08249609917402267,
-0.21441225707530975,
-0.9081230163574219,
0.38414737582206726,
0.2477881759405136,
0.8760286569595337,
-0.4458518922328949,
-0.3525615930557251,
-0.38585329055786133,
-0.016834495589137077,
-0.3208962678909302,
0.5817418098449707,
-0.41217875480651855,
-0.7731444835662842,
-0.14433787763118744,
-0.6217206716537476,
-0.39408543705940247,
-0.5310189723968506,
0.3835899233818054,
-0.19957208633422852,
0.4460797905921936,
-0.01713304966688156,
-0.5619893074035645,
0.357715368270874,
0.21900321543216705,
-0.36065930128097534,
1.2474268674850464,
0.524286687374115,
-0.7935450077056885,
0.2907545864582062,
-0.7034949660301208,
-0.13625675439834595,
0.3126714825630188,
-0.5736594796180725,
-0.3793431222438812,
0.14566989243030548,
0.13331718742847443,
-0.012609346769750118,
-0.1068151444196701,
0.04313706234097481,
-0.5043252110481262,
-0.5800924301147461,
0.24474850296974182,
0.004021910950541496,
0.5780622363090515,
0.242399662733078,
-0.5289769172668457,
-0.21011650562286377,
-0.4635772705078125,
0.43974581360816956,
-0.03751220926642418,
-0.5743722319602966,
0.06252121925354004,
-0.0876399353146553,
-0.421713262796402,
0.2330498993396759,
0.2356022149324417,
-0.8917038440704346,
0.4522686004638672,
-0.5439857244491577,
0.1865614950656891,
0.767760694026947,
0.4463765323162079,
0.27398863434791565,
-0.19465047121047974,
0.9931175112724304,
-0.22617992758750916,
0.4140336215496063,
0.2985592484474182,
-0.7083390355110168,
-0.511946976184845,
-0.15398433804512024,
0.19148659706115723,
0.7834357619285583,
-0.7038548588752747,
0.06647317856550217,
0.2058659940958023,
-0.4205682575702667,
-0.2500193417072296,
0.2546258866786957,
0.20367567241191864,
0.20885232090950012,
0.16637039184570312,
-0.3213025629520416,
-0.07627814263105392,
-0.8816030621528625,
-0.09810992330312729,
-0.043024223297834396,
-0.040332961827516556,
0.43678203225135803,
0.5582557320594788,
-0.06713356822729111,
0.632826030254364,
-1.1201963424682617,
0.17165276408195496,
-0.17421607673168182,
-0.004613738972693682,
0.2231971025466919,
0.47238069772720337,
0.3080271780490875,
-0.8321162462234497,
-0.6838456392288208,
-0.1259908378124237,
-0.09986015409231186,
-0.4388381838798523,
-0.3095964193344116,
0.1070803701877594,
-0.04174184799194336,
0.3173695504665375,
-0.5474311113357544,
0.6518632173538208,
0.6626132130622864,
-0.21670129895210266,
1.049033284187317,
-0.10342121124267578,
-0.017383141443133354,
-0.55352383852005,
-0.23688733577728271,
-0.18033084273338318,
0.10799884796142578,
-0.23730222880840302,
0.3090772032737732,
-0.01375391986221075,
-0.6914565563201904,
-0.4218008518218994,
0.31907543540000916,
-0.8084262609481812,
0.2256017029285431,
0.015795135870575905,
-0.15599922835826874,
-0.35834306478500366,
0.6945463418960571,
-0.09960957616567612,
1.001068115234375,
0.3859006464481354,
-0.6068171262741089,
-0.20510002970695496,
0.02891385927796364,
-0.3416629135608673,
0.1539359837770462,
-0.6764340400695801,
0.45959562063217163,
0.1869223564863205,
0.026050567626953125,
-0.8397254347801208,
-0.47080549597740173,
0.20425496995449066,
-0.4933302700519562,
0.18534818291664124,
0.1526084691286087,
0.017619000747799873,
-0.6890080571174622,
-0.44237014651298523,
0.8129740357398987,
0.44378700852394104,
-0.24245962500572205,
0.019245672971010208,
0.12585611641407013,
-0.4019710421562195,
-0.43680205941200256,
-0.5491358041763306,
-0.28540903329849243,
-0.1755039244890213,
-1.0281898975372314,
0.6069563031196594,
-0.8494313359260559,
0.13142351806163788,
-0.4463377892971039,
-0.1762266755104065,
-0.37102386355400085,
-0.0013947786064818501,
0.24408173561096191,
0.07434024661779404,
-0.10707001388072968,
-0.3596191108226776,
-0.01314646564424038,
0.13686513900756836,
-0.21294066309928894,
-0.10750924795866013,
0.46613559126853943,
-0.3005068898200989,
-0.5487945675849915,
-0.09216262400150299,
0.8493438959121704,
0.3070410490036011,
-0.3593599498271942,
-0.024062443524599075,
0.28388598561286926,
-0.4249822199344635,
-0.5659176707267761,
-0.25665807723999023,
0.06797133386135101,
-0.5170645117759705,
0.08528570085763931,
-0.5065851211547852,
-1.044696569442749,
0.29203692078590393,
-0.16759470105171204,
0.11599184572696686,
-0.01842094399034977,
0.7490948438644409,
0.2158184051513672,
1.216288447380066,
0.4990374445915222,
0.3592577278614044,
0.3848852515220642,
-0.18859325349330902,
0.5621823072433472,
-0.6597819924354553,
0.023750755935907364,
-0.4392305016517639,
-0.17661403119564056,
-0.7111680507659912,
-0.41348138451576233,
0.7859678268432617,
0.3077840209007263,
-0.321729838848114,
0.07610692828893661,
-0.8574286699295044,
0.6997672319412231,
0.6392031908035278,
0.03522420674562454,
-0.16584648191928864,
-0.3816521167755127,
-0.6829633116722107,
-0.27898386120796204,
-0.6388356685638428,
-0.04043549671769142,
0.8140180110931396,
-0.0822061151266098,
0.4125981330871582,
0.19307738542556763,
1.0738482475280762,
0.06338467448949814,
0.4271009564399719,
-0.6062037348747253,
0.40580275654792786,
0.3853333592414856,
-0.7432937622070312,
-0.21508266031742096,
-0.45678022503852844,
-0.8642277717590332,
0.124668650329113,
-0.08124557137489319,
-1.0710277557373047,
0.15800964832305908,
0.3498801290988922,
-0.4525377154350281,
-0.0032849356066435575,
-0.8197661638259888,
0.674730658531189,
-0.33582305908203125,
-0.3678688108921051,
0.12996883690357208,
-0.548364520072937,
0.8150518536567688,
0.05205714702606201,
0.25776395201683044,
-0.025096891447901726,
0.12461243569850922,
0.26633691787719727,
-0.604611337184906,
0.42792582511901855,
-0.3637281358242035,
0.31385642290115356,
0.5963821411132812,
0.2416488528251648,
0.3735652565956116,
0.1999559998512268,
0.13363850116729736,
-0.2724217474460602,
0.005331373307853937,
-0.5700219869613647,
-0.3820050060749054,
0.7085668444633484,
-0.47547513246536255,
-0.5544561147689819,
-0.7160422801971436,
-0.7517799735069275,
-0.30453255772590637,
0.3817233145236969,
0.6036615371704102,
0.17130988836288452,
-0.2336593121290207,
-0.1586778461933136,
0.5333836674690247,
-0.3461594581604004,
0.45629048347473145,
0.24683065712451935,
0.12242502719163895,
-0.6351302266120911,
0.7687733173370361,
0.02702832780778408,
0.4557150602340698,
0.038500960916280746,
0.40764740109443665,
-0.3565658628940582,
-1.0962820053100586,
-0.5064516067504883,
0.12666159868240356,
-0.16125188767910004,
-0.15318156778812408,
0.023194629698991776,
-0.1331358551979065,
-0.4509812593460083,
-0.6200516223907471,
-0.24556699395179749,
-0.3755131959915161,
0.0657593384385109,
0.01255782600492239,
-0.4413558542728424,
0.5361456274986267,
-0.4543043076992035,
0.46242833137512207,
-0.47207364439964294,
0.33676594495773315,
0.1571429967880249,
0.2550486922264099,
-0.36948370933532715,
0.20157647132873535,
-0.13890062272548676,
-0.08754114806652069,
-0.9366225004196167,
-1.2488913536071777,
0.2510022819042206,
-0.05183407664299011,
0.3556746244430542,
0.19678054749965668,
0.10170173645019531,
0.6365735530853271,
-0.4429863393306732,
1.1188002824783325,
0.4936797022819519,
-0.9695205688476562,
0.2461099773645401,
-0.5573347210884094,
0.21226774156093597,
0.776022732257843,
0.18268777430057526,
-0.4414891004562378,
-0.49712279438972473,
-0.7768136262893677,
-1.0225036144256592,
0.11932552605867386,
0.5804281830787659,
-0.27195268869400024,
-0.17691798508167267,
0.41743749380111694,
-0.0740107074379921,
0.08051884919404984,
-0.9800477623939514,
0.13664846122264862,
-0.030658384785056114,
-0.2995993494987488,
0.31844112277030945,
0.04503551125526428,
0.16505594551563263,
-0.0330030582845211,
0.6428078413009644,
-0.11240204423666,
0.1603459119796753,
0.6302214860916138,
-0.1492886245250702,
0.10560977458953857,
0.31860312819480896,
0.8346011638641357,
0.9066590666770935,
-0.3716990351676941,
-0.17820079624652863,
0.254621684551239,
-0.626321017742157,
0.11997148394584656,
0.1863991618156433,
-0.5887755155563354,
-0.07666245847940445,
0.010035330429673195,
0.2948150932788849,
-0.10742835700511932,
-0.638187050819397,
0.5317579507827759,
0.04576751962304115,
-0.3983422517776489,
-0.5618600249290466,
0.3252537250518799,
0.10326526314020157,
-0.1102331131696701,
0.14154233038425446,
-0.2144714891910553,
0.28456246852874756,
-0.21190997958183289,
0.5216089487075806,
0.29624179005622864,
-0.17400047183036804,
-0.07719302177429199,
0.7618998289108276,
0.20425698161125183,
-0.463925838470459,
0.5748315453529358,
-0.6388688683509827,
-0.6383640170097351,
0.6900458335876465,
0.7658666372299194,
0.4031977653503418,
-0.4089547395706177,
0.22435584664344788,
0.56499183177948,
0.4497394263744354,
0.019676629453897476,
0.7266093492507935,
-0.06771738827228546,
-0.6461461186408997,
-0.4041462242603302,
-0.2573002278804779,
-0.574120283126831,
0.13851308822631836,
-0.6146379709243774,
0.24773980677127838,
-0.5795636177062988,
0.01958581991493702,
-0.19174648821353912,
0.31707313656806946,
-0.8955170512199402,
0.364441841840744,
0.4126388728618622,
0.8660150766372681,
-0.5500215888023376,
0.20926633477210999,
0.383259117603302,
-0.4308267831802368,
-0.9192017912864685,
-0.05766463279724121,
-0.06215285509824753,
-0.8912593722343445,
-0.2114720642566681,
0.39186444878578186,
0.037122197449207306,
0.07331674546003342,
-0.7064533829689026,
-0.6775942444801331,
1.0311046838760376,
0.21056172251701355,
-0.5719380974769592,
-0.023908991366624832,
0.32136401534080505,
0.048907652497291565,
-0.3873036503791809,
0.23451107740402222,
0.4494949281215668,
0.5380809307098389,
-0.017510976642370224,
-0.6214373111724854,
0.010910735465586185,
-0.2445157915353775,
0.02535668946802616,
0.6867258548736572,
-0.7472409009933472,
0.710547924041748,
-0.5205423831939697,
-0.36711984872817993,
0.26728829741477966,
0.6083910465240479,
0.8134168982505798,
0.7008821964263916,
0.8003777265548706,
0.7059059143066406,
1.0655460357666016,
0.1617840975522995,
0.9808497428894043,
-0.2458520531654358,
0.3286396861076355,
1.0021909475326538,
-0.388251930475235,
0.566825807094574,
0.569352388381958,
-0.11525506526231766,
0.5209153890609741,
1.1946148872375488,
0.06941071897745132,
0.5374118685722351,
1.109475016593933,
-0.4493425190448761,
-0.06036200001835823,
-0.08967236429452896,
-0.3466017544269562,
0.1459766924381256,
0.34088045358657837,
0.13720230758190155,
-0.18141892552375793,
-0.41078028082847595,
0.038443468511104584,
-0.0022474981378763914,
-0.11828961223363876,
0.1892363578081131,
0.07172586023807526,
-0.970637857913971,
0.585705578327179,
0.06970752030611038,
0.43640127778053284,
-0.5810256600379944,
-0.02942623943090439,
-0.3730379343032837,
0.049759697169065475,
-0.18085022270679474,
-0.5107184052467346,
0.25051966309547424,
0.06232073903083801,
-0.02723216824233532,
-0.1016732007265091,
0.5726037621498108,
-0.5231112241744995,
-0.6026749014854431,
-0.005016665440052748,
0.45569878816604614,
0.34707531332969666,
-0.11472950875759125,
-0.6872376203536987,
-0.20362305641174316,
0.5935998558998108,
-0.2533348500728607,
0.10668427497148514,
0.28224050998687744,
-0.07659853994846344,
0.30515965819358826,
0.8436844944953918,
0.19004091620445251,
0.47175291180610657,
-0.03213290870189667,
0.742597758769989,
-0.7291746735572815,
-0.7105899453163147,
-0.6812540292739868,
0.7198599576950073,
-0.03154166042804718,
-0.7488239407539368,
0.11806963384151459,
0.9041686654090881,
0.8889995217323303,
0.08000382035970688,
1.1197642087936401,
-0.18080605566501617,
0.25391826033592224,
-0.6042283177375793,
-0.0986010804772377,
-0.4231645166873932,
0.004569211043417454,
-0.05068516358733177,
-0.8036347031593323,
-0.2179485559463501,
0.1829967498779297,
-0.08654715120792389,
-0.21364451944828033,
1.1287962198257446,
1.036948323249817,
-0.22679206728935242,
-0.22755776345729828,
0.1161644458770752,
-0.2934899628162384,
0.4603862464427948,
1.3819997310638428,
1.0522520542144775,
0.05887546017765999,
0.6322263479232788,
-0.46721136569976807,
-0.6013302803039551,
0.1694413125514984,
-0.667389988899231,
-0.730839729309082,
-0.3817596435546875,
-0.20606501400470734,
-0.23827265202999115,
-0.300673246383667,
0.5302000045776367,
0.47905582189559937,
-0.44732311367988586,
-0.19562606513500214,
-0.3569261431694031,
0.2721436023712158,
-0.09277947247028351,
-0.30636173486709595,
0.1626538336277008,
-0.23786872625350952,
-0.5994454622268677,
0.4791838824748993,
0.0016066896496340632,
0.26678767800331116,
-0.17298001050949097,
-0.1493687927722931,
-0.03164244443178177,
0.12071748822927475,
-0.07737690955400467,
0.47480955719947815,
-0.3267941474914551,
-0.38560160994529724,
0.38735297322273254,
0.2710438370704651,
0.06514659523963928,
1.2733604907989502,
-0.1714032143354416,
0.24924778938293457,
0.5442503094673157,
0.5257183313369751,
0.7977064847946167,
0.3217400908470154,
0.8565680980682373,
-0.7622717618942261,
0.18162497878074646,
0.699553370475769,
0.33016133308410645,
0.2921234667301178,
-0.6391626596450806,
0.6587803959846497,
0.3417503833770752,
-0.8574941754341125,
-0.8654470443725586,
0.6413390040397644,
-0.962787389755249,
-0.34882262349128723,
1.1916359663009644,
0.014117463491857052,
-0.0395062193274498,
-0.028531597927212715,
-0.06631281226873398,
0.1503007560968399,
-0.32468611001968384,
0.7576062679290771,
0.9517344832420349,
-0.8387091755867004,
0.17197805643081665,
-0.690906286239624,
0.42662352323532104,
0.4241788387298584,
-0.6898176074028015,
-0.4031810462474823,
0.7635983824729919,
0.3431992828845978,
0.19259445369243622,
0.9620228409767151,
0.22121450304985046,
0.38410311937332153,
0.12471528351306915,
0.4382532238960266,
0.024667520076036453,
-0.15333852171897888,
0.11783209443092346,
0.13669078052043915,
0.12032992392778397,
-0.39835864305496216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08819v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08819v2
|
The Illusion of State in State-Space Models
| 2024-04-12T21:30:06 | 2024-06-04T22:05:45 |
William Merrill, Jackson Petty, Ashish Sabharwal
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CC, cs.CL, cs.FL
|
State-space models (SSMs) have emerged as a potential alternative
architecture for building large language models (LLMs) compared to the
previously ubiquitous transformer architecture. One theoretical weakness of
transformers is that they cannot express certain kinds of sequential
computation and state tracking (Merrill & Sabharwal, 2023), which SSMs are
explicitly designed to address via their close architectural similarity to
recurrent neural networks (RNNs). But do SSMs truly have an advantage (over
transformers) in expressive power for state tracking? Surprisingly, the answer
is no. Our analysis reveals that the expressive power of SSMs is limited very
similarly to transformers: SSMs cannot express computation outside the
complexity class $\mathsf{TC}^0$. In particular, this means they cannot solve
simple state-tracking problems like permutation composition. It follows that
SSMs are provably unable to accurately track chess moves with certain notation,
evaluate code, or track entities in a long narrative. To supplement our formal
analysis, we report experiments showing that Mamba-style SSMs indeed struggle
with state tracking. Thus, despite its recurrent formulation, the "state" in an
SSM is an illusion: SSMs have similar expressiveness limitations to
non-recurrent models like transformers, which may fundamentally limit their
ability to solve real-world state-tracking problems.
|
[
-0.07710328698158264,
-0.5136438608169556,
0.9202709794044495,
-0.07293806970119476,
-0.34851837158203125,
0.5918830037117004,
-0.08030858635902405,
-0.1965174823999405,
0.598960280418396,
0.3442543148994446,
-0.8030495643615723,
-0.11900053173303604,
-0.5572665929794312,
0.014651344157755375,
-0.7384973168373108,
0.6825138926506042,
-0.16009537875652313,
-0.03088674321770668,
-0.17231348156929016,
-0.003196723759174347,
-0.2989416718482971,
-0.6408249735832214,
-0.050458874553442,
-0.39219164848327637,
0.11757799237966537,
-0.17914387583732605,
0.8256973624229431,
0.3452836573123932,
0.4393436312675476,
0.3747229278087616,
-0.07763014733791351,
0.186928391456604,
-0.6832504272460938,
0.17640766501426697,
-0.12333053350448608,
-1.0276777744293213,
-0.22165657579898834,
0.03157023340463638,
0.92335444688797,
0.5815392136573792,
-0.2780069410800934,
0.11456990242004395,
-0.10124392062425613,
0.8768205046653748,
-0.6847608089447021,
0.15431925654411316,
-0.5931156873703003,
0.31453922390937805,
-0.3042922616004944,
-0.03693065419793129,
-0.35005176067352295,
-0.19094814360141754,
-0.0014758530305698514,
-0.6550239324569702,
-0.022314531728625298,
0.17912860214710236,
1.1701480150222778,
0.46700888872146606,
-0.19208955764770508,
-0.00794399343430996,
-1.2765363454818726,
0.7312434911727905,
-0.47998782992362976,
0.36679142713546753,
-0.10827042907476425,
0.43062183260917664,
-0.3297082483768463,
-0.46147382259368896,
-0.906614363193512,
-0.30564114451408386,
-0.03635818511247635,
0.34809741377830505,
-0.5952625274658203,
-0.07587633281946182,
0.5059171915054321,
0.5135732293128967,
-0.1777079850435257,
0.031431831419467926,
-0.379694402217865,
-0.2822224795818329,
0.25126197934150696,
0.5794593095779419,
0.2581346929073334,
-0.5188173055648804,
-0.7441381812095642,
0.01974351704120636,
-0.6059537529945374,
0.21827416121959686,
0.2426106333732605,
0.15185439586639404,
-0.03748764842748642,
0.6739078164100647,
0.10379569977521896,
0.7079852223396301,
0.22343581914901733,
0.13318239152431488,
-0.19491270184516907,
-0.057155050337314606,
-0.18484918773174286,
-0.1483914852142334,
0.8264473080635071,
-0.00485231401398778,
-0.03729523345828056,
-0.3623711168766022,
-0.19265955686569214,
0.5491533875465393,
0.7778083086013794,
-0.3673804700374603,
0.067270427942276,
0.04471899941563606,
-0.38884949684143066,
-0.08596213907003403,
0.3375753164291382,
-0.5023078918457031,
-0.5381035804748535,
-0.23076309263706207,
0.7587616443634033,
-0.40768083930015564,
-0.49273160099983215,
0.11213236302137375,
-0.11008652299642563,
0.39772742986679077,
0.13604678213596344,
-0.6447663903236389,
0.5292200446128845,
0.9169335961341858,
1.0134491920471191,
-0.2793327867984772,
-0.015397951938211918,
0.2106742262840271,
-0.11069559305906296,
-0.7992125749588013,
0.5740495324134827,
-0.7490825653076172,
-0.4943690896034241,
-0.28817397356033325,
0.03507449850440025,
-0.20345398783683777,
-0.4268076717853546,
-0.08686474710702896,
-0.4536023736000061,
-0.08596983551979065,
-0.17991891503334045,
-0.7278286814689636,
0.04192221909761429,
-0.08979786932468414,
-0.8177610039710999,
0.8967958688735962,
0.12940235435962677,
-0.15645630657672882,
0.29801705479621887,
-0.41970711946487427,
-0.4685525894165039,
-0.02791595831513405,
-0.4786577820777893,
-0.33018288016319275,
0.7386090755462646,
-0.3405238091945648,
0.4122942388057709,
-0.04138551279902458,
0.19581420719623566,
-0.3125983476638794,
-0.7598492503166199,
0.545120120048523,
-0.26497799158096313,
0.360446959733963,
0.4096139967441559,
-0.315400093793869,
-0.047603052109479904,
-0.6840096712112427,
-0.20617540180683136,
0.1980847418308258,
-0.30877700448036194,
-0.372867614030838,
0.4648413360118866,
-0.6574224829673767,
0.38635215163230896,
0.26767051219940186,
-0.7324619293212891,
0.19998830556869507,
-0.5482630729675293,
0.5787225365638733,
0.8879439830780029,
-0.2626120150089264,
0.7782853245735168,
-0.2563728094100952,
0.9660770297050476,
0.09844654053449631,
-0.06788608431816101,
-0.14372964203357697,
-0.1864425241947174,
-0.7528318166732788,
-0.349435955286026,
0.1080930083990097,
0.4951772689819336,
-0.7841658592224121,
0.36469894647598267,
-0.5269913673400879,
-0.6333901882171631,
-0.7177784442901611,
-0.2784402072429657,
0.29667115211486816,
0.21824005246162415,
0.2014344334602356,
-0.09724166989326477,
-0.43532079458236694,
-1.0843803882598877,
-0.5562270879745483,
0.16400116682052612,
0.0622854083776474,
0.16937439143657684,
0.5305061340332031,
0.623462438583374,
0.9089748859405518,
-0.33577850461006165,
-0.24458667635917664,
-0.23702183365821838,
-0.35001927614212036,
0.2473890334367752,
0.45722806453704834,
0.18772892653942108,
-0.6333643198013306,
-0.002019721083343029,
-0.3006132245063782,
-0.7138608694076538,
0.33618831634521484,
-0.20019209384918213,
0.011919648386538029,
0.20150959491729736,
0.34744876623153687,
-0.9517420530319214,
0.6710247993469238,
0.4779656231403351,
-0.21145494282245636,
0.3219048082828522,
-0.006316178943961859,
0.1130591407418251,
-0.9566113948822021,
-0.0012640063650906086,
-0.012277752161026001,
-0.0038616624660789967,
-0.7379158139228821,
0.13006693124771118,
0.07663127779960632,
-0.39785605669021606,
-0.42076030373573303,
0.3191460072994232,
-0.4772505462169647,
-0.34700703620910645,
-0.35934212803840637,
0.3191165030002594,
-0.2331569343805313,
0.6564801931381226,
0.12098344415426254,
0.44342970848083496,
0.5054354667663574,
-0.748576819896698,
0.17288270592689514,
-0.1319746971130371,
-0.7988908290863037,
0.7149099707603455,
-0.2611220180988312,
-0.09649821370840073,
-0.2785791754722595,
0.644923746585846,
-1.1110469102859497,
0.07219508290290833,
0.13019894063472748,
-0.3159323036670685,
0.5555433034896851,
0.03288508951663971,
-0.3793686032295227,
-0.4342977702617645,
-0.09688811749219894,
0.021255603060126305,
0.6977595090866089,
-0.41275808215141296,
1.041965365409851,
0.2701251208782196,
0.45977702736854553,
-0.5723394155502319,
-0.9361414313316345,
0.03373941406607628,
-0.1081516444683075,
-0.27728378772735596,
0.12606842815876007,
0.36564090847969055,
-0.19400276243686676,
0.1805746853351593,
-0.6702399253845215,
0.20359152555465698,
0.46026891469955444,
0.47505849599838257,
0.5030937790870667,
-0.18314237892627716,
0.09768739342689514,
0.05455925315618515,
-0.08358314633369446,
0.10945430397987366,
-0.25853872299194336,
0.4787391424179077,
-0.2519070506095886,
-0.5701490044593811,
-0.7768939137458801,
0.14752653241157532,
0.6299120783805847,
-0.11148396879434586,
0.8059958815574646,
0.06718531996011734,
-0.4957530200481415,
-0.32901227474212646,
-0.23198489844799042,
-0.1115817278623581,
-0.5006858110427856,
0.4383227527141571,
-0.6084265112876892,
-1.0135525465011597,
0.3590797185897827,
-0.16153912246227264,
0.11780215054750443,
0.645336925983429,
0.3133184313774109,
-0.527072012424469,
1.1647292375564575,
0.3965578079223633,
-0.06179982051253319,
0.42121201753616333,
-0.290873646736145,
0.14810000360012054,
-1.0853638648986816,
-0.3523160219192505,
-0.5172122716903687,
-1.012856125831604,
-0.8456178307533264,
-0.31514236330986023,
0.2398887425661087,
-0.008326547220349312,
-0.2549377977848053,
0.5128191709518433,
-0.46816447377204895,
0.38285505771636963,
0.23932881653308868,
0.15149030089378357,
0.1035616397857666,
0.05144666135311127,
-0.03171812370419502,
-0.3575303852558136,
-0.991627037525177,
-0.4500735104084015,
0.9308855533599854,
0.2532738149166107,
1.2290403842926025,
0.2379210889339447,
0.5031670928001404,
0.063348188996315,
0.10081817954778671,
-0.8962196111679077,
0.8199425339698792,
-0.40738603472709656,
-0.8068855404853821,
-0.26469549536705017,
-0.4553925395011902,
-0.8181901574134827,
0.4188980758190155,
-0.3928682506084442,
-0.911557674407959,
0.32403117418289185,
0.2607062757015228,
-0.38358381390571594,
0.6549641489982605,
-0.3650737404823303,
0.5818272233009338,
-0.09143001586198807,
-0.2115367352962494,
-0.44888514280319214,
-0.5266072154045105,
0.48165592551231384,
0.029505034908652306,
0.09562209248542786,
-0.22544696927070618,
-0.2088610678911209,
0.5217068791389465,
-0.6112286448478699,
0.914974570274353,
-0.3461674451828003,
-0.06300812214612961,
0.2763773500919342,
0.6247746348381042,
0.4885747730731964,
-0.5753406286239624,
0.16114389896392822,
0.1558545082807541,
-0.1351020336151123,
-0.3271208703517914,
-0.8046182990074158,
0.7882809638977051,
-0.5065349340438843,
-0.8228428959846497,
-0.524323046207428,
-0.38257071375846863,
-0.24704046547412872,
-0.1065305545926094,
0.2239091545343399,
0.4384456276893616,
-0.18346132338047028,
0.12408967316150665,
0.56483393907547,
-0.08286122977733612,
0.3481125235557556,
0.6179599165916443,
-0.4349426031112671,
0.15001344680786133,
1.0337241888046265,
0.34608736634254456,
0.4584679901599884,
0.5646637678146362,
0.044039785861968994,
-0.41560623049736023,
-0.02955453470349312,
-0.4623454511165619,
0.19415563344955444,
-0.514822244644165,
0.21520721912384033,
-0.12644949555397034,
-0.1865941435098648,
0.22260814905166626,
-0.006275203078985214,
-0.5819867849349976,
-0.9418365955352783,
-0.22151802480220795,
-0.11676342040300369,
-0.01644899882376194,
0.9039255976676941,
0.18253649771213531,
0.21936407685279846,
-0.320060670375824,
0.4251128137111664,
0.07847678661346436,
0.6272128224372864,
0.13077402114868164,
-0.806660532951355,
-0.20673061907291412,
-0.1872342824935913,
-0.18913601338863373,
-0.7543390393257141,
-0.12152755260467529,
-0.029044536873698235,
0.4049750566482544,
0.3171404004096985,
-0.19381476938724518,
0.9633980393409729,
-0.8110800981521606,
1.1423453092575073,
0.26984715461730957,
-1.0225436687469482,
0.3120328485965729,
0.07953878492116928,
0.5422508120536804,
0.014908958226442337,
0.3555627465248108,
-0.3899087905883789,
-0.8801994919776917,
-0.6912675499916077,
-0.4528518319129944,
0.9136180877685547,
0.04203369840979576,
0.3295297920703888,
0.055398836731910706,
0.514132559299469,
-0.12047257274389267,
0.3435315489768982,
-0.502282977104187,
-0.612011730670929,
-0.5290591716766357,
-0.008071246556937695,
-0.127899631857872,
-0.01524537056684494,
0.08930307626724243,
0.021615197882056236,
0.6433073282241821,
0.3166561424732208,
0.4709678292274475,
0.2868604063987732,
-0.18000298738479614,
-0.27754074335098267,
0.35325372219085693,
0.8556146621704102,
0.6018286347389221,
0.22198200225830078,
0.21302612125873566,
0.14779044687747955,
-0.11427351087331772,
0.3861835300922394,
-0.11312893033027649,
-0.3342114984989166,
0.09210822731256485,
0.13542623817920685,
1.1360353231430054,
0.49114173650741577,
-0.21485547721385956,
0.3871719539165497,
0.2815578281879425,
-0.24761836230754852,
-0.364923894405365,
0.3951091170310974,
0.23216986656188965,
0.3161526918411255,
0.3752768933773041,
0.39014238119125366,
-0.17946834862232208,
-0.5218801498413086,
-0.23687644302845,
0.8005263805389404,
-0.7779920101165771,
-0.5314379334449768,
0.9747369289398193,
-0.22290492057800293,
-0.6812219023704529,
0.4016971290111542,
0.16708312928676605,
-0.48366278409957886,
0.6127151846885681,
0.5443194508552551,
0.8323240876197815,
-0.31969520449638367,
-0.029079847037792206,
0.26458418369293213,
0.5476512908935547,
-0.17136536538600922,
0.27753859758377075,
-0.13266615569591522,
-0.7545787692070007,
-0.5638150572776794,
-0.6167035698890686,
-0.3173215687274933,
0.1644987016916275,
-0.8860125541687012,
-0.04521428421139717,
-0.6529572010040283,
-0.4446706771850586,
-0.036852091550827026,
-0.2944655418395996,
-0.46100616455078125,
-0.125047504901886,
0.25790396332740784,
0.9433686137199402,
-0.6612956523895264,
0.6359903216362,
0.540379524230957,
-0.08786416053771973,
-0.817822277545929,
-0.2593309283256531,
0.15377305448055267,
-0.6841346025466919,
0.35533785820007324,
0.03846415504813194,
-0.5030640363693237,
-0.16389970481395721,
-0.8003727793693542,
-0.8762333393096924,
0.9868283271789551,
0.36040565371513367,
-0.7544480562210083,
-0.011152293533086777,
0.1359460949897766,
0.7827911376953125,
-0.03847570717334747,
-0.3132036328315735,
0.563652515411377,
0.4435417056083679,
-0.25257042050361633,
-0.8666220903396606,
0.10221581906080246,
0.09348847717046738,
0.1779749095439911,
0.7243521213531494,
-1.0633779764175415,
0.6606509685516357,
-0.13412104547023773,
-0.6438096761703491,
0.33462560176849365,
0.8875423669815063,
0.05371221527457237,
-0.1909695267677307,
0.5235032439231873,
0.7157161235809326,
0.45654264092445374,
-0.36393943428993225,
1.1991983652114868,
-0.22980964183807373,
0.25107696652412415,
1.0104849338531494,
-0.5346998572349548,
0.7649961113929749,
0.42619237303733826,
-0.45063695311546326,
0.8139652609825134,
0.04327375441789627,
-0.25552332401275635,
0.2720108926296234,
0.528446614742279,
-0.07085346430540085,
-0.5161296725273132,
0.3228181302547455,
0.0014165849424898624,
0.5016258955001831,
0.5244441032409668,
-0.22707904875278473,
-0.043507277965545654,
-0.018514949828386307,
0.10048933327198029,
0.43821585178375244,
-0.42665600776672363,
0.5091782808303833,
0.24454954266548157,
-0.6411290168762207,
0.21464647352695465,
-0.2961733639240265,
0.4383372366428375,
-0.9751018285751343,
-0.028927335515618324,
-0.0907965749502182,
0.04643136262893677,
-0.13835783302783966,
-0.6435445547103882,
0.18473504483699799,
0.047827575355768204,
-0.08310801535844803,
-0.06575490534305573,
0.5339192152023315,
-0.17554453015327454,
-0.355112224817276,
-0.03851448744535446,
0.34780728816986084,
0.34842801094055176,
0.2155533730983734,
-0.5856954455375671,
-0.060614533722400665,
-0.3161540925502777,
-0.4772550165653229,
0.26898685097694397,
0.11898157745599747,
-0.04235563799738884,
1.0150829553604126,
0.3477276563644409,
0.3065919280052185,
0.21552808582782745,
-0.27957671880722046,
0.4174775779247284,
-0.791303277015686,
-0.4902551770210266,
-0.9572175741195679,
0.1932242512702942,
0.20584498345851898,
-0.04796785116195679,
0.7468342185020447,
0.6683863401412964,
0.7091811299324036,
-0.09511017054319382,
0.6384778618812561,
-0.07334767282009125,
0.6230645179748535,
-0.6553812026977539,
0.8632712960243225,
-0.7003596425056458,
0.3369610607624054,
-0.13316088914871216,
-0.7602678537368774,
0.07990733534097672,
0.5153839588165283,
-0.259040892124176,
0.0031522870995104313,
0.8059621453285217,
0.612248420715332,
0.023975752294063568,
0.0913100615143776,
0.5019711852073669,
0.5908329486846924,
-0.03639078140258789,
0.5935571193695068,
1.4214357137680054,
-0.18384601175785065,
0.5715237259864807,
-0.23169973492622375,
0.07099368423223495,
0.14290648698806763,
-0.5813023447990417,
-0.5406642556190491,
-0.7320890426635742,
-0.08749809116125107,
-0.38130733370780945,
-0.27909258008003235,
0.5473023056983948,
0.7012611627578735,
-0.6468867063522339,
-0.2849745452404022,
0.15238536894321442,
0.14526470005512238,
-0.3863794505596161,
-0.2789599597454071,
0.33017459511756897,
-0.07859080284833908,
-0.7930153012275696,
0.7749175429344177,
0.39338040351867676,
0.08288268744945526,
-0.7297953367233276,
0.14577549695968628,
-0.05875953659415245,
0.2825637459754944,
0.5146674513816833,
0.4100949466228485,
-1.0275616645812988,
-0.3030276298522949,
0.06800252199172974,
-0.20985078811645508,
0.0937594324350357,
0.8680372834205627,
-1.049761176109314,
0.6260867118835449,
0.10868089646100998,
0.4364805221557617,
0.6283962726593018,
0.03653252497315407,
0.4048413634300232,
-0.5099380016326904,
-0.0610298290848732,
0.16429975628852844,
0.4130089581012726,
-0.008914768695831299,
-0.17152035236358643,
0.14272060990333557,
0.29195281863212585,
-0.21641193330287933,
-0.592112123966217,
0.4550211727619171,
-0.859545111656189,
-0.4911956787109375,
0.7557000517845154,
0.08112659305334091,
-0.45290467143058777,
0.2435896098613739,
0.18892940878868103,
0.11064843833446503,
-0.22283810377120972,
0.7613669037818909,
0.943532407283783,
-0.2845141589641571,
0.29530465602874756,
-0.5990810990333557,
0.49809545278549194,
0.50669264793396,
-0.3334198296070099,
-0.11316441744565964,
0.49946847558021545,
0.29073289036750793,
0.42084813117980957,
0.3995145857334137,
-0.1857287883758545,
0.24158866703510284,
0.021767884492874146,
-0.15622961521148682,
-0.1522834599018097,
-0.3502981960773468,
-0.7803894877433777,
0.2035403549671173,
-0.30371925234794617,
-0.32627394795417786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08817v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08817v2
|
Revisiting Code Similarity Evaluation with Abstract Syntax Tree Edit Distance
| 2024-04-12T21:28:18 | 2024-06-03T11:56:38 |
Yewei Song, Cedric Lothritz, Daniel Tang, Tegawendé F. Bissyandé, Jacques Klein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.PL, cs.SE
|
This paper revisits recent code similarity evaluation metrics, particularly
focusing on the application of Abstract Syntax Tree (AST) editing distance in
diverse programming languages. In particular, we explore the usefulness of
these metrics and compare them to traditional sequence similarity metrics. Our
experiments showcase the effectiveness of AST editing distance in capturing
intricate code structures, revealing a high correlation with established
metrics. Furthermore, we explore the strengths and weaknesses of AST editing
distance and prompt-based GPT similarity scores in comparison to BLEU score,
execution match, and Jaccard Similarity. We propose, optimize, and publish an
adaptable metric that demonstrates effectiveness across all tested languages,
representing an enhanced version of Tree Similarity of Edit Distance (TSED).
|
[
-0.058405712246894836,
-0.5566495060920715,
0.42871397733688354,
0.26697802543640137,
-0.18099363148212433,
0.5291270613670349,
-0.4026811718940735,
-0.7127934694290161,
0.15336692333221436,
-0.12519697844982147,
0.0365847572684288,
-0.8021027445793152,
-0.6071417927742004,
0.26424622535705566,
-0.6817363500595093,
0.6684892177581787,
-0.3097456395626068,
-0.40315261483192444,
-0.18768467009067535,
-0.30377066135406494,
-0.22530417144298553,
-0.23293031752109528,
-0.3983185589313507,
0.3012194037437439,
0.32292842864990234,
0.16403095424175262,
0.8844831585884094,
0.9015830755233765,
0.5669199824333191,
0.31387457251548767,
-0.094232939183712,
-0.18745438754558563,
0.03932519629597664,
-0.12956534326076508,
-0.1281253546476364,
-0.3467003405094147,
-0.5620763897895813,
-0.33070534467697144,
0.9350272417068481,
0.7301463484764099,
0.26915156841278076,
0.3068278729915619,
0.05235973373055458,
1.0212453603744507,
-0.4273046851158142,
0.09682367742061615,
-0.6079397797584534,
0.11283227056264877,
-0.34923699498176575,
-0.3177502751350403,
-0.0023300207685679197,
-0.8814054131507874,
-0.009119478985667229,
-0.3831675946712494,
0.2746151387691498,
-0.18185003101825714,
0.7918602228164673,
0.27686017751693726,
-0.14314323663711548,
-0.5655861496925354,
-0.4755236804485321,
0.307748943567276,
-0.7228555679321289,
0.4538489282131195,
-0.14682963490486145,
0.2566230297088623,
0.15649178624153137,
-0.6815476417541504,
-0.3894152343273163,
-0.31323373317718506,
0.01046580821275711,
-0.009143284521996975,
-0.48736685514450073,
0.33190813660621643,
0.5623779892921448,
0.6444858312606812,
-0.5613362193107605,
-0.04496961086988449,
-0.5624167323112488,
-0.09668445587158203,
0.5118134617805481,
0.017594950273633003,
0.4559376537799835,
-0.006871084216982126,
0.04339181259274483,
0.10031159967184067,
-0.7292866706848145,
0.2919292747974396,
0.5516272783279419,
0.024057308211922646,
0.06133509427309036,
0.4503783583641052,
-0.3643478751182556,
0.7516223192214966,
-0.29521456360816956,
0.33919844031333923,
0.4703178405761719,
-0.39540284872055054,
-0.2034195512533188,
-0.19586412608623505,
0.7453726530075073,
0.7173802256584167,
0.28700071573257446,
-0.21808896958827972,
-0.2404865026473999,
0.19444267451763153,
0.2821292579174042,
-0.6328431963920593,
-0.7057350873947144,
-0.16991588473320007,
-0.7337540984153748,
-0.14077261090278625,
0.31714317202568054,
-0.560368537902832,
-0.07941598445177078,
-0.2123129963874817,
0.07557517290115356,
-0.4756384491920471,
-0.10106121748685837,
0.05870960280299187,
-0.32732290029525757,
0.2704768776893616,
0.5345150828361511,
-0.4465882480144501,
0.2850619852542877,
0.9630702137947083,
1.200165033340454,
-0.26073917746543884,
-0.47684887051582336,
-0.2379121035337448,
-0.36208757758140564,
-0.2768116593360901,
0.580774188041687,
-0.9769375324249268,
-0.5609192252159119,
-0.30432531237602234,
-0.37299567461013794,
-0.004538902081549168,
-0.5507932901382446,
0.16824176907539368,
-0.44774749875068665,
-0.2819693982601166,
-0.04077364131808281,
-0.5055104494094849,
-0.35526952147483826,
0.2839373052120209,
-0.41093599796295166,
1.0761176347732544,
0.503722071647644,
-0.7791845202445984,
0.2827818989753723,
-0.8619214296340942,
-0.44097837805747986,
-0.24805007874965668,
-0.14638812839984894,
-0.4621894955635071,
0.3301079273223877,
-0.11116991937160492,
-0.1304207146167755,
0.14287225902080536,
-0.20175497233867645,
-0.24017547070980072,
-0.5755961537361145,
0.11532245576381683,
-0.3427881896495819,
0.8136852979660034,
0.2342635840177536,
-0.23123203217983246,
0.541719913482666,
-0.6943072080612183,
0.3987223207950592,
-0.3960379660129547,
-0.5142604112625122,
-0.4702737331390381,
-0.16560634970664978,
-0.17422635853290558,
0.07788866013288498,
0.2585931718349457,
-0.5512501001358032,
0.5804322361946106,
-0.29758453369140625,
0.48265156149864197,
0.6853731870651245,
-0.01864333637058735,
0.05614297837018967,
-0.2535821199417114,
0.9052779674530029,
-0.36562246084213257,
-0.0596943125128746,
-0.07269435375928879,
-0.46373963356018066,
-0.3030157685279846,
-0.13062234222888947,
0.6908068060874939,
0.63288813829422,
-0.46712392568588257,
0.3478463590145111,
-0.38095709681510925,
-0.6841726899147034,
-0.5173695087432861,
-0.04981333762407303,
0.7389580607414246,
0.08499070256948471,
0.20254923403263092,
-0.9271010160446167,
-0.5607947707176208,
-0.5929669737815857,
-0.941874086856842,
-0.2632738947868347,
-0.010859743691980839,
0.2555285096168518,
0.3637290894985199,
-0.3821874260902405,
0.7971056699752808,
-0.6619508266448975,
0.43556398153305054,
0.18329545855522156,
-0.18642538785934448,
0.12880483269691467,
0.6202489137649536,
0.7330337762832642,
-0.20847947895526886,
-0.9490048289299011,
0.309324711561203,
-0.35369861125946045,
-0.3574616014957428,
0.0836537554860115,
0.2565895915031433,
0.11056797951459885,
0.7167239189147949,
-0.4235531985759735,
0.6375336647033691,
0.4728097915649414,
-0.632796585559845,
0.9704911112785339,
-0.16384819149971008,
0.808849036693573,
-0.7442252039909363,
0.30109938979148865,
-0.30943435430526733,
-0.3740719258785248,
-0.07523981481790543,
0.5513123273849487,
0.2568991780281067,
-0.013302702456712723,
-0.29656392335891724,
0.12428320944309235,
-0.392352432012558,
-0.7705721259117126,
0.11847022920846939,
-0.05927549675107002,
-0.21390442550182343,
0.2648337781429291,
-0.27632197737693787,
0.9009177088737488,
0.5667892694473267,
-0.1520208865404129,
0.39276254177093506,
0.022411685436964035,
-0.5401318669319153,
0.33547285199165344,
-0.632313072681427,
0.5603812336921692,
0.33641618490219116,
0.12896019220352173,
-1.0527998208999634,
0.424544095993042,
-0.06672514230012894,
-0.7358084321022034,
0.18415331840515137,
-0.2291024923324585,
-0.45651957392692566,
-0.1908838003873825,
-0.7913649678230286,
0.7566304206848145,
0.5373150706291199,
-0.3699548840522766,
-0.05740823596715927,
-0.21426387131214142,
-0.23449018597602844,
-0.5883653163909912,
-0.42912620306015015,
0.20674002170562744,
-0.2739097476005554,
-0.45835527777671814,
0.2872637212276459,
-0.03941356763243675,
-0.42243248224258423,
0.19514746963977814,
-0.5268418192863464,
0.095600426197052,
0.23731456696987152,
0.26670005917549133,
-0.20869264006614685,
-0.6115356683731079,
-0.1454440802335739,
0.2228819727897644,
-0.16632209718227386,
0.047649189829826355,
-0.2979394197463989,
0.18770867586135864,
-0.5019656419754028,
-0.6548739075660706,
-0.22964927554130554,
0.236526757478714,
0.40757662057876587,
-0.3493618071079254,
0.15001019835472107,
0.14819911122322083,
-0.3300832211971283,
0.19602437317371368,
-0.20153695344924927,
0.24306844174861908,
-0.4330863058567047,
0.4797514081001282,
-0.6432591676712036,
-1.1607553958892822,
0.4992842376232147,
-0.13187628984451294,
0.25520092248916626,
0.2811861038208008,
0.08107772469520569,
0.15538249909877777,
0.474311500787735,
0.47009512782096863,
-0.19587641954421997,
0.6140713095664978,
-0.14560040831565857,
0.11287084966897964,
-0.7957686185836792,
0.11712037771940231,
-0.9562579393386841,
-0.522061824798584,
-0.6245951056480408,
-0.6696738600730896,
0.06650479882955551,
0.4277959167957306,
-0.15867206454277039,
0.5942761301994324,
-0.48037296533584595,
0.9514182209968567,
0.39992254972457886,
-0.20770613849163055,
0.6602305173873901,
-0.27521222829818726,
0.12061264365911484,
-0.041312187910079956,
-0.32651278376579285,
-0.41597938537597656,
0.9561138153076172,
0.31214654445648193,
0.41655707359313965,
0.21283990144729614,
0.8127056956291199,
0.40533387660980225,
0.10704495012760162,
-0.46855875849723816,
0.391310453414917,
-0.27324482798576355,
-0.019513282924890518,
-0.37157726287841797,
-0.36968308687210083,
-0.735298752784729,
0.0682470053434372,
0.4469153583049774,
-0.8551495671272278,
-0.03706410527229309,
0.32499322295188904,
-0.4129306375980377,
0.3579990863800049,
-0.952969491481781,
1.146500587463379,
0.04917408153414726,
0.1740076243877411,
-0.44441741704940796,
-0.6603829264640808,
0.01861000433564186,
0.13631878793239594,
-0.03782539814710617,
0.27208036184310913,
-0.23363594710826874,
0.610226035118103,
-0.6433588266372681,
0.4656250774860382,
-0.06448768079280853,
0.11844001710414886,
0.26930302381515503,
0.515602707862854,
0.08855494111776352,
0.1616775244474411,
-0.173982173204422,
0.37579959630966187,
0.2696115970611572,
-0.3718630373477936,
-0.7587666511535645,
0.8938891291618347,
-0.43422502279281616,
-0.40957874059677124,
-0.28040218353271484,
-0.42941179871559143,
-0.005529459100216627,
0.28017207980155945,
0.06922513246536255,
0.5689324140548706,
-0.20127369463443756,
0.012418226338922977,
0.059641607105731964,
-0.3892371356487274,
0.6168162226676941,
0.34353888034820557,
-0.2519710063934326,
-0.22603467106819153,
0.6803581118583679,
-0.07062093913555145,
0.4579147696495056,
0.5485419631004333,
0.055897559970617294,
-0.2935548722743988,
-0.8406593799591064,
-0.6482632160186768,
-0.2889748215675354,
-0.6330643892288208,
-0.4160669445991516,
-0.5189629793167114,
-0.1521216481924057,
-0.09645167738199234,
-0.7681456804275513,
-0.3575548231601715,
-0.8126578330993652,
0.390838086605072,
-0.21488043665885925,
0.8871215581893921,
0.9054539203643799,
-0.05922861397266388,
-0.04863128811120987,
-0.7476121187210083,
0.015412656590342522,
-0.06031179428100586,
0.787632167339325,
0.19553788006305695,
-0.17109735310077667,
-0.11476012319326401,
-0.16871210932731628,
-0.44218212366104126,
-0.845592200756073,
-0.03467893227934837,
0.32230058312416077,
0.07280832529067993,
-0.18516004085540771,
-0.16804362833499908,
0.9940350651741028,
-0.4814644753932953,
0.8170409202575684,
-0.05488278716802597,
-1.2889286279678345,
0.6445266008377075,
-0.29455676674842834,
0.5573428869247437,
0.864234447479248,
-0.06807158887386322,
-0.6676948666572571,
-0.7015114426612854,
-0.7328826189041138,
-0.667914092540741,
0.4911454916000366,
0.35697823762893677,
-0.21123811602592468,
0.04786287620663643,
0.2882520854473114,
0.11365780234336853,
0.16566021740436554,
-0.5107114315032959,
-0.3155384361743927,
-0.10738008469343185,
-0.13120515644550323,
0.14002101123332977,
0.17886802554130554,
0.5236380100250244,
-0.5626047849655151,
0.1812395602464676,
0.08548998087644577,
0.37953948974609375,
0.07524003088474274,
-0.1345246285200119,
-0.15417639911174774,
0.426856130361557,
0.43472662568092346,
0.8775917291641235,
-0.09230698645114899,
0.22805222868919373,
0.40843459963798523,
-0.6144016981124878,
-0.165532186627388,
-0.012244584038853645,
0.0406595878303051,
0.1784234344959259,
0.6806256175041199,
0.3118429183959961,
0.1783864051103592,
-0.7277796268463135,
0.45317694544792175,
0.08172588795423508,
0.11473299562931061,
0.04573804512619972,
0.04744667187333107,
0.04821659252047539,
0.10273855924606323,
-0.3652923107147217,
0.5012540221214294,
0.5401166677474976,
-0.67820805311203,
0.5492830276489258,
0.25826162099838257,
-0.6169759035110474,
-0.42721953988075256,
0.2928667366504669,
0.27239736914634705,
-0.9206460118293762,
0.6471560597419739,
-0.5062859058380127,
-0.8479886054992676,
0.9439279437065125,
0.45977360010147095,
0.963507354259491,
-0.2751065492630005,
-0.22239455580711365,
0.4715057909488678,
0.2141537368297577,
0.24530372023582458,
0.15124790370464325,
-0.4001940190792084,
-0.14502966403961182,
-0.5794808268547058,
-0.4576006531715393,
-0.10113059729337692,
-0.36274296045303345,
-0.4583503305912018,
0.36558476090431213,
-0.7964486479759216,
0.5282582640647888,
-0.09867943078279495,
0.11083148419857025,
-0.4133404791355133,
-0.16311697661876678,
-0.4265289306640625,
1.0802843570709229,
-0.7043992280960083,
0.9822809100151062,
0.8649885058403015,
-0.14898976683616638,
-0.8610960841178894,
0.16801176965236664,
0.1600305289030075,
-0.5086270570755005,
0.09164474904537201,
0.28456026315689087,
-0.08121541142463684,
-0.07344997674226761,
0.12131699919700623,
-0.5283442735671997,
0.8705350160598755,
0.20084521174430847,
-0.5821896195411682,
-0.0048755863681435585,
-0.09430292993783951,
0.8077758550643921,
-0.11898759752511978,
0.6229004263877869,
1.1510132551193237,
0.12787888944149017,
-0.2833319306373596,
-1.3675709962844849,
0.1351243257522583,
-0.6093568801879883,
0.12255112081766129,
0.7239037752151489,
-0.4219011068344116,
0.5471175312995911,
-0.3433617055416107,
-0.24960987269878387,
0.2418108880519867,
0.2841973304748535,
0.17461130023002625,
0.3909779191017151,
0.49939244985580444,
0.6025984287261963,
0.46454665064811707,
0.10567318648099899,
0.9332430958747864,
-0.22492702305316925,
0.500999391078949,
1.1897488832473755,
0.09694994986057281,
0.6906905770301819,
0.10696391016244888,
-0.7109997272491455,
0.5866437554359436,
0.4917328357696533,
0.11963088065385818,
0.24741633236408234,
0.4030276834964752,
0.03808845952153206,
0.3444576859474182,
0.36814016103744507,
-0.6407288312911987,
0.07772966474294662,
0.2627537250518799,
-0.38452163338661194,
-0.2931646704673767,
-0.5335612297058105,
0.10782493650913239,
0.6017829775810242,
-0.16685625910758972,
0.6826790571212769,
0.217708021402359,
-0.31402871012687683,
0.45733216404914856,
0.1717856079339981,
0.6051425933837891,
-0.2669511139392853,
-0.1635131537914276,
-0.14967091381549835,
-0.03742212429642677,
-0.4676210284233093,
-1.1370222568511963,
1.0143760442733765,
0.38583311438560486,
-0.026641186326742172,
-0.14294610917568207,
0.28940078616142273,
-0.2675589919090271,
-0.17317377030849457,
0.14494408667087555,
0.24930763244628906,
0.15009649097919464,
-0.19509407877922058,
-0.9705666303634644,
0.1062847226858139,
0.3952435553073883,
0.1751186102628708,
0.10035711526870728,
0.7191907167434692,
-0.11373648047447205,
0.3189518451690674,
0.346171110868454,
0.15441006422042847,
0.05019954964518547,
0.05417703837156296,
0.6170811653137207,
-0.9391528367996216,
-0.7717827558517456,
-1.1321783065795898,
0.25293630361557007,
-0.04359082877635956,
-0.6410434246063232,
0.9598672986030579,
1.1104151010513306,
1.1629643440246582,
-0.3659367263317108,
0.5998358726501465,
-0.4508611559867859,
0.40415823459625244,
-0.4702976644039154,
0.44875144958496094,
-0.26751625537872314,
0.5445266366004944,
-1.0616956949234009,
-1.4359911680221558,
-0.41368260979652405,
0.5598351359367371,
-0.26719921827316284,
-0.08086156100034714,
1.0325325727462769,
0.9013628959655762,
-0.1113809272646904,
0.05510946735739708,
0.1368124634027481,
0.13028188049793243,
0.36501544713974,
1.015161395072937,
0.9335812926292419,
-0.4268799424171448,
0.2848103940486908,
-0.03357407823204994,
-0.21478894352912903,
-0.028220226988196373,
-0.8324607610702515,
-0.6796179413795471,
-0.6401875615119934,
-0.711295485496521,
-0.23564369976520538,
0.3703043460845947,
1.134896993637085,
0.23664939403533936,
-0.7598429918289185,
-0.17909152805805206,
-0.18458962440490723,
0.3287273943424225,
-0.6246533393859863,
-0.20961911976337433,
0.6603675484657288,
0.03670298680663109,
-0.3486669063568115,
0.03984273225069046,
0.46258044242858887,
-0.10326927900314331,
0.328742653131485,
-0.05918426066637039,
0.18847520649433136,
-0.31719300150871277,
0.6705840229988098,
0.5422583818435669,
-0.7453936338424683,
-0.767863929271698,
-0.19502630829811096,
-0.0037682943511754274,
0.2745034098625183,
1.0486119985580444,
-0.7049400210380554,
0.5266565680503845,
0.7688924670219421,
0.7829487323760986,
-0.05319882556796074,
0.2250957190990448,
0.5498355031013489,
-0.8830068707466125,
-0.06748691201210022,
0.1563349962234497,
0.24735857546329498,
0.27155330777168274,
-0.12927183508872986,
0.8016974329948425,
0.13690048456192017,
-0.40934112668037415,
-0.7955460548400879,
0.31163546442985535,
-1.0546071529388428,
0.023501960560679436,
1.1737569570541382,
-0.36078840494155884,
0.17337734997272491,
-0.24821068346500397,
-0.5457567572593689,
0.014950434677302837,
-0.4759165346622467,
0.8045817017555237,
0.5163465142250061,
-0.23918694257736206,
-0.006063664332032204,
-0.35161083936691284,
0.7783480882644653,
0.09362856298685074,
-0.8368101716041565,
0.1409500390291214,
0.47642749547958374,
0.4663146734237671,
0.12114422768354416,
0.6265199780464172,
-0.5037146210670471,
0.6008898019790649,
0.11737559735774994,
-0.005034370813518763,
-0.07086049020290375,
-0.10113193839788437,
-0.6294722557067871,
-0.13378269970417023,
0.7114994525909424,
-0.14218764007091522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08816v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08816v1
|
Evaluating the Quality of Answers in Political Q&A Sessions with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-12T21:16:53 | 2024-04-12T21:16:53 |
R. Michael Alvarez, Jacob Morrier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, econ.EM
|
This paper presents a new approach to evaluating the quality of answers in
political question-and-answer sessions. We propose to measure an answer's
quality based on the degree to which it allows us to infer the initial question
accurately. This conception of answer quality inherently reflects their
relevance to initial questions. Drawing parallels with semantic search, we
argue that this measurement approach can be operationalized by fine-tuning a
large language model on the observed corpus of questions and answers without
additional labeled data. We showcase our measurement approach within the
context of the Question Period in the Canadian House of Commons. Our approach
yields valuable insights into the correlates of the quality of answers in the
Question Period. We find that answer quality varies significantly based on the
party affiliation of the members of Parliament asking the questions and uncover
a meaningful correlation between answer quality and the topics of the
questions.
|
[
-0.5828015208244324,
-0.9511565566062927,
0.954096257686615,
-0.24955062568187714,
-0.37033286690711975,
0.057453230023384094,
-0.11495883017778397,
-0.10838070511817932,
0.3920612335205078,
0.5781291127204895,
-0.466630756855011,
-0.3157445192337036,
-0.7041832804679871,
-0.1546945571899414,
-0.5921196341514587,
0.4391382336616516,
0.36048388481140137,
0.1175471618771553,
-0.25887829065322876,
-0.3066663146018982,
-0.35364091396331787,
-0.6020258069038391,
-0.5876989364624023,
-0.2079053819179535,
0.6418587565422058,
0.3520475924015045,
1.0956312417984009,
0.7486066222190857,
0.585540235042572,
0.2834065556526184,
-0.2530011236667633,
0.24320854246616364,
-0.6439201831817627,
-0.013337871991097927,
-0.3763068914413452,
-0.5484907031059265,
-0.1530017852783203,
0.2241416871547699,
0.6010749936103821,
0.8120495676994324,
-0.1816444844007492,
0.24712690711021423,
-0.01492499839514494,
0.49077823758125305,
-0.5282066464424133,
0.08318662643432617,
-0.9616571664810181,
-0.28814682364463806,
0.015862109139561653,
-0.5386311411857605,
-0.29069527983665466,
-0.4719468057155609,
0.07153458148241043,
-0.4290972054004669,
0.06024795025587082,
0.02469208650290966,
1.0535331964492798,
-0.11166180670261383,
-0.5025686621665955,
-0.5247429609298706,
-0.5038378834724426,
0.5798692107200623,
-0.7613391280174255,
0.23649726808071136,
0.3787713348865509,
0.28821122646331787,
-0.12293531745672226,
-0.6184701919555664,
-0.7670855522155762,
-0.2028970718383789,
-0.44444939494132996,
0.07873157411813736,
-0.009080257266759872,
-0.08551596850156784,
-0.06246885284781456,
0.46903401613235474,
-0.6998833417892456,
-0.1790810227394104,
-0.22894832491874695,
-0.18265090882778168,
0.7545093297958374,
0.5235305428504944,
0.4141559600830078,
-0.2647615969181061,
0.046132318675518036,
-0.32767271995544434,
-0.2174891084432602,
0.3151903748512268,
0.5953835844993591,
0.45508021116256714,
0.22127021849155426,
0.7651055455207825,
-0.2211575210094452,
0.6973091959953308,
0.02417406439781189,
0.3481786847114563,
-0.532929003238678,
-0.9024440050125122,
0.22974541783332825,
-0.3226947486400604,
0.6420127153396606,
0.2641989290714264,
0.07652034610509872,
0.00200070277787745,
-0.23524919152259827,
0.036914754658937454,
0.08797144144773483,
-0.8855388760566711,
-0.21724927425384521,
0.4747043550014496,
-0.5483371615409851,
0.2077418714761734,
0.39678955078125,
-0.6123960614204407,
-0.23284968733787537,
-0.616279661655426,
0.44683757424354553,
-0.23599842190742493,
-0.5564153790473938,
0.18847844004631042,
-0.1174796000123024,
0.469457745552063,
0.34642893075942993,
-0.6867559552192688,
0.32613858580589294,
1.1227402687072754,
0.5902100801467896,
-0.09463857114315033,
0.06346168369054794,
-0.9658868312835693,
-0.49340036511421204,
-0.6870017051696777,
0.8792399764060974,
-0.6208042502403259,
-0.21425077319145203,
0.16520148515701294,
-0.00922516081482172,
0.10453922301530838,
-0.5879520773887634,
0.11547794193029404,
-1.1003371477127075,
0.49555569887161255,
-0.6599542498588562,
-0.8114312291145325,
0.05082913115620613,
0.38922008872032166,
-0.5085026621818542,
0.7872717976570129,
0.17945493757724762,
-0.7236683368682861,
0.5282629728317261,
-0.6497066617012024,
0.08622611314058304,
-0.02402687631547451,
0.08051255345344543,
0.07154850661754608,
0.16587881743907928,
0.3197258710861206,
0.2596937417984009,
-0.17994831502437592,
0.32032883167266846,
-0.41687214374542236,
-0.23378226161003113,
0.8727279901504517,
-0.15847066044807434,
0.8534618616104126,
0.03062456101179123,
0.21271441876888275,
0.41764283180236816,
-0.7358654141426086,
0.43066540360450745,
-0.2793673276901245,
-0.12525825202465057,
-0.40918734669685364,
-0.011997109279036522,
-0.14721529185771942,
0.2708265781402588,
0.2684177756309509,
-0.8040283918380737,
-0.17061421275138855,
-0.7416141033172607,
0.48679110407829285,
0.5972965955734253,
0.36215949058532715,
0.47008877992630005,
-0.33275318145751953,
0.2441711574792862,
-0.2890130579471588,
0.23883001506328583,
0.11494998633861542,
-0.3020038306713104,
-0.5773637294769287,
0.02421334944665432,
0.6467617154121399,
0.3679177165031433,
-0.5151877999305725,
0.3152396082878113,
-0.3143863379955292,
-0.4976663887500763,
-0.6139928102493286,
-0.02463102526962757,
-0.01819920353591442,
0.09811928123235703,
0.21773910522460938,
-0.49666446447372437,
-0.14224179089069366,
-0.7252886891365051,
-0.37420323491096497,
-0.7475056052207947,
-0.18912233412265778,
0.5848903656005859,
0.6662141680717468,
0.3552091121673584,
1.0551891326904297,
-0.4699004292488098,
0.44797825813293457,
0.04158509895205498,
0.3404451906681061,
0.38058969378471375,
0.13043339550495148,
0.3310902714729309,
-0.7693927884101868,
-0.29487356543540955,
-0.053360287100076675,
-0.3351432681083679,
-0.02358756586909294,
0.19063729047775269,
-0.6076834201812744,
-0.0944778174161911,
0.3592873513698578,
-0.3102153241634369,
0.08788006752729416,
0.5131223797798157,
-0.7057632207870483,
0.24785465002059937,
-0.10680867731571198,
0.5692983269691467,
-1.030754804611206,
0.28871339559555054,
-0.5560994744300842,
-0.08887049555778503,
-0.49242082238197327,
0.26099175214767456,
0.07973788678646088,
-0.17529644072055817,
-0.5957496166229248,
0.731395423412323,
-0.08646219968795776,
-0.1182267963886261,
-0.3266204595565796,
0.434536874294281,
0.12811297178268433,
0.11994972079992294,
-0.20757822692394257,
0.8876382112503052,
0.07809939980506897,
-0.5411381125450134,
0.40525519847869873,
0.43655404448509216,
-0.5370267033576965,
0.6984443664550781,
-0.8474711775779724,
0.49401968717575073,
-0.4260847270488739,
-0.22884032130241394,
-1.6370607614517212,
-0.49101147055625916,
-0.11058183014392853,
-0.8099954724311829,
0.015220734290778637,
-0.07684852182865143,
-0.692330002784729,
-0.10261418670415878,
-0.036280110478401184,
0.29458534717559814,
0.21587133407592773,
-0.3653581738471985,
0.19099922478199005,
0.535720705986023,
-0.20273981988430023,
-0.3862084746360779,
-0.1596895307302475,
-0.02545800246298313,
-0.04462713003158569,
-0.8643545508384705,
0.0021050223149359226,
-0.13841155171394348,
-0.5592107176780701,
0.2359359711408615,
-0.1923997849225998,
-0.5017759799957275,
-0.006662146653980017,
-0.2658275067806244,
0.09685518592596054,
-0.5246478915214539,
0.27632251381874084,
-0.2549630105495453,
0.0026760122273117304,
0.18721741437911987,
0.010485555976629257,
0.8679630160331726,
0.06785450130701065,
-0.29846611618995667,
-0.5036690831184387,
0.6402180194854736,
0.8358482718467712,
-0.7590867280960083,
0.9011867642402649,
0.18834367394447327,
-0.18440985679626465,
0.37947478890419006,
-0.6178669929504395,
-0.5084376931190491,
-0.45540571212768555,
0.37250301241874695,
0.03130320459604263,
-1.1000251770019531,
0.974872887134552,
0.32903948426246643,
0.19172661006450653,
0.6509660482406616,
0.45899835228919983,
-0.2583467960357666,
1.1239076852798462,
0.5392130613327026,
0.18965041637420654,
0.31853893399238586,
0.03898550570011139,
0.3925583064556122,
-0.35732612013816833,
-0.27632632851600647,
-1.0001567602157593,
-0.28268128633499146,
-0.5894845724105835,
-0.27071407437324524,
0.323373019695282,
-0.015158184804022312,
-0.6473361253738403,
0.1856006681919098,
-0.5129961371421814,
0.26296430826187134,
0.4855106472969055,
0.19404761493206024,
0.002440487267449498,
-0.44014081358909607,
0.45455431938171387,
-0.11779762804508209,
-0.4895242750644684,
-0.5769104957580566,
0.7437907457351685,
0.23810502886772156,
0.5639913082122803,
0.15580742061138153,
0.49808013439178467,
-0.05609509348869324,
0.38260385394096375,
-0.692150354385376,
0.5546697974205017,
0.07194332033395767,
-0.7768640518188477,
-0.9576493501663208,
-0.7008998990058899,
-0.940345048904419,
0.362807959318161,
-0.18040990829467773,
-0.5683460831642151,
0.1913909912109375,
-0.09607497602701187,
-0.5390899181365967,
0.18699444830417633,
-0.05721231549978256,
0.9854035377502441,
-0.28749367594718933,
-0.17512385547161102,
-0.14783675968647003,
-0.4816201329231262,
0.21629340946674347,
0.2271493822336197,
0.029896337538957596,
-0.44153308868408203,
-0.19350849092006683,
0.9923399090766907,
-0.21960484981536865,
0.3197624385356903,
-0.07419037073850632,
-0.08825017511844635,
0.6263952255249023,
-0.03285262733697891,
0.13188506662845612,
0.47462350130081177,
-0.296060711145401,
-0.22903846204280853,
0.6824731826782227,
-0.5253833532333374,
-0.9063007831573486,
0.6616714596748352,
-0.7851476073265076,
-0.684076189994812,
-0.18352708220481873,
-0.5215532779693604,
-0.047111667692661285,
0.08916882425546646,
0.12281571328639984,
0.5471966862678528,
-0.27798962593078613,
0.5574074387550354,
0.5658748149871826,
-0.28617963194847107,
0.28748705983161926,
0.6049279570579529,
-0.12889720499515533,
-0.4225062131881714,
0.2730918824672699,
0.36547496914863586,
0.3342586159706116,
0.6131376028060913,
0.3714767396450043,
-0.77461177110672,
-0.23051095008850098,
-0.25967586040496826,
0.3220851421356201,
-0.6635395288467407,
-0.26719844341278076,
-0.6303123831748962,
-0.12997904419898987,
-0.15662185847759247,
0.19508036971092224,
-0.45900723338127136,
-0.27381789684295654,
-0.2619437575340271,
0.12765948474407196,
0.25561439990997314,
0.37423428893089294,
0.1554999202489853,
0.2536373436450958,
-0.6386057138442993,
0.2084774374961853,
0.660267174243927,
0.5261984467506409,
-0.36666667461395264,
-0.7408550381660461,
0.06094830483198166,
0.2554830014705658,
-0.23842285573482513,
-1.2380832433700562,
0.17046451568603516,
0.24235300719738007,
0.35090285539627075,
0.04048024117946625,
0.4145139753818512,
0.5589257478713989,
-0.2541755735874176,
1.2899069786071777,
-0.06336648017168045,
-0.7421405911445618,
0.7985021471977234,
-0.26602208614349365,
0.3261038362979889,
0.8628612160682678,
0.17049430310726166,
-0.5335798263549805,
-0.7247918248176575,
-0.477725088596344,
-0.8125807046890259,
0.25249961018562317,
0.04548628255724907,
0.752587080001831,
-0.23926158249378204,
0.5635326504707336,
-0.11830028146505356,
0.23907984793186188,
-0.3120776414871216,
-0.05106660723686218,
0.022301405668258667,
0.33118778467178345,
-0.1454378068447113,
-0.47342053055763245,
-0.19329065084457397,
-0.23724645376205444,
0.41495999693870544,
-0.0910196527838707,
0.19795027375221252,
0.16259467601776123,
0.2826283872127533,
-0.273685485124588,
0.5432682037353516,
0.33023592829704285,
1.3444292545318604,
-0.2329731285572052,
-0.0030027180910110474,
0.11600212752819061,
0.11994323879480362,
0.1958911269903183,
-0.39762935042381287,
0.1383124589920044,
0.4636358320713043,
0.1777176856994629,
0.2960357069969177,
-0.12080682814121246,
-0.4079248607158661,
0.645171582698822,
-0.2204878330230713,
-0.24206973612308502,
-0.20386454463005066,
0.08435466140508652,
0.09405193477869034,
-0.10205421596765518,
0.16567668318748474,
-0.4228253662586212,
0.06799130141735077,
-1.1305994987487793,
0.5247328281402588,
0.8227089643478394,
-0.5834848880767822,
-0.14443989098072052,
0.6007838845252991,
-0.033036794513463974,
-0.6200434565544128,
0.736163854598999,
0.029839439317584038,
-0.39625129103660583,
0.6517431735992432,
0.13838835060596466,
0.4248151481151581,
-0.35834962129592896,
0.24936898052692413,
0.6547954082489014,
0.3654750883579254,
0.21397073566913605,
0.5412264466285706,
0.30123549699783325,
-0.6069530248641968,
-0.772599458694458,
-0.6369512677192688,
-0.6892894506454468,
0.37887436151504517,
-0.883084237575531,
-0.05004620924592018,
-0.29228389263153076,
-0.36916717886924744,
0.05618204548954964,
0.38103118538856506,
-0.7296785116195679,
0.24731867015361786,
-0.25824853777885437,
0.9541268348693848,
-0.8990206718444824,
0.3029569089412689,
0.4529808759689331,
-0.20288562774658203,
-0.7614532113075256,
0.022350803017616272,
-0.4284626841545105,
-0.4975005090236664,
0.4297935366630554,
-0.12452168762683868,
0.01518880482763052,
-0.25315165519714355,
-0.7520699501037598,
-0.8356438875198364,
0.7108545303344727,
0.603794515132904,
-0.21488940715789795,
0.23411469161510468,
0.2872447669506073,
0.6963759064674377,
-0.029728883877396584,
0.4405977725982666,
0.7819954752922058,
0.46448814868927,
-0.13843193650245667,
-0.9118728041648865,
-0.2505148947238922,
-0.1398102343082428,
-0.10331104695796967,
0.44140589237213135,
-0.470285028219223,
0.7313262820243835,
0.2783691883087158,
-0.37001046538352966,
0.15911370515823364,
0.933588981628418,
-0.1496843844652176,
0.3724774420261383,
0.5441817045211792,
-0.006993662100285292,
0.8308205008506775,
-0.4276123344898224,
1.085517406463623,
-0.6949648857116699,
0.41469690203666687,
0.6704011559486389,
-0.05723024904727936,
1.1014066934585571,
0.6982519030570984,
-0.07310221344232559,
0.020261192694306374,
0.602815568447113,
0.5390257239341736,
0.5258151888847351,
0.7375567555427551,
-0.1946418732404709,
-0.6292750239372253,
-0.19115017354488373,
-0.11153212189674377,
0.6580573320388794,
0.3415524959564209,
0.04110521078109741,
-0.2620895206928253,
-0.10586624592542648,
-0.14467863738536835,
0.7311925888061523,
-0.23461571335792542,
1.0287082195281982,
-0.11810915172100067,
-1.0106122493743896,
0.4912801682949066,
-0.033539898693561554,
0.21635743975639343,
-0.3743434548377991,
-0.06963366270065308,
-0.5465734004974365,
-0.26373809576034546,
0.09236779063940048,
-1.3725101947784424,
0.5955917239189148,
-0.0660615935921669,
-0.1668858677148819,
-0.01595640927553177,
0.07616325467824936,
-0.44671720266342163,
-0.4032478928565979,
0.20946981012821198,
0.8105330467224121,
0.1533723622560501,
-0.02342902310192585,
-0.4300413131713867,
0.017171964049339294,
-0.5257087349891663,
-0.2524433434009552,
0.31079524755477905,
0.6143659353256226,
0.43881475925445557,
0.35240182280540466,
0.4965205490589142,
0.023291688412427902,
-0.06366731971502304,
-0.3237175941467285,
0.8945583701133728,
-0.09388696402311325,
-0.5155273675918579,
-0.768157422542572,
0.5769363641738892,
-0.32152727246284485,
-0.5531640648841858,
0.40156054496765137,
0.5376546382904053,
0.872966468334198,
0.3761662542819977,
0.3275473117828369,
-0.009373237378895283,
0.7825536727905273,
-0.4720443785190582,
0.816138505935669,
-0.6825408339500427,
0.12254154682159424,
-0.001325329765677452,
-0.966194212436676,
-0.23148617148399353,
0.6309199929237366,
-0.4611418843269348,
-0.32464227080345154,
0.5406776666641235,
1.1960808038711548,
-0.32672592997550964,
-0.0872751995921135,
0.5425448417663574,
-0.0734364241361618,
0.4206288158893585,
0.17476165294647217,
1.1121405363082886,
-0.2787710428237915,
0.6177214980125427,
-0.1222475916147232,
-0.11255326867103577,
0.03940294682979584,
-0.562171995639801,
-0.6019432544708252,
-0.8630138635635376,
-0.37827426195144653,
-0.5741479396820068,
0.2917904257774353,
0.7004556655883789,
0.6125896573066711,
-0.7923625111579895,
-0.41029927134513855,
0.4073258638381958,
-0.15004463493824005,
-0.054069772362709045,
-0.22194980084896088,
0.676796019077301,
-0.5644357800483704,
-0.4659503698348999,
0.06038322672247887,
0.06691236793994904,
-0.5716302990913391,
-0.19105291366577148,
0.27191367745399475,
-0.10277155786752701,
0.5953163504600525,
0.5832585096359253,
0.03765745460987091,
-0.8248193264007568,
-0.9900193810462952,
0.49873512983322144,
-0.28984421491622925,
0.15391944348812103,
0.8676122426986694,
-0.148188054561615,
0.5915854573249817,
0.7472516298294067,
0.7731660604476929,
0.1761123687028885,
0.3109554350376129,
0.37602177262306213,
-0.6953787207603455,
-0.2078355997800827,
0.589863657951355,
0.0350869819521904,
0.31376293301582336,
-0.17263032495975494,
0.2748366594314575,
-0.34662801027297974,
-0.7610235214233398,
-0.7352781891822815,
0.23917527496814728,
-0.8981395363807678,
-0.10195333510637283,
1.1115065813064575,
-0.15185514092445374,
-0.0860699713230133,
-0.11157237738370895,
-0.36369839310646057,
0.15317942202091217,
-0.19330419600009918,
0.7958410978317261,
1.0148911476135254,
-0.015059457160532475,
-0.3954373002052307,
-0.87176513671875,
0.22172535955905914,
0.21526449918746948,
-0.68025803565979,
0.15897643566131592,
0.28522220253944397,
0.24152006208896637,
0.12684841454029083,
0.8483781814575195,
-0.3863898813724518,
0.461169570684433,
-0.2666272819042206,
-0.44946110248565674,
0.43999290466308594,
-0.18827232718467712,
-0.08510797470808029,
0.5332657098770142,
0.2752886116504669,
-0.32228878140449524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08806v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08806v1
|
CreativEval: Evaluating Creativity of LLM-Based Hardware Code Generation
| 2024-04-12T20:41:47 | 2024-04-12T20:41:47 |
Matthew DeLorenzo, Vasudev Gohil, Jeyavijayan Rajendran
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have proved effective and efficient in
generating code, leading to their utilization within the hardware design
process. Prior works evaluating LLMs' abilities for register transfer level
code generation solely focus on functional correctness. However, the creativity
associated with these LLMs, or the ability to generate novel and unique
solutions, is a metric not as well understood, in part due to the challenge of
quantifying this quality.
To address this research gap, we present CreativeEval, a framework for
evaluating the creativity of LLMs within the context of generating hardware
designs. We quantify four creative sub-components, fluency, flexibility,
originality, and elaboration, through various prompting and post-processing
techniques. We then evaluate multiple popular LLMs (including GPT models,
CodeLlama, and VeriGen) upon this creativity metric, with results indicating
GPT-3.5 as the most creative model in generating hardware designs.
|
[
-0.4553244411945343,
-0.764378011226654,
0.6925148367881775,
0.4167011082172394,
-0.5210255980491638,
0.4262768626213074,
-0.16008874773979187,
-0.30474889278411865,
-0.03598873317241669,
0.13795502483844757,
-0.6384881138801575,
-0.42225340008735657,
-0.26319456100463867,
0.029663210734725,
-0.16336661577224731,
0.7692688703536987,
-0.2682899832725525,
-0.3385765850543976,
-0.30876895785331726,
0.13549762964248657,
-0.651407778263092,
-0.31665515899658203,
-0.020679466426372528,
-0.13855908811092377,
0.38611096143722534,
0.284257173538208,
0.3472210168838501,
0.2289605438709259,
0.749982476234436,
0.3983991742134094,
-0.15195542573928833,
0.22738251090049744,
-0.44491299986839294,
0.3306959867477417,
-0.19337715208530426,
-0.4552968442440033,
-0.5630568265914917,
-0.09246771782636642,
0.33054444193840027,
0.2338889241218567,
-0.118809774518013,
0.5058525204658508,
-0.055888831615448,
0.5258498787879944,
-0.23101545870304108,
-0.08666755259037018,
-0.8524649143218994,
0.2458716630935669,
-0.4656066596508026,
-0.5328043699264526,
-0.29863521456718445,
-0.9472200870513916,
-0.4226490259170532,
-0.5954433083534241,
0.23887617886066437,
-0.23429784178733826,
0.32950901985168457,
0.3869321048259735,
0.05203445255756378,
-0.6623931527137756,
-0.911766529083252,
0.6332626938819885,
-0.7289596796035767,
0.22869257628917694,
-0.23574501276016235,
0.4221896231174469,
-0.17924214899539948,
-0.9060056209564209,
-0.6942996382713318,
-0.037771355360746384,
0.723823070526123,
0.04958714544773102,
-0.17458513379096985,
-0.19673378765583038,
0.3447730541229248,
0.7905682325363159,
-0.6512147188186646,
0.12273756414651871,
-0.2180866301059723,
0.14562617242336273,
0.6562807559967041,
0.2175276130437851,
0.3435980975627899,
0.09304632246494293,
-0.42579299211502075,
0.19401682913303375,
-0.9299780130386353,
0.11593169718980789,
0.4822094440460205,
-0.07989607006311417,
0.1909133642911911,
0.60059654712677,
-0.06485769897699356,
0.6191438436508179,
0.010580950416624546,
-0.4009139835834503,
0.35962823033332825,
-0.5053464770317078,
-0.24430449306964874,
-0.2561874985694885,
0.480021208524704,
0.17369234561920166,
-0.022313693538308144,
-0.20468156039714813,
-0.709376335144043,
0.017908306792378426,
0.43099841475486755,
-0.829018235206604,
-0.1675010621547699,
0.24113762378692627,
-0.5011059045791626,
-0.6234855055809021,
0.01687750220298767,
-0.2912234663963318,
-0.3588099479675293,
-0.3336350619792938,
0.4165972173213959,
-0.0798012763261795,
-0.30515074729919434,
0.13473014533519745,
-0.39821988344192505,
0.004661877173930407,
0.14235588908195496,
-0.5798549652099609,
-0.2754038870334625,
0.7891906499862671,
0.49416399002075195,
-0.3416960835456848,
0.05606274679303169,
-0.41122424602508545,
-0.19482776522636414,
-0.5963161587715149,
0.7784462571144104,
-0.24873784184455872,
-0.42019084095954895,
-0.2350538671016693,
-0.30222398042678833,
0.4158231317996979,
-0.6743887066841125,
0.37390515208244324,
-1.002721905708313,
-0.13353897631168365,
-0.5382582545280457,
-0.5207808017730713,
0.07705650478601456,
0.07676608860492706,
-0.5334617495536804,
0.7204280495643616,
0.22547557950019836,
-0.47620153427124023,
0.6511850357055664,
-0.43791088461875916,
-0.418021559715271,
0.7755494713783264,
-0.39210009574890137,
-0.29160451889038086,
0.7263559699058533,
-0.13411231338977814,
0.0999266728758812,
-0.4352436363697052,
0.39127352833747864,
-0.36630430817604065,
-0.4166809916496277,
0.8201702237129211,
-0.5563951134681702,
0.6694719195365906,
0.5192795395851135,
-0.43070241808891296,
0.21282507479190826,
-0.8847101926803589,
0.28915297985076904,
0.08176016062498093,
-0.45981016755104065,
0.07063837349414825,
-0.22497138381004333,
-0.06299871951341629,
0.3829505145549774,
0.4400772154331207,
-0.7688226103782654,
0.27428653836250305,
-0.2897852063179016,
0.47467952966690063,
0.733742356300354,
0.17374056577682495,
0.01193100307136774,
-0.49547916650772095,
0.9286729097366333,
-0.4811570644378662,
0.03393644466996193,
-0.04410427063703537,
-0.6632334589958191,
-0.4311361312866211,
-0.31222018599510193,
0.07121513783931732,
0.502924382686615,
-0.8907120823860168,
0.21458369493484497,
0.14929704368114471,
-0.7404073476791382,
-0.44145330786705017,
0.477058082818985,
0.2183440774679184,
0.4095688462257385,
-0.010609530843794346,
-0.27147412300109863,
-0.4034268260002136,
-0.7190647125244141,
-0.25760120153427124,
-0.11738717555999756,
-0.16746826469898224,
0.22812692821025848,
0.1997537910938263,
-0.2555026412010193,
0.6822230815887451,
-0.16657881438732147,
0.18703307211399078,
-0.26080626249313354,
0.477130651473999,
0.5190197825431824,
0.3467438519001007,
0.5595351457595825,
-0.3887239396572113,
-0.31335678696632385,
0.06178461015224457,
-0.799505352973938,
-0.49890780448913574,
-0.22768759727478027,
0.019734498113393784,
0.2575465440750122,
0.16986553370952606,
-0.6801625490188599,
0.4727230668067932,
0.2379729002714157,
-0.004777584690600634,
0.7693341374397278,
-0.10632223635911942,
0.41819143295288086,
-0.837395966053009,
0.18321473896503448,
-0.5007503628730774,
0.05553388223052025,
-0.2558894455432892,
0.335393488407135,
-0.1543801724910736,
-0.018056081607937813,
-0.6126310229301453,
0.39401087164878845,
-0.4031611979007721,
-0.2767694592475891,
-0.4573252201080322,
0.09563067555427551,
-0.048368655145168304,
0.13466748595237732,
-0.17309892177581787,
1.0231668949127197,
0.3499376177787781,
-0.35900717973709106,
0.8276386260986328,
-0.14881490170955658,
-0.6079086065292358,
0.4963913559913635,
-0.9648394584655762,
0.41833531856536865,
0.11040028929710388,
-0.31058165431022644,
-1.219360589981079,
-0.12936989963054657,
-0.48502057790756226,
-0.39377886056900024,
0.1832812875509262,
0.13107769191265106,
-0.7116222381591797,
-0.7665495276451111,
-0.09370072185993195,
0.6919997930526733,
0.7794391512870789,
-0.47075948119163513,
0.19642409682273865,
0.4206591546535492,
-0.459314227104187,
-0.1216077208518982,
-0.971157968044281,
0.05421195551753044,
-0.332414835691452,
-0.9372867941856384,
0.6911168694496155,
-0.5837950706481934,
-0.29455438256263733,
-0.01642894372344017,
0.01763894036412239,
0.13733355700969696,
0.16524530947208405,
0.07434047758579254,
0.2908160090446472,
-0.5017516016960144,
-0.032316453754901886,
-0.10810771584510803,
0.009467124938964844,
0.11479242891073227,
-0.3493249714374542,
0.4090721011161804,
-0.6043778657913208,
-0.5260450839996338,
-0.2656746506690979,
0.14734108746051788,
0.5262449383735657,
-0.21212777495384216,
0.2138092964887619,
0.5999704599380493,
-0.1668022722005844,
-0.7297704219818115,
-0.5422795414924622,
0.24892279505729675,
-0.6183558702468872,
0.242671936750412,
-0.499674916267395,
-0.9385508298873901,
0.7612915635108948,
0.1358197182416916,
0.23732100427150726,
0.28036895394325256,
1.0699173212051392,
0.12357962876558304,
0.8496695160865784,
0.5384593605995178,
0.47608569264411926,
0.2557257115840912,
-0.07430961728096008,
0.43960443139076233,
-0.5817959308624268,
-0.36386778950691223,
-0.13279937207698822,
-0.46028125286102295,
-0.5748007297515869,
-0.5040767788887024,
0.18916864693164825,
0.07789237797260284,
-0.20058588683605194,
0.1506337672472,
-0.7175738215446472,
0.6477256417274475,
0.43173930048942566,
-0.3056466281414032,
0.21305027604103088,
0.173186257481575,
-0.40320849418640137,
-0.15075838565826416,
-0.7792107462882996,
-0.5095812678337097,
0.8161718845367432,
0.45371299982070923,
0.909895122051239,
0.2914380133152008,
0.7805302143096924,
0.2384364902973175,
0.505971372127533,
-0.7768015265464783,
0.5302344560623169,
-0.1544499695301056,
-0.28743836283683777,
0.007070892956107855,
-0.5824427008628845,
-0.5734614133834839,
-0.35709813237190247,
0.24188102781772614,
-0.43454277515411377,
0.0966431275010109,
-0.005384134128689766,
-0.6896448731422424,
0.407254159450531,
-0.3348446786403656,
0.5711402297019958,
-0.6066758632659912,
-0.6270198822021484,
-0.15641430020332336,
-0.0008856749627739191,
0.6341743469238281,
-0.3885243833065033,
0.16012874245643616,
0.10446137189865112,
-0.045014914125204086,
0.5264967679977417,
-0.41236546635627747,
0.4120665192604065,
0.02046509087085724,
-0.33850541710853577,
0.737920880317688,
0.4036549925804138,
0.06288129091262817,
0.13738849759101868,
-0.2652859389781952,
-0.2705215811729431,
-0.2420201599597931,
-0.023682300001382828,
-0.5642493367195129,
0.9245507121086121,
-0.5654430985450745,
-0.5211478471755981,
-0.022092999890446663,
-0.6803471446037292,
-0.25719720125198364,
0.30743080377578735,
0.46981745958328247,
0.533205509185791,
-0.25782766938209534,
0.3701324760913849,
0.61114901304245,
-0.5740826725959778,
0.5823850631713867,
0.2568156123161316,
-0.22587211430072784,
-0.6514570116996765,
1.1026978492736816,
0.11758466809988022,
0.105707548558712,
-0.07023270428180695,
0.08590604364871979,
-0.47158846259117126,
-0.5913224816322327,
-0.5576999187469482,
-0.009718980640172958,
-0.7339473962783813,
-0.33134162425994873,
0.02085013873875141,
-0.5131649971008301,
-0.19662165641784668,
-0.4528052806854248,
-0.41938549280166626,
-0.6550386548042297,
-0.43926090002059937,
-0.0034562337677925825,
0.23196397721767426,
1.092530369758606,
-0.037231381982564926,
-0.0046176789328455925,
-0.6869546175003052,
0.3056592643260956,
0.6005641222000122,
0.5599188208580017,
0.10418767482042313,
-0.6912028193473816,
0.06552482396364212,
-0.1995106339454651,
-0.6463624238967896,
-0.8270891308784485,
0.47017619013786316,
-0.027729308232665062,
0.8463588953018188,
0.1832636594772339,
-0.1887148767709732,
0.5506919622421265,
-0.20097936689853668,
0.9778818488121033,
0.3445611596107483,
-0.8566021919250488,
0.6955074071884155,
-0.26497411727905273,
0.42371633648872375,
0.33090904355049133,
0.04672976955771446,
-0.04461479187011719,
-0.10086239129304886,
-0.7484617829322815,
-0.6183299422264099,
0.056352242827415466,
0.14388388395309448,
0.004405814688652754,
-0.12553547322750092,
0.19566741585731506,
0.19404058158397675,
0.4821512997150421,
-0.5963804125785828,
0.324640154838562,
-0.16667374968528748,
-0.29446032643318176,
0.5395461916923523,
-0.08333014696836472,
-0.024233374744653702,
-0.07730856537818909,
0.4458397626876831,
0.10091478377580643,
0.34730449318885803,
0.05124974623322487,
0.05316789075732231,
-0.13394582271575928,
0.346276193857193,
0.8208628296852112,
0.7979362607002258,
0.10051147639751434,
0.23654510080814362,
-0.010647201910614967,
-0.1292736530303955,
0.23273581266403198,
-0.1331903636455536,
-0.040147241204977036,
-0.12181756645441055,
0.20785580575466156,
0.6592283844947815,
-0.2218928039073944,
-0.6588491201400757,
0.5244860053062439,
-0.22485896944999695,
-0.22061394155025482,
-0.12095876783132553,
0.34205642342567444,
0.17240531742572784,
0.3515221178531647,
0.23525728285312653,
0.2388084977865219,
0.11506939679384232,
-0.39526501297950745,
0.369655579328537,
0.5540280938148499,
-0.04410459101200104,
-0.516411304473877,
0.7361999154090881,
0.1026257574558258,
-0.6492422819137573,
0.5997474789619446,
-0.7183843851089478,
-0.39650169014930725,
0.7917441129684448,
0.8296260833740234,
1.1697187423706055,
0.0037021522875875235,
0.09863698482513428,
0.2193824201822281,
0.3241099715232849,
0.3032141923904419,
0.8256186842918396,
-0.0928213968873024,
-0.42861607670783997,
-0.5998310446739197,
-0.8516135215759277,
-0.0986708477139473,
0.20279750227928162,
-0.32159093022346497,
0.25393086671829224,
-0.5753920078277588,
-0.5496428608894348,
-0.1654592603445053,
-0.11946910619735718,
-0.9025079011917114,
-0.07216016203165054,
0.2963732182979584,
0.8006072640419006,
-0.48469334840774536,
0.5934224128723145,
0.6456130146980286,
-0.3736260235309601,
-0.7616037130355835,
-0.5828782320022583,
0.05437524616718292,
-0.7901419997215271,
0.7054756283760071,
-0.13982422649860382,
-0.1197659820318222,
-0.13753020763397217,
-0.48944661021232605,
-0.6722458600997925,
0.9461976289749146,
0.2230551689863205,
-0.5330291986465454,
0.2274048775434494,
0.3316862881183624,
0.6013385653495789,
-0.5828694701194763,
-0.010095901787281036,
0.3598291277885437,
0.13442888855934143,
0.5244800448417664,
-0.6916494369506836,
-0.08370991051197052,
-0.665084719657898,
0.24378880858421326,
-0.12039177864789963,
-0.3804730474948883,
0.6705029010772705,
-0.5092706084251404,
-0.1266363561153412,
0.39504483342170715,
0.5135568380355835,
0.9694244265556335,
0.260387122631073,
0.04807880520820618,
0.5752317309379578,
1.003497838973999,
-0.02209368161857128,
0.8295944333076477,
-0.4859444797039032,
-0.0463525615632534,
0.8112137317657471,
-0.21578770875930786,
0.8004754185676575,
0.27942782640457153,
0.08110875636339188,
0.4503050446510315,
0.5268033742904663,
-0.19323812425136566,
0.489493191242218,
0.4909288287162781,
-0.31686800718307495,
-0.18517935276031494,
0.09714645147323608,
-0.43488597869873047,
0.12286897748708725,
0.38683974742889404,
-0.36299362778663635,
0.10343585163354874,
0.12884780764579773,
-0.3680518865585327,
-0.22156226634979248,
-0.19183415174484253,
0.6647322177886963,
0.19242596626281738,
-0.7162729501724243,
0.7365798354148865,
-0.09390579909086227,
0.45803573727607727,
-0.14272285997867584,
-0.002557385014370084,
-0.33287954330444336,
0.2663596272468567,
-0.21006065607070923,
-1.2203726768493652,
0.517723023891449,
0.302335262298584,
-0.1163257285952568,
-0.38515323400497437,
0.6845294237136841,
-0.20336639881134033,
-0.657157301902771,
-0.3603808283805847,
0.31923964619636536,
0.2041848599910736,
0.21562886238098145,
-0.5538697838783264,
0.445820689201355,
0.04566744714975357,
-0.046590398997068405,
-0.012243338860571384,
0.9614273309707642,
0.19955313205718994,
0.5176805257797241,
0.7084978222846985,
0.4007629454135895,
0.19644081592559814,
0.19146494567394257,
0.8055170178413391,
-0.5706086158752441,
-0.5274959802627563,
-0.6030431985855103,
0.6934967041015625,
0.1538955271244049,
-0.7811477184295654,
0.9141926765441895,
0.524986982345581,
0.5687211751937866,
-0.25088226795196533,
0.8499758243560791,
0.09883974492549896,
-0.013307559303939342,
-0.36000290513038635,
0.5042290091514587,
-0.5484816431999207,
0.7998052835464478,
-0.41689586639404297,
-0.973709225654602,
-0.24269428849220276,
0.657230794429779,
-0.2694869041442871,
0.0781090036034584,
0.3004539906978607,
0.8662201166152954,
-0.09572646766901016,
0.27471235394477844,
0.20402932167053223,
0.08514667302370071,
0.46235084533691406,
0.6805574893951416,
1.3792767524719238,
-0.12230086326599121,
0.11512499302625656,
-0.018096717074513435,
-0.5732330679893494,
-0.04535387083888054,
-1.1921641826629639,
-0.5405938625335693,
-0.32920584082603455,
-0.434951514005661,
-0.17782999575138092,
-0.37177661061286926,
0.5483298301696777,
0.605333685874939,
-0.5254666805267334,
-0.22134926915168762,
-0.5769779086112976,
0.008436870761215687,
-0.03785852715373039,
-0.20629017055034637,
0.004239308647811413,
-0.545186460018158,
-0.05538354068994522,
0.5687069892883301,
0.40510979294776917,
0.10741950571537018,
-0.4986453652381897,
-0.012749343179166317,
0.7357216477394104,
0.4011255204677582,
1.0086430311203003,
0.21165668964385986,
-0.7834733128547668,
0.22338639199733734,
0.5020887851715088,
-0.0985848531126976,
-0.21347962319850922,
0.8309342861175537,
-0.6687484979629517,
0.4977635145187378,
1.1550310850143433,
0.8132889270782471,
0.3048234283924103,
0.02848149463534355,
0.4271680414676666,
-0.4973047375679016,
-0.13877007365226746,
0.49648866057395935,
0.06118273735046387,
0.3852351903915405,
-0.19251243770122528,
0.08774610608816147,
0.3928340673446655,
-1.0630545616149902,
-0.7554824352264404,
0.1642989069223404,
-0.8493385910987854,
-0.3505849242210388,
1.1486486196517944,
0.03392057865858078,
-0.2911217510700226,
0.16565687954425812,
-0.07831810414791107,
-0.08204907923936844,
0.09148012101650238,
0.724407434463501,
0.5081562995910645,
-0.4250486195087433,
-0.023688754066824913,
-0.5247307419776917,
0.4921976625919342,
0.1538631170988083,
-0.6213797330856323,
-0.00030653522117063403,
0.357358455657959,
0.34431326389312744,
0.24676281213760376,
0.614534854888916,
-0.2638055384159088,
0.5348789095878601,
0.1756565272808075,
0.12543076276779175,
-0.21463023126125336,
-0.4092443287372589,
-0.1296291947364807,
0.5232327580451965,
0.5158341526985168,
0.14564992487430573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08801v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08801v2
|
Megalodon: Efficient LLM Pretraining and Inference with Unlimited Context Length
| 2024-04-12T20:28:14 | 2024-04-16T07:27:58 |
Xuezhe Ma, Xiaomeng Yang, Wenhan Xiong, Beidi Chen, Lili Yu, Hao Zhang, Jonathan May, Luke Zettlemoyer, Omer Levy, Chunting Zhou
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The quadratic complexity and weak length extrapolation of Transformers limits
their ability to scale to long sequences, and while sub-quadratic solutions
like linear attention and state space models exist, they empirically
underperform Transformers in pretraining efficiency and downstream task
accuracy. We introduce Megalodon, a neural architecture for efficient sequence
modeling with unlimited context length. Megalodon inherits the architecture of
Mega (exponential moving average with gated attention), and further introduces
multiple technical components to improve its capability and stability,
including complex exponential moving average (CEMA), timestep normalization
layer, normalized attention mechanism and pre-norm with two-hop residual
configuration. In a controlled head-to-head comparison with Llama2, Megalodon
achieves better efficiency than Transformer in the scale of 7 billion
parameters and 2 trillion training tokens. Megalodon reaches a training loss of
1.70, landing mid-way between Llama2-7B (1.75) and 13B (1.67). Code:
https://github.com/XuezheMax/megalodon
|
[
-0.4464765191078186,
-0.28858932852745056,
0.6005918979644775,
0.4198325276374817,
-0.3419947028160095,
-0.16530868411064148,
-0.13835299015045166,
-0.4064752757549286,
0.31554123759269714,
0.36763787269592285,
-0.550136148929596,
-0.11775951087474823,
-0.6989864706993103,
0.027115561068058014,
-0.408203125,
0.9528154730796814,
0.4656139612197876,
0.073178231716156,
-0.1087518036365509,
-0.23981522023677826,
-0.16676363348960876,
-0.4691910445690155,
-0.5446441173553467,
-0.4449115991592407,
1.0343724489212036,
0.249372199177742,
0.7055816650390625,
0.9367985725402832,
0.3421057164669037,
0.3566047251224518,
-0.1994958370923996,
0.2129267007112503,
-0.4895705580711365,
-0.20619894564151764,
-0.18572363257408142,
-0.45322418212890625,
-0.8713799118995667,
-0.2006763517856598,
0.5272042155265808,
0.7906221747398376,
0.05701456591486931,
0.33640167117118835,
-0.07497058808803558,
0.5680593252182007,
-0.7276421785354614,
-0.007034717593342066,
-0.4977875351905823,
0.23009438812732697,
0.07142018526792526,
-0.18994365632534027,
-0.4299713969230652,
-0.30350950360298157,
0.4539278447628021,
-0.608415961265564,
-0.07356660068035126,
0.01343627367168665,
0.4535232484340668,
0.6961762309074402,
-0.5502766370773315,
-0.3270522356033325,
-0.6489995718002319,
0.7248709797859192,
-0.5346900820732117,
0.5427658557891846,
-0.03769145905971527,
0.12251117825508118,
0.17749518156051636,
-1.0408453941345215,
-0.5736531615257263,
-0.18028762936592102,
0.040517259389162064,
0.23690347373485565,
-0.1164359301328659,
0.2931593358516693,
0.5754311084747314,
0.09970880299806595,
-0.46469783782958984,
0.32525479793548584,
-0.30094385147094727,
-0.09566662460565567,
0.423355370759964,
0.1874651461839676,
-0.28556275367736816,
-0.17118039727210999,
-0.564680814743042,
-0.07634947448968887,
-0.7388351559638977,
-0.13606727123260498,
0.5167180299758911,
-0.26862993836402893,
0.14159131050109863,
0.23807936906814575,
-0.024684373289346695,
0.5745155215263367,
-0.017014993354678154,
-0.2274419069290161,
0.19710956513881683,
0.06635551899671555,
-0.3226354420185089,
0.0708906278014183,
0.6780109405517578,
0.18931008875370026,
0.1944805234670639,
-0.178360715508461,
-0.06900393217802048,
-0.25815215706825256,
0.4545779526233673,
-0.8180387616157532,
-0.11971212178468704,
0.26110586524009705,
-0.19236956536769867,
0.11182918399572372,
-0.1685844212770462,
-0.9818089604377747,
-0.22358740866184235,
-0.45663997530937195,
0.6743084192276001,
-0.3387053906917572,
0.13731802999973297,
0.07066401094198227,
0.24345645308494568,
0.33308836817741394,
0.11487919092178345,
-1.1274313926696777,
0.09193708002567291,
0.6444183588027954,
0.8571847081184387,
-0.1299336552619934,
-0.4777889847755432,
-0.3607197701931,
0.05881780385971069,
-0.3748589754104614,
0.6819146871566772,
-0.03618322312831879,
-0.3423548936843872,
-0.27362555265426636,
-0.17968137562274933,
-0.1610884815454483,
-0.6691113710403442,
0.33082056045532227,
-0.7995831370353699,
-0.273463636636734,
0.2839454114437103,
-0.29562658071517944,
-0.3946669101715088,
0.058223020285367966,
-0.7064865231513977,
0.6293044686317444,
0.14676259458065033,
-0.3374684751033783,
0.1928827315568924,
-0.7342466115951538,
-0.45684221386909485,
-0.07707367837429047,
0.08549004048109055,
-0.23071089386940002,
0.1901162564754486,
0.14892229437828064,
0.38823238015174866,
-0.4114939570426941,
0.1697930544614792,
-0.2110695242881775,
-0.4650256931781769,
0.02422599121928215,
-0.4137924015522003,
0.5731278657913208,
0.126437246799469,
-0.5058220624923706,
0.3484646677970886,
-0.6400912404060364,
0.1586240828037262,
-0.0889110118150711,
-0.34381189942359924,
-0.026596803218126297,
-0.04427366331219673,
-0.2072651982307434,
0.20092174410820007,
0.2263602912425995,
-0.1880144625902176,
0.2870170474052429,
-0.4750067889690399,
0.6404905319213867,
0.8562108874320984,
-0.3655340373516083,
0.49619394540786743,
-0.153326153755188,
0.44258788228034973,
0.010552004911005497,
0.41095903515815735,
-0.31896623969078064,
-0.13468894362449646,
-0.9327734708786011,
-0.41607996821403503,
0.669535756111145,
0.5990753769874573,
-0.6265665292739868,
0.6632263660430908,
-0.7581073641777039,
-0.3780100643634796,
-0.14022250473499298,
0.2033098042011261,
0.37520015239715576,
0.3128446936607361,
0.416829913854599,
-0.22852203249931335,
-0.7544915676116943,
-0.9776686429977417,
0.3064901828765869,
0.3282988965511322,
-0.268417090177536,
0.33374935388565063,
0.6047201752662659,
-0.5832967758178711,
0.7043003439903259,
-0.3562077283859253,
-0.05903051793575287,
-0.37956884503364563,
-0.05606422573328018,
0.5546959638595581,
0.3415605425834656,
0.3887217342853546,
-0.737924337387085,
-0.18797428905963898,
-0.1248433068394661,
-0.6148027777671814,
0.004160972777754068,
-0.22679643332958221,
-0.10262240469455719,
-0.10800015926361084,
0.2836155891418457,
-0.9734631180763245,
0.23710079491138458,
0.7155462503433228,
0.12036893516778946,
0.439773291349411,
-0.1612216681241989,
-0.31526827812194824,
-1.1188006401062012,
0.17739421129226685,
-0.2868267893791199,
-0.035285960882902145,
-0.6574680805206299,
-0.04356839880347252,
0.35951924324035645,
-0.029029004275798798,
-0.5410362482070923,
0.3401544988155365,
-0.18378859758377075,
-0.4919489920139313,
-0.32809150218963623,
0.13508100807666779,
-0.15700995922088623,
0.7730989456176758,
-0.2190607190132141,
0.8225289583206177,
0.3379042446613312,
-0.75460284948349,
0.5036274194717407,
0.1384686678647995,
-0.4109176993370056,
0.14857153594493866,
-0.8417716026306152,
0.36583074927330017,
-0.03290935233235359,
0.5481239557266235,
-0.6858011484146118,
-0.29147136211395264,
-0.09725743532180786,
-0.3942417502403259,
0.3264665901660919,
0.014541340060532093,
-0.45343369245529175,
-0.6272100806236267,
-0.35066384077072144,
0.6655141711235046,
0.6114303469657898,
-0.8456775546073914,
0.8675869107246399,
0.1082744374871254,
0.08441475033760071,
-0.9397531747817993,
-0.48421424627304077,
0.027862921357154846,
-0.23685014247894287,
-0.4390680193901062,
0.2944084405899048,
-0.14349280297756195,
0.13398496806621552,
-0.2585943043231964,
-0.339613676071167,
-0.03561236709356308,
-0.00901059340685606,
0.47899872064590454,
0.30594247579574585,
-0.19738231599330902,
0.1298893839120865,
-0.029151996597647667,
-0.34147629141807556,
0.22497040033340454,
-0.6512507796287537,
0.9085457921028137,
0.04660392552614212,
-0.1709224432706833,
-0.4556400775909424,
0.22507937252521515,
0.9401639699935913,
0.02109389938414097,
0.4010835289955139,
0.4479595124721527,
-0.12898798286914825,
-0.4803014397621155,
-0.39011260867118835,
-0.11051227152347565,
-0.4994847774505615,
0.62159264087677,
-0.21401284635066986,
-0.7306398749351501,
0.34383538365364075,
-0.35647332668304443,
-0.09750363975763321,
0.4308827817440033,
0.6147302985191345,
0.09402766823768616,
1.0940240621566772,
0.5994192957878113,
-0.26649239659309387,
0.3322613835334778,
-0.7108129858970642,
0.34020230174064636,
-1.2021929025650024,
-0.30030012130737305,
-0.0686514601111412,
-0.7067238688468933,
-0.32575079798698425,
-0.4002557694911957,
0.36880120635032654,
0.1849634349346161,
-0.3766920566558838,
0.529444694519043,
-0.22615903615951538,
0.5900892615318298,
0.6893953680992126,
0.2655983567237854,
-0.06891258805990219,
-0.27753812074661255,
-0.10489168018102646,
0.1718786060810089,
-0.9467271566390991,
-0.3824683129787445,
1.2538598775863647,
0.27281373739242554,
0.6955310106277466,
0.0419987216591835,
0.3408300280570984,
0.21121782064437866,
0.5093801617622375,
-1.1345552206039429,
0.7291659712791443,
0.027166249230504036,
-0.576551616191864,
-0.27583175897598267,
-0.4633572995662689,
-0.8074143528938293,
0.2162460833787918,
-0.01340169832110405,
-0.689479649066925,
0.058541130274534225,
0.3753562867641449,
-0.8518317341804504,
0.42794090509414673,
-0.6162239909172058,
0.6397337317466736,
-0.4537111222743988,
-0.4036383330821991,
-0.34387168288230896,
-0.7316386103630066,
0.37061232328414917,
-0.47173255681991577,
-0.2074897140264511,
0.03309714049100876,
-0.41290783882141113,
0.5769190788269043,
-0.3134344220161438,
0.5730744004249573,
0.07366105169057846,
0.12874877452850342,
0.18709050118923187,
-0.248328298330307,
0.3486456871032715,
0.2480015754699707,
-0.0429244339466095,
0.3641318380832672,
-0.46050548553466797,
-0.46892574429512024,
-0.7790818810462952,
0.6573747396469116,
-0.8421969413757324,
-0.6271587610244751,
-0.16511815786361694,
-0.9650782942771912,
-0.2994476854801178,
0.1875585913658142,
0.4360353350639343,
0.49253135919570923,
0.2821978032588959,
0.555933952331543,
0.922459602355957,
-0.22317419946193695,
0.7452414035797119,
0.06096850708127022,
0.0606205128133297,
-0.6825376749038696,
0.484468013048172,
0.19224902987480164,
0.18370932340621948,
0.38502249121665955,
0.04474940523505211,
-0.48483431339263916,
-0.641248345375061,
-0.5501981973648071,
0.09646505862474442,
-0.7706698179244995,
-0.34785929322242737,
-0.778451144695282,
-0.34636634588241577,
-0.2925052046775818,
-0.0833607092499733,
-0.36066684126853943,
-0.21500299870967865,
-0.06611409038305283,
-0.17476701736450195,
-0.08273225277662277,
0.6500372290611267,
-0.204195037484169,
0.5645716786384583,
-0.7666963934898376,
0.31613925099372864,
0.8502093553543091,
0.1503487229347229,
0.3542296290397644,
-0.7838767170906067,
-0.3745497465133667,
-0.22030676901340485,
-0.3156481385231018,
-0.4761815071105957,
0.362046480178833,
0.15914468467235565,
0.46252310276031494,
0.5730841159820557,
-0.31278368830680847,
0.8331843614578247,
-0.7675458788871765,
0.603828489780426,
0.35794076323509216,
-0.9274168014526367,
0.23466607928276062,
-0.10769712924957275,
0.41735589504241943,
0.1395045518875122,
0.7817913293838501,
-0.07642021030187607,
0.38329631090164185,
-0.5543572902679443,
-1.1190730333328247,
0.528907060623169,
-0.06811627000570297,
0.36024489998817444,
-0.05332044139504433,
0.4162594974040985,
-0.09377805143594742,
0.1865367293357849,
-0.6974682211875916,
-0.032866593450307846,
-0.22322914004325867,
-0.18946333229541779,
-0.31763818860054016,
-0.488922119140625,
-0.20664812624454498,
-0.5003976821899414,
0.43496426939964294,
-0.2315024435520172,
0.47566312551498413,
0.28367021679878235,
-0.35696613788604736,
0.333038330078125,
-0.015807675197720528,
0.9825941920280457,
0.8754571676254272,
0.06474512070417404,
0.3307778835296631,
0.8791187405586243,
-0.5610666871070862,
0.3264472186565399,
0.05757448077201843,
0.16330486536026,
-0.19331718981266022,
0.5875223278999329,
0.7275750637054443,
0.48549023270606995,
-0.7705392241477966,
0.37675774097442627,
0.23772095143795013,
-0.31539154052734375,
-0.3786575496196747,
0.2373838722705841,
0.23865248262882233,
0.5667004585266113,
0.5079659223556519,
0.03184168040752411,
-0.009854906238615513,
-0.38422855734825134,
0.16623392701148987,
-0.032982777804136276,
-0.24949848651885986,
-0.3388410210609436,
0.8298172354698181,
0.1341797262430191,
-0.3241654336452484,
0.5465481281280518,
0.006250725127756596,
-0.5172945261001587,
0.966216504573822,
0.5003347992897034,
0.7427960634231567,
-0.23239247500896454,
-0.3313254415988922,
0.34471896290779114,
0.19327649474143982,
-0.060955505818128586,
-0.13719722628593445,
-0.26089295744895935,
-0.4573289155960083,
-0.7835142612457275,
-0.7369376420974731,
-0.36081957817077637,
0.2735922932624817,
-0.4490698575973511,
-0.1600736826658249,
-0.851696789264679,
-0.2722899317741394,
0.12887202203273773,
-0.17049959301948547,
-0.4938749074935913,
0.27218377590179443,
0.36641085147857666,
0.9709467887878418,
-0.30698421597480774,
1.0701137781143188,
0.4895360767841339,
0.1268356442451477,
-0.8406203389167786,
-0.03952450305223465,
-0.004162753000855446,
-0.7339453101158142,
0.9768840074539185,
0.589475691318512,
-0.29155874252319336,
0.3701055347919464,
-0.4364944398403168,
-0.9296993613243103,
1.4573553800582886,
0.33140695095062256,
-0.7760381698608398,
-0.10809947550296783,
0.16786915063858032,
0.423286497592926,
-0.3541700541973114,
0.33717110753059387,
0.6978468298912048,
0.23539096117019653,
0.08585850894451141,
-0.6104913353919983,
-0.2771547734737396,
-0.02721858210861683,
0.2534930408000946,
0.3648735284805298,
-0.8385331034660339,
0.8128024339675903,
-0.44805535674095154,
0.11441560834646225,
0.39377090334892273,
0.6393051743507385,
0.09558580070734024,
0.16298606991767883,
0.7446805834770203,
0.9644346237182617,
0.42399582266807556,
-0.16220977902412415,
1.0748404264450073,
-0.4674093723297119,
0.3793116807937622,
1.0830566883087158,
-0.27739065885543823,
0.4986741840839386,
0.2108275294303894,
-0.0460602343082428,
0.3848787248134613,
0.6269901990890503,
0.038251664489507675,
0.46400368213653564,
0.23721416294574738,
-0.4183763563632965,
-0.17294348776340485,
0.05358743295073509,
-0.1930975317955017,
0.4687020778656006,
0.3644726276397705,
-0.5422047972679138,
0.030532682314515114,
0.08429834991693497,
-0.0679367184638977,
-0.47379544377326965,
-0.5191860198974609,
0.5700066685676575,
0.08720877021551132,
-0.6597900390625,
0.5024494528770447,
-0.4461992383003235,
0.6130722165107727,
-0.8152527213096619,
0.13166290521621704,
-0.43155884742736816,
0.39883285760879517,
-0.2056613266468048,
-0.3658841550350189,
0.06999761611223221,
-0.24891012907028198,
-0.2475641518831253,
-0.09628462046384811,
0.34044066071510315,
0.03734879940748215,
0.022600505501031876,
0.5648959279060364,
0.13085636496543884,
-0.03691796585917473,
-0.05112487077713013,
-0.4469984769821167,
-0.06285848468542099,
-0.21408188343048096,
-0.5600413680076599,
0.2656639814376831,
0.2832155227661133,
0.2179899960756302,
0.8043779730796814,
0.6837484836578369,
-0.08164212852716446,
0.34654203057289124,
0.010874733328819275,
0.8006650805473328,
-0.7239307165145874,
-0.29670393466949463,
-0.8419674038887024,
0.30069372057914734,
-0.14577828347682953,
-0.5223541259765625,
0.6016536951065063,
0.420727014541626,
0.8708388805389404,
-0.17149601876735687,
0.2677898705005646,
-0.10741622745990753,
0.027635501697659492,
-0.5243162512779236,
0.4304072856903076,
-0.3732084333896637,
0.0888359546661377,
0.2878611385822296,
-1.2984510660171509,
-0.3895401060581207,
0.41955476999282837,
-0.39183592796325684,
0.12081590294837952,
0.7737147212028503,
0.6740203499794006,
-0.21255584061145782,
-0.18358778953552246,
0.651046097278595,
0.3248116672039032,
0.011007329449057579,
1.0281673669815063,
0.8478599190711975,
-0.25902214646339417,
0.833463728427887,
-0.2612561583518982,
-0.15641699731349945,
-0.3305683732032776,
-0.7004510164260864,
-0.7855985164642334,
-0.13117940723896027,
0.2190428078174591,
-0.0028769474010914564,
0.009009920060634613,
0.9307321310043335,
1.2351595163345337,
-0.5802389979362488,
-0.12149960547685623,
0.09104419499635696,
-0.01921333558857441,
-0.061040543019771576,
-0.12355156242847443,
0.25466787815093994,
-0.39674264192581177,
-0.8632916808128357,
0.42165660858154297,
0.4976603388786316,
-0.08564237505197525,
-0.35462966561317444,
-0.09443087130784988,
-0.14338839054107666,
0.11360848695039749,
1.0159716606140137,
0.2693776786327362,
-0.5279585719108582,
-0.495701402425766,
-0.1116659864783287,
-0.1673041433095932,
0.13208667933940887,
0.8420868515968323,
-0.6644241809844971,
0.16739247739315033,
0.32883113622665405,
0.8701446056365967,
0.5219366550445557,
0.005350039340555668,
0.32659268379211426,
-0.464629590511322,
0.4856887459754944,
0.4086015820503235,
0.441596120595932,
0.007146493066102266,
-0.13687025010585785,
0.7604672312736511,
0.2552196979522705,
-0.8806307315826416,
-0.39538222551345825,
0.28471097350120544,
-0.9846665263175964,
-0.2412368804216385,
0.9240999221801758,
-0.24047189950942993,
-0.46533381938934326,
0.20335520803928375,
-0.03707844391465187,
0.2563379406929016,
0.08465316146612167,
0.7313204407691956,
0.30912306904792786,
-0.1937539130449295,
-0.1637403964996338,
-0.9094876050949097,
0.18910275399684906,
0.6263566613197327,
-0.7690525054931641,
-0.3355626165866852,
0.268482506275177,
0.195622056722641,
0.4988761842250824,
0.1252214014530182,
0.09711284190416336,
0.5313949584960938,
0.04145202785730362,
0.018992044031620026,
-0.10776954889297485,
-0.8492764234542847,
-0.43809184432029724,
0.2127576321363449,
-0.34467408061027527,
-0.16185341775417328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08793v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08793v1
|
JailbreakLens: Visual Analysis of Jailbreak Attacks Against Large Language Models
| 2024-04-12T19:54:42 | 2024-04-12T19:54:42 |
Yingchaojie Feng, Zhizhang Chen, Zhining Kang, Sijia Wang, Minfeng Zhu, Wei Zhang, Wei Chen
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
The proliferation of large language models (LLMs) has underscored concerns
regarding their security vulnerabilities, notably against jailbreak attacks,
where adversaries design jailbreak prompts to circumvent safety mechanisms for
potential misuse. Addressing these concerns necessitates a comprehensive
analysis of jailbreak prompts to evaluate LLMs' defensive capabilities and
identify potential weaknesses. However, the complexity of evaluating jailbreak
performance and understanding prompt characteristics makes this analysis
laborious. We collaborate with domain experts to characterize problems and
propose an LLM-assisted framework to streamline the analysis process. It
provides automatic jailbreak assessment to facilitate performance evaluation
and support analysis of components and keywords in prompts. Based on the
framework, we design JailbreakLens, a visual analysis system that enables users
to explore the jailbreak performance against the target model, conduct
multi-level analysis of prompt characteristics, and refine prompt instances to
verify findings. Through a case study, technical evaluations, and expert
interviews, we demonstrate our system's effectiveness in helping users evaluate
model security and identify model weaknesses.
|
[
-0.3455618917942047,
-1.0842459201812744,
0.6386089324951172,
0.522987961769104,
-0.19720610976219177,
0.30362018942832947,
-0.15468037128448486,
-0.45915600657463074,
0.23267985880374908,
0.7265787124633789,
-0.6461775898933411,
-0.5930284261703491,
-0.6397338509559631,
0.18056222796440125,
-0.47755587100982666,
0.5798464417457581,
-0.0696135088801384,
-0.0033020623959600925,
-0.25148582458496094,
0.04536919668316841,
-0.9688993096351624,
-0.3467561602592468,
-0.4962461292743683,
0.40480634570121765,
0.3867645263671875,
0.4776149094104767,
0.48924893140792847,
0.34054258465766907,
0.6718540787696838,
0.42941808700561523,
-0.17150545120239258,
-0.24083212018013,
-0.37599977850914,
0.562538206577301,
-0.051294151693582535,
-0.2646840214729309,
-0.4139349162578583,
-0.14590497314929962,
0.20574410259723663,
0.3194044530391693,
0.10754511505365372,
0.3123413026332855,
-0.20293761789798737,
0.6803674697875977,
-0.6335784792900085,
-0.056472569704055786,
-0.6208072304725647,
0.0624929741024971,
-0.4911939203739166,
0.17433126270771027,
-0.4379841685295105,
-0.3216327130794525,
0.03440544381737709,
-0.19052396714687347,
0.01579633355140686,
0.29035574197769165,
0.4432237446308136,
0.22408568859100342,
-0.10668337345123291,
-0.14429323375225067,
-0.1845976859331131,
0.493798166513443,
-0.7940781116485596,
0.19412517547607422,
0.1355295181274414,
0.5953307151794434,
-0.2830977141857147,
-0.3995550274848938,
-0.18746034801006317,
-0.7805115580558777,
0.09075720608234406,
-0.38211363554000854,
-0.5484604835510254,
0.10245232284069061,
0.506757915019989,
0.10126354545354843,
-0.8356855511665344,
0.3800303637981415,
-0.4523099958896637,
-0.2899402678012848,
0.6529756784439087,
0.43334200978279114,
0.7697669267654419,
-0.27902165055274963,
-0.47344866394996643,
0.1242864727973938,
-0.7607507705688477,
0.006361231207847595,
0.38480326533317566,
0.36776041984558105,
-0.3010156750679016,
0.6427101492881775,
-0.06335894763469696,
1.0129303932189941,
-0.26156866550445557,
-0.18258710205554962,
0.11257363855838776,
-0.12593069672584534,
-0.23380471765995026,
-0.06078284978866577,
0.9531322717666626,
0.5225393176078796,
0.3620251417160034,
-0.1965520977973938,
-0.2997035086154938,
-0.22069787979125977,
0.21217294037342072,
-1.0452276468276978,
-0.23595714569091797,
0.34175339341163635,
-0.5578505396842957,
-0.540156900882721,
-0.004260448273271322,
-1.1934155225753784,
-1.1664862632751465,
0.01813547872006893,
0.048753656446933746,
-0.41643136739730835,
-0.10268477350473404,
-0.2025831639766693,
-0.2799684405326843,
-0.09696339815855026,
0.3030717372894287,
-0.687542200088501,
0.2986212968826294,
0.44568803906440735,
1.023111343383789,
-0.2442491054534912,
-0.2541191577911377,
-0.662405252456665,
-0.037370551377534866,
-0.06740222126245499,
0.8627501130104065,
-0.5027807950973511,
-0.559887170791626,
-0.13513608276844025,
-0.13777793943881989,
-0.12497519701719284,
-0.6434921026229858,
0.22605080902576447,
-0.5395753383636475,
-0.5294831395149231,
-0.20592144131660461,
-0.6572402715682983,
0.05970248207449913,
0.3918573260307312,
-1.0580378770828247,
0.45140784978866577,
-0.10254593193531036,
-0.8912521600723267,
0.0777759775519371,
-0.5133565664291382,
-0.2648813724517822,
0.2597489655017853,
-0.2699267864227295,
-0.3295934200286865,
0.31277960538864136,
0.37192249298095703,
0.4870159924030304,
-0.1992935687303543,
0.22327262163162231,
-0.5545161366462708,
-0.2886558473110199,
0.31383997201919556,
-0.24142807722091675,
0.9204015731811523,
0.37260058522224426,
-0.3064645528793335,
0.556364119052887,
-0.8469707369804382,
-0.21955257654190063,
0.4427292048931122,
0.015619844198226929,
-0.3962128162384033,
0.09033112227916718,
0.0834258422255516,
-0.16183212399482727,
0.4355331063270569,
-0.42452794313430786,
0.4644920825958252,
-0.2368306964635849,
0.5019934177398682,
0.7781304121017456,
0.02586737833917141,
0.18501345813274384,
0.3211769163608551,
0.945161759853363,
-0.1631343513727188,
0.42222917079925537,
-0.4275541603565216,
-0.3609825670719147,
-0.3374710977077484,
-0.41024351119995117,
0.17780674993991852,
0.8193759322166443,
-0.476669579744339,
0.1582884043455124,
0.09103856235742569,
-0.6357406973838806,
-0.16687124967575073,
0.49123692512512207,
0.4258791208267212,
0.44181132316589355,
0.22043609619140625,
-0.16694872081279755,
-0.6931270956993103,
-0.9704008102416992,
-0.5650508999824524,
-0.24630127847194672,
0.17758427560329437,
0.1418108344078064,
0.5010783672332764,
-0.2616821527481079,
0.8878800272941589,
-0.44087937474250793,
0.007163678295910358,
-0.5694236755371094,
-0.07894410938024521,
0.0015366855077445507,
0.3622737526893616,
0.9103562831878662,
-0.45195674896240234,
-0.2377966046333313,
-0.29790782928466797,
-0.858405590057373,
-0.5974602699279785,
-0.02373649738729,
0.1660155951976776,
-0.06929440796375275,
0.9291893839836121,
-0.4845197796821594,
0.5243570804595947,
0.5040766000747681,
-0.8575088381767273,
1.02769935131073,
0.09941807389259338,
-0.017745282500982285,
-0.6254057288169861,
-0.00522817624732852,
0.16874511539936066,
-0.16149283945560455,
-0.5715457201004028,
0.23401501774787903,
0.13746467232704163,
-0.3873794972896576,
-0.47858726978302,
0.7378076910972595,
-0.4620100259780884,
-0.1975124478340149,
-0.08305179327726364,
0.20239289104938507,
-0.061153020709753036,
-0.05038031190633774,
-0.39589250087738037,
0.8912562727928162,
0.4990330636501312,
0.01767277531325817,
0.8121804594993591,
0.019404467195272446,
-0.5219079852104187,
0.31087926030158997,
-0.8074982166290283,
-0.0030878307297825813,
0.11558523774147034,
-0.25107046961784363,
-1.1092380285263062,
-0.349179744720459,
0.2610085606575012,
-0.2591494619846344,
0.27488037943840027,
-0.3250477910041809,
-0.536247193813324,
-0.42258894443511963,
-0.43852072954177856,
0.18050424754619598,
0.1558411568403244,
-0.4888700246810913,
0.46233129501342773,
0.28326699137687683,
-0.43493127822875977,
-0.4612296521663666,
-0.38200435042381287,
0.5261134505271912,
-0.4896495044231415,
-1.0305564403533936,
-0.020225154235959053,
0.014316266402602196,
-0.8700512647628784,
-0.12971986830234528,
0.16499637067317963,
-0.03051953762769699,
0.5592137575149536,
0.5031273365020752,
0.5930460691452026,
0.04928458109498024,
-0.28343406319618225,
-0.06932166963815689,
0.039734482765197754,
0.3216988146305084,
0.047047920525074005,
0.44606199860572815,
-0.2765749394893646,
-0.220114603638649,
-0.45758137106895447,
0.2840946614742279,
0.9021582007408142,
-0.3856070339679718,
0.6770469546318054,
0.12187176942825317,
-0.01982799358665943,
-0.23927029967308044,
-0.6564489006996155,
0.17127232253551483,
-0.48838725686073303,
0.38744837045669556,
-0.42763084173202515,
-0.9948213696479797,
0.7470920085906982,
-0.1108245924115181,
-0.21772384643554688,
0.058181922882795334,
0.42529916763305664,
0.03641194850206375,
0.908600926399231,
0.9083406925201416,
-0.31192541122436523,
0.7362033128738403,
0.026737011969089508,
-0.027259433642029762,
-0.4990074634552002,
-0.40897583961486816,
-0.4372706711292267,
-0.12904712557792664,
-0.17523649334907532,
-0.02319491095840931,
0.18304932117462158,
0.37673214077949524,
-0.24568715691566467,
0.376619815826416,
-0.21632108092308044,
0.5670046806335449,
0.178217351436615,
-0.12909814715385437,
0.1705913096666336,
-0.09032891690731049,
-0.26392099261283875,
-0.038060013204813004,
-0.3486582338809967,
-0.624015748500824,
0.8619603514671326,
0.5580546259880066,
1.0257749557495117,
0.1753775030374527,
0.6047664880752563,
0.534636914730072,
0.1732853502035141,
-0.803554892539978,
0.8011147975921631,
0.0858297199010849,
-0.37641027569770813,
-0.08612386882305145,
-0.4933699071407318,
-0.6276759505271912,
0.10704806447029114,
0.0009250176954083145,
-1.1254826784133911,
0.009501785039901733,
0.22614626586437225,
-0.5388153791427612,
0.2600608468055725,
-0.9795828461647034,
1.2704910039901733,
-0.5666512846946716,
-0.26935577392578125,
-0.032708149403333664,
-0.6186261177062988,
0.818696141242981,
-0.03850475698709488,
0.4206222593784332,
-0.19796694815158844,
0.12543943524360657,
0.7628780603408813,
-0.9269868731498718,
1.107140302658081,
-0.4763399362564087,
-0.12030011415481567,
0.37493228912353516,
0.5345073938369751,
0.449308305978775,
0.08550510555505753,
0.16967375576496124,
0.0514400452375412,
-0.17595413327217102,
-0.13457965850830078,
-0.7113493084907532,
0.7598711252212524,
-0.433275043964386,
-0.8313952088356018,
-0.07512149214744568,
-0.44307708740234375,
-0.15694040060043335,
0.12805350124835968,
0.09234160929918289,
0.27020907402038574,
-0.2497500479221344,
-0.35770726203918457,
0.527955174446106,
-0.43628209829330444,
0.5133461952209473,
0.18775391578674316,
-0.6727123856544495,
-0.4610588550567627,
0.6473953723907471,
-0.021343598142266273,
-0.01620335690677166,
-0.1131187155842781,
0.1073794811964035,
-0.07695981115102768,
-0.9777041673660278,
-0.6955609321594238,
0.069282665848732,
-0.6081402897834778,
-0.35450342297554016,
-0.09887949377298355,
-0.02026841603219509,
-0.3693467974662781,
-0.15741939842700958,
-0.12812276184558868,
-0.35448306798934937,
-0.15183939039707184,
-0.17906609177589417,
0.7309427261352539,
0.749338686466217,
0.1501190960407257,
0.5090523958206177,
-1.03915536403656,
0.3377184569835663,
0.3164290487766266,
0.2982378900051117,
0.063926100730896,
-0.3619077503681183,
-0.11311419308185577,
-0.6289303302764893,
-0.22172744572162628,
-1.447180151939392,
0.46847039461135864,
-0.22304920852184296,
0.5404419302940369,
0.5887641310691833,
-0.11065425723791122,
0.5949110984802246,
-0.8027472496032715,
0.8053159117698669,
0.3646119236946106,
-1.160512924194336,
1.005426049232483,
-0.30818966031074524,
-0.16072531044483185,
0.7421290874481201,
-0.07469915598630905,
-0.2667700946331024,
-0.4294208884239197,
-0.32784503698349,
-0.9059931039810181,
0.4145580530166626,
0.06647530198097229,
-0.059029471129179,
0.019081342965364456,
0.32913437485694885,
-0.07069165259599686,
0.1552601456642151,
-0.5124814510345459,
-0.09959904104471207,
-0.16624246537685394,
-0.08662105351686478,
0.2440774291753769,
-0.4203665554523468,
-0.04002890735864639,
-0.14475052058696747,
0.1618502289056778,
0.27309295535087585,
-0.20273931324481964,
-0.08022752404212952,
-0.4561499059200287,
0.13995206356048584,
0.38804054260253906,
0.5839610695838928,
0.7395951151847839,
-0.15875911712646484,
0.07232049107551575,
0.10449744015932083,
-0.5834723711013794,
0.1621321737766266,
0.12896139919757843,
-0.13045786321163177,
-0.037779536098241806,
0.6681236624717712,
0.9376450181007385,
-0.08127011358737946,
-1.2116436958312988,
0.7992784976959229,
-0.1697826087474823,
0.21822257339954376,
-0.3175293207168579,
0.1882956176996231,
-0.06427758932113647,
0.5770807266235352,
0.13029435276985168,
-0.015592005103826523,
0.213176891207695,
-0.3652331531047821,
0.10763796418905258,
0.5199611783027649,
-0.3361562192440033,
-0.29106271266937256,
0.6019394993782043,
0.3245031535625458,
-0.4745946228504181,
0.6489270329475403,
-0.006447458639740944,
-0.654339075088501,
0.8600105047225952,
0.4882684350013733,
1.0513362884521484,
-0.43039724230766296,
0.018879637122154236,
0.07961490005254745,
0.6458408832550049,
0.09252005815505981,
0.2554415166378021,
0.03873320668935776,
-0.4340919852256775,
-0.5468619465827942,
-0.5064356923103333,
-0.3392845094203949,
0.1370757520198822,
-0.5526518225669861,
0.3572756052017212,
-0.8658105134963989,
-0.23133672773838043,
-0.22861643135547638,
-0.3586064279079437,
-0.30171555280685425,
-0.022887058556079865,
0.4245535135269165,
1.3470523357391357,
-0.8191081285476685,
0.5262070298194885,
0.4722183346748352,
-0.3049772381782532,
-0.5366703271865845,
-0.3408878743648529,
0.41282933950424194,
-0.5853386521339417,
0.9941624402999878,
0.42901578545570374,
-0.05415749549865723,
-0.42994120717048645,
-0.87857985496521,
-0.5460205078125,
0.7973522543907166,
0.58758544921875,
-1.0169233083724976,
0.061590611934661865,
-0.13134416937828064,
0.17348966002464294,
-0.3012522757053375,
0.11915378272533417,
0.9084729552268982,
0.6023421883583069,
-0.23832692205905914,
-0.8634922504425049,
0.23628026247024536,
-0.4314036965370178,
0.050542064011096954,
0.19604985415935516,
-0.36121296882629395,
0.71415114402771,
-0.5605080723762512,
-0.03234110400080681,
0.35535097122192383,
0.4682101309299469,
0.6532252430915833,
0.23561012744903564,
0.5186644792556763,
0.6674874424934387,
0.6053199768066406,
0.09340132027864456,
1.010135531425476,
-0.23625348508358002,
0.08429208397865295,
1.1734364032745361,
-0.21014070510864258,
0.7954596877098083,
0.632472574710846,
-0.07058919966220856,
0.5073562860488892,
0.4512266516685486,
-0.41027554869651794,
0.4922192394733429,
0.6254850625991821,
-0.14063942432403564,
-0.1989588439464569,
0.25160789489746094,
-0.2124246209859848,
0.26744338870048523,
0.47134968638420105,
-0.39507749676704407,
-0.30049121379852295,
0.4096166491508484,
0.24231065809726715,
0.011889535933732986,
-0.5136793255805969,
0.6274670958518982,
0.08585646748542786,
-0.05103752762079239,
0.3539617955684662,
0.12664707005023956,
0.5076566934585571,
-0.5629786252975464,
0.10295586287975311,
-0.2132703810930252,
-0.07401654869318008,
-0.21569953858852386,
-0.6464866995811462,
0.17666377127170563,
0.6919563412666321,
-0.002538457978516817,
0.0930328369140625,
0.8436566591262817,
0.15328966081142426,
-0.44681471586227417,
0.5319919586181641,
0.5495978593826294,
0.0731109082698822,
-0.1967693567276001,
-0.8457627296447754,
0.7041318416595459,
-0.034312792122364044,
-0.4835554361343384,
0.28225797414779663,
0.2198881059885025,
-0.16575860977172852,
0.8522233963012695,
0.37375956773757935,
0.2296573668718338,
0.22497813403606415,
0.29700136184692383,
1.013092041015625,
-0.8440313339233398,
-0.2626291811466217,
-1.489503264427185,
0.5881062746047974,
-0.36286184191703796,
-0.1751856505870819,
1.0185824632644653,
0.41688403487205505,
0.42310118675231934,
-0.0976848229765892,
0.839921236038208,
-0.03787446767091751,
0.22379884123802185,
-0.6909806132316589,
0.8960483074188232,
-0.2943597435951233,
0.796031653881073,
-0.5076112747192383,
-0.7303318381309509,
-0.43106988072395325,
0.41198277473449707,
-0.5440478920936584,
-0.2397695779800415,
0.3706210255622864,
0.6876944899559021,
0.15947146713733673,
-0.0977688580751419,
0.18462267518043518,
0.41319355368614197,
0.43932852149009705,
0.36359578371047974,
1.3109809160232544,
-0.02267005294561386,
0.4527992010116577,
-0.06100606545805931,
-0.35794585943222046,
-0.2349550426006317,
-0.8882268667221069,
-1.34867262840271,
-0.07761088758707047,
-0.2796541750431061,
-0.2515369653701782,
0.11701302230358124,
0.7774803042411804,
0.4529421925544739,
-0.7548122406005859,
-0.3720873296260834,
-0.05128614231944084,
0.17156116664409637,
0.24822457134723663,
-0.22879832983016968,
0.23407739400863647,
-0.5058788061141968,
-0.23348265886306763,
0.8792015314102173,
0.3855745196342468,
0.05468297004699707,
-0.4121057987213135,
0.25391602516174316,
0.4318554401397705,
-0.032669901847839355,
0.6340924501419067,
0.3688656985759735,
-0.6832237839698792,
-0.0953625962138176,
-0.10849767178297043,
-0.04368312656879425,
-0.1955072432756424,
0.9201593399047852,
-0.7814751863479614,
0.4861283004283905,
0.5492446422576904,
0.6088951826095581,
0.05982683226466179,
-0.0025021780747920275,
0.4164072871208191,
-0.6687461733818054,
0.3202153146266937,
-0.015331597067415714,
0.636549711227417,
0.3063560724258423,
-0.28809279203414917,
0.11296903342008591,
0.265767365694046,
-0.26848095655441284,
-1.000322699546814,
0.33310914039611816,
-0.8753634095191956,
-0.7020117044448853,
1.0397224426269531,
-0.26892316341400146,
-0.4438228905200958,
-0.10598310083150864,
-0.3639499247074127,
-0.3071262538433075,
-0.4448372721672058,
0.5780569314956665,
0.6587838530540466,
-0.04946976900100708,
-0.23828768730163574,
-0.77443927526474,
0.4468368589878082,
-0.057569220662117004,
-0.8632432222366333,
0.37104061245918274,
0.7130774855613708,
0.3840600550174713,
0.12449927628040314,
0.235920712351799,
-0.23410886526107788,
0.14140693843364716,
-0.08013352006673813,
0.0008208664366975427,
-0.45469769835472107,
-0.5401396751403809,
-0.6951725482940674,
0.3877162039279938,
0.1991272270679474,
0.054728131741285324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08763v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08763v2
|
CATS: Contextually-Aware Thresholding for Sparsity in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-12T18:42:18 | 2024-04-27T00:01:02 |
Je-Yong Lee, Donghyun Lee, Genghan Zhang, Mo Tiwari, Azalia Mirhoseini
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have dramatically advanced AI applications, yet
their deployment remains challenging due to their immense inference costs.
Recent studies ameliorate the computational costs of LLMs by increasing their
activation sparsity but suffer from significant performance degradation on
downstream tasks. In this work, we introduce a new framework for sparsifying
the activations of base LLMs and reducing inference costs, dubbed Contextually
Aware Thresholding for Sparsity (CATS). CATS is relatively simple, easy to
implement, and highly effective. At the heart of our framework is a new
non-linear activation function. We demonstrate that CATS can be applied to
various base models, including Mistral-7B and Llama2-7B, and outperforms
existing sparsification techniques in downstream task performance. More
precisely, CATS-based models often achieve downstream task performance within
1-2% of their base models without any fine-tuning and even at activation
sparsity levels of 50%. Furthermore, CATS-based models converge faster and
display better task performance than competing techniques when fine-tuning is
applied. Finally, we develop a custom GPU kernel for efficient implementation
of CATS that translates the activation of sparsity of CATS to real wall-clock
time speedups. Our custom kernel implementation of CATS results in a ~15%
improvement in wall-clock inference latency of token generation on both
Llama-7B and Mistral-7B.
|
[
-0.4800737798213959,
-1.0271539688110352,
0.4153439998626709,
0.6287288665771484,
-0.4516650140285492,
-0.2095702737569809,
-0.20959173142910004,
-0.574744701385498,
0.28979960083961487,
0.5562998056411743,
-0.3783635199069977,
-0.19809980690479279,
-0.5829606056213379,
0.07997138053178787,
-0.18337009847164154,
0.618529736995697,
0.20791994035243988,
-0.13020023703575134,
-0.07953401654958725,
-0.035703256726264954,
-0.5879499912261963,
-0.4245915114879608,
-0.622334897518158,
-0.3673466145992279,
0.26327231526374817,
0.08991636335849762,
0.4054943323135376,
0.8400755524635315,
0.49038591980934143,
0.20455318689346313,
-0.4464167356491089,
0.07109380513429642,
-0.46877920627593994,
0.253279447555542,
0.08174625039100647,
-0.1368686407804489,
-0.4766516387462616,
-0.5724120736122131,
0.8063386678695679,
0.5676590204238892,
-0.1294058859348297,
0.03294508531689644,
0.24878692626953125,
0.576044499874115,
-0.9317329525947571,
-0.06454141438007355,
-0.8549220561981201,
0.12071385979652405,
-0.07690904289484024,
-0.44338685274124146,
-0.7146803736686707,
0.1695161610841751,
-0.2178066074848175,
-0.8067215085029602,
0.08225874602794647,
-0.3255915343761444,
0.8185651302337646,
0.741913914680481,
-0.4645681083202362,
0.07692889124155045,
-0.34596291184425354,
0.8253993988037109,
-0.5461418628692627,
0.8030605316162109,
0.31057578325271606,
-0.09137823432683945,
-0.47739535570144653,
-0.6343068480491638,
-0.3690336048603058,
-0.41607779264450073,
-0.03725205361843109,
-0.14826352894306183,
-0.3835543990135193,
0.11174751073122025,
0.4470463693141937,
0.31405308842658997,
-0.5313557982444763,
-0.03424333408474922,
0.17204627394676208,
-0.12224727123975754,
0.1569599211215973,
0.17318414151668549,
0.16570143401622772,
0.10152239352464676,
-0.6507679224014282,
0.03054237924516201,
-0.6535500884056091,
0.38854098320007324,
-0.20187188684940338,
0.43232423067092896,
-0.13579760491847992,
0.20571275055408478,
-0.38210177421569824,
0.702237606048584,
0.43503013253211975,
0.08590228855609894,
0.24000318348407745,
-0.09746961295604706,
-0.3260210156440735,
-0.15439824759960175,
0.341291218996048,
0.13294459879398346,
-0.07111898064613342,
-0.1906629204750061,
-0.3509036898612976,
0.21044185757637024,
0.06521932035684586,
-0.9541979432106018,
0.04170515388250351,
0.04691646993160248,
-0.19089527428150177,
-0.2678573727607727,
-0.5104842185974121,
-0.48931685090065,
-0.368302583694458,
-0.24258127808570862,
0.2797505259513855,
-0.15646634995937347,
-0.5162134170532227,
0.3092731237411499,
0.03812083601951599,
0.3083024024963379,
0.22849030792713165,
-0.8727571964263916,
0.49707192182540894,
0.6806601285934448,
0.8400906324386597,
-0.21431037783622742,
-0.11898522824048996,
-1.141249179840088,
0.14524173736572266,
-0.5506995320320129,
0.749221682548523,
-0.7298603653907776,
-0.43150559067726135,
-0.3989412486553192,
-0.008738852106034756,
-0.0015119126765057445,
-0.4915471076965332,
0.3059388995170593,
-0.6920349597930908,
-0.5300310254096985,
-0.24929091334342957,
-0.17769037187099457,
-0.12291193753480911,
0.41192755103111267,
-0.7694509625434875,
1.5453948974609375,
-0.37519606947898865,
-0.6017215251922607,
0.5448050498962402,
-0.715786337852478,
-0.619117796421051,
0.25177061557769775,
0.35374805331230164,
-0.3804779052734375,
0.23529194295406342,
0.3391668498516083,
0.6554222702980042,
-0.022979775443673134,
0.7121981382369995,
-0.39623337984085083,
-0.46247273683547974,
0.16484756767749786,
-0.3338235020637512,
0.5923026204109192,
0.09643419831991196,
-0.5059394240379333,
0.20424440503120422,
-0.6644195914268494,
-0.036765798926353455,
-0.24984335899353027,
-0.315986305475235,
-0.6121866106987,
0.0031471666879951954,
0.2172725945711136,
0.10943842679262161,
0.29996928572654724,
-0.2085086554288864,
-0.022859370335936546,
-0.3639621436595917,
0.4651062786579132,
0.6740608215332031,
0.08649735152721405,
0.33299997448921204,
-0.08441411703824997,
0.3351925313472748,
0.061063479632139206,
0.08622393012046814,
0.0031504493672400713,
-0.5514172911643982,
-0.7165535092353821,
-0.6432030200958252,
-0.10074467211961746,
0.3611665964126587,
-0.6149103045463562,
0.5014286637306213,
-0.2972315847873688,
-0.43075889348983765,
0.26025938987731934,
0.2569655478000641,
0.5676159858703613,
0.5291280150413513,
0.4404064416885376,
-0.4869319498538971,
-0.5516841411590576,
-0.7902066707611084,
-0.15392334759235382,
-0.051609721034765244,
0.1924336850643158,
0.27542468905448914,
0.45165857672691345,
-0.22149407863616943,
0.8785073757171631,
-0.23289808630943298,
-0.1905427873134613,
-0.24221119284629822,
0.10687386244535446,
0.09395352751016617,
0.668232262134552,
0.2585511803627014,
-0.6495071053504944,
-0.344791442155838,
0.09391078352928162,
-0.2828240692615509,
-0.31087130308151245,
-0.11707897484302521,
-0.3212815821170807,
0.08760006725788116,
0.5516366958618164,
-0.5606532692909241,
0.3743849992752075,
0.5491310358047485,
-0.28702232241630554,
0.238366961479187,
0.028511250391602516,
-0.08398397266864777,
-1.0350955724716187,
0.4726181626319885,
0.25601881742477417,
-0.3745264708995819,
-0.9255493879318237,
-0.10565153509378433,
0.03845255821943283,
0.05271172523498535,
-0.4105609953403473,
0.8445220589637756,
-0.5051741600036621,
-0.16381657123565674,
-0.22565653920173645,
-0.23104000091552734,
-0.02491605281829834,
0.8728405833244324,
0.44583457708358765,
0.7974963188171387,
0.5332593321800232,
-0.8481905460357666,
-0.43974098563194275,
0.04496188461780548,
-0.11220766603946686,
0.2543624937534332,
-0.5411343574523926,
-0.06725430488586426,
0.13346831500530243,
0.5202504992485046,
-0.8190038204193115,
-0.15002696216106415,
0.1537269800901413,
-0.4197903871536255,
0.1117512509226799,
-0.1738862842321396,
-0.15839345753192902,
0.17387713491916656,
-0.22049732506275177,
0.7080819606781006,
0.3554729223251343,
-0.6258840560913086,
0.7648184299468994,
0.6820818185806274,
0.1675676554441452,
-1.0890690088272095,
-0.561277449131012,
0.29864218831062317,
-0.23047496378421783,
-0.2937224507331848,
0.2855072021484375,
0.07773774117231369,
0.003145006252452731,
-0.013436770997941494,
-0.07215390354394913,
-0.3222847878932953,
0.47291961312294006,
0.45016342401504517,
0.06605455279350281,
-0.3426074981689453,
0.09148970246315002,
0.15542738139629364,
-0.25642648339271545,
-0.21383601427078247,
-0.22373917698860168,
0.5322996377944946,
-0.20810197293758392,
-0.10380531847476959,
-0.5172392129898071,
0.0656585767865181,
0.5610582828521729,
-0.38769811391830444,
0.38074830174446106,
0.6818670034408569,
-0.7201205492019653,
-0.4718468487262726,
-0.7603034377098083,
-0.3362092673778534,
-0.4819023907184601,
0.5636873841285706,
-0.57993084192276,
-1.2072172164916992,
0.4556490182876587,
0.06446703523397446,
0.07004503905773163,
0.25476348400115967,
0.8473972678184509,
0.5615121722221375,
1.0883753299713135,
0.8265301585197449,
-0.10260958969593048,
0.7911287546157837,
-0.012704490683972836,
0.21266265213489532,
-0.9682475924491882,
0.01157662644982338,
-0.25422194600105286,
-0.0849720761179924,
-0.14993691444396973,
-0.6783438324928284,
0.4480878412723541,
0.06622796505689621,
-0.17723356187343597,
0.26520106196403503,
-0.5706012845039368,
0.6182634830474854,
0.1562713384628296,
0.1716998666524887,
0.33676573634147644,
0.314532995223999,
0.025454452261328697,
0.02606167085468769,
-0.7123461961746216,
-0.3871925473213196,
0.7414649128913879,
0.49605390429496765,
0.6109306216239929,
-0.11679775267839432,
0.11077945679426193,
0.552467942237854,
0.7356112003326416,
-0.7492988109588623,
0.6913828253746033,
-0.18075211346149445,
-0.7407152056694031,
-0.4737757444381714,
-0.33898699283599854,
-0.9306290149688721,
0.44869866967201233,
-0.23391921818256378,
-0.8655712604522705,
0.3916395902633667,
0.44023868441581726,
-0.34339359402656555,
0.3978535532951355,
-0.5505630373954773,
0.7302064299583435,
0.07929614186286926,
-0.852067768573761,
-0.27730125188827515,
-0.2616461217403412,
0.544171929359436,
0.13889886438846588,
-0.014323455281555653,
-0.36504891514778137,
-0.24055279791355133,
0.5835263729095459,
-0.2189939171075821,
1.2078311443328857,
-0.3363368809223175,
-0.020043497905135155,
0.23449338972568512,
0.2553502023220062,
0.5475142598152161,
0.132077157497406,
-0.06673845648765564,
0.2268790602684021,
-0.14976420998573303,
-0.24295172095298767,
-0.3542611598968506,
0.7342763543128967,
-0.3742658793926239,
-0.6213193535804749,
-0.20765617489814758,
-0.5823729038238525,
-0.395484983921051,
0.19093307852745056,
-0.056587979197502136,
0.5554124712944031,
-0.1863943189382553,
0.33230695128440857,
0.6113010048866272,
0.07605233788490295,
0.34308379888534546,
0.4022345244884491,
0.05894405022263527,
-0.49891752004623413,
0.9435351490974426,
-0.33352407813072205,
0.09290121495723724,
0.5634638667106628,
0.05232676491141319,
-0.5106738209724426,
-0.37933802604675293,
-0.7381407022476196,
0.13407395780086517,
-0.612429678440094,
-0.24085162580013275,
-0.7015567421913147,
-0.1035928875207901,
-0.1860290914773941,
-0.41430217027664185,
-0.3990294635295868,
-0.1929933875799179,
-0.29680541157722473,
0.04739134758710861,
0.3735277056694031,
0.4395482540130615,
-0.2507975399494171,
0.43669357895851135,
-0.4816029965877533,
0.24102312326431274,
0.1854175627231598,
0.612669825553894,
0.27046486735343933,
-0.4908056855201721,
-0.3057984709739685,
-0.17300507426261902,
-0.1557711958885193,
-0.5940244793891907,
0.42200708389282227,
0.20602580904960632,
0.44207262992858887,
0.4759467542171478,
-0.07388141006231308,
1.0018390417099,
-0.29845356941223145,
0.6654509902000427,
0.29943007230758667,
-1.400104284286499,
0.053403258323669434,
-0.14507651329040527,
0.04355819895863533,
0.3757796287536621,
-0.08887512236833572,
-0.5541110038757324,
-0.2725546658039093,
-0.02349134162068367,
-0.8926719427108765,
0.5915286540985107,
0.10151205956935883,
0.2540033459663391,
-0.06823939085006714,
0.2438887357711792,
0.07261674106121063,
-0.16361941397190094,
-1.0670151710510254,
0.25353866815567017,
0.012735969386994839,
0.09659931808710098,
-0.11806274950504303,
-0.4099465608596802,
0.13236699998378754,
-0.08872691541910172,
0.7855060696601868,
-0.21751494705677032,
-0.05138546973466873,
0.40327155590057373,
-0.4433087408542633,
-0.3236013650894165,
0.2097521275281906,
0.7397174835205078,
0.37178200483322144,
-0.032151561230421066,
0.1778281331062317,
0.633145809173584,
-0.6016172766685486,
0.2610529661178589,
-0.2581601142883301,
-0.06944547593593597,
-0.044022154062986374,
0.3075762391090393,
0.9566120505332947,
0.3495517373085022,
-0.7805536389350891,
0.4337034523487091,
-0.060922734439373016,
-0.148870050907135,
-0.10209934413433075,
0.04596751928329468,
-0.15263092517852783,
0.14841672778129578,
0.23960401117801666,
-0.12677817046642303,
0.2929598093032837,
0.11949063092470169,
0.2945046126842499,
0.7652624249458313,
-0.5928664207458496,
-0.28066661953926086,
0.7164704203605652,
0.3105817437171936,
0.0694044828414917,
0.05305493250489235,
-0.10670603811740875,
-0.5727680325508118,
0.7593916654586792,
0.6607671976089478,
1.0912961959838867,
-0.20193123817443848,
-0.12485798448324203,
0.5597940683364868,
0.343744158744812,
-0.1193653866648674,
0.04180994629859924,
-0.65288245677948,
-0.6920299530029297,
-0.6878496408462524,
-0.796042799949646,
-0.35929322242736816,
0.3102671504020691,
-0.5060396194458008,
0.2829814851284027,
-0.45871502161026,
-0.5214158892631531,
-0.17532451450824738,
-0.2829362154006958,
-0.15592385828495026,
0.29802411794662476,
0.18549484014511108,
0.850374698638916,
-0.8516219854354858,
0.6361944675445557,
0.7025212049484253,
0.207015261054039,
-0.4997067451477051,
-0.10726049542427063,
-0.3668060898780823,
-0.7078163623809814,
0.8529936075210571,
0.3724166750907898,
-0.6922229528427124,
0.08425451070070267,
-0.39425626397132874,
-0.8345715403556824,
0.7122144103050232,
0.1542038768529892,
-0.4926418662071228,
0.2617376148700714,
0.14430131018161774,
0.44367435574531555,
-0.30038899183273315,
0.07894498109817505,
0.4338115453720093,
0.43636053800582886,
0.07247727364301682,
-0.7992209792137146,
0.34387850761413574,
-0.653118908405304,
0.30062440037727356,
0.3783460855484009,
-0.41734352707862854,
0.7066218852996826,
-0.04487962648272514,
-0.34765294194221497,
0.08851984143257141,
0.4833099842071533,
0.33686792850494385,
0.4251936674118042,
0.9022355079650879,
0.6942912936210632,
0.4126245379447937,
-0.016320163384079933,
0.6370700001716614,
-0.7703434824943542,
0.13219177722930908,
0.6241157054901123,
-0.28554242849349976,
1.030996561050415,
0.6773043870925903,
0.26344308257102966,
0.12173985689878464,
0.650758683681488,
0.17635713517665863,
0.36291345953941345,
0.23194679617881775,
-0.36831265687942505,
-0.7988594174385071,
-0.39639872312545776,
-0.4471963346004486,
0.11797536164522171,
0.6206013560295105,
-0.07766998559236526,
-0.14203791320323944,
-0.0006307482253760099,
-0.06843984872102737,
-0.23018118739128113,
-0.28833791613578796,
0.760361909866333,
-0.023539278656244278,
-0.7923957109451294,
1.0474029779434204,
0.08393076807260513,
0.6808693408966064,
-0.5195838809013367,
-0.08509504050016403,
-0.2438705861568451,
0.27960696816444397,
-0.15030302107334137,
-0.5099670886993408,
0.22146248817443848,
0.29847434163093567,
-0.1718577891588211,
-0.17836986482143402,
0.7415995001792908,
-0.28337156772613525,
-0.3482760787010193,
0.33039647340774536,
0.34237268567085266,
0.0027586868964135647,
-0.12485849112272263,
-0.47365063428878784,
0.3106445372104645,
-0.19567963480949402,
-0.4012945294380188,
0.08668635785579681,
0.24427206814289093,
-0.5036720037460327,
0.8393350839614868,
1.030165672302246,
-0.028993980959057808,
0.17913204431533813,
-0.13256330788135529,
1.0055004358291626,
-0.5409082770347595,
-0.7916228771209717,
-0.7519053220748901,
0.6034685373306274,
0.16590794920921326,
-0.5026825666427612,
0.3680497109889984,
0.6952309012413025,
0.4769171178340912,
-0.01866523176431656,
0.4866640269756317,
0.1988697201013565,
0.15539957582950592,
-0.6266698837280273,
0.5902683734893799,
-0.9162980318069458,
0.3051571547985077,
-0.17860092222690582,
-0.661245584487915,
-0.7189633846282959,
0.49124154448509216,
-0.4870389699935913,
-0.12909799814224243,
0.3805062770843506,
1.27654230594635,
-0.18637646734714508,
-0.2449130266904831,
0.5221465826034546,
0.10860247164964676,
0.2533986270427704,
0.7422605156898499,
0.9665015935897827,
-0.03138680011034012,
0.4434213936328888,
-0.2573031783103943,
-0.28743526339530945,
-0.4258453845977783,
-0.8571500778198242,
-1.0067352056503296,
-0.6931500434875488,
-0.2047864943742752,
-0.32644563913345337,
0.26777881383895874,
0.7649300694465637,
1.0190861225128174,
-0.7169798612594604,
-0.4067397117614746,
-0.25055521726608276,
0.05918602645397186,
-0.1595854014158249,
-0.24177178740501404,
0.2502463459968567,
-0.6067863702774048,
-0.5211374759674072,
0.3040679693222046,
0.5115162134170532,
-0.1904406100511551,
-0.1147022396326065,
-0.21028007566928864,
0.028352979570627213,
0.1918811798095703,
0.6871281266212463,
0.4827671945095062,
-0.8544522523880005,
-0.06390660256147385,
0.11558549851179123,
-0.25958120822906494,
0.3198111057281494,
0.9076901078224182,
-0.7206230163574219,
0.2710011601448059,
0.4091714322566986,
0.8600265383720398,
0.49523985385894775,
0.05523652955889702,
0.20221221446990967,
-0.5066743493080139,
0.4552993178367615,
0.12396041303873062,
0.2770814895629883,
0.2881673574447632,
-0.43373996019363403,
0.26243001222610474,
0.2820248603820801,
-0.23321077227592468,
-1.1862266063690186,
0.13712383806705475,
-1.1419533491134644,
-0.13822481036186218,
1.039167881011963,
0.1386404186487198,
-0.47117021679878235,
-0.18408064544200897,
-0.07666230946779251,
0.14831984043121338,
-0.581948459148407,
0.6989415287971497,
0.4736819863319397,
0.006387707311660051,
-0.029664086177945137,
-0.3865742087364197,
0.6553462743759155,
0.8048920631408691,
-0.7083248496055603,
0.31314030289649963,
0.47960522770881653,
0.28431159257888794,
-0.14361423254013062,
0.641589879989624,
0.07224401831626892,
0.4173237085342407,
0.09425864368677139,
0.3685665428638458,
-0.12004952877759933,
-0.26346808671951294,
-0.4195946156978607,
0.1025572195649147,
-0.03817778453230858,
-0.11488484591245651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08760v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08760v2
|
The Generation Gap:Exploring Age Bias in the Underlying Value Systems of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-12T18:36:20 | 2024-05-13T22:11:02 |
Siyang Liu, Trish Maturi, Bowen Yi, Siqi Shen, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper, we explore the alignment of values in Large Language Models
(LLMs) with specific age groups, leveraging data from the World Value Survey
across thirteen categories. Through a diverse set of prompts tailored to ensure
response robustness, we find a general inclination of LLM values towards
younger demographics. Additionally, we explore the impact of incorporating age
identity information in prompts and observe challenges in mitigating value
discrepancies with different age cohorts. Our findings highlight the age bias
in LLMs and provide insights for future work.
|
[
-0.38564857840538025,
-0.5054035186767578,
0.43901166319847107,
0.06545614451169968,
0.26084813475608826,
0.3129514157772064,
0.1990710347890854,
-0.6690709590911865,
-0.21190284192562103,
0.14321033656597137,
-0.8429892063140869,
-0.08521435409784317,
-0.6007749438285828,
-0.10956607013940811,
0.17605289816856384,
0.5746748447418213,
0.30601128935813904,
0.07434453070163727,
-0.440449982881546,
-0.060177676379680634,
-0.36465439200401306,
-0.4609682559967041,
-0.5924344062805176,
-0.5476445555686951,
0.47880712151527405,
0.5844235420227051,
0.6847365498542786,
0.5047393441200256,
0.22437003254890442,
0.1678646355867386,
-0.5118428468704224,
0.06318160891532898,
-0.4851209819316864,
0.5833936333656311,
-0.31606200337409973,
-0.2824408710002899,
-0.5519388318061829,
-0.026890965178608894,
0.39330583810806274,
1.0440318584442139,
0.3376125991344452,
0.23522329330444336,
-0.08161640912294388,
0.9091339111328125,
-0.5891680717468262,
0.07690192759037018,
-0.6634131669998169,
-0.00045026378938928246,
-0.5142544507980347,
-0.14602920413017273,
-0.3476826250553131,
-0.5751568078994751,
0.18004748225212097,
-0.23729263246059418,
0.19254688918590546,
0.16165395081043243,
1.044851541519165,
-0.004856242798268795,
-0.6776345372200012,
-0.15918880701065063,
-0.5033782720565796,
1.0860792398452759,
-0.7636646032333374,
0.27890515327453613,
0.28404563665390015,
0.16691674292087555,
-0.2095947563648224,
-0.06511162966489792,
-0.4431734085083008,
0.16604793071746826,
0.4005413055419922,
-0.14144647121429443,
-0.15009233355522156,
-0.2688654363155365,
0.06495316326618195,
0.6359639167785645,
-0.4725054204463959,
0.8389503359794617,
-0.5146200060844421,
-0.03551476076245308,
0.5818166136741638,
0.4798135757446289,
0.4421249330043793,
-0.08142245560884476,
-0.30317971110343933,
-0.15976983308792114,
-1.372394323348999,
0.4651775360107422,
0.9127246141433716,
0.5998644828796387,
-0.21412324905395508,
0.8836368322372437,
-0.29055851697921753,
0.7562189698219299,
0.3057805299758911,
-0.2492416948080063,
0.3258378207683563,
-0.2332528978586197,
0.07256977260112762,
0.14341174066066742,
0.695441484451294,
0.7286416888237,
0.7646507620811462,
0.143315851688385,
-0.1349640041589737,
-0.040913332253694534,
-0.19973720610141754,
-0.6513624787330627,
0.36180731654167175,
0.08627806603908539,
-0.5859778523445129,
-0.28671562671661377,
-0.13599371910095215,
-1.209690809249878,
-0.7106528282165527,
-0.19758115708827972,
-0.08886164426803589,
-0.015856312587857246,
-0.2443239539861679,
0.11740458756685257,
-0.22001172602176666,
0.3249047100543976,
0.312799870967865,
-1.432395339012146,
0.061275068670511246,
0.3509516716003418,
0.5647676587104797,
-0.14513060450553894,
0.09787459671497345,
-0.44137153029441833,
0.15604719519615173,
-0.3630402386188507,
0.7450955510139465,
-0.8576686978340149,
-0.5407896637916565,
0.13426853716373444,
0.06130804494023323,
0.19727817177772522,
-0.7359179854393005,
0.24111436307430267,
-0.7788798809051514,
0.5069370269775391,
-0.2475326508283615,
-0.40234071016311646,
0.33407479524612427,
0.026914609596133232,
-0.6701831221580505,
1.2074991464614868,
0.22587822377681732,
-0.72523033618927,
0.770523726940155,
-0.32755428552627563,
-0.08442142605781555,
0.2704038918018341,
-0.2416657656431198,
-0.26654818654060364,
0.07707502692937851,
0.3788517415523529,
0.326259970664978,
-0.480898380279541,
0.4058859944343567,
-0.6268725991249084,
-0.1997198909521103,
0.36541682481765747,
-0.8280122876167297,
0.8526089787483215,
0.5570144653320312,
-0.2693960964679718,
0.11308272927999496,
-0.693305492401123,
0.04603985324501991,
0.29127946496009827,
-0.25636571645736694,
-0.5480326414108276,
-0.09583042562007904,
-0.18557944893836975,
0.33563071489334106,
0.5059556365013123,
-0.44069766998291016,
0.6300056576728821,
-0.08206579834222794,
0.5375688672065735,
0.8289363980293274,
-0.16183185577392578,
0.4938850402832031,
-0.425100713968277,
0.8008373379707336,
0.10311482846736908,
0.0015677883056923747,
-0.18438664078712463,
-0.45729491114616394,
-0.4320377707481384,
0.2377987951040268,
0.18110521137714386,
0.5295049548149109,
-0.3291909396648407,
0.5361303687095642,
-0.4704112708568573,
-0.19058512151241302,
-0.47338056564331055,
0.26944249868392944,
-0.215683251619339,
0.12054373323917389,
0.037308722734451294,
-0.05817171931266785,
-0.6227372288703918,
-0.9835635423660278,
-0.10541760176420212,
-0.6578689813613892,
-0.3045639395713806,
0.18600018322467804,
0.06630218774080276,
-0.1694267988204956,
0.886508584022522,
-0.4488270878791809,
0.21519605815410614,
-0.18964242935180664,
0.04037274420261383,
0.0849880799651146,
0.47650718688964844,
-0.004105349536985159,
-0.6722585558891296,
-0.1067829430103302,
-0.11387454718351364,
-0.4133557379245758,
-0.756632924079895,
0.03031257912516594,
0.19302049279212952,
0.1201712116599083,
0.7101423740386963,
-0.36571112275123596,
0.19125951826572418,
0.8609063029289246,
-0.618073582649231,
0.31444230675697327,
0.16023656725883484,
0.16036716103553772,
-1.0090311765670776,
0.02638239413499832,
0.4587723910808563,
0.11138932406902313,
-0.41075584292411804,
-0.44098442792892456,
0.02866516076028347,
0.0783124789595604,
-0.31404179334640503,
0.6493804454803467,
-0.7030038833618164,
0.11867091804742813,
-0.06544814258813858,
0.14512492716312408,
0.15463502705097198,
-0.30821508169174194,
-0.16756583750247955,
1.0027652978897095,
-0.04115919768810272,
-0.4302522540092468,
0.2520541250705719,
0.19138288497924805,
-0.3652121126651764,
0.9471181035041809,
-0.47649890184402466,
0.11022162437438965,
-0.3993167579174042,
0.40303897857666016,
-1.04426908493042,
-0.09556802362203598,
0.03636781871318817,
-0.5982755422592163,
0.25367212295532227,
-0.2914978861808777,
-0.1117190569639206,
-0.31579142808914185,
-0.3469734191894531,
0.7569658756256104,
0.5751442909240723,
-0.21773239970207214,
0.2672353982925415,
0.5153563618659973,
-0.8088210821151733,
-0.7670623660087585,
-0.5847698450088501,
0.19030624628067017,
-0.6585561633110046,
-0.8692072629928589,
0.37675991654396057,
-0.16021732985973358,
-0.6608695983886719,
-0.026544027030467987,
-0.06607947498559952,
0.07913072407245636,
-0.1680169403553009,
0.2749119997024536,
0.5001387596130371,
-0.34081020951271057,
0.23918527364730835,
-0.009334263391792774,
-0.026977071538567543,
-0.12663257122039795,
-0.23851150274276733,
0.871966540813446,
-0.09056311845779419,
-0.10924158245325089,
0.2703796923160553,
0.15886230766773224,
0.8310835361480713,
-0.11453478038311005,
0.8833804726600647,
0.12319699674844742,
-0.250501424074173,
-0.16496630012989044,
-0.7493671178817749,
0.2220199853181839,
-0.5105016827583313,
-0.14180000126361847,
-0.27123263478279114,
-1.3941266536712646,
0.7200191020965576,
0.17557469010353088,
-0.2873231768608093,
0.6760892271995544,
0.833477795124054,
0.28158679604530334,
1.0761332511901855,
0.6039961576461792,
-0.01666150614619255,
0.4972629249095917,
0.11677655577659607,
0.3387500047683716,
-1.0206806659698486,
-0.582640528678894,
-0.6968417167663574,
-0.21273908019065857,
-0.6324081420898438,
-0.2142592817544937,
0.07504687458276749,
0.22422772645950317,
-0.5816476941108704,
-0.2540837526321411,
-0.38595208525657654,
0.48187026381492615,
0.43449893593788147,
-0.23150667548179626,
0.29767218232154846,
-0.43029749393463135,
-0.04131055995821953,
-0.2752602696418762,
-0.7546547651290894,
-0.7495409250259399,
0.9111281633377075,
0.6539893746376038,
1.2852654457092285,
0.07945609837770462,
0.3050893545150757,
0.3226325511932373,
0.2677859365940094,
-0.6942993402481079,
0.3927270770072937,
-0.009217762388288975,
-0.890533447265625,
-0.5892356634140015,
-0.5598759651184082,
-1.3711684942245483,
0.08991759270429611,
0.07746678590774536,
-0.9593380093574524,
0.4622686505317688,
-0.21436138451099396,
-0.4833030700683594,
0.31919533014297485,
-0.5393290519714355,
0.7699412703514099,
-0.18411147594451904,
-0.5785694718360901,
0.32597920298576355,
-0.8083708882331848,
0.6232351064682007,
0.10471463203430176,
0.4048583507537842,
-0.7524930834770203,
-0.06757767498493195,
0.5274071097373962,
-0.268146812915802,
0.8869061470031738,
-0.05138170346617699,
-0.591829240322113,
0.23311519622802734,
-0.03815176337957382,
0.08675678074359894,
-0.1371733397245407,
-0.022741062566637993,
-0.19439606368541718,
0.08770507574081421,
-0.5813955664634705,
0.005491106305271387,
1.0919032096862793,
-0.6798324584960938,
-0.7692739963531494,
-0.6456719040870667,
-0.8672274351119995,
-0.36307525634765625,
0.09390495717525482,
0.14955396950244904,
0.24578475952148438,
-0.2558874487876892,
0.24270352721214294,
0.9816511869430542,
-0.7337759733200073,
0.437994122505188,
0.3382573127746582,
-0.2756901979446411,
-0.20699980854988098,
0.33973026275634766,
0.2952384650707245,
0.832551896572113,
0.3386751115322113,
0.2022036910057068,
-0.6261075735092163,
-0.13776877522468567,
-0.6679628491401672,
0.05491111800074577,
-0.8049054145812988,
-0.12431512773036957,
-0.45472657680511475,
-0.1343512088060379,
-0.7581995129585266,
-0.2406902015209198,
0.12670375406742096,
-0.19268235564231873,
0.032697271555662155,
-0.20211400091648102,
0.3587963581085205,
0.7409613728523254,
-0.04070165380835533,
-0.014499991200864315,
-0.9188777804374695,
0.12123142182826996,
0.5204668641090393,
0.40698546171188354,
0.15426714718341827,
-0.36075446009635925,
0.019743118435144424,
0.014131990261375904,
-0.2893028259277344,
-0.8738852143287659,
0.2598489820957184,
-0.09362995624542236,
0.7222048044204712,
0.36330917477607727,
-0.01909445971250534,
0.32906100153923035,
-0.3195784389972687,
1.3189375400543213,
0.07098522037267685,
-1.0652939081192017,
0.3249311149120331,
-0.6588653922080994,
0.7265177965164185,
0.5179330706596375,
0.20613111555576324,
-1.044384479522705,
-0.03933459147810936,
-0.63581383228302,
-1.0473716259002686,
0.311499685049057,
-0.3390059173107147,
0.2055179625749588,
0.07116158306598663,
-0.0646614283323288,
0.1816592514514923,
0.09423046559095383,
-0.854331910610199,
-0.0988631546497345,
0.15746209025382996,
-0.6826234459877014,
0.13989028334617615,
-0.27178066968917847,
-0.13223646581172943,
0.0356169119477272,
0.4043111503124237,
-0.22984032332897186,
0.05650615692138672,
-0.18853996694087982,
0.06397712230682373,
-0.7950546741485596,
0.7723519802093506,
0.6842806935310364,
1.0004582405090332,
-0.0777292475104332,
0.5247735977172852,
0.3624134063720703,
-0.09512168914079666,
0.8319103717803955,
-0.004839719273149967,
0.016748830676078796,
-0.4115693271160126,
0.30940672755241394,
0.611465573310852,
-0.0907917395234108,
-0.8562042713165283,
0.4290699064731598,
0.12600688636302948,
0.11923853307962418,
-0.10433828830718994,
-0.1629171073436737,
0.3368588984012604,
0.10937386751174927,
0.6164950728416443,
-0.46191301941871643,
-0.35234999656677246,
-0.7157186269760132,
-0.12081041932106018,
0.5012885928153992,
-0.2995264530181885,
-0.08672863990068436,
0.8942247629165649,
0.08152680844068527,
-0.28358790278434753,
0.4925127327442169,
0.0748935118317604,
-0.37246906757354736,
0.6123472452163696,
0.469016969203949,
0.6716984510421753,
-0.4262153208255768,
0.10534071177244186,
-0.14235712587833405,
0.4268896281719208,
-0.10211148113012314,
0.13526853919029236,
0.3941362798213959,
-0.9207183122634888,
-0.8426963686943054,
-0.33760079741477966,
-0.2750246226787567,
0.28995540738105774,
-0.6106213927268982,
0.24878835678100586,
-0.03275951370596886,
-0.2193223536014557,
-0.09588009119033813,
-0.20381225645542145,
-0.816217839717865,
0.41080835461616516,
0.4618149995803833,
0.7541098594665527,
-1.1726807355880737,
0.603611171245575,
0.343814879655838,
-0.35201001167297363,
-0.5480194091796875,
-0.03960949927568436,
0.38746172189712524,
-1.0042909383773804,
1.0471194982528687,
0.2243007868528366,
-0.06935649365186691,
-0.315962553024292,
-0.6029000282287598,
-0.9495766162872314,
0.8465501070022583,
0.024671152234077454,
-0.6339119672775269,
-0.24885529279708862,
0.23993347585201263,
0.39880192279815674,
-0.44637712836265564,
0.0730414092540741,
0.6126570105552673,
0.5029136538505554,
0.08582769334316254,
-0.8441184759140015,
-0.09089962393045425,
-0.4139755964279175,
0.2306167632341385,
0.5642421841621399,
-0.7784202694892883,
0.7401132583618164,
0.003995611798018217,
-0.08850101381540298,
0.02308010123670101,
0.4918502867221832,
0.5214705467224121,
0.6329488754272461,
0.6231111288070679,
0.6391664147377014,
0.5116395950317383,
-0.21532104909420013,
0.6656146049499512,
-0.2766413986682892,
0.026827961206436157,
0.5523145794868469,
-0.28599411249160767,
0.30458518862724304,
0.5914878845214844,
-0.4782273471355438,
0.41664111614227295,
0.9918456077575684,
0.05525384098291397,
0.15257589519023895,
0.5177145600318909,
-0.32964658737182617,
-0.03390061855316162,
-0.35899826884269714,
-0.6676322221755981,
-0.06367994844913483,
0.5683532953262329,
-0.36258792877197266,
0.1316908746957779,
-0.28439125418663025,
0.393710196018219,
-0.027121301740407944,
-0.32820194959640503,
0.5765905976295471,
0.33555492758750916,
-0.604767918586731,
0.41998451948165894,
-0.20276212692260742,
0.9104101061820984,
-0.7693036794662476,
0.20007431507110596,
-0.263013631105423,
0.004369067028164864,
-0.18214334547519684,
-0.9040207862854004,
-0.16761305928230286,
0.0595199353992939,
-0.36045628786087036,
-0.329100102186203,
0.6458317637443542,
-0.6800808906555176,
-0.4298548698425293,
0.010710266418755054,
0.7675154805183411,
-0.23469266295433044,
0.4605357050895691,
-0.39417678117752075,
0.4068973958492279,
-0.10240579396486282,
-0.11995352059602737,
0.3958926498889923,
0.8127533793449402,
-0.3114619851112366,
0.7894676327705383,
0.35791635513305664,
0.2509932518005371,
0.30959007143974304,
0.13873913884162903,
0.47966161370277405,
-0.7868176698684692,
-0.34285464882850647,
-1.036814570426941,
0.7181872129440308,
-0.15793772041797638,
-0.8669376373291016,
0.9425320029258728,
0.49812808632850647,
0.8169701099395752,
0.2575245499610901,
0.9542092084884644,
-0.0028434263076633215,
0.39668339490890503,
-0.6683909893035889,
0.20780770480632782,
-0.3168540894985199,
0.4405689835548401,
-0.4586600959300995,
-1.0841739177703857,
-0.14090116322040558,
0.3320842981338501,
-0.5199995040893555,
0.33120185136795044,
0.3467985987663269,
0.6781337261199951,
0.4020782709121704,
-0.13559888303279877,
0.19755764305591583,
-0.4169170558452606,
0.6655266880989075,
0.6835870146751404,
1.4019914865493774,
-0.021646147593855858,
0.13024519383907318,
0.2940683960914612,
-0.13876183331012726,
-0.3335842192173004,
-1.069173812866211,
-0.44521981477737427,
-0.26898419857025146,
-0.06682373583316803,
-0.6299934983253479,
0.037231843918561935,
1.0635085105895996,
0.41355982422828674,
-0.8169548511505127,
-0.37236493825912476,
0.3322203457355499,
-0.11840888112783432,
-0.04109157621860504,
-0.2959529459476471,
0.04594874382019043,
-0.20891481637954712,
-0.9242793321609497,
0.35262104868888855,
0.15475015342235565,
0.5188502073287964,
-0.6728981137275696,
0.04790719226002693,
0.0343007892370224,
0.24264061450958252,
0.26943105459213257,
0.2073443979024887,
-0.687235414981842,
-0.5523567199707031,
0.2504841685295105,
-0.2687217891216278,
0.21392913162708282,
1.0050175189971924,
-0.42719072103500366,
0.38191330432891846,
0.5675378441810608,
0.6780514717102051,
0.36187320947647095,
0.1744709312915802,
0.8687999844551086,
-0.4422369599342346,
0.06768959015607834,
0.30922144651412964,
0.27810928225517273,
0.8300843238830566,
-0.41445693373680115,
0.39442506432533264,
0.2612916827201843,
-0.9303562045097351,
-0.8171524405479431,
0.39179179072380066,
-0.8603885769844055,
-0.37111279368400574,
1.208534836769104,
0.326666921377182,
0.3277246952056885,
-0.2640652060508728,
-0.0842432826757431,
0.10604707896709442,
-0.36922770738601685,
0.8876569271087646,
1.2099052667617798,
0.05449092388153076,
-0.42054468393325806,
-0.612250566482544,
0.25753360986709595,
0.5451443195343018,
-0.8566694259643555,
0.07702837139368057,
0.7713316082954407,
0.20016790926456451,
-0.1459018886089325,
0.35043275356292725,
-0.3308078646659851,
-0.3365512788295746,
-0.031571511179208755,
0.06355097144842148,
0.30544355511665344,
-0.03160601481795311,
-0.6631925702095032,
0.2306661307811737,
0.5257613658905029,
0.19232702255249023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08634v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08634v1
|
Pre-training Small Base LMs with Fewer Tokens
| 2024-04-12T17:53:34 | 2024-04-12T17:53:34 |
Sunny Sanyal, Sujay Sanghavi, Alexandros G. Dimakis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We study the effectiveness of a simple approach to develop a small base
language model (LM) starting from an existing large base LM: first inherit a
few transformer blocks from the larger LM, and then train this smaller model on
a very small subset (0.1\%) of the raw pretraining data of the larger model. We
call our simple recipe Inheritune and first demonstrate it for building a small
base LM with 1.5B parameters using 1B tokens (and a starting few layers of
larger LM of 3B parameters); we do this using a single A6000 GPU for less than
half a day. Across 9 diverse evaluation datasets as well as the MMLU benchmark,
the resulting model compares favorably to publicly available base models of
1B-2B size, some of which have been trained using 50-1000 times more tokens.
We investigate Inheritune in a slightly different setting where we train
small LMs utilizing larger LMs and their full pre-training dataset. Here we
show that smaller LMs trained utilizing some of the layers of GPT2-medium
(355M) and GPT-2-large (770M) can effectively match the val loss of their
bigger counterparts when trained from scratch for the same number of training
steps on OpenWebText dataset with 9B tokens. We analyze our recipe with
extensive experiments and demonstrate it efficacy on diverse settings. Our code
is available at https://github.com/sanyalsunny111/LLM-Inheritune.
|
[
-0.5052308440208435,
-0.4923972189426422,
0.2766537070274353,
-0.002129671396687627,
-0.46673107147216797,
-0.08724016696214676,
-0.27445778250694275,
-0.31886616349220276,
0.21162676811218262,
0.3331916332244873,
-0.5124344229698181,
-0.0911054015159607,
-0.6137139797210693,
-0.20129717886447906,
-0.06822168081998825,
0.884423553943634,
0.02423793077468872,
0.27532774209976196,
0.10074537992477417,
-0.1636628955602646,
-0.43187427520751953,
-0.2790474593639374,
-0.9402080774307251,
-0.5119112730026245,
0.5497757196426392,
0.6250609159469604,
0.3906925916671753,
0.8069056272506714,
0.24660035967826843,
0.10841100662946701,
-0.2590787410736084,
0.12069056183099747,
-0.725595235824585,
-0.573226809501648,
0.19239354133605957,
-0.6684198379516602,
-0.30852484703063965,
-0.19827239215373993,
0.7309868335723877,
0.8384789228439331,
0.09108588099479675,
0.3650747239589691,
0.2517389953136444,
0.845705509185791,
-0.6241979002952576,
-0.04238484799861908,
-0.7081496715545654,
0.1505461484193802,
-0.2530531585216522,
0.08842812478542328,
-0.6753441691398621,
-0.17552347481250763,
-0.07586522400379181,
-0.3459186255931854,
0.16002732515335083,
0.2626427710056305,
0.60257887840271,
0.05006510019302368,
-0.38563409447669983,
0.04583894833922386,
-0.7213476300239563,
0.6725691556930542,
-0.615774929523468,
0.49748697876930237,
0.18256206810474396,
0.21615056693553925,
-0.007802055217325687,
-0.8000872731208801,
-0.41718751192092896,
-0.24893343448638916,
-0.18525762856006622,
-0.032516319304704666,
-0.32241979241371155,
-0.11681751161813736,
0.4857717454433441,
0.38074585795402527,
-0.6652572154998779,
0.3746813237667084,
-0.4103722870349884,
-0.1230267882347107,
-0.051944151520729065,
0.18365634977817535,
0.0691383108496666,
-0.028177181258797646,
-0.4072551131248474,
-0.04744541272521019,
-1.367859125137329,
-0.10096937417984009,
0.2995387613773346,
0.5477226376533508,
-0.3062635362148285,
0.360312819480896,
-0.09232370555400848,
0.46585169434547424,
0.32291179895401,
-0.12176220118999481,
0.21048757433891296,
-0.5280212163925171,
-0.4220912754535675,
0.14563007652759552,
0.5895415544509888,
0.02608637511730194,
0.22469696402549744,
-0.10046407580375671,
-0.09041326493024826,
-0.058945491909980774,
0.07098378986120224,
-1.198042392730713,
-0.5039236545562744,
-0.22008545696735382,
-0.6269749999046326,
-0.18836060166358948,
-0.14022131264209747,
-0.2661142647266388,
-0.3781373202800751,
-0.4604221284389496,
0.5245881080627441,
-0.4669846296310425,
-0.1729152351617813,
-0.196676105260849,
0.045069750398397446,
0.5486459136009216,
0.3191731870174408,
-1.2440192699432373,
0.6233368515968323,
0.678956925868988,
0.8956596851348877,
-0.2510964572429657,
-0.175186425447464,
-0.8549027442932129,
-0.08238264918327332,
-0.35635775327682495,
0.43536049127578735,
-0.1561848670244217,
-0.5813062191009521,
-0.35724639892578125,
-0.05629158765077591,
-0.13500790297985077,
-0.7078360319137573,
0.36342480778694153,
-0.36371245980262756,
0.09074859321117401,
-0.3375590145587921,
-0.4539700150489807,
0.22424748539924622,
0.022166768088936806,
-0.8929715752601624,
0.9814969897270203,
0.168282613158226,
-0.6309030652046204,
0.5466387867927551,
-0.5256741046905518,
-0.571264922618866,
-0.050245169550180435,
-0.17397160828113556,
-0.4281698167324066,
0.45646461844444275,
0.2443816214799881,
0.09837473183870316,
-0.2950851023197174,
-0.6668659448623657,
-0.18926416337490082,
-0.5840063095092773,
-0.4069080352783203,
-0.42356276512145996,
0.639157772064209,
0.21689188480377197,
-0.46209460496902466,
0.06977098435163498,
-0.6838270425796509,
0.14413130283355713,
0.12435464560985565,
-0.2951889634132385,
-0.3857237994670868,
-0.39599844813346863,
0.08747172355651855,
0.07018055021762848,
-0.032860562205314636,
-0.3218100368976593,
0.30694064497947693,
-0.6497663259506226,
0.22526846826076508,
0.7608567476272583,
-0.151632621884346,
0.9635549783706665,
-0.33762848377227783,
0.39926210045814514,
0.1312597543001175,
0.14843270182609558,
-0.1283942610025406,
-0.43473511934280396,
-1.0621974468231201,
-0.3759947717189789,
0.5600683689117432,
0.21385730803012848,
-0.49487295746803284,
0.4733411967754364,
-0.49559125304222107,
-0.4395082890987396,
-0.6407337784767151,
0.3735300898551941,
0.3826504349708557,
0.3267108201980591,
0.30826690793037415,
-0.3918399214744568,
-0.8405161499977112,
-1.0887879133224487,
-0.07908781617879868,
0.11195892840623856,
-0.010488188825547695,
0.21524576842784882,
0.5860430598258972,
-0.34472256898880005,
1.021801471710205,
-0.23151810467243195,
-0.1219320073723793,
-0.633729100227356,
0.06563602387905121,
0.17393232882022858,
0.7151607871055603,
0.742307722568512,
-0.5589299201965332,
-0.6974239349365234,
0.1177610233426094,
-0.27461710572242737,
0.15510907769203186,
0.15975818037986755,
-0.16585493087768555,
0.17718826234340668,
0.24158060550689697,
-0.5956762433052063,
0.31176164746284485,
0.4829936921596527,
-0.07104498147964478,
0.5078179836273193,
-0.00643108831718564,
-0.21915173530578613,
-1.3309111595153809,
0.043859343975782394,
-0.2899739444255829,
-0.4691896438598633,
-0.6617813110351562,
-0.14369140565395355,
0.12822826206684113,
-0.025293894112110138,
-0.6255477666854858,
0.7162349820137024,
-0.5630594491958618,
-0.11573705077171326,
-0.4449174702167511,
-0.4131765365600586,
-0.22734570503234863,
0.5163186192512512,
-0.010900168679654598,
0.7043763995170593,
0.3283706307411194,
-0.4561828672885895,
0.013665162026882172,
-0.0469026193022728,
-0.30501502752304077,
0.23360185325145721,
-0.6744602918624878,
0.35112783312797546,
-0.03343215957283974,
0.23321059346199036,
-0.7837728261947632,
0.10400369763374329,
0.4023016691207886,
-0.08317071944475174,
0.414234459400177,
-0.5132383704185486,
-0.48368316888809204,
-0.28994545340538025,
-0.39564067125320435,
0.2706746459007263,
0.9042546153068542,
-0.919540524482727,
0.5978713631629944,
-0.005667973775416613,
-0.15854981541633606,
-0.4699349105358124,
-0.7700541615486145,
-0.05970622971653938,
-0.31058835983276367,
-0.36752793192863464,
0.1542774736881256,
-0.3306612968444824,
-0.01438529696315527,
0.08046792447566986,
-0.21713584661483765,
0.1415310949087143,
0.16754330694675446,
0.4039314389228821,
0.06168900057673454,
-0.6401155591011047,
-0.022170372307300568,
0.046736009418964386,
-0.21127068996429443,
-0.14406804740428925,
-0.6260392665863037,
0.8161548376083374,
-0.630719006061554,
-0.46180808544158936,
-0.20301444828510284,
-0.04378918185830116,
0.3210682272911072,
0.07900815457105637,
0.9176061153411865,
0.538179337978363,
-0.4790022671222687,
-0.42231690883636475,
-0.3301723301410675,
-0.24365152418613434,
-0.45819100737571716,
0.28365811705589294,
-0.5172852277755737,
-0.7408997416496277,
0.5013715028762817,
-0.11173440515995026,
-0.07818236947059631,
0.5366032123565674,
0.7058835029602051,
0.05076546221971512,
0.6897214651107788,
0.6613119840621948,
-0.4772178530693054,
0.5930460691452026,
-0.4654609262943268,
-0.21269381046295166,
-0.6494237780570984,
0.10239537060260773,
-0.23967011272907257,
-0.3698738217353821,
-0.45936471223831177,
-0.6237606406211853,
0.07553502917289734,
0.28425273299217224,
-0.29617950320243835,
0.37948721647262573,
-0.2077995240688324,
0.7628016471862793,
0.698062002658844,
0.2961418628692627,
0.3394160866737366,
0.19573232531547546,
-0.1271667182445526,
0.0016094293678179383,
-0.9968742728233337,
-0.49751895666122437,
1.2971394062042236,
0.532783567905426,
0.9561395049095154,
-0.03163285553455353,
0.9701203107833862,
0.22066563367843628,
0.7453705072402954,
-0.7890974879264832,
0.28809526562690735,
-0.22603899240493774,
-0.4718761444091797,
-0.32350587844848633,
-0.6818206906318665,
-0.7430077195167542,
0.4411223828792572,
-0.2035726010799408,
-0.32143208384513855,
-0.09253906458616257,
0.4596640169620514,
-0.25667116045951843,
0.48998787999153137,
-0.9917905926704407,
1.0336546897888184,
-0.4934878647327423,
-0.2942935824394226,
0.02741275541484356,
-0.7037138342857361,
0.29419830441474915,
-0.24265949428081512,
0.15398402512073517,
0.16458596289157867,
0.21695372462272644,
0.7124091982841492,
-0.6969809532165527,
0.8987014889717102,
-0.3409937024116516,
0.10217192023992538,
0.17678256332874298,
-0.18637415766716003,
0.6456321477890015,
-0.05827314034104347,
0.1456187665462494,
-0.06405758857727051,
-0.25765591859817505,
-0.5188760161399841,
-0.5381426215171814,
0.6155345439910889,
-0.8097088932991028,
-0.2602819800376892,
-0.04449760168790817,
0.06498005241155624,
-0.1158667728304863,
0.5049965977668762,
0.615173876285553,
0.31352558732032776,
-0.406739205121994,
0.5863617658615112,
0.6260131597518921,
0.22073061764240265,
0.3569988012313843,
0.29661762714385986,
-0.0804409608244896,
-0.30823662877082825,
0.6837209463119507,
-0.11867637932300568,
0.38429155945777893,
0.44577568769454956,
0.5559709072113037,
0.0019290269119665027,
-0.6444365978240967,
-0.694318413734436,
0.09379807859659195,
-0.6654215455055237,
-0.17532417178153992,
-0.23595035076141357,
-0.15206380188465118,
-0.15696591138839722,
0.17462781071662903,
-0.7426156401634216,
-0.3701917827129364,
-0.18132804334163666,
-0.16298887133598328,
0.13485564291477203,
0.6800097227096558,
0.04509998485445976,
0.7640013098716736,
-0.6793685555458069,
0.13176146149635315,
0.22828570008277893,
0.4574088156223297,
0.18381567299365997,
-0.7680574059486389,
-0.46036767959594727,
0.2844398021697998,
0.025141561403870583,
-0.3467566967010498,
0.09163269400596619,
0.2762598395347595,
0.7437071204185486,
0.4936313331127167,
-0.2488861382007599,
0.612151026725769,
-0.8332429528236389,
0.533755362033844,
0.4635756313800812,
-0.8730361461639404,
0.5290714502334595,
-0.04184374213218689,
0.3079344630241394,
0.8031166195869446,
0.411085844039917,
-0.2852056920528412,
0.013281814754009247,
-0.6190111041069031,
-0.6009708642959595,
0.6289956569671631,
0.25592926144599915,
0.13261742889881134,
0.3114466369152069,
0.3596900701522827,
0.4781540632247925,
-0.02099999040365219,
-1.0358678102493286,
-0.5399647951126099,
-0.06863300502300262,
-0.24582991003990173,
-0.19459137320518494,
-0.27271395921707153,
-0.2297828495502472,
-0.3039456307888031,
0.546151340007782,
-0.09068700671195984,
0.31111615896224976,
-0.3493535816669464,
-0.4816415309906006,
-0.11780806630849838,
0.16103722155094147,
0.5985129475593567,
0.5161200761795044,
-0.23920182883739471,
0.32587891817092896,
0.5597237944602966,
-0.5141087770462036,
0.15069933235645294,
-0.073883056640625,
-0.10101833194494247,
-0.04241206496953964,
0.44345998764038086,
1.2589342594146729,
0.30791106820106506,
-0.21853291988372803,
0.433102548122406,
-0.10192485898733139,
-0.23122954368591309,
-0.12491361796855927,
-0.014106766320765018,
0.3534240424633026,
0.08160240203142166,
0.31252554059028625,
0.047082796692848206,
-0.19573919475078583,
-0.5799445509910583,
0.32994988560676575,
0.35577377676963806,
-0.2032337486743927,
-0.32127615809440613,
0.5202579498291016,
0.17917358875274658,
-0.1092320904135704,
0.5332470536231995,
-0.16198977828025818,
-0.3134560286998749,
0.5768066048622131,
0.7275322675704956,
0.7762214541435242,
0.11823375523090363,
-0.17538441717624664,
-0.02576659992337227,
0.6863412261009216,
-0.27663281559944153,
-0.10515318065881729,
-0.03478359803557396,
-0.7487056255340576,
-0.21935109794139862,
-0.6253530383110046,
-0.5064610838890076,
0.29969510436058044,
-0.45250818133354187,
0.2858465611934662,
-0.6496847867965698,
0.04351652413606644,
-0.05090542137622833,
0.012759174220263958,
-0.9112973213195801,
0.22079581022262573,
0.4780881404876709,
0.9209212064743042,
-0.980666995048523,
1.006187915802002,
0.6470717787742615,
-0.42230361700057983,
-0.8908489346504211,
-0.10165493935346603,
-0.2716454863548279,
-0.9177117943763733,
1.0272451639175415,
0.1412280648946762,
-0.16436561942100525,
-0.02695087343454361,
-0.39709463715553284,
-0.6628199219703674,
1.0268440246582031,
0.39668720960617065,
-0.6142305731773376,
-0.06783221662044525,
0.24388979375362396,
0.46920692920684814,
-0.48722028732299805,
0.1098485216498375,
0.5735167860984802,
0.25717654824256897,
0.18817155063152313,
-0.8962511420249939,
0.07996934652328491,
-0.13977058231830597,
-0.12907107174396515,
0.2693741023540497,
-0.4586917757987976,
0.8112537860870361,
-0.23802249133586884,
-0.180734321475029,
0.2753542959690094,
0.5636785626411438,
0.1793709695339203,
0.2738342583179474,
0.6761555075645447,
0.6772094368934631,
0.5586004853248596,
-0.03336004540324211,
0.9154295325279236,
-0.2830932140350342,
0.38666489720344543,
1.2754895687103271,
-0.13418272137641907,
0.8424587845802307,
0.4300537705421448,
-0.262989342212677,
0.3266861140727997,
0.5840493440628052,
0.07567136734724045,
0.6039389371871948,
0.4465590715408325,
-0.15825894474983215,
-0.03543046861886978,
0.4559640884399414,
-0.6133673787117004,
0.19008587300777435,
0.1501331627368927,
-0.4403814971446991,
-0.1562209576368332,
0.17343847453594208,
-0.019941560924053192,
-0.47702792286872864,
-0.5591551661491394,
0.7367293834686279,
0.3219898045063019,
-0.23901872336864471,
0.5769968628883362,
-0.00038125336868688464,
0.6528525948524475,
-0.8226815462112427,
0.3132373094558716,
-0.5872081518173218,
0.29806533455848694,
-0.1314990073442459,
-0.15163801610469818,
0.06095775216817856,
-0.07585377991199493,
-0.2332613319158554,
-0.2630540430545807,
0.8636807203292847,
-0.228244811296463,
-0.5387035608291626,
0.03146497532725334,
0.6400234699249268,
-0.016097407788038254,
-0.09417937695980072,
-0.34594011306762695,
-0.07941969484090805,
-0.1648174375295639,
-0.4206911325454712,
0.5708450675010681,
0.2593350410461426,
-0.11632852256298065,
0.3988865315914154,
0.5990781784057617,
0.3117578327655792,
0.27090564370155334,
0.26221778988838196,
1.0386520624160767,
-0.5086456537246704,
-0.49390026926994324,
-0.9561945199966431,
0.15111510455608368,
0.026040805503726006,
-0.24364614486694336,
0.8417598605155945,
0.9932151436805725,
0.8103731274604797,
-0.4360389709472656,
0.7847538590431213,
0.1733350157737732,
0.3522857129573822,
-0.639474630355835,
0.5617239475250244,
-0.49901410937309265,
0.3384263217449188,
-0.14908237755298615,
-1.2207976579666138,
-0.12645594775676727,
0.5827831029891968,
-0.2211971879005432,
0.2755418121814728,
0.5943289995193481,
0.5274229049682617,
-0.3699856698513031,
-0.13879191875457764,
0.22046583890914917,
-0.06177894398570061,
0.18298277258872986,
0.6343492865562439,
1.0165547132492065,
-0.34898677468299866,
0.5868895053863525,
-0.286628395318985,
-0.31027257442474365,
-0.48136386275291443,
-0.8434293270111084,
-0.9199856519699097,
0.11801056563854218,
0.0847291350364685,
-0.1267736852169037,
0.16800935566425323,
1.1186975240707397,
0.9527803063392639,
-0.7927130460739136,
-0.20118971168994904,
-0.15436550974845886,
-0.023209286853671074,
-0.17398308217525482,
-0.11423001438379288,
0.3357231020927429,
-0.06900472939014435,
-0.5504879355430603,
0.38562512397766113,
0.029645757749676704,
0.21064309775829315,
0.04249203950166702,
-0.3993043303489685,
0.1680627018213272,
-0.23201972246170044,
0.8095030188560486,
0.3728961646556854,
-0.4105202853679657,
-0.4623299241065979,
-0.036835700273513794,
-0.3151848316192627,
0.09318646788597107,
0.9817646741867065,
-0.6263256669044495,
0.15834251046180725,
0.43006008863449097,
0.8097215294837952,
0.8761603832244873,
0.057750850915908813,
0.49140337109565735,
-1.1606438159942627,
0.17567892372608185,
0.08109186589717865,
0.4528804421424866,
0.13846942782402039,
-0.05344061926007271,
0.5407541394233704,
0.4649459719657898,
-0.13521741330623627,
-0.7207075953483582,
0.29045891761779785,
-1.0856250524520874,
-0.24115398526191711,
1.0528665781021118,
0.23800991475582123,
0.10719820857048035,
0.44209179282188416,
-0.267987459897995,
0.06724143028259277,
-0.10063182562589645,
0.31882867217063904,
0.4497424364089966,
-0.11134926229715347,
-0.25378096103668213,
-0.39132145047187805,
0.6196300983428955,
0.5522119402885437,
-0.8317698836326599,
0.08720756322145462,
0.1799122840166092,
0.542494535446167,
-0.004155039321631193,
0.8577666878700256,
0.05206616595387459,
0.32937759160995483,
0.3497636318206787,
0.019097188487648964,
-0.25019678473472595,
-0.32229822874069214,
-0.3880617916584015,
0.014790862798690796,
0.43146803975105286,
-0.31946197152137756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08627v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08627v1
|
Is ChatGPT Transforming Academics' Writing Style?
| 2024-04-12T17:41:05 | 2024-04-12T17:41:05 |
Mingmeng Geng, Roberto Trotta
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DL, cs.LG
|
Based on one million arXiv papers submitted from May 2018 to January 2024, we
assess the textual density of ChatGPT's writing style in their abstracts by
means of a statistical analysis of word frequency changes. Our model is
calibrated and validated on a mixture of real abstracts and ChatGPT-modified
abstracts (simulated data) after a careful noise analysis. We find that ChatGPT
is having an increasing impact on arXiv abstracts, especially in the field of
computer science, where the fraction of ChatGPT-revised abstracts is estimated
to be approximately 35%, if we take the output of one of the simplest prompts,
"revise the following sentences", as a baseline. We conclude with an analysis
of both positive and negative aspects of the penetration of ChatGPT into
academics' writing style.
|
[
-0.36288148164749146,
-0.8296476006507874,
0.3382445275783539,
0.23462530970573425,
-0.24929040670394897,
0.18230818212032318,
-0.1727503389120102,
-0.4682396650314331,
0.37167707085609436,
0.34816738963127136,
-0.35888680815696716,
-0.3546094000339508,
-0.8801495432853699,
0.3857526481151581,
-0.7896700501441956,
1.6127841472625732,
0.040675677359104156,
0.03071882762014866,
-0.10422959178686142,
0.041237667202949524,
0.001855239039286971,
-0.40896889567375183,
-0.8647252917289734,
-0.25305160880088806,
0.723200261592865,
0.2643113434314728,
0.5199006795883179,
0.436440646648407,
0.7424298524856567,
0.20032313466072083,
-0.07324408739805222,
-0.3185572326183319,
-0.551030695438385,
0.11570856720209122,
0.14356309175491333,
-0.4243234395980835,
-0.5836310982704163,
0.03583725169301033,
0.8783276677131653,
0.6789364218711853,
-0.24569293856620789,
0.08124320954084396,
0.3382774889469147,
0.9236065745353699,
-0.24774420261383057,
0.19334471225738525,
-0.6185798645019531,
-0.09806463122367859,
-0.3433663249015808,
-0.520855724811554,
-0.5983216166496277,
-0.3694763481616974,
0.35772809386253357,
-0.39144712686538696,
0.37390148639678955,
0.36747387051582336,
0.5781898498535156,
-0.08653531968593597,
-0.25285351276397705,
-0.13525617122650146,
-0.6298884749412537,
0.4372537136077881,
-0.48502570390701294,
0.22568482160568237,
-0.2004484385251999,
0.04421701654791832,
-0.4216527044773102,
-0.9150604009628296,
-0.6091347932815552,
-0.06075180321931839,
0.03996216505765915,
0.22349241375923157,
-0.4486589729785919,
-0.037334758788347244,
0.07192743569612503,
0.2595917284488678,
-0.5680513978004456,
-0.4814985394477844,
-0.8165151476860046,
0.14660349488258362,
0.5823870301246643,
-0.01850072294473648,
0.6132378578186035,
0.3561374247074127,
-0.07640711963176727,
-0.31803661584854126,
-0.6848176121711731,
-0.14789073169231415,
0.45182564854621887,
0.19704601168632507,
0.14617712795734406,
0.4785861372947693,
-0.05191252753138542,
0.4364398419857025,
-0.21732962131500244,
0.016771569848060608,
0.021219585090875626,
-0.32826271653175354,
0.06000960245728493,
0.40773144364356995,
0.8905128836631775,
0.5836033821105957,
0.38497069478034973,
-0.0030892016366124153,
-0.0372270792722702,
-0.19180187582969666,
0.48640015721321106,
-0.8536010980606079,
-0.730165421962738,
-0.08534843474626541,
-0.5277361273765564,
-0.49970510601997375,
-0.0017341176280751824,
-0.8621875047683716,
-0.66303551197052,
-0.0879727378487587,
0.2275044322013855,
-0.7182309627532959,
-0.2495262771844864,
0.10611078143119812,
-0.22742781043052673,
0.3031848967075348,
0.4948744475841522,
-0.8439847230911255,
0.3725099563598633,
0.7987788319587708,
1.1353617906570435,
-0.3982102572917938,
-0.28040727972984314,
-0.15252315998077393,
-0.3650377690792084,
-0.27708590030670166,
1.4527530670166016,
-0.5858173370361328,
-0.8664367198944092,
-0.07176383584737778,
-0.2711915969848633,
-0.30495738983154297,
0.06522589921951294,
0.6058058142662048,
-0.3343521058559418,
0.38722190260887146,
-0.1787552386522293,
-0.15498994290828705,
-0.07550139725208282,
0.14274685084819794,
-0.3033224642276764,
0.8558048009872437,
0.09411577880382538,
-0.6937460899353027,
0.4824689030647278,
-0.9253369569778442,
-0.39913520216941833,
0.014617916196584702,
0.29849907755851746,
-0.6891725063323975,
-0.3133990466594696,
-0.00015729962615296245,
0.1540863960981369,
0.25032737851142883,
-0.09401394426822662,
-0.023741796612739563,
-0.4724794328212738,
0.5822473764419556,
-0.40163615345954895,
0.406771719455719,
0.31413063406944275,
0.08268934488296509,
-0.12105400115251541,
-0.881445586681366,
-0.04912121221423149,
-0.3532770872116089,
-0.2881394922733307,
-0.18994680047035217,
0.21608635783195496,
0.24682629108428955,
-0.06573695689439774,
0.007140817120671272,
-0.6669238209724426,
0.5911177396774292,
-0.3460260033607483,
0.7025360465049744,
0.6309849619865417,
0.4842148721218109,
0.30371803045272827,
-0.6515663266181946,
0.6179289221763611,
-0.5263893008232117,
0.019401537254452705,
-0.08971408009529114,
-0.7986688017845154,
-0.5396152138710022,
-0.18475645780563354,
0.3499102294445038,
0.44470682740211487,
0.004037405364215374,
-0.11748085916042328,
-0.2224075198173523,
-0.8502073287963867,
-0.3034571707248688,
-0.518459141254425,
0.026846174150705338,
0.5536991953849792,
0.5257174372673035,
-0.4088982939720154,
-0.48536887764930725,
-0.5972417593002319,
-0.721260130405426,
-0.3137092590332031,
0.1780426949262619,
-0.08904176950454712,
0.6742058992385864,
-0.17815007269382477,
0.5748908519744873,
-0.31510090827941895,
-0.05855220556259155,
-0.1316555142402649,
0.7828729152679443,
-0.021554188802838326,
0.5135183334350586,
0.2708214819431305,
-0.6186699271202087,
-0.8819050788879395,
-0.0063965655863285065,
-0.09032128006219864,
-0.4428688585758209,
-0.4209069609642029,
-0.04671908915042877,
0.1476881206035614,
0.7624964714050293,
-0.2077893167734146,
0.50046306848526,
0.43813443183898926,
-0.49858948588371277,
1.0098052024841309,
0.018658751621842384,
0.6326566934585571,
-0.6818552017211914,
0.005128439515829086,
0.1573602706193924,
0.1889035701751709,
-0.5825681686401367,
-0.17479553818702698,
-0.11029265820980072,
-0.32180240750312805,
-0.10977516323328018,
0.3929533064365387,
-0.3812893331050873,
0.283580482006073,
-0.2796095311641693,
0.18057166039943695,
0.016837887465953827,
0.13568587601184845,
-0.13289152085781097,
1.3509522676467896,
0.3461170494556427,
-0.3984294533729553,
-0.09197253733873367,
0.40284737944602966,
-0.47069546580314636,
0.5590763092041016,
-0.822026789188385,
0.08601019531488419,
-0.10986660420894623,
0.4314972162246704,
-1.4349654912948608,
-0.09332717955112457,
0.2124808132648468,
-0.6313962340354919,
0.23526597023010254,
-0.41827690601348877,
-0.39298999309539795,
0.18449513614177704,
-0.3492477834224701,
0.0802573561668396,
0.6456363201141357,
0.015340344980359077,
0.6077543497085571,
0.011963417753577232,
-0.7802956104278564,
-0.46845632791519165,
-0.5808094143867493,
0.6228114366531372,
-0.04270832985639572,
-0.7481846809387207,
0.4940546452999115,
-0.08850956708192825,
-0.6893566846847534,
-0.04896537587046623,
0.04636571556329727,
-0.016804251819849014,
-0.11957862228155136,
0.01871035061776638,
0.2990623712539673,
-0.10521063953638077,
0.13363465666770935,
0.15549783408641815,
0.2097504734992981,
0.23725102841854095,
-0.14746329188346863,
0.7988242506980896,
-0.3616780638694763,
-0.14024674892425537,
-0.41673657298088074,
0.27408307790756226,
0.45367658138275146,
-0.3691646456718445,
0.7868736386299133,
0.5562843680381775,
0.41648468375205994,
0.05095531418919563,
-0.3901967704296112,
-0.18610768020153046,
-0.4629480242729187,
0.5014785528182983,
-0.04371493309736252,
-0.5005952715873718,
0.4825805723667145,
0.003649796824902296,
0.2794857621192932,
0.6039695739746094,
0.35283735394477844,
-0.1748349964618683,
0.8389188647270203,
0.7393389940261841,
0.4200255572795868,
0.7964025735855103,
-0.018846267834305763,
0.3030475676059723,
-0.826819658279419,
-0.25553056597709656,
-0.6990600228309631,
-0.32337674498558044,
-0.7352518439292908,
0.12682215869426727,
0.5608399510383606,
-0.4046168327331543,
0.0026183754671365023,
0.1549142599105835,
-0.9911984801292419,
0.536675751209259,
0.3694055378437042,
-0.05312618240714073,
0.2714630365371704,
0.1427304446697235,
0.44013312458992004,
-0.15857096016407013,
-0.46376070380210876,
-0.6803892850875854,
1.2146289348602295,
0.14765910804271698,
0.6106926798820496,
0.11466103047132492,
0.6686640977859497,
0.5449443459510803,
0.3721597194671631,
-0.7974292039871216,
0.5895615220069885,
-0.05229873210191727,
-0.09878779947757721,
-0.2704950273036957,
-0.008879439905285835,
-1.0976365804672241,
0.17767752707004547,
-0.3961327075958252,
-0.6304511427879333,
0.2607389986515045,
-0.005555172450840473,
-0.14194345474243164,
0.40570148825645447,
-0.7255905866622925,
0.43649548292160034,
0.4167994260787964,
-0.26260513067245483,
-0.1463388204574585,
-0.46011078357696533,
0.09993133693933487,
-0.0020706825889647007,
0.056113824248313904,
-0.18469537794589996,
-0.03598014637827873,
1.167393445968628,
-0.36600440740585327,
0.7768387198448181,
0.229020893573761,
-0.049636270850896835,
0.3691805303096771,
0.3900867700576782,
0.5791642665863037,
0.1185082197189331,
-0.20538699626922607,
0.04416721686720848,
0.45633289217948914,
-0.3783406615257263,
-0.5127110481262207,
0.5541266798973083,
-0.7122891545295715,
-0.4458611309528351,
-0.921070396900177,
-0.4526907503604889,
-0.13843144476413727,
0.21538272500038147,
0.44655174016952515,
0.7348684072494507,
-0.4623492658138275,
0.1901017278432846,
0.7069752812385559,
0.0695694088935852,
0.28672707080841064,
0.28154996037483215,
-0.09933796525001526,
-0.1454572230577469,
0.7349020838737488,
0.38313284516334534,
0.3158414661884308,
0.20817190408706665,
0.20089758932590485,
0.010755212046205997,
-0.8112872242927551,
-0.29409825801849365,
0.0933101624250412,
-0.4948931634426117,
0.3195856809616089,
-1.1020283699035645,
-0.12880466878414154,
-0.8727103471755981,
-0.5169050097465515,
0.003895226866006851,
-0.7898015975952148,
-0.18828998506069183,
0.3635404706001282,
0.7115665674209595,
0.6555809378623962,
0.10923339426517487,
0.7349877953529358,
-0.45085176825523376,
-0.37575945258140564,
0.15806251764297485,
0.3368309736251831,
-0.3480239808559418,
-0.8231469392776489,
0.07617440074682236,
-0.11952951550483704,
-0.4014042019844055,
-0.7124438881874084,
0.6134520173072815,
0.3830980658531189,
0.03509329631924629,
0.06857026368379593,
-0.30374348163604736,
0.2400706559419632,
-0.7284972667694092,
1.0128345489501953,
-0.055502645671367645,
-0.48926684260368347,
0.2981378436088562,
-0.700233519077301,
0.33474433422088623,
0.6387355327606201,
0.30408650636672974,
-1.275317668914795,
-0.4478069841861725,
-0.8795392513275146,
-0.7263683676719666,
0.3560393452644348,
0.08886773884296417,
0.3473984897136688,
0.02780003286898136,
0.3969229459762573,
0.11566292494535446,
0.18438775837421417,
-0.5317386984825134,
-0.31199201941490173,
-0.4007592499256134,
-0.026535511016845703,
0.2341967672109604,
-0.5593416690826416,
-0.16743150353431702,
-0.22440648078918457,
0.7501015067100525,
0.21843455731868744,
0.7673608660697937,
0.22734935581684113,
0.4060996174812317,
0.24748070538043976,
0.7373297214508057,
0.9225640892982483,
0.9129664897918701,
-0.3898250460624695,
0.05025187134742737,
-0.03423948213458061,
-1.0045017004013062,
-0.26049667596817017,
0.069102942943573,
-0.1802692711353302,
0.0963321253657341,
0.3997567594051361,
0.32735756039619446,
0.007366630248725414,
-0.28201767802238464,
0.3999949097633362,
-0.08857537060976028,
-0.5589718222618103,
-0.5244157910346985,
0.38146892189979553,
-0.4188908040523529,
-0.1764654517173767,
0.5475130081176758,
0.666917622089386,
0.5149987936019897,
-0.6145578026771545,
0.22249868512153625,
0.28342536091804504,
-0.5927530527114868,
-0.43268758058547974,
0.6279933452606201,
0.1321779489517212,
-0.3852667510509491,
0.29957520961761475,
-0.22988547384738922,
-0.3811691999435425,
0.4751220643520355,
0.6683501601219177,
0.8767597079277039,
-0.04694362357258797,
0.27914777398109436,
0.40780138969421387,
0.25664740800857544,
-0.21840780973434448,
0.08001123368740082,
0.2852157950401306,
-0.5058478116989136,
-0.42146536707878113,
-0.4100531339645386,
-0.7057069540023804,
-0.08839785307645798,
-0.3284338116645813,
0.6523267030715942,
-0.5022938847541809,
0.016374621540308,
0.303498238325119,
-0.22540882229804993,
0.04129528999328613,
0.030205629765987396,
-0.348543256521225,
0.6882477402687073,
-0.5555166602134705,
0.4252409040927887,
0.8287771940231323,
-0.23312495648860931,
-0.28454652428627014,
0.1152314767241478,
0.31781908869743347,
-0.7247059941291809,
0.38052427768707275,
-0.15130005776882172,
-0.37215107679367065,
0.3220122754573822,
-1.031242847442627,
-0.7435528039932251,
0.7324116826057434,
-0.3908970355987549,
-0.23374047875404358,
0.21215637028217316,
-0.0632857009768486,
0.8536273837089539,
-0.1648099422454834,
0.2401239424943924,
0.41673123836517334,
0.4171062409877777,
-0.15334393084049225,
-0.743028998374939,
-0.4311540424823761,
-0.554658830165863,
-0.3849301040172577,
0.6029639840126038,
-0.6572372317314148,
0.9995518326759338,
-0.02478731796145439,
-0.4590839445590973,
-0.2822057604789734,
0.5699872970581055,
-0.029706383123993874,
0.11551224440336227,
0.0370800644159317,
0.04107997938990593,
0.6539797186851501,
-0.16947494447231293,
1.0114928483963013,
-0.47112444043159485,
-0.010286656208336353,
0.6993687748908997,
-0.013943558558821678,
0.8376874327659607,
0.5559196472167969,
-0.4113801419734955,
1.0887067317962646,
0.21136535704135895,
-0.31975626945495605,
0.2647360563278198,
0.06775065511465073,
-0.6155030727386475,
0.13650895655155182,
-0.06154561787843704,
-0.6034330725669861,
0.3164598047733307,
0.48722362518310547,
-0.30327728390693665,
-0.1769963949918747,
0.13738083839416504,
0.81902015209198,
0.2653957009315491,
-0.27894970774650574,
0.762719988822937,
0.012825850397348404,
-0.6692937612533569,
0.4809540808200836,
0.10636861622333527,
0.6817902326583862,
-0.5292399525642395,
-0.16774392127990723,
-0.05084223672747612,
-0.06981918215751648,
-0.2863287627696991,
-1.1468467712402344,
0.326292484998703,
-0.08620314300060272,
-0.10073623806238174,
-0.5276767015457153,
0.8694616556167603,
-0.3651452362537384,
-0.3966967761516571,
-0.6455590128898621,
0.2334083616733551,
0.25283369421958923,
-0.17387820780277252,
-0.4922774136066437,
-0.16326452791690826,
0.050873517990112305,
-0.19787512719631195,
0.5409317016601562,
0.5586994886398315,
0.05137269198894501,
0.7465234994888306,
0.6081582307815552,
0.18487633764743805,
-0.10437514632940292,
-0.23582443594932556,
0.6177544593811035,
-0.2384185642004013,
-0.4606325328350067,
-0.9212209582328796,
0.15821510553359985,
-0.18210607767105103,
-0.637072741985321,
0.7249837517738342,
0.42937710881233215,
0.38749605417251587,
-0.025403887033462524,
0.9977177381515503,
-0.18328119814395905,
0.4910025894641876,
-0.4152025580406189,
1.1528695821762085,
-0.12405288964509964,
0.12741851806640625,
-0.43709617853164673,
-0.7686264514923096,
-0.3669285774230957,
0.43250560760498047,
-0.7666022181510925,
-0.11124806851148605,
0.7941464781761169,
0.6813145875930786,
0.12560315430164337,
0.35603758692741394,
-0.04687255993485451,
0.03852974623441696,
0.35719525814056396,
-0.09788466989994049,
0.4627768099308014,
-0.482307106256485,
0.9010949730873108,
-0.34802788496017456,
-0.3028903007507324,
-0.3103949725627899,
-1.0306974649429321,
-0.6434795260429382,
-0.7899351119995117,
-0.7779066562652588,
-0.5503021478652954,
0.2503368556499481,
0.7104830145835876,
-0.0065739038400352,
-0.6563789248466492,
-0.052812643349170685,
-0.06206006184220314,
-0.3178882598876953,
-0.3705371916294098,
-0.2960934042930603,
0.5278803706169128,
-0.4626324474811554,
-0.5974794626235962,
0.10358667373657227,
0.331277996301651,
0.2122817486524582,
0.11659394204616547,
0.5173052549362183,
-0.1877303421497345,
0.3058279752731323,
0.80207759141922,
0.4339134991168976,
-0.08622254431247711,
-0.45931172370910645,
0.2225264012813568,
-0.21832747757434845,
0.3969748914241791,
0.8175195455551147,
-0.433228462934494,
0.3450626730918884,
0.6484140157699585,
0.22107046842575073,
0.28570255637168884,
0.16826340556144714,
0.4710851311683655,
-0.6147865653038025,
-0.2076559066772461,
0.1812938004732132,
0.3503091633319855,
0.062339235097169876,
-0.35644641518592834,
0.563538670539856,
0.40012702345848083,
-1.1808058023452759,
-0.9202657341957092,
-0.25813060998916626,
-1.0484707355499268,
-0.2060331106185913,
1.3387176990509033,
0.3623085618019104,
-0.22912490367889404,
-0.32660943269729614,
-0.6896025538444519,
-0.0827367827296257,
-0.7106782793998718,
1.1302212476730347,
1.0221130847930908,
-0.5376333594322205,
-0.35685575008392334,
-0.837291419506073,
0.8303235173225403,
0.21487243473529816,
-0.560646116733551,
0.20999322831630707,
0.26572081446647644,
0.2746843695640564,
0.17671296000480652,
0.7898797988891602,
-0.4500912129878998,
0.26221925020217896,
0.23986588418483734,
0.37156790494918823,
-0.005117454566061497,
0.043605972081422806,
0.0779431164264679,
-0.04563412070274353,
0.19490647315979004,
0.48534443974494934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08617v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08617v1
|
Synthetic Dataset Creation and Fine-Tuning of Transformer Models for Question Answering in Serbian
| 2024-04-12T17:27:54 | 2024-04-12T17:27:54 |
Aleksa Cvetanović, Predrag Tadić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we focus on generating a synthetic question answering (QA)
dataset using an adapted Translate-Align-Retrieve method. Using this method, we
created the largest Serbian QA dataset of more than 87K samples, which we name
SQuAD-sr. To acknowledge the script duality in Serbian, we generated both
Cyrillic and Latin versions of the dataset. We investigate the dataset quality
and use it to fine-tune several pre-trained QA models. Best results were
obtained by fine-tuning the BERTi\'c model on our Latin SQuAD-sr dataset,
achieving 73.91% Exact Match and 82.97% F1 score on the benchmark XQuAD
dataset, which we translated into Serbian for the purpose of evaluation. The
results show that our model exceeds zero-shot baselines, but fails to go beyond
human performance. We note the advantage of using a monolingual pre-trained
model over multilingual, as well as the performance increase gained by using
Latin over Cyrillic. By performing additional analysis, we show that questions
about numeric values or dates are more likely to be answered correctly than
other types of questions. Finally, we conclude that SQuAD-sr is of sufficient
quality for fine-tuning a Serbian QA model, in the absence of a manually
crafted and annotated dataset.
|
[
-0.46347254514694214,
-0.6431989669799805,
0.2971995770931244,
0.11042796075344086,
-0.20025557279586792,
0.591029167175293,
0.011702174320816994,
-0.3906708061695099,
0.3324759304523468,
0.3738604485988617,
-1.1861439943313599,
-0.4356081783771515,
-0.15686528384685516,
0.3411017060279846,
-0.19303016364574432,
1.2168365716934204,
-0.25261664390563965,
0.4733363389968872,
-0.10378512740135193,
-0.18384352326393127,
-0.48606929183006287,
-0.394127756357193,
-0.35069820284843445,
-0.13984200358390808,
0.40160951018333435,
0.6106202602386475,
0.6541824340820312,
0.18067273497581482,
0.5887657999992371,
0.2776939570903778,
0.23532547056674957,
0.13972987234592438,
-0.5899068713188171,
0.32706359028816223,
-0.19886507093906403,
-0.6466513276100159,
-0.11304491013288498,
-0.07238876819610596,
0.6414382457733154,
0.22033485770225525,
-0.010844995267689228,
0.7852320671081543,
-0.5779110193252563,
0.4853985905647278,
-0.17871037125587463,
0.2529050409793854,
-0.7316269874572754,
-0.10480997711420059,
0.15563321113586426,
0.013758931308984756,
-0.33508238196372986,
-0.52187579870224,
0.19450582563877106,
-0.7120615839958191,
0.5051301717758179,
0.06381820142269135,
1.0949007272720337,
0.29985469579696655,
-0.354470819234848,
-0.14147622883319855,
-0.9477875232696533,
0.7114366888999939,
-0.5029060244560242,
0.16814294457435608,
0.0668693259358406,
0.7213124632835388,
-0.12630987167358398,
-0.5880533456802368,
-0.6041010022163391,
0.17491576075553894,
-0.08653970062732697,
0.40487998723983765,
-0.2849404513835907,
-0.14202794432640076,
0.23185186088085175,
0.15173500776290894,
-0.9018930792808533,
-0.24410727620124817,
-0.7411271929740906,
-0.13023626804351807,
0.7126094698905945,
0.21396413445472717,
0.546961784362793,
-0.24293632805347443,
-0.058731015771627426,
-0.17172442376613617,
-0.7483742237091064,
0.36096373200416565,
0.7580482959747314,
0.3904971480369568,
0.21217350661754608,
0.8892784714698792,
-0.5343195796012878,
0.5374096632003784,
0.12665441632270813,
0.25432682037353516,
0.04939374327659607,
-0.629289984703064,
-0.13543324172496796,
-0.01080490741878748,
0.5971991419792175,
0.1564761996269226,
0.5597600340843201,
-0.3885078430175781,
0.08993569016456604,
0.4131283164024353,
0.6257545948028564,
-0.8227114677429199,
-0.3600143790245056,
0.21139675378799438,
0.0025686505250632763,
-0.17479175329208374,
0.3048606514930725,
-0.5020143389701843,
0.39798301458358765,
-0.44709131121635437,
0.4014638066291809,
-0.3756357431411743,
-0.0633697509765625,
0.1745941936969757,
0.00392676517367363,
0.5648615956306458,
-0.05873793363571167,
-0.5622079968452454,
0.2927224636077881,
0.44361579418182373,
0.3725642263889313,
-0.1438778042793274,
0.07706095278263092,
-0.3897396922111511,
-0.3139785826206207,
-0.37393918633461,
1.0257225036621094,
-0.4241296947002411,
-0.07529811561107635,
-0.02025943621993065,
0.3030639886856079,
-0.20644864439964294,
-0.4395752549171448,
0.5580726861953735,
-0.9303464889526367,
0.41509512066841125,
-0.2214929610490799,
-0.3209461569786072,
-0.06616632640361786,
0.36929893493652344,
-0.5769471526145935,
1.1114118099212646,
0.5124748349189758,
-0.5179775357246399,
0.29662656784057617,
-0.42184892296791077,
-0.40818339586257935,
0.12743356823921204,
0.12480779737234116,
-0.3516070246696472,
-0.012921655550599098,
0.34011781215667725,
0.037185512483119965,
-0.24230071902275085,
0.4145676791667938,
-0.014505506493151188,
-0.24528157711029053,
0.439237117767334,
-0.03870265558362007,
0.6343920826911926,
0.12488493323326111,
0.05935823917388916,
0.19154950976371765,
-0.7550714612007141,
0.6488658785820007,
-0.08464892953634262,
-0.12338673323392868,
0.016105934977531433,
-0.19031797349452972,
0.03497377783060074,
0.6631792783737183,
0.049612052738666534,
-0.9422743916511536,
0.15179210901260376,
-0.606806218624115,
0.35762736201286316,
0.3101837933063507,
0.036889296025037766,
0.37304574251174927,
-0.5191376209259033,
1.2795331478118896,
-0.05291739106178284,
0.15670563280582428,
0.00915069691836834,
-0.5311990976333618,
-0.4823095500469208,
-0.17685838043689728,
0.5780917406082153,
0.8111845850944519,
-1.1962887048721313,
0.2662980854511261,
-0.25338950753211975,
-0.6557237505912781,
-1.0986524820327759,
-0.09638306498527527,
0.48092973232269287,
0.5975232720375061,
0.3973578214645386,
0.17387129366397858,
-0.9710459113121033,
-1.1233571767807007,
-0.0924568697810173,
-0.33609578013420105,
-0.08832468092441559,
0.28522637486457825,
0.5626583695411682,
0.09462356567382812,
1.1629761457443237,
-0.6257126927375793,
-0.09616527706384659,
-0.6645276546478271,
0.024017129093408585,
0.30271396040916443,
0.505131721496582,
0.4892120361328125,
-0.9372902512550354,
-0.6082699298858643,
-0.2698814868927002,
-0.47772982716560364,
-0.11755291372537613,
-0.06636553257703781,
-0.44168704748153687,
0.20803676545619965,
0.10700724273920059,
-0.6270543932914734,
0.2020762711763382,
0.6557388305664062,
-0.38498473167419434,
0.7696794867515564,
-0.10449551790952682,
0.4433151185512543,
-1.4438976049423218,
0.09636855125427246,
0.02520807273685932,
-0.2162429541349411,
-0.8951417803764343,
0.28753364086151123,
0.2142178863286972,
-0.22832265496253967,
-0.6940511465072632,
0.46243223547935486,
-0.15979036688804626,
0.020139988511800766,
0.009040797129273415,
-0.0001859290641732514,
0.18974453210830688,
0.42679253220558167,
-0.06484575569629669,
1.191934585571289,
0.2635807991027832,
-0.2089081108570099,
0.4418470859527588,
0.8341286778450012,
-0.6033370494842529,
0.42599329352378845,
-1.076994776725769,
0.03622610867023468,
-0.3537719249725342,
0.23742128908634186,
-1.3054003715515137,
-0.27765408158302307,
0.28219982981681824,
-0.569775402545929,
0.2959049940109253,
-0.525967001914978,
-0.624325156211853,
-0.5734376311302185,
0.06110202893614769,
0.6268266439437866,
0.5682905912399292,
-0.2829248607158661,
0.4121834635734558,
0.33269935846328735,
-0.3981989026069641,
-0.34469640254974365,
-0.382900208234787,
-0.17233583331108093,
-0.08089692145586014,
-0.9899334907531738,
0.33393824100494385,
-0.33717969059944153,
-0.04966185614466667,
-0.3003969192504883,
-0.2357596904039383,
-0.34568119049072266,
-0.13229818642139435,
0.16665081679821014,
0.7267938852310181,
-0.37183454632759094,
0.12155438959598541,
0.23372389376163483,
-0.05184386670589447,
0.06756334751844406,
-0.11197644472122192,
0.6530112624168396,
-0.17896172404289246,
0.03853912651538849,
-0.45596542954444885,
0.4836500287055969,
0.47174516320228577,
-0.365543007850647,
0.7952302098274231,
0.43094581365585327,
-0.029611827805638313,
0.066305011510849,
-0.4886138141155243,
-0.1779741793870926,
-0.414702445268631,
0.18599005043506622,
-0.630516529083252,
-0.7148545980453491,
0.907242476940155,
0.2759714722633362,
-0.19124078750610352,
0.4385640621185303,
0.3860054612159729,
-0.3606942296028137,
1.3377642631530762,
0.3695908486843109,
0.04339065030217171,
0.25247862935066223,
-0.4737797677516937,
0.2710023522377014,
-0.750235378742218,
-0.4346221387386322,
-0.7812008261680603,
-0.4366315007209778,
-0.8372273445129395,
-0.15020695328712463,
0.4663386344909668,
-0.25118017196655273,
-0.10652302205562592,
0.5495900511741638,
-0.36614328622817993,
0.583171010017395,
0.5570144653320312,
0.19495020806789398,
0.13883206248283386,
-0.2985862195491791,
0.23899886012077332,
-0.17074720561504364,
-0.8632410168647766,
-0.5308693051338196,
1.030275821685791,
-0.13442102074623108,
0.7075743079185486,
0.03036436438560486,
0.460636705160141,
-0.10255187004804611,
0.029695061966776848,
-0.6844140887260437,
0.32633790373802185,
0.03512382507324219,
-0.8720276355743408,
-0.31030362844467163,
-0.4528515338897705,
-0.7143551111221313,
0.0308186337351799,
-0.3366718888282776,
-0.31200212240219116,
0.05407792702317238,
-0.04079751670360565,
-0.510513424873352,
-0.1505083441734314,
-0.8972057700157166,
1.0045171976089478,
0.0856686532497406,
0.06186862289905548,
0.15606428682804108,
-0.8718971014022827,
0.4187034070491791,
0.00861041247844696,
-0.22928853332996368,
-0.1906605064868927,
0.33559679985046387,
0.6418723464012146,
-0.08147142827510834,
0.34704282879829407,
-0.03447301685810089,
-0.08603202551603317,
0.261086642742157,
0.04522521793842316,
0.3978111743927002,
0.4472169876098633,
-0.18271371722221375,
-0.15590466558933258,
0.6588305830955505,
-0.6533488631248474,
-0.8447219729423523,
0.46923109889030457,
-0.9291437268257141,
-0.5253956317901611,
-0.30651184916496277,
-0.9380334615707397,
-0.3103969991207123,
0.11527280509471893,
0.4737095832824707,
0.6058229804039001,
-0.3977280557155609,
0.101580910384655,
0.7314444780349731,
-0.2650652825832367,
-0.04712706804275513,
0.7942818403244019,
0.03345062956213951,
-0.2907484471797943,
0.6256237626075745,
0.2069997936487198,
0.4568018615245819,
0.2780977189540863,
-0.19495312869548798,
-0.4821914732456207,
-0.3959682881832123,
-0.8128965497016907,
0.330188125371933,
-0.23777158558368683,
-0.5580801963806152,
-0.5723420977592468,
-0.42911604046821594,
-0.64837247133255,
0.11179078370332718,
-0.24590668082237244,
-0.6802565455436707,
-0.2698811888694763,
-0.1268993318080902,
0.27856582403182983,
0.37651002407073975,
0.5139884948730469,
0.30976244807243347,
-0.7362085580825806,
0.7990599274635315,
-0.023110559210181236,
0.26868945360183716,
-0.7016473412513733,
-0.650853157043457,
-0.13690422475337982,
0.511863112449646,
-0.16478602588176727,
-0.8079941272735596,
0.6283426284790039,
0.17632107436656952,
0.3875906765460968,
-0.16723600029945374,
0.5020143985748291,
0.6616232991218567,
-0.5178062915802002,
0.6993666291236877,
-0.29808223247528076,
-0.6795952916145325,
0.7130390405654907,
-0.4401722252368927,
0.6138678789138794,
0.9110749959945679,
0.5577096939086914,
-0.32543709874153137,
-0.6879611611366272,
-0.708617091178894,
-0.5220097303390503,
0.969427764415741,
0.42276090383529663,
0.3298666477203369,
-0.10502565652132034,
0.49730774760246277,
0.18695349991321564,
0.15877476334571838,
-0.3487367331981659,
-0.19836804270744324,
-0.19461749494075775,
-0.4144613742828369,
-0.02439630962908268,
-0.053937822580337524,
-0.04788142442703247,
-0.5056266784667969,
0.9683470129966736,
-0.35723182559013367,
0.20189283788204193,
0.11703315377235413,
-0.28227293491363525,
-0.22942115366458893,
0.40539199113845825,
0.721193253993988,
0.7775972485542297,
-0.2952415645122528,
-0.36096516251564026,
0.1546308994293213,
-0.3424716591835022,
0.4161984920501709,
0.004383346531540155,
-0.4922042787075043,
0.09733413904905319,
-0.17466117441654205,
0.5863267183303833,
0.04150770977139473,
-0.9014878869056702,
0.2149408459663391,
-0.3871806263923645,
-0.24529904127120972,
-0.4715341329574585,
0.14452242851257324,
-0.29786014556884766,
0.2565198540687561,
0.389691025018692,
0.0738537535071373,
0.01888996735215187,
-0.7116420269012451,
0.27140167355537415,
0.5553678870201111,
-0.3140511214733124,
-0.5985403656959534,
0.3848353922367096,
-0.20248715579509735,
-0.3138909637928009,
0.7928789854049683,
-0.028618600219488144,
-0.7435583472251892,
0.789428174495697,
0.6262602210044861,
0.4134870171546936,
-0.23931407928466797,
0.8391191959381104,
0.45784151554107666,
0.21190448105335236,
-0.08272877335548401,
0.7552661895751953,
0.1244126632809639,
-0.7981409430503845,
-0.5213760733604431,
-0.5439550280570984,
-0.38158470392227173,
-0.19926714897155762,
-1.1347702741622925,
0.11079363524913788,
-0.08166750520467758,
-0.07976343482732773,
-0.057790957391262054,
0.4195224344730377,
-0.7201594114303589,
0.4016283452510834,
-0.48961836099624634,
0.9481260776519775,
-0.9160787463188171,
0.8488389253616333,
0.748092770576477,
-0.4964534044265747,
-0.827431321144104,
-0.3160732388496399,
-0.581916332244873,
-0.7431343793869019,
0.7663081884384155,
-0.04450370743870735,
0.10210829228162766,
0.32057270407676697,
-0.5062423348426819,
-0.9889483451843262,
0.9427562952041626,
0.4746324419975281,
-0.20968294143676758,
-0.2947077453136444,
0.4195180833339691,
0.9517019391059875,
-0.4632143974304199,
0.25258126854896545,
0.8695738315582275,
0.38217929005622864,
0.31764519214630127,
-0.5688593983650208,
-0.12892527878284454,
-0.5051180720329285,
-0.07758903503417969,
0.23930425941944122,
-0.49465125799179077,
0.35254967212677,
-0.19059830904006958,
-0.32835853099823,
0.5948386192321777,
0.5455032587051392,
0.16537722945213318,
0.009821600280702114,
-0.054570768028497696,
0.33514195680618286,
0.4043790400028229,
-0.44107764959335327,
0.990691602230072,
-0.3284529149532318,
0.1307336837053299,
1.0846068859100342,
-0.32599684596061707,
0.7044268846511841,
0.520188570022583,
-0.09502110630273819,
0.570147693157196,
0.41522371768951416,
-0.1735183596611023,
0.4793214201927185,
0.306230753660202,
-0.028525592759251595,
-0.4229297339916229,
0.018806610256433487,
-0.08497334271669388,
0.5210705995559692,
-0.04968320205807686,
-0.10040466487407684,
-0.23821352422237396,
0.2065296322107315,
-0.4161596894264221,
0.10287299007177353,
0.006702987942844629,
1.0357027053833008,
-0.372756689786911,
-1.0872931480407715,
0.47580960392951965,
-0.15598024427890778,
0.20609842240810394,
-0.581466019153595,
0.18032604455947876,
-0.36515867710113525,
0.019283119589090347,
0.011785568669438362,
-0.8747295141220093,
0.5377551913261414,
0.09530533850193024,
-0.6860780715942383,
-0.3122596740722656,
0.40908411145210266,
-0.7510080933570862,
-1.0274841785430908,
-0.29068368673324585,
0.523737907409668,
0.0009021726436913013,
-0.09739342331886292,
-0.5863767862319946,
-0.21564804017543793,
-0.12189387530088425,
0.2680538594722748,
0.3055521547794342,
0.2781856060028076,
0.01583241857588291,
0.7784944176673889,
0.6142980456352234,
0.26812833547592163,
0.2471109926700592,
0.07497751712799072,
0.8088647723197937,
-0.37370914220809937,
-0.36762505769729614,
-0.4152749180793762,
0.5802433490753174,
0.13361921906471252,
-0.3400242030620575,
0.6522676944732666,
0.6750721335411072,
0.8496173024177551,
-0.40022990107536316,
0.5999718904495239,
0.1259600818157196,
0.8127105236053467,
-0.414930135011673,
0.6403920650482178,
-0.06248392164707184,
-0.08943167328834534,
-0.22337108850479126,
-0.8381971716880798,
-0.24938876926898956,
0.44110092520713806,
-0.19050249457359314,
-0.27957120537757874,
0.38847091794013977,
1.0462130308151245,
-0.10887730121612549,
0.18693259358406067,
0.3023412823677063,
0.006101149134337902,
0.38288962841033936,
0.5016763806343079,
0.9265355467796326,
-1.1041479110717773,
0.8168610334396362,
-0.1764393448829651,
0.1663871705532074,
0.11446768790483475,
-0.3507702350616455,
-0.7928848266601562,
-0.7015414237976074,
-0.3587229549884796,
-0.3319467306137085,
0.09943391382694244,
0.8274829983711243,
0.6413551568984985,
-1.167906403541565,
0.008342204615473747,
0.08148296177387238,
0.03390325978398323,
-0.12047383934259415,
-0.2694169282913208,
0.07861748337745667,
-0.5206679701805115,
-0.7204782962799072,
0.38723552227020264,
-0.1731538474559784,
0.16284878551959991,
-0.08739854395389557,
0.15423212945461273,
-0.33569279313087463,
0.19868993759155273,
0.47237613797187805,
0.3508191704750061,
-0.5841063261032104,
-0.35614749789237976,
0.7444440722465515,
0.111149862408638,
0.23540356755256653,
0.946236789226532,
-1.0865387916564941,
0.4453607201576233,
0.6499763131141663,
0.5257946252822876,
0.43259772658348083,
0.4443681240081787,
1.024776577949524,
-0.8288068771362305,
-0.14031094312667847,
0.3665889501571655,
0.1921951323747635,
0.2068208009004593,
-0.22506068646907806,
0.33541926741600037,
-0.22319191694259644,
-0.530600905418396,
-0.7537238001823425,
0.22922177612781525,
-1.061954140663147,
-0.01828085258603096,
1.0659728050231934,
-0.19224245846271515,
-0.19786511361598969,
-0.39603227376937866,
-0.5919020771980286,
0.44711026549339294,
-0.304007887840271,
1.050320029258728,
0.7333988547325134,
0.045036640018224716,
-0.02492417022585869,
-0.3552085757255554,
0.5656711459159851,
0.3413582146167755,
-1.0281153917312622,
-0.061540331691503525,
0.4692382216453552,
0.3945624530315399,
-0.029351230710744858,
0.07452111691236496,
-0.07575210183858871,
0.5685314536094666,
-0.548272967338562,
-0.20955535769462585,
-0.0406130775809288,
-0.5537651181221008,
-0.18068401515483856,
0.06672443449497223,
-0.43335795402526855,
-0.1174490749835968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08727v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08727v1
|
Can LLMs substitute SQL? Comparing Resource Utilization of Querying LLMs versus Traditional Relational Databases
| 2024-04-12T16:44:28 | 2024-04-12T16:44:28 |
Xiang Zhang, Khatoon Khedri, Reza Rawassizadeh
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, 68-04, H.2.m
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) can automate or substitute different types of
tasks in the software engineering process. This study evaluates the resource
utilization and accuracy of LLM in interpreting and executing natural language
queries against traditional SQL within relational database management systems.
We empirically examine the resource utilization and accuracy of nine LLMs
varying from 7 to 34 Billion parameters, including Llama2 7B, Llama2 13B,
Mistral, Mixtral, Optimus-7B, SUS-chat-34B, platypus-yi-34b,
NeuralHermes-2.5-Mistral-7B and Starling-LM-7B-alpha, using a small transaction
dataset. Our findings indicate that using LLMs for database queries incurs
significant energy overhead (even small and quantized models), making it an
environmentally unfriendly approach. Therefore, we advise against replacing
relational databases with LLMs due to their substantial resource utilization.
|
[
-0.08576574921607971,
-0.8138339519500732,
0.7906257510185242,
0.23934069275856018,
-0.2072286754846573,
0.04691827669739723,
-0.22713333368301392,
-0.6311814188957214,
0.06062666326761246,
0.9659874439239502,
-0.38317209482192993,
-0.3840715289115906,
0.23532135784626007,
0.3674277663230896,
-0.40937677025794983,
0.32989585399627686,
-0.17474320530891418,
0.1783667802810669,
-0.4285648763179779,
-0.10773026198148727,
-0.5748335719108582,
-0.7074824571609497,
-0.37050506472587585,
-0.3405612111091614,
0.345731258392334,
0.10429524630308151,
0.9229735732078552,
0.5609540343284607,
0.6788200736045837,
0.3411272168159485,
-0.11012432724237442,
0.15080371499061584,
-0.35079747438430786,
0.22989337146282196,
-0.2946248948574066,
-0.47786739468574524,
-0.450412780046463,
-0.02705221436917782,
0.5816823244094849,
0.8398475646972656,
-0.4717530906200409,
0.3557176887989044,
0.10482069849967957,
1.109745740890503,
-0.6379619836807251,
0.4155253767967224,
-0.9839842319488525,
0.19364425539970398,
-0.36485081911087036,
-0.11933496594429016,
-0.5914832949638367,
-0.3843959867954254,
-0.13538572192192078,
-0.5441605448722839,
-0.09072885662317276,
0.43684160709381104,
0.5801482796669006,
0.4431654214859009,
-0.34788599610328674,
-0.3001638352870941,
-1.0126757621765137,
1.0136734247207642,
-0.8454089164733887,
0.33018332719802856,
0.26857224106788635,
0.27526023983955383,
-0.3495334982872009,
-0.3700668513774872,
-0.6042888760566711,
-0.4320753514766693,
-0.4069001078605652,
-0.10776758193969727,
-0.07164507359266281,
0.4074242413043976,
0.526069700717926,
0.33501365780830383,
-0.6257372498512268,
0.4506434202194214,
-0.17803801596164703,
-0.010662581771612167,
0.7047584056854248,
0.6384913921356201,
0.16036561131477356,
-0.43486288189888,
-0.27003079652786255,
0.19289711117744446,
-0.931925892829895,
-0.26929783821105957,
0.04821297898888588,
0.47598281502723694,
0.2539707124233246,
0.7875473499298096,
-0.07174358516931534,
1.1404932737350464,
-0.3981435298919678,
-0.1586325764656067,
-0.11304371803998947,
-0.4814157485961914,
-0.6963208317756653,
-0.03794140741229057,
0.9119736552238464,
0.42928940057754517,
0.23205600678920746,
-0.27083903551101685,
-0.28541773557662964,
-0.05086531862616539,
0.12977425754070282,
-0.469870924949646,
-0.08392073214054108,
0.2285054475069046,
-0.38623321056365967,
0.005706624127924442,
-0.20475205779075623,
-0.5031530261039734,
-0.6194273233413696,
-0.41984227299690247,
0.24336543679237366,
-0.36390599608421326,
-0.19287744164466858,
-0.04445322975516319,
0.25610387325286865,
0.33502084016799927,
0.2876393496990204,
-0.6276010274887085,
0.5439081192016602,
0.46518123149871826,
0.8583233952522278,
-0.22559191286563873,
0.06463319808244705,
-0.0487636998295784,
0.2930549085140228,
-0.489002525806427,
0.6364667415618896,
-0.4798957109451294,
-0.7642112374305725,
-0.3228403627872467,
-0.17745721340179443,
-0.08689531683921814,
-1.051491379737854,
0.24954211711883545,
-0.7175436615943909,
0.03875107318162918,
-0.49182066321372986,
-0.7272260189056396,
-0.04563096910715103,
-0.2162589579820633,
-1.0431650876998901,
1.1177479028701782,
0.1513717621564865,
-0.2687559425830841,
0.24471911787986755,
-0.5838293433189392,
-0.3001514971256256,
0.028641624376177788,
-0.1411575973033905,
-0.30429843068122864,
0.028502896428108215,
-0.01519276574254036,
0.35014036297798157,
-0.8393742442131042,
0.026264827698469162,
-0.31401294469833374,
-0.6909818053245544,
0.5600031614303589,
-0.23054257035255432,
0.6762648224830627,
0.40779873728752136,
-0.04707491025328636,
-0.4323720335960388,
-0.6787102222442627,
0.21498411893844604,
0.13077925145626068,
-0.44392043352127075,
-0.37727636098861694,
0.3351321220397949,
-0.02114197611808777,
0.04506793990731239,
0.14825253188610077,
-0.38951626420021057,
0.18855807185173035,
-0.4409085214138031,
0.32443010807037354,
0.5660315752029419,
0.019402695819735527,
0.6283772587776184,
-0.24354295432567596,
0.4730921983718872,
-0.23299261927604675,
0.0804520696401596,
0.17653433978557587,
-0.09494458884000778,
-0.4802478551864624,
-0.05747569352388382,
0.14522723853588104,
0.6771057844161987,
-0.6136776804924011,
0.23368020355701447,
-0.161630779504776,
-0.5427937507629395,
-0.21244770288467407,
0.4377620220184326,
0.12145206332206726,
0.26763343811035156,
0.3671747148036957,
0.18603579699993134,
-0.7817893028259277,
-0.7667275667190552,
-0.7444697618484497,
-0.3509353697299957,
-0.09503811597824097,
0.7642700672149658,
0.2420937865972519,
0.1081843376159668,
1.0027637481689453,
-0.20003102719783783,
-0.305247962474823,
0.054431162774562836,
-0.36226174235343933,
0.5692349672317505,
0.3152829706668854,
0.5444727540016174,
-0.5283991694450378,
-0.6295343041419983,
0.014147097244858742,
-1.129846453666687,
-0.2159108966588974,
-0.3661923408508301,
-0.021178560331463814,
0.7113315463066101,
0.45349636673927307,
-0.870535135269165,
-0.013438397087156773,
0.43252867460250854,
-0.09580434113740921,
0.5046312212944031,
-0.021652568131685257,
0.1535044014453888,
-0.6325960755348206,
0.06933615356683731,
0.04096322879195213,
0.02177480421960354,
-0.46616050601005554,
0.07255280762910843,
0.10115569084882736,
-0.20625263452529907,
-0.5058982968330383,
0.35350489616394043,
-1.0490702390670776,
-0.48826271295547485,
0.03416532650589943,
0.10639407485723495,
0.04630779102444649,
0.021243270486593246,
-0.14027102291584015,
1.0510542392730713,
0.3831706941127777,
-0.7437172532081604,
0.5843949317932129,
-0.050783656537532806,
-0.5185310244560242,
0.5201630592346191,
-0.5690890550613403,
0.2784506380558014,
-0.04590236023068428,
0.0978798046708107,
-0.668178915977478,
-0.06400984525680542,
-0.0019275646191090345,
-0.005895022302865982,
0.2104199230670929,
-0.20827196538448334,
-0.8564301133155823,
-0.2546655237674713,
-0.28293702006340027,
-0.14710713922977448,
0.5979650020599365,
-0.4456455111503601,
0.6692617535591125,
0.26352787017822266,
-0.04919613525271416,
-0.37062254548072815,
-0.9720216393470764,
0.42409053444862366,
-0.26205092668533325,
-0.5902718901634216,
0.33275464177131653,
0.36968597769737244,
-0.5424696803092957,
0.13986143469810486,
-0.21754208207130432,
-0.005358797498047352,
0.19324007630348206,
0.13475485146045685,
0.4999353885650635,
-0.4003668427467346,
0.24326737225055695,
-0.30802568793296814,
0.18302853405475616,
0.28375333547592163,
-0.03508273884654045,
0.3694082200527191,
0.14052465558052063,
-0.5891979932785034,
-0.4645446240901947,
0.15505822002887726,
0.6170064210891724,
0.09035416692495346,
1.1693781614303589,
0.03363537788391113,
-0.393711656332016,
0.05390615016222,
-0.7212968468666077,
-0.15343043208122253,
-0.49165764451026917,
0.22883617877960205,
-0.15026389062404633,
-0.5869988203048706,
0.45529481768608093,
-0.003625705139711499,
0.13850753009319305,
0.4116343855857849,
0.2554566264152527,
-0.4131689667701721,
0.716779887676239,
0.23751050233840942,
-0.06135132163763046,
0.5190907716751099,
-0.16051402688026428,
0.12101917713880539,
-0.6963256597518921,
-0.14620321989059448,
-0.5668866038322449,
-0.19618193805217743,
-0.6591038107872009,
-0.5882142782211304,
0.48655062913894653,
0.11985930800437927,
-0.28687596321105957,
0.30884334444999695,
-0.3790627419948578,
0.6702235341072083,
0.15662430226802826,
0.0189663078635931,
0.5250529050827026,
0.2987818717956543,
0.35244813561439514,
-0.2697393596172333,
-0.5916975736618042,
-0.7106519937515259,
1.0414706468582153,
-0.040866438299417496,
1.1996649503707886,
0.34463024139404297,
0.5500040054321289,
0.12694039940834045,
0.3795758783817291,
-0.5275328755378723,
0.8423347473144531,
-0.12831628322601318,
-0.5607096552848816,
-0.5221947431564331,
-0.7325251698493958,
-0.9255126118659973,
0.4327287971973419,
-0.20967307686805725,
-0.5772294402122498,
-0.030226919800043106,
0.15023021399974823,
-0.19345669448375702,
0.6023861765861511,
-0.8342925906181335,
0.6824671626091003,
-0.4367202818393707,
-0.3609899878501892,
-0.43282273411750793,
-0.11907339841127396,
0.32468318939208984,
-0.22169658541679382,
0.21113935112953186,
-0.19983378052711487,
-0.29225847125053406,
0.6154031753540039,
-0.5075144171714783,
0.7242857217788696,
-0.284097820520401,
0.0026170900091528893,
0.488796591758728,
0.29318758845329285,
0.7545833587646484,
-0.2584068477153778,
-0.701076865196228,
0.14222660660743713,
0.03393550217151642,
-0.290650337934494,
-0.6890001893043518,
0.8131872415542603,
-0.44957053661346436,
-0.7518085241317749,
-0.6304662227630615,
-0.37242963910102844,
-0.3407169282436371,
0.028628705069422722,
-0.15199816226959229,
-0.03388349339365959,
-0.2734600901603699,
0.19054551422595978,
0.4089227020740509,
-0.346662700176239,
0.4257549047470093,
0.7522259950637817,
-0.28888484835624695,
0.22785614430904388,
0.7999205589294434,
0.4962424635887146,
0.33246180415153503,
0.34939584136009216,
0.01987815834581852,
-0.5236936211585999,
-0.6144667863845825,
-0.30103832483291626,
0.4483657479286194,
-0.3476122319698334,
-0.4482801854610443,
-0.5800994038581848,
-0.029214801266789436,
-0.12642525136470795,
0.0032050420995801687,
-0.3993181586265564,
-0.24818576872348785,
-0.48694783449172974,
0.035197123885154724,
0.6130853295326233,
0.7259294986724854,
0.37947240471839905,
0.16270551085472107,
-0.9399288892745972,
-0.033825065940618515,
0.0911567360162735,
0.5292527079582214,
-0.020107796415686607,
-0.2704256772994995,
-0.14529834687709808,
0.05590025708079338,
-0.0980677455663681,
-1.0265045166015625,
0.25910821557044983,
0.25052469968795776,
0.8452788591384888,
-0.2610153555870056,
0.1578686535358429,
0.5937542915344238,
-0.36789947748184204,
0.7775618433952332,
-0.004717247560620308,
-0.8316347002983093,
0.4868682324886322,
-0.2324983924627304,
0.10697346925735474,
0.28965118527412415,
0.39639461040496826,
-0.4312419593334198,
-0.1809873729944229,
-0.3069038987159729,
-0.712658703327179,
0.7036969661712646,
0.2390626221895218,
-0.0013415840221568942,
0.19435036182403564,
0.5697035789489746,
-0.27231091260910034,
0.31585124135017395,
-0.6839917898178101,
-0.27920177578926086,
0.318844199180603,
0.15753187239170074,
0.12044906616210938,
-0.3274523615837097,
0.1889483481645584,
-0.02001439407467842,
0.5364896059036255,
-0.00006632783333770931,
0.15206559002399445,
-0.16521494090557098,
-0.2613978087902069,
-0.126662015914917,
0.3449680209159851,
0.06948741525411606,
0.7483660578727722,
-0.3283945918083191,
-0.12509305775165558,
0.57545006275177,
-0.13381993770599365,
0.031923506408929825,
-0.09309317171573639,
0.03130049258470535,
0.1869419664144516,
0.04827312007546425,
0.47604379057884216,
0.052555520087480545,
-0.749101459980011,
-0.19848114252090454,
0.18221452832221985,
0.1888526976108551,
-0.3413429856300354,
0.15874424576759338,
0.4300406873226166,
0.1443605273962021,
0.18523406982421875,
-0.21118010580539703,
0.1500241905450821,
-0.6281322240829468,
-0.39130640029907227,
0.7376613020896912,
0.06053098663687706,
0.10653571039438248,
0.5692726373672485,
0.14870497584342957,
-0.16289106011390686,
0.7330946326255798,
-0.0037669807206839323,
0.10289232432842255,
0.440288782119751,
0.31095758080482483,
0.33966654539108276,
-0.31206461787223816,
-0.06577657163143158,
0.22368574142456055,
0.44576212763786316,
-0.10974610596895218,
0.48049604892730713,
0.23870065808296204,
-0.6226166486740112,
-0.7848551273345947,
-0.6822926998138428,
-0.6972423791885376,
0.01290363073348999,
-0.5670241117477417,
0.07713095098733902,
-0.6304246187210083,
-0.2646314799785614,
0.07216397672891617,
0.0015692090382799506,
-0.541858971118927,
-0.10328800976276398,
-0.034727949649095535,
0.8552123308181763,
-0.6409895420074463,
0.7795314788818359,
0.9435597658157349,
-0.3743567168712616,
-0.7184327244758606,
-0.4689776301383972,
0.2482384443283081,
-0.6463744044303894,
0.5966443419456482,
-0.40258580446243286,
-0.1607988327741623,
-0.3085567355155945,
-0.3493524193763733,
-0.9568790197372437,
1.2852216958999634,
0.6565993428230286,
-0.7434278130531311,
-0.04722253605723381,
0.4450570344924927,
0.6572240591049194,
0.006509072612971067,
0.08317245543003082,
0.6831085085868835,
0.37760159373283386,
-0.11495880037546158,
-1.061879277229309,
0.18118974566459656,
0.264388769865036,
0.469165563583374,
0.3673432171344757,
-0.5301743149757385,
0.8941742777824402,
-0.24152329564094543,
-0.5564101934432983,
0.009478815831243992,
0.5101783275604248,
0.38339585065841675,
0.019524715840816498,
0.5318764448165894,
0.12338979542255402,
0.8428505659103394,
0.03728804737329483,
1.1423022747039795,
-0.4863501191139221,
0.4207543432712555,
0.7416271567344666,
-0.9382790923118591,
0.7931286096572876,
0.7405429482460022,
-0.9219633340835571,
0.2877039909362793,
0.5347626209259033,
0.1069943904876709,
0.008053343743085861,
0.263171911239624,
-0.32867518067359924,
-0.145171657204628,
-0.016180582344532013,
-0.3119436204433441,
0.219197615981102,
0.5514227747917175,
-0.19349117577075958,
-0.15874646604061127,
-0.4057510197162628,
-0.0034624957479536533,
0.22393035888671875,
-0.11556173115968704,
0.6635845899581909,
0.3555169105529785,
-0.3543218970298767,
0.7985356450080872,
0.06533046066761017,
0.4879070520401001,
-0.35000988841056824,
0.014608779922127724,
-0.27565664052963257,
0.0254829041659832,
-0.4008937478065491,
-0.8987946510314941,
0.47031012177467346,
0.031031159684062004,
0.01515233889222145,
-0.30715471506118774,
0.7272199392318726,
-0.03308465704321861,
-0.4153607487678528,
0.21494600176811218,
0.6890337467193604,
0.17338134348392487,
-0.37390458583831787,
-0.8663405776023865,
0.06259394437074661,
-0.1452116072177887,
-0.3200070858001709,
0.5166115164756775,
0.35835006833076477,
0.10101717710494995,
0.7947415113449097,
0.6285387873649597,
0.32722538709640503,
-0.15444020926952362,
-0.021654969081282616,
0.7347018122673035,
-0.8794913291931152,
-0.22277763485908508,
-0.9867337346076965,
-0.042944733053445816,
-0.12952056527137756,
0.3098587095737457,
0.9069897532463074,
0.6020824313163757,
0.5115175247192383,
-0.013783256523311138,
0.6007668375968933,
0.13205480575561523,
0.6376370191574097,
-1.0592167377471924,
0.46009090542793274,
-0.3799746334552765,
0.9251776933670044,
-0.36342111229896545,
-1.3545938730239868,
-0.0846930518746376,
0.5672023892402649,
-0.3134913742542267,
0.13861411809921265,
0.6204060912132263,
1.0912649631500244,
0.18499508500099182,
0.11519104987382889,
0.3066313862800598,
0.4408617615699768,
0.19692353904247284,
0.3309548795223236,
0.867837131023407,
-0.1317654848098755,
0.45230695605278015,
-0.05696630850434303,
0.11641404777765274,
-0.3591559827327728,
-0.7681375741958618,
-0.42680272459983826,
-0.06800228357315063,
-0.2276274412870407,
-0.5244656801223755,
0.1346236765384674,
0.8997732996940613,
0.2784584164619446,
-0.8119956254959106,
-0.790974497795105,
0.1296127736568451,
0.2372308373451233,
-0.1775340586900711,
-0.2660703659057617,
0.18826302886009216,
-0.2871858477592468,
-0.48104625940322876,
0.43306517601013184,
0.28706425428390503,
0.09393348544836044,
-0.5204569101333618,
0.0783499926328659,
-0.15530414879322052,
-0.09911122918128967,
0.70661461353302,
0.22712476551532745,
-0.6502156853675842,
-0.17243903875350952,
0.42199772596359253,
-0.46989086270332336,
0.08339059352874756,
0.8163448572158813,
-0.7931773066520691,
-0.025699028745293617,
0.3290838897228241,
0.4486504793167114,
0.477405846118927,
-0.131755992770195,
0.43514978885650635,
-0.5823767185211182,
0.001540430006571114,
0.3086388409137726,
0.4906715750694275,
0.39790335297584534,
-0.4817233681678772,
0.6232980489730835,
0.3488507568836212,
-0.6358503699302673,
-0.9057695865631104,
0.10185596346855164,
-0.9727369546890259,
-0.3148447573184967,
1.233946681022644,
0.23540808260440826,
-0.3116043210029602,
-0.20211932063102722,
-0.13494551181793213,
-0.23818805813789368,
-0.236188143491745,
0.4112186133861542,
0.5321487188339233,
-0.6732770800590515,
-0.1516963094472885,
-0.8030792474746704,
0.4655318558216095,
0.531854510307312,
-0.7419921159744263,
0.22083497047424316,
0.74769127368927,
0.3060329258441925,
-0.008921606466174126,
0.7954066395759583,
-0.17807520925998688,
0.060141757130622864,
-0.023270247504115105,
0.07969285547733307,
0.14042837917804718,
0.3363662660121918,
-0.16334307193756104,
-0.1013822928071022,
0.25817954540252686,
0.13088549673557281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08579v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08579v1
|
Small Models Are (Still) Effective Cross-Domain Argument Extractors
| 2024-04-12T16:23:41 | 2024-04-12T16:23:41 |
William Gantt, Aaron Steven White
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Effective ontology transfer has been a major goal of recent work on event
argument extraction (EAE). Two methods in particular -- question answering (QA)
and template infilling (TI) -- have emerged as promising approaches to this
problem. However, detailed explorations of these techniques' ability to
actually enable this transfer are lacking. In this work, we provide such a
study, exploring zero-shot transfer using both techniques on six major EAE
datasets at both the sentence and document levels. Further, we challenge the
growing reliance on LLMs for zero-shot extraction, showing that vastly smaller
models trained on an appropriate source ontology can yield zero-shot
performance superior to that of GPT-3.5 or GPT-4.
|
[
-0.37767738103866577,
-0.7000952363014221,
1.0104879140853882,
-0.5391257405281067,
-0.25351831316947937,
-0.22877849638462067,
0.05656122788786888,
-0.5866031646728516,
-0.19415108859539032,
0.3690328001976013,
-0.5227376818656921,
-0.2145225554704666,
-0.6775854825973511,
0.13419340550899506,
-0.5573501586914062,
1.0369236469268799,
-0.010688039474189281,
-0.20821309089660645,
-0.15910927951335907,
-0.12517252564430237,
-0.4043895900249481,
-0.4138838052749634,
-0.9448740482330322,
-0.2529400885105133,
0.651445746421814,
0.6564164161682129,
0.28342387080192566,
0.6914283037185669,
0.327192485332489,
0.0123232901096344,
0.22885513305664062,
-0.10470835864543915,
-0.33563360571861267,
-0.08965099602937698,
-0.6178087592124939,
-0.5610545873641968,
-0.39048099517822266,
0.12186764925718307,
0.4014529883861542,
0.38089922070503235,
0.08614664524793625,
0.34095174074172974,
-0.21042749285697937,
0.06892702728509903,
-0.8608432412147522,
-0.15057460963726044,
-0.8331966400146484,
0.14385555684566498,
-0.3572613298892975,
-0.14334748685359955,
-0.5408369302749634,
0.013622763566672802,
0.4291878342628479,
-0.6133913993835449,
0.12831544876098633,
-0.07570654153823853,
1.1108461618423462,
-0.0177890807390213,
-0.41891512274742126,
-0.2697907090187073,
-0.750311017036438,
0.8519876003265381,
-0.9702951908111572,
-0.09230705350637436,
0.08947756141424179,
0.1537565141916275,
0.1239786371588707,
-1.0042970180511475,
-0.7780265212059021,
0.2619466185569763,
0.11355626583099365,
0.17056477069854736,
-0.735738217830658,
-0.04493479058146477,
0.3558427393436432,
-0.06312595307826996,
-0.6044203639030457,
0.22525140643119812,
-0.3011366128921509,
-0.0028187576681375504,
0.6184354424476624,
0.17452800273895264,
0.3830418288707733,
-0.491485059261322,
-0.345983624458313,
-0.03514869883656502,
-0.8138546347618103,
-0.16454985737800598,
-0.055275265127420425,
0.3006322979927063,
0.03171267360448837,
0.5842936635017395,
0.0523233525454998,
0.7142577171325684,
0.21164609491825104,
-0.042597074061632156,
-0.6373050212860107,
-0.5719729065895081,
-0.48493361473083496,
-0.12744462490081787,
0.6333516240119934,
0.2226255089044571,
0.2758302390575409,
-0.49477419257164,
0.263132244348526,
-0.16589586436748505,
0.23719047009944916,
-0.9932634234428406,
-0.060417041182518005,
0.2754669785499573,
-0.4681699275970459,
-0.21395207941532135,
0.06124230474233627,
-0.9435603618621826,
-0.23048263788223267,
0.05900353193283081,
0.6916840672492981,
-0.31971651315689087,
0.13350427150726318,
0.12232350558042526,
-0.5009564161300659,
0.6432585120201111,
0.47565957903862,
-0.5831930637359619,
0.2254343330860138,
0.7057042121887207,
0.7780665755271912,
-0.2630479335784912,
0.16818958520889282,
-0.8130664825439453,
0.4619402587413788,
-0.4602692425251007,
1.374521017074585,
-0.595305323600769,
-0.2837705612182617,
0.01961451582610607,
-0.21502502262592316,
-0.17866475880146027,
-0.40275147557258606,
0.7706260085105896,
-0.34067925810813904,
0.5464792847633362,
-0.3542822301387787,
-0.9677349328994751,
-0.24163818359375,
0.2330608069896698,
-0.314447820186615,
0.7212474942207336,
0.06146888807415962,
-0.2581635117530823,
0.49894973635673523,
-0.8049362897872925,
-0.19583657383918762,
0.1071915552020073,
-0.3908669948577881,
-0.14937984943389893,
0.3613429665565491,
0.2332467883825302,
0.5747696161270142,
-0.5950956344604492,
-0.5451808571815491,
-0.4648849070072174,
-0.175999253988266,
-0.028103189542889595,
-0.30638769268989563,
0.6342136859893799,
0.16654235124588013,
-0.3986648917198181,
-0.29444336891174316,
-0.8751310706138611,
0.05409223958849907,
0.29080766439437866,
0.10878389328718185,
-0.33119386434555054,
-0.27525708079338074,
-0.38260960578918457,
0.5671529173851013,
-0.2543281018733978,
-0.9696146249771118,
0.5228571891784668,
-0.43530938029289246,
0.41524043679237366,
0.3410334289073944,
0.25073692202568054,
0.751473605632782,
-0.4205804765224457,
0.7638434171676636,
0.057514745742082596,
-0.16747359931468964,
-0.18147458136081696,
-0.5850728154182434,
-0.7283981442451477,
-0.2576635181903839,
0.47944942116737366,
0.5455483794212341,
-1.0054806470870972,
-0.0815785825252533,
-0.27557820081710815,
-0.5186665058135986,
-0.5496854186058044,
-0.10795587301254272,
0.1488392949104309,
0.6086820960044861,
0.33613771200180054,
-0.0022188895381987095,
-0.25756141543388367,
-0.6489116549491882,
-0.3831850290298462,
-0.35650140047073364,
-0.15938465297222137,
0.32949328422546387,
0.34229353070259094,
0.4072827100753784,
1.1342977285385132,
-0.4619239866733551,
-0.4381404221057892,
-0.49425390362739563,
0.4022766649723053,
0.010480925440788269,
0.13171152770519257,
1.0626410245895386,
-0.2782197594642639,
-0.7649251818656921,
0.11660190671682358,
-0.8632633090019226,
-0.2718490958213806,
-0.5027227997779846,
-0.18641790747642517,
0.1762986183166504,
0.3975342810153961,
-0.87896728515625,
0.6806127429008484,
0.16192303597927094,
-0.41655632853507996,
0.2612120807170868,
0.24886587262153625,
0.05857347697019577,
-1.2168569564819336,
-0.19204312562942505,
0.05911083146929741,
-0.49118128418922424,
-0.787499725818634,
-0.0570259615778923,
-0.024785125628113747,
-0.021441882476210594,
-0.8075196146965027,
0.9527168869972229,
-0.4981469213962555,
0.2016756385564804,
-0.5281386375427246,
0.6407681107521057,
0.3507241904735565,
0.1759221851825714,
-0.0020393747836351395,
0.5193224549293518,
0.48457014560699463,
-0.19757458567619324,
0.13877734541893005,
0.4603130519390106,
0.06540319323539734,
0.8659148216247559,
-0.45242610573768616,
0.5127484202384949,
-0.010507983155548573,
0.09941434115171432,
-0.9258570671081543,
0.16110345721244812,
0.39689841866493225,
-0.15271113812923431,
0.43358397483825684,
-0.7020815014839172,
-0.16113124787807465,
-0.03223024681210518,
-0.5155044794082642,
0.1515151411294937,
0.5982379913330078,
-0.5003412961959839,
0.7026232481002808,
0.07286199182271957,
-0.3537587523460388,
-0.3016161024570465,
-0.62367182970047,
0.25687044858932495,
-0.45039448142051697,
-0.5829834938049316,
0.3913757801055908,
0.15377658605575562,
-0.24664472043514252,
0.2812459468841553,
-0.06287043541669846,
-0.02971074916422367,
-0.2522165775299072,
-0.07510122656822205,
0.3491814136505127,
-0.5952284932136536,
0.11478739231824875,
-0.0993545725941658,
-0.006628548260778189,
-0.10086913406848907,
-0.362900972366333,
0.052630260586738586,
0.19591118395328522,
-0.3905228078365326,
-0.4575108289718628,
0.7570868730545044,
0.29021790623664856,
0.2322472333908081,
0.837230920791626,
0.30893945693969727,
-0.39981809258461,
-0.5052365660667419,
-0.48474833369255066,
-0.3527044951915741,
-0.3235485553741455,
0.20709076523780823,
-0.5436471104621887,
-0.7892668843269348,
0.41914990544319153,
0.005304811988025904,
0.32028743624687195,
0.8046318292617798,
0.3876035213470459,
-0.18948332965373993,
0.7106817960739136,
0.6220978498458862,
0.19131061434745789,
0.5257126092910767,
-0.30287501215934753,
0.3189544379711151,
-0.731497049331665,
0.20403455197811127,
-0.7734472155570984,
-0.05166971683502197,
-0.19895978271961212,
-0.536708652973175,
0.0647365003824234,
0.2546083331108093,
0.028456708416342735,
0.3850299119949341,
-0.13728304207324982,
0.4223524332046509,
0.0036000392865389585,
-0.514158308506012,
0.3216453790664673,
0.14700926840305328,
0.16100338101387024,
-0.09071619808673859,
-1.1965575218200684,
-0.7235506772994995,
1.0750280618667603,
0.26475679874420166,
0.5569443106651306,
0.13738936185836792,
0.5880537629127502,
0.21105219423770905,
0.47815749049186707,
-0.9482147097587585,
0.4046461582183838,
-0.5393955707550049,
-0.6451133489608765,
-0.4206227958202362,
-0.27290797233581543,
-0.832129716873169,
0.5555317401885986,
-0.34516966342926025,
-1.1677418947219849,
0.6267018914222717,
-0.16234983503818512,
-0.8097321391105652,
0.6724396347999573,
-0.6279586553573608,
0.8517409563064575,
0.24520771205425262,
-0.2943069338798523,
0.1272611916065216,
-0.31631311774253845,
0.11806485801935196,
-0.2753140330314636,
0.002833121921867132,
-0.2774777114391327,
0.08444112539291382,
0.8384090662002563,
-0.3403615951538086,
0.592689037322998,
0.0906735360622406,
-0.23224470019340515,
0.6353975534439087,
0.20837455987930298,
0.550321102142334,
-0.06951729208230972,
-0.290503591299057,
0.2650562822818756,
0.48557305335998535,
-0.4848405718803406,
-0.8924536108970642,
0.4197580814361572,
-0.5191245079040527,
-0.7571896910667419,
-0.3465021848678589,
-0.3200804591178894,
-0.2671338617801666,
0.11002521216869354,
0.43656787276268005,
0.570933997631073,
-0.2167593091726303,
0.3094635605812073,
0.4111822247505188,
0.08437002450227737,
0.762161374092102,
0.7676519155502319,
0.11315187811851501,
-0.04497597739100456,
0.7525374889373779,
0.5076319575309753,
0.35687869787216187,
0.1927875280380249,
0.23272886872291565,
-0.23257100582122803,
-0.5540850758552551,
-0.8002628087997437,
0.21996790170669556,
-0.8178155422210693,
-0.5163587927818298,
-0.8565065264701843,
-0.34043580293655396,
-0.4633421003818512,
-0.3838202655315399,
-0.5056296586990356,
-0.8660608530044556,
-0.41905316710472107,
-0.11061921715736389,
0.21041187644004822,
0.6648285984992981,
-0.12009791284799576,
0.3204609453678131,
-1.2429355382919312,
0.2570405602455139,
0.21827422082424164,
-0.16481974720954895,
-0.007135005667805672,
-0.8379002213478088,
-0.08420731872320175,
-0.1465814858675003,
-0.3769470155239105,
-0.9670698046684265,
0.27104830741882324,
0.4719967544078827,
0.5266509652137756,
0.31646600365638733,
0.31041982769966125,
0.8391932845115662,
-0.4262752830982208,
1.0894087553024292,
0.12829618155956268,
-0.8827947378158569,
0.4120844304561615,
-0.04102121666073799,
0.09673797339200974,
0.4191814064979553,
0.4031789004802704,
-0.33112141489982605,
-0.27975282073020935,
-0.8417114019393921,
-0.5736030340194702,
0.7570396661758423,
0.2071322202682495,
-0.00007439448381774127,
-0.08182661980390549,
0.782464325428009,
0.30106207728385925,
-0.15459267795085907,
-0.5219554901123047,
0.11976370215415955,
0.2519010901451111,
-0.11873586475849152,
0.3039732575416565,
-0.15878696739673615,
-0.2652100920677185,
0.13110750913619995,
0.3992120623588562,
-0.4479384422302246,
0.26657190918922424,
0.44317299127578735,
-0.08761722594499588,
-0.31554871797561646,
0.4498131573200226,
0.35595691204071045,
0.46584266424179077,
-0.02709796093404293,
0.12165497988462448,
0.3976738750934601,
-0.10462091863155365,
0.24875538051128387,
-0.08341625332832336,
-0.3771173357963562,
-0.03674626350402832,
0.7115583419799805,
0.6647277474403381,
-0.08747339248657227,
-0.30731210112571716,
0.7195504307746887,
-0.23453965783119202,
-0.3405022919178009,
0.05795898288488388,
0.009274892508983612,
-0.196905717253685,
0.44612425565719604,
0.17413800954818726,
-0.27798235416412354,
0.12417522072792053,
-0.7559709548950195,
0.20394062995910645,
0.5366277098655701,
-0.5836180448532104,
-0.464546263217926,
0.5872580409049988,
0.05703628063201904,
-0.0539296492934227,
0.3777023255825043,
0.07134714722633362,
-0.005830854643136263,
0.4544021189212799,
0.6173263192176819,
0.939274787902832,
0.43397852778434753,
0.3707631230354309,
0.08573329448699951,
0.15402546525001526,
0.22755546867847443,
0.15855816006660461,
0.018151873722672462,
-0.8715044856071472,
-0.582843005657196,
-0.4825136661529541,
-0.4746953547000885,
0.09121459722518921,
-0.6919247508049011,
0.11490413546562195,
-0.18539007008075714,
-0.15316429734230042,
0.4141616225242615,
0.1484854370355606,
-0.7296292185783386,
-0.03321591392159462,
0.2707950472831726,
1.0690288543701172,
-0.8589645624160767,
0.9794861674308777,
0.6876152157783508,
-0.740527868270874,
-0.8162707090377808,
0.14973750710487366,
0.0355185903608799,
-0.28498780727386475,
0.49657920002937317,
-0.39751923084259033,
-0.15294767916202545,
0.028409183025360107,
-0.5103133916854858,
-0.6727933287620544,
0.962143063545227,
0.559307336807251,
-0.3164364993572235,
-0.10362149775028229,
0.15897749364376068,
0.49578726291656494,
-0.6837524175643921,
0.20440354943275452,
0.677085280418396,
0.39666590094566345,
0.26899126172065735,
-0.7586439847946167,
0.15890705585479736,
0.19271229207515717,
-0.14506219327449799,
-0.1211010217666626,
-0.5968722105026245,
0.6998853087425232,
-0.12816135585308075,
-0.3833179771900177,
0.2452508807182312,
0.7010874152183533,
0.003775232005864382,
0.39179325103759766,
0.18671941757202148,
0.4631512463092804,
0.44511181116104126,
0.022089025005698204,
1.3649413585662842,
0.16012030839920044,
0.26350608468055725,
1.0569360256195068,
-0.8025943636894226,
1.1289277076721191,
0.5804148316383362,
0.039554473012685776,
0.4501243531703949,
0.40562814474105835,
0.1522611528635025,
0.4744237959384918,
-0.24530376493930817,
-0.023869726806879044,
-0.5190535187721252,
-0.15065576136112213,
-0.0695289596915245,
0.6449498534202576,
0.18682540953159332,
-0.0016182261751964688,
-0.5705057978630066,
-0.020913157612085342,
0.1609940230846405,
-0.21955028176307678,
-0.12270840257406235,
1.1137537956237793,
0.3744933307170868,
-0.48658832907676697,
0.20636425912380219,
-0.04012610390782356,
0.4020110070705414,
-0.4991081655025482,
-0.23613686859607697,
-0.3275837302207947,
0.10263250023126602,
-0.0949358344078064,
-0.8270666003227234,
0.532271683216095,
0.2296961545944214,
-0.13089503347873688,
-0.11949042975902557,
1.2038023471832275,
-0.24563603103160858,
-0.23058615624904633,
0.45396503806114197,
0.9459514021873474,
0.2190553992986679,
-0.03778309375047684,
-0.47546741366386414,
-0.4111919701099396,
-0.09373439848423004,
-0.3237799108028412,
0.637514591217041,
0.7942609190940857,
-0.21843312680721283,
0.2746680676937103,
0.5543704032897949,
0.4266532063484192,
0.2283639758825302,
-0.26649606227874756,
0.7063978910446167,
-0.6417885422706604,
-0.10672277212142944,
-1.0054901838302612,
0.42550569772720337,
-0.21397964656352997,
-0.29568222165107727,
0.8916872143745422,
0.17705947160720825,
0.6615484952926636,
-0.05669908970594406,
0.8335464596748352,
-0.012554388493299484,
0.4367910921573639,
-0.45042240619659424,
0.519666850566864,
-0.7022467255592346,
0.06888610869646072,
-0.12151380628347397,
-0.8285170793533325,
-0.4185675084590912,
0.48912107944488525,
-0.2897309362888336,
-0.23636384308338165,
0.7203372120857239,
0.4867008328437805,
-0.051307808607816696,
0.04929715767502785,
0.8316181898117065,
0.04251861572265625,
0.6586105227470398,
0.5718750953674316,
0.8243352770805359,
-0.7296201586723328,
0.7560818195343018,
-0.030674807727336884,
-0.1805354505777359,
-0.2581721246242523,
-1.291170597076416,
-0.8352048993110657,
-0.105723075568676,
-0.6657260060310364,
-0.24914923310279846,
0.06376129388809204,
0.7591431736946106,
0.9281433820724487,
-0.9508150219917297,
0.030906295403838158,
0.33254122734069824,
-0.0946154072880745,
-0.08553535491228104,
-0.1576804369688034,
0.3666228652000427,
-0.2050500363111496,
-0.625316321849823,
0.49821701645851135,
0.6090810894966125,
-0.08158761262893677,
0.14903421700000763,
0.3851771652698517,
-0.36329805850982666,
0.914526641368866,
0.8872438073158264,
0.6023209095001221,
-0.6290839910507202,
-0.884502112865448,
-0.15086165070533752,
-0.08284313976764679,
0.12801332771778107,
0.9222896099090576,
-0.6089963912963867,
0.2748122811317444,
0.6490914225578308,
0.6891075372695923,
0.593695878982544,
0.0805659145116806,
0.6651474237442017,
-0.745518147945404,
0.11254982650279999,
0.0930650383234024,
0.37529584765434265,
0.07401071488857269,
-0.2974047362804413,
0.6735371947288513,
0.27726516127586365,
-0.42285820841789246,
-0.7376827597618103,
0.0866854190826416,
-1.026179552078247,
-0.4638710618019104,
1.2367922067642212,
-0.4493559002876282,
-0.2906157076358795,
-0.2547042965888977,
-0.19334326684474945,
0.19213515520095825,
-0.03828141838312149,
0.5847722887992859,
0.9453403949737549,
-0.5832135081291199,
-0.41100504994392395,
-0.6154162287712097,
0.4715195298194885,
0.4481419324874878,
-1.0886297225952148,
-0.0399789921939373,
0.2941102087497711,
0.4257960021495819,
0.2877661883831024,
0.6661912202835083,
-0.24461528658866882,
0.2447340339422226,
0.2332441508769989,
-0.017965909093618393,
0.08555086702108383,
-0.31382572650909424,
-0.5356150269508362,
0.6445352435112,
0.07379896193742752,
-0.10819225013256073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08559v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08559v1
|
MoPE: Mixture of Prefix Experts for Zero-Shot Dialogue State Tracking
| 2024-04-12T15:57:41 | 2024-04-12T15:57:41 |
Tianwen Tang, Tong Zhu, Haodong Liu, Yin Bai, Jia Cheng, Wenliang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Zero-shot dialogue state tracking (DST) transfers knowledge to unseen
domains, reducing the cost of annotating new datasets. Previous zero-shot DST
models mainly suffer from domain transferring and partial prediction problems.
To address these challenges, we propose Mixture of Prefix Experts (MoPE) to
establish connections between similar slots in different domains, which
strengthens the model transfer performance in unseen domains. Empirical results
demonstrate that MoPE-DST achieves the joint goal accuracy of 57.13% on
MultiWOZ2.1 and 55.40% on SGD.
|
[
-0.5036216974258423,
-0.6484972834587097,
0.8239115476608276,
-0.1684383600950241,
-0.28130170702934265,
0.5110258460044861,
0.19158244132995605,
-0.4183414876461029,
0.44078153371810913,
0.49628472328186035,
-0.8520631194114685,
-0.22458955645561218,
-0.7283522486686707,
-0.43130436539649963,
-0.15635070204734802,
0.8137989044189453,
0.19577328860759735,
-0.10795039683580399,
-0.07051769644021988,
-0.027858536690473557,
-0.7000739574432373,
-0.6014251112937927,
-0.3895704448223114,
-0.2863162159919739,
0.03221490606665611,
0.22654876112937927,
0.4040914475917816,
0.15880730748176575,
0.18413898348808289,
0.15905353426933289,
0.05155660957098007,
0.320165753364563,
-0.38821616768836975,
0.19788675010204315,
-0.4218152165412903,
-0.41432487964630127,
-0.8915038704872131,
-0.06266966462135315,
0.15006378293037415,
0.5112335085868835,
-0.2688588798046112,
-0.08997029066085815,
-0.26609891653060913,
0.31450173258781433,
-0.7391668558120728,
-0.049796223640441895,
-0.7191838622093201,
0.0036265661474317312,
-0.12673752009868622,
-0.5483692288398743,
-0.14626888930797577,
0.0506124310195446,
0.26378291845321655,
-0.5725303292274475,
0.38118016719818115,
-0.19258736073970795,
0.5448772311210632,
0.3638608157634735,
-0.9026829600334167,
0.21144767105579376,
-0.7821170687675476,
0.8121524453163147,
-0.8193416595458984,
0.16572242975234985,
0.3335137963294983,
0.22986863553524017,
-0.30909571051597595,
-0.34695297479629517,
-0.7575584650039673,
0.11114179342985153,
0.3673652410507202,
0.3559408187866211,
-0.044692642986774445,
0.17333126068115234,
0.2782610058784485,
0.4108852744102478,
-0.13448117673397064,
-0.13330355286598206,
-0.4211367964744568,
-0.29624906182289124,
0.7668920755386353,
0.28194722533226013,
0.2729029655456543,
0.07514932751655579,
-0.7550438642501831,
0.2180296927690506,
-0.4659155309200287,
-0.11059217900037766,
0.13891631364822388,
0.3142651319503784,
0.04222094267606735,
0.4545997083187103,
-0.4475754499435425,
0.9033797979354858,
0.2545093595981598,
-0.4642830789089203,
0.08782442659139633,
-0.4993014633655548,
-0.24989916384220123,
-0.0998770073056221,
0.6219260692596436,
0.5207967758178711,
-0.033944662660360336,
-0.11182621866464615,
-0.24384768307209015,
0.005767658352851868,
0.09836407750844955,
-0.6717162728309631,
-0.2555882930755615,
0.0883527472615242,
0.1318514496088028,
-0.08447105437517166,
-0.019145894795656204,
-0.7047107219696045,
-0.34821605682373047,
-0.4570766091346741,
0.7210249900817871,
-0.7837602496147156,
-0.6139402389526367,
0.3239908814430237,
-0.4034961462020874,
0.07564391940832138,
0.8076207041740417,
-0.9149802923202515,
0.45672401785850525,
0.6509972810745239,
1.0145708322525024,
-0.4329710602760315,
-0.03774145990610123,
-0.4302438199520111,
0.34631168842315674,
-0.16509993374347687,
1.1229629516601562,
-0.42480722069740295,
-0.6973533034324646,
-0.3498721718788147,
-0.26362133026123047,
-0.6206761598587036,
-0.029792293906211853,
0.3488071858882904,
-0.2263340950012207,
0.2927601635456085,
-0.05081414431333542,
-0.9674163460731506,
-0.31090307235717773,
0.39940524101257324,
-0.12048493325710297,
1.0920207500457764,
0.2151205837726593,
-0.15303094685077667,
0.29885396361351013,
-0.7261048555374146,
-0.31173741817474365,
0.3322034478187561,
-0.2136376053094864,
0.2884413003921509,
0.2560568153858185,
0.1832202672958374,
0.391204833984375,
-0.08947191387414932,
0.14104682207107544,
-0.19960880279541016,
-0.2440047264099121,
0.07199931889772415,
-0.5117152333259583,
0.6581456065177917,
-0.04672135040163994,
-0.23507192730903625,
-0.1937381625175476,
-0.9418756365776062,
0.22693955898284912,
-0.2537078857421875,
0.10862161964178085,
-0.5905356407165527,
-0.30507251620292664,
-0.25172746181488037,
0.4451904892921448,
-0.027042435482144356,
-0.6060172319412231,
0.5175104141235352,
0.009186975657939911,
0.23457683622837067,
0.7557594776153564,
0.4764249622821808,
0.35683223605155945,
-0.31444984674453735,
0.8797409534454346,
0.16333438456058502,
-0.09422636777162552,
-0.3233167827129364,
-0.8760025501251221,
-0.7456896305084229,
-0.3815340995788574,
0.30383262038230896,
0.561970591545105,
-1.0245413780212402,
0.48143211007118225,
-0.10301841050386429,
-0.675729513168335,
-0.3900275230407715,
-0.1682845503091812,
0.34782469272613525,
0.6832711100578308,
0.4029754102230072,
-0.5817203521728516,
0.032383132725954056,
-0.7666199803352356,
0.018684817478060722,
-0.07284430414438248,
-0.08357121795415878,
0.21697092056274414,
0.45588791370391846,
0.22792866826057434,
0.9975837469100952,
-0.8166238069534302,
-0.42580723762512207,
-0.03222712129354477,
0.3342074155807495,
-0.04815232753753662,
0.5028880834579468,
0.7822456359863281,
-0.6672249436378479,
-0.8431301116943359,
-0.09403369575738907,
-0.2895492613315582,
-0.04089752957224846,
-0.09798424690961838,
-0.07945847511291504,
0.018764782696962357,
0.0632137581706047,
-0.7736397385597229,
0.568668782711029,
0.6587445139884949,
-0.43510669469833374,
0.5367063283920288,
0.17220288515090942,
0.5425142645835876,
-1.3793727159500122,
-0.1455434411764145,
0.034865301102399826,
-0.47653287649154663,
-0.9615740180015564,
-0.21868877112865448,
-0.08963131904602051,
-0.24478642642498016,
-0.7014923095703125,
0.6185206770896912,
-0.45779386162757874,
0.017440738156437874,
-0.276779443025589,
0.22824221849441528,
-0.04237986356019974,
0.911808967590332,
0.06647706776857376,
1.219573974609375,
0.7949164509773254,
-0.6924379467964172,
0.4461151361465454,
0.41155317425727844,
-0.341452032327652,
1.0468995571136475,
-0.37626180052757263,
0.4607389569282532,
0.5102986693382263,
0.17686118185520172,
-0.9642255306243896,
-0.02521221712231636,
0.12179958075284958,
-0.620675802230835,
0.19062601029872894,
-0.6176912188529968,
-0.056838441640138626,
0.025149349123239517,
-0.08898162096738815,
0.34634509682655334,
0.593551516532898,
0.11558917164802551,
0.5473070740699768,
0.5016464591026306,
-0.18561610579490662,
-0.4772031307220459,
-0.4307771921157837,
0.14386966824531555,
0.1299053281545639,
-0.6099135279655457,
0.514714241027832,
-0.0342278778553009,
0.0720151886343956,
0.06128982454538345,
-0.6584057211875916,
-0.44329509139060974,
-0.003882765769958496,
0.21138842403888702,
0.37613555788993835,
-0.3274868428707123,
-0.10087159276008606,
-0.14302857220172882,
-0.3505459427833557,
-0.26156431436538696,
-0.28918978571891785,
0.6864835023880005,
0.20500527322292328,
-0.709460437297821,
-0.6803100109100342,
0.5247840881347656,
0.7985802888870239,
-0.005381503142416477,
0.7080456018447876,
0.23720376193523407,
-0.1638089269399643,
-0.3042767643928528,
-0.613279402256012,
-0.08797351270914078,
-0.4303884506225586,
0.07629004865884781,
-0.7460257411003113,
-0.6787019968032837,
0.3602939546108246,
-0.200227752327919,
0.025441789999604225,
0.5416851043701172,
0.23648743331432343,
-0.0820443257689476,
0.9376035928726196,
1.0428431034088135,
0.04987609386444092,
0.5062596797943115,
-0.14710135757923126,
0.23515774309635162,
-0.9956082105636597,
-0.2060004025697708,
-0.23715734481811523,
-0.23822949826717377,
0.058074504137039185,
-0.6722639799118042,
0.4275972247123718,
0.2576836943626404,
0.11498664319515228,
0.684733510017395,
-0.2848898768424988,
0.5400991439819336,
0.8792083263397217,
0.0782661959528923,
0.5167084336280823,
-0.02714790590107441,
0.10159569978713989,
-0.10896681249141693,
-0.5931823253631592,
-0.047452542930841446,
0.8438783884048462,
-0.1462375670671463,
0.670698881149292,
0.1347777098417282,
0.4732986092567444,
0.617267370223999,
-0.38893482089042664,
-1.0313752889633179,
0.8136821985244751,
0.002088929293677211,
-0.6580933928489685,
-0.2046930342912674,
-0.17484907805919647,
-0.304926335811615,
0.27907687425613403,
-0.23513352870941162,
-1.0080727338790894,
0.369651198387146,
-0.008823520503938198,
-0.6546877026557922,
0.5303971767425537,
-0.5520893931388855,
0.42962896823883057,
0.010952558368444443,
-0.024548429995775223,
-0.41245895624160767,
-0.5132786631584167,
0.4448138475418091,
-0.2535051107406616,
-0.44529983401298523,
-0.6695399284362793,
-0.04415910691022873,
0.637008547782898,
-0.4893531799316406,
0.7841629385948181,
-0.23368719220161438,
-0.131400927901268,
0.2792375087738037,
0.34388384222984314,
0.38341617584228516,
-0.30393216013908386,
-0.05802939459681511,
0.37222686409950256,
0.14755727350711823,
-0.6032683253288269,
-0.8091158270835876,
0.33716362714767456,
-0.5565714836120605,
-0.8368574976921082,
-0.5300328731536865,
-0.5957638025283813,
-0.7197045087814331,
0.18088823556900024,
0.2193705439567566,
0.5958197116851807,
-0.09642156213521957,
0.13367734849452972,
0.653693675994873,
0.17813467979431152,
0.19990228116512299,
1.0205594301223755,
0.18204021453857422,
-0.3042502999305725,
0.7246634364128113,
0.14773105084896088,
0.8245978951454163,
0.2753753960132599,
-0.2687573730945587,
-0.10718927532434464,
-0.4514037072658539,
-0.5875949859619141,
-0.044580958783626556,
-0.44270992279052734,
-0.50872802734375,
-0.6451678276062012,
-0.6499432325363159,
-0.5459175705909729,
-0.23801812529563904,
-0.5982031226158142,
-0.8772144317626953,
0.050147946923971176,
-0.1176602691411972,
0.48596128821372986,
0.38458314538002014,
-0.019526075571775436,
0.5115829110145569,
-0.9286446571350098,
0.49509942531585693,
0.4557042717933655,
0.18822364509105682,
-0.40959593653678894,
-0.7441476583480835,
0.0010728498455137014,
0.3944389224052429,
-0.3914894163608551,
-0.8993313908576965,
0.23808319866657257,
0.270183801651001,
0.5877500176429749,
0.3391251266002655,
0.18500280380249023,
1.1997941732406616,
-0.2799524664878845,
1.1459693908691406,
0.6322941184043884,
-1.236035704612732,
0.7125284671783447,
-0.6218733787536621,
0.18173553049564362,
0.43590083718299866,
0.29161423444747925,
-0.7081547975540161,
-0.37872642278671265,
-0.7876605987548828,
-0.41992393136024475,
1.0902884006500244,
0.22236333787441254,
0.055589668452739716,
0.2714007794857025,
0.022215932607650757,
0.29571738839149475,
0.34761276841163635,
-0.10120777785778046,
-0.2755979597568512,
0.17739851772785187,
0.19809816777706146,
0.23986925184726715,
-0.22098173201084137,
-0.39829888939857483,
-0.14709576964378357,
0.8717117309570312,
-0.2644502818584442,
0.3975512981414795,
0.19994695484638214,
-0.009238909929990768,
-0.16689461469650269,
0.2940960228443146,
0.8960626125335693,
0.8358516693115234,
-0.3129951059818268,
-0.14792202413082123,
0.15873855352401733,
-0.4920102059841156,
0.42766132950782776,
-0.23841388523578644,
-0.3456595838069916,
0.03763945400714874,
0.24391384422779083,
1.0396267175674438,
0.0879826694726944,
-0.3951958417892456,
0.7616643905639648,
0.21168337762355804,
-0.5307604670524597,
-0.0876728817820549,
0.5206655263900757,
-0.30697140097618103,
0.18380703032016754,
0.5045355558395386,
0.7696488499641418,
0.10438244789838791,
-0.5777149796485901,
0.31979653239250183,
0.32724639773368835,
-0.5465752482414246,
-0.6591374278068542,
0.5264570713043213,
0.6364175081253052,
-0.423108845949173,
0.4627583920955658,
-0.10463624447584152,
-0.6421862244606018,
0.6709692478179932,
0.5778107047080994,
0.902059018611908,
-0.38977953791618347,
0.45659124851226807,
0.06242189183831215,
-0.0867014229297638,
-0.2333967536687851,
0.15864717960357666,
-0.18326973915100098,
-0.987910807132721,
-0.6174497604370117,
-0.2606070935726166,
-0.8493566513061523,
0.15585406124591827,
-0.7923619747161865,
0.4809606671333313,
-0.20179761946201324,
-0.2686629295349121,
-0.017783869057893753,
0.051421478390693665,
-0.4898603558540344,
0.07693740725517273,
0.2592841684818268,
0.970506489276886,
-0.9197744727134705,
1.1301954984664917,
0.6226186752319336,
-0.32545238733291626,
-0.6217707991600037,
0.05901912599802017,
0.3264281749725342,
-1.0677319765090942,
0.3554590344429016,
-0.16351649165153503,
-0.4289594292640686,
0.16010119020938873,
-0.30723249912261963,
-0.8237625956535339,
1.057477355003357,
0.3345411419868469,
-0.5155685544013977,
0.10973542928695679,
-0.158646360039711,
0.40558093786239624,
-0.20548872649669647,
0.27164342999458313,
0.5411785244941711,
0.15339314937591553,
0.5388522148132324,
-1.2579621076583862,
-0.178548201918602,
-0.18735429644584656,
-0.4327731728553772,
0.5506165623664856,
-0.9252794981002808,
0.8212823867797852,
-0.04385066404938698,
-0.36767929792404175,
-0.014534905552864075,
0.3965514302253723,
0.03330712765455246,
0.418236643075943,
0.6343836784362793,
0.5384983420372009,
0.7172095775604248,
-0.007232361007481813,
0.589831531047821,
-0.38743123412132263,
0.24879318475723267,
1.2668205499649048,
-0.5256420373916626,
0.6447128653526306,
0.37272536754608154,
-0.32420438528060913,
0.4404089152812958,
0.39040127396583557,
-0.11157874763011932,
0.7542892694473267,
-0.48368677496910095,
-0.6750640869140625,
-0.38726481795310974,
-0.24601030349731445,
-0.4878407418727875,
0.3549312949180603,
0.4719652831554413,
0.23750057816505432,
-0.1853867918252945,
-0.10864478349685669,
-0.11465202271938324,
-0.23365123569965363,
-0.13677121698856354,
0.9036840796470642,
0.07018938660621643,
-0.7710029482841492,
0.23602843284606934,
-0.24850288033485413,
0.6760994791984558,
-0.8739638328552246,
-0.11830595135688782,
-0.4138818681240082,
0.06276492029428482,
-0.08494805544614792,
-0.762175977230072,
0.1275182068347931,
-0.17490431666374207,
-0.10208818316459656,
-0.26687148213386536,
0.8742295503616333,
-0.6064149737358093,
-0.2621186375617981,
0.08547080308198929,
0.9176566004753113,
0.22495336830615997,
-0.24877594411373138,
-0.6572331786155701,
-0.6529400944709778,
0.2936322093009949,
-0.1439119130373001,
0.44521617889404297,
0.5024593472480774,
0.0012188989203423262,
0.7421340942382812,
0.6807789206504822,
0.3526853919029236,
0.18947942554950714,
-0.16648928821086884,
0.8553675413131714,
-0.8431291580200195,
-0.5411507487297058,
-0.6852483749389648,
0.5302506685256958,
-0.28320032358169556,
-0.5169944763183594,
0.7902660369873047,
0.33243945240974426,
0.577118992805481,
-0.06111031025648117,
0.8645005822181702,
-0.4088805615901947,
0.5791010856628418,
-0.5317150950431824,
0.36061131954193115,
-0.5033506751060486,
0.03907979652285576,
-0.0702754482626915,
-1.1034932136535645,
0.13508513569831848,
0.146744966506958,
-0.02794141136109829,
-0.2936960756778717,
0.7138022780418396,
0.7293465733528137,
-0.4262365698814392,
0.0974414050579071,
0.7887025475502014,
-0.08637569844722748,
0.34487879276275635,
0.6845796704292297,
0.883069634437561,
-0.5540285706520081,
0.3068035840988159,
-0.456013023853302,
-0.15099729597568512,
-0.14778974652290344,
-0.7530745267868042,
-0.8761946558952332,
-0.627471387386322,
-0.6871742606163025,
0.13180358707904816,
-0.07115762680768967,
0.8660554885864258,
1.1731548309326172,
-0.8002052307128906,
0.03700725734233856,
0.11404456198215485,
-0.2064153552055359,
-0.3516649901866913,
-0.30878615379333496,
0.19349093735218048,
-0.22779376804828644,
-0.9134565591812134,
0.8438761830329895,
0.5653409361839294,
0.17576634883880615,
-0.16251443326473236,
0.18777036666870117,
-0.21814540028572083,
0.2766602635383606,
0.4847141206264496,
0.30428358912467957,
-0.6446061730384827,
-0.2099500298500061,
-0.1269153356552124,
-0.04291379451751709,
0.010451599024236202,
1.0511701107025146,
-0.7598245739936829,
0.41004398465156555,
0.5797144770622253,
0.52036452293396,
0.577055037021637,
0.40097686648368835,
1.0731467008590698,
-0.8999313712120056,
0.4107889235019684,
0.2626326382160187,
0.3383975923061371,
0.03227453678846359,
-0.3739370107650757,
0.9466255903244019,
0.7215863466262817,
-0.41228240728378296,
-0.7396975159645081,
0.21418388187885284,
-1.2688041925430298,
-0.14133526384830475,
1.100761890411377,
-0.2909083664417267,
0.20154869556427002,
-0.34873682260513306,
-0.24184221029281616,
-0.06179242208600044,
-0.7292876243591309,
0.5284679532051086,
0.8035434484481812,
-0.40649744868278503,
-0.19676542282104492,
-0.814399242401123,
0.4577445983886719,
0.442802369594574,
-0.6669822931289673,
-0.3290256857872009,
0.4218846261501312,
0.35606759786605835,
0.2437366098165512,
1.0913100242614746,
0.20945879817008972,
0.0699937492609024,
0.2577957808971405,
0.08319389075040817,
-0.24214044213294983,
-0.24827256798744202,
-0.029484879225492477,
0.009042302146553993,
-0.5123571753501892,
-0.5075383186340332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08555v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08555v2
|
RLHF Deciphered: A Critical Analysis of Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback for LLMs
| 2024-04-12T15:54:15 | 2024-04-16T00:22:16 |
Shreyas Chaudhari, Pranjal Aggarwal, Vishvak Murahari, Tanmay Rajpurohit, Ashwin Kalyan, Karthik Narasimhan, Ameet Deshpande, Bruno Castro da Silva
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
State-of-the-art large language models (LLMs) have become indispensable tools
for various tasks. However, training LLMs to serve as effective assistants for
humans requires careful consideration. A promising approach is reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF), which leverages human feedback to update
the model in accordance with human preferences and mitigate issues like
toxicity and hallucinations. Yet, an understanding of RLHF for LLMs is largely
entangled with initial design choices that popularized the method and current
research focuses on augmenting those choices rather than fundamentally
improving the framework. In this paper, we analyze RLHF through the lens of
reinforcement learning principles to develop an understanding of its
fundamentals, dedicating substantial focus to the core component of RLHF -- the
reward model. Our study investigates modeling choices, caveats of function
approximation, and their implications on RLHF training algorithms, highlighting
the underlying assumptions made about the expressivity of reward. Our analysis
improves the understanding of the role of reward models and methods for their
training, concurrently revealing limitations of the current methodology. We
characterize these limitations, including incorrect generalization, model
misspecification, and the sparsity of feedback, along with their impact on the
performance of a language model. The discussion and analysis are substantiated
by a categorical review of current literature, serving as a reference for
researchers and practitioners to understand the challenges of RLHF and build
upon existing efforts.
|
[
-0.27116748690605164,
-0.7145465016365051,
0.5241862535476685,
0.0888577401638031,
-0.12473037838935852,
0.20684662461280823,
-0.28422093391418457,
-0.7277626395225525,
-0.0653814971446991,
0.773033857345581,
-0.8369380235671997,
-0.23744498193264008,
-0.658926248550415,
0.14384421706199646,
-0.01491332333534956,
0.8978865146636963,
-0.07795241475105286,
0.13254797458648682,
-0.20353278517723083,
-0.1339217722415924,
-0.40397894382476807,
-0.77659672498703,
-0.5904186964035034,
-0.7752543091773987,
0.7730979919433594,
0.49858948588371277,
0.5317890048027039,
0.6480604410171509,
0.40806740522384644,
0.21740803122520447,
-0.20203568041324615,
0.06986799091100693,
-0.7567175030708313,
0.19200536608695984,
0.15619038045406342,
-0.4742637872695923,
-0.0562622994184494,
-0.002683128695935011,
0.5642299056053162,
0.7594797015190125,
-0.4669176936149597,
-0.002106432570144534,
0.08458098769187927,
0.9033259749412537,
-0.6100439429283142,
0.3776813745498657,
-0.22237664461135864,
0.4299986958503723,
0.12906499207019806,
-0.24060694873332977,
-0.7102565765380859,
-0.24171872437000275,
0.26766830682754517,
-0.6011271476745605,
0.008675415068864822,
-0.007807042449712753,
0.5293321013450623,
0.37867501378059387,
-0.258713036775589,
-0.3229884207248688,
-0.8130833506584167,
0.7763686776161194,
-0.5996274948120117,
0.38951143622398376,
0.4861845076084137,
0.37512651085853577,
-0.3825864791870117,
-0.36855214834213257,
-0.1958562433719635,
-0.8507657051086426,
-0.16136713325977325,
-0.0715457946062088,
0.36346885561943054,
0.3978118300437927,
0.32225924730300903,
0.3026143014431,
-0.25752872228622437,
0.23423929512500763,
-0.314342200756073,
-0.14428801834583282,
0.5234794020652771,
0.18343007564544678,
0.1931786686182022,
-0.0711740255355835,
-0.4767543077468872,
-0.3813008964061737,
-0.8169438242912292,
0.4820649027824402,
0.4228851795196533,
0.21895447373390198,
-0.04345904663205147,
0.3230213224887848,
-0.11021362245082855,
0.5418959856033325,
-0.14360520243644714,
-0.2393198013305664,
0.019899960607290268,
0.11831733584403992,
-0.018343500792980194,
-0.11998744308948517,
0.5463248491287231,
0.21901752054691315,
0.2944270372390747,
-0.3804328143596649,
-0.47533097863197327,
-0.11053814738988876,
0.457294762134552,
-0.7651364207267761,
-0.07616157084703445,
0.08512578904628754,
-0.6859399676322937,
-0.5408372282981873,
0.10226277261972427,
-0.4463518559932709,
-0.6784902215003967,
-0.2609071731567383,
0.12425429373979568,
-0.159207284450531,
-0.4715867340564728,
0.0877598375082016,
-0.08809258043766022,
0.19159413874149323,
0.2968668043613434,
-1.0701367855072021,
0.48614269495010376,
0.8738086819648743,
0.40276598930358887,
-0.3376021087169647,
-0.575259804725647,
-0.5809210538864136,
-0.2152857929468155,
-0.26634734869003296,
0.7413549423217773,
-0.5599281787872314,
-0.6326408386230469,
0.17735429108142853,
-0.007557851728051901,
-0.07607651501893997,
-0.716788113117218,
0.5391284227371216,
-0.6880085468292236,
-0.06846973299980164,
-0.3524533212184906,
-0.47718217968940735,
-0.3040104806423187,
0.2977387309074402,
-0.7884070873260498,
0.7309169173240662,
0.10364788770675659,
-0.6784513592720032,
0.18517252802848816,
-0.4957863986492157,
-0.30915898084640503,
-0.045716580003499985,
-0.24308258295059204,
-0.29669618606567383,
0.20622119307518005,
-0.035239316523075104,
0.20389306545257568,
-0.20290185511112213,
0.2523522973060608,
-0.37692442536354065,
-0.5447422862052917,
0.7155001759529114,
-0.40624722838401794,
0.40625032782554626,
0.09476486593484879,
-0.2774122953414917,
0.4873262345790863,
-0.5312352776527405,
-0.0974014550447464,
0.19128720462322235,
-0.6497153639793396,
-0.002936291042715311,
0.15473462641239166,
0.13237237930297852,
0.053720325231552124,
0.012116021476686,
-0.34845054149627686,
-0.0285466518253088,
-0.5659446716308594,
0.5466006398200989,
0.8578844666481018,
0.11824379861354828,
0.4419832229614258,
-0.34852826595306396,
0.8577904105186462,
-0.330045223236084,
0.3511402904987335,
-0.10075175017118454,
0.05033168941736221,
-0.4814146161079407,
-0.11816961318254471,
0.409714937210083,
0.40981578826904297,
-0.44629913568496704,
0.12100403755903244,
0.05537591502070427,
-0.11762179434299469,
-0.5101940035820007,
0.15419429540634155,
0.5790905356407166,
0.2431287318468094,
0.2215992510318756,
-0.32172828912734985,
-0.5228299498558044,
-0.8964585065841675,
-0.2568081319332123,
-0.3406968414783478,
0.23349937796592712,
0.23189440369606018,
0.4769606292247772,
-0.20126916468143463,
0.7005308866500854,
-0.2833101749420166,
-0.13833829760551453,
-0.5243497490882874,
0.14629381895065308,
-0.045425087213516235,
0.26688775420188904,
0.014170149341225624,
-0.4736923575401306,
-0.05712784826755524,
-0.1293734908103943,
-0.5404772162437439,
0.13394606113433838,
-0.12620888650417328,
0.0812353566288948,
0.12670184671878815,
0.5417307019233704,
-0.37303411960601807,
0.3764807879924774,
0.33502650260925293,
-0.22881904244422913,
0.7640359401702881,
-0.326516717672348,
-0.137450709939003,
-0.26596423983573914,
-0.01339044887572527,
-0.24864889681339264,
-0.31201496720314026,
-0.42565345764160156,
0.29824793338775635,
-0.0785590335726738,
0.0775613859295845,
-0.31061026453971863,
0.5518272519111633,
-0.35279518365859985,
-0.09463891386985779,
-0.7299811840057373,
-0.0133278239518404,
-0.38134101033210754,
0.8455830812454224,
0.3411109149456024,
0.5256584882736206,
0.005021261516958475,
-0.5579342246055603,
0.32915574312210083,
0.04194408282637596,
-0.24320770800113678,
0.24032998085021973,
-0.7227385640144348,
0.07846379280090332,
-0.0037196173798292875,
0.309857577085495,
-0.6696619987487793,
-0.1223519966006279,
0.4673217833042145,
-0.505593478679657,
0.21380175650119781,
-0.028821999207139015,
-0.38405781984329224,
-0.12496823072433472,
-0.3491637110710144,
0.3433028757572174,
0.39836692810058594,
-0.5598825812339783,
0.4568426311016083,
0.6694515943527222,
0.11851446330547333,
-0.7587107419967651,
-0.29248958826065063,
-0.0935622900724411,
-0.16078199446201324,
-0.23150748014450073,
0.2614944577217102,
-0.0390390120446682,
-0.23824343085289001,
-0.15809598565101624,
-0.18125717341899872,
0.11137329041957855,
0.5005836486816406,
0.407949835062027,
0.26219502091407776,
0.2834569215774536,
0.09040874242782593,
-0.4128120243549347,
-0.3572564721107483,
0.5542008280754089,
0.08278687298297882,
0.3474840521812439,
-0.2081233114004135,
-0.3946095407009125,
-0.19670608639717102,
0.06975340098142624,
0.46894922852516174,
-0.14314068853855133,
0.4144476652145386,
0.5169817805290222,
-0.15790028870105743,
-0.4545258581638336,
-0.24635130167007446,
-0.6221463680267334,
-0.4139672517776489,
0.5530976057052612,
-0.1451287418603897,
-0.9392708539962769,
0.36445483565330505,
-0.14643718302249908,
0.12308934330940247,
0.020386284217238426,
0.4716785252094269,
-0.04926999285817146,
0.940703809261322,
0.7649164199829102,
-0.10109338164329529,
0.5470795631408691,
-0.11409878730773926,
-0.06888314336538315,
-0.8097584843635559,
-0.45315611362457275,
-0.2728387117385864,
-0.21898029744625092,
-0.5485661625862122,
-0.24501314759254456,
0.10984847694635391,
-0.06683100759983063,
-0.1907629370689392,
-0.10127551853656769,
-0.2654064893722534,
0.47613492608070374,
0.5586727261543274,
0.2819087505340576,
0.32109925150871277,
-0.06470044702291489,
-0.15084651112556458,
-0.09880506247282028,
-0.733379065990448,
-0.2938854694366455,
0.9368495345115662,
0.8655113577842712,
1.018140435218811,
-0.010565957054495811,
0.7370257377624512,
0.44329431653022766,
0.2883666455745697,
-1.0582079887390137,
0.38644030690193176,
0.3446292281150818,
-0.24683156609535217,
-0.48013681173324585,
-0.36720526218414307,
-1.0097819566726685,
0.5364829897880554,
-0.2075793594121933,
-0.424258291721344,
-0.0706435814499855,
0.16058197617530823,
-0.29391053318977356,
0.08057714253664017,
-0.4824342727661133,
0.8787904977798462,
-0.3962234854698181,
-0.357143759727478,
-0.5691394209861755,
-0.7840564846992493,
0.5349632501602173,
0.4275386929512024,
0.35760706663131714,
0.0274471715092659,
0.22298863530158997,
1.0146578550338745,
-0.4021817147731781,
1.0751473903656006,
-0.2764424979686737,
-0.34026917815208435,
0.12265849113464355,
0.13270117342472076,
0.5340030789375305,
0.068827785551548,
0.3896915316581726,
-0.28166821599006653,
0.2151677906513214,
-0.32290899753570557,
-0.6349931955337524,
0.3965001106262207,
-0.8770416975021362,
-0.5809521675109863,
-0.4873363673686981,
-0.443830281496048,
-0.4973463714122772,
-0.16449306905269623,
-0.10297029465436935,
0.33625271916389465,
-0.3669847846031189,
0.04036513343453407,
0.9554949998855591,
-0.1924433559179306,
0.17448340356349945,
0.41964519023895264,
-0.5361316204071045,
-0.4991469979286194,
0.8930423855781555,
-0.3752737045288086,
0.3043157756328583,
0.45056694746017456,
0.14465656876564026,
-0.5208916664123535,
-0.4755948483943939,
-0.26773276925086975,
0.5631080865859985,
-1.0021930932998657,
0.29880809783935547,
-0.1807788908481598,
-0.09838798642158508,
0.07295473664999008,
0.19532905519008636,
-0.32375362515449524,
-0.1572047621011734,
-0.3438926935195923,
-0.20414544641971588,
0.05322347581386566,
1.1487526893615723,
-0.017856430262327194,
0.042018450796604156,
-0.7314050793647766,
0.22304856777191162,
0.44505754113197327,
0.40521565079689026,
0.40839722752571106,
-0.5755959749221802,
-0.42487719655036926,
-0.07676760852336884,
-0.07123338431119919,
-0.9383663535118103,
0.12353431433439255,
-0.26223552227020264,
0.7736180424690247,
0.2450786530971527,
0.12108296155929565,
0.3958550989627838,
-0.23919150233268738,
0.562947154045105,
0.21608324348926544,
-0.7007655501365662,
0.19485709071159363,
-0.055381890386343,
0.11713699251413345,
0.5515193343162537,
-0.025162460282444954,
-0.8588961362838745,
-0.18759317696094513,
-0.6474084854125977,
-0.6443414688110352,
0.7330778241157532,
-0.2775214612483978,
-0.13362820446491241,
0.21632389724254608,
0.3631877899169922,
0.2507617175579071,
0.1451236605644226,
-0.9534755945205688,
-0.15448296070098877,
-0.01060779020190239,
-0.003412680933251977,
0.11921780556440353,
-0.45618805289268494,
-0.33929771184921265,
-0.11641152203083038,
0.5082908272743225,
-0.12979243695735931,
0.28168371319770813,
0.07272851467132568,
-0.4250982999801636,
-0.25882235169410706,
0.36886754631996155,
0.8064528703689575,
0.654390811920166,
-0.31695356965065,
0.1975170224905014,
0.08080080151557922,
-0.37154555320739746,
0.18849176168441772,
-0.14696668088436127,
0.07077310979366302,
-0.29335230588912964,
0.6835605502128601,
1.0605182647705078,
0.45431777834892273,
-1.164202094078064,
0.37337592244148254,
-0.2141263335943222,
-0.3360477387905121,
-0.31426626443862915,
0.19891251623630524,
0.03610233590006828,
0.29548728466033936,
0.3141288161277771,
-0.10501875728368759,
-0.030325008556246758,
-0.5062334537506104,
0.14667803049087524,
0.5012937784194946,
-0.8036235570907593,
-0.33432161808013916,
0.27017834782600403,
0.3127009868621826,
-0.36887267231941223,
0.5061940550804138,
-0.055382341146469116,
-0.7665554285049438,
0.5516964197158813,
0.29953891038894653,
0.9485651850700378,
0.07372277230024338,
0.5143213272094727,
0.16396600008010864,
0.3239361345767975,
-0.2386993169784546,
-0.023989032953977585,
-0.38841959834098816,
-0.6248315572738647,
-0.5746533870697021,
-0.50562584400177,
-0.7876337170600891,
0.17025083303451538,
-0.8019430637359619,
-0.18473868072032928,
-0.5585296154022217,
0.01609094813466072,
-0.4763503074645996,
0.01814049296081066,
-0.27750542759895325,
-0.04112538322806358,
0.2491515427827835,
0.6988165378570557,
-0.6059200763702393,
0.6666129231452942,
0.5200552940368652,
-0.47111567854881287,
-0.8377873301506042,
-0.002609426388517022,
-0.19019809365272522,
-0.9949416518211365,
0.8976702094078064,
0.004444375168532133,
-0.3576580584049225,
-0.21027244627475739,
-0.4224216938018799,
-0.5338849425315857,
0.895920991897583,
0.17987088859081268,
-0.4298494756221771,
-0.17049725353717804,
0.08857709169387817,
0.4909410774707794,
-0.40722304582595825,
0.34678515791893005,
0.8777897953987122,
0.4495363235473633,
0.10344834625720978,
-0.8848920464515686,
0.20899690687656403,
-0.04762943834066391,
0.13669678568840027,
-0.037232398986816406,
-0.35284584760665894,
0.4638165533542633,
-0.4885985851287842,
-0.2463756650686264,
-0.068365678191185,
0.5942156910896301,
0.5393507480621338,
-0.0805334523320198,
0.6215264797210693,
0.3149378001689911,
0.694930374622345,
0.20649388432502747,
0.9903739094734192,
-0.04202195256948471,
0.4892195165157318,
0.9361414909362793,
-0.1046697124838829,
0.9490681290626526,
0.6498402953147888,
-0.4141322374343872,
0.4832595884799957,
0.8819400668144226,
0.30299198627471924,
0.7120975255966187,
0.6710845828056335,
-0.05923145264387131,
-0.2644519805908203,
-0.03690095245838165,
-0.38339856266975403,
0.0414203517138958,
0.3151816725730896,
-0.2647821009159088,
-0.2589645981788635,
0.08529914915561676,
-0.14540855586528778,
0.1178589016199112,
-0.2534065544605255,
0.871057391166687,
0.150913268327713,
-0.8632475733757019,
0.8526269197463989,
0.026650341227650642,
0.606661319732666,
-0.41066011786460876,
-0.27582699060440063,
-0.13236530125141144,
0.22283758223056793,
-0.0688062459230423,
-0.5934396982192993,
0.028968024998903275,
-0.3066732883453369,
-0.08771252632141113,
-0.3429597318172455,
0.639910876750946,
-0.35913294553756714,
0.05113980919122696,
0.47845056653022766,
0.38243117928504944,
-0.05006732791662216,
-0.02467186748981476,
-0.8447076082229614,
0.358603835105896,
0.16358043253421783,
-0.22565485537052155,
0.4873802363872528,
-0.016479987651109695,
0.2307567000389099,
0.8475430607795715,
0.47780993580818176,
0.22481326758861542,
-0.20343759655952454,
0.0501529797911644,
0.6070683598518372,
-0.8954613208770752,
-0.5806329250335693,
-0.8149271011352539,
0.21874269843101501,
0.25087547302246094,
-0.18257664144039154,
0.24111631512641907,
0.07048746198415756,
0.7850452065467834,
-0.2753370702266693,
0.8162168264389038,
0.4738490581512451,
0.509125828742981,
-0.7651189565658569,
0.5085922479629517,
-0.29841217398643494,
0.48629724979400635,
0.1617775559425354,
-0.5355960726737976,
-0.13737748563289642,
0.7016512751579285,
-0.3843308985233307,
0.0368967242538929,
0.8770761489868164,
0.7342304587364197,
0.36052677035331726,
0.16022907197475433,
0.3024532198905945,
0.04299776256084442,
0.3359015882015228,
0.586950421333313,
1.349626064300537,
-0.016674978658556938,
0.6133434176445007,
-0.23366999626159668,
-0.1434490978717804,
-0.4833410084247589,
-0.5817390084266663,
-0.9503401517868042,
-0.49171534180641174,
-0.10285801440477371,
-0.4208007752895355,
0.07812130451202393,
1.1298688650131226,
0.6518155932426453,
-0.6318473815917969,
-0.6644302010536194,
-0.2986973524093628,
0.6114934682846069,
-0.3590104579925537,
-0.21112152934074402,
0.2517523765563965,
-0.4611999988555908,
-0.38404130935668945,
0.3907560408115387,
0.12145058810710907,
-0.07649781554937363,
-0.7364976406097412,
-0.7126722931861877,
0.13572421669960022,
-0.14820970594882965,
0.48382410407066345,
0.6956771612167358,
-1.0882302522659302,
-0.19980311393737793,
0.03775159269571304,
-0.10954112559556961,
-0.012552816420793533,
1.0702744722366333,
-0.8197917342185974,
0.21481071412563324,
0.38687583804130554,
0.8908161520957947,
0.39100712537765503,
-0.04542610049247742,
0.5561879277229309,
-0.47339338064193726,
0.007152899634093046,
0.2542761564254761,
0.13422071933746338,
0.2854726314544678,
-0.2696421444416046,
0.36984673142433167,
0.3628624379634857,
-0.5735563635826111,
-1.0563405752182007,
0.5683650374412537,
-0.7836706042289734,
-0.5668969750404358,
1.0762405395507812,
0.06293867528438568,
-0.39718863368034363,
-0.1280258595943451,
-0.3904929757118225,
-0.0636383518576622,
-0.4746168255805969,
0.9880696535110474,
0.7341834902763367,
-0.25705960392951965,
-0.5238121151924133,
-0.5185220241546631,
0.8450986742973328,
0.5108721852302551,
-0.6668992638587952,
0.4483993649482727,
0.45973658561706543,
0.23907648026943207,
-0.18217024207115173,
0.7982372045516968,
0.02787543274462223,
0.5252131819725037,
-0.250388503074646,
0.12334377318620682,
-0.19559462368488312,
-0.27969351410865784,
-0.5436835885047913,
0.2941741347312927,
0.8024148941040039,
-0.08598916977643967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08538v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08538v1
|
VertAttack: Taking advantage of Text Classifiers' horizontal vision
| 2024-04-12T15:32:17 | 2024-04-12T15:32:17 |
Jonathan Rusert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Text classification systems have continuously improved in performance over
the years. However, nearly all current SOTA classifiers have a similar
shortcoming, they process text in a horizontal manner. Vertically written words
will not be recognized by a classifier. In contrast, humans are easily able to
recognize and read words written both horizontally and vertically. Hence, a
human adversary could write problematic words vertically and the meaning would
still be preserved to other humans. We simulate such an attack, VertAttack.
VertAttack identifies which words a classifier is reliant on and then rewrites
those words vertically. We find that VertAttack is able to greatly drop the
accuracy of 4 different transformer models on 5 datasets. For example, on the
SST2 dataset, VertAttack is able to drop RoBERTa's accuracy from 94 to 13%.
Furthermore, since VertAttack does not replace the word, meaning is easily
preserved. We verify this via a human study and find that crowdworkers are able
to correctly label 77% perturbed texts perturbed, compared to 81% of the
original texts. We believe VertAttack offers a look into how humans might
circumvent classifiers in the future and thus inspire a look into more robust
algorithms.
|
[
-0.11230070888996124,
-0.7806110382080078,
0.4390351474285126,
-0.013414931483566761,
-0.21599125862121582,
0.18145987391471863,
-0.1285628080368042,
-0.781247079372406,
0.1843540072441101,
0.854304313659668,
-0.6052590608596802,
-0.48098716139793396,
-0.7154625058174133,
0.18184489011764526,
-0.613563060760498,
1.2243069410324097,
-0.053900521248579025,
-0.07174555957317352,
-0.10726133733987808,
0.0016148720169439912,
-0.6122362613677979,
-0.7124554514884949,
-0.42611658573150635,
-0.4140084385871887,
0.7009499669075012,
0.6229903697967529,
0.6160928010940552,
0.5556653141975403,
0.6706575751304626,
0.41101688146591187,
-0.11611247807741165,
-0.19628632068634033,
-0.7926750779151917,
0.3044012486934662,
0.11006050556898117,
-0.7309237122535706,
-0.015328094363212585,
0.11285526305437088,
0.7455220818519592,
0.25939658284187317,
-0.1608455777168274,
0.21950294077396393,
0.26420217752456665,
0.8839627504348755,
-0.5525885224342346,
-0.13173148036003113,
-0.7158322930335999,
0.29115450382232666,
-0.6541737914085388,
-0.1934022605419159,
-0.45444899797439575,
-0.4478897452354431,
0.2054804414510727,
-0.48143649101257324,
0.14541293680667877,
-0.005338935647159815,
1.230151653289795,
0.5132787227630615,
-0.09799855947494507,
-0.1272890865802765,
-0.6389433145523071,
0.7311119437217712,
0.08451879024505615,
0.19950400292873383,
0.5103433132171631,
0.8047310709953308,
0.029496250674128532,
-1.0685845613479614,
-0.5678342580795288,
-0.12078750133514404,
0.028130700811743736,
0.45244669914245605,
-0.3601468801498413,
-0.2766609787940979,
0.19647808372974396,
0.2143884301185608,
-0.3687116205692291,
0.12750668823719025,
-0.6925017237663269,
-0.18825317919254303,
0.40168941020965576,
0.3328076899051666,
0.24199052155017853,
-0.4049380123615265,
-0.9634026885032654,
-0.2816891670227051,
-0.5292384624481201,
0.20980660617351532,
0.5242811441421509,
-0.06150120869278908,
0.36943650245666504,
0.6476978659629822,
0.12029565870761871,
0.5709421634674072,
-0.10286145657300949,
0.008837585337460041,
0.10338393598794937,
-0.13372236490249634,
-0.5576673150062561,
0.17068515717983246,
0.4711713492870331,
0.3091824948787689,
0.09399531036615372,
0.031404584646224976,
0.06615212559700012,
0.16870805621147156,
0.8270902633666992,
-0.49411505460739136,
-0.24770332872867584,
-0.13457942008972168,
-0.4871140718460083,
-0.6026492714881897,
-0.0060013532638549805,
-0.8723956942558289,
-0.9363468885421753,
-0.30385279655456543,
0.6406410336494446,
-0.3706374168395996,
0.18092389404773712,
0.21564140915870667,
-0.4090961813926697,
0.21479208767414093,
0.46547970175743103,
-0.5728745460510254,
0.11532550305128098,
0.7987183928489685,
0.7175551652908325,
0.09156553447246552,
-0.5307365655899048,
-0.31564533710479736,
-0.06173808127641678,
0.046468596905469894,
0.9496098160743713,
-0.4042171537876129,
-0.4730326533317566,
-0.08404826372861862,
-0.0823083445429802,
0.15185001492500305,
-0.26971709728240967,
0.6630288362503052,
-0.23078066110610962,
0.41130831837654114,
-0.38057243824005127,
-0.3663399815559387,
-0.1663389950990677,
0.35122206807136536,
-0.5431228280067444,
0.9171792268753052,
-0.07594593614339828,
-1.2783002853393555,
0.5265749096870422,
-0.20057201385498047,
-0.38602545857429504,
0.20134252309799194,
-0.19987399876117706,
-0.7228530049324036,
0.179935485124588,
-0.27816659212112427,
0.2549462914466858,
-0.1916629523038864,
-0.2317831814289093,
-0.10035406798124313,
-0.18151694536209106,
0.17212699353694916,
-0.423324316740036,
1.107897162437439,
0.071706123650074,
-0.3902173340320587,
0.024697717279195786,
-0.4176896810531616,
-0.038480255752801895,
-0.013110753148794174,
-0.4762820601463318,
-0.668673038482666,
0.04479711875319481,
0.28126972913742065,
-0.18894749879837036,
0.17396314442157745,
-0.5940936207771301,
0.15822169184684753,
-0.14888165891170502,
0.1679213047027588,
0.9066002368927002,
-0.4597127139568329,
0.2825515866279602,
-0.3834149241447449,
0.543490469455719,
-0.5020748972892761,
0.2378951758146286,
0.26126420497894287,
-0.6488021016120911,
-0.6196995973587036,
-0.6228730082511902,
0.24001161754131317,
0.7572455406188965,
-0.7655481696128845,
0.12275653332471848,
-0.30738118290901184,
-0.8236416578292847,
-0.33855485916137695,
0.2066330760717392,
0.5338668823242188,
0.7067064046859741,
0.16659922897815704,
-0.2691284120082855,
-0.9311946034431458,
-0.8674800395965576,
-0.6737370491027832,
-0.2843686044216156,
-0.1995726376771927,
-0.025651471689343452,
0.3819557726383209,
-0.418154776096344,
0.8167266249656677,
-0.4968847632408142,
-0.69289231300354,
-0.26534053683280945,
0.21881502866744995,
-0.03161599114537239,
0.21580180525779724,
0.33883944153785706,
-0.8243534564971924,
-0.33989500999450684,
0.10627531260251999,
-0.7939671277999878,
-0.04065258055925369,
-0.02283349446952343,
-0.23746484518051147,
0.39502668380737305,
0.5524287223815918,
-0.16136743128299713,
0.8719884753227234,
0.5903206467628479,
-0.4916573166847229,
0.5256412029266357,
-0.523637592792511,
-0.07197742164134979,
-0.8694678544998169,
-0.11742357164621353,
0.1459655612707138,
-0.17624612152576447,
-0.8336220383644104,
-0.16190992295742035,
0.19909782707691193,
0.11802206188440323,
-0.2817201316356659,
0.18522050976753235,
-0.29404258728027344,
0.1166391521692276,
-0.29570242762565613,
0.09251264482736588,
-0.043174996972084045,
0.015121770091354847,
0.0823359414935112,
0.448387086391449,
0.14971444010734558,
-0.2520538568496704,
0.12999719381332397,
0.20391526818275452,
-0.5180382132530212,
0.8791714310646057,
-0.5343931913375854,
0.029011541977524757,
-0.34836575388908386,
0.4015694260597229,
-1.0134449005126953,
-0.2546951472759247,
0.030884644016623497,
-0.5621527433395386,
0.34104225039482117,
0.14141899347305298,
-0.49456530809402466,
-0.4882146120071411,
-0.5494041442871094,
-0.005392122082412243,
0.5135295391082764,
-0.7416226863861084,
0.7904532551765442,
0.8865221738815308,
0.07702898234128952,
-0.7144253253936768,
-1.0428402423858643,
0.47723034024238586,
-0.5116281509399414,
-0.6129825115203857,
0.11637740582227707,
0.4099195599555969,
-0.11151491105556488,
-0.3543078899383545,
-0.01342987734824419,
-0.1943386048078537,
0.2823537588119507,
0.6462236642837524,
0.2794322669506073,
0.20800964534282684,
0.26312723755836487,
-0.14658115804195404,
-0.33990833163261414,
0.09672579914331436,
-0.21902458369731903,
0.33723604679107666,
-0.4587287902832031,
-0.059841401875019073,
-0.6598491668701172,
0.07707905024290085,
0.34133589267730713,
-0.021444259211421013,
0.5903621912002563,
0.5528513193130493,
-0.45685380697250366,
-0.0008531144703738391,
-0.5506072640419006,
-0.1770547479391098,
-0.4927758276462555,
0.404381662607193,
-0.4196324348449707,
-0.7948382496833801,
0.3809039294719696,
0.2766686975955963,
0.023920558393001556,
0.3029594421386719,
0.5873806476593018,
-0.5177152752876282,
0.6787023544311523,
0.8250954747200012,
-0.2034807652235031,
0.5801319479942322,
-0.1646970808506012,
0.13836047053337097,
-0.42351484298706055,
-0.4450017213821411,
-1.0552175045013428,
-0.40080946683883667,
-0.7068881988525391,
-0.19514018297195435,
0.23812051117420197,
-0.22963087260723114,
-0.0005380032234825194,
0.5765336751937866,
-0.7767584323883057,
0.4835456907749176,
0.7511671185493469,
0.2913343906402588,
0.1628272831439972,
0.32342100143432617,
0.2192411720752716,
-0.35030585527420044,
-0.46168753504753113,
-0.6343550682067871,
0.8737130165100098,
0.5915955901145935,
0.7493789196014404,
-0.051776155829429626,
0.819467306137085,
0.30089351534843445,
0.5281819701194763,
-0.5147880911827087,
0.4004751741886139,
-0.3074512481689453,
-0.8439590930938721,
-0.48550736904144287,
-0.2592726945877075,
-1.0617964267730713,
0.08898215740919113,
-0.2542775273323059,
-0.920704185962677,
0.10008696466684341,
0.2645237445831299,
0.02663816325366497,
0.45095598697662354,
-0.8300718069076538,
0.8644033074378967,
-0.15245972573757172,
-0.4343754053115845,
-0.2246052622795105,
-0.6546341776847839,
0.37332475185394287,
-0.1261865496635437,
0.22223815321922302,
0.34487462043762207,
0.08548123389482498,
0.6117042303085327,
-0.5781635642051697,
1.1614502668380737,
-0.27335241436958313,
-0.21782343089580536,
0.39981794357299805,
-0.058870069682598114,
0.367167204618454,
-0.056460075080394745,
0.13744394481182098,
0.4863654673099518,
0.013126392848789692,
-0.43036818504333496,
-0.3900373876094818,
0.4103630483150482,
-0.7353529334068298,
-0.6260076761245728,
-0.46471482515335083,
-0.09551990032196045,
0.274094820022583,
0.2325589805841446,
0.5436250567436218,
0.34447765350341797,
-0.19696688652038574,
0.4564978778362274,
0.44458895921707153,
-0.07459123432636261,
0.008682540617883205,
-0.036269351840019226,
-0.3467731475830078,
-0.42888596653938293,
0.848888635635376,
0.3106970489025116,
0.033001892268657684,
0.4040611684322357,
0.5057039260864258,
-0.409939169883728,
-0.29899582266807556,
-0.270291805267334,
-0.15400606393814087,
-0.6644870042800903,
-0.279390811920166,
-0.5844091176986694,
0.00040569304837845266,
0.09308675676584244,
-0.35893765091896057,
-0.11349562555551529,
-0.33697429299354553,
0.025780094787478447,
-0.1933472752571106,
0.4159151315689087,
0.6403749585151672,
-0.14022225141525269,
0.3739670515060425,
-0.5226844549179077,
0.07492641359567642,
0.6052732467651367,
0.07175151258707047,
-0.45122915506362915,
-0.4993166923522949,
-0.13869087398052216,
-0.15831977128982544,
-0.18123939633369446,
-0.8169578313827515,
0.27533504366874695,
-0.2578912377357483,
0.3788134455680847,
0.24945814907550812,
-0.057777151465415955,
0.6699475646018982,
-0.5182973146438599,
0.44287437200546265,
0.3274465501308441,
-1.093156099319458,
0.4788312613964081,
-0.16821260750293732,
0.25552499294281006,
0.8654714822769165,
0.0714510902762413,
-0.5175656676292419,
-0.7531680464744568,
-0.5589575171470642,
-0.6605895757675171,
0.47724586725234985,
0.41581428050994873,
0.04448149725794792,
0.4106809198856354,
0.306187242269516,
0.3030715882778168,
0.033962346613407135,
-0.4977759122848511,
0.00535584706813097,
-0.6923766732215881,
-0.32671454548835754,
-0.16147474944591522,
-0.33027762174606323,
0.01420226227492094,
-0.21569983661174774,
0.27127060294151306,
0.13190117478370667,
0.14594747126102448,
0.34374427795410156,
-0.0931181088089943,
0.09206750243902206,
0.05681926757097244,
0.6768471598625183,
0.3338955044746399,
-0.07615911960601807,
0.5149772763252258,
0.4860225021839142,
-1.0261814594268799,
-0.01833539828658104,
-0.06197574362158775,
-0.28161293268203735,
-0.0037040524184703827,
0.3705947995185852,
0.5418221950531006,
0.09046059846878052,
-0.5633528232574463,
0.33313071727752686,
-0.5288076400756836,
-0.44728419184684753,
-0.6123641133308411,
-0.02873048186302185,
-0.12428732216358185,
0.30931952595710754,
0.4185698628425598,
0.27715325355529785,
0.15260566771030426,
-0.4408472180366516,
0.076234370470047,
0.3375014662742615,
-0.64375239610672,
-0.2214280664920807,
0.6098830699920654,
-0.06401795148849487,
-0.7141783833503723,
0.15695767104625702,
0.2733125686645508,
-0.8208694458007812,
0.6414048075675964,
0.23497232794761658,
0.8904138803482056,
-0.13652051985263824,
0.1706383228302002,
0.1104477196931839,
0.6018922328948975,
-0.22517706453800201,
0.169460728764534,
-0.20713575184345245,
-0.48223620653152466,
-0.2164781093597412,
-0.29716968536376953,
-0.5173942446708679,
-0.1913035809993744,
-0.646450400352478,
0.3635670840740204,
-0.6484457850456238,
-0.41372475028038025,
0.20141755044460297,
0.26145222783088684,
-0.6480419635772705,
0.14260725677013397,
0.08061856776475906,
0.7942972183227539,
-0.7197341918945312,
0.9313470125198364,
0.9855418801307678,
-0.18254543840885162,
-0.6452680826187134,
0.007046821061521769,
0.25850823521614075,
-0.6658915877342224,
0.8758976459503174,
0.5127003192901611,
-0.508776843547821,
-0.07170887291431427,
-0.6941934823989868,
-0.4790991544723511,
0.9996337890625,
0.07344838976860046,
-0.39807000756263733,
0.2174527794122696,
-0.03175247833132744,
0.868472158908844,
0.1371518224477768,
0.12390363961458206,
0.48765188455581665,
0.8250787258148193,
-0.26263079047203064,
-0.7651844620704651,
-0.10395371168851852,
-0.11465249955654144,
0.08704719692468643,
0.09361803531646729,
-0.5214002728462219,
0.7344737648963928,
0.09463492035865784,
-0.5560311675071716,
0.05221543461084366,
0.6374737024307251,
0.1581813544034958,
0.4885755181312561,
0.6479437947273254,
0.5309260487556458,
1.0174839496612549,
-0.12612363696098328,
1.2187113761901855,
0.28023529052734375,
0.3609776496887207,
0.8895549178123474,
-0.28830811381340027,
0.9299090504646301,
0.5710752606391907,
-0.06726770102977753,
0.6696081161499023,
0.10845034569501877,
-0.009766736999154091,
0.4904252290725708,
0.3927207589149475,
-0.09349652379751205,
-0.30450302362442017,
0.23654690384864807,
-0.19599027931690216,
0.8681997656822205,
0.1384718269109726,
0.07292232662439346,
-0.209559828042984,
0.271494060754776,
0.25885409116744995,
0.5604948401451111,
-0.07381641864776611,
0.5127031207084656,
-0.06111804395914078,
-0.44164958596229553,
0.5785265564918518,
-0.11884859949350357,
0.5680977702140808,
-0.22476676106452942,
0.30009064078330994,
-0.14668779075145721,
0.7226889729499817,
-0.16601639986038208,
-0.7958292365074158,
0.3563709557056427,
0.2360718548297882,
-0.16653549671173096,
-0.5508355498313904,
1.0085766315460205,
0.0010588850127533078,
-0.5642701387405396,
0.2053391933441162,
0.08530863374471664,
0.11925667524337769,
0.14459353685379028,
-0.4526188373565674,
0.06954050064086914,
0.0969010517001152,
-0.17467941343784332,
0.2242210954427719,
0.663220226764679,
-0.03876715153455734,
0.7082971334457397,
0.4012887179851532,
-0.09136848896741867,
0.17889243364334106,
-0.14353032410144806,
0.7237673997879028,
-0.7075262665748596,
-0.5097258687019348,
-0.8152735829353333,
0.4435253143310547,
-0.4537798762321472,
-0.4378058612346649,
1.1015660762786865,
0.4425504505634308,
0.7559158205986023,
-0.03616941720247269,
0.6904407143592834,
0.153800368309021,
0.7725278735160828,
-0.454472154378891,
0.9487083554267883,
-0.630644679069519,
0.13011077046394348,
-0.3293408155441284,
-0.5198211669921875,
-0.5848318934440613,
0.7220112681388855,
-0.46929728984832764,
-0.3667842745780945,
0.6868772506713867,
0.5169431567192078,
0.22527925670146942,
0.33165445923805237,
0.24046652019023895,
0.16981403529644012,
0.3034832775592804,
0.39949458837509155,
1.1291841268539429,
-0.3423961400985718,
0.8341305255889893,
-0.08016887307167053,
-0.4368651509284973,
-0.5823509693145752,
-0.6577998399734497,
-1.299142837524414,
-0.5586044788360596,
-0.13751398026943207,
-0.44657236337661743,
0.3060010075569153,
0.138602614402771,
0.3875885605812073,
-0.42848190665245056,
-0.16990239918231964,
-0.18772192299365997,
0.2720761001110077,
-0.11892945319414139,
-0.15155237913131714,
0.2428741753101349,
-0.3287343382835388,
-0.45102643966674805,
0.08659589290618896,
0.2779141962528229,
-0.0289475005120039,
-0.42020678520202637,
0.050010740756988525,
0.14283770322799683,
-0.17983491718769073,
0.44161468744277954,
0.3268127739429474,
-0.43832969665527344,
-0.6070989966392517,
-0.012896926142275333,
-0.40580204129219055,
0.041985370218753815,
0.7652219533920288,
-0.9095980525016785,
0.5158348679542542,
0.8225666880607605,
0.7612452507019043,
0.5967172384262085,
0.08908331394195557,
0.3496510088443756,
-0.37131211161613464,
0.1051112487912178,
0.1544603556394577,
0.09047434478998184,
0.14281699061393738,
-0.2754579782485962,
0.35046303272247314,
0.2187313586473465,
-0.5595331192016602,
-1.0144113302230835,
0.18455418944358826,
-0.5845276117324829,
-0.354078084230423,
0.803716242313385,
-0.024128282442688942,
-0.6717602014541626,
-0.1986405849456787,
-0.5741467475891113,
0.06979086250066757,
-0.13855238258838654,
1.1108160018920898,
0.49716612696647644,
0.3434430658817291,
-0.0010658582905307412,
-0.6449692845344543,
0.4056711196899414,
0.562181830406189,
-0.9073233008384705,
-0.02473265491425991,
0.45795899629592896,
0.13210029900074005,
0.43837717175483704,
0.41977083683013916,
0.039138391613960266,
0.31711435317993164,
0.18430259823799133,
0.0895228236913681,
0.05871414393186569,
-0.48624563217163086,
-0.46173208951950073,
0.35993701219558716,
-0.24045270681381226,
-0.37346941232681274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08517v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08517v1
|
Online Safety Analysis for LLMs: a Benchmark, an Assessment, and a Path Forward
| 2024-04-12T14:55:16 | 2024-04-12T14:55:16 |
Xuan Xie, Jiayang Song, Zhehua Zhou, Yuheng Huang, Da Song, Lei Ma
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) have seen widespread applications across
numerous fields, their limited interpretability poses concerns regarding their
safe operations from multiple aspects, e.g., truthfulness, robustness, and
fairness. Recent research has started developing quality assurance methods for
LLMs, introducing techniques such as offline detector-based or uncertainty
estimation methods. However, these approaches predominantly concentrate on
post-generation analysis, leaving the online safety analysis for LLMs during
the generation phase an unexplored area. To bridge this gap, we conduct in this
work a comprehensive evaluation of the effectiveness of existing online safety
analysis methods on LLMs. We begin with a pilot study that validates the
feasibility of detecting unsafe outputs in the early generation process.
Following this, we establish the first publicly available benchmark of online
safety analysis for LLMs, including a broad spectrum of methods, models, tasks,
datasets, and evaluation metrics. Utilizing this benchmark, we extensively
analyze the performance of state-of-the-art online safety analysis methods on
both open-source and closed-source LLMs. This analysis reveals the strengths
and weaknesses of individual methods and offers valuable insights into
selecting the most appropriate method based on specific application scenarios
and task requirements. Furthermore, we also explore the potential of using
hybridization methods, i.e., combining multiple methods to derive a collective
safety conclusion, to enhance the efficacy of online safety analysis for LLMs.
Our findings indicate a promising direction for the development of innovative
and trustworthy quality assurance methodologies for LLMs, facilitating their
reliable deployments across diverse domains.
|
[
-0.2784174084663391,
-0.8079470992088318,
0.6269223093986511,
0.13606765866279602,
-0.23880396783351898,
0.31673935055732727,
-0.10580810159444809,
-0.6995781660079956,
-0.1581350415945053,
0.16017475724220276,
-0.31153956055641174,
-0.5875481963157654,
-0.6320125460624695,
0.11529990285634995,
-0.467254638671875,
0.6742205619812012,
-0.23203283548355103,
0.11968380957841873,
-0.35852399468421936,
0.06109299510717392,
-0.24193483591079712,
-0.65908282995224,
-0.6875084638595581,
0.1257646381855011,
0.32246553897857666,
-0.0737551897764206,
0.40224531292915344,
0.5282644629478455,
0.7042303085327148,
0.3388412296772003,
-0.33742836117744446,
0.21215079724788666,
-0.6628910303115845,
0.11391031742095947,
0.03222713619470596,
-0.26816368103027344,
-0.7943427562713623,
-0.06123357638716698,
0.5934302806854248,
0.5843035578727722,
-0.3707313537597656,
0.14851975440979004,
0.1882079690694809,
0.3987374007701874,
-0.8774367570877075,
-0.06366369873285294,
-0.6988083124160767,
0.18141479790210724,
-0.1819412112236023,
-0.1945917159318924,
-0.3491799831390381,
-1.0542666912078857,
-0.03678613156080246,
-0.35434290766716003,
-0.13092578947544098,
0.08694761246442795,
0.6923296451568604,
0.051984068006277084,
-0.3953985869884491,
-0.38114455342292786,
-0.7348964214324951,
0.8966428637504578,
-0.8821344971656799,
0.4075303077697754,
0.3151467442512512,
0.5617225170135498,
-0.3438172936439514,
-0.6811382174491882,
-0.4921388626098633,
-0.18381768465042114,
0.23368647694587708,
0.07093631476163864,
-0.15235979855060577,
0.030486661940813065,
0.09312932193279266,
0.3382570445537567,
-0.6386322379112244,
0.4301303029060364,
-0.11301285028457642,
-0.4615500867366791,
0.6842353940010071,
0.1564113348722458,
0.38743653893470764,
0.09430773556232452,
-0.49519070982933044,
0.08762870728969574,
-0.9753302931785583,
-0.159036785364151,
0.49332237243652344,
0.06496558338403702,
-0.32998034358024597,
0.37813588976860046,
-0.21592119336128235,
0.47477981448173523,
-0.27916839718818665,
-0.44518622756004333,
0.263461172580719,
-0.6223810315132141,
0.03501756489276886,
-0.09414472430944443,
0.9850979447364807,
0.7067962288856506,
0.25897762179374695,
-0.24822917580604553,
-0.2832576632499695,
0.07071082293987274,
0.1954246610403061,
-0.6110962629318237,
0.2983642816543579,
0.4651425778865814,
-0.6616877913475037,
-0.5097030997276306,
0.08890566974878311,
-1.00624680519104,
-0.5898733735084534,
0.013201478868722916,
0.32525670528411865,
-0.09427734464406967,
-0.48375990986824036,
-0.027293773368000984,
0.2863107919692993,
0.28646567463874817,
0.037595588713884354,
-0.44915661215782166,
0.29394471645355225,
0.8007668852806091,
0.9228917360305786,
-0.5539992451667786,
-0.07903490960597992,
-0.6553851962089539,
0.2002425193786621,
-0.24644900858402252,
0.7868537902832031,
-0.04706443473696709,
-0.42414364218711853,
0.418134868144989,
-0.2381751537322998,
0.052614111453294754,
-0.45046666264533997,
0.6388841271400452,
-0.6372608542442322,
-0.03923940286040306,
-0.034541063010692596,
-0.7390394806861877,
0.07227032631635666,
0.471861869096756,
-0.5526273250579834,
0.9192824363708496,
-0.20113712549209595,
-0.8878863453865051,
0.47515079379081726,
-0.3786526620388031,
-0.3222927451133728,
-0.13209547102451324,
-0.19469046592712402,
-0.6399325728416443,
0.11117470264434814,
0.04144361987709999,
0.533804714679718,
-0.2427719086408615,
0.3550748825073242,
-0.6268408894538879,
-0.30300119519233704,
0.593997061252594,
-0.43524760007858276,
0.7422656416893005,
0.19573381543159485,
-0.4121641516685486,
0.26612815260887146,
-0.9117691516876221,
0.3417598307132721,
0.20942579209804535,
-0.44349437952041626,
0.020563652738928795,
0.19717693328857422,
0.07304786890745163,
0.2787637412548065,
0.3460495173931122,
-0.8140180110931396,
-0.36307698488235474,
-0.32246315479278564,
0.25861063599586487,
0.6325752139091492,
0.241775780916214,
-0.0371880829334259,
-0.25320321321487427,
0.5614417195320129,
-0.2589896023273468,
0.5421808958053589,
0.10852472484111786,
-0.46465519070625305,
-0.5616732239723206,
-0.024841582402586937,
0.28570160269737244,
0.5930137634277344,
-0.5284776091575623,
0.7432920932769775,
-0.24536459147930145,
-0.47035273909568787,
-0.3069751560688019,
0.2377205789089203,
0.647377073764801,
-0.011164863593876362,
0.0768914744257927,
-0.467876672744751,
-0.5557250380516052,
-0.6495668888092041,
-0.2760378420352936,
-0.21935459971427917,
-0.0011628518113866448,
-0.1697615385055542,
0.1309080719947815,
-0.34743964672088623,
0.9718509912490845,
-0.22064566612243652,
0.018844086676836014,
-0.420944482088089,
0.18760685622692108,
-0.1515694409608841,
0.3189442455768585,
0.3789144456386566,
-0.4839508831501007,
-0.32535141706466675,
-0.09368191659450531,
-0.9819819331169128,
-0.15771889686584473,
0.06526552885770798,
-0.03568987920880318,
0.1851804405450821,
0.5008217096328735,
-0.35639485716819763,
0.21352557837963104,
0.7890526652336121,
-0.09349475055932999,
0.388137549161911,
-0.25427013635635376,
0.057545535266399384,
-0.9116742610931396,
-0.0035926634445786476,
0.06671751290559769,
-0.342454731464386,
-0.7837199568748474,
0.3539777994155884,
0.023071477189660072,
0.10187748819589615,
-0.8419594764709473,
0.13735023140907288,
-0.4632498621940613,
-0.35372063517570496,
-0.30185428261756897,
0.24565792083740234,
-0.22171755135059357,
-0.027404846623539925,
-0.23753029108047485,
0.6283624768257141,
0.45990249514579773,
-0.3538345396518707,
0.24654535949230194,
-0.06216614320874214,
-0.6005235910415649,
0.3384312093257904,
-0.5618640780448914,
0.311171293258667,
0.06170681491494179,
0.07324285805225372,
-0.7850707769393921,
-0.20495830476284027,
0.21585096418857574,
-0.28069400787353516,
0.15999865531921387,
0.05534922331571579,
-0.7725161910057068,
-0.020610548555850983,
-0.4974954128265381,
0.14870434999465942,
0.5210873484611511,
-0.31141600012779236,
0.5556700825691223,
0.7146885395050049,
-0.30704835057258606,
-0.22621823847293854,
-0.3978373110294342,
0.012684393674135208,
-0.33864691853523254,
-0.6800351142883301,
-0.022075915709137917,
-0.1033158227801323,
-0.7622723579406738,
-0.2171948254108429,
-0.10227587819099426,
-0.33985090255737305,
0.5678104758262634,
0.33462586998939514,
0.4711669981479645,
-0.1458752304315567,
-0.3660838007926941,
0.14108966290950775,
-0.32831764221191406,
0.1837320774793625,
0.2460174560546875,
0.3092690110206604,
-0.1646009087562561,
-0.5467672944068909,
-0.49505892395973206,
0.19564254581928253,
0.4480855464935303,
-0.1290389746427536,
0.7524033188819885,
0.502532958984375,
-0.5443341732025146,
-0.20035327970981598,
-0.6762121319770813,
0.06753160059452057,
-0.5439887642860413,
0.07313122600317001,
-0.019624680280685425,
-0.8394361138343811,
0.2920513451099396,
-0.2131134420633316,
0.26238760352134705,
0.2580620050430298,
0.4640158414840698,
-0.24845796823501587,
0.7391971945762634,
0.5980746746063232,
0.10910987108945847,
0.1301613450050354,
0.25573477149009705,
0.26989567279815674,
-0.28450798988342285,
-0.3887539803981781,
-0.4696047902107239,
0.17658168077468872,
-0.46098729968070984,
-0.5186175107955933,
0.5282716155052185,
0.24405211210250854,
0.09966809302568436,
0.11930812895298004,
-0.042265232652425766,
0.5477110743522644,
0.11866427958011627,
-0.1507057100534439,
0.6328442692756653,
0.006924112793058157,
-0.10712280124425888,
-0.04605572298169136,
-0.3202650249004364,
-0.855983555316925,
1.2046526670455933,
0.6722645163536072,
0.5621829628944397,
0.30043140053749084,
0.648211658000946,
0.19949780404567719,
0.5084317922592163,
-0.4700513780117035,
0.7177558541297913,
0.12232178449630737,
-0.6207674145698547,
-0.18772722780704498,
-0.7181570529937744,
-0.7842605113983154,
0.303768128156662,
-0.4756961762905121,
-0.8422876596450806,
-0.31925225257873535,
0.09542931616306305,
-0.533976137638092,
0.3492580056190491,
-0.6051157712936401,
0.6627326011657715,
-0.779609739780426,
-0.36062416434288025,
-0.29149240255355835,
-0.5887562036514282,
0.6360107064247131,
-0.5441539883613586,
0.5363893508911133,
-0.31838008761405945,
-0.1272744983434677,
0.531833827495575,
-0.24385802447795868,
0.861447811126709,
-0.011444350704550743,
-0.32028281688690186,
0.3359322249889374,
0.19228573143482208,
0.5269825458526611,
-0.3458428680896759,
-0.19551296532154083,
0.5076128244400024,
0.04683133587241173,
-0.056516729295253754,
-0.3118620812892914,
0.9112363457679749,
-0.6346561908721924,
-0.27294349670410156,
-0.4789136052131653,
-0.2517680525779724,
-0.662559449672699,
0.1907661408185959,
0.04421301558613777,
0.2801250219345093,
-0.23302404582500458,
0.1554630547761917,
0.654927670955658,
-0.5348933935165405,
0.6737177968025208,
0.5133291482925415,
-0.28873997926712036,
-0.4423398971557617,
1.047570824623108,
0.018893355503678322,
0.5422793626785278,
0.2742939293384552,
0.27732083201408386,
-0.45619040727615356,
-1.1941531896591187,
-0.2784489393234253,
0.0456470362842083,
-0.8960185050964355,
0.06984052807092667,
-0.5275622606277466,
-0.1911681592464447,
-0.22662003338336945,
0.033424802124500275,
-0.38254427909851074,
-0.22232577204704285,
-0.06860297173261642,
-0.1775905042886734,
-0.07120763510465622,
0.9487625956535339,
0.14151659607887268,
0.19755379855632782,
-1.0904786586761475,
0.16681119799613953,
0.20363262295722961,
0.6331616640090942,
0.014348971657454967,
-0.027697909623384476,
-0.015245899558067322,
-0.3434509038925171,
-0.4444587528705597,
-0.793204128742218,
-0.0073144687339663506,
-0.07359989732503891,
0.8657745718955994,
0.6183722615242004,
0.036096472293138504,
0.22932012379169464,
-0.3923133611679077,
0.7047695517539978,
0.3375296890735626,
-0.870513379573822,
0.27991369366645813,
-0.4496600031852722,
-0.28193339705467224,
0.6000065803527832,
0.42785215377807617,
-0.22474326193332672,
-0.358524352312088,
-0.35485967993736267,
-0.8881645202636719,
0.24434047937393188,
0.5802379250526428,
-0.2298625409603119,
0.2617879807949066,
0.03904246911406517,
0.2912295460700989,
0.16058364510536194,
-0.7967520356178284,
-0.1574893295764923,
0.08975910395383835,
-0.1573752760887146,
0.10844266414642334,
-0.23641903698444366,
-0.21802973747253418,
0.2015034705400467,
0.5360880494117737,
0.0013947661500424147,
0.06065978854894638,
-0.35979387164115906,
-0.11647697538137436,
-0.2317768782377243,
0.44864413142204285,
0.48384514451026917,
1.0652670860290527,
-0.2614138126373291,
0.23188427090644836,
0.397706538438797,
-0.26753273606300354,
0.2219960242509842,
0.05498744919896126,
-0.13607899844646454,
-0.08445443958044052,
0.526766836643219,
0.38440948724746704,
0.23475298285484314,
-0.9655730724334717,
0.7233843803405762,
-0.17549535632133484,
0.15288059413433075,
-0.35831648111343384,
0.0599428154528141,
0.11974312365055084,
0.002791839651763439,
0.262654185295105,
-0.34659966826438904,
0.04090622439980507,
-0.4415164589881897,
0.1562734693288803,
0.43016695976257324,
-0.24147218465805054,
-0.19790545105934143,
0.49175146222114563,
0.5089319348335266,
-0.1012611836194992,
-0.028471633791923523,
-0.2478443682193756,
-0.270696222782135,
0.5681409239768982,
0.31596696376800537,
1.073267936706543,
-0.01758703403174877,
0.14792583882808685,
0.17648760974407196,
0.5774775743484497,
-0.10173875838518143,
0.3106797933578491,
0.4239654541015625,
-0.6266776919364929,
-0.41338369250297546,
-0.7964391112327576,
-0.675112783908844,
0.22844839096069336,
-0.5029789209365845,
-0.03928009048104286,
-0.7047393918037415,
-0.2783031463623047,
-0.41217491030693054,
-0.24609248340129852,
-0.2205362617969513,
0.18656796216964722,
0.3307039439678192,
0.694795548915863,
-0.7856967449188232,
0.5237374901771545,
0.46026790142059326,
-0.12803474068641663,
-0.5510124564170837,
0.33481961488723755,
0.34581175446510315,
-0.6628659963607788,
0.3169427514076233,
0.24050688743591309,
-0.4035482108592987,
-0.24868448078632355,
-0.20401854813098907,
-0.9541502594947815,
1.1060572862625122,
0.3197072148323059,
-0.8733904957771301,
0.2200760692358017,
0.4210929274559021,
0.5071642994880676,
-0.040469251573085785,
0.29494723677635193,
0.5627540946006775,
0.3320842683315277,
-0.13312457501888275,
-1.0556386709213257,
0.32323402166366577,
0.02615506947040558,
0.03897310048341751,
0.16099199652671814,
-0.3602055609226227,
0.5302046537399292,
0.07418867945671082,
-0.5005162954330444,
0.24455229938030243,
0.4795515239238739,
0.44912636280059814,
0.43116769194602966,
0.6198549270629883,
0.32736462354660034,
0.6271432638168335,
-0.07792854309082031,
1.2254329919815063,
-0.4164380133152008,
0.36549249291419983,
1.0202704668045044,
-0.4832734167575836,
1.0840774774551392,
0.5389574766159058,
-0.4667137861251831,
0.2336050570011139,
0.5632230639457703,
0.20856797695159912,
0.3916580379009247,
0.36494237184524536,
-0.37384510040283203,
-0.366347074508667,
-0.15539510548114777,
-0.43706756830215454,
0.006282210815697908,
0.13695284724235535,
-0.2777809798717499,
-0.2657069265842438,
-0.1985698938369751,
-0.07084524631500244,
0.005379364360123873,
-0.2552213966846466,
0.7809541821479797,
0.16567566990852356,
-0.3386492431163788,
0.26598674058914185,
0.14148439466953278,
0.626655638217926,
-0.5476140975952148,
0.1514461785554886,
-0.08684689551591873,
0.3552372455596924,
-0.2219667285680771,
-0.7488074898719788,
0.2515033781528473,
0.3173218071460724,
0.4944673180580139,
-0.2390235960483551,
0.8438438773155212,
-0.005481197033077478,
-0.4213462471961975,
0.542227029800415,
0.7151188254356384,
0.13785704970359802,
0.15110504627227783,
-0.39921391010284424,
0.5919265151023865,
-0.30160677433013916,
-0.06791919469833374,
0.557711660861969,
-0.0012397500686347485,
-0.03519507870078087,
0.6872777342796326,
0.6792197227478027,
0.26011884212493896,
0.48769262433052063,
-0.012318327091634274,
0.7471124529838562,
-0.41821879148483276,
-0.4180331826210022,
-0.7884082198143005,
0.7294273376464844,
-0.20321577787399292,
-0.3218744695186615,
0.8886542916297913,
0.46026021242141724,
0.8321723341941833,
0.12008988112211227,
1.0033717155456543,
0.058683350682258606,
0.5275737047195435,
-0.7375105619430542,
0.9585078954696655,
-0.32097479701042175,
0.3717101812362671,
-0.37966176867485046,
-0.9857364892959595,
-0.32308441400527954,
0.29526618123054504,
-0.20249077677726746,
-0.12676571309566498,
0.7935655117034912,
0.7253307104110718,
0.018774952739477158,
0.2695271372795105,
0.38097524642944336,
0.03419964760541916,
0.36035817861557007,
0.2881251573562622,
1.3450485467910767,
-0.2049034982919693,
0.7529900074005127,
-0.2947675585746765,
-0.3204832673072815,
-0.10675752907991409,
-1.223366141319275,
-1.0982120037078857,
-0.037341341376304626,
-0.3592047095298767,
-0.3586909770965576,
0.1626550555229187,
1.0078564882278442,
0.504356861114502,
-0.9640612006187439,
-0.3805675506591797,
0.013747496530413628,
-0.13752955198287964,
-0.05941149964928627,
-0.12662504613399506,
0.05950384587049484,
-0.018691428005695343,
-0.43513479828834534,
0.764579713344574,
0.21647685766220093,
0.13933917880058289,
-0.5194754600524902,
-0.21658389270305634,
0.030141055583953857,
0.03749154135584831,
0.566373348236084,
0.17424742877483368,
-0.8126665353775024,
-0.329635888338089,
-0.37613436579704285,
-0.2711235582828522,
-0.09946297854185104,
0.8322188854217529,
0.015759224072098732,
0.46211135387420654,
0.6456310749053955,
0.9219317436218262,
0.18189746141433716,
-0.006530006881803274,
0.6046069264411926,
-0.5045318603515625,
-0.24469654262065887,
0.16167515516281128,
0.5179483294487,
0.49552470445632935,
-0.17341169714927673,
0.35158592462539673,
0.15970830619335175,
-0.38573211431503296,
-0.981324315071106,
0.12359773367643356,
-0.851460874080658,
-0.07322914153337479,
1.398625135421753,
-0.5420735478401184,
0.2102077603340149,
-0.427272766828537,
0.11667405813932419,
0.38112351298332214,
-0.16746090352535248,
0.8700092434883118,
0.5902318954467773,
-0.06340552121400833,
0.07266025990247726,
-0.6843482255935669,
0.2894198000431061,
0.18781325221061707,
-1.5316283702850342,
-0.15478669106960297,
0.4961208403110504,
0.4528771638870239,
0.11473175138235092,
0.3390009105205536,
-0.23129384219646454,
0.07761214673519135,
-0.20749475061893463,
0.05835844203829765,
-0.029870308935642242,
-0.27620771527290344,
-0.5465545058250427,
0.5370801091194153,
0.22287094593048096,
-0.20303519070148468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08511v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08511v1
|
Leveraging Multi-AI Agents for Cross-Domain Knowledge Discovery
| 2024-04-12T14:50:41 | 2024-04-12T14:50:41 |
Shiva Aryal, Tuyen Do, Bisesh Heyojoo, Sandeep Chataut, Bichar Dip Shrestha Gurung, Venkataramana Gadhamshetty, Etienne Gnimpieba
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In the rapidly evolving field of artificial intelligence, the ability to
harness and integrate knowledge across various domains stands as a paramount
challenge and opportunity. This study introduces a novel approach to
cross-domain knowledge discovery through the deployment of multi-AI agents,
each specialized in distinct knowledge domains. These AI agents, designed to
function as domain-specific experts, collaborate in a unified framework to
synthesize and provide comprehensive insights that transcend the limitations of
single-domain expertise. By facilitating seamless interaction among these
agents, our platform aims to leverage the unique strengths and perspectives of
each, thereby enhancing the process of knowledge discovery and decision-making.
We present a comparative analysis of the different multi-agent workflow
scenarios evaluating their performance in terms of efficiency, accuracy, and
the breadth of knowledge integration. Through a series of experiments involving
complex, interdisciplinary queries, our findings demonstrate the superior
capability of domain specific multi-AI agent system in identifying and bridging
knowledge gaps. This research not only underscores the significance of
collaborative AI in driving innovation but also sets the stage for future
advancements in AI-driven, cross-disciplinary research and application. Our
methods were evaluated on a small pilot data and it showed a trend we expected,
if we increase the amount of data we custom train the agents, the trend is
expected to be more smooth.
|
[
-0.7291162014007568,
-0.525103747844696,
0.7142138481140137,
-0.23356541991233826,
0.312335729598999,
0.747566819190979,
-0.05434192344546318,
-0.6434752345085144,
0.06730645149946213,
0.11047172546386719,
-0.5129294395446777,
-0.47828954458236694,
-0.6548770070075989,
-0.05982562527060509,
-0.02656574919819832,
0.5538507699966431,
-0.017063146457076073,
-0.11045591533184052,
-0.7287198901176453,
-0.44082772731781006,
-0.5777415633201599,
-0.45355087518692017,
-0.44041529297828674,
-0.7427689433097839,
0.4860488772392273,
0.3058761656284332,
0.7570557594299316,
0.3350921869277954,
0.43848279118537903,
0.3820064663887024,
0.37708890438079834,
0.7208918333053589,
-0.050686124712228775,
0.05568600445985794,
-0.35037070512771606,
-0.3245338201522827,
-0.436271071434021,
0.009210644289851189,
0.01929815672338009,
0.6288067698478699,
0.05644077807664871,
-0.08608870953321457,
-0.12968026101589203,
0.4515323042869568,
-0.5745895504951477,
0.34767428040504456,
-0.4412107765674591,
0.26317253708839417,
-0.26475653052330017,
-0.26465660333633423,
-0.1249793991446495,
0.10811717063188553,
0.6516008973121643,
-0.812619686126709,
0.3692357540130615,
0.07839487493038177,
0.5121913552284241,
0.5471968650817871,
-0.35666629672050476,
0.03649196773767471,
-0.8788418173789978,
0.6199832558631897,
-0.48276299238204956,
0.22042205929756165,
-0.15158507227897644,
0.7579602003097534,
0.020724168047308922,
-0.6593396067619324,
-0.5897624492645264,
0.031640227884054184,
-0.02912316471338272,
-0.03681723773479462,
-0.0967036634683609,
-0.3028648793697357,
-0.23809011280536652,
0.07191172242164612,
-0.7557575702667236,
0.10112069547176361,
-0.012762478552758694,
-0.41191044449806213,
0.8504791855812073,
0.24522145092487335,
0.3257523477077484,
0.6885969638824463,
-0.37954166531562805,
-0.12687894701957703,
-0.3529597520828247,
0.04936029762029648,
-0.02299061231315136,
0.6193861365318298,
0.04446510225534439,
0.42599743604660034,
-0.416025847196579,
0.2356276512145996,
-0.1426428258419037,
-0.14203718304634094,
0.5460344552993774,
-0.6496456265449524,
-0.0422670915722847,
-0.2758617401123047,
0.638038694858551,
-0.03808269277215004,
-0.0402778722345829,
-0.5330360531806946,
-0.024568023160099983,
-0.059860553592443466,
0.38027113676071167,
-0.293731153011322,
-0.030514409765601158,
0.03745517134666443,
-0.2409646064043045,
0.127955362200737,
0.01702239364385605,
-0.5242468118667603,
-0.6377828121185303,
-0.40407833456993103,
0.556794285774231,
-0.4195249676704407,
-0.4124503433704376,
-0.18785227835178375,
-0.7600767016410828,
0.0364457406103611,
0.6456161141395569,
-0.2793864607810974,
0.06608136743307114,
0.7404871582984924,
0.5604076385498047,
-0.24949900805950165,
-0.9528236985206604,
-0.029092689976096153,
0.3157220184803009,
-0.13890992105007172,
1.0071358680725098,
-0.6805886030197144,
-0.08811182528734207,
0.02308877371251583,
-0.19137050211429596,
-0.4203484356403351,
-0.561069667339325,
0.1664787083864212,
-0.6966012716293335,
-0.14660578966140747,
-0.2787245512008667,
-0.4659954011440277,
-0.4248293936252594,
0.4602920711040497,
-0.6980255246162415,
0.6127625107765198,
0.13287746906280518,
-0.4073115587234497,
0.6641954183578491,
-0.9925355315208435,
-0.4127129316329956,
0.36949196457862854,
-0.44372445344924927,
-0.3877217173576355,
-0.39882686734199524,
0.1423119604587555,
0.42423900961875916,
-0.5590965151786804,
0.13944190740585327,
-0.27157092094421387,
-0.10626768320798874,
0.05823292210698128,
-0.12433741986751556,
0.47004786133766174,
-0.007969371043145657,
-0.6711965799331665,
0.17202700674533844,
-0.3669697046279907,
-0.012985588051378727,
0.058963727205991745,
0.06415897607803345,
-0.5079554915428162,
-0.23215992748737335,
-0.29269760847091675,
0.25002405047416687,
0.25474050641059875,
-0.2976169288158417,
0.23628315329551697,
0.10885851085186005,
0.12300962209701538,
0.566169023513794,
0.045510128140449524,
0.7162880897521973,
-0.8704150319099426,
0.5225976705551147,
0.2904098629951477,
0.34927722811698914,
0.07688641548156738,
-0.7436205744743347,
-0.25535833835601807,
-0.24262326955795288,
0.0662003681063652,
0.35929983854293823,
-0.8591180443763733,
0.35521724820137024,
-0.10698089748620987,
-0.726777970790863,
-0.7140435576438904,
0.07726217061281204,
0.15837234258651733,
0.41690897941589355,
0.46158087253570557,
-0.28382161259651184,
-0.14725267887115479,
-0.6244271993637085,
-0.22550298273563385,
0.028238780796527863,
0.26967260241508484,
0.7612568140029907,
0.6402166485786438,
-0.7813184857368469,
0.9686190485954285,
-0.17578911781311035,
-0.4897884130477905,
-0.2654549479484558,
0.20498807728290558,
-0.27169349789619446,
0.3835044205188751,
0.5240664482116699,
-1.1447954177856445,
-0.609039306640625,
0.38326895236968994,
-0.9960382580757141,
0.3568844795227051,
-0.004601106513291597,
-0.4083276093006134,
0.0621616430580616,
0.026729188859462738,
-0.8153248429298401,
0.6386599540710449,
-0.0011043717386201024,
-0.29135674238204956,
0.29861289262771606,
-0.055723391473293304,
0.36538365483283997,
-0.7541595697402954,
0.10558129847049713,
-0.11448778957128525,
0.17302390933036804,
-0.7697246074676514,
0.025069689378142357,
-0.3575781285762787,
0.0934215784072876,
-0.21123896539211273,
0.5037502646446228,
-0.4099375009536743,
-0.08621994405984879,
-0.15019941329956055,
0.14100800454616547,
0.19972790777683258,
0.5993424654006958,
0.09748809784650803,
0.7904050946235657,
0.7612357139587402,
-0.6165746450424194,
0.26562172174453735,
0.5088571906089783,
0.27022871375083923,
0.37787356972694397,
-0.33693981170654297,
0.2705387771129608,
-0.013617594726383686,
0.1873047947883606,
-0.430083692073822,
0.07544339448213577,
0.3590677082538605,
-0.5603215098381042,
-0.30615246295928955,
0.0014110017800703645,
-0.3463693857192993,
-0.22769397497177124,
-0.27137330174446106,
0.7175180315971375,
0.10953957587480545,
-0.5208130478858948,
1.0312811136245728,
0.7729036211967468,
-0.06899221986532211,
-0.8301520943641663,
-0.27913475036621094,
0.13038967549800873,
-0.029690183699131012,
-0.8938546776771545,
0.44442030787467957,
-0.11474751681089401,
-0.3558725118637085,
0.20710039138793945,
-0.05505746975541115,
-0.2537689507007599,
0.009928658604621887,
0.39428433775901794,
-0.053563885390758514,
-0.2885417938232422,
0.06487470120191574,
0.1206950843334198,
0.026845699176192284,
-0.01616412028670311,
-0.6894076466560364,
0.34356963634490967,
-0.1103655993938446,
-0.5671725273132324,
-0.33093705773353577,
0.5105990171432495,
0.8222141265869141,
-0.7904236316680908,
0.7742341756820679,
0.7194129824638367,
-0.5677618980407715,
-0.6206857562065125,
-0.3635047674179077,
-0.12509886920452118,
-0.4154382050037384,
-0.12639135122299194,
-0.39779824018478394,
-0.6581673622131348,
0.5291392803192139,
-0.5510095953941345,
0.05798882246017456,
0.6221746206283569,
0.5947765111923218,
0.23797279596328735,
0.9082656502723694,
0.9426301121711731,
-0.2016409933567047,
-0.032620739191770554,
-0.6864902973175049,
0.34516945481300354,
-0.5704681873321533,
-0.7977074384689331,
-0.6532216668128967,
-0.058140140026807785,
-0.24196849763393402,
-0.621671199798584,
0.6060124039649963,
-0.6638489365577698,
-0.1560095101594925,
-0.08938131481409073,
-0.3600456416606903,
0.09914373606443405,
0.94898521900177,
-0.03483814373612404,
0.45479562878608704,
-0.3777211606502533,
-0.11853793263435364,
0.42952024936676025,
-0.8601192235946655,
-0.4403173625469208,
1.119856834411621,
0.014571220614016056,
0.4470524489879608,
-0.03918483480811119,
0.6694250702857971,
0.8847411870956421,
-0.04363192245364189,
-0.5296110510826111,
0.2532111704349518,
0.30995428562164307,
-0.4780985414981842,
-0.7081058621406555,
-0.359997421503067,
-0.9503078460693359,
0.27952656149864197,
-0.25011205673217773,
-0.1565505415201187,
0.33642154932022095,
-0.23703479766845703,
-0.3679240345954895,
0.43522369861602783,
-0.4663231074810028,
0.959433376789093,
-0.3122154176235199,
-0.22626012563705444,
-0.41197872161865234,
-0.6795679926872253,
-0.0532742440700531,
-0.12442328035831451,
0.16053541004657745,
-0.1245608776807785,
0.0918366089463234,
0.5049456357955933,
-0.4189603328704834,
0.5267031788825989,
-0.2770088315010071,
0.009777478873729706,
0.5500438213348389,
-0.346925288438797,
0.22445790469646454,
0.1627683937549591,
-0.05869191139936447,
0.4157361090183258,
-0.43466195464134216,
-0.36549538373947144,
-0.5526896715164185,
0.47115418314933777,
-1.226648211479187,
-0.46847766637802124,
-0.4344750940799713,
-0.7755680084228516,
-0.408927857875824,
0.31567928194999695,
-0.14899764955043793,
0.32973235845565796,
-0.36834070086479187,
-0.3140941858291626,
0.4033360183238983,
0.10707639902830124,
0.3901573121547699,
0.6064355969429016,
0.6018836498260498,
0.0065378108993172646,
0.9382098317146301,
0.10323242098093033,
-0.17334389686584473,
0.5601058602333069,
-0.04190482571721077,
-0.25653979182243347,
-0.6989848613739014,
-0.38524946570396423,
0.010617279447615147,
-0.3866015076637268,
-0.3318391442298889,
-0.6504595875740051,
-0.13708221912384033,
-0.6631736755371094,
-0.06917475908994675,
-0.33495277166366577,
-0.09919697046279907,
-0.043609049171209335,
0.1603674292564392,
0.1497645080089569,
0.8925764560699463,
-0.24575991928577423,
-0.07918921858072281,
-0.9118457436561584,
0.21973688900470734,
0.37069472670555115,
0.17472174763679504,
0.3136487901210785,
0.1428086757659912,
-0.6995407938957214,
0.12532614171504974,
-0.331045925617218,
-0.41757479310035706,
0.3404505252838135,
0.170929417014122,
1.0714833736419678,
0.29775798320770264,
0.2834876775741577,
0.4113524258136749,
-0.2197781354188919,
0.5242459774017334,
-0.4091590940952301,
-0.6848947405815125,
0.36209943890571594,
-0.08400502800941467,
0.051726799458265305,
0.5316519141197205,
0.5494300127029419,
-0.2853308618068695,
-0.43468567728996277,
-0.711755096912384,
-0.7982239127159119,
0.6170879602432251,
0.203069806098938,
-0.4545292556285858,
0.6775931715965271,
0.13989941775798798,
0.7308257818222046,
0.38440173864364624,
0.22893404960632324,
-0.40880531072616577,
-0.08843044936656952,
-0.04302429035305977,
-0.14114895462989807,
0.758689820766449,
-0.5016340017318726,
-0.11013338714838028,
0.7090578675270081,
-0.40285202860832214,
0.387442022562027,
0.1493125855922699,
-0.3441833555698395,
-0.0031844910699874163,
0.02456546016037464,
0.19528071582317352,
1.0148050785064697,
0.18060912191867828,
-0.032449521124362946,
-0.11034277081489563,
-0.25380125641822815,
0.03922157362103462,
0.47190624475479126,
-0.13145644962787628,
-0.05306889861822128,
0.534927248954773,
0.5525384545326233,
-0.6302305459976196,
-0.8761175870895386,
0.3708658814430237,
-0.3233393728733063,
-0.2718551754951477,
-0.3127802610397339,
0.254772812128067,
-0.258273184299469,
1.0612518787384033,
0.6898729801177979,
0.6520636081695557,
0.38489213585853577,
-0.7464849948883057,
0.4059622585773468,
0.568112850189209,
0.19331075251102448,
-0.22072330117225647,
0.6491841077804565,
0.36709681153297424,
-0.4188530445098877,
0.4559476673603058,
-0.18847504258155823,
-0.6260760426521301,
0.9530556201934814,
-0.09898318350315094,
0.7981479167938232,
0.12349309772253036,
0.513876736164093,
-0.432502806186676,
0.0451803058385849,
0.23632049560546875,
0.08162713795900345,
-0.41550493240356445,
-1.1138736009597778,
-0.00810347218066454,
0.03529724106192589,
-0.8497982621192932,
-0.26453882455825806,
-0.3221176266670227,
-0.3017948269844055,
-0.057207196950912476,
-0.17514470219612122,
0.33572670817375183,
0.34287819266319275,
-1.026687741279602,
0.1780933141708374,
0.13603419065475464,
0.6678435206413269,
-0.7418450713157654,
0.6395164728164673,
0.9050389528274536,
-0.5438032150268555,
-0.6155762076377869,
0.093049056828022,
0.15942256152629852,
-0.9139370918273926,
0.16879700124263763,
-0.008808393031358719,
-0.27834179997444153,
-0.2818104326725006,
-0.30780601501464844,
-0.5271701812744141,
1.4188381433486938,
-0.019961925223469734,
-0.06083562970161438,
0.14160214364528656,
0.416523277759552,
0.7684669494628906,
-0.8223716616630554,
0.43890491127967834,
0.6514924764633179,
0.5418808460235596,
0.08873626589775085,
-0.8829619288444519,
0.04905446991324425,
-0.4350050985813141,
-0.3460979461669922,
0.005843005143105984,
-0.8002892732620239,
0.9126452803611755,
-0.4650425910949707,
0.14632076025009155,
-0.272473007440567,
0.670973539352417,
0.18584220111370087,
1.2138029336929321,
0.4039936065673828,
0.4626927375793457,
1.081322431564331,
0.2941262125968933,
0.3784969449043274,
-0.335508793592453,
0.1462092399597168,
0.5513765215873718,
-0.5739498734474182,
0.35555219650268555,
0.12918849289417267,
0.026780923828482628,
0.5879058837890625,
0.3486792743206024,
-0.03201877698302269,
0.5802220106124878,
-0.2064887285232544,
-0.39440396428108215,
-0.26320481300354004,
-0.46473613381385803,
-0.35116589069366455,
0.322313517332077,
0.22850292921066284,
0.1696712076663971,
0.08053267747163773,
0.29820382595062256,
-0.22848445177078247,
-0.023264504969120026,
-0.260745108127594,
0.9159324169158936,
-0.2253868281841278,
-0.7018915414810181,
0.1390092968940735,
-0.207910418510437,
0.41042378544807434,
-0.2324487715959549,
-0.37575563788414,
-0.3199491798877716,
0.33532169461250305,
-0.05810553580522537,
-0.5612953305244446,
0.031698938459157944,
-0.3734237551689148,
-0.2757936716079712,
-0.13637302815914154,
0.6717543601989746,
-0.3170101046562195,
0.19100993871688843,
0.5986968278884888,
1.321196436882019,
-0.1172942966222763,
-0.23292173445224762,
-0.5944166779518127,
-0.16840700805187225,
-0.3500770330429077,
0.29507163166999817,
0.1948372721672058,
0.7976759672164917,
-0.05876283347606659,
0.8908491730690002,
0.4681936502456665,
-0.21008995175361633,
0.09508531540632248,
0.2986140847206116,
0.9392295479774475,
-0.5895245671272278,
-0.2741508185863495,
-0.3626784682273865,
0.4373590350151062,
-0.13320553302764893,
-0.26518332958221436,
0.5469734072685242,
0.5233553647994995,
0.9285687208175659,
-0.039911236613988876,
1.4816042184829712,
-0.2305053323507309,
0.40735480189323425,
0.0821547657251358,
0.8700942397117615,
-0.7113041877746582,
0.22176717221736908,
-0.044709622859954834,
-0.31305229663848877,
-0.08246800303459167,
0.016318634152412415,
0.16059711575508118,
0.19499638676643372,
0.5384582877159119,
0.6421526670455933,
0.13074779510498047,
0.20873256027698517,
0.08950430899858475,
-0.006447024643421173,
0.4329719841480255,
0.6143902540206909,
1.0048930644989014,
-0.25309935212135315,
0.39005982875823975,
-0.287753701210022,
-0.3091702163219452,
-0.12331856787204742,
-0.08138951659202576,
-1.1253108978271484,
-0.8646337985992432,
-0.23879387974739075,
0.23534022271633148,
0.27417004108428955,
0.8283293843269348,
0.8337677121162415,
-0.5676642060279846,
-0.0601007454097271,
0.10107206553220749,
0.5180429816246033,
-0.6203275918960571,
-0.16656874120235443,
0.19852314889431,
-0.23759496212005615,
-0.701788067817688,
0.7434776425361633,
0.22828823328018188,
-0.05748683959245682,
-0.38052159547805786,
-0.4332544207572937,
-0.2851990759372711,
0.16879622638225555,
0.37821367383003235,
0.4171447157859802,
-0.19663165509700775,
0.012433853931725025,
0.11771099269390106,
-0.016732195392251015,
-0.04820892959833145,
0.93034827709198,
-0.9548601508140564,
0.0633663684129715,
0.47598737478256226,
1.1917896270751953,
0.35298600792884827,
-0.04446299001574516,
0.6439239382743835,
-0.5284216403961182,
-0.10607116669416428,
0.36474817991256714,
0.13936446607112885,
0.14544722437858582,
-0.5534945726394653,
0.5069253444671631,
0.5262972116470337,
-0.6783134937286377,
-0.4798503816127777,
-0.1619264930486679,
-0.8307337164878845,
-0.2961784303188324,
0.4678128957748413,
-0.17653682827949524,
0.10389203578233719,
-0.4512341320514679,
0.012384968809783459,
0.2294916957616806,
-0.6713389158248901,
0.9205113649368286,
0.22898148000240326,
-0.7927578687667847,
0.11706092208623886,
-0.09990469366312027,
0.4755474030971527,
0.2300303876399994,
-1.0218815803527832,
-0.3232077360153198,
0.2937239408493042,
-0.10379184037446976,
0.4293958842754364,
0.4719134271144867,
0.40781939029693604,
0.30448275804519653,
0.2521052062511444,
-0.03265963867306709,
-0.24041615426540375,
-1.0366188287734985,
0.06097724661231041,
0.4479202330112457,
-0.001689619617536664,
-0.23237241804599762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08509v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08509v1
|
Efficient Interactive LLM Serving with Proxy Model-based Sequence Length Prediction
| 2024-04-12T14:46:15 | 2024-04-12T14:46:15 |
Haoran Qiu, Weichao Mao, Archit Patke, Shengkun Cui, Saurabh Jha, Chen Wang, Hubertus Franke, Zbigniew T. Kalbarczyk, Tamer Başar, Ravishankar K. Iyer
|
cs.DC
|
cs.DC, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have been driving a new wave of interactive AI
applications across numerous domains. However, efficiently serving LLM
inference requests is challenging due to their unpredictable execution times
originating from the autoregressive nature of generative models. Existing LLM
serving systems exploit first-come-first-serve (FCFS) scheduling, suffering
from head-of-line blocking issues. To address the non-deterministic nature of
LLMs and enable efficient interactive LLM serving, we present a speculative
shortest-job-first (SSJF) scheduler that uses a light proxy model to predict
LLM output sequence lengths. Our open-source SSJF implementation does not
require changes to memory management or batching strategies. Evaluations on
real-world datasets and production workload traces show that SSJF reduces
average job completion times by 30.5-39.6% and increases throughput by 2.2-3.6x
compared to FCFS schedulers, across no batching, dynamic batching, and
continuous batching settings.
|
[
-0.293154776096344,
-0.702262282371521,
0.9052215218544006,
0.34597811102867126,
-0.37157419323921204,
0.173039972782135,
-0.0022415458224713802,
-0.5595763325691223,
0.4326038062572479,
0.6829115152359009,
-0.9712309837341309,
-0.21925218403339386,
-0.5178726315498352,
0.07992628961801529,
-0.45912688970565796,
0.5931353569030762,
0.27684152126312256,
-0.01927156187593937,
-0.29314351081848145,
0.33484283089637756,
-0.057053931057453156,
0.12078577280044556,
-0.889356255531311,
-0.14246712625026703,
0.7072767615318298,
0.5337703227996826,
1.2354251146316528,
1.2443941831588745,
0.3361085057258606,
0.27364686131477356,
0.13776849210262299,
0.4494861960411072,
-0.6410397291183472,
0.3077445924282074,
0.07611329853534698,
-0.5986840724945068,
-0.2464008927345276,
-0.1418505609035492,
0.6749218702316284,
1.050209403038025,
-0.15759296715259552,
0.2941126227378845,
-0.19431331753730774,
0.7239890694618225,
-0.4313732385635376,
0.11157073080539703,
-0.7192443609237671,
0.2701995372772217,
-0.57879638671875,
-0.2516300082206726,
-0.5206862688064575,
-0.12113958597183228,
0.06964033842086792,
-0.763188362121582,
0.160005584359169,
0.4411679208278656,
0.6251769661903381,
0.48106688261032104,
-0.38413792848587036,
0.35692423582077026,
-0.8244462609291077,
0.5299655795097351,
-0.8110243082046509,
0.48648902773857117,
0.14517521858215332,
0.47876936197280884,
-0.530791163444519,
-0.7851290106773376,
-0.5872317552566528,
-0.2791331112384796,
-0.13244377076625824,
0.21712583303451538,
0.16161373257637024,
0.25618621706962585,
0.37212416529655457,
0.22368048131465912,
-0.7610364556312561,
0.4159010648727417,
-0.14489687979221344,
0.2207901030778885,
0.4171316921710968,
0.6190661191940308,
-0.08825153857469559,
0.10845822095870972,
-0.5427511930465698,
0.10939820110797882,
-0.6815394163131714,
0.03236954286694527,
0.5645138621330261,
0.11623624712228775,
-0.10913988202810287,
0.5583062171936035,
-0.5426999926567078,
0.7300495505332947,
0.011993959546089172,
-0.036007072776556015,
-0.4484718441963196,
0.219782292842865,
-0.20328053832054138,
-0.1608360856771469,
0.8300685286521912,
0.409921258687973,
0.0064766439609229565,
-0.363359659910202,
-0.10953903198242188,
-0.08550241589546204,
0.23072116076946259,
-0.9376370906829834,
-0.05182994157075882,
0.07794151455163956,
-0.2085714489221573,
-0.19574487209320068,
0.17170953750610352,
-0.6910846829414368,
-0.49076640605926514,
-0.006510543171316385,
-0.06308536976575851,
-0.2668609917163849,
0.13923759758472443,
-0.37933942675590515,
0.16532151401042938,
0.12589383125305176,
0.3680817484855652,
-0.7370401620864868,
0.4170874357223511,
0.7363746166229248,
1.0471564531326294,
-0.4348090589046478,
-0.1690073311328888,
-1.1611745357513428,
0.40689945220947266,
-0.3351846933364868,
0.5563437938690186,
-0.4498075842857361,
-0.5088517665863037,
-0.12030407041311264,
0.1463560312986374,
0.04621681943535805,
-0.1483655422925949,
0.3298549950122833,
-0.8584636449813843,
-0.32162508368492126,
0.05711475759744644,
-0.901275634765625,
0.25516435503959656,
-0.23286126554012299,
-0.8818199634552002,
0.9007893204689026,
0.05247434973716736,
-0.5518020987510681,
0.28753697872161865,
-0.461683452129364,
-0.6697971820831299,
0.5107147097587585,
-0.20045024156570435,
-0.18617792427539825,
0.04062168672680855,
0.13543151319026947,
0.6233193278312683,
-0.4455600082874298,
0.35568967461586,
-0.5239998698234558,
-0.7688066363334656,
0.11943086236715317,
-0.595526933670044,
0.3362608551979065,
0.4345735013484955,
-0.26249033212661743,
0.23882488906383514,
-0.550872266292572,
0.002056615659967065,
0.2778635025024414,
-0.14674890041351318,
0.09262547641992569,
0.32612884044647217,
0.09634809195995331,
-0.054198551923036575,
0.14313919842243195,
-0.49969640374183655,
0.37234795093536377,
-0.5234764814376831,
0.08902624994516373,
0.9237020611763,
-0.28072279691696167,
0.3403514325618744,
-0.44867023825645447,
0.899628758430481,
-0.24646437168121338,
0.5150920748710632,
-0.35368382930755615,
-0.4116249978542328,
-0.7046405076980591,
-0.38949793577194214,
0.09836040437221527,
0.5805872678756714,
-1.3295775651931763,
-0.06613780558109283,
-0.49997785687446594,
-0.689133882522583,
-0.4546206295490265,
0.24051356315612793,
0.4885278344154358,
0.4040051996707916,
0.11090074479579926,
-0.11381164193153381,
-0.396314799785614,
-1.0130523443222046,
-0.3128436803817749,
-0.20196223258972168,
0.05935998260974884,
0.2940271198749542,
0.006516467314213514,
-0.11518901586532593,
0.8540950417518616,
-0.604400098323822,
0.07761714607477188,
-0.2208838164806366,
-0.021630560979247093,
0.8468171954154968,
0.1711273491382599,
0.4365934729576111,
-0.6214867234230042,
-0.7930178046226501,
-0.3256015479564667,
-0.3647403419017792,
-0.2894105315208435,
-0.3958266079425812,
-0.2024858146905899,
0.33802253007888794,
0.3082338869571686,
-0.6611599326133728,
0.4083494246006012,
0.6709645986557007,
-0.38643839955329895,
0.39205825328826904,
-0.04731346666812897,
0.07950402796268463,
-0.6803287863731384,
-0.24198126792907715,
-0.099583201110363,
-0.5698352456092834,
-0.642331063747406,
-0.12314911186695099,
-0.10390403121709824,
-0.01415314618498087,
-0.7182166576385498,
0.781613826751709,
-0.4453617036342621,
-0.3118009567260742,
-0.5028117299079895,
-0.04023066163063049,
0.016099916771054268,
0.314054012298584,
0.04441554471850395,
1.0072954893112183,
0.35399341583251953,
-0.6778521537780762,
0.04908517375588417,
-0.005149598233401775,
-0.28305914998054504,
-0.0026512318290770054,
-0.5801413655281067,
0.19294960796833038,
0.17312967777252197,
0.3013645112514496,
-0.8785490989685059,
-0.2232411652803421,
0.26141631603240967,
0.039684657007455826,
0.13144561648368835,
-0.5488917231559753,
-0.6651475429534912,
-0.4672021269798279,
-0.016787651926279068,
0.35209858417510986,
0.4782426357269287,
-0.8462314009666443,
0.44311100244522095,
0.0538872629404068,
-0.15815740823745728,
-0.5347078442573547,
-0.6745297908782959,
-0.0026920780073851347,
0.03161969408392906,
-0.7946977615356445,
0.8757996559143066,
-0.09605761617422104,
0.060018669813871384,
-0.2301293909549713,
-0.195022851228714,
0.028739647939801216,
0.3209042251110077,
0.5511955618858337,
0.6580133438110352,
-0.01824767142534256,
-0.5165355801582336,
0.22049997746944427,
0.04773494601249695,
-0.03550923243165016,
-0.1252772957086563,
0.549409031867981,
0.046922020614147186,
-0.6877685785293579,
-0.4165942668914795,
0.342758446931839,
0.7366393208503723,
0.3223764896392822,
0.8585452437400818,
0.7150578498840332,
-0.0895148515701294,
-0.19970445334911346,
-0.6861494183540344,
-0.17934592068195343,
-0.5180881023406982,
0.14130786061286926,
-0.19694869220256805,
-0.8582077622413635,
0.43418434262275696,
-0.06551874428987503,
0.09023165702819824,
0.17044471204280853,
0.11194708943367004,
-0.10036078840494156,
1.0216883420944214,
0.3352034389972687,
0.019322669133543968,
0.5885799527168274,
0.0074203647673130035,
0.06765091419219971,
-0.4760189354419708,
-0.029891738668084145,
0.16168372333049774,
-0.1717846691608429,
-0.6515743136405945,
-0.5938500165939331,
0.5966362357139587,
0.14148108661174774,
-0.04896383360028267,
0.0939461961388588,
-0.13139000535011292,
0.5845467448234558,
0.5747187733650208,
0.07341200858354568,
0.24914276599884033,
-0.2803553342819214,
-0.16827432811260223,
0.11014288663864136,
-0.6745770573616028,
-0.4620608389377594,
0.7311193943023682,
0.15101675689220428,
0.7135088443756104,
0.09674801677465439,
0.5998069047927856,
0.4228053092956543,
0.336099237203598,
-0.5024915933609009,
0.766765296459198,
-0.2698289453983307,
-0.16377843916416168,
-0.49193158745765686,
-0.4004736542701721,
-0.6960515975952148,
0.2667686939239502,
-0.1713358759880066,
-0.45403605699539185,
-0.27267736196517944,
0.2790880799293518,
-0.4324008822441101,
0.5520540475845337,
-0.4272245168685913,
0.3515470027923584,
-0.4217739999294281,
-0.8963539600372314,
0.019793281331658363,
-0.6816405057907104,
0.5416161417961121,
0.13297326862812042,
0.08725634962320328,
-0.31210020184516907,
-0.10826867818832397,
0.5264487862586975,
-0.676489531993866,
0.7490724325180054,
-0.41946759819984436,
0.21114379167556763,
0.014838971197605133,
0.20530812442302704,
0.9467344284057617,
0.3921211361885071,
-0.2970910668373108,
0.1781005710363388,
0.16534847021102905,
-0.35464608669281006,
-0.5577212572097778,
0.6518194675445557,
-0.4621201455593109,
-0.9130730628967285,
-0.6211579442024231,
-0.34178340435028076,
-0.2945491671562195,
0.24506226181983948,
0.12155598402023315,
-0.11652931571006775,
-0.2988533079624176,
-0.1411219835281372,
0.4340685307979584,
-0.16767801344394684,
0.6853664517402649,
0.6530221104621887,
-0.6973257660865784,
-0.08940643817186356,
0.4811423718929291,
0.05243498086929321,
0.27309471368789673,
0.35522523522377014,
-0.09168578684329987,
-0.2827911972999573,
-0.499141126871109,
-0.7836664319038391,
-0.08356069773435593,
-0.40984657406806946,
-0.2046034038066864,
-0.6517289280891418,
-0.2106437385082245,
-0.29901227355003357,
-0.14447781443595886,
-0.5288313031196594,
-0.38227155804634094,
-0.33659565448760986,
0.15361841022968292,
0.6977062821388245,
0.4676191806793213,
0.24922627210617065,
0.5952869653701782,
-0.7419292330741882,
0.34224820137023926,
-0.013408373109996319,
0.584318220615387,
0.02934390679001808,
-0.4218955636024475,
-0.2493714839220047,
-0.20857176184654236,
-0.028974687680602074,
-0.6468731760978699,
0.5705408453941345,
0.11053277552127838,
0.5412748456001282,
0.6525188088417053,
0.1139107421040535,
0.7945073843002319,
-0.9265654683113098,
0.8116752505302429,
0.2579253911972046,
-0.6054192185401917,
0.2321484237909317,
-0.39752066135406494,
0.36758944392204285,
0.41359013319015503,
0.5398710370063782,
-0.4927210807800293,
-0.29393208026885986,
-0.30110156536102295,
-1.0696262121200562,
0.7531931400299072,
0.1188763901591301,
-0.08803600072860718,
-0.3687548041343689,
0.4503793716430664,
0.4857805669307709,
0.13848793506622314,
-0.29898449778556824,
-0.5188775062561035,
-0.02130979113280773,
0.10429155081510544,
-0.008143824525177479,
-0.1558067798614502,
0.271221399307251,
-0.20926833152770996,
0.7461324334144592,
-0.4104454815387726,
0.5724785327911377,
-0.05726396292448044,
-0.1230798214673996,
-0.12317482382059097,
0.057249583303928375,
0.45812949538230896,
0.6296591758728027,
-0.22192178666591644,
0.13944023847579956,
0.28059282898902893,
-0.19806328415870667,
0.0010206608567386866,
0.3042507767677307,
-0.12671959400177002,
-0.003463166067376733,
0.13053886592388153,
0.8696262836456299,
0.15952609479427338,
-0.8045973777770996,
0.4301586449146271,
-0.047671690583229065,
0.12391471117734909,
-0.8797280192375183,
0.4883766174316406,
0.22409480810165405,
0.49778562784194946,
0.42662477493286133,
-0.18601521849632263,
0.2967691719532013,
-0.24037578701972961,
0.04905058443546295,
0.42077645659446716,
-0.18464618921279907,
0.20642155408859253,
0.9677414894104004,
-0.11351574957370758,
-0.23449808359146118,
0.744850218296051,
-0.23808634281158447,
-0.18188787996768951,
0.6815481781959534,
0.43887922167778015,
0.731216311454773,
-0.06824643909931183,
0.1301838606595993,
-0.14359275996685028,
-0.10140736401081085,
-0.14066240191459656,
0.31786873936653137,
0.15910671651363373,
-0.29214584827423096,
-0.577174961566925,
-0.8937035799026489,
-0.7603709101676941,
0.04744846001267433,
-0.5423732399940491,
0.21234340965747833,
-0.5801209211349487,
-0.15893502533435822,
-0.16979357600212097,
-0.1592734456062317,
-0.9103898406028748,
-0.025826996192336082,
0.354465514421463,
0.8726046085357666,
-0.528015673160553,
1.031919240951538,
0.38264673948287964,
-0.13186070322990417,
-0.37233710289001465,
-0.12693895399570465,
0.01293637789785862,
-0.6609007120132446,
0.5362269282341003,
0.246797576546669,
-0.3737856149673462,
0.01406811736524105,
-0.5015414953231812,
-1.1200326681137085,
1.478821039199829,
0.5875919461250305,
-1.0054205656051636,
-0.1036870926618576,
0.47060588002204895,
0.3048069179058075,
-0.4979884922504425,
0.697212278842926,
0.27050986886024475,
0.5276880264282227,
0.1548847258090973,
-0.43554413318634033,
0.2665269076824188,
-0.31507936120033264,
0.5196582674980164,
-0.05098779499530792,
-0.9346233010292053,
0.5178130269050598,
-0.18735545873641968,
-0.17203323543071747,
0.43965598940849304,
1.1954917907714844,
0.42133283615112305,
0.35790279507637024,
0.8179746270179749,
0.21454642713069916,
0.7185924053192139,
-0.12592098116874695,
1.2507942914962769,
-0.4689498543739319,
-0.23283608257770538,
1.2585216760635376,
-0.7510301470756531,
0.6036415696144104,
0.7196139693260193,
-0.23395316302776337,
0.4003031253814697,
0.8533317446708679,
-0.23308522999286652,
0.5848221778869629,
0.36721372604370117,
-0.16108256578445435,
-0.2967667579650879,
-0.2530418336391449,
0.02686459757387638,
0.08279460668563843,
0.08851484209299088,
-0.2357618361711502,
0.14946889877319336,
0.018888624384999275,
-0.09086573868989944,
-0.033914513885974884,
-0.15946198999881744,
0.3606213629245758,
0.03124770149588585,
-0.9631300568580627,
0.3148936629295349,
0.1274343729019165,
0.7516880035400391,
-0.31420615315437317,
-0.2497352957725525,
-0.32302361726760864,
-0.1461694985628128,
-0.03440283238887787,
-0.5583921074867249,
0.18587888777256012,
-0.07000159472227097,
-0.5124123096466064,
-0.2873862385749817,
0.5138681530952454,
-0.3257145285606384,
-0.29579198360443115,
0.5469740629196167,
0.4527604579925537,
0.014166569337248802,
0.09834360331296921,
-0.4989817440509796,
0.13044176995754242,
-0.31203752756118774,
-0.5097840428352356,
0.49726420640945435,
-0.06686677038669586,
-0.060869306325912476,
0.8258088827133179,
0.8212886452674866,
-0.04562599956989288,
0.5291838049888611,
0.1281369924545288,
0.7564867734909058,
-0.5692564249038696,
-0.5838329195976257,
-0.8690019249916077,
0.23911812901496887,
0.0263778418302536,
0.04301746189594269,
0.20007602870464325,
0.5064886808395386,
0.8035341501235962,
-0.25733962655067444,
0.5256580114364624,
0.11935531347990036,
0.38771894574165344,
-0.8078758120536804,
0.5804884433746338,
-0.5710305571556091,
0.5432338714599609,
-0.12233076989650726,
-0.8829783201217651,
0.1398700624704361,
0.13231800496578217,
-0.16103345155715942,
0.05130258947610855,
0.45198240876197815,
0.7455493211746216,
-0.19176341593265533,
0.2920967936515808,
0.46900689601898193,
0.11479149758815765,
0.1702611893415451,
0.3904486894607544,
0.8631548285484314,
0.035268183797597885,
0.3720875382423401,
-0.6811813116073608,
-0.024269763380289078,
-0.4221021234989166,
-0.960900604724884,
-0.7266289591789246,
-0.2929687201976776,
-0.1822073757648468,
-0.06206338107585907,
0.29219865798950195,
1.1523557901382446,
0.6577090620994568,
-0.4855855405330658,
-0.2748538851737976,
-0.1935514509677887,
-0.17209728062152863,
-0.5095267295837402,
-0.35796791315078735,
0.2286149114370346,
-0.24988816678524017,
-0.7393479943275452,
0.9999991059303284,
0.18845881521701813,
-0.06451980024576187,
-0.14680776000022888,
-0.18975968658924103,
-0.3664955198764801,
0.23605866730213165,
0.40333178639411926,
0.18649056553840637,
-0.925024151802063,
-0.14403466880321503,
0.025302311405539513,
-0.1308247447013855,
-0.19965004920959473,
0.3897111117839813,
-0.5823283195495605,
0.08781298249959946,
0.32382380962371826,
0.9591216444969177,
0.903572142124176,
-0.17825756967067719,
0.5675800442695618,
-0.629341185092926,
-0.061760298907756805,
0.17240677773952484,
0.5826300382614136,
-0.04366561025381088,
-0.9383752346038818,
0.7367551922798157,
0.11535332351922989,
-0.3059201240539551,
-0.6971750259399414,
0.3138611912727356,
-0.9970242381095886,
-0.19513338804244995,
0.888825535774231,
-0.27904000878334045,
-0.37599653005599976,
0.23214854300022125,
0.3329932987689972,
0.5582301616668701,
-0.43320325016975403,
0.5186907649040222,
0.30249863862991333,
-0.5385576486587524,
-0.2687664031982422,
-0.7678660154342651,
0.22988705337047577,
0.6260995864868164,
-0.5523243546485901,
-0.04592667147517204,
0.4042331576347351,
0.05835498124361038,
-0.2832907438278198,
0.5025438666343689,
0.20385824143886566,
0.15979091823101044,
-0.33055025339126587,
-0.11071444302797318,
-0.4929704964160919,
-0.4758761525154114,
0.14735004305839539,
0.0579913929104805,
0.03160480782389641,
0.14410299062728882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08495v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08495v3
|
Dataset Reset Policy Optimization for RLHF
| 2024-04-12T14:25:49 | 2024-04-16T17:36:39 |
Jonathan D. Chang, Wenhao Zhan, Owen Oertell, Kianté Brantley, Dipendra Misra, Jason D. Lee, Wen Sun
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Reinforcement Learning (RL) from Human Preference-based feedback is a popular
paradigm for fine-tuning generative models, which has produced impressive
models such as GPT-4 and Claude3 Opus. This framework often consists of two
steps: learning a reward model from an offline preference dataset followed by
running online RL to optimize the learned reward model. In this work,
leveraging the idea of reset, we propose a new RLHF algorithm with provable
guarantees. Motivated by the fact that offline preference dataset provides
informative states (i.e., data that is preferred by the labelers), our new
algorithm, Dataset Reset Policy Optimization (DR-PO), integrates the existing
offline preference dataset into the online policy training procedure via
dataset reset: it directly resets the policy optimizer to the states in the
offline dataset, instead of always starting from the initial state
distribution. In theory, we show that DR-PO learns to perform at least as good
as any policy that is covered by the offline dataset under general function
approximation with finite sample complexity. In experiments, we demonstrate
that on both the TL;DR summarization and the Anthropic Helpful Harmful (HH)
dataset, the generation from DR-PO is better than that from Proximal Policy
Optimization (PPO) and Direction Preference Optimization (DPO), under the
metric of GPT4 win-rate. Code for this work can be found at
https://github.com/Cornell-RL/drpo.
|
[
-0.39066916704177856,
-0.3882642388343811,
0.2281631976366043,
-0.4480011761188507,
-0.13823390007019043,
-0.1152094230055809,
-0.3839249610900879,
-0.15980499982833862,
0.2065422683954239,
0.5523059368133545,
-1.0377624034881592,
0.015457402914762497,
-0.10169015824794769,
0.1939922273159027,
0.3202148377895355,
1.4790427684783936,
-0.10887210816144943,
-0.26954200863838196,
-0.1970902383327484,
-0.10201998054981232,
-0.4176422655582428,
-0.31116077303886414,
-0.6694729924201965,
-0.7946131229400635,
0.5035390257835388,
0.46391403675079346,
0.7750091552734375,
0.6338891386985779,
0.23570358753204346,
0.21229732036590576,
0.2140805572271347,
0.5419325232505798,
-1.1216497421264648,
-0.021867023780941963,
-0.19178897142410278,
-0.4128149449825287,
-0.20960944890975952,
0.029691437259316444,
0.5101959705352783,
0.28761640191078186,
-0.5817379951477051,
-0.14089323580265045,
0.011140887625515461,
1.0258783102035522,
-0.7487332224845886,
0.2132629156112671,
-0.49867624044418335,
0.40384286642074585,
0.26950228214263916,
-0.6160770058631897,
-0.4426654577255249,
-0.8004867434501648,
0.09411429613828659,
-0.9945201277732849,
0.14048223197460175,
0.12052227556705475,
0.9376873970031738,
0.43889784812927246,
-0.16162313520908356,
0.06576260924339294,
-0.7897529006004333,
0.9658031463623047,
-0.460126668214798,
0.1249440610408783,
0.5627953410148621,
0.4088382422924042,
-0.46051591634750366,
-0.5016757249832153,
-0.6171858310699463,
-0.2680817246437073,
0.04613800719380379,
0.3950076699256897,
0.09752050042152405,
0.13489098846912384,
0.20964503288269043,
0.4716908037662506,
-0.4109567105770111,
0.0058543020859360695,
-0.12064022570848465,
-0.2612290680408478,
0.6465165019035339,
0.18331420421600342,
-0.23774603009223938,
-0.036907993257045746,
-0.42847558856010437,
-0.525537371635437,
-0.8573760986328125,
0.3662292957305908,
0.4735766351222992,
0.32626602053642273,
-0.04962429031729698,
0.23061726987361908,
-0.2942779064178467,
0.7744360566139221,
0.1439681500196457,
-0.30256572365760803,
0.4958299994468689,
-0.17251762747764587,
0.03377265855669975,
-0.020697571337223053,
0.34775134921073914,
0.613921046257019,
0.4891452193260193,
-0.007976661436259747,
-0.5214357972145081,
-0.2671595513820648,
0.4074443280696869,
-0.5424231290817261,
-0.3251996636390686,
0.25686800479888916,
-0.461860716342926,
-0.5174274444580078,
0.17748267948627472,
-0.645331859588623,
-0.5118183493614197,
-0.43853893876075745,
0.3545636534690857,
-0.09917175024747849,
-0.4895859658718109,
0.20256589353084564,
0.03220590949058533,
0.10648240149021149,
0.27547329664230347,
-0.9509730339050293,
0.22234739363193512,
0.5925015807151794,
0.4094960689544678,
-0.20874319970607758,
-0.3504573702812195,
-0.7621996998786926,
-0.0986858606338501,
-0.3678496479988098,
0.42032766342163086,
-0.4028806686401367,
-0.5577012896537781,
0.2037162482738495,
0.029122307896614075,
-0.10864919424057007,
-0.7073034644126892,
0.5406721830368042,
-0.666431188583374,
0.3057294487953186,
-0.5332682728767395,
-0.5825129151344299,
-0.1645440012216568,
0.5408300161361694,
-0.8351981043815613,
0.8662244081497192,
0.17150457203388214,
-0.8035562634468079,
0.5882938504219055,
-0.7653095722198486,
-0.27896547317504883,
-0.22212108969688416,
-0.09795397520065308,
-1.0821117162704468,
-0.32458972930908203,
0.027739277109503746,
0.12207051366567612,
0.028781119734048843,
0.4769305884838104,
-0.4770633578300476,
-0.40379953384399414,
0.0724513977766037,
-0.19262152910232544,
0.5333410501480103,
0.0137438103556633,
-0.3647194504737854,
0.4859740734100342,
-0.6001089811325073,
0.16393768787384033,
0.2464139610528946,
-0.6918123364448547,
0.03740178793668747,
0.14784853160381317,
-0.10981722176074982,
0.19331525266170502,
0.031009960919618607,
-0.7184867262840271,
0.3916575610637665,
-0.3938942551612854,
0.6283007264137268,
1.0054033994674683,
0.3609769940376282,
0.27612316608428955,
-0.605195164680481,
0.5338451266288757,
-0.3295362889766693,
0.3152965307235718,
0.02206723764538765,
-0.3100505471229553,
-0.4043445289134979,
-0.19729116559028625,
0.15602584183216095,
0.5208461880683899,
-0.9169421195983887,
0.5196589827537537,
-0.20974156260490417,
0.01909637451171875,
-0.2432456761598587,
-0.25424861907958984,
0.6015177965164185,
0.7906185388565063,
0.4103882610797882,
0.10481180250644684,
-0.45617082715034485,
-0.8779114484786987,
-0.050990812480449677,
-0.08587586134672165,
0.09793612360954285,
0.6404050588607788,
0.502319872379303,
0.05382031947374344,
1.2082207202911377,
-0.672063946723938,
-0.4225735366344452,
-0.2649160325527191,
0.08480977267026901,
0.20108914375305176,
0.2112703174352646,
0.32847505807876587,
-0.7915520071983337,
-0.24157795310020447,
-0.3115943372249603,
-0.5273155570030212,
0.21048887073993683,
-0.02574763633310795,
0.06331305205821991,
0.2621692717075348,
-0.005824253894388676,
-0.16105276346206665,
0.3648253083229065,
0.2358773648738861,
-0.1856445074081421,
0.5938675999641418,
-0.8195345997810364,
0.26086193323135376,
-0.6384021639823914,
0.1386975347995758,
-0.3477230370044708,
-0.43457624316215515,
-0.5098463892936707,
-0.1360437572002411,
-0.051771361380815506,
-0.23731940984725952,
-0.510349690914154,
0.5417218208312988,
-0.11390847712755203,
-0.13774777948856354,
-0.38703182339668274,
-0.1560230553150177,
-0.09978894889354706,
0.7616745233535767,
0.24870097637176514,
0.6609065532684326,
0.1688973307609558,
-0.7599573731422424,
0.35648113489151,
0.3130199909210205,
-0.08003050833940506,
0.43625447154045105,
-0.4537927210330963,
0.027015887200832367,
-0.38099998235702515,
0.6216611862182617,
-0.4647267162799835,
-0.22970354557037354,
0.4566315710544586,
0.01742525026202202,
0.28621622920036316,
0.15229418873786926,
-0.20087935030460358,
-0.31327900290489197,
-0.541368305683136,
0.3184228837490082,
0.40090224146842957,
-0.7527985572814941,
0.2673560082912445,
0.39718005061149597,
0.43216368556022644,
-0.7576446533203125,
-0.13670292496681213,
-0.42431366443634033,
-0.3504802882671356,
-0.0825137346982956,
0.3918561637401581,
-0.005305868107825518,
0.07003957778215408,
-0.0268226508051157,
0.019856004044413567,
0.300540566444397,
0.004887174349278212,
0.14332041144371033,
0.36961105465888977,
0.4638899862766266,
0.11795574426651001,
-0.34635230898857117,
-0.3972567319869995,
-0.15448814630508423,
-0.3635232448577881,
0.4213979244232178,
-0.17373985052108765,
-0.20608022809028625,
-0.40359973907470703,
-0.07215013355016708,
-0.002063038758933544,
-0.13947421312332153,
0.3390776813030243,
0.3984639346599579,
-0.2700306177139282,
-0.3157406151294708,
0.0032416442409157753,
-0.6653025150299072,
-0.4061356484889984,
0.3521323800086975,
-0.38246312737464905,
-0.5868796110153198,
0.18600575625896454,
0.17075733840465546,
0.3085005283355713,
0.21454301476478577,
0.29350581765174866,
-0.07544426620006561,
0.6475739479064941,
0.4633835256099701,
-0.2400124967098236,
0.45250827074050903,
-0.43408551812171936,
0.1168685331940651,
-0.4345146715641022,
-0.3444380760192871,
-0.07395918667316437,
-0.3782392740249634,
-0.6948501467704773,
-0.03321843221783638,
0.5595195889472961,
0.05278025195002556,
-0.3986082077026367,
0.1069289818406105,
-0.5341812968254089,
0.4292503893375397,
0.7248697876930237,
0.5685002207756042,
0.2334693968296051,
0.2032398283481598,
0.04249786585569382,
0.007303692400455475,
-0.7160687446594238,
0.009702303446829319,
1.2095285654067993,
0.25293487310409546,
0.7362987995147705,
-0.2298542708158493,
0.8166128993034363,
0.5638658404350281,
0.18139848113059998,
-0.623469889163971,
0.31643569469451904,
-0.13051189482212067,
-0.33772408962249756,
-0.5844355225563049,
-0.6508317589759827,
-0.9861218333244324,
0.028470007702708244,
-0.372139036655426,
-0.4436582624912262,
0.3630911111831665,
0.8991621136665344,
-0.38114386796951294,
0.41149580478668213,
-0.23910827934741974,
0.5845712423324585,
-0.19035761058330536,
-0.4617544710636139,
-0.48803338408470154,
-0.74156653881073,
0.34084534645080566,
0.04062590375542641,
0.047536492347717285,
-0.22450953722000122,
0.21553699672222137,
0.833880603313446,
-0.5351929664611816,
0.5793424844741821,
-0.7736647725105286,
-0.06031934916973114,
0.16195470094680786,
-0.2288178652524948,
0.8351484537124634,
0.06471157819032669,
-0.08996769785881042,
-0.11674851924180984,
-0.008822587318718433,
-0.272952139377594,
-0.5635010600090027,
0.4410308301448822,
-0.9208964705467224,
-0.23498056828975677,
-0.4607681334018707,
-0.4361366331577301,
-0.36348289251327515,
0.15115925669670105,
0.3240503668785095,
0.5059658885002136,
-0.14647090435028076,
-0.023755516856908798,
0.9180400371551514,
-0.3631325364112854,
0.3459114134311676,
0.5180684924125671,
-0.28009891510009766,
-0.6287659406661987,
1.2454533576965332,
-0.2808836102485657,
0.33126893639564514,
0.6163100004196167,
0.45713919401168823,
-0.49173349142074585,
-0.04476047679781914,
-0.5129311680793762,
0.05609133094549179,
-0.6109678149223328,
-0.24533408880233765,
-0.18199844658374786,
0.024807963520288467,
0.18974533677101135,
-0.02339000441133976,
-0.43217408657073975,
-0.43129146099090576,
-0.12233070284128189,
-0.06589554250240326,
0.45674002170562744,
0.4324282109737396,
-0.425098180770874,
0.010789540596306324,
-0.3600667417049408,
0.6153720021247864,
0.2515678107738495,
0.46807384490966797,
-0.20864127576351166,
-0.4050869345664978,
-0.06930731981992722,
0.36435744166374207,
-0.21013818681240082,
-0.5218450427055359,
0.11422042548656464,
0.5452678799629211,
0.4995245635509491,
0.6325122117996216,
0.4788927435874939,
0.3350292444229126,
-0.40750840306282043,
0.19283081591129303,
0.23186329007148743,
-0.2685074806213379,
0.4093208312988281,
-0.36414480209350586,
0.1917223334312439,
0.7982022166252136,
0.3121103048324585,
-0.4691173732280731,
0.21107426285743713,
-0.5757832527160645,
-0.6968838572502136,
0.8336756229400635,
0.03628619760274887,
-0.2092132568359375,
0.24650560319423676,
0.5338777899742126,
0.24836313724517822,
0.4028271436691284,
-0.46853014826774597,
-0.44373106956481934,
-0.5071215033531189,
0.06924711167812347,
-0.1187448650598526,
-0.0949556827545166,
-0.38048022985458374,
-0.00993778184056282,
0.9728445410728455,
-0.13938693702220917,
0.23973482847213745,
-0.03625566139817238,
0.1792842298746109,
-0.24057671427726746,
0.25629037618637085,
0.5789777636528015,
0.6581628918647766,
-0.6151204109191895,
-0.18451984226703644,
-0.16601096093654633,
-0.391448974609375,
0.3825247287750244,
0.1113818809390068,
-0.709552526473999,
-0.472088485956192,
0.1254481077194214,
1.0598732233047485,
0.26566144824028015,
-0.7061772346496582,
0.3813132643699646,
-0.05232030153274536,
-0.4567337930202484,
-0.3395892083644867,
0.24444010853767395,
-0.3898313045501709,
-0.18184147775173187,
0.19266660511493683,
0.01563757099211216,
-0.028495710343122482,
-0.41506949067115784,
0.5568665266036987,
0.38501670956611633,
-0.3415724039077759,
-0.15378671884536743,
0.5602153539657593,
0.2188328206539154,
-0.1534358263015747,
0.8081911206245422,
-0.36351826786994934,
-0.6533659100532532,
0.5483599305152893,
0.5118696093559265,
0.5973408222198486,
0.004312117118388414,
0.5570266842842102,
0.6375910639762878,
-0.08250320702791214,
-0.2832915484905243,
0.5855968594551086,
-0.03482399135828018,
-1.0087049007415771,
-0.02005343697965145,
-0.5784385204315186,
-0.5367509722709656,
0.21306876838207245,
-0.8096877336502075,
0.06921762973070145,
-0.4109058082103729,
-0.1593802571296692,
-0.31082549691200256,
0.18906690180301666,
-0.5433140397071838,
0.4374130666255951,
-0.3065846264362335,
0.5309531688690186,
-0.8268642425537109,
0.7761507034301758,
0.48212653398513794,
-0.3434925675392151,
-0.7160344123840332,
-0.02887931652367115,
0.0638074055314064,
-0.9908099174499512,
0.36408329010009766,
-0.0019761600997298956,
-0.18173585832118988,
0.26635169982910156,
-0.14555419981479645,
-0.7608392834663391,
1.003709077835083,
0.24922148883342743,
-0.5832260847091675,
0.1829976737499237,
0.11319486051797867,
0.1970180720090866,
-0.21630756556987762,
0.141192227602005,
0.7160366177558899,
0.7108398675918579,
-0.11000977456569672,
-0.7762585878372192,
0.03493041545152664,
0.06574942916631699,
-0.12096612900495529,
0.39425987005233765,
-0.4986967146396637,
0.42892760038375854,
-0.5976743102073669,
0.020421909168362617,
-0.2723107635974884,
0.3768216371536255,
0.6549420356750488,
0.028164291754364967,
0.9975829124450684,
0.7131524682044983,
0.7898291349411011,
-0.12530916929244995,
1.0700583457946777,
-0.1576353907585144,
0.5888598561286926,
1.2352005243301392,
-0.2932230234146118,
0.8108859658241272,
0.3385690450668335,
-0.3849708139896393,
0.2206711769104004,
0.9796670079231262,
-0.17272308468818665,
1.0652459859848022,
0.41822975873947144,
-0.26056820154190063,
-0.16776354610919952,
-0.2374987006187439,
-0.3755040466785431,
0.16148199141025543,
-0.27530649304389954,
-0.03285117819905281,
-0.3672041594982147,
0.3162338137626648,
-0.08319239318370819,
0.13165833055973053,
-0.3463880717754364,
0.8941567540168762,
-0.28290534019470215,
-1.014666199684143,
0.8114413022994995,
0.0882466584444046,
0.3796369731426239,
-0.5197237133979797,
-0.21750640869140625,
-0.2676646411418915,
0.47345033288002014,
-0.34441420435905457,
-0.6422632932662964,
0.16504301130771637,
-0.5089523196220398,
-0.3751934766769409,
-0.30817368626594543,
0.5741134881973267,
-0.4442967176437378,
0.010594295337796211,
0.12665042281150818,
-0.03621341660618782,
0.01696689799427986,
0.2397681027650833,
-0.7011488080024719,
-0.23863673210144043,
0.2752029001712799,
-0.4248400628566742,
0.4101002812385559,
-0.2957277297973633,
-0.09606782346963882,
0.8682363033294678,
0.4852999448776245,
0.1754891276359558,
-0.30199486017227173,
0.13103047013282776,
0.7149757146835327,
-0.3306835889816284,
-0.8157932162284851,
-0.448091983795166,
0.27042829990386963,
0.019752437248826027,
-0.2350546419620514,
0.17334677278995514,
0.527600884437561,
0.8883301615715027,
-0.2031552940607071,
0.9314725995063782,
-0.09277771413326263,
0.7008902430534363,
-0.612047553062439,
0.5701472759246826,
-0.5479370951652527,
0.019680259749293327,
0.21586111187934875,
-0.7352864742279053,
0.1905841827392578,
0.5222132205963135,
-0.3885722756385803,
0.2052382081747055,
0.5067133903503418,
0.8575451970100403,
-0.030638685449957848,
0.0774766057729721,
0.19490653276443481,
-0.2698959708213806,
0.17552131414413452,
0.6896348595619202,
0.4974473714828491,
-0.10113154351711273,
0.4556862711906433,
-0.530442476272583,
-0.47598958015441895,
-0.2393827587366104,
-1.1042771339416504,
-0.5155408978462219,
-0.4099675714969635,
-0.18300428986549377,
-0.46605315804481506,
0.4218156635761261,
0.9692444801330566,
0.6315222382545471,
-0.8902661204338074,
0.01653180457651615,
-0.25240376591682434,
0.05685276538133621,
-0.5880790948867798,
-0.24656102061271667,
0.5555993318557739,
-0.22617872059345245,
-0.3547726273536682,
0.3738933503627777,
0.10902280360460281,
-0.35397157073020935,
-0.2870582640171051,
-0.6748806238174438,
-0.03606482595205307,
-0.2620004415512085,
0.19768281280994415,
0.7891802787780762,
-0.5350573658943176,
-0.2740456163883209,
-0.3811275362968445,
0.2837584614753723,
0.22771696746349335,
1.0286006927490234,
-0.8474459648132324,
0.6595076322555542,
0.4269033968448639,
0.7584689855575562,
0.6177530288696289,
0.2879951298236847,
0.7268068194389343,
-0.6186537742614746,
0.010610992088913918,
0.10670433938503265,
0.2369154542684555,
0.348779559135437,
-0.4540329873561859,
0.4219944179058075,
0.25911471247673035,
-0.6658743619918823,
-0.6436052918434143,
0.5219272375106812,
-0.4620843231678009,
-0.16972441971302032,
1.0068107843399048,
-0.3371487557888031,
0.08337516337633133,
-0.041179608553647995,
-0.04965268447995186,
0.2523082494735718,
-0.5738289952278137,
1.0338815450668335,
0.19126099348068237,
-0.4407573938369751,
-0.15271438658237457,
-0.3719905614852905,
1.1105066537857056,
0.38886818289756775,
-0.9330557584762573,
0.2263394147157669,
0.4944295883178711,
0.35013702511787415,
-0.34236273169517517,
0.8789610862731934,
0.25307902693748474,
0.22733381390571594,
-0.4085281789302826,
-0.004485647659748793,
-0.48185375332832336,
-0.4532421827316284,
-0.3299815058708191,
0.06628476083278656,
0.01802733913064003,
-0.35332852602005005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08491v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08491v1
|
Mitigating Language-Level Performance Disparity in mPLMs via Teacher Language Selection and Cross-lingual Self-Distillation
| 2024-04-12T14:19:16 | 2024-04-12T14:19:16 |
Haozhe Zhao, Zefan Cai, Shuzheng Si, Liang Chen, Yufeng He, Kaikai An, Baobao Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large-scale multilingual Pretrained Language Models (mPLMs) yield impressive
performance on cross-language tasks, yet significant performance disparities
exist across different languages within the same mPLM. Previous studies
endeavored to narrow these disparities by supervise fine-tuning the mPLMs with
multilingual data. However, obtaining labeled multilingual data is
time-consuming, and fine-tuning mPLM with limited labeled multilingual data
merely encapsulates the knowledge specific to the labeled data. Therefore, we
introduce ALSACE to leverage the learned knowledge from the well-performing
languages to guide under-performing ones within the same mPLM, eliminating the
need for additional labeled multilingual data. Experiments show that ALSACE
effectively mitigates language-level performance disparity across various mPLMs
while showing the competitive performance on different multilingual NLU tasks,
ranging from full resource to limited resource settings. The code for our
approach is available at https://github.com/pkunlp-icler/ALSACE.
|
[
-0.6701013445854187,
-0.41557562351226807,
0.3274358808994293,
0.37473514676094055,
-0.16213560104370117,
0.33826157450675964,
-0.3197419345378876,
-0.2784876823425293,
-0.10809756070375443,
0.4475996792316437,
-0.3753525912761688,
-0.3070305287837982,
-0.9704420566558838,
0.10991154611110687,
-0.06867051869630814,
1.0952417850494385,
0.0967959314584732,
0.18474934995174408,
-0.2639048993587494,
-0.3047749996185303,
-0.21426191926002502,
-0.8300842046737671,
-0.7053353786468506,
-0.7265187501907349,
0.6787140965461731,
0.5391994714736938,
0.30609130859375,
0.38738030195236206,
0.24558424949645996,
0.26314884424209595,
0.02294011414051056,
0.11208591610193253,
-0.6724801659584045,
-0.1297442764043808,
-0.22849848866462708,
-0.2230743020772934,
-0.4137342572212219,
-0.13601499795913696,
0.8261653184890747,
0.5162855982780457,
-0.3656974732875824,
0.17189665138721466,
0.5201084613800049,
0.9114389419555664,
-0.8245945572853088,
0.15162913501262665,
-0.5389935970306396,
0.14234712719917297,
-0.4849776029586792,
-0.08575992286205292,
-0.36668071150779724,
-0.07061988115310669,
-0.049236077815294266,
-0.3734980821609497,
0.1795443892478943,
-0.2603810429573059,
0.636205792427063,
0.4376680552959442,
-0.5020477771759033,
0.1618182212114334,
-0.7227405905723572,
0.8583648800849915,
-0.6337605118751526,
0.6470306515693665,
0.7111160755157471,
0.37196144461631775,
0.1732025146484375,
-0.4876890182495117,
-0.1978493481874466,
-0.07018019258975983,
-0.4054235816001892,
0.03249144181609154,
-0.24018047749996185,
-0.22076326608657837,
0.3336079716682434,
0.09001804143190384,
-0.7526006698608398,
0.44811487197875977,
-0.25173261761665344,
-0.18617981672286987,
0.627305269241333,
-0.07845434546470642,
0.16502965986728668,
0.3538186848163605,
-0.2175692617893219,
-0.08887592703104019,
-0.6985063552856445,
0.1395656168460846,
0.5414952039718628,
0.39436084032058716,
-0.02678116410970688,
0.27863335609436035,
-0.290514200925827,
0.6101272702217102,
-0.1985204815864563,
-0.21839076280593872,
0.39976194500923157,
-0.13150262832641602,
0.0028995180036872625,
0.12950919568538666,
0.627598226070404,
0.04760897159576416,
0.5241185426712036,
-0.06963537633419037,
-0.5323405265808105,
-0.07046311348676682,
-0.13632473349571228,
-0.9137701392173767,
-0.7323573231697083,
-0.22371017932891846,
-0.1847020536661148,
0.21904446184635162,
-0.2834051251411438,
-0.8936418294906616,
-0.12035568803548813,
-0.33387377858161926,
0.3634604215621948,
-0.13560889661312103,
-0.3927048444747925,
-0.11915362626314163,
-0.1290457546710968,
-0.3203217685222626,
0.05769624188542366,
-1.2133899927139282,
0.33310452103614807,
0.39164990186691284,
0.5775090456008911,
-0.20409151911735535,
-0.8683974146842957,
-0.7015777826309204,
0.2823888957500458,
-0.09051983803510666,
0.5284072160720825,
-0.6762340068817139,
-0.4490663707256317,
-0.15261739492416382,
-0.15267226099967957,
-0.1694546639919281,
-0.6450644731521606,
0.14673075079917908,
-0.3263475000858307,
0.19910313189029694,
-0.24975651502609253,
-0.4354526698589325,
0.09600123018026352,
0.18273048102855682,
-0.755878746509552,
1.3344969749450684,
0.10462851077318192,
-0.702472448348999,
0.6009165644645691,
-0.3183250427246094,
-0.7038174271583557,
-0.10952039062976837,
-0.13943225145339966,
-0.5110077857971191,
0.04253341630101204,
0.6414344310760498,
0.3611712157726288,
-0.15484672784805298,
0.20088274776935577,
0.21718384325504303,
-0.24094043672084808,
-0.37694501876831055,
-0.5973230004310608,
0.518181562423706,
0.11850032210350037,
-0.3615712821483612,
0.029534751549363136,
-0.8246477246284485,
-0.021640188992023468,
0.105294369161129,
-0.45224323868751526,
-0.3214494585990906,
0.061780668795108795,
-0.11895622313022614,
0.395769327878952,
0.27143752574920654,
-0.27938172221183777,
0.2005242556333542,
-0.07662113755941391,
0.13482163846492767,
0.7133548855781555,
-0.4054661989212036,
0.5141023397445679,
-0.12364781647920609,
0.5817197561264038,
0.16018925607204437,
0.3170294165611267,
0.12781234085559845,
-0.2882190942764282,
-0.7032436728477478,
-0.46549418568611145,
0.504552960395813,
0.4843670129776001,
-0.9265245199203491,
0.1844445765018463,
-0.09451210498809814,
-0.6243822574615479,
-0.6986722350120544,
0.5543608069419861,
0.4435567855834961,
0.5054737329483032,
0.7081922292709351,
-0.3104615807533264,
-0.0842682495713234,
-1.1208584308624268,
-0.2329832911491394,
0.12707623839378357,
0.2107449173927307,
0.1751863956451416,
0.20933258533477783,
-0.18619996309280396,
0.5801497101783752,
-0.5897159576416016,
-0.5204946994781494,
-0.41214728355407715,
0.1854587346315384,
0.1216542199254036,
0.6285513043403625,
0.8029249310493469,
-0.8677369952201843,
-0.8039926886558533,
-0.00773715740069747,
-0.22799652814865112,
-0.3179447650909424,
0.20163756608963013,
-0.20819130539894104,
0.41006946563720703,
0.599851667881012,
-0.12662947177886963,
0.1469697505235672,
0.9135726690292358,
-0.21690917015075684,
0.42125633358955383,
-0.48980605602264404,
0.1443479061126709,
-0.6814576983451843,
0.07899054884910583,
-0.005471698474138975,
-0.3499624729156494,
-0.5099144577980042,
-0.2775299847126007,
0.07120931893587112,
-0.01704016886651516,
-0.37389126420021057,
0.3931528627872467,
-0.5029975771903992,
0.12643927335739136,
-0.17297539114952087,
0.0841057226061821,
0.0708475261926651,
0.5291965007781982,
0.2783032953739166,
0.6269161701202393,
0.7129974961280823,
-0.5632991790771484,
-0.0005019442760385573,
0.0096311429515481,
-0.4362012445926666,
0.26038190722465515,
-0.3484540283679962,
-0.09937091171741486,
-0.13788121938705444,
0.09191811084747314,
-0.5561659336090088,
0.11579833924770355,
-0.0026890523731708527,
-0.06964895129203796,
0.5291096568107605,
-0.451829731464386,
-0.42672938108444214,
-0.1734209507703781,
0.25799018144607544,
0.7241049408912659,
0.6069592833518982,
-0.6566713452339172,
0.4271106421947479,
0.4653816521167755,
-0.2830640971660614,
-0.8373814225196838,
-0.8068891763687134,
-0.075352743268013,
-0.24272160232067108,
-0.12685289978981018,
0.04218621924519539,
-0.0007167918956838548,
-0.016919510439038277,
-0.10340794920921326,
-0.056409530341625214,
-0.2938566207885742,
0.26155126094818115,
-0.19348053634166718,
-0.003753917058929801,
-0.11552031338214874,
0.35574403405189514,
0.1326989233493805,
-0.3328551650047302,
-0.1630910038948059,
-0.35183751583099365,
0.7351519465446472,
0.14774660766124725,
-0.5658251643180847,
-0.1057521179318428,
0.3766935467720032,
0.41823676228523254,
-0.8125458359718323,
1.0470257997512817,
0.740531861782074,
-0.11244812607765198,
-0.5626819133758545,
-0.5071468949317932,
-0.32592764496803284,
-0.442945271730423,
0.3313978314399719,
-0.5659580230712891,
-0.9259853363037109,
0.2769910991191864,
-0.1309790313243866,
-0.1348295509815216,
0.302925169467926,
0.47784334421157837,
0.16273674368858337,
1.0334997177124023,
0.7734424471855164,
-0.4528939425945282,
0.5289104580879211,
-0.14662618935108185,
0.2940719425678253,
-0.3731108605861664,
-0.12387890368700027,
-0.5745552778244019,
-0.3441338837146759,
-0.6772298216819763,
-0.4354305565357208,
0.4076150357723236,
0.2923225462436676,
-0.0349673368036747,
0.22590821981430054,
-0.41655927896499634,
0.7025379538536072,
0.8332951068878174,
-0.17583653330802917,
0.2742663621902466,
-0.07831108570098877,
-0.24714916944503784,
-0.15339510142803192,
-1.069474220275879,
-0.40452468395233154,
0.8308037519454956,
0.17889909446239471,
0.6969942450523376,
0.18327057361602783,
0.9430614113807678,
0.0875503271818161,
0.042779598385095596,
-0.1766119748353958,
0.30928725004196167,
-0.4579314887523651,
-0.4422830045223236,
-0.5854529142379761,
-0.7067498564720154,
-0.804286003112793,
0.512750506401062,
-0.14949695765972137,
-0.6282516717910767,
0.01849837228655815,
0.44484296441078186,
-0.03362002968788147,
0.3263462781906128,
-0.7629756331443787,
1.279976725578308,
-0.5443527102470398,
-0.29036468267440796,
-0.39218869805336,
-0.473649263381958,
-0.0830562636256218,
-0.5277359485626221,
0.3712008595466614,
-0.4627925455570221,
0.34044885635375977,
0.3473242223262787,
-0.21050268411636353,
0.7755577564239502,
-0.4030844569206238,
-0.36571043729782104,
0.06241605803370476,
0.12187664955854416,
0.5561814308166504,
-0.04524561017751694,
-0.13761211931705475,
0.43094897270202637,
-0.02286412939429283,
-0.6176367402076721,
-0.5465496182441711,
0.8379954099655151,
-0.7063676714897156,
-0.6465725898742676,
-0.201593279838562,
-0.46988484263420105,
-0.3822777569293976,
0.2432207614183426,
0.43377894163131714,
0.5078993439674377,
-0.14786118268966675,
-0.10253474861383438,
0.4725390672683716,
-0.197121724486351,
0.45591795444488525,
0.631019651889801,
-0.34437698125839233,
-0.09776172786951065,
1.3458675146102905,
0.3428039252758026,
0.44683176279067993,
0.536552906036377,
0.3093368113040924,
-0.4227730333805084,
-0.5351259708404541,
-0.4992017447948456,
0.009876870550215244,
-0.5999226570129395,
0.012974447570741177,
-0.46728408336639404,
-0.05787475034594536,
-0.5174372792243958,
0.07338811457157135,
-0.51828533411026,
-0.4180929958820343,
-0.12280819565057755,
0.04184478893876076,
-0.037331655621528625,
0.7042812705039978,
-0.36091911792755127,
0.08975323289632797,
-0.9232543110847473,
0.1989031732082367,
0.327332079410553,
0.4888446629047394,
0.11131777614355087,
-0.37046706676483154,
-0.49414005875587463,
0.1615976095199585,
-0.2091442197561264,
-0.351182222366333,
0.30574679374694824,
0.4540397822856903,
0.8193283081054688,
0.03190864250063896,
0.23294208943843842,
0.5943621397018433,
-0.8751170039176941,
0.601807177066803,
0.1338769793510437,
-0.9967642426490784,
0.6390165090560913,
-0.06166033074259758,
0.5984096527099609,
0.5265740156173706,
0.585843563079834,
-0.5098205804824829,
-0.5188661813735962,
-0.25992995500564575,
-1.0351431369781494,
0.7819076776504517,
0.18644769489765167,
0.026194460690021515,
0.1247759610414505,
-0.18465813994407654,
0.17434030771255493,
0.20589135587215424,
-0.9786765575408936,
-0.31070783734321594,
-0.258823424577713,
-0.05621582269668579,
-0.7823466062545776,
-0.2392883151769638,
-0.2861635982990265,
-0.43952539563179016,
0.8614686727523804,
-0.21581342816352844,
-0.3577471077442169,
0.12352347373962402,
-0.2848324179649353,
-0.06252086162567139,
0.2902478873729706,
0.511732280254364,
0.9425391554832458,
0.257292777299881,
0.282889723777771,
0.38578394055366516,
-0.15572625398635864,
0.3301863670349121,
0.2644197642803192,
0.24095211923122406,
-0.21105501055717468,
0.5350145697593689,
0.8739659190177917,
0.029544772580266,
-0.5814308524131775,
0.2675900161266327,
-0.06603265553712845,
0.018482806161046028,
0.08320584893226624,
0.15236908197402954,
0.0956382229924202,
0.35391098260879517,
0.22044475376605988,
-0.19432130455970764,
-0.09811530262231827,
-0.2816718518733978,
0.31096479296684265,
0.14818157255649567,
-0.20963431894779205,
-0.02829202637076378,
0.5277044177055359,
0.4058099687099457,
-0.23150330781936646,
0.542422354221344,
-0.03927556425333023,
-0.6212696433067322,
0.4565446674823761,
0.43274638056755066,
0.5726809501647949,
-0.5178452134132385,
0.2561562955379486,
0.23814623057842255,
0.43778368830680847,
-0.10000395774841309,
0.01852242648601532,
-0.25613805651664734,
-0.6134384870529175,
-0.41886869072914124,
-0.7088660001754761,
-0.01702357456088066,
-0.04566005617380142,
-0.7277539372444153,
0.2193579524755478,
-0.11808457970619202,
-0.05832931771874428,
-0.099223792552948,
-0.301176518201828,
-0.6571041941642761,
0.30650076270103455,
0.2560616135597229,
0.8607549071311951,
-0.8968340158462524,
1.2279248237609863,
0.4829530715942383,
-0.0808391198515892,
-0.7549830079078674,
0.22538217902183533,
-0.1907319724559784,
-0.5735036134719849,
0.767468273639679,
-0.04983333870768547,
-0.2934301793575287,
0.16709770262241364,
0.15945985913276672,
-0.6493311524391174,
0.6275320649147034,
0.6884886622428894,
-1.162644863128662,
0.3429604768753052,
0.5843341946601868,
0.6312769055366516,
-0.0915680080652237,
0.029813390225172043,
0.6634510159492493,
0.49175405502319336,
-0.08331012725830078,
-1.294994831085205,
-0.48663270473480225,
0.02147158421576023,
-0.3238791525363922,
0.6420921683311462,
-0.6543287038803101,
0.7306616306304932,
0.014221692457795143,
0.05805737152695656,
-0.4824990928173065,
0.3056240975856781,
-0.04942427948117256,
0.301133930683136,
0.5087724328041077,
0.7633898258209229,
0.7330103516578674,
-0.17378884553909302,
0.8589608669281006,
-0.5056174397468567,
0.4284624755382538,
1.3354907035827637,
-0.382236510515213,
0.7731232643127441,
0.4433720111846924,
-0.012790089473128319,
0.2706194519996643,
0.4976336658000946,
0.08849174529314041,
0.742338240146637,
0.19925104081630707,
-0.4400007128715515,
-0.6108704805374146,
-0.09788376837968826,
-0.45320573449134827,
0.6488990187644958,
0.08729624003171921,
-0.07261443138122559,
-0.43144527077674866,
0.2171483039855957,
-0.19338035583496094,
0.28070497512817383,
-0.3373918831348419,
0.8232535719871521,
0.045072656124830246,
-0.7217291593551636,
0.7118670344352722,
-0.22847998142242432,
0.4588990807533264,
-0.702046275138855,
-0.17200244963169098,
-0.21254396438598633,
0.27992692589759827,
-0.08343755453824997,
-0.8232266306877136,
0.2248775064945221,
0.001654620049521327,
-0.19038507342338562,
-0.5498923063278198,
0.5910933613777161,
-1.0364784002304077,
-0.5472268462181091,
0.8683282136917114,
0.7463987469673157,
0.005607724189758301,
-0.045463912189006805,
-0.6160417795181274,
0.029403749853372574,
0.010246970690786839,
-0.13153879344463348,
0.5376282334327698,
0.6166561841964722,
0.11559383571147919,
0.7522286176681519,
0.3547462522983551,
0.22473368048667908,
0.029071366414427757,
0.4136977791786194,
0.879189133644104,
-0.12575724720954895,
-0.5152943730354309,
-1.134665846824646,
0.47062793374061584,
-0.04460567235946655,
-0.4725114107131958,
0.8343859314918518,
0.7366577386856079,
1.337691068649292,
-0.05446377024054527,
0.6271960139274597,
0.22750313580036163,
0.45956864953041077,
-0.55492103099823,
1.0452852249145508,
-0.8781716823577881,
0.10595151036977768,
-0.20521342754364014,
-1.0293759107589722,
-0.09463473409414291,
0.3795739710330963,
-0.2706151604652405,
0.0467602014541626,
0.327243834733963,
0.6621092557907104,
-0.22547370195388794,
-0.3968709409236908,
0.6635278463363647,
0.030421020463109016,
0.3526960015296936,
0.5232718586921692,
0.7419220805168152,
0.1044342890381813,
0.4124211072921753,
-0.4934205710887909,
-0.17357449233531952,
0.1351926028728485,
-0.8762240409851074,
-1.043253779411316,
-0.629940390586853,
-0.28865909576416016,
0.14594411849975586,
0.18598538637161255,
0.6410264372825623,
0.8365391492843628,
-0.8325573205947876,
-0.37133169174194336,
0.13294179737567902,
0.26258406043052673,
-0.06420230120420456,
-0.12063422799110413,
0.16608718037605286,
-0.3942053020000458,
-0.9382253885269165,
0.45693469047546387,
0.090822234749794,
0.2416037619113922,
-0.21220673620700836,
-0.2579922378063202,
-0.3353483974933624,
-0.23392529785633087,
0.5365760326385498,
0.18308046460151672,
-0.4223121702671051,
0.061981137841939926,
-0.5871395468711853,
-0.11847808212041855,
0.04240803420543671,
0.9866124987602234,
-0.6212713718414307,
0.4502001404762268,
0.25742781162261963,
0.5004385113716125,
0.5100939273834229,
-0.1603344976902008,
0.6619512438774109,
-1.2248890399932861,
0.4393259584903717,
0.39415693283081055,
0.36251044273376465,
0.3163909316062927,
-0.30676430463790894,
0.467535138130188,
0.0878545418381691,
-0.6460074782371521,
-0.7841602563858032,
0.13883918523788452,
-0.2280975878238678,
-0.5327253937721252,
0.9910582304000854,
-0.25941917300224304,
0.2615605294704437,
0.1123744398355484,
-0.23178265988826752,
0.15842445194721222,
-0.16645847260951996,
0.7175464630126953,
0.9734161496162415,
-0.1212095096707344,
-0.3170625865459442,
-0.3653041422367096,
0.8278791308403015,
0.5980752110481262,
-0.7346580028533936,
0.16510197520256042,
0.3138267397880554,
0.16385826468467712,
-0.09795337915420532,
0.6414493322372437,
0.30151423811912537,
0.0836481973528862,
-0.1612071394920349,
0.043080609291791916,
0.06950489431619644,
-0.7993866801261902,
-0.31823089718818665,
-0.05831143260002136,
0.2759755849838257,
-0.08623450994491577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08488v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08488v1
|
Thematic Analysis with Large Language Models: does it work with languages other than English? A targeted test in Italian
| 2024-04-12T14:10:09 | 2024-04-12T14:10:09 |
Stefano De Paoli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper proposes a test to perform Thematic Analysis (TA) with Large
Language Model (LLM) on data which is in a different language than English.
While there has been initial promising work on using pre-trained LLMs for TA on
data in English, we lack any tests on whether these models can reasonably
perform the same analysis with good quality in other language. In this paper a
test will be proposed using an open access dataset of semi-structured
interviews in Italian. The test shows that a pre-trained model can perform such
a TA on the data, also using prompts in Italian. A comparative test shows the
model capacity to produce themes which have a good resemblance with those
produced independently by human researchers. The main implication of this study
is that pre-trained LLMs may thus be suitable to support analysis in
multilingual situations, so long as the language is supported by the model
used.
|
[
-0.27890893816947937,
-0.7446405291557312,
0.6379207968711853,
0.25357720255851746,
-0.4496648907661438,
0.06911183893680573,
-0.47944551706314087,
-0.7283791303634644,
0.6906160712242126,
0.322391539812088,
-0.5572046041488647,
-0.6704446077346802,
-0.46322381496429443,
0.5552207231521606,
-0.5945857167243958,
0.8437850475311279,
-0.20399361848831177,
0.7258850336074829,
-0.1993853747844696,
-0.46609994769096375,
-0.5202648043632507,
-0.4831817150115967,
-1.0402095317840576,
-0.23421043157577515,
0.6930332183837891,
0.381181001663208,
0.13643960654735565,
0.038286130875349045,
0.5369154214859009,
0.30911001563072205,
-0.09526506066322327,
0.06157112866640091,
-0.40147948265075684,
-0.03022015653550625,
-0.4945163130760193,
-0.7225380539894104,
-0.21844808757305145,
0.09354143589735031,
0.7034490704536438,
0.6905452013015747,
0.09675288945436478,
0.2721753418445587,
0.05131998658180237,
0.4067639708518982,
-0.27119970321655273,
0.25953707098960876,
-0.7026669383049011,
0.11096441000699997,
-0.21653716266155243,
-0.07596468925476074,
-0.35060393810272217,
-0.3881894052028656,
-0.1442420482635498,
-0.0885174348950386,
-0.017403259873390198,
0.25317126512527466,
0.9379077553749084,
0.007234138436615467,
-0.5517207980155945,
-0.2947222888469696,
-0.9703949689865112,
0.7155621647834778,
-0.6029110550880432,
0.17333818972110748,
0.4081639051437378,
0.2991456985473633,
-0.04345916211605072,
-0.659683883190155,
-0.41240787506103516,
-0.5819489359855652,
0.05903324857354164,
0.15718601644039154,
-0.22181400656700134,
-0.29767993092536926,
0.14216235280036926,
0.4678342044353485,
-0.5435089468955994,
0.45127245783805847,
-0.21592040359973907,
0.012309962883591652,
0.6475654244422913,
0.2875250279903412,
0.3834195137023926,
0.0782860517501831,
-0.2950470447540283,
0.24113239347934723,
-1.110122561454773,
-0.021916043013334274,
0.4486914277076721,
0.5161268711090088,
-0.19363580644130707,
0.8719476461410522,
0.04452405497431755,
0.3842216730117798,
-0.3342286944389343,
-0.12975431978702545,
0.07390177994966507,
-0.520614504814148,
0.1610165238380432,
0.0408986359834671,
0.8892389535903931,
0.2491469830274582,
0.7700477242469788,
0.04515782743692398,
-0.26272061467170715,
-0.2085014134645462,
-0.06253258883953094,
-0.5522558689117432,
0.11099119484424591,
0.027507340535521507,
-0.30481231212615967,
0.1774476170539856,
0.11868394166231155,
-0.818960428237915,
-0.14750899374485016,
-0.2598877251148224,
0.054068662226200104,
-0.3490123152732849,
-0.25100457668304443,
0.24795997142791748,
0.293178915977478,
0.21734395623207092,
0.21064326167106628,
-0.4690827429294586,
0.05436581000685692,
0.5276627540588379,
0.931006669998169,
-0.3175334930419922,
-0.39446088671684265,
-0.3068833649158478,
0.061323147267103195,
-0.3922308683395386,
0.8799034953117371,
-0.6983753442764282,
-0.4631577134132385,
0.20278632640838623,
0.24043573439121246,
-0.10577405244112015,
-0.2945501208305359,
0.29643362760543823,
-0.3685833811759949,
0.5940929651260376,
-0.2202601581811905,
-0.4707649350166321,
0.040010467171669006,
0.498868852853775,
-0.7188100218772888,
1.1847548484802246,
-0.03368156775832176,
-0.8554558753967285,
0.21904580295085907,
-0.6192781329154968,
-0.4765297770500183,
-0.11876679956912994,
-0.43066784739494324,
-0.37804678082466125,
0.21978409588336945,
0.00962106417864561,
0.2652074694633484,
-0.7092260122299194,
0.6831437945365906,
-0.38203951716423035,
-0.2989039123058319,
0.434103399515152,
-0.28475522994995117,
0.7370626330375671,
0.2731521427631378,
-0.4981025755405426,
-0.03953263536095619,
-0.8065927028656006,
-0.1287120282649994,
0.31716758012771606,
-0.08257508277893066,
-0.5281176567077637,
0.19781135022640228,
0.2162540704011917,
0.10517214983701706,
0.15550778806209564,
-0.8264325857162476,
0.27663642168045044,
-0.373683899641037,
0.2916448414325714,
0.49353381991386414,
-0.10789201408624649,
0.014630149118602276,
-0.12777569890022278,
0.9542858004570007,
0.04856856167316437,
-0.40560153126716614,
-0.13414648175239563,
-0.4338549077510834,
-0.822404682636261,
-0.5359841585159302,
0.5787712931632996,
0.6368609666824341,
-0.9487258791923523,
0.5219120383262634,
-0.3725219666957855,
-0.4132753014564514,
-0.323359876871109,
-0.2698809504508972,
0.26157382130622864,
0.14730393886566162,
-0.026290412992239,
-0.5751824378967285,
-0.6737362742424011,
-0.9629873633384705,
-0.3114733397960663,
-0.3734293580055237,
0.0033846592996269464,
0.2600133717060089,
0.906520664691925,
0.1361226588487625,
1.0180573463439941,
-0.32905203104019165,
-0.29052066802978516,
-0.5732284784317017,
0.21250736713409424,
0.3798310458660126,
0.349143922328949,
0.7999093532562256,
-0.5717164278030396,
-0.39835211634635925,
0.1470327079296112,
-0.6559369564056396,
-0.1795092076063156,
0.1429840326309204,
0.23810149729251862,
-0.01865627057850361,
0.4541926383972168,
-0.5861828923225403,
0.3854120671749115,
0.486782431602478,
-0.3685901165008545,
0.3612201511859894,
-0.25788360834121704,
0.3107978403568268,
-1.4940299987792969,
0.2127016931772232,
0.28387942910194397,
-0.08312611281871796,
-0.47691109776496887,
0.02861887216567993,
-0.2676497995853424,
-0.5535169839859009,
-0.6407447457313538,
0.9454890489578247,
-0.40487805008888245,
-0.19077220559120178,
-0.15171021223068237,
-0.22327999770641327,
-0.13096319139003754,
0.15824002027511597,
0.40387892723083496,
0.9979496598243713,
0.4568142890930176,
-0.1847703754901886,
0.11029519140720367,
0.0517166331410408,
-0.773236095905304,
0.5962080955505371,
-0.7205094695091248,
0.1077287346124649,
-0.2069086730480194,
0.05488532409071922,
-1.236393928527832,
-0.08926203846931458,
0.14379209280014038,
-0.29840973019599915,
0.11241216212511063,
0.04972920939326286,
-0.5648849010467529,
-0.2935906946659088,
-0.10537014156579971,
0.4557831883430481,
0.22559241950511932,
-0.3288925290107727,
0.4011610150337219,
0.23456843197345734,
-0.4648301899433136,
-0.2897396981716156,
-0.7799779176712036,
0.08932539820671082,
-0.8077622652053833,
-0.42118361592292786,
-0.04925926402211189,
-0.054235439747571945,
-0.5783903002738953,
-0.2552874684333801,
0.2553462088108063,
-0.6822232007980347,
0.26238471269607544,
-0.22002695500850677,
0.08973868191242218,
-0.5732998847961426,
0.10235705226659775,
-0.15068283677101135,
-0.03486258164048195,
0.08671547472476959,
-0.4695250689983368,
0.6035448908805847,
0.09130566567182541,
-0.6111142635345459,
-0.5405546426773071,
0.4642241299152374,
0.5341091752052307,
-0.6203859448432922,
0.7834246158599854,
0.5022399425506592,
-0.27058133482933044,
0.047235991805791855,
-0.4693354666233063,
-0.03723735734820366,
-0.39902645349502563,
0.48804545402526855,
-0.5180724263191223,
-0.9882590770721436,
0.7344715595245361,
-0.036398641765117645,
-0.19486701488494873,
0.4110817015171051,
0.7746924161911011,
-0.3318406939506531,
0.8415945172309875,
0.7578991651535034,
-0.4570699632167816,
0.6184929609298706,
-0.12559658288955688,
0.32021716237068176,
-0.20402169227600098,
-0.17109844088554382,
-1.2177326679229736,
-0.3919743299484253,
-0.7984684109687805,
-0.1798771619796753,
0.4252452254295349,
-0.3068160116672516,
0.005621994845569134,
0.002694136928766966,
0.07420048862695694,
0.706078290939331,
0.27619993686676025,
-0.053408268839120865,
0.45228591561317444,
0.1982877403497696,
-0.006913365330547094,
-0.29391342401504517,
-0.4804357886314392,
-0.6052099466323853,
0.8340274095535278,
0.18322236835956573,
0.6614350080490112,
-0.049451883882284164,
0.5273499488830566,
-0.0451742485165596,
0.11735516786575317,
-0.8157707452774048,
0.488742470741272,
-0.15426921844482422,
-0.7447277307510376,
-0.22838135063648224,
-0.3548881411552429,
-1.271071434020996,
0.16882987320423126,
0.03912079334259033,
-0.75433748960495,
0.19117124378681183,
-0.34676438570022583,
0.04301698878407478,
0.41020750999450684,
-0.5077353715896606,
0.5837328433990479,
-0.2935030460357666,
-0.13807541131973267,
-0.11664631217718124,
-0.2977612614631653,
0.26937785744667053,
-0.21748219430446625,
0.3741755783557892,
-0.2847364842891693,
0.012583390809595585,
0.7936518788337708,
0.0659371018409729,
0.9816919565200806,
-0.04552523046731949,
-0.24383662641048431,
0.31137797236442566,
0.02801176719367504,
0.2581169903278351,
0.21998895704746246,
-0.25488847494125366,
0.3401738703250885,
0.05912652984261513,
-0.5206076502799988,
-0.5452693104743958,
0.36518019437789917,
-0.6349853277206421,
-0.7588208913803101,
-0.5005735158920288,
-0.7262623310089111,
-0.39986974000930786,
0.21514096856117249,
0.05496707186102867,
0.3142533004283905,
-0.41737234592437744,
0.3676208257675171,
0.4965362846851349,
-0.1634298413991928,
0.3497936427593231,
0.9828463196754456,
-0.17610828578472137,
-0.10937099903821945,
0.619907557964325,
0.06099514663219452,
-0.017970120534300804,
0.3599279224872589,
0.2967228293418884,
-0.050872694700956345,
-0.9365874528884888,
-0.2903352677822113,
0.34255847334861755,
-0.2027631551027298,
0.042562298476696014,
-0.13070528209209442,
-0.00254333415068686,
-0.0981348529458046,
0.24958032369613647,
-0.4140520691871643,
-0.21733035147190094,
-0.1356506645679474,
-0.239322230219841,
0.3746808171272278,
0.8039199709892273,
0.1526942402124405,
0.07336251437664032,
-0.8001984357833862,
-0.1055918037891388,
-0.1417171210050583,
0.03711201995611191,
-0.3308892250061035,
-0.3909491300582886,
-0.4336969256401062,
0.16756340861320496,
-0.0625089704990387,
-0.9446727633476257,
0.38436925411224365,
0.20409564673900604,
0.44631993770599365,
0.3711724281311035,
-0.16493232548236847,
0.6837972402572632,
-0.766319990158081,
0.917781412601471,
0.1735418736934662,
-0.7707985639572144,
0.5997958779335022,
-0.6849786043167114,
0.1752752959728241,
1.019782304763794,
0.9228104948997498,
-0.3744002878665924,
-0.8056568503379822,
-0.4242296516895294,
-0.4838876724243164,
0.7524083852767944,
0.22108973562717438,
0.38725849986076355,
-0.18182677030563354,
0.5270770788192749,
0.2283324897289276,
0.30447912216186523,
-0.9368226528167725,
-0.10444334149360657,
0.4533906579017639,
-0.48252609372138977,
-0.5609912872314453,
-0.2548336088657379,
-0.22905954718589783,
-0.3520897924900055,
0.21856527030467987,
-0.052877798676490784,
0.32202816009521484,
0.05136265978217125,
0.11249116063117981,
0.061197344213724136,
0.33549338579177856,
0.3033016324043274,
0.9436869025230408,
0.10421207547187805,
-0.004078460391610861,
0.2955355644226074,
-0.31095534563064575,
0.45157936215400696,
-0.13113008439540863,
-0.1406877338886261,
0.12431617081165314,
0.7946375608444214,
0.7395884394645691,
0.26553425192832947,
-0.7450248003005981,
0.37679240107536316,
-0.17069752514362335,
-0.06369980424642563,
-0.41428327560424805,
-0.17185331881046295,
0.08558524399995804,
0.3201887905597687,
0.14919687807559967,
-0.5054115056991577,
-0.11818859726190567,
-0.9986093044281006,
0.10844593495130539,
0.5074692368507385,
-0.32136133313179016,
-0.5174177885055542,
0.35745394229888916,
0.28225085139274597,
-0.5180730819702148,
0.6214771270751953,
-0.07376350462436676,
-0.35878950357437134,
0.8884942531585693,
0.6957317590713501,
0.8014392256736755,
-0.4556621313095093,
0.20458850264549255,
0.15850397944450378,
0.47978466749191284,
0.10210531204938889,
0.5901669859886169,
0.1909063756465912,
-0.848402738571167,
-0.534131646156311,
-0.4571502208709717,
-0.46470367908477783,
0.10034318268299103,
-0.982995331287384,
0.45507892966270447,
-0.11036187410354614,
0.16543681919574738,
-0.32939836382865906,
0.15123969316482544,
-0.48830273747444153,
0.371056467294693,
-0.0907202810049057,
1.0368244647979736,
-1.2538607120513916,
1.2358348369598389,
1.0297863483428955,
-0.3803715109825134,
-0.7054372429847717,
0.050254762172698975,
-0.16453754901885986,
-1.0000861883163452,
0.794398844242096,
0.1029948890209198,
-0.0447269007563591,
-0.005893066991120577,
-0.37400221824645996,
-0.8175122737884521,
0.9908459186553955,
0.7016644477844238,
-0.4949498474597931,
-0.10721743851900101,
0.4787461757659912,
0.9058886766433716,
-0.6996312737464905,
0.6702408790588379,
0.5747291445732117,
0.542414128780365,
0.1754673272371292,
-0.9946807622909546,
-0.4526214599609375,
-0.20192979276180267,
-0.034675974398851395,
0.2836674749851227,
-0.7356439232826233,
0.7754014134407043,
0.2915678024291992,
-0.17272037267684937,
0.4148158133029938,
0.8274484872817993,
0.18706880509853363,
0.5447788238525391,
0.5073921084403992,
0.4708654582500458,
0.724510669708252,
-0.2796197831630707,
1.2240463495254517,
-0.43336695432662964,
0.5660663843154907,
0.9789686799049377,
-0.7018837332725525,
0.8680312633514404,
0.5602982044219971,
-0.3450094163417816,
0.6202369332313538,
0.9608228206634521,
0.19838742911815643,
0.45406001806259155,
0.19323581457138062,
-0.12661053240299225,
-0.07479922473430634,
-0.5221983194351196,
-0.47602856159210205,
0.8358380794525146,
0.05184115841984749,
-0.17124789953231812,
-0.3486407995223999,
0.3016318082809448,
0.19401423633098602,
0.17962130904197693,
-0.370329886674881,
0.671463131904602,
0.09904659539461136,
-0.5774281620979309,
0.19016188383102417,
0.17949806153774261,
0.30627939105033875,
-0.9052230715751648,
0.24137428402900696,
-0.7331758737564087,
-0.1006394475698471,
0.04313463345170021,
-0.648583173751831,
0.5922092199325562,
0.43009647727012634,
0.047512564808130264,
-0.12860967218875885,
0.4256054759025574,
-0.6334431171417236,
-0.9550807476043701,
0.4167550802230835,
0.9002683162689209,
0.4338231384754181,
0.14935944974422455,
-0.6571446657180786,
0.014909244142472744,
0.05486231669783592,
-0.21747034788131714,
0.4662248492240906,
0.578768253326416,
-0.22790215909481049,
0.5197778344154358,
0.3681468665599823,
0.35381463170051575,
-0.23332366347312927,
0.14715354144573212,
0.7397252321243286,
-0.8147147297859192,
-0.5129072666168213,
-0.9507762789726257,
0.4906882643699646,
0.06643553823232651,
-0.3358783721923828,
0.8909572958946228,
0.6093217730522156,
0.8581926226615906,
0.05267137661576271,
0.3535727858543396,
0.02217048779129982,
0.3878785967826843,
-1.0123158693313599,
0.3887695372104645,
-0.8474633693695068,
0.1089417040348053,
-0.1657496988773346,
-1.2449748516082764,
-0.14464634656906128,
0.4741416275501251,
-0.44573915004730225,
0.16967891156673431,
1.259623408317566,
0.7319108843803406,
-0.0838150829076767,
0.15907412767410278,
0.3688284456729889,
0.27043241262435913,
0.10703115910291672,
0.5851557850837708,
1.2839858531951904,
0.10567860305309296,
-0.023921290412545204,
0.04098912701010704,
-0.05823401361703873,
0.41025352478027344,
-0.8012614250183105,
-1.31873619556427,
-0.4932527244091034,
-0.09195148199796677,
-0.13710278272628784,
0.06736890971660614,
0.7838852405548096,
0.3290465474128723,
-0.9960144758224487,
-0.637039303779602,
0.350022554397583,
0.03451806679368019,
0.22003214061260223,
-0.1515476256608963,
0.28455784916877747,
-0.09103143960237503,
-1.1912181377410889,
0.5940136909484863,
0.16441597044467926,
-0.19431449472904205,
-0.4501248300075531,
0.28757914900779724,
-0.41561803221702576,
0.0259096659719944,
0.3612057566642761,
0.0434025377035141,
-0.5332276225090027,
-0.4955218732357025,
-0.06962762027978897,
0.12564904987812042,
0.22259095311164856,
1.3292118310928345,
-0.39249494671821594,
0.29864320158958435,
0.3695543110370636,
0.7317074537277222,
0.4853722155094147,
-0.1587192565202713,
0.6834955215454102,
-0.7894314527511597,
0.648607075214386,
0.2777712047100067,
0.745542585849762,
0.08771306276321411,
-0.29010114073753357,
0.6474403738975525,
0.17120173573493958,
-0.15323439240455627,
-0.7753210067749023,
0.3176775276660919,
-0.6310291290283203,
-0.2106664925813675,
1.2550311088562012,
-0.6650351285934448,
-0.11043820530176163,
-0.06018733233213425,
-0.16104209423065186,
0.032488591969013214,
-0.005778925493359566,
0.7798331379890442,
1.1524927616119385,
0.05982891097664833,
0.04398958012461662,
-0.32878950238227844,
-0.18493781983852386,
0.6119236350059509,
-1.1877150535583496,
-0.5059788227081299,
0.22006793320178986,
0.2768954634666443,
-0.01997998356819153,
0.6554744839668274,
-0.1420285850763321,
0.09462174028158188,
-0.5086988806724548,
0.019308332353830338,
0.06905971467494965,
-0.48421090841293335,
-0.7078201770782471,
0.10209404677152634,
0.3286987543106079,
0.065223328769207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08480v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08480v1
|
Decoding AI: The inside story of data analysis in ChatGPT
| 2024-04-12T13:57:30 | 2024-04-12T13:57:30 |
Ozan Evkaya, Miguel de Carvalho
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.CO
|
As a result of recent advancements in generative AI, the field of Data
Science is prone to various changes. This review critically examines the Data
Analysis (DA) capabilities of ChatGPT assessing its performance across a wide
range of tasks. While DA provides researchers and practitioners with
unprecedented analytical capabilities, it is far from being perfect, and it is
important to recognize and address its limitations.
|
[
-0.30299803614616394,
-1.0880640745162964,
0.36106622219085693,
0.14754100143909454,
0.014997106976807117,
0.5313409566879272,
0.1530844271183014,
-0.6078083515167236,
-0.23693926632404327,
0.17249421775341034,
-0.46979355812072754,
-0.21893860399723053,
-0.8665318489074707,
0.09343033283948898,
-0.7568045258522034,
1.2625751495361328,
0.0499715618789196,
0.11846960335969925,
-0.384807288646698,
0.02504095621407032,
-0.7686101198196411,
-0.8386670351028442,
-1.1834614276885986,
0.02553468383848667,
-0.11446266621351242,
0.6726774573326111,
0.8773245215415955,
0.4040736258029938,
1.0270076990127563,
0.23411303758621216,
0.07523486763238907,
0.11070185154676437,
-0.6573284864425659,
0.3443264365196228,
0.4356776773929596,
-0.7093259692192078,
-0.5048994421958923,
-0.06571865826845169,
0.8034791946411133,
0.8661798238754272,
-0.06854952871799469,
-0.07982288300991058,
0.10985718667507172,
1.0387145280838013,
-0.2685486972332001,
0.9551701545715332,
-0.47976014018058777,
0.16491225361824036,
-0.5253651142120361,
-0.2092822641134262,
-0.2629335820674896,
-0.4226871728897095,
0.44957271218299866,
-0.4728144109249115,
0.5472227334976196,
-0.01789182797074318,
0.5239824056625366,
0.6361439228057861,
-0.46075746417045593,
-0.6271971464157104,
-1.0609002113342285,
0.5685123801231384,
-0.4450005888938904,
0.2709750831127167,
0.4560399651527405,
0.6100192666053772,
-0.2324511706829071,
-0.8609689474105835,
-0.6305633187294006,
-0.20706422626972198,
0.15269508957862854,
0.22489699721336365,
-0.5552056431770325,
0.18292801082134247,
0.2399785816669464,
0.9382061958312988,
-0.5846253037452698,
-0.10333838313817978,
-0.5936124324798584,
0.10109004378318787,
0.8924886584281921,
0.6499572396278381,
0.578394889831543,
0.07713286578655243,
-0.038413263857364655,
-0.20573364198207855,
-0.4594082534313202,
-0.13889765739440918,
0.2147475928068161,
0.003720509586855769,
-0.1911577731370926,
0.5758213996887207,
-0.20800945162773132,
0.5466275811195374,
-0.36567315459251404,
0.4059031903743744,
0.07620252668857574,
-0.36212581396102905,
-0.32043129205703735,
0.0160687156021595,
0.6552395224571228,
0.408399373292923,
0.12176507711410522,
-0.39963018894195557,
0.12641164660453796,
0.11614847183227539,
0.37138286232948303,
-0.6694689989089966,
-0.7687599658966064,
0.29247063398361206,
-0.5463629961013794,
-0.2016146183013916,
0.06747878342866898,
-1.111067771911621,
-0.7039912343025208,
-0.1806604266166687,
-0.007314058020710945,
-0.6155756115913391,
-0.347901850938797,
0.13223926723003387,
-0.36612802743911743,
0.637150228023529,
0.22237038612365723,
-0.8062008023262024,
0.4281221032142639,
0.7665396928787231,
1.013511300086975,
-0.2686848044395447,
-0.18393725156784058,
-0.20667392015457153,
-0.35327309370040894,
-0.5152862071990967,
1.0154141187667847,
-0.5900267958641052,
-0.64200359582901,
-0.24448005855083466,
-0.3031538128852844,
-0.46843644976615906,
-0.35678616166114807,
0.6413382887840271,
-0.7216372489929199,
-0.010331640020012856,
-0.2559996247291565,
-0.8277794122695923,
-0.38938412070274353,
0.20081976056098938,
-0.8568702936172485,
0.8081372976303101,
0.18032889068126678,
-0.8641632795333862,
0.6986262798309326,
-1.1707719564437866,
-0.1541929692029953,
0.09125422686338425,
-0.2526499629020691,
-0.5889683365821838,
0.10213112086057663,
0.26708605885505676,
0.29277488589286804,
-0.2594700753688812,
-0.11553177982568741,
-0.04525879770517349,
-0.5128343105316162,
0.6210244297981262,
-0.8660668134689331,
0.9281182885169983,
0.5441011786460876,
-0.1797495037317276,
0.05514979735016823,
-0.8404994606971741,
-0.03605927154421806,
0.17817750573158264,
-0.18811780214309692,
0.20728811621665955,
0.42095881700515747,
-0.16129520535469055,
-0.36515188217163086,
-0.3682551980018616,
-0.35427820682525635,
0.3748455345630646,
-0.41123998165130615,
0.6347045302391052,
0.39712783694267273,
0.09728364646434784,
0.34243154525756836,
-0.23978391289710999,
0.9510499835014343,
-0.22952353954315186,
-0.10293781757354736,
-0.2485571950674057,
-0.7911394238471985,
-0.6695000529289246,
-0.1232057437300682,
0.527990996837616,
0.6942840218544006,
-0.9078752398490906,
0.10694032907485962,
-0.2857937216758728,
-0.359395295381546,
-0.9091017842292786,
-0.29046890139579773,
-0.01853174716234207,
0.127866730093956,
0.22437836229801178,
-0.27796995639801025,
-0.5107769966125488,
-0.6025130748748779,
-0.008542093448340893,
-0.19324150681495667,
0.008993498049676418,
0.0773392915725708,
0.32005205750465393,
-0.2535172998905182,
0.9347431063652039,
-0.5903074145317078,
-0.27143773436546326,
-0.46147242188453674,
0.201034277677536,
0.0969301089644432,
0.23447789251804352,
0.4985102415084839,
-0.8827037215232849,
-0.6531901359558105,
0.19992458820343018,
-0.8776198029518127,
0.10712108016014099,
-0.21453191339969635,
0.17746217548847198,
-0.09293258190155029,
0.6466867327690125,
-0.657074511051178,
0.8759734630584717,
0.4266927242279053,
-0.4244047999382019,
0.5369382500648499,
-0.2678987979888916,
0.39708128571510315,
-0.6894277334213257,
0.07990594208240509,
-0.3732984960079193,
0.17719297111034393,
-0.8454071879386902,
-0.14428108930587769,
-0.16678400337696075,
-0.48686715960502625,
0.2886503040790558,
0.10381689667701721,
-0.4015268385410309,
-0.20522835850715637,
-0.6875248551368713,
-0.3523191213607788,
-0.2939484119415283,
0.04640764743089676,
-0.2239973247051239,
0.9265992045402527,
0.9076453447341919,
-0.5073605179786682,
0.7780263423919678,
0.5278979539871216,
-0.5892947316169739,
0.44478991627693176,
-0.5781463384628296,
0.45753538608551025,
-0.38618841767311096,
0.30568966269493103,
-1.376686692237854,
-0.5018304586410522,
0.5116128921508789,
-0.7207170724868774,
0.13176104426383972,
-0.37237387895584106,
-0.6145522594451904,
-0.20094949007034302,
-0.013017113320529461,
0.6403974890708923,
0.5829346776008606,
-0.512474775314331,
0.22574156522750854,
0.4521312713623047,
-0.21685189008712769,
-0.32876014709472656,
-0.5616976022720337,
0.4019198715686798,
-0.571154773235321,
-0.7275421619415283,
0.17413902282714844,
-0.17948627471923828,
-0.6447399854660034,
0.051506251096725464,
0.11034239828586578,
-0.41867727041244507,
0.19394707679748535,
0.12832550704479218,
0.10459905862808228,
-0.006567762233316898,
0.10057682543992996,
-0.1887628734111786,
-0.4830646216869354,
0.35066112875938416,
0.15581631660461426,
0.5112329721450806,
-0.08086229860782623,
-0.34716272354125977,
-0.6895288228988647,
0.3212779760360718,
0.5872902274131775,
-0.24523836374282837,
0.6050996780395508,
0.5542853474617004,
-0.04141538217663765,
-0.16837547719478607,
0.021228663623332977,
0.16204015910625458,
-0.42997515201568604,
0.37096932530403137,
-0.436888188123703,
-0.22475355863571167,
0.6041072010993958,
0.2819342613220215,
-0.03866330161690712,
0.5057497024536133,
0.34059324860572815,
-0.20578469336032867,
1.0973145961761475,
0.6629244089126587,
-0.27360185980796814,
0.5522614121437073,
-0.4084663689136505,
0.48842036724090576,
-0.45913165807724,
-0.1768411546945572,
-0.6046165227890015,
-0.1069396510720253,
-0.714829683303833,
-0.0065548294223845005,
0.5683056116104126,
-0.1448102742433548,
0.07733345776796341,
-0.2516983449459076,
-0.6391890645027161,
0.5054035186767578,
0.5606386065483093,
-0.06526557356119156,
0.4199049472808838,
-0.024828137829899788,
1.0472215414047241,
-0.03454001992940903,
-0.7334964871406555,
-0.26124170422554016,
1.3457767963409424,
0.5070469975471497,
0.7493099570274353,
0.06306979805231094,
0.21758128702640533,
0.6619674563407898,
-0.028657592833042145,
-1.0353076457977295,
0.2895444631576538,
-0.07831204682588577,
-0.38646045327186584,
-0.20321772992610931,
-0.5172674059867859,
-1.2398796081542969,
0.12522505223751068,
0.04657166451215744,
-0.5069793462753296,
0.15494835376739502,
-0.08137524127960205,
-0.23730534315109253,
0.35519805550575256,
-1.0530656576156616,
0.6569225788116455,
0.14970819652080536,
0.43618956208229065,
-0.1771915853023529,
-0.4648055136203766,
0.18701200187206268,
0.08922287076711655,
-0.021925069391727448,
-0.007258231285959482,
0.33977410197257996,
0.9107425808906555,
-0.2823653519153595,
0.7325958609580994,
-0.21883514523506165,
-0.02745918184518814,
0.551250696182251,
0.1427575647830963,
0.25172916054725647,
0.03247136250138283,
-0.1957055926322937,
0.22576595842838287,
0.40809202194213867,
-0.6405053734779358,
-0.746670663356781,
0.21659575402736664,
-0.5202432870864868,
-0.5057156682014465,
-0.6084609627723694,
-0.7498226761817932,
-0.35580363869667053,
-0.2133704274892807,
0.2989966571331024,
0.2985759973526001,
-0.35775232315063477,
0.2186318039894104,
0.540547788143158,
-0.11288507282733917,
0.42553550004959106,
-0.07857558876276016,
0.2127123922109604,
0.01839868724346161,
1.0508025884628296,
0.13110953569412231,
-0.010382812470197678,
0.05749015510082245,
-0.08031047880649567,
-0.11905964463949203,
-1.001835584640503,
-0.6203159689903259,
-0.39795979857444763,
-0.6091786623001099,
-0.016966525465250015,
-0.4192119240760803,
-0.42615455389022827,
-0.20236007869243622,
0.1831960678100586,
-0.3231584131717682,
-0.3112249970436096,
-0.11170272529125214,
-0.16849811375141144,
0.5515850782394409,
1.0958476066589355,
-0.07517116516828537,
0.468279093503952,
-0.6458069682121277,
0.3086503744125366,
0.12907688319683075,
0.35608619451522827,
0.013619874604046345,
-0.053714897483587265,
-0.2135947346687317,
0.1733071357011795,
-0.33703917264938354,
-0.9011742472648621,
0.3217932879924774,
0.03470196947455406,
0.5418490767478943,
0.3339694142341614,
-0.12759260833263397,
0.5582913756370544,
-0.043445900082588196,
0.8777035474777222,
-0.3622229993343353,
-0.7840739488601685,
0.4514891505241394,
-0.22438661754131317,
0.03447991609573364,
0.300645112991333,
0.2202402949333191,
-0.5985643863677979,
-0.024053385481238365,
-0.6561686992645264,
-0.6059426069259644,
0.8951355218887329,
0.6459817290306091,
0.2538066506385803,
0.2276722937822342,
0.41004830598831177,
0.44035106897354126,
-0.025375893339514732,
-0.3259419798851013,
-0.29459282755851746,
-0.24852941930294037,
-0.2102888524532318,
-0.06039706617593765,
-0.22364535927772522,
0.05529102310538292,
-0.36207929253578186,
0.17679427564144135,
-0.024645673111081123,
0.7815240025520325,
-0.003310122760012746,
0.017108943313360214,
0.3670981526374817,
0.15343870222568512,
-0.0914907231926918,
0.778297483921051,
-0.055807437747716904,
-0.18887604773044586,
0.06343637406826019,
-0.7221132516860962,
-0.27618879079818726,
0.32253992557525635,
0.08780156821012497,
-0.18171513080596924,
0.7472689747810364,
0.7187964916229248,
-0.38272544741630554,
-0.7059399485588074,
0.3370639681816101,
-0.26417964696884155,
-0.09618363529443741,
-0.26995813846588135,
0.40700584650039673,
-0.5532689094543457,
0.27055349946022034,
0.4571983516216278,
-0.11733388155698776,
0.5197686553001404,
-0.7396402359008789,
0.09801604598760605,
0.3355664610862732,
-0.3159538209438324,
-0.4040978252887726,
0.5150519609451294,
0.02699093706905842,
-0.07212840765714645,
1.4357504844665527,
-0.20249329507350922,
-0.4464302062988281,
1.1077029705047607,
0.39298632740974426,
0.9898408055305481,
-0.2034231573343277,
0.17759951949119568,
-0.02133992128074169,
0.18489693105220795,
0.339670330286026,
0.3794252574443817,
-0.2838844358921051,
-0.8211164474487305,
-0.27425891160964966,
-0.11277016252279282,
-0.6465176343917847,
0.015939345583319664,
-0.6750319600105286,
-0.2141050398349762,
-0.08337248861789703,
0.07934887707233429,
0.23086212575435638,
0.22654767334461212,
-0.7021462321281433,
0.3566458821296692,
-0.17254118621349335,
0.5607801675796509,
-0.4269718527793884,
0.6722020506858826,
0.3203054368495941,
-0.4216479957103729,
-0.04029344394803047,
0.2292746752500534,
0.13780660927295685,
-0.801220178604126,
0.5343942642211914,
-0.08662499487400055,
0.11376412212848663,
0.024797476828098297,
-0.6825379729270935,
-0.7490387558937073,
1.0421422719955444,
0.20257748663425446,
0.09326458722352982,
-0.045515213161706924,
0.3568000793457031,
0.7081946730613708,
-0.06974859535694122,
0.34723418951034546,
1.1893757581710815,
0.4501759111881256,
-0.1392127424478531,
-0.974216639995575,
-0.5060351490974426,
-0.3120991289615631,
-0.323555052280426,
0.05717375874519348,
-0.4621686637401581,
0.9143337607383728,
-0.08190740644931793,
-0.8051760196685791,
0.0315784327685833,
0.5561602711677551,
-0.30933594703674316,
0.5895702838897705,
0.20844604074954987,
0.27446144819259644,
0.9540309309959412,
-0.2748103737831116,
1.3343570232391357,
0.0548362173140049,
0.2871738374233246,
0.7602076530456543,
0.08241836726665497,
0.33184197545051575,
-0.030063452199101448,
-0.6284704208374023,
0.20208898186683655,
0.7496994733810425,
-0.30974167585372925,
0.4840591251850128,
0.05478879064321518,
-0.22254006564617157,
0.2657584846019745,
0.2390536665916443,
-0.4335578680038452,
0.8289375305175781,
0.7599220871925354,
-0.09105127304792404,
-0.22241158783435822,
0.1600732058286667,
-0.21323338150978088,
-0.3261736333370209,
-0.19679653644561768,
1.0731878280639648,
-0.10663536936044693,
-0.16172374784946442,
0.19633370637893677,
-0.23787878453731537,
0.20369720458984375,
-0.3546219766139984,
-0.4137989282608032,
-0.30425456166267395,
0.0596030056476593,
-0.26933497190475464,
-1.180036187171936,
0.90616375207901,
0.06218018755316734,
0.04277096316218376,
-0.006019381806254387,
0.6038612127304077,
-0.011453988961875439,
-0.11699096113443375,
0.03523222357034683,
0.5876734256744385,
0.43538203835487366,
-0.3401399850845337,
-0.5601531267166138,
0.39521563053131104,
0.13477309048175812,
-0.06419457495212555,
-0.06532008945941925,
0.483838826417923,
-0.019725341349840164,
0.9795582294464111,
0.5067993998527527,
-0.18635283410549164,
0.13772974908351898,
-0.16358500719070435,
0.6933166980743408,
-0.9905104041099548,
-0.5210793018341064,
-0.9323040843009949,
0.3296350836753845,
-0.0989101305603981,
-0.3353116810321808,
0.9334243535995483,
0.6594172716140747,
0.733869194984436,
0.09533898532390594,
1.0927270650863647,
-0.4569721519947052,
0.2731378972530365,
-0.6579402089118958,
0.7774444222450256,
-0.02485591359436512,
0.26395082473754883,
-0.08740540593862534,
-0.8759523034095764,
-0.30255433917045593,
0.28036925196647644,
-0.4884791374206543,
0.046782877296209335,
0.4901217222213745,
0.3967074155807495,
-0.07671968638896942,
0.619236171245575,
0.26009079813957214,
0.2086065411567688,
0.6991980671882629,
0.41472914814949036,
1.229647159576416,
-0.49038225412368774,
0.6768402457237244,
-0.09454678744077682,
-0.35582175850868225,
0.024055415764451027,
-0.27435827255249023,
-0.856427788734436,
-0.8959318399429321,
-0.2772800028324127,
-0.19835016131401062,
0.016368046402931213,
0.14693862199783325,
0.7175835967063904,
-0.7523148059844971,
-0.12357965111732483,
-0.4130443334579468,
0.12230513989925385,
-0.4254359304904938,
-0.31669995188713074,
0.934302806854248,
-0.6435375809669495,
-1.112849235534668,
0.6274881958961487,
-0.0664762556552887,
0.045122165232896805,
-0.053580380976200104,
0.17631302773952484,
0.44573062658309937,
-0.10414101183414459,
0.6542686820030212,
0.41398271918296814,
-0.0791991651058197,
-0.08212115615606308,
-0.33032241463661194,
0.2055414468050003,
0.34751421213150024,
0.9761962890625,
-0.6611411571502686,
0.7889983057975769,
0.636484682559967,
1.0752369165420532,
0.6762754321098328,
0.07355844229459763,
0.7768746018409729,
-0.42974036931991577,
-0.13359609246253967,
0.26061737537384033,
0.10733292996883392,
0.2787657380104065,
-0.5995774269104004,
0.7199139595031738,
0.04104107618331909,
-0.8756099343299866,
-0.7758244276046753,
-0.0016503334045410156,
-0.9796732068061829,
-0.2843513488769531,
0.8277542591094971,
0.0423990823328495,
0.12712152302265167,
-0.5807291269302368,
-0.6390301585197449,
0.07365963608026505,
-0.15480037033557892,
1.1360350847244263,
0.9872643351554871,
-0.9023274183273315,
-0.13885338604450226,
-1.0188853740692139,
0.9736525416374207,
0.24691928923130035,
-1.0772629976272583,
0.284543514251709,
0.36854004859924316,
0.07283090800046921,
-0.25941139459609985,
0.7687317728996277,
-0.1935359686613083,
0.2548798620700836,
0.6212205290794373,
-0.4711637794971466,
0.10302967578172684,
-0.2750684320926666,
-0.407558798789978,
0.19595853984355927,
0.11158663034439087,
-0.6409838795661926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08417v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08417v1
|
AdapterSwap: Continuous Training of LLMs with Data Removal and Access-Control Guarantees
| 2024-04-12T12:06:02 | 2024-04-12T12:06:02 |
William Fleshman, Aleem Khan, Marc Marone, Benjamin Van Durme
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly capable of completing knowledge
intensive tasks by recalling information from a static pretraining corpus. Here
we are concerned with LLMs in the context of evolving data requirements. For
instance: batches of new data that are introduced periodically; subsets of data
with user-based access controls; or requirements on dynamic removal of
documents with guarantees that associated knowledge cannot be recalled. We wish
to satisfy these requirements while at the same time ensuring a model does not
forget old information when new data becomes available. To address these
issues, we introduce AdapterSwap, a training and inference scheme that
organizes knowledge from a data collection into a set of low-rank adapters,
which are dynamically composed during inference. Our experiments demonstrate
AdapterSwap's ability to support efficient continual learning, while also
enabling organizations to have fine-grained control over data access and
deletion.
|
[
-0.38660237193107605,
-0.5635029077529907,
0.456883043050766,
0.07623395323753357,
0.022175587713718414,
0.017369646579027176,
-0.2359474152326584,
-0.5354737043380737,
-0.1585666388273239,
0.6700780987739563,
-0.7533602714538574,
-0.3178296685218811,
-0.7542821764945984,
-0.06846503168344498,
-0.7379077076911926,
0.8833171129226685,
-0.3753567934036255,
-0.3698136508464813,
-0.5274158716201782,
-0.22827447950839996,
-0.5561167597770691,
-0.2956145703792572,
-0.7814450860023499,
-0.4654083251953125,
0.6285344958305359,
0.65532386302948,
0.5422109961509705,
0.7689881920814514,
0.4044218957424164,
0.25058475136756897,
-0.14406931400299072,
0.15716026723384857,
-0.5817696452140808,
0.3696899712085724,
-0.24585290253162384,
-0.7744860053062439,
-0.2767617404460907,
-0.11713980883359909,
0.7858006358146667,
0.9252768754959106,
-0.5556742548942566,
0.1124752014875412,
0.21759569644927979,
0.802122950553894,
-0.7062332034111023,
0.08811041712760925,
-0.9445762634277344,
0.09171626716852188,
0.12839005887508392,
-0.156527578830719,
-0.43095436692237854,
-0.4359855651855469,
0.19707638025283813,
-0.574337363243103,
0.0868493989109993,
-0.0667428970336914,
0.8378680348396301,
0.2430947870016098,
-0.22044511139392853,
-0.5732192397117615,
-0.9194599390029907,
0.7328600883483887,
-0.32354936003685,
0.4046488106250763,
0.4357190728187561,
0.308524489402771,
-0.4843633770942688,
-1.0068793296813965,
-0.6376445889472961,
0.05943269282579422,
0.0994870737195015,
0.19115883111953735,
-0.07514307647943497,
-0.04943891242146492,
0.3008631765842438,
0.31333765387535095,
-0.15963397920131683,
0.3293445110321045,
-0.4600030779838562,
0.16537916660308838,
0.30589357018470764,
0.16658146679401398,
0.2850194573402405,
0.2181910127401352,
-0.2507690191268921,
0.14813876152038574,
-1.0205261707305908,
-0.24177592992782593,
-0.01466661412268877,
-0.054723020642995834,
-0.18869717419147491,
0.5536710619926453,
-0.41513586044311523,
0.6964516639709473,
-0.18341439962387085,
-0.06824728846549988,
0.06162118911743164,
0.22409500181674957,
-0.30472332239151,
-0.09189125895500183,
0.2321394383907318,
0.0330473817884922,
0.43023625016212463,
-0.49888449907302856,
-0.4008733332157135,
-0.0814608559012413,
0.28321373462677,
-0.47427573800086975,
-0.2200060337781906,
0.21589024364948273,
-0.5248633027076721,
-0.2749481797218323,
-0.21537117660045624,
-0.6437730193138123,
-0.4881969392299652,
-0.5823124647140503,
0.3967163562774658,
-0.4148775637149811,
-0.1468045711517334,
0.03340627998113632,
-0.17723840475082397,
0.37831684947013855,
0.5265676975250244,
-1.120627999305725,
0.49043241143226624,
0.5037376880645752,
0.7365196347236633,
-0.5625936985015869,
-0.3125585615634918,
-0.48552659153938293,
0.6382323503494263,
-0.17764882743358612,
0.6735689640045166,
-0.7373554706573486,
-0.4325345754623413,
0.136784628033638,
0.19004632532596588,
-0.3051574230194092,
-0.7703114748001099,
0.23880691826343536,
-0.8860557675361633,
0.11951321363449097,
-0.08643470704555511,
-0.878317654132843,
0.013049991801381111,
0.1916477382183075,
-0.3538791835308075,
0.7205269932746887,
0.27026233077049255,
-0.4802147448062897,
0.475009024143219,
-0.636746346950531,
-0.24843616783618927,
0.05934847146272659,
-0.14971822500228882,
-0.4196447432041168,
0.21819886565208435,
-0.006869478616863489,
0.31895989179611206,
-0.1855170875787735,
0.0968497097492218,
-0.5382346510887146,
-0.0874720960855484,
0.12920793890953064,
-0.3987008333206177,
0.3542841970920563,
0.3592396676540375,
-0.10629383474588394,
0.007274144794791937,
-0.9794763922691345,
-0.16722525656223297,
0.24425871670246124,
-0.7620298862457275,
-0.36734771728515625,
0.41190749406814575,
-0.2751392722129822,
0.14913056790828705,
0.1869797557592392,
-0.26186805963516235,
0.34419819712638855,
-0.12378838658332825,
0.4757898449897766,
1.0193315744400024,
0.10842065513134003,
0.5315485000610352,
-0.5329493284225464,
0.4447191655635834,
-0.03767132759094238,
0.35312193632125854,
-0.1986335813999176,
-0.2187364399433136,
-1.0475915670394897,
-0.2891812324523926,
-0.0977080687880516,
0.5261695384979248,
-0.752655029296875,
0.43485698103904724,
-0.3582460880279541,
-0.32710593938827515,
-0.0862804502248764,
0.32196372747421265,
0.05287881940603256,
0.4963580071926117,
0.4842284023761749,
-0.011674792505800724,
-0.5234447717666626,
-0.6369799971580505,
-0.15514972805976868,
0.08483327925205231,
-0.4263322055339813,
0.16216658055782318,
0.23622587323188782,
-0.4644845426082611,
0.9578779339790344,
-0.4939378798007965,
-0.10484648495912552,
-0.2759672701358795,
-0.13558326661586761,
0.11590727418661118,
0.5846057534217834,
0.3400286138057709,
-0.8131608963012695,
-0.1880473494529724,
-0.18697349727153778,
-0.8899638056755066,
-0.19935336709022522,
-0.19659563899040222,
-0.11422275751829147,
0.04804671183228493,
0.8216190934181213,
-0.42562878131866455,
0.296501487493515,
0.6259693503379822,
-0.048936694860458374,
0.4014565348625183,
-0.2851276695728302,
-0.21813049912452698,
-0.986841082572937,
0.09408903867006302,
-0.3078378438949585,
-0.5314522981643677,
-0.4587212800979614,
-0.0013274732045829296,
0.05917671322822571,
-0.05821017548441887,
-0.25969159603118896,
0.6396519541740417,
-0.4266437590122223,
-0.0681239664554596,
-0.4467577040195465,
0.1915668547153473,
-0.16519737243652344,
0.24425600469112396,
0.34599006175994873,
0.5461640954017639,
0.44959932565689087,
-1.1292036771774292,
0.2865840196609497,
0.3774060904979706,
-0.4249838888645172,
0.42063942551612854,
-0.41968491673469543,
0.04077446088194847,
-0.23263515532016754,
0.18006454408168793,
-0.8264608383178711,
-0.23492534458637238,
0.057920437306165695,
-0.03887881338596344,
0.2761685252189636,
-0.26884111762046814,
-0.36048856377601624,
-0.3570854067802429,
0.07020286470651627,
-0.07156738638877869,
0.6398928761482239,
-0.8672323822975159,
0.5961663126945496,
0.4721081554889679,
-0.40563467144966125,
-0.4291010797023773,
-0.5776469111442566,
-0.0939212441444397,
-0.35790517926216125,
-0.033059775829315186,
0.07946250587701797,
-0.12191947549581528,
-0.08072870224714279,
-0.05665026605129242,
-0.30947577953338623,
-0.2404007762670517,
0.32891571521759033,
0.46622830629348755,
0.2788863182067871,
0.11848978698253632,
0.2991824448108673,
0.2574995160102844,
-0.05143807828426361,
0.1231481209397316,
-0.31913596391677856,
0.7177065014839172,
0.27608567476272583,
-0.5677415728569031,
-0.3088166415691376,
-0.07934249937534332,
0.6179016828536987,
0.19919224083423615,
0.9235069155693054,
0.32090431451797485,
-0.35835182666778564,
-0.20886008441448212,
-0.6867983937263489,
-0.10969545692205429,
-0.5704452395439148,
0.28743529319763184,
-0.3430550992488861,
-0.7621507048606873,
0.47558873891830444,
-0.43675631284713745,
0.60061115026474,
0.3716038465499878,
0.4331916868686676,
-0.3442719280719757,
0.6734417080879211,
0.6659159660339355,
-0.23447012901306152,
0.9341958165168762,
0.0260478425770998,
-0.31213104724884033,
-0.8344277143478394,
-0.3254626393318176,
-0.4343336820602417,
-0.38371309638023376,
-0.3315522074699402,
-0.14116384088993073,
0.09127423167228699,
0.318444162607193,
-0.22733034193515778,
0.16567286849021912,
-0.2589488625526428,
0.5460048913955688,
0.3440488874912262,
0.29140689969062805,
0.29572075605392456,
0.11906003952026367,
0.1961163878440857,
0.28557056188583374,
-0.7040373682975769,
-0.3181288540363312,
1.2846704721450806,
0.46518030762672424,
0.9506745934486389,
0.06112579256296158,
0.6989790201187134,
0.3676585853099823,
0.5396268963813782,
-0.5635383725166321,
0.3973311483860016,
-0.023809652775526047,
-0.3687267303466797,
-0.2735501825809479,
-0.5446518659591675,
-1.04084050655365,
-0.06759738177061081,
-0.26421937346458435,
-0.8201560378074646,
0.3053427040576935,
0.569733202457428,
0.042749300599098206,
0.3942851722240448,
-0.6111572980880737,
0.3712441623210907,
0.014879260212182999,
-0.3469814956188202,
-0.6216034293174744,
-0.38753852248191833,
0.33542072772979736,
-0.30064329504966736,
0.20653857290744781,
-0.24366042017936707,
-0.11330966651439667,
0.8695873022079468,
-0.404989629983902,
0.8710684776306152,
-0.4347302317619324,
0.09167161583900452,
0.20852608978748322,
0.07441367954015732,
0.8408361673355103,
0.087466761469841,
-0.19390973448753357,
-0.15754088759422302,
0.2455170750617981,
-0.6133878231048584,
-0.2774701416492462,
0.5779656171798706,
-0.6667629480361938,
-0.43411242961883545,
-0.1633259803056717,
-0.6965422034263611,
-0.398271381855011,
0.2705943286418915,
-0.01528716180473566,
0.21717020869255066,
-0.061023175716400146,
0.4029243290424347,
0.8391456604003906,
-0.3673951029777527,
0.4294145107269287,
0.7447142004966736,
-0.28308433294296265,
-0.01495011430233717,
0.8047840595245361,
0.07417073100805283,
0.704467236995697,
0.3422754406929016,
0.21717531979084015,
-0.14714406430721283,
-0.9212411046028137,
0.007972922176122665,
0.048639409244060516,
-0.9302838444709778,
0.06275641918182373,
-0.5541151762008667,
-0.32475751638412476,
-0.10778099298477173,
-0.15767979621887207,
-0.1715063899755478,
-0.36626535654067993,
-0.21096491813659668,
0.05877836421132088,
0.5872116088867188,
0.6234013438224792,
-0.02277827262878418,
0.6721284985542297,
-0.803763747215271,
0.5535071492195129,
0.35269951820373535,
0.5733014941215515,
-0.07275800406932831,
-0.8383240699768066,
-0.3307405114173889,
-0.24652761220932007,
-0.1840517818927765,
-0.2602097988128662,
0.24711982905864716,
0.2967270612716675,
0.7054947018623352,
0.43911245465278625,
0.037866514176130295,
0.5104605555534363,
-0.4917066991329193,
0.4699377417564392,
0.060828063637018204,
-0.6097675561904907,
0.4993670582771301,
-0.40123191475868225,
0.3366478681564331,
0.7100304961204529,
0.3498718738555908,
-0.74700927734375,
-0.40289565920829773,
-0.5081376433372498,
-0.9391799569129944,
0.5866920351982117,
-0.26668134331703186,
0.27707937359809875,
-0.03198033198714256,
1.0392833948135376,
0.14431653916835785,
0.4305466413497925,
-0.5503759384155273,
-0.002148502040654421,
0.333522766828537,
-0.32705867290496826,
0.2000708431005478,
-0.33986547589302063,
-0.09188659489154816,
-0.025005623698234558,
0.6462770104408264,
0.03429112583398819,
0.15919488668441772,
-0.14871171116828918,
-0.3206184208393097,
0.11698820441961288,
0.19108662009239197,
0.3407507538795471,
0.9953531622886658,
-0.22658184170722961,
0.0033682684879750013,
0.526742696762085,
-0.8046848773956299,
0.061326924711465836,
-0.3412848114967346,
-0.2879180610179901,
-0.290195494890213,
0.3049743175506592,
0.6047701835632324,
0.24575071036815643,
-0.7057665586471558,
0.1090700775384903,
-0.08411106467247009,
-0.12951353192329407,
-0.5473143458366394,
0.5246663093566895,
0.08681569248437881,
-0.0012983668129891157,
0.3070714473724365,
0.10080339759588242,
-0.1839882731437683,
-0.4923260509967804,
0.40970203280448914,
0.227908194065094,
-0.48391517996788025,
-0.11624559015035629,
0.4866982698440552,
0.12075997143983841,
-0.03626217693090439,
0.7841218113899231,
0.2720791697502136,
0.04854349419474602,
0.46852996945381165,
0.5411807894706726,
0.5208063125610352,
-0.4057808816432953,
-0.17317359149456024,
0.048551492393016815,
0.2389802783727646,
-0.34766897559165955,
0.17438684403896332,
-0.07314199209213257,
-0.8343595862388611,
-0.14950086176395416,
-0.7342848181724548,
-0.7228548526763916,
0.4113858640193939,
-0.8236848711967468,
0.34639355540275574,
-0.6793678402900696,
0.2826439440250397,
-0.18315988779067993,
-0.44046372175216675,
-0.8501932621002197,
0.29019808769226074,
0.0737813338637352,
1.175615668296814,
-0.8800476789474487,
1.2889188528060913,
0.1104838028550148,
-0.23074164986610413,
-0.42744991183280945,
-0.011206044815480709,
0.01452173013240099,
-1.158651351928711,
0.4467479884624481,
-0.02395857498049736,
0.0685461014509201,
0.15204714238643646,
-0.38178932666778564,
-0.9224676489830017,
0.9478337168693542,
0.37548375129699707,
-0.9386453628540039,
-0.18979275226593018,
-0.043642863631248474,
0.15694975852966309,
-0.21225734055042267,
-0.12515337765216827,
0.961111307144165,
0.45460477471351624,
0.02528093382716179,
-0.4523185193538666,
-0.2752591073513031,
0.08592862635850906,
-0.32195210456848145,
0.09130008518695831,
-0.2986907660961151,
0.545612633228302,
0.09004535526037216,
-0.08697859197854996,
0.08594883978366852,
0.6655516028404236,
0.34309905767440796,
0.19842015206813812,
0.7891308665275574,
0.3064933717250824,
0.9434843063354492,
-0.04720752313733101,
1.081231951713562,
-0.24229373037815094,
0.09586993604898453,
1.5142399072647095,
-0.29255613684654236,
1.0197018384933472,
0.5910604000091553,
-0.2634655237197876,
0.5099289417266846,
0.6957899332046509,
0.03909611329436302,
0.4766443371772766,
0.2110625058412552,
-0.4863303601741791,
-0.015846187248826027,
0.15051278471946716,
-0.08087503910064697,
0.21446073055267334,
0.652854323387146,
-0.3673824667930603,
-0.015076952986419201,
0.16005657613277435,
-0.039208993315696716,
-0.041541241109371185,
-0.3710296154022217,
1.054618239402771,
0.053935423493385315,
-0.6284950375556946,
0.5114024877548218,
-0.2429404854774475,
0.48713552951812744,
-0.9784150123596191,
0.21095825731754303,
-0.17142686247825623,
0.3109224736690521,
-0.3509944975376129,
-0.7773699760437012,
0.558025598526001,
-0.14743514358997345,
-0.37553009390830994,
-0.0841001495718956,
0.5336955785751343,
-0.41838783025741577,
-0.15543881058692932,
0.46335142850875854,
0.26790159940719604,
0.23372645676136017,
0.10627327114343643,
-0.6141373515129089,
0.13316316902637482,
-0.13916432857513428,
-0.6146467924118042,
0.6043696999549866,
0.25897666811943054,
-0.2061445415019989,
0.9409890174865723,
0.6404621601104736,
0.4346042573451996,
0.285966157913208,
0.29794448614120483,
1.0495448112487793,
-0.23171445727348328,
-0.35574856400489807,
-0.7012608051300049,
0.09621476382017136,
-0.2601488530635834,
0.08805734664201736,
0.3757878541946411,
0.5194523334503174,
0.5410703420639038,
0.05746316909790039,
1.1388870477676392,
-0.037983547896146774,
0.6790788769721985,
-0.8260966539382935,
0.6925004124641418,
-0.4571250081062317,
0.4577580988407135,
0.0869925245642662,
-1.0254215002059937,
-0.17041799426078796,
0.45141497254371643,
-0.44582557678222656,
0.014477609656751156,
0.4396767318248749,
0.5360860824584961,
-0.2942429780960083,
-0.23639531433582306,
0.11297652870416641,
0.1217070072889328,
0.5739102959632874,
0.4674927592277527,
0.6202985048294067,
-0.08772151917219162,
0.5245052576065063,
0.005107393488287926,
-0.3466018736362457,
-0.10445044934749603,
-0.8968570828437805,
-0.6582332849502563,
-0.5034677386283875,
-0.2306496500968933,
-0.3123936355113983,
0.11025218665599823,
0.9595720767974854,
0.6657506227493286,
-0.9132371544837952,
-0.21151115000247955,
-0.4291641116142273,
0.1895255148410797,
-0.20082221925258636,
-0.17353679239749908,
0.3387751579284668,
-0.6259864568710327,
-0.5793361067771912,
0.5602981448173523,
0.33572977781295776,
0.20440387725830078,
-0.07744643837213516,
-0.15401425957679749,
-0.03098207525908947,
0.20018762350082397,
0.5275309085845947,
0.7505589127540588,
-0.3690037429332733,
-0.48966699838638306,
-0.4742475152015686,
0.03194528818130493,
-0.028365086764097214,
0.7698553204536438,
-0.7793462872505188,
0.47176745533943176,
0.39036470651626587,
0.7529698014259338,
0.7451806664466858,
-0.16304831206798553,
0.7416462898254395,
-0.7704277634620667,
0.4058820605278015,
-0.20989255607128143,
0.4615696966648102,
0.10590462386608124,
-0.21163949370384216,
0.42306751012802124,
0.24674922227859497,
-0.5943960547447205,
-0.8721537590026855,
0.34492501616477966,
-0.7389999628067017,
-0.3863357901573181,
0.9621666669845581,
-0.2365085780620575,
-0.22891604900360107,
-0.37431228160858154,
0.08521852642297745,
0.21967968344688416,
-0.06695390492677689,
1.1042728424072266,
0.45369091629981995,
-0.026431173086166382,
-0.47029533982276917,
-0.869360625743866,
0.6235477328300476,
0.13714340329170227,
-1.252405047416687,
0.4988516867160797,
0.27722376585006714,
0.649820864200592,
-0.13145026564598083,
0.655061662197113,
-0.13217341899871826,
0.13609495759010315,
-0.19238735735416412,
0.19974727928638458,
0.048126220703125,
-0.3975891172885895,
-0.27761220932006836,
0.22953540086746216,
0.42164871096611023,
-0.3108074963092804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00743v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00743v1
|
AIMDiT: Modality Augmentation and Interaction via Multimodal Dimension Transformation for Emotion Recognition in Conversations
| 2024-04-12T11:31:18 | 2024-04-12T11:31:18 |
Sheng Wu, Jiaxing Liu, Longbiao Wang, Dongxiao He, Xiaobao Wang, Jianwu Dang
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Emotion Recognition in Conversations (ERC) is a popular task in natural
language processing, which aims to recognize the emotional state of the speaker
in conversations. While current research primarily emphasizes contextual
modeling, there exists a dearth of investigation into effective multimodal
fusion methods. We propose a novel framework called AIMDiT to solve the problem
of multimodal fusion of deep features. Specifically, we design a Modality
Augmentation Network which performs rich representation learning through
dimension transformation of different modalities and parameter-efficient
inception block. On the other hand, the Modality Interaction Network performs
interaction fusion of extracted inter-modal features and intra-modal features.
Experiments conducted using our AIMDiT framework on the public benchmark
dataset MELD reveal 2.34% and 2.87% improvements in terms of the Acc-7 and w-F1
metrics compared to the state-of-the-art (SOTA) models.
|
[
-0.699236273765564,
-0.6367037296295166,
0.4316830635070801,
-0.0018709448631852865,
-0.11977346986532211,
-0.11607147008180618,
-0.585313618183136,
-0.6077138781547546,
0.498035728931427,
0.06178494915366173,
-0.5757497549057007,
-0.3569675385951996,
-0.46646079421043396,
0.013200724497437477,
-0.2493346631526947,
0.627285361289978,
-0.2589995265007019,
0.07138781249523163,
-0.3828122019767761,
-0.4440705180168152,
-0.3394014239311218,
-0.28874510526657104,
-0.3557691276073456,
0.06743142753839493,
0.654213011264801,
0.6391972899436951,
0.31087589263916016,
0.05674606189131737,
0.8090075254440308,
0.41409653425216675,
0.1460188776254654,
0.5601494908332825,
-0.4984673857688904,
0.4192315340042114,
0.13753139972686768,
-0.14603698253631592,
-0.48913365602493286,
0.11485112458467484,
0.490119993686676,
0.3922025263309479,
0.08457359671592712,
-0.10905475169420242,
0.1423502266407013,
0.44356659054756165,
-0.8015845417976379,
0.2447059154510498,
-0.3713829219341278,
0.10456424951553345,
0.009836701676249504,
-0.26930081844329834,
-0.30951017141342163,
-0.12082910537719727,
0.0547766387462616,
-0.29290762543678284,
-0.19134017825126648,
0.3236018717288971,
0.559110164642334,
0.21005727350711823,
-0.6413681507110596,
-0.07224614173173904,
-0.8161917924880981,
0.4489567279815674,
-0.6592305302619934,
0.4970364272594452,
0.25321531295776367,
0.3004187047481537,
0.2858928143978119,
-0.47423282265663147,
-1.011225700378418,
-0.20776493847370148,
-0.3466266393661499,
0.20689761638641357,
-0.2597167193889618,
0.3182695508003235,
0.17759869992733002,
0.4809730648994446,
-0.48428767919540405,
-0.12467188388109207,
-0.10598151385784149,
-0.0967901274561882,
0.5605766177177429,
0.26380792260169983,
0.2953430712223053,
-0.46711015701293945,
-0.45149797201156616,
-0.3540477454662323,
-0.21850252151489258,
0.1502300351858139,
0.2502753436565399,
0.14823268353939056,
-0.27863582968711853,
0.4861783981323242,
-0.21678505837917328,
0.46065109968185425,
0.029335876926779747,
0.08603370934724808,
0.5400691032409668,
-0.5230880975723267,
-0.18759867548942566,
0.09776221960783005,
0.898158609867096,
0.40533876419067383,
-0.25823459029197693,
0.3317877948284149,
0.013890660367906094,
0.1189691573381424,
0.29350966215133667,
-0.645816445350647,
0.06385132670402527,
0.23234707117080688,
-0.6031333804130554,
-0.27067944407463074,
0.15100841224193573,
-0.95610511302948,
-0.37706589698791504,
-0.42931610345840454,
0.626038670539856,
-0.5872235298156738,
-0.5231425166130066,
-0.09596598893404007,
0.19009873270988464,
0.22830894589424133,
0.41739508509635925,
-0.6311131119728088,
0.016344085335731506,
0.418039470911026,
0.8193239569664001,
-0.026950635015964508,
-0.3050007224082947,
-0.18961036205291748,
-0.08644657582044601,
-0.06762033700942993,
0.6691476702690125,
-0.9650676250457764,
-0.3271806240081787,
-0.12827512621879578,
-0.006533196195960045,
-0.21674159169197083,
-0.191614031791687,
0.5103157758712769,
-0.0750044509768486,
0.4252862334251404,
-0.18903113901615143,
-0.19458918273448944,
-0.33780211210250854,
0.6009300351142883,
-0.7200267314910889,
0.7916572690010071,
0.10936977714300156,
-0.7730749249458313,
0.1380952149629593,
-1.093167781829834,
-0.3704243302345276,
-0.12799744307994843,
0.0356028713285923,
-0.14892099797725677,
0.23210705816745758,
0.22386372089385986,
0.5417782068252563,
-0.2341766208410263,
0.038285255432128906,
-0.5305833220481873,
-0.1440971940755844,
0.5066587924957275,
-0.674880862236023,
0.011744098737835884,
0.39611539244651794,
-0.37209802865982056,
0.4303918480873108,
-0.8974576592445374,
-0.10857953131198883,
-0.29741770029067993,
-0.0729069709777832,
-0.4798145890235901,
-0.1835019886493683,
0.28903210163116455,
0.46705731749534607,
0.10804711282253265,
-0.7899243235588074,
-0.08159541338682175,
-0.3218126595020294,
0.46108531951904297,
0.6299452781677246,
-0.15124735236167908,
0.5173398852348328,
-0.032312121242284775,
0.3780008554458618,
0.5153192281723022,
0.1380484700202942,
-0.48673734068870544,
-0.08539590984582901,
-0.9603763818740845,
-0.3804979920387268,
0.13248486816883087,
0.29714927077293396,
-0.7460429668426514,
0.40274062752723694,
-0.20277760922908783,
-0.35088950395584106,
-0.6855881810188293,
-0.08980315923690796,
0.5335035920143127,
0.5366674661636353,
0.3546258211135864,
-0.429569274187088,
-0.5801849365234375,
-1.0927428007125854,
-0.0022813277319073677,
-0.30539774894714355,
0.056222718209028244,
0.7801569104194641,
0.14622077345848083,
-0.4035392999649048,
0.8904826045036316,
-0.21899829804897308,
-0.4708232283592224,
-0.23772691190242767,
0.5481871962547302,
-0.15857632458209991,
0.5302706360816956,
0.40423932671546936,
-1.0557327270507812,
-0.5282655358314514,
0.2697890102863312,
-0.8018661141395569,
-0.002051727846264839,
-0.06309216469526291,
-0.1911149024963379,
0.10332578420639038,
0.39733341336250305,
-0.4504237174987793,
0.47751161456108093,
0.7138500809669495,
-0.4269672930240631,
-0.15682649612426758,
-0.0025158259086310863,
0.9019780158996582,
-1.3562222719192505,
0.1150108203291893,
0.2305566519498825,
-0.22701647877693176,
-0.7599238753318787,
-0.4430350363254547,
0.2755359411239624,
-0.4079284071922302,
-0.5777947306632996,
0.4558313488960266,
-0.38034218549728394,
0.04256386682391167,
-0.05592162534594536,
0.2143198400735855,
0.2061876803636551,
0.7172390222549438,
-0.17489488422870636,
0.5470813512802124,
0.42717066407203674,
-0.2918778955936432,
0.6297047138214111,
0.4868423044681549,
-0.1930534541606903,
1.282158374786377,
-0.2803454101085663,
0.07319352775812149,
-0.26103833317756653,
0.15754197537899017,
-1.231942892074585,
-0.5315331220626831,
0.30101895332336426,
-0.4734894335269928,
0.4410054087638855,
0.3206680417060852,
-0.013729049824178219,
-0.096007339656353,
-0.2671482264995575,
0.7134963274002075,
0.2921065092086792,
-0.4958847165107727,
1.178709864616394,
0.2566622793674469,
-0.28141507506370544,
-0.30311378836631775,
-0.5097790360450745,
0.19205103814601898,
-0.18700319528579712,
-0.9501006007194519,
0.37322235107421875,
-0.1802312582731247,
-0.1489657163619995,
0.010928685776889324,
0.24903367459774017,
0.11413955688476562,
-0.16679906845092773,
0.5533441305160522,
-0.017999986186623573,
-0.11366098374128342,
0.36961182951927185,
0.1795133799314499,
-0.06969901919364929,
-0.11670393496751785,
0.4494459629058838,
0.5355211496353149,
-0.31670668721199036,
-0.72948157787323,
-0.5761604905128479,
0.7649503350257874,
0.9027966856956482,
-0.48289954662323,
0.5940966010093689,
1.0005520582199097,
-0.378234326839447,
0.11557850241661072,
-0.7694950103759766,
-0.27092960476875305,
-0.4345271587371826,
0.586872935295105,
-0.33990833163261414,
-1.0283491611480713,
0.5000452995300293,
-0.1550484597682953,
-0.12077636271715164,
0.35039639472961426,
0.5068354606628418,
-0.25693634152412415,
1.2710598707199097,
0.5211849808692932,
0.08733004331588745,
0.7625110745429993,
-0.021949028596282005,
0.5066326856613159,
-1.241661787033081,
-0.45908498764038086,
-0.12572813034057617,
-0.9608958959579468,
-0.12786895036697388,
-0.4488822817802429,
0.7418438792228699,
-0.3274763822555542,
0.07860209047794342,
0.26517394185066223,
-0.13200971484184265,
0.13238723576068878,
0.38563278317451477,
0.5233731865882874,
-0.0031206633429974318,
-0.16441942751407623,
0.20653408765792847,
-0.3504195809364319,
-0.3833276927471161,
-0.02097168192267418,
0.7068551778793335,
0.4859396815299988,
0.8977922797203064,
0.1862323135137558,
0.5353929996490479,
0.2574252784252167,
0.3133202791213989,
-0.8140630125999451,
0.7094307541847229,
0.10522611439228058,
-0.3108879327774048,
-0.14250127971172333,
-0.5225237011909485,
-0.49037042260169983,
0.1539967805147171,
-0.6026021838188171,
-0.5442386269569397,
0.7186150550842285,
0.09028337895870209,
-0.13391205668449402,
0.24237503111362457,
-0.8696205019950867,
0.8427345156669617,
-0.3534907400608063,
-0.3499043881893158,
-0.45103684067726135,
-0.6297341585159302,
0.3390173316001892,
0.07072092592716217,
0.17758916318416595,
-0.20913748443126678,
0.2553684413433075,
0.48640525341033936,
-0.2229509800672531,
0.8534795045852661,
-0.13143236935138702,
0.04472700133919716,
-0.004184417426586151,
0.2441462129354477,
0.3388436436653137,
0.06855660676956177,
0.10322516411542892,
0.24407781660556793,
-0.39663460850715637,
0.18200677633285522,
-0.6854735016822815,
0.7391340136528015,
-0.5292847156524658,
-0.21591243147850037,
-0.1155041977763176,
-0.7802050709724426,
-0.4094516932964325,
-0.17458228766918182,
-0.12864506244659424,
0.7593016028404236,
-0.3728193938732147,
0.6041355133056641,
0.5581269860267639,
-0.011203174479305744,
0.6643621325492859,
0.2571931481361389,
0.2616976201534271,
-0.5178669691085815,
0.9465423822402954,
-0.31706809997558594,
0.2587797939777374,
0.355172336101532,
0.03031432442367077,
-0.07342524826526642,
0.0236407108604908,
-0.10943638533353806,
0.009069827385246754,
-0.7092171907424927,
-0.43278029561042786,
-0.9105396270751953,
-0.1787337362766266,
-0.5056604743003845,
-0.04793259873986244,
-0.4589006006717682,
-0.20935022830963135,
-0.43683212995529175,
-0.09627462178468704,
0.43476444482803345,
0.3664438724517822,
-0.37946897745132446,
0.1734757274389267,
-0.8699599504470825,
0.1993207484483719,
0.5523562431335449,
0.4105468988418579,
-0.22370122373104095,
-0.44214192032814026,
-0.26788145303726196,
0.2667495012283325,
-0.17988380789756775,
-0.8503087759017944,
0.6348387002944946,
0.6249619722366333,
0.3819812536239624,
0.7403886914253235,
0.0704754963517189,
0.7426339983940125,
-0.23661519587039948,
0.6257994771003723,
0.5370380878448486,
-1.1812530755996704,
0.573435366153717,
-0.06467807292938232,
0.11725297570228577,
0.5019251108169556,
0.4444546699523926,
-0.8089051842689514,
-0.04784131795167923,
-0.42209017276763916,
-0.7806273102760315,
0.7586764693260193,
0.2046445608139038,
0.2691386342048645,
-0.0002976952528115362,
0.049435097724199295,
-0.1107146218419075,
0.3755069077014923,
-0.5929767489433289,
0.017479706555604935,
-0.20805314183235168,
-0.7935843467712402,
0.10153035074472427,
-0.5635465383529663,
-0.3607587516307831,
-0.16103622317314148,
0.30238431692123413,
-0.42449137568473816,
0.4873066544532776,
0.3092394471168518,
-0.18620914220809937,
-0.2582426071166992,
0.3471464514732361,
0.627765417098999,
0.32938069105148315,
-0.14785534143447876,
0.2303112894296646,
0.08238980174064636,
-0.12100382149219513,
-0.09801721572875977,
0.17681121826171875,
0.5357954502105713,
-0.1613766998052597,
0.32699909806251526,
1.3101292848587036,
0.5687988996505737,
-0.6280463933944702,
0.683339536190033,
-0.33508655428886414,
-0.24261799454689026,
-0.006029915995895863,
-0.04547774791717529,
-0.24760714173316956,
0.7709909081459045,
0.11309780180454254,
0.2380271703004837,
0.3413935899734497,
-0.6827821731567383,
0.1591733694076538,
0.5014782547950745,
-0.8102373480796814,
-0.4151284396648407,
0.503685712814331,
0.6080644726753235,
-0.25442928075790405,
0.40652766823768616,
0.1336095780134201,
-0.6827455163002014,
0.29056501388549805,
0.24587078392505646,
0.9692861437797546,
-0.43766283988952637,
0.2654077410697937,
0.36047059297561646,
-0.0690157562494278,
0.32935667037963867,
0.34230268001556396,
-0.32102492451667786,
-0.7763307094573975,
-0.17143337428569794,
-0.5585139989852905,
-0.5973716974258423,
-0.40800637006759644,
-0.533233642578125,
0.16153910756111145,
-0.14563912153244019,
-0.14305105805397034,
-0.27229413390159607,
-0.5896031260490417,
-0.6493111252784729,
0.06353724002838135,
0.40527239441871643,
0.3743538558483124,
-0.9191992878913879,
0.4358076751232147,
0.6542712450027466,
-0.416149765253067,
-0.6067380309104919,
-0.3614039123058319,
0.09536866098642349,
-0.572012722492218,
0.6551727056503296,
0.3582758605480194,
-0.0614762157201767,
-0.06688154488801956,
-0.5299012660980225,
-0.777180016040802,
1.1556624174118042,
0.1508512794971466,
-0.5849842429161072,
0.1218033879995346,
0.019855720922350883,
0.3544396460056305,
-0.813429057598114,
0.6593062281608582,
0.2057269811630249,
0.5222793817520142,
0.30689796805381775,
-0.9882892966270447,
-0.11981170624494553,
-0.569425106048584,
0.032947104424238205,
0.3110085427761078,
-0.6423110365867615,
0.7925786375999451,
0.0855289101600647,
-0.21108944714069366,
-0.400325208902359,
0.6140459179878235,
-0.1500004529953003,
0.30888471007347107,
0.7989324331283569,
0.5833031535148621,
0.37991809844970703,
-0.2914484441280365,
0.5902144312858582,
-0.5164313912391663,
0.3158414363861084,
0.6321678161621094,
-0.4845258295536041,
0.8923153877258301,
0.5218295454978943,
0.1643543541431427,
0.5933371782302856,
0.4669368267059326,
0.34077492356300354,
0.33965250849723816,
-0.3375524580478668,
-0.3894580900669098,
-0.4355885684490204,
-0.3111704885959625,
-0.31968238949775696,
0.7649157047271729,
0.5977280735969543,
-0.32349833846092224,
0.031616151332855225,
0.6996504664421082,
-0.12716136872768402,
-0.1749057173728943,
-0.20897410809993744,
1.0369195938110352,
-0.03186877444386482,
-0.279476135969162,
0.213274285197258,
-0.2560834586620331,
0.799717366695404,
-0.6861314177513123,
-0.3021799325942993,
-0.3548198640346527,
0.11079791188240051,
-0.28264862298965454,
-0.623622477054596,
0.20220112800598145,
-0.30614712834358215,
-0.11940054595470428,
-0.2925693094730377,
0.7910283803939819,
-0.9825698733329773,
-0.3761841952800751,
0.2222985029220581,
0.2388020157814026,
-0.22573255002498627,
-0.16134904325008392,
-0.4557538330554962,
0.39479032158851624,
-0.24457472562789917,
-0.388651579618454,
0.3680954575538635,
0.5578296780586243,
0.36101457476615906,
0.5049080848693848,
0.5650948286056519,
-0.1631384640932083,
-0.28870150446891785,
-0.01932699792087078,
1.1800321340560913,
-0.6277799606323242,
-0.4663114547729492,
-0.6635329723358154,
0.8060986995697021,
-0.297719269990921,
-0.2600964307785034,
0.5139166712760925,
0.06364117562770844,
0.6114522814750671,
0.12363184243440628,
0.4759587347507477,
-0.41788250207901,
0.37354013323783875,
-0.5705882906913757,
0.5898128151893616,
-0.9652706980705261,
-0.022830849513411522,
-0.3771877884864807,
-0.9939931035041809,
-0.14306631684303284,
0.6944713592529297,
-0.04336896911263466,
0.13213223218917847,
0.8758520483970642,
0.8290607333183289,
-0.28484147787094116,
0.08434354513883591,
0.5540035367012024,
0.33473601937294006,
0.43031978607177734,
0.7039340734481812,
0.8143359422683716,
-0.30847129225730896,
0.43977227807044983,
-0.389953076839447,
-0.24549387395381927,
-0.4365358352661133,
-0.7697692513465881,
-0.6982028484344482,
-1.0081589221954346,
-0.2640168368816376,
-0.32368898391723633,
-0.2691597640514374,
1.1337672472000122,
0.7307829260826111,
-0.6375760436058044,
0.06991098821163177,
0.32454749941825867,
-0.22671085596084595,
-0.0231697428971529,
-0.26169756054878235,
0.2003346085548401,
-0.2698044180870056,
-0.8687772154808044,
0.5911471247673035,
0.7552696466445923,
-0.1515733301639557,
-0.5626134872436523,
-0.16307155787944794,
-0.2284020185470581,
0.011882724240422249,
0.6729912757873535,
0.130575031042099,
-0.4791916310787201,
-0.5811194777488708,
-0.09359000623226166,
-0.031528376042842865,
0.32479801774024963,
1.0371335744857788,
-0.6130282282829285,
0.8208596110343933,
0.6436559557914734,
0.6629531383514404,
0.2214912474155426,
-0.014923064038157463,
0.6208924055099487,
-0.7293315529823303,
0.24265530705451965,
0.24942928552627563,
0.6199197769165039,
0.34021493792533875,
-0.26768577098846436,
0.30951106548309326,
0.2632591128349304,
-0.43893253803253174,
-0.8339794278144836,
0.43543267250061035,
-1.3464603424072266,
0.12751257419586182,
1.109324336051941,
-0.07190877944231033,
-0.3268004357814789,
0.22794978320598602,
-0.6203377842903137,
-0.018565641716122627,
-0.442004531621933,
0.5615983605384827,
0.48694053292274475,
-0.18711358308792114,
-0.715444028377533,
0.018663009628653526,
0.21033254265785217,
0.44372400641441345,
-1.0439839363098145,
0.03802453354001045,
0.7357988953590393,
-0.2544896602630615,
0.36289864778518677,
0.4070380628108978,
-0.0467403270304203,
0.06491398066282272,
-0.1269700825214386,
0.2916600704193115,
-0.2826901376247406,
-0.5535843968391418,
-0.3581395745277405,
0.23221009969711304,
-0.3333088457584381,
-0.03647146373987198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08403v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08403v1
|
Learning representations of learning representations
| 2024-04-12T11:30:16 | 2024-04-12T11:30:16 |
Rita González-Márquez, Dmitry Kobak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DL, cs.LG
|
The ICLR conference is unique among the top machine learning conferences in
that all submitted papers are openly available. Here we present the ICLR
dataset consisting of abstracts of all 24 thousand ICLR submissions from
2017-2024 with meta-data, decision scores, and custom keyword-based labels. We
find that on this dataset, bag-of-words representation outperforms most
dedicated sentence transformer models in terms of $k$NN classification
accuracy, and the top performing language models barely outperform TF-IDF. We
see this as a challenge for the NLP community. Furthermore, we use the ICLR
dataset to study how the field of machine learning has changed over the last
seven years, finding some improvement in gender balance. Using a 2D embedding
of the abstracts' texts, we describe a shift in research topics from 2017 to
2024 and identify hedgehogs and foxes among the authors with the highest number
of ICLR submissions.
|
[
-0.24115420877933502,
0.3390769064426422,
0.16904017329216003,
-0.1772090196609497,
0.036246854811906815,
0.4669654667377472,
-0.05354620888829231,
-0.5102651119232178,
-0.17690379917621613,
0.16399598121643066,
-0.23927059769630432,
-0.5250954627990723,
-1.0956671237945557,
0.426613450050354,
-0.7120410203933716,
1.210717797279358,
0.25293558835983276,
0.3611966371536255,
-0.5351449847221375,
-0.5916794538497925,
-0.29797622561454773,
-0.6506509184837341,
-0.1683417111635208,
-0.5833988189697266,
0.6302369236946106,
0.2048332542181015,
0.43225112557411194,
0.5400509834289551,
0.631009042263031,
0.16183198988437653,
-0.2617720067501068,
0.18333843350410461,
-0.3042990267276764,
-0.24223050475120544,
-0.34973540902137756,
-0.4657171368598938,
-0.16318686306476593,
0.04175243526697159,
0.8558686971664429,
1.017799973487854,
-0.217648446559906,
0.1503015160560608,
0.3831157982349396,
0.6117017865180969,
-0.7202304005622864,
0.38095933198928833,
-0.7878990769386292,
0.3314099907875061,
-0.23598657548427582,
0.17572253942489624,
-0.7468510866165161,
0.06760323792695999,
0.027079490944743156,
-0.3417297899723053,
0.1419956535100937,
0.07907289266586304,
0.7650883793830872,
0.06287430226802826,
-0.39206168055534363,
-0.47876405715942383,
-0.6359009742736816,
0.9305936098098755,
-0.3964375853538513,
0.28186288475990295,
0.30494681000709534,
0.13601739704608917,
-0.1355658918619156,
-0.7448369860649109,
-0.18973839282989502,
-0.08431390672922134,
-0.12197810411453247,
-0.16724535822868347,
-0.5831881165504456,
-0.1393192559480667,
0.19987671077251434,
0.10172440856695175,
-0.44313883781433105,
0.16878092288970947,
-0.44147273898124695,
-0.08912039548158646,
0.7335842251777649,
0.14309678971767426,
0.31644290685653687,
0.15338078141212463,
-0.07611849159002304,
-0.2482297122478485,
-0.5988797545433044,
-0.20472705364227295,
0.24856449663639069,
0.4773464500904083,
-0.054050005972385406,
0.698420524597168,
0.19790607690811157,
0.5741124749183655,
0.1148124560713768,
0.14483532309532166,
0.24299286305904388,
-0.16245391964912415,
0.09466495364904404,
0.24375095963478088,
0.9008164405822754,
0.4062872529029846,
-0.03467520326375961,
-0.1794786900281906,
-0.08351241052150726,
-0.3438155949115753,
0.11921897530555725,
-0.6976212859153748,
-0.15950503945350647,
-0.2883221507072449,
-0.673453152179718,
-0.3843448758125305,
0.39658617973327637,
-0.7336624264717102,
-0.4656621217727661,
-0.26983198523521423,
-0.07009681314229965,
-0.08528515696525574,
-0.332390159368515,
0.1575309932231903,
-0.09920311719179153,
0.4193631410598755,
0.1145460307598114,
-0.8969419002532959,
0.5314903259277344,
0.6538688540458679,
0.7936775088310242,
-0.30145034193992615,
0.004985797684639692,
-0.2100236713886261,
0.06184394285082817,
-0.5081939101219177,
0.5399196743965149,
-0.9020578861236572,
-0.44882461428642273,
-0.06671421974897385,
-0.014716515317559242,
-0.10522685945034027,
-0.7218724489212036,
0.4507692754268646,
-0.2630848288536072,
0.313946008682251,
-0.41198644042015076,
-0.5843857526779175,
-0.1660122573375702,
0.1015339344739914,
-0.6066904067993164,
0.7701464891433716,
-0.14848408102989197,
-1.0644793510437012,
0.47393691539764404,
-0.7914892435073853,
-0.029654622077941895,
0.18413157761096954,
-0.5647287964820862,
-0.6177446842193604,
0.1766705960035324,
0.21719588339328766,
0.3350639343261719,
-0.021999724209308624,
0.3918197751045227,
-0.2314024418592453,
-0.33588311076164246,
0.5355345606803894,
-0.06727749109268188,
0.9013116955757141,
0.18637202680110931,
-0.012772454880177975,
0.04635123535990715,
-0.7105448842048645,
-0.2466164082288742,
0.16039197146892548,
-0.11529527604579926,
-0.05223100259900093,
0.3488277494907379,
0.1190735325217247,
0.23547419905662537,
0.013991751708090305,
-0.6296641230583191,
0.35993117094039917,
-0.33343276381492615,
0.9025675654411316,
0.5908576250076294,
-0.37534239888191223,
0.4366026818752289,
-0.3472132086753845,
0.47630035877227783,
0.4471789300441742,
-0.22827742993831635,
-0.26531368494033813,
-0.5113539695739746,
-0.5761545896530151,
-0.014697335660457611,
0.6556646823883057,
0.2260063737630844,
-0.28164756298065186,
0.4162118136882782,
-0.29229098558425903,
-0.4107603430747986,
-0.6873874068260193,
-0.3118664622306824,
0.13349708914756775,
0.2739369869232178,
0.32428398728370667,
0.056020587682724,
-0.7538043260574341,
-0.9202507734298706,
-0.4195123314857483,
-0.3064103126525879,
0.13001571595668793,
0.14150534570217133,
0.6899436712265015,
-0.2301756888628006,
0.8300248980522156,
-0.352095365524292,
-0.28662917017936707,
-0.4081375300884247,
0.5453589558601379,
-0.02953149378299713,
0.6236720085144043,
0.5415529012680054,
-0.7876169681549072,
-0.31735825538635254,
0.14251486957073212,
-0.6830697059631348,
0.18670181930065155,
0.08182817697525024,
0.20441317558288574,
0.28815850615501404,
0.6954773664474487,
-0.4851682186126709,
0.4223810136318207,
0.5053072571754456,
-0.23904651403427124,
0.22470128536224365,
0.028185149654746056,
-0.08169729262590408,
-0.8842418789863586,
0.26342177391052246,
-0.09266205132007599,
-0.33858346939086914,
-0.20788432657718658,
-0.05006751790642738,
-0.07696747034788132,
-0.2852066457271576,
-0.2185458391904831,
0.3989740014076233,
-0.27181535959243774,
-0.2873672842979431,
-0.12664386630058289,
-0.2163180112838745,
-0.13323183357715607,
0.10654649883508682,
-0.26023030281066895,
0.8693446516990662,
0.47290945053100586,
-0.354524701833725,
-0.2855622172355652,
0.4783641993999481,
-0.4298882484436035,
-0.04726743698120117,
-0.54789137840271,
0.42072632908821106,
-0.6734286546707153,
0.397382915019989,
-1.041202187538147,
-0.07835819572210312,
0.34270384907722473,
-0.5104712843894958,
0.4948301911354065,
-0.09453529119491577,
-0.5670657157897949,
-0.32588624954223633,
-0.132366344332695,
0.3695482015609741,
0.3712928593158722,
-0.32015159726142883,
0.6417412161827087,
0.45566102862358093,
0.033917222172021866,
-0.8715688586235046,
-0.8495809435844421,
0.4877844750881195,
-0.008843990042805672,
0.07373925298452377,
0.6824151873588562,
-0.03663000836968422,
-0.22635440528392792,
0.303046315908432,
0.1668730229139328,
0.15373577177524567,
-0.028638094663619995,
0.19102589786052704,
0.07042717188596725,
-0.1315990835428238,
0.2789236009120941,
-0.07225695997476578,
-0.23353928327560425,
0.08177564293146133,
-0.5473286509513855,
0.526218593120575,
-0.2550630271434784,
-0.33192262053489685,
-0.3669465482234955,
0.4762275815010071,
0.5175417065620422,
-0.24543197453022003,
0.7891786098480225,
0.46979737281799316,
-0.4285336434841156,
0.023462222889065742,
-0.0491245873272419,
-0.03542574867606163,
-0.37100937962532043,
0.5245901346206665,
-0.10972807556390762,
-0.9819373488426208,
0.3477482497692108,
-0.0037733749486505985,
0.33019623160362244,
0.7815551161766052,
0.3270080089569092,
-0.3785654604434967,
1.6003546714782715,
0.9250621199607849,
-0.2521727681159973,
0.29238152503967285,
-0.15047523379325867,
0.278175950050354,
-0.6847725510597229,
-0.5125274658203125,
-0.8712354302406311,
-0.581118643283844,
-0.78150475025177,
-0.14028719067573547,
0.0710400864481926,
0.015347838401794434,
-0.21533790230751038,
0.12411017715930939,
-0.7193817496299744,
0.367784321308136,
0.23754552006721497,
-0.00870261900126934,
0.23870748281478882,
0.010991065762937069,
-0.18059319257736206,
-0.4446254372596741,
-0.6471834182739258,
-0.6526520848274231,
1.0513756275177002,
0.28923025727272034,
0.49595731496810913,
-0.19589586555957794,
0.4249095916748047,
0.6415730118751526,
0.21352413296699524,
-0.5305220484733582,
0.6989014744758606,
-0.5916627049446106,
-0.3923720121383667,
0.2509468197822571,
-0.3138402998447418,
-0.9551266431808472,
0.21241024136543274,
-0.10003969073295593,
-0.43085426092147827,
0.22109785676002502,
-0.20953942835330963,
0.03312350809574127,
0.6740634441375732,
-0.14142709970474243,
0.3150283992290497,
-0.02984433062374592,
0.20348848402500153,
-0.07945813983678818,
-0.679953932762146,
0.12243065237998962,
0.14899347722530365,
0.11626126617193222,
-0.26102855801582336,
-0.22916017472743988,
1.0958607196807861,
-0.184620201587677,
0.8250174522399902,
-0.090082086622715,
0.18322235345840454,
0.1384851038455963,
-0.24773181974887848,
0.15145421028137207,
-0.24415180087089539,
-0.2029145359992981,
0.44489848613739014,
-0.06790304183959961,
-0.284993976354599,
-0.3470052480697632,
0.3958764970302582,
-0.829643189907074,
-0.27810823917388916,
-0.7398934364318848,
-0.39141130447387695,
0.1740054488182068,
0.12712179124355316,
0.431537926197052,
0.536411464214325,
-0.15900661051273346,
0.37747612595558167,
0.6132928729057312,
-0.3576573431491852,
0.6110393404960632,
0.05095776915550232,
-0.5654839873313904,
-0.4349261522293091,
0.7829282879829407,
0.3423820436000824,
-0.18710818886756897,
0.6070990562438965,
0.2615986466407776,
-0.11627497524023056,
-0.7671505808830261,
-0.46880748867988586,
0.07600679248571396,
-0.8471162915229797,
-0.42038291692733765,
-1.129822850227356,
-0.5140538215637207,
-0.24931496381759644,
0.04265330731868744,
-0.10605015605688095,
-0.4244886636734009,
-0.7259570956230164,
-0.219083771109581,
0.1374174952507019,
1.1226568222045898,
-0.08843010663986206,
0.11861927062273026,
-0.49506673216819763,
-0.10838465392589569,
0.06360644102096558,
0.10452792793512344,
0.022620689123868942,
-0.346426784992218,
-0.18641427159309387,
0.029627567157149315,
-0.4337465167045593,
-0.49128204584121704,
0.41602250933647156,
0.5741932988166809,
0.4942065179347992,
0.2177189588546753,
0.0279033612459898,
0.5352710485458374,
-0.3351220190525055,
0.9485021233558655,
0.3484236001968384,
-0.8022542595863342,
0.48031601309776306,
-0.3396914601325989,
0.42837467789649963,
0.5368063449859619,
0.6118105053901672,
-0.4915059804916382,
-0.3214375376701355,
-0.6063641309738159,
-0.5222069025039673,
0.685187041759491,
0.01664627529680729,
0.44662898778915405,
0.038550183176994324,
0.5492757558822632,
0.2862488329410553,
0.306820273399353,
-0.7324803471565247,
-0.4683106243610382,
-0.10812509059906006,
-0.6353201270103455,
0.1670779287815094,
-0.2916748523712158,
0.11408765614032745,
-0.43982207775115967,
0.4829123020172119,
-0.40548381209373474,
0.5573180317878723,
-0.06085250899195671,
-0.06597527861595154,
-0.056791942566633224,
0.14224986732006073,
0.6877933740615845,
0.8884550929069519,
-0.023607585579156876,
0.23964081704616547,
0.22507049143314362,
-0.4528929889202118,
0.07544521242380142,
-0.03476236015558243,
-0.2618790566921234,
0.26568228006362915,
0.7294904589653015,
0.551074206829071,
0.245339035987854,
-0.7360430955886841,
0.6711006164550781,
-0.28989166021347046,
-0.5261690020561218,
-0.21176820993423462,
-0.07850819826126099,
-0.0346817784011364,
0.043208155781030655,
0.6530215740203857,
0.5367293357849121,
0.32485252618789673,
-0.4556238055229187,
0.33186498284339905,
0.27570244669914246,
-0.950987696647644,
-0.5009121894836426,
0.6319189667701721,
-0.1791170835494995,
-0.05953839421272278,
0.6603211164474487,
-0.23692461848258972,
-0.7245181202888489,
0.39767658710479736,
0.5110980868339539,
0.8308342099189758,
-0.01879231259226799,
0.24544647336006165,
0.5973734855651855,
0.24627797305583954,
0.01289583183825016,
0.020105702802538872,
0.2282673716545105,
-0.5781287550926208,
-0.4720934331417084,
-0.3703623414039612,
-0.38644036650657654,
0.17284314334392548,
-0.8407862186431885,
0.584962010383606,
-0.4618552625179291,
0.030962785705924034,
0.14812923967838287,
0.08696186542510986,
-0.4734686017036438,
-0.2789662778377533,
0.4307991564273834,
0.9196835160255432,
-0.6294988989830017,
0.5878753662109375,
0.9194430112838745,
-0.2632005512714386,
-0.16878066956996918,
-0.09028588235378265,
-0.07948963344097137,
-0.5004381537437439,
0.9343648552894592,
0.3562771677970886,
-0.10144579410552979,
-0.09393569827079773,
-1.1481435298919678,
-0.8479195237159729,
0.8512609601020813,
0.5472856163978577,
-0.7584162950515747,
-0.20276764035224915,
0.4775841534137726,
0.30695486068725586,
-0.5710805058479309,
0.12414498627185822,
0.17002540826797485,
0.3160703182220459,
0.05620395764708519,
-0.5314710140228271,
-0.3880566358566284,
-0.250597208738327,
0.04057495668530464,
0.17924563586711884,
-0.44059258699417114,
0.8108827471733093,
-0.060424819588661194,
-0.40860775113105774,
-0.024218549951910973,
0.9270175695419312,
0.2641577422618866,
0.2547690272331238,
0.368379145860672,
0.43530744314193726,
0.9111878871917725,
-0.29180583357810974,
0.7206494212150574,
0.12119699269533157,
0.29111412167549133,
1.0153578519821167,
-0.29784688353538513,
0.8500418663024902,
0.20703962445259094,
-0.3317418694496155,
0.6582201719284058,
0.43289732933044434,
-0.20898453891277313,
0.6629611253738403,
0.3841116726398468,
-0.19205506145954132,
-0.2429163157939911,
-0.3590264320373535,
-0.31278958916664124,
0.7170530557632446,
0.5454851388931274,
-0.3570272922515869,
-0.5029166340827942,
0.7099248766899109,
-0.0020709435921162367,
0.2608295679092407,
-0.3444397747516632,
1.1274923086166382,
0.15768006443977356,
-0.25786086916923523,
0.19168174266815186,
0.015613584779202938,
0.7843706011772156,
-0.36708587408065796,
-0.3347108066082001,
-0.05669207125902176,
0.2289959043264389,
-0.24648159742355347,
-0.9092532396316528,
0.5389609932899475,
-0.18231309950351715,
-0.41876620054244995,
-0.47074630856513977,
0.992659330368042,
-0.5302360653877258,
-0.8653863668441772,
0.2436993420124054,
0.03594454005360603,
0.16443730890750885,
0.2313036024570465,
-0.898816704750061,
0.24982616305351257,
-0.08096543699502945,
0.35566210746765137,
0.5252280235290527,
0.38221311569213867,
-0.0924527570605278,
0.729323148727417,
0.23333434760570526,
-0.19292274117469788,
0.06778649240732193,
-0.2113124132156372,
0.9034526348114014,
-0.6203070878982544,
-0.1920028030872345,
-0.8816062808036804,
0.380998432636261,
-0.10161716490983963,
-0.391092449426651,
0.35241928696632385,
0.6750197410583496,
0.8870399594306946,
0.16959118843078613,
0.8144502639770508,
-0.189265638589859,
0.628254234790802,
-0.27676770091056824,
0.7716442346572876,
-0.4035320580005646,
-0.0036794759798794985,
0.05924243852496147,
-0.34648704528808594,
-0.6017948389053345,
0.4586382210254669,
0.10710262507200241,
0.12092894315719604,
0.2660336494445801,
0.40527769923210144,
-0.002059066900983453,
0.3275342583656311,
0.21589675545692444,
-0.09810619801282883,
0.4119631350040436,
0.3244965076446533,
1.198518991470337,
-0.7855708003044128,
0.448261022567749,
-0.1272454708814621,
0.23348820209503174,
-0.5104416608810425,
-1.2173618078231812,
-0.675685703754425,
-1.072230577468872,
-0.8097077012062073,
-0.14770694077014923,
0.05048728361725807,
1.1210286617279053,
0.7905916571617126,
-1.0087847709655762,
-0.1745692640542984,
-0.1197720617055893,
0.1534094363451004,
-0.2983216941356659,
-0.14934572577476501,
0.23097407817840576,
-0.4950641095638275,
-0.4409361779689789,
0.12678655982017517,
0.16258084774017334,
0.049767643213272095,
-0.28788092732429504,
0.07797477394342422,
-0.2484211027622223,
-0.3298826515674591,
0.7176445126533508,
-0.0733625665307045,
-0.7151975631713867,
-0.16503633558750153,
-0.012389102019369602,
-0.2249395102262497,
0.3307262063026428,
0.8224554657936096,
-0.7772275805473328,
0.23557186126708984,
0.3210752010345459,
0.7535449266433716,
0.4710652828216553,
-0.47712329030036926,
0.6308616995811462,
-0.6579849123954773,
-0.214078888297081,
0.6018040776252747,
0.36140957474708557,
0.47377875447273254,
-0.18780764937400818,
0.4360102713108063,
0.07361062616109848,
-0.4308643639087677,
-1.0011959075927734,
-0.14599208533763885,
-0.868557333946228,
-0.431310772895813,
0.6817445755004883,
-0.12972788512706757,
-0.04200000315904617,
-0.1991094946861267,
-0.07821623235940933,
0.12194576114416122,
-0.2610006332397461,
0.5696351528167725,
0.9000968337059021,
-0.05544377490878105,
-0.6605493426322937,
-0.6064473986625671,
0.4299437999725342,
0.24056103825569153,
-0.6964764595031738,
0.054754238575696945,
0.0644771084189415,
0.017352882772684097,
0.20179875195026398,
0.17874108254909515,
-0.5387101173400879,
-0.18784686923027039,
-0.42380738258361816,
0.16527467966079712,
0.0802864283323288,
-0.48900023102760315,
-0.5442981123924255,
0.2002989500761032,
0.15307168662548065,
-0.09728992730379105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08720v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08720v1
|
Exploring Contrastive Learning for Long-Tailed Multi-Label Text Classification
| 2024-04-12T11:12:16 | 2024-04-12T11:12:16 |
Alexandre Audibert, Aurélien Gauffre, Massih-Reza Amini
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Learning an effective representation in multi-label text classification
(MLTC) is a significant challenge in NLP. This challenge arises from the
inherent complexity of the task, which is shaped by two key factors: the
intricate connections between labels and the widespread long-tailed
distribution of the data. To overcome this issue, one potential approach
involves integrating supervised contrastive learning with classical supervised
loss functions. Although contrastive learning has shown remarkable performance
in multi-class classification, its impact in the multi-label framework has not
been thoroughly investigated. In this paper, we conduct an in-depth study of
supervised contrastive learning and its influence on representation in MLTC
context. We emphasize the importance of considering long-tailed data
distributions to build a robust representation space, which effectively
addresses two critical challenges associated with contrastive learning that we
identify: the "lack of positives" and the "attraction-repulsion imbalance".
Building on this insight, we introduce a novel contrastive loss function for
MLTC. It attains Micro-F1 scores that either match or surpass those obtained
with other frequently employed loss functions, and demonstrates a significant
improvement in Macro-F1 scores across three multi-label datasets.
|
[
-0.649345874786377,
-0.39825010299682617,
0.38872653245925903,
0.29299893975257874,
-0.23444221913814545,
0.12958334386348724,
-0.19071348011493683,
-0.43988606333732605,
0.35732612013816833,
0.26044994592666626,
-0.5510631203651428,
-0.642717182636261,
-0.7159144878387451,
0.2145647257566452,
-0.31807345151901245,
1.2704068422317505,
-0.05756519362330437,
-0.24271418154239655,
-0.11735840141773224,
-0.6795760989189148,
-0.25382286310195923,
-0.8478001952171326,
-0.6159095168113708,
-0.5702015161514282,
1.0268436670303345,
0.0871502012014389,
0.4367193281650543,
0.28354400396347046,
0.4944133758544922,
0.1919557899236679,
-0.16120077669620514,
0.06314211338758469,
-0.5411262512207031,
0.0009070895612239838,
-0.060556523501873016,
-0.35990267992019653,
0.12025479972362518,
-0.03462737053632736,
0.8401680588722229,
0.8029230237007141,
-0.08039076626300812,
-0.3095838129520416,
0.6201929450035095,
0.8754696846008301,
-0.7878720760345459,
0.22281542420387268,
-0.3725672960281372,
0.4093741476535797,
-0.20208582282066345,
-0.3249320983886719,
-0.735549807548523,
0.05040694400668144,
0.23792099952697754,
-0.6983476281166077,
0.035158365964889526,
0.09387210756540298,
0.824167788028717,
0.2834564447402954,
-0.9624063968658447,
-0.3240651488304138,
-0.3331575095653534,
1.0982962846755981,
-0.1870996206998825,
0.5184541940689087,
0.18177849054336548,
0.16753363609313965,
0.04985380172729492,
-0.4462019205093384,
-0.24400924146175385,
-0.06894902884960175,
-0.34259486198425293,
0.4045107066631317,
-0.16767063736915588,
0.001823896775022149,
-0.11404866725206375,
0.33595651388168335,
-0.38977622985839844,
0.4154280722141266,
-0.07260847091674805,
-0.20400524139404297,
0.1306026130914688,
0.16143493354320526,
-0.3545989394187927,
0.0488378182053566,
-0.5708425641059875,
-0.3321757912635803,
-0.47743335366249084,
-0.04344918951392174,
0.26122206449508667,
0.5452637672424316,
-0.20728908479213715,
0.3066540062427521,
0.1084846705198288,
0.5283787250518799,
-0.0009332948829978704,
0.01567746140062809,
0.37552884221076965,
-0.26189443469047546,
-0.14305472373962402,
0.09606694430112839,
0.8138669729232788,
0.4434416592121124,
0.07338231056928635,
0.13905133306980133,
-0.056675441563129425,
-0.33482053875923157,
-0.012019958347082138,
-1.1755536794662476,
-0.3854905664920807,
0.021381724625825882,
-0.591402530670166,
-0.5487576723098755,
0.15675167739391327,
-0.6765807867050171,
-0.7149194478988647,
-0.240142822265625,
0.468552827835083,
-0.3932948708534241,
-0.3126474916934967,
0.1216682568192482,
-0.09559760242700577,
0.14050188660621643,
0.31682097911834717,
-0.8536149859428406,
0.3590811789035797,
0.34160858392715454,
0.897153377532959,
-0.4103519022464752,
-0.17792195081710815,
-0.5285382866859436,
0.16741079092025757,
-0.3690081834793091,
0.5734813213348389,
-0.47997766733169556,
-0.21505537629127502,
0.07763370871543884,
-0.12151840329170227,
-0.06797196716070175,
-0.5897466540336609,
0.3970543444156647,
-0.48272839188575745,
0.15900421142578125,
0.10761820524930954,
-0.5282617211341858,
-0.3272477686405182,
0.44764670729637146,
-0.8364460468292236,
0.7277929186820984,
0.1602829396724701,
-1.2137786149978638,
0.4422512650489807,
-0.49405422806739807,
-0.446183979511261,
-0.35823845863342285,
-0.057769376784563065,
-0.9138291478157043,
-0.018883464857935905,
0.18365857005119324,
0.8717730045318604,
0.0755629912018776,
0.01898699253797531,
-0.4730195701122284,
-0.42012152075767517,
0.44471728801727295,
-0.389072448015213,
0.8577746748924255,
0.009447657503187656,
-0.18401359021663666,
0.06625428795814514,
-0.8090912699699402,
-0.20421022176742554,
-0.10090436041355133,
-0.28949788212776184,
-0.8094263672828674,
-0.16432876884937286,
0.20858776569366455,
0.15526653826236725,
-0.22255492210388184,
-0.3086695373058319,
0.0661645382642746,
-0.21652531623840332,
0.10995788127183914,
0.7193894386291504,
0.06482655555009842,
0.4297069311141968,
-0.14085468649864197,
0.1617310494184494,
0.5640469789505005,
-0.22092528641223907,
-0.3060493767261505,
-0.42833220958709717,
-0.6956979036331177,
-0.3059101104736328,
0.4670121967792511,
0.4851049780845642,
-0.7753345966339111,
0.3236600160598755,
0.0916435569524765,
-0.326836496591568,
-0.5141870379447937,
0.05307740718126297,
0.20516474545001984,
0.540751039981842,
0.7863304018974304,
0.07672616839408875,
-0.2876623868942261,
-1.1030783653259277,
0.08291256427764893,
0.26086878776550293,
-0.05941251665353775,
0.14550365507602692,
0.6053736209869385,
-0.5846731662750244,
0.5284845232963562,
-0.6448425650596619,
-0.7651965618133545,
-0.06998966634273529,
0.4477766156196594,
0.3589980900287628,
0.6138656139373779,
0.6010698080062866,
-1.0254398584365845,
-0.5799391269683838,
0.20170994102954865,
-0.6639733910560608,
0.0785902738571167,
-0.4568829834461212,
0.08184631168842316,
0.2995661497116089,
0.5399748682975769,
-0.3364992141723633,
0.40883126854896545,
0.6291515231132507,
-0.1214476227760315,
0.6957629919052124,
-0.25227832794189453,
0.21040849387645721,
-0.8205650448799133,
-0.11869261413812637,
0.4147327244281769,
0.003924787975847721,
-0.4369790852069855,
0.01139798853546381,
0.3001343905925751,
0.03535831719636917,
-0.3065100610256195,
0.42815130949020386,
-0.18372906744480133,
0.29971420764923096,
-0.10060721635818481,
-0.06445980817079544,
0.15735305845737457,
0.5447545051574707,
0.09848775714635849,
0.6662556529045105,
0.5458365678787231,
-0.816453754901886,
-0.10452900826931,
0.0335913822054863,
-0.05092160403728485,
0.8458390235900879,
-0.3244372010231018,
-0.3176523447036743,
-0.22666949033737183,
0.36733800172805786,
-1.0634413957595825,
0.005042931996285915,
0.30403730273246765,
-0.24080562591552734,
0.6207749247550964,
0.1097889244556427,
-0.5561932325363159,
-0.056444406509399414,
-0.6323323249816895,
0.42660725116729736,
0.12113852053880692,
-0.7525100708007812,
0.49605506658554077,
0.03352254256606102,
0.13992054760456085,
-0.8426677584648132,
-0.9867818355560303,
-0.16561904549598694,
-0.5121524930000305,
-0.17005474865436554,
0.637546181678772,
-0.026271451264619827,
0.020057110115885735,
-0.11923018842935562,
-0.18180274963378906,
-0.10746324062347412,
0.060335807502269745,
0.04455000162124634,
-0.19682015478610992,
-0.1111559271812439,
0.5299519896507263,
0.2385650873184204,
-0.34744343161582947,
0.10916658490896225,
-0.07201910018920898,
0.3798648715019226,
-0.3172445595264435,
-0.17991802096366882,
-0.4956696927547455,
0.5076866745948792,
0.09956622123718262,
-0.05079413205385208,
0.9999117851257324,
1.0512125492095947,
-0.19329914450645447,
-0.29565921425819397,
-0.3075341582298279,
-0.12242252379655838,
-0.4740496873855591,
0.5614921450614929,
-0.48433542251586914,
-0.8530285954475403,
0.6147302985191345,
-0.014956708066165447,
-0.17177161574363708,
0.7696229219436646,
0.2754782736301422,
-0.5135266184806824,
0.8723840117454529,
0.9297298789024353,
0.108492411673069,
0.44949835538864136,
-0.25562769174575806,
-0.13333851099014282,
-0.7388622760772705,
-0.33556467294692993,
-0.43743863701820374,
-0.24574832618236542,
-0.9098892211914062,
-0.23517243564128876,
0.268336683511734,
0.021372515708208084,
-0.4256533682346344,
0.042766276746988297,
-0.6145297288894653,
0.368796706199646,
0.5519382357597351,
0.4329490661621094,
0.23212899267673492,
-0.049889784306287766,
-0.10294442623853683,
-0.39994996786117554,
-0.5008188486099243,
-0.03417585417628288,
1.0372692346572876,
0.36904215812683105,
0.7443198561668396,
0.08225899189710617,
1.2259336709976196,
0.3133569359779358,
0.6342052817344666,
-0.7961063981056213,
0.21693558990955353,
-0.5417953133583069,
-0.1866157054901123,
-0.08989731967449188,
-0.7310712337493896,
-1.071718454360962,
0.5523439645767212,
-0.5851143598556519,
-0.3487384021282196,
0.22586145997047424,
0.20380841195583344,
-0.0475902333855629,
0.3130757212638855,
-0.7218284010887146,
1.00968599319458,
-0.1990170180797577,
-0.4896641671657562,
-0.18843430280685425,
-0.8584822416305542,
0.4830653667449951,
-0.3133901059627533,
0.18756264448165894,
0.2002256214618683,
-0.22816643118858337,
0.8930023312568665,
0.03903317078948021,
0.8253924250602722,
-0.1622537523508072,
-0.11422664672136307,
0.026115788146853447,
-0.0420224666595459,
0.2134229689836502,
-0.046487972140312195,
-0.13970772922039032,
-0.034656792879104614,
-0.12988948822021484,
-0.49385184049606323,
-0.5278866291046143,
0.6174009442329407,
-0.5044171214103699,
-0.1640436351299286,
-0.590743899345398,
-0.3191554844379425,
-0.16826365888118744,
0.33770179748535156,
0.10273268073797226,
0.2592121362686157,
-0.0928940698504448,
0.5441415905952454,
0.9480998516082764,
-0.5282551050186157,
0.1672445386648178,
-0.06489980220794678,
-0.31186240911483765,
-0.5540015697479248,
1.1815273761749268,
0.0556371808052063,
0.1700184941291809,
0.8237581849098206,
0.516086995601654,
-0.48833513259887695,
-0.5449765920639038,
-0.10121391713619232,
0.24982555210590363,
-1.0386366844177246,
-0.40880289673805237,
-0.5004217624664307,
-0.057528551667928696,
0.14388607442378998,
-0.3095974028110504,
-0.019908800721168518,
-0.3027052581310272,
-0.6759095191955566,
-0.04685337841510773,
-0.02488778717815876,
0.5887835621833801,
-0.08309537172317505,
0.4463197588920593,
-0.5601649284362793,
0.3416750729084015,
0.18476592004299164,
0.550574004650116,
0.06865446269512177,
-0.30757707357406616,
-0.3330700397491455,
-0.18579129874706268,
-0.4650925099849701,
-0.8691049218177795,
0.2100936472415924,
0.3684763014316559,
0.5343343615531921,
0.5707098841667175,
0.2993066608905792,
0.6394360661506653,
-0.2608780264854431,
0.299022912979126,
0.5901681780815125,
-0.636630654335022,
0.19365260004997253,
-0.13865269720554352,
0.3668922781944275,
0.7274256348609924,
0.7314231991767883,
-0.25312334299087524,
-0.4591788649559021,
-0.4546029269695282,
-0.8881415724754333,
0.3337569832801819,
0.20390518009662628,
0.040116894990205765,
-0.0035784831270575523,
0.10528545081615448,
0.25549349188804626,
0.17008015513420105,
-1.306783676147461,
-0.530750572681427,
-0.529314398765564,
-0.3723372519016266,
-0.1071755588054657,
-0.17180612683296204,
0.11613332480192184,
-0.16798652708530426,
0.5450417995452881,
-0.13285987079143524,
0.1516670137643814,
0.05819490924477577,
-0.03821485489606857,
0.5592000484466553,
0.42419150471687317,
0.5342216491699219,
0.048784445971250534,
-0.5376929044723511,
0.4084826111793518,
-0.003053143620491028,
-0.23354698717594147,
0.1500295251607895,
0.4066353440284729,
0.10524101555347443,
-0.03848669305443764,
0.42817285656929016,
0.3765764534473419,
0.32154110074043274,
-0.3802792429924011,
0.5392183065414429,
0.10914801806211472,
-0.4682392179965973,
0.0411282442510128,
-0.349491149187088,
0.1970834583044052,
0.00018902868032455444,
0.5505379438400269,
0.18642070889472961,
0.4855535626411438,
-0.3315286934375763,
0.47097915410995483,
0.3540732264518738,
-0.6789644956588745,
0.2018309235572815,
0.4186277687549591,
0.17587731778621674,
0.21887043118476868,
0.7163010239601135,
-0.3541754186153412,
-0.5340989232063293,
0.5847424864768982,
0.6499654054641724,
0.6069187521934509,
-0.13965444266796112,
0.1981513649225235,
0.5657145977020264,
0.24980323016643524,
0.07406152784824371,
-0.45995476841926575,
-0.19374164938926697,
-0.47755253314971924,
-0.4439181983470917,
-0.3972952663898468,
-0.650687038898468,
-0.0020202919840812683,
-0.8048851490020752,
0.19750583171844482,
-0.3327312469482422,
-0.09766256809234619,
0.23409684002399445,
0.010539178736507893,
-0.5203973054885864,
0.1932423710823059,
0.1643994152545929,
0.6738169193267822,
-0.7149325609207153,
0.6659704446792603,
0.3395814597606659,
-0.38249602913856506,
-0.27175119519233704,
0.042930252850055695,
-0.09169437736272812,
-0.41499200463294983,
0.8819183707237244,
0.9123885631561279,
-0.3798113763332367,
-0.14855721592903137,
-0.34691792726516724,
-0.38742366433143616,
0.7416417002677917,
0.025518663227558136,
-0.47696638107299805,
0.29105672240257263,
0.16405779123306274,
0.6363680958747864,
-0.39172738790512085,
0.06667572259902954,
0.37490224838256836,
0.4842914640903473,
-0.1589355617761612,
-0.4169653058052063,
-0.02628200501203537,
0.025885503739118576,
-0.2641020715236664,
0.5185562372207642,
-0.4998284876346588,
0.7257556915283203,
-0.2861489951610565,
-0.193691685795784,
-0.1333574801683426,
0.7622296214103699,
0.3154076933860779,
0.5739926695823669,
0.39906996488571167,
0.3757675290107727,
0.6109893918037415,
-0.19065923988819122,
0.9016831517219543,
0.12483497709035873,
0.6149519681930542,
0.9128124117851257,
0.026549082249403,
0.9730331301689148,
0.7296068668365479,
-0.23095348477363586,
0.4954398274421692,
0.6871198415756226,
-0.0441853404045105,
0.683823823928833,
0.5953129529953003,
-0.21025748550891876,
-0.15129128098487854,
-0.02119949460029602,
-0.27827852964401245,
0.16205920279026031,
0.5866420865058899,
-0.29086318612098694,
-0.38262641429901123,
0.3240964412689209,
-0.17784589529037476,
0.23198509216308594,
-0.4078729450702667,
0.6239407658576965,
0.20861577987670898,
-0.03366854414343834,
0.7449218034744263,
-0.12921607494354248,
1.197826862335205,
-0.5617144107818604,
-0.3048129677772522,
-0.09195785969495773,
0.3889820873737335,
-0.35798296332359314,
-1.1630332469940186,
0.40406689047813416,
-0.6207722425460815,
-0.1969020813703537,
-0.2468603402376175,
0.5060079097747803,
-0.6942138075828552,
-0.4087110161781311,
0.6674883961677551,
0.11375066637992859,
-0.041740600019693375,
-0.1994592845439911,
-0.8923782706260681,
0.04673777520656586,
-0.08327438682317734,
-0.24584434926509857,
0.5590561032295227,
0.5229753851890564,
0.19178247451782227,
0.7617020010948181,
0.290530264377594,
-0.3365197777748108,
-0.2672383785247803,
0.10772739350795746,
0.7181020379066467,
-0.7776356935501099,
-0.5135175585746765,
-0.8107759356498718,
0.48224079608917236,
-0.16525797545909882,
-0.26399651169776917,
0.48308804631233215,
0.600832462310791,
0.666270911693573,
-0.2239815890789032,
0.4874444901943207,
0.2595454454421997,
0.48294076323509216,
-0.580875813961029,
0.6915672421455383,
-0.8642799854278564,
0.07031399011611938,
-0.4764443337917328,
-0.7987262010574341,
-1.0670742988586426,
0.6521813869476318,
0.08233479410409927,
-0.04283944517374039,
0.8514618873596191,
0.4353504776954651,
-0.10500036925077438,
-0.29665833711624146,
0.36046063899993896,
-0.020653389394283295,
0.35766518115997314,
0.7254588603973389,
0.7718051671981812,
-0.5940924882888794,
1.0011495351791382,
-0.5711085796356201,
-0.14527377486228943,
-0.2984159588813782,
-1.0980573892593384,
-1.0214428901672363,
-0.7506031394004822,
-0.3853876292705536,
-0.35623180866241455,
0.04043111205101013,
0.666609525680542,
0.4913635849952698,
-0.8269861340522766,
-0.051034051924943924,
0.1925157904624939,
0.3147430419921875,
-0.47390931844711304,
-0.2922547459602356,
0.8726081848144531,
-0.3738592863082886,
-0.5418230295181274,
-0.07787070423364639,
0.2287347912788391,
0.42138299345970154,
-0.06613025814294815,
-0.1821480542421341,
-0.20166082680225372,
-0.4109731912612915,
0.9131290316581726,
0.10767191648483276,
-0.4660035967826843,
-0.15880733728408813,
-0.2836421728134155,
-0.1779518872499466,
0.3017621636390686,
0.6468242406845093,
-0.816043496131897,
0.31517601013183594,
0.03191890940070152,
1.0007487535476685,
0.7284131050109863,
-0.07204930484294891,
0.1984979808330536,
-0.9925405979156494,
0.11137857288122177,
0.3063682019710541,
0.3221893906593323,
0.5044233798980713,
-0.033035073429346085,
0.4849095046520233,
0.05641151964664459,
-0.3852843940258026,
-0.7707580924034119,
0.2172280251979828,
-1.34757399559021,
-0.3885349929332733,
0.8326989412307739,
0.04457222670316696,
0.148715078830719,
-0.18572719395160675,
-0.2940787971019745,
-0.010919390246272087,
-0.43864190578460693,
0.6390163898468018,
0.7402845025062561,
-0.3414781987667084,
-0.5235904455184937,
-0.3133985102176666,
0.4744001030921936,
0.3829740881919861,
-0.7084296345710754,
0.1725844442844391,
0.317920982837677,
0.04986468330025673,
0.448043555021286,
0.3762734532356262,
0.1575905680656433,
0.06076466292142868,
0.09772185981273651,
-0.17075160145759583,
-0.10637320578098297,
-0.37672296166419983,
-0.3702835440635681,
0.4619286060333252,
-0.17090222239494324,
-0.15750756859779358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08382v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08382v1
|
Look at the Text: Instruction-Tuned Language Models are More Robust Multiple Choice Selectors than You Think
| 2024-04-12T10:36:15 | 2024-04-12T10:36:15 |
Xinpeng Wang, Chengzhi Hu, Bolei Ma, Paul Röttger, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Multiple choice questions (MCQs) are commonly used to evaluate the
capabilities of large language models (LLMs). One common way to evaluate the
model response is to rank the candidate answers based on the log probability of
the first token prediction. An alternative way is to examine the text output.
Prior work has shown that first token probabilities lack robustness to changes
in MCQ phrasing, and that first token probabilities do not match text answers
for instruction-tuned models. Therefore, in this paper, we investigate the
robustness of text answers. We show that the text answers are more robust to
question perturbations than the first token probabilities, when the first token
answers mismatch the text answers. The difference in robustness increases as
the mismatch rate becomes greater. As the mismatch reaches over 50\%, the text
answer is more robust to option order changes than the debiased first token
probabilities using state-of-the-art debiasing methods such as PriDe. Our
findings provide further evidence for the benefits of text answer evaluation
over first token probability evaluation.
|
[
-0.23786218464374542,
-0.8919522166252136,
0.5451800227165222,
-0.11544721573591232,
-0.3419831693172455,
0.04649341478943825,
-0.027546018362045288,
-0.19138015806674957,
-0.06474023312330246,
0.3670639097690582,
-0.4220443069934845,
-0.43520304560661316,
-0.6809450387954712,
0.16939322650432587,
-0.2814652621746063,
1.0611687898635864,
0.29031577706336975,
0.09020204097032547,
-0.4067801535129547,
-0.19868236780166626,
-0.3399635851383209,
-0.8486921191215515,
-0.7608001828193665,
-0.05114087089896202,
0.5411030650138855,
0.32903775572776794,
1.0206540822982788,
0.6548581123352051,
0.6289064288139343,
0.36712896823883057,
-0.26838937401771545,
0.09150835871696472,
-0.2745327055454254,
0.27066704630851746,
-0.1353594809770584,
-0.5381426215171814,
-0.4771665930747986,
0.07548237591981888,
0.43664127588272095,
0.243389293551445,
0.1293070912361145,
0.36070001125335693,
0.1579820215702057,
0.3103494346141815,
-0.6035621762275696,
-0.19529373943805695,
-1.1367194652557373,
-0.2711690068244934,
-0.14420145750045776,
-0.4767096936702728,
-0.6475784778594971,
-0.2315954566001892,
-0.1052216961979866,
-0.09284660965204239,
-0.06875000894069672,
0.0894082635641098,
0.6832671761512756,
0.49924346804618835,
-0.4576883912086487,
-0.335837721824646,
-0.4411419928073883,
0.9525985717773438,
-0.713469922542572,
0.18391142785549164,
0.5400983691215515,
0.22752812504768372,
-0.09859362989664078,
-0.4542114734649658,
-0.4896460771560669,
-0.31292256712913513,
0.0036158340517431498,
0.11487720161676407,
0.03029879927635193,
0.0952761247754097,
0.08909803628921509,
0.41975781321525574,
-0.5265854597091675,
0.37057796120643616,
0.187835231423378,
-0.48708343505859375,
0.545211911201477,
0.23519015312194824,
0.21969614923000336,
-0.27234724164009094,
-0.4954473376274109,
-0.45746171474456787,
-0.17253707349300385,
0.43311548233032227,
0.6873795986175537,
0.37610864639282227,
0.2762258052825928,
0.8239493370056152,
0.11579641699790955,
0.8719573616981506,
0.1419665664434433,
-0.5120407342910767,
-0.1458623707294464,
-0.6380465626716614,
-0.24703332781791687,
0.004991606809198856,
0.6997934579849243,
0.28563717007637024,
0.2961362898349762,
0.01715671643614769,
-0.08105544745922089,
-0.1742487996816635,
0.3394841253757477,
-0.7344895601272583,
-0.025305068120360374,
0.4178790748119354,
-0.5874609351158142,
-0.6069934964179993,
0.1485287845134735,
-0.6101418733596802,
-0.14780783653259277,
0.0970650166273117,
0.39626994729042053,
-0.37142935395240784,
-0.02744426392018795,
0.05227254703640938,
0.013440839946269989,
0.2470931112766266,
0.0990433320403099,
-1.0916118621826172,
0.10864733159542084,
0.915812611579895,
0.5904210209846497,
-0.45059144496917725,
-0.2287282645702362,
-0.771239161491394,
-0.3616788387298584,
-0.32210031151771545,
0.7180417776107788,
-0.6932022571563721,
-0.32149744033813477,
-0.21260012686252594,
-0.1468472182750702,
-0.2779892086982727,
-0.44744935631752014,
0.9216628074645996,
-0.6454545855522156,
0.18724779784679413,
-0.17941009998321533,
-0.5362874269485474,
0.2867906391620636,
0.3632412850856781,
-0.6301862597465515,
1.0800153017044067,
0.08260281383991241,
-1.2203878164291382,
0.5147356390953064,
-0.09010631591081619,
-0.3071885108947754,
-0.35422590374946594,
-0.10461311787366867,
-0.5427253842353821,
0.0856017917394638,
0.36975669860839844,
0.2590227723121643,
0.16922298073768616,
0.0901334136724472,
-0.6246272921562195,
-0.4280480444431305,
0.8539363741874695,
-1.0697381496429443,
0.8602131009101868,
0.10528895258903503,
-0.11754222214221954,
-0.0043157367035746574,
-0.6969830989837646,
0.5149531364440918,
-0.37506014108657837,
-0.9402871131896973,
-0.3362776041030884,
0.020910514518618584,
-0.14982351660728455,
0.28438177704811096,
0.06164751574397087,
-0.3118109107017517,
0.04309721663594246,
-0.5751373171806335,
0.16146481037139893,
1.1378167867660522,
-0.11141732335090637,
0.2867111563682556,
-0.5502372980117798,
0.6562055945396423,
0.21111983060836792,
0.14208446443080902,
-0.1480761170387268,
-0.6981201171875,
-0.4037201702594757,
-0.24669215083122253,
0.531993567943573,
0.711659848690033,
-0.5879451036453247,
0.26885098218917847,
-0.22551101446151733,
-0.5245198011398315,
-0.5957688093185425,
0.03320259600877762,
0.4747706949710846,
0.49572595953941345,
0.2906703054904938,
-0.10123856365680695,
-0.3631220757961273,
-0.8696941137313843,
-0.793501079082489,
-0.6501083970069885,
-0.02583935856819153,
0.29731619358062744,
0.2995562255382538,
0.10839830338954926,
0.7292294502258301,
-0.2922340929508209,
0.3884240686893463,
-0.0962865948677063,
-0.05219568684697151,
0.28200212121009827,
0.4127792716026306,
0.5767993330955505,
-0.8521504402160645,
-0.42992207407951355,
-0.12336135655641556,
-0.12967173755168915,
0.07213840633630753,
-0.05285247787833214,
-0.4126126170158386,
0.35529574751853943,
0.19615954160690308,
-0.5995602607727051,
0.3600842356681824,
0.4702865481376648,
-0.5012697577476501,
0.6767033934593201,
0.1354115903377533,
0.37745875120162964,
-1.1184556484222412,
0.01480129174888134,
-0.3354701101779938,
-0.28171607851982117,
-0.39138808846473694,
0.07684889435768127,
-0.1235179603099823,
0.2612140476703644,
-0.43927866220474243,
0.5290489792823792,
0.05623342841863632,
-0.09837819635868073,
-0.046232182532548904,
0.16132058203220367,
-0.07934708893299103,
0.1516214907169342,
-0.3784024119377136,
1.0801420211791992,
0.35674750804901123,
-0.729375958442688,
-0.02410101890563965,
0.3798328936100006,
-0.3341248035430908,
0.3236069083213806,
-0.5117897391319275,
0.27842921018600464,
-0.16522619128227234,
-0.2308020442724228,
-1.3488688468933105,
-0.21925151348114014,
-0.08984322100877762,
-0.7961346507072449,
0.36017897725105286,
0.032629478722810745,
-0.3719681203365326,
-0.35262683033943176,
-0.4970042407512665,
0.16844168305397034,
0.1566128432750702,
-0.40373095870018005,
0.30441710352897644,
0.24858121573925018,
-0.2274424284696579,
-1.0987378358840942,
-0.8625905513763428,
-0.1386507898569107,
-0.1242939680814743,
-0.36368873715400696,
0.1744314581155777,
-0.5661230087280273,
-0.3530290126800537,
-0.2280576080083847,
-0.5674846172332764,
-0.2133268564939499,
0.6037161350250244,
-0.07503164559602737,
0.3894842863082886,
-0.3409558832645416,
0.21341794729232788,
0.10552050173282623,
-0.008085138164460659,
-0.09210588783025742,
-0.22019505500793457,
0.5216588973999023,
-0.009994062595069408,
-0.5772324800491333,
-0.20088905096054077,
0.2991349697113037,
0.7708230018615723,
-0.12286075204610825,
0.8997020125389099,
0.41318628191947937,
-0.14008839428424835,
0.10579383373260498,
-0.31822171807289124,
-0.08840091526508331,
-0.49796062707901,
0.47745802998542786,
-0.45882007479667664,
-1.040482997894287,
0.29690486192703247,
0.508568286895752,
0.24776874482631683,
0.4738057255744934,
0.7734023928642273,
-0.037253230810165405,
1.3816238641738892,
0.4605569541454315,
0.07895433157682419,
0.3537086546421051,
0.5098002552986145,
0.2344105988740921,
-0.46738335490226746,
-0.02166212536394596,
-0.9681996703147888,
-0.4130885601043701,
-0.8480491638183594,
-0.22771598398685455,
0.21702808141708374,
0.2597831189632416,
-0.3242255449295044,
0.16893360018730164,
-0.6195536851882935,
0.4979652464389801,
0.6629502773284912,
0.0921873077750206,
0.3834719955921173,
0.13534387946128845,
-0.5290824174880981,
-0.16623756289482117,
-0.7057456970214844,
-0.9651281237602234,
1.2167845964431763,
0.2308916300535202,
0.7383025288581848,
0.16513951122760773,
0.575878918170929,
0.022993523627519608,
0.3421477973461151,
-0.7264408469200134,
0.549392580986023,
-0.370800644159317,
-0.8343015909194946,
-0.45972514152526855,
-0.3998796343803406,
-0.7549661993980408,
0.2364269495010376,
-0.4326103925704956,
-0.9227818250656128,
-0.05350898206233978,
0.20533373951911926,
-0.38950151205062866,
0.2597576975822449,
-0.5051509737968445,
0.749026894569397,
-0.42363569140434265,
-0.28909826278686523,
0.39490148425102234,
-0.4160124957561493,
0.24684584140777588,
-0.08065623790025711,
0.06318726390600204,
0.19291076064109802,
-0.13624055683612823,
0.6559807658195496,
-0.14270099997520447,
0.5366619229316711,
0.2765183746814728,
-0.18870961666107178,
0.37343913316726685,
0.12411165982484818,
0.281356543302536,
0.3117968738079071,
-0.6716405749320984,
-0.34032365679740906,
0.20825736224651337,
-0.376335084438324,
-0.5688318610191345,
0.7904635071754456,
-0.6734247803688049,
-0.8369742035865784,
-0.14219175279140472,
-0.31650346517562866,
-0.24964337050914764,
0.22373183071613312,
0.5349239110946655,
0.5477129220962524,
0.07350228726863861,
0.28805309534072876,
0.6554238200187683,
-0.36972832679748535,
0.7023073434829712,
0.1381167322397232,
-0.2238723188638687,
-0.5209195613861084,
0.3606325089931488,
0.11376930773258209,
0.42501547932624817,
0.5970408916473389,
0.29774925112724304,
-0.47635963559150696,
-0.451743483543396,
-0.48947447538375854,
-0.22828136384487152,
-0.9722030758857727,
-0.32793062925338745,
-0.7419050931930542,
-0.12921588122844696,
-0.3571140766143799,
-0.07825947552919388,
-0.09422452002763748,
-0.5248600244522095,
-0.3500917851924896,
-0.4573993682861328,
0.03633102774620056,
0.3762321472167969,
0.39474236965179443,
0.011407577432692051,
-0.7133897542953491,
0.13785547018051147,
0.5828936696052551,
0.461548388004303,
-0.15283642709255219,
-0.541747510433197,
-0.004291559103876352,
0.07852581143379211,
-0.42935502529144287,
-1.1104456186294556,
-0.06938625127077103,
0.26902902126312256,
0.7191726565361023,
0.33608120679855347,
0.13075193762779236,
0.6388198733329773,
-0.2462538480758667,
0.9559931755065918,
-0.16709193587303162,
-0.7449480891227722,
0.5181759595870972,
-0.04848256707191467,
0.4026365876197815,
0.9657000303268433,
0.28561511635780334,
0.13672353327274323,
-0.6652741432189941,
-0.5712965130805969,
-0.5324100852012634,
0.6058523654937744,
0.2100929319858551,
0.4985509216785431,
-0.4299105703830719,
0.4262583553791046,
0.2720469534397125,
0.30041810870170593,
-0.8396749496459961,
-0.40323421359062195,
-0.1388363242149353,
-0.37959811091423035,
-0.09404698759317398,
-0.3988268971443176,
0.2273801863193512,
-0.13158608973026276,
0.6608029007911682,
-0.1743476837873459,
0.24038444459438324,
0.2074768990278244,
0.10339769721031189,
-0.033206939697265625,
0.5877505540847778,
0.5974945425987244,
0.4472295343875885,
-0.07034723460674286,
0.4001162350177765,
0.1888187676668167,
-0.6410816311836243,
0.15787647664546967,
-0.16723954677581787,
-0.3019563555717468,
0.19609792530536652,
0.5151298642158508,
0.7472798228263855,
0.2214561253786087,
-0.6003921031951904,
0.5866895318031311,
-0.25680193305015564,
-0.03894065320491791,
0.27486440539360046,
0.3780718147754669,
-0.12979674339294434,
-0.05886538699269295,
0.35294046998023987,
0.337779700756073,
0.03174858167767525,
-0.6360031366348267,
0.38002994656562805,
0.6694691181182861,
-0.45855894684791565,
-0.030379364266991615,
0.9274974465370178,
-0.19019512832164764,
-0.6383880972862244,
0.370719850063324,
-0.061964984983205795,
-0.787822961807251,
0.768579363822937,
0.722814679145813,
0.6577689051628113,
-0.1974400132894516,
0.3242519795894623,
0.4749051630496979,
0.5025901198387146,
0.006369010079652071,
0.46828827261924744,
0.09190838038921356,
-0.5424206852912903,
-0.4705237150192261,
-0.8781276345252991,
-0.27282872796058655,
0.1532890647649765,
-0.5659358501434326,
0.37433433532714844,
-0.3180835247039795,
-0.6134861707687378,
-0.16664621233940125,
-0.058013953268527985,
-0.5511400699615479,
0.35395097732543945,
-0.056710612028837204,
0.9728788733482361,
-0.6316851377487183,
0.47435513138771057,
0.929709255695343,
-0.10697739571332932,
-0.8993018865585327,
0.30896511673927307,
-0.3797153830528259,
-0.6201148629188538,
0.29697877168655396,
0.30362948775291443,
-0.1600707769393921,
0.04185131564736366,
-0.6841601729393005,
-0.8645457625389099,
0.8579027056694031,
0.642124354839325,
-0.24511078000068665,
0.251193642616272,
0.1704990714788437,
0.5427950024604797,
-0.16507259011268616,
0.5712848901748657,
0.4573717415332794,
0.38347128033638,
-0.06504976004362106,
-0.8736960291862488,
-0.12871482968330383,
-0.04893112927675247,
-0.06487856805324554,
0.08486143499612808,
-0.5088924765586853,
0.9313322901725769,
-0.34717026352882385,
-0.2781940996646881,
0.2033008635044098,
0.46455612778663635,
0.2988688349723816,
0.28767842054367065,
0.4262370467185974,
0.4310571551322937,
0.8733921647071838,
-0.1374891698360443,
1.1887532472610474,
-0.3458404242992401,
0.41594356298446655,
1.0660098791122437,
-0.022656580433249474,
1.1387841701507568,
0.6060441136360168,
-0.2887010872364044,
0.5145048499107361,
0.7479405999183655,
0.3689243793487549,
0.42134034633636475,
0.15112005174160004,
-0.014816723763942719,
-0.672693133354187,
0.28610455989837646,
-0.06174188107252121,
0.727300226688385,
-0.1278999298810959,
-0.38014453649520874,
0.007119585759937763,
-0.17376500368118286,
0.08385879546403885,
0.2943686842918396,
-0.314959853887558,
0.7577989101409912,
-0.04845781251788139,
-1.089624285697937,
0.5330417156219482,
0.005825905594974756,
0.6038628220558167,
-0.3144685626029968,
0.18636251986026764,
-0.2650471329689026,
0.06613561511039734,
-0.1727190911769867,
-0.9870216846466064,
0.2391950786113739,
0.15397602319717407,
-0.2941531538963318,
0.0650179460644722,
0.8264046311378479,
-0.17346231639385223,
-0.6390034556388855,
-0.06962801516056061,
0.49652087688446045,
-0.06001066043972969,
0.22715391218662262,
-0.6285169124603271,
-0.11049547046422958,
-0.05994743853807449,
-0.38069361448287964,
0.40303537249565125,
0.2339116632938385,
0.10300622880458832,
0.7589331269264221,
0.5817634463310242,
-0.2154902070760727,
0.26725730299949646,
-0.3114809989929199,
0.6214582920074463,
-0.24041154980659485,
-0.42075103521347046,
-1.2434579133987427,
0.6420213580131531,
-0.09367209672927856,
-0.5648719668388367,
0.7308201789855957,
0.3887459933757782,
0.6888857483863831,
-0.04494167119264603,
0.6298222541809082,
0.12621812522411346,
0.43461403250694275,
-0.6162643432617188,
0.5201643705368042,
-0.44756019115448,
0.4264366626739502,
-0.37478673458099365,
-0.8217918276786804,
-0.2519807517528534,
0.4168899953365326,
-0.08289220929145813,
0.15588438510894775,
0.651826798915863,
0.6826643347740173,
0.046907689422369,
-0.14302922785282135,
0.39943912625312805,
0.00733407074585557,
-0.05243436619639397,
0.4167116582393646,
0.6753061413764954,
-0.5327482223510742,
0.8104340434074402,
0.09979339689016342,
-0.10873787105083466,
-0.10293444246053696,
-0.9869344234466553,
-1.0468690395355225,
-0.4152432978153229,
-0.19154369831085205,
-0.3902844190597534,
-0.15495887398719788,
0.7493712902069092,
0.38007888197898865,
-0.9532174468040466,
0.25435909628868103,
0.13093723356723785,
0.48066818714141846,
-0.2658079266548157,
-0.22678597271442413,
0.32995131611824036,
-0.32890748977661133,
-0.6487234830856323,
0.19586147367954254,
0.2230614423751831,
0.12893462181091309,
-0.046002957969903946,
0.12156590074300766,
-0.17265138030052185,
0.5150693655014038,
0.4497325122356415,
-0.1989840865135193,
-0.6083806157112122,
-0.6168456673622131,
0.485561728477478,
-0.39606785774230957,
0.09898294508457184,
0.5164567232131958,
-0.6695240139961243,
0.44679906964302063,
0.3633306622505188,
0.8869627118110657,
-0.15565238893032074,
0.37296566367149353,
0.2968469560146332,
-0.8709953427314758,
-0.08539333939552307,
0.1858970820903778,
0.16696111857891083,
0.25150761008262634,
-0.4527754485607147,
0.17051498591899872,
-0.26660019159317017,
-0.7480260133743286,
-0.933943510055542,
0.353656530380249,
-0.802914559841156,
-0.2264702022075653,
1.1588836908340454,
-0.05572345480322838,
-0.12597833573818207,
-0.034266140311956406,
-0.3002707064151764,
0.2532528042793274,
0.01631104201078415,
0.7953172326087952,
1.16526198387146,
0.08086370676755905,
-0.09252162277698517,
-0.5013117790222168,
0.43247535824775696,
0.5448431968688965,
-0.6617595553398132,
-0.1390741914510727,
0.09149356186389923,
0.19588999450206757,
0.0735684260725975,
0.6782244443893433,
-0.12404122948646545,
0.21080005168914795,
-0.057754624634981155,
-0.7633404731750488,
0.08256499469280243,
-0.172768697142601,
-0.35380569100379944,
0.3552580773830414,
0.5232661366462708,
-0.18269753456115723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08368v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08368v1
|
ASR advancements for indigenous languages: Quechua, Guarani, Bribri, Kotiria, and Wa'ikhana
| 2024-04-12T10:12:38 | 2024-04-12T10:12:38 |
Monica Romero, Sandra Gomez, Iván G. Torre
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Indigenous languages are a fundamental legacy in the development of human
communication, embodying the unique identity and culture of local communities
of America. The Second AmericasNLP Competition Track 1 of NeurIPS 2022 proposed
developing automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems for five indigenous
languages: Quechua, Guarani, Bribri, Kotiria, and Wa'ikhana. In this paper, we
propose a reliable ASR model for each target language by crawling speech
corpora spanning diverse sources and applying data augmentation methods that
resulted in the winning approach in this competition. To achieve this, we
systematically investigated the impact of different hyperparameters by a
Bayesian search on the performance of the language models, specifically
focusing on the variants of the Wav2vec2.0 XLS-R model: 300M and 1B parameters.
Moreover, we performed a global sensitivity analysis to assess the contribution
of various hyperparametric configurations to the performances of our best
models. Importantly, our results show that freeze fine-tuning updates and
dropout rate are more vital parameters than the total number of epochs of lr.
Additionally, we liberate our best models -- with no other ASR model reported
until now for two Wa'ikhana and Kotiria -- and the many experiments performed
to pave the way to other researchers to continue improving ASR in minority
languages. This insight opens up interesting avenues for future work, allowing
for the advancement of ASR techniques in the preservation of minority
indigenous and acknowledging the complexities involved in this important
endeavour.
|
[
-0.23311559855937958,
-0.39260753989219666,
0.15827497839927673,
0.291572630405426,
-0.06531094759702682,
0.29163089394569397,
-0.40394654870033264,
-0.7273226380348206,
-0.14162085950374603,
0.4722119867801666,
-0.09841903299093246,
-0.3602179288864136,
-0.6180208921432495,
0.3410521149635315,
-0.5231276154518127,
0.5263275504112244,
0.21881332993507385,
-0.127464160323143,
0.2047840803861618,
-0.3866928219795227,
-0.45970943570137024,
-0.4775371253490448,
-0.7243854999542236,
-0.4041684865951538,
0.43013063073158264,
0.30148568749427795,
0.8170337677001953,
0.7831299901008606,
0.5700984597206116,
0.2673071026802063,
-0.5064351558685303,
-0.06412975490093231,
0.1065765917301178,
0.1360691636800766,
-0.12602916359901428,
-0.43051186203956604,
-0.12726588547229767,
-0.2600657343864441,
0.741576075553894,
0.614665687084198,
-0.44264712929725647,
0.0904901772737503,
-0.11188237369060516,
0.31460511684417725,
-0.6926189064979553,
0.17934373021125793,
-0.6520389914512634,
0.0240750964730978,
-0.41730114817619324,
-0.033687617629766464,
-0.09469243884086609,
-0.6042811274528503,
0.3948294520378113,
-0.3572341799736023,
0.2265750914812088,
-0.18961162865161896,
0.8227713704109192,
0.3611133098602295,
-0.18799316883087158,
-0.3270888924598694,
-0.8214048147201538,
0.6955401301383972,
-1.0733364820480347,
0.6603056192398071,
0.4721732437610626,
0.3127325475215912,
0.023419097065925598,
-0.6010317802429199,
-0.4917883574962616,
-0.13709580898284912,
0.18865297734737396,
0.0006144074141047895,
-0.600686252117157,
-0.0707794576883316,
0.14912666380405426,
0.28481218218803406,
-0.7356738448143005,
0.5441835522651672,
-0.6361969113349915,
-0.35079264640808105,
0.6431106328964233,
0.11043781787157059,
0.27067163586616516,
-0.009160053916275501,
-0.11451704800128937,
-0.08795713633298874,
-0.4689154028892517,
0.154915452003479,
0.36814767122268677,
0.5979240536689758,
-0.20632822811603546,
0.4796017110347748,
-0.5036047697067261,
0.8148107528686523,
-0.18346896767616272,
-0.34097597002983093,
0.2851284146308899,
-0.16119076311588287,
0.19471465051174164,
0.09424492716789246,
0.8302658796310425,
0.03875800967216492,
0.12569737434387207,
-0.3043031692504883,
-0.00038191641215234995,
0.3796059489250183,
-0.16520890593528748,
-0.5128169655799866,
-0.25742876529693604,
0.12066078186035156,
-0.40566474199295044,
0.0938512459397316,
-0.30165860056877136,
-0.6815100312232971,
-0.13349318504333496,
-0.3940047025680542,
0.43659886717796326,
-0.41565603017807007,
-0.413097083568573,
0.17230939865112305,
-0.25206759572029114,
0.32847267389297485,
0.16016411781311035,
-0.8370977640151978,
0.46040958166122437,
0.5974782109260559,
0.8376438617706299,
-0.24559514224529266,
-0.49367040395736694,
-0.5065661668777466,
0.03654506430029869,
-0.18578588962554932,
0.8127784132957458,
-0.9360013008117676,
-0.38630861043930054,
0.12624236941337585,
-0.2780241370201111,
-0.21600574254989624,
-0.7350385189056396,
0.7801008820533752,
-0.6694869995117188,
-0.184906005859375,
-0.38573750853538513,
-0.15787100791931152,
-0.3239564001560211,
-0.03341689705848694,
-0.49714046716690063,
0.9281467199325562,
-0.09760598838329315,
-0.4669400751590729,
0.31005316972732544,
-0.6481664180755615,
-0.48945140838623047,
0.21274277567863464,
0.06601627171039581,
-0.3709414303302765,
0.09745053946971893,
0.16654072701931,
0.050789568573236465,
-0.4828207194805145,
0.15314829349517822,
-0.06914439052343369,
-0.4289843738079071,
0.2706042528152466,
-0.4844873249530792,
0.7750361561775208,
0.3681737184524536,
-0.34444454312324524,
-0.08522378653287888,
-0.8865358829498291,
0.1944882869720459,
-0.13672354817390442,
-0.7671965956687927,
-0.1682567596435547,
0.05106876790523529,
0.11900003999471664,
0.0797930583357811,
0.06504960358142853,
-0.6965060234069824,
-0.15313784778118134,
-0.3118031322956085,
0.679172933101654,
0.25961846113204956,
-0.012077735736966133,
0.21074412763118744,
0.049146804958581924,
0.4245987832546234,
-0.07251599431037903,
0.13348819315433502,
-0.17264202237129211,
-0.6672322750091553,
-0.6578817963600159,
-0.07320620864629745,
0.6315211057662964,
0.49512478709220886,
-0.26778000593185425,
0.23289699852466583,
-0.2687240242958069,
-0.5650820732116699,
-0.6639273762702942,
-0.17717264592647552,
0.4844990372657776,
0.5088562369346619,
0.44928956031799316,
-0.5290722250938416,
-0.6265506148338318,
-0.6700191497802734,
-0.13101769983768463,
-0.39959853887557983,
-0.08610577136278152,
0.08009015768766403,
0.17996349930763245,
-0.49725714325904846,
0.9164968729019165,
-0.244944229722023,
-0.1148819774389267,
-0.0420403853058815,
0.2816524803638458,
0.14898982644081116,
0.48377862572669983,
0.210031658411026,
-0.7700731754302979,
-0.4775264859199524,
0.2242152839899063,
-0.40788891911506653,
-0.1580275297164917,
0.36203616857528687,
0.28329330682754517,
0.2839024066925049,
0.22904284298419952,
-0.4788602590560913,
0.5393959879875183,
0.5430495738983154,
-0.017397958785295486,
0.4950900971889496,
-0.21525131165981293,
0.16051322221755981,
-0.4894176423549652,
0.2040666788816452,
-0.018661729991436005,
0.26126572489738464,
-0.7282387018203735,
0.3375450372695923,
0.19675439596176147,
-0.3651697635650635,
-0.10733957588672638,
0.3828287720680237,
-0.3653436005115509,
-0.1232595220208168,
-0.42973756790161133,
-0.16820105910301208,
-0.4648653566837311,
0.2869930863380432,
0.5171326994895935,
0.5832780003547668,
0.6395769715309143,
-0.752045214176178,
0.23868755996227264,
0.4203159809112549,
-0.15075692534446716,
0.21058408915996552,
-0.9384726285934448,
0.3884648382663727,
-0.017474379390478134,
0.05264055356383324,
-0.7113713026046753,
-0.1480177491903305,
0.16546182334423065,
-0.7684901356697083,
0.2332805097103119,
-0.4866218864917755,
-0.5125547051429749,
-0.4479314982891083,
0.25904685258865356,
0.31232091784477234,
0.5316223502159119,
-0.4887106120586395,
0.5001410841941833,
0.47214236855506897,
-0.5256316661834717,
-0.5646445155143738,
-0.6060915589332581,
0.3744775950908661,
-0.416208952665329,
-0.44163084030151367,
0.11894284933805466,
-0.03629370033740997,
-0.20710815489292145,
-0.3034660816192627,
-0.040087778121232986,
-0.1430753469467163,
-0.16275432705879211,
0.15683911740779877,
0.06445100903511047,
-0.34943482279777527,
-0.21875466406345367,
0.13634929060935974,
-0.328083872795105,
-0.03273136168718338,
-0.37393873929977417,
0.7574405670166016,
-0.21611252427101135,
-0.2596428096294403,
-0.5207414031028748,
0.3181610405445099,
0.4148479402065277,
-0.8639054298400879,
0.3131799101829529,
0.6991867423057556,
-0.5387156009674072,
0.36593949794769287,
-0.9764145016670227,
0.08924245089292526,
-0.4324395954608917,
0.16127699613571167,
-0.4021041989326477,
-0.6953302025794983,
0.7621173858642578,
0.1932620406150818,
-0.1058727577328682,
0.1764879822731018,
0.42433837056159973,
0.4831976294517517,
0.9227263331413269,
0.5381002426147461,
-0.3657313883304596,
0.2361324280500412,
-0.23890501260757446,
0.09503652900457382,
-0.9914276003837585,
-0.3489548861980438,
-1.0104153156280518,
-0.0014137803809717298,
-0.7753767967224121,
-0.4472264349460602,
0.42748090624809265,
-0.2679794430732727,
-0.042638808488845825,
0.6503171324729919,
-0.319687157869339,
0.3318924605846405,
0.9007477164268494,
-0.0595904104411602,
0.40494516491889954,
0.05441674962639809,
0.056546103209257126,
-0.148935467004776,
-0.6310286521911621,
-0.37534967064857483,
0.9958643317222595,
0.3672381043434143,
0.7128543853759766,
0.15217046439647675,
0.6083882451057434,
0.1732224076986313,
-0.1653755009174347,
-0.587175190448761,
0.3125697672367096,
-0.12278224527835846,
-0.5847026109695435,
-0.4759490489959717,
-0.301093190908432,
-1.0124167203903198,
0.20559503138065338,
0.09700779616832733,
-0.8978031277656555,
0.6925385594367981,
-0.00947487447410822,
-0.618613600730896,
-0.00663519324734807,
-0.3213900327682495,
0.5274088382720947,
-0.05746731162071228,
-0.2318805456161499,
-0.21161936223506927,
-1.022607445716858,
-0.10607977211475372,
0.09808848053216934,
0.09632578492164612,
-0.1328698694705963,
-0.09850148111581802,
0.5876711010932922,
-0.11415242403745651,
0.4827544093132019,
-0.2039242386817932,
0.03002406843006611,
0.4068181812763214,
-0.0049487529322505,
0.415134459733963,
-0.02284736931324005,
-0.5153258442878723,
0.29353031516075134,
-0.06735305488109589,
-0.3106442093849182,
-0.3174593150615692,
0.5064383745193481,
-0.6660594940185547,
-0.21846497058868408,
-0.3721713423728943,
-0.5449389815330505,
-0.08817432820796967,
0.2027847021818161,
0.31177639961242676,
0.5357894897460938,
0.12376736849546432,
0.23295314610004425,
0.5861896276473999,
-0.15850558876991272,
0.5481679439544678,
0.9446244239807129,
0.19064220786094666,
-0.5338947176933289,
1.0289417505264282,
0.35606005787849426,
0.13753193616867065,
0.30466148257255554,
0.35014504194259644,
-0.525471031665802,
-1.1290929317474365,
-0.41764968633651733,
0.13025715947151184,
-0.4585171937942505,
-0.2897355556488037,
-0.888294517993927,
-0.1666850447654724,
-0.5888060927391052,
0.08554720878601074,
-0.22990180552005768,
-0.45689013600349426,
-0.1657518744468689,
0.048298660665750504,
0.1719362884759903,
0.44830358028411865,
-0.42650967836380005,
0.34054234623908997,
-0.7185465693473816,
0.1966453641653061,
0.35368308424949646,
0.16285085678100586,
0.10862183570861816,
-0.7923507690429688,
-0.13411755859851837,
0.12320241332054138,
-0.18484097719192505,
-0.5952354073524475,
0.7787714004516602,
0.5053516030311584,
0.5791085958480835,
0.36251869797706604,
0.010855134576559067,
0.8220507502555847,
-0.39221397042274475,
0.48070386052131653,
-0.045537449419498444,
-0.8003494143486023,
0.7349494695663452,
-0.5026598572731018,
0.38186877965927124,
0.5088697075843811,
0.3616340756416321,
-0.6392959356307983,
-0.4446725845336914,
-0.43887096643447876,
-0.9288046956062317,
0.5623995661735535,
0.14331449568271637,
0.153116375207901,
0.06398075073957443,
0.3467836380004883,
0.2752709984779358,
0.20602081716060638,
-0.436201810836792,
-0.0768498107790947,
-0.05378441512584686,
0.06836295872926712,
0.08285734057426453,
-0.023952575400471687,
0.20794662833213806,
-0.24528108537197113,
0.543624222278595,
-0.13138878345489502,
0.041554566472768784,
0.18697920441627502,
-0.10412769764661789,
-0.23369979858398438,
0.1951313465833664,
0.23139484226703644,
0.6128420829772949,
-0.13097847998142242,
-0.06412824243307114,
0.2744689881801605,
-0.5968432426452637,
0.022770697250962257,
0.5423569083213806,
-0.5162582397460938,
0.0924067571759224,
0.13860155642032623,
0.8252192735671997,
0.15891143679618835,
-0.751860499382019,
-0.046724408864974976,
-0.015498717315495014,
0.20665699243545532,
-0.4129820168018341,
0.08709057420492172,
-0.10684750229120255,
0.3238200843334198,
0.7466986775398254,
0.33746588230133057,
0.6528598070144653,
-0.7143966555595398,
-0.0025308707263320684,
0.24961704015731812,
-0.42597496509552,
-0.47577136754989624,
0.8087776303291321,
0.07127028703689575,
-0.5631665587425232,
0.745361328125,
-0.13619185984134674,
-0.6579645872116089,
0.5241748094558716,
0.7886399030685425,
0.5689191818237305,
-0.5741141438484192,
0.12336693704128265,
0.6101890206336975,
0.2506174147129059,
-0.2539183497428894,
0.15948443114757538,
-0.17364384233951569,
-0.5340352654457092,
-0.2301144152879715,
-0.7447355389595032,
-0.6950287222862244,
-0.020315933972597122,
-0.9141279458999634,
0.287180632352829,
-0.18921153247356415,
-0.21741043031215668,
0.10827436298131943,
0.15729868412017822,
-0.5657989382743835,
0.4272153973579407,
0.3713749349117279,
0.7639831304550171,
-0.8503203988075256,
0.5998817682266235,
0.5491639971733093,
-0.3539051115512848,
-0.5970122218132019,
0.06800186634063721,
-0.025137832388281822,
-0.6030139923095703,
0.23233869671821594,
-0.05956968665122986,
0.018643757328391075,
0.11923997104167938,
-0.2563033699989319,
-1.3967963457107544,
0.8896461725234985,
0.26548638939857483,
-0.46253687143325806,
-0.1518407166004181,
0.25260812044143677,
0.7639703750610352,
-0.148101806640625,
0.31760674715042114,
0.9391873478889465,
0.40048131346702576,
0.14550986886024475,
-1.2833129167556763,
-0.2081453800201416,
-0.36387383937835693,
0.2795969247817993,
0.0930778980255127,
-0.7980371117591858,
0.5637236833572388,
-0.5303912162780762,
-0.189993754029274,
0.5473711490631104,
0.7914406061172485,
0.5436466932296753,
0.4787764847278595,
0.09642720222473145,
0.4940013587474823,
0.5947185754776001,
-0.15278439223766327,
0.7914627194404602,
-0.08755670487880707,
-0.08722710609436035,
1.111038327217102,
-0.2204761952161789,
1.1199254989624023,
0.15159127116203308,
-0.5548916459083557,
0.3548583388328552,
0.5764596462249756,
-0.0605504997074604,
0.3323056697845459,
0.0963117852807045,
-0.24986103177070618,
0.05533448979258537,
-0.3744506537914276,
-0.49839770793914795,
0.8029999732971191,
0.4494556486606598,
-0.0313139446079731,
0.17538976669311523,
0.014159281738102436,
0.007902424782514572,
0.14289020001888275,
-0.184944286942482,
0.5411165952682495,
-0.16293303668498993,
-0.6038475632667542,
0.5890750885009766,
0.12364400923252106,
0.8524292707443237,
-0.6485142111778259,
0.1751682460308075,
-0.2236408293247223,
-0.01063908077776432,
-0.2890467047691345,
-0.31999772787094116,
0.2557774782180786,
0.18624627590179443,
-0.02456315979361534,
0.47130918502807617,
0.6145886778831482,
-0.5012567043304443,
-0.49445465207099915,
0.29411110281944275,
0.21545755863189697,
0.20067550241947174,
-0.1226402297616005,
-0.33049333095550537,
0.5162465572357178,
-0.24139747023582458,
0.23712627589702606,
0.14091967046260834,
0.14600326120853424,
-0.07024842500686646,
0.8452076315879822,
0.7176355719566345,
0.3355935513973236,
0.4372091591358185,
0.19912534952163696,
0.7223283648490906,
-0.47899118065834045,
-0.3753611743450165,
-0.49600738286972046,
0.4776316285133362,
0.12056824564933777,
-0.31028634309768677,
0.8061484098434448,
0.8810644149780273,
0.7871128916740417,
0.03641078248620033,
0.8207933902740479,
-0.1301657259464264,
0.8429961800575256,
-0.28534552454948425,
0.5596147179603577,
-0.04920767620205879,
0.08344576507806778,
-0.5218387842178345,
-0.8719733953475952,
-0.29650965332984924,
0.44096189737319946,
-0.28956371545791626,
-0.17479144036769867,
0.1739855855703354,
0.6962296962738037,
-0.035939380526542664,
-0.012754478491842747,
0.13531701266765594,
0.09174584597349167,
0.19106154143810272,
0.207840695977211,
0.8048740029335022,
-0.7137172222137451,
0.8106947541236877,
-0.3411002457141876,
-0.1394987404346466,
-0.03220284357666969,
-0.4011114239692688,
-0.26904797554016113,
-0.6279924511909485,
-0.6610428094863892,
-0.04769998416304588,
0.3618714213371277,
0.7863304615020752,
0.6774842739105225,
-1.0279057025909424,
-0.4911150336265564,
0.002198926405981183,
-0.14663131535053253,
-0.3082211911678314,
-0.1845303177833557,
0.15715178847312927,
-0.10793834924697876,
-0.9131626486778259,
0.624097466468811,
0.2890333831310272,
0.08271340280771255,
0.05779711529612541,
-0.265394926071167,
-0.08278278261423111,
-0.08095240592956543,
0.5299116969108582,
0.8911283016204834,
-0.817221999168396,
-0.14889535307884216,
0.09805316478013992,
0.31046298146247864,
0.09990924596786499,
0.5836426019668579,
-0.8261753916740417,
0.5426516532897949,
0.31830400228500366,
0.37988442182540894,
0.5095426440238953,
0.018981873989105225,
0.6703993082046509,
-0.2318056970834732,
0.19899918138980865,
0.4902907609939575,
0.16958574950695038,
0.5191458463668823,
0.030036384239792824,
0.6668272614479065,
0.10722179710865021,
-0.5770969986915588,
-1.1475834846496582,
0.1393980234861374,
-0.6384431719779968,
0.3483773171901703,
1.0172092914581299,
-0.12941785156726837,
0.22321082651615143,
-0.4205402135848999,
-0.13198772072792053,
0.32039815187454224,
-0.5385271310806274,
0.8055076003074646,
0.24004365503787994,
-0.20560571551322937,
-0.2721776068210602,
-0.45940420031547546,
0.2723233997821808,
0.31292909383773804,
-0.4527806341648102,
-0.05378188192844391,
0.44584277272224426,
0.29348596930503845,
0.3959681987762451,
0.44675567746162415,
-0.3178088366985321,
0.466521680355072,
0.0868692696094513,
-0.12871968746185303,
0.27231156826019287,
-0.38115525245666504,
-0.5747557878494263,
-0.008834833279252052,
0.3200952410697937,
-0.0768146812915802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08359v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08359v1
|
Improving Health Question Answering with Reliable and Time-Aware Evidence Retrieval
| 2024-04-12T09:56:12 | 2024-04-12T09:56:12 |
Juraj Vladika, Florian Matthes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
In today's digital world, seeking answers to health questions on the Internet
is a common practice. However, existing question answering (QA) systems often
rely on using pre-selected and annotated evidence documents, thus making them
inadequate for addressing novel questions. Our study focuses on the open-domain
QA setting, where the key challenge is to first uncover relevant evidence in
large knowledge bases. By utilizing the common retrieve-then-read QA pipeline
and PubMed as a trustworthy collection of medical research documents, we answer
health questions from three diverse datasets. We modify different retrieval
settings to observe their influence on the QA pipeline's performance, including
the number of retrieved documents, sentence selection process, the publication
year of articles, and their number of citations. Our results reveal that
cutting down on the amount of retrieved documents and favoring more recent and
highly cited documents can improve the final macro F1 score up to 10%. We
discuss the results, highlight interesting examples, and outline challenges for
future research, like managing evidence disagreement and crafting user-friendly
explanations.
|
[
-0.19884338974952698,
-0.6983155608177185,
1.0863800048828125,
-0.15874533355236053,
-0.37028762698173523,
-0.0686434730887413,
0.1768142580986023,
-0.700238823890686,
0.4325549006462097,
0.26918432116508484,
-0.25451552867889404,
-0.32137858867645264,
-0.7005213499069214,
0.24496790766716003,
-0.046261660754680634,
0.8828072547912598,
-0.05291648954153061,
0.0834822952747345,
-0.4012215733528137,
-0.30596503615379333,
-0.021782351657748222,
-0.3630577623844147,
-0.5006009936332703,
-0.2251368910074234,
0.7452247738838196,
0.3530270457267761,
0.7617862224578857,
0.5212347507476807,
0.8449759483337402,
0.08018800616264343,
-0.11913066357374191,
0.31138503551483154,
-0.5803450345993042,
0.31961145997047424,
-0.20507964491844177,
-0.3357415497303009,
-0.3818906843662262,
-0.08240673691034317,
0.32763102650642395,
0.6758980751037598,
0.15431661903858185,
0.393524169921875,
-0.20336340367794037,
0.7394482493400574,
-0.7591028809547424,
-0.020064949989318848,
-0.42133551836013794,
-0.059860482811927795,
-0.31499263644218445,
-0.6029497385025024,
-0.23794415593147278,
-0.5985415577888489,
0.5109228491783142,
-0.9324708580970764,
0.12255629897117615,
-0.0915464460849762,
0.9349433779716492,
0.11780889332294464,
-0.6994158625602722,
-0.15148305892944336,
-0.6812779307365417,
0.34546637535095215,
-0.7883504033088684,
0.375447154045105,
0.3746771514415741,
0.2997531294822693,
-0.02845199964940548,
-0.8975510001182556,
-0.2530352771282196,
0.42665424942970276,
-0.25160709023475647,
0.17634733021259308,
-0.18110291659832,
-0.05493636801838875,
0.27986735105514526,
0.34821179509162903,
-0.6218963265419006,
-0.30372750759124756,
-0.4372147023677826,
-0.3162192404270172,
0.5127199292182922,
-0.022277919575572014,
0.21160313487052917,
-0.11404161900281906,
-0.013442381285130978,
-0.03901074081659317,
-0.8790566921234131,
0.20027147233486176,
-0.1995549499988556,
-0.03207401931285858,
0.42697739601135254,
0.5761123895645142,
-0.4433872103691101,
0.5865440368652344,
0.060714296996593475,
0.030064217746257782,
0.3901466727256775,
-0.5852132439613342,
-0.10085355490446091,
-0.15566588938236237,
0.2735859751701355,
0.5802339911460876,
-0.05057542398571968,
-0.20337483286857605,
0.20643268525600433,
-0.3248273730278015,
0.4282245934009552,
-1.0602425336837769,
-0.15470926463603973,
0.7225295901298523,
-0.7103304266929626,
0.1091788187623024,
0.17730242013931274,
-0.925205647945404,
-0.19546248018741608,
0.009240257553756237,
0.5355349183082581,
-0.4209887385368347,
-0.19600409269332886,
0.11797081679105759,
-0.37804073095321655,
0.21115060150623322,
0.40126627683639526,
-0.42573124170303345,
0.24487708508968353,
0.5388941168785095,
0.6859723925590515,
0.057266395539045334,
0.3167535066604614,
-0.9330419898033142,
0.048448409885168076,
-0.37742847204208374,
0.9129968285560608,
-0.4555147886276245,
-0.42954111099243164,
0.1434912085533142,
0.30330851674079895,
-0.10406968742609024,
-0.6857397556304932,
0.5634946227073669,
-0.8080140352249146,
0.5684781670570374,
-0.5927591323852539,
-0.533364474773407,
-0.00045765622053295374,
0.1699034422636032,
-0.7113309502601624,
0.47265520691871643,
-0.009913546964526176,
-0.87309730052948,
0.48620280623435974,
-0.6748366951942444,
-0.5964735746383667,
-0.060514017939567566,
-0.04974566027522087,
-0.41757744550704956,
0.20339100062847137,
0.601257860660553,
0.17303812503814697,
-0.13337358832359314,
0.08562766015529633,
-0.24507449567317963,
-0.29383429884910583,
0.05755047872662544,
-0.12090610712766647,
0.7355896830558777,
0.45138707756996155,
-0.3301703631877899,
-0.08907894045114517,
-0.5433352589607239,
0.339949369430542,
0.03338328003883362,
-0.31729158759117126,
-0.6777528524398804,
0.01699005626142025,
-0.25992709398269653,
0.19116802513599396,
0.045885320752859116,
-0.8571836352348328,
-0.058815449476242065,
-0.3819144666194916,
0.4853406548500061,
0.3861786127090454,
0.5485796332359314,
0.10937122255563736,
-0.821171760559082,
0.44553449749946594,
0.09222113341093063,
0.2845636010169983,
-0.24226395785808563,
-0.802120566368103,
0.030244501307606697,
-0.11840222030878067,
0.3675844371318817,
0.28509625792503357,
-0.7914648652076721,
-0.05965946614742279,
-0.4328191578388214,
-0.20150083303451538,
-0.9306772947311401,
-0.08895688503980637,
0.22637438774108887,
0.7792744636535645,
0.6548104286193848,
-0.41470810770988464,
-0.23882752656936646,
-0.7210858464241028,
-0.4580121636390686,
-0.3248002827167511,
-0.24416033923625946,
0.5605421662330627,
0.4283641576766968,
-0.05530975013971329,
0.9016545414924622,
-0.8546218276023865,
-0.0445592887699604,
0.2669142782688141,
0.14397533237934113,
0.07274314761161804,
0.22542916238307953,
0.5115770101547241,
-1.0220736265182495,
-0.21802324056625366,
-0.2430163025856018,
-0.6300662159919739,
-0.16014236211776733,
0.19291849434375763,
-0.2534716725349426,
-0.2190772294998169,
0.2819840908050537,
-0.6367901563644409,
0.28302839398384094,
0.18280863761901855,
-0.46649953722953796,
0.15807956457138062,
-0.023825228214263916,
0.581278383731842,
-0.9485939741134644,
0.46906402707099915,
-0.20018379390239716,
-0.30083030462265015,
-0.46854090690612793,
0.087214894592762,
0.1670246720314026,
-0.19068732857704163,
-0.39615270495414734,
0.5990892648696899,
-0.42280271649360657,
0.2087041735649109,
0.02461693435907364,
0.13158755004405975,
0.44474637508392334,
-0.015627505257725716,
-0.0727381780743599,
0.7670568823814392,
-0.05333481356501579,
-0.24862849712371826,
-0.28679490089416504,
0.35222098231315613,
-0.2930032014846802,
0.4968361556529999,
-0.724387526512146,
0.25994834303855896,
-0.4065380394458771,
0.23713670670986176,
-0.7882376909255981,
-0.44005391001701355,
0.12581954896450043,
-0.4125056862831116,
0.19280745089054108,
0.07231943309307098,
-0.22879743576049805,
-0.4144801199436188,
-0.3950313627719879,
0.24459964036941528,
0.3368580937385559,
-0.26388537883758545,
0.3189353048801422,
0.5815633535385132,
-0.43591728806495667,
-0.6598650813102722,
-0.2577744722366333,
-0.22907626628875732,
0.011338616721332073,
-0.4376922845840454,
0.32441791892051697,
-0.1511041522026062,
-0.38988813757896423,
0.2883526682853699,
-0.5708176493644714,
-0.3983273208141327,
0.12877152860164642,
0.08610169589519501,
-0.0822480320930481,
-0.2745037376880646,
0.4417225122451782,
0.08037219196557999,
0.3155204653739929,
0.28364819288253784,
-0.23427334427833557,
0.03476464003324509,
0.0597415529191494,
-0.3268674612045288,
-0.12480714172124863,
0.7452400326728821,
0.66571444272995,
-0.4406631886959076,
0.6264679431915283,
0.3939319849014282,
-0.5516594648361206,
0.2863292098045349,
-0.4821418821811676,
-0.4174439311027527,
-0.3112679719924927,
0.07332299649715424,
-0.06567056477069855,
-1.0644954442977905,
0.2913961708545685,
-0.11145702749490738,
0.47841954231262207,
0.5708649158477783,
0.26879990100860596,
-0.3086240589618683,
0.7891430258750916,
0.21290577948093414,
0.12934473156929016,
0.17777039110660553,
-0.020450497046113014,
0.19808325171470642,
-0.6315942406654358,
-0.29925668239593506,
-0.5894120335578918,
-0.14181196689605713,
-0.26343563199043274,
-0.6082745790481567,
0.874994695186615,
0.010180369950830936,
0.029557207599282265,
-0.07716851681470871,
-0.43766629695892334,
0.13031704723834991,
0.549493134021759,
0.7894285321235657,
0.5865357518196106,
-0.4449019432067871,
-0.14269350469112396,
0.1674092411994934,
-0.6563456654548645,
-0.34223824739456177,
1.3987175226211548,
0.27409303188323975,
0.4157238006591797,
0.17411236464977264,
0.6527008414268494,
0.11527436971664429,
0.2823752164840698,
-0.3338596522808075,
0.1280297189950943,
0.04227646067738533,
-1.1879069805145264,
-0.3454553484916687,
-0.4988168179988861,
-1.106582760810852,
0.10095079243183136,
-0.3606990873813629,
-0.3433442711830139,
0.2608284652233124,
0.18451344966888428,
-0.7414160966873169,
0.07179301977157593,
-0.6820409297943115,
0.8281785845756531,
-0.20870843529701233,
-0.3743501901626587,
-0.08132641762495041,
-0.8737741112709045,
0.06915389001369476,
-0.05880965292453766,
0.12192799150943756,
-0.0028856731951236725,
0.08792388439178467,
0.6211555600166321,
-0.44194653630256653,
0.27563056349754333,
-0.15634535253047943,
0.138114333152771,
0.46809864044189453,
-0.23195746541023254,
0.30848759412765503,
0.418691486120224,
-0.2262510508298874,
-0.08062365651130676,
0.6050259470939636,
-0.6976624727249146,
-0.738358199596405,
0.5168083906173706,
-0.6238142848014832,
-0.8923599720001221,
-0.45448142290115356,
-0.25659552216529846,
-0.3568083345890045,
0.3954884707927704,
0.1844750940799713,
0.5029292702674866,
-0.4206039607524872,
0.4033992290496826,
0.96759033203125,
-0.1913851946592331,
0.03380604088306427,
0.5409085154533386,
-0.03774859383702278,
-0.32180655002593994,
0.41814151406288147,
0.2429036796092987,
0.1895330846309662,
0.7856665849685669,
0.24939341843128204,
-0.3176250159740448,
-0.59348464012146,
-0.3930138945579529,
0.19057181477546692,
-0.5729998350143433,
-0.27968406677246094,
-0.8906161189079285,
-0.20278039574623108,
-0.818585216999054,
0.15272890031337738,
-0.03399078920483589,
-0.5172058343887329,
-0.3947693109512329,
-0.19131408631801605,
0.3397178053855896,
0.37010589241981506,
-0.010197131894528866,
-0.27256515622138977,
-1.021615982055664,
0.5610301494598389,
0.6142569780349731,
0.47826725244522095,
-0.26640206575393677,
-0.21656829118728638,
-0.20752626657485962,
-0.04666509851813316,
-0.18020673096179962,
-1.0098977088928223,
0.06510597467422485,
0.2323346883058548,
0.6790216565132141,
0.4422798454761505,
0.5340901017189026,
0.5227795839309692,
-0.4440399706363678,
0.7090316414833069,
-0.2108948528766632,
-0.3698767423629761,
0.7818973064422607,
-0.27111709117889404,
0.6280748844146729,
0.9314174652099609,
0.9068155288696289,
-0.2537696063518524,
-0.1755698025226593,
-0.5484345555305481,
-0.83248370885849,
0.03455107659101486,
0.22328072786331177,
-0.28099286556243896,
-0.25935643911361694,
0.3992023169994354,
0.20253396034240723,
0.2740355134010315,
-0.21409280598163605,
-0.046878840774297714,
-0.3272649347782135,
-0.0710812360048294,
0.053609974682331085,
-0.1933562159538269,
-0.5052191019058228,
-0.1864623874425888,
0.5119364857673645,
-0.32982614636421204,
0.36653056740760803,
0.8384603261947632,
-0.09257075935602188,
-0.3334735929965973,
0.668472945690155,
0.37147828936576843,
0.9231322407722473,
-0.5975319147109985,
0.19967716932296753,
-0.21541358530521393,
-0.677944540977478,
0.1327076405286789,
0.2980385422706604,
-0.31481438875198364,
0.2122243195772171,
0.365668386220932,
0.20145317912101746,
0.03628464415669441,
-0.8530276417732239,
0.5179469585418701,
-0.0541900135576725,
-0.20022787153720856,
0.09624802321195602,
-0.10048084706068039,
0.12632928788661957,
0.1946740746498108,
0.5508244633674622,
-0.1587393432855606,
0.38224416971206665,
-0.5567943453788757,
0.5213208198547363,
0.3636825978755951,
-0.5095017552375793,
-0.17441456019878387,
0.8398379683494568,
0.3176777958869934,
-0.03422646224498749,
0.4990581274032593,
0.363635778427124,
0.030103720724582672,
0.4170837998390198,
0.3210376799106598,
0.3743159770965576,
-0.017371881753206253,
0.42942723631858826,
0.3560529053211212,
0.20326250791549683,
-0.13344720005989075,
0.5822970867156982,
0.19217273592948914,
-0.3045375347137451,
-0.38365939259529114,
-0.3774224817752838,
-0.5877805352210999,
0.16494795680046082,
-0.7629262804985046,
-0.30895522236824036,
-0.22065487504005432,
-0.4777281582355499,
0.1378738284111023,
0.24954189360141754,
-0.6897422075271606,
0.3630802631378174,
-0.31604960560798645,
1.1533141136169434,
-0.6619247198104858,
0.5896403193473816,
0.8539172410964966,
-0.5380951166152954,
-0.6393241882324219,
0.22969718277454376,
-0.07494685053825378,
-0.3646538257598877,
0.0927581936120987,
-0.013803827576339245,
0.14809095859527588,
-0.10560443997383118,
-0.47720539569854736,
-0.842342734336853,
1.193727970123291,
0.31688404083251953,
-0.2697473168373108,
-0.3343414068222046,
-0.21822910010814667,
0.7394540905952454,
-0.20779313147068024,
0.42354318499565125,
0.3657006323337555,
0.4233913719654083,
-0.0735735073685646,
-0.8602965474128723,
0.07460654526948929,
-0.4002241790294647,
-0.44482558965682983,
0.03934715688228607,
-0.6054102182388306,
0.5450607538223267,
-0.47701913118362427,
-0.236189603805542,
-0.029582921415567398,
0.5148769021034241,
0.22271306812763214,
0.90620356798172,
0.38407817482948303,
0.6245455741882324,
0.9745791554450989,
-0.15302014350891113,
0.9634265303611755,
-0.13629931211471558,
-0.040829531848430634,
1.0482958555221558,
-0.3285178244113922,
0.8619888424873352,
0.6486719250679016,
-0.07190053910017014,
0.5551917552947998,
0.7222940325737,
0.5676637291908264,
0.7544388771057129,
0.06867853552103043,
-0.29322877526283264,
-0.2237926721572876,
-0.25713083148002625,
-0.6041709780693054,
0.08095342665910721,
0.20472882688045502,
-0.6066297888755798,
-0.2258390635251999,
0.053537290543317795,
0.17612425982952118,
0.0028621270321309566,
-0.1728704273700714,
0.7576726078987122,
0.13349783420562744,
-0.8797652125358582,
0.38840988278388977,
-0.5310076475143433,
0.07082254439592361,
-0.4974702298641205,
-0.23261108994483948,
-0.3334278166294098,
-0.200079083442688,
-0.14833614230155945,
-0.7983995676040649,
0.3141184151172638,
-0.08585650473833084,
-0.46660569310188293,
-0.18221797049045563,
0.7128663659095764,
-0.2577105760574341,
-0.08049386739730835,
0.14230825006961823,
0.8949980735778809,
0.12672366201877594,
-0.13942602276802063,
-0.36543285846710205,
-0.165265291929245,
-0.34461456537246704,
-0.36271098256111145,
0.3900670111179352,
0.61586993932724,
0.09278939664363861,
0.47331658005714417,
0.7198927998542786,
0.3393104374408722,
-0.040217358618974686,
-0.309222549200058,
0.9994819760322571,
-0.38259363174438477,
-0.2745770215988159,
-0.17110204696655273,
0.24843314290046692,
-0.3070870041847229,
-0.3465643525123596,
0.5421399474143982,
0.4293637275695801,
0.7692973017692566,
0.05112003907561302,
0.5598654747009277,
-0.05319027975201607,
1.115067481994629,
-0.49431106448173523,
0.87235426902771,
-0.7760458588600159,
-0.001321678631938994,
-0.1819499284029007,
-0.4690128564834595,
-0.3082032799720764,
0.21557681262493134,
-0.22972427308559418,
-0.2515932023525238,
0.8914847373962402,
0.4667099714279175,
0.21492862701416016,
0.14219634234905243,
0.02192741632461548,
0.2925119996070862,
0.45178455114364624,
0.653055727481842,
0.2563995122909546,
-0.5293850898742676,
0.5262932181358337,
-0.13432906568050385,
-0.16365578770637512,
-0.2647525370121002,
-0.8306158781051636,
-0.46908673644065857,
-0.4547847509384155,
-0.280944287776947,
-0.540030837059021,
0.6477190256118774,
0.7971140146255493,
0.6680693626403809,
-0.8866676092147827,
0.44137653708457947,
0.39509204030036926,
0.2572227418422699,
-0.5657450556755066,
-0.18113797903060913,
0.39385998249053955,
-0.1380695253610611,
-0.3205932676792145,
0.4979217052459717,
0.19996967911720276,
-0.29649364948272705,
0.3090369701385498,
0.17092080414295197,
-0.6484609842300415,
0.06754789501428604,
0.464932382106781,
0.6559210419654846,
-0.2569217383861542,
-0.4741246700286865,
0.48844513297080994,
-0.2717163562774658,
0.36774519085884094,
0.8799270987510681,
-0.868065357208252,
0.7474968433380127,
0.6923881769180298,
1.0960290431976318,
0.5010069608688354,
0.4242284595966339,
0.6829487681388855,
-0.2268860787153244,
-0.6322104930877686,
0.5079972147941589,
0.15622101724147797,
0.11811745911836624,
-0.5363277196884155,
0.5785381197929382,
0.3407326638698578,
-0.7298303842544556,
-0.6121299266815186,
-0.16019244492053986,
-0.9032167792320251,
-0.5509592294692993,
0.8910158276557922,
-0.36771446466445923,
-0.2337750941514969,
-0.5442128777503967,
0.038318000733852386,
0.17617417871952057,
-0.3404073417186737,
0.9642353057861328,
0.6173481345176697,
-0.26077499985694885,
-0.12595050036907196,
-0.5894396305084229,
0.5718298554420471,
0.47653326392173767,
-1.1211917400360107,
-0.07497198134660721,
0.6470667719841003,
0.428626149892807,
0.10853490978479385,
1.202329158782959,
-0.4487498998641968,
0.6506892442703247,
-0.34981125593185425,
-0.4508477747440338,
0.04201970621943474,
-0.4769420027732849,
-0.16350539028644562,
0.47026553750038147,
-0.018826961517333984,
-0.12393087893724442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08354v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08354v3
|
Gaining More Insight into Neural Semantic Parsing with Challenging Benchmarks
| 2024-04-12T09:48:58 | 2024-05-07T21:15:40 |
Xiao Zhang, Chunliu Wang, Rik van Noord, Johan Bos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Parallel Meaning Bank (PMB) serves as a corpus for semantic processing
with a focus on semantic parsing and text generation. Currently, we witness an
excellent performance of neural parsers and generators on the PMB. This might
suggest that such semantic processing tasks have by and large been solved. We
argue that this is not the case and that performance scores from the past on
the PMB are inflated by non-optimal data splits and test sets that are too
easy. In response, we introduce several changes. First, instead of the prior
random split, we propose a more systematic splitting approach to improve the
reliability of the standard test data. Second, except for the standard test
set, we also propose two challenge sets: one with longer texts including
discourse structure, and one that addresses compositional generalization. We
evaluate five neural models for semantic parsing and meaning-to-text
generation. Our results show that model performance declines (in some cases
dramatically) on the challenge sets, revealing the limitations of neural models
when confronting such challenges.
|
[
-0.34627097845077515,
-0.6110415458679199,
0.6481123566627502,
0.2371816635131836,
-0.2902415990829468,
-0.14328715205192566,
-0.2504866123199463,
-0.4764244854450226,
-0.0315985307097435,
0.5274937152862549,
-0.6415032744407654,
-0.3719991445541382,
-0.7704471945762634,
0.263415664434433,
-0.3089240491390228,
0.9538054466247559,
0.11264891177415848,
0.09617936611175537,
-0.5738716721534729,
-0.19341392815113068,
-0.7405581474304199,
-0.42022064328193665,
-0.49041658639907837,
-0.45153647661209106,
0.5445546507835388,
0.14428794384002686,
0.6616423726081848,
0.8758441805839539,
0.6855772137641907,
0.33444175124168396,
-0.3504869043827057,
0.12568043172359467,
-0.07211942970752716,
0.19121681153774261,
-0.5271276831626892,
-0.5029638409614563,
-0.3172551691532135,
-0.07016724348068237,
0.6383923292160034,
1.1777983903884888,
-0.029033930972218513,
0.09202280640602112,
-0.1914168894290924,
0.5613846182823181,
-0.6238781213760376,
0.2350015491247177,
-0.7159383893013,
-0.19615058600902557,
-0.31875360012054443,
0.0952598825097084,
-0.45505574345588684,
0.05633261427283287,
0.20329801738262177,
-0.15853947401046753,
0.36650046706199646,
0.22113996744155884,
1.0341646671295166,
0.2552087903022766,
-0.43670403957366943,
-0.15342803299427032,
-0.397891104221344,
0.849622905254364,
-0.6247959136962891,
0.2066427618265152,
0.34487229585647583,
0.35359475016593933,
-0.03701556473970413,
-0.7278623580932617,
-0.5291946530342102,
-0.303854376077652,
0.03140655532479286,
-0.04541805759072304,
-0.04820822924375534,
0.036067698150873184,
0.3183291256427765,
0.32619842886924744,
-0.3305477797985077,
0.009308699518442154,
-0.29559895396232605,
-0.16261637210845947,
0.4073587656021118,
0.5287855267524719,
0.13217881321907043,
-0.5831863880157471,
-0.49053817987442017,
-0.40787115693092346,
-0.4287542700767517,
0.05951642617583275,
0.534846305847168,
0.3622475266456604,
0.4573466181755066,
0.6247008442878723,
-0.2247474193572998,
0.8928186297416687,
-0.3809407353401184,
0.07809150964021683,
0.10321150720119476,
-0.4429808259010315,
-0.19449399411678314,
-0.05717863887548447,
0.48305490612983704,
0.3016481399536133,
0.131449356675148,
-0.2104688286781311,
-0.42471447587013245,
0.2893320322036743,
0.28238096833229065,
-0.7147851586341858,
-0.3093127906322479,
0.13847693800926208,
-0.5758853554725647,
-0.05974844470620155,
-0.1933562308549881,
-0.575239896774292,
-0.24871861934661865,
-0.61968594789505,
0.1862713247537613,
-0.7295788526535034,
-0.2824339270591736,
0.33653002977371216,
-0.4779629111289978,
0.33498817682266235,
0.17839567363262177,
-1.0981603860855103,
0.6307200193405151,
0.9743191599845886,
0.57508784532547,
0.015585029497742653,
-0.35990771651268005,
-0.18789327144622803,
-0.0027118499856442213,
-0.10460008680820465,
1.0402370691299438,
-0.5536643266677856,
-0.09802161157131195,
-0.31783294677734375,
-0.43841850757598877,
-0.5821356177330017,
-0.8543923497200012,
0.5398644804954529,
-0.49207165837287903,
0.010118131525814533,
-0.6390843987464905,
-0.8015338182449341,
0.10406351834535599,
0.49867579340934753,
-0.619035542011261,
0.6165580749511719,
0.12226191908121109,
-0.7196449041366577,
0.14749780297279358,
-0.418976366519928,
-0.32505396008491516,
-0.11907526850700378,
-0.17204466462135315,
-0.019937530159950256,
0.41989266872406006,
0.12374287843704224,
0.24351879954338074,
-0.6522617936134338,
0.4208500385284424,
-0.2691737413406372,
-0.04438544809818268,
0.2483902871608734,
-0.25145095586776733,
0.6529164910316467,
0.10251882672309875,
-0.2515202462673187,
0.01018591970205307,
-1.049176573753357,
0.16366170346736908,
0.07760577648878098,
-0.10789782553911209,
-0.28968462347984314,
0.3559543192386627,
0.1912054866552353,
0.3147222697734833,
0.1273975968360901,
-0.742567241191864,
-0.2558283507823944,
-0.4449375569820404,
0.5109505653381348,
1.0452882051467896,
-0.35556188225746155,
0.21099458634853363,
-0.26221856474876404,
0.08291913568973541,
0.3653384745121002,
0.0038547739386558533,
-0.2180388867855072,
-0.4564254879951477,
-0.8782464861869812,
-0.09696560353040695,
0.6739182472229004,
0.4338504374027252,
-0.34387528896331787,
0.31506770849227905,
-0.33890461921691895,
-0.19078338146209717,
-0.5877770185470581,
0.1493043601512909,
0.477243572473526,
0.885660707950592,
0.621344268321991,
-0.3329140245914459,
-0.2899271249771118,
-1.2712905406951904,
-0.37782904505729675,
-0.10460161417722702,
-0.07586625218391418,
0.29123684763908386,
0.453528493642807,
0.1257333755493164,
0.9696812033653259,
-0.5590714812278748,
-0.008617846295237541,
-0.24612747132778168,
0.17909659445285797,
0.21873067319393158,
0.4762786030769348,
0.14910708367824554,
-0.9130834341049194,
0.033772580325603485,
-0.2666337192058563,
-0.5886055827140808,
-0.07242920249700546,
-0.01070625800639391,
-0.11360041052103043,
0.053544458001852036,
0.42075279355049133,
-0.804402768611908,
0.13854092359542847,
0.3946841061115265,
-0.501036524772644,
0.49803176522254944,
-0.07531853020191193,
-0.3938603699207306,
-1.089113473892212,
-0.07062774896621704,
-0.272996187210083,
-0.08149874955415726,
-0.3606570363044739,
0.08425746113061905,
0.17889666557312012,
-0.037590160965919495,
-0.2128719687461853,
0.2401905208826065,
-0.22505342960357666,
-0.03391953930258751,
-0.4805039167404175,
0.09446399658918381,
0.10957340151071548,
0.358254998922348,
-0.09631950408220291,
0.1970181167125702,
0.2310095876455307,
-0.3011282980442047,
0.5007887482643127,
0.31255555152893066,
-0.4816268980503082,
0.5104640126228333,
-0.7168819308280945,
0.12287337332963943,
-0.32261475920677185,
0.14665476977825165,
-1.0404856204986572,
-0.16152417659759521,
-0.08032411336898804,
-0.29054421186447144,
0.16602128744125366,
0.3669687509536743,
-0.7310948967933655,
-0.1323857307434082,
0.04610316827893257,
0.5371775031089783,
0.4687656760215759,
-0.5900385975837708,
0.5345104336738586,
-0.03581225499510765,
0.12159226089715958,
-0.49577102065086365,
-0.7311550378799438,
0.1648993194103241,
-0.039847761392593384,
-1.1877931356430054,
0.5498263239860535,
0.24364112317562103,
-0.42834872007369995,
0.3366329073905945,
-0.3106689155101776,
-0.07366098463535309,
0.14334316551685333,
0.08667823672294617,
0.22218719124794006,
-0.4456663727760315,
0.25794002413749695,
-0.11166224628686905,
-0.3504028618335724,
0.4019010066986084,
-0.33718737959861755,
0.48384907841682434,
-0.1431412398815155,
-0.1565995216369629,
-0.211813285946846,
0.546838104724884,
0.1051926389336586,
-0.4832665026187897,
1.0448921918869019,
0.146052286028862,
-0.27058854699134827,
-0.36010053753852844,
-0.534343421459198,
-0.014859646558761597,
-0.4686858057975769,
0.21786652505397797,
-0.5652994513511658,
-0.8486914038658142,
0.47531476616859436,
-0.12594223022460938,
-0.18902656435966492,
0.5046048164367676,
0.46187955141067505,
0.00025093049043789506,
0.8227142691612244,
0.440844863653183,
0.34957122802734375,
0.11904951184988022,
0.05771547183394432,
0.2951955795288086,
-0.6702793836593628,
-0.18367385864257812,
-0.4808589816093445,
-0.49531272053718567,
-0.5170568823814392,
-0.19738030433654785,
-0.12243907898664474,
0.02138473466038704,
0.08086295425891876,
0.3563937842845917,
-0.2650752067565918,
0.6372180581092834,
0.6532073616981506,
0.1878184974193573,
0.1390042006969452,
-0.3924574851989746,
-0.38304463028907776,
0.03318587318062782,
-0.4395468235015869,
-0.2944449484348297,
1.0142862796783447,
0.10159964859485626,
0.23093655705451965,
-0.05417078360915184,
0.6552250385284424,
-0.25016701221466064,
0.10547666251659393,
-0.48301783204078674,
0.6862695217132568,
-0.27135032415390015,
-0.6358463764190674,
-0.0005750952987000346,
-0.5068166255950928,
-0.767234742641449,
0.536920428276062,
0.1170472800731659,
-0.6119977831840515,
0.0737760066986084,
-0.13334974646568298,
-0.4075391888618469,
0.14151915907859802,
-0.9579000473022461,
1.2091513872146606,
0.15018703043460846,
-0.2719265818595886,
-0.1435295045375824,
-0.8378169536590576,
0.5243273973464966,
0.02507835440337658,
-0.025336500257253647,
-0.4974677860736847,
-0.07688944041728973,
0.5975093841552734,
-0.7336785793304443,
0.6311502456665039,
-0.15903684496879578,
0.31966015696525574,
0.2642422616481781,
-0.26191866397857666,
0.294178307056427,
-0.04841182380914688,
0.00718270055949688,
-0.10215494781732559,
-0.002625427907332778,
-0.8332741260528564,
-0.6446375250816345,
0.5885721445083618,
-0.6485735774040222,
-0.6678469777107239,
-0.3345275819301605,
-0.8619309067726135,
-0.4389551877975464,
0.10416208207607269,
0.1091855987906456,
0.3467355966567993,
0.056408099830150604,
0.16351373493671417,
0.5240586400032043,
-0.06877225637435913,
0.5325928926467896,
0.07069197297096252,
0.11183640360832214,
-0.5044124722480774,
0.7358264923095703,
0.12715059518814087,
0.2761959731578827,
0.37955984473228455,
0.30507293343544006,
-0.3658902645111084,
-0.8212769627571106,
-0.23330345749855042,
0.17236532270908356,
-0.6759570240974426,
-0.0833866149187088,
-0.5655427575111389,
-0.010841909795999527,
-0.584380567073822,
0.21073481440544128,
-0.4079256057739258,
-0.5811823606491089,
-0.056357383728027344,
-0.19167762994766235,
-0.027756499126553535,
0.34140342473983765,
0.054682206362485886,
0.2664833068847656,
-0.7713881134986877,
0.28703728318214417,
0.26768842339515686,
0.19321931898593903,
-0.09760567545890808,
-0.0937192440032959,
-0.14517571032047272,
-0.3014679253101349,
-0.3163864314556122,
-0.8666757941246033,
0.16685564815998077,
-0.08980558067560196,
0.25209128856658936,
0.12743383646011353,
-0.06161731109023094,
0.7387100458145142,
-0.6616598963737488,
0.6397784352302551,
0.07954616844654083,
-0.9999324083328247,
0.4026722311973572,
-0.370669960975647,
0.4512600302696228,
0.6738281846046448,
0.2512000501155853,
-0.4544702470302582,
-0.22965605556964874,
-0.7275848388671875,
-0.9396282434463501,
0.7697588205337524,
0.26922568678855896,
0.3666474223136902,
-0.29849985241889954,
0.34570935368537903,
0.06129516288638115,
0.14233186841011047,
-0.49677956104278564,
-0.0514875166118145,
-0.1438300758600235,
-0.33337971568107605,
-0.15414002537727356,
-0.3508167564868927,
-0.04171140864491463,
-0.2518237829208374,
0.275412917137146,
-0.05212274193763733,
0.01621682569384575,
0.09018462151288986,
-0.13238035142421722,
0.23907403647899628,
0.22518345713615417,
0.3782094120979309,
0.6378747820854187,
-0.15610823035240173,
0.2865946590900421,
-0.14348439872264862,
-0.11747932434082031,
-0.029909852892160416,
0.3607749044895172,
-0.050528861582279205,
-0.03153710812330246,
0.4056856334209442,
0.9123806953430176,
0.33635270595550537,
-0.897367000579834,
0.5393694043159485,
-0.031021516770124435,
-0.3692922592163086,
-0.16407246887683868,
0.009542296640574932,
0.3896379768848419,
0.35988128185272217,
-0.07870986312627792,
0.2836596369743347,
0.0030217203311622143,
-0.3124958574771881,
0.23528936505317688,
0.11459241062402725,
0.014014532789587975,
-0.29558101296424866,
0.499716579914093,
-0.054340340197086334,
-0.2415035367012024,
1.0799899101257324,
-0.14426489174365997,
-0.3339773416519165,
0.6974972486495972,
0.6649434566497803,
0.8928737044334412,
-0.016591675579547882,
0.060474857687950134,
0.10189501941204071,
0.20237500965595245,
-0.20523859560489655,
0.13774588704109192,
-0.3829067349433899,
-0.8392540216445923,
-0.6508978605270386,
-0.9768028259277344,
-0.45607689023017883,
-0.05547213926911354,
-0.7754214406013489,
0.18963880836963654,
-0.6079393625259399,
-0.1898806095123291,
0.37665146589279175,
-0.26441946625709534,
-0.5199111104011536,
0.28652074933052063,
0.22541262209415436,
0.9133919477462769,
-0.5761435627937317,
0.7604426741600037,
0.6087729334831238,
-0.2465442568063736,
-0.7810218930244446,
-0.22809185087680817,
-0.29831403493881226,
-0.5438225865364075,
0.7709805369377136,
0.5263122916221619,
0.5306896567344666,
-0.17379045486450195,
-0.1315743625164032,
-0.8117669224739075,
0.7185720205307007,
0.5375543832778931,
-0.2874707579612732,
-0.42274174094200134,
0.5675728917121887,
0.6469473242759705,
-0.10177379101514816,
0.29604238271713257,
0.8617117404937744,
0.40757983922958374,
0.05766390636563301,
-0.7071530222892761,
0.15480270981788635,
-0.31427720189094543,
0.21911607682704926,
0.4479421079158783,
-0.7792798280715942,
1.25392746925354,
0.2581968903541565,
-0.024279700592160225,
0.14375275373458862,
0.7686870694160461,
0.16140247881412506,
0.2873690128326416,
0.4698467254638672,
1.1116917133331299,
0.6397103071212769,
-0.14771540462970734,
1.19559645652771,
0.10034742206335068,
0.1829528957605362,
1.2666339874267578,
-0.3119051158428192,
1.0027883052825928,
0.6339030861854553,
-0.04740311577916145,
0.5579994916915894,
0.6264370679855347,
-0.162650927901268,
0.44201090931892395,
0.5897874236106873,
-0.28213706612586975,
-0.5183908939361572,
-0.14074236154556274,
-0.11734174191951752,
0.7512632608413696,
0.10505440086126328,
-0.5767613053321838,
-0.7888392210006714,
-0.00630497420206666,
-0.19973042607307434,
0.324297159910202,
-0.09661304950714111,
0.5127344131469727,
0.17703859508037567,
-0.8047520518302917,
0.3887074291706085,
0.3329727351665497,
0.3106558322906494,
-0.5083824396133423,
0.16467924416065216,
-0.12261496484279633,
0.5325104594230652,
0.08478259295225143,
-0.26287975907325745,
0.7855270504951477,
-0.016345661133527756,
-0.335721880197525,
-0.5380037426948547,
0.7729542851448059,
0.05550985410809517,
-0.40151798725128174,
0.46513986587524414,
0.5441219806671143,
0.014393491670489311,
-0.2986295521259308,
-0.6083335876464844,
-0.019937656819820404,
-0.2474992424249649,
-0.4164258539676666,
0.6877446174621582,
0.4063909351825714,
0.09892547875642776,
0.10453721135854721,
0.6405029296875,
-0.22292378544807434,
0.5233139395713806,
-0.010854218155145645,
0.802125871181488,
-1.0569058656692505,
-0.2879222631454468,
-1.086419939994812,
0.23106011748313904,
-0.16067081689834595,
-0.6378068327903748,
0.6611586213111877,
0.4887216091156006,
1.1239478588104248,
0.18773728609085083,
0.2579493522644043,
-0.06689237058162689,
0.28141239285469055,
-0.5664410591125488,
0.4070487320423126,
-0.41795849800109863,
0.1164391040802002,
-0.07750418037176132,
-0.9165692329406738,
-0.3456033170223236,
0.1447942554950714,
-0.417959988117218,
-0.236040398478508,
1.1466081142425537,
0.5617828369140625,
0.12892292439937592,
0.5089014768600464,
0.3756968080997467,
0.028086865320801735,
0.23780322074890137,
1.0035699605941772,
1.036167860031128,
-0.5181280970573425,
0.6640278697013855,
-0.5111919045448303,
0.0419231653213501,
0.4420524537563324,
-0.6945037245750427,
-0.8759953379631042,
-0.31637266278266907,
-0.11057767271995544,
-0.39912039041519165,
0.030821848660707474,
0.7159923315048218,
0.44839024543762207,
-0.5738279819488525,
-0.25541290640830994,
-0.5389376282691956,
-0.009031245484948158,
-0.2098078578710556,
-0.18470574915409088,
0.31343939900398254,
-0.9141517877578735,
-0.8240829110145569,
0.42705878615379333,
0.12345945090055466,
-0.3428358733654022,
0.12821997702121735,
0.3716476559638977,
-0.1699668914079666,
0.22019539773464203,
0.36808261275291443,
-0.11078224331140518,
-0.5165767669677734,
-0.28505897521972656,
0.012425119988620281,
-0.17328330874443054,
0.05234793573617935,
0.8074323534965515,
-0.7070987224578857,
0.1530432552099228,
0.6973808407783508,
1.2720484733581543,
0.5432370901107788,
-0.07498743385076523,
0.42180731892585754,
-0.5259568691253662,
0.04096927493810654,
0.4009343683719635,
0.4483379125595093,
0.2731930613517761,
0.029649341478943825,
0.26245301961898804,
0.6471084952354431,
-0.38062095642089844,
-0.8308950066566467,
0.20164431631565094,
-0.9815213084220886,
-0.5191900730133057,
0.9350908994674683,
-0.14994460344314575,
-0.9295647740364075,
0.09894932061433792,
0.18047624826431274,
0.03708484396338463,
0.03903231769800186,
0.5763168931007385,
1.1837917566299438,
-0.35777437686920166,
0.04367176443338394,
-0.3832424283027649,
0.18550872802734375,
1.2116775512695312,
-0.6335228681564331,
0.06335828453302383,
0.564922571182251,
0.25381603837013245,
0.33987072110176086,
0.49630481004714966,
-0.21513724327087402,
0.2554466724395752,
0.5075703859329224,
-0.3009272813796997,
-0.12703806161880493,
-0.35564810037612915,
-0.23624342679977417,
0.710720956325531,
-0.1325923353433609,
-0.18302161991596222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08345v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08345v1
|
FastSpell: the LangId Magic Spell
| 2024-04-12T09:21:29 | 2024-04-12T09:21:29 |
Marta Bañón, Jaume Zaragoza-Bernabeu, Gema Ramírez-Sánchez, Sergio Ortiz-Rojas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language identification is a crucial component in the automated production of
language resources, particularly in multilingual and big data contexts.
However, commonly used language identifiers struggle to differentiate between
similar or closely-related languages. This paper introduces FastSpell, a
language identifier that combines fastText (a pre-trained language identifier
tool) and Hunspell (a spell checker) with the aim of having a refined
second-opinion before deciding which language should be assigned to a text. We
provide a description of the FastSpell algorithm along with an explanation on
how to use and configure it. To that end, we motivate the need of such a tool
and present a benchmark including some popular language identifiers evaluated
during the development of FastSpell. We show how FastSpell is useful not only
to improve identification of similar languages, but also to identify new ones
ignored by other tools.
|
[
-0.3936099708080292,
-0.5959807634353638,
-0.009473160840570927,
0.2923971712589264,
-0.23070263862609863,
0.4765818119049072,
-0.3605636656284332,
-0.54960697889328,
0.3178474009037018,
0.3522878587245941,
-0.29856255650520325,
-0.6059972047805786,
-0.7460388541221619,
0.3033187985420227,
-0.5015257000923157,
1.104243278503418,
-0.18144719302654266,
-0.422757625579834,
0.04703403264284134,
-0.4835812747478485,
-0.23075394332408905,
-0.38300639390945435,
-0.5142903327941895,
-0.19620046019554138,
0.9979479312896729,
0.3769165575504303,
1.2173776626586914,
0.9569979906082153,
0.3864842653274536,
0.41696804761886597,
0.04219217225909233,
0.40071287751197815,
-0.1904219090938568,
0.04624626412987709,
-0.3326270282268524,
-0.37672123312950134,
-0.13798950612545013,
0.05461039021611214,
0.30585289001464844,
0.5804587602615356,
-0.05216725170612335,
0.613258421421051,
0.028644617646932602,
0.5389964580535889,
-0.8519872426986694,
-0.021582825109362602,
-0.5949615836143494,
0.12042100727558136,
-1.0927404165267944,
-0.14978240430355072,
-0.25513073801994324,
-0.8129860162734985,
0.1970265954732895,
-0.6125398874282837,
0.2408296763896942,
0.4920438230037689,
0.9339079260826111,
0.07178901135921478,
-0.44425931572914124,
-0.661029040813446,
-0.7138825058937073,
0.7104206681251526,
-0.4387601613998413,
0.4006909430027008,
0.20834308862686157,
0.5913330316543579,
-0.06025895103812218,
-0.6982046961784363,
-0.8119367957115173,
0.022042984142899513,
-0.32715922594070435,
-0.4320385158061981,
0.23372313380241394,
-0.1153915598988533,
0.28163403272628784,
0.16601358354091644,
-0.7945864796638489,
0.24154257774353027,
-0.2884019911289215,
-0.6735720634460449,
0.44199907779693604,
-0.03832591697573662,
0.4826290011405945,
0.1142897829413414,
-0.07524514198303223,
0.04475210979580879,
-0.584416389465332,
-0.2727043330669403,
0.5152367949485779,
0.52375328540802,
0.11403711885213852,
0.40108591318130493,
0.028018653392791748,
0.6952698230743408,
-0.025238504633307457,
-0.3998374044895172,
0.48146259784698486,
0.12507013976573944,
-0.153667151927948,
0.22093188762664795,
0.7100995779037476,
0.09964153915643692,
0.6525341272354126,
-0.11800529062747955,
-0.029837602749466896,
0.0017879989463835955,
-0.17898395657539368,
-0.8127992749214172,
0.008069989271461964,
-0.0022789486683905125,
-0.4759053885936737,
-0.05378389358520508,
0.005245111882686615,
-0.8611761927604675,
-0.6630681157112122,
-0.21612921357154846,
0.2981805205345154,
-0.18126164376735687,
-0.42498600482940674,
-0.25347864627838135,
-0.09058317542076111,
-0.10071814060211182,
0.16743531823158264,
-0.8665601015090942,
0.40283194184303284,
0.9153512120246887,
0.5700890421867371,
-0.4144066572189331,
-0.943607747554779,
-0.36868050694465637,
-0.09938804805278778,
-0.5032034516334534,
0.7366831302642822,
-0.37748250365257263,
-0.1349027454853058,
0.28318628668785095,
0.24268941581249237,
-0.1414688527584076,
-0.794439435005188,
0.4863978922367096,
-0.7352346777915955,
0.25226694345474243,
0.02001900039613247,
-0.48317763209342957,
-0.050494495779275894,
-0.10150568187236786,
-0.9063324928283691,
1.169370412826538,
0.05529697984457016,
-0.8521982431411743,
0.6011176705360413,
-0.2470778077840805,
-0.8577064871788025,
0.44593173265457153,
0.1762043982744217,
-0.48507389426231384,
0.24067018926143646,
-0.17500434815883636,
0.24725502729415894,
-0.440824419260025,
0.04401729255914688,
-0.32291582226753235,
-0.5888311862945557,
0.27516892552375793,
-0.3416837155818939,
0.6745390892028809,
0.4873884916305542,
-0.3085778057575226,
-0.18640023469924927,
-0.8916372060775757,
0.31028658151626587,
0.057876404374837875,
-0.059831466525793076,
-0.8966014385223389,
0.07712498307228088,
0.14225651323795319,
0.11290772259235382,
0.4638245701789856,
-0.3245415687561035,
-0.027089262381196022,
-0.5218359231948853,
-0.10900706052780151,
0.6135878562927246,
-0.3342559039592743,
0.27153295278549194,
0.10004980117082596,
0.4312868118286133,
-0.2986130118370056,
0.2723275125026703,
-0.013767511583864689,
-0.1592283397912979,
-0.5858165621757507,
-0.43460121750831604,
0.5634055733680725,
0.6574708819389343,
-0.6983784437179565,
0.2514948546886444,
-0.1052839607000351,
-0.6780021786689758,
-0.7738956212997437,
0.456737220287323,
0.6666488647460938,
-0.048489462584257126,
0.09492160379886627,
-0.09258457273244858,
-0.6355350017547607,
-0.8946566581726074,
-0.9951152801513672,
0.15424497425556183,
0.22073994576931,
0.12172821909189224,
0.3010038733482361,
-0.28242719173431396,
0.7183653712272644,
-0.3368239402770996,
-0.25408706068992615,
-0.13741472363471985,
0.23556125164031982,
0.4936915338039398,
0.014660405926406384,
0.5936623811721802,
-0.7517635226249695,
-1.0762022733688354,
0.2906073331832886,
-0.534873902797699,
-0.1889449656009674,
0.2691349983215332,
-0.035615406930446625,
0.03251158818602562,
0.21890202164649963,
-0.36608579754829407,
0.42072921991348267,
0.656867504119873,
-0.4657842814922333,
0.8001714944839478,
-0.4981335699558258,
0.42425674200057983,
-0.6132388114929199,
0.20009073615074158,
-0.043580129742622375,
0.34516647458076477,
-0.7718352675437927,
0.20870769023895264,
0.2625879645347595,
-0.28123629093170166,
-0.7235193252563477,
1.1393531560897827,
-0.5476932525634766,
-0.009949742816388607,
-0.30566999316215515,
0.021642491221427917,
-0.23999643325805664,
0.2088261991739273,
-0.18914757668972015,
1.0448745489120483,
0.47569355368614197,
-0.4550919830799103,
0.3739197850227356,
0.12029732018709183,
-0.7535351514816284,
0.6436033844947815,
-0.3495076894760132,
0.17918482422828674,
-0.07163292169570923,
-0.0957728922367096,
-0.6481673717498779,
-0.049354277551174164,
-0.18797963857650757,
0.011437118984758854,
-0.029942918568849564,
-0.08148988336324692,
-0.6640721559524536,
-0.9695377945899963,
0.046302180737257004,
0.5126566886901855,
0.4398098289966583,
-0.8801177144050598,
0.6065446734428406,
0.3900681436061859,
-0.15016049146652222,
-0.8275934457778931,
-0.3922470808029175,
-0.05082248896360397,
-0.29134613275527954,
-0.21087446808815002,
0.21559801697731018,
-0.06250453740358353,
-0.4293953478336334,
-0.21217471361160278,
-0.06132794916629791,
-0.7211615443229675,
0.13908647000789642,
0.4584888517856598,
0.02036716602742672,
-0.08790502697229385,
0.06386896967887878,
0.18460527062416077,
-0.32971611618995667,
-0.38220345973968506,
-0.10355046391487122,
0.1412532776594162,
0.1392279714345932,
-0.4097839891910553,
-0.5583128333091736,
0.46780622005462646,
1.0956023931503296,
-0.4926229417324066,
0.5502004623413086,
0.5872460007667542,
-0.18349160254001617,
-0.6614935994148254,
-0.6171417832374573,
0.04393872246146202,
-0.5201680064201355,
0.1931043118238449,
-0.6693728566169739,
-0.5826507210731506,
0.43662604689598083,
-0.2742227017879486,
0.09511558711528778,
0.276339054107666,
0.6030799746513367,
0.03412716090679169,
0.9509918689727783,
0.5524967312812805,
-0.16835440695285797,
0.3581663966178894,
0.38037028908729553,
0.5676838159561157,
-0.12348417937755585,
0.0644335001707077,
-0.8395279049873352,
-0.244135320186615,
-0.4355769157409668,
-0.14588405191898346,
-0.10071691870689392,
0.1308627426624298,
0.02146477811038494,
0.6648234128952026,
-0.5469697713851929,
0.6838154792785645,
0.6547009348869324,
-0.3246185779571533,
-0.09813030809164047,
0.08853431791067123,
-0.42579880356788635,
-0.3461034297943115,
-0.3017973005771637,
-0.371076375246048,
0.7493501305580139,
0.012449136935174465,
0.458074688911438,
-0.02326587587594986,
0.7564809918403625,
0.6583857536315918,
0.5860525965690613,
-0.4785744547843933,
0.7145107984542847,
-0.5286858081817627,
-0.7369869947433472,
-0.11495085805654526,
0.05750340595841408,
-1.0030097961425781,
0.5416378378868103,
-0.20709732174873352,
-0.3918806314468384,
-0.027461452409625053,
0.3726780116558075,
-0.4221360981464386,
-0.03363541513681412,
-0.9187813401222229,
1.0795258283615112,
-0.4313777983188629,
-0.2942715883255005,
-0.39722052216529846,
-0.21574018895626068,
0.10687144100666046,
-0.22718465328216553,
0.7039294838905334,
-0.38684552907943726,
0.34651803970336914,
0.8429548144340515,
-0.814075231552124,
0.5894017219543457,
-0.28275081515312195,
-0.03136561065912247,
0.49427634477615356,
0.3365214765071869,
0.6230080723762512,
-0.5463362336158752,
-0.3156249225139618,
0.30735480785369873,
0.3550223410129547,
-0.1678975522518158,
-0.742186963558197,
0.7836094498634338,
-0.5208185911178589,
-0.33280402421951294,
-0.3390323221683502,
-0.224101722240448,
0.03452116623520851,
0.4768607020378113,
-0.0895327776670456,
0.6543015837669373,
-0.07371523231267929,
-0.19879868626594543,
0.361805260181427,
-0.2859726846218109,
0.43997809290885925,
0.8976752161979675,
-0.2966121435165405,
-0.41476893424987793,
1.219868540763855,
0.1886330246925354,
-0.1530780792236328,
0.2802116572856903,
0.45767709612846375,
-0.2042238414287567,
-0.3276699483394623,
-0.21980340778827667,
0.41587111353874207,
-0.5713281631469727,
0.09260839223861694,
-0.24647536873817444,
-0.013984953984618187,
-0.24375949800014496,
-0.22102339565753937,
-0.3142366409301758,
-0.07382381707429886,
0.15556980669498444,
0.10806690156459808,
0.20060579478740692,
0.3949781358242035,
0.059663593769073486,
0.1729671210050583,
-0.6504313349723816,
0.37329134345054626,
0.5518317818641663,
0.3440444767475128,
-0.13205979764461517,
-0.07553647458553314,
-0.4375852346420288,
-0.35283660888671875,
0.47488003969192505,
-0.8415687680244446,
0.2930504381656647,
0.35500022768974304,
0.6101707816123962,
0.5379250645637512,
0.06969300657510757,
0.8244836926460266,
-0.9700538516044617,
0.47173255681991577,
0.04893138259649277,
-0.8585673570632935,
0.3385714292526245,
0.25833022594451904,
0.22182373702526093,
0.6653730273246765,
0.46125707030296326,
-0.9197655916213989,
-0.4264577627182007,
-0.3071218729019165,
-0.5877668261528015,
0.11609355360269547,
-0.3827023208141327,
-0.1446451097726822,
-0.4484606683254242,
0.13289932906627655,
0.47199004888534546,
0.368467777967453,
-0.290484219789505,
-0.33016788959503174,
0.18795061111450195,
-0.5161886215209961,
-0.07789736241102219,
-0.4727320671081543,
-0.11565650254487991,
-0.06585365533828735,
0.3331068158149719,
-0.27409690618515015,
-0.05721089988946915,
-0.499194860458374,
-0.5608499646186829,
0.1721339076757431,
0.3886471092700958,
0.413348913192749,
0.5282353162765503,
0.16647516191005707,
0.40360671281814575,
0.18919780850410461,
-0.6634776592254639,
0.029398426413536072,
0.12000557780265808,
-0.07622041553258896,
0.24918518960475922,
0.5855096578598022,
0.7145606279373169,
0.3855527639389038,
-0.7271782159805298,
0.6738680601119995,
0.21476344764232635,
-0.1442313939332962,
-0.04378687962889671,
-0.022099586203694344,
-0.5832295417785645,
0.06596359610557556,
0.3761166036128998,
0.05129478871822357,
-0.10572745651006699,
-0.31679320335388184,
0.26093733310699463,
0.43107134103775024,
-0.3076331317424774,
-0.4392866790294647,
0.3492170572280884,
0.5000503659248352,
-0.8897461891174316,
0.23960186541080475,
-0.19352136552333832,
-0.7685329914093018,
0.4650493264198303,
0.3689827620983124,
1.0082697868347168,
-0.5384067893028259,
0.1969270557165146,
0.1455693542957306,
0.2705744802951813,
-0.027835262939333916,
0.16460777819156647,
-0.21107231080532074,
-0.6516813039779663,
-0.49038931727409363,
-0.7618074417114258,
-0.20756621658802032,
-0.40418753027915955,
-0.4479069411754608,
0.2822451889514923,
-0.3444983959197998,
-0.07354594767093658,
0.116706982254982,
0.3000966012477875,
-1.0034916400909424,
0.22657296061515808,
0.12240497022867203,
1.0702768564224243,
-1.262848973274231,
1.3507096767425537,
0.23163624107837677,
0.28140968084335327,
-0.6027306914329529,
-0.16292962431907654,
0.43258756399154663,
-0.773950457572937,
1.0414838790893555,
0.0836867168545723,
-0.25890007615089417,
-0.02283608540892601,
0.004055443219840527,
-0.8461377620697021,
0.7471470832824707,
-0.16647474467754364,
-0.7007756233215332,
0.21600039303302765,
0.08025678992271423,
0.6325507164001465,
-0.1109561175107956,
0.556606650352478,
0.7953034043312073,
0.8700037002563477,
-0.1731342226266861,
-1.3026565313339233,
-0.07743804156780243,
-0.10046196728944778,
-0.010311723686754704,
0.38570570945739746,
-0.18294915556907654,
0.632079005241394,
-0.3526565134525299,
-0.6404469609260559,
0.26322346925735474,
0.6161758899688721,
0.05517546087503433,
0.40019142627716064,
0.8070608973503113,
0.24905063211917877,
1.0453215837478638,
-0.11402040719985962,
0.7731739282608032,
-0.5500398874282837,
0.20964054763317108,
1.0781067609786987,
-0.7654348015785217,
0.8410824537277222,
0.39682257175445557,
-0.3000364303588867,
0.6063947081565857,
0.37881994247436523,
0.1204676404595375,
0.728607177734375,
0.31420597434043884,
-0.25962501764297485,
0.24652019143104553,
0.03515036776661873,
-0.29871195554733276,
0.08865069597959518,
0.3971520662307739,
-0.10160145163536072,
-0.2783113718032837,
0.43310728669166565,
0.2707989811897278,
0.4156637191772461,
-0.12191981822252274,
0.48443952202796936,
-0.35578423738479614,
-0.8438873887062073,
0.5712292194366455,
-0.18208780884742737,
0.7956981062889099,
-0.7568924427032471,
0.19929523766040802,
-0.21376873552799225,
0.6095811724662781,
-0.18410024046897888,
-0.639858067035675,
0.3002009987831116,
-0.3193614184856415,
-0.14770890772342682,
-0.31840914487838745,
0.5855384469032288,
-0.766007661819458,
-0.11496654152870178,
0.3053646981716156,
0.3557898700237274,
0.18922807276248932,
0.19726143777370453,
-0.8348589539527893,
0.4421935975551605,
-0.30360326170921326,
-0.040697820484638214,
0.11147987097501755,
0.5263753533363342,
-0.2322159707546234,
0.6482766270637512,
0.5803418159484863,
0.3221339285373688,
0.23153415322303772,
0.29169899225234985,
0.10976709425449371,
-0.45506665110588074,
-0.5957769155502319,
-0.8077904582023621,
0.11729582399129868,
-0.16797763109207153,
-0.5173202157020569,
1.223438024520874,
0.5080201029777527,
0.35107243061065674,
-0.2318093329668045,
0.6492421627044678,
-0.1773415505886078,
1.1974800825119019,
-0.08017434179782867,
0.7529426217079163,
-0.41899538040161133,
-0.2785659432411194,
-0.27944955229759216,
-0.914524257183075,
-0.534744381904602,
0.2490396797657013,
-0.15700434148311615,
-0.4697037935256958,
1.2531678676605225,
1.010993480682373,
0.1572355329990387,
-0.07466401159763336,
0.3693835139274597,
0.16155165433883667,
0.0931491032242775,
0.17729227244853973,
0.5514300465583801,
-0.198741152882576,
0.4840107560157776,
-0.16794972121715546,
-0.27821481227874756,
-0.3893871009349823,
-0.9412248134613037,
-1.0208581686019897,
-0.680198609828949,
-0.49462631344795227,
-0.46808063983917236,
0.38660287857055664,
0.9042726159095764,
0.8109773397445679,
-1.0016472339630127,
-0.41099369525909424,
0.43278124928474426,
0.5184611678123474,
-0.9238846302032471,
-0.15338653326034546,
0.530735969543457,
-0.09122806042432785,
-0.8054143190383911,
0.4883691668510437,
0.40165019035339355,
-0.04095153883099556,
-0.32178357243537903,
-0.0963139683008194,
0.03226599842309952,
0.14379450678825378,
0.5706490874290466,
0.9100642204284668,
-0.8197525143623352,
-0.3080586791038513,
-0.3319217562675476,
-0.3109000623226166,
-0.5711973309516907,
1.0810195207595825,
-0.7041776180267334,
0.4784192144870758,
0.36517006158828735,
0.5305601358413696,
0.24188043177127838,
-0.4494110643863678,
0.37668779492378235,
-0.5174112319946289,
0.6160901784896851,
-0.122553750872612,
0.10823863744735718,
0.011080491356551647,
0.0774366557598114,
0.16490811109542847,
0.29433536529541016,
-0.42367789149284363,
-0.7882845401763916,
0.1081373393535614,
-0.24983909726142883,
-0.17290110886096954,
0.9465875625610352,
-0.0007110285223461688,
-0.5571801662445068,
-0.2907179892063141,
-0.21709378063678741,
-0.3934757113456726,
0.0831800326704979,
0.4470173716545105,
0.6303232908248901,
0.5892375707626343,
-0.04589339345693588,
-0.3492307662963867,
0.8282961845397949,
0.17201754450798035,
-0.6805470585823059,
0.08057249337434769,
0.23202453553676605,
0.38968220353126526,
0.2801811397075653,
0.6096210479736328,
0.2327548861503601,
0.1686978042125702,
-0.3081768751144409,
0.3071615993976593,
0.11977768689393997,
-0.611760139465332,
0.13636797666549683,
0.6675369739532471,
0.026955243200063705,
-0.20937326550483704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08335v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08335v1
|
Toward a Theory of Tokenization in LLMs
| 2024-04-12T09:01:14 | 2024-04-12T09:01:14 |
Nived Rajaraman, Jiantao Jiao, Kannan Ramchandran
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
While there has been a large body of research attempting to circumvent
tokenization for language modeling (Clark et al., 2022; Xue et al., 2022), the
current consensus is that it is a necessary initial step for designing
state-of-the-art performant language models. In this paper, we investigate
tokenization from a theoretical point of view by studying the behavior of
transformers on simple data generating processes. When trained on data drawn
from certain simple $k^{\text{th}}$-order Markov processes for $k > 1$,
transformers exhibit a surprising phenomenon - in the absence of tokenization,
they empirically fail to learn the right distribution and predict characters
according to a unigram model (Makkuva et al., 2024). With the addition of
tokenization, however, we empirically observe that transformers break through
this barrier and are able to model the probabilities of sequences drawn from
the source near-optimally, achieving small cross-entropy loss. With this
observation as starting point, we study the end-to-end cross-entropy loss
achieved by transformers with and without tokenization. With the appropriate
tokenization, we show that even the simplest unigram models (over tokens)
learnt by transformers are able to model the probability of sequences drawn
from $k^{\text{th}}$-order Markov sources near optimally. Our analysis provides
a justification for the use of tokenization in practice through studying the
behavior of transformers on Markovian data.
|
[
-0.22187592089176178,
-0.5733508467674255,
0.5504036545753479,
-0.1958436518907547,
-0.4506065249443054,
-0.04373880848288536,
-0.23353125154972076,
-0.2136390209197998,
0.16280759871006012,
0.33817780017852783,
-0.4144989848136902,
-0.27320051193237305,
-0.689161479473114,
-0.12439122051000595,
-0.7560235857963562,
1.045271873474121,
0.031086904928088188,
0.19199788570404053,
0.08536896854639053,
0.133781298995018,
-0.3314998745918274,
-0.818070113658905,
-0.5471821427345276,
-0.44043758511543274,
0.5962987542152405,
0.19715236127376556,
0.673383891582489,
0.7378300428390503,
0.3662433922290802,
0.26043057441711426,
-0.011066928505897522,
-0.29356980323791504,
-0.4493663012981415,
0.17417725920677185,
0.055516086518764496,
-1.0992622375488281,
-0.07694441080093384,
0.11141808331012726,
0.6757749319076538,
0.9622930288314819,
-0.2247588187456131,
0.1675516813993454,
-0.03818690404295921,
0.3495175838470459,
-0.19439369440078735,
0.048549819737672806,
-0.9681953191757202,
0.24988426268100739,
-0.48672252893447876,
-0.4820864200592041,
-0.6781697869300842,
0.1404137909412384,
-0.28362178802490234,
-0.2680405378341675,
0.3334755599498749,
0.2758783996105194,
0.5824670195579529,
0.1411123275756836,
-0.447051078081131,
-0.17861714959144592,
-1.0377594232559204,
0.822815477848053,
-0.6167794466018677,
0.4623032212257385,
0.2353663593530655,
0.2972213327884674,
-0.26125097274780273,
-0.8420752286911011,
-0.6707652807235718,
-0.13272824883460999,
-0.09260955452919006,
-0.03192324936389923,
-0.42115068435668945,
0.11170694977045059,
0.2843606770038605,
0.32841482758522034,
-0.1144789457321167,
0.3324487507343292,
-0.4472651481628418,
-0.17469815909862518,
0.15181049704551697,
0.5373767018318176,
0.23849251866340637,
-0.3238235116004944,
-0.5530501008033752,
0.018782170489430428,
-0.7018902897834778,
0.14891114830970764,
0.5025824904441833,
0.45717573165893555,
0.01881391555070877,
0.9497427344322205,
0.2990441918373108,
0.30371251702308655,
0.059034861624240875,
0.08662493526935577,
-0.1838657557964325,
-0.37767571210861206,
-0.2605290412902832,
-0.06184465065598488,
0.6096890568733215,
0.07861419767141342,
0.3909333348274231,
-0.5327953696250916,
-0.38439470529556274,
0.18259276449680328,
0.38422316312789917,
-0.6309922337532043,
-0.16452479362487793,
0.17315219342708588,
-0.6563156247138977,
-0.4978678822517395,
0.19325478374958038,
-0.304237961769104,
-0.14127898216247559,
-0.3584512770175934,
0.33355244994163513,
-0.3340959846973419,
-0.18109415471553802,
-0.052157241851091385,
-0.1289922147989273,
0.23959463834762573,
-0.0560002401471138,
-1.1035481691360474,
0.3735578656196594,
0.7450518012046814,
0.8255387544631958,
-0.5201610922813416,
-0.41659536957740784,
-0.36544233560562134,
0.26118630170822144,
-0.370338499546051,
0.7722040414810181,
-0.5733484625816345,
-0.47007158398628235,
-0.04909595102071762,
-0.06586448103189468,
-0.08257623016834259,
-0.3393861651420593,
0.26702970266342163,
-0.6370680332183838,
0.01603868044912815,
-0.010793570429086685,
-0.7048514485359192,
0.11786295473575592,
-0.14418376982212067,
-0.5206860303878784,
0.8731837272644043,
-0.04811201989650726,
-0.8783130049705505,
0.6935068964958191,
-0.5957093834877014,
-0.37105631828308105,
-0.20664681494235992,
-0.03396740183234215,
-0.2306220382452011,
0.672866702079773,
-0.1933777630329132,
0.539184033870697,
-0.2253943234682083,
0.3922366201877594,
-0.1565447747707367,
-0.47821447253227234,
0.6747580766677856,
-0.7877222895622253,
0.6454586982727051,
0.19898948073387146,
-0.33436912298202515,
0.08638685941696167,
-0.7674404978752136,
-0.13163971900939941,
0.09589014947414398,
-0.5434514880180359,
-0.23411840200424194,
0.18366660177707672,
0.20574401319026947,
0.0854678824543953,
-0.2087765783071518,
-0.519467294216156,
0.3017866015434265,
-0.495453804731369,
0.3843308985233307,
1.1240488290786743,
-0.06753046065568924,
0.8458476662635803,
-0.3088746666908264,
0.5213963389396667,
0.4709520637989044,
0.22222673892974854,
-0.3610592782497406,
-0.4696909487247467,
-1.0100566148757935,
-0.30428165197372437,
0.4407747685909271,
0.3014502227306366,
-0.539006233215332,
0.32439374923706055,
-0.18885672092437744,
-0.29277169704437256,
-0.34789255261421204,
-0.13678757846355438,
-0.012920728884637356,
0.298256516456604,
0.23680616915225983,
-0.43845945596694946,
-0.7978304624557495,
-0.7556299567222595,
-0.3607277274131775,
-0.42812198400497437,
-0.27478286623954773,
-0.08433783799409866,
0.26235851645469666,
-0.37209808826446533,
1.1391384601593018,
-0.21211251616477966,
-0.08514714986085892,
-0.3240107595920563,
0.07787206023931503,
0.4866355061531067,
0.5929426550865173,
0.14571787416934967,
-0.44628849625587463,
-0.07597926259040833,
-0.10932176560163498,
-0.48409411311149597,
0.03896116837859154,
-0.19198837876319885,
0.06159062311053276,
0.4824349284172058,
0.5836021900177002,
-0.8108461499214172,
0.6859279870986938,
0.2572452127933502,
-0.2786388099193573,
0.40718817710876465,
-0.15164202451705933,
-0.36278054118156433,
-1.2829781770706177,
0.07636115700006485,
-0.19800132513046265,
-0.25545117259025574,
-0.9842312932014465,
-0.14910608530044556,
-0.3423740863800049,
0.0038993051275610924,
-0.48879390954971313,
0.4951671361923218,
-0.30908676981925964,
-0.2598166763782501,
-0.3284185826778412,
-0.2374681681394577,
-0.37529903650283813,
0.6158695220947266,
-0.11776746064424515,
0.5213037133216858,
0.615951657295227,
-0.670179009437561,
0.03057294338941574,
-0.07235174626111984,
-0.32433006167411804,
0.4264191687107086,
-0.655156672000885,
-0.02960542030632496,
-0.29180821776390076,
0.17192934453487396,
-1.121293544769287,
0.07125632464885712,
0.41334038972854614,
-0.49404218792915344,
0.46640339493751526,
-0.366115540266037,
-0.696951687335968,
-0.04329634830355644,
-0.05888370797038078,
0.5768434405326843,
0.8364992141723633,
-0.5923961400985718,
0.5653144717216492,
0.47949182987213135,
0.3177810311317444,
-0.39209553599357605,
-0.7945160865783691,
0.16261176764965057,
-0.4366844892501831,
-0.4209395945072174,
0.2279493808746338,
-0.07670357078313828,
-0.2206181138753891,
-0.1355167180299759,
-0.00785911176353693,
0.1396469920873642,
0.2208852618932724,
0.3576405346393585,
0.2503737807273865,
-0.08195658028125763,
0.2087886482477188,
-0.2559293210506439,
-0.5319988131523132,
0.18277928233146667,
-0.5219451189041138,
0.7147843837738037,
0.07398927956819534,
-0.6510162353515625,
-0.4564793109893799,
0.06885714083909988,
0.4142724275588989,
0.28738510608673096,
0.8691743612289429,
0.7755591869354248,
-0.39866116642951965,
-0.24689312279224396,
-0.34887632727622986,
-0.3137281835079193,
-0.5108001828193665,
0.2129213809967041,
-0.47749078273773193,
-0.7697867751121521,
0.7653726935386658,
-0.044062290340662,
-0.006946469657123089,
0.5167761445045471,
0.8286814093589783,
-0.2420329749584198,
0.9876346588134766,
0.7345931529998779,
-0.0051384116522967815,
0.5034219622612,
-0.38525667786598206,
0.47064560651779175,
-0.706917405128479,
-0.2963288128376007,
-0.3930774927139282,
-0.3762354552745819,
-0.8856499195098877,
-0.6046514511108398,
0.3009020686149597,
0.14996425807476044,
-0.058479469269514084,
0.3037854731082916,
-0.24573752284049988,
0.5021305084228516,
0.6323531866073608,
-0.30863359570503235,
0.3255539536476135,
0.24697598814964294,
-0.438612699508667,
-0.0409700907766819,
-0.94829261302948,
-0.5288659334182739,
1.106257677078247,
0.47212857007980347,
1.034870982170105,
-0.006436533760279417,
0.8259162902832031,
0.3912036418914795,
0.30156028270721436,
-0.8098652362823486,
0.5007545948028564,
0.175508052110672,
-0.5725144147872925,
-0.47277379035949707,
-0.3400038182735443,
-1.3056234121322632,
0.20809093117713928,
-0.10078972578048706,
-0.8078950643539429,
0.2003439962863922,
0.029198652133345604,
0.11033577471971512,
0.7561498284339905,
-0.48396986722946167,
0.5968874096870422,
0.016184715554118156,
0.1226460337638855,
-0.102235808968544,
-0.5795838236808777,
0.45360106229782104,
-0.2299339324235916,
0.2308107614517212,
-0.019388427957892418,
-0.22035802900791168,
0.6878454685211182,
-0.6297305226325989,
1.0587762594223022,
-0.1934656947851181,
-0.05436083301901817,
0.3734787106513977,
0.17352354526519775,
0.6635780334472656,
-0.029265450313687325,
0.16270458698272705,
0.3353700041770935,
0.022651175037026405,
-0.5324987173080444,
-0.5623143911361694,
0.32878583669662476,
-0.6813027262687683,
-0.4793422222137451,
-0.39733266830444336,
-0.3772488534450531,
0.015084818936884403,
0.06626800447702408,
0.4581429660320282,
0.3437463343143463,
-0.16225729882717133,
-0.19962814450263977,
0.291978120803833,
-0.01168079860508442,
0.7130889892578125,
0.283525675535202,
-0.3045850992202759,
-0.2667997181415558,
0.9532353281974792,
0.2064424753189087,
0.26602238416671753,
0.18509846925735474,
0.15394097566604614,
-0.2524269223213196,
-0.6420549750328064,
-0.3556353449821472,
0.16396833956241608,
-0.9412457346916199,
-0.18183788657188416,
-0.4700559675693512,
-0.2461114078760147,
-0.04053819924592972,
0.020868832245469093,
-0.2712273895740509,
-0.7117136716842651,
-0.5138354897499084,
-0.25623729825019836,
0.10190403461456299,
0.8225541710853577,
-0.18750905990600586,
0.40296417474746704,
-0.8139259219169617,
0.10598539561033249,
0.16362793743610382,
0.37861138582229614,
0.38342198729515076,
-0.8151536583900452,
-0.44936272501945496,
-0.10987970978021622,
-0.1386549025774002,
-0.6518652439117432,
0.20320749282836914,
-0.0999213382601738,
0.6568509340286255,
0.49340444803237915,
-0.14132912456989288,
0.6842331290245056,
-0.8348831534385681,
0.8120492696762085,
0.35501450300216675,
-1.1573258638381958,
-0.0005344737437553704,
-0.26351451873779297,
-0.038904041051864624,
0.31499218940734863,
0.1021561473608017,
-0.8679776191711426,
-0.4966448247432709,
-0.813246488571167,
-0.8061179518699646,
0.6665971875190735,
0.39574408531188965,
0.5566715598106384,
-0.29572078585624695,
0.23935309052467346,
0.3457503318786621,
0.22369778156280518,
-0.7192070484161377,
-0.41457751393318176,
-0.11385659873485565,
-0.1077994853258133,
-0.14418166875839233,
-0.2582513988018036,
0.26346975564956665,
-0.21728673577308655,
0.5757555961608887,
-0.05237352102994919,
0.6362063884735107,
-0.17882029712200165,
-0.2668144106864929,
-0.26575037837028503,
0.23296289145946503,
0.6145554780960083,
0.5105327367782593,
0.04283011332154274,
0.49330925941467285,
0.11759154498577118,
-0.14518694579601288,
0.3242456912994385,
-0.3456032872200012,
-0.22827428579330444,
0.17610228061676025,
0.27433764934539795,
0.8327624797821045,
0.2712194621562958,
-0.38993826508522034,
0.4916767477989197,
0.018958542495965958,
0.20867659151554108,
-0.314435213804245,
-0.04354560002684593,
0.024564199149608612,
0.3414863348007202,
0.5655326843261719,
0.26898306608200073,
-0.0950518399477005,
-0.6730036735534668,
0.44723039865493774,
0.6918333172798157,
-0.3784177601337433,
-0.76926189661026,
0.8073153495788574,
-0.09472282975912094,
-0.5490147471427917,
0.665080189704895,
0.004407778847962618,
-0.3952968120574951,
0.4969941973686218,
0.6417199969291687,
1.0027199983596802,
0.049765292555093765,
0.10973720997571945,
0.10408918559551239,
0.4481610357761383,
-0.10423716902732849,
-0.02974110282957554,
-0.12100687623023987,
-0.7417116761207581,
-0.38486382365226746,
-0.7604043483734131,
-0.20498205721378326,
-0.28733596205711365,
-0.45580995082855225,
0.3004297912120819,
-0.35245952010154724,
-0.466230183839798,
-0.19131700694561005,
-0.4983765184879303,
-0.7256531119346619,
-0.1270766705274582,
0.22679202258586884,
0.7997322082519531,
-0.8782743215560913,
0.8170732259750366,
0.1934879869222641,
-0.3298925459384918,
-0.5237835049629211,
0.11226896941661835,
-0.3561736047267914,
-1.1740809679031372,
0.7543359398841858,
0.07447599619626999,
0.2025277316570282,
0.04346603527665138,
-0.41735410690307617,
-1.010486364364624,
0.9656771421432495,
0.27968883514404297,
-0.09818292409181595,
-0.13170456886291504,
0.5648316144943237,
0.627888560295105,
-0.3590969443321228,
0.16814903914928436,
0.5413774251937866,
0.3986111581325531,
0.05878289043903351,
-0.6099302768707275,
-0.020751144737005234,
-0.07558272778987885,
0.2787238359451294,
0.5080936551094055,
-0.40582141280174255,
0.8756150007247925,
-0.39493629336357117,
-0.60853111743927,
0.16466526687145233,
0.7087054252624512,
0.02136494405567646,
0.2279093861579895,
0.4414440393447876,
0.47734570503234863,
0.5096077919006348,
-0.024556390941143036,
1.078311800956726,
-0.3157074451446533,
0.44453203678131104,
0.6782517433166504,
-0.03399991616606712,
0.7249037027359009,
1.0577242374420166,
-0.49232399463653564,
0.40097278356552124,
0.5284519791603088,
-0.08290970325469971,
0.4846477508544922,
0.5840538144111633,
0.007879065349698067,
-0.18101783096790314,
-0.13110405206680298,
0.16266582906246185,
0.3431341350078583,
-0.007925903424620628,
-0.4761162996292114,
-0.07904870808124542,
0.05936696007847786,
-0.1750718355178833,
-0.33079251646995544,
-0.21232756972312927,
0.7487185597419739,
0.2863585352897644,
-0.3145498037338257,
0.5359302163124084,
0.28794389963150024,
0.6414682269096375,
-0.4033595323562622,
0.2512434422969818,
-0.24071891605854034,
-0.15748341381549835,
-0.09147787094116211,
-0.4554428458213806,
0.4140574038028717,
0.07894814014434814,
-0.249101459980011,
-0.3272388279438019,
0.645967423915863,
-0.2970738410949707,
-0.7391350865364075,
0.047857992351055145,
0.5954124331474304,
0.4116833209991455,
0.37398460507392883,
-0.2689836323261261,
-0.08845198899507523,
-0.25242534279823303,
-0.481845498085022,
0.4869552254676819,
0.355473130941391,
0.04885147511959076,
0.5992688536643982,
0.8330938220024109,
0.1716359257698059,
0.386383980512619,
0.07003432512283325,
0.6183767318725586,
-0.7346594333648682,
-0.4367823600769043,
-1.1988985538482666,
0.7194749116897583,
0.3256034255027771,
0.02429181896150112,
0.5301274657249451,
0.5710223317146301,
0.9187303185462952,
-0.09794646501541138,
0.6525375247001648,
0.16560007631778717,
0.1308847963809967,
-0.6521269083023071,
0.5052527189254761,
-0.30269789695739746,
0.41298907995224,
-0.043319642543792725,
-1.004150152206421,
-0.3558359742164612,
0.30469462275505066,
0.17590399086475372,
0.09367100149393082,
0.7062667012214661,
0.7736994028091431,
-0.1727566421031952,
-0.18849101662635803,
0.6359124183654785,
0.08073060214519501,
0.26400721073150635,
0.3364843726158142,
1.040052056312561,
-0.5131063461303711,
0.5177176594734192,
-0.07743656635284424,
0.23288601636886597,
-0.07510977238416672,
-0.7108566761016846,
-1.0887264013290405,
-0.7956163883209229,
0.11313587427139282,
-0.3093583881855011,
-0.2669777274131775,
0.9391286373138428,
0.4214741885662079,
-0.6269699931144714,
-0.37962862849235535,
-0.2891552448272705,
0.1963970959186554,
0.0610908679664135,
-0.19606634974479675,
0.24810846149921417,
-0.5728826522827148,
-0.6611955165863037,
0.26162540912628174,
0.341482937335968,
0.44441279768943787,
-0.5279628038406372,
-0.17560245096683502,
0.19964390993118286,
0.49802690744400024,
0.4258906841278076,
0.052648186683654785,
-0.8430770635604858,
-0.33954641222953796,
0.03861894831061363,
-0.07698940485715866,
0.37187713384628296,
1.2607289552688599,
-0.8451473116874695,
0.1512167900800705,
0.3663167655467987,
0.6135923266410828,
0.5810654759407043,
-0.1431632936000824,
0.5597710609436035,
-0.8265434503555298,
0.059486597776412964,
-0.01791161671280861,
0.46884697675704956,
0.1641990840435028,
-0.19159547984600067,
0.43653586506843567,
0.49225249886512756,
-0.3311747610569,
-1.2349048852920532,
0.42549359798431396,
-0.7192025184631348,
-0.14674338698387146,
0.9744217395782471,
0.2304692566394806,
-0.1958385854959488,
0.026533929631114006,
0.018302740529179573,
0.5338510870933533,
-0.1654644012451172,
0.9148234128952026,
0.6782214641571045,
-0.13087500631809235,
-0.007088662125170231,
-0.17300066351890564,
0.43404144048690796,
0.5618540644645691,
-0.5350092649459839,
0.19068001210689545,
-0.03067382238805294,
0.25234612822532654,
0.045411545783281326,
0.5916606783866882,
0.07092196494340897,
0.012250741012394428,
-0.12839801609516144,
-0.11960241198539734,
0.032420363277196884,
-0.22649551928043365,
-0.6099936962127686,
0.10292802006006241,
0.288551390171051,
-0.03803477808833122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08313v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08313v1
|
The Integration of Semantic and Structural Knowledge in Knowledge Graph Entity Typing
| 2024-04-12T08:17:44 | 2024-04-12T08:17:44 |
Muzhi Li, Minda Hu, Irwin King, Ho-fung Leung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The Knowledge Graph Entity Typing (KGET) task aims to predict missing type
annotations for entities in knowledge graphs. Recent works only utilize the
\textit{\textbf{structural knowledge}} in the local neighborhood of entities,
disregarding \textit{\textbf{semantic knowledge}} in the textual
representations of entities, relations, and types that are also crucial for
type inference. Additionally, we observe that the interaction between semantic
and structural knowledge can be utilized to address the false-negative problem.
In this paper, we propose a novel \textbf{\underline{S}}emantic and
\textbf{\underline{S}}tructure-aware KG \textbf{\underline{E}}ntity
\textbf{\underline{T}}yping~{(SSET)} framework, which is composed of three
modules. First, the \textit{Semantic Knowledge Encoding} module encodes factual
knowledge in the KG with a Masked Entity Typing task. Then, the
\textit{Structural Knowledge Aggregation} module aggregates knowledge from the
multi-hop neighborhood of entities to infer missing types. Finally, the
\textit{Unsupervised Type Re-ranking} module utilizes the inference results
from the two models above to generate type predictions that are robust to
false-negative samples. Extensive experiments show that SSET significantly
outperforms existing state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.30971187353134155,
-0.7101030349731445,
0.577314555644989,
0.06214834004640579,
-0.21689963340759277,
0.41159406304359436,
0.1411578506231308,
-0.46059462428092957,
0.9002088904380798,
0.36665862798690796,
-0.16959135234355927,
-0.9676812291145325,
-0.5634539127349854,
-0.027836117893457413,
-0.2579954266548157,
0.6758019328117371,
-0.26722392439842224,
-0.14202819764614105,
-0.29207557439804077,
-0.126357764005661,
-0.38385680317878723,
-0.21703650057315826,
-0.25447869300842285,
-0.22590062022209167,
0.4921891987323761,
0.1968199461698532,
0.5268936157226562,
0.5246504545211792,
0.2159314751625061,
0.20087525248527527,
0.0028576271142810583,
0.13933786749839783,
-0.3385491967201233,
0.0738479420542717,
-0.25685304403305054,
-0.5430610179901123,
-0.6423984169960022,
-0.05676707625389099,
0.5604091882705688,
0.684904932975769,
0.037153203040361404,
0.06476790457963943,
-0.09038317948579788,
0.6112093925476074,
-0.46586716175079346,
0.4076966345310211,
-0.9183204770088196,
0.33161109685897827,
-0.3504687249660492,
-0.33771848678588867,
-0.5266091823577881,
-0.3068898320198059,
0.016117148101329803,
-0.7695995569229126,
0.16630730032920837,
0.13043071329593658,
0.846467912197113,
0.4162454307079315,
-0.9016116857528687,
-0.16622748970985413,
-0.3298921585083008,
0.1696266531944275,
-0.3415093719959259,
0.7147235870361328,
0.5239541530609131,
0.2474021464586258,
-0.16802699863910675,
-0.42868736386299133,
-0.314897745847702,
-0.26735252141952515,
-0.21851445734500885,
0.36890870332717896,
0.13133081793785095,
0.35149896144866943,
-0.0547337606549263,
0.272002637386322,
-0.4444130063056946,
0.14217548072338104,
-0.42098042368888855,
-0.5816567540168762,
0.22403502464294434,
-0.2502399682998657,
0.49896231293678284,
-0.5778687596321106,
-0.24432286620140076,
0.32614782452583313,
-0.9661197066307068,
-0.22474317252635956,
0.2834983468055725,
0.4544469118118286,
-0.06115826964378357,
1.0529356002807617,
-0.35667335987091064,
0.6348884701728821,
0.075861357152462,
0.04883299767971039,
0.4400631785392761,
-0.10878749191761017,
-0.34664592146873474,
0.24256056547164917,
0.3502240777015686,
0.052089668810367584,
0.04937945678830147,
-0.6736152172088623,
0.025824302807450294,
0.5221713781356812,
0.24321667850017548,
-0.5610821843147278,
-0.24709032475948334,
0.3571103811264038,
-0.2988089919090271,
-0.4930436909198761,
-0.36923277378082275,
-0.5549404621124268,
-0.3796861469745636,
-0.17002375423908234,
0.7950299382209778,
-0.6950318813323975,
-0.526444137096405,
-0.24990110099315643,
-0.630904495716095,
-0.20649096369743347,
0.16572421789169312,
-0.48233023285865784,
-0.15488757193088531,
0.4465595781803131,
0.7184338569641113,
0.2522185742855072,
0.005267164204269648,
-0.5181823968887329,
0.6525348424911499,
-0.2448083460330963,
0.81396484375,
-0.7042218446731567,
-0.3355291187763214,
-0.14026738703250885,
-0.3531825840473175,
-0.31320032477378845,
-0.12512509524822235,
0.4650821089744568,
-0.8550435304641724,
-0.033160123974084854,
-0.25756481289863586,
-0.934682309627533,
-0.34388646483421326,
0.513358473777771,
-0.637140691280365,
1.0166869163513184,
0.511672854423523,
-1.0853625535964966,
0.6129793524742126,
-0.6752761006355286,
-0.6429107785224915,
0.24201790988445282,
-0.3287230134010315,
-0.38782405853271484,
-0.018258634954690933,
-0.061921700835227966,
0.4788702428340912,
0.05204392597079277,
0.10502254217863083,
-0.9751233458518982,
-0.05713622272014618,
-0.18620732426643372,
0.3229926526546478,
0.48679545521736145,
-0.16735801100730896,
-0.24491150677204132,
-0.32369714975357056,
-1.1633542776107788,
0.21912690997123718,
-0.08653664588928223,
-0.2599618136882782,
-0.7693382501602173,
-0.09053284674882889,
-0.6797903776168823,
0.2078435868024826,
0.1121017262339592,
-0.9140727519989014,
0.1494225412607193,
-0.3774876594543457,
0.5516215562820435,
0.7212558388710022,
0.2346833199262619,
0.4262573719024658,
0.0821399837732315,
0.3567134141921997,
0.11022915691137314,
-0.20923003554344177,
0.5800818800926208,
-0.32224240899086,
-0.5765791535377502,
-0.45163074135780334,
0.3253307044506073,
0.593061625957489,
-1.382616639137268,
0.307466059923172,
-0.42949622869491577,
-0.8689123392105103,
-0.1277269572019577,
-0.13412807881832123,
0.5999473333358765,
0.9006721377372742,
0.664113461971283,
-0.0400075688958168,
-0.48301181197166443,
-0.739263653755188,
-0.4898543655872345,
-0.218777135014534,
0.13173750042915344,
0.43421027064323425,
0.5029999613761902,
-0.18213222920894623,
1.0287529230117798,
-0.7507414221763611,
-0.3314419686794281,
-0.08638761937618256,
0.24294140934944153,
-0.11386143416166306,
0.519608199596405,
0.48561593890190125,
-0.9588119983673096,
-0.542120099067688,
-0.03683876991271973,
-0.8145512342453003,
0.2003447562456131,
0.38789108395576477,
-0.3807186186313629,
0.04951215535402298,
0.21536698937416077,
-0.7964581847190857,
0.4649428427219391,
0.40809670090675354,
-0.5540008544921875,
0.670051097869873,
0.1653178334236145,
0.05097110942006111,
-1.2937792539596558,
-0.1882445365190506,
-0.010742063634097576,
-0.09266798198223114,
-0.5836887359619141,
-0.14032310247421265,
0.23132729530334473,
-0.2197025567293167,
-0.10194960981607437,
0.4895728826522827,
-0.32051095366477966,
-0.3589727580547333,
0.270646870136261,
0.35539788007736206,
0.12099505215883255,
0.6866308450698853,
0.1904553920030594,
0.4778105318546295,
0.5480342507362366,
-0.7500683665275574,
0.03308134526014328,
0.5363511443138123,
-0.002034114906564355,
0.8761022090911865,
-0.4180692434310913,
0.036434244364500046,
-0.28383105993270874,
0.2355121225118637,
-1.068621039390564,
-0.301350861787796,
0.20651377737522125,
-0.7254688143730164,
0.5527177453041077,
-0.7296334505081177,
-0.28517821431159973,
-0.6194372773170471,
-0.2509646713733673,
0.24770982563495636,
-0.02423027716577053,
-0.25811731815338135,
1.1519279479980469,
0.33344221115112305,
0.13328377902507782,
-0.6523080468177795,
-0.8526688814163208,
-0.08314830809831619,
-0.13477309048175812,
-0.8462089896202087,
0.44094008207321167,
0.26134344935417175,
0.22419673204421997,
0.5778568983078003,
-0.47599053382873535,
-0.39515113830566406,
0.22959579527378082,
0.27385643124580383,
0.38945192098617554,
-0.45624005794525146,
0.5172637104988098,
0.513642430305481,
-0.27652353048324585,
-0.29970112442970276,
-0.6704084873199463,
0.31619197130203247,
0.06002720817923546,
-0.5621834993362427,
-0.17354987561702728,
-0.17466981709003448,
0.5087934136390686,
-0.32163333892822266,
0.6698217391967773,
0.45991250872612,
-0.4510374963283539,
-0.033600710332393646,
-0.48878487944602966,
0.07216411083936691,
-0.43873900175094604,
0.651177704334259,
-0.6474031805992126,
-0.9127758145332336,
0.44911855459213257,
0.04657420143485069,
-0.23333580791950226,
0.5968834161758423,
0.08481639623641968,
-0.13528762757778168,
0.573849081993103,
0.41689470410346985,
0.17394882440567017,
0.2988317012786865,
-0.23256565630435944,
0.44232505559921265,
-0.85984206199646,
-0.03192718327045441,
-0.4261620342731476,
-0.09376660734415054,
-0.7234216332435608,
-0.18312126398086548,
0.5102241635322571,
0.060342829674482346,
-0.31949755549430847,
0.8283249139785767,
-0.3194423317909241,
0.1943705826997757,
0.42448318004608154,
0.30291756987571716,
0.16949522495269775,
0.01776961423456669,
-0.67821204662323,
0.09445323050022125,
-0.6574850678443909,
-0.0052737887017428875,
1.2166674137115479,
0.028850002214312553,
0.2294924259185791,
0.04348132759332657,
1.039039134979248,
0.6017735004425049,
0.49465546011924744,
-0.7349525094032288,
0.5257171392440796,
-0.19570164382457733,
-0.7685307860374451,
-0.45428234338760376,
-0.7278544902801514,
-0.3730316758155823,
0.2625413239002228,
-0.06040708348155022,
-0.8411550521850586,
0.26103702187538147,
0.5587003827095032,
-0.23928479850292206,
0.5044544339179993,
-1.057037591934204,
0.8528909087181091,
0.251312792301178,
0.07215418666601181,
-0.2603069245815277,
-0.578274667263031,
0.2316540628671646,
0.04710673913359642,
0.03685189411044121,
-0.05329841747879982,
0.3179648816585541,
0.6183488368988037,
-0.3380708396434784,
1.018818736076355,
-0.6079282164573669,
-0.018710309639573097,
0.3911602795124054,
0.47600361704826355,
1.0527265071868896,
0.01174559723585844,
-0.05777856335043907,
0.03694102540612221,
-0.058200523257255554,
-0.4407157301902771,
-0.7638518810272217,
0.3406218886375427,
-0.717215359210968,
-0.3833402097225189,
0.1457175314426422,
-0.26196709275245667,
-0.7248461842536926,
0.4452982544898987,
0.28525832295417786,
0.8715887069702148,
0.007600690703839064,
0.03497806563973427,
0.6035877466201782,
0.0442158468067646,
-0.04069066420197487,
0.5644686818122864,
0.17078441381454468,
-0.7001675963401794,
1.4677624702453613,
0.695747971534729,
0.37397149205207825,
1.0960381031036377,
0.03060293197631836,
-0.4202919900417328,
-0.36922743916511536,
-0.4704776108264923,
0.34651899337768555,
-0.9483938217163086,
-0.45909953117370605,
-0.9297552108764648,
-0.32469552755355835,
-0.42751118540763855,
-0.3668017089366913,
-0.5097671747207642,
-0.8728628754615784,
-0.024435296654701233,
-0.668974757194519,
0.30310457944869995,
0.4220443069934845,
0.06867566704750061,
0.042775169014930725,
-0.8278487920761108,
0.22287403047084808,
0.254921019077301,
0.49649444222450256,
0.17050479352474213,
-0.15682575106620789,
-0.11773097515106201,
-0.07696406543254852,
-0.06708534806966782,
-0.911271870136261,
0.01564597152173519,
-0.0788785070180893,
0.581095278263092,
0.3379373848438263,
0.15288959443569183,
0.4758269786834717,
-0.15303027629852295,
0.48225751519203186,
0.09478255361318588,
-0.7764918208122253,
0.3605571389198303,
-0.41932928562164307,
-0.3914130628108978,
0.5173985362052917,
0.5006130337715149,
-0.7176940441131592,
-0.7306601405143738,
-0.6676828265190125,
-0.5560094118118286,
0.43542495369911194,
0.45885539054870605,
-0.41204264760017395,
-0.07124315202236176,
0.25860753655433655,
0.01648315228521824,
0.47276821732521057,
-0.8621408939361572,
-0.27768585085868835,
-0.6658634543418884,
-0.4441109299659729,
0.4686603248119354,
-0.35752472281455994,
-0.04042378067970276,
0.0393289178609848,
0.9852727651596069,
-0.1088506355881691,
0.5704836249351501,
0.3162842094898224,
-0.5034117102622986,
0.14771459996700287,
0.25335821509361267,
0.3866792619228363,
0.40124431252479553,
-0.3136206269264221,
0.41592440009117126,
0.1128726527094841,
-0.47435030341148376,
0.010507768951356411,
0.2060956358909607,
-0.4692747890949249,
-0.1846451759338379,
0.3620707094669342,
0.5465362668037415,
0.2740969657897949,
-0.0004334842087700963,
0.1770160049200058,
0.39331379532814026,
-0.25434839725494385,
-0.30917781591415405,
-0.14076514542102814,
0.17198409140110016,
0.14195314049720764,
0.18758980929851532,
0.2873898148536682,
0.02338234893977642,
0.020497558638453484,
0.19548101723194122,
0.29384303092956543,
-0.6527222990989685,
-0.5327734351158142,
0.38743939995765686,
0.42572256922721863,
-0.05919112265110016,
0.3584999144077301,
-0.6851403117179871,
-0.9344677329063416,
0.7378911972045898,
0.5658150315284729,
0.7675964832305908,
-0.08055541664361954,
0.5974549055099487,
0.27797335386276245,
0.24222517013549805,
0.43858110904693604,
0.22709991037845612,
-0.27176520228385925,
-1.1231788396835327,
-0.3238706886768341,
-0.4985002875328064,
0.0660489872097969,
-0.27093857526779175,
-0.2918825149536133,
0.2401268184185028,
-0.2954880893230438,
0.04221951216459274,
-0.03973209485411644,
0.08541107177734375,
-0.5330933928489685,
0.24379846453666687,
-0.04633534699678421,
1.1026098728179932,
-0.986217737197876,
0.7038772702217102,
0.7729198336601257,
-0.7396073937416077,
-0.9059388637542725,
-0.12144133448600769,
0.024569973349571228,
-1.2060754299163818,
0.7879571318626404,
0.09623300284147263,
-0.2142215222120285,
0.3860614597797394,
0.0004024324589408934,
-1.2895334959030151,
1.2003313302993774,
0.14827874302864075,
-0.07630852609872818,
-0.4081718325614929,
0.19437113404273987,
0.23599161207675934,
-0.1904493272304535,
0.1530904620885849,
0.2187298685312271,
0.7054266333580017,
0.20467716455459595,
-0.5962384343147278,
0.35860902070999146,
-0.029155731201171875,
-0.10237306356430054,
0.5878723859786987,
-0.8864784836769104,
0.2793375551700592,
0.0499039888381958,
-0.2782309353351593,
-0.23735910654067993,
0.7830400466918945,
0.03576525300741196,
0.28779858350753784,
0.6136407256126404,
0.9879347681999207,
0.8320614099502563,
0.11516938358545303,
0.7751312851905823,
-0.5041282176971436,
0.4420568645000458,
1.10199773311615,
-0.18769337236881256,
0.4662744104862213,
0.17453230917453766,
-0.17055585980415344,
0.6224474906921387,
0.6334916949272156,
-0.008888344280421734,
0.6490112543106079,
-0.21261896193027496,
-0.013679579831659794,
-0.4649474620819092,
0.022471783682703972,
-0.5959031581878662,
0.43720924854278564,
0.4476948082447052,
-0.30011868476867676,
-0.37725332379341125,
-0.25130775570869446,
0.16351670026779175,
-0.31701597571372986,
-0.22449466586112976,
0.2974030077457428,
-0.030327431857585907,
-0.4037248492240906,
0.22795800864696503,
-0.0632760226726532,
0.22276103496551514,
-0.6062532067298889,
0.04446740075945854,
-0.13089428842067719,
-0.22052687406539917,
-0.33576130867004395,
-0.5384088754653931,
0.371472030878067,
-0.6768070459365845,
-0.23451727628707886,
0.22021500766277313,
1.107002854347229,
-0.4633069932460785,
-0.29913923144340515,
0.3125359117984772,
0.33357030153274536,
-0.18923766911029816,
-0.19189395010471344,
-0.2578839063644409,
-0.5773391723632812,
-0.10733368992805481,
-0.14551572501659393,
0.06144952028989792,
0.7449613213539124,
-0.09792102873325348,
0.6832745671272278,
0.3448433578014374,
-0.0753764808177948,
0.02972416952252388,
0.07653196901082993,
0.9817417860031128,
-0.4439934492111206,
-0.7921015620231628,
-0.5143964886665344,
0.40527865290641785,
-0.279776930809021,
-0.09345307946205139,
0.8218553066253662,
0.5689328908920288,
0.5229684114456177,
-0.07133326679468155,
0.8466360569000244,
-0.5279225707054138,
0.5752189755439758,
-0.5406575798988342,
0.6679449677467346,
-0.5065818428993225,
-0.25157392024993896,
-0.5713706612586975,
-0.64986252784729,
-0.15740372240543365,
0.05677497386932373,
-0.6835724115371704,
-0.0941924899816513,
0.8915388584136963,
0.7979043126106262,
-0.08604836463928223,
0.09568068385124207,
0.23196731507778168,
0.6379439234733582,
0.2560920715332031,
0.4444296658039093,
0.5471411347389221,
-0.21243904531002045,
0.6596167683601379,
-0.06029374524950981,
-0.09302935749292374,
-0.35906314849853516,
-0.840172290802002,
-0.8823962807655334,
-0.6022360324859619,
-0.2917417287826538,
-0.562877893447876,
-0.07952334731817245,
0.8358076214790344,
0.600265622138977,
-0.5780108571052551,
0.5637489557266235,
-0.39882805943489075,
0.5715472102165222,
-0.03838372975587845,
-0.28808528184890747,
0.655436098575592,
-0.20159222185611725,
0.12818753719329834,
0.3898193836212158,
0.4575960636138916,
0.19342827796936035,
0.0024617291055619717,
0.12875962257385254,
-0.07652521133422852,
-0.07623699307441711,
0.6841151118278503,
0.26197350025177,
-0.3589603006839752,
-0.700212299823761,
-0.04431594908237457,
0.1347765326499939,
0.11668024212121964,
0.8085627555847168,
-0.5663332343101501,
0.2758691906929016,
0.487109512090683,
0.806551992893219,
0.5867143273353577,
-0.17533622682094574,
0.4948346018791199,
-1.0207288265228271,
0.03120795451104641,
0.23799371719360352,
0.54377281665802,
0.2066141963005066,
-0.7353301048278809,
0.5758900046348572,
0.9742074608802795,
-0.034571751952171326,
-0.6513505578041077,
0.5473679304122925,
-0.7615137100219727,
-0.04564405232667923,
1.0125031471252441,
-0.19697333872318268,
-0.32735079526901245,
-0.296865850687027,
0.24921751022338867,
0.4628032147884369,
-0.4152139723300934,
0.8871654868125916,
0.666999340057373,
-0.0004479945346247405,
0.4126574397087097,
-0.03177120164036751,
0.3358913064002991,
0.18857823312282562,
-0.6428428292274475,
-0.19506233930587769,
0.3702267110347748,
0.5057994723320007,
0.3566051423549652,
0.6715016961097717,
0.008148539811372757,
0.13939619064331055,
0.25370296835899353,
0.15614983439445496,
-0.4055050313472748,
-0.39327239990234375,
0.6651520729064941,
0.4057878851890564,
-0.1539730429649353,
-0.14825521409511566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08309v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08309v1
|
Subtoxic Questions: Dive Into Attitude Change of LLM's Response in Jailbreak Attempts
| 2024-04-12T08:08:44 | 2024-04-12T08:08:44 |
Tianyu Zhang, Zixuan Zhao, Jiaqi Huang, Jingyu Hua, Sheng Zhong
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) of Prompt Jailbreaking are getting more and
more attention, it is of great significance to raise a generalized research
paradigm to evaluate attack strengths and a basic model to conduct subtler
experiments. In this paper, we propose a novel approach by focusing on a set of
target questions that are inherently more sensitive to jailbreak prompts,
aiming to circumvent the limitations posed by enhanced LLM security. Through
designing and analyzing these sensitive questions, this paper reveals a more
effective method of identifying vulnerabilities in LLMs, thereby contributing
to the advancement of LLM security. This research not only challenges existing
jailbreaking methodologies but also fortifies LLMs against potential exploits.
|
[
-0.5174218416213989,
-1.1090039014816284,
0.7689307928085327,
-0.09717628359794617,
-0.3658176362514496,
0.04464147239923477,
-0.004243851639330387,
-0.3654133379459381,
0.34822818636894226,
0.6124460101127625,
-0.6557696461677551,
-0.28531336784362793,
-0.6793861389160156,
0.2801307737827301,
-0.33238929510116577,
1.0611737966537476,
0.02007477357983589,
-0.1872704029083252,
-0.16403944790363312,
-0.2083570510149002,
-0.6240810751914978,
-0.6807759404182434,
-0.3493518829345703,
0.0005932425265200436,
0.6537407636642456,
0.34076184034347534,
0.5287994146347046,
-0.18705706298351288,
0.6809249520301819,
0.3012126386165619,
-0.4323243796825409,
-0.361481249332428,
-0.22687962651252747,
0.36508339643478394,
-0.4857806861400604,
-0.8624047636985779,
-0.2316385805606842,
-0.13736261427402496,
0.008959022350609303,
0.21728326380252838,
0.061810750514268875,
0.18645377457141876,
-0.24629567563533783,
0.7838312983512878,
-0.5690736770629883,
-0.39369526505470276,
-0.8952661156654358,
0.07366321980953217,
-0.1644972711801529,
-0.15822818875312805,
-0.5486517548561096,
-0.2945156991481781,
-0.15617701411247253,
-0.12094190716743469,
0.028557879850268364,
-0.05995846539735794,
0.3553847670555115,
0.2786543667316437,
-0.4174807071685791,
-0.2781658172607422,
-0.4028502106666565,
0.7489783763885498,
-0.8649988174438477,
0.2009052187204361,
0.28107309341430664,
0.09019003808498383,
-0.15402589738368988,
-0.2835623621940613,
-0.1339130699634552,
-0.5722874402999878,
0.1938013732433319,
-0.16125287115573883,
-0.2726699113845825,
-0.189390629529953,
0.23216107487678528,
0.31699448823928833,
-0.5008537769317627,
0.0901971235871315,
-0.2047935128211975,
-0.2185375839471817,
0.7020477652549744,
0.31581950187683105,
0.48877760767936707,
-0.0305462796241045,
-0.3374788761138916,
0.19483089447021484,
-1.0124361515045166,
0.10836558789014816,
0.6162156462669373,
0.36477595567703247,
-0.09457060694694519,
0.7903615832328796,
-0.007058062124997377,
0.43761777877807617,
0.28765520453453064,
-0.04372700676321983,
-0.1431571990251541,
-0.3584016263484955,
-0.02126646228134632,
-0.0948132649064064,
0.5717819929122925,
0.4636155962944031,
0.34607937932014465,
-0.0395822636783123,
-0.07379709184169769,
-0.5065246224403381,
0.4362335801124573,
-0.7353546619415283,
0.09768329560756683,
0.6857835054397583,
-0.29741790890693665,
-0.6592671275138855,
-0.015507652424275875,
-0.7656404376029968,
-0.9925703406333923,
0.197713702917099,
0.20142146944999695,
-0.2888462245464325,
-0.4486156105995178,
-0.09400317072868347,
-0.026198623701930046,
0.5634602904319763,
0.26386386156082153,
-0.9466281533241272,
0.13587498664855957,
0.6994268894195557,
0.9253918528556824,
-0.19419342279434204,
0.14897042512893677,
-0.2229943424463272,
0.01874465122818947,
-0.2396429181098938,
0.5831518173217773,
-0.49788904190063477,
-0.7027475833892822,
-0.04181140288710594,
-0.06381437927484512,
0.13758912682533264,
-0.6547921299934387,
0.2785038948059082,
-0.8681508898735046,
-0.1761694997549057,
-0.5206204056739807,
-0.36690694093704224,
0.11097732931375504,
0.7406693696975708,
-0.5767545700073242,
0.74955153465271,
0.09657004475593567,
-1.1545213460922241,
-0.0699072852730751,
-0.4584164619445801,
-0.3424801230430603,
-0.08498083055019379,
0.039480067789554596,
-0.31336545944213867,
0.24877135455608368,
0.4076644480228424,
0.15828590095043182,
-0.2725813090801239,
0.3258959949016571,
-0.3190218210220337,
-0.010513768531382084,
0.7764132618904114,
-0.19859862327575684,
0.7902185916900635,
0.30065447092056274,
-0.3494115471839905,
0.20058736205101013,
-0.27873432636260986,
-0.194061279296875,
0.33161497116088867,
-0.4300557076931,
-0.6346592903137207,
-0.035019733011722565,
-0.3537543714046478,
0.05455601215362549,
0.5825735926628113,
-0.8153828382492065,
0.4620925486087799,
-0.4580029249191284,
0.577423095703125,
0.9549172520637512,
0.24948738515377045,
0.4590214788913727,
0.058621492236852646,
0.8748254776000977,
0.09437046200037003,
0.5038892030715942,
0.013220896013081074,
-0.3414977192878723,
-0.5694278478622437,
0.14171965420246124,
0.08455927670001984,
0.874738872051239,
-0.5790093541145325,
0.06669552624225616,
0.19874083995819092,
-0.6732921600341797,
-0.2745184004306793,
0.33155426383018494,
0.41468536853790283,
0.6035940051078796,
0.5990870594978333,
-0.09362097829580307,
-0.5821461081504822,
-0.8168038725852966,
-0.6921220421791077,
-0.5650180578231812,
0.15279169380664825,
0.4268220365047455,
0.6069549918174744,
-0.14434538781642914,
0.9150800704956055,
-0.5750344395637512,
0.21568423509597778,
-0.8423053622245789,
-0.1863013356924057,
0.28268882632255554,
0.4099541902542114,
0.6121765375137329,
-0.9059967398643494,
-0.40477272868156433,
-0.22503885626792908,
-0.758924663066864,
-0.35687655210494995,
0.10432453453540802,
0.27160772681236267,
-0.04856201633810997,
1.0527435541152954,
-0.6058825850486755,
0.17262376844882965,
0.31539931893348694,
-0.41518479585647583,
0.7375735640525818,
0.19349928200244904,
0.026829902082681656,
-1.0760265588760376,
-0.41677185893058777,
0.03787844628095627,
0.12096059322357178,
-0.713272750377655,
0.5427676439285278,
-0.007995164021849632,
-0.06754005700349808,
-0.8685632348060608,
0.6608819365501404,
-0.2362445741891861,
0.08949774503707886,
-0.24910537898540497,
-0.14884741604328156,
-0.28987643122673035,
0.06000857427716255,
-0.14596685767173767,
0.8101595640182495,
0.5420789122581482,
-0.44958198070526123,
0.5639467239379883,
0.01575726456940174,
-0.1416558176279068,
0.44606301188468933,
-0.9995689392089844,
0.4625529646873474,
-0.023944726213812828,
0.05249308422207832,
-1.2128289937973022,
-0.14939896762371063,
0.23296600580215454,
-0.38936400413513184,
0.24005787074565887,
-0.41960400342941284,
-0.2521640658378601,
-0.22673000395298004,
-0.5605876445770264,
0.568157434463501,
0.40255439281463623,
-0.2752969563007355,
0.5122008323669434,
0.37091773748397827,
-0.5138795375823975,
-0.5859186053276062,
-0.5952425599098206,
0.16762413084506989,
-0.665672779083252,
-0.6851256489753723,
-0.022406451404094696,
-0.11349384486675262,
-0.7591307163238525,
-0.36029648780822754,
-0.16429543495178223,
0.19556958973407745,
0.3324819505214691,
0.10807754844427109,
0.3836604058742523,
-0.11047188192605972,
-0.2884267568588257,
0.16092340648174286,
-0.07331959158182144,
0.38829073309898376,
-0.019495565444231033,
0.6034443378448486,
-0.2544843256473541,
-0.2544332444667816,
-0.025607667863368988,
0.4217057228088379,
0.53392493724823,
-0.27065664529800415,
0.7641385197639465,
-0.011825475841760635,
0.12655094265937805,
0.1205751895904541,
-0.4387805163860321,
-0.22048118710517883,
-0.5797336101531982,
0.4289323389530182,
-0.4459117352962494,
-1.1921749114990234,
0.7339006662368774,
-0.32020479440689087,
-0.08909965306520462,
0.013652284629642963,
0.8277115225791931,
-0.039097826927900314,
0.8222733736038208,
0.8278324604034424,
-0.41095656156539917,
0.5749621391296387,
0.11333469301462173,
0.22433249652385712,
-0.9362905621528625,
-0.2556467652320862,
-0.4904724359512329,
-0.12953223288059235,
-0.5039742588996887,
-0.31366220116615295,
0.47353628277778625,
-0.02654670737683773,
-0.03270579129457474,
0.6565675735473633,
-0.17105582356452942,
0.48482850193977356,
0.058513469994068146,
0.13405108451843262,
0.28092050552368164,
-0.5387938618659973,
-0.36949098110198975,
0.11037005484104156,
-0.21576035022735596,
-0.45560044050216675,
1.0643209218978882,
0.6562898755073547,
1.1776756048202515,
0.46387720108032227,
0.6857227087020874,
0.18971411883831024,
0.28721973299980164,
-0.8661574721336365,
0.842105507850647,
0.3848406970500946,
-1.2247707843780518,
-0.43543511629104614,
-0.2277912199497223,
-0.7230543494224548,
0.2309514731168747,
0.1551433652639389,
-0.9974413514137268,
0.15201178193092346,
0.09026870876550674,
-0.31918662786483765,
0.4738213121891022,
-0.6565450429916382,
0.6650867462158203,
-0.3018015921115875,
-0.313109815120697,
0.2486647218465805,
-0.8102157711982727,
0.5379471182823181,
-0.05102032050490379,
0.5021940469741821,
-0.13945770263671875,
-0.268169105052948,
0.5936349630355835,
-0.5214219093322754,
1.0791499614715576,
-0.37925928831100464,
-0.585256814956665,
0.5409935712814331,
0.41454261541366577,
0.6382474899291992,
0.42304331064224243,
-0.15737798810005188,
-0.1017940565943718,
-0.24755477905273438,
-0.2781584858894348,
-0.5708572864532471,
0.4966830015182495,
-0.5493146181106567,
-1.0988891124725342,
-0.17386163771152496,
-0.742663562297821,
-0.4465653598308563,
0.022128770127892494,
0.3505808115005493,
-0.009656550362706184,
-0.21614305675029755,
-0.07278724759817123,
1.0152758359909058,
-0.5956280827522278,
0.4705525040626526,
0.5625979900360107,
-0.2633543610572815,
-0.1383228302001953,
0.46949079632759094,
-0.07110618054866791,
0.4546513259410858,
0.5095417499542236,
0.325823575258255,
-0.34542250633239746,
-0.8834654092788696,
-0.28478559851646423,
0.07344427704811096,
-0.5888161659240723,
-0.23031461238861084,
-0.5159494280815125,
-0.11329714953899384,
-0.7283425331115723,
-0.24967661499977112,
-0.45554277300834656,
-0.20191791653633118,
-0.08667347580194473,
-0.5405745506286621,
0.6775542497634888,
0.40638467669487,
0.03596924617886543,
0.15974478423595428,
-0.7644599676132202,
0.38450193405151367,
0.46916428208351135,
-0.2039748728275299,
-0.3642022907733917,
-0.8571192622184753,
-0.0022594458423554897,
-0.35223472118377686,
-0.17608942091464996,
-1.4280753135681152,
0.3251612186431885,
-0.2931225001811981,
0.40058863162994385,
0.1876201033592224,
0.34719163179397583,
0.1711367517709732,
-0.34956657886505127,
0.7868441343307495,
0.14579276740550995,
-0.9087299704551697,
1.1562975645065308,
-0.5239700675010681,
-0.011712050065398216,
0.809450626373291,
0.6006834506988525,
-0.33186060190200806,
-0.7629270553588867,
-0.4789296090602875,
-1.0776371955871582,
0.2274753302335739,
-0.06595876812934875,
0.5864852666854858,
0.10748331248760223,
0.6377789378166199,
0.1442597508430481,
0.1824207752943039,
-0.9755305647850037,
-0.2644728720188141,
-0.06282881647348404,
0.045440707355737686,
0.018878208473324776,
-0.4063360393047333,
-0.19119352102279663,
-0.3821227252483368,
0.28453344106674194,
-0.001296939910389483,
-0.04639767110347748,
0.26797378063201904,
-0.266438364982605,
0.16053055226802826,
0.9691821932792664,
0.36667120456695557,
0.39692139625549316,
-0.3607732355594635,
0.3475120961666107,
0.47966432571411133,
-0.7592475414276123,
0.6420807838439941,
-0.41619348526000977,
-0.52220219373703,
-0.3511451780796051,
0.4538761079311371,
0.4155908524990082,
-0.2095799744129181,
-0.7598590850830078,
0.504260241985321,
0.03544814512133598,
-0.0317709818482399,
-0.14729991555213928,
0.38180243968963623,
0.08152768760919571,
0.3427481949329376,
0.30055123567581177,
-0.33542272448539734,
-0.04138311371207237,
-1.0065600872039795,
0.10967984795570374,
0.42092156410217285,
-0.7053459286689758,
-0.31679871678352356,
0.4570009112358093,
0.25000983476638794,
-0.26522043347358704,
0.4580037593841553,
-0.009499764069914818,
-0.7163538932800293,
0.688194751739502,
0.7652406692504883,
0.8858145475387573,
-0.47954270243644714,
0.22968913614749908,
0.16664057970046997,
0.842361569404602,
0.40368232131004333,
0.44358810782432556,
0.0951649621129036,
-0.8409278392791748,
-0.3631431460380554,
-0.3615679144859314,
-0.601789116859436,
0.1655930131673813,
-0.8316086530685425,
0.015531828626990318,
-0.8399037718772888,
-0.27857521176338196,
-0.32907941937446594,
-0.2842102646827698,
0.2539270520210266,
0.19012315571308136,
0.010470091365277767,
1.1356672048568726,
-0.916023313999176,
0.7444362640380859,
0.835928201675415,
-0.32164493203163147,
-0.49851641058921814,
0.14160002768039703,
0.24208463728427887,
-0.7388485670089722,
0.5495158433914185,
-0.018066508695483208,
0.06965555250644684,
-0.14876298606395721,
-1.0656205415725708,
-0.6430584192276001,
0.7839115858078003,
0.47205445170402527,
-0.6235937476158142,
0.11294478923082352,
0.2734309732913971,
0.30791184306144714,
-0.18201109766960144,
0.07408573478460312,
0.9707806706428528,
0.5334542393684387,
-0.05712782219052315,
-0.6330624222755432,
0.4334268271923065,
-0.3715347945690155,
-0.25121721625328064,
0.3803553283214569,
-0.6812639236450195,
0.9740716814994812,
-0.7299923896789551,
0.29928454756736755,
0.02501143328845501,
0.5253329873085022,
0.5341148376464844,
0.2543887197971344,
0.5164240002632141,
0.5392380952835083,
0.39974135160446167,
-0.09882768988609314,
1.1404000520706177,
0.1202046275138855,
0.27516600489616394,
0.9647932052612305,
-0.36671727895736694,
0.6667143702507019,
1.042352557182312,
-0.3913020193576813,
0.583928108215332,
0.6181468963623047,
0.020227355882525444,
0.6699719429016113,
0.5147917866706848,
-0.3034994602203369,
-0.3183993995189667,
-0.03059914894402027,
-0.5130963325500488,
0.14967568218708038,
0.31511807441711426,
-0.06161493808031082,
-0.20534655451774597,
0.3697409927845001,
0.2282496690750122,
0.04646393284201622,
-0.5507233142852783,
0.8417089581489563,
0.24941480159759521,
-0.38323357701301575,
0.09479282051324844,
0.3809114098548889,
0.8776713013648987,
-0.5567976236343384,
0.4181769788265228,
-0.5398539900779724,
-0.10063938051462173,
-0.1940574198961258,
-0.9009941220283508,
0.35219138860702515,
0.542026698589325,
0.05789488926529884,
0.05212271586060524,
1.061414122581482,
0.2615002989768982,
-0.34310534596443176,
0.3889857232570648,
0.4313211441040039,
0.12385569512844086,
-0.2968941628932953,
-0.8913357853889465,
0.158880814909935,
-0.02597680687904358,
-0.45986202359199524,
0.725842297077179,
0.2124556303024292,
0.04909782484173775,
0.8154857754707336,
0.6026103496551514,
-0.12614436447620392,
0.24530936777591705,
0.04962984472513199,
1.2012643814086914,
-0.8818762302398682,
-0.29798734188079834,
-1.2549570798873901,
0.5488231778144836,
0.13890142738819122,
-0.3385584056377411,
0.9433543682098389,
0.20834898948669434,
0.6502838134765625,
-0.04568658396601677,
0.828130304813385,
-0.394439160823822,
0.3677878677845001,
-0.6896809339523315,
0.3323512673377991,
-0.28525733947753906,
0.6827791929244995,
-0.5674654841423035,
-0.5377119183540344,
0.07630584388971329,
0.35818883776664734,
-0.6989964246749878,
0.06193791329860687,
0.5797760486602783,
0.7877441048622131,
0.3215162754058838,
-0.15120117366313934,
0.1769680231809616,
0.30430465936660767,
0.4172164499759674,
0.7349745035171509,
1.3788232803344727,
-0.3345370590686798,
0.4934108555316925,
-0.19333717226982117,
-0.07567553967237473,
-0.26255834102630615,
-0.8102673888206482,
-1.0481256246566772,
-0.1624501794576645,
-0.3054491877555847,
-0.3972776532173157,
-0.02957497164607048,
0.6645485162734985,
0.20812545716762543,
-0.8509184122085571,
-0.05305115506052971,
-0.31348344683647156,
0.5066143870353699,
0.13452255725860596,
-0.2584063708782196,
-0.022643359377980232,
-0.1545146256685257,
-0.4966394603252411,
0.5553386211395264,
0.22195377945899963,
0.17910534143447876,
-0.34530210494995117,
0.12946951389312744,
-0.2732864320278168,
0.40182068943977356,
0.6135920882225037,
0.3260911703109741,
-0.3277203142642975,
-0.3768540918827057,
0.26550042629241943,
-0.09458080679178238,
-0.1113065704703331,
1.039056420326233,
-0.4280746877193451,
-0.08178003132343292,
0.4500207006931305,
0.538378894329071,
0.2148309350013733,
0.2035285085439682,
0.29867324233055115,
-0.820432722568512,
0.3454505503177643,
0.36550670862197876,
0.24503520131111145,
0.0933142825961113,
-0.552998960018158,
0.3955481946468353,
0.09954269975423813,
-0.2757861912250519,
-0.9876167178153992,
0.7161508202552795,
-0.9412344098091125,
-0.6450552344322205,
1.4018827676773071,
-0.3073681592941284,
-0.2202930748462677,
-0.4864371418952942,
-0.31935974955558777,
-0.187836155295372,
-0.1534697413444519,
0.7056537866592407,
0.7395195364952087,
-0.3737465739250183,
-0.26103636622428894,
-0.4679666757583618,
0.14919205009937286,
0.5253405570983887,
-1.0045911073684692,
0.14300334453582764,
0.08197900652885437,
0.5284414887428284,
0.1942199021577835,
0.6530532240867615,
-0.5681339502334595,
0.05506015941500664,
-0.101967453956604,
-0.3741162121295929,
-0.046108417212963104,
-0.4495866894721985,
-0.27227210998535156,
0.4119996428489685,
0.3300676941871643,
0.19723986089229584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08263v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08263v1
|
Relational Prompt-based Pre-trained Language Models for Social Event Detection
| 2024-04-12T06:23:07 | 2024-04-12T06:23:07 |
Pu Li, Xiaoyan Yu, Hao Peng, Yantuan Xian, Linqin Wang, Li Sun, Jingyun Zhang, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
Social Event Detection (SED) aims to identify significant events from social
streams, and has a wide application ranging from public opinion analysis to
risk management. In recent years, Graph Neural Network (GNN) based solutions
have achieved state-of-the-art performance. However, GNN-based methods often
struggle with noisy and missing edges between messages, affecting the quality
of learned message embedding. Moreover, these methods statically initialize
node embedding before training, which, in turn, limits the ability to learn
from message texts and relations simultaneously. In this paper, we approach
social event detection from a new perspective based on Pre-trained Language
Models (PLMs), and present RPLM_SED (Relational prompt-based Pre-trained
Language Models for Social Event Detection). We first propose a new pairwise
message modeling strategy to construct social messages into message pairs with
multi-relational sequences. Secondly, a new multi-relational prompt-based
pairwise message learning mechanism is proposed to learn more comprehensive
message representation from message pairs with multi-relational prompts using
PLMs. Thirdly, we design a new clustering constraint to optimize the encoding
process by enhancing intra-cluster compactness and inter-cluster dispersion,
making the message representation more distinguishable. We evaluate the
RPLM_SED on three real-world datasets, demonstrating that the RPLM_SED model
achieves state-of-the-art performance in offline, online, low-resource, and
long-tail distribution scenarios for social event detection tasks.
|
[
-0.18056844174861908,
-1.1361274719238281,
0.6080754399299622,
0.20247681438922882,
-0.6921494603157043,
0.1456073820590973,
-0.36301153898239136,
-0.1408889889717102,
0.5781105756759644,
0.17550525069236755,
-0.6609093546867371,
-0.9152772426605225,
-0.381717711687088,
0.08002828806638718,
-0.08794628828763962,
0.7681907415390015,
0.1376439779996872,
-0.14333300292491913,
-0.3957078456878662,
-0.167433500289917,
-0.1301405429840088,
-0.8481975793838501,
-0.7686216235160828,
-0.10666324943304062,
0.4069434404373169,
0.2865273356437683,
0.5322313904762268,
0.2989402711391449,
0.23136815428733826,
0.2599030137062073,
-0.10346967726945877,
0.4216274619102478,
-0.5689860582351685,
0.17738835513591766,
-0.008323738351464272,
0.053134262561798096,
-0.12433815747499466,
-0.049138814210891724,
0.8491736054420471,
0.6460893750190735,
-0.1932840794324875,
0.03894814848899841,
0.13033299148082733,
0.37530484795570374,
-0.5151058435440063,
0.45529794692993164,
-0.38983869552612305,
-0.02015565149486065,
-0.07872451841831207,
-0.27509161829948425,
-0.5223237872123718,
-0.38221991062164307,
-0.12774886190891266,
-0.5890994668006897,
0.02318180724978447,
-0.06446685642004013,
0.6894040703773499,
-0.12501156330108643,
-0.3518196940422058,
-0.09744202345609665,
-0.41520243883132935,
0.5059193968772888,
-0.4496724009513855,
0.4148229956626892,
0.17444774508476257,
0.15337908267974854,
-0.2764643132686615,
-0.5862030982971191,
-0.47621509432792664,
0.001294919871725142,
-0.07496705651283264,
-0.006236905697733164,
0.11458389461040497,
-0.01124366745352745,
0.11780714243650436,
-0.26349812746047974,
-0.7433416247367859,
0.09981846809387207,
0.1369502991437912,
-0.04693823307752609,
0.6468743681907654,
0.22011978924274445,
0.41690972447395325,
-0.42187780141830444,
-0.35110026597976685,
-0.03469454124569893,
-0.5568615198135376,
0.013371176086366177,
0.19955390691757202,
0.5728918313980103,
-0.5140159726142883,
0.011304876767098904,
-0.19555695354938507,
0.39105024933815,
-0.06705835461616516,
-0.0878305733203888,
0.23761339485645294,
-0.49821680784225464,
0.1594683974981308,
-0.1361238658428192,
1.0822051763534546,
0.30122703313827515,
0.38582974672317505,
-0.042056065052747726,
0.08805236220359802,
0.2741311192512512,
-0.3252660930156708,
-0.7097994089126587,
-0.20870447158813477,
-0.13373516499996185,
-0.876242458820343,
-0.44330060482025146,
-0.0007648312603123486,
-0.6848713159561157,
-0.5835469365119934,
-0.27210429310798645,
0.1829739511013031,
-0.3579820692539215,
-0.5534635782241821,
0.07070236653089523,
0.1547880619764328,
0.07911908626556396,
0.4442776143550873,
-0.38684728741645813,
0.13870352506637573,
0.6428853273391724,
0.8890032172203064,
-0.1463741958141327,
-0.3582630157470703,
-0.7761129140853882,
-0.06295634806156158,
-0.007920872420072556,
0.8722659349441528,
-0.514664351940155,
-0.40294119715690613,
0.1607760488986969,
0.14042359590530396,
-0.21806471049785614,
-0.1132972463965416,
0.32124972343444824,
-0.62171870470047,
-0.029131975024938583,
-0.3293115198612213,
-0.6104509830474854,
0.21995852887630463,
0.2761492133140564,
-0.3735726773738861,
0.6737569570541382,
-0.16068778932094574,
-0.8659570813179016,
0.28006845712661743,
-0.24992606043815613,
-0.6844817399978638,
0.31810927391052246,
-0.4428179860115051,
-0.6928783655166626,
-0.1284130960702896,
0.386907696723938,
0.6752732992172241,
-0.10908515006303787,
0.5352270007133484,
-0.8007833361625671,
-0.2883789539337158,
0.32093340158462524,
-0.2498733103275299,
0.7399277687072754,
0.06815104186534882,
0.08933941274881363,
0.49352842569351196,
-0.8628949522972107,
-0.0837889313697815,
0.3562268316745758,
-0.026840781792998314,
-0.30126434564590454,
0.209830179810524,
0.059501856565475464,
0.3371071219444275,
0.11432987451553345,
-0.3741460144519806,
-0.10978646576404572,
-0.18016043305397034,
0.5237972140312195,
0.8427940607070923,
0.33215227723121643,
0.3977569341659546,
-0.041093870997428894,
0.5493960976600647,
0.289520800113678,
0.31461915373802185,
-0.5169574618339539,
-0.5496421456336975,
-0.23249267041683197,
0.044459179043769836,
-0.037771619856357574,
0.7268161773681641,
-0.947780966758728,
0.5970326066017151,
-0.03068389929831028,
-0.07996933907270432,
0.06382990628480911,
-0.007174711208790541,
0.21911346912384033,
0.34455785155296326,
0.16523052752017975,
-0.13425764441490173,
-0.5399061441421509,
-0.36512118577957153,
-0.407429963350296,
-0.5396093726158142,
0.38644933700561523,
0.33174487948417664,
0.2988092005252838,
-0.04936249926686287,
0.7690541744232178,
-0.3991279900074005,
-0.2115095853805542,
-0.6529666185379028,
0.10877490043640137,
0.2607329487800598,
0.29953667521476746,
0.42631101608276367,
-0.7368805408477783,
-0.6589036583900452,
-0.11616694927215576,
-0.8518155217170715,
-0.20333386957645416,
-0.18591418862342834,
0.16624568402767181,
0.12516430020332336,
0.6961809396743774,
-0.5399735569953918,
0.5744630098342896,
0.19868256151676178,
-0.49613603949546814,
0.5218809247016907,
-0.18914811313152313,
0.051293421536684036,
-1.1477304697036743,
-0.4552888870239258,
0.08489298820495605,
-0.4816732406616211,
-0.8054424524307251,
-0.17230649292469025,
0.2171933501958847,
-0.41163375973701477,
-0.6104567646980286,
0.5595065355300903,
-0.5893387794494629,
-0.22154149413108826,
-0.20382171869277954,
0.426836222410202,
-0.06465157121419907,
0.4306652545928955,
0.25541749596595764,
0.35320019721984863,
0.5512702465057373,
-0.5564736723899841,
0.4819067418575287,
0.3021031618118286,
-0.37552157044410706,
0.5852186679840088,
-0.5052080750465393,
0.17058996856212616,
-0.5331606268882751,
0.3618362247943878,
-0.996433436870575,
-0.07066571712493896,
0.5088633894920349,
-0.5530440807342529,
0.18249955773353577,
-0.3295735716819763,
-0.6260510087013245,
-0.3654383718967438,
-0.22791491448879242,
0.31288763880729675,
0.34837669134140015,
-0.6708943843841553,
0.7439677715301514,
0.4020238518714905,
-0.22090210020542145,
-0.2647360861301422,
-0.2351621687412262,
0.00006716329517075792,
-0.23600120842456818,
-0.9838677048683167,
0.14691731333732605,
0.26543596386909485,
0.07064362615346909,
0.09827043861150742,
0.12882879376411438,
0.037550102919340134,
0.16667087376117706,
0.2920003831386566,
0.33012667298316956,
-0.0313480980694294,
0.23684954643249512,
-0.175951287150383,
-0.3369496166706085,
0.21522404253482819,
-0.18855388462543488,
0.6391974091529846,
-0.13026711344718933,
-0.48406800627708435,
-0.7360923886299133,
0.5772373080253601,
0.14499540627002716,
-0.2989341914653778,
1.093862533569336,
0.8136804699897766,
-0.32574447989463806,
-0.06776547431945801,
-0.46064138412475586,
-0.44858747720718384,
-0.42878836393356323,
0.3081129193305969,
-0.11607147008180618,
-1.0153626203536987,
0.72641921043396,
-0.18878979980945587,
-0.5090335011482239,
-0.17328913509845734,
0.0792720690369606,
-0.06834634393453598,
1.064997673034668,
0.26730015873908997,
-0.0696980357170105,
0.8471449017524719,
0.03643316030502319,
0.25220808386802673,
-0.47204500436782837,
-0.07406247407197952,
-0.49872997403144836,
0.039081837981939316,
-0.31576797366142273,
-0.43228182196617126,
0.3283667266368866,
0.27306675910949707,
-0.14153723418712616,
-0.050129860639572144,
-0.17981496453285217,
0.5740931630134583,
0.38275837898254395,
0.3581787943840027,
0.20825351774692535,
-0.03149600699543953,
0.018331795930862427,
0.004460806027054787,
-0.8931401371955872,
-0.33933699131011963,
0.8410630226135254,
0.12261780351400375,
0.7385814189910889,
-0.18189223110675812,
0.9573988318443298,
0.16359147429466248,
0.14180395007133484,
-0.1989547312259674,
0.7770512700080872,
-0.06608062982559204,
-0.04034092649817467,
-0.3128949999809265,
-0.62714022397995,
-0.8084655404090881,
0.17106230556964874,
-0.39764153957366943,
-0.7155585289001465,
0.2608832120895386,
0.041434045881032944,
-0.45426511764526367,
0.3043999969959259,
-0.6030272841453552,
1.1719164848327637,
-0.10084214806556702,
-0.2753918766975403,
-0.15067420899868011,
-0.8287913799285889,
0.05458754301071167,
0.26181265711784363,
0.6410182118415833,
-0.25456002354621887,
0.32496923208236694,
0.7025643587112427,
-0.3079270124435425,
1.091211199760437,
-0.4753105938434601,
0.443006306886673,
0.501101016998291,
-0.18611958622932434,
1.2744569778442383,
0.45176786184310913,
0.2866448760032654,
-0.16372829675674438,
-0.10542279481887817,
-0.22590786218643188,
-0.4420226812362671,
0.6058177351951599,
-0.7541817426681519,
-0.47983667254447937,
-0.22263804078102112,
-0.19123056530952454,
0.02262304723262787,
0.027249645441770554,
0.12397672981023788,
0.6703271269798279,
-0.4435712695121765,
0.1633511781692505,
0.5828809142112732,
-0.679189920425415,
0.4812885522842407,
0.45686355233192444,
-0.5006913542747498,
-0.4453587830066681,
0.852429211139679,
-0.08963076025247574,
0.09067918360233307,
0.2842928469181061,
0.15208151936531067,
-0.4305213391780853,
-0.4615415036678314,
-0.2558266818523407,
0.4567831754684448,
-0.9166584610939026,
-0.13250529766082764,
-1.0713835954666138,
-0.04786377772688866,
-0.7369123697280884,
-0.06870919466018677,
-0.20949971675872803,
-0.09577519446611404,
-0.8262275457382202,
-0.11806795001029968,
0.38511690497398376,
0.32613658905029297,
-0.2999263107776642,
0.4624420404434204,
-0.8805697560310364,
0.48618829250335693,
0.1161763072013855,
0.26344776153564453,
-0.0702214390039444,
-0.1073828712105751,
0.0054974788799881935,
-0.09945253282785416,
0.12459638714790344,
-1.2150869369506836,
0.3829876482486725,
0.3058854341506958,
0.50979083776474,
0.514767587184906,
0.4428630471229553,
0.2754304111003876,
-0.3123258948326111,
0.3891051411628723,
0.2510671019554138,
-0.6969317197799683,
0.7456353306770325,
-0.38056519627571106,
0.033594753593206406,
0.27246177196502686,
0.3166164457798004,
-0.7841939926147461,
-0.009371940046548843,
-0.6647705435752869,
-0.6333481669425964,
0.8492112159729004,
-0.03803984075784683,
0.0017116614617407322,
-0.45521080493927,
0.41678082942962646,
-0.26748126745224,
0.06611134111881256,
-0.8717325329780579,
-0.2923610508441925,
-0.20596528053283691,
-0.1323966234922409,
0.018300218507647514,
-0.42691516876220703,
0.3644596040248871,
0.014470226131379604,
0.4907272756099701,
-0.13641175627708435,
0.07395678013563156,
0.08489565551280975,
-0.2433808147907257,
-0.005210392642766237,
0.3264538645744324,
0.30009371042251587,
0.5760102272033691,
-0.09665132313966751,
0.09978686273097992,
0.1325647532939911,
-0.0644286647439003,
0.23568888008594513,
0.24734728038311005,
-0.13541580736637115,
-0.0046809520572423935,
0.3199080526828766,
0.9389090538024902,
0.1824493557214737,
-0.3978288769721985,
0.8750516176223755,
-0.3271675705909729,
0.1604173630475998,
-0.3150103688240051,
-0.23367583751678467,
0.24638158082962036,
0.2231920063495636,
0.18276070058345795,
-0.32301414012908936,
-0.0802399292588234,
-0.5928789973258972,
0.29678019881248474,
0.6012875437736511,
-0.3547520339488983,
-0.454056054353714,
0.5084229707717896,
0.304890900850296,
-0.3347952961921692,
0.5243973135948181,
-0.759540855884552,
-0.7404272556304932,
0.7352929711341858,
0.5699982643127441,
0.5767953395843506,
-0.36715540289878845,
0.6958954930305481,
0.2305304855108261,
0.2576228678226471,
0.025180872529745102,
0.6374319195747375,
0.006381928455084562,
-1.094688892364502,
-0.5991085767745972,
-0.5102327466011047,
-0.17939959466457367,
0.14190715551376343,
-0.5548444986343384,
0.39219552278518677,
-0.45340535044670105,
-0.1988818496465683,
-0.1838124692440033,
-0.1853896677494049,
-0.5906444191932678,
-0.18019327521324158,
0.08403610438108444,
0.4797256886959076,
-1.1573071479797363,
0.6549113988876343,
0.743276834487915,
-0.06515293568372726,
-0.7218484878540039,
-0.550791323184967,
0.09751168638467789,
-0.46160566806793213,
0.4652591347694397,
0.32377639412879944,
0.34822794795036316,
0.1423138827085495,
-0.20843149721622467,
-0.6509435772895813,
0.7313328385353088,
0.10955123603343964,
-0.43224284052848816,
-0.021971626207232475,
0.10888724029064178,
0.2737225294113159,
-0.5788280367851257,
0.12935152649879456,
0.17821446061134338,
0.3424764573574066,
0.03652780503034592,
-0.4121710956096649,
0.10996697098016739,
-0.10198558121919632,
0.10801298171281815,
0.41598883271217346,
-0.37516242265701294,
0.9098413586616516,
-0.105524942278862,
-0.6056158542633057,
-0.15417328476905823,
0.7455046772956848,
0.5441551804542542,
0.6042068600654602,
0.4833553731441498,
0.29167163372039795,
0.7282582521438599,
-0.15422423183918,
0.9856764674186707,
-0.25980427861213684,
0.347400963306427,
1.089672565460205,
-0.6185000538825989,
0.3768573999404907,
-0.01890735700726509,
-0.14864860475063324,
0.4901496171951294,
0.6561104655265808,
0.4900936484336853,
0.5363631248474121,
0.09387949854135513,
-0.43751752376556396,
-0.7397751808166504,
-0.32581597566604614,
-0.5205482840538025,
-0.03905433788895607,
0.5756199359893799,
-0.2224402278661728,
-0.36592474579811096,
0.24542172253131866,
-0.2655763626098633,
0.3534281849861145,
-0.3374321460723877,
0.8038380146026611,
0.19241873919963837,
-0.2001935988664627,
0.08442769199609756,
-0.15899252891540527,
0.5546305179595947,
-0.3314603269100189,
0.1321183294057846,
-0.1569538116455078,
0.08631239831447601,
0.01515291165560484,
-0.4645750820636749,
0.17811410129070282,
-0.40343403816223145,
0.0022957155015319586,
-0.16405673325061798,
1.4986295700073242,
-0.41260436177253723,
-0.3516658544540405,
0.5905396938323975,
0.744505763053894,
0.07013427466154099,
-0.3339763283729553,
-0.7056190967559814,
0.3180826008319855,
-0.2804284393787384,
-0.12398078292608261,
0.31497523188591003,
0.7216567993164062,
-0.1511404663324356,
0.5635401010513306,
0.7893355488777161,
0.014786924235522747,
-0.057661473751068115,
0.5853742957115173,
0.8334929943084717,
-0.6761863827705383,
-1.156952142715454,
-0.9730978012084961,
0.08113191276788712,
-0.3304269015789032,
0.19245409965515137,
0.4840189218521118,
0.13542497158050537,
0.5691389441490173,
0.056119583547115326,
0.6515995264053345,
0.3286551237106323,
0.6670767664909363,
-0.505657970905304,
0.45960310101509094,
-0.11018341779708862,
0.19273261725902557,
-0.5092729330062866,
-0.6273053288459778,
-0.3591712713241577,
0.7544255256652832,
-0.303261935710907,
0.0960741713643074,
0.5460686683654785,
0.7146395444869995,
0.19118835031986237,
0.31812742352485657,
0.20008467137813568,
-0.0550701804459095,
0.3918028771877289,
0.5935266017913818,
1.3747786283493042,
-0.0580192431807518,
0.4737755358219147,
-0.11998920887708664,
-0.2890360653400421,
-0.4222105145454407,
-1.089688777923584,
-1.2414898872375488,
-0.5992631316184998,
-0.5415049195289612,
-0.30037957429885864,
0.3582797348499298,
1.1990329027175903,
0.6010496020317078,
-0.6473007202148438,
-0.028758348897099495,
-0.12348941713571548,
0.48278501629829407,
-0.09579906612634659,
-0.24334368109703064,
0.4790429472923279,
-0.4370517432689667,
0.008720035664737225,
0.45575928688049316,
0.38302287459373474,
0.1473948061466217,
0.11706066131591797,
-0.11926758289337158,
-0.46776506304740906,
-0.3373977839946747,
0.6731476187705994,
0.20805394649505615,
-0.39567434787750244,
-0.4466148018836975,
-0.08801142871379852,
0.04877908155322075,
-0.07816846668720245,
0.628669261932373,
-0.8287220597267151,
-0.07337348163127899,
0.6276968717575073,
0.5872839689254761,
0.44350552558898926,
0.07377966493368149,
0.32200583815574646,
-1.0217102766036987,
0.32214251160621643,
-0.0531671904027462,
0.48190104961395264,
0.3941127061843872,
-0.5370149612426758,
0.3337813913822174,
0.5509752631187439,
-0.4867652356624603,
-0.7980481386184692,
0.4241122007369995,
-0.8198519945144653,
-0.3373839259147644,
1.195635437965393,
-0.1886901706457138,
-0.33326050639152527,
-0.4046943187713623,
0.04077950865030289,
0.4523344337940216,
-0.5829373598098755,
0.4404783546924591,
0.45818212628364563,
0.04856419935822487,
-0.5391837358474731,
0.020977558568120003,
0.3947324752807617,
0.14237257838249207,
-0.8468174934387207,
0.16134771704673767,
0.6191492676734924,
0.04513602331280708,
0.0172109454870224,
1.0389975309371948,
0.16829441487789154,
0.4364951252937317,
-0.36948758363723755,
-0.05974658206105232,
-0.2967163324356079,
-0.43403539061546326,
-0.30010008811950684,
0.2358064502477646,
-0.24474722146987915,
0.08762680739164352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08262v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08262v2
|
Pretraining and Updating Language- and Domain-specific Large Language Model: A Case Study in Japanese Business Domain
| 2024-04-12T06:21:48 | 2024-04-16T02:24:00 |
Kosuke Takahashi, Takahiro Omi, Kosuke Arima, Tatsuya Ishigaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50
|
Several previous studies have considered language- and domain-specific large
language models (LLMs) as separate topics. This study explores the combination
of a non-English language and a high-demand industry domain, focusing on a
Japanese business-specific LLM. This type of a model requires expertise in the
business domain, strong language skills, and regular updates of its knowledge.
We trained a 13-billion-parameter LLM from scratch using a new dataset of
business texts and patents, and continually pretrained it with the latest
business documents. Further we propose a new benchmark for Japanese business
domain question answering (QA) and evaluate our models on it. The results show
that our pretrained model improves QA accuracy without losing general
knowledge, and that continual pretraining enhances adaptation to new
information. Our pretrained model and business domain benchmark are publicly
available.
|
[
-0.2542915344238281,
-0.9724680781364441,
0.6033151745796204,
0.20702089369297028,
-0.48660531640052795,
0.2160705178976059,
-0.1965714395046234,
-0.6327933669090271,
-0.00521377706900239,
0.9359694123268127,
-0.5979313850402832,
-0.5024651288986206,
-0.3517659902572632,
0.15499509871006012,
0.05302282050251961,
0.8560676574707031,
-0.19464600086212158,
0.14751140773296356,
-0.304442435503006,
-0.23527194559574127,
-0.9120888710021973,
-0.9217101335525513,
-1.042684555053711,
-0.33311644196510315,
0.23041969537734985,
0.1082269623875618,
0.6082834601402283,
0.280970960855484,
0.43869903683662415,
0.25717753171920776,
0.27150753140449524,
-0.14828048646450043,
-0.4006976783275604,
0.03005823865532875,
-0.2631792426109314,
-0.7558728456497192,
-0.5134987831115723,
-0.02739107608795166,
0.6786528825759888,
0.9504947066307068,
-0.25483238697052,
0.21451085805892944,
-0.3041597604751587,
0.5266091823577881,
-0.4216674864292145,
0.3280221223831177,
-0.7251759171485901,
-0.3161564767360687,
-0.09226556122303009,
-0.2255723774433136,
-0.42434731125831604,
-0.25522130727767944,
0.23504118621349335,
-0.8025968074798584,
0.06544732302427292,
0.17948676645755768,
1.1053074598312378,
0.1682373285293579,
-0.3133566677570343,
-0.09976885467767715,
-0.6422414779663086,
0.5649149417877197,
-0.6929207444190979,
0.48868975043296814,
0.43732696771621704,
0.2917964458465576,
-0.14660075306892395,
-0.8954286575317383,
-0.27622562646865845,
-0.2560158371925354,
0.2156846970319748,
0.12866704165935516,
-0.06313550472259521,
-0.0563264936208725,
0.41861623525619507,
0.17977774143218994,
-0.5001937747001648,
0.41997164487838745,
-0.16120830178260803,
0.21081165969371796,
0.6906677484512329,
0.02335514687001705,
0.5239654779434204,
0.3228006660938263,
-0.15284886956214905,
-0.09497349709272385,
-0.8750735521316528,
-0.09185861051082611,
0.18305082619190216,
0.12081160396337509,
0.1552666574716568,
0.16014380753040314,
-0.379738450050354,
0.6188724637031555,
-0.14388211071491241,
-0.08905884623527527,
0.17261235415935516,
-0.18093830347061157,
-0.39793160557746887,
-0.03778665140271187,
0.5383794903755188,
0.07507016509771347,
0.6275335550308228,
-0.26891329884529114,
-0.13802611827850342,
-0.25659191608428955,
0.3248922824859619,
-0.8012629747390747,
-0.12599356472492218,
0.10341102629899979,
-0.2824854850769043,
0.19279152154922485,
-0.1652342975139618,
-0.5218154788017273,
-0.26224276423454285,
-0.3144158720970154,
0.6326445937156677,
-0.0435425341129303,
-0.36071059107780457,
0.4136139750480652,
-0.012691842392086983,
0.4984497129917145,
0.3030257821083069,
-0.7687368988990784,
0.16996119916439056,
0.4685768485069275,
0.33174675703048706,
0.023041145876049995,
-0.40945497155189514,
-0.142472043633461,
0.2924215495586395,
-0.6151836514472961,
0.6449303030967712,
-0.5430508255958557,
-0.3585997521877289,
0.14686398208141327,
0.15765784680843353,
-0.09712018072605133,
-0.8573736548423767,
0.17244264483451843,
-1.1373542547225952,
0.2969042956829071,
-0.09163974970579147,
-0.6668407320976257,
-0.12031585723161697,
0.30762362480163574,
-0.6137657761573792,
0.7366793155670166,
0.26564058661460876,
-0.440760999917984,
0.47751617431640625,
-0.5121687650680542,
-0.5432172417640686,
0.47117263078689575,
-0.07234369218349457,
-0.4924355447292328,
-0.019965896382927895,
0.15701644122600555,
0.38416731357574463,
-0.34723401069641113,
0.40442028641700745,
-0.315077543258667,
-0.07517122477293015,
0.49369895458221436,
-0.18380847573280334,
0.667030394077301,
0.04241638630628586,
-0.061895184218883514,
-0.17296740412712097,
-0.8465869426727295,
0.1894240528345108,
0.33914050459861755,
-0.3316519856452942,
-0.45445430278778076,
-0.2840574383735657,
-0.27672237157821655,
0.1564711630344391,
0.7194142937660217,
-0.2718842029571533,
0.18349111080169678,
-0.3011459708213806,
0.17931051552295685,
0.5764666795730591,
0.3765704929828644,
0.0742708072066307,
-0.2627986967563629,
0.8694179058074951,
0.11851805448532104,
0.09878023713827133,
-0.27681779861450195,
-0.5010373592376709,
-0.7072470188140869,
-0.10629633069038391,
0.451872855424881,
0.4230097830295563,
-0.7503682374954224,
0.26952818036079407,
-0.36305901408195496,
-0.43396320939064026,
-0.6421699523925781,
0.16103458404541016,
0.2605058550834656,
0.23604269325733185,
0.3527199327945709,
-0.5708164572715759,
-0.4582624137401581,
-0.6804246306419373,
-0.3940636217594147,
0.028165588155388832,
-0.04958643764257431,
0.2927405834197998,
0.2610622048377991,
-0.4347509741783142,
0.775481104850769,
-0.6726261973381042,
-0.15287089347839355,
-0.5119432210922241,
0.18742933869361877,
0.42442786693573,
0.22177410125732422,
0.4469074308872223,
-0.7377815842628479,
-0.7053996920585632,
0.10105223953723907,
-0.494473397731781,
-0.053287118673324585,
-0.11759042739868164,
-0.2827019989490509,
0.2079993635416031,
0.49039900302886963,
-0.6991147994995117,
0.22590847313404083,
0.30909955501556396,
-0.13328613340854645,
0.5815751552581787,
-0.473491907119751,
0.23048454523086548,
-1.3871471881866455,
0.15426820516586304,
0.01714816316962242,
-0.43415480852127075,
-0.7772889733314514,
0.18692640960216522,
0.013160360977053642,
-0.579021155834198,
-0.3875296115875244,
0.6822331547737122,
-0.64422208070755,
-0.2832690477371216,
-0.5691508054733276,
0.11737695336341858,
0.17229779064655304,
0.6155341267585754,
0.438720166683197,
0.8929262161254883,
0.6482274532318115,
-0.9238680601119995,
0.3021214008331299,
0.35997191071510315,
-0.6679274439811707,
0.315528005361557,
-0.6885090470314026,
0.24610477685928345,
-0.11160611361265182,
-0.045382652431726456,
-0.6573705673217773,
-0.1562965214252472,
-0.11644067615270615,
-0.22007538378238678,
0.48889583349227905,
-0.11315789073705673,
-0.5432374477386475,
-0.3505774736404419,
0.2547720670700073,
0.14457370340824127,
0.763770580291748,
-0.39744827151298523,
0.5687888860702515,
0.3813929557800293,
-0.6575205326080322,
-0.25433701276779175,
-0.47589269280433655,
0.03412686288356781,
-0.11694381386041641,
-0.4049414396286011,
0.2132963091135025,
-0.1392313688993454,
-0.00787377916276455,
-0.061080507934093475,
-0.13259659707546234,
-0.6664611101150513,
0.4635695219039917,
-0.2072666585445404,
0.2930576205253601,
-0.44935038685798645,
-0.18988849222660065,
-0.227279394865036,
-0.11574891209602356,
0.25862056016921997,
-0.2726614773273468,
0.6166217923164368,
0.1636204570531845,
-0.12982586026191711,
-0.5992375612258911,
0.05757575109601021,
0.3860616087913513,
-0.309981107711792,
0.7819346785545349,
0.07035184651613235,
-0.4026417136192322,
-0.24784408509731293,
-0.5824511051177979,
-0.04320111870765686,
-0.5169380903244019,
0.7697022557258606,
-0.5358058214187622,
-0.8177396059036255,
0.4217783212661743,
-0.3468649387359619,
-0.1321789175271988,
0.3795449733734131,
0.5712591409683228,
-0.012981914915144444,
0.8988721966743469,
1.0301380157470703,
-0.3651042580604553,
0.4393720328807831,
0.007375472690910101,
0.5379448533058167,
-0.435574471950531,
-0.1097646951675415,
-0.6053733825683594,
0.08204182237386703,
-0.47620463371276855,
-0.2681347727775574,
0.05238990858197212,
0.19806303083896637,
-0.18456658720970154,
0.37202778458595276,
0.19091039896011353,
0.6065471768379211,
0.4404955804347992,
-0.17573648691177368,
0.267155259847641,
-0.14336247742176056,
0.15417735278606415,
0.10178954899311066,
-0.6169300675392151,
-0.460736483335495,
1.155313491821289,
0.2977665066719055,
0.8139323592185974,
0.039430856704711914,
0.3306823670864105,
0.031792718917131424,
0.4376365542411804,
-0.5353385806083679,
0.4089624881744385,
-0.28702497482299805,
-0.8414227962493896,
-0.22690045833587646,
-0.510066568851471,
-0.9571744799613953,
-0.006037749350070953,
0.0640215203166008,
-0.4572162628173828,
-0.10126091539859772,
0.055274199694395065,
-0.16376732289791107,
0.15698447823524475,
-0.7153295874595642,
1.1017251014709473,
-0.5010015964508057,
-0.1932782381772995,
-0.23786784708499908,
-0.3791827857494354,
-0.02322539873421192,
-0.6474429965019226,
0.1749858260154724,
-0.11160465329885483,
-0.019022153690457344,
0.7971616387367249,
-0.11248499900102615,
0.7636968493461609,
-0.2407970279455185,
-0.210049569606781,
0.1583368331193924,
-0.2867831885814667,
0.44470319151878357,
-0.04942911118268967,
-0.034737151116132736,
0.07185883820056915,
-0.023488463833928108,
-0.5142709016799927,
-0.7531309127807617,
0.3200840651988983,
-0.9455683827400208,
-0.9602032899856567,
-0.29648423194885254,
-0.44410425424575806,
-0.8923884630203247,
0.5071208477020264,
0.16603556275367737,
0.2965257167816162,
-0.36432427167892456,
0.24694889783859253,
0.875699520111084,
-0.39719316363334656,
0.046307001262903214,
1.0425500869750977,
-0.2824283838272095,
-0.23742420971393585,
0.660641074180603,
0.06215366721153259,
0.3025040626525879,
0.5644538402557373,
-0.000558704137802124,
-0.4979068636894226,
-0.6157941818237305,
-0.2672029435634613,
0.5173866152763367,
-0.5599477291107178,
-0.01216152124106884,
-0.561709463596344,
-0.30583783984184265,
-0.4823480248451233,
0.0668693259358406,
-0.3032596707344055,
0.02021768130362034,
-0.18009591102600098,
0.048916324973106384,
0.11837092787027359,
0.7274619936943054,
0.6507980227470398,
0.34911292791366577,
-0.8541891574859619,
0.40578752756118774,
0.31542012095451355,
0.48741310834884644,
-0.20728720724582672,
-0.738978385925293,
-0.7007413506507874,
0.21969357132911682,
-0.17640651762485504,
-0.5781629681587219,
0.4230596423149109,
0.15482529997825623,
0.7903301119804382,
0.2174646109342575,
-0.11634911596775055,
0.6362779140472412,
-0.5345363020896912,
0.8287132382392883,
0.18544256687164307,
-0.8930865526199341,
0.5810482501983643,
-0.26655852794647217,
0.41420722007751465,
0.6002748012542725,
1.071160078048706,
-0.5775927901268005,
-0.30993643403053284,
-0.688774585723877,
-0.6144809126853943,
0.5810704231262207,
-0.41711899638175964,
0.527065098285675,
0.16602516174316406,
0.7048755884170532,
0.17427003383636475,
0.5692949295043945,
-0.7734894156455994,
-0.0765797570347786,
0.10007715970277786,
-0.24755454063415527,
-0.3543630838394165,
-0.3630692958831787,
0.27127811312675476,
-0.016034826636314392,
1.0656871795654297,
-0.04639413207769394,
0.09548391401767731,
-0.20501795411109924,
-0.352684885263443,
0.1724127233028412,
0.32146796584129333,
0.1837698221206665,
1.144365906715393,
-0.0025235870853066444,
-0.3217490315437317,
0.23549091815948486,
-0.5042673349380493,
0.20295561850070953,
0.05038003996014595,
-0.1393052488565445,
-0.09166640788316727,
0.16117534041404724,
1.0325708389282227,
0.1301000714302063,
-0.8504133820533752,
0.5249240398406982,
0.0025001121684908867,
-0.3905906677246094,
-0.20526844263076782,
0.021525397896766663,
0.11231773346662521,
0.04326878488063812,
0.25581714510917664,
-0.5049676299095154,
-0.22298124432563782,
-0.824871838092804,
0.016760369762778282,
0.26766425371170044,
-0.12171737104654312,
-0.3115905225276947,
0.6313074827194214,
0.16825471818447113,
-0.09430653601884842,
0.6180158257484436,
-0.02589208260178566,
-0.6409010291099548,
0.5115460157394409,
0.7500322461128235,
0.8179333806037903,
-0.27579960227012634,
0.09519154578447342,
0.06695040315389633,
0.19491782784461975,
-0.13369004428386688,
0.40364179015159607,
0.22643670439720154,
-0.9940983057022095,
-0.527350127696991,
-0.5121187567710876,
-0.8903324604034424,
0.57362300157547,
-0.6699369549751282,
0.23750776052474976,
-0.7471792101860046,
-0.23932692408561707,
-0.1950296312570572,
0.5316199064254761,
-0.7287271022796631,
0.7088449001312256,
-0.1234380379319191,
0.7692731022834778,
-0.7276496887207031,
1.06732976436615,
0.9377703070640564,
-0.5255748629570007,
-0.8466518521308899,
0.06333789974451065,
-0.8296715021133423,
-0.865301251411438,
0.7321823239326477,
0.06367647647857666,
0.07092753797769547,
0.3057122230529785,
-0.38427895307540894,
-0.9301939606666565,
0.900986909866333,
0.3866908848285675,
-0.6682917475700378,
0.14392220973968506,
0.395564466714859,
0.6704826354980469,
-0.3753468692302704,
-0.1326863169670105,
0.5204586386680603,
0.2033945769071579,
-0.28328266739845276,
-0.6820805668830872,
-0.2208532691001892,
-0.28772687911987305,
0.20925301313400269,
0.1639220416545868,
-0.7615147233009338,
0.4684816002845764,
0.09066479653120041,
-0.15183046460151672,
0.027716124430298805,
0.6572481989860535,
0.16542550921440125,
0.21875625848770142,
0.25472062826156616,
0.6190956234931946,
1.0685960054397583,
-0.03560454398393631,
0.9226475358009338,
-0.6169360876083374,
-0.03399411961436272,
1.2808995246887207,
-0.865708589553833,
1.0638748407363892,
0.07216636091470718,
-0.23303763568401337,
0.7198675274848938,
0.6108261346817017,
-0.11139564961194992,
0.43051108717918396,
0.1372402012348175,
-0.22402729094028473,
-0.26473870873451233,
-0.051220446825027466,
-0.4793541431427002,
0.24640926718711853,
0.1183256134390831,
-0.050546806305646896,
0.2858981192111969,
0.12419568002223969,
0.1499069482088089,
-0.15603430569171906,
-0.38912492990493774,
0.8993366956710815,
0.14125372469425201,
-0.8054823875427246,
0.3834872543811798,
0.26404809951782227,
0.390646368265152,
-1.0137723684310913,
0.54725581407547,
-0.3360600471496582,
0.12575462460517883,
0.1864417940378189,
-0.5184763073921204,
0.17871586978435516,
0.23940502107143402,
-0.15967540442943573,
-0.2871909737586975,
0.6380272507667542,
-0.5303263068199158,
-0.1790410280227661,
0.18043124675750732,
0.34342747926712036,
0.2157946079969406,
-0.18038471043109894,
-0.6548587679862976,
-0.09114609658718109,
-0.1577344387769699,
-0.2618401348590851,
0.4001674950122833,
0.5656980276107788,
-0.0534653514623642,
0.7262277007102966,
0.6419190764427185,
0.19548606872558594,
0.19447128474712372,
0.6071772575378418,
0.6918409466743469,
-0.8372268676757812,
-0.7474849820137024,
-0.2821480333805084,
0.13507050275802612,
-0.05785253643989563,
-0.3500938415527344,
0.786982536315918,
0.5593464970588684,
1.1272231340408325,
-0.31060799956321716,
0.8603700995445251,
0.5325390100479126,
0.41723400354385376,
-0.7298460602760315,
0.71844083070755,
-0.7250884771347046,
0.10307689756155014,
0.05700305104255676,
-1.0212632417678833,
-0.05680500343441963,
0.44819918274879456,
-0.5108219385147095,
0.44675928354263306,
0.8908831477165222,
0.6618449091911316,
0.18849687278270721,
0.09310449659824371,
0.5506126880645752,
0.4540415108203888,
0.24458461999893188,
0.5561434030532837,
0.7812107801437378,
-0.41134053468704224,
0.2573727071285248,
-0.056198637932538986,
-0.0515257902443409,
-0.09115749597549438,
-0.8433051109313965,
-0.7991256713867188,
-0.3738609850406647,
-0.8412246704101562,
-0.1139688789844513,
0.04762449115514755,
0.6362392902374268,
0.5541888475418091,
-0.6582629084587097,
-0.44032391905784607,
0.12026158720254898,
-0.2274285852909088,
-0.11102216690778732,
-0.20675304532051086,
0.04127688333392143,
-0.6437975764274597,
-0.5212028622627258,
0.384798139333725,
0.2800542116165161,
0.24395333230495453,
-0.11277447640895844,
0.08223998546600342,
-0.23509204387664795,
0.34726482629776,
0.5606338381767273,
0.23039421439170837,
-0.10724101960659027,
0.05497844144701958,
0.03635941818356514,
-0.023933840915560722,
0.10532302409410477,
0.8071265816688538,
-0.42189332842826843,
0.1954907774925232,
0.28049349784851074,
1.1571804285049438,
0.6608225703239441,
-0.056798238307237625,
0.7982075810432434,
-0.6142539381980896,
0.029238076880574226,
0.04500771686434746,
0.3834044933319092,
0.4824080765247345,
-0.3365313708782196,
0.22529907524585724,
0.3800928592681885,
-0.4930799901485443,
-0.46779865026474,
0.27187079191207886,
-0.6685070991516113,
-0.5384864807128906,
0.960149347782135,
-0.25710269808769226,
-0.4157138168811798,
-0.35462674498558044,
0.008747005835175514,
0.16338017582893372,
0.15435120463371277,
0.5494046807289124,
0.8624882698059082,
0.3672339618206024,
-0.07716095447540283,
-0.4050605595111847,
0.3643512725830078,
0.4047311246395111,
-1.190521478652954,
0.09524895250797272,
0.28924763202667236,
0.5787031054496765,
-0.24731436371803284,
1.0712651014328003,
-0.008512597531080246,
0.42389050126075745,
-0.18392039835453033,
0.13389787077903748,
0.10712363570928574,
-0.39041516184806824,
-0.3787037432193756,
0.12500131130218506,
0.6323602795600891,
0.04293760657310486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08259v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08259v1
|
Investigating Neural Machine Translation for Low-Resource Languages: Using Bavarian as a Case Study
| 2024-04-12T06:16:26 | 2024-04-12T06:16:26 |
Wan-Hua Her, Udo Kruschwitz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Machine Translation has made impressive progress in recent years offering
close to human-level performance on many languages, but studies have primarily
focused on high-resource languages with broad online presence and resources.
With the help of growing Large Language Models, more and more low-resource
languages achieve better results through the presence of other languages.
However, studies have shown that not all low-resource languages can benefit
from multilingual systems, especially those with insufficient training and
evaluation data. In this paper, we revisit state-of-the-art Neural Machine
Translation techniques to develop automatic translation systems between German
and Bavarian. We investigate conditions of low-resource languages such as data
scarcity and parameter sensitivity and focus on refined solutions that combat
low-resource difficulties and creative solutions such as harnessing language
similarity. Our experiment entails applying Back-translation and Transfer
Learning to automatically generate more training data and achieve higher
translation performance. We demonstrate noisiness in the data and present our
approach to carry out text preprocessing extensively. Evaluation was conducted
using combined metrics: BLEU, chrF and TER. Statistical significance results
with Bonferroni correction show surprisingly high baseline systems, and that
Back-translation leads to significant improvement. Furthermore, we present a
qualitative analysis of translation errors and system limitations.
|
[
-0.4397406578063965,
-0.5539968609809875,
0.5844733119010925,
0.2295612096786499,
-0.29029956459999084,
0.06986304372549057,
-0.6250051259994507,
-0.36426636576652527,
0.059290312230587006,
0.17566771805286407,
-0.39257994294166565,
-0.3882123529911041,
-0.6778317093849182,
0.40210622549057007,
-0.309600293636322,
0.857562243938446,
-0.20387817919254303,
0.49430835247039795,
0.10287727415561676,
-0.5365694165229797,
-0.4968354403972626,
-0.8069906234741211,
-0.6746584177017212,
-0.5439711213111877,
0.7209978103637695,
0.28930002450942993,
0.6374420523643494,
0.6222206950187683,
0.5824442505836487,
0.30799388885498047,
-0.1067904531955719,
0.10143865644931793,
-0.29616430401802063,
0.06154751032590866,
-0.15138475596904755,
-0.32096099853515625,
-0.3514476418495178,
-0.42943131923675537,
0.8105108141899109,
0.9189473986625671,
0.24083442986011505,
0.2527407109737396,
0.20506738126277924,
0.5750569105148315,
-0.7043017148971558,
0.09504810720682144,
-0.4761536717414856,
0.234889954328537,
-0.20214734971523285,
-0.11512355506420135,
-0.31205952167510986,
-0.20233765244483948,
0.0065859402529895306,
-0.294283390045166,
0.39331957697868347,
-0.06077682599425316,
0.6505602598190308,
0.36009418964385986,
-0.44916531443595886,
-0.044511280953884125,
-0.8955442309379578,
0.7988954782485962,
-0.7137424945831299,
0.5322213768959045,
0.25508618354797363,
0.1468142420053482,
-0.0395827554166317,
-0.46612292528152466,
-0.3695078194141388,
-0.19338010251522064,
-0.2742600739002228,
0.06788236647844315,
-0.5161431431770325,
-0.37090596556663513,
0.06365016847848892,
0.07086128741502762,
-0.6092783808708191,
0.33989331126213074,
-0.21018771827220917,
-0.24962730705738068,
0.38808420300483704,
0.19156228005886078,
-0.01563144288957119,
-0.059835053980350494,
-0.06419830024242401,
-0.37209680676460266,
-0.2900160551071167,
-0.03129369020462036,
0.31664276123046875,
0.524463415145874,
-0.07066433876752853,
0.4183063805103302,
-0.2081376016139984,
0.6871967911720276,
-0.1436557173728943,
0.37438684701919556,
0.3785956799983978,
-0.5968271493911743,
-0.04964292421936989,
0.11034232378005981,
0.8165881633758545,
0.030771609395742416,
0.09113515913486481,
-0.49013420939445496,
-0.484284907579422,
-0.16463665664196014,
0.20147289335727692,
-0.8252513408660889,
0.05122864618897438,
-0.12507082521915436,
-0.6492350697517395,
-0.09661483019590378,
-0.3758613169193268,
-0.6076930165290833,
-0.1969107836484909,
-0.15501926839351654,
0.27668386697769165,
-0.645704984664917,
-0.1510312855243683,
-0.00865813810378313,
0.05731192231178284,
-0.027859045192599297,
0.12170764058828354,
-0.9514920711517334,
0.24964575469493866,
0.24688935279846191,
0.9865689873695374,
-0.2939971685409546,
-0.49462324380874634,
-0.45745953917503357,
-0.05654556676745415,
-0.5574694275856018,
0.6424404978752136,
-0.13477693498134613,
-0.33255958557128906,
0.01119579654186964,
0.030618129298090935,
-0.08443854749202728,
-0.6554544568061829,
0.5076743960380554,
-0.6668638586997986,
-0.1214570701122284,
-0.07351939380168915,
-0.16212034225463867,
-0.08971435576677322,
0.19166281819343567,
-0.7131763696670532,
0.7728891372680664,
0.07835985720157623,
-0.535224437713623,
0.12060081213712692,
-0.5286445617675781,
-1.0563181638717651,
-0.025654183700680733,
0.0788145661354065,
-0.23311617970466614,
0.5279160141944885,
0.07480071485042572,
0.2703763246536255,
-0.3731423318386078,
0.005616954527795315,
-0.08297545462846756,
-0.40179046988487244,
0.4300156533718109,
-0.8169465065002441,
0.6471783518791199,
0.2841823399066925,
-0.3455843925476074,
0.05025478079915047,
-0.6555075645446777,
0.3163401782512665,
0.17945504188537598,
-0.5814040303230286,
-0.2871619760990143,
-0.4413730800151825,
0.32147419452667236,
0.26200881600379944,
0.35325732827186584,
-0.25537002086639404,
-0.11222206801176071,
-0.3759554922580719,
0.5554143786430359,
0.4026619791984558,
-0.22162096202373505,
0.7128575444221497,
-0.06453672796487808,
0.49297186732292175,
0.10669338703155518,
-0.17956037819385529,
0.029446976259350777,
-0.21054096519947052,
-0.8738362193107605,
0.05994703993201256,
0.6452683210372925,
0.6779471039772034,
-1.0104516744613647,
0.33951783180236816,
-0.4038788974285126,
-0.3424789607524872,
-0.8504698872566223,
0.20167165994644165,
0.4423378109931946,
0.5090327858924866,
0.5582157969474792,
-0.4375161826610565,
-0.20053285360336304,
-1.1929951906204224,
-0.11568186432123184,
0.05723259225487709,
-0.0936049297451973,
0.23081056773662567,
0.32468748092651367,
-0.1366586983203888,
0.35718342661857605,
-0.2327893078327179,
-0.22124582529067993,
-0.09517043828964233,
0.19082051515579224,
0.15192201733589172,
0.5601925253868103,
0.5205824375152588,
-0.6849455833435059,
-0.2589796483516693,
0.4098200798034668,
-0.8109421133995056,
0.16713516414165497,
-0.00809591356664896,
-0.1795617789030075,
0.6470756530761719,
0.34474849700927734,
-0.5796990990638733,
0.12474385648965836,
0.6943280100822449,
0.046280521899461746,
0.2800998389720917,
-0.5471248030662537,
0.2881307899951935,
-0.9484184384346008,
0.4165066182613373,
-0.05934730917215347,
-0.11987770348787308,
-0.5784552693367004,
-0.06402657926082611,
0.013223908841609955,
-0.2536526620388031,
-0.6075308918952942,
0.5305680632591248,
-0.3072133958339691,
-0.22275124490261078,
-0.3580567538738251,
-0.02879294753074646,
-0.21980370581150055,
0.6356794238090515,
-0.021752702072262764,
0.6664018630981445,
0.18793943524360657,
-0.5591109991073608,
0.4092678725719452,
0.10116095840930939,
-0.03970474377274513,
0.5841424465179443,
-0.2049034684896469,
0.21167181432247162,
0.060120370239019394,
-0.026675865054130554,
-0.5938860774040222,
-0.11356540769338608,
0.43342289328575134,
-0.5717481374740601,
0.3439132571220398,
-0.1201377883553505,
-0.8210800886154175,
-0.18137745559215546,
0.3714714050292969,
0.5481637120246887,
0.546894907951355,
-0.1277550309896469,
0.305160790681839,
0.06859711557626724,
-0.3016175627708435,
-0.3057221472263336,
-0.9857860207557678,
0.30548226833343506,
-0.16262272000312805,
-0.45919403433799744,
0.302946001291275,
0.18129415810108185,
-0.1964598447084427,
0.32138895988464355,
-0.1035790666937828,
-0.4185624122619629,
0.18934622406959534,
-0.24066442251205444,
0.10550832003355026,
-0.4524068832397461,
0.43592047691345215,
0.05138561502099037,
-0.24080470204353333,
-0.13985693454742432,
-0.754102349281311,
0.5798730254173279,
-0.5285666584968567,
-0.3321540355682373,
-0.44542238116264343,
0.4023967981338501,
0.30238768458366394,
-0.3006654977798462,
0.7072689533233643,
0.8731339573860168,
-0.5756815671920776,
0.0799165889620781,
-0.2976594567298889,
-0.4571981132030487,
-0.3849460184574127,
0.5816912651062012,
-0.5264143943786621,
-0.6792711615562439,
0.3745264708995819,
-0.11537349224090576,
-0.12763290107250214,
0.567744791507721,
0.7073573470115662,
-0.171763077378273,
1.0698833465576172,
0.7116978764533997,
0.022572319954633713,
0.41468095779418945,
-0.12578420341014862,
0.1814490109682083,
-0.211272731423378,
0.046760670840740204,
-0.6414381861686707,
-0.6287533640861511,
-0.8160111308097839,
-0.2171814888715744,
0.15652048587799072,
0.17444290220737457,
-0.009566950611770153,
0.716154158115387,
-0.26060330867767334,
0.19839167594909668,
0.7744194269180298,
-0.06684238463640213,
0.47340261936187744,
0.15344366431236267,
-0.17641675472259521,
-0.18760372698307037,
-1.1536930799484253,
-0.5341558456420898,
0.7030711770057678,
-0.02337736263871193,
0.270332008600235,
-0.07916546612977982,
0.7347381711006165,
0.2671968638896942,
0.3821181654930115,
-0.877471387386322,
0.3096352517604828,
-0.4386051893234253,
-0.49745941162109375,
-0.5241568684577942,
-0.736186146736145,
-0.9714716076850891,
0.38796016573905945,
-0.3832882344722748,
-0.2551524043083191,
0.08635827153921127,
0.15951363742351532,
-0.3156789243221283,
0.2790321707725525,
-0.8431142568588257,
0.9640974998474121,
-0.7078898549079895,
-0.3921695947647095,
-0.40213873982429504,
-0.6512482762336731,
-0.05495423078536987,
-0.4386095106601715,
0.16495907306671143,
0.18790747225284576,
0.0098762521520257,
0.36193662881851196,
-0.050728876143693924,
0.5740556716918945,
0.11423642933368683,
-0.1303943693637848,
-0.06530920416116714,
0.15092505514621735,
0.25931113958358765,
-0.25550585985183716,
-0.2319740355014801,
0.5291231274604797,
-0.09707590937614441,
-0.5889335870742798,
-0.663748562335968,
0.7038677930831909,
-0.6014521718025208,
-0.4159601330757141,
-0.2555873394012451,
-0.7186142802238464,
-0.22362235188484192,
0.6394833922386169,
0.4820817708969116,
-0.16295617818832397,
-0.2481791079044342,
0.12413207441568375,
0.37097403407096863,
-0.19495119154453278,
0.5883164405822754,
0.5191753506660461,
0.19565965235233307,
-0.3669547438621521,
1.088804006576538,
0.3155239522457123,
-0.034225087612867355,
0.12867672741413116,
-0.07114119827747345,
-0.11730014532804489,
-0.5960023403167725,
-1.1189444065093994,
0.11427765339612961,
-0.4884510636329651,
-0.14396046102046967,
-0.43790796399116516,
-0.1606183499097824,
-0.26945966482162476,
-0.08783643692731857,
-0.48430556058883667,
-0.451876163482666,
-0.22994662821292877,
0.20238707959651947,
-0.0460905022919178,
0.4927852153778076,
-0.09754303842782974,
0.37264546751976013,
-1.1292381286621094,
-0.01455091405659914,
-0.1920497864484787,
0.21935515105724335,
0.20424921810626984,
-0.32094666361808777,
-0.8348700404167175,
0.02285504713654518,
-0.4459776282310486,
-0.7809709310531616,
0.5246906876564026,
-0.15646180510520935,
0.4883251190185547,
-0.12400417029857635,
0.06795132160186768,
0.3778727650642395,
-0.6573302745819092,
0.19399653375148773,
0.2065054178237915,
-0.8536744713783264,
0.2394464761018753,
-0.13533128798007965,
0.3253333270549774,
0.5298216938972473,
0.27878859639167786,
-0.6797493100166321,
-0.19533222913742065,
-0.5465158224105835,
-0.7524041533470154,
0.7004534006118774,
0.5058630704879761,
0.33888328075408936,
0.33229073882102966,
0.25871574878692627,
0.122665636241436,
0.3876911699771881,
-0.4299168884754181,
-0.09027458727359772,
-0.11522878706455231,
-0.0805082693696022,
-0.34264862537384033,
0.4268788695335388,
-0.08716372400522232,
0.1199013739824295,
0.6203547716140747,
-0.12796418368816376,
0.03501532971858978,
-0.007246552035212517,
-0.2728222906589508,
-0.21849395334720612,
0.5293164253234863,
0.47914668917655945,
0.329601526260376,
0.14025627076625824,
0.11906109005212784,
0.6967540383338928,
-0.03678133711218834,
0.48580071330070496,
0.4911162853240967,
-0.300249844789505,
0.13342127203941345,
0.40487250685691833,
0.7999059557914734,
0.0808311477303505,
-0.4212819039821625,
0.21758009493350983,
-0.02707810141146183,
-0.02877112105488777,
-0.1073477640748024,
-0.29356998205184937,
0.28615912795066833,
0.4404269754886627,
0.30570077896118164,
0.46479666233062744,
0.043832313269376755,
-0.3326534032821655,
0.08333927392959595,
0.27230408787727356,
-0.5537222027778625,
-0.3807196617126465,
0.38566863536834717,
0.2507811188697815,
-0.5292162895202637,
0.7665572166442871,
-0.3081623613834381,
-0.3984394073486328,
0.5160340666770935,
0.5025767087936401,
0.781378448009491,
0.057569682598114014,
0.12405569851398468,
0.11215011775493622,
0.4151349663734436,
-0.041000910103321075,
0.03152140602469444,
-0.0716773048043251,
-0.5967053771018982,
-0.4830271005630493,
-0.5445313453674316,
-0.22192879021167755,
0.1843162626028061,
-0.6157297492027283,
0.23855389654636383,
-0.24682307243347168,
-0.6234097480773926,
-0.21323232352733612,
-0.12304671108722687,
-0.8806694746017456,
-0.007426357362419367,
0.1809195727109909,
0.6837161183357239,
-0.7884042859077454,
0.8951451182365417,
0.8349812030792236,
-0.421633780002594,
-0.3503290116786957,
0.19011330604553223,
-0.32361268997192383,
-0.5979913473129272,
0.8182523846626282,
-0.09005851298570633,
-0.3929966986179352,
0.22434957325458527,
-0.03328441083431244,
-0.5853446125984192,
0.6899740695953369,
0.7837091684341431,
-0.48882853984832764,
-0.21928207576274872,
0.1786758005619049,
1.0016803741455078,
-0.05987463518977165,
-0.28260084986686707,
0.5821869969367981,
0.6256479024887085,
-0.21492213010787964,
-0.7848688364028931,
0.04282214492559433,
-0.24444793164730072,
-0.056773047894239426,
0.22387540340423584,
-0.7243785262107849,
0.6252827048301697,
-0.14268821477890015,
-0.2513868808746338,
0.20628291368484497,
0.6008066534996033,
-0.10312741994857788,
0.3893643021583557,
0.23345023393630981,
0.4694579541683197,
0.5201541185379028,
-0.03377357870340347,
0.9572488069534302,
-0.4857726991176605,
0.20915158092975616,
1.0121136903762817,
-0.2917303144931793,
0.7984586358070374,
0.6672180891036987,
0.17475734651088715,
0.03394164517521858,
0.5761581659317017,
-0.12931008636951447,
0.5295089483261108,
0.3297808766365051,
-0.2731550335884094,
-0.3437824547290802,
-0.45481204986572266,
-0.3405994474887848,
0.4620157480239868,
0.00892649032175541,
-0.35002997517585754,
-0.24019412696361542,
0.09825453907251358,
-0.04525662586092949,
0.09891169518232346,
-0.032962530851364136,
0.6413077712059021,
0.21741145849227905,
-0.689236581325531,
0.8163246512413025,
0.3546946346759796,
0.5014632344245911,
-0.3990328013896942,
0.02078651264309883,
-0.3636432886123657,
0.3597409427165985,
0.008283738978207111,
-0.5012916922569275,
0.4454919993877411,
0.18022166192531586,
-0.21529799699783325,
-0.4329470694065094,
0.571705162525177,
-0.32020601630210876,
-0.5680974125862122,
0.6383332014083862,
1.0057717561721802,
0.20038530230522156,
0.03282869979739189,
-0.4585992991924286,
-0.13877102732658386,
-0.24364924430847168,
-0.03614816442131996,
0.4248740077018738,
0.6198340654373169,
-0.16852417588233948,
0.36186686158180237,
0.5875540375709534,
0.41096028685569763,
-0.06636074930429459,
-0.04995562881231308,
0.635380208492279,
-0.6249467134475708,
-0.4143892228603363,
-0.9057170152664185,
0.029451260343194008,
0.1838134080171585,
-0.3928021788597107,
0.6284485459327698,
0.5894357562065125,
1.2320799827575684,
-0.12972362339496613,
0.8612294793128967,
0.21873432397842407,
0.03906593471765518,
-0.4937356114387512,
1.08133864402771,
-0.6650818586349487,
-0.22647453844547272,
0.005689979065209627,
-1.0354079008102417,
-0.3639523684978485,
0.34721916913986206,
-0.2332669049501419,
-0.04459888115525246,
0.7042398452758789,
0.48514899611473083,
-0.1315327286720276,
-0.2623356282711029,
0.5555493235588074,
0.08122522383928299,
-0.0785088911652565,
0.6743150949478149,
0.7622490525245667,
-0.3278807997703552,
1.0677753686904907,
-0.3180209696292877,
-0.027592511847615242,
-0.26114097237586975,
-0.6060976386070251,
-0.5009644627571106,
-0.46431779861450195,
0.026507629081606865,
-0.4368552267551422,
0.2872830927371979,
0.7119132280349731,
0.6542654037475586,
-0.9244921207427979,
-0.4335574805736542,
0.08802446722984314,
0.04055853560566902,
-0.29580581188201904,
-0.08988846093416214,
0.33132728934288025,
-0.5361389517784119,
-0.830734133720398,
0.5336397886276245,
0.08772674947977066,
0.35169947147369385,
-0.18373581767082214,
-0.29278498888015747,
0.023236608132719994,
-0.26248449087142944,
0.4238426089286804,
0.2347322702407837,
-0.42766323685646057,
-0.0730401948094368,
0.35908788442611694,
-0.4770703911781311,
0.14936348795890808,
1.000710368156433,
-0.5605342984199524,
0.12974341213703156,
0.5434447526931763,
1.168224573135376,
0.6393323540687561,
-0.2801574766635895,
0.6855233907699585,
-0.7622796297073364,
0.21553649008274078,
0.3286038935184479,
0.356017142534256,
0.6054785847663879,
-0.225625142455101,
0.3714461624622345,
0.2762422263622284,
-0.19541329145431519,
-0.5853509902954102,
0.3140469193458557,
-0.26081886887550354,
-0.29576975107192993,
0.7169593572616577,
-0.21300114691257477,
-0.1045117899775505,
0.1305609941482544,
-0.0091862166300416,
0.8001556396484375,
-0.36345046758651733,
0.792341411113739,
1.0636076927185059,
-0.16217182576656342,
0.06979796290397644,
-0.5621011853218079,
0.19359363615512848,
0.7831631302833557,
-0.6375698447227478,
-0.030047951266169548,
0.4771706759929657,
-0.013882556930184364,
0.37066367268562317,
0.3485721945762634,
0.04028892144560814,
0.22136002779006958,
0.06623805314302444,
0.026691893115639687,
0.07031340152025223,
-0.2450721263885498,
-0.8466475009918213,
0.02183404564857483,
0.007169289048761129,
-0.26185014843940735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08191v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08191v1
|
Measuring Cross-lingual Transfer in Bytes
| 2024-04-12T01:44:46 | 2024-04-12T01:44:46 |
Leandro Rodrigues de Souza, Thales Sales Almeida, Roberto Lotufo, Rodrigo Nogueira
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multilingual pretraining has been a successful solution to the challenges
posed by the lack of resources for languages. These models can transfer
knowledge to target languages with minimal or no examples. Recent research
suggests that monolingual models also have a similar capability, but the
mechanisms behind this transfer remain unclear. Some studies have explored
factors like language contamination and syntactic similarity. An emerging line
of research suggests that the representations learned by language models
contain two components: a language-specific and a language-agnostic component.
The latter is responsible for transferring a more universal knowledge. However,
there is a lack of comprehensive exploration of these properties across diverse
target languages. To investigate this hypothesis, we conducted an experiment
inspired by the work on the Scaling Laws for Transfer. We measured the amount
of data transferred from a source language to a target language and found that
models initialized from diverse languages perform similarly to a target
language in a cross-lingual setting. This was surprising because the amount of
data transferred to 10 diverse target languages, such as Spanish, Korean, and
Finnish, was quite similar. We also found evidence that this transfer is not
related to language contamination or language proximity, which strengthens the
hypothesis that the model also relies on language-agnostic knowledge. Our
experiments have opened up new possibilities for measuring how much data
represents the language-agnostic representations learned during pretraining.
|
[
-0.46707260608673096,
-0.37702879309654236,
0.46455544233322144,
0.2352139949798584,
-0.0465887226164341,
0.012884551659226418,
-0.16649901866912842,
-0.7334749102592468,
0.4962681829929352,
0.26972776651382446,
-0.3968532383441925,
0.049843382090330124,
-0.6644887328147888,
0.0716891884803772,
-0.5066689848899841,
0.8241748213768005,
-0.34587201476097107,
0.2487344741821289,
-0.1372913122177124,
-0.3106151819229126,
-0.27796095609664917,
-0.5284874439239502,
-0.13539373874664307,
-0.4909851849079132,
0.39448973536491394,
0.222751647233963,
0.5629960298538208,
0.5506407022476196,
0.36514922976493835,
0.23516133427619934,
0.37172773480415344,
-0.5845741033554077,
-0.3884274661540985,
-0.39410367608070374,
-0.5566551685333252,
-0.7757971286773682,
-0.22884908318519592,
0.07506097853183746,
0.9319366812705994,
1.1530739068984985,
0.09776012599468231,
0.37637948989868164,
-0.03215315565466881,
0.46940580010414124,
-0.6264031529426575,
-0.07126552611589432,
-0.6202524304389954,
0.33331307768821716,
-0.3307724595069885,
-0.13700439035892487,
-0.5734501481056213,
-0.13964445888996124,
0.24619659781455994,
-0.8919869065284729,
0.21695950627326965,
-0.027510838583111763,
0.7570367455482483,
-0.15892408788204193,
-0.6681475043296814,
-0.3718299865722656,
-0.7836463451385498,
0.778529703617096,
-0.2938452363014221,
0.674763560295105,
0.34498330950737,
0.13579747080802917,
0.37141847610473633,
-0.4966271221637726,
-0.5102669596672058,
-0.253361314535141,
-0.19400976598262787,
-0.026907458901405334,
-0.40601539611816406,
-0.20127475261688232,
0.20475922524929047,
0.19425663352012634,
-0.49621570110321045,
-0.01388291921466589,
-0.5251480937004089,
-0.5260339379310608,
0.41591140627861023,
-0.12429168820381165,
0.6483751535415649,
0.19218656420707703,
-0.5823627710342407,
-0.28954917192459106,
-0.6462429165840149,
0.10078217834234238,
0.40044403076171875,
0.34602615237236023,
-0.30084317922592163,
0.4150448441505432,
-0.008553246036171913,
0.5882577896118164,
0.0163875799626112,
-0.004318626131862402,
0.3796510696411133,
-0.8002269268035889,
0.18424494564533234,
0.3301301896572113,
0.7432693243026733,
0.10672000795602798,
0.7157604694366455,
-0.4474436938762665,
0.07161073386669159,
0.061669208109378815,
0.2369077205657959,
-1.0875009298324585,
-0.19385817646980286,
-0.4053346514701843,
-0.42988407611846924,
0.0901528000831604,
-0.10720942914485931,
-0.5292878150939941,
-0.14442653954029083,
-0.18549491465091705,
0.6311270594596863,
-0.5695214867591858,
-0.7820103764533997,
0.23777680099010468,
-0.04746254161000252,
0.2045903354883194,
0.045244503766298294,
-1.3554564714431763,
0.32819730043411255,
0.2908732295036316,
0.6606549620628357,
-0.3725244700908661,
-0.7208282351493835,
-0.25560104846954346,
0.17149142920970917,
-0.4125750660896301,
0.7611865997314453,
-0.6610119938850403,
-0.2463308721780777,
-0.07291590422391891,
0.054137393832206726,
-0.3239784240722656,
-0.3907488286495209,
-0.2674054205417633,
-0.4175756573677063,
-0.04792695492506027,
-0.6062852144241333,
-0.5068950057029724,
-0.24219390749931335,
0.20756256580352783,
-0.5921626091003418,
0.6049699187278748,
0.22101980447769165,
-0.6562603712081909,
0.6137682795524597,
-0.3131599426269531,
-0.6140048503875732,
-0.03695262596011162,
-0.25489500164985657,
0.09635443985462189,
0.2613069713115692,
-0.17243604362010956,
0.20561492443084717,
-0.19547255337238312,
0.012356902472674847,
-0.5227968692779541,
-0.21978969871997833,
0.26068028807640076,
-0.36554551124572754,
0.8000047206878662,
0.14322277903556824,
-0.29441797733306885,
-0.09667032212018967,
-0.7171394228935242,
0.19995872676372528,
0.00007694689702475443,
-0.3095690608024597,
-0.5505832433700562,
-0.4709629416465759,
-0.12406247854232788,
0.19299133121967316,
0.3624500036239624,
-0.717311680316925,
0.25951504707336426,
-0.018918266519904137,
0.18314360082149506,
0.48068875074386597,
-0.3318667411804199,
0.8746659159660339,
-0.10857312381267548,
0.6448233723640442,
0.26852256059646606,
-0.1816471964120865,
-0.3241942524909973,
-0.12143220752477646,
-0.5518054962158203,
0.013083657249808311,
0.370599627494812,
0.3988148868083954,
-0.5170428156852722,
-0.04013700783252716,
-0.6103583574295044,
-0.4424872398376465,
-0.7530956268310547,
0.09890619665384293,
0.35879603028297424,
0.33388903737068176,
0.35647743940353394,
-0.5958101749420166,
-0.3108794391155243,
-1.054579496383667,
-0.5035105347633362,
-0.3319261968135834,
0.07830450683832169,
0.08993714302778244,
0.4199840724468231,
-0.24979257583618164,
0.7432685494422913,
-0.0720234215259552,
-0.010226116515696049,
-0.19966359436511993,
0.2988376021385193,
-0.08510497957468033,
0.6027130484580994,
0.93826824426651,
-0.6569534540176392,
-0.8333883881568909,
0.41469308733940125,
-0.5767407417297363,
-0.07520841807126999,
-0.06228083372116089,
-0.14392657577991486,
0.06474675238132477,
0.4472614824771881,
-0.4358266294002533,
0.286243200302124,
0.7193034291267395,
-0.6203874945640564,
0.7738288044929504,
-0.2401244044303894,
0.4049603343009949,
-0.8252902030944824,
0.35399478673934937,
-0.3112773895263672,
-0.32717180252075195,
-0.8969880938529968,
-0.11198681592941284,
0.38332968950271606,
0.05092213302850723,
-0.5964634418487549,
0.7564628720283508,
-0.6402958631515503,
-0.42296504974365234,
-0.17060218751430511,
-0.21033912897109985,
0.0215380247682333,
0.29633980989456177,
0.30002155900001526,
0.9119881391525269,
0.7551656365394592,
-0.6242525577545166,
0.10227912664413452,
0.023586438968777657,
-0.41369616985321045,
0.5913974642753601,
-0.5247702598571777,
0.07776694744825363,
0.07426552474498749,
-0.1732754409313202,
-1.0066463947296143,
0.08056847006082535,
0.014409041963517666,
-0.43392372131347656,
0.3141810894012451,
-0.3044719696044922,
-0.21575698256492615,
0.13500970602035522,
0.15023823082447052,
0.8184929490089417,
0.3990667760372162,
-0.27729785442352295,
0.5452165603637695,
0.378971129655838,
-0.19720560312271118,
-0.5836948752403259,
-0.996821939945221,
-0.2430407702922821,
-0.23718726634979248,
-0.5655457377433777,
0.28956303000450134,
-0.11472110450267792,
-0.06596197932958603,
0.22181807458400726,
-0.23880785703659058,
-0.23187442123889923,
0.12344402819871902,
-0.1398935765028,
0.09555749595165253,
-0.40820759534835815,
0.014342454262077808,
-0.10436476767063141,
0.04014739766716957,
0.48606860637664795,
-0.4926839768886566,
0.6053363680839539,
-0.26342183351516724,
-0.6043664216995239,
0.058093395084142685,
0.2613309323787689,
0.6310729384422302,
-0.3621346950531006,
0.8133084774017334,
0.7435550689697266,
-0.23635002970695496,
0.025780195370316505,
-0.3589504361152649,
-0.07365179806947708,
-0.4136308431625366,
0.572948157787323,
-0.7647253274917603,
-0.6887494921684265,
0.9530623555183411,
0.019765781238675117,
-0.22495828568935394,
0.341942697763443,
0.3448253571987152,
0.3370486795902252,
0.8079289197921753,
0.9266216158866882,
-0.1056659147143364,
0.5802678465843201,
0.05152877792716026,
0.04790326580405235,
-0.4742272198200226,
-0.0031299972906708717,
-0.5667651891708374,
-0.2381281554698944,
-0.48806703090667725,
-0.29308903217315674,
0.009626315906643867,
0.20612317323684692,
-0.16167864203453064,
0.5316274762153625,
0.05952189117670059,
0.6046230792999268,
0.34166789054870605,
-0.32850220799446106,
0.21032394468784332,
0.32269784808158875,
-0.4449889659881592,
-0.032571375370025635,
-0.7321475148200989,
-0.06276993453502655,
1.2250758409500122,
0.25766053795814514,
0.7444833517074585,
0.11853476613759995,
0.5159065127372742,
0.07615890353918076,
0.4012931287288666,
-0.5124890208244324,
0.32057899236679077,
-0.2297302633523941,
-0.7947016358375549,
-0.2898348569869995,
-0.7164909243583679,
-1.0022004842758179,
0.40698638558387756,
-0.12999297678470612,
-0.7792959213256836,
0.2406632900238037,
-0.04134121537208557,
0.018748397007584572,
0.44906583428382874,
-0.75490403175354,
1.110975980758667,
-0.36715373396873474,
-0.4144572615623474,
-0.3723994791507721,
-0.526997447013855,
0.0965893343091011,
-0.3612157702445984,
0.2839851379394531,
0.021007085219025612,
0.16467511653900146,
0.8787251710891724,
-0.058830033987760544,
0.5380833148956299,
-0.15579159557819366,
-0.2942027747631073,
0.21370260417461395,
0.5152924060821533,
0.19883204996585846,
-0.38245320320129395,
-0.009431225247681141,
0.35841065645217896,
0.32682713866233826,
-0.6595566868782043,
-0.4508182108402252,
0.37031057476997375,
-0.8901064395904541,
-0.29843226075172424,
-0.228022962808609,
-0.6485246419906616,
-0.18386100232601166,
0.7661975622177124,
0.35677075386047363,
0.16078290343284607,
-0.21030457317829132,
0.15271104872226715,
0.6481347680091858,
-0.08936312794685364,
0.23162217438220978,
1.0495975017547607,
-0.6035999059677124,
0.14871123433113098,
1.018175721168518,
0.32964423298835754,
0.7278280854225159,
0.48602357506752014,
0.14845037460327148,
-0.3057183027267456,
-0.6033774614334106,
-0.6830653548240662,
0.219205841422081,
-0.7345365881919861,
0.2967372238636017,
-0.549269437789917,
-0.031552206724882126,
-0.557632327079773,
-0.1454818695783615,
-0.7375869750976562,
-0.2821890711784363,
-0.055428098887205124,
-0.08634398132562637,
-0.039013709872961044,
0.6190462112426758,
-0.2453431785106659,
0.10985568165779114,
-1.0125610828399658,
0.2179894596338272,
0.19269168376922607,
0.38141894340515137,
0.006913464050740004,
-0.6777454018592834,
-0.4406367838382721,
0.2248614877462387,
0.20469890534877777,
-1.0562033653259277,
0.34520936012268066,
0.19109193980693817,
0.7540854215621948,
0.33793890476226807,
-0.1357170194387436,
0.805401086807251,
-0.4847697615623474,
0.4838802218437195,
0.4722476005554199,
-1.1798393726348877,
0.16157273948192596,
-0.21508489549160004,
0.38448068499565125,
0.7538079023361206,
0.7670862674713135,
-0.6286559104919434,
-0.14509204030036926,
-0.4084782600402832,
-0.4742138683795929,
0.7554143667221069,
-0.2337183654308319,
0.14584970474243164,
0.1702141910791397,
0.09795205295085907,
0.4059722423553467,
0.22968895733356476,
-0.8737771511077881,
-0.16443364322185516,
-0.18240080773830414,
0.05333047732710838,
-0.23003271222114563,
0.05077401548624039,
0.24134600162506104,
-0.2243693768978119,
0.27659058570861816,
-0.1918659508228302,
0.11188196390867233,
0.1367768496274948,
-0.543114423751831,
-0.283790647983551,
0.28083696961402893,
0.27654242515563965,
0.7257110476493835,
0.05269807577133179,
0.5486042499542236,
0.242933452129364,
-0.8914168477058411,
0.5546293258666992,
-0.008746245875954628,
-0.2103085219860077,
-0.14002901315689087,
0.5091080665588379,
0.8448165059089661,
0.17641225457191467,
-0.5632997751235962,
0.4678365886211395,
-0.06319869309663773,
-0.0945001095533371,
-0.10563122481107712,
-0.06625113636255264,
0.15098458528518677,
-0.027888154610991478,
0.1807778924703598,
0.13255959749221802,
0.07746314257383347,
-0.8636424541473389,
0.31204214692115784,
0.4305972158908844,
-0.3796257972717285,
-0.8975458145141602,
0.453640341758728,
0.0433184951543808,
0.11345230042934418,
0.6479982137680054,
-0.2624439597129822,
-0.5486657619476318,
0.5988473892211914,
0.7966212630271912,
0.495663583278656,
-0.5341755151748657,
0.22045908868312836,
0.38069677352905273,
0.5147094130516052,
-0.09608055651187897,
0.04408843815326691,
-0.19675213098526,
-1.0354204177856445,
-0.48225143551826477,
-0.6151257157325745,
-0.08325236290693283,
-0.04410092905163765,
-0.950660228729248,
0.08727966248989105,
0.017582422122359276,
0.031926561146974564,
0.1735427975654602,
0.07830332219600677,
-0.9884731769561768,
-0.05856310576200485,
0.35151147842407227,
0.8712986707687378,
-1.2171540260314941,
1.0089111328125,
0.8860129117965698,
-0.2939992845058441,
-0.8537918925285339,
-0.19768938422203064,
-0.32327553629875183,
-1.0150185823440552,
0.7687978148460388,
0.24998381733894348,
-0.12507106363773346,
-0.0600740909576416,
-0.04113304987549782,
-1.1095329523086548,
0.711202085018158,
0.7698673009872437,
-0.5744717717170715,
-0.035038020461797714,
0.7277700304985046,
0.5542447566986084,
-0.44355466961860657,
0.3991764187812805,
0.4771721065044403,
0.5092698931694031,
-0.06185721606016159,
-1.255106806755066,
0.17118704319000244,
-0.3687724769115448,
-0.3484123945236206,
0.25125396251678467,
-0.4744328558444977,
1.2237224578857422,
-0.20395247638225555,
-0.4068170487880707,
-0.4892810881137848,
0.5578877925872803,
-0.06140969321131706,
0.20745670795440674,
0.5412704348564148,
0.5158967971801758,
0.7244715690612793,
0.2752000093460083,
1.0163344144821167,
-0.4816854000091553,
0.13858677446842194,
0.7779584527015686,
-0.4476536214351654,
0.6078762412071228,
0.6169897317886353,
-0.3706980049610138,
0.4235338866710663,
0.26509594917297363,
0.19561652839183807,
0.4998680353164673,
0.2637544572353363,
-0.08592196553945541,
-0.30485233664512634,
-0.14890702068805695,
-0.4243518114089966,
0.3516855835914612,
0.23923681676387787,
-0.14048005640506744,
-0.3090924620628357,
0.2684593200683594,
0.14082381129264832,
-0.19278393685817719,
-0.41458767652511597,
0.5801907181739807,
-0.032058630138635635,
-0.9451490640640259,
0.7324962615966797,
-0.2801545262336731,
0.6775403022766113,
-0.9516006112098694,
0.16489845514297485,
-0.21568402647972107,
0.2331085503101349,
-0.11023601144552231,
-0.8376263976097107,
0.527724027633667,
-0.012904833070933819,
-0.2661076486110687,
-0.5385265350341797,
0.9436119198799133,
-0.7160843014717102,
-0.2605299949645996,
0.7358608245849609,
0.6970701813697815,
0.5291231274604797,
-0.013260755687952042,
-0.3357681334018707,
0.024272413924336433,
0.3778749406337738,
-0.1930381953716278,
0.8566262722015381,
0.6075791716575623,
-0.05641017481684685,
0.5259801745414734,
0.4802526831626892,
0.472912460565567,
0.5651451349258423,
-0.1791512668132782,
0.5457992553710938,
-0.5198943018913269,
-0.6487346887588501,
-0.7302793264389038,
0.18297719955444336,
0.365263432264328,
-0.17958956956863403,
1.0588737726211548,
0.5093362927436829,
1.1789796352386475,
-0.15537375211715698,
0.8988752961158752,
-0.13958947360515594,
0.13143177330493927,
-0.377678781747818,
0.7916304469108582,
-0.641442596912384,
-0.11174546927213669,
0.033983223140239716,
-0.9485930800437927,
0.31234800815582275,
0.5393580198287964,
-0.29394590854644775,
-0.0408947579562664,
0.6582993865013123,
0.3814474046230316,
-0.4970724284648895,
-0.08280229568481445,
0.28073355555534363,
0.07662893086671829,
0.16413192451000214,
0.6972970962524414,
0.6391220092773438,
-0.21129441261291504,
0.6359665989875793,
-0.16631516814231873,
-0.16563256084918976,
0.025380084291100502,
-0.8092228174209595,
-0.7102000117301941,
-0.621141791343689,
-0.35161682963371277,
-0.13245077431201935,
-0.10400336235761642,
0.380452424287796,
0.8444675803184509,
-0.6979570388793945,
-0.467151403427124,
-0.1795683205127716,
-0.20783306658267975,
-0.2113601565361023,
-0.13791555166244507,
0.14485399425029755,
-0.3635278046131134,
-0.42167502641677856,
0.3333641588687897,
-0.12723489105701447,
0.28983601927757263,
-0.4004509449005127,
0.0016441146144643426,
-0.11648968607187271,
0.011139537207782269,
0.4166719615459442,
0.4272702634334564,
-0.10272157192230225,
-0.2977192997932434,
0.20271453261375427,
-0.1689382791519165,
-0.040474552661180496,
0.8919464945793152,
-0.721966028213501,
0.4496433436870575,
0.7342064380645752,
0.6878600716590881,
0.7111228108406067,
-0.3739517629146576,
0.5952280163764954,
-0.8682913184165955,
0.3353276252746582,
-0.06096602603793144,
0.28655263781547546,
0.15347625315189362,
-0.08436021953821182,
0.3001285195350647,
0.27388709783554077,
-0.25398072600364685,
-0.8664193749427795,
0.3487533926963806,
-0.6499593257904053,
-0.3981516659259796,
1.1265912055969238,
-0.4458322525024414,
-0.22503139078617096,
0.08276723325252533,
0.377588152885437,
0.22697865962982178,
0.014956344850361347,
0.4483624994754791,
1.0491913557052612,
0.025128118693828583,
0.03950057178735733,
-0.5753406882286072,
0.26927658915519714,
0.6863651871681213,
-0.6815299391746521,
0.16547144949436188,
0.19727784395217896,
0.6216877102851868,
0.6504455208778381,
0.8113543391227722,
-0.16981621086597443,
0.12510614097118378,
0.41227856278419495,
0.24020040035247803,
0.08855599164962769,
-0.5077134370803833,
-0.2720288634300232,
0.07810919731855392,
-0.0913001298904419,
-0.03941430151462555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08189v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08189v1
|
Reducing hallucination in structured outputs via Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-04-12T01:42:09 | 2024-04-12T01:42:09 |
Patrice Béchard, Orlando Marquez Ayala
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
A common and fundamental limitation of Generative AI (GenAI) is its
propensity to hallucinate. While large language models (LLM) have taken the
world by storm, without eliminating or at least reducing hallucinations,
real-world GenAI systems may face challenges in user adoption. In the process
of deploying an enterprise application that produces workflows based on natural
language requirements, we devised a system leveraging Retrieval Augmented
Generation (RAG) to greatly improve the quality of the structured output that
represents such workflows. Thanks to our implementation of RAG, our proposed
system significantly reduces hallucinations in the output and improves the
generalization of our LLM in out-of-domain settings. In addition, we show that
using a small, well-trained retriever encoder can reduce the size of the
accompanying LLM, thereby making deployments of LLM-based systems less
resource-intensive.
|
[
-0.4958263337612152,
-0.610931396484375,
0.4883594214916229,
0.09108009934425354,
-0.17922571301460266,
0.14679618179798126,
-0.25999587774276733,
-0.6248945593833923,
0.5698544979095459,
0.6948143839836121,
-0.27202415466308594,
-0.29222458600997925,
-0.5049562454223633,
0.34434014558792114,
-0.5094760656356812,
1.0249607563018799,
0.1264093965291977,
-0.3005464971065521,
-0.14047981798648834,
0.09403051435947418,
-0.4940924346446991,
-0.5264961123466492,
-0.7715988159179688,
-0.6050100922584534,
0.39629918336868286,
0.2402401566505432,
0.8171632885932922,
0.40686795115470886,
0.7288633584976196,
0.29300251603126526,
-0.03471121937036514,
0.5705262422561646,
-0.6665158271789551,
0.46911299228668213,
-0.09415393322706223,
-0.2570972442626953,
-0.45983076095581055,
-0.3526668846607208,
0.5977612137794495,
0.7593401074409485,
-0.460782915353775,
0.07261765003204346,
0.1711585521697998,
0.8938542604446411,
-0.7530232071876526,
0.06994213163852692,
-0.4658924639225006,
0.19304364919662476,
-0.11153291165828705,
-0.40641629695892334,
-0.6301485300064087,
-0.11596111208200455,
-0.15162332355976105,
-0.790151059627533,
0.4191303849220276,
0.1755024939775467,
0.9686340689659119,
0.5363081097602844,
-0.03740565478801727,
-0.1992039978504181,
-1.2406214475631714,
0.5869426727294922,
-0.6064777970314026,
0.366587370634079,
0.3990992307662964,
0.2796054184436798,
-0.47116556763648987,
-0.7407616376876831,
-0.5671603679656982,
-0.15202361345291138,
-0.33309903740882874,
0.018176142126321793,
-0.007689058315008879,
0.23144367337226868,
0.48288729786872864,
0.48259109258651733,
-0.8653318285942078,
-0.01117727067321539,
-0.48640769720077515,
-0.09817437827587128,
0.5839434266090393,
0.2864404320716858,
0.17916204035282135,
-0.2505483627319336,
0.1351536214351654,
-0.05485723540186882,
-0.6581626534461975,
-0.5628721714019775,
0.14198172092437744,
0.2552172839641571,
0.3539712727069855,
0.7247040867805481,
-0.27440938353538513,
0.6031057834625244,
0.13097044825553894,
-0.12365248799324036,
0.41430172324180603,
0.02203889563679695,
-0.5279630422592163,
-0.10373256355524063,
0.62692791223526,
0.028264811262488365,
0.13911902904510498,
-0.47836148738861084,
-0.42050832509994507,
0.15130329132080078,
0.6947917342185974,
-0.9116207957267761,
-0.12499471008777618,
0.08375845104455948,
-0.5038254857063293,
-0.07835276424884796,
0.06612072139978409,
-0.8040132522583008,
-0.6828683018684387,
-0.391019344329834,
0.3229704797267914,
-0.5079807043075562,
-0.02956243045628071,
-0.29096779227256775,
-0.26929011940956116,
0.40486273169517517,
0.284699022769928,
-0.9467511177062988,
0.29959824681282043,
0.819249153137207,
0.885016918182373,
-0.100284643471241,
0.017206046730279922,
-0.9134624004364014,
0.39816027879714966,
-0.4866766333580017,
0.6533461213111877,
-0.7208002209663391,
-0.4779878258705139,
-0.08673257380723953,
-0.19365781545639038,
-0.014129642397165298,
-1.106740117073059,
0.3189299702644348,
-0.6012238264083862,
0.11988251656293869,
0.2613462805747986,
-0.4150923788547516,
-0.031140154227614403,
0.15757755935192108,
-0.6094682812690735,
0.8985145688056946,
0.11876882612705231,
-0.39466437697410583,
0.394121378660202,
-0.5913597941398621,
-0.6716683506965637,
0.39365020394325256,
-0.39265117049217224,
-0.3335781395435333,
0.42299526929855347,
0.12432517856359482,
0.3558168411254883,
-0.316944420337677,
0.28786328434944153,
0.07465236634016037,
-0.6982554793357849,
-0.2442225217819214,
-0.20938658714294434,
0.4028688073158264,
0.4969201683998108,
-0.4352565109729767,
0.020312663167715073,
-0.9648206233978271,
-0.19828784465789795,
0.10520050674676895,
-0.3428589701652527,
-0.44973599910736084,
0.017092864960432053,
-0.1859290599822998,
-0.12601882219314575,
0.04151070863008499,
-0.3155653178691864,
0.2269456535577774,
-0.7008287906646729,
0.0218109842389822,
0.5798946619033813,
0.03499852120876312,
0.722210705280304,
-0.25578346848487854,
0.6063579320907593,
-0.13866089284420013,
0.04631270095705986,
0.18821336328983307,
-0.3921481668949127,
-0.8307138085365295,
-0.4971563518047333,
-0.11962932348251343,
0.483085036277771,
-1.2079147100448608,
0.36592167615890503,
-0.30762651562690735,
-0.23673757910728455,
-0.632801353931427,
0.36960726976394653,
0.37595421075820923,
0.5913002490997314,
0.19604505598545074,
-0.23883700370788574,
-0.728266716003418,
-0.9095538258552551,
0.09079886227846146,
-0.2365800440311432,
-0.4552682042121887,
0.29484623670578003,
0.4281967878341675,
-0.6852223873138428,
0.6840710639953613,
-0.3671870529651642,
-0.6022294163703918,
-0.37243837118148804,
0.4611603617668152,
0.3375183939933777,
0.348495751619339,
0.17819346487522125,
-0.8805717825889587,
-0.2991809546947479,
0.0604851208627224,
-0.9244621396064758,
-0.17178106307983398,
-0.26746344566345215,
-0.2741619646549225,
0.6219834685325623,
0.2965908944606781,
-0.7605174779891968,
0.7160133123397827,
0.5086999535560608,
-0.2630867660045624,
0.42787179350852966,
-0.4654994010925293,
0.14604394137859344,
-1.1979560852050781,
0.24654996395111084,
-0.19379298388957977,
-0.1641097515821457,
-0.6544302701950073,
0.2104429453611374,
-0.26531124114990234,
-0.2873302400112152,
0.041705090552568436,
0.32379046082496643,
-0.5011852979660034,
-0.26340800523757935,
-0.2994828224182129,
0.13200430572032928,
0.3433280885219574,
0.44261986017227173,
0.13025890290737152,
1.1312073469161987,
0.27168411016464233,
-0.8992522358894348,
0.2175796627998352,
0.6480922102928162,
-0.059778232127428055,
0.4760974943637848,
-0.4769735336303711,
0.250373512506485,
-0.47171124815940857,
0.15464399755001068,
-0.4439881145954132,
-0.5223686099052429,
0.31336715817451477,
-0.4245060384273529,
0.45387956500053406,
0.05455835908651352,
-0.510190486907959,
-0.2637755572795868,
-0.17930220067501068,
0.0005344931269064546,
0.8926090002059937,
-0.8230010867118835,
0.9212583899497986,
0.226371631026268,
0.10094350576400757,
-0.34345993399620056,
-0.7907237410545349,
0.38000887632369995,
-0.1017414852976799,
-0.5889706611633301,
0.5218052864074707,
0.0651525929570198,
-0.2829974889755249,
-0.11965351551771164,
0.0286939088255167,
-0.031049327924847603,
0.06824681907892227,
0.36318719387054443,
0.23019026219844818,
-0.08779007196426392,
0.13358308374881744,
-0.11204440891742706,
0.10246045887470245,
0.09808895736932755,
-0.11730031669139862,
0.5186314582824707,
0.06276062875986099,
-0.2605101466178894,
-0.36915427446365356,
0.4373466670513153,
0.5467951893806458,
-0.1748950481414795,
1.0276813507080078,
0.6376585364341736,
-0.5637081861495972,
-0.5210517048835754,
-0.49606841802597046,
-0.2570810317993164,
-0.5066042542457581,
0.2922748029232025,
-0.36536115407943726,
-0.7930444478988647,
0.5154582858085632,
-0.051295604556798935,
-0.09620464593172073,
0.35263410210609436,
0.4380655586719513,
-0.10327222943305969,
1.1462551355361938,
0.5890002846717834,
0.049415696412324905,
0.3642462491989136,
-0.4773787260055542,
0.49273455142974854,
-1.1753383874893188,
-0.3869754672050476,
-0.5542320013046265,
-0.1126556321978569,
-0.573665201663971,
-0.3348079323768616,
0.4287842810153961,
-0.003481284249573946,
-0.25348374247550964,
0.12085726857185364,
-0.8629088401794434,
0.30111825466156006,
0.5987548232078552,
0.03605325147509575,
0.2623077630996704,
0.17528143525123596,
0.1928093582391739,
0.018217887729406357,
-0.6350199580192566,
-0.6984735727310181,
0.7311365604400635,
0.1196652203798294,
0.863189160823822,
0.25655660033226013,
1.1015448570251465,
0.5229471325874329,
0.3852235674858093,
-0.6202183961868286,
0.6173148155212402,
-0.33580952882766724,
-0.3187691569328308,
-0.5229154825210571,
-0.7734575867652893,
-1.0353626012802124,
0.11029886454343796,
-0.09483382850885391,
-0.6321507096290588,
0.3018328547477722,
0.1995747983455658,
-0.4162132441997528,
0.34131380915641785,
-0.6118694543838501,
0.5800475478172302,
0.09685757756233215,
-0.3039335012435913,
-0.1576426923274994,
-0.25227439403533936,
0.32009872794151306,
-0.11058983206748962,
0.09867315739393234,
0.2127770185470581,
0.2576034963130951,
0.6007148027420044,
-0.719771146774292,
0.6701259016990662,
-0.24086566269397736,
-0.10770941525697708,
0.376986026763916,
0.23731014132499695,
0.7513153553009033,
-0.13412462174892426,
-0.12833811342716217,
-0.151823028922081,
-0.41980674862861633,
-0.14556211233139038,
-0.8620484471321106,
0.5320088863372803,
-0.5591456294059753,
-0.6896138191223145,
-0.37646374106407166,
-0.5463799834251404,
-0.15620596706867218,
-0.08038654178380966,
0.3817671835422516,
0.40699249505996704,
-0.22861360013484955,
0.1135244071483612,
0.780865490436554,
-0.3649556040763855,
0.3200327754020691,
0.05622977390885353,
-0.35456570982933044,
-0.3730182945728302,
1.0398800373077393,
0.06396622955799103,
0.13696682453155518,
0.28590303659439087,
-0.05406658723950386,
-0.105347640812397,
-0.5856033563613892,
-0.41962379217147827,
0.19580034911632538,
-0.5797356367111206,
-0.3431376516819,
-0.4999891519546509,
-0.33920109272003174,
-0.6661700010299683,
-0.12423884868621826,
-0.1625162661075592,
-0.27097776532173157,
-0.6693311929702759,
0.12716160714626312,
0.3519395887851715,
0.9437971115112305,
-0.021179012954235077,
0.21658942103385925,
-0.7679150104522705,
0.7442398071289062,
0.33121564984321594,
0.587144136428833,
0.02255968749523163,
-0.9432004690170288,
-0.33125966787338257,
-0.05848977714776993,
-0.09580527245998383,
-0.6789785027503967,
0.867057204246521,
0.49960312247276306,
0.39236122369766235,
0.3911689519882202,
0.13154298067092896,
0.8694778084754944,
-0.5419699549674988,
0.6052887439727783,
-0.10634438693523407,
-0.6909586787223816,
0.5782573223114014,
-0.1613033264875412,
0.063043512403965,
0.47905635833740234,
0.05495842546224594,
-0.3684561252593994,
-0.5570507049560547,
-0.2190154790878296,
-0.8383610844612122,
0.545818030834198,
0.3390894830226898,
0.1582881212234497,
-0.259504109621048,
0.4819178581237793,
0.009917215444147587,
0.12106545269489288,
-0.35614150762557983,
0.0012381726410239935,
-0.14690585434436798,
-0.17130449414253235,
0.05740808695554733,
-0.3957013785839081,
0.0071195876225829124,
-0.15166495740413666,
0.9898198843002319,
-0.09635411947965622,
0.39612284302711487,
0.33213165402412415,
-0.24507050216197968,
-0.13429011404514313,
0.2815716564655304,
0.43172410130500793,
0.5632287859916687,
-0.2469882369041443,
0.08091150224208832,
-0.019867558032274246,
-0.5313482284545898,
-0.005041762255132198,
-0.00028190991724841297,
-0.5982927083969116,
0.22434599697589874,
0.17093922197818756,
0.9293214678764343,
-0.26779407262802124,
-0.6511375308036804,
0.1744435876607895,
0.06763742119073868,
-0.15431495010852814,
-0.5426678657531738,
0.1697636991739273,
-0.25752368569374084,
0.3364116847515106,
0.5191634893417358,
-0.001716524944640696,
0.5485348105430603,
-0.4870189130306244,
0.07484100759029388,
0.3823738992214203,
-0.07950078696012497,
0.006318454630672932,
0.7654388546943665,
0.16568678617477417,
-0.6639313697814941,
0.9542878866195679,
-0.6045738458633423,
-0.3177955448627472,
0.43622106313705444,
0.703143835067749,
1.213369369506836,
0.007366755045950413,
0.4152618646621704,
0.26711076498031616,
0.46231192350387573,
-0.14139467477798462,
0.27348724007606506,
0.12692034244537354,
-0.5085723996162415,
-0.6939669847488403,
-0.8655723929405212,
-0.4813629686832428,
0.13083165884017944,
-0.6916370391845703,
-0.12186097353696823,
-0.4264039099216461,
-0.17739789187908173,
-0.3811296820640564,
-0.2781165540218353,
-0.6041859984397888,
0.0016814148984849453,
0.415143758058548,
0.5421663522720337,
-0.5845235586166382,
0.6400541663169861,
0.6780019998550415,
-0.6713638305664062,
-0.6479269862174988,
-0.08874702453613281,
-0.4121187925338745,
-0.3135741651058197,
0.7458057403564453,
0.1658484786748886,
-0.1492001712322235,
-0.18534952402114868,
-0.48370543122291565,
-0.6918919682502747,
1.0088613033294678,
0.2787472903728485,
-0.5971639156341553,
-0.0566452331840992,
0.2237098067998886,
0.9167339205741882,
-0.3807007074356079,
-0.07179013639688492,
0.6768240332603455,
0.4369085431098938,
0.18416272103786469,
-0.870409369468689,
0.06357253342866898,
-0.43599504232406616,
0.3355858027935028,
0.26916900277137756,
-0.20846311748027802,
0.5044108629226685,
-0.20237483084201813,
-0.4769280254840851,
0.07981666922569275,
0.7798835635185242,
0.5193822383880615,
0.46391838788986206,
0.2539735734462738,
0.6487048864364624,
0.8746801614761353,
0.013124599121510983,
1.1472200155258179,
-0.08807539194822311,
-0.08394844084978104,
1.2272075414657593,
-0.5549029111862183,
0.8478899598121643,
0.7127205729484558,
0.12825298309326172,
0.7213983535766602,
0.23293572664260864,
-0.01739937625825405,
0.3137310743331909,
0.20760664343833923,
-0.2866939306259155,
-0.0877743512392044,
-0.338675320148468,
-0.11686183512210846,
0.2703670561313629,
0.3653453290462494,
-0.43312105536460876,
0.17379017174243927,
0.3499162793159485,
-0.23137225210666656,
0.3695385754108429,
-0.2669602930545807,
1.0854718685150146,
-0.010175497271120548,
-0.7269161939620972,
0.8515376448631287,
-0.22586867213249207,
0.6397784352302551,
-0.29544273018836975,
-0.5253825187683105,
-0.5373905301094055,
0.12032901495695114,
-0.3821842074394226,
-0.2743537425994873,
0.68998783826828,
0.18516652286052704,
-0.29954007267951965,
-0.3945360779762268,
0.7351130843162537,
-0.30337607860565186,
-0.3883565366268158,
0.449479877948761,
0.33861076831817627,
0.4543665647506714,
-0.2649773955345154,
-0.15890851616859436,
0.04557214304804802,
-0.23921020328998566,
-0.3892631530761719,
0.24173322319984436,
0.5685116052627563,
-0.0856100395321846,
0.6799548864364624,
0.5288593769073486,
0.28786197304725647,
0.14999429881572723,
0.48712244629859924,
0.8795897364616394,
-0.5419294238090515,
-0.20078915357589722,
-0.5493941307067871,
0.17029635608196259,
-0.16261427104473114,
0.14336428046226501,
0.4631188213825226,
0.6352039575576782,
0.6634764671325684,
-0.19356712698936462,
0.7352766990661621,
-0.28083598613739014,
0.5239507555961609,
-0.39708438515663147,
0.7980364561080933,
-0.6418298482894897,
0.5349496006965637,
-0.19693967700004578,
-1.0772892236709595,
-0.45434123277664185,
0.6571680903434753,
-0.014896199107170105,
0.07945014536380768,
0.596763551235199,
1.0698086023330688,
0.13857658207416534,
-0.31761592626571655,
0.512457013130188,
0.19060559570789337,
0.2807847261428833,
0.3523855209350586,
0.7261179089546204,
-0.3409464955329895,
0.6573655605316162,
-0.3408048152923584,
-0.17810553312301636,
-0.23178791999816895,
-0.6811060905456543,
-0.8970956802368164,
-0.4820176362991333,
-0.24984431266784668,
-0.5509893298149109,
0.2952229976654053,
0.9048281908035278,
0.4679968059062958,
-0.9515536427497864,
-0.17146459221839905,
-0.211806520819664,
0.053785040974617004,
-0.10033928602933884,
-0.26869314908981323,
0.23574194312095642,
-0.6851538419723511,
-0.5590184926986694,
0.4713321626186371,
0.40804633498191833,
-0.023571401834487915,
-0.38471561670303345,
-0.46935227513313293,
-0.11259405314922333,
0.11372241377830505,
0.7098885774612427,
0.33729422092437744,
-0.6121654510498047,
-0.30088552832603455,
0.1422620266675949,
-0.2485928237438202,
0.1287616640329361,
0.5547939538955688,
-0.9948933124542236,
0.4354826807975769,
0.6685039401054382,
0.800400972366333,
0.4538387358188629,
0.06209962069988251,
0.5867578983306885,
-0.8532757759094238,
0.07889227569103241,
0.41819947957992554,
0.2628896236419678,
0.37970423698425293,
-0.6009940505027771,
0.8810288906097412,
0.15763191878795624,
-0.5634263753890991,
-0.8290286064147949,
0.08240803331136703,
-0.49183428287506104,
-0.1524842530488968,
1.0935263633728027,
0.29403412342071533,
-0.3300018608570099,
-0.13378672301769257,
-0.1914667785167694,
0.3130730390548706,
-0.31709280610084534,
1.2110487222671509,
0.29142504930496216,
-0.18720589578151703,
-0.06156335398554802,
-0.45492425560951233,
0.6051033735275269,
0.5221294164657593,
-0.9596263766288757,
0.12748722732067108,
0.8027248382568359,
-0.36197856068611145,
0.3832189440727234,
0.5856522917747498,
0.08309759944677353,
0.13879461586475372,
-0.11232175678014755,
0.5529878735542297,
-0.02262195013463497,
-0.6540482044219971,
-0.40571844577789307,
0.1317821890115738,
0.1066121757030487,
-0.14285632967948914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08164v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08164v2
|
Language Model Prompt Selection via Simulation Optimization
| 2024-04-12T00:03:56 | 2024-05-20T02:34:42 |
Haoting Zhang, Jinghai He, Rhonda Righter, Zeyu Zheng
|
stat.ML
|
stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
With the advancement in generative language models, the selection of prompts
has gained significant attention in recent years. A prompt is an instruction or
description provided by the user, serving as a guide for the generative
language model in content generation. Despite existing methods for prompt
selection that are based on human labor, we consider facilitating this
selection through simulation optimization, aiming to maximize a pre-defined
score for the selected prompt. Specifically, we propose a two-stage framework.
In the first stage, we determine a feasible set of prompts in sufficient
numbers, where each prompt is represented by a moderate-dimensional vector. In
the subsequent stage for evaluation and selection, we construct a surrogate
model of the score regarding the moderate-dimensional vectors that represent
the prompts. We propose sequentially selecting the prompt for evaluation based
on this constructed surrogate model. We prove the consistency of the sequential
evaluation procedure in our framework. We also conduct numerical experiments to
demonstrate the efficacy of our proposed framework, providing practical
instructions for implementation.
|
[
-0.6275911927223206,
-0.9505969882011414,
0.8022887706756592,
0.7715522050857544,
-0.3475819230079651,
-0.14206257462501526,
-0.24171046912670135,
0.22524455189704895,
-0.1229432001709938,
0.30711522698402405,
-0.9832601547241211,
-0.24703578650951385,
0.004107348155230284,
0.48436084389686584,
-0.19804862141609192,
0.7586548924446106,
0.14088062942028046,
0.04189036041498184,
-0.5981032252311707,
0.48251399397850037,
-0.8697254061698914,
-0.25422975420951843,
-1.0426279306411743,
-0.20221784710884094,
0.5156859159469604,
0.4067673683166504,
0.4794304668903351,
0.6739095449447632,
0.09071309864521027,
0.2988746166229248,
-0.26020368933677673,
-0.10536663234233856,
-0.36227068305015564,
0.4574040174484253,
-0.020768286660313606,
-0.26301249861717224,
0.2586238980293274,
0.0401441790163517,
0.7509773969650269,
0.7309777736663818,
-0.11088435351848602,
0.09954705089330673,
-0.004898035433143377,
0.35834890604019165,
-0.46257293224334717,
-0.10640659928321838,
-0.2821633219718933,
0.10062313824892044,
0.03362284228205681,
-0.3070752024650574,
-0.6486630439758301,
-0.6902851462364197,
0.12088412046432495,
-0.4577479958534241,
0.23270440101623535,
0.26051366329193115,
0.544849693775177,
0.04136911779642105,
-0.15261641144752502,
-0.18496155738830566,
-0.6745052933692932,
0.8389399647712708,
-0.31018441915512085,
0.25413745641708374,
0.2596798539161682,
0.5760481953620911,
-0.254622220993042,
-0.6758593916893005,
-0.5108308792114258,
-0.8486325144767761,
0.21838153898715973,
0.1547538936138153,
-0.17143481969833374,
0.15910017490386963,
0.5098669528961182,
0.06222283095121384,
-0.957646369934082,
0.27748680114746094,
-0.2842930257320404,
-0.29528674483299255,
0.38435521721839905,
0.49589821696281433,
0.5044924020767212,
-0.34888869524002075,
-0.5269095301628113,
-0.23206712305545807,
-0.6846415400505066,
0.16411660611629486,
0.6233372688293457,
0.45140549540519714,
-0.0824933871626854,
0.36794552206993103,
-0.21087288856506348,
0.8797691464424133,
-0.0866207554936409,
-0.12534628808498383,
0.010713636875152588,
-0.25407442450523376,
0.05677264928817749,
-0.21547453105449677,
0.8936773538589478,
0.36954426765441895,
0.250428169965744,
0.031025592237710953,
-0.4599685072898865,
0.35641998052597046,
0.33321502804756165,
-0.8471340537071228,
0.11193644255399704,
0.24321402609348297,
-0.5934566855430603,
-0.4569249749183655,
-0.23014037311077118,
-1.0096122026443481,
-0.3394569754600525,
-0.3566135764122009,
0.19734059274196625,
-0.2410898357629776,
-0.13363923132419586,
0.02427622489631176,
-0.16929690539836884,
-0.11458506435155869,
0.39814260601997375,
-0.9268105626106262,
0.20015908777713776,
0.49046510457992554,
0.7763258218765259,
-0.2798427641391754,
-0.19884496927261353,
-0.6957699656486511,
-0.3795444667339325,
-0.5609443783760071,
0.8810265064239502,
-0.9143885970115662,
-1.0638189315795898,
0.07462682574987411,
-0.3500434458255768,
-0.01971735805273056,
-0.3363838791847229,
0.888199508190155,
-0.6568819880485535,
0.4172076880931854,
-0.45821401476860046,
-0.49898654222488403,
0.02109953574836254,
0.037680573761463165,
-0.8339681029319763,
1.0703057050704956,
0.41580575704574585,
-0.5769789814949036,
0.21067579090595245,
-0.6251153945922852,
-0.33687591552734375,
0.32733482122421265,
-0.3150993585586548,
-0.12430296093225479,
0.07414859533309937,
0.11704522371292114,
0.19977188110351562,
-0.6899781823158264,
0.29972603917121887,
0.015030748210847378,
-0.4736016094684601,
0.09680578112602234,
-0.548693060874939,
0.9426960945129395,
0.45721524953842163,
-0.05581722781062126,
0.2410852313041687,
-0.4828360676765442,
-0.06625626236200333,
0.06199759244918823,
-0.5783483386039734,
0.015447479672729969,
-0.07832387834787369,
0.041786808520555496,
0.15193456411361694,
0.03345911204814911,
-0.39639392495155334,
0.3745439946651459,
-0.24941499531269073,
0.028184017166495323,
0.7250586748123169,
0.38353729248046875,
0.5057651996612549,
-0.27497416734695435,
1.3816579580307007,
-0.25119316577911377,
0.360516756772995,
-0.37911245226860046,
-0.5631089210510254,
-0.37842869758605957,
-0.07903581112623215,
0.48424282670021057,
0.7634010910987854,
-1.0093891620635986,
0.3018624186515808,
0.08808127045631409,
-0.2937995195388794,
-0.3976076543331146,
-0.16347123682498932,
0.4911004900932312,
0.6685919165611267,
0.17653052508831024,
0.06510312110185623,
-0.5251535177230835,
-0.8034831285476685,
-0.009700813330709934,
-0.4168103337287903,
0.008089576847851276,
0.2594407796859741,
0.1454777717590332,
-0.00628812238574028,
1.1007658243179321,
-0.6130279898643494,
0.23769314587116241,
-0.6591475605964661,
0.31586283445358276,
0.39409181475639343,
0.5159486532211304,
0.8226994276046753,
-0.7988013625144958,
-0.43070706725120544,
-0.27692288160324097,
-0.4338177442550659,
-0.5849048495292664,
-0.5415971279144287,
-0.205491840839386,
-0.052631594240665436,
0.546806275844574,
-0.6394272446632385,
0.32433369755744934,
0.3381291925907135,
-0.216888427734375,
1.0515365600585938,
-0.18207119405269623,
0.18079835176467896,
-0.9378350973129272,
0.1566302627325058,
0.0682249590754509,
-0.09945297986268997,
-0.5652187466621399,
-0.05757041648030281,
-0.06662745028734207,
-0.3311461806297302,
-0.2944985330104828,
0.9146538972854614,
-0.332164466381073,
0.12661586701869965,
-0.2276029735803604,
0.15111708641052246,
0.10999499261379242,
0.3804778754711151,
0.05932990089058876,
1.1533478498458862,
0.6114969849586487,
-0.7493011355400085,
0.48588064312934875,
0.20247410237789154,
-0.5128597617149353,
0.3857651352882385,
-0.9189466238021851,
0.10559093952178955,
-0.3772152364253998,
0.06377067416906357,
-0.9909083247184753,
-0.014763565734028816,
0.29861870408058167,
-0.4337040185928345,
0.17680741846561432,
-0.12055506557226181,
-0.5300833582878113,
-0.49092936515808105,
-0.17290601134300232,
0.4275153875350952,
0.7976490259170532,
-0.37184998393058777,
0.4331517219543457,
0.10990841686725616,
-0.5640402436256409,
-0.27051445841789246,
-0.10794535279273987,
-0.07339444011449814,
-0.15997374057769775,
-0.39827415347099304,
0.20244286954402924,
-0.4840888977050781,
-0.17533591389656067,
-0.18582411110401154,
0.2811985909938812,
0.3468407690525055,
0.16150031983852386,
0.06865262985229492,
0.4552832841873169,
-0.02619759924709797,
0.07942686229944229,
0.45671024918556213,
-0.3748486042022705,
0.21267558634281158,
-0.14141087234020233,
0.7495558857917786,
0.26582324504852295,
-0.3758857548236847,
-0.33453136682510376,
0.6659682393074036,
0.10363583266735077,
-0.24582019448280334,
0.42459315061569214,
0.34654128551483154,
-0.3491109013557434,
-0.45973098278045654,
-0.43220430612564087,
-0.30678921937942505,
-0.526549756526947,
0.3139423429965973,
-0.5436868667602539,
-0.5961248874664307,
0.3685297966003418,
-0.23088568449020386,
0.010302379727363586,
0.11482056975364685,
0.619845986366272,
0.26237964630126953,
1.4853700399398804,
0.4192466139793396,
0.2034910023212433,
0.6822874546051025,
-0.015432987362146378,
0.011991235427558422,
-0.7332569360733032,
-0.2868235409259796,
-0.8894721269607544,
0.09048300236463547,
-0.2754207253456116,
-0.439822793006897,
0.5831775069236755,
0.36596593260765076,
-0.08162694424390793,
0.14162805676460266,
-0.3130645453929901,
0.6215920448303223,
0.8046044111251831,
-0.05837775021791458,
-0.20551128685474396,
0.0035502901300787926,
-0.953641414642334,
-0.09790632128715515,
-0.67127925157547,
-0.8033102750778198,
0.3796853721141815,
0.19414018094539642,
0.5460091829299927,
-0.071992427110672,
0.522916853427887,
0.28695857524871826,
0.18044619262218475,
-0.5418843030929565,
0.8013638854026794,
0.040748920291662216,
-0.5142250061035156,
-0.3808525502681732,
-0.5691390633583069,
-0.996910572052002,
0.25096815824508667,
-0.1082913726568222,
-0.9370713829994202,
0.04687684401869774,
0.07167007029056549,
-0.7119736075401306,
-0.3290945887565613,
-0.6746079921722412,
1.0668933391571045,
-0.012835617177188396,
-0.07263365387916565,
-0.07980948686599731,
-0.5798293352127075,
0.1531643271446228,
-0.08303172886371613,
0.12550581991672516,
-0.08013174682855606,
0.018549026921391487,
0.4907541871070862,
-0.39025723934173584,
0.8040972948074341,
-0.3662653863430023,
0.08035164326429367,
0.47038397192955017,
0.2663551867008209,
0.41664785146713257,
0.27775776386260986,
-0.4367208778858185,
-0.4558909833431244,
-0.12927481532096863,
-0.08829168975353241,
-0.8635530471801758,
0.3583877384662628,
-0.6227906346321106,
-0.7438413500785828,
-0.09718405455350876,
-0.1902036815881729,
-0.2564071714878082,
0.18684858083724976,
0.38710400462150574,
0.7008798122406006,
-0.36628085374832153,
-0.1995825320482254,
0.4849131107330322,
-0.6891513466835022,
0.5489053130149841,
0.26272913813591003,
-0.5676937699317932,
-0.30197659134864807,
0.9125441908836365,
-0.2730812430381775,
0.25774726271629333,
0.34139323234558105,
0.6156244874000549,
-0.5775642395019531,
-0.40872636437416077,
-0.7565754652023315,
0.015812210738658905,
-0.8820964097976685,
-0.23294414579868317,
-0.5708641409873962,
-0.0929965227842331,
-0.26237547397613525,
-0.22998587787151337,
0.09847134351730347,
-0.17565329372882843,
-0.504771888256073,
-0.1793300360441208,
0.16478388011455536,
0.48959922790527344,
-0.059107571840286255,
0.33209502696990967,
-0.7862013578414917,
0.42218777537345886,
0.3757598102092743,
0.11501744389533997,
0.07111762464046478,
-0.45898303389549255,
0.1446908712387085,
-0.022072672843933105,
-0.17126187682151794,
-1.019235372543335,
0.26185300946235657,
-0.04610753059387207,
0.8826868534088135,
0.4666918218135834,
0.21576550602912903,
0.3673681616783142,
-0.7943947911262512,
0.8975595235824585,
0.2552494406700134,
-0.9657605886459351,
0.9162166714668274,
-0.35492566227912903,
0.43374165892601013,
0.5470895767211914,
0.3458896577358246,
-0.7433026432991028,
-0.2993607819080353,
-0.3619142174720764,
-0.6514400243759155,
0.7040573954582214,
0.1819850504398346,
0.5586320161819458,
-0.5161153674125671,
0.3782661259174347,
0.3228088915348053,
0.1496044099330902,
-0.37227779626846313,
-0.25245925784111023,
0.09986917674541473,
-0.070942722260952,
0.2833549976348877,
-0.49685928225517273,
0.10562964528799057,
-0.009635171853005886,
0.5683937668800354,
-0.09567563980817795,
0.3056018054485321,
-0.104454904794693,
0.14345332980155945,
-0.18485505878925323,
0.07015959918498993,
0.7253198623657227,
0.6243937611579895,
0.2138327807188034,
-0.2595517635345459,
0.03489123284816742,
-0.5176854133605957,
0.15385635197162628,
0.09774494916200638,
-0.5948110222816467,
0.30030742287635803,
0.33547383546829224,
1.2570222616195679,
0.15701386332511902,
-0.7650867104530334,
0.613580584526062,
-0.26277443766593933,
0.005298634525388479,
-0.21560467779636383,
0.28423798084259033,
-0.1360704004764557,
0.2980509400367737,
0.2743600308895111,
-0.05766289308667183,
0.27032384276390076,
-0.19625036418437958,
0.16098958253860474,
0.22182349860668182,
-0.047475460916757584,
-0.15666405856609344,
0.8331677913665771,
0.2284606546163559,
-0.6989572048187256,
0.8367510437965393,
-0.6851955652236938,
-0.5922119617462158,
0.7235249876976013,
0.6818069815635681,
0.8963788151741028,
-0.4818500876426697,
0.634140133857727,
0.5768091678619385,
0.020709503442049026,
-0.26528868079185486,
0.8127960562705994,
0.1376027762889862,
-0.6615779995918274,
-0.4607080817222595,
-0.9099392890930176,
-0.33695951104164124,
-0.1884976178407669,
-0.6442225575447083,
0.594636082649231,
-0.3228902518749237,
-0.34778785705566406,
-0.1941644549369812,
-0.010870366357266903,
-0.7410455942153931,
0.328777015209198,
0.23838943243026733,
1.124003291130066,
-0.8298169374465942,
0.5751979947090149,
0.6748411655426025,
-0.5524868965148926,
-0.9504522085189819,
-0.040967900305986404,
-0.08308479189872742,
-0.709013044834137,
0.6416112780570984,
0.2104531079530716,
0.044934049248695374,
0.24476328492164612,
-0.42714667320251465,
-0.5738924741744995,
0.8028140664100647,
0.5766275525093079,
-0.5117359161376953,
-0.04970049858093262,
-0.1576496809720993,
0.47000983357429504,
-0.5181685090065002,
0.41510236263275146,
0.3637307286262512,
0.37660232186317444,
0.5000896453857422,
-0.7205337882041931,
0.16108091175556183,
-0.2248959243297577,
0.7579661011695862,
-0.08044391870498657,
-0.2309429794549942,
0.8861114382743835,
-0.3557080328464508,
-0.4697602093219757,
0.422504186630249,
0.6972920894622803,
0.7181917428970337,
-0.12158866971731186,
0.7501171827316284,
0.08296763896942139,
0.6733777523040771,
0.05839560553431511,
1.3367866277694702,
-0.27522653341293335,
0.26559096574783325,
0.6960545778274536,
-0.2322266846895218,
0.6256102919578552,
0.4066492021083832,
-0.3274995684623718,
0.5528666377067566,
1.0173906087875366,
0.008412957191467285,
0.725581169128418,
0.556510329246521,
-0.5004357099533081,
-0.3040512502193451,
-0.4675031006336212,
-0.292737752199173,
0.24972786009311676,
0.18405061960220337,
-0.29419198632240295,
-0.22497756779193878,
0.08488421887159348,
-0.10862821340560913,
0.008623777888715267,
-0.15545274317264557,
0.6605303287506104,
0.008956640027463436,
-1.119544506072998,
0.43669214844703674,
0.1997424066066742,
0.079153873026371,
-0.47834810614585876,
-0.2457551807165146,
-0.34661394357681274,
-0.5250101089477539,
0.2131967395544052,
-0.5980320572853088,
-0.06118028610944748,
0.12901389598846436,
-0.23777735233306885,
-0.48041653633117676,
0.6353731155395508,
-0.479414165019989,
-0.5807444453239441,
0.007612511981278658,
0.4860462248325348,
0.22081685066223145,
0.017633739858865738,
-0.6932887434959412,
0.4668664038181305,
-0.1484326720237732,
-0.4749900996685028,
-0.0314558744430542,
0.48541194200515747,
-0.25338324904441833,
0.6185924410820007,
0.7709781527519226,
0.12805181741714478,
-0.14195668697357178,
0.7253020405769348,
1.0047152042388916,
-0.3852227032184601,
-1.007197380065918,
-0.9492030143737793,
0.7408677339553833,
-0.1395816206932068,
-0.3793245255947113,
0.3169519305229187,
0.42268669605255127,
0.46628743410110474,
-0.2633987069129944,
1.0068076848983765,
-0.05271666869521141,
0.48530104756355286,
-0.71656733751297,
0.29600197076797485,
-0.3085545599460602,
0.3301996886730194,
-0.3619723916053772,
-1.1805437803268433,
-0.12805387377738953,
0.7320526838302612,
-0.2726884186267853,
0.4217205345630646,
0.6739142537117004,
0.9850277304649353,
0.3289988040924072,
0.21382273733615875,
0.39877548813819885,
-0.3342302739620209,
0.06553323566913605,
0.3330352306365967,
1.1550328731536865,
0.08250351995229721,
0.29063403606414795,
-0.1699848771095276,
-0.40559121966362,
-0.3066975474357605,
-1.007636547088623,
-1.1214635372161865,
-0.7579043507575989,
-0.23744706809520721,
-0.21838794648647308,
-0.04648692160844803,
1.2565613985061646,
0.5651021599769592,
-0.5855110287666321,
-0.19156788289546967,
-0.12311182171106339,
0.17207127809524536,
-0.26692354679107666,
-0.2509421706199646,
0.11667781323194504,
-0.6744634509086609,
-0.7442612648010254,
0.5284148454666138,
0.23069417476654053,
0.1888815313577652,
-0.5049781203269958,
-0.10204310715198517,
0.05762271210551262,
0.0754549577832222,
0.4416726231575012,
0.09978055208921432,
-0.6119939684867859,
-0.24320361018180847,
0.16455695033073425,
-0.28083541989326477,
-0.3056034445762634,
1.013120174407959,
-0.8261410593986511,
0.5478651523590088,
0.7346885204315186,
0.7204795479774475,
0.08188467472791672,
0.198653906583786,
1.024746060371399,
-1.0621589422225952,
0.11096954345703125,
0.38495802879333496,
0.2514611780643463,
0.2642461061477661,
-0.47768622636795044,
0.26053372025489807,
0.02878807671368122,
-0.3566502332687378,
-0.8194620609283447,
0.5374919772148132,
-0.713643491268158,
-0.37248367071151733,
1.508599877357483,
-0.07282208651304245,
-0.015413859859108925,
-0.01592010073363781,
-0.5752654075622559,
0.191635400056839,
-0.4393806457519531,
0.6751337647438049,
0.5964205265045166,
-0.08349209278821945,
-0.42622676491737366,
-0.7231817245483398,
0.6524601578712463,
0.29358533024787903,
-0.741682231426239,
-0.16758780181407928,
0.6153165102005005,
-0.08732578158378601,
-0.017888132482767105,
0.7222511768341064,
0.0991915836930275,
0.43315377831459045,
0.16153845191001892,
-0.13605615496635437,
0.10968831181526184,
-0.44328173995018005,
-0.42139193415641785,
0.10926874727010727,
0.17622660100460052,
-0.21217165887355804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08156v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08156v1
|
Multimodal Contextual Dialogue Breakdown Detection for Conversational AI Models
| 2024-04-11T23:09:18 | 2024-04-11T23:09:18 |
Md Messal Monem Miah, Ulie Schnaithmann, Arushi Raghuvanshi, Youngseo Son
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Detecting dialogue breakdown in real time is critical for conversational AI
systems, because it enables taking corrective action to successfully complete a
task. In spoken dialog systems, this breakdown can be caused by a variety of
unexpected situations including high levels of background noise, causing STT
mistranscriptions, or unexpected user flows. In particular, industry settings
like healthcare, require high precision and high flexibility to navigate
differently based on the conversation history and dialogue states. This makes
it both more challenging and more critical to accurately detect dialog
breakdown. To accurately detect breakdown, we found it requires processing
audio inputs along with downstream NLP model inferences on transcribed text in
real time. In this paper, we introduce a Multimodal Contextual Dialogue
Breakdown (MultConDB) model. This model significantly outperforms other known
best models by achieving an F1 of 69.27.
|
[
-0.6758363246917725,
-1.0893949270248413,
0.7478841543197632,
0.22461643815040588,
0.010523734614253044,
0.1256137639284134,
0.009804847650229931,
-0.42839694023132324,
0.14970676600933075,
0.5441704392433167,
-1.0918937921524048,
-0.3171249032020569,
-0.4112641513347626,
-0.22327539324760437,
-0.2803664207458496,
0.7928221225738525,
0.3594561815261841,
0.2073758989572525,
-0.3198152482509613,
-0.4482004940509796,
-1.0390609502792358,
-0.6180984377861023,
-0.8552514314651489,
-0.24099545180797577,
0.30457833409309387,
0.39194485545158386,
0.744541585445404,
0.07658525556325912,
0.278166800737381,
0.3702962100505829,
0.042008593678474426,
0.23499582707881927,
-0.12601616978645325,
0.5027822256088257,
0.19379858672618866,
-0.2931751310825348,
-0.4617226719856262,
-0.19979871809482574,
0.48987603187561035,
0.5333685874938965,
-0.4456516206264496,
-0.26108554005622864,
-0.09343641251325607,
0.3074016273021698,
-0.44091346859931946,
0.21461568772792816,
-0.3027702271938324,
0.08121670037508011,
0.13105465471744537,
-0.25573283433914185,
-0.4844597578048706,
-0.05288071557879448,
0.06266721338033676,
-0.2750026285648346,
0.13643144071102142,
-0.20264089107513428,
0.5942829847335815,
0.42348477244377136,
-0.6297748684883118,
-0.27070707082748413,
-0.721625566482544,
0.5501846671104431,
-0.6986768245697021,
0.7474055290222168,
0.23020732402801514,
0.3885556757450104,
-0.09121143817901611,
-0.7529730796813965,
-0.6923090219497681,
-0.5182730555534363,
-0.19670075178146362,
0.01687493361532688,
-0.14023414254188538,
0.3201884627342224,
0.2846421003341675,
0.1785222887992859,
-0.40368932485580444,
0.050045594573020935,
-0.11533617973327637,
-0.1331603080034256,
0.05258456617593765,
0.34293022751808167,
0.43114426732063293,
-0.44777047634124756,
-0.3377281725406647,
-0.10253005474805832,
-0.3124675452709198,
0.061994120478630066,
-0.047005850821733475,
-0.12234911322593689,
-0.1469273865222931,
0.050867222249507904,
-0.10335083305835724,
0.6863794326782227,
-0.03562110662460327,
-0.5272421836853027,
0.249236598610878,
-0.8092285990715027,
-0.35306841135025024,
0.21691668033599854,
0.9747175574302673,
0.41626015305519104,
-0.17322678864002228,
0.20768263936042786,
-0.03986575827002525,
-0.16122503578662872,
0.10869400948286057,
-0.7805078029632568,
-0.19226442277431488,
0.4461706876754761,
-0.44602853059768677,
-0.24413813650608063,
-0.27430474758148193,
-0.45364031195640564,
-0.30805209279060364,
-0.2682146430015564,
-0.08570642024278641,
-0.6471502780914307,
-0.5091922283172607,
-0.36254188418388367,
-0.011690858751535416,
-0.07885098457336426,
0.40812617540359497,
-0.7500710487365723,
-0.1188601478934288,
0.3275093734264374,
1.038475751876831,
0.09161264449357986,
-0.09746473282575607,
-0.8059491515159607,
-0.17508241534233093,
-0.09686807543039322,
0.8010850548744202,
-0.44605255126953125,
-0.5207709670066833,
-0.25859546661376953,
0.10659851133823395,
-0.35774773359298706,
-0.4850688874721527,
0.6706950068473816,
-0.07050864398479462,
0.2219059318304062,
0.29650160670280457,
-0.3783469498157501,
-0.1504041850566864,
0.4631645977497101,
-0.9004696607589722,
0.7227817177772522,
0.04189855605363846,
-0.637738049030304,
0.37000739574432373,
-1.0763431787490845,
-0.2963109612464905,
-0.03872650861740112,
-0.2230992317199707,
-0.4164608120918274,
-0.03372448310256004,
0.4610138237476349,
0.5035826563835144,
-0.29416343569755554,
0.8165993094444275,
-0.5313535928726196,
-0.054196808487176895,
0.4450361430644989,
-1.0615482330322266,
0.9745268225669861,
0.30507832765579224,
-0.3701600432395935,
0.23436295986175537,
-0.9129603505134583,
0.0471142902970314,
-0.1852206587791443,
-0.25460880994796753,
-0.22432246804237366,
0.039560385048389435,
0.41498634219169617,
0.4708317816257477,
-0.38598206639289856,
-0.41085633635520935,
0.05664984509348869,
-0.3043767511844635,
0.5117204189300537,
0.46833741664886475,
0.11262308061122894,
0.10256204754114151,
-0.2517598271369934,
0.7318196296691895,
0.266908198595047,
0.09835271537303925,
-0.7072312235832214,
-0.5421500205993652,
-0.6764930486679077,
-0.6166058778762817,
0.27134934067726135,
0.6192255020141602,
-0.6332416534423828,
0.27741095423698425,
-0.008108208887279034,
-0.5834876894950867,
-0.6353036761283875,
-0.17358919978141785,
0.37040701508522034,
0.9266619086265564,
0.2741037607192993,
-0.10009437054395676,
-0.2960895597934723,
-0.9169337749481201,
0.050755906850099564,
-0.05756061524152756,
-0.1254422664642334,
0.5087855458259583,
0.2751483619213104,
-0.5417786240577698,
0.8399165272712708,
-0.350311279296875,
-0.3971594274044037,
-0.4364868700504303,
0.37428906559944153,
0.20157650113105774,
0.6174986958503723,
0.49403268098831177,
-0.9059630036354065,
-0.15619732439517975,
-0.13982705771923065,
-0.8142097592353821,
0.0552169606089592,
-0.4247455894947052,
0.0344209223985672,
0.26578402519226074,
0.7842962741851807,
-0.6547403931617737,
0.5847791433334351,
0.7749108672142029,
-0.35765594244003296,
0.8373070955276489,
-0.21892409026622772,
0.4454227387905121,
-1.1622297763824463,
0.1578296422958374,
-0.09779877960681915,
-0.47459331154823303,
-0.7474508285522461,
-0.36481669545173645,
0.0007655796362087131,
-0.24453672766685486,
-0.6095961928367615,
0.2685803174972534,
-0.3328872621059418,
0.06397145241498947,
0.1423371583223343,
0.035198140889406204,
0.2687852382659912,
0.6935082077980042,
0.20054596662521362,
0.5599642395973206,
0.32098910212516785,
-0.4810877740383148,
0.6261113286018372,
0.3360733389854431,
-0.6112794876098633,
0.7675931453704834,
-0.6776015162467957,
-0.103206567466259,
0.16555677354335785,
0.7264885902404785,
-1.1417092084884644,
-0.3936525881290436,
0.12403048574924469,
-0.3344319760799408,
0.1479300707578659,
-0.09724502265453339,
-0.22917552292346954,
0.15229393541812897,
-0.09236881881952286,
0.6040890216827393,
-0.2590607702732086,
-0.42774295806884766,
0.8075749278068542,
0.48294296860694885,
-0.377503901720047,
-0.4623638093471527,
-0.8220648765563965,
0.013584654778242111,
0.019305836409330368,
-1.1244927644729614,
0.13615284860134125,
-0.18835097551345825,
-0.24933572113513947,
-0.2978150248527527,
0.13700805604457855,
-0.2356485277414322,
0.24453110992908478,
0.6069269180297852,
0.35789597034454346,
-0.29640185832977295,
0.28032854199409485,
0.23534554243087769,
-0.0774875059723854,
0.1393294334411621,
0.1259431540966034,
0.760700523853302,
-0.09092964231967926,
-0.5906937718391418,
-1.0103332996368408,
0.6505193710327148,
1.0809228420257568,
-0.3649686574935913,
0.9339801073074341,
0.6123009920120239,
-0.320827454328537,
0.1461605429649353,
-0.489686518907547,
-0.3163219392299652,
-0.41266170144081116,
0.41792041063308716,
-0.36064109206199646,
-0.597874104976654,
0.45799940824508667,
0.06695836037397385,
-0.043917976319789886,
0.31097549200057983,
0.7839693427085876,
-0.21508529782295227,
1.391290545463562,
0.4311102330684662,
0.17536695301532745,
0.5765480995178223,
-0.16718311607837677,
0.3574923872947693,
-0.6017564535140991,
-0.39401039481163025,
-0.40092039108276367,
-0.04038907587528229,
-0.5496453046798706,
-0.19032898545265198,
0.6835847496986389,
0.014881649985909462,
0.2489212304353714,
-0.3038235008716583,
-0.3251957893371582,
0.2741943895816803,
0.7918645143508911,
0.19581195712089539,
0.4494076669216156,
-0.1401064693927765,
-0.41092026233673096,
0.10470406711101532,
-0.6675987839698792,
-0.15520033240318298,
0.6460607647895813,
0.4621015787124634,
0.7085864543914795,
0.204186350107193,
0.26995494961738586,
0.5860291123390198,
0.4108615219593048,
-0.801764965057373,
0.09654336422681808,
0.3308020234107971,
-0.8541821837425232,
-0.3291504383087158,
-0.20484769344329834,
-0.6203216314315796,
0.3864530920982361,
-0.23033826053142548,
-0.6930983662605286,
0.27266356348991394,
0.2873980402946472,
-0.5500834584236145,
0.0362359918653965,
-0.8881530165672302,
1.3303927183151245,
-0.159353569149971,
0.03767622262239456,
-0.230749249458313,
-0.7834516763687134,
0.6775345802307129,
0.17836590111255646,
0.49594324827194214,
-0.14390023052692413,
0.6013419032096863,
0.5988975763320923,
-0.6534502506256104,
0.7151665091514587,
-0.3295217454433441,
0.030705422163009644,
0.1643276959657669,
0.17349202930927277,
0.22234274446964264,
0.3283427059650421,
0.26464471220970154,
0.23313510417938232,
0.28282779455184937,
-0.26843467354774475,
-0.4838207960128784,
0.6581761240959167,
-0.43949198722839355,
-0.2348940670490265,
-0.385160356760025,
-0.5712950229644775,
-0.4603501260280609,
-0.012595195323228836,
0.40228864550590515,
0.9062192440032959,
-0.38852348923683167,
0.3077660799026489,
0.46397143602371216,
-0.16763362288475037,
0.5159765481948853,
0.1962808519601822,
-0.20880475640296936,
-0.3707965910434723,
0.7207148671150208,
-0.06512956321239471,
0.4287896454334259,
0.05740455165505409,
-0.12929470837116241,
-0.5009657740592957,
-0.317350834608078,
-0.6805209517478943,
0.11732670664787292,
-0.8710381984710693,
-0.1405155062675476,
-0.9562382698059082,
-0.16464342176914215,
-0.37925663590431213,
-0.04993465915322304,
-0.30092334747314453,
-0.37836962938308716,
-0.25579896569252014,
-0.25826457142829895,
-0.1696062535047531,
0.5219852328300476,
-0.003870750777423382,
0.3440187871456146,
-1.1693735122680664,
0.28338274359703064,
0.34089115262031555,
0.04386013001203537,
-0.06917045265436172,
-0.1250007301568985,
-0.10745826363563538,
0.13739658892154694,
-0.45519834756851196,
-0.9346117377281189,
0.4373409152030945,
0.29880958795547485,
0.4226883053779602,
0.5864080786705017,
-0.07146572321653366,
0.5958269834518433,
-0.3439895510673523,
0.822823703289032,
0.5919592380523682,
-0.8716408014297485,
0.5572183132171631,
-0.33259299397468567,
0.5170036554336548,
0.5015736818313599,
0.12247258424758911,
-0.9096472263336182,
-0.48268067836761475,
-0.605986475944519,
-0.7565032243728638,
0.8593353033065796,
-0.030581695958971977,
-0.2800610661506653,
-0.03086780197918415,
-0.39657220244407654,
-0.02894243225455284,
0.1593589186668396,
-0.45248597860336304,
-0.2705080211162567,
-0.23548242449760437,
-0.1625787615776062,
-0.07885311543941498,
-0.345304399728775,
-0.22762826085090637,
-0.001001065713353455,
0.3660411536693573,
-0.2345820814371109,
0.28728267550468445,
0.2520686089992523,
-0.4453893303871155,
0.20156124234199524,
0.46102526783943176,
1.0089786052703857,
0.8969295024871826,
-0.41596925258636475,
-0.1108311265707016,
0.002966527361422777,
-0.29502159357070923,
0.30068647861480713,
0.20507536828517914,
0.06154410168528557,
0.3792031407356262,
0.46825480461120605,
0.8232963681221008,
0.22859930992126465,
-1.0499557256698608,
0.5948488116264343,
-0.5089678764343262,
-0.014681894332170486,
-0.4197883605957031,
0.02059226483106613,
0.16715644299983978,
0.27798834443092346,
0.22125303745269775,
0.44969359040260315,
0.3989982306957245,
-0.6593388319015503,
0.501917839050293,
0.23324769735336304,
-0.6596090197563171,
-0.008103848434984684,
0.6629490852355957,
0.4572792053222656,
-0.3467032313346863,
0.8250924944877625,
0.13153785467147827,
-0.43729761242866516,
0.718716025352478,
0.29480838775634766,
0.8114715814590454,
-0.43221989274024963,
0.24406760931015015,
0.07898751646280289,
0.0004068537673447281,
0.2949412167072296,
-0.11978909373283386,
-0.20194678008556366,
-0.8053829073905945,
-0.5303128957748413,
-0.5751530528068542,
-0.5957679152488708,
0.24880589544773102,
-0.720914363861084,
0.04071059823036194,
-0.44007599353790283,
-0.2468562126159668,
0.2924768924713135,
-0.6116079688072205,
-0.6353355646133423,
0.3727201223373413,
0.2730621099472046,
0.5772619247436523,
-0.537553071975708,
0.8823476433753967,
0.1852646917104721,
-0.3769493103027344,
-0.522817075252533,
-0.15448510646820068,
0.29899919033050537,
-0.4603455662727356,
0.7142341732978821,
0.5255233645439148,
-0.27896952629089355,
-0.3614954352378845,
-0.33505457639694214,
-0.29263025522232056,
0.7803612947463989,
0.4955579340457916,
-0.7252100706100464,
-0.1918347179889679,
-0.14143991470336914,
0.28694838285446167,
-0.5184344053268433,
0.7021897435188293,
0.8516510128974915,
0.42859992384910583,
-0.019301220774650574,
-1.135647177696228,
-0.09047259390354156,
-0.11975383013486862,
-0.3102969229221344,
0.26512959599494934,
-0.4681813716888428,
0.8589969277381897,
0.046880245208740234,
-0.08491960912942886,
-0.16967248916625977,
0.24055609107017517,
0.26773300766944885,
0.6521217823028564,
0.7872860431671143,
0.5001988410949707,
0.8084529042243958,
-0.16717296838760376,
1.1352262496948242,
-0.327192485332489,
0.2849131226539612,
1.2347252368927002,
0.1398618370294571,
0.5521766543388367,
0.2488706260919571,
0.14762556552886963,
0.4464736580848694,
0.5801604986190796,
0.332963228225708,
0.43652865290641785,
-0.4102935791015625,
-0.47387072443962097,
-0.39258691668510437,
-0.30579429864883423,
-0.2941742241382599,
0.7481469511985779,
0.7495232224464417,
-0.44884464144706726,
-0.1364569216966629,
0.5242168307304382,
0.2905186414718628,
-0.4660806655883789,
-0.005791915580630302,
0.8852971792221069,
-0.13708291947841644,
-1.1286752223968506,
0.8806064128875732,
-0.16640493273735046,
0.40589576959609985,
-0.5791002511978149,
-0.1973973512649536,
-0.3005848228931427,
0.34093177318573,
-0.2411985844373703,
-0.36392080783843994,
0.3244290351867676,
-0.2187597006559372,
-0.31249600648880005,
-0.258047878742218,
0.5801249742507935,
-0.5205515623092651,
-0.38807064294815063,
0.41323110461235046,
0.4589824974536896,
0.039790134876966476,
-0.41937947273254395,
-0.9031636118888855,
0.11099382489919662,
0.28953877091407776,
-0.28407832980155945,
0.1405859887599945,
0.2179383486509323,
0.17583906650543213,
0.7950635552406311,
0.8849205374717712,
-0.37852510809898376,
0.09790284186601639,
0.10711334645748138,
0.7759475111961365,
-0.76366126537323,
-0.5202588438987732,
-0.8439763188362122,
0.8613343238830566,
-0.2359222024679184,
-0.39237144589424133,
0.3202303349971771,
0.347991019487381,
0.42186981439590454,
0.2221098691225052,
0.844209611415863,
-0.08373531699180603,
0.4661688208580017,
-0.6248322129249573,
0.7637805938720703,
-0.5956156849861145,
0.19675487279891968,
-0.0881383866071701,
-0.5649495124816895,
-0.22757144272327423,
0.434417188167572,
0.23702402412891388,
-0.30948778986930847,
0.7867623567581177,
0.8055142164230347,
-0.1303672343492508,
0.16064810752868652,
0.4943436086177826,
0.20811665058135986,
0.8519585728645325,
0.2184121012687683,
0.8536852598190308,
-0.045324597507715225,
0.7225483059883118,
-0.25890305638313293,
-0.405499666929245,
-0.5128951072692871,
-0.6396433711051941,
-0.6733194589614868,
-0.5649345517158508,
-0.1512906700372696,
-0.6170783042907715,
-0.3015625476837158,
0.9465375542640686,
0.9615687131881714,
-0.9719199538230896,
-0.0540236160159111,
0.12461648881435394,
0.27540603280067444,
-0.3059501349925995,
-0.3034665286540985,
0.12990786135196686,
-0.46029192209243774,
-0.7717358469963074,
0.7821725010871887,
0.589401125907898,
-0.1925715208053589,
-0.40704795718193054,
-0.07968854159116745,
-0.49772319197654724,
-0.12955953180789948,
0.6605346202850342,
0.1236797347664833,
-0.7125328183174133,
-0.08055593818426132,
-0.34157437086105347,
-0.16018450260162354,
0.3443547189235687,
0.8938006162643433,
-0.6679284572601318,
0.7563173174858093,
0.45164087414741516,
0.46436887979507446,
0.5893182754516602,
-0.058756958693265915,
0.5986288785934448,
-0.6946404576301575,
0.35906481742858887,
0.552005410194397,
0.5208159685134888,
0.3005955219268799,
-0.22263561189174652,
0.3451918065547943,
0.41914957761764526,
-0.6290152072906494,
-0.8581624031066895,
0.20437774062156677,
-0.9069023728370667,
-0.36253753304481506,
0.600805401802063,
-0.13222461938858032,
-0.18369443714618683,
-0.3749903738498688,
-0.5269713401794434,
0.017561491578817368,
-0.6707351207733154,
0.28954118490219116,
0.8254535794258118,
-0.565973162651062,
-0.38774949312210083,
-0.6648836731910706,
0.5364416241645813,
0.41229987144470215,
-0.7242605090141296,
-0.09268797934055328,
0.8246557116508484,
0.05429324135184288,
0.5215573310852051,
0.8034207820892334,
0.2349872589111328,
0.390907883644104,
0.01754070818424225,
-0.0723927766084671,
0.07622087746858597,
-0.3451230227947235,
-0.15311399102210999,
0.5444276332855225,
-0.25296664237976074,
-0.3298676013946533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08155v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08155v1
|
Graph Integrated Language Transformers for Next Action Prediction in Complex Phone Calls
| 2024-04-11T22:47:50 | 2024-04-11T22:47:50 |
Amin Hosseiny Marani, Ulie Schnaithmann, Youngseo Son, Akil Iyer, Manas Paldhe, Arushi Raghuvanshi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current Conversational AI systems employ different machine learning
pipelines, as well as external knowledge sources and business logic to predict
the next action. Maintaining various components in dialogue managers' pipeline
adds complexity in expansion and updates, increases processing time, and causes
additive noise through the pipeline that can lead to incorrect next action
prediction. This paper investigates graph integration into language
transformers to improve understanding the relationships between humans'
utterances, previous, and next actions without the dependency on external
sources or components. Experimental analyses on real calls indicate that the
proposed Graph Integrated Language Transformer models can achieve higher
performance compared to other production level conversational AI systems in
driving interactive calls with human users in real-world settings.
|
[
-0.38552534580230713,
-0.7950555682182312,
0.37227776646614075,
0.12549327313899994,
0.08959585428237915,
0.5690337419509888,
0.16004735231399536,
-0.953564465045929,
-0.0033045103773474693,
0.7056125998497009,
-0.7091159224510193,
-0.17281818389892578,
-0.43717169761657715,
-0.15317589044570923,
-0.37967875599861145,
0.5327079892158508,
0.12046428769826889,
0.20389634370803833,
-0.08684465289115906,
0.015050699934363365,
-0.7749816179275513,
-0.4302915334701538,
-0.9164385199546814,
-0.7819415330886841,
0.22820024192333221,
0.3633498251438141,
1.229337453842163,
0.16572757065296173,
0.36640986800193787,
0.45259782671928406,
0.058623332530260086,
0.2142481952905655,
-0.2679961025714874,
0.08026581257581711,
0.16265949606895447,
-0.6408255696296692,
-0.4860948622226715,
-0.047869231551885605,
0.30463191866874695,
0.686802327632904,
0.033157266676425934,
-0.011529463343322277,
-0.06182638928294182,
0.3390790522098541,
-0.1309315264225006,
0.8621791005134583,
-0.3429110646247864,
0.20802627503871918,
0.24428537487983704,
-0.15758073329925537,
-0.598809003829956,
-0.5631511807441711,
0.4953036308288574,
-0.26167032122612,
-0.10317715257406235,
-0.040225837379693985,
0.7099289298057556,
0.27894848585128784,
-0.2326231449842453,
-0.35734012722969055,
-1.2409671545028687,
0.28975972533226013,
-0.7118108868598938,
0.44352105259895325,
0.17854948341846466,
0.512895405292511,
-0.3009410798549652,
-0.9735658168792725,
-0.6864268779754639,
-0.2521437704563141,
-0.535352885723114,
0.294863760471344,
-0.4545847773551941,
0.44462329149246216,
0.2343817949295044,
-0.1636636108160019,
-0.17467661201953888,
0.3180656135082245,
-0.43638139963150024,
-0.23546001315116882,
0.4367213547229767,
0.43993937969207764,
0.43101873993873596,
0.002038052538409829,
0.12975019216537476,
-0.05830997973680496,
-0.636863112449646,
0.28851068019866943,
0.5267155766487122,
0.450115442276001,
-0.012875028885900974,
0.4684939980506897,
-0.037900447845458984,
0.8690246939659119,
0.2488320916891098,
-0.06204662099480629,
0.1683841198682785,
-0.11325632780790329,
-0.1641291379928589,
0.310634583234787,
0.8521488308906555,
0.2657451033592224,
0.6394538879394531,
-0.20842969417572021,
0.19675733149051666,
0.1104392483830452,
0.37346482276916504,
-0.9212621450424194,
-0.2728038728237152,
0.28608930110931396,
-0.15170134603977203,
-0.2670278549194336,
-0.016876766458153725,
-0.4902457296848297,
-0.2028171420097351,
-0.5358316898345947,
0.09017419070005417,
-0.563388466835022,
-0.2772069573402405,
-0.1709248572587967,
0.08425875753164291,
0.26232007145881653,
0.29907864332199097,
-0.7013617753982544,
0.5703951120376587,
0.6262142658233643,
0.7912057042121887,
-0.009230553172528744,
-0.25450730323791504,
-0.9142669439315796,
0.15112614631652832,
-0.3376581370830536,
0.9624884128570557,
-0.8366286158561707,
-0.5316945314407349,
0.10851798206567764,
0.03424137458205223,
-0.2801758348941803,
-0.6669544577598572,
0.4130505323410034,
-0.5955045819282532,
0.32760393619537354,
0.29443657398223877,
-0.31182152032852173,
-0.40185287594795227,
-0.0713406428694725,
-0.5656808018684387,
0.9292643070220947,
0.4094963073730469,
-0.41740909218788147,
0.23367106914520264,
-0.9811638593673706,
-0.7510397434234619,
0.4476257860660553,
-0.19768694043159485,
-0.44558390974998474,
-0.2499517798423767,
0.21013054251670837,
0.3787551522254944,
-0.005456154700368643,
0.3690881133079529,
-0.16643297672271729,
-0.602550208568573,
0.31186625361442566,
-0.22319164872169495,
0.6819051504135132,
-0.07938145846128464,
-0.4596753716468811,
0.40234118700027466,
-0.48818111419677734,
0.017427826300263405,
-0.24825555086135864,
-0.09638635069131851,
0.20199686288833618,
0.10874410718679428,
-0.11983367800712585,
0.492027223110199,
-0.11828215420246124,
-0.29090797901153564,
-0.04090869054198265,
-0.4933086633682251,
0.5273512005805969,
0.6905441880226135,
-0.24360644817352295,
0.570168673992157,
-0.02576437033712864,
0.8126441836357117,
0.1366625726222992,
0.1628788858652115,
-0.2766910195350647,
-0.7089268565177917,
-0.8998776078224182,
0.09350629150867462,
0.28914567828178406,
0.9279215335845947,
-0.4792715013027191,
0.49999216198921204,
-0.5387690663337708,
-0.5153417587280273,
-0.4576038122177124,
0.009721929207444191,
0.25986382365226746,
0.7205469012260437,
0.15495002269744873,
-0.4126201868057251,
-0.5529899001121521,
-0.6307823657989502,
-0.14800503849983215,
-0.5198206901550293,
-0.07708438485860825,
0.5596550703048706,
-0.12699513137340546,
-0.5150519013404846,
1.3282161951065063,
-0.47770023345947266,
-0.1268628090620041,
-0.3957187235355377,
0.22481900453567505,
0.24585658311843872,
0.047192394733428955,
0.4397226870059967,
-0.8366172313690186,
-0.6476982235908508,
0.18629810214042664,
-0.478686660528183,
-0.1041276827454567,
-0.07815253734588623,
-0.011862620711326599,
0.00213410216383636,
0.7684645056724548,
-0.6287394165992737,
0.44397103786468506,
0.7923434972763062,
-0.09809041768312454,
0.31454139947891235,
-0.01392112672328949,
-0.26451921463012695,
-0.9264699220657349,
-0.24890387058258057,
0.0295996256172657,
-0.3748225271701813,
-0.8768793344497681,
-0.6783414483070374,
-0.24681948125362396,
-0.5591092705726624,
-0.3411763310432434,
0.2909553349018097,
-0.22812789678573608,
-0.5042598843574524,
-0.029002871364355087,
0.10965991765260696,
-0.4496147334575653,
0.6303362250328064,
-0.11671586334705353,
0.933352530002594,
0.5709485411643982,
-0.7673046588897705,
0.4555377662181854,
0.5033318996429443,
-0.32755404710769653,
0.35049670934677124,
-0.6068840026855469,
0.17534948885440826,
0.04403179511427879,
0.5259528160095215,
-1.302308440208435,
-0.17184054851531982,
0.219054713845253,
-0.4882470965385437,
0.26824259757995605,
-0.26656487584114075,
-0.47080934047698975,
-0.6594620943069458,
0.2221607118844986,
-0.02803548239171505,
0.5496804714202881,
-0.35416051745414734,
1.039566159248352,
0.4702020585536957,
-0.4835120141506195,
-0.35223400592803955,
-0.5682101845741272,
0.19054703414440155,
-0.0036224275827407837,
-0.836220920085907,
0.08638428151607513,
0.03526486083865166,
-0.23444566130638123,
-0.023765891790390015,
0.13006381690502167,
-0.017220044508576393,
-0.07519317418336868,
0.6246355772018433,
0.3814326822757721,
-0.07250988483428955,
-0.099623903632164,
0.02383360080420971,
-0.4771953225135803,
0.22960978746414185,
-0.3608464300632477,
0.9629294276237488,
0.016134221106767654,
-0.4085749685764313,
-0.9869755506515503,
0.30386561155319214,
0.9143674969673157,
-0.10208539664745331,
0.4529040455818176,
0.7102485299110413,
0.05198643356561661,
0.3233296871185303,
-0.32685714960098267,
-0.1889421045780182,
-0.5432908535003662,
0.5737407207489014,
-0.43132999539375305,
-0.690036416053772,
0.5410761833190918,
-0.6486928462982178,
0.025823963806033134,
0.1205759271979332,
0.4965544044971466,
-0.1987657994031906,
1.6730647087097168,
0.5189666748046875,
-0.1914016604423523,
0.9133827090263367,
-0.3784652054309845,
0.8018826842308044,
-0.6045606136322021,
-0.28572356700897217,
-0.15060994029045105,
-0.38708430528640747,
-0.7337736487388611,
-0.16840143501758575,
0.35991135239601135,
-0.10187053680419922,
-0.39316806197166443,
0.5770306587219238,
-0.18488633632659912,
0.2216145396232605,
0.5308005809783936,
0.015912996605038643,
0.24853387475013733,
-0.0005588539643213153,
0.19039006531238556,
0.0785309225320816,
-0.8273351192474365,
-0.379401296377182,
0.6255338191986084,
0.29835817217826843,
0.6433936357498169,
0.017609000205993652,
0.302094966173172,
0.214511439204216,
0.5486305952072144,
-1.1170377731323242,
0.49993589520454407,
0.13396906852722168,
-0.082201287150383,
-0.34865865111351013,
-0.16072705388069153,
-0.9789907932281494,
-0.0006921212188899517,
-0.1898515820503235,
-0.9567987322807312,
-0.05259739235043526,
0.17143824696540833,
-0.3666454553604126,
0.0810147225856781,
-1.0863862037658691,
0.4194745123386383,
-0.04749736562371254,
0.1346392035484314,
-0.22096267342567444,
-0.7061704993247986,
0.05467546731233597,
0.14835791289806366,
0.30839812755584717,
0.006789313163608313,
0.5287656188011169,
0.5039684176445007,
-0.5074334144592285,
1.1566672325134277,
-0.09096765518188477,
-0.15763697028160095,
0.5614754557609558,
0.09955376386642456,
1.0049272775650024,
-0.2324521392583847,
0.001255071721971035,
0.20305445790290833,
-0.5507742762565613,
-0.1769983023405075,
-0.5846111178398132,
0.4840162694454193,
-0.718390166759491,
-0.6373720169067383,
0.07981343567371368,
-0.6193411350250244,
-0.47439202666282654,
0.2399892807006836,
0.2374737709760666,
0.6180183291435242,
-0.050142548978328705,
-0.1293891817331314,
0.20622482895851135,
0.121237613260746,
0.6996681690216064,
0.3215932250022888,
-0.11203945428133011,
-0.24835190176963806,
0.7529839277267456,
0.2272605448961258,
0.33788955211639404,
0.1866910308599472,
0.11105070263147354,
-0.33950626850128174,
-0.4510350525379181,
-0.6128890514373779,
0.05308900400996208,
-0.5320768356323242,
-0.2561566233634949,
-1.1081455945968628,
-0.22896099090576172,
-0.5780794620513916,
-0.12294291704893112,
-0.18836122751235962,
-0.29679349064826965,
-0.10113949328660965,
-0.3722604215145111,
0.3451472222805023,
0.8667280077934265,
0.3511921763420105,
0.7583215236663818,
-0.9435144066810608,
0.07322453707456589,
0.4663836658000946,
0.4701051414012909,
0.013312989845871925,
-0.26571330428123474,
-0.30885279178619385,
0.037450652569532394,
-0.4642074704170227,
-0.7973687648773193,
0.426867812871933,
0.08858826011419296,
0.45045164227485657,
0.31466665863990784,
-0.213612362742424,
0.9415836930274963,
-0.7026949524879456,
0.625415563583374,
0.3753063380718231,
-1.0257285833358765,
0.3710382580757141,
-0.21849510073661804,
0.30529457330703735,
0.07650865614414215,
0.13095365464687347,
-0.6989514231681824,
-0.4713290333747864,
-0.6581527590751648,
-0.7339279055595398,
0.9738269448280334,
0.20357277989387512,
0.38930031657218933,
0.2820340096950531,
0.05836402252316475,
-0.18023346364498138,
-0.1211518943309784,
-0.3199324607849121,
-0.27778714895248413,
-0.02301711030304432,
-0.08147735148668289,
0.018499290570616722,
-0.036860086023807526,
0.01410198025405407,
-0.30207833647727966,
0.25197431445121765,
-0.41985538601875305,
0.33315062522888184,
-0.13136819005012512,
-0.02481761947274208,
-0.3569963872432709,
-0.011557916179299355,
0.33399248123168945,
0.712623119354248,
0.006285288371145725,
-0.3292224109172821,
0.4176696538925171,
-0.46681663393974304,
-0.0972752720117569,
0.039085231721401215,
0.17911259829998016,
0.20307129621505737,
0.3399653732776642,
0.9822193384170532,
0.3612731993198395,
-0.6728405356407166,
0.2639453113079071,
-0.04714498296380043,
0.07013887166976929,
-0.742506206035614,
0.21000729501247406,
0.25849583745002747,
0.39863166213035583,
0.28706493973731995,
0.41911938786506653,
0.15903013944625854,
-0.8529408574104309,
0.2682543992996216,
0.27664217352867126,
-0.9476780891418457,
-0.37125277519226074,
0.3725457787513733,
0.4561833143234253,
-1.0003780126571655,
0.7081884145736694,
0.09768754243850708,
-0.8957576155662537,
0.5605135560035706,
0.6517885327339172,
0.8277519345283508,
-0.5271451473236084,
0.31325268745422363,
0.2180027812719345,
-0.10164814442396164,
0.1598527580499649,
-0.01637679524719715,
0.11124347895383835,
-0.8585927486419678,
-0.748805046081543,
-0.13664713501930237,
-0.7348766922950745,
-0.09367706626653671,
-0.27316758036613464,
0.6127794981002808,
-0.20559611916542053,
-0.15162986516952515,
0.022421272471547127,
-0.23942795395851135,
-0.6353483200073242,
0.17631486058235168,
0.10050266236066818,
0.5756391882896423,
-0.7060117125511169,
0.7777268290519714,
0.3364144265651703,
-0.24136559665203094,
-0.7855335474014282,
-0.03844289109110832,
-0.2815690040588379,
-0.8044365048408508,
0.955161988735199,
0.20655223727226257,
-0.6420018672943115,
0.15917393565177917,
-0.3411943018436432,
-0.6866291165351868,
1.0812058448791504,
0.4479178488254547,
-0.3962397277355194,
-0.05720105767250061,
0.39934033155441284,
0.5687485933303833,
-0.5452640056610107,
0.6262534260749817,
0.6721643805503845,
0.49901440739631653,
0.40292251110076904,
-0.9609216451644897,
-0.12887991964817047,
-0.13356457650661469,
-0.03280191123485565,
0.5407328009605408,
-0.7368021011352539,
0.7043781280517578,
-0.2649749219417572,
-0.416505366563797,
-0.2191312164068222,
0.7018353939056396,
-0.3383164703845978,
0.1497635692358017,
0.7188931107521057,
0.0896175354719162,
0.6798511743545532,
-0.10539529472589493,
1.0266810655593872,
-0.3752696216106415,
0.1339515596628189,
1.226802945137024,
-0.17648714780807495,
0.6932380199432373,
0.1615801900625229,
-0.2573888301849365,
0.9467194676399231,
0.5419167280197144,
0.12843601405620575,
0.22894948720932007,
0.002158990828320384,
-0.3075145184993744,
-0.10580131411552429,
-0.1483840048313141,
-0.053277045488357544,
0.7884306907653809,
0.6613109111785889,
-0.24583700299263,
-0.06423923373222351,
-0.2719559967517853,
0.013789149932563305,
-0.14058522880077362,
0.05419633910059929,
1.1086064577102661,
-0.18044337630271912,
-0.8327401280403137,
0.3699464499950409,
-0.4397399127483368,
0.40993595123291016,
-0.39485469460487366,
-0.259089857339859,
-0.06115279346704483,
0.23638516664505005,
-0.40294885635375977,
-0.8576609492301941,
0.49651220440864563,
-0.22867432236671448,
0.167059987783432,
-0.10146384686231613,
0.636330246925354,
-0.3805634081363678,
-0.22450533509254456,
0.6521291732788086,
0.30426251888275146,
-0.05595774948596954,
-0.026683762669563293,
-0.6629637479782104,
-0.14996030926704407,
-0.004341719206422567,
0.005540295969694853,
0.037901706993579865,
0.2539035677909851,
-0.19374975562095642,
1.0066977739334106,
0.7495965361595154,
-0.24977238476276398,
-0.01942111924290657,
0.26213470101356506,
0.8925124406814575,
-0.5275472402572632,
-0.5118628740310669,
-0.6898220181465149,
0.5010188817977905,
-0.3757936954498291,
-0.05090617015957832,
0.39762797951698303,
0.6181179285049438,
0.6664778590202332,
0.17188681662082672,
0.9361262321472168,
0.19476787745952606,
0.13262590765953064,
-0.2531036138534546,
0.365236759185791,
0.27636733651161194,
0.07250793278217316,
-0.37395524978637695,
-0.8542386293411255,
-0.3451175391674042,
0.3495384752750397,
-0.40694767236709595,
-0.19486099481582642,
0.5347452759742737,
0.6869215369224548,
-0.21818388998508453,
0.31491008400917053,
0.34700796008110046,
0.25186601281166077,
0.7616771459579468,
0.22382289171218872,
0.8192721605300903,
-0.4121164381504059,
0.9124752879142761,
-0.026652412489056587,
-0.07830414921045303,
-0.46119892597198486,
-0.40752092003822327,
-0.7905957102775574,
-0.5263677835464478,
-0.19555553793907166,
-0.5268124938011169,
-0.27194491028785706,
0.6469175815582275,
0.8687277436256409,
-0.9094903469085693,
-0.4461342394351959,
-0.4098120629787445,
0.0036729334387928247,
-0.33465102314949036,
-0.33012697100639343,
0.12742163240909576,
-0.595044732093811,
-1.2983886003494263,
0.24902743101119995,
0.48814842104911804,
0.11264342814683914,
-0.1702648401260376,
-0.2711283564567566,
0.19104579091072083,
0.01177448034286499,
0.8726138472557068,
0.22703970968723297,
-0.6733893156051636,
-0.473681777715683,
-0.10918773710727692,
0.13821649551391602,
0.4193671643733978,
1.1465489864349365,
-0.9243969321250916,
0.5033730268478394,
0.48444098234176636,
0.5197489857673645,
0.6821334958076477,
-0.060923684388399124,
1.1760691404342651,
-0.3684535324573517,
0.404735267162323,
0.3055897653102875,
0.34655728936195374,
0.3619876205921173,
-0.5412316918373108,
0.5576915740966797,
0.011824078857898712,
-0.22909502685070038,
-0.4414029121398926,
0.7102985978126526,
-0.8383397459983826,
0.04177597910165787,
0.7391930818557739,
-0.1793442964553833,
0.002004504669457674,
-0.5129439830780029,
-0.5538846254348755,
0.48046359419822693,
-0.5627577900886536,
0.4658758342266083,
0.5497202277183533,
-0.7881245017051697,
-0.28098610043525696,
-0.3848009705543518,
0.35054653882980347,
0.14878913760185242,
-0.7639135718345642,
0.14103925228118896,
0.3451635241508484,
-0.2043706178665161,
0.49922022223472595,
0.37242546677589417,
-0.12398423254489899,
-0.043749965727329254,
-0.12002246081829071,
-0.43119433522224426,
0.19629007577896118,
-0.058505259454250336,
-0.02191215008497238,
0.03474973514676094,
-0.20399673283100128,
-0.19760484993457794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08148v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08148v1
|
Distilling Algorithmic Reasoning from LLMs via Explaining Solution Programs
| 2024-04-11T22:19:50 | 2024-04-11T22:19:50 |
Jierui Li, Raymond Mooney
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Distilling explicit chain-of-thought reasoning paths has emerged as an
effective method for improving the reasoning abilities of large language models
(LLMs) across various tasks. However, when tackling complex tasks that pose
significant challenges for state-of-the-art models, this technique often
struggles to produce effective chains of thought that lead to correct answers.
In this work, we propose a novel approach to distill reasoning abilities from
LLMs by leveraging their capacity to explain solutions. We apply our method to
solving competitive-level programming challenges. More specifically, we employ
an LLM to generate explanations for a set of <problem, solution-program> pairs,
then use <problem, explanation> pairs to fine-tune a smaller language model,
which we refer to as the Reasoner, to learn algorithmic reasoning that can
generate "how-to-solve" hints for unseen problems. Our experiments demonstrate
that learning from explanations enables the Reasoner to more effectively guide
program implementation by a Coder, resulting in higher solve rates than strong
chain-of-thought baselines on competitive-level programming problems. It also
outperforms models that learn directly from <problem, solution-program> pairs.
We curated an additional test set in the CodeContests format, which includes
246 more recent problems posted after the models' knowledge cutoff.
|
[
-0.5124712586402893,
-0.5849854350090027,
0.9028180837631226,
-0.030331619083881378,
-0.15979266166687012,
0.36362791061401367,
-0.4637763798236847,
-0.10470665246248245,
-0.03971812129020691,
0.3427709937095642,
-0.8443538546562195,
-0.21418388187885284,
-0.6085181832313538,
0.0951065942645073,
-0.13255201280117035,
1.060164451599121,
-0.2829761803150177,
-0.27344968914985657,
-0.36033520102500916,
0.13761688768863678,
-0.5643702149391174,
-0.09359188377857208,
-0.5510322451591492,
-0.6480728983879089,
0.5107015371322632,
0.5973911881446838,
0.4407922327518463,
0.7634803056716919,
0.49971210956573486,
0.36462461948394775,
-0.04886436462402344,
0.3523133397102356,
-0.6010000109672546,
0.22137241065502167,
-0.3884841799736023,
-0.8226029872894287,
-0.06916576623916626,
-0.10547389090061188,
0.10959171503782272,
0.9115109443664551,
-0.3287615180015564,
0.28446584939956665,
0.05677342042326927,
0.7537240982055664,
-0.493566632270813,
0.16989794373512268,
-1.0167638063430786,
-0.13857509195804596,
0.053293950855731964,
-0.5665743350982666,
-0.45643994212150574,
-0.1394246518611908,
-0.050019580870866776,
-0.629821240901947,
0.16258850693702698,
-0.027502484619617462,
0.5680516362190247,
0.619434654712677,
-0.09001082926988602,
-0.600755512714386,
-0.859959065914154,
0.6797923445701599,
-0.5626969337463379,
-0.12409022450447083,
0.011184757575392723,
0.6059356331825256,
-0.3875381350517273,
-0.5785328149795532,
-0.48018017411231995,
0.05543747916817665,
0.14697220921516418,
0.04667556658387184,
-0.3125794529914856,
-0.08815360069274902,
0.3881850838661194,
0.35672345757484436,
-0.4055241346359253,
-0.04725223034620285,
-0.5830240249633789,
0.09961342811584473,
0.7667068839073181,
0.04739823192358017,
0.09611926972866058,
0.3454214632511139,
-0.22402456402778625,
0.18378105759620667,
-0.6352584362030029,
0.18102210760116577,
0.07676133513450623,
-0.0010638154344633222,
0.12297812104225159,
0.4210890531539917,
0.007749711163341999,
0.7199239134788513,
0.24694906175136566,
-0.16973094642162323,
-0.05415106192231178,
-0.060483671724796295,
-0.09643787890672684,
0.1637754738330841,
0.35800307989120483,
0.172752246260643,
0.38824373483657837,
-0.19707408547401428,
-0.34010931849479675,
0.07478594034910202,
0.22392672300338745,
-0.519326388835907,
-0.5416647791862488,
0.28144240379333496,
-0.4112553596496582,
-0.2920305132865906,
-0.22665955126285553,
-0.6580966711044312,
-0.6211223602294922,
-0.4934490919113159,
0.305881530046463,
-0.11720391362905502,
-0.23661170899868011,
0.35713067650794983,
-0.48552191257476807,
0.22021198272705078,
0.11917068809270859,
-0.7561163902282715,
0.15307952463626862,
0.6977351903915405,
0.6641019582748413,
0.13128802180290222,
-0.031941428780555725,
-0.6258591413497925,
0.05593651533126831,
-0.4713950455188751,
0.7688040137290955,
-0.5888503193855286,
-0.022227071225643158,
-0.2857147455215454,
-0.4409630000591278,
0.11463941633701324,
-0.8170621991157532,
0.21334530413150787,
-0.4254382848739624,
-0.01508819404989481,
-0.32326436042785645,
-0.5323712825775146,
0.10927747189998627,
0.3269426226615906,
-0.27921751141548157,
0.7992019653320312,
-0.33470672369003296,
-0.627140462398529,
0.10193557292222977,
-0.6360697746276855,
-0.24036093056201935,
0.2323419451713562,
-0.43351462483406067,
-0.14492318034172058,
0.3769325613975525,
0.5515385866165161,
0.2982383370399475,
-0.2173435240983963,
0.2923184931278229,
-0.25045961141586304,
-0.40748101472854614,
0.2233179360628128,
-0.27441585063934326,
0.8201842904090881,
0.27338728308677673,
-0.4922114312648773,
0.0899985209107399,
-0.5518753528594971,
0.044340845197439194,
0.5322105884552002,
-0.20651081204414368,
-0.268246591091156,
0.20798170566558838,
-0.9813172817230225,
0.403331995010376,
0.2321424037218094,
-0.180207297205925,
0.2633892595767975,
-0.49556341767311096,
0.7335947751998901,
0.9985058903694153,
0.09380088001489639,
0.16338644921779633,
-0.3779967427253723,
0.7649549841880798,
-0.16785438358783722,
0.050495777279138565,
-0.28175586462020874,
-0.4482479393482208,
-0.9129119515419006,
-0.007424621842801571,
-0.08941248804330826,
0.37986934185028076,
-0.9343469142913818,
0.09992998093366623,
-0.10804622620344162,
-0.5592855215072632,
-0.7388588190078735,
0.30898529291152954,
0.48425936698913574,
0.5656840205192566,
0.40869802236557007,
0.3141743242740631,
-0.3968566060066223,
-0.7531550526618958,
-0.48897236585617065,
-0.13368545472621918,
-0.010424863547086716,
0.34265100955963135,
0.5995412468910217,
0.08673074096441269,
0.7203598618507385,
-0.748315691947937,
0.2673189342021942,
-0.6764860153198242,
0.07915249466896057,
0.4809935688972473,
0.23903943598270416,
0.18286685645580292,
-0.6428811550140381,
-0.3920675218105316,
-0.10536312311887741,
-0.6357824802398682,
-0.37863463163375854,
-0.4051753282546997,
-0.185845747590065,
-0.1939467042684555,
0.6891624927520752,
-0.21423378586769104,
0.07992469519376755,
0.3861020505428314,
-0.28822061419487,
0.7631959915161133,
-0.5675208568572998,
-0.2337009608745575,
-0.8483922481536865,
-0.09584638476371765,
0.09901175647974014,
-0.17913825809955597,
-0.3112129867076874,
0.37454718351364136,
-0.44570717215538025,
-0.09916163980960846,
-0.05475562438368797,
0.15786390006542206,
-0.663122832775116,
0.06388749927282333,
-0.3120938837528229,
0.5480235815048218,
0.125450000166893,
0.592722475528717,
-0.12868894636631012,
0.5171852111816406,
0.629960834980011,
-0.45988979935646057,
0.6815654039382935,
-0.03559981659054756,
-0.17972049117088318,
0.2846084237098694,
-0.8285607695579529,
0.356058269739151,
-0.41023486852645874,
0.07504575699567795,
-1.0687564611434937,
0.20156612992286682,
-0.05425211414694786,
-0.37318214774131775,
0.03927520662546158,
-0.3750220835208893,
-0.3098507821559906,
-0.7029651999473572,
-0.09352977573871613,
0.36823323369026184,
0.6540840864181519,
-0.8310579061508179,
0.37044063210487366,
0.26671770215034485,
-0.06678105890750885,
-0.4313534200191498,
-0.5539430975914001,
-0.022770293056964874,
-0.4700244963169098,
-0.5190461874008179,
0.3979535698890686,
-0.36324435472488403,
-0.4971100687980652,
-0.15905804932117462,
-0.5439085364341736,
-0.12308919429779053,
0.4620164632797241,
0.09569025784730911,
0.25427332520484924,
-0.09830508381128311,
0.20257923007011414,
0.011299186386168003,
-0.3581455647945404,
0.5329917073249817,
-0.5388864874839783,
0.36612996459007263,
-0.1835753470659256,
-0.3717324435710907,
-0.2235586941242218,
0.28399956226348877,
0.4589668810367584,
-0.4659337103366852,
0.7874050736427307,
0.1806376576423645,
-0.17020051181316376,
-0.767646074295044,
-0.43279778957366943,
-0.29563429951667786,
-0.49391648173332214,
0.18038085103034973,
-0.7452685236930847,
-0.7909770011901855,
0.526454508304596,
-0.5335944890975952,
0.13542015850543976,
0.1725609004497528,
0.531094491481781,
-0.12250854074954987,
1.2741881608963013,
0.4133223593235016,
-0.01341450959444046,
0.1177266463637352,
-0.38718974590301514,
0.6167964339256287,
-0.4805676341056824,
-0.42493319511413574,
-0.4244644343852997,
-0.4455435276031494,
-0.31330999732017517,
-0.49552369117736816,
0.42407557368278503,
0.5112950801849365,
-0.1347774714231491,
0.10406863689422607,
-0.7580650448799133,
1.0935072898864746,
0.5008589625358582,
0.12330462783575058,
0.3063949942588806,
-0.12291739135980606,
-0.2757277190685272,
0.1530313491821289,
-0.9924051761627197,
-0.42523637413978577,
0.8067906498908997,
0.36012744903564453,
0.5677876472473145,
0.01575521193444729,
1.088857889175415,
-0.01464806217700243,
-0.011784926988184452,
-0.6034619212150574,
0.3791901171207428,
-0.01906013861298561,
-0.4391607642173767,
-0.1270228624343872,
-0.5977592468261719,
-0.5815937519073486,
0.21941125392913818,
-0.09989818930625916,
-0.6164431571960449,
-0.10286082327365875,
0.4561145603656769,
-0.41852959990501404,
0.22965936362743378,
-0.5132855772972107,
0.9743994474411011,
-0.3358364999294281,
-0.3452412784099579,
-0.37070032954216003,
-0.49502015113830566,
0.3702833652496338,
0.2318374216556549,
0.5268152356147766,
0.09746214002370834,
0.19123360514640808,
0.5378171801567078,
-0.6121118664741516,
0.5441542863845825,
-0.13862814009189606,
-0.24446451663970947,
0.38293781876564026,
0.2627980411052704,
0.6784211993217468,
-0.048858173191547394,
-0.038132861256599426,
-0.23497439920902252,
-0.20057769119739532,
-0.3806861639022827,
-0.9438799619674683,
0.6165640950202942,
-0.31637799739837646,
-1.0397530794143677,
-0.02772120200097561,
-0.5858304500579834,
-0.008281891234219074,
0.007898780517280102,
0.07797521352767944,
0.5098543167114258,
0.39777833223342896,
-0.09862379729747772,
0.8189578056335449,
-0.14354343712329865,
0.25677767395973206,
0.21678251028060913,
0.0073830136097967625,
0.08253071457147598,
0.9579435586929321,
-0.24256093800067902,
0.3596070408821106,
0.16599391400814056,
0.42607152462005615,
-0.1857059895992279,
-0.8598576188087463,
-0.2082538604736328,
0.21563470363616943,
-0.8464213013648987,
-0.06920935958623886,
-0.11301879584789276,
-0.14962442219257355,
0.23996806144714355,
-0.4249674379825592,
-0.2182670682668686,
-0.3239807188510895,
0.07131224870681763,
-0.17758837342262268,
0.1073351725935936,
0.6339721083641052,
-0.06206683814525604,
-0.015311836265027523,
-0.45125991106033325,
0.4254763722419739,
0.32284507155418396,
0.2630462348461151,
0.22380924224853516,
-0.4850718677043915,
-0.2784692347049713,
0.2368800938129425,
-0.21016180515289307,
-0.9701921939849854,
0.1939787119626999,
0.02125590480864048,
0.7687938809394836,
0.4577038586139679,
0.20574414730072021,
0.9573095440864563,
-0.35427045822143555,
0.6835451722145081,
0.03066861443221569,
-1.0024044513702393,
1.0043838024139404,
-0.11697307974100113,
0.2524634301662445,
0.5092397332191467,
0.3272603452205658,
-0.24815158545970917,
-0.5706777572631836,
-0.4602470397949219,
-0.7836630344390869,
0.5887574553489685,
0.30763718485832214,
-0.23606792092323303,
-0.2239876687526703,
0.7442016005516052,
0.05160462111234665,
-0.05567320063710213,
-0.7748913764953613,
-0.3808574378490448,
0.14903570711612701,
-0.29002663493156433,
0.06937344372272491,
-0.05820463225245476,
-0.25383204221725464,
-0.2774757742881775,
0.8206632137298584,
-0.17558011412620544,
-0.08728566020727158,
0.08247488737106323,
-0.18506763875484467,
0.05166015401482582,
0.3849199712276459,
0.3746735453605652,
0.9787432551383972,
0.02533450722694397,
0.7078032493591309,
-0.054898157715797424,
0.14209096133708954,
0.00811102893203497,
0.03314833343029022,
0.15617096424102783,
-0.1979924887418747,
0.5868286490440369,
0.5556846857070923,
-0.2423938363790512,
-0.9685670137405396,
0.42450493574142456,
0.09079483896493912,
-0.29835087060928345,
0.0413370244204998,
0.2322843372821808,
0.4562998414039612,
0.5876294374465942,
0.22866834700107574,
-0.009596658870577812,
0.1627630889415741,
-0.4904087483882904,
-0.029891714453697205,
0.4898044168949127,
-0.28713709115982056,
-0.1218152567744255,
0.5656725764274597,
0.29095596075057983,
-0.28612154722213745,
0.5514621138572693,
-0.46141016483306885,
-0.8622695207595825,
0.864981472492218,
0.7606128454208374,
0.4969234764575958,
0.15989014506340027,
0.23936140537261963,
0.20982199907302856,
0.21865911781787872,
-0.2055954933166504,
0.23975332081317902,
-0.41002294421195984,
-0.6164213418960571,
-0.6658458709716797,
-0.31753066182136536,
-0.08332321047782898,
0.11416856944561005,
-0.5798681974411011,
-0.09067041426897049,
-0.29234936833381653,
0.2614210844039917,
0.23250146210193634,
-0.08928801119327545,
-0.41851940751075745,
-0.2601745128631592,
0.42109203338623047,
0.8193222284317017,
-0.8577499389648438,
0.40258434414863586,
0.6605846881866455,
-0.4666730463504791,
-1.0645811557769775,
-0.1267692744731903,
-0.0484028160572052,
-0.8919534087181091,
0.6863794922828674,
0.127874493598938,
-0.29903069138526917,
-0.016613753512501717,
-0.5715311169624329,
-0.5406000018119812,
1.102652907371521,
0.5574144721031189,
-0.9106757640838623,
0.06095244735479355,
0.044321198016405106,
0.39965134859085083,
-0.46488675475120544,
0.19082428514957428,
0.7002534866333008,
0.30287396907806396,
0.2614714801311493,
-0.7721412181854248,
0.19152094423770905,
-0.39010104537010193,
-0.16166311502456665,
0.31826332211494446,
-0.2029830515384674,
0.5862064957618713,
-0.716174304485321,
-0.1025339886546135,
-0.3054876923561096,
0.30511999130249023,
0.727297842502594,
0.3185199797153473,
0.5209251046180725,
0.5018857717514038,
0.9195874333381653,
0.13560236990451813,
0.7905802726745605,
-0.24246035516262054,
0.3006576597690582,
1.2698184251785278,
-0.04757745936512947,
0.5518270134925842,
0.79835045337677,
-0.12350957095623016,
0.9407907724380493,
0.49216681718826294,
0.07490728795528412,
0.5045716166496277,
0.8614605665206909,
-0.056572411209344864,
-0.7527503967285156,
0.04840172827243805,
-0.10526097565889359,
0.37277600169181824,
0.21617789566516876,
-0.3462803065776825,
-0.37178632616996765,
-0.09154703468084335,
-0.09533815085887909,
0.6059799194335938,
-0.5510391592979431,
0.7428408265113831,
0.13321302831172943,
-0.9165177345275879,
0.7673203945159912,
-0.026313774287700653,
0.47518643736839294,
-0.2741747200489044,
-0.3567796051502228,
-0.15369151532649994,
0.49676817655563354,
-0.11903472989797592,
-0.7985906600952148,
0.3564997911453247,
0.24322600662708282,
-0.3130406439304352,
-0.3595086634159088,
0.5391750335693359,
-0.5170730352401733,
-0.49293825030326843,
0.21664875745773315,
0.6040711998939514,
0.32232174277305603,
-0.13084085285663605,
-0.821443498134613,
-0.05150896683335304,
0.14552311599254608,
0.1879483163356781,
-0.00836336798965931,
0.6918991804122925,
0.1585879772901535,
1.051682949066162,
0.4528603255748749,
0.1656923145055771,
0.061962053179740906,
0.15238915383815765,
1.0259407758712769,
-0.3727629780769348,
-0.49958041310310364,
-1.3152670860290527,
0.5343907475471497,
-0.14330458641052246,
0.07460110634565353,
0.5533836483955383,
0.4690020680427551,
0.712381899356842,
0.002199246548116207,
0.758159875869751,
0.10807041823863983,
0.20034101605415344,
-0.5504673719406128,
0.3453420400619507,
-0.5030609369277954,
0.8392395377159119,
0.022215282544493675,
-0.6051965355873108,
-0.08064927160739899,
0.6559114456176758,
-0.3885725736618042,
-0.07474385201931,
0.6535696387290955,
0.6390103697776794,
-0.049256496131420135,
-0.18389376997947693,
-0.14525984227657318,
0.32116347551345825,
0.5170558094978333,
1.1595898866653442,
0.8918188810348511,
-0.009362047538161278,
0.8096837401390076,
-0.27171218395233154,
-0.531079888343811,
0.08613745123147964,
-1.0460827350616455,
-1.154006004333496,
-0.3222957253456116,
-0.526433527469635,
-0.20581674575805664,
0.22814887762069702,
0.8553433418273926,
0.5471336841583252,
-0.48185884952545166,
-0.17691846191883087,
-0.6721966862678528,
0.5759003758430481,
-0.6231088638305664,
-0.20306429266929626,
0.14560864865779877,
-0.5378952026367188,
-0.17956507205963135,
0.4443531930446625,
0.18449974060058594,
-0.4143771529197693,
-0.28963926434516907,
-0.20857730507850647,
0.06608742475509644,
0.23853982985019684,
0.28601548075675964,
0.13593606650829315,
-0.7884940505027771,
-0.0803457498550415,
-0.07257925719022751,
0.4380108416080475,
-0.03790709376335144,
0.8960937857627869,
-0.8529655933380127,
0.6087009310722351,
0.34963488578796387,
0.5077647566795349,
0.4825105667114258,
-0.0747407004237175,
0.6279510855674744,
-0.7381864786148071,
-0.17249217629432678,
0.1353893280029297,
0.3541510999202728,
0.028841454535722733,
-0.2946354150772095,
0.2763141393661499,
0.04970022290945053,
-0.4687586724758148,
-0.8025904893875122,
0.419903039932251,
-0.7225594520568848,
-0.6651096940040588,
0.9346563220024109,
-0.31996554136276245,
-0.11512745916843414,
-0.09778448194265366,
-0.08331593871116638,
0.17111492156982422,
-0.1358160674571991,
1.0182652473449707,
0.5954176187515259,
-0.35370734333992004,
-0.3651706874370575,
-0.2815883755683899,
0.49740296602249146,
0.11424604803323746,
-0.7737126350402832,
0.4486777186393738,
0.33114317059516907,
0.28990066051483154,
0.12372846901416779,
0.5424473881721497,
0.04889480397105217,
0.1647127866744995,
-0.00011328620894346386,
-0.2598288953304291,
-0.5196223855018616,
-0.48091188073158264,
-0.2767174243927002,
0.14565423130989075,
0.2677367329597473,
-0.14836792647838593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08134v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08134v1
|
Extending Translate-Train for ColBERT-X to African Language CLIR
| 2024-04-11T21:31:02 | 2024-04-11T21:31:02 |
Eugene Yang, Dawn J. Lawrie, Paul McNamee, James Mayfield
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
This paper describes the submission runs from the HLTCOE team at the CIRAL
CLIR tasks for African languages at FIRE 2023. Our submissions use machine
translation models to translate the documents and the training passages, and
ColBERT-X as the retrieval model. Additionally, we present a set of unofficial
runs that use an alternative training procedure with a similar training
setting.
|
[
-0.29022160172462463,
-0.16114071011543274,
0.28640878200531006,
0.16321437060832977,
-0.1310843825340271,
0.043809015303850174,
-0.3963637053966522,
-0.484815776348114,
0.40130189061164856,
0.7193963527679443,
-0.3287847340106964,
-0.15437109768390656,
-0.7086400985717773,
0.24289081990718842,
-0.7791133522987366,
0.9803746938705444,
-0.4858362078666687,
-0.07192926108837128,
0.19897793233394623,
-0.2666722536087036,
-0.12465929239988327,
-0.9193376898765564,
-0.5329207181930542,
-0.31605878472328186,
0.7112511992454529,
0.663286566734314,
0.736858606338501,
0.6407549381256104,
0.6129152774810791,
0.19913449883460999,
0.044583097100257874,
-0.3253520429134369,
-0.761914074420929,
-0.10991743206977844,
-0.243185892701149,
-0.3805260956287384,
-0.22884522378444672,
-0.03366142511367798,
0.5735366940498352,
0.41553738713264465,
-0.10941417515277863,
-0.007946336641907692,
-0.18755927681922913,
0.508819043636322,
-0.7383565902709961,
-0.11781375110149384,
-0.5853778719902039,
-0.09221599251031876,
-0.14540864527225494,
-0.15885592997074127,
-0.49320030212402344,
-0.43061521649360657,
0.2112605720758438,
-0.5926768779754639,
0.3735945522785187,
0.2139529585838318,
0.8891452550888062,
-0.23819710314273834,
-0.5478501915931702,
-0.774588942527771,
-0.49782344698905945,
0.8724219799041748,
-0.4172809422016144,
0.5715404152870178,
0.37959325313568115,
0.41499775648117065,
0.12626293301582336,
-1.1626591682434082,
-0.7448234558105469,
-0.1710146814584732,
-0.08429259806871414,
0.010975521057844162,
0.03803528472781181,
0.014816832728683949,
0.04030865803360939,
0.6194842457771301,
-0.4723980128765106,
-0.2704210877418518,
-0.6395444869995117,
-0.2953304052352905,
1.1787512302398682,
0.1376747488975525,
0.03349180147051811,
0.004400006961077452,
-0.3913584053516388,
-0.35880711674690247,
-0.4851571321487427,
-0.021260898560285568,
0.6018925309181213,
0.1636795550584793,
-0.46312418580055237,
0.33661115169525146,
-0.35352590680122375,
0.6813997626304626,
-0.32619544863700867,
0.10825629532337189,
0.3906787037849426,
-0.09643278270959854,
-0.06245122104883194,
0.3312435448169708,
0.702086865901947,
0.1184004470705986,
0.28920868039131165,
-0.30208829045295715,
-0.39869534969329834,
-0.16943727433681488,
0.29507923126220703,
-0.9085414409637451,
-0.49391794204711914,
-0.004944318439811468,
-0.3273155987262726,
-0.40809276700019836,
-0.20366264879703522,
-0.8037090301513672,
-0.12828579545021057,
-0.26313111186027527,
0.4428594708442688,
-0.3557121157646179,
-0.22950412333011627,
0.13850320875644684,
-0.19647936522960663,
0.2989916503429413,
0.278220534324646,
-0.7406975030899048,
0.32033392786979675,
0.3410717248916626,
0.6643826365470886,
0.06160508468747139,
-0.27641770243644714,
-0.8591878414154053,
-0.06500809639692307,
0.04961315169930458,
0.2890346646308899,
-0.6996709704399109,
-0.6999933123588562,
0.5101647973060608,
0.3278473913669586,
-0.35317933559417725,
-0.18539094924926758,
1.2732630968093872,
-0.8081154227256775,
-0.11658422648906708,
-0.6494596600532532,
-0.29863041639328003,
-0.47741374373435974,
0.13691703975200653,
-0.5702212452888489,
0.9487552642822266,
0.3900333344936371,
-0.672065019607544,
0.02510598488152027,
-0.6093465685844421,
-0.6958181262016296,
-0.029260141775012016,
0.1985040158033371,
-0.48267805576324463,
-0.0716409683227539,
0.33960697054862976,
0.13544714450836182,
-0.10082082450389862,
-0.09923815727233887,
-0.25081920623779297,
-0.30560269951820374,
0.020591305568814278,
0.15341511368751526,
1.1065462827682495,
0.5523074269294739,
-0.477798193693161,
-0.09169121086597443,
-0.9040178060531616,
0.20917625725269318,
0.03469270095229149,
-0.38317689299583435,
0.009684449061751366,
-0.2611859142780304,
0.6219090223312378,
0.4710162281990051,
0.05012083053588867,
-1.0139833688735962,
0.32328274846076965,
0.10960138589143753,
0.4625261127948761,
0.070905901491642,
-0.24731841683387756,
0.5956319570541382,
-0.31756356358528137,
0.8385714888572693,
-0.25490665435791016,
-0.042548295110464096,
-0.21227312088012695,
-0.4603803753852844,
-0.8958224654197693,
-0.11496861279010773,
0.36724403500556946,
0.8215975165367126,
-0.747898280620575,
-0.03518782556056976,
-0.3186647295951843,
-0.595781147480011,
-0.6704095005989075,
0.3389034569263458,
0.21925705671310425,
0.4571630358695984,
0.5162519812583923,
-0.3299005925655365,
-0.9463940262794495,
-0.6787842512130737,
-0.001403803820721805,
0.0348847396671772,
0.7047795653343201,
0.16110435128211975,
1.0405150651931763,
-0.4747872054576874,
0.41122472286224365,
-0.21011222898960114,
-0.45998871326446533,
-0.6495893001556396,
0.2057477831840515,
-0.08084847033023834,
0.6592191457748413,
0.6627124547958374,
-0.798610270023346,
-0.8510730266571045,
0.522024393081665,
-0.6669647097587585,
0.023439770564436913,
0.05136369168758392,
-0.11862780898809433,
0.024324797093868256,
0.6178745031356812,
-0.14805103838443756,
0.8934316635131836,
0.5429223775863647,
-0.03511577472090721,
0.38830849528312683,
0.002984355902299285,
0.22343425452709198,
-0.9396805167198181,
0.22182630002498627,
-0.4008054733276367,
-0.5986961722373962,
-0.6072810292243958,
0.3860945999622345,
0.18421120941638947,
-0.4249057471752167,
-0.5707830786705017,
0.8828064203262329,
-0.487843781709671,
0.09720635414123535,
-0.4295002222061157,
0.08547952026128769,
0.05793469026684761,
0.29749637842178345,
0.5013713836669922,
0.7152910828590393,
0.5289420485496521,
-0.5625654458999634,
0.4357607066631317,
0.8887813091278076,
-0.531342089176178,
0.4267194867134094,
-0.7127175331115723,
0.385158896446228,
0.031500060111284256,
0.321264386177063,
-0.7107829451560974,
-0.26746514439582825,
-0.03334064409136772,
-0.45131444931030273,
0.387533575296402,
-0.10925252735614777,
-0.3480963706970215,
-0.5778598189353943,
0.15653817355632782,
0.3276243209838867,
0.5897366404533386,
-0.614410936832428,
0.27516886591911316,
-0.04285827651619911,
-0.12193632870912552,
-0.8521628975868225,
-0.7417566180229187,
0.4830031096935272,
-0.06566867232322693,
-0.674369752407074,
0.3185868263244629,
0.019569534808397293,
-0.18042588233947754,
-0.1795838326215744,
0.4190049469470978,
-0.21363712847232819,
0.06487024575471878,
0.0397803969681263,
-0.4114806056022644,
-0.28692957758903503,
-0.37909603118896484,
-0.057489145547151566,
0.3813028633594513,
0.05693307891488075,
-0.16466790437698364,
0.48933684825897217,
-0.18038465082645416,
0.19213975965976715,
-0.4940739870071411,
0.7465679049491882,
0.2516745924949646,
-0.5428382158279419,
0.9598432183265686,
0.8115279674530029,
0.07026166468858719,
0.15459758043289185,
-0.6099234223365784,
-0.0528295673429966,
-0.43343907594680786,
0.16569505631923676,
-0.46114999055862427,
-0.823672354221344,
0.6120560169219971,
0.14199890196323395,
0.04916238784790039,
0.21243320405483246,
0.639451265335083,
-0.3638686239719391,
0.7099490165710449,
0.9042104482650757,
-0.022827886044979095,
0.4412863850593567,
-0.8220605254173279,
-0.03977501392364502,
-1.0395630598068237,
-0.04597936570644379,
-0.6587046980857849,
-0.49248072504997253,
-0.3304862976074219,
0.12219429761171341,
0.17548798024654388,
0.09926190972328186,
-0.010302912443876266,
0.9842633605003357,
-0.18427859246730804,
0.14590030908584595,
0.40146902203559875,
-0.06360850483179092,
0.09033843874931335,
0.07880976796150208,
-0.20563220977783203,
0.21106824278831482,
-0.7159076929092407,
-0.49039021134376526,
1.2052834033966064,
0.1762668639421463,
0.5260496735572815,
0.13047918677330017,
1.063861608505249,
0.4192817807197571,
0.7831477522850037,
-0.5535369515419006,
0.25707823038101196,
0.08392450958490372,
-1.025909185409546,
-0.2319689691066742,
-0.05482746660709381,
-1.0366311073303223,
0.16665758192539215,
0.07013419270515442,
-0.6306817531585693,
0.7618935108184814,
0.14728869497776031,
0.018033957108855247,
0.42058008909225464,
-0.4945599436759949,
0.9406295418739319,
-0.4096528887748718,
-0.3842848539352417,
-0.33890751004219055,
-0.9097856879234314,
0.3211051821708679,
-0.2243068665266037,
0.18120461702346802,
0.3808804750442505,
0.3352094888687134,
0.6863545775413513,
-0.5759739279747009,
0.45948705077171326,
-0.17170394957065582,
-0.21198724210262299,
0.6792455911636353,
0.21528750658035278,
0.6521331667900085,
0.05245759338140488,
-0.7745761275291443,
0.13726340234279633,
-0.038904882967472076,
-0.6364725232124329,
-0.1939164698123932,
0.5299427509307861,
-0.9377122521400452,
-0.4132751524448395,
-0.6013051271438599,
-0.8829326629638672,
0.19738812744617462,
0.24181948602199554,
0.6723104119300842,
0.5912912487983704,
-0.3746853172779083,
0.2557320296764374,
0.16859322786331177,
0.10569818317890167,
0.6509928107261658,
0.21094650030136108,
-0.2480902224779129,
-0.7891687154769897,
0.7039183974266052,
-0.11757893115282059,
0.47237348556518555,
0.5885244011878967,
-0.25859522819519043,
-0.35387569665908813,
-0.654961347579956,
-0.49820899963378906,
0.28076326847076416,
-0.7774619460105896,
0.028683988377451897,
-0.8042675256729126,
-0.16707156598567963,
-0.593207836151123,
-0.5819577574729919,
0.025086110457777977,
-0.5368092060089111,
-0.257546067237854,
0.03846147656440735,
0.15689082443714142,
0.6644557118415833,
-0.37878066301345825,
1.2361639738082886,
-0.7004982829093933,
-0.07399433106184006,
0.1716597080230713,
-0.2401740998029709,
-0.3079166114330292,
-1.1614331007003784,
-0.7841081619262695,
0.19238834083080292,
-0.8046162128448486,
-0.7077534198760986,
0.8702009320259094,
0.5314833521842957,
0.3684719204902649,
0.17626900970935822,
0.12527604401111603,
0.5357198119163513,
-0.5703086256980896,
0.5837127566337585,
0.3498361110687256,
-0.9320792555809021,
0.5952363610267639,
-0.23926137387752533,
-0.15512186288833618,
0.9841883182525635,
0.7889035940170288,
-0.3294760286808014,
0.03021695651113987,
-0.5374538898468018,
-0.2167365998029709,
0.6033176779747009,
0.6042781472206116,
0.1825554221868515,
-0.13942892849445343,
0.3366841673851013,
0.1805691123008728,
0.3602036237716675,
-0.7076261043548584,
-0.0860922709107399,
-0.5059008598327637,
0.172488272190094,
-0.2288403958082199,
-0.2617780864238739,
-0.06916625797748566,
-0.441904753446579,
0.7858065962791443,
-0.0510544627904892,
0.3187899887561798,
0.5696521401405334,
-0.6601971387863159,
-0.12116912007331848,
0.4596109092235565,
0.9110649228096008,
0.8413011431694031,
-0.4147409498691559,
-0.3219757676124573,
0.08215208351612091,
-0.5761630535125732,
0.41572675108909607,
0.1172385886311531,
-0.031210126355290413,
0.2235593944787979,
0.3933558762073517,
1.0379010438919067,
-0.020347828045487404,
-0.3360644280910492,
0.7047119736671448,
0.07286036759614944,
-0.5120235681533813,
-0.8270816206932068,
-0.08463773131370544,
-0.19555598497390747,
-0.04348523169755936,
0.13824497163295746,
0.17687231302261353,
0.1940651386976242,
-0.7654691338539124,
0.2871187925338745,
0.14947284758090973,
-1.064507007598877,
-0.6477643251419067,
0.9270654916763306,
0.7697575092315674,
-0.28818419575691223,
0.8504812717437744,
-0.564871609210968,
-1.0063310861587524,
0.4478718042373657,
0.5260536074638367,
0.835628867149353,
-0.3549143970012665,
0.030265063047409058,
0.6585547924041748,
0.5394542217254639,
0.1255580484867096,
0.9101003408432007,
-0.1710643768310547,
-0.515572190284729,
-0.34472623467445374,
-0.45621585845947266,
-0.2263496071100235,
0.16766276955604553,
-1.0806010961532593,
0.6328817009925842,
-0.039968110620975494,
-0.11986670643091202,
-0.4079481363296509,
-0.10175948590040207,
-0.9156178832054138,
0.48674526810646057,
0.34055477380752563,
1.3774532079696655,
-0.6447321772575378,
1.2959777116775513,
0.7491033673286438,
-0.295364648103714,
-0.31227028369903564,
-0.2820662260055542,
-0.3137096166610718,
-0.842821478843689,
1.0650427341461182,
-0.028310997411608696,
0.2389334738254547,
0.1684444099664688,
-0.5470825433731079,
-0.6743817329406738,
0.8772302865982056,
0.32262134552001953,
-0.8326343894004822,
-0.01113696675747633,
0.2793371379375458,
0.19097018241882324,
-0.5743010640144348,
0.3370698392391205,
0.6275746822357178,
0.4846782982349396,
0.02172386646270752,
-1.2094463109970093,
-0.4078126847743988,
-0.1842583566904068,
-0.20426560938358307,
0.17196644842624664,
-0.7319682836532593,
0.6839537024497986,
-0.6095129251480103,
-0.12655331194400787,
0.7255712747573853,
1.0707582235336304,
-0.2641940712928772,
0.29605862498283386,
0.47168847918510437,
0.8362351059913635,
0.5361557602882385,
0.04549678787589073,
1.4304289817810059,
-0.47626906633377075,
0.44695451855659485,
1.1919662952423096,
-0.5154850482940674,
0.9301280379295349,
0.3548617959022522,
0.025960762053728104,
0.8829078078269958,
0.4741431474685669,
0.3199348747730255,
0.6158859729766846,
0.32367467880249023,
-0.30932343006134033,
-0.3063996434211731,
-0.20369020104408264,
-0.5966143012046814,
0.39479267597198486,
0.5001115202903748,
-0.49349987506866455,
-0.1118694320321083,
0.2772969901561737,
0.24450136721134186,
0.18641652166843414,
-0.36126723885536194,
0.3062434494495392,
0.35882866382598877,
-0.687018096446991,
0.9627962112426758,
-0.059938810765743256,
0.3154318332672119,
-0.5651003122329712,
0.0629122257232666,
-0.12867002189159393,
0.3934098184108734,
-0.29988133907318115,
-0.805214524269104,
0.31409502029418945,
-0.3269372582435608,
-0.057601604610681534,
-0.1620410978794098,
0.3428296446800232,
-0.6202566623687744,
-0.6777923107147217,
0.2886299788951874,
0.07325316965579987,
0.26240384578704834,
-0.11585476994514465,
-0.6790081858634949,
0.22568388283252716,
0.3116435110569,
0.2133907824754715,
0.049519483000040054,
0.40124061703681946,
-0.17993056774139404,
0.5672905445098877,
0.3726746439933777,
0.15037789940834045,
0.48527219891548157,
-0.24971136450767517,
0.5944225192070007,
-0.548331618309021,
-0.6535003185272217,
-0.3955855667591095,
0.2402360439300537,
-0.17014575004577637,
-0.6128484606742859,
0.5994641184806824,
0.8366762399673462,
0.828834593296051,
-0.3677928149700165,
1.1452821493148804,
-0.3390742242336273,
0.4599505364894867,
-0.22081179916858673,
0.6608583331108093,
-0.42325401306152344,
-0.32634249329566956,
-0.05541035905480385,
-1.0351386070251465,
0.14740920066833496,
0.37148019671440125,
-0.33376365900039673,
-0.3120366930961609,
1.0405819416046143,
0.5799591541290283,
-0.3291412591934204,
0.17406387627124786,
0.37460944056510925,
-0.04087439551949501,
0.38148173689842224,
0.6490925550460815,
0.8503877520561218,
-0.9976896643638611,
0.9594396352767944,
-0.6053043007850647,
0.10861211270093918,
-0.4322754144668579,
-0.854109525680542,
-1.032770037651062,
-0.7538942098617554,
-0.4529719352722168,
-0.4964313805103302,
0.07456963509321213,
0.7440244555473328,
0.878284215927124,
-1.1573420763015747,
-0.5849262475967407,
0.30771663784980774,
-0.16282042860984802,
-0.3243764638900757,
-0.15628734230995178,
0.32010549306869507,
-0.4379069209098816,
-0.6042833924293518,
0.48672962188720703,
-0.18038223683834076,
-0.012318131513893604,
-0.058938100934028625,
-0.39424362778663635,
-0.5254398584365845,
-0.17450323700904846,
0.7203689217567444,
0.6876987814903259,
-0.547016978263855,
-0.3145562410354614,
0.08389531821012497,
-0.01658083125948906,
0.14747150242328644,
1.1037689447402954,
-0.7197800874710083,
0.3838236927986145,
0.5186428427696228,
0.8576061725616455,
0.7672837972640991,
-0.2496880441904068,
0.8323410153388977,
-0.5729734897613525,
0.4031597375869751,
0.08582446724176407,
0.6045019626617432,
0.591281533241272,
-0.3292372226715088,
0.7713780999183655,
0.37186992168426514,
-0.636420488357544,
-0.7513229846954346,
0.11884966492652893,
-1.3128983974456787,
0.5048824548721313,
1.3544461727142334,
-0.3021312952041626,
-0.35220620036125183,
-0.42618370056152344,
-0.36741378903388977,
-0.07718607783317566,
-0.3000321686267853,
0.44464483857154846,
0.7243515253067017,
0.3571436107158661,
-0.2564920485019684,
-0.8125062584877014,
0.4137834310531616,
0.29755064845085144,
-0.540176510810852,
-0.30813243985176086,
-0.16015520691871643,
0.1574375480413437,
0.18918488919734955,
0.3498933017253876,
-0.036361195147037506,
0.5977494716644287,
-0.3150208294391632,
0.4297713041305542,
0.1825396567583084,
-0.2390112429857254,
-0.15796047449111938,
-0.06148234382271767,
-0.251680463552475,
-0.17518800497055054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08118v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08118v1
|
HLTCOE at TREC 2023 NeuCLIR Track
| 2024-04-11T20:46:18 | 2024-04-11T20:46:18 |
Eugene Yang, Dawn Lawrie, James Mayfield
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
The HLTCOE team applied PLAID, an mT5 reranker, and document translation to
the TREC 2023 NeuCLIR track. For PLAID we included a variety of models and
training techniques -- the English model released with ColBERT v2,
translate-train~(TT), Translate Distill~(TD) and multilingual
translate-train~(MTT). TT trains a ColBERT model with English queries and
passages automatically translated into the document language from the MS-MARCO
v1 collection. This results in three cross-language models for the track, one
per language. MTT creates a single model for all three document languages by
combining the translations of MS-MARCO passages in all three languages into
mixed-language batches. Thus the model learns about matching queries to
passages simultaneously in all languages. Distillation uses scores from the mT5
model over non-English translated document pairs to learn how to score
query-document pairs. The team submitted runs to all NeuCLIR tasks: the CLIR
and MLIR news task as well as the technical documents task.
|
[
-0.4442419409751892,
-0.5270503163337708,
0.47905558347702026,
0.15764576196670532,
-0.3119465410709381,
0.3928779363632202,
-0.21582743525505066,
-0.6283958554267883,
0.2968633472919464,
0.5356506109237671,
-0.49067866802215576,
-0.5084820985794067,
-0.6744985580444336,
0.4706001877784729,
-0.5143311619758606,
1.2329579591751099,
-0.30238762497901917,
0.2471393644809723,
0.17537330090999603,
-0.2072150558233261,
-0.3050122559070587,
-0.3378492593765259,
-0.7050561308860779,
-0.5582411885261536,
0.8831532001495361,
0.5690345764160156,
0.3360060453414917,
0.35192373394966125,
0.6921884417533875,
0.26797714829444885,
-0.25417524576187134,
-0.23445186018943787,
-0.6169172525405884,
0.19868475198745728,
-0.3308015763759613,
-0.3915241062641144,
-0.5072806477546692,
0.38549524545669556,
0.5885361433029175,
0.2950454652309418,
-0.19906887412071228,
0.06925833970308304,
0.19308874011039734,
0.40819910168647766,
-0.5028482675552368,
-0.08785316348075867,
-0.5955726504325867,
0.1174921914935112,
-0.3088502883911133,
-0.39127835631370544,
-0.6896376013755798,
-0.4342651665210724,
0.06391029059886932,
-0.8146380186080933,
0.34233397245407104,
0.39672714471817017,
1.071930170059204,
0.005985745694488287,
-0.8405778408050537,
-0.6917575001716614,
-0.48029008507728577,
1.0860538482666016,
-0.3864099383354187,
0.7313435673713684,
0.3860105872154236,
0.377115398645401,
0.11612197756767273,
-1.0559762716293335,
-0.4630858600139618,
-0.159409299492836,
0.03283333033323288,
0.3149891495704651,
0.09128622710704803,
-0.0471704825758934,
-0.03726720064878464,
0.2906118333339691,
-0.4398975372314453,
0.07464416325092316,
-0.7631360292434692,
-0.20197029411792755,
0.5767114758491516,
0.21842795610427856,
-0.1800866574048996,
-0.15958304703235626,
-0.5784502029418945,
-0.3304079473018646,
-0.4339830279350281,
-0.3273793160915375,
0.37126195430755615,
0.09305382519960403,
-0.3680163323879242,
0.2964019775390625,
-0.016887102276086807,
0.5001917481422424,
0.286182701587677,
0.06923773884773254,
0.2676528990268707,
-0.5242624282836914,
-0.34314489364624023,
0.24699610471725464,
0.9144850969314575,
-0.03280548378825188,
0.13060325384140015,
-0.23683500289916992,
-0.4959545135498047,
-0.7361503839492798,
0.31774571537971497,
-0.6922746300697327,
-0.29131653904914856,
0.0024884939193725586,
-0.41379693150520325,
-0.39744436740875244,
-0.2154388725757599,
-0.8974941968917847,
-0.048953041434288025,
-0.4269842803478241,
0.5347469449043274,
-0.4557286500930786,
-0.2828453779220581,
-0.1458878070116043,
-0.32126209139823914,
0.3905702233314514,
0.4534868001937866,
-0.7708298563957214,
0.20101577043533325,
0.5145828723907471,
0.7197238206863403,
-0.2615063786506653,
-0.7119361758232117,
-0.9395158886909485,
0.1406758725643158,
-0.24347864091396332,
0.6123008131980896,
-0.48883482813835144,
-0.4632222354412079,
0.001325323130004108,
0.3860273063182831,
-0.2945552170276642,
-0.29196688532829285,
0.901965856552124,
-0.6787073016166687,
0.5977523326873779,
-0.5468578338623047,
-0.24499304592609406,
-0.13472379744052887,
0.3394244611263275,
-0.8142768144607544,
1.191211223602295,
0.2161950320005417,
-0.8962255716323853,
0.37873995304107666,
-0.719963014125824,
-0.5930072665214539,
-0.0857706144452095,
0.502604067325592,
-0.4309643805027008,
0.11208020895719528,
-0.002046679612249136,
0.24589170515537262,
-0.3011249303817749,
0.24049969017505646,
-0.010152578353881836,
-0.3917574882507324,
-0.12011227756738663,
-0.14457355439662933,
0.9680107831954956,
0.5346124768257141,
-0.33731743693351746,
-0.03583041578531265,
-0.46359169483184814,
-0.16667789220809937,
-0.21998056769371033,
-0.8756443858146667,
-0.10572116076946259,
-0.5037081241607666,
0.6737690567970276,
0.4005171060562134,
0.16462112963199615,
-0.689708948135376,
-0.006790702696889639,
0.055234286934137344,
0.6522247791290283,
0.4391147792339325,
-0.038736190646886826,
0.6010293960571289,
-0.2975747287273407,
0.6448898911476135,
0.06586215645074844,
0.29473862051963806,
0.11714747548103333,
-0.5669306516647339,
-0.8061476349830627,
-0.009285759180784225,
0.7303125858306885,
0.5141729712486267,
-0.9788603186607361,
-0.2152732014656067,
-0.2359422892332077,
-0.4825860559940338,
-0.6339685916900635,
-0.007919764146208763,
0.4054308235645294,
0.6004840731620789,
0.6149665713310242,
-0.017402632161974907,
-0.6436361074447632,
-0.825637698173523,
0.01725512184202671,
0.020800232887268066,
0.38030514121055603,
-0.19207186996936798,
1.0110758543014526,
0.04367556422948837,
0.30050766468048096,
-0.04299674555659294,
-0.3208702504634857,
-0.5334795713424683,
0.5817332863807678,
0.28535857796669006,
0.6350191831588745,
0.48758256435394287,
-0.8345194458961487,
-0.8195486664772034,
0.26014798879623413,
-0.5345102548599243,
-0.04537854343652725,
0.15065202116966248,
-0.3902673125267029,
0.41618120670318604,
0.6662517786026001,
-0.2378002107143402,
0.3959371745586395,
0.6415672302246094,
-0.07026626169681549,
0.41321009397506714,
-0.29176121950149536,
0.6380754113197327,
-1.439568281173706,
0.012661793269217014,
-0.11620752513408661,
-0.39283210039138794,
-0.46902379393577576,
0.10387206822633743,
0.3022233545780182,
-0.08693874627351761,
-0.7769572138786316,
0.4403168261051178,
-0.6649501323699951,
0.07940792292356491,
0.01326610054820776,
0.1501452624797821,
0.36981895565986633,
0.3112930953502655,
0.19888322055339813,
0.626412034034729,
0.2531817853450775,
-0.5874894857406616,
0.4075843095779419,
0.3334285020828247,
-0.13683798909187317,
0.7790247201919556,
-0.6241973042488098,
0.2327759861946106,
0.14931340515613556,
0.019620249047875404,
-0.9624853730201721,
-0.09151485562324524,
-0.16258372366428375,
-0.6120424270629883,
0.6864140033721924,
-0.25593772530555725,
-0.29566118121147156,
-0.5466125011444092,
-0.13580943644046783,
0.283723920583725,
0.4399832487106323,
-0.4583531320095062,
0.7218316197395325,
0.32001298666000366,
0.13408790528774261,
-0.5554571151733398,
-1.0781904458999634,
0.40817275643348694,
-0.42306482791900635,
-0.498169869184494,
0.5516127943992615,
0.045464202761650085,
-0.14705011248588562,
0.05648520961403847,
0.1870088428258896,
-0.4166954755783081,
-0.00499336700886488,
-0.14425252377986908,
0.08769877254962921,
-0.3018152117729187,
-0.09134555608034134,
-0.05120627209544182,
0.08446309715509415,
-0.12350357323884964,
-0.4114987552165985,
0.613653302192688,
-0.003251642920076847,
-0.004736876580864191,
-0.6240412592887878,
0.36436033248901367,
0.6832742094993591,
-0.3926686644554138,
0.6939285397529602,
0.8949307799339294,
-0.06347253173589706,
0.11162270605564117,
-0.7971416115760803,
-0.1980731338262558,
-0.42587220668792725,
0.2956847548484802,
-0.6535410284996033,
-0.7420765161514282,
0.525465726852417,
0.3025573790073395,
0.21380986273288727,
0.5286544561386108,
0.6118699312210083,
-0.4924145042896271,
0.5776018500328064,
0.6470087766647339,
-0.07067625969648361,
0.5349854230880737,
-0.4118909537792206,
-0.03249680995941162,
-0.9721627831459045,
-0.4515450894832611,
-0.9143104553222656,
-0.5170412063598633,
-0.8490308523178101,
-0.22290712594985962,
0.38389331102371216,
-0.12603087723255157,
-0.1308336704969406,
0.9349501132965088,
-0.4202209413051605,
0.3791695237159729,
0.8429491519927979,
-0.10497060418128967,
0.3679005801677704,
-0.05741462856531143,
-0.36055949330329895,
-0.1677101105451584,
-0.7680030465126038,
-0.25895780324935913,
1.1899940967559814,
0.2841198742389679,
0.6789984107017517,
0.1219872534275055,
1.1739362478256226,
0.12843354046344757,
0.5079037547111511,
-0.7033487558364868,
0.21162088215351105,
-0.20028144121170044,
-0.7949093580245972,
-0.3236657679080963,
-0.2669629156589508,
-0.9163452982902527,
0.018259473145008087,
-0.17646591365337372,
-0.23991350829601288,
0.5104589462280273,
-0.03131646290421486,
0.10003755241632462,
0.3003684878349304,
-0.5378636717796326,
0.7521089911460876,
-0.365935742855072,
-0.8195812702178955,
-0.20920515060424805,
-0.4921388328075409,
0.3915962874889374,
-0.25479942560195923,
0.3400755524635315,
0.28266993165016174,
0.17725211381912231,
0.9173229336738586,
-0.06608108431100845,
0.3782256841659546,
-0.10058758407831192,
-0.1961994618177414,
0.2379118949174881,
0.3903931677341461,
0.6182692646980286,
0.03474841266870499,
-0.6465247273445129,
0.013480281457304955,
0.05685736984014511,
-0.42576995491981506,
0.013328444212675095,
0.6092912554740906,
-0.683993935585022,
-0.5871101021766663,
-0.49071648716926575,
-0.50689697265625,
0.08692704886198044,
0.3584880232810974,
0.6378955841064453,
0.3919825851917267,
-0.40566951036453247,
0.48595836758613586,
0.5515393614768982,
-0.04745997488498688,
0.7975250482559204,
0.5685071349143982,
-0.020774729549884796,
-0.7486079335212708,
0.5887234210968018,
-0.16557343304157257,
0.4594654142856598,
0.7695165872573853,
0.033495936542749405,
-0.6448997855186462,
-0.8024159073829651,
-0.3128918409347534,
0.271711528301239,
-0.631456732749939,
-0.025925369933247566,
-0.7308477163314819,
-0.11664676666259766,
-0.583509624004364,
-0.24081316590309143,
-0.3084396421909332,
-0.4067099392414093,
-0.11385459452867508,
-0.0104703763499856,
-0.02434195764362812,
1.0523831844329834,
-0.20996546745300293,
0.4442600905895233,
-0.6227794885635376,
0.050335828214883804,
0.26043111085891724,
-0.05871625244617462,
-0.5167174339294434,
-0.9952442049980164,
-0.5482880473136902,
0.033434271812438965,
-0.6754471659660339,
-0.8314208388328552,
0.5439213514328003,
0.16155074536800385,
0.6493884921073914,
-0.15688224136829376,
-0.0954832136631012,
0.653386116027832,
-0.41099998354911804,
0.5846807956695557,
0.40715229511260986,
-1.015919804573059,
0.6528372168540955,
-0.42596012353897095,
0.12279654294252396,
0.9882984161376953,
0.48019737005233765,
-0.5571237206459045,
-0.4317546486854553,
-0.4143403470516205,
-0.36056390404701233,
0.8599444031715393,
0.2630888521671295,
-0.0631730780005455,
-0.08785380423069,
0.01375746913254261,
0.007136722560971975,
0.27643001079559326,
-0.8896868824958801,
0.34228426218032837,
-0.46214917302131653,
-0.08989774435758591,
-0.05109018832445145,
-0.22719429433345795,
-0.05234013870358467,
-0.2825538218021393,
0.7471638321876526,
0.008657937869429588,
-0.03218412399291992,
0.32896047830581665,
-0.24773509800434113,
0.007107368670403957,
0.39632683992385864,
0.7372873425483704,
0.7138208746910095,
-0.42097851634025574,
0.10411164909601212,
0.255991131067276,
-0.6520935893058777,
0.10274884104728699,
-0.0900469720363617,
0.024261193349957466,
0.24825558066368103,
0.5497653484344482,
0.7534017562866211,
0.31405141949653625,
-0.09765570610761642,
0.4015457034111023,
-0.07768572121858597,
-0.7928053736686707,
-0.24599681794643402,
-0.23633520305156708,
0.28661292791366577,
0.09276729077100754,
0.2509387135505676,
-0.1476750373840332,
0.14403490722179413,
-0.6937665939331055,
0.2797508239746094,
0.04762810841202736,
-0.9543377757072449,
-0.3537842929363251,
1.0084478855133057,
0.6620820164680481,
-0.26530054211616516,
0.8689209222793579,
-0.31335705518722534,
-0.669122576713562,
0.6762068867683411,
0.4530811905860901,
1.0342515707015991,
-0.48165732622146606,
0.22229789197444916,
0.7187026739120483,
0.5935302376747131,
-0.145130455493927,
0.3451770842075348,
-0.10134433209896088,
-0.4176642596721649,
-0.2361002266407013,
-0.7351137399673462,
-0.3918091058731079,
0.027366051450371742,
-0.907314121723175,
0.6794840097427368,
0.03531412035226822,
-0.2248004972934723,
-0.10455597192049026,
0.14063669741153717,
-0.8105341196060181,
0.1952495574951172,
-0.07734420895576477,
1.1414533853530884,
-0.7017871737480164,
1.2726740837097168,
0.7008740305900574,
-0.4635525941848755,
-0.7423833012580872,
-0.004325882066041231,
-0.16562248766422272,
-0.6870102286338806,
1.2625203132629395,
-0.2809773087501526,
0.06533148139715195,
0.23432403802871704,
-0.267233282327652,
-0.6472916007041931,
1.262518048286438,
0.12186315655708313,
-0.8022752404212952,
-0.07855777442455292,
0.18546335399150848,
0.37999841570854187,
-0.42103222012519836,
0.39906084537506104,
0.5283557176589966,
0.7424213290214539,
0.4457520842552185,
-1.4274897575378418,
-0.38243916630744934,
-0.07431909441947937,
-0.37878546118736267,
0.22703401744365692,
-0.5675195455551147,
1.1614235639572144,
-0.30818066000938416,
-0.11733893305063248,
-0.10518843680620193,
0.40904542803764343,
0.12701986730098724,
0.47622019052505493,
0.2832707464694977,
0.7347413897514343,
0.6813919544219971,
-0.25293201208114624,
1.0741381645202637,
-0.3777177035808563,
0.5104063153266907,
1.3540829420089722,
-0.363885760307312,
0.8309873342514038,
0.6933006048202515,
0.004341571591794491,
0.38778451085090637,
0.74489426612854,
0.16858503222465515,
0.6592115759849548,
0.02043326385319233,
-0.06742142885923386,
-0.2968927025794983,
-0.26282474398612976,
-0.29006946086883545,
0.6040125489234924,
0.1577845960855484,
-0.4814421534538269,
-0.26165932416915894,
0.08775550872087479,
0.09150592237710953,
0.025771569460630417,
-0.1418212503194809,
0.6811933517456055,
0.15001405775547028,
-0.9621450901031494,
0.8367785811424255,
0.1330220103263855,
0.6444992423057556,
-0.4026871919631958,
0.15502841770648956,
-0.4617728590965271,
0.18433567881584167,
-0.0835861936211586,
-1.02705717086792,
0.4314492344856262,
-0.1616479605436325,
0.04522465541958809,
-0.5651931762695312,
0.1248575821518898,
-0.5825102925300598,
-0.6209242343902588,
0.4246727228164673,
0.41012105345726013,
0.1521107405424118,
0.07395397126674652,
-0.6717144250869751,
-0.000893301737960428,
0.15296868979930878,
-0.2339521050453186,
0.10173840075731277,
0.8515686392784119,
-0.14622479677200317,
0.47521132230758667,
0.39690491557121277,
0.027433766052126884,
0.21983350813388824,
0.19941288232803345,
0.7178202271461487,
-0.7226492762565613,
-0.3819270133972168,
-0.6588696837425232,
0.26073476672172546,
-0.25649088621139526,
-0.5733926892280579,
0.5735242366790771,
1.0231592655181885,
0.7100368738174438,
-0.15067817270755768,
0.6173559427261353,
-0.16773204505443573,
0.2416650950908661,
-0.6356713175773621,
0.6821334362030029,
-0.7315565347671509,
-0.08599938452243805,
-0.07374335825443268,
-0.9540674090385437,
0.23535344004631042,
0.2385597974061966,
-0.3383423089981079,
-0.1304122805595398,
1.3829786777496338,
0.5923001766204834,
-0.2732609212398529,
0.023354945704340935,
0.3383941650390625,
0.17226339876651764,
0.35063883662223816,
1.0592283010482788,
0.8702040910720825,
-0.7354188561439514,
0.9073134064674377,
-0.3786593973636627,
0.18968351185321808,
-0.11849512159824371,
-0.9414700269699097,
-1.0860689878463745,
-0.9221104383468628,
-0.20673952996730804,
-0.41396263241767883,
0.16590043902397156,
0.49334293603897095,
0.7916133999824524,
-0.898527204990387,
-0.4867148995399475,
0.014046951197087765,
0.28294792771339417,
0.2196974754333496,
-0.2714553475379944,
0.09304511547088623,
-0.4335086941719055,
-1.1677165031433105,
0.32878416776657104,
0.3441368639469147,
0.17718198895454407,
-0.06484972685575485,
-0.172536700963974,
-0.6083136200904846,
-0.34877485036849976,
0.40941131114959717,
-0.0642809122800827,
-0.48494189977645874,
-0.15305636823177338,
0.3472023904323578,
-0.3558906316757202,
0.20712696015834808,
0.8825188875198364,
-0.5492255687713623,
0.16541855037212372,
0.8106114864349365,
0.2537555992603302,
1.052298903465271,
-0.21609753370285034,
0.74698406457901,
-0.42436882853507996,
0.32206597924232483,
0.35462039709091187,
0.3732810318470001,
0.3492397665977478,
-0.18846502900123596,
0.7215372920036316,
0.3585043251514435,
-0.5416849851608276,
-0.7682236433029175,
-0.07239113003015518,
-0.9351827502250671,
-0.04226486384868622,
1.0294355154037476,
0.08106984943151474,
-0.43418189883232117,
-0.5193168520927429,
-0.02503187581896782,
0.2018500119447708,
-0.3238385021686554,
0.5987398028373718,
0.9126367568969727,
0.2684589624404907,
-0.31382131576538086,
-1.0051624774932861,
0.4057101309299469,
0.1427438110113144,
-0.6346938610076904,
-0.3508147895336151,
0.12660624086856842,
0.5219985246658325,
0.05677245557308197,
0.714220404624939,
-0.29874899983406067,
0.2782231569290161,
-0.15446215867996216,
0.28810542821884155,
-0.10302674770355225,
-0.3376369774341583,
0.0666922777891159,
0.14105531573295593,
-0.1326611191034317,
-0.261531800031662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08111v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08111v1
|
S3Editor: A Sparse Semantic-Disentangled Self-Training Framework for Face Video Editing
| 2024-04-11T20:25:26 | 2024-04-11T20:25:26 |
Guangzhi Wang, Tianyi Chen, Kamran Ghasedi, HsiangTao Wu, Tianyu Ding, Chris Nuesmeyer, Ilya Zharkov, Mohan Kankanhalli, Luming Liang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Face attribute editing plays a pivotal role in various applications. However,
existing methods encounter challenges in achieving high-quality results while
preserving identity, editing faithfulness, and temporal consistency. These
challenges are rooted in issues related to the training pipeline, including
limited supervision, architecture design, and optimization strategy. In this
work, we introduce S3Editor, a Sparse Semantic-disentangled Self-training
framework for face video editing. S3Editor is a generic solution that
comprehensively addresses these challenges with three key contributions.
Firstly, S3Editor adopts a self-training paradigm to enhance the training
process through semi-supervision. Secondly, we propose a semantic disentangled
architecture with a dynamic routing mechanism that accommodates diverse editing
requirements. Thirdly, we present a structured sparse optimization schema that
identifies and deactivates malicious neurons to further disentangle impacts
from untarget attributes. S3Editor is model-agnostic and compatible with
various editing approaches. Our extensive qualitative and quantitative results
affirm that our approach significantly enhances identity preservation, editing
fidelity, as well as temporal consistency.
|
[
0.1032448261976242,
-0.7006184458732605,
0.708728015422821,
0.27954259514808655,
0.12835556268692017,
0.15421470999717712,
-0.11568913608789444,
0.02742622420191765,
0.1221463680267334,
0.3526827096939087,
-0.9483246803283691,
-0.3478921055793762,
-0.7459390759468079,
0.23790934681892395,
-0.47710487246513367,
1.2135963439941406,
-0.3836665451526642,
-0.0683218315243721,
-0.3500480353832245,
-0.15635700523853302,
-0.40589654445648193,
0.06977007538080215,
-0.4632943272590637,
0.12074001133441925,
0.4641663134098053,
0.1027739942073822,
0.7660351395606995,
0.8469896912574768,
0.31156036257743835,
0.41937655210494995,
-0.2871730923652649,
0.184463232755661,
-0.4192405343055725,
0.06616637855768204,
-0.3743126690387726,
0.01671823300421238,
-0.7061194181442261,
0.10295100510120392,
0.6094807982444763,
0.5083433985710144,
-0.1955883651971817,
0.3729417324066162,
0.16341105103492737,
0.8230311274528503,
-0.9055646657943726,
-0.17190927267074585,
-0.6198345422744751,
0.27260300517082214,
-0.19105404615402222,
0.16887062788009644,
0.16615751385688782,
-0.03540490195155144,
-0.26479822397232056,
-0.856758713722229,
0.5026686191558838,
-0.5172677040100098,
0.5815446972846985,
1.0036213397979736,
-0.04394467920064926,
0.26761069893836975,
-0.5721820592880249,
0.388839989900589,
-0.09133157134056091,
0.42100247740745544,
0.29306676983833313,
0.49703794717788696,
-0.04807063564658165,
-0.7044315934181213,
-0.6859003305435181,
0.48224392533302307,
0.305153489112854,
0.24914208054542542,
-0.2983260750770569,
0.2423011213541031,
0.2584124505519867,
0.3917909264564514,
-0.34504103660583496,
0.17446643114089966,
0.0776229202747345,
-0.17531178891658783,
0.6573601365089417,
0.1566646844148636,
0.2684669494628906,
-0.23553775250911713,
-0.21223554015159607,
0.14567115902900696,
-0.5487698316574097,
-0.15641027688980103,
0.6821911931037903,
-0.19290964305400848,
0.20036065578460693,
0.27899467945098877,
-0.5552095770835876,
0.5771692991256714,
0.40635228157043457,
-0.2916805148124695,
0.11572985351085663,
0.02081426791846752,
-0.25288209319114685,
0.22274434566497803,
0.6893157362937927,
0.5247927308082581,
-0.32179874181747437,
-0.3021099269390106,
-0.2010217159986496,
0.07369310408830643,
0.4793049097061157,
-0.7673433423042297,
-0.3551976680755615,
0.40770968794822693,
-0.5308315753936768,
-0.7638601660728455,
-0.25247907638549805,
-0.7764623761177063,
-0.4718616306781769,
-0.13345006108283997,
0.7386206388473511,
-0.1520625352859497,
-0.2831776440143585,
0.3437592387199402,
-0.21747131645679474,
-0.36698803305625916,
1.0275968313217163,
-1.2428666353225708,
0.27544739842414856,
0.44392791390419006,
0.7648454308509827,
-0.30395200848579407,
-0.6492799520492554,
-0.4593155086040497,
0.4091590642929077,
-0.06244681403040886,
0.45234352350234985,
-0.08013110607862473,
0.008615154772996902,
0.0508611686527729,
-0.12902826070785522,
0.1681290566921234,
-0.39066219329833984,
-0.08648093044757843,
-0.6460387706756592,
-0.3583998382091522,
0.14044702053070068,
-0.23610638082027435,
0.18575340509414673,
0.1776117980480194,
-0.7978439927101135,
1.2220127582550049,
0.24424776434898376,
-0.5231220722198486,
0.3851974308490753,
-0.34972915053367615,
0.05433483421802521,
-0.04729190468788147,
-0.18189522624015808,
-0.6802944540977478,
0.15231257677078247,
0.3040764331817627,
0.5726566314697266,
0.23125414550304413,
0.39317870140075684,
-0.21900780498981476,
-0.20237280428409576,
0.0342593751847744,
-0.20580390095710754,
0.6403348445892334,
0.021783994510769844,
-0.2656968832015991,
-0.010832752101123333,
-0.938552737236023,
-0.36420515179634094,
0.0073848203755915165,
-0.024726660922169685,
0.047894224524497986,
-0.09477462619543076,
-0.21681420505046844,
0.15733662247657776,
0.3019316494464874,
-1.0777671337127686,
0.3646347224712372,
0.19011813402175903,
0.5509983897209167,
1.0917503833770752,
0.11652388423681259,
0.3425518572330475,
0.024363378062844276,
0.1457018107175827,
0.014059143140912056,
0.48395171761512756,
0.2806512117385864,
0.07094468176364899,
-0.6200093626976013,
-0.5350337028503418,
0.03197960555553436,
0.28018781542778015,
-0.8124167323112488,
0.14403533935546875,
-0.35923367738723755,
-0.3432600200176239,
-0.6091009974479675,
0.7479379177093506,
0.2294624149799347,
0.47986340522766113,
0.49583643674850464,
0.05561442673206329,
-0.1247553899884224,
-0.8934066295623779,
-0.6227225065231323,
0.29862096905708313,
-0.10706262290477753,
-0.09802789986133575,
0.5638375878334045,
-0.3968304395675659,
0.9537861943244934,
-0.5243356823921204,
-0.7277063131332397,
-0.2365025132894516,
-0.024787457659840584,
0.034150514751672745,
0.6911914944648743,
0.4593333899974823,
-0.5252635478973389,
-0.4043276607990265,
-0.34188979864120483,
-0.9105350375175476,
-0.12328479439020157,
-0.5032766461372375,
-0.3622862696647644,
-0.22871825098991394,
0.6415728330612183,
-0.6499428749084473,
0.694365382194519,
0.36617109179496765,
0.2675580382347107,
0.2969007194042206,
0.015003927052021027,
0.10129737854003906,
-0.7051503658294678,
-0.20707498490810394,
-0.14295408129692078,
-0.31203678250312805,
-0.6245530843734741,
-0.33696648478507996,
0.24702446162700653,
-0.369270384311676,
-0.5113603472709656,
0.3183356523513794,
-0.1856795847415924,
0.047481562942266464,
-0.07127633690834045,
0.1501396745443344,
0.16439595818519592,
0.8556599617004395,
0.1758609265089035,
0.6332303285598755,
0.48308128118515015,
-0.3536205291748047,
0.4765669107437134,
0.6603360176086426,
-0.2354709506034851,
1.028153419494629,
-0.6704152226448059,
0.20223189890384674,
-0.3456555902957916,
0.03127282112836838,
-0.611691415309906,
-0.4579909145832062,
0.00986518245190382,
-0.31955960392951965,
0.33290496468544006,
-0.3943512439727783,
-0.6542112231254578,
0.028985800221562386,
-0.5361167788505554,
0.4474017024040222,
-0.04800009727478027,
-0.9527326226234436,
0.7698857188224792,
0.2881450355052948,
0.0676126778125763,
-0.5396670699119568,
-0.621111273765564,
0.159676656126976,
-0.14744512736797333,
-0.6928756237030029,
0.8263548612594604,
0.07836610823869705,
0.2401055097579956,
0.10733398050069809,
-0.5729156136512756,
-0.16847644746303558,
0.1495741307735443,
0.3397528827190399,
0.2943371832370758,
0.4380965828895569,
-0.1409052014350891,
0.35212308168411255,
-0.21337679028511047,
-0.05697605386376381,
0.13232676684856415,
-0.39715394377708435,
-0.059964992105960846,
-0.21070317924022675,
-0.9030289053916931,
0.479245126247406,
0.2171066552400589,
-0.13712748885154724,
0.3840435743331909,
0.4281446039676666,
-0.3110710680484772,
-0.28038057684898376,
-0.6521828770637512,
0.2733808755874634,
-0.5638955235481262,
0.5357215404510498,
-0.37729528546333313,
-1.0912448167800903,
0.506860077381134,
-0.4638859033584595,
-0.13207709789276123,
0.36121252179145813,
0.35759228467941284,
-0.36242005228996277,
1.0871044397354126,
0.518082857131958,
0.3260187804698944,
0.659831702709198,
-0.44876566529273987,
-0.08322659879922867,
-1.1289589405059814,
-0.13836751878261566,
0.08488188683986664,
-0.2417675405740738,
-0.43975672125816345,
-0.013707839883863926,
0.7945924401283264,
0.010806544683873653,
-0.41906601190567017,
0.3762786388397217,
-0.5022276639938354,
0.6640718579292297,
0.23500944674015045,
0.32308006286621094,
0.039487358182668686,
-0.32100948691368103,
0.4710423946380615,
-0.20522059500217438,
-0.5835903286933899,
-0.19334931671619415,
0.7884040474891663,
0.479218453168869,
0.9824461936950684,
0.45868948101997375,
0.7793806195259094,
0.43679314851760864,
-0.04508064687252045,
-0.3352469801902771,
0.4105042517185211,
-0.10399109870195389,
-0.5377112627029419,
-0.2930343747138977,
-0.2773280441761017,
-0.3855886459350586,
0.06642495840787888,
-0.349047988653183,
-0.9120375514030457,
0.30860835313796997,
0.5527694225311279,
-0.48987752199172974,
0.3963981568813324,
-0.25374865531921387,
1.4290351867675781,
-0.2572847008705139,
-1.071125864982605,
-0.1316276341676712,
-0.732288658618927,
0.26231542229652405,
0.005114653613418341,
-0.23711621761322021,
-0.13546748459339142,
0.0594690777361393,
0.5231883525848389,
-0.7970609068870544,
0.9193655252456665,
-0.3673034608364105,
0.2552774250507355,
0.04862930625677109,
0.42569437623023987,
0.4770392179489136,
0.46358999609947205,
0.402828186750412,
0.38433215022087097,
0.13290727138519287,
-0.1213071271777153,
-1.05174720287323,
0.650631844997406,
-0.9139429926872253,
-0.6111284494400024,
-0.5728698968887329,
-0.08347255736589432,
-0.35696855187416077,
0.2131035029888153,
0.03717769309878349,
0.3469891846179962,
-0.19636783003807068,
0.12822599709033966,
0.7825050354003906,
-0.17540672421455383,
0.3614526093006134,
0.20735271275043488,
0.20277437567710876,
-0.6575737595558167,
0.953742504119873,
-0.23831403255462646,
0.3632393777370453,
0.09933768212795258,
-0.1077810600399971,
0.0752846896648407,
-0.40102049708366394,
-0.9089936017990112,
0.015647945925593376,
-0.6681156158447266,
-0.6360732913017273,
-0.6692941784858704,
-0.3474966883659363,
-0.3733559846878052,
-0.38623037934303284,
-0.8499734997749329,
-0.44982221722602844,
-0.39263564348220825,
-0.03839839622378349,
0.5686966776847839,
0.5346700549125671,
-0.30848804116249084,
0.7953347563743591,
-0.5644797086715698,
0.553788959980011,
0.6938281059265137,
0.8271087408065796,
-0.24757236242294312,
-0.30549201369285583,
-0.3977838158607483,
-0.3252509534358978,
-0.3898164629936218,
-0.9201907515525818,
0.024776294827461243,
0.461274117231369,
0.40561503171920776,
0.13996249437332153,
-0.2753942012786865,
0.8809699416160583,
-0.6860592365264893,
0.8236281871795654,
0.07237065583467484,
-1.2338238954544067,
0.7357423901557922,
-0.32195019721984863,
0.17331695556640625,
1.0319889783859253,
0.1088867112994194,
-0.560512363910675,
-0.25355562567710876,
-0.5702484846115112,
-0.4668569266796112,
0.9505183100700378,
0.1749066710472107,
0.17783069610595703,
0.0796772912144661,
0.3809888958930969,
0.17178431153297424,
0.4824706017971039,
-0.638874351978302,
-0.09480925649404526,
-1.0241893529891968,
-0.12003283947706223,
0.4987952709197998,
-0.35792338848114014,
-0.21494993567466736,
-0.20024871826171875,
0.5587875247001648,
-0.11309567838907242,
0.17443330585956573,
0.3318410813808441,
-0.4371734857559204,
0.00567740760743618,
-0.141254723072052,
0.23596109449863434,
0.20834074914455414,
-0.5402113795280457,
-0.05187999829649925,
0.25088512897491455,
-0.6683900356292725,
0.19735819101333618,
-0.1470455378293991,
-0.15965814888477325,
-0.21023449301719666,
0.3508695662021637,
0.9756677746772766,
0.23688426613807678,
-0.2759474217891693,
1.1258409023284912,
-0.160697802901268,
-0.4373355209827423,
-0.240000918507576,
0.11048208922147751,
-0.4719019830226898,
0.11108096688985825,
0.040718924254179,
0.3004225790500641,
0.5549997687339783,
-0.09438524395227432,
0.00195473525673151,
0.14114847779273987,
-0.1518435925245285,
-0.2999384105205536,
1.1123197078704834,
0.2513214647769928,
-0.0040694959461688995,
0.43338266015052795,
-0.0459594652056694,
-0.39095333218574524,
0.07878012210130692,
0.17120487987995148,
1.1394456624984741,
-0.11232823133468628,
0.30432888865470886,
0.3363836407661438,
0.1780346930027008,
0.004748927894979715,
-0.1310807168483734,
-0.49340158700942993,
-0.5355716347694397,
-0.22530151903629303,
-0.6404820680618286,
-0.17364181578159332,
0.12007322907447815,
-0.7597790956497192,
0.2553383708000183,
-0.7942092418670654,
0.02582702226936817,
0.24765446782112122,
-0.3257712125778198,
-0.650354266166687,
0.31156599521636963,
-0.20611803233623505,
0.8181922435760498,
-0.8439892530441284,
0.43309667706489563,
0.318660706281662,
-0.4156782031059265,
-0.4800336956977844,
-0.3229500651359558,
0.5011215209960938,
-0.5180203318595886,
0.6570484042167664,
0.09984534233808517,
-0.4354200065135956,
-0.03809681162238121,
-0.37872499227523804,
-0.7779815196990967,
1.1307469606399536,
0.3077940046787262,
-0.21217533946037292,
0.17127199470996857,
0.017882369458675385,
0.4038402736186981,
-0.13894589245319366,
-0.10707974433898926,
0.5809829831123352,
-0.10879151523113251,
0.1826239377260208,
-0.586603045463562,
-0.23409897089004517,
-0.26209327578544617,
0.43256574869155884,
0.039788100868463516,
-0.8556649684906006,
0.578064501285553,
0.19915267825126648,
-0.12753374874591827,
0.04367305710911751,
0.6833877563476562,
-0.3427211046218872,
0.013775834813714027,
0.5453255772590637,
0.7301148772239685,
0.1427721530199051,
0.06196773424744606,
0.5388979911804199,
-0.22528788447380066,
0.12695389986038208,
1.2251275777816772,
-0.20903748273849487,
0.39478644728660583,
0.5589771270751953,
-0.021699506789445877,
0.45980966091156006,
0.5661497712135315,
-0.032151319086551666,
0.8673245310783386,
-0.22786742448806763,
-0.5600753426551819,
-0.3960879445075989,
0.22322724759578705,
-0.011348101310431957,
0.9171248078346252,
0.03138108178973198,
-0.18391790986061096,
-0.3527822196483612,
0.11706282943487167,
0.26564574241638184,
0.27382954955101013,
-0.3451121151447296,
1.0884979963302612,
-0.5836678147315979,
-0.3197651505470276,
0.0862082839012146,
-0.07426248490810394,
0.1735176295042038,
-0.4872586131095886,
-0.31341472268104553,
-0.2471465915441513,
0.047863949090242386,
-0.4259708523750305,
-0.8152034282684326,
0.4464694857597351,
0.34733477234840393,
-0.021432025358080864,
-0.7231019735336304,
0.5383560657501221,
-0.39821451902389526,
-0.25250524282455444,
-0.17524108290672302,
0.0947420746088028,
-0.09720107913017273,
-0.0291755311191082,
-0.6675307750701904,
0.4345684349536896,
-0.23965880274772644,
-0.2173410952091217,
0.4489111304283142,
0.5460361838340759,
0.13389821350574493,
0.2784605026245117,
0.44221043586730957,
0.12075533717870712,
-0.3682451844215393,
0.008217946626245975,
1.1069111824035645,
-0.3714211583137512,
-0.46245691180229187,
-0.7949673533439636,
0.6621198058128357,
-0.4171660244464874,
-0.4180167615413666,
0.7122130990028381,
0.5270301699638367,
0.8264468908309937,
-0.19633519649505615,
0.5693417191505432,
-0.0035480414517223835,
0.44429001212120056,
-0.6774495244026184,
0.6678017973899841,
-0.5824158191680908,
0.09342149645090103,
-0.6110617518424988,
-0.8931146264076233,
-0.35048046708106995,
0.6997737288475037,
0.07731200009584427,
-0.1354449987411499,
0.27732521295547485,
0.9204772114753723,
-0.15782643854618073,
-0.13860246539115906,
0.061521682888269424,
-0.06344465911388397,
0.1765744388103485,
0.29664358496665955,
0.743778645992279,
-0.5198237895965576,
0.1344633549451828,
-0.4831007719039917,
-0.47678983211517334,
-0.12238438427448273,
-1.0437114238739014,
-0.943893313407898,
-0.49129873514175415,
-0.564261257648468,
-0.2779862880706787,
0.20592831075191498,
0.6337217688560486,
0.5418370366096497,
-0.19395779073238373,
0.09332162141799927,
-0.04305623471736908,
-0.0014457587385550141,
-0.34164077043533325,
-0.09693498909473419,
0.390546977519989,
-0.06259222328662872,
-0.5335869193077087,
0.23785123229026794,
0.6699671149253845,
-0.09004419296979904,
-0.25518444180488586,
0.12950164079666138,
0.051266927272081375,
-0.23402947187423706,
0.44755247235298157,
0.4304405748844147,
-0.4874946177005768,
-0.6479280591011047,
-0.24650461971759796,
-0.03218160942196846,
-0.15008223056793213,
0.48830097913742065,
-0.509672999382019,
0.9546709656715393,
0.10933727771043777,
0.8363661170005798,
0.718132734298706,
-0.0028701398987323046,
0.18732479214668274,
-1.0854207277297974,
0.20799872279167175,
-0.07746823877096176,
0.118648461997509,
0.48730817437171936,
-0.6230995059013367,
0.4895044267177582,
0.30948537588119507,
-0.5947718620300293,
-0.9158881306648254,
0.15045565366744995,
-1.0165153741836548,
0.1426405906677246,
0.7026083469390869,
-0.07969961315393448,
-0.4694156348705292,
0.3758884072303772,
-0.249394491314888,
0.325792521238327,
-0.058577992022037506,
0.9503604769706726,
0.5516358613967896,
-0.5734845995903015,
-0.2726433575153351,
-0.6768418550491333,
1.2392430305480957,
0.3071306645870209,
-0.5787317752838135,
0.33595576882362366,
0.7368103861808777,
0.2981495261192322,
-0.13818246126174927,
0.5381523370742798,
-0.1650879830121994,
0.8321769833564758,
0.10468771308660507,
0.25272613763809204,
-0.48193153738975525,
-0.626853346824646,
-0.5310196280479431,
-0.37267306447029114,
-0.160927876830101,
-0.3141377866268158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16053v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16053v1
|
Human Latency Conversational Turns for Spoken Avatar Systems
| 2024-04-11T20:20:48 | 2024-04-11T20:20:48 |
Derek Jacoby, Tianyi Zhang, Aanchan Mohan, Yvonne Coady
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
A problem with many current Large Language Model (LLM) driven spoken
dialogues is the response time. Some efforts such as Groq address this issue by
lightning fast processing of the LLM, but we know from the cognitive psychology
literature that in human-to-human dialogue often responses occur prior to the
speaker completing their utterance. No amount of delay for LLM processing is
acceptable if we wish to maintain human dialogue latencies. In this paper, we
discuss methods for understanding an utterance in close to real time and
generating a response so that the system can comply with human-level
conversational turn delays. This means that the information content of the
final part of the speaker's utterance is lost to the LLM. Using the Google
NaturalQuestions (NQ) database, our results show GPT-4 can effectively fill in
missing context from a dropped word at the end of a question over 60% of the
time. We also provide some examples of utterances and the impacts of this
information loss on the quality of LLM response in the context of an avatar
that is currently under development. These results indicate that a simple
classifier could be used to determine whether a question is semantically
complete, or requires a filler phrase to allow a response to be generated
within human dialogue time constraints.
|
[
-0.6171808838844299,
-1.0270744562149048,
0.6854103803634644,
0.18767185509204865,
-0.18884609639644623,
0.28785085678100586,
0.024340011179447174,
-0.7070010304450989,
0.24935553967952728,
0.5056124329566956,
-0.7630172967910767,
0.03940650820732117,
-0.1200813353061676,
0.17465627193450928,
-0.26980122923851013,
0.6711901426315308,
0.16708599030971527,
-0.026469053700566292,
-0.43672049045562744,
0.050399117171764374,
-0.562915027141571,
-0.7624172568321228,
-0.9349600672721863,
-0.5641145706176758,
0.3969288766384125,
0.32824406027793884,
0.9746184349060059,
0.2780717611312866,
0.28935912251472473,
0.22446376085281372,
-0.2817663848400116,
-0.11142091453075409,
-0.4519737958908081,
0.1612541228532791,
0.09861473739147186,
-0.5474815368652344,
-0.3089969754219055,
-0.00851472094655037,
0.6047527194023132,
0.7630034685134888,
-0.3509633243083954,
0.039110660552978516,
-0.18458274006843567,
0.4181286096572876,
-0.40525758266448975,
0.12907704710960388,
-0.29437166452407837,
0.48068755865097046,
-0.19315436482429504,
-0.29933962225914,
-0.2106035351753235,
-0.2515322268009186,
0.3481100797653198,
-0.641365647315979,
0.3408493101596832,
0.09943853318691254,
0.6116670966148376,
0.30473384261131287,
-0.175406813621521,
-0.12015305459499359,
-1.175232172012329,
0.5145813226699829,
-0.8478237986564636,
0.34214720129966736,
0.47234323620796204,
0.4229898750782013,
-0.3917108178138733,
-0.4618699550628662,
-1.15682053565979,
-0.3242343068122864,
0.006240060552954674,
0.2098432183265686,
0.00740210572257638,
0.3272867202758789,
0.41061893105506897,
0.4309564232826233,
-0.5756663680076599,
-0.1637512743473053,
-0.14458394050598145,
-0.3606835603713989,
0.48650112748146057,
0.46301135420799255,
0.3642694354057312,
-0.2868896722793579,
0.013705819845199585,
-0.21009579300880432,
-0.5784875750541687,
0.09034192562103271,
0.5132302641868591,
-0.07134592533111572,
-0.00936579704284668,
0.6112338900566101,
-0.27186742424964905,
0.7600563764572144,
0.23321273922920227,
-0.14397338032722473,
0.046855341643095016,
-0.5916556119918823,
-0.06170648708939552,
-0.05845693126320839,
0.6927219033241272,
0.44359055161476135,
0.1542510837316513,
-0.12509161233901978,
-0.21078850328922272,
0.17303726077079773,
0.32563120126724243,
-0.7119256854057312,
0.062049899250268936,
0.3240469992160797,
-0.10122054815292358,
0.0629863366484642,
-0.3771020174026489,
-0.3304556608200073,
-0.02376147173345089,
-0.3377981185913086,
0.23916855454444885,
-0.2023819237947464,
-0.24785052239894867,
0.0601264089345932,
0.05776261165738106,
0.7260090112686157,
0.4076293408870697,
-0.7657460570335388,
0.37571531534194946,
0.49488410353660583,
0.9221340417861938,
-0.08830293267965317,
0.17469291388988495,
-0.8536625504493713,
-0.054026536643505096,
-0.4384872019290924,
0.807860791683197,
-0.5670679211616516,
-0.5283722281455994,
-0.1306000053882599,
-0.11572188884019852,
0.015784122049808502,
-0.46714916825294495,
0.28807249665260315,
-0.8079867362976074,
0.5723093152046204,
-0.127489373087883,
-0.3901946544647217,
-0.10062749683856964,
0.34174346923828125,
-0.3786710500717163,
0.6967372894287109,
0.0022015399299561977,
-0.6863201260566711,
-0.04212023690342903,
-0.7046895623207092,
-0.4705672264099121,
0.34989774227142334,
-0.31381961703300476,
-0.16980411112308502,
0.002718581585213542,
0.28088948130607605,
0.4019192159175873,
-0.08929181098937988,
0.0817418172955513,
-0.030193770304322243,
-0.6294701099395752,
0.4899037778377533,
-0.27267587184906006,
0.31253284215927124,
0.23179775476455688,
-0.26270052790641785,
-0.13378527760505676,
-0.4826638102531433,
0.16550789773464203,
0.18190844357013702,
-0.46993741393089294,
0.03690984472632408,
0.20155926048755646,
0.04460315406322479,
0.06212930381298065,
-0.04468388482928276,
-0.6589850783348083,
0.03963564336299896,
-0.5045151114463806,
0.5912134647369385,
0.648628294467926,
0.18796183168888092,
0.283054381608963,
-0.32151103019714355,
0.7497208118438721,
-0.17318351566791534,
0.23233142495155334,
-0.3317456543445587,
-0.6834866404533386,
-0.7873610854148865,
0.2803816795349121,
0.07992411404848099,
0.7378785610198975,
-0.9773609042167664,
0.10571062564849854,
-0.18517473340034485,
-0.2067841738462448,
-0.39478546380996704,
-0.2252149134874344,
0.5824291110038757,
0.5205272436141968,
0.10222177952528,
-0.7272570729255676,
-0.23263618350028992,
-0.7577857971191406,
-0.15871767699718475,
-0.6259651184082031,
-0.42147284746170044,
0.7268859148025513,
0.05939574912190437,
-0.2536434531211853,
1.0614402294158936,
-0.5967666506767273,
0.10431744158267975,
0.045380670577287674,
0.40551382303237915,
0.04536052793264389,
0.055073101073503494,
0.24756506085395813,
-0.8876282572746277,
-0.10430409014225006,
-0.1393217295408249,
-0.8688173294067383,
-0.13008180260658264,
-0.19281509518623352,
0.11422248184680939,
0.16885064542293549,
0.4876578450202942,
-0.6271983981132507,
0.5301223397254944,
0.3758089244365692,
-0.28363165259361267,
0.5406917929649353,
-0.05803419277071953,
0.21929343044757843,
-0.7314628958702087,
-0.06329255551099777,
-0.3190392553806305,
-0.3927527368068695,
-0.7906960844993591,
-0.23026028275489807,
-0.3794993460178375,
-0.3521192669868469,
-0.7187926769256592,
0.7310124635696411,
-0.37985002994537354,
-0.5400928854942322,
-0.23595893383026123,
0.2919510304927826,
-0.14308281242847443,
0.6378300786018372,
0.13206006586551666,
1.1084436178207397,
0.02311917021870613,
-0.9406783580780029,
0.48500701785087585,
0.5400171279907227,
-0.20800694823265076,
0.6835811734199524,
-0.8938079476356506,
0.7013536691665649,
-0.33537423610687256,
0.3591063618659973,
-1.0846675634384155,
-0.5405504703521729,
0.47105729579925537,
-0.7292121052742004,
0.02376745082437992,
-0.22949762642383575,
-0.2958766222000122,
-0.43895819783210754,
0.10254628956317902,
0.5877180099487305,
0.41309788823127747,
-0.19239339232444763,
0.6062363386154175,
0.34490010142326355,
-0.6331378817558289,
-0.358936607837677,
-0.5706361532211304,
0.41641420125961304,
0.026469284668564796,
-0.8734340667724609,
0.30320456624031067,
-0.438987135887146,
-0.21826867759227753,
-0.20589850842952728,
0.21451137959957123,
0.03514188155531883,
0.03739393875002861,
0.3213099241256714,
0.11148720979690552,
-0.08724360913038254,
0.05333526059985161,
-0.23264652490615845,
-0.03615017980337143,
0.023844106122851372,
-0.04242165386676788,
0.7026256322860718,
-0.11004436761140823,
-0.4582516849040985,
-0.685142457485199,
0.4752490222454071,
0.617455005645752,
0.13281121850013733,
0.3332516849040985,
0.5306779742240906,
-0.30059173703193665,
0.8368560671806335,
-0.7286742925643921,
-0.27734678983688354,
-0.38135817646980286,
0.18885675072669983,
-0.2849944233894348,
-0.776818037033081,
0.8565791845321655,
0.50368732213974,
-0.021711470559239388,
0.12075440585613251,
0.5653943419456482,
-0.10158689320087433,
1.2441669702529907,
0.5816022753715515,
-0.047879863530397415,
0.9301650524139404,
-0.08124390244483948,
0.17425256967544556,
-0.8953784704208374,
-0.36305898427963257,
-0.23344092071056366,
-0.1448659896850586,
-0.4060184955596924,
-0.4243216812610626,
0.5313898324966431,
-0.1882541924715042,
-0.2160675823688507,
0.0169680118560791,
-0.23883020877838135,
0.38883498311042786,
0.5513102412223816,
-0.1485634744167328,
0.3469226360321045,
-0.05300767347216606,
-0.010315114632248878,
0.006224593613296747,
-0.5600224733352661,
-0.43501436710357666,
0.6284723281860352,
0.3244214653968811,
0.8472723364830017,
0.1856943666934967,
0.28662627935409546,
0.45525768399238586,
0.022898273542523384,
-0.8362734317779541,
0.6225066184997559,
0.5277904868125916,
-0.5226914286613464,
-0.5876791477203369,
-0.3559776544570923,
-0.7885115742683411,
0.062334854155778885,
-0.1886729598045349,
-0.5479863882064819,
-0.09728629887104034,
0.1154889389872551,
-0.6543546319007874,
-0.09663507342338562,
-0.6970282196998596,
0.40444061160087585,
-0.2225641906261444,
-0.3220684230327606,
-0.12409733980894089,
-0.9217963218688965,
0.13916745781898499,
0.07276905328035355,
0.06338439136743546,
-0.1279827356338501,
0.29748988151550293,
0.9267231822013855,
-0.43757906556129456,
0.7630284428596497,
-0.362894207239151,
-0.10631511360406876,
0.4216156601905823,
0.012394970282912254,
0.37048205733299255,
0.23334231972694397,
0.38721033930778503,
0.03851030766963959,
-0.08843828737735748,
-0.48128774762153625,
-0.6686394214630127,
0.32889431715011597,
-0.8580127954483032,
-0.6393779516220093,
-0.4710070788860321,
-0.2389799803495407,
-0.2379290610551834,
-0.10982511937618256,
0.3528836667537689,
0.2845647931098938,
-0.2810620367527008,
-0.37775278091430664,
0.6675752401351929,
-0.34877458214759827,
0.5163586139678955,
0.5527675747871399,
-0.2908408045768738,
-0.28662174940109253,
0.5640589594841003,
0.11222745478153229,
0.33516809344291687,
0.14909370243549347,
-0.0367601104080677,
-0.34481802582740784,
-0.305076539516449,
-0.715627908706665,
0.3676798939704895,
-0.40221062302589417,
-0.023413781076669693,
-0.6206099987030029,
-0.3397262990474701,
-0.37486782670021057,
0.10044098645448685,
-0.305541455745697,
-0.3319626450538635,
-0.25998324155807495,
0.0184249859303236,
0.27897244691848755,
0.9643720388412476,
0.18581463396549225,
0.6635139584541321,
-0.9057462215423584,
0.4585278332233429,
0.6314902305603027,
0.2323290854692459,
0.05077726021409035,
-0.6816752552986145,
-0.09327924251556396,
0.3555367887020111,
-0.3280094861984253,
-0.5496081113815308,
0.31123706698417664,
0.30705371499061584,
0.44692403078079224,
0.43027257919311523,
-0.17447462677955627,
0.7405089735984802,
-0.5282824635505676,
1.1456962823867798,
0.25601938366889954,
-0.7664524912834167,
0.561285138130188,
-0.3248417377471924,
0.7257336378097534,
0.0015590484254062176,
0.1657370626926422,
-1.3561300039291382,
-0.2765416204929352,
-0.49387767910957336,
-0.8830227851867676,
0.6667914986610413,
0.42971310019493103,
0.2963404059410095,
-0.1060698851943016,
0.6550129055976868,
-0.09962751716375351,
0.1950777769088745,
-0.3713711202144623,
0.009587952867150307,
-0.19921936094760895,
0.44728440046310425,
-0.1857333779335022,
-0.3886658847332001,
0.06089526414871216,
0.1811680942773819,
0.3074168860912323,
-0.26292988657951355,
0.6729838848114014,
0.306680828332901,
-0.06908058375120163,
-0.2976137101650238,
0.3380548059940338,
0.7652760744094849,
0.5563941597938538,
-0.40978503227233887,
-0.15796342492103577,
0.0808168351650238,
-0.5213627815246582,
0.16293121874332428,
-0.215700164437294,
-0.13921427726745605,
-0.10070046782493591,
0.3558374345302582,
0.7968068718910217,
-0.034126266837120056,
-0.6217426061630249,
0.5443050265312195,
-0.5559884309768677,
0.10006973892450333,
-0.6148228645324707,
-0.000640741316601634,
-0.0674026757478714,
0.16203565895557404,
0.6996997594833374,
-0.1189815029501915,
0.10906507074832916,
-0.6089676022529602,
0.09072082489728928,
0.3390474319458008,
-0.3789939284324646,
-0.5216864943504333,
0.6234943270683289,
0.26688340306282043,
-0.578271210193634,
0.9339820742607117,
-0.14640484750270844,
-0.6272637844085693,
0.3378555476665497,
0.4371764063835144,
0.749658465385437,
-0.3268446922302246,
0.2406017780303955,
0.08795833587646484,
-0.2738317549228668,
0.022099660709500313,
0.26447975635528564,
-0.26942768692970276,
-0.6738566756248474,
-0.9045137763023376,
-0.5324472188949585,
-0.7613860964775085,
0.11539866775274277,
-0.5996609926223755,
-0.18947003781795502,
-0.45116758346557617,
-0.464694082736969,
-0.17838139832019806,
-0.16657733917236328,
-0.7414337396621704,
0.22904062271118164,
0.42088940739631653,
0.41825416684150696,
-0.8009225726127625,
0.06041443347930908,
0.6359208226203918,
-0.3828868567943573,
-0.5469661951065063,
0.060985978692770004,
-0.23240163922309875,
-0.7546467185020447,
0.6204590797424316,
0.013124827295541763,
-0.4765937328338623,
-0.22908921539783478,
-0.8296060562133789,
-0.7511054873466492,
0.8372476100921631,
0.3361661434173584,
-0.5711001753807068,
-0.32247287034988403,
0.21164290606975555,
0.6679828763008118,
-0.19148239493370056,
0.608679473400116,
0.65996253490448,
0.20726852118968964,
0.5360682010650635,
-1.1501245498657227,
-0.19385790824890137,
-0.19779889285564423,
0.2526286244392395,
0.11250059306621552,
-0.6356868147850037,
0.7928722500801086,
-0.24174189567565918,
-0.3402409851551056,
0.1542873978614807,
0.738590657711029,
-0.0793006420135498,
0.4724176824092865,
0.45844563841819763,
0.46898379921913147,
0.7936107516288757,
0.028533756732940674,
1.0795369148254395,
0.024726856499910355,
0.13243629038333893,
0.7510735988616943,
-0.11639063060283661,
0.8875904083251953,
0.463735967874527,
-0.34749090671539307,
0.26109638810157776,
0.9173009395599365,
0.6240580081939697,
0.4173014760017395,
0.2592158615589142,
-0.4872382879257202,
-0.4117623567581177,
-0.2642773389816284,
-0.5235927104949951,
0.5873572826385498,
0.4664694666862488,
0.3631269931793213,
0.1566777378320694,
0.3467923402786255,
-0.06448326259851456,
-0.25341230630874634,
-0.16585099697113037,
0.9655986428260803,
0.06469652056694031,
-0.8646125793457031,
0.8120001554489136,
-0.30093297362327576,
0.5662856698036194,
-0.17035087943077087,
-0.18014851212501526,
-0.6600896716117859,
-0.1316128820180893,
-0.19649401307106018,
-0.8015889525413513,
0.2621343731880188,
-0.1338750571012497,
-0.3735872209072113,
0.15490390360355377,
0.3869163393974304,
-0.2800561785697937,
-0.21276140213012695,
0.12588326632976532,
0.5116167664527893,
0.5466024875640869,
-0.2438012808561325,
-0.2950979769229889,
-0.06042144447565079,
-0.07300562411546707,
-0.19166241586208344,
0.18348540365695953,
0.14442738890647888,
-0.1982044279575348,
1.0771530866622925,
0.607857346534729,
-0.028807878494262695,
0.1330283135175705,
0.00003284982449258678,
0.8955317139625549,
-0.826790452003479,
-0.5375714302062988,
-0.5219249129295349,
0.09157693386077881,
0.13144415616989136,
0.00115016323979944,
0.3215603232383728,
0.32855042815208435,
0.7624708414077759,
0.005728062707930803,
0.9873812198638916,
0.06227384880185127,
0.5789908170700073,
-0.7121172547340393,
0.37636587023735046,
-0.37032777070999146,
0.2822115123271942,
-0.17679008841514587,
-1.0072381496429443,
-0.19169719517230988,
0.6734701991081238,
-0.3461669683456421,
0.011513701640069485,
0.3511289954185486,
0.6359884142875671,
0.11170131713151932,
-0.0597272627055645,
0.46840009093284607,
0.06943025439977646,
0.6442237496376038,
0.5659372210502625,
1.1329237222671509,
-0.32467225193977356,
0.6712573170661926,
0.2311246246099472,
-0.12148047238588333,
-0.5465788841247559,
-0.6778163313865662,
-0.6918260455131531,
-0.49057111144065857,
-0.28771573305130005,
-0.3625802993774414,
0.16732950508594513,
0.6337119340896606,
0.6763042211532593,
-0.617165207862854,
-0.16587568819522858,
0.151603564620018,
0.0009007229236885905,
0.069443479180336,
-0.2593666911125183,
0.030837031081318855,
-0.17728513479232788,
-0.7185531258583069,
0.32120198011398315,
0.3501698076725006,
0.3965315818786621,
-0.3075273931026459,
-0.2928920090198517,
-0.05987636744976044,
0.145533487200737,
0.5238964557647705,
0.6524752974510193,
-0.7880316972732544,
-0.6433285474777222,
0.261728972196579,
0.1349300593137741,
0.32320812344551086,
0.8219384551048279,
-1.0613011121749878,
0.6925634741783142,
0.3432745039463043,
0.48755761981010437,
0.8049673438072205,
0.24404147267341614,
0.7965313196182251,
-0.7538332343101501,
0.03587663546204567,
0.48295360803604126,
-0.07546327263116837,
0.6538035273551941,
-0.465751588344574,
0.37600192427635193,
0.3673378527164459,
-0.72809898853302,
-0.5315333008766174,
0.43332087993621826,
-0.89309161901474,
0.29464709758758545,
0.9485650658607483,
0.004697570111602545,
-0.3280493915081024,
-0.3334450125694275,
-0.3894091546535492,
0.27237898111343384,
-0.5662668943405151,
0.5890464186668396,
0.8367539644241333,
-0.6088927984237671,
-0.1874653548002243,
-0.5518632531166077,
0.40241286158561707,
0.37745246291160583,
-0.5013548731803894,
-0.03874678537249565,
0.5948874354362488,
0.17152298986911774,
0.5394541025161743,
0.9969134330749512,
0.1123279333114624,
0.2712974548339844,
-0.08526472747325897,
0.053937382996082306,
0.23236510157585144,
-0.11490977555513382,
-0.1681216061115265,
-0.2020712047815323,
0.28290367126464844,
-0.340343713760376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16859v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16859v1
|
Rumour Evaluation with Very Large Language Models
| 2024-04-11T19:38:22 | 2024-04-11T19:38:22 |
Dahlia Shehata, Robin Cohen, Charles Clarke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Conversational prompt-engineering-based large language models (LLMs) have
enabled targeted control over the output creation, enhancing versatility,
adaptability and adhoc retrieval. From another perspective, digital
misinformation has reached alarming levels. The anonymity, availability and
reach of social media offer fertile ground for rumours to propagate. This work
proposes to leverage the advancement of prompting-dependent LLMs to combat
misinformation by extending the research efforts of the RumourEval task on its
Twitter dataset. To the end, we employ two prompting-based LLM variants
(GPT-3.5-turbo and GPT-4) to extend the two RumourEval subtasks: (1) veracity
prediction, and (2) stance classification. For veracity prediction, three
classifications schemes are experimented per GPT variant. Each scheme is tested
in zero-, one- and few-shot settings. Our best results outperform the precedent
ones by a substantial margin. For stance classification,
prompting-based-approaches show comparable performance to prior results, with
no improvement over finetuning methods. Rumour stance subtask is also extended
beyond the original setting to allow multiclass classification. All of the
generated predictions for both subtasks are equipped with confidence scores
determining their trustworthiness degree according to the LLM, and post-hoc
justifications for explainability and interpretability purposes. Our primary
aim is AI for social good.
|
[
-0.2946632206439972,
-0.8677560091018677,
0.685785174369812,
0.46721985936164856,
-0.1831662803888321,
0.2580961585044861,
-0.4755573272705078,
-0.607213020324707,
0.463961660861969,
0.19001422822475433,
-0.6951848268508911,
-0.4595639109611511,
-0.6722416281700134,
-0.052545756101608276,
-0.46959352493286133,
1.1090463399887085,
0.08486882597208023,
-0.038330622017383575,
0.11877351999282837,
0.15208633244037628,
-0.5197225213050842,
-0.38787224888801575,
-0.7843881845474243,
-0.13574466109275818,
0.6840476393699646,
0.5002453923225403,
0.7974483966827393,
0.07261992990970612,
0.1146174967288971,
0.2184746265411377,
-0.0009219654020853341,
0.21234653890132904,
-0.46519628167152405,
0.31394147872924805,
-0.053843192756175995,
-0.45378080010414124,
-0.16712702810764313,
0.2675156891345978,
0.3275650143623352,
0.3679703176021576,
-0.3795936107635498,
0.25278472900390625,
0.06712896376848221,
0.36313867568969727,
-0.4771050810813904,
0.283342182636261,
-1.0939356088638306,
-0.1834333837032318,
-0.09510498493909836,
-0.2136055827140808,
-0.5086870193481445,
-0.6292473673820496,
0.2520691752433777,
-0.33910974860191345,
0.050303395837545395,
0.3806067407131195,
0.8290301561355591,
-0.03973345085978508,
0.21612869203090668,
-0.4535502791404724,
-0.7049412727355957,
0.8021059036254883,
-0.6526854038238525,
0.13168849050998688,
0.46968698501586914,
0.5434852838516235,
-0.04997390881180763,
-0.3517204523086548,
-0.5289133191108704,
-0.4916928708553314,
0.012463553808629513,
0.2104230523109436,
-0.41065260767936707,
-0.17549721896648407,
0.2746503949165344,
-0.007423095405101776,
-0.47398641705513,
0.091275654733181,
-0.29381993412971497,
-0.4498233199119568,
0.5284129977226257,
-0.14736706018447876,
0.08396816998720169,
-0.19595268368721008,
-0.2156943529844284,
0.21052734553813934,
-0.6715720891952515,
-0.28107500076293945,
0.4110380709171295,
0.2655934989452362,
-0.1946183741092682,
0.5191306471824646,
-0.340101420879364,
0.15690024197101593,
0.39037057757377625,
-0.33422067761421204,
0.13217921555042267,
-0.07312024384737015,
-0.015973038971424103,
0.39264726638793945,
0.7292020916938782,
0.5077603459358215,
0.4516565501689911,
-0.11092881858348846,
-0.297710120677948,
0.23543228209018707,
0.03478305786848068,
-0.40941122174263,
0.027901863679289818,
0.271511971950531,
-0.45482948422431946,
-0.4948320984840393,
0.04287901148200035,
-0.75437992811203,
-0.7636902928352356,
-0.22638291120529175,
0.41299599409103394,
-0.6584975123405457,
-0.24986183643341064,
-0.011569821275770664,
-0.12814052402973175,
0.23715561628341675,
0.8639441132545471,
-0.5494136214256287,
-0.05152488499879837,
0.7603569030761719,
0.7214828133583069,
-0.016700545325875282,
-0.28047651052474976,
-0.5419999361038208,
0.3018232583999634,
-0.4592573642730713,
0.914518415927887,
-0.584895133972168,
-0.2012251913547516,
0.2422517091035843,
-0.2562459111213684,
0.09475965052843094,
-0.36728498339653015,
0.8445978164672852,
-0.6599000096321106,
0.4186646342277527,
-0.2508728504180908,
-0.3328297734260559,
-0.34435558319091797,
0.542571485042572,
-0.5243253707885742,
0.9041411280632019,
0.05473596602678299,
-0.9993104934692383,
0.3405601680278778,
-0.5225499272346497,
-0.4882301390171051,
0.03435530513525009,
-0.07741141319274902,
-0.15718962252140045,
0.2273223102092743,
0.4991483986377716,
0.5918369889259338,
-0.5589427351951599,
0.5071161985397339,
-0.23061156272888184,
-0.2963315546512604,
0.335002601146698,
-0.967286229133606,
0.5202289819717407,
0.25453460216522217,
-0.47541818022727966,
0.04988515377044678,
-0.3709532916545868,
-0.15578609704971313,
-0.13942936062812805,
-0.0027879599947482347,
-0.17749376595020294,
-0.29754704236984253,
-0.3115702271461487,
0.18727834522724152,
0.18994010984897614,
-0.3769495189189911,
0.09276330471038818,
-0.24716807901859283,
0.19705675542354584,
0.7205485701560974,
0.10607677698135376,
0.057207413017749786,
-0.7602526545524597,
0.5560516119003296,
0.03929324820637703,
0.22790707647800446,
-0.19659367203712463,
-0.5888864994049072,
-0.6528977751731873,
-0.23083855211734772,
0.28247177600860596,
0.6488991975784302,
-0.9235348701477051,
0.1307285577058792,
-0.22853714227676392,
-0.6255685687065125,
-0.6062085032463074,
-0.18356163799762726,
0.10749572515487671,
0.47542595863342285,
0.20229706168174744,
0.2415401041507721,
-0.6785096526145935,
-0.9213209748268127,
-0.39368534088134766,
-0.7419835925102234,
0.0542500801384449,
0.033505745232105255,
-0.01712207868695259,
-0.1332109123468399,
0.8056023716926575,
-0.14702853560447693,
0.04955747723579407,
-0.5112823247909546,
0.46475279331207275,
0.3847280740737915,
0.03822821378707886,
0.49700456857681274,
-0.44976332783699036,
-0.6614195704460144,
-0.14751799404621124,
-0.4556502401828766,
-0.18228910863399506,
-0.15450789034366608,
0.16781489551067352,
0.5945395827293396,
0.08801920711994171,
-1.0273946523666382,
0.4078931212425232,
0.4081858992576599,
-0.007932421751320362,
1.0333783626556396,
0.1880732625722885,
0.41854730248451233,
-0.935054361820221,
-0.3263641893863678,
0.12500853836536407,
-0.24797363579273224,
-0.5182182192802429,
-0.4554992616176605,
-0.14551202952861786,
0.17467831075191498,
-0.4142797887325287,
0.4661995470523834,
-0.35594791173934937,
0.1432799994945526,
-0.3116345703601837,
0.09350621700286865,
-0.2809094786643982,
-0.0018968796357512474,
0.007217367645353079,
0.5961577296257019,
0.8827648758888245,
-0.5313340425491333,
0.3996366262435913,
-0.12280319631099701,
-0.23943202197551727,
0.5930414199829102,
-0.4776976704597473,
0.007132242899388075,
-0.32906728982925415,
0.4485054910182953,
-1.0659866333007812,
-0.4829395115375519,
0.4923206865787506,
-0.7551892399787903,
0.22892490029335022,
-0.2215282917022705,
-0.681325376033783,
-0.5720385313034058,
-0.6485577821731567,
-0.25762781500816345,
0.6926916837692261,
-0.640774667263031,
0.5378621816635132,
0.14607475697994232,
-0.44068649411201477,
-0.5720447897911072,
-0.5506187677383423,
0.2896193861961365,
-0.5618177652359009,
-0.6189641356468201,
-0.09584197402000427,
0.004646116402000189,
-0.5351239442825317,
-0.19555877149105072,
-0.15295660495758057,
0.14518074691295624,
-0.2730177044868469,
0.2662546634674072,
0.601327657699585,
-0.1885809749364853,
0.07980072498321533,
-0.09994058310985565,
-0.1676662564277649,
0.2678358256816864,
-0.38147085905075073,
0.5274018049240112,
-0.09772619605064392,
-0.23920254409313202,
-0.5189455151557922,
0.04827315732836723,
0.582973062992096,
0.10495439916849136,
0.8606552481651306,
0.7526922225952148,
-0.4293966591358185,
-0.2657701075077057,
-1.2507634162902832,
-0.21803024411201477,
-0.4703940749168396,
0.15338961780071259,
-0.2142253816127777,
-0.7497096061706543,
0.3655269742012024,
-0.19721511006355286,
0.08553564548492432,
0.48041000962257385,
0.5543286204338074,
-0.06628947705030441,
0.7884421348571777,
0.27750444412231445,
-0.4312158226966858,
0.06570982933044434,
0.03228957951068878,
0.1336972415447235,
-0.2130931168794632,
-0.08290878683328629,
-0.41758012771606445,
0.019775494933128357,
-0.42927709221839905,
-0.601593554019928,
0.12876304984092712,
-0.021758709102869034,
0.15158633887767792,
0.20374223589897156,
-0.21611915528774261,
0.369119793176651,
0.209686741232872,
-0.09422016143798828,
0.4501818120479584,
0.3253643214702606,
-0.031878501176834106,
-0.07139161974191666,
-0.7063493728637695,
-0.6973705887794495,
0.8321518301963806,
0.6733470559120178,
0.9133157730102539,
-0.039974410086870193,
0.49039220809936523,
0.45387956500053406,
0.8279249668121338,
-0.8617837429046631,
0.610363781452179,
0.1420094221830368,
-0.6911044716835022,
-0.3270729184150696,
-0.33526673913002014,
-0.4159422516822815,
-0.03966934233903885,
-0.2599961459636688,
-0.9274184107780457,
-0.22858113050460815,
0.12685541808605194,
-0.3601086735725403,
0.33160117268562317,
-0.5207011103630066,
0.07701408118009567,
-0.2414419949054718,
-0.10124562680721283,
-0.5537937879562378,
-0.46492698788642883,
0.5603071451187134,
-0.2604132890701294,
0.5932877659797668,
-0.29369768500328064,
0.0809035673737526,
0.6237087845802307,
-0.11965064704418182,
1.0342025756835938,
-0.25891318917274475,
-0.167847141623497,
0.5694737434387207,
0.005330157000571489,
0.9322613477706909,
0.20644065737724304,
-0.5528379678726196,
0.18607677519321442,
-0.17537114024162292,
-0.03776663541793823,
-0.4787064492702484,
0.7120508551597595,
-0.6329919695854187,
-0.7810434699058533,
-0.3793656527996063,
-0.5229930877685547,
-0.5775864124298096,
-0.04689083248376846,
0.4100377559661865,
0.18006360530853271,
-0.19815115630626678,
0.12870074808597565,
0.6730772852897644,
-0.3172896206378937,
0.38611194491386414,
0.5816270709037781,
-0.392877459526062,
-0.2564438581466675,
0.811870276927948,
0.08548334985971451,
0.10871189087629318,
0.2902771234512329,
0.5428699851036072,
-0.5074187517166138,
-0.5936195254325867,
-0.22854019701480865,
0.23126120865345,
-0.6774693727493286,
-0.3188839554786682,
-0.5896989703178406,
-0.5669638514518738,
-0.42771872878074646,
-0.12411630898714066,
-0.23278121650218964,
-0.39894282817840576,
0.06200384348630905,
-0.33933156728744507,
0.6069740653038025,
0.9338088631629944,
-0.11619790643453598,
0.405365914106369,
-0.6465531587600708,
0.17885775864124298,
0.17660899460315704,
0.2926241159439087,
0.08123549073934555,
-0.7894929051399231,
-0.11834875494241714,
0.06878316402435303,
-0.05827925726771355,
-0.9277117848396301,
0.3034810423851013,
-0.17536702752113342,
0.6622940897941589,
0.5109907388687134,
0.22945602238178253,
0.6245018839836121,
-0.4215322732925415,
0.7128216624259949,
0.512811541557312,
-0.6822454929351807,
0.5008907914161682,
-0.5787968039512634,
-0.13039451837539673,
0.6247209310531616,
0.606369137763977,
-0.499705046415329,
-0.5845872759819031,
-0.9271171689033508,
-0.602894127368927,
0.5709812045097351,
0.17279987037181854,
0.0831327810883522,
-0.13618186116218567,
0.24863192439079285,
0.46671026945114136,
0.22881492972373962,
-0.5033483505249023,
-0.2884658873081207,
-0.05763367563486099,
-0.06154223531484604,
0.24236512184143066,
-0.5093408226966858,
-0.031042519956827164,
-0.1732255518436432,
0.8917434811592102,
-0.05170905962586403,
0.06697090715169907,
-0.05462617799639702,
0.015760812908411026,
-0.22906231880187988,
0.549627959728241,
0.27353471517562866,
0.8994441628456116,
-0.07549937814474106,
0.07098355889320374,
0.44342294335365295,
-0.44435814023017883,
0.12371228635311127,
0.16962040960788727,
-0.35245832800865173,
0.4195897579193115,
0.2991343140602112,
0.6668449640274048,
-0.055701084434986115,
-0.38416963815689087,
0.37439095973968506,
-0.14349372684955597,
-0.3312036097049713,
-0.5114284157752991,
-0.12125547975301743,
0.22871024906635284,
0.22484847903251648,
0.5831637978553772,
0.05792511999607086,
0.10951220989227295,
-0.6536480784416199,
0.1276816427707672,
0.49266496300697327,
-0.3051258623600006,
-0.3824598789215088,
0.39095279574394226,
0.0571369007229805,
-0.07007608562707901,
0.23638854920864105,
-0.45288771390914917,
-0.4785986542701721,
0.26848092675209045,
0.5210964679718018,
0.8128548860549927,
-0.35683897137641907,
0.7115328907966614,
0.37501099705696106,
0.4799276888370514,
-0.4144521951675415,
0.16995732486248016,
0.3745421767234802,
-0.6893580555915833,
-0.5474672317504883,
-0.5232174396514893,
-0.5092383027076721,
0.5935906767845154,
-0.21925902366638184,
0.4727542996406555,
-0.5083387494087219,
-0.12454898655414581,
-0.06453817337751389,
0.003943192772567272,
-0.46734321117401123,
0.09490661323070526,
0.33902958035469055,
1.0819753408432007,
-0.6177285313606262,
0.7448962330818176,
0.7438159584999084,
-0.10903459042310715,
-1.1459108591079712,
0.6694664359092712,
0.24875178933143616,
-0.8476228713989258,
0.371111661195755,
0.35988616943359375,
-0.07812484353780746,
-0.2769920527935028,
-0.861426055431366,
-0.8264749050140381,
0.9787634611129761,
0.5568249225616455,
-0.7938206195831299,
0.12514595687389374,
0.11848095059394836,
0.27183854579925537,
-0.38547319173812866,
0.4444858431816101,
0.5590998530387878,
0.8266821503639221,
0.630267858505249,
-1.1188544034957886,
0.1129918098449707,
0.20701809227466583,
-0.24813847243785858,
-0.31120723485946655,
-0.672152578830719,
0.4713943600654602,
-0.2401040941476822,
-0.1280292123556137,
0.032420817762613297,
0.7735683917999268,
0.7105371356010437,
0.3416649401187897,
0.7638598680496216,
0.07962960749864578,
1.0489401817321777,
-0.015479867346584797,
0.9031402468681335,
-0.41557776927948,
-0.001633713603951037,
1.0196974277496338,
-0.32900190353393555,
0.6297768950462341,
0.3403239846229553,
-0.10240332037210464,
0.4620656371116638,
0.6278873085975647,
0.20723401010036469,
0.2416560798883438,
0.28524601459503174,
-0.20160698890686035,
-0.17145228385925293,
-0.31672874093055725,
-0.3731282651424408,
0.2678622603416443,
0.6866282820701599,
-0.09003463387489319,
-0.30955004692077637,
-0.11230174452066422,
0.24357962608337402,
-0.1287815123796463,
-0.42214715480804443,
0.40788066387176514,
0.11041690409183502,
-0.7703018188476562,
0.32895922660827637,
-0.002423540921881795,
1.017492413520813,
-0.7027400732040405,
0.03780890256166458,
-0.07050462812185287,
-0.19807931780815125,
-0.18142281472682953,
-0.7748139500617981,
0.28088048100471497,
0.05911913886666298,
-0.1303320974111557,
-0.13164940476417542,
1.173245906829834,
-0.40485310554504395,
-0.5498654246330261,
0.18802271783351898,
0.6444873213768005,
0.18177048861980438,
-0.33945417404174805,
-0.7516396641731262,
0.21858689188957214,
0.0496181920170784,
-0.2686164677143097,
0.05598471686244011,
0.850976824760437,
-0.24576546251773834,
0.7336297631263733,
0.4992440938949585,
0.3287109136581421,
-0.2419138252735138,
0.26474422216415405,
1.089287519454956,
-0.612921416759491,
-0.4984923005104065,
-0.8977307081222534,
0.21520502865314484,
-0.08025344461202621,
0.09975791722536087,
1.0240788459777832,
0.39901795983314514,
0.28188464045524597,
0.026110349223017693,
1.2418231964111328,
-0.041006606072187424,
0.8795995712280273,
-0.5048813223838806,
0.7275568842887878,
0.05821355804800987,
0.6372154951095581,
-0.4530690610408783,
-0.9207996726036072,
-0.052739497274160385,
0.4283183217048645,
-0.5570001006126404,
0.0404895581305027,
0.7074280977249146,
0.7818629145622253,
0.20220234990119934,
0.3577271103858948,
0.26272013783454895,
0.5189136862754822,
0.10852600634098053,
0.11155103147029877,
1.2927476167678833,
0.10269727557897568,
0.700180172920227,
-0.08751886337995529,
-0.33170387148857117,
-0.31809839606285095,
-0.995215117931366,
-1.0421333312988281,
-0.1762683093547821,
-0.37327393889427185,
-0.6005043387413025,
0.32993030548095703,
0.9599560499191284,
0.690444827079773,
-0.8421934247016907,
0.030042948201298714,
0.2067244052886963,
0.12939128279685974,
0.04143846407532692,
-0.2664499282836914,
0.14372606575489044,
-0.3052622973918915,
-0.28978925943374634,
0.36795774102211,
0.2125471532344818,
0.006057369522750378,
-0.44680655002593994,
-0.12788215279579163,
-0.011233785189688206,
0.3518046438694,
0.6937048435211182,
0.05886749178171158,
-0.7571489214897156,
-0.3500839173793793,
-0.011460707522928715,
0.05569877475500107,
-0.16721844673156738,
0.5735993385314941,
-0.799752414226532,
-0.1359969675540924,
0.21708239614963531,
0.51261305809021,
0.21425434947013855,
0.22415806353092194,
0.6267616152763367,
-0.7216804623603821,
0.03980178013443947,
0.23165400326251984,
0.24322772026062012,
0.4472867548465729,
-0.6199118494987488,
0.3397443890571594,
0.08380026370286942,
-0.28547635674476624,
-0.452328622341156,
-0.018108095973730087,
-0.7556407451629639,
-0.19261237978935242,
1.5410207509994507,
0.12695728242397308,
-0.2637042701244354,
-0.31618064641952515,
-0.38885340094566345,
0.013871333561837673,
-0.939916729927063,
1.0279172658920288,
0.9850795269012451,
-0.022295329719781876,
-0.1770058125257492,
-0.7145129442214966,
0.487577348947525,
0.23127177357673645,
-0.7658833265304565,
0.25626420974731445,
0.5651690363883972,
0.3772597312927246,
0.25095170736312866,
0.7299160957336426,
-0.11513838171958923,
0.17271330952644348,
-0.14634914696216583,
-0.2249998152256012,
0.09107577800750732,
-0.44961851835250854,
-0.11141905188560486,
0.18174231052398682,
0.2563498318195343,
0.1447448432445526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08092v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08092v1
|
Data-Augmentation-Based Dialectal Adaptation for LLMs
| 2024-04-11T19:15:32 | 2024-04-11T19:15:32 |
Fahim Faisal, Antonios Anastasopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This report presents GMUNLP's participation to the Dialect-Copa shared task
at VarDial 2024, which focuses on evaluating the commonsense reasoning
capabilities of large language models (LLMs) on South Slavic micro-dialects.
The task aims to assess how well LLMs can handle non-standard dialectal
varieties, as their performance on standard languages is already
well-established. We propose an approach that combines the strengths of
different types of language models and leverages data augmentation techniques
to improve task performance on three South Slavic dialects: Chakavian,
Cherkano, and Torlak. We conduct experiments using a language-family-focused
encoder-based model (BERTi\'c) and a domain-agnostic multilingual model
(AYA-101). Our results demonstrate that the proposed data augmentation
techniques lead to substantial performance gains across all three test datasets
in the open-source model category. This work highlights the practical utility
of data augmentation and the potential of LLMs in handling non-standard
dialectal varieties, contributing to the broader goal of advancing natural
language understanding in low-resource and dialectal settings.
Code:https://github.com/ffaisal93/dialect_copa
|
[
-0.33049142360687256,
-0.4908340573310852,
0.5019816756248474,
0.2438298612833023,
-0.4565277397632599,
0.08837277442216873,
-0.4612598717212677,
-0.5069674253463745,
0.06482824683189392,
0.8993760943412781,
-0.6142365336418152,
-0.4509422183036804,
-0.19438692927360535,
0.3409745693206787,
0.050564415752887726,
0.6993129253387451,
0.17540967464447021,
0.39483243227005005,
-0.4616684019565582,
0.04680252820253372,
-0.29179221391677856,
-0.7336500883102417,
-0.26306846737861633,
-0.27785447239875793,
0.1563919335603714,
0.7247259020805359,
0.5081419944763184,
0.37824851274490356,
0.34201779961586,
0.20374107360839844,
0.01743842475116253,
0.4507741928100586,
-0.34559839963912964,
0.24348466098308563,
-0.20240522921085358,
-0.6142888069152832,
-0.6273975968360901,
-0.31781208515167236,
0.6012489795684814,
0.7457402944564819,
-0.08312913775444031,
-0.055466849356889725,
0.07022993266582489,
0.5733594298362732,
-0.24747540056705475,
0.2909378111362457,
-0.9415199160575867,
-0.23998652398586273,
-0.18395434319972992,
0.06356413662433624,
-0.31043586134910583,
-0.22309327125549316,
0.05507424473762512,
-0.603482186794281,
0.17843325436115265,
0.40372058749198914,
0.5826836824417114,
-0.006916012614965439,
-0.17861713469028473,
-0.15368114411830902,
-0.5213439464569092,
0.8588526844978333,
-0.9813194274902344,
0.5313788056373596,
0.3317089378833771,
0.29199838638305664,
-0.3471359610557556,
-0.2063894122838974,
-0.4418339133262634,
-0.25488248467445374,
0.13820548355579376,
0.13484501838684082,
-0.30995529890060425,
0.2600241005420685,
-0.0304497592151165,
0.4089638888835907,
-0.32703423500061035,
0.21181996166706085,
-0.49211937189102173,
-0.14108777046203613,
0.6368982791900635,
0.38453641533851624,
-0.19201983511447906,
-0.23872876167297363,
-0.14428097009658813,
0.41736769676208496,
-0.7107807397842407,
-0.27474185824394226,
0.5961721539497375,
0.8175456523895264,
-0.2772037088871002,
0.7167859673500061,
-0.2685146629810333,
1.1006213426589966,
0.2360503375530243,
0.2286030799150467,
0.3170352280139923,
-0.7283542156219482,
-0.342654287815094,
-0.26041242480278015,
0.3835293650627136,
0.35266193747520447,
0.2481922209262848,
-0.3143700361251831,
-0.19162017107009888,
-0.3000093698501587,
0.17085453867912292,
-0.3030001223087311,
-0.036252833902835846,
0.10888030380010605,
-0.17403724789619446,
-0.4762670397758484,
-0.2694622576236725,
-1.226698637008667,
-0.6242269277572632,
-0.6214147806167603,
0.2369692176580429,
-0.5972910523414612,
-0.12204108387231827,
0.22808793187141418,
0.1083194836974144,
0.2331608086824417,
0.4862460196018219,
-0.9257258772850037,
0.592719554901123,
0.7986519932746887,
0.7881683707237244,
-0.3932078778743744,
-0.22428756952285767,
-0.5673825740814209,
0.05328986048698425,
-0.3881954848766327,
0.630021870136261,
-0.8549953103065491,
-0.2506229281425476,
0.018056632950901985,
0.16192875802516937,
-0.25556084513664246,
-0.8805531859397888,
0.5380164384841919,
-0.34831148386001587,
0.09873523563146591,
-0.2730938792228699,
-0.4842987060546875,
-0.1474168300628662,
-0.02483854629099369,
-0.5835360288619995,
1.1128407716751099,
0.4791567325592041,
-0.4782435894012451,
0.29653695225715637,
-0.5848877429962158,
-0.20220321416854858,
-0.01385837234556675,
0.09469545632600784,
-0.14969134330749512,
0.43971148133277893,
0.18986375629901886,
0.3422597646713257,
-0.4931000769138336,
0.2159387469291687,
-0.5584059357643127,
-0.28083473443984985,
0.2737303078174591,
-0.2878915071487427,
0.692337155342102,
0.14861443638801575,
0.01329233217984438,
0.25109657645225525,
-0.7984100580215454,
-0.18674485385417938,
-0.1811218410730362,
-0.1363040804862976,
-0.22903956472873688,
-0.18954654037952423,
0.16001799702644348,
0.20570100843906403,
0.19554436206817627,
-0.5698485374450684,
0.2649947702884674,
-0.544520378112793,
0.2851523160934448,
0.783024787902832,
-0.05753372609615326,
0.5476367473602295,
-0.45945945382118225,
0.5335702300071716,
0.11760679632425308,
0.2242666333913803,
0.1868758350610733,
-0.2393541932106018,
-1.1090757846832275,
-0.3563571274280548,
0.5554422736167908,
0.5640078186988831,
-1.0539110898971558,
0.5718327760696411,
-0.4592805504798889,
-0.4348599314689636,
-0.6326597929000854,
0.2154647558927536,
-0.05058588832616806,
0.4161278307437897,
0.30164897441864014,
-0.36635637283325195,
-0.9134167432785034,
-0.9430643916130066,
-0.02071358636021614,
-0.07678679376840591,
-0.07311764359474182,
0.6587013602256775,
0.4414212703704834,
-0.06038275733590126,
0.7980313897132874,
-0.052188098430633545,
0.03774480149149895,
-0.5988502502441406,
-0.03866192325949669,
0.25636664032936096,
0.3342534601688385,
0.5347800254821777,
-0.4753117263317108,
-0.29445189237594604,
0.16307534277439117,
-0.32594773173332214,
-0.585136353969574,
0.03559013456106186,
0.07607870548963547,
0.5097295641899109,
0.17101967334747314,
-0.21616899967193604,
0.12968231737613678,
0.87735915184021,
-0.2710646688938141,
0.9219704866409302,
-0.2173629105091095,
0.24073220789432526,
-0.9574354887008667,
-0.23164896667003632,
-0.14250639081001282,
-0.33294445276260376,
-1.1058008670806885,
-0.04552258551120758,
-0.03676406666636467,
-0.1376972198486328,
-0.44452720880508423,
0.4330444633960724,
-0.36444830894470215,
-0.4920337498188019,
-0.2567194998264313,
-0.026283223181962967,
-0.10762026906013489,
0.3192911744117737,
0.15821436047554016,
1.1128671169281006,
0.6974396109580994,
-0.49704042077064514,
0.45000720024108887,
-0.1618773639202118,
-0.30358773469924927,
0.619031548500061,
-0.4555825889110565,
0.2521514892578125,
0.01656068116426468,
-0.018386397510766983,
-0.7977707982063293,
-0.3698323965072632,
0.33212536573410034,
-0.38030189275741577,
0.056618764996528625,
-0.5400456786155701,
-0.41548952460289,
0.04727199301123619,
-0.1507987082004547,
0.11325621604919434,
0.21504206955432892,
-0.5697833299636841,
0.709248960018158,
0.32574567198753357,
-0.44998520612716675,
-0.17360183596611023,
-0.7563031911849976,
0.372274786233902,
-0.4492776393890381,
-0.8124773502349854,
0.22668275237083435,
0.08912305533885956,
-0.47336071729660034,
-0.11020766943693161,
-0.02382560446858406,
-0.24482472240924835,
-0.06678622215986252,
-0.039379559457302094,
0.6678076386451721,
-0.1919906735420227,
0.1436961591243744,
-0.08270299434661865,
0.12580256164073944,
-0.2251238077878952,
-0.4540041387081146,
0.7619518637657166,
-0.49873822927474976,
-0.2486913502216339,
0.027689393609762192,
0.3013797104358673,
0.6269439458847046,
0.01729106344282627,
0.6312477588653564,
0.4283689558506012,
-0.17562878131866455,
-0.018863944336771965,
-0.6175601482391357,
-0.019153224304318428,
-0.45398131012916565,
0.17697446048259735,
-0.3784997761249542,
-1.0683900117874146,
0.5598088502883911,
-0.2389356791973114,
-0.21307234466075897,
0.16230489313602448,
0.450231671333313,
-0.1686292141675949,
0.4233735501766205,
0.535739541053772,
-0.25067341327667236,
0.3774605989456177,
-0.050519250333309174,
-0.032287128269672394,
-1.1096466779708862,
-0.1129947304725647,
-0.4428952634334564,
0.14613468945026398,
-0.6365998983383179,
-1.1087207794189453,
0.33347082138061523,
-0.16693101823329926,
0.03941261023283005,
0.32187697291374207,
0.05917975306510925,
0.13988380134105682,
0.3320784568786621,
0.19801297783851624,
0.28699928522109985,
0.06758783757686615,
0.054525576531887054,
-0.22729483246803284,
-0.7530351281166077,
-0.3813193738460541,
1.167790174484253,
-0.01820904016494751,
0.8278489708900452,
0.11970152705907822,
0.6570716500282288,
0.4467870593070984,
-0.21151778101921082,
-0.6888421773910522,
0.5627522468566895,
-0.40211501717567444,
-0.37193062901496887,
-0.3320889174938202,
-0.40243735909461975,
-0.6810612678527832,
0.34778061509132385,
-0.3411175310611725,
-0.7401205897331238,
0.523289680480957,
0.041616883128881454,
-0.0551580935716629,
0.10595864057540894,
-0.4533858597278595,
0.49779844284057617,
-0.3024485111236572,
-0.5224116444587708,
-0.2754933834075928,
-0.4664459824562073,
0.27327659726142883,
-0.2705036997795105,
0.49013757705688477,
-0.1258976310491562,
-0.3087802231311798,
0.3400145471096039,
-0.09408505260944366,
0.9031258225440979,
-0.3151529133319855,
0.12169380486011505,
0.07876040041446686,
-0.08462908864021301,
0.6619420647621155,
-0.1279810070991516,
-0.47603359818458557,
0.3219943344593048,
-0.19733163714408875,
-0.477164626121521,
-0.7368767261505127,
0.5332416892051697,
-0.47247928380966187,
-0.6066774725914001,
-0.33150801062583923,
-0.9042962193489075,
-0.4908623993396759,
-0.006415220908820629,
-0.19624587893486023,
0.2900142967700958,
-0.267089307308197,
0.271266907453537,
0.6375685930252075,
-0.14121167361736298,
-0.009050420485436916,
0.6337295174598694,
-0.32727140188217163,
-0.6762964725494385,
0.819378137588501,
-0.12370339781045914,
0.7003949284553528,
0.08003216981887817,
0.08598598092794418,
-0.19855260848999023,
-0.9836077094078064,
-0.6363028287887573,
0.21588844060897827,
-0.3919108211994171,
0.03655502200126648,
-0.22046178579330444,
-0.07251608371734619,
-0.6118173003196716,
-0.11251255869865417,
-0.24328216910362244,
-0.8414862155914307,
-0.32694992423057556,
0.07022155076265335,
0.36722466349601746,
0.499342143535614,
-0.16087859869003296,
0.29101336002349854,
-0.47085052728652954,
0.010912205092608929,
0.049186185002326965,
0.12012903392314911,
-0.5334005355834961,
-0.8975749611854553,
-0.2225775271654129,
0.09009768813848495,
0.2506445348262787,
-0.8425135612487793,
0.5402141809463501,
0.31908875703811646,
0.6977553367614746,
-0.10864122211933136,
-0.03660230711102486,
0.7514472603797913,
-0.2830358147621155,
0.9153707027435303,
-0.10754769295454025,
-1.0379201173782349,
0.40535128116607666,
-0.5314363837242126,
0.07404456287622452,
0.6395609378814697,
-0.051343560218811035,
-0.5951515436172485,
-0.39146560430526733,
-0.41969889402389526,
-0.7327595353126526,
0.7337988018989563,
0.1277228593826294,
0.04425549879670143,
0.493050217628479,
0.37468796968460083,
0.3585785925388336,
0.24868199229240417,
-0.40187811851501465,
0.07441379129886627,
-0.17069053649902344,
-0.22958804666996002,
-0.10633376985788345,
-0.1359361708164215,
-0.04578648507595062,
-0.39676663279533386,
0.7393806576728821,
-0.39149677753448486,
0.22672294080257416,
-0.014817943796515465,
-0.2753291130065918,
0.10126093029975891,
0.633355438709259,
0.6651211977005005,
0.4742492139339447,
-0.17028582096099854,
0.11637388914823532,
0.5819633603096008,
-0.2664370536804199,
0.05601051077246666,
0.16865192353725433,
-0.2336885780096054,
-0.04666624963283539,
0.21368715167045593,
0.9949647188186646,
0.2966660261154175,
-0.5785534381866455,
0.2498590350151062,
0.1894434541463852,
-0.24364203214645386,
-0.09814570844173431,
0.1486513912677765,
0.03953317925333977,
0.21950581669807434,
0.20684024691581726,
0.11470623314380646,
0.2031358927488327,
-0.6431503891944885,
0.18641330301761627,
0.22579750418663025,
-0.413897305727005,
-0.3772374391555786,
0.06833001226186752,
0.21480099856853485,
-0.08438054472208023,
0.3333134353160858,
-0.055997204035520554,
-0.5373426079750061,
0.5196338295936584,
0.7307149171829224,
0.712746262550354,
-0.2654860317707062,
0.18142342567443848,
0.1572302132844925,
0.4196966886520386,
0.32716652750968933,
0.4881567060947418,
0.04683934152126312,
-0.724498450756073,
-0.32855504751205444,
-0.5330125689506531,
-0.6521040201187134,
0.28029656410217285,
-0.6245869398117065,
0.3633211851119995,
-0.20548178255558014,
0.10565527528524399,
-0.08324246108531952,
0.13348470628261566,
-0.5583535432815552,
0.007308202795684338,
0.017460137605667114,
1.0952720642089844,
-1.1172447204589844,
0.9523757100105286,
0.5458407402038574,
0.0035517739597707987,
-0.14998330175876617,
0.08952309191226959,
0.1725146770477295,
-0.8788421750068665,
0.26286008954048157,
-0.3660835325717926,
-0.17313407361507416,
-0.24334238469600677,
-0.3699933886528015,
-0.9025332927703857,
0.9135993719100952,
0.5232075452804565,
-0.5620050430297852,
0.150949165225029,
0.481270968914032,
0.6294348835945129,
-0.7741659879684448,
-0.021476199850440025,
0.9004838466644287,
0.6905916929244995,
0.16556715965270996,
-0.9817236661911011,
-0.07335241883993149,
-0.044806551188230515,
0.13026045262813568,
-0.06993220001459122,
-0.5006026029586792,
0.5918364524841309,
-0.04535157233476639,
0.18213005363941193,
0.23867274820804596,
0.6631008386611938,
0.3387736678123474,
0.2926119267940521,
0.6163936257362366,
0.3367753028869629,
0.8368023037910461,
-0.175925612449646,
0.6795739531517029,
-0.2554064989089966,
0.022601759061217308,
1.2890006303787231,
-0.2881753444671631,
0.6040729880332947,
0.6416987776756287,
-0.3712577521800995,
0.40836861729621887,
0.6419355869293213,
-0.12647202610969543,
0.6061851382255554,
0.1838531792163849,
-0.47604721784591675,
-0.3388698399066925,
-0.3055625259876251,
-0.13382646441459656,
0.684319257736206,
0.6622061729431152,
-0.27392107248306274,
-0.07418598234653473,
0.017154932022094727,
-0.055362846702337265,
0.017375506460666656,
-0.292556494474411,
0.7790126204490662,
-0.22348535060882568,
-0.5410187840461731,
0.524803638458252,
-0.15501485764980316,
0.6141804456710815,
-0.4788709878921509,
0.10471831262111664,
-0.2365187704563141,
0.004585121292620897,
-0.12522591650485992,
-0.7201048731803894,
0.5083818435668945,
0.15953218936920166,
-0.09335610270500183,
0.11990339308977127,
0.9972706437110901,
-0.7041634321212769,
-0.697957456111908,
0.14425891637802124,
0.4803650677204132,
0.30589404702186584,
0.17811232805252075,
-0.6418272852897644,
0.29743558168411255,
0.1008346825838089,
0.3133283257484436,
0.42796385288238525,
0.36631515622138977,
-0.031773969531059265,
0.5448039174079895,
0.5702949166297913,
0.5777403116226196,
0.1957133710384369,
0.29367199540138245,
0.9560574889183044,
-0.38749265670776367,
-0.17105630040168762,
-0.514269232749939,
0.22490818798542023,
-0.2414059191942215,
0.007948585785925388,
0.9180888533592224,
0.810066282749176,
0.6845898628234863,
-0.1300334930419922,
1.0646283626556396,
-0.06007658317685127,
0.43435975909233093,
-0.6650009155273438,
0.1559869945049286,
-0.4286227822303772,
0.37868624925613403,
-0.1433536559343338,
-0.6954658627510071,
-0.22603093087673187,
0.2680909037590027,
-0.4784792959690094,
-0.14216947555541992,
0.29461783170700073,
1.0075838565826416,
-0.08939221501350403,
0.24661755561828613,
0.4689284563064575,
0.1417633444070816,
0.11014081537723541,
0.5070674419403076,
0.7834745049476624,
-0.08795890212059021,
0.4214257597923279,
-0.37329596281051636,
-0.3058052659034729,
-0.20296263694763184,
-0.873087465763092,
-0.6898256540298462,
-0.5900263786315918,
0.07870117574930191,
-0.1561891734600067,
0.6546602845191956,
0.9733349084854126,
0.7009506225585938,
-0.9745888113975525,
-0.46517595648765564,
-0.21211418509483337,
0.0433216467499733,
-0.2300998866558075,
-0.24518945813179016,
-0.006454457063227892,
-0.512068510055542,
-0.8369715213775635,
0.8347836136817932,
0.3944118916988373,
-0.009119893424212933,
-0.177167609333992,
-0.16050489246845245,
-0.07913220673799515,
0.33512672781944275,
0.465541809797287,
-0.06358940899372101,
-0.8256767988204956,
-0.5009191036224365,
0.16751855611801147,
0.2563367784023285,
0.20230551064014435,
0.8894590735435486,
-0.5625576972961426,
0.7086094617843628,
0.5005210638046265,
0.37450119853019714,
0.5776206851005554,
0.09561657160520554,
0.8035426735877991,
-0.6384941935539246,
0.11669915914535522,
0.3199172914028168,
0.40779682993888855,
0.5625571012496948,
-0.32678884267807007,
0.7203654050827026,
0.3982880413532257,
-0.5013620853424072,
-0.8334584832191467,
0.22792015969753265,
-1.0215860605239868,
-0.08158407360315323,
1.3270764350891113,
-0.10892108082771301,
-0.1895207315683365,
-0.6542513966560364,
-0.13776296377182007,
0.038708508014678955,
-0.48030704259872437,
0.6424819231033325,
0.9006053805351257,
-0.3986208736896515,
-0.31021547317504883,
-0.6608864665031433,
0.37582600116729736,
0.24496258795261383,
-0.9895180463790894,
0.6286966800689697,
0.6512587070465088,
0.3158017694950104,
-0.2126777470111847,
0.39896175265312195,
-0.15845908224582672,
0.33765673637390137,
0.02917441911995411,
-0.08992215245962143,
-0.24911387264728546,
-0.3944023549556732,
-0.7879458665847778,
-0.3552262485027313,
-0.040269941091537476,
0.008456224575638771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08080v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08080v1
|
Variance-reduced Zeroth-Order Methods for Fine-Tuning Language Models
| 2024-04-11T18:35:49 | 2024-04-11T18:35:49 |
Tanmay Gautam, Youngsuk Park, Hao Zhou, Parameswaran Raman, Wooseok Ha
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.OC
|
Fine-tuning language models (LMs) has demonstrated success in a wide array of
downstream tasks. However, as LMs are scaled up, the memory requirements for
backpropagation become prohibitively high. Zeroth-order (ZO) optimization
methods can leverage memory-efficient forward passes to estimate gradients.
More recently, MeZO, an adaptation of ZO-SGD, has been shown to consistently
outperform zero-shot and in-context learning when combined with suitable task
prompts. In this work, we couple ZO methods with variance reduction techniques
to enhance stability and convergence for inference-based LM fine-tuning. We
introduce Memory-Efficient Zeroth-Order Stochastic Variance-Reduced Gradient
(MeZO-SVRG) and demonstrate its efficacy across multiple LM fine-tuning tasks,
eliminating the reliance on task-specific prompts. Evaluated across a range of
both masked and autoregressive LMs on benchmark GLUE tasks, MeZO-SVRG
outperforms MeZO with up to 20% increase in test accuracies in both full- and
partial-parameter fine-tuning settings. MeZO-SVRG benefits from reduced
computation time as it often surpasses MeZO's peak test accuracy with a
$2\times$ reduction in GPU-hours. MeZO-SVRG significantly reduces the required
memory footprint compared to first-order SGD, i.e. by $2\times$ for
autoregressive models. Our experiments highlight that MeZO-SVRG's memory
savings progressively improve compared to SGD with larger batch sizes.
|
[
-0.5236194729804993,
-0.7757993936538696,
0.07105903327465057,
0.1024676039814949,
-0.14408805966377258,
-0.13415805995464325,
-0.5387139320373535,
-0.08950148522853851,
-0.23249664902687073,
0.4308212101459503,
-0.7848914265632629,
-0.593829870223999,
-0.2052968293428421,
-0.3179357349872589,
0.1475602239370346,
0.8284963965415955,
0.03210999071598053,
0.15403777360916138,
-0.017905939370393753,
-0.0887562707066536,
-0.2749226987361908,
-0.16106978058815002,
-0.6692308783531189,
-0.2773253619670868,
0.718569815158844,
0.7979035377502441,
0.4797813594341278,
0.7464337348937988,
0.11663473397493362,
0.17467069625854492,
0.0007017352618277073,
0.19436584413051605,
-0.6991021633148193,
0.15207839012145996,
-0.21143998205661774,
-0.4816954731941223,
-0.5017277598381042,
-0.02023678459227085,
0.2684547007083893,
0.6906397938728333,
-0.5169359445571899,
0.2888263761997223,
-0.13347166776657104,
0.7216652631759644,
-1.1979620456695557,
-0.02797589637339115,
-0.41078436374664307,
0.13567690551280975,
-0.1777002066373825,
-0.23091310262680054,
-0.36673128604888916,
-0.239373579621315,
-0.1550518274307251,
-0.35021212697029114,
0.5351647734642029,
-0.1245684027671814,
0.7866950631141663,
0.4745745062828064,
0.32157275080680847,
0.11813812702894211,
-0.880508303642273,
0.9214834570884705,
-1.1570342779159546,
0.5434614419937134,
0.35901108384132385,
0.29691264033317566,
-0.31809285283088684,
-0.30227863788604736,
-0.4725680351257324,
-0.056582432240247726,
0.5902247428894043,
0.1916717141866684,
-0.07760246843099594,
0.5041924118995667,
0.1933218389749527,
0.60787034034729,
-0.5279709100723267,
0.5181664824485779,
-0.3644162118434906,
-0.1211303174495697,
0.5422089099884033,
0.28357359766960144,
-0.03221122547984123,
0.28565847873687744,
-0.07211845368146896,
-0.38708391785621643,
-0.7067968845367432,
0.1956273317337036,
0.2511785328388214,
0.5746961236000061,
0.28391167521476746,
0.28913214802742004,
-0.4891437590122223,
0.8265115022659302,
0.3644437789916992,
-0.18534402549266815,
0.1750471293926239,
-0.26785609126091003,
-0.5660934448242188,
-0.2868143916130066,
0.7359870672225952,
0.31653672456741333,
0.2164471596479416,
-0.13815006613731384,
-0.12400607019662857,
-0.15210498869419098,
0.32206991314888,
-1.0868034362792969,
-0.13573147356510162,
0.045826639980077744,
-0.32362428307533264,
-0.04820319637656212,
-0.3372526466846466,
-0.8274532556533813,
-0.012038318440318108,
-0.16558268666267395,
0.4419419765472412,
-0.39838722348213196,
0.08668433129787445,
0.3645710051059723,
0.18114115297794342,
0.1545451432466507,
0.7041574120521545,
-1.1502459049224854,
0.4291045069694519,
0.519993007183075,
0.7395596504211426,
0.08819103240966797,
-0.40851396322250366,
-0.7898794412612915,
-0.13744133710861206,
-0.816386878490448,
0.3221474587917328,
-0.43810027837753296,
-0.1787383109331131,
-0.06496579200029373,
-0.24146954715251923,
-0.14235422015190125,
-0.6396134495735168,
0.476470023393631,
-0.3401278257369995,
0.06514360755681992,
-0.23880396783351898,
-0.48927411437034607,
-0.24847689270973206,
0.0005282407510094345,
-0.23628467321395874,
1.272743821144104,
0.22480449080467224,
-0.09547071158885956,
0.1814422309398651,
-0.13932852447032928,
-0.3280741572380066,
-0.48213252425193787,
-0.07211557775735855,
-0.45061546564102173,
0.39826956391334534,
-0.048544615507125854,
0.7890510559082031,
-0.45280030369758606,
-0.12504041194915771,
-0.5922297239303589,
-0.49902576208114624,
-0.46240317821502686,
-0.38637399673461914,
0.37524157762527466,
0.3277833163738251,
-0.46420738101005554,
0.042524002492427826,
-1.0015424489974976,
0.05680565908551216,
-0.2321314513683319,
-0.20198014378547668,
-0.45561498403549194,
0.0603979155421257,
-0.2720225751399994,
0.3929067850112915,
0.016004446893930435,
-0.5222463011741638,
0.14544138312339783,
-0.5672553777694702,
0.2479037642478943,
0.593502938747406,
-0.09441123157739639,
0.6587045788764954,
-0.09021417051553726,
0.35521191358566284,
-0.06090746819972992,
0.2282099723815918,
-0.17704999446868896,
-0.2988828718662262,
-0.9909040927886963,
-0.29616668820381165,
0.20062968134880066,
0.5942322015762329,
-0.5541030168533325,
0.2793405055999756,
-0.17922905087471008,
-0.6315943598747253,
-0.5222282409667969,
0.29801300168037415,
0.6432822942733765,
0.5312811136245728,
0.6257577538490295,
-0.12212587147951126,
0.10282567888498306,
-0.8774929642677307,
-0.09193935990333557,
0.08444840461015701,
-0.2775323688983917,
0.5721467137336731,
0.14917603135108948,
-0.06166214123368263,
0.5757617354393005,
-0.5930301547050476,
-0.10557190328836441,
0.1390923708677292,
0.46787765622138977,
0.2832782566547394,
0.634080171585083,
0.7314078211784363,
-0.22864389419555664,
-0.5228100419044495,
0.204875186085701,
0.020969176664948463,
-0.23060233891010284,
-0.17834340035915375,
0.03840670362114906,
0.3350231349468231,
0.5479449033737183,
-0.5092869997024536,
0.40121957659721375,
0.3638383150100708,
-0.20511965453624725,
0.5052313208580017,
-0.6454436779022217,
0.09545546770095825,
-0.8501505851745605,
-0.25480756163597107,
-0.08146630972623825,
-0.17533254623413086,
-0.8784131407737732,
-0.0754617229104042,
0.21814139187335968,
0.09169983118772507,
-0.14195920526981354,
0.5783795118331909,
-0.5524646639823914,
-0.0455741249024868,
-0.18700912594795227,
-0.14091446995735168,
-0.06172709912061691,
0.7535998225212097,
-0.44319576025009155,
0.8527448773384094,
0.4245184659957886,
-0.8402204513549805,
-0.023398669436573982,
-0.18316656351089478,
-0.21234790980815887,
0.26273608207702637,
-0.4257034659385681,
0.10377257317304611,
-0.02318364754319191,
-0.397880494594574,
-1.0088133811950684,
0.22956326603889465,
0.3253183364868164,
-0.42059606313705444,
0.8400177359580994,
-0.009856837801635265,
-0.42004385590553284,
-0.26415541768074036,
-0.48281094431877136,
0.17070181667804718,
0.4935777187347412,
-0.5080723762512207,
0.3831295967102051,
-0.03329799696803093,
-0.2861717641353607,
-0.774625301361084,
-0.6417267322540283,
-0.19000983238220215,
-0.01249944232404232,
-0.2709709703922272,
0.40536320209503174,
-0.21325081586837769,
-0.13974864780902863,
-0.3823089599609375,
-0.41193172335624695,
-0.18284089863300323,
0.2739381194114685,
-0.12610246241092682,
0.061555031687021255,
-0.4466269612312317,
0.157244473695755,
0.42926108837127686,
-0.09949193149805069,
-0.4841878116130829,
-0.20839174091815948,
0.5279532074928284,
-0.15415331721305847,
-0.21773496270179749,
-0.18649087846279144,
0.2571066915988922,
0.7160395383834839,
-0.03479083254933357,
0.7984235882759094,
0.781902551651001,
-0.17468807101249695,
-0.6561352610588074,
-0.6726327538490295,
-0.13784284889698029,
-0.47627025842666626,
0.3570631444454193,
-0.33096635341644287,
-1.2300262451171875,
0.7068393230438232,
-0.06215225160121918,
0.15293878316879272,
0.2691406309604645,
0.7868784070014954,
-0.025212645530700684,
0.6750232577323914,
0.4607107639312744,
-0.2934311628341675,
0.7829898595809937,
-0.1066833883523941,
0.3535211980342865,
-0.5647383332252502,
0.2279510498046875,
-0.5534893870353699,
-0.20933745801448822,
-0.3967680037021637,
-0.9273605346679688,
-0.14517129957675934,
0.4624536633491516,
-0.25852248072624207,
0.1883719265460968,
-0.20952481031417847,
0.5056526064872742,
0.4715166687965393,
0.06475544720888138,
0.0033035443630069494,
-0.06594053655862808,
-0.042329341173172,
-0.14299583435058594,
-0.7435508370399475,
0.007236226461827755,
0.8039522767066956,
0.1549147516489029,
0.8414880037307739,
-0.21520274877548218,
0.5164424777030945,
0.20483838021755219,
0.022744784131646156,
-0.6331005096435547,
0.33761921525001526,
-0.44406625628471375,
-0.2124677300453186,
-0.6560724973678589,
-0.4011887013912201,
-0.5839348435401917,
0.5400703549385071,
-0.07231713086366653,
-0.7963765859603882,
0.4554116129875183,
0.22662687301635742,
-0.7507529258728027,
0.21752823889255524,
-0.5367605090141296,
0.5299732089042664,
0.0673079788684845,
-0.7020620107650757,
-0.628524899482727,
-0.4930882453918457,
0.1058134138584137,
0.21617291867733002,
0.05033613368868828,
-0.41270583868026733,
-0.0353192538022995,
0.28137296438217163,
-0.8030567765235901,
0.6840983033180237,
-0.3047032058238983,
-0.36193031072616577,
0.005963086616247892,
0.12726837396621704,
0.511343240737915,
-0.21460524201393127,
-0.2408808320760727,
0.20589715242385864,
-0.20505459606647491,
-0.38092467188835144,
-0.803936779499054,
0.8057729601860046,
-0.5574747323989868,
-0.5501968264579773,
0.1875670999288559,
-0.720814049243927,
-0.2886139154434204,
0.2875634729862213,
0.13897767663002014,
0.4524804353713989,
-0.18060609698295593,
0.0869520753622055,
0.8657150268554688,
-0.2624739408493042,
0.6552040576934814,
0.504538357257843,
0.1799871325492859,
-0.45058193802833557,
0.9379259943962097,
0.477803111076355,
0.4564257264137268,
0.4060543179512024,
0.05473639816045761,
0.1388484537601471,
-0.8988628387451172,
-0.61796635389328,
0.08335936069488525,
-0.4107359051704407,
-0.3046480715274811,
-0.33520275354385376,
0.08922981470823288,
-0.20828664302825928,
-0.29963192343711853,
-0.9566948413848877,
-0.5729037523269653,
-0.41210120916366577,
-0.003092254512012005,
0.3450740873813629,
0.08875808864831924,
-0.09328687191009521,
0.3458366394042969,
-0.6754444241523743,
0.17008233070373535,
0.189000204205513,
0.5287652611732483,
0.0643828958272934,
-0.3912917375564575,
-0.5153377652168274,
0.15844082832336426,
0.08735492080450058,
-0.5399672389030457,
0.3694659471511841,
0.4336658716201782,
0.5973601341247559,
0.7162508368492126,
0.19976529479026794,
1.2074146270751953,
-0.7734366059303284,
0.5332717895507812,
0.047525547444820404,
-0.990963876247406,
0.2804322838783264,
-0.7011780142784119,
-0.026826048269867897,
0.7235811948776245,
0.01458062045276165,
-0.2467534840106964,
-0.3056589663028717,
-0.4297246038913727,
-0.9154204726219177,
0.7408053874969482,
0.15474091470241547,
0.1424306333065033,
0.12529079616069794,
0.8336032032966614,
0.23680822551250458,
0.4004044830799103,
-0.09075517952442169,
-0.5577288866043091,
0.008613006211817265,
-0.1323331743478775,
-0.4792337119579315,
-0.2787962257862091,
0.2283935695886612,
-0.4407302439212799,
0.5578987002372742,
-0.2835227847099304,
0.13679924607276917,
0.10334416478872299,
-0.06577052921056747,
-0.20529867708683014,
0.32545116543769836,
1.0377445220947266,
0.5049942135810852,
-0.38082411885261536,
-0.05699244514107704,
0.3905843198299408,
-0.3619047701358795,
-0.004955945536494255,
0.02594449557363987,
-0.290063738822937,
0.17147384583950043,
-0.14553797245025635,
1.0243325233459473,
0.5805834531784058,
-0.5529257655143738,
0.3386368155479431,
0.02884189784526825,
-0.27184224128723145,
0.26671040058135986,
0.4785567820072174,
-0.08003982156515121,
0.5229412317276001,
0.2242320328950882,
0.1611729860305786,
0.23764385282993317,
-0.1947147101163864,
0.11969604343175888,
0.5187137126922607,
-0.338323712348938,
-0.3308037221431732,
0.4468834102153778,
-0.17822302877902985,
-0.32276904582977295,
0.15035055577754974,
-0.029952354729175568,
-0.09093552082777023,
0.5046582221984863,
0.49363642930984497,
0.861408531665802,
-0.6479673981666565,
0.10984029620885849,
0.4930664300918579,
0.14571674168109894,
-0.46734195947647095,
0.2998962998390198,
-0.5224342942237854,
-0.737307608127594,
-0.26580458879470825,
-0.5600802898406982,
-0.5665259957313538,
0.13990996778011322,
-0.9809975028038025,
-0.001044100266881287,
-0.8528782725334167,
0.032366834580898285,
-0.10703425109386444,
0.10087758302688599,
-0.2466764599084854,
0.3135529160499573,
0.14877642691135406,
0.8284046649932861,
-0.5914799571037292,
0.9701671600341797,
0.2952744960784912,
-0.05054992809891701,
-0.5475093722343445,
0.07670539617538452,
-0.29568397998809814,
-0.6233411431312561,
0.07405579835176468,
-0.032067786902189255,
-0.4360312521457672,
0.26301950216293335,
-0.5316805243492126,
-0.902101457118988,
1.0698988437652588,
0.5934197306632996,
-0.7610832452774048,
0.20361079275608063,
-0.2799791991710663,
0.7073748111724854,
-0.3365049660205841,
0.15201503038406372,
0.500188410282135,
0.11423646658658981,
0.3089354336261749,
-0.798831045627594,
-0.06198493763804436,
-0.2242935746908188,
0.3293852210044861,
0.3767239451408386,
-0.8345931172370911,
1.2880147695541382,
-0.37242069840431213,
-0.13101617991924286,
0.0529324971139431,
0.675822913646698,
0.14447052776813507,
0.14450165629386902,
0.2010113000869751,
0.5683717131614685,
0.9955146312713623,
0.031198300421237946,
0.7090471982955933,
-0.29807722568511963,
0.5668523907661438,
1.1682274341583252,
-0.1455886960029602,
0.9966262578964233,
0.5631563663482666,
-0.12574812769889832,
0.476156085729599,
0.8162270188331604,
-0.03166293725371361,
0.7239953875541687,
0.2990283668041229,
-0.0028728931210935116,
-0.3150370419025421,
0.21766385436058044,
-0.3163238763809204,
0.08086083084344864,
0.419971227645874,
-0.0012893116800114512,
-0.42104706168174744,
-0.05379471927881241,
0.29216820001602173,
-0.14148734509944916,
-0.6538053154945374,
0.5337516665458679,
0.012476610951125622,
-0.4287405014038086,
0.9800028800964355,
0.058155357837677,
0.6308653354644775,
-0.3091016709804535,
0.03808215633034706,
-0.41134700179100037,
0.6464999318122864,
0.0396869033575058,
-0.1309995800256729,
0.20357683300971985,
-0.2721763253211975,
-0.38152140378952026,
-0.1908671110868454,
0.6019271016120911,
-0.6897923946380615,
-0.31416794657707214,
0.5249192714691162,
0.43781235814094543,
-0.15193043649196625,
0.09657797962427139,
-0.5623535513877869,
-0.3725740313529968,
-0.15034587681293488,
-0.5252004861831665,
0.5338762998580933,
0.41042256355285645,
-0.044825129210948944,
0.7521795630455017,
0.677492082118988,
0.19890645146369934,
0.25415825843811035,
0.17945843935012817,
0.7773492932319641,
-0.6152245998382568,
-0.4711611568927765,
-0.9919087290763855,
0.1970217227935791,
0.21369221806526184,
-0.10085941851139069,
0.8636388182640076,
0.3226095736026764,
0.8983607888221741,
-0.22309266030788422,
0.5226711630821228,
0.18978092074394226,
0.39806821942329407,
-0.595553994178772,
0.7158097624778748,
-0.8461337089538574,
0.05337939411401749,
-0.3481115400791168,
-0.6111095547676086,
-0.4927322566509247,
0.8692188262939453,
-0.20053443312644958,
0.05296184867620468,
0.25237712264060974,
0.7954868674278259,
-0.012480461038649082,
-0.28121885657310486,
0.5771828889846802,
0.33796030282974243,
0.014984416775405407,
0.48909589648246765,
0.4554600715637207,
-0.5524285435676575,
0.05948926508426666,
-0.3807377517223358,
-0.22943295538425446,
-0.3698231875896454,
-0.6151361465454102,
-1.0748931169509888,
-0.2736015319824219,
-0.1293024718761444,
-0.21483570337295532,
0.22460055351257324,
0.8911675214767456,
0.6332572102546692,
-1.1072142124176025,
-0.3067994713783264,
-0.25681883096694946,
0.08398070931434631,
-0.23642697930335999,
-0.13519759476184845,
0.163986936211586,
-0.6842719912528992,
-0.7706243395805359,
0.3960231840610504,
0.8147788643836975,
-0.144773930311203,
-0.07909609377384186,
-0.2439335584640503,
-0.10414797067642212,
0.2751053273677826,
0.42122331261634827,
0.4521578550338745,
-0.6558867692947388,
-0.22168639302253723,
0.18671917915344238,
-0.11787434667348862,
0.32756468653678894,
0.5726534724235535,
-0.4086158573627472,
0.4535130262374878,
0.7005274295806885,
0.5150644183158875,
0.7020915150642395,
0.08396408706903458,
0.8136125206947327,
-0.5142678618431091,
0.2542382478713989,
0.14358077943325043,
0.13386064767837524,
-0.06545359641313553,
-0.31720662117004395,
0.4345061182975769,
0.0974944680929184,
-0.32663729786872864,
-0.7803807258605957,
-0.011340580880641937,
-0.7548863291740417,
-0.3353644013404846,
0.9484755396842957,
-0.2529563307762146,
-0.2887280285358429,
-0.05125600844621658,
0.06555219739675522,
0.29945290088653564,
-0.4179786443710327,
0.7948170304298401,
0.6424604654312134,
-0.16731272637844086,
-0.43135660886764526,
-0.6184989213943481,
0.737452507019043,
0.6730408072471619,
-0.5417929887771606,
0.4035488963127136,
0.5807839035987854,
0.30405402183532715,
0.10945654660463333,
0.6925958395004272,
0.152908593416214,
0.39688748121261597,
-0.1479419767856598,
0.2378004491329193,
-0.16108721494674683,
-0.4606483280658722,
-0.4925732910633087,
0.002492181956768036,
-0.14220581948757172,
-0.25532010197639465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08078v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08078v1
|
SQBC: Active Learning using LLM-Generated Synthetic Data for Stance Detection in Online Political Discussions
| 2024-04-11T18:34:11 | 2024-04-11T18:34:11 |
Stefan Sylvius Wagner, Maike Behrendt, Marc Ziegele, Stefan Harmeling
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Stance detection is an important task for many applications that analyse or
support online political discussions. Common approaches include fine-tuning
transformer based models. However, these models require a large amount of
labelled data, which might not be available. In this work, we present two
different ways to leverage LLM-generated synthetic data to train and improve
stance detection agents for online political discussions: first, we show that
augmenting a small fine-tuning dataset with synthetic data can improve the
performance of the stance detection model. Second, we propose a new active
learning method called SQBC based on the "Query-by-Comittee" approach. The key
idea is to use LLM-generated synthetic data as an oracle to identify the most
informative unlabelled samples, that are selected for manual labelling.
Comprehensive experiments show that both ideas can improve the stance detection
performance. Curiously, we observed that fine-tuning on actively selected
samples can exceed the performance of using the full dataset.
|
[
-0.5668492317199707,
-1.0651884078979492,
0.45491328835487366,
-0.1399783194065094,
-0.5335479378700256,
0.17271818220615387,
-0.3747453987598419,
-0.35036736726760864,
0.6573562026023865,
0.4326389729976654,
-0.44898760318756104,
-0.6242788434028625,
-0.3900889754295349,
-0.04346662387251854,
-0.24090531468391418,
0.843599259853363,
0.20251180231571198,
0.2402995228767395,
-0.04630076512694359,
-0.35811036825180054,
-0.12645064294338226,
-0.3814639747142792,
-0.6362875699996948,
-0.1332653909921646,
0.5826810598373413,
0.4585062265396118,
0.7394970059394836,
0.7538211345672607,
0.09323972463607788,
0.33117425441741943,
-0.15497815608978271,
0.5474798679351807,
-0.6098764538764954,
0.33122971653938293,
-0.07566794008016586,
-0.765386164188385,
-0.4076403081417084,
0.20393988490104675,
0.7266167402267456,
0.3228483498096466,
-0.050997696816921234,
-0.17073817551136017,
-0.2687683403491974,
0.5535348057746887,
-0.6076410412788391,
0.10282596200704575,
-0.9222464561462402,
0.16564396023750305,
-0.1683788150548935,
-0.12579044699668884,
-0.49667057394981384,
-0.43536415696144104,
-0.4539317786693573,
-0.6404229998588562,
0.3864592909812927,
0.11553236842155457,
0.5995901226997375,
0.057891596108675,
-0.5777308940887451,
-0.3149116337299347,
-0.6800134181976318,
0.5587289929389954,
-0.7183218598365784,
0.36173856258392334,
0.20114295184612274,
0.29617631435394287,
-0.2172957807779312,
-0.8216527104377747,
-0.9339799880981445,
-0.08913136273622513,
-0.023183608427643776,
0.2649177312850952,
-0.30640098452568054,
0.16554614901542664,
0.1878707855939865,
0.2972170412540436,
-0.33954840898513794,
0.11082004755735397,
-0.2110738605260849,
-0.2886539399623871,
0.7756420373916626,
0.02744891680777073,
-0.14020812511444092,
-0.4698006212711334,
-0.4958931803703308,
-0.16388843953609467,
-0.7017430067062378,
-0.0009502795292064548,
0.7261953353881836,
0.5647771954536438,
0.26452645659446716,
0.7069350481033325,
-0.3001134991645813,
0.5910900831222534,
0.6081551313400269,
0.30310288071632385,
-0.07908719033002853,
-0.1788666695356369,
-0.1476794183254242,
0.03775814548134804,
0.8604761958122253,
0.022616606205701828,
-0.16186542809009552,
0.18851575255393982,
-0.3340187966823578,
0.07456074655056,
0.3195476830005646,
-0.706941545009613,
-0.38140571117401123,
0.22542360424995422,
-0.4060649275779724,
-0.43137726187705994,
0.4567774534225464,
-0.5968597531318665,
-0.7892282605171204,
-0.711706817150116,
0.2674698829650879,
-0.1618584245443344,
-0.24722282588481903,
-0.22339874505996704,
0.05646681413054466,
0.3801323473453522,
0.5317288041114807,
-0.44059163331985474,
0.07689797878265381,
0.8248615860939026,
0.6293419599533081,
-0.5586860775947571,
0.31650033593177795,
-0.701995849609375,
-0.012896503321826458,
-0.4953977167606354,
1.0339423418045044,
-0.6590608358383179,
-0.24084828794002533,
0.09808044880628586,
0.14431807398796082,
0.286532461643219,
-0.8736932873725891,
0.4096764326095581,
-0.5997389554977417,
0.1515999734401703,
-0.26683205366134644,
-0.7418666481971741,
0.061853840947151184,
0.5658400654792786,
-0.9776711463928223,
1.1668020486831665,
-0.2680648863315582,
-0.5991309881210327,
0.5941594839096069,
-0.5194317102432251,
-0.36499151587486267,
-0.014570298604667187,
-0.3061301112174988,
-0.7040770649909973,
-0.04705717787146568,
0.20784494280815125,
0.5443823337554932,
0.2916209101676941,
0.3110237717628479,
-0.43695545196533203,
-0.18322749435901642,
0.5605371594429016,
-0.2905433475971222,
0.7532048225402832,
0.11169444024562836,
-0.4280344545841217,
0.6393299698829651,
-0.7927218675613403,
-0.14040477573871613,
-0.15789708495140076,
-0.42783328890800476,
-0.256669819355011,
0.17218241095542908,
-0.23038733005523682,
0.14659278094768524,
0.029891284182667732,
-0.4100772440433502,
0.3858092129230499,
-0.4330444931983948,
0.01663188822567463,
0.8426021337509155,
0.2106628268957138,
0.5587520003318787,
-0.15198317170143127,
0.4641910195350647,
0.007463823538273573,
0.030445529147982597,
0.1639133244752884,
-0.35299432277679443,
-1.0190538167953491,
-0.36918210983276367,
0.35228338837623596,
0.3819316029548645,
-0.6695966124534607,
0.3803441822528839,
0.05511820688843727,
-0.42498111724853516,
-0.5485827922821045,
0.13238535821437836,
0.002795882523059845,
-0.07039859890937805,
0.3803464472293854,
-0.11733342707157135,
-0.6301371455192566,
-0.6939764618873596,
-0.5530925989151001,
-0.4100286364555359,
0.03907331824302673,
0.3889625370502472,
0.23887552320957184,
-0.037146057933568954,
0.9943757057189941,
-0.409008264541626,
-0.09193948656320572,
-0.33972299098968506,
0.4439472556114197,
-0.15547682344913483,
0.04409037530422211,
0.22490368783473969,
-0.9015132188796997,
-0.537056028842926,
-0.1009940430521965,
-0.35966622829437256,
-0.043243881314992905,
-0.47802984714508057,
-0.2760213315486908,
0.2567656338214874,
0.5016700029373169,
-0.8503379225730896,
0.41606101393699646,
0.15846748650074005,
-0.24968649446964264,
0.2549920678138733,
0.20555540919303894,
0.08943478018045425,
-1.1037880182266235,
-0.23059335350990295,
0.09199985861778259,
-0.6850194334983826,
-0.7037609815597534,
0.0002837965148501098,
0.13505540788173676,
-0.12071844935417175,
-0.7535473704338074,
0.48788824677467346,
-0.41645142436027527,
0.12344460189342499,
-0.5975151658058167,
0.25242164731025696,
-0.2390347421169281,
0.3458540737628937,
0.2880292236804962,
0.43614619970321655,
0.3007899820804596,
-0.5247966051101685,
0.5462560653686523,
0.16710633039474487,
-0.10964731872081757,
0.3662656247615814,
-0.2837384343147278,
0.39070531725883484,
-0.05936170741915703,
0.5360469222068787,
-1.2888625860214233,
-0.3266984820365906,
0.46693241596221924,
-0.4276748299598694,
0.4578719139099121,
-0.24945878982543945,
-0.3903129994869232,
-0.05427957698702812,
-0.4851906895637512,
0.09033963829278946,
0.13787761330604553,
-0.6459201574325562,
0.5958766937255859,
0.6907348036766052,
0.19446927309036255,
-0.5142149925231934,
-0.29791176319122314,
-0.08207126706838608,
-0.31431877613067627,
-0.3163234293460846,
0.36492085456848145,
0.3597790598869324,
-0.39184871315956116,
-0.21361789107322693,
-0.3058071434497833,
0.13388308882713318,
-0.3179726004600525,
0.36973315477371216,
0.012914334423840046,
-0.14841493964195251,
0.21878863871097565,
0.035777945071458817,
-0.04758886992931366,
0.18585889041423798,
-0.1347907930612564,
0.325883686542511,
-0.0009615625604055822,
-0.46011918783187866,
-0.5373569130897522,
0.1733749955892563,
0.4854019582271576,
-0.0381915308535099,
0.7004192471504211,
0.8027368783950806,
-0.2738845646381378,
-0.6498698592185974,
-0.4113978147506714,
-0.5196830034255981,
-0.5184382796287537,
0.1372431218624115,
0.25172460079193115,
-0.7533694505691528,
0.2927071750164032,
-0.45306217670440674,
0.13600310683250427,
0.25222596526145935,
0.8579760193824768,
-0.40051040053367615,
1.0013021230697632,
0.4557947814464569,
0.00213858881033957,
0.6128413677215576,
-0.3347669243812561,
0.21924400329589844,
-0.13528813421726227,
-0.26689594984054565,
-0.38249513506889343,
-0.6323416233062744,
-0.6403009295463562,
-0.810938835144043,
0.2574732005596161,
-0.20607642829418182,
-0.03744319826364517,
0.1513989269733429,
-0.45921772718429565,
0.37761956453323364,
0.24723897874355316,
0.2962145507335663,
0.15996123850345612,
0.0065836794674396515,
0.24887047708034515,
-0.10200279951095581,
-0.573241651058197,
-0.41266247630119324,
0.8027122616767883,
0.12956245243549347,
0.7207595109939575,
0.036209139972925186,
0.432025283575058,
0.5329083204269409,
0.3601585030555725,
-1.2633212804794312,
0.8967956900596619,
0.08974401652812958,
-0.680934727191925,
-0.2379486858844757,
-0.47654345631599426,
-1.060851812362671,
0.3648609220981598,
-0.5094102621078491,
0.05949962139129639,
0.165582075715065,
0.299888014793396,
-0.025396203622221947,
0.49697741866111755,
-0.2026309072971344,
0.7549869418144226,
-0.36680471897125244,
-0.5052545070648193,
-0.48233744502067566,
-0.6415172815322876,
0.09605375677347183,
0.1056901291012764,
0.005055224988609552,
-0.01968507096171379,
-0.10595747828483582,
0.7667788863182068,
-0.24334707856178284,
1.279437780380249,
-0.6162194013595581,
-0.041835568845272064,
0.5677889585494995,
-0.10970771312713623,
0.8407281637191772,
0.31679144501686096,
-0.14219501614570618,
-0.17883896827697754,
-0.5449742674827576,
-0.25453218817710876,
-0.5592912435531616,
0.5208681225776672,
-0.7792783379554749,
-0.7604691982269287,
-0.4145897626876831,
-0.41278550028800964,
-0.2480081468820572,
0.017644433304667473,
-0.023894760757684708,
0.08203529566526413,
-0.525122880935669,
0.5092978477478027,
0.7177945971488953,
-0.01967882737517357,
0.16729186475276947,
0.5184758305549622,
0.025718338787555695,
-0.31091007590293884,
0.67330002784729,
0.14370304346084595,
0.041925206780433655,
0.4143247604370117,
0.24946939945220947,
-0.5962413549423218,
-0.44812339544296265,
-0.15068209171295166,
0.1778249442577362,
-0.7438021302223206,
-0.5333269238471985,
-0.4803154766559601,
-0.006170439999550581,
-0.2398797869682312,
-0.07535792887210846,
-0.5504517555236816,
-0.8670899271965027,
-0.41360336542129517,
-0.3847009539604187,
0.38341638445854187,
0.6073858141899109,
-0.034082867205142975,
0.4862787127494812,
-0.2760010063648224,
0.5395091772079468,
0.3374721109867096,
0.0746719017624855,
-0.5395452380180359,
-0.47438564896583557,
-0.008950583636760712,
0.2502943277359009,
-0.7455636262893677,
-1.1743836402893066,
0.33889323472976685,
0.30543896555900574,
0.6426576375961304,
0.7198305130004883,
0.49261078238487244,
0.6246786117553711,
-0.024663148447871208,
0.7223902940750122,
-0.0855979397892952,
-0.6447303891181946,
0.7335537075996399,
-0.390453040599823,
-0.13060642778873444,
0.3850509226322174,
0.6474130749702454,
0.004096295218914747,
-0.6823143362998962,
-0.6201688051223755,
-0.9368169903755188,
0.7246829271316528,
0.22713269293308258,
0.32616060972213745,
-0.07381598651409149,
0.3942243158817291,
0.2360563427209854,
0.14747200906276703,
-0.8026784658432007,
-0.23625068366527557,
-0.3603988587856293,
0.059027038514614105,
0.4242081940174103,
0.13117991387844086,
-0.286893367767334,
-0.44300541281700134,
0.8117814064025879,
-0.389499694108963,
0.1845608949661255,
-0.10832243412733078,
-0.14526478946208954,
-0.27243635058403015,
0.17226125299930573,
0.2278471142053604,
0.39498618245124817,
0.07063733786344528,
0.17693577706813812,
0.40167176723480225,
-0.24722644686698914,
0.07162871956825256,
-0.17124143242835999,
-0.13257430493831635,
0.279753714799881,
0.015323546715080738,
0.9766582250595093,
-0.010921688750386238,
-0.31300419569015503,
0.4782378375530243,
0.015924528241157532,
-0.21319672465324402,
-0.41303810477256775,
0.2500397861003876,
0.2083539217710495,
0.3211069405078888,
0.3046260476112366,
0.049692247062921524,
-0.02597404643893242,
-0.8667192459106445,
0.4828821122646332,
0.7919776439666748,
-0.4553816020488739,
-0.35455960035324097,
0.5633374452590942,
0.1666993349790573,
-0.2229173481464386,
0.3894709646701813,
-0.14712819457054138,
-0.5249916911125183,
0.6184619665145874,
0.5174248814582825,
0.4061366617679596,
-0.2618374824523926,
0.4226500391960144,
0.4358760416507721,
-0.022061876952648163,
0.10364698618650436,
0.22774475812911987,
-0.16455170512199402,
-0.6784466505050659,
-0.26707878708839417,
-0.33461713790893555,
-0.6271349787712097,
0.2896561622619629,
-0.6930393576622009,
0.7189134359359741,
-0.562086820602417,
-0.44825804233551025,
0.04298881068825722,
0.4847429394721985,
-0.23025870323181152,
0.147853821516037,
0.22244788706302643,
0.6225329041481018,
-0.9572265148162842,
0.86693274974823,
0.944159984588623,
0.12871842086315155,
-0.5788806080818176,
0.2007562518119812,
0.2127760499715805,
-0.5253685116767883,
0.13222959637641907,
0.06578388065099716,
-0.1041506975889206,
-0.11211938410997391,
-0.7652190327644348,
-0.2763660252094269,
1.0039440393447876,
0.46203553676605225,
-0.4087448716163635,
0.33038511872291565,
0.3353812098503113,
0.5340788960456848,
-0.2816430330276489,
0.15904425084590912,
0.1953033208847046,
0.6868565678596497,
0.17731954157352448,
-0.17064957320690155,
0.09375447034835815,
-0.11238136142492294,
-0.5316550135612488,
0.3674858510494232,
-0.9132171273231506,
0.5907512307167053,
0.10717607289552689,
-0.31995025277137756,
-0.3678242564201355,
1.0671387910842896,
0.3781469464302063,
0.5183122754096985,
0.6829489469528198,
0.27268072962760925,
0.9280498623847961,
-0.08552052825689316,
0.5691263675689697,
-0.0932508036494255,
0.2716207802295685,
0.6408564448356628,
-0.31282439827919006,
0.9070541262626648,
0.4355463981628418,
-0.04342695325613022,
0.321365624666214,
0.737275242805481,
-0.1418282687664032,
0.2759552299976349,
0.18972273170948029,
-0.5111187696456909,
-0.6609147787094116,
0.11045999079942703,
0.06299182772636414,
0.5305611491203308,
0.6542273163795471,
-0.12417305260896683,
-0.045482560992240906,
-0.028057772666215897,
-0.04038793966174126,
0.23152010142803192,
-0.31302422285079956,
1.0475969314575195,
0.06569401174783707,
-0.6643868088722229,
0.546465277671814,
0.02670201286673546,
0.5207479596138,
-0.490205854177475,
-0.12227178364992142,
-0.37551140785217285,
0.1187952309846878,
-0.3719317317008972,
-0.8146782517433167,
0.381683886051178,
-0.02352922037243843,
0.005818783771246672,
-0.2881084382534027,
1.041197657585144,
-0.5296257138252258,
-0.30898547172546387,
0.014478509314358234,
0.5651241540908813,
0.0822685956954956,
0.022281436249613762,
-0.8479596376419067,
-0.02468961663544178,
0.06267185509204865,
-0.580356776714325,
0.4473251402378082,
0.623081386089325,
-0.3225836157798767,
0.4257977604866028,
0.9507916569709778,
0.14238688349723816,
-0.01397115457803011,
-0.12590770423412323,
1.2492334842681885,
-0.5187183022499084,
-0.40479740500450134,
-0.6372675895690918,
0.43277567625045776,
-0.31775352358818054,
0.02972439117729664,
0.7963798642158508,
0.7504457235336304,
0.7741534113883972,
0.08784681558609009,
0.825528621673584,
-0.07674405723810196,
0.38657045364379883,
-0.45571044087409973,
0.7585400342941284,
-0.5073368549346924,
0.3525010943412781,
0.2528024911880493,
-0.8825104236602783,
-0.47789764404296875,
0.9201695322990417,
-0.14083826541900635,
-0.15924309194087982,
0.4064425528049469,
1.1536335945129395,
-0.5892274379730225,
0.11727651208639145,
0.12400837987661362,
0.26824951171875,
0.30426448583602905,
-0.0399615503847599,
1.0065497159957886,
-0.1057514101266861,
0.6462789177894592,
-0.23006361722946167,
0.0715184360742569,
-0.3073127567768097,
-0.7924726605415344,
-1.1048372983932495,
-0.4786470830440521,
-0.5318440198898315,
-0.44974184036254883,
0.005695999134331942,
1.0357438325881958,
0.8002484440803528,
-1.0451023578643799,
-0.1185411661863327,
-0.03382908180356026,
0.05898723006248474,
-0.09901273250579834,
-0.20967034995555878,
0.4324864149093628,
-0.20707498490810394,
-0.7406539916992188,
0.6220272183418274,
-0.1662008911371231,
-0.17544294893741608,
-0.15867196023464203,
-0.12498500198125839,
-0.2617972791194916,
0.4156495928764343,
0.5052593946456909,
0.41029655933380127,
-0.741009533405304,
-0.1925172209739685,
0.07720179855823517,
-0.005755356978625059,
0.39633649587631226,
1.11787748336792,
-0.9519250392913818,
0.47269219160079956,
0.6628797650337219,
0.546884298324585,
0.7943228483200073,
0.5521456003189087,
0.39229610562324524,
-1.1446354389190674,
0.24154289066791534,
0.4652310013771057,
0.14758101105690002,
0.3564324378967285,
-0.3671353757381439,
0.289865106344223,
0.3281169533729553,
-0.4359768331050873,
-0.77378249168396,
0.18843668699264526,
-1.202402114868164,
-0.4443795382976532,
1.4555145502090454,
0.016557440161705017,
-0.11186612397432327,
-0.29325443506240845,
-0.4998544454574585,
0.7283936738967896,
-0.5326683521270752,
0.8123851418495178,
0.2600202262401581,
-0.32377734780311584,
-0.05423719435930252,
-0.3952190577983856,
0.5488993525505066,
0.3203955888748169,
-0.7847562432289124,
0.22018985450267792,
0.692680299282074,
0.07075884938240051,
-0.1356954723596573,
0.43537166714668274,
0.07072426378726959,
0.09960860013961792,
-0.2228945642709732,
-0.2637876868247986,
-0.14377668499946594,
-0.3707195222377777,
-0.07198785990476608,
0.3270784318447113,
-0.18767012655735016,
-0.06389613449573517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08066v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08066v1
|
MSciNLI: A Diverse Benchmark for Scientific Natural Language Inference
| 2024-04-11T18:12:12 | 2024-04-11T18:12:12 |
Mobashir Sadat, Cornelia Caragea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The task of scientific Natural Language Inference (NLI) involves predicting
the semantic relation between two sentences extracted from research articles.
This task was recently proposed along with a new dataset called SciNLI derived
from papers published in the computational linguistics domain. In this paper,
we aim to introduce diversity in the scientific NLI task and present MSciNLI, a
dataset containing 132,320 sentence pairs extracted from five new scientific
domains. The availability of multiple domains makes it possible to study domain
shift for scientific NLI. We establish strong baselines on MSciNLI by
fine-tuning Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) and prompting Large Language
Models (LLMs). The highest Macro F1 scores of PLM and LLM baselines are 77.21%
and 51.77%, respectively, illustrating that MSciNLI is challenging for both
types of models. Furthermore, we show that domain shift degrades the
performance of scientific NLI models which demonstrates the diverse
characteristics of different domains in our dataset. Finally, we use both
scientific NLI datasets in an intermediate task transfer learning setting and
show that they can improve the performance of downstream tasks in the
scientific domain. We make our dataset and code available on Github.
|
[
-0.1878637671470642,
-0.3729704022407532,
0.15780037641525269,
0.5145527720451355,
0.06131795793771744,
0.3038054406642914,
-0.3837156891822815,
-0.7795167565345764,
-0.08307012915611267,
0.3754166066646576,
-0.6340411901473999,
-0.44678956270217896,
-0.6354804039001465,
0.6955652832984924,
-0.021623168140649796,
1.0460150241851807,
0.20811304450035095,
0.19488424062728882,
-0.2746952772140503,
-0.1511056274175644,
-0.0752020925283432,
0.040217045694589615,
-0.4037492871284485,
-0.11659333854913712,
0.6087360978126526,
0.25602179765701294,
0.4039604961872101,
0.4108198881149292,
0.6856127381324768,
0.15910862386226654,
-0.0812876895070076,
0.47444725036621094,
-0.4773584306240082,
0.01459855679422617,
-0.24297566711902618,
-0.5861179828643799,
-0.06712674349546432,
-0.04728605970740318,
0.7934366464614868,
1.1858882904052734,
0.37090548872947693,
0.1829303652048111,
0.06425588577985764,
0.5839545726776123,
-0.6529161334037781,
0.09017796814441681,
-0.7318926453590393,
-0.014748968183994293,
-0.3360811769962311,
-0.04016972333192825,
-0.7478204369544983,
-0.36377426981925964,
0.3197004199028015,
-0.8242922425270081,
0.24787214398384094,
0.08157739043235779,
0.8071209788322449,
0.3338426351547241,
-0.564680278301239,
0.010581915266811848,
-0.48107779026031494,
1.2214914560317993,
-0.9301888346672058,
0.37668198347091675,
0.17310118675231934,
0.2720179557800293,
-0.22549289464950562,
-0.6320306658744812,
-0.44999322295188904,
-0.4212554395198822,
-0.00503027718514204,
0.08184973895549774,
-0.14782603085041046,
-0.2576877474784851,
0.13885293900966644,
-0.06241348385810852,
-0.7791739702224731,
0.1863502413034439,
-0.5478686690330505,
0.1900825798511505,
0.7337269186973572,
-0.006914173718541861,
0.16813978552818298,
0.053748875856399536,
0.020747927948832512,
-0.10875828564167023,
-0.8109560012817383,
-0.14590351283550262,
0.20263193547725677,
0.5817367434501648,
0.09691593796014786,
0.5427830219268799,
-0.08096165955066681,
0.8349819183349609,
-0.1981261819601059,
-0.04062596336007118,
0.48769137263298035,
-0.6789279580116272,
-0.2684982717037201,
0.20603647828102112,
0.7636290788650513,
0.4695042669773102,
0.32770031690597534,
-0.2827345132827759,
0.3644517660140991,
0.1984173208475113,
0.16393795609474182,
-0.6882835626602173,
-0.15083065629005432,
-0.08040887862443924,
-0.30103346705436707,
-0.1436251997947693,
0.17081257700920105,
-0.5670554041862488,
-0.15709879994392395,
-0.38892537355422974,
-0.12854164838790894,
-0.5222020745277405,
-0.12751109898090363,
-0.08677822351455688,
-0.039764221757650375,
-0.09641347080469131,
0.09492699056863785,
-0.558368980884552,
0.44508153200149536,
0.8166218996047974,
0.9436826109886169,
-0.7255367040634155,
-0.3448936939239502,
-0.25920143723487854,
0.2948492467403412,
-0.150977224111557,
0.5430768132209778,
-0.6931626796722412,
-0.37363672256469727,
-0.25112077593803406,
0.061739254742860794,
-0.7039901614189148,
-0.5658954381942749,
0.6744365096092224,
-0.38735997676849365,
0.18389587104320526,
-0.23504434525966644,
-0.6954138875007629,
-0.07238107174634933,
-0.13195843994617462,
-0.7322196364402771,
1.0376980304718018,
-0.1051255539059639,
-1.165770411491394,
0.3880259096622467,
-0.9497671723365784,
-0.47575682401657104,
0.06919153034687042,
0.20359092950820923,
-0.09865950047969818,
0.10855487734079361,
-0.10973081737756729,
0.13400238752365112,
-0.2527557611465454,
0.7386817336082458,
-0.6027136445045471,
-0.19717206060886383,
0.3335259258747101,
-0.34506964683532715,
0.8875076174736023,
0.5429485440254211,
-0.2186063528060913,
-0.0757923349738121,
-1.038731575012207,
0.0397285558283329,
-0.39180171489715576,
-0.005658218637108803,
-0.6131703853607178,
0.030140487477183342,
0.3979156017303467,
0.19872044026851654,
-0.04963993281126022,
-0.8597192168235779,
0.1199142262339592,
-0.5666012167930603,
0.481225848197937,
0.3322535455226898,
0.040083497762680054,
0.26347100734710693,
-0.09230994433164597,
0.07932263612747192,
0.007585433311760426,
0.09932035952806473,
0.3909558355808258,
-0.7923990488052368,
-0.3311813473701477,
-0.3632180690765381,
0.4129802882671356,
0.6363717317581177,
-0.6030793786048889,
0.3965894281864166,
-0.480269193649292,
-0.4128293991088867,
-0.9366680979728699,
-0.04340371862053871,
0.15231794118881226,
0.5426070690155029,
0.38800913095474243,
0.17745794355869293,
-0.6757437586784363,
-1.1127893924713135,
-0.5377232432365417,
-0.011200938373804092,
-0.18133153021335602,
0.20109178125858307,
0.7000581622123718,
-0.23757411539554596,
1.1722065210342407,
-0.23736611008644104,
0.2100885808467865,
-0.02055232971906662,
0.5637292265892029,
0.5104573369026184,
0.5349619388580322,
0.5451009273529053,
-0.9944359660148621,
-0.5454117655754089,
0.25506824254989624,
-0.7902939319610596,
-0.2702348232269287,
-0.15541303157806396,
-0.23054349422454834,
0.03308683633804321,
0.25380048155784607,
-0.5693334937095642,
0.23141656816005707,
0.5195520520210266,
-0.3350985646247864,
0.5357240438461304,
0.1363031417131424,
0.3087751567363739,
-1.0659840106964111,
0.40814802050590515,
0.3729766309261322,
-0.011223608627915382,
-1.012142539024353,
0.02855609729886055,
-0.14216648042201996,
0.39730557799339294,
-0.5681573748588562,
0.42060455679893494,
-0.18100599944591522,
0.06032625213265419,
-0.2826315760612488,
-0.08140912652015686,
-0.1284119039773941,
0.09433574974536896,
0.1396554708480835,
0.8893330097198486,
0.45145148038864136,
-0.5928939580917358,
-0.4018436074256897,
0.1977423131465912,
-0.31176120042800903,
0.18977749347686768,
-0.6839307546615601,
-0.2272023856639862,
0.0769287496805191,
0.15491028130054474,
-0.7047370076179504,
0.005815716926008463,
-0.07285691052675247,
-0.21700036525726318,
0.17227581143379211,
0.27473512291908264,
-0.37349677085876465,
-0.338306725025177,
-0.1192251592874527,
0.457785040140152,
0.06746391952037811,
-0.48979124426841736,
0.22674892842769623,
0.15933461487293243,
-0.23381365835666656,
-0.6073896884918213,
-0.7392563819885254,
0.33536481857299805,
-0.2250187247991562,
-0.5056337118148804,
0.5482025742530823,
-0.3985368311405182,
-0.5589940547943115,
0.11472082138061523,
-0.07801046967506409,
-0.27658894658088684,
0.15067172050476074,
0.28456833958625793,
0.4248546063899994,
-0.4471645951271057,
-0.1405244618654251,
0.31263643503189087,
0.14147178828716278,
0.1769523322582245,
-0.3990600109100342,
-0.2099446803331375,
-0.18438948690891266,
-0.07521113753318787,
-0.3614591956138611,
0.431186705827713,
0.5929269790649414,
0.06134554743766785,
0.6937005519866943,
0.42038679122924805,
-0.3413999378681183,
-0.03531627729535103,
-0.3264321982860565,
0.009450657293200493,
-0.37615880370140076,
0.33378297090530396,
-0.42651426792144775,
-1.1862766742706299,
0.13912540674209595,
-0.24923622608184814,
0.3372117877006531,
0.6356069445610046,
0.2254672795534134,
0.07416339963674545,
0.9618421792984009,
0.6344437599182129,
-0.23349754512310028,
-0.06692495942115784,
-0.12356727570295334,
0.26678258180618286,
-0.6964353322982788,
-0.07131408154964447,
-0.7771621346473694,
-0.12990671396255493,
-0.642166793346405,
-0.48332688212394714,
0.14646455645561218,
0.04316110536456108,
-0.12464912235736847,
0.3361184597015381,
-0.40489089488983154,
0.47380247712135315,
0.46763676404953003,
-0.1741681843996048,
0.41848403215408325,
0.0015838340623304248,
-0.058881763368844986,
-0.40773147344589233,
-0.7093419432640076,
-0.6622908711433411,
0.8823280334472656,
0.12375793606042862,
0.323616087436676,
-0.031989362090826035,
0.5044206380844116,
0.29909828305244446,
0.6549891233444214,
-0.2829577922821045,
0.4209374785423279,
-0.5091473460197449,
-0.34347450733184814,
-0.24178065359592438,
-0.6759951710700989,
-0.7533144354820251,
0.3903668224811554,
-0.15004310011863708,
-0.6595211625099182,
0.4200657308101654,
-0.2916765511035919,
-0.05267811194062233,
0.25212064385414124,
-0.6534267067909241,
0.7637876868247986,
-0.09911863505840302,
-0.3392319977283478,
-0.14213185012340546,
-1.0313705205917358,
0.6963056921958923,
-0.2129247635602951,
0.3508715033531189,
-0.39990463852882385,
0.16405919194221497,
0.6534983515739441,
-0.09963103383779526,
0.9752675890922546,
-0.004305195529013872,
0.20395399630069733,
0.029408147558569908,
-0.0639345794916153,
0.12745484709739685,
0.24210435152053833,
-0.5238285660743713,
0.27494528889656067,
0.10535115748643875,
-0.4133855402469635,
-0.46918728947639465,
0.9395446181297302,
-0.7760195732116699,
-0.22106750309467316,
-0.4448963403701782,
-0.7810800075531006,
-0.31103602051734924,
0.1416785567998886,
0.30096858739852905,
-0.1499338001012802,
-0.5250409245491028,
0.038254640996456146,
0.6624422073364258,
0.04440057650208473,
0.5648963451385498,
0.3967984616756439,
0.269715279340744,
-0.25264614820480347,
0.8182995319366455,
-0.24696163833141327,
0.17917442321777344,
0.4712109863758087,
0.01207226887345314,
-0.20299096405506134,
-0.6227515935897827,
-0.14757946133613586,
0.3329141139984131,
-0.4025741517543793,
-0.14298520982265472,
-0.8959078192710876,
-0.2016238570213318,
-0.5026810765266418,
-0.17022930085659027,
-0.19618406891822815,
-0.5913928747177124,
-0.5731926560401917,
-0.12757644057273865,
0.41465529799461365,
0.7318865060806274,
0.17782153189182281,
-0.11599838733673096,
-0.7514362335205078,
0.06432412564754486,
-0.09121661633253098,
-0.07694876939058304,
-0.28570178151130676,
-0.5079368352890015,
-0.07196106016635895,
0.13695330917835236,
0.16328421235084534,
-0.5816059112548828,
0.6512458920478821,
0.9210039973258972,
0.6272789239883423,
0.40234071016311646,
0.10378635674715042,
0.7123319506645203,
-0.7041177153587341,
0.7665222883224487,
0.28785794973373413,
-0.7143233418464661,
0.4589165449142456,
-0.10133806616067886,
0.48291757702827454,
1.0624403953552246,
0.7815091013908386,
-0.3948494791984558,
-0.8481162786483765,
-0.310332715511322,
-0.670088529586792,
0.28599756956100464,
0.20098525285720825,
-0.2784518897533417,
-0.17854611575603485,
0.24219907820224762,
0.615745484828949,
0.17463910579681396,
-0.6191613078117371,
-0.12528660893440247,
-0.170366570353508,
-0.42391037940979004,
-0.2945198714733124,
0.19517771899700165,
-0.13975675404071808,
-0.5416725873947144,
0.7088063359260559,
-0.5257631540298462,
0.001410412136465311,
0.21665100753307343,
-0.40808677673339844,
0.0756445974111557,
0.17855684459209442,
0.8331413865089417,
0.857062816619873,
-0.23701484501361847,
0.28925853967666626,
0.2623009979724884,
-0.5957872271537781,
-0.21752648055553436,
0.1914806365966797,
-0.18191714584827423,
0.30148354172706604,
0.6049035787582397,
0.9342061281204224,
0.44312238693237305,
-0.7498286366462708,
0.09586275368928909,
0.04334172606468201,
-0.4232006072998047,
0.24119296669960022,
-0.0992022231221199,
-0.005926886573433876,
0.0024581633042544127,
0.5520443916320801,
0.43763622641563416,
0.4877721071243286,
-0.1964305341243744,
0.5094805955886841,
0.13683301210403442,
-0.2484036237001419,
-0.5971755981445312,
0.7739128470420837,
-0.0823209285736084,
-0.014879572205245495,
0.44297125935554504,
-0.11899525672197342,
-0.1427963376045227,
0.5217309594154358,
0.7386610507965088,
0.7084518074989319,
-0.20565488934516907,
0.5021626353263855,
0.4830828011035919,
0.19536830484867096,
0.01693505235016346,
0.08980786055326462,
0.1134248599410057,
-0.5506640672683716,
-0.8128811120986938,
-0.6416701674461365,
-0.4009452760219574,
-0.17087338864803314,
-0.7394666075706482,
-0.07739699631929398,
-0.08308152109384537,
-0.019938664510846138,
0.548653781414032,
0.0362451896071434,
-0.48028022050857544,
-0.020818796008825302,
0.1166921928524971,
1.104824423789978,
-1.1938776969909668,
1.1436679363250732,
0.5707454085350037,
0.11363688856363297,
-0.14898943901062012,
-0.24220478534698486,
0.041312143206596375,
-0.2644619941711426,
1.1464189291000366,
0.22852014005184174,
-0.22421042621135712,
-0.15164387226104736,
-0.7542722225189209,
-0.888016939163208,
0.7651883363723755,
0.3099265396595001,
-0.750124454498291,
0.1735507696866989,
0.3274269104003906,
0.8049638271331787,
-0.7922825217247009,
0.32692405581474304,
0.7513940334320068,
0.642887532711029,
0.1416502743959427,
-0.7480336427688599,
0.04265614226460457,
-0.562917947769165,
0.11795098334550858,
-0.11999170482158661,
-0.2267378568649292,
0.6181827783584595,
-0.12127711623907089,
-0.11245710402727127,
0.12765367329120636,
0.935408890247345,
0.6775192618370056,
0.6537191867828369,
0.46955206990242004,
0.28816381096839905,
0.9327313899993896,
0.03464973345398903,
0.8420588374137878,
-0.263337105512619,
0.0953155905008316,
1.0698682069778442,
-0.8338733911514282,
1.0146845579147339,
0.7821756601333618,
-0.0910920724272728,
0.5006957054138184,
0.740595281124115,
-0.2995063066482544,
0.6063356399536133,
0.2264033854007721,
-0.5074378252029419,
-0.07003088295459747,
-0.4297610819339752,
-0.2857835590839386,
0.09035404026508331,
0.41450822353363037,
-0.15711979568004608,
-0.18521787226200104,
0.3787634074687958,
-0.09090474247932434,
0.09494046866893768,
0.09544264525175095,
0.3634485900402069,
0.05331508815288544,
-0.6911252737045288,
0.4803333580493927,
-0.24241812527179718,
0.7466551661491394,
-0.5269591212272644,
-0.16528385877609253,
-0.06419779360294342,
-0.043839193880558014,
-0.2568170726299286,
-0.5200552344322205,
0.4002154767513275,
0.0012794830836355686,
-0.41928523778915405,
-0.0786135122179985,
0.515003502368927,
-0.5659624934196472,
-0.7653339505195618,
0.22876615822315216,
0.26349079608917236,
0.22941988706588745,
0.2776797115802765,
-0.7684547901153564,
-0.10183539986610413,
0.15025174617767334,
-0.14859023690223694,
0.37714293599128723,
0.23873542249202728,
-0.3795580565929413,
0.5510318875312805,
0.7416430115699768,
0.07256922125816345,
0.29978325963020325,
0.3351465165615082,
0.7558392882347107,
-0.43893399834632874,
-0.2459368258714676,
-0.4930238723754883,
0.25587162375450134,
-0.4109438955783844,
-0.5682500600814819,
0.9584289789199829,
0.7927667498588562,
0.5202733874320984,
-0.3716473877429962,
0.8140109181404114,
0.002062859944999218,
0.4376111924648285,
-0.3940904140472412,
0.5197800397872925,
-0.21470917761325836,
0.0292161013931036,
-0.13712795078754425,
-0.8003050684928894,
-0.810305118560791,
0.305393785238266,
-0.09279964119195938,
-0.29487645626068115,
0.9253965616226196,
0.6925700902938843,
-0.021461686119437218,
0.5224146246910095,
0.05157165974378586,
0.2674734890460968,
0.10936672985553741,
0.5301643013954163,
0.6424636840820312,
-0.2551952302455902,
0.09256003797054291,
-0.09407314658164978,
-0.17201422154903412,
0.09932137280702591,
-0.8815250396728516,
-0.7381035685539246,
-0.31354662775993347,
-0.8256539702415466,
0.06086267903447151,
0.4431084990501404,
0.8152865767478943,
0.8632382154464722,
-1.4096430540084839,
-0.43758487701416016,
-0.33106714487075806,
-0.014495646581053734,
-0.6403075456619263,
-0.28187111020088196,
0.299495667219162,
-0.3847220540046692,
-0.7787480354309082,
1.1124614477157593,
0.2630080580711365,
-0.29687103629112244,
0.09226786345243454,
0.023966824635863304,
-0.8302428126335144,
-0.07961024343967438,
0.5753540396690369,
0.4662102460861206,
-0.7415180802345276,
-0.06660134345293045,
0.268858402967453,
-0.007305470295250416,
0.005213449709117413,
0.7934159636497498,
-0.43789422512054443,
0.11859174817800522,
0.38343575596809387,
0.7995997667312622,
0.514347493648529,
-0.27117031812667847,
0.6577587127685547,
-0.8285965919494629,
-0.025926226750016212,
0.281202495098114,
0.055403728038072586,
0.2260170727968216,
-0.2686452865600586,
0.7700711488723755,
0.35541877150535583,
-0.46936869621276855,
-0.9904612302780151,
-0.15263894200325012,
-1.0550401210784912,
-0.5397343039512634,
0.822496235370636,
-0.12449566274881363,
-0.5595014691352844,
-0.3843396306037903,
0.21113507449626923,
0.06821259111166,
-0.16482040286064148,
0.46944499015808105,
0.5811884999275208,
-0.11298959702253342,
-0.10914044082164764,
-0.825630784034729,
0.5987486243247986,
0.5608054995536804,
-0.8515617251396179,
-0.13838890194892883,
0.21541255712509155,
0.19377422332763672,
0.3268798589706421,
-0.022150667384266853,
0.06489672511816025,
0.07055450975894928,
-0.18299835920333862,
0.18203012645244598,
0.15866447985172272,
-0.42471346259117126,
-0.27369222044944763,
0.23279869556427002,
-0.23663702607154846,
-0.00045400881208479404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07989v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07989v2
|
Any2Point: Empowering Any-modality Large Models for Efficient 3D Understanding
| 2024-04-11T17:59:45 | 2024-05-31T01:36:53 |
Yiwen Tang, Ray Zhang, Jiaming Liu, Zoey Guo, Dong Wang, Zhigang Wang, Bin Zhao, Shanghang Zhang, Peng Gao, Hongsheng Li, Xuelong Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Large foundation models have recently emerged as a prominent focus of
interest, attaining superior performance in widespread scenarios. Due to the
scarcity of 3D data, many efforts have been made to adapt pre-trained
transformers from vision to 3D domains. However, such 2D-to-3D approaches are
still limited, due to the potential loss of spatial geometries and high
computation cost. More importantly, their frameworks are mainly designed for 2D
models, lacking a general any-to-3D paradigm. In this paper, we introduce
Any2Point, a parameter-efficient method to empower any-modality large models
(vision, language, audio) for 3D understanding. Given a frozen transformer from
any source modality, we propose a 3D-to-any (1D or 2D) virtual projection
strategy that correlates the input 3D points to the original 1D or 2D positions
within the source modality. This mechanism enables us to assign each 3D token
with a positional encoding paired with the pre-trained model, which avoids 3D
geometry loss caused by the true projection and better motivates the
transformer for 3D learning with 1D/2D positional priors. Then, within each
transformer block, we insert an any-to-3D guided adapter module for
parameter-efficient fine-tuning. The adapter incorporates prior spatial
knowledge from the source modality to guide the local feature aggregation of 3D
tokens, compelling the semantic adaption of any-modality transformers. We
conduct extensive experiments to showcase the effectiveness and efficiency of
our method. Code and models are released at
https://github.com/Ivan-Tang-3D/Any2Point.
|
[
-0.2545391917228699,
-0.5189244151115417,
0.8575851321220398,
0.049805041402578354,
-0.2916218340396881,
-0.7891597747802734,
0.05074132978916168,
-0.4060530960559845,
-0.05046982690691948,
0.6049992442131042,
-0.19636821746826172,
-0.5428755879402161,
-0.37893974781036377,
-0.1318158507347107,
-0.3122446537017822,
0.3862933814525604,
-0.05323232710361481,
-0.0817912220954895,
-0.0686650425195694,
-0.1611584722995758,
-0.2941776216030121,
-0.22059403359889984,
-0.707003653049469,
-0.1417936533689499,
0.3633037805557251,
0.6589454412460327,
0.7359644770622253,
1.0391572713851929,
0.1300709992647171,
0.30891889333724976,
0.063911072909832,
-0.08482025563716888,
-0.7735757827758789,
0.005233238451182842,
-0.4661512076854706,
-0.64366215467453,
-0.40241244435310364,
-0.15949797630310059,
0.6806713938713074,
0.8885138034820557,
-0.03386234492063522,
0.06997222453355789,
-0.10421955585479736,
0.5438243746757507,
-0.7200021743774414,
-0.057411085814237595,
-0.6088851094245911,
0.33550673723220825,
0.054078906774520874,
-0.17301148176193237,
-0.2274426817893982,
-0.12401339411735535,
0.30507177114486694,
-1.0586432218551636,
0.3882901966571808,
-0.03500305488705635,
0.5581239461898804,
0.37304192781448364,
-0.6523366570472717,
0.28495776653289795,
-0.6618335247039795,
0.6253911852836609,
-0.19091472029685974,
1.0019481182098389,
0.2101397067308426,
0.6684235334396362,
0.06944151967763901,
-0.6965451240539551,
-0.46615108847618103,
0.13718488812446594,
-0.08045630156993866,
0.4389181137084961,
-0.04191289469599724,
-0.032228734344244,
0.18056778609752655,
0.03906062990427017,
-0.6779332756996155,
0.17962060868740082,
-0.23188640177249908,
0.04149027168750763,
0.3346917927265167,
0.003813220653682947,
-0.20640626549720764,
-0.5685809254646301,
-0.6970731019973755,
-0.47054898738861084,
-0.4940141439437866,
0.13784997165203094,
-0.11655241250991821,
0.26154211163520813,
-0.46894708275794983,
0.6869322061538696,
0.12174946069717407,
1.0003100633621216,
0.2894686460494995,
-0.15147319436073303,
-0.13992737233638763,
-0.22803089022636414,
-0.24664682149887085,
-0.06376604735851288,
0.4285467267036438,
0.16406629979610443,
-0.0929715633392334,
-0.09300659596920013,
-0.07305246591567993,
-0.4296158254146576,
0.4651152491569519,
-0.9186104536056519,
-0.38982999324798584,
0.05175841599702835,
-0.5514068603515625,
-0.0347505584359169,
0.0808638259768486,
-0.7037314176559448,
-0.8387420177459717,
-0.30740389227867126,
0.5378085374832153,
-0.42154765129089355,
-0.5638851523399353,
0.30365169048309326,
-0.2494836002588272,
0.40993019938468933,
0.5200890302658081,
-0.8844286203384399,
-0.14964629709720612,
0.4806745946407318,
0.8854110240936279,
-0.10218853503465652,
-0.18022796511650085,
-0.15779010951519012,
0.4758269488811493,
-0.526624321937561,
0.8039906620979309,
-0.32748669385910034,
-0.6035762429237366,
-0.08609984070062637,
-0.37282469868659973,
-0.2286423295736313,
-0.3860752284526825,
0.43152448534965515,
-0.3314577043056488,
0.23440103232860565,
-0.12322840839624405,
-0.22456280887126923,
-0.5806564092636108,
0.29239529371261597,
-0.6857935190200806,
0.47792282700538635,
0.6278225779533386,
-0.33595529198646545,
0.3767211139202118,
-0.8662701845169067,
-0.23245856165885925,
-0.24405232071876526,
-0.6361863613128662,
-0.2261815071105957,
0.33947038650512695,
0.1790481060743332,
0.5794864296913147,
-0.49509117007255554,
-0.1476019024848938,
-0.245369553565979,
-0.08912014216184616,
-0.1969902366399765,
-0.49822714924812317,
0.6208857893943787,
-0.0255380030721426,
-0.26584914326667786,
0.12443224340677261,
-0.8827975392341614,
-0.35305243730545044,
0.32940053939819336,
-0.15634658932685852,
-0.01740371435880661,
-0.12273748219013214,
0.3207193911075592,
0.3790440559387207,
0.0680447369813919,
-0.3372337520122528,
0.08836563676595688,
-0.3278588354587555,
0.3088885247707367,
0.4748634696006775,
-0.17401190102100372,
0.9254618883132935,
-0.14524683356285095,
0.4893578588962555,
-0.16044925153255463,
0.17066168785095215,
-0.323801726102829,
-0.2784962058067322,
-0.4765164256095886,
-0.8072522878646851,
-0.01170631218701601,
0.29204878211021423,
-0.7349067330360413,
0.4911627173423767,
-0.7999165058135986,
-0.4416973292827606,
-0.23744860291481018,
0.03367798402905464,
0.09092151373624802,
0.7300066351890564,
0.3722373843193054,
0.12919719517230988,
-0.5041754841804504,
-0.7561481595039368,
0.12895087897777557,
-0.15715056657791138,
-0.8289756178855896,
0.3426300883293152,
0.16562321782112122,
0.20030640065670013,
1.152266502380371,
-0.39206957817077637,
-0.7074319124221802,
-0.1701437532901764,
-0.32167959213256836,
0.25365149974823,
0.5919820070266724,
0.7124710083007812,
-1.0616546869277954,
-0.2287195473909378,
0.11868273466825485,
-0.874748706817627,
0.2300177365541458,
-0.17755013704299927,
-0.29087576270103455,
-0.03127383813261986,
0.5152269601821899,
-0.6593202948570251,
0.35351717472076416,
0.7200223207473755,
-0.7224711775779724,
-0.007406365592032671,
0.1384393721818924,
0.06824637204408646,
-1.1789352893829346,
0.29583942890167236,
-0.11743074655532837,
-0.25365567207336426,
-0.7322647571563721,
-0.036056991666555405,
-0.0073226639069616795,
-0.4655866324901581,
-0.5668565630912781,
0.6892871260643005,
-0.22996586561203003,
-0.03174404427409172,
-0.05361515283584595,
0.6319633722305298,
0.49635621905326843,
0.4782256782054901,
0.5393198728561401,
0.08204758912324905,
0.6208983063697815,
-0.35298335552215576,
0.23466217517852783,
0.597595751285553,
-0.34648820757865906,
0.9101873636245728,
-0.5145607590675354,
0.0648932158946991,
0.06034599617123604,
0.43402838706970215,
-1.0157581567764282,
-0.12436402589082718,
0.178084135055542,
-0.42311546206474304,
0.25658708810806274,
-0.3632219135761261,
-0.19002138078212738,
0.09850625693798065,
-0.22801746428012848,
0.7188246846199036,
0.07919975370168686,
-1.1447794437408447,
1.4300777912139893,
0.010266914032399654,
0.2725434899330139,
-0.09618784487247467,
-0.586046040058136,
-0.0970577821135521,
-0.06157205253839493,
-0.8891087174415588,
0.4330218732357025,
0.21824222803115845,
0.146363765001297,
0.05887353792786598,
-0.4658868908882141,
0.10696928203105927,
-0.15089456737041473,
0.41906875371932983,
0.20374883711338043,
-0.35044240951538086,
-0.1508135050535202,
-0.04495592042803764,
-0.5238306522369385,
-0.052948832511901855,
-0.3726677894592285,
0.33293429017066956,
0.25424012541770935,
-0.41572105884552,
-0.22163362801074982,
0.4748917818069458,
0.8601570129394531,
-0.0770052969455719,
0.4084276854991913,
0.617640495300293,
-0.42333361506462097,
-0.20560839772224426,
-0.566933274269104,
-0.15891556441783905,
-0.4922625422477722,
0.8152559995651245,
-0.8780960440635681,
-0.8410651087760925,
0.30763739347457886,
-0.22154124081134796,
0.1229422315955162,
0.23023833334445953,
0.23965361714363098,
0.14068013429641724,
1.432601809501648,
0.9092391729354858,
0.1387183517217636,
0.4579086899757385,
-0.6049590706825256,
0.43501508235931396,
-0.8444535136222839,
-0.5553840398788452,
-0.3669426441192627,
-0.44424664974212646,
-0.03639661520719528,
-0.7930763959884644,
0.6992958188056946,
0.5360656380653381,
-0.41693776845932007,
0.42491188645362854,
-0.44248324632644653,
0.33514535427093506,
0.24555227160453796,
0.08174531161785126,
0.1929374784231186,
-0.01529935747385025,
-0.08017176389694214,
0.22924953699111938,
-1.167118787765503,
-0.08874014019966125,
0.7732548117637634,
0.43521952629089355,
0.3719503879547119,
0.2765575349330902,
0.04474213719367981,
-0.2527029514312744,
-0.015057994052767754,
-0.8854381442070007,
0.3731003403663635,
-0.11200566589832306,
-0.7226381301879883,
-0.5772998929023743,
-0.3779469430446625,
-0.6610129475593567,
0.6104569435119629,
-0.49329203367233276,
-0.7449513673782349,
0.9311438202857971,
0.28168219327926636,
-0.49164342880249023,
0.7160808444023132,
-0.5625136494636536,
1.0044779777526855,
-0.19707724452018738,
-0.24694892764091492,
-0.10853928327560425,
-0.4732248783111572,
0.3042796552181244,
-0.24583293497562408,
-0.0997534915804863,
-0.07356123626232147,
-0.2871659994125366,
0.40597373247146606,
-0.10750750452280045,
0.620855987071991,
-0.3549211323261261,
-0.40895983576774597,
-0.12116266787052155,
0.5058549642562866,
0.41496923565864563,
0.6066921353340149,
-0.34420815110206604,
0.5785732865333557,
0.13922470808029175,
-0.4713232219219208,
-0.9484481811523438,
0.6738031506538391,
-0.8938990235328674,
-0.3946988880634308,
0.09823841601610184,
-0.7244697213172913,
-0.36146751046180725,
0.13996903598308563,
0.5485645532608032,
0.5526559948921204,
0.031608618795871735,
0.4203246235847473,
0.23297208547592163,
0.03645659610629082,
0.16496576368808746,
0.7598362565040588,
-0.11261950433254242,
-0.24416473507881165,
0.8448969125747681,
-0.37076541781425476,
0.07644661515951157,
0.7788209319114685,
0.13455839455127716,
-0.4836077094078064,
-0.2914571762084961,
-0.5747011303901672,
0.07028839737176895,
-0.7648276686668396,
-0.46926188468933105,
-0.4470074772834778,
-0.07173717767000198,
-0.37337222695350647,
-0.9146750569343567,
-0.8847370147705078,
-0.612302839756012,
-0.25059932470321655,
-0.20323620736598969,
0.292918860912323,
0.4530605375766754,
-0.4531322717666626,
0.22186817228794098,
-0.5073211789131165,
0.7353276014328003,
0.5612561106681824,
0.5121430158615112,
-0.0011754209408536553,
-0.804300844669342,
-0.09985113143920898,
0.032651517540216446,
-0.12428741157054901,
-0.492294579744339,
0.019779346883296967,
0.20969554781913757,
0.28567373752593994,
1.2024798393249512,
-0.04197339341044426,
0.8122190833091736,
-0.4117070138454437,
0.7777121663093567,
0.502685010433197,
-1.0301642417907715,
0.4288133978843689,
-0.19503243267536163,
0.36693525314331055,
0.5082170367240906,
0.4975244998931885,
-0.24558500945568085,
0.22786885499954224,
-0.2524009346961975,
-0.7840408682823181,
0.8428490161895752,
0.05071011558175087,
-0.025696324184536934,
0.3039397895336151,
0.5720230937004089,
0.08893794566392899,
-0.2856982946395874,
-0.32564958930015564,
-0.27324002981185913,
-0.8641254901885986,
0.08464699983596802,
-0.19251227378845215,
-0.09970378130674362,
-0.3453300893306732,
-0.44241419434547424,
0.21852272748947144,
-0.17505314946174622,
0.34636619687080383,
0.19079196453094482,
-0.02593042328953743,
-0.2509758174419403,
-0.22082282602787018,
0.41438382863998413,
0.939275324344635,
-0.13777312636375427,
0.26563456654548645,
0.28936079144477844,
-0.3521057069301605,
-0.036421287804841995,
0.21985578536987305,
-0.008329811505973339,
0.045746512711048126,
0.39083191752433777,
0.9333106279373169,
0.3586618900299072,
-0.4001390039920807,
0.6690776348114014,
0.07376979291439056,
-0.5687907934188843,
-0.14963790774345398,
-0.14517176151275635,
-0.29166626930236816,
0.5908722877502441,
0.4403986930847168,
0.2581680119037628,
0.08811400085687637,
-0.21204859018325806,
-0.020886028185486794,
0.22309176623821259,
-0.7290964722633362,
-0.41832971572875977,
0.8673280477523804,
0.27035579085350037,
-0.10053341090679169,
0.6485094428062439,
0.26034465432167053,
-0.30474573373794556,
0.2176840603351593,
0.729735791683197,
0.7857405543327332,
-0.35670775175094604,
0.1366337090730667,
0.4080478847026825,
-0.05189767852425575,
0.12946589291095734,
-0.12369594722986221,
-0.4589553475379944,
-1.0018640756607056,
-0.4291575849056244,
-0.4828953146934509,
-0.23921912908554077,
0.09858737885951996,
-0.6237452626228333,
0.3981509506702423,
-0.4100434482097626,
0.13776130974292755,
-0.19049127399921417,
-0.41114866733551025,
-0.7399821281433105,
0.27555426955223083,
0.296783447265625,
1.0003724098205566,
-0.6862397193908691,
0.6348427534103394,
0.6703384518623352,
-0.03868068382143974,
-0.7024722695350647,
-0.42184731364250183,
0.12303612381219864,
-0.8679561018943787,
0.2937307357788086,
-0.06654807925224304,
-0.3749312162399292,
0.32649797201156616,
-0.25648176670074463,
-1.0132828950881958,
1.2603330612182617,
0.4284699261188507,
-0.43692725896835327,
-0.06482402980327606,
0.36817508935928345,
0.0665392205119133,
-0.23915454745292664,
0.31256401538848877,
0.6939824819564819,
0.7626311182975769,
0.4979936182498932,
-0.5373880863189697,
0.28382784128189087,
-0.32471558451652527,
0.2924722135066986,
0.19949473440647125,
-0.1542312502861023,
0.38806232810020447,
-0.2951720952987671,
-0.26136061549186707,
0.2273922860622406,
0.6293718814849854,
0.27211636304855347,
-0.12078756093978882,
1.024648904800415,
0.36559587717056274,
0.12679560482501984,
-0.06596450507640839,
0.9584985971450806,
-0.40878748893737793,
-0.014711168594658375,
0.7587693333625793,
-0.06153556704521179,
0.7960828542709351,
0.5054110884666443,
0.23480939865112305,
0.08685893565416336,
0.35024845600128174,
-0.12871673703193665,
0.6347193717956543,
0.04900723323225975,
-0.027287758886814117,
-0.6536890268325806,
-0.04268936812877655,
-0.3886263966560364,
0.8827786445617676,
0.3944680392742157,
-0.026420028880238533,
-0.3534201681613922,
0.3055895268917084,
-0.15404894948005676,
0.12429971992969513,
-0.17291371524333954,
0.5574740767478943,
0.18735115230083466,
-0.20566099882125854,
0.8715808987617493,
0.0443812794983387,
0.35095706582069397,
-0.8194382786750793,
-0.22014804184436798,
-0.31020841002464294,
0.01606394350528717,
-0.365872859954834,
-0.3150237798690796,
0.13381460309028625,
-0.27339738607406616,
-0.41913914680480957,
-0.27195364236831665,
0.07678793370723724,
-0.32683882117271423,
-0.44156137108802795,
0.32405972480773926,
0.27840349078178406,
-0.09327107667922974,
-0.44771698117256165,
-0.4845324158668518,
0.004870537668466568,
-0.2859167456626892,
-0.33903568983078003,
0.27218329906463623,
0.5491149425506592,
0.12484383583068848,
0.3243219554424286,
0.638276219367981,
-0.012594767846167088,
-0.26388809084892273,
0.11151719093322754,
0.7841688990592957,
-0.39593902230262756,
-0.39140015840530396,
-0.23538760840892792,
0.5229184031486511,
0.056733012199401855,
-0.4801173806190491,
0.6953418254852295,
0.5939671993255615,
0.9216079711914062,
0.055052220821380615,
0.4577544331550598,
-0.15662476420402527,
0.373953253030777,
-0.5728793740272522,
0.6930227875709534,
-0.8595142364501953,
0.28200510144233704,
0.038505613803863525,
-1.4350861310958862,
-0.7064700722694397,
1.0011632442474365,
-0.2679853141307831,
0.09206954389810562,
0.6142311692237854,
0.8834096789360046,
-0.3586842119693756,
-0.13331338763237,
0.829162061214447,
0.38331103324890137,
0.33530592918395996,
0.49445754289627075,
0.6645830869674683,
-0.292501300573349,
0.9126650094985962,
-0.39208686351776123,
-0.3128620982170105,
-0.06161060929298401,
-0.8174474239349365,
-0.8364318609237671,
-0.5139437317848206,
-0.08623755723237991,
-0.1312815397977829,
-0.10639537125825882,
0.7461585402488708,
1.0929011106491089,
-0.6932971477508545,
-0.19311578571796417,
0.002357231918722391,
-0.06739288568496704,
-0.2608957290649414,
-0.14433273673057556,
0.7310858368873596,
0.18296335637569427,
-0.7028960585594177,
0.7417710423469543,
0.4007812738418579,
-0.2938254773616791,
-0.15501409769058228,
0.04882674664258957,
0.20332293212413788,
0.022241996601223946,
0.9120975732803345,
0.44322073459625244,
-0.5428083539009094,
-0.5387218594551086,
-0.03597656637430191,
0.19590625166893005,
0.053641125559806824,
0.9437127709388733,
-0.5761594176292419,
0.6390653848648071,
0.5320546627044678,
0.3346424996852875,
0.7069215774536133,
0.1324806958436966,
0.7861050963401794,
-0.4308263063430786,
0.3350589871406555,
0.18950624763965607,
0.29377058148384094,
0.4068254232406616,
-0.07890046387910843,
0.4841040074825287,
-0.14577935636043549,
-0.20402821898460388,
-0.4565926492214203,
0.39921095967292786,
-1.1530917882919312,
-0.3708081841468811,
1.1731961965560913,
-0.09535741806030273,
-0.010110689327120781,
-0.2170926332473755,
-0.21105234324932098,
0.1270170658826828,
-0.03653885796666145,
0.9168072938919067,
-0.3615046441555023,
-0.06679656356573105,
-0.20939941704273224,
-0.4045523703098297,
0.5747861266136169,
0.39113491773605347,
-0.4335913062095642,
-0.23354752361774445,
0.3196363151073456,
-0.017633913084864616,
0.22529999911785126,
0.19614087045192719,
-0.3184860050678253,
0.3206050992012024,
0.05420564115047455,
0.09006580710411072,
-0.32455500960350037,
-0.5799820423126221,
-0.5921971201896667,
0.34547239542007446,
-0.2692815661430359,
-0.21831835806369781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07982v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07982v3
|
Language Imbalance Can Boost Cross-lingual Generalisation
| 2024-04-11T17:58:05 | 2024-05-13T13:30:35 |
Anton Schäfer, Shauli Ravfogel, Thomas Hofmann, Tiago Pimentel, Imanol Schlag
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
Multilinguality is crucial for extending recent advancements in language
modelling to diverse linguistic communities. To maintain high performance while
representing multiple languages, multilingual models ideally align
representations, allowing what is learned in one language to generalise to
others. Prior research has emphasised the importance of parallel data and
shared vocabulary elements as key factors for such alignment. In this study, we
investigate an unintuitive novel driver of cross-lingual generalisation:
language imbalance. In controlled experiments on perfectly equivalent cloned
languages, we observe that the existence of a predominant language during
training boosts the performance of less frequent languages and leads to
stronger alignment of model representations across languages. Furthermore, we
find that this trend is amplified with scale: with large enough models or long
enough training, we observe that bilingual training data with a 90/10 language
split yields better performance on both languages than a balanced 50/50 split.
Building on these insights, we design training schemes that can improve
performance in all cloned languages, even without altering the training data.
As we extend our analysis to real languages, we find that infrequent languages
still benefit from frequent ones, yet whether language imbalance causes
cross-lingual generalisation there is not conclusive.
|
[
-0.46911272406578064,
-0.3771198093891144,
-0.08655141294002533,
0.6103086471557617,
-0.08667697757482529,
0.42868179082870483,
-0.15502023696899414,
-0.6227182745933533,
0.6800585389137268,
0.2519652843475342,
-0.2434762865304947,
0.127488374710083,
-0.6946395039558411,
0.06894250959157944,
-0.23998214304447174,
0.8435373306274414,
-0.021642131730914116,
0.6420430541038513,
-0.1561487913131714,
-0.9938027262687683,
-0.5633196830749512,
-0.7506003379821777,
-0.32711777091026306,
-0.8599762320518494,
0.4901282489299774,
0.30502834916114807,
0.8920083045959473,
0.7496182322502136,
0.11162824928760529,
0.25229978561401367,
0.14285434782505035,
0.13999676704406738,
-0.6483812928199768,
-0.02949054352939129,
-0.2207091897726059,
-0.6977189779281616,
-0.4294280707836151,
-0.30765172839164734,
1.0099204778671265,
1.0813188552856445,
-0.1514778584241867,
-0.1296377182006836,
0.2367919534444809,
0.6135929822921753,
-0.5765368938446045,
-0.1531122326850891,
-0.6712676286697388,
-0.04057953506708145,
-0.4288325309753418,
-0.1403147429227829,
-0.01646270602941513,
0.27443927526474,
-0.01861434616148472,
-0.8103737235069275,
0.244890034198761,
0.10156013071537018,
0.9065544605255127,
-0.12871937453746796,
-0.36353182792663574,
-0.13728053867816925,
-0.5504656434059143,
0.957175612449646,
-0.4011573791503906,
0.42380931973457336,
-0.09160157293081284,
-0.0031506961677223444,
0.4448142945766449,
0.04005273059010506,
-0.5517941117286682,
0.09380008280277252,
-0.10197415202856064,
-0.1016014814376831,
-0.1499948352575302,
-0.2495926022529602,
0.257506400346756,
0.4903301000595093,
-0.6614250540733337,
0.4431236684322357,
-0.2978474199771881,
-0.24260973930358887,
0.26888519525527954,
0.06086772680282593,
0.8697582483291626,
0.25164198875427246,
-0.3618159890174866,
-0.18433208763599396,
-0.8896808624267578,
-0.0018708412535488605,
0.7051766514778137,
0.3214566111564636,
-0.2532328963279724,
0.5613181591033936,
0.004781884606927633,
0.750361442565918,
0.10819822549819946,
-0.060802292078733444,
0.5567221641540527,
-0.6018062829971313,
0.22013936936855316,
0.21428035199642181,
0.5801181197166443,
0.43972858786582947,
0.876124382019043,
-0.1940053105354309,
-0.023180540651082993,
0.08791174739599228,
0.15034233033657074,
-0.6344570517539978,
-0.0501774325966835,
-0.17221328616142273,
-0.06449586898088455,
-0.12532341480255127,
0.11563071608543396,
-0.5052444338798523,
-0.011186010204255581,
-0.31988298892974854,
0.18398244678974152,
-0.3338823616504669,
-0.7041031122207642,
0.13085341453552246,
-0.39128896594047546,
0.2206597477197647,
0.0016221170080825686,
-1.3535274267196655,
0.2508564889431,
0.8133079409599304,
0.77291339635849,
-0.37738844752311707,
-0.8810324668884277,
-0.4005008637905121,
0.3048398792743683,
-0.44013944268226624,
0.5313661694526672,
-0.5320143699645996,
-0.07256969064474106,
-0.032297272235155106,
0.1340976506471634,
-0.32831501960754395,
-0.9215363264083862,
-0.09048868715763092,
-0.3540020287036896,
0.2940066456794739,
-0.41360387206077576,
-0.2229594886302948,
0.06516911834478378,
0.13361835479736328,
-0.7954301238059998,
0.9016467928886414,
0.17251411080360413,
-0.9703462719917297,
0.8013217449188232,
-0.10255301743745804,
-0.7397674322128296,
-0.006793133914470673,
-0.21824082732200623,
-0.41082173585891724,
0.14530706405639648,
0.24318194389343262,
-0.005462838802486658,
-0.17338413000106812,
0.17026415467262268,
-0.5357003808021545,
-0.4214743673801422,
0.1384580433368683,
-0.27570202946662903,
0.8351231217384338,
0.07571867108345032,
-0.36803293228149414,
-0.20649227499961853,
-0.21291905641555786,
0.0026640919968485832,
-0.029704874381422997,
-0.14912894368171692,
-0.8258690237998962,
-0.367275208234787,
0.09272396564483643,
0.24874573945999146,
0.20285964012145996,
-0.5527777671813965,
0.1437762826681137,
-0.4196658134460449,
0.08114714175462723,
0.48122137784957886,
-0.34839174151420593,
0.854375422000885,
-0.6808331608772278,
0.6826372146606445,
0.43115973472595215,
-0.28016582131385803,
-0.007029722910374403,
-0.5367673635482788,
-0.5472260117530823,
-0.36425742506980896,
0.3790798783302307,
0.7740113139152527,
-0.49619051814079285,
-0.03212714195251465,
-0.7034118175506592,
-0.09966740012168884,
-1.0748481750488281,
0.7794463634490967,
0.5552489161491394,
0.051495492458343506,
0.21661895513534546,
-0.5390231013298035,
-0.4250473082065582,
-1.2464874982833862,
-0.5720991492271423,
0.08855239301919937,
0.09923806041479111,
0.1430397927761078,
-0.008048759773373604,
-0.34963178634643555,
0.8025274276733398,
0.01828583888709545,
-0.11307770013809204,
-0.5040887594223022,
0.1854405254125595,
-0.16085734963417053,
0.7017686367034912,
0.969496488571167,
-0.8381090760231018,
-0.7462698817253113,
0.5479564070701599,
-0.7261607646942139,
-0.45964860916137695,
-0.1448502391576767,
-0.049791429191827774,
0.32818174362182617,
0.4177416265010834,
-0.292026162147522,
-0.06560508906841278,
0.7824735045433044,
-0.027461111545562744,
0.15367968380451202,
-0.258293479681015,
0.0991116389632225,
-0.8666425347328186,
0.049752749502658844,
-0.10540344566106796,
-0.1459001749753952,
-0.5790261626243591,
0.12090784311294556,
0.20709878206253052,
-0.024639321491122246,
-0.3601676821708679,
0.7193074226379395,
-0.5803011059761047,
-0.013357339426875114,
-0.3574092388153076,
0.08824510872364044,
0.005068526137620211,
0.2977316081523895,
-0.09006039798259735,
0.6773604154586792,
0.7107756733894348,
-0.3042028248310089,
0.10850223898887634,
-0.13201077282428741,
-0.16607901453971863,
0.6471715569496155,
-0.5577307939529419,
-0.4034459590911865,
-0.13541758060455322,
-0.153058260679245,
-0.8098961114883423,
-0.23702050745487213,
-0.1789248138666153,
-0.2697053849697113,
0.7038710713386536,
-0.09884580224752426,
-0.42297255992889404,
-0.25191357731819153,
-0.15631458163261414,
0.9600943922996521,
0.2765143811702728,
-0.6741304397583008,
0.5944916009902954,
0.5133073329925537,
-0.07053042948246002,
-0.9008471369743347,
-0.9943482279777527,
-0.12269135564565659,
-0.356447696685791,
-0.7288937568664551,
0.2721130847930908,
0.08104289323091507,
-0.5375580191612244,
-0.01233131904155016,
-0.23837876319885254,
0.019334709271788597,
0.1542832851409912,
0.009648227132856846,
-0.12525995075702667,
-0.3750678300857544,
-0.025870751589536667,
0.09300259500741959,
0.03455548733472824,
-0.16942693293094635,
-0.5087425112724304,
0.7550150156021118,
-0.023487094789743423,
-0.4554671049118042,
-0.06488978862762451,
0.6267673969268799,
0.9351795315742493,
-0.0998147502541542,
0.738531231880188,
0.4213259816169739,
-0.1013609915971756,
-0.2927461862564087,
-0.5258224606513977,
0.0940379872918129,
-0.408224880695343,
0.4146166145801544,
-0.47508177161216736,
-0.8485156893730164,
0.7845379710197449,
0.25752681493759155,
-0.03932598978281021,
0.3569052517414093,
0.5874907374382019,
0.15075603127479553,
1.079932689666748,
0.7449158430099487,
-0.6043691635131836,
0.6148412227630615,
0.10655421763658524,
0.07049990445375443,
-0.44072264432907104,
0.004101369064301252,
-0.20398521423339844,
-0.3370863199234009,
-0.7871827483177185,
-0.509814441204071,
0.07744967937469482,
0.13756020367145538,
0.1347818374633789,
0.1988644152879715,
-0.037868764251470566,
0.6413530111312866,
0.5891852974891663,
-0.15024659037590027,
0.32435014843940735,
0.3524850606918335,
-0.5531538724899292,
-0.08153752237558365,
-1.0714088678359985,
-0.10880517959594727,
1.186821460723877,
0.14214681088924408,
0.8719379901885986,
0.032581813633441925,
0.6705372929573059,
-0.007710326928645372,
0.30200669169425964,
-0.4559018313884735,
0.10277007520198822,
-0.3664122223854065,
-0.6520515084266663,
-0.2378501445055008,
-0.5058782696723938,
-0.9430922865867615,
0.6464548110961914,
-0.10136527568101883,
-0.21979151666164398,
0.22476427257061005,
0.32947221398353577,
0.04797039180994034,
0.37074723839759827,
-0.808931827545166,
1.0050513744354248,
-0.4908588230609894,
-0.6265451312065125,
-0.46236249804496765,
-0.42475077509880066,
0.4032459557056427,
-0.42192307114601135,
0.4238255023956299,
0.1107042133808136,
0.09508254379034042,
0.4033827483654022,
-0.4302229881286621,
0.7249601483345032,
0.018878810107707977,
-0.2771630585193634,
0.010413690470159054,
-0.08815546333789825,
0.1421881765127182,
-0.06886593252420425,
0.16129623353481293,
0.3208657503128052,
-0.10682172328233719,
-1.1286489963531494,
-0.516912043094635,
1.061078667640686,
-0.8910831212997437,
-0.5689370632171631,
-0.3394864499568939,
-0.76341712474823,
-0.2651227116584778,
0.14452005922794342,
0.43937283754348755,
0.23981806635856628,
-0.29730749130249023,
0.14932647347450256,
0.5579379200935364,
-0.03608199208974838,
0.16385196149349213,
0.45661818981170654,
-0.46753841638565063,
-0.4527968466281891,
1.1147781610488892,
0.21729636192321777,
0.8829677700996399,
0.5099923014640808,
0.0008895202772691846,
0.07593284547328949,
-0.12780216336250305,
-0.6703442931175232,
0.3133400082588196,
-0.3779582679271698,
0.2223334163427353,
-0.7870537042617798,
0.20374922454357147,
-0.5039602518081665,
-0.28994524478912354,
-0.2885527014732361,
-0.7335062623023987,
0.169377401471138,
-0.09117216616868973,
-0.1370498538017273,
0.5598369240760803,
-0.42303532361984253,
0.4605879783630371,
-0.4486558139324188,
0.4048771262168884,
0.4849858582019806,
0.18467719852924347,
0.12062755227088928,
-0.3005298376083374,
-0.46704229712486267,
0.3108818233013153,
-0.23303364217281342,
-0.5322942137718201,
0.332337349653244,
0.3485124707221985,
0.8831436038017273,
0.49476611614227295,
-0.5302127003669739,
0.8079618811607361,
-0.3405744433403015,
0.4276624321937561,
0.22344325482845306,
-0.7911798357963562,
-0.18264418840408325,
-0.45312273502349854,
0.6450979113578796,
0.4190102815628052,
0.354950875043869,
-0.8428350687026978,
-0.7601920366287231,
-0.5057730674743652,
-0.7787117958068848,
0.6577744483947754,
-0.026894139125943184,
0.17074857652187347,
0.07435927540063858,
-0.23073865473270416,
0.2235795557498932,
0.1499256044626236,
-0.9665483236312866,
-0.2689542770385742,
-0.32990050315856934,
-0.11101078987121582,
-0.33058053255081177,
-0.20576149225234985,
-0.2313605695962906,
-0.2632772624492645,
0.4319847822189331,
-0.18230147659778595,
-0.09923961758613586,
-0.29245007038116455,
-0.47432658076286316,
-0.4759727716445923,
0.13141995668411255,
0.5281475186347961,
0.674017608165741,
0.09304218739271164,
0.1370537430047989,
0.22033846378326416,
-0.4192278981208801,
0.17575788497924805,
-0.053900379687547684,
-0.13464176654815674,
0.1022958979010582,
0.5218306183815002,
0.6212911605834961,
0.4582817852497101,
-0.6030750870704651,
0.5099735856056213,
0.22032848000526428,
-0.0647675022482872,
0.22240281105041504,
-0.042501721531152725,
0.20190516114234924,
-0.003493141382932663,
0.3205620348453522,
0.22585351765155792,
-0.43406009674072266,
-0.7139794826507568,
0.3192965090274811,
0.7963842153549194,
-0.05648990347981453,
-0.371661901473999,
0.5524255633354187,
0.1414836347103119,
0.05203428864479065,
0.486118882894516,
-0.009474069811403751,
-0.8344351053237915,
0.7568680047988892,
0.7186782956123352,
0.6928178071975708,
-0.3382391333580017,
0.0517534539103508,
0.19222426414489746,
0.5460487604141235,
-0.2248304784297943,
0.26999375224113464,
-0.1303909868001938,
-0.9249333143234253,
-0.31170231103897095,
-0.715099573135376,
-0.2787778973579407,
-0.25561684370040894,
-0.682870090007782,
0.3020590543746948,
-0.033904992043972015,
0.14886832237243652,
-0.1658349633216858,
-0.40434005856513977,
-0.5493988394737244,
-0.09510302543640137,
0.3489244878292084,
0.5829307436943054,
-1.2154836654663086,
1.0772981643676758,
0.7498303651809692,
-0.05392257496714592,
-0.6013701558113098,
0.06315407156944275,
-0.07434488832950592,
-1.016377329826355,
0.7519845962524414,
0.22172358632087708,
0.013935543596744537,
-0.3298858404159546,
-0.0690690204501152,
-0.7946566343307495,
0.5478906631469727,
0.5161389112472534,
-0.6879302263259888,
-0.14132830500602722,
0.7737301588058472,
0.7152361273765564,
-0.634821355342865,
0.011256127618253231,
0.24461813271045685,
0.24275389313697815,
-0.10907196998596191,
-1.1879687309265137,
-0.15756139159202576,
-0.3320155739784241,
-0.12245070934295654,
0.5092909932136536,
-0.6253534555435181,
1.0143922567367554,
-0.09542059898376465,
0.0012999537866562605,
-0.11317211389541626,
0.4277409017086029,
0.2506457567214966,
0.23795606195926666,
0.35065993666648865,
0.8920984268188477,
0.6388410329818726,
0.01859300769865513,
0.912433922290802,
-0.5963669419288635,
0.05178218334913254,
1.116990566253662,
-0.23695404827594757,
0.44979992508888245,
0.6949946880340576,
0.166048064827919,
0.4310041666030884,
0.2302045375108719,
-0.02278882823884487,
0.47777259349823,
0.03365808725357056,
-0.1504822075366974,
-0.36916184425354004,
0.058535389602184296,
-0.5804275274276733,
0.348137229681015,
0.27490660548210144,
-0.37733790278434753,
-0.44759514927864075,
0.3819926381111145,
0.022434022277593613,
0.09980200231075287,
-0.36487552523612976,
0.49024051427841187,
-0.0660974383354187,
-0.9149696826934814,
0.8400753736495972,
-0.3317197859287262,
0.9873875975608826,
-0.6213823556900024,
0.2834377586841583,
-0.45188140869140625,
0.44314858317375183,
-0.16525070369243622,
-0.5996474623680115,
0.3850467801094055,
-0.3364339768886566,
-0.3333585858345032,
-0.6562968492507935,
0.23711615800857544,
-0.9507141709327698,
-0.33905261754989624,
0.7608014345169067,
0.6261775493621826,
-0.11693553626537323,
-0.0012638119515031576,
-0.531304121017456,
-0.1373213827610016,
0.1483481228351593,
0.3594762682914734,
0.7491964101791382,
0.7351264953613281,
-0.4285937249660492,
0.5836441516876221,
0.4103652834892273,
0.3225349187850952,
0.5388743877410889,
0.06813590973615646,
0.7503957748413086,
-0.38185927271842957,
-0.3976540267467499,
-0.8692984580993652,
0.18787381052970886,
-0.009367125108838081,
-0.3857453167438507,
0.9396124482154846,
0.9110314846038818,
1.3290194272994995,
-0.08578300476074219,
0.6934555768966675,
0.12652486562728882,
0.4489765763282776,
-0.23513224720954895,
0.661510705947876,
-0.9631001949310303,
0.1910470575094223,
-0.2135554999113083,
-0.7928064465522766,
-0.22410380840301514,
0.14815683662891388,
-0.16916067898273468,
-0.18491317331790924,
0.5572181344032288,
0.8727388381958008,
-0.39372333884239197,
-0.33277052640914917,
0.3005995452404022,
0.048457253724336624,
0.05854051187634468,
0.4457973539829254,
0.7017315030097961,
-0.20676648616790771,
0.4811723530292511,
-0.30251067876815796,
-0.1965187042951584,
-0.08122292160987854,
-0.529437780380249,
-0.9055565595626831,
-0.323583722114563,
-0.1600070744752884,
-0.20427551865577698,
0.0983109399676323,
0.6067368984222412,
0.527416467666626,
-0.9426229000091553,
-0.7558484673500061,
-0.09269041568040848,
0.24486535787582397,
-0.39710262417793274,
-0.20117700099945068,
-0.3150990605354309,
-0.5175095796585083,
-0.9285573959350586,
0.10711736232042313,
0.2404060810804367,
0.23380550742149353,
-0.13655805587768555,
-0.09765680134296417,
-0.3417200446128845,
-0.18670570850372314,
0.34425613284111023,
0.6552325487136841,
-0.6764825582504272,
0.220457524061203,
0.04576489329338074,
-0.3744622468948364,
0.21299263834953308,
1.0786082744598389,
-0.5881499648094177,
0.5845189690589905,
0.5503893494606018,
0.6493362188339233,
0.3807900846004486,
0.05360564589500427,
1.1428931951522827,
-0.8864259719848633,
0.5642682909965515,
-0.07520626485347748,
0.5082027912139893,
0.5685743093490601,
-0.11604051291942596,
0.26856327056884766,
0.4985506534576416,
-0.22910062968730927,
-0.8102755546569824,
0.098753422498703,
-0.8112596869468689,
-0.291932076215744,
1.1455644369125366,
0.10841301083564758,
-0.11463527381420135,
-0.03435787186026573,
-0.019712036475539207,
0.08992745727300644,
-0.1386827975511551,
0.592354416847229,
1.0706629753112793,
0.13970132172107697,
0.12688209116458893,
-0.29546037316322327,
0.3330734968185425,
1.0183396339416504,
-0.3013778328895569,
0.15980058908462524,
0.25183576345443726,
0.5076281428337097,
0.3444250226020813,
0.2459862232208252,
-0.09886221587657928,
0.22708961367607117,
-0.076201431453228,
-0.11288826167583466,
0.4590287208557129,
-0.23361855745315552,
-0.46210798621177673,
0.20297901332378387,
0.07509570568799973,
0.025756189599633217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07981v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07981v1
|
Manipulating Large Language Models to Increase Product Visibility
| 2024-04-11T17:57:32 | 2024-04-11T17:57:32 |
Aounon Kumar, Himabindu Lakkaraju
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being integrated into search
engines to provide natural language responses tailored to user queries.
Customers and end-users are also becoming more dependent on these models for
quick and easy purchase decisions. In this work, we investigate whether
recommendations from LLMs can be manipulated to enhance a product's visibility.
We demonstrate that adding a strategic text sequence (STS) -- a carefully
crafted message -- to a product's information page can significantly increase
its likelihood of being listed as the LLM's top recommendation. To understand
the impact of STS, we use a catalog of fictitious coffee machines and analyze
its effect on two target products: one that seldom appears in the LLM's
recommendations and another that usually ranks second. We observe that the
strategic text sequence significantly enhances the visibility of both products
by increasing their chances of appearing as the top recommendation. This
ability to manipulate LLM-generated search responses provides vendors with a
considerable competitive advantage and has the potential to disrupt fair market
competition. Just as search engine optimization (SEO) revolutionized how
webpages are customized to rank higher in search engine results, influencing
LLM recommendations could profoundly impact content optimization for AI-driven
search services. Code for our experiments is available at
https://github.com/aounon/llm-rank-optimizer.
|
[
-0.12699158489704132,
-0.7013047337532043,
0.8517113924026489,
0.5692034959793091,
-0.4182511270046234,
0.3593009412288666,
-0.33262115716934204,
-0.7054623961448669,
0.28961169719696045,
0.7256012558937073,
-0.44044527411460876,
-0.7011861801147461,
-0.7373954653739929,
-0.15720781683921814,
-0.5852330923080444,
1.0560896396636963,
0.3561059832572937,
-0.11468487232923508,
-0.20963074266910553,
0.02158750779926777,
-0.5488596558570862,
-0.513363242149353,
-0.733849823474884,
-0.1924455314874649,
0.9400891065597534,
0.3896505534648895,
1.0918586254119873,
0.7718474864959717,
0.6730450987815857,
0.43517565727233887,
-0.2758059799671173,
0.2985026240348816,
-0.6960168480873108,
0.6551871299743652,
-0.33310991525650024,
-0.6935346126556396,
-0.3484783470630646,
-0.31562843918800354,
0.7839643359184265,
0.6879671216011047,
0.018897127360105515,
-0.052119284868240356,
0.5387967824935913,
0.6976938843727112,
-0.6081597208976746,
0.02060815505683422,
-0.7739889621734619,
-0.1888187825679779,
-0.16918031871318817,
-0.3544039726257324,
-0.8441643118858337,
-0.23159971833229065,
0.2996133863925934,
-0.7601941823959351,
-0.13959257304668427,
0.3121988773345947,
0.9248858690261841,
0.22665223479270935,
-0.31024324893951416,
-0.23542852699756622,
-1.2970175743103027,
0.8370060920715332,
-0.5882107615470886,
0.3800489902496338,
0.1263585388660431,
0.23627178370952606,
-0.4114857316017151,
-0.704490602016449,
-0.1786893755197525,
-0.18482552468776703,
-0.2128760665655136,
0.04065040126442909,
-0.37674662470817566,
0.03191129118204117,
0.23277795314788818,
0.20156385004520416,
-0.5613663196563721,
0.17684078216552734,
-0.3159600496292114,
0.09281773120164871,
0.6777198314666748,
0.018982481211423874,
0.19946640729904175,
0.19981880486011505,
-0.20170241594314575,
-0.0032644874881953,
-0.6729499697685242,
-0.1557101458311081,
0.2123582810163498,
0.2722133696079254,
0.21281859278678894,
0.8059584498405457,
-0.30209222435951233,
0.6199020743370056,
0.2662520706653595,
-0.018023040145635605,
0.12968534231185913,
-0.3210439085960388,
-0.2404528260231018,
0.30248719453811646,
0.6497779488563538,
0.454170823097229,
0.10495179146528244,
-0.05590324476361275,
-0.3148612082004547,
-0.2453257441520691,
0.464499831199646,
-0.8745453953742981,
0.07208795845508575,
-0.09658346325159073,
-0.586980938911438,
-0.4097975790500641,
0.44740089774131775,
-0.45785441994667053,
-0.6530451774597168,
-0.22274786233901978,
0.6393229961395264,
-0.16743475198745728,
0.21728210151195526,
0.26047801971435547,
-0.30489909648895264,
0.019389532506465912,
0.093599334359169,
-0.761063277721405,
0.29766908288002014,
0.9167418479919434,
1.0149050951004028,
-0.23794174194335938,
0.11036740988492966,
-0.3800482451915741,
0.5976305603981018,
-0.4983066916465759,
0.8018186092376709,
-0.783063530921936,
-0.6590197682380676,
0.25067707896232605,
0.08383885025978088,
0.2700265347957611,
-0.8606447577476501,
0.6265546679496765,
-0.8774622082710266,
0.29495641589164734,
-0.31289684772491455,
-0.4928709864616394,
-0.0932173803448677,
0.09466156363487244,
-0.5971137881278992,
0.8266631364822388,
-0.41697701811790466,
-0.4749651253223419,
0.3367893099784851,
-0.5543089509010315,
-0.9865555167198181,
0.12429819256067276,
0.05124802514910698,
-0.31215330958366394,
0.19025790691375732,
0.3017660677433014,
0.4251817464828491,
-0.013156118802726269,
0.04463111609220505,
-0.3329988718032837,
-0.3733097016811371,
0.36047616600990295,
-0.3878784477710724,
0.29119569063186646,
0.12604020535945892,
-0.3123316168785095,
0.41642266511917114,
-0.6580150723457336,
-0.1554459184408188,
0.24119050800800323,
-0.6149330139160156,
-0.6676177978515625,
0.1235908716917038,
-0.1210281029343605,
-0.06604989618062973,
0.4997842013835907,
-0.01599670946598053,
0.24984025955200195,
-0.7238268256187439,
0.2797011137008667,
0.9792935252189636,
0.358892560005188,
0.5908199548721313,
-0.411572128534317,
0.6267485618591309,
-0.2077065259218216,
0.2965085208415985,
-0.3492790162563324,
-0.706429660320282,
-0.9977585673332214,
-0.07296115905046463,
0.2573504149913788,
0.3574906885623932,
-0.5223155617713928,
0.45287418365478516,
-0.28838875889778137,
-0.43975377082824707,
-0.4358028173446655,
0.17530480027198792,
0.2635374069213867,
0.12515288591384888,
0.19637389481067657,
-0.21471834182739258,
-0.5366976857185364,
-1.0086625814437866,
-0.7424700260162354,
-0.04855545982718468,
-0.16246649622917175,
0.5919415950775146,
-0.17577432096004486,
-0.34296849370002747,
0.6903902888298035,
-1.0059881210327148,
-0.3497867286205292,
-0.3351055085659027,
-0.005425033625215292,
0.720876157283783,
0.022631969302892685,
0.2817579209804535,
-0.6418552994728088,
-0.6265159845352173,
-0.07761502265930176,
-0.24058860540390015,
-0.2732679545879364,
-0.17760182917118073,
-0.3851219117641449,
0.06809884309768677,
0.436054527759552,
-0.5679457187652588,
0.22634421288967133,
0.43470457196235657,
-0.22152583301067352,
0.4939785897731781,
-0.49305906891822815,
0.12065884470939636,
-1.0436030626296997,
-0.30229780077934265,
0.32493817806243896,
-0.14337371289730072,
-0.3646269142627716,
-0.04625660553574562,
-0.2543843388557434,
-0.04751284047961235,
-0.29383787512779236,
0.554772138595581,
-0.17152918875217438,
-0.2693418860435486,
-0.3255019187927246,
0.23444052040576935,
0.4132373631000519,
0.15736152231693268,
-0.2420327216386795,
0.8017575144767761,
0.30619245767593384,
-0.9008104205131531,
-0.0950203612446785,
0.24168771505355835,
-0.5946460366249084,
0.2687872648239136,
-0.8351715803146362,
-0.043213870376348495,
-0.106831394135952,
0.28432294726371765,
-1.1034083366394043,
-0.005267263390123844,
0.06696070730686188,
-0.2117290198802948,
0.16321034729480743,
0.06145695224404335,
-0.772005558013916,
-0.05838221311569214,
-0.21112442016601562,
0.18318068981170654,
0.36942777037620544,
-0.6290961503982544,
0.41150781512260437,
0.28987762331962585,
-0.34172284603118896,
-0.2937628924846649,
-0.7250068187713623,
0.3319830596446991,
-0.28874245285987854,
-0.7629786729812622,
0.8910409212112427,
-0.416439414024353,
-0.30727896094322205,
-0.19408032298088074,
-0.04768149554729462,
0.40758657455444336,
0.1408662647008896,
0.4632890522480011,
0.3505415916442871,
-0.08848350495100021,
0.3685241937637329,
-0.03710377961397171,
-0.10664159804582596,
0.08883156627416611,
-0.6972095966339111,
0.7450169324874878,
-0.07535078376531601,
-0.2839079201221466,
-0.48239555954933167,
0.12421967089176178,
0.455833375453949,
-0.2191566526889801,
0.7519783973693848,
0.4132886826992035,
-0.2120179384946823,
-0.2899259328842163,
-0.38558682799339294,
-0.28220465779304504,
-0.6707339882850647,
0.35746482014656067,
-0.025937329977750778,
-0.7903299331665039,
0.10770206898450851,
-0.12055830657482147,
-0.12353391945362091,
0.41811513900756836,
0.6635085940361023,
-0.25996655225753784,
1.697155475616455,
0.7371742129325867,
-0.16497620940208435,
0.8359730243682861,
-0.08654172718524933,
0.4938282370567322,
-0.5493491888046265,
-0.3002205491065979,
-0.5696448087692261,
-0.720211386680603,
-0.8800002932548523,
-0.35730960965156555,
0.47073450684547424,
-0.07111337035894394,
-0.21290671825408936,
0.24932706356048584,
-0.5397725105285645,
0.5957098603248596,
0.6808443665504456,
0.36220332980155945,
0.5726615786552429,
0.1902245283126831,
-0.2704771161079407,
-0.07086238265037537,
-0.5849365592002869,
-0.4476243555545807,
0.8359124660491943,
0.3787325918674469,
0.7881979942321777,
0.15241193771362305,
0.4951287508010864,
0.5966767072677612,
-0.02003719098865986,
-0.8614463210105896,
0.7884306311607361,
-0.49520549178123474,
-0.34177377820014954,
0.001980121247470379,
-0.1586650162935257,
-1.0023692846298218,
-0.11416386067867279,
-0.2880922257900238,
-0.4634488523006439,
0.057742033153772354,
-0.19167053699493408,
-0.3642421364784241,
-0.13271883130073547,
-0.5093177556991577,
0.43194741010665894,
-0.7319673299789429,
-0.6136084198951721,
-0.7075208425521851,
-0.17657257616519928,
-0.03509816899895668,
-0.05393189936876297,
0.2349298894405365,
0.1334889680147171,
-0.12325192242860794,
0.7944576740264893,
-0.30796822905540466,
0.6888120174407959,
0.2563224732875824,
-0.2496802806854248,
-0.11796807497739792,
0.16935428977012634,
0.762589156627655,
-0.025428004562854767,
-0.0594596341252327,
-0.01092765387147665,
-0.5179736018180847,
-0.19016915559768677,
-0.7803879380226135,
0.9802911877632141,
-0.5313692688941956,
-1.1947615146636963,
-0.2719171345233917,
-0.3356960415840149,
-0.27086201310157776,
0.5647934675216675,
0.10037205368280411,
0.17574037611484528,
-0.18984220921993256,
0.5402045249938965,
0.7186124920845032,
-0.5384235382080078,
0.40024903416633606,
0.4233975112438202,
-0.5151450634002686,
-0.4016946256160736,
0.878237247467041,
0.011411760002374649,
0.2872731685638428,
0.6560032963752747,
0.5029294490814209,
-0.36960169672966003,
-0.6417664289474487,
0.013491293415427208,
0.23635603487491608,
-0.8163295984268188,
0.022132935002446175,
-0.6646193265914917,
-0.2422919124364853,
-0.35507678985595703,
-0.16998672485351562,
-0.03208277001976967,
-0.5200383067131042,
-0.3904978632926941,
-0.22023199498653412,
0.21122148633003235,
0.9863570332527161,
0.25643420219421387,
0.667502224445343,
-0.6198387145996094,
0.11811938136816025,
0.2413122057914734,
0.535666286945343,
-0.14461641013622284,
-0.6041263937950134,
-0.41507649421691895,
-0.11304166913032532,
-0.3888484835624695,
-0.6558353900909424,
0.4162302315235138,
0.13453194499015808,
0.524006187915802,
0.8959754705429077,
-0.09456130862236023,
0.6630011796951294,
-0.5683149695396423,
0.6688350439071655,
-0.026939282193779945,
-0.6796868443489075,
0.644670844078064,
-0.574205756187439,
0.5128583908081055,
0.29121842980384827,
0.47450587153434753,
-0.49138012528419495,
-0.48312804102897644,
-0.3563031852245331,
-0.9478817582130432,
0.49405333399772644,
0.033643029630184174,
0.3757438361644745,
0.036693159490823746,
0.17757648229599,
-0.06116993725299835,
0.3277706801891327,
-0.3987463414669037,
-0.2941785752773285,
0.31427305936813354,
0.02223251387476921,
-0.1366356611251831,
-0.46580106019973755,
0.12257010489702225,
-0.022137613967061043,
1.0443782806396484,
0.22918391227722168,
-0.0683852955698967,
-0.03178804740309715,
0.15486465394496918,
-0.017973821610212326,
0.22680117189884186,
0.5826660394668579,
0.5859748721122742,
-0.04419400542974472,
-0.06536814570426941,
-0.2611546516418457,
-0.16877920925617218,
-0.26275116205215454,
-0.09902580082416534,
-0.3209492266178131,
0.1274542361497879,
0.08330751955509186,
0.696346640586853,
0.49791285395622253,
-0.5840899348258972,
0.2028677612543106,
-0.07841221988201141,
0.10201768577098846,
-0.04331694170832634,
0.17362192273139954,
0.15943379700183868,
0.5191397666931152,
0.3935990631580353,
0.06261040270328522,
0.359832763671875,
-0.6616347432136536,
0.26579269766807556,
0.6290168762207031,
-0.3652382791042328,
0.05461594834923744,
0.6074565649032593,
0.13728579878807068,
-0.7692256569862366,
0.28712403774261475,
0.3223167359828949,
-0.6331381797790527,
0.3309597074985504,
0.6985361576080322,
0.8276605010032654,
-0.24127845466136932,
0.3107892572879791,
0.17636768519878387,
0.3186296224594116,
-0.17651429772377014,
-0.2549554407596588,
0.19352896511554718,
-0.5669355392456055,
-0.3123832643032074,
-0.6169335246086121,
-0.3831198811531067,
0.03593063727021217,
-0.3704652786254883,
0.6124054789543152,
-0.7641007304191589,
-0.41340354084968567,
0.3553600609302521,
0.005693705752491951,
-0.5061251521110535,
0.12058087438344955,
0.22614000737667084,
0.7097103595733643,
-0.2786446809768677,
0.5027086734771729,
0.48132970929145813,
-0.23033668100833893,
-0.3663182258605957,
0.34836283326148987,
-0.11186369508504868,
-0.8123096227645874,
0.5328676700592041,
0.31978660821914673,
-0.29650598764419556,
-0.19091272354125977,
-0.6081557273864746,
-0.9661603569984436,
0.9879248738288879,
0.22867226600646973,
-0.7698991894721985,
0.08921947330236435,
0.4532355070114136,
0.6444786190986633,
-0.5564886927604675,
0.20717884600162506,
0.2633691430091858,
0.6446861624717712,
0.19042731821537018,
-0.6311095356941223,
0.13955093920230865,
-0.04814426228404045,
0.09496203809976578,
0.1244037076830864,
-0.6334661841392517,
0.18122443556785583,
-0.3170015513896942,
-0.2944870889186859,
0.14425574243068695,
0.416186660528183,
0.5126711130142212,
0.24051399528980255,
0.49018001556396484,
0.3321484327316284,
0.6332966089248657,
0.18862377107143402,
0.9923397898674011,
-0.2645094692707062,
-0.0713726282119751,
1.1919764280319214,
-0.4655238389968872,
1.1129156351089478,
0.3153188228607178,
0.08379784226417542,
0.8060706853866577,
0.5620226263999939,
-0.3004058003425598,
0.7222580313682556,
0.15641726553440094,
-0.2379278987646103,
-0.2621613144874573,
-0.44484275579452515,
-0.28923556208610535,
0.39162781834602356,
0.4504150152206421,
-0.9535499215126038,
0.03733139857649803,
-0.17890194058418274,
-0.05626828595995903,
0.11445404589176178,
-0.19786573946475983,
0.9240113496780396,
0.13623209297657013,
-0.7488530278205872,
0.467263400554657,
0.3814736306667328,
0.568453311920166,
-0.5284693837165833,
-0.03854483366012573,
-0.06881526112556458,
0.4367610216140747,
-0.25468719005584717,
-0.7828016877174377,
0.08572421222925186,
-0.15397752821445465,
-0.383517861366272,
-0.5404288172721863,
1.0583765506744385,
-0.35606205463409424,
-0.7830696105957031,
0.5088743567466736,
0.28409311175346375,
-0.20528259873390198,
-0.28505608439445496,
-0.7224252820014954,
0.2061057984828949,
-0.009242402389645576,
-0.2888256311416626,
0.36107003688812256,
0.09147859364748001,
0.0597560741007328,
0.7214736938476562,
0.9958068132400513,
-0.09587758034467697,
-0.08688879758119583,
0.19298872351646423,
0.8501799702644348,
-0.5727221369743347,
-0.6456555128097534,
-0.9700810313224792,
0.22472408413887024,
-0.2806165814399719,
0.31300681829452515,
0.9038798809051514,
0.7176147103309631,
0.7725136280059814,
0.08496379852294922,
0.7795704007148743,
0.527728796005249,
0.14681965112686157,
-0.3887784481048584,
0.9923548102378845,
-0.6382051110267639,
0.8900297284126282,
-0.12334723770618439,
-1.1903072595596313,
-0.33112868666648865,
0.11436239629983902,
-0.4229356646537781,
0.14290840923786163,
0.4380863904953003,
0.9059048891067505,
0.11789563298225403,
0.007347727194428444,
0.39492857456207275,
0.7663539052009583,
0.37563568353652954,
0.19285182654857635,
0.6996815204620361,
-0.13038112223148346,
0.9082950949668884,
-0.04475655034184456,
-0.11966362595558167,
-0.3638727068901062,
-1.0308036804199219,
-0.6816576719284058,
-0.3737015426158905,
-0.3558136820793152,
-0.5288021564483643,
0.5360747575759888,
0.6100767254829407,
0.6768475770950317,
-0.6680151224136353,
-0.1888820230960846,
0.1113157570362091,
0.33478912711143494,
-0.23596127331256866,
-0.26573875546455383,
0.19009098410606384,
-0.22217057645320892,
-0.6680378913879395,
0.7612420320510864,
0.5991299748420715,
-0.07610011845827103,
-0.31993648409843445,
-0.012729795649647713,
-0.18129418790340424,
0.29134681820869446,
0.7826291918754578,
-0.28525596857070923,
-0.6938387751579285,
-0.03786215931177139,
0.3273739814758301,
0.07489532977342606,
0.23394489288330078,
0.8549747467041016,
-0.8299559950828552,
0.3659086227416992,
0.5877373218536377,
0.5741998553276062,
0.5143150091171265,
0.09966875612735748,
0.8179602026939392,
-0.8252498507499695,
-0.19383004307746887,
-0.0617162249982357,
0.2628172039985657,
0.2640904188156128,
-0.6549592018127441,
0.17391519248485565,
-0.020866060629487038,
-0.5127598643302917,
-0.5095889568328857,
0.3158276081085205,
-0.7712512612342834,
-0.4152253568172455,
1.6030869483947754,
0.1800713837146759,
-0.04511396214365959,
0.1804807484149933,
-0.29774317145347595,
0.09615378081798553,
-0.6548634171485901,
1.0114259719848633,
0.7501214146614075,
0.03867457062005997,
0.09749910235404968,
-0.5839663147926331,
0.24265801906585693,
0.5550541281700134,
-0.576499342918396,
-0.16717341542243958,
0.2077759951353073,
0.18280330300331116,
0.2691109776496887,
0.11810383945703506,
0.0012429177295416594,
-0.14647889137268066,
-0.6818600296974182,
-0.6109275221824646,
0.10659467428922653,
-0.573756992816925,
-0.3578494191169739,
0.033988598734140396,
0.2662256360054016,
-0.12314926087856293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07979v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07979v1
|
LLoCO: Learning Long Contexts Offline
| 2024-04-11T17:57:22 | 2024-04-11T17:57:22 |
Sijun Tan, Xiuyu Li, Shishir Patil, Ziyang Wu, Tianjun Zhang, Kurt Keutzer, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Raluca Ada Popa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Processing long contexts remains a challenge for large language models (LLMs)
due to the quadratic computational and memory overhead of the self-attention
mechanism and the substantial KV cache sizes during generation. We propose a
novel approach to address this problem by learning contexts offline through
context compression and in-domain parameter-efficient finetuning. Our method
enables an LLM to create a concise representation of the original context and
efficiently retrieve relevant information to answer questions accurately. We
introduce LLoCO, a technique that combines context compression, retrieval, and
parameter-efficient finetuning using LoRA. Our approach extends the effective
context window of a 4k token LLaMA2-7B model to handle up to 128k tokens. We
evaluate our approach on several long-context question-answering datasets,
demonstrating that LLoCO significantly outperforms in-context learning while
using $30\times$ fewer tokens during inference. LLoCO achieves up to
$7.62\times$ speed-up and substantially reduces the cost of long document
question answering, making it a promising solution for efficient long context
processing. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/jeffreysijuntan/lloco.
|
[
-0.30584970116615295,
-0.9101534485816956,
0.7035239338874817,
0.11212193965911865,
-0.4638582468032837,
-0.1023326963186264,
-0.5226150751113892,
-0.7036633491516113,
0.14179980754852295,
0.42721229791641235,
-0.6252239346504211,
-0.30701005458831787,
-0.2611405551433563,
0.2470102310180664,
-0.30426570773124695,
0.8854639530181885,
-0.022449083626270294,
-0.2226731926202774,
-0.3023254871368408,
-0.009930687956511974,
-0.28199303150177,
-0.36416926980018616,
-0.8478463292121887,
-0.038485679775476456,
0.6238459348678589,
0.6182172894477844,
-0.15131965279579163,
0.6677362322807312,
0.07923422753810883,
0.33273327350616455,
-0.22435204684734344,
0.4652039110660553,
-1.0507107973098755,
0.41305041313171387,
0.017328700050711632,
-0.4985639154911041,
-0.3624146580696106,
-0.34880921244621277,
0.5943323373794556,
0.5116274952888489,
-0.14436013996601105,
0.17221041023731232,
0.2161308377981186,
0.5803416967391968,
-0.7248868942260742,
0.13805152475833893,
-0.9285038113594055,
-0.09659325331449509,
-0.13113830983638763,
-0.4758681058883667,
-0.3937433362007141,
0.01250522118061781,
0.11410005390644073,
-0.8016248345375061,
-0.06858968734741211,
0.0505874827504158,
0.5879497528076172,
0.5660800933837891,
-0.5029590725898743,
-0.46633079648017883,
-0.43413132429122925,
0.8509583473205566,
-0.4929972290992737,
0.2615966796875,
0.532170832157135,
0.3774888217449188,
-0.19588495790958405,
-1.0183489322662354,
-0.47515642642974854,
0.11015326529741287,
0.21837648749351501,
0.030466850847005844,
0.11822409927845001,
0.061022356152534485,
0.15101490914821625,
0.39933642745018005,
-0.07267981767654419,
0.27797186374664307,
-0.5348301529884338,
-0.11279613524675369,
0.33575350046157837,
-0.08211231976747513,
-0.1772342026233673,
-0.1662701964378357,
-0.509490966796875,
0.2071675807237625,
-0.9439517259597778,
0.1904233694076538,
0.13976171612739563,
0.31898102164268494,
0.012002740986645222,
0.2025856375694275,
-0.3376808166503906,
0.7408791780471802,
0.11663450300693512,
-0.3672085106372833,
-0.11283493041992188,
-0.086370088160038,
-0.42651432752609253,
0.08892093598842621,
0.41344696283340454,
0.24266871809959412,
-0.05158926546573639,
-0.28607597947120667,
-0.18887048959732056,
-0.48503127694129944,
0.04344478249549866,
-0.9798955917358398,
0.31856298446655273,
0.36083558201789856,
-0.021079614758491516,
-0.12475211918354034,
-0.17466141283512115,
-0.9213937520980835,
-0.06903707981109619,
-0.46836888790130615,
0.18687082827091217,
-0.034019146114587784,
0.5129854679107666,
-0.14348746836185455,
0.22834160923957825,
0.2163131684064865,
0.6104184985160828,
-0.8781317472457886,
0.2911813259124756,
0.6492470502853394,
0.9707604050636292,
-0.2222450077533722,
-0.11367485672235489,
-1.1926764249801636,
0.19361472129821777,
-0.023378567770123482,
0.7396115660667419,
-0.28790876269340515,
-0.18578927218914032,
0.06050149351358414,
0.23409594595432281,
0.2482406497001648,
-0.45242840051651,
0.4578121304512024,
-0.6637109518051147,
0.16615194082260132,
-0.21388867497444153,
-0.6356295943260193,
0.010395582765340805,
0.220712810754776,
-0.5857906937599182,
1.1557269096374512,
0.23901037871837616,
-0.5123973488807678,
0.1483631283044815,
-0.5511878728866577,
-0.48589301109313965,
0.14679238200187683,
-0.2690984010696411,
-0.16909043490886688,
-0.016628000885248184,
0.3049198091030121,
0.7259501814842224,
-0.3551560640335083,
0.22483177483081818,
-0.13446509838104248,
-0.6194552779197693,
-0.10667367279529572,
-0.18563689291477203,
0.6461225152015686,
0.2945334017276764,
-0.4431374669075012,
0.0769757628440857,
-0.7825832962989807,
-0.052780088037252426,
0.13718174397945404,
-0.7109659314155579,
-0.3217918872833252,
-0.07477817684412003,
-0.02083428204059601,
0.12105618417263031,
0.42180538177490234,
-0.5189166069030762,
0.2704352140426636,
-0.4543856382369995,
0.9815517663955688,
0.7808443903923035,
-0.23757725954055786,
0.49615809321403503,
-0.03988310322165489,
0.2664879262447357,
-0.14580529928207397,
0.0008945416775532067,
-0.35657185316085815,
-0.28484219312667847,
-0.8911131620407104,
-0.4173012673854828,
0.0474449098110199,
0.4324241280555725,
-0.6877879500389099,
0.40602630376815796,
-0.3447142243385315,
-0.12018529325723648,
-0.3133154809474945,
0.6381051540374756,
0.3307429850101471,
0.8831545114517212,
0.5314350724220276,
0.05839028209447861,
-0.6614095568656921,
-0.5978873372077942,
0.14277300238609314,
0.11335833370685577,
-0.12445896118879318,
0.7257177233695984,
0.5200180411338806,
-0.48990392684936523,
1.0861543416976929,
-0.5893807411193848,
-0.5630854368209839,
-0.24676841497421265,
0.03708541393280029,
0.07848580926656723,
0.15537330508232117,
0.3197176158428192,
-0.7645382881164551,
-0.4372536242008209,
0.049359630793333054,
-0.5528318285942078,
-0.100972481071949,
-0.022301677614450455,
0.08795613050460815,
0.5198777914047241,
0.8820922374725342,
-0.3838779926300049,
0.08157195895910263,
0.6125580072402954,
0.1100955680012703,
0.0210366640239954,
-0.376796156167984,
-0.11602289974689484,
-1.3985575437545776,
0.2189001888036728,
-0.294653981924057,
-0.70517498254776,
-0.5011398792266846,
0.2034492790699005,
0.20851363241672516,
-0.07879020273685455,
-0.9381032586097717,
0.8179550170898438,
-0.5727024674415588,
-0.08316242694854736,
-0.2717079818248749,
0.4017714858055115,
0.1559605747461319,
0.7242085337638855,
-0.02846396714448929,
0.9385583400726318,
0.3833504021167755,
-0.6219890117645264,
0.3152894973754883,
0.015319151803851128,
-0.6491433382034302,
0.19982920587062836,
-0.5513973236083984,
0.4699147343635559,
-0.35954749584198,
0.6874241828918457,
-0.9164474606513977,
-0.4912828803062439,
-0.0541156604886055,
0.028913553804159164,
0.2755107283592224,
-0.3313140273094177,
-0.35389843583106995,
-0.016522886231541634,
-0.2599623501300812,
0.61299067735672,
0.4534218907356262,
-0.7943565249443054,
0.4441264569759369,
0.44998663663864136,
-0.049268465489149094,
-0.7641963958740234,
-0.6733352541923523,
0.006859288550913334,
-0.5759362578392029,
-0.238007590174675,
0.47016608715057373,
-0.1700754016637802,
-0.11832171678543091,
-0.551258385181427,
0.013430759310722351,
-0.26677754521369934,
0.1739349514245987,
0.22090865671634674,
-0.1707172989845276,
0.007455810438841581,
0.296581894159317,
0.1661536544561386,
0.15144488215446472,
-0.20373758673667908,
-0.27962762117385864,
0.6206039190292358,
-0.18331673741340637,
0.2615337073802948,
-0.3997154235839844,
0.3828713297843933,
0.5449795126914978,
0.1085730791091919,
0.6107726693153381,
0.19710759818553925,
-0.40668991208076477,
-0.46999332308769226,
-0.5113773941993713,
-0.12289918214082718,
-0.5329678058624268,
0.27657464146614075,
-0.3040016293525696,
-1.364866852760315,
0.6800986528396606,
-0.21976085007190704,
-0.03431355208158493,
0.17802542448043823,
0.4313826560974121,
-0.21674340963363647,
0.44596990942955017,
0.6733500957489014,
-0.26028162240982056,
0.6048204302787781,
-0.3666386008262634,
0.09050828218460083,
-0.8862723112106323,
-0.08360480517148972,
-0.12746229767799377,
-0.06527888029813766,
-0.29151758551597595,
-0.6826457977294922,
0.3545339107513428,
0.45838266611099243,
-0.029825152829289436,
0.382295697927475,
-0.2099730372428894,
0.7901520133018494,
0.22232882678508759,
0.24009627103805542,
0.3198985159397125,
0.09831257164478302,
0.15301969647407532,
0.33683323860168457,
-0.5945373773574829,
-0.2873828709125519,
0.9879419207572937,
0.42309001088142395,
0.5764453411102295,
0.08962380141019821,
0.75603848695755,
0.1915295124053955,
0.20658506453037262,
-1.0641154050827026,
0.4913713335990906,
0.12506943941116333,
-0.460829496383667,
-0.5769519209861755,
-0.48952752351760864,
-0.9333106279373169,
-0.01925693452358246,
0.11897768825292587,
-0.9088537096977234,
0.0463043674826622,
0.3358514606952667,
-0.642823338508606,
0.18507961928844452,
-0.4755992591381073,
0.5884068608283997,
-0.1234661117196083,
-0.6806473731994629,
-0.10224281251430511,
-0.7939241528511047,
0.19334393739700317,
-0.4613119959831238,
0.24583597481250763,
0.013247870840132236,
-0.20176903903484344,
0.6226447224617004,
-0.3635788857936859,
1.0618542432785034,
0.03421999514102936,
-0.550225555896759,
0.5174219608306885,
-0.11905684322118759,
0.6820347905158997,
0.46084681153297424,
-0.12421449273824692,
0.1448473185300827,
0.03326904773712158,
-0.3446999788284302,
-0.629666268825531,
0.9819193482398987,
-0.5746186375617981,
-0.5368834137916565,
-0.1981474608182907,
-0.517837643623352,
-0.08436768501996994,
0.32385125756263733,
0.47503507137298584,
0.6114115715026855,
-0.029139583930373192,
0.34282445907592773,
0.5544465184211731,
-0.0189959779381752,
0.6342607736587524,
0.22812987864017487,
0.051976051181554794,
-0.42685651779174805,
0.6448268890380859,
0.1450842320919037,
0.2495572865009308,
0.6272801756858826,
0.22257018089294434,
-0.37332990765571594,
-0.26813971996307373,
-0.4508526027202606,
0.13686345517635345,
-1.1158995628356934,
-0.3465111255645752,
-0.48392000794410706,
0.06222445145249367,
-0.31326451897621155,
-0.2986147999763489,
-0.36633607745170593,
-0.2598411440849304,
-0.5746082663536072,
0.11939394474029541,
0.3405190408229828,
0.4515531063079834,
0.2320893257856369,
0.42833566665649414,
-0.5111557245254517,
0.12688221037387848,
0.5666300058364868,
0.20222409069538116,
0.047572314739227295,
-0.5703250169754028,
-0.2310958057641983,
0.10457312315702438,
-0.1749746948480606,
-0.5383262634277344,
0.296691358089447,
0.6601638793945312,
0.0796700119972229,
0.721745491027832,
0.31552010774612427,
1.090686559677124,
-0.7554801106452942,
0.6027221083641052,
-0.14704976975917816,
-1.0573234558105469,
0.5253708958625793,
-0.3365146219730377,
0.25897297263145447,
0.8709498047828674,
0.5489007830619812,
-0.3989335298538208,
-0.022575147449970245,
-0.22015468776226044,
-1.057509183883667,
0.5483132600784302,
0.05050930753350258,
0.29546141624450684,
-0.25332364439964294,
0.8380064368247986,
0.2067645788192749,
0.07364679127931595,
-0.8581127524375916,
0.027775999158620834,
0.042041804641485214,
-0.030487844720482826,
-0.29837480187416077,
-0.3616804778575897,
-0.26632460951805115,
-0.3417772948741913,
0.32880595326423645,
-0.6942813396453857,
0.34815695881843567,
0.46530506014823914,
-0.43645575642585754,
-0.08050437271595001,
0.31947338581085205,
1.0077868700027466,
0.8769508004188538,
-0.31343936920166016,
0.20822690427303314,
0.6728254556655884,
-0.10875021666288376,
-0.08023970574140549,
-0.13771075010299683,
0.1801738739013672,
-0.4483185112476349,
0.41212064027786255,
0.7262433767318726,
0.4732166528701782,
-1.0302549600601196,
0.5531123280525208,
-0.18237073719501495,
-0.0947367399930954,
-0.6531932353973389,
-0.020907843485474586,
-0.03575886785984039,
0.22307537496089935,
0.4340456426143646,
-0.5909504294395447,
0.1267232596874237,
-0.8488851189613342,
0.1715908944606781,
0.23660686612129211,
-0.44459182024002075,
-0.06293954700231552,
0.491543710231781,
0.38631054759025574,
-0.03902840241789818,
0.6071845293045044,
-0.03223241865634918,
-0.32315006852149963,
0.5582070350646973,
0.7806985974311829,
0.41442087292671204,
0.07573672384023666,
-0.19879621267318726,
0.2586286962032318,
-0.37774863839149475,
-0.09342790395021439,
0.16978012025356293,
-0.7754415273666382,
-0.31559863686561584,
-0.5984494090080261,
-0.6415689587593079,
-0.3274194300174713,
0.3565506637096405,
-0.5547753572463989,
0.30071648955345154,
-0.5098490715026855,
0.13987921178340912,
-0.35885536670684814,
0.10376730561256409,
-0.3656632900238037,
0.20732587575912476,
0.11546102166175842,
0.810806155204773,
-0.4386104643344879,
1.130990982055664,
0.3720606863498688,
-0.04549304395914078,
-0.4392911195755005,
0.00211885804310441,
-0.18322820961475372,
-0.7395390868186951,
0.9011387825012207,
0.6450887322425842,
-0.41514965891838074,
0.2931411564350128,
-0.5642406940460205,
-0.9097442626953125,
1.3131107091903687,
0.36810001730918884,
-0.8885690569877625,
-0.16679178178310394,
0.04353753477334976,
0.48394495248794556,
-0.4642629623413086,
0.20547181367874146,
0.3751407563686371,
0.09424517303705215,
0.1597214788198471,
-0.7684120535850525,
0.06343800574541092,
0.09245812147855759,
-0.2797030806541443,
0.16533885896205902,
-0.8289363980293274,
0.6316431164741516,
-0.23800766468048096,
-0.3677852153778076,
0.17691567540168762,
0.7803824543952942,
0.18102987110614777,
0.28741133213043213,
0.556098222732544,
0.4033631384372711,
0.908329427242279,
0.0955059602856636,
0.9692810773849487,
-0.4858637750148773,
0.5568299889564514,
1.1774380207061768,
-0.2342263013124466,
1.1548715829849243,
0.8018996119499207,
0.25005587935447693,
0.48001188039779663,
0.8487679958343506,
0.49684154987335205,
0.6742848753929138,
0.33666831254959106,
-0.41162440180778503,
-0.3252406418323517,
-0.057207297533750534,
-0.1210469901561737,
0.48413825035095215,
0.23807069659233093,
-0.16354799270629883,
-0.1799211949110031,
-0.0186422448605299,
0.1660829782485962,
-0.134272962808609,
-0.35559704899787903,
0.7199423313140869,
0.3656965494155884,
-0.8771012425422668,
0.8981335163116455,
-0.017288167029619217,
0.704510509967804,
-0.5235622525215149,
-0.01323916669934988,
-0.45911580324172974,
0.2794153094291687,
-0.09086529910564423,
-0.40278491377830505,
0.1885218769311905,
0.03554736077785492,
-0.052709560841321945,
-0.32427170872688293,
0.29445967078208923,
-0.5009253621101379,
-0.24970027804374695,
0.45964768528938293,
0.11568135023117065,
0.29215922951698303,
-0.03397790715098381,
-0.3418183922767639,
-0.0042433408088982105,
-0.22519084811210632,
-0.28065624833106995,
0.4322645962238312,
0.3449532091617584,
-0.23379336297512054,
0.8327723741531372,
0.5984345078468323,
-0.17748220264911652,
-0.039328090846538544,
-0.10568946599960327,
1.059383749961853,
-0.47739431262016296,
-0.6924040913581848,
-0.7812280058860779,
0.3018464744091034,
-0.002815338782966137,
-0.5147917866706848,
0.4474587142467499,
0.553555428981781,
1.023241400718689,
0.1146320328116417,
0.3194405138492584,
0.052882470190525055,
0.2306670993566513,
-0.791198194026947,
0.5686467885971069,
-0.9196599125862122,
0.2872421145439148,
-0.009681976400315762,
-0.8579082489013672,
-0.25869131088256836,
0.5624711513519287,
-0.29872003197669983,
-0.17356500029563904,
0.7124403119087219,
0.5524019598960876,
-0.3524957299232483,
-0.3346061706542969,
0.254339337348938,
0.02510088123381138,
0.3004067838191986,
0.8009422421455383,
0.6820604801177979,
-0.5342804789543152,
0.5089333653450012,
-0.28438594937324524,
-0.13377274572849274,
-0.36335304379463196,
-1.182596206665039,
-1.1224607229232788,
-0.7180763483047485,
0.033957429230213165,
0.02852601744234562,
0.1551690250635147,
1.103724479675293,
0.9927119612693787,
-0.5741922855377197,
-0.32366010546684265,
-0.18620355427265167,
-0.01007008645683527,
0.1080828309059143,
-0.1575658917427063,
0.45120882987976074,
-0.4803154170513153,
-0.924133837223053,
0.8014556169509888,
0.19427867233753204,
-0.12017218768596649,
-0.15555070340633392,
-0.20072391629219055,
-0.0842587873339653,
-0.010618438012897968,
0.9218822121620178,
0.4611382484436035,
-0.8553325533866882,
-0.28645122051239014,
-0.12889321148395538,
-0.028863409534096718,
0.35716280341148376,
0.8085374236106873,
-0.8384307622909546,
0.31128135323524475,
0.5604951977729797,
0.7952967286109924,
0.6505353450775146,
0.2596719264984131,
0.42913857102394104,
-0.9107806086540222,
0.3833158314228058,
0.03936571627855301,
0.40981462597846985,
0.29212477803230286,
-0.7073041796684265,
0.3549818992614746,
-0.07287347316741943,
-0.6371076703071594,
-0.8828877806663513,
0.22425131499767303,
-1.1172629594802856,
-0.5065547227859497,
1.2564808130264282,
-0.295322984457016,
-0.5225357413291931,
-0.06879958510398865,
-0.19215728342533112,
0.26022180914878845,
-0.4571080803871155,
0.893720805644989,
0.3388220965862274,
-0.1179419681429863,
-0.2872544825077057,
-0.7272325754165649,
0.6272872090339661,
0.2669125497341156,
-0.9794511795043945,
0.11886114627122879,
0.3376487195491791,
0.37040504813194275,
-0.024701092392206192,
0.4862026572227478,
0.30136725306510925,
0.013582994230091572,
-0.6650882959365845,
-0.266196072101593,
-0.23879215121269226,
-0.6403062343597412,
-0.3742835819721222,
0.24458473920822144,
-0.21976430714130402,
0.19010613858699799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07972v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07972v2
|
OSWorld: Benchmarking Multimodal Agents for Open-Ended Tasks in Real Computer Environments
| 2024-04-11T17:56:05 | 2024-05-30T08:55:12 |
Tianbao Xie, Danyang Zhang, Jixuan Chen, Xiaochuan Li, Siheng Zhao, Ruisheng Cao, Toh Jing Hua, Zhoujun Cheng, Dongchan Shin, Fangyu Lei, Yitao Liu, Yiheng Xu, Shuyan Zhou, Silvio Savarese, Caiming Xiong, Victor Zhong, Tao Yu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Autonomous agents that accomplish complex computer tasks with minimal human
interventions have the potential to transform human-computer interaction,
significantly enhancing accessibility and productivity. However, existing
benchmarks either lack an interactive environment or are limited to
environments specific to certain applications or domains, failing to reflect
the diverse and complex nature of real-world computer use, thereby limiting the
scope of tasks and agent scalability. To address this issue, we introduce
OSWorld, the first-of-its-kind scalable, real computer environment for
multimodal agents, supporting task setup, execution-based evaluation, and
interactive learning across various operating systems such as Ubuntu, Windows,
and macOS. OSWorld can serve as a unified, integrated computer environment for
assessing open-ended computer tasks that involve arbitrary applications.
Building upon OSWorld, we create a benchmark of 369 computer tasks involving
real web and desktop apps in open domains, OS file I/O, and workflows spanning
multiple applications. Each task example is derived from real-world computer
use cases and includes a detailed initial state setup configuration and a
custom execution-based evaluation script for reliable, reproducible evaluation.
Extensive evaluation of state-of-the-art LLM/VLM-based agents on OSWorld
reveals significant deficiencies in their ability to serve as computer
assistants. While humans can accomplish over 72.36% of the tasks, the best
model achieves only 12.24% success, primarily struggling with GUI grounding and
operational knowledge. Comprehensive analysis using OSWorld provides valuable
insights for developing multimodal generalist agents that were not possible
with previous benchmarks. Our code, environment, baseline models, and data are
publicly available at https://os-world.github.io.
|
[
-0.5423715710639954,
-0.7780066728591919,
0.646345317363739,
0.19089621305465698,
0.24022182822227478,
0.1584334820508957,
-0.05042315647006035,
-0.757447361946106,
-0.0018958867294713855,
0.27733609080314636,
-0.7127553224563599,
-0.31181642413139343,
-0.2846418023109436,
0.03794582933187485,
0.05593327805399895,
0.7282151579856873,
-0.08214913308620453,
-0.45675796270370483,
-0.909230649471283,
-0.5216496586799622,
-0.24920353293418884,
-0.38620463013648987,
-0.35099881887435913,
-0.19527573883533478,
0.39609161019325256,
0.3814941942691803,
0.9528633952140808,
0.4241408407688141,
0.5619949102401733,
0.3678741455078125,
0.3535946011543274,
0.42171186208724976,
-0.38576167821884155,
0.5193296670913696,
-0.25039607286453247,
-0.03884422779083252,
-0.7006204724311829,
0.22304968535900116,
0.39764076471328735,
0.3995760679244995,
0.01822025515139103,
0.2608743906021118,
-0.2264517992734909,
0.26847514510154724,
-1.019547462463379,
0.24090667068958282,
-0.17751312255859375,
0.28495919704437256,
0.03929844871163368,
-0.03480025380849838,
-0.2816590368747711,
-0.09273812919855118,
-0.027419744059443474,
-1.120430588722229,
-0.02129204012453556,
0.11953259259462357,
0.4719953238964081,
0.17945514619350433,
-0.5101099014282227,
-0.04994763806462288,
-0.7059361934661865,
0.8951676487922668,
-0.26863130927085876,
0.48274749517440796,
-0.06283441185951233,
0.5476095676422119,
-0.32262274622917175,
-0.715664803981781,
-0.5203314423561096,
-0.6845777034759521,
0.20926256477832794,
0.24448736011981964,
-0.4328729212284088,
0.180834099650383,
0.49240559339523315,
0.19635339081287384,
-0.5645937323570251,
-0.17644691467285156,
-0.14000506699085236,
-0.39116793870925903,
0.42953187227249146,
0.3280169665813446,
0.5560448169708252,
0.4619688093662262,
-0.4918474555015564,
-0.5184371471405029,
-0.20201179385185242,
0.4053639769554138,
0.329552561044693,
0.321024626493454,
-0.16032645106315613,
0.5209276080131531,
-0.7047753930091858,
0.5513277649879456,
-0.4434954822063446,
-0.5334257483482361,
0.46493926644325256,
-0.25905776023864746,
-0.19302727282047272,
-0.46969619393348694,
0.6107867956161499,
0.6225309371948242,
0.0829479768872261,
-0.38975775241851807,
-0.433818519115448,
0.3875804543495178,
0.5781760811805725,
-0.6805016398429871,
0.15235768258571625,
0.293578177690506,
-0.25991323590278625,
-0.1997232288122177,
-0.013356776908040047,
-0.46059450507164,
-0.4465634822845459,
-0.3628504276275635,
0.6489611268043518,
-0.23531542718410492,
-0.3184433877468109,
-0.32661089301109314,
-0.3765872120857239,
-0.01355653628706932,
0.627088189125061,
-0.14493708312511444,
0.6941522359848022,
0.5693820714950562,
0.9466190934181213,
-0.42839914560317993,
-0.44353559613227844,
-0.8663981556892395,
-0.03388739377260208,
-0.17386558651924133,
0.7167632579803467,
-0.4967864155769348,
-0.22273221611976624,
-0.12803494930267334,
0.04477393254637718,
0.16442346572875977,
-0.5305747985839844,
0.2354453057050705,
-0.32628968358039856,
-0.21618972718715668,
0.03966889530420303,
-0.012114005163311958,
-0.03557106480002403,
0.782425582408905,
-0.6294464468955994,
1.074215054512024,
0.2297956943511963,
-0.3400672674179077,
0.23487547039985657,
-0.9739362597465515,
-0.35207173228263855,
0.0460914708673954,
-0.09655967354774475,
-0.12870222330093384,
0.13549888134002686,
0.01487389300018549,
0.2748912572860718,
-0.35761335492134094,
-0.15910016000270844,
-0.5365115404129028,
-0.37142887711524963,
0.042698800563812256,
-0.2877974808216095,
0.5715044140815735,
0.35213539004325867,
-0.26947394013404846,
0.2833297550678253,
-0.7067269682884216,
0.41724732518196106,
0.04848964512348175,
-0.16687756776809692,
-0.3448570668697357,
-0.09435858577489853,
0.33711400628089905,
0.2956988215446472,
0.3230256736278534,
-1.0115835666656494,
0.5104507207870483,
0.32527464628219604,
0.15217246115207672,
0.671930193901062,
-0.3097934424877167,
0.08188788592815399,
-0.3933807909488678,
0.7655552625656128,
0.023014433681964874,
0.6256885528564453,
-0.1112535372376442,
-0.4380713105201721,
-0.18885158002376556,
-0.5410290360450745,
-0.18342354893684387,
0.5493752360343933,
-0.893558919429779,
-0.23287354409694672,
-0.3586045205593109,
-0.6250958442687988,
-0.17268913984298706,
0.10163029283285141,
0.6326481103897095,
0.32141441106796265,
0.31699883937835693,
-0.5397008657455444,
-0.2503250241279602,
-1.0067529678344727,
-0.1536407768726349,
-0.12252745032310486,
-0.03320220857858658,
0.3919045031070709,
0.5768860578536987,
-0.69697105884552,
1.2605724334716797,
-0.3394375145435333,
-0.2598317265510559,
-0.03578411415219307,
0.12340206652879715,
-0.10170242935419083,
0.288474977016449,
0.39083895087242126,
-0.7957723140716553,
-0.46951571106910706,
0.31479835510253906,
-0.9906257390975952,
-0.1426176279783249,
0.060576438903808594,
-0.08890608698129654,
-0.010324270464479923,
0.3575287163257599,
-0.3999277353286743,
0.24176649749279022,
0.6177809834480286,
-0.16107195615768433,
0.6364821791648865,
-0.5964404344558716,
0.203190878033638,
-0.5879572033882141,
0.28790250420570374,
-0.008311791345477104,
-0.5738471150398254,
-0.4974317252635956,
0.5381848812103271,
0.2521500289440155,
-0.41079092025756836,
-0.45952922105789185,
0.7207943797111511,
-0.5134725570678711,
-0.4235425591468811,
-0.17902080714702606,
0.13358139991760254,
-0.10296397656202316,
0.5515490770339966,
-0.1567305326461792,
0.9747787117958069,
0.4834069609642029,
-0.5522264242172241,
0.5945977568626404,
-0.19152869284152985,
-0.1350930780172348,
0.8048940896987915,
-0.5780377388000488,
0.2694140374660492,
0.11879435181617737,
0.30651620030403137,
-0.8303911685943604,
-0.22965459525585175,
0.10655106604099274,
-0.1821136474609375,
-0.35952430963516235,
0.2254810929298401,
-0.6073575615882874,
-0.3254353404045105,
-0.48515141010284424,
0.3439871668815613,
0.48364412784576416,
-0.4669974446296692,
0.7261873483657837,
0.35232821106910706,
0.13172295689582825,
-0.7262205481529236,
-0.2785009741783142,
0.15801148116588593,
0.23142282664775848,
-0.6132586598396301,
0.20964431762695312,
-0.3797132670879364,
-0.590190052986145,
0.024487266317009926,
-0.31653764843940735,
-0.03584878891706467,
0.39638713002204895,
0.7710396647453308,
0.05904805287718773,
-0.2147969752550125,
-0.11579649150371552,
0.012775334529578686,
-0.14673008024692535,
-0.1713368445634842,
-0.17016997933387756,
0.012676168233156204,
-0.3975648283958435,
-0.470233678817749,
-0.2626490592956543,
0.250313937664032,
1.0364383459091187,
-0.10526499152183533,
0.3651885986328125,
0.5104668736457825,
-0.4125506579875946,
-0.27284491062164307,
-0.5365808606147766,
0.24513199925422668,
-0.4439200460910797,
0.2304743528366089,
-0.5663039684295654,
-0.5398542284965515,
0.3196556270122528,
-0.395253449678421,
0.4282971918582916,
0.2180347442626953,
0.2063557207584381,
0.09818542003631592,
1.0732802152633667,
0.8204444050788879,
0.028004683554172516,
0.41473469138145447,
-0.11586706340312958,
-0.22428490221500397,
-0.7819696068763733,
-0.05855509638786316,
-0.15286940336227417,
-0.2979409396648407,
-0.37724441289901733,
-0.5279778242111206,
0.8159686326980591,
-0.3524230122566223,
-0.073603056371212,
0.3466075658798218,
-0.4325387477874756,
0.4940037131309509,
0.6323005557060242,
0.12533332407474518,
0.24082060158252716,
-0.011446960270404816,
-0.3595484793186188,
0.3252719044685364,
-0.2452695369720459,
-0.5088096857070923,
0.9899717569351196,
0.27287957072257996,
0.7157152891159058,
0.19188399612903595,
0.37754788994789124,
1.0332088470458984,
0.579903244972229,
-0.5181714296340942,
0.6358668208122253,
0.25982189178466797,
-0.6149033904075623,
-0.546752393245697,
-0.2449791431427002,
-0.8537173271179199,
0.7059014439582825,
-0.1875324249267578,
-0.7455087900161743,
-0.06675361841917038,
0.07387692481279373,
-0.2990434467792511,
0.17348186671733856,
-0.6086558699607849,
1.148066520690918,
-0.24593786895275116,
-0.7414364814758301,
-0.28866803646087646,
-0.5998049378395081,
0.06481363624334335,
0.28057828545570374,
0.4230507016181946,
-0.280386745929718,
-0.3890162408351898,
0.3675972819328308,
-0.46862468123435974,
0.6380592584609985,
-0.42895060777664185,
-0.01081801950931549,
0.07945431768894196,
0.10778974741697311,
0.38505083322525024,
-0.19446144998073578,
-0.11294005066156387,
0.08282236009836197,
0.17539046704769135,
-0.48046964406967163,
-0.3994985520839691,
0.810144305229187,
-1.0374757051467896,
-0.17750942707061768,
-0.7043002247810364,
-0.6659650802612305,
-0.5167506337165833,
0.22384284436702728,
-0.18999134004116058,
0.7387477159500122,
-0.5813564658164978,
0.19021748006343842,
0.5165624022483826,
-0.11385280638933182,
0.29541251063346863,
0.8085044026374817,
-0.25252655148506165,
-0.2465137541294098,
1.0042245388031006,
-0.041932277381420135,
0.3560832738876343,
0.391753226518631,
-0.05018361657857895,
-0.01063958927989006,
-0.28974053263664246,
-0.7388983964920044,
-0.21816736459732056,
-0.650216281414032,
-0.06497296690940857,
-0.6997321844100952,
0.24904078245162964,
-0.39561283588409424,
-0.22487851977348328,
-0.46362951397895813,
-0.11894256621599197,
0.27009159326553345,
0.2615026831626892,
-0.07145906239748001,
0.8654592633247375,
-0.18636198341846466,
0.24850942194461823,
-0.5125411748886108,
0.6405042409896851,
0.5349358320236206,
0.37858977913856506,
-0.13079874217510223,
0.10420801490545273,
-0.3080044984817505,
-0.025927720591425896,
-0.699489176273346,
-0.44240906834602356,
0.2452470064163208,
0.17423097789287567,
0.9371344447135925,
0.47676557302474976,
0.27795082330703735,
0.6617236137390137,
-0.24617300927639008,
0.8359258770942688,
0.12717758119106293,
-0.9352758526802063,
0.42459776997566223,
-0.16606245934963226,
0.38648030161857605,
0.6222848892211914,
0.34874358773231506,
-0.5813158750534058,
-0.4505748450756073,
-0.40311193466186523,
-0.7022433280944824,
1.0023548603057861,
0.22203437983989716,
-0.13175345957279205,
0.10755839198827744,
-0.10490705817937851,
0.3506118655204773,
0.2624783515930176,
-0.8124715089797974,
-0.14608216285705566,
-0.012330655939877033,
0.06293291598558426,
-0.3018916845321655,
0.12155412137508392,
-0.2334618717432022,
0.12752129137516022,
0.6827713251113892,
-0.42265546321868896,
0.26108643412590027,
0.269520103931427,
-0.648082435131073,
-0.17066001892089844,
0.05261145904660225,
0.7463734149932861,
0.8548634052276611,
-0.3690078556537628,
0.32017040252685547,
0.08221858739852905,
-0.5449718832969666,
0.19412152469158173,
0.05714994668960571,
0.07877738773822784,
-0.341632604598999,
0.49418148398399353,
0.5649555921554565,
0.04112441837787628,
-1.2801433801651,
0.5582102537155151,
-0.34733346104621887,
0.06098064407706261,
-0.33467912673950195,
0.32769468426704407,
-0.1778545379638672,
0.3369991183280945,
0.4542771577835083,
0.18866664171218872,
0.2992676794528961,
-1.0215528011322021,
-0.05089646205306053,
0.5170895457267761,
-0.5929524302482605,
-0.24936148524284363,
0.6695404648780823,
0.33783456683158875,
-0.36113759875297546,
0.5881963968276978,
-0.3263554871082306,
-0.14772439002990723,
0.8520846366882324,
0.37455493211746216,
0.9415911436080933,
-0.027028974145650864,
0.11551828682422638,
0.08526330441236496,
0.4894351661205292,
0.001669619930908084,
0.24388179183006287,
-0.6786375641822815,
-0.4157748818397522,
0.027700649574398994,
-0.5373304486274719,
-1.011244773864746,
-0.22247286140918732,
-0.5388574004173279,
-0.2842506766319275,
-0.4314334988594055,
-0.18359695374965668,
-0.06525908410549164,
0.06799283623695374,
-0.6426326632499695,
0.3479679524898529,
0.2808532416820526,
0.9069465398788452,
-0.7921210527420044,
0.6410796642303467,
1.0860233306884766,
-0.2049848437309265,
0.027295667678117752,
0.012207693420350552,
0.09804674983024597,
-0.6216006875038147,
0.4900398254394531,
0.47069987654685974,
-0.4609314501285553,
-0.47260937094688416,
-0.49051937460899353,
-0.687358558177948,
1.255658745765686,
0.22857216000556946,
-0.3491671085357666,
0.22706115245819092,
0.20464454591274261,
0.6419111490249634,
-0.2915036976337433,
0.9253549575805664,
-0.10744535177946091,
0.5864965319633484,
-0.3590236306190491,
-1.1072437763214111,
0.10407156497240067,
-0.6805291771888733,
0.16821765899658203,
0.04430794343352318,
-0.6756163239479065,
1.0223278999328613,
-0.11194821447134018,
-0.03362295404076576,
0.1338459700345993,
0.4665726125240326,
0.13838429749011993,
0.8382214307785034,
0.9624342322349548,
0.42853230237960815,
0.4909423291683197,
0.017510881647467613,
1.1641966104507446,
-0.2712610065937042,
0.1024181991815567,
0.5746015310287476,
-0.5445528626441956,
0.6718263626098633,
0.2598459720611572,
-0.20383235812187195,
0.4531904458999634,
0.32126083970069885,
0.5405336022377014,
0.43189382553100586,
0.051921285688877106,
-0.3486408591270447,
-0.44780170917510986,
-0.21838708221912384,
-0.18863503634929657,
0.17932191491127014,
0.1836232990026474,
0.23390644788742065,
-0.23444169759750366,
0.5349214673042297,
-0.2694143056869507,
-0.012828076258301735,
-0.23776941001415253,
0.7302817702293396,
-0.3218972980976105,
-0.8053584694862366,
0.2564656138420105,
0.042446430772542953,
0.7482584714889526,
-1.0144928693771362,
-0.18427863717079163,
-0.17174814641475677,
0.3958858847618103,
-0.002615422010421753,
-0.5242528915405273,
-0.14396998286247253,
-0.022572658956050873,
-0.1669752299785614,
-0.5932415723800659,
0.6256052255630493,
0.1316438764333725,
-0.15357764065265656,
0.40480291843414307,
0.4249110221862793,
0.25713974237442017,
-0.3461582064628601,
-0.4566977620124817,
0.3612898290157318,
-0.3222963511943817,
-0.3040098547935486,
0.6507828831672668,
0.3111456632614136,
-0.41485124826431274,
1.0051722526550293,
0.6722533702850342,
-0.35761532187461853,
-0.19966977834701538,
-0.4151216149330139,
0.8053247928619385,
-0.5349602103233337,
-0.6109184622764587,
-0.42285287380218506,
0.34649357199668884,
-0.21609915792942047,
-0.47239911556243896,
0.7662191390991211,
0.8724473118782043,
0.7340631484985352,
-0.1604590117931366,
0.9252821207046509,
-0.389949768781662,
0.2635505497455597,
0.07453453540802002,
0.41258981823921204,
-1.0079286098480225,
-0.34975364804267883,
-0.289631187915802,
-0.7935988306999207,
0.14307153224945068,
0.36552858352661133,
-0.011671951040625572,
0.038849350064992905,
0.38974112272262573,
0.6787559986114502,
-0.46936464309692383,
-0.08313886821269989,
0.7410476207733154,
0.078946553170681,
0.3473922908306122,
0.39660489559173584,
0.9574225544929504,
-0.13405779004096985,
0.5720890164375305,
-0.48551511764526367,
-0.5608004331588745,
-0.40083181858062744,
-0.8805075883865356,
-0.5781469941139221,
-0.45579278469085693,
-0.32905322313308716,
-0.08506737649440765,
0.42497822642326355,
1.0935053825378418,
0.9695495367050171,
-0.5492981672286987,
-0.4001474976539612,
0.20421139895915985,
-0.01969044841825962,
-0.8465228080749512,
-0.1628912091255188,
-0.349219411611557,
-0.22161199152469635,
-0.7388073801994324,
0.6484392881393433,
0.41305360198020935,
-0.35092294216156006,
-0.3955516517162323,
-0.17810028791427612,
0.17306122183799744,
0.016742747277021408,
0.8839138746261597,
0.6059421896934509,
-0.6654052734375,
-0.24285562336444855,
-0.029453236609697342,
-0.3833058178424835,
-0.24581798911094666,
0.669111430644989,
-1.056924819946289,
0.7074169516563416,
0.25761494040489197,
0.40078264474868774,
0.23100487887859344,
0.10019399970769882,
0.3750499188899994,
-0.7836786508560181,
0.06825129687786102,
0.13933221995830536,
0.12711763381958008,
0.03378205746412277,
-0.10166793316602707,
0.7465327382087708,
0.2563610374927521,
-0.4232044517993927,
-1.0117156505584717,
-0.097289077937603,
-1.2557212114334106,
-0.34864726662635803,
0.7813377380371094,
-0.20942772924900055,
-0.18150362372398376,
-0.09922902286052704,
-0.2996295690536499,
-0.10275454074144363,
-0.48210716247558594,
0.4741480052471161,
0.3770861029624939,
-0.3809225559234619,
0.2969013452529907,
-0.7656782269477844,
-0.06883940100669861,
0.026218673214316368,
-1.038175106048584,
0.06725297123193741,
0.6906093955039978,
0.17639204859733582,
0.4002745747566223,
0.7293555736541748,
0.39565256237983704,
0.465006023645401,
0.3521810472011566,
0.5433380603790283,
-0.558628499507904,
-0.5326501727104187,
0.12510105967521667,
0.49873030185699463,
-0.0842328667640686,
-0.4289652109146118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07965v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07965v2
|
Rho-1: Not All Tokens Are What You Need
| 2024-04-11T17:52:01 | 2024-05-23T06:57:07 |
Zhenghao Lin, Zhibin Gou, Yeyun Gong, Xiao Liu, Yelong Shen, Ruochen Xu, Chen Lin, Yujiu Yang, Jian Jiao, Nan Duan, Weizhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Previous language model pre-training methods have uniformly applied a
next-token prediction loss to all training tokens. Challenging this norm, we
posit that ''Not all tokens in a corpus are equally important for language
model training''. Our initial analysis examines token-level training dynamics
of language model, revealing distinct loss patterns for different tokens.
Leveraging these insights, we introduce a new language model called Rho-1.
Unlike traditional LMs that learn to predict every next token in a corpus,
Rho-1 employs Selective Language Modeling (SLM), which selectively trains on
useful tokens that aligned with the desired distribution. This approach
involves scoring pretraining tokens using a reference model, and then training
the language model with a focused loss on tokens with higher scores. When
continual pretraining on 15B OpenWebMath corpus, Rho-1 yields an absolute
improvement in few-shot accuracy of up to 30% in 9 math tasks. After
fine-tuning, Rho-1-1B and 7B achieved state-of-the-art results of 40.6% and
51.8% on MATH dataset, respectively - matching DeepSeekMath with only 3% of the
pretraining tokens. Furthermore, when pretraining on 80B general tokens, Rho-1
achieves 6.8% average enhancement across 15 diverse tasks, increasing both
efficiency and performance of the language model pre-training.
|
[
-0.17038753628730774,
-0.7039106488227844,
0.1311509609222412,
0.0650450587272644,
-0.49393871426582336,
0.1819673478603363,
0.04094333574175835,
-0.30687177181243896,
0.31707099080085754,
0.478553831577301,
-0.6654893755912781,
-0.669875979423523,
-0.8259602785110474,
-0.09540572762489319,
-0.4731632173061371,
1.026198148727417,
0.08764539659023285,
0.3287951946258545,
-0.17874537408351898,
-0.29846319556236267,
-0.4227515459060669,
-0.6777029037475586,
-0.6015763878822327,
-0.39723244309425354,
0.713196337223053,
0.336525022983551,
0.4209284782409668,
0.8440191149711609,
0.6351580023765564,
0.10139439254999161,
0.04174061864614487,
-0.09774987399578094,
-0.6582366824150085,
0.022810762748122215,
0.06609378755092621,
-0.7236267328262329,
-0.4378001391887665,
0.08288335800170898,
0.6280643343925476,
0.8156135678291321,
-0.38956332206726074,
0.3934381306171417,
-0.2602490484714508,
0.5898829102516174,
-0.7737802267074585,
-0.16388064622879028,
-0.9735232591629028,
0.2144770473241806,
-0.6044249534606934,
-0.18048392236232758,
-0.544811487197876,
-0.19188271462917328,
0.05684163048863411,
-0.7119210362434387,
0.24380818009376526,
0.3855205774307251,
0.7094358205795288,
0.29878923296928406,
-0.06524412333965302,
-0.12370917946100235,
-0.2069644033908844,
0.9339116215705872,
-0.6321941018104553,
0.5806940793991089,
0.4972994029521942,
0.08573772013187408,
0.09397481381893158,
-0.6795740723609924,
-0.2836703658103943,
-0.13215307891368866,
0.04676327481865883,
0.13366545736789703,
-0.10724867880344391,
0.13281279802322388,
0.0434829406440258,
0.02276115119457245,
-0.4530324637889862,
0.2689497768878937,
-0.35795116424560547,
-0.49639612436294556,
0.08025544881820679,
0.3145217299461365,
0.1571808159351349,
0.10321816056966782,
-0.3866347670555115,
-0.1660718470811844,
-0.6199618577957153,
0.062167298048734665,
0.39630430936813354,
0.5296010375022888,
-0.04646465927362442,
0.37532901763916016,
0.2755727171897888,
0.6994490027427673,
-0.18538843095302582,
-0.3290160894393921,
-0.0824117511510849,
-0.18060913681983948,
-0.15108230710029602,
0.06720563024282455,
0.6413859128952026,
-0.0037067821249365807,
0.4178692400455475,
-0.23636236786842346,
-0.18506215512752533,
0.18713808059692383,
0.3232198655605316,
-0.8487736582756042,
-0.1577426940202713,
0.024839822202920914,
-0.527026355266571,
-0.3403957188129425,
0.08465375751256943,
-0.48943471908569336,
-0.268812894821167,
-0.2213403582572937,
0.12326471507549286,
-0.39209726452827454,
-0.5048548579216003,
0.08697275072336197,
-0.01966041512787342,
0.127012237906456,
0.23524712026119232,
-0.983281135559082,
0.641391932964325,
0.8551079630851746,
0.9110801815986633,
-0.6076557636260986,
-0.7279771566390991,
-0.7734143137931824,
-0.4372979402542114,
-0.8279535174369812,
0.8688471913337708,
-0.6780650019645691,
-0.3192209005355835,
0.12320814281702042,
-0.298149436712265,
-0.15755309164524078,
-0.5520220398902893,
0.2737811505794525,
-0.5672013759613037,
0.002828601049259305,
-0.03479107841849327,
-0.6132050156593323,
0.13333049416542053,
0.15859025716781616,
-0.5881830453872681,
1.1236207485198975,
0.17861296236515045,
-0.810630202293396,
0.7470115423202515,
-0.3743464946746826,
-0.42728063464164734,
-0.055253006517887115,
-0.048705123364925385,
-0.4935338497161865,
0.3654024004936218,
0.030907534062862396,
0.215219184756279,
-0.20037299394607544,
0.1477515548467636,
-0.4678727984428406,
-0.4335480332374573,
0.1754383146762848,
-0.1849602907896042,
0.4509872794151306,
0.1337554156780243,
0.006725165992975235,
0.3009551167488098,
-0.8783601522445679,
0.24020850658416748,
-0.0005963658331893384,
-0.37006086111068726,
-0.1528770625591278,
-0.2948429584503174,
0.22085101902484894,
0.12265598028898239,
0.09744245558977127,
-0.5197041034698486,
0.13897253572940826,
-0.6335556507110596,
0.1558377742767334,
0.889271080493927,
-0.3419042229652405,
0.7197763323783875,
-0.19194744527339935,
1.0767724514007568,
0.23902413249015808,
0.11415055394172668,
-0.2611553966999054,
-0.35204994678497314,
-0.7372705936431885,
-0.3709357976913452,
0.535647451877594,
0.5781189799308777,
-0.19081322848796844,
0.2717786133289337,
-0.21760447323322296,
-0.5427588820457458,
-0.8253146409988403,
0.18244658410549164,
0.677263617515564,
0.5880565047264099,
0.28407609462738037,
-0.35483264923095703,
-0.926787257194519,
-0.8060820698738098,
-0.4767521917819977,
-0.06748669594526291,
0.43631282448768616,
-0.173171728849411,
0.4313901960849762,
-0.16321450471878052,
1.2454766035079956,
-0.17572209239006042,
-0.28741660714149475,
-0.4890177547931671,
0.11133666336536407,
0.10420257598161697,
0.3953021168708801,
0.4918324649333954,
-0.33264055848121643,
-0.44374725222587585,
0.06186883896589279,
-0.48225077986717224,
-0.02239857241511345,
0.0758306011557579,
-0.06914454698562622,
0.2854653298854828,
0.46237099170684814,
-0.2026190608739853,
0.5328987836837769,
0.6558247208595276,
-0.08334596455097198,
0.3549549877643585,
-0.2033921480178833,
-0.38497453927993774,
-0.8541298508644104,
0.18517667055130005,
-0.311933696269989,
-0.27685245871543884,
-0.544142484664917,
-0.02946518175303936,
0.13743944466114044,
-0.2800726592540741,
-0.6572023630142212,
1.1707007884979248,
-0.21503393352031708,
-0.187994122505188,
-0.3538403809070587,
0.11202266812324524,
-0.11871638149023056,
0.7659352421760559,
-0.016626300290226936,
0.8180216550827026,
0.9006568789482117,
-0.6704152226448059,
-0.1269657015800476,
0.17652659118175507,
-0.4159396290779114,
-0.025272218510508537,
-0.6330106258392334,
0.3267929255962372,
-0.31840765476226807,
0.04685794189572334,
-0.9066020846366882,
0.11148270219564438,
0.0851488783955574,
-0.5996121168136597,
0.4186197817325592,
0.01853836514055729,
-0.26898622512817383,
-0.17629477381706238,
-0.22605818510055542,
0.43316906690597534,
0.48765596747398376,
-0.2619994878768921,
0.6273863911628723,
0.38229504227638245,
-0.05022618547081947,
-1.0163021087646484,
-0.8784250617027283,
-0.2005559802055359,
-0.10104437917470932,
-0.15808507800102234,
0.100283682346344,
0.03412764519453049,
-0.12655530869960785,
-0.015832144767045975,
-0.367554634809494,
-0.1185593381524086,
0.28392502665519714,
0.25274112820625305,
0.2045113742351532,
-0.030978497117757797,
0.24175575375556946,
-0.15316885709762573,
-0.502963662147522,
-0.17640094459056854,
-0.39023229479789734,
0.7758171558380127,
0.003944779746234417,
-0.4662216901779175,
-0.6114693284034729,
0.2738634943962097,
0.48352599143981934,
-0.3224281072616577,
0.9063996076583862,
0.5646684169769287,
-0.2845744490623474,
-0.1078137680888176,
-0.5178079009056091,
-0.21109077334403992,
-0.3376159071922302,
0.7609440088272095,
-0.6248385906219482,
-0.8066795468330383,
0.8541341423988342,
0.09668637812137604,
0.1887284219264984,
0.3363313674926758,
0.3883649706840515,
0.2217966914176941,
1.0519658327102661,
0.8058733940124512,
-0.2243371456861496,
0.8246870040893555,
-0.20172271132469177,
0.20952771604061127,
-0.6428573131561279,
-0.1263510137796402,
-0.4956868588924408,
-0.1289769560098648,
-0.4224947392940521,
-0.05686606094241142,
0.08097448945045471,
0.33272525668144226,
-0.24941585958003998,
0.22882486879825592,
-0.3957194983959198,
0.4917689859867096,
0.6350686550140381,
0.04491155594587326,
-0.0040965611115098,
0.18812386691570282,
-0.2793169915676117,
-0.17861497402191162,
-1.1509360074996948,
-0.39485225081443787,
1.3363488912582397,
0.49552035331726074,
0.9409827589988708,
-0.17374518513679504,
0.9333528280258179,
0.13304826617240906,
0.6983017325401306,
-0.945130467414856,
0.4554603695869446,
-0.11077342182397842,
-0.7548084855079651,
-0.5018421411514282,
-0.39682939648628235,
-1.130086898803711,
0.20146168768405914,
-0.26771098375320435,
-0.3089312016963959,
-0.18772941827774048,
0.2057766169309616,
-0.39995530247688293,
0.2436111867427826,
-0.5545606017112732,
0.872904360294342,
-0.1096426323056221,
-0.23795567452907562,
-0.2062988579273224,
-0.5653467178344727,
0.1419162154197693,
-0.25909700989723206,
0.40108683705329895,
-0.1759587973356247,
-0.14172132313251495,
0.9016897082328796,
-0.5776151418685913,
0.8005331754684448,
-0.16176383197307587,
-0.009610936045646667,
0.4830264747142792,
0.2228482961654663,
0.5234313011169434,
-0.16523735225200653,
-0.2026771903038025,
0.20380602777004242,
0.06822177022695541,
-0.722885251045227,
-0.5955960750579834,
0.26597848534584045,
-0.8196799755096436,
-0.3719363510608673,
-0.4953233599662781,
-0.17250163853168488,
0.027640772983431816,
0.244630366563797,
0.4968295693397522,
0.7643449902534485,
-0.2557610273361206,
0.20742027461528778,
0.4646906852722168,
-0.07889451831579208,
0.22403837740421295,
0.2586056888103485,
-0.4546327590942383,
-0.6269612312316895,
0.7512320280075073,
-0.00669766403734684,
0.44638022780418396,
0.6088995337486267,
0.3933725357055664,
-0.48632726073265076,
-0.6745573282241821,
-0.29862064123153687,
0.1936277151107788,
-1.0838207006454468,
-0.25750014185905457,
-0.6766940355300903,
0.02774793840944767,
-0.7353050112724304,
-0.045970115810632706,
-0.516669750213623,
-0.2235063761472702,
-0.2326807826757431,
-0.250842809677124,
0.30607151985168457,
0.5786904692649841,
-0.03753761574625969,
0.474347323179245,
-0.7828603386878967,
0.10667754709720612,
0.38778042793273926,
0.5137917399406433,
0.0833243727684021,
-0.8392385244369507,
-0.2794629633426666,
-0.07238098978996277,
0.15981438755989075,
-0.6079273819923401,
0.368422269821167,
0.28879839181900024,
0.7512053847312927,
0.2168830931186676,
-0.3046204447746277,
0.87257981300354,
-0.5835040211677551,
0.5902667045593262,
0.5627907514572144,
-0.9173614978790283,
0.5056132078170776,
-0.1840677261352539,
0.27014273405075073,
0.8495022058486938,
0.034184619784355164,
-0.46674033999443054,
-0.14809654653072357,
-0.6074281930923462,
-0.505311906337738,
1.0174510478973389,
-0.04240516573190689,
0.25481414794921875,
-0.2831406891345978,
0.4546229839324951,
0.27016985416412354,
0.2356303185224533,
-0.9087279438972473,
-0.4412756562232971,
-0.4162712097167969,
-0.24456682801246643,
0.02057821862399578,
-0.1589445322751999,
0.1311037391424179,
-0.2518504858016968,
0.6041558384895325,
-0.13949228823184967,
0.08754000812768936,
0.013438551686704159,
-0.2839134931564331,
-0.2589096426963806,
0.048846714198589325,
0.6434966325759888,
0.9336151480674744,
-0.1584015190601349,
0.0359005331993103,
0.37703555822372437,
-0.6483194231987,
-0.06631766259670258,
-0.3128340244293213,
0.16603979468345642,
0.18588241934776306,
0.7783033847808838,
1.160570740699768,
0.5306151509284973,
-0.7787681221961975,
0.46234431862831116,
0.08447998017072678,
-0.22647777199745178,
-0.11049699038267136,
-0.005290079861879349,
-0.19470497965812683,
-0.31331825256347656,
0.3816046714782715,
0.07224074006080627,
-0.43205565214157104,
-0.8899519443511963,
0.23161447048187256,
0.37655970454216003,
-0.41949453949928284,
-0.23996460437774658,
0.5763221979141235,
0.06294871866703033,
-0.618187427520752,
0.5475398302078247,
-0.26560279726982117,
-0.6068973541259766,
0.6486217975616455,
0.6943288445472717,
0.8357418179512024,
-0.20244519412517548,
0.06350892782211304,
0.5936475992202759,
0.19444639980793,
-0.21450531482696533,
0.1218566745519638,
0.04972678795456886,
-0.7236382961273193,
-0.4450750946998596,
-0.9950317144393921,
-0.5306459665298462,
-0.14830166101455688,
-0.7102561593055725,
0.49713096022605896,
-0.606082022190094,
-0.12298031896352768,
-0.2593330144882202,
-0.032765962183475494,
-0.8577536940574646,
0.24631480872631073,
-0.1462005376815796,
0.8951314091682434,
-0.6151577830314636,
1.07081937789917,
0.6296621561050415,
-0.33601561188697815,
-0.7122180461883545,
-0.458220899105072,
-0.46323493123054504,
-1.2278075218200684,
0.8669933676719666,
0.042015355080366135,
-0.0914100855588913,
0.36769574880599976,
-0.40915948152542114,
-1.0216310024261475,
0.8782594799995422,
0.3834223747253418,
-0.7816921472549438,
-0.07091692090034485,
0.20579984784126282,
0.3794080317020416,
-0.5442302823066711,
0.3079156279563904,
0.37886756658554077,
0.26307931542396545,
0.05905238538980484,
-0.856446385383606,
-0.35648149251937866,
-0.06213272362947464,
0.022920232266187668,
0.4732048511505127,
-0.3712295591831207,
1.0114270448684692,
-0.25042229890823364,
-0.3771730363368988,
0.07592238485813141,
0.5844739675521851,
0.5168265104293823,
0.317010760307312,
0.5524200201034546,
0.617283821105957,
0.7443556189537048,
0.138278990983963,
1.1406304836273193,
-0.42380303144454956,
0.36827805638313293,
1.1069316864013672,
-0.13161127269268036,
0.9006500840187073,
0.3741627335548401,
-0.38947612047195435,
0.4052746593952179,
0.631597101688385,
0.40638500452041626,
0.5382870435714722,
0.2819210886955261,
0.06900623440742493,
-0.6099542379379272,
0.14427146315574646,
-0.34805235266685486,
0.4071895480155945,
0.14985309541225433,
-0.0179873239248991,
-0.2372969388961792,
0.28486597537994385,
-0.05348639562726021,
0.2431877702474594,
-0.2767850458621979,
0.663589596748352,
0.13758344948291779,
-0.7946726083755493,
0.6078357696533203,
-0.15894615650177002,
0.870712161064148,
-0.9953247904777527,
0.21872766315937042,
-0.43219467997550964,
0.16588447988033295,
-0.02320345677435398,
-0.3098295032978058,
0.3581453859806061,
-0.03931594267487526,
-0.05287604033946991,
-0.41133877635002136,
0.6320191025733948,
-0.22865284979343414,
-0.5886534452438354,
0.31202730536460876,
0.6959843635559082,
0.31025999784469604,
-0.11987173557281494,
-0.7208932638168335,
0.17526422441005707,
-0.20868825912475586,
-0.19593149423599243,
0.5079988241195679,
0.3568377196788788,
0.07050030678510666,
0.702308177947998,
0.8110743165016174,
0.18290287256240845,
0.34403151273727417,
0.4757811427116394,
0.6380834579467773,
-0.7265410423278809,
-0.4336141347885132,
-0.8073115944862366,
0.3219940960407257,
0.18934926390647888,
-0.7905970215797424,
0.5265329480171204,
0.5288594365119934,
0.7558445930480957,
0.006121870130300522,
0.611436128616333,
0.3242017328739166,
0.7377446293830872,
-0.48992013931274414,
0.3763974905014038,
-0.6027030944824219,
-0.05570370331406593,
-0.0645492821931839,
-0.9219651818275452,
-0.452604204416275,
0.7851623296737671,
0.06254412233829498,
-0.03327009081840515,
0.9112672805786133,
0.7767118811607361,
0.20826129615306854,
-0.2552069425582886,
0.5816868543624878,
-0.15742599964141846,
0.20738813281059265,
0.300285667181015,
0.7577932476997375,
-0.6476085782051086,
0.6961407661437988,
-0.058986980468034744,
-0.10550689697265625,
-0.21488748490810394,
-0.7461661100387573,
-1.0656890869140625,
-0.46424099802970886,
-0.22234933078289032,
-0.15005311369895935,
-0.027621354907751083,
0.9995682239532471,
0.9296748042106628,
-0.7955982089042664,
-0.13642913103103638,
-0.48416802287101746,
-0.019241277128458023,
-0.2655336260795593,
-0.14590801298618317,
0.19707468152046204,
-0.8189355134963989,
-0.6324065923690796,
0.2615211009979248,
0.19775032997131348,
0.03887634351849556,
-0.44030994176864624,
-0.09964019805192947,
-0.14328962564468384,
-0.02169898711144924,
0.4826158285140991,
0.22512778639793396,
-0.9383409023284912,
-0.11657196283340454,
0.47985631227493286,
-0.18609021604061127,
0.06769712269306183,
0.9856696128845215,
-0.9117335677146912,
0.4080153703689575,
0.42139145731925964,
0.6967144012451172,
0.5380560159683228,
-0.12368077784776688,
0.3221721053123474,
-0.736420214176178,
0.49868494272232056,
0.3553614914417267,
0.31032806634902954,
0.1481652408838272,
0.030859701335430145,
0.4807884991168976,
0.239456906914711,
-0.3579455018043518,
-1.0390478372573853,
0.2805309295654297,
-0.9114311337471008,
-0.3416116535663605,
1.0025357007980347,
-0.052951447665691376,
-0.2734714448451996,
-0.11542636901140213,
-0.16230972111225128,
0.3485516309738159,
-0.33206069469451904,
0.5883439183235168,
0.9469395279884338,
0.1190873309969902,
-0.21601402759552002,
-0.3615169823169708,
0.4417966306209564,
0.7874775528907776,
-0.6135167479515076,
0.18218663334846497,
0.05095253139734268,
0.2540459632873535,
0.2255553901195526,
0.9283468723297119,
0.08451028168201447,
0.13975824415683746,
0.2848789691925049,
0.11070212721824646,
-0.12427259236574173,
-0.534043550491333,
-0.3423876166343689,
0.1673451066017151,
0.23683956265449524,
-0.3102353513240814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08707v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08707v4
|
Large Language Model Can Continue Evolving From Mistakes
| 2024-04-11T17:44:56 | 2024-06-17T11:32:29 |
Haokun Zhao, Haixia Han, Jie Shi, Chengyu Du, Jiaqing Liang, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
As world knowledge evolves and new task paradigms emerge, Continual Learning
(CL) is crucial for keeping Large Language Models (LLMs) up-to-date and
addressing their shortcomings. In practical applications, LLMs often require
both continual instruction tuning (CIT) and continual pre-training (CPT) to
adapt to new task paradigms and acquire necessary knowledge for task-solving.
However, it remains challenging to collect CPT data that addresses the
knowledge deficiencies in models while maintaining adequate volume, and
improving the efficiency of utilizing this data also presents significant
difficulties. Inspired by the 'summarizing mistakes' learning skill, we propose
the Continue Evolving from Mistakes (CEM) method, aiming to provide a
data-efficient approach for collecting CPT data and continually improving LLMs'
performance through iterative evaluation and supplementation with
mistake-relevant knowledge. To efficiently utilize these CPT data and mitigate
forgetting, we design a novel CL training set construction paradigm that
integrates parallel CIT and CPT data. Extensive experiments demonstrate the
efficacy of the CEM method, achieving up to a 17% improvement in accuracy in
the best case. Furthermore, additional experiments confirm the potential of
combining CEM with catastrophic forgetting mitigation methods, enabling
iterative and continual model evolution.
|
[
-0.016217704862356186,
-0.7413510084152222,
0.49551963806152344,
0.29839199781417847,
-0.23768562078475952,
0.35874536633491516,
-0.6600762009620667,
-0.008538867346942425,
-0.29297325015068054,
0.46957477927207947,
-0.6646050214767456,
-0.4234582781791687,
-0.5702502131462097,
-0.16054213047027588,
-0.02916654571890831,
0.9162840247154236,
-0.10424032062292099,
0.16578169167041779,
-0.30251017212867737,
-0.2371107041835785,
-1.0652728080749512,
-0.501911461353302,
-1.1200799942016602,
-0.17739586532115936,
0.4193175137042999,
0.7564793229103088,
0.3881399631500244,
0.7559633851051331,
0.2684785723686218,
0.25846314430236816,
-0.056542642414569855,
0.47106608748435974,
-0.7876671552658081,
0.06231699511408806,
-0.4839153289794922,
-0.44261687994003296,
-0.24789787828922272,
-0.30710288882255554,
0.9460596442222595,
0.8457064032554626,
-0.3689934015274048,
0.009185305796563625,
0.34767839312553406,
0.7777660489082336,
-0.5608423352241516,
0.2889677882194519,
-0.9385272860527039,
-0.12823691964149475,
-0.17881089448928833,
-0.28910934925079346,
-0.5459191203117371,
-0.267222136259079,
0.14692524075508118,
-0.4188208281993866,
0.2732028067111969,
-0.09965190291404724,
0.6200845241546631,
0.3951021432876587,
0.19585244357585907,
-0.3834378719329834,
-0.6926085948944092,
0.9853326678276062,
-0.7666686177253723,
0.44807812571525574,
0.14787137508392334,
0.15381421148777008,
-0.2063804417848587,
-0.522185206413269,
-0.45637866854667664,
-0.29525986313819885,
0.29737111926078796,
0.16781717538833618,
0.323209285736084,
-0.34749308228492737,
0.0787581130862236,
0.12303303182125092,
-0.5996830463409424,
0.18324558436870575,
-0.3540020287036896,
-0.027270786464214325,
0.4737730026245117,
0.12299665063619614,
0.40418103337287903,
0.5846105217933655,
-0.3146905303001404,
-0.3544151186943054,
-1.1190828084945679,
-0.1413871794939041,
-0.03944668173789978,
0.30575332045555115,
-0.12405192106962204,
-0.006529191974550486,
0.20243851840496063,
0.7398248910903931,
-0.07310980558395386,
-0.28543952107429504,
0.30485036969184875,
-0.27482542395591736,
-0.1369163990020752,
-0.013433934189379215,
0.5425399541854858,
0.04655618965625763,
0.4397275149822235,
-0.1547899693250656,
-0.16187484562397003,
-0.0796249657869339,
0.4600341320037842,
-0.27091100811958313,
-0.5249213576316833,
-0.10290905833244324,
-0.10924486070871353,
0.024591555818915367,
-0.18857072293758392,
-0.589989423751831,
-0.11213276535272598,
-0.6966797709465027,
0.30218058824539185,
-0.7056655287742615,
-0.22928093373775482,
0.24171221256256104,
0.08484451472759247,
0.07034154236316681,
0.2504316568374634,
-0.6946089267730713,
0.03668270260095596,
0.5892283916473389,
0.8146754503250122,
-0.20047760009765625,
-0.5977752208709717,
-0.5646931529045105,
0.20336870849132538,
-0.6523482203483582,
0.7035355567932129,
-0.32287290692329407,
-0.5180630683898926,
-0.008356687612831593,
0.09174123406410217,
-0.4919971525669098,
-0.8214188814163208,
0.3596187233924866,
-0.49118438363075256,
-0.01483279187232256,
-0.531421959400177,
-0.6436406970024109,
-0.08126389980316162,
0.4442192018032074,
-0.3672826290130615,
0.7690294981002808,
0.18008437752723694,
-0.5861897468566895,
0.3774629235267639,
-0.45111167430877686,
-0.17677150666713715,
0.15495310723781586,
-0.09556417912244797,
-0.8498995304107666,
0.18092764914035797,
0.21424667537212372,
0.3344772160053253,
-0.04332152009010315,
0.2893719971179962,
-0.3525925278663635,
-0.2871367037296295,
-0.0442182794213295,
-0.3542376458644867,
0.6129862070083618,
-0.2235431671142578,
-0.320234090089798,
-0.2076045423746109,
-0.50703364610672,
-0.06441681832075119,
0.2633552849292755,
-0.45584169030189514,
-0.25693944096565247,
0.3068470060825348,
-0.44788023829460144,
0.42019152641296387,
0.4088188409805298,
-0.4350002706050873,
0.15527677536010742,
-0.23534232378005981,
0.17124421894550323,
0.8599418997764587,
0.2588486969470978,
0.10468541830778122,
-0.8400638103485107,
0.27312543988227844,
0.29610952734947205,
0.12075138837099075,
-0.44680434465408325,
-0.04825471341609955,
-1.1900111436843872,
0.16040335595607758,
0.062062159180641174,
0.7171401381492615,
-0.8121263384819031,
0.40203461050987244,
-0.6928008198738098,
-0.66785728931427,
-0.0056131999008357525,
0.44655346870422363,
0.6178574562072754,
0.48682358860969543,
0.6197803020477295,
-0.17947277426719666,
-0.6266493201255798,
-0.5222477912902832,
-0.18227925896644592,
-0.1245136559009552,
0.2494126558303833,
0.054185133427381516,
0.42188116908073425,
-0.24786119163036346,
0.7983222007751465,
-0.2309328019618988,
-0.047670878469944,
-0.2581256628036499,
0.08417868614196777,
0.030413201078772545,
0.8703606724739075,
0.3029365539550781,
-0.45530515909194946,
-0.5754483938217163,
0.0649961605668068,
-0.8499482274055481,
0.16632361710071564,
-0.4980407655239105,
-0.1308777630329132,
0.1596788763999939,
0.6006709337234497,
-0.3478959798812866,
-0.02100096084177494,
0.37543120980262756,
-0.09761664271354675,
0.7482161521911621,
-0.3537362813949585,
-0.012569871731102467,
-0.8849598169326782,
-0.20227020978927612,
-0.35304513573646545,
-0.24809584021568298,
-0.3324579894542694,
-0.15162955224514008,
0.36855438351631165,
0.1747710257768631,
-0.3663412034511566,
0.4788413643836975,
-0.6416235566139221,
0.23113073408603668,
-0.33109280467033386,
0.01795506849884987,
-0.3860372006893158,
0.5534597635269165,
0.1213143914937973,
0.6724967956542969,
0.7667797803878784,
-0.8672694563865662,
-0.011782649904489517,
0.26006776094436646,
-0.14767758548259735,
0.4585595428943634,
-0.2542143762111664,
0.3079606592655182,
-0.2291964441537857,
-0.0466960072517395,
-0.48452284932136536,
-0.029125388711690903,
-0.039924610406160355,
-0.39324837923049927,
0.6826363205909729,
0.05387849360704422,
-0.5085753202438354,
-0.35779374837875366,
-0.10439103096723557,
0.17234501242637634,
0.6539366245269775,
-0.8698081374168396,
0.37503284215927124,
0.12557628750801086,
-0.5583212971687317,
-0.6153858304023743,
-0.3598231077194214,
0.0671747699379921,
-0.1867131143808365,
-0.48034927248954773,
0.1684824526309967,
-0.369549036026001,
-0.008641809225082397,
-0.26254910230636597,
-0.28842929005622864,
0.21909703314304352,
-0.06033916398882866,
-0.08416790515184402,
0.3128519356250763,
-0.11469727754592896,
0.3975663483142853,
-0.012353894300758839,
-0.005571404937654734,
-0.04036397486925125,
-0.5732820630073547,
0.6913394331932068,
-0.08803020417690277,
-0.20335963368415833,
-0.2636314034461975,
0.1432667374610901,
0.5006120800971985,
-0.07686425745487213,
0.7847942113876343,
0.14076152443885803,
-0.3010454773902893,
-0.5872615575790405,
-0.7598394751548767,
-0.029235288500785828,
-0.4451678991317749,
0.4991767108440399,
-0.26176291704177856,
-0.8440902233123779,
0.39734187722206116,
-0.25211042165756226,
0.5506904125213623,
0.2983699142932892,
0.4578019976615906,
-0.35283008217811584,
0.5812710523605347,
0.8805627822875977,
-0.22892220318317413,
0.48664119839668274,
-0.11503065377473831,
0.0258624367415905,
-0.7173455357551575,
-0.08796343207359314,
-0.26594823598861694,
-0.04044325649738312,
-0.08462516218423843,
-0.3883917033672333,
0.32430627942085266,
0.46258544921875,
-0.611674964427948,
0.3417728543281555,
-0.2857608199119568,
0.4547920227050781,
0.24452802538871765,
0.39368510246276855,
0.25896093249320984,
0.038515836000442505,
0.01742621324956417,
0.006849979516118765,
-0.8875628709793091,
-0.25784969329833984,
1.2190513610839844,
0.28803330659866333,
0.5444950461387634,
-0.07798024266958237,
0.7006571888923645,
0.14368019998073578,
0.6028372645378113,
-0.24572284519672394,
0.32180699706077576,
-0.1310032457113266,
-0.03742583841085434,
-0.2615366578102112,
-0.512061357498169,
-0.6855082511901855,
-0.06885400414466858,
0.22821259498596191,
-0.6350867748260498,
0.08132577687501907,
0.7561285495758057,
-0.16141963005065918,
0.4395219385623932,
-0.4347052574157715,
0.7754703164100647,
-0.3479314148426056,
-0.3451765179634094,
-0.3292531967163086,
-0.46756309270858765,
0.3461754322052002,
-0.5623435974121094,
0.28298214077949524,
0.15835250914096832,
-0.05037214979529381,
0.7025314569473267,
-0.5477541089057922,
0.9464000463485718,
-0.12283635884523392,
-0.027124669402837753,
0.4587165415287018,
0.027562759816646576,
0.7499633431434631,
0.08454493433237076,
0.12888649106025696,
0.1907067447900772,
-0.22752709686756134,
-0.6345083117485046,
-0.46218663454055786,
0.7359884977340698,
-0.6638985276222229,
-0.4270802438259125,
-0.2430138736963272,
-0.5713460445404053,
-0.5771337151527405,
0.0010576583445072174,
0.47830337285995483,
0.33915773034095764,
-0.0827314630150795,
0.23465076088905334,
0.9812639951705933,
-0.3073030412197113,
0.6446176171302795,
0.463908851146698,
0.1979491114616394,
-0.4116321802139282,
1.0707029104232788,
0.19274289906024933,
0.4842091202735901,
0.15608662366867065,
0.18014869093894958,
-0.16899433732032776,
-0.789297342300415,
-0.27360135316848755,
0.3528329133987427,
-0.7132291793823242,
-0.31889626383781433,
-0.6538118124008179,
-0.2351098656654358,
-0.165769562125206,
-0.46769896149635315,
-0.6251553297042847,
0.26922234892845154,
-0.01476300973445177,
0.03819317743182182,
0.20807741582393646,
0.3142837882041931,
-0.23322804272174835,
0.46769726276397705,
-1.0926767587661743,
-0.2225424200296402,
0.24339225888252258,
0.19623683393001556,
0.051589805632829666,
-0.6017560958862305,
-0.5889007449150085,
0.1509557068347931,
-0.38325366377830505,
-0.5932965874671936,
0.4522458612918854,
0.333301842212677,
0.5173631906509399,
0.052621595561504364,
-0.2968716025352478,
0.7900348901748657,
-0.5851832628250122,
0.7592894434928894,
0.2787594497203827,
-0.693423867225647,
0.45889219641685486,
-0.44619864225387573,
0.706547737121582,
0.7152302861213684,
0.2056991010904312,
-0.6087841987609863,
-0.3129481375217438,
-0.6980993747711182,
-0.7107052803039551,
0.5061070322990417,
-0.08400557190179825,
0.07461750507354736,
-0.22563914954662323,
0.46136993169784546,
0.13978321850299835,
0.12692178785800934,
-0.6854848265647888,
0.0658336952328682,
-0.09321669489145279,
-0.32101505994796753,
-0.24441415071487427,
-0.1620628833770752,
0.10408015549182892,
-0.20202180743217468,
1.0507302284240723,
-0.16168320178985596,
0.1625768095254898,
-0.12330035120248795,
-0.5150887966156006,
0.1258528083562851,
0.16349810361862183,
0.5436300039291382,
0.9802426695823669,
0.17235223948955536,
-0.15189440548419952,
0.6604872345924377,
-0.5583465099334717,
-0.001247851992957294,
-0.28481239080429077,
-0.07073290646076202,
0.016930583864450455,
0.43094706535339355,
0.5927053093910217,
0.45223698019981384,
-0.9473240971565247,
0.3695039749145508,
0.2366330921649933,
-0.16297712922096252,
-0.8991257548332214,
0.22024548053741455,
0.3486303687095642,
0.04757651686668396,
0.10383446514606476,
0.12890489399433136,
-0.5173214673995972,
-0.4304460883140564,
0.4696972370147705,
0.12154188007116318,
-0.40646854043006897,
-0.04574479162693024,
0.24657371640205383,
-0.18846376240253448,
-0.16894812881946564,
0.9201605319976807,
-0.20722012221813202,
-0.5622937083244324,
0.6843113303184509,
0.6864324808120728,
0.6894198060035706,
-0.497012734413147,
-0.04127604514360428,
0.6719185709953308,
0.2746725380420685,
-0.7501030564308167,
0.29075920581817627,
-0.11809531599283218,
-0.7889805436134338,
-0.4545324444770813,
-0.7365636825561523,
-0.32578349113464355,
0.30051255226135254,
-0.42282530665397644,
0.35667574405670166,
-0.7024086713790894,
0.40706396102905273,
-0.5787119269371033,
-0.41480252146720886,
-0.7440334558486938,
0.3779469430446625,
-0.03910840302705765,
0.7844240069389343,
-0.5622650980949402,
0.9711540937423706,
0.405362606048584,
-0.2210792452096939,
-0.948242723941803,
0.010684029199182987,
0.10186425596475601,
-0.597872793674469,
0.5409814119338989,
0.05489040166139603,
0.057908911257982254,
0.12422829866409302,
-0.5632369518280029,
-1.020804524421692,
1.0845805406570435,
0.16315530240535736,
-1.3068010807037354,
-0.08940241485834122,
-0.07551954686641693,
0.2599942088127136,
-0.37361210584640503,
-0.17109929025173187,
0.8307608962059021,
0.293056458234787,
0.11227862536907196,
-0.8143540024757385,
-0.24533934891223907,
-0.10252474248409271,
0.03591722249984741,
0.33331504464149475,
-0.6313270330429077,
0.8399840593338013,
-0.25899237394332886,
-0.25411292910575867,
0.0410538949072361,
0.49253562092781067,
0.6013253331184387,
0.06853026896715164,
0.5996887683868408,
0.8733444213867188,
0.7807793617248535,
-0.1552646905183792,
0.645606517791748,
-0.24226537346839905,
0.49377259612083435,
1.688999891281128,
-0.0665724128484726,
0.8028229475021362,
0.10618281364440918,
0.09361854940652847,
0.4258589446544647,
0.7627030611038208,
-0.19705790281295776,
0.5208960175514221,
0.33002564311027527,
-0.5228791236877441,
-0.4018247723579407,
0.5599920749664307,
-0.31558048725128174,
0.2605161964893341,
0.6200848817825317,
-0.28370121121406555,
-0.42687568068504333,
0.3304700255393982,
0.3661397099494934,
0.15465517342090607,
-0.49819403886795044,
0.7796109914779663,
0.1620291918516159,
-0.8269472718238831,
0.7331746816635132,
-0.228597953915596,
0.6767857074737549,
-0.6097689867019653,
-0.027505457401275635,
-0.17583490908145905,
0.3770306408405304,
0.13307073712348938,
-0.28420042991638184,
0.49345046281814575,
-0.10481222718954086,
-0.25783708691596985,
-0.1953989863395691,
0.36061495542526245,
-0.5525817275047302,
-0.5084327459335327,
0.18150344491004944,
0.37798869609832764,
0.05267561599612236,
0.05164213851094246,
-0.7127477526664734,
0.2393014132976532,
0.09334447234869003,
-0.014831769280135632,
0.2651573717594147,
0.19462339580059052,
-0.21537594497203827,
0.6843627691268921,
0.6289462447166443,
0.13579906523227692,
0.18129116296768188,
-0.06891558319330215,
0.7930023074150085,
-0.7173295021057129,
-0.5542014241218567,
-0.917280912399292,
0.6885578036308289,
-0.24648262560367584,
-0.5312557816505432,
0.3406752347946167,
0.43223807215690613,
1.145542025566101,
-0.2226376235485077,
0.9768094420433044,
0.1980467438697815,
0.6721417307853699,
-0.7083960771560669,
0.7356973886489868,
-0.3188536465167999,
0.36814817786216736,
-0.03963584080338478,
-1.0278488397598267,
-0.14901575446128845,
0.3990201950073242,
-0.2742619514465332,
0.07330859452486038,
0.964388370513916,
0.6900379657745361,
0.0319778211414814,
-0.06432929635047913,
0.3989824950695038,
0.37681862711906433,
0.338032066822052,
1.0019844770431519,
0.5119128227233887,
-0.26713454723358154,
0.35603225231170654,
-0.08218519389629364,
-0.3861037790775299,
0.18387532234191895,
-0.7043076753616333,
-0.847226083278656,
-0.5859654545783997,
-0.5265573263168335,
-0.18904460966587067,
0.3999766409397125,
0.7886813879013062,
0.6479921340942383,
-0.7279197573661804,
0.021649854257702827,
-0.5512024760246277,
-0.20360586047172546,
-0.4407050907611847,
-0.12749461829662323,
0.511663019657135,
-1.0806995630264282,
-0.6844732165336609,
0.6795167922973633,
0.30648699402809143,
-0.08551952242851257,
-0.06885990500450134,
-0.23486454784870148,
-0.08286533504724503,
-0.03905892372131348,
0.4885205328464508,
0.7191333770751953,
-0.34470340609550476,
-0.5399059057235718,
-0.10793638974428177,
0.18345433473587036,
0.1032826155424118,
0.7326120734214783,
-0.7850939631462097,
0.596282422542572,
0.11174419522285461,
1.0885732173919678,
0.45969271659851074,
-0.29183611273765564,
0.7297371625900269,
-0.7308470010757446,
-0.13522017002105713,
0.2321401983499527,
0.5217766165733337,
0.6027390360832214,
-0.3859609067440033,
0.3618561327457428,
0.3983801305294037,
-0.700326144695282,
-0.5710015892982483,
0.18827112019062042,
-0.860765814781189,
-0.3116339147090912,
0.7926107048988342,
-0.4053962826728821,
-0.046029046177864075,
-0.3418618142604828,
0.047034528106451035,
0.29982346296310425,
0.03207377716898918,
0.9393334984779358,
0.6878604292869568,
0.06291373819112778,
-0.4882134199142456,
-0.5707264542579651,
0.5068007111549377,
0.5475010871887207,
-0.9815036058425903,
0.1426696479320526,
0.38969558477401733,
0.7730415463447571,
0.07922372967004776,
0.5626349449157715,
-0.38526099920272827,
0.5031770467758179,
0.05114592984318733,
0.04553203284740448,
-0.010568925179541111,
-0.5964611768722534,
-0.17541734874248505,
0.14453257620334625,
0.1331663578748703,
-0.22071051597595215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07922v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07922v5
|
LaVy: Vietnamese Multimodal Large Language Model
| 2024-04-11T17:09:28 | 2024-05-26T10:27:51 |
Chi Tran, Huong Le Thanh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) and Multimodal Large language models (MLLMs)
have taken the world by storm with impressive abilities in complex reasoning
and linguistic comprehension. Meanwhile there are plethora of works related to
Vietnamese Large Language Models, the lack of high-quality resources in
multimodality limits the progress of Vietnamese MLLMs. In this paper, we
pioneer in address this by introducing LaVy, a state-of-the-art Vietnamese
MLLM, and we also introduce LaVy-Bench benchmark designated for evaluating
MLLMs's understanding on Vietnamese visual language tasks. Our project is
public at https://github.com/baochi0212/LaVy
|
[
-0.2770879864692688,
-1.0660768747329712,
0.7406666874885559,
0.291162371635437,
-0.17214161157608032,
0.1185348629951477,
-0.3605678081512451,
-0.36708319187164307,
-0.153580904006958,
0.7193195819854736,
-0.2498704493045807,
-0.5173406600952148,
-0.5111566185951233,
-0.117889404296875,
-0.4229353368282318,
0.5430607795715332,
-0.22428560256958008,
0.19741445779800415,
-0.2941349148750305,
-0.41693559288978577,
-0.13683974742889404,
-0.5393693447113037,
-0.48120608925819397,
-0.25569069385528564,
0.736479640007019,
0.20451390743255615,
0.3989677131175995,
0.6351486444473267,
0.5769007205963135,
0.33196040987968445,
-0.03035476617515087,
0.38201266527175903,
-0.7417436242103577,
0.26767072081565857,
-0.05882006138563156,
-0.6545426845550537,
-0.4666781723499298,
-0.3180598318576813,
0.7336967587471008,
0.37768417596817017,
0.07873877137899399,
0.33034548163414,
-0.29068809747695923,
0.6659846305847168,
-0.7718933820724487,
0.42292505502700806,
-0.5557705760002136,
-0.25986194610595703,
-0.19492493569850922,
-0.17606520652770996,
-0.29525309801101685,
-0.03212732821702957,
0.03676970303058624,
-0.5455859899520874,
-0.09671657532453537,
-0.08734221756458282,
0.5865895748138428,
0.41589629650115967,
-0.727389931678772,
0.12154265493154526,
-0.31581154465675354,
0.9644351601600647,
-0.5483048558235168,
0.6091361045837402,
0.25520333647727966,
0.49909311532974243,
-0.20293302834033966,
-0.8960031270980835,
-0.5501941442489624,
-0.6419795751571655,
0.14419075846672058,
0.17587584257125854,
0.0026097437366843224,
-0.05170838534832001,
0.14463208615779877,
0.19089771807193756,
-0.6389219760894775,
0.14350810647010803,
-0.4642828106880188,
-0.025922298431396484,
0.7164551019668579,
0.30773472785949707,
0.16645072400569916,
-0.07876182347536087,
-0.5962480902671814,
0.2544381618499756,
-0.4821339249610901,
0.04317007213830948,
0.07199198007583618,
0.3572060465812683,
-0.1402692049741745,
0.8636455535888672,
-0.3876410126686096,
1.044905424118042,
-0.5046604871749878,
-0.6102741956710815,
0.3625488877296448,
-0.5141233801841736,
-0.4358316659927368,
-0.29499804973602295,
0.7061194777488708,
0.5888791084289551,
0.3594358563423157,
0.24691753089427948,
-0.3562074601650238,
0.22153064608573914,
-0.018202561885118484,
-0.3594064712524414,
0.18784798681735992,
0.4039543569087982,
-0.5639317035675049,
-0.1403753161430359,
-0.04682381823658943,
-0.6077512502670288,
-0.7046285271644592,
-0.3938784599304199,
0.47914645075798035,
-0.14884111285209656,
-0.6498520374298096,
0.1907251477241516,
-0.12703193724155426,
0.4045366644859314,
0.6078628301620483,
-0.4853239357471466,
-0.130269855260849,
0.7963932752609253,
0.8784565925598145,
-0.4773557186126709,
-0.501449465751648,
-0.7557206153869629,
0.1966000497341156,
-0.18150050938129425,
0.7274602651596069,
-0.4973016083240509,
-0.2273392230272293,
0.4153312146663666,
0.11686905473470688,
0.13561898469924927,
-0.6052666902542114,
0.40744104981422424,
-0.3039584755897522,
-0.12961514294147491,
0.007854356430470943,
-0.40699315071105957,
-0.22231918573379517,
0.4496408700942993,
-0.7837017178535461,
1.1163157224655151,
0.3377331793308258,
-0.5345678925514221,
0.08380409330129623,
-0.4654127061367035,
-0.08161409944295883,
0.15926606953144073,
-0.049111172556877136,
-0.08033806085586548,
0.21429677307605743,
0.09130895882844925,
0.7515127658843994,
-0.43319422006607056,
0.3455101549625397,
-0.3868379592895508,
-0.3407788574695587,
0.43483880162239075,
-0.34094783663749695,
0.8121233582496643,
0.48101159930229187,
0.012882753275334835,
0.5889835953712463,
-0.8968775272369385,
0.03413625434041023,
0.232181116938591,
-0.48626652359962463,
-0.3164520859718323,
-0.48568475246429443,
0.6515862941741943,
0.24989673495292664,
0.607001006603241,
-0.07614731788635254,
0.2732509970664978,
0.1753007471561432,
0.5120627284049988,
0.590541422367096,
-0.3129667043685913,
0.3694796860218048,
-0.19797174632549286,
0.4584442377090454,
-0.0013238900573924184,
0.1633414626121521,
-0.4913322329521179,
-0.36784324049949646,
-1.0792487859725952,
-0.6877835988998413,
-0.09114314615726471,
0.6761778593063354,
-0.9727577567100525,
-0.01306204218417406,
-0.09132944047451019,
-0.6190295219421387,
-0.6336642503738403,
0.3838391900062561,
0.3942564129829407,
0.03895990923047066,
0.23538954555988312,
-0.07655633985996246,
-0.514818549156189,
-0.9168471097946167,
-0.3668273091316223,
-0.23850826919078827,
0.037095632404088974,
0.11775266379117966,
0.5062723755836487,
-0.574582040309906,
0.5336269736289978,
-0.24136456847190857,
-0.22154600918293,
-0.453520268201828,
-0.09474433213472366,
0.20622272789478302,
0.10642742365598679,
0.640255331993103,
-0.9113190770149231,
-0.5572128891944885,
0.06575752794742584,
-0.9160648584365845,
-0.2428438514471054,
0.09194609522819519,
-0.03686290979385376,
0.3291298449039459,
0.8915815949440002,
-0.7520046234130859,
0.2804112136363983,
0.7716281414031982,
-0.47380587458610535,
0.6916512846946716,
-0.32687661051750183,
0.10940059274435043,
-0.8724228143692017,
-0.11793669313192368,
0.14740750193595886,
-0.49172818660736084,
-0.769156277179718,
0.5151782631874084,
0.10268858075141907,
0.25741052627563477,
-0.8881452679634094,
0.976779043674469,
-0.5511493682861328,
-0.09930345416069031,
-0.18567755818367004,
0.38602423667907715,
-0.14320799708366394,
0.25824376940727234,
-0.0048520732671022415,
0.5267094373703003,
0.5445451736450195,
-0.4375664293766022,
1.0211846828460693,
-0.19953791797161102,
-0.4909476637840271,
0.8108689785003662,
-0.5594334602355957,
-0.1998211294412613,
-0.20757290720939636,
0.06622647494077682,
-0.8144195079803467,
-0.3202417492866516,
0.04081062227487564,
-0.10675263404846191,
0.11482074856758118,
-0.12347117811441422,
-0.39065682888031006,
-0.3411918878555298,
-0.23665109276771545,
0.31957268714904785,
0.28658878803253174,
-0.4770107865333557,
0.5547239184379578,
0.48659273982048035,
0.038267526775598526,
-0.7527285218238831,
-0.508668065071106,
0.14059413969516754,
-0.42332708835601807,
-0.3847423493862152,
-0.16832007467746735,
-0.15807481110095978,
-0.7457444071769714,
-0.1563510000705719,
0.24663671851158142,
-0.1937464028596878,
-0.25580692291259766,
0.1100206971168518,
0.25376325845718384,
-0.4330024719238281,
0.31398868560791016,
-0.6368764638900757,
-0.1527632623910904,
-0.15799064934253693,
-0.2831372916698456,
0.5638934969902039,
-0.4973571300506592,
-0.39240461587905884,
-0.31403863430023193,
0.15552803874015808,
0.9995359778404236,
-0.40617796778678894,
0.6829625964164734,
1.0567277669906616,
-0.1656188666820526,
0.037295207381248474,
-0.8896737694740295,
0.5290508270263672,
-0.4134509265422821,
1.0204765796661377,
-0.45471978187561035,
-1.0655642747879028,
0.19067373871803284,
-0.06791859120130539,
-0.008325640112161636,
0.21762806177139282,
1.0024086236953735,
-0.002411750378087163,
0.6017818450927734,
0.6922318935394287,
-0.05064237490296364,
0.6657615303993225,
-0.20497313141822815,
-0.15957307815551758,
-0.6081348061561584,
-0.22287139296531677,
-0.27866649627685547,
0.036176614463329315,
-0.7476001977920532,
-1.1344342231750488,
0.20774050056934357,
0.10462716221809387,
-0.4493100643157959,
0.053984761238098145,
-0.1587093621492386,
0.1778254359960556,
0.6720393896102905,
-0.06313506513834,
0.5581196546554565,
-0.06808311492204666,
0.10928517580032349,
0.11893346160650253,
-0.49457618594169617,
-0.5440484285354614,
1.1642364263534546,
0.43945935368537903,
0.9935604929924011,
0.07964412122964859,
0.5061758160591125,
0.1285131573677063,
0.09894420206546783,
-0.8609395027160645,
0.6987203359603882,
-0.158868208527565,
-0.4255215525627136,
-0.4624939560890198,
-0.43235287070274353,
-0.8147413730621338,
0.5276377201080322,
-0.32983291149139404,
-0.6646246314048767,
-0.3660338819026947,
0.05840137228369713,
0.12894506752490997,
0.24338197708129883,
-0.6558303833007812,
0.8572993278503418,
-0.7743263840675354,
-0.5316646099090576,
-0.32459738850593567,
-0.28828346729278564,
0.5653983354568481,
-0.14870783686637878,
0.4417196214199066,
-0.42300865054130554,
-0.51595538854599,
0.4277536869049072,
-0.12677501142024994,
0.5480220317840576,
-0.1885288804769516,
-0.21471050381660461,
0.4207272529602051,
-0.12456879764795303,
0.41242530941963196,
0.32332298159599304,
0.23048743605613708,
0.1878720074892044,
0.06265134364366531,
-0.5308310389518738,
-0.4901505410671234,
1.0268679857254028,
-0.8213767409324646,
-0.5601370334625244,
-0.3764086961746216,
-0.7242686748504639,
-0.09641571342945099,
0.3971668779850006,
-0.1810716986656189,
0.0732278972864151,
-0.2540774345397949,
0.25160250067710876,
0.6697850823402405,
-0.48121947050094604,
0.3767767548561096,
0.5061790347099304,
-0.8182416558265686,
-0.48917460441589355,
0.987343430519104,
0.03473342955112457,
0.36521270871162415,
0.498493492603302,
0.013740464113652706,
-0.25615254044532776,
-0.49389755725860596,
-0.2499486654996872,
0.42208823561668396,
-0.8509963750839233,
0.062248967587947845,
-0.6382281184196472,
-0.28993481397628784,
-0.12610676884651184,
-0.06544752418994904,
-0.5517956018447876,
-0.46605947613716125,
-0.11698804795742035,
0.22353191673755646,
0.3915329575538635,
1.0241060256958008,
0.24051731824874878,
0.13557463884353638,
-0.7948641180992126,
0.7144123911857605,
0.5245171785354614,
0.3490336835384369,
-0.16538351774215698,
-0.4860219955444336,
-0.27358850836753845,
-0.14980071783065796,
0.1430453658103943,
-0.3456525206565857,
0.31555894017219543,
-0.03793980926275253,
0.9280471801757812,
0.371210515499115,
-0.22934037446975708,
0.721306324005127,
-0.3424132168292999,
0.77166348695755,
0.3387027680873871,
-0.6932893395423889,
0.30929291248321533,
-0.49802088737487793,
0.7397799491882324,
0.13283492624759674,
0.13105592131614685,
-0.5379049777984619,
-0.3118387460708618,
-0.26828140020370483,
-0.7920084595680237,
0.10178141295909882,
-0.035992033779621124,
-0.11876294761896133,
0.4321784973144531,
0.12972155213356018,
0.12155849486589432,
0.3075107932090759,
-0.9626678228378296,
-0.21654412150382996,
-0.2159973531961441,
-0.25660839676856995,
-0.5254474878311157,
-0.48116448521614075,
0.0158701129257679,
-0.22177310287952423,
0.48338985443115234,
-0.2023550570011139,
0.07462222874164581,
-0.12809787690639496,
-0.3609355092048645,
0.04078206792473793,
0.30391305685043335,
0.9086480736732483,
0.837173581123352,
-0.12120614945888519,
0.3002375364303589,
0.2548774182796478,
-0.4506487250328064,
0.2277873307466507,
-0.08204236626625061,
0.04233676195144653,
-0.008516167290508747,
0.8119530081748962,
0.741360604763031,
0.01663001999258995,
-1.1285961866378784,
0.4309036135673523,
-0.12057612091302872,
-0.02545715868473053,
-0.44048163294792175,
0.07623021304607391,
0.400285542011261,
0.6644794344902039,
0.2861946225166321,
-0.21196621656417847,
-0.30318084359169006,
-0.5517295598983765,
-0.07725419849157333,
0.5706067681312561,
-0.5676059722900391,
-0.07375660538673401,
0.5341547727584839,
0.21204960346221924,
-0.1950702965259552,
0.3558672368526459,
0.20638009905815125,
-0.4153168201446533,
0.3335324227809906,
0.4172590672969818,
0.5924506187438965,
-0.18782202899456024,
0.005530789028853178,
0.46390315890312195,
0.395985871553421,
-0.2532275915145874,
0.45962008833885193,
0.20706678926944733,
-0.5004105567932129,
-0.45564964413642883,
-0.7659384608268738,
-0.14668768644332886,
0.42161402106285095,
-0.4605309069156647,
0.46606212854385376,
-0.17434047162532806,
-0.22153279185295105,
-0.3209710121154785,
-0.037227097898721695,
-0.7730967998504639,
0.11947554349899292,
0.3285517692565918,
1.0576599836349487,
-0.5449244379997253,
1.0294609069824219,
0.8848835229873657,
-0.30235621333122253,
-0.1030537337064743,
-0.2631697654724121,
0.14702361822128296,
-1.0851647853851318,
0.7779231071472168,
0.2892565131187439,
-0.11673478037118912,
-0.2645986080169678,
-0.5520804524421692,
-0.939271092414856,
0.9674919247627258,
0.45288294553756714,
-0.6456723213195801,
0.17789463698863983,
0.2145577371120453,
0.5444108247756958,
-0.4622357487678528,
0.15309223532676697,
0.6536862850189209,
0.6836994290351868,
-0.09529833495616913,
-1.2279527187347412,
-0.27724120020866394,
-0.26904988288879395,
0.12596100568771362,
-0.0893649235367775,
-0.966386616230011,
0.9853875637054443,
-0.4108744263648987,
0.2126927226781845,
0.19934074580669403,
0.6998794078826904,
0.452867329120636,
0.28294116258621216,
0.5612674355506897,
0.30800890922546387,
0.673514187335968,
-0.09634607285261154,
0.7501387000083923,
0.04665137082338333,
0.28815945982933044,
1.0660346746444702,
-0.19622507691383362,
1.1719104051589966,
0.6791185140609741,
-0.2564462721347809,
0.12470145523548126,
0.5190194249153137,
0.08710512518882751,
0.33099648356437683,
0.31062376499176025,
-0.26089221239089966,
-0.4737841486930847,
-0.3246370553970337,
-0.42406508326530457,
0.7343569397926331,
0.5325741171836853,
-0.1691996157169342,
0.26784953474998474,
0.10150828212499619,
-0.08020218461751938,
0.06674662232398987,
-0.5783688426017761,
0.5280610918998718,
0.1802154779434204,
-0.5216862559318542,
0.8600988388061523,
-0.2553353011608124,
0.6759573817253113,
-0.6156998872756958,
-0.08945392072200775,
-0.07063139230012894,
0.4292656183242798,
-0.07744790613651276,
-0.8251382112503052,
-0.1997162252664566,
-0.16076672077178955,
-0.04467279836535454,
-0.09004777669906616,
0.6317386627197266,
-0.7442658543586731,
-0.6147030591964722,
0.6106041669845581,
0.8376450538635254,
0.00018721591914072633,
0.02038789913058281,
-0.629941999912262,
0.4994252026081085,
-0.12063644826412201,
-0.4039846360683441,
0.2591201364994049,
0.5763854384422302,
-0.2089771330356598,
1.0734270811080933,
0.47966960072517395,
0.12504149973392487,
0.1505325883626938,
0.21272827684879303,
0.7480958104133606,
-0.8422524333000183,
-0.3797788918018341,
-0.8266488313674927,
0.6085101962089539,
-0.0970369428396225,
-0.14713233709335327,
0.8579386472702026,
0.4801822602748871,
0.9442367553710938,
-0.300013929605484,
1.017120122909546,
0.12210603058338165,
0.2796962559223175,
-0.5527508854866028,
0.7007930874824524,
-0.9052150845527649,
0.10386083275079727,
-0.27603721618652344,
-0.9617026448249817,
-0.5205066800117493,
0.548001766204834,
0.1566699594259262,
-0.005402731709182262,
0.6812573075294495,
0.7074050903320312,
0.09014226496219635,
-0.4598105251789093,
0.7744680643081665,
0.5621445178985596,
0.2980763912200928,
0.6118444800376892,
1.301299810409546,
-0.19478610157966614,
0.6814647316932678,
0.01906840316951275,
-0.370829313993454,
-0.5039121508598328,
-0.9036269187927246,
-1.3284153938293457,
-0.7220859527587891,
-0.020415913313627243,
-0.26917704939842224,
0.004984036087989807,
0.8855159282684326,
0.5953666567802429,
-0.6506856083869934,
-0.7013263702392578,
0.35177916288375854,
0.13328558206558228,
-0.1394881308078766,
-0.1557176560163498,
0.1938331425189972,
-0.16258534789085388,
-0.7767919301986694,
0.3957381546497345,
0.46894386410713196,
0.14003096520900726,
-0.7438486814498901,
-0.3650432527065277,
-0.41213637590408325,
-0.19798903167247772,
0.9645408987998962,
0.058076564222574234,
-1.2142654657363892,
-0.11955331265926361,
-0.008207233622670174,
-0.32239922881126404,
-0.11882392317056656,
0.8541189432144165,
-0.7535498142242432,
0.7428708672523499,
0.48415008187294006,
0.3196171522140503,
0.5539623498916626,
-0.37887078523635864,
0.5690349340438843,
-0.26730337738990784,
0.6552913784980774,
-0.21574506163597107,
0.6424230337142944,
0.454437792301178,
0.03891070932149887,
0.7448683381080627,
0.14415064454078674,
-0.523094654083252,
-0.9505042433738708,
0.23557651042938232,
-1.1832022666931152,
-0.22622127830982208,
1.33323073387146,
-0.11518216133117676,
-0.3343992233276367,
-0.23005712032318115,
-0.5615396499633789,
0.27104151248931885,
-0.21205054223537445,
0.3990226984024048,
0.5751460194587708,
-0.0007838599267415702,
-0.5238410830497742,
-1.05301034450531,
0.23105312883853912,
-0.09481935203075409,
-0.8737260103225708,
0.22551824152469635,
0.46328088641166687,
-0.04184231907129288,
0.05902498587965965,
0.6595621109008789,
0.18645671010017395,
0.2764245569705963,
0.06135176494717598,
-0.1385168880224228,
-0.18920332193374634,
-0.3100888431072235,
-0.21071773767471313,
0.11644645780324936,
0.2659991383552551,
0.23845991492271423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07921v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07921v2
|
AmpleGCG: Learning a Universal and Transferable Generative Model of Adversarial Suffixes for Jailbreaking Both Open and Closed LLMs
| 2024-04-11T17:05:50 | 2024-05-02T01:08:37 |
Zeyi Liao, Huan Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As large language models (LLMs) become increasingly prevalent and integrated
into autonomous systems, ensuring their safety is imperative. Despite
significant strides toward safety alignment, recent work
GCG~\citep{zou2023universal} proposes a discrete token optimization algorithm
and selects the single suffix with the lowest loss to successfully jailbreak
aligned LLMs. In this work, we first discuss the drawbacks of solely picking
the suffix with the lowest loss during GCG optimization for jailbreaking and
uncover the missed successful suffixes during the intermediate steps. Moreover,
we utilize those successful suffixes as training data to learn a generative
model, named AmpleGCG, which captures the distribution of adversarial suffixes
given a harmful query and enables the rapid generation of hundreds of suffixes
for any harmful queries in seconds. AmpleGCG achieves near 100\% attack success
rate (ASR) on two aligned LLMs (Llama-2-7B-chat and Vicuna-7B), surpassing two
strongest attack baselines. More interestingly, AmpleGCG also transfers
seamlessly to attack different models, including closed-source LLMs, achieving
a 99\% ASR on the latest GPT-3.5. To summarize, our work amplifies the impact
of GCG by training a generative model of adversarial suffixes that is universal
to any harmful queries and transferable from attacking open-source LLMs to
closed-source LLMs. In addition, it can generate 200 adversarial suffixes for
one harmful query in only 4 seconds, rendering it more challenging to defend.
|
[
-0.22577473521232605,
-0.8783820867538452,
0.4983564615249634,
-0.005799487233161926,
-0.18915104866027832,
0.25103095173835754,
-0.23135516047477722,
-0.2537415325641632,
-0.030179422348737717,
0.4608452022075653,
-0.6116546392440796,
-0.7523062825202942,
-0.7660253643989563,
-0.19032926857471466,
-0.5023273825645447,
1.0630993843078613,
0.178152397274971,
0.044071704149246216,
0.1553579568862915,
-0.043910738080739975,
-0.46192705631256104,
-0.6444612741470337,
-0.7317190766334534,
0.0681120753288269,
0.10805495083332062,
0.3488146662712097,
0.9759389162063599,
0.8909773826599121,
0.4587980806827545,
0.26702600717544556,
-0.12422087043523788,
0.28940728306770325,
-0.6429690718650818,
-0.12365901470184326,
-0.10398709774017334,
-0.3462807238101959,
-0.24302412569522858,
-0.012539949268102646,
0.2435823380947113,
0.412233829498291,
-0.35479992628097534,
-0.11840127408504486,
-0.04625152796506882,
0.5860714912414551,
-0.6346979141235352,
-0.40340474247932434,
-1.079764485359192,
0.09646176546812057,
-0.3196910619735718,
0.02180124819278717,
-0.37903639674186707,
-0.5204980373382568,
-0.24877235293388367,
-0.8190162777900696,
0.29120203852653503,
0.14797136187553406,
0.8150531649589539,
0.35207340121269226,
-0.28081461787223816,
-0.25993964076042175,
-0.5303395986557007,
0.4576176702976227,
-0.3238968551158905,
0.12645156681537628,
0.11863340437412262,
0.12789803743362427,
-0.6603500247001648,
-0.781521201133728,
-0.35987257957458496,
-0.4748951196670532,
0.27574363350868225,
0.05824863910675049,
-0.34928199648857117,
0.41055428981781006,
0.20272615551948547,
0.594594419002533,
-0.6243516802787781,
0.282897412776947,
-0.3497669994831085,
-0.28351151943206787,
0.5502008199691772,
0.12792059779167175,
0.6954677104949951,
0.0032171376515179873,
-0.7653061151504517,
0.1935497522354126,
-1.146884799003601,
-0.2754196226596832,
0.635775625705719,
0.2103365957736969,
-0.0655614584684372,
0.3426840901374817,
0.1515888124704361,
0.6856051087379456,
0.03895946219563484,
0.17209242284297943,
-0.09672798961400986,
-0.2275972217321396,
-0.06718982756137848,
-0.07524073123931885,
1.0188628435134888,
0.1737046241760254,
0.35444074869155884,
-0.5917432904243469,
0.10130417346954346,
0.12638017535209656,
0.5168433785438538,
-0.6186815500259399,
-0.2914905846118927,
0.061057861894369125,
-0.033889807760715485,
-0.4051198661327362,
0.20881588757038116,
-0.6327593326568604,
-0.6288955807685852,
-0.15474833548069,
0.22940200567245483,
-0.7180435657501221,
0.09133871644735336,
0.09213673323392868,
-0.05258186534047127,
0.24350771307945251,
0.011812460608780384,
-1.1302530765533447,
0.23851877450942993,
0.9487754702568054,
1.1446460485458374,
-0.1851453334093094,
-0.2708016037940979,
-0.8528764843940735,
0.28252071142196655,
-0.3698093593120575,
0.5533508062362671,
-0.2805352509021759,
-0.632569432258606,
-0.17662203311920166,
-0.053032469004392624,
-0.20593896508216858,
-0.28263425827026367,
0.6974615454673767,
-0.6190937161445618,
-0.21198783814907074,
0.007062772288918495,
-0.7642399668693542,
-0.04991009458899498,
0.14268425107002258,
-0.5747049450874329,
0.4757102429866791,
-0.05866387113928795,
-0.6894832253456116,
0.356661319732666,
-0.42585426568984985,
-0.39691653847694397,
0.17459246516227722,
-0.07341895997524261,
-0.47442057728767395,
0.23237504065036774,
0.3375717103481293,
0.25289833545684814,
-0.18220478296279907,
0.2531353831291199,
-0.5842157006263733,
-0.3965209722518921,
0.02966923639178276,
-0.36911413073539734,
0.9044157266616821,
0.3071490526199341,
-0.15641845762729645,
0.44183069467544556,
-0.4136262536048889,
-0.11571086198091507,
0.1887408345937729,
-0.19108998775482178,
-0.2981087267398834,
0.01760663092136383,
-0.25816720724105835,
-0.06635534763336182,
0.021859442815184593,
-0.5613642334938049,
0.6208212971687317,
-0.5494351983070374,
0.4640563726425171,
1.0117825269699097,
-0.0771273821592331,
0.4547435939311981,
0.007263059727847576,
0.6198610663414001,
-0.471830278635025,
0.4874279201030731,
0.23393194377422333,
-0.35373586416244507,
-0.5847461819648743,
-0.5674670338630676,
0.5224210023880005,
0.6747572422027588,
-0.6461188793182373,
0.5608701705932617,
-0.22788798809051514,
-0.3326053321361542,
-0.5368067026138306,
0.3812902867794037,
0.38425907492637634,
0.1701657474040985,
0.16134436428546906,
-0.2783487141132355,
-0.5993538498878479,
-0.6366415619850159,
-0.3880499005317688,
-0.13378189504146576,
0.04825727641582489,
0.11986584216356277,
0.347012996673584,
-0.17240114510059357,
0.4873228073120117,
-0.668630063533783,
-0.35643771290779114,
-0.177202969789505,
-0.09205833077430725,
-0.05061596632003784,
0.3824048638343811,
0.6222177743911743,
-0.706126868724823,
-0.4735172390937805,
0.09026512503623962,
-0.7694329023361206,
0.07070087641477585,
-0.10383651405572891,
-0.379660427570343,
0.02313336357474327,
0.764207124710083,
-0.7728323340415955,
0.3461504578590393,
0.4644816219806671,
-0.3208695650100708,
0.819705605506897,
-0.15977156162261963,
-0.07533501833677292,
-1.0473705530166626,
-0.11175692081451416,
-0.2305033653974533,
-0.3074033260345459,
-0.7658123970031738,
0.6694997549057007,
0.053118396550416946,
-0.02820117585361004,
-0.5525037050247192,
0.5628529787063599,
-0.5452840924263,
0.21156448125839233,
-0.3851092457771301,
0.042388252913951874,
-0.4362395107746124,
0.3487730026245117,
-0.4747602343559265,
1.0506433248519897,
0.840797483921051,
-0.4410902261734009,
0.5132082104682922,
0.2872009873390198,
-0.14059051871299744,
0.18858805298805237,
-0.5156548023223877,
0.2885721027851105,
0.10686687380075455,
-0.11762937158346176,
-0.7364299893379211,
-0.3266628086566925,
0.4220288395881653,
-0.5320037007331848,
0.4946701228618622,
-0.5126662254333496,
-0.5436680316925049,
-0.2332463413476944,
-0.359353244304657,
0.10189773887395859,
0.5989051461219788,
-1.0256246328353882,
0.41420939564704895,
0.44670453667640686,
0.17269104719161987,
-0.6561781167984009,
-0.27691444754600525,
0.23677000403404236,
-0.5612741112709045,
-0.6866929531097412,
0.49567586183547974,
0.06773638725280762,
-0.08094582706689835,
-0.01660735160112381,
-0.11391681432723999,
0.31365275382995605,
0.4262625575065613,
0.3335033059120178,
0.5292641520500183,
0.09552018344402313,
0.01215361524373293,
-0.24655945599079132,
-0.1032649502158165,
0.03389226645231247,
-0.6399131417274475,
0.4652974605560303,
-0.365731418132782,
-0.38079479336738586,
0.22225461900234222,
0.20505213737487793,
0.38058894872665405,
-0.01052805408835411,
1.0778168439865112,
0.6455632448196411,
-0.20199498534202576,
-0.24821904301643372,
-0.325927734375,
0.09200622886419296,
-0.5202388167381287,
0.3897710144519806,
-0.2878386676311493,
-1.1153842210769653,
0.5476106405258179,
-0.13322295248508453,
-0.04611280933022499,
0.39030981063842773,
0.31292375922203064,
0.4541328251361847,
1.1898934841156006,
0.8779379725456238,
-0.4931485056877136,
0.4486452043056488,
-0.12111744284629822,
0.23879773914813995,
-0.8772035241127014,
-0.1523660272359848,
-0.09787939488887787,
0.13308502733707428,
-0.7093805074691772,
-0.21978960931301117,
0.3655689060688019,
0.6256076097488403,
-0.23358598351478577,
0.2690759003162384,
-0.5747793912887573,
0.6987242698669434,
0.34711387753486633,
0.06440296769142151,
0.09621226787567139,
0.09092870354652405,
-0.21309785544872284,
0.1835681051015854,
-0.5657103657722473,
-0.32928717136383057,
1.3537591695785522,
0.16884398460388184,
0.8253186941146851,
0.3931178152561188,
0.6028170585632324,
0.2667027413845062,
0.5797443389892578,
-0.7272579669952393,
0.5351467132568359,
-0.6143968105316162,
-0.4016742706298828,
0.0753093808889389,
-0.5492421984672546,
-0.8746600151062012,
0.22506459057331085,
0.02244105190038681,
-1.0840110778808594,
-0.37258124351501465,
0.18028271198272705,
-0.36424872279167175,
0.6519327163696289,
-0.656117856502533,
0.8465341329574585,
-0.40237194299697876,
-0.27859628200531006,
-0.07828110456466675,
-0.6250693202018738,
0.9222700595855713,
0.03552098944783211,
0.06829041242599487,
-0.03621869906783104,
0.06168511137366295,
0.44758784770965576,
-0.6985154151916504,
0.5247167348861694,
-0.10105908662080765,
0.12721407413482666,
0.3043158948421478,
0.05404233932495117,
0.6124640703201294,
-0.018440108746290207,
0.2087150514125824,
0.1586141735315323,
-0.5517598390579224,
-0.2861683964729309,
-0.5237994194030762,
0.9408984780311584,
-0.827800989151001,
-0.9909224510192871,
-0.4682270586490631,
-0.399304062128067,
-0.11602450162172318,
0.025404125452041626,
0.48659980297088623,
0.06764907389879227,
-0.43843331933021545,
-0.07299212366342545,
0.7737666368484497,
-0.13788513839244843,
0.22558723390102386,
0.22756177186965942,
-0.22928522527217865,
-0.46263548731803894,
0.9915013313293457,
-0.16264504194259644,
0.40701302886009216,
-0.044793225824832916,
0.08165770769119263,
-0.31147459149360657,
-0.7769514322280884,
-0.6302235722541809,
0.09881609678268433,
-0.6735584139823914,
-0.4083845615386963,
-0.5693338513374329,
-0.5522837042808533,
-0.3281608521938324,
-0.24682223796844482,
-0.11516221612691879,
-0.3399551808834076,
-0.512997567653656,
-0.27602389454841614,
0.6569352149963379,
0.46398040652275085,
-0.39809101819992065,
0.538377046585083,
-0.7053849697113037,
0.3933441936969757,
0.2560027241706848,
0.38718923926353455,
-0.12070566415786743,
-0.6071869730949402,
0.08687567710876465,
-0.24126851558685303,
-0.4898102581501007,
-1.0742634534835815,
0.3870626389980316,
0.3400730788707733,
0.4208023250102997,
0.5369117259979248,
-0.1849208027124405,
0.6666723489761353,
-0.6281808018684387,
0.6510188579559326,
0.38370200991630554,
-0.9802344441413879,
0.47439855337142944,
-0.5457306504249573,
-0.0530320443212986,
0.4958488643169403,
0.3556835651397705,
-0.4450211226940155,
-0.2529159486293793,
-0.5191397666931152,
-1.2023669481277466,
0.6571756601333618,
0.15582308173179626,
0.1477878838777542,
-0.1440722495317459,
0.5654521584510803,
0.11530600488185883,
-0.02670321613550186,
-0.617275595664978,
-0.3413007855415344,
-0.08556067198514938,
-0.11421246081590652,
0.21634136140346527,
-0.11681206524372101,
-0.21247544884681702,
-0.07118615508079529,
0.8800140619277954,
-0.20371578633785248,
0.1777411550283432,
-0.2126827985048294,
-0.05662542209029198,
0.32505255937576294,
0.39643552899360657,
0.3730676472187042,
0.0034426478669047356,
-0.0867178663611412,
0.11214031279087067,
0.2004886269569397,
-0.7110370993614197,
0.3568192422389984,
0.40689557790756226,
-0.24840690195560455,
-0.528093695640564,
-0.0005662422045134008,
0.8692024946212769,
-0.2824763357639313,
-0.587080717086792,
0.5662664771080017,
-0.18155895173549652,
-0.18187469244003296,
-0.36252179741859436,
0.3859183192253113,
-0.14015330374240875,
-0.08908694982528687,
0.23042446374893188,
0.18415436148643494,
0.17139679193496704,
-0.475432425737381,
0.24840272963047028,
0.9069344401359558,
-0.35176417231559753,
-0.12918061017990112,
0.9214460849761963,
-0.09994112700223923,
-0.0499064065515995,
0.6328414678573608,
-0.5459054708480835,
-0.7812337279319763,
0.5446497797966003,
0.5526735186576843,
1.198598027229309,
-0.19968773424625397,
0.10554945468902588,
0.21729536354541779,
0.42995575070381165,
-0.3131466507911682,
-0.013764298520982265,
0.14202453196048737,
-0.5694112181663513,
-0.3844166100025177,
-0.6807364225387573,
-0.2059939056634903,
0.31508004665374756,
-0.3614281117916107,
0.15527242422103882,
-0.7403391003608704,
-0.09664084017276764,
-0.09806323051452637,
-0.3087300956249237,
-0.4302111864089966,
-0.01015174388885498,
0.2563186585903168,
0.7139790058135986,
-0.72561115026474,
0.46411818265914917,
0.46814581751823425,
-0.22836138308048248,
-0.7814324498176575,
0.049011100083589554,
0.29225876927375793,
-0.9626035690307617,
0.2409251630306244,
0.29153820872306824,
-0.22960412502288818,
0.08108785003423691,
-0.8487544059753418,
-1.0250506401062012,
0.7856824994087219,
0.513836145401001,
-0.4821007251739502,
0.029764853417873383,
0.014641815796494484,
0.32328295707702637,
-0.13291269540786743,
0.018194155767560005,
0.7451319694519043,
0.18075063824653625,
0.26978689432144165,
-0.5269801616668701,
0.31037601828575134,
-0.3061975836753845,
-0.027754951268434525,
0.5756500363349915,
-0.6833292841911316,
0.5582760572433472,
-0.44412025809288025,
-0.5549872517585754,
0.5131317973136902,
0.6391703486442566,
0.3717229664325714,
-0.17506098747253418,
0.2732217609882355,
0.9064704775810242,
0.6256936192512512,
-0.45956146717071533,
1.2993427515029907,
-0.23472781479358673,
0.1612103283405304,
0.8738735914230347,
0.009142045862972736,
0.4476906359195709,
0.268094539642334,
-0.06130778789520264,
0.1677999198436737,
0.5265265703201294,
-0.2858632802963257,
0.7636958360671997,
0.575780987739563,
-0.5858492851257324,
-0.12477843463420868,
-0.06963276863098145,
-0.20908796787261963,
0.2378072291612625,
0.6037800908088684,
-0.15587525069713593,
-0.15792497992515564,
0.15834267437458038,
0.3194662928581238,
-0.007429117802530527,
-0.5489298105239868,
0.8084166646003723,
0.12748636305332184,
-0.6850425004959106,
0.6826361417770386,
0.3418174088001251,
0.8084176778793335,
-0.7636188864707947,
0.22067329287528992,
-0.12649795413017273,
0.2455766499042511,
-0.32149538397789,
-0.5893466472625732,
0.32287463545799255,
0.2876504063606262,
0.04724854603409767,
0.202629953622818,
0.841628909111023,
-0.1969662755727768,
-0.34256646037101746,
0.3568386435508728,
0.04944869130849838,
0.12410286068916321,
-0.1316411942243576,
-0.5957803130149841,
-0.07335466891527176,
0.10884452611207962,
-0.00987545307725668,
0.446950227022171,
0.12344173341989517,
-0.036205776035785675,
0.700567901134491,
0.9143062233924866,
0.3601122200489044,
0.292482852935791,
0.08148455619812012,
1.0030213594436646,
-0.5522289872169495,
-0.5251306295394897,
-1.2163504362106323,
0.32054275274276733,
-0.08527177572250366,
-0.13034258782863617,
0.8927006721496582,
0.43502840399742126,
0.6143420338630676,
0.17715293169021606,
1.0322761535644531,
-0.1530987024307251,
-0.06923338025808334,
-0.8431304097175598,
0.6564003825187683,
-0.28316059708595276,
0.4685831367969513,
-0.027499446645379066,
-0.6881362199783325,
-0.33436906337738037,
0.24107757210731506,
-0.4374827444553375,
-0.12697894871234894,
0.3724651038646698,
0.8171631693840027,
-0.06884968280792236,
0.00793713890016079,
0.28414246439933777,
-0.008056255988776684,
0.5104159116744995,
0.7885469198226929,
0.9670044779777527,
-0.3536930978298187,
0.671310544013977,
0.13781383633613586,
-0.2786380350589752,
-0.03545930236577988,
-0.7363913059234619,
-0.9506799578666687,
-0.08826857060194016,
-0.290678471326828,
-0.43117958307266235,
0.5177662968635559,
0.7461202144622803,
0.6021941304206848,
-0.5586693286895752,
0.20830652117729187,
-0.6451157927513123,
0.13612297177314758,
0.06907710433006287,
-0.23435765504837036,
0.45853495597839355,
-0.35673290491104126,
-0.318185418844223,
0.5988871455192566,
0.22947637736797333,
0.17940813302993774,
-0.10687615722417831,
0.001757041085511446,
-0.0035295758862048388,
-0.012330012395977974,
0.24646544456481934,
0.5944423079490662,
-0.7292649149894714,
-0.3560742139816284,
-0.0022522052749991417,
-0.0777047649025917,
0.006182584445923567,
0.637854814529419,
-0.45161086320877075,
0.3421466648578644,
0.10294131934642792,
0.7519661784172058,
0.2734966278076172,
0.3305279612541199,
0.6183522939682007,
-1.0924668312072754,
0.04572572186589241,
-0.07121412456035614,
0.3900068402290344,
0.4969472587108612,
-0.6067757606506348,
0.5348891019821167,
0.24044659733772278,
-0.6464186310768127,
-0.7008963227272034,
0.504258394241333,
-0.5842846035957336,
-0.48644495010375977,
1.3500572443008423,
-0.24797682464122772,
-0.1506078839302063,
0.019612403586506844,
-0.11214697360992432,
0.34632956981658936,
-0.17903928458690643,
0.8398237228393555,
0.4899786412715912,
0.04484197497367859,
0.08463812619447708,
-0.494398295879364,
0.8263159990310669,
0.2860523760318756,
-0.8598120808601379,
0.047372005879879,
0.43376657366752625,
0.3954499065876007,
0.0007901514763943851,
0.4135729670524597,
-0.19977329671382904,
0.35830676555633545,
0.06285592168569565,
-0.02273194119334221,
-0.2250882238149643,
-0.33328771591186523,
-0.6058158278465271,
0.25417560338974,
0.10506541281938553,
-0.38499876856803894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07917v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07917v1
|
DesignQA: A Multimodal Benchmark for Evaluating Large Language Models' Understanding of Engineering Documentation
| 2024-04-11T16:59:54 | 2024-04-11T16:59:54 |
Anna C. Doris, Daniele Grandi, Ryan Tomich, Md Ferdous Alam, Hyunmin Cheong, Faez Ahmed
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This research introduces DesignQA, a novel benchmark aimed at evaluating the
proficiency of multimodal large language models (MLLMs) in comprehending and
applying engineering requirements in technical documentation. Developed with a
focus on real-world engineering challenges, DesignQA uniquely combines
multimodal data-including textual design requirements, CAD images, and
engineering drawings-derived from the Formula SAE student competition.
Different from many existing MLLM benchmarks, DesignQA contains
document-grounded visual questions where the input image and input document
come from different sources. The benchmark features automatic evaluation
metrics and is divided into segments-Rule Comprehension, Rule Compliance, and
Rule Extraction-based on tasks that engineers perform when designing according
to requirements. We evaluate state-of-the-art models like GPT4 and LLaVA
against the benchmark, and our study uncovers the existing gaps in MLLMs'
abilities to interpret complex engineering documentation. Key findings suggest
that while MLLMs demonstrate potential in navigating technical documents,
substantial limitations exist, particularly in accurately extracting and
applying detailed requirements to engineering designs. This benchmark sets a
foundation for future advancements in AI-supported engineering design
processes. DesignQA is publicly available at:
https://github.com/anniedoris/design_qa/.
|
[
-0.6010316014289856,
-0.5829082727432251,
0.6613874435424805,
0.4408052861690521,
-0.15277905762195587,
0.37532398104667664,
0.2737117409706116,
-0.4493405520915985,
-0.2404162883758545,
0.338382363319397,
-0.640001118183136,
-0.594153881072998,
-0.2351880520582199,
-0.0691288411617279,
-0.33652976155281067,
0.26926058530807495,
-0.6953408122062683,
-0.11865202337503433,
-0.4691663384437561,
-0.11940073221921921,
-0.5562121272087097,
-0.42652904987335205,
-0.36921900510787964,
-0.14505478739738464,
0.5567991733551025,
0.03589266538619995,
0.5231381058692932,
0.20179066061973572,
0.54996258020401,
0.24703708291053772,
-0.10344593226909637,
0.3340698480606079,
0.05810273811221123,
0.36426037549972534,
0.23354196548461914,
-0.1816316843032837,
-0.5260902643203735,
0.1861913502216339,
0.6422193050384521,
0.43374916911125183,
0.09171102941036224,
0.39550909399986267,
0.20263230800628662,
0.6375098824501038,
-0.6421326398849487,
0.6235847473144531,
-0.005726034753024578,
0.05344398692250252,
-0.050694480538368225,
-0.14130184054374695,
-0.5256337523460388,
-0.27802738547325134,
-0.13391926884651184,
-0.9553744792938232,
-0.09651581943035126,
0.25954920053482056,
1.1773743629455566,
0.3299992084503174,
-0.9147272109985352,
-0.4237058460712433,
-0.2711823582649231,
0.6071223616600037,
-0.514882504940033,
1.112990379333496,
0.2635124623775482,
0.5309398770332336,
-0.2409704178571701,
-0.9021588563919067,
-0.5126182436943054,
-0.5005363821983337,
0.0627799853682518,
0.0819019228219986,
-0.060647957026958466,
0.2071147859096527,
0.47274231910705566,
0.3388630449771881,
-0.8514777421951294,
0.039172448217868805,
-0.5648142695426941,
-0.4435834586620331,
0.48048943281173706,
0.06428782641887665,
0.4094778895378113,
-0.28740373253822327,
-0.30922606587409973,
-0.15749941766262054,
-0.47808268666267395,
0.21503953635692596,
0.11695805937051773,
-0.15869663655757904,
-0.23765252530574799,
0.4407012164592743,
-0.28725385665893555,
0.45307639241218567,
-0.38700205087661743,
-0.02298904024064541,
0.7221495509147644,
-0.43962353467941284,
-0.314147412776947,
-0.5256191492080688,
0.6500651240348816,
0.2240416556596756,
0.1515301764011383,
-0.12234632670879364,
-0.456371545791626,
-0.19297614693641663,
0.31260091066360474,
-0.6162058115005493,
-0.33208033442497253,
-0.005849589128047228,
-0.6214759349822998,
0.0192410908639431,
-0.342653751373291,
-0.6583496332168579,
-0.5436216592788696,
-0.6325631737709045,
0.6508012413978577,
0.03360266983509064,
-0.2998746335506439,
-0.06852523982524872,
-0.4363938570022583,
0.31992918252944946,
0.29730021953582764,
-0.486642986536026,
-0.2005435824394226,
0.6316255927085876,
0.8424552083015442,
0.055863477289676666,
-0.2997328042984009,
-0.37317997217178345,
-0.08519420027732849,
-0.34319067001342773,
0.878273069858551,
-0.3676144778728485,
-0.4438352882862091,
-0.13021796941757202,
-0.04233703762292862,
0.01467972807586193,
-0.48459669947624207,
1.087523341178894,
-0.6134743690490723,
-0.17069992423057556,
-0.11883504688739777,
-0.17175422608852386,
-0.2941044270992279,
0.3315489590167999,
-1.024529218673706,
1.0087003707885742,
0.3143507242202759,
-0.4930537939071655,
0.6087765097618103,
-0.8467608094215393,
-0.1852671504020691,
0.12587592005729675,
-0.5215824842453003,
-0.34964099526405334,
0.10381826013326645,
0.061905570328235626,
-0.02254052832722664,
-0.4717181324958801,
0.2868141233921051,
-0.48044732213020325,
-0.10478532314300537,
0.05760800465941429,
-0.42348048090934753,
0.7486551403999329,
0.4328978955745697,
-0.19306674599647522,
0.3332313299179077,
-0.8197064995765686,
0.41283202171325684,
-0.06194609776139259,
-0.6008319854736328,
-0.23557034134864807,
-0.10666656494140625,
0.2549625337123871,
0.6274073719978333,
0.07206393778324127,
-0.5444068908691406,
0.12031706422567368,
-0.0665116161108017,
0.5170199275016785,
0.6942359805107117,
-0.1835947185754776,
0.3458193838596344,
-0.39511770009994507,
0.7087031006813049,
-0.2036408931016922,
0.3058920204639435,
-0.18979233503341675,
-0.4670560657978058,
-0.8084163069725037,
-0.3282092809677124,
0.40704694390296936,
0.22725561261177063,
-0.8236740231513977,
-0.1586732119321823,
0.052887994796037674,
-0.4533608555793762,
-0.7535015940666199,
0.30512735247612,
0.33360204100608826,
0.32534104585647583,
0.3136990964412689,
-0.2551964819431305,
-0.6414324045181274,
-1.2305152416229248,
-0.14695486426353455,
-0.3274605870246887,
-0.41055262088775635,
0.19397446513175964,
0.5835617184638977,
-0.1558384895324707,
0.4508434236049652,
-0.15629462897777557,
-0.1825145184993744,
0.010898598469793797,
0.7473235130310059,
0.07547729462385178,
0.29080110788345337,
0.5990155339241028,
-1.0009278059005737,
-0.4622010588645935,
-0.08532075583934784,
-1.0388046503067017,
-0.2510867714881897,
-0.2173282653093338,
-0.21027426421642303,
-0.021551795303821564,
0.48067885637283325,
-0.8145385980606079,
0.5035240650177002,
0.4430258274078369,
-0.2972732186317444,
0.6183995604515076,
-0.07873532176017761,
0.30948084592819214,
-0.7419758439064026,
0.1565951108932495,
-0.03217538073658943,
0.07089897245168686,
-0.4060690104961395,
0.47751641273498535,
0.6962587833404541,
-0.15872442722320557,
-0.4790635108947754,
0.7535831332206726,
-0.73714679479599,
-0.007815176621079445,
-0.09964804351329803,
0.13704276084899902,
0.5409051179885864,
0.4699367880821228,
-0.2650042176246643,
0.8596405386924744,
0.23098398745059967,
-0.3074241876602173,
0.26733607053756714,
0.3030734360218048,
-0.6664344668388367,
0.6752799153327942,
-0.6948812007904053,
0.19315806031227112,
-0.18142069876194,
0.2866935729980469,
-0.9727447032928467,
0.08880402892827988,
-0.09556814283132553,
-0.26029935479164124,
0.19010236859321594,
0.09578006714582443,
-0.7194401621818542,
-0.5993556380271912,
-0.3216603398323059,
0.5296332836151123,
0.27800148725509644,
-0.2823459506034851,
1.0400304794311523,
0.36357957124710083,
-0.2420322746038437,
-0.3273424804210663,
-0.43602657318115234,
0.28325456380844116,
0.04414058476686478,
-0.8436976671218872,
0.347275048494339,
-0.47885045409202576,
-0.42626500129699707,
-0.1870451420545578,
-0.33163079619407654,
-0.47587499022483826,
0.2858940660953522,
0.5584033131599426,
0.14515922963619232,
-0.3695571720600128,
0.28122133016586304,
0.013983221724629402,
-0.029972435906529427,
0.39244508743286133,
-0.07081976532936096,
0.18753965198993683,
0.018936721608042717,
-0.5551066994667053,
-0.7510079145431519,
0.6972885131835938,
0.9970926642417908,
-0.3091928958892822,
0.22239452600479126,
0.44412723183631897,
-0.4338756799697876,
-0.15874658524990082,
-0.6421825885772705,
0.13469275832176208,
-0.4770960807800293,
0.3542833626270294,
-1.0142158269882202,
-0.43772900104522705,
0.27896153926849365,
0.03448408097028732,
0.5811917781829834,
0.60891193151474,
0.316886305809021,
-0.48889702558517456,
1.105350136756897,
0.7212422490119934,
0.1022491306066513,
0.2770747244358063,
-0.012210121378302574,
0.03498765826225281,
-0.8048848509788513,
-0.36318153142929077,
-0.7765505909919739,
-0.2662763297557831,
-0.1792861968278885,
-0.30083903670310974,
0.38568034768104553,
-0.07356840372085571,
-0.4076162278652191,
0.1525304913520813,
-0.15213735401630402,
0.26471570134162903,
0.6300413012504578,
0.04211782291531563,
0.4278036653995514,
-0.2436131089925766,
-0.637078583240509,
-0.07028187066316605,
-0.3618265390396118,
-0.5587961077690125,
0.9421218633651733,
0.6843020915985107,
0.8629180788993835,
0.17217519879341125,
0.3202687203884125,
0.5851659178733826,
0.37243911623954773,
-0.8076868057250977,
0.25137877464294434,
0.17056329548358917,
-0.606062650680542,
-0.13855881989002228,
-0.325685977935791,
-0.5700249671936035,
0.3582811653614044,
-0.056777335703372955,
-0.21231457591056824,
0.1673640012741089,
0.001892267377115786,
-0.25402316451072693,
0.016171786934137344,
-0.796788215637207,
0.9457744359970093,
-0.5839635729789734,
-0.07324521988630295,
-0.2119387984275818,
-0.17887336015701294,
0.3660720884799957,
-0.40981122851371765,
0.49035564064979553,
-0.19197297096252441,
-0.08121266216039658,
0.7072634100914001,
-0.10849904268980026,
0.5317331552505493,
-0.11446776986122131,
-0.39494410157203674,
0.025898534804582596,
0.06981770694255829,
0.386790931224823,
-0.1502106785774231,
-0.4240564703941345,
-0.07076086848974228,
0.26036331057548523,
-0.5440579056739807,
-0.608758270740509,
0.4923565685749054,
-0.6281191110610962,
-0.6821148991584778,
-0.20054891705513,
-0.5633540153503418,
-0.3779439628124237,
0.2600908577442169,
-0.027947895228862762,
0.43757912516593933,
-0.17814745008945465,
0.41639968752861023,
0.454772412776947,
-0.22127477824687958,
0.2980256974697113,
0.6138725280761719,
-0.034639663994312286,
-0.202861025929451,
0.5692611336708069,
0.10160836577415466,
0.13633394241333008,
0.4284656345844269,
-0.19094377756118774,
-0.7217252850532532,
-0.6764780879020691,
-0.9186277985572815,
0.10432196408510208,
-1.1082600355148315,
-0.020722512155771255,
-0.5967662334442139,
-0.5525249242782593,
-0.13074341416358948,
0.09857834875583649,
-0.07798577100038528,
-0.40067124366760254,
-0.1306481510400772,
0.09015291929244995,
-0.27460727095603943,
1.0879710912704468,
0.3741088807582855,
-0.2899361550807953,
-0.7581158876419067,
0.3541887700557709,
0.45534321665763855,
0.5033916234970093,
-0.013722596690058708,
-0.720507025718689,
-0.0835946798324585,
-0.07615043222904205,
-0.7377278804779053,
-0.6863167881965637,
-0.05484502390027046,
0.10026462376117706,
1.226993203163147,
-0.06398263573646545,
0.15281078219413757,
0.34166932106018066,
-0.3929755985736847,
0.53175288438797,
-0.00028979903436265886,
-0.7958388924598694,
0.3497362434864044,
-0.23529477417469025,
0.5838273167610168,
0.48166424036026,
0.34853458404541016,
-0.4796641170978546,
-0.18840616941452026,
-0.1450061798095703,
-0.5854902267456055,
0.08109712600708008,
0.2156887799501419,
-0.10284975171089172,
0.4854954183101654,
0.1629723757505417,
-0.04953319951891899,
0.17203685641288757,
-0.6358606219291687,
0.1324181705713272,
-0.19677673280239105,
-0.3778303861618042,
0.28051722049713135,
-0.3905044198036194,
-0.07561742514371872,
0.10728171467781067,
0.4127311706542969,
-0.12041106820106506,
0.02489110827445984,
-0.1358119696378708,
-0.4406302273273468,
0.17655615508556366,
0.342510461807251,
0.8539125919342041,
1.0366511344909668,
-0.010057521052658558,
0.15131568908691406,
0.14681756496429443,
-0.3483874201774597,
0.1473401039838791,
0.17689411342144012,
-0.09027925133705139,
0.23306399583816528,
0.3469091057777405,
0.4293422996997833,
0.30394676327705383,
-0.6710193157196045,
0.4274110794067383,
-0.3616980016231537,
-0.7481973171234131,
-0.22902953624725342,
-0.31195229291915894,
0.1497660130262375,
0.4074764549732208,
0.5625410079956055,
-0.25169360637664795,
0.273888498544693,
-0.23093000054359436,
0.3742654621601105,
0.3937336206436157,
-0.29468321800231934,
-0.3317345082759857,
0.9068135619163513,
0.5937076210975647,
-0.3218529522418976,
0.33509716391563416,
-0.10362941026687622,
-0.2184048295021057,
0.8204904198646545,
0.20607130229473114,
0.9859889149665833,
0.14287137985229492,
0.26231858134269714,
0.33520859479904175,
0.41960179805755615,
0.2633359134197235,
0.6130397915840149,
-0.23614509403705597,
-0.03862394765019417,
-0.3378773629665375,
-0.7666611671447754,
-0.49746689200401306,
0.09739737212657928,
-0.2986457943916321,
0.3309526741504669,
-0.4070212244987488,
-0.06095553934574127,
0.30942031741142273,
-0.09061365574598312,
-0.8466358184814453,
0.0650104433298111,
0.12529627978801727,
1.256221890449524,
-0.5186587572097778,
0.6977929472923279,
0.5996688604354858,
-0.5929137468338013,
-0.6308376789093018,
-0.15519964694976807,
0.4447982609272003,
-0.5707443952560425,
1.0642335414886475,
0.21825966238975525,
-0.17040805518627167,
-0.2608316242694855,
0.030770616605877876,
-0.700517475605011,
1.0435429811477661,
0.19901345670223236,
-0.6327328085899353,
-0.44077160954475403,
0.1357390433549881,
0.39280855655670166,
-0.1187632754445076,
0.45798036456108093,
0.17818880081176758,
0.5867025852203369,
-0.13887232542037964,
-1.3978382349014282,
0.009448791854083538,
-0.7038452625274658,
-0.2369346022605896,
0.28618910908699036,
-0.631205677986145,
0.8943867683410645,
0.16763977706432343,
-0.405872106552124,
0.29251328110694885,
0.4183407127857208,
0.27890509366989136,
0.49548807740211487,
0.6179505586624146,
0.3427734076976776,
0.7270718812942505,
-0.06411096453666687,
0.5599731206893921,
-0.31175732612609863,
0.08052215725183487,
0.9572411775588989,
-0.08802346885204315,
0.9636303782463074,
0.4099893569946289,
-0.13092465698719025,
0.5122945308685303,
0.7339819669723511,
0.18279346823692322,
0.15565736591815948,
0.3298663794994354,
-0.2925754189491272,
-0.30135828256607056,
-0.2572687268257141,
-0.6584884524345398,
0.40923017263412476,
0.2559548020362854,
-0.52556973695755,
-0.2749621570110321,
0.043156545609235764,
-0.3451000452041626,
-0.03530226647853851,
-0.19717402756214142,
0.6106473207473755,
0.14996226131916046,
-0.5101680159568787,
0.880364716053009,
-0.24076880514621735,
0.18092699348926544,
-0.380418598651886,
-0.23374465107917786,
-0.26001590490341187,
0.12768468260765076,
-0.030747514218091965,
-0.9920145869255066,
0.04588344320654869,
-0.12822726368904114,
-0.2170434296131134,
-0.392813116312027,
0.1750713735818863,
-0.02346782013773918,
-0.49210232496261597,
0.18498261272907257,
0.42768561840057373,
0.06759744882583618,
-0.19280065596103668,
-0.7614537477493286,
0.2172451615333557,
-0.10236556828022003,
-0.0848754346370697,
0.1957269161939621,
0.424051433801651,
-0.30734094977378845,
0.8682758808135986,
0.3359565734863281,
-0.39740267395973206,
-0.028240008279681206,
0.45285657048225403,
1.0423225164413452,
-0.6377221345901489,
-0.35676348209381104,
-0.485830157995224,
0.6443095207214355,
-0.11766276508569717,
-0.3226659893989563,
0.6558558344841003,
0.7290837168693542,
0.7151495814323425,
-0.016013802960515022,
0.9935442209243774,
0.26168614625930786,
0.23918859660625458,
-0.6449539065361023,
0.7888273000717163,
-0.8914804458618164,
0.13131873309612274,
-0.12106785923242569,
-0.637627124786377,
-0.20019209384918213,
0.16800691187381744,
-0.007947531528770924,
-0.00006337364902719855,
0.7827204465866089,
0.8217519521713257,
-0.12263580411672592,
0.09000127762556076,
0.305136501789093,
-0.03192993998527527,
0.6613462567329407,
0.7309235334396362,
1.1677112579345703,
-0.40252354741096497,
0.9716094136238098,
0.03697406128048897,
-0.3095232844352722,
-0.09281659871339798,
-0.791832685470581,
-0.9324679970741272,
-0.845130443572998,
-0.019174322485923767,
-0.055823083966970444,
-0.0855918675661087,
0.6570270657539368,
0.7863403558731079,
-0.6766271591186523,
-0.018720699474215508,
0.34725552797317505,
0.1218651831150055,
0.028395967558026314,
-0.09921238571405411,
0.20046117901802063,
-0.3209349811077118,
-0.5596322417259216,
0.5207262635231018,
0.33067551255226135,
0.21879225969314575,
-0.6083627939224243,
-0.1332586705684662,
-0.07998176664113998,
-0.06307132542133331,
0.737343430519104,
0.31907227635383606,
-0.950921893119812,
-0.10415492206811905,
0.2638290226459503,
-0.32324862480163574,
0.14668388664722443,
0.783681333065033,
-0.47501036524772644,
0.6863062977790833,
0.8628591895103455,
0.7168117761611938,
0.406844824552536,
-0.10020264238119125,
0.5683503746986389,
-0.4765363037586212,
-0.16233676671981812,
-0.048992861062288284,
0.4171381890773773,
0.12170065939426422,
-0.05389559268951416,
0.3848710060119629,
0.0322391539812088,
-0.5941191911697388,
-0.7379911541938782,
0.2338918298482895,
-0.7147794365882874,
-0.1947486847639084,
0.8572414517402649,
-0.15790323913097382,
0.031211014837026596,
-0.601708173751831,
-0.5205387473106384,
-0.17793802917003632,
-0.23656436800956726,
0.8613005876541138,
0.8664276003837585,
-0.030893957242369652,
-0.48521673679351807,
-1.201806902885437,
0.38631728291511536,
0.3014533221721649,
-0.919635534286499,
0.055750470608472824,
0.5490779876708984,
0.05152202397584915,
0.04840215668082237,
0.43081220984458923,
0.10152801126241684,
0.719054102897644,
0.05377430096268654,
0.029178835451602936,
-0.18760946393013,
-0.3306335508823395,
0.059679631143808365,
0.45115354657173157,
0.4673689007759094,
-0.19630645215511322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07904v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07904v1
|
HGRN2: Gated Linear RNNs with State Expansion
| 2024-04-11T16:43:03 | 2024-04-11T16:43:03 |
Zhen Qin, Songlin Yang, Weixuan Sun, Xuyang Shen, Dong Li, Weigao Sun, Yiran Zhong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Hierarchically gated linear RNN (HGRN,Qin et al. 2023) has demonstrated
competitive training speed and performance in language modeling, while offering
efficient inference. However, the recurrent state size of HGRN remains
relatively small, which limits its expressiveness.To address this issue,
inspired by linear attention, we introduce a simple outer-product-based state
expansion mechanism so that the recurrent state size can be significantly
enlarged without introducing any additional parameters. The linear attention
form also allows for hardware-efficient training.Our extensive experiments
verify the advantage of HGRN2 over HGRN1 in language modeling, image
classification, and Long Range Arena.Our largest 3B HGRN2 model slightly
outperforms Mamba and LLaMa Architecture Transformer for language modeling in a
controlled experiment setting; and performs competitively with many open-source
3B models in downstream evaluation while using much fewer total training
tokens.
|
[
-0.22808922827243805,
-0.6346739530563354,
0.21832427382469177,
0.28213006258010864,
-0.1367882490158081,
-0.11235018819570541,
-0.3505476713180542,
-0.6253589391708374,
-0.15127383172512054,
0.13553033769130707,
-0.37402087450027466,
-0.038046836853027344,
-0.6709122657775879,
-0.23242652416229248,
-0.12709026038646698,
0.9819526672363281,
-0.004295084625482559,
-0.02289736643433571,
0.13069266080856323,
0.023537956178188324,
0.0186940748244524,
-0.21774345636367798,
-0.8880435228347778,
-0.7975213527679443,
0.993922770023346,
0.006771471351385117,
0.7529540061950684,
1.0182427167892456,
0.7084907293319702,
0.3062492311000824,
-0.19520147144794464,
-0.13926179707050323,
-0.9004146456718445,
-0.03993190824985504,
-0.002225067000836134,
-0.298261821269989,
-0.49198341369628906,
-0.2731526494026184,
0.647412121295929,
0.42121243476867676,
-0.22753719985485077,
0.3625050187110901,
0.15417374670505524,
0.7009056210517883,
-0.5995274782180786,
0.49954354763031006,
-0.5266247391700745,
0.19679699838161469,
-0.18259871006011963,
0.21792350709438324,
-0.3013212978839874,
-0.31826090812683105,
0.3144419193267822,
-0.47935885190963745,
0.15425093472003937,
0.13961009681224823,
0.9562261700630188,
0.2744450569152832,
-0.12614771723747253,
0.1769626885652542,
-0.7680975794792175,
0.772779643535614,
-0.6773552298545837,
0.6129297614097595,
-0.07066276669502258,
0.3256888687610626,
-0.16198182106018066,
-0.8320187926292419,
-0.43630072474479675,
0.017528381198644638,
-0.07033061981201172,
0.0852210745215416,
-0.5770586133003235,
0.5276693105697632,
0.4211605191230774,
0.38384008407592773,
-0.5871115922927856,
0.019490839913487434,
-0.6184230446815491,
-0.04959466680884361,
0.25418782234191895,
-0.14973728358745575,
0.04935990273952484,
-0.1727035492658615,
-0.775619626045227,
0.08667260408401489,
-0.6929230690002441,
-0.07326645404100418,
0.13609495759010315,
0.3078460097312927,
-0.037563227117061615,
0.5205601453781128,
-0.20093953609466553,
0.6974620819091797,
-0.03668278828263283,
-0.14934974908828735,
0.16921281814575195,
-0.11201903969049454,
-0.3795611560344696,
-0.03455493971705437,
0.7385963797569275,
0.15549826622009277,
-0.08246825635433197,
-0.28149351477622986,
-0.3657439053058624,
0.011324312537908554,
0.1086985319852829,
-0.9297876954078674,
-0.15665383636951447,
0.025653518736362457,
-0.7965294718742371,
-0.13380621373653412,
-0.1159057468175888,
-0.9299683570861816,
-0.3637203276157379,
-0.27576789259910583,
0.55610591173172,
0.24649673700332642,
-0.31100985407829285,
0.21251681447029114,
-0.23325198888778687,
0.23209810256958008,
0.08291544020175934,
-1.1198005676269531,
0.6203266382217407,
1.027305245399475,
0.9487659931182861,
-0.3337736427783966,
0.07396188378334045,
-0.48635831475257874,
-0.3321223855018616,
-0.4345371425151825,
0.4614483118057251,
-0.252958744764328,
0.09300071746110916,
-0.07042292505502701,
-0.11031799018383026,
0.17950588464736938,
-0.5144510865211487,
0.04548400267958641,
-1.0249106884002686,
0.08361075073480606,
-0.18493764102458954,
-0.04660334810614586,
-0.11309368163347244,
0.0878659188747406,
-0.6736016273498535,
1.1374821662902832,
0.5431225299835205,
-0.5722768306732178,
0.07657911628484726,
-0.5600519180297852,
-0.15697401762008667,
0.034161683171987534,
-0.3183412253856659,
-0.4237616956233978,
0.030892107635736465,
-0.1571250557899475,
-0.09076627343893051,
-0.5046955943107605,
0.14486192166805267,
-0.3375667929649353,
-0.15392301976680756,
-0.06359679251909256,
-0.31390541791915894,
0.39372217655181885,
0.34912630915641785,
-0.44371312856674194,
0.1603839248418808,
-0.42126649618148804,
0.08802376687526703,
0.04030811786651611,
-0.5228840708732605,
-0.06070917472243309,
-0.2874399721622467,
-0.04741981625556946,
0.5251333117485046,
0.25651687383651733,
-0.7660204768180847,
0.10311583429574966,
-0.7291151881217957,
0.28136759996414185,
0.7098271250724792,
0.003259279765188694,
0.6528159379959106,
-0.20342518389225006,
0.7692381143569946,
-0.12393157184123993,
0.1402677744626999,
-0.010134127922356129,
-0.6607083082199097,
-0.8579867482185364,
-0.1584254801273346,
0.6126073598861694,
0.4346950650215149,
-0.6927188634872437,
0.29069432616233826,
-0.4229927659034729,
0.01771915890276432,
-0.5337717533111572,
0.23149430751800537,
0.67608642578125,
0.3462068736553192,
0.07602270692586899,
-0.3336102068424225,
-0.6875793933868408,
-1.1343235969543457,
-0.1761322319507599,
-0.22814755141735077,
0.04345678165555,
0.29851028323173523,
0.37180161476135254,
-0.20915992558002472,
0.8932519555091858,
-0.37021327018737793,
-0.3358299732208252,
-0.6071645021438599,
0.2536587715148926,
0.3028257191181183,
0.2767837643623352,
0.03755990043282509,
-0.2196681946516037,
-0.2716256380081177,
0.3520755171775818,
-0.4879905879497528,
-0.0487021878361702,
-0.15879285335540771,
-0.2258809357881546,
0.18514251708984375,
0.42448127269744873,
-0.5724402666091919,
0.5129256844520569,
0.6803573966026306,
0.08029875159263611,
0.04857688397169113,
-0.10632729530334473,
-0.4130176901817322,
-1.0853594541549683,
-0.17016640305519104,
0.189650759100914,
-0.32938021421432495,
-0.5954164862632751,
0.185713529586792,
-0.04297174513339996,
-0.17124196887016296,
-0.3141172528266907,
0.7544640302658081,
-0.6461189985275269,
-0.5382212400436401,
-0.6517965793609619,
0.25839078426361084,
-0.19435518980026245,
0.8184595108032227,
-0.03847381845116615,
0.5591658353805542,
0.3024519681930542,
-0.3305497467517853,
0.5738086700439453,
0.0857718363404274,
-0.45811793208122253,
-0.3097188174724579,
-0.8678786754608154,
0.002834559651091695,
-0.38851311802864075,
0.35809728503227234,
-0.810876190662384,
-0.09096594154834747,
0.32842010259628296,
-0.3574414849281311,
0.2954338490962982,
-0.3074522912502289,
-0.390553742647171,
-0.6379032135009766,
-0.09336474537849426,
0.5633032917976379,
0.8870239853858948,
-0.8821170926094055,
0.4943033754825592,
0.15568985044956207,
-0.22517991065979004,
-0.5080679059028625,
-0.8889324069023132,
0.08087001740932465,
0.18553219735622406,
-0.45142197608947754,
0.17030608654022217,
0.4773027300834656,
-0.2735457122325897,
0.18872809410095215,
-0.2522905766963959,
0.18488574028015137,
-0.20174813270568848,
0.10360080748796463,
0.039754804223775864,
-0.645973265171051,
0.24649479985237122,
-0.1636226773262024,
-0.34390413761138916,
0.14810636639595032,
-0.7569343447685242,
0.4934239685535431,
-0.23944595456123352,
-0.1307556927204132,
-0.5546590089797974,
0.23781685531139374,
0.2670392692089081,
-0.3102840185165405,
0.45031285285949707,
0.4034675061702728,
-0.6885160207748413,
-0.5066985487937927,
-0.2539465129375458,
-0.3239390254020691,
-0.5036150217056274,
0.7187789678573608,
-0.30982762575149536,
-0.8242908120155334,
0.17877669632434845,
0.01332512591034174,
-0.001843571080826223,
0.41838374733924866,
0.5908990502357483,
0.18855217099189758,
0.8397524356842041,
0.43473005294799805,
-0.10563839226961136,
0.577918291091919,
-0.1541125625371933,
0.4575810432434082,
-1.0365697145462036,
-0.21738578379154205,
-0.26852548122406006,
-0.6362073421478271,
-0.7295372486114502,
-0.7736619710922241,
0.3241616487503052,
-0.027198100462555885,
-0.2915462553501129,
0.37315472960472107,
-0.23545026779174805,
0.4804483950138092,
0.49645140767097473,
0.31485044956207275,
0.06763121485710144,
0.3217965364456177,
0.08273589611053467,
-0.1423415094614029,
-0.9102010726928711,
0.02007204294204712,
0.8216240406036377,
1.0670549869537354,
1.4003188610076904,
0.2902625799179077,
0.3830462098121643,
0.10998702794313431,
0.4336155354976654,
-1.1763317584991455,
0.24672791361808777,
-0.17150302231311798,
-0.7229824066162109,
-0.39489731192588806,
-0.4667423963546753,
-0.8469721078872681,
0.38779404759407043,
0.05043782666325569,
-0.6409617066383362,
0.4045163691043854,
0.3274634778499603,
-0.6875457167625427,
0.35441815853118896,
-0.5772677659988403,
0.6232537031173706,
-0.34321269392967224,
-0.5650840401649475,
-0.06146737560629845,
-0.5347716808319092,
0.3698652982711792,
0.1814267486333847,
-0.09861140698194504,
0.20092594623565674,
-0.12565813958644867,
0.6525427103042603,
-0.41018080711364746,
0.7485832571983337,
-0.17455753684043884,
-0.284432977437973,
0.27321603894233704,
0.028049392625689507,
0.6974102258682251,
-0.017622854560613632,
0.10633455961942673,
-0.005043811164796352,
-0.7233585119247437,
-0.4020514190196991,
-0.9928538203239441,
0.7153491377830505,
-0.6357564330101013,
-0.6573663353919983,
-0.3927760124206543,
-0.4319680333137512,
-0.13382913172245026,
0.21522188186645508,
-0.029678888618946075,
0.7312962412834167,
0.13452325761318207,
0.5668251514434814,
0.9004004597663879,
0.0246789138764143,
0.4858078360557556,
0.15988481044769287,
-0.6121631860733032,
-0.5226422548294067,
0.7520758509635925,
-0.14841927587985992,
0.715876042842865,
0.3675284683704376,
0.46501052379608154,
-0.49786919355392456,
-0.17415955662727356,
-0.5296673774719238,
0.25417083501815796,
-0.6210929751396179,
-0.09318023175001144,
-0.8099173307418823,
-0.5767374038696289,
-0.20877577364444733,
0.310204416513443,
-0.48407942056655884,
-0.49842536449432373,
-0.04445991665124893,
-0.19975559413433075,
0.3733537495136261,
1.0186922550201416,
-0.24173402786254883,
0.6027422547340393,
-0.2701491713523865,
0.6895882487297058,
0.7061130404472351,
0.7040517926216125,
0.2605123817920685,
-0.7467884421348572,
-0.27615198493003845,
-0.022573048248887062,
-0.08668314665555954,
-0.5685446858406067,
0.17576450109481812,
0.21257193386554718,
0.4228651523590088,
0.6954962015151978,
-0.4598110616207123,
0.5617712736129761,
-0.6686709523200989,
0.5813225507736206,
0.45649170875549316,
-0.5692654252052307,
0.09537167102098465,
-0.5052845478057861,
0.49833813309669495,
0.14131690561771393,
0.10191407799720764,
-0.5372860431671143,
0.10950334370136261,
-0.3938876986503601,
-0.5824005007743835,
0.8747664093971252,
0.09098973125219345,
0.10936827957630157,
0.07555857300758362,
0.35370755195617676,
-0.09149821102619171,
0.036328431218862534,
-0.8370866179466248,
-0.29734617471694946,
-0.05777774751186371,
-0.11719299107789993,
0.09285013377666473,
-0.40719538927078247,
-0.16576118767261505,
-0.26763367652893066,
0.7453992366790771,
-0.06467602401971817,
0.7350487112998962,
0.1797766536474228,
0.13229554891586304,
-0.13598978519439697,
0.1455232799053192,
0.5453868508338928,
0.28976356983184814,
-0.10408806800842285,
0.2852744162082672,
0.08163762837648392,
-0.22258998453617096,
0.15689152479171753,
0.04117213562130928,
-0.12530528008937836,
0.0925678238272667,
0.1468288153409958,
1.2506053447723389,
0.2783840000629425,
-0.08722192794084549,
0.5423064827919006,
0.06280183792114258,
-0.42873579263687134,
0.09482316672801971,
-0.049738187342882156,
0.2126135230064392,
0.33844128251075745,
0.0032425043173134327,
0.26096728444099426,
0.20551586151123047,
-0.4410317838191986,
0.34120407700538635,
0.2606039047241211,
-0.8722960948944092,
-0.14934806525707245,
0.6404988169670105,
0.31446489691734314,
-0.3618115186691284,
0.34706324338912964,
-0.507571816444397,
-0.6420915722846985,
0.5741629004478455,
0.963455855846405,
0.9978353381156921,
0.05476564168930054,
0.09635636955499649,
0.6741719245910645,
0.6909778714179993,
-0.39029768109321594,
0.37667348980903625,
-0.07138585299253464,
-0.6756470203399658,
-0.3850801885128021,
-0.3974299430847168,
0.026461631059646606,
0.35805973410606384,
-0.5880125761032104,
-0.0815419852733612,
-0.5878299474716187,
-0.4252861440181732,
-0.28104367852211,
-0.18356089293956757,
-0.36351174116134644,
0.1533002108335495,
0.39880985021591187,
0.877311646938324,
-0.39939433336257935,
0.8800132274627686,
0.21067216992378235,
-0.04736078903079033,
-0.41724899411201477,
-0.12445037066936493,
0.06018267944455147,
-0.6364201307296753,
0.9077361226081848,
0.07159432023763657,
-0.45792916417121887,
0.04252045974135399,
-0.41320502758026123,
-1.1801058053970337,
0.8899584412574768,
-0.07261082530021667,
-0.7857007384300232,
-0.16746288537979126,
0.12476757913827896,
0.7274200320243835,
-0.3303947150707245,
-0.05029749497771263,
0.5314765572547913,
0.3146291971206665,
-0.015078365802764893,
-0.6356350779533386,
-0.0654636025428772,
-0.3398124575614929,
0.5900543928146362,
0.2736547589302063,
-0.6514551043510437,
0.7522820234298706,
-0.41692885756492615,
-0.43950703740119934,
0.303852379322052,
0.9966508746147156,
0.08323699235916138,
-0.09896572679281235,
0.5753709077835083,
0.6437428593635559,
0.44672128558158875,
-0.38186490535736084,
1.0038983821868896,
-0.1315777748823166,
0.454821914434433,
1.470823884010315,
-0.2968187928199768,
0.8707677125930786,
0.3867700397968292,
-0.08259133994579315,
0.47632378339767456,
0.413763165473938,
-0.006374817807227373,
0.5849102735519409,
0.7497556209564209,
-0.3071916699409485,
-0.11712407320737839,
-0.27101394534111023,
-0.45249682664871216,
0.21084050834178925,
0.2516591548919678,
-0.4061056673526764,
-0.37753233313560486,
-0.1262788027524948,
-0.10322735458612442,
-0.11674084514379501,
-0.2036370038986206,
0.8086764216423035,
0.24128201603889465,
-0.5605746507644653,
0.388345330953598,
0.16742368042469025,
0.6542602777481079,
-0.5487460494041443,
-0.002038576640188694,
-0.17500193417072296,
0.45371365547180176,
-0.12729968130588531,
-0.45863524079322815,
-0.02258613146841526,
0.01397310383617878,
-0.14735262095928192,
-0.31910550594329834,
0.6627373695373535,
-0.7664285898208618,
-0.3747636675834656,
0.49706923961639404,
0.17821331322193146,
-0.23316897451877594,
0.2709612548351288,
-0.6031414270401001,
-0.04048636928200722,
-0.2185109406709671,
-0.2661053240299225,
0.06201065704226494,
0.2163555920124054,
-0.09238272160291672,
0.6635051965713501,
0.44683584570884705,
0.18531344830989838,
0.38420796394348145,
0.32807448506355286,
0.7257354259490967,
-0.4019208252429962,
-0.3758631944656372,
-0.5271782875061035,
0.20590126514434814,
-0.09391822665929794,
-0.283006876707077,
0.4869302809238434,
0.7765055298805237,
0.592993438243866,
-0.08980759233236313,
0.9560486674308777,
0.07101157307624817,
0.3248070180416107,
-0.46749237179756165,
0.7186212539672852,
-0.407699853181839,
-0.06598740071058273,
0.19729207456111908,
-0.6751765608787537,
-0.15120044350624084,
0.40166231989860535,
-0.27354732155799866,
0.2767447829246521,
0.7333895564079285,
1.1112836599349976,
-0.05522153154015541,
-0.09926527738571167,
0.2864306569099426,
0.3662489056587219,
0.2297484576702118,
0.6192641258239746,
0.7915937304496765,
-0.7350834608078003,
0.37040483951568604,
-0.2331908643245697,
-0.3651542365550995,
-0.13453403115272522,
-0.7330203056335449,
-0.8785537481307983,
-0.2671544849872589,
-0.23103997111320496,
-0.5731066465377808,
0.21810665726661682,
1.0397495031356812,
0.9499008655548096,
-0.7618467211723328,
-0.23139451444149017,
-0.17795415222644806,
0.08219566941261292,
-0.06447681039571762,
-0.21895861625671387,
0.015142946504056454,
-0.41981571912765503,
-0.39329254627227783,
0.336982786655426,
0.4020368754863739,
-0.03976178169250488,
-0.41959062218666077,
-0.15068931877613068,
-0.04085357114672661,
0.06233115866780281,
0.7639315128326416,
0.47071555256843567,
-0.9413647651672363,
-0.007915446534752846,
0.2087804526090622,
-0.44613996148109436,
0.05667641758918762,
0.7816038727760315,
-0.5692327618598938,
0.6647132635116577,
0.8092588782310486,
1.0176582336425781,
0.5151839256286621,
0.3011133372783661,
0.738401472568512,
-0.6850560903549194,
0.14635764062404633,
-0.1380731165409088,
0.10208436101675034,
0.03563623130321503,
-0.19253860414028168,
0.16161838173866272,
0.06605373322963715,
-0.48462796211242676,
-0.273947536945343,
0.32662999629974365,
-0.8308379650115967,
0.0691625252366066,
1.6809602975845337,
0.04743560403585434,
-0.5029945373535156,
0.03360087797045708,
-0.1933508664369583,
0.17882372438907623,
-0.4719105064868927,
0.6006969213485718,
0.3756776452064514,
0.06668290495872498,
-0.2967877686023712,
-0.6482890248298645,
0.7005022168159485,
0.19180350005626678,
-0.8939911127090454,
0.09445870667695999,
0.21752861142158508,
-0.0880410298705101,
0.08572676032781601,
0.41917169094085693,
-0.3113340735435486,
0.48623210191726685,
0.024457210674881935,
0.26599594950675964,
-0.013741926290094852,
-0.6709694266319275,
-0.7407958507537842,
0.005286660045385361,
0.05933215469121933,
-0.4165618419647217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07900v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07900v2
|
High-Dimension Human Value Representation in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-11T16:39:00 | 2024-06-25T12:23:00 |
Samuel Cahyawijaya, Delong Chen, Yejin Bang, Leila Khalatbari, Bryan Wilie, Ziwei Ji, Etsuko Ishii, Pascale Fung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The widespread application of Large Language Models (LLMs) across various
tasks and fields has necessitated the alignment of these models with human
values and preferences. Given various approaches of human value alignment,
ranging from Reinforcement Learning with Human Feedback (RLHF), to
constitutional learning, etc. there is an urgent need to understand the scope
and nature of human values injected into these models before their release.
There is also a need for model alignment without a costly large scale human
annotation effort. We propose UniVaR, a high-dimensional representation of
human value distributions in LLMs, orthogonal to model architecture and
training data. Trained from the value-relevant output of eight multilingual
LLMs and tested on the output from four multilingual LLMs, namely LlaMA2,
ChatGPT, JAIS and Yi, we show that UniVaR is a powerful tool to compare the
distribution of human values embedded in different LLMs with different langauge
sources. Through UniVaR, we explore how different LLMs prioritize various
values in different languages and cultures, shedding light on the complex
interplay between human values and language modeling.
|
[
-0.1691758781671524,
-0.18971668183803558,
0.33436477184295654,
0.27060607075691223,
-0.04836432263255119,
0.3661663830280304,
-0.4716903865337372,
-0.47810986638069153,
0.22287239134311676,
0.6051232814788818,
-0.2082308530807495,
-0.3920205235481262,
-0.38935285806655884,
-0.30170953273773193,
-0.06906182318925858,
0.7507818937301636,
0.07749513536691666,
0.14622150361537933,
-0.4065295159816742,
-0.46022775769233704,
-0.2888036072254181,
-1.1166402101516724,
-0.0684838593006134,
-0.6618854999542236,
0.5357102155685425,
0.4320303797721863,
0.8292006254196167,
0.4757392406463623,
0.2925673723220825,
0.24516136944293976,
-0.19835719466209412,
0.10315032303333282,
-0.34953415393829346,
-0.015900922939181328,
-0.1468505859375,
-0.1689261496067047,
-0.5212352275848389,
0.271583616733551,
0.691569983959198,
1.0558273792266846,
-0.12125131487846375,
0.3194808065891266,
0.1068434789776802,
0.6072608828544617,
-0.44463077187538147,
0.28300943970680237,
-0.23372790217399597,
-0.023964472115039825,
-0.4589442014694214,
0.03245145455002785,
-0.3930245637893677,
-0.2976303696632385,
-0.20280253887176514,
-0.4618974030017853,
-0.271555095911026,
0.08416000753641129,
1.0845283269882202,
0.2289889007806778,
-0.7163260579109192,
0.46879416704177856,
-0.6059503555297852,
1.1539171934127808,
-0.585940420627594,
0.3838331997394562,
0.2410992980003357,
0.4180109202861786,
-0.27543750405311584,
0.0006225340766832232,
-0.35988837480545044,
0.14462290704250336,
-0.1949230134487152,
-0.09895036369562149,
0.025972243398427963,
-0.04430106282234192,
-0.16929151117801666,
0.31119441986083984,
-0.24664734303951263,
0.6334301829338074,
-0.07019069045782089,
-0.16077199578285217,
0.7842882871627808,
0.16238364577293396,
-0.0007585257408209145,
-0.3003179430961609,
-0.43772682547569275,
-0.42622435092926025,
-0.8029001355171204,
0.31661391258239746,
0.5113986134529114,
0.5381667613983154,
-0.10638544708490372,
0.5793358683586121,
-0.17953692376613617,
0.6521787643432617,
-0.2064066380262375,
-0.24062007665634155,
0.5247095823287964,
0.05492733046412468,
-0.17973992228507996,
-0.1500384658575058,
0.9891648292541504,
0.2617189288139343,
0.529862105846405,
-0.05593257024884224,
-0.19641858339309692,
-0.2485003024339676,
0.14852403104305267,
-0.7057526707649231,
0.1568601280450821,
-0.059727348387241364,
-0.6275394558906555,
-0.5787736773490906,
-0.1456085741519928,
-0.941422164440155,
-0.47285890579223633,
-0.5212559103965759,
0.11018006503582001,
-0.04757919907569885,
-0.27340883016586304,
0.010235276073217392,
0.21972143650054932,
0.22727446258068085,
0.33306801319122314,
-1.2777698040008545,
0.04120262339711189,
0.4145433008670807,
0.36794427037239075,
-0.2935584485530853,
-0.5115578174591064,
-0.4048091471195221,
0.06989137083292007,
-0.39147788286209106,
0.918160617351532,
-0.6962653398513794,
-0.13397294282913208,
-0.0031215331982821226,
-0.1648096889257431,
0.3858970105648041,
-0.5955030918121338,
0.5008240342140198,
-0.6175709962844849,
0.013188093900680542,
-0.5435636639595032,
-0.421826034784317,
-0.28972184658050537,
0.04812704026699066,
-0.5780996680259705,
1.253555178642273,
0.441365510225296,
-0.6630982756614685,
0.5021253228187561,
-0.6718016862869263,
-0.35251855850219727,
0.16080212593078613,
-0.6804343461990356,
-0.35382041335105896,
0.223414346575737,
0.13145016133785248,
0.7700316905975342,
-0.7932441830635071,
0.3730734586715698,
-0.3188015818595886,
-0.12936189770698547,
0.5048983097076416,
-0.7858222126960754,
0.8189610242843628,
0.1219656765460968,
-0.14484110474586487,
0.4133417010307312,
-0.7255190014839172,
0.21282926201820374,
0.16015909612178802,
-0.6009662747383118,
-0.318253755569458,
-0.09418745338916779,
0.4553411602973938,
0.18894082307815552,
0.28193578124046326,
-0.4017447531223297,
0.4230051636695862,
-0.04831954091787338,
0.38363316655158997,
0.7891979813575745,
-0.27963289618492126,
0.5032492876052856,
0.0003802952414844185,
0.5191316604614258,
0.15590617060661316,
0.09825193881988525,
0.1659073829650879,
-0.3087257146835327,
-0.33016708493232727,
-0.47740259766578674,
0.5115854144096375,
0.3155486583709717,
0.0981939285993576,
0.4059143662452698,
-0.18894821405410767,
-0.16618111729621887,
-0.8317106366157532,
0.1417040377855301,
0.26584747433662415,
0.12767241895198822,
0.19571374356746674,
-0.09666533023118973,
-0.43156641721725464,
-1.1154474020004272,
-0.09215641021728516,
-0.22045527398586273,
-0.19675131142139435,
0.09636228531599045,
0.2502083480358124,
-0.29587823152542114,
0.984571099281311,
-0.5417819023132324,
-0.3574405312538147,
-0.26328155398368835,
0.46828794479370117,
0.06615894287824631,
0.13696928322315216,
0.603224515914917,
-0.7035226225852966,
-0.2888389527797699,
0.30832037329673767,
-0.6881930232048035,
-0.24877630174160004,
0.07909681648015976,
-0.2637678384780884,
0.3577573597431183,
0.1858457624912262,
-0.29517099261283875,
0.3817789554595947,
0.6660625338554382,
-0.40670499205589294,
0.4589861035346985,
-0.4340232312679291,
0.3468586206436157,
-1.118662714958191,
0.19352537393569946,
-0.2042742818593979,
-0.2855382263660431,
-0.37548765540122986,
-0.1437901258468628,
0.22909927368164062,
0.11303095519542694,
-0.39689841866493225,
0.6626111268997192,
-0.46683797240257263,
-0.5889367461204529,
-0.1295858472585678,
-0.1127408817410469,
0.08914147317409515,
0.5344762802124023,
0.14648708701133728,
0.8691611886024475,
0.09837643057107925,
-0.2585922181606293,
0.5224813222885132,
0.396963506937027,
-0.4729224443435669,
0.8232152462005615,
-0.48762673139572144,
-0.24507850408554077,
-0.2662004828453064,
-0.02497647888958454,
-0.6794927716255188,
-0.43757808208465576,
-0.2515943646430969,
-0.37091585993766785,
0.10715615749359131,
-0.1846616119146347,
-0.6455435752868652,
0.06580222398042679,
-0.16339126229286194,
0.6570907235145569,
0.7004448175430298,
-0.6134916543960571,
0.4677696228027344,
0.8835231065750122,
0.037137221544981,
-0.5397353172302246,
-0.5227840542793274,
0.04178222641348839,
-0.4800550937652588,
-0.4563814401626587,
0.12812654674053192,
0.14843976497650146,
-0.3135233521461487,
-0.12561696767807007,
0.5274713635444641,
-0.13820140063762665,
0.16213680803775787,
0.31417715549468994,
0.2076815813779831,
-0.05981145799160004,
0.2748987376689911,
-0.15098439157009125,
-0.16863636672496796,
-0.14926482737064362,
-0.353295236825943,
0.43621572852134705,
-0.12119118124246597,
-0.5482721924781799,
-0.12795491516590118,
0.5464369654655457,
0.8107358813285828,
-0.4878372848033905,
0.6938802003860474,
0.45933470129966736,
-0.43215543031692505,
0.09856845438480377,
-0.4276234209537506,
0.15255415439605713,
-0.3472162187099457,
0.37414178252220154,
-0.20005396008491516,
-0.7608562111854553,
0.5429619550704956,
-0.09110786765813828,
0.16423091292381287,
0.5278722643852234,
0.713732123374939,
-0.17982542514801025,
1.1363530158996582,
0.6751596331596375,
-0.4259961247444153,
0.22089095413684845,
-0.13762670755386353,
0.09247496724128723,
-0.9642842411994934,
-0.4679311513900757,
-0.4718412160873413,
-0.3666023015975952,
-0.3590056598186493,
-0.6597254872322083,
0.31045398116111755,
0.3012055456638336,
-0.6060492992401123,
0.0984223335981369,
-0.3314152657985687,
0.4659231901168823,
0.49612441658973694,
-0.44963181018829346,
0.30867910385131836,
0.15705351531505585,
-0.2490948885679245,
-0.3342059254646301,
-0.5213196873664856,
-0.7282652854919434,
1.0319725275039673,
0.5190948247909546,
1.0336251258850098,
0.223792165517807,
0.42833009362220764,
0.07128071784973145,
0.4681532680988312,
-0.74068683385849,
0.21391557157039642,
-0.3088991343975067,
-0.38624313473701477,
-0.7024744749069214,
-0.44715434312820435,
-1.0748482942581177,
0.5438730120658875,
-0.22713041305541992,
-0.8001875877380371,
0.3223542273044586,
0.17219874262809753,
-0.5804256200790405,
0.43183398246765137,
-0.42953258752822876,
1.1005243062973022,
-0.7536084651947021,
-0.1136239767074585,
-0.07599751651287079,
-0.4933227300643921,
0.17242178320884705,
-0.060803405940532684,
0.47065073251724243,
-0.4436080753803253,
0.23054692149162292,
0.663873553276062,
-0.151766836643219,
0.924336850643158,
0.07214165478944778,
-0.27664247155189514,
-0.07874471694231033,
-0.012743393890559673,
0.2085203230381012,
-0.04219967499375343,
-0.10325873643159866,
0.38098183274269104,
-0.000140462041599676,
-0.6093868613243103,
-0.29556986689567566,
0.6168203353881836,
-1.204624056816101,
-0.41982516646385193,
-0.6407185196876526,
-0.8342893123626709,
-0.1781378984451294,
0.15274736285209656,
0.13560764491558075,
0.21570992469787598,
-0.4302949011325836,
0.055694714188575745,
0.6373417973518372,
-0.43881499767303467,
0.13722537457942963,
0.22482775151729584,
-0.5874695181846619,
-0.36117345094680786,
0.7326621413230896,
-0.008452806621789932,
0.47752833366394043,
0.5886049866676331,
0.307719349861145,
-0.4464970529079437,
-0.08148656040430069,
-0.7281669974327087,
0.19574132561683655,
-0.7298792600631714,
-0.28179964423179626,
-0.36976537108421326,
-0.1032978743314743,
-0.3347126543521881,
-0.18014360964298248,
-0.5400068759918213,
-0.26802346110343933,
-0.3784630298614502,
-0.06051911041140556,
0.7375506162643433,
1.037203311920166,
-0.05118437111377716,
0.10217089205980301,
-0.7211299538612366,
0.03026985190808773,
0.39819228649139404,
0.48036977648735046,
0.0731445848941803,
-0.5433319211006165,
-0.2743206322193146,
0.3336437940597534,
-0.27542752027511597,
-0.6738669276237488,
0.5342086553573608,
-0.022627679631114006,
0.5790655612945557,
0.598722517490387,
0.009458585642278194,
0.7065714001655579,
-0.4226698577404022,
0.5794864296913147,
0.21707190573215485,
-0.8661150932312012,
-0.04404572769999504,
-0.2716479003429413,
0.22363299131393433,
0.4460532069206238,
0.15377673506736755,
-1.0144753456115723,
0.15819209814071655,
-0.28325697779655457,
-0.7499711513519287,
0.6157549023628235,
-0.19849570095539093,
0.1122061237692833,
0.10721863806247711,
0.17348450422286987,
0.05750086531043053,
0.2125847488641739,
-0.664124608039856,
-0.020809587091207504,
-0.20716646313667297,
-0.39787718653678894,
-0.23360994458198547,
-0.34894731640815735,
-0.10262329131364822,
-0.3127501308917999,
0.2805611193180084,
-0.2418443262577057,
0.23423273861408234,
-0.36664867401123047,
-0.10541098564863205,
-0.4175049066543579,
0.44107332825660706,
0.5102370977401733,
0.5472924709320068,
-0.16520535945892334,
0.3439808487892151,
0.13519549369812012,
0.14094196259975433,
0.5663201808929443,
-0.19045038521289825,
0.06305990368127823,
-0.40194380283355713,
0.2904866933822632,
0.867374837398529,
0.47883471846580505,
-0.7331516146659851,
0.6805172562599182,
0.19853180646896362,
-0.10368645936250687,
-0.3539198935031891,
-0.3324166536331177,
0.521244466304779,
0.18292447924613953,
0.11074420809745789,
-0.1516827493906021,
-0.2233835756778717,
-0.8305070400238037,
-0.0478072464466095,
0.4731082022190094,
-0.37325984239578247,
-0.42118996381759644,
0.7574914693832397,
0.2397000938653946,
-0.1534276157617569,
0.8484825491905212,
-0.2696003317832947,
-0.7483693361282349,
0.26592743396759033,
0.2103661149740219,
0.6292169690132141,
-0.32298532128334045,
0.3612349331378937,
0.009272880852222443,
-0.0012939053121954203,
-0.1970093846321106,
0.28921133279800415,
0.32717618346214294,
-0.7018389105796814,
-0.5753132700920105,
-0.8823175430297852,
-0.17666171491146088,
0.12264221906661987,
-0.6332165002822876,
0.1131838858127594,
-0.01660092920064926,
0.07781568169593811,
0.1312161535024643,
-0.11826030164957047,
-0.6643613576889038,
-0.182822585105896,
0.0993877574801445,
0.4802655577659607,
-1.1569254398345947,
0.9859240651130676,
0.8119658827781677,
-0.5196648836135864,
-0.7210500240325928,
-0.016201727092266083,
0.07150648534297943,
-0.8116236329078674,
1.2762081623077393,
-0.0229287538677454,
0.004487278871238232,
-0.3305703103542328,
-0.08627056330442429,
-1.012675166130066,
1.0154651403427124,
0.6882864832878113,
-0.35756200551986694,
0.15405957400798798,
0.6513068079948425,
0.562498927116394,
-0.4702686667442322,
0.2677319049835205,
0.5002564191818237,
0.6197213530540466,
0.19053083658218384,
-0.8383269906044006,
-0.19279374182224274,
0.1341392695903778,
0.3533017635345459,
0.5949032306671143,
-0.7674384713172913,
0.9183996319770813,
-0.2535755932331085,
-0.09877382218837738,
-0.21060581505298615,
0.7489972114562988,
0.1557837426662445,
-0.31202831864356995,
0.4240393340587616,
0.5211554169654846,
0.8613773584365845,
0.13386142253875732,
0.8262211084365845,
-0.024854613468050957,
0.3353199064731598,
0.7947278022766113,
-0.4494688808917999,
0.9601583480834961,
0.501173734664917,
-0.4406138062477112,
0.1684628576040268,
0.8299495577812195,
0.23773783445358276,
0.2953788638114929,
0.441739559173584,
0.009013867005705833,
-0.5777060985565186,
-0.2587468922138214,
-0.002762148156762123,
0.4830124080181122,
0.03172842040657997,
0.01870296336710453,
-0.2662004828453064,
-0.04306279867887497,
0.1285618543624878,
0.36109477281570435,
-0.055849071592092514,
0.615837812423706,
-0.011557143181562424,
-0.6091561317443848,
0.8006042838096619,
0.027074845507740974,
0.5174477100372314,
-0.276390939950943,
-0.1512012481689453,
-0.2855864465236664,
0.3076021075248718,
-0.19104470312595367,
-0.9793234467506409,
0.13872933387756348,
0.07314184308052063,
-0.33746641874313354,
-0.427341490983963,
0.014643716625869274,
-0.7288859486579895,
-0.6273610591888428,
0.5744009017944336,
0.18119969964027405,
0.2954501807689667,
-0.0879417210817337,
-0.44484779238700867,
0.05625634267926216,
-0.07952678203582764,
-0.27295225858688354,
0.7311486601829529,
0.5597279071807861,
-0.6844544410705566,
0.5749894976615906,
0.4609992206096649,
0.1716107875108719,
-0.07922447472810745,
0.32699498534202576,
0.5757386684417725,
-0.6931840777397156,
-0.280082106590271,
-0.693581759929657,
0.4443008303642273,
-0.0607757568359375,
-0.41991403698921204,
0.43532463908195496,
0.45878708362579346,
0.8232371807098389,
0.13523896038532257,
0.7193797826766968,
0.2848110496997833,
0.45564940571784973,
-0.31299683451652527,
0.6953580379486084,
-0.5579764246940613,
0.299450159072876,
-0.08680930733680725,
-0.7614619731903076,
-0.3497388958930969,
0.6797318458557129,
-0.05577811598777771,
-0.05158750340342522,
0.34347105026245117,
0.38791197538375854,
-0.016353104263544083,
-0.41579294204711914,
0.6147031188011169,
0.026852207258343697,
0.3814578056335449,
0.44227707386016846,
0.8552576303482056,
-0.026666628196835518,
0.18537384271621704,
-0.028380699455738068,
-0.46143969893455505,
-0.41794678568840027,
-0.948630154132843,
-0.8508139848709106,
-0.6890605092048645,
-0.04432712495326996,
0.04283161833882332,
-0.29304763674736023,
1.3982151746749878,
0.7566856741905212,
-0.8114601969718933,
-0.7328629493713379,
0.3786512613296509,
-0.04247637838125229,
-0.3329642415046692,
-0.12533652782440186,
0.5359188318252563,
-0.23225216567516327,
-0.5123928189277649,
0.07878600805997849,
0.4274795651435852,
0.1960289627313614,
-0.6583849191665649,
-0.2614651918411255,
-0.13871406018733978,
0.13191896677017212,
0.6742461919784546,
0.21877555549144745,
-0.7732850909233093,
-0.5430801510810852,
-0.10376197099685669,
-0.16557946801185608,
0.26228752732276917,
0.7505340576171875,
-0.6413615345954895,
0.11605676263570786,
0.4117698073387146,
0.7921671867370605,
0.18271781504154205,
-0.05690329894423485,
0.7253395915031433,
-0.7616367936134338,
0.18371959030628204,
0.07996094226837158,
0.5493662357330322,
0.481869101524353,
-0.46448180079460144,
0.132180854678154,
-0.06847882270812988,
-0.7175086736679077,
-0.7271947264671326,
0.5238967537879944,
-0.7520610094070435,
-0.2701095640659332,
1.2205277681350708,
-0.08548788726329803,
-0.16630013287067413,
0.004440166521817446,
-0.15495339035987854,
0.03773071989417076,
-0.5034924149513245,
0.8314900398254395,
0.6465594172477722,
-0.04350145906209946,
-0.13524043560028076,
-0.6336004137992859,
0.45752832293510437,
0.43367287516593933,
-1.0301787853240967,
0.6975148916244507,
0.401123583316803,
0.14259929955005646,
-0.011764599941670895,
0.3986579179763794,
-0.3515876233577728,
-0.17461784183979034,
-0.6658745408058167,
0.7485440373420715,
0.24473358690738678,
-0.1711357980966568,
-0.46199023723602295,
-0.021179096773266792,
0.6474466323852539,
-0.10680098086595535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07879v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07879v1
|
Analyzing Toxicity in Deep Conversations: A Reddit Case Study
| 2024-04-11T16:10:44 | 2024-04-11T16:10:44 |
Vigneshwaran Shankaran, Rajesh Sharma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI
|
Online social media has become increasingly popular in recent years due to
its ease of access and ability to connect with others. One of social media's
main draws is its anonymity, allowing users to share their thoughts and
opinions without fear of judgment or retribution. This anonymity has also made
social media prone to harmful content, which requires moderation to ensure
responsible and productive use. Several methods using artificial intelligence
have been employed to detect harmful content. However, conversation and
contextual analysis of hate speech are still understudied. Most promising works
only analyze a single text at a time rather than the conversation supporting
it. In this work, we employ a tree-based approach to understand how users
behave concerning toxicity in public conversation settings. To this end, we
collect both the posts and the comment sections of the top 100 posts from 8
Reddit communities that allow profanity, totaling over 1 million responses. We
find that toxic comments increase the likelihood of subsequent toxic comments
being produced in online conversations. Our analysis also shows that immediate
context plays a vital role in shaping a response rather than the original post.
We also study the effect of consensual profanity and observe overlapping
similarities with non-consensual profanity in terms of user behavior and
patterns.
|
[
-0.2386610358953476,
-1.3074820041656494,
0.5153976678848267,
0.23925285041332245,
-0.3553062677383423,
0.05613496154546738,
-0.11341826617717743,
-0.6647582054138184,
0.10471858829259872,
0.47551560401916504,
-0.5160011053085327,
-0.5251877903938293,
-0.8141797184944153,
-0.055282268673181534,
-0.7807063460350037,
1.1438482999801636,
0.38933229446411133,
-0.2124975621700287,
-0.06826483458280563,
-0.24742794036865234,
-0.5026082396507263,
-0.7008472681045532,
-0.9191489219665527,
0.1415770798921585,
0.8787818551063538,
0.34177276492118835,
0.6723260879516602,
0.3971370756626129,
0.6340492963790894,
0.3987492322921753,
-0.35255441069602966,
-0.19761982560157776,
-0.9730402827262878,
0.46712201833724976,
-0.38479894399642944,
-0.10146500170230865,
-0.14348627626895905,
-0.17796948552131653,
0.2318030595779419,
0.3347781300544739,
0.045305486768484116,
0.17666777968406677,
0.025803033262491226,
0.3438129425048828,
-0.508050799369812,
-0.134134903550148,
-0.7162889838218689,
0.2220398485660553,
-0.3022046983242035,
-0.27932557463645935,
-0.193881556391716,
-0.47996070981025696,
0.13848386704921722,
-0.4024864435195923,
-0.09344885498285294,
-0.29563072323799133,
0.5593786835670471,
0.1852617859840393,
-0.6293054223060608,
-0.6401247978210449,
-1.0762765407562256,
0.8312751054763794,
-0.7518066763877869,
0.10686106979846954,
0.34436193108558655,
0.10533682256937027,
0.0998419001698494,
-0.6469695568084717,
-0.6106775999069214,
-0.1812583953142166,
-0.6257534027099609,
-0.0036814361810684204,
-0.3118148446083069,
0.13595101237297058,
0.14898774027824402,
0.2261408418416977,
-0.24217063188552856,
-0.023539826273918152,
-0.45128142833709717,
-0.14830297231674194,
0.9325329065322876,
0.3192877769470215,
0.6249635815620422,
-0.13199685513973236,
-0.17931760847568512,
0.09005643427371979,
-0.21452191472053528,
-0.2188328206539154,
0.3978692591190338,
0.09579291939735413,
0.04665355011820793,
0.3607092499732971,
0.12467991560697556,
0.30734941363334656,
-0.31886911392211914,
0.05031465366482735,
-0.10240104794502258,
-0.522202730178833,
0.0502619631588459,
-0.009013314731419086,
0.9148181676864624,
0.9755861759185791,
0.6824563145637512,
0.2415000945329666,
0.32226133346557617,
0.43166816234588623,
0.5332097411155701,
-1.000849723815918,
-0.3708586096763611,
0.11447270959615707,
-0.5163959860801697,
-0.5380772948265076,
-0.2537616193294525,
-1.1459741592407227,
-1.0830962657928467,
0.011111171916127205,
0.08278229832649231,
-0.06792151182889938,
-0.4479774832725525,
-0.27789655327796936,
-0.1279444694519043,
-0.23293951153755188,
0.15089447796344757,
-0.5310234427452087,
0.3640314042568207,
0.44417697191238403,
0.8047709465026855,
-0.2065870463848114,
0.04162401333451271,
-0.18891549110412598,
0.1470523327589035,
-0.16716384887695312,
0.6110255122184753,
-0.8545868992805481,
-0.3719555139541626,
0.2976081669330597,
-0.09719254821538925,
0.32610437273979187,
-0.5137717127799988,
1.041098952293396,
-0.41067755222320557,
0.2752046585083008,
-0.21026889979839325,
-0.2407972365617752,
-0.5174334049224854,
0.3855023682117462,
-0.28748631477355957,
0.5066615343093872,
-0.20280961692333221,
-1.0422037839889526,
0.1952597200870514,
-0.7814562320709229,
-0.7396779656410217,
0.16210554540157318,
-0.11328373104333878,
-0.4066866338253021,
-0.07970773428678513,
-0.19356609880924225,
0.34677159786224365,
0.24314823746681213,
0.0396079421043396,
-0.5229137539863586,
-0.35722002387046814,
0.3931877017021179,
-0.4524553120136261,
0.6939730048179626,
0.42352744936943054,
-0.5676528811454773,
0.42603522539138794,
-0.243021160364151,
-0.127180278301239,
0.04750620201230049,
-0.1683877408504486,
-0.769141435623169,
0.2976987957954407,
0.06507309526205063,
0.2518220543861389,
-0.17995023727416992,
-0.6652006506919861,
-0.6087213754653931,
-0.4840391278266907,
0.8995604515075684,
0.5314744710922241,
0.550114631652832,
0.053551625460386276,
-0.33271485567092896,
0.1446097046136856,
0.20383968949317932,
0.5187432169914246,
0.15371589362621307,
-0.2991175353527069,
-0.5506560802459717,
0.28924277424812317,
-0.2957005798816681,
0.38613444566726685,
-0.19296912848949432,
0.08865632116794586,
-0.014637148007750511,
-0.46856242418289185,
-0.2708524167537689,
-0.030276939272880554,
0.5313580632209778,
0.41901668906211853,
0.4180276095867157,
-0.6014955043792725,
-0.5637469291687012,
-0.90165114402771,
-0.40246713161468506,
-0.2991693913936615,
0.047137923538684845,
0.6986504197120667,
0.21229244768619537,
-0.3243524730205536,
0.6728860139846802,
-0.5226801633834839,
-0.5545344948768616,
0.25210341811180115,
0.18105213344097137,
-0.22952969372272491,
0.35581567883491516,
0.5093804597854614,
-0.7491348385810852,
-0.8155884146690369,
0.056659799069166183,
-0.612106442451477,
-0.05364135652780533,
-0.00891395378857851,
-0.26269277930259705,
-0.21797595918178558,
0.5549653768539429,
-0.30300161242485046,
0.3733876943588257,
0.4446525573730469,
-0.37102267146110535,
0.198340505361557,
0.1675388365983963,
0.4487518072128296,
-0.6399052739143372,
0.1257365643978119,
0.07866497337818146,
0.1581255942583084,
-1.0528031587600708,
-0.10916139930486679,
-0.591064989566803,
-0.02028329111635685,
-0.6476234793663025,
0.29670560359954834,
-0.04615769535303116,
0.2840101420879364,
-0.14606687426567078,
0.27174118161201477,
-0.17393460869789124,
0.3266976475715637,
0.024079397320747375,
0.6095631122589111,
0.1919650286436081,
-0.5128584504127502,
0.16414642333984375,
0.2527076303958893,
-0.19550520181655884,
0.502842903137207,
-0.46973222494125366,
0.15297214686870575,
-0.3952271342277527,
0.23926560580730438,
-0.9678443670272827,
-0.3064109981060028,
0.48935866355895996,
-0.5625065565109253,
-0.3175400197505951,
0.04977940768003464,
-0.32361698150634766,
-0.3319002687931061,
-0.44468533992767334,
0.5229641795158386,
0.1200655996799469,
-0.005599966272711754,
0.25200411677360535,
0.9209034442901611,
-0.4520662724971771,
-0.3969508111476898,
-0.6123005747795105,
0.1496068239212036,
-0.5997850298881531,
-0.4689105153083801,
0.16783548891544342,
-0.4110730290412903,
-0.7387317419052124,
-0.13044987618923187,
0.06436610221862793,
-0.32591912150382996,
0.32299676537513733,
0.3214455544948578,
-0.4416968524456024,
0.15916700661182404,
0.1698756068944931,
0.17481322586536407,
0.34437164664268494,
0.6131559014320374,
0.6324937343597412,
0.6168230772018433,
-0.15677018463611603,
0.16695338487625122,
-0.61201411485672,
0.6196029186248779,
0.7524619102478027,
-0.026836099103093147,
0.6251013875007629,
0.36125418543815613,
-0.36361387372016907,
-0.13735748827457428,
-0.32278743386268616,
-0.4601099491119385,
-0.49490875005722046,
0.3625551760196686,
0.29498299956321716,
-0.8930036425590515,
0.45396870374679565,
0.0612567737698555,
0.19220376014709473,
0.13825254142284393,
0.6359598636627197,
-0.3379172384738922,
1.1466013193130493,
0.28533920645713806,
0.05232016369700432,
0.6846068501472473,
0.11101948469877243,
0.4056619703769684,
-0.21369579434394836,
-0.16597628593444824,
-0.27895644307136536,
-0.4065248668193817,
-0.4276933968067169,
-0.10347729921340942,
0.2448660433292389,
-0.2422618865966797,
-0.5008718371391296,
0.15582135319709778,
-0.714280366897583,
0.7433152198791504,
0.21768125891685486,
0.18854200839996338,
0.44809985160827637,
0.07016782462596893,
0.3141748905181885,
-0.2688550651073456,
-0.3127177953720093,
-0.5511153936386108,
0.5498097538948059,
0.5623127818107605,
0.4409366250038147,
0.3054089844226837,
0.2078702449798584,
0.695146381855011,
0.8248000144958496,
-0.7243098020553589,
0.5485922694206238,
-0.20539109408855438,
-1.1497377157211304,
-0.29501086473464966,
-0.3122769594192505,
-0.9326623678207397,
0.1670357584953308,
-0.40307241678237915,
-0.6701949238777161,
-0.17914098501205444,
0.13985173404216766,
-0.6433441042900085,
0.25047433376312256,
-0.8010550737380981,
0.7744913101196289,
-0.2537112534046173,
-0.5949957370758057,
-0.39605700969696045,
-0.8731212019920349,
0.581164538860321,
-0.012511221691966057,
0.6438475251197815,
-0.07542047649621964,
0.24769842624664307,
0.927885115146637,
-0.041813626885414124,
1.1389641761779785,
-0.1518963873386383,
-0.1643105447292328,
0.6013929843902588,
0.17873898148536682,
0.07106747478246689,
0.0912836492061615,
0.04470248147845268,
0.21250495314598083,
0.03394473344087601,
-0.036146268248558044,
-0.26249197125434875,
0.8424866199493408,
-0.7483528852462769,
-0.48317378759384155,
-0.14801667630672455,
-0.20312221348285675,
-0.1618323028087616,
0.2939985990524292,
0.05579163506627083,
0.02882227674126625,
-0.28556951880455017,
0.3099590539932251,
0.6754115223884583,
-0.49904242157936096,
0.3159192204475403,
0.2619762122631073,
-0.10047802329063416,
-0.24677839875221252,
0.8403834700584412,
0.0011113965883851051,
0.12284387648105621,
0.024382611736655235,
0.6398336887359619,
-0.1583215296268463,
-0.6258648037910461,
-0.09896904975175858,
0.32001543045043945,
-0.7001656889915466,
-0.1841527819633484,
-0.6779769659042358,
-0.269232839345932,
-0.29975202679634094,
-0.1248481273651123,
-0.08165580779314041,
0.11554775387048721,
-0.2277652770280838,
-0.2196461409330368,
0.3055209219455719,
0.9975511431694031,
0.09750397503376007,
0.4720085561275482,
-0.8137627243995667,
-0.21040739119052887,
0.6039298176765442,
0.4612865746021271,
0.26132944226264954,
-0.33033686876296997,
0.19738654792308807,
0.1352519690990448,
-0.39352959394454956,
-1.2797406911849976,
0.3743680715560913,
0.05362289026379585,
0.14237669110298157,
0.5930091142654419,
0.36116674542427063,
0.6631460785865784,
-0.20811952650547028,
0.7581297159194946,
-0.017715727910399437,
-0.5770453810691833,
0.6484779119491577,
-0.5850839614868164,
-0.16743583977222443,
0.795504629611969,
0.6692529320716858,
-1.1033947467803955,
-0.7931581139564514,
-0.5401204228401184,
-0.8068147897720337,
0.3748798668384552,
0.38958653807640076,
0.8510104417800903,
-0.31168001890182495,
0.13009552657604218,
0.0366814024746418,
0.2454453855752945,
-0.8735264539718628,
-0.41243094205856323,
-0.2151743322610855,
-0.06355834007263184,
0.13056395947933197,
-0.5475183129310608,
-0.6360898613929749,
-0.3409363031387329,
0.43742549419403076,
0.3520713150501251,
0.10477732121944427,
0.0067306458950042725,
-0.10599295049905777,
-0.35384222865104675,
0.3414194583892822,
0.8883638978004456,
0.48099908232688904,
-0.22359000146389008,
0.3640945255756378,
0.21288903057575226,
-0.6227376461029053,
-0.1628756821155548,
-0.44261589646339417,
-0.11799190938472748,
-0.20961196720600128,
0.25886479020118713,
0.39469802379608154,
0.23190148174762726,
-0.7607312202453613,
0.7281177639961243,
-0.156142458319664,
-0.09711594879627228,
-0.29893502593040466,
0.08209557831287384,
0.2134549766778946,
0.203639417886734,
-0.014271609485149384,
-0.13306298851966858,
0.23010209202766418,
-0.8392008543014526,
0.5238533616065979,
0.3473661541938782,
-0.6750041842460632,
-0.26508772373199463,
0.6762256622314453,
0.6920874118804932,
-0.4190731942653656,
0.41256797313690186,
0.0727437287569046,
-0.5496278405189514,
0.26485925912857056,
0.22133775055408478,
0.5886287689208984,
-0.16004884243011475,
0.409957617521286,
0.6443242430686951,
0.11913790553808212,
0.7455379366874695,
-0.06436125189065933,
-0.0012928874930366874,
-0.696460485458374,
-0.21999573707580566,
-0.6958199739456177,
-0.2020447999238968,
0.6439709663391113,
-0.15173693001270294,
-0.17519386112689972,
-0.8224242329597473,
-0.26044660806655884,
0.106843963265419,
0.08479850739240646,
-0.15493424236774445,
0.18450383841991425,
0.19917649030685425,
0.32572484016418457,
-1.2633953094482422,
0.3669127821922302,
0.4022866189479828,
-0.40959370136260986,
-0.3065193295478821,
0.22481320798397064,
0.2890267074108124,
-0.5881333351135254,
0.3885226845741272,
0.30341842770576477,
-0.23512430489063263,
0.0228229071944952,
-0.6716112494468689,
-0.5536580681800842,
0.6551923751831055,
-0.00872368086129427,
-0.34117966890335083,
0.24698154628276825,
0.22532208263874054,
1.1495344638824463,
0.0064901201985776424,
0.44425052404403687,
0.6428735852241516,
0.3964253067970276,
0.19655422866344452,
-0.5286788940429688,
0.2320341169834137,
-0.2623843252658844,
-0.048118527978658676,
0.21630708873271942,
-0.6732339859008789,
0.5148084759712219,
0.10687897354364395,
-0.94907146692276,
-0.2582891881465912,
0.5539343357086182,
-0.01840575970709324,
0.36835065484046936,
0.5810562372207642,
0.1502503752708435,
0.4841424524784088,
0.3433920443058014,
0.5714128017425537,
-0.24375419318675995,
0.28167760372161865,
1.0367692708969116,
-0.025370139628648758,
0.8459575772285461,
0.3774665594100952,
-0.03447443246841431,
0.6060255765914917,
0.47226080298423767,
0.19385042786598206,
0.33297985792160034,
0.5362287163734436,
-0.6587321162223816,
-0.062410805374383926,
-0.561240553855896,
-0.3428937494754791,
0.19580745697021484,
0.5077794194221497,
-0.5633743405342102,
-0.35861432552337646,
-0.04386357590556145,
0.584857702255249,
0.5827733874320984,
-0.34261971712112427,
0.949252188205719,
-0.0008865295676514506,
-0.6451291441917419,
0.06677346676588058,
-0.05790155380964279,
0.8530807495117188,
-0.22748731076717377,
-0.04046844691038132,
-0.3792998194694519,
0.1576230376958847,
-0.46981990337371826,
-1.098569393157959,
0.7848955392837524,
0.09263620525598526,
0.3767675757408142,
-0.2560548782348633,
1.0051813125610352,
-0.5052501559257507,
-0.10843750834465027,
0.4433155059814453,
0.30709409713745117,
0.27615293860435486,
-0.1426514983177185,
-0.7585736513137817,
0.16692504286766052,
-0.221293643116951,
-0.10115023702383041,
0.306218683719635,
0.3251487612724304,
-0.1500246822834015,
0.5018084049224854,
0.6221535205841064,
-0.2165088653564453,
0.0756402239203453,
0.006474266294389963,
0.9683302044868469,
-0.474125474691391,
-0.15954315662384033,
-1.0332152843475342,
0.5028389692306519,
-0.46238285303115845,
-0.5504991412162781,
0.7436608076095581,
0.28642234206199646,
0.8890482187271118,
0.22309328615665436,
0.5082675814628601,
-0.15181834995746613,
0.6276366114616394,
0.11597908288240433,
1.2883455753326416,
-0.2415015548467636,
0.004005249124020338,
-0.4423924684524536,
-0.7047079801559448,
-0.7334696054458618,
0.7182258367538452,
-0.39861825108528137,
-0.08015336096286774,
0.5745741724967957,
0.8729745149612427,
0.189663827419281,
0.2018846720457077,
0.2507346570491791,
0.7046051025390625,
0.325033575296402,
0.2842472493648529,
1.0475796461105347,
-0.13131815195083618,
0.9215288162231445,
-0.35413357615470886,
-0.17682725191116333,
-0.1546448916196823,
-0.7093560099601746,
-0.892566442489624,
-0.39456701278686523,
-0.28244537115097046,
-0.34081119298934937,
0.029113953933119774,
0.36867451667785645,
0.31971475481987,
-0.8264058232307434,
-0.19150924682617188,
-0.1653313934803009,
0.25687509775161743,
-0.021634016185998917,
-0.3515957295894623,
-0.007415418047457933,
0.06342456489801407,
-0.7092087864875793,
0.12009208649396896,
0.14728686213493347,
-0.22007742524147034,
-0.18650780618190765,
-0.00916752964258194,
-0.35159119963645935,
0.2504529058933258,
1.110134482383728,
0.22019679844379425,
-0.5058850646018982,
-0.7216066122055054,
-0.23837292194366455,
-0.10298344492912292,
0.05656728520989418,
0.7814512252807617,
-0.31323960423469543,
0.4337988495826721,
0.6261076331138611,
0.3588789403438568,
0.3865070044994354,
0.3788680136203766,
0.25270721316337585,
-0.7745590209960938,
-0.42257505655288696,
0.5317513346672058,
-0.28991004824638367,
0.1556590348482132,
-0.42092710733413696,
0.21885272860527039,
0.35404250025749207,
-0.5616621971130371,
-0.8871392607688904,
0.33285802602767944,
-0.8029749989509583,
-0.5913374423980713,
1.3121360540390015,
0.16005592048168182,
-0.037264179438352585,
-0.36530801653862,
-0.5526381731033325,
0.29806211590766907,
-0.6022103428840637,
1.0560945272445679,
0.8123006224632263,
-0.1633811891078949,
-0.0751955658197403,
-0.6823471784591675,
0.8173500895500183,
0.20321401953697205,
-1.0295307636260986,
0.4888468384742737,
0.5880305171012878,
0.31442898511886597,
0.3309285342693329,
0.7916824817657471,
-0.0698971226811409,
-0.04322655126452446,
-0.17154815793037415,
-0.41360434889793396,
0.34206998348236084,
-0.30136463046073914,
-0.15323635935783386,
0.5868988037109375,
-0.20918767154216766,
0.09366364032030106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07851v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07851v1
|
Guiding Large Language Models to Post-Edit Machine Translation with Error Annotations
| 2024-04-11T15:47:10 | 2024-04-11T15:47:10 |
Dayeon Ki, Marine Carpuat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Machine Translation (MT) remains one of the last NLP tasks where large
language models (LLMs) have not yet replaced dedicated supervised systems. This
work exploits the complementary strengths of LLMs and supervised MT by guiding
LLMs to automatically post-edit MT with external feedback on its quality,
derived from Multidimensional Quality Metric (MQM) annotations. Working with
LLaMA-2 models, we consider prompting strategies varying the nature of feedback
provided and then fine-tune the LLM to improve its ability to exploit the
provided guidance. Through experiments on Chinese-English, English-German, and
English-Russian MQM data, we demonstrate that prompting LLMs to post-edit MT
improves TER, BLEU and COMET scores, although the benefits of fine-grained
feedback are not clear. Fine-tuning helps integrate fine-grained feedback more
effectively and further improves translation quality based on both automatic
and human evaluation.
|
[
-0.20519739389419556,
-0.5627434849739075,
0.6644976735115051,
0.31538766622543335,
-0.4066048860549927,
0.04290200024843216,
-0.5738656520843506,
-0.279876172542572,
0.12435285747051239,
0.7177747488021851,
-0.4649309813976288,
-0.5836144685745239,
-0.8278855085372925,
0.5281445980072021,
-0.09865207970142365,
1.2187243700027466,
-0.3256627917289734,
0.26688554883003235,
0.14840003848075867,
-0.044889114797115326,
-0.691695511341095,
-0.5674569010734558,
-0.7173017263412476,
-0.27902892231941223,
0.9182390570640564,
0.43681928515434265,
1.0484448671340942,
0.6842822432518005,
0.5610655546188354,
0.21749994158744812,
-0.14152520895004272,
0.9265368580818176,
-0.18023833632469177,
0.014972955919802189,
-0.1986658275127411,
-0.6606301665306091,
-0.8074139952659607,
-0.060102127492427826,
0.676579475402832,
0.6600953340530396,
-0.00733626214787364,
0.2555341124534607,
0.5637005567550659,
0.5878199338912964,
-0.24049854278564453,
0.13726551830768585,
-0.5202034711837769,
0.024696409702301025,
-0.14173074066638947,
-0.4320389926433563,
-0.6202181577682495,
-0.3280869722366333,
-0.3214774429798126,
-0.5846153497695923,
-0.18228976428508759,
0.08131693303585052,
0.8053153157234192,
0.6916326284408569,
-0.326436311006546,
-0.11456430703401566,
-0.6857457756996155,
0.7815309166908264,
-0.7927190065383911,
0.2574147880077362,
0.6163386106491089,
0.04404905065894127,
-0.41677555441856384,
-0.2583044171333313,
-0.3667412996292114,
-0.12490066140890121,
-0.21290715038776398,
0.058033961802721024,
0.017872996628284454,
0.022542718797922134,
0.13466034829616547,
0.14608804881572723,
-0.21630369126796722,
0.5038068294525146,
-0.2322053760290146,
-0.13782204687595367,
0.5481281876564026,
0.15907318890094757,
-0.013613907620310783,
-0.09056457877159119,
0.04948842525482178,
-0.13393887877464294,
-0.7959715723991394,
0.13144485652446747,
0.28188833594322205,
0.42981573939323425,
-0.1021907776594162,
0.819406270980835,
-0.30310767889022827,
0.607361912727356,
0.07095054537057877,
-0.00474418792873621,
0.2739170491695404,
-0.30665233731269836,
-0.19813717901706696,
-0.25054609775543213,
0.9051170945167542,
0.8022895455360413,
0.1472397893667221,
-0.1205151155591011,
-0.6308764219284058,
-0.2219058722257614,
0.18061836063861847,
-0.5608406662940979,
-0.19168034195899963,
0.2814430594444275,
-0.531576931476593,
-0.21373654901981354,
-0.006023103836923838,
-0.5510697364807129,
-0.4641457200050354,
-0.6204712986946106,
0.5493259429931641,
-0.23107212781906128,
0.016008974984288216,
0.10223134607076645,
0.1042058989405632,
-0.06564143300056458,
0.8114925622940063,
-0.9411990642547607,
-0.1270456463098526,
0.6632772088050842,
0.9224724173545837,
0.009699597023427486,
-0.40709587931632996,
-1.1520748138427734,
0.17252320051193237,
-0.6885150074958801,
0.7577904462814331,
-0.45729127526283264,
-0.2750711143016815,
0.026016129180788994,
0.23147256672382355,
0.1679714024066925,
-0.6098416447639465,
0.6180039048194885,
-0.46975916624069214,
0.16995356976985931,
-0.41439738869667053,
-0.22421854734420776,
-0.3315434455871582,
0.3593462109565735,
-0.30666306614875793,
0.9988058805465698,
0.133006751537323,
-0.5098692178726196,
0.40460747480392456,
-0.6325270533561707,
-0.37063413858413696,
-0.13696153461933136,
0.27156350016593933,
-0.3795378506183624,
0.5735928416252136,
0.6452761888504028,
0.5454226136207581,
-0.168129101395607,
0.37247946858406067,
-0.19232821464538574,
-0.16184283792972565,
0.20408494770526886,
-0.21775293350219727,
0.3046220541000366,
0.021596895530819893,
-0.08532095700502396,
0.5452713370323181,
-0.6174660325050354,
-0.04185977205634117,
-0.10674861073493958,
-0.6998962759971619,
-0.13752314448356628,
0.005627560894936323,
-0.12554384768009186,
0.38320061564445496,
0.08938578516244888,
-0.19122108817100525,
0.5141296982765198,
-0.27008166909217834,
0.3987969756126404,
0.6794861555099487,
-0.07733374089002609,
0.277847558259964,
-0.38903653621673584,
0.4341917037963867,
-0.05434955656528473,
0.1375800222158432,
-0.3584725558757782,
-0.48895660042762756,
-0.7811485528945923,
0.02791130170226097,
0.541523814201355,
0.6284388303756714,
-0.9517355561256409,
0.5015822052955627,
-0.2020871341228485,
-0.3548261523246765,
-1.0569931268692017,
0.6030199527740479,
0.30076634883880615,
0.12108372896909714,
0.6159890294075012,
-0.35206735134124756,
-0.46491485834121704,
-0.6391278505325317,
-0.0587381049990654,
-0.0968475192785263,
-0.2691170573234558,
0.022476593032479286,
0.38310912251472473,
-0.5917150378227234,
0.3616686165332794,
-0.028112497180700302,
-0.42916345596313477,
-0.13961651921272278,
0.16779468953609467,
0.17460530996322632,
0.5710300803184509,
0.1129232794046402,
-0.29800963401794434,
-0.3616804778575897,
0.16469191014766693,
-0.5649991631507874,
-0.43230074644088745,
-0.23686964809894562,
-0.25824978947639465,
0.23298916220664978,
0.46200254559516907,
-0.6199722290039062,
0.08105557411909103,
0.773305356502533,
-0.052539389580488205,
0.6116064190864563,
-0.5555398464202881,
0.4958997368812561,
-0.9685599207878113,
-0.17091290652751923,
-0.1655339151620865,
-0.308113694190979,
-0.3263784646987915,
0.024519558995962143,
0.10785095393657684,
0.40327590703964233,
-0.30649301409721375,
0.23447322845458984,
-0.17553652822971344,
-0.04063522070646286,
-0.49673497676849365,
0.3494839072227478,
0.11253713071346283,
0.3322586715221405,
-0.017535807564854622,
0.5634858012199402,
0.2051275074481964,
-0.5616148710250854,
0.3390517830848694,
0.3360942304134369,
-0.10812889784574509,
0.6248617768287659,
-0.6153100728988647,
0.1239713728427887,
-0.10782008618116379,
0.3764860928058624,
-0.9518627524375916,
-0.38978826999664307,
0.28864115476608276,
-0.47924116253852844,
0.3567407429218292,
-0.24463313817977905,
-0.9625190496444702,
-0.22821930050849915,
-0.28921955823898315,
-0.1274861991405487,
0.20160576701164246,
-0.5586504340171814,
0.3153069317340851,
0.02726396918296814,
-0.22363387048244476,
-0.2727760076522827,
-0.8289420008659363,
0.40451547503471375,
-0.07189254462718964,
-0.46473658084869385,
0.11623076349496841,
-0.007141963113099337,
-0.20571210980415344,
-0.1822286695241928,
0.3661799728870392,
0.16328085958957672,
0.2778894901275635,
0.28194671869277954,
0.2541233003139496,
-0.2133021503686905,
0.27028924226760864,
0.3807317614555359,
-0.39382508397102356,
-0.022257406264543533,
-0.44064855575561523,
0.4252583682537079,
0.11509685963392258,
-0.21396729350090027,
-0.7356228232383728,
0.12367292493581772,
0.4075242578983307,
-0.4235994517803192,
0.7632929682731628,
0.7507836222648621,
-0.270355224609375,
-0.007362485397607088,
-0.511480450630188,
-0.41993749141693115,
-0.355206698179245,
0.22992730140686035,
-0.3482816517353058,
-1.0135456323623657,
0.30130329728126526,
-0.08734731376171112,
0.3298375904560089,
0.6230612397193909,
0.6998311281204224,
-0.3583016097545624,
1.38697350025177,
0.5176597833633423,
0.020197609439492226,
0.2862919569015503,
-0.07440100610256195,
-0.07414879649877548,
-1.1617882251739502,
0.013749120756983757,
-0.55398029088974,
-0.4517965316772461,
-0.5979760885238647,
-0.5190346837043762,
0.24378591775894165,
0.4633912444114685,
-0.029542695730924606,
0.19873200356960297,
-0.326511412858963,
0.28349214792251587,
0.6064328551292419,
0.11686190962791443,
0.3987639844417572,
-0.14061588048934937,
-0.1799907684326172,
-0.23150064051151276,
-0.6428127288818359,
-0.8197473287582397,
0.9479647874832153,
0.5231103301048279,
0.5382166504859924,
-0.018916813656687737,
0.5644986629486084,
0.036408551037311554,
0.5255409479141235,
-0.6078101396560669,
0.12909628450870514,
-0.24952659010887146,
-0.24603389203548431,
-0.15751570463180542,
-0.43284422159194946,
-0.6738592386245728,
0.36522728204727173,
-0.40481340885162354,
-0.5319036841392517,
-0.2751331329345703,
0.5455325245857239,
-0.6301486492156982,
0.2346416860818863,
-0.6428579688072205,
0.8478441834449768,
-0.31874924898147583,
-0.2093200981616974,
-0.2726896405220032,
-0.6160573959350586,
0.26016753911972046,
-0.3761671483516693,
0.5321498513221741,
-0.05588996410369873,
-0.1666545569896698,
0.5317764282226562,
-0.4431524872779846,
0.8403440117835999,
-0.153605654835701,
-0.355909526348114,
0.1215633675456047,
0.3255060911178589,
0.8263232111930847,
0.0003726645663846284,
-0.157342329621315,
0.030624400824308395,
-0.05676938593387604,
-0.1603972166776657,
-0.5310415625572205,
0.4817722737789154,
-0.7084115147590637,
-0.6974542140960693,
0.1971619874238968,
-0.5332305431365967,
-0.1510995328426361,
0.1553238332271576,
0.27074581384658813,
0.08394721895456314,
0.5222631692886353,
0.2913280725479126,
0.3429493308067322,
-0.410964697599411,
0.26731404662132263,
0.4890916049480438,
-0.5340513586997986,
-0.5142036080360413,
0.66335529088974,
0.24681971967220306,
0.34419628977775574,
0.34938696026802063,
0.38649415969848633,
-0.2256689965724945,
-0.8447540998458862,
-0.9289209842681885,
0.22080768644809723,
-0.6205257177352905,
-0.4244549572467804,
-0.6336216330528259,
0.09044834971427917,
-0.06670995056629181,
-0.16757716238498688,
-0.4123801589012146,
-0.2918596863746643,
-0.3500611484050751,
-0.2394973337650299,
0.4604102671146393,
0.8371934294700623,
-0.1965496689081192,
0.7867575287818909,
-1.2548165321350098,
0.04238196834921837,
-0.08336959779262543,
0.33522269129753113,
-0.16723378002643585,
-0.9762995839118958,
-0.5824817419052124,
0.20053935050964355,
-0.32445499300956726,
-0.6275412440299988,
0.31839054822921753,
0.046443209052085876,
0.1534527689218521,
0.07891026139259338,
-0.1919448971748352,
0.6739475727081299,
-0.5492327213287354,
0.983569860458374,
-0.04958883672952652,
-0.9038944244384766,
0.7707046866416931,
-0.41615691781044006,
0.5017945766448975,
0.3201444745063782,
0.11286512762308121,
-0.660739004611969,
-0.7677603960037231,
-0.15111230313777924,
-0.6317066550254822,
0.5912514328956604,
-0.11569719761610031,
0.11223463714122772,
0.08169956505298615,
0.4962189793586731,
0.205765962600708,
0.31191566586494446,
-0.7581006288528442,
0.02074066922068596,
-0.0040484461933374405,
-0.18095381557941437,
-0.20676559209823608,
-0.2652626931667328,
-0.034787680953741074,
-0.049834057688713074,
0.8177983164787292,
-0.24374587833881378,
-0.36259227991104126,
0.21530765295028687,
-0.23826368153095245,
-0.5745737552642822,
0.26021167635917664,
0.6700855493545532,
0.5919641256332397,
-0.01824560947716236,
0.2200876921415329,
0.5382744073867798,
0.05069512501358986,
0.09009663015604019,
-0.06938888877630234,
-0.32817840576171875,
0.02206188626587391,
0.45396092534065247,
0.7069457769393921,
0.05200764909386635,
-0.27679771184921265,
0.12218950688838959,
0.041362226009368896,
-0.12175072729587555,
0.19397300481796265,
-0.028656743466854095,
-0.037979405373334885,
0.34840086102485657,
0.20804253220558167,
0.1789340227842331,
-0.12118912488222122,
-0.15747931599617004,
0.13992208242416382,
0.26876991987228394,
-0.52694171667099,
-0.4099994897842407,
0.8065363764762878,
0.151804119348526,
-0.41889721155166626,
0.2418820559978485,
-0.2188015729188919,
-0.5861343145370483,
0.013268575072288513,
0.20964694023132324,
0.5047553777694702,
-0.38618600368499756,
0.0904080718755722,
0.3897278904914856,
0.733803391456604,
-0.4019635319709778,
0.0760718360543251,
0.2567267417907715,
-0.37660619616508484,
-1.1177197694778442,
-0.624544084072113,
-0.48763173818588257,
0.012888272292912006,
-0.36788955330848694,
0.4800841212272644,
-0.41229569911956787,
-0.28734090924263,
-0.11587341874837875,
-0.15683332085609436,
-0.6091688871383667,
0.3383021652698517,
0.11828653514385223,
0.6007448434829712,
-0.5651946663856506,
0.9281544089317322,
0.5972743034362793,
-0.4763883054256439,
-0.8471877574920654,
-0.17264661192893982,
0.1402169167995453,
-0.658574640750885,
0.7046216726303101,
0.2096196711063385,
-0.11274019628763199,
-0.018637385219335556,
-0.3868929445743561,
-0.7939662933349609,
0.6307375431060791,
0.3215904235839844,
-0.8174652457237244,
0.20468471944332123,
0.20196673274040222,
0.6583724617958069,
-0.15161575376987457,
0.2246563583612442,
0.5627807974815369,
0.7164903879165649,
-0.20705191791057587,
-1.134871006011963,
-0.06739303469657898,
0.053733401000499725,
-0.026604093611240387,
0.2877961993217468,
-0.5705171823501587,
0.5000186562538147,
-0.2601076364517212,
0.1481751799583435,
0.07723971456289291,
0.6450666189193726,
-0.10979127883911133,
0.00435259286314249,
0.5367925763130188,
0.4970758557319641,
0.6966701149940491,
-0.25218266248703003,
1.0782638788223267,
-0.08829666674137115,
0.06982080638408661,
1.2937445640563965,
0.06149895489215851,
1.2224773168563843,
0.565902829170227,
-0.09466269612312317,
0.25631487369537354,
0.8940718770027161,
-0.04382743313908577,
0.18477553129196167,
0.23202961683273315,
0.2907971739768982,
-0.16768795251846313,
-0.3006436228752136,
-0.29438695311546326,
0.3218655288219452,
0.4394405484199524,
-0.5477858185768127,
0.06203319877386093,
0.008467663079500198,
0.16763919591903687,
0.06832944601774216,
-0.4861450791358948,
0.8291006684303284,
0.15847979485988617,
-0.9216095209121704,
0.5386828184127808,
0.2374696135520935,
0.6837752461433411,
-0.29120463132858276,
-0.026583652943372726,
-0.23460887372493744,
0.09870981425046921,
-0.5083730816841125,
-0.8845142722129822,
0.5628568530082703,
0.12803493440151215,
-0.27205654978752136,
-0.24450431764125824,
0.08617321401834488,
-0.6448422074317932,
-0.5418694615364075,
0.454372763633728,
0.4055507779121399,
0.06240493431687355,
-0.25296398997306824,
-0.4720606803894043,
0.30586889386177063,
0.04811534658074379,
-0.18863153457641602,
0.058305032551288605,
0.6763249039649963,
-0.10384730994701385,
0.5023389458656311,
0.8042605519294739,
0.3645661175251007,
-0.031523965299129486,
0.19956806302070618,
0.5254141092300415,
-0.5288833975791931,
-0.2076355665922165,
-1.0751984119415283,
0.7238402962684631,
0.21872638165950775,
-0.2989707589149475,
0.8392143249511719,
0.2516322433948517,
1.0381062030792236,
-0.021565260365605354,
0.6383505463600159,
0.44577792286872864,
0.598737895488739,
-0.7063551545143127,
0.4255058467388153,
-0.644441545009613,
0.27521175146102905,
-0.18782676756381989,
-1.1344705820083618,
-0.774024248123169,
0.39932072162628174,
-0.33403488993644714,
-0.22105488181114197,
0.5165997743606567,
0.8025074601173401,
0.18645061552524567,
-0.32212212681770325,
0.254443496465683,
0.3555682599544525,
0.4657759666442871,
0.3716784119606018,
0.8905375003814697,
-0.37464699149131775,
0.6364685893058777,
-0.041508905589580536,
-0.11317423731088638,
-0.4560130834579468,
-0.7853475213050842,
-0.7275906801223755,
-0.2728835940361023,
-0.5104635953903198,
-0.5252189040184021,
-0.06619114428758621,
1.2744706869125366,
0.6452401876449585,
-0.906182050704956,
-0.06228850781917572,
0.27271419763565063,
0.16625572741031647,
-0.17375434935092926,
-0.1022883728146553,
0.30918848514556885,
-0.7064942717552185,
-0.699786901473999,
0.2912812829017639,
0.46375608444213867,
0.15651863813400269,
-0.14070206880569458,
-0.2732491195201874,
0.1904478669166565,
-0.13136667013168335,
0.7052468061447144,
-0.3278202414512634,
-1.0206021070480347,
-0.46213197708129883,
-0.2691887617111206,
-0.26989108324050903,
0.18981234729290009,
0.5210745334625244,
-0.1818850040435791,
0.5141342878341675,
0.2530815303325653,
0.7586848735809326,
0.055317364633083344,
-0.0715852752327919,
0.8369773626327515,
-0.6518468260765076,
0.025022903457283974,
-0.07963795214891434,
0.4899027943611145,
0.7178446054458618,
-0.2697609066963196,
0.48353755474090576,
-0.04749377444386482,
-0.6897763013839722,
-0.6856880784034729,
-0.10239671170711517,
-0.4811685383319855,
0.018784601241350174,
1.2702393531799316,
-0.2375730723142624,
-0.08909814059734344,
0.10896296054124832,
-0.733027458190918,
0.34427398443222046,
-0.24809859693050385,
0.8409834504127502,
0.9834870100021362,
0.2294653058052063,
-0.3985922038555145,
-0.8299298882484436,
0.637057900428772,
0.5956342220306396,
-0.84156334400177,
0.12052761763334274,
0.49023202061653137,
-0.18652550876140594,
0.11096788197755814,
0.17292745411396027,
-0.049895722419023514,
0.31303468346595764,
-0.4095032811164856,
-0.04744339361786842,
-0.013522052206099033,
-0.36978214979171753,
-0.5550392270088196,
-0.2582515478134155,
0.5601885914802551,
-0.05483770743012428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07840v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07840v2
|
On Training Data Influence of GPT Models
| 2024-04-11T15:27:56 | 2024-04-16T10:05:27 |
Qingyi Liu, Yekun Chai, Shuohuan Wang, Yu Sun, Qiwei Peng, Keze Wang, Hua Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Amidst the rapid advancements in generative language models, the
investigation of how training data shapes the performance of GPT models is
still emerging. This paper presents GPTfluence, a novel approach that leverages
a featurized simulation to assess the impact of training examples on the
training dynamics of GPT models. Our approach not only traces the influence of
individual training instances on performance trajectories, such as loss and
other key metrics, on targeted test points but also enables a comprehensive
comparison with existing methods across various training scenarios in GPT
models, ranging from 14 million to 2.8 billion parameters, across a range of
downstream tasks. Contrary to earlier methods that struggle with generalization
to new data, GPTfluence introduces a parameterized simulation of training
dynamics, demonstrating robust generalization capabilities to unseen training
data. This adaptability is evident across both fine-tuning and
instruction-tuning scenarios, spanning tasks in natural language understanding
and generation. We will make our code and data publicly available.
|
[
-0.19982938468456268,
-1.0081771612167358,
0.43053051829338074,
0.044126104563474655,
0.07515665143728256,
-0.040555212646722794,
-0.16924048960208893,
-0.2837600111961365,
-0.41648170351982117,
0.2192978858947754,
-0.3789033889770508,
-0.18797487020492554,
-0.5892719626426697,
-0.2800816595554352,
-0.4801748991012573,
1.4080379009246826,
-0.13838760554790497,
0.033192191272974014,
-0.25593671202659607,
-0.10710738599300385,
-0.3672163486480713,
-0.7874535322189331,
-0.5094476342201233,
-0.40042775869369507,
0.18795038759708405,
-0.2148134559392929,
0.6561985611915588,
0.39461299777030945,
0.16967730224132538,
0.279436320066452,
0.08097067475318909,
-0.43980270624160767,
-0.8159520030021667,
-0.05447489023208618,
-0.09110614657402039,
-0.6838453412055969,
0.02743537724018097,
0.2839929163455963,
1.064602017402649,
0.5321817398071289,
-0.3322802484035492,
-0.07964160293340683,
0.41725802421569824,
0.3075849413871765,
-0.3579007685184479,
0.4964374303817749,
-0.5779638290405273,
0.01314796507358551,
-0.015247387811541557,
-0.11270153522491455,
-0.18986423313617706,
-0.3220136761665344,
0.4314195513725281,
-0.5107632279396057,
0.9584418535232544,
-0.23760603368282318,
0.6795428395271301,
0.21497352421283722,
-0.1908939629793167,
-0.16989269852638245,
-0.9427666664123535,
0.5743432641029358,
-0.47810617089271545,
0.7522258758544922,
0.16427719593048096,
0.3020405173301697,
-0.33344051241874695,
-0.8903475403785706,
-0.3686662018299103,
-0.493471622467041,
-0.02545839175581932,
0.08165350556373596,
0.06083161383867264,
0.32454413175582886,
0.45165106654167175,
0.5225368142127991,
-0.5388392210006714,
-0.2307165414094925,
-0.3419032096862793,
0.032796915620565414,
0.4163613021373749,
0.15594780445098877,
0.3604724705219269,
0.3456927239894867,
-0.055535756051540375,
-0.37226471304893494,
-0.5046080946922302,
0.20191586017608643,
0.4592253267765045,
0.39530470967292786,
-0.2838185727596283,
0.22240786254405975,
-0.2341061234474182,
0.5494382381439209,
-0.10786531865596771,
0.04808156564831734,
-0.06217973306775093,
-0.33418089151382446,
-0.503284752368927,
-0.12241566181182861,
0.7307626008987427,
-0.01687636598944664,
0.16302600502967834,
-0.7013686299324036,
0.05756162479519844,
-0.0823817327618599,
0.48065903782844543,
-1.0770364999771118,
-0.735621452331543,
-0.3343161344528198,
-0.0557558611035347,
-0.3515404462814331,
0.03384566307067871,
-0.6973050236701965,
-0.3090910017490387,
-0.3468720614910126,
0.4103289842605591,
-0.6105966567993164,
-0.3214379847049713,
0.10854266583919525,
-0.009256348013877869,
0.2544880211353302,
0.32250383496284485,
-1.25719153881073,
0.20635998249053955,
0.9006629586219788,
0.9332447052001953,
0.04680512845516205,
-0.5329219102859497,
-0.5693502426147461,
0.11862093210220337,
-0.1016680970788002,
0.5235323905944824,
-0.7584002614021301,
-0.46975910663604736,
-0.15227384865283966,
0.04118278995156288,
-0.5759487152099609,
-0.24763648211956024,
0.43077126145362854,
-0.45022720098495483,
0.1865137815475464,
-0.25289490818977356,
-0.8109164237976074,
-0.30904266238212585,
0.08736233413219452,
-0.7610579133033752,
1.0407541990280151,
0.25419509410858154,
-0.6617801189422607,
0.8377847075462341,
-0.800197958946228,
-0.36797958612442017,
0.15516561269760132,
-0.4802549481391907,
-0.5355133414268494,
0.5156525373458862,
0.0782160833477974,
0.4163343906402588,
-0.11940117180347443,
0.3608931303024292,
-0.35940778255462646,
-0.32995399832725525,
-0.11872206628322601,
-0.6065095663070679,
0.47854745388031006,
-0.16969899833202362,
-0.4371545910835266,
-0.03437734395265579,
-0.7527601718902588,
0.07717794924974442,
0.038331154733896255,
-0.3973388671875,
-0.28446149826049805,
0.11068624258041382,
0.010098626837134361,
0.03007962927222252,
-0.413451611995697,
-0.312000572681427,
0.4756079316139221,
-0.28521955013275146,
0.3640764653682709,
0.540052056312561,
0.2930230498313904,
0.24413776397705078,
-0.03460763767361641,
0.8494257926940918,
-0.29610201716423035,
0.13473212718963623,
0.16418863832950592,
-0.7051689624786377,
-0.22524599730968475,
-0.07672908902168274,
0.4620762765407562,
0.190606951713562,
-0.6453056931495667,
-0.33763065934181213,
-0.33640578389167786,
-0.28289756178855896,
-0.4569498598575592,
0.1924741119146347,
0.1603003740310669,
0.49471616744995117,
0.26760759949684143,
-0.10441861301660538,
-0.33821478486061096,
-0.6232031583786011,
-0.3024129569530487,
-0.3286219835281372,
-0.10821250826120377,
-0.009570512920618057,
0.5172077417373657,
0.023660078644752502,
0.8955082893371582,
-0.2348824143409729,
0.15912695229053497,
-0.29922059178352356,
0.5030868649482727,
-0.07817785441875458,
0.6740691065788269,
0.9307700991630554,
-0.5692643523216248,
-0.20048601925373077,
-0.07048477977514267,
-0.59749835729599,
0.2130625993013382,
-0.355320543050766,
-0.08253179490566254,
-0.07433542609214783,
0.1665060818195343,
-0.3286850154399872,
0.39565038681030273,
0.7956383228302002,
-0.37152737379074097,
0.6780723333358765,
-0.26875412464141846,
0.3511944115161896,
-0.6828393936157227,
0.07825253903865814,
0.012737062759697437,
0.11130007356405258,
-0.8094615340232849,
0.17589014768600464,
-0.049864403903484344,
-0.09149760007858276,
-0.21444600820541382,
0.16120360791683197,
-0.2544091045856476,
0.00583954993635416,
0.06270773708820343,
-0.5051879286766052,
-0.06602241843938828,
0.2914012372493744,
0.015770919620990753,
1.3626601696014404,
0.5789216160774231,
-0.4109034538269043,
0.13217109441757202,
0.24004434049129486,
-0.5302284955978394,
0.23089401423931122,
-0.682900071144104,
0.23464004695415497,
-0.0017030970193445683,
-0.0065869432874023914,
-0.9056646227836609,
-0.28491172194480896,
-0.0036192787811160088,
-0.22228045761585236,
0.3453044891357422,
-0.7308260798454285,
-0.6775806546211243,
-0.12470956891775131,
-0.05016925930976868,
0.35445982217788696,
0.4000466763973236,
-0.5448938608169556,
0.5584000945091248,
0.04134400188922882,
-0.022559259086847305,
-0.1733545958995819,
-0.5356508493423462,
0.06597860902547836,
-0.4491351246833801,
-0.4442274868488312,
0.037386611104011536,
-0.025413358584046364,
0.15361288189888,
-0.28068381547927856,
0.018356088548898697,
-0.10882260650396347,
0.518761932849884,
0.3012525737285614,
0.12925361096858978,
-0.2889818847179413,
0.2352038025856018,
0.04016894847154617,
0.23358041048049927,
0.33369141817092896,
-0.4441821873188019,
0.5339901447296143,
-0.4124000370502472,
-0.3819310963153839,
-0.3540818393230438,
-0.0005329818814061582,
0.38782843947410583,
-0.047282665967941284,
1.0608981847763062,
0.7576676607131958,
-0.14241467416286469,
-0.3410058319568634,
-0.337246298789978,
-0.1109587773680687,
-0.5045281052589417,
0.6565700173377991,
-0.28427425026893616,
-0.776105523109436,
0.5105681419372559,
0.1040857806801796,
-0.048993341624736786,
0.1822204887866974,
0.5829133987426758,
0.11060047894716263,
1.1221327781677246,
0.7624605894088745,
-0.35856157541275024,
0.721735954284668,
-0.4719240367412567,
-0.02258765883743763,
-0.5309216976165771,
-0.12443526834249496,
-0.22543442249298096,
-0.17417950928211212,
-0.6194422841072083,
-0.4254825711250305,
0.20043650269508362,
0.44266995787620544,
-0.04511263221502304,
0.11378535628318787,
-0.3078189492225647,
0.48211026191711426,
0.3226947486400604,
-0.05900406837463379,
0.23342235386371613,
0.0818827673792839,
-0.13591404259204865,
-0.0966678038239479,
-0.7522292137145996,
-0.348351389169693,
1.2564690113067627,
0.30642279982566833,
0.7241852283477783,
-0.021223388612270355,
0.41692203283309937,
0.07782897353172302,
0.7822475433349609,
-0.6663225889205933,
0.26939156651496887,
0.05134185403585434,
-0.4482305943965912,
-0.253047376871109,
-0.6394416689872742,
-0.805312991142273,
0.0939580425620079,
-0.08584949374198914,
-0.798704981803894,
-0.24135060608386993,
0.26724162697792053,
-0.1610477864742279,
0.4921339154243469,
-0.787876307964325,
0.9689885973930359,
-0.32831525802612305,
-0.425214946269989,
-0.050539691001176834,
-0.19536131620407104,
0.34528848528862,
-0.05273328721523285,
-0.21666975319385529,
-0.038637708872556686,
0.1928723007440567,
0.7706268429756165,
-0.3566617965698242,
0.7984379529953003,
-0.4432820677757263,
-0.244188591837883,
0.20520909130573273,
-0.06810619682073593,
0.6867712140083313,
0.20807187259197235,
-0.08136651664972305,
0.11049021035432816,
-0.012828327715396881,
-0.33213716745376587,
-0.9931385517120361,
0.5594174265861511,
-0.5748136043548584,
-0.44104596972465515,
0.09641388058662415,
-0.7751268148422241,
-0.7268341183662415,
0.002618070924654603,
0.23785080015659332,
0.5302023887634277,
-0.4553256630897522,
0.09042234718799591,
0.5087943077087402,
-0.002359948353841901,
0.2557108402252197,
0.22400236129760742,
-0.13226035237312317,
-0.2659681737422943,
1.0090417861938477,
0.16688574850559235,
0.4073961079120636,
0.09234709292650223,
0.3250737190246582,
-0.42798665165901184,
-0.9718902111053467,
-0.6286357045173645,
0.11175033450126648,
-0.5187780261039734,
0.172105610370636,
-0.5266352295875549,
0.015072386711835861,
-0.32912272214889526,
-0.02511550858616829,
-0.2204315960407257,
-0.21817274391651154,
-0.11333522200584412,
-0.39784273505210876,
0.6318714618682861,
0.9124847054481506,
0.24785394966602325,
0.46548014879226685,
-0.5934404730796814,
-0.10102594643831253,
0.5316474437713623,
0.8570771217346191,
-0.00995910819619894,
-0.3798985779285431,
-0.42226001620292664,
0.16444525122642517,
-0.302278995513916,
-0.5703344941139221,
0.1330193132162094,
0.5679391622543335,
0.8979749083518982,
0.3595512807369232,
-0.29181191325187683,
0.7251996994018555,
-0.3378957211971283,
0.7791357636451721,
0.033987414091825485,
-0.7754024863243103,
0.6183928847312927,
-0.5876255035400391,
0.1439928561449051,
0.852945864200592,
0.3296215236186981,
-0.2584432065486908,
-0.5794634819030762,
-0.7305115461349487,
-0.44659391045570374,
0.6085450053215027,
0.3815234303474426,
0.18773527443408966,
0.21080449223518372,
0.5417037010192871,
0.10163242369890213,
0.11859399080276489,
-0.33976101875305176,
0.01880665495991707,
-0.37445831298828125,
-0.17668509483337402,
-0.1969648003578186,
0.06826302409172058,
0.0446668341755867,
-0.49660763144493103,
0.43532007932662964,
-0.1997230350971222,
0.3831081986427307,
-0.18627376854419708,
-0.16893820464611053,
0.20155666768550873,
0.0587124340236187,
0.6611969470977783,
0.4591071307659149,
-0.09277505427598953,
-0.15795858204364777,
0.3922663629055023,
-0.9621197581291199,
0.21130047738552094,
0.25465402007102966,
-0.1522321105003357,
-0.01998802460730076,
0.4559342861175537,
1.0716187953948975,
0.5111761093139648,
-0.366364061832428,
0.21628707647323608,
-0.22739683091640472,
-0.5474463701248169,
0.23828235268592834,
0.5267307162284851,
-0.046229757368564606,
0.3363882005214691,
0.2543122172355652,
-0.22091682255268097,
0.13004617393016815,
-0.4916868209838867,
0.4819239675998688,
0.3160003423690796,
-0.6010581254959106,
-0.7597670555114746,
0.9787021279335022,
-0.11868233978748322,
0.023257074877619743,
0.7192050218582153,
-0.13362672924995422,
-0.5362542271614075,
0.5690467357635498,
0.4173319339752197,
0.9113678932189941,
-0.4488184452056885,
0.2364944964647293,
0.24701958894729614,
0.15577952563762665,
-0.328328400850296,
-0.0578736811876297,
-0.14229325950145721,
-0.4729570150375366,
-0.6112251281738281,
-0.6631120443344116,
-0.28747299313545227,
0.4341825842857361,
-0.8046095967292786,
-0.09171883761882782,
-0.5068290829658508,
-0.13321729004383087,
-0.09844645857810974,
-0.05555152893066406,
-0.8675488829612732,
0.1473524272441864,
0.08634647727012634,
0.6450918912887573,
-0.9536377787590027,
1.1634502410888672,
0.8458089828491211,
-0.31229981780052185,
-0.9081842303276062,
0.4307759702205658,
-0.09490568190813065,
-0.8509525656700134,
0.5527488589286804,
0.1939166784286499,
-0.09614794701337814,
0.20656371116638184,
-0.4066111743450165,
-0.6525065898895264,
1.0540180206298828,
0.7380339503288269,
-0.18438850343227386,
-0.18352779746055603,
0.5363965630531311,
0.7962872982025146,
-0.02778828702867031,
0.1365266740322113,
0.9477115273475647,
0.22092285752296448,
0.055228378623723984,
-0.8609343767166138,
-0.12384817004203796,
-0.10050275176763535,
0.20174580812454224,
0.2883077561855316,
-0.3878931403160095,
0.5562085509300232,
-0.15420566499233246,
-0.5416033864021301,
-0.14626751840114594,
0.5432233214378357,
0.08764539659023285,
-0.027619820088148117,
0.25584498047828674,
0.5328249335289001,
0.6752808690071106,
-0.15766818821430206,
1.3117982149124146,
-0.26486852765083313,
0.8116757869720459,
1.1832777261734009,
0.08151821047067642,
0.48093488812446594,
0.27801787853240967,
-0.6326990127563477,
0.12397489696741104,
0.36036378145217896,
-0.2589205503463745,
0.717526912689209,
0.3536032438278198,
-0.36606523394584656,
-0.07131327688694,
0.1627829521894455,
-0.5975666046142578,
0.4645836353302002,
0.17153501510620117,
-0.3437204957008362,
-0.44767916202545166,
0.2513814866542816,
-0.09296070039272308,
-0.28534382581710815,
-0.19552306830883026,
0.5788081288337708,
-0.3491097092628479,
-0.2538246512413025,
0.7366352677345276,
-0.3220687210559845,
0.4553845524787903,
-0.6701866388320923,
-0.13451410830020905,
-0.1385738104581833,
0.1527750939130783,
0.05372455716133118,
-0.600447952747345,
0.3116747736930847,
-0.09517782926559448,
0.006830431055277586,
-0.2101326584815979,
0.4137275218963623,
-0.4175072908401489,
-0.5721210241317749,
0.22755256295204163,
0.3202046751976013,
-0.10266689211130142,
-0.23374007642269135,
-0.6945590972900391,
-0.05606560781598091,
-0.07649480551481247,
-0.483061283826828,
0.7173472046852112,
0.4645560085773468,
0.14770646393299103,
0.5830883979797363,
0.44993290305137634,
-0.0071706525050103664,
0.25714948773384094,
0.202589213848114,
0.8445800542831421,
-0.4685302674770355,
-0.5332973599433899,
-0.7588449716567993,
0.25035759806632996,
0.09268642961978912,
-0.46816766262054443,
0.6702253818511963,
0.6510944366455078,
0.8622152805328369,
-0.11354676634073257,
0.9310792088508606,
0.058204855769872665,
0.11456074565649033,
-0.6129387617111206,
0.9859896898269653,
-0.2884257435798645,
0.12652890384197235,
-0.34499576687812805,
-0.6210626363754272,
-0.07437139749526978,
0.47643861174583435,
-0.676634669303894,
0.19631138443946838,
0.30740612745285034,
0.6830347180366516,
-0.18042847514152527,
0.5666504502296448,
0.4223785102367401,
0.05558909848332405,
0.5113244652748108,
0.3957902491092682,
0.8950766324996948,
-0.44990670680999756,
0.5034295320510864,
-0.3036414384841919,
0.004319422412663698,
-0.04412488266825676,
-0.7904916405677795,
-0.8670477271080017,
-0.6654857397079468,
-0.34466639161109924,
-0.021412311121821404,
0.24049095809459686,
0.44282084703445435,
0.6949052214622498,
-0.9631525278091431,
0.044803839176893234,
-0.6237388253211975,
-0.25618118047714233,
-0.364737331867218,
-0.3031102418899536,
0.3270775079727173,
-0.5255880355834961,
-0.5893674492835999,
0.4300050437450409,
-0.15773028135299683,
0.4862174391746521,
-0.11050659418106079,
-0.08367897570133209,
0.10378342866897583,
-0.33284980058670044,
0.4846101999282837,
0.2516751289367676,
-0.3927227556705475,
-0.5775688886642456,
-0.3945917785167694,
0.21736834943294525,
0.050921276211738586,
1.2346667051315308,
-0.8821022510528564,
0.4302138090133667,
0.24218572676181793,
0.8186516165733337,
0.6333390474319458,
0.16707205772399902,
0.8393421769142151,
-0.904355525970459,
0.14665669202804565,
0.04578707739710808,
0.10881555080413818,
0.055007196962833405,
-0.45173120498657227,
0.7236653566360474,
0.4763205051422119,
-0.5068153738975525,
-0.8336221575737,
-0.07286087423563004,
-0.5545241832733154,
0.09191872924566269,
0.9146643877029419,
-0.28119003772735596,
0.25437963008880615,
-0.2656683325767517,
0.2088427096605301,
0.2058982104063034,
-0.25905415415763855,
0.988334596157074,
0.7917594909667969,
-0.3458583950996399,
-0.327972412109375,
-1.2782938480377197,
0.8257041573524475,
0.2571888864040375,
-0.817276120185852,
0.4074094295501709,
0.44392916560173035,
0.5834851264953613,
-0.34578683972358704,
0.2872748076915741,
0.16249026358127594,
0.08027734607458115,
0.21708136796951294,
-0.25657474994659424,
-0.30381837487220764,
-0.12858690321445465,
-0.5355881452560425,
0.2343260943889618,
-0.08057781308889389,
-0.08483024686574936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07839v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07839v1
|
RecurrentGemma: Moving Past Transformers for Efficient Open Language Models
| 2024-04-11T15:27:22 | 2024-04-11T15:27:22 |
Aleksandar Botev, Soham De, Samuel L Smith, Anushan Fernando, George-Cristian Muraru, Ruba Haroun, Leonard Berrada, Razvan Pascanu, Pier Giuseppe Sessa, Robert Dadashi, Léonard Hussenot, Johan Ferret, Sertan Girgin, Olivier Bachem, Alek Andreev, Kathleen Kenealy, Thomas Mesnard, Cassidy Hardin, Surya Bhupatiraju, Shreya Pathak, Laurent Sifre, Morgane Rivière, Mihir Sanjay Kale, Juliette Love, Pouya Tafti, Armand Joulin, Noah Fiedel, Evan Senter, Yutian Chen, Srivatsan Srinivasan, Guillaume Desjardins, David Budden, Arnaud Doucet, Sharad Vikram, Adam Paszke, Trevor Gale, Sebastian Borgeaud, Charlie Chen, Andy Brock, Antonia Paterson, Jenny Brennan, Meg Risdal, Raj Gundluru, Nesh Devanathan, Paul Mooney, Nilay Chauhan, Phil Culliton, Luiz GUStavo Martins, Elisa Bandy, David Huntsperger, Glenn Cameron, Arthur Zucker, Tris Warkentin, Ludovic Peran, Minh Giang, Zoubin Ghahramani, Clément Farabet, Koray Kavukcuoglu, Demis Hassabis, Raia Hadsell, Yee Whye Teh, Nando de Frietas
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We introduce RecurrentGemma, an open language model which uses Google's novel
Griffin architecture. Griffin combines linear recurrences with local attention
to achieve excellent performance on language. It has a fixed-sized state, which
reduces memory use and enables efficient inference on long sequences. We
provide a pre-trained model with 2B non-embedding parameters, and an
instruction tuned variant. Both models achieve comparable performance to
Gemma-2B despite being trained on fewer tokens.
|
[
-0.39124852418899536,
-0.9694867134094238,
0.258586585521698,
0.01682388037443161,
-0.06350239366292953,
-0.02473876066505909,
-0.20852375030517578,
-0.41575682163238525,
0.03758746385574341,
0.5475040078163147,
-0.4357767701148987,
-0.34498244524002075,
-0.6582947373390198,
-0.17246244847774506,
-0.5454394817352295,
0.7032831907272339,
-0.05527195706963539,
-0.0040053934790194035,
0.07126045972108841,
-0.3476024866104126,
-0.14219896495342255,
-0.6330809593200684,
-0.7183287739753723,
-0.5292348861694336,
0.4402047097682953,
0.31816527247428894,
0.8527149558067322,
0.6997997164726257,
0.21618831157684326,
0.2836966812610626,
-0.24578994512557983,
-0.008421851322054863,
-0.673407256603241,
0.02645523101091385,
-0.2569395899772644,
-0.5696796774864197,
-0.19397848844528198,
0.0996917188167572,
0.7977460622787476,
0.6355878114700317,
-0.23437529802322388,
0.2960332930088043,
0.061258308589458466,
0.6988524794578552,
-0.5647764801979065,
0.41440367698669434,
-0.5886678695678711,
0.34338507056236267,
-0.07286737114191055,
-0.121223583817482,
-0.5824882984161377,
-0.46990251541137695,
0.061648495495319366,
-0.5108463168144226,
0.32913291454315186,
0.06431309878826141,
0.7627350091934204,
0.34645819664001465,
-0.029459388926625252,
-0.21214348077774048,
-0.7184831500053406,
1.0481061935424805,
-0.33700689673423767,
0.6051438450813293,
0.14367803931236267,
0.20477381348609924,
-0.5205300450325012,
-1.414455771446228,
-0.41660794615745544,
-0.22223486006259918,
0.16605526208877563,
0.02092350646853447,
-0.7073798179626465,
-0.10301806032657623,
0.30629292130470276,
0.8190165162086487,
-0.45068779587745667,
-0.19306287169456482,
-0.3294384479522705,
-0.019476860761642456,
0.021130088716745377,
0.11280468851327896,
0.2757149338722229,
0.3577166795730591,
-0.3646550178527832,
0.313659131526947,
-0.7172185182571411,
0.3336527645587921,
0.14024923741817474,
0.45823320746421814,
0.13253270089626312,
0.6269260048866272,
-0.0129391485825181,
0.7290655970573425,
0.7356135249137878,
-0.023671142756938934,
0.15630929172039032,
0.1070265993475914,
-0.43236109614372253,
0.019838925451040268,
0.401399701833725,
-0.21566422283649445,
0.32696619629859924,
-0.6129123568534851,
0.15978966653347015,
0.027374165132641792,
0.6341463923454285,
-0.9021304845809937,
-0.2993212640285492,
0.08599575608968735,
-0.7388176918029785,
0.0007085496908985078,
0.021093185991048813,
-0.7460052371025085,
0.023496586829423904,
-0.2844715118408203,
0.3615400493144989,
-0.42012378573417664,
-0.20825253427028656,
0.4703654646873474,
0.17541204392910004,
0.35271012783050537,
0.07106322795152664,
-1.270064353942871,
0.5125570297241211,
1.003700852394104,
0.9478682279586792,
0.1408286988735199,
-0.2927173674106598,
-1.1816827058792114,
-0.04865244776010513,
-0.34518834948539734,
0.6111832857131958,
-0.9237841963768005,
-0.30973145365715027,
0.0900629386305809,
0.33366596698760986,
-0.1870581954717636,
-0.5852958559989929,
0.3571300804615021,
-0.47817328572273254,
0.38472211360931396,
0.09131492674350739,
-0.6763260960578918,
-0.6983417272567749,
-0.09011207520961761,
-0.734870970249176,
1.4202181100845337,
0.4227292835712433,
-0.6712732911109924,
0.35473763942718506,
-0.7888988256454468,
-0.3803921639919281,
0.00169469160027802,
0.14979325234889984,
-0.3977912664413452,
0.2560386061668396,
0.21919193863868713,
0.23659060895442963,
-0.1877233386039734,
0.0974559634923935,
-0.2738085687160492,
-0.4407653212547302,
-0.2309526652097702,
-0.028736691921949387,
0.5495171546936035,
0.4214683771133423,
-0.489427775144577,
0.3435952067375183,
-0.5916854739189148,
-0.07239703834056854,
0.023300310596823692,
-0.3374727964401245,
-0.0990198403596878,
0.13406740128993988,
-0.38990652561187744,
0.018766995519399643,
0.28929364681243896,
-0.6363910436630249,
0.42606326937675476,
-0.46781477332115173,
0.6726120114326477,
0.31519535183906555,
-0.3425978720188141,
0.7177622318267822,
-0.37506675720214844,
0.7443274259567261,
0.05312270298600197,
0.14341014623641968,
-0.33883437514305115,
-0.8401914238929749,
-0.7454522252082825,
-0.561631441116333,
0.25869765877723694,
0.49501657485961914,
-0.5767269730567932,
0.26454198360443115,
0.04631730169057846,
-0.43885618448257446,
-0.8107495307922363,
0.1414753794670105,
0.33766594529151917,
0.34858766198158264,
0.4771697521209717,
-0.4591844379901886,
-0.5196093916893005,
-0.757537841796875,
-0.22331050038337708,
-0.1832106113433838,
-0.16971802711486816,
0.23423467576503754,
0.13236147165298462,
-0.37328657507896423,
0.9498034715652466,
-0.4388449788093567,
-0.037428077310323715,
-0.6498221755027771,
0.480145126581192,
0.3340798020362854,
0.20136451721191406,
0.668379545211792,
-0.269672155380249,
-0.25255364179611206,
0.10403506457805634,
-0.4862121045589447,
-0.10578084737062454,
-0.05561395362019539,
-0.08320070803165436,
0.5685034394264221,
0.5130351781845093,
-0.882573664188385,
0.43536195158958435,
0.663670003414154,
-0.19812211394309998,
0.2546164393424988,
-0.09529884904623032,
0.023842690512537956,
-1.0973114967346191,
0.08062998950481415,
-0.005899887531995773,
-0.4994494915008545,
-0.6290330290794373,
0.5342698693275452,
-0.008088888600468636,
-0.2063770592212677,
-0.6004910469055176,
0.7268869280815125,
-0.6524147987365723,
-0.38921257853507996,
-0.39233800768852234,
0.16143223643302917,
-0.2755368947982788,
0.6505093574523926,
0.13256995379924774,
1.078809380531311,
0.7268689274787903,
-0.6827616095542908,
0.23613493144512177,
0.3261970579624176,
-0.670187771320343,
-0.22104333341121674,
-0.4705445170402527,
0.23725304007530212,
-0.16346193850040436,
-0.0033727227710187435,
-0.8375054597854614,
0.18900804221630096,
0.3962530195713043,
-0.4928365647792816,
0.5102720856666565,
-0.3120572865009308,
-0.43836814165115356,
-0.5436350703239441,
-0.11705364286899567,
0.29489007592201233,
0.6811841726303101,
-1.0194721221923828,
0.6555435061454773,
0.5029287934303284,
-0.38231539726257324,
-0.5556301474571228,
-0.444235235452652,
-0.0043861945159733295,
-0.1528177559375763,
-0.643921971321106,
0.25197067856788635,
0.3352928161621094,
-0.23800727725028992,
0.01948927529156208,
0.07416266202926636,
-0.1094852089881897,
-0.014158054254949093,
0.09125503152608871,
-0.11158923804759979,
-0.5428121089935303,
0.15489082038402557,
-0.24989397823810577,
-0.11326926201581955,
-0.16793954372406006,
-0.41432225704193115,
0.8734549283981323,
-0.4275229275226593,
-0.0853271484375,
-0.6420580744743347,
0.3955996632575989,
0.6500542163848877,
-0.31805241107940674,
0.7165267467498779,
0.6014143228530884,
-0.21245548129081726,
-0.21729622781276703,
-0.2315811812877655,
-0.09317470341920853,
-0.4818572700023651,
0.3064080476760864,
-0.35418593883514404,
-1.2938274145126343,
0.5166396498680115,
-0.016565268859267235,
0.2939210534095764,
0.1930815875530243,
0.9388250112533569,
0.26233649253845215,
0.8555446863174438,
0.5531213879585266,
-0.38775667548179626,
0.6506580710411072,
-0.04543380066752434,
0.5517957210540771,
-0.6524552702903748,
-0.14107191562652588,
-0.6378188133239746,
-0.10421072691679001,
-0.6582518219947815,
-0.6080434322357178,
-0.3661927580833435,
0.41134968400001526,
-0.6298760771751404,
0.6143172979354858,
-0.439222127199173,
0.1749933660030365,
0.9302594661712646,
-0.1875760406255722,
0.05836116150021553,
0.10421377420425415,
-0.28600218892097473,
0.06539788097143173,
-0.9641123414039612,
-0.6229791641235352,
0.9418243169784546,
0.694079577922821,
1.1435728073120117,
0.2378462702035904,
0.47293591499328613,
0.22914966940879822,
0.39451611042022705,
-1.0899248123168945,
0.544472336769104,
-0.28506162762641907,
-0.357006311416626,
-0.26833540201187134,
-0.2765273153781891,
-1.328738808631897,
0.16359685361385345,
0.0005055352230556309,
-0.9184193015098572,
-0.280913770198822,
0.24213111400604248,
-0.2825019955635071,
0.7087247371673584,
-0.5575315952301025,
0.5579766631126404,
0.24741509556770325,
-0.41200536489486694,
-0.15942779183387756,
-0.09068647772073746,
0.44329455494880676,
0.1832076460123062,
-0.33380210399627686,
0.19603075087070465,
0.245000958442688,
0.26083943247795105,
-0.414882093667984,
0.7360953688621521,
-0.052766989916563034,
-0.06070064380764961,
0.6242290139198303,
0.11367104947566986,
0.6579121947288513,
-0.17089691758155823,
0.12017118185758591,
0.40772029757499695,
-0.4162648320198059,
-0.4127184748649597,
-0.5446633100509644,
0.7096367478370667,
-0.5649386644363403,
-0.843152642250061,
-0.3521619439125061,
-0.38804957270622253,
-0.09624304622411728,
0.03027132898569107,
0.14788247644901276,
0.642035186290741,
-0.054975952953100204,
0.4002276360988617,
0.5664472579956055,
-0.4390929937362671,
0.5756644010543823,
0.415336936712265,
-0.5616956949234009,
-0.30943167209625244,
0.43101072311401367,
-0.06123263016343117,
0.13259826600551605,
0.49031129479408264,
0.09607696533203125,
-0.5933647155761719,
-0.5300738215446472,
-0.4680343568325043,
0.16131050884723663,
-0.3388763964176178,
0.1899496614933014,
-0.7762596607208252,
-0.3645116984844208,
-0.40192151069641113,
0.03108414076268673,
-0.5140009522438049,
-0.6013802886009216,
-0.3883952796459198,
-0.1321471631526947,
0.3359155058860779,
0.7193742990493774,
-0.008630380034446716,
0.19748207926750183,
-1.0852354764938354,
0.49786293506622314,
0.44460299611091614,
0.6228589415550232,
0.14184147119522095,
-0.7607742547988892,
-0.21532317996025085,
-0.09076683223247528,
-0.6042486429214478,
-0.38049694895744324,
0.47861310839653015,
0.09129648655653,
0.9433212876319885,
0.5828666687011719,
-0.15497134625911713,
0.7052249312400818,
-0.8154935836791992,
0.9834975600242615,
0.2496822327375412,
-1.0050053596496582,
0.1589447259902954,
-0.2910093069076538,
0.5824723243713379,
0.14933350682258606,
0.26453647017478943,
-0.3705444037914276,
-0.5675157904624939,
-0.4251532554626465,
-0.4572773873806,
0.6443563103675842,
0.15112704038619995,
0.10435045510530472,
-0.6321848630905151,
0.3786674439907074,
0.262577623128891,
0.05019409582018852,
-0.48169711232185364,
-0.2864156663417816,
-0.3969677984714508,
-0.04609989747405052,
-0.008122680708765984,
-0.4569031596183777,
0.16499127447605133,
-0.19747185707092285,
0.7252286076545715,
0.040340617299079895,
0.760601282119751,
0.01585378684103489,
-0.17340049147605896,
-0.28795406222343445,
0.1754881739616394,
1.0382634401321411,
0.5009339451789856,
-0.09459925442934036,
-0.24224470555782318,
-0.0934329628944397,
-0.5749557614326477,
-0.050042446702718735,
-0.07674124091863632,
-0.19062860310077667,
0.202909916639328,
0.25630009174346924,
0.8536787629127502,
0.5296999216079712,
-0.3376336395740509,
0.22846972942352295,
-0.005525853484869003,
-0.3399467468261719,
-0.47830817103385925,
0.055829767137765884,
0.1849362999200821,
0.5042709708213806,
0.2023322582244873,
-0.17709104716777802,
0.017356885597109795,
-0.7639904618263245,
0.5768224596977234,
0.3765232264995575,
-0.61744624376297,
-0.2555824816226959,
0.8542522192001343,
0.1938871294260025,
-0.6060945391654968,
0.5653408765792847,
-0.01103274431079626,
-0.37748631834983826,
0.41667383909225464,
0.6917977333068848,
1.2218486070632935,
-0.3746492862701416,
0.18945465981960297,
0.6348931789398193,
0.1711387038230896,
-0.3565368354320526,
0.4734041094779968,
-0.03313887491822243,
-0.6467912793159485,
-0.6203303933143616,
-0.6583486795425415,
-0.3402680456638336,
0.48427489399909973,
-1.0519263744354248,
0.1407676488161087,
-0.6516759991645813,
-0.3161259889602661,
-0.1830022931098938,
-0.0970344990491867,
-0.30637040734291077,
-0.20430012047290802,
0.02368803322315216,
1.3431984186172485,
-0.14087191224098206,
1.1263478994369507,
0.5209575891494751,
-0.07849729061126709,
-0.4602280855178833,
-0.057707782834768295,
-0.14652258157730103,
-0.8823768496513367,
0.7515020966529846,
0.44987568259239197,
-0.6339748501777649,
0.15072090923786163,
-0.46725958585739136,
-0.9147508144378662,
0.9235098958015442,
0.269871324300766,
-0.7875825762748718,
0.21172019839286804,
-0.22091510891914368,
0.4664808511734009,
-0.5720899105072021,
-0.2389664500951767,
0.6306380033493042,
0.23997308313846588,
0.1686224490404129,
-0.69167160987854,
-0.35429009795188904,
-0.15181273221969604,
-0.14392688870429993,
0.7254811525344849,
-0.7269265055656433,
1.0440685749053955,
-0.4390678405761719,
-0.6677306294441223,
0.7593569755554199,
0.7805606722831726,
0.0028190172743052244,
0.19211575388908386,
0.10768753290176392,
0.9688251614570618,
0.7657681703567505,
-0.2575005292892456,
1.2114894390106201,
-0.6546264290809631,
0.611294150352478,
1.4303975105285645,
-0.297638863325119,
0.9292638897895813,
0.28262484073638916,
-0.1784944236278534,
0.5924463868141174,
0.5456037521362305,
0.02770131081342697,
0.6508285403251648,
0.36659538745880127,
-0.4495542645454407,
-0.2965308725833893,
0.27581802010536194,
-0.37814995646476746,
0.5380585789680481,
0.19405736029148102,
-0.5676501989364624,
-0.38434356451034546,
-0.23836931586265564,
0.018853172659873962,
0.24206265807151794,
-0.6887349486351013,
0.7845544219017029,
-0.01849438063800335,
-0.8587724566459656,
0.6628022193908691,
0.1286267191171646,
0.40876317024230957,
-0.4703975021839142,
-0.09152908623218536,
-0.36755266785621643,
0.3229183256626129,
0.07237973809242249,
-0.6509995460510254,
0.4209100008010864,
0.013480874709784985,
-0.2993222177028656,
0.05050482600927353,
0.45990151166915894,
-0.5975773334503174,
-0.4617528021335602,
0.5338397026062012,
0.17874635756015778,
0.12271975725889206,
0.03781134635210037,
-0.6313091516494751,
-0.33605363965034485,
-0.2047727108001709,
-0.2517451345920563,
0.2469760626554489,
0.3164025545120239,
0.04968304559588432,
1.0700876712799072,
0.6107068657875061,
-0.09698054939508438,
0.36951300501823425,
0.16484889388084412,
0.6657929420471191,
-0.9332679510116577,
-0.5060303807258606,
-0.6351137757301331,
0.08790494501590729,
0.23577554523944855,
-0.05968707799911499,
0.6173906326293945,
0.5701354742050171,
0.7723981142044067,
-0.2494714856147766,
0.7428910136222839,
0.3107132613658905,
0.7312787771224976,
-0.6613621115684509,
0.4883267879486084,
-0.3571295738220215,
-0.10650485754013062,
0.006725052371621132,
-1.0588780641555786,
-0.3907712996006012,
0.7042329907417297,
-0.19423294067382812,
-0.09411068260669708,
0.6583767533302307,
0.8711727857589722,
0.048017360270023346,
0.16308552026748657,
0.5279384255409241,
0.19639408588409424,
0.0816674679517746,
0.6672899723052979,
0.8578335046768188,
-0.1765136569738388,
0.4665833115577698,
0.28137022256851196,
-0.20407700538635254,
-0.2342211753129959,
-0.8042643070220947,
-1.1715457439422607,
-0.3227870464324951,
-0.10085488110780716,
-0.1549830138683319,
-0.04581713676452637,
0.9230061173439026,
0.5742872953414917,
-0.8807674050331116,
0.007092717569321394,
-0.1726096123456955,
-0.14062319695949554,
-0.2871116101741791,
-0.25874751806259155,
0.1862255334854126,
-0.7892597317695618,
-1.0213984251022339,
0.4181387722492218,
0.6418806314468384,
-0.05138525366783142,
-0.252637654542923,
-0.1435164213180542,
-0.11555653810501099,
0.39550918340682983,
0.9037033915519714,
0.8118056058883667,
-1.0094376802444458,
-0.5902059078216553,
-0.14301523566246033,
-0.03622129186987877,
0.3309156596660614,
1.0636807680130005,
-0.7904864549636841,
0.47433993220329285,
0.3975572884082794,
0.8782299160957336,
0.6018632054328918,
0.3232121467590332,
0.705261766910553,
-0.21101172268390656,
0.3931918144226074,
-0.09485819190740585,
0.6337155103683472,
0.1274644136428833,
-0.1208275854587555,
0.4336928427219391,
0.009186138398945332,
-0.4455297589302063,
-0.34328916668891907,
0.47958898544311523,
-0.8495455384254456,
-0.37006235122680664,
1.1865450143814087,
-0.46049997210502625,
-0.1751360148191452,
-0.4692736566066742,
-0.027569159865379333,
0.12564142048358917,
-0.35792917013168335,
1.0593976974487305,
0.8730483651161194,
-0.08784571290016174,
-0.4575819671154022,
-0.417706161737442,
0.422151654958725,
0.18635301291942596,
-0.46741223335266113,
0.032200299203395844,
0.30508601665496826,
0.27004551887512207,
0.12293562293052673,
0.4253334701061249,
-0.4340525269508362,
0.44966813921928406,
0.12502822279930115,
0.08615349233150482,
-0.2962800860404968,
-0.7464752197265625,
-0.38598886132240295,
0.4436902105808258,
0.06046977639198303,
-0.652744710445404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07836v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07836v1
|
Question Generation in Knowledge-Driven Dialog: Explainability and Evaluation
| 2024-04-11T15:24:50 | 2024-04-11T15:24:50 |
Juliette Faille, Quentin Brabant, Gwenole Lecorve, Lina M. Rojas-Barahona, Claire Gardent
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We explore question generation in the context of knowledge-grounded dialogs
focusing on explainability and evaluation. Inspired by previous work on
planning-based summarisation, we present a model which instead of directly
generating a question, sequentially predicts first a fact then a question. We
evaluate our approach on 37k test dialogs adapted from the KGConv dataset and
we show that, although more demanding in terms of inference, our approach
performs on par with a standard model which solely generates a question while
allowing for a detailed referenceless evaluation of the model behaviour in
terms of relevance, factuality and pronominalisation.
|
[
-0.590039074420929,
-0.8625786900520325,
0.8084720373153687,
-0.08998783677816391,
-0.11974576115608215,
-0.35104355216026306,
0.2204328030347824,
-0.06642360985279083,
-0.10799809545278549,
0.5916839838027954,
-0.8509958982467651,
-0.15376055240631104,
-0.16404305398464203,
0.04644772782921791,
-0.4884982705116272,
0.9634456634521484,
0.09106279909610748,
-0.024014052003622055,
-0.8794751167297363,
-0.1795053482055664,
-0.5172752737998962,
-0.3854866027832031,
-0.5556714534759521,
-0.422331303358078,
0.29120978713035583,
0.5375591516494751,
0.732345461845398,
0.23242691159248352,
-0.14645831286907196,
0.25770139694213867,
-0.2151263803243637,
0.09653542935848236,
-0.46079403162002563,
0.33098864555358887,
0.06224820390343666,
-0.7372764945030212,
0.15931041538715363,
0.14221498370170593,
0.36122918128967285,
1.1871939897537231,
-0.06343623250722885,
0.2262340933084488,
-0.21040312945842743,
0.4740394949913025,
-0.49771976470947266,
0.10245215892791748,
-0.4926266074180603,
0.06071363389492035,
0.5742013454437256,
-0.3186251223087311,
-0.3259935975074768,
-0.7018613815307617,
0.5039482712745667,
-0.511084794998169,
0.3516293466091156,
0.10160109400749207,
0.514625608921051,
-0.046364255249500275,
-0.7039921283721924,
-0.766776978969574,
-0.7394081950187683,
0.3535449802875519,
-0.64745032787323,
0.4499945044517517,
0.17143458127975464,
0.5810505747795105,
-0.03265206143260002,
-0.9562545418739319,
-0.659707248210907,
-0.2743702530860901,
-0.141695037484169,
0.3897562026977539,
0.056715983897447586,
-0.061968669295310974,
0.49339327216148376,
0.41524097323417664,
-0.6137731075286865,
-0.4192531108856201,
-0.3565410077571869,
-0.12924252450466156,
0.4960368871688843,
0.3854862451553345,
0.11156121641397476,
-0.44621986150741577,
-0.11048509925603867,
0.17065700888633728,
-0.6246212124824524,
0.24216967821121216,
0.442950040102005,
-0.14045794308185577,
0.26462316513061523,
0.513337254524231,
-0.6091127395629883,
0.6543538570404053,
0.3958445191383362,
-0.16165947914123535,
-0.3003652095794678,
-0.6463930010795593,
-0.14520664513111115,
0.07931320369243622,
0.4689997434616089,
0.680064857006073,
0.30383557081222534,
-0.23410704731941223,
0.25831520557403564,
-0.15691512823104858,
0.1899324655532837,
-0.9817290902137756,
-0.21032875776290894,
0.501870334148407,
-0.2196391224861145,
-0.7186481952667236,
-0.016846179962158203,
-0.5200494527816772,
-0.2985416650772095,
-0.2538395822048187,
0.3300751745700836,
-0.21396654844284058,
-0.542177140712738,
0.07846471667289734,
-0.20593588054180145,
0.4186560809612274,
0.35916975140571594,
-0.6931490302085876,
0.05250609666109085,
0.38757848739624023,
0.047184355556964874,
0.2147483378648758,
-0.11696699261665344,
-0.11267553269863129,
0.13277941942214966,
-0.4670553207397461,
0.8016812801361084,
-0.2988361120223999,
-0.7832836508750916,
-0.03154483065009117,
-0.009547587484121323,
-0.09742000699043274,
-0.6962674856185913,
0.07924987375736237,
-0.5191032886505127,
0.7808178663253784,
-0.6564245820045471,
-0.5902076959609985,
-0.510256290435791,
0.5377967357635498,
-0.2482864111661911,
0.9072765707969666,
0.1940162181854248,
-0.7344772219657898,
0.6207406520843506,
-0.5363732576370239,
-0.2981623411178589,
0.09625184535980225,
-0.23927201330661774,
0.07379062473773956,
-0.018465319648385048,
0.15885798633098602,
0.4310344159603119,
-0.5064657926559448,
0.7595638036727905,
-0.0078984210267663,
0.09296976774930954,
0.3951297402381897,
-0.2811959981918335,
0.5372861623764038,
0.3068660497665405,
-0.036819566041231155,
0.013843669556081295,
-0.7470345497131348,
0.43144339323043823,
0.09692700207233429,
-0.043178360909223557,
-0.004686342552304268,
0.06544721126556396,
-0.6202492713928223,
0.3289748430252075,
0.01804620958864689,
-0.37075865268707275,
0.014407237060368061,
-0.356850266456604,
0.2567631006240845,
0.33884397149086,
0.6753242015838623,
0.30346691608428955,
-0.3521497845649719,
0.8442790508270264,
0.08751004934310913,
0.2194906771183014,
-0.5738947987556458,
-0.5338737964630127,
-0.7487685680389404,
0.3186209201812744,
0.24056275188922882,
0.5112012028694153,
-0.8565671443939209,
-0.04238271340727806,
0.069786936044693,
-0.7035639882087708,
-0.1541038155555725,
-0.1713629513978958,
0.4004621207714081,
1.0650354623794556,
-0.17971600592136383,
-0.050365522503852844,
-0.3963907063007355,
-0.82086181640625,
-0.07606574892997742,
-0.6793084740638733,
-0.0007283465238288045,
0.6297974586486816,
0.5102720856666565,
0.2737674117088318,
1.1488701105117798,
-0.9273586273193359,
0.7846524119377136,
-0.7042444944381714,
0.5930903553962708,
0.08067791163921356,
0.2846119999885559,
0.34189844131469727,
-1.17388117313385,
-0.1839563548564911,
-0.22620338201522827,
-1.0051573514938354,
-0.33273395895957947,
-0.2514253556728363,
-0.05198905989527702,
-0.21093715727329254,
0.5649510025978088,
-0.9326812028884888,
0.3181571364402771,
-0.025891365483403206,
-0.41369709372520447,
0.9250044226646423,
0.08664321899414062,
0.2985820174217224,
-1.3702977895736694,
0.12690365314483643,
-0.6158828735351562,
-0.27962490916252136,
-0.8882434964179993,
-0.07420327514410019,
-0.2782288193702698,
-0.49290207028388977,
-0.6446629166603088,
0.47105851769447327,
-0.07391554862260818,
-0.03228072077035904,
-0.202788308262825,
0.16419796645641327,
0.2874380350112915,
0.4160507917404175,
-0.284887433052063,
0.6905739307403564,
0.2784544825553894,
-1.0482603311538696,
0.33535298705101013,
0.5542792081832886,
-0.6361105442047119,
0.43856537342071533,
-0.9135867357254028,
0.11459469795227051,
-0.4596099257469177,
0.10628678649663925,
-1.2080657482147217,
-0.38880157470703125,
0.10392003506422043,
-0.6937255263328552,
-0.02635311149060726,
-0.07291463762521744,
-0.4266307055950165,
-0.34906840324401855,
0.0765528529882431,
0.3875913918018341,
0.6610528230667114,
-0.3805745244026184,
0.4573528468608856,
0.10155829787254333,
-0.5328691601753235,
-0.21689701080322266,
-0.19875603914260864,
-0.35112226009368896,
-0.24259692430496216,
-0.8938851952552795,
-0.15727390348911285,
-0.3626619577407837,
-0.5317174792289734,
-0.0761038064956665,
-0.20242762565612793,
-0.01829221099615097,
0.30246850848197937,
0.32006311416625977,
-0.011262898333370686,
-0.21904295682907104,
0.1472344994544983,
0.08872392028570175,
-0.007720319088548422,
0.48385027050971985,
-0.11012330651283264,
0.46151235699653625,
0.15801610052585602,
-0.3035638630390167,
-0.16953198611736298,
0.5254635810852051,
0.5913914442062378,
-0.03213771432638168,
0.42023152112960815,
0.04689597338438034,
-0.11222100257873535,
-0.09073100239038467,
-0.48453882336616516,
-0.1168682873249054,
-0.4440215229988098,
0.2494872659444809,
-0.46768414974212646,
-0.7659779787063599,
0.7205290794372559,
-0.3060460388660431,
-0.01616353541612625,
0.5891993045806885,
0.6034398674964905,
-0.2347063422203064,
1.3187570571899414,
0.4743266701698303,
0.4588349163532257,
-0.014998320490121841,
-0.19879339635372162,
0.22742053866386414,
-0.35872510075569153,
-0.3991929888725281,
-0.2723698019981384,
0.2624300420284271,
-0.33595630526542664,
-0.23461225628852844,
0.43618547916412354,
0.39619168639183044,
0.12096118927001953,
0.09268875420093536,
0.11788483709096909,
0.459144651889801,
0.3502454459667206,
-0.24342544376850128,
0.2642342746257782,
-0.5874080061912537,
-0.45659133791923523,
0.17814409732818604,
-0.9897844791412354,
-0.49563392996788025,
1.0517921447753906,
-0.03779391944408417,
0.22231462597846985,
-0.13849219679832458,
0.4314152002334595,
0.12825271487236023,
0.32816195487976074,
-0.7118172645568848,
0.6492876410484314,
0.6924874782562256,
-0.7669442892074585,
-0.34481409192085266,
-0.4722960293292999,
-0.6873993873596191,
0.3441660702228546,
0.004467209335416555,
-0.5175178050994873,
-0.09161707758903503,
0.17920926213264465,
-0.689988374710083,
0.022419609129428864,
-0.9416236877441406,
0.8396005034446716,
0.038369014859199524,
-0.06465346366167068,
0.09866991639137268,
-0.6926859617233276,
0.677520215511322,
0.04708331823348999,
0.006249346770346165,
-0.03715137764811516,
0.5829907655715942,
0.8821331858634949,
-0.5660659074783325,
0.39776816964149475,
-0.4395064115524292,
-0.017466941848397255,
0.8924108147621155,
0.10408002883195877,
0.1885027289390564,
0.2934059202671051,
0.14647237956523895,
-0.607731282711029,
0.23603156208992004,
-0.10534916818141937,
-1.1382784843444824,
0.19963857531547546,
-0.34869086742401123,
-0.9742040634155273,
0.0692920833826065,
-0.8789377212524414,
-0.4870743751525879,
0.24922622740268707,
0.2430858612060547,
0.786426305770874,
-0.4379355013370514,
-0.013981727883219719,
0.8376554846763611,
-0.5449570417404175,
0.154660165309906,
0.729428768157959,
-0.6681927442550659,
-0.31619274616241455,
0.6812260746955872,
0.23492754995822906,
0.6131281852722168,
0.13609221577644348,
0.35758617520332336,
-0.3271440863609314,
-0.36659517884254456,
-0.4016817808151245,
-0.02389889396727085,
-0.8476983308792114,
0.07753843814134598,
-0.8060837984085083,
-0.3128775954246521,
-0.5519281625747681,
-0.0944376289844513,
-0.2335631251335144,
-0.7367245554924011,
0.027524467557668686,
-0.582047164440155,
0.14282722771167755,
0.9232971668243408,
0.23998016119003296,
0.3202436864376068,
-0.4181356728076935,
0.4332793653011322,
0.9271003007888794,
-0.14155131578445435,
-0.08345023542642593,
-0.34319403767585754,
0.08608637005090714,
0.1437360793352127,
-0.5627066493034363,
-0.8539594411849976,
0.14570170640945435,
-0.2023676037788391,
0.39484092593193054,
0.6370911002159119,
0.18662208318710327,
0.5516528487205505,
-0.29822656512260437,
1.1350406408309937,
0.11790728569030762,
-0.6098765730857849,
0.7778860926628113,
-0.4120626151561737,
0.575118362903595,
0.7844381332397461,
0.37836581468582153,
-0.47729408740997314,
-0.36798810958862305,
-1.0653529167175293,
-0.700215756893158,
0.46131646633148193,
0.2937520742416382,
0.03579851612448692,
-0.0994628518819809,
0.43096187710762024,
0.5928840041160583,
0.49308839440345764,
-0.19005516171455383,
-0.3561967611312866,
-0.13716013729572296,
0.09829943627119064,
-0.04038489609956741,
-0.7104694843292236,
-0.140253484249115,
-0.26342636346817017,
0.42844319343566895,
-0.11553604155778885,
0.39908021688461304,
0.32595333456993103,
-0.1309397667646408,
0.0848158746957779,
0.3934389054775238,
0.7290585041046143,
1.1237212419509888,
-0.3104250133037567,
-0.0840427428483963,
0.26733285188674927,
-0.042319878935813904,
0.09642207622528076,
0.005860322155058384,
-0.5156822204589844,
0.0559752993285656,
0.18403971195220947,
0.7443175911903381,
0.13494032621383667,
-0.6138857007026672,
0.42204001545906067,
-0.12900656461715698,
-0.7815322875976562,
-0.3318619132041931,
0.04201292619109154,
0.1330556422472,
0.17975667119026184,
0.1419556736946106,
-0.1899864226579666,
0.11039716750383377,
-0.686454713344574,
0.3026846647262573,
0.1927776038646698,
-0.2829107642173767,
-0.45309796929359436,
0.844849169254303,
0.1555524617433548,
-0.06447646021842957,
0.5166513919830322,
-0.32315632700920105,
-0.6686067581176758,
0.8214405179023743,
0.418578565120697,
0.8270991444587708,
-0.09607896208763123,
0.5654737949371338,
0.38681644201278687,
0.04891197383403778,
0.35215818881988525,
0.903564989566803,
-0.5697426199913025,
-0.9257984161376953,
-0.3327598571777344,
-0.2549968659877777,
-0.7346415519714355,
0.2761250138282776,
-0.8429082036018372,
0.029497645795345306,
-0.2362474650144577,
0.14347058534622192,
0.02937461994588375,
-0.18042835593223572,
-0.5321282744407654,
0.5420997142791748,
-0.1434573531150818,
1.0264558792114258,
-0.8285597562789917,
0.33680880069732666,
0.4174710810184479,
-0.3904300928115845,
-0.8081264495849609,
0.09938474744558334,
-0.31423062086105347,
-0.7081881761550903,
0.5244517922401428,
0.31920501589775085,
0.23078703880310059,
-0.018307246267795563,
-0.6645025610923767,
-0.7073990702629089,
1.4682955741882324,
0.16543865203857422,
0.16726765036582947,
-0.0507577583193779,
0.4004756510257721,
0.3319547772407532,
-0.3171764314174652,
0.37296926975250244,
0.62838214635849,
0.39948877692222595,
0.4095093607902527,
-0.5959278345108032,
-0.058686599135398865,
-0.28328564763069153,
-0.22294797003269196,
0.09945026785135269,
-0.4800109267234802,
0.506206750869751,
-0.41834092140197754,
-0.29402023553848267,
0.0642041340470314,
0.7289895415306091,
0.12156711518764496,
0.5519117712974548,
0.6239253282546997,
0.5079177021980286,
0.7533515095710754,
-0.07864390313625336,
1.2667416334152222,
-0.38912951946258545,
0.008044304326176643,
1.1066993474960327,
-0.15679432451725006,
0.2288544923067093,
0.38450905680656433,
-0.11032797396183014,
0.2808167636394501,
0.5147945880889893,
0.2915552258491516,
0.5341595411300659,
0.28711214661598206,
-0.15451985597610474,
-0.24603040516376495,
-0.3955564498901367,
-0.3560279905796051,
0.6279784440994263,
0.18211157619953156,
-0.2850089371204376,
-0.33291155099868774,
-0.06534627825021744,
0.07019031047821045,
-0.22197024524211884,
-0.2903890311717987,
0.9691189527511597,
-0.15106385946273804,
-1.217068076133728,
0.3728238642215729,
-0.280392587184906,
-0.3820897936820984,
-0.785315752029419,
-0.0920541062951088,
-0.3641583025455475,
-0.34080567955970764,
0.1411154717206955,
-0.7362568378448486,
0.23212695121765137,
-0.05767370015382767,
-0.4362955093383789,
-0.40726760029792786,
0.7107950448989868,
-0.418011337518692,
-0.45921972393989563,
-0.3343092203140259,
0.8140935897827148,
0.3562987744808197,
-0.0289614200592041,
-0.2330923080444336,
-0.6955475807189941,
0.28168514370918274,
-0.5007930397987366,
0.13045436143875122,
0.5496503710746765,
0.15248578786849976,
0.9113373160362244,
0.4487190246582031,
-0.3898128867149353,
0.1755828559398651,
0.10073604434728622,
0.8774191737174988,
-0.6537956595420837,
-0.624803364276886,
-0.409016489982605,
0.8057517409324646,
0.11440588533878326,
-0.4706578254699707,
0.8006246089935303,
0.5039775371551514,
0.47137656807899475,
-0.05509660765528679,
1.070521354675293,
-0.24123001098632812,
0.5400152802467346,
-0.5708457827568054,
0.6018121242523193,
-0.21595782041549683,
-0.11871641129255295,
-0.1935003250837326,
-0.5594529509544373,
0.24445027112960815,
0.061722226440906525,
-0.3679669499397278,
-0.027141369879245758,
0.7585518956184387,
0.776461124420166,
0.3399506211280823,
0.5650972127914429,
0.5651208162307739,
0.217060387134552,
0.10206986963748932,
0.35394346714019775,
1.211780071258545,
-0.36433693766593933,
0.5195174813270569,
-0.41004666686058044,
0.019073985517024994,
0.2294376939535141,
-0.7196155190467834,
-0.8723618984222412,
-0.6169302463531494,
-0.32146286964416504,
-0.14323413372039795,
-0.3239605128765106,
0.45010483264923096,
0.47439301013946533,
-0.6814131140708923,
0.10221672058105469,
-0.28941065073013306,
0.268738329410553,
0.06266195327043533,
-0.30271345376968384,
0.04560564458370209,
-0.29519301652908325,
-0.26856327056884766,
0.4249253273010254,
-0.06018948554992676,
0.10421618074178696,
-0.2979345917701721,
0.05269414931535721,
-0.0876370370388031,
0.23432821035385132,
0.7126842737197876,
0.17041519284248352,
-0.3999249041080475,
-0.2864576578140259,
-0.09967634826898575,
0.5533162951469421,
-0.23586872220039368,
0.9858608245849609,
-0.8570849895477295,
0.6448702812194824,
0.38244980573654175,
0.5289609432220459,
0.44995149970054626,
0.2855013608932495,
0.9907963275909424,
-0.731945276260376,
-0.08234881609678268,
0.22154539823532104,
0.07537134736776352,
0.15312744677066803,
-0.3528783619403839,
0.4062541127204895,
0.2652742266654968,
-0.4444580674171448,
-0.7034592032432556,
0.5393810272216797,
-0.7118372321128845,
-0.057505395263433456,
1.0940570831298828,
-0.04891165345907211,
0.14757758378982544,
-0.10007926821708679,
-0.2778434157371521,
0.18761029839515686,
0.16357509791851044,
0.5116500854492188,
0.9746498465538025,
-0.31904494762420654,
-0.06878157705068588,
-0.8847456574440002,
0.5177826285362244,
0.6062895059585571,
-0.7644996643066406,
0.20107059180736542,
0.4282706677913666,
0.3598695993423462,
0.0058371517807245255,
0.6255265474319458,
-0.08084618300199509,
0.3743324875831604,
0.08771339803934097,
-0.18940523266792297,
-0.21398165822029114,
-0.27992498874664307,
0.20847514271736145,
0.5703966617584229,
0.030298292636871338,
-0.0011794897727668285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07824v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07824v1
|
Heron-Bench: A Benchmark for Evaluating Vision Language Models in Japanese
| 2024-04-11T15:09:22 | 2024-04-11T15:09:22 |
Yuichi Inoue, Kento Sasaki, Yuma Ochi, Kazuki Fujii, Kotaro Tanahashi, Yu Yamaguchi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Vision Language Models (VLMs) have undergone a rapid evolution, giving rise
to significant advancements in the realm of multimodal understanding tasks.
However, the majority of these models are trained and evaluated on
English-centric datasets, leaving a gap in the development and evaluation of
VLMs for other languages, such as Japanese. This gap can be attributed to the
lack of methodologies for constructing VLMs and the absence of benchmarks to
accurately measure their performance. To address this issue, we introduce a
novel benchmark, Japanese Heron-Bench, for evaluating Japanese capabilities of
VLMs. The Japanese Heron-Bench consists of a variety of imagequestion answer
pairs tailored to the Japanese context. Additionally, we present a baseline
Japanese VLM that has been trained with Japanese visual instruction tuning
datasets. Our Heron-Bench reveals the strengths and limitations of the proposed
VLM across various ability dimensions. Furthermore, we clarify the capability
gap between strong closed models like GPT-4V and the baseline model, providing
valuable insights for future research in this domain. We release the benchmark
dataset and training code to facilitate further developments in Japanese VLM
research.
|
[
-0.3454665541648865,
-0.2666267454624176,
0.6203930377960205,
-0.012656879611313343,
-0.43239644169807434,
-0.22240355610847473,
-0.05723143368959427,
-0.6539552807807922,
-0.28596845269203186,
0.554050624370575,
-0.5518348813056946,
-0.5457950234413147,
-0.4008182883262634,
-0.050651852041482925,
0.03336334228515625,
0.38804003596305847,
-0.18186986446380615,
0.40049439668655396,
-0.2494359314441681,
-0.6314947009086609,
-0.6237701773643494,
-0.08742683380842209,
-0.38892197608947754,
-0.06638189405202866,
0.38108932971954346,
0.19437405467033386,
0.48478370904922485,
0.7518385052680969,
0.613032877445221,
0.27257734537124634,
0.3784756660461426,
0.031487978994846344,
-0.27677425742149353,
0.20200254023075104,
-0.08096466958522797,
-0.5683778524398804,
-0.20815548300743103,
-0.10759346932172775,
1.0472441911697388,
0.8330720067024231,
0.15608590841293335,
0.3000899851322174,
-0.1731926053762436,
0.7425416111946106,
-1.1135377883911133,
0.5200926661491394,
-0.5078232288360596,
0.34831616282463074,
-0.5324310660362244,
0.06628447771072388,
-0.24467308819293976,
-0.0550837367773056,
0.1389998495578766,
-0.8035269379615784,
0.12200901657342911,
-0.048630308359861374,
0.8486150503158569,
0.2930572032928467,
-0.2336442917585373,
0.44691434502601624,
-0.3551752269268036,
0.940560519695282,
-0.6051099300384521,
0.6737295389175415,
0.3872649669647217,
0.835006594657898,
0.3871883153915405,
-0.7274959683418274,
-0.2605922222137451,
-0.28871139883995056,
0.19741030037403107,
0.4948071539402008,
-0.04673967510461807,
-0.031125888228416443,
0.4132674038410187,
0.27686795592308044,
-0.6709347367286682,
0.00360865774564445,
-0.39383623003959656,
-0.11310447007417679,
0.4442175030708313,
0.3187021017074585,
0.2264450341463089,
-0.3124472498893738,
-0.26663127541542053,
-0.38335320353507996,
-0.3530759811401367,
0.14877751469612122,
0.03999669477343559,
0.3034974932670593,
-0.04818082973361015,
0.6439740061759949,
-0.4592875838279724,
1.1092149019241333,
-0.62958824634552,
-0.19998614490032196,
0.2769744396209717,
-0.37382930517196655,
-0.21948674321174622,
-0.20045511424541473,
0.7175691723823547,
0.7162196040153503,
0.21204137802124023,
0.02951529622077942,
-0.2622705101966858,
0.2938469648361206,
0.25808319449424744,
-0.530968427658081,
0.1404157429933548,
-0.2588522136211395,
-0.4699350893497467,
-0.11588896811008453,
0.14816957712173462,
-0.6136628985404968,
-0.22768695652484894,
-0.12904492020606995,
0.4719770550727844,
-0.41384977102279663,
-0.3317835032939911,
0.09136779606342316,
-0.4134501516819,
0.7093759179115295,
0.17857375741004944,
-0.5168610215187073,
0.24957500398159027,
0.5972707867622375,
0.8324154019355774,
-0.030044827610254288,
-0.4762049913406372,
-0.5083265900611877,
0.10827702283859253,
-0.5873154997825623,
0.37811827659606934,
-0.6535942554473877,
-0.3964621126651764,
-0.06465232372283936,
-0.035512614995241165,
-0.09345263242721558,
-0.4173031449317932,
0.2993844449520111,
-0.17461296916007996,
0.18496522307395935,
-0.3261694610118866,
-0.36024507880210876,
-0.141913041472435,
0.23621921241283417,
-0.5779157280921936,
0.7599515318870544,
0.40347763895988464,
-0.6504804491996765,
0.36470165848731995,
-0.425142765045166,
-0.058435212820768356,
0.6656410098075867,
-0.637924313545227,
-0.41779401898384094,
0.43049827218055725,
0.21627815067768097,
0.15793447196483612,
-0.44346165657043457,
0.01708422414958477,
-0.6833229660987854,
-0.40107783675193787,
0.269867479801178,
-0.5388979911804199,
0.7234799265861511,
0.15890756249427795,
-0.3474460542201996,
-0.12076214700937271,
-0.7509379386901855,
0.6147323250770569,
0.007779676932841539,
0.11872150003910065,
-0.7146472930908203,
-0.20266762375831604,
0.151675283908844,
-0.06686252355575562,
0.2945965528488159,
-0.49040475487709045,
-0.051972147077322006,
-0.16122040152549744,
0.20449969172477722,
0.6443417072296143,
-0.20063354074954987,
-0.056730762124061584,
-0.20631782710552216,
0.7190890312194824,
-0.12164191901683807,
0.5943329334259033,
-0.44999831914901733,
-0.5701202750205994,
-0.7989093065261841,
-0.23463572561740875,
0.0027066529728472233,
0.23672953248023987,
-0.9825707077980042,
-0.15262940526008606,
-0.29707708954811096,
-0.544937789440155,
-0.8843407034873962,
0.0018243013182654977,
0.959465742111206,
0.6496161818504333,
0.19633333384990692,
-0.7439180612564087,
-0.5320894718170166,
-1.1069862842559814,
-0.3688461482524872,
-0.20862573385238647,
0.1663200706243515,
0.536913275718689,
0.2166476547718048,
-0.01006122212857008,
0.7559856176376343,
-0.22208674252033234,
-0.08105966448783875,
-0.0023544756695628166,
0.018334249034523964,
0.06554608792066574,
0.2633700370788574,
0.6238725781440735,
-0.925544798374176,
-0.6029245257377625,
0.18032367527484894,
-1.0618081092834473,
-0.09239356219768524,
0.2945926785469055,
-0.03591177985072136,
0.0797610804438591,
0.33076539635658264,
-0.24053990840911865,
0.5410459637641907,
0.5573142766952515,
-0.2490537166595459,
0.5832128524780273,
-0.06408432871103287,
0.2883940041065216,
-0.8669260144233704,
0.30074605345726013,
0.21588338911533356,
-0.2555887699127197,
-0.4356679916381836,
0.5309885740280151,
0.42786267399787903,
-0.2943134605884552,
-0.4760383069515228,
0.4594288170337677,
-0.5420511960983276,
-0.8348437547683716,
-0.09048662334680557,
-0.05323930084705353,
0.014569714665412903,
0.2778967618942261,
0.2611404061317444,
0.870533287525177,
0.6977511644363403,
-0.4023107588291168,
0.4096364378929138,
0.08804244548082352,
-0.6413551568984985,
0.8639050722122192,
-0.783280074596405,
0.0018194745061919093,
0.027067894116044044,
-0.326129674911499,
-0.9284278154373169,
-0.1606525182723999,
0.134362131357193,
-0.2611769735813141,
0.1460881233215332,
-0.4109414219856262,
-0.010020121932029724,
-0.4733884036540985,
-0.3491268754005432,
0.4401690363883972,
0.527953028678894,
-0.27700260281562805,
0.376535564661026,
0.23086945712566376,
0.038729194551706314,
-0.8430458903312683,
-0.775107204914093,
0.09876368194818497,
-0.0691407173871994,
-0.4294564425945282,
0.3567996323108673,
-0.07709630578756332,
-0.3758563697338104,
0.21190272271633148,
-0.17250214517116547,
-0.11889341473579407,
-0.00718223862349987,
0.1662915199995041,
0.47089481353759766,
-0.8577857613563538,
-0.22036029398441315,
-0.4419279098510742,
-0.4213860332965851,
-0.13227057456970215,
-0.5040078163146973,
0.24046164751052856,
-0.5523123741149902,
-0.5927174091339111,
-0.39104416966438293,
-0.001449007191695273,
0.9460858106613159,
-0.5258458852767944,
0.4211830496788025,
0.5491619110107422,
-0.17629513144493103,
0.034416258335113525,
-0.576471209526062,
0.10650067031383514,
-0.4220891296863556,
0.6177712082862854,
-0.691466748714447,
-0.5020148158073425,
0.19611752033233643,
0.12714716792106628,
-0.013045404106378555,
0.2535592019557953,
0.10083889216184616,
0.023564616218209267,
1.045557975769043,
0.8809649348258972,
0.0393245592713356,
0.5607027411460876,
-0.21076539158821106,
-0.23101112246513367,
-1.1465610265731812,
-0.0706164613366127,
-0.22708465158939362,
-0.13370314240455627,
-0.5108844637870789,
-0.5060406923294067,
0.515908420085907,
-0.10518315434455872,
0.00870728213340044,
0.2089514434337616,
-0.22253715991973877,
0.598297119140625,
0.47679898142814636,
-0.06035490706562996,
0.23981018364429474,
-0.06776175647974014,
-0.2837446630001068,
-0.43900176882743835,
-0.6897870302200317,
-0.13836561143398285,
1.2370742559432983,
0.05459657683968544,
0.45893722772598267,
0.055598288774490356,
0.37655484676361084,
0.07104232162237167,
0.010293821804225445,
-0.6339824199676514,
0.5971832871437073,
-0.2866058647632599,
-0.315861314535141,
-0.445197194814682,
-0.4624042510986328,
-0.7929937839508057,
0.647370457649231,
0.07205358892679214,
-0.5726513266563416,
0.0059350160881876945,
-0.1729905754327774,
-0.10842326283454895,
0.07619044929742813,
-0.607285737991333,
1.2339308261871338,
-0.5645015239715576,
-0.771069347858429,
-0.1367071270942688,
-0.45862236618995667,
0.5110700726509094,
-0.012689206749200821,
0.17135049402713776,
-0.19760744273662567,
-0.31642869114875793,
0.4421132504940033,
-0.502484917640686,
0.6616112589836121,
-0.36736756563186646,
0.21995703876018524,
-0.17442423105239868,
-0.29927530884742737,
-0.02278936468064785,
0.028304919600486755,
-0.047406330704689026,
-0.0076667251996695995,
0.12009985744953156,
-0.6092620491981506,
-0.5281424522399902,
0.5630409121513367,
-0.987585723400116,
-0.3587562143802643,
-0.4146844446659088,
-0.3671424686908722,
-0.5490114688873291,
0.36078161001205444,
0.30837932229042053,
0.6769442558288574,
-0.09610037505626678,
0.3776662051677704,
0.5001691579818726,
-0.20909108221530914,
0.3522048592567444,
1.0455013513565063,
-0.40316444635391235,
-0.3384181559085846,
0.8276821374893188,
0.23345746099948883,
0.2560480237007141,
0.2909049093723297,
0.1791476309299469,
-0.3740277588367462,
-0.7041412591934204,
-0.6053323745727539,
0.12959052622318268,
-0.7272788286209106,
-0.017598506063222885,
-0.11261744797229767,
-0.32443198561668396,
-0.29037749767303467,
0.056704286485910416,
-0.6384323239326477,
-0.15786601603031158,
0.40167036652565,
0.19413548707962036,
0.11651424318552017,
0.6577456593513489,
0.20461644232273102,
-0.07800426334142685,
-0.6568478345870972,
0.43795496225357056,
0.49785012006759644,
0.7489525675773621,
-0.21794773638248444,
-0.41711264848709106,
-0.2510792315006256,
-0.01686045713722706,
0.042461175471544266,
-0.6845382452011108,
0.2772914171218872,
0.10892464220523834,
0.9217426180839539,
0.25082165002822876,
-0.03695539012551308,
1.0948330163955688,
-0.22187136113643646,
0.6978908181190491,
0.387468546628952,
-0.7750828266143799,
0.7516040802001953,
-0.38670751452445984,
0.746651828289032,
0.6423255801200867,
0.16330257058143616,
-0.6557690501213074,
-0.4464764893054962,
-0.5061405301094055,
-0.730506181716919,
0.6642439365386963,
0.02204006351530552,
-0.14571954309940338,
0.4969225227832794,
0.2612040042877197,
0.16395004093647003,
0.22909478843212128,
-0.7145145535469055,
-0.014537454582750797,
-0.4486445486545563,
-0.18263912200927734,
-0.33112117648124695,
-0.06146479770541191,
0.17595477402210236,
-0.3086289167404175,
0.4317116439342499,
-0.2587449252605438,
-0.1940515637397766,
-0.019653141498565674,
-0.2855153977870941,
-0.1200186014175415,
-0.002411444904282689,
0.3133559823036194,
0.8612212538719177,
-0.09200979769229889,
0.0007413116400130093,
0.052478477358818054,
-0.5689793825149536,
-0.16639411449432373,
0.07651739567518234,
-0.44672849774360657,
0.042983077466487885,
0.5261119604110718,
1.1806117296218872,
0.39491912722587585,
-0.7732759714126587,
0.5163965821266174,
-0.3859206438064575,
-0.04060741513967514,
-0.33046308159828186,
0.24479718506336212,
-0.24004754424095154,
0.20122474431991577,
0.2980840802192688,
0.06157469376921654,
0.08160644769668579,
-0.5773705244064331,
0.15694183111190796,
0.40552592277526855,
-0.6258491277694702,
-0.08242485672235489,
0.4504234492778778,
0.05115453153848648,
-0.14586128294467926,
0.6150516271591187,
0.09824766963720322,
-0.33240652084350586,
0.6296316385269165,
0.3749140799045563,
0.8505815267562866,
-0.18482308089733124,
0.25060373544692993,
0.4657880663871765,
0.3900741934776306,
0.03840460255742073,
0.36773258447647095,
-0.2847561836242676,
-0.7476833462715149,
-0.22311928868293762,
-0.61821049451828,
-0.5418336987495422,
0.49740269780158997,
-1.043041706085205,
0.15423332154750824,
-0.5453483462333679,
-0.18158875405788422,
-0.035385068506002426,
0.1271555870771408,
-0.746798574924469,
0.0798274427652359,
0.4141833484172821,
0.6929633021354675,
-0.7355168461799622,
0.9313307404518127,
0.8739912509918213,
-0.49484819173812866,
-0.49603861570358276,
-0.10130300372838974,
0.09640124440193176,
-1.0144777297973633,
0.48883405327796936,
0.42592135071754456,
-0.3286513388156891,
0.0007814923883415759,
-0.2926989793777466,
-0.7817812561988831,
1.1404556035995483,
0.38559406995773315,
-0.7355833053588867,
0.3489547371864319,
0.21228118240833282,
0.5442290902137756,
-0.3484179377555847,
0.3287968933582306,
0.3775353729724884,
0.5709531903266907,
-0.11446536332368851,
-0.8557450175285339,
-0.3621276319026947,
-0.6872550249099731,
0.6396086812019348,
-0.089436836540699,
-0.786523163318634,
0.7442402839660645,
0.004613286815583706,
-0.08066045492887497,
0.33829349279403687,
0.4243682622909546,
0.3520858585834503,
0.27730610966682434,
0.43659716844558716,
0.49581581354141235,
0.6074483394622803,
-0.13426432013511658,
1.104664921760559,
-0.2803674638271332,
-0.044667959213256836,
0.9658091068267822,
-0.4397469460964203,
0.9985901117324829,
0.4776313006877899,
-0.1837330460548401,
0.28693681955337524,
0.2663780152797699,
-0.1430990993976593,
0.5888654589653015,
-0.05789180099964142,
-0.11534565687179565,
-0.3596510887145996,
-0.15125307440757751,
-0.5561501979827881,
0.7051295042037964,
0.31586700677871704,
-0.045993056148290634,
-0.011638276278972626,
0.33502116799354553,
-0.5026999711990356,
0.23793543875217438,
-0.4541338086128235,
0.5967187285423279,
0.022403348237276077,
-0.8685097694396973,
0.6036670207977295,
-0.029936468228697777,
0.4628427028656006,
-1.0595495700836182,
0.12956075370311737,
-0.3213779032230377,
0.49725157022476196,
0.19315402209758759,
-0.8401156663894653,
0.10739810764789581,
0.1912769228219986,
-0.0720779076218605,
-0.18060827255249023,
0.5835720896720886,
-0.18943805992603302,
-0.5388096570968628,
0.2873043119907379,
0.4100050628185272,
0.10937915742397308,
0.2266138792037964,
-0.853361964225769,
0.4467003643512726,
-0.054220739752054214,
-0.07804752886295319,
0.29285725951194763,
0.3661704957485199,
-0.06876089423894882,
0.6825813055038452,
0.43094825744628906,
0.18748509883880615,
0.09216804057359695,
0.37921905517578125,
0.4685932993888855,
-0.6649098992347717,
-0.44126734137535095,
-0.6559234261512756,
0.44614583253860474,
-0.3623611032962799,
-0.5823527574539185,
1.0010532140731812,
0.6560158133506775,
0.9630218744277954,
-0.14915817975997925,
1.0828056335449219,
0.2079557627439499,
0.21779997646808624,
-0.6592718362808228,
0.569932222366333,
-0.8637322187423706,
0.13173985481262207,
-0.2367067188024521,
-0.8476734161376953,
-0.10235992819070816,
0.8477917313575745,
-0.3661675453186035,
0.17071039974689484,
0.556591272354126,
0.6293171644210815,
-0.2707928419113159,
-0.048530541360378265,
0.7987415194511414,
0.23136863112449646,
0.03678767755627632,
0.8587378859519958,
1.0052862167358398,
-0.480154424905777,
0.3167377710342407,
-0.35115310549736023,
-0.3023040294647217,
-0.16113685071468353,
-0.7431052923202515,
-0.6724613308906555,
-0.6670618653297424,
-0.35695475339889526,
0.14244841039180756,
0.38074710965156555,
0.21348260343074799,
0.8099501729011536,
-0.514940619468689,
-0.5103096961975098,
-0.2006562352180481,
-0.209554985165596,
-0.5030274391174316,
-0.16715851426124573,
0.018257755786180496,
-0.442942351102829,
-0.5719109773635864,
0.34678471088409424,
0.5624189376831055,
0.12957002222537994,
-0.5992817282676697,
-0.3175349235534668,
0.3538679778575897,
-0.2856028079986572,
0.3737647831439972,
0.521938681602478,
-0.878241240978241,
-0.1276334524154663,
0.021895553916692734,
-0.20238187909126282,
-0.17105348408222198,
0.5485562086105347,
-0.9009232521057129,
0.9923163056373596,
0.2982882261276245,
0.5686501860618591,
0.8197337985038757,
-0.45125195384025574,
0.9087769985198975,
-0.6595594882965088,
0.34931373596191406,
0.14370250701904297,
0.6102460026741028,
0.6044278144836426,
0.2413409799337387,
0.6441608667373657,
0.40785670280456543,
0.08556346595287323,
-0.841900646686554,
0.2966795861721039,
-0.8654674887657166,
-0.32262122631073,
0.7925639152526855,
-0.23789948225021362,
-0.5057175159454346,
-0.009084775112569332,
-0.08978208899497986,
0.03228655457496643,
0.34495750069618225,
0.48898178339004517,
0.6596570014953613,
0.3066355288028717,
-0.527488112449646,
-0.8176508545875549,
0.31567859649658203,
0.48319217562675476,
-0.6236789226531982,
0.22697727382183075,
0.5034925937652588,
0.09000074863433838,
-0.06585124135017395,
0.7532152533531189,
-0.3254276514053345,
0.812166690826416,
0.27566400170326233,
-0.19838596880435944,
-0.31822964549064636,
-0.300160676240921,
-0.26325008273124695,
0.0686725527048111,
0.2531576454639435,
-0.33859506249427795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07814v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07814v1
|
MultiLS-SP/CA: Lexical Complexity Prediction and Lexical Simplification Resources for Catalan and Spanish
| 2024-04-11T14:57:19 | 2024-04-11T14:57:19 |
Stefan Bott, Horacio Saggion, Nelson Peréz Rojas, Martin Solis Salazar, Saul Calderon Ramirez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic lexical simplification is a task to substitute lexical items that
may be unfamiliar and difficult to understand with easier and more common
words. This paper presents MultiLS-SP/CA, a novel dataset for lexical
simplification in Spanish and Catalan. This dataset represents the first of its
kind in Catalan and a substantial addition to the sparse data on automatic
lexical simplification which is available for Spanish. Specifically, MultiLS-SP
is the first dataset for Spanish which includes scalar ratings of the
understanding difficulty of lexical items. In addition, we describe experiments
with this dataset, which can serve as a baseline for future work on the same
data.
|
[
-0.42999398708343506,
-0.3914700448513031,
0.3908768892288208,
0.8129517436027527,
-0.25472548604011536,
0.19061847031116486,
-0.023791298270225525,
-0.3261212408542633,
0.47021540999412537,
0.10594535619020462,
-0.8914414644241333,
-0.4023417830467224,
-0.7080522775650024,
0.2156861126422882,
-0.24347390234470367,
1.043001651763916,
0.10942117124795914,
0.39661580324172974,
0.12048806995153427,
-0.12860246002674103,
-0.2512468099594116,
-0.6485369801521301,
-0.5416660308837891,
-0.09856593608856201,
0.8359428644180298,
0.45739662647247314,
1.1947709321975708,
0.6241423487663269,
0.5704811811447144,
0.2924131751060486,
-0.29318004846572876,
0.5197047591209412,
-0.39127853512763977,
-0.22137989103794098,
-0.09675879776477814,
-0.26109591126441956,
-0.5218964219093323,
-0.6110842823982239,
0.6240699887275696,
0.9776986837387085,
-0.08221232891082764,
0.09241575002670288,
0.024210287258028984,
0.9355219006538391,
-0.5483527779579163,
0.5756906867027283,
-0.5856572985649109,
0.23817968368530273,
-0.22436219453811646,
-0.5537614226341248,
-0.1821247786283493,
-0.39212799072265625,
0.0765470564365387,
-0.6642530560493469,
0.6244703531265259,
0.05928998440504074,
0.33949729800224304,
0.8578592538833618,
-0.5604403018951416,
-0.7410070300102234,
-0.760125458240509,
0.6918004751205444,
-0.02054862678050995,
0.47140759229660034,
0.1440715491771698,
0.2367662936449051,
-0.42335811257362366,
-0.7598655819892883,
-0.37334713339805603,
-0.18758542835712433,
-0.0740128755569458,
-0.1584935337305069,
-0.045141786336898804,
0.15198926627635956,
0.21109943091869354,
0.4355561435222626,
-0.5368480682373047,
-0.24671652913093567,
-0.9860084652900696,
-0.4765784740447998,
0.4645518660545349,
0.29841348528862,
0.22618159651756287,
0.11691917479038239,
-0.3161480724811554,
-0.014912977814674377,
-0.8363382816314697,
0.18627922236919403,
0.3361893594264984,
0.5239633321762085,
0.14909954369068146,
0.757322371006012,
-0.09092506766319275,
0.4924590289592743,
-0.4059537649154663,
-0.23511210083961487,
0.7550935745239258,
-0.5075359344482422,
-0.1435410976409912,
0.2679034471511841,
0.4456377625465393,
-0.12379612028598785,
0.31657078862190247,
0.09415637701749802,
-0.042872317135334015,
0.21439464390277863,
-0.1244691014289856,
-0.36398932337760925,
-0.2646850049495697,
0.00004424803773872554,
-0.20636920630931854,
-0.0003052144020330161,
0.2481188178062439,
-0.5449507832527161,
-0.4771287143230438,
-0.35386544466018677,
0.13906040787696838,
-0.16918866336345673,
-0.07166450470685959,
0.5619739294052124,
-0.004410038702189922,
-0.17880967259407043,
0.5482977032661438,
-0.4050723612308502,
0.7643976211547852,
0.4513045847415924,
0.7377616167068481,
-0.26877883076667786,
-0.7524440884590149,
-0.2758895754814148,
-0.20624291896820068,
-0.25812533497810364,
0.6632837653160095,
-0.18507295846939087,
-0.09616643935441971,
-0.5025588870048523,
0.19440683722496033,
0.021385442465543747,
-0.19770461320877075,
0.9305895566940308,
-0.12843799591064453,
-0.3264034688472748,
-0.4454239010810852,
-0.21259823441505432,
-0.02960553765296936,
-0.23373495042324066,
-1.2293214797973633,
1.4343435764312744,
-0.3713792860507965,
-1.0379736423492432,
0.28215107321739197,
-0.3733161985874176,
-0.43283119797706604,
-0.06360695511102676,
-0.00003099404784734361,
-0.11856058239936829,
0.2662560045719147,
0.24742545187473297,
0.3282312750816345,
-0.2985372841358185,
0.21043474972248077,
-0.1463989019393921,
-0.24367575347423553,
0.19308440387248993,
-0.7556211948394775,
0.5125451683998108,
0.45690998435020447,
-0.09183215349912643,
-0.28836655616760254,
-0.9069445133209229,
-0.0924745723605156,
0.1345011293888092,
-0.1799333393573761,
-0.28477367758750916,
0.26319730281829834,
-0.03743331879377365,
0.554925262928009,
0.7869685888290405,
-0.5109794735908508,
-0.12915439903736115,
-0.4495220482349396,
-0.095290407538414,
0.3903871178627014,
-0.16624049842357635,
0.2195642590522766,
-0.3648208975791931,
0.5923608541488647,
0.05609561502933502,
0.3178040087223053,
-0.3029717803001404,
-0.8162239789962769,
-0.6784693002700806,
-0.23719504475593567,
0.09917701780796051,
0.6238381266593933,
-0.6532431244850159,
0.26675260066986084,
-0.23540419340133667,
-0.7406342625617981,
-0.493509441614151,
0.1828942447900772,
0.43251174688339233,
0.09196823835372925,
0.5718247294425964,
-0.07589488476514816,
-0.6483858227729797,
-0.6849592924118042,
0.014580469578504562,
-0.029714839532971382,
0.2710704803466797,
0.08334917575120926,
0.37197086215019226,
0.18539054691791534,
0.760310709476471,
-0.49417001008987427,
-0.41202422976493835,
-0.2312101572751999,
0.15158401429653168,
0.17186279594898224,
0.3851143717765808,
0.43665504455566406,
-0.8883516192436218,
-0.385014146566391,
-0.08199246227741241,
-0.39096489548683167,
-0.045799847692251205,
0.10798411071300507,
0.5030493140220642,
-0.14663676917552948,
0.6696637272834778,
0.07320757955312729,
0.6432088017463684,
0.7959335446357727,
-0.4004416763782501,
0.5010011196136475,
-0.9064170718193054,
-0.05823538079857826,
-0.6177260279655457,
-0.1943960189819336,
-0.06121290102601051,
-0.006203302647918463,
-0.8356703519821167,
-0.22237546741962433,
0.06056378409266472,
0.03536223620176315,
-0.8890390396118164,
0.49677491188049316,
-0.6058428287506104,
-0.34437206387519836,
0.22294440865516663,
-0.39578017592430115,
-0.1167304515838623,
0.6297716498374939,
0.25740960240364075,
0.8547640442848206,
0.6595732569694519,
-0.6328051090240479,
0.3652479648590088,
-0.2642243802547455,
-0.2990409731864929,
-0.0943441390991211,
-0.8472132682800293,
-0.18852534890174866,
-0.5964986681938171,
0.2907007038593292,
-1.2925992012023926,
-0.05830973759293556,
-0.19835321605205536,
-0.22005224227905273,
-0.37120166420936584,
0.18555191159248352,
-0.7352258563041687,
-0.5342091917991638,
-0.3610898554325104,
0.9684682488441467,
-0.2433626353740692,
-0.5511756539344788,
0.3275269865989685,
0.3649105131626129,
-0.3787676692008972,
-0.8875150084495544,
-1.0174450874328613,
0.02408427931368351,
0.027696574106812477,
-0.41499829292297363,
0.3653380274772644,
-0.6417747139930725,
0.01789044961333275,
-0.17469751834869385,
0.09375190734863281,
-0.4199655055999756,
-0.1910623461008072,
0.36519256234169006,
0.07945042848587036,
-0.13732683658599854,
0.3959227502346039,
0.33026978373527527,
-0.08061432838439941,
-0.28799596428871155,
0.25301045179367065,
0.7100739479064941,
-0.640667200088501,
-0.7373404502868652,
-0.5009247660636902,
0.10864870995283127,
0.8502593040466309,
-0.08689332008361816,
0.5764944553375244,
0.3685603141784668,
-0.591126024723053,
-0.07730032503604889,
-0.5697165727615356,
0.2633393406867981,
-0.4329887330532074,
0.36647215485572815,
-0.9097363948822021,
-0.4216451346874237,
0.783013105392456,
-0.010933090932667255,
-0.047640856355428696,
0.6220446825027466,
0.7400757670402527,
0.27489325404167175,
1.1527577638626099,
0.6156918406486511,
0.04030100256204605,
0.05528740957379341,
-0.0627029538154602,
0.03472907841205597,
-0.0056062848307192326,
-0.6807678937911987,
-0.7228406667709351,
-0.18083041906356812,
-0.45785126090049744,
-0.6129574179649353,
0.3278185725212097,
-0.24910983443260193,
-0.13283680379390717,
0.2678815722465515,
-0.4647790491580963,
0.9853220582008362,
0.21032172441482544,
0.14617210626602173,
0.6431605815887451,
0.06165382266044617,
-0.3048992156982422,
-0.331045925617218,
-0.8087211847305298,
-0.24855230748653412,
1.1234517097473145,
0.6192456483840942,
1.0479512214660645,
0.21830035746097565,
0.5433261394500732,
0.46236681938171387,
-0.38653460144996643,
-0.8672747611999512,
0.26523977518081665,
-0.6036894917488098,
-0.32098251581192017,
-0.3668191432952881,
-0.3850449025630951,
-0.9173299670219421,
0.2835909426212311,
-0.29177311062812805,
-0.37077489495277405,
0.47149109840393066,
-0.05533672496676445,
-0.38705259561538696,
0.1848735809326172,
-0.9933145642280579,
0.5233919024467468,
-0.22647780179977417,
0.1424902230501175,
-0.20307081937789917,
-0.6044192910194397,
0.1658996343612671,
-0.1950027197599411,
0.6060677170753479,
-0.054246556013822556,
-0.36653754115104675,
0.5625114440917969,
-0.540062665939331,
0.7218701243400574,
-0.06449521332979202,
-0.004787045065313578,
0.19228991866111755,
0.1216101124882698,
0.3041713833808899,
0.005211069714277983,
-0.30955079197883606,
-0.0752861425280571,
0.2539588510990143,
-0.320909321308136,
-0.3928613066673279,
0.69154292345047,
-0.7832769155502319,
0.22712653875350952,
-0.6242685317993164,
-0.692288339138031,
0.058128245174884796,
-0.017890945076942444,
0.16025063395500183,
0.5992499589920044,
-0.5112850666046143,
0.12680773437023163,
0.6816920042037964,
-0.2545206844806671,
0.23464907705783844,
0.3743669092655182,
0.1167825311422348,
-0.3535864055156708,
1.0516444444656372,
0.24207553267478943,
0.01182516384869814,
0.11077506095170975,
0.23241744935512543,
-0.6177921295166016,
-0.33495134115219116,
-0.3470068573951721,
0.3102480173110962,
-0.8372858166694641,
-0.19666166603565216,
-0.5815565586090088,
-0.37355417013168335,
-0.2800544798374176,
-0.11211327463388443,
-0.5745863914489746,
-0.8969360589981079,
-0.40777352452278137,
-0.07703523337841034,
0.1423242837190628,
1.2207967042922974,
-0.0715840607881546,
0.35110458731651306,
-0.4327789843082428,
0.5022124648094177,
0.10537797957658768,
0.16420555114746094,
-0.0703178197145462,
-0.318724125623703,
0.002170397900044918,
-0.12745481729507446,
0.14965349435806274,
-1.016666293144226,
0.582319438457489,
0.6243357062339783,
0.5289745926856995,
0.40570446848869324,
-0.11648555099964142,
0.8752278685569763,
-0.5015004873275757,
0.5464179515838623,
0.28715118765830994,
-0.9837723970413208,
0.3117440342903137,
0.13109107315540314,
0.22568069398403168,
0.6320908665657043,
0.5106607675552368,
-0.32882052659988403,
-0.394013375043869,
-0.8126263618469238,
-0.7594307065010071,
0.8754815459251404,
0.17344771325588226,
-0.16872605681419373,
0.07259458303451538,
0.3079279959201813,
0.2841804027557373,
0.26777634024620056,
-0.9694184064865112,
-0.7237483263015747,
-0.08420953899621964,
-0.48529788851737976,
-0.4623816907405853,
-0.3972408175468445,
0.29650774598121643,
-0.5044066309928894,
0.6001644730567932,
-0.07661265879869461,
-0.054074034094810486,
0.20796704292297363,
-0.1838020235300064,
0.0020621989388018847,
0.19018271565437317,
0.6504855751991272,
0.6531817317008972,
-0.03043641895055771,
0.4300993084907532,
0.6260790228843689,
-0.567026674747467,
0.09218079596757889,
-0.06736328452825546,
0.3979925215244293,
0.18449704349040985,
0.2007891684770584,
0.6378074884414673,
0.2455391138792038,
-0.8228159546852112,
0.6661509871482849,
-0.12294483929872513,
-0.14754770696163177,
-0.4910617768764496,
-0.23809145390987396,
-0.08451476693153381,
-0.04196812957525253,
0.4220885634422302,
0.09544899314641953,
0.4045310914516449,
-0.5277644991874695,
0.18634073436260223,
-0.05881479009985924,
-0.13804475963115692,
-0.27545085549354553,
0.22492866218090057,
-0.3340594172477722,
0.061408329755067825,
-0.09640387445688248,
-0.5431877970695496,
-0.5265623331069946,
0.9153363108634949,
0.5296085476875305,
0.16316403448581696,
-0.3907303512096405,
0.2608678936958313,
0.5355189442634583,
0.5231226086616516,
-0.5437474250793457,
0.7069005966186523,
-0.03069177083671093,
-0.6164599657058716,
-0.2776147723197937,
-0.6748418211936951,
-0.5391914248466492,
-0.12494802474975586,
-0.5517033338546753,
0.7155994772911072,
-0.5794118642807007,
0.16165272891521454,
0.1434101015329361,
0.07660403847694397,
-0.894073486328125,
0.22670350968837738,
0.10190965235233307,
1.0300266742706299,
-1.3630379438400269,
1.0749387741088867,
0.6184830069541931,
-0.25508493185043335,
-0.6490954756736755,
-0.49086835980415344,
0.24792124330997467,
-0.9462562799453735,
0.771721363067627,
-0.14252375066280365,
-0.7161563634872437,
-0.20904849469661713,
-0.151791512966156,
-1.0775407552719116,
1.0218236446380615,
0.4023486077785492,
-0.2048383355140686,
-0.14822795987129211,
0.6776295900344849,
0.8478900194168091,
-0.46042871475219727,
0.3959452509880066,
0.6636711359024048,
0.49213048815727234,
0.5586947798728943,
-1.139644742012024,
-0.2033344805240631,
-0.31447726488113403,
-0.10529980063438416,
0.07955590635538101,
-0.3343726098537445,
1.2879494428634644,
-0.311674565076828,
-0.17056262493133545,
0.11971554160118103,
0.6941908597946167,
0.0013564744731411338,
0.5274139642715454,
0.5933165550231934,
0.4916185736656189,
0.9871335625648499,
-0.06057038903236389,
0.36349815130233765,
-0.29244229197502136,
0.4844371974468231,
1.400900959968567,
0.08754972368478775,
0.6604211926460266,
0.5002234578132629,
-0.252142071723938,
0.4250209927558899,
0.6509092450141907,
0.12090200930833817,
0.39449965953826904,
0.3893948793411255,
-0.3474491238594055,
0.09843600541353226,
-0.16720564663410187,
-0.45185866951942444,
0.4778151214122772,
1.0349884033203125,
-0.18050777912139893,
-0.48487651348114014,
0.05981442332267761,
-0.20801518857479095,
-0.01049228198826313,
-0.6132985353469849,
0.7765153050422668,
-0.32949724793434143,
-0.38157984614372253,
0.5663345456123352,
0.0957985669374466,
0.6335034966468811,
-0.6001598834991455,
0.07487337291240692,
-0.013799000531435013,
0.11824075132608414,
-0.4445576071739197,
-1.0067592859268188,
0.6233338713645935,
-0.05519133806228638,
-0.018025623634457588,
-0.06595517694950104,
0.6285676956176758,
-0.5387502312660217,
-0.7942820191383362,
0.44219866394996643,
0.8957109451293945,
0.6331273913383484,
-0.14987866580486298,
-0.8313061594963074,
-0.09705160558223724,
0.07279405742883682,
0.21309609711170197,
-0.09986231476068497,
0.8250525593757629,
-0.04696804657578468,
0.9203143119812012,
0.47460898756980896,
0.43903735280036926,
0.7878146767616272,
0.22250136733055115,
0.8736355900764465,
-0.5830216407775879,
-0.7810593843460083,
-0.5326528549194336,
0.15016207098960876,
0.34579893946647644,
-0.33435219526290894,
0.34291064739227295,
0.6940145492553711,
0.5907271504402161,
0.032248903065919876,
0.49817517399787903,
-0.025434505194425583,
0.4961235523223877,
-0.2248411774635315,
0.2430228739976883,
-0.7811217308044434,
0.25004279613494873,
-0.32591134309768677,
-0.8350938558578491,
-0.660462498664856,
0.3148837685585022,
0.1980888992547989,
-0.20334866642951965,
1.0401417016983032,
1.2784847021102905,
-0.3816017806529999,
0.14692260324954987,
0.29651668667793274,
-0.07359140366315842,
-0.06979173421859741,
0.6821506023406982,
0.5477856397628784,
-0.3888818323612213,
0.9154735207557678,
-0.5986325144767761,
-0.4216465353965759,
0.14699819684028625,
-0.7608519196510315,
-0.6878343820571899,
-0.9793131351470947,
0.19294069707393646,
-0.16099627315998077,
-0.08054722845554352,
1.227510929107666,
0.2824738621711731,
-0.9650143980979919,
-0.36223307251930237,
-0.3915223777294159,
0.15119126439094543,
-0.2108856588602066,
-0.13119648396968842,
0.6568459272384644,
-0.6124087572097778,
-0.8083635568618774,
0.5195188522338867,
0.016343750059604645,
0.23063696920871735,
-0.4388188123703003,
-0.2183685004711151,
0.015955546870827675,
0.07656102627515793,
0.44286394119262695,
0.49728986620903015,
-0.8200511336326599,
0.11532939225435257,
-0.05760318785905838,
-0.17481572926044464,
0.12405775487422943,
0.9043559432029724,
-0.7925472259521484,
0.6079038977622986,
0.6078330278396606,
0.466035395860672,
0.3619321286678314,
-0.3410366177558899,
0.01171068288385868,
-0.9866211414337158,
0.5465516448020935,
-0.017120907083153725,
0.7245172262191772,
0.07087858766317368,
-0.32293015718460083,
0.3935670852661133,
0.1582956314086914,
-0.21329468488693237,
-0.4521285891532898,
0.15680687129497528,
-1.212375521659851,
-0.20573675632476807,
1.000435471534729,
0.057204995304346085,
0.06096470728516579,
-0.6758117079734802,
-0.4772466719150543,
0.014771840535104275,
-0.3970756232738495,
0.48227035999298096,
0.6793537139892578,
0.013439381495118141,
0.011967473663389683,
-0.30264151096343994,
0.7282392382621765,
0.5626574754714966,
-0.6622198224067688,
0.1008986160159111,
0.47595125436782837,
-0.035439856350421906,
0.31037265062332153,
0.6930386424064636,
-0.2745593190193176,
0.4240667521953583,
-0.12553822994232178,
0.06718234717845917,
0.030248554423451424,
-1.1571030616760254,
-0.6038668751716614,
0.47047802805900574,
0.16831594705581665,
0.1758296638727188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07792v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07792v1
|
Nostra Domina at EvaLatin 2024: Improving Latin Polarity Detection through Data Augmentation
| 2024-04-11T14:35:23 | 2024-04-11T14:35:23 |
Stephen Bothwell, Abigail Swenor, David Chiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper describes submissions from the team Nostra Domina to the EvaLatin
2024 shared task of emotion polarity detection. Given the low-resource
environment of Latin and the complexity of sentiment in rhetorical genres like
poetry, we augmented the available data through automatic polarity annotation.
We present two methods for doing so on the basis of the $k$-means algorithm,
and we employ a variety of Latin large language models (LLMs) in a neural
architecture to better capture the underlying contextual sentiment
representations. Our best approach achieved the second highest macro-averaged
Macro-$F_1$ score on the shared task's test set.
|
[
-0.7179579138755798,
-0.28048446774482727,
0.6102543473243713,
0.33294275403022766,
-0.6293693780899048,
0.25186941027641296,
-0.28324422240257263,
-0.6691723465919495,
0.8335866928100586,
0.4611995220184326,
-0.6822518706321716,
-0.9111058115959167,
-0.5918614268302917,
0.3946005403995514,
-0.2572583854198456,
1.2816635370254517,
-0.05401414632797241,
0.3255826234817505,
-0.29584717750549316,
-0.6938316822052002,
-0.14246030151844025,
-0.5627154111862183,
-0.3454284071922302,
-0.4070894122123718,
0.8073074221611023,
0.5596672892570496,
0.3346872925758362,
-0.07910208404064178,
0.4505102038383484,
0.25613313913345337,
0.03144901245832443,
0.13113363087177277,
-0.25262942910194397,
0.4590522050857544,
-0.04264010861515999,
-0.6376041769981384,
-0.9371211528778076,
0.18670690059661865,
0.4305926263332367,
0.31899797916412354,
0.4786604344844818,
0.06467636674642563,
-0.393362432718277,
0.7965593338012695,
-0.36986008286476135,
0.26306936144828796,
-0.4109099209308624,
0.02186557650566101,
-0.09514790773391724,
-0.32537057995796204,
-0.2927781641483307,
-0.27488359808921814,
-0.09395705908536911,
-0.2948874831199646,
0.10459138453006744,
0.07458566874265671,
0.5750089883804321,
0.4362984001636505,
-0.6311575174331665,
-0.02548530511558056,
-0.6075848340988159,
0.95525062084198,
-0.5803647637367249,
0.26177313923835754,
0.10389333963394165,
-0.04255830869078636,
0.1621425896883011,
-0.19310809671878815,
-0.606631875038147,
-0.03232559934258461,
0.1263553649187088,
0.2994444966316223,
-0.39971181750297546,
-0.04505832493305206,
0.09156797081232071,
0.1623753309249878,
-0.318427711725235,
-0.1601439118385315,
-0.2561247646808624,
0.12699884176254272,
0.8230584859848022,
0.11057356745004654,
0.4331187307834625,
-0.2513152062892914,
-0.3750169575214386,
-0.025216979905962944,
-0.7147666811943054,
-0.09932802617549896,
0.8261417746543884,
0.10941149294376373,
-0.3606274724006653,
0.4731042981147766,
-0.1962675154209137,
0.4117266535758972,
-0.07295539975166321,
0.5820052027702332,
0.5164307951927185,
-0.34747400879859924,
0.05100487172603607,
-0.0539100244641304,
0.6575515866279602,
0.613142192363739,
-0.032035354524850845,
0.10711905360221863,
-0.34856709837913513,
0.4328157603740692,
0.2695077061653137,
-0.5950632691383362,
-0.18907958269119263,
0.5094688534736633,
-0.10391788184642792,
-0.4384392499923706,
0.01578844152390957,
-1.2423113584518433,
-0.5948201417922974,
-0.8026976585388184,
-0.04669906198978424,
-0.3812655210494995,
-0.2987269163131714,
0.063423752784729,
-0.17623719573020935,
0.23265770077705383,
0.5319840908050537,
-0.5410342216491699,
0.3739641010761261,
0.9677783250808716,
0.6468483209609985,
-0.27902787923812866,
0.06977000832557678,
-0.629815399646759,
-0.631543755531311,
-0.13159669935703278,
1.1704212427139282,
-0.5964369177818298,
-0.09292761236429214,
-0.1475718766450882,
0.06037016585469246,
-0.1502232700586319,
-0.4145638942718506,
0.8711686134338379,
-0.49832475185394287,
0.258165568113327,
-0.42221391201019287,
-0.4266488552093506,
-0.26017406582832336,
0.16224370896816254,
-0.7072798609733582,
1.1321920156478882,
0.3761482536792755,
-0.910446286201477,
0.05491146072745323,
-0.6738282442092896,
-0.20312485098838806,
0.24779556691646576,
-0.08317099511623383,
-0.5086376070976257,
0.415274441242218,
0.05542219430208206,
0.282204270362854,
-0.159559965133667,
0.24495746195316315,
-0.5361694693565369,
-0.13705696165561676,
0.42203831672668457,
0.039211466908454895,
0.7087526917457581,
-0.061408329755067825,
-0.814530074596405,
0.35414260625839233,
-0.6260265111923218,
-0.22717802226543427,
-0.08563882857561111,
0.11290407180786133,
-0.2732424736022949,
-0.22155936062335968,
0.3070492446422577,
0.3432803452014923,
0.3432757556438446,
-0.8615000247955322,
0.1415318101644516,
-0.5626423358917236,
0.2611903250217438,
0.7799127697944641,
-0.12500402331352234,
0.6639319062232971,
-0.07939908653497696,
0.9016446471214294,
-0.06329784542322159,
0.13659046590328217,
0.1763097643852234,
-0.643181562423706,
-0.9626821279525757,
-0.28489798307418823,
0.22190941870212555,
0.6548264622688293,
-0.622971773147583,
0.5162064433097839,
-0.2240218073129654,
-0.5174804925918579,
-0.6441689133644104,
0.25301361083984375,
0.16696730256080627,
0.451963871717453,
0.49311643838882446,
-0.31602248549461365,
-0.9302957057952881,
-0.9806967377662659,
-0.020543619990348816,
-0.12032751739025116,
0.25620824098587036,
0.3140037953853607,
0.6677743196487427,
-0.3352026641368866,
0.5560626983642578,
-0.26706111431121826,
-0.10402839630842209,
-0.4579327404499054,
0.6698625087738037,
0.1952003538608551,
0.20264820754528046,
0.7579033374786377,
-0.7726365327835083,
-0.7975020408630371,
0.19684836268424988,
-0.5776421427726746,
-0.5280243158340454,
0.33995819091796875,
-0.16634395718574524,
0.4605511724948883,
0.16071449220180511,
-0.4236346185207367,
0.3557555377483368,
0.6718383431434631,
-0.568254292011261,
0.38356897234916687,
0.13880805671215057,
0.39680442214012146,
-0.763071596622467,
-0.0863722488284111,
0.15052686631679535,
-0.3987899422645569,
-0.8969734311103821,
-0.20343902707099915,
0.18052630126476288,
-0.025601087138056755,
-0.4718005359172821,
0.4627155363559723,
-0.2851087152957916,
0.012880200520157814,
-0.6321110129356384,
0.2077811360359192,
0.2682186961174011,
0.48712944984436035,
0.09197348356246948,
0.6650428771972656,
0.6428310871124268,
0.08437557518482208,
0.5995074510574341,
0.06944966316223145,
0.079926997423172,
1.1309690475463867,
-0.5355220437049866,
0.15132267773151398,
-0.6113885045051575,
0.3138609528541565,
-1.0604145526885986,
-0.0797574445605278,
0.3224695920944214,
-0.6083975434303284,
0.1855657994747162,
-0.18429134786128998,
-0.23277786374092102,
-0.31299805641174316,
-0.5981112718582153,
0.59059077501297,
0.35986796021461487,
-0.3751201629638672,
0.8283264636993408,
0.3742750585079193,
-0.4632629156112671,
-0.3420594334602356,
-0.289465993642807,
0.3428654968738556,
-0.4018213450908661,
-0.7240778207778931,
0.26785150170326233,
-0.1549687385559082,
-0.4148705303668976,
-0.14743058383464813,
0.24339090287685394,
0.1910768300294876,
-0.017784686759114265,
0.47209423780441284,
0.5687822699546814,
-0.05018894374370575,
0.15409815311431885,
0.11649850755929947,
-0.1364438682794571,
0.2482842057943344,
-0.034189485013484955,
0.7553710341453552,
-0.4118048846721649,
-0.14303651452064514,
-0.6606712341308594,
0.5576435923576355,
0.8094509243965149,
-0.3238452970981598,
0.6456264853477478,
0.5933164358139038,
-0.22893019020557404,
-0.18448840081691742,
-0.6129618883132935,
-0.1269656866788864,
-0.3809875249862671,
-0.049689847975969315,
0.10275470465421677,
-0.7187206745147705,
0.7417437434196472,
0.13998351991176605,
-0.36381465196609497,
0.4022606313228607,
0.44147467613220215,
-0.269065260887146,
1.0830296277999878,
0.5154415965080261,
-0.4982914626598358,
0.6012319922447205,
-0.4906012713909149,
0.505211591720581,
-1.0582990646362305,
-0.15277110040187836,
-0.4958800673484802,
-0.46988606452941895,
-0.3959890305995941,
-0.6913560032844543,
0.45246779918670654,
-0.49578654766082764,
0.23123453557491302,
0.4008095860481262,
-0.4151839315891266,
0.2692910432815552,
0.44426581263542175,
0.08857602626085281,
-0.0526457317173481,
-0.13229498267173767,
0.2716946005821228,
-0.2454974353313446,
-0.2717154622077942,
-0.28312841057777405,
1.2361350059509277,
0.31327974796295166,
0.07381736487150192,
-0.1417471468448639,
0.8623456954956055,
0.41302689909935,
0.756966769695282,
-0.8120432496070862,
0.556211531162262,
-0.11887943744659424,
-0.32663288712501526,
0.09307610988616943,
-0.15770207345485687,
-0.6143697500228882,
0.06157973036170006,
-0.25705087184906006,
-0.4697759449481964,
0.4057602882385254,
-0.018688328564167023,
-0.2677309215068817,
0.037080492824316025,
-0.4826463460922241,
0.740895688533783,
-0.17004193365573883,
-0.3888191282749176,
-0.14461666345596313,
-0.44830894470214844,
0.1994340568780899,
0.18857820332050323,
0.39162006974220276,
-0.27784162759780884,
-0.19435444474220276,
0.7676272988319397,
-0.11487577855587006,
0.8968072533607483,
-0.3809107542037964,
0.03680608794093132,
0.3743874728679657,
-0.14985239505767822,
0.7100759744644165,
0.15854468941688538,
-0.2488381415605545,
0.2266320437192917,
-0.4317465126514435,
-0.42421755194664,
-0.7257883548736572,
0.8003801703453064,
-0.637866199016571,
-0.3284762501716614,
-0.48751577734947205,
-0.47757279872894287,
-0.02134387195110321,
-0.25555217266082764,
0.14037491381168365,
0.43431031703948975,
-0.12188855558633804,
0.15997619926929474,
0.6552473902702332,
-0.032731544226408005,
0.2853778898715973,
0.38616204261779785,
0.07239662855863571,
-1.033074140548706,
0.980546772480011,
-0.0592569075524807,
0.003312707645818591,
0.11915669590234756,
0.02422158047556877,
-0.3990445137023926,
-0.4712376594543457,
-0.29617592692375183,
0.44628673791885376,
-0.5585969090461731,
-0.47686904668807983,
-0.9149550795555115,
0.2241932600736618,
-0.6653958559036255,
-0.31920647621154785,
-0.5857391357421875,
-0.4578898251056671,
-0.4122608006000519,
-0.4418937563896179,
0.6111646294593811,
0.6749898195266724,
-0.1370576024055481,
0.44217121601104736,
-0.4305523931980133,
0.1736103743314743,
0.07084248960018158,
0.08050436526536942,
-0.4641907811164856,
-0.4510360062122345,
-0.1382659673690796,
-0.11848174035549164,
-0.2740243077278137,
-1.1395999193191528,
0.8616978526115417,
0.05073412507772446,
0.19409340620040894,
0.4430701434612274,
0.16487611830234528,
0.17304429411888123,
-0.20384250581264496,
0.7862685322761536,
0.13859403133392334,
-1.077260971069336,
0.7463303804397583,
-0.6290397644042969,
0.10383423417806625,
0.6904995441436768,
0.41775187849998474,
-0.4599490761756897,
-0.8627320528030396,
-0.8145872950553894,
-0.9537948369979858,
0.5411224365234375,
0.3784884810447693,
0.11743680387735367,
0.005583773832768202,
0.2864534854888916,
0.14329630136489868,
0.3506462574005127,
-0.9559701085090637,
-0.4029403626918793,
-0.23036038875579834,
-0.6059648394584656,
-0.23932263255119324,
-0.3740842640399933,
-0.3100728690624237,
-0.6289231777191162,
0.7238788604736328,
-0.26340922713279724,
0.5019129514694214,
0.24575863778591156,
0.1499425768852234,
-0.28199729323387146,
0.4049830138683319,
0.8335989117622375,
0.2274576872587204,
-0.33435559272766113,
0.37302812933921814,
0.14934764802455902,
-0.2163059264421463,
0.061882104724645615,
0.155056431889534,
-0.21126675605773926,
0.2024119794368744,
0.3694418668746948,
1.065643072128296,
0.13829825818538666,
-0.6125947833061218,
0.7318039536476135,
-0.1317051202058792,
-0.236969992518425,
-0.6411557793617249,
-0.13443173468112946,
0.0003683187533169985,
0.37329748272895813,
0.15012608468532562,
0.1256101280450821,
0.31728002429008484,
-0.5217418074607849,
0.15503628551959991,
0.6577987670898438,
-0.7641436457633972,
-0.9284027218818665,
0.45942142605781555,
0.1980576366186142,
-0.28006601333618164,
0.016954295337200165,
-0.5525079965591431,
-1.220996618270874,
0.7911056280136108,
0.19074515998363495,
0.9735232591629028,
-0.31581395864486694,
0.6634925007820129,
0.378939688205719,
0.13921067118644714,
0.10516740381717682,
0.8285701274871826,
-0.09436596184968948,
-0.681315004825592,
-0.17759686708450317,
-0.5216257572174072,
-0.5075297951698303,
-0.07948705554008484,
-0.590747594833374,
0.49717721343040466,
-0.38709792494773865,
-0.19548462331295013,
-0.0881861075758934,
0.1318495124578476,
-0.60076504945755,
0.15282346308231354,
0.33267098665237427,
0.32490769028663635,
-1.3997395038604736,
0.5194913744926453,
0.8060160279273987,
-0.24592731893062592,
-0.15746566653251648,
-0.5622750520706177,
0.03865468129515648,
-0.47611498832702637,
0.7518070340156555,
0.3004639744758606,
-0.16699399054050446,
-0.34618422389030457,
-0.7272282242774963,
-0.6809021830558777,
0.9079532623291016,
0.2078172266483307,
-0.21874037384986877,
0.5426039099693298,
0.2620113790035248,
1.0531038045883179,
-0.843116044998169,
0.36264586448669434,
0.5757569670677185,
0.7284382581710815,
-0.0775885283946991,
-0.21751481294631958,
-0.10915020108222961,
-0.5889690518379211,
-0.4163530170917511,
0.348626971244812,
-0.6275044083595276,
0.9335103631019592,
0.363319993019104,
-0.13801206648349762,
-0.237486332654953,
0.7149588465690613,
-0.035191114991903305,
0.8104296922683716,
0.5837603211402893,
0.8596149682998657,
0.6100727915763855,
-0.07381515204906464,
0.8234206438064575,
-0.5947738885879517,
0.22349300980567932,
1.118041753768921,
-0.4252818822860718,
0.7561146020889282,
0.66801518201828,
-0.08657000213861465,
0.8461222052574158,
0.3626728355884552,
0.09183309972286224,
0.24539288878440857,
-0.02450631372630596,
-0.7713606357574463,
-0.3452729284763336,
-0.5445258021354675,
-0.09054411947727203,
0.337530255317688,
0.33290717005729675,
-0.34961003065109253,
-0.09069449454545975,
0.2839949429035187,
0.05396406725049019,
0.1531076282262802,
-0.21289296448230743,
0.6440149545669556,
0.07431663572788239,
-0.7406367659568787,
0.37652021646499634,
-0.16316482424736023,
0.6423807144165039,
0.18779630959033966,
0.09042221307754517,
-0.4196697771549225,
-0.19139142334461212,
-0.3170321583747864,
-0.5425166487693787,
0.4316447973251343,
0.1911754459142685,
-0.12314946204423904,
-0.4418652355670929,
0.8150441646575928,
-0.4267585873603821,
-0.8024110794067383,
0.8056821227073669,
0.30986490845680237,
-0.01765906997025013,
-0.3355599045753479,
-0.4331420958042145,
0.23956960439682007,
-0.09486736357212067,
-0.12124911695718765,
0.14813421666622162,
0.46821534633636475,
0.13809716701507568,
0.4047490358352661,
0.36362341046333313,
0.4187542796134949,
0.09647643566131592,
0.3324595093727112,
1.1734116077423096,
-0.5527995228767395,
-0.1998715102672577,
-0.6723887324333191,
0.624137818813324,
-0.3723853528499603,
-0.13519461452960968,
0.6339167952537537,
0.3789089620113373,
0.4513130486011505,
-0.05798115208745003,
0.5796838402748108,
0.14570249617099762,
0.34058821201324463,
-0.08937060832977295,
0.29267725348472595,
-0.5748090147972107,
0.10374573618173599,
-0.3388819992542267,
-0.9124888181686401,
-0.37985292077064514,
0.3253866732120514,
-0.7337213754653931,
-0.5022525787353516,
0.7303824424743652,
0.8429971933364868,
0.014400108717381954,
0.3173401653766632,
0.08181942999362946,
0.016198663040995598,
0.16100159287452698,
0.5424211025238037,
0.7771435379981995,
-0.6025123596191406,
0.02055184170603752,
-0.6143723130226135,
-0.32341331243515015,
-0.3486473560333252,
-0.752903401851654,
-0.821424126625061,
-0.5966833233833313,
-0.6785104870796204,
-0.3050503730773926,
-0.25692176818847656,
1.083351731300354,
0.29735422134399414,
-1.1508536338806152,
-0.04753383621573448,
-0.34539487957954407,
0.4227502942085266,
0.148864284157753,
-0.26600736379623413,
0.02041035331785679,
-0.27409103512763977,
-0.9892758727073669,
0.4329838752746582,
0.6860501766204834,
-0.00878384429961443,
-0.29004979133605957,
0.01843859814107418,
-0.16979536414146423,
0.24500270187854767,
0.5283518433570862,
0.11379018425941467,
-0.3375645577907562,
-0.4269375503063202,
0.08410260826349258,
0.12926797568798065,
0.41411978006362915,
0.8840073347091675,
-0.4977927803993225,
0.3502109944820404,
0.7479872703552246,
0.4514724314212799,
0.1873706877231598,
0.17893148958683014,
0.4971303641796112,
-0.5025978088378906,
0.286087304353714,
0.6383215188980103,
0.5058174133300781,
0.541199803352356,
-0.5216938853263855,
0.4216795563697815,
0.49770388007164,
-0.576552152633667,
-0.8675731420516968,
0.25141796469688416,
-1.2968006134033203,
0.1752389669418335,
1.1254138946533203,
-0.12565648555755615,
-0.680012583732605,
-0.23582422733306885,
-0.2112555056810379,
0.07099590450525284,
-0.6774036884307861,
0.7740322947502136,
0.6922231316566467,
-0.4223122000694275,
-0.25604626536369324,
-0.4345698654651642,
0.4621586501598358,
0.7968611717224121,
-0.9879798889160156,
-0.05108118802309036,
0.5627233386039734,
0.039584457874298096,
0.2699246406555176,
0.6394205689430237,
-0.10951240360736847,
0.2220749855041504,
-0.37881290912628174,
0.3303416073322296,
0.3313148617744446,
-0.6380771994590759,
-0.689970850944519,
0.11332538723945618,
-0.17568254470825195,
0.16349534690380096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07775v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07775v1
|
Discourse-Aware In-Context Learning for Temporal Expression Normalization
| 2024-04-11T14:13:44 | 2024-04-11T14:13:44 |
Akash Kumar Gautam, Lukas Lange, Jannik Strötgen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Temporal expression (TE) normalization is a well-studied problem. However,
the predominately used rule-based systems are highly restricted to specific
settings, and upcoming machine learning approaches suffer from a lack of
labeled data. In this work, we explore the feasibility of proprietary and
open-source large language models (LLMs) for TE normalization using in-context
learning to inject task, document, and example information into the model. We
explore various sample selection strategies to retrieve the most relevant set
of examples. By using a window-based prompt design approach, we can perform TE
normalization across sentences, while leveraging the LLM knowledge without
training the model. Our experiments show competitive results to models designed
for this task. In particular, our method achieves large performance
improvements for non-standard settings by dynamically including relevant
examples during inference.
|
[
0.23182931542396545,
-0.831325352191925,
0.7613082528114319,
0.26972654461860657,
-0.48950761556625366,
-0.10630900412797928,
-0.36643099784851074,
-0.319903165102005,
-0.12845881283283234,
0.3248611092567444,
-0.36053234338760376,
-0.6999266147613525,
-0.4091945290565491,
0.20942622423171997,
-0.17314141988754272,
0.7283807396888733,
-0.0456886887550354,
0.08316852152347565,
-0.04292777180671692,
-0.2601500451564789,
-0.46392276883125305,
-0.29297778010368347,
-0.6669048070907593,
-0.2466854602098465,
0.24743780493736267,
0.4436430037021637,
0.14234447479248047,
0.5856220722198486,
-0.14420141279697418,
0.26532256603240967,
-0.3216031789779663,
0.22251012921333313,
-0.4921666979789734,
0.3107704222202301,
-0.08059174567461014,
-0.32852187752723694,
-0.23262973129749298,
0.09432481229305267,
0.9958863854408264,
0.9163248538970947,
-0.018784411251544952,
0.2550458312034607,
0.11034277826547623,
0.05343740060925484,
-0.5963534712791443,
0.5194565057754517,
-0.6917304992675781,
0.29762399196624756,
-0.09444563835859299,
-0.17842963337898254,
-0.65949547290802,
-0.6955434083938599,
0.1460609883069992,
-0.7196269035339355,
-0.13294856250286102,
0.09570052474737167,
0.8955549001693726,
0.12091880291700363,
-0.793897271156311,
-0.004516554996371269,
-0.7106562852859497,
0.8926565647125244,
-0.9537764191627502,
0.20308467745780945,
0.010558976791799068,
0.4213581085205078,
-0.029767554253339767,
-0.8493254780769348,
-0.3679341971874237,
-0.20425525307655334,
-0.29136013984680176,
0.07744959741830826,
-0.2644405961036682,
0.06195429340004921,
0.5743706226348877,
0.16610461473464966,
-0.37603628635406494,
0.3458273112773895,
-0.08521588146686554,
0.17054231464862823,
0.024070126935839653,
0.23542751371860504,
0.1456536203622818,
-0.19665218889713287,
-0.38234785199165344,
0.32136163115501404,
-0.6964319944381714,
0.25082048773765564,
-0.19638583064079285,
0.48534128069877625,
-0.08085641264915466,
0.5123569965362549,
-0.21478328108787537,
0.8516678214073181,
0.09238690882921219,
-0.20512747764587402,
0.16917851567268372,
0.02474469132721424,
-0.6787476539611816,
-0.21623629331588745,
0.4779450595378876,
0.3092567026615143,
0.09210871160030365,
-0.44029268622398376,
-0.2991505265235901,
-0.10477019846439362,
-0.18249568343162537,
-1.0458614826202393,
0.4679003357887268,
-0.08383084088563919,
-0.38036221265792847,
-0.05233752354979515,
-0.08670145273208618,
-0.7046553492546082,
-0.2273506373167038,
-0.5872789025306702,
0.36839383840560913,
-0.37689176201820374,
0.05884832888841629,
0.018281986936926842,
-0.08867410570383072,
0.3069216012954712,
0.49655988812446594,
-0.3915507197380066,
0.31966787576675415,
0.4126332700252533,
0.6968916058540344,
-0.07934514433145523,
0.10577353835105896,
-1.019687294960022,
0.5086929202079773,
-0.3952879011631012,
0.4281923472881317,
-0.7260175943374634,
-0.43686893582344055,
0.11199324578046799,
0.13735508918762207,
-0.10003357380628586,
-0.5624029040336609,
0.44855982065200806,
-0.7107919454574585,
0.6110354661941528,
-0.002335415920242667,
-0.8261055946350098,
-0.0966096743941307,
0.1134393960237503,
-0.3641616106033325,
0.9571123719215393,
0.23874478042125702,
-0.6314842104911804,
0.3639872670173645,
-0.8942760825157166,
-0.5111828446388245,
0.18304885923862457,
-0.28604191541671753,
-0.36273592710494995,
0.259102463722229,
0.3178921937942505,
0.6052006483078003,
-0.21356737613677979,
0.6644312143325806,
-0.126679465174675,
-0.5028654932975769,
0.06351232528686523,
-0.29286280274391174,
0.9052901864051819,
0.36171725392341614,
-0.49097156524658203,
0.24444003403186798,
-0.6626785397529602,
-0.09811826795339584,
-0.001260761870071292,
-0.3636063039302826,
-0.3510861396789551,
-0.2822423577308655,
0.05062335357069969,
0.3134618103504181,
0.09418687224388123,
-0.7052816152572632,
0.2258877456188202,
-0.48361682891845703,
0.559576690196991,
0.8071282505989075,
0.16722705960273743,
0.5399945378303528,
-0.24435749650001526,
0.5619620084762573,
0.1071082055568695,
0.08188009262084961,
-0.34237217903137207,
-0.29117628931999207,
-0.5141394138336182,
-0.45941871404647827,
0.305518239736557,
0.6187224388122559,
-0.7656377553939819,
0.4559905230998993,
-0.432770699262619,
-0.2604010999202728,
-0.23645323514938354,
-0.20150406658649445,
0.38133955001831055,
1.2495036125183105,
0.4110304117202759,
0.11595308035612106,
-0.3355654180049896,
-0.9657461643218994,
-0.34580957889556885,
0.20746038854122162,
-0.47466081380844116,
0.5296241044998169,
0.06404624134302139,
-0.18940940499305725,
1.1505404710769653,
-0.42503267526626587,
-0.022486457601189613,
-0.11491426825523376,
0.3769950270652771,
0.1940881311893463,
0.12627843022346497,
0.4923505187034607,
-0.5160903334617615,
-0.39337271451950073,
-0.17917639017105103,
-0.827659010887146,
-0.5146970748901367,
-0.20469257235527039,
0.3063637912273407,
0.30088621377944946,
0.8663692474365234,
-0.17058998346328735,
0.4850102663040161,
0.22855854034423828,
-0.34424710273742676,
0.04395408555865288,
-0.14793549478054047,
0.04319251328706741,
-1.3813984394073486,
0.07666759938001633,
0.3181557059288025,
-0.5859968066215515,
-0.5784236192703247,
-0.11578791588544846,
0.24660390615463257,
-0.44034069776535034,
-0.7645593285560608,
0.7828315496444702,
-0.45189711451530457,
-0.005859917029738426,
-0.048913683742284775,
0.17674244940280914,
0.05241989344358444,
0.558057963848114,
0.04493173211812973,
0.6789344549179077,
0.3479095995426178,
-0.6107465028762817,
-0.1711525171995163,
-0.09734391421079636,
-0.44988712668418884,
0.39181581139564514,
-0.6941481232643127,
0.11160426586866379,
-0.341447114944458,
0.4436550438404083,
-0.753139078617096,
-0.1803676187992096,
0.08405014127492905,
0.013389128260314465,
0.36654382944107056,
-0.21276430785655975,
-0.6880024075508118,
0.2760547697544098,
-0.10400507599115372,
0.37761035561561584,
0.6491854786872864,
-0.6440510749816895,
0.8297968506813049,
0.3681090176105499,
-0.09034734964370728,
-0.4616963863372803,
-0.5709197521209717,
0.16789014637470245,
-0.5452994108200073,
-0.4824480712413788,
0.688996434211731,
0.15164057910442352,
-0.397029846906662,
-0.21560326218605042,
-0.014796338975429535,
0.04112542048096657,
0.1995718628168106,
0.17822322249412537,
0.24506957828998566,
-0.11063523590564728,
0.5015525817871094,
0.460114449262619,
0.16621313989162445,
-0.2783382833003998,
-0.2942138612270355,
0.2589203715324402,
-0.15769393742084503,
-0.10000793635845184,
-0.6802802085876465,
0.6285033822059631,
0.4953871965408325,
-0.16576455533504486,
0.5685006976127625,
0.4054897129535675,
-0.716031551361084,
-0.34803128242492676,
-0.42687711119651794,
-0.24681095778942108,
-0.46807971596717834,
0.028218716382980347,
-0.18402795493602753,
-1.380853295326233,
0.21335183084011078,
-0.4984792172908783,
0.19332024455070496,
0.15755514800548553,
0.360899418592453,
-0.04780511185526848,
0.7811089754104614,
0.6635627746582031,
0.10879391431808472,
0.8427035808563232,
-0.009395252913236618,
0.17853064835071564,
-0.6937090754508972,
-0.020310990512371063,
-0.36423590779304504,
-0.3899969458580017,
-0.48410555720329285,
-0.35257723927497864,
0.6758447885513306,
-0.12337783724069595,
-0.5470758676528931,
0.060425691306591034,
-0.29257649183273315,
0.5334444642066956,
0.38116389513015747,
0.2102910578250885,
0.37089237570762634,
-0.18150991201400757,
-0.24186846613883972,
-0.17759041488170624,
-0.5981598496437073,
-0.6379419565200806,
0.7814355492591858,
0.24481722712516785,
0.5622045993804932,
-0.006882732734084129,
0.4922693967819214,
0.16156113147735596,
0.45330193638801575,
-0.642540693283081,
0.674044668674469,
-0.2708483934402466,
-0.1878417283296585,
-0.3635852038860321,
-0.53719162940979,
-1.027684211730957,
-0.09262756258249283,
-0.10172038525342941,
-0.9121142625808716,
0.1950061023235321,
-0.10169894993305206,
-0.5137978792190552,
0.1995222568511963,
-0.8699760437011719,
0.7926549911499023,
0.11317741870880127,
-0.24019253253936768,
0.0381740964949131,
-0.8166112899780273,
0.10360676050186157,
0.04943861812353134,
0.2663821876049042,
-0.11699945479631424,
-0.36169469356536865,
0.4854758381843567,
-0.12279874831438065,
1.2904677391052246,
-0.33586353063583374,
0.1313529908657074,
0.1718970686197281,
0.03142706677317619,
0.499634325504303,
0.22864605486392975,
-0.09068610519170761,
-0.2092818021774292,
-0.32561540603637695,
-0.39194145798683167,
-0.6824910640716553,
0.6402642726898193,
-0.5285373330116272,
-0.6158592700958252,
-0.2604793906211853,
-0.556065022945404,
-0.39016833901405334,
0.13576683402061462,
0.26292726397514343,
0.4746350049972534,
-0.3608936667442322,
0.3376566171646118,
0.8828129768371582,
-0.248869851231575,
0.7396777272224426,
0.6904593110084534,
-0.1659732162952423,
-0.03762997314333916,
0.48291125893592834,
0.1765519678592682,
0.03482179343700409,
0.7315488457679749,
0.42929089069366455,
-0.19355382025241852,
-0.39274442195892334,
-0.2860320806503296,
0.15567518770694733,
-0.6701553463935852,
-0.2340690940618515,
-0.6809335947036743,
0.0345468632876873,
-0.563525378704071,
-0.11864093691110611,
0.03140903264284134,
-0.6327430009841919,
-0.6532855033874512,
-0.10565918684005737,
0.2671622633934021,
0.4330722987651825,
0.4637487530708313,
0.2626650333404541,
-0.6811805963516235,
0.24750705063343048,
0.44898006319999695,
0.23559162020683289,
-0.2500409781932831,
-0.6731081008911133,
-0.08974238485097885,
-0.28766965866088867,
-0.31586071848869324,
-0.9365265965461731,
0.332381010055542,
0.28254327178001404,
0.38221243023872375,
0.424780011177063,
0.08614318817853928,
0.33028560876846313,
-0.6161842346191406,
0.9298563003540039,
-0.20756398141384125,
-1.1260349750518799,
0.7225713133811951,
-0.4861348867416382,
0.4779796600341797,
0.21051660180091858,
0.3757295608520508,
-0.7734375,
-0.3373734652996063,
-0.5907182097434998,
-0.7334116697311401,
0.43897393345832825,
-0.17989441752433777,
0.11513666063547134,
-0.14061877131462097,
0.5320172905921936,
0.1885884702205658,
0.1990516632795334,
-0.7168794274330139,
0.1883261799812317,
0.020517412573099136,
-0.20446477830410004,
0.08247387409210205,
-0.013563486747443676,
-0.20059344172477722,
-0.271424800157547,
0.4066713750362396,
-0.3787529766559601,
0.1597047746181488,
0.06945259869098663,
-0.27044621109962463,
0.08724915236234665,
0.6456221342086792,
0.4967452585697174,
0.6639218330383301,
-0.020393287762999535,
-0.11444666981697083,
0.42927318811416626,
0.21341794729232788,
0.03068518079817295,
0.19912491738796234,
-0.4337141811847687,
0.11351200193166733,
0.035062503069639206,
0.700446605682373,
0.48512017726898193,
-0.7017252445220947,
0.556663453578949,
-0.18283231556415558,
0.09883508086204529,
-0.3189052641391754,
-0.16602317988872528,
0.09987438470125198,
0.4164690375328064,
0.19834280014038086,
-0.23900671303272247,
0.18969382345676422,
-0.49577826261520386,
0.017741478979587555,
0.3470993936061859,
-0.32491084933280945,
-0.17218735814094543,
0.6262232065200806,
-0.005855455528944731,
-0.2709326446056366,
0.6034303307533264,
-0.27614203095436096,
-0.06278691440820694,
0.4576568305492401,
0.6242037415504456,
0.9489644765853882,
-0.18806856870651245,
0.12101897597312927,
0.14674976468086243,
0.0006313291960395873,
0.061393462121486664,
0.3279597759246826,
0.028705259785056114,
-0.41948455572128296,
-0.546355128288269,
-0.33801788091659546,
-0.4871777892112732,
0.16724659502506256,
-0.49825364351272583,
0.5613499283790588,
-0.5561031699180603,
-0.2599308490753174,
-0.23821617662906647,
-0.2807861268520355,
-0.6686666011810303,
0.18618930876255035,
0.023260150104761124,
0.9359415769577026,
-0.9357291460037231,
1.0349316596984863,
0.5936371088027954,
-0.16630010306835175,
-0.6735543608665466,
0.21678367257118225,
-0.09186658263206482,
-0.40245321393013,
0.6086480021476746,
0.2268071323633194,
-0.07421187311410904,
-0.2241220772266388,
-0.5559848546981812,
-0.5113674998283386,
1.3280266523361206,
0.8511418104171753,
-0.4299715757369995,
-0.3816624581813812,
-0.20782676339149475,
0.6536944508552551,
-0.7857531905174255,
0.1486281007528305,
0.37416356801986694,
0.36909961700439453,
-0.10264387726783752,
-0.7135469913482666,
0.1835455596446991,
-0.19472062587738037,
0.3827154338359833,
0.13386686146259308,
-0.5866602659225464,
0.8391991257667542,
0.1170230507850647,
-0.542953372001648,
-0.1264103651046753,
0.8184697031974792,
-0.0024964031763374805,
0.44117817282676697,
0.5414416193962097,
0.48787814378738403,
0.8104511499404907,
-0.009835354052484035,
0.8921135067939758,
-0.1818663626909256,
-0.08443739265203476,
1.457711100578308,
-0.299063503742218,
0.6438894867897034,
0.49203941226005554,
0.35089772939682007,
0.4791848063468933,
0.6614229083061218,
0.25932154059410095,
0.29953625798225403,
0.29495710134506226,
-0.5782322883605957,
-0.10783734172582626,
-0.5073235630989075,
-0.06589193642139435,
0.3259859085083008,
0.473585844039917,
-0.49639585614204407,
-0.4444163143634796,
0.16373972594738007,
0.3287975788116455,
0.3271538317203522,
-0.27047109603881836,
0.9000355005264282,
-0.031114919111132622,
-0.5576896667480469,
0.42069241404533386,
0.14189928770065308,
0.6869102120399475,
-0.47300341725349426,
-0.09690806269645691,
-0.17447882890701294,
-0.1583830714225769,
0.02186787873506546,
-0.4248179793357849,
0.41297468543052673,
0.15010659396648407,
-0.04551112279295921,
-0.5010985732078552,
0.5505537390708923,
-0.3906306028366089,
-0.3525380492210388,
0.18818481266498566,
0.604993999004364,
-0.09179174154996872,
0.08841552585363388,
-0.2707400321960449,
-0.3119312524795532,
-0.23924221098423004,
-0.3085399270057678,
0.4515402913093567,
0.7888966798782349,
-0.4651587903499603,
0.44968777894973755,
0.1043180599808693,
-0.13367190957069397,
-0.0577995590865612,
0.13306912779808044,
1.021651268005371,
-0.4397415816783905,
-0.5428504943847656,
-0.6809931993484497,
0.5035883784294128,
-0.2915944457054138,
-0.3793051540851593,
0.5174118280410767,
0.5477127432823181,
0.7056599259376526,
-0.022132592275738716,
0.5904058218002319,
0.39183202385902405,
0.7674766182899475,
-0.5907626748085022,
0.42840805649757385,
-0.5788618922233582,
0.380121111869812,
-0.09455468505620956,
-0.7584336996078491,
-0.5333729386329651,
0.16229142248630524,
-0.41622981429100037,
-0.0705975890159607,
0.7245760560035706,
0.698381781578064,
-0.13380588591098785,
0.10757730901241302,
0.39067643880844116,
0.1924431324005127,
0.4268746078014374,
0.6391480565071106,
0.49622398614883423,
0.05588158220052719,
0.4457639753818512,
-0.1157594546675682,
-0.6959846019744873,
-0.1298000067472458,
-1.3456770181655884,
-0.9431356191635132,
-0.6618841886520386,
-0.2232949137687683,
-0.07097838819026947,
0.08751767873764038,
1.2674070596694946,
0.6130329370498657,
-0.5330207943916321,
-0.2556730806827545,
0.2737376093864441,
-0.010111148469150066,
-0.16166473925113678,
-0.20623667538166046,
0.2964544892311096,
-0.5339012145996094,
-0.8608062863349915,
0.6499428749084473,
0.2314278781414032,
0.137562558054924,
0.260811984539032,
0.36469051241874695,
-0.13169032335281372,
0.20372094213962555,
0.7637459635734558,
0.20536567270755768,
-0.5784038305282593,
-0.46159112453460693,
0.18050551414489746,
-0.11467483639717102,
0.21445055305957794,
1.0716396570205688,
-0.9691916704177856,
0.35571524500846863,
0.4617827832698822,
0.7897316813468933,
0.6167416572570801,
-0.1744711548089981,
0.610914945602417,
-1.1157511472702026,
0.2520082890987396,
0.6906163096427917,
0.6840605139732361,
0.31893816590309143,
-0.43934333324432373,
0.3361934423446655,
0.16204945743083954,
-0.5257296562194824,
-0.6014145016670227,
0.4721720814704895,
-0.9305245280265808,
-0.5224153995513916,
1.1386516094207764,
-0.3547447621822357,
-0.16543640196323395,
0.0246288999915123,
-0.10334255546331406,
0.5135922431945801,
-0.6560292840003967,
0.9272038340568542,
0.4027765393257141,
-0.20737873017787933,
-0.10066483169794083,
-0.3570195436477661,
0.4371359050273895,
0.2155798226594925,
-0.931429922580719,
0.1666550487279892,
0.6184355020523071,
0.26399582624435425,
-0.12211019545793533,
0.4988950490951538,
-0.2751673758029938,
0.046225909143686295,
-0.6237132549285889,
-0.2881150543689728,
-0.13336747884750366,
-0.21239057183265686,
-0.5737295150756836,
0.309061735868454,
-0.11478424072265625,
0.06663955003023148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07768v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07768v3
|
Using Letter Positional Probabilities to Assess Word Complexity
| 2024-04-11T14:06:39 | 2024-04-30T07:03:19 |
Michael Dalvean
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7; J.4
|
Word complexity is defined in a number of different ways. Psycholinguistic,
morphological and lexical proxies are often used. Human ratings are also used.
The problem here is that these proxies do not measure complexity directly, and
human ratings are susceptible to subjective bias. In this study we contend that
some form of 'latent complexity' can be approximated by using samples of simple
and complex words. We use a sample of 'simple' words from primary school
picture books and a sample of 'complex' words from high school and academic
settings. In order to analyse the differences between these classes, we look at
the letter positional probabilities (LPPs). We find strong statistical
associations between several LPPs and complexity. For example, simple words are
significantly (p<.001) more likely to start with w, b, s, h, g, k, j, t, y or
f, while complex words are significantly (p<.001) more likely to start with i,
a, e, r, v, u or d. We find similar strong associations for subsequent letter
positions, with 84 letter-position variables in the first 6 positions being
significant at the p<.001 level. We then use LPPs as variables in creating a
classifier which can classify the two classes with an 83% accuracy. We test
these findings using a second data set, with 66 LPPs significant (p<.001) in
the first 6 positions common to both datasets. We use these 66 variables to
create a classifier that is able to classify a third dataset with an accuracy
of 70%. Finally, we create a fourth sample by combining the extreme high and
low scoring words generated by three classifiers built on the first three
separate datasets and use this sample to build a classifier which has an
accuracy of 97%. We use this to score the four levels of English word groups
from an ESL program.
|
[
-0.17508099973201752,
-0.6908593773841858,
0.7650049924850464,
0.2925689220428467,
-0.1018168106675148,
0.23157259821891785,
-0.08431506901979446,
-0.571225643157959,
-0.08234871923923492,
-0.12902678549289703,
-0.2534599304199219,
-0.5776244401931763,
-0.8941003680229187,
-0.06733115762472153,
-0.04370380565524101,
0.54539954662323,
0.03144031763076782,
0.07016288489103317,
-0.15862439572811127,
-0.16682466864585876,
-0.39849749207496643,
-0.4877699315547943,
-0.3945382833480835,
-0.4569915533065796,
0.6175057888031006,
0.450300931930542,
0.963684618473053,
0.4470159411430359,
0.6429003477096558,
0.4027932286262512,
-0.3017939627170563,
-0.058840636163949966,
-0.32486385107040405,
-0.09423782676458359,
-0.060986362397670746,
-0.7153464555740356,
-0.3458532989025116,
0.1925920993089676,
0.3153839111328125,
1.3343721628189087,
-0.20493316650390625,
-0.16986489295959473,
0.07823334634304047,
0.939457893371582,
-0.6308728456497192,
0.2028445452451706,
-0.42695119976997375,
0.3298669755458832,
-0.3739793002605438,
-0.2409578412771225,
-0.224626362323761,
-0.3401567041873932,
0.4603859484195709,
-0.49475550651550293,
0.22469063103199005,
0.25704866647720337,
0.5062262415885925,
-0.1746748387813568,
-0.21424980461597443,
-0.7808459997177124,
-0.8478987812995911,
0.8137605786323547,
-0.45214635133743286,
0.2727498710155487,
0.4743180572986603,
-0.035842087119817734,
-0.5235974192619324,
-0.34788691997528076,
-0.6999550461769104,
-0.43193256855010986,
0.020748311653733253,
0.21573156118392944,
-0.21437928080558777,
0.29368555545806885,
0.4168948531150818,
0.5883661508560181,
-0.7687420845031738,
0.2127538025379181,
-0.3817249834537506,
-0.1805306077003479,
0.530234694480896,
0.06516625732183456,
0.41099628806114197,
-0.12281889468431473,
-0.07231201976537704,
-0.2621521055698395,
-0.4926806092262268,
0.7033330798149109,
0.9296101927757263,
0.4182688593864441,
0.3016341030597687,
0.9638680815696716,
-0.07409364730119705,
0.616001546382904,
-0.024574384093284607,
-0.42337071895599365,
0.3496810793876648,
-0.029245898127555847,
-0.07338393479585648,
0.19963505864143372,
0.6380844116210938,
0.25521692633628845,
0.2798091471195221,
-0.11231760680675507,
-0.21141266822814941,
0.24555779993534088,
-0.004465693607926369,
-0.31612443923950195,
-0.3456254303455353,
0.24490958452224731,
-0.2508053481578827,
-0.2128995805978775,
0.3646624684333801,
-0.22710531949996948,
-0.36910274624824524,
-0.13844366371631622,
0.6389008164405823,
-0.5607916116714478,
0.15817826986312866,
0.5333972573280334,
-0.056907810270786285,
0.1464693546295166,
0.1392202526330948,
-0.6392427682876587,
0.24754510819911957,
0.6523264050483704,
0.8168235421180725,
-0.29068928956985474,
-0.52248615026474,
-0.16107262670993805,
0.01567692495882511,
-0.36105817556381226,
0.8545660376548767,
-0.6387032270431519,
-0.4219340980052948,
0.02704526297748089,
0.08230983465909958,
0.15875664353370667,
-0.558230996131897,
0.8716549873352051,
-0.27434241771698,
0.48226746916770935,
-0.1122283786535263,
-0.8530887961387634,
-0.10555870831012726,
0.07585025578737259,
-0.6901810765266418,
0.9936487674713135,
0.030573925003409386,
-0.9289148449897766,
0.4060819447040558,
-0.0706208273768425,
-0.6893352270126343,
0.11287623643875122,
-0.1232808455824852,
-0.29633456468582153,
0.22497323155403137,
-0.1151779443025589,
0.519690752029419,
0.013803492300212383,
-0.13824082911014557,
-0.20212742686271667,
-0.617935836315155,
0.35851702094078064,
-0.3907812237739563,
0.3510857820510864,
-0.1380135416984558,
-0.3096693754196167,
-0.27897366881370544,
-0.8130834102630615,
0.1244906559586525,
-0.025035783648490906,
-0.7340219020843506,
-0.6250573992729187,
0.13986623287200928,
-0.11683332920074463,
0.09858957678079605,
0.2817254662513733,
-0.48421403765678406,
0.4061233103275299,
-0.6894443035125732,
0.2009396255016327,
0.44248607754707336,
-0.07002144306898117,
0.6471953392028809,
-0.51484215259552,
0.5834251046180725,
0.09477893263101578,
-0.12263502925634384,
0.3776334226131439,
-0.8215293288230896,
-0.41111528873443604,
0.012725277803838253,
0.38722991943359375,
0.8688845634460449,
-0.5781427621841431,
0.6971970200538635,
-0.22082482278347015,
-0.8040637373924255,
-0.2583061158657074,
0.017170798033475876,
0.4765806794166565,
0.16968902945518494,
0.24383626878261566,
-0.37948256731033325,
-0.2255026400089264,
-0.7574118971824646,
-0.38673555850982666,
-0.5170511603355408,
-0.4608125388622284,
0.10110247880220413,
0.24006067216396332,
0.1264323592185974,
0.5853827595710754,
-0.7617794871330261,
-0.3317231237888336,
-0.07903104275465012,
0.5385180115699768,
0.5388106107711792,
0.2915666699409485,
0.2114708125591278,
-0.4556554853916168,
-0.13498952984809875,
-0.5400444865226746,
-0.41911837458610535,
-0.11532139778137207,
0.164603590965271,
0.07362712174654007,
-0.05831567198038101,
0.40929028391838074,
-0.38932156562805176,
0.4357212483882904,
0.4022238552570343,
-0.44689851999282837,
0.5171132683753967,
-0.6328902840614319,
-0.0596652589738369,
-0.6512548923492432,
-0.22772133350372314,
0.07031232118606567,
0.1883460134267807,
-0.654769778251648,
-0.21386681497097015,
-0.37259137630462646,
0.16311296820640564,
-0.3582536280155182,
0.11027137190103531,
-0.5596072673797607,
-0.08608490228652954,
-0.00845920480787754,
0.07456124573945999,
-0.218698188662529,
0.4210559129714966,
-0.0467233806848526,
0.48551005125045776,
0.30475282669067383,
-0.4938598871231079,
0.1036141961812973,
-0.3809933662414551,
-0.8247767090797424,
0.4515049159526825,
-0.6719602346420288,
-0.12359919399023056,
-0.30474165081977844,
-0.12058930844068527,
-1.5097808837890625,
-0.11298530548810959,
-0.007861031219363213,
-0.15706494450569153,
0.20341745018959045,
0.3915965259075165,
-0.3479732275009155,
-0.4911685585975647,
-0.31910964846611023,
0.2663796842098236,
0.28659260272979736,
0.09012850373983383,
0.3474898934364319,
0.6326196789741516,
-0.2665388882160187,
-0.6387860774993896,
-0.6919810175895691,
-0.10041728615760803,
-0.07468052953481674,
-0.5041786432266235,
0.4513036608695984,
-0.38126322627067566,
-0.34914490580558777,
-0.0522836297750473,
-0.3448858857154846,
0.014986653812229633,
-0.09113334864377975,
0.5688987374305725,
-0.1473187655210495,
-0.08170000463724136,
0.24435080587863922,
-0.07776521146297455,
0.1403106451034546,
-0.1401383876800537,
0.017052214592695236,
0.5716699957847595,
-0.47412553429603577,
-0.34980762004852295,
-0.18437814712524414,
0.2573256492614746,
0.7318013906478882,
0.26763325929641724,
0.5488483309745789,
0.3858100473880768,
-0.5394643545150757,
-0.016799112781882286,
-0.2653573155403137,
0.11896432191133499,
-0.4371897876262665,
0.40839025378227234,
-0.6887249946594238,
-0.6540642976760864,
0.5727840065956116,
0.29415956139564514,
-0.1556842178106308,
0.3143925368785858,
0.4403124451637268,
-0.3871646225452423,
0.9798958897590637,
0.4316946864128113,
0.13675719499588013,
0.4272353947162628,
-0.2612689733505249,
0.3116745352745056,
-0.38611721992492676,
-0.3345886468887329,
-0.25701257586479187,
-0.6478580832481384,
-0.8632515668869019,
-0.40046900510787964,
0.20213627815246582,
0.3978902995586395,
0.06041505187749863,
0.2208389788866043,
-0.3920811414718628,
0.6290794014930725,
0.6040140986442566,
0.29556506872177124,
0.24974298477172852,
0.18225523829460144,
-0.1954537332057953,
-0.23091140389442444,
-0.6364350318908691,
-0.633442759513855,
0.9021983742713928,
0.520458996295929,
0.727126955986023,
0.5511270761489868,
0.5527370572090149,
0.4289059638977051,
0.14124611020088196,
-1.360687494277954,
0.6899787187576294,
-0.6557758450508118,
-0.19984441995620728,
-0.7254461050033569,
-0.11231084167957306,
-1.2977330684661865,
-0.07154713571071625,
-0.48589983582496643,
-0.4464360475540161,
0.34507542848587036,
-0.2137557864189148,
-0.41396620869636536,
0.1323181688785553,
-0.6063291430473328,
0.23432482779026031,
0.01615097187459469,
-0.42387768626213074,
0.09053424745798111,
-0.5920272469520569,
0.2402620017528534,
0.06293879449367523,
0.476651668548584,
-0.11302657425403595,
-0.12774062156677246,
1.0674315690994263,
-0.6784071922302246,
0.553489625453949,
0.024545026943087578,
-0.3009200394153595,
0.33692723512649536,
0.1974291354417801,
0.33773085474967957,
-0.3644215166568756,
-0.17757286131381989,
-0.030587704852223396,
0.049921076744794846,
-0.3863183856010437,
-0.5867738723754883,
0.4595666825771332,
-0.9842361807823181,
-0.5400131940841675,
-0.7680761814117432,
-0.5128276944160461,
-0.20081564784049988,
0.13680504262447357,
0.4833262264728546,
0.5218786597251892,
0.010317888110876083,
0.42826390266418457,
0.5174136161804199,
-0.11637236177921295,
0.3597548305988312,
0.4882621169090271,
0.2619997560977936,
-0.277681827545166,
0.9195364117622375,
0.8658881187438965,
0.047490444034338,
0.5922963619232178,
0.7047566771507263,
-0.39700597524642944,
-0.7065789103507996,
0.20788688957691193,
0.03470884636044502,
-0.7005442380905151,
0.1669294685125351,
-0.4090932309627533,
-0.23558415472507477,
-0.30829939246177673,
-0.3061547577381134,
-0.007987011224031448,
-0.41792482137680054,
-0.021003035828471184,
-0.08093411475419998,
-0.13037559390068054,
0.8937896490097046,
-0.012710141949355602,
0.42846208810806274,
-0.36300355195999146,
0.22693182528018951,
0.6689586639404297,
0.17237474024295807,
-0.12635615468025208,
-0.640812873840332,
0.18740200996398926,
-0.33022814989089966,
-0.10536934435367584,
-1.145694375038147,
0.25486141443252563,
0.4836614727973938,
0.688181459903717,
0.5698568820953369,
0.07740353792905807,
0.4834679067134857,
-0.5163092017173767,
0.8948989510536194,
0.24755746126174927,
-0.9357461929321289,
0.30761823058128357,
-0.1856127381324768,
0.38130611181259155,
0.6375985145568848,
0.5642139315605164,
-0.25405776500701904,
-0.6515074968338013,
-0.8421041369438171,
-0.9986721873283386,
0.37119588255882263,
0.2679266929626465,
-0.2549048960208893,
0.01754557341337204,
0.5473932027816772,
-0.18533815443515778,
0.1509488970041275,
-0.5998774766921997,
-0.3141953647136688,
0.1780446618795395,
-0.4838756024837494,
-0.23273153603076935,
-0.4383138120174408,
0.04822223633527756,
-0.1092243641614914,
0.3239659368991852,
0.11455197632312775,
0.13155224919319153,
0.2657127380371094,
-0.07869036495685577,
-0.0800102949142456,
0.47894006967544556,
0.7790462374687195,
0.6642066240310669,
-0.5125935673713684,
0.6499248147010803,
0.15462321043014526,
-1.083679437637329,
0.511684000492096,
-0.19743017852306366,
0.051717936992645264,
-0.02310536429286003,
1.0224875211715698,
0.4390343725681305,
0.3684518039226532,
-0.5369667410850525,
0.7471327781677246,
-0.12083685398101807,
-0.21905045211315155,
-0.320379376411438,
0.07660189270973206,
0.07498438656330109,
0.14757318794727325,
0.2638438940048218,
0.03296054154634476,
0.34135106205940247,
-0.9366064667701721,
0.17715279757976532,
0.057883504778146744,
-0.38238388299942017,
-0.2691380977630615,
0.15332837402820587,
0.0034411000087857246,
-0.574039876461029,
0.3048572242259979,
-0.5581421256065369,
-0.5904454588890076,
0.6052865386009216,
0.4901108741760254,
0.6105796098709106,
-0.30583810806274414,
0.14941644668579102,
0.4943386912345886,
0.4467065930366516,
-0.5337766408920288,
0.6997313499450684,
0.2721157670021057,
-0.8149834871292114,
-0.1294402927160263,
-0.8788092732429504,
-0.608936071395874,
0.32710766792297363,
-0.5093094110488892,
0.19280481338500977,
-0.5610992908477783,
-0.24381574988365173,
0.06306895613670349,
0.3758755922317505,
-0.675633430480957,
0.2962385416030884,
0.286048024892807,
0.6639596819877625,
-1.2026907205581665,
0.552067220211029,
1.0242315530776978,
-0.1951410174369812,
-0.9794416427612305,
0.21664376556873322,
-0.17010271549224854,
-0.5993213057518005,
0.8735317587852478,
0.30962878465652466,
-0.5204648375511169,
-0.16942359507083893,
-0.35536885261535645,
-0.5531452298164368,
0.9919630885124207,
-0.10313256084918976,
-0.9622201323509216,
-0.12532451748847961,
0.31721460819244385,
0.8275465965270996,
-0.18816985189914703,
0.2745911180973053,
0.39805781841278076,
0.3580624461174011,
0.3500647246837616,
-0.5409653782844543,
-0.09292431175708771,
-0.11280521750450134,
0.10255619138479233,
-0.1667601615190506,
-0.10195200890302658,
0.942672610282898,
-0.3602299392223358,
-0.39540478587150574,
-0.1316782683134079,
0.7230133414268494,
0.48285213112831116,
0.38472867012023926,
0.9845247864723206,
0.5511832237243652,
1.1625251770019531,
-0.14505888521671295,
0.7243466377258301,
-0.48286911845207214,
0.22537094354629517,
1.0833455324172974,
0.03577744588255882,
1.1811637878417969,
0.3979435861110687,
-0.7316623330116272,
0.4966811537742615,
0.7072641849517822,
0.15965873003005981,
0.4286614656448364,
0.7783029675483704,
-0.3536619544029236,
-0.2791602611541748,
0.002826639683917165,
-0.1563033163547516,
0.6419428586959839,
0.6110266447067261,
-0.20408211648464203,
0.1547960788011551,
-0.050730299204587936,
-0.11673149466514587,
0.19232140481472015,
-0.3926853835582733,
0.4698106646537781,
0.08641540259122849,
-0.5917380452156067,
0.3112633228302002,
0.11490465700626373,
0.7413448691368103,
-0.4887901246547699,
0.20669156312942505,
-0.01676177978515625,
0.11208857595920563,
-0.2677813768386841,
-1.5483735799789429,
0.0952746644616127,
-0.30580082535743713,
-0.2917962968349457,
0.1442863941192627,
0.7504025101661682,
-0.6346129775047302,
-0.7333157062530518,
0.06405459344387054,
0.6124652624130249,
0.40826722979545593,
0.12766440212726593,
-0.44254428148269653,
-0.22791534662246704,
-0.47617974877357483,
-0.4971165060997009,
-0.09065359830856323,
0.697708249092102,
0.12768767774105072,
0.5398949384689331,
0.46847638487815857,
0.5223225951194763,
-0.002724071266129613,
0.1210164949297905,
0.3896603584289551,
-0.5286065936088562,
-0.5893885493278503,
-0.7967053055763245,
0.015337411314249039,
0.16866791248321533,
-0.4638931155204773,
0.5359535217285156,
0.32338353991508484,
0.6269018054008484,
-0.07881796360015869,
0.6174644827842712,
0.019229605793952942,
0.30758586525917053,
-0.5180582404136658,
0.39676332473754883,
-0.5314591526985168,
0.3730413615703583,
-0.5361637473106384,
-0.9420523047447205,
-0.5604305863380432,
0.8632508516311646,
-0.6288430690765381,
-0.18270538747310638,
0.6722210645675659,
0.7000638246536255,
0.13205651938915253,
-0.10544008761644363,
0.518272340297699,
0.2173614203929901,
0.17211338877677917,
0.7856844067573547,
0.7016462087631226,
-0.4548012316226959,
0.32236650586128235,
-0.30829739570617676,
-0.4766223430633545,
-0.22768446803092957,
-0.9010043144226074,
-0.8414825201034546,
-0.6831339001655579,
-0.20796944200992584,
-0.5445843935012817,
-0.10909122973680496,
0.9293688535690308,
0.2507110834121704,
-0.6933587789535522,
-0.1693064421415329,
-0.0745268315076828,
0.23412291705608368,
-0.274427592754364,
-0.21917062997817993,
0.6449966430664062,
0.09221634268760681,
-0.7362473607063293,
0.12885098159313202,
0.1422680765390396,
0.32384756207466125,
-0.36408233642578125,
0.17105364799499512,
-0.18252970278263092,
0.19231362640857697,
0.9508883953094482,
0.15819379687309265,
-0.7515199780464172,
-0.741375744342804,
0.03665323927998543,
-0.3219224512577057,
-0.10273315012454987,
0.5666950941085815,
-0.4276353120803833,
0.37771570682525635,
1.0535624027252197,
0.13387563824653625,
-0.16440241038799286,
0.01993553154170513,
0.2698732614517212,
-0.8304534554481506,
0.014301055110991001,
0.14345261454582214,
0.369590163230896,
0.2975986897945404,
-0.22307175397872925,
0.42873379588127136,
0.5828213691711426,
-0.498858779668808,
-0.6855527758598328,
0.3643343150615692,
-1.1245536804199219,
-0.40834248065948486,
1.150815486907959,
-0.1229577511548996,
-0.2654111981391907,
-0.3230912685394287,
-0.17848564684391022,
0.15353423357009888,
-0.21911169588565826,
0.7829889059066772,
1.094728708267212,
-0.2818371057510376,
0.1470101773738861,
-0.30432647466659546,
0.5714075565338135,
0.2759104371070862,
-0.41917684674263,
-0.2830803096294403,
0.065693199634552,
0.2731285095214844,
0.6526083946228027,
0.5147901177406311,
0.033858053386211395,
-0.2610241174697876,
-0.04268806427717209,
0.03142625465989113,
0.24303176999092102,
-0.3868521451950073,
-0.36181995272636414,
0.8202987313270569,
0.2171991765499115,
0.03344796970486641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07765v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07765v1
|
AnnoCTR: A Dataset for Detecting and Linking Entities, Tactics, and Techniques in Cyber Threat Reports
| 2024-04-11T14:04:36 | 2024-04-11T14:04:36 |
Lukas Lange, Marc Müller, Ghazaleh Haratinezhad Torbati, Dragan Milchevski, Patrick Grau, Subhash Pujari, Annemarie Friedrich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Monitoring the threat landscape to be aware of actual or potential attacks is
of utmost importance to cybersecurity professionals. Information about cyber
threats is typically distributed using natural language reports. Natural
language processing can help with managing this large amount of unstructured
information, yet to date, the topic has received little attention. With this
paper, we present AnnoCTR, a new CC-BY-SA-licensed dataset of cyber threat
reports. The reports have been annotated by a domain expert with named
entities, temporal expressions, and cybersecurity-specific concepts including
implicitly mentioned techniques and tactics. Entities and concepts are linked
to Wikipedia and the MITRE ATT&CK knowledge base, the most widely-used taxonomy
for classifying types of attacks. Prior datasets linking to MITRE ATT&CK either
provide a single label per document or annotate sentences out-of-context; our
dataset annotates entire documents in a much finer-grained way. In an
experimental study, we model the annotations of our dataset using
state-of-the-art neural models. In our few-shot scenario, we find that for
identifying the MITRE ATT&CK concepts that are mentioned explicitly or
implicitly in a text, concept descriptions from MITRE ATT&CK are an effective
source for training data augmentation.
|
[
-0.38995760679244995,
-1.0884697437286377,
0.13297492265701294,
-0.2183210253715515,
-0.26139307022094727,
0.36574122309684753,
-0.21671906113624573,
-1.0297362804412842,
0.3926251232624054,
0.4368297755718231,
-0.4070371985435486,
-0.553013265132904,
-0.4536723792552948,
0.2430790215730667,
-0.6537330746650696,
1.4234068393707275,
0.1604323834180832,
-0.4036870300769806,
-0.21075914800167084,
0.24112679064273834,
-0.5353826284408569,
-0.6539105176925659,
-0.7447211742401123,
0.11463749408721924,
0.37782034277915955,
0.22840461134910583,
0.4286781847476959,
0.5303292274475098,
1.07246732711792,
0.2953849732875824,
0.08533155918121338,
0.08680862933397293,
-0.21419329941272736,
0.010196884162724018,
0.07039010524749756,
-0.25124722719192505,
-0.4160962998867035,
-0.07064870744943619,
0.15704315900802612,
0.2698710858821869,
0.139093279838562,
0.2438153475522995,
-0.049303390085697174,
-0.0530799925327301,
-0.5899953246116638,
-0.020541055127978325,
-0.9283046722412109,
-0.0527934767305851,
-0.40583378076553345,
-0.43006643652915955,
-0.5377538204193115,
-0.32136160135269165,
0.5076296925544739,
-0.8706843256950378,
0.0904923602938652,
0.2926388680934906,
0.42176878452301025,
0.28225424885749817,
-0.27552032470703125,
-0.4347050189971924,
-0.5182008743286133,
0.3925591707229614,
-0.3670160174369812,
0.07250121235847473,
0.4868207573890686,
0.4339500367641449,
0.1386222392320633,
-0.7388464212417603,
-0.3897671103477478,
-0.22196650505065918,
-0.39488548040390015,
-0.25446033477783203,
-0.5550653338432312,
0.01572631113231182,
0.2000182718038559,
-0.00879604835063219,
-0.484986811876297,
0.10633031278848648,
-0.6459658741950989,
-0.5363752245903015,
0.7058392763137817,
0.1692025363445282,
0.2861415445804596,
-0.14011959731578827,
-0.8645282983779907,
0.08963600546121597,
-0.469676673412323,
-0.14932949841022491,
0.42901545763015747,
0.47650420665740967,
-0.45529377460479736,
0.4403737783432007,
-0.08975262939929962,
0.791166365146637,
-0.002099569421261549,
-0.20985683798789978,
0.1302730292081833,
-0.4820926785469055,
-0.0817752480506897,
0.674180269241333,
0.6826645135879517,
0.3532118499279022,
0.3113418221473694,
-0.2848290205001831,
-0.2789492607116699,
0.24422544240951538,
0.7785941958427429,
-0.5616897344589233,
-0.5227808952331543,
-0.11350251734256744,
-0.1473664939403534,
-0.6271237134933472,
0.20369742810726166,
-0.8279481530189514,
-0.5619574785232544,
-0.4995310306549072,
0.24531398713588715,
-0.5548938512802124,
-0.02956838347017765,
-0.28808847069740295,
-0.12725508213043213,
-0.17872276902198792,
0.29822617769241333,
-0.3926472067832947,
0.646744430065155,
0.6060196161270142,
0.6782178282737732,
-0.27849283814430237,
0.038940176367759705,
-0.4221741557121277,
0.004734241869300604,
-0.19310934841632843,
1.0852750539779663,
-0.699650764465332,
-0.01652652770280838,
0.1562657356262207,
-0.34691953659057617,
0.06440719962120056,
-0.22245028614997864,
0.4389619529247284,
-0.6575267314910889,
0.029200835153460503,
0.06036905571818352,
-0.38426896929740906,
-0.2895318865776062,
0.6266049742698669,
-0.6672763228416443,
0.8440655469894409,
0.030340339988470078,
-1.0456414222717285,
0.5185302495956421,
-0.94566410779953,
-0.5994784832000732,
0.31018757820129395,
-0.11544472724199295,
-0.15604650974273682,
-0.18208453059196472,
0.06580569595098495,
0.22631770372390747,
-0.48670482635498047,
0.01857561618089676,
-0.018851134926080704,
0.0071374112740159035,
0.40736910700798035,
-0.2527095377445221,
0.6052753329277039,
0.1102294921875,
-0.2454463392496109,
0.10597328841686249,
-0.680912435054779,
-0.03458750993013382,
-0.017763983458280563,
0.035974178463220596,
-0.5943200588226318,
-0.057922571897506714,
0.1261696070432663,
0.09806188941001892,
0.24247896671295166,
-0.6466875672340393,
0.08431580662727356,
-0.23305924236774445,
0.316165566444397,
0.544319748878479,
0.30583521723747253,
0.30838683247566223,
-0.2889094948768616,
0.3972207009792328,
0.16638706624507904,
0.4165332615375519,
-0.1993100941181183,
-0.25985097885131836,
-0.5893966555595398,
-0.31674686074256897,
0.07253478467464447,
0.7437689304351807,
-0.913748025894165,
0.17149151861667633,
-0.2675485908985138,
-0.4552392363548279,
-0.492782860994339,
-0.00667449738830328,
0.25068145990371704,
0.8078268766403198,
0.77939772605896,
-0.008178324438631535,
-0.7070084810256958,
-0.9285584688186646,
-0.09724412113428116,
-0.2623876631259918,
0.10344402492046356,
-0.008750113658607006,
0.6162823438644409,
-0.07299402356147766,
1.0862236022949219,
-0.626425564289093,
-0.44831833243370056,
-0.1827237606048584,
0.6210534572601318,
-0.1940905600786209,
0.20788761973381042,
0.6059737205505371,
-0.9689659476280212,
-0.4629426896572113,
0.10945695638656616,
-0.6748822331428528,
-0.08442998677492142,
-0.3281528651714325,
0.15559060871601105,
0.13764840364456177,
0.5562782883644104,
-0.3259912431240082,
0.6432368159294128,
-0.0922389104962349,
-0.2201714962720871,
0.3534514307975769,
0.18207794427871704,
0.2458367645740509,
-0.9963523745536804,
0.09390304982662201,
0.07345086336135864,
-0.13144756853580475,
-0.9962009191513062,
-0.0287731122225523,
-0.2514818608760834,
0.06173177435994148,
-0.6807348132133484,
0.40799587965011597,
-0.103195421397686,
0.09865335375070572,
-0.22418466210365295,
0.35009029507637024,
-0.19166187942028046,
0.2539035975933075,
0.12993718683719635,
0.5240408182144165,
0.5045700073242188,
-0.7329674363136292,
0.5064231753349304,
0.42331692576408386,
-0.145706444978714,
0.8522251844406128,
-0.6027596592903137,
0.3002173900604248,
0.061477482318878174,
0.10590847581624985,
-0.6310771703720093,
-0.318266361951828,
0.47875070571899414,
-0.6678127646446228,
0.31058189272880554,
-0.013818103820085526,
-0.5441181659698486,
-0.17865778505802155,
-0.433303564786911,
0.41641685366630554,
-0.14998102188110352,
-0.2996402382850647,
0.5116965174674988,
0.5219237208366394,
-0.11305743455886841,
-0.5546590685844421,
-0.8866487741470337,
0.2652347981929779,
-0.2973651885986328,
-0.3879590630531311,
0.42047807574272156,
-0.04305247589945793,
-0.45515891909599304,
0.02520846202969551,
0.12709999084472656,
-0.3558470904827118,
0.2444562464952469,
0.3851037621498108,
0.595595121383667,
-0.04040269926190376,
0.05635788291692734,
-0.47129714488983154,
-0.1181303858757019,
0.2836346924304962,
-0.2887111008167267,
0.3794180154800415,
0.11957823485136032,
-0.151708722114563,
-0.49057722091674805,
0.23116330802440643,
0.10796817392110825,
-0.18532665073871613,
0.6716070771217346,
0.6869770288467407,
-0.5636051297187805,
0.024061352014541626,
-0.4436691999435425,
-0.47915902733802795,
-0.3882560729980469,
0.05217352136969566,
0.12638020515441895,
-0.825644850730896,
0.3746720552444458,
0.2540113627910614,
0.22365891933441162,
0.5017703175544739,
0.09434805810451508,
-0.02384367026388645,
0.3531467914581299,
0.6924824714660645,
-0.3726477324962616,
0.4170774817466736,
-0.12359309941530228,
0.4084019660949707,
-0.6591883301734924,
-0.4092000722885132,
-0.46001699566841125,
-0.30240243673324585,
-0.6770942807197571,
0.0043139345943927765,
0.31610387563705444,
-0.3703424334526062,
-0.3253077268600464,
0.7957062721252441,
-0.6763479709625244,
0.23034916818141937,
0.31430351734161377,
0.13852640986442566,
0.29188454151153564,
0.00792727805674076,
0.0446513332426548,
0.09700674563646317,
-0.47986873984336853,
-0.4662993252277374,
1.031143069267273,
0.23332521319389343,
0.5988637804985046,
0.005767147522419691,
0.5708434581756592,
0.7308694124221802,
0.3632923662662506,
-0.6533214449882507,
0.5441306829452515,
0.11074241995811462,
-0.811231255531311,
-0.06549686938524246,
-0.35793137550354004,
-0.6847205758094788,
-0.4151608645915985,
-0.5573946833610535,
-1.0332252979278564,
-0.0659748986363411,
0.15286557376384735,
-0.5440864562988281,
0.3061218857765198,
-0.22168876230716705,
0.50986647605896,
-0.225104421377182,
-0.15928702056407928,
-0.08419309556484222,
-0.7562589645385742,
0.22500863671302795,
-0.405251145362854,
0.20157532393932343,
0.12556979060173035,
-0.07454898208379745,
0.685770571231842,
-0.2690575122833252,
1.0923266410827637,
0.2105277180671692,
0.25592926144599915,
0.7560474276542664,
-0.010067353956401348,
0.523858904838562,
0.114667609333992,
0.11898443847894669,
0.18588568270206451,
-0.37091174721717834,
0.13490423560142517,
-0.2246103435754776,
0.37599730491638184,
-0.48195838928222656,
-0.1757090836763382,
-0.6134501695632935,
-0.4066181480884552,
0.21889828145503998,
0.1913895606994629,
0.5160110592842102,
0.6286938190460205,
-0.3302380442619324,
0.1302180141210556,
0.564565896987915,
-0.09943118691444397,
0.4485601484775543,
0.3765471577644348,
0.2709744870662689,
-0.5435317754745483,
0.6913114190101624,
0.12987272441387177,
0.3053933382034302,
0.8331429958343506,
-0.17432524263858795,
-0.13618940114974976,
-0.5140624642372131,
0.06894098222255707,
-0.3179822266101837,
-0.6745498776435852,
-0.897824227809906,
-0.6605629920959473,
-0.3490876257419586,
-0.3379359543323517,
-0.4502665400505066,
-0.014167227782309055,
-0.2958475649356842,
-0.19466693699359894,
-0.33882778882980347,
0.9958636164665222,
0.7548583149909973,
0.0673753023147583,
0.7736268639564514,
-0.4618111550807953,
0.31638556718826294,
0.05558200925588608,
-0.15920846164226532,
-0.302155464887619,
-0.305085688829422,
-0.2015199065208435,
0.23156622052192688,
-0.25637656450271606,
-0.8052525520324707,
0.40835872292518616,
0.05273563042283058,
0.3797857463359833,
0.2562336027622223,
0.4167664647102356,
0.45516636967658997,
-0.24022500216960907,
0.7659757137298584,
0.24479267001152039,
-0.7162168622016907,
0.6787436604499817,
-0.2371918112039566,
0.05270398408174515,
0.8073505163192749,
0.6477635502815247,
-0.3259263038635254,
-0.18132242560386658,
-0.7574178576469421,
-0.831477701663971,
0.6599153876304626,
0.231134831905365,
-0.11597825586795807,
-0.3227205276489258,
0.1066199541091919,
-0.14172855019569397,
0.3866908550262451,
-0.6334118843078613,
-0.25889554619789124,
-0.0005668310914188623,
-0.14844918251037598,
0.3572780191898346,
0.024261467158794403,
-0.23804017901420593,
-0.027333877980709076,
0.5715527534484863,
-0.22780492901802063,
0.5927339792251587,
0.09996646642684937,
-0.41293632984161377,
0.002173225861042738,
0.11553629487752914,
0.5147038102149963,
0.3941991329193115,
-0.0962892472743988,
0.3774702250957489,
0.555612325668335,
-0.7098797559738159,
-0.19212932884693146,
0.17880700528621674,
-0.17030319571495056,
0.09819561243057251,
0.7611516118049622,
0.5859898924827576,
0.6052598357200623,
-0.5122025012969971,
0.6113095879554749,
0.13554589450359344,
0.06590718775987625,
-0.7090122699737549,
-0.06321745365858078,
-0.4500763714313507,
0.11149774491786957,
0.5292075276374817,
0.19918794929981232,
0.30185413360595703,
-0.48073023557662964,
0.5615666508674622,
0.31819087266921997,
-0.5685426592826843,
-0.40110108256340027,
0.5464754104614258,
0.061909645795822144,
-0.2476191520690918,
0.7173436880111694,
-0.13364148139953613,
-0.8313798904418945,
0.5817601680755615,
0.4057193696498871,
0.7687159180641174,
-0.14242058992385864,
0.16590461134910583,
0.34203681349754333,
0.7039899230003357,
0.30254605412483215,
0.04190395027399063,
-0.015014058910310268,
-0.36949363350868225,
-0.17303535342216492,
-0.4425116181373596,
-0.1198454350233078,
0.18606747686862946,
-0.5550290942192078,
0.6579650044441223,
-0.8653467297554016,
-0.3452393412590027,
0.5314213037490845,
-0.01580568589270115,
-0.8040057420730591,
0.1643178015947342,
0.30128711462020874,
0.9954742789268494,
-0.7390446662902832,
0.4386047124862671,
0.6338273882865906,
-0.5065878629684448,
-0.5002157092094421,
-0.19763392210006714,
0.5156587958335876,
-0.4598931074142456,
0.8087136149406433,
0.24422165751457214,
0.06686864048242569,
-0.3418869972229004,
-0.6038402915000916,
-0.7017905712127686,
1.0203319787979126,
0.16428475081920624,
-0.31200674176216125,
0.015044309198856354,
0.5096254348754883,
0.5269411206245422,
-0.7715248465538025,
0.3806331157684326,
0.4689673185348511,
0.5974588990211487,
-0.12711971998214722,
-0.8788716793060303,
-0.013630477711558342,
-0.1490626037120819,
-0.5491141676902771,
0.6101579666137695,
-0.2526453733444214,
0.7067680358886719,
-0.04359858110547066,
-0.13304251432418823,
-0.3955676853656769,
0.507298469543457,
-0.28279250860214233,
0.5541834831237793,
0.3943437933921814,
0.3861345946788788,
0.4342934787273407,
-0.12480568885803223,
0.9592397809028625,
-0.17814742028713226,
-0.05117706581950188,
1.3466830253601074,
-0.010122026316821575,
0.8250496983528137,
0.18525764346122742,
0.24326194822788239,
0.48569512367248535,
0.5037853717803955,
-0.25108397006988525,
0.5019897222518921,
0.0007285374449566007,
-0.3148171305656433,
-0.11785749346017838,
-0.6256990432739258,
-0.05125103518366814,
0.4771358370780945,
0.49038103222846985,
-0.4423794746398926,
-0.34312576055526733,
0.07136421650648117,
0.24480196833610535,
0.046773478388786316,
-0.26127567887306213,
1.123633861541748,
0.017351113259792328,
-0.2183915674686432,
0.14819976687431335,
-0.19802184402942657,
0.6705659627914429,
-0.6760359406471252,
-0.024784596636891365,
0.34894120693206787,
-0.14886513352394104,
-0.46073299646377563,
-0.6735289096832275,
0.49504703283309937,
0.24438618123531342,
-0.02169601246714592,
0.13726913928985596,
0.9146704077720642,
-0.34913453459739685,
-0.37635183334350586,
0.23041562736034393,
-0.044211119413375854,
-0.0009253888274542987,
-0.002003136556595564,
-0.5306516885757446,
0.02344132959842682,
-0.10230976343154907,
0.09707740694284439,
0.17469444870948792,
0.3261471390724182,
-0.2499266266822815,
0.5348206162452698,
0.7100004553794861,
-0.01124883908778429,
-0.12014642357826233,
-0.38379231095314026,
1.0717408657073975,
-0.26034826040267944,
-0.48120465874671936,
-0.8667241334915161,
0.6116368770599365,
-0.5853186249732971,
-0.6594051122665405,
0.4772826135158539,
0.6000218391418457,
0.847271740436554,
0.2521584928035736,
0.7558863162994385,
-0.2780799865722656,
0.40462496876716614,
-0.301649272441864,
0.4497435390949249,
-0.019610704854130745,
0.4420310854911804,
-0.3442661762237549,
-0.7727310061454773,
-0.2274322509765625,
0.41101279854774475,
-0.4394223988056183,
-0.31488198041915894,
0.6512879729270935,
0.5867028832435608,
-0.07227866351604462,
0.29820913076400757,
-0.06445793807506561,
0.061651185154914856,
0.12903375923633575,
0.26168492436408997,
0.6320009827613831,
-0.4435393810272217,
0.538581132888794,
-0.5040319561958313,
-0.0007865793304517865,
-0.4113747477531433,
-1.0269198417663574,
-1.0564768314361572,
-0.5448305010795593,
-0.6607560515403748,
0.07649832963943481,
0.28473907709121704,
1.2039377689361572,
0.6352478265762329,
-0.8385633230209351,
0.3125045895576477,
0.13934050500392914,
-0.16990549862384796,
-0.047107961028814316,
-0.20842747390270233,
0.18181352317333221,
-0.34181004762649536,
-0.031565017998218536,
0.23709142208099365,
0.18234260380268097,
0.06761690229177475,
-0.0035339542664587498,
0.3843012750148773,
-0.5479886531829834,
0.050105493515729904,
0.5313199758529663,
0.11283581703901291,
-0.33401259779930115,
-0.5837246179580688,
0.1180567592382431,
-0.04092184081673622,
-0.11624538153409958,
0.8337532877922058,
-0.7206014394760132,
0.3370003402233124,
0.34292927384376526,
0.7934526205062866,
0.040416914969682693,
-0.0763937383890152,
0.42368283867836,
-1.103447437286377,
0.11435426026582718,
0.5069746375083923,
0.12902630865573883,
0.4958362281322479,
-0.8012478351593018,
0.7312880754470825,
-0.007878750562667847,
-0.1328130066394806,
-0.7620542645454407,
-0.1507020890712738,
-0.9269462823867798,
-0.22683480381965637,
0.787150502204895,
0.016468964517116547,
-0.1762382984161377,
-0.3435060977935791,
-0.10912787169218063,
0.23348192870616913,
-0.54864102602005,
0.6585873961448669,
0.4704280197620392,
0.1153402253985405,
0.1303418129682541,
-0.8791893124580383,
0.7682042121887207,
-0.3551699221134186,
-1.1898444890975952,
0.2377438247203827,
0.4473906457424164,
-0.06701833754777908,
0.6538938879966736,
0.1330263763666153,
0.09175634384155273,
0.30987200140953064,
-0.00749225215986371,
-0.19630011916160583,
-0.20157824456691742,
-0.7714614272117615,
0.08982919901609421,
0.07278738915920258,
-0.302807480096817,
-0.11271340399980545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07738v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07738v1
|
ResearchAgent: Iterative Research Idea Generation over Scientific Literature with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-11T13:36:29 | 2024-04-11T13:36:29 |
Jinheon Baek, Sujay Kumar Jauhar, Silviu Cucerzan, Sung Ju Hwang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Scientific Research, vital for improving human life, is hindered by its
inherent complexity, slow pace, and the need for specialized experts. To
enhance its productivity, we propose a ResearchAgent, a large language
model-powered research idea writing agent, which automatically generates
problems, methods, and experiment designs while iteratively refining them based
on scientific literature. Specifically, starting with a core paper as the
primary focus to generate ideas, our ResearchAgent is augmented not only with
relevant publications through connecting information over an academic graph but
also entities retrieved from an entity-centric knowledge store based on their
underlying concepts, mined and shared across numerous papers. In addition,
mirroring the human approach to iteratively improving ideas with peer
discussions, we leverage multiple ReviewingAgents that provide reviews and
feedback iteratively. Further, they are instantiated with human
preference-aligned large language models whose criteria for evaluation are
derived from actual human judgments. We experimentally validate our
ResearchAgent on scientific publications across multiple disciplines,
showcasing its effectiveness in generating novel, clear, and valid research
ideas based on human and model-based evaluation results.
|
[
-0.18296101689338684,
-0.5749590992927551,
0.7133777141571045,
0.2056443840265274,
-0.16693364083766937,
0.4341079592704773,
-0.21122945845127106,
-0.3303240239620209,
0.5611709952354431,
0.44546419382095337,
-0.1274873912334442,
-0.3099202811717987,
-0.23593643307685852,
0.14830097556114197,
-0.3750247359275818,
1.195223093032837,
-0.09807255864143372,
-0.039254527539014816,
-0.2693215310573578,
0.4230284094810486,
-0.16523297131061554,
-0.04893099516630173,
-0.7835168838500977,
-0.6159443855285645,
0.7784551382064819,
0.5929149389266968,
0.5440093874931335,
0.4150596261024475,
0.6287146210670471,
0.39675572514533997,
0.29249316453933716,
0.14541372656822205,
-0.4552221894264221,
0.30691275000572205,
-0.4129182696342468,
-0.3111245632171631,
-0.46167322993278503,
-0.14477138221263885,
0.46029040217399597,
0.3853398263454437,
-0.16287527978420258,
0.19094634056091309,
-0.25710543990135193,
0.3672281801700592,
-0.37731608748435974,
0.10333386808633804,
-0.6238023638725281,
0.03533574193716049,
-0.06838885694742203,
-0.3901713192462921,
-0.4058450162410736,
-0.6212614178657532,
0.18922655284404755,
-0.7305149435997009,
0.4925656020641327,
0.15941010415554047,
0.8145059943199158,
-0.019946979358792305,
0.08848739415407181,
-0.3198511302471161,
-0.8085570335388184,
0.5554858446121216,
-0.8200281262397766,
-0.27016404271125793,
0.06006082147359848,
0.25811439752578735,
-0.26675400137901306,
-0.8820648789405823,
-0.6620436310768127,
-0.6426427364349365,
0.06719204783439636,
0.039597686380147934,
-0.23078174889087677,
-0.21638868749141693,
-0.020944302901625633,
-0.04605916514992714,
-0.7286876440048218,
-0.30898210406303406,
-0.45600947737693787,
-0.0030078240670263767,
0.7291969656944275,
0.12946170568466187,
0.2140650898218155,
-0.005139479413628578,
0.05158237740397453,
-0.20680645108222961,
-0.28576231002807617,
-0.15253731608390808,
0.3234180808067322,
0.10384070128202438,
0.6636525392532349,
0.6990747451782227,
-0.07034096121788025,
0.22447295486927032,
-0.05186418816447258,
0.06485050916671753,
0.1607603132724762,
-0.39078986644744873,
0.11084660142660141,
0.18908634781837463,
0.8671370148658752,
0.1817740947008133,
-0.032391130924224854,
-0.47470515966415405,
-0.3094900846481323,
0.2729693353176117,
0.6062913537025452,
-1.045913577079773,
-0.3638063967227936,
0.2347060889005661,
-0.06579575687646866,
-0.6780766248703003,
0.11602603644132614,
-0.5843900442123413,
-0.601614773273468,
-0.050275836139917374,
0.44205260276794434,
-0.47744038701057434,
-0.7406143546104431,
0.14812034368515015,
-0.5572407841682434,
-0.12366241216659546,
0.38286256790161133,
-0.23140044510364532,
0.3195617198944092,
0.5479618906974792,
0.7952592372894287,
-0.1509864777326584,
-0.6192852854728699,
-0.03548349812626839,
0.18048067390918732,
-0.5508114695549011,
1.1402543783187866,
-0.6592015624046326,
-0.496243953704834,
-0.2892788052558899,
-0.22292201220989227,
-0.08120343834161758,
-0.13297341763973236,
0.5476771593093872,
-0.6138524413108826,
0.04784199595451355,
-0.124040886759758,
-0.41104626655578613,
0.2038886547088623,
0.25023967027664185,
-0.8102544546127319,
0.9290829300880432,
-0.03781694173812866,
-1.0765540599822998,
0.34489354491233826,
-1.12783682346344,
-0.4883005619049072,
0.3385370075702667,
-0.14851534366607666,
-0.5971134305000305,
0.04790809378027916,
-0.22251352667808533,
0.021123947575688362,
-0.7193724513053894,
0.4708402156829834,
-0.022267935797572136,
-0.05063950642943382,
0.4820765256881714,
0.047727249562740326,
0.3494129478931427,
0.40802955627441406,
-0.47867551445961,
0.49636101722717285,
-0.8520981669425964,
0.14199425280094147,
0.4901948571205139,
-0.04752374440431595,
-0.43554309010505676,
-0.13606542348861694,
0.13005033135414124,
-0.1552789807319641,
0.024587681517004967,
-1.1005170345306396,
0.4481387436389923,
-0.1730429083108902,
0.7352413535118103,
0.4882360100746155,
0.287422776222229,
0.47567951679229736,
-0.5579497218132019,
0.6742143034934998,
-0.39292868971824646,
-0.2546965181827545,
-0.06511841714382172,
-0.3478047847747803,
-0.6991312503814697,
-0.025042377412319183,
0.33871161937713623,
0.19074492156505585,
-0.7739346027374268,
0.15745942294597626,
-0.21614393591880798,
-0.8599076271057129,
-0.6768993735313416,
-0.1231168806552887,
0.152801513671875,
0.5750676393508911,
0.0377938412129879,
-0.21227897703647614,
-0.38907745480537415,
-0.6951583623886108,
-0.34838348627090454,
-0.14661015570163727,
0.09891504794359207,
-0.05239615961909294,
0.86429762840271,
-0.16187284886837006,
1.140881061553955,
-0.6112588047981262,
-0.2431745082139969,
-0.3666982054710388,
0.7238826751708984,
-0.09345927089452744,
0.500843346118927,
0.2061098963022232,
-0.7717304229736328,
-0.37900611758232117,
0.25895261764526367,
-0.5698337554931641,
-0.18967832624912262,
0.09795325994491577,
-0.4123929440975189,
-0.04429317265748978,
0.21732982993125916,
-0.9613229632377625,
0.2983899712562561,
-0.2856685519218445,
-0.5378673076629639,
0.7272691130638123,
-0.27855730056762695,
0.4242250919342041,
-1.246498942375183,
0.4868842661380768,
-0.15553687512874603,
0.18881741166114807,
-0.6896300911903381,
-0.17169523239135742,
0.00027770595625042915,
-0.5308839678764343,
0.031921643763780594,
0.6234021186828613,
-0.3665817677974701,
0.3628291189670563,
-0.734413743019104,
0.07714486122131348,
0.3938707709312439,
-0.13338196277618408,
0.13601018488407135,
0.7527101635932922,
0.09731411188840866,
-0.2007494568824768,
0.15768353641033173,
0.09400349855422974,
-0.11834913492202759,
0.17718061804771423,
-0.8345862030982971,
0.49623432755470276,
-0.3651870787143707,
0.2782985270023346,
-0.7282220125198364,
-0.31450775265693665,
-0.07959893345832825,
-0.4276167154312134,
0.16292352974414825,
0.3278457224369049,
-0.5958384275436401,
-0.6548570394515991,
-0.3608570396900177,
0.2433633804321289,
0.13589486479759216,
-0.04598557576537132,
0.5890124440193176,
0.23786820471286774,
-0.6361417770385742,
-0.5442988276481628,
-0.44533732533454895,
0.4711204171180725,
-0.10585328936576843,
-0.7447826862335205,
0.44007906317710876,
-0.15739679336547852,
-0.6021133065223694,
0.7319748997688293,
0.3573726713657379,
-0.15360641479492188,
-0.25611138343811035,
0.04022190719842911,
0.13049423694610596,
-0.010076056234538555,
0.4015355408191681,
-0.07627527415752411,
-0.12087199836969376,
0.20687203109264374,
-0.4458710551261902,
0.20699697732925415,
-0.14242656528949738,
-0.20719477534294128,
0.21787331998348236,
0.5756444334983826,
0.5395988821983337,
-0.3644939064979553,
0.16179242730140686,
0.6192565560340881,
-0.21128278970718384,
-0.6219801306724548,
-0.5339159369468689,
-0.42927104234695435,
-0.4214865267276764,
0.5496340990066528,
-0.5623778104782104,
-0.7619220614433289,
0.31254252791404724,
0.00595439225435257,
0.4393506944179535,
0.2879992723464966,
0.45854493975639343,
0.12461576610803604,
0.7953675985336304,
0.7991767525672913,
0.1891656219959259,
0.293533056974411,
-0.3923880457878113,
0.32716307044029236,
-0.4287317395210266,
0.002506403485313058,
-0.8213136196136475,
-0.11948498338460922,
-0.09415752440690994,
-0.5413916110992432,
0.23303790390491486,
-0.3291916847229004,
-0.13556018471717834,
0.2121851146221161,
-0.8975740671157837,
0.5522141456604004,
0.6333510875701904,
-0.025341719388961792,
0.399116188287735,
-0.008909116499125957,
-0.2323133498430252,
0.010418182238936424,
-0.8217340707778931,
-0.7551013231277466,
0.9679825901985168,
0.0997871533036232,
1.074941635131836,
-0.1313624531030655,
0.7254699468612671,
0.5769749879837036,
0.6076157093048096,
-0.719307541847229,
0.39732053875923157,
0.4593642055988312,
-0.673679530620575,
-0.25096383690834045,
-0.2445853352546692,
-0.9605888724327087,
0.2564699351787567,
0.09281602501869202,
-0.5139561295509338,
0.11663373559713364,
0.11199937760829926,
-0.2211497277021408,
0.23125287890434265,
-0.5573676824569702,
0.7041571736335754,
-0.33568018674850464,
-0.7354961633682251,
-0.4080865681171417,
-0.2988419830799103,
0.32921645045280457,
-0.16553382575511932,
0.027939505875110626,
0.11003786325454712,
0.16917841136455536,
0.8781635165214539,
-0.5909906625747681,
0.6746968626976013,
-0.19395075738430023,
-0.017839064821600914,
0.74814373254776,
0.3352709412574768,
0.6082598567008972,
-0.007708027493208647,
-0.25969991087913513,
-0.378555566072464,
-0.14188243448734283,
-0.2837466895580292,
-0.35409656167030334,
0.7464303970336914,
-0.9280688762664795,
-0.7244538068771362,
-0.46095526218414307,
-0.922447681427002,
0.0010054418817162514,
0.27387791872024536,
0.30924442410469055,
0.15626485645771027,
-0.3901265263557434,
-0.08046388626098633,
0.38309618830680847,
0.04390565678477287,
0.28777092695236206,
0.6403526663780212,
-0.18767264485359192,
-0.4414975941181183,
1.1025714874267578,
0.1386023908853531,
0.0828152447938919,
0.32422715425491333,
0.33669596910476685,
-0.07539623230695724,
-0.5282443761825562,
-0.37408071756362915,
0.24283850193023682,
-0.7314364314079285,
-0.14808721840381622,
-0.7956516146659851,
-0.16018977761268616,
-0.4251258671283722,
-0.2518705129623413,
-0.4382879137992859,
-0.5076718926429749,
-0.11709149926900864,
-0.06238735839724541,
0.5266458988189697,
1.1114486455917358,
-0.060047026723623276,
-0.010505053214728832,
-0.5360198616981506,
0.09703665971755981,
0.29564881324768066,
-0.043619897216558456,
0.1987450271844864,
-0.3737756013870239,
-0.3116315007209778,
-0.22313353419303894,
-0.4861193299293518,
-0.7075828313827515,
0.6590108275413513,
0.09912048280239105,
0.4193177819252014,
0.24388299882411957,
0.029445050284266472,
0.3328063488006592,
-0.6727823615074158,
0.5348901748657227,
0.1355932503938675,
-0.46890297532081604,
0.5671483874320984,
-0.38269737362861633,
0.14478759467601776,
0.6990571022033691,
0.29593974351882935,
-0.24459388852119446,
-0.44478046894073486,
-0.5689514875411987,
-0.7783253192901611,
0.31864213943481445,
0.2905719578266144,
-0.3015596866607666,
0.19115577638149261,
0.12509235739707947,
0.293108195066452,
0.4683558940887451,
-0.5993772149085999,
0.38998064398765564,
-0.5339566469192505,
-0.11379455029964447,
0.20983245968818665,
0.012756492011249065,
-0.5454255938529968,
-0.09236080199480057,
0.9521524310112,
-0.3441329896450043,
0.44306880235671997,
0.4944024980068207,
-0.1492481827735901,
-0.5478096008300781,
0.6016106605529785,
0.6311392784118652,
1.120103359222412,
-0.18285684287548065,
0.319051057100296,
-0.34548571705818176,
-0.5379543304443359,
0.3996730148792267,
0.5805243849754333,
-0.5590960383415222,
0.035769205540418625,
0.0888049304485321,
0.5524905920028687,
-0.20489411056041718,
-0.6640360355377197,
0.14715109765529633,
-0.42735251784324646,
-0.45422783493995667,
-0.3299940228462219,
0.07740047574043274,
0.4122288227081299,
0.26850759983062744,
0.6664091944694519,
0.25337621569633484,
0.1772889792919159,
-0.35821595788002014,
0.09189843386411667,
0.4235609173774719,
-0.20978452265262604,
-0.5697672367095947,
0.5864993333816528,
0.21983197331428528,
-0.5702457427978516,
0.06399621069431305,
-0.5178965330123901,
-0.4700886607170105,
0.9177559018135071,
0.8436703085899353,
1.1458123922348022,
0.13730821013450623,
0.5570486187934875,
0.13739627599716187,
0.49187415838241577,
0.014413892291486263,
0.414747953414917,
0.12697403132915497,
-0.7042953968048096,
-0.4808753430843353,
-0.7272852063179016,
-0.48215579986572266,
0.25277766585350037,
-0.12070781737565994,
0.11538251489400864,
-0.2026064097881317,
-0.34981390833854675,
0.35929086804389954,
0.12987327575683594,
-0.5722223520278931,
-0.35366517305374146,
-0.37526196241378784,
0.8166473507881165,
-0.7213659286499023,
0.8275198936462402,
1.2306350469589233,
-0.6361722350120544,
-0.9059493541717529,
-0.2835547924041748,
-0.15161104500293732,
-0.3072535991668701,
0.652504563331604,
-0.02292143739759922,
-0.35966169834136963,
0.24492505192756653,
-0.5390564799308777,
-0.8879817128181458,
1.2582958936691284,
0.1283113956451416,
-0.5457537174224854,
-0.09174207597970963,
0.04876184090971947,
0.7187424898147583,
-0.7561459541320801,
0.34443435072898865,
0.26157674193382263,
0.7129213809967041,
0.1962052434682846,
-0.7986692190170288,
0.02982715331017971,
-0.871940553188324,
-0.21913358569145203,
0.08081169426441193,
-0.5388442873954773,
0.8267896771430969,
-0.5293101668357849,
0.07361368089914322,
0.2245909720659256,
0.4392946660518646,
0.47787144780158997,
0.37134191393852234,
0.26955702900886536,
0.5672407746315002,
0.7812530398368835,
0.3490997850894928,
0.8689756393432617,
-0.27262815833091736,
0.11360303312540054,
1.1155065298080444,
-0.578011691570282,
0.3583351671695709,
0.3631807565689087,
0.18355226516723633,
0.4068315327167511,
0.32173797488212585,
-0.14835204184055328,
0.3801717758178711,
0.2454633265733719,
-0.3376215696334839,
0.0066094654612243176,
-0.539581298828125,
-0.24258844554424286,
0.1432618498802185,
0.21241821348667145,
-0.40672412514686584,
-0.24364396929740906,
0.34223437309265137,
0.2474747747182846,
0.2648996114730835,
-0.08530440181493759,
0.5996042490005493,
0.030330965295433998,
-0.8999476432800293,
0.2786416709423065,
-0.1378897726535797,
0.2809332609176636,
-0.707973062992096,
-0.16771133244037628,
0.14648163318634033,
0.29081085324287415,
-0.10424163937568665,
-0.6437469720840454,
-0.2083936333656311,
0.1370842456817627,
-0.3046763241291046,
0.0220516175031662,
1.2714967727661133,
-0.3733850121498108,
-0.6498837471008301,
0.024281924590468407,
0.6981558203697205,
0.08527711778879166,
0.09107090532779694,
-0.6908634901046753,
0.07078322023153305,
-0.2740539610385895,
-0.6169542670249939,
-0.013864151202142239,
0.6854614615440369,
-0.2252582460641861,
0.6895705461502075,
0.5063559412956238,
0.5856097936630249,
-0.14122557640075684,
0.2803720533847809,
1.13859224319458,
-0.7772243618965149,
-0.5008245706558228,
-0.5271527171134949,
0.37639954686164856,
-0.42363569140434265,
-0.2595219314098358,
0.7035056948661804,
0.37680867314338684,
0.34783002734184265,
-0.14792458713054657,
1.3754887580871582,
-0.2686026394367218,
0.4999464750289917,
0.2704885005950928,
0.90927654504776,
-0.1458139717578888,
-0.03672271594405174,
-0.37783780694007874,
-0.8506958484649658,
-0.09182705730199814,
0.642041027545929,
-0.2937700152397156,
0.0001714176032692194,
1.0139005184173584,
0.744354784488678,
0.07786095887422562,
0.06126689910888672,
0.0036415245849639177,
0.3189086616039276,
0.8005414605140686,
0.09376844763755798,
0.9434565901756287,
0.0712222084403038,
0.5501344203948975,
-0.24247586727142334,
-0.361099511384964,
-0.03458760678768158,
-0.808807373046875,
-1.029363989830017,
-0.42468586564064026,
-0.19674968719482422,
-0.3066853880882263,
0.17848628759384155,
0.9445645809173584,
0.544330894947052,
-0.5259510278701782,
-0.44174161553382874,
-0.5727415084838867,
-0.17761340737342834,
-0.08646579831838608,
-0.3514755964279175,
0.41899028420448303,
-0.4854578971862793,
-0.4568254053592682,
0.37105658650398254,
0.1938983052968979,
-0.40927350521087646,
-0.6570636034011841,
-0.07119417190551758,
-0.3247452974319458,
0.30916473269462585,
0.46436187624931335,
0.35797977447509766,
-0.3515012562274933,
-0.1022840067744255,
0.1872720867395401,
-0.19022037088871002,
-0.1930810958147049,
1.2146141529083252,
-0.6275677680969238,
0.7319573163986206,
0.4957190752029419,
0.8296129703521729,
0.699478805065155,
-0.0713895782828331,
0.7209892868995667,
-0.36145108938217163,
0.1298283189535141,
0.8103477358818054,
0.19389310479164124,
0.45445212721824646,
-0.3018798828125,
0.5745249390602112,
0.16181835532188416,
-1.0325709581375122,
-0.8595455288887024,
0.12741166353225708,
-0.6718035936355591,
-0.4515939950942993,
1.0724585056304932,
0.026936795562505722,
-0.6484036445617676,
-0.10807742923498154,
-0.5717897415161133,
0.13686883449554443,
-0.8490556478500366,
1.0898059606552124,
0.4701586961746216,
-0.2688869535923004,
0.0027329912409186363,
-0.4201197028160095,
0.5497109293937683,
0.3556345999240875,
-0.9990270137786865,
0.06672616302967072,
0.35349240899086,
0.22565150260925293,
0.6902452111244202,
0.804878830909729,
0.06670215725898743,
0.35233044624328613,
0.3380247950553894,
0.8344817161560059,
-0.1825411021709442,
-0.30404844880104065,
0.39306947588920593,
0.4985414445400238,
0.5313209891319275,
0.3371140956878662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07720v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07720v2
|
Automatic Generation and Evaluation of Reading Comprehension Test Items with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-11T13:11:21 | 2024-05-20T19:08:00 |
Andreas Säuberli, Simon Clematide
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Reading comprehension tests are used in a variety of applications, reaching
from education to assessing the comprehensibility of simplified texts. However,
creating such tests manually and ensuring their quality is difficult and
time-consuming. In this paper, we explore how large language models (LLMs) can
be used to generate and evaluate multiple-choice reading comprehension items.
To this end, we compiled a dataset of German reading comprehension items and
developed a new protocol for human and automatic evaluation, including a metric
we call text informativity, which is based on guessability and answerability.
We then used this protocol and the dataset to evaluate the quality of items
generated by Llama 2 and GPT-4. Our results suggest that both models are
capable of generating items of acceptable quality in a zero-shot setting, but
GPT-4 clearly outperforms Llama 2. We also show that LLMs can be used for
automatic evaluation by eliciting item reponses from them. In this scenario,
evaluation results with GPT-4 were the most similar to human annotators.
Overall, zero-shot generation with LLMs is a promising approach for generating
and evaluating reading comprehension test items, in particular for languages
without large amounts of available data.
|
[
-0.4130364954471588,
-0.7832398414611816,
0.7888776659965515,
-0.08308777958154678,
-0.3388574421405792,
-0.2521817088127136,
-0.056888923048973083,
-0.6186622977256775,
-0.16525103151798248,
0.3548395037651062,
-0.4610292613506317,
-0.24479718506336212,
-0.49762481451034546,
0.6119645237922668,
-0.5320116281509399,
0.9937900304794312,
-0.39386123418807983,
-0.13091720640659332,
-0.2748830318450928,
-0.07264643162488937,
-0.3686024248600006,
-0.2965383529663086,
-0.5012112259864807,
-0.6090770363807678,
0.5913995504379272,
0.44466108083724976,
0.6368125677108765,
0.6829525828361511,
0.5649404525756836,
0.28363433480262756,
0.1198621615767479,
0.06757377833127975,
-0.28136545419692993,
0.26494860649108887,
-0.08002679795026779,
-0.38909977674484253,
-0.3278498649597168,
0.15579168498516083,
0.6960373520851135,
0.3980165123939514,
0.0019325587200000882,
0.42560791969299316,
0.0726633369922638,
0.4923088848590851,
-0.3646009862422943,
0.087111696600914,
-0.5253758430480957,
0.12441328912973404,
0.05340580642223358,
-0.2951890230178833,
-0.5034972429275513,
-0.3368534743785858,
0.3119647800922394,
-0.5432066321372986,
0.21486522257328033,
0.16552717983722687,
0.9084262251853943,
0.3101089596748352,
-0.5138263702392578,
-0.6393044590950012,
-0.4827336072921753,
0.6474326848983765,
-0.7596576809883118,
0.32897716760635376,
0.6266428828239441,
0.3495190143585205,
0.14637012779712677,
-0.5622791051864624,
-0.8682018518447876,
-0.5460851788520813,
0.07721015065908432,
0.24157817661762238,
-0.07772880047559738,
-0.2263352870941162,
0.2694566249847412,
0.22543853521347046,
-0.8457422256469727,
0.07984211295843124,
-0.24935691058635712,
0.010132814757525921,
0.7260265350341797,
0.2485235631465912,
0.26182541251182556,
-0.3759273588657379,
-0.2544475793838501,
-0.22160854935646057,
-0.6835269927978516,
-0.10665813088417053,
0.48509204387664795,
-0.02478770911693573,
0.15329942107200623,
0.9448556303977966,
-0.3330850601196289,
0.9003475308418274,
-0.02508811466395855,
-0.3042048215866089,
0.3135448694229126,
-0.6417540907859802,
-0.26601937413215637,
-0.23879683017730713,
0.7044578790664673,
0.3915458023548126,
0.4223663806915283,
-0.12223058938980103,
-0.44377565383911133,
-0.06758814305067062,
0.11837014555931091,
-0.8643928170204163,
-0.04897236451506615,
0.327526330947876,
-0.44040447473526,
-0.46468475461006165,
-0.12634842097759247,
-0.45681479573249817,
-0.18992944061756134,
-0.29650285840034485,
0.6438778638839722,
-0.4701623320579529,
0.05664009973406792,
0.2622043192386627,
-0.09153973311185837,
0.47778621315956116,
0.16939698159694672,
-0.8256874680519104,
-0.04582853242754936,
0.25679802894592285,
0.7890929579734802,
-0.22811129689216614,
-0.49749475717544556,
-0.6221709847450256,
0.15118148922920227,
-0.41336193680763245,
1.1570407152175903,
-0.4471350908279419,
-0.23999188840389252,
-0.06265294551849365,
-0.1877245157957077,
-0.02698364481329918,
-0.36166590452194214,
0.450767457485199,
-0.703061580657959,
0.4281136989593506,
-0.2736825942993164,
-0.8018918633460999,
-0.17370344698429108,
0.569099485874176,
-0.6393200159072876,
0.96917325258255,
0.2806711494922638,
-0.7543814778327942,
0.5006728768348694,
-0.7487363815307617,
-0.4808463454246521,
0.28372102975845337,
0.058875247836112976,
-0.377824068069458,
-0.08389671891927719,
0.3495323061943054,
0.5463139414787292,
-0.4499174952507019,
0.1107623502612114,
-0.3959333598613739,
-0.5848663449287415,
0.4837304949760437,
-0.6708334684371948,
0.47516191005706787,
0.006829097401350737,
-0.31424814462661743,
-0.07908705621957779,
-0.5373568534851074,
0.1850852519273758,
0.28567513823509216,
-0.5643733739852905,
0.010280300863087177,
-0.10427599400281906,
-0.13200686872005463,
0.25467798113822937,
0.2178374081850052,
-0.537397563457489,
0.06507988274097443,
-0.3690784275531769,
0.37925902009010315,
0.691048264503479,
0.3158385753631592,
0.3619566559791565,
-0.6218153834342957,
0.7354634404182434,
-0.2004818618297577,
0.1830858588218689,
-0.3978497087955475,
-0.478858083486557,
-0.8553686141967773,
0.015457929112017155,
0.34241536259651184,
0.7530019283294678,
-0.9605348706245422,
0.560209333896637,
-0.07068396359682083,
-0.6871635317802429,
-0.30009621381759644,
0.13409945368766785,
0.26081082224845886,
0.5820115804672241,
-0.007003124803304672,
-0.07001237571239471,
0.07967712730169296,
-0.6278702616691589,
-0.06374754756689072,
-0.3809633255004883,
-0.22599497437477112,
0.3772883415222168,
0.6719563007354736,
-0.26261332631111145,
0.6976466178894043,
-0.5271117687225342,
-0.036309584975242615,
-0.1122165322303772,
-0.021519199013710022,
0.10267847031354904,
0.03466608747839928,
0.5659485459327698,
-0.3653319776058197,
-0.32173049449920654,
-0.0697939395904541,
-0.7490119338035583,
-0.3278917670249939,
-0.033717457205057144,
-0.12496533989906311,
0.2772941291332245,
0.19575534760951996,
-0.45403853058815,
0.11351051181554794,
0.5313078761100769,
-0.4814651906490326,
0.8769580125808716,
-0.16425953805446625,
0.17321598529815674,
-0.9999828338623047,
0.053489651530981064,
0.04436706006526947,
-0.29059967398643494,
-0.46834608912467957,
0.2135050743818283,
0.1541607677936554,
-0.05587201565504074,
-0.489009290933609,
0.8576357364654541,
-0.35677579045295715,
-0.17199106514453888,
-0.18306107819080353,
0.3359244763851166,
0.22040130198001862,
0.14474953711032867,
-0.00969751924276352,
0.7100417017936707,
0.45113807916641235,
-0.5536974668502808,
0.430882066488266,
0.32171735167503357,
-0.5333850383758545,
0.7005511522293091,
-0.7531293630599976,
0.11816725879907608,
-0.2817803919315338,
0.29672303795814514,
-1.0111819505691528,
-0.4013173282146454,
0.2834745943546295,
-0.3760398328304291,
0.02438158169388771,
0.2278832495212555,
-0.7586789131164551,
-0.4496477246284485,
-0.2725718021392822,
0.31674227118492126,
0.4956952631473541,
-0.44986671209335327,
0.22101671993732452,
0.08245526999235153,
-0.45440033078193665,
-0.45819538831710815,
-0.750459611415863,
-0.09406338632106781,
-0.22840958833694458,
-0.6346192359924316,
-0.2294388711452484,
-0.5462467074394226,
-0.13338017463684082,
-0.1193387359380722,
0.0517568364739418,
-0.04883873090147972,
0.053131189197301865,
0.00040724739665165544,
0.4105774760246277,
-0.13957776129245758,
0.2689189016819,
0.27054694294929504,
-0.24182939529418945,
-0.1470353752374649,
-0.1919122189283371,
0.42356622219085693,
-0.17518456280231476,
-0.7606358528137207,
-0.3715668022632599,
0.3312464654445648,
0.29733413457870483,
-0.3066876232624054,
0.2823912799358368,
0.5727683901786804,
-0.228223517537117,
-0.2600780427455902,
-0.6254262924194336,
-0.36274001002311707,
-0.49006572365760803,
0.23646345734596252,
-0.4351503551006317,
-0.9024161100387573,
0.31847673654556274,
0.33326244354248047,
0.24796272814273834,
0.41792574524879456,
0.7335789799690247,
-0.21288344264030457,
1.0038955211639404,
0.23622624576091766,
0.15466190874576569,
0.2748437523841858,
-0.05155232548713684,
0.14112961292266846,
-0.6603044867515564,
0.03235127031803131,
-0.47074633836746216,
-0.07013185322284698,
-0.1622389405965805,
-0.3859468102455139,
0.3862512707710266,
-0.0038962853141129017,
-0.3148020803928375,
0.12175332009792328,
-0.539630651473999,
0.6872203350067139,
0.5616719722747803,
0.008266148157417774,
0.6903504729270935,
0.1971217840909958,
-0.14344216883182526,
0.24139347672462463,
-0.5016809701919556,
-0.9536407589912415,
1.3169081211090088,
0.36442312598228455,
0.45965132117271423,
-0.016020458191633224,
0.7397690415382385,
0.2742867171764374,
0.5343619585037231,
-1.0796419382095337,
0.4728137254714966,
0.14765073359012604,
-0.47515490651130676,
-0.6030439734458923,
-0.37605106830596924,
-0.9461146593093872,
0.26858043670654297,
0.03356253355741501,
-0.5225260257720947,
-0.07225815951824188,
-0.0734611377120018,
-0.43864336609840393,
-0.047237761318683624,
-0.8031208515167236,
0.6298800110816956,
-0.21307189762592316,
0.15885142982006073,
0.22555117309093475,
-0.3559482991695404,
0.46986451745033264,
-0.5726991295814514,
-0.02667565457522869,
-0.2793160378932953,
-0.2615588903427124,
0.6976319551467896,
-0.06839078664779663,
0.4743329882621765,
0.08435407280921936,
-0.3422364294528961,
0.4789975881576538,
0.3371436893939972,
0.384424090385437,
0.22739313542842865,
-0.5461105108261108,
0.06497062742710114,
0.2968330979347229,
-0.4009915888309479,
-0.4457928240299225,
0.4284091591835022,
-0.7662674784660339,
-0.4072401523590088,
-0.5050674080848694,
-0.672496497631073,
-0.20919352769851685,
0.4955390393733978,
0.28711944818496704,
0.4338012933731079,
-0.09803774952888489,
-0.09663081169128418,
0.44948717951774597,
-0.1809718757867813,
0.6524761915206909,
0.8596265912055969,
0.017559640109539032,
-0.2824775278568268,
0.8737897872924805,
0.16290108859539032,
0.4212091267108917,
0.11966094374656677,
0.13982369005680084,
-0.5444610118865967,
-0.6682730317115784,
-0.749178409576416,
0.3067547678947449,
-0.7366613149642944,
-0.2414921075105667,
-0.31635159254074097,
-0.21644996106624603,
-0.11981581151485443,
-0.23084527254104614,
0.14563697576522827,
-0.16177941858768463,
-0.3391631245613098,
-0.25045809149742126,
0.14631713926792145,
0.9751787185668945,
-0.02290346287190914,
0.28419312834739685,
-0.8025218844413757,
0.31166037917137146,
0.3481808602809906,
0.31293079257011414,
0.036097243428230286,
-0.5823763012886047,
-0.09581129997968674,
-0.11753908544778824,
-0.37026163935661316,
-0.98760986328125,
0.24323728680610657,
0.013558605685830116,
0.3173380494117737,
0.47261860966682434,
0.0349496491253376,
0.27786949276924133,
-0.6408957242965698,
0.8946426510810852,
-0.013045074418187141,
-0.9040907025337219,
0.17305879294872284,
-0.44527554512023926,
0.43604153394699097,
0.4856608808040619,
0.1369711309671402,
-0.5289067625999451,
-0.4646027088165283,
-0.49486079812049866,
-0.5648744702339172,
0.6522819995880127,
0.2494116872549057,
0.17722463607788086,
-0.07249432057142258,
0.36273059248924255,
0.33257341384887695,
0.08485935628414154,
-0.7784910798072815,
0.026966020464897156,
-0.052079938352108,
-0.2322339117527008,
-0.2402535080909729,
-0.37047290802001953,
-0.07101216912269592,
0.06013103201985359,
0.6498271822929382,
-0.21462614834308624,
0.2252286672592163,
0.23349812626838684,
-0.0844717025756836,
-0.11063677072525024,
0.2743361294269562,
0.4155767261981964,
0.794448971748352,
0.06550513952970505,
-0.043447740375995636,
0.25151926279067993,
-0.3439372181892395,
0.5029714107513428,
0.15971091389656067,
-0.5088299512863159,
-0.10312534868717194,
0.527535617351532,
0.73905348777771,
-0.23416440188884735,
-0.849635899066925,
0.560354471206665,
-0.12267614901065826,
-0.404798299074173,
-0.3703259825706482,
0.07432640343904495,
0.10354379564523697,
0.29783177375793457,
0.2483035773038864,
-0.3997822701931,
0.09508556127548218,
-0.21564961969852448,
0.3462964594364166,
0.2771480977535248,
-0.0726580023765564,
-0.03786337375640869,
0.4242047369480133,
0.13971532881259918,
-0.17511191964149475,
0.5802263617515564,
-0.5459120869636536,
-0.11807969957590103,
0.5199858546257019,
0.6536698341369629,
0.5773431658744812,
-0.24387118220329285,
0.6484197974205017,
0.2091088443994522,
0.6172923445701599,
-0.040363240987062454,
0.44761747121810913,
-0.045303136110305786,
-0.8181541562080383,
-0.6267976760864258,
-0.7867853045463562,
-0.5358719229698181,
0.2412310391664505,
-0.49441683292388916,
0.031102962791919708,
-0.08290442079305649,
-0.027620697394013405,
-0.12271704524755478,
0.09099753946065903,
-0.8416626453399658,
0.2653220593929291,
0.01946522295475006,
0.8018436431884766,
-0.9421199560165405,
0.6487967371940613,
0.6037715673446655,
-0.48227667808532715,
-0.8963279128074646,
0.22729706764221191,
-0.24410319328308105,
-0.8508257269859314,
0.3064384460449219,
0.19651901721954346,
0.22437424957752228,
0.05841216444969177,
-0.17620259523391724,
-0.9782288074493408,
1.0680241584777832,
0.40386924147605896,
-0.5375887155532837,
-0.13594448566436768,
0.33014237880706787,
0.49924156069755554,
-0.09085768461227417,
0.623175859451294,
0.7838451266288757,
0.7803894877433777,
0.028416508808732033,
-0.799585223197937,
0.08529185503721237,
-0.14636199176311493,
-0.08284684270620346,
0.04877424240112305,
-0.4749641716480255,
0.6290074586868286,
-0.11439356207847595,
-0.10120779275894165,
0.18519432842731476,
0.35254234075546265,
0.5769450068473816,
0.2452087104320526,
0.4982340335845947,
0.566735565662384,
0.8855700492858887,
0.04527260735630989,
1.32117760181427,
-0.12521840631961823,
0.29299113154411316,
0.9855142831802368,
-0.5471401810646057,
0.992196261882782,
0.21088562905788422,
-0.04669933766126633,
0.29513055086135864,
0.8844630718231201,
-0.18408465385437012,
0.1751343458890915,
0.24059167504310608,
-0.2374858558177948,
-0.24119681119918823,
0.09959154576063156,
-0.1675540655851364,
0.4832206964492798,
0.04400619864463806,
-0.3387327194213867,
-0.3853755593299866,
0.0896308422088623,
-0.058645956218242645,
-0.3395477831363678,
-0.06357377767562866,
0.8638083338737488,
0.01904991827905178,
-0.8091352581977844,
0.6779364347457886,
0.01799067109823227,
0.38307589292526245,
-0.4644380509853363,
0.17736203968524933,
-0.16916009783744812,
-0.11522781103849411,
-0.020543716847896576,
-1.2095832824707031,
0.16523630917072296,
0.2436838001012802,
-0.1090269386768341,
-0.03899864852428436,
0.6793152093887329,
-0.3736366033554077,
-0.7263141870498657,
0.11225008964538574,
0.7762627601623535,
0.4601537585258484,
-0.0910770520567894,
-0.6824462413787842,
-0.15529803931713104,
-0.015942992642521858,
-0.7847411632537842,
0.24271605908870697,
0.34484583139419556,
0.17639786005020142,
0.707815408706665,
0.7604184150695801,
0.09986508637666702,
0.00911196880042553,
0.16288411617279053,
0.4146939516067505,
-0.45303839445114136,
-0.33022743463516235,
-0.8696780204772949,
0.4046555757522583,
0.06625854223966599,
-0.31705471873283386,
0.6991205215454102,
0.35362768173217773,
0.747154951095581,
-0.056316960602998734,
1.1154778003692627,
0.17069865763187408,
0.3776049315929413,
-0.3823959529399872,
0.8223431706428528,
-0.4812406301498413,
-0.034623488783836365,
-0.268433541059494,
-1.1835899353027344,
-0.2684725821018219,
0.4719148874282837,
-0.2627388834953308,
0.10684869438409805,
0.8821357488632202,
0.6047513484954834,
-0.036527976393699646,
-0.0002100667916238308,
0.3827490210533142,
0.035412080585956573,
0.2904069125652313,
0.6145698428153992,
0.762301504611969,
-0.3911548852920532,
0.7543764114379883,
0.03247814625501633,
-0.39150819182395935,
-0.036480385810136795,
-0.9616698026657104,
-0.9992974996566772,
-0.7046703100204468,
-0.11115936189889908,
-0.2635856568813324,
-0.13886460661888123,
0.4772682189941406,
0.4981924593448639,
-0.46347305178642273,
-0.13214318454265594,
0.07143674045801163,
0.06570401787757874,
0.056576602160930634,
-0.2215113341808319,
0.3906978666782379,
-0.32867905497550964,
-0.7966097593307495,
0.36458760499954224,
0.26763367652893066,
0.29518625140190125,
-0.42904001474380493,
-0.04538554698228836,
0.16729073226451874,
0.37973278760910034,
0.794382631778717,
0.005203912500292063,
-0.619390070438385,
-0.4315662086009979,
0.029012421146035194,
0.07171317934989929,
-0.17540304362773895,
0.37469449639320374,
-0.5789473056793213,
0.4617055356502533,
0.6927080750465393,
0.6682929396629333,
0.426553875207901,
0.07723405212163925,
0.45789575576782227,
-0.3536231517791748,
-0.1636582314968109,
0.34264034032821655,
0.3482866883277893,
0.36243754625320435,
-0.2393268197774887,
0.48230355978012085,
-0.17595677077770233,
-0.9161005020141602,
-0.8859080076217651,
0.3673814833164215,
-0.7345197200775146,
-0.04807526245713234,
1.4666370153427124,
-0.0960194543004036,
-0.18231931328773499,
0.002318113576620817,
-0.32362109422683716,
0.2007974088191986,
-0.31032320857048035,
0.7609735727310181,
0.9436219334602356,
-0.1582852303981781,
-0.10389435291290283,
-0.7103531956672668,
0.21465319395065308,
0.3612072765827179,
-1.1965371370315552,
-0.08427009731531143,
0.5588715672492981,
0.5212924480438232,
-0.07954233139753342,
0.6229467988014221,
-0.0232696570456028,
0.3541088104248047,
-0.12069778889417648,
-0.0025193113833665848,
-0.07949158549308777,
-0.22443947196006775,
-0.23063001036643982,
0.16131773591041565,
0.08075474202632904,
-0.045419830828905106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07677v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07677v2
|
ODA: Observation-Driven Agent for integrating LLMs and Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-04-11T12:16:16 | 2024-06-04T07:16:14 |
Lei Sun, Zhengwei Tao, Youdi Li, Hiroshi Arakawa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) and knowledge graphs (KGs)
has achieved remarkable success in various natural language processing tasks.
However, existing methodologies that integrate LLMs and KGs often navigate the
task-solving process solely based on the LLM's analysis of the question,
overlooking the rich cognitive potential inherent in the vast knowledge
encapsulated in KGs. To address this, we introduce Observation-Driven Agent
(ODA), a novel AI agent framework tailored for tasks involving KGs. ODA
incorporates KG reasoning abilities via global observation, which enhances
reasoning capabilities through a cyclical paradigm of observation, action, and
reflection. Confronting the exponential explosion of knowledge during
observation, we innovatively design a recursive observation mechanism.
Subsequently, we integrate the observed knowledge into the action and
reflection modules. Through extensive experiments, ODA demonstrates
state-of-the-art performance on several datasets, notably achieving accuracy
improvements of 12.87% and 8.9%.
|
[
-0.27195635437965393,
-0.9338318109512329,
1.1065293550491333,
-0.015143265947699547,
-0.04745868220925331,
0.2588976323604584,
-0.009518048726022243,
-0.48353445529937744,
0.3660582900047302,
0.6148524284362793,
-0.6362901329994202,
-0.6633704900741577,
-0.5488814115524292,
0.05215637385845184,
-0.19309033453464508,
0.7085943222045898,
-0.24537108838558197,
-0.15785673260688782,
-0.42678022384643555,
-0.07068922370672226,
-0.1932588815689087,
0.0014618110144510865,
-0.9786538481712341,
-0.6447465419769287,
0.6044264435768127,
0.22633236646652222,
0.6665475368499756,
0.7078877091407776,
0.13489870727062225,
0.37744802236557007,
0.26540786027908325,
0.9422757029533386,
-0.41577374935150146,
0.27657440304756165,
-0.42185330390930176,
-0.6873646378517151,
-0.7849906086921692,
0.07502474635839462,
0.5329610109329224,
0.7910711169242859,
-0.2381449192762375,
-0.1360529065132141,
-0.1767110973596573,
0.5152756571769714,
-0.6349610686302185,
0.9835940003395081,
-0.1660497784614563,
0.04850577563047409,
0.18168844282627106,
-0.030762474983930588,
-0.31883537769317627,
-0.4081513583660126,
0.0806187093257904,
-0.9833353161811829,
-0.2794530987739563,
-0.04452238976955414,
0.2703091502189636,
0.5762370228767395,
-0.4366267919540405,
-0.4267970323562622,
-0.7249143719673157,
0.5821897983551025,
-0.567964494228363,
0.4205676019191742,
0.16931277513504028,
0.4518413543701172,
-0.45056387782096863,
-0.9032635688781738,
-0.8701359629631042,
-0.1066880077123642,
-0.09604208171367645,
0.16272781789302826,
-0.18548360466957092,
0.050133805721998215,
-0.04770737513899803,
0.019647717475891113,
-0.3371168076992035,
0.05753473937511444,
0.06849602609872818,
0.0030963073950260878,
0.6862874031066895,
0.5157283544540405,
0.13491374254226685,
0.014553779736161232,
-0.2227104753255844,
0.20649147033691406,
-0.358376145362854,
-0.1361512839794159,
0.2721189856529236,
0.3439129889011383,
-0.0673188716173172,
0.5229690074920654,
-0.6943063735961914,
0.890052855014801,
-0.12275531142950058,
-0.19520926475524902,
0.3243882358074188,
-0.2253674417734146,
-0.33619314432144165,
0.02907697856426239,
0.7112067341804504,
0.2321067750453949,
0.24141262471675873,
-0.3207400441169739,
-0.16764287650585175,
0.3114325702190399,
0.2897929251194,
-0.6163615584373474,
-0.13456982374191284,
0.23632600903511047,
-0.12496329098939896,
-0.4527007043361664,
0.07603783160448074,
-0.6772828102111816,
-0.9466649889945984,
-0.3587496876716614,
0.2829500436782837,
-0.4163286089897156,
-0.42532750964164734,
0.19724789261817932,
-0.009411410428583622,
0.1286153495311737,
0.6067123413085938,
-0.4452809989452362,
0.2978930175304413,
0.8198069930076599,
0.5405770540237427,
-0.0790942832827568,
-0.5721747279167175,
-0.7650504112243652,
0.2357499599456787,
-0.5441420078277588,
0.8341268301010132,
-0.7317437529563904,
-0.20118285715579987,
0.04927657172083855,
-0.17475974559783936,
-0.23897379636764526,
-0.40493151545524597,
0.2717783749103546,
-0.9482273459434509,
-0.06093870848417282,
-0.1243431493639946,
-0.4856458604335785,
-0.40306565165519714,
0.5198860764503479,
-0.4197356700897217,
1.002138376235962,
0.3517743647098541,
-0.33621513843536377,
0.5039207935333252,
-1.1410760879516602,
-0.35914573073387146,
0.11061608791351318,
-0.40513840317726135,
0.01382684800773859,
-0.2141343355178833,
0.38276466727256775,
0.3004838824272156,
-0.31441158056259155,
0.256102055311203,
-0.12208148837089539,
-0.09052453190088272,
0.12663617730140686,
-0.16853809356689453,
0.5724918246269226,
0.32165786623954773,
-0.21108783781528473,
0.26086750626564026,
-0.9137361645698547,
0.19599150121212006,
0.26666370034217834,
-0.4118451178073883,
-0.2420348823070526,
0.33678147196769714,
-0.6364990472793579,
-0.1811479777097702,
0.2937392592430115,
-0.5562703609466553,
0.6277992725372314,
-0.390074223279953,
0.630365252494812,
0.7120054364204407,
0.12855204939842224,
0.43074315786361694,
-0.18872655928134918,
0.5906815528869629,
-0.0070420666597783566,
0.18218424916267395,
-0.10965236276388168,
-0.5061814188957214,
-0.7313998341560364,
-0.2992578446865082,
-0.10236161202192307,
0.20891188085079193,
-1.2315673828125,
0.29852065443992615,
-0.4267442226409912,
-0.40833309292793274,
-0.6470285654067993,
0.1963387280702591,
0.3453398644924164,
0.6773979067802429,
0.10781706869602203,
-0.19876722991466522,
-0.37313443422317505,
-0.5643364787101746,
-0.23249603807926178,
-0.43374335765838623,
0.18073770403862,
0.40369218587875366,
0.5059682726860046,
-0.600041389465332,
1.2965004444122314,
-0.8571646213531494,
-0.36182504892349243,
-0.3983705937862396,
0.2618388533592224,
0.3374629318714142,
0.1787310689687729,
0.4682876169681549,
-0.7447536587715149,
-0.5046062469482422,
0.2804695963859558,
-1.1925479173660278,
-0.2960481345653534,
0.15261057019233704,
-0.19009169936180115,
0.44581887125968933,
0.6845911145210266,
-0.6427661776542664,
0.4404987692832947,
0.23251566290855408,
-0.4580453932285309,
0.31807419657707214,
-0.20357061922550201,
-0.0022120520006865263,
-0.8282016515731812,
-0.1216360330581665,
-0.36075830459594727,
-0.43643829226493835,
-0.7260606288909912,
0.2649003863334656,
-0.17607653141021729,
0.24555961787700653,
-0.23944874107837677,
0.6064940094947815,
-0.3772600293159485,
-0.3716251254081726,
-0.4333963096141815,
0.47225329279899597,
0.057993289083242416,
0.6233218908309937,
0.05363588407635689,
0.5887047648429871,
0.5571042895317078,
-0.6786186099052429,
0.7706789374351501,
0.2422456443309784,
-0.6195969581604004,
0.709252655506134,
-0.24995097517967224,
0.44838184118270874,
-0.41296491026878357,
0.03008984960615635,
-0.6032036542892456,
-0.32419225573539734,
0.6186797618865967,
-0.514186680316925,
0.09495317190885544,
0.06978771835565567,
-0.5712634921073914,
-0.15127988159656525,
-0.15994319319725037,
0.2232009917497635,
0.16271165013313293,
-0.7036840319633484,
1.2936989068984985,
0.11540917307138443,
0.07376522570848465,
-0.5981845259666443,
-0.48961323499679565,
-0.07474689185619354,
0.3016194999217987,
-0.5637861490249634,
-0.07192641496658325,
0.15310196578502655,
-0.6063917875289917,
0.4974926710128784,
-0.07279373705387115,
0.2636832892894745,
-0.006300149019807577,
0.18116886913776398,
0.04465484991669655,
-0.27294692397117615,
0.12043651193380356,
-0.12502062320709229,
-0.1670839488506317,
0.18275323510169983,
-0.7085872888565063,
0.6960698962211609,
-0.009280024096369743,
-0.6790474057197571,
-0.32561615109443665,
0.09811874479055405,
0.7513483166694641,
-0.23882444202899933,
0.872886061668396,
0.14987905323505402,
-0.27919113636016846,
-0.6487218141555786,
-0.34112295508384705,
0.16779199242591858,
-0.4792655110359192,
0.48953908681869507,
-0.3343771994113922,
-0.317639023065567,
0.40081897377967834,
0.014300801791250706,
0.010478866286575794,
0.2782256603240967,
0.23450691998004913,
-0.2188238948583603,
1.1247212886810303,
0.637400209903717,
-0.3408249616622925,
0.5435378551483154,
-0.4888366758823395,
0.16366234421730042,
-0.8958302736282349,
-0.43437686562538147,
-0.2416861206293106,
-0.20942771434783936,
-0.2940782606601715,
-0.5241629481315613,
0.5361681580543518,
-0.057491134852170944,
-0.5486313700675964,
-0.20894096791744232,
-0.23990242183208466,
0.39032432436943054,
0.5612608194351196,
0.22207418084144592,
0.6329290270805359,
-0.44588303565979004,
0.07907600700855255,
0.5032950043678284,
-0.8028411269187927,
-0.40338385105133057,
0.9707325100898743,
0.02115231193602085,
0.8357683420181274,
0.08461254835128784,
0.5169160962104797,
0.5521061420440674,
0.5423362255096436,
-0.758237898349762,
0.8365384936332703,
0.24435412883758545,
-0.2428313046693802,
-0.5875359177589417,
-0.48540806770324707,
-0.8527055978775024,
0.2655956745147705,
0.09741431474685669,
-0.7769500017166138,
0.11748988181352615,
0.008320658467710018,
-0.07829272001981735,
0.3149383068084717,
-0.651566743850708,
0.6683757901191711,
-0.1475059688091278,
-0.05718821659684181,
-0.24046555161476135,
-0.4026491343975067,
0.14120808243751526,
0.07574112713336945,
0.3167191445827484,
0.14060281217098236,
-0.09686915576457977,
0.451096773147583,
-0.7490290403366089,
1.1326406002044678,
-0.44709739089012146,
-0.2068583071231842,
0.5570775270462036,
-0.047716327011585236,
1.012908935546875,
-0.10562653094530106,
0.08229294419288635,
-0.1161869540810585,
-0.34919023513793945,
-0.2767597436904907,
-1.0339962244033813,
0.5900985598564148,
-0.8634142875671387,
-0.7086475491523743,
-0.5173267722129822,
-0.8150455355644226,
-0.21612206101417542,
0.3457719683647156,
-0.247761070728302,
0.2554023265838623,
-0.13991987705230713,
-0.2677612006664276,
0.3349226415157318,
0.029536403715610504,
0.24290622770786285,
1.0928411483764648,
-0.7061959505081177,
-0.359725683927536,
0.9059026837348938,
0.0731131061911583,
0.4713505506515503,
0.3743848204612732,
0.09942706674337387,
-0.2253522127866745,
-0.5328601598739624,
-0.3520495295524597,
0.23873284459114075,
-0.8625314235687256,
-0.0211185272783041,
-0.6154851317405701,
-0.14679847657680511,
-0.4796980023384094,
-0.10209767520427704,
-0.22453294694423676,
0.011090532876551151,
-0.07826586067676544,
-0.31999096274375916,
0.4143073260784149,
1.1107829809188843,
0.1261194348335266,
0.12452583014965057,
-0.348868727684021,
0.469231516122818,
0.47132614254951477,
0.4107249081134796,
0.24985910952091217,
-0.07511360943317413,
-0.23679755628108978,
-0.00573876965790987,
-0.1438419669866562,
-0.646029531955719,
0.3243350684642792,
0.026394404470920563,
0.7247962355613708,
0.7490350604057312,
0.14079992473125458,
0.46969375014305115,
-0.20057444274425507,
0.5257605910301208,
-0.24516582489013672,
-0.8133567571640015,
0.5390868186950684,
-0.3435664474964142,
0.31702080368995667,
0.11976653337478638,
0.07355235517024994,
-0.4769730269908905,
-0.6696933507919312,
-0.3433414697647095,
-0.44841063022613525,
0.9925332069396973,
0.09524346888065338,
-0.4035343825817108,
0.0241620484739542,
0.4919475317001343,
0.0586443729698658,
0.4955252707004547,
-0.21535862982273102,
-0.2853119373321533,
-0.10573335736989975,
-0.13041625916957855,
-0.3250354528427124,
0.06716899573802948,
-0.13581717014312744,
-0.03257349506020546,
0.5887812972068787,
-0.5060199499130249,
0.11580970883369446,
0.4004446566104889,
-0.17848926782608032,
-0.08987096697092056,
0.009363415651023388,
0.35149529576301575,
0.649368405342102,
-0.03356491029262543,
0.19906413555145264,
0.08231596648693085,
-0.6599909663200378,
-0.1302417814731598,
0.10839316993951797,
-0.489952027797699,
-0.4109540283679962,
0.6519054770469666,
0.6630770564079285,
0.039279695600271225,
-0.8087510466575623,
-0.02886170893907547,
0.23270848393440247,
-0.098702572286129,
-0.378398597240448,
0.3361395001411438,
0.2510605752468109,
0.9265803098678589,
0.3230895400047302,
0.0033169833477586508,
-0.13637009263038635,
-1.0055633783340454,
-0.2222992479801178,
0.41393449902534485,
-0.27183884382247925,
-0.32982319593429565,
0.6823275685310364,
0.14926466345787048,
-0.4951237738132477,
0.7130390405654907,
-0.4515221416950226,
-0.6108497381210327,
0.9662594199180603,
0.226872980594635,
0.751713216304779,
-0.08578468859195709,
0.30463892221450806,
-0.15242785215377808,
0.33559954166412354,
0.14237777888774872,
0.7964741587638855,
-0.1532786339521408,
-1.2925087213516235,
-0.3341098725795746,
-0.45380711555480957,
-0.5953353643417358,
-0.19824156165122986,
-0.6455112099647522,
-0.08528803288936615,
-0.1632026880979538,
0.13765156269073486,
0.10057912021875381,
0.1205805167555809,
-0.6132582426071167,
0.20316444337368011,
-0.1590883433818817,
0.9293519258499146,
-0.6090660691261292,
1.0071181058883667,
0.8726465106010437,
-0.492885559797287,
-0.5773459672927856,
-0.17231538891792297,
-0.1001611202955246,
-1.1154626607894897,
0.675255298614502,
-0.04768809303641319,
-0.4652665853500366,
0.07689875364303589,
-0.5523741245269775,
-0.7005922198295593,
1.450244665145874,
0.44865578413009644,
-0.20704467594623566,
0.18710587918758392,
0.20528095960617065,
0.6713263988494873,
-0.6914859414100647,
0.05284285172820091,
0.9213240742683411,
0.7745369076728821,
0.04443351551890373,
-0.5740992426872253,
-0.09835927188396454,
-0.09801885485649109,
-0.3823257386684418,
0.43720194697380066,
-0.811161458492279,
0.7655646800994873,
-0.399679571390152,
-0.10377607494592667,
0.05213809013366699,
0.764631986618042,
0.09077274799346924,
0.7722736597061157,
0.6976860761642456,
0.6254987716674805,
0.9934027791023254,
0.06291335076093674,
1.1939020156860352,
-0.12165133655071259,
0.07880619168281555,
1.1699187755584717,
-0.6878619194030762,
0.41454413533210754,
0.34482455253601074,
-0.25677189230918884,
0.6468819975852966,
0.025321878492832184,
0.1876804381608963,
0.6318692564964294,
-0.0383237823843956,
-0.4213953912258148,
-0.23634137213230133,
-0.40704345703125,
0.055356670171022415,
0.36789238452911377,
0.3339478671550751,
-0.31732332706451416,
-0.19297172129154205,
-0.03136223927140236,
0.05124377831816673,
0.3700907230377197,
-0.5816816687583923,
0.891548752784729,
-0.14440487325191498,
-0.8774692416191101,
0.07840455323457718,
-0.1236448809504509,
0.161521777510643,
-0.7139423489570618,
-0.28305912017822266,
-0.2584349811077118,
0.3337896168231964,
-0.22502686083316803,
-0.7486429214477539,
0.21343423426151276,
-0.0691487118601799,
-0.27523452043533325,
-0.2722574472427368,
0.5572967529296875,
-0.18116895854473114,
-0.3169522285461426,
0.5207698941230774,
0.6601031422615051,
0.10437352955341339,
-0.06066127121448517,
0.06230870261788368,
-0.03189895302057266,
-0.1545003354549408,
-0.32085758447647095,
0.258932501077652,
0.6557320356369019,
-0.12422306090593338,
0.9980184435844421,
0.41360700130462646,
0.0784863829612732,
-0.11375566571950912,
0.09076092392206192,
1.161366581916809,
-0.5927708148956299,
-0.5131597518920898,
-0.6889916062355042,
0.22521109879016876,
-0.11727716773748398,
-0.14564228057861328,
0.5561126470565796,
0.49878111481666565,
0.8005505204200745,
0.14608973264694214,
1.0276950597763062,
-0.15886972844600677,
0.5267257690429688,
-0.644120454788208,
0.7264294028282166,
-0.3971361815929413,
0.26240360736846924,
0.06942734122276306,
-0.7045322060585022,
0.09999208152294159,
0.4116581380367279,
-0.48867306113243103,
0.04222422093153,
0.5685185194015503,
0.6877580881118774,
0.24651391804218292,
0.16997429728507996,
0.2673283517360687,
0.7169556617736816,
0.5799199342727661,
0.519333004951477,
0.922521710395813,
0.030286578461527824,
0.5035930871963501,
-0.06236552447080612,
-0.24654749035835266,
0.01884574443101883,
-0.8662037253379822,
-0.9533886909484863,
-0.40501895546913147,
-0.2995220422744751,
-0.034915171563625336,
0.115015409886837,
0.8223327398300171,
0.4142882227897644,
-0.5617132782936096,
0.020514050498604774,
-0.3647434115409851,
0.41346150636672974,
-0.5479199886322021,
-0.2697524130344391,
0.37090080976486206,
-0.37213388085365295,
-0.9233668446540833,
0.7758433222770691,
0.2603858709335327,
-0.4408920705318451,
-0.5128095746040344,
-0.3190663158893585,
-0.054243914783000946,
0.24291963875293732,
0.5851174592971802,
0.3794406056404114,
-0.5924219489097595,
-0.4509928226470947,
-0.16306965053081512,
0.0748433992266655,
-0.009533843025565147,
0.6365272998809814,
-1.1197541952133179,
0.7396368384361267,
0.3956587314605713,
0.5813730359077454,
0.6627447009086609,
-0.07471933960914612,
0.6979821920394897,
-0.5181149840354919,
-0.03725059702992439,
0.20962780714035034,
0.3734129071235657,
-0.08606778085231781,
-0.3490143120288849,
0.8519154191017151,
0.24721655249595642,
-0.34303879737854004,
-0.9031735062599182,
0.34583771228790283,
-0.836794912815094,
-0.16386468708515167,
0.9030048251152039,
-0.22046349942684174,
-0.189926877617836,
-0.1984533965587616,
-0.2658398449420929,
0.17189504206180573,
-0.5152373909950256,
0.8104071617126465,
0.5293564200401306,
-0.4454616904258728,
-0.07094898074865341,
-0.5658246278762817,
0.1404605358839035,
-0.02782803401350975,
-1.0769453048706055,
-0.06590072810649872,
0.4221140444278717,
0.033241238445043564,
0.30440250039100647,
0.7589100003242493,
0.15197527408599854,
0.18677634000778198,
0.15694986283779144,
0.06663303077220917,
-0.6266275644302368,
-0.34521543979644775,
-0.09506571292877197,
0.3089779317378998,
0.031065240502357483,
-0.3813876509666443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07673v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07673v1
|
Curated Datasets and Neural Models for Machine Translation of Informal Registers between Mayan and Spanish Vernaculars
| 2024-04-11T12:09:47 | 2024-04-11T12:09:47 |
Andrés Lou, Juan Antonio Pérez-Ortiz, Felipe Sánchez-Martínez, Víctor M. Sánchez-Cartagena
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The Mayan languages comprise a language family with an ancient history,
millions of speakers, and immense cultural value, that, nevertheless, remains
severely underrepresented in terms of resources and global exposure. In this
paper we develop, curate, and publicly release a set of corpora in several
Mayan languages spoken in Guatemala and Southern Mexico, which we call MayanV.
The datasets are parallel with Spanish, the dominant language of the region,
and are taken from official native sources focused on representing informal,
day-to-day, and non-domain-specific language. As such, and according to our
dialectometric analysis, they differ in register from most other available
resources. Additionally, we present neural machine translation models, trained
on as many resources and Mayan languages as possible, and evaluated exclusively
on our datasets. We observe lexical divergences between the dialects of Spanish
in our resources and the more widespread written standard of Spanish, and that
resources other than the ones we present do not seem to improve translation
performance, indicating that many such resources may not accurately capture
common, real-life language usage. The MayanV dataset is available at
https://github.com/transducens/mayanv.
|
[
-0.15918928384780884,
-0.21925067901611328,
0.2748037576675415,
0.2821939289569855,
-0.25255221128463745,
0.17256216704845428,
-0.564350426197052,
-0.47254160046577454,
0.07013794034719467,
0.4928523600101471,
-0.4028725028038025,
-0.7229524850845337,
-0.6420093774795532,
0.34556844830513,
-0.3225671648979187,
0.9079570770263672,
-0.04879860207438469,
0.24113953113555908,
-0.14938704669475555,
-0.4250613749027252,
-0.11006683111190796,
-0.37786197662353516,
-0.25932541489601135,
-0.15039080381393433,
0.5438961386680603,
0.035557474941015244,
0.8408745527267456,
1.1452902555465698,
0.3820469081401825,
0.2953069806098938,
-0.19531433284282684,
0.3043659031391144,
-0.42437830567359924,
0.13645441830158234,
-0.1684989184141159,
-0.3281823396682739,
-0.3637976348400116,
-0.13576443493366241,
0.4737086594104767,
0.9281598329544067,
0.04938910901546478,
0.40718016028404236,
-0.03718750923871994,
0.1783328503370285,
-0.6200669407844543,
0.48819345235824585,
-0.42600497603416443,
0.08752874284982681,
-0.5357411503791809,
-0.09368700534105301,
-0.06236277520656586,
-0.765408992767334,
0.21853433549404144,
-0.31340542435646057,
0.45241373777389526,
-0.03604467585682869,
0.537176251411438,
0.3431960344314575,
-0.6025644540786743,
-0.3314440846443176,
-0.734955906867981,
0.6927933096885681,
-0.6254261136054993,
0.3075191080570221,
0.44251611828804016,
0.17610274255275726,
-0.2350430190563202,
-0.6951117515563965,
-0.32825204730033875,
-0.32514679431915283,
-0.015857283025979996,
0.09138476103544235,
-0.3994365930557251,
0.03518671914935112,
-0.20216608047485352,
0.4706418216228485,
-0.519518256187439,
0.1543530374765396,
-0.6030461192131042,
-0.21952494978904724,
0.49068528413772583,
0.3973641097545624,
0.17446890473365784,
-0.1587139368057251,
-0.1269637793302536,
-0.1380372792482376,
-0.8171581029891968,
-0.14735089242458344,
0.6447176337242126,
0.6079319715499878,
-0.08042442053556442,
0.7387197613716125,
-0.14705577492713928,
0.9911755323410034,
-0.43023014068603516,
-0.18698370456695557,
0.27553853392601013,
-0.7318421602249146,
-0.17717494070529938,
-0.1356869637966156,
0.7777433395385742,
0.07185116410255432,
0.11784236878156662,
-0.4706234037876129,
-0.5046923160552979,
-0.021782968193292618,
0.1900341510772705,
-0.4287540912628174,
-0.10916619747877121,
-0.0869082659482956,
-0.40083763003349304,
-0.27320125699043274,
-0.001444379799067974,
-0.5846372842788696,
-0.4226457476615906,
-0.6337214708328247,
-0.013390988111495972,
-0.030158361420035362,
-0.3445470929145813,
0.05733976885676384,
0.06263720989227295,
-0.0006457999115809798,
0.2584437131881714,
-0.6055132150650024,
0.6255191564559937,
0.6560930013656616,
1.1452568769454956,
-0.250683456659317,
-0.05856526270508766,
0.08696805685758591,
-0.30204710364341736,
-0.5086348056793213,
0.42713648080825806,
-0.3557210862636566,
-0.3242911398410797,
0.3211350440979004,
0.07629036158323288,
-0.015124521218240261,
-0.6838140487670898,
0.2695249617099762,
-0.6826566457748413,
-0.026891984045505524,
-0.17330752313137054,
0.019541965797543526,
-0.001307024504058063,
0.09213846176862717,
-0.8422523140907288,
1.0446385145187378,
0.2844076454639435,
-0.3473508059978485,
0.07554472982883453,
-0.1663680225610733,
-0.4263363480567932,
-0.19313110411167145,
0.04040206968784332,
0.03880154341459274,
0.2227218896150589,
0.06250003725290298,
0.560112476348877,
-0.5239101648330688,
0.3761621117591858,
-0.09670881927013397,
-0.12114041298627853,
0.32461562752723694,
-0.4849703013896942,
0.8164211511611938,
0.5914030075073242,
-0.2835976481437683,
-0.07249820977449417,
-0.6918410062789917,
-0.33683353662490845,
-0.05660491809248924,
-0.175550177693367,
-0.604747474193573,
-0.2362578809261322,
0.3591988980770111,
0.3764488101005554,
0.36003223061561584,
-0.4577532708644867,
0.3351728916168213,
-0.3950178325176239,
0.1464201956987381,
0.6896272897720337,
-0.30918076634407043,
0.6454412341117859,
-0.2939836382865906,
0.5300349593162537,
0.13657225668430328,
-0.11219536513090134,
-0.05792386829853058,
-0.48307004570961,
-0.7232614755630493,
-0.18499895930290222,
0.37287506461143494,
0.3343783915042877,
-0.5215874314308167,
0.13669221103191376,
-0.7867733836174011,
-0.3734736144542694,
-0.7699595093727112,
0.16046759486198425,
0.43726402521133423,
0.5493395328521729,
0.42463961243629456,
-0.25336694717407227,
-0.6398530006408691,
-0.8313548564910889,
0.40598541498184204,
-0.14537525177001953,
-0.22563043236732483,
0.43110761046409607,
0.28059622645378113,
-0.030969377607107162,
0.8623912930488586,
-0.3073579668998718,
-0.33160075545310974,
0.027583323419094086,
0.14093026518821716,
0.14612601697444916,
0.4281846284866333,
0.42014792561531067,
-0.5103501081466675,
-0.01665044017136097,
0.43758824467658997,
-0.5459825396537781,
-0.34026220440864563,
-0.10178418457508087,
0.17519629001617432,
0.29905107617378235,
0.5328413844108582,
-0.06620923429727554,
0.34066158533096313,
0.7747218012809753,
-0.05590460076928139,
0.2502298653125763,
-0.20318859815597534,
0.00991145335137844,
-1.3049144744873047,
0.312968909740448,
-0.11420443654060364,
-0.22387592494487762,
-0.45449790358543396,
0.010317753069102764,
-0.05821935832500458,
0.14022357761859894,
-0.5998182892799377,
0.7316888570785522,
-0.6907584071159363,
-0.1941627413034439,
-0.17702633142471313,
-0.016666186973452568,
-0.16033615171909332,
0.3243591785430908,
0.38975274562835693,
0.8310710787773132,
0.16736853122711182,
-0.5762224197387695,
0.6531952619552612,
0.08775322884321213,
-0.33691731095314026,
0.08263929933309555,
-0.6825875639915466,
0.34533074498176575,
-0.1328846961259842,
0.12201917171478271,
-0.6560764312744141,
-0.23411007225513458,
0.44633224606513977,
-0.21109163761138916,
0.2763252556324005,
-0.5041126012802124,
-0.44970637559890747,
-0.05324316397309303,
0.011593179777264595,
0.5150424242019653,
0.24553422629833221,
-0.3353074789047241,
0.21277590095996857,
0.4184192419052124,
-0.3305484354496002,
-0.791154146194458,
-0.968124508857727,
0.211604505777359,
0.11218384653329849,
-0.7351406216621399,
0.2501440644264221,
0.36242160201072693,
-0.515708327293396,
0.2692388892173767,
-0.11051272600889206,
-0.23505562543869019,
-0.15858545899391174,
0.19943735003471375,
0.4351314604282379,
-0.7577980756759644,
0.1457597315311432,
0.02111748605966568,
0.2299736738204956,
-0.014364496804773808,
-0.8430720567703247,
0.4925600588321686,
-0.3843100070953369,
-0.17778444290161133,
0.04109732061624527,
0.13243331015110016,
0.5336124897003174,
-0.2186397910118103,
1.018196702003479,
0.40840885043144226,
-0.5245416164398193,
-0.0462297685444355,
-0.7103338837623596,
0.09784776717424393,
-0.3288393020629883,
0.25803616642951965,
-0.45242005586624146,
-0.5364288687705994,
0.8564834594726562,
-0.09152950346469879,
-0.13803675770759583,
0.30753093957901,
0.7642782330513,
0.24148479104042053,
0.48144233226776123,
0.4048832058906555,
-0.13860103487968445,
0.4218484163284302,
-0.5151709914207458,
-0.21922904253005981,
-0.8072016835212708,
-0.6106212735176086,
-0.8090422749519348,
-0.30934008955955505,
-0.6813153028488159,
-0.8055862784385681,
0.15122798085212708,
-0.431319922208786,
0.10665930062532425,
0.7304645776748657,
-0.12674768269062042,
0.5000672340393066,
0.6448084115982056,
-0.1710139513015747,
0.41991275548934937,
-0.21158616244792938,
-0.26296839118003845,
-0.0979166179895401,
-0.6654464602470398,
-0.6704275012016296,
1.1182856559753418,
0.008312763646245003,
0.8176407217979431,
0.2763868272304535,
0.4544176161289215,
0.4021049737930298,
0.2022397816181183,
-0.8473429083824158,
0.12694333493709564,
-0.1635395884513855,
-0.3793676495552063,
-0.049353647977113724,
-0.4786439538002014,
-1.2478268146514893,
0.12674322724342346,
0.06037871167063713,
-0.376292884349823,
0.6993009448051453,
-0.2088942527770996,
-0.3343345522880554,
0.18158632516860962,
-0.5720000863075256,
0.9384844303131104,
-0.002000146545469761,
-0.3491515815258026,
0.037311237305402756,
-0.728704035282135,
0.2902452349662781,
0.01810741052031517,
-0.04741762951016426,
-0.00821500550955534,
-0.4761936366558075,
0.30327075719833374,
-0.3365824520587921,
0.92798912525177,
0.39718106389045715,
-0.016174284741282463,
0.2647804617881775,
0.37542325258255005,
0.33072835206985474,
0.040212422609329224,
-0.203111469745636,
0.5293294787406921,
0.06836447864770889,
-0.5043109655380249,
-0.44235292077064514,
0.6059542298316956,
-1.1369706392288208,
-0.1960773915052414,
-0.7188640832901001,
-0.4811573922634125,
0.16982778906822205,
0.041072167456150055,
0.2963888943195343,
0.5052038431167603,
-0.6919970512390137,
0.04086478427052498,
0.5156534314155579,
0.051202911883592606,
0.30874761939048767,
0.32651486992836,
0.15149790048599243,
-0.22945135831832886,
0.8239915370941162,
0.272926390171051,
0.1600591391324997,
0.15170007944107056,
0.10093120485544205,
-0.48916077613830566,
-0.6746537685394287,
-0.6323604583740234,
0.027723899111151695,
-0.7406451106071472,
-0.32880038022994995,
-0.6302706599235535,
-0.09537462145090103,
-0.7441784143447876,
-0.11975067108869553,
-0.5304500460624695,
-0.6649163365364075,
-0.397291898727417,
-0.04962708801031113,
0.09412278234958649,
0.9536114931106567,
-0.09242451190948486,
0.09088978916406631,
-0.6343824863433838,
0.04252452403306961,
0.10172896087169647,
-0.02241591177880764,
-0.03273460641503334,
-0.5771085619926453,
-0.2172233611345291,
0.10129883140325546,
0.24021290242671967,
-0.7863323092460632,
0.6660974621772766,
0.08343932777643204,
0.4369160532951355,
0.40512681007385254,
0.07229071855545044,
0.713647723197937,
-0.40342217683792114,
0.5060941576957703,
-0.20867140591144562,
-0.7126836776733398,
0.3368268311023712,
-0.506544291973114,
0.32458436489105225,
0.5140140056610107,
0.38347283005714417,
-1.2239545583724976,
-0.5040056109428406,
-0.44073355197906494,
-1.0113815069198608,
0.9266483187675476,
0.29130345582962036,
0.5256624817848206,
-0.20858405530452728,
0.061015695333480835,
0.28511732816696167,
0.2723701596260071,
-0.47068843245506287,
-0.2697223424911499,
-0.415283203125,
-0.27035266160964966,
0.13489285111427307,
0.3022999167442322,
-0.0874134972691536,
-0.11253967136144638,
0.4967672824859619,
-0.06796106696128845,
0.03417650982737541,
0.1503741294145584,
-0.4445502758026123,
0.1760709285736084,
0.013919509015977383,
0.6240711212158203,
0.5548189282417297,
-0.1317370980978012,
0.5122898817062378,
0.06586194038391113,
-0.8176469206809998,
0.05014035478234291,
0.12910741567611694,
-0.4669035077095032,
0.14108048379421234,
0.3180486559867859,
0.7261876463890076,
0.10265728831291199,
-0.33761081099510193,
0.3912190794944763,
0.010236394591629505,
0.46582937240600586,
-0.48914170265197754,
-0.15802621841430664,
0.12767727673053741,
0.1240142434835434,
0.17999911308288574,
0.6428999304771423,
0.1326543390750885,
-0.5078014135360718,
-0.23390169441699982,
-0.10270670056343079,
-0.29649218916893005,
-0.5366249084472656,
0.5602021217346191,
0.29301753640174866,
-0.18546795845031738,
0.7142003178596497,
-0.33543121814727783,
-0.22984309494495392,
0.6725148558616638,
0.4808513820171356,
0.870755672454834,
0.0384756438434124,
0.27279043197631836,
0.5026834011077881,
0.4267345070838928,
-0.3906991183757782,
-0.2569811940193176,
-0.19243046641349792,
-0.6493160128593445,
-0.21683983504772186,
-0.6066471338272095,
-0.3464643359184265,
0.23850908875465393,
-0.5751376748085022,
0.24758093059062958,
-0.29672515392303467,
-0.14959125220775604,
-0.24943003058433533,
-0.0523904487490654,
-0.8646228909492493,
-0.128093883395195,
0.315643310546875,
0.6567953824996948,
-0.862665057182312,
0.8432660102844238,
0.4774405360221863,
-0.6670729517936707,
-0.19082900881767273,
-0.12102164328098297,
0.2922329306602478,
-0.7130969762802124,
0.7978443503379822,
-0.38762566447257996,
-0.32791686058044434,
-0.12424026429653168,
-0.27562615275382996,
-1.0265016555786133,
0.9137768149375916,
0.48277947306632996,
-0.2902638018131256,
0.005769066978245974,
0.37041425704956055,
0.9172500967979431,
-0.4204738438129425,
0.2936509847640991,
0.47913798689842224,
0.33153995871543884,
0.10729304701089859,
-0.8187212347984314,
0.017248284071683884,
-0.44074565172195435,
0.441525399684906,
-0.020383641123771667,
-0.42093273997306824,
0.6347626447677612,
-0.053705472499132156,
-0.30440035462379456,
0.2484162300825119,
0.744915783405304,
-0.2175871878862381,
0.13354647159576416,
-0.09298224747180939,
0.0422649011015892,
0.8837230801582336,
-0.34078434109687805,
1.0299168825149536,
-0.037521012127399445,
-0.13883532583713531,
1.3260841369628906,
-0.06169213354587555,
0.6177791953086853,
0.4441744387149811,
0.014153516851365566,
0.20845651626586914,
0.7851896286010742,
-0.1545436978340149,
0.3441810607910156,
0.47532913088798523,
-0.7483931183815002,
-0.04342789202928543,
-0.5910320281982422,
-0.3848288357257843,
0.6048665046691895,
0.2940020263195038,
-0.5154549479484558,
-0.06331584602594376,
-0.17347663640975952,
0.32206958532333374,
0.15887048840522766,
-0.29698336124420166,
0.5636878609657288,
0.07948390394449234,
-0.8081604242324829,
0.4298599064350128,
0.2853303849697113,
0.5393881797790527,
-0.5591449737548828,
0.240495964884758,
-0.6845008134841919,
0.14815586805343628,
-0.1303814798593521,
-0.4640573263168335,
0.5790725350379944,
0.18513546884059906,
-0.06630740314722061,
-0.32036292552948,
0.5714951157569885,
-0.5655075311660767,
-0.4608367085456848,
0.12169697135686874,
0.9720584750175476,
0.20594163239002228,
0.14560599625110626,
-0.2872946262359619,
-0.20321735739707947,
-0.4422503113746643,
-0.201496884226799,
0.12098301202058792,
0.575482189655304,
-0.5521494150161743,
0.42715680599212646,
0.7897624969482422,
0.5832733511924744,
0.5749271512031555,
0.3302399516105652,
0.79390549659729,
-0.4224312901496887,
-0.17899182438850403,
-0.712398886680603,
0.08246393501758575,
0.023774469271302223,
-0.6454411149024963,
0.6283409595489502,
0.7463131546974182,
1.214988350868225,
-0.2747883200645447,
0.4748772382736206,
-0.036456312984228134,
-0.26680228114128113,
-0.43084871768951416,
0.8702807426452637,
-0.22380180656909943,
0.21658232808113098,
-0.09967935085296631,
-0.9616847634315491,
-0.5155333876609802,
0.48243048787117004,
-0.12068074196577072,
-0.17691104114055634,
0.6273281574249268,
0.9286255836486816,
-0.35942593216896057,
-0.21511898934841156,
0.32931408286094666,
0.17637203633785248,
-0.048370201140642166,
0.18914374709129333,
0.7071711421012878,
-0.33237433433532715,
0.9069865942001343,
-0.42840829491615295,
0.12908166646957397,
-0.10604440420866013,
-0.8316936492919922,
-0.6561843752861023,
-0.8488590121269226,
-0.22338047623634338,
-0.5011014938354492,
0.1920066624879837,
1.328430414199829,
0.6066333055496216,
-0.9177473783493042,
-0.4917837381362915,
0.06671181321144104,
0.2375003695487976,
-0.22518575191497803,
-0.1037987470626831,
0.39456236362457275,
-0.29435667395591736,
-1.111095905303955,
0.4812798500061035,
0.20760026574134827,
0.289217472076416,
-0.5002334713935852,
-0.06298808008432388,
-0.04945971816778183,
-0.08583089709281921,
0.2856505513191223,
0.432495653629303,
-0.64390629529953,
0.008582589216530323,
0.6513509154319763,
-0.6477529406547546,
0.16097967326641083,
0.8762812614440918,
-0.8450117111206055,
0.6433038115501404,
0.8059470057487488,
0.578821063041687,
0.5231583714485168,
-0.2902628183364868,
0.6872490048408508,
-1.1150649785995483,
0.4587996304035187,
0.598778247833252,
0.39766067266464233,
0.5810596346855164,
-0.0855853483080864,
0.7273783087730408,
0.4876464605331421,
-0.15022709965705872,
-0.5215433239936829,
-0.014464656822383404,
-0.7470598816871643,
0.045963626354932785,
1.3121134042739868,
-0.2927086651325226,
-0.5329446792602539,
-0.7700332999229431,
-0.06505550444126129,
0.6385547518730164,
-0.32781529426574707,
0.9024447202682495,
0.7100157141685486,
0.4481549561023712,
0.25551173090934753,
-0.4970165193080902,
0.5216144919395447,
-0.032898109406232834,
-0.377875953912735,
0.021230796352028847,
0.6604243516921997,
0.15429429709911346,
0.30491724610328674,
0.6531505584716797,
-0.3583871126174927,
0.23702864348888397,
0.13389062881469727,
0.0978558287024498,
-0.3444673717021942,
-0.2130497545003891,
-0.5225205421447754,
-0.20626486837863922,
-0.2537001669406891,
-0.11453904211521149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07654v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07654v1
|
rollama: An R package for using generative large language models through Ollama
| 2024-04-11T11:37:18 | 2024-04-11T11:37:18 |
Johannes B. Gruber, Maximilian Weber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
rollama is an R package that wraps the Ollama API, which allows you to run
different Generative Large Language Models (GLLM) locally. The package and
learning material focus on making it easy to use Ollama for annotating textual
or imagine data with open-source models as well as use these models for
document embedding. But users can use or extend rollama to do essentially
anything else that is possible through OpenAI's API, yet more private,
reproducible and for free.
|
[
-0.35841289162635803,
-0.9933853149414062,
0.3227218687534332,
-0.13032467663288116,
-0.25986534357070923,
0.16789281368255615,
0.010638675652444363,
-0.3957374691963196,
0.5610748529434204,
1.0667030811309814,
-0.2377077341079712,
-0.7239762544631958,
-0.43240392208099365,
-0.18154357373714447,
-0.22268570959568024,
1.186247706413269,
-0.4108825623989105,
-0.13518738746643066,
0.04752020165324211,
-0.5853508710861206,
-0.42226991057395935,
-0.28663361072540283,
-0.3856790363788605,
-0.34437814354896545,
0.8430619239807129,
0.5133017301559448,
1.0712065696716309,
0.4754905104637146,
0.9494907259941101,
0.24824465811252594,
0.05851622298359871,
0.2920216917991638,
-0.29200637340545654,
0.1579810231924057,
-0.1178896352648735,
-1.0274887084960938,
-0.6797766089439392,
-0.03226979449391365,
0.6529949903488159,
0.30586618185043335,
-0.3316291570663452,
0.6129657030105591,
-0.6246374845504761,
0.7221103310585022,
-0.9725044965744019,
-0.09587772935628891,
-0.2889167368412018,
0.1050981655716896,
-0.5390147566795349,
-0.2724404036998749,
-0.3084770441055298,
-0.7942217588424683,
-0.18799981474876404,
-0.6657852530479431,
-0.09792426228523254,
0.2993902862071991,
0.926398754119873,
0.4752807319164276,
-0.1875271201133728,
-0.9860427379608154,
-0.9516400098800659,
0.7882508039474487,
-0.6677694320678711,
-0.21328867971897125,
0.5330663323402405,
0.699587881565094,
-0.35692742466926575,
-0.44103196263313293,
-0.6798858642578125,
-0.3415433466434479,
0.12591974437236786,
0.08744088560342789,
0.08764544129371643,
-0.0712720975279808,
0.2934381365776062,
0.9634604454040527,
-0.896966814994812,
0.38872966170310974,
-0.8109204769134521,
0.5403540134429932,
0.6002695560455322,
0.22605951130390167,
0.9981999397277832,
0.033149462193250656,
-0.813877522945404,
-0.29940229654312134,
-0.8947007656097412,
-0.4238082468509674,
0.767104983329773,
0.27089980244636536,
-0.5294568538665771,
1.0771634578704834,
0.3122982978820801,
0.7546484470367432,
-0.7479159235954285,
-0.31777262687683105,
0.502767026424408,
0.1999935507774353,
-0.5629924535751343,
-0.061489056795835495,
0.7763856053352356,
-0.03490152209997177,
0.2084677666425705,
0.10098931193351746,
-0.2685503661632538,
0.3383331000804901,
0.31984373927116394,
-0.6068577766418457,
-0.1404554396867752,
0.7009923458099365,
-0.6990205645561218,
-0.08930731564760208,
0.30845239758491516,
-1.234938144683838,
-0.3127330541610718,
-0.28529882431030273,
0.4466557502746582,
-0.37896043062210083,
-0.5818521976470947,
0.23873545229434967,
-0.01808151789009571,
0.27465200424194336,
0.006391050294041634,
-0.6528176069259644,
0.18520736694335938,
0.7727339863777161,
1.2886974811553955,
-0.22407743334770203,
-0.26033419370651245,
-0.8686214089393616,
0.3411506712436676,
-0.528552770614624,
1.0068058967590332,
-0.7440672516822815,
-0.6438230872154236,
0.42747992277145386,
-0.2008516639471054,
-0.061629265546798706,
-0.7570019960403442,
0.538076639175415,
-0.6744955778121948,
0.40552133321762085,
0.21620622277259827,
-0.5181256532669067,
-0.616868257522583,
-0.1046803817152977,
-0.9030510783195496,
1.0796000957489014,
0.2998316287994385,
-0.48713648319244385,
0.33036211133003235,
-1.2728968858718872,
-0.1640036553144455,
0.3137202858924866,
-0.036730602383613586,
-0.5324676632881165,
0.2054906189441681,
-0.08009497076272964,
0.4369905889034271,
-0.21263141930103302,
0.29255592823028564,
-0.49531570076942444,
-0.40425607562065125,
0.4553748071193695,
0.16707293689250946,
0.9578193426132202,
0.6969741582870483,
-0.03653275594115257,
0.5048367977142334,
-1.0064711570739746,
-0.11441569775342941,
0.1108398288488388,
-0.24580910801887512,
-0.820405900478363,
-0.2547183632850647,
0.22673511505126953,
-0.05506686866283417,
-0.06397218257188797,
-0.24315385520458221,
0.8222658634185791,
-0.20665757358074188,
0.2397472858428955,
0.526508629322052,
-0.33817258477211,
0.5134902000427246,
-0.32362473011016846,
1.0373375415802002,
0.18648679554462433,
-0.036771975457668304,
-0.399574875831604,
-0.8226876258850098,
-0.8506975173950195,
-0.6810447573661804,
0.09487903863191605,
0.6666459441184998,
-0.9711951613426208,
0.1941661536693573,
-0.15905626118183136,
-0.5029462575912476,
-0.9660506844520569,
0.38002705574035645,
0.4379752576351166,
-0.10468192398548126,
0.5333728194236755,
-0.21723583340644836,
-0.5482721328735352,
-0.7708476781845093,
0.46157172322273254,
-0.019248351454734802,
-0.2850528061389923,
-0.3883304297924042,
0.9663212895393372,
-0.6871383786201477,
1.0936415195465088,
-0.917324423789978,
-1.0624985694885254,
-0.2297976016998291,
0.6276689767837524,
0.19443362951278687,
0.24045993387699127,
0.6797291040420532,
-0.8035111427307129,
-0.3172045648097992,
0.20411942899227142,
-0.9260414838790894,
-0.09176921844482422,
0.09923845529556274,
-0.015499643050134182,
0.6699721217155457,
0.1394365429878235,
-0.6251600384712219,
0.49783840775489807,
1.1193084716796875,
-0.2707466185092926,
0.37081998586654663,
-0.5762934684753418,
-0.0736452043056488,
-1.4164464473724365,
0.24871981143951416,
-0.25042110681533813,
-0.005567086860537529,
-0.539763331413269,
0.6114891767501831,
-0.3055630624294281,
-0.19320887327194214,
-0.2978067696094513,
0.8893620371818542,
-0.6204698085784912,
-0.2786000072956085,
-0.5384945273399353,
0.24881614744663239,
-0.3293435871601105,
0.2507665157318115,
0.011578244157135487,
1.0365278720855713,
0.42112234234809875,
-0.6607315540313721,
-0.006404292769730091,
0.4107814431190491,
-0.5754361152648926,
0.6616169810295105,
-0.5116536021232605,
0.47190409898757935,
-0.2908802330493927,
0.19333519041538239,
-0.7197880148887634,
-0.4804796874523163,
0.6016448736190796,
-0.2525324821472168,
0.0660647302865982,
0.037645671516656876,
-0.14311760663986206,
-0.3494669497013092,
-0.5652818083763123,
0.323058545589447,
0.6391098499298096,
-0.6955316662788391,
1.1349281072616577,
0.8130620121955872,
0.21354332566261292,
-0.5570893883705139,
-0.846716582775116,
-0.003067952347919345,
-0.5737653970718384,
-0.2864602208137512,
0.04249245673418045,
-0.21294093132019043,
-0.7063595056533813,
0.11207018047571182,
0.750720739364624,
-0.15668036043643951,
-0.2390124499797821,
0.801723301410675,
0.4271685481071472,
-0.5006265044212341,
-0.03845420852303505,
-0.3504653573036194,
-0.39453452825546265,
-0.3145626485347748,
0.23187853395938873,
0.7527124285697937,
-0.09982623159885406,
-0.27423378825187683,
-0.1599932461977005,
0.43512624502182007,
0.3534663915634155,
-0.37618738412857056,
1.001896858215332,
0.804884135723114,
-0.16678090393543243,
-0.6807578802108765,
-0.4488673210144043,
0.4652062952518463,
-0.4819384813308716,
-0.060508087277412415,
-0.3126942217350006,
-0.8501511812210083,
0.7113016843795776,
0.3629685938358307,
0.17142781615257263,
0.22246800363063812,
0.7382226586341858,
0.016228454187512398,
0.46342599391937256,
0.5741178393363953,
-0.3203105032444,
0.18773800134658813,
-0.41634562611579895,
0.12965039908885956,
-1.0825806856155396,
-0.06487425416707993,
-0.9182218313217163,
-0.18871310353279114,
-0.4114534854888916,
-1.074465036392212,
0.05860205739736557,
0.11833570152521133,
-0.2831763029098511,
0.23640623688697815,
-0.5898094177246094,
0.29083168506622314,
0.6937417984008789,
-0.31641533970832825,
0.5656529664993286,
-0.01937425136566162,
0.4614221155643463,
0.36719247698783875,
-0.43755042552948,
-0.8571091890335083,
1.0946760177612305,
0.5646024346351624,
1.2501920461654663,
0.3188035190105438,
0.6575416922569275,
0.31478145718574524,
0.7488560676574707,
-0.8951860070228577,
0.6477529406547546,
-0.34112924337387085,
-0.44708529114723206,
0.06108161062002182,
-0.40166744589805603,
-1.1649483442306519,
-0.018183954060077667,
0.08327416330575943,
-0.789955198764801,
-0.005238826386630535,
0.045798178762197495,
-0.2578721344470978,
0.6889997720718384,
-0.6906659007072449,
0.4263164699077606,
0.023734070360660553,
0.43307894468307495,
-0.21455290913581848,
-0.16432249546051025,
0.772083580493927,
0.16845794022083282,
0.37904685735702515,
-0.33215731382369995,
-0.2488187700510025,
0.73674476146698,
-0.2456844002008438,
0.9043567180633545,
-0.1436547338962555,
-0.46226319670677185,
0.6890284419059753,
0.2021280974149704,
0.16964761912822723,
-0.08162487298250198,
0.1736840307712555,
0.4605124592781067,
-0.1961335390806198,
-0.09509343653917313,
-0.5529387593269348,
0.71957927942276,
-0.8389847874641418,
-0.2797904312610626,
-0.6101755499839783,
-0.6372823715209961,
0.23982878029346466,
-0.10031598061323166,
-0.12366870790719986,
0.4329832196235657,
0.07140244543552399,
0.21662300825119019,
0.658181369304657,
-0.462013304233551,
0.34529244899749756,
0.5009658336639404,
-1.088636875152588,
-0.5104771256446838,
0.925866425037384,
0.22258062660694122,
0.2893543839454651,
0.4849375784397125,
0.17658132314682007,
-0.1913289576768875,
-0.5384994745254517,
-0.5408912897109985,
0.24209418892860413,
-0.7934773564338684,
-0.26167094707489014,
-0.6407297849655151,
-0.10456628352403641,
0.13276554644107819,
-0.39407098293304443,
-0.2397594153881073,
-0.16078892350196838,
-0.20156243443489075,
-0.025970980525016785,
0.5705486536026001,
1.169498324394226,
0.030608393251895905,
0.4870947003364563,
-0.7576859593391418,
0.7966218590736389,
0.17666363716125488,
0.3380119204521179,
-0.13977418839931488,
-0.2354028970003128,
-0.06915802508592606,
-0.019057445228099823,
0.0001925977412611246,
-0.6907129883766174,
0.40420854091644287,
0.1608726531267166,
0.3984472155570984,
0.4890621602535248,
-0.06850097328424454,
0.5978385210037231,
-0.21319694817066193,
0.8987507224082947,
0.08824031054973602,
-0.648415207862854,
0.6733535528182983,
-0.5265530943870544,
0.4916898310184479,
0.237543523311615,
0.6794720888137817,
-0.22276520729064941,
-0.3725259006023407,
-0.12780937552452087,
-0.7785398960113525,
0.44244590401649475,
-0.09650633484125137,
0.09527517110109329,
-0.04889601469039917,
0.1362161487340927,
0.2920832335948944,
-0.04862052947282791,
-0.6362612247467041,
-0.15333224833011627,
0.07260708510875702,
-0.3712417185306549,
-0.14732429385185242,
-0.5987454056739807,
-0.45177924633026123,
0.4806503653526306,
0.7809129953384399,
-0.36365288496017456,
0.22171492874622345,
-0.07897201180458069,
-0.16309058666229248,
-0.282341331243515,
0.12194042652845383,
0.8238787651062012,
0.7737528085708618,
-0.2586517632007599,
0.07716390490531921,
-0.0679432675242424,
-0.8460262417793274,
0.14040710031986237,
-0.2757776379585266,
-0.5434232950210571,
-0.0043907808139920235,
0.31981927156448364,
1.020389437675476,
0.2382071614265442,
-0.8781545758247375,
-0.1387414038181305,
0.2546112835407257,
0.05577652156352997,
-0.6316290497779846,
0.37354016304016113,
-0.0058137839660048485,
0.075236015021801,
0.4842270016670227,
-0.3621535897254944,
-0.0854826271533966,
-0.8102264404296875,
-0.20243971049785614,
0.3557679057121277,
-0.1745063215494156,
-0.2754841446876526,
0.6902849078178406,
-0.1381322741508484,
-0.7473272681236267,
0.40695738792419434,
-0.029505066573619843,
-0.1511334329843521,
0.59025639295578,
0.5719402432441711,
1.079792857170105,
-0.6503725051879883,
0.895727813243866,
0.4418179988861084,
0.1942201554775238,
-0.10086751729249954,
0.5074385404586792,
0.4482343792915344,
-0.6805326342582703,
-0.33574482798576355,
-0.9697434902191162,
-0.7320369482040405,
0.14569522440433502,
-0.7304238080978394,
0.4887616038322449,
-0.34236910939216614,
-0.04600697010755539,
-0.03415132686495781,
-0.35558441281318665,
-0.40049508213996887,
0.1553766280412674,
0.12608981132507324,
0.8472753167152405,
-0.4350399971008301,
1.0529510974884033,
0.8934086561203003,
-0.8703871369361877,
-0.7392638921737671,
-0.1859401911497116,
0.042875129729509354,
-0.8643757700920105,
0.789536714553833,
0.2954839766025543,
-0.4686005115509033,
-0.5375598669052124,
-0.28977546095848083,
-0.8083353042602539,
0.9237939715385437,
0.08794478327035904,
-0.2619249224662781,
0.1529870182275772,
0.5243905782699585,
0.6115143299102783,
-0.5500277280807495,
0.4079798758029938,
0.11189588159322739,
0.45368391275405884,
0.17074935138225555,
-0.7110322117805481,
-0.16575543582439423,
0.12584802508354187,
0.41971778869628906,
0.35226279497146606,
-0.6181410551071167,
0.9821732044219971,
-0.23283375799655914,
-0.40369081497192383,
0.2761726975440979,
0.8826718330383301,
0.4538591504096985,
0.3548624813556671,
0.3052363097667694,
0.7812963128089905,
0.8044437766075134,
-0.07058954238891602,
1.107633352279663,
0.0076289488933980465,
0.40243449807167053,
1.356648325920105,
-0.7026268243789673,
1.3590071201324463,
0.255265474319458,
-0.3207070827484131,
0.8926690220832825,
0.12524084746837616,
0.05394958332180977,
0.11543925106525421,
0.05931760370731354,
-0.1802072674036026,
0.38419169187545776,
0.15273208916187286,
-0.5786293745040894,
0.6792179942131042,
0.4854670464992523,
-0.08804868906736374,
-0.09834584593772888,
0.4566427767276764,
0.32744836807250977,
0.17900852859020233,
-0.625140905380249,
0.5029849410057068,
0.3256762623786926,
-0.670101523399353,
0.47057631611824036,
-0.22096963226795197,
0.9480723738670349,
-0.9734217524528503,
-0.15059998631477356,
-0.19841936230659485,
0.49316728115081787,
-0.3224979043006897,
-1.0254665613174438,
0.8958190083503723,
-0.21569718420505524,
0.058113377541303635,
0.12359358370304108,
0.775109589099884,
-0.48801910877227783,
-0.4882037341594696,
0.5266554951667786,
0.0550399124622345,
0.16731412708759308,
0.3177950084209442,
-0.551315426826477,
0.4180563688278198,
-0.3978116512298584,
-0.5055351853370667,
0.4058185815811157,
-0.11181572824716568,
-0.1691923588514328,
1.2533667087554932,
0.7669623494148254,
-0.03538346290588379,
0.00996040552854538,
0.05308770388364792,
0.7273848056793213,
-0.5886192917823792,
-0.43108972907066345,
-0.6202810406684875,
0.5263112783432007,
0.04166799038648605,
-0.6057511568069458,
0.9373859167098999,
0.5866245627403259,
0.6150093674659729,
-0.6792380809783936,
0.4545828700065613,
-0.3732184171676636,
0.5783067941665649,
-0.9461035132408142,
0.77664715051651,
-0.5204263925552368,
-0.07115580141544342,
-0.02064448781311512,
-1.196773648262024,
-0.3777537941932678,
0.6759275794029236,
-0.26501038670539856,
-0.22575372457504272,
0.5833475589752197,
0.9701414704322815,
-0.035416413098573685,
0.19543017446994781,
0.32178086042404175,
0.1259821355342865,
0.31434836983680725,
0.2964329421520233,
0.7429192066192627,
-0.15006552636623383,
0.1632126420736313,
0.10745958238840103,
-0.3552098572254181,
-0.17740270495414734,
-0.8245730400085449,
-1.3613091707229614,
-0.8429048657417297,
-0.3617941439151764,
-0.3439841866493225,
0.03569016978144646,
0.9444984793663025,
0.5557290315628052,
-1.1028395891189575,
-0.5044056177139282,
0.3738824427127838,
0.07026071846485138,
-0.024053195491433144,
-0.2805907130241394,
0.45988839864730835,
-0.3895646631717682,
-1.0332337617874146,
0.4959731101989746,
0.5880069136619568,
-0.0542873740196228,
-1.0469143390655518,
-0.12617024779319763,
-0.37570759654045105,
0.10467147827148438,
0.4663250744342804,
0.6059426665306091,
-0.502728283405304,
-0.2168084681034088,
-0.47764280438423157,
0.0007067464757710695,
0.1684415340423584,
0.81258624792099,
-0.6630033850669861,
0.4295983612537384,
0.5076851844787598,
0.43173351883888245,
0.27049848437309265,
-0.15475842356681824,
0.6730992794036865,
-0.2435484677553177,
0.690629243850708,
0.07345733791589737,
0.23723895847797394,
0.19913840293884277,
-0.1780671328306198,
1.0244460105895996,
-0.3937529921531677,
-0.7737486958503723,
-1.0573514699935913,
0.1457912027835846,
-1.3201197385787964,
-0.11678960174322128,
1.3358216285705566,
-0.4353240728378296,
-0.582204282283783,
-0.18034763634204865,
-0.5339105129241943,
-0.21684464812278748,
-0.03746505081653595,
0.8978093862533569,
0.4600357711315155,
0.44933924078941345,
-0.21599404513835907,
-1.1075356006622314,
0.4866226613521576,
-0.03720158711075783,
-1.3230767250061035,
-0.35805562138557434,
0.26611989736557007,
0.023750290274620056,
0.6615840792655945,
0.8210943937301636,
-0.09054769575595856,
-0.007378668058663607,
-0.029788190498948097,
0.24483849108219147,
-0.19824077188968658,
-0.42577069997787476,
-0.2266148030757904,
0.5523300170898438,
-0.23263488709926605,
-0.3845643103122711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07647v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07647v1
|
Why do small language models underperform? Studying Language Model Saturation via the Softmax Bottleneck
| 2024-04-11T11:10:36 | 2024-04-11T11:10:36 |
Nathan Godey, Éric de la Clergerie, Benoît Sagot
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advances in language modeling consist in pretraining highly
parameterized neural networks on extremely large web-mined text corpora.
Training and inference with such models can be costly in practice, which
incentivizes the use of smaller counterparts. However, it has been observed
that smaller models can suffer from saturation, characterized as a drop in
performance at some advanced point in training followed by a plateau. In this
paper, we find that such saturation can be explained by a mismatch between the
hidden dimension of smaller models and the high rank of the target contextual
probability distribution. This mismatch affects the performance of the linear
prediction head used in such models through the well-known softmax bottleneck
phenomenon. We measure the effect of the softmax bottleneck in various settings
and find that models based on less than 1000 hidden dimensions tend to adopt
degenerate latent representations in late pretraining, which leads to reduced
evaluation performance.
|
[
-0.5957645773887634,
-0.49320968985557556,
0.6533597707748413,
0.04842134565114975,
-0.11740388721227646,
-0.04683990776538849,
-0.3335403800010681,
-0.34802690148353577,
-0.31076711416244507,
0.43097060918807983,
-0.4823775589466095,
0.03079356625676155,
-0.6578472256660461,
-0.08241737633943558,
-0.12160136550664902,
0.8231861591339111,
0.13957078754901886,
0.12308599799871445,
-0.5270220637321472,
-0.32330024242401123,
-0.6953060626983643,
-0.5105635523796082,
-0.3696926534175873,
-0.7287271022796631,
0.356533020734787,
0.573723554611206,
0.9115022420883179,
0.5791382193565369,
0.28449323773384094,
0.26242485642433167,
-0.1904943734407425,
-0.20097143948078156,
-0.7559893727302551,
-0.017157768830657005,
0.1998927742242813,
-0.6502450704574585,
-0.2552351653575897,
0.27629244327545166,
0.7720308899879456,
1.3598207235336304,
0.07061220705509186,
0.13661794364452362,
0.34598857164382935,
0.604004979133606,
-0.7753405570983887,
0.013523888774216175,
-0.7988100051879883,
-0.02762744203209877,
-0.20785772800445557,
0.18933798372745514,
-0.20175185799598694,
-0.11367201805114746,
0.3130094110965729,
-0.24058742821216583,
0.39715126156806946,
-0.002779208356514573,
0.5165287256240845,
0.2645835876464844,
-0.22016870975494385,
-0.15107640624046326,
-0.8957564830780029,
0.9238738417625427,
-0.6925094723701477,
0.22738958895206451,
0.23340876400470734,
0.21077613532543182,
0.2077990621328354,
-0.3687334358692169,
-0.5375726222991943,
-0.4127645492553711,
-0.0658663734793663,
-0.44344380497932434,
-0.35745930671691895,
-0.10042722523212433,
0.45575380325317383,
0.3685893714427948,
-0.6483261585235596,
0.3611075282096863,
-0.4466487169265747,
0.046552982181310654,
0.41768914461135864,
0.22415278851985931,
-0.06774120777845383,
0.047208499163389206,
-0.1420007050037384,
-0.09957683086395264,
-0.9712731242179871,
-0.013219672255218029,
0.3274836242198944,
0.6999163627624512,
0.1224038228392601,
0.47530466318130493,
-0.013025892898440361,
0.4170019328594208,
-0.09440165758132935,
-0.02570459060370922,
0.47693508863449097,
-0.11078988760709763,
-0.3968256413936615,
-0.10450474172830582,
0.5710117220878601,
0.038192979991436005,
0.6026831865310669,
0.03194703161716461,
-0.3414580523967743,
-0.056747715920209885,
0.1170189157128334,
-0.9349427819252014,
-0.024492530152201653,
0.06995522230863571,
-0.5468827486038208,
-0.2529557943344116,
-0.30489015579223633,
-0.5364776849746704,
-0.40665608644485474,
-0.13500109314918518,
0.5237356424331665,
-0.026710212230682373,
-0.40024834871292114,
0.0591062530875206,
-0.08101768046617508,
-0.17908653616905212,
0.0791100338101387,
-0.6459791660308838,
0.5092118382453918,
0.4795443117618561,
0.8380107879638672,
-0.15069551765918732,
-0.26304134726524353,
-0.18051014840602875,
-0.3518899083137512,
-0.5359249711036682,
0.5413961410522461,
-0.5846444368362427,
-0.40671056509017944,
0.026739444583654404,
-0.15854701399803162,
-0.37258797883987427,
-1.036769151687622,
0.2726159393787384,
-0.21638885140419006,
0.09135160595178604,
-0.18869006633758545,
-0.30135032534599304,
0.20085297524929047,
-0.17326620221138,
-0.7823289036750793,
0.8898531794548035,
0.10320929437875748,
-0.6009947657585144,
0.3479519486427307,
-0.18955814838409424,
-0.24198780953884125,
0.038580410182476044,
-0.24896478652954102,
-0.3664645254611969,
0.6455367803573608,
-0.1684083640575409,
0.41521191596984863,
-0.47299137711524963,
-0.2555612027645111,
-0.28417590260505676,
-0.8316280245780945,
0.4292779862880707,
-0.5511478781700134,
0.6296552419662476,
0.19591061770915985,
-0.4063756465911865,
-0.1298479288816452,
-0.7393066883087158,
0.30664223432540894,
0.33203455805778503,
-0.26731395721435547,
-0.6441798806190491,
-0.17329946160316467,
-0.014284494332969189,
0.3412288725376129,
0.017519013956189156,
-0.06790908426046371,
0.23951838910579681,
-0.6748216152191162,
0.37520933151245117,
0.5351451635360718,
-0.23501437902450562,
0.6571877598762512,
-0.09510115534067154,
0.666557788848877,
0.1465812772512436,
0.023141883313655853,
0.17010273039340973,
-0.3376472592353821,
-0.8568693399429321,
0.19257399439811707,
0.4515896737575531,
0.44646915793418884,
-0.2863989472389221,
-0.23302653431892395,
-0.4316655695438385,
-0.5852771997451782,
-0.5212839245796204,
0.5351128578186035,
0.53805011510849,
0.1554946005344391,
0.15517936646938324,
-0.40227603912353516,
-0.24927014112472534,
-1.167845368385315,
-0.2848255932331085,
0.038793325424194336,
-0.16555383801460266,
0.36290886998176575,
0.5595846772193909,
-0.4462880492210388,
0.7191524505615234,
-0.46891555190086365,
-0.40557003021240234,
-0.7241442203521729,
0.30451449751853943,
0.2646239697933197,
0.681344211101532,
0.5837714076042175,
-0.7059741616249084,
-0.3363156020641327,
-0.3469483256340027,
-0.2563838064670563,
-0.09316971898078918,
0.08304032683372498,
0.3344186842441559,
0.1844325214624405,
0.4863151013851166,
-0.6739194393157959,
0.39598166942596436,
0.5893179178237915,
-0.11889693886041641,
0.5762107968330383,
-0.30644258856773376,
-0.4855698347091675,
-0.4603714644908905,
-0.027970533818006516,
-0.024567829445004463,
-0.13701412081718445,
-0.45966237783432007,
-0.2089412808418274,
-0.1566735953092575,
-0.3934999108314514,
-0.27770352363586426,
0.25283825397491455,
-0.5651611685752869,
-0.16764554381370544,
-0.449206680059433,
0.38198208808898926,
0.10970283299684525,
0.48918768763542175,
-0.2613813877105713,
0.7526909112930298,
0.367376446723938,
-0.5131850838661194,
-0.0156778022646904,
-0.02384204789996147,
-0.39315447211265564,
0.20537082850933075,
-0.7940481305122375,
0.05712595582008362,
-0.1022055521607399,
-0.019987929612398148,
-0.738240122795105,
0.08758122473955154,
-0.31183719635009766,
-0.23437418043613434,
0.5372329354286194,
-0.21425749361515045,
-0.4032168686389923,
-0.37414076924324036,
-0.190818190574646,
0.5857409238815308,
0.5767659544944763,
-0.09818849712610245,
0.04238109290599823,
0.3768913149833679,
-0.06334290653467178,
-0.6337838768959045,
-1.0435749292373657,
-0.2798078954219818,
-0.03755350038409233,
-0.49207818508148193,
0.16483449935913086,
-0.18316130340099335,
-0.37925198674201965,
0.020707886666059494,
-0.23783637583255768,
-0.16687582433223724,
0.13782158493995667,
0.3780960738658905,
-0.2023816555738449,
-0.7094796895980835,
0.19756586849689484,
-0.2472037672996521,
-0.23622944951057434,
-0.04858371242880821,
-0.23111557960510254,
0.6101123690605164,
-0.6379770040512085,
-0.07984725385904312,
-0.1679924577474594,
0.35006752610206604,
0.5839475393295288,
0.14501871168613434,
1.1280066967010498,
0.3232124149799347,
-0.43267908692359924,
-0.5009617805480957,
-0.4386445879936218,
-0.1132645308971405,
-0.4700549840927124,
0.32506388425827026,
-0.44580501317977905,
-0.7972947955131531,
0.43540871143341064,
-0.007552676368504763,
-0.4316202700138092,
0.6220772862434387,
0.5324610471725464,
0.1227739080786705,
1.2135019302368164,
1.0145496129989624,
0.24094383418560028,
0.295680969953537,
-0.5688625574111938,
0.08295714855194092,
-0.7140549421310425,
0.017435038462281227,
-0.5348896384239197,
-0.04006665199995041,
-0.9563098549842834,
-0.39619389176368713,
0.10115676373243332,
0.3351116180419922,
-0.21207615733146667,
0.36499106884002686,
-0.234218567609787,
0.7167190313339233,
0.5059359669685364,
-0.37814709544181824,
0.20772391557693481,
-0.09732785820960999,
-0.3274694085121155,
-0.29316017031669617,
-1.13150954246521,
-0.6741828918457031,
0.8795656561851501,
0.605022668838501,
0.8039595484733582,
-0.15236729383468628,
0.2813092768192291,
0.29188576340675354,
0.182088240981102,
-0.6242064237594604,
0.3841778039932251,
-0.23621582984924316,
-0.7333878874778748,
-0.39346298575401306,
-0.5866320133209229,
-1.0608595609664917,
0.45341649651527405,
-0.1537243127822876,
-0.6950764060020447,
0.5942023992538452,
0.41103434562683105,
-0.5198343992233276,
-0.08216343075037003,
-0.890733003616333,
1.55190908908844,
-0.13600113987922668,
-0.4247274696826935,
-0.3039332330226898,
-0.3701270818710327,
0.20989647507667542,
-0.11104419082403183,
0.34149667620658875,
-0.17624638974666595,
0.18934118747711182,
0.5679126977920532,
-0.5823292136192322,
0.6764625310897827,
-0.24746659398078918,
0.12320560216903687,
0.24055293202400208,
0.304858535528183,
0.3470610976219177,
0.034821007400751114,
0.09003984183073044,
0.17724713683128357,
0.061355553567409515,
-0.5273210406303406,
-0.4258522093296051,
0.8558028936386108,
-0.7818319201469421,
-0.5738822817802429,
-0.4686771035194397,
-0.17466840147972107,
-0.48150670528411865,
0.08839473873376846,
0.608534038066864,
0.5876254439353943,
-0.07223518192768097,
0.4429949223995209,
0.6119579076766968,
-0.31780508160591125,
0.32670652866363525,
0.2309679239988327,
0.01625905930995941,
0.13518039882183075,
0.9474454522132874,
0.4909016489982605,
0.5023468732833862,
0.005879527889192104,
0.23217861354351044,
-0.050073444843292236,
-0.6389756798744202,
-0.14221017062664032,
0.18934416770935059,
-0.7805179953575134,
-0.06168290972709656,
-0.3681621253490448,
-0.21407584846019745,
-0.562002420425415,
0.08382829278707504,
-0.8084558248519897,
-0.46223220229148865,
-0.23858529329299927,
0.07770434767007828,
-0.3611936867237091,
0.889376699924469,
-0.24318724870681763,
0.5745221972465515,
-0.35054054856300354,
0.03025464154779911,
0.402596652507782,
0.5770587921142578,
0.2922006845474243,
-0.517321765422821,
-0.5985898375511169,
-0.16597330570220947,
-0.2594766616821289,
-0.6848525404930115,
0.37345099449157715,
0.32728683948516846,
0.5725774765014648,
0.4358961880207062,
-0.22462114691734314,
0.47315457463264465,
-0.6126907467842102,
0.47044217586517334,
-0.012703163549304008,
-0.934586763381958,
0.2532798647880554,
-0.03654981777071953,
0.5792802572250366,
0.652553915977478,
0.3434876501560211,
-0.34644371271133423,
-0.2470812201499939,
-0.7000477910041809,
-0.933133602142334,
0.6438667178153992,
0.28131166100502014,
0.3151823878288269,
0.22740893065929413,
0.16983725130558014,
0.28603488206863403,
0.4383804500102997,
-1.0564275979995728,
-0.33502379059791565,
-0.16716954112052917,
0.10741272568702698,
-0.38869544863700867,
-0.7330431938171387,
0.22678939998149872,
-0.07247694581747055,
0.5225940346717834,
-0.15713366866111755,
0.3093481659889221,
-0.18924760818481445,
-0.36378738284111023,
-0.4409983158111572,
0.22060154378414154,
0.6362303495407104,
0.8010147213935852,
-0.296269953250885,
0.16579358279705048,
0.2545132339000702,
-0.2600519359111786,
-0.1226465180516243,
0.06859975308179855,
-0.007019828539341688,
0.1318199336528778,
0.5318948030471802,
1.0438026189804077,
0.4016708731651306,
-0.7835543751716614,
0.8320662379264832,
-0.1569978892803192,
0.17287656664848328,
-0.47599685192108154,
0.16862890124320984,
-0.009740820154547691,
0.29852917790412903,
0.6793935894966125,
0.21521277725696564,
0.019489048048853874,
-0.7628403902053833,
-0.03584187477827072,
0.5331160426139832,
-0.44362708926200867,
-0.1199045330286026,
0.6318114995956421,
0.11139745265245438,
-0.131410613656044,
0.5311148762702942,
-0.13521099090576172,
-0.6391137838363647,
0.6070458292961121,
0.23319746553897858,
0.5928747057914734,
0.06389392912387848,
0.048294391483068466,
0.14253801107406616,
0.6390969753265381,
-0.1269291639328003,
-0.06463547050952911,
0.08185451477766037,
-0.5281715989112854,
-0.4964199662208557,
-0.833200216293335,
-0.05113976076245308,
0.6925256848335266,
-0.4544518291950226,
-0.031203722581267357,
-0.37018343806266785,
-0.317430704832077,
-0.06681836396455765,
0.26479458808898926,
-1.0480561256408691,
0.43955564498901367,
0.3973899185657501,
0.7653008699417114,
-0.8895303010940552,
0.7180644869804382,
0.1201668530702591,
-0.4778525233268738,
-0.5982111692428589,
0.15986356139183044,
-0.24080462753772736,
-0.5027102828025818,
0.8736147284507751,
0.4407244622707367,
-0.09872352331876755,
-0.18483807146549225,
-0.330085426568985,
-0.8653550744056702,
0.49396073818206787,
0.4129978120326996,
-0.6611995100975037,
-0.1200561672449112,
0.4794761538505554,
0.8691898584365845,
-0.7256407141685486,
0.10218651592731476,
0.575562596321106,
0.14043787121772766,
-0.19585350155830383,
-1.0763535499572754,
0.04139821231365204,
-0.03805386275053024,
0.3629370629787445,
-0.12262046337127686,
-0.4726579189300537,
1.2366629838943481,
-0.28504177927970886,
-0.3273366689682007,
0.10506931692361832,
0.3672082722187042,
0.07166055589914322,
0.3753722608089447,
0.5628519654273987,
0.34961482882499695,
0.3973195552825928,
-0.13008622825145721,
1.1365883350372314,
-0.07462039589881897,
0.49042198061943054,
0.9459485411643982,
-0.21326284110546112,
0.942044734954834,
0.260027676820755,
-0.019463790580630302,
0.49584102630615234,
0.5522717237472534,
0.05209458991885185,
0.5283130407333374,
0.3590943217277527,
0.12291023880243301,
-0.4512786269187927,
0.20077389478683472,
-0.4753531217575073,
0.5110888481140137,
0.4335717558860779,
-0.40569832921028137,
0.056077051907777786,
0.25841066241264343,
-0.2325146645307541,
0.06171208247542381,
-0.43268758058547974,
0.4173195958137512,
0.3199562132358551,
-0.4474709630012512,
0.999800443649292,
-0.04080198332667351,
0.505637526512146,
-0.2989414930343628,
0.2891697287559509,
-0.3028399348258972,
0.47919270396232605,
-0.0008131813956424594,
-0.4057576656341553,
0.32885581254959106,
-0.1795474737882614,
-0.2557290196418762,
-0.3466896116733551,
0.8617258667945862,
-0.28607475757598877,
-0.360681414604187,
0.4482543170452118,
0.8944767117500305,
0.226263165473938,
-0.32538700103759766,
-0.7221261262893677,
0.25808775424957275,
-0.49248018860816956,
-0.43600210547447205,
0.3599262237548828,
0.5645627379417419,
0.10161660611629486,
0.6082065105438232,
0.280868798494339,
0.1934792399406433,
-0.05152183026075363,
0.17035575211048126,
0.709378719329834,
-0.49624940752983093,
-0.28006288409233093,
-0.8187916874885559,
0.1933152675628662,
0.03210177272558212,
-0.45502397418022156,
0.7095699310302734,
0.6487351059913635,
1.0315355062484741,
-0.2893717885017395,
0.5961348414421082,
0.22423438727855682,
0.5846149921417236,
-0.24739420413970947,
0.8262723088264465,
-0.9066601991653442,
0.37636011838912964,
-0.0976908802986145,
-1.1145223379135132,
-0.027871279045939445,
0.5468908548355103,
-0.5488181114196777,
0.33604559302330017,
0.5421140193939209,
0.6119986772537231,
-0.13073129951953888,
-0.4862314462661743,
0.6093061566352844,
0.5562364459037781,
-0.14032712578773499,
0.6986162662506104,
0.6700498461723328,
-0.3399091064929962,
0.7262861132621765,
-0.32095223665237427,
0.016163459047675133,
-0.6867150068283081,
-0.7802518010139465,
-1.0432984828948975,
-0.5493207573890686,
-0.2641403079032898,
-0.41012042760849,
0.013364486396312714,
0.5755559802055359,
0.9103038311004639,
-0.8213945031166077,
-0.266157329082489,
-0.20088210701942444,
0.16925260424613953,
0.031123751774430275,
-0.2652952969074249,
0.05681140720844269,
-0.15149591863155365,
-0.7124342322349548,
0.3908003568649292,
0.06947853416204453,
0.19661125540733337,
-0.664638102054596,
0.15098664164543152,
0.10315483808517456,
0.25260287523269653,
0.3538958728313446,
0.46642008423805237,
-0.421238511800766,
-0.08067477494478226,
-0.33302533626556396,
-0.5322404503822327,
-0.004178272560238838,
0.9922484159469604,
-1.0297340154647827,
0.061023321002721786,
0.3691813051700592,
0.33489781618118286,
0.5779806971549988,
-0.39603349566459656,
0.6515491008758545,
-1.122681736946106,
0.5023191571235657,
0.3149109184741974,
0.23662346601486206,
0.5483338832855225,
-0.14248444139957428,
0.21367745101451874,
0.541908323764801,
-0.4023391604423523,
-1.2230026721954346,
0.19731679558753967,
-0.5098581314086914,
-0.7547248005867004,
1.006776213645935,
0.18462161719799042,
-0.2774096429347992,
0.10403939336538315,
0.12988178431987762,
-0.02450190857052803,
0.0691402480006218,
0.5871835947036743,
0.6981740593910217,
-0.0625571459531784,
-0.02645406872034073,
-0.9125770926475525,
0.790968120098114,
0.5830081105232239,
-0.2035585641860962,
0.15247029066085815,
0.2418489158153534,
0.3155533969402313,
0.3646013140678406,
0.35863807797431946,
0.3383130431175232,
0.11242733895778656,
0.38304299116134644,
-0.5233161449432373,
0.16299234330654144,
-0.31389665603637695,
-0.40196317434310913,
0.48806676268577576,
0.3171442449092865,
0.2332083135843277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07622v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07622v1
|
Multi-Image Visual Question Answering for Unsupervised Anomaly Detection
| 2024-04-11T10:16:44 | 2024-04-11T10:16:44 |
Jun Li, Cosmin I. Bercea, Philip Müller, Lina Felsner, Suhwan Kim, Daniel Rueckert, Benedikt Wiestler, Julia A. Schnabel
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Unsupervised anomaly detection enables the identification of potential
pathological areas by juxtaposing original images with their pseudo-healthy
reconstructions generated by models trained exclusively on normal images.
However, the clinical interpretation of resultant anomaly maps presents a
challenge due to a lack of detailed, understandable explanations. Recent
advancements in language models have shown the capability of mimicking
human-like understanding and providing detailed descriptions. This raises an
interesting question: \textit{How can language models be employed to make the
anomaly maps more explainable?} To the best of our knowledge, we are the first
to leverage a language model for unsupervised anomaly detection, for which we
construct a dataset with different questions and answers. Additionally, we
present a novel multi-image visual question answering framework tailored for
anomaly detection, incorporating diverse feature fusion strategies to enhance
visual knowledge extraction. Our experiments reveal that the framework,
augmented by our new Knowledge Q-Former module, adeptly answers questions on
the anomaly detection dataset. Besides, integrating anomaly maps as inputs
distinctly aids in improving the detection of unseen pathologies.
|
[
-0.44486477971076965,
-0.9985026717185974,
0.7769917249679565,
-0.24459312856197357,
-0.47730889916419983,
-0.1397838443517685,
0.27340787649154663,
-0.5027751326560974,
0.2184632420539856,
0.8277170062065125,
-0.8426833748817444,
-0.45216819643974304,
-0.6116344928741455,
-0.09722698479890823,
-0.37336206436157227,
0.6618489027023315,
-0.024315472692251205,
0.3841695785522461,
-0.5353005528450012,
-0.39408066868782043,
-0.517112672328949,
0.01302048284560442,
-0.37776604294776917,
0.02445114403963089,
0.1812106817960739,
0.3536003530025482,
0.6675880551338196,
0.5689062476158142,
0.8850915431976318,
0.3074212372303009,
0.24993544816970825,
0.16804316639900208,
-0.10315302759408951,
-0.036116600036621094,
0.08199673891067505,
-0.6046230792999268,
-0.3312205374240875,
-0.4300203323364258,
0.4973653554916382,
0.7859086990356445,
0.05825166404247284,
-0.042668357491493225,
-0.5035163760185242,
0.47319209575653076,
-0.38487666845321655,
-0.05320560187101364,
-0.5643046498298645,
0.22906604409217834,
-0.15774641931056976,
-0.45361328125,
0.06579285860061646,
-0.04862140491604805,
0.35390082001686096,
-0.8602526783943176,
0.4067838490009308,
-0.1640886664390564,
0.7143312692642212,
0.3753374218940735,
-0.3397659659385681,
-0.10781361907720566,
-0.5072714686393738,
0.3506942689418793,
-0.25824397802352905,
0.23365245759487152,
0.13938036561012268,
0.5506268739700317,
-0.1906391680240631,
-1.0096313953399658,
-0.5825757384300232,
0.15457020699977875,
-0.08440067619085312,
0.3041308522224426,
-0.5341551899909973,
-0.25063958764076233,
0.07761286944150925,
0.3413935601711273,
-0.9746120572090149,
0.06935273110866547,
-0.532745897769928,
-0.32188543677330017,
0.43686679005622864,
0.44371113181114197,
0.9206649661064148,
-0.09526161104440689,
-0.5283524990081787,
0.11389116197824478,
-0.638282835483551,
0.30664387345314026,
0.05928996577858925,
-0.2962771952152252,
-0.1327061951160431,
0.42075443267822266,
-0.15661294758319855,
0.7528694272041321,
-0.2580193877220154,
-0.00281383004039526,
0.13708123564720154,
-0.18737289309501648,
0.09397653490304947,
-0.2921174466609955,
0.5023515224456787,
0.7789780497550964,
0.16489504277706146,
-0.009443092159926891,
0.057114820927381516,
0.1772226244211197,
0.190291166305542,
-0.6205611228942871,
-0.751115083694458,
0.16195908188819885,
-0.6634165048599243,
-0.26852521300315857,
0.14755848050117493,
-1.0267242193222046,
-0.7517674565315247,
0.08436700701713562,
0.5481106638908386,
-0.2939199209213257,
-0.6839746832847595,
0.26347649097442627,
-0.5899236798286438,
0.19392052292823792,
0.6017159223556519,
-0.4590053856372833,
0.11161454766988754,
0.015000064857304096,
0.2714892029762268,
-0.06271249800920486,
-0.36342719197273254,
-0.5955372452735901,
0.04666674882173538,
-0.4416174292564392,
1.1495767831802368,
-0.5131404399871826,
-0.21696588397026062,
-0.0004126337298657745,
0.4914645850658417,
-0.00005631391832139343,
-0.5297822952270508,
0.04661104455590248,
-0.5220472812652588,
0.26135438680648804,
-0.5419206619262695,
-0.29762300848960876,
-0.5498364567756653,
0.29535436630249023,
-0.4506557583808899,
0.5408465266227722,
0.21512527763843536,
-0.7153376340866089,
0.32778629660606384,
-0.8669021725654602,
-0.09957749396562576,
0.32825374603271484,
-0.2747936546802521,
-0.3252888321876526,
0.17790046334266663,
0.7142599821090698,
0.293781578540802,
-0.3693475127220154,
-0.003904276993125677,
-0.4697897136211395,
-0.20291486382484436,
0.5401062965393066,
-0.4001143276691437,
0.5088315606117249,
-0.006233065854758024,
-0.09053685516119003,
0.1185222640633583,
-0.47855252027511597,
0.13767503201961517,
0.6100126504898071,
0.20617854595184326,
-0.35433104634284973,
-0.34521961212158203,
-0.09567267447710037,
0.010680541396141052,
0.23567327857017517,
-0.5576925873756409,
0.0693490132689476,
-0.13767977058887482,
0.1591288447380066,
0.40539485216140747,
0.5443078875541687,
0.19050686061382294,
-0.10593001544475555,
0.8222251534461975,
0.7596223950386047,
0.3240697979927063,
-0.5764225125312805,
-0.9681148529052734,
-0.5216350555419922,
-0.46880894899368286,
-0.0981157124042511,
0.5737560987472534,
-0.8517959117889404,
-0.04529727250337601,
-0.1076456680893898,
-0.21589072048664093,
-0.79649817943573,
0.09515447169542313,
0.3880990147590637,
0.8640660643577576,
0.5721285939216614,
-0.3098199963569641,
-0.2973420321941376,
-0.9246944189071655,
-0.33220404386520386,
0.13136132061481476,
0.24397030472755432,
0.3014460802078247,
0.5693984031677246,
-0.2896028757095337,
0.6270201206207275,
-0.9140066504478455,
-0.2710641026496887,
-0.23812445998191833,
0.28451618552207947,
0.04638628289103508,
0.40386149287223816,
0.7969223856925964,
-1.1231861114501953,
-0.17281277477741241,
-0.03557078540325165,
-0.9978617429733276,
-0.0762706771492958,
-0.12312798947095871,
0.1884436309337616,
-0.17263853549957275,
0.5408534407615662,
-0.3258473575115204,
0.7972861528396606,
0.25186556577682495,
-0.198771134018898,
0.3673165738582611,
-0.43555933237075806,
0.46532848477363586,
-1.0849583148956299,
-0.10786198824644089,
0.046225305646657944,
-0.26096174120903015,
-0.7723065614700317,
0.222794309258461,
0.21341747045516968,
-0.22520248591899872,
-0.4769851565361023,
0.3489062190055847,
-0.46412116289138794,
-0.18506617844104767,
-0.09534097462892532,
-0.10273544490337372,
0.20893077552318573,
0.42347434163093567,
0.009044568985700607,
0.5432881712913513,
1.398787498474121,
-0.32087138295173645,
0.48707708716392517,
0.1858217567205429,
-0.19072464108467102,
0.6486909985542297,
-0.5509546399116516,
0.060477979481220245,
-0.7090451717376709,
-0.07030050456523895,
-1.3547327518463135,
-0.5633143186569214,
0.258197158575058,
-0.5542312860488892,
0.26106730103492737,
-0.4226348102092743,
-0.1452690213918686,
-0.6508051753044128,
-0.12948672473430634,
0.468032568693161,
0.37362587451934814,
-0.6728720664978027,
0.3645747900009155,
0.4283735156059265,
0.22795982658863068,
-0.5117101669311523,
-0.9013343453407288,
0.0023863324895501137,
-0.35561293363571167,
-0.5934141278266907,
-0.14264148473739624,
-0.027838168665766716,
-0.15226693451404572,
0.41158515214920044,
0.08518018573522568,
-0.702562153339386,
0.17553822696208954,
0.17157182097434998,
0.35811614990234375,
-0.5738195180892944,
0.09608739614486694,
0.061458855867385864,
0.15978482365608215,
-0.042197439819574356,
-0.09849795699119568,
0.3563910126686096,
-0.33193281292915344,
-0.8512123823165894,
-0.5728844404220581,
0.804527997970581,
0.7391150593757629,
-0.5145298838615417,
0.33697110414505005,
0.6477834582328796,
-0.6792675256729126,
0.2732600271701813,
-0.2925090789794922,
-0.165365532040596,
-0.44578611850738525,
0.6090378165245056,
-0.2973456382751465,
-0.546966552734375,
0.7713620662689209,
-0.06362179666757584,
-0.3083401620388031,
0.27652794122695923,
0.28889256715774536,
-0.44292137026786804,
1.299230694770813,
0.5238080024719238,
0.34039071202278137,
0.047179799526929855,
-0.3155471086502075,
0.22430889308452606,
-0.6877833008766174,
-0.3327990472316742,
0.06240563467144966,
-0.11852527409791946,
-0.46846792101860046,
-0.34756678342819214,
0.8077043294906616,
0.15269948542118073,
0.38626807928085327,
0.03320329636335373,
-0.5034317374229431,
0.6686201095581055,
0.34309566020965576,
0.3659134805202484,
0.11738501489162445,
-0.11188440769910812,
0.24213409423828125,
-0.1420149803161621,
-0.8392539620399475,
-0.011025692336261272,
1.0925774574279785,
0.006745930295437574,
0.6616331338882446,
0.17023447155952454,
0.41873297095298767,
0.1824464350938797,
0.13218505680561066,
-0.45467227697372437,
0.2583196759223938,
-0.09568221122026443,
-0.569671094417572,
-0.32873642444610596,
-0.14888250827789307,
-1.038096308708191,
0.2733021676540375,
-0.523339033126831,
-0.9652658104896545,
0.4653909504413605,
0.4493609368801117,
-0.41798490285873413,
0.4221673011779785,
-0.8940492272377014,
1.1595454216003418,
-0.3078295588493347,
0.11593586206436157,
0.15636061131954193,
-0.8522256016731262,
0.7583522200584412,
0.15468049049377441,
0.27880358695983887,
0.32129794359207153,
0.09498471021652222,
0.18499316275119781,
-0.16840264201164246,
0.6485579013824463,
-0.23998220264911652,
0.33981239795684814,
0.322904497385025,
-0.01749802567064762,
-0.04569835960865021,
0.2707241177558899,
0.6619378924369812,
0.1428593099117279,
0.18555863201618195,
-0.4795321524143219,
-0.9102408289909363,
0.4853440225124359,
-0.48124009370803833,
-0.56413334608078,
-0.13373586535453796,
-0.7957712411880493,
-0.14136138558387756,
0.1215457022190094,
0.44891178607940674,
0.7629599571228027,
-0.05076631158590317,
0.011868024244904518,
0.80354243516922,
-0.5422412157058716,
0.4389212429523468,
0.38225483894348145,
-0.18166998028755188,
-0.07672393321990967,
0.9544246196746826,
-0.18230849504470825,
0.010433721356093884,
0.4368542730808258,
0.2576662302017212,
-0.38627880811691284,
-0.5628142356872559,
-0.769313633441925,
0.07702895253896713,
-0.8377604484558105,
-0.09966961294412613,
-0.783206582069397,
-0.04967379570007324,
-0.5348007678985596,
0.11974114179611206,
-0.12660832703113556,
-0.4545194208621979,
-0.3411180377006531,
0.34170085191726685,
0.45680925250053406,
0.5689430832862854,
-0.10855201631784439,
0.2313288152217865,
-0.9970473647117615,
0.6810115575790405,
0.5879091620445251,
0.07873135805130005,
-0.2868952751159668,
-0.3843066990375519,
0.1490541249513626,
0.13278089463710785,
-0.17253626883029938,
-1.335487961769104,
0.30903157591819763,
0.21548978984355927,
0.6286720037460327,
0.767463207244873,
-0.1286149024963379,
0.858855664730072,
-0.1261257380247116,
0.6893743276596069,
0.4522346556186676,
-0.3558948040008545,
0.6995505690574646,
-0.3893158733844757,
0.3807445168495178,
0.21399210393428802,
0.3570440411567688,
-0.35324910283088684,
-0.34724581241607666,
-0.7346675992012024,
-0.5556783080101013,
0.4696425497531891,
-0.11405416578054428,
-0.08157731592655182,
0.1437067687511444,
0.4019189178943634,
-0.03149471431970596,
0.19191965460777283,
-0.5423528552055359,
-0.3926751911640167,
-0.4800156354904175,
0.04565021023154259,
-0.10505126416683197,
0.030311819165945053,
-0.47667983174324036,
-0.39767640829086304,
0.001770891947671771,
-0.30068710446357727,
0.4169148802757263,
0.36734601855278015,
-0.4822496473789215,
-0.1836370825767517,
0.1685057133436203,
0.6843928694725037,
0.6895910501480103,
-0.022484494373202324,
0.3887781798839569,
0.14753791689872742,
-0.5493475198745728,
-0.2027345597743988,
0.09406709671020508,
0.12470905482769012,
-0.0283975712954998,
0.465647429227829,
0.6674069166183472,
-0.23577852547168732,
-0.7809924483299255,
0.8605303168296814,
-0.32429105043411255,
-0.21326975524425507,
-0.2707820534706116,
0.1222144365310669,
0.18083491921424866,
0.35567089915275574,
0.34378233551979065,
0.3735077977180481,
0.41670405864715576,
-0.577613115310669,
0.38788652420043945,
0.7097445130348206,
-0.5974327921867371,
-0.40069660544395447,
0.4958624839782715,
-0.2062167525291443,
-0.07964181900024414,
0.4991381764411926,
0.03415334224700928,
-0.6338493227958679,
0.9888819456100464,
0.4675871729850769,
0.340031236410141,
-0.1860196441411972,
0.37772151827812195,
-0.06265412271022797,
0.5621960759162903,
0.2736514210700989,
0.7306072115898132,
0.25361207127571106,
-0.8366832137107849,
0.024745523929595947,
0.04708850756287575,
-0.05566006526350975,
0.4922332465648651,
-0.7595515847206116,
0.040925346314907074,
-0.16920046508312225,
0.1294439285993576,
0.14822988212108612,
-0.7050034999847412,
-0.7126169800758362,
0.4955368638038635,
0.01804645173251629,
0.5837159156799316,
-1.131758451461792,
0.5162476301193237,
1.1744126081466675,
-0.4252817928791046,
-0.5499700307846069,
0.0031933116260915995,
-0.017917513847351074,
-1.1032105684280396,
0.12810499966144562,
0.08603066951036453,
0.2500431537628174,
0.014549309387803078,
-0.5506402254104614,
-0.614547073841095,
0.7577295899391174,
0.4170686900615692,
0.010584915988147259,
0.44678664207458496,
0.17114025354385376,
0.6092079877853394,
-0.4373946785926819,
0.28660643100738525,
0.5185328722000122,
0.43585771322250366,
0.0961170643568039,
-0.30624398589134216,
-0.08657100051641464,
-0.3132719397544861,
-0.23616835474967957,
0.3962186276912689,
-0.08133655786514282,
0.6428282260894775,
-0.7879587411880493,
0.060041315853595734,
0.0023197380360215902,
0.265251100063324,
0.028878891840577126,
0.6264217495918274,
0.5903834104537964,
0.6588438749313354,
0.8374824523925781,
-0.24340569972991943,
1.1642646789550781,
-0.29578015208244324,
-0.0894995629787445,
0.7393127679824829,
0.21406474709510803,
0.18828034400939941,
0.5125398635864258,
0.14624159038066864,
0.30966463685035706,
0.7803451418876648,
0.03284241631627083,
0.6041879653930664,
-0.08467041701078415,
-0.07814877480268478,
-0.7223363518714905,
-0.163275808095932,
-0.6641939282417297,
0.7054256796836853,
0.23905092477798462,
-0.1206284612417221,
-0.41334137320518494,
0.24048465490341187,
-0.5616112947463989,
-0.07572073489427567,
-0.3713405132293701,
0.7699195146560669,
-0.168922558426857,
-0.42715486884117126,
0.41677480936050415,
-0.3776320219039917,
0.07864121347665787,
-0.33729758858680725,
-0.4288557469844818,
-0.3310198485851288,
-0.07792704552412033,
-0.09793116897344589,
-0.9764909744262695,
0.19892653822898865,
-0.17658840119838715,
-0.1664923131465912,
0.2789185643196106,
0.7477567195892334,
-0.5556724071502686,
-0.5563523173332214,
-0.18774545192718506,
0.8438736200332642,
0.4354510009288788,
0.051838554441928864,
-0.6487028002738953,
-0.5019738078117371,
-0.17103418707847595,
0.16973763704299927,
0.34516990184783936,
0.7837649583816528,
-0.46294763684272766,
0.713844358921051,
0.6744381189346313,
-0.04868074133992195,
0.19191114604473114,
0.040192704647779465,
0.850709080696106,
-0.20646078884601593,
-0.600285530090332,
-0.33671656250953674,
0.8282501697540283,
-0.22562989592552185,
-0.468131422996521,
0.44915899634361267,
0.20848926901817322,
0.3739839792251587,
-0.4719599187374115,
0.5330854058265686,
0.17673520743846893,
0.3035114109516144,
-0.3904089629650116,
0.7534077167510986,
-1.3085894584655762,
0.1491071730852127,
-0.3044981062412262,
-0.42148399353027344,
-0.43525445461273193,
0.3361222743988037,
0.0646197497844696,
-0.3214472830295563,
0.8404911160469055,
1.1110260486602783,
-0.2695934772491455,
0.01066041924059391,
0.5382547378540039,
0.01591421663761139,
0.0001104661132558249,
0.470763236284256,
1.148598551750183,
-0.40932828187942505,
0.4693848490715027,
-0.19740065932273865,
-0.33491116762161255,
-0.041393112391233444,
-0.6655479669570923,
-0.8715832233428955,
-0.6839740872383118,
-0.42432916164398193,
0.043703190982341766,
0.1059037372469902,
0.4068048298358917,
0.7199839949607849,
-0.6875518560409546,
0.3196602165699005,
-0.20837947726249695,
0.35527515411376953,
-0.34569457173347473,
-0.18291115760803223,
0.5393610596656799,
0.04773908481001854,
-0.39113447070121765,
0.33376479148864746,
0.4727136194705963,
0.35091903805732727,
-0.133384570479393,
0.2773300111293793,
-0.05490916594862938,
-0.32304447889328003,
0.06430401653051376,
0.42267072200775146,
-0.4811531901359558,
-0.04438605532050133,
0.16081726551055908,
0.22088304162025452,
0.33327609300613403,
1.0091696977615356,
-0.576768159866333,
0.7679587602615356,
0.43767982721328735,
0.6850031614303589,
0.3655151128768921,
-0.09976902604103088,
0.34139230847358704,
-0.47569137811660767,
0.4076060652732849,
0.11733872443437576,
0.538062334060669,
0.3775862157344818,
-0.715854287147522,
-0.01693466491997242,
0.44945207238197327,
-0.08774055540561676,
-0.913979172706604,
0.524834930896759,
-0.9511973857879639,
-0.4608394205570221,
0.7452555894851685,
-0.3982526361942291,
-0.20977333188056946,
-0.4084368944168091,
-0.022203614935278893,
0.106754831969738,
-0.022648388519883156,
0.7411511540412903,
0.19250865280628204,
-0.5401270389556885,
-0.6583225727081299,
-0.361009418964386,
0.3151140511035919,
0.4846208989620209,
-1.120192050933838,
-0.3621198236942291,
0.436063289642334,
0.376956582069397,
-0.02926398441195488,
0.6676849722862244,
-0.26008298993110657,
1.0523093938827515,
-0.28669676184654236,
-0.13374468684196472,
-0.21211060881614685,
-0.49409592151641846,
-0.4467053711414337,
0.06963010877370834,
-0.16691307723522186,
-0.7297767996788025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07616v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07616v1
|
Audio Dialogues: Dialogues dataset for audio and music understanding
| 2024-04-11T10:08:34 | 2024-04-11T10:08:34 |
Arushi Goel, Zhifeng Kong, Rafael Valle, Bryan Catanzaro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Existing datasets for audio understanding primarily focus on single-turn
interactions (i.e. audio captioning, audio question answering) for describing
audio in natural language, thus limiting understanding audio via interactive
dialogue. To address this gap, we introduce Audio Dialogues: a multi-turn
dialogue dataset containing 163.8k samples for general audio sounds and music.
In addition to dialogues, Audio Dialogues also has question-answer pairs to
understand and compare multiple input audios together. Audio Dialogues
leverages a prompting-based approach and caption annotations from existing
datasets to generate multi-turn dialogues using a Large Language Model (LLM).
We evaluate existing audio-augmented large language models on our proposed
dataset to demonstrate the complexity and applicability of Audio Dialogues. Our
code for generating the dataset will be made publicly available. Detailed
prompts and generated dialogues can be found on the demo website
https://audiodialogues.github.io/.
|
[
-0.5787306427955627,
-0.67942214012146,
0.8336069583892822,
0.2645852565765381,
-0.14818543195724487,
0.11558298021554947,
-0.36736637353897095,
-0.40852487087249756,
0.20977111160755157,
0.822345495223999,
-1.140235424041748,
-0.7055522799491882,
-0.10933797806501389,
0.15270288288593292,
-0.5232697129249573,
0.8861694931983948,
0.24163416028022766,
0.41796210408210754,
-0.37507733702659607,
-0.4060967266559601,
-0.674365758895874,
-0.22206108272075653,
-0.7868250012397766,
-0.12102146446704865,
0.3983410894870758,
0.6987438797950745,
0.49427103996276855,
0.03787509351968765,
0.32372671365737915,
0.33831772208213806,
0.07151500135660172,
0.16599427163600922,
-0.23081424832344055,
0.39844319224357605,
0.3314051330089569,
-0.33740177750587463,
-0.052309539169073105,
0.13633213937282562,
0.4733645021915436,
0.6815520524978638,
-0.15363863110542297,
0.35555756092071533,
-0.41034963726997375,
0.6871284246444702,
-0.1436198353767395,
0.4709043502807617,
-0.42640921473503113,
0.0930207148194313,
0.04109879955649376,
-0.2963044047355652,
-0.3570597171783447,
-0.26366502046585083,
0.2163846790790558,
-0.9398857355117798,
0.09159024804830551,
0.17497889697551727,
0.26010358333587646,
0.2739841341972351,
-0.09999728202819824,
-0.6529351472854614,
-1.008636713027954,
0.7614654302597046,
-0.5179187655448914,
0.28629106283187866,
0.654866099357605,
0.7035918831825256,
0.006950582843273878,
-0.45787450671195984,
-0.8227638602256775,
-0.09689657390117645,
0.20206640660762787,
0.21034598350524902,
-0.014722995460033417,
0.05870158597826958,
0.2683669328689575,
0.7413821816444397,
-0.4513699412345886,
-0.18244732916355133,
-0.2783661484718323,
-0.009371534921228886,
0.7566002011299133,
0.29361656308174133,
0.5700034499168396,
-0.29012012481689453,
0.004073876887559891,
-0.07530578970909119,
-0.5362452268600464,
0.1279069185256958,
0.6027777194976807,
0.4167197644710541,
-0.24876669049263,
0.5549793243408203,
0.056526362895965576,
0.8682994246482849,
-0.03641728311777115,
-0.25553518533706665,
0.35152876377105713,
-0.8986835479736328,
-0.14532685279846191,
0.18560636043548584,
0.8663039207458496,
0.36717674136161804,
0.3502297103404999,
-0.1735432744026184,
-0.05470800772309303,
-0.21828040480613708,
-0.009647947736084461,
-0.4383547902107239,
-0.3109436333179474,
0.6930221319198608,
-0.29337626695632935,
-0.24355436861515045,
-0.015227253548800945,
-0.7842028737068176,
-0.6976184844970703,
-0.7015025019645691,
0.5597732067108154,
-0.38354185223579407,
-0.21028292179107666,
0.2899472713470459,
-0.23776555061340332,
0.1545322984457016,
0.46860581636428833,
-0.8123798966407776,
0.48798954486846924,
0.44116705656051636,
0.7619396448135376,
-0.09778638929128647,
-0.07355502992868423,
-0.7357192039489746,
0.032901495695114136,
-0.08219355344772339,
0.7197281122207642,
-0.5971787571907043,
-0.5085368156433105,
0.05984574556350708,
-0.055316951125860214,
0.07151739299297333,
-0.6687110662460327,
0.4873824119567871,
-0.2462967187166214,
0.30831634998321533,
-0.05233226343989372,
-0.43197572231292725,
-0.26517951488494873,
-0.03564802184700966,
-0.9857861399650574,
0.6825301051139832,
-0.14208486676216125,
-0.5639918446540833,
0.18194089829921722,
-1.052065134048462,
-0.3941299617290497,
-0.12844537198543549,
-0.22882087528705597,
-0.27807942032814026,
-0.07253856956958771,
0.6608344912528992,
0.12278351187705994,
-0.31206876039505005,
0.23162071406841278,
-0.19559608399868011,
-0.490052729845047,
0.5909252762794495,
-0.425331711769104,
0.64979088306427,
0.2963502109050751,
0.10472528636455536,
0.2676207423210144,
-0.7661895155906677,
-0.36644071340560913,
0.1887926608324051,
-0.15372885763645172,
0.05143766477704048,
0.021756675094366074,
0.2671833336353302,
-0.11751897633075714,
-0.1746230572462082,
-0.7037052512168884,
0.3049688935279846,
-0.15841498970985413,
0.8345098495483398,
0.3986656069755554,
0.2211225926876068,
0.3920627236366272,
-0.35370543599128723,
0.6103721261024475,
0.10237934440374374,
0.14110930263996124,
-0.8681458234786987,
-0.5406137108802795,
-0.42335227131843567,
-0.20931614935398102,
0.2984931170940399,
0.68068528175354,
-0.5848499536514282,
0.25194600224494934,
-0.17205636203289032,
-0.14237307012081146,
-0.989942193031311,
0.19838054478168488,
0.16965095698833466,
0.3295033872127533,
0.376221626996994,
-0.16525675356388092,
-0.691331148147583,
-0.8050963282585144,
0.020160367712378502,
-0.21700216829776764,
-0.33581459522247314,
0.6898880004882812,
0.17746636271476746,
-0.056062594056129456,
0.9168200492858887,
-0.2420063018798828,
-0.09934362769126892,
-0.41898149251937866,
0.3722854554653168,
0.4815937578678131,
0.30195704102516174,
0.3161010444164276,
-0.7433975338935852,
-0.149394690990448,
-0.3788716197013855,
-0.4500576853752136,
-0.027771158143877983,
-0.3850914537906647,
0.05954456329345703,
-0.33290591835975647,
0.6128122806549072,
-0.6558747291564941,
0.07664143294095993,
0.6264520287513733,
0.07742007076740265,
0.44672009348869324,
0.4706980288028717,
0.48316046595573425,
-1.0249934196472168,
-0.24840642511844635,
-0.11365015059709549,
-0.2675733268260956,
-0.678213894367218,
-0.662804365158081,
-0.5647426247596741,
-0.42277395725250244,
-0.3982565104961395,
0.2668236494064331,
-0.2665126621723175,
-0.4702175259590149,
-0.05473046749830246,
0.3408532440662384,
0.13369375467300415,
0.6103610992431641,
0.20276299118995667,
0.9695988297462463,
0.710520327091217,
-0.3615415692329407,
0.6933659911155701,
0.7397329211235046,
-0.7849875688552856,
0.5598083734512329,
-0.5379683375358582,
0.3846496641635895,
0.013422368094325066,
0.334637850522995,
-1.30774986743927,
-0.344916433095932,
0.09099901467561722,
-0.5723234415054321,
0.27457553148269653,
-0.41594603657722473,
-0.5474802255630493,
-0.22234410047531128,
-0.16794748604297638,
0.5854556560516357,
0.13234077394008636,
-0.6503041386604309,
0.6081032156944275,
0.5363985300064087,
-0.6747264266014099,
-0.2111104130744934,
-0.4925626814365387,
0.19503317773342133,
-0.28581106662750244,
-0.7906227707862854,
-0.13330276310443878,
-0.4542500972747803,
-0.5460532903671265,
-0.18527139723300934,
0.05719932168722153,
-0.17813365161418915,
-0.25924617052078247,
0.44266796112060547,
0.23762477934360504,
-0.20031209290027618,
0.376891553401947,
-0.019502749666571617,
-0.07209835201501846,
0.13564550876617432,
-0.3251110315322876,
0.4372289180755615,
-0.11840736865997314,
-0.5073070526123047,
-0.559937059879303,
0.6056420207023621,
0.7722717523574829,
-0.20801882445812225,
0.22128602862358093,
0.3730483055114746,
0.07734338939189911,
0.22616441547870636,
-0.5022571682929993,
-0.19894561171531677,
-0.41996487975120544,
0.216719850897789,
-0.34706413745880127,
-0.9136707782745361,
0.5289543867111206,
-0.04787463694810867,
0.3015621602535248,
0.041505567729473114,
0.5711761116981506,
-0.5128151178359985,
1.1897345781326294,
0.08705837279558182,
-0.19373123347759247,
0.5648506879806519,
-0.21360531449317932,
0.09087321162223816,
-0.7509890198707581,
-0.24411673843860626,
-0.4921075701713562,
-0.1862507164478302,
-0.48037299513816833,
-0.27371320128440857,
0.2579666078090668,
-0.3579771816730499,
-0.15030817687511444,
0.24971261620521545,
-0.31433141231536865,
0.6215425729751587,
0.6844637989997864,
0.11210903525352478,
0.5071463584899902,
-0.04442167654633522,
0.0497620515525341,
0.10179083049297333,
-0.4833524525165558,
-0.1967191994190216,
1.1494807004928589,
0.42098650336265564,
0.741867184638977,
0.14354625344276428,
0.4857572317123413,
0.291912704706192,
-0.2684485912322998,
-1.157362937927246,
0.24004696309566498,
0.33107230067253113,
-0.7172470688819885,
-0.5680177211761475,
-0.45751574635505676,
-0.7445240020751953,
-0.1856950968503952,
-0.23164469003677368,
-0.6991762518882751,
-0.036133747547864914,
-0.10305893421173096,
-0.42830130457878113,
0.15787607431411743,
-0.7690452337265015,
0.6121801733970642,
-0.22620195150375366,
-0.06307270377874374,
-0.037363793700933456,
-0.642839789390564,
0.2683091163635254,
0.19878622889518738,
0.6298243999481201,
-0.16669180989265442,
0.625670313835144,
0.7599905729293823,
-0.14864963293075562,
0.506820023059845,
-0.22914931178092957,
-0.02506135404109955,
0.5610337257385254,
0.07815730571746826,
0.06197327747941017,
0.4731593728065491,
0.10274658352136612,
0.10330474376678467,
0.05264540761709213,
-0.19757342338562012,
-0.7268814444541931,
0.5503360629081726,
-0.6662549376487732,
-0.4252025783061981,
-0.06017927825450897,
-0.89776211977005,
-0.5863123536109924,
-0.1094280332326889,
0.0904061421751976,
0.7299177646636963,
0.017117202281951904,
0.21779604256153107,
0.7692756056785583,
-0.4762919843196869,
0.43070805072784424,
0.5824849605560303,
-0.40663081407546997,
-0.6941041350364685,
0.8070046901702881,
-0.35409805178642273,
0.2415066361427307,
0.12767086923122406,
0.015368969179689884,
-0.4520355761051178,
-0.5831500887870789,
-0.6994896531105042,
0.17289848625659943,
-0.5945903062820435,
0.08327634632587433,
-0.5461335778236389,
0.10679040104150772,
-0.2687906324863434,
0.25907668471336365,
-0.2824101746082306,
-0.683894693851471,
0.00875050202012062,
-0.41252806782722473,
0.7971692681312561,
1.0230655670166016,
-0.17250332236289978,
0.19613389670848846,
-0.8964247703552246,
0.6799269318580627,
0.6007636785507202,
0.4105848968029022,
-0.28552111983299255,
-0.48198166489601135,
-0.33549559116363525,
-0.02968422695994377,
-0.023338401690125465,
-1.069594383239746,
0.08932049572467804,
0.1224779561161995,
0.34515148401260376,
0.3309626281261444,
-0.20051082968711853,
0.44349998235702515,
-0.6119329333305359,
0.9336698055267334,
0.29844003915786743,
-0.9520252346992493,
0.7509466409683228,
-0.46372708678245544,
0.3994911015033722,
0.9114041328430176,
0.16449983417987823,
-0.7110550999641418,
-0.3809647858142853,
-0.40326058864593506,
-0.6551557183265686,
0.7944804430007935,
0.5019993185997009,
0.10111726075410843,
0.3150331676006317,
0.05565531179308891,
0.2921672761440277,
0.38706767559051514,
-0.5218967199325562,
-0.4105318486690521,
-0.4499475657939911,
-0.33906155824661255,
-0.3049008846282959,
0.0006213895394466817,
-0.41443198919296265,
-0.3924248218536377,
0.46224233508110046,
-0.042579878121614456,
0.3867073655128479,
0.11745887994766235,
-0.034383438527584076,
-0.07780701667070389,
0.49136364459991455,
0.5404139757156372,
0.38563472032546997,
-0.28055277466773987,
-0.10276587307453156,
-0.016821805387735367,
-0.5411757826805115,
0.10693516582250595,
0.04856957495212555,
0.22263970971107483,
0.10828150808811188,
0.42746004462242126,
1.046603798866272,
0.2775392234325409,
-0.7538794875144958,
0.2984491288661957,
-0.4238726794719696,
-0.2095007449388504,
-0.5886407494544983,
0.05575040727853775,
0.43724900484085083,
-0.08382401615381241,
0.29225561022758484,
-0.1387883722782135,
0.5453106760978699,
-0.7111756801605225,
0.2804071009159088,
0.041042547672986984,
-0.717134416103363,
-0.10039448738098145,
0.2984446883201599,
0.28703567385673523,
-0.3024711310863495,
0.935416579246521,
0.1546919345855713,
-0.1788509339094162,
0.6080067753791809,
0.14092907309532166,
0.9626686573028564,
0.09131577610969543,
0.2535858750343323,
0.48737701773643494,
0.044258031994104385,
0.34596994519233704,
0.4481641948223114,
-0.5981387495994568,
-0.604912281036377,
-0.6875839233398438,
-0.5388191938400269,
-1.0169425010681152,
0.5203233957290649,
-0.7439486980438232,
0.12182516604661942,
-0.2262003868818283,
0.0835769847035408,
0.2938092350959778,
-0.1921883374452591,
-0.47801673412323,
-0.020751558244228363,
0.22803279757499695,
0.8340315818786621,
-1.0216591358184814,
0.491163045167923,
0.4355822503566742,
-0.7102475166320801,
-0.6378903985023499,
-0.08260071277618408,
0.1091243326663971,
-0.4261333644390106,
0.29191040992736816,
0.29563000798225403,
-0.18975168466567993,
-0.2138366401195526,
-1.0862053632736206,
-0.40169766545295715,
0.7946389317512512,
0.1615423709154129,
-0.6406603455543518,
0.3646716773509979,
0.3121615946292877,
0.31429824233055115,
-0.5318976044654846,
0.42307353019714355,
0.8013338446617126,
0.7402417659759521,
0.44502201676368713,
-0.8529611229896545,
-0.5812665820121765,
-0.5118630528450012,
-0.510575532913208,
0.09049424529075623,
-0.24706502258777618,
0.5218708515167236,
-0.21909283101558685,
-0.03541532903909683,
0.19242779910564423,
0.5119956731796265,
0.3608465790748596,
0.6568270325660706,
0.7518967986106873,
0.4176906645298004,
0.5436679720878601,
-0.37503287196159363,
1.0208138227462769,
-0.04852975532412529,
-0.0035927272401750088,
1.442809820175171,
-0.09054644405841827,
0.48487788438796997,
0.4965062439441681,
-0.2639153301715851,
0.4794952869415283,
0.8086239099502563,
0.10279928147792816,
0.42702651023864746,
0.37331414222717285,
-0.4811602532863617,
-0.588059663772583,
-0.1964961737394333,
-0.1708413064479828,
0.5162602663040161,
0.43431052565574646,
-0.024511633440852165,
0.23721075057983398,
0.23649822175502777,
-0.39463990926742554,
-0.06224483251571655,
-0.1518319547176361,
1.1628692150115967,
0.08594273775815964,
-0.4531283974647522,
-0.024123165756464005,
-0.6441364884376526,
0.20425547659397125,
-0.4179987907409668,
-0.49650269746780396,
-0.06937900185585022,
-0.521052896976471,
-0.18006181716918945,
-1.1681376695632935,
0.05810242146253586,
0.07212217152118683,
-0.3885129690170288,
-0.08452792465686798,
0.1862325817346573,
-0.7290379405021667,
-0.36954283714294434,
0.23340539634227753,
0.25041812658309937,
0.26913076639175415,
-0.11863209307193756,
-0.6090722680091858,
0.13285361230373383,
-0.07346133887767792,
-0.032297275960445404,
-0.06820766627788544,
0.429727703332901,
0.3326016068458557,
0.5901879072189331,
0.695829451084137,
-0.026876628398895264,
-0.016478195786476135,
0.6606733798980713,
0.630742073059082,
-0.4945431649684906,
-0.46172478795051575,
-0.2626227140426636,
0.44386157393455505,
-0.009340785443782806,
-0.023363225162029266,
0.5098571181297302,
0.6043604016304016,
0.642388105392456,
-0.1878187209367752,
1.027204990386963,
0.2735711336135864,
0.8191631436347961,
-0.8638792634010315,
0.2327910214662552,
-0.516361653804779,
0.331438809633255,
-0.3969843089580536,
-0.744636058807373,
-0.02797209471464157,
0.4810192286968231,
-0.24393166601657867,
0.033542584627866745,
0.3898063600063324,
0.675132691860199,
-0.183354452252388,
0.756248950958252,
0.1810060292482376,
0.09064121544361115,
0.20811685919761658,
0.5415788888931274,
1.2339606285095215,
-0.35811200737953186,
0.7837463021278381,
-0.17809395492076874,
-0.036338504403829575,
0.041855230927467346,
-0.5639824867248535,
-0.8321871161460876,
-0.8037556409835815,
-0.2824490964412689,
-0.2797379791736603,
-0.14266470074653625,
0.831329345703125,
0.7344084978103638,
-1.293837547302246,
-0.4182592034339905,
-0.19482694566249847,
0.19684697687625885,
-0.06818561255931854,
-0.2428150177001953,
0.13506415486335754,
-0.1602182239294052,
-1.0958281755447388,
0.9808201789855957,
0.36343109607696533,
-0.023918375372886658,
-0.4408026337623596,
-0.2855248749256134,
-0.047965750098228455,
0.29665473103523254,
0.3139426112174988,
0.45830294489860535,
-0.4709499776363373,
-0.16310271620750427,
0.0797824114561081,
0.34949272871017456,
0.3962593078613281,
1.1891170740127563,
-0.4715743958950043,
0.9390281438827515,
0.5097523927688599,
0.36803293228149414,
0.8508046865463257,
-0.12500488758087158,
0.7463783621788025,
-0.6163438558578491,
0.0007236081873998046,
0.21101512014865875,
0.29601290822029114,
0.571810781955719,
-0.07177789509296417,
0.362821489572525,
-0.09917397052049637,
-0.5000890493392944,
-0.6329173445701599,
0.47064343094825745,
-1.3493348360061646,
-0.055103350430727005,
1.0417488813400269,
-0.005376046989113092,
-0.015214648097753525,
-0.5191376805305481,
-0.5104551315307617,
0.2662912905216217,
-0.6528089046478271,
0.3782411515712738,
0.960163950920105,
-0.359351247549057,
-0.4076007008552551,
-0.7475218176841736,
0.5758436322212219,
0.22483979165554047,
-0.7893846035003662,
0.20709265768527985,
0.7141780853271484,
-0.05200345814228058,
0.32259535789489746,
0.4897219240665436,
-0.3451051712036133,
0.4597336947917938,
-0.12782786786556244,
0.052983358502388,
-0.268900603055954,
-0.6200273036956787,
-0.5030823945999146,
-0.05595046654343605,
-0.07912500947713852,
-0.42419931292533875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07613v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07613v1
|
Medical mT5: An Open-Source Multilingual Text-to-Text LLM for The Medical Domain
| 2024-04-11T10:01:32 | 2024-04-11T10:01:32 |
Iker García-Ferrero, Rodrigo Agerri, Aitziber Atutxa Salazar, Elena Cabrio, Iker de la Iglesia, Alberto Lavelli, Bernardo Magnini, Benjamin Molinet, Johana Ramirez-Romero, German Rigau, Jose Maria Villa-Gonzalez, Serena Villata, Andrea Zaninello
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Research on language technology for the development of medical applications
is currently a hot topic in Natural Language Understanding and Generation.
Thus, a number of large language models (LLMs) have recently been adapted to
the medical domain, so that they can be used as a tool for mediating in
human-AI interaction. While these LLMs display competitive performance on
automated medical texts benchmarks, they have been pre-trained and evaluated
with a focus on a single language (English mostly). This is particularly true
of text-to-text models, which typically require large amounts of
domain-specific pre-training data, often not easily accessible for many
languages. In this paper, we address these shortcomings by compiling, to the
best of our knowledge, the largest multilingual corpus for the medical domain
in four languages, namely English, French, Italian and Spanish. This new corpus
has been used to train Medical mT5, the first open-source text-to-text
multilingual model for the medical domain. Additionally, we present two new
evaluation benchmarks for all four languages with the aim of facilitating
multilingual research in this domain. A comprehensive evaluation shows that
Medical mT5 outperforms both encoders and similarly sized text-to-text models
for the Spanish, French, and Italian benchmarks, while being competitive with
current state-of-the-art LLMs in English.
|
[
-0.26396673917770386,
-0.4039846658706665,
0.7748000621795654,
0.2371724247932434,
-0.33015552163124084,
0.001714379177428782,
-0.4110642075538635,
-0.6235842108726501,
0.12686510384082794,
0.5169322490692139,
-0.3102191984653473,
-0.9261433482170105,
-0.9272594451904297,
0.6769367456436157,
-0.10906471312046051,
0.8963466286659241,
-0.27943694591522217,
0.6220294237136841,
-0.4535244107246399,
-0.6682139039039612,
-0.27290043234825134,
-0.9411468505859375,
-0.4681212604045868,
-0.2792893648147583,
0.833244800567627,
0.21223235130310059,
0.39614948630332947,
0.7343317270278931,
0.8983556032180786,
0.24995948374271393,
0.2922678291797638,
0.29083746671676636,
-0.23449155688285828,
-0.011498138308525085,
-0.08702912926673889,
-0.3110392689704895,
-0.7043578028678894,
-0.22472889721393585,
0.6677947044372559,
0.7030693292617798,
-0.15613636374473572,
0.1279750019311905,
-0.2583826184272766,
0.5884442925453186,
-0.3767813444137573,
0.13586413860321045,
-0.41507717967033386,
0.02597125433385372,
-0.41141435503959656,
-0.47720128297805786,
-0.5086496472358704,
-0.3106919229030609,
-0.07494733482599258,
-0.5238500833511353,
0.009556900709867477,
0.00828371662646532,
0.6337031722068787,
0.36362212896347046,
-0.570537805557251,
-0.46846747398376465,
-0.4653632342815399,
0.626220703125,
-0.704348623752594,
0.7338936924934387,
0.39431920647621155,
0.4281345009803772,
-0.0300743468105793,
-1.0458346605300903,
-0.42881450057029724,
-0.19782176613807678,
0.21466675400733948,
0.16285403072834015,
0.0064775897189974785,
-0.07333607226610184,
-0.09807625412940979,
0.23681530356407166,
-0.6182523965835571,
0.2241702675819397,
-0.4940391480922699,
0.10057536512613297,
0.27675312757492065,
0.13733313977718353,
0.44475939869880676,
0.21301788091659546,
-0.22579245269298553,
0.1246701031923294,
-0.9987918734550476,
-0.5643543004989624,
-0.0772862657904625,
0.14950674772262573,
-0.24355550110340118,
0.5886156558990479,
0.2489602267742157,
0.5063831210136414,
-0.3000670373439789,
-0.4386807680130005,
0.6598919630050659,
-0.5210024118423462,
-0.20659732818603516,
-0.0814732238650322,
1.054366946220398,
0.3657727539539337,
0.23585036396980286,
-0.21001560986042023,
-0.014204439707100391,
0.035033173859119415,
0.4464832842350006,
-0.992991030216217,
-0.146465465426445,
0.37957563996315,
-0.6372935175895691,
-0.17134299874305725,
-0.4129922091960907,
-0.43019917607307434,
-0.23134258389472961,
-0.04533740133047104,
0.14844968914985657,
-0.629202127456665,
-0.010459293611347675,
0.27901849150657654,
0.2599451541900635,
-0.21232204139232635,
0.2262001782655716,
-0.7607836127281189,
0.27130696177482605,
0.3279452323913574,
0.7156600952148438,
-0.4740182161331177,
-0.47244343161582947,
-0.3910974860191345,
0.31471338868141174,
-0.35383155941963196,
0.8607780933380127,
-0.4715459942817688,
-0.5134748220443726,
-0.008207108825445175,
0.15136680006980896,
0.01591452769935131,
-0.7967507839202881,
0.7696147561073303,
-0.2600427567958832,
0.5390529036521912,
0.009619205258786678,
-0.3266132175922394,
-0.09139876812696457,
0.3902797996997833,
-0.7079010009765625,
0.724398136138916,
-0.001283668214455247,
-0.6933367848396301,
0.3624041676521301,
-1.0444024801254272,
-0.5947331190109253,
0.0798325166106224,
-0.30661141872406006,
-0.705518901348114,
0.0008051714976318181,
0.43428337574005127,
0.47899746894836426,
-0.7434033155441284,
0.3579811751842499,
-0.27992916107177734,
-0.06346666067838669,
0.28003615140914917,
-0.3631031811237335,
0.48306089639663696,
0.2923855781555176,
0.07584860175848007,
0.35972270369529724,
-0.8133031129837036,
-0.13946431875228882,
0.23042990267276764,
-0.5664830803871155,
-0.27218833565711975,
0.11178386956453323,
0.11660066246986389,
0.24386604130268097,
0.2677537202835083,
-0.5006555318832397,
0.053369853645563126,
-0.5254911780357361,
0.4150305390357971,
0.324796199798584,
-0.19572536647319794,
0.031540971249341965,
-0.28151053190231323,
0.4691050946712494,
0.2248435616493225,
0.1878948211669922,
-0.40801918506622314,
-0.4643027186393738,
-0.30311110615730286,
-0.661455512046814,
0.6412492394447327,
0.5231361985206604,
-0.8671805262565613,
0.0853881761431694,
-0.38645729422569275,
-0.18756619095802307,
-1.0016112327575684,
0.08209638297557831,
0.3299279510974884,
0.40428951382637024,
0.5900236368179321,
-0.26545482873916626,
-0.5046391487121582,
-0.8422786593437195,
-0.18579989671707153,
0.1763370782136917,
0.0013698736438527703,
0.18748705089092255,
0.4457632899284363,
-0.6018477082252502,
0.3933531939983368,
-0.22102849185466766,
-0.4180719554424286,
-0.3562355935573578,
-0.1385897397994995,
0.15301503241062164,
0.3392588496208191,
0.7532212734222412,
-0.6088959574699402,
-0.4993340075016022,
0.3531613051891327,
-0.8948624730110168,
-0.05557209998369217,
0.31046605110168457,
0.11885133385658264,
0.20501457154750824,
0.19187770783901215,
-0.3311672508716583,
0.029264329001307487,
0.8982489109039307,
-0.039601944386959076,
0.2480621039867401,
-0.7696684002876282,
0.2998802959918976,
-1.5786808729171753,
0.4513791799545288,
-0.001466103596612811,
-0.3911230266094208,
-0.5941811800003052,
0.10927114635705948,
0.23546333611011505,
0.012177062220871449,
-0.6184135675430298,
0.6939824223518372,
-0.5826455950737,
0.05561109259724617,
-0.20365670323371887,
-0.011442101560533047,
-0.1737767457962036,
0.10204896330833435,
0.05035160109400749,
0.7402410507202148,
0.4158478081226349,
-0.5295745730400085,
0.32349082827568054,
0.3864911198616028,
-0.25075003504753113,
0.6757506728172302,
-0.5406633019447327,
0.12910830974578857,
-0.11933203041553497,
0.09662867337465286,
-0.49400079250335693,
-0.30563926696777344,
0.15864643454551697,
-0.6631395220756531,
0.228956937789917,
-0.03895295783877373,
-0.7416985630989075,
-0.42918160557746887,
-0.17079871892929077,
0.5075473189353943,
0.4564588963985443,
-0.46546557545661926,
0.3366718292236328,
0.665921151638031,
-0.27896445989608765,
-0.5216477513313293,
-0.7977564334869385,
0.2608989477157593,
-0.077003613114357,
-0.4514031410217285,
0.2630099654197693,
-0.2855968475341797,
0.09624255448579788,
-0.10433061420917511,
0.2432333528995514,
-0.35572925209999084,
-0.11062699556350708,
0.028569912537932396,
0.3408213257789612,
-0.3794771432876587,
0.23535001277923584,
0.11662010848522186,
-0.2474294900894165,
-0.006913053337484598,
-0.38773471117019653,
0.42200908064842224,
0.20852932333946228,
-0.5636619329452515,
-0.2492954581975937,
0.42804864048957825,
0.7548909783363342,
-0.46547839045524597,
0.8245106339454651,
0.41667991876602173,
-0.45565974712371826,
0.12113521248102188,
-0.4556513726711273,
0.09929902851581573,
-0.38283640146255493,
0.5830911993980408,
-0.48514488339424133,
-0.8194350004196167,
0.24269722402095795,
-0.35617873072624207,
0.2563818097114563,
0.5146597027778625,
0.9861534237861633,
-0.05921773239970207,
1.1607167720794678,
0.6924242973327637,
0.13966360688209534,
0.011076266877353191,
0.25811973214149475,
-0.09579441696405411,
-0.6005892753601074,
-0.28305429220199585,
-0.6001963019371033,
-0.0733608528971672,
-0.49533575773239136,
-0.6016583442687988,
0.7118375301361084,
-0.46044811606407166,
0.04483460634946823,
0.03977952152490616,
-0.41550689935684204,
0.34396058320999146,
0.2615668773651123,
-0.032780714333057404,
0.5551865100860596,
0.10521013289690018,
-0.579059898853302,
-0.09038028120994568,
-0.8148962259292603,
-0.561860203742981,
1.4196733236312866,
0.4597732424736023,
0.5611884593963623,
0.08473867923021317,
0.5219706892967224,
-0.1372281014919281,
0.6849012970924377,
-0.587134599685669,
0.22276736795902252,
-0.6993692517280579,
-0.5716733336448669,
0.13668911159038544,
-0.49679434299468994,
-1.2937461137771606,
0.2619018256664276,
-0.2746489644050598,
-0.1270831823348999,
-0.36635130643844604,
0.09403975307941437,
-0.18701188266277313,
0.32502371072769165,
-0.6101325750350952,
1.041488766670227,
-0.46312493085861206,
-0.19074812531471252,
-0.16670095920562744,
-0.7590199708938599,
0.20201876759529114,
-0.3861810863018036,
0.5237306356430054,
-0.03485661372542381,
-0.196649968624115,
0.4353157877922058,
-0.3385218679904938,
0.6187028288841248,
0.049353037029504776,
-0.0923236757516861,
-0.13821962475776672,
-0.28908559679985046,
0.03797435015439987,
-0.07841672748327255,
-0.018415527418255806,
0.45596039295196533,
0.34284523129463196,
-0.4134107232093811,
-0.1815931797027588,
0.601067066192627,
-0.7694243788719177,
-0.09438478946685791,
-0.449178010225296,
-0.4161875247955322,
-0.36711978912353516,
0.48709172010421753,
0.2882094979286194,
0.498713880777359,
-0.5236459970474243,
0.17159150540828705,
0.6169881820678711,
-0.7233709096908569,
0.10779914259910583,
0.7268174886703491,
-0.5063721537590027,
-0.6748014092445374,
0.8684268593788147,
-0.0374857634305954,
0.20840708911418915,
0.5380064249038696,
0.11642378568649292,
-0.3696707487106323,
-0.887538731098175,
-0.8693528771400452,
0.5520455241203308,
-0.5406199097633362,
-0.06353476643562317,
-0.7022145986557007,
-0.06335929036140442,
-0.3447708785533905,
0.05783019959926605,
-0.40690848231315613,
-0.11286115646362305,
-0.11521250754594803,
0.03939097002148628,
0.21644359827041626,
0.8933043479919434,
0.23984113335609436,
0.12752628326416016,
-1.1812199354171753,
0.5185233950614929,
-0.3416283428668976,
0.6211603283882141,
-0.49296700954437256,
-0.17418725788593292,
-0.5234167575836182,
-0.08689607679843903,
-0.22261758148670197,
-0.7424564957618713,
0.5194111466407776,
-0.032041799277067184,
0.6088802814483643,
0.3053635358810425,
-0.29716095328330994,
0.38776716589927673,
-1.0321749448776245,
0.5334383249282837,
0.5038172006607056,
-0.5174015760421753,
0.3251909613609314,
-0.25491270422935486,
0.5073133111000061,
0.4829782247543335,
0.49554213881492615,
-0.620817244052887,
-0.28105080127716064,
-0.4282190799713135,
-0.6057876348495483,
0.48439374566078186,
-0.005008247215300798,
-0.0008770402637310326,
-0.15573322772979736,
0.08973505347967148,
0.3661821782588959,
0.43216386437416077,
-0.6565566062927246,
-0.18715716898441315,
-0.006490565370768309,
-0.8425218462944031,
-0.1546243578195572,
-0.08768608421087265,
-0.2995215058326721,
-0.086601622402668,
0.3796828091144562,
-0.31122490763664246,
0.5483826994895935,
0.05052744969725609,
-0.14664813876152039,
0.07401472330093384,
0.26411810517311096,
0.8824601769447327,
0.6374109983444214,
0.051574792712926865,
0.13398469984531403,
0.3588499128818512,
-0.7459718585014343,
0.03576943650841713,
0.22663632035255432,
0.19298504292964935,
0.19486865401268005,
0.3358125686645508,
0.7122499346733093,
0.0732438936829567,
-0.9230992794036865,
0.5290194153785706,
-0.11855695396661758,
-0.3411477208137512,
-0.16284559667110443,
-0.41822153329849243,
0.2926599979400635,
-0.03069165162742138,
-0.05324816331267357,
0.06855131685733795,
-0.022653572261333466,
-0.5598834156990051,
0.18758830428123474,
0.294580340385437,
-0.30100083351135254,
-0.4795898199081421,
0.8751437067985535,
0.4283140003681183,
-0.06429778039455414,
0.29015669226646423,
0.16914138197898865,
-0.2991316020488739,
0.2654574513435364,
0.6163856983184814,
0.5794826149940491,
-0.5112706422805786,
-0.2346024066209793,
0.25614699721336365,
0.3155445456504822,
-0.12234791368246078,
0.5280718803405762,
0.46244877576828003,
-0.6220956444740295,
-0.6317348480224609,
-0.41186219453811646,
-0.4718998968601227,
0.04214207082986832,
-0.19646939635276794,
0.47350266575813293,
-0.28660714626312256,
-0.30327704548835754,
0.04940325394272804,
-0.3197396397590637,
-0.625604510307312,
0.38595977425575256,
0.039203766733407974,
0.7857140898704529,
-0.19189196825027466,
1.294731616973877,
0.9136214852333069,
-0.42730608582496643,
-0.36484238505363464,
-0.2515929937362671,
-0.141065314412117,
-1.0274732112884521,
0.5103473663330078,
0.0055228727869689465,
-0.07271823287010193,
-0.048254553228616714,
-0.3206617832183838,
-0.4579334259033203,
0.9055690169334412,
0.6211366653442383,
-0.43920040130615234,
-0.24585650861263275,
0.45467984676361084,
0.704289972782135,
-0.5309396386146545,
0.2966160476207733,
0.22098907828330994,
0.3616536557674408,
-0.0006139901815913618,
-1.2188621759414673,
-0.07784155756235123,
-0.30969658493995667,
-0.3455195426940918,
0.33200502395629883,
-0.5487041473388672,
0.6046841740608215,
-0.307891309261322,
0.044008150696754456,
0.08306749165058136,
0.32902956008911133,
0.2054782509803772,
0.36905431747436523,
0.013977518305182457,
0.46009114384651184,
0.7159132361412048,
-0.11043599992990494,
1.2614564895629883,
-0.7399775981903076,
0.10401754081249237,
0.8563330173492432,
-0.5056727528572083,
0.9399906992912292,
0.30681687593460083,
-0.12418100237846375,
0.2114163637161255,
0.516331672668457,
0.14500732719898224,
0.34396228194236755,
0.01754157990217209,
-0.4371253252029419,
0.10857418924570084,
0.0719769075512886,
-0.5711419582366943,
0.21313035488128662,
0.5050693154335022,
-0.6341060400009155,
0.06223011016845703,
0.1986967921257019,
0.1915857344865799,
-0.061624251306056976,
-0.1534004658460617,
0.8709973096847534,
0.2910214960575104,
-0.4785020053386688,
0.6344425082206726,
0.32944250106811523,
0.4914357662200928,
-0.809709906578064,
0.07511575520038605,
-0.0009528141235932708,
0.3178415596485138,
-0.1612267941236496,
-0.5676472783088684,
0.36467599868774414,
0.2593114376068115,
-0.13478773832321167,
-0.28557589650154114,
0.5929415822029114,
-0.6228641867637634,
-0.5890257358551025,
0.287174791097641,
0.688831627368927,
0.34113070368766785,
0.21906602382659912,
-0.5067604184150696,
0.14754894375801086,
-0.15940900146961212,
0.07204887270927429,
0.41520971059799194,
0.6122072339057922,
0.020383043214678764,
0.7014588117599487,
0.7825546860694885,
0.39477288722991943,
-0.0481785349547863,
0.21574871242046356,
0.7018144130706787,
-0.6655840277671814,
-0.36594489216804504,
-0.9318796992301941,
0.33602574467658997,
0.07185834646224976,
-0.2731224000453949,
0.4417988955974579,
0.8019157648086548,
0.5871601104736328,
-0.14298562705516815,
0.9982913136482239,
0.37366458773612976,
0.9202020168304443,
-0.5671781897544861,
0.9467512369155884,
-0.7530242800712585,
0.1323765367269516,
0.05963125452399254,
-0.5467930436134338,
-0.7350676655769348,
0.4556959569454193,
0.006924137007445097,
0.09080621600151062,
1.1640191078186035,
0.3646047115325928,
-0.005515481345355511,
-0.17795298993587494,
0.5969873070716858,
0.2959917485713959,
0.14964915812015533,
0.6898576021194458,
0.5495908856391907,
-0.22977496683597565,
0.49473991990089417,
0.2771780490875244,
-0.09768503159284592,
-0.15646059811115265,
-0.7265200614929199,
-0.968226432800293,
-0.40410253405570984,
-0.087320975959301,
-0.27687323093414307,
0.21692094206809998,
1.1650160551071167,
0.6382798552513123,
-0.7391777038574219,
-0.2884838879108429,
0.3805522918701172,
-0.17331130802631378,
-0.03263534978032112,
0.016634875908493996,
0.18769997358322144,
-0.20317433774471283,
-0.8678901791572571,
0.5944868326187134,
0.6631886959075928,
0.04172725975513458,
-0.3050813376903534,
-0.22512435913085938,
-0.06287834793329239,
0.03788701072335243,
0.7314373254776001,
0.07757308334112167,
-0.5687888264656067,
-0.048087239265441895,
0.17479120194911957,
-0.45199236273765564,
0.627325177192688,
0.8326451182365417,
-0.6295543909072876,
0.5207639932632446,
0.15411736071109772,
0.8939589858055115,
0.44934043288230896,
-0.30711376667022705,
0.8236551880836487,
-0.47019460797309875,
-0.05686088651418686,
0.24005967378616333,
0.4547465741634369,
0.4592433273792267,
0.020880065858364105,
0.6072038412094116,
0.33163899183273315,
-0.46611303091049194,
-0.7411026358604431,
-0.011804965324699879,
-0.7701168656349182,
-0.3566531538963318,
0.9551641941070557,
-0.11495862156152725,
-0.08803099393844604,
-0.11608029156923294,
-0.36565354466438293,
0.40654733777046204,
-0.08150909096002579,
0.5680628418922424,
0.6922797560691833,
-0.01585325039923191,
-0.13167530298233032,
-1.084722638130188,
0.37861084938049316,
0.3166497051715851,
-1.3227218389511108,
-0.35482046008110046,
0.36117592453956604,
0.3991597294807434,
-0.07008013129234314,
0.9731749296188354,
-0.4952377676963806,
0.22534486651420593,
-0.31258875131607056,
0.36283549666404724,
-0.012630990706384182,
-0.34807735681533813,
-0.25696292519569397,
0.3233962953090668,
0.2555173635482788,
-0.22409357130527496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07611v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07611v2
|
NoticIA: A Clickbait Article Summarization Dataset in Spanish
| 2024-04-11T09:59:01 | 2024-05-31T15:19:18 |
Iker García-Ferrero, Begoña Altuna
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present NoticIA, a dataset consisting of 850 Spanish news articles
featuring prominent clickbait headlines, each paired with high-quality,
single-sentence generative summarizations written by humans. This task demands
advanced text understanding and summarization abilities, challenging the
models' capacity to infer and connect diverse pieces of information to meet the
user's informational needs generated by the clickbait headline. We evaluate the
Spanish text comprehension capabilities of a wide range of state-of-the-art
large language models. Additionally, we use the dataset to train
ClickbaitFighter, a task-specific model that achieves near-human performance in
this task.
|
[
-0.06799722462892532,
-0.3863345682621002,
0.2858346700668335,
0.7897759675979614,
-0.24101869761943817,
0.20724555850028992,
0.010779707692563534,
-0.40796780586242676,
0.3847532272338867,
0.5997113585472107,
-0.5421090126037598,
-0.6645145416259766,
-0.5884796977043152,
0.4883059561252594,
-0.7629535794258118,
1.446946620941162,
0.21248134970664978,
-0.017113350331783295,
-0.37863004207611084,
0.029198074713349342,
-0.12059774249792099,
0.15602467954158783,
-0.5508752465248108,
-0.07705771923065186,
0.5919175744056702,
0.4237467050552368,
0.6617844104766846,
0.44162970781326294,
0.3342999815940857,
0.17658454179763794,
0.032779350876808167,
0.04274996370077133,
-0.8217443823814392,
-0.3561543822288513,
-0.5104278922080994,
-0.5297399163246155,
-0.4828892946243286,
-0.12316178530454636,
0.40698882937431335,
1.003645420074463,
0.033704131841659546,
0.27714934945106506,
-0.13985131680965424,
0.9103310108184814,
-0.33829110860824585,
0.11747939884662628,
-0.5191073417663574,
-0.23175449669361115,
-0.09083080291748047,
-0.29383787512779236,
-0.4274367392063141,
-0.6925638914108276,
0.2689473330974579,
-0.6382092833518982,
0.5297263264656067,
0.2995459735393524,
0.8692672252655029,
0.8600578308105469,
-0.6981892585754395,
-0.3846134841442108,
-0.3053990602493286,
0.5534064769744873,
-0.3631015717983246,
0.3858810067176819,
0.6123215556144714,
-0.04084985330700874,
-0.12347497045993805,
-0.34068384766578674,
-0.1349911242723465,
-0.3443238139152527,
-0.045711662620306015,
0.26500239968299866,
-0.4484376609325409,
-0.11674882471561432,
0.05724663287401199,
0.2764381766319275,
-0.8661538362503052,
-0.021621495485305786,
-0.8233433365821838,
-0.012318962253630161,
0.7143216729164124,
0.10135986655950546,
0.3711574375629425,
-0.27413299679756165,
-0.29310664534568787,
0.13433624804019928,
-0.6793134808540344,
-0.13567492365837097,
0.8018247485160828,
0.07104571908712387,
-0.23822753131389618,
0.46258270740509033,
-0.4835174083709717,
0.7786703705787659,
0.08151212334632874,
-0.3205795884132385,
0.369056761264801,
-0.1481662392616272,
-0.47031915187835693,
0.107988640666008,
0.7663821578025818,
0.5726969838142395,
0.31911414861679077,
-0.672051727771759,
0.10086459666490555,
-0.09212565422058105,
0.4629519581794739,
-0.5501940250396729,
-0.1911969780921936,
0.6803115606307983,
-0.49734261631965637,
-0.8163832426071167,
0.2697139084339142,
-0.9616055488586426,
-0.3478195071220398,
0.017053518444299698,
0.4155617952346802,
-0.23192793130874634,
-0.20243680477142334,
0.5029410123825073,
-0.471292108297348,
-0.17798225581645966,
0.08818919211626053,
-0.8186818361282349,
0.16895413398742676,
0.11855088174343109,
0.6332715153694153,
-0.3910718262195587,
-0.6210663914680481,
-0.24854610860347748,
0.16026854515075684,
-0.38100963830947876,
1.0026963949203491,
-0.26602262258529663,
-0.2483881115913391,
-0.26426976919174194,
0.12560395896434784,
-0.558396577835083,
-0.4147005081176758,
0.6631668210029602,
-0.7737264037132263,
0.3061772286891937,
-0.3520806133747101,
-0.17908449470996857,
-0.642716646194458,
0.10460717976093292,
-1.125173807144165,
0.8892501592636108,
0.10762375593185425,
-0.972426176071167,
0.31517139077186584,
-0.8199187517166138,
-0.8860222697257996,
-0.23918896913528442,
0.2792401909828186,
-0.11810078471899033,
0.2721114754676819,
0.285988986492157,
0.3609284460544586,
-0.2893047630786896,
0.4829902946949005,
0.26939499378204346,
-0.22209949791431427,
0.2878413796424866,
-0.3180384635925293,
0.7500595450401306,
-0.014934270642697811,
-0.3014122545719147,
0.035490911453962326,
-0.7571533918380737,
-0.5842772722244263,
0.07598353177309036,
-0.6836686730384827,
-0.23116393387317657,
-0.1661345511674881,
0.282036691904068,
0.21896207332611084,
0.5941522717475891,
-0.3656071424484253,
-0.03211617469787598,
-0.47280392050743103,
0.17797686159610748,
0.1368843913078308,
0.07543456554412842,
0.3886373043060303,
-0.5588611364364624,
0.6927889585494995,
-0.21079808473587036,
0.1317257285118103,
-0.40905338525772095,
-0.21998478472232819,
-0.5636433959007263,
0.11991283297538757,
0.48678115010261536,
0.7553515434265137,
-1.0664845705032349,
0.03241957724094391,
-0.4855477511882782,
-0.4667356312274933,
-0.2758435606956482,
0.1660454422235489,
0.5038250088691711,
0.6975693702697754,
0.36547988653182983,
0.25049465894699097,
-0.626959502696991,
-0.7269412875175476,
-0.36675772070884705,
0.03845231607556343,
-0.07833608239889145,
0.03227141499519348,
0.9597892761230469,
0.3289532959461212,
0.8280956745147705,
-0.40480175614356995,
-0.6811202764511108,
-0.6658783555030823,
0.46442490816116333,
0.44376280903816223,
-0.07892508804798126,
0.7583458423614502,
-1.1068670749664307,
-0.3477129340171814,
-0.23671971261501312,
-0.9961742758750916,
-0.25634345412254333,
-0.26401305198669434,
0.2873607277870178,
0.07125093787908554,
0.6335670948028564,
-0.1623820662498474,
0.29080504179000854,
0.8238492012023926,
-0.5082554221153259,
0.5100416541099548,
-0.45946168899536133,
0.4926118552684784,
-1.0410652160644531,
0.4356767237186432,
0.2422603964805603,
-0.23669034242630005,
-0.614454984664917,
-0.1961526870727539,
0.21756099164485931,
0.12707488238811493,
-0.789849042892456,
0.3434727191925049,
-0.40306422114372253,
-0.18165534734725952,
-0.46715494990348816,
-0.03692273050546646,
0.15354321897029877,
0.38342389464378357,
0.3821524977684021,
1.025362253189087,
0.3559796214103699,
-0.6483253836631775,
0.33559486269950867,
0.49155500531196594,
-0.291928231716156,
0.6355269551277161,
-1.0566935539245605,
-0.4522131085395813,
-0.6615986227989197,
0.3629443645477295,
-1.0502712726593018,
-0.7722875475883484,
-0.1983630657196045,
-0.6319485306739807,
-0.13580453395843506,
-0.13415728509426117,
-0.5972526669502258,
-0.4164418876171112,
-0.6348883509635925,
0.2445509135723114,
0.08191454410552979,
-0.48286423087120056,
0.3612143099308014,
0.4509802460670471,
-0.14208517968654633,
-0.5914090871810913,
-0.7164713144302368,
0.38134920597076416,
-0.3366987705230713,
-0.47589683532714844,
0.37581363320350647,
0.11840423941612244,
-0.04526667669415474,
0.1355191320180893,
0.0432489737868309,
-0.10074391216039658,
0.06828507781028748,
0.1515258252620697,
0.08228268474340439,
-0.016033150255680084,
0.20152759552001953,
0.3122197687625885,
-0.1554654836654663,
0.06441228091716766,
-0.2127101570367813,
0.498156875371933,
0.35377877950668335,
-0.027109263464808464,
-0.558135449886322,
0.2494661957025528,
0.7408920526504517,
-0.3472353518009186,
0.9059082269668579,
0.17477798461914062,
-0.2173505276441574,
-0.03859719634056091,
-0.4559653103351593,
0.10308648645877838,
-0.3481198847293854,
0.3706028461456299,
-0.2152070552110672,
-0.4388086497783661,
0.49167799949645996,
0.09774426370859146,
0.12067660689353943,
0.5980252623558044,
0.4176473319530487,
-0.20592905580997467,
0.8464592695236206,
0.6881767511367798,
-0.3091214895248413,
0.18824535608291626,
-0.36944591999053955,
-0.166480153799057,
-0.47721320390701294,
-0.54788738489151,
-0.4173562228679657,
-0.4768224060535431,
-0.10103767365217209,
-0.25430378317832947,
0.41214364767074585,
-0.35907334089279175,
0.31783291697502136,
0.47564634680747986,
-0.021214673295617104,
0.8893525004386902,
0.539115846157074,
0.12362740933895111,
0.7588196992874146,
-0.1674196422100067,
0.4982880651950836,
0.11687055975198746,
-0.6214497685432434,
-0.4682886302471161,
1.175767421722412,
0.16340909898281097,
0.9973645806312561,
0.22782014310359955,
0.3201465606689453,
0.6250196695327759,
-0.11846379935741425,
-0.6519850492477417,
0.17828859388828278,
-0.33615559339523315,
-0.6746429204940796,
-0.16677959263324738,
-0.2940172553062439,
-1.1720504760742188,
0.323812872171402,
-0.13154983520507812,
-0.6172313690185547,
0.15466101467609406,
0.020229093730449677,
-0.4735957086086273,
0.2139492928981781,
-0.5947211980819702,
0.8658368587493896,
-0.16908776760101318,
0.04787914454936981,
-0.20479002594947815,
-0.5902409553527832,
0.32504943013191223,
-0.02272816002368927,
0.2827257215976715,
-0.02408575639128685,
-0.5922818779945374,
1.0501999855041504,
0.010462765581905842,
0.8305473327636719,
0.25762084126472473,
0.02960232086479664,
-0.050214897841215134,
0.036581408232450485,
0.2894810438156128,
-0.0203224066644907,
-0.09655699878931046,
-0.02223655954003334,
-0.15114116668701172,
-0.5851261019706726,
-0.11745316535234451,
0.46746736764907837,
-0.5485430359840393,
-0.013744980096817017,
-0.4000922739505768,
-0.674765408039093,
-0.12418904155492783,
0.236747145652771,
0.5840649604797363,
0.44102418422698975,
-0.5125908255577087,
0.15224283933639526,
0.8854361176490784,
-0.10466468334197998,
0.6513229608535767,
0.6559479236602783,
0.02653534524142742,
-0.37847086787223816,
1.0858371257781982,
0.07776334136724472,
-0.12328799068927765,
0.4751514494419098,
-0.23727653920650482,
-0.5900103449821472,
-0.8798701167106628,
-0.6441117525100708,
0.6063246130943298,
-0.2978737950325012,
-0.10430990904569626,
-0.9945991039276123,
0.1174100786447525,
-0.2789548933506012,
-0.15438126027584076,
-0.15134723484516144,
-0.290667325258255,
-0.5322173833847046,
-0.3794536292552948,
0.2674144208431244,
1.1219255924224854,
0.12324851006269455,
0.5383375287055969,
-0.7588236331939697,
0.622989296913147,
-0.03295021504163742,
0.19941960275173187,
-0.056882716715335846,
-0.5572159886360168,
-0.3195522725582123,
-0.3325175344944,
-0.133645698428154,
-1.3697843551635742,
0.47635123133659363,
0.07551632076501846,
0.45484352111816406,
0.6042700409889221,
0.1373874843120575,
0.18524469435214996,
-0.06922092288732529,
0.6601993441581726,
-0.10936202853918076,
-0.7383592128753662,
0.637711763381958,
-0.948215901851654,
0.3034261465072632,
0.956388533115387,
0.7872216105461121,
-0.276566743850708,
-0.48572254180908203,
-0.7021002769470215,
-0.7496200203895569,
0.8637810349464417,
0.35388606786727905,
0.17194433510303497,
-0.020239580422639847,
-0.060576677322387695,
0.353849321603775,
0.700798749923706,
-0.6708317399024963,
-0.1794595718383789,
-0.05505089461803436,
-0.4299502372741699,
-0.032449014484882355,
-0.4167691767215729,
0.21647171676158905,
0.038272932171821594,
0.7907471060752869,
-0.01876886747777462,
-0.34542110562324524,
-0.016192596405744553,
-0.7609387636184692,
0.10463228821754456,
0.022581620141863823,
0.7805300354957581,
1.1228290796279907,
-0.23699864745140076,
-0.1340726912021637,
0.18079227209091187,
-0.5871154069900513,
-0.12956510484218597,
0.055880576372146606,
-0.2742317318916321,
0.19319719076156616,
0.4887169599533081,
0.6852493286132812,
0.7611138820648193,
-0.8687809109687805,
0.6442987322807312,
-0.0928778201341629,
-0.4408709704875946,
-0.17261430621147156,
-0.06179816275835037,
-0.02500126138329506,
0.17693792283535004,
0.8159729242324829,
-0.1763618290424347,
0.48325735330581665,
-0.35288915038108826,
0.13697727024555206,
-0.08128384500741959,
-0.23298440873622894,
-0.46343374252319336,
1.0909749269485474,
0.45215246081352234,
0.22878725826740265,
0.1439056396484375,
-0.18822520971298218,
-0.4244988262653351,
0.8694628477096558,
0.40725141763687134,
0.45743000507354736,
-0.03744516149163246,
0.7797529101371765,
0.43779197335243225,
0.4137113094329834,
-0.4786410927772522,
0.3802182078361511,
0.033410683274269104,
-0.378164142370224,
-0.6115606427192688,
-0.4225256145000458,
-0.46266189217567444,
0.16476409137248993,
-0.6052221655845642,
0.1632920801639557,
-0.13960382342338562,
0.18197397887706757,
0.07030100375413895,
-0.0757158100605011,
-0.34145963191986084,
0.328551322221756,
-0.2831283211708069,
1.2024496793746948,
-1.383304476737976,
0.458810031414032,
0.850298285484314,
-0.8353520631790161,
-0.11509837210178375,
0.1773795634508133,
-0.1179102286696434,
-0.607977569103241,
0.28864020109176636,
0.054820768535137177,
-0.0331035740673542,
0.2545469403266907,
-0.41129663586616516,
-0.8121177554130554,
0.9808871150016785,
0.5615994334220886,
-0.050801798701286316,
-0.5062240362167358,
0.03569032624363899,
0.4619573652744293,
-0.1040806770324707,
0.22435420751571655,
0.9392784833908081,
0.5675070285797119,
0.2997530400753021,
-1.0766892433166504,
-0.3022642135620117,
-0.09981431066989899,
-0.3688342571258545,
0.2186201810836792,
-0.8981314301490784,
0.7477896213531494,
-0.3382813632488251,
-0.0005450306343846023,
-0.07635820657014847,
0.7080504894256592,
-0.15968908369541168,
0.5073909759521484,
0.3698650598526001,
0.6009573936462402,
0.7184298038482666,
-0.05530228093266487,
1.060127854347229,
-0.05067617818713188,
0.3227359354496002,
1.1531221866607666,
0.3775215744972229,
0.5915156006813049,
0.34280070662498474,
-0.16302183270454407,
0.39041662216186523,
0.6298666000366211,
-0.058733824640512466,
0.6440128087997437,
-0.3427615463733673,
-0.03716258332133293,
-0.19000652432441711,
-0.3710382282733917,
-0.11780723184347153,
0.6795952320098877,
0.1562599539756775,
-0.512428343296051,
-0.732142984867096,
0.34919801354408264,
0.3903981149196625,
0.22994957864284515,
-0.5531090497970581,
0.9444454908370972,
-0.34350648522377014,
-0.6814633011817932,
0.18090221285820007,
0.04891062155365944,
0.6870002150535583,
-0.2208508849143982,
0.31639742851257324,
-0.22116629779338837,
-0.31149640679359436,
-0.5618204474449158,
-0.6735630631446838,
0.4580951929092407,
0.31617510318756104,
-0.4890567362308502,
-0.059039078652858734,
0.3919782042503357,
-0.3637621998786926,
-0.5860010981559753,
0.021198363974690437,
0.5998669862747192,
0.5009623169898987,
-0.4844062626361847,
-0.5046671032905579,
0.02916327491402626,
0.11117859184741974,
-0.1487787514925003,
0.0112596545368433,
0.09360280632972717,
-0.12861593067646027,
0.554979681968689,
0.6319132447242737,
0.1389363557100296,
0.021383319050073624,
0.355770468711853,
0.7496539950370789,
-0.7236992716789246,
-0.8356876373291016,
-0.835071861743927,
0.5630433559417725,
-0.2378932386636734,
-0.2880498170852661,
0.6777220964431763,
0.8994492292404175,
0.4835292100906372,
-0.26794523000717163,
0.8859411478042603,
-0.10753898322582245,
0.47333821654319763,
-0.43944594264030457,
0.8871280550956726,
-0.5837777256965637,
-0.2956850528717041,
0.03908984363079071,
-0.7242954969406128,
-0.3380350172519684,
0.3096141815185547,
-0.5150499939918518,
-0.03151670843362808,
0.7153525948524475,
0.44025781750679016,
-0.2504180669784546,
0.06633029133081436,
0.37464094161987305,
0.25130167603492737,
-0.1777881681919098,
0.6905418634414673,
0.5182979106903076,
-0.48330122232437134,
0.9054733514785767,
-0.014378177002072334,
-0.2883547842502594,
-0.5723593235015869,
-1.010612964630127,
-1.4434317350387573,
-0.6864649057388306,
-0.31793344020843506,
0.0013929936103522778,
0.025146471336483955,
0.6502590179443359,
0.5118039846420288,
-0.7616474032402039,
-0.059121936559677124,
0.01543955784291029,
0.4263221025466919,
0.10407761484384537,
-0.20788246393203735,
0.4387146532535553,
-0.2523840665817261,
-1.088830590248108,
0.537356436252594,
0.23522473871707916,
-0.0057615721598267555,
-0.2839967906475067,
0.3516820967197418,
-0.07268679141998291,
0.17590180039405823,
0.46521779894828796,
0.46053072810173035,
-0.2882092297077179,
0.23861782252788544,
0.05116674304008484,
0.06878139823675156,
-0.04957148805260658,
0.6725130081176758,
-0.9850962162017822,
0.15700605511665344,
0.6967824697494507,
0.42668846249580383,
0.41974368691444397,
0.3146074712276459,
0.3455485701560974,
-0.7704721689224243,
0.34127184748649597,
-0.06924018263816833,
0.17874890565872192,
0.3740313649177551,
-0.42115429043769836,
0.45195725560188293,
-0.10629182308912277,
-0.17635151743888855,
-0.6961719989776611,
-0.050968676805496216,
-0.9384095072746277,
-0.16245491802692413,
0.9974440336227417,
0.22688667476177216,
-0.5309020280838013,
-0.5336697101593018,
-0.3588714599609375,
-0.007649624720215797,
-0.6757375001907349,
0.9004293084144592,
0.5047725439071655,
-0.007461754605174065,
-0.14473797380924225,
-0.7216832637786865,
0.5568593144416809,
0.03849880397319794,
-1.0255308151245117,
-0.20411109924316406,
0.3845426142215729,
0.519088089466095,
-0.008558874018490314,
0.6830646395683289,
-0.05263541266322136,
0.6618170738220215,
-0.13507616519927979,
-0.22770331799983978,
-0.35573258996009827,
-0.6907075643539429,
-0.22945097088813782,
0.46308836340904236,
-0.3275906443595886,
-0.3276923894882202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07584v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07584v1
|
UltraEval: A Lightweight Platform for Flexible and Comprehensive Evaluation for LLMs
| 2024-04-11T09:17:12 | 2024-04-11T09:17:12 |
Chaoqun He, Renjie Luo, Shengding Hu, Yuanqian Zhao, Jie Zhou, Hanghao Wu, Jiajie Zhang, Xu Han, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Evaluation is pivotal for honing Large Language Models (LLMs), pinpointing
their capabilities and guiding enhancements. The rapid development of LLMs
calls for a lightweight and easy-to-use framework for swift evaluation
deployment. However, due to the various implementation details to consider,
developing a comprehensive evaluation platform is never easy. Existing
platforms are often complex and poorly modularized, hindering seamless
incorporation into researcher's workflows. This paper introduces UltraEval, a
user-friendly evaluation framework characterized by lightweight,
comprehensiveness, modularity, and efficiency. We identify and reimplement
three core components of model evaluation (models, data, and metrics). The
resulting composability allows for the free combination of different models,
tasks, prompts, and metrics within a unified evaluation workflow. Additionally,
UltraEval supports diverse models owing to a unified HTTP service and provides
sufficient inference acceleration. UltraEval is now available for researchers
publicly~\footnote{Website is at \url{https://github.com/OpenBMB/UltraEval}}.
|
[
-0.0029427718836814165,
-0.5914047360420227,
0.49173474311828613,
0.49244001507759094,
-0.23421131074428558,
0.2582198977470398,
-0.45886653661727905,
-0.2154841125011444,
-0.03588227555155754,
0.3467389941215515,
-0.23664578795433044,
-0.5433273911476135,
-0.11495228856801987,
-0.15414610505104065,
-0.6188881397247314,
0.8795166611671448,
-0.007882403209805489,
0.23391568660736084,
-0.2830420434474945,
-0.2862793505191803,
0.034475985914468765,
-0.4215977191925049,
0.005251464433968067,
-0.5689101815223694,
0.18318946659564972,
0.4322182834148407,
0.6956812143325806,
0.49125537276268005,
0.8044813871383667,
0.323491632938385,
-0.1451638787984848,
-0.11541920155286789,
-0.6052607893943787,
0.3932354748249054,
-0.3159034252166748,
-0.2107527107000351,
-0.50857013463974,
-0.29470008611679077,
0.7211504578590393,
0.945959746837616,
-0.4394682049751282,
0.6212007999420166,
0.2303977906703949,
0.6463320255279541,
-0.8324178457260132,
-0.205923393368721,
-0.5857813358306885,
-0.08951324969530106,
-0.21996460855007172,
-0.0068856398575007915,
-0.3985282778739929,
-0.26669514179229736,
0.11360934376716614,
-0.2823641300201416,
-0.13256120681762695,
0.06158124655485153,
0.25092706084251404,
-0.10201392322778702,
-0.25136974453926086,
0.12446867674589157,
-0.7057662010192871,
0.8328109979629517,
-0.6315699219703674,
0.613543689250946,
-0.2632891535758972,
0.5326893925666809,
-0.11310038715600967,
-1.0088696479797363,
-0.3239346146583557,
-0.5281347632408142,
0.357234388589859,
-0.06531980633735657,
-0.27481794357299805,
0.1091228723526001,
-0.15880897641181946,
0.42492422461509705,
-0.44201940298080444,
0.2180412858724594,
0.08376795798540115,
-0.15605108439922333,
0.23794104158878326,
0.5121166706085205,
0.2892504036426544,
-0.4067608118057251,
-0.4272085726261139,
0.3740863502025604,
-0.7233713865280151,
-0.037333350628614426,
0.03680161386728287,
0.6482123136520386,
-0.1905900239944458,
0.6435810327529907,
-0.33173736929893494,
0.3655363917350769,
-0.32846730947494507,
0.02937684953212738,
0.3212188184261322,
-0.3093802034854889,
-0.4646463692188263,
-0.35017868876457214,
0.9474530220031738,
0.1716884821653366,
-0.27502769231796265,
-0.08352915197610855,
-0.6560191512107849,
-0.1303015947341919,
0.09278853237628937,
-0.8716555833816528,
-0.17082850635051727,
0.1309152990579605,
-0.9180410504341125,
-0.4328896999359131,
-0.08890687674283981,
-0.8300487995147705,
-0.5637928247451782,
-0.14489537477493286,
0.36877691745758057,
-0.03473560884594917,
-0.23071546852588654,
0.09402285516262054,
0.2759352922439575,
-0.04014189913868904,
0.31802162528038025,
-0.8035275936126709,
0.35886189341545105,
0.6197253465652466,
0.7969411015510559,
-0.272575706243515,
-0.27359071373939514,
-0.48212459683418274,
-0.023064671084284782,
-0.2194579690694809,
0.7919481992721558,
-0.7616077065467834,
-0.5991132855415344,
0.06926155835390091,
-0.12091442197561264,
0.07018119096755981,
-0.4243195056915283,
0.9158656001091003,
-0.47861936688423157,
-0.2917950451374054,
-0.024815823882818222,
-0.42627280950546265,
0.11116036772727966,
0.04037382826209068,
-0.49610036611557007,
1.322628378868103,
0.3592495620250702,
-0.7057344317436218,
0.0994482934474945,
-0.8737866878509521,
-0.22036327421665192,
0.7059869766235352,
-0.09764087945222855,
0.012299908325076103,
0.38371941447257996,
0.09185317903757095,
0.5119994282722473,
-0.5861670970916748,
0.2818843424320221,
-0.5689896941184998,
-0.5557413697242737,
0.12070775032043457,
-0.42381376028060913,
0.7256426811218262,
0.37982481718063354,
-0.5407547950744629,
0.47473451495170593,
-0.8246573209762573,
0.11652472615242004,
0.02429061010479927,
-0.5637253522872925,
-0.31277036666870117,
-0.04814855381846428,
0.6164659857749939,
-0.1998540461063385,
0.3823595941066742,
-0.5476102828979492,
0.15189693868160248,
-0.14584332704544067,
0.20849384367465973,
0.7708700299263,
-0.2789950966835022,
0.23567010462284088,
0.1490505188703537,
0.6575828194618225,
-0.5109392404556274,
0.4682568609714508,
0.013907955959439278,
0.0418388694524765,
-0.7689118981361389,
-0.5269713401794434,
0.5525183081626892,
0.5223552584648132,
-0.47700265049934387,
0.5234046578407288,
-0.4052685797214508,
-0.7513127326965332,
-0.7558596134185791,
0.5025561451911926,
0.5569945573806763,
0.5074602961540222,
0.08972568809986115,
0.006548999343067408,
-0.7694278955459595,
-0.7902562022209167,
-0.0826852023601532,
-0.2935972213745117,
-0.2629793584346771,
0.16642571985721588,
0.6417478322982788,
-0.6107699871063232,
0.6550831198692322,
-0.09066975116729736,
0.06505464017391205,
-0.6793547868728638,
0.10195475071668625,
0.14710836112499237,
0.44516921043395996,
0.33219054341316223,
-0.48165076971054077,
-0.2589242160320282,
0.0710424929857254,
-0.8175336122512817,
-0.255357027053833,
0.21095511317253113,
-0.020487342029809952,
-0.08592317253351212,
0.22733338177204132,
-0.3342110812664032,
0.023250838741660118,
0.43597981333732605,
-0.11413192749023438,
0.7318228483200073,
-0.1448211669921875,
0.08445392549037933,
-0.8635444045066833,
0.31655260920524597,
-0.20514938235282898,
-0.35413500666618347,
-0.3690750300884247,
0.47704941034317017,
0.10728351771831512,
-0.11539684981107712,
-0.6062914133071899,
0.5737357139587402,
-0.44583770632743835,
-0.26580896973609924,
-0.03152875974774361,
0.35346072912216187,
-0.050939373672008514,
-0.2794266641139984,
-0.19905641674995422,
0.7934705018997192,
0.7312606573104858,
-0.2915206253528595,
0.5567511916160583,
0.16934572160243988,
-0.6933072209358215,
0.5429078936576843,
-0.8181822299957275,
0.13237066566944122,
0.31376659870147705,
0.1632390320301056,
-0.7945765852928162,
-0.10917031019926071,
-0.2904365360736847,
-0.2624568045139313,
-0.0688280388712883,
-0.16204716265201569,
-0.5125081539154053,
-0.31629225611686707,
-0.6777718663215637,
0.2269904762506485,
0.48746591806411743,
-0.8103405237197876,
0.5325191617012024,
0.45834648609161377,
-0.15297788381576538,
-0.5962488055229187,
-0.6489360332489014,
0.28160426020622253,
-0.017246106639504433,
-0.5286983847618103,
-0.06683288514614105,
-0.19855742156505585,
-0.370552659034729,
-0.026370299980044365,
-0.08429824560880661,
0.11361391842365265,
0.24762912094593048,
0.2399364560842514,
0.6323373317718506,
-0.3774581849575043,
0.0084485849365592,
-0.24254608154296875,
-0.07960467040538788,
-0.26822593808174133,
-0.23583123087882996,
0.3011001646518707,
-0.6467178463935852,
-0.5222703814506531,
-0.47833681106567383,
0.1350277215242386,
0.7460355758666992,
-0.12738460302352905,
0.24506331980228424,
0.3618743419647217,
-0.29298365116119385,
-0.30676114559173584,
-0.7100750207901001,
0.22044488787651062,
-0.4837723970413208,
0.42831429839134216,
-0.42852312326431274,
-0.9855506420135498,
0.566777765750885,
-0.3195692300796509,
0.1510981172323227,
0.39661872386932373,
0.8170220851898193,
-0.07974950224161148,
1.0930776596069336,
0.8106560111045837,
-0.010399107821285725,
0.25428977608680725,
-0.2912382185459137,
0.0618085078895092,
-1.2877001762390137,
-0.586344838142395,
-0.8602985739707947,
-0.058421142399311066,
-0.2530558407306671,
-0.461768239736557,
0.23542281985282898,
0.23348577320575714,
-0.06534227728843689,
0.12045197933912277,
-0.5311466455459595,
0.5224364995956421,
-0.009328927844762802,
-0.3699001967906952,
0.44447633624076843,
-0.15944063663482666,
-0.5894740223884583,
-0.10565454512834549,
-0.4907567501068115,
-1.023451805114746,
1.3458646535873413,
0.4109160006046295,
1.2737821340560913,
-0.0021750524174422026,
0.6052760481834412,
0.3795988857746124,
0.49190235137939453,
-0.7400128841400146,
0.7147374749183655,
-0.1858794093132019,
-0.5211579203605652,
-0.16181398928165436,
-0.5322931408882141,
-0.70662522315979,
0.46310293674468994,
-0.308476984500885,
-0.9663488268852234,
0.052139706909656525,
-0.1550583392381668,
-0.5507887005805969,
0.3410152196884155,
-0.5290294289588928,
0.7182925939559937,
-0.5318365097045898,
-0.33602678775787354,
-0.18492020666599274,
-0.487686425447464,
0.4100862145423889,
-0.046156421303749084,
0.35356083512306213,
-0.1449708342552185,
-0.26575982570648193,
0.888907253742218,
-0.329289972782135,
0.49648353457450867,
-0.19480116665363312,
0.2677810788154602,
0.056531067937612534,
0.38502269983291626,
0.15231531858444214,
0.34070149064064026,
-0.41481658816337585,
-0.186680868268013,
0.10733877867460251,
-0.3125975728034973,
-0.6690382361412048,
1.1046762466430664,
-0.5973804593086243,
-0.14295656979084015,
-0.12101449072360992,
-0.5942720174789429,
-0.34436967968940735,
0.3047531843185425,
-0.2431996762752533,
0.5929602980613708,
-0.5975092649459839,
0.5249265432357788,
0.6767048835754395,
0.034268155694007874,
0.5581548810005188,
0.8043286204338074,
-0.6699022054672241,
-0.37416237592697144,
0.7299444079399109,
-0.3877027630805969,
0.037614159286022186,
0.23145441710948944,
0.3548789620399475,
-0.5765528082847595,
-0.9503408074378967,
-0.5605854988098145,
-0.16880002617835999,
-0.7969930171966553,
-0.13681046664714813,
-0.5319076180458069,
0.18578195571899414,
-0.2768252193927765,
-0.3093342185020447,
-0.6297264695167542,
-0.6619852185249329,
-0.16157574951648712,
-0.25103211402893066,
-0.028756679967045784,
0.9644829630851746,
-0.06877579540014267,
0.3512185215950012,
-0.8822072744369507,
0.2907843589782715,
0.24140582978725433,
0.5715362429618835,
0.07559659332036972,
-0.5877590775489807,
-0.17011336982250214,
-0.21031197905540466,
-0.11913566291332245,
-0.38301387429237366,
-0.059411585330963135,
0.21344654262065887,
0.8172587752342224,
0.5534398555755615,
-0.05601430684328079,
0.6854504346847534,
-0.2765932083129883,
0.8844296336174011,
0.24989917874336243,
-1.0785858631134033,
0.37440821528434753,
-0.29177936911582947,
0.009946456179022789,
1.1979702711105347,
0.24736954271793365,
-0.32086890935897827,
-0.05698780715465546,
-0.3915971517562866,
-0.9243226647377014,
0.20188947021961212,
-0.0874728113412857,
0.3554202616214752,
0.23097321391105652,
0.256264865398407,
0.17845191061496735,
0.21959452331066132,
-0.7359371185302734,
-0.010408297181129456,
-0.026692118495702744,
-0.03828681632876396,
0.157697856426239,
-0.5283028483390808,
-0.2942240536212921,
-0.45299333333969116,
0.5984693765640259,
-0.12329013645648956,
-0.024408765137195587,
0.010592948645353317,
-0.42778730392456055,
-0.002540699439123273,
0.5100785493850708,
0.048034410923719406,
0.9621466994285583,
-0.47697269916534424,
0.13463576138019562,
0.15138281881809235,
-0.20979706943035126,
0.1772228330373764,
0.1762351393699646,
-0.20218193531036377,
-0.03219522535800934,
0.669007420539856,
0.6363557577133179,
0.5577728152275085,
-0.9404653906822205,
0.6568118333816528,
-0.08026794344186783,
0.09646399319171906,
0.20247694849967957,
-0.294305682182312,
0.1785302758216858,
0.2486957162618637,
0.4249853491783142,
-0.17582394182682037,
0.5273899435997009,
-0.6983715891838074,
0.18766774237155914,
0.4798058569431305,
-0.6275628209114075,
-0.3096882104873657,
0.559088945388794,
0.641298234462738,
-0.16654248535633087,
0.4916718006134033,
-0.1276104748249054,
-0.49165743589401245,
0.015672070905566216,
0.6063120365142822,
1.137086272239685,
-0.4066167175769806,
0.3406156897544861,
-0.2522490918636322,
0.35193464159965515,
0.010883632116019726,
0.5837254524230957,
-0.037585433572530746,
-0.17053037881851196,
-0.32883694767951965,
-1.121297001838684,
-0.546830415725708,
-0.13350193202495575,
-0.48824283480644226,
0.09708518534898758,
-0.36286818981170654,
0.09330533444881439,
-0.120306096971035,
-0.04141564667224884,
-0.26318109035491943,
0.06178494542837143,
0.022303570061922073,
1.214125633239746,
-0.7292478680610657,
0.6641948223114014,
0.93296879529953,
-0.30850449204444885,
-0.6806801557540894,
-0.25247979164123535,
0.17673121392726898,
-0.7244880199432373,
0.5130906701087952,
0.04591256380081177,
-0.49452826380729675,
-0.3629724979400635,
-0.3477737009525299,
-0.40258485078811646,
0.9358411431312561,
0.6124938130378723,
-0.556640625,
0.17366687953472137,
0.07270912081003189,
0.6677815318107605,
-0.7166072130203247,
0.8445023894309998,
0.6220797300338745,
0.5059401392936707,
0.1716253012418747,
-1.0214428901672363,
0.12881124019622803,
-0.2833605706691742,
0.3075522482395172,
-0.001996059203520417,
-0.570046067237854,
0.5088860988616943,
-0.25939005613327026,
0.048095837235450745,
0.29531773924827576,
0.47662267088890076,
0.2516848146915436,
0.03860185667872429,
0.3893299698829651,
0.45985010266304016,
0.8490321040153503,
0.13706021010875702,
1.0706005096435547,
-0.25823235511779785,
0.4995085597038269,
1.0003453493118286,
-0.6052945852279663,
1.0903676748275757,
0.349701851606369,
-0.25132042169570923,
0.5839732885360718,
0.4588891565799713,
-0.0407944954931736,
0.22760000824928284,
0.2970917820930481,
-0.3301692008972168,
-0.38096368312835693,
-0.3938353359699249,
-0.23437511920928955,
0.4608575105667114,
0.07941557466983795,
-0.022635111585259438,
-0.4509390890598297,
-0.11248134821653366,
-0.08316092938184738,
0.14959608018398285,
-0.2916271686553955,
0.3715181350708008,
0.08032332360744476,
-0.04122035950422287,
0.608361542224884,
0.10606789588928223,
0.7276446223258972,
-0.780029833316803,
0.14812497794628143,
-0.23904602229595184,
0.25756850838661194,
-0.5700575709342957,
-0.652453601360321,
0.10892408341169357,
0.21686498820781708,
0.14464041590690613,
-0.12056221812963486,
0.7206965684890747,
0.09854206442832947,
-0.680378794670105,
0.6945963501930237,
0.5969774127006531,
0.23623622953891754,
0.11573565006256104,
-0.9039998650550842,
0.4379989802837372,
-0.08944068849086761,
-0.6386616826057434,
0.41153258085250854,
0.14901655912399292,
-0.17039422690868378,
1.0302674770355225,
0.8185549378395081,
0.2321627289056778,
-0.09510725736618042,
0.5258597135543823,
0.985820472240448,
-0.5587291717529297,
-0.11161714047193527,
-0.8375818133354187,
0.561441957950592,
0.13040633499622345,
-0.24316200613975525,
0.7718721628189087,
1.0067378282546997,
0.18148918449878693,
0.2319403886795044,
0.8886723518371582,
-0.15141098201274872,
0.5143683552742004,
-0.23644229769706726,
0.78619384765625,
-0.6017245650291443,
0.5867918133735657,
-0.5371807813644409,
-1.133005976676941,
-0.4371868371963501,
0.23714853823184967,
0.15149283409118652,
-0.022808915004134178,
0.7500531077384949,
0.5991915464401245,
-0.26924124360084534,
0.02081415057182312,
0.3504185378551483,
0.16303464770317078,
0.3167394697666168,
0.3144165873527527,
1.0392531156539917,
0.027656590566039085,
0.8017820119857788,
-0.1793351173400879,
-0.6630477905273438,
-0.2917633652687073,
-1.0132136344909668,
-0.8096661567687988,
-0.21944209933280945,
-0.04449116811156273,
0.006360391154885292,
0.24402345716953278,
1.0243582725524902,
0.8410311341285706,
-0.7118076086044312,
-0.7383071184158325,
0.30894866585731506,
0.11428190022706985,
0.0749567449092865,
-0.2099284529685974,
0.3160350024700165,
-0.2779649496078491,
-0.4733617901802063,
0.9226223826408386,
0.6191039085388184,
-0.26928335428237915,
-0.5587694048881531,
-0.016652662307024002,
-0.11861689388751984,
0.1628747135400772,
0.5476932525634766,
0.06678979098796844,
-0.5559107661247253,
0.014063273556530476,
-0.11050417274236679,
-0.056016553193330765,
-0.1355682611465454,
0.8826233148574829,
-0.7152541279792786,
0.624415934085846,
0.5350703597068787,
0.7992246150970459,
0.26672059297561646,
-0.09015154093503952,
0.45626363158226013,
-0.25359252095222473,
0.033950041979551315,
0.3188749849796295,
0.5216186046600342,
0.656928300857544,
-0.12531718611717224,
0.5618281960487366,
0.07888492941856384,
-0.6711229085922241,
-1.3291219472885132,
-0.011023721657693386,
-0.9279559850692749,
-0.04382048174738884,
0.8977351188659668,
-0.3475315570831299,
-0.047858089208602905,
-0.08663232624530792,
0.04426738619804382,
-0.14828531444072723,
-0.4333788752555847,
0.46662041544914246,
0.4954962134361267,
-0.36965641379356384,
0.06941856443881989,
-0.7328250408172607,
0.08246789872646332,
0.5609122514724731,
-0.8462542295455933,
0.36939603090286255,
0.47478342056274414,
0.4494771361351013,
0.04266916587948799,
0.5769728422164917,
-0.36366382241249084,
0.20785076916217804,
-0.2338956743478775,
0.2606084942817688,
-0.03302823007106781,
-0.40129944682121277,
-0.7578563690185547,
0.20282968878746033,
0.4250389337539673,
0.10404213517904282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07549v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07549v1
|
Comments as Natural Logic Pivots: Improve Code Generation via Comment Perspective
| 2024-04-11T08:30:46 | 2024-04-11T08:30:46 |
Yijie Chen, Yijin Liu, Fandong Meng, Yufeng Chen, Jinan Xu, Jie Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Code generation aims to understand the problem description and generate
corresponding code snippets, where existing works generally decompose such
complex tasks into intermediate steps by prompting strategies, such as
Chain-of-Thought and its variants. While these studies have achieved some
success, their effectiveness is highly dependent on the capabilities of
advanced Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT-4, particularly in terms of
API calls, which significantly limits their practical applicability.
Consequently, how to enhance the code generation capabilities of small and
medium-scale code LLMs without significantly increasing training costs is an
appealing challenge. In this paper, we suggest that code comments are the
natural logic pivot between natural language and code language and propose
using comments to boost the code generation ability of code LLMs. Concretely,
we propose MANGO (comMents As Natural loGic pivOts), including a comment
contrastive training strategy and a corresponding logical comment decoding
strategy. Experiments are performed on HumanEval and MBPP, utilizing StarCoder
and WizardCoder as backbone models, and encompassing model parameter sizes
between 3B and 7B. The results indicate that MANGO significantly improves the
code pass rate based on the strong baselines. Meanwhile, the robustness of the
logical comment decoding strategy is notably higher than the Chain-of-thoughts
prompting. The code is publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/pppa2019/Mango}.
|
[
-0.639500617980957,
-0.5922852754592896,
0.4476605951786041,
0.19158011674880981,
-0.620664119720459,
0.0994865745306015,
-0.3902749717235565,
-0.2963206470012665,
0.12607252597808838,
0.7893166542053223,
-0.599289059638977,
-0.15999719500541687,
-0.18711845576763153,
0.50146484375,
-0.09858088195323944,
1.3588086366653442,
0.20001304149627686,
-0.020638806745409966,
-0.1322062909603119,
0.09425479918718338,
-0.3653469681739807,
-0.6280000805854797,
-0.44425299763679504,
-0.1454492211341858,
0.22942359745502472,
0.382358580827713,
0.3795561194419861,
0.2714501619338989,
0.4559619426727295,
0.26550599932670593,
0.27812790870666504,
0.5308716893196106,
-0.2768007516860962,
0.08146283030509949,
-0.14746886491775513,
-0.7087541222572327,
-0.26669976115226746,
-0.23102205991744995,
0.19284357130527496,
0.31771016120910645,
0.02245628833770752,
0.2057579606771469,
0.15916088223457336,
1.1205871105194092,
-0.5120604634284973,
0.6625362634658813,
-0.7812759876251221,
0.2049674689769745,
-0.08019489049911499,
-0.3372138440608978,
-0.5874245762825012,
-0.7555570602416992,
-0.5355218648910522,
-0.20633767545223236,
-0.03434710204601288,
-0.15454883873462677,
0.5075685381889343,
0.4719935357570648,
-0.06380929797887802,
-0.1810370832681656,
-0.5649547576904297,
0.7007922530174255,
-1.0781834125518799,
-0.025178834795951843,
0.1728171706199646,
0.363739013671875,
-0.1691683828830719,
-0.6446734666824341,
-0.6618239879608154,
-0.2989804148674011,
0.03760480135679245,
-0.12543267011642456,
-0.020399801433086395,
-0.16512100398540497,
0.5964656472206116,
0.3026076853275299,
-0.005013908725231886,
-0.5318371653556824,
-0.19053462147712708,
-0.020843779668211937,
0.6296898126602173,
0.1140369176864624,
0.2177617996931076,
-0.3822002708911896,
0.08893655240535736,
0.5877692699432373,
-0.8899147510528564,
0.09255887567996979,
0.264573872089386,
0.45655137300491333,
-0.17187701165676117,
0.48346829414367676,
-0.4049057364463806,
0.9340569376945496,
0.16031087934970856,
-0.1693837195634842,
0.4243212342262268,
-0.522872269153595,
-0.03306577354669571,
-0.30030542612075806,
0.7124183177947998,
0.7641366124153137,
0.6105286478996277,
-0.014676998369395733,
-0.0542716346681118,
0.21316030621528625,
0.49940964579582214,
-1.0528329610824585,
-0.5571584701538086,
-0.1634248048067093,
-0.3563661575317383,
-0.44826287031173706,
0.14275799691677094,
-0.8890193700790405,
-0.5331718921661377,
-0.5686233043670654,
-0.09524880349636078,
-0.42966702580451965,
-0.21921633183956146,
-0.23636494576931,
0.18566124141216278,
0.42676424980163574,
0.45209524035453796,
-0.793851375579834,
0.42113855481147766,
0.7182198762893677,
0.5995875000953674,
0.2394639551639557,
0.10065288096666336,
-0.8829396963119507,
-0.026838066056370735,
-0.31832510232925415,
0.6335749626159668,
-0.657404363155365,
-0.31527024507522583,
-0.12000712752342224,
-0.36132532358169556,
-0.12303368002176285,
-0.5723390579223633,
0.4076712429523468,
-0.4075491726398468,
0.0846199318766594,
-0.33270031213760376,
-0.2144079953432083,
-0.089445561170578,
0.3137465715408325,
-0.383003294467926,
0.8696834444999695,
0.05451878532767296,
-1.2377740144729614,
0.2192690670490265,
-0.8219434022903442,
-0.7794904112815857,
0.13152332603931427,
-0.6562848687171936,
-0.4064667224884033,
0.2897873818874359,
0.4772229492664337,
0.4155164062976837,
-0.4607587158679962,
0.10174930095672607,
-0.09251780062913895,
-0.14520634710788727,
0.5758999586105347,
-0.06378432363271713,
0.3964821398258209,
0.5267651677131653,
-0.6430658102035522,
-0.046749114990234375,
-0.6248254179954529,
0.40218958258628845,
0.06892404705286026,
-0.5742471218109131,
0.12057334929704666,
0.1447221338748932,
-0.4173435866832733,
0.4104088246822357,
-0.043501511216163635,
-0.39602458477020264,
0.2729080021381378,
-0.6189696192741394,
0.5348735451698303,
0.46913865208625793,
0.459481805562973,
0.29605183005332947,
-0.05068023502826691,
0.3710692226886749,
0.09438112378120422,
0.1514703333377838,
-0.40490034222602844,
-0.8280128836631775,
-0.7419486045837402,
-0.2163970023393631,
0.19390858709812164,
0.39446109533309937,
-1.2749978303909302,
0.21046856045722961,
-0.21129608154296875,
-0.011620738543570042,
-0.45703819394111633,
0.6336456537246704,
0.5353724360466003,
0.7564292550086975,
0.17657236754894257,
-0.6245425939559937,
-0.892529308795929,
-0.8527336120605469,
-0.3607311248779297,
-0.10482040047645569,
-0.10338879376649857,
0.27512627840042114,
0.3689466714859009,
-0.25413861870765686,
1.2723658084869385,
-0.7075809836387634,
0.15877331793308258,
-0.433885782957077,
-0.07474151998758316,
0.44286370277404785,
0.3703846037387848,
0.2849002778530121,
-0.7297179102897644,
-0.7622675895690918,
-0.04681309685111046,
-0.4881778359413147,
-0.2688409388065338,
0.12092140316963196,
-0.2174939066171646,
0.4220603108406067,
0.37470394372940063,
-0.6203604936599731,
0.4069187045097351,
0.034648679196834564,
0.21733607351779938,
0.33701664209365845,
0.030077651143074036,
0.17050035297870636,
-1.048438310623169,
0.03204415738582611,
-0.047420088201761246,
-0.2821992039680481,
-0.5298736095428467,
0.2941213846206665,
0.1248568743467331,
-0.14686205983161926,
-0.44328564405441284,
-0.07704834640026093,
-0.3262880742549896,
0.08301568776369095,
-0.39704352617263794,
-0.19321496784687042,
-0.03400421515107155,
0.834871232509613,
0.03747117891907692,
0.7766184210777283,
0.2274443805217743,
-0.6261594295501709,
0.16836261749267578,
-0.23404577374458313,
-0.1471942663192749,
0.6110748648643494,
-0.33254384994506836,
0.4211570918560028,
0.2122579962015152,
0.35215863585472107,
-0.7189174294471741,
-0.2610970735549927,
0.42225489020347595,
-0.5187342762947083,
0.2794446349143982,
-0.36073213815689087,
-0.7167828679084778,
-0.5414879322052002,
-0.8347323536872864,
-0.004847975913435221,
0.8080493807792664,
-0.32890602946281433,
0.34068813920021057,
0.4044833779335022,
-0.2724950611591339,
-0.20061920583248138,
-0.8256482481956482,
0.27118420600891113,
0.0783907026052475,
-0.5193833112716675,
-0.34725427627563477,
-0.19594214856624603,
-0.20288939774036407,
-0.1835923045873642,
-0.18334677815437317,
0.10826239734888077,
-0.08982738107442856,
0.34775394201278687,
0.27541664242744446,
-0.2628413140773773,
-0.15242695808410645,
-0.31231340765953064,
-0.1967657059431076,
0.34740424156188965,
-0.5082206726074219,
0.5460528135299683,
-0.3984183967113495,
-0.13152506947517395,
0.07033572345972061,
0.16357870399951935,
0.3853437304496765,
-0.6015735268592834,
0.528504490852356,
0.09722922742366791,
-0.20642608404159546,
-0.4399854242801666,
-0.5982835292816162,
-0.03130827471613884,
-0.4551626443862915,
0.1358136385679245,
-0.3760918080806732,
-0.5750386714935303,
0.2324609011411667,
-0.16345639526844025,
0.09206699579954147,
0.21254423260688782,
0.8649917244911194,
0.17391793429851532,
1.124388337135315,
0.6405153274536133,
-0.14016617834568024,
0.2532833218574524,
-0.3303067088127136,
0.634672224521637,
-0.9273228645324707,
-0.2455453872680664,
-0.5348646640777588,
0.16311797499656677,
-0.5018402934074402,
-0.9288209080696106,
0.047971975058317184,
-0.07675981521606445,
-0.35167351365089417,
0.06132589653134346,
-0.7569413781166077,
0.7185481786727905,
0.4526607394218445,
0.20877520740032196,
0.2832365036010742,
0.08719806373119354,
-0.4029623568058014,
-0.17623411118984222,
-0.7296335101127625,
-0.514319658279419,
1.2033631801605225,
0.2522120773792267,
0.7059473991394043,
-0.021152229979634285,
0.8968666195869446,
0.10335344076156616,
0.6623126864433289,
-0.5965716242790222,
0.815252959728241,
-0.04346032813191414,
-0.2669981122016907,
0.18588802218437195,
-0.7110471725463867,
-0.3828590512275696,
0.08072462677955627,
0.08875293284654617,
-0.5870382785797119,
-0.12216458469629288,
0.20657914876937866,
-0.20448455214500427,
0.3398248851299286,
-0.8867924809455872,
0.5962542295455933,
-0.19428646564483643,
-0.7447217106819153,
0.0625137910246849,
-0.7593062520027161,
0.5378151535987854,
-0.06629052758216858,
0.5727198719978333,
0.09014685451984406,
-0.040963735431432724,
0.46404626965522766,
-1.0710508823394775,
1.0711733102798462,
-0.4333951473236084,
-0.11033926904201508,
0.6970527172088623,
0.15506167709827423,
0.4372444450855255,
0.08729266375303268,
-0.06434668600559235,
-0.36869028210639954,
-0.6958544254302979,
-0.20542269945144653,
-0.48498231172561646,
0.708040714263916,
-0.5928719639778137,
-0.4909622073173523,
0.01198630966246128,
-0.35395580530166626,
-0.5111574530601501,
0.22510313987731934,
0.3320056200027466,
0.3802638351917267,
0.36399099230766296,
-0.08286689221858978,
0.5855779647827148,
0.1276845633983612,
0.48786404728889465,
0.3574453890323639,
-0.4572521150112152,
-0.6690052151679993,
1.0372347831726074,
-0.05665753409266472,
0.20609651505947113,
0.3025866150856018,
0.04760471358895302,
-0.23237447440624237,
-0.3762674331665039,
-0.3230869472026825,
0.25317710638046265,
-0.8538174629211426,
-0.6687416434288025,
-0.544313371181488,
-0.16773006319999695,
-0.17908373475074768,
-0.06292426586151123,
-0.2511138617992401,
-0.6131483316421509,
0.15155582129955292,
-0.18421539664268494,
0.5624927878379822,
0.7376576662063599,
0.3183022737503052,
-0.14299152791500092,
-0.6594253778457642,
0.6109822988510132,
0.36638143658638,
0.6257175803184509,
0.20082618296146393,
-0.25939807295799255,
-0.5099238157272339,
0.14803212881088257,
-0.2863090932369232,
-0.9017355442047119,
0.27041080594062805,
0.0086516123265028,
0.2921827435493469,
0.1619989424943924,
0.2561555504798889,
0.4463910460472107,
-0.6566564440727234,
0.7485374212265015,
0.4554644227027893,
-0.9558920860290527,
0.8602675199508667,
-0.19685345888137817,
0.33792856335639954,
0.758675754070282,
-0.15315137803554535,
-0.10901908576488495,
-0.7045347690582275,
-0.4316163957118988,
-0.7486502528190613,
0.6304810643196106,
0.32041171193122864,
0.1492992788553238,
-0.15169063210487366,
0.24802733957767487,
0.09461101144552231,
0.7215865254402161,
-1.0672876834869385,
0.1056293249130249,
-0.5472691059112549,
-0.1520388275384903,
0.12594178318977356,
-0.06710359454154968,
-0.04573577269911766,
-0.3669419288635254,
0.4061363935470581,
-0.3998100757598877,
0.2027326226234436,
-0.027540283277630806,
-0.06793154031038284,
-0.1259029358625412,
0.500311553478241,
0.43016210198402405,
0.48663902282714844,
-0.05861897021532059,
0.42192894220352173,
0.10887589305639267,
-0.5186500549316406,
0.04682179167866707,
-0.18819525837898254,
-0.24978229403495789,
-0.13536950945854187,
0.16769079864025116,
0.574346661567688,
0.38057446479797363,
-0.39928385615348816,
0.3291393220424652,
0.0029666253831237555,
-0.12694846093654633,
0.11404940485954285,
0.4673783481121063,
0.3081248998641968,
-0.1065346747636795,
0.17297756671905518,
0.5044201016426086,
0.057248786091804504,
-0.7429834008216858,
0.19059069454669952,
0.08438536524772644,
-0.16457875072956085,
-0.2358502745628357,
0.7018253207206726,
0.7275063991546631,
-0.3460041582584381,
0.5252259969711304,
-0.40860292315483093,
-0.8440870642662048,
0.5486330986022949,
0.5228478312492371,
1.0330064296722412,
0.1582741141319275,
0.06907115131616592,
0.1651206910610199,
0.4017094373703003,
0.08130773901939392,
0.4105250835418701,
-0.476201593875885,
-0.4096687436103821,
-0.7396609783172607,
-0.5410378575325012,
-0.523492693901062,
-0.3738572299480438,
-0.3480040729045868,
0.2695760130882263,
-0.8509214520454407,
-0.10586561262607574,
-0.2810891568660736,
0.23614230751991272,
-0.5287776589393616,
0.12221179157495499,
0.43104857206344604,
0.9208096265792847,
-0.6129934191703796,
1.13961660861969,
0.8583149313926697,
-0.7895509600639343,
-0.91790771484375,
0.30169013142585754,
-0.15443013608455658,
-0.4866221845149994,
0.593781590461731,
0.5558679103851318,
-0.34075382351875305,
-0.25541451573371887,
-0.677690327167511,
-0.21659359335899353,
0.4973059892654419,
0.49640995264053345,
-0.3436914384365082,
0.2913517653942108,
0.4966227412223816,
0.732985258102417,
-0.6420053839683533,
0.19540934264659882,
0.6010048389434814,
0.32057496905326843,
0.04184921458363533,
-0.6634957194328308,
0.24257536232471466,
-0.8363806009292603,
0.1822446584701538,
0.3302498459815979,
-0.5230211019515991,
0.6695014834403992,
-0.45517268776893616,
0.18398329615592957,
-0.14952506124973297,
0.2685350477695465,
0.48372599482536316,
0.33298754692077637,
0.3661341071128845,
0.43062061071395874,
0.4183974862098694,
0.027049943804740906,
1.3295986652374268,
-0.48494547605514526,
0.17080643773078918,
1.0281901359558105,
-0.5754539370536804,
0.9780362844467163,
0.7874763607978821,
-0.43047475814819336,
0.7218700051307678,
0.22236791253089905,
0.1647842675447464,
0.5281707048416138,
0.4446548819541931,
-0.07860127091407776,
-0.0165584534406662,
0.21524347364902496,
-0.5213394165039062,
-0.18421342968940735,
0.29300421476364136,
-0.08667212724685669,
-0.005672060884535313,
-0.2278399020433426,
0.22739772498607635,
0.45780545473098755,
-0.4450937509536743,
0.808413028717041,
0.2508150041103363,
-0.8439087867736816,
0.5956135988235474,
0.009646437130868435,
0.7134416103363037,
-0.5280085206031799,
-0.2407580018043518,
-0.5503095388412476,
0.28585097193717957,
-0.6249534487724304,
-0.6116164326667786,
0.27608999609947205,
0.5892941951751709,
-0.23231329023838043,
-0.09772716462612152,
0.682107150554657,
-0.10934315621852875,
-0.5889726281166077,
0.02822892926633358,
0.08852755278348923,
-0.21757908165454865,
-0.11885363608598709,
-0.5734639763832092,
0.125750333070755,
0.38695335388183594,
-0.21463172137737274,
0.15447746217250824,
0.5741804838180542,
0.08416237682104111,
0.46266090869903564,
0.6540291905403137,
-0.058698076754808426,
0.22867527604103088,
0.011175226420164108,
1.1706393957138062,
-0.6799145340919495,
-0.8054579496383667,
-0.9200706481933594,
0.6624025702476501,
-0.4318724572658539,
0.10675608366727829,
0.9701652526855469,
0.707709014415741,
0.5725836753845215,
-0.43778470158576965,
0.9547380805015564,
-0.11124218255281448,
0.7071030139923096,
-0.6078634858131409,
0.3268164098262787,
-0.04608449712395668,
0.8961238861083984,
-0.5667184591293335,
-0.9840563535690308,
-0.30227598547935486,
0.636581301689148,
-0.6015666723251343,
0.18343079090118408,
0.5994779467582703,
0.7162122130393982,
-0.0432342104613781,
0.13996382057666779,
-0.0817030519247055,
0.24086928367614746,
0.37578245997428894,
0.7824521660804749,
0.9459989666938782,
-0.11257798224687576,
0.5510150790214539,
-0.3641112148761749,
-0.20753727853298187,
-0.42034903168678284,
-0.9502770304679871,
-0.9219715595245361,
-0.002041152212768793,
-0.5233361721038818,
-0.3890252113342285,
-0.2285548597574234,
0.8167465925216675,
0.6108454465866089,
-0.756462037563324,
-0.2631630599498749,
-0.5863066911697388,
0.24607950448989868,
0.11905568093061447,
-0.25720396637916565,
0.030690617859363556,
-0.6160420179367065,
-0.2527751922607422,
-0.08709387481212616,
0.4843977391719818,
-0.4775225818157196,
-0.03460389003157616,
-0.39415210485458374,
0.07459603250026703,
0.36060991883277893,
0.6803320050239563,
0.46372729539871216,
-0.47641611099243164,
-0.05970478057861328,
-0.13419516384601593,
-0.08188113570213318,
0.272388756275177,
1.0733624696731567,
-1.0270167589187622,
0.47305911779403687,
0.42703813314437866,
0.6391046047210693,
0.5886082649230957,
0.0002801602822728455,
0.5976446866989136,
-0.8495445251464844,
0.3443949520587921,
0.1667262613773346,
0.31432899832725525,
0.4657294452190399,
-0.15293502807617188,
0.711870551109314,
0.18397840857505798,
-0.28044393658638,
-0.8539818525314331,
0.3985101580619812,
-0.6278476119041443,
-0.14881405234336853,
0.8213003873825073,
-0.05404917895793915,
-0.22392185032367706,
0.029087211936712265,
-0.6649658679962158,
-0.03249014914035797,
-0.3324759900569916,
0.4511534571647644,
0.2368593066930771,
-0.45299121737480164,
-0.21865032613277435,
-0.6598036885261536,
0.5712069869041443,
0.4025644361972809,
-1.13498055934906,
0.06641820818185806,
0.487595796585083,
0.24747474491596222,
0.1890335977077484,
0.9345721006393433,
-0.4267243444919586,
0.5611575245857239,
0.08931588381528854,
0.12165650725364685,
-0.12298064678907394,
-0.05917966365814209,
-0.21709629893302917,
0.2466389387845993,
0.4807853400707245,
-0.17897510528564453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07546v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07546v1
|
Decomposing Label Space, Format and Discrimination: Rethinking How LLMs Respond and Solve Tasks via In-Context Learning
| 2024-04-11T08:20:10 | 2024-04-11T08:20:10 |
Quanyu Long, Yin Wu, Wenya Wang, Sinno Jialin Pan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-context Learning (ICL) has emerged as a powerful capability alongside the
development of scaled-up large language models (LLMs). By instructing LLMs
using few-shot demonstrative examples, ICL enables them to perform a wide range
of tasks without updating millions of parameters. However, the precise
contributions of demonstrations towards improving end-task performance have not
been thoroughly investigated in recent analytical studies. In this paper, we
empirically decompose the overall performance of ICL into three dimensions,
label space, format, and discrimination, and we evaluate four general-purpose
LLMs across a diverse range of tasks. Counter-intuitively, we find that the
demonstrations have a marginal impact on provoking discriminative knowledge of
language models. However, ICL exhibits significant efficacy in regulating the
label space and format which helps LLMs to respond in desired label words. We
then demonstrate this ability functions similar to detailed instructions for
LLMs to follow. We additionally provide an in-depth analysis of the mechanism
of retrieval helping with ICL and find that retrieving the most semantically
similar examples notably boosts model's discriminative capability.
|
[
-0.3225448429584503,
-0.6778642535209656,
0.516315758228302,
0.010431395843625069,
-0.29568353295326233,
0.024780845269560814,
-0.34286579489707947,
-0.4668773114681244,
-0.4084431529045105,
0.2644362151622772,
-0.2263038605451584,
-0.5082044005393982,
-0.4785858392715454,
0.06981094926595688,
-0.463505357503891,
1.1207152605056763,
-0.08138798177242279,
-0.13068470358848572,
-0.6228325963020325,
-0.1455201953649521,
-0.34844139218330383,
-0.6849843859672546,
-0.41476455330848694,
-0.5092719197273254,
0.23469649255275726,
0.6806818842887878,
0.15046370029449463,
0.6041973233222961,
0.22347694635391235,
0.24905046820640564,
-0.23431512713432312,
0.10027676075696945,
-0.6755161285400391,
0.05256754532456398,
0.03851764649152756,
-0.45255252718925476,
0.018254496157169342,
0.24926504492759705,
0.8839086294174194,
0.9653959274291992,
-0.06077948585152626,
0.24437259137630463,
0.6512569785118103,
0.4087866246700287,
-0.657340407371521,
0.2636675536632538,
-0.7038004994392395,
-0.08831378072500229,
-0.12823174893856049,
-0.09420523047447205,
-0.7902665138244629,
-0.06740093231201172,
0.12088784575462341,
-0.6058292984962463,
0.09548721462488174,
0.1152624562382698,
0.5969311594963074,
0.2361641377210617,
-0.5987557768821716,
-0.5376471877098083,
-0.7847414612770081,
0.8064026832580566,
-0.6721324324607849,
0.48357337713241577,
0.3648860454559326,
0.283315509557724,
-0.1637142449617386,
-0.8947537541389465,
-0.3950575590133667,
-0.3970355689525604,
-0.31505122780799866,
-0.016469571739435196,
-0.11041400581598282,
-0.04220755398273468,
0.5105541944503784,
0.09609360247850418,
-0.23686771094799042,
0.4502721130847931,
-0.23813723027706146,
-0.015119753777980804,
0.35233184695243835,
0.12807652354240417,
0.2834289073944092,
0.246282160282135,
-0.5195190906524658,
-0.09677612781524658,
-1.0205124616622925,
0.31616610288619995,
0.001532295485958457,
0.2995089590549469,
-0.10411281883716583,
0.2950369417667389,
-0.09430764615535736,
0.8775020837783813,
0.0894308015704155,
-0.38321971893310547,
0.03962097316980362,
-0.03101445361971855,
-0.33778440952301025,
0.04729427024722099,
0.4985733926296234,
0.16698043048381805,
-0.036210913211107254,
-0.27600499987602234,
-0.3063334822654724,
-0.15339720249176025,
0.11482954025268555,
-0.8034393191337585,
-0.016641002148389816,
-0.10922540724277496,
-0.4727516174316406,
0.18497423827648163,
-0.2869199812412262,
-0.28104478120803833,
-0.24574968218803406,
-0.5225815773010254,
0.5627637505531311,
-0.4484727382659912,
0.03616176173090935,
0.13671761751174927,
-0.057869426906108856,
0.29295703768730164,
0.2928242087364197,
-0.7569465637207031,
0.6018561124801636,
0.6606135964393616,
0.5376237034797668,
-0.35321342945098877,
-0.1550629734992981,
-0.48806020617485046,
0.3445282578468323,
-0.28912800550460815,
0.6246797442436218,
-0.5763406753540039,
-0.3122311532497406,
0.07075060904026031,
-0.16393598914146423,
-0.04072543606162071,
-1.1053212881088257,
0.1534990817308426,
-0.5403622984886169,
0.1049092710018158,
-0.3543892204761505,
-0.7202998399734497,
-0.1501813530921936,
0.32989662885665894,
-0.5644302368164062,
0.8288799524307251,
-0.019769061356782913,
-0.48895493149757385,
0.6364809274673462,
-0.8008593320846558,
-0.29840341210365295,
0.25393691658973694,
-0.3211372494697571,
-0.2891302704811096,
0.186070516705513,
-0.05330580100417137,
0.7056596875190735,
-0.1281239092350006,
0.18606245517730713,
-0.22388464212417603,
-0.6703658103942871,
0.467589408159256,
-0.31251707673072815,
0.5673664808273315,
0.15150262415409088,
-0.39195775985717773,
-0.023150917142629623,
-0.7049006819725037,
-0.2021287977695465,
-0.061812326312065125,
-0.6202390193939209,
-0.4661896228790283,
0.12091591209173203,
-0.26084959506988525,
0.37569794058799744,
-0.05361456051468849,
-0.6029061079025269,
0.0057622529566287994,
-0.409035325050354,
0.416443407535553,
0.4699171483516693,
-0.20488309860229492,
0.5183041095733643,
-0.07507316023111343,
0.45181360840797424,
0.0853511169552803,
-0.010311445221304893,
-0.09325092285871506,
-0.1223641186952591,
-0.49394404888153076,
-0.35545244812965393,
-0.05175638943910599,
0.07278245687484741,
-0.7350561022758484,
-0.23203012347221375,
-0.17137958109378815,
-0.20734736323356628,
-0.3296279013156891,
0.19364313781261444,
0.6807428002357483,
0.7050144672393799,
0.345988392829895,
-0.1302218735218048,
-0.22992366552352905,
-1.0337371826171875,
-0.23028890788555145,
-0.20632587373256683,
-0.1285877674818039,
0.306206077337265,
0.5329649448394775,
0.10832139849662781,
0.9592761993408203,
-0.20133259892463684,
-0.23975443840026855,
-0.34084683656692505,
-0.06699400395154953,
-0.021623028442263603,
0.20370729267597198,
0.5523242950439453,
-0.6984109878540039,
-0.561125636100769,
0.0845075324177742,
-0.6304673552513123,
-0.16255410015583038,
0.08519156277179718,
0.1857105791568756,
0.16735778748989105,
0.8670202493667603,
-0.11439196020364761,
0.4899027645587921,
0.2340242862701416,
-0.21920078992843628,
0.5690147280693054,
-0.2020355463027954,
-0.2294313907623291,
-0.6487342119216919,
-0.16159044206142426,
0.10810675472021103,
-0.122601218521595,
-0.711466372013092,
0.22600498795509338,
0.340806782245636,
0.08056089282035828,
-0.735703706741333,
0.6505689024925232,
-0.5011439919471741,
-0.21233013272285461,
-0.4142913222312927,
0.36388710141181946,
-0.1320301741361618,
0.4661400020122528,
0.012046094983816147,
0.8269256949424744,
0.29695937037467957,
-0.8375880122184753,
-0.226949542760849,
-0.005164604168385267,
-0.5396053791046143,
0.38572052121162415,
-0.41488322615623474,
0.11358147114515305,
-0.38519716262817383,
0.3526308536529541,
-1.2837214469909668,
-0.15494491159915924,
0.09847687184810638,
0.07258196175098419,
0.4572386145591736,
-0.00800203438848257,
-0.6523137092590332,
-0.026871569454669952,
-0.13308367133140564,
0.6174529790878296,
0.45619553327560425,
-0.848297119140625,
0.29355716705322266,
0.35161131620407104,
0.23073893785476685,
-0.41667410731315613,
-0.5773835778236389,
-0.11848129332065582,
-0.6334701180458069,
-0.033983394503593445,
0.6026028990745544,
-0.24915209412574768,
-0.5847160816192627,
-0.31307631731033325,
-0.05994601920247078,
0.11832764744758606,
0.415377140045166,
0.16179712116718292,
-0.09915409982204437,
0.07506111264228821,
0.3086048364639282,
-0.042476266622543335,
0.09237516671419144,
0.1276623159646988,
-0.23458538949489594,
0.3166109621524811,
-0.25244489312171936,
-0.5052589774131775,
-0.3012995421886444,
0.29204338788986206,
0.3985394537448883,
-0.0671340748667717,
0.6565335988998413,
0.3084064722061157,
-0.4101352393627167,
-0.4152141213417053,
-0.23829083144664764,
-0.15354354679584503,
-0.4584246277809143,
0.38742172718048096,
-0.4627246558666229,
-1.010023832321167,
0.4142550230026245,
-0.33298322558403015,
0.16448034346103668,
0.03482244536280632,
0.5452655553817749,
-0.2199205458164215,
0.9257153868675232,
0.8630979657173157,
0.19951049983501434,
0.51335608959198,
-0.35307490825653076,
0.24867726862430573,
-1.1052557229995728,
-0.6757075190544128,
-0.43010425567626953,
-0.5238715410232544,
-0.25243404507637024,
-0.2045384645462036,
0.42163440585136414,
0.32424196600914,
-0.35301464796066284,
0.16508473455905914,
-0.3952619433403015,
0.591306209564209,
0.4537838399410248,
0.16390882432460785,
0.19299811124801636,
-0.03076847642660141,
-0.3288900852203369,
-0.14073829352855682,
-0.6378061175346375,
-0.7081261873245239,
0.8006953001022339,
0.3156493604183197,
0.7680999040603638,
0.26270225644111633,
0.6514381766319275,
-0.06924574077129364,
0.6961847543716431,
-0.8227056264877319,
0.6448211669921875,
-0.2615002393722534,
-0.3105231821537018,
-0.10039909929037094,
0.1397055685520172,
-0.8588300347328186,
0.41724732518196106,
0.15844281017780304,
-0.9492476582527161,
0.12918440997600555,
0.19506005942821503,
-0.13594931364059448,
0.3064554035663605,
-0.7974606156349182,
0.6440368294715881,
-0.1528504490852356,
-0.3163456618785858,
-0.013080156408250332,
-0.5324063897132874,
0.3643442392349243,
-0.0900040715932846,
0.26753002405166626,
0.10384050011634827,
-0.16332107782363892,
0.749849259853363,
-0.17758488655090332,
1.2371200323104858,
-0.1990465670824051,
-0.46631455421447754,
0.16455990076065063,
0.28303584456443787,
0.24661530554294586,
-0.11740384250879288,
-0.04691055044531822,
-0.32300901412963867,
-0.10039384663105011,
-0.2590128481388092,
-0.875469446182251,
0.6518356204032898,
-0.6483737826347351,
-0.6494269967079163,
0.16145670413970947,
-0.6709269881248474,
-0.2777349650859833,
-0.24287213385105133,
0.19795088469982147,
0.7025697231292725,
-0.0587531179189682,
0.4090958833694458,
0.8003713488578796,
-0.169009268283844,
0.6875777244567871,
0.5805986523628235,
-0.1991759091615677,
0.1336781084537506,
0.7088413238525391,
0.1598564237356186,
0.5350115895271301,
0.5737806558609009,
0.08013617992401123,
-0.46843358874320984,
-0.6038385033607483,
-0.10633622109889984,
0.09703125059604645,
-1.0576967000961304,
-0.1353612244129181,
-0.5686776041984558,
0.06413685530424118,
-0.10944254696369171,
-0.21497131884098053,
-0.04858227074146271,
-0.21578508615493774,
-0.44118404388427734,
-0.20185300707817078,
-0.051666807383298874,
0.9532206058502197,
0.05600137636065483,
0.45935750007629395,
-0.1493539810180664,
0.04052773118019104,
0.3579484820365906,
0.25446581840515137,
0.2278313785791397,
-0.743076741695404,
-0.38203516602516174,
-0.08858426660299301,
-0.44437429308891296,
-0.7961594462394714,
0.2511371970176697,
0.36176252365112305,
0.8147743344306946,
0.39618393778800964,
-0.02706350013613701,
0.8257309794425964,
-0.5173162221908569,
0.9377680420875549,
-0.13694451749324799,
-0.9401646256446838,
0.4328777492046356,
0.0917721688747406,
0.3420293927192688,
0.08495122194290161,
0.5489925146102905,
-0.4775938093662262,
-0.43403753638267517,
-0.4077385663986206,
-0.8394871354103088,
0.7192164063453674,
-0.14778415858745575,
0.08436104655265808,
-0.20943093299865723,
0.5905296206474304,
0.3099418580532074,
-0.02901935577392578,
-0.8374117612838745,
-0.22472873330116272,
-0.04096787050366402,
-0.12882237136363983,
-0.18595610558986664,
-0.48048296570777893,
-0.25266581773757935,
-0.3640778958797455,
0.43827497959136963,
-0.4072127938270569,
0.30270418524742126,
-0.024279514327645302,
-0.4757568836212158,
0.3476923108100891,
0.377171128988266,
0.719106137752533,
0.6925600171089172,
0.1017177477478981,
0.3496073782444,
0.2757658362388611,
-0.049753233790397644,
0.2676455080509186,
-0.14179857075214386,
-0.016917048022150993,
-0.25336259603500366,
0.5509181618690491,
0.8628323674201965,
0.5392698049545288,
-0.7106408476829529,
0.30955860018730164,
0.006297561340034008,
-0.2545221447944641,
-0.03481733798980713,
0.032541289925575256,
-0.0653439313173294,
0.2538965344429016,
0.4130423963069916,
-0.3927040100097656,
0.32115796208381653,
-0.6355727314949036,
0.25442758202552795,
0.5826706886291504,
-0.4635560214519501,
-0.31720224022865295,
0.7226319909095764,
-0.272006630897522,
-0.43925219774246216,
0.5299749970436096,
-0.1377667635679245,
-0.3974887430667877,
0.5506640672683716,
1.256091594696045,
0.6645190715789795,
0.1315932720899582,
0.22740374505519867,
0.1267833709716797,
0.024260707199573517,
0.16190612316131592,
-0.126500204205513,
-0.4971868693828583,
-0.752777099609375,
-0.4576968848705292,
-0.401759535074234,
-0.23877719044685364,
0.262153297662735,
-0.7352612614631653,
-0.08022672683000565,
-0.3614714443683624,
0.1632111668586731,
-0.12437241524457932,
-0.06741037964820862,
-0.7532913088798523,
0.1064196228981018,
0.3389608860015869,
0.9276530742645264,
-0.8889099359512329,
0.752068281173706,
0.8794094324111938,
-0.1842639297246933,
-0.8452309370040894,
0.2078990787267685,
0.020634036511182785,
-0.5934251546859741,
1.212600827217102,
0.2833440601825714,
-0.2505803406238556,
0.009824397973716259,
-0.9204861521720886,
-0.8127138614654541,
1.084611177444458,
0.5468915104866028,
-0.23649528622627258,
0.24126943945884705,
0.18972982466220856,
0.6468825936317444,
-0.6897493600845337,
0.3642885982990265,
0.6135671734809875,
0.023562010377645493,
-0.07341837882995605,
-0.885399580001831,
0.03241150453686714,
-0.05010424554347992,
0.2722018361091614,
-0.08123307675123215,
-0.5065083503723145,
0.5431557893753052,
-0.14429675042629242,
-0.3988654911518097,
-0.04920017346739769,
0.6158571243286133,
0.5645021200180054,
0.2592967748641968,
0.4490301012992859,
0.23595690727233887,
0.65476393699646,
-0.14049918949604034,
1.1092244386672974,
0.014079826883971691,
0.15975773334503174,
1.0141717195510864,
-0.3830603361129761,
0.92404705286026,
0.7200464010238647,
-0.02956661954522133,
0.6792263984680176,
0.5931056141853333,
0.551056981086731,
0.6535196900367737,
0.38167089223861694,
-0.4042464792728424,
-0.22193177044391632,
-0.3494854271411896,
0.037581633776426315,
0.5617422461509705,
0.7413674592971802,
-0.1723817139863968,
-0.48623064160346985,
0.5534693598747253,
-0.11528634279966354,
0.4018290042877197,
-0.2526039779186249,
0.9127799272537231,
0.03469884395599365,
-0.5468956232070923,
0.6038613319396973,
-0.18180233240127563,
0.6787810325622559,
-0.35615915060043335,
-0.3175102174282074,
-0.269176185131073,
0.20023004710674286,
0.0460987463593483,
-0.8710136413574219,
0.11932973563671112,
-0.27841654419898987,
-0.21132850646972656,
-0.5246652960777283,
0.6713092923164368,
-0.5566140413284302,
0.052525509148836136,
0.4445771872997284,
0.226400226354599,
0.35713183879852295,
0.25591617822647095,
-0.39079418778419495,
0.1921914517879486,
-0.10652711242437363,
0.028684338554739952,
0.6088305115699768,
0.5385215878486633,
-0.33421027660369873,
0.9970265626907349,
0.2921619117259979,
-0.33588629961013794,
0.05522650107741356,
0.051586318761110306,
0.7957594394683838,
-0.3738381266593933,
-0.2551272213459015,
-0.9649245738983154,
0.4938758611679077,
0.11738158762454987,
-0.18316662311553955,
0.7259282469749451,
0.5991874933242798,
1.520813226699829,
-0.14503221213817596,
0.5050674080848694,
0.13587823510169983,
0.33889955282211304,
-0.589381992816925,
0.40923842787742615,
-0.7354673147201538,
0.4838678240776062,
-0.1544274091720581,
-0.48144999146461487,
-0.5318437218666077,
0.3502500653266907,
-0.33924323320388794,
0.037388868629932404,
0.5630351901054382,
0.6690176725387573,
-0.07588931173086166,
-0.28239020705223083,
0.5404077172279358,
0.1175244152545929,
0.6420748233795166,
0.4952634871006012,
1.0808019638061523,
-0.1529286950826645,
0.5054758191108704,
-0.3699778616428375,
-0.14902125298976898,
-0.21218463778495789,
-0.773104190826416,
-0.8166838884353638,
-0.8223868012428284,
-0.3474814295768738,
-0.05964558944106102,
-0.18020322918891907,
0.8525059819221497,
0.7245218753814697,
-0.4647309482097626,
-0.5088905692100525,
0.32165592908859253,
0.10951752215623856,
-0.3669818937778473,
-0.23568664491176605,
0.35492604970932007,
-0.5716401934623718,
-0.8100537061691284,
0.5460546612739563,
0.3746628165245056,
0.06110895425081253,
-0.03454564884305,
-0.18421079218387604,
-0.0036606760695576668,
-0.3714631199836731,
1.1056575775146484,
0.32019999623298645,
-1.0384597778320312,
-0.2798756957054138,
-0.16657789051532745,
-0.07748109847307205,
-0.08816263824701309,
0.9213642477989197,
-1.1597862243652344,
0.3367586135864258,
0.1850241720676422,
0.6762576103210449,
0.38783273100852966,
-0.14225532114505768,
0.3976750075817108,
-1.0510168075561523,
0.1240459680557251,
0.03551888465881348,
0.37964317202568054,
0.26784077286720276,
-0.20944853127002716,
0.3292557895183563,
-0.05804865434765816,
-0.5017929673194885,
-0.872046172618866,
0.3708754777908325,
-0.5496020913124084,
-0.5433782935142517,
1.1803866624832153,
-0.12907859683036804,
-0.17341960966587067,
-0.12844066321849823,
-0.1897697150707245,
0.13301518559455872,
-0.04959335923194885,
0.7038969397544861,
0.5683493614196777,
-0.3957521915435791,
-0.180319145321846,
-0.5305207371711731,
0.6038447618484497,
0.2955576777458191,
-0.5755310654640198,
0.0769311934709549,
0.4388444721698761,
0.42706820368766785,
-0.016291175037622452,
0.6136361956596375,
-0.14330455660820007,
0.04430112987756729,
-0.48779699206352234,
-0.16868466138839722,
-0.023434599861502647,
-0.4540822505950928,
-0.5414662957191467,
0.3105802834033966,
0.2848266661167145,
-0.2063652127981186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07544v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07544v2
|
From Words to Numbers: Your Large Language Model Is Secretly A Capable Regressor When Given In-Context Examples
| 2024-04-11T08:12:43 | 2024-04-30T07:40:57 |
Robert Vacareanu, Vlad-Andrei Negru, Vasile Suciu, Mihai Surdeanu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We analyze how well pre-trained large language models (e.g., Llama2, GPT-4,
Claude 3, etc) can do linear and non-linear regression when given in-context
examples, without any additional training or gradient updates. Our findings
reveal that several large language models (e.g., GPT-4, Claude 3) are able to
perform regression tasks with a performance rivaling (or even outperforming)
that of traditional supervised methods such as Random Forest, Bagging, or
Gradient Boosting. For example, on the challenging Friedman #2 regression
dataset, Claude 3 outperforms many supervised methods such as AdaBoost, SVM,
Random Forest, KNN, or Gradient Boosting. We then investigate how well the
performance of large language models scales with the number of in-context
exemplars. We borrow from the notion of regret from online learning and
empirically show that LLMs are capable of obtaining a sub-linear regret.
|
[
-0.20333722233772278,
-0.895135760307312,
0.6408669352531433,
0.3585003912448883,
-0.10389471799135208,
-0.005616396199911833,
-0.3365475833415985,
-0.40675556659698486,
0.1269141137599945,
0.3734654188156128,
-0.453590989112854,
-0.1440895050764084,
-0.7033867239952087,
0.025022348389029503,
-0.6996188759803772,
1.1541249752044678,
0.06787999719381332,
0.40484586358070374,
-0.3792169690132141,
-0.04040520638227463,
-0.4269162714481354,
-0.7567153573036194,
-0.6841374635696411,
-0.29092660546302795,
0.5998812317848206,
-0.03326376527547836,
0.6761909127235413,
0.451948881149292,
0.3569028973579407,
0.33971747756004333,
0.18358442187309265,
-0.021276934072375298,
-0.8260789513587952,
0.09000001847743988,
0.13488523662090302,
-0.6114663481712341,
-0.17044977843761444,
0.2002822905778885,
0.5589563250541687,
0.7145228385925293,
-0.06661222875118256,
0.04648812860250473,
0.2859393060207367,
0.6355968713760376,
-0.32309019565582275,
0.30714869499206543,
-0.6334391832351685,
-0.2383895069360733,
-0.07723337411880493,
0.11780814081430435,
-0.6581355333328247,
-0.7074464559555054,
0.21496114134788513,
-0.5382645130157471,
0.08827365189790726,
-0.19108161330223083,
0.8020540475845337,
0.37853625416755676,
-0.25738444924354553,
-0.5910468101501465,
-0.9214795827865601,
0.9892263412475586,
-0.8204061985015869,
0.34265488386154175,
0.6217771768569946,
0.20013895630836487,
-0.18211907148361206,
-0.9775547981262207,
-0.3132134675979614,
-0.3104574978351593,
-0.13867752254009247,
-0.10428181290626526,
-0.2565261721611023,
-0.05888378247618675,
0.5684934854507446,
0.22933723032474518,
-0.3201017379760742,
0.012294978834688663,
-0.3095354437828064,
-0.06081612408161163,
0.47995492815971375,
-0.25069984793663025,
0.033244289457798004,
0.43369826674461365,
-0.2575647532939911,
-0.29067760705947876,
-0.732437252998352,
-0.00885714776813984,
0.2956331968307495,
0.32246726751327515,
0.13378077745437622,
0.4243657886981964,
0.1318301558494568,
0.8766533732414246,
-0.25218281149864197,
-0.23762071132659912,
0.18644502758979797,
-0.16471771895885468,
-0.32512152194976807,
-0.33291444182395935,
0.6181928515434265,
0.005472514778375626,
0.6682788729667664,
-0.3211345076560974,
-0.3905494809150696,
0.1214851513504982,
0.08716493099927902,
-0.725613534450531,
-0.18923039734363556,
-0.07985837757587433,
-0.36805590987205505,
-0.3207383155822754,
0.05212289094924927,
-0.8034830689430237,
-0.4186936616897583,
-0.1451694220304489,
0.8153817653656006,
-0.3164159655570984,
0.14054825901985168,
0.07735922932624817,
-0.021692965179681778,
0.1647414118051529,
0.34921252727508545,
-0.7287033796310425,
0.5875763893127441,
0.7714177370071411,
0.918934166431427,
0.31583309173583984,
-0.22221149504184723,
-0.7704765200614929,
-0.3480112552642822,
-0.6145006418228149,
0.4255080223083496,
-0.5582205057144165,
-0.29030197858810425,
0.2693084478378296,
-0.18154177069664001,
0.08743345737457275,
-0.4222605228424072,
0.220021590590477,
-0.5162606835365295,
0.4162919819355011,
-0.37573903799057007,
-0.6544994115829468,
-0.29657214879989624,
-0.01760433055460453,
-0.6616693735122681,
1.0146801471710205,
0.06294842809438705,
-0.4391500949859619,
0.3611866235733032,
-0.31444722414016724,
-0.3402155339717865,
-0.032520852982997894,
-0.10745873302221298,
-0.44308939576148987,
0.5572133660316467,
0.014257537201046944,
0.5383355021476746,
-0.34874415397644043,
0.5801007747650146,
-0.5288339257240295,
-0.4698745608329773,
0.4483569860458374,
-0.4825274646282196,
0.6682563424110413,
-0.02237667515873909,
-0.41876959800720215,
0.003977241460233927,
-0.6224019527435303,
0.02366030588746071,
0.053502220660448074,
-0.2914716601371765,
-0.5616108179092407,
0.3851049244403839,
-0.048816192895174026,
0.4574746787548065,
0.20445549488067627,
-0.4195375442504883,
0.3132832944393158,
-0.21481218934059143,
0.4537782669067383,
0.7576639652252197,
-0.396880179643631,
0.20998269319534302,
-0.33507040143013,
0.5086284875869751,
-0.49945536255836487,
-0.13294684886932373,
-0.1932685375213623,
-0.7123567461967468,
-0.9075955748558044,
-0.3940869867801666,
0.37103429436683655,
0.3535875678062439,
-0.6936140060424805,
0.25628650188446045,
-0.3288859724998474,
-0.5602919459342957,
-0.3775044083595276,
0.2555100619792938,
0.42981356382369995,
0.35774266719818115,
0.363914430141449,
0.055606909096241,
-0.48214197158813477,
-0.9309821724891663,
-0.45414847135543823,
-0.17888647317886353,
-0.09558927267789841,
0.44081446528434753,
0.3459984362125397,
-0.07136469334363937,
0.9539726376533508,
-0.4106978178024292,
-0.371830016374588,
-0.20496691763401031,
0.36085253953933716,
0.19751904904842377,
0.074469193816185,
0.5434631109237671,
-0.6995882391929626,
-0.40103432536125183,
-0.14971321821212769,
-0.8432374596595764,
-0.2929280400276184,
-0.15362393856048584,
0.4594302773475647,
0.24448800086975098,
0.8291594386100769,
-0.2559150755405426,
0.28983044624328613,
0.9058939814567566,
-0.3217618763446808,
-0.08663144707679749,
-0.3700355589389801,
-0.42273491621017456,
-1.1247295141220093,
-0.12277944386005402,
0.2566164433956146,
-0.36271390318870544,
-0.720789909362793,
-0.05956094339489937,
0.07007210701704025,
0.017133619636297226,
-0.14401189982891083,
0.37341341376304626,
-0.393414705991745,
-0.0981372818350792,
-0.2534031867980957,
-0.1622840166091919,
-0.2598084807395935,
0.2009219229221344,
-0.0201941579580307,
0.633125364780426,
0.677191972732544,
-0.30792000889778137,
0.18021711707115173,
-0.049770500510931015,
-0.5807863473892212,
-0.17178981006145477,
-0.7222822308540344,
0.09549487382173538,
-0.3682895004749298,
0.34504565596580505,
-1.219037413597107,
-0.2284305989742279,
-0.2505100965499878,
-0.28278425335884094,
0.36639368534088135,
-0.15113800764083862,
-0.5392794013023376,
-0.4815661609172821,
-0.32196715474128723,
0.12459198385477066,
0.7926629185676575,
-0.4694182574748993,
0.3699710965156555,
0.2639167904853821,
-0.26963385939598083,
-0.6818599700927734,
-0.8767256140708923,
0.1037021204829216,
-0.4839355945587158,
-0.1750257909297943,
-0.06720016151666641,
-0.06712580472230911,
-0.5494867563247681,
-0.1906723529100418,
0.2700512111186981,
-0.074051134288311,
0.17492248117923737,
0.27957677841186523,
0.3590594232082367,
-0.1912054717540741,
0.3833584785461426,
-0.5113604068756104,
-0.015570787712931633,
0.040345072746276855,
-0.41967615485191345,
0.6417989730834961,
-0.31139814853668213,
-0.09809248894453049,
0.07100335508584976,
0.20763635635375977,
0.5364312529563904,
-0.06691210716962814,
0.7526478171348572,
0.5087271332740784,
-0.5491630434989929,
-0.19707848131656647,
-0.6040235161781311,
-0.2666928172111511,
-0.45170941948890686,
0.5274885892868042,
-0.22630152106285095,
-1.0959795713424683,
0.3727141320705414,
-0.02782154083251953,
-0.0028691929765045643,
0.18425633013248444,
0.5699679851531982,
0.18741244077682495,
1.0359207391738892,
0.8269355893135071,
-0.24748075008392334,
0.5307210683822632,
-0.1724288910627365,
0.305325984954834,
-0.3990611732006073,
-0.03195710852742195,
-0.39342501759529114,
-0.3728204369544983,
-0.9608149528503418,
-0.5676078796386719,
0.0895179882645607,
0.33582356572151184,
-0.1156420037150383,
0.3398038446903229,
-0.03503791615366936,
0.43784114718437195,
0.45363402366638184,
-0.1794826090335846,
0.06909523904323578,
0.0899244174361229,
0.2768690884113312,
-0.19521066546440125,
-0.5733392238616943,
-0.47547000646591187,
1.0910100936889648,
0.4043959677219391,
0.9840487837791443,
0.13678576052188873,
0.6059976816177368,
0.036566827446222305,
0.8828976154327393,
-1.0808141231536865,
0.3583904802799225,
-0.3145048916339874,
-0.5338439345359802,
-0.4828401207923889,
-0.49672943353652954,
-0.8898249864578247,
0.16107888519763947,
-0.19681790471076965,
-0.9502612352371216,
0.32341906428337097,
0.14313052594661713,
-0.2224925458431244,
0.3119257390499115,
-0.667731761932373,
0.4526969790458679,
-0.24445737898349762,
-0.4587259888648987,
0.009079542011022568,
-0.535353422164917,
0.3448461890220642,
-0.734773576259613,
0.4198262095451355,
0.13082647323608398,
-0.22625425457954407,
0.7743752002716064,
-0.4114638864994049,
0.9037047624588013,
-0.10835039615631104,
-0.26399582624435425,
0.21042072772979736,
0.18118318915367126,
0.7539945244789124,
-0.1735229343175888,
-0.16129298508167267,
0.213326096534729,
-0.3670622706413269,
-0.3477238714694977,
-0.7015390396118164,
1.0107616186141968,
-0.7466511130332947,
-0.49334585666656494,
-0.4104442596435547,
-0.5341858863830566,
-0.4998173713684082,
0.15595640242099762,
0.38278985023498535,
0.5626465082168579,
-0.01815851405262947,
0.5038822293281555,
0.40358319878578186,
-0.34148654341697693,
0.8338819146156311,
0.3222556710243225,
-0.462993860244751,
-0.3857319951057434,
1.077881097793579,
0.5420425534248352,
0.3880177140235901,
0.5128887891769409,
0.5142550468444824,
-0.41383302211761475,
-0.3471771776676178,
-0.036717597395181656,
0.36351531744003296,
-0.4976871907711029,
-0.17349611222743988,
-0.5643976926803589,
0.0031113694421947002,
-0.21135343611240387,
-0.2106906622648239,
-0.34586358070373535,
-0.30760449171066284,
-0.03911273181438446,
-0.24866417050361633,
0.3390037715435028,
1.470253586769104,
-0.18655158579349518,
0.28116172552108765,
-0.5100781917572021,
-0.002599820028990507,
0.6699817776679993,
0.253816694021225,
0.05091266706585884,
-0.47198405861854553,
-0.2491999864578247,
0.08925319463014603,
0.043222665786743164,
-0.6746950745582581,
0.7157978415489197,
0.24530808627605438,
0.21174649894237518,
0.5080698132514954,
-0.20464999973773956,
0.8075960874557495,
-0.5396589636802673,
0.7283733487129211,
-0.02168266661465168,
-1.006201982498169,
0.1594024896621704,
-0.46904242038726807,
-0.15921209752559662,
0.31195321679115295,
0.578873872756958,
-0.30856212973594666,
-0.20038048923015594,
-0.683336615562439,
-0.9256118535995483,
0.6115662455558777,
0.04590544477105141,
0.3119398355484009,
-0.07823121547698975,
0.2437506765127182,
0.05301622673869133,
0.34573158621788025,
-1.070035457611084,
-0.17911510169506073,
-0.166314035654068,
-0.026462730020284653,
-0.6233323216438293,
-0.41019389033317566,
0.06752602756023407,
-0.03146833926439285,
0.49282705783843994,
-0.25959551334381104,
0.2384299337863922,
0.0029387567192316055,
-0.00568330567330122,
-0.049052104353904724,
0.08915101736783981,
0.8908663392066956,
0.6899595260620117,
-0.24733136594295502,
0.11223314702510834,
0.21159978210926056,
-0.20294363796710968,
0.09709487110376358,
-0.010425618849694729,
-0.15817594528198242,
-0.09638771414756775,
0.6865379810333252,
0.7388501167297363,
0.2337917685508728,
-0.5048993229866028,
0.6143467426300049,
-0.08942791819572449,
-0.27672624588012695,
-0.37397298216819763,
-0.3354385197162628,
0.09769544005393982,
0.053955066949129105,
0.4374864101409912,
0.014939069747924805,
-0.012181157246232033,
-0.5938212275505066,
0.2916455566883087,
0.44494572281837463,
-0.8388090133666992,
-0.410899817943573,
0.5546839237213135,
-0.12430234253406525,
-0.4054611325263977,
0.5261597633361816,
0.03449440747499466,
-0.3655160665512085,
0.4290129542350769,
0.9807836413383484,
0.7463545203208923,
-0.12802673876285553,
0.2030608206987381,
0.2191142737865448,
0.3054010272026062,
-0.6360208988189697,
0.20211169123649597,
0.2662407457828522,
-0.7356736660003662,
-0.7857862114906311,
-0.5871841311454773,
-0.05510736629366875,
0.5772954821586609,
-0.7983013391494751,
0.1726340353488922,
-0.3044349253177643,
-0.1302236169576645,
-0.06555584073066711,
-0.13035143911838531,
-0.5121178030967712,
0.22256171703338623,
0.20716696977615356,
0.839928388595581,
-1.0046536922454834,
0.9830662608146667,
0.5787951946258545,
-0.2612551748752594,
-0.8096148371696472,
0.19342410564422607,
-0.10298314690589905,
-0.9204803705215454,
0.8749597668647766,
0.23402923345565796,
-0.0851438045501709,
0.14702364802360535,
-0.6234740018844604,
-1.005834937095642,
0.7926551699638367,
0.5010347366333008,
-0.6669583320617676,
-0.10639622807502747,
0.022650176659226418,
0.7611346244812012,
-0.22572457790374756,
0.14548373222351074,
0.20525920391082764,
0.443711519241333,
-0.09994542598724365,
-0.7509539723396301,
-0.1788274496793747,
-0.03222110867500305,
0.010226311162114143,
0.25852063298225403,
-0.8178908824920654,
1.178402066230774,
-0.2611398994922638,
0.03795677050948143,
0.2905423641204834,
0.5000787973403931,
-0.060239098966121674,
-0.02587061934173107,
0.43586957454681396,
0.5626077651977539,
0.794329047203064,
-0.22110958397388458,
1.4402495622634888,
-0.20160096883773804,
0.3963439464569092,
0.9811171293258667,
-0.2548680007457733,
1.0089644193649292,
0.5455930233001709,
-0.21371911466121674,
0.41377735137939453,
0.5145021080970764,
0.10987014323472977,
0.5009289383888245,
0.468380868434906,
-0.14384149014949799,
-0.41515952348709106,
-0.05066312104463577,
-0.20946338772773743,
0.4711393713951111,
0.533145010471344,
-0.5013524889945984,
-0.09763038158416748,
0.0007682960713282228,
0.23247762024402618,
0.07094689458608627,
-0.2308768332004547,
0.8044187426567078,
0.20176269114017487,
-0.6006174683570862,
0.3882080614566803,
-0.21545934677124023,
0.6199827194213867,
-0.7564868927001953,
-0.14786770939826965,
-0.13685426115989685,
0.41348567605018616,
-0.01184825412929058,
-0.5455084443092346,
0.1485440880060196,
-0.16403664648532867,
0.09066420793533325,
-0.4458342492580414,
0.5618399381637573,
-0.4684433341026306,
-0.8365005850791931,
0.5422213673591614,
0.7405476570129395,
0.17624123394489288,
0.05855000764131546,
-0.26927852630615234,
-0.16245803236961365,
0.08455291390419006,
-0.32543858885765076,
0.46593213081359863,
0.40440380573272705,
-0.2205342948436737,
0.8322222828865051,
0.6293390393257141,
0.3380313813686371,
-0.003323162905871868,
0.12518078088760376,
0.6871060132980347,
-0.5924227237701416,
-0.0923776775598526,
-1.198678731918335,
0.08702101558446884,
0.041755158454179764,
-0.3009953796863556,
0.8822681903839111,
0.6263940930366516,
0.9338764548301697,
-0.20180962979793549,
0.9047784209251404,
0.12233028560876846,
0.4226061999797821,
-0.31004077196121216,
0.4789488911628723,
-0.47705087065696716,
0.149786114692688,
-0.36766740679740906,
-0.9067373275756836,
-0.4874715209007263,
0.9100897908210754,
-0.45191892981529236,
0.15257062017917633,
0.6066187620162964,
0.6982386112213135,
0.26531782746315,
-0.15578284859657288,
0.7742316126823425,
0.4801183342933655,
0.3690303564071655,
0.2970764636993408,
0.8352862596511841,
-0.4043622612953186,
0.42698416113853455,
-0.04303240403532982,
-0.3287080228328705,
-0.1309361308813095,
-0.9641318321228027,
-0.9166287779808044,
-0.6021842956542969,
0.03316274285316467,
-0.5670439600944519,
-0.05792413651943207,
0.8291725516319275,
0.6855971813201904,
-0.7911446690559387,
-0.43428876996040344,
-0.18496115505695343,
-0.039923664182424545,
-0.04984340816736221,
-0.20053544640541077,
0.16529256105422974,
-0.43813556432724,
-0.8322237133979797,
0.468902587890625,
0.11628925055265427,
0.2904799282550812,
-0.3856203258037567,
0.07650177925825119,
-0.013339802622795105,
0.23144468665122986,
0.7935559153556824,
0.11670329421758652,
-0.6539282202720642,
-0.36295023560523987,
0.08983242511749268,
0.03028678521513939,
-0.189233660697937,
1.0387959480285645,
-0.9911747574806213,
0.33355453610420227,
0.5989857912063599,
0.6489567756652832,
0.48335227370262146,
0.07189258188009262,
0.8834614157676697,
-0.6820340156555176,
0.11971821635961533,
0.1060057058930397,
0.5533371567726135,
0.37304845452308655,
-0.01933625154197216,
0.6252090334892273,
0.17254289984703064,
-0.49532565474510193,
-0.8224487900733948,
0.20878632366657257,
-0.5685019493103027,
-0.1634436696767807,
1.3883379697799683,
-0.24488016963005066,
0.03694084286689758,
-0.10844533890485764,
0.004460637457668781,
0.06662395596504211,
-0.31737804412841797,
0.8663608431816101,
0.8971623182296753,
-0.07382812350988388,
0.08833850175142288,
-0.6926745176315308,
0.7802444696426392,
0.282725065946579,
-0.6034093499183655,
0.2792869508266449,
0.2801511585712433,
0.07073402404785156,
0.28157320618629456,
0.3817731440067291,
-0.05585254356265068,
-0.354995459318161,
0.011631340719759464,
-0.22661972045898438,
0.06532467156648636,
-0.26195627450942993,
-0.5082460045814514,
0.1385309398174286,
0.2297472357749939,
0.13055719435214996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08705v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08705v1
|
Introducing L2M3, A Multilingual Medical Large Language Model to Advance Health Equity in Low-Resource Regions
| 2024-04-11T07:39:22 | 2024-04-11T07:39:22 |
Agasthya Gangavarapu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Addressing the imminent shortfall of 10 million health workers by 2030,
predominantly in Low- and Middle-Income Countries (LMICs), this paper
introduces an innovative approach that harnesses the power of Large Language
Models (LLMs) integrated with machine translation models. This solution is
engineered to meet the unique needs of Community Health Workers (CHWs),
overcoming language barriers, cultural sensitivities, and the limited
availability of medical dialog datasets. I have crafted a model that not only
boasts superior translation capabilities but also undergoes rigorous
fine-tuning on open-source datasets to ensure medical accuracy and is equipped
with comprehensive safety features to counteract the risks of misinformation.
Featuring a modular design, this approach is specifically structured for
swift adaptation across various linguistic and cultural contexts, utilizing
open-source components to significantly reduce healthcare operational costs.
This strategic innovation markedly improves the accessibility and quality of
healthcare services by providing CHWs with contextually appropriate medical
knowledge and diagnostic tools. This paper highlights the transformative impact
of this context-aware LLM, underscoring its crucial role in addressing the
global healthcare workforce deficit and propelling forward healthcare outcomes
in LMICs.
|
[
0.26672083139419556,
-0.23670533299446106,
0.7491154670715332,
0.022715145722031593,
-0.1817387491464615,
0.05287187173962593,
-0.11953255534172058,
-0.731432318687439,
0.022508226335048676,
0.7095416784286499,
-0.3810982406139374,
-0.23956163227558136,
-0.8305737972259521,
0.11476004868745804,
0.04850646108388901,
0.7377949953079224,
-0.15685582160949707,
0.27723562717437744,
0.12243646383285522,
-0.3065679967403412,
-0.2563472092151642,
-0.26291221380233765,
-0.40387240052223206,
-0.5425195693969727,
0.7309955358505249,
0.810379147529602,
0.9864992499351501,
0.8939968943595886,
0.3779429793357849,
0.1243031844496727,
-0.05140623077750206,
0.2469867616891861,
-0.6210600137710571,
-0.2933792769908905,
-0.05123284459114075,
-0.6570622324943542,
-0.5884150266647339,
-0.26244229078292847,
0.42439910769462585,
0.830977737903595,
-0.17040368914604187,
0.12020359933376312,
0.2960572838783264,
0.7447267174720764,
-0.35701867938041687,
0.12880052626132965,
-0.6412752270698547,
0.14334098994731903,
-0.24368605017662048,
0.09443248063325882,
-0.02122725546360016,
-0.06571919471025467,
-0.12345632165670395,
-0.28327232599258423,
-0.26185116171836853,
-0.12673194706439972,
0.3879806399345398,
0.3505701720714569,
-0.6647680401802063,
-0.17267534136772156,
-0.4781899154186249,
0.8260836601257324,
-0.8593502044677734,
0.3062574565410614,
0.41240638494491577,
0.3580781817436218,
-0.3222444951534271,
-0.8814502954483032,
-0.3690633773803711,
0.4898535907268524,
-0.13717693090438843,
0.24142950773239136,
-0.11275479942560196,
-0.055555518716573715,
-0.23435615003108978,
0.1858825385570526,
-0.4494391083717346,
0.5533411502838135,
-0.672781229019165,
0.04526486247777939,
0.2962087392807007,
0.32118576765060425,
0.2956632673740387,
-0.34565451741218567,
-0.31557193398475647,
0.4624243378639221,
-0.9538739323616028,
-0.05317796394228935,
-0.19722095131874084,
0.5144367218017578,
-0.6162912845611572,
0.48684194684028625,
-0.17905862629413605,
0.3348451256752014,
-0.4807532727718353,
-0.7731216549873352,
0.3311329185962677,
-0.2205280214548111,
-0.2655227482318878,
-0.0739939883351326,
0.5847418904304504,
0.3836360275745392,
-0.2445792406797409,
0.025101367384195328,
-0.08588070422410965,
-0.39605915546417236,
-0.06829551607370377,
-0.8435475826263428,
0.05887454003095627,
0.41287699341773987,
-0.8037997484207153,
-0.19613702595233917,
-0.3881951570510864,
-0.6502885222434998,
-0.8146207928657532,
-0.23601356148719788,
-0.03698580339550972,
-0.024709433317184448,
-0.2803840637207031,
0.3383229970932007,
0.43661391735076904,
-0.11468639969825745,
0.3201640844345093,
-0.7640528082847595,
0.031939465552568436,
0.8432472944259644,
1.0903019905090332,
-0.042470354586839676,
0.004204082302749157,
-0.2962452471256256,
0.33160874247550964,
-0.2623289227485657,
0.25033625960350037,
-0.18362215161323547,
-0.4174676239490509,
0.21269425749778748,
0.3365781009197235,
0.13841333985328674,
-0.6984579563140869,
0.32821717858314514,
-0.2324514240026474,
-0.010494071058928967,
-0.17729875445365906,
0.1048216000199318,
-0.055008839815855026,
0.23696087300777435,
-0.6316271424293518,
0.853990912437439,
0.3942681550979614,
-0.6192319393157959,
0.06035522744059563,
-0.7068377137184143,
-0.4819914400577545,
0.3197824954986572,
-0.26032304763793945,
-0.4713810384273529,
0.20427384972572327,
0.16402138769626617,
0.4075002074241638,
-0.7335953712463379,
0.36490485072135925,
-0.29524359107017517,
-0.23123283684253693,
0.05261164903640747,
-0.3301383852958679,
0.9011242389678955,
0.2798042297363281,
-0.2108958214521408,
0.1754867136478424,
-0.2823711633682251,
-0.1270214170217514,
0.2139899730682373,
-0.42173007130622864,
-0.21001000702381134,
0.2325209677219391,
0.17324377596378326,
0.467050164937973,
0.3078196346759796,
-0.13616228103637695,
-0.07629167288541794,
-0.6029680371284485,
0.7791052460670471,
0.3750099241733551,
-0.0475798174738884,
0.3013208508491516,
-0.33877408504486084,
0.47681331634521484,
0.10812978446483612,
0.5811574459075928,
-0.06478484719991684,
-0.5905587673187256,
-0.3630772531032562,
-0.45539894700050354,
-0.10020765662193298,
0.7552576065063477,
-0.9050988554954529,
0.21650904417037964,
-0.2817123532295227,
-0.4378786087036133,
-0.9346508979797363,
0.35408681631088257,
0.039748866111040115,
0.7744783163070679,
0.39830297231674194,
0.09285446256399155,
-0.42610853910446167,
-1.1017292737960815,
-0.07863716036081314,
-0.18805454671382904,
-0.0902690589427948,
0.21355760097503662,
0.4377967417240143,
-0.6730949878692627,
0.5747184753417969,
-0.3326798677444458,
-0.3295696973800659,
-0.634804904460907,
-0.3262166976928711,
0.4461309611797333,
0.48850950598716736,
0.27510273456573486,
-0.8660628199577332,
-0.28175437450408936,
0.27428165078163147,
-0.8189838528633118,
-0.07760648429393768,
0.23409797251224518,
-0.25241324305534363,
-0.004433743190020323,
0.3352140784263611,
-0.07320313155651093,
0.11122972518205643,
0.9506517052650452,
0.0037065893411636353,
0.10371004045009613,
-0.19674398005008698,
-0.1537432074546814,
-1.4354325532913208,
0.2135130912065506,
-0.11990677565336227,
-0.23836039006710052,
-0.7298443913459778,
0.10948684811592102,
0.232416033744812,
-0.42851704359054565,
-0.6876773238182068,
0.7646951079368591,
-0.3886217474937439,
0.17097441852092743,
-0.4235101342201233,
-0.05255897343158722,
-0.08983791619539261,
-0.033196017146110535,
0.008305496536195278,
0.531339704990387,
0.2009076476097107,
-0.18738561868667603,
0.07542360574007034,
0.08940847963094711,
-0.4804246127605438,
0.5235692262649536,
-0.5608516931533813,
-0.014475096017122269,
-0.025387393310666084,
0.4201708436012268,
-0.3176509439945221,
-0.43579912185668945,
0.17643605172634125,
-0.13000580668449402,
-0.12478388100862503,
-0.13660411536693573,
-0.7947598099708557,
-0.6729981899261475,
0.04518582671880722,
0.5057165622711182,
0.6204882860183716,
-0.3343127965927124,
0.19796863198280334,
0.7066925168037415,
-0.4897810220718384,
-0.5323724746704102,
-1.0859369039535522,
0.21191446483135223,
-0.2515619397163391,
-0.6726692914962769,
0.0584949292242527,
0.15421047806739807,
-0.31787893176078796,
-0.277820348739624,
-0.00970063079148531,
-0.23334217071533203,
0.5251736640930176,
0.0410638190805912,
0.3722197711467743,
-0.22498589754104614,
0.14746268093585968,
0.08067173510789871,
-0.25398316979408264,
-0.08655542880296707,
-0.5170596837997437,
0.26832613348960876,
-0.007671642582863569,
-0.3554818034172058,
-0.29166221618652344,
0.6689350605010986,
0.7169105410575867,
-0.16964605450630188,
0.8085072636604309,
0.6647334694862366,
-0.9387806057929993,
0.3216720521450043,
-0.4467350244522095,
-0.03728726506233215,
-0.42941001057624817,
0.850602388381958,
0.1118912622332573,
-1.2362284660339355,
0.37486910820007324,
-0.2879067361354828,
0.06587617099285126,
0.19995641708374023,
0.808801531791687,
-0.02841736190021038,
0.7832401990890503,
0.7777597308158875,
-0.10560066252946854,
0.006618224084377289,
0.06876995414495468,
0.43865877389907837,
-0.8151424527168274,
-0.45092999935150146,
-0.4200122058391571,
-0.20138250291347504,
-0.7120449542999268,
-1.010047435760498,
1.1576142311096191,
0.23271925747394562,
-0.187852144241333,
-0.06909028440713882,
-0.20502136647701263,
0.19234783947467804,
0.2957485318183899,
0.38730481266975403,
0.33288803696632385,
-0.35105228424072266,
0.059561099857091904,
-0.2370910942554474,
-0.8366889953613281,
-0.6024473905563354,
0.7286101579666138,
0.7784592509269714,
0.49282029271125793,
0.4074447453022003,
0.5473332405090332,
0.28187087178230286,
0.6349824666976929,
-0.7733283042907715,
-0.00872983131557703,
-0.27379101514816284,
-0.5589797496795654,
-0.24780693650245667,
-0.25762939453125,
-0.8107426762580872,
0.35190683603286743,
-0.3362535834312439,
-0.5865739583969116,
0.10024713724851608,
0.06135334447026253,
-0.4951937198638916,
0.44348469376564026,
-0.3277260363101959,
0.7645305395126343,
-0.4540131092071533,
-0.5233898758888245,
-0.2654295861721039,
-0.7238285541534424,
0.48838621377944946,
-0.459529846906662,
1.078561544418335,
-0.5370888710021973,
-0.3195021450519562,
0.4052516520023346,
-0.6002510786056519,
1.0298115015029907,
-0.21543562412261963,
-0.34367966651916504,
0.16107304394245148,
-0.1211690902709961,
0.464253693819046,
0.14197447896003723,
-0.323424369096756,
0.30573537945747375,
-0.25370365381240845,
-0.7986276149749756,
0.030940622091293335,
0.6371261477470398,
-0.7511873841285706,
-0.5025107264518738,
0.013022549450397491,
-0.63884037733078,
-0.39450716972351074,
0.4181807339191437,
-0.14043943583965302,
0.229675754904747,
-0.14304779469966888,
0.08187464624643326,
0.41513288021087646,
-0.6429033279418945,
0.28096267580986023,
0.5963425040245056,
-0.026286063715815544,
-0.4858107566833496,
0.46953678131103516,
0.04564027488231659,
0.4083453118801117,
0.19271330535411835,
0.2567961513996124,
-0.04976775124669075,
-0.42573094367980957,
-0.4690203070640564,
0.33205878734588623,
-0.769039511680603,
-0.5238684415817261,
-0.6353744864463806,
-0.06463620066642761,
-0.3985525369644165,
-0.5572644472122192,
-0.26368802785873413,
0.03569277003407478,
-0.2139163315296173,
-0.12006005644798279,
0.10202517360448837,
0.96439528465271,
-0.3643048107624054,
0.40423083305358887,
-0.8279173970222473,
0.25605249404907227,
0.11686474084854126,
0.29767653346061707,
0.03659644350409508,
-0.4112541973590851,
-0.811042845249176,
-0.030268827453255653,
-0.0856592208147049,
-0.9450697302818298,
0.6217959523200989,
-0.4025118947029114,
0.2937507629394531,
0.29757121205329895,
-0.07669083029031754,
0.5610231757164001,
-0.8281847834587097,
0.773288369178772,
0.7008180618286133,
-0.7890479564666748,
0.4237782061100006,
-0.5692030787467957,
0.5407783389091492,
0.5151992440223694,
0.17211146652698517,
-0.861617386341095,
-0.17636357247829437,
-0.0720699205994606,
-1.224042534828186,
0.46499383449554443,
-0.21281476318836212,
0.027831651270389557,
-0.21801912784576416,
0.005752271506935358,
0.24427430331707,
-0.028375087305903435,
-0.8900554776191711,
0.08095104992389679,
0.02194829098880291,
-0.4452053904533386,
0.10205916315317154,
-0.3451702892780304,
-0.43022167682647705,
-0.027817057445645332,
0.5305023789405823,
-0.4544930160045624,
0.05118183419108391,
0.20024535059928894,
-0.0754285454750061,
-0.270531564950943,
0.609712541103363,
0.6180101633071899,
0.5687062740325928,
0.04467223212122917,
0.2032826691865921,
0.41277533769607544,
-0.2521190047264099,
0.2064729779958725,
-0.018948860466480255,
0.08860365301370621,
-0.1406617909669876,
0.4900246858596802,
0.632353663444519,
0.4133128225803375,
-0.6366971731185913,
0.5058507919311523,
0.33047983050346375,
0.06352084130048752,
-0.19143450260162354,
-0.2742742598056793,
0.6213387250900269,
0.3894506096839905,
0.5459408760070801,
-0.06179535388946533,
0.07182668149471283,
-0.5123790502548218,
-0.04576574265956879,
-0.001164240762591362,
-0.5747982263565063,
-0.10454903542995453,
0.7716948390007019,
0.531494677066803,
-0.14092913269996643,
0.30268529057502747,
0.21933092176914215,
-0.27157971262931824,
0.576054036617279,
0.5986153483390808,
0.4276260733604431,
-0.24557378888130188,
-0.07739856839179993,
0.3266366124153137,
0.6523391008377075,
-0.49900761246681213,
0.2846125364303589,
0.5901110172271729,
-0.4472368359565735,
-0.5434492230415344,
-0.3062360882759094,
-0.3265392780303955,
0.20112362504005432,
-0.7471367716789246,
0.32523852586746216,
-0.1377924084663391,
0.0010279694106429815,
-0.45028337836265564,
-0.2799617648124695,
-0.9106177091598511,
0.16168396174907684,
0.41972607374191284,
0.8752959966659546,
-0.8865976333618164,
1.0175683498382568,
0.38497716188430786,
-0.1088639497756958,
-0.49928051233291626,
0.18644744157791138,
0.3401812016963959,
-1.3438078165054321,
0.31872719526290894,
0.27193504571914673,
-0.006710180081427097,
-0.24572309851646423,
-0.33415111899375916,
-0.8372944593429565,
1.4097408056259155,
0.46517491340637207,
-0.8405748009681702,
-0.06402549147605896,
0.3972588777542114,
0.3414720892906189,
-0.519512951374054,
0.07323101907968521,
0.4968602955341339,
0.5547681450843811,
-0.4026801288127899,
-1.314601182937622,
0.1707267016172409,
0.04282353073358536,
0.1632615178823471,
-0.12828776240348816,
-0.8211313486099243,
0.6930090188980103,
-0.5777053833007812,
-0.10341886430978775,
0.1487652212381363,
0.5813546180725098,
0.29454806447029114,
0.2119528204202652,
0.27985289692878723,
0.16203558444976807,
0.9037317633628845,
-0.06828295439481735,
1.2146145105361938,
-0.45772331953048706,
0.1786952167749405,
0.9622468948364258,
-0.5851261019706726,
0.7840790748596191,
0.38557374477386475,
-0.21429289877414703,
0.2921428680419922,
0.4888704717159271,
0.454546183347702,
0.509842574596405,
0.3785063922405243,
-0.5263705849647522,
-0.08438555896282196,
-0.5643959045410156,
-0.35764214396476746,
0.4218943119049072,
0.5477598309516907,
-0.5058483481407166,
-0.015627898275852203,
0.13225123286247253,
0.5574959516525269,
0.283702552318573,
-0.6597307920455933,
0.6260178089141846,
0.4188615679740906,
-0.33706435561180115,
0.445901483297348,
0.3280811905860901,
0.6515396237373352,
-0.4470749795436859,
0.022616857662796974,
-0.2731725573539734,
0.15814130008220673,
-0.36098453402519226,
-0.6080101132392883,
0.4098741114139557,
-0.04182647541165352,
-0.4171801507472992,
-0.3472479581832886,
0.49774911999702454,
-0.5753642916679382,
-0.6939573884010315,
0.6644375920295715,
0.8651053309440613,
-0.014074311591684818,
0.35200124979019165,
-0.7026938796043396,
0.285778284072876,
-0.034659408032894135,
0.45318663120269775,
0.35782912373542786,
0.610805869102478,
-0.04280436411499977,
0.3916749954223633,
0.3824273645877838,
0.31216543912887573,
-0.40295735001564026,
0.0817817896604538,
0.5933369398117065,
-0.49967584013938904,
-0.5537781715393066,
-0.8489436507225037,
0.7245367765426636,
0.031781964004039764,
-0.008366584777832031,
0.15950576961040497,
0.5475510954856873,
0.4038422107696533,
0.0012798544485121965,
1.240394949913025,
0.13213200867176056,
0.7291336059570312,
-0.32658082246780396,
0.8252663016319275,
-0.7949824333190918,
0.05456441640853882,
0.036950644105672836,
-0.13441894948482513,
-0.4084118902683258,
0.17568577826023102,
-0.20749199390411377,
-0.2968977093696594,
0.5303214192390442,
0.6728078722953796,
0.021372072398662567,
-0.46389153599739075,
0.5898903608322144,
0.37090709805488586,
0.3029439449310303,
0.6596657633781433,
0.36383914947509766,
-0.29981711506843567,
0.33003273606300354,
0.21114414930343628,
-0.25045081973075867,
-0.2979179322719574,
-0.7782090902328491,
-0.46852827072143555,
-0.09677504003047943,
-0.05738731101155281,
-0.5614399313926697,
0.15670713782310486,
1.0353915691375732,
0.6864875555038452,
-0.6801198124885559,
-0.33403444290161133,
0.4806455075740814,
0.11560248583555222,
-0.019617965444922447,
-0.16991160809993744,
0.16410961747169495,
0.22299039363861084,
-0.49260658025741577,
0.63395094871521,
0.7009903788566589,
0.021575819700956345,
-0.4400864243507385,
-0.22297702729701996,
0.042583219707012177,
0.03306007757782936,
0.637787938117981,
0.2436901181936264,
-0.9333593845367432,
-0.004621065687388182,
-0.18955080211162567,
-0.46891704201698303,
0.1840471625328064,
0.5910267233848572,
-0.3882903456687927,
0.25993719696998596,
-0.01700863614678383,
0.5802366733551025,
0.08310454338788986,
-0.41857296228408813,
0.5793234705924988,
-0.3259585499763489,
0.46248582005500793,
0.3375318944454193,
0.669429361820221,
0.7371003031730652,
-0.35552507638931274,
0.6969819068908691,
0.2799190580844879,
-0.3340685963630676,
-0.8094955682754517,
0.3992307186126709,
-0.5104341506958008,
-0.34775975346565247,
1.260617971420288,
-0.18190935254096985,
0.0355672761797905,
-0.2884858250617981,
0.035137198865413666,
0.424022376537323,
-0.13084490597248077,
0.7658613324165344,
0.29934853315353394,
-0.000026765432266984135,
-0.021327780559659004,
-1.0304635763168335,
0.17412474751472473,
0.33798283338546753,
-1.1255099773406982,
0.06431297212839127,
0.31573328375816345,
0.31229671835899353,
-0.24924980103969574,
1.1219990253448486,
-0.44773200154304504,
0.1511818766593933,
-0.4343881905078888,
0.3827686309814453,
0.35799214243888855,
-0.08155002444982529,
-0.3361082673072815,
0.05533594638109207,
0.2296779304742813,
0.28623804450035095
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.